id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00770v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00770v1
|
Automatic Instruction Evolving for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T15:09:00
| 2024-06-02T15:09:00
|
Weihao Zeng, Can Xu, Yingxiu Zhao, Jian-Guang Lou, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Fine-tuning large pre-trained language models with Evol-Instruct has achieved
encouraging results across a wide range of tasks. However, designing effective
evolving methods for instruction evolution requires substantial human
expertise. This paper proposes Auto Evol-Instruct, an end-to-end framework that
evolves instruction datasets using large language models without any human
effort. The framework automatically analyzes and summarizes suitable
evolutionary strategies for the given instruction data and iteratively improves
the evolving method based on issues exposed during the instruction evolution
process. Our extensive experiments demonstrate that the best method optimized
by Auto Evol-Instruct outperforms human-designed methods on various benchmarks,
including MT-Bench, AlpacaEval, GSM8K, and HumanEval.
|
[
-0.3537849187850952,
-0.7459995746612549,
0.20883676409721375,
-0.15845096111297607,
-0.06599273532629013,
0.1843963861465454,
-0.4374323785305023,
-0.45255374908447266,
-0.22657479345798492,
0.4317067265510559,
-0.720881462097168,
-0.43791404366493225,
-0.5762985348701477,
0.1426071971654892,
-0.28084105253219604,
0.8001470565795898,
0.023934075608849525,
-0.04898746311664581,
-0.23404337465763092,
0.07727080583572388,
-0.39347803592681885,
-0.1014832928776741,
-0.5329713225364685,
-0.06576207280158997,
-0.21286556124687195,
0.8021974563598633,
0.5730617642402649,
1.003234624862671,
-0.019325943663716316,
0.353769451379776,
0.14290682971477509,
0.5319342017173767,
-0.4848818778991699,
0.1282246857881546,
-0.4205140769481659,
-0.1566273719072342,
-0.26545587182044983,
-0.27050265669822693,
0.34696897864341736,
0.654304563999176,
-0.4406627118587494,
0.492613822221756,
0.00573063874617219,
0.658198356628418,
-0.7225155234336853,
0.07617036253213882,
-0.4957762360572815,
-0.04232926666736603,
0.009674087166786194,
-0.27392035722732544,
-0.772252082824707,
-0.43682923913002014,
0.3239264190196991,
-0.4572374224662781,
0.1824573129415512,
0.22573645412921906,
0.5483766198158264,
0.36958348751068115,
-0.039247628301382065,
-0.5883541107177734,
-0.6975635886192322,
0.7845107913017273,
-0.6116782426834106,
0.5630233883857727,
0.17465339601039886,
0.3941071629524231,
-0.5802744626998901,
-0.46103987097740173,
-0.2364189475774765,
-0.44481897354125977,
0.3794916570186615,
0.028874268755316734,
-0.02972974069416523,
0.19437572360038757,
-0.008483851328492165,
0.23829753696918488,
-0.6901317834854126,
0.628161609172821,
-0.28396737575531006,
0.20175349712371826,
0.612946093082428,
-0.005410614889115095,
0.6192514300346375,
0.30995839834213257,
0.037407949566841125,
-0.38003790378570557,
-0.7016989588737488,
-0.05465961992740631,
0.3965223729610443,
0.07229813188314438,
-0.02032402530312538,
0.257741242647171,
-0.14916695654392242,
0.9088609218597412,
0.423831969499588,
0.1547883152961731,
0.29477521777153015,
0.19307246804237366,
-0.42175695300102234,
0.22108931839466095,
0.6160193085670471,
-0.011394631117582321,
0.2859894931316376,
-0.38193967938423157,
-0.24558313190937042,
-0.3102438747882843,
0.18529175221920013,
-0.8036236763000488,
-0.23817706108093262,
0.006031273398548365,
-0.2171492725610733,
-0.1995639204978943,
-0.03380254656076431,
-1.102539300918579,
-0.26686128973960876,
-0.4705182909965515,
0.44179800152778625,
-0.36914026737213135,
0.06578398495912552,
0.45244425535202026,
0.1116403117775917,
0.4413052797317505,
0.26516953110694885,
-1.4584383964538574,
0.2937004268169403,
0.5653067231178284,
0.397376149892807,
0.12401364743709564,
-0.29296502470970154,
-0.6793465614318848,
0.18852031230926514,
-0.4673231542110443,
0.8732697367668152,
-0.8423490524291992,
-0.5192482471466064,
-0.08011592924594879,
0.2346998155117035,
-0.13475550711154938,
-0.6231986284255981,
0.29393595457077026,
-0.40376248955726624,
0.7345054745674133,
0.10408223420381546,
-0.8602790832519531,
-0.1669292151927948,
-0.24818779528141022,
-0.353017121553421,
0.9090637564659119,
0.46258795261383057,
-0.07375141978263855,
0.2500629127025604,
-1.2418447732925415,
-0.5266503691673279,
0.23143580555915833,
-0.15720520913600922,
-0.41710060834884644,
0.17729343473911285,
0.6098944544792175,
0.369880735874176,
-0.5684789419174194,
0.1858900785446167,
-0.17938897013664246,
-0.22695045173168182,
-0.19135819375514984,
-0.3475798964500427,
0.9772554636001587,
0.07764428853988647,
-0.8560811281204224,
0.01988023705780506,
-0.7574183344841003,
0.09285444766283035,
0.13313111662864685,
-0.07315744459629059,
-0.20042599737644196,
0.08173856884241104,
-0.5114126801490784,
0.09728134423494339,
0.28769418597221375,
-0.4158061146736145,
0.7015601396560669,
-0.607650637626648,
0.45494183897972107,
0.97371906042099,
0.17558947205543518,
0.8689354062080383,
-0.14158912003040314,
0.6515586972236633,
-0.488068163394928,
0.6780601143836975,
-0.2827926576137543,
-0.33317500352859497,
-0.8510398864746094,
0.15025217831134796,
0.06686709076166153,
0.5840243697166443,
-0.5069528818130493,
0.6805064678192139,
-0.22628866136074066,
-0.44519487023353577,
-0.7206355333328247,
0.40103062987327576,
0.3430001139640808,
0.2848822772502899,
0.571973443031311,
-0.0803685411810875,
-0.26820531487464905,
-0.8459974527359009,
0.04530716687440872,
0.0635673999786377,
0.09753527492284775,
0.07954718917608261,
0.2835535407066345,
-0.5256555676460266,
0.6032321453094482,
-0.42115944623947144,
0.39209866523742676,
0.006402634084224701,
0.5392835140228271,
-0.1715632975101471,
0.541983962059021,
0.7927772402763367,
-0.19783242046833038,
-0.5588070750236511,
0.2859876751899719,
-0.6485001444816589,
-0.3716481626033783,
-0.3051968216896057,
-0.4677349328994751,
0.12585331499576569,
0.46272146701812744,
-0.3449491262435913,
0.12756918370723724,
0.38810157775878906,
-0.08392664045095444,
0.3112224042415619,
-0.5338143110275269,
0.15738940238952637,
-0.9342405796051025,
-0.29134199023246765,
-0.2173939049243927,
0.11711215227842331,
-0.6050564050674438,
0.035190947353839874,
0.17928919196128845,
-0.16133910417556763,
0.04368060454726219,
0.5745312571525574,
-0.795210599899292,
-0.1369638741016388,
-0.2152658849954605,
-0.19647632539272308,
-0.02775510959327221,
0.32328519225120544,
-0.1192750334739685,
0.6892980337142944,
0.6706756949424744,
-0.6665983200073242,
0.3562662601470947,
0.2742176055908203,
-0.3758578598499298,
0.14637035131454468,
-0.32580676674842834,
0.6050629615783691,
-0.3185422420501709,
-0.03032797947525978,
-0.5424731373786926,
-0.29671183228492737,
0.20425067842006683,
-0.2919156551361084,
0.7524479627609253,
-0.31950056552886963,
-0.5113449692726135,
-0.38258522748947144,
-0.13022863864898682,
-0.17037801444530487,
0.794709324836731,
-1.0688552856445312,
0.5447163581848145,
0.05109911039471626,
-0.19363488256931305,
-0.5959821939468384,
-0.19351840019226074,
0.17290304601192474,
-0.16204123198986053,
-0.5418452024459839,
0.14799387753009796,
-0.3336963653564453,
-0.1348971575498581,
-0.19103416800498962,
0.05932348966598511,
-0.07701157033443451,
-0.00607355497777462,
-0.013132140971720219,
0.24100734293460846,
-0.3116585612297058,
0.28200963139533997,
0.6488569378852844,
-0.07519767433404922,
-0.040206972509622574,
-0.6881238222122192,
0.4604721665382385,
0.10653472691774368,
-0.5145329833030701,
-0.6925899386405945,
0.25695228576660156,
0.925462007522583,
-0.5433383584022522,
0.47991743683815,
0.34026846289634705,
-0.03362063318490982,
-0.821572482585907,
-0.5875810384750366,
-0.16824759542942047,
-0.5781458616256714,
0.5635004639625549,
-0.022703809663653374,
-0.5682548880577087,
0.08514642715454102,
-0.38000744581222534,
0.6866528391838074,
0.1138690933585167,
0.2982695698738098,
-0.06237001344561577,
1.1992055177688599,
0.7641994953155518,
-0.002188271377235651,
0.6882323622703552,
-0.23902836441993713,
-0.008487457409501076,
-0.48711737990379333,
-0.2671298086643219,
-0.399262398481369,
-0.16400904953479767,
-0.29784438014030457,
-0.27748164534568787,
0.02314980886876583,
0.023376787081360817,
-0.5210045576095581,
0.504205048084259,
-1.035447359085083,
0.5808154344558716,
0.186493918299675,
0.07734642177820206,
-0.13363629579544067,
0.10672494769096375,
0.4247290790081024,
0.23789340257644653,
-0.8191837072372437,
-0.2625204920768738,
1.231896996498108,
0.2341645509004593,
0.8566685914993286,
0.08382229506969452,
1.0150138139724731,
0.39416056871414185,
0.46299976110458374,
-0.5815743803977966,
0.3158625662326813,
-0.356031596660614,
-0.17985539138317108,
-0.43088340759277344,
-0.2935396432876587,
-0.8392727971076965,
-0.1590138077735901,
-0.04230472818017006,
-0.7752920985221863,
0.482421338558197,
0.3071754276752472,
-0.4721086621284485,
0.020316291600465775,
-1.1095032691955566,
0.8958309888839722,
-0.8407530784606934,
-0.21892569959163666,
-0.2112337201833725,
-0.4809741973876953,
0.238515704870224,
-0.2090744823217392,
0.403858482837677,
0.13218837976455688,
-0.039174649864435196,
0.7999019026756287,
-0.47592490911483765,
0.6434674263000488,
-0.4162113070487976,
-0.25159311294555664,
0.3778059184551239,
0.11519717425107956,
0.7222937345504761,
-0.3467147648334503,
-0.17039349675178528,
-0.49407923221588135,
-0.38456985354423523,
-0.39957907795906067,
-1.0733153820037842,
0.4126620590686798,
-0.7919699549674988,
-0.5400830507278442,
0.19184699654579163,
-0.26401132345199585,
-0.27167245745658875,
0.039015188813209534,
0.3100142478942871,
0.8007543087005615,
-0.060788195580244064,
0.12552562355995178,
0.904131293296814,
-0.5390601754188538,
0.5460138916969299,
0.5430474877357483,
0.041277818381786346,
-0.39942896366119385,
0.8956030011177063,
-0.031796157360076904,
0.5928525924682617,
0.30147784948349,
0.5950038433074951,
-0.3230627477169037,
-0.6841594576835632,
-1.0153546333312988,
-0.027793826535344124,
-0.7724555730819702,
-0.18890388309955597,
-0.45327028632164,
0.07335543632507324,
-0.34967702627182007,
-0.594322919845581,
-0.582322895526886,
-0.10862290859222412,
-0.39175277948379517,
0.001969560282304883,
0.5780189037322998,
0.8508726358413696,
0.0505746454000473,
0.46306002140045166,
-0.9407594203948975,
0.0554778091609478,
0.4401492178440094,
0.159348726272583,
0.07774349302053452,
-1.1104488372802734,
-0.3787577152252197,
0.21177157759666443,
0.021154994145035744,
-0.774488627910614,
0.4149843752384186,
0.7238704562187195,
0.706372082233429,
0.6812698841094971,
0.14657075703144073,
0.9130389094352722,
-0.6373962759971619,
0.4651365876197815,
0.05019691586494446,
-1.0723884105682373,
0.5891927480697632,
-0.1338663399219513,
0.4367872178554535,
0.6896860599517822,
0.3165305256843567,
-0.17956194281578064,
-0.07782764732837677,
-0.43543845415115356,
-0.7716654539108276,
0.6538875699043274,
-0.2952643632888794,
0.3350483179092407,
0.09767413884401321,
0.5830550789833069,
0.4659360349178314,
-0.19283735752105713,
-0.3030807673931122,
0.12993475794792175,
-0.2799181342124939,
-0.43228211998939514,
0.19823554158210754,
0.07044005393981934,
0.1521909087896347,
-0.6313803791999817,
0.606438159942627,
-0.11467854678630829,
0.2205996960401535,
-0.30619996786117554,
-0.4787587523460388,
-0.3188930153846741,
0.38824135065078735,
0.6641851663589478,
0.8533838987350464,
-0.017462514340877533,
-0.30001160502433777,
0.4726223051548004,
-0.3943428099155426,
0.31046411395072937,
0.007094500120729208,
-0.0021738235373049974,
-0.3427445888519287,
0.44677630066871643,
0.7801512479782104,
0.6162168383598328,
-0.8310980796813965,
0.32931631803512573,
-0.020798103883862495,
-0.20490577816963196,
-0.3318232595920563,
0.5037979483604431,
-0.0026825349777936935,
0.23418045043945312,
0.26504120230674744,
-0.23644928634166718,
-0.0035289365332573652,
-0.502042293548584,
0.33387491106987,
0.05636994168162346,
-0.10575598478317261,
-0.31523463129997253,
0.36366409063339233,
0.31963586807250977,
-0.4344441890716553,
0.807813286781311,
-0.5595752596855164,
-0.3851953446865082,
0.621316134929657,
0.6017095446586609,
1.1957165002822876,
-0.7167834043502808,
0.25108802318573,
0.23063045740127563,
0.34037697315216064,
-0.2523818910121918,
-0.00793815404176712,
-0.15313281118869781,
-0.35721564292907715,
-0.6097722053527832,
-0.6736825704574585,
-0.39876797795295715,
0.14282166957855225,
-0.5510827898979187,
0.4452003836631775,
-0.48720046877861023,
0.5199053287506104,
0.08859241753816605,
-0.3915051221847534,
-0.48536568880081177,
0.12485360354185104,
0.18660002946853638,
0.7744194269180298,
-0.7225350737571716,
0.881769061088562,
0.6585108041763306,
-0.04729266092181206,
-0.44624063372612,
-0.13218270242214203,
-0.05728565901517868,
-0.6985693573951721,
0.7758004069328308,
0.08134984225034714,
-0.3764273524284363,
0.41139253973960876,
-0.9237614274024963,
-0.7725067138671875,
1.0069066286087036,
0.36304810643196106,
-0.8052657842636108,
-0.16327808797359467,
-0.04105514660477638,
0.5245108008384705,
-0.6228346228599548,
0.2694360613822937,
0.397255539894104,
0.3243746757507324,
0.01984001137316227,
-0.6343901753425598,
-0.30394014716148376,
-0.16867583990097046,
-0.29401832818984985,
0.294155478477478,
-0.445584237575531,
0.5585735440254211,
-0.28776291012763977,
-0.32788804173469543,
-0.0724274218082428,
0.6822152733802795,
-0.514119565486908,
-0.1762891411781311,
0.5231730937957764,
0.504924476146698,
0.697058379650116,
0.3390231132507324,
0.645030677318573,
-0.48617392778396606,
0.25305885076522827,
1.2786587476730347,
-0.11877389997243881,
0.6439286470413208,
-0.16117361187934875,
0.0030262963846325874,
0.5212113857269287,
0.7245873808860779,
-0.29638931155204773,
0.34425511956214905,
0.31060442328453064,
-0.27944159507751465,
-0.21804450452327728,
0.32993844151496887,
-0.13343456387519836,
0.8032100200653076,
0.5680730938911438,
-0.35013875365257263,
-0.45728689432144165,
0.1350339651107788,
-0.05303100124001503,
0.029702331870794296,
-0.18560554087162018,
0.8944653868675232,
-0.29774585366249084,
-0.6501460075378418,
0.8437798023223877,
-0.05365738272666931,
0.44384458661079407,
-0.5141520500183105,
-0.27709442377090454,
-0.12979348003864288,
-0.06694027036428452,
-0.1631104201078415,
-0.3599255383014679,
-0.06588245183229446,
0.15757793188095093,
0.060060054063797,
-0.2978539764881134,
0.3314013183116913,
-0.34216997027397156,
-0.16211414337158203,
0.3155156373977661,
0.28957945108413696,
0.051735758781433105,
0.35608237981796265,
-0.7532325983047485,
-0.14513321220874786,
0.11970314383506775,
-0.3056798577308655,
0.40138623118400574,
0.37989354133605957,
-0.06424989551305771,
0.820457398891449,
0.560137152671814,
-0.3279174864292145,
0.299235075712204,
0.10509876161813736,
0.7448962926864624,
-0.37689879536628723,
-0.3173306882381439,
-0.8692343831062317,
0.4555785059928894,
-0.2734561264514923,
-0.41233593225479126,
0.3428003489971161,
0.42544248700141907,
0.774998128414154,
-0.11349498480558395,
0.8615641593933105,
-0.07034766674041748,
0.09983418881893158,
-0.45805373787879944,
0.7548301815986633,
-0.31038761138916016,
0.18344147503376007,
-0.07619000971317291,
-1.0498663187026978,
0.04896683618426323,
0.6112217307090759,
-0.3589267134666443,
0.09817773103713989,
0.5084245204925537,
0.8031479120254517,
-0.19267268478870392,
0.19656920433044434,
0.12096492946147919,
0.005470660049468279,
0.2937275767326355,
0.555442214012146,
0.8355212211608887,
0.023410653695464134,
0.28219401836395264,
-0.3418298363685608,
-0.7650290131568909,
-0.21003928780555725,
-0.6380817890167236,
-1.049642562866211,
-0.4287515878677368,
-0.40027856826782227,
0.1359717845916748,
0.4620513916015625,
1.4859676361083984,
0.7715167999267578,
-0.7544334530830383,
-0.24142558872699738,
-0.2768542170524597,
-0.42671871185302734,
-0.1661491096019745,
-0.193848118185997,
0.6017800569534302,
-0.6708374619483948,
-0.8600044250488281,
0.8499729633331299,
0.4179220199584961,
0.14766925573349,
-0.3373432159423828,
-0.14478488266468048,
0.01153131015598774,
-0.054282210767269135,
0.6445739269256592,
0.7875813841819763,
-0.38673025369644165,
-0.5077703595161438,
0.27893123030662537,
0.17397600412368774,
-0.01667228899896145,
0.5895206332206726,
-0.4335193336009979,
0.9104567766189575,
0.2993600070476532,
1.1394767761230469,
0.29270195960998535,
-0.10191210359334946,
0.8130120635032654,
-0.39556849002838135,
-0.13610973954200745,
0.20055770874023438,
0.1271333247423172,
0.20242130756378174,
-0.4847967326641083,
0.2791488766670227,
-0.006820756010711193,
-0.7508624196052551,
-0.6203768849372864,
0.23245972394943237,
-0.5077816247940063,
-0.29162371158599854,
0.826137125492096,
0.04612481966614723,
-0.3415578007698059,
-0.24225878715515137,
-0.04849517345428467,
0.32464414834976196,
-0.4454059600830078,
1.117713212966919,
0.4284069836139679,
-0.5740554928779602,
-0.531538188457489,
-0.9502215385437012,
0.49138203263282776,
0.16744746267795563,
-1.2347917556762695,
0.3458622694015503,
0.3232415020465851,
0.1626894176006317,
-0.15748274326324463,
-0.14961428940296173,
0.08463332056999207,
0.44751739501953125,
0.04019291698932648,
0.2827856242656708,
-0.32660284638404846,
-0.35541078448295593,
-0.31392204761505127,
-0.18431466817855835,
0.11322683840990067,
-0.17507991194725037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00765v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00765v1
|
The Embodied World Model Based on LLM with Visual Information and Prediction-Oriented Prompts
| 2024-06-02T14:50:01
| 2024-06-02T14:50:01
|
Wakana Haijima, Kou Nakakubo, Masahiro Suzuki, Yutaka Matsuo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In recent years, as machine learning, particularly for vision and language
understanding, has been improved, research in embedded AI has also evolved.
VOYAGER is a well-known LLM-based embodied AI that enables autonomous
exploration in the Minecraft world, but it has issues such as underutilization
of visual data and insufficient functionality as a world model. In this
research, the possibility of utilizing visual data and the function of LLM as a
world model were investigated with the aim of improving the performance of
embodied AI. The experimental results revealed that LLM can extract necessary
information from visual data, and the utilization of the information improves
its performance as a world model. It was also suggested that devised prompts
could bring out the LLM's function as a world model.
|
[
-0.4208472669124603,
-1.2128100395202637,
0.9768316149711609,
0.12159627676010132,
-0.37853237986564636,
-0.1294754445552826,
0.08323641121387482,
-0.6576531529426575,
0.2210572510957718,
0.39345741271972656,
-0.8357738256454468,
-0.4010981619358063,
-0.5159795880317688,
0.036700598895549774,
-0.23505139350891113,
-0.038359660655260086,
0.3366195857524872,
-0.03648765757679939,
-0.6932108402252197,
0.0011928357416763902,
-0.871193528175354,
-0.22281880676746368,
-0.41318440437316895,
-0.2775709927082062,
0.6025606393814087,
0.4557330310344696,
0.6705112457275391,
0.5837520360946655,
0.40126320719718933,
0.43459874391555786,
-0.08885370194911957,
0.5818953514099121,
-0.47206124663352966,
0.37926527857780457,
0.04128522425889969,
-0.642844021320343,
-0.457075297832489,
0.011844098567962646,
0.7319967746734619,
0.23235441744327545,
0.3088942766189575,
0.23696444928646088,
0.2379278689622879,
0.30350086092948914,
-0.21349748969078064,
0.53082275390625,
-0.24547319114208221,
0.31232553720474243,
0.2966204881668091,
-0.2969515919685364,
-0.4257746934890747,
-0.05814970284700394,
0.24848031997680664,
-1.0216188430786133,
-0.08963225781917572,
0.4827510416507721,
0.28291213512420654,
0.5462896823883057,
-0.4736846685409546,
-0.0180169977247715,
-0.5824723839759827,
0.812034010887146,
-0.43504756689071655,
0.5523833632469177,
-0.18779464066028595,
0.23904502391815186,
-0.4367927610874176,
-0.5497081279754639,
-0.723210871219635,
-0.36573803424835205,
0.024270283058285713,
0.4236176311969757,
-0.13883282244205475,
-0.13110633194446564,
0.1812220960855484,
-0.0961553230881691,
-0.4942329227924347,
0.49626097083091736,
-0.3387192487716675,
0.10371945798397064,
0.754632294178009,
0.6338834166526794,
0.541880190372467,
-0.37237733602523804,
-0.4222259819507599,
-0.207587331533432,
-0.8694560527801514,
0.1597321629524231,
0.05578169971704483,
0.42477938532829285,
-0.3356139063835144,
0.7439294457435608,
-0.13637977838516235,
0.7739689350128174,
-0.03550921380519867,
-0.028306547552347183,
-0.03732385113835335,
0.5146937370300293,
-0.3085940480232239,
-0.003476253245025873,
0.4526088833808899,
0.6665370464324951,
-0.09325620532035828,
-0.24774722754955292,
-0.0027276428882032633,
-0.15625323355197906,
0.4936620891094208,
-0.6572112441062927,
0.25485190749168396,
0.5058003067970276,
-0.7370178699493408,
-0.3399510383605957,
0.17437219619750977,
-0.4933587312698364,
-0.7670696377754211,
-0.6163069009780884,
0.2457129806280136,
-0.32712194323539734,
-0.2961138188838959,
-0.15466250479221344,
-0.38797128200531006,
0.5046888589859009,
0.8888722658157349,
-0.5395664572715759,
0.011779558844864368,
0.9337074160575867,
0.9621420502662659,
-0.5546296238899231,
-0.16859498620033264,
-0.3900893032550812,
0.07230299711227417,
-0.14328743517398834,
0.7955226302146912,
-0.4989771246910095,
-0.9850263595581055,
-0.10085036605596542,
0.23026159405708313,
0.1633971482515335,
-0.3503457307815552,
0.17926621437072754,
-0.40263354778289795,
0.01481373980641365,
-0.29060596227645874,
-0.5709982514381409,
-0.7015524506568909,
0.49151143431663513,
-0.7752284407615662,
0.9235957860946655,
-0.27540403604507446,
-0.6468758583068848,
0.37784630060195923,
-0.6138281226158142,
0.01735895313322544,
0.5128993391990662,
-0.14820808172225952,
-0.24763676524162292,
0.41715872287750244,
0.33066391944885254,
0.7267866730690002,
-0.2199769914150238,
0.2478257715702057,
-0.4235686957836151,
-0.996980607509613,
0.39515265822410583,
-0.35077154636383057,
0.5251269340515137,
0.06383564323186874,
-0.30009204149246216,
0.04234907031059265,
-0.7065518498420715,
0.2099081426858902,
0.04014669358730316,
-0.2601509988307953,
-0.2982976734638214,
0.3720454275608063,
-0.12358736991882324,
-0.15065814554691315,
0.16844773292541504,
-0.628093421459198,
0.47248420119285583,
-0.2536141574382782,
-0.04019060358405113,
0.9891024231910706,
0.09567628800868988,
0.36856260895729065,
-0.34279435873031616,
0.5477604269981384,
-0.16575153172016144,
0.09406875818967819,
-0.174355611205101,
-0.7951593995094299,
-1.0136034488677979,
-0.3255157470703125,
-0.13268029689788818,
0.6455933451652527,
-0.6556328535079956,
0.30063971877098083,
-0.24295178055763245,
-0.5690726041793823,
-0.3313242495059967,
-0.4044272005558014,
0.12019463628530502,
0.422881543636322,
0.38495489954948425,
0.019182004034519196,
-0.6332060694694519,
-0.7109967470169067,
-0.06738489121198654,
-0.47060927748680115,
0.059480439871549606,
0.9015344381332397,
0.3656870722770691,
-0.5518108606338501,
0.8456788063049316,
-0.2285914570093155,
0.18608351051807404,
-0.440029114484787,
-0.1178930401802063,
0.49327701330184937,
0.673829197883606,
0.05109373480081558,
-0.8112133145332336,
-0.33365702629089355,
0.07162029296159744,
-1.386528730392456,
0.13604499399662018,
-0.11304803192615509,
-0.3294519782066345,
-0.34991583228111267,
0.28884875774383545,
-0.4992330074310303,
0.7108172178268433,
0.43261799216270447,
-0.4842454791069031,
0.3537694215774536,
-0.37672775983810425,
0.3307695686817169,
-0.7114132642745972,
-0.12107373028993607,
-0.17127899825572968,
-0.3153369426727295,
-0.34561219811439514,
0.42721664905548096,
0.1655634343624115,
-0.1815691441297531,
-0.6046571135520935,
0.9521532654762268,
-0.6153537631034851,
-0.05203546583652496,
-0.48619839549064636,
0.24821797013282776,
-0.2987004518508911,
0.33394572138786316,
0.2991180717945099,
0.6602137088775635,
0.8541632890701294,
-1.0983514785766602,
0.8133212327957153,
0.47839808464050293,
-0.07791443914175034,
0.5650158524513245,
-0.8453415036201477,
0.18919014930725098,
-0.4390486776828766,
-0.11890630424022675,
-0.7719235420227051,
-0.11747687309980392,
-0.02746020071208477,
-0.3472348749637604,
0.32562175393104553,
-0.2629733979701996,
-0.32637345790863037,
-0.39898601174354553,
-0.062179163098335266,
-0.0250428207218647,
0.840532660484314,
-0.9216909408569336,
1.0720402002334595,
0.2775707542896271,
-0.03270653635263443,
-0.19879946112632751,
-0.7333842515945435,
-0.00782348494976759,
-0.5469478368759155,
-0.8638068437576294,
0.37659022212028503,
0.0010930030839517713,
-0.43713533878326416,
-0.21545147895812988,
0.312510222196579,
0.552394449710846,
0.326275110244751,
1.081265926361084,
0.6732171773910522,
-0.12349841743707657,
0.14602325856685638,
-0.1057179644703865,
-0.3019324243068695,
0.13204368948936462,
-0.45942771434783936,
0.2603508532047272,
-0.2528616189956665,
-0.5777133703231812,
-0.4746662676334381,
0.05469414219260216,
0.27426737546920776,
0.19889983534812927,
0.5478115081787109,
0.2206835150718689,
0.009466392919421196,
-0.2591398358345032,
-0.4864165484905243,
-0.08529509603977203,
-0.5526554584503174,
0.2560618221759796,
-0.24749325215816498,
-0.763095498085022,
0.4827674925327301,
-0.30492421984672546,
0.03592361509799957,
0.3294850289821625,
0.4718593955039978,
-0.4408969283103943,
0.847873330116272,
0.8713290095329285,
0.14690172672271729,
0.5772210955619812,
-0.4908415377140045,
-0.4399396777153015,
-1.1199074983596802,
-0.6757186055183411,
-0.07446298003196716,
-0.6016151309013367,
-0.7231380939483643,
-0.7144640684127808,
0.7884937524795532,
-0.29806581139564514,
-0.3069576025009155,
0.07027816772460938,
-0.5117940902709961,
0.17861026525497437,
0.9014532566070557,
0.4937098026275635,
0.16638804972171783,
-0.07259724289178848,
-0.3460528552532196,
-0.11822518706321716,
-0.5200440287590027,
-0.7529407739639282,
1.0311594009399414,
0.18393561244010925,
1.2308049201965332,
0.14436012506484985,
0.5617817044258118,
0.5913046598434448,
0.05365205183625221,
-0.5981718897819519,
0.6858729124069214,
0.3257850110530853,
-0.2483074814081192,
-0.27391937375068665,
-0.041502565145492554,
-0.925080418586731,
0.6072100400924683,
-0.4477423131465912,
-0.8853340148925781,
0.177978977560997,
0.324215292930603,
-0.12908051908016205,
0.10290830582380295,
-0.5408093929290771,
0.44714969396591187,
-0.3791457712650299,
-0.7232140898704529,
-0.14622840285301208,
-0.4006746709346771,
0.214154452085495,
0.356216698884964,
-0.04225430265069008,
0.036719910800457,
0.04436045140028,
0.45153993368148804,
-0.2206232100725174,
0.9927195906639099,
-0.49316129088401794,
0.0851074680685997,
0.5164012312889099,
0.20667994022369385,
0.7554746270179749,
0.38088786602020264,
-0.11527566611766815,
-0.015475367195904255,
-0.5358536839485168,
-0.08546142280101776,
-0.6536657810211182,
0.7508355975151062,
-0.7465006113052368,
-0.8590849041938782,
-0.2968398928642273,
-0.24739901721477509,
-0.24913260340690613,
-0.0006945746717974544,
-0.06094973906874657,
0.37499088048934937,
-0.748988151550293,
0.18890781700611115,
0.804478108882904,
-0.5472115874290466,
0.5851055383682251,
0.5879082679748535,
-0.33290934562683105,
-0.12515200674533844,
0.6827083230018616,
-0.3200865387916565,
-0.16752153635025024,
0.5403464436531067,
0.19569461047649384,
-0.36077994108200073,
-0.316866397857666,
-0.7967457175254822,
-0.05739873647689819,
-0.5873128771781921,
-0.0370505191385746,
-0.7194770574569702,
-0.00708182156085968,
0.05898278206586838,
-0.21483220160007477,
-0.10912275314331055,
-0.45319148898124695,
-0.5465554594993591,
-0.39674127101898193,
0.3600277602672577,
0.9261497259140015,
0.11543887108564377,
0.3180612325668335,
-0.7996534109115601,
0.15919585525989532,
0.42899641394615173,
-0.0658232718706131,
0.18803392350673676,
-0.4931902289390564,
-0.1569390445947647,
0.09547614306211472,
-0.23621921241283417,
-0.4991810917854309,
0.4374060332775116,
-0.1710003912448883,
0.8808396458625793,
0.2234143167734146,
-0.3566869795322418,
1.0223132371902466,
-0.47718432545661926,
1.0122909545898438,
-0.011877201497554779,
-0.7051446437835693,
0.5272002816200256,
-0.2678815722465515,
0.3956979811191559,
-0.18796759843826294,
-0.016479801386594772,
-0.7304167747497559,
-0.5016696453094482,
-0.6403659582138062,
-0.37944746017456055,
0.5285549163818359,
0.010805489495396614,
0.1917569637298584,
0.2995045483112335,
0.31134656071662903,
0.29956021904945374,
-0.02216981165111065,
-0.7220954298973083,
-0.12448564171791077,
-0.15270176529884338,
-0.00012241466902196407,
0.022775674238801003,
-0.15455275774002075,
0.3204876184463501,
-0.1874215006828308,
0.7325655817985535,
-0.3364402651786804,
0.7021453380584717,
0.3443440794944763,
-0.33878159523010254,
0.11604371666908264,
-0.15846651792526245,
0.1351335197687149,
0.24199411273002625,
0.07694664597511292,
0.17874588072299957,
0.2935110628604889,
-0.34227263927459717,
0.08341522514820099,
-0.1196957379579544,
-0.43847566843032837,
-0.3460310697555542,
0.7392438650131226,
0.8046207427978516,
-0.004117671865969896,
-0.9458476305007935,
0.3501824140548706,
-0.1106763556599617,
0.18956275284290314,
-0.5609353184700012,
0.5946692228317261,
0.1511296182870865,
0.8011926412582397,
0.23925051093101501,
-0.06152668967843056,
0.27055972814559937,
-0.428817480802536,
-0.0754934549331665,
0.6831098794937134,
-0.5555907487869263,
-0.26804205775260925,
1.0367125272750854,
0.20065946877002716,
-0.1174941286444664,
1.0104097127914429,
0.19851182401180267,
-0.3649269938468933,
0.9174007177352905,
0.6246978044509888,
0.6788793206214905,
0.07874565571546555,
0.09646733105182648,
0.39970335364341736,
0.22581090033054352,
0.21219010651111603,
0.6780789494514465,
-0.08344972878694534,
-0.5786630511283875,
-0.12903344631195068,
-0.31463178992271423,
-0.38658612966537476,
-0.5062090754508972,
-0.2595708966255188,
0.449550598859787,
-0.4516971707344055,
-0.02808755449950695,
-0.552229642868042,
-0.12546426057815552,
-1.0786621570587158,
0.4390178918838501,
0.4305051565170288,
0.8074249029159546,
-0.40721601247787476,
0.36160215735435486,
0.4583643972873688,
-0.26894110441207886,
-0.454924076795578,
-0.4209141433238983,
0.16436316072940826,
-1.247502326965332,
0.9288104176521301,
0.35793325304985046,
-0.10310244560241699,
-0.06183002516627312,
-0.9538697600364685,
-1.0781235694885254,
1.4119576215744019,
-0.004286603536456823,
-0.44569528102874756,
0.1432993859052658,
-0.12157437205314636,
0.33965784311294556,
-0.5182273983955383,
0.4972648024559021,
-0.04996670037508011,
0.7294851541519165,
0.10162719339132309,
-0.4789738357067108,
0.11955168843269348,
-0.40205854177474976,
0.3213019073009491,
-0.20760667324066162,
-0.8309754729270935,
0.8554763197898865,
-0.5466344952583313,
-0.16117003560066223,
0.2625880241394043,
0.9272739887237549,
0.39754679799079895,
0.16147659718990326,
0.3416803181171417,
0.28805893659591675,
0.8475323915481567,
-0.0983399823307991,
1.1606464385986328,
0.11026722937822342,
0.08416163921356201,
0.6453515887260437,
-0.11078529059886932,
0.604498565196991,
0.3529151976108551,
-0.06067242845892906,
0.5600730776786804,
0.6044964790344238,
-0.26738277077674866,
0.625141441822052,
0.1293574720621109,
-0.07847288995981216,
-0.31000763177871704,
0.10400484502315521,
-0.12307743728160858,
0.5648251175880432,
0.5003237128257751,
-0.3576982617378235,
0.3185946047306061,
0.2692049443721771,
-0.4519490599632263,
-0.3407853841781616,
-0.31097206473350525,
1.0258188247680664,
-0.11931531876325607,
-0.6570183038711548,
0.29412761330604553,
0.11957470327615738,
0.4895212650299072,
-0.3226865530014038,
-0.5280123353004456,
-0.21111570298671722,
-0.19520987570285797,
-0.1604236662387848,
-0.4330298900604248,
-0.15069927275180817,
-0.057413019239902496,
0.07158323377370834,
-0.22304217517375946,
0.9098484516143799,
0.013803358189761639,
-0.6275120377540588,
0.10612092167139053,
0.8114372491836548,
0.3365877866744995,
-0.07374753803014755,
-0.37721380591392517,
0.17473115026950836,
0.12170456349849701,
-0.15594300627708435,
-0.22904902696609497,
0.4852895140647888,
-0.04375969246029854,
1.1224360466003418,
0.6884221434593201,
-0.1285155564546585,
0.37922972440719604,
-0.34202566742897034,
0.8622640371322632,
-1.1961023807525635,
-0.8449728488922119,
-0.8838997483253479,
0.8997328877449036,
-0.2996654510498047,
0.027102675288915634,
0.9482002258300781,
0.5967387557029724,
0.1754148006439209,
-0.27105480432510376,
0.9529889822006226,
-0.17553073167800903,
0.42980921268463135,
-0.8136829733848572,
0.3431260287761688,
-0.5885534286499023,
0.19276836514472961,
-0.1769619882106781,
-0.9296340346336365,
-0.15127718448638916,
0.6159769296646118,
0.018566686660051346,
0.022899214178323746,
0.431882381439209,
0.585881233215332,
-0.28952905535697937,
0.3478700518608093,
0.5503266453742981,
0.1615068018436432,
0.46694210171699524,
0.1535789966583252,
1.2269999980926514,
-0.1578831523656845,
-0.24788659811019897,
-0.03262050077319145,
-0.20650924742221832,
-0.504054605960846,
-0.8674178123474121,
-1.0099502801895142,
-0.38016557693481445,
-0.09980648010969162,
-0.10337310284376144,
0.07127860933542252,
0.7234891057014465,
0.9481910467147827,
-0.24325233697891235,
0.00546910660341382,
-0.11310800164937973,
0.15264366567134857,
-0.25088420510292053,
-0.1565108597278595,
0.2508258521556854,
0.06017522141337395,
-0.9254545569419861,
0.9317692518234253,
0.4016624093055725,
0.41274935007095337,
-0.5605554580688477,
-0.3112905025482178,
0.3188042640686035,
-0.15510369837284088,
0.6225563883781433,
0.0060447282157838345,
-0.7666462659835815,
-0.41836410760879517,
0.1823147088289261,
0.1673092544078827,
-0.010007230564951897,
0.7448559403419495,
-1.230013132095337,
0.7351475954055786,
0.1797800064086914,
0.42932993173599243,
0.8570596575737,
0.29676491022109985,
0.7228031754493713,
-0.5921716094017029,
0.5550772547721863,
0.09593502432107925,
0.5805864334106445,
0.3075014352798462,
-0.8547576069831848,
0.5393403172492981,
0.11901850253343582,
-0.38632386922836304,
-0.19077667593955994,
0.015236906707286835,
-1.082646369934082,
-0.11451853811740875,
1.0827234983444214,
-0.07829955965280533,
-0.550751805305481,
0.08625173568725586,
-0.44020217657089233,
-0.013168349862098694,
-0.3339851200580597,
0.5895894169807434,
0.2957014739513397,
-0.48780447244644165,
-0.1756981462240219,
-0.47231605648994446,
-0.1461978256702423,
-0.09135358780622482,
-0.8408699631690979,
-0.20242714881896973,
0.8245548605918884,
-0.000980233890004456,
-0.07070601731538773,
0.27582597732543945,
0.08082229644060135,
0.15896932780742645,
0.27281248569488525,
0.051664579659700394,
-0.5271373391151428,
-0.24662142992019653,
0.01870802417397499,
-0.044166211038827896,
0.032961394637823105,
-0.266215056180954
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06561v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06561v1
|
Brainstorming Brings Power to Large Language Models of Knowledge Reasoning
| 2024-06-02T14:47:14
| 2024-06-02T14:47:14
|
Zining Qin, Chenhao Wang, Huiling Qin, Weijia Jia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated amazing capabilities in
language generation, text comprehension, and knowledge reasoning. While a
single powerful model can already handle multiple tasks, relying on a single
perspective can lead to biased and unstable results. Recent studies have
further improved the model's reasoning ability on a wide range of tasks by
introducing multi-model collaboration. However, models with different
capabilities may produce conflicting answers on the same problem, and how to
reasonably obtain the correct answer from multiple candidate models has become
a challenging problem. In this paper, we propose the multi-model brainstorming
based on prompt. It incorporates different models into a group for
brainstorming, and after multiple rounds of reasoning elaboration and
re-inference, a consensus answer is reached within the group. We conducted
experiments on three different types of datasets, and demonstrate that the
brainstorming can significantly improve the effectiveness in logical reasoning
and fact extraction. Furthermore, we find that two small-parameter models can
achieve accuracy approximating that of larger-parameter models through
brainstorming, which provides a new solution for distributed deployment of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.4746209383010864,
-0.736870288848877,
1.1451795101165771,
0.3405326306819916,
-0.13390213251113892,
0.002333875512704253,
-0.3884263336658478,
-0.09214462339878082,
0.054164450615644455,
0.30966874957084656,
-0.6906837224960327,
-0.2873537242412567,
-0.617038905620575,
0.10287307947874069,
-0.15216684341430664,
0.6059974431991577,
-0.04785500094294548,
0.06664834916591644,
-0.5187479257583618,
-0.017325174063444138,
-0.9394538402557373,
-0.4246006906032562,
-0.421176552772522,
-0.36481761932373047,
0.6923115849494934,
0.6654338836669922,
0.5760477185249329,
0.3774561882019043,
0.3952762186527252,
0.4671506881713867,
-0.10154902935028076,
0.4335635006427765,
0.09802918881177902,
0.5965301394462585,
-0.3485090732574463,
-0.6182513236999512,
-0.29268476366996765,
0.18187224864959717,
0.4702188968658447,
0.6115798354148865,
-0.4701274335384369,
-0.19342373311519623,
-0.018258696421980858,
0.22060975432395935,
-0.3630707859992981,
0.2302507758140564,
-1.0159547328948975,
-0.20622356235980988,
0.13920988142490387,
-0.027676783502101898,
-0.3515969514846802,
-0.2559361755847931,
0.41774269938468933,
-0.6945106983184814,
-0.04516824334859848,
0.34731170535087585,
0.5919062495231628,
0.32084739208221436,
0.015443595126271248,
-0.2660842537879944,
-0.3927046060562134,
1.0778003931045532,
-0.9848088622093201,
0.20818260312080383,
-0.06580960005521774,
0.3338923454284668,
-0.2725396752357483,
-0.6662653684616089,
-0.8954522013664246,
0.10934283584356308,
0.1893446147441864,
0.000507412594743073,
-0.04243860021233559,
-0.04839091747999191,
0.365792840719223,
-0.3947964012622833,
-0.21614311635494232,
0.1908581256866455,
-0.2320994734764099,
0.05911725014448166,
0.6810478568077087,
0.2349703460931778,
0.10516371577978134,
-0.24140040576457977,
-0.2976846396923065,
0.0413581021130085,
-0.32827073335647583,
-0.41519060730934143,
-0.20769648253917694,
0.48842599987983704,
0.07374600321054459,
0.603813111782074,
-0.43893712759017944,
0.9182137250900269,
0.09149763733148575,
-0.3614061176776886,
0.012943628244102001,
-0.6535308361053467,
-0.22417567670345306,
-0.2147216796875,
0.763301432132721,
0.5838453769683838,
0.21544267237186432,
-0.09351196885108948,
-0.018920307978987694,
-0.2583468556404114,
-0.10250654071569443,
-0.8284265995025635,
-0.05931626632809639,
0.40351852774620056,
-0.384919136762619,
-0.11834289133548737,
-0.2621062994003296,
-0.7395749688148499,
-0.7136421799659729,
-0.5583488345146179,
0.3288875222206116,
-0.2928248941898346,
-0.3029206097126007,
0.23141725361347198,
-0.5772826671600342,
-0.06869138777256012,
0.7603861093521118,
-0.8385923504829407,
-0.18318939208984375,
0.6717339158058167,
0.8042910099029541,
-0.2641552686691284,
-0.501581609249115,
-0.0849636122584343,
0.1317746341228485,
-0.3120228052139282,
0.9258078336715698,
-0.2624894082546234,
-0.06566549837589264,
-0.5021920800209045,
-0.41734105348587036,
-0.162017822265625,
-0.5503962635993958,
0.1783706545829773,
-0.38893812894821167,
0.24254946410655975,
-0.6216779351234436,
-0.7271983027458191,
-0.18493667244911194,
0.461229145526886,
-0.4596738815307617,
0.33149081468582153,
-0.436463862657547,
-0.8135208487510681,
0.49484384059906006,
-0.5374097228050232,
0.0323028638958931,
0.3976011574268341,
-0.7749250531196594,
-0.16724373400211334,
0.027125272899866104,
0.5600222945213318,
0.8121368288993835,
-0.6170250177383423,
0.7073906660079956,
-0.3464384377002716,
0.004732916131615639,
0.4165656566619873,
-0.2734546661376953,
0.7846555113792419,
0.15958118438720703,
-0.10227174311876297,
0.6141017079353333,
-0.4373166263103485,
0.41113725304603577,
0.37056615948677063,
-0.15551134943962097,
-0.1524001955986023,
-0.10867639631032944,
-0.29500171542167664,
0.4933719336986542,
0.14843089878559113,
-0.43357929587364197,
0.4074483811855316,
-0.12802019715309143,
0.5977939367294312,
0.6911964416503906,
0.2273436337709427,
0.37193816900253296,
-0.7182178497314453,
0.3684099316596985,
0.09196850657463074,
-0.06817450374364853,
-0.1831447333097458,
-0.9508277177810669,
-0.4102059006690979,
-0.38056451082229614,
-0.07757357507944107,
0.44968852400779724,
-0.735989511013031,
0.24260729551315308,
-0.1647855043411255,
-0.7314497232437134,
-0.45565149188041687,
0.08338489383459091,
0.06317221373319626,
0.4827527403831482,
0.25622424483299255,
0.3113529086112976,
-0.6103750467300415,
-0.8832796216011047,
-0.17790630459785461,
-0.1426582783460617,
0.14056354761123657,
0.2661183476448059,
0.5767354369163513,
0.1616431176662445,
1.2044494152069092,
-0.5860565304756165,
0.09114609658718109,
-0.8630728721618652,
0.24607345461845398,
0.3906773328781128,
0.36859357357025146,
0.14758014678955078,
-0.7669164538383484,
-0.3166228234767914,
-0.30456432700157166,
-0.9148589372634888,
0.025105422362685204,
-0.09695243835449219,
-0.04238676279783249,
0.07407986372709274,
0.34946349263191223,
-1.0881596803665161,
0.055256642401218414,
0.4104628562927246,
-0.01603773981332779,
0.8308129906654358,
-0.057604625821113586,
0.20024992525577545,
-1.3497105836868286,
-0.2362583428621292,
-0.2892111837863922,
0.2958039343357086,
-0.4400905668735504,
0.21671172976493835,
-0.11078808456659317,
-0.2775868773460388,
-0.4674539864063263,
0.5297248363494873,
-0.3273407220840454,
0.16745132207870483,
-0.40040338039398193,
0.5514745116233826,
0.2161131203174591,
0.4301530420780182,
0.20948688685894012,
0.7575998902320862,
0.6313510537147522,
-0.6062657833099365,
0.7938323020935059,
0.34235823154449463,
-0.6177871227264404,
0.5498796701431274,
-0.7493248581886292,
0.22454340755939484,
-0.29039549827575684,
0.43117278814315796,
-0.8061314225196838,
-0.3160320818424225,
-0.07784498482942581,
-0.10116828233003616,
-0.4011913239955902,
-0.009167269803583622,
-0.5903838872909546,
-0.3998784124851227,
0.084718719124794,
0.19285905361175537,
0.21074673533439636,
-0.44725093245506287,
0.6810737252235413,
0.4365307092666626,
-0.5259121060371399,
-0.4474785029888153,
-0.45765429735183716,
0.1481110155582428,
-0.3172309398651123,
-0.8695895671844482,
0.38710513710975647,
-0.3418785631656647,
-0.594268262386322,
-0.15513059496879578,
-0.02414323017001152,
-0.15553252398967743,
-0.0850672796368599,
0.22271165251731873,
0.22394222021102905,
0.10678878426551819,
0.35690075159072876,
-0.15379449725151062,
0.11209384351968765,
0.0802144780755043,
-0.4370135962963104,
0.45674851536750793,
-0.0957392007112503,
-0.4120482802391052,
-0.32752525806427,
0.5248680710792542,
0.5996152758598328,
-0.3407634198665619,
0.8318927884101868,
0.2235022634267807,
-0.44590312242507935,
-0.3903904855251312,
-0.8177992701530457,
-0.5389150381088257,
-0.4909323453903198,
0.5229933261871338,
-0.4210790991783142,
-0.7128950953483582,
0.453696608543396,
-0.23806338012218475,
0.5358368158340454,
0.02559315785765648,
0.7795488238334656,
0.031575459986925125,
1.0953253507614136,
0.5278473496437073,
0.24032941460609436,
0.17345011234283447,
-0.05361977219581604,
0.160482719540596,
-0.41694262623786926,
-0.6017276644706726,
-0.53706955909729,
-0.09545447677373886,
0.0438712053000927,
-0.5736502408981323,
0.34512394666671753,
0.08023489266633987,
0.12279924005270004,
0.04853053390979767,
-0.4975178837776184,
0.46074795722961426,
0.5971866846084595,
0.08084982633590698,
0.2944665253162384,
0.030504852533340454,
-0.5457297563552856,
-0.20357324182987213,
-1.0787593126296997,
-0.25886690616607666,
0.8480891585350037,
-0.030290326103568077,
0.6138917207717896,
-0.05102105066180229,
0.7815297842025757,
-0.2734321355819702,
0.19199085235595703,
-0.8007377982139587,
0.9026577472686768,
0.34213483333587646,
-0.6651583909988403,
-0.5739129781723022,
-0.5126811861991882,
-0.6447221040725708,
0.5474034547805786,
-0.29410842061042786,
-0.631178617477417,
-0.08197426050901413,
-0.12403064221143723,
-0.6597393751144409,
0.31742748618125916,
-0.6737279295921326,
0.8485721945762634,
-0.08785156905651093,
-0.06969276070594788,
-0.5057675242424011,
-0.32330620288848877,
0.30878937244415283,
-0.07841242104768753,
0.5394638180732727,
-0.14966538548469543,
0.182313933968544,
1.065956950187683,
-0.17506518959999084,
0.5376192927360535,
-0.19360770285129547,
-0.22662431001663208,
0.5405073761940002,
-0.19600898027420044,
0.5490187406539917,
0.005827136803418398,
-0.19299419224262238,
-0.1834649294614792,
-0.3525325059890747,
-0.10389796644449234,
-1.1637624502182007,
0.6199454069137573,
-0.45892584323883057,
-1.1650208234786987,
0.0009604547522030771,
-1.1760246753692627,
-0.2487841546535492,
0.2662545144557953,
0.11126016825437546,
0.43807119131088257,
0.13741940259933472,
0.05443749204277992,
0.569958508014679,
-0.08757153898477554,
0.578099250793457,
0.45987534523010254,
-0.44146910309791565,
-0.4361940920352936,
0.7599388957023621,
0.2489749789237976,
0.4098297357559204,
0.02001729980111122,
0.32969775795936584,
-0.12169869244098663,
-0.71095871925354,
-0.3894512355327606,
0.16118256747722626,
-0.9242209792137146,
-0.022054819390177727,
-0.8295912742614746,
-0.178023561835289,
-0.42630359530448914,
-0.05938705429434776,
-0.3203640282154083,
-0.607522189617157,
0.23718224465847015,
-0.1254221796989441,
0.1926015466451645,
0.7633211612701416,
0.0013513913145288825,
0.1962796002626419,
-0.700988233089447,
0.06748853623867035,
0.7451049089431763,
-0.25984448194503784,
0.3199191689491272,
-0.30327746272087097,
-0.24817843735218048,
-0.09203197807073593,
-0.3636559545993805,
-1.1838573217391968,
0.27573415637016296,
-0.37152397632598877,
0.6821432709693909,
0.034271981567144394,
-0.12807050347328186,
0.6083304286003113,
-0.5135914087295532,
0.5902546048164368,
0.3735421895980835,
-0.7596957683563232,
0.5528309941291809,
-0.3128391206264496,
0.6071881055831909,
0.27740612626075745,
0.14319191873073578,
-0.45849987864494324,
-0.6337567567825317,
-0.6154115200042725,
-0.709364116191864,
0.4840621054172516,
0.03901425004005432,
-0.23527587950229645,
0.016105813905596733,
0.10986422747373581,
0.0010463602375239134,
0.33336979150772095,
-0.39646115899086,
-0.11494804173707962,
-0.01894664391875267,
-0.10929428786039352,
0.32161766290664673,
0.06024580076336861,
-0.25612813234329224,
-0.4058930575847626,
0.6049255132675171,
-0.1918041855096817,
0.21480792760849,
0.07042553275823593,
0.26812636852264404,
-0.011721590533852577,
0.665015459060669,
0.5152994394302368,
1.0149577856063843,
0.06317717581987381,
0.22944329679012299,
0.386513352394104,
0.021114248782396317,
0.25944897532463074,
0.1390826553106308,
-0.22847364842891693,
-0.054303448647260666,
0.3017304837703705,
0.6109009981155396,
0.06775937974452972,
-0.6447455883026123,
0.387052446603775,
-0.09671440720558167,
-0.2871462404727936,
0.04544072225689888,
0.24636420607566833,
0.6274999380111694,
0.515903651714325,
0.5670362710952759,
0.29769328236579895,
-0.1952131688594818,
-0.2977200746536255,
0.3485235571861267,
0.6638560891151428,
0.20837514102458954,
0.06211633235216141,
0.5614340305328369,
0.17823651432991028,
-0.13275232911109924,
0.766829252243042,
-0.3045527935028076,
-0.7620500922203064,
0.9300491809844971,
0.5837486982345581,
0.5112806558609009,
-0.0680033266544342,
0.27787572145462036,
0.29553353786468506,
0.21632806956768036,
-0.25314024090766907,
0.4651220738887787,
0.19231721758842468,
-1.0971219539642334,
-0.7631561756134033,
-0.18500028550624847,
-0.6944384574890137,
0.2061607390642166,
-0.3022937774658203,
0.14029110968112946,
-0.36751753091812134,
-0.338015079498291,
0.39208462834358215,
0.16629044711589813,
-0.6901689767837524,
0.06299887597560883,
0.1282237023115158,
0.8469282984733582,
-0.6273654699325562,
0.7362174987792969,
0.7776721715927124,
-0.25366348028182983,
-1.0884625911712646,
-0.1334012895822525,
0.11207042634487152,
-0.49991700053215027,
0.8492443561553955,
0.29788973927497864,
0.14672213792800903,
0.2240092158317566,
-0.8045049905776978,
-0.9181668758392334,
1.196091651916504,
0.4047369658946991,
-0.657950222492218,
-0.16266153752803802,
-0.3641865849494934,
-0.05978630110621452,
-0.6529977917671204,
0.2938147485256195,
0.2101343870162964,
0.7578463554382324,
0.23808623850345612,
-1.0264784097671509,
0.36093220114707947,
0.14608247578144073,
-0.29533568024635315,
-0.3566197454929352,
-0.45060187578201294,
1.0898253917694092,
-0.7877734899520874,
-0.1554969847202301,
0.008283752016723156,
1.019897222518921,
1.1022573709487915,
0.11830500513315201,
0.5992721319198608,
0.4704292416572571,
1.1230820417404175,
0.10393214225769043,
0.6888788938522339,
-0.015013227239251137,
0.028884707018733025,
1.082883358001709,
-0.4473583400249481,
0.5985909700393677,
0.46148625016212463,
0.01776222325861454,
0.5092207193374634,
0.08650081604719162,
0.0008723356877453625,
0.33135542273521423,
0.09613865613937378,
-0.182032510638237,
-0.5899433493614197,
-0.41529834270477295,
-0.16531550884246826,
0.1152862012386322,
0.3217078745365143,
-0.0028458198066800833,
-0.35620060563087463,
0.19675497710704803,
0.1439930498600006,
0.012114339508116245,
-0.170906201004982,
0.595313310623169,
0.22606515884399414,
-1.1431491374969482,
0.4039047360420227,
0.23346887528896332,
0.642148494720459,
-0.3431347906589508,
-0.10791344940662384,
0.015311113558709621,
0.09445889294147491,
-0.026542870327830315,
-0.91534423828125,
0.07585731893777847,
-0.20887118577957153,
-0.448681503534317,
-0.4971526265144348,
0.6615520119667053,
-0.6285668611526489,
-0.24857185781002045,
0.049604326486587524,
0.9539276957511902,
0.1354130655527115,
-0.11483965814113617,
-0.8307476043701172,
0.0897875726222992,
-0.14000602066516876,
-0.19298599660396576,
0.2405214160680771,
0.5197967886924744,
-0.0574265755712986,
1.038520336151123,
0.4619036018848419,
0.0764153003692627,
0.03900142386555672,
0.31842219829559326,
0.8162532448768616,
-0.44179707765579224,
-0.5174837112426758,
-1.0607801675796509,
0.2834509313106537,
-0.37871187925338745,
-0.042239271104335785,
0.9810176491737366,
0.16018804907798767,
0.3595333695411682,
-0.10872815549373627,
0.9586286544799805,
-0.18274478614330292,
0.37089914083480835,
-0.34173914790153503,
0.5683698654174805,
-0.30469462275505066,
0.04057622328400612,
-0.15308590233325958,
-0.7090684175491333,
-0.14161863923072815,
0.490782767534256,
-0.11185848712921143,
0.15768980979919434,
0.8442044258117676,
0.6614965796470642,
0.22335343062877655,
0.26363030076026917,
0.20981578528881073,
0.26883217692375183,
0.4541580379009247,
0.5799713730812073,
0.824708878993988,
0.10296298563480377,
0.4189144968986511,
-0.07913514971733093,
-0.2982679307460785,
0.2080070674419403,
-0.969139039516449,
-1.08810555934906,
-0.7290467023849487,
-0.3280915915966034,
-0.1467297226190567,
0.08791591972112656,
1.2838276624679565,
0.8945069909095764,
-0.6008113622665405,
-0.18135158717632294,
-0.20208872854709625,
0.6160208582878113,
-0.42953965067863464,
-0.2265874147415161,
0.18502536416053772,
-0.4080604612827301,
-0.6412717700004578,
0.7627444267272949,
0.03411993384361267,
-0.012870484963059425,
-0.33554112911224365,
0.042814530432224274,
-0.33781155943870544,
0.4127454459667206,
0.2979997992515564,
-0.2128027230501175,
-0.8318561315536499,
-0.09802911430597305,
0.05610336363315582,
-0.1792164295911789,
-0.3249795138835907,
0.8165074586868286,
-0.8742978572845459,
0.22612982988357544,
0.6202158331871033,
0.6430597901344299,
-0.006264172028750181,
-0.023271260783076286,
0.8083626627922058,
-0.7833606004714966,
0.18575419485569,
0.0021244981326162815,
0.36492425203323364,
0.39373672008514404,
-0.055067043751478195,
0.12969240546226501,
0.4022953510284424,
-0.643200159072876,
-0.6190676093101501,
0.3883405327796936,
-0.6569564342498779,
-0.6670745611190796,
1.0527571439743042,
-0.09418890625238419,
0.01028885506093502,
-0.20722760260105133,
-0.2812870740890503,
0.24095341563224792,
-0.4312274158000946,
0.6550504565238953,
1.0298711061477661,
-0.08420426398515701,
-0.32232052087783813,
-0.5341968536376953,
0.3674194812774658,
0.5933751463890076,
-1.0583242177963257,
0.27460575103759766,
0.294741153717041,
0.17119266092777252,
0.34942173957824707,
0.7070896625518799,
0.3954303562641144,
0.008824989199638367,
-0.011591454036533833,
-0.05381197854876518,
-0.3800927698612213,
-0.6649011969566345,
0.06537490338087082,
0.3836897909641266,
0.053405825048685074,
0.11392819881439209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00755v1
|
Evaluating Mathematical Reasoning of Large Language Models: A Focus on Error Identification and Correction
| 2024-06-02T14:16:24
| 2024-06-02T14:16:24
|
Xiaoyuan Li, Wenjie Wang, Moxin Li, Junrong Guo, Yang Zhang, Fuli Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the realm of
mathematical reasoning necessitates comprehensive evaluations to gauge progress
and inspire future directions. Existing assessments predominantly focus on
problem-solving from the examinee perspective, overlooking a dual perspective
of examiner regarding error identification and correction. From the examiner
perspective, we define four evaluation tasks for error identification and
correction along with a new dataset with annotated error types and steps. We
also design diverse prompts to thoroughly evaluate eleven representative LLMs.
Our principal findings indicate that GPT-4 outperforms all models, while
open-source model LLaMA-2-7B demonstrates comparable abilities to closed-source
models GPT-3.5 and Gemini Pro. Notably, calculation error proves the most
challenging error type. Moreover, prompting LLMs with the error types can
improve the average correction accuracy by 47.9\%. These results reveal
potential directions for developing the mathematical reasoning abilities of
LLMs. Our code and dataset is available on https://github.com/LittleCirc1e/EIC.
|
[
0.05887894704937935,
-0.7475209832191467,
0.8840811848640442,
0.5095946192741394,
-0.032952189445495605,
0.15072296559810638,
-0.4198266565799713,
-0.35285404324531555,
-0.08976731449365616,
0.4131883680820465,
-0.36031660437583923,
-0.3854379653930664,
-0.6339511275291443,
0.2466740757226944,
-0.39558953046798706,
0.6794566512107849,
-0.3569103181362152,
0.315205842256546,
-0.42148464918136597,
0.1501360684633255,
-0.5923606157302856,
-0.4379881024360657,
-0.9182063341140747,
-0.2763492465019226,
0.49254143238067627,
0.2985139489173889,
0.5303860306739807,
0.4451216757297516,
0.59794020652771,
0.4162524938583374,
-0.07044132798910141,
0.2420647293329239,
-0.4294719099998474,
-0.1056293174624443,
-0.2516138255596161,
-0.45930707454681396,
-0.5825960636138916,
-0.06568577140569687,
0.6467484831809998,
0.709589958190918,
-0.30247747898101807,
0.16585098206996918,
-0.1145269051194191,
0.6243215799331665,
-0.41047585010528564,
0.44417640566825867,
-0.5204832553863525,
-0.12924981117248535,
-0.2411998063325882,
0.08522601425647736,
-0.5212119221687317,
-0.5682175159454346,
0.17971034348011017,
-0.605261504650116,
-0.053291235119104385,
0.023679198697209358,
0.39203882217407227,
0.3086744248867035,
-0.33125534653663635,
-0.5044351816177368,
-0.7022911310195923,
0.8854701519012451,
-0.6775871515274048,
0.3513340950012207,
0.11991853266954422,
0.34211429953575134,
-0.17750197649002075,
-0.6740019917488098,
-0.37115809321403503,
-0.28649455308914185,
0.29722467064857483,
0.09391991049051285,
-0.31880638003349304,
-0.1035943329334259,
0.5685295462608337,
0.20211030542850494,
-0.3893662095069885,
0.31644338369369507,
-0.44578447937965393,
-0.3392289876937866,
0.8461312055587769,
0.29879090189933777,
0.14509384334087372,
0.10176334530115128,
0.06100987643003464,
0.02356165461242199,
-0.8124307990074158,
-0.3601856827735901,
0.39009419083595276,
0.12071558833122253,
-0.1405554711818695,
0.6346321702003479,
0.02062811143696308,
0.6327584981918335,
-0.09677442908287048,
-0.19535447657108307,
0.1956212818622589,
-0.18516680598258972,
-0.3158324956893921,
-0.1311185657978058,
0.5903450846672058,
0.21733981370925903,
0.35608628392219543,
0.08217792212963104,
-0.5788109302520752,
0.07124296575784683,
0.06244393065571785,
-0.53384929895401,
-0.22097398340702057,
0.10824703425168991,
-0.1923971027135849,
-0.11088372021913528,
0.08991377800703049,
-0.7512351870536804,
-0.5328124165534973,
-0.6531892418861389,
0.5724408626556396,
-0.10796089470386505,
-0.07594089955091476,
0.3134435713291168,
0.1663466989994049,
0.07270894199609756,
0.8557536602020264,
-0.5837370157241821,
0.3377701938152313,
0.8771783113479614,
0.6032100915908813,
-0.06670714914798737,
-0.1909337043762207,
-0.47950518131256104,
-0.17662443220615387,
-0.5216944813728333,
0.8580248951911926,
-0.5603160262107849,
-0.2903043031692505,
-0.032261721789836884,
-0.1835809201002121,
-0.19367463886737823,
-0.6538099050521851,
0.8581215739250183,
-0.573057234287262,
0.12479505687952042,
-0.3086978495121002,
-0.573276937007904,
-0.3254753351211548,
0.18833893537521362,
-0.7143040895462036,
0.9487818479537964,
0.2301332652568817,
-0.5517092943191528,
-0.10276985913515091,
-0.9489107728004456,
-0.16598042845726013,
-0.056390292942523956,
-0.07880784571170807,
-0.3403826951980591,
0.3678460717201233,
0.2287791222333908,
0.09234025329351425,
-0.6384112238883972,
0.28645044565200806,
-0.3082806468009949,
-0.37496936321258545,
0.32979056239128113,
-0.49124082922935486,
0.7761091589927673,
0.16596515476703644,
-0.2576841711997986,
0.2878749966621399,
-0.8271167278289795,
0.048246197402477264,
0.40756335854530334,
-0.1335783302783966,
-0.11325349658727646,
-0.00030919909477233887,
-0.327129065990448,
-0.044907793402671814,
0.27610018849372864,
-0.43848270177841187,
0.14006103575229645,
-0.2606405019760132,
0.512743353843689,
0.9335607290267944,
-0.15250010788440704,
0.07445596158504486,
-0.1706189215183258,
0.6841629147529602,
-0.0350886769592762,
0.16640354692935944,
-0.19826731085777283,
-0.6202769875526428,
-0.7820748090744019,
-0.1288319230079651,
0.6337746381759644,
0.6642206907272339,
-0.6136093139648438,
0.13242916762828827,
-0.20541872084140778,
-0.6296268105506897,
-0.27710825204849243,
0.25241801142692566,
0.4736560583114624,
0.39305126667022705,
0.144694522023201,
-0.06305749714374542,
-0.5396664142608643,
-0.7712117433547974,
-0.32166197896003723,
-0.18474622070789337,
0.00733288936316967,
0.2484525889158249,
0.647626519203186,
-0.15550808608531952,
0.563766360282898,
-0.36544305086135864,
0.08494176715612411,
-0.09639576822519302,
0.010816088877618313,
0.3050227165222168,
0.2579188346862793,
0.36738917231559753,
-0.46430572867393494,
-0.31798145174980164,
-0.011916265822947025,
-0.6117389798164368,
-0.504374623298645,
0.05964260175824165,
-0.024973856285214424,
0.11859069764614105,
0.1876797080039978,
-0.502682626247406,
0.29725825786590576,
0.5262266993522644,
-0.24133437871932983,
0.859839141368866,
-0.14739224314689636,
0.03908506780862808,
-0.5225309729576111,
-0.13764595985412598,
0.256916344165802,
0.04771740734577179,
-0.36544370651245117,
0.07668611407279968,
0.06950748711824417,
0.09897185862064362,
-0.22585436701774597,
0.5066209435462952,
-0.5213644504547119,
-0.3204929232597351,
-0.09520860761404037,
0.360984206199646,
-0.0839516893029213,
0.08080284297466278,
-0.18025636672973633,
0.6634089946746826,
0.5995553135871887,
-0.3802560567855835,
0.7431236505508423,
0.032422687858343124,
-0.5131094455718994,
0.48736438155174255,
-0.7703869342803955,
0.4751541018486023,
-0.08259154111146927,
0.12713533639907837,
-0.9431736469268799,
-0.27693864703178406,
0.3372250199317932,
-0.3443355858325958,
0.25325265526771545,
0.04997829347848892,
-0.6024622321128845,
-0.5307610630989075,
-0.15793821215629578,
0.39326533675193787,
0.30287835001945496,
-0.6019984483718872,
0.7868737578392029,
0.10690996050834656,
-0.34848055243492126,
-0.6598503589630127,
-0.32767850160598755,
0.047880567610263824,
-0.13026554882526398,
-0.7108224034309387,
-0.07856130599975586,
-0.2301328033208847,
-0.7592000365257263,
-0.08922372758388519,
-0.01964615471661091,
0.00044818519381806254,
0.2130008041858673,
0.012535663321614265,
0.4961289167404175,
-0.40115615725517273,
0.11868636310100555,
-0.03640388324856758,
-0.19793950021266937,
0.33545562624931335,
-0.17047449946403503,
0.35268643498420715,
-0.24199748039245605,
-0.7343797087669373,
-0.32176485657691956,
-0.008823070675134659,
0.5033677220344543,
-0.369340717792511,
0.3156423568725586,
0.13819915056228638,
-0.5838325023651123,
-0.09750975668430328,
-0.6740012764930725,
0.09457423537969589,
-0.3903011083602905,
0.5068721175193787,
-0.5528145432472229,
-0.6873490810394287,
0.5844926834106445,
0.04680388793349266,
0.1023072898387909,
0.6709318161010742,
0.6936433911323547,
0.14520972967147827,
1.0733144283294678,
0.3509911596775055,
0.07053320854902267,
-0.002710457658395171,
-0.0663495734333992,
0.24829545617103577,
-0.7880395650863647,
-0.1961660385131836,
-0.7565774917602539,
-0.0900978073477745,
-0.20751886069774628,
-0.5774095058441162,
0.2577996850013733,
0.1210726648569107,
-0.3172088861465454,
0.048344627022743225,
-0.2575361430644989,
0.6024496555328369,
0.2667378783226013,
-0.01860346831381321,
0.47454148530960083,
-0.08788491040468216,
-0.14640650153160095,
-0.1527138501405716,
-0.35594385862350464,
-0.783687949180603,
1.2872536182403564,
0.5713778138160706,
0.8343480825424194,
0.2592279016971588,
0.49577176570892334,
-0.031737301498651505,
0.8537275195121765,
-0.856899082660675,
0.5218943357467651,
0.07223070412874222,
-0.49830156564712524,
-0.2765977680683136,
-0.6643232703208923,
-0.45233914256095886,
0.2695060074329376,
0.07108692079782486,
-0.7198539972305298,
-0.1354857087135315,
0.12108241766691208,
-0.28148749470710754,
0.25339898467063904,
-0.8210088610649109,
0.869941771030426,
-0.5540921092033386,
-0.21070781350135803,
-0.35743188858032227,
-0.2682618796825409,
0.6224882006645203,
-0.5366942882537842,
0.2993122637271881,
-0.004069298971444368,
-0.2145063430070877,
0.590972363948822,
-0.25758469104766846,
0.7541743516921997,
-0.20556673407554626,
-0.4911884069442749,
0.4290139377117157,
0.13062448799610138,
0.5907191634178162,
-0.04211711883544922,
-0.3699271082878113,
0.12776879966259003,
0.12315217405557632,
-0.14920063316822052,
-0.8647781014442444,
0.535391628742218,
-0.6691732406616211,
-0.7498283982276917,
-0.4574164152145386,
-0.40859848260879517,
-0.25822803378105164,
0.04938642308115959,
-0.20262213051319122,
0.5432997941970825,
-0.13693030178546906,
-0.07061636447906494,
0.45447731018066406,
-0.3232581913471222,
0.14976027607917786,
0.6173754930496216,
-0.4913155734539032,
-0.4760935604572296,
0.7920033931732178,
0.012452216818928719,
0.22602596879005432,
0.2248702347278595,
0.37164023518562317,
-0.5008507966995239,
-0.7716427445411682,
-0.6116184592247009,
0.5910219550132751,
-0.9947221279144287,
-0.15771694481372833,
-0.22954706847667694,
-0.12483859062194824,
-0.18857833743095398,
0.236280158162117,
-0.35340481996536255,
-0.3103281557559967,
-0.28066450357437134,
-0.01362661737948656,
0.16755016148090363,
1.046306848526001,
0.020702319219708443,
0.2953329384326935,
-0.7374069690704346,
-0.10481153428554535,
0.23409520089626312,
0.41309303045272827,
0.18478891253471375,
-0.6484953761100769,
-0.016107812523841858,
-0.0027447540778666735,
-0.44463837146759033,
-0.7417864203453064,
0.05761303752660751,
-0.034041810780763626,
0.6120764017105103,
0.36309775710105896,
-0.34999093413352966,
0.6911743879318237,
-0.4988260269165039,
0.655200719833374,
0.18729543685913086,
-1.2098524570465088,
0.3072967827320099,
-0.2164277881383896,
-0.028062772005796432,
0.10206791013479233,
0.21922968327999115,
-0.41832906007766724,
-0.019899452105164528,
-0.4882110357284546,
-0.16693328320980072,
0.5669500827789307,
0.01606275513768196,
-0.0024758775252848864,
0.028016874566674232,
0.5500378012657166,
-0.055501025170087814,
0.09123232960700989,
-0.6189146041870117,
0.013112382031977177,
0.12002686411142349,
-0.3397980034351349,
-0.13933420181274414,
-0.37250643968582153,
-0.17976023256778717,
-0.2917977571487427,
0.6748632788658142,
-0.25901368260383606,
0.2741228938102722,
0.015622423030436039,
-0.08436775952577591,
-0.3161350190639496,
0.2620218098163605,
0.90537029504776,
1.317880630493164,
0.1241440698504448,
-0.05519403517246246,
0.30540931224823,
-0.2883099913597107,
-0.054201819002628326,
0.17971481382846832,
0.07490882277488708,
-0.10163667798042297,
0.42634403705596924,
0.660763680934906,
0.28397461771965027,
-0.8316918015480042,
0.5506187677383423,
-0.06178421154618263,
-0.21233855187892914,
-0.4770680367946625,
-0.17180463671684265,
0.15517523884773254,
0.3363211750984192,
0.23730945587158203,
-0.07492700964212418,
0.025282971560955048,
-0.33835458755493164,
-0.12929625809192657,
0.3193584978580475,
-0.023292822763323784,
-0.5085574984550476,
0.6148378849029541,
0.11382649093866348,
-0.31920862197875977,
0.6387470960617065,
-0.15509438514709473,
-0.7718287706375122,
0.7437288761138916,
0.6562818288803101,
0.8232144713401794,
-0.44176286458969116,
0.014260516501963139,
0.3872844874858856,
0.4089203476905823,
-0.19996418058872223,
0.39529862999916077,
0.351142942905426,
-0.774692714214325,
-0.8956934809684753,
-0.5614951848983765,
-0.6656853556632996,
0.0394909493625164,
-0.36307618021965027,
0.4897802174091339,
-0.5127912163734436,
0.08982264995574951,
0.09114694595336914,
0.027029145509004593,
-0.42331477999687195,
0.13741983473300934,
0.22339566051959991,
0.9752405285835266,
-0.7512360215187073,
0.5568340420722961,
0.7828938961029053,
-0.177682027220726,
-0.9293070435523987,
-0.37291625142097473,
0.2342965453863144,
-0.8911696672439575,
0.8330517411231995,
0.07820212095975876,
-0.034797489643096924,
-0.02528316341340542,
-0.583665132522583,
-0.8288245797157288,
0.8417540788650513,
0.5319169759750366,
-0.8887179493904114,
0.005072110798209906,
-0.06470702588558197,
0.618222177028656,
-0.4625881016254425,
0.6322984099388123,
0.6830652952194214,
0.683786928653717,
0.24428944289684296,
-1.2403796911239624,
-0.1991109400987625,
-0.06708476692438126,
0.03051251918077469,
0.31431296467781067,
-0.544506311416626,
0.8297535181045532,
-0.42476335167884827,
-0.09493847191333771,
0.38818514347076416,
0.5195556879043579,
0.5063484311103821,
0.3748995363712311,
0.4920105040073395,
0.7783845067024231,
0.8337129950523376,
-0.3141755163669586,
0.9959456324577332,
0.01976388320326805,
0.38488656282424927,
1.0182570219039917,
-0.44599002599716187,
0.7931630611419678,
0.2456926852464676,
-0.5418345928192139,
0.4015698730945587,
0.6991701126098633,
-0.10468757897615433,
-0.0016000071773305535,
0.5067787766456604,
-0.1489139050245285,
-0.2268519252538681,
0.2569386959075928,
-0.2323920875787735,
0.3866729736328125,
0.5719594955444336,
-0.34316787123680115,
-0.24757766723632812,
-0.29054737091064453,
0.031184034422039986,
0.04117068275809288,
-0.5115174055099487,
0.41746097803115845,
0.20675376057624817,
-0.5917390584945679,
0.24837063252925873,
0.2009725421667099,
0.1766085922718048,
-0.3337026834487915,
-0.2682482898235321,
-0.0005435506463982165,
0.42346256971359253,
-0.2874811589717865,
-0.7500317096710205,
0.2599497139453888,
0.16802452504634857,
0.04671895131468773,
0.13142147660255432,
0.47731849551200867,
-0.18886613845825195,
-0.6863052248954773,
0.1319774091243744,
0.46479693055152893,
0.345093697309494,
-0.14926974475383759,
-0.8427388668060303,
0.4459478259086609,
0.059810083359479904,
-0.04899365082383156,
-0.06832299381494522,
0.4220971465110779,
-0.3220970034599304,
0.6720741987228394,
0.5484119057655334,
0.16539527475833893,
0.07172171026468277,
0.47096025943756104,
0.6535539031028748,
-0.5617513060569763,
-0.16752934455871582,
-0.8357759118080139,
0.3747120499610901,
0.06542734801769257,
-0.2929668128490448,
0.7109745740890503,
0.5315713882446289,
0.7589676380157471,
-0.1507103443145752,
0.6537960171699524,
0.20549461245536804,
0.7734044194221497,
-0.6391153335571289,
0.10858117789030075,
-0.2852359414100647,
0.5840194821357727,
-0.427154541015625,
-1.1907955408096313,
-0.46658724546432495,
0.6908072233200073,
-0.6581193804740906,
0.2930869460105896,
0.8129310011863708,
0.667767345905304,
0.06580832600593567,
0.3474854528903961,
0.24772730469703674,
0.3886914849281311,
0.3865707814693451,
0.7742361426353455,
1.3443620204925537,
-0.41604214906692505,
0.30873584747314453,
-0.12177097797393799,
-0.4519915282726288,
-0.10115666687488556,
-0.9381582736968994,
-0.748449444770813,
-0.1680777668952942,
-0.5901616215705872,
-0.3894709050655365,
-0.1893148273229599,
0.9644538164138794,
0.10928459465503693,
-0.7844750881195068,
-0.28999489545822144,
0.11666048318147659,
0.15062862634658813,
-0.11524943262338638,
-0.15018270909786224,
0.38720324635505676,
-0.1540609896183014,
-0.9205231070518494,
0.31365689635276794,
0.35871168971061707,
-0.13930517435073853,
-0.4493080973625183,
-0.19107069075107574,
0.28442785143852234,
0.10090100020170212,
0.6735791563987732,
0.10935548692941666,
-1.0011411905288696,
-0.39046144485473633,
-0.03513389080762863,
0.0759388655424118,
0.02596074528992176,
0.7923900485038757,
-0.29536452889442444,
0.5154147744178772,
0.2604350447654724,
0.8296552300453186,
0.25937989354133606,
-0.08923164010047913,
0.45234382152557373,
0.009045549668371677,
-0.2204502671957016,
0.17737236618995667,
0.6418312788009644,
0.3929986357688904,
-0.1157940998673439,
0.7316372394561768,
0.4870017468929291,
-0.616209864616394,
-0.9451586604118347,
0.04161883145570755,
-0.930679202079773,
0.17120090126991272,
1.0421456098556519,
-0.27994078397750854,
-0.27833130955696106,
0.06827950477600098,
-0.37735021114349365,
-0.13732388615608215,
-0.05880625173449516,
0.5876274108886719,
1.019835352897644,
-0.15535809099674225,
-0.32078301906585693,
-0.7264890074729919,
0.10924829542636871,
0.387460857629776,
-0.8898158669471741,
-0.006972224451601505,
0.7661288976669312,
0.38140571117401123,
0.2627854347229004,
0.3522621989250183,
-0.49851369857788086,
0.47114717960357666,
-0.10523496568202972,
-0.09676505625247955,
0.06413564085960388,
-0.3516457676887512,
-0.5940386652946472,
-0.10165657848119736,
0.29845935106277466,
0.2508116364479065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00751v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00751v1
|
How well do distributed representations convey contextual lexical semantics: a Thesis Proposal
| 2024-06-02T14:08:51
| 2024-06-02T14:08:51
|
Zhu Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern neural networks (NNs), trained on extensive raw sentence data,
construct distributed representations by compressing individual words into
dense, continuous, high-dimensional vectors. These representations are
specifically designed to capture the varied meanings, including ambiguity, of
word occurrences within context. In this thesis, our objective is to examine
the efficacy of distributed representations from NNs in encoding lexical
meaning. Initially, we identify four sources of ambiguity - homonymy, polysemy,
semantic roles, and multifunctionality - based on the relatedness and
similarity of meanings influenced by context. Subsequently, we aim to evaluate
these sources by collecting or constructing multilingual datasets, leveraging
various language models, and employing linguistic analysis tools.
|
[
-0.4442642033100128,
-0.4244941174983978,
0.5657605528831482,
0.5338946580886841,
-0.12214445322751999,
-0.3518643379211426,
-0.39324653148651123,
-0.505741536617279,
0.5114114880561829,
0.07266990095376968,
-0.4706380069255829,
-0.20187103748321533,
-0.931206464767456,
0.577700674533844,
-0.4942377507686615,
0.5035206079483032,
-0.20418991148471832,
0.27787479758262634,
-0.3748099207878113,
-0.3565993309020996,
-0.5635976791381836,
-0.5706983208656311,
-0.0648038238286972,
-0.5692768096923828,
0.7776616215705872,
0.14171665906906128,
1.0260443687438965,
0.6123801469802856,
0.49554067850112915,
0.34561118483543396,
-0.22478805482387543,
0.022536877542734146,
-0.3817765414714813,
0.3963025212287903,
-0.14909246563911438,
-0.46848365664482117,
-0.038199443370103836,
-0.03999260440468788,
1.0637993812561035,
1.3591136932373047,
-0.15392960608005524,
0.015005103312432766,
0.15718145668506622,
0.33009493350982666,
-0.8104451894760132,
0.18188028037548065,
-0.3730561435222626,
0.173361137509346,
-0.24328596889972687,
-0.11282682418823242,
-0.43957069516181946,
-0.252034991979599,
0.5148501396179199,
-0.7971113324165344,
-0.16443392634391785,
-0.2699877917766571,
0.5532639026641846,
0.04238476604223251,
-0.7249398827552795,
-0.6046760082244873,
-0.5378775596618652,
0.8131665587425232,
-0.35966962575912476,
0.2589839994907379,
0.1508926898241043,
0.2630663216114044,
-0.3238254487514496,
-0.7521249055862427,
-0.4972583055496216,
-0.03259986639022827,
-0.3127295672893524,
0.22873766720294952,
0.16494764387607574,
-0.024654574692249298,
0.015883348882198334,
0.02461213804781437,
-0.26691770553588867,
-0.11997231841087341,
-0.10069365799427032,
-0.06760498136281967,
0.5610558390617371,
0.23026013374328613,
0.1739131510257721,
-0.5046197175979614,
-0.5359379649162292,
-0.06105552613735199,
-0.2405920922756195,
-0.3439065217971802,
0.34383249282836914,
0.34342750906944275,
-0.051291536539793015,
0.5724761486053467,
-0.07857222110033035,
0.8466901779174805,
-0.4885575771331787,
0.1242668479681015,
0.15635044872760773,
-0.37544456124305725,
-0.3582245111465454,
0.3663955330848694,
0.4852912724018097,
0.2673810124397278,
0.18445122241973877,
-0.13447201251983643,
-0.17534033954143524,
-0.05808355659246445,
0.17316080629825592,
-0.3099072575569153,
0.4735276401042938,
-0.006009021308273077,
-0.5048037171363831,
-0.06525535881519318,
0.2220713198184967,
-0.6764045357704163,
-0.5318499803543091,
-0.74089115858078,
0.4733109772205353,
-0.33240100741386414,
-0.36579519510269165,
0.20712652802467346,
-0.5334205031394958,
0.1957101821899414,
0.17638565599918365,
-0.884954035282135,
0.3002987802028656,
0.4495098888874054,
0.8008490800857544,
-0.13017632067203522,
-0.3388562798500061,
0.19051256775856018,
0.41060835123062134,
-0.4143897294998169,
0.3298409581184387,
-0.5883190631866455,
-0.14175955951213837,
0.2830303907394409,
-0.05858739838004112,
-0.37840506434440613,
-0.5508792996406555,
0.25723373889923096,
-0.6013513207435608,
-0.11616354435682297,
-0.39937204122543335,
-0.7530377507209778,
-0.17627264559268951,
0.3421899676322937,
-0.8527913689613342,
0.7430192232131958,
0.04005177319049835,
-0.973429799079895,
0.15482385456562042,
-0.4724840819835663,
-0.26765286922454834,
0.14699748158454895,
-0.49364835023880005,
0.19346141815185547,
0.42803633213043213,
0.08564768731594086,
0.6586893200874329,
0.012299793772399426,
0.4426766335964203,
0.005636801943182945,
-0.5989468097686768,
0.36964094638824463,
-0.5381143689155579,
0.7474232316017151,
0.19644592702388763,
-0.40552836656570435,
-0.05232692509889603,
-0.368139386177063,
-0.22951017320156097,
0.17906789481639862,
-0.26221582293510437,
-0.6035782694816589,
-0.19056397676467896,
0.008867847733199596,
-0.008070484735071659,
0.34049543738365173,
-0.4189314842224121,
0.15269382297992706,
-0.37165606021881104,
0.22902223467826843,
0.7416815757751465,
-0.20637740194797516,
0.6008672714233398,
-0.05387140065431595,
0.31975820660591125,
0.3552570343017578,
-0.0043440950103104115,
-0.14347590506076813,
-0.6296736001968384,
-0.5085030794143677,
0.22828878462314606,
0.35103917121887207,
0.3547753691673279,
-0.8139650225639343,
0.024626580998301506,
-0.5364748239517212,
-0.04152972623705864,
-0.1293516457080841,
-0.1060628667473793,
-0.13595697283744812,
0.05618854984641075,
0.014157751575112343,
-0.05863266438245773,
-0.5793340802192688,
-0.9722318649291992,
-0.05067054182291031,
0.27749332785606384,
0.1678003966808319,
0.4405320882797241,
0.5889157056808472,
-0.5351885557174683,
1.0558099746704102,
-0.4198068678379059,
0.1195158064365387,
-0.0057742055505514145,
0.19317759573459625,
0.1862260401248932,
0.10759081691503525,
0.5540252923965454,
-0.8540598154067993,
-0.20926840603351593,
0.04753163456916809,
-1.0520148277282715,
0.013716679997742176,
-0.22014175355434418,
-0.19577614963054657,
-0.06569719314575195,
0.4329904615879059,
-0.3802187144756317,
0.430844783782959,
0.7732396721839905,
-0.21996568143367767,
0.6832295656204224,
-0.3970731496810913,
0.09159816801548004,
-1.2308357954025269,
-0.0705670714378357,
-0.22409115731716156,
-0.19651982188224792,
-0.5092096924781799,
0.04135321453213692,
0.09552188217639923,
-0.23415187001228333,
-0.5079431533813477,
0.4321717917919159,
-0.685634970664978,
-0.14779509603977203,
-0.17449480295181274,
0.6864979267120361,
-0.17822523415088654,
0.1403382569551468,
-0.08360990881919861,
0.5767431259155273,
0.7467154264450073,
-0.7430177330970764,
0.6876944303512573,
0.036625802516937256,
-0.2590399384498596,
0.6971206665039062,
-0.4697878658771515,
-0.2915055453777313,
-0.6712799668312073,
0.250992089509964,
-0.6979540586471558,
-0.5272184014320374,
0.029926907271146774,
-0.16415196657180786,
0.014642298221588135,
0.2753731310367584,
-0.6185939311981201,
-0.1378014087677002,
0.21398353576660156,
0.7167914509773254,
-0.16792891919612885,
-0.42066729068756104,
0.3423148989677429,
0.3189636468887329,
0.4238321781158447,
-0.706352949142456,
-1.0494678020477295,
0.09053900092840195,
-0.10350657999515533,
-0.7315073013305664,
0.4451035261154175,
0.22566534578800201,
-0.295209676027298,
0.1786290407180786,
-0.10825516283512115,
-0.05900202691555023,
0.047104910016059875,
0.3670964241027832,
-0.18147605657577515,
-0.1573966145515442,
0.5075016021728516,
-0.211370587348938,
0.04472890496253967,
0.10418299585580826,
-0.5195516347885132,
0.46801674365997314,
-0.05348803848028183,
-0.5122088193893433,
-0.1790008842945099,
0.7550187706947327,
0.39914825558662415,
0.15135815739631653,
1.1894490718841553,
0.6457529664039612,
-0.6308963894844055,
-0.18293356895446777,
0.09110742062330246,
-0.02247948944568634,
-0.45988720655441284,
0.08705607801675797,
-0.40660393238067627,
-0.9415807723999023,
0.9577529430389404,
-0.3013963997364044,
-0.30554381012916565,
0.4597722589969635,
0.42969754338264465,
0.041107647120952606,
0.8849194049835205,
0.38478371500968933,
0.07147172838449478,
0.43747231364250183,
-0.4000174403190613,
0.03140607848763466,
-0.6775837540626526,
-0.28151750564575195,
-0.31204286217689514,
-0.5573515892028809,
-0.8072402477264404,
-0.5269380807876587,
0.40655335783958435,
0.10096539556980133,
-0.17794349789619446,
0.34875431656837463,
-0.3851639926433563,
0.33819901943206787,
0.49467548727989197,
-0.1422826498746872,
-0.20385949313640594,
0.0887194499373436,
-0.6353253722190857,
-0.02541619911789894,
-0.7551047801971436,
-0.4836726188659668,
0.7710105180740356,
0.39398249983787537,
0.5720205307006836,
0.38706570863723755,
0.8561082482337952,
0.09897308796644211,
-0.11813165992498398,
-0.7202547192573547,
0.45285937190055847,
-0.04396887123584747,
-0.7025532126426697,
0.010213777422904968,
-0.4640960097312927,
-1.329401969909668,
0.37756842374801636,
-0.18974587321281433,
-0.6970372796058655,
0.4964950382709503,
-0.5207143425941467,
-0.32437166571617126,
0.10943419486284256,
-0.6657484173774719,
0.6583529114723206,
0.056045789271593094,
-0.07776687294244766,
-0.18828564882278442,
-0.803390622138977,
0.20043273270130157,
0.22287100553512573,
0.2443210780620575,
0.0311887264251709,
-0.08570603281259537,
0.7711369395256042,
-0.01749923638999462,
0.7896969318389893,
-0.04590899124741554,
-0.039793532341718674,
0.3321589529514313,
0.012450765818357468,
0.08632005751132965,
0.28713458776474,
-0.6137810945510864,
0.3612065315246582,
0.3240131139755249,
-0.5223729014396667,
-0.6151525974273682,
0.7100256681442261,
-0.849929928779602,
-0.3009013235569,
-0.6373928189277649,
-0.773961067199707,
0.045328348875045776,
0.32538673281669617,
0.3176786005496979,
0.8081333041191101,
-0.18010830879211426,
0.36204349994659424,
0.4659746587276459,
-0.12429556250572205,
0.6333452463150024,
-0.27911704778671265,
-0.12256224453449249,
-0.3805919885635376,
0.2972622215747833,
0.23456627130508423,
0.26281532645225525,
0.22340995073318481,
0.1170794814825058,
-0.15038631856441498,
-0.17704276740550995,
-0.4050658941268921,
-0.001909967977553606,
-1.1630700826644897,
-0.16496434807777405,
-0.2759014666080475,
-0.35225415229797363,
-0.45002731680870056,
-0.1786595731973648,
-0.14758315682411194,
-0.2042851746082306,
-0.4384314715862274,
0.10698965936899185,
0.2633989751338959,
1.2891501188278198,
-0.003138152649626136,
0.702702522277832,
-0.6479249000549316,
0.1431669145822525,
0.05626407638192177,
0.5513607859611511,
0.0850071981549263,
-0.018866457045078278,
-0.5347161889076233,
0.2786365747451782,
-0.03721567615866661,
-1.2892719507217407,
0.2603548765182495,
0.21226970851421356,
0.9745588302612305,
0.3783588707447052,
-0.1215796247124672,
0.6214330792427063,
-0.34379053115844727,
0.9970424175262451,
0.16844019293785095,
-0.9154332876205444,
0.4108031094074249,
-0.4037643074989319,
0.5659703612327576,
0.4280718266963959,
0.5340771079063416,
-0.8292476534843445,
-0.165935680270195,
-0.40080544352531433,
-0.7905960083007812,
0.6799866557121277,
0.34539973735809326,
0.6163684129714966,
-0.39633169770240784,
0.8275848031044006,
0.0423220731317997,
0.06450390815734863,
-0.6281710863113403,
-0.6355667114257812,
-0.10839192569255829,
-0.3276001214981079,
0.004101947881281376,
-0.28155648708343506,
-0.13349638879299164,
-0.22830228507518768,
0.024063492193818092,
-0.15953126549720764,
0.6822240352630615,
0.5025614500045776,
-0.21421697735786438,
0.20700864493846893,
0.2058812379837036,
0.7482483983039856,
0.7767214179039001,
-0.009449413046240807,
0.834930956363678,
0.026925688609480858,
-0.4909232556819916,
0.14332431554794312,
-0.11005957424640656,
0.00009256019984604791,
0.34392207860946655,
0.5911306738853455,
0.9333746433258057,
0.30380022525787354,
-0.2708343267440796,
0.4283307194709778,
-0.12668554484844208,
-0.21251429617404938,
-0.2558678984642029,
-0.3464464247226715,
0.38920268416404724,
0.133643239736557,
0.2817095220088959,
0.11201651394367218,
0.15695077180862427,
-0.6382644772529602,
0.4876735508441925,
0.32333889603614807,
-0.41261324286460876,
-0.07533041387796402,
0.22244258224964142,
-0.12450937926769257,
0.09459289908409119,
0.7076839804649353,
-0.3476250469684601,
-0.6749300360679626,
0.4797959327697754,
0.7866725325584412,
0.4529585540294647,
-0.21914267539978027,
0.2342519760131836,
0.39507266879081726,
0.15494105219841003,
-0.20304512977600098,
0.16053760051727295,
-0.007312174420803785,
-1.006914496421814,
-0.29643669724464417,
-0.7266452312469482,
-0.10590460151433945,
-0.46523159742355347,
-0.7004078030586243,
0.04366932809352875,
-0.07769691944122314,
-0.44915342330932617,
-0.06524786353111267,
-0.25396111607551575,
-0.7228389382362366,
0.017087316140532494,
0.4022389054298401,
0.6925198435783386,
-0.8541502356529236,
0.7322900891304016,
0.8754163384437561,
-0.2878749966621399,
-1.0081223249435425,
0.18272259831428528,
-0.09189771115779877,
-0.5140307545661926,
0.9344137907028198,
0.31784453988075256,
-0.03876180201768875,
-0.10423421859741211,
-0.3130778670310974,
-1.131287932395935,
0.937862753868103,
0.6009141802787781,
-0.3965499699115753,
0.13499882817268372,
0.6711515784263611,
0.4750543534755707,
-0.6421852111816406,
0.391539603471756,
0.4150402247905731,
0.6519272327423096,
0.29646337032318115,
-0.8989539742469788,
0.03009115718305111,
-0.11314019560813904,
0.3312157988548279,
0.0017371614230796695,
0.06991931796073914,
0.9584844708442688,
0.3308209776878357,
-0.3991585373878479,
-0.4105946719646454,
0.46714261174201965,
-0.0206502266228199,
0.1033959612250328,
0.19202250242233276,
0.37497708201408386,
0.8537691831588745,
-0.17847487330436707,
1.2225697040557861,
-0.04414768144488335,
0.3243437111377716,
0.8410793542861938,
0.015380815602838993,
0.723357081413269,
0.6821519136428833,
0.22338137030601501,
0.6993756294250488,
0.6737998723983765,
0.37770673632621765,
0.5256243348121643,
0.5532676577568054,
-0.44348740577697754,
-0.03289289027452469,
-0.3861863911151886,
-0.1898898184299469,
0.505334734916687,
0.431918203830719,
-0.41576361656188965,
-0.46001774072647095,
0.40413209795951843,
-0.4978697597980499,
0.23505724966526031,
-0.28658342361450195,
0.6891739368438721,
0.34889933466911316,
-0.45367300510406494,
0.6924393177032471,
-0.0008038745727390051,
0.6681496500968933,
-0.35781413316726685,
0.08511602133512497,
-0.031918931752443314,
0.20640842616558075,
-0.30031636357307434,
-0.946187436580658,
0.6697217226028442,
-0.6273977756500244,
0.0417172946035862,
-0.37798628211021423,
0.690361738204956,
-0.4057823419570923,
-0.3443254828453064,
0.70505291223526,
0.45779263973236084,
0.21997086703777313,
0.2164199948310852,
-0.5260807275772095,
0.2829724848270416,
-0.3768857419490814,
-0.08420935273170471,
-0.08286334574222565,
0.6342180967330933,
-0.1887092888355255,
0.42848432064056396,
-0.021826595067977905,
0.2279270738363266,
0.5194353461265564,
0.42411068081855774,
0.5442972183227539,
-0.7182650566101074,
-0.42894452810287476,
-0.8224484324455261,
0.4036143720149994,
-0.0014978961553424597,
-0.04714343324303627,
0.7315390110015869,
0.11063925921916962,
0.879087507724762,
0.08376383036375046,
0.32460710406303406,
-0.13706360757350922,
-0.3263188600540161,
-0.14230836927890778,
0.5636905431747437,
-0.5552502274513245,
-0.0004943416570313275,
-0.06211750581860542,
-0.8573359251022339,
-0.6530492901802063,
0.7693257331848145,
-0.2349797487258911,
0.0807918831706047,
0.7607642412185669,
0.4285699427127838,
-0.247892826795578,
0.27670785784721375,
0.2882124185562134,
-0.2739807367324829,
-0.13557778298854828,
0.3425600230693817,
0.94527268409729,
-0.585213840007782,
0.05547336861491203,
-0.1859671026468277,
-0.02655721642076969,
-0.2658957839012146,
-0.956169843673706,
-0.4421781301498413,
-0.8241881132125854,
0.02205551788210869,
-0.11739601939916611,
-0.1519888937473297,
0.9646729230880737,
0.8097510933876038,
-0.5947107076644897,
-0.47997117042541504,
-0.27021297812461853,
0.255910187959671,
-0.3518858253955841,
-0.18587003648281097,
0.3017456531524658,
-0.41408947110176086,
-0.6014235615730286,
0.27370697259902954,
-0.06929293274879456,
-0.08833548426628113,
-0.45522674918174744,
-0.12685532867908478,
-0.3448200523853302,
0.11406823992729187,
0.6968826055526733,
-0.6490827202796936,
-0.6283239722251892,
-0.46403181552886963,
0.12105848640203476,
-0.4882757067680359,
-0.020225748419761658,
0.7414698004722595,
-0.35911867022514343,
0.6295301914215088,
0.8471625447273254,
0.6982918381690979,
0.268283873796463,
-0.26575180888175964,
0.8052184581756592,
-1.0628814697265625,
0.4506990909576416,
0.14937038719654083,
0.5057727098464966,
0.3810913562774658,
-0.5013531446456909,
0.15929077565670013,
0.18460232019424438,
-0.3696514368057251,
-0.45711004734039307,
0.3789149224758148,
-0.8408511281013489,
-0.4645310938358307,
1.159031867980957,
-0.11972255259752274,
-0.3976994454860687,
-0.13427305221557617,
0.11391539871692657,
0.5791224241256714,
-0.040783729404211044,
0.2060386836528778,
0.8954114317893982,
-0.20509231090545654,
-0.015805121511220932,
-0.9437946081161499,
0.3298693299293518,
0.23136122524738312,
-0.32601621747016907,
0.021833127364516258,
0.40453386306762695,
0.11839732527732849,
0.5629644393920898,
0.2194312959909439,
-0.13147760927677155,
-0.17974123358726501,
0.048126570880413055,
0.010093177668750286,
0.25983890891075134,
-0.15175247192382812,
-0.6726417541503906,
0.4155239462852478,
-0.11779142171144485,
-0.20319126546382904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06560v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06560v1
|
Inverse Constitutional AI: Compressing Preferences into Principles
| 2024-06-02T11:54:50
| 2024-06-02T11:54:50
|
Arduin Findeis, Timo Kaufmann, Eyke Hüllermeier, Samuel Albanie, Robert Mullins
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Feedback data plays an important role in fine-tuning and evaluating
state-of-the-art AI models. Often pairwise text preferences are used: given two
texts, human (or AI) annotators select the "better" one. Such feedback data is
widely used to align models to human preferences (e.g., reinforcement learning
from human feedback), or to rank models according to human preferences (e.g.,
Chatbot Arena). Despite its wide-spread use, prior work has demonstrated that
human-annotated pairwise text preference data often exhibits unintended biases.
For example, human annotators have been shown to prefer assertive over truthful
texts in certain contexts. Models trained or evaluated on this data may
implicitly encode these biases in a manner hard to identify. In this paper, we
formulate the interpretation of existing pairwise text preference data as a
compression task: the Inverse Constitutional AI (ICAI) problem. In
constitutional AI, a set of principles (or constitution) is used to provide
feedback and fine-tune AI models. The ICAI problem inverts this process: given
a dataset of feedback, we aim to extract a constitution that best enables a
large language model (LLM) to reconstruct the original annotations. We propose
a corresponding initial ICAI algorithm and validate its generated constitutions
quantitatively based on reconstructed annotations. Generated constitutions have
many potential use-cases -- they may help identify undesirable biases, scale
feedback to unseen data or assist with adapting LLMs to individual user
preferences. We demonstrate our approach on a variety of datasets: (a)
synthetic feedback datasets with known underlying principles; (b) the
AlpacaEval dataset of cross-annotated human feedback; and (c) the crowdsourced
Chatbot Arena data set. We release the code for our algorithm and experiments
at https://github.com/rdnfn/icai .
|
[
-0.5112609267234802,
-0.4438341557979584,
0.26876190304756165,
-0.04283006861805916,
-0.3949658274650574,
-0.3534320890903473,
-0.6771115064620972,
-0.27066275477409363,
0.26915889978408813,
0.8221064209938049,
-0.44235193729400635,
-0.05758143216371536,
-0.5177354216575623,
0.1989048272371292,
-0.4365974962711334,
1.2806568145751953,
0.2230679839849472,
0.15017516911029816,
-0.3049558401107788,
-0.2470531165599823,
-0.3117826581001282,
-0.7796159982681274,
-0.4825652539730072,
-0.6265137195587158,
0.016090095043182373,
0.6910886168479919,
0.7975024580955505,
0.5919997692108154,
0.38037583231925964,
0.25108465552330017,
0.21046748757362366,
0.24016650021076202,
-0.7484750747680664,
-0.23553957045078278,
0.09988553076982498,
-0.5418909192085266,
0.041020385921001434,
0.43568068742752075,
0.597144603729248,
0.4785948693752289,
0.02286243624985218,
0.176558718085289,
0.2388216108083725,
0.8864787817001343,
-0.4788857102394104,
0.3442634046077728,
-0.7212882041931152,
-0.12838901579380035,
-0.10392505675554276,
-0.24937045574188232,
-0.3619127869606018,
-0.4912804365158081,
0.25476428866386414,
-0.7677136659622192,
0.060905758291482925,
0.29776865243911743,
0.9712718725204468,
0.48331204056739807,
-0.17902882397174835,
-0.3545272946357727,
-0.7788171768188477,
0.6750016212463379,
-0.7299946546554565,
0.24516376852989197,
0.6531855463981628,
0.10705279558897018,
-0.3199600577354431,
-0.39864984154701233,
-1.1630048751831055,
-0.42656195163726807,
-0.42884665727615356,
0.1545621007680893,
0.08468414098024368,
0.27667340636253357,
0.2186126708984375,
0.4872656762599945,
-0.12186184525489807,
0.25720876455307007,
-0.5116605758666992,
0.015696506947278976,
0.8093630075454712,
-0.11598937958478928,
0.25771138072013855,
-0.3303688168525696,
0.014234988018870354,
-0.2950824201107025,
-0.7237371206283569,
0.39129337668418884,
0.9001379013061523,
0.39531058073043823,
-0.2247469127178192,
0.680202841758728,
-0.3876958191394806,
0.5048540830612183,
0.5121094584465027,
0.05770469456911087,
0.13457177579402924,
-0.11671396344900131,
-0.2761884331703186,
-0.046667829155921936,
0.8751528859138489,
0.5759022235870361,
0.25465822219848633,
-0.2632255256175995,
-0.18278221786022186,
0.07135764509439468,
0.290353000164032,
-0.5777649283409119,
-0.3876808285713196,
0.38161882758140564,
-0.6936275959014893,
-0.5769237279891968,
0.34551239013671875,
-0.7428980469703674,
-0.6011419296264648,
-0.9286693930625916,
0.3460902273654938,
-0.25975024700164795,
-0.1047026738524437,
-0.04062817618250847,
-0.1733674556016922,
0.33649128675460815,
0.1058114692568779,
-1.081101417541504,
0.39760902523994446,
0.9957829713821411,
0.5806270241737366,
-0.06670532375574112,
-0.0497911274433136,
-0.4022494852542877,
-0.1774977743625641,
-0.1626344919204712,
0.8010782599449158,
-0.6956431865692139,
-0.23414693772792816,
-0.11203201860189438,
-0.0643092468380928,
0.2346183955669403,
-0.5387732982635498,
0.9120640754699707,
-0.2019924521446228,
0.27620595693588257,
-0.2862555682659149,
-0.5927951335906982,
-0.07614108175039291,
0.3891198933124542,
-0.8638699650764465,
0.7828108668327332,
-0.23987028002738953,
-0.7511927485466003,
0.5705467462539673,
-0.7395859360694885,
-0.13999320566654205,
-0.12102290242910385,
-0.4098062217235565,
-0.48812681436538696,
0.06090260297060013,
0.40231573581695557,
0.20031869411468506,
-0.52690589427948,
0.31430813670158386,
-0.533405065536499,
-0.4919305145740509,
0.2867790460586548,
-0.2049216628074646,
0.8597081303596497,
-0.05192532762885094,
-0.4147278666496277,
0.20364317297935486,
-0.7147483229637146,
-0.21094287931919098,
-0.11699143052101135,
-0.3590669333934784,
-0.4601825475692749,
0.18123945593833923,
-0.10001732409000397,
-0.09879403561353683,
-0.03489314764738083,
-0.5847893953323364,
0.5084696412086487,
-0.6342194676399231,
0.5709006190299988,
1.0948396921157837,
-0.07275302708148956,
0.6727866530418396,
-0.5800092816352844,
0.202431321144104,
-0.11563348770141602,
0.24143247306346893,
0.32048988342285156,
-0.3296542465686798,
-0.8791944980621338,
-0.21324798464775085,
0.41326382756233215,
0.5147882103919983,
-0.5085312128067017,
0.6529132723808289,
-0.4717257022857666,
-0.2785034775733948,
-0.8133143782615662,
0.023903094232082367,
0.25890782475471497,
0.45412716269493103,
0.1892601102590561,
-0.1818368285894394,
-0.6292349100112915,
-1.1586978435516357,
-0.1878107786178589,
-0.7228655815124512,
0.12388786673545837,
0.5285940170288086,
0.411405473947525,
-0.046294670552015305,
0.8613420128822327,
-0.23433832824230194,
-0.2604936957359314,
0.006657082121819258,
0.2536657750606537,
0.2171715348958969,
0.6781482696533203,
0.400012344121933,
-1.0093708038330078,
0.025877662003040314,
-0.2056797593832016,
-0.4259999692440033,
-0.07577842473983765,
-0.41196081042289734,
-0.3759438991546631,
-0.028783472254872322,
0.2463134378194809,
-0.36059778928756714,
0.6179599165916443,
0.32957446575164795,
0.02232808992266655,
0.47346583008766174,
-0.07985562831163406,
0.46297237277030945,
-0.9384872913360596,
0.32146814465522766,
-0.09194757044315338,
-0.020948294550180435,
-0.4067046046257019,
0.09868790209293365,
-0.19591788947582245,
0.05389157310128212,
0.035439494997262955,
0.42006033658981323,
-0.2127983272075653,
0.11992080509662628,
-0.22206789255142212,
0.04375351592898369,
-0.22431713342666626,
0.7176908254623413,
0.05773947387933731,
0.6645671129226685,
0.06017298996448517,
-0.5933598279953003,
0.42949479818344116,
0.5379132628440857,
-0.1258171647787094,
0.5879384875297546,
-0.6527098417282104,
0.5356498956680298,
-0.45262596011161804,
0.41507795453071594,
-1.0140273571014404,
-0.3082302212715149,
0.5361741185188293,
-0.5055695176124573,
0.16900202631950378,
-0.32478582859039307,
-0.32485145330429077,
-0.1845351755619049,
-0.5199320912361145,
0.37045103311538696,
0.3569817841053009,
-0.7203994989395142,
0.3825014531612396,
0.7509759664535522,
0.1838502138853073,
-0.8506800532341003,
-0.5983071327209473,
0.08178675919771194,
-0.297087699174881,
-0.22393938899040222,
0.38858577609062195,
-0.23674394190311432,
-0.5296292901039124,
0.045905087143182755,
0.2584812343120575,
-0.0318252369761467,
0.0605241060256958,
0.7597508430480957,
0.24284569919109344,
0.07342949509620667,
0.18157127499580383,
0.23059986531734467,
-0.006743812933564186,
-0.027260292321443558,
-0.3741297423839569,
0.2192438542842865,
-0.04811139032244682,
-0.0667036697268486,
-0.6884066462516785,
0.3278519809246063,
0.5093108415603638,
-0.01667405478656292,
0.6450216770172119,
0.10613597929477692,
-0.41178444027900696,
0.056491490453481674,
-0.5543805956840515,
-0.35532698035240173,
-0.34492701292037964,
-0.13831184804439545,
-0.22695623338222504,
-0.5142863392829895,
0.41638118028640747,
-0.007917618378996849,
0.4385424256324768,
0.4614376723766327,
0.48443353176116943,
-0.0371246375143528,
0.8274444341659546,
0.6212804317474365,
-0.5342527627944946,
0.48789143562316895,
-0.31575194001197815,
0.0587824247777462,
-0.6626186966896057,
-0.1541001945734024,
-0.9725146889686584,
-0.5342068672180176,
-0.6810849905014038,
0.3420926034450531,
0.3582000136375427,
0.15635842084884644,
-0.09127791225910187,
0.22029928863048553,
-0.5760472416877747,
0.5745227932929993,
0.9286792874336243,
0.5350296497344971,
0.1552589237689972,
-0.10628481209278107,
0.08602025359869003,
0.10081388056278229,
-0.2574761211872101,
-0.6579912304878235,
1.301808476448059,
-0.14620211720466614,
0.49132218956947327,
0.13114845752716064,
0.848808765411377,
0.45424461364746094,
0.40317198634147644,
-0.8872008919715881,
0.2691596448421478,
-0.17112530767917633,
-0.479878306388855,
-0.38939183950424194,
-0.3630446791648865,
-0.6786579489707947,
-0.077260822057724,
-0.7526358366012573,
-0.6260703802108765,
0.3435291647911072,
0.44543027877807617,
-0.5479750633239746,
0.23121178150177002,
-0.6190757155418396,
0.5713134407997131,
0.09856157004833221,
-0.1514759659767151,
-0.46505028009414673,
-0.7617918252944946,
0.43650907278060913,
0.07132351398468018,
-0.042280521243810654,
0.0563187412917614,
0.15914256870746613,
0.7429528832435608,
-0.5293144583702087,
0.8567438721656799,
-0.08012229204177856,
0.17580091953277588,
0.1257326602935791,
-0.19194002449512482,
0.39940330386161804,
0.27435484528541565,
-0.33148089051246643,
0.07617174834012985,
0.17379306256771088,
-0.18950839340686798,
-0.8491153717041016,
0.7490794658660889,
-1.1266618967056274,
-0.7637845873832703,
-0.16546104848384857,
-0.16863368451595306,
-0.09815462678670883,
0.010183358564972878,
0.3941633105278015,
0.6277833580970764,
-0.173505038022995,
0.18557068705558777,
0.2563410699367523,
-0.08787964284420013,
0.16523520648479462,
0.10207659006118774,
0.12639233469963074,
-0.5300276279449463,
0.5921534299850464,
0.06877657026052475,
-0.23808571696281433,
0.44658929109573364,
0.35549604892730713,
-0.2943892478942871,
-0.6196047067642212,
-0.5403001308441162,
0.1303681582212448,
-0.5001953840255737,
-0.2243276983499527,
-0.3123379647731781,
0.022691775113344193,
-0.4990631639957428,
0.08523918688297272,
-0.06131976470351219,
-0.8319135308265686,
-0.426044762134552,
-0.022821102291345596,
0.09205760061740875,
0.6682543158531189,
-0.21306003630161285,
0.18280473351478577,
-0.47711625695228577,
0.5771263241767883,
0.28924521803855896,
0.2789047956466675,
-0.26710954308509827,
-0.5354888439178467,
0.10587650537490845,
0.30565452575683594,
-0.10295600444078445,
-0.78617924451828,
0.05863511562347412,
0.2688070237636566,
0.45396918058395386,
0.39622196555137634,
0.5847047567367554,
0.7854382991790771,
-0.21508309245109558,
0.7872574925422668,
-0.22760790586471558,
-0.8483757972717285,
0.48047924041748047,
0.1131555512547493,
-0.16053730249404907,
0.9228132963180542,
0.2647762894630432,
-0.44743913412094116,
-0.2693316340446472,
-0.5294370055198669,
-0.38254621624946594,
0.8443182706832886,
0.2825460433959961,
0.2822105884552002,
0.19499342143535614,
1.066009283065796,
0.39993607997894287,
0.14396671950817108,
-0.6593190431594849,
-0.18604153394699097,
-0.3300490379333496,
-0.4437997043132782,
0.11243430525064468,
-0.15023823082447052,
-0.3012552261352539,
-0.3079336881637573,
0.9571287035942078,
-0.28073787689208984,
0.25716936588287354,
0.31563183665275574,
-0.08515097200870514,
-0.09525331854820251,
0.301283597946167,
0.6252824068069458,
0.3994995951652527,
-0.1634303778409958,
0.040223948657512665,
-0.07550700753927231,
-0.37351372838020325,
0.059326235204935074,
0.31642457842826843,
-0.5066651105880737,
-0.43671149015426636,
0.18178078532218933,
0.6593132019042969,
-0.17029529809951782,
-0.4667264223098755,
0.6197272539138794,
-0.3875666558742523,
0.11685628443956375,
-0.5985608696937561,
-0.04500511661171913,
-0.6285757422447205,
0.14418494701385498,
0.29933983087539673,
0.33920708298683167,
0.4087657928466797,
-0.5583924055099487,
0.1046154722571373,
0.5914813876152039,
-0.44196563959121704,
-0.5645551681518555,
0.5158864855766296,
0.4123184084892273,
-0.17532649636268616,
0.8346056342124939,
0.03328623250126839,
-0.5757390856742859,
0.42251917719841003,
0.09526459872722626,
0.8337616324424744,
0.2455558031797409,
0.06857194006443024,
0.529634952545166,
0.3545492887496948,
-0.09349943697452545,
0.004940785001963377,
-0.3487417697906494,
-0.8334313631057739,
-0.1814345270395279,
-0.24374984204769135,
-0.409397155046463,
0.28006553649902344,
-0.671721339225769,
0.5401850938796997,
-0.6235769987106323,
-0.2097516804933548,
0.09331236779689789,
0.13521422445774078,
-0.5539978742599487,
0.06163397803902626,
0.12655769288539886,
0.42506852746009827,
-0.6595987677574158,
0.7464918494224548,
0.4683765470981598,
-0.5682304501533508,
-0.7236641645431519,
0.18186968564987183,
0.2562372386455536,
-0.8155606985092163,
0.3993827700614929,
0.07368654757738113,
-0.00391322560608387,
-0.2937694489955902,
-1.0595126152038574,
-0.27463120222091675,
0.6021494269371033,
0.5539774298667908,
-0.449516624212265,
-0.13455069065093994,
0.10732359439134598,
0.4951707720756531,
-0.20983782410621643,
0.36388736963272095,
0.7196227312088013,
0.4646202325820923,
-0.21964852511882782,
-0.9379324316978455,
0.14002209901809692,
-0.3752392828464508,
-0.3323451578617096,
0.24841226637363434,
-0.6427929401397705,
0.4206463396549225,
-0.15026208758354187,
-0.13640344142913818,
0.3703976273536682,
0.6688726544380188,
-0.1434224545955658,
0.08695830404758453,
0.818134605884552,
0.5399774312973022,
0.7136696577072144,
-0.14034050703048706,
1.0538426637649536,
-0.3114909827709198,
0.16072529554367065,
1.0370053052902222,
0.0407196544110775,
0.7220212817192078,
0.5897384285926819,
0.15302033722400665,
0.3837270140647888,
0.47553831338882446,
0.0679318755865097,
0.3440759479999542,
0.21328584849834442,
0.0810912698507309,
-0.12233780324459076,
-0.3096168637275696,
-0.2033771574497223,
0.6214427947998047,
0.17984983325004578,
-0.3531631827354431,
0.33519867062568665,
-0.24889016151428223,
0.03318775072693825,
0.1890190839767456,
-0.1828552782535553,
1.0797441005706787,
-0.24676387012004852,
-1.0331604480743408,
0.3485304117202759,
-0.05008050426840782,
0.6110671758651733,
-0.2469080239534378,
-0.4106218218803406,
-0.32019078731536865,
0.09306365996599197,
-0.279112309217453,
-0.6549732685089111,
0.1962737739086151,
-0.169464573264122,
-0.21731239557266235,
-0.02478419989347458,
0.3959673047065735,
-0.43558549880981445,
-0.21269547939300537,
-0.26402729749679565,
-0.0842435210943222,
0.028689974918961525,
-0.027112266048789024,
-0.6163593530654907,
-0.021111689507961273,
0.10167533159255981,
-0.005315673537552357,
-0.15206696093082428,
0.19988010823726654,
-0.1677217185497284,
0.35599854588508606,
0.7146845459938049,
0.12585040926933289,
-0.4168943166732788,
-0.13515223562717438,
1.0169388055801392,
-0.46365886926651,
-0.5923677682876587,
-0.8390218019485474,
0.27713844180107117,
-0.349128782749176,
-0.5564150810241699,
0.3049488365650177,
0.468212753534317,
0.7919335961341858,
0.19524626433849335,
0.8039739727973938,
-0.09270557016134262,
0.42284202575683594,
-0.7015630602836609,
0.7166247963905334,
-0.29369932413101196,
0.17386546730995178,
-0.31399351358413696,
-0.6561263799667358,
-0.2837899923324585,
0.380776047706604,
-0.2826186716556549,
-0.3260318636894226,
0.2209656834602356,
0.8360170722007751,
-0.06978330761194229,
0.344369113445282,
-0.04367315396666527,
0.03132280707359314,
0.401970237493515,
0.32201242446899414,
0.8570323586463928,
-0.45191070437431335,
0.5525274872779846,
-0.537685215473175,
-0.3401419520378113,
-0.12939895689487457,
-0.7406740784645081,
-0.9514015913009644,
-1.0503897666931152,
-0.24014583230018616,
-0.5219179391860962,
-0.13218532502651215,
1.4573298692703247,
0.9675513505935669,
-0.921196460723877,
-0.13986682891845703,
0.04385622590780258,
0.008939406834542751,
-0.16728314757347107,
-0.21599127352237701,
0.41696181893348694,
0.051056355237960815,
-0.7720268368721008,
0.07539687305688858,
-0.015170175582170486,
0.10059034079313278,
-0.2112818956375122,
-0.2178206592798233,
0.11831695586442947,
0.22304129600524902,
0.12651985883712769,
0.5074738264083862,
-0.9045494794845581,
-0.6395449638366699,
-0.41689953207969666,
0.04314799606800079,
0.22905588150024414,
1.241806983947754,
-0.8999013304710388,
0.5182244181632996,
0.5798529386520386,
0.7027108073234558,
0.43020346760749817,
0.2205817997455597,
0.766818642616272,
-0.5166072249412537,
0.4789482057094574,
0.206660196185112,
0.35088223218917847,
0.3641948103904724,
-0.5605100393295288,
0.5145263075828552,
0.13316723704338074,
-0.5157918930053711,
-0.7609632611274719,
0.14453013241291046,
-0.8694546818733215,
-0.01605297438800335,
1.0299774408340454,
-0.038207028061151505,
-0.30120813846588135,
0.017904629930853844,
-0.7021530270576477,
0.27388522028923035,
-0.603260338306427,
1.2099798917770386,
0.6690235137939453,
-0.18646983802318573,
-0.14023272693157196,
0.05099165439605713,
0.8930381536483765,
0.24774858355522156,
-0.7864352464675903,
0.08127084374427795,
0.6647030115127563,
-0.06417105346918106,
0.11855214089155197,
0.4661561846733093,
-0.07431936264038086,
0.11855518817901611,
-0.3097795248031616,
-0.08669554442167282,
-0.05209631845355034,
-0.11211803555488586,
-0.604452908039093,
0.046584174036979675,
0.03017624281346798,
-0.15413668751716614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00697v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00697v2
|
Comprehensive Evaluation of Large Language Models for Topic Modeling
| 2024-06-02T10:25:02
| 2024-06-25T08:42:53
|
Tomoki Doi, Masaru Isonuma, Hitomi Yanaka
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work utilizes Large Language Models (LLMs) for topic modeling,
generating comprehensible topic labels for given documents. However, their
performance has mainly been evaluated qualitatively, and there remains room for
quantitative investigation of their capabilities. In this paper, we
quantitatively evaluate LLMs from multiple perspectives: the quality of topics,
the impact of LLM-specific concerns, such as hallucination and shortcuts for
limited documents, and LLMs' controllability of topic categories via prompts.
Our findings show that LLMs can identify coherent and diverse topics with few
hallucinations but may take shortcuts by focusing only on parts of documents.
We also found that their controllability is limited.
|
[
-0.46741074323654175,
-0.9801296591758728,
0.9476116299629211,
0.3479112982749939,
-0.249289408326149,
0.08782011270523071,
-0.4895966947078705,
-0.30761241912841797,
0.30410757660865784,
0.6807172894477844,
-0.2695755362510681,
-0.6599138975143433,
-0.8196300864219666,
0.08254167437553406,
-0.7223798036575317,
0.7678604125976562,
-0.02329016663134098,
0.09428782761096954,
-0.3068699836730957,
0.026656044647097588,
-0.47245222330093384,
-0.6240596771240234,
-0.5202513337135315,
-0.36576685309410095,
0.6959013342857361,
0.24715295433998108,
0.6954190731048584,
0.42507514357566833,
0.6576701998710632,
0.3305814862251282,
-0.5771684050559998,
-0.21773259341716766,
-0.6046634912490845,
0.2652882933616638,
-0.37963852286338806,
-0.3023054003715515,
-0.3227972090244293,
0.016270335763692856,
1.036551594734192,
0.9561499953269958,
-0.10274939984083176,
-0.0879846066236496,
0.22529223561286926,
0.27687641978263855,
-0.3678128719329834,
-0.23336108028888702,
-0.6116474270820618,
-0.055424049496650696,
-0.12485772371292114,
-0.19152291119098663,
-0.45216819643974304,
-0.32993221282958984,
0.4722963571548462,
-0.19619286060333252,
0.060522351413965225,
-0.02908586524426937,
0.6968705654144287,
0.12960538268089294,
-0.568396270275116,
-0.6123697757720947,
-0.7090562582015991,
0.9553908109664917,
-0.6532994508743286,
0.42094841599464417,
0.3892518877983093,
0.22778017818927765,
-0.08216812461614609,
-0.6449859142303467,
-0.20550864934921265,
-0.4939061403274536,
-0.0016780791338533163,
-0.15801239013671875,
-0.17475585639476776,
0.007721244357526302,
0.37415409088134766,
0.3983652591705322,
-0.6671115159988403,
0.40577417612075806,
-0.19537240266799927,
-0.3193342983722687,
0.5078637599945068,
0.5486375689506531,
0.25720223784446716,
-0.20493358373641968,
-0.07835961878299713,
0.25765690207481384,
-0.5381832122802734,
-0.21936310827732086,
0.26915428042411804,
0.16546818614006042,
-0.03996216878294945,
0.7906313538551331,
-0.2255648672580719,
0.8414289951324463,
-0.20422865450382233,
-0.5302024483680725,
-0.08128278702497482,
-0.30383574962615967,
-0.1763463020324707,
-0.2990929186344147,
0.6891325116157532,
0.18626189231872559,
-0.10138498246669769,
-0.45072296261787415,
-0.19766606390476227,
-0.23226991295814514,
0.33777013421058655,
-0.8794354796409607,
0.08975628763437271,
0.5137099027633667,
-0.6747376918792725,
-0.05845806375145912,
-0.1604412943124771,
-0.6652330756187439,
-0.6213289499282837,
-0.4566374719142914,
0.32878342270851135,
-0.32516321539878845,
-0.1474183350801468,
0.16863684356212616,
-0.08558793365955353,
0.2304139882326126,
0.6463903784751892,
-0.6086027026176453,
0.25634583830833435,
1.0414924621582031,
1.0920394659042358,
-0.6805598139762878,
-0.3563407361507416,
-0.36079296469688416,
-0.02877674251794815,
-0.34088537096977234,
0.8128876686096191,
-0.7356734275817871,
-0.538176953792572,
0.022193631157279015,
0.040989723056554794,
0.15781748294830322,
-0.6196184158325195,
0.43305206298828125,
-0.5709603428840637,
0.0543350875377655,
-0.3968455493450165,
-0.7272406220436096,
-0.018513580784201622,
0.39433518052101135,
-0.7265214323997498,
0.49503815174102783,
-0.046493589878082275,
-0.7696658968925476,
0.2388635277748108,
-0.18850450217723846,
-0.35735464096069336,
-0.09645774960517883,
-0.22402195632457733,
-0.023858677595853806,
0.206583634018898,
-0.32206833362579346,
0.5270505547523499,
-0.5644291639328003,
0.7481054663658142,
-0.2253025323152542,
-0.36700204014778137,
0.609117865562439,
-0.5061036348342896,
0.5088477730751038,
0.2109854519367218,
-0.11653593182563782,
0.5283089876174927,
-0.7143938541412354,
-0.26857614517211914,
-0.14832817018032074,
-0.29787999391555786,
-0.3759174942970276,
0.011554530821740627,
0.04549172520637512,
0.1544482558965683,
0.3390415906906128,
-0.04723481088876724,
0.30154117941856384,
-0.2564820647239685,
0.3364427089691162,
0.5979428887367249,
0.16376051306724548,
0.398669570684433,
-0.2772855758666992,
0.6719145774841309,
-0.14055322110652924,
-0.030654635280370712,
-0.1504962146282196,
-0.4170137345790863,
-0.798784077167511,
-0.44595780968666077,
0.32473430037498474,
0.28210514783859253,
-0.6159051656723022,
0.5025457143783569,
0.07302190363407135,
-0.6295866370201111,
0.012355023063719273,
-0.009385395795106888,
0.30936992168426514,
0.1281459629535675,
-0.0581989586353302,
-0.31632137298583984,
-0.09444614499807358,
-0.9420425891876221,
-0.019234349951148033,
-0.040621086955070496,
-0.08273427933454514,
0.289026141166687,
0.6649748682975769,
-0.17500966787338257,
0.6116442680358887,
-0.4542565643787384,
0.1131395474076271,
-0.2908953130245209,
0.32962068915367126,
0.16305722296237946,
0.20368875563144684,
0.3045726418495178,
-0.5037700533866882,
-0.32626286149024963,
-0.31176507472991943,
-0.6157145500183105,
-0.17060354351997375,
-0.2451801598072052,
-0.11923906207084656,
0.03325502574443817,
0.42755913734436035,
-0.7307242155075073,
0.12378428131341934,
0.3423231244087219,
-0.430860698223114,
0.6114506721496582,
-0.14226797223091125,
-0.000466035126009956,
-0.9569001197814941,
0.056863658130168915,
0.17066466808319092,
-0.05299978703260422,
-0.6532688140869141,
0.08563758432865143,
-0.020421236753463745,
-0.2804766595363617,
-0.4912753999233246,
0.7617461085319519,
-0.43938323855400085,
-0.28318777680397034,
-0.5152596831321716,
0.363827109336853,
-0.030479902401566505,
0.08134192228317261,
0.2735278904438019,
0.5533856153488159,
0.6540091633796692,
-0.5767795443534851,
0.28988873958587646,
0.015641311183571815,
-0.5178719758987427,
0.30988070368766785,
-0.711456298828125,
0.1693991720676422,
-0.11976761370897293,
0.10585323721170425,
-0.9579707384109497,
-0.23474650084972382,
0.07126870006322861,
-0.06960900127887726,
0.4629988968372345,
0.12853814661502838,
-0.5349076986312866,
-0.11641760915517807,
-0.3856443464756012,
0.173908993601799,
0.2203071266412735,
-0.152865931391716,
0.42988789081573486,
0.41266754269599915,
-0.439939945936203,
-0.30088698863983154,
-0.2649374008178711,
0.27045348286628723,
-0.43117594718933105,
-0.3459024429321289,
0.20131565630435944,
-0.14281493425369263,
-0.6340895295143127,
-0.06307991594076157,
0.016045358031988144,
-0.07562839984893799,
0.3185570538043976,
0.34170687198638916,
0.03132917732000351,
-0.009666516445577145,
0.3223995268344879,
0.026314005255699158,
-0.07102084904909134,
0.06828831136226654,
-0.02876765839755535,
0.8353148698806763,
-0.009343845769762993,
-0.41323766112327576,
-0.29079774022102356,
0.42036718130111694,
0.5587872862815857,
-0.26790785789489746,
0.7364431023597717,
0.24658308923244476,
-0.4492218494415283,
-0.1640446037054062,
-0.6764249205589294,
-0.16085736453533173,
-0.39241185784339905,
0.6344488859176636,
-0.41074931621551514,
-1.2524645328521729,
0.6135265827178955,
-0.09654432535171509,
-0.13948217034339905,
0.4840269982814789,
0.8569753170013428,
0.18886138498783112,
0.658776581287384,
0.6541274785995483,
-0.18131454288959503,
0.19116096198558807,
-0.22537294030189514,
0.1425117403268814,
-0.6651319861412048,
-0.41487136483192444,
-0.9361850619316101,
-0.0363914892077446,
-0.6196315884590149,
-0.5406331419944763,
0.029466016218066216,
0.2955997586250305,
-0.032680876553058624,
-0.046279486268758774,
-0.37022164463996887,
0.3707756996154785,
0.2662583291530609,
-0.09986768662929535,
0.3480648696422577,
-0.06691493093967438,
0.14036652445793152,
-0.15108241140842438,
-0.4385172724723816,
-1.0864410400390625,
0.9065216779708862,
0.7100814580917358,
1.017675757408142,
-0.017354995012283325,
0.507578432559967,
0.15484896302223206,
0.41910871863365173,
-1.0018165111541748,
0.6755430102348328,
-0.19779881834983826,
-0.6398464441299438,
-0.6343891024589539,
-0.4153478145599365,
-0.7662098407745361,
0.4296414256095886,
-0.06391752511262894,
-1.0700687170028687,
0.12629079818725586,
-0.2645229995250702,
-0.2861171364784241,
0.17051032185554504,
-0.239223912358284,
0.7214372754096985,
-0.42509710788726807,
-0.3527555465698242,
-0.3565809726715088,
-0.23505114018917084,
0.49476608633995056,
-0.5546985864639282,
0.0167958065867424,
-0.2350820004940033,
-0.24907396733760834,
0.9011297821998596,
-0.08479557186365128,
0.871526300907135,
0.13996624946594238,
-0.49487778544425964,
0.2787560820579529,
0.08751832693815231,
0.1618727594614029,
0.1842656135559082,
-0.22029422223567963,
0.2669563889503479,
0.013201781548559666,
-0.14463651180267334,
-0.5111008882522583,
0.8514671921730042,
-0.6794878244400024,
-0.8906263709068298,
-0.3729965090751648,
-0.6133304238319397,
-0.38029760122299194,
0.24661211669445038,
0.06219777092337608,
0.3846462666988373,
-0.44939517974853516,
0.33673396706581116,
0.7404198050498962,
-0.7631770968437195,
0.2884548008441925,
0.5955972671508789,
-0.6044422388076782,
-0.3572770059108734,
0.9181964993476868,
0.22168315947055817,
0.1406891793012619,
0.40142953395843506,
0.171665757894516,
-0.3505288064479828,
-0.8100221157073975,
-0.04051822051405907,
0.44209322333335876,
-0.7894293665885925,
0.10048696398735046,
-0.8279090523719788,
-0.2359340488910675,
-0.20385248959064484,
-0.008003877475857735,
-0.2467331439256668,
-0.35891830921173096,
-0.5196037888526917,
-0.01099136471748352,
-0.059773337095975876,
0.8239333033561707,
0.210001602768898,
0.3932608962059021,
-0.7116783261299133,
0.48873448371887207,
0.21143567562103271,
0.3746074140071869,
0.14761431515216827,
-0.7025473713874817,
-0.18668243288993835,
-0.28676605224609375,
-0.3811781108379364,
-1.0178890228271484,
0.3037523031234741,
-0.15502402186393738,
0.7151517271995544,
0.5645231604576111,
-0.13756482303142548,
0.28352388739585876,
-0.3604607880115509,
0.8402552604675293,
0.10670866072177887,
-1.0782407522201538,
0.4504241943359375,
-0.24646559357643127,
0.2551436722278595,
0.37447604537010193,
0.7747399806976318,
-0.4110720157623291,
-0.5276638865470886,
-0.253304660320282,
-0.6951248049736023,
0.549198567867279,
0.07820682972669601,
0.26730990409851074,
-0.00254634371958673,
0.34313249588012695,
0.3432578146457672,
0.35226160287857056,
-0.4835965037345886,
-0.13307765126228333,
0.14123165607452393,
0.14124856889247894,
-0.211431086063385,
-0.8810824751853943,
-0.15444569289684296,
-0.08858295530080795,
0.34312164783477783,
0.15957851707935333,
0.11019036918878555,
-0.14148499071598053,
-0.03110218606889248,
0.013884690590202808,
0.4885246157646179,
0.8764053583145142,
1.0988487005233765,
-0.31720268726348877,
0.2636462152004242,
0.10390312969684601,
-0.22854986786842346,
0.3457214832305908,
-0.046983491629362106,
-0.21731364727020264,
0.24350734055042267,
0.6379175186157227,
0.9018934965133667,
-0.022272339090704918,
-0.6819069981575012,
0.1601375937461853,
-0.0391508974134922,
-0.21089428663253784,
0.0467805452644825,
-0.05101832374930382,
0.3124926686286926,
0.3842317759990692,
0.2261848896741867,
-0.5657872557640076,
0.13974738121032715,
-0.7658132314682007,
0.03700510039925575,
0.520618200302124,
-0.2809542119503021,
-0.1692817360162735,
0.40928447246551514,
0.03998790681362152,
-0.2342386096715927,
0.4746696352958679,
-0.0196785107254982,
-0.5129225254058838,
0.7458435893058777,
0.4875636100769043,
0.9837265014648438,
-0.11029815673828125,
0.29867884516716003,
0.21676623821258545,
0.40212735533714294,
-0.1614690124988556,
0.2257358729839325,
0.05986752733588219,
-0.5993435978889465,
-0.5984514355659485,
-0.7719244360923767,
-0.7357439398765564,
0.41078129410743713,
-0.6789495944976807,
0.17187096178531647,
-0.27247777581214905,
-0.3761388659477234,
0.15405814349651337,
0.07587417215108871,
-0.3189448416233063,
0.3297971785068512,
-0.01895219087600708,
0.9591109752655029,
-0.6738733053207397,
0.958581268787384,
0.5983073711395264,
-0.11989207565784454,
-0.45500174164772034,
0.28682899475097656,
-0.21415166556835175,
-0.27406561374664307,
0.8503358960151672,
-0.023306595161557198,
0.08264889568090439,
-0.3464871048927307,
-0.4406331181526184,
-0.8904076814651489,
0.8334707617759705,
0.21664802730083466,
-0.8035810589790344,
-0.04762442409992218,
0.33590030670166016,
0.6932600736618042,
-0.16811718046665192,
0.23166115581989288,
0.43592584133148193,
0.49525296688079834,
0.1621921956539154,
-0.9259652495384216,
0.039548445492982864,
0.10451698303222656,
0.15220195055007935,
0.026519328355789185,
-0.7030802369117737,
0.7441461086273193,
0.07830255478620529,
-0.043733149766922,
0.0937279686331749,
0.6103236079216003,
0.41216495633125305,
0.40148472785949707,
0.22718383371829987,
0.3271539807319641,
0.8628968596458435,
-0.08891674131155014,
1.0551096200942993,
-0.37731462717056274,
0.34655556082725525,
1.0985947847366333,
-0.627151370048523,
0.6613537669181824,
0.4577968418598175,
-0.11264190077781677,
-0.19598573446273804,
0.760410726070404,
0.059455931186676025,
0.6040615439414978,
0.5971317887306213,
-0.013309041038155556,
-0.26363885402679443,
-0.31304723024368286,
-0.4719785451889038,
0.29507818818092346,
0.5020638108253479,
-0.3783837854862213,
-0.07607217878103256,
0.1844474971294403,
-0.05014397203922272,
-0.1821296215057373,
-0.20094135403633118,
0.7181347012519836,
0.3113127052783966,
-0.5000395178794861,
0.3857896327972412,
0.3521135449409485,
0.5368655323982239,
-0.534320056438446,
0.04234129190444946,
-0.4755869507789612,
-0.28069373965263367,
-0.002421519486233592,
-0.8247302770614624,
0.4199695885181427,
0.24306173622608185,
-0.08478248864412308,
-0.2111300230026245,
0.9543024301528931,
-0.2284371554851532,
-0.5313520431518555,
0.26910707354545593,
0.5057761073112488,
0.3557835519313812,
-0.16376276314258575,
-0.4024712145328522,
0.6155707240104675,
-0.12118479609489441,
-0.531944990158081,
0.4709075391292572,
0.6584084630012512,
-0.2243916243314743,
0.7544745802879333,
0.1810663491487503,
0.3058108389377594,
-0.13948564231395721,
0.22184625267982483,
0.8207862973213196,
-0.9414165616035461,
-0.1401861608028412,
-0.8707590103149414,
0.22867709398269653,
0.07485237717628479,
-0.31019002199172974,
0.9439414143562317,
0.6334295868873596,
0.6886523365974426,
-0.03334818035364151,
0.6295552849769592,
0.2827736437320709,
0.4424075484275818,
-0.7079649567604065,
0.8047627210617065,
-0.6373652219772339,
0.5187236666679382,
-0.3328106105327606,
-1.2142181396484375,
-0.302115797996521,
0.537977933883667,
-0.5385801792144775,
0.07283318787813187,
0.7571141123771667,
0.670987606048584,
0.16460737586021423,
-0.13655580580234528,
0.7353173494338989,
0.24121171236038208,
0.24259644746780396,
0.28766152262687683,
1.4040666818618774,
0.2626923620700836,
0.11611339449882507,
-0.35955265164375305,
-0.05578257888555527,
-0.25447872281074524,
-0.787754237651825,
-1.1033531427383423,
-0.501561164855957,
-0.46569809317588806,
-0.23995040357112885,
-0.031228037551045418,
0.5112997889518738,
0.482653945684433,
-0.7022172212600708,
-0.4288005232810974,
0.3198828101158142,
0.429283082485199,
0.3907659649848938,
-0.1947944015264511,
0.5363630056381226,
-0.10063710808753967,
-0.6620804071426392,
0.21761657297611237,
0.49336159229278564,
0.04136015474796295,
-0.7525160312652588,
-0.09605233371257782,
0.13130292296409607,
0.13528406620025635,
0.7951239347457886,
-0.1385219842195511,
-1.0456291437149048,
-0.022495875135064125,
0.04422440752387047,
-0.46575966477394104,
-0.18849661946296692,
1.0819754600524902,
-0.1343100666999817,
0.2112455666065216,
0.7071157097816467,
0.5555109977722168,
0.43694111704826355,
-0.01920187845826149,
0.26145973801612854,
-0.19241191446781158,
0.17411349713802338,
0.22664377093315125,
0.3914690613746643,
0.15753485262393951,
-0.14120373129844666,
0.35270607471466064,
-0.10004911571741104,
-0.531026303768158,
-0.8684338927268982,
0.05439000949263573,
-1.0303386449813843,
-0.6715014576911926,
1.4026058912277222,
-0.11696425825357437,
-0.012625196017324924,
-0.04846395179629326,
-0.3603750467300415,
0.0870312973856926,
-0.13931958377361298,
0.7057197690010071,
1.0069286823272705,
-0.048847414553165436,
-0.2179919183254242,
-0.7286818027496338,
0.14908593893051147,
0.3163473308086395,
-0.9264512658119202,
-0.10988052934408188,
0.7739555239677429,
0.1713707000017166,
0.16290952265262604,
0.6612154245376587,
-0.04923224821686745,
-0.2480562925338745,
-0.19306521117687225,
-0.037012360990047455,
0.33712872862815857,
-0.6725760102272034,
-0.6762319207191467,
0.33482566475868225,
0.5873605012893677,
0.3279692828655243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00684v1
|
Deciphering Oracle Bone Language with Diffusion Models
| 2024-06-02T09:42:23
| 2024-06-02T09:42:23
|
Haisu Guan, Huanxin Yang, Xinyu Wang, Shengwei Han, Yongge Liu, Lianwen Jin, Xiang Bai, Yuliang Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Originating from China's Shang Dynasty approximately 3,000 years ago, the
Oracle Bone Script (OBS) is a cornerstone in the annals of linguistic history,
predating many established writing systems. Despite the discovery of thousands
of inscriptions, a vast expanse of OBS remains undeciphered, casting a veil of
mystery over this ancient language. The emergence of modern AI technologies
presents a novel frontier for OBS decipherment, challenging traditional NLP
methods that rely heavily on large textual corpora, a luxury not afforded by
historical languages. This paper introduces a novel approach by adopting image
generation techniques, specifically through the development of Oracle Bone
Script Decipher (OBSD). Utilizing a conditional diffusion-based strategy, OBSD
generates vital clues for decipherment, charting a new course for AI-assisted
analysis of ancient languages. To validate its efficacy, extensive experiments
were conducted on an oracle bone script dataset, with quantitative results
demonstrating the effectiveness of OBSD. Code and decipherment results will be
made available at https://github.com/guanhaisu/OBSD.
|
[
-0.12976641952991486,
-1.0111942291259766,
0.6838414072990417,
0.21784117817878723,
-0.4811495542526245,
-0.0642765685915947,
-0.1488010287284851,
-0.6153728365898132,
0.32783111929893494,
0.784777820110321,
-0.41609880328178406,
-0.8363417983055115,
-0.46830353140830994,
0.09233620762825012,
-0.3903229832649231,
0.3582150340080261,
0.19822178781032562,
-0.15504169464111328,
0.1574653536081314,
-0.13167984783649445,
-0.21583884954452515,
0.19820217788219452,
-0.7393250465393066,
-0.4090178608894348,
-0.48651739954948425,
0.02682347595691681,
0.7983407974243164,
1.5834389925003052,
0.29047268629074097,
0.31025952100753784,
-0.17558428645133972,
0.17059066891670227,
0.0196414515376091,
0.03401365876197815,
0.16446848213672638,
-0.6359394192695618,
-0.3404301702976227,
-0.2502727210521698,
0.5826796889305115,
1.0637861490249634,
-0.33468735218048096,
-0.07079552859067917,
-0.3429138660430908,
0.819552481174469,
-0.4437609910964966,
0.31818026304244995,
-0.7059782147407532,
0.09033596515655518,
-0.6295899748802185,
-0.08328841626644135,
-0.7097956538200378,
-0.40778547525405884,
0.36801210045814514,
-0.6546319723129272,
0.10077951103448868,
-0.23147396743297577,
0.8677672743797302,
0.4433213174343109,
-0.06268242001533508,
-0.46293655037879944,
-0.7596467733383179,
0.7045271396636963,
-0.6225244402885437,
0.18786738812923431,
0.7355273365974426,
0.13646040856838226,
-0.050765544176101685,
-0.6426905989646912,
-0.3966536521911621,
-0.46997231245040894,
0.13651300966739655,
-0.19491000473499298,
-0.27845704555511475,
-0.13456158339977264,
-0.12031728029251099,
0.3588404357433319,
-0.6999858617782593,
0.06617436558008194,
-0.4680706262588501,
-0.4027820825576782,
0.5741241574287415,
0.01940912753343582,
0.4423849284648895,
-0.26227572560310364,
-0.39507657289505005,
0.0075512235052883625,
-0.8709149360656738,
-0.2472745031118393,
0.1597040891647339,
0.08863452076911926,
-0.08532348275184631,
0.658151388168335,
-0.0064179361797869205,
0.987678050994873,
0.13601122796535492,
-0.5232979655265808,
0.4370831549167633,
0.01504217553883791,
-0.17006149888038635,
0.06865508109331131,
0.5525867938995361,
0.24065344035625458,
0.1516410857439041,
-0.21272745728492737,
0.031135650351643562,
0.3497535288333893,
0.013499044813215733,
-0.5666351318359375,
-0.38945677876472473,
0.2045455127954483,
-0.9327213764190674,
-0.09984707087278366,
-0.33739298582077026,
-0.8314915299415588,
-0.7127212285995483,
0.027362016960978508,
0.10674642771482468,
-0.8399093747138977,
-0.7424982190132141,
0.3108941614627838,
-0.3061550259590149,
0.5681496858596802,
0.28865259885787964,
-0.7964782118797302,
0.20785890519618988,
0.5109036564826965,
0.7397576570510864,
-0.1552075296640396,
-0.0843866616487503,
-0.02720017172396183,
0.24520426988601685,
-0.6297764182090759,
1.0148804187774658,
-0.6233102083206177,
-0.3730209469795227,
0.08279231935739517,
-0.38872310519218445,
0.23328880965709686,
-1.0677725076675415,
0.15395808219909668,
-0.3211517333984375,
-0.35567256808280945,
0.22922155261039734,
-0.40021026134490967,
-0.20699743926525116,
-0.15188336372375488,
-0.7194486260414124,
0.9536941051483154,
-0.027437755838036537,
-0.39338356256484985,
0.46700090169906616,
-0.45772606134414673,
-0.530281662940979,
0.43133556842803955,
-0.6122859716415405,
-0.1312076896429062,
0.04596378281712532,
0.0673694759607315,
0.2945024371147156,
-0.3108738660812378,
-0.029568858444690704,
-0.09871479123830795,
-0.02718055248260498,
-0.238601416349411,
-0.31344661116600037,
0.7068572044372559,
0.43938779830932617,
-0.5642688870429993,
-0.46240150928497314,
-0.9417884945869446,
0.017857160419225693,
0.2717190384864807,
-0.09503054618835449,
-0.8038354516029358,
0.24230049550533295,
-0.42736291885375977,
-0.29320892691612244,
0.2189878523349762,
-0.711035430431366,
0.2553958594799042,
-0.6748330593109131,
0.17984738945960999,
0.61708664894104,
-0.13752500712871552,
0.6237912774085999,
0.10662703216075897,
0.3705367147922516,
-0.205643430352211,
-0.0944984182715416,
-0.5199989080429077,
-0.7480456233024597,
-0.4950271546840668,
-0.41721245646476746,
-0.07666073739528656,
0.5149754881858826,
-1.1437053680419922,
0.1916324496269226,
-0.05603503808379173,
-0.4537365734577179,
-0.9608190059661865,
0.11336665600538254,
0.46823182702064514,
0.415588915348053,
0.2648414671421051,
-0.24437151849269867,
-0.3127230107784271,
-0.9246411323547363,
0.14523880183696747,
-0.6494309306144714,
0.016213450580835342,
0.24297024309635162,
0.07293394207954407,
-0.1321721076965332,
1.0307179689407349,
-0.7715660333633423,
-0.2528131902217865,
-0.2831844389438629,
0.2753683924674988,
0.16093802452087402,
0.3335064649581909,
0.7051594853401184,
-0.7381391525268555,
-0.3690192699432373,
0.379406601190567,
-0.8061126470565796,
-0.40388432145118713,
-0.09800142794847488,
-0.017669854685664177,
0.3537902235984802,
0.935725748538971,
-0.2083350569009781,
0.8257524967193604,
0.5504987239837646,
-0.15872591733932495,
0.5126949548721313,
-0.3253980278968811,
-0.292129784822464,
-0.8895324468612671,
0.28598541021347046,
-0.1617613434791565,
0.1276056319475174,
-0.5420273542404175,
-0.0019928361289203167,
-0.0895620658993721,
0.07755407691001892,
-0.43929752707481384,
0.6294222474098206,
-0.8519315719604492,
-0.061751626431941986,
-0.5018659234046936,
0.11289563775062561,
-0.5537901520729065,
0.17593535780906677,
0.764809250831604,
0.3937748968601227,
0.8047581315040588,
-0.5732023119926453,
0.039771705865859985,
0.2711699604988098,
-0.2996675670146942,
0.37224140763282776,
-0.4785788953304291,
0.08831211924552917,
-0.14228738844394684,
-0.03905810788273811,
-0.8180237412452698,
0.10818251967430115,
0.1384541094303131,
-0.3079666197299957,
0.1821291446685791,
-0.4584153890609741,
-0.12638601660728455,
-0.15930718183517456,
-0.20543617010116577,
0.3081134259700775,
0.6764903664588928,
-0.3865811228752136,
0.9181151390075684,
0.6997314691543579,
-0.1100178137421608,
-0.7698006629943848,
-0.675845742225647,
0.05203641578555107,
-0.017690103501081467,
-0.9938053488731384,
0.35669875144958496,
0.007239355705678463,
-0.48853662610054016,
0.12289297580718994,
-0.11232838779687881,
-0.3693588078022003,
-0.08740811794996262,
0.34765246510505676,
0.2624782919883728,
-0.6720460653305054,
-0.2733977138996124,
0.131675124168396,
-0.37219691276550293,
-0.0024827460292726755,
-0.4038785398006439,
0.8059702515602112,
0.014426019974052906,
-0.2902348041534424,
-0.5366567969322205,
0.12940914928913116,
0.4770630896091461,
-0.14315003156661987,
0.5297970771789551,
0.412090539932251,
-0.30597856640815735,
-0.4835738241672516,
-0.6161902546882629,
0.17325280606746674,
-0.48843905329704285,
0.2608194649219513,
-0.2108454555273056,
-0.1287902146577835,
0.48030319809913635,
-0.7245426774024963,
-0.09793625771999359,
0.4733382761478424,
0.5380173325538635,
0.33895477652549744,
0.6593745350837708,
0.7987722754478455,
-0.04857620969414711,
0.4077986180782318,
-0.6164458394050598,
-0.3043418228626251,
-0.6678177714347839,
-0.36678043007850647,
-0.3397592008113861,
0.07787708193063736,
-0.2776065766811371,
-0.3717905282974243,
0.1367490440607071,
-0.0011479370296001434,
0.38084471225738525,
0.33121898770332336,
-0.28482234477996826,
0.6358698010444641,
0.29380154609680176,
0.11535538733005524,
0.2560058534145355,
-0.08628630638122559,
-0.27451997995376587,
0.1732666939496994,
-0.1147884652018547,
-0.5220652222633362,
0.9978895783424377,
0.16370300948619843,
1.0395303964614868,
-0.03332308307290077,
0.7451601624488831,
0.40968096256256104,
0.11244437843561172,
-0.42729562520980835,
0.8527988791465759,
-0.5405696630477905,
-0.2985747158527374,
-0.18170234560966492,
-0.08305239677429199,
-1.1529817581176758,
0.2365877330303192,
-0.06786583364009857,
-0.7209032773971558,
0.36994868516921997,
0.2189767062664032,
-0.33784976601600647,
0.2227230668067932,
-0.8810611367225647,
0.7135216593742371,
-0.06005966290831566,
-0.08366477489471436,
0.04408271983265877,
-0.972743570804596,
0.2752681076526642,
0.09697825461626053,
0.22611257433891296,
0.019744249060750008,
-0.012576545588672161,
0.5148154497146606,
-0.5353655815124512,
1.006873607635498,
-0.28109851479530334,
-0.25118133425712585,
0.5310665965080261,
0.36432331800460815,
0.17746010422706604,
-0.09267647564411163,
-0.41751202940940857,
0.11072678864002228,
-0.27206915616989136,
-0.32086750864982605,
-0.03672976791858673,
0.5336068272590637,
-0.4991070330142975,
-0.22008384764194489,
-0.20718297362327576,
-0.26030218601226807,
0.3699641525745392,
0.4084601402282715,
0.2544631063938141,
0.30593612790107727,
-0.4217805564403534,
-0.14551593363285065,
0.6637166738510132,
-0.4028323292732239,
0.5355705618858337,
0.6832398176193237,
-0.29081422090530396,
-0.22715160250663757,
0.9252399802207947,
-0.1789250522851944,
0.3900506794452667,
0.32572904229164124,
0.2268921285867691,
-0.15393966436386108,
-1.0330849885940552,
-0.8185815811157227,
0.48775094747543335,
-0.5949366688728333,
-0.04205271229147911,
-0.2817254662513733,
0.00975834671407938,
-0.34712207317352295,
-0.17771084606647491,
-0.4917253851890564,
-0.15197165310382843,
-0.19038893282413483,
-0.09252139180898666,
0.16104257106781006,
0.9455358386039734,
-0.21817147731781006,
0.3153687119483948,
-0.6095055341720581,
0.5171686410903931,
-0.043329719454050064,
0.08082754909992218,
-0.08407162129878998,
-0.06518766283988953,
-0.04189819097518921,
-0.018128247931599617,
0.07720876485109329,
-1.0342084169387817,
0.7108844518661499,
0.30457043647766113,
0.6479711532592773,
0.759766697883606,
-0.082845039665699,
0.7171772718429565,
-0.6454681754112244,
0.8199979662895203,
-0.20377671718597412,
-0.8648297786712646,
0.7136228084564209,
-0.16936762630939484,
0.10751836001873016,
0.3728390634059906,
-0.03849046677350998,
-0.16341789066791534,
-0.5830928087234497,
-0.5485069155693054,
-1.1026324033737183,
0.7933853268623352,
0.05025370419025421,
-0.1020924374461174,
-0.26095646619796753,
0.696127712726593,
0.5435281991958618,
-0.030318165197968483,
-0.5778899192810059,
-0.5998289585113525,
0.02531583420932293,
-0.17799817025661469,
0.46925559639930725,
0.17342379689216614,
0.30073824524879456,
0.20534135401248932,
0.2478417158126831,
-0.04077942669391632,
0.1937587559223175,
0.04491099342703819,
-0.37739303708076477,
-0.04833490028977394,
-0.18948014080524445,
0.44329261779785156,
0.5355030298233032,
-0.2671317756175995,
0.21022352576255798,
-0.2065858393907547,
-1.141358494758606,
-0.2312457263469696,
0.04782553017139435,
-0.5357111692428589,
0.1580927073955536,
0.45823606848716736,
0.6547453999519348,
-0.6173495650291443,
-0.7786785364151001,
0.4186541736125946,
0.1341691017150879,
-0.05570988729596138,
-0.7072773575782776,
-0.08942557126283646,
-0.06670103222131729,
0.20637135207653046,
0.8285927772521973,
0.21735790371894836,
0.03902285173535347,
-0.6089432835578918,
0.2218899130821228,
0.5148811340332031,
-0.11115062236785889,
-0.4945363700389862,
0.5786768794059753,
0.11891599744558334,
-0.21895137429237366,
0.694362223148346,
-0.23404903709888458,
-0.1995212882757187,
0.7722814083099365,
0.6710449457168579,
0.8651793599128723,
-0.6035506129264832,
0.6335889101028442,
0.07367861270904541,
0.5630044937133789,
-0.23326221108436584,
0.350279301404953,
0.06758932024240494,
-0.6002032160758972,
-0.4716489911079407,
-0.7121047377586365,
-0.05620849132537842,
0.06373587250709534,
-0.5818930268287659,
0.2162768691778183,
-0.3226209282875061,
0.12767143547534943,
0.3507545590400696,
-0.4137657880783081,
-0.4344121515750885,
0.2669511139392853,
0.4759554862976074,
0.8735327124595642,
-1.0861155986785889,
1.0760564804077148,
0.5426715016365051,
-0.47181928157806396,
-0.4933680593967438,
0.15007071197032928,
0.16360899806022644,
-1.4317421913146973,
0.9370341897010803,
-0.08851652592420578,
-0.2903958857059479,
-0.04690990597009659,
-0.49670401215553284,
-0.642473042011261,
1.1061780452728271,
0.5308942198753357,
0.23295192420482635,
-0.04480025917291641,
0.06316526234149933,
0.7672187089920044,
-0.4094177186489105,
0.15784063935279846,
0.7177326679229736,
0.3878863453865051,
0.20562054216861725,
-0.8494057059288025,
0.05008270964026451,
-0.3316124379634857,
0.009292373433709145,
0.38068723678588867,
-0.04280611127614975,
0.8393842577934265,
-0.43140923976898193,
-0.5399564504623413,
0.5579960346221924,
0.6415939927101135,
-0.07266535609960556,
0.4473138153553009,
0.55430006980896,
0.6084871888160706,
0.3889460265636444,
-0.02313229627907276,
1.0483759641647339,
-0.05309532582759857,
-0.20141248404979706,
0.5300533175468445,
-0.4763249158859253,
0.9887917637825012,
0.30509883165359497,
-0.07707113772630692,
0.7999382615089417,
0.2375061959028244,
0.09935320168733597,
0.7553394436836243,
0.2339121550321579,
-0.14185631275177002,
-0.10260195285081863,
-0.12799060344696045,
-0.45505428314208984,
0.5490999817848206,
0.7328789830207825,
-0.39752259850502014,
-0.26294830441474915,
0.10574067384004593,
0.1358504295349121,
0.04939776659011841,
-0.3038589358329773,
0.9290673732757568,
-0.18176260590553284,
-0.552647054195404,
0.737293004989624,
-0.15440723299980164,
0.5963358879089355,
-1.013468861579895,
-0.5271705985069275,
-0.2916662395000458,
0.42318952083587646,
-0.11559802293777466,
-0.8367022275924683,
0.5339668393135071,
-0.2028055638074875,
0.056166231632232666,
-0.07464168220758438,
0.5737912654876709,
-0.5238880515098572,
-0.1300903558731079,
0.38248464465141296,
0.47802093625068665,
0.41594409942626953,
0.1708770990371704,
-0.5211727619171143,
0.23452788591384888,
0.2705366015434265,
0.06342235207557678,
0.07536793500185013,
0.5375596880912781,
-0.15451738238334656,
0.7251484394073486,
0.6116071939468384,
0.4119029939174652,
0.15457220375537872,
-0.3978060483932495,
0.6885807514190674,
-0.5226219892501831,
-0.42830851674079895,
-0.9000548124313354,
0.19642993807792664,
-0.0004234403604641557,
-0.24817082285881042,
0.7339633107185364,
0.6127772927284241,
0.7126367092132568,
-0.20709668099880219,
0.6916065216064453,
-0.38932928442955017,
0.4966452419757843,
-0.7295480966567993,
0.6634638905525208,
-0.4085639417171478,
0.494263231754303,
-0.5814694166183472,
-0.3943074941635132,
-0.32874971628189087,
0.7367372512817383,
-0.1443278044462204,
-0.20470111072063446,
0.8825833201408386,
0.6951028108596802,
0.2432730346918106,
-0.1315155178308487,
0.07123370468616486,
0.4261088967323303,
-0.04882305487990379,
0.15777255594730377,
0.6712374091148376,
-0.03272140398621559,
0.8919926881790161,
-0.22165414690971375,
-0.5817601680755615,
-0.032189857214689255,
-0.8079386353492737,
-0.5833032131195068,
-0.7294259071350098,
-0.34764420986175537,
-0.3233970105648041,
0.19825921952724457,
0.5888952612876892,
0.505646824836731,
-0.5273982286453247,
-0.42953869700431824,
-0.0512709841132164,
-0.12352044880390167,
-0.573941707611084,
-0.1530034989118576,
0.984018862247467,
0.21991799771785736,
-0.7204165458679199,
0.7004610300064087,
0.6245102882385254,
0.10055980086326599,
-0.13616055250167847,
-0.019472844898700714,
-0.1967039555311203,
-0.07100345939397812,
0.40890878438949585,
0.7835956811904907,
-0.9014433026313782,
0.07723210006952286,
0.28793027997016907,
0.061811164021492004,
0.029063843190670013,
0.79949551820755,
-0.9797218441963196,
0.6150333285331726,
0.5095380544662476,
0.5288076400756836,
0.39627352356910706,
0.01372777670621872,
0.5988547205924988,
-0.6778826117515564,
0.5017091035842896,
0.21258819103240967,
0.2911003828048706,
0.18609359860420227,
-0.10182827711105347,
0.6478474140167236,
0.344849556684494,
-0.18804210424423218,
-0.6344178915023804,
0.2898334264755249,
-1.1600418090820312,
-0.638228178024292,
1.1252365112304688,
-0.08481011539697647,
-0.5640250444412231,
-0.5423823595046997,
-0.4958072602748871,
-0.10457579046487808,
-0.3013232946395874,
0.7165545225143433,
0.12924157083034515,
-0.22531068325042725,
0.030279966071248055,
-0.2819421589374542,
0.5834144353866577,
0.18114781379699707,
-0.7231009602546692,
0.23126579821109772,
0.6004066467285156,
0.10223223268985748,
0.6405754089355469,
1.036656379699707,
-0.2558649480342865,
0.34265342354774475,
0.2594682276248932,
0.25246375799179077,
0.10160717368125916,
-0.09796329587697983,
-0.09070664644241333,
0.05085199326276779,
-0.008801538497209549,
-0.37384068965911865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00682v1
|
A lexicon obtained and validated by a data-driven approach for organic residues valorization in emerging and developing countries
| 2024-06-02T09:36:33
| 2024-06-02T09:36:33
|
Christiane Rakotomalala, Jean-Marie Paillat, Frédéric Feder, Angel Avadí, Laurent Thuriès, Marie-Liesse Vermeire, Jean-Michel Médoc, Tom Wassenaar, Caroline Hottelart, Lilou Kieffer, Elisa Ndjie, Mathieu Picart, Jorel Tchamgoue, Alvin Tulle, Laurine Valade, Annie Boyer, Marie-Christine Duchamp, Mathieu Roche
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The text mining method presented in this paper was used for annotation of
terms related to biological transformation and valorization of organic residues
in agriculture in low and middle-income country. Specialized lexicon was
obtained through different steps: corpus and extraction of terms, annotation of
extracted terms, selection of relevant terms.
|
[
-0.21534624695777893,
-1.1126118898391724,
0.6514002680778503,
-0.4119880199432373,
-0.35569897294044495,
0.19238145649433136,
-0.20545940101146698,
-0.24633440375328064,
0.6513696908950806,
0.9362519383430481,
-0.3605566918849945,
-0.9497637748718262,
-0.7117300033569336,
0.6120312809944153,
-0.4545919895172119,
1.1374348402023315,
-0.12939085066318512,
0.14188149571418762,
-0.21791556477546692,
-0.15575599670410156,
-0.08403195440769196,
-0.5584904551506042,
-0.5196118950843811,
0.052416130900382996,
0.32144588232040405,
0.33895576000213623,
0.5084624886512756,
0.6873764395713806,
0.4831171929836273,
0.26121756434440613,
-0.4076065421104431,
0.32816311717033386,
-0.25742390751838684,
-0.011220804415643215,
-0.4020838737487793,
-0.4027157127857208,
-0.4893043637275696,
0.030491884797811508,
0.2733745276927948,
0.7658986449241638,
0.01944676972925663,
0.39399486780166626,
0.14395588636398315,
0.44283878803253174,
-0.48647090792655945,
0.03519641235470772,
-0.7139440774917603,
-0.26727744936943054,
-0.14153479039669037,
-0.46092870831489563,
-0.2395545244216919,
-0.6438109874725342,
-0.269616961479187,
-0.4755944311618805,
0.17541801929473877,
-0.24400392174720764,
0.9089639782905579,
-0.05133906751871109,
-0.4810679256916046,
-0.38296252489089966,
-0.6895293593406677,
0.8861287832260132,
-0.35170963406562805,
-0.02009737864136696,
0.5671691298484802,
0.34430447220802307,
-0.11875462532043457,
-1.0308821201324463,
-0.29355672001838684,
0.02044740505516529,
-0.3016093671321869,
-0.2586207389831543,
0.49392151832580566,
0.304052472114563,
-0.00348819512873888,
0.7807996273040771,
0.1953396499156952,
-0.2802952527999878,
-0.7743297815322876,
-0.39682239294052124,
0.4066401422023773,
0.16519795358181,
0.5186942219734192,
-0.13260598480701447,
-0.666077196598053,
0.2253517359495163,
-0.892200767993927,
0.3409905731678009,
0.4355376660823822,
0.5249982476234436,
0.3998734652996063,
0.9329920411109924,
-0.3037289083003998,
0.659610390663147,
-0.18205538392066956,
-0.22556442022323608,
0.09189749509096146,
-1.0714150667190552,
-0.08052406460046768,
0.04502455145120621,
0.2596573233604431,
0.48505252599716187,
0.15579530596733093,
0.16515310108661652,
-0.6091817617416382,
0.3469299077987671,
0.18324866890907288,
-0.5709037184715271,
-0.08642333745956421,
0.1271590292453766,
-0.5751792192459106,
-0.5870574116706848,
0.13938045501708984,
-0.9566712379455566,
-0.00718874204903841,
-0.16418571770191193,
0.11463439464569092,
-0.11142870783805847,
-0.0508604496717453,
-0.26111647486686707,
-0.4498860538005829,
0.05948532745242119,
0.12162967026233673,
-1.3051453828811646,
0.7178361415863037,
0.6690863966941833,
1.041649341583252,
-0.3627849817276001,
0.2541925311088562,
0.06426069885492325,
0.11532840132713318,
-0.2052198052406311,
1.0301060676574707,
-0.725378155708313,
-0.25093379616737366,
0.05690102279186249,
0.4339931309223175,
0.02566116861999035,
-0.5631585717201233,
0.5635008811950684,
-0.31610703468322754,
-0.2611733376979828,
-0.21207886934280396,
-0.3848291337490082,
-0.7004196643829346,
0.7346436381340027,
-0.7130861878395081,
1.0334503650665283,
0.5232861042022705,
-0.54976886510849,
0.8522623181343079,
-0.47921547293663025,
-0.3333929181098938,
0.4743035137653351,
-0.050181660801172256,
0.19395186007022858,
0.0030517997220158577,
-0.01687098667025566,
0.42343372106552124,
-0.1480678915977478,
0.42003947496414185,
0.06134938821196556,
-0.13354822993278503,
0.13960851728916168,
-0.01205780915915966,
0.5476497411727905,
-0.008357314392924309,
0.11852144449949265,
0.22279994189739227,
-0.8338524699211121,
-0.13507428765296936,
-0.3346417546272278,
-0.6003237962722778,
-0.7674283385276794,
0.23927907645702362,
0.40960294008255005,
0.1580192744731903,
0.36652523279190063,
-0.7424885630607605,
0.4643273651599884,
-0.43577146530151367,
0.4875237047672272,
0.6278918385505676,
0.7310425639152527,
0.21900959312915802,
-0.34244975447654724,
0.18037159740924835,
-0.021891005337238312,
0.04155547171831131,
-0.1390172839164734,
-0.5019652843475342,
-0.6349313259124756,
-0.30814820528030396,
0.5542100071907043,
0.5684522390365601,
-0.8812430500984192,
0.5760414600372314,
-0.3472446799278259,
-0.33031442761421204,
-0.16080492734909058,
-0.04053241387009621,
-0.18968918919563293,
0.4074912667274475,
0.4754108786582947,
-0.1905532330274582,
-0.7128434181213379,
-0.8635846972465515,
-0.27238255739212036,
0.041006602346897125,
0.08332699537277222,
0.06849060952663422,
0.8749000430107117,
-0.6690384745597839,
0.9292600154876709,
-0.643312931060791,
-0.575775682926178,
-0.10110214352607727,
-0.005819596815854311,
0.4076193869113922,
0.5026451349258423,
0.38361912965774536,
-0.7802751660346985,
-0.5602706074714661,
0.4947223365306854,
-0.31779080629348755,
-0.11411327123641968,
0.09192002564668655,
-0.03492683172225952,
0.408864825963974,
0.41702067852020264,
0.0899534747004509,
0.6827911138534546,
0.3440043330192566,
-0.4375556409358978,
0.5996588468551636,
0.00792420469224453,
0.6293226480484009,
-0.855787456035614,
0.3069748282432556,
-0.006608030758798122,
-0.3384121060371399,
-0.5672005414962769,
-0.06877300888299942,
-0.3280084729194641,
0.12646383047103882,
-0.4457264542579651,
0.458420991897583,
-0.2709225118160248,
0.24811941385269165,
-0.30259761214256287,
-0.18817003071308136,
-0.14870136976242065,
0.4503551721572876,
0.18204401433467865,
0.7887023687362671,
0.44176873564720154,
-0.7736667394638062,
0.4569469690322876,
0.16783718764781952,
-0.0621756874024868,
0.43810978531837463,
-0.3474443554878235,
-0.4360145926475525,
0.15780135989189148,
-0.13511447608470917,
-0.7424172163009644,
-0.11487320065498352,
0.3630169630050659,
-0.31002241373062134,
0.0018154034623876214,
-0.21299605071544647,
-0.4169306755065918,
-0.028116023167967796,
-0.3325221836566925,
0.18602292239665985,
0.26712480187416077,
-0.017313484102487564,
0.577922523021698,
0.401930570602417,
-0.19277450442314148,
-0.13224554061889648,
-0.6049401164054871,
-0.000044396754674380645,
-0.45208045840263367,
-0.28238746523857117,
0.009391909465193748,
0.1327860802412033,
-0.4700402617454529,
0.21228165924549103,
-0.10499997437000275,
-0.12050078809261322,
0.19297659397125244,
0.09740246832370758,
-0.12021981179714203,
0.19722871482372284,
0.22481222450733185,
0.4609766900539398,
-0.15078184008598328,
0.17413805425167084,
-0.276237815618515,
0.45126283168792725,
0.31610000133514404,
0.3569072484970093,
-0.054858796298503876,
0.47904762625694275,
0.3387177288532257,
0.08901645243167877,
0.6974560022354126,
0.3919130861759186,
-0.6640316247940063,
-0.05327441543340683,
-0.11331511288881302,
-0.29326000809669495,
-0.3686051666736603,
0.06955298036336899,
-0.12122469395399094,
-0.41098707914352417,
0.6288926005363464,
-0.7857123613357544,
0.09502168744802475,
0.9454753994941711,
0.46392878890037537,
0.19748209416866302,
0.4768482446670532,
0.8615184426307678,
0.4316810369491577,
-0.08678561449050903,
-0.4469519555568695,
0.01816350221633911,
-0.9950897693634033,
-0.7256006598472595,
-0.5502562522888184,
-0.1897699236869812,
-0.6211444139480591,
-0.7265112400054932,
0.48437607288360596,
-0.23292483389377594,
0.08903435617685318,
0.42773106694221497,
-0.5127399563789368,
0.007091817446053028,
0.23459073901176453,
0.1787576675415039,
0.5127898454666138,
0.31419453024864197,
-0.35410749912261963,
-0.10302455723285675,
-0.2364843785762787,
-1.2118955850601196,
1.2145591974258423,
0.2402062863111496,
0.3574065566062927,
-0.20947374403476715,
0.7590165138244629,
0.5628662705421448,
0.6509179472923279,
-1.2139393091201782,
0.5962820053100586,
-0.1444418877363205,
-0.8190540075302124,
-0.4051770269870758,
-0.07558950036764145,
-0.8704976439476013,
-0.08688050508499146,
-0.59205561876297,
-0.9529364109039307,
0.4225602447986603,
-0.2506488859653473,
-0.13389335572719574,
0.5494283437728882,
-0.13049830496311188,
0.49297061562538147,
-0.11551712453365326,
-0.20252583920955658,
-0.2309795320034027,
-0.2574215233325958,
0.12448176741600037,
-0.1824141889810562,
0.41409289836883545,
-0.020785992965102196,
-0.44933071732521057,
1.250710368156433,
-0.6112146377563477,
0.7670221328735352,
-0.31393560767173767,
0.03838874027132988,
0.6837294101715088,
0.15831239521503448,
0.25029057264328003,
0.19525758922100067,
-0.1380227506160736,
0.26046350598335266,
0.1633291095495224,
-0.33578044176101685,
-0.03395618870854378,
0.49942660331726074,
-0.2850157618522644,
-0.5093429684638977,
-0.7077885270118713,
-0.08018739521503448,
0.09495458751916885,
0.4988096058368683,
0.09190811216831207,
0.13592594861984253,
-0.5905036330223083,
0.3343335688114166,
0.6335175037384033,
0.13299013674259186,
0.31336161494255066,
-0.06715060025453568,
-0.12324108183383942,
-0.6996728181838989,
0.5364521741867065,
0.4544031023979187,
-0.04801557958126068,
0.526728093624115,
0.31862303614616394,
0.054239172488451004,
-0.9048581123352051,
-0.20601312816143036,
-0.1208101138472557,
-0.7616133689880371,
-0.41321516036987305,
-0.899273157119751,
-0.04778957739472389,
-0.3230346441268921,
-0.306540846824646,
-0.20936541259288788,
-0.2724640667438507,
-0.4963269531726837,
-0.4606214463710785,
0.5582458972930908,
0.8507025241851807,
0.08887232840061188,
0.4612630009651184,
-1.0219529867172241,
0.27167370915412903,
0.10870712995529175,
0.331132709980011,
-0.3621383309364319,
0.004729246720671654,
-0.6456617116928101,
0.3027038872241974,
-0.2404555231332779,
-1.2620446681976318,
0.5088937282562256,
0.17658469080924988,
0.6882851719856262,
0.41202983260154724,
-0.3044934868812561,
0.08069850504398346,
-0.0855143591761589,
0.8802353143692017,
-0.02404054068028927,
-0.9553374648094177,
0.801510214805603,
-0.5682735443115234,
-0.17582131922245026,
0.9265037178993225,
0.7066794037818909,
-0.59365314245224,
0.044135261327028275,
-0.6250088214874268,
-1.5447391271591187,
0.3663432002067566,
0.11030556261539459,
-0.2376108318567276,
-0.0688459500670433,
0.35307246446609497,
0.9321162104606628,
0.23890848457813263,
-0.7095483541488647,
-0.37498995661735535,
0.32552775740623474,
-0.13770917057991028,
0.26419591903686523,
-0.39923909306526184,
-0.3945240378379822,
-0.2567661702632904,
0.770013689994812,
-0.173745259642601,
-0.18615193665027618,
0.36274102330207825,
-0.3969588577747345,
-0.01258797850459814,
0.15651634335517883,
0.11838223040103912,
0.8038114309310913,
-0.2010655552148819,
0.08940842002630234,
0.08091933280229568,
-0.8505058884620667,
0.4675616919994354,
-0.11151555180549622,
-0.4207296073436737,
-0.1425163596868515,
0.32848480343818665,
0.3431832194328308,
0.08975448459386826,
-0.28137511014938354,
0.03459492698311806,
0.22794723510742188,
-0.24049842357635498,
-0.39589619636535645,
-0.062001366168260574,
-0.3670855462551117,
-0.283348947763443,
0.8351872563362122,
0.4172435998916626,
0.5987817645072937,
-0.6338687539100647,
0.35080012679100037,
-0.0338938944041729,
-0.4993909001350403,
-0.3936503529548645,
0.18545594811439514,
0.5341805219650269,
0.1006544753909111,
0.3133573830127716,
-0.18826808035373688,
-0.4837127923965454,
0.62783282995224,
0.28865206241607666,
0.6330587267875671,
-0.19930467009544373,
0.39669162034988403,
0.7352778315544128,
0.31202250719070435,
-0.03436831384897232,
0.5888475775718689,
-0.3212208151817322,
-0.3925936818122864,
-0.18094000220298767,
-0.7608638405799866,
-0.07100595533847809,
-0.19501392543315887,
-0.4699134826660156,
0.5065503716468811,
-0.312337726354599,
-0.3670154809951782,
0.02325068973004818,
0.29540660977363586,
-0.4599894881248474,
0.2590748369693756,
-0.07067347317934036,
0.7221668362617493,
-1.309329628944397,
0.601047694683075,
1.308380365371704,
-0.10845081508159637,
-0.23647302389144897,
-0.24978776276111603,
-0.08704724907875061,
-0.533772349357605,
0.6030260324478149,
0.09265328198671341,
0.11212465912103653,
-0.2206529974937439,
-0.46343788504600525,
-1.0907493829727173,
1.1942598819732666,
-0.6025534868240356,
-0.27476754784584045,
0.5537494421005249,
0.10270264744758606,
0.6195539236068726,
-0.418487548828125,
-0.04956839606165886,
0.8633149266242981,
0.9497800469398499,
-0.12577904760837555,
-0.5660809874534607,
0.21545812487602234,
-0.38594651222229004,
0.044194307178258896,
0.3307768404483795,
-0.3705140948295593,
0.8518572449684143,
0.27773517370224,
-0.5301145315170288,
-0.03916618973016739,
0.5885311365127563,
0.09136718511581421,
0.3895741105079651,
0.4297451376914978,
0.2297404259443283,
0.449063241481781,
-0.44132116436958313,
0.4918195307254791,
-0.28548237681388855,
0.4040758013725281,
0.13418780267238617,
0.022440757602453232,
0.2561631202697754,
0.8684710264205933,
-0.24402201175689697,
0.7668727040290833,
0.9417435526847839,
-0.18462003767490387,
0.5203984975814819,
0.22993595898151398,
-0.11307083070278168,
-0.04773527756333351,
-0.4334307014942169,
-0.049011390656232834,
0.6949521899223328,
1.130262851715088,
-0.7311321496963501,
-0.2286427915096283,
0.02262820303440094,
0.10192394256591797,
0.5281206965446472,
-0.9059864282608032,
1.1615506410598755,
0.08391380310058594,
-0.6614746451377869,
0.2238243818283081,
0.3249191641807556,
0.6752526760101318,
-0.659668505191803,
-0.49045613408088684,
-0.07810313254594803,
0.12614397704601288,
-0.6277961134910583,
-0.9197627902030945,
0.827251136302948,
-0.1841304898262024,
-0.19074350595474243,
-0.24605727195739746,
1.072806715965271,
-0.5233567357063293,
-0.7363709807395935,
0.2528221607208252,
0.47557154297828674,
0.01728835515677929,
0.11223946511745453,
-0.2729080617427826,
-0.16194666922092438,
0.038406506180763245,
-0.30226847529411316,
-0.04492555186152458,
0.38211962580680847,
-0.5403150320053101,
0.23631350696086884,
0.7073781490325928,
0.4777549207210541,
-0.34590983390808105,
-0.4778275787830353,
0.9410068392753601,
-0.9729847311973572,
-0.7653844356536865,
-0.9176139235496521,
0.4227055609226227,
-0.20327429473400116,
-0.15485116839408875,
0.8390755653381348,
0.5959583520889282,
0.8581945300102234,
-0.15166699886322021,
0.9069133996963501,
-0.5042715072631836,
0.14551639556884766,
-0.4926440119743347,
0.6235588192939758,
-0.12425648421049118,
-0.1527283489704132,
-0.027484919875860214,
-1.069420576095581,
-0.26425662636756897,
0.24925260245800018,
-0.18407781422138214,
0.11948829889297485,
1.0380958318710327,
0.3599169850349426,
0.1536458432674408,
-0.259456992149353,
0.008879066444933414,
0.05135806277394295,
0.1297890841960907,
-0.02258134074509144,
0.2475799322128296,
-0.3421197235584259,
0.00319704320281744,
-0.43658939003944397,
-0.4533084034919739,
-0.22973847389221191,
-0.7548941969871521,
-0.2933996617794037,
-0.7353745102882385,
-0.15426835417747498,
-0.459641695022583,
-0.02717009000480175,
1.0008985996246338,
0.3688673675060272,
-1.0251394510269165,
-0.4553425908088684,
-0.09281281381845474,
0.32794591784477234,
-0.5283306241035461,
-0.2199537307024002,
0.5442880988121033,
-0.06694644689559937,
-0.7171726822853088,
0.03362759202718735,
0.3584050238132477,
0.0003827649634331465,
-0.4051208794116974,
0.34152287244796753,
-0.8100294470787048,
0.02781706117093563,
0.5194839239120483,
-0.014839724637567997,
-0.16939343512058258,
-0.11600218713283539,
-0.24102582037448883,
0.16425344347953796,
0.20126347243785858,
1.0036201477050781,
-0.7057324647903442,
0.5223802924156189,
0.8694860935211182,
0.060340359807014465,
0.18837645649909973,
0.2607623338699341,
0.5373467803001404,
-0.6642734408378601,
0.3188494145870209,
0.41421225666999817,
0.16428114473819733,
0.39955297112464905,
-0.9446511268615723,
0.5469606518745422,
0.6355347633361816,
-0.4515746831893921,
-0.43223103880882263,
0.10265658050775528,
-0.918326735496521,
-0.3459506630897522,
1.334325909614563,
-0.29666608572006226,
-0.7472162246704102,
-0.39212140440940857,
-0.18655528128147125,
0.40950578451156616,
-0.3805549144744873,
0.5322986841201782,
0.606947124004364,
0.058934736996889114,
0.35145190358161926,
-0.08536297082901001,
0.8263359665870667,
-0.5078948140144348,
-0.7842590808868408,
-0.0381668284535408,
0.31566327810287476,
0.13813059031963348,
0.3056463897228241,
0.6139684915542603,
-0.5561126470565796,
-0.14703916013240814,
0.11724713444709778,
0.44009527564048767,
0.0690331757068634,
-0.33880946040153503,
-0.28157687187194824,
0.13128915429115295,
-0.10112990438938141,
-0.05241146683692932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00667v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00667v1
|
An Early Investigation into the Utility of Multimodal Large Language Models in Medical Imaging
| 2024-06-02T08:29:23
| 2024-06-02T08:29:23
|
Sulaiman Khan, Md. Rafiul Biswas, Alina Murad, Hazrat Ali, Zubair Shah
|
eess.IV
|
eess.IV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Recent developments in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have spurred
significant interest in their potential applications across various medical
imaging domains. On the one hand, there is a temptation to use these generative
models to synthesize realistic-looking medical image data, while on the other
hand, the ability to identify synthetic image data in a pool of data is also
significantly important. In this study, we explore the potential of the Gemini
(\textit{gemini-1.0-pro-vision-latest}) and GPT-4V (gpt-4-vision-preview)
models for medical image analysis using two modalities of medical image data.
Utilizing synthetic and real imaging data, both Gemini AI and GPT-4V are first
used to classify real versus synthetic images, followed by an interpretation
and analysis of the input images. Experimental results demonstrate that both
Gemini and GPT-4 could perform some interpretation of the input images. In this
specific experiment, Gemini was able to perform slightly better than the GPT-4V
on the classification task. In contrast, responses associated with GPT-4V were
mostly generic in nature. Our early investigation presented in this work
provides insights into the potential of MLLMs to assist with the classification
and interpretation of retinal fundoscopy and lung X-ray images. We also
identify key limitations associated with the early investigation study on MLLMs
for specialized tasks in medical image analysis.
|
[
-0.3645048141479492,
-0.5272665023803711,
0.8156852722167969,
0.04031284153461456,
-0.40067100524902344,
-0.13616760075092316,
0.04663633182644844,
-0.6384671330451965,
0.07145524770021439,
0.5253008008003235,
-0.4162803888320923,
-0.4208357632160187,
-0.7287880182266235,
0.22959798574447632,
-0.5487589240074158,
0.887313187122345,
0.006717088632285595,
0.4820902645587921,
-0.035780008882284164,
-0.12945520877838135,
-0.2574024498462677,
-0.6442084312438965,
-0.7389892339706421,
0.08028342574834824,
0.8030292987823486,
-0.28789156675338745,
0.9394509196281433,
0.2839416265487671,
0.9110704064369202,
0.3483864665031433,
0.2308008372783661,
-0.0008415396441705525,
-0.05670870840549469,
0.10621950775384903,
0.14529503881931305,
-0.2632100284099579,
-0.30369776487350464,
0.19825057685375214,
0.7175410389900208,
0.4694746732711792,
0.03274061903357506,
-0.15501751005649567,
-0.5800299048423767,
0.5531350374221802,
-0.4641258120536804,
0.27491429448127747,
-0.3709002435207367,
0.19648928940296173,
-0.3191817104816437,
-0.26573073863983154,
-0.14652620255947113,
0.10842757672071457,
0.3183393180370331,
-0.71192467212677,
0.1327192634344101,
0.0014028537552803755,
1.0484119653701782,
0.21127431094646454,
-0.4026262164115906,
-0.4904029071331024,
-0.6084780097007751,
0.5284372568130493,
-0.7331579923629761,
0.4827194809913635,
-0.0368013009428978,
0.6338629722595215,
0.01848672144114971,
-1.108054757118225,
-0.7079725861549377,
-0.4750274121761322,
-0.1726456880569458,
0.3701237738132477,
-0.21893802285194397,
0.10737869888544083,
0.13962920010089874,
0.32145923376083374,
-0.6107934713363647,
0.14288093149662018,
-0.7020283341407776,
-0.29081717133522034,
0.24095332622528076,
0.3315621018409729,
0.469094455242157,
-0.28475674986839294,
-0.4478485584259033,
0.1039365753531456,
-0.5026538372039795,
-0.2589399814605713,
-0.20741209387779236,
-0.08046923577785492,
-0.16037440299987793,
0.734186589717865,
0.22607755661010742,
0.8536620140075684,
-0.18806377053260803,
-0.28236228227615356,
0.41854020953178406,
-0.41769060492515564,
-0.523507833480835,
-0.4846717417240143,
0.8868705630302429,
0.37106096744537354,
0.08618184179067612,
0.16244693100452423,
-0.3244002163410187,
0.28258252143859863,
0.26310956478118896,
-0.827459454536438,
-0.15714603662490845,
0.2157130390405655,
-1.0117064714431763,
-0.4710080921649933,
0.004870506934821606,
-0.4195542633533478,
-0.4216504395008087,
-0.43708446621894836,
0.532718300819397,
-0.36769765615463257,
-0.19035878777503967,
0.0623028464615345,
-0.1869424432516098,
0.12032438069581985,
0.24666176736354828,
-0.7537129521369934,
0.12368757277727127,
0.5167524218559265,
0.9011097550392151,
-0.14534549415111542,
-0.11750921607017517,
-0.3553488850593567,
-0.15100395679473877,
-0.38728317618370056,
0.6423144936561584,
-0.6871626377105713,
-0.40399208664894104,
-0.2148357778787613,
0.04768165573477745,
-0.17837689816951752,
-0.5474557280540466,
0.5538142919540405,
-0.4672420918941498,
0.3918602764606476,
0.03715602308511734,
-0.25820714235305786,
-0.15454892814159393,
0.4711996018886566,
-0.9279695153236389,
0.41750967502593994,
0.21463516354560852,
-0.6115103363990784,
0.46017107367515564,
-0.7873328328132629,
-0.2948155105113983,
0.009810791350901127,
-0.7076340317726135,
-0.5702809691429138,
0.26423409581184387,
0.2203129082918167,
0.7593629360198975,
-0.33456575870513916,
0.20683950185775757,
-0.16558483242988586,
-0.2460891753435135,
0.6803581714630127,
-0.681780993938446,
0.3345639705657959,
0.46448057889938354,
0.038711901754140854,
0.2150607854127884,
-0.5589795708656311,
-0.16560496389865875,
0.2552416920661926,
-0.26847121119499207,
-0.241796612739563,
-0.1453617811203003,
0.1620502471923828,
0.4781518280506134,
0.037695590406656265,
-0.7038946151733398,
0.12363626062870026,
-0.2735821306705475,
0.3648739159107208,
0.5660420060157776,
-0.2491704821586609,
0.06195569038391113,
-0.26788246631622314,
0.6526246070861816,
0.32824596762657166,
0.5061871409416199,
-0.4371667206287384,
-0.9370142221450806,
-0.4426944851875305,
-0.7562392950057983,
0.25604990124702454,
0.44175463914871216,
-0.9541471004486084,
-0.4614817202091217,
-0.24092058837413788,
-0.29488471150398254,
-0.7113550305366516,
-0.2276051789522171,
0.3386194705963135,
0.36442187428474426,
0.2587161064147949,
-0.29512444138526917,
-0.5512804985046387,
-1.25501549243927,
0.0383637398481369,
0.06698007136583328,
-0.16515928506851196,
0.45440471172332764,
0.4175274670124054,
-0.5211958885192871,
0.5592814087867737,
-0.4712490141391754,
-0.3154328167438507,
0.011505705304443836,
0.061724986881017685,
0.41354960203170776,
0.15247933566570282,
0.777388334274292,
-1.1286770105361938,
-0.48569685220718384,
0.29715391993522644,
-0.8595429062843323,
0.13029925525188446,
-0.186075821518898,
0.11152952909469604,
0.2621084451675415,
0.2846291661262512,
-0.6484674215316772,
0.4101546108722687,
0.9050922989845276,
-0.1978425830602646,
0.6228206753730774,
-0.4757756292819977,
0.3125578761100769,
-0.9325060844421387,
0.21411237120628357,
0.22757937014102936,
-0.23672455549240112,
-0.8034930229187012,
0.02594761922955513,
0.38028600811958313,
-0.30237066745758057,
-0.38390833139419556,
0.45774292945861816,
-0.4617341160774231,
-0.2059091180562973,
-0.23481447994709015,
-0.26711305975914,
0.0017889507580548525,
0.12427668273448944,
0.3125998377799988,
0.6176138520240784,
0.7578215003013611,
-0.15816514194011688,
0.22701430320739746,
-0.02368766814470291,
-0.30892229080200195,
0.29352471232414246,
-0.5832371115684509,
0.08476129174232483,
-0.4805329740047455,
0.3146999776363373,
-0.8277841806411743,
-0.25468412041664124,
0.388968288898468,
-0.4210243821144104,
0.5732637047767639,
-0.10853023082017899,
-0.391919881105423,
-0.5692028999328613,
-0.2388499230146408,
0.44989460706710815,
0.436981737613678,
-0.4153900146484375,
0.8207603096961975,
0.20866850018501282,
-0.0716446191072464,
-0.5345162153244019,
-0.5649420619010925,
0.11263377964496613,
-0.12428173422813416,
-0.60561603307724,
0.454307496547699,
0.1370958834886551,
-0.20323069393634796,
0.08794547617435455,
0.17073042690753937,
-0.10867970436811447,
-0.17796553671360016,
0.5037054419517517,
0.9343361258506775,
-0.3464592695236206,
0.07855989038944244,
-0.13370729982852936,
-0.3078502416610718,
-0.02601506933569908,
-0.24769119918346405,
0.20847022533416748,
-0.16513614356517792,
-0.37514734268188477,
-0.44777482748031616,
0.3974347412586212,
1.205819010734558,
-0.20349717140197754,
0.6707141995429993,
0.8687891364097595,
-0.3756066858768463,
0.5820160508155823,
-0.6381609439849854,
-0.01855398528277874,
-0.4576304256916046,
0.5871880054473877,
-0.45675286650657654,
-0.6186185479164124,
0.23684312403202057,
0.1839691400527954,
0.012570735067129135,
0.43928611278533936,
0.7836796641349792,
-0.4100433886051178,
1.0933856964111328,
0.2500883638858795,
0.09734276682138443,
0.43283483386039734,
-0.2765754759311676,
0.06744229048490524,
-0.973626434803009,
-0.3574260473251343,
-0.190770223736763,
-0.21087142825126648,
-0.4453388452529907,
-0.6060888171195984,
0.6500688791275024,
-0.6798720359802246,
0.1323348730802536,
-0.30392834544181824,
-0.46509477496147156,
0.2512759566307068,
0.2079468071460724,
0.09035655856132507,
0.09573915600776672,
0.0737232118844986,
-0.15539135038852692,
-0.16422009468078613,
-0.5859611630439758,
-0.3542415201663971,
1.389670968055725,
0.42831042408943176,
0.7159985899925232,
-0.020535334944725037,
0.20714503526687622,
0.11231812089681625,
0.8498772382736206,
-0.8160586357116699,
0.2919825613498688,
-0.7928452491760254,
-0.8778405785560608,
0.050658535212278366,
-0.24913112819194794,
-1.1302133798599243,
0.6726475358009338,
-0.5722185373306274,
-0.09193722903728485,
0.015810564160346985,
0.15412279963493347,
-0.4668852388858795,
0.18287254869937897,
-0.8236590623855591,
0.7706004977226257,
-0.47242194414138794,
-0.08937295526266098,
-0.09349951893091202,
-0.7114277482032776,
0.49709951877593994,
-0.39269012212753296,
0.4583120048046112,
0.12564502656459808,
-0.06555558741092682,
0.4892014265060425,
-0.08972685039043427,
0.8015549182891846,
-0.2851828932762146,
0.06612126529216766,
0.06482506543397903,
-0.13938553631305695,
0.18669208884239197,
-0.14331908524036407,
0.14172302186489105,
0.2685598134994507,
0.311002254486084,
-0.1459304839372635,
-0.6545237898826599,
0.7846376299858093,
-0.7104631066322327,
-0.4356050491333008,
-0.44552603363990784,
-0.5780135989189148,
0.04570668563246727,
0.02921280264854431,
0.10775125026702881,
0.701176643371582,
0.11851261556148529,
0.10888241976499557,
0.025075823068618774,
-0.3718045949935913,
0.20830519497394562,
0.4236608147621155,
-0.4877115786075592,
-0.2954552471637726,
0.8378878831863403,
0.04080846533179283,
0.3470308780670166,
0.29037120938301086,
0.3301208019256592,
-0.4008447825908661,
-0.9015744924545288,
-0.45003294944763184,
0.5242273211479187,
-0.6702373027801514,
-0.0279243104159832,
-0.5626187324523926,
-0.015183757990598679,
-0.1828291416168213,
0.01246833149343729,
-0.2774776816368103,
-0.31563523411750793,
-0.170745387673378,
0.38200274109840393,
-0.09959522634744644,
0.5549253225326538,
0.18674229085445404,
-0.012002911418676376,
-1.037314534187317,
0.3445262312889099,
0.13891689479351044,
0.07948727160692215,
-0.3613501489162445,
-0.18773530423641205,
-0.1449127048254013,
-0.15316346287727356,
-0.14455580711364746,
-0.8442419767379761,
0.4386853873729706,
0.07760081440210342,
0.6097591519355774,
0.5808029770851135,
-0.5410537719726562,
0.6149895787239075,
-0.37524497509002686,
0.7714787721633911,
0.46115803718566895,
-0.5347498655319214,
0.26352447271347046,
-0.2158387154340744,
0.2116256207227707,
0.08440407365560532,
0.32346025109291077,
-0.4966728091239929,
-0.26879626512527466,
-0.4059320092201233,
-0.4535093307495117,
0.27396443486213684,
0.4474702477455139,
0.06414292007684708,
-0.037745408713817596,
0.5822474360466003,
0.27550965547561646,
0.18678027391433716,
-0.664985179901123,
-0.005390130914747715,
-0.3492623269557953,
-0.37833350896835327,
-0.0027527143247425556,
0.0024649747647345066,
-0.14730611443519592,
-0.18259115517139435,
0.17845198512077332,
-0.15231436491012573,
0.5522521734237671,
0.272266685962677,
0.08405528217554092,
0.2136358618736267,
0.1554839313030243,
0.6733514666557312,
0.3306226134300232,
0.0030522483866661787,
0.16927969455718994,
-0.16027356684207916,
-0.7057077884674072,
-0.12459903210401535,
0.07625101506710052,
0.08385694026947021,
-0.032589178532361984,
0.4660341739654541,
0.7486480474472046,
0.0245068296790123,
-0.7465962767601013,
0.5982886552810669,
-0.21405167877674103,
-0.29379990696907043,
-0.38397443294525146,
-0.02976822853088379,
0.03292958810925484,
0.34600603580474854,
0.1929653286933899,
0.4389079809188843,
0.24541980028152466,
-0.681725025177002,
-0.05282522365450859,
0.748012363910675,
-0.14259451627731323,
-0.4029274582862854,
0.5302445888519287,
0.20009665191173553,
0.12010619044303894,
0.945734977722168,
0.20752689242362976,
-0.4508166015148163,
0.6348271369934082,
0.5080946683883667,
0.4358954429626465,
-0.052090998739004135,
0.056627701967954636,
0.24137195944786072,
0.10192803293466568,
0.19664493203163147,
0.3099733293056488,
0.18839317560195923,
-0.9360930919647217,
-0.581523597240448,
-0.3926200866699219,
-0.11593163013458252,
0.17437899112701416,
-0.4271213114261627,
0.19604837894439697,
-0.4462845027446747,
-0.5425627827644348,
0.45307597517967224,
-0.43357932567596436,
-0.756125271320343,
0.5077853798866272,
0.6097144484519958,
0.5436525344848633,
-0.5838021636009216,
1.0070204734802246,
0.6159240007400513,
-0.2485395222902298,
-0.66701740026474,
-0.2024553269147873,
0.08314087986946106,
-0.9810981750488281,
0.9161710143089294,
0.23066650331020355,
-0.04976386949419975,
-0.0869571715593338,
-0.28823578357696533,
-0.5781025290489197,
1.1814165115356445,
0.09530998021364212,
-0.6122490763664246,
-0.20565497875213623,
-0.0737929716706276,
0.611355185508728,
-0.6066867709159851,
0.2367958128452301,
0.48423734307289124,
0.5295175909996033,
0.3992370665073395,
-0.9940910935401917,
0.05585835874080658,
-0.332806795835495,
-0.013333011418581009,
0.2986850440502167,
-0.2129397690296173,
1.1072643995285034,
-0.4888176918029785,
-0.23102930188179016,
0.23353809118270874,
0.11627350747585297,
0.33953747153282166,
0.4159879684448242,
0.5796631574630737,
0.17847448587417603,
0.5264782905578613,
-0.1788865327835083,
1.4646522998809814,
-0.17126226425170898,
0.2872218191623688,
0.3626822233200073,
-0.17809316515922546,
0.675369143486023,
0.6613679528236389,
-0.1777595579624176,
0.4020652770996094,
0.4930780827999115,
-0.2895857095718384,
0.5095040798187256,
0.02559950016438961,
-0.3312903940677643,
-0.12224072962999344,
0.2971286475658417,
-0.4982181191444397,
0.3663439154624939,
0.8463878631591797,
-0.7123669385910034,
0.21638977527618408,
0.40379148721694946,
-0.20261727273464203,
-0.6592251062393188,
-0.3201151490211487,
0.4053991138935089,
0.12727773189544678,
-0.5395873785018921,
0.5108546018600464,
0.0028546710964292288,
0.7258490920066833,
-0.7138922810554504,
-0.008817133493721485,
0.14592447876930237,
0.1888168901205063,
-0.21408618986606598,
-0.7506765127182007,
0.3882843852043152,
-0.14024677872657776,
0.1134299635887146,
0.1192799061536789,
0.770662784576416,
-0.04202064126729965,
-0.7383797764778137,
0.11080226302146912,
0.29110562801361084,
0.3043668866157532,
-0.1913239061832428,
-0.6544088125228882,
0.24122023582458496,
-0.08301662653684616,
-0.12956233322620392,
0.26139354705810547,
0.19693432748317719,
-0.022588051855564117,
0.6986568570137024,
0.9343390464782715,
0.11015507578849792,
0.03761846199631691,
0.07591766864061356,
0.9601941108703613,
-0.5920240879058838,
-0.19245147705078125,
-0.7323265075683594,
0.5990509986877441,
0.04566045105457306,
-0.1069910079240799,
0.3958877921104431,
0.43319517374038696,
0.28641119599342346,
-0.38572657108306885,
0.8680967092514038,
0.022573035210371017,
0.16129803657531738,
-0.8566586375236511,
0.534665584564209,
-0.8351564407348633,
0.14850647747516632,
-0.1345134824514389,
-0.43186548352241516,
-0.7445423603057861,
0.6851609349250793,
-0.30452287197113037,
0.10928795486688614,
0.9669807553291321,
0.9093536734580994,
-0.15732815861701965,
0.03763662651181221,
0.5943483114242554,
0.24291345477104187,
0.48749715089797974,
0.3493887186050415,
1.017130970954895,
-0.10820154845714569,
0.532512366771698,
0.02931082621216774,
-0.28583791851997375,
-0.18327657878398895,
-0.3805321156978607,
-0.8913958668708801,
-0.5417688488960266,
-0.18259385228157043,
-0.3360578119754791,
-0.22967354953289032,
0.5795257687568665,
0.8723629117012024,
-0.42411354184150696,
0.3456243574619293,
0.2910175323486328,
-0.5362874865531921,
-0.07488145679235458,
-0.06796912848949432,
0.5787383913993835,
0.0038899558130651712,
-0.6873518824577332,
0.31847456097602844,
0.5864140391349792,
0.4632515609264374,
-0.5327609777450562,
-0.16893960535526276,
0.26703688502311707,
-0.06829480081796646,
0.7648745179176331,
0.1348816454410553,
-1.0172934532165527,
-0.009176692925393581,
0.24074333906173706,
-0.1451951563358307,
0.07279375940561295,
1.2114089727401733,
-0.855971097946167,
0.733706533908844,
0.18929365277290344,
0.3590557873249054,
0.6664972901344299,
-0.14567169547080994,
0.38830214738845825,
-0.23573674261569977,
0.2447388917207718,
0.18767283856868744,
0.6012341976165771,
0.26551389694213867,
-0.3575392961502075,
0.17186817526817322,
0.2530086040496826,
-0.3989231288433075,
-0.4830367863178253,
0.11493442207574844,
-1.1730116605758667,
-0.3482140302658081,
1.007826566696167,
-0.15629836916923523,
-0.08010199666023254,
-0.12580682337284088,
-0.5726903676986694,
-0.11845134198665619,
-0.06315156072378159,
0.5697207450866699,
0.5683541297912598,
-0.38580361008644104,
-0.39212068915367126,
-0.7522257566452026,
0.13239963352680206,
0.22314152121543884,
-0.886847972869873,
-0.546843409538269,
0.558783233165741,
0.48032963275909424,
0.30065271258354187,
0.8509536981582642,
-0.6237170696258545,
0.3863185942173004,
-0.06322047114372253,
-0.3248239755630493,
-0.31576141715049744,
-0.15608783066272736,
-0.2840562164783478,
0.43113210797309875,
-0.08214753121137619,
-0.4941073954105377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00656v1
|
Presence or Absence: Are Unknown Word Usages in Dictionaries?
| 2024-06-02T07:57:45
| 2024-06-02T07:57:45
|
Xianghe Ma, Dominik Schlechtweg, Wei Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this work, we outline the components and results of our system submitted
to the AXOLOTL-24 shared task for Finnish, Russian and German languages. Our
system is fully unsupervised. It leverages a graph-based clustering approach to
predict mappings between unknown word usages and dictionary entries for Subtask
1, and generates dictionary-like definitions for those novel word usages
through the state-of-the-art Large Language Models such as GPT-4 and LLaMA-3
for Subtask 2. In Subtask 1, our system outperforms the baseline system by a
large margin, and it offers interpretability for the mapping results by
distinguishing between matched and unmatched (novel) word usages through our
graph-based clustering approach. Our system ranks first in Finnish and German,
and ranks second in Russian on the Subtask 2 test-phase leaderboard. These
results show the potential of our system in managing dictionary entries,
particularly for updating dictionaries to include novel sense entries. Our code
and data are made publicly
available\footnote{\url{https://github.com/xiaohemaikoo/axolotl24-ABDN-NLP}}.
|
[
-0.3287011384963989,
-0.4627262055873871,
0.6710889935493469,
0.2587638795375824,
-0.4406013786792755,
0.2792622148990631,
0.0357377789914608,
-0.6530235409736633,
0.5990753173828125,
0.030480993911623955,
-0.47481569647789,
-0.6170251369476318,
-0.5781827569007874,
0.2978673279285431,
-0.6604252457618713,
0.6947641968727112,
-0.0726551041007042,
-0.0830787941813469,
-0.5543150305747986,
-0.6613404750823975,
-0.4409809112548828,
-0.5259234309196472,
-0.18698850274085999,
-0.4676692485809326,
0.6143471002578735,
0.060657814145088196,
0.6484674215316772,
0.26798853278160095,
0.36408424377441406,
0.29292577505111694,
-0.14421403408050537,
0.08016451448202133,
-0.1258580982685089,
0.034115541726350784,
-0.4232112467288971,
-0.024037569761276245,
-0.3342527449131012,
-0.4378170967102051,
0.657356321811676,
1.033254623413086,
-0.2624078392982483,
-0.23708009719848633,
0.11959630250930786,
0.2619636654853821,
-0.5582554340362549,
0.372517466545105,
-0.6389412879943848,
0.03408942371606827,
-0.41160228848457336,
0.3361268937587738,
-0.061787061393260956,
0.0879320427775383,
-0.07774235308170319,
-0.7670178413391113,
0.13751375675201416,
-0.025856010615825653,
0.6608824729919434,
0.09344809502363205,
-0.2053241729736328,
-0.4046846926212311,
-0.45263832807540894,
0.5103129148483276,
-0.6147876381874084,
0.3733328580856323,
0.5869329571723938,
0.01802455633878708,
-0.39426302909851074,
-0.8402830958366394,
-0.8106704354286194,
0.1229642853140831,
-0.3534475862979889,
0.23308990895748138,
-0.8185800313949585,
0.056514475494623184,
0.005999986082315445,
0.34851691126823425,
-0.44494715332984924,
0.22820356488227844,
-0.3066251277923584,
-0.2601455748081207,
0.4600672125816345,
0.05555222928524017,
0.28572532534599304,
-0.1382780224084854,
0.02947794459760189,
0.25750452280044556,
-0.6311699748039246,
-0.3816692531108856,
0.1395408809185028,
0.33108726143836975,
-0.23122458159923553,
0.9234898686408997,
-0.5439345240592957,
0.6452692151069641,
-0.3211573362350464,
0.25825607776641846,
0.5974973440170288,
-0.6455363631248474,
0.12918873131275177,
-0.22239410877227783,
0.6802895069122314,
0.2609541714191437,
-0.05356135219335556,
-0.41048043966293335,
-0.45840707421302795,
0.31621378660202026,
0.0246682558208704,
-0.19512471556663513,
-0.501357913017273,
0.013778015039861202,
-0.057670075446367264,
-0.1903047412633896,
-0.04742550849914551,
-0.5335237383842468,
-0.5176618695259094,
0.009060485288500786,
0.6181371212005615,
-0.2686369717121124,
-0.47145357728004456,
-0.2794157564640045,
-0.3289874494075775,
-0.3805525302886963,
0.3132770359516144,
-0.7902379035949707,
0.682135283946991,
0.509896993637085,
1.1734564304351807,
-0.4926616847515106,
-0.3988095819950104,
-0.3870551884174347,
-0.41583919525146484,
-0.5981042981147766,
0.7322564721107483,
-0.2268407791852951,
-0.655603289604187,
0.27839353680610657,
0.24425692856311798,
0.06739430874586105,
-0.6922023892402649,
0.12996938824653625,
-0.330346941947937,
0.02835489995777607,
-0.42767998576164246,
-0.42805662751197815,
-0.26493486762046814,
0.1105257198214531,
-0.6440013647079468,
1.2013812065124512,
0.43745145201683044,
-0.5459785461425781,
0.4538683295249939,
-0.7666747570037842,
-0.529264509677887,
0.8198290467262268,
-0.2713971734046936,
-0.05437026917934418,
0.4131046533584595,
-0.1543618142604828,
0.34199851751327515,
0.4455429017543793,
-0.1390979290008545,
-0.1601542979478836,
-0.2929784059524536,
0.3616485297679901,
-0.06696084886789322,
0.6695916652679443,
0.3133089244365692,
-0.2590685188770294,
-0.2001137137413025,
-0.7549554705619812,
-0.1153503805398941,
0.022492099553346634,
-0.38078102469444275,
-0.8418509364128113,
0.2642396092414856,
0.11974932253360748,
-0.07225719094276428,
0.5538887977600098,
-0.9481611251831055,
0.08308497071266174,
-0.39626985788345337,
0.3565067946910858,
0.5591610074043274,
0.05034951493144035,
0.3091716766357422,
-0.07843468338251114,
0.6248503923416138,
0.14975091814994812,
-0.12152816355228424,
-0.11123095452785492,
-0.8093288540840149,
-0.8176409602165222,
-0.1845729649066925,
0.38410311937332153,
0.37374407052993774,
-0.8708882927894592,
0.32180482149124146,
-0.16706904768943787,
-0.47134214639663696,
-0.12812726199626923,
0.041830532252788544,
0.18364568054676056,
0.21121516823768616,
0.35221606492996216,
-0.07632739841938019,
-0.3656151294708252,
-0.7474207282066345,
0.060200706124305725,
-0.20772413909435272,
0.09572846442461014,
0.1857365518808365,
0.6341255307197571,
-0.537121593952179,
0.9447317719459534,
-0.540318489074707,
-0.32809221744537354,
-0.2545693814754486,
0.04290102422237396,
0.3754216134548187,
0.24789784848690033,
0.5585435628890991,
-0.7285586595535278,
-0.44610595703125,
0.36614876985549927,
-0.8202014565467834,
-0.3008648753166199,
0.21064822375774384,
0.27656427025794983,
0.2635250389575958,
0.2588115930557251,
-0.6268970966339111,
0.5551432371139526,
0.7584675550460815,
-0.40946346521377563,
0.2473766803741455,
-0.5423743724822998,
-0.35768136382102966,
-1.0214773416519165,
0.18199686706066132,
-0.2725517749786377,
-0.27327314019203186,
-0.5413203239440918,
0.17406600713729858,
0.04205527901649475,
-0.022531569004058838,
-0.39633625745773315,
0.5912013053894043,
-0.6117172241210938,
-0.21041615307331085,
-0.30834513902664185,
0.059586308896541595,
-0.1459604650735855,
0.2375037521123886,
-0.015534959733486176,
0.6195949912071228,
0.7264764308929443,
-0.5289574265480042,
0.5952107310295105,
0.2577940821647644,
-0.579258382320404,
0.41510531306266785,
-0.523598313331604,
-0.0025256515946239233,
0.1371975541114807,
-0.15079262852668762,
-1.0866941213607788,
-0.17307418584823608,
0.3716757595539093,
-0.42966675758361816,
0.012599301524460316,
-0.008448686450719833,
-0.7029714584350586,
-0.29505500197410583,
0.25661319494247437,
0.2277616560459137,
0.4895413815975189,
-0.3333006799221039,
0.34983959794044495,
0.7694250345230103,
-0.2194562554359436,
-0.45471060276031494,
-0.6957041621208191,
0.21978053450584412,
-0.1108667328953743,
-0.07418200373649597,
0.1401558667421341,
0.06890588253736496,
-0.5688481330871582,
0.3101780116558075,
-0.23405832052230835,
-0.22550426423549652,
0.3068583607673645,
0.5071360468864441,
0.10061856359243393,
0.20615386962890625,
0.29841238260269165,
0.26655855774879456,
-0.10194462537765503,
-0.13811349868774414,
-0.3736685514450073,
0.45777595043182373,
-0.1155230700969696,
-0.33473676443099976,
0.026955608278512955,
0.6828432083129883,
0.5248191952705383,
-0.12037049978971481,
0.5933022499084473,
0.26464390754699707,
-0.9063107371330261,
-0.21577633917331696,
-0.123786561191082,
0.020578134804964066,
-0.446354478597641,
0.4210578203201294,
-0.2081538289785385,
-0.7541714310646057,
0.8581186532974243,
0.09379357099533081,
0.03748241066932678,
0.5116894245147705,
0.323994517326355,
-0.15761861205101013,
0.8626406192779541,
0.7539651393890381,
0.005746468901634216,
0.20120161771774292,
-0.19271451234817505,
0.24317319691181183,
-0.5439187288284302,
-0.20832760632038116,
-0.304593026638031,
-0.19906024634838104,
-0.6603139638900757,
-0.27963390946388245,
0.5560719966888428,
-0.10334879159927368,
0.554490327835083,
0.49808356165885925,
-0.37681448459625244,
0.36276933550834656,
0.574794590473175,
-0.33072519302368164,
0.2689143419265747,
0.19537000358104706,
-0.562903642654419,
-0.04958858713507652,
-0.8392716646194458,
0.04533284530043602,
0.9322441220283508,
0.042691364884376526,
0.5569130778312683,
0.12212174385786057,
0.7371315360069275,
0.6053332090377808,
0.054946042597293854,
-0.9507865905761719,
0.5685412287712097,
-0.295614629983902,
-0.6227997541427612,
-0.2835155725479126,
-0.20575262606143951,
-1.2450731992721558,
0.4320645034313202,
-0.19955095648765564,
-0.9181959629058838,
0.396146297454834,
-0.12063156068325043,
-0.4417359530925751,
-0.0037983395159244537,
-0.6186406016349792,
0.7363412380218506,
0.03667581453919411,
0.08304379880428314,
-0.2714831829071045,
-0.359977662563324,
-0.2580898702144623,
-0.4435892105102539,
0.39709410071372986,
0.12434782832860947,
-0.016385046765208244,
0.9192298054695129,
-0.6296698451042175,
0.8189135193824768,
-0.27526870369911194,
-0.07169842720031738,
0.22165071964263916,
0.09843520820140839,
0.5125389695167542,
-0.04678727313876152,
0.07730413228273392,
0.8038029670715332,
0.3880283534526825,
-0.17377716302871704,
-0.38964083790779114,
0.9857757091522217,
-0.37874218821525574,
-0.22662118077278137,
-1.1036895513534546,
-0.5033376216888428,
-0.0029813721776008606,
0.8522068858146667,
0.42327165603637695,
0.6491379737854004,
-0.253478080034256,
0.24039612710475922,
0.3768481910228729,
-0.13931578397750854,
0.5308070778846741,
0.8795559406280518,
-0.4849371910095215,
-0.19163337349891663,
1.0859240293502808,
0.7068443298339844,
-0.12165427207946777,
0.3778669238090515,
0.3152078092098236,
-0.5450586080551147,
-0.8203752636909485,
-0.31315022706985474,
0.3609845042228699,
-0.6641504764556885,
-0.028407787904143333,
-0.7146923542022705,
-0.16132493317127228,
-0.6333113312721252,
0.009812564589083195,
-0.14854119718074799,
-0.44335320591926575,
-0.15191127359867096,
-0.24086374044418335,
0.3584165871143341,
1.1110975742340088,
-0.4446128010749817,
0.37640580534935,
-0.4430502653121948,
0.18593595921993256,
0.17878131568431854,
0.27979883551597595,
-0.47172534465789795,
-0.10442961752414703,
-0.5736832022666931,
0.16122503578662872,
0.13159075379371643,
-0.8473702073097229,
0.44275984168052673,
0.21023347973823547,
0.7692853212356567,
0.4655895531177521,
0.28746122121810913,
0.4910869300365448,
-0.4101288616657257,
0.8079020977020264,
0.018654365092515945,
-0.8003134727478027,
0.18433645367622375,
-0.5317912697792053,
0.5276256203651428,
0.4593783915042877,
0.22234658896923065,
-0.8452903032302856,
-0.6322402358055115,
-0.6801915168762207,
-0.8870002031326294,
0.7095562219619751,
0.35243088006973267,
0.34754782915115356,
-0.2442430853843689,
0.08740117400884628,
0.043963052332401276,
0.5554536581039429,
-0.5991668701171875,
-0.3919311761856079,
-0.13661448657512665,
-0.1876770555973053,
-0.4788978695869446,
-0.1402004212141037,
-0.19655686616897583,
-0.3738202750682831,
0.4300292730331421,
0.015041379258036613,
0.17801712453365326,
0.010133104398846626,
-0.02275325171649456,
-0.08727710694074631,
-0.12370133399963379,
0.5225613713264465,
1.02991783618927,
-0.02732584811747074,
0.4027423858642578,
0.3075345754623413,
-0.7984357476234436,
-0.20805372297763824,
0.05437244474887848,
-0.2569707930088043,
0.7626319527626038,
0.34978431463241577,
0.5785903334617615,
0.16374029219150543,
-0.6700153350830078,
0.5982855558395386,
0.19644230604171753,
-0.08567938208580017,
-0.8994894027709961,
-0.16841305792331696,
0.10741035640239716,
-0.09549408406019211,
0.45353248715400696,
0.234478160738945,
0.11377424746751785,
-0.40130919218063354,
0.11458387970924377,
0.5147398710250854,
-0.38881808519363403,
-0.5417160987854004,
0.37668099999427795,
0.04529530555009842,
-0.2833372950553894,
0.3526143729686737,
-0.5123013854026794,
-0.37678080797195435,
0.37026000022888184,
0.44858992099761963,
0.45725810527801514,
-0.16038650274276733,
0.3365463316440582,
-0.011751655489206314,
0.39406585693359375,
0.1274230182170868,
0.26013612747192383,
-0.32908323407173157,
-0.9532942771911621,
0.08402119576931,
-0.4304557740688324,
-0.12788809835910797,
0.4018195867538452,
-0.5855361223220825,
0.26271891593933105,
-0.3582867681980133,
-0.04490526393055916,
0.05721038579940796,
0.03090483881533146,
-0.42528000473976135,
0.12760815024375916,
-0.05279261991381645,
0.4464026987552643,
-1.105924367904663,
0.7812538146972656,
1.0981857776641846,
-0.04197491332888603,
-0.4117293953895569,
-0.3164691627025604,
0.16342371702194214,
-0.7635027170181274,
0.2347419410943985,
-0.1828387975692749,
-0.0574699342250824,
0.15621010959148407,
-0.05369142070412636,
-0.9760168790817261,
0.8669000864028931,
-0.12772440910339355,
-0.33524471521377563,
0.2725319266319275,
0.03370346128940582,
0.8375036716461182,
-0.0321536660194397,
-0.0778987929224968,
0.2135668843984604,
0.3534729480743408,
0.05228559672832489,
-0.8872053027153015,
-0.11773251742124557,
-0.5248653888702393,
-0.1426936835050583,
0.3721529245376587,
-0.2705695331096649,
0.858575701713562,
0.023456402122974396,
-0.6219088435173035,
0.1354919672012329,
0.3907105624675751,
-0.15023556351661682,
0.597909688949585,
0.5661078095436096,
0.7407748103141785,
0.8308862447738647,
-0.01329237874597311,
0.7905760407447815,
0.023773271590471268,
0.2948433458805084,
1.061252474784851,
-0.3581802248954773,
0.6393520832061768,
0.6464531421661377,
-0.3722839951515198,
0.3680505156517029,
0.5216036438941956,
0.06702528148889542,
0.7075517177581787,
0.08529981225728989,
-0.5987368822097778,
-0.10181678831577301,
-0.27140527963638306,
-0.45536667108535767,
0.6050552725791931,
0.5642135143280029,
-0.1527983844280243,
-0.471233606338501,
0.17864669859409332,
0.08557165414094925,
-0.0988842323422432,
0.06993206590414047,
0.9010708332061768,
0.24132002890110016,
-0.6374768018722534,
0.5456801652908325,
0.06398280709981918,
0.43163779377937317,
-0.847590446472168,
-0.11666279286146164,
-0.5714590549468994,
0.1750156134366989,
-0.25281110405921936,
-0.7197164297103882,
0.31043896079063416,
-0.007734534330666065,
-0.03691353648900986,
-0.05326927453279495,
0.50776606798172,
-0.30014461278915405,
-0.7286502122879028,
0.31959766149520874,
0.6179186105728149,
0.46434029936790466,
-0.03573432192206383,
-0.22108885645866394,
-0.23688708245754242,
-0.14983023703098297,
0.29065021872520447,
0.43309083580970764,
0.42385634779930115,
-0.30728796124458313,
0.5650851726531982,
0.5107885599136353,
0.4150896668434143,
0.1122862845659256,
-0.010040412656962872,
0.8092651963233948,
-0.1170862540602684,
-0.7980583906173706,
-0.567298173904419,
0.24074718356132507,
-0.035855796188116074,
-0.5227773785591125,
1.2517484426498413,
0.6960158944129944,
0.9024612307548523,
-0.011502091772854328,
0.9652569890022278,
-0.35809895396232605,
0.6758663654327393,
-0.16923834383487701,
1.0260369777679443,
-0.7848747372627258,
0.1963401883840561,
-0.5204505324363708,
-0.9565214514732361,
-0.33357319235801697,
0.6331092119216919,
0.03267001360654831,
-0.3982931077480316,
0.7925170660018921,
0.8045715689659119,
-0.07277548313140869,
-0.35103633999824524,
0.6366482973098755,
0.25446224212646484,
-0.11887553334236145,
0.14005780220031738,
0.8615342974662781,
-0.24271582067012787,
0.14781726896762848,
-0.4832819402217865,
-0.29451784491539,
-0.07786179333925247,
-0.6208177208900452,
-0.45119524002075195,
-1.0257835388183594,
-0.3669435381889343,
-0.19416484236717224,
0.045902758836746216,
0.4635413587093353,
0.41588959097862244,
-0.9213073253631592,
-0.2840811014175415,
-0.3082604706287384,
0.28837311267852783,
-0.5817875266075134,
-0.188398078083992,
0.10525808483362198,
-0.02600724995136261,
-0.6877524256706238,
0.6769981980323792,
0.10993540287017822,
0.12543907761573792,
-0.2497079074382782,
0.03493799269199371,
-0.2216854840517044,
-0.20981526374816895,
0.5265761613845825,
0.3720667064189911,
-0.48663491010665894,
-0.2614459693431854,
0.11165866255760193,
0.2825043499469757,
-0.2169487476348877,
0.5387601256370544,
-0.7915858626365662,
0.777759850025177,
0.6571952700614929,
0.14271149039268494,
0.27831247448921204,
0.010706961154937744,
0.28528159856796265,
-0.9093157649040222,
0.325219064950943,
0.0892273336648941,
0.5759813189506531,
0.1908310502767563,
-0.35533803701400757,
0.33883190155029297,
0.8286874294281006,
-0.18842343986034393,
-1.0530719757080078,
0.011400701478123665,
-0.9244514107704163,
-0.26631131768226624,
1.3865416049957275,
-0.22314055263996124,
0.0746827945113182,
-0.5522014498710632,
0.09387318789958954,
0.09295608103275299,
-0.3549175262451172,
0.8117737174034119,
0.9075456857681274,
-0.09446271508932114,
0.04194246605038643,
-0.3478773832321167,
0.2943238317966461,
0.26158076524734497,
-0.5095894932746887,
-0.21895207464694977,
0.7262986302375793,
0.270011842250824,
0.5228222608566284,
0.7362743020057678,
0.005599557887762785,
0.11218427121639252,
0.13793829083442688,
-0.17283807694911957,
-0.1725710928440094,
-0.3811728060245514,
-0.4698045253753662,
-0.06895744055509567,
0.0008902006084099412,
-0.6090545654296875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00654v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00654v1
|
Enhancing Zero-shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis with Human Feedback
| 2024-06-02T07:54:33
| 2024-06-02T07:54:33
|
Chen Chen, Yuchen Hu, Wen Wu, Helin Wang, Eng Siong Chng, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In recent years, text-to-speech (TTS) technology has witnessed impressive
advancements, particularly with large-scale training datasets, showcasing
human-level speech quality and impressive zero-shot capabilities on unseen
speakers. However, despite human subjective evaluations, such as the mean
opinion score (MOS), remaining the gold standard for assessing the quality of
synthetic speech, even state-of-the-art TTS approaches have kept human feedback
isolated from training that resulted in mismatched training objectives and
evaluation metrics. In this work, we investigate a novel topic of integrating
subjective human evaluation into the TTS training loop. Inspired by the recent
success of reinforcement learning from human feedback, we propose a
comprehensive sampling-annotating-learning framework tailored to TTS
optimization, namely uncertainty-aware optimization (UNO). Specifically, UNO
eliminates the need for a reward model or preference data by directly
maximizing the utility of speech generations while considering the uncertainty
that lies in the inherent variability in subjective human speech perception and
evaluations. Experimental results of both subjective and objective evaluations
demonstrate that UNO considerably improves the zero-shot performance of TTS
models in terms of MOS, word error rate, and speaker similarity. Additionally,
we present a remarkable ability of UNO that it can adapt to the desired
speaking style in emotional TTS seamlessly and flexibly.
|
[
-0.5187650918960571,
-0.61197829246521,
0.49892905354499817,
0.05857579782605171,
-0.4977809190750122,
0.31824061274528503,
-0.4839906394481659,
-0.3193955719470978,
0.17696481943130493,
0.07300566136837006,
-0.6093026399612427,
-0.5214325189590454,
-0.177969828248024,
0.31851065158843994,
-0.13591772317886353,
1.2340188026428223,
0.21330249309539795,
-0.002417172770947218,
0.06691263616085052,
0.0037615832407027483,
-0.24646851420402527,
-0.6163497567176819,
-0.656724750995636,
-0.31926047801971436,
0.48970550298690796,
0.5281574726104736,
0.362337201833725,
0.4507840573787689,
-0.2989744246006012,
0.21176683902740479,
0.09891638904809952,
0.06717973202466965,
-0.40101853013038635,
0.21868857741355896,
-0.30368393659591675,
-0.31046295166015625,
-0.46753281354904175,
0.07120680809020996,
0.5628140568733215,
0.5480733513832092,
-0.17990998923778534,
0.0824885219335556,
0.1390630155801773,
0.5248559713363647,
-0.6754187941551208,
-0.1383904069662094,
-0.5500993728637695,
0.27285072207450867,
0.012010510079562664,
-0.4705062806606293,
-0.4196285903453827,
-0.29834723472595215,
0.5357764363288879,
-0.684758186340332,
0.24335013329982758,
-0.14611251652240753,
0.38968124985694885,
0.46506455540657043,
-0.11331760138273239,
0.07019422203302383,
-1.084413766860962,
0.9123622179031372,
-0.7387701272964478,
0.5617154836654663,
0.24716752767562866,
0.1758287250995636,
0.04255693778395653,
-0.08736275136470795,
-0.545228123664856,
-0.3113626539707184,
0.47965139150619507,
0.4133281707763672,
-0.28367123007774353,
0.3653264343738556,
-0.3510151207447052,
0.039426933974027634,
-0.2820805609226227,
0.11385675519704819,
-0.29664644598960876,
-0.4197846055030823,
0.6242353916168213,
-0.14544792473316193,
-0.06228010356426239,
-0.2611762285232544,
-0.13592682778835297,
-0.23471315205097198,
-0.2090729922056198,
0.1260412633419037,
0.5700342655181885,
0.6136330962181091,
-0.13075768947601318,
0.4851418733596802,
-0.53846675157547,
0.733328640460968,
0.13229447603225708,
-0.0040222639217972755,
0.414166122674942,
-0.08518346399068832,
-0.19432252645492554,
0.15897604823112488,
1.0370218753814697,
0.4931308329105377,
0.14229677617549896,
-0.4908471405506134,
-0.18949531018733978,
0.19601696729660034,
0.4929184913635254,
-0.5957239866256714,
0.13631147146224976,
0.3767915666103363,
-0.003515691729262471,
-0.5449903011322021,
0.18138118088245392,
-1.0514042377471924,
-0.23153220117092133,
-0.5385195016860962,
0.4827492833137512,
-0.3679962754249573,
-0.24426224827766418,
0.14797091484069824,
-0.23688900470733643,
-0.2251298725605011,
0.3568996787071228,
-0.7905517816543579,
0.13519155979156494,
0.38369303941726685,
0.5981466770172119,
-0.08379337936639786,
-0.22705481946468353,
-0.7798960208892822,
-0.013984199613332748,
-0.5916107892990112,
0.8213799595832825,
-0.32617443799972534,
-0.6504467129707336,
-0.17958956956863403,
-0.6787446737289429,
0.37642529606819153,
-0.38153067231178284,
0.6657534241676331,
0.20729631185531616,
0.4028674066066742,
-0.07221213728189468,
-0.3113272190093994,
0.08329813927412033,
0.10750101506710052,
-0.0649302750825882,
0.9891976118087769,
0.2596427798271179,
-0.41458576917648315,
0.3645264804363251,
-0.6966995000839233,
-0.42592915892601013,
-0.08460861444473267,
-0.2046722173690796,
-0.31096580624580383,
0.5168033242225647,
0.22924666106700897,
0.22546738386154175,
-0.26484259963035583,
0.1584918051958084,
-0.3173404037952423,
-0.3820731043815613,
0.4927217662334442,
-0.578173816204071,
0.07109906524419785,
0.30592310428619385,
-0.6035767197608948,
0.2954390347003937,
-0.8146079778671265,
0.46332865953445435,
-0.24820147454738617,
-0.21924063563346863,
-0.15097132325172424,
-0.051227420568466187,
-0.004043928813189268,
0.08304872363805771,
-0.16864052414894104,
-0.6930921673774719,
-0.036356911063194275,
-0.7952120304107666,
0.5182936787605286,
0.7666719555854797,
0.2858491539955139,
0.5348465442657471,
-0.2650001645088196,
0.5190764665603638,
-0.1895761638879776,
0.21820439398288727,
0.11368526518344879,
-0.29165634512901306,
-0.7512147426605225,
-0.0889241099357605,
0.37190037965774536,
0.488135427236557,
-0.8988097906112671,
0.6041290163993835,
-0.2599922716617584,
-0.5779509544372559,
-0.8845629096031189,
-0.09993860125541687,
0.5411727428436279,
0.5213125348091125,
0.4074240028858185,
-0.6582468152046204,
-0.6980623006820679,
-0.6338294148445129,
-0.3275744915008545,
-0.575516939163208,
-0.4675208628177643,
0.12261682003736496,
0.058539051562547684,
0.017038101330399513,
1.382948398590088,
-0.28734925389289856,
-0.356481671333313,
-0.17281858623027802,
0.5640832781791687,
-0.18103468418121338,
0.3236583173274994,
0.37353289127349854,
-0.23099341988563538,
-0.12942224740982056,
-0.08400507271289825,
-0.2943617105484009,
-0.29016995429992676,
-0.28946325182914734,
-0.12750118970870972,
0.3217836320400238,
0.1608811765909195,
-0.22200290858745575,
0.5356210470199585,
0.2216263860464096,
-0.03658311814069748,
0.6951971054077148,
-0.2614966034889221,
0.29477283358573914,
-0.8332564234733582,
0.0010313758393749595,
0.2231106013059616,
-0.26508551836013794,
-0.6014852523803711,
-0.4365214705467224,
-0.5319789052009583,
-0.09614884108304977,
-0.5432596802711487,
0.5643950700759888,
-0.15173682570457458,
-0.20193293690681458,
-0.26315778493881226,
0.3388274013996124,
-0.03890366852283478,
0.7763373255729675,
0.11875678598880768,
0.7929767966270447,
0.4577418565750122,
-0.5646205544471741,
0.17531026899814606,
0.14239148795604706,
-0.120510034263134,
0.9523409008979797,
-0.6974719166755676,
0.4774721562862396,
-0.16491742432117462,
0.2434234619140625,
-0.6916502714157104,
-0.3373466432094574,
0.29941558837890625,
-0.9680823683738708,
0.19475577771663666,
0.053975481539964676,
-0.23026692867279053,
-0.18370699882507324,
-0.5527787208557129,
0.08784652501344681,
0.5468370318412781,
-0.18129877746105194,
0.45865508913993835,
0.3094521462917328,
-0.1805202215909958,
-0.4514506161212921,
-0.6283453702926636,
0.21407152712345123,
-0.036380331963300705,
-0.05518345162272453,
0.32203176617622375,
-0.1978616714477539,
-0.013750125654041767,
-0.1343514621257782,
-0.25181037187576294,
0.04024083539843559,
-0.051543112844228745,
0.1966623067855835,
0.2185939997434616,
0.25281521677970886,
0.06422454118728638,
0.23105262219905853,
-0.3299885094165802,
-0.10104123502969742,
-0.5945165157318115,
0.2065320611000061,
-0.1188027560710907,
-0.20878401398658752,
-0.8558545708656311,
0.3324587345123291,
0.5102485418319702,
0.012106714770197868,
0.07538050413131714,
0.6303883194923401,
-0.19538110494613647,
-0.39138320088386536,
-0.3652838170528412,
-0.22700537741184235,
-0.4287465214729309,
0.50785893201828,
-0.09256964921951294,
-0.923934280872345,
-0.09019812196493149,
0.0400884747505188,
0.052687570452690125,
0.1977989375591278,
0.6388459801673889,
-0.2806532680988312,
0.997098445892334,
0.37605711817741394,
-0.221732959151268,
0.7230722308158875,
-0.18117299675941467,
0.04664333164691925,
-0.7596240639686584,
-0.07089938223361969,
-0.5594322085380554,
-0.3348247706890106,
-0.4378977119922638,
-0.4653874635696411,
0.5777486562728882,
-0.20820051431655884,
-0.43238988518714905,
0.035383664071559906,
-0.8625423908233643,
0.3276081681251526,
0.8639454245567322,
0.3865385949611664,
0.04262402281165123,
0.19944627583026886,
-0.12396935373544693,
-0.248790442943573,
-0.5386411547660828,
-0.3268243372440338,
1.176706314086914,
0.05495692789554596,
0.48378992080688477,
-0.2820190191268921,
0.9476046562194824,
0.4027632474899292,
0.21860291063785553,
-0.8535906076431274,
0.4589693248271942,
-0.08177078515291214,
-0.42714923620224,
-0.5069103240966797,
-0.7140993475914001,
-0.6618677973747253,
0.006340266205370426,
-0.39536958932876587,
-0.9963327646255493,
0.03570624813437462,
0.23784443736076355,
-0.8336524367332458,
0.24869847297668457,
-0.8117022514343262,
0.5376974940299988,
-0.24005654454231262,
-0.4552485942840576,
-0.12153805047273636,
-0.8511049747467041,
-0.17441126704216003,
0.12810055911540985,
0.2631146311759949,
-0.09314552694559097,
0.07723619043827057,
0.7501742839813232,
-0.2686309218406677,
0.978712797164917,
-0.2712928056716919,
0.08571905642747879,
0.48563534021377563,
0.10784445703029633,
-0.015413641929626465,
-0.011714648455381393,
-0.13016247749328613,
0.10444233566522598,
-0.2057383954524994,
-0.15964387357234955,
-0.7598512172698975,
0.34256991744041443,
-1.031785249710083,
-0.31517279148101807,
-0.2896505296230316,
-0.3846253454685211,
-0.7884291410446167,
-0.0250413678586483,
0.5170060992240906,
0.4845179319381714,
-0.31950297951698303,
0.12394188344478607,
0.3609873056411743,
-0.31142938137054443,
0.3513619005680084,
0.26918789744377136,
-0.1382678896188736,
-0.9844593405723572,
1.0397082567214966,
-0.05561013147234917,
0.40767788887023926,
0.49949681758880615,
0.3402682840824127,
-0.4720161259174347,
-0.47352972626686096,
-0.5901646614074707,
0.085048608481884,
-0.26953819394111633,
-0.2920970022678375,
-0.27698904275894165,
0.009703942574560642,
-0.2990526258945465,
-0.30316510796546936,
-0.6688570976257324,
-0.5879136919975281,
-0.6101346015930176,
-0.3129994571208954,
0.16575273871421814,
0.5324485898017883,
-0.31859123706817627,
0.46960586309432983,
-0.7232322096824646,
0.30255094170570374,
0.3958076536655426,
0.6282640099525452,
0.011755360290408134,
-0.5944745540618896,
-0.14725060760974884,
0.4504311680793762,
-0.4902631640434265,
-0.9007114171981812,
0.42581602931022644,
0.22721637785434723,
0.2137535661458969,
0.26411983370780945,
0.2933654189109802,
0.6762349009513855,
-0.42263516783714294,
0.9060115218162537,
0.5187567472457886,
-1.3316377401351929,
0.6891458034515381,
-0.2889021933078766,
0.3801334500312805,
0.782930850982666,
-0.14276356995105743,
-0.5332612991333008,
-0.6090191006660461,
-0.5837469100952148,
-0.7847009301185608,
0.8520315289497375,
0.5032822489738464,
0.11613056808710098,
0.20610149204730988,
0.47605255246162415,
0.12660691142082214,
0.40943583846092224,
-0.4977017343044281,
-0.1667572259902954,
-0.4917965829372406,
-0.2566829025745392,
-0.07876822352409363,
-0.10145703703165054,
-0.04271881654858589,
-0.3595605492591858,
0.8852999210357666,
-0.1410120278596878,
0.4406837522983551,
0.38862574100494385,
0.2629311680793762,
-0.3104022443294525,
0.7170991897583008,
0.5657384395599365,
0.3076552152633667,
-0.4079352617263794,
0.031361620873212814,
0.057190656661987305,
-0.20401006937026978,
0.3495102524757385,
-0.05139203742146492,
-0.2269202172756195,
0.2748663127422333,
-0.0101141557097435,
1.1368683576583862,
0.2866595983505249,
-0.6154804229736328,
0.3740979731082916,
-0.026461701840162277,
-0.29407447576522827,
-0.07992379367351532,
0.09389810264110565,
-0.37253931164741516,
0.0855703055858612,
0.5503462553024292,
0.3998751938343048,
0.18106994032859802,
-0.4368034303188324,
0.1899126023054123,
0.174104243516922,
-0.6906218528747559,
-0.610185980796814,
0.8825209736824036,
0.4880582392215729,
-0.6647591590881348,
0.2995039224624634,
-0.4558688998222351,
-0.5186962485313416,
0.07949917018413544,
0.12166503816843033,
1.3318437337875366,
-0.43541356921195984,
0.5718594789505005,
0.41320887207984924,
0.2781449854373932,
0.17429699003696442,
0.3206731081008911,
-0.39966943860054016,
-0.41029033064842224,
-0.45519205927848816,
-0.5274280905723572,
-0.8180592060089111,
-0.18513576686382294,
-0.7196447849273682,
0.3885614275932312,
-0.472164511680603,
-0.5665167570114136,
-0.10420151054859161,
-0.2624005675315857,
-0.4737790524959564,
0.5014602541923523,
0.2740881145000458,
0.3034440875053406,
-0.47876662015914917,
0.5964440703392029,
0.47584837675094604,
-0.38714611530303955,
-0.7513523697853088,
0.08907987922430038,
0.11504638195037842,
-0.4146806299686432,
0.04404927417635918,
0.04947168007493019,
-0.3461005389690399,
0.04034670442342758,
-0.4681612551212311,
-0.46255823969841003,
0.7245389223098755,
0.7676180005073547,
-0.4887009561061859,
0.034343425184488297,
0.37093210220336914,
0.8004597425460815,
-0.12195979058742523,
0.42948830127716064,
0.5199775695800781,
0.18858279287815094,
0.19026149809360504,
-1.0470274686813354,
-0.36839917302131653,
0.013699212111532688,
0.22487036883831024,
0.015715891495347023,
-0.43103888630867004,
0.2494696080684662,
-0.3195999264717102,
-0.11396236717700958,
0.022661752998828888,
0.8498460650444031,
0.2497244030237198,
0.33013057708740234,
0.6883544921875,
0.42306920886039734,
0.4930208623409271,
-0.10887165367603302,
1.0082449913024902,
0.0031828617211431265,
0.3381475806236267,
1.2902089357376099,
-0.13433308899402618,
0.9426515102386475,
0.5293054580688477,
-0.3481942117214203,
0.2732463777065277,
0.5215063691139221,
0.47411537170410156,
0.6048631072044373,
0.26354238390922546,
-0.46574920415878296,
-0.2589404284954071,
-0.2693902552127838,
-0.20430979132652283,
0.5322508811950684,
0.05765698477625847,
-0.08341290801763535,
-0.1640281081199646,
0.04041633754968643,
-0.17152471840381622,
-0.04765087366104126,
-0.052310843020677567,
0.958052396774292,
-0.09201330691576004,
-0.7483818531036377,
0.619111955165863,
-0.07373664528131485,
0.7777793407440186,
-0.6270614862442017,
0.06807409971952438,
-0.09415410459041595,
-0.11225622147321701,
-0.14228960871696472,
-0.6168566942214966,
0.24185526371002197,
0.3147028386592865,
-0.10184776782989502,
-0.32266202569007874,
0.22999164462089539,
-0.4813506603240967,
-0.2970738708972931,
0.11943232268095016,
0.35088586807250977,
0.06784915179014206,
-0.2807316482067108,
-0.4397500455379486,
0.0892229825258255,
0.28534674644470215,
-0.1701025366783142,
0.2269294410943985,
0.4369015395641327,
0.2743147611618042,
0.4643496870994568,
0.7217710018157959,
0.19266116619110107,
-0.20828573405742645,
0.30996474623680115,
0.6300936937332153,
-0.5739982724189758,
-0.6789345145225525,
-0.7717130184173584,
0.6625872254371643,
-0.014527428895235062,
-0.5299844741821289,
0.3350031077861786,
0.39972636103630066,
0.8694725632667542,
0.00665621180087328,
1.2149276733398438,
0.1621936857700348,
0.7198106646537781,
-0.15164439380168915,
0.5810836553573608,
-0.4297763407230377,
0.12355209141969681,
-0.7574081420898438,
-0.8548990488052368,
-0.23086650669574738,
0.5814340114593506,
-0.1298675686120987,
-0.02519039437174797,
0.4279024302959442,
0.5421725511550903,
0.4565739631652832,
0.14498263597488403,
0.5067707300186157,
0.11689066141843796,
0.32473406195640564,
0.518160879611969,
0.7721111178398132,
-0.27802038192749023,
0.7080038189888,
-0.3587937355041504,
-0.3959539234638214,
-0.11106095463037491,
-0.8972934484481812,
-0.44580769538879395,
-0.7020731568336487,
-0.46324729919433594,
-0.24995464086532593,
0.13497045636177063,
1.2246642112731934,
0.8434298038482666,
-0.7012004852294922,
-0.30826500058174133,
-0.12787997722625732,
-0.11598922312259674,
-0.13730721175670624,
-0.2511814534664154,
-0.06378527730703354,
-0.2669866979122162,
-0.9206249117851257,
0.43260329961776733,
0.6282910704612732,
0.26244691014289856,
-0.1748797744512558,
-0.17048503458499908,
0.27368131279945374,
0.2957783639431,
0.479391872882843,
0.38077667355537415,
-0.7929476499557495,
-0.45508813858032227,
-0.0555698536336422,
0.24435928463935852,
0.10246185958385468,
0.6961190700531006,
-0.977203905582428,
1.0536706447601318,
0.13213302195072174,
0.6212599873542786,
0.41578009724617004,
0.06234286352992058,
0.7535287737846375,
-1.156633734703064,
0.2716902494430542,
0.5113670229911804,
0.10455577820539474,
0.5761188864707947,
-0.1065128818154335,
0.43221667408943176,
0.23464979231357574,
-0.4003351926803589,
-0.8488466739654541,
0.04403698816895485,
-1.2370517253875732,
-0.044313862919807434,
1.1352614164352417,
0.1750691533088684,
-0.181475430727005,
0.03877222165465355,
-0.4781681299209595,
0.5313473343849182,
-0.833048403263092,
1.0416659116744995,
0.5155786275863647,
-0.23509536683559418,
0.11786149442195892,
-0.3072696924209595,
0.3458282947540283,
0.584256112575531,
-0.9729193449020386,
-0.014004910364747047,
0.6772087812423706,
0.11176436394453049,
0.050054676830768585,
0.6499325633049011,
0.07381091266870499,
0.3512670695781708,
-0.20159265398979187,
0.3057379424571991,
-0.02563546970486641,
-0.22679473459720612,
-0.3560171127319336,
-0.06271225959062576,
0.004591725766658783,
-0.4605099856853485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06559v1
|
Harnessing Business and Media Insights with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:24:38
| 2024-06-02T06:24:38
|
Yujia Bao, Ankit Parag Shah, Neeru Narang, Jonathan Rivers, Rajeev Maksey, Lan Guan, Louise N. Barrere, Shelley Evenson, Rahul Basole, Connie Miao, Ankit Mehta, Fabien Boulay, Su Min Park, Natalie E. Pearson, Eldhose Joy, Tiger He, Sumiran Thakur, Koustav Ghosal, Josh On, Phoebe Morrison, Tim Major, Eva Siqi Wang, Gina Escobar, Jiaheng Wei, Tharindu Cyril Weerasooriya, Queena Song, Daria Lashkevich, Clare Chen, Gyuhak Kim, Dengpan Yin, Don Hejna, Mo Nomeli, Wei Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Fortune Analytics Language Model (FALM). FALM empowers
users with direct access to comprehensive business analysis, including market
trends, company performance metrics, and expert insights. Unlike generic LLMs,
FALM leverages a curated knowledge base built from professional journalism,
enabling it to deliver precise and in-depth answers to intricate business
questions. Users can further leverage natural language queries to directly
visualize financial data, generating insightful charts and graphs to understand
trends across diverse business sectors clearly. FALM fosters user trust and
ensures output accuracy through three novel methods: 1) Time-aware reasoning
guarantees accurate event registration and prioritizes recent updates. 2)
Thematic trend analysis explicitly examines topic evolution over time,
providing insights into emerging business landscapes. 3) Content referencing
and task decomposition enhance answer fidelity and data visualization accuracy.
We conduct both automated and human evaluations, demonstrating FALM's
significant performance improvements over baseline methods while prioritizing
responsible AI practices. These benchmarks establish FALM as a cutting-edge LLM
in the business and media domains, with exceptional accuracy and
trustworthiness.
|
[
-0.041420310735702515,
-0.8649071455001831,
0.5331215858459473,
0.3355025351047516,
-0.42003318667411804,
0.534916877746582,
-0.05198271572589874,
-0.4923073649406433,
0.3173874616622925,
0.8379453420639038,
-0.7439075112342834,
-0.6197339296340942,
-0.5434909462928772,
-0.18878760933876038,
-0.4331044852733612,
1.1819933652877808,
0.34924110770225525,
0.016062172129750252,
-0.14824138581752777,
-0.32861584424972534,
-0.180442214012146,
-0.6164247989654541,
-0.7705536484718323,
-0.09384924173355103,
0.29706817865371704,
0.2290162295103073,
1.0664042234420776,
0.4421140253543854,
0.4696136713027954,
0.2650816738605499,
0.23864571750164032,
0.5699412226676941,
-0.7202394604682922,
-0.026596883311867714,
-0.20666807889938354,
-0.2443220317363739,
-0.741087019443512,
0.16229012608528137,
0.3903999328613281,
0.8376577496528625,
-0.1558620184659958,
0.3982802927494049,
-0.12087886035442352,
0.9677873849868774,
-0.17516882717609406,
0.5399743318557739,
-0.8543937802314758,
-0.2992907464504242,
-0.15347756445407867,
-0.28215575218200684,
-0.4163230061531067,
-0.497132807970047,
0.3516235947608948,
-0.5120825171470642,
-0.12769299745559692,
0.5911732912063599,
0.846582293510437,
0.27375417947769165,
-0.6077604293823242,
-0.41992688179016113,
-0.7356541752815247,
0.8601171374320984,
-0.30491113662719727,
0.6696557998657227,
0.33073171973228455,
0.34592312574386597,
0.09895040094852448,
-0.6727243065834045,
-0.25844764709472656,
-0.23418277502059937,
-0.04363667964935303,
-0.1114930510520935,
-0.5206068754196167,
-0.2877555787563324,
-0.012325230985879898,
0.3537960648536682,
-0.3920760452747345,
-0.15218421816825867,
-0.247456893324852,
-0.15747641026973724,
1.1141632795333862,
0.41493186354637146,
-0.006230098195374012,
0.1662469208240509,
-0.13181670010089874,
0.21097902953624725,
-0.6166693568229675,
-0.2298600822687149,
0.1910858452320099,
0.22892700135707855,
-0.13688041269779205,
0.37693920731544495,
-0.23121580481529236,
0.7596637010574341,
-0.008680437691509724,
-0.188520610332489,
0.14060312509536743,
-0.36462920904159546,
-0.4692395031452179,
-0.03349291533231735,
0.676479160785675,
0.5225039124488831,
0.31675854325294495,
-0.47700202465057373,
-0.05539002642035484,
-0.3648924231529236,
0.1705455183982849,
-0.6885068416595459,
-0.3652259111404419,
0.34019070863723755,
-0.6943046450614929,
-0.14846450090408325,
0.12521983683109283,
-1.006492257118225,
-0.8883075714111328,
-0.5253605246543884,
0.32300373911857605,
-0.25209906697273254,
-0.13318048417568207,
0.13753367960453033,
0.06126227602362633,
0.4278146028518677,
0.5761687755584717,
-0.6360768675804138,
0.1531166285276413,
0.7701613903045654,
0.8879477381706238,
-0.3343800902366638,
0.024565255269408226,
-0.8528570532798767,
0.307465523481369,
-0.6642389893531799,
0.449863076210022,
-0.27548086643218994,
-0.31773829460144043,
0.1408659815788269,
-0.26903235912323,
0.28307101130485535,
-0.35453808307647705,
0.19620908796787262,
-0.8293185234069824,
0.14488014578819275,
-0.26073157787323,
-0.6197676658630371,
-0.3605293333530426,
0.07725696265697479,
-0.8712502121925354,
0.6764363050460815,
0.021803051233291626,
-0.6038281917572021,
0.7262802720069885,
-0.9944329857826233,
-0.4301336407661438,
0.21879558265209198,
-0.17495782673358917,
-0.224564790725708,
0.07947571575641632,
0.3414784371852875,
0.6720228791236877,
-0.5801703333854675,
0.5459316372871399,
-0.18475289642810822,
0.20421093702316284,
0.406241238117218,
-0.4404453933238983,
0.8500619530677795,
0.5068612694740295,
-0.22273850440979004,
0.26648688316345215,
-0.8572025895118713,
-0.15477387607097626,
0.3163687586784363,
-0.1302196979522705,
-0.4128296375274658,
0.19084501266479492,
0.17353381216526031,
-0.13308699429035187,
0.48843660950660706,
-0.28767821192741394,
0.08065518736839294,
-0.2258644700050354,
0.4018344581127167,
0.5753360390663147,
0.10002588480710983,
0.3648342788219452,
-0.23734503984451294,
0.39417681097984314,
-0.2938768267631531,
0.18152491748332977,
-0.18450534343719482,
-0.3363162875175476,
-0.6505727767944336,
-0.2664825916290283,
0.05823173001408577,
0.5201242566108704,
-0.5241596102714539,
0.42667320370674133,
-0.6891462802886963,
-0.763892650604248,
-0.5744468569755554,
0.3185845911502838,
-0.18756572902202606,
0.24535992741584778,
0.18305537104606628,
-0.07411648333072662,
-0.40351220965385437,
-1.0384994745254517,
-0.5776979327201843,
-0.10853671282529831,
-0.11599689722061157,
0.3860013484954834,
0.17816388607025146,
-0.10047899931669235,
1.2482081651687622,
-0.906887948513031,
-0.258539617061615,
-0.661983847618103,
0.27416136860847473,
0.492997944355011,
-0.04459124431014061,
0.5198515057563782,
-1.1270101070404053,
-0.4729718565940857,
0.07896991074085236,
-0.5111679434776306,
-0.1901245266199112,
-0.4224458336830139,
-0.21330131590366364,
0.5445167422294617,
0.3118290901184082,
-0.37669840455055237,
0.34817710518836975,
0.4270741939544678,
-0.6679627299308777,
0.3541920781135559,
0.17182956635951996,
0.17813381552696228,
-1.038885235786438,
0.28373754024505615,
0.1718081682920456,
-0.3739877939224243,
-0.75094074010849,
-0.25983092188835144,
0.007209386210888624,
-0.24831008911132812,
-0.13597747683525085,
0.7738714218139648,
-0.33808305859565735,
-0.28687170147895813,
-0.13595101237297058,
0.07432951033115387,
0.21594402194023132,
0.19415171444416046,
0.01891344226896763,
0.8024305701255798,
0.3110015094280243,
-0.5314849615097046,
0.39739999175071716,
0.24263568222522736,
-0.7081559300422668,
0.3061222434043884,
-0.573205828666687,
0.1317373365163803,
0.022533677518367767,
0.03817053884267807,
-1.1238528490066528,
-0.18648402392864227,
-0.14089134335517883,
-0.5466291904449463,
0.16462989151477814,
0.2330700308084488,
-0.7538846731185913,
-0.17786727845668793,
-0.05527221038937569,
-0.3957363963127136,
0.5195013880729675,
-0.43543121218681335,
1.0763109922409058,
0.5873376727104187,
-0.1980358362197876,
-0.29450666904449463,
-0.8321671485900879,
0.1839969903230667,
-0.31452471017837524,
-0.9443200826644897,
0.08037421107292175,
-0.14821505546569824,
-0.7329431176185608,
-0.07880105823278427,
-0.4052870273590088,
-0.3174695372581482,
0.3351425230503082,
0.014882047660648823,
0.6566275954246521,
-0.16160136461257935,
-0.04551010951399803,
-0.3532448410987854,
0.08887085318565369,
0.22823414206504822,
-0.29308271408081055,
0.5512087345123291,
-0.19915607571601868,
-0.03608784079551697,
-0.4147549271583557,
0.2966868281364441,
1.1593942642211914,
-0.3501521646976471,
0.931367039680481,
0.3746345639228821,
-0.21209195256233215,
-0.11062227189540863,
-0.8615726232528687,
0.05276402458548546,
-0.5062714219093323,
0.2925659716129303,
-0.09924961626529694,
-0.7984102368354797,
0.637084424495697,
0.10932444781064987,
0.4656113088130951,
0.5105679035186768,
0.7334499955177307,
0.23966358602046967,
0.9703052639961243,
0.9357302784919739,
-0.48078393936157227,
0.3934638798236847,
-0.1865154355764389,
0.5397199392318726,
0.03334379941225052,
-0.437568336725235,
-0.4023681879043579,
0.014439360238611698,
-0.17817682027816772,
-0.2848799228668213,
0.2198210209608078,
-0.28445079922676086,
-0.25790899991989136,
-0.15072283148765564,
-0.07575786113739014,
0.42631039023399353,
0.5448376536369324,
-0.3458985984325409,
0.5383421778678894,
0.1023862212896347,
0.3264051079750061,
-0.212464839220047,
-0.3679726719856262,
-0.5047677755355835,
0.9147647619247437,
0.4859005808830261,
1.1938390731811523,
0.1996326595544815,
0.3069324791431427,
0.6719754934310913,
0.4726200997829437,
-0.8720124959945679,
0.4175058901309967,
-0.2975603938102722,
-0.822742760181427,
-0.28674477338790894,
-0.3290269672870636,
-0.4313572347164154,
0.1844826340675354,
-0.09763224422931671,
-0.8038244247436523,
-0.07324464619159698,
0.1178661659359932,
-0.4639838933944702,
0.23230300843715668,
-0.7356406450271606,
0.6717289686203003,
-0.6022065877914429,
-0.6179213523864746,
-0.20848076045513153,
-0.4133407175540924,
0.2983008027076721,
-0.33475467562675476,
0.3648197054862976,
-0.08774465322494507,
-0.2798868417739868,
0.8301926255226135,
-0.3315444886684418,
0.7330784797668457,
0.08071161806583405,
-0.10489089787006378,
0.1714477688074112,
0.22995440661907196,
0.48197710514068604,
-0.03654924035072327,
-0.10538028925657272,
0.4445076882839203,
-0.3170408606529236,
-0.23646783828735352,
-0.7063589096069336,
0.5644585490226746,
-0.5982199311256409,
-0.6905922293663025,
-0.5119613409042358,
-0.7671455144882202,
-0.5704062581062317,
0.0975433960556984,
-0.11726698279380798,
0.2742167115211487,
-0.13010810315608978,
0.6029462814331055,
0.44912365078926086,
-0.2182847559452057,
0.2613445222377777,
0.992973804473877,
-0.5787009596824646,
-0.5461769700050354,
0.6672999262809753,
0.2932182848453522,
0.20821362733840942,
0.47152605652809143,
0.13944704830646515,
-0.684172511100769,
-0.5316035747528076,
-0.3203526437282562,
0.3677319586277008,
-0.6472660899162292,
-0.18189728260040283,
-0.7665925025939941,
-0.07006070017814636,
-0.48233503103256226,
-0.34844931960105896,
-0.25937163829803467,
-0.1096862331032753,
-0.060501907020807266,
-0.21410764753818512,
0.5592870116233826,
0.5616582036018372,
0.23425395786762238,
0.2044145166873932,
-0.8630268573760986,
0.15686221420764923,
0.23582036793231964,
0.30061236023902893,
0.10082411766052246,
-0.24978268146514893,
-0.4935591518878937,
-0.1350485235452652,
-0.16212260723114014,
-0.9864383339881897,
0.6954438090324402,
0.0793912410736084,
0.6153059005737305,
0.5057372450828552,
-0.11137912422418594,
0.7506681084632874,
-0.3350817561149597,
1.1309261322021484,
0.13497811555862427,
-1.253533124923706,
0.6699213981628418,
-0.5083299875259399,
0.08786121010780334,
0.6199851632118225,
0.7242702841758728,
-0.55572509765625,
-0.15290264785289764,
-0.632620096206665,
-0.9261313676834106,
0.7015140056610107,
-0.02909996174275875,
0.11844242364168167,
0.11832742393016815,
0.12772834300994873,
0.30495911836624146,
0.5923259258270264,
-0.6165685653686523,
-0.38971278071403503,
-0.06583113968372345,
-0.19142356514930725,
-0.1459713578224182,
-0.20183885097503662,
0.078530453145504,
-0.33316487073898315,
0.7091507315635681,
-0.11884886026382446,
-0.07371750473976135,
0.04384111613035202,
-0.02377026155591011,
-0.05960647761821747,
-0.1260737031698227,
0.27395281195640564,
1.218863844871521,
-0.14570613205432892,
-0.31487414240837097,
0.0353243425488472,
-0.3898155689239502,
-0.37489527463912964,
-0.0049607898108661175,
-0.019330298528075218,
0.11174987256526947,
0.34539735317230225,
0.7801955938339233,
0.04585403576493263,
-0.8887680172920227,
0.369640052318573,
0.05146518722176552,
-0.09924343973398209,
-0.4970150887966156,
-0.05300779268145561,
0.27701735496520996,
0.3166719079017639,
1.0316170454025269,
-0.4090428054332733,
0.2937938868999481,
-0.6632464528083801,
0.313556432723999,
0.5407752394676208,
-0.23592203855514526,
-0.03537749871611595,
0.9306074976921082,
0.37443506717681885,
-0.11969399452209473,
0.5876809358596802,
0.024956434965133667,
-0.4473850131034851,
0.6236082315444946,
0.43959173560142517,
0.8711583614349365,
-0.13739734888076782,
0.18301980197429657,
-0.15097159147262573,
0.4096633791923523,
0.17765596508979797,
0.3076566755771637,
0.17595534026622772,
-0.6995250582695007,
-0.7477540373802185,
-0.710067093372345,
-0.6619298458099365,
0.5835752487182617,
-0.5672956109046936,
0.2925017476081848,
-0.6065351963043213,
0.03985755145549774,
0.3731115758419037,
0.48097220063209534,
-0.7734537124633789,
0.19589319825172424,
0.12748277187347412,
1.2222212553024292,
-0.8432181477546692,
0.7916699051856995,
0.665958821773529,
-0.3948169946670532,
-0.7083675265312195,
0.12768857181072235,
0.35764211416244507,
-0.8850318193435669,
0.8411381840705872,
0.1294814944267273,
-0.2289329618215561,
0.0023669549264013767,
-0.7789959907531738,
-1.0125983953475952,
1.320304274559021,
0.22368481755256653,
-0.495745450258255,
0.24631723761558533,
-0.029710855334997177,
0.4026329517364502,
-0.7223350405693054,
-0.2519482672214508,
0.7579903602600098,
0.4163395166397095,
0.1775149703025818,
-0.6715775728225708,
-0.1860833317041397,
-0.020633995532989502,
-0.2912764251232147,
0.3389151692390442,
-0.8277668952941895,
0.554816484451294,
-0.07570549100637436,
-0.07995782792568207,
-0.28475984930992126,
0.8917726874351501,
-0.005978281609714031,
0.8636465668678284,
0.41489532589912415,
0.08736858516931534,
0.9250115156173706,
0.04809466004371643,
1.1871744394302368,
-0.518122673034668,
0.27689334750175476,
0.9964483380317688,
-0.4410794973373413,
0.6942138671875,
0.21829929947853088,
-0.20897720754146576,
0.3897993266582489,
0.41866374015808105,
-0.27417463064193726,
0.5127377510070801,
-0.0923820286989212,
0.06500096619129181,
-0.27423927187919617,
-0.15385077893733978,
0.08846455067396164,
0.6310771107673645,
0.5865659713745117,
-0.46166837215423584,
-0.06323911994695663,
-0.24077676236629486,
0.5152824521064758,
0.08517777174711227,
-0.5701441168785095,
0.5993448495864868,
-0.026988156139850616,
-0.45202961564064026,
0.11228784173727036,
-0.07138020545244217,
0.6664336323738098,
-0.9763893485069275,
0.25609782338142395,
-0.37318721413612366,
-0.025341195985674858,
-0.10773415118455887,
-0.6618126630783081,
0.7248885035514832,
0.17688943445682526,
-0.03216002136468887,
-0.18904133141040802,
0.7398970127105713,
-0.317070335149765,
-0.41495341062545776,
0.19671329855918884,
0.6590925455093384,
0.08310521394014359,
-0.18251150846481323,
-0.6583394408226013,
0.31710830330848694,
0.266390860080719,
-0.24130015075206757,
-0.008917237631976604,
0.3636127710342407,
0.03686467558145523,
0.9717188477516174,
0.6925219297409058,
-0.013281495310366154,
-0.0676582008600235,
-0.0229824036359787,
0.5642111897468567,
-0.7646094560623169,
-0.7868712544441223,
-1.1228139400482178,
0.4677993357181549,
-0.5744358897209167,
-0.29339292645454407,
0.8931251764297485,
0.7720005512237549,
0.2618792951107025,
-0.0644390881061554,
0.7957290410995483,
0.07932858169078827,
0.4024878144264221,
-0.5733651518821716,
1.0629092454910278,
-0.7387953400611877,
0.1863490492105484,
-0.1423698216676712,
-0.8028151392936707,
-0.4255947470664978,
0.4073854386806488,
-0.7151076197624207,
-0.1055273786187172,
0.47351768612861633,
0.571530282497406,
0.077646903693676,
0.2571715712547302,
0.515802264213562,
0.4050109386444092,
0.37391236424446106,
0.049985043704509735,
0.44512104988098145,
0.09934953600168228,
0.6325937509536743,
-0.0256675872951746,
-0.2554093301296234,
-0.5629698634147644,
-1.0749567747116089,
-0.8553177714347839,
-0.6945800185203552,
-0.5229270458221436,
-0.19957761466503143,
0.02488546632230282,
1.010300636291504,
0.7489421367645264,
-0.6367865800857544,
-0.29048973321914673,
0.2998412251472473,
-0.00870877131819725,
0.02462521567940712,
-0.3782942593097687,
0.4934549927711487,
-0.14681476354599,
-0.655197024345398,
0.24709708988666534,
0.5299872159957886,
-0.14554813504219055,
-0.6129608750343323,
0.1649591028690338,
0.05630218982696533,
0.5069130659103394,
0.8571929931640625,
-0.1149110198020935,
-0.7275495529174805,
-0.12256431579589844,
0.21781204640865326,
0.048121728003025055,
-0.23788529634475708,
0.9047836065292358,
-0.5874955654144287,
0.12128903716802597,
0.4587406814098358,
1.0214768648147583,
0.28367695212364197,
0.14693088829517365,
0.5070915818214417,
-0.4832128584384918,
-0.13963566720485687,
0.21006742119789124,
0.326961874961853,
0.44628027081489563,
-0.7375193238258362,
0.7370736002922058,
0.03599493205547333,
-0.5460293292999268,
-0.5174944996833801,
0.1605655401945114,
-1.0344619750976562,
-0.38116365671157837,
1.325722575187683,
0.15441741049289703,
-0.40413451194763184,
-0.29108569025993347,
-0.08266211301088333,
-0.14549914002418518,
-0.753455400466919,
0.691800057888031,
1.0902210474014282,
-0.12161769717931747,
0.007990725338459015,
-0.9098688364028931,
0.34550946950912476,
0.15326105058193207,
-0.7855977416038513,
0.29029226303100586,
0.8629447221755981,
0.4020507335662842,
0.25952744483947754,
0.8734075427055359,
-0.07299745827913284,
-0.03407816216349602,
-0.19013406336307526,
-0.3047557473182678,
-0.1769457906484604,
-0.3911087214946747,
-0.15782839059829712,
0.32606109976768494,
0.17488878965377808,
-0.17462539672851562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00628v1
|
Transforming Computer Security and Public Trust Through the Exploration of Fine-Tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T06:10:31
| 2024-06-02T06:10:31
|
Garrett Crumrine, Izzat Alsmadi, Jesus Guerrero, Yuvaraj Munian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CY, cs.LG, B.8.0; I.2.7; I.2.8; I.2.11; J.0; K.4.2; K.4.1
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized how we interact with
machines. However, this technological advancement has been paralleled by the
emergence of "Mallas," malicious services operating underground that exploit
LLMs for nefarious purposes. Such services create malware, phishing attacks,
and deceptive websites, escalating the cyber security threats landscape. This
paper delves into the proliferation of Mallas by examining the use of various
pre-trained language models and their efficiency and vulnerabilities when
misused. Building on a dataset from the Common Vulnerabilities and Exposures
(CVE) program, it explores fine-tuning methodologies to generate code and
explanatory text related to identified vulnerabilities. This research aims to
shed light on the operational strategies and exploitation techniques of Mallas,
leading to the development of more secure and trustworthy AI applications. The
paper concludes by emphasizing the need for further research, enhanced
safeguards, and ethical guidelines to mitigate the risks associated with the
malicious application of LLMs.
|
[
-0.3855642080307007,
-0.958861768245697,
0.6358870267868042,
-0.19967161118984222,
-0.031907569617033005,
0.1220630556344986,
-0.06333118677139282,
-0.6598653197288513,
-0.22971706092357635,
0.8485522270202637,
-0.2844645380973816,
-0.32641592621803284,
-0.8607302308082581,
-0.18592005968093872,
-0.6519423127174377,
1.0899866819381714,
0.3108453154563904,
-0.1827528327703476,
0.061300747096538544,
0.26651591062545776,
-0.5224624872207642,
-0.8811261057853699,
-0.704580545425415,
-0.02178954891860485,
0.3225565552711487,
0.36804312467575073,
0.8312229514122009,
0.37285107374191284,
0.7694380283355713,
0.37148338556289673,
0.22694604098796844,
0.1876136213541031,
-0.7562474608421326,
-0.04786185175180435,
-0.23191720247268677,
-0.8459792733192444,
-0.2217419445514679,
0.018215708434581757,
0.14717768132686615,
0.2385759949684143,
-0.05078764632344246,
0.39562177658081055,
-0.08807136863470078,
0.5381578803062439,
-0.8676924705505371,
-0.14208608865737915,
-1.2441086769104004,
-0.3930850625038147,
-0.49957746267318726,
-0.46984297037124634,
-0.5032131671905518,
-0.48393574357032776,
0.1174892708659172,
-0.3895825743675232,
-0.313895583152771,
0.07677223533391953,
0.48869603872299194,
0.2679879367351532,
-0.2403002828359604,
-0.1606733202934265,
-1.0381168127059937,
0.9888539910316467,
-0.556157648563385,
0.27241581678390503,
0.41252508759498596,
0.5142426490783691,
-0.40594664216041565,
-0.5566730499267578,
-0.41185691952705383,
-0.17557431757450104,
0.18018342554569244,
-0.6185773015022278,
-0.4781371057033539,
-0.14990024268627167,
0.30739396810531616,
0.018057646229863167,
-0.5144903659820557,
0.4701260030269623,
-0.6875577569007874,
-0.13763724267482758,
0.6924620270729065,
0.20536081492900848,
0.4511849284172058,
0.25308194756507874,
-0.14199991524219513,
-0.39399453997612,
-1.065264105796814,
0.2071305513381958,
0.4981634318828583,
0.30287596583366394,
-0.050433315336704254,
0.4025839567184448,
0.25861719250679016,
0.5866640210151672,
-0.25584664940834045,
-0.40623924136161804,
-0.07781445235013962,
0.10743619501590729,
-0.7137681841850281,
-0.14234943687915802,
0.4818083941936493,
0.2332315444946289,
0.6673093438148499,
-0.23872867226600647,
-0.1490429788827896,
0.21080702543258667,
0.7360360026359558,
-0.5877113342285156,
-0.13033485412597656,
0.2666302025318146,
-0.3167019188404083,
-0.6876683235168457,
0.22954827547073364,
-0.8811290860176086,
-0.7080382704734802,
-0.27347904443740845,
0.18822261691093445,
-0.39260607957839966,
-0.06644003838300705,
0.23038192093372345,
0.16289590299129486,
0.16701677441596985,
0.2555185556411743,
-0.5930955410003662,
0.4427855908870697,
0.9526024460792542,
0.5031993389129639,
-0.00551421195268631,
-0.16384856402873993,
-0.5149436593055725,
0.25667935609817505,
-0.31802982091903687,
0.3052225708961487,
-0.6506085395812988,
-0.5114032030105591,
0.37662649154663086,
-0.11759941279888153,
0.13071271777153015,
-0.5319167375564575,
0.44465726613998413,
-0.7529473304748535,
-0.1471264362335205,
0.1681896299123764,
-0.004265994764864445,
-0.11726357042789459,
0.42233380675315857,
-0.6261218190193176,
0.8460752964019775,
-0.16287292540073395,
-0.6680727005004883,
-0.03044380061328411,
-0.6624422669410706,
-0.438095360994339,
-0.28433531522750854,
0.0689351037144661,
-0.451109379529953,
0.20752108097076416,
0.4176587462425232,
0.6980929970741272,
-0.38586506247520447,
0.07215628772974014,
-0.4371064007282257,
-0.28660714626312256,
0.6868795156478882,
-0.4083539545536041,
0.7184532284736633,
0.3927544355392456,
-0.25533759593963623,
0.057082649320364,
-0.7903627157211304,
-0.13809579610824585,
0.28561922907829285,
0.14299631118774414,
-0.5505097508430481,
0.003350833896547556,
-0.001440749503672123,
0.1699320375919342,
0.5005555748939514,
-0.22689189016819,
-0.022381022572517395,
-0.6399943232536316,
0.553261935710907,
0.9380759000778198,
0.10846894979476929,
0.3592322766780853,
-0.4124082624912262,
0.3807998299598694,
0.10742378979921341,
0.803555965423584,
-0.12122837454080582,
-0.30711907148361206,
-0.4367789626121521,
-0.14527453482151031,
-0.24409015476703644,
0.6979776620864868,
-0.10733260959386826,
0.25202253460884094,
-0.1994796097278595,
-0.7534136772155762,
-0.39753279089927673,
0.12361853569746017,
0.08047282695770264,
0.01733468472957611,
0.3459099531173706,
-0.011040468700230122,
-0.45048484206199646,
-0.8893164396286011,
-0.2943514585494995,
-0.16437044739723206,
0.01834779605269432,
0.25397631525993347,
0.3083660900592804,
-0.6564556360244751,
0.5389897227287292,
-0.5175110697746277,
-0.0045390953309834,
0.17036908864974976,
-0.016468193382024765,
0.009280534461140633,
0.4525558352470398,
0.5747894644737244,
-0.680332601070404,
-0.15636242926120758,
-0.01585543155670166,
-0.3338465690612793,
0.1338852345943451,
-0.2132815271615982,
0.09404412657022476,
-0.013500593602657318,
0.7364072799682617,
-0.4137190878391266,
0.42118096351623535,
0.5777640342712402,
0.07120776176452637,
0.6828180551528931,
-0.10365891456604004,
0.20137999951839447,
-1.128660798072815,
0.13816630840301514,
-0.2245027720928192,
-0.31158238649368286,
-0.7131592631340027,
0.5461702942848206,
-0.15553729236125946,
-0.36559420824050903,
-0.44223153591156006,
0.2543877065181732,
-0.38705193996429443,
0.010483400896191597,
-0.3600880205631256,
0.2448815554380417,
-0.27497783303260803,
0.02645600587129593,
-0.740722119808197,
0.7831885814666748,
0.9439994096755981,
-0.5984387993812561,
0.19538003206253052,
-0.15404926240444183,
-0.20690983533859253,
0.3392491936683655,
-0.517575204372406,
0.4137555956840515,
0.16035808622837067,
-0.13508638739585876,
-0.6336416006088257,
-0.03084794618189335,
0.07485495507717133,
-0.2645942270755768,
0.39325398206710815,
0.07944241166114807,
-0.7438482642173767,
-0.31443390250205994,
-0.38697656989097595,
0.44224104285240173,
0.5243541598320007,
-0.47180065512657166,
0.40294307470321655,
0.8749387860298157,
-0.057538408786058426,
-0.676569938659668,
-0.6375830769538879,
0.3776114583015442,
-0.5072759985923767,
-0.7832061052322388,
-0.05648211017251015,
0.0533469095826149,
-0.7233018279075623,
-0.5041808485984802,
0.10923835635185242,
-0.19284182786941528,
0.7150394320487976,
0.5758397579193115,
0.1824912428855896,
-0.1422465592622757,
-0.061693768948316574,
-0.17848530411720276,
0.026001354679465294,
0.3450694978237152,
-0.3041747212409973,
0.5541321039199829,
-0.1895546019077301,
-0.5699058175086975,
-0.6321449875831604,
0.33830726146698,
0.8560759425163269,
-0.4505326449871063,
0.7364415526390076,
0.3837917447090149,
-0.4940131902694702,
-0.16744166612625122,
-0.6528977751731873,
-0.354444682598114,
-0.5294715166091919,
0.34252598881721497,
-0.18796373903751373,
-1.2219369411468506,
0.42439061403274536,
-0.4473460018634796,
0.2147383689880371,
0.27187037467956543,
0.5131298303604126,
0.2948961555957794,
0.9418829679489136,
1.0837939977645874,
-0.49642252922058105,
0.423720121383667,
-0.00992207694798708,
0.5725905895233154,
-0.39832231402397156,
-0.26270198822021484,
-0.7998833060264587,
-0.12395370751619339,
-0.8181709051132202,
-0.625969648361206,
0.3548245429992676,
0.1467938870191574,
-0.32003724575042725,
0.4187674820423126,
-0.49841949343681335,
0.5802369713783264,
0.3714439570903778,
-0.07906532287597656,
0.22406071424484253,
-0.08519437164068222,
0.3621557354927063,
0.3068954348564148,
-0.1618899703025818,
-1.0048452615737915,
1.4287830591201782,
0.5774809718132019,
1.0369449853897095,
0.29708078503608704,
0.721682608127594,
0.22995586693286896,
0.06709135323762894,
-0.3570038676261902,
0.6336783170700073,
-0.1824820339679718,
-0.488599568605423,
-0.3423629701137543,
-0.0335068441927433,
-1.202940583229065,
-0.3241516947746277,
-0.2541472911834717,
-1.4897657632827759,
-0.06920622289180756,
-0.11343488842248917,
-0.4513329565525055,
0.49216702580451965,
-0.5297196507453918,
0.49499157071113586,
-0.24586237967014313,
-0.11850585788488388,
-0.8064797520637512,
-0.4859008193016052,
0.6607598662376404,
-0.3715904951095581,
0.2611456513404846,
-0.07092176377773285,
0.13585644960403442,
0.4924907386302948,
-0.12402497977018356,
1.0148950815200806,
0.10691958665847778,
-0.35733845829963684,
0.12561309337615967,
0.35743963718414307,
0.8570716977119446,
0.33263370394706726,
0.07366900891065598,
0.1597694307565689,
0.09108804911375046,
-0.3791100084781647,
-0.5569437742233276,
0.978840708732605,
-1.0851234197616577,
-0.9308664798736572,
-0.3509122431278229,
-0.41193169355392456,
-0.3790631890296936,
0.15784700214862823,
-0.3550356924533844,
0.2444452941417694,
-0.5712675452232361,
0.05351261422038078,
0.9678529500961304,
-0.3153969347476959,
0.21779252588748932,
0.33228573203086853,
-0.24664334952831268,
0.107966847717762,
0.640607476234436,
-0.24458692967891693,
0.20593491196632385,
0.5198460817337036,
-0.013278878293931484,
0.04649578779935837,
-0.843350350856781,
-0.00789922010153532,
0.06893949955701828,
-0.40452420711517334,
-0.4310392439365387,
-0.4783112108707428,
-0.283172070980072,
-0.628149151802063,
-0.5354218482971191,
-0.2565552592277527,
-0.22127938270568848,
-0.5556244254112244,
-0.12632323801517487,
0.5538762211799622,
0.9130963683128357,
0.08324658125638962,
0.5554723143577576,
-0.8191705346107483,
0.09794125705957413,
0.31601622700691223,
0.16391344368457794,
-0.07328559458255768,
-0.3167969584465027,
-0.30129826068878174,
-0.016002293676137924,
-0.26682132482528687,
-0.9232527613639832,
0.41240787506103516,
-0.29007312655448914,
0.5623922348022461,
0.5147905349731445,
-0.22809340059757233,
0.5730167627334595,
-0.3964475393295288,
0.8294115662574768,
0.0845172330737114,
-0.8032768964767456,
0.46865034103393555,
-0.3435554802417755,
0.009008515626192093,
0.5005680918693542,
0.33823099732398987,
-0.2981386184692383,
-0.5837878584861755,
-0.5529009103775024,
-0.699637234210968,
0.43456918001174927,
0.07636525481939316,
0.3139773905277252,
0.24831824004650116,
0.2715532183647156,
0.027408044785261154,
0.10296068340539932,
-0.42742499709129333,
-0.22999544441699982,
-0.12293609976768494,
0.16835524141788483,
-0.10737676173448563,
-0.24316303431987762,
-0.47050032019615173,
0.12896138429641724,
0.7604672908782959,
0.00462768180295825,
0.06288851052522659,
-0.2607322037220001,
-0.13367846608161926,
-0.09178997576236725,
0.5169580578804016,
0.746903121471405,
0.673122763633728,
0.03691883012652397,
0.28340083360671997,
0.10864914953708649,
-0.4813333749771118,
-0.09115133434534073,
0.03353570029139519,
0.027499793097376823,
-0.5440601706504822,
-0.08256369829177856,
0.6116719245910645,
0.034127939492464066,
-0.8790886402130127,
0.3317866921424866,
-0.011387025937438011,
0.2151581197977066,
-0.4680154621601105,
0.2671912610530853,
-0.12233729660511017,
0.40843871235847473,
0.426560640335083,
0.2223321795463562,
0.00844744686037302,
-0.6617248058319092,
0.3390980362892151,
0.6791590452194214,
-0.18431688845157623,
-0.35246679186820984,
0.30477175116539,
0.10449494421482086,
-0.4947226047515869,
0.3105263113975525,
0.1834704428911209,
-0.3742925226688385,
0.34207385778427124,
0.5861825942993164,
1.0356948375701904,
-0.2769501507282257,
0.08307929337024689,
0.1524466872215271,
0.9012091159820557,
0.07270144671201706,
-0.034357160329818726,
0.304907888174057,
-0.5107985138893127,
-0.19321078062057495,
-0.6792701482772827,
-0.12896886467933655,
0.6597375869750977,
-0.3985287845134735,
0.26394492387771606,
-0.847786009311676,
-0.20477619767189026,
-0.16037771105766296,
0.09856810420751572,
-0.710395872592926,
0.0283537358045578,
0.318820059299469,
0.8995819091796875,
-0.7551039457321167,
0.8512570858001709,
0.4223099946975708,
-0.04923701658844948,
-0.7759420275688171,
0.16637128591537476,
0.06961110979318619,
-1.0560275316238403,
0.44024068117141724,
0.08593127131462097,
-0.19057096540927887,
-0.17548874020576477,
-0.7971304655075073,
-0.9610651135444641,
0.9134885668754578,
0.4617381691932678,
-0.5793052911758423,
0.1093340516090393,
0.5562323927879333,
0.5392670631408691,
-0.29982540011405945,
-0.0878560021519661,
0.7532868981361389,
0.5281214714050293,
-0.5398325324058533,
-0.9207037687301636,
0.2055235356092453,
-0.002989740576595068,
-0.034083981066942215,
0.29085126519203186,
-0.4606950581073761,
0.6850370168685913,
-0.23323023319244385,
-0.15277990698814392,
0.04568634182214737,
0.46348875761032104,
0.1770285964012146,
0.09182045608758926,
0.30049681663513184,
0.4573863744735718,
0.9648302793502808,
0.2481948435306549,
0.9029749631881714,
-0.3389194905757904,
-0.24626514315605164,
0.8964627981185913,
-0.22033023834228516,
0.8586848974227905,
0.6266060471534729,
-0.1425466686487198,
0.5416774153709412,
0.2934233248233795,
-0.09530654549598694,
0.13521648943424225,
0.44245001673698425,
-0.05866418033838272,
-0.16931243240833282,
-0.016270998865365982,
-0.14614439010620117,
0.620393693447113,
0.5328772068023682,
-0.43075066804885864,
-0.30156993865966797,
-0.01879083178937435,
0.1798669844865799,
0.30610719323158264,
-0.49527233839035034,
0.6694244742393494,
0.24232539534568787,
-0.4547877907752991,
0.47471892833709717,
0.39045533537864685,
0.5724261403083801,
-0.6336253881454468,
0.35499826073646545,
0.36127880215644836,
0.14362627267837524,
-0.05084982141852379,
-0.5365519523620605,
0.4061660170555115,
0.12954138219356537,
-0.03448805958032608,
-0.05859295278787613,
0.8533936142921448,
0.14907027781009674,
-0.263348251581192,
0.290147602558136,
0.3363792896270752,
0.10323069244623184,
-0.2841589152812958,
-0.8315987586975098,
0.19617091119289398,
-0.19085298478603363,
-0.011258764192461967,
0.6920941472053528,
0.3884119391441345,
-0.25100383162498474,
0.8317713737487793,
1.0327702760696411,
0.05752529203891754,
0.24858875572681427,
0.010701014660298824,
0.9542320370674133,
-0.3760346472263336,
-0.37693285942077637,
-1.0410082340240479,
0.2718953788280487,
-0.1271314173936844,
-0.13563847541809082,
0.9110134243965149,
0.5129141807556152,
0.8040800094604492,
0.06328150629997253,
0.7582837343215942,
0.4188403785228729,
0.3263320326805115,
-0.42519938945770264,
0.8942181468009949,
-0.24073666334152222,
0.44447603821754456,
-0.21894705295562744,
-0.6060962080955505,
-0.34833893179893494,
0.18411816656589508,
-0.4930395483970642,
-0.22275370359420776,
0.40651655197143555,
1.1356533765792847,
0.08492475748062134,
-0.11739484965801239,
0.5935463309288025,
0.3799528181552887,
0.5435291528701782,
0.4052826762199402,
0.6087777018547058,
-0.3811059296131134,
0.5197625160217285,
0.04002251476049423,
-0.20754440128803253,
-0.4332497715950012,
-0.7373068928718567,
-1.0418652296066284,
-0.5361104607582092,
0.008504928089678288,
-0.2832629382610321,
0.317303329706192,
0.5661388635635376,
0.6484299898147583,
-0.9340003132820129,
-0.18241572380065918,
0.04290386661887169,
0.028755981475114822,
0.0022484941873699427,
-0.19320949912071228,
0.031165434047579765,
-0.2959882616996765,
-0.5977455973625183,
0.5517133474349976,
0.40814340114593506,
0.22399768233299255,
-0.7717005014419556,
0.21189190447330475,
-0.09858249127864838,
0.4911802411079407,
0.5080265402793884,
0.42009395360946655,
-0.5975306630134583,
-0.31527790427207947,
0.08696756511926651,
-0.38506433367729187,
-0.17101892828941345,
0.9928547739982605,
-0.6450182199478149,
0.12758347392082214,
0.39740049839019775,
1.0024186372756958,
0.09390486776828766,
-0.15029191970825195,
0.7189549803733826,
-0.5617321133613586,
0.059906866401433945,
0.2160409688949585,
0.22916264832019806,
0.352823406457901,
-0.5553123354911804,
0.06455095112323761,
-0.15438702702522278,
-0.7322416305541992,
-1.2105551958084106,
0.44825077056884766,
-0.9741888046264648,
-0.5184940099716187,
0.972995400428772,
0.10445939749479294,
-0.4652297794818878,
-0.37407705187797546,
-0.1538856476545334,
0.19833774864673615,
-0.2836529016494751,
1.2216191291809082,
0.29420986771583557,
0.37105831503868103,
0.23062771558761597,
-0.4974004328250885,
0.7815490961074829,
0.1602874994277954,
-1.0450972318649292,
0.3270820379257202,
0.17895247042179108,
0.12920734286308289,
0.3501463532447815,
0.39195001125335693,
-0.2726992070674896,
0.08306650072336197,
-0.23957738280296326,
-0.3103097081184387,
-0.0821785181760788,
-0.5428516268730164,
-0.3310681879520416,
0.2914382517337799,
0.2360679656267166,
0.12921962141990662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00627v1
|
Prompt Framework for Role-playing: Generation and Evaluation
| 2024-06-02T06:09:56
| 2024-06-02T06:09:56
|
Xun Liu, Zhengwei Ni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLM) have demonstrated remarkable abilities in
generating natural language, understanding user instruction, and mimicking
human language use. These capabilities have garnered considerable interest in
applications such as role-playing. However, the process of collecting
individual role scripts (or profiles) data and manually evaluating the
performance can be costly. We introduce a framework that uses prompts to
leverage the state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs to construct role-playing dialogue
datasets and evaluate the role-playing performance. Additionally, we employ
recall-oriented evaluation Rouge-L metric to support the result of the LLM
evaluator.
|
[
-0.1698889583349228,
-0.733720064163208,
0.5953189730644226,
0.49679306149482727,
0.1730651557445526,
-0.07553968578577042,
0.05218028277158737,
0.14106543362140656,
0.1022186130285263,
0.7386561632156372,
-1.031548261642456,
-0.4702267050743103,
-0.1654851734638214,
0.27990421652793884,
-0.20373213291168213,
0.8604909777641296,
0.3575130105018616,
0.1916714310646057,
-0.35015246272087097,
0.09871602803468704,
-0.8348322510719299,
-0.35030853748321533,
-1.1645621061325073,
-0.1489662528038025,
0.47147563099861145,
0.7999448776245117,
0.3436904549598694,
0.5085012912750244,
0.18283148109912872,
0.33327221870422363,
0.24721075594425201,
0.05543376877903938,
-0.6334212422370911,
0.7006300687789917,
-0.20749495923519135,
-0.5011393427848816,
-0.44529226422309875,
0.10476411879062653,
0.758533775806427,
0.24977800250053406,
-0.1419239342212677,
0.40352320671081543,
-0.09382850676774979,
0.2797534167766571,
-0.3178279399871826,
0.35083338618278503,
-0.32819607853889465,
0.10050734877586365,
-0.10205428302288055,
-0.48712581396102905,
-0.4960736036300659,
-0.44004034996032715,
0.11879879236221313,
-0.663987398147583,
0.015003676526248455,
0.14767664670944214,
0.281855970621109,
-0.02156178094446659,
-0.2135394960641861,
-0.6018897294998169,
-0.4753879904747009,
0.6465886831283569,
-0.5947268605232239,
0.11840033531188965,
0.41508838534355164,
0.7127559781074524,
-0.3050260543823242,
-0.6096023917198181,
-0.4661237299442291,
-0.5796837210655212,
0.18439878523349762,
0.19012778997421265,
0.08438687771558762,
-0.015718480572104454,
0.602677583694458,
0.26129812002182007,
-0.5068377256393433,
0.3838610351085663,
-0.2116696536540985,
-0.15526676177978516,
0.8067288398742676,
0.701993465423584,
0.44187989830970764,
-0.47168880701065063,
-0.4850698709487915,
-0.046742163598537445,
-0.8396148681640625,
0.3207872807979584,
0.6312611699104309,
0.6001847982406616,
-0.03206854313611984,
0.573665976524353,
0.12226083129644394,
0.4653283357620239,
0.09392278641462326,
-0.3457956612110138,
-0.26517874002456665,
-0.22905316948890686,
-0.22214564681053162,
-0.06613510102033615,
0.7823772430419922,
0.5957471132278442,
0.22283606231212616,
0.04242080822587013,
-0.4122885465621948,
0.024874508380889893,
-0.00799162033945322,
-0.9239579439163208,
0.10493084788322449,
0.04508001357316971,
-0.46040576696395874,
-0.375154972076416,
-0.09776488691568375,
-1.1393684148788452,
-0.9640418291091919,
-0.1761307716369629,
0.4905080795288086,
-0.2541074752807617,
-0.023929152637720108,
-0.06752276420593262,
-0.1371636986732483,
0.1377585083246231,
0.3114314079284668,
-0.9709897041320801,
0.44483524560928345,
0.4789436161518097,
0.7136104702949524,
-0.3181378245353699,
-0.2103784680366516,
-1.294089436531067,
-0.25866591930389404,
-0.35705968737602234,
0.6261643767356873,
-0.6668168306350708,
-0.7206308245658875,
0.3296920359134674,
-0.033812541514635086,
0.08364292979240417,
-0.6754323244094849,
0.4822727143764496,
-0.4972725510597229,
0.4019734859466553,
-0.359628289937973,
-0.5215402245521545,
0.33412039279937744,
0.2726524770259857,
-0.9504550099372864,
1.1317938566207886,
0.11933780461549759,
-0.2741231322288513,
0.5080739855766296,
-0.8073739409446716,
-0.27847158908843994,
0.3704715073108673,
-0.2291068285703659,
-0.04424236714839935,
-0.05302991718053818,
0.1729339212179184,
0.6204984188079834,
-0.8182799816131592,
0.4246847331523895,
0.05210033431649208,
-0.5073131918907166,
0.3916222155094147,
-0.42389020323753357,
0.6762401461601257,
0.12103092670440674,
-0.12819397449493408,
0.4458538591861725,
-0.668674647808075,
-0.30274972319602966,
-0.006046301685273647,
-0.31008031964302063,
0.11069058626890182,
-0.020088976249098778,
0.003322577802464366,
0.2960395812988281,
0.06492345035076141,
-0.16278885304927826,
0.16598698496818542,
-0.20425622165203094,
0.2686895728111267,
0.7720454931259155,
0.18414705991744995,
0.3618776202201843,
-0.3256571292877197,
1.1125773191452026,
-0.3305814862251282,
0.0345529168844223,
-0.8014252185821533,
-0.2752440571784973,
-0.44429492950439453,
-0.39638271927833557,
0.19107523560523987,
0.5456416606903076,
-0.8275492787361145,
0.6002461314201355,
0.16376705467700958,
-0.3726670444011688,
-0.38221126794815063,
0.13227753341197968,
0.3172241449356079,
0.4448508620262146,
0.16504092514514923,
-0.33756715059280396,
-0.5999405384063721,
-0.6481613516807556,
-0.13280442357063293,
-0.3628266453742981,
-0.18659751117229462,
0.5740993618965149,
0.21190191805362701,
-0.06910382956266403,
1.041493535041809,
-0.26043304800987244,
-0.156376451253891,
-0.6316638588905334,
0.20729702711105347,
0.1666223704814911,
0.42728349566459656,
0.3085649609565735,
-0.3952360153198242,
-0.334257572889328,
-0.48233160376548767,
-0.6796738505363464,
-0.5381647944450378,
-0.354653537273407,
-0.027696190401911736,
0.10775815695524216,
0.552373468875885,
-0.6435772776603699,
0.3393482267856598,
0.4803727865219116,
-0.556168794631958,
0.8436850309371948,
0.0029564928263425827,
0.5012364983558655,
-0.9415786266326904,
0.44315946102142334,
-0.05178378149867058,
-0.32716262340545654,
-0.5223397612571716,
-0.10154789686203003,
-0.41420620679855347,
-0.26093143224716187,
-0.31362617015838623,
0.8611953854560852,
-0.34370362758636475,
-0.34173524379730225,
-0.06032206863164902,
0.5055011510848999,
-0.02485475316643715,
0.11366333812475204,
-0.12669263780117035,
1.0565927028656006,
0.584531307220459,
-0.7504542469978333,
0.5266427397727966,
0.20347028970718384,
-0.5894380211830139,
0.5289425253868103,
-0.645752489566803,
0.011808897368609905,
-0.06266980618238449,
0.2536674439907074,
-1.1109191179275513,
-0.39174386858940125,
0.12022042274475098,
-0.008246042765676975,
0.18277202546596527,
-0.2549747824668884,
-0.5598997473716736,
-0.3069983422756195,
-0.3556062877178192,
0.1977377086877823,
0.6063178777694702,
-0.5154176354408264,
0.4196041226387024,
0.46141406893730164,
-0.4117436110973358,
-0.5985447764396667,
-0.26569247245788574,
0.1698213666677475,
-0.5109612941741943,
-0.40607017278671265,
0.14600913226604462,
-0.3436494767665863,
-0.16638264060020447,
-0.45857539772987366,
-0.13582764565944672,
0.16020429134368896,
0.20784763991832733,
0.200161412358284,
0.23893500864505768,
-0.23373118042945862,
0.18673114478588104,
-0.009250285103917122,
-0.23426420986652374,
0.2005126029253006,
0.05918879061937332,
0.7115529179573059,
0.08747144043445587,
-0.32274723052978516,
-0.33946678042411804,
0.2930878698825836,
0.44052672386169434,
-0.09172314405441284,
0.320853054523468,
0.1745147556066513,
-0.21275074779987335,
-0.33989787101745605,
-0.5341237187385559,
-0.3397664427757263,
-0.46267613768577576,
0.21741582453250885,
-0.14100827276706696,
-1.0435020923614502,
0.6071876883506775,
-0.25259721279144287,
0.05691085010766983,
0.15853014588356018,
0.5205696225166321,
0.04886629432439804,
1.052397608757019,
0.3693108856678009,
0.2580723166465759,
0.4931540787220001,
0.03655047342181206,
-0.0389474518597126,
-0.4096279740333557,
-0.07557589560747147,
-0.3524457812309265,
-0.23455961048603058,
-0.32969674468040466,
-0.6172664761543274,
0.23741738498210907,
0.2525821924209595,
-0.3668556213378906,
0.21105659008026123,
-0.025614099577069283,
0.603914737701416,
0.3953660726547241,
-0.2171817272901535,
0.20599214732646942,
-0.23013955354690552,
-0.1920519322156906,
-0.14705371856689453,
-0.6894848346710205,
-1.0971260070800781,
0.7778051495552063,
0.41216498613357544,
0.6257815361022949,
0.2291942685842514,
0.7779300808906555,
0.543720543384552,
0.47080451250076294,
-0.8970596194267273,
0.9544693827629089,
0.04606178030371666,
-0.5410801768302917,
-0.6412400007247925,
-0.39796656370162964,
-0.8726239204406738,
-0.22010816633701324,
-0.4237818121910095,
-1.0252479314804077,
-0.24912004172801971,
0.1689944863319397,
-0.7495008707046509,
-0.2688879370689392,
-0.4901667833328247,
1.0860589742660522,
-0.12125515192747116,
-0.5431838631629944,
0.009138490073382854,
-0.4940488040447235,
0.4623391628265381,
0.038317225873470306,
-0.09407803416252136,
-0.10953594744205475,
0.03443580120801926,
0.6340174674987793,
-0.10466217994689941,
0.9461557269096375,
-0.46551084518432617,
-0.1850060224533081,
0.49581214785575867,
0.4131322205066681,
0.1378430277109146,
0.4490842819213867,
-0.37678682804107666,
-0.40451186895370483,
0.00019178549700882286,
0.12199798226356506,
-0.9616912007331848,
0.64308762550354,
-0.30979305505752563,
-0.7970806956291199,
-0.1934896856546402,
-0.37388452887535095,
-0.32778501510620117,
0.11011870950460434,
0.026514124125242233,
0.6707388162612915,
-0.9470236301422119,
-0.004238943103700876,
0.5092273950576782,
-0.6322096586227417,
0.4182203710079193,
0.38911712169647217,
-0.7030057311058044,
-0.18432949483394623,
0.7074555158615112,
0.0030548430513590574,
0.061618871986866,
0.2489333599805832,
0.4062565565109253,
-0.5923186540603638,
-0.008200346492230892,
-0.7395603656768799,
-0.06078694388270378,
-0.5841484069824219,
-0.42878982424736023,
-0.343033105134964,
-0.08318707346916199,
-0.20405741035938263,
-0.07689465582370758,
0.06572846323251724,
-0.3337628245353699,
-0.20182153582572937,
-0.2692120373249054,
0.3783584237098694,
0.9509961605072021,
0.0006572830607183278,
0.6315075755119324,
-0.8270898461341858,
0.11002792418003082,
0.5498007535934448,
0.36908605694770813,
0.007671772502362728,
-0.2523382902145386,
-0.04081697016954422,
-0.22967050969600677,
-0.1686994731426239,
-1.045704960823059,
0.35763344168663025,
0.049119122326374054,
0.7597386240959167,
0.3741581439971924,
-0.11708686500787735,
0.5730315446853638,
-0.6674566864967346,
1.268845558166504,
0.22634783387184143,
-1.1688207387924194,
0.5873845219612122,
-0.4286300241947174,
0.08230821788311005,
0.607484757900238,
0.2459113448858261,
-0.6629800796508789,
0.051008570939302444,
-0.5651775598526001,
-0.6980715394020081,
1.1054582595825195,
0.02051512710750103,
0.21647650003433228,
-0.28633275628089905,
0.19611956179141998,
0.25048521161079407,
0.3205971419811249,
-0.3580210208892822,
0.046111077070236206,
-0.010050386190414429,
-0.26798343658447266,
-0.26952970027923584,
-0.39897334575653076,
-0.17937786877155304,
0.22451260685920715,
0.4189382791519165,
-0.29208284616470337,
0.2530636489391327,
-0.0667659193277359,
-0.15184232592582703,
-0.06825131177902222,
0.3437930941581726,
0.5331096649169922,
0.5941171050071716,
0.06767313182353973,
0.014911551028490067,
0.25774645805358887,
-0.11877145618200302,
0.17778071761131287,
-0.09230588376522064,
0.028859414160251617,
-0.28768661618232727,
0.3988684415817261,
0.7700525522232056,
0.5245199799537659,
-1.182163953781128,
0.7439859509468079,
-0.1257331371307373,
0.02637295238673687,
-0.04407305270433426,
0.32869789004325867,
0.20801693201065063,
0.3769628405570984,
0.19366399943828583,
-0.28518572449684143,
0.33608198165893555,
-0.8248517513275146,
0.4501051604747772,
0.12126760184764862,
-0.32412922382354736,
-0.20620402693748474,
0.3408067524433136,
0.27743983268737793,
-0.7806957364082336,
0.4303790330886841,
-0.13336026668548584,
-0.27814167737960815,
0.633825957775116,
0.7800828218460083,
0.8784859776496887,
-0.5874799489974976,
0.5220960974693298,
0.4160594046115875,
-0.0869150161743164,
-0.2394651174545288,
0.45234885811805725,
-0.04915903881192207,
-0.4807778596878052,
-0.4625258147716522,
-0.43402087688446045,
-0.3034842312335968,
0.23290027678012848,
-0.5685611963272095,
0.47585806250572205,
-0.6660160422325134,
-0.3599723279476166,
-0.3680756390094757,
0.05657432600855827,
-0.8115338087081909,
0.16736023128032684,
-0.025614885613322258,
1.0485546588897705,
-0.9203596711158752,
0.3023337721824646,
0.37181100249290466,
-0.6701856851577759,
-0.7431764602661133,
0.10794762521982193,
0.014438741840422153,
-0.6724216938018799,
0.8830804824829102,
0.4923830032348633,
-0.15356700122356415,
0.020476950332522392,
-0.5290607213973999,
-0.3151094317436218,
1.1796553134918213,
0.47662588953971863,
-0.43350863456726074,
-0.12245862931013107,
-0.021544072777032852,
0.7023178935050964,
-0.8432657718658447,
0.667972981929779,
0.8116788268089294,
0.3789001405239105,
0.12455811351537704,
-0.6880300641059875,
0.15548574924468994,
-0.19788633286952972,
0.0257649514824152,
-0.38925400376319885,
-0.40833723545074463,
0.58641517162323,
-0.06772948801517487,
-0.5756260752677917,
0.2933346927165985,
0.4826143682003021,
0.7307931184768677,
0.4273674786090851,
0.7192584276199341,
-0.2034362405538559,
0.8295299410820007,
0.18075677752494812,
0.7695996165275574,
-0.18404358625411987,
-0.0818144902586937,
1.029841423034668,
-0.6949882507324219,
0.6149947643280029,
0.18288949131965637,
0.30561015009880066,
0.4547894299030304,
0.4709743559360504,
0.18000218272209167,
0.2310630977153778,
0.7035444378852844,
-0.2345789223909378,
-0.4962347447872162,
-0.33877161145210266,
0.14129440486431122,
0.5981753468513489,
0.41376417875289917,
-0.4265158176422119,
-0.1981562227010727,
-0.2891291379928589,
-0.13587994873523712,
0.417287141084671,
-0.3136501908302307,
0.8379226326942444,
0.07326812297105789,
-0.9056838154792786,
-0.07099545747041702,
-0.07677161693572998,
0.366632342338562,
-0.6505064368247986,
-0.49591895937919617,
-0.2167714536190033,
-0.2550261914730072,
0.05261221155524254,
-0.8117328882217407,
-0.011306685395538807,
0.4934636652469635,
-0.1395173817873001,
-0.44185134768486023,
0.6057695150375366,
-0.4012953042984009,
-0.2502759099006653,
0.32214921712875366,
0.7721117734909058,
0.2940436601638794,
0.5044382810592651,
-0.656661331653595,
0.11133900284767151,
-0.33019334077835083,
-0.2647729218006134,
0.20300446450710297,
0.5513123869895935,
-0.3043985366821289,
0.5905128717422485,
0.519008994102478,
-0.10394903272390366,
-0.2152101695537567,
0.45070990920066833,
0.7622331380844116,
-0.6014400124549866,
-0.6460100412368774,
-0.8325774073600769,
0.6913794875144958,
-0.2996474504470825,
-0.5151156783103943,
0.6972838640213013,
0.6847809553146362,
0.2164677232503891,
-0.10033988952636719,
0.8532224297523499,
0.011163504794239998,
0.5902764797210693,
-0.7096412181854248,
0.4908168315887451,
-0.22849129140377045,
0.49203476309776306,
-0.43271705508232117,
-0.9420399069786072,
-0.22129616141319275,
0.8506864905357361,
-0.15522514283657074,
0.21071434020996094,
0.3424069583415985,
1.1167290210723877,
0.07152067124843597,
0.1540219485759735,
0.5724815726280212,
-0.06134979426860809,
0.40261921286582947,
0.25180327892303467,
1.3038370609283447,
-0.21018239855766296,
0.1005539819598198,
0.5708885192871094,
-0.5268851518630981,
-0.3083494305610657,
-1.2420392036437988,
-1.1714845895767212,
-0.5302658677101135,
-0.024896290153265,
-0.4532333016395569,
0.06539032608270645,
1.3991029262542725,
0.5541955828666687,
-0.6264917254447937,
-0.6314701437950134,
0.07085858285427094,
-0.024534789845347404,
-0.2850785553455353,
-0.25693443417549133,
0.1759645938873291,
-0.5626071095466614,
-0.738968551158905,
0.9694445133209229,
0.21903035044670105,
-0.28149178624153137,
-0.680445671081543,
-0.23823359608650208,
0.001211431692354381,
0.4633161127567291,
0.7594107389450073,
0.2663886249065399,
-0.5188418030738831,
-0.23713372647762299,
0.34459784626960754,
-0.20970365405082703,
-0.2503582239151001,
1.1904023885726929,
-0.719704806804657,
0.4749831557273865,
0.5752999186515808,
0.6499748826026917,
0.28730952739715576,
0.1444954127073288,
1.1186167001724243,
-0.7796860337257385,
-0.2920987010002136,
0.28877919912338257,
0.1107623279094696,
0.38253891468048096,
-0.37352702021598816,
0.42313095927238464,
-0.042950019240379333,
-0.479234516620636,
-0.9033132195472717,
0.342624694108963,
-0.7474993467330933,
0.14756444096565247,
1.2006690502166748,
-0.33723241090774536,
0.02308497577905655,
-0.03352201357483864,
-0.5133386254310608,
0.244201198220253,
-0.6203986406326294,
0.6175490021705627,
0.6446043848991394,
-0.021825173869729042,
-0.24777570366859436,
-0.47113627195358276,
0.8573551177978516,
0.07122468203306198,
-0.8285704851150513,
0.33480170369148254,
0.7749788165092468,
0.08879407495260239,
0.03402184695005417,
0.920701801776886,
0.03873073682188988,
0.20361126959323883,
0.02662443183362484,
-0.03806691616773605,
-0.01315774954855442,
-0.6890023946762085,
-0.4677920937538147,
0.12645071744918823,
0.05453217774629593,
0.29771050810813904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00606v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00606v2
|
LLMs Could Autonomously Learn Without External Supervision
| 2024-06-02T03:36:37
| 2024-06-06T22:48:35
|
Ke Ji, Junying Chen, Anningzhe Gao, Wenya Xie, Xiang Wan, Benyou Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the quest for super-human performance, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
traditionally been tethered to human-annotated datasets and predefined training
objectives-a process that is both labor-intensive and inherently limited. This
paper presents a transformative approach: Autonomous Learning for LLMs, a
self-sufficient learning paradigm that frees models from the constraints of
human supervision. This method endows LLMs with the ability to self-educate
through direct interaction with text, akin to a human reading and comprehending
literature. Our approach eliminates the reliance on annotated data, fostering
an Autonomous Learning environment where the model independently identifies and
reinforces its knowledge gaps. Empirical results from our comprehensive
experiments, which utilized a diverse array of learning materials and were
evaluated against standard public quizzes, reveal that Autonomous Learning
outstrips the performance of both Pre-training and Supervised Fine-Tuning
(SFT), as well as retrieval-augmented methods. These findings underscore the
potential of Autonomous Learning to not only enhance the efficiency and
effectiveness of LLM training but also to pave the way for the development of
more advanced, self-reliant AI systems.
|
[
-0.1889224797487259,
-0.5850999355316162,
0.5910389423370361,
-0.2669498026371002,
0.034291792660951614,
0.27994439005851746,
-0.4777737855911255,
-0.572956919670105,
0.20177601277828217,
0.6045681834220886,
-0.6898488402366638,
-0.32517799735069275,
-0.4959390163421631,
0.2985427677631378,
-0.4165794849395752,
0.8660052418708801,
0.06287700682878494,
-0.002065477427095175,
-0.5082420110702515,
0.08158434182405472,
-0.12420565634965897,
-0.4349633455276489,
-0.6562649011611938,
-0.3205532133579254,
0.715459942817688,
0.41503340005874634,
0.3832780122756958,
1.223530888557434,
0.3069741725921631,
0.4076068103313446,
0.46473827958106995,
0.6049286127090454,
-0.20383469760417938,
0.20542192459106445,
-0.34423115849494934,
-0.7211587429046631,
-0.2652316391468048,
0.24637068808078766,
0.6092720627784729,
0.4692853093147278,
0.02201448753476143,
0.13098439574241638,
0.2509745657444,
0.8581040501594543,
-0.42757007479667664,
0.4146881103515625,
-0.6975117921829224,
0.015247090719640255,
-0.045688167214393616,
-0.13063284754753113,
-0.35614097118377686,
-0.3037291467189789,
-0.06582720577716827,
-0.6877064108848572,
0.1533532738685608,
-0.14453011751174927,
0.39382463693618774,
0.829535186290741,
-0.38097506761550903,
-0.31911614537239075,
-0.8700935244560242,
0.5544705390930176,
-0.28124356269836426,
0.45667582750320435,
0.5024059414863586,
0.19703777134418488,
-0.001813097856938839,
-0.48042798042297363,
-0.3996618390083313,
-0.4403608441352844,
-0.2127549946308136,
0.1782497763633728,
0.16544240713119507,
-0.04106047749519348,
-0.19470641016960144,
0.2118547409772873,
-0.31679993867874146,
0.5016698241233826,
-0.38683778047561646,
0.056853119283914566,
0.8905877470970154,
0.18813586235046387,
0.2669362425804138,
0.051445331424474716,
-0.38419631123542786,
-0.033163461834192276,
-0.7079786658287048,
-0.02966253273189068,
0.2721650302410126,
0.4937335252761841,
0.0329132005572319,
0.4031939208507538,
-0.22283664345741272,
0.3832361102104187,
0.1083155944943428,
-0.1506512314081192,
0.013679471798241138,
-0.00633172458037734,
-0.12268558144569397,
-0.09366841614246368,
1.0392990112304688,
-0.22111116349697113,
0.4098927080631256,
-0.46405357122421265,
-0.4913458526134491,
-0.09300463646650314,
0.45821359753608704,
-0.3370824456214905,
-0.6038511991500854,
0.019316235557198524,
0.016001921147108078,
-0.13776734471321106,
-0.059142399579286575,
-0.5036371350288391,
-0.5231949687004089,
-0.8184396028518677,
0.6956949830055237,
-0.3444686233997345,
-0.20569118857383728,
-0.34843873977661133,
0.36646613478660583,
0.017419807612895966,
0.3715447783470154,
-1.2268433570861816,
0.23883578181266785,
0.3817650079727173,
0.711559534072876,
-0.32954904437065125,
-0.47723397612571716,
-0.42179760336875916,
0.28590258955955505,
-0.5955804586410522,
0.7449353933334351,
-0.2251499593257904,
-0.2976299822330475,
-0.23705242574214935,
-0.07890100032091141,
-0.11541842669248581,
-0.6207050681114197,
0.027226533740758896,
-0.446929395198822,
-0.036059893667697906,
-0.03448793664574623,
-0.5869446992874146,
-0.16391177475452423,
0.015688695013523102,
-0.5512572526931763,
0.8566930890083313,
-0.05571892112493515,
-0.33338308334350586,
0.14798730611801147,
-0.7583642601966858,
-0.4738096296787262,
0.20771823823451996,
-0.4762301743030548,
-0.15090356767177582,
0.08992743492126465,
0.2222772091627121,
0.7199386358261108,
-0.10213713347911835,
0.34835249185562134,
-0.00148090161383152,
-0.16451053321361542,
-0.09954211115837097,
-0.5150851607322693,
0.6307673454284668,
-0.1422053873538971,
-0.6199321746826172,
0.2970719039440155,
-0.8588924407958984,
-0.140990749001503,
0.22075925767421722,
-0.4521262049674988,
-0.46513286232948303,
0.2628200948238373,
-0.5001543760299683,
0.19933189451694489,
0.3935244083404541,
-0.25502052903175354,
0.3697701692581177,
-0.5707367658615112,
0.12394428998231888,
1.1925289630889893,
-0.2876942753791809,
0.738716185092926,
-0.3273952603340149,
0.4239751994609833,
-0.2218698114156723,
0.0788460224866867,
-0.33460795879364014,
0.16604773700237274,
-1.0391147136688232,
-0.45382368564605713,
0.08310124278068542,
0.507770299911499,
-0.7390580773353577,
0.6499385237693787,
-0.01387826632708311,
-0.659976065158844,
-0.8149487376213074,
0.8382507562637329,
0.3640028238296509,
0.4030410349369049,
0.5926880836486816,
-0.0299125574529171,
-0.5681878328323364,
-0.7152682542800903,
-0.13431042432785034,
-0.13954488933086395,
0.04778876155614853,
0.1631905883550644,
0.5876883864402771,
-0.38085657358169556,
1.0127215385437012,
-0.12818823754787445,
-0.7668455839157104,
-0.30082201957702637,
0.0729738175868988,
-0.3307366967201233,
0.6496444344520569,
0.018106713891029358,
-0.4532468914985657,
-0.4399104714393616,
0.1123896911740303,
-1.221074104309082,
-0.059010520577430725,
-0.18429170548915863,
0.293221116065979,
0.39567995071411133,
1.008991003036499,
-0.34333640336990356,
0.21890269219875336,
0.35129302740097046,
0.08382251858711243,
0.5926753878593445,
-0.7789602279663086,
-0.46215397119522095,
-0.6152536869049072,
-0.10641101002693176,
-0.0628306120634079,
-0.2805939018726349,
-0.3397531807422638,
0.029058651998639107,
0.16828653216362,
0.4122137129306793,
-0.10907580703496933,
0.8295959830284119,
-0.6919543147087097,
0.07622712850570679,
-0.5516325831413269,
0.2322033792734146,
-0.2867288589477539,
0.47631385922431946,
0.3176226019859314,
0.822285532951355,
0.44410625100135803,
-0.7162429094314575,
0.26646092534065247,
0.10132675617933273,
-0.3309972584247589,
0.07139380276203156,
-0.574246883392334,
0.09595675021409988,
-0.28764793276786804,
0.21063412725925446,
-0.7564246654510498,
-0.3718593716621399,
0.1487724334001541,
-0.22186881303787231,
0.2064451426267624,
0.26599952578544617,
-0.5254269242286682,
0.07476985454559326,
0.16822625696659088,
-0.007288563530892134,
0.3512013852596283,
-0.7947956919670105,
0.7402268648147583,
0.3547802269458771,
-0.03782656416296959,
-0.4944804906845093,
-0.4952884018421173,
0.03190411254763603,
-0.1181422770023346,
0.009668959304690361,
-0.06365160644054413,
-0.017026497051119804,
-0.308117538690567,
-0.20679543912410736,
0.13955970108509064,
0.0811830535531044,
0.43627506494522095,
0.5243755578994751,
0.23760250210762024,
0.007300141267478466,
0.5100786685943604,
0.016622988507151604,
-0.3207598030567169,
0.19940170645713806,
-0.43970203399658203,
0.21710646152496338,
-0.16843271255493164,
-0.43670034408569336,
-0.6892772316932678,
0.12421731650829315,
0.5311882495880127,
-0.6010030508041382,
0.6328417062759399,
0.32536545395851135,
-0.16648294031620026,
-0.5826402902603149,
-0.4979083836078644,
-0.34651753306388855,
-0.5608147978782654,
0.19197288155555725,
-0.18178822100162506,
-0.8358809351921082,
0.13684645295143127,
-0.07967289537191391,
0.11950789391994476,
0.46499523520469666,
0.5418119430541992,
-0.2662593126296997,
0.8586694598197937,
1.0106189250946045,
-0.14002588391304016,
0.4586397409439087,
-0.209976464509964,
-0.10566310584545135,
-0.6323170065879822,
-0.5120891332626343,
-0.16880996525287628,
-0.08892229199409485,
-0.5023242235183716,
-0.3032371699810028,
0.5248916149139404,
-0.08487555384635925,
-0.38498929142951965,
0.20205549895763397,
-0.5553686618804932,
0.684823751449585,
0.9012277722358704,
0.11906086653470993,
0.6336585283279419,
-0.4127225875854492,
-0.18747754395008087,
0.06821047514677048,
-0.6800405979156494,
-0.5436334013938904,
1.1571751832962036,
0.2696909010410309,
0.8852447271347046,
-0.18284423649311066,
0.9587112665176392,
0.2539633810520172,
0.5298398733139038,
-0.6409826278686523,
0.5826259255409241,
0.044545721262693405,
-0.5196902751922607,
-0.5677685141563416,
-0.4130050539970398,
-0.8929646015167236,
0.18129600584506989,
-0.2857834994792938,
-0.6232360005378723,
-0.05855053290724754,
0.13882629573345184,
-0.38037291169166565,
0.34972476959228516,
-0.7456648945808411,
0.6218940019607544,
-0.7856725454330444,
-0.40614789724349976,
-0.16820484399795532,
-0.6691638231277466,
0.30851903557777405,
-0.5152625441551208,
0.42298004031181335,
-0.1258825957775116,
-0.2646093964576721,
0.6798700094223022,
-0.09410282224416733,
1.3718715906143188,
-0.1442759931087494,
-0.26795265078544617,
0.18702289462089539,
0.24073123931884766,
0.3264347314834595,
-0.11622491478919983,
0.1867072880268097,
-0.041828010231256485,
-0.20594890415668488,
-0.241621196269989,
-0.5873882174491882,
0.5045965909957886,
-1.059816837310791,
-0.7430983781814575,
-0.3453733026981354,
-0.5100753307342529,
-0.2580055892467499,
0.2955758273601532,
-0.03368845954537392,
0.20731812715530396,
-0.1103224903345108,
0.11672145873308182,
0.6484155654907227,
-0.00505234207957983,
0.5480917096138,
0.7233982682228088,
-0.31747546792030334,
-0.20659224689006805,
0.9459360241889954,
0.3745938837528229,
0.2693558633327484,
0.37664058804512024,
0.35382676124572754,
-0.5825101137161255,
-0.4590883255004883,
-0.32244256138801575,
0.2622656524181366,
-0.6543833613395691,
-0.06318189948797226,
-0.7270084023475647,
-0.21166567504405975,
-0.3173597753047943,
-0.22370696067810059,
-0.7015048265457153,
-0.0024669424165040255,
-0.6272615790367126,
-0.288507878780365,
0.15232886373996735,
1.2523465156555176,
-0.4653622508049011,
0.31201136112213135,
-0.6188523173332214,
0.10856751352548599,
0.671100914478302,
0.23686274886131287,
0.19510751962661743,
-0.5294873714447021,
-0.43139174580574036,
-0.09935515373945236,
-0.2510884404182434,
-0.27529311180114746,
0.4837403893470764,
0.3165246546268463,
0.6414172053337097,
0.419420450925827,
0.4094756543636322,
0.5240195989608765,
-0.5866480469703674,
0.4293871521949768,
-0.028248116374015808,
-0.9202268719673157,
0.6022746562957764,
-0.4440908432006836,
0.20361047983169556,
0.6626952290534973,
0.7288159132003784,
-0.16645552217960358,
-0.584778904914856,
-0.485636830329895,
-0.8487696647644043,
0.5283504128456116,
-0.4050222635269165,
0.18282055854797363,
-0.03671908378601074,
0.4138025939464569,
0.33264434337615967,
0.013432659208774567,
-0.994293749332428,
-0.08258383721113205,
0.06657545268535614,
-0.2019384354352951,
-0.48781639337539673,
0.190185084939003,
0.029926270246505737,
-0.5543522834777832,
0.7556068897247314,
-0.3813728094100952,
0.0035780041944235563,
0.39385977387428284,
-0.27221378684043884,
-0.009510813280940056,
-0.19592247903347015,
0.1377098709344864,
0.4702357053756714,
0.11137900501489639,
0.42041051387786865,
0.0757957324385643,
0.03227589651942253,
0.3397519588470459,
-0.14288029074668884,
0.009776190854609013,
-0.42869487404823303,
0.5054965019226074,
0.41338929533958435,
0.1874397248029709,
-0.8739292025566101,
0.3204852342605591,
0.046299152076244354,
-0.1634676158428192,
-0.6016896963119507,
0.4891776442527771,
0.1670348048210144,
0.5368981957435608,
0.6263392567634583,
-0.019984278827905655,
-0.33927690982818604,
-0.40264540910720825,
0.4381885230541229,
0.419905424118042,
-0.5536701083183289,
-0.25779423117637634,
0.870722234249115,
0.1999594271183014,
-0.42756980657577515,
0.41617387533187866,
-0.05561186745762825,
-0.15620173513889313,
0.4036642014980316,
0.4020482301712036,
0.703362226486206,
-0.4726392924785614,
0.22165082395076752,
0.11013118177652359,
0.5367647409439087,
-0.32261228561401367,
-0.41782960295677185,
-0.46163731813430786,
-0.6774173378944397,
-0.4330977201461792,
-0.5063045620918274,
-0.5127187967300415,
0.13672681152820587,
-0.4405483901500702,
0.06488196551799774,
-0.7361879944801331,
0.4956548511981964,
0.03593005985021591,
0.019870437681674957,
-0.3883236348628998,
0.5039954781532288,
0.06211638078093529,
0.6832686066627502,
-0.7117586135864258,
1.110060453414917,
0.4525441825389862,
-0.41775625944137573,
-0.7821029424667358,
-0.06918902695178986,
-0.06725263595581055,
-0.7957964539527893,
0.6721122860908508,
0.33492791652679443,
-0.42781761288642883,
0.29681774973869324,
-0.5946848392486572,
-0.786479651927948,
1.0058130025863647,
0.5092337131500244,
-0.4022458791732788,
-0.1865421086549759,
0.002758207032456994,
0.6149691343307495,
-0.32179582118988037,
0.2500251233577728,
0.47799110412597656,
0.19783560931682587,
-0.2700200080871582,
-0.830923318862915,
-0.2400086373090744,
0.02478983998298645,
-0.4322957694530487,
-0.09420625120401382,
-0.8671312928199768,
0.6795470714569092,
-0.22281916439533234,
-0.13384173810482025,
0.02955825999379158,
0.9256590008735657,
-0.3797658681869507,
0.050485845655202866,
0.3240397572517395,
0.15742331743240356,
0.8085852265357971,
0.16156388819217682,
0.7945795655250549,
-0.24134458601474762,
0.18731188774108887,
1.385226845741272,
-0.15197336673736572,
0.936724066734314,
0.21254213154315948,
0.004844763316214085,
0.5425518751144409,
0.3649055063724518,
0.1538538783788681,
0.43992969393730164,
-0.033327940851449966,
-0.4780360162258148,
-0.6498364806175232,
0.08008579909801483,
0.04696491360664368,
0.9949151873588562,
0.2989237308502197,
-0.31605619192123413,
-0.28582191467285156,
0.17383846640586853,
-0.17752458155155182,
0.5965241193771362,
-0.3688165247440338,
1.0730456113815308,
0.05166206881403923,
-0.6792252063751221,
0.48665541410446167,
-0.15240271389484406,
0.7371147871017456,
-0.7277958393096924,
0.18342767655849457,
-0.11497339606285095,
0.39615193009376526,
-0.2119443565607071,
-0.3838624060153961,
0.5392242670059204,
-0.046610601246356964,
0.023641487583518028,
-0.5359587669372559,
0.5516837239265442,
-0.4380752742290497,
-0.45646432042121887,
0.5713905096054077,
0.9338647723197937,
0.06551908701658249,
0.06488008797168732,
-0.4785400331020355,
-0.3973422050476074,
-0.1690414845943451,
-0.17299990355968475,
0.6408800482749939,
0.45161327719688416,
0.0943131148815155,
1.1645081043243408,
0.5087618231773376,
-0.10217271000146866,
-0.03737315535545349,
-0.520922839641571,
0.7418961524963379,
-0.562817394733429,
-0.41503071784973145,
-0.9856905341148376,
0.269806832075119,
0.3262310326099396,
-0.1589621901512146,
0.9205272197723389,
0.45875221490859985,
1.0042033195495605,
0.0753328800201416,
1.0632851123809814,
0.3040792942047119,
0.670676052570343,
-0.4363120496273041,
0.95068359375,
-0.6979227066040039,
0.20090579986572266,
0.05443085357546806,
-0.43892425298690796,
-0.3286104202270508,
0.6872317790985107,
-0.562116801738739,
-0.012561416253447533,
0.2844860553741455,
0.6584869027137756,
0.10804504156112671,
0.0000884410401340574,
0.49127066135406494,
0.1501302719116211,
0.18820717930793762,
0.2841436564922333,
0.9304104447364807,
0.1391320824623108,
0.29567381739616394,
-0.29758790135383606,
-0.2669178247451782,
0.02927207574248314,
-0.6804547309875488,
-1.1578236818313599,
-0.7238165736198425,
-0.09605485200881958,
0.13612328469753265,
0.11149587482213974,
1.3791853189468384,
0.7210920453071594,
-0.4500368535518646,
-0.38789916038513184,
-0.29684391617774963,
0.20053568482398987,
-0.10614913702011108,
-0.14912688732147217,
0.3190864026546478,
-0.7802591919898987,
-0.8522855043411255,
0.9086260795593262,
0.2728910446166992,
0.14772765338420868,
-0.7660500407218933,
0.0006032696692273021,
-0.15999570488929749,
0.0008155443938449025,
0.4020022451877594,
0.5327363610267639,
-0.596718966960907,
-0.25153371691703796,
-0.12524129450321198,
-0.10550037026405334,
0.08542432636022568,
0.5672440528869629,
-1.1912386417388916,
0.39645135402679443,
-0.1997418999671936,
1.0553025007247925,
0.25494399666786194,
-0.08990057557821274,
0.4790480434894562,
-0.7601152062416077,
-0.031742289662361145,
0.19997963309288025,
-0.1053171306848526,
0.19328731298446655,
-0.5630236268043518,
0.37241050601005554,
0.24324385821819305,
-0.7547768950462341,
-0.5439441800117493,
0.07847131788730621,
-0.4479254484176636,
-0.39228367805480957,
1.0219743251800537,
-0.1622767150402069,
-0.2601975202560425,
-0.23732517659664154,
-0.052612680941820145,
0.28540337085723877,
-0.18037930130958557,
1.1287943124771118,
0.27554288506507874,
-0.25517791509628296,
-0.26783934235572815,
-0.621381938457489,
0.5718840956687927,
0.432364821434021,
-0.9731152653694153,
0.2928422689437866,
0.4356864392757416,
0.2862589955329895,
-0.03272581472992897,
0.644315242767334,
0.23347099125385284,
0.008820309303700924,
-0.14544612169265747,
0.21193420886993408,
-0.3777448832988739,
-0.8262736201286316,
-0.5719365477561951,
0.1571485549211502,
0.005597218405455351,
-0.12098467350006104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00605v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00605v1
|
LongSkywork: A Training Recipe for Efficiently Extending Context Length in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-02T03:34:41
| 2024-06-02T03:34:41
|
Liang Zhao, Tianwen Wei, Liang Zeng, Cheng Cheng, Liu Yang, Peng Cheng, Lijie Wang, Chenxia Li, Xuejie Wu, Bo Zhu, Yimeng Gan, Rui Hu, Shuicheng Yan, Han Fang, Yahui Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce LongSkywork, a long-context Large Language Model (LLM) capable
of processing up to 200,000 tokens. We provide a training recipe for
efficiently extending context length of LLMs. We identify that the critical
element in enhancing long-context processing capability is to incorporate a
long-context SFT stage following the standard SFT stage. A mere 200 iterations
can convert the standard SFT model into a long-context model. To reduce the
effort in collecting and annotating data for long-context language modeling, we
develop two novel methods for creating synthetic data. These methods are
applied during the continual pretraining phase as well as the Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) phase, greatly enhancing the training efficiency of our
long-context LLMs. Our findings suggest that synthetic long-context SFT data
can surpass the performance of data curated by humans to some extent.
LongSkywork achieves outstanding performance on a variety of long-context
benchmarks. In the Needle test, a benchmark for long-context information
retrieval, our models achieved perfect accuracy across multiple context spans.
Moreover, in realistic application scenarios, LongSkywork-13B demonstrates
performance on par with Claude2.1, the leading long-context model, underscoring
the effectiveness of our proposed methods.
|
[
-0.07321903854608536,
-0.7754101753234863,
0.7644566297531128,
0.450762540102005,
-0.30269157886505127,
0.0482870489358902,
-0.5825907588005066,
-0.8185303211212158,
0.11555051058530807,
0.8263552784919739,
-0.6209534406661987,
-0.5401670336723328,
-0.2544851005077362,
0.16525843739509583,
-0.6060572266578674,
0.8695456385612488,
-0.1975477784872055,
-0.005209191702306271,
-0.22494903206825256,
0.05950157344341278,
-0.5391360521316528,
-0.5580132603645325,
-0.5750152468681335,
-0.3027518093585968,
0.7192490696907043,
0.41043558716773987,
0.2682991027832031,
0.6898506283760071,
0.17498381435871124,
0.29210734367370605,
0.00421867286786437,
0.0864662379026413,
-0.7560190558433533,
0.25580114126205444,
-0.2429867535829544,
-0.2666594386100769,
-0.5878565311431885,
-0.10281018167734146,
0.7463049292564392,
0.8059017062187195,
0.0956619381904602,
0.07949397712945938,
0.07913784682750702,
0.8123822808265686,
-0.49136507511138916,
0.1504867821931839,
-0.41515859961509705,
0.0041006323881447315,
-0.39735087752342224,
-0.15201124548912048,
-0.6041003465652466,
0.018122248351573944,
0.11992105841636658,
-0.6312383413314819,
-0.0852910652756691,
0.047893814742565155,
0.13446305692195892,
0.020952844992280006,
-0.7624797224998474,
-0.2217140644788742,
-0.7481990456581116,
0.9264875650405884,
-0.5376330614089966,
0.573593020439148,
0.5251576900482178,
0.31954705715179443,
-0.375821977853775,
-1.0334616899490356,
-0.25957635045051575,
-0.5383986830711365,
-0.08103375881910324,
0.030544830486178398,
0.21893024444580078,
0.25189924240112305,
0.3995558023452759,
0.15478229522705078,
-0.5796104669570923,
0.17614832520484924,
-0.7701029777526855,
0.04436562582850456,
0.5872964859008789,
0.09832891821861267,
-0.14884965121746063,
-0.11685412377119064,
-0.5386109352111816,
0.14201728999614716,
-0.7811371088027954,
0.10313218832015991,
0.22992339730262756,
0.29679831862449646,
0.13812418282032013,
0.5112982988357544,
-0.7182831764221191,
0.8190909028053284,
-0.21991513669490814,
-0.0543229803442955,
0.18846556544303894,
-0.29457005858421326,
-0.26950743794441223,
0.052179571241140366,
0.48030102252960205,
0.28380629420280457,
0.21103151142597198,
-0.32962942123413086,
-0.3181091845035553,
-0.2158416360616684,
0.25042787194252014,
-1.0833215713500977,
0.01655374839901924,
0.12391619384288788,
-0.15424847602844238,
-0.23359103500843048,
-0.054356899112463,
-0.39599037170410156,
-0.14524804055690765,
-0.7689775228500366,
0.33803263306617737,
-0.5785776972770691,
-0.2141401767730713,
0.39184969663619995,
-0.00031603118986822665,
0.016814207658171654,
0.30665767192840576,
-0.7442448735237122,
0.32549145817756653,
1.1475234031677246,
0.7139855027198792,
-0.4730203449726105,
-0.6281309127807617,
-0.594304084777832,
0.19639797508716583,
-0.5277064442634583,
0.5492111444473267,
-0.470354288816452,
-0.249757319688797,
0.014353650622069836,
0.32573431730270386,
0.2120949625968933,
-0.5965061783790588,
0.29198357462882996,
-0.40986648201942444,
0.0686749815940857,
-0.13668125867843628,
-0.7410274744033813,
0.11746121197938919,
0.2561103105545044,
-0.743575930595398,
1.3935805559158325,
0.3909858465194702,
-0.4379139542579651,
0.40619969367980957,
-0.9322271347045898,
-0.6430519223213196,
0.16734851896762848,
0.06398732960224152,
-0.11031189560890198,
0.24402615427970886,
-0.1493694931268692,
0.7604930996894836,
-0.183997243642807,
0.5441694855690002,
-0.29082292318344116,
-0.7172338366508484,
0.25757896900177,
-0.10903611779212952,
0.514045000076294,
0.12953884899616241,
-0.1878998577594757,
0.28050071001052856,
-0.9219120144844055,
-0.036329176276922226,
-0.05022817477583885,
-0.4852037727832794,
-0.49262985587120056,
-0.0503915473818779,
0.20886777341365814,
0.14417599141597748,
0.22175650298595428,
-0.5703504085540771,
0.3737589716911316,
-0.4044688045978546,
0.520226001739502,
0.8483964800834656,
-0.4708612263202667,
0.4620518684387207,
-0.07463599741458893,
0.41050779819488525,
-0.02366725727915764,
0.04094117879867554,
-0.29633858799934387,
0.14341573417186737,
-0.7937107682228088,
-0.33325135707855225,
0.16203276813030243,
0.28075242042541504,
-0.7030187845230103,
0.5377956032752991,
-0.5862282514572144,
-0.4108039140701294,
-0.15473410487174988,
0.19624869525432587,
0.20813684165477753,
0.4081241488456726,
0.4877561032772064,
-0.24640151858329773,
-0.8227404356002808,
-1.0637657642364502,
-0.29974910616874695,
0.2902269959449768,
-0.10554734617471695,
0.04091533645987511,
0.6805621981620789,
-0.35704469680786133,
1.1629629135131836,
-0.47132739424705505,
-0.025376811623573303,
-0.28755441308021545,
-0.010813171043992043,
0.35339656472206116,
0.6143157482147217,
0.3791535496711731,
-0.5097609162330627,
-0.505654513835907,
-0.025659577921032906,
-0.5298354029655457,
0.13208135962486267,
-0.05208856239914894,
-0.24466735124588013,
0.3059101402759552,
0.8220028281211853,
-0.6577631831169128,
0.256268173456192,
0.5340116024017334,
-0.39815041422843933,
0.7159880995750427,
0.07941723614931107,
0.04866135120391846,
-1.3866702318191528,
0.32743707299232483,
-0.27790021896362305,
-0.6124945878982544,
-0.8502929210662842,
0.11957638710737228,
0.26048627495765686,
-0.28597626090049744,
-0.6417819857597351,
0.7487291693687439,
-0.4037415087223053,
0.1368427276611328,
-0.4165034890174866,
-0.24312824010849,
-0.1388087123632431,
0.3823483884334564,
0.12340077757835388,
0.8369308114051819,
0.42222973704338074,
-0.2637970745563507,
0.7233032584190369,
-0.19944031536579132,
-0.6637693047523499,
0.5092807412147522,
-0.5722402334213257,
0.2413889467716217,
-0.004254772327840328,
0.7886471748352051,
-0.6455984115600586,
-0.46750757098197937,
-0.08563030511140823,
-0.129815012216568,
0.30610236525535583,
-0.36666983366012573,
-0.6626657843589783,
-0.362846702337265,
-0.29232552647590637,
0.5850948691368103,
0.47003045678138733,
-0.7503252625465393,
0.26727530360221863,
-0.09468628466129303,
-0.06978483498096466,
-0.4720505475997925,
-0.590606689453125,
0.2905563712120056,
-0.5263917446136475,
-0.7521172761917114,
0.4696069657802582,
-0.1713617593050003,
0.05332118272781372,
-0.35269150137901306,
-0.001225768937729299,
-0.1801835298538208,
0.0780329629778862,
0.2660284638404846,
-0.09281721711158752,
-0.21417835354804993,
0.30799999833106995,
-0.18028715252876282,
-0.2673783600330353,
0.1296333372592926,
-0.4098982810974121,
0.5767046213150024,
-0.0896863043308258,
-0.14995704591274261,
-0.25960850715637207,
0.5361153483390808,
0.5124293565750122,
-0.02607046440243721,
0.8448588848114014,
0.6485366225242615,
-0.5026665329933167,
-0.40620434284210205,
-0.5859329700469971,
-0.23742669820785522,
-0.5044049620628357,
0.6791947484016418,
-0.41758233308792114,
-1.270452857017517,
0.3069033622741699,
-0.35703372955322266,
-0.11200811713933945,
0.19767910242080688,
0.2618270218372345,
0.03858590126037598,
0.8487729430198669,
0.7265637516975403,
-0.21309307217597961,
0.6386473178863525,
-0.22250190377235413,
0.03465642035007477,
-0.7690945267677307,
0.01090560294687748,
-0.2034364491701126,
-0.16036123037338257,
-0.39464113116264343,
-0.44140833616256714,
0.24585574865341187,
0.17488247156143188,
-0.20127718150615692,
0.4944439232349396,
-0.3042047619819641,
0.8689472675323486,
0.4445572793483734,
0.15565548837184906,
0.15014439821243286,
-0.054136089980602264,
0.25520655512809753,
0.13685999810695648,
-0.35267114639282227,
-0.12224415689706802,
1.1337491273880005,
0.41703662276268005,
0.6707030534744263,
-0.10076117515563965,
0.8276234269142151,
-0.0836578980088234,
0.2811080515384674,
-0.8006558418273926,
0.5427165627479553,
-0.06816175580024719,
-0.7450816035270691,
-0.5754001140594482,
-0.3433760106563568,
-0.9382281303405762,
-0.055659014731645584,
-0.045282430946826935,
-0.6424242854118347,
-0.44070735573768616,
0.07165385782718658,
-0.15700846910476685,
-0.03405170515179634,
-0.5877021551132202,
0.9246883392333984,
-0.2794145941734314,
-0.5883816480636597,
-0.4469927251338959,
-0.5359876155853271,
0.31695741415023804,
-0.4402470588684082,
0.055679623037576675,
-0.1367882341146469,
0.19508500397205353,
0.8583734035491943,
-0.3097658157348633,
0.8975960612297058,
-0.16236601769924164,
-0.15947560966014862,
0.07859448343515396,
0.023647861555218697,
0.7273522019386292,
0.06683139503002167,
-0.21098317205905914,
0.04302450641989708,
0.1873946338891983,
-0.572952926158905,
-0.4275689423084259,
0.8140486478805542,
-0.3638051748275757,
-0.47665637731552124,
-0.3384765386581421,
-0.5478394031524658,
-0.15627916157245636,
0.4304589331150055,
0.014402397908270359,
0.5099665522575378,
-0.29854756593704224,
0.828646719455719,
0.21599946916103363,
-0.020523803308606148,
0.2154848575592041,
0.3068746328353882,
-0.3273431658744812,
-0.15107667446136475,
0.5890153050422668,
0.11332283169031143,
0.3192874491214752,
0.355400025844574,
0.18111035227775574,
-0.17714551091194153,
-0.5948609113693237,
-0.13791263103485107,
0.051683563739061356,
-0.6815284490585327,
-0.11169037967920303,
-0.23782995343208313,
-0.20589232444763184,
-0.3838309943675995,
-0.32049882411956787,
-0.6168147921562195,
-0.3330150246620178,
-0.12197977304458618,
-0.09913939237594604,
0.4176047444343567,
0.6515974998474121,
0.09880547225475311,
0.38487064838409424,
-0.6657508015632629,
0.10305342078208923,
0.3193749487400055,
0.7760436534881592,
-0.1686415672302246,
-0.3099624514579773,
-0.7270748019218445,
0.1293884515762329,
-0.07837632298469543,
-0.39008063077926636,
0.22297459840774536,
0.08575090765953064,
0.07840470969676971,
0.045702315866947174,
-0.12808676064014435,
0.9719215631484985,
-0.7238851189613342,
0.7501797676086426,
0.17137712240219116,
-0.7930374145507812,
0.4181986153125763,
-0.630579948425293,
0.46508821845054626,
0.5983099937438965,
0.267536997795105,
-0.6751617193222046,
-0.049128174781799316,
-0.1836979240179062,
-1.055111050605774,
0.6410862803459167,
0.08517352491617203,
0.22018948197364807,
-0.17136478424072266,
0.40784525871276855,
0.3788119852542877,
-0.09124533087015152,
-0.8441681265830994,
0.3535420298576355,
0.05854916572570801,
-0.17386676371097565,
-0.3328770697116852,
-0.38689061999320984,
-0.18740881979465485,
-0.46120575070381165,
0.555558979511261,
-0.3308171033859253,
0.009494739584624767,
0.07702253758907318,
-0.3467579483985901,
-0.035073161125183105,
0.3010135591030121,
0.7593250274658203,
1.1363298892974854,
-0.30597570538520813,
0.1432078629732132,
0.5405392646789551,
-0.24877069890499115,
-0.10513724386692047,
0.05384271964430809,
0.35788339376449585,
-0.2403060644865036,
0.6201843619346619,
0.8582980036735535,
0.41141006350517273,
-0.7744075059890747,
0.4181084930896759,
0.0730617418885231,
-0.1975904405117035,
-0.9021238684654236,
0.0472874641418457,
0.39461997151374817,
0.32305610179901123,
0.40891116857528687,
-0.4886295199394226,
0.15220889449119568,
-0.6656389832496643,
0.21124842762947083,
0.37255921959877014,
-0.13981199264526367,
-0.3144586384296417,
0.18003129959106445,
0.1640537828207016,
-0.29269927740097046,
0.6677207946777344,
0.1584368646144867,
-0.34525609016418457,
0.451259970664978,
0.8056566119194031,
0.6762638092041016,
-0.0899963229894638,
-0.3262275755405426,
0.24061155319213867,
-0.11424581706523895,
-0.33321017026901245,
-0.05467021092772484,
-0.18035052716732025,
-0.22005167603492737,
-0.8129241466522217,
-0.8608977794647217,
-0.07603348791599274,
0.5108522772789001,
-0.5623243451118469,
0.47391220927238464,
-0.26752761006355286,
0.018684349954128265,
-0.058014947921037674,
0.0965425968170166,
-0.6674435138702393,
0.19610363245010376,
0.03531115874648094,
1.0201778411865234,
-0.5894735455513,
1.060823917388916,
0.38811203837394714,
0.28485652804374695,
-0.4378706216812134,
-0.26646310091018677,
-0.21697844564914703,
-0.6574941873550415,
0.7964479923248291,
0.7309602499008179,
-0.07622159272432327,
-0.03466195985674858,
-0.7129936218261719,
-0.8389988541603088,
1.2205662727355957,
0.14766713976860046,
-0.7762400507926941,
-0.10982071608304977,
0.46507829427719116,
0.5744473338127136,
-0.353519082069397,
-0.23582568764686584,
0.7411680221557617,
0.4346303343772888,
0.028846416622400284,
-1.021313190460205,
0.1641813963651657,
-0.15541298687458038,
-0.05721098929643631,
0.46107661724090576,
-0.3801250755786896,
0.5467059016227722,
0.2474357634782791,
-0.050909679383039474,
0.35287749767303467,
0.6658802032470703,
0.2762053310871124,
0.2775057852268219,
0.6057234406471252,
0.4291699230670929,
0.32503071427345276,
0.07375596463680267,
0.7545842528343201,
-0.38140034675598145,
0.31200364232063293,
1.0542107820510864,
-0.2244514524936676,
0.9196518659591675,
0.6690440773963928,
0.01043608132749796,
0.19571553170681,
0.5967200994491577,
0.23909123241901398,
0.2785315215587616,
0.5150943398475647,
-0.3252347409725189,
-0.36771613359451294,
0.11124797910451889,
-0.3757568597793579,
0.5111892819404602,
0.22775974869728088,
-0.3268847167491913,
-0.027543656527996063,
-0.0338028259575367,
0.2018282115459442,
-0.20633918046951294,
0.01752488501369953,
0.648197591304779,
0.3086017966270447,
-0.956174373626709,
0.8302720189094543,
0.19416481256484985,
0.7851443886756897,
-0.7343724370002747,
0.1014949306845665,
-0.15211065113544464,
0.32983624935150146,
-0.10453496128320694,
-0.6448169350624084,
0.3208274245262146,
-0.09322726726531982,
-0.060200680047273636,
-0.46115419268608093,
0.6442071795463562,
-0.6188562512397766,
-0.5735827684402466,
0.3549199104309082,
0.11382312327623367,
0.07362203299999237,
-0.2292148321866989,
-0.33025622367858887,
0.059333235025405884,
-0.14425493776798248,
-0.5666624903678894,
0.5561702251434326,
0.31108999252319336,
-0.1532430499792099,
0.5039873719215393,
0.9279830455780029,
0.028009582310914993,
-0.16457237303256989,
-0.12710361182689667,
0.9080654382705688,
-0.9971977472305298,
-0.5049453973770142,
-0.973175048828125,
0.5665037631988525,
-0.1763836145401001,
-0.2860085666179657,
0.3993787467479706,
0.8375390768051147,
0.876647412776947,
-0.21428391337394714,
0.5226402282714844,
0.1940467357635498,
0.573302686214447,
-0.8418801426887512,
0.6137104630470276,
-0.5903124213218689,
-0.01562199741601944,
0.05161164700984955,
-1.168796181678772,
-0.2945915460586548,
0.4380906820297241,
-0.26333290338516235,
-0.005487548187375069,
0.7318193912506104,
0.6698606014251709,
-0.4987866282463074,
-0.1181267499923706,
0.2972162067890167,
0.24256804585456848,
0.5245242714881897,
0.715160608291626,
0.8039566874504089,
-0.14765991270542145,
0.15474733710289001,
-0.3384440839290619,
-0.1525147259235382,
-0.3664056658744812,
-1.1288732290267944,
-1.0550369024276733,
-0.7483082413673401,
0.17595316469669342,
-0.18239930272102356,
0.2004176378250122,
1.0646905899047852,
1.051190972328186,
-0.44462552666664124,
-0.5085455179214478,
0.06441228836774826,
-0.38605961203575134,
0.13299815356731415,
-0.1852695494890213,
0.2658841907978058,
-0.26121047139167786,
-0.551558792591095,
0.9779694080352783,
0.16380161046981812,
-0.02457589842379093,
-0.21347282826900482,
-0.255260169506073,
0.026341279968619347,
-0.0689711719751358,
1.0777450799942017,
0.18803496658802032,
-0.5696286559104919,
-0.5922384262084961,
0.08907966315746307,
0.09918024390935898,
-0.04510752111673355,
0.82193922996521,
-0.7710562348365784,
0.35978373885154724,
0.37060922384262085,
0.4295179843902588,
0.8827951550483704,
0.005963467061519623,
0.6062860488891602,
-1.0004957914352417,
0.4547516405582428,
0.2049681395292282,
0.2561429738998413,
0.2678859531879425,
-0.23464323580265045,
0.6388314962387085,
0.0012521663447842002,
-0.600128710269928,
-1.115775465965271,
0.31949958205223083,
-0.9789708852767944,
-0.5032715797424316,
1.3055987358093262,
0.12244579941034317,
-0.2557479739189148,
0.21361112594604492,
-0.17026975750923157,
0.24954552948474884,
-0.13595107197761536,
0.8080922961235046,
0.8210014700889587,
-0.0067672161385416985,
0.19848360121250153,
-0.7145298719406128,
0.6595936417579651,
0.36078065633773804,
-0.8876073360443115,
0.39364638924598694,
0.5237477421760559,
0.593560516834259,
-0.011625104583799839,
0.6340225338935852,
0.10377458482980728,
0.21564623713493347,
-0.4158704876899719,
-0.18895836174488068,
-0.3517567813396454,
-0.6016448736190796,
-0.1196717843413353,
-0.14710474014282227,
0.06732699275016785,
0.29588139057159424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00562v1
|
SPAGHETTI: Open-Domain Question Answering from Heterogeneous Data Sources with Retrieval and Semantic Parsing
| 2024-06-01T21:54:09
| 2024-06-01T21:54:09
|
Heidi C. Zhang, Sina J. Semnani, Farhad Ghassemi, Jialiang Xu, Shicheng Liu, Monica S. Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce SPAGHETTI: Semantic Parsing Augmented Generation for Hybrid
English information from Text Tables and Infoboxes, a hybrid question-answering
(QA) pipeline that utilizes information from heterogeneous knowledge sources,
including knowledge base, text, tables, and infoboxes. Our LLM-augmented
approach achieves state-of-the-art performance on the Compmix dataset, the most
comprehensive heterogeneous open-domain QA dataset, with 56.5% exact match (EM)
rate. More importantly, manual analysis on a sample of the dataset suggests
that SPAGHETTI is more than 90% accurate, indicating that EM is no longer
suitable for assessing the capabilities of QA systems today.
|
[
-0.5636990070343018,
-1.2477591037750244,
0.5289978981018066,
0.2639259696006775,
0.1901419460773468,
0.3545215129852295,
0.2503865361213684,
-0.3042723536491394,
0.4216310381889343,
0.5642072558403015,
-0.48354294896125793,
-0.40677914023399353,
-0.04312323033809662,
0.22262918949127197,
-0.32751041650772095,
0.970445454120636,
-0.1835508495569229,
0.09830353409051895,
-0.46742480993270874,
-0.046480972319841385,
-0.17329828441143036,
-0.27496322989463806,
-0.16547846794128418,
-0.08390525728464127,
0.41296613216400146,
0.7387785315513611,
1.2055615186691284,
0.7407561540603638,
0.23746781051158905,
0.29045960307121277,
0.28157544136047363,
0.3959372341632843,
-0.47369256615638733,
0.05696049705147743,
-0.5070985555648804,
-0.634054958820343,
-0.5721360445022583,
-0.024255134165287018,
0.5601559281349182,
0.9037066102027893,
0.03940509632229805,
0.31746283173561096,
-0.20427067577838898,
0.548463761806488,
-0.9532727003097534,
-0.12670323252677917,
-0.9239368438720703,
0.3039309084415436,
-0.20912353694438934,
-0.6173096299171448,
-0.4145991802215576,
-0.5424627065658569,
0.003408953547477722,
-1.1051255464553833,
0.2542457580566406,
0.45250311493873596,
1.131611943244934,
0.12303851544857025,
-0.27997881174087524,
-0.24118337035179138,
-0.6327232122421265,
0.5750682950019836,
-0.6781929135322571,
0.3091884255409241,
0.30886274576187134,
0.3761560618877411,
-0.5149906873703003,
-0.9842458367347717,
-0.8936084508895874,
0.10276170819997787,
0.18561065196990967,
0.18990403413772583,
-0.036838434636592865,
-0.03310103714466095,
0.2210787534713745,
0.6804959774017334,
-0.7855890393257141,
-0.15655022859573364,
-0.350689172744751,
0.018186630681157112,
0.555042028427124,
0.41344502568244934,
0.8373916149139404,
-0.09842293709516525,
-0.5851427912712097,
0.17992737889289856,
-0.6825078129768372,
-0.21576668322086334,
0.3730793595314026,
-0.042389772832393646,
0.18140514194965363,
1.1424524784088135,
-0.48148322105407715,
0.9398986101150513,
0.006854478735476732,
-0.11622883379459381,
0.16590158641338348,
-0.4209739565849304,
-0.3398315906524658,
-0.01963113807141781,
0.7210289239883423,
0.4860154688358307,
0.14350932836532593,
-0.5126392245292664,
0.25283172726631165,
0.14847496151924133,
0.1683763563632965,
-0.16005122661590576,
-0.369686484336853,
0.5392476916313171,
0.11324232816696167,
0.041283443570137024,
0.20386114716529846,
-1.3117878437042236,
-0.17846325039863586,
-0.21326759457588196,
0.26573824882507324,
-0.3469855487346649,
-0.25923284888267517,
0.23566219210624695,
-0.22364623844623566,
0.3895968496799469,
0.22933237254619598,
-0.4733610153198242,
0.4855133295059204,
0.5979602336883545,
0.5026321411132812,
-0.3156691789627075,
-0.503808856010437,
-0.7586180567741394,
0.49600914120674133,
-0.4508582651615143,
1.2240854501724243,
-0.44273731112480164,
0.02906697988510132,
0.1043182760477066,
-0.011115258559584618,
-0.1758522242307663,
-0.8225139379501343,
0.2731238603591919,
-0.7574880719184875,
0.48373258113861084,
0.044298380613327026,
-0.8428556323051453,
0.05538493022322655,
0.46385714411735535,
-0.7539005279541016,
1.236561894416809,
0.3456752896308899,
-0.9504634141921997,
0.3582158386707306,
-0.5003364086151123,
-0.08919019997119904,
0.07969140261411667,
-0.002728002378717065,
-0.18835346400737762,
-0.166115865111351,
0.16490311920642853,
0.0964110940694809,
-0.5421621799468994,
0.2896571159362793,
-0.6580239534378052,
-0.14483143389225006,
0.23912671208381653,
-0.11965402215719223,
0.4093724191188812,
0.43739959597587585,
-0.15424592792987823,
0.006553412415087223,
-0.859093189239502,
0.4315846264362335,
0.15883401036262512,
-0.48663485050201416,
-0.359510600566864,
0.1449299156665802,
-0.12188233435153961,
0.505438506603241,
0.18280251324176788,
-0.7648816108703613,
0.26222044229507446,
-0.6851126551628113,
0.07350870221853256,
0.5514896512031555,
-0.03593072295188904,
0.37679046392440796,
-0.3838436007499695,
0.5302541255950928,
0.2648676633834839,
-0.01486209500581026,
0.10318498313426971,
-0.7323936223983765,
-0.9170440435409546,
-0.12442218512296677,
0.30789056420326233,
0.9906517863273621,
-1.3606743812561035,
0.3403097689151764,
-0.3258933424949646,
-0.3257928192615509,
-0.6500248908996582,
0.21183377504348755,
0.2854236960411072,
0.5577120780944824,
0.4652079641819,
0.06704475730657578,
-0.5758694410324097,
-0.9300061464309692,
-0.41647639870643616,
-0.14256399869918823,
-0.0611463338136673,
0.06909794360399246,
0.23958857357501984,
-0.02056155540049076,
1.2078146934509277,
-0.7798874974250793,
0.13499456644058228,
-0.2961837351322174,
-0.09882096201181412,
0.11771693825721741,
0.3793826699256897,
0.10711273550987244,
-0.9400995969772339,
-0.711304783821106,
0.16391387581825256,
-0.9734823107719421,
-0.1860729455947876,
0.2953875958919525,
-0.46110379695892334,
0.07800058275461197,
0.36731210350990295,
-0.4479679465293884,
0.22939561307430267,
0.6035833358764648,
-0.7269707322120667,
0.45997804403305054,
0.0802232176065445,
0.3458649218082428,
-1.4879217147827148,
-0.013972177170217037,
-0.2713059186935425,
-0.2512560486793518,
-0.5425118803977966,
0.20262934267520905,
-0.0913534015417099,
-0.4136793911457062,
-0.6328175067901611,
0.586813747882843,
-0.463534951210022,
-0.2252635508775711,
-0.04573938995599747,
0.3608253598213196,
0.29390138387680054,
0.431234210729599,
-0.1793050467967987,
1.160210132598877,
0.302924245595932,
-0.3072197735309601,
0.678938090801239,
0.20718595385551453,
-0.2564490735530853,
0.45957523584365845,
-0.5495985746383667,
0.12575441598892212,
0.05964996665716171,
-0.17881865799427032,
-1.0599117279052734,
-0.5919619798660278,
0.2865012288093567,
-0.2629172205924988,
-0.11661610007286072,
0.24241949617862701,
-0.8508351445198059,
-0.2894931137561798,
-0.4507898688316345,
0.37420791387557983,
0.1717878133058548,
-0.649860680103302,
0.6444302797317505,
0.5495179295539856,
-0.2345111072063446,
-0.44784554839134216,
-0.45734795928001404,
-0.08157278597354889,
-0.07768145948648453,
-1.011587381362915,
0.23899701237678528,
-0.08993516117334366,
-0.32131731510162354,
0.3394276201725006,
-0.08029806613922119,
-0.716084897518158,
-0.02062768116593361,
-0.04198434576392174,
0.4301983416080475,
-0.547767162322998,
-0.047883499413728714,
0.3160180151462555,
0.030035480856895447,
-0.11532297730445862,
0.005786862690001726,
0.6856773495674133,
0.02729073539376259,
-0.2677243649959564,
-0.11337020248174667,
0.7400380373001099,
0.44826048612594604,
-0.11308630555868149,
0.724926769733429,
0.1449105143547058,
-0.16290903091430664,
-0.26989132165908813,
-0.5577807426452637,
0.18802878260612488,
-0.4219641089439392,
0.2239290475845337,
-0.7007806897163391,
-0.8835246562957764,
0.49854668974876404,
-0.21528634428977966,
0.025315728038549423,
0.46345406770706177,
0.5743834972381592,
-0.04170921444892883,
0.9922587871551514,
0.3576834797859192,
0.04864281788468361,
-0.00036780323716811836,
0.028025155887007713,
0.24556714296340942,
-0.5109399557113647,
-0.23126649856567383,
-0.4869929850101471,
-0.029292019084095955,
-0.5433047413825989,
-0.6493450999259949,
0.6125957369804382,
0.2854067087173462,
0.026086730882525444,
0.2702415883541107,
-0.25622984766960144,
0.5935018658638,
0.6372054219245911,
0.1280236691236496,
0.7400065064430237,
-0.07924050092697144,
-0.06792376935482025,
0.26148122549057007,
-1.1711763143539429,
-0.4050583243370056,
1.00216543674469,
0.2351066917181015,
0.8964129090309143,
-0.010080063715577126,
0.3386576175689697,
0.2594592571258545,
0.025575658306479454,
-0.49324554204940796,
0.6119855046272278,
0.289601594209671,
-0.8183364868164062,
-0.11141807585954666,
-0.6257311105728149,
-0.888947606086731,
0.21959377825260162,
-0.3142624497413635,
-0.5536687970161438,
0.01684589684009552,
0.3477897346019745,
-0.17307978868484497,
0.5070232152938843,
-1.0335142612457275,
1.0082114934921265,
0.24284662306308746,
-0.46815672516822815,
0.24767544865608215,
-0.4931293725967407,
0.5895106792449951,
0.041070353239774704,
0.15894173085689545,
-0.20753522217273712,
-0.30193081498146057,
0.4821949601173401,
-0.3861563503742218,
0.2859419584274292,
0.16424493491649628,
-0.10579987615346909,
0.365386039018631,
0.19308112561702728,
0.3633739650249481,
0.26631635427474976,
0.02388664335012436,
-0.043309636414051056,
0.3524327874183655,
-0.7845807671546936,
-0.9046183228492737,
0.735579252243042,
-0.6386565566062927,
-0.5924335718154907,
-0.449224054813385,
-0.9438077211380005,
-0.7170718312263489,
-0.11132782697677612,
0.38620907068252563,
0.1994016319513321,
0.04706919193267822,
-0.22966298460960388,
0.6857830882072449,
-0.38013309240341187,
0.057914845645427704,
0.455878883600235,
-0.3333078920841217,
-0.5543249845504761,
1.0936987400054932,
-0.030069056898355484,
0.4931540787220001,
0.3255138099193573,
-0.21546198427677155,
-0.08166821300983429,
-0.148411825299263,
-0.773740291595459,
0.34463778138160706,
-0.5054448246955872,
-0.32904449105262756,
-0.7640826106071472,
-0.11792141944169998,
-0.46489793062210083,
-0.11325742304325104,
-0.43393194675445557,
-0.4415372610092163,
-0.14254458248615265,
0.04589703306555748,
0.0776306688785553,
0.46489518880844116,
0.3498130440711975,
0.0016700682463124394,
-0.9078106880187988,
0.6321120858192444,
0.2602229714393616,
0.48137518763542175,
-0.6083290576934814,
0.1320469081401825,
-0.20296891033649445,
-0.10217898339033127,
-0.2999773919582367,
-1.182204246520996,
0.19802315533161163,
0.1304766833782196,
0.39151260256767273,
-0.0037382678128778934,
0.30367788672447205,
0.7153353691101074,
-0.6898032426834106,
1.074483036994934,
0.1526041030883789,
-0.7864797711372375,
0.5759403705596924,
-0.16887299716472626,
0.34799912571907043,
0.43320420384407043,
0.7122104167938232,
-0.12476859986782074,
-0.8527008891105652,
-0.6665249466896057,
-0.883155345916748,
0.6863617300987244,
0.12206452339887619,
-0.07456454634666443,
-0.1523164063692093,
0.06899593770503998,
0.23935234546661377,
0.1950068473815918,
-0.587901771068573,
-0.28648674488067627,
-0.05284442752599716,
-0.24553880095481873,
0.29191339015960693,
-0.3068651556968689,
-0.1699853241443634,
-0.3350068926811218,
0.693305492401123,
-0.3848704695701599,
0.3725539743900299,
0.3410723805427551,
0.024175183847546577,
-0.24129550158977509,
0.4491882920265198,
0.2643718421459198,
0.8977090716362,
-0.01914740912616253,
0.22333496809005737,
0.1048116534948349,
-0.28853118419647217,
0.1919127255678177,
0.21530430018901825,
-0.16589415073394775,
0.2280796319246292,
0.19236953556537628,
0.6108182072639465,
-0.041877686977386475,
-1.1178289651870728,
0.27137288451194763,
0.21698987483978271,
-0.11791867017745972,
-0.15368366241455078,
0.18343079090118408,
-0.11818902939558029,
0.16879165172576904,
0.1672292947769165,
-0.4447869658470154,
0.45482081174850464,
-0.7258145809173584,
0.4387568533420563,
0.16650961339473724,
-0.03595518320798874,
-0.19017775356769562,
0.5136681795120239,
0.00010865252988878638,
-0.01775340363383293,
0.4161357283592224,
0.13535726070404053,
-0.3329574167728424,
0.3663880228996277,
0.6739373207092285,
0.5621660947799683,
-0.14248377084732056,
0.45288363099098206,
0.15712164342403412,
-0.02615738846361637,
0.2578120827674866,
0.5929608941078186,
0.0951399952173233,
-0.7555176615715027,
-0.6875503659248352,
-0.6935908198356628,
-0.5384050011634827,
-0.05601310729980469,
-0.5734575986862183,
0.19382208585739136,
-0.26982149481773376,
0.15623116493225098,
0.11335231363773346,
-0.32832521200180054,
-0.2139436900615692,
0.2597135007381439,
-0.33429762721061707,
1.2273828983306885,
-0.6762533187866211,
0.793775200843811,
0.9483897089958191,
-0.46013087034225464,
-1.0141512155532837,
0.11426932364702225,
-0.3520098924636841,
-0.5607004761695862,
0.493897020816803,
-0.460496187210083,
0.279979944229126,
0.12185190618038177,
-0.48415064811706543,
-0.6727736592292786,
0.7060331702232361,
0.6991692185401917,
0.020016631111502647,
-0.5305278897285461,
0.714127242565155,
0.2849006652832031,
-0.20476016402244568,
0.1902255415916443,
0.6435955762863159,
0.30056053400039673,
-0.004462775774300098,
-0.991592288017273,
-0.28575587272644043,
-0.6438963413238525,
0.01635323464870453,
0.40476930141448975,
-0.2596169114112854,
0.8028435707092285,
0.16173331439495087,
-0.11495772004127502,
-0.02070620097219944,
0.7154459953308105,
0.26875612139701843,
0.5642601251602173,
0.2466932237148285,
0.9690508842468262,
0.33582794666290283,
-0.2820018231868744,
1.208512306213379,
-0.2219989001750946,
0.5266656279563904,
1.2108243703842163,
-0.37727200984954834,
0.8108633160591125,
0.8192566633224487,
-0.23822364211082458,
0.6167110204696655,
0.4838137924671173,
0.3279520571231842,
0.3627212941646576,
0.08118729293346405,
-0.41216886043548584,
-0.2836011052131653,
-0.11610789597034454,
-0.40747979283332825,
0.18430426716804504,
0.18433719873428345,
-0.20191362500190735,
-0.7158528566360474,
0.24739792943000793,
-0.007428135257214308,
0.43856021761894226,
-0.29843294620513916,
1.0350080728530884,
-0.31837257742881775,
-0.7984020709991455,
0.6630818843841553,
-0.181425541639328,
0.24804635345935822,
-0.5343794226646423,
-0.28237423300743103,
-0.23056793212890625,
-0.15214671194553375,
-0.3364090919494629,
-1.0757901668548584,
0.5487306118011475,
0.03290789946913719,
-0.2966543734073639,
0.16514906287193298,
0.5660405158996582,
-0.5387908220291138,
-0.20008361339569092,
0.20968645811080933,
0.7945528626441956,
0.019036272540688515,
0.02329825423657894,
-0.6692534685134888,
0.06056607514619827,
-0.1844402700662613,
-0.3247462809085846,
0.31232208013534546,
0.5750581622123718,
0.25082746148109436,
0.7319160103797913,
0.5481590032577515,
0.017771324142813683,
0.7818679809570312,
-0.551150918006897,
1.2624242305755615,
-0.5309497117996216,
-0.37823987007141113,
-0.39534077048301697,
0.6307024359703064,
-0.18335206806659698,
-0.3683531582355499,
0.913293182849884,
0.9130910038948059,
1.2235262393951416,
-0.34600862860679626,
0.5091872811317444,
-0.362008273601532,
0.7981640100479126,
-0.8225683569908142,
0.25235944986343384,
-0.7077466249465942,
0.1331479847431183,
-0.39101651310920715,
-1.118284821510315,
-0.09762074798345566,
0.08697924017906189,
-0.3206688165664673,
-0.4411759078502655,
0.7324530482292175,
0.8272722959518433,
-0.31460335850715637,
0.13838720321655273,
0.5848386287689209,
0.011324096471071243,
-0.04209739714860916,
0.7724102735519409,
0.983907163143158,
-0.5999650955200195,
0.3498068153858185,
-0.30692026019096375,
-0.2080426663160324,
0.11372232437133789,
-0.3116024136543274,
-0.6350970268249512,
-0.6647505164146423,
-0.3026737868785858,
-0.7672426104545593,
0.23620732128620148,
0.9774714708328247,
0.43123775720596313,
-0.9605712890625,
-0.2670521140098572,
-0.15468360483646393,
0.2691943645477295,
-0.003907484468072653,
-0.41862183809280396,
0.11249881982803345,
-0.7678008079528809,
-1.042167067527771,
0.40035805106163025,
0.42551085352897644,
-0.5187798738479614,
-0.17129403352737427,
0.0717957392334938,
-0.6843950152397156,
0.17280350625514984,
0.6116371154785156,
0.4589308202266693,
-0.4670160412788391,
-0.13645918667316437,
0.1323278248310089,
-0.15687915682792664,
0.3336300551891327,
0.7175561189651489,
-0.6806677579879761,
0.5314592719078064,
0.670619785785675,
0.9941998720169067,
0.091542549431324,
0.03765314444899559,
0.8084551692008972,
-0.5498334169387817,
0.11484216153621674,
0.3959707021713257,
0.131582573056221,
-0.031071742996573448,
-0.3404137194156647,
0.6843734383583069,
0.48212265968322754,
-0.48554959893226624,
-0.8386202454566956,
0.19992832839488983,
-1.1264852285385132,
-0.3371405303478241,
1.09470796585083,
-0.3960988521575928,
-0.5761563181877136,
-0.4977738559246063,
-0.21525219082832336,
0.1936333328485489,
-0.0760057270526886,
0.5514935851097107,
0.4173838794231415,
-0.31463751196861267,
-0.21550039947032928,
-0.6061150431632996,
0.3426864743232727,
0.4928252696990967,
-1.4491419792175293,
-0.21386012434959412,
0.7693861722946167,
0.4474104344844818,
0.43124061822891235,
0.5598478317260742,
-0.2404938042163849,
0.49658384919166565,
0.00525128748267889,
-0.07973838597536087,
0.1425994485616684,
-0.33923766016960144,
0.301885187625885,
0.8652607798576355,
-0.10409315675497055,
-0.2121218889951706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00554v1
|
Guiding and Diversifying LLM-Based Story Generation via Answer Set Programming
| 2024-06-01T21:14:25
| 2024-06-01T21:14:25
|
Phoebe J. Wang, Max Kreminski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) are capable of generating
stories in response to open-ended user requests, but the resulting stories tend
to be limited in their diversity. Older, symbolic approaches to story
generation (such as planning) can generate substantially more diverse plot
outlines, but are limited to producing stories that recombine a fixed set of
hand-engineered character action templates. Can we combine the strengths of
these approaches while mitigating their weaknesses? We propose to do so by
using a higher-level and more abstract symbolic specification of high-level
story structure -- implemented via answer set programming (ASP) -- to guide and
diversify LLM-based story generation. Via semantic similarity analysis, we
demonstrate that our approach produces more diverse stories than an unguided
LLM, and via code excerpts, we demonstrate the improved compactness and
flexibility of ASP-based outline generation over full-fledged narrative
planning.
|
[
-0.36218151450157166,
-0.3902050256729126,
0.3914158344268799,
0.3811410069465637,
-0.12021224945783615,
0.3203940987586975,
-0.16807173192501068,
-0.5387912392616272,
0.5044956207275391,
0.771619975566864,
-0.9328441619873047,
-0.5016402006149292,
-0.3517676889896393,
0.2519131898880005,
-0.14758901298046112,
1.1283406019210815,
-0.40906986594200134,
-0.1778649091720581,
-0.13600508868694305,
-0.22711464762687683,
-0.49934297800064087,
-0.21084050834178925,
-0.3551512360572815,
-0.20366495847702026,
0.7616913914680481,
0.5338732600212097,
0.60671466588974,
0.936886191368103,
0.46589934825897217,
0.20612327754497528,
0.0220534335821867,
0.38531923294067383,
-0.5501985549926758,
0.38277822732925415,
-0.07695267349481583,
-0.42858266830444336,
-0.21060819923877716,
-0.14294594526290894,
0.6641260385513306,
0.9039139151573181,
0.21393433213233948,
0.2296231985092163,
0.11146873235702515,
0.704211950302124,
-0.6630047559738159,
-0.07109043747186661,
-0.33269256353378296,
0.20491373538970947,
0.321301132440567,
-0.3797430992126465,
-0.08740947395563126,
-0.5023494958877563,
0.10146796703338623,
-0.5148683786392212,
0.25441452860832214,
0.0773186981678009,
0.5452972650527954,
0.0776892751455307,
-0.38247644901275635,
-0.593133270740509,
-0.823685884475708,
0.7584146857261658,
-0.6766400933265686,
-0.29729172587394714,
0.023569859564304352,
0.3107534348964691,
0.14107856154441833,
-0.46649983525276184,
-0.33352717757225037,
-0.012238893657922745,
0.08609261363744736,
0.12407398968935013,
0.0008711479022167623,
-0.15336063504219055,
0.3928111493587494,
0.33424413204193115,
-0.6064123511314392,
0.38393184542655945,
-0.4554429352283478,
0.08881286531686783,
0.8556522130966187,
0.5294486284255981,
0.3005635440349579,
-0.22643110156059265,
-0.546280562877655,
-0.24421431124210358,
-1.0512012243270874,
0.19912855327129364,
0.5986542105674744,
0.31933537125587463,
-0.0972931906580925,
0.813325822353363,
-0.33054763078689575,
0.343711256980896,
-0.20155595242977142,
0.03488649055361748,
-0.043080877512693405,
-0.3102082908153534,
0.02577800862491131,
0.18289732933044434,
0.5321124196052551,
0.7831137776374817,
0.39380404353141785,
-0.11565970629453659,
-0.31573837995529175,
-0.07995431125164032,
0.20639939606189728,
-0.8245179057121277,
0.056801944971084595,
0.31638646125793457,
-0.594519317150116,
-0.5020688772201538,
0.014067448675632477,
-0.5434255003929138,
-0.5464267730712891,
-0.2988593578338623,
-0.04870464280247688,
-0.5046233534812927,
0.058087680488824844,
0.1949203610420227,
-0.6251792311668396,
0.5913835763931274,
0.3992471694946289,
-1.0716097354888916,
0.29715290665626526,
0.7155263423919678,
0.8020260334014893,
-0.35261350870132446,
-0.28237423300743103,
-0.3671983778476715,
0.7310361266136169,
-0.2910189628601074,
0.9166242480278015,
-0.5640352964401245,
-0.538011908531189,
0.04519624635577202,
-0.6670075058937073,
0.37090012431144714,
-0.5581778883934021,
0.14170421659946442,
-0.2501201331615448,
0.2757469415664673,
-0.3481466472148895,
-0.46898043155670166,
-0.18132604658603668,
0.31192004680633545,
-0.4507085680961609,
0.5264480113983154,
0.08801747858524323,
-0.6749027371406555,
0.3931320309638977,
-0.3702278435230255,
-0.6450387239456177,
0.021740224212408066,
-0.5879818201065063,
-0.15854518115520477,
0.3171546459197998,
0.49455660581588745,
0.1286863386631012,
-0.39772021770477295,
0.13398407399654388,
-0.22608301043510437,
-0.35948804020881653,
0.1515807956457138,
-0.21831916272640228,
0.8494192361831665,
0.22873684763908386,
-0.1349928081035614,
0.4950835108757019,
-0.7459360361099243,
0.32269108295440674,
0.06821820139884949,
-0.4374961853027344,
-0.012836618348956108,
0.16528229415416718,
-0.08822540193796158,
0.14748525619506836,
0.27228373289108276,
-0.2742004990577698,
0.4640902876853943,
-0.486783504486084,
0.07247843593358994,
0.6415311098098755,
0.2540813684463501,
0.2974499762058258,
-1.0145293474197388,
0.8458386659622192,
-0.14775213599205017,
-0.21809989213943481,
-0.55271315574646,
-0.5399312376976013,
-0.8336960077285767,
-0.03193412348628044,
-0.2636023163795471,
0.5387830138206482,
-0.6504417061805725,
0.3662750720977783,
-0.29396334290504456,
-0.33789485692977905,
-0.23485052585601807,
-0.02681448683142662,
0.431317538022995,
0.33329159021377563,
0.22002443671226501,
-0.40633219480514526,
-0.7079273462295532,
-0.7872304916381836,
-0.4094996750354767,
-0.19926515221595764,
-0.4068131744861603,
0.324808806180954,
0.19396083056926727,
0.12992863357067108,
1.0737487077713013,
-0.8071503043174744,
0.1585582047700882,
-0.8147956132888794,
0.018369827419519424,
0.2828540503978729,
0.325942724943161,
0.36165115237236023,
-0.634501039981842,
-0.6637662649154663,
-0.07773329317569733,
-0.7478379011154175,
-0.2681875228881836,
-0.287291020154953,
0.07958487421274185,
-0.07069280743598938,
0.4270891845226288,
-0.568730890750885,
0.44051793217658997,
0.03035750612616539,
-0.4441942870616913,
0.7871450781822205,
-0.2366710752248764,
0.018693720921874046,
-1.3253470659255981,
-0.09998267143964767,
-0.34246668219566345,
-0.0528264194726944,
-0.4390586316585541,
0.28054380416870117,
-0.1868649274110794,
-0.3498038947582245,
-0.2134251892566681,
0.6103482842445374,
-0.5396944284439087,
-0.3162543773651123,
-0.2637089192867279,
0.14310967922210693,
0.007415623404085636,
0.5853548645973206,
0.10278041660785675,
0.35227808356285095,
0.4109949767589569,
-0.5409924983978271,
0.4617694318294525,
0.5120759010314941,
-0.1751818209886551,
0.4685650169849396,
-0.6486441493034363,
-0.12876394391059875,
-0.32773837447166443,
0.29980671405792236,
-0.5895705819129944,
-0.28182169795036316,
0.057690203189849854,
-0.3681357204914093,
0.1281040459871292,
0.06393872201442719,
-0.39671871066093445,
-0.23932793736457825,
-0.7608249187469482,
-0.09974179416894913,
0.6140193343162537,
-0.4829925298690796,
0.4184063971042633,
-0.010404095984995365,
-0.5786423087120056,
-0.4657329320907593,
-0.6004897356033325,
-0.024238968268036842,
-0.41982942819595337,
-0.8859040141105652,
0.3710038959980011,
-0.34542298316955566,
-0.4208992123603821,
-0.11305256932973862,
-0.30257803201675415,
0.10330203175544739,
-0.23162104189395905,
0.23823654651641846,
0.0712081640958786,
-0.6162452697753906,
0.04792414978146553,
0.3139742612838745,
-0.03482840210199356,
-0.1190829947590828,
-0.35531479120254517,
0.5568608641624451,
0.10419873148202896,
-0.5253022313117981,
0.11130927503108978,
0.908573567867279,
0.20079423487186432,
-0.42542028427124023,
0.4931415915489197,
0.19543179869651794,
-0.07531977444887161,
-0.576777458190918,
-0.07744686305522919,
-0.03544527292251587,
-0.4932299256324768,
0.303450345993042,
-0.18557675182819366,
-1.0183199644088745,
0.640809953212738,
-0.05206424370408058,
0.6447321176528931,
0.31326767802238464,
0.5446482300758362,
-0.21025604009628296,
0.6937618851661682,
0.7779173851013184,
0.34808990359306335,
0.31371739506721497,
0.009904616512358189,
0.05677684023976326,
-0.5761827826499939,
-0.055666517466306686,
-0.3431307375431061,
-0.8942447304725647,
-0.46530887484550476,
-0.4183803200721741,
0.2473059594631195,
0.3315078914165497,
-0.3296142518520355,
0.23360376060009003,
-0.30235567688941956,
0.8168988227844238,
0.5143648386001587,
-0.2398468255996704,
0.615042507648468,
0.1687421202659607,
0.017584875226020813,
0.10625910758972168,
-0.6661904454231262,
-0.7071942687034607,
1.2519081830978394,
0.36140626668930054,
0.7915889620780945,
0.2928597927093506,
1.123365044593811,
-0.027710124850273132,
0.1778930425643921,
-0.4209292531013489,
0.6281501054763794,
-0.26207873225212097,
-0.3031774163246155,
-0.48277103900909424,
-0.3224010169506073,
-0.8647189736366272,
0.2017822563648224,
-0.17445127665996552,
-0.91441410779953,
0.08080416917800903,
-0.08808307349681854,
-0.41671431064605713,
0.11303845793008804,
-0.7532891035079956,
0.5559664964675903,
-0.15148767828941345,
0.14567351341247559,
-0.1967516988515854,
-0.7101232409477234,
0.22947600483894348,
0.007200183812528849,
-0.3403991758823395,
-0.02478097751736641,
-0.23849350214004517,
0.33476945757865906,
-0.4738397002220154,
0.8923488855361938,
0.24445588886737823,
-0.22213114798069,
0.6689907312393188,
0.09248996526002884,
0.5164910554885864,
0.14408960938453674,
-0.03311825916171074,
-0.36023393273353577,
-0.2888892590999603,
-0.31829845905303955,
-0.6300613880157471,
0.7880405187606812,
-0.6033291220664978,
-0.8045992255210876,
-0.019638843834400177,
-1.1620664596557617,
-0.40924134850502014,
0.1455797404050827,
0.22688336670398712,
0.4550475776195526,
-0.1408955156803131,
0.18189793825149536,
0.6281633973121643,
-0.4259677529335022,
0.7289363741874695,
0.4660433828830719,
-0.4896980822086334,
-0.22481925785541534,
0.9061751365661621,
-0.1288970410823822,
0.44874101877212524,
0.46976667642593384,
0.19843748211860657,
-0.07578415423631668,
-0.7989382147789001,
-0.3144729733467102,
0.017996465787291527,
-0.7381643652915955,
-0.15724614262580872,
-0.6021610498428345,
-0.4753977954387665,
-0.17960554361343384,
-0.6383596062660217,
0.07763474434614182,
-0.8397591710090637,
-0.11639456450939178,
-0.1878879815340042,
0.3138735890388489,
0.8129560351371765,
0.2014504224061966,
0.33460405468940735,
-0.7144030928611755,
0.48742756247520447,
0.18110574781894684,
0.21591275930404663,
-0.1787269562482834,
-0.08695349842309952,
0.11108803749084473,
0.00031759380362927914,
-0.599880039691925,
-0.8620760440826416,
0.3804715573787689,
0.12468002736568451,
0.37584808468818665,
0.29580700397491455,
0.10419194400310516,
0.5213074088096619,
-0.5691576600074768,
0.46415868401527405,
0.3226925730705261,
-0.41706737875938416,
0.7276520133018494,
-0.6693353056907654,
0.663123369216919,
0.3438027501106262,
0.39277714490890503,
-0.4974411129951477,
-0.6699855923652649,
-0.6903517842292786,
-0.8446735143661499,
0.7527832388877869,
0.4429742991924286,
0.22679392993450165,
0.23215621709823608,
0.16327860951423645,
0.2642463147640228,
0.4281710982322693,
-0.7893414497375488,
-0.012367019429802895,
-0.11798591911792755,
-0.3971831202507019,
0.021950846537947655,
-0.02634790539741516,
-0.3198680579662323,
0.23276352882385254,
0.2161993533372879,
-0.2780543565750122,
-0.058932431042194366,
-0.13525885343551636,
0.03964531421661377,
-0.23265701532363892,
0.27075594663619995,
0.3912070095539093,
0.734376847743988,
-0.045667920261621475,
0.05696607381105423,
0.10031730681657791,
-0.36453571915626526,
-0.15551437437534332,
0.2165304571390152,
-0.4474184215068817,
-0.19562238454818726,
0.680677592754364,
0.8151538968086243,
-0.018110133707523346,
-1.090622067451477,
0.3250657618045807,
0.14984217286109924,
-0.14001406729221344,
0.07540081441402435,
0.5033038854598999,
0.3551963269710541,
0.5848275423049927,
0.19907404482364655,
-0.127613365650177,
-0.09600871056318283,
-0.567899763584137,
0.2847031056880951,
0.28439369797706604,
-0.38096821308135986,
0.14895015954971313,
0.3081643283367157,
0.2574523985385895,
-0.5062827467918396,
0.6383894681930542,
-0.027569705620408058,
-0.03603862226009369,
1.081518292427063,
0.9246338605880737,
0.9919094443321228,
0.008080522529780865,
0.2691023647785187,
0.09326948970556259,
0.35394084453582764,
0.317417711019516,
0.5234106183052063,
0.0640140026807785,
-0.4905277490615845,
-0.37695446610450745,
-0.7556539177894592,
-0.2265971601009369,
-0.0637504979968071,
-0.46285155415534973,
0.5743500590324402,
-0.747707188129425,
0.5908621549606323,
-0.22975072264671326,
-0.18675902485847473,
-0.1128692626953125,
0.020372169092297554,
0.20384466648101807,
0.951586902141571,
-0.4477224349975586,
0.38874176144599915,
0.7636880874633789,
-0.5666988492012024,
-0.7627654671669006,
0.43973666429519653,
-0.13067631423473358,
-0.7534283995628357,
0.5403473377227783,
0.38905879855155945,
0.11772657930850983,
-0.06859200447797775,
-0.4192332625389099,
-0.6961750388145447,
1.3017115592956543,
0.27835556864738464,
-0.44559162855148315,
-0.4844944477081299,
0.33873826265335083,
0.6225966215133667,
-0.7687608003616333,
-0.14260441064834595,
0.10903260111808777,
0.09451407939195633,
0.5494510531425476,
-0.5957089066505432,
0.016233157366514206,
-0.14731645584106445,
0.0931464433670044,
0.20538322627544403,
-0.42741596698760986,
0.4974491596221924,
-0.630340576171875,
-0.27501043677330017,
0.13704419136047363,
0.8678644299507141,
0.710739016532898,
0.1441812515258789,
0.13642705976963043,
0.33795544505119324,
0.41365259885787964,
0.24955645203590393,
1.0000336170196533,
-0.10368373990058899,
-0.051162682473659515,
1.2733536958694458,
-0.23774904012680054,
0.6823263764381409,
0.321963369846344,
-0.028222503140568733,
0.463593453168869,
0.5229938626289368,
-0.024439727887511253,
0.3965768814086914,
0.43962183594703674,
-0.2509019076824188,
-0.09035404026508331,
0.002325209090486169,
-0.24403418600559235,
0.3046121299266815,
0.23482538759708405,
-0.22406326234340668,
-0.6146048903465271,
-0.3303300142288208,
-0.3052774965763092,
0.28738653659820557,
-0.5807890295982361,
0.6552389860153198,
0.16448219120502472,
-0.6318469047546387,
0.22880755364894867,
0.0216669924557209,
0.4440681040287018,
-0.8449941277503967,
-0.10627288371324539,
-0.294143944978714,
-0.18162666261196136,
-0.07671180367469788,
-1.0412228107452393,
0.445011705160141,
0.259949654340744,
-0.4319368898868561,
-0.7358016967773438,
0.6724711060523987,
-0.4905090928077698,
-0.514783501625061,
-0.316450297832489,
0.6343991160392761,
-0.12808462977409363,
0.13998724520206451,
-0.291390597820282,
-0.1633673757314682,
0.16333290934562683,
-0.11528094857931137,
0.30931222438812256,
0.5088916420936584,
-0.42740458250045776,
0.7699155807495117,
0.4329752027988434,
-0.05971250310540199,
0.0653478130698204,
0.0700485110282898,
0.9249337911605835,
-0.6513159871101379,
-0.9448546767234802,
-0.6627904176712036,
0.6413211226463318,
-0.18222765624523163,
-0.45553091168403625,
0.6338734030723572,
0.6860878467559814,
0.6348739266395569,
-0.22078409790992737,
0.7748331427574158,
0.011913474649190903,
0.40548568964004517,
-0.581732451915741,
0.5897327065467834,
-0.24659712612628937,
0.5953237414360046,
-0.1432114988565445,
-1.1758089065551758,
-0.18934515118598938,
0.3074328303337097,
-0.06909922510385513,
0.20468772947788239,
0.773891806602478,
0.43397051095962524,
-0.04651147872209549,
0.21479016542434692,
0.07900219410657883,
-0.17133097350597382,
0.25647538900375366,
0.8095654249191284,
1.0473268032073975,
0.24285836517810822,
0.7178065180778503,
0.3480321764945984,
-0.36996719241142273,
0.039275527000427246,
-0.8225864171981812,
-1.1399531364440918,
-0.3032169044017792,
-0.24895597994327545,
-0.0596855990588665,
-0.04228295758366585,
0.5933524370193481,
0.1876939982175827,
-0.564258873462677,
-0.544919490814209,
-0.2729300856590271,
0.17172196507453918,
-0.18882063031196594,
-0.12365031987428665,
0.11980468034744263,
-0.35434550046920776,
-0.5203725695610046,
0.26905879378318787,
0.6121434569358826,
0.0569123849272728,
-0.34443050622940063,
-0.18974336981773376,
0.08303044736385345,
0.22562497854232788,
0.4253309667110443,
0.3653014600276947,
-0.47032108902931213,
-0.1604277640581131,
-0.05355873331427574,
-0.08709495514631271,
0.125726118683815,
1.2564806938171387,
-0.5032522678375244,
0.18710313737392426,
0.4610351026058197,
0.6965276002883911,
0.402093768119812,
-0.14443577826023102,
1.0684359073638916,
-1.2098692655563354,
-0.018141750246286392,
0.5127915143966675,
0.17573212087154388,
0.0878419578075409,
-0.30920925736427307,
0.4008307158946991,
-0.10633883625268936,
-0.0829484611749649,
-0.35711413621902466,
0.8643326759338379,
-0.9384192824363708,
-0.5328815579414368,
1.3494806289672852,
0.007561924401670694,
0.0446518175303936,
0.0514654666185379,
-0.43641698360443115,
0.010958119295537472,
-0.04779621213674545,
0.6022651195526123,
0.7383584380149841,
-0.5839319229125977,
-0.20911988615989685,
-0.15367215871810913,
0.42587313055992126,
0.16034401953220367,
-1.2032532691955566,
0.3188193738460541,
0.7621553540229797,
0.08465208858251572,
0.1721208691596985,
0.5559108853340149,
-0.12340236455202103,
0.21137681603431702,
0.11019890010356903,
-0.027596307918429375,
-0.2568061649799347,
-0.37033793330192566,
-0.07599037885665894,
0.2552356421947479,
0.004055516328662634,
0.22204157710075378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00548v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00548v1
|
LIDAO: Towards Limited Interventions for Debiasing (Large) Language Models
| 2024-06-01T20:12:54
| 2024-06-01T20:12:54
|
Tianci Liu, Haoyu Wang, Shiyang Wang, Yu Cheng, Jing Gao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance on various
natural language generation tasks. Nonetheless, they suffer from generating
negative and harmful contents that are biased against certain demographic
groups (e.g., female), raising severe fairness concerns. As remedies, prior
works intervened the generation by removing attitude or demographic
information, inevitably degrading the generation quality and resulting in
notable \textit{fairness-fluency} trade-offs. However, it is still
under-explored to what extent the fluency \textit{has to} be affected in order
to achieve a desired level of fairness. In this work, we conduct the first
formal study from an information-theoretic perspective. We show that previous
approaches are excessive for debiasing and propose LIDAO, a general framework
to debias a (L)LM at a better fluency provably. We further robustify LIDAO in
adversarial scenarios, where a carefully-crafted prompt may stimulate LLMs
exhibiting instruction-following abilities to generate texts with fairness
issue appears only when the prompt is also taken into account. Experiments on
three LMs ranging from 0.7B to 7B parameters demonstrate the superiority of our
method.
|
[
-0.3925543427467346,
-1.1338237524032593,
0.43562567234039307,
0.12141327559947968,
-0.1410699188709259,
-0.34033462405204773,
-0.3624245524406433,
-0.39812082052230835,
0.10988681763410568,
0.7268313765525818,
-0.2271953970193863,
-0.37513187527656555,
-0.8634191751480103,
-0.07485075294971466,
-0.2597266733646393,
1.1202189922332764,
0.3656347990036011,
0.1743851751089096,
0.13504557311534882,
0.11497049778699875,
-0.5323778986930847,
-0.3545888364315033,
-0.8193191885948181,
-0.25775399804115295,
0.6575018763542175,
0.6297654509544373,
0.9619957208633423,
0.4907209873199463,
0.37255731225013733,
0.14748446643352509,
-0.20397734642028809,
-0.10494539886713028,
-0.8140713572502136,
0.22995519638061523,
-0.14124254882335663,
-0.7568355202674866,
-0.38194647431373596,
0.056894686073064804,
0.7814000248908997,
0.8056666851043701,
-0.20342662930488586,
-0.18540796637535095,
0.2705698609352112,
0.7326415777206421,
-0.7137629389762878,
-0.0464966744184494,
-1.0416566133499146,
0.05104976147413254,
-0.19425109028816223,
-0.15067142248153687,
-0.5137079954147339,
-0.3860776126384735,
-0.028492238372564316,
-0.5632447600364685,
0.04483408108353615,
-0.0007491319556720555,
0.7200644016265869,
0.47597411274909973,
-0.49175888299942017,
-0.6379081606864929,
-0.7436899542808533,
1.0988576412200928,
-0.8514382243156433,
0.021508198231458664,
0.5511924624443054,
0.38166797161102295,
-0.41681843996047974,
-0.2438419610261917,
-0.5735593438148499,
-0.43798893690109253,
0.1553230583667755,
-0.0073532285168766975,
-0.2782266438007355,
0.3085207939147949,
0.39398807287216187,
0.18432553112506866,
-0.21480803191661835,
0.45315617322921753,
-0.5347527861595154,
0.07367182523012161,
0.5570792555809021,
0.16467612981796265,
0.2837076187133789,
-0.2026546597480774,
-0.43716368079185486,
0.03809673339128494,
-0.953120768070221,
0.05452585220336914,
0.8679227232933044,
0.33861827850341797,
0.06625542789697647,
0.4165881276130676,
-0.09768225252628326,
0.5864298939704895,
0.19203516840934753,
-0.19163958728313446,
0.02311617136001587,
0.04358527064323425,
-0.2792789936065674,
0.0649586170911789,
0.8133145570755005,
0.23031927645206451,
0.40413549542427063,
0.021823009476065636,
-0.2518070340156555,
0.021245982497930527,
0.18782104551792145,
-1.076507329940796,
0.17311100661754608,
0.2554280161857605,
-0.37743982672691345,
-0.5998541712760925,
-0.033647093921899796,
-0.9358134269714355,
-0.7086093425750732,
-0.2992252707481384,
0.24894648790359497,
-0.32715141773223877,
-0.15169252455234528,
0.18199200928211212,
-0.0686621144413948,
0.11246620118618011,
0.2764630615711212,
-1.0413087606430054,
0.10917473584413528,
0.539320170879364,
0.3237794041633606,
0.04959547892212868,
-0.13660816848278046,
-0.6436842679977417,
0.25348013639450073,
-0.49169766902923584,
0.3684840798377991,
-0.7736334204673767,
-0.33678138256073,
0.07317014783620834,
-0.4737975299358368,
0.10982577502727509,
-0.5295900106430054,
0.7969751954078674,
-0.35021889209747314,
0.2743401825428009,
-0.48760509490966797,
-0.3624395728111267,
-0.12148221582174301,
-0.0037769740447402,
-0.7021246552467346,
0.6585593819618225,
-0.11032760888338089,
-0.9724238514900208,
0.6622437238693237,
-0.4627883732318878,
-0.32611972093582153,
-0.20676930248737335,
-0.5064269304275513,
-0.189503476023674,
0.1180877685546875,
0.2598074674606323,
0.3521893620491028,
-0.6598721146583557,
1.0013771057128906,
-0.44355452060699463,
-0.48965996503829956,
0.2951360046863556,
-0.9354819059371948,
1.0576119422912598,
0.4375300109386444,
-0.5259948968887329,
0.0018249880522489548,
-0.7276760935783386,
-0.3784258961677551,
0.06922753155231476,
-0.08359114825725555,
-0.4067893624305725,
-0.0841321349143982,
-0.14196892082691193,
0.022036651149392128,
0.2706381380558014,
-0.40082818269729614,
0.26801514625549316,
-0.6097802519798279,
0.1911872774362564,
1.0471757650375366,
-0.07813718169927597,
0.4329673945903778,
-0.5181578993797302,
0.6967664957046509,
-0.01623004488646984,
0.3513152599334717,
0.25734326243400574,
-0.47540953755378723,
-0.6229128837585449,
-0.5060171484947205,
0.20098070800304413,
0.4151412546634674,
-0.9607521891593933,
0.3287513554096222,
-0.16945496201515198,
-0.18049557507038116,
-0.6149759292602539,
0.3424515724182129,
0.42617303133010864,
0.4668431878089905,
0.04599965736269951,
-0.007626752834767103,
-0.44604653120040894,
-1.1161307096481323,
-0.12351827323436737,
-0.04014217481017113,
0.0563247986137867,
0.24083949625492096,
0.3114255368709564,
-0.26972824335098267,
0.8977360129356384,
-0.3135128915309906,
-0.3433322310447693,
-0.3425552248954773,
0.08682745695114136,
0.453593373298645,
0.25493335723876953,
0.9895371794700623,
-0.8176159262657166,
-0.32858940958976746,
-0.3858603537082672,
-0.7861798405647278,
-0.30403846502304077,
-0.04435015097260475,
-0.15089352428913116,
0.11444644629955292,
0.4420255422592163,
-0.40559858083724976,
0.2758398652076721,
0.4684945046901703,
-0.11882719397544861,
0.20098982751369476,
-0.181069478392601,
0.20712891221046448,
-0.9512309432029724,
0.1721327155828476,
-0.26153308153152466,
0.06822243332862854,
-0.7699664831161499,
0.1038937121629715,
-0.5552034974098206,
0.006467911414802074,
-0.4093894958496094,
0.9167082905769348,
-0.24126684665679932,
0.14812812209129333,
-0.5750246644020081,
0.41940364241600037,
-0.1319163292646408,
0.37408632040023804,
-0.24485065042972565,
0.4745230972766876,
0.5725936889648438,
-0.6736725568771362,
0.12211384624242783,
-0.01840747892856598,
-0.22820059955120087,
0.6395110487937927,
-0.765234649181366,
-0.05668198689818382,
-0.5852487683296204,
0.12618224322795868,
-0.8497588038444519,
-0.3378966450691223,
0.4116726815700531,
-0.38135290145874023,
0.23589476943016052,
0.016207361593842506,
-0.35130348801612854,
-0.18697895109653473,
-0.5618669986724854,
0.5308972597122192,
0.6014739274978638,
-0.5136693716049194,
0.14441363513469696,
0.5324791073799133,
-0.16723734140396118,
-1.0124956369400024,
-0.7601063251495361,
0.047574661672115326,
-0.519850492477417,
-0.5832504630088806,
0.12349480390548706,
-0.260606974363327,
-0.6068090796470642,
-0.14588072896003723,
0.3510381877422333,
-0.06538049131631851,
0.4169631600379944,
0.13176177442073822,
-0.063641756772995,
0.010787468403577805,
0.21026504039764404,
0.34771251678466797,
-0.05175433307886124,
-0.1887510120868683,
-0.06392361968755722,
0.44719398021698,
0.05404293164610863,
-0.15997450053691864,
-0.23253098130226135,
0.23408453166484833,
0.32361799478530884,
0.022583169862627983,
0.9169804453849792,
0.5486729145050049,
-0.4225006103515625,
-0.43836677074432373,
-0.49158602952957153,
-0.2153376042842865,
-0.4482666850090027,
0.11689404398202896,
-0.2844524383544922,
-0.7803849577903748,
0.5070574879646301,
0.5303010940551758,
0.0582936629652977,
0.3045361042022705,
0.707417905330658,
0.2771974205970764,
0.80683434009552,
0.5267068147659302,
-0.20164534449577332,
0.6510422229766846,
-0.019614940509200096,
0.2543618977069855,
-0.6386182904243469,
0.22823317348957062,
-0.5881606936454773,
-0.2785058915615082,
-0.655604362487793,
-0.37967124581336975,
0.3212920129299164,
0.5321335196495056,
-0.19523940980434418,
0.016852371394634247,
-0.335383802652359,
0.24921229481697083,
0.7884030938148499,
0.1341344118118286,
0.33990755677223206,
-0.08968702703714371,
0.08240391314029694,
-0.07101580500602722,
-0.9167311787605286,
-0.6218708157539368,
1.3517202138900757,
0.43335992097854614,
0.8221724033355713,
0.18943533301353455,
0.8815047740936279,
0.45700591802597046,
0.5531322360038757,
-0.5091831684112549,
0.533234715461731,
-0.2457212656736374,
-0.8253272771835327,
-0.49076521396636963,
-0.6358466744422913,
-1.3466153144836426,
0.20615020394325256,
-0.1719392091035843,
-0.8353291153907776,
0.3181343078613281,
0.29607149958610535,
-0.14266444742679596,
0.18938636779785156,
-0.38860785961151123,
0.7241803407669067,
-0.17845295369625092,
-0.45612502098083496,
-0.20571106672286987,
-0.3635197579860687,
0.6428069472312927,
0.028718965128064156,
0.4548378586769104,
-0.2831682562828064,
-0.007520563900470734,
0.506729781627655,
-0.11988087743520737,
1.020264744758606,
-0.4601899981498718,
-0.6386223435401917,
0.6169041991233826,
0.15604931116104126,
0.38590142130851746,
0.15629160404205322,
-0.4108823835849762,
0.048378266394138336,
-0.2781628668308258,
-0.598219096660614,
-0.5193834900856018,
0.8054478764533997,
-0.5525753498077393,
-0.8192831873893738,
-0.1730417162179947,
-0.6082175970077515,
-0.05534522607922554,
0.20706181228160858,
0.4129946231842041,
0.34482595324516296,
-0.31039103865623474,
0.4352557957172394,
0.7222275733947754,
-0.5645542144775391,
0.2606448531150818,
0.3462630808353424,
-0.38304248452186584,
-0.5032305121421814,
0.8235856890678406,
0.173288032412529,
0.3428118824958801,
0.4646144211292267,
0.5618736743927002,
-0.11577345430850983,
-0.6474001407623291,
-0.31744185090065,
-0.06859897077083588,
-0.7094199061393738,
-0.12908880412578583,
-0.355735182762146,
0.0985216349363327,
-0.47012385725975037,
-0.1280442774295807,
-0.14768564701080322,
-0.2909170985221863,
-0.1616012454032898,
-0.062097419053316116,
0.036723777651786804,
0.591729998588562,
-0.12644323706626892,
0.3304608464241028,
-0.45798248052597046,
0.5603654980659485,
0.25254037976264954,
0.05465145781636238,
0.07902126759290695,
-0.6797113418579102,
-0.014002392999827862,
0.47149622440338135,
-0.168231800198555,
-0.8801171779632568,
0.1914261281490326,
-0.03648223355412483,
0.7444068193435669,
0.4729650914669037,
0.3155187964439392,
0.1818583458662033,
-0.10384431481361389,
0.6601943969726562,
0.10881620645523071,
-0.8766475915908813,
0.6759204864501953,
-0.7487489581108093,
-0.1068660095334053,
0.6145889759063721,
0.24495038390159607,
-0.2358522117137909,
-0.7596005201339722,
-0.6347620487213135,
-0.7731270790100098,
0.5281134843826294,
0.23620299994945526,
0.21682244539260864,
-0.34907829761505127,
0.29706892371177673,
0.25371894240379333,
0.6289427280426025,
-0.9730311036109924,
-0.008601347915828228,
0.14049938321113586,
-0.46488699316978455,
0.09761669486761093,
-0.3772664964199066,
-0.1807994842529297,
0.2910937964916229,
0.7378334999084473,
-0.13219508528709412,
-0.13799120485782623,
0.23661606013774872,
-0.18153724074363708,
-0.06973249465227127,
0.578898549079895,
0.5532947182655334,
0.6330074667930603,
-0.09922684729099274,
-0.047741908580064774,
-0.107708640396595,
-0.14629822969436646,
0.09432947635650635,
0.06598328799009323,
-0.8401988744735718,
-0.21546334028244019,
0.3899827301502228,
0.9165115356445312,
0.11071284115314484,
-0.7777501940727234,
0.689021646976471,
0.1906629353761673,
-0.06918145716190338,
-0.040367286652326584,
0.31370168924331665,
-0.40901249647140503,
0.18495994806289673,
0.30040061473846436,
-0.3756849765777588,
0.32964348793029785,
-0.7440085411071777,
0.09217807650566101,
0.664065957069397,
-0.33074456453323364,
0.057085685431957245,
0.798149585723877,
0.44709041714668274,
-0.004258842207491398,
0.22095660865306854,
-0.5340538620948792,
-0.30068981647491455,
0.7697249054908752,
0.2457331269979477,
0.9226753115653992,
-0.23722730576992035,
0.31633293628692627,
0.3647458553314209,
0.45337411761283875,
-0.03640116751194,
0.059373803436756134,
0.17675413191318512,
-0.7719479203224182,
-0.19578808546066284,
-0.5555522441864014,
-0.24545606970787048,
0.13856090605258942,
-0.6326867341995239,
0.29145514965057373,
-0.44922709465026855,
-0.20779278874397278,
-0.38251203298568726,
0.09890629351139069,
-0.573249340057373,
0.15048620104789734,
0.07404250651597977,
0.416631817817688,
-0.6066564321517944,
0.7031872272491455,
0.18867193162441254,
-0.627697765827179,
-0.32936811447143555,
0.17295998334884644,
-0.19593320786952972,
-0.7676500678062439,
0.7501994371414185,
0.16930092871189117,
-0.22840361297130585,
-0.30353057384490967,
-0.4374837875366211,
-0.43538668751716614,
0.8880046010017395,
0.7558567523956299,
-0.7315638661384583,
-0.12228438258171082,
0.13695695996284485,
0.6467772722244263,
-0.19213727116584778,
0.2784121632575989,
0.44387614727020264,
0.5587894320487976,
-0.1796996295452118,
-0.8344468474388123,
0.16492582857608795,
0.02880389802157879,
0.020209604874253273,
0.02924863062798977,
-0.8324234485626221,
0.8762838244438171,
-0.32286539673805237,
-0.23597249388694763,
0.21781519055366516,
0.4758576452732086,
0.007897290401160717,
0.2506185472011566,
0.48115861415863037,
0.3685106635093689,
0.9443725347518921,
0.11671838164329529,
1.119878888130188,
-0.3956197202205658,
0.17657972872257233,
1.119558572769165,
-0.275039941072464,
0.49239736795425415,
0.5210967063903809,
0.03463795408606529,
0.09689578413963318,
0.21745629608631134,
0.132864847779274,
0.3233601748943329,
0.5807227492332458,
-0.09367258101701736,
-0.003652901854366064,
-0.4177205562591553,
-0.4398438036441803,
0.4228988587856293,
0.16674405336380005,
-0.38582247495651245,
-0.011063018813729286,
0.2866479158401489,
0.1983175277709961,
0.41110002994537354,
-0.228244349360466,
0.5604642629623413,
0.1564752608537674,
-0.7487745881080627,
0.6433385014533997,
0.04816897585988045,
0.8075222969055176,
-0.504949688911438,
-0.005119503475725651,
-0.43376624584198,
0.12459439039230347,
-0.0063744280487298965,
-0.6765331625938416,
0.13670514523983002,
0.06802826374769211,
-0.20414187014102936,
-0.09641776978969574,
0.6283252239227295,
-0.5331712365150452,
-0.41357848048210144,
0.4569149613380432,
0.4118454158306122,
0.0008618822903372347,
0.02730174921452999,
-0.5835936069488525,
0.08551597595214844,
0.16985918581485748,
-0.3377101421356201,
0.23776598274707794,
0.560744047164917,
0.15121622383594513,
0.6498593688011169,
0.3512309491634369,
0.1617758572101593,
-0.03415244072675705,
0.3657195568084717,
0.4976383447647095,
-0.6443471312522888,
-0.4066765606403351,
-0.772750973701477,
0.22998473048210144,
-0.053218405693769455,
-0.3777081072330475,
0.6783894896507263,
0.2987511456012726,
0.6904283165931702,
0.09652357548475266,
0.8170892000198364,
-0.08014828711748123,
0.25003013014793396,
-0.8551792502403259,
0.45273298025131226,
-0.5779780149459839,
0.6193526983261108,
-0.3989596664905548,
-0.9424264430999756,
-0.0961245521903038,
0.5391597747802734,
-0.44496166706085205,
0.146011620759964,
0.31533363461494446,
0.799368143081665,
0.3066774308681488,
-0.256152480840683,
0.4533165395259857,
0.32512086629867554,
0.5680526494979858,
0.975210428237915,
0.9119648933410645,
-0.3756064474582672,
0.6506372094154358,
0.010723436251282692,
-0.38882678747177124,
-0.3197583556175232,
-0.8850449919700623,
-1.1559048891067505,
-0.23301458358764648,
0.11398004740476608,
-0.2541612386703491,
0.30265453457832336,
0.9345730543136597,
0.3531649708747864,
-0.4157358705997467,
-0.14933903515338898,
-0.2606824040412903,
0.48621705174446106,
0.19521668553352356,
-0.2554646134376526,
0.09823206812143326,
-0.39465785026550293,
-1.0653047561645508,
0.15379752218723297,
0.0010014924919232726,
-0.04189148172736168,
-0.3583522140979767,
-0.1447666436433792,
0.21591176092624664,
0.3083915114402771,
0.36172744631767273,
0.03499898314476013,
-0.6877592206001282,
-0.3401610255241394,
-0.37016060948371887,
-0.3315408527851105,
0.09198129177093506,
0.7847360372543335,
-0.588144838809967,
0.4805457293987274,
0.5477099418640137,
0.6559299826622009,
0.09627566486597061,
-0.16071847081184387,
0.7018564939498901,
-0.6185204982757568,
0.5798137784004211,
0.4925643503665924,
0.3421191871166229,
0.2230934500694275,
-0.3648884892463684,
0.38512322306632996,
-0.016468748450279236,
-0.37917301058769226,
-0.9590274691581726,
0.5833540558815002,
-0.6222177147865295,
-0.47054323554039,
1.2704458236694336,
0.08759281784296036,
-0.002319485181942582,
0.28160586953163147,
-0.48702552914619446,
0.08815397322177887,
-0.5928848385810852,
1.021462321281433,
0.7971361875534058,
0.18251845240592957,
0.14529059827327728,
-0.681211531162262,
0.5158149003982544,
0.5567646026611328,
-0.9866109490394592,
0.17910358309745789,
0.5944817662239075,
-0.04535839334130287,
0.006360403262078762,
0.9086631536483765,
-0.011658222414553165,
0.19565989077091217,
0.255060076713562,
-0.1569664180278778,
0.11486639082431793,
-0.6514120101928711,
-0.382114976644516,
0.14438064396381378,
0.31640130281448364,
0.14617082476615906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00515v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models for Code Generation
| 2024-06-01T17:48:15
| 2024-06-01T17:48:15
|
Juyong Jiang, Fan Wang, Jiasi Shen, Sungju Kim, Sunghun Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have garnered remarkable advancements across
diverse code-related tasks, known as Code LLMs, particularly in code generation
that generates source code with LLM from natural language descriptions. This
burgeoning field has captured significant interest from both academic
researchers and industry professionals due to its practical significance in
software development, e.g., GitHub Copilot. Despite the active exploration of
LLMs for a variety of code tasks, either from the perspective of natural
language processing (NLP) or software engineering (SE) or both, there is a
noticeable absence of a comprehensive and up-to-date literature review
dedicated to LLM for code generation. In this survey, we aim to bridge this gap
by providing a systematic literature review that serves as a valuable reference
for researchers investigating the cutting-edge progress in LLMs for code
generation. We introduce a taxonomy to categorize and discuss the recent
developments in LLMs for code generation, covering aspects such as data
curation, latest advances, performance evaluation, and real-world applications.
In addition, we present a historical overview of the evolution of LLMs for code
generation and offer an empirical comparison using the widely recognized
HumanEval and MBPP benchmarks to highlight the progressive enhancements in LLM
capabilities for code generation. We identify critical challenges and promising
opportunities regarding the gap between academia and practical development.
Furthermore, we have established a dedicated resource website
(https://codellm.github.io) to continuously document and disseminate the most
recent advances in the field.
|
[
-0.46822232007980347,
-0.61552494764328,
0.4555298089981079,
0.1489386260509491,
-0.06867700070142746,
0.2774070203304291,
-0.5312483310699463,
-0.49891313910484314,
0.08753415942192078,
0.6118853688240051,
-0.4010668992996216,
-0.6144666075706482,
-0.301613450050354,
0.2928253412246704,
-0.3169204294681549,
0.9206027388572693,
-0.03710228204727173,
0.26149001717567444,
-0.3485505282878876,
0.258066326379776,
-0.36035245656967163,
-0.6709992289543152,
-0.40525269508361816,
-0.25775986909866333,
0.49253618717193604,
0.12747971713542938,
0.3135071098804474,
0.15532128512859344,
0.6829200387001038,
0.2241077870130539,
-0.21450647711753845,
0.23290641605854034,
-0.36846840381622314,
0.3192368149757385,
-0.0010147240245714784,
-0.19142015278339386,
-0.6795159578323364,
-0.31866756081581116,
0.6635496616363525,
0.6869863867759705,
-0.12947426736354828,
0.41628149151802063,
0.004923814907670021,
0.8133911490440369,
-0.48385530710220337,
0.11066840589046478,
-0.7836750149726868,
0.02321772091090679,
-0.206327885389328,
-0.28410977125167847,
-0.4121324121952057,
-0.521064281463623,
-0.35936760902404785,
0.027593083679676056,
0.09469389915466309,
-0.07046396285295486,
0.36543887853622437,
0.018160181120038033,
-0.38043496012687683,
-0.6229568123817444,
-0.8291166424751282,
0.8410148620605469,
-0.8924720287322998,
0.19347478449344635,
0.029352115467190742,
0.10879433155059814,
-0.37165963649749756,
-0.8193013072013855,
-0.35589146614074707,
-0.5176805853843689,
0.3398338854312897,
-0.08947480469942093,
-0.08338272571563721,
-0.15198031067848206,
0.32126858830451965,
0.6250001192092896,
-0.6616193056106567,
0.3275972604751587,
-0.4096120595932007,
-0.15343953669071198,
0.8411098718643188,
0.360046923160553,
0.23319734632968903,
-0.2579959034919739,
-0.14955109357833862,
0.23638516664505005,
-1.1593910455703735,
-0.12934650480747223,
0.48243197798728943,
0.15272913873195648,
-0.1846054345369339,
0.5529370903968811,
-0.07057798653841019,
0.7460461258888245,
-0.4169526994228363,
-0.16259345412254333,
0.2425576150417328,
-0.5123836994171143,
-0.12891878187656403,
-0.24619488418102264,
0.9175149202346802,
0.2938438951969147,
0.13551674783229828,
0.05593908578157425,
-0.41755643486976624,
-0.020274236798286438,
0.3584901988506317,
-0.9166820049285889,
0.06087749823927879,
0.18483836948871613,
-0.4689660370349884,
-0.48335781693458557,
-0.04084078222513199,
-0.6950055360794067,
-0.30203768610954285,
-0.23790229856967926,
-0.4248776435852051,
0.036416299641132355,
-0.43952852487564087,
0.02297906205058098,
0.22378839552402496,
0.48165860772132874,
0.16903811693191528,
-0.6169865727424622,
-0.02106383442878723,
0.9090157747268677,
0.8017203211784363,
-0.12667182087898254,
0.020720383152365685,
-0.27301180362701416,
-0.025178568437695503,
-0.6069433689117432,
0.49981093406677246,
-0.3032290041446686,
-0.4617374837398529,
0.47797802090644836,
-0.2207513153553009,
0.31510382890701294,
-0.5918260216712952,
0.4389626979827881,
-0.6962680220603943,
-0.09820689260959625,
0.08779222518205643,
-0.4798065721988678,
0.161378413438797,
0.4084092080593109,
-0.4981027841567993,
0.9016770124435425,
0.014032846316695213,
-0.7635997533798218,
0.2756563723087311,
-0.4752480089664459,
-0.4185296893119812,
0.311506450176239,
-0.5981007218360901,
-0.6303802132606506,
0.2657574415206909,
-0.08660124242305756,
0.65647953748703,
-0.7848520874977112,
0.8214108347892761,
-0.3597421944141388,
-0.10383067280054092,
0.5114724636077881,
-0.17344771325588226,
0.6242339015007019,
0.5073487162590027,
-0.21098050475120544,
0.20853744447231293,
-0.6529279351234436,
0.12311991304159164,
0.3452804386615753,
-0.5100022554397583,
0.01882709376513958,
0.23979654908180237,
0.06744866818189621,
0.28510671854019165,
0.3380696475505829,
-0.382687509059906,
0.4727901220321655,
-0.21116633713245392,
0.7777819037437439,
0.4682442247867584,
0.18204109370708466,
0.34596607089042664,
-0.3880784809589386,
0.7011833190917969,
-0.25801220536231995,
0.13127152621746063,
-0.45329034328460693,
-0.4195883572101593,
-0.4670265018939972,
-0.015112373977899551,
0.3541548550128937,
0.17931921780109406,
-0.6646961569786072,
0.4571484327316284,
-0.20253412425518036,
-0.576810896396637,
-0.2301255464553833,
0.42989861965179443,
0.39947134256362915,
0.0012865938479080796,
-0.029885204508900642,
-0.2852809429168701,
-0.7188323140144348,
-0.8493622541427612,
0.10338835418224335,
-0.18408061563968658,
-0.15693075954914093,
0.3609940707683563,
0.45752426981925964,
-0.5783346891403198,
0.766004741191864,
-0.5455662608146667,
0.04950648918747902,
-0.4802232086658478,
-0.000745245604775846,
0.1362205594778061,
0.45214205980300903,
0.38331079483032227,
-0.6154899001121521,
-0.31842532753944397,
-0.04795651137828827,
-0.5360763072967529,
-0.19513291120529175,
-0.11595278233289719,
0.0007899054908193648,
0.520179033279419,
0.6641191840171814,
-0.4667402505874634,
-0.12245927006006241,
0.7223374247550964,
0.10626799613237381,
0.6241251826286316,
0.07637312263250351,
-0.06093592196702957,
-1.128896951675415,
0.28869369626045227,
-0.0576312355697155,
-0.12007143348455429,
-0.5620209574699402,
0.5555663108825684,
0.07092303782701492,
-0.15211421251296997,
-0.3200548589229584,
0.32922154664993286,
-0.7893459796905518,
-0.3401155471801758,
-0.31246551871299744,
0.11221249401569366,
-0.2530778646469116,
0.2785322964191437,
0.03688621148467064,
0.6922304034233093,
0.6306523680686951,
-0.497370183467865,
0.2792069613933563,
-0.051258597522974014,
-0.4164440333843231,
-0.051502831280231476,
-0.6120191216468811,
0.28237560391426086,
0.17436397075653076,
0.40746140480041504,
-0.710418164730072,
-0.3920501470565796,
0.001247097854502499,
-0.3073222041130066,
0.3824955224990845,
-0.25478556752204895,
-0.8679839372634888,
-0.652094841003418,
-0.3878090977668762,
0.3151162564754486,
0.8316421508789062,
-0.19494636356830597,
0.03000013716518879,
0.4129336178302765,
-0.45000049471855164,
-0.18246892094612122,
-0.5731876492500305,
0.14671725034713745,
-0.09203379601240158,
-0.6609348058700562,
0.010644156485795975,
-0.20658978819847107,
-0.4702461063861847,
-0.43810075521469116,
0.007634991779923439,
0.0805683508515358,
0.08316633105278015,
0.07808516919612885,
0.3579637110233307,
-0.4055373966693878,
0.22636571526527405,
-0.20143014192581177,
0.18873564898967743,
0.43056729435920715,
-0.23323369026184082,
0.7581457495689392,
-0.07705006748437881,
-0.2886922061443329,
0.21026141941547394,
0.17461739480495453,
0.427550345659256,
-0.34283390641212463,
0.3840412497520447,
0.47587260603904724,
-0.059631120413541794,
-0.5862094759941101,
-0.5908867716789246,
0.1519775688648224,
-0.40919029712677,
0.28646746277809143,
-0.0866989865899086,
-1.1911054849624634,
0.38607001304626465,
-0.3505130112171173,
0.3735566735267639,
0.3655499815940857,
0.963947594165802,
0.16073304414749146,
0.7912778258323669,
0.6881606578826904,
0.024869279935956,
0.39097586274147034,
-0.23043540120124817,
0.2058550864458084,
-0.8233162760734558,
-0.03652014210820198,
-0.6749748587608337,
-0.0032524510752409697,
-0.8239918947219849,
-0.6661064624786377,
0.15846197307109833,
0.22299762070178986,
-0.11491138488054276,
-0.04592954367399216,
-0.6362506747245789,
0.20431891083717346,
0.1351792812347412,
-0.25477683544158936,
0.3617061972618103,
0.002203228883445263,
0.00897301733493805,
0.18452508747577667,
-0.7664109468460083,
-0.7341389656066895,
1.360612392425537,
0.428318589925766,
0.8781733512878418,
0.08532712608575821,
0.8189356923103333,
0.33122313022613525,
0.5509703755378723,
-0.5107593536376953,
0.6610390543937683,
0.03991226106882095,
-0.5926406383514404,
-0.11392496526241302,
-0.6816627979278564,
-0.999718189239502,
-0.06236271187663078,
-0.08177125453948975,
-0.2794550657272339,
-0.33633533120155334,
0.07529360055923462,
-0.1045164242386818,
0.27288171648979187,
-0.30858418345451355,
0.597883939743042,
-0.417662650346756,
-0.5748453140258789,
-0.1930028647184372,
-0.527717649936676,
0.7933125495910645,
-0.44898828864097595,
0.4160516858100891,
-0.030336814001202583,
-0.1766403317451477,
0.5260705351829529,
-0.38306277990341187,
0.8018392324447632,
-0.03903435915708542,
-0.6642817258834839,
0.6507608890533447,
-0.007045364938676357,
0.5187008380889893,
0.10325287282466888,
-0.13338586688041687,
0.22175933420658112,
-0.3157385587692261,
-0.18448691070079803,
-0.024870354682207108,
0.9159194231033325,
-0.3917135000228882,
-0.4038741886615753,
-0.2387676239013672,
-0.43752413988113403,
-0.2656431794166565,
0.14002855122089386,
0.25215643644332886,
0.4664076268672943,
-0.21154436469078064,
0.19744059443473816,
0.6141940951347351,
-0.5638883709907532,
0.43613937497138977,
0.3534463047981262,
-0.718469500541687,
-0.39613473415374756,
0.8533399701118469,
-0.06236861273646355,
0.2947954833507538,
0.27738961577415466,
-0.004043659660965204,
-0.05540384352207184,
-0.9876856207847595,
-0.38452988862991333,
0.27839067578315735,
-0.4118390381336212,
-0.3767281174659729,
-0.4096904993057251,
-0.4205932021141052,
-0.4861919581890106,
-0.3263283669948578,
-0.19926829636096954,
-0.12767533957958221,
-0.07870101928710938,
0.09316882491111755,
0.32373911142349243,
1.1021531820297241,
0.3076733946800232,
-0.016266800463199615,
-0.9543032050132751,
0.26965275406837463,
-0.05407086759805679,
0.3902784585952759,
0.11229372024536133,
-0.19972987473011017,
-0.38181793689727783,
-0.07643679529428482,
-0.48274821043014526,
-0.6057581901550293,
0.3717120885848999,
-0.23128564655780792,
0.4832606911659241,
0.08283878117799759,
0.1066339761018753,
0.4397512674331665,
-0.5052201747894287,
0.9958935379981995,
0.5436842441558838,
-0.6349488496780396,
0.4979200065135956,
-0.5609104037284851,
0.39726993441581726,
0.20445163547992706,
0.22294968366622925,
-0.37925294041633606,
-0.5171102285385132,
-0.5033586025238037,
-1.043912649154663,
0.40142422914505005,
0.2190755009651184,
0.26222506165504456,
-0.0001814510760596022,
0.12563049793243408,
0.08172091096639633,
0.5101566910743713,
-0.8742221593856812,
0.009350189007818699,
0.3681926131248474,
-0.009022101759910583,
-0.012308742851018906,
-0.285083144903183,
-0.034454770386219025,
0.1525420844554901,
0.4874485433101654,
-0.22919631004333496,
0.2366018295288086,
-0.06606754660606384,
-0.14424633979797363,
-0.17631293833255768,
0.6321694254875183,
0.7203770875930786,
0.8004032373428345,
0.009318217635154724,
-0.04570954665541649,
-0.06704811751842499,
-0.4139191210269928,
0.014614676125347614,
-0.045761194080114365,
-0.29368048906326294,
-0.01792384497821331,
0.42219775915145874,
0.4989418387413025,
0.24171820282936096,
-1.0110950469970703,
0.5525087714195251,
0.06972481310367584,
-0.5067752003669739,
-0.6209194660186768,
0.14451384544372559,
0.3269847631454468,
0.2174322009086609,
0.3818590044975281,
-0.20979292690753937,
0.05173656344413757,
-0.5495807528495789,
-0.04048680514097214,
0.4886905252933502,
0.07134895026683807,
-0.12560205161571503,
0.4589505195617676,
0.5470504760742188,
-0.24776816368103027,
0.4891396462917328,
-0.393269419670105,
-0.21357664465904236,
0.6988210678100586,
0.41383716464042664,
1.0393574237823486,
0.22217079997062683,
-0.09201044589281082,
0.34564024209976196,
0.3408086597919464,
-0.01305268332362175,
0.376064658164978,
-0.17183269560337067,
-0.35437706112861633,
-0.6658158898353577,
-0.94694584608078,
-0.28620925545692444,
0.2664701044559479,
-0.3739871382713318,
0.2570978105068207,
-0.4640253484249115,
-0.30435168743133545,
-0.2178041934967041,
0.1061820536851883,
-0.4253355860710144,
-0.3111252188682556,
0.550965428352356,
0.95585036277771,
-0.38566625118255615,
0.7424107789993286,
0.8718302845954895,
-0.35019269585609436,
-0.5888282060623169,
-0.007571720518171787,
-0.16600468754768372,
-0.36647829413414,
0.5747802257537842,
-0.05385615676641464,
0.004198802635073662,
-0.15711800754070282,
-0.702427327632904,
-0.49905455112457275,
1.0000413656234741,
0.15107615292072296,
-0.9733114242553711,
-0.28532999753952026,
0.19053833186626434,
0.6641579270362854,
-0.47682440280914307,
0.10800958424806595,
0.275544673204422,
0.23502545058727264,
-0.0010417503071948886,
-0.7532565593719482,
-0.17393700778484344,
-0.3449198603630066,
0.43865376710891724,
0.44916027784347534,
-0.7842465043067932,
0.6792600750923157,
-0.15245531499385834,
-0.043903570622205734,
0.33664488792419434,
0.41212961077690125,
0.6561093330383301,
0.3657376170158386,
0.08156812936067581,
0.06472909450531006,
0.3558187186717987,
0.027618786320090294,
0.9779266715049744,
-0.6829453706741333,
0.34200045466423035,
0.9361630082130432,
-0.6508077383041382,
0.8383722901344299,
0.4369710087776184,
-0.38160276412963867,
0.34969353675842285,
0.5379999279975891,
-0.25256872177124023,
-0.04747224971652031,
0.7567453384399414,
-0.09807858616113663,
-0.23272642493247986,
0.11315570026636124,
-0.5072013735771179,
0.16525334119796753,
0.23046521842479706,
-0.6642115116119385,
-0.08365622162818909,
-0.23538726568222046,
-0.011678752489387989,
0.11521214991807938,
-0.5996916890144348,
0.8367443680763245,
0.24414202570915222,
-0.779365599155426,
0.6360999941825867,
0.20698904991149902,
0.8111740946769714,
-0.7975702881813049,
-0.0527084581553936,
-0.29935264587402344,
-0.03456763178110123,
-0.33434921503067017,
-0.7735077738761902,
0.20014576613903046,
0.6171873807907104,
-0.18589885532855988,
-0.4715902805328369,
0.766037106513977,
-0.18303132057189941,
-0.4330393075942993,
0.2364082783460617,
0.6386931538581848,
0.1926688402891159,
0.35872700810432434,
-0.6191091537475586,
0.4338468611240387,
0.13006170094013214,
-0.4053637683391571,
0.4504757523536682,
0.37369304895401,
0.07216060161590576,
0.6313948035240173,
0.6872321367263794,
0.221684992313385,
0.34754905104637146,
0.13921621441841125,
0.9021382927894592,
-0.8256361484527588,
-0.31022512912750244,
-0.6642603278160095,
0.32618656754493713,
0.08945347368717194,
-0.3228396773338318,
0.7290425896644592,
0.794170081615448,
0.9640315771102905,
-0.316022127866745,
0.8446124196052551,
-0.18395106494426727,
0.39841753244400024,
-0.60415118932724,
0.5726419687271118,
-0.4247095584869385,
0.5518030524253845,
-0.45441633462905884,
-1.0432589054107666,
-0.33649417757987976,
0.18324017524719238,
-0.25702837109565735,
0.13615916669368744,
0.47136250138282776,
0.8174403309822083,
0.2623366713523865,
-0.17805986106395721,
0.40758976340293884,
0.14796476066112518,
0.3205878734588623,
0.5602762699127197,
1.1291241645812988,
-0.051301538944244385,
0.6293901801109314,
0.12787297368049622,
0.12107805907726288,
-0.3973338305950165,
-0.8345144391059875,
-0.7845521569252014,
-0.3478962182998657,
-0.34404897689819336,
-0.12338382750749588,
-0.14659400284290314,
0.9623286724090576,
0.4689406454563141,
-0.5512164235115051,
-0.5659651160240173,
-0.4266355633735657,
-0.00446716183796525,
0.07561531662940979,
-0.18922755122184753,
-0.06493967026472092,
-0.6030221581459045,
-0.7230706810951233,
0.13232281804084778,
0.23798197507858276,
-0.20980677008628845,
-0.7178141474723816,
-0.42462238669395447,
0.03178218752145767,
0.011231948621571064,
0.8492444753646851,
0.23273207247257233,
-0.682114839553833,
0.3659553825855255,
-0.011390753090381622,
-0.6158279776573181,
-0.08091875165700912,
1.207527756690979,
-0.3166940212249756,
0.08136308193206787,
0.5081145763397217,
0.6846124529838562,
0.35105380415916443,
-0.41499918699264526,
0.48399338126182556,
-0.6250840425491333,
-0.12940680980682373,
0.4033767879009247,
0.44323575496673584,
0.34184250235557556,
-0.10189580917358398,
0.6935337781906128,
0.0463879331946373,
-0.8372544050216675,
-1.066611886024475,
0.4566822648048401,
-0.8820443749427795,
-0.33244937658309937,
1.4759154319763184,
0.09183784574270248,
-0.05536692216992378,
0.09371886402368546,
-0.14291642606258392,
0.0758456215262413,
-0.3343565762042999,
0.42431482672691345,
0.5030229091644287,
-0.03833877667784691,
-0.13860301673412323,
-0.7550166845321655,
0.3800535798072815,
-0.04770999401807785,
-0.9423345923423767,
0.29114049673080444,
0.9277048707008362,
0.14801794290542603,
0.05876021087169647,
0.6371433138847351,
-0.3299489915370941,
0.19197958707809448,
-0.04296861216425896,
0.5266287326812744,
0.0328393317759037,
-0.18607249855995178,
-0.49490952491760254,
0.3389882445335388,
0.7093313932418823,
0.3688623607158661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00507v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00507v1
|
Prompt Chaining or Stepwise Prompt? Refinement in Text Summarization
| 2024-06-01T17:28:38
| 2024-06-01T17:28:38
|
Shichao Sun, Ruifeng Yuan, Ziqiang Cao, Wenjie Li, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated the capacity to improve
summary quality by mirroring a human-like iterative process of critique and
refinement starting from the initial draft. Two strategies are designed to
perform this iterative process: Prompt Chaining and Stepwise Prompt. Prompt
chaining orchestrates the drafting, critiquing, and refining phases through a
series of three discrete prompts, while Stepwise prompt integrates these phases
within a single prompt. However, the relative effectiveness of the two methods
has not been extensively studied. This paper is dedicated to examining and
comparing these two methods in the context of text summarization to ascertain
which method stands out as the most effective. Experimental results show that
the prompt chaining method can produce a more favorable outcome. This might be
because stepwise prompt might produce a simulated refinement process according
to our various experiments. Since refinement is adaptable to diverse tasks, our
conclusions have the potential to be extrapolated to other applications,
thereby offering insights that may contribute to the broader development of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.25424107909202576,
-0.6156555414199829,
0.6543003916740417,
0.42250514030456543,
-0.4126175045967102,
0.4952038824558258,
-0.10613393783569336,
-0.3774639964103699,
0.23291070759296417,
0.3889264762401581,
-0.7404587864875793,
-0.2227327525615692,
-0.1771307736635208,
0.7324555516242981,
-0.5651835203170776,
1.1965763568878174,
-0.2779180109500885,
0.23005588352680206,
-0.16316093504428864,
-0.0682513415813446,
-0.550234317779541,
-0.41188549995422363,
-0.9600884914398193,
-0.7012000679969788,
0.8636345863342285,
0.3823661208152771,
0.590638279914856,
0.6270196437835693,
0.34659871459007263,
0.31279438734054565,
-0.21799413859844208,
0.15808403491973877,
-0.3463718891143799,
0.5356718897819519,
-0.15982438623905182,
-0.5060386061668396,
-0.3306693434715271,
-0.04583609476685524,
0.49160999059677124,
0.8785486221313477,
0.007534679025411606,
0.1153755784034729,
0.17065955698490143,
1.045820951461792,
-0.5741533041000366,
-0.08307674527168274,
-0.2394600510597229,
-0.11558707058429718,
0.1596023589372635,
-0.36110609769821167,
-0.32156994938850403,
-0.7189610004425049,
0.2024698555469513,
-0.4305737018585205,
0.1770728975534439,
0.11939438432455063,
0.45033636689186096,
0.04899325221776962,
-0.2575211226940155,
-0.37909936904907227,
-0.6989840269088745,
0.6288650035858154,
-0.7647436857223511,
0.2024957239627838,
0.08235989511013031,
0.16533787548542023,
-0.09010575711727142,
-0.8968096375465393,
-0.30869436264038086,
-0.44173988699913025,
-0.08119242638349533,
0.1516382098197937,
0.06634645909070969,
0.13620540499687195,
0.32909268140792847,
0.5614057779312134,
-0.4211791157722473,
0.30801835656166077,
-0.38463202118873596,
-0.17461733520030975,
0.6642917990684509,
0.30550599098205566,
0.18384607136249542,
-0.21544711291790009,
-0.44912996888160706,
-0.09604129940271378,
-0.9171189069747925,
0.21423019468784332,
0.3295579254627228,
0.5502623319625854,
0.03704763203859329,
0.5546562075614929,
-0.46217039227485657,
0.5154878497123718,
0.22247348725795746,
-0.37318000197410583,
-0.11393895745277405,
-0.7095438241958618,
-0.13251006603240967,
0.08508036285638809,
0.7766485810279846,
0.8803068995475769,
0.45772597193717957,
-0.0013817447470501065,
-0.5276346206665039,
-0.2469264268875122,
0.10148598998785019,
-0.756821870803833,
0.00891724694520235,
0.3731846809387207,
-0.6240004897117615,
-0.3654642403125763,
0.05166013538837433,
-0.6161596179008484,
-0.4868633449077606,
-0.5372411012649536,
0.156504824757576,
-0.282992422580719,
0.1980857402086258,
-0.21635472774505615,
-0.3237505555152893,
0.07210668176412582,
0.7198033928871155,
-0.796230137348175,
0.36655327677726746,
0.7117889523506165,
1.0504190921783447,
-0.3783858120441437,
-0.366970956325531,
-0.6044114232063293,
-0.29429638385772705,
-0.5912121534347534,
1.0273123979568481,
-0.2654615342617035,
-0.6501672267913818,
0.08075404912233353,
-0.1550745666027069,
0.16810348629951477,
-0.5297122597694397,
0.542944073677063,
-0.421795129776001,
0.22643350064754486,
-0.6065856218338013,
-0.31099894642829895,
-0.14729276299476624,
0.15061277151107788,
-0.6884386539459229,
1.0610657930374146,
-0.12303012609481812,
-0.7016220688819885,
0.4307321310043335,
-0.13696005940437317,
-0.5650425553321838,
-0.17055340111255646,
0.026626156643033028,
-0.22256343066692352,
0.1619480550289154,
0.3744690418243408,
0.48273730278015137,
-0.389030396938324,
0.13064336776733398,
-0.16977234184741974,
-0.4417365789413452,
0.29126590490341187,
-0.1991203874349594,
0.4185448884963989,
0.18341481685638428,
0.053780145943164825,
0.3612399399280548,
-0.7759807109832764,
-0.14994299411773682,
-0.15560013055801392,
-0.3926817774772644,
-0.2767597734928131,
0.012650315649807453,
-0.3126562833786011,
0.1669514775276184,
0.011633648537099361,
-0.13863784074783325,
0.26699838042259216,
-0.40906205773353577,
0.2648180425167084,
0.7803187370300293,
0.3963397145271301,
0.5545456409454346,
-0.8239643573760986,
0.6286598443984985,
-0.15949416160583496,
-0.1110115647315979,
-0.8611963987350464,
-0.35935598611831665,
-0.6227798461914062,
0.055241335183382034,
0.34426820278167725,
0.6455527544021606,
-1.0382046699523926,
0.13184119760990143,
0.02211211621761322,
-0.41262391209602356,
-0.39328905940055847,
-0.06516145169734955,
0.4189535975456238,
0.46712371706962585,
0.2928454577922821,
-0.0903286412358284,
-0.5314185619354248,
-0.6209631562232971,
-0.6152241826057434,
-0.4068801999092102,
-0.2541496455669403,
-0.4460630714893341,
0.5313241481781006,
0.2992778718471527,
0.7149693965911865,
-0.3215385377407074,
0.18283721804618835,
-0.5196712613105774,
0.40544411540031433,
0.38489046692848206,
0.30190137028694153,
0.2847976088523865,
-0.2961951196193695,
-0.5270944833755493,
-0.23271001875400543,
-0.6449804902076721,
-0.40934470295906067,
-0.4895290732383728,
0.22482378780841827,
0.23333188891410828,
0.696352481842041,
-0.19657279551029205,
0.36546263098716736,
0.27853575348854065,
-0.20474931597709656,
0.9432569146156311,
-0.306173175573349,
0.5702070593833923,
-0.8433736562728882,
0.0319734662771225,
-0.0006678407662548125,
-0.4149453043937683,
-0.9157997965812683,
0.2069305181503296,
-0.05940842628479004,
0.14714373648166656,
-0.20683708786964417,
0.4527624547481537,
-0.7601332068443298,
-0.019308097660541534,
-0.5747975707054138,
0.38565582036972046,
0.033788908272981644,
0.23665626347064972,
-0.06499425321817398,
1.049389123916626,
0.2981109917163849,
-0.8825175762176514,
0.3937569856643677,
0.06742028146982193,
-0.31931185722351074,
0.5543785095214844,
-0.9484775066375732,
0.08845937252044678,
-0.25939202308654785,
0.633876621723175,
-1.2437025308609009,
-0.04799657315015793,
0.22219684720039368,
-0.2200208157300949,
0.04127493128180504,
0.2992483675479889,
-0.4396360218524933,
-0.3660273551940918,
-1.1381746530532837,
0.2993127405643463,
0.571279764175415,
-0.5865537524223328,
0.4808255732059479,
-0.2801665663719177,
-0.5626278519630432,
-0.44551873207092285,
-0.7088248133659363,
0.12325962632894516,
-0.11941099166870117,
-0.4149928092956543,
0.4230938255786896,
-0.23439982533454895,
-0.5877605080604553,
-0.6000659465789795,
-0.4865122437477112,
0.21925118565559387,
-0.09577585756778717,
0.1649705022573471,
0.30201202630996704,
0.12808334827423096,
-0.043191179633140564,
0.1066305860877037,
-0.27515000104904175,
0.11526311188936234,
-0.009977767243981361,
0.47509127855300903,
0.4248369038105011,
-0.1514413058757782,
-0.5282456278800964,
0.5228855609893799,
0.4886615574359894,
-0.03052944876253605,
0.4282100796699524,
-0.07137603312730789,
0.010496203787624836,
-0.31694942712783813,
-0.6031845211982727,
-0.24290092289447784,
-0.4628318250179291,
-0.2148597240447998,
-0.3337853252887726,
-0.8203427791595459,
0.7824527025222778,
-0.269735187292099,
0.48056560754776,
0.34164977073669434,
0.4707862436771393,
-0.21670736372470856,
0.832751452922821,
0.695015549659729,
-0.05295298993587494,
0.5408142805099487,
0.09524594992399216,
0.018813999369740486,
-0.9078307747840881,
-0.15928061306476593,
-0.8446232676506042,
-0.18891485035419464,
-0.42672422528266907,
-0.27665582299232483,
0.3706456124782562,
0.25913599133491516,
-0.053751759231090546,
0.15561531484127045,
-0.3146488666534424,
0.49934303760528564,
0.6114096641540527,
0.11469356715679169,
0.7402204275131226,
0.07124198973178864,
-0.23400673270225525,
0.12979203462600708,
-0.6053217053413391,
-0.646477997303009,
0.7557595372200012,
0.26321616768836975,
0.8039866089820862,
-0.22414296865463257,
0.64590984582901,
0.1382085680961609,
0.16701056063175201,
-0.8189101219177246,
0.7029663324356079,
0.24314004182815552,
-0.19379501044750214,
-0.30249831080436707,
-0.3011612296104431,
-0.8010040521621704,
0.3779042363166809,
-0.27590033411979675,
-0.7215256094932556,
0.12544094026088715,
0.1973235011100769,
-0.41664043068885803,
0.2032538205385208,
-0.3940703868865967,
0.11014958471059799,
0.26158517599105835,
-0.24297697842121124,
-0.10218867659568787,
-0.8400158882141113,
0.3041844964027405,
-0.1293722242116928,
0.2620494067668915,
0.20892569422721863,
-0.29878947138786316,
0.7963076829910278,
-0.9736147522926331,
0.7204261422157288,
0.24573813378810883,
-0.5064228773117065,
0.4173085391521454,
0.07198426127433777,
0.8030160069465637,
-0.10100863873958588,
-0.20908115804195404,
-0.25911763310432434,
-0.14122357964515686,
-0.1648898869752884,
-0.7233566045761108,
0.523535430431366,
-0.3296840488910675,
-0.6175155639648438,
-0.32017579674720764,
-0.329851359128952,
-0.10571060329675674,
0.1681770384311676,
0.48041683435440063,
0.6484326720237732,
-0.07090675085783005,
-0.47980305552482605,
0.5889998078346252,
-0.17050039768218994,
0.9161200523376465,
0.2963237464427948,
-0.5812219977378845,
-0.5858787298202515,
0.48241809010505676,
0.11865005642175674,
0.5281549096107483,
0.4950558543205261,
0.22903381288051605,
-0.17934003472328186,
-0.7222336530685425,
-0.17916539311408997,
0.48307862877845764,
-0.9435352683067322,
-0.13929018378257751,
-0.4814317226409912,
-0.06701721996068954,
-0.3414190113544464,
-0.5223021507263184,
-0.09948119521141052,
-0.6338609457015991,
-0.011438354849815369,
-0.33418142795562744,
0.4297506511211395,
0.8556514382362366,
0.1325034350156784,
0.32062169909477234,
-0.7954773902893066,
0.4581165313720703,
0.2942143380641937,
0.3396076560020447,
0.1314987987279892,
-0.41735872626304626,
0.040814150124788284,
-0.1623494029045105,
-0.09299839287996292,
-0.9589830040931702,
0.022229697555303574,
-0.23068585991859436,
0.2632175087928772,
0.38182947039604187,
0.10784000158309937,
0.7702916860580444,
-0.6386140584945679,
1.1654906272888184,
0.4514155983924866,
-0.9001746773719788,
0.4987450838088989,
-0.4689517021179199,
0.7958288788795471,
0.905368983745575,
0.5023719072341919,
-0.6555262207984924,
-0.589238703250885,
-0.2819858193397522,
-0.9501203894615173,
0.496539831161499,
0.13761305809020996,
-0.2377612441778183,
-0.02460600808262825,
0.5066264867782593,
0.38474613428115845,
0.32485058903694153,
-0.4750085473060608,
-0.4197499752044678,
0.20841532945632935,
0.11406663805246353,
-0.09680402278900146,
-0.44406822323799133,
-0.03182395547628403,
-0.1457977294921875,
0.5898894667625427,
-0.015676971524953842,
0.03535629063844681,
0.422233521938324,
0.0790051743388176,
-0.20766985416412354,
0.27645981311798096,
0.5933443307876587,
1.1124004125595093,
0.02429555356502533,
0.22444958984851837,
0.43117108941078186,
-0.43575865030288696,
0.30204686522483826,
-0.3040725588798523,
-0.4119498133659363,
0.34242933988571167,
0.9877983927726746,
0.6143902540206909,
0.25378867983818054,
-0.40750277042388916,
0.26146456599235535,
0.044817715883255005,
-0.4404343068599701,
0.13642634451389313,
-0.001586924190632999,
-0.22268696129322052,
0.2457735389471054,
0.47171443700790405,
-0.06088930740952492,
0.35440683364868164,
-0.7240156531333923,
0.004888264928013086,
0.03337075188755989,
-0.08682852983474731,
-0.2198001593351364,
0.498252272605896,
0.38616013526916504,
-0.5155889391899109,
0.4945315420627594,
0.164189875125885,
-0.3270806074142456,
0.35544511675834656,
0.4818333387374878,
1.0319024324417114,
-0.42936283349990845,
0.3735209107398987,
0.5361525416374207,
0.20558758080005646,
-0.4971383810043335,
0.38580235838890076,
-0.20753315091133118,
-0.2765425741672516,
-0.8346592783927917,
-0.332064688205719,
-0.6045690774917603,
-0.3605944812297821,
-0.6907709836959839,
0.2515888214111328,
-0.40818431973457336,
-0.07003834843635559,
-0.19372862577438354,
-0.15940843522548676,
-0.08649148792028427,
0.1080937311053276,
-0.23241610825061798,
1.252266526222229,
-0.6518681645393372,
0.24138393998146057,
0.874325692653656,
-0.4170937240123749,
-0.8474507927894592,
0.28961560130119324,
0.1268007904291153,
-0.5630422830581665,
0.41535496711730957,
0.10123962163925171,
-0.3258938193321228,
-0.07421532273292542,
-0.45425790548324585,
-0.7175713777542114,
1.2500425577163696,
-0.22059445083141327,
-0.6590980887413025,
-0.28368979692459106,
-0.1751561015844345,
0.5139917731285095,
-0.14260272681713104,
0.4983634352684021,
0.6033742427825928,
0.4491989016532898,
0.5109936594963074,
-1.014512062072754,
0.45000943541526794,
-0.02015792950987816,
0.42101481556892395,
0.25050053000450134,
-0.6592130661010742,
0.7019328474998474,
-0.47860172390937805,
-0.5142135620117188,
0.3101295828819275,
0.6511240601539612,
0.4851599931716919,
0.3296588063240051,
0.5218883752822876,
0.22987769544124603,
0.8321931958198547,
-0.1035931259393692,
1.2387548685073853,
-0.12065700441598892,
-0.05359973385930061,
1.0035151243209839,
-0.26718997955322266,
0.6090463399887085,
0.5571229457855225,
-0.4332869350910187,
0.6603632569313049,
0.6318919658660889,
0.35421621799468994,
0.4692040681838989,
0.34593573212623596,
-0.2072295844554901,
0.048168573528528214,
0.014866665005683899,
-0.2658863067626953,
-0.2959260642528534,
-0.2486971616744995,
-0.3161379396915436,
-0.48192939162254333,
-0.044446177780628204,
0.4123672544956207,
0.09288530796766281,
-0.7153075933456421,
1.0445548295974731,
0.37388649582862854,
-1.2056628465652466,
0.44443532824516296,
-0.001887963037006557,
0.5378481149673462,
-0.48319005966186523,
0.0076839495450258255,
-0.4940720498561859,
-0.16204799711704254,
-0.3192025125026703,
-0.741563618183136,
0.09444978088140488,
0.1836862713098526,
-0.23863451182842255,
-0.5478001236915588,
0.6232477426528931,
-0.2480209916830063,
-0.1571328043937683,
0.09128803014755249,
0.45960602164268494,
0.0027996639255434275,
0.019240137189626694,
-0.46845564246177673,
0.15989620983600616,
-0.0575118251144886,
-0.4247269928455353,
0.08048299700021744,
0.42401427030563354,
-0.23986440896987915,
0.8979440331459045,
0.5316259860992432,
0.23627257347106934,
-0.19555340707302094,
0.365345299243927,
1.0449565649032593,
-0.8208826184272766,
-0.5508242249488831,
-1.2038984298706055,
0.8557509779930115,
-0.16949954628944397,
-0.2675164043903351,
0.9900197386741638,
0.34007376432418823,
0.5193719267845154,
0.04087699577212334,
0.7773224115371704,
0.3509066104888916,
0.4299694895744324,
-0.7732491493225098,
0.0908011719584465,
-0.10457126051187515,
0.4514860510826111,
-0.5564525127410889,
-1.036207675933838,
-0.3390415608882904,
0.36901527643203735,
-0.09759579598903656,
0.2627575099468231,
1.2760698795318604,
0.528673529624939,
0.5168980360031128,
0.15689526498317719,
-0.09143882989883423,
0.18402110040187836,
0.1682855635881424,
0.20179344713687897,
1.165931224822998,
-0.29981473088264465,
0.18230971693992615,
-0.08252333104610443,
-0.39575400948524475,
-0.034414105117321014,
-1.0225918292999268,
-1.2067363262176514,
-0.47942405939102173,
-0.40501806139945984,
-0.27311941981315613,
0.1750536412000656,
1.0862817764282227,
0.2694605588912964,
-0.5170146822929382,
-0.46928757429122925,
-0.24930983781814575,
0.34020495414733887,
-0.471844881772995,
-0.16345641016960144,
0.03571314364671707,
-0.4905707836151123,
-0.4582556486129761,
0.4070146381855011,
0.3324856162071228,
0.10352951288223267,
-0.24051816761493683,
0.2525350749492645,
0.004603145644068718,
0.19916518032550812,
0.753582775592804,
0.04903002828359604,
-0.5715504288673401,
-0.02678995206952095,
-0.11704225838184357,
0.00579055305570364,
-0.10910984873771667,
1.2058049440383911,
-0.7796509265899658,
0.27810221910476685,
0.8514302372932434,
0.12866412103176117,
0.2782585918903351,
0.5119178891181946,
0.8759051561355591,
-0.6663811802864075,
-0.19958637654781342,
-0.10233603417873383,
0.20791789889335632,
0.16815200448036194,
-0.25106680393218994,
0.5053002238273621,
-0.04587838053703308,
-0.6538352966308594,
-0.6996771693229675,
0.25689074397087097,
-0.944951057434082,
-0.6019484400749207,
1.2277743816375732,
0.06293462961912155,
-0.113227479159832,
0.04770703241229057,
-0.5090104341506958,
0.14517909288406372,
-0.5138674974441528,
0.5287349224090576,
0.7943731546401978,
-0.2605871558189392,
-0.1387542486190796,
-0.2803592383861542,
0.4420754015445709,
0.10375040024518967,
-0.8263651728630066,
0.1689622700214386,
0.5954426527023315,
0.203724205493927,
0.11454992741346359,
0.9609369039535522,
0.0786258727312088,
0.1735561341047287,
-0.19902947545051575,
-0.2538246214389801,
-0.06296300888061523,
-0.4678725302219391,
-0.7987501621246338,
0.27666571736335754,
0.12434493005275726,
0.2283499836921692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00497v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00497v1
|
Recent Advances in End-to-End Simultaneous Speech Translation
| 2024-06-01T16:56:19
| 2024-06-01T16:56:19
|
Xiaoqian Liu, Guoqiang Hu, Yangfan Du, Erfeng He, YingFeng Luo, Chen Xu, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Simultaneous speech translation (SimulST) is a demanding task that involves
generating translations in real-time while continuously processing speech
input. This paper offers a comprehensive overview of the recent developments in
SimulST research, focusing on four major challenges. Firstly, the complexities
associated with processing lengthy and continuous speech streams pose
significant hurdles. Secondly, satisfying real-time requirements presents
inherent difficulties due to the need for immediate translation output.
Thirdly, striking a balance between translation quality and latency constraints
remains a critical challenge. Finally, the scarcity of annotated data adds
another layer of complexity to the task. Through our exploration of these
challenges and the proposed solutions, we aim to provide valuable insights into
the current landscape of SimulST research and suggest promising directions for
future exploration.
|
[
-0.3350140452384949,
-0.7994449138641357,
0.49995526671409607,
0.39821481704711914,
-0.5585732460021973,
0.6627526879310608,
-0.26304763555526733,
-0.723778247833252,
0.0757829025387764,
0.33306822180747986,
-0.7130429744720459,
0.11499382555484772,
-0.8400536775588989,
0.33140134811401367,
-0.44402119517326355,
0.8078057169914246,
-0.5569093823432922,
0.18744517862796783,
-0.19097164273262024,
-0.012468659318983555,
-0.6147467494010925,
-0.8486880660057068,
-0.811593234539032,
0.03427674621343613,
0.011012747883796692,
0.36113157868385315,
0.9058250784873962,
0.4352896809577942,
0.6844598054885864,
0.2166573405265808,
-0.05195382982492447,
0.18453754484653473,
-0.31406378746032715,
0.848646879196167,
0.13541431725025177,
-0.12072815746068954,
-0.2848263680934906,
-0.09107522666454315,
0.9076299071311951,
0.6982556581497192,
-0.04135824739933014,
0.18837888538837433,
-0.10374654084444046,
0.286892294883728,
-0.18686087429523468,
-0.02080685645341873,
-0.16589733958244324,
0.14258229732513428,
-0.7636023759841919,
-0.22490112483501434,
-0.055466923862695694,
-0.1603960394859314,
0.14882569015026093,
-0.6558305621147156,
0.062294233590364456,
0.13109129667282104,
0.7775015830993652,
0.7139475345611572,
-0.5063379406929016,
-0.43275225162506104,
-0.9992049336433411,
0.8015871047973633,
-0.605530321598053,
0.41036513447761536,
0.046162199229002,
0.7205747365951538,
-0.2790083587169647,
-1.1433972120285034,
-0.20592866837978363,
-0.14466428756713867,
0.34488362073898315,
0.3402833938598633,
0.07567573338747025,
-0.034753233194351196,
0.2514391541481018,
0.19280500710010529,
-0.39296862483024597,
-0.30103856325149536,
-0.3514489233493805,
-0.0567588284611702,
0.7631557583808899,
0.17306599020957947,
0.512700080871582,
0.09002760797739029,
-0.400067538022995,
0.16787029802799225,
-0.16148222982883453,
0.048679228872060776,
0.19413192570209503,
0.15143196284770966,
-0.14072516560554504,
0.5164481401443481,
-0.11867210268974304,
0.5581705570220947,
-0.42910781502723694,
0.0633499026298523,
0.31063324213027954,
-0.5182309150695801,
0.1833263635635376,
0.3450411558151245,
0.6079714894294739,
-0.0041833193972706795,
0.1703023463487625,
-0.023006634786725044,
-0.2881319522857666,
-0.289933979511261,
0.13383665680885315,
-0.5190068483352661,
0.40482261776924133,
0.49893462657928467,
-0.03164413943886757,
-0.15374784171581268,
0.1606411337852478,
-0.5040210485458374,
0.10859252512454987,
-0.6556568741798401,
0.2999878525733948,
-0.32875996828079224,
-0.31140291690826416,
0.17202143371105194,
-0.04162543639540672,
0.11748498678207397,
0.6331716179847717,
-0.4449900686740875,
0.8296217918395996,
0.6682590246200562,
1.3719416856765747,
-0.5136768221855164,
-0.2388189435005188,
-0.6960270404815674,
0.275213360786438,
-0.272850900888443,
0.7548425793647766,
-0.32555046677589417,
-0.15666042268276215,
-0.3176266551017761,
-0.3489536941051483,
-0.15815426409244537,
-0.32929936051368713,
0.6962363123893738,
0.127620667219162,
-0.20290352404117584,
-0.5910658836364746,
-0.4564860761165619,
0.09426399320363998,
-0.10271056741476059,
-0.3998164236545563,
1.1268599033355713,
-0.07293074578046799,
-0.7421379089355469,
-0.13518764078617096,
-0.5430309176445007,
-0.6073533296585083,
0.3467962443828583,
-0.449637234210968,
-0.29777848720550537,
0.3896375894546509,
0.0964699387550354,
0.3220522701740265,
-0.7256830930709839,
0.5608636736869812,
0.2497447282075882,
-0.5183481574058533,
0.49812766909599304,
-0.5084774494171143,
0.7672354578971863,
0.5736947059631348,
-0.3695809841156006,
-0.012842129915952682,
-0.4597088098526001,
-0.2546623647212982,
0.34004151821136475,
0.1628732532262802,
0.0639927089214325,
0.3364952504634857,
0.43721628189086914,
0.4857635498046875,
0.26798468828201294,
-0.8550915122032166,
0.054001688957214355,
0.1428842693567276,
0.5840075612068176,
0.5868688225746155,
0.14216655492782593,
-0.12294860929250717,
-0.36102721095085144,
0.6653235554695129,
-0.058747854083776474,
0.5815244317054749,
-0.11018477380275726,
-0.7711009979248047,
-0.4583418667316437,
-0.2204432338476181,
0.25383204221725464,
0.7631824016571045,
-0.7338811159133911,
-0.3553338348865509,
-0.3047671914100647,
-0.38293981552124023,
-1.0210530757904053,
-0.24129749834537506,
0.0904468446969986,
-0.01961148902773857,
0.5804211497306824,
-0.2874632477760315,
-0.4367859959602356,
-0.7332277894020081,
-0.4259524345397949,
0.4274456202983856,
0.4136492609977722,
0.05502237379550934,
0.17411816120147705,
0.12326422333717346,
0.738184928894043,
-0.35183626413345337,
-0.6144784092903137,
-0.14307276904582977,
0.3180307149887085,
-0.03024381957948208,
0.6059594750404358,
0.3283081352710724,
-1.1468929052352905,
-0.7589941024780273,
0.41116246581077576,
-0.8805280327796936,
-0.4210081398487091,
-0.5565776228904724,
0.35538703203201294,
-0.187387615442276,
0.8883544206619263,
-0.5177576541900635,
0.32477614283561707,
0.5513477921485901,
0.36474642157554626,
0.5313459634780884,
-0.08801284432411194,
0.28523731231689453,
-1.0983507633209229,
-0.3373161256313324,
-0.6680614948272705,
-0.4503703713417053,
-0.9014666676521301,
-0.09596879780292511,
-0.08009906858205795,
-0.41396260261535645,
-0.6762815117835999,
0.169653981924057,
-0.8194251656532288,
-0.4224633276462555,
0.017846079543232918,
0.29526272416114807,
-0.638524055480957,
0.0853608027100563,
-0.32686910033226013,
1.1372655630111694,
0.5756819248199463,
-0.1520535796880722,
0.8168079257011414,
0.06300751119852066,
0.023931261152029037,
0.4213683009147644,
-0.5656188130378723,
0.13367323577404022,
0.11240656673908234,
0.4346933662891388,
-1.1325958967208862,
-0.48740071058273315,
0.13750703632831573,
-0.6713857054710388,
0.39406952261924744,
0.09409034997224808,
-0.6142482161521912,
-0.26687198877334595,
-0.1205509677529335,
0.7048251628875732,
0.641502857208252,
-0.1128435730934143,
0.3248441815376282,
0.29774221777915955,
-0.7855346202850342,
-0.4804456830024719,
-0.6660321354866028,
0.4465402364730835,
0.2557094693183899,
-0.5949189066886902,
0.2874882221221924,
-0.08090916275978088,
-0.1588944047689438,
0.06722128391265869,
-0.35616767406463623,
0.15571750700473785,
-0.1665974110364914,
0.3288627564907074,
-0.3823623061180115,
0.012534667737782001,
-0.3132189214229584,
0.47233161330223083,
-0.4229032099246979,
-0.16614751517772675,
-0.2221294343471527,
0.41895467042922974,
0.029916109517216682,
-0.5840962529182434,
-0.7576519846916199,
0.8556590676307678,
0.6800147294998169,
-0.2952812612056732,
0.3260210156440735,
0.7911810278892517,
-0.3066909611225128,
-0.1898726224899292,
-0.5624956488609314,
0.10005328804254532,
-0.3827299177646637,
0.18924827873706818,
-0.7147699594497681,
-0.8565818071365356,
0.48603856563568115,
-0.5537499785423279,
0.3636845350265503,
0.07311942428350449,
0.528315007686615,
-0.1236703097820282,
0.9408032894134521,
0.017552893608808517,
0.6770778298377991,
0.30565163493156433,
0.23570378124713898,
0.43150198459625244,
-0.7980883121490479,
-0.28202757239341736,
-0.33186858892440796,
-0.2486787587404251,
-0.3612108528614044,
-0.6729860305786133,
0.41384291648864746,
-0.03547172620892525,
0.4200022220611572,
0.42638081312179565,
-0.427642285823822,
0.2395452857017517,
0.31422367691993713,
-0.3249362111091614,
0.26859477162361145,
-0.047031402587890625,
-0.08753138780593872,
-0.36831215023994446,
-0.49570000171661377,
-0.20239034295082092,
0.5317987203598022,
0.2537643015384674,
0.3531479835510254,
0.18130537867546082,
0.8867185711860657,
0.31740355491638184,
-0.25478264689445496,
-0.4882718026638031,
0.5359523892402649,
-0.31745004653930664,
-0.653010368347168,
-0.3899071514606476,
-0.36735254526138306,
-0.6031836271286011,
0.559349000453949,
0.02405690774321556,
-0.23487795889377594,
-0.0665752962231636,
0.09197073429822922,
-0.14040178060531616,
0.2245258092880249,
-0.49622729420661926,
0.48075070977211,
-0.5181355476379395,
-0.5571199655532837,
0.20288889110088348,
-1.2085398435592651,
0.006392928771674633,
-0.3906857967376709,
0.5158135294914246,
-0.6161220669746399,
-0.22872713208198547,
0.6156447529792786,
-0.23607684671878815,
0.5166347026824951,
-0.011311916634440422,
0.009533851407468319,
0.19393737614154816,
0.029409518465399742,
0.32594558596611023,
0.007784384768456221,
0.17291182279586792,
0.2994415760040283,
0.2942523956298828,
-0.6487140655517578,
-0.23102819919586182,
0.4311535954475403,
-0.573133647441864,
-0.3764350116252899,
-0.968941867351532,
-0.8424610495567322,
-0.20879845321178436,
0.08984008431434631,
0.5591787099838257,
0.3282943367958069,
-0.19886402785778046,
-0.09290772676467896,
0.3898380398750305,
-0.04628754034638405,
0.3420872986316681,
-0.24269016087055206,
-0.3749656081199646,
-0.47920966148376465,
1.2797576189041138,
0.773616373538971,
0.6946374773979187,
0.05214915797114372,
-0.13708555698394775,
0.047263361513614655,
-0.6835684776306152,
-0.6033288836479187,
0.34118974208831787,
-0.3300282955169678,
-0.15190310776233673,
-0.6717476844787598,
-0.509610116481781,
-0.6763496994972229,
-0.2767970860004425,
-0.9367402195930481,
-0.7392940521240234,
-0.16044358909130096,
0.2640083134174347,
0.12896482646465302,
1.0627459287643433,
-0.2632273733615875,
0.46843430399894714,
-0.5562424063682556,
0.7597886323928833,
0.15658682584762573,
0.13299736380577087,
-0.4816519320011139,
-0.4449108839035034,
-0.2144666165113449,
0.0027889451012015343,
-0.038585808128118515,
-0.9265121221542358,
0.2918916940689087,
0.04087191820144653,
0.36558082699775696,
-0.1854131817817688,
0.16337710618972778,
0.9269787669181824,
-0.6146701574325562,
0.9734432101249695,
0.09559322893619537,
-1.037566900253296,
0.34867575764656067,
-0.1769922375679016,
0.2159176468849182,
0.3997967541217804,
0.3225333094596863,
-0.8479328751564026,
-0.28153178095817566,
-0.41639357805252075,
-1.1157633066177368,
0.8924162983894348,
0.8407312631607056,
-0.13433177769184113,
0.2048361897468567,
0.2885794937610626,
0.22016727924346924,
0.27932485938072205,
-0.04170698672533035,
-0.11587735265493393,
-0.05658029392361641,
-0.027806784957647324,
-0.040398720651865005,
-0.18406416475772858,
0.30921319127082825,
-0.2993394434452057,
0.6920217275619507,
0.31969839334487915,
0.19423255324363708,
0.2320154905319214,
-0.22293204069137573,
-0.3803618848323822,
0.38286277651786804,
0.8767338991165161,
0.2885262370109558,
-0.45587265491485596,
0.05424845963716507,
0.3316308557987213,
-0.6645306944847107,
0.3638283908367157,
0.2885717451572418,
-0.36197611689567566,
0.2796931862831116,
0.31275758147239685,
0.9646592140197754,
0.5444166660308838,
-0.47413960099220276,
0.8501794338226318,
-0.15653957426548004,
-0.4103071987628937,
-0.6603887677192688,
-0.5010786056518555,
0.04346310719847679,
0.005479834508150816,
0.4817757308483124,
0.24433529376983643,
0.08038961887359619,
-0.15487729012966156,
0.27576979994773865,
0.02857143059372902,
-0.4424420893192291,
-0.330690860748291,
0.8280218243598938,
0.15529675781726837,
-0.17461030185222626,
0.4191502630710602,
-0.06200871244072914,
-0.3652164936065674,
0.3556077182292938,
0.7780067324638367,
0.9618077278137207,
-0.8949763774871826,
0.015689082443714142,
-0.04002983868122101,
0.5042346119880676,
-0.2647098898887634,
0.40951859951019287,
-0.21819768846035004,
0.07688048481941223,
-0.5540567636489868,
-0.6169888377189636,
-0.7978649139404297,
-0.3953033983707428,
-0.9053162336349487,
0.42597225308418274,
-0.12986505031585693,
-0.3733976483345032,
-0.08320560306310654,
-0.43940576910972595,
-0.19523178040981293,
-0.11265701800584793,
0.11195623129606247,
0.40836766362190247,
-0.802686870098114,
0.651434063911438,
0.8371182680130005,
-0.2723567485809326,
-0.26597219705581665,
-0.09339836984872818,
0.3153753876686096,
-0.3776337802410126,
0.2818409502506256,
-0.1314067244529724,
-0.3760780990123749,
0.33162033557891846,
-0.5547789931297302,
-1.013397216796875,
0.9101536273956299,
0.6005182862281799,
-0.6636860966682434,
-0.285331666469574,
0.49244654178619385,
0.2630520164966583,
-0.08481885492801666,
-0.26052913069725037,
0.6086028218269348,
0.5089693665504456,
0.15084300935268402,
-0.9901729822158813,
-0.19245973229408264,
-0.0327715128660202,
0.20918413996696472,
0.27727028727531433,
-0.6842985153198242,
1.1966432332992554,
-0.01953667774796486,
-0.4916766881942749,
-0.10432971268892288,
0.8140155673027039,
-0.042080026119947433,
0.4232545793056488,
0.24430881440639496,
0.24454891681671143,
0.15282706916332245,
-0.28694626688957214,
0.9432196021080017,
0.1341380774974823,
0.3381235599517822,
1.2552038431167603,
-0.4957471191883087,
0.8247966170310974,
0.8096594214439392,
-0.1858941912651062,
-0.4359794557094574,
0.5771321654319763,
0.25488945841789246,
0.15642432868480682,
0.18539178371429443,
-0.4402131736278534,
-0.3479878604412079,
-0.6209842562675476,
-0.6515796184539795,
0.1951337456703186,
0.6247548460960388,
0.31128060817718506,
-0.21641777455806732,
0.5621975064277649,
0.06358841061592102,
-0.047443948686122894,
0.3728049099445343,
0.7407747507095337,
0.459033727645874,
-0.46175435185432434,
0.35604867339134216,
-0.33299145102500916,
0.3374735116958618,
-0.8755152821540833,
-0.3075563907623291,
-0.07293132692575455,
-0.09344539046287537,
-0.18113218247890472,
-0.6474876403808594,
0.28612327575683594,
-0.040092259645462036,
0.42094430327415466,
-0.47744691371917725,
0.43221986293792725,
-0.5509486198425293,
-0.15894193947315216,
0.5210185647010803,
0.6353219747543335,
0.5825602412223816,
-0.13313336670398712,
-0.5786355137825012,
0.8683980703353882,
0.22071093320846558,
-0.3887653648853302,
0.1694411337375641,
0.5712884068489075,
-0.2628929913043976,
0.5325431227684021,
0.700027346611023,
0.4086592197418213,
0.7705309391021729,
-0.06083154305815697,
0.5610759854316711,
-0.591602087020874,
-0.3146134912967682,
-0.40309450030326843,
0.29699575901031494,
-0.03267575427889824,
-0.25976496934890747,
0.5738193392753601,
0.5994779467582703,
0.6735907793045044,
-0.00523917144164443,
0.8776310086250305,
-0.1165224015712738,
0.5354673862457275,
-0.2578485608100891,
0.5091723203659058,
-0.5769319534301758,
-0.09721365571022034,
-0.31076717376708984,
-0.8798303604125977,
-0.4235610365867615,
0.31532037258148193,
0.18308408558368683,
-0.2136182188987732,
1.0034576654434204,
0.12363219261169434,
-0.223768949508667,
0.2657703757286072,
0.6533402800559998,
0.2514004111289978,
0.4726690649986267,
0.3613963723182678,
0.8081281185150146,
-0.7279865741729736,
0.44286563992500305,
-0.6168938875198364,
-0.2536344826221466,
-0.28957197070121765,
-0.5935106873512268,
-0.33873483538627625,
-1.1153439283370972,
-0.32069337368011475,
0.1438077837228775,
0.4045332372188568,
1.1779109239578247,
0.543940007686615,
-0.7950365543365479,
-0.4315284788608551,
0.12042258679866791,
-0.4864863455295563,
-0.6797646284103394,
-0.08287618309259415,
0.2484767884016037,
-0.5468408465385437,
-0.7044171094894409,
0.48898428678512573,
0.5975862145423889,
0.41140592098236084,
0.24269329011440277,
-0.09833236783742905,
-0.5902107954025269,
0.20260608196258545,
0.5641118884086609,
0.2965332567691803,
-0.8946143984794617,
-0.04031340032815933,
-0.15548330545425415,
0.04256729781627655,
-0.20336757600307465,
1.0425776243209839,
-0.2527894973754883,
0.6643494367599487,
0.34259316325187683,
1.0415256023406982,
0.8787633180618286,
0.17918404936790466,
0.46204185485839844,
-0.8831071257591248,
0.1918664127588272,
0.38281556963920593,
0.07624097913503647,
0.5239665508270264,
-0.18053485453128815,
0.6912888288497925,
0.4981047809123993,
-0.5010573863983154,
-1.1074327230453491,
0.39676353335380554,
-1.563906192779541,
-0.13335742056369781,
0.8163332343101501,
0.06916894018650055,
-0.07780633121728897,
-0.5780377984046936,
-0.5862057209014893,
0.7860933542251587,
-0.26960450410842896,
-0.07257634401321411,
0.80694979429245,
-0.5177817344665527,
-0.3004205822944641,
-1.4160449504852295,
0.5266146659851074,
0.6612168550491333,
-0.8080481290817261,
0.3008222281932831,
0.2389936000108719,
-0.06503626704216003,
0.0211622454226017,
0.7443177700042725,
-0.37650758028030396,
0.31880274415016174,
0.2155129462480545,
-0.1688975691795349,
-0.2996160686016083,
-0.49149051308631897,
-0.1662631779909134,
0.1808728575706482,
0.04973658546805382,
-0.22055386006832123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01633v1
|
On Overcoming Miscalibrated Conversational Priors in LLM-based Chatbots
| 2024-06-01T15:54:45
| 2024-06-01T15:54:45
|
Christine Herlihy, Jennifer Neville, Tobias Schnabel, Adith Swaminathan
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We explore the use of Large Language Model (LLM-based) chatbots to power
recommender systems. We observe that the chatbots respond poorly when they
encounter under-specified requests (e.g., they make incorrect assumptions,
hedge with a long response, or refuse to answer). We conjecture that such
miscalibrated response tendencies (i.e., conversational priors) can be
attributed to LLM fine-tuning using annotators -- single-turn annotations may
not capture multi-turn conversation utility, and the annotators' preferences
may not even be representative of users interacting with a recommender system.
We first analyze public LLM chat logs to conclude that query
under-specification is common. Next, we study synthetic recommendation problems
with configurable latent item utilities and frame them as Partially Observed
Decision Processes (PODP). We find that pre-trained LLMs can be sub-optimal for
PODPs and derive better policies that clarify under-specified queries when
appropriate. Then, we re-calibrate LLMs by prompting them with learned control
messages to approximate the improved policy. Finally, we show empirically that
our lightweight learning approach effectively uses logged conversation data to
re-calibrate the response strategies of LLM-based chatbots for recommendation
tasks.
|
[
-0.1560163050889969,
-0.8422636985778809,
0.6178274154663086,
-0.0015273474855348468,
-0.12186402827501297,
0.009395954199135303,
-0.4825311303138733,
-0.2744077444076538,
0.154332235455513,
0.8172366619110107,
-0.7564687728881836,
-0.2599533498287201,
-0.36873987317085266,
-0.13021498918533325,
0.11188740283250809,
1.1464961767196655,
0.2232835292816162,
0.09442014247179031,
-0.3987908661365509,
0.01965663582086563,
-0.8777267336845398,
-0.5697318911552429,
-0.6896302700042725,
-0.7604172229766846,
0.45280635356903076,
0.5461292266845703,
1.014458179473877,
-0.18749961256980896,
0.4711454212665558,
0.2729945778846741,
-0.05031793192028999,
0.3963279128074646,
-1.0091818571090698,
0.1439313143491745,
-0.0665789544582367,
-0.8960199356079102,
-0.437982439994812,
-0.16115102171897888,
0.21238568425178528,
0.692049503326416,
-0.2776869237422943,
-0.07601641118526459,
0.22560065984725952,
0.5977288484573364,
-0.7990778088569641,
0.09066477417945862,
-1.1468939781188965,
0.15220242738723755,
0.17242269217967987,
-0.4115801155567169,
-0.6736829876899719,
-0.0995398759841919,
0.3276471197605133,
-0.6838090419769287,
0.3045642673969269,
0.3303532004356384,
0.4097325801849365,
0.5054259896278381,
-0.11841176450252533,
-0.27128446102142334,
-1.0780315399169922,
0.9178086519241333,
-0.7326370477676392,
0.33265647292137146,
0.9560315012931824,
0.5181930065155029,
-0.6664707660675049,
-0.4666745364665985,
-0.48205333948135376,
-0.463199257850647,
-0.2605176270008087,
0.08736150711774826,
-0.23886728286743164,
0.18334421515464783,
0.3249126672744751,
0.17029784619808197,
-0.42697054147720337,
0.1780119687318802,
-0.26037490367889404,
-0.41371822357177734,
0.496561735868454,
0.20262731611728668,
-0.34383055567741394,
0.018022093921899796,
-0.16123464703559875,
0.07553992420434952,
-0.8685446381568909,
-0.11623585224151611,
0.3363140821456909,
0.4047410786151886,
0.02803688310086727,
0.6167840361595154,
-0.210643470287323,
0.4628691077232361,
0.4503326416015625,
-0.03539476543664932,
0.09284656494855881,
-0.4262999892234802,
-0.3724709153175354,
0.06928104907274246,
0.8034929037094116,
0.5813704133033752,
0.705498993396759,
-0.1322983205318451,
-0.06922359764575958,
-0.24941430985927582,
0.4226047396659851,
-0.6269588470458984,
-0.4027954638004303,
0.008825321681797504,
-0.2052258849143982,
-0.11504259705543518,
-0.45411649346351624,
-0.2861696183681488,
-0.642823338508606,
-0.13600261509418488,
0.4759146273136139,
-0.16712920367717743,
0.06230537220835686,
0.1948755830526352,
0.11690303683280945,
-0.03900615870952606,
0.46954429149627686,
-0.9554059505462646,
0.39488527178764343,
0.34136879444122314,
0.5970306396484375,
0.29971519112586975,
0.026015350595116615,
-0.31714215874671936,
0.04587448015809059,
-0.30861204862594604,
0.7802202701568604,
-0.5399249792098999,
-0.7657285332679749,
0.09385842829942703,
0.07845064997673035,
-0.019119665026664734,
-0.5964705348014832,
0.4446824789047241,
-0.487347275018692,
0.2632976770401001,
-0.003527906257659197,
-0.47264111042022705,
-0.17744210362434387,
0.42174243927001953,
-0.17021368443965912,
0.7527329921722412,
-0.17723804712295532,
-0.5629052519798279,
0.32456275820732117,
-0.28211796283721924,
-0.21207532286643982,
-0.143380805850029,
0.03257985785603523,
-0.13220034539699554,
0.05181775987148285,
0.3168681859970093,
0.7212388515472412,
-0.33862507343292236,
0.2702665328979492,
-0.47709015011787415,
-0.446625292301178,
0.08981907367706299,
-0.6579405069351196,
0.07237639278173447,
0.13192817568778992,
0.08152017742395401,
0.4038042724132538,
-0.553966760635376,
-0.016769597306847572,
0.07403749227523804,
-0.03194670379161835,
-0.2659609019756317,
0.3023791015148163,
-0.044074226170778275,
-0.12334267050027847,
0.47675445675849915,
-0.25359851121902466,
0.16481894254684448,
-0.6578570604324341,
0.5013808012008667,
0.7444726228713989,
0.08720554411411285,
0.5808091163635254,
-0.5350669026374817,
0.15739963948726654,
-0.14185206592082977,
0.15400192141532898,
-0.2909280061721802,
-0.24388164281845093,
-0.8985838294029236,
0.3223784267902374,
-0.012039247900247574,
0.6396965980529785,
-0.6728278398513794,
0.585124671459198,
-0.07059946656227112,
-0.6758231520652771,
-0.3184705376625061,
0.27741187810897827,
0.3025527000427246,
0.45346853137016296,
0.43431705236434937,
-0.20746026933193207,
-0.52497398853302,
-0.9358543753623962,
-0.05185433849692345,
-0.47864770889282227,
-0.16895900666713715,
0.725222110748291,
0.09769204258918762,
-0.3941230773925781,
0.86037278175354,
-0.6006741523742676,
-0.4128260314464569,
-0.09516743570566177,
-0.1948884129524231,
0.27195119857788086,
0.39931970834732056,
0.11831137537956238,
-0.619178831577301,
-0.19823691248893738,
-0.19494491815567017,
-0.3433936536312103,
-0.0537630096077919,
-0.302495539188385,
0.15436533093452454,
0.06587289273738861,
0.6329941749572754,
-0.48005184531211853,
0.2081782966852188,
0.32074403762817383,
0.13935722410678864,
0.4605981111526489,
-0.5740999579429626,
-0.09006759524345398,
-0.9947975873947144,
-0.3019648790359497,
0.24686002731323242,
-0.5074759721755981,
-0.25497302412986755,
-0.40661370754241943,
-0.16528767347335815,
0.0695548802614212,
-0.35751911997795105,
0.39089256525039673,
-0.12272649258375168,
0.14333803951740265,
-0.4917985498905182,
0.14140932261943817,
-0.3031165599822998,
0.7366872429847717,
-0.020005609840154648,
0.6714839339256287,
0.3214404881000519,
-0.6799399852752686,
0.31700003147125244,
0.1745075285434723,
0.04362065717577934,
0.7006785869598389,
-0.9238170981407166,
0.380205363035202,
-0.038141097873449326,
0.7641429901123047,
-1.1830133199691772,
0.04090388864278793,
0.3473154604434967,
-0.08543532341718674,
0.028803156688809395,
-0.5352518558502197,
-0.44223299622535706,
-0.2540406584739685,
-0.20087255537509918,
0.21022550761699677,
0.4325307607650757,
-0.19657762348651886,
0.5323240756988525,
0.3013492226600647,
0.011789595708251,
-0.4861719310283661,
-0.3665965795516968,
-0.07426686584949493,
-0.08785675466060638,
-0.395411878824234,
0.37699514627456665,
-0.5312178134918213,
-0.13490398228168488,
-0.42292022705078125,
-0.11635058373212814,
0.11846070736646652,
0.07359641045331955,
0.6112140417098999,
0.2068634182214737,
-0.10926046967506409,
0.21671968698501587,
-0.21492503583431244,
-0.12292083352804184,
-0.15960878133773804,
-0.24802803993225098,
0.7768189907073975,
-0.093834288418293,
-0.44004392623901367,
-0.5022979378700256,
-0.20446787774562836,
0.4545581638813019,
0.291973739862442,
0.39843541383743286,
0.5652509331703186,
-0.22916238009929657,
0.06593992561101913,
-0.7878642082214355,
-0.637033224105835,
-0.5036210417747498,
0.27410075068473816,
-0.2830103635787964,
-0.9091684818267822,
0.38890451192855835,
-0.1430768519639969,
0.2210867553949356,
0.27969008684158325,
0.6824122071266174,
-0.17171978950500488,
0.9290584921836853,
0.7491351366043091,
-0.24116992950439453,
0.6271542310714722,
-0.05257376655936241,
0.08777295053005219,
-0.672569751739502,
0.022313257679343224,
-0.44742950797080994,
-0.29659175872802734,
-0.673227071762085,
-0.3020550012588501,
0.30189386010169983,
0.13095849752426147,
-0.16454362869262695,
0.4141848087310791,
-0.25779464840888977,
0.5347723364830017,
0.5652753114700317,
0.2815863788127899,
0.15389268100261688,
-0.29463469982147217,
-0.13162830471992493,
-0.04085010662674904,
-0.7386748790740967,
-0.5679264068603516,
1.2867487668991089,
0.32685405015945435,
1.1193543672561646,
-0.25823360681533813,
0.32353392243385315,
0.3881782591342926,
0.09269782900810242,
-1.001068353652954,
0.47999557852745056,
0.08866045624017715,
-0.41707372665405273,
-0.14193570613861084,
-0.25158417224884033,
-0.895208477973938,
0.22959303855895996,
-0.5832195281982422,
-0.8628904819488525,
-0.1634226143360138,
0.27656877040863037,
-0.37838876247406006,
-0.030742572620511055,
-0.9132130146026611,
0.6860715746879578,
-0.08232979476451874,
-0.22529257833957672,
-0.49528127908706665,
-0.7028898596763611,
0.04661181569099426,
-0.07419726997613907,
0.18247903883457184,
-0.2814685106277466,
0.34086868166923523,
0.5448964834213257,
-0.35272496938705444,
1.2357029914855957,
-0.14084124565124512,
-0.013495129533112049,
0.09999841451644897,
0.20410925149917603,
0.7377520799636841,
0.16992738842964172,
0.08365002274513245,
0.06262309104204178,
0.15985827147960663,
-0.188933864235878,
-0.735935389995575,
0.764648973941803,
-0.7906486988067627,
-0.9633853435516357,
0.0669579803943634,
-0.4472004473209381,
-0.5220859050750732,
0.06716039776802063,
0.07647471874952316,
0.19069331884384155,
-0.3582683205604553,
0.314643919467926,
0.40694135427474976,
0.016236715018749237,
0.2028207778930664,
0.6869475841522217,
-0.10840675234794617,
-0.3009030222892761,
0.6137239933013916,
-0.044286370277404785,
0.2061435580253601,
0.4321293830871582,
0.40350472927093506,
-0.34292566776275635,
-0.6577631235122681,
-0.29621222615242004,
0.030544856563210487,
-0.5917851328849792,
-0.14146849513053894,
-0.5331527590751648,
-0.022003866732120514,
-0.3632164001464844,
-0.07632838189601898,
-0.23994098603725433,
-0.2094564139842987,
-0.5167191028594971,
-0.03048400767147541,
0.41363075375556946,
0.5666030645370483,
0.22438372671604156,
0.7768498659133911,
-0.6472167372703552,
0.1234675943851471,
0.12034635990858078,
0.08437220752239227,
-0.16848087310791016,
-0.6657153367996216,
-0.14944961667060852,
0.31515318155288696,
-0.5231430530548096,
-0.4359965920448303,
0.2156066745519638,
0.12108124792575836,
0.6069158911705017,
0.3911968469619751,
0.23370665311813354,
0.7487871646881104,
-0.694407045841217,
0.8047799468040466,
0.09841522574424744,
-0.45284727215766907,
0.6240261197090149,
-0.22151686251163483,
0.2843949794769287,
0.6348887085914612,
0.3972014784812927,
-0.5217500925064087,
-0.3721640706062317,
-0.6977410316467285,
-0.7775929570198059,
0.5103058218955994,
0.06806611269712448,
0.6438498497009277,
0.21235287189483643,
0.33987635374069214,
0.13989588618278503,
0.2629888951778412,
-0.47001785039901733,
-0.45383235812187195,
0.0030375735368579626,
-0.05442442372441292,
-0.6291759014129639,
-0.390829473733902,
-0.148665189743042,
0.13637369871139526,
0.6776549816131592,
-0.3155226707458496,
-0.1906302571296692,
0.15275102853775024,
-0.1854809820652008,
-0.24439845979213715,
0.1900808960199356,
0.6184399127960205,
0.5289474725723267,
-0.37312427163124084,
-0.07319432497024536,
0.355739563703537,
-0.2119339257478714,
-0.14633876085281372,
0.14705030620098114,
0.08565975725650787,
-0.2740701138973236,
0.07693933695554733,
0.7185395359992981,
0.5538589954376221,
-0.553957998752594,
0.2647751271724701,
-0.18870417773723602,
0.10956455767154694,
-0.36542046070098877,
0.307115375995636,
-0.085898257791996,
0.22307509183883667,
0.42911258339881897,
0.4506853520870209,
-0.07382377982139587,
-0.4378474950790405,
0.06814565509557724,
0.7097287774085999,
-0.7985242009162903,
-0.20319205522537231,
0.30580759048461914,
0.41296419501304626,
-0.5771269202232361,
0.20281149446964264,
0.34019359946250916,
-0.3049744963645935,
0.20406629145145416,
0.5216143131256104,
0.6442292928695679,
0.26551541686058044,
-0.024146296083927155,
0.0348956398665905,
0.23917712271213531,
-0.12363799661397934,
-0.2719099819660187,
-0.4527072310447693,
-1.1522120237350464,
-0.19152095913887024,
-0.39545804262161255,
-0.7055042386054993,
0.13747571408748627,
-0.19420641660690308,
0.2722941040992737,
-0.7671833038330078,
-0.4005052447319031,
0.12641258537769318,
0.13317453861236572,
-0.7590203881263733,
-0.01960647478699684,
-0.04740293696522713,
0.48796331882476807,
-0.5822267532348633,
0.5772773027420044,
0.46620485186576843,
-0.301268607378006,
-0.5669277906417847,
0.018350280821323395,
0.013060505501925945,
-0.9851007461547852,
0.3378898799419403,
-0.06655055284500122,
-0.308171808719635,
-0.021809764206409454,
-0.6910322904586792,
-0.5255652666091919,
0.803007960319519,
0.3636212944984436,
-0.7537115812301636,
0.05536339059472084,
-0.20120693743228912,
0.650238573551178,
-0.16569441556930542,
0.7501019239425659,
0.2394159436225891,
0.2032517045736313,
0.3345101475715637,
-1.393478512763977,
-0.10735000669956207,
0.12917479872703552,
-0.2073441445827484,
0.11175770312547684,
-0.6358456015586853,
0.2657455503940582,
-0.3501388430595398,
0.04199656844139099,
0.15487979352474213,
0.4818262457847595,
0.29090332984924316,
0.3864358961582184,
0.5224862694740295,
0.28544068336486816,
0.73783278465271,
0.158957377076149,
0.9551546573638916,
-0.05347640439867973,
0.16321700811386108,
1.2989447116851807,
-0.48647430539131165,
0.9275447130203247,
0.5754306316375732,
-0.29167884588241577,
0.38918086886405945,
0.807165265083313,
0.10986658185720444,
0.41488611698150635,
0.3079012334346771,
-0.005702713970094919,
-0.48023107647895813,
-0.21924808621406555,
-0.285497784614563,
0.36176303029060364,
0.49588510394096375,
-0.24805587530136108,
-0.2534298598766327,
-0.08271566033363342,
-0.17737071216106415,
0.17962616682052612,
-0.29437243938446045,
1.0992213487625122,
0.19579100608825684,
-0.4926258623600006,
0.7242558002471924,
-0.11908480525016785,
1.0809108018875122,
-0.6378600001335144,
0.0029718189034610987,
-0.06419011950492859,
0.16090066730976105,
-0.15910492837429047,
-0.5550367832183838,
-0.033986110240221024,
-0.27162808179855347,
-0.41948509216308594,
-0.20924954116344452,
0.9571456909179688,
-0.25503942370414734,
-0.46291813254356384,
-0.0014090852346271276,
0.6448113918304443,
0.26966172456741333,
-0.14531639218330383,
-0.7485709190368652,
-0.4627116918563843,
-0.07026387751102448,
-0.011982341296970844,
0.20887233316898346,
0.320823073387146,
-0.1398100107908249,
0.9842333197593689,
0.880669891834259,
0.05357624962925911,
-0.4769657552242279,
0.20737729966640472,
0.597874641418457,
-0.48008251190185547,
-0.3634943664073944,
-0.7975244522094727,
0.059047698974609375,
0.2459230124950409,
-0.20690158009529114,
0.587693452835083,
0.22636964917182922,
0.9949050545692444,
0.07626431435346603,
0.5273237228393555,
0.46553781628608704,
0.2623744010925293,
-0.7108153104782104,
0.5744510293006897,
-0.3550109267234802,
0.5805543661117554,
-0.06734984368085861,
-0.9476139545440674,
-0.2435392290353775,
0.44123804569244385,
-0.6627724766731262,
0.2903836667537689,
0.3149975538253784,
1.0521881580352783,
0.09800360351800919,
0.04045456647872925,
0.6290322542190552,
0.10160453617572784,
0.31335383653640747,
0.5401129126548767,
0.9454365968704224,
-0.29884856939315796,
0.6587173342704773,
-0.06237379088997841,
0.17215530574321747,
-0.49804985523223877,
-0.6958456635475159,
-0.9678761959075928,
-0.38287463784217834,
-0.05640081688761711,
-0.2716616690158844,
0.21283459663391113,
1.2632356882095337,
0.9872704744338989,
-0.762744128704071,
-0.11541538685560226,
-0.06997241079807281,
0.407073050737381,
0.12663327157497406,
-0.22022555768489838,
-0.07172081619501114,
-0.3815520703792572,
-0.654310941696167,
0.5438345670700073,
0.06802191585302353,
0.32230624556541443,
-0.36467117071151733,
-0.022688306868076324,
0.0985386073589325,
-0.023507067933678627,
0.4469965696334839,
0.08246707171201706,
-0.8458145260810852,
-0.3677622675895691,
-0.3107708990573883,
-0.1829552799463272,
0.18285241723060608,
0.9778473973274231,
-1.0960922241210938,
0.3883986175060272,
0.17471159994602203,
0.35539186000823975,
0.6217272281646729,
-0.15096858143806458,
0.8592161536216736,
-0.8105875253677368,
0.3121175169944763,
0.388421893119812,
0.4268372058868408,
0.39766570925712585,
-0.4148513674736023,
0.24470636248588562,
0.12577193975448608,
-0.6580374240875244,
-0.5809028148651123,
0.245232954621315,
-0.9282357692718506,
-0.2014434039592743,
1.0939124822616577,
0.05976145714521408,
0.03515409678220749,
-0.17707641422748566,
-0.6710541248321533,
-0.09591618180274963,
-0.7419638633728027,
0.617042064666748,
0.6640161275863647,
-0.04287511482834816,
-0.07826893776655197,
-0.39589637517929077,
0.48245203495025635,
0.529633104801178,
-0.24593234062194824,
0.26255002617836,
0.7511464357376099,
0.19158393144607544,
0.2403901368379593,
0.8050170540809631,
0.308551549911499,
-0.023792847990989685,
-0.2460305094718933,
-0.32700103521347046,
0.0710594654083252,
-0.30778414011001587,
-0.13762539625167847,
0.0171603262424469,
0.3252109885215759,
-0.05209644138813019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00456v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00456v1
|
Mix-of-Granularity: Optimize the Chunking Granularity for Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-01T14:45:03
| 2024-06-01T14:45:03
|
Zijie Zhong, Hanwen Liu, Xiaoya Cui, Xiaofan Zhang, Zengchang Qin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Integrating information from different reference data sources is a major
challenge for Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) systems because each
knowledge source adopts a unique data structure and follows different
conventions. Retrieving from multiple knowledge sources with one fixed strategy
usually leads to under-exploitation of information. To mitigate this drawback,
inspired by Mix-of-Expert, we introduce Mix-of-Granularity (MoG), a method that
dynamically determines the optimal granularity of a knowledge database based on
input queries using a router. The router is efficiently trained with a newly
proposed loss function employing soft labels. We further extend MoG to
Mix-of-Granularity-Graph (MoGG), where reference documents are pre-processed
into graphs, enabling the retrieval of relevant information from distantly
situated chunks. Extensive experiments demonstrate that both MoG and MoGG
effectively predict optimal granularity levels, significantly enhancing the
performance of the RAG system in downstream tasks. The code of both MoG and
MoGG will be made public.
|
[
-0.6459574103355408,
-0.9115641117095947,
0.3851551413536072,
-0.15196579694747925,
-0.28232434391975403,
0.2331436276435852,
0.26018598675727844,
-0.34983715415000916,
0.4915555417537689,
0.35961034893989563,
-0.30931997299194336,
-0.07328115403652191,
-0.5335931777954102,
-0.33405813574790955,
-0.300050288438797,
0.9115514159202576,
0.10784270614385605,
-0.12045828998088837,
-0.5081804990768433,
-0.21810609102249146,
-0.34889525175094604,
-0.4239855110645294,
-0.3176831305027008,
-0.7335953116416931,
0.569803774356842,
0.26093921065330505,
0.8526544570922852,
0.692977786064148,
0.5107060670852661,
0.25266924500465393,
-0.36223626136779785,
0.8795248866081238,
-0.6422472596168518,
0.20523232221603394,
-0.44639700651168823,
-0.03921445831656456,
-0.7310961484909058,
-0.20097950100898743,
0.4471452236175537,
0.7976397275924683,
-0.35961660742759705,
0.05779918283224106,
-0.06554052978754044,
0.710450291633606,
-0.9628655910491943,
0.0032162282150238752,
-0.6886265873908997,
0.1654503047466278,
-0.24565444886684418,
-0.4569145739078522,
-0.06302361935377121,
-0.19436821341514587,
-0.03327639400959015,
-0.5750168561935425,
0.049242909997701645,
0.15040814876556396,
0.7574435472488403,
0.31177979707717896,
-0.5613935589790344,
-0.5341616272926331,
-0.619543731212616,
0.5935324430465698,
-0.40453147888183594,
0.2986268401145935,
0.4064708948135376,
0.27209052443504333,
-0.27879780530929565,
-0.665930986404419,
-0.48188167810440063,
0.043409012258052826,
-0.2724255323410034,
0.05485021695494652,
0.22508646547794342,
-0.058322615921497345,
-0.015902496874332428,
0.678786039352417,
-0.26261106133461,
-0.5635721683502197,
-0.19355444610118866,
-0.1350802779197693,
0.5085279941558838,
-0.004860732238739729,
0.06885898113250732,
-0.34032779932022095,
-0.40948957204818726,
-0.0009196067112497985,
-0.3701756000518799,
-0.4801671504974365,
0.45926252007484436,
0.2629276216030121,
0.3856829106807709,
0.43561333417892456,
-0.46269872784614563,
1.049644947052002,
0.6092498302459717,
-0.552431046962738,
0.44697198271751404,
-0.6444605588912964,
0.04642987623810768,
-0.17074830830097198,
0.6394652724266052,
0.030133821070194244,
-0.2989298403263092,
-0.4248463809490204,
-0.483575701713562,
-0.5983943343162537,
0.44144487380981445,
-0.4803934395313263,
-0.11251400411128998,
0.000127374121802859,
-0.3384764790534973,
-0.5529152154922485,
0.0889587476849556,
-0.6621853709220886,
-0.570911705493927,
-0.2675305902957916,
0.6456172466278076,
-0.7011962532997131,
-0.2387719601392746,
-0.09868668019771576,
-0.3303760588169098,
-0.23134614527225494,
0.18190081417560577,
-0.719140887260437,
0.4153265655040741,
0.5535979866981506,
0.7344377636909485,
-0.05272957682609558,
-0.08555158972740173,
-0.7508924007415771,
0.5638871788978577,
-0.037865880876779556,
0.8236862421035767,
-0.5399606823921204,
-0.7697718739509583,
-0.1630660593509674,
-0.6176819205284119,
-0.14676512777805328,
-0.7953508496284485,
0.40681692957878113,
-0.7759901881217957,
0.12545189261436462,
-0.11863954365253448,
-0.4823541045188904,
-0.19798435270786285,
0.48394620418548584,
-0.6083650588989258,
1.2401734590530396,
0.5341011881828308,
-0.7760726809501648,
0.5356155633926392,
-0.4803202450275421,
-0.557561457157135,
0.23728740215301514,
-0.26674744486808777,
-0.09768597781658173,
0.19195674359798431,
0.06779562681913376,
0.10447289049625397,
-0.06207263842225075,
0.17793498933315277,
-0.1635628342628479,
-0.1253172904253006,
-0.16081121563911438,
0.10766111314296722,
0.3214656114578247,
0.4352259635925293,
0.10635549575090408,
-0.27536293864250183,
-0.7882760167121887,
0.3212277293205261,
-0.08431710302829742,
-0.8264355659484863,
-0.64508455991745,
0.3497175872325897,
-0.18012253940105438,
0.17947596311569214,
0.42168816924095154,
-0.0022196059580892324,
0.20780590176582336,
0.2544151246547699,
-0.003107303287833929,
0.3882259428501129,
0.1387685090303421,
0.68412184715271,
-0.6017438769340515,
0.4489506185054779,
0.17036202549934387,
0.004260477144271135,
-0.10779991000890732,
-0.08803043514490128,
-0.5708662271499634,
-0.04210801050066948,
0.6147870421409607,
0.4736309349536896,
-1.1017917394638062,
0.5450394749641418,
-0.35029128193855286,
-0.4301830232143402,
-0.06383481621742249,
0.2252677083015442,
0.35560286045074463,
0.7086236476898193,
0.3697463274002075,
-0.4270578622817993,
-0.32231491804122925,
-0.6000561714172363,
-0.2369261234998703,
-0.1162266656756401,
0.020425623282790184,
0.8324496150016785,
0.20466472208499908,
-0.45391085743904114,
0.9968363642692566,
-0.5786649584770203,
-0.22623981535434723,
-0.08901248872280121,
0.273314505815506,
0.11790705472230911,
0.4728953242301941,
0.38660746812820435,
-1.2041879892349243,
-0.3548373878002167,
0.5030949115753174,
-0.5698996186256409,
-0.23162199556827545,
0.08702412247657776,
-0.3197327256202698,
-0.35565564036369324,
0.38143590092658997,
-0.22910372912883759,
0.06241658702492714,
0.5706313252449036,
-0.21814532577991486,
0.6277185082435608,
-0.26823484897613525,
0.3463090658187866,
-0.9485480189323425,
0.019451193511486053,
-0.27879035472869873,
-0.4456866681575775,
-0.5167930126190186,
0.30429717898368835,
0.07313325256109238,
0.01603986881673336,
-0.22396492958068848,
0.5340393781661987,
-0.48062387108802795,
-0.0480562262237072,
-0.23599830269813538,
0.22621451318264008,
0.17334848642349243,
0.2318723499774933,
-0.3910806477069855,
0.9576190114021301,
0.26483944058418274,
-0.8806954622268677,
0.21771132946014404,
0.13154396414756775,
0.0014550666091963649,
0.7181211709976196,
-0.41208529472351074,
0.25648996233940125,
-0.18875521421432495,
0.15315347909927368,
-0.33519673347473145,
-0.5757388472557068,
0.08233928680419922,
-0.3418494760990143,
0.5379337668418884,
-0.5190032124519348,
-0.43399178981781006,
-0.05380522832274437,
-0.07256718724966049,
0.4887675642967224,
0.6532820463180542,
-0.3367369472980499,
1.1863219738006592,
0.6761773228645325,
0.08492176234722137,
-0.49780991673469543,
-0.4685038626194,
-0.23208127915859222,
-0.03324652090668678,
-0.9963217377662659,
0.6365424394607544,
0.0015835666563361883,
-0.2756240665912628,
0.11915560811758041,
-0.376035213470459,
-0.30744728446006775,
-0.39310529828071594,
-0.01894260011613369,
-0.0632326677441597,
0.10748022049665451,
0.09556826949119568,
0.1268681138753891,
0.06638593971729279,
-0.31054991483688354,
-0.6007131934165955,
0.742734968662262,
0.05734769627451897,
-0.4454989433288574,
0.44785892963409424,
0.28717145323753357,
0.3059505522251129,
-0.08535965532064438,
0.5759044289588928,
0.6124426126480103,
-0.023648200556635857,
-0.25878599286079407,
-0.6436140537261963,
0.24335536360740662,
-0.5364865064620972,
0.24401085078716278,
-0.5117576718330383,
-0.37397506833076477,
0.6213914155960083,
-0.4676399528980255,
-0.20051473379135132,
0.3634240925312042,
0.3068946599960327,
-0.10865724086761475,
0.5467584729194641,
0.43210020661354065,
0.1333799660205841,
0.7695784568786621,
-0.37115615606307983,
0.06000540778040886,
-0.9032397270202637,
-0.4885998070240021,
-0.25814884901046753,
-0.44265854358673096,
-0.2501196265220642,
-0.923516571521759,
0.5816072225570679,
0.42202019691467285,
0.12538295984268188,
0.01070944219827652,
-0.4018649160861969,
0.6989281177520752,
0.5462921857833862,
0.41201671957969666,
0.36331284046173096,
0.22742599248886108,
-0.2922080457210541,
0.5231123566627502,
-0.9871594309806824,
-0.20832031965255737,
0.8210040330886841,
-0.15026026964187622,
0.9151334166526794,
-0.0512789748609066,
0.9961615800857544,
0.443571537733078,
-0.23901845514774323,
-0.842962920665741,
0.6487417817115784,
-0.3248937129974365,
-0.621601939201355,
-0.06333254277706146,
-0.9641100168228149,
-0.8411654233932495,
0.45182862877845764,
-0.11990530788898468,
-0.35507115721702576,
0.3302520215511322,
0.37761011719703674,
0.027911754325032234,
0.3979432284832001,
-0.6583096981048584,
0.19481024146080017,
0.005535229574888945,
-0.2675926983356476,
-0.06016600504517555,
-0.3837182819843292,
0.2786453664302826,
-0.22809326648712158,
0.5691496133804321,
0.1962285190820694,
-0.13959693908691406,
0.6574347615242004,
-0.693837583065033,
0.17717358469963074,
-0.09005814790725708,
0.21196259558200836,
0.6175405979156494,
0.23419995605945587,
0.6327582597732544,
-0.0704820528626442,
-0.1778300553560257,
0.028649060055613518,
-0.2695085406303406,
-0.6053159236907959,
-0.5480545163154602,
0.6878224611282349,
-0.6856990456581116,
-0.39949825406074524,
-0.2698034644126892,
-0.8732015490531921,
-0.3305676281452179,
0.4094793498516083,
0.2876338064670563,
0.6377760767936707,
0.12535475194454193,
0.2005830854177475,
0.989445686340332,
0.23659513890743256,
0.16690407693386078,
0.16779910027980804,
-0.18531495332717896,
-0.5941284894943237,
1.1195076704025269,
0.3416103422641754,
0.5094738602638245,
0.30472105741500854,
0.36584511399269104,
0.09741117060184479,
-0.6529800891876221,
-0.38359254598617554,
0.23642465472221375,
-0.7068992257118225,
-0.22997577488422394,
-0.5960823893547058,
-0.26802802085876465,
-0.17083103954792023,
-0.1887764036655426,
-0.18835273385047913,
-0.39941808581352234,
-0.24481068551540375,
0.2821393311023712,
0.10385634005069733,
0.7688223123550415,
-0.15058858692646027,
0.3821025490760803,
-1.0830397605895996,
0.24574697017669678,
0.4116646349430084,
0.4246875047683716,
-0.1533910483121872,
-0.4181303381919861,
-0.40355437994003296,
0.037924136966466904,
-0.4059893488883972,
-0.7870309948921204,
0.00529574416577816,
0.22423838078975677,
0.702700138092041,
0.2429109811782837,
-0.25758326053619385,
0.8866754770278931,
-0.5581889748573303,
0.5481474995613098,
0.2792629599571228,
-0.7597838640213013,
0.42033064365386963,
-0.8341342210769653,
0.2633315622806549,
0.7224465608596802,
0.1976798176765442,
-0.3414241373538971,
0.08654049038887024,
-0.7920346260070801,
-1.1724252700805664,
0.6842830181121826,
0.16652169823646545,
-0.039422765374183655,
0.03012884594500065,
0.3183014690876007,
0.24999898672103882,
0.40360456705093384,
-0.31432482600212097,
-0.23620504140853882,
0.10439451038837433,
-0.07681309431791306,
0.5691645741462708,
-0.24998176097869873,
-0.47908544540405273,
0.04638360068202019,
0.6573426723480225,
-0.1537655144929886,
0.1368522346019745,
0.0675586462020874,
-0.054690171033144,
-0.1808006316423416,
-0.08743466436862946,
0.01429924089461565,
0.9939315319061279,
-0.20834468305110931,
0.1373215913772583,
0.16335977613925934,
-0.8449117541313171,
0.023539451882243156,
-0.05987633019685745,
-0.6013636589050293,
0.23073959350585938,
0.2675945460796356,
0.5832970142364502,
0.025907160714268684,
-0.4609464406967163,
0.14012910425662994,
0.374286413192749,
-0.27931734919548035,
0.11277095228433609,
0.5420038104057312,
-0.13751067221164703,
0.1716756969690323,
0.7092264294624329,
0.2817670404911041,
0.35544589161872864,
-0.549626350402832,
0.246831476688385,
0.3763124644756317,
-0.04048238694667816,
0.02563181146979332,
0.3561828136444092,
0.21804921329021454,
-0.4389828145503998,
0.1809113621711731,
-0.5508891344070435,
-0.3025524318218231,
0.43830254673957825,
0.24201257526874542,
0.582170307636261,
0.03626324608922005,
0.15863125026226044,
-0.031006019562482834,
-0.16888874769210815,
-0.09522248059511185,
0.3018397092819214,
-0.09727295488119125,
-0.5410264134407043,
-0.2820266783237457,
-0.7204515337944031,
-0.4655083119869232,
-0.24924281239509583,
-0.6244760155677795,
0.16949956119060516,
-0.16713367402553558,
-0.33479616045951843,
-0.23558075726032257,
0.0023657840210944414,
-0.6078329086303711,
0.3334066867828369,
-0.05818720906972885,
0.8334568738937378,
-0.4471427798271179,
0.5252201557159424,
0.9461813569068909,
-0.3186592757701874,
-0.7486585378646851,
0.151021346449852,
-0.19132651388645172,
-0.726912796497345,
0.532956600189209,
-0.5401306748390198,
-0.16778089106082916,
-0.14783784747123718,
-0.2475663721561432,
-1.0644171237945557,
1.2853182554244995,
-0.0726781040430069,
-0.15694370865821838,
-0.21114124357700348,
-0.15170225501060486,
0.10150838643312454,
-0.3267180621623993,
0.23443429172039032,
0.4495406448841095,
0.4569832384586334,
0.7637138366699219,
-0.7959789633750916,
-0.2965447008609772,
-0.12508518993854523,
-0.013594724237918854,
0.6292275786399841,
-0.7065832018852234,
0.9671486020088196,
0.11227795481681824,
0.053318291902542114,
-0.6115555763244629,
0.5833157896995544,
0.37391120195388794,
0.5007031559944153,
0.673619270324707,
0.5695382952690125,
0.9602864384651184,
-0.07079560309648514,
1.2219538688659668,
-0.2968021333217621,
0.38497403264045715,
1.0223647356033325,
0.17246967554092407,
0.4748939573764801,
0.5452249646186829,
-0.4136391282081604,
0.5204624533653259,
0.3527354300022125,
0.4440712332725525,
0.7672324180603027,
-0.09727155417203903,
-0.42151978611946106,
0.0761374682188034,
-0.15705369412899017,
-0.42708656191825867,
0.006216047797352076,
0.29890257120132446,
-0.2507348656654358,
-0.37447893619537354,
-0.3600996434688568,
0.007181940600275993,
-0.19391979277133942,
-0.47238677740097046,
0.8166802525520325,
-0.3183140456676483,
-0.4410146474838257,
0.5657957196235657,
-0.20648469030857086,
0.5553217530250549,
-0.8546319603919983,
0.15761345624923706,
-0.4054042100906372,
0.01833389326930046,
-0.477230042219162,
-0.5331683158874512,
0.25230327248573303,
-0.41825756430625916,
-0.5018970966339111,
-0.049634214490652084,
1.0260417461395264,
-0.5278275012969971,
-0.5022132992744446,
0.06458437442779541,
0.6702671647071838,
0.039266008883714676,
0.03101140819489956,
-0.4835340082645416,
0.014330847188830376,
0.00951299536973238,
-0.36085617542266846,
0.6987507939338684,
0.8875808715820312,
0.16220764815807343,
0.5136899352073669,
0.5619361400604248,
0.325929194688797,
0.35521748661994934,
-0.17383742332458496,
1.284385085105896,
-0.3594430387020111,
-0.5013434886932373,
-0.40823209285736084,
0.5084888935089111,
-0.3780911862850189,
-0.023871317505836487,
0.5512754321098328,
0.42998698353767395,
0.7288827896118164,
0.07123831659555435,
0.8632875084877014,
-0.6098094582557678,
0.23993030190467834,
-0.41175493597984314,
0.4494095742702484,
-0.7689689993858337,
0.10946618020534515,
-0.11680009961128235,
-0.969921350479126,
0.1682063490152359,
0.3286106288433075,
-0.1863078624010086,
0.5308519601821899,
0.710364580154419,
0.57124263048172,
-0.4138859510421753,
-0.350372314453125,
0.2905435860157013,
-0.26111704111099243,
0.26642102003097534,
0.046878620982170105,
0.37453001737594604,
-0.3428666293621063,
0.7065500617027283,
-0.32183927297592163,
-0.3875980079174042,
-0.4919140040874481,
-0.8693161606788635,
-0.5750659108161926,
-0.330419659614563,
-0.21130862832069397,
-0.3913488984107971,
0.06641300022602081,
0.5149362683296204,
0.917923092842102,
-0.3746044337749481,
-0.006573403719812632,
-0.041759785264730453,
0.1866341084241867,
-0.08321405947208405,
-0.2162947803735733,
0.13129137456417084,
-0.6154177784919739,
-0.6107977032661438,
0.40093985199928284,
0.25902774930000305,
0.017993325367569923,
-0.08406560122966766,
-0.11154485493898392,
-0.3614726960659027,
0.400336354970932,
0.5099849700927734,
-0.038717709481716156,
-0.276162713766098,
0.0033008193131536245,
-0.1275419145822525,
-0.07686550915241241,
-0.019847890362143517,
0.9291900396347046,
-0.9137483835220337,
0.6191452741622925,
0.8124096989631653,
0.5807039737701416,
0.61538165807724,
0.6560617685317993,
0.29032963514328003,
-1.0218729972839355,
0.18557992577552795,
0.40203163027763367,
0.31269025802612305,
0.11613258719444275,
-0.5327321290969849,
0.8433241248130798,
0.25055035948753357,
-0.7283233404159546,
-0.5296951532363892,
0.28223562240600586,
-0.9695597290992737,
-0.32528048753738403,
1.235826015472412,
0.11113841831684113,
-0.21347282826900482,
0.019282497465610504,
-0.23773913085460663,
0.00443115271627903,
-0.46127697825431824,
0.6875566244125366,
0.7547128796577454,
-0.3167141079902649,
0.2195938676595688,
-0.3662821054458618,
0.2729373276233673,
0.15738582611083984,
-0.7747569680213928,
-0.3511676788330078,
0.6663463115692139,
0.0923561081290245,
0.5218766927719116,
0.6198664307594299,
-0.03890284150838852,
0.0030234616715461016,
0.47143882513046265,
-0.1772269457578659,
-0.5406100153923035,
-0.18507996201515198,
0.2541329562664032,
0.4197714924812317,
-0.20780256390571594,
-0.12555871903896332
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00393v1
|
Gender Bias Detection in Court Decisions: A Brazilian Case Study
| 2024-06-01T10:34:15
| 2024-06-01T10:34:15
|
Raysa Benatti, Fabiana Severi, Sandra Avila, Esther Luna Colombini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Data derived from the realm of the social sciences is often produced in
digital text form, which motivates its use as a source for natural language
processing methods. Researchers and practitioners have developed and relied on
artificial intelligence techniques to collect, process, and analyze documents
in the legal field, especially for tasks such as text summarization and
classification. While increasing procedural efficiency is often the primary
motivation behind natural language processing in the field, several works have
proposed solutions for human rights-related issues, such as assessment of
public policy and institutional social settings. One such issue is the presence
of gender biases in court decisions, which has been largely studied in social
sciences fields; biased institutional responses to gender-based violence are a
violation of international human rights dispositions since they prevent gender
minorities from accessing rights and hamper their dignity. Natural language
processing-based approaches can help detect these biases on a larger scale.
Still, the development and use of such tools require researchers and
practitioners to be mindful of legal and ethical aspects concerning data
sharing and use, reproducibility, domain expertise, and value-charged choices.
In this work, we (a) present an experimental framework developed to
automatically detect gender biases in court decisions issued in Brazilian
Portuguese and (b) describe and elaborate on features we identify to be
critical in such a technology, given its proposed use as a support tool for
research and assessment of court~activity.
|
[
-0.4320501685142517,
-0.8198614120483398,
0.45014214515686035,
0.30235299468040466,
-0.034467581659555435,
0.09104318171739578,
-0.022879282012581825,
-0.48383864760398865,
-0.14288043975830078,
0.47470635175704956,
-0.34811484813690186,
-0.24168553948402405,
-0.6475576162338257,
0.2416767179965973,
-0.7513509392738342,
1.0326735973358154,
-0.10705696791410446,
0.6645563840866089,
-0.1864253580570221,
-0.38224250078201294,
-0.5922523140907288,
-0.44984373450279236,
-0.5311114192008972,
-0.2315460741519928,
0.07983561605215073,
0.06006975099444389,
0.511165201663971,
0.4478044807910919,
0.2594163417816162,
0.32890281081199646,
-0.44835343956947327,
-0.024968240410089493,
-0.21673545241355896,
0.0914776548743248,
-0.22395460307598114,
-0.4807831048965454,
-0.39121076464653015,
0.22876912355422974,
0.6150781512260437,
0.4687282145023346,
-0.09328919649124146,
0.3485885560512543,
-0.08816778659820557,
0.8607900142669678,
-0.5668869018554688,
0.2763574421405792,
-0.3700876235961914,
0.48535600304603577,
-0.16810210049152374,
-0.0868024006485939,
-0.14105667173862457,
-0.6583415865898132,
0.37543267011642456,
-0.39924222230911255,
0.6934677958488464,
0.12747858464717865,
0.7459843158721924,
0.2627091407775879,
-0.42589426040649414,
-0.2702440917491913,
-0.6958850622177124,
0.7217440009117126,
-0.4521287977695465,
0.3708799183368683,
0.4924794137477875,
0.45947596430778503,
-0.20934738218784332,
-0.10205207020044327,
-0.534351646900177,
-0.33219635486602783,
-0.22993086278438568,
-0.2072734832763672,
-0.4081689417362213,
-0.08373796194791794,
0.626376748085022,
-0.13571973145008087,
-0.3979414701461792,
-0.051204223185777664,
-0.3782828450202942,
-0.2914051413536072,
0.7313490509986877,
-0.2623109221458435,
0.37460362911224365,
-0.15557029843330383,
0.23120848834514618,
0.09454413503408432,
-0.4915403127670288,
0.08150150626897812,
0.9557892084121704,
0.3828103840351105,
0.0003474803233984858,
0.3478735685348511,
-0.20849278569221497,
0.5178789496421814,
0.15619418025016785,
0.07589507102966309,
0.2250237911939621,
-0.19075772166252136,
-0.03115549124777317,
0.38030102849006653,
0.8664999604225159,
0.11886481940746307,
0.4949236810207367,
0.06690461188554764,
-0.20824141800403595,
-0.008762923069298267,
0.40887510776519775,
-0.5824448466300964,
0.3762373924255371,
0.20778509974479675,
-0.6401823163032532,
-0.4935459792613983,
-0.06651122123003006,
-0.9296601414680481,
-0.6680678129196167,
-0.5146908164024353,
-0.02153090387582779,
-0.2621960937976837,
-0.15793055295944214,
-0.1738252490758896,
-0.5153785943984985,
0.246965229511261,
0.41243109107017517,
-0.7704774141311646,
0.386654794216156,
0.5749524831771851,
0.6196324825286865,
0.13232488930225372,
0.1566951870918274,
-0.4843177795410156,
-0.14672845602035522,
-0.1563080996274948,
0.6144960522651672,
-0.49414491653442383,
-0.5269432663917542,
0.2347378432750702,
0.000357927696313709,
0.22381336987018585,
-0.5644651651382446,
0.9506858587265015,
-0.20503652095794678,
0.34498849511146545,
-0.4736015200614929,
-0.2513314187526703,
-0.05629950761795044,
0.09327871352434158,
-0.573733389377594,
0.9109663367271423,
0.012326851487159729,
-0.8948143720626831,
1.0329983234405518,
-0.860672652721405,
-0.6252975463867188,
0.09937336295843124,
-0.6858518719673157,
-0.8319193720817566,
-0.1849573701620102,
0.10715194046497345,
0.06381871551275253,
-0.31309646368026733,
0.6380885243415833,
-0.4541790187358856,
-0.39479494094848633,
0.2557474672794342,
-0.32745227217674255,
0.875999927520752,
0.038052428513765335,
-0.6406269669532776,
0.18984651565551758,
-0.576777994632721,
-0.5100468993186951,
0.21783150732517242,
-0.16424274444580078,
-0.2996094226837158,
0.2251807600259781,
0.043597668409347534,
0.13731107115745544,
-0.20945122838020325,
-0.5976263880729675,
-0.08640814572572708,
0.07227536290884018,
0.3929624557495117,
0.6230647563934326,
-0.4019480347633362,
0.654754102230072,
-0.30049172043800354,
0.46175774931907654,
-0.1759498566389084,
0.31503596901893616,
0.2936145067214966,
-0.5064902305603027,
-0.4273878335952759,
-0.15521839261054993,
0.5877798199653625,
0.5696629881858826,
-0.4279773533344269,
0.32978570461273193,
-0.09514379501342773,
-0.021101413294672966,
-0.8573415279388428,
-0.06797614693641663,
0.26972058415412903,
0.6374223828315735,
0.18034589290618896,
-0.10467025637626648,
-0.7964882254600525,
-1.2365115880966187,
-0.5601357817649841,
-0.1280089169740677,
0.033823270350694656,
0.3387463390827179,
0.9394176006317139,
-0.1297243982553482,
1.358510971069336,
-0.020700370892882347,
-0.3652178943157196,
0.06631738692522049,
0.5159397125244141,
0.08976304531097412,
0.4229958951473236,
0.8284153938293457,
-1.139401912689209,
0.039963334798812866,
-0.024365276098251343,
-0.8942988514900208,
-0.4727512300014496,
0.2915201485157013,
-0.33157217502593994,
0.22170676290988922,
0.14081867039203644,
-0.12261724472045898,
0.7747654914855957,
-0.1563911885023117,
-0.6413022875785828,
0.6580969095230103,
-0.11244627833366394,
0.5754153728485107,
-0.21023288369178772,
0.17830504477024078,
0.3260871469974518,
-0.5437074303627014,
-0.6156854629516602,
-0.24885247647762299,
0.14279823005199432,
0.31132379174232483,
-0.5349023938179016,
0.35558611154556274,
-0.388137549161911,
-0.4352092444896698,
-0.3581054210662842,
-0.09634865075349808,
-0.19511714577674866,
0.2012479156255722,
0.15646056830883026,
0.737417459487915,
0.19339236617088318,
-0.6193463206291199,
-0.04649197682738304,
0.36865219473838806,
0.016521135345101357,
1.0758564472198486,
-0.5142117738723755,
0.02809377759695053,
-0.4137156903743744,
0.14930258691310883,
-0.276311993598938,
-0.12130988389253616,
0.45326870679855347,
-0.4317361116409302,
0.052712395787239075,
-0.6593034863471985,
-0.364799439907074,
-0.5362319350242615,
-0.5560634136199951,
0.23940564692020416,
0.22271281480789185,
-0.08608279377222061,
0.548054039478302,
0.9186730980873108,
-0.06673777848482132,
-0.8434154987335205,
-0.6146090030670166,
0.09591055661439896,
-0.28454598784446716,
-0.3640170991420746,
0.16448165476322174,
0.085879847407341,
-0.5759992599487305,
-0.021494776010513306,
0.21165676414966583,
-0.18855972588062286,
0.16845782101154327,
0.5117204189300537,
0.31273335218429565,
0.11811896413564682,
0.05830701068043709,
0.6104483008384705,
0.1997595578432083,
0.2972269356250763,
-0.07637617737054825,
0.49324896931648254,
-0.29778435826301575,
-0.1738322675228119,
-0.3525889813899994,
0.4737132787704468,
0.5660203695297241,
-0.04822652041912079,
0.47288548946380615,
0.4660136103630066,
-0.5825015902519226,
0.00019780050206463784,
-0.6286553144454956,
0.04004935920238495,
-0.36820024251937866,
-0.07487162202596664,
-0.013225816190242767,
-0.8352693319320679,
0.5657360553741455,
0.19416989386081696,
0.034448131918907166,
0.3740919828414917,
0.6204434037208557,
-0.1850491464138031,
0.9896292090415955,
0.4193696081638336,
-0.2884328067302704,
0.6718254685401917,
-0.04286767914891243,
0.08726433664560318,
-0.5998284816741943,
-0.06892795860767365,
-1.0099385976791382,
-0.32306379079818726,
-0.8066681027412415,
-0.10699689388275146,
0.30276480317115784,
-0.483765572309494,
-0.35955914855003357,
0.11239436268806458,
-0.5121703743934631,
0.35267457365989685,
0.8441348075866699,
0.17489643394947052,
0.35363712906837463,
-0.0871715173125267,
-0.16520482301712036,
0.10996510088443756,
-0.4293316900730133,
-0.9046937823295593,
1.0121756792068481,
0.21918413043022156,
0.23056431114673615,
-0.09969676285982132,
0.5381664633750916,
1.057770013809204,
0.22942997515201569,
-0.585046112537384,
0.4777334928512573,
0.12561748921871185,
-0.7457797527313232,
-0.32528531551361084,
-0.3999105989933014,
-1.0419306755065918,
0.4260896146297455,
-0.4727054536342621,
-0.7116299271583557,
0.5379561185836792,
0.060282908380031586,
-0.28853368759155273,
0.04796314984560013,
-0.3788606822490692,
0.7735561728477478,
-0.0967530831694603,
-0.8441526293754578,
-0.17246152460575104,
-0.45553502440452576,
0.34824252128601074,
0.12099532037973404,
0.431844562292099,
-0.06450866162776947,
0.42910236120224,
0.9340677261352539,
-0.3146139085292816,
0.49009010195732117,
-0.18949855864048004,
-0.15367011725902557,
0.23174375295639038,
0.11424769461154938,
0.18785028159618378,
0.08332914113998413,
-0.14678962528705597,
0.23665843904018402,
0.05227642133831978,
-0.2941203713417053,
-0.2931179404258728,
0.43095239996910095,
-0.7526683211326599,
-0.48078030347824097,
-0.7010089755058289,
-0.4633379280567169,
0.02071206644177437,
0.27631139755249023,
-0.08863291889429092,
-0.057897962629795074,
-0.48168450593948364,
-0.22218526899814606,
0.6185114979743958,
-0.1988208293914795,
0.34804269671440125,
0.7246854901313782,
-0.11856213212013245,
0.0285093504935503,
0.559063732624054,
0.3282102346420288,
-0.4464949369430542,
0.04333408176898956,
0.17411449551582336,
-0.2499224841594696,
-0.48439598083496094,
-0.7060145735740662,
0.04507767781615257,
-0.3605179786682129,
0.029068797826766968,
-0.6035574078559875,
0.1613243669271469,
-0.682102382183075,
0.022830486297607422,
-0.007585649844259024,
-0.2880517840385437,
-0.02329804003238678,
-0.1739068329334259,
0.19070042669773102,
0.40640223026275635,
0.09999074786901474,
0.07816973328590393,
-0.44633564352989197,
0.6278056502342224,
0.3105778098106384,
0.16004012525081635,
-0.35845741629600525,
-0.39019307494163513,
0.29067274928092957,
0.15318942070007324,
-0.26618778705596924,
-1.0901449918746948,
0.619688868522644,
-0.32062190771102905,
0.5541468262672424,
0.2176329493522644,
-0.21289226412773132,
0.29509779810905457,
-0.4636242687702179,
0.36685091257095337,
-0.23973950743675232,
-1.0563178062438965,
1.0285718441009521,
-0.6849514842033386,
-0.06764484196901321,
0.6447035074234009,
0.1677224189043045,
-0.4915805757045746,
-0.4574407935142517,
-0.7976372241973877,
-0.6506521701812744,
1.1055670976638794,
0.5371633172035217,
-0.17800462245941162,
0.34148749709129333,
0.47019824385643005,
0.2795056104660034,
0.7460927367210388,
-0.5956546664237976,
0.013767130672931671,
0.0482989177107811,
-0.04048136994242668,
0.44570493698120117,
-0.08153744786977768,
-0.40403103828430176,
-0.32290777564048767,
0.7107095718383789,
-0.2618650197982788,
0.3246901333332062,
0.28080281615257263,
-0.44725823402404785,
-0.17914338409900665,
0.5328973531723022,
0.5465588569641113,
0.5800520777702332,
-0.25849419832229614,
-0.036471810191869736,
0.27637526392936707,
-0.33738985657691956,
0.18115505576133728,
0.2776736915111542,
-0.8453484177589417,
0.11760899424552917,
0.09593542665243149,
0.6212552189826965,
-0.10705607384443283,
-0.7698715925216675,
0.5913425087928772,
-0.43112167716026306,
-0.19566036760807037,
-0.485208660364151,
-0.03188970312476158,
-0.4207380712032318,
0.34587061405181885,
0.33796948194503784,
0.1819474846124649,
0.8737300038337708,
-0.6791337728500366,
0.21185988187789917,
0.3504246175289154,
-0.5464915633201599,
0.012692789547145367,
0.5701097846031189,
0.275600790977478,
-0.3844280540943146,
0.22936217486858368,
-0.42094144225120544,
-0.680817723274231,
0.7446179389953613,
0.04777126386761665,
0.8486190438270569,
0.0520908422768116,
0.3667938709259033,
0.04444504156708717,
0.22930707037448883,
-0.41472068428993225,
0.2578098475933075,
-0.25411754846572876,
-0.6775388121604919,
0.05166118964552879,
-0.37758365273475647,
-0.462710976600647,
-0.3448486924171448,
-0.7121605277061462,
0.3969863951206207,
-0.5122941732406616,
-0.44962140917778015,
-0.08441278338432312,
-0.11251252889633179,
-0.7728519439697266,
-0.06889075040817261,
0.4370864927768707,
0.37967774271965027,
-0.9361646771430969,
0.3853130042552948,
0.4282371401786804,
-0.3617240786552429,
-0.025431593880057335,
-0.344645231962204,
0.4812963902950287,
-0.5531175136566162,
0.771346390247345,
0.1733400672674179,
-0.3068988025188446,
-0.8127308487892151,
-0.44995713233947754,
-0.07096101343631744,
0.7822731137275696,
0.7626341581344604,
-0.6768704652786255,
0.15471389889717102,
0.40263667702674866,
0.7492366433143616,
-0.09124923497438431,
0.657489001750946,
1.1711671352386475,
0.7086151242256165,
-0.26348620653152466,
-0.9755181670188904,
0.07576806098222733,
-0.3519914448261261,
-0.11067868024110794,
0.2473098635673523,
-0.45650917291641235,
0.5269517302513123,
0.08498984575271606,
-0.0005024874699302018,
-0.5710320472717285,
0.6054142713546753,
0.3306533396244049,
0.7234551906585693,
0.5248337984085083,
0.18010345101356506,
1.0371581315994263,
-0.41653192043304443,
1.1485698223114014,
0.01969534531235695,
0.1713729202747345,
0.900206983089447,
-0.4789980947971344,
0.2674960792064667,
0.44563809037208557,
-0.333133727312088,
0.3570321798324585,
0.3693208396434784,
-0.0879942998290062,
0.042867597192525864,
0.37874311208724976,
-0.25948286056518555,
0.05030108988285065,
-0.6200447082519531,
-0.11091284453868866,
0.39830848574638367,
0.27933263778686523,
-0.5201586484909058,
-0.03157839551568031,
-0.08858764916658401,
0.28856250643730164,
0.25408801436424255,
-0.2985466420650482,
0.5779783129692078,
-0.1241862028837204,
-0.6648793816566467,
-0.19743627309799194,
0.15904594957828522,
0.6797335147857666,
-0.28903549909591675,
-0.1930965632200241,
-0.08340422809123993,
-0.028214817866683006,
-0.275044322013855,
-0.8414953947067261,
0.24986231327056885,
0.4382003843784332,
-0.3021186292171478,
-0.4499947130680084,
0.8644037842750549,
-0.057618144899606705,
-0.5938239097595215,
0.4157378375530243,
0.5335320830345154,
-0.1769222468137741,
-0.20387780666351318,
-0.9106510877609253,
-0.026065807789564133,
-0.2666262686252594,
-0.07240402698516846,
0.3925534188747406,
0.3034361004829407,
-0.5819554924964905,
0.8327113389968872,
0.4931667745113373,
0.2364264577627182,
0.0704241469502449,
0.5390813946723938,
0.45276108384132385,
-0.5423905253410339,
-0.6045150756835938,
-0.9019815921783447,
0.019055625423789024,
-0.5711001753807068,
-0.2653782069683075,
0.43629783391952515,
0.5151320695877075,
0.49340546131134033,
0.21889030933380127,
0.9507812857627869,
-0.13473328948020935,
0.40052568912506104,
-0.22615933418273926,
0.6941207051277161,
0.0172982607036829,
0.0824841558933258,
-0.4194105863571167,
-0.44317764043807983,
-0.26221346855163574,
0.7633715271949768,
-0.45646074414253235,
0.05758892744779587,
0.16286805272102356,
0.5513880848884583,
0.18810023367404938,
0.40831834077835083,
-0.07046487182378769,
-0.06856933981180191,
0.3751598298549652,
0.016242926940321922,
0.8133039474487305,
-0.36564987897872925,
0.24543017148971558,
0.019953889772295952,
-0.2628323435783386,
-0.2991451323032379,
-0.7409229278564453,
-0.8507515788078308,
-0.23306521773338318,
-0.34990984201431274,
-0.2220449596643448,
0.4096105992794037,
0.9551109075546265,
0.6037382483482361,
-0.9146198630332947,
-0.465433269739151,
-0.10381004959344864,
0.5223590135574341,
-0.25781920552253723,
-0.20834186673164368,
0.11747515946626663,
-0.009853044524788857,
-0.7445088028907776,
-0.05191308632493019,
0.061132870614528656,
-0.09112945199012756,
-0.03595595061779022,
0.014033121056854725,
-0.3901473879814148,
-0.12277266383171082,
0.5421105027198792,
0.2792808711528778,
-0.3186391592025757,
-0.23912402987480164,
-0.42107897996902466,
0.12473845481872559,
0.20934033393859863,
1.08932626247406,
-0.839791476726532,
0.3240099847316742,
0.6773524284362793,
0.36928561329841614,
0.42476987838745117,
-0.16511976718902588,
0.8530625700950623,
-0.4785386323928833,
0.20577086508274078,
0.40694013237953186,
0.9460281729698181,
0.1845577359199524,
-0.2593960762023926,
0.5684705972671509,
0.32691216468811035,
-0.3894691467285156,
-0.795587956905365,
-0.1342024803161621,
-0.8073270916938782,
-0.3216690421104431,
0.9397106170654297,
0.22502008080482483,
-0.4500729441642761,
-0.3810168206691742,
-0.731949508190155,
0.5750412940979004,
-0.9891612529754639,
1.022173285484314,
0.6256884336471558,
-0.08413548022508621,
0.1557150036096573,
-0.8617624044418335,
0.4609558582305908,
0.22871926426887512,
-0.7804274559020996,
-0.007291426882147789,
0.5338253974914551,
0.08864726126194,
0.1609557420015335,
0.3138430416584015,
-0.38693517446517944,
0.481450617313385,
-0.5186581015586853,
0.24347367882728577,
0.16460943222045898,
0.09806465357542038,
-0.4668537676334381,
0.3121672570705414,
-0.2745000422000885,
0.13269002735614777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06558v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06558v1
|
Enhancing Text Authenticity: A Novel Hybrid Approach for AI-Generated Text Detection
| 2024-06-01T10:21:54
| 2024-06-01T10:21:54
|
Ye Zhang, Qian Leng, Mengran Zhu, Rui Ding, Yue Wu, Jintong Song, Yulu Gong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) has ushered in an era
where AI-generated text is increasingly indistinguishable from human-generated
content. Detecting AI-generated text has become imperative to combat
misinformation, ensure content authenticity, and safeguard against malicious
uses of AI. In this paper, we propose a novel hybrid approach that combines
traditional TF-IDF techniques with advanced machine learning models, including
Bayesian classifiers, Stochastic Gradient Descent (SGD), Categorical Gradient
Boosting (CatBoost), and 12 instances of Deberta-v3-large models. Our approach
aims to address the challenges associated with detecting AI-generated text by
leveraging the strengths of both traditional feature extraction methods and
state-of-the-art deep learning models. Through extensive experiments on a
comprehensive dataset, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method
in accurately distinguishing between human and AI-generated text. Our approach
achieves superior performance compared to existing methods. This research
contributes to the advancement of AI-generated text detection techniques and
lays the foundation for developing robust solutions to mitigate the challenges
posed by AI-generated content.
|
[
-0.043729037046432495,
-1.2157132625579834,
0.3453853130340576,
-0.02385844476521015,
-0.3138132691383362,
0.804837703704834,
-0.090378537774086,
-0.686726987361908,
0.09423129260540009,
0.6198642253875732,
-0.30961140990257263,
-0.70164555311203,
-0.6139361262321472,
0.22187155485153198,
-0.5951934456825256,
0.9544959664344788,
0.08643020689487457,
-0.2144375741481781,
-0.03165741264820099,
-0.07033280283212662,
-0.16872335970401764,
-0.33253058791160583,
-0.8142018914222717,
-0.3486345708370209,
0.1290714591741562,
0.19210058450698853,
0.5694612264633179,
0.6165401935577393,
0.4045649766921997,
0.3088932931423187,
-0.00020929570018779486,
0.7003384232521057,
-0.17898884415626526,
-0.04093164950609207,
-0.10013870149850845,
-0.269326388835907,
-0.3295581042766571,
-0.034115828573703766,
0.6830234527587891,
-0.004814032930880785,
0.056112486869096756,
-0.04751179739832878,
-0.05966730788350105,
0.38734009861946106,
-0.6020287275314331,
-0.1937006115913391,
-0.8705082535743713,
-0.10932236909866333,
-0.33936047554016113,
-0.3487609028816223,
-0.5066759586334229,
-0.1962224841117859,
-0.22870658338069916,
-0.3963424861431122,
0.32637113332748413,
-0.037047699093818665,
0.8521643877029419,
0.19168293476104736,
-0.5274572968482971,
-0.38123977184295654,
-1.0351015329360962,
0.6269261240959167,
-0.8285230994224548,
0.11261934041976929,
0.17119675874710083,
0.19658923149108887,
-0.10013897716999054,
-0.7280827164649963,
-1.2027150392532349,
-0.3824726939201355,
0.054437290877103806,
0.08808374404907227,
-0.1769692301750183,
-0.1441403478384018,
0.07362110167741776,
0.5753195881843567,
-0.6254112720489502,
0.6401693224906921,
0.044001951813697815,
-0.36345383524894714,
0.7275385856628418,
0.050011005252599716,
0.8363945484161377,
-0.05959498509764671,
-0.45465633273124695,
-0.26819080114364624,
-0.5895112752914429,
0.027550704777240753,
0.49787798523902893,
0.03513438627123833,
-0.09674832224845886,
0.4022912085056305,
-0.13083720207214355,
0.37284156680107117,
0.055912960320711136,
-0.5789848566055298,
0.2194521725177765,
-0.4241134524345398,
-0.16417039930820465,
0.043798185884952545,
1.1812748908996582,
0.06076927110552788,
0.29763907194137573,
-0.16083374619483948,
-0.2969205975532532,
0.21621227264404297,
0.09610038250684738,
-0.6692010760307312,
-0.05191376060247421,
0.0632501021027565,
-0.6460072994232178,
-0.9307597875595093,
0.2703072130680084,
-0.8565534949302673,
-0.6172718405723572,
0.006976667791604996,
0.5046309232711792,
-0.38295868039131165,
-0.5827487707138062,
-0.06702351570129395,
-0.12415798008441925,
0.2673560380935669,
0.25023576617240906,
-0.7547067403793335,
0.06530950218439102,
0.7002008557319641,
0.6129184365272522,
-0.47786715626716614,
0.020857704803347588,
-0.5019873976707458,
0.24328391253948212,
-0.3304966986179352,
0.7780799865722656,
-0.6418960094451904,
-0.2209092676639557,
0.12286214530467987,
-0.3626413941383362,
0.2239357829093933,
-0.7205557227134705,
0.7925222516059875,
-0.6532773971557617,
0.17299659550189972,
0.3510710299015045,
-0.5244336724281311,
-0.10902004688978195,
0.4018942415714264,
-0.8033245801925659,
1.3666869401931763,
0.0037610202562063932,
-0.7963787317276001,
0.4445596933364868,
-0.6299658417701721,
-0.7448117136955261,
0.4019726514816284,
-0.293630450963974,
-0.7972936630249023,
-0.02326114848256111,
0.5118954181671143,
0.44692885875701904,
-0.18366506695747375,
0.4294312000274658,
-0.16577574610710144,
-0.23246990144252777,
0.46954911947250366,
-0.8709869980812073,
0.8022174835205078,
0.04131300002336502,
-0.5977559685707092,
0.1042485460639,
-1.0057806968688965,
-0.1882573515176773,
0.24010856449604034,
-0.25083836913108826,
-0.4826543629169464,
-0.02444974146783352,
0.263902485370636,
0.01868567243218422,
0.4681210219860077,
-0.6041257381439209,
0.009374922141432762,
-0.43445149064064026,
0.32433125376701355,
0.6286984086036682,
0.10636238008737564,
0.4333304762840271,
-0.19555117189884186,
0.5650668144226074,
0.15051384270191193,
-0.19307494163513184,
-0.3799128234386444,
-0.4615463614463806,
-0.6524116396903992,
-0.5224454998970032,
0.35385826230049133,
0.8769923448562622,
-1.0939573049545288,
0.9109212160110474,
-0.22549384832382202,
-0.6349119544029236,
-0.5923618674278259,
0.23181378841400146,
0.3649255633354187,
0.5808284878730774,
0.2582724392414093,
0.04923534765839577,
-0.23534949123859406,
-0.9295371174812317,
-0.3513290584087372,
-0.379487007856369,
-0.14425404369831085,
0.15420441329479218,
0.6307554841041565,
-0.40452587604522705,
0.8515873551368713,
-0.09803034365177155,
-0.22556576132774353,
-0.4363299608230591,
0.4500945806503296,
-0.1807498037815094,
0.6773524284362793,
0.5859474539756775,
-1.0747283697128296,
-0.5757350921630859,
0.12614023685455322,
-0.72640460729599,
-0.21508744359016418,
-0.4686202108860016,
0.04530920088291168,
0.19545042514801025,
0.47403833270072937,
-0.47106730937957764,
0.5173736214637756,
0.2811906039714813,
-0.20076847076416016,
0.32824328541755676,
-0.20396508276462555,
0.37268495559692383,
-1.330381989479065,
0.11816365271806717,
0.27656781673431396,
-0.43402084708213806,
-0.518958330154419,
0.24923986196517944,
0.13575829565525055,
-0.0006685002590529621,
-0.07908468693494797,
0.6208449006080627,
-0.18032920360565186,
0.33391058444976807,
-0.5695350170135498,
0.00011786547838710248,
0.11594251543283463,
0.1056089997291565,
0.046415798366069794,
0.880653440952301,
0.18947069346904755,
-0.2577981650829315,
0.31176379323005676,
0.07095979899168015,
-0.20010080933570862,
0.530646800994873,
-0.5773549675941467,
0.21138666570186615,
-0.14087584614753723,
0.42953062057495117,
-1.1138869524002075,
-0.17493993043899536,
0.595234215259552,
-0.6995146870613098,
0.5310837626457214,
0.19093841314315796,
-0.9645390510559082,
-0.12572017312049866,
-0.3776406943798065,
0.4174725413322449,
0.6296846866607666,
-0.6963803768157959,
0.8983299732208252,
0.27876704931259155,
-0.09605053812265396,
-0.5011224746704102,
-0.5472049117088318,
0.48776480555534363,
-0.25260043144226074,
-0.6238431930541992,
0.7174528241157532,
0.05914389342069626,
-0.2645654082298279,
-0.06772080063819885,
0.13382749259471893,
-0.18239164352416992,
0.5223990678787231,
-0.041595496237277985,
0.31694892048835754,
-0.33390212059020996,
-0.15298348665237427,
0.5190830230712891,
-0.1586279422044754,
-0.13863928616046906,
-0.22348496317863464,
0.3322032690048218,
0.2524028718471527,
-0.17178837954998016,
-1.0619702339172363,
0.5184656381607056,
0.722913920879364,
-0.5561999678611755,
0.8491305708885193,
1.1590818166732788,
-0.6047847270965576,
-0.4466668665409088,
-0.622890293598175,
-0.2390270084142685,
-0.4878785312175751,
0.3421126902103424,
0.0018145503709092736,
-0.8615778684616089,
0.1968114674091339,
-0.060314737260341644,
-0.05002303421497345,
0.6490105986595154,
0.6246705651283264,
-0.10455367714166641,
1.0377806425094604,
0.7423032522201538,
-0.25655192136764526,
0.5360766649246216,
0.038786549121141434,
0.36491402983665466,
-0.38527098298072815,
-0.34865355491638184,
-0.6404144763946533,
-0.21683216094970703,
-0.8266352415084839,
-0.2544001638889313,
0.053229786455631256,
0.025551417842507362,
0.043150097131729126,
0.08392323553562164,
-0.455996572971344,
0.4874343276023865,
0.7378647327423096,
0.388656347990036,
0.48560139536857605,
0.2165859192609787,
0.2332216054201126,
-0.0009454441606067121,
-0.23973342776298523,
-0.7907322645187378,
1.1983630657196045,
0.3125966191291809,
0.3987314701080322,
0.03462710604071617,
0.6472216248512268,
0.7550169229507446,
0.4834069311618805,
-0.4452567398548126,
0.5371766686439514,
-0.1994701772928238,
-0.5717521905899048,
0.03867116943001747,
-0.3654528856277466,
-0.558539867401123,
0.03068491257727146,
-0.7936299443244934,
-0.6827491521835327,
-0.34256142377853394,
0.052689388394355774,
-0.20168714225292206,
0.49182334542274475,
-0.4844474494457245,
0.7034209966659546,
-0.3904978930950165,
-0.33649882674217224,
-0.3246690034866333,
-0.3878771662712097,
0.28648439049720764,
-0.31145766377449036,
0.09976674616336823,
0.07350216060876846,
-0.3162594139575958,
0.6739471554756165,
0.006067556794732809,
0.8482146859169006,
0.023624010384082794,
-0.2586039900779724,
0.283354252576828,
0.11743253469467163,
0.7931555509567261,
0.2277568131685257,
0.0743720531463623,
0.20462347567081451,
-0.5738232135772705,
-0.3790018558502197,
-0.5412904024124146,
0.5715168118476868,
-0.6071627736091614,
-0.49450376629829407,
-0.33434346318244934,
-0.42471420764923096,
0.06175293028354645,
0.39794889092445374,
0.284471333026886,
0.3407890796661377,
-0.32432401180267334,
0.15084241330623627,
0.6919470429420471,
-0.422901451587677,
0.6334866881370544,
0.41089022159576416,
0.07628628611564636,
-0.6649717092514038,
1.0504049062728882,
-0.4875016510486603,
0.03345920145511627,
0.7359997630119324,
0.13232329487800598,
-0.30574485659599304,
-1.121334433555603,
-0.6774922013282776,
0.08273407071828842,
-0.369089275598526,
-0.14938604831695557,
-0.8078573942184448,
-0.274545818567276,
-0.4201677739620209,
-0.1437608152627945,
-0.09488687664270401,
-0.1373150497674942,
-0.6606348752975464,
-0.12240596860647202,
0.12709271907806396,
0.5965191721916199,
0.21460272371768951,
0.3594086766242981,
-0.9399551749229431,
0.5533702373504639,
-0.036801472306251526,
-0.19355402886867523,
-0.07516283541917801,
-0.42619919776916504,
-0.011553898453712463,
0.14308881759643555,
-0.3311921954154968,
-0.7686539888381958,
0.4402463734149933,
0.13553082942962646,
0.5782163739204407,
0.6532727479934692,
0.14222842454910278,
0.1211051493883133,
-0.24483434855937958,
0.930709719657898,
0.018836261704564095,
-0.8695288896560669,
0.5424900650978088,
-0.49305394291877747,
-0.1128808781504631,
0.47879332304000854,
0.24623288214206696,
-0.06714215874671936,
-0.5765434503555298,
-0.7219488024711609,
-0.624137818813324,
0.22020961344242096,
0.46869829297065735,
0.31896135210990906,
0.15481586754322052,
0.4609651267528534,
0.240462064743042,
0.291526734828949,
-0.9881159067153931,
-0.1319747269153595,
0.05553433299064636,
-0.6665970087051392,
-0.009118539281189442,
-0.1689978390932083,
0.1960396021604538,
0.09493495523929596,
0.6086275577545166,
-0.11579273641109467,
0.011283861473202705,
-0.08245403319597244,
-0.17637427151203156,
0.16253794729709625,
0.10629580914974213,
0.6568557620048523,
0.29696375131607056,
0.07438638806343079,
-0.04341115057468414,
-0.039615172892808914,
-0.4634987413883209,
0.1680247038602829,
0.2055620402097702,
-0.5804876089096069,
-0.016258010640740395,
0.7310214042663574,
0.46240296959877014,
-0.3016124665737152,
-0.8228868842124939,
0.5994060635566711,
0.11054676026105881,
-0.011882291175425053,
-0.3848073184490204,
0.2513269782066345,
-0.2789691984653473,
0.3538011610507965,
0.6957188844680786,
0.22948479652404785,
0.13563905656337738,
-0.4214200973510742,
0.23031821846961975,
0.6272456645965576,
-0.07808414846658707,
-0.33119305968284607,
0.6876513361930847,
0.480112224817276,
-0.6265375018119812,
0.4181402027606964,
-0.1931079626083374,
-0.8146088719367981,
0.8372304439544678,
0.754543125629425,
1.0099008083343506,
0.00562655134126544,
0.42209765315055847,
0.1898190826177597,
0.4861423075199127,
-0.011604344472289085,
-0.10388658195734024,
-0.3017291724681854,
-0.9180309772491455,
-0.19863340258598328,
-0.6018903255462646,
-0.21585549414157867,
0.4897615909576416,
-0.30631712079048157,
0.1623091846704483,
-0.5818974375724792,
0.1108829602599144,
0.08040811866521835,
0.03290676325559616,
-0.2657006084918976,
0.25559625029563904,
0.5118920803070068,
0.8009777069091797,
-1.0074694156646729,
0.7552127838134766,
0.44427290558815,
-0.2737034857273102,
-0.39731302857398987,
0.4672326147556305,
-0.016047097742557526,
-0.7117056846618652,
0.31877657771110535,
0.49065011739730835,
-0.13048355281352997,
0.18188181519508362,
-0.6500018239021301,
-0.3901963233947754,
1.0430324077606201,
0.18070833384990692,
-0.19472895562648773,
0.053075745701789856,
0.2546634376049042,
0.6652104258537292,
-0.499367892742157,
0.16377611458301544,
0.5338534712791443,
0.3719242513179779,
-0.08631418645381927,
-0.5621167421340942,
0.07839447259902954,
-0.3357853293418884,
-0.033017247915267944,
0.14369931817054749,
-0.4602023661136627,
0.49739518761634827,
0.11621042340993881,
-0.26917627453804016,
0.3446394205093384,
0.8482022881507874,
0.2831747829914093,
0.5453994274139404,
0.44897910952568054,
0.6234959363937378,
0.7830824851989746,
0.12527774274349213,
0.742336630821228,
-0.09824781119823456,
0.11030187457799911,
0.7145766615867615,
-0.3664413392543793,
0.7725517153739929,
0.1979590207338333,
0.08837903290987015,
0.7966850996017456,
0.5956354737281799,
-0.3300682604312897,
0.410929411649704,
-0.10646205395460129,
-0.6447879076004028,
-0.3833940029144287,
-0.2535648047924042,
-0.18403714895248413,
0.5818923115730286,
0.4567220211029053,
-0.6684430241584778,
-0.07348766922950745,
0.12939335405826569,
0.08055606484413147,
0.542630136013031,
-0.33945149183273315,
0.8530239462852478,
-0.23570917546749115,
-0.6359195113182068,
0.11701184511184692,
0.3487390875816345,
1.0004740953445435,
-0.30202528834342957,
-0.15283514559268951,
-0.05388926342129707,
0.35427042841911316,
-0.1684512495994568,
-0.5831552147865295,
-0.06263292580842972,
0.1920495629310608,
-0.1231018528342247,
-0.2672499418258667,
1.0439385175704956,
-0.4346151649951935,
-0.7291250228881836,
0.12465553730726242,
0.4348570704460144,
-0.3088183104991913,
-0.13265356421470642,
-0.6233431696891785,
0.009397104382514954,
0.027007857337594032,
0.13277558982372284,
0.09297770261764526,
0.40515270829200745,
-0.007073572836816311,
0.4497573971748352,
0.888293445110321,
-0.13563106954097748,
-0.19254282116889954,
-0.2686839997768402,
0.6660563349723816,
-0.4619270861148834,
-0.624700129032135,
-1.2316144704818726,
0.46020641922950745,
-0.4754127860069275,
-0.19955343008041382,
0.5993898510932922,
0.5019749999046326,
0.7682710886001587,
0.0642104521393776,
1.0830883979797363,
0.04228348284959793,
0.37184441089630127,
-0.6380508542060852,
0.8543461561203003,
-0.6521926522254944,
0.31373730301856995,
-0.41730421781539917,
-0.7771168351173401,
-0.3172130286693573,
0.3233562409877777,
0.014614293351769447,
0.0681951493024826,
0.46044033765792847,
0.8373444676399231,
-0.11062383651733398,
-0.04730131849646568,
0.11247621476650238,
-0.11755058169364929,
0.5972118377685547,
0.4375464916229248,
0.9647788405418396,
-0.47318756580352783,
0.6018803119659424,
-0.0724676251411438,
-0.44252505898475647,
-0.3155573010444641,
-0.9107367396354675,
-1.252657175064087,
-0.46622252464294434,
-0.5747129321098328,
-0.41582950949668884,
-0.14264634251594543,
0.6843268275260925,
0.45939067006111145,
-0.7717155814170837,
0.3444903492927551,
-0.17145094275474548,
0.03436437249183655,
-0.10214763879776001,
-0.24227745831012726,
0.37844088673591614,
0.14549395442008972,
-0.8782169222831726,
0.47466304898262024,
0.30082061886787415,
0.35016870498657227,
-0.38369569182395935,
0.16742247343063354,
-0.17213349044322968,
0.24370314180850983,
0.34281110763549805,
0.21484258770942688,
-0.685150146484375,
-0.19041116535663605,
-0.10346841812133789,
-0.38800084590911865,
0.01721559278666973,
0.7878943085670471,
-0.9181070923805237,
0.20997300744056702,
0.532423734664917,
1.082290530204773,
0.35081160068511963,
0.1465662568807602,
0.46143171191215515,
-0.6309406757354736,
0.24315917491912842,
0.31954002380371094,
0.09254150092601776,
0.5107571482658386,
-0.5850734710693359,
0.18532393872737885,
0.5186921954154968,
-0.24468764662742615,
-0.8857528567314148,
0.3226947784423828,
-0.9448217153549194,
-0.1269422173500061,
0.9523666501045227,
-0.16951292753219604,
-0.1112983226776123,
-0.016547827050089836,
-0.19923509657382965,
0.2734503746032715,
-0.45606786012649536,
0.8828639984130859,
0.4247587025165558,
0.3561309278011322,
-0.12646304070949554,
-0.16189457476139069,
0.4386885464191437,
0.21520717442035675,
-1.038755178451538,
-0.26592257618904114,
0.46211352944374084,
0.18626870214939117,
0.1713360846042633,
0.3813738524913788,
-0.06188902258872986,
0.29436543583869934,
-0.10556720197200775,
-0.19369620084762573,
-0.20932213962078094,
-0.3876674771308899,
-0.14298893511295319,
0.3472053110599518,
-0.3084963262081146,
-0.17697195708751678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00380v1
|
The Best of Both Worlds: Toward an Honest and Helpful Large Language Model
| 2024-06-01T09:36:16
| 2024-06-01T09:36:16
|
Chujie Gao, Qihui Zhang, Dongping Chen, Yue Huang, Siyuan Wu, Zhengyan Fu, Yao Wan, Xiangliang Zhang, Lichao Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success across various
industries due to their exceptional generative capabilities. However, for safe
and effective real-world deployments, ensuring honesty and helpfulness is
critical. This paper addresses the question: Can we prioritize the helpfulness
of LLMs while preserving their honesty? To begin with, we establish exhaustive
principles aimed at guaranteeing the honesty of LLM. Additionally, we introduce
a novel dataset, referred to as HoneSet, comprising 930 queries spanning six
categories meticulously crafted to assess an LLM's capacity for maintaining
honesty. Subsequently, we present two approaches to augmenting honesty and
helpfulness in LLMs: a training-free enhancement and a fine-tuning-based
improvement. The training-free approach, which is based on curiosity-driven
prompting, empowers LLMs to articulate internal confusion and uncertainty
regarding queries, thereby optimizing their responses. Conversely, the
fine-tuning-based method employs a two-stage process inspired by curriculum
learning: initially instructing LLMs to discern between honest and dishonest
responses, then refining their training to enhance helpfulness. Experiments
conducted on nine prominent LLMs demonstrate a significant improvement in
alignment with honesty across all models through the implementation of our
proposed enhancements. Particularly noteworthy is the 65.3% enhancement
observed in Llama3-8b and the remarkable 124.7% improvement in Mistral-7b, as
measured by the H$^{2}$ (honest and helpful) assessment. We believe that our
work can pave the way for developing more trustworthy LLMs for real-world
applications.
|
[
-0.1314944624900818,
-0.7097775340080261,
0.7283855080604553,
0.1149902269244194,
-0.08667545765638351,
0.10023267567157745,
-0.5868512988090515,
-0.5408755540847778,
-0.3480740487575531,
0.5337651371955872,
-0.3665531277656555,
-0.33172330260276794,
-0.6212944388389587,
-0.07742816209793091,
-0.03614707663655281,
1.037198543548584,
0.19605495035648346,
0.30290186405181885,
0.062316879630088806,
-0.24567916989326477,
-0.5467355251312256,
-0.38909628987312317,
-0.8163759112358093,
-0.4562334716320038,
0.8415977954864502,
0.3825283646583557,
1.1945809125900269,
0.8552238941192627,
0.6909841299057007,
0.2729535400867462,
-0.2548234164714813,
0.4114079773426056,
-0.7845117449760437,
0.36588647961616516,
-0.5777993202209473,
-0.7534565925598145,
-0.562180757522583,
0.16916950047016144,
0.20347608625888824,
0.580151379108429,
-0.46239811182022095,
0.14005416631698608,
0.2588347792625427,
0.567286491394043,
-0.5803983807563782,
0.10949700325727463,
-0.9343815445899963,
-0.3562387228012085,
0.01327679492533207,
-0.05290144681930542,
-0.24089843034744263,
-0.7418519854545593,
-0.03719193488359451,
-0.6712045073509216,
-0.0905236080288887,
0.08439440280199051,
0.7740476131439209,
0.25113120675086975,
-0.23955100774765015,
-0.44143936038017273,
-0.5620635151863098,
1.157977819442749,
-0.8345255851745605,
0.4642341732978821,
0.473992258310318,
0.26046669483184814,
-0.3182339072227478,
-0.4199468791484833,
-0.3974434435367584,
-0.3708949089050293,
0.1819024384021759,
-0.07291404902935028,
0.17470614612102509,
0.16821809113025665,
0.004829751793295145,
0.5708447694778442,
-0.33278757333755493,
0.5076649785041809,
0.10266304761171341,
-0.42159390449523926,
0.6418302059173584,
0.07239595800638199,
-0.03147720545530319,
0.20739677548408508,
-0.24101203680038452,
-0.21465297043323517,
-0.9291781187057495,
0.02742045372724533,
0.6432309150695801,
0.3740403354167938,
-0.06975758075714111,
0.5675297975540161,
-0.28217336535453796,
0.43080681562423706,
0.07993748039007187,
-0.4867682158946991,
0.06829679012298584,
-0.426901638507843,
-0.15525944530963898,
-0.281644731760025,
0.7088773250579834,
0.478806734085083,
0.4820612668991089,
-0.20758362114429474,
-0.6107958555221558,
0.24410705268383026,
0.3324679732322693,
-0.7531983256340027,
0.05850372835993767,
0.17459750175476074,
-0.4729497730731964,
-0.6509400010108948,
-0.06790459901094437,
-0.408738374710083,
-0.6574608683586121,
-0.49840977787971497,
0.4851372539997101,
-0.4269105792045593,
-0.3228694200515747,
0.13910824060440063,
0.28882354497909546,
0.2859955132007599,
0.4298226833343506,
-0.8183324933052063,
0.09218093007802963,
1.088371753692627,
0.5036542415618896,
0.15014028549194336,
-0.0901026725769043,
-0.783905565738678,
0.009235171601176262,
-0.5449584126472473,
0.3716247081756592,
-0.652837872505188,
-0.39941948652267456,
0.19683937728405,
-0.24227003753185272,
0.4866299033164978,
-0.7663576006889343,
0.9114588499069214,
-0.5982084274291992,
0.16187255084514618,
-0.45288732647895813,
-0.5793412923812866,
-0.03692891448736191,
0.5030831098556519,
-0.357899010181427,
0.9663016200065613,
0.17340849339962006,
-0.5879990458488464,
0.20382556319236755,
-0.43013036251068115,
-0.022153763100504875,
-0.19423502683639526,
-0.15207043290138245,
-0.3849906623363495,
0.3597829043865204,
0.2397199273109436,
0.4410612881183624,
-0.2852967381477356,
0.5152850151062012,
-0.44300752878189087,
-0.3959576487541199,
0.5077524781227112,
-0.6230942606925964,
0.7748076915740967,
0.2794930636882782,
-0.30580562353134155,
-0.058494117110967636,
-0.499234139919281,
0.15599273145198822,
0.012492753565311432,
-0.3742019832134247,
-0.2841235101222992,
-0.3017228841781616,
-0.25150543451309204,
0.12879085540771484,
0.4650496244430542,
-0.5789709091186523,
0.17638972401618958,
-0.7380504608154297,
-0.03769673407077789,
1.1667912006378174,
-0.11449972540140152,
0.565985381603241,
-0.5098944902420044,
0.4438057243824005,
-0.16314123570919037,
0.5566490888595581,
-0.042703088372945786,
-0.3538620173931122,
-0.8218606114387512,
-0.06900959461927414,
0.316322922706604,
0.4900716245174408,
-0.7158185243606567,
0.5226898789405823,
-0.39007487893104553,
-0.45756253600120544,
-0.8781778812408447,
0.3570765554904938,
0.7381173968315125,
0.5014368891716003,
0.21065853536128998,
-0.33376869559288025,
-0.10199978947639465,
-1.073837399482727,
-0.43501147627830505,
-0.38952550292015076,
-0.07809796929359436,
0.3073751926422119,
0.11648046970367432,
0.05260228365659714,
0.715018630027771,
-0.3007054328918457,
-0.2277275174856186,
-0.027889126911759377,
-0.23742443323135376,
0.2608124613761902,
0.3793427348136902,
0.3221648931503296,
-0.8118520379066467,
-0.5493455529212952,
0.009671276435256004,
-0.7241982221603394,
-0.16115643084049225,
0.2136479765176773,
-0.1419937163591385,
-0.044203829020261765,
0.05056482553482056,
-0.4083828330039978,
0.18573665618896484,
0.5539263486862183,
-0.2262318730354309,
0.4464932978153229,
-0.27052783966064453,
0.06292114406824112,
-0.9547874331474304,
-0.22921912372112274,
-0.2373235672712326,
-0.3882090151309967,
-0.5175760388374329,
0.44423115253448486,
0.031310632824897766,
0.32192540168762207,
-0.3860457241535187,
0.7251963019371033,
-0.45099154114723206,
0.055512502789497375,
-0.2780414819717407,
0.0578012578189373,
0.11105536669492722,
0.2981679439544678,
-0.34533122181892395,
0.889842689037323,
0.639505922794342,
-0.5086952447891235,
0.33768656849861145,
0.31735023856163025,
-0.28133508563041687,
0.9843579530715942,
-0.5561937093734741,
0.3697877526283264,
-0.10381300747394562,
0.03254017233848572,
-0.5983072519302368,
-0.09641248732805252,
0.14543916285037994,
-0.4588192105293274,
0.4701542258262634,
-0.066890649497509,
-0.6578701734542847,
0.00399138405919075,
-0.5986949801445007,
-0.047709763050079346,
0.7222068309783936,
-0.6037620902061462,
0.3667657673358917,
0.20247703790664673,
-0.2964685261249542,
-0.8379389643669128,
-0.6714853644371033,
0.07608474791049957,
-0.1546974778175354,
-0.5227159857749939,
0.09040878713130951,
-0.4520047605037689,
-0.48520657420158386,
-0.17307938635349274,
-0.16511043906211853,
-0.10601828247308731,
0.15827670693397522,
0.14444828033447266,
0.37795934081077576,
-0.08695035427808762,
-0.0856296643614769,
-0.14170688390731812,
-0.19378049671649933,
-0.19096402823925018,
-0.20664450526237488,
0.25634610652923584,
-0.23641736805438995,
-0.37307092547416687,
-0.45489218831062317,
0.21858634054660797,
0.37977591156959534,
-0.3738109767436981,
0.9366580843925476,
0.7547332644462585,
-0.03956495597958565,
-0.07585768401622772,
-1.0414642095565796,
-0.4774627685546875,
-0.5519043803215027,
0.2219839096069336,
-0.22240646183490753,
-1.0637412071228027,
0.3290943205356598,
0.009966379962861538,
0.431802898645401,
-0.11136221140623093,
0.4699424207210541,
-0.027217429131269455,
0.9387191534042358,
0.9847372174263,
-0.28019359707832336,
0.36178499460220337,
0.013945325277745724,
0.49283915758132935,
-0.9062418937683105,
-0.17314428091049194,
-0.555650532245636,
-0.0472913458943367,
-0.6129440069198608,
-0.40554025769233704,
0.44116538763046265,
0.17351748049259186,
-0.143006831407547,
-0.1279003620147705,
-0.5010396838188171,
0.6189308166503906,
0.2959933578968048,
0.2080858051776886,
0.48141786456108093,
0.02089953050017357,
0.025873534381389618,
-0.2436518669128418,
-0.4226031005382538,
-0.780670166015625,
1.1501598358154297,
0.5834141373634338,
0.9032324552536011,
0.2355373203754425,
0.6676535606384277,
-0.1194305345416069,
0.5818603038787842,
-0.8480564951896667,
0.6308385133743286,
-0.027774866670370102,
-0.5563666820526123,
-0.29162299633026123,
-0.5318278074264526,
-0.747708797454834,
0.19050048291683197,
0.026965955272316933,
-0.5635647773742676,
-0.006895043887197971,
0.22665290534496307,
-0.2487352043390274,
0.15871529281139374,
-0.5554146766662598,
0.34386175870895386,
-0.415115088224411,
-0.6664631366729736,
-0.3559131622314453,
-0.6830810904502869,
0.2893833518028259,
-0.20069490373134613,
0.4063878059387207,
-0.25736767053604126,
-0.37320205569267273,
0.3019457161426544,
-0.19685180485248566,
0.7544384002685547,
-0.2402176707983017,
-0.4761306345462799,
0.025998536497354507,
0.22761337459087372,
0.8665613532066345,
0.03795040026307106,
-0.6422300934791565,
0.07764288038015366,
-0.363299697637558,
-0.3651854395866394,
-0.789331316947937,
0.9296956062316895,
-0.6414033770561218,
-0.640556812286377,
-0.15104639530181885,
-0.6294066905975342,
-0.4931901693344116,
0.23417992889881134,
-0.03716127201914787,
0.4334143400192261,
-0.1258675754070282,
0.41223251819610596,
1.1146464347839355,
-0.343967080116272,
0.2683582007884979,
0.7512266635894775,
-0.3131764233112335,
-0.2035851776599884,
0.8023998737335205,
-0.03008910082280636,
0.5669206380844116,
0.2868237793445587,
0.3807516098022461,
-0.618197500705719,
-0.7840786576271057,
-0.1864212155342102,
0.34399938583374023,
-0.7130230665206909,
-0.40417277812957764,
-0.4056340157985687,
-0.05386535823345184,
-0.2788505554199219,
-0.15235182642936707,
-0.6831652522087097,
-0.2585405111312866,
0.008165317587554455,
-0.21719437837600708,
0.29118454456329346,
0.6088885068893433,
-0.07150819897651672,
0.2212090939283371,
-0.5831086039543152,
0.2610412538051605,
0.2512817680835724,
0.5584958791732788,
-0.1080966591835022,
-0.6530845761299133,
-0.22068637609481812,
0.2742365896701813,
-0.42397329211235046,
-0.33614009618759155,
0.12740354239940643,
0.20373979210853577,
0.632993221282959,
0.2999575734138489,
0.009986442513763905,
0.6195269227027893,
-0.3544671833515167,
0.856109082698822,
0.06193263828754425,
-0.57961106300354,
0.4327782094478607,
-0.560599684715271,
0.03834051266312599,
0.8712072968482971,
0.27712222933769226,
-0.2749484181404114,
-0.6596426367759705,
-0.671684205532074,
-0.6961994767189026,
0.5479526519775391,
0.3196485638618469,
0.5109717845916748,
0.3199848532676697,
0.5054108500480652,
0.33428680896759033,
0.5576910376548767,
-0.6800166368484497,
-0.2493319809436798,
-0.018345864489674568,
-0.34657102823257446,
0.12052895873785019,
-0.18968187272548676,
-0.23210646212100983,
0.001483321189880371,
0.8507910966873169,
-0.14836281538009644,
0.11130909621715546,
-0.06466298550367355,
0.05997982248663902,
0.04844711720943451,
0.613865077495575,
0.1449752002954483,
0.8320052027702332,
0.09662780910730362,
0.1810152530670166,
0.09036735445261002,
-0.3289034068584442,
0.1760348081588745,
-0.0652187168598175,
-0.19824205338954926,
-0.17262737452983856,
0.17981703579425812,
0.5833629965782166,
0.221858412027359,
-0.48267537355422974,
0.7676287889480591,
-0.010298158042132854,
0.1852901726961136,
-0.05597420036792755,
0.4246233403682709,
0.14849399030208588,
0.2117537558078766,
0.13611996173858643,
-0.18030409514904022,
0.03584285452961922,
-0.6266131401062012,
-0.036337025463581085,
0.6573356986045837,
-0.18873095512390137,
-0.2660505473613739,
0.36925050616264343,
0.1473560333251953,
-0.3384103775024414,
0.5239259004592896,
-0.29991263151168823,
-0.4359438121318817,
0.129338338971138,
0.36388781666755676,
0.6235629916191101,
-0.6475523114204407,
0.22955794632434845,
0.10184179246425629,
0.31498488783836365,
-0.4061385691165924,
0.33423563838005066,
0.07248911261558533,
-0.8615427017211914,
-0.25671282410621643,
-0.7885330319404602,
-0.45639243721961975,
0.33404773473739624,
-0.7436001896858215,
0.12873488664627075,
-0.4287793040275574,
-0.14118044078350067,
-0.38688668608665466,
0.24062864482402802,
-0.6977761387825012,
0.24089208245277405,
-0.026175154373049736,
0.7754393219947815,
-0.3288750946521759,
0.8162353038787842,
0.3941577076911926,
-0.2578802704811096,
-1.1636143922805786,
-0.05682222172617912,
-0.02600335329771042,
-1.0215097665786743,
0.1522763967514038,
0.025213511660695076,
-0.18128924071788788,
-0.028873564675450325,
-0.7571792006492615,
-0.625798225402832,
1.0168355703353882,
0.6552126407623291,
-0.8912869691848755,
-0.03320678323507309,
0.07339400798082352,
0.5574501752853394,
-0.16039714217185974,
0.3523096740245819,
0.4257865846157074,
0.6142733097076416,
-0.0929189994931221,
-1.21721613407135,
-0.010472152382135391,
0.14563938975334167,
0.22416310012340546,
0.08232428878545761,
-0.8147759437561035,
0.4239386022090912,
-0.27763211727142334,
0.06258358061313629,
0.43782514333724976,
0.4511307179927826,
0.3358001112937927,
0.17326170206069946,
0.5336070656776428,
0.34824684262275696,
1.0515432357788086,
-0.048545464873313904,
1.1233649253845215,
-0.2842877507209778,
0.22194792330265045,
1.0711960792541504,
-0.3306645154953003,
0.7261074185371399,
0.6514682173728943,
0.001070784986950457,
0.3463688790798187,
0.4382994771003723,
0.14271309971809387,
0.5471672415733337,
0.03851960226893425,
-0.3025009334087372,
-0.16061633825302124,
-0.6205189824104309,
-0.31136149168014526,
0.2569555342197418,
0.3433554768562317,
-0.3301129639148712,
-0.1816987544298172,
-0.06048080697655678,
0.42002683877944946,
0.22945274412631989,
-0.33995121717453003,
0.6326792240142822,
0.38012367486953735,
-0.6719046235084534,
0.4579794406890869,
0.08087634295225143,
0.9429221153259277,
-0.7765061259269714,
0.08168191462755203,
-0.3135794997215271,
0.18701568245887756,
-0.31285983324050903,
-0.9119057655334473,
0.06293383985757828,
0.11481482535600662,
-0.037103522568941116,
-0.4549860656261444,
0.7021019458770752,
-0.5429768562316895,
-0.3363718092441559,
0.18646833300590515,
0.5207151174545288,
0.08881375193595886,
-0.0754837617278099,
-0.7776290774345398,
0.43389496207237244,
-0.016650527715682983,
-0.32894209027290344,
0.4331086575984955,
0.45570334792137146,
0.00854811817407608,
0.7799800038337708,
0.7330594658851624,
0.4606553316116333,
-0.18948021531105042,
0.30919045209884644,
0.923917293548584,
-0.24957339465618134,
-0.4076647460460663,
-0.7326217293739319,
0.5415363907814026,
-0.05103571340441704,
-0.09572207182645798,
0.9023457169532776,
0.44857144355773926,
0.8017832636833191,
0.2059476673603058,
0.642397403717041,
0.2905380427837372,
0.6112660765647888,
-0.49067583680152893,
0.5244428515434265,
-0.3873470723628998,
0.5724883079528809,
-0.09720449894666672,
-1.2160555124282837,
-0.08902066200971603,
0.718196451663971,
-0.3531992435455322,
0.21132370829582214,
0.429097056388855,
1.2356876134872437,
-0.09437906742095947,
-0.007409709971398115,
0.4916499853134155,
0.4318685531616211,
0.5152832269668579,
0.4464151859283447,
1.015476942062378,
-0.24382825195789337,
0.4177202582359314,
-0.3322524130344391,
-0.3125700354576111,
-0.029905227944254875,
-0.9222323894500732,
-0.6294831037521362,
-0.17672011256217957,
-0.1335868388414383,
-0.3078063726425171,
0.2582615911960602,
0.8829052448272705,
0.7299947142601013,
-0.4652250409126282,
-0.020646102726459503,
-0.007229382172226906,
-0.037885989993810654,
-0.00985437911003828,
-0.20963209867477417,
-0.03833659365773201,
-0.3585439920425415,
-0.6976982355117798,
0.5603451728820801,
0.3065701127052307,
-0.044592276215553284,
-0.5643330216407776,
-0.25075650215148926,
0.44812849164009094,
0.1880832016468048,
0.5087778568267822,
-0.21595661342144012,
-0.7726287841796875,
-0.5109297037124634,
0.0946602150797844,
-0.22929953038692474,
0.0701492577791214,
0.667326033115387,
-0.5637614130973816,
0.4070935547351837,
0.0776069387793541,
0.7180578112602234,
0.07628367096185684,
0.03563716262578964,
0.6833251118659973,
-0.6875755190849304,
0.049785397946834564,
0.5052725672721863,
0.07650695741176605,
0.8701062202453613,
-0.6634896993637085,
0.5565609335899353,
-0.334782212972641,
-0.8103259205818176,
-0.943792998790741,
0.3517065942287445,
-0.7968391180038452,
0.06126135587692261,
1.3330556154251099,
-0.3036840558052063,
-0.005653419066220522,
-0.251187801361084,
-0.3228168785572052,
0.18941786885261536,
-0.513891875743866,
0.8321899771690369,
0.7268476486206055,
-0.029958393424749374,
0.11812826246023178,
-0.5563312768936157,
0.4920458197593689,
0.5492628812789917,
-0.6947435140609741,
0.19765080511569977,
0.5330860614776611,
0.45920419692993164,
0.020817991346120834,
0.6674822568893433,
-0.35596027970314026,
0.006867047864943743,
-0.40196847915649414,
-0.38202446699142456,
-0.20879504084587097,
-0.42957738041877747,
-0.4123881757259369,
0.06621550023555756,
0.6642400026321411,
0.0034266836009919643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00367v1
|
RoBERTa-BiLSTM: A Context-Aware Hybrid Model for Sentiment Analysis
| 2024-06-01T08:59:46
| 2024-06-01T08:59:46
|
Md. Mostafizer Rahman, Ariful Islam Shiplu, Yutaka Watanobe, Md. Ashad Alam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE
|
Effectively analyzing the comments to uncover latent intentions holds immense
value in making strategic decisions across various domains. However, several
challenges hinder the process of sentiment analysis including the lexical
diversity exhibited in comments, the presence of long dependencies within the
text, encountering unknown symbols and words, and dealing with imbalanced
datasets. Moreover, existing sentiment analysis tasks mostly leveraged
sequential models to encode the long dependent texts and it requires longer
execution time as it processes the text sequentially. In contrast, the
Transformer requires less execution time due to its parallel processing nature.
In this work, we introduce a novel hybrid deep learning model, RoBERTa-BiLSTM,
which combines the Robustly Optimized BERT Pretraining Approach (RoBERTa) with
Bidirectional Long Short-Term Memory (BiLSTM) networks. RoBERTa is utilized to
generate meaningful word embedding vectors, while BiLSTM effectively captures
the contextual semantics of long-dependent texts. The RoBERTa-BiLSTM hybrid
model leverages the strengths of both sequential and Transformer models to
enhance performance in sentiment analysis. We conducted experiments using
datasets from IMDb, Twitter US Airline, and Sentiment140 to evaluate the
proposed model against existing state-of-the-art methods. Our experimental
findings demonstrate that the RoBERTa-BiLSTM model surpasses baseline models
(e.g., BERT, RoBERTa-base, RoBERTa-GRU, and RoBERTa-LSTM), achieving accuracies
of 80.74%, 92.36%, and 82.25% on the Twitter US Airline, IMDb, and Sentiment140
datasets, respectively. Additionally, the model achieves F1-scores of 80.73%,
92.35%, and 82.25% on the same datasets, respectively.
|
[
-0.3455362319946289,
-0.6418160200119019,
0.3707902133464813,
0.43482229113578796,
-0.6748051643371582,
0.43243536353111267,
-0.5519815683364868,
-0.24112017452716827,
0.14859457314014435,
0.2780342996120453,
-0.7532786130905151,
-0.380647748708725,
-0.6652207374572754,
0.01799147017300129,
-0.24965247511863708,
1.569617748260498,
0.026338521391153336,
0.4165427088737488,
-0.08440762758255005,
-0.3507559895515442,
-0.27851569652557373,
-0.6928136348724365,
-0.39388278126716614,
-0.026725880801677704,
0.5244512557983398,
-0.08685817569494247,
0.5186656713485718,
-0.5966840982437134,
0.5432481169700623,
0.25877124071121216,
-0.28304457664489746,
0.40001463890075684,
-0.5268324613571167,
-0.07764347642660141,
-0.35538536310195923,
-0.13933682441711426,
-0.4809902608394623,
0.1120646744966507,
0.6449780464172363,
0.6878003478050232,
0.020098218694329262,
0.13398605585098267,
0.2005397081375122,
0.7118703722953796,
-0.3880825638771057,
-0.07149512320756912,
-0.6065638661384583,
0.020618697628378868,
-0.08429524302482605,
-0.029006678611040115,
-0.4150201976299286,
-0.295694500207901,
0.5761121511459351,
-0.07223208993673325,
0.17256012558937073,
-0.1204625740647316,
0.9677268266677856,
0.1510576456785202,
-0.5372823476791382,
-0.16538473963737488,
-0.9255585670471191,
1.0926954746246338,
-0.8498618006706238,
0.2612120807170868,
-0.37022367119789124,
0.32329094409942627,
0.31881406903266907,
-0.5959380865097046,
-0.7421760559082031,
-0.06736664474010468,
-0.07637207955121994,
0.5610697865486145,
0.017264164984226227,
-0.10748129338026047,
-0.07019002735614777,
0.5630970597267151,
-0.786050021648407,
-0.06363768130540848,
-0.1561453938484192,
0.0683407187461853,
0.2880541980266571,
0.26944878697395325,
0.03308857977390289,
-0.42455682158470154,
-0.7759445309638977,
-0.04159756749868393,
-0.3236229419708252,
0.09471514075994492,
0.2097458690404892,
0.5015467405319214,
-0.3224842846393585,
0.2033265084028244,
0.03219961002469063,
0.6060121059417725,
-0.09150683134794235,
0.24320508539676666,
0.3593747317790985,
-0.4536430239677429,
-0.32492321729660034,
-0.3889612555503845,
0.9422744512557983,
0.2017868608236313,
0.18809984624385834,
-0.07739127427339554,
-0.22393536567687988,
0.33844056725502014,
0.25306785106658936,
-0.7306399345397949,
-0.1943659484386444,
0.10840385407209396,
-0.6901528239250183,
-0.38612130284309387,
0.3145939111709595,
-1.0012630224227905,
-0.1847476065158844,
-0.4206414520740509,
0.3424903154373169,
-0.46201571822166443,
-0.4354545474052429,
0.07033223658800125,
-0.11265882104635239,
0.38363224267959595,
0.40423843264579773,
-0.31172290444374084,
0.05417947843670845,
0.5180081129074097,
0.7813053727149963,
-0.26889801025390625,
-0.08261234313249588,
-0.20419341325759888,
-0.08052834123373032,
-0.036688242107629776,
0.6685587763786316,
-0.5323168039321899,
-0.6595039367675781,
-0.07751312106847763,
-0.30317386984825134,
-0.24353164434432983,
-0.3560855984687805,
0.6711050271987915,
-0.7823241353034973,
0.6485427618026733,
-0.08895799517631531,
-0.35380464792251587,
-0.4757603704929352,
0.5014649033546448,
-0.5151992440223694,
1.1178784370422363,
0.13982246816158295,
-0.8096230030059814,
0.2651144564151764,
-0.605550229549408,
-0.7215229272842407,
-0.1650175005197525,
-0.10746464133262634,
-0.6513329744338989,
0.2517941892147064,
0.2335050106048584,
0.4660937190055847,
-0.49746188521385193,
0.5204840302467346,
-0.32483237981796265,
-0.10158376395702362,
0.4259936213493347,
-0.6090074777603149,
0.7551848292350769,
0.08305484801530838,
-0.36256417632102966,
0.3432900309562683,
-0.4655914306640625,
-0.016884122043848038,
0.09544221311807632,
-0.3640030324459076,
-0.3178749084472656,
-0.029196983203291893,
0.41472089290618896,
0.43077775835990906,
0.36607083678245544,
-0.5083549618721008,
-0.05648525431752205,
-0.5446722507476807,
0.2703009247779846,
0.7920227646827698,
0.0002812703314702958,
0.4446929395198822,
-0.13041691482067108,
0.4119330644607544,
0.4133296012878418,
0.36746805906295776,
-0.03927921876311302,
-0.3323483467102051,
-0.8483314514160156,
-0.2538836896419525,
0.25837138295173645,
0.570475161075592,
-0.44170263409614563,
0.6852120161056519,
-0.6217684149742126,
-0.3765159547328949,
-0.3889445662498474,
0.13411377370357513,
0.460605651140213,
0.463188499212265,
0.41089844703674316,
-0.3842372000217438,
-0.7624388933181763,
-0.9222419857978821,
-0.46863603591918945,
0.15901173651218414,
0.41236811876296997,
0.2993124723434448,
0.40658092498779297,
-0.4026060402393341,
0.9391293525695801,
-0.3282041847705841,
-0.23204807937145233,
-0.6784472465515137,
0.49070441722869873,
0.4546350836753845,
0.27834853529930115,
0.4669072926044464,
-1.0752254724502563,
-0.7167605757713318,
-0.2088245451450348,
-0.8241616487503052,
0.4718146324157715,
-0.2236069291830063,
-0.16495513916015625,
0.3060501217842102,
-0.0043067107908427715,
-0.7274578213691711,
0.31624722480773926,
0.5892686247825623,
-0.07417737692594528,
0.23428036272525787,
0.08432495594024658,
-0.11613451689481735,
-1.3026554584503174,
-0.0025010034441947937,
0.1526186317205429,
-0.19281579554080963,
-0.4412030279636383,
-0.17254184186458588,
-0.043580833822488785,
-0.2542281150817871,
-0.2840537428855896,
0.0764925479888916,
-0.37725916504859924,
0.0016582758398726583,
-0.13934840261936188,
0.01886935904622078,
0.20549581944942474,
0.5389333367347717,
0.1813526302576065,
0.7102651000022888,
0.2486923635005951,
-0.19585883617401123,
0.03228606656193733,
0.0690697431564331,
-0.4152386784553528,
0.4268799126148224,
-0.6063346862792969,
0.2312876433134079,
-0.10136536508798599,
0.5598480701446533,
-1.1683919429779053,
0.21972069144248962,
-0.10275715589523315,
-0.4211587905883789,
0.43735942244529724,
0.001371662481687963,
-0.5101606845855713,
-0.5012904405593872,
-0.35470372438430786,
0.3342057466506958,
0.7241907119750977,
-0.5207333564758301,
1.1044660806655884,
0.15852272510528564,
-0.0680873915553093,
-0.2506951689720154,
-0.4568510353565216,
0.11844876408576965,
-0.2374720573425293,
-0.7374846339225769,
0.3882463574409485,
-0.004818173125386238,
-0.053032997995615005,
-0.006539743393659592,
0.19164690375328064,
0.218568816781044,
-0.158426433801651,
0.228804349899292,
0.7239987254142761,
-0.2118409425020218,
-0.20690728724002838,
-0.04133013263344765,
-0.23767763376235962,
-0.052010100334882736,
-0.352809339761734,
0.7353362441062927,
-0.48664620518684387,
0.10375797748565674,
-0.41929173469543457,
0.46873897314071655,
0.7773861885070801,
-0.5910983085632324,
0.9017212986946106,
0.8072924613952637,
-0.03286449611186981,
-0.44715943932533264,
-0.51700758934021,
-0.10962383449077606,
-0.4251229166984558,
0.270569384098053,
-0.12742795050144196,
-0.779802143573761,
0.21554048359394073,
-0.3714154064655304,
-0.24481071531772614,
0.29776668548583984,
0.7774550318717957,
-0.3048459589481354,
1.020889163017273,
0.49986782670021057,
-0.5265844464302063,
0.5497673749923706,
-0.6487650871276855,
0.7340040802955627,
-0.9831444621086121,
-0.0314079150557518,
-0.08622528612613678,
-0.34094250202178955,
-0.4402864873409271,
-0.6155138611793518,
0.6739138960838318,
-0.25553566217422485,
-0.06894103437662125,
0.018292441964149475,
-0.3398534655570984,
0.09103665500879288,
0.5594824552536011,
0.18419122695922852,
-0.04946017265319824,
-0.05780298262834549,
-0.09568662196397781,
-0.06356626749038696,
-0.41331085562705994,
-0.375954270362854,
1.0799076557159424,
0.1521536111831665,
0.5123929381370544,
0.20475095510482788,
0.5544643402099609,
0.4344235956668854,
0.2655235826969147,
-0.6028722524642944,
0.6406102180480957,
-0.4950748682022095,
-0.6383588910102844,
0.05538045987486839,
-0.297521710395813,
-0.364006370306015,
0.21639831364154816,
-0.24968887865543365,
-0.264952152967453,
0.00717727467417717,
-0.07602649927139282,
-0.5141713619232178,
0.34905052185058594,
-0.48903632164001465,
0.7971504926681519,
-0.5902131795883179,
-0.5514603853225708,
-0.5264397859573364,
-0.8334798216819763,
0.42662081122398376,
0.005285228602588177,
0.1276879906654358,
-0.11902784556150436,
0.3109668493270874,
0.7101069688796997,
-0.4128291606903076,
0.9541873335838318,
-0.4384740889072418,
0.3482404351234436,
0.21186292171478271,
-0.08485618978738785,
0.6295510530471802,
-0.12223055958747864,
-0.1301458477973938,
0.26572108268737793,
-0.2764413356781006,
-0.19351214170455933,
-0.5551550984382629,
0.7828143239021301,
-0.8950154781341553,
-0.359276682138443,
-0.562796950340271,
-0.39726170897483826,
-0.484609991312027,
0.10616330802440643,
0.2030012607574463,
0.3264201879501343,
-0.18956518173217773,
0.29774701595306396,
0.5735251307487488,
-0.23150980472564697,
0.43480348587036133,
0.4287475645542145,
-0.03671635687351227,
-0.5384249687194824,
1.0195363759994507,
0.03477311134338379,
0.03307056427001953,
0.3630349040031433,
0.26756271719932556,
-0.3462560474872589,
-0.5027735233306885,
-0.33871617913246155,
0.2506491243839264,
-0.4973543584346771,
-0.19319774210453033,
-0.6549261808395386,
-0.21885833144187927,
-0.24106761813163757,
-0.15201394259929657,
-0.3908829987049103,
-0.17943723499774933,
-0.2159808874130249,
-0.11937053501605988,
0.21709123253822327,
0.5476325750350952,
0.3176547586917877,
0.23002874851226807,
-0.8054752945899963,
0.2868712544441223,
0.18341897428035736,
0.23767785727977753,
0.14149728417396545,
-0.48222601413726807,
-0.32096391916275024,
-0.006886279210448265,
-0.17287620902061462,
-0.7049477100372314,
0.4526672065258026,
0.003170831361785531,
0.2602505385875702,
0.2782592177391052,
0.012011452578008175,
0.6205793023109436,
-0.11500408500432968,
1.0534437894821167,
0.25345945358276367,
-0.8398802280426025,
0.6508746147155762,
-0.5821012854576111,
-0.014216853305697441,
0.6215270161628723,
0.3671516478061676,
-0.17658144235610962,
-0.15321914851665497,
-0.4583306312561035,
-0.9563314318656921,
0.550288200378418,
0.1413239985704422,
0.30793696641921997,
0.06184474751353264,
-0.03934771940112114,
0.05694447457790375,
0.2688899040222168,
-0.8371984958648682,
0.014371966943144798,
-0.29778242111206055,
-0.536271333694458,
-0.2814403474330902,
-0.4589475989341736,
-0.03067399002611637,
-0.5144249796867371,
0.7998968958854675,
0.17936080694198608,
0.17448975145816803,
0.08532651513814926,
-0.21762211620807648,
0.06624778360128403,
0.23939476907253265,
0.46302762627601624,
0.2504737675189972,
-0.4271685779094696,
-0.13517417013645172,
0.08102878928184509,
-0.026806317269802094,
-0.21810562908649445,
0.1121891438961029,
-0.27382004261016846,
0.06307918578386307,
0.20942729711532593,
0.7701289057731628,
0.37128138542175293,
-0.6393135786056519,
0.7595915794372559,
-0.07980209589004517,
0.15022654831409454,
-0.7111738920211792,
-0.22829179465770721,
0.04777703806757927,
0.13182395696640015,
0.19001618027687073,
0.36475780606269836,
0.20741213858127594,
-0.6098801493644714,
-0.1020769253373146,
0.6952884197235107,
-0.4167064428329468,
-0.48026326298713684,
0.46539515256881714,
0.41261300444602966,
0.03226041793823242,
0.6317814588546753,
-0.08289831131696701,
-0.9359426498413086,
0.35693293809890747,
0.3819221556186676,
1.0995564460754395,
0.06761360168457031,
0.12165036052465439,
0.16590836644172668,
0.02313365414738655,
0.24850982427597046,
0.41174590587615967,
-0.18915139138698578,
-0.7681192755699158,
-0.12421804666519165,
-0.9156686663627625,
-0.28428196907043457,
-0.11723174899816513,
-0.8463036417961121,
0.1678471714258194,
-0.7463197112083435,
-0.3095369040966034,
-0.04970111325383186,
-0.06851841509342194,
-0.7640137672424316,
0.47340551018714905,
0.1968843936920166,
0.7617814540863037,
-0.8233230113983154,
0.9540559649467468,
0.6673743724822998,
-0.6451107859611511,
-0.8501461744308472,
0.15153323113918304,
0.01761455088853836,
-0.5229976177215576,
0.7423643469810486,
0.35264962911605835,
-0.28261566162109375,
-0.130531445145607,
-0.0269085131585598,
-0.557300329208374,
0.9526904225349426,
-0.33740171790122986,
-0.5543015599250793,
-0.06772678345441818,
0.19525940716266632,
0.7224797010421753,
-0.4812738597393036,
0.1679052859544754,
0.44124895334243774,
0.3454749882221222,
-0.05932403355836868,
-0.49492430686950684,
-0.17800454795360565,
-0.47871851921081543,
0.29627901315689087,
0.3103845715522766,
-0.9389855265617371,
1.0557479858398438,
0.07116193324327469,
0.07808312028646469,
0.07294952869415283,
0.74013751745224,
0.08652624487876892,
0.2846703827381134,
0.6540545225143433,
0.7828633785247803,
0.4552757740020752,
-0.024843506515026093,
1.111734390258789,
-0.42673927545547485,
0.49879828095436096,
1.1789112091064453,
-0.6800704598426819,
1.0585126876831055,
0.5654405951499939,
-0.28484660387039185,
1.0890121459960938,
0.36187735199928284,
-0.010510982945561409,
0.7811312079429626,
-0.14518848061561584,
-0.5155831575393677,
-0.33235639333724976,
0.051326777786016464,
-0.19016923010349274,
0.45398759841918945,
0.33752280473709106,
-0.6005218625068665,
-0.20352356135845184,
0.25379231572151184,
0.013184714131057262,
0.2379833459854126,
0.05350003391504288,
0.8684675097465515,
0.09766897559165955,
-0.70306396484375,
0.12102456390857697,
0.050668999552726746,
0.9012911319732666,
-0.6856042146682739,
0.22053684294223785,
-0.22180688381195068,
0.5639882683753967,
-0.037144459784030914,
-0.6660692095756531,
0.33524325489997864,
0.14793317019939423,
-0.47848284244537354,
-0.3017934560775757,
0.5984971523284912,
-0.24248379468917847,
-0.8031584620475769,
0.6937520503997803,
0.3045448064804077,
-0.3839031457901001,
-0.08398447185754776,
-0.7561099529266357,
0.2522779107093811,
0.0459677129983902,
-0.43567711114883423,
0.23996195197105408,
0.286624938249588,
0.058347780257463455,
0.18930239975452423,
0.9373093843460083,
0.06599271297454834,
0.04761809483170509,
0.305001437664032,
1.0869064331054688,
-0.6475226283073425,
-0.6947062015533447,
-0.8436646461486816,
0.8077107667922974,
-0.39261481165885925,
-0.26092180609703064,
0.904999852180481,
0.6561837792396545,
0.6352216005325317,
-0.28461208939552307,
1.0682177543640137,
0.06907262653112411,
0.9857374429702759,
-0.47463229298591614,
0.4656497538089752,
-0.4551188051700592,
0.36852580308914185,
-0.2772979736328125,
-0.754469633102417,
-0.1929124891757965,
0.5698870420455933,
-0.8265097737312317,
0.3611796200275421,
0.4836236536502838,
0.7595251798629761,
-0.21287381649017334,
0.2868519425392151,
0.005298251751810312,
0.21315152943134308,
0.29296937584877014,
0.5963492393493652,
1.1195447444915771,
-0.35878264904022217,
0.29172375798225403,
-0.3130607008934021,
-0.1650322526693344,
-0.4440440535545349,
-0.6842225193977356,
-1.1097056865692139,
-0.45464465022087097,
-0.0552651472389698,
-0.3705635368824005,
0.06330990791320801,
0.8558194637298584,
0.7889097332954407,
-0.7400832176208496,
-0.14400440454483032,
-0.14872592687606812,
-0.1315702199935913,
0.013380324468016624,
-0.341936320066452,
0.3599759340286255,
-0.360207736492157,
-0.4542859196662903,
0.32258322834968567,
0.5422968864440918,
-0.13029813766479492,
-0.32824909687042236,
-0.20181310176849365,
-0.29396146535873413,
0.34808123111724854,
0.7437989711761475,
-0.17362026870250702,
-0.7936253547668457,
-0.19961367547512054,
-0.20329290628433228,
-0.1299203783273697,
-0.05931771546602249,
0.9267598390579224,
-0.8130478858947754,
0.36738109588623047,
0.3741063177585602,
0.5215820074081421,
0.6542564034461975,
0.09545767307281494,
0.44114255905151367,
-0.5840937495231628,
0.30052950978279114,
0.5564002394676208,
0.5308657884597778,
0.42165058851242065,
-0.3329504430294037,
0.13370612263679504,
0.38254043459892273,
-0.30296000838279724,
-0.7480925917625427,
0.16232767701148987,
-1.4388577938079834,
-0.4917932450771332,
0.8836107850074768,
-0.07020377367734909,
-0.1515098363161087,
0.22145836055278778,
-0.1647217571735382,
0.22987408936023712,
-0.23712091147899628,
0.5829805731773376,
0.339078813791275,
-0.02051459811627865,
-0.1432592123746872,
-0.07015293836593628,
0.2720024287700653,
0.8056479692459106,
-0.5765038728713989,
-0.13826721906661987,
0.3819718658924103,
0.26431065797805786,
0.09615737944841385,
0.44744381308555603,
-0.25384870171546936,
0.06249794736504555,
-0.2975255846977234,
-0.19972115755081177,
0.036561548709869385,
-0.485732764005661,
-0.22885315120220184,
0.31902292370796204,
-0.18449096381664276,
-0.08954103291034698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06556v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06556v1
|
Enhancing Presentation Slide Generation by LLMs with a Multi-Staged End-to-End Approach
| 2024-06-01T07:49:31
| 2024-06-01T07:49:31
|
Sambaran Bandyopadhyay, Himanshu Maheshwari, Anandhavelu Natarajan, Apoorv Saxena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generating presentation slides from a long document with multimodal elements
such as text and images is an important task. This is time consuming and needs
domain expertise if done manually. Existing approaches for generating a rich
presentation from a document are often semi-automatic or only put a flat
summary into the slides ignoring the importance of a good narrative. In this
paper, we address this research gap by proposing a multi-staged end-to-end
model which uses a combination of LLM and VLM. We have experimentally shown
that compared to applying LLMs directly with state-of-the-art prompting, our
proposed multi-staged solution is better in terms of automated metrics and
human evaluation.
|
[
-0.2688654959201813,
-0.6863645911216736,
0.45279982686042786,
0.1890682429075241,
-0.7247399091720581,
0.3860247731208801,
0.050319887697696686,
-0.3000349998474121,
0.3377394378185272,
0.0968567430973053,
-0.4137839078903198,
-0.36894458532333374,
-0.48069629073143005,
0.1568298041820526,
-0.7043154835700989,
0.8192794919013977,
-0.09729567170143127,
-0.0570359006524086,
-0.48015502095222473,
0.14322741329669952,
-0.3453981280326843,
-0.08884769678115845,
-0.22284941375255585,
-0.5010721683502197,
0.3235279619693756,
0.4525907635688782,
0.5690369606018066,
0.2857716977596283,
0.09289871901273727,
0.2114332914352417,
-0.025221221148967743,
0.6394683718681335,
-0.23148871958255768,
0.3239154815673828,
-0.028995277360081673,
-0.08872397243976593,
-0.6466788053512573,
-0.06413207948207855,
0.44848984479904175,
0.28521671891212463,
0.034742578864097595,
0.1908663809299469,
0.13070526719093323,
0.49083301424980164,
-0.49025654792785645,
-0.045162368565797806,
-0.3827248215675354,
0.3998289704322815,
-0.02062283083796501,
-0.8343101143836975,
-0.5692452788352966,
0.12429233640432358,
-0.0583658441901207,
-0.5433844327926636,
0.030689680948853493,
0.08829376846551895,
0.596311092376709,
-0.1124095544219017,
-0.6235815286636353,
-0.1791599690914154,
-0.790132999420166,
0.4784006178379059,
-0.5785099864006042,
0.15669383108615875,
-0.10401087254285812,
0.3279869854450226,
-0.10403741151094437,
-1.0304523706436157,
-0.3513573110103607,
-0.4838908016681671,
0.2264976054430008,
0.6985243558883667,
0.01999969780445099,
-0.08949355036020279,
0.016421591863036156,
0.1893562376499176,
-0.6039229035377502,
0.3803776800632477,
-0.4766235947608948,
-0.2516842186450958,
0.5941876173019409,
0.3824406862258911,
0.22082984447479248,
-0.3835846483707428,
-0.8149935007095337,
0.018033666536211967,
-0.7226277589797974,
-0.15706169605255127,
0.17608608305454254,
-0.052348893135786057,
-0.15595415234565735,
0.6728034019470215,
-0.09881583601236343,
0.6343291997909546,
-0.006423826329410076,
-0.3907489776611328,
-0.10656041651964188,
-0.5790379643440247,
-0.3164423704147339,
0.17817322909832,
0.5794364213943481,
0.946211040019989,
0.1867416948080063,
0.1157781109213829,
-0.36862531304359436,
-0.23415355384349823,
0.18053537607192993,
-0.8233340382575989,
0.09163737297058105,
0.27672457695007324,
-0.5499183535575867,
-0.48785948753356934,
-0.19142799079418182,
-0.876310408115387,
-0.4034300148487091,
-0.7486435770988464,
0.7374451160430908,
-0.42166176438331604,
0.028249401599168777,
-0.1856762170791626,
-0.24079719185829163,
0.21082046627998352,
0.7796633243560791,
-0.5021620392799377,
0.033574428409338,
0.19445644319057465,
0.9769867658615112,
-0.0837043896317482,
-0.2228083610534668,
-0.9525688886642456,
0.5238955616950989,
-0.5784595608711243,
0.9137107133865356,
-0.4408239722251892,
-0.7448989152908325,
0.30698463320732117,
-0.34111520648002625,
0.30008411407470703,
-0.29907262325286865,
0.28405776619911194,
-0.4056888222694397,
0.7645460367202759,
0.18149378895759583,
-0.563152551651001,
0.38072800636291504,
0.2763129770755768,
-0.3533419668674469,
0.9797582030296326,
0.016882725059986115,
-0.700778067111969,
0.42667853832244873,
-0.5522849559783936,
-0.6742545366287231,
0.28351229429244995,
-0.5853919982910156,
-0.2250785082578659,
0.27974867820739746,
0.6133084297180176,
0.5528723001480103,
-0.18529734015464783,
0.39184918999671936,
0.3039889335632324,
-0.22079503536224365,
0.26740530133247375,
-0.5022927522659302,
-0.2218913733959198,
0.31128254532814026,
-0.15963710844516754,
0.5131916999816895,
-1.0264379978179932,
-0.20934389531612396,
0.09119610488414764,
-0.6498265266418457,
0.17337016761302948,
0.03168615326285362,
0.19388407468795776,
0.7346319556236267,
0.36325404047966003,
-0.045794665813446045,
0.08919691294431686,
-0.33127981424331665,
0.09340839833021164,
0.9536175727844238,
0.11158620566129684,
0.5816936492919922,
-0.6153213977813721,
0.8465738296508789,
0.1700427383184433,
0.21322698891162872,
-1.0390084981918335,
-0.5933163166046143,
-0.5374786853790283,
-0.09030485153198242,
0.08808638900518417,
0.20127549767494202,
-1.0000227689743042,
-0.16159455478191376,
-0.21068961918354034,
-0.16275784373283386,
-0.20089219510555267,
0.18572570383548737,
0.3552980124950409,
0.6261329054832458,
0.14179585874080658,
-0.5712898373603821,
-0.330081969499588,
-0.6324495673179626,
0.2049722522497177,
0.2048414647579193,
-0.247191920876503,
0.24802370369434357,
0.26381850242614746,
0.1959662288427353,
0.8086190819740295,
-0.29097509384155273,
-0.3689362704753876,
-0.28504541516304016,
0.47058457136154175,
0.23367616534233093,
0.05650901049375534,
0.4459615647792816,
-0.6047507524490356,
-0.7656683921813965,
0.00345339416526258,
-0.8501632213592529,
0.062262192368507385,
-0.6287757158279419,
0.06310316920280457,
0.5858714580535889,
0.5343065857887268,
-0.5692223310470581,
0.5916591882705688,
0.30647775530815125,
-0.047597553580999374,
0.7816290855407715,
-0.8213458061218262,
0.24790705740451813,
-1.3189167976379395,
0.11009190231561661,
-0.034631356596946716,
-0.3022632598876953,
-0.8286453485488892,
-0.1381313055753708,
0.05973511189222336,
-0.6191752552986145,
-0.8596097230911255,
0.6301859617233276,
-0.8357787728309631,
-0.4725807309150696,
-0.49598315358161926,
0.6931999921798706,
0.3129318654537201,
0.26396438479423523,
-0.07917333394289017,
0.6202257871627808,
0.5769574046134949,
-0.702259361743927,
0.45701754093170166,
0.19431179761886597,
-0.13596446812152863,
0.716285228729248,
-0.4708130955696106,
-0.05550623685121536,
-0.26181700825691223,
0.47687941789627075,
-0.9983986020088196,
-0.6933416724205017,
0.14160795509815216,
-0.36886054277420044,
0.650810182094574,
0.07877729088068008,
-0.533031702041626,
-0.1716238260269165,
-0.814346432685852,
-0.1528668850660324,
0.6750171184539795,
-0.4462566375732422,
0.6555595397949219,
-0.10745695233345032,
-0.3764511048793793,
-0.35951539874076843,
-0.5078189373016357,
0.7727802991867065,
-0.13582061231136322,
-1.0250351428985596,
0.9284606575965881,
-0.21580016613006592,
-0.15214166045188904,
-0.2839314639568329,
0.004423457197844982,
0.36868637800216675,
-0.3170332610607147,
0.1475379467010498,
0.30392986536026,
-0.06146685779094696,
0.11184763163328171,
0.3013325333595276,
-0.24121466279029846,
-0.18221870064735413,
-0.1297493278980255,
0.5490880012512207,
0.34560349583625793,
-0.7020567059516907,
-0.589331328868866,
0.7756432294845581,
0.6844490766525269,
-0.11986992508172989,
0.5652841329574585,
0.8230483531951904,
-0.36383986473083496,
-0.03839467093348503,
-0.298587441444397,
-0.12395001947879791,
-0.4176187217235565,
0.192712664604187,
-0.0359828807413578,
-0.47988566756248474,
0.4061570167541504,
-0.3460516631603241,
0.4684089422225952,
0.10126776248216629,
0.9259415864944458,
-0.18159155547618866,
0.9393202066421509,
0.39733225107192993,
0.3007732629776001,
0.615736186504364,
-0.065397709608078,
0.18693101406097412,
-0.6563522815704346,
-0.6027803421020508,
-0.10436997562646866,
-0.3301343023777008,
-0.056866422295570374,
-0.6188612580299377,
0.6280142068862915,
0.11035150289535522,
0.19339951872825623,
-0.2520042359828949,
-0.323607474565506,
0.18814483284950256,
0.5141929984092712,
0.1279892772436142,
0.5057359933853149,
0.13995769619941711,
-0.31621992588043213,
0.08212318271398544,
-0.5839649438858032,
-0.8607956171035767,
0.9802654981613159,
0.13936525583267212,
0.7606163620948792,
-0.03295357897877693,
0.8515980839729309,
0.35129639506340027,
0.220299631357193,
-0.45278653502464294,
0.772510290145874,
0.19625656306743622,
-0.3828319311141968,
-0.2961714267730713,
0.19450883567333221,
-0.951655924320221,
0.30362436175346375,
-0.3741610050201416,
-0.6828413009643555,
-0.2598098814487457,
0.2157050520181656,
-0.22234037518501282,
0.0009707047720439732,
-0.5790979862213135,
0.18117637932300568,
-0.3919123411178589,
-0.6159476041793823,
-0.2761712372303009,
-0.8059568405151367,
0.39333343505859375,
-0.3060155212879181,
0.6850084066390991,
0.12565010786056519,
-0.17485223710536957,
0.5781940221786499,
-0.4389830231666565,
0.7456573247909546,
-0.011951876804232597,
-0.2862243950366974,
0.352875679731369,
0.17004920542240143,
0.855596661567688,
0.0008533645886927843,
-0.08356944471597672,
-0.6447855830192566,
-0.5042989253997803,
-0.2088465392589569,
-0.6244534254074097,
0.650550901889801,
-0.42818835377693176,
-0.7059146761894226,
-0.12774156033992767,
-0.4722537696361542,
0.09705769270658493,
-0.002048343187198043,
0.17838548123836517,
1.003385305404663,
-0.14437337219715118,
-0.08938446640968323,
0.48308348655700684,
-0.48656007647514343,
0.9269115328788757,
0.22624367475509644,
-0.5821902751922607,
-0.6255326867103577,
0.6803745627403259,
0.18314112722873688,
0.5645652413368225,
0.3744405210018158,
0.06276744604110718,
-0.38510072231292725,
-0.7514956593513489,
-0.5758650898933411,
-0.01175929605960846,
-0.9645635485649109,
-0.13986459374427795,
-0.5028181076049805,
-0.19905401766300201,
-0.4925386905670166,
-0.5934199094772339,
-0.0363536961376667,
-0.5513479709625244,
-0.7077544331550598,
-0.3034933805465698,
0.08816216140985489,
0.6486667990684509,
-0.2809007167816162,
0.1001727357506752,
-1.0088276863098145,
0.48192673921585083,
0.5025426149368286,
-0.05674316734075546,
0.1467403769493103,
-0.67219477891922,
-0.3411805033683777,
-0.2787289023399353,
-0.7626563310623169,
-0.8005684614181519,
0.7472761273384094,
0.4597693383693695,
0.8521072864532471,
0.652802586555481,
0.047574482858181,
0.6113812923431396,
-0.5196600556373596,
1.1915451288223267,
0.839292585849762,
-0.499921590089798,
0.860702395439148,
-0.4681970477104187,
0.37026286125183105,
-0.28421750664711,
0.37385138869285583,
-0.3390151560306549,
-0.2542886435985565,
-0.6426610946655273,
-1.2731044292449951,
0.4992631673812866,
0.248630091547966,
0.3492032289505005,
0.09824729710817337,
-0.056127939373254776,
0.18089821934700012,
0.21258683502674103,
-0.6574452519416809,
-0.0082590626552701,
-0.32243144512176514,
0.15627720952033997,
-0.036964356899261475,
-0.34055736660957336,
-0.4865364730358124,
0.2403942048549652,
0.3631129860877991,
-0.26113903522491455,
0.16282226145267487,
0.24166221916675568,
-0.29541271924972534,
-0.39371469616889954,
0.4455399513244629,
0.9980916976928711,
1.1985323429107666,
-0.06881807744503021,
0.14821061491966248,
0.2415289282798767,
-0.029863087460398674,
0.11639150232076645,
-0.09929409623146057,
0.13357166945934296,
0.1970454454421997,
0.6235664486885071,
0.668778121471405,
0.46312272548675537,
-0.685748815536499,
0.45416611433029175,
0.17253589630126953,
-0.46686112880706787,
-0.033484335988759995,
-0.24819926917552948,
0.1766129583120346,
0.1730092167854309,
0.7699022889137268,
-0.2744079828262329,
-0.14458195865154266,
-0.6294733285903931,
0.5020221471786499,
0.12159378826618195,
-0.29431572556495667,
-0.1656993180513382,
0.8539307117462158,
0.5853071212768555,
-0.6937488913536072,
0.3045485019683838,
0.046971991658210754,
-0.10261675715446472,
0.4137134253978729,
0.650392472743988,
0.44090381264686584,
-0.040109410881996155,
0.41719314455986023,
0.0944599062204361,
0.1010584831237793,
0.3233981728553772,
0.17251305282115936,
-0.052689019590616226,
-0.03699100390076637,
-0.7454490661621094,
-0.4901014566421509,
-0.5843117237091064,
-0.04609179496765137,
-0.39994102716445923,
0.5635460019111633,
-0.2463124543428421,
-0.11099831014871597,
-0.3097054064273834,
-0.2556022107601166,
-0.17538850009441376,
0.2876686155796051,
0.5421710014343262,
1.0559664964675903,
-0.691385805606842,
0.36484086513519287,
0.5287479162216187,
-0.43638357520103455,
-0.3661457598209381,
-0.27410587668418884,
0.09775570780038834,
-0.6453414559364319,
0.5087037086486816,
0.11744952946901321,
0.19062025845050812,
-0.1534227579832077,
-0.3183600604534149,
-0.42444369196891785,
1.493728518486023,
0.12046054750680923,
-0.6183655858039856,
-0.14833728969097137,
0.07153666764497757,
0.5454427599906921,
-0.4651744067668915,
0.3143313527107239,
-0.13273465633392334,
0.2915801703929901,
0.7331835031509399,
-0.8387219905853271,
-0.107572041451931,
-0.054021041840314865,
0.07704084366559982,
-0.011485719121992588,
-0.4993687868118286,
0.5526419281959534,
-0.3552526533603668,
-0.1767318844795227,
-0.28607305884361267,
0.8543781638145447,
0.6677332520484924,
0.6906468868255615,
0.2745142877101898,
0.06978823989629745,
0.47600695490837097,
0.4417310655117035,
0.9848978519439697,
-0.4780644476413727,
0.012354569509625435,
1.2109342813491821,
-0.44552022218704224,
0.4913632273674011,
0.5262773633003235,
-0.04997003450989723,
-0.043960798531770706,
0.7896591424942017,
0.16537559032440186,
0.6256011128425598,
0.10709204524755478,
-0.47690850496292114,
-0.42366108298301697,
-0.2640436887741089,
-0.5218045711517334,
0.15692877769470215,
0.2796022295951843,
-0.5067927837371826,
-0.6798871159553528,
0.12952309846878052,
0.011292211711406708,
0.13447950780391693,
-0.2849145233631134,
0.5305588245391846,
0.39082857966423035,
-0.5800482630729675,
0.18045464158058167,
-0.05929950624704361,
0.5953446626663208,
-0.5762563347816467,
0.042543597519397736,
-0.23763059079647064,
-0.4298819303512573,
-0.27144166827201843,
-0.9588481783866882,
0.0834517776966095,
0.10746122151613235,
0.1046697273850441,
-0.7143557667732239,
1.0874263048171997,
-0.2485949695110321,
-0.35231977701187134,
0.1922411471605301,
0.642085611820221,
0.1904962658882141,
0.26874229311943054,
-0.5182503461837769,
-0.22256417572498322,
-0.1593063324689865,
-0.6247183084487915,
0.8388450145721436,
0.5392331480979919,
-0.0813678503036499,
0.7249727249145508,
0.748878002166748,
-0.3324200212955475,
0.25970491766929626,
0.607157826423645,
1.091416835784912,
-0.39815476536750793,
-0.3087625205516815,
-0.8775065541267395,
1.0816755294799805,
-0.18023669719696045,
-0.08603478223085403,
0.6212340593338013,
0.6592366695404053,
0.25494128465652466,
-0.06027151644229889,
0.6259080171585083,
0.19551797211170197,
0.007470081560313702,
-0.7072957158088684,
0.5812947750091553,
-0.6906174421310425,
0.17849260568618774,
-0.45142677426338196,
-0.7687044739723206,
-0.2645341455936432,
0.0820082351565361,
0.351741760969162,
-0.06347991526126862,
0.5194798707962036,
0.7675119042396545,
0.030298558995127678,
-0.290182888507843,
0.8391920328140259,
-0.20847927033901215,
0.6108969449996948,
0.3183239698410034,
1.1197021007537842,
-0.07834925502538681,
0.7635557651519775,
0.09608695656061172,
-0.31179022789001465,
-0.5452063679695129,
-1.3673678636550903,
-0.8386951088905334,
-0.5850173830986023,
-0.4696231484413147,
-0.21936526894569397,
-0.07439399510622025,
0.7459750771522522,
0.5087512731552124,
0.016678586602211,
-0.10958478599786758,
0.46455997228622437,
-0.20629721879959106,
0.1157945841550827,
-0.12902061641216278,
0.32710906863212585,
-0.2575043737888336,
-0.49631741642951965,
0.5496900081634521,
0.8478230237960815,
0.39170071482658386,
-0.5611405968666077,
-0.1502750962972641,
-0.252944678068161,
0.301275372505188,
0.9641410708427429,
-0.13863934576511383,
-0.3038969337940216,
-0.023562530055642128,
-0.10550497472286224,
0.07750502973794937,
0.2593589127063751,
0.5298830270767212,
-0.7512076497077942,
0.43195098638534546,
0.47081977128982544,
0.005209687165915966,
0.7689502239227295,
-0.08196016401052475,
0.7462217807769775,
-0.8794227242469788,
-0.07875824719667435,
-0.002927555236965418,
0.44435474276542664,
0.26557597517967224,
-0.2844742238521576,
0.33187228441238403,
0.029234562069177628,
-0.37272799015045166,
-0.6875439286231995,
0.23228946328163147,
-1.2236465215682983,
-0.3092213571071625,
1.017174243927002,
0.00785817764699459,
-0.008083520457148552,
-0.07098101079463959,
-0.39258190989494324,
0.3440343737602234,
-0.27054154872894287,
0.9044641256332397,
0.5723004341125488,
-0.3949662744998932,
-0.21785369515419006,
-0.2878846228122711,
-0.04862853139638901,
-0.1428830325603485,
-1.0182299613952637,
-0.3499166667461395,
0.546122133731842,
0.017115740105509758,
0.18544670939445496,
0.9033281803131104,
-0.27157720923423767,
0.35954612493515015,
-0.09720306843519211,
-0.21848808228969574,
-0.4513692259788513,
-0.5406497716903687,
-0.17784714698791504,
0.45079976320266724,
-0.09967359155416489,
0.030779274180531502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00343v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00343v2
|
Beyond Metrics: Evaluating LLMs' Effectiveness in Culturally Nuanced, Low-Resource Real-World Scenarios
| 2024-06-01T07:36:59
| 2024-06-13T17:53:45
|
Millicent Ochieng, Varun Gumma, Sunayana Sitaram, Jindong Wang, Vishrav Chaudhary, Keshet Ronen, Kalika Bali, Jacki O'Neill
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) in real-world applications
presents both opportunities and challenges, particularly in multilingual and
code-mixed communication settings. This research evaluates the performance of
seven leading LLMs in sentiment analysis on a dataset derived from multilingual
and code-mixed WhatsApp chats, including Swahili, English and Sheng. Our
evaluation includes both quantitative analysis using metrics like F1 score and
qualitative assessment of LLMs' explanations for their predictions. We find
that, while Mistral-7b and Mixtral-8x7b achieved high F1 scores, they and other
LLMs such as GPT-3.5-Turbo, Llama-2-70b, and Gemma-7b struggled with
understanding linguistic and contextual nuances, as well as lack of
transparency in their decision-making process as observed from their
explanations. In contrast, GPT-4 and GPT-4-Turbo excelled in grasping diverse
linguistic inputs and managing various contextual information, demonstrating
high consistency with human alignment and transparency in their decision-making
process. The LLMs however, encountered difficulties in incorporating cultural
nuance especially in non-English settings with GPT-4s doing so inconsistently.
The findings emphasize the necessity of continuous improvement of LLMs to
effectively tackle the challenges of culturally nuanced, low-resource
real-world settings and the need for developing evaluation benchmarks for
capturing these issues.
|
[
-0.46096891164779663,
-0.43384936451911926,
0.4200281500816345,
0.7178047299385071,
-0.2016625702381134,
0.6773777604103088,
-0.6359404921531677,
-0.5388511419296265,
0.0637822151184082,
0.04515964910387993,
-0.43538200855255127,
-0.628046989440918,
-0.6163415908813477,
0.2452327460050583,
-0.10765759646892548,
0.9925926327705383,
-0.031121060252189636,
0.3031105101108551,
0.016438404098153114,
-0.3618583381175995,
-0.5804526209831238,
-0.6843210458755493,
-0.3428802490234375,
-0.35846462845802307,
0.4722959101200104,
0.5824741721153259,
0.7599484324455261,
0.04200684651732445,
0.7539585828781128,
0.2293672412633896,
-0.40787428617477417,
0.34081462025642395,
-0.6693812608718872,
-0.0028092374559491873,
-0.003713754005730152,
-0.49230262637138367,
-0.40455183386802673,
0.1116497814655304,
0.6445520520210266,
0.666963517665863,
-0.19519244134426117,
0.3807470500469208,
0.2907232642173767,
0.5223292708396912,
-0.5996788144111633,
0.20225848257541656,
-0.4658356308937073,
0.2721961736679077,
0.11964519321918488,
0.07421461492776871,
-0.1317693144083023,
-0.5747247934341431,
0.030493345111608505,
-0.2672056257724762,
-0.44950053095817566,
-0.23722848296165466,
0.6554344296455383,
0.019750986248254776,
-0.4716269373893738,
-0.31996244192123413,
-0.7248954772949219,
1.0624228715896606,
-0.8769290447235107,
0.34960806369781494,
0.1592712104320526,
0.23574525117874146,
-0.08487080782651901,
-0.22294487059116364,
-0.3707329034805298,
-0.1881958246231079,
0.1791624128818512,
0.3431376516819,
0.1529598832130432,
-0.2670169174671173,
0.19136153161525726,
0.3401891887187958,
-0.42669782042503357,
0.3515552878379822,
-0.31960538029670715,
-0.21699465811252594,
0.6778677105903625,
0.3574674129486084,
-0.0981936976313591,
-0.1636532098054886,
-0.2639559209346771,
0.18415670096874237,
-0.6029802560806274,
0.034393589943647385,
0.06213420629501343,
0.25731784105300903,
-0.6912412047386169,
0.35837122797966003,
-0.17174102365970612,
0.3335978090763092,
-0.168568417429924,
-0.4500749707221985,
0.5158898234367371,
-0.46758076548576355,
-0.11095387488603592,
-0.19178442656993866,
0.914055585861206,
0.5259854793548584,
0.5343737602233887,
-0.030329745262861252,
-0.19819973409175873,
0.2890418469905853,
-0.11710882931947708,
-0.7949268817901611,
0.2443680465221405,
0.19782692193984985,
-0.49019932746887207,
-0.26706260442733765,
-0.18388055264949799,
-0.7110517024993896,
-0.5382957458496094,
-0.1836625337600708,
-0.07519234716892242,
-0.3313004672527313,
-0.6921939849853516,
-0.012852828949689865,
-0.0428280346095562,
0.5440958142280579,
0.3203080892562866,
-0.49649927020072937,
0.02034868113696575,
0.7082799077033997,
1.1348530054092407,
-0.12864401936531067,
-0.15214383602142334,
0.09767498821020126,
-0.3342515528202057,
-0.541853129863739,
0.40269705653190613,
-0.5472711324691772,
-0.7392878532409668,
0.18769781291484833,
-0.41522207856178284,
0.07561425119638443,
-0.6453275084495544,
0.7041686177253723,
-0.3552672863006592,
0.031852301210165024,
-0.5106984972953796,
-0.30348801612854004,
-0.07257764041423798,
0.7334795594215393,
-0.37534889578819275,
1.0848803520202637,
-0.03615574911236763,
-0.6009406447410583,
0.5245776772499084,
-0.5972923636436462,
-0.29379957914352417,
0.2131621539592743,
-0.2480143904685974,
-0.09573440253734589,
0.2603413462638855,
0.005900819320231676,
0.5583563446998596,
-0.399715781211853,
0.2576698064804077,
-0.404569536447525,
-0.709260106086731,
0.5562323927879333,
-0.58925461769104,
0.4382839798927307,
0.29441240429878235,
-0.43580296635627747,
-0.1514855921268463,
-0.7548002600669861,
0.2713075876235962,
0.1813095062971115,
-0.4582209587097168,
-0.06711704283952713,
0.005634891800582409,
0.12993665039539337,
0.6028634905815125,
0.2582879662513733,
-0.5331929326057434,
-0.04429417476058006,
-0.31515198945999146,
0.4703846573829651,
0.4939998984336853,
-0.2322932481765747,
0.36931362748146057,
-0.09885801374912262,
0.851422131061554,
0.05506197363138199,
0.38666844367980957,
-0.016218123957514763,
-0.4195486307144165,
-0.6328517198562622,
-0.2590559720993042,
0.07635078579187393,
0.6377617120742798,
-0.708848774433136,
0.1474379599094391,
-0.6083535552024841,
-0.7075729966163635,
-0.5657911896705627,
0.3718789219856262,
0.4944729804992676,
0.1864665150642395,
-0.08151812106370926,
-0.2588993310928345,
-0.3313616216182709,
-0.7292463183403015,
-0.20510341227054596,
-0.30447301268577576,
0.19721443951129913,
0.27153703570365906,
0.383470356464386,
-0.2759760022163391,
0.7870513796806335,
-0.12952469289302826,
-0.02618790790438652,
-0.41853222250938416,
0.033752162009477615,
0.3739452660083771,
0.04129328951239586,
0.3206987977027893,
-0.7506222128868103,
-0.4768450856208801,
0.1653866469860077,
-0.9671510457992554,
-0.07306408137083054,
0.13717567920684814,
0.20266501605510712,
0.3360375761985779,
0.18782168626785278,
-0.4223543405532837,
0.03658024221658707,
0.9716800451278687,
-0.16452829539775848,
0.6791874766349792,
0.031090332195162773,
0.41039177775382996,
-0.8267951607704163,
-0.1647721230983734,
0.35308873653411865,
-0.13392765820026398,
-0.4712132513523102,
-0.0454484224319458,
-0.06789099425077438,
-0.11100948601961136,
-0.7082881331443787,
0.4038686156272888,
-0.41620394587516785,
-0.21514053642749786,
-0.03491980582475662,
0.42641183733940125,
-0.033726271241903305,
0.3168153464794159,
-0.04460303857922554,
0.8857445120811462,
0.3353632688522339,
-0.338349848985672,
0.35422948002815247,
0.054796069860458374,
-0.7419103384017944,
0.712630033493042,
-0.3991011381149292,
-0.08384333550930023,
-0.021456846967339516,
0.26472052931785583,
-0.9820942878723145,
0.060406364500522614,
0.006274884101003408,
-0.40003007650375366,
-0.10659264773130417,
-0.055541910231113434,
-0.6764349341392517,
-0.2950302064418793,
-0.44202563166618347,
0.43170365691185,
0.5436671376228333,
-0.2040344774723053,
0.37723633646965027,
0.3079341650009155,
-0.11964181065559387,
-0.5343834757804871,
-0.8567324280738831,
0.4918633699417114,
-0.5683683753013611,
-0.554645299911499,
-0.14319317042827606,
0.055297236889600754,
-0.6182690858840942,
-0.41084936261177063,
0.029093297198414803,
0.014247831888496876,
0.29199573397636414,
0.1883031129837036,
0.22686772048473358,
-0.4065181612968445,
-0.0004735030233860016,
-0.2376522719860077,
-0.007654291577637196,
0.1264820396900177,
0.09174461662769318,
0.46547362208366394,
-0.564440906047821,
-0.27187392115592957,
-0.36935359239578247,
0.22696147859096527,
0.6938588619232178,
-0.2515996992588043,
0.9152523279190063,
0.8919884562492371,
-0.12825898826122284,
-0.034364085644483566,
-0.7461221218109131,
0.1167461946606636,
-0.4458257853984833,
0.4883134961128235,
-0.4822194576263428,
-1.0229655504226685,
0.7582941651344299,
-0.2536415755748749,
0.13731779158115387,
0.04950448125600815,
0.7287459373474121,
-0.2734397053718567,
1.0216081142425537,
0.45240065455436707,
-0.23636117577552795,
0.4645441174507141,
-0.2778296172618866,
0.4160711169242859,
-0.7964296936988831,
-0.36382079124450684,
-0.21916459500789642,
-0.2859899699687958,
-0.8840542435646057,
-0.5201055407524109,
0.5874194502830505,
0.04640645533800125,
-0.24892543256282806,
-0.08590514957904816,
-0.15400411188602448,
0.3813626170158386,
0.02736694924533367,
-0.16487741470336914,
0.35901010036468506,
-0.048068296164274216,
-0.056581418961286545,
-0.18692539632320404,
-0.769108772277832,
-0.9014896154403687,
0.7659856677055359,
0.5310880541801453,
0.8532125353813171,
0.30261465907096863,
0.4873337149620056,
0.30171477794647217,
0.6540598273277283,
-0.8921820521354675,
0.5082400441169739,
0.03759852796792984,
-0.38282549381256104,
-0.13308221101760864,
-0.528573751449585,
-0.5521676540374756,
0.7831913232803345,
-0.2246864289045334,
-0.6803411841392517,
-0.07854973524808884,
-0.03386383503675461,
-0.15669859945774078,
0.040553539991378784,
-0.7170733213424683,
0.7134292125701904,
-0.44713714718818665,
-0.22785091400146484,
-0.31090646982192993,
-0.40405723452568054,
0.5184207558631897,
-0.2580089867115021,
0.7808756828308105,
-0.4254476726055145,
-0.16546833515167236,
0.5399020314216614,
-0.05642348527908325,
1.0915724039077759,
-0.07928192615509033,
-0.5533039569854736,
0.19897405803203583,
0.1487598419189453,
0.2371523380279541,
-0.011145384982228279,
-0.5352299809455872,
0.6413129568099976,
0.1169755756855011,
-0.3436576724052429,
-0.6278046369552612,
0.818655252456665,
-0.7210019826889038,
-0.3999421000480652,
-0.21137972176074982,
-0.3314861059188843,
-0.569469690322876,
-0.26183953881263733,
0.04347725212574005,
0.3088139295578003,
-0.37263068556785583,
0.18440057337284088,
0.28268155455589294,
-0.42263856530189514,
0.527958333492279,
0.6217146515846252,
-0.11003457009792328,
-0.3315514326095581,
0.7817882299423218,
0.22070522606372833,
0.4884064197540283,
0.0690702572464943,
0.2122647762298584,
-0.3433729410171509,
-0.3212134540081024,
-0.5609407424926758,
0.24556055665016174,
-0.8451909422874451,
-0.10640489310026169,
-0.2636493444442749,
-0.0630674883723259,
-0.23274508118629456,
-0.19951194524765015,
-0.3327525854110718,
-0.19037093222141266,
0.06417348235845566,
-0.17749668657779694,
0.17886240780353546,
0.6778272390365601,
0.1444597989320755,
0.42536041140556335,
-0.9334354996681213,
-0.12548094987869263,
-0.360655277967453,
0.4924907982349396,
0.2270209640264511,
-0.66709303855896,
-0.6133792996406555,
0.17913344502449036,
-0.2549842298030853,
-0.7000365257263184,
0.294170618057251,
0.1291925460100174,
0.4057793617248535,
0.20739059150218964,
-0.29050350189208984,
0.9618576169013977,
-0.35641032457351685,
0.9253873825073242,
0.1341501772403717,
-0.9735028147697449,
0.21815095841884613,
-0.3969308137893677,
0.39389336109161377,
0.5576647520065308,
0.377021849155426,
-0.7926461100578308,
-0.5936467051506042,
-0.2872556746006012,
-0.7326698899269104,
0.5208544135093689,
0.07705073803663254,
0.5599954724311829,
-0.06440673023462296,
0.2905399203300476,
-0.0646037757396698,
0.3548194169998169,
-0.924069881439209,
-0.13462914526462555,
-0.005657342728227377,
-0.27476227283477783,
-0.07576026022434235,
-0.3820142447948456,
0.03426731750369072,
-0.05126563459634781,
0.4012426435947418,
-0.05890776216983795,
-0.07203957438468933,
-0.1377352923154831,
-0.20475247502326965,
0.21787740290164948,
0.4849112927913666,
0.4839801788330078,
0.8590152263641357,
0.01804492622613907,
-0.18468743562698364,
0.4097021222114563,
-0.200977623462677,
0.18994168937206268,
-0.46430596709251404,
0.2860579192638397,
-0.18487432599067688,
0.6313947439193726,
0.5940135717391968,
0.31642064452171326,
-0.8446418046951294,
0.5541304349899292,
-0.05308419093489647,
0.05625752732157707,
-0.29242148995399475,
-0.05915124714374542,
0.11189325153827667,
0.25565847754478455,
0.1722368746995926,
-0.4395971894264221,
-0.009326005354523659,
-0.674712061882019,
-0.25969287753105164,
0.504374623298645,
-0.5634225010871887,
-0.2182392179965973,
0.051711760461330414,
0.46840807795524597,
-0.06257884204387665,
0.504347562789917,
-0.18979938328266144,
-0.4829482436180115,
0.5721163749694824,
0.44190046191215515,
0.5101868510246277,
-0.18487252295017242,
0.42411521077156067,
0.035249821841716766,
0.3982226848602295,
-0.10699477046728134,
0.4074339270591736,
0.0012713562464341521,
-1.081049919128418,
-0.7286251783370972,
-0.6058133840560913,
-0.5008273124694824,
-0.15176433324813843,
-0.7184176445007324,
0.1584225594997406,
-0.484609991312027,
-0.5300440788269043,
-0.2493080496788025,
-0.03276706486940384,
-0.792456865310669,
0.29961705207824707,
0.40721991658210754,
0.8647035956382751,
-0.9771024584770203,
0.47882190346717834,
0.7347444891929626,
-0.2633329927921295,
-0.7439782023429871,
-0.10519301891326904,
0.142839252948761,
-0.949866771697998,
0.7557558417320251,
0.1573491394519806,
-0.19890931248664856,
-0.36848142743110657,
-0.14745865762233734,
-0.7470511794090271,
0.8969646096229553,
0.2757995128631592,
-0.5777928233146667,
0.34609925746917725,
0.3251494765281677,
0.923397421836853,
-0.24813096225261688,
0.6023747324943542,
0.7149286270141602,
0.5232639908790588,
0.07136416435241699,
-1.196319818496704,
-0.0995514988899231,
-0.17658084630966187,
0.09169065207242966,
0.1478450894355774,
-1.0718506574630737,
0.3770197927951813,
-0.105904221534729,
-0.11718512326478958,
-0.11634846031665802,
0.4681268632411957,
0.3359031677246094,
0.09596914052963257,
0.3742862343788147,
0.15479443967342377,
0.5602589845657349,
-0.154334157705307,
1.1237995624542236,
-0.3915942907333374,
0.2591102421283722,
0.7028157114982605,
-0.7265949249267578,
0.8735824823379517,
0.3597111105918884,
-0.33436325192451477,
0.602143406867981,
0.5722901821136475,
0.06652430444955826,
0.18925437331199646,
0.3517567813396454,
-0.29586437344551086,
-0.15079809725284576,
-0.4388705790042877,
-0.10300613194704056,
0.6954905390739441,
0.5918418169021606,
-0.035583652555942535,
-0.06260273605585098,
0.0687859058380127,
0.239551842212677,
0.06007301062345505,
-0.31544557213783264,
0.7363243103027344,
0.4155305027961731,
-0.5128600001335144,
0.8046537041664124,
0.20682501792907715,
0.9965233206748962,
-0.4428936243057251,
0.07264726608991623,
-0.4156627953052521,
0.04588555544614792,
-0.4833049178123474,
-0.9774644374847412,
0.2702205181121826,
0.3559670150279999,
-0.007512988056987524,
-0.18410100042819977,
0.22845454514026642,
-0.24333803355693817,
-0.7016598582267761,
0.5717733502388,
0.6893244385719299,
0.26189520955085754,
0.09656302630901337,
-0.825528621673584,
0.5909157991409302,
-0.10278421640396118,
-0.23826278746128082,
0.21493154764175415,
0.6218855977058411,
-0.2694155275821686,
0.9204269647598267,
0.37752392888069153,
0.4472615718841553,
-0.1787344068288803,
0.5677942633628845,
0.5351294279098511,
-0.7678584456443787,
-0.3128897547721863,
-1.092815637588501,
0.4697811007499695,
0.00771087221801281,
-0.3838243782520294,
0.9178166389465332,
0.4781514108181,
0.8083314299583435,
0.27969077229499817,
0.8156633973121643,
0.14074885845184326,
0.18912085890769958,
-0.35702750086784363,
0.3580709397792816,
-0.4298626184463501,
0.4725903272628784,
-0.33515694737434387,
-0.9743067026138306,
-0.14581745862960815,
0.5896957516670227,
-0.51361083984375,
0.23456643521785736,
0.4558877944946289,
0.6364943385124207,
0.1927446722984314,
-0.0068479375913739204,
0.5073958039283752,
0.18416298925876617,
0.40025249123573303,
0.41957321763038635,
1.2741056680679321,
-0.0942050963640213,
0.5052300095558167,
0.1101897582411766,
-0.2688716948032379,
0.0483248233795166,
-0.9317521452903748,
-0.815459132194519,
-0.12091653048992157,
-0.2052663415670395,
-0.25612106919288635,
-0.12323079258203506,
0.9298664927482605,
0.6102361083030701,
-0.5123447179794312,
-0.5328392386436462,
0.5693686008453369,
0.05908624082803726,
0.051569614559412,
-0.30142471194267273,
-0.057987358421087265,
-0.3561968505382538,
-0.5699525475502014,
0.16995693743228912,
0.4962179660797119,
-0.1245577484369278,
-0.6003810167312622,
-0.10150168091058731,
0.2223357856273651,
0.0666770488023758,
0.9842069149017334,
-0.1437290459871292,
-0.8273910284042358,
-0.05726533755660057,
-0.12448538839817047,
-0.21886348724365234,
0.10843998193740845,
0.7834261655807495,
-0.5526440739631653,
-0.03391239047050476,
0.14177058637142181,
0.5534961819648743,
0.22343507409095764,
0.023634595796465874,
0.590201735496521,
-0.6531361937522888,
0.22497257590293884,
0.209185391664505,
0.34659436345100403,
0.7657497525215149,
-0.13634754717350006,
0.47565463185310364,
-0.04816029593348503,
-0.3185980021953583,
-0.8348788619041443,
0.08384811878204346,
-0.7215991616249084,
-0.02654477208852768,
1.586777925491333,
-0.2905600965023041,
0.15566261112689972,
-0.09760189056396484,
-0.015977224335074425,
-0.08383806049823761,
-0.38955312967300415,
0.7344983220100403,
0.938950777053833,
0.042820800095796585,
-0.0636565163731575,
-0.6048346757888794,
0.19762183725833893,
0.5355480313301086,
-0.6860138773918152,
0.051432739943265915,
0.4343717098236084,
0.3524799942970276,
0.04967885836958885,
0.7372943758964539,
-0.3809879422187805,
-0.13169077038764954,
-0.3607569932937622,
-0.038605496287345886,
0.3019087016582489,
0.0612608976662159,
-0.5345419049263,
-0.12014796584844589,
0.4300418496131897,
0.06640761345624924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06555v1
|
An Evaluation Benchmark for Autoformalization in Lean4
| 2024-06-01T07:06:57
| 2024-06-01T07:06:57
|
Aryan Gulati, Devanshu Ladsaria, Shubhra Mishra, Jasdeep Sidhu, Brando Miranda
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.PL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) hold the potential to revolutionize
autoformalization. The introduction of Lean4, a mathematical programming
language, presents an unprecedented opportunity to rigorously assess the
autoformalization capabilities of LLMs. This paper introduces a novel
evaluation benchmark designed for Lean4, applying it to test the abilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs, including GPT-3.5, GPT-4, and Gemini Pro. Our
comprehensive analysis reveals that, despite recent advancements, these LLMs
still exhibit limitations in autoformalization, particularly in more complex
areas of mathematics. These findings underscore the need for further
development in LLMs to fully harness their potential in scientific research and
development. This study not only benchmarks current LLM capabilities but also
sets the stage for future enhancements in autoformalization.
|
[
-0.1957382708787918,
-0.2668381929397583,
0.6231663227081299,
0.47984737157821655,
-0.038200169801712036,
0.2621311843395233,
-0.376480370759964,
-0.4702480733394623,
-0.30129560828208923,
0.004233664367347956,
-0.5248439311981201,
-0.4720894992351532,
-0.6641568541526794,
0.36750438809394836,
-0.5291637778282166,
0.8663436770439148,
-0.5640196800231934,
0.268280565738678,
-0.4328308403491974,
-0.1426956206560135,
-0.23423808813095093,
-0.38155287504196167,
-0.26255252957344055,
-0.21081332862377167,
0.11790626496076584,
0.0286273006349802,
0.8586156964302063,
0.8026766777038574,
0.7961045503616333,
0.455669105052948,
0.6230924725532532,
-0.4749387204647064,
-0.4743817448616028,
0.33525896072387695,
0.3661954402923584,
-0.37948930263519287,
-0.6074895262718201,
0.23025044798851013,
1.068406581878662,
0.6508282423019409,
-0.13835985958576202,
0.29093819856643677,
-0.19730085134506226,
0.5130774974822998,
-0.6491929888725281,
0.527942419052124,
-0.594088077545166,
0.15108533203601837,
-0.2963758111000061,
0.34793952107429504,
0.23534637689590454,
-0.8988683223724365,
-0.14030452072620392,
-0.4727419912815094,
-0.10265742987394333,
-0.21634891629219055,
0.8114067912101746,
0.7340638637542725,
-0.08674647659063339,
-0.25690943002700806,
-0.7024180889129639,
0.777528703212738,
-0.9662733674049377,
0.722816526889801,
-0.07630109786987305,
0.5858672857284546,
-0.10657832026481628,
-1.020727515220642,
-0.5031906366348267,
-0.2621440887451172,
0.435043603181839,
0.03321152925491333,
-0.1199224591255188,
-0.05685817822813988,
0.41517332196235657,
0.6361047625541687,
-0.5655708312988281,
0.31024235486984253,
-0.46276822686195374,
-0.3489408493041992,
0.5761206746101379,
0.24361298978328705,
0.18894611299037933,
0.12336935102939606,
-0.18890956044197083,
0.03613846376538277,
-0.5956648588180542,
-0.0848512127995491,
0.3611688017845154,
-0.1753903180360794,
0.011361271142959595,
0.5524839758872986,
-0.23545245826244354,
0.5557121634483337,
-0.13030095398426056,
-0.08062011748552322,
0.5399613976478577,
-0.33782798051834106,
-0.4812573194503784,
-0.34331580996513367,
0.9941326379776001,
0.1417383998632431,
0.16871599853038788,
-0.14856265485286713,
-0.5275840163230896,
0.26747819781303406,
0.06672622263431549,
-1.0308336019515991,
-0.32776468992233276,
-0.060369234532117844,
-0.4129132330417633,
-0.24525487422943115,
-0.11636213958263397,
-0.47301018238067627,
-0.1423814594745636,
-0.27874472737312317,
0.3582735061645508,
-0.34328532218933105,
-0.09343557804822922,
-0.01867075264453888,
0.16070027649402618,
0.6949479579925537,
0.2752969563007355,
-0.9903304576873779,
0.6385912299156189,
0.9952262043952942,
0.6918228268623352,
-0.4520746171474457,
-0.3529188334941864,
-0.46607527136802673,
-0.04008892551064491,
-0.538701593875885,
0.6581955552101135,
-0.483934223651886,
-0.15052726864814758,
-0.06692252308130264,
-0.3314552307128906,
0.21327164769172668,
-0.8006555438041687,
0.6880196928977966,
-0.3557087779045105,
0.055740877985954285,
-0.13834279775619507,
-0.572425901889801,
0.15140782296657562,
0.23811164498329163,
-0.7386763095855713,
1.2952216863632202,
0.41952866315841675,
-0.1797831505537033,
0.5983595848083496,
-0.5346981883049011,
-0.33203116059303284,
0.3016834855079651,
-0.7420132756233215,
-0.6530583500862122,
0.17901922762393951,
-0.03019213117659092,
0.27834442257881165,
-0.6425871253013611,
0.34577158093452454,
-0.6890450119972229,
-0.4340749979019165,
0.27911680936813354,
-0.5983016490936279,
0.3524395227432251,
0.21375975012779236,
-0.6615331768989563,
0.04201863706111908,
-0.7071985602378845,
0.5611027479171753,
-0.12491502612829208,
-0.3645763099193573,
0.06606198847293854,
-0.1539888083934784,
-0.33766257762908936,
0.42793983221054077,
0.6826584339141846,
-0.382707417011261,
0.2304469645023346,
-0.41741156578063965,
0.5118624567985535,
0.7872767448425293,
-0.5427938103675842,
0.2686435282230377,
-0.001465794863179326,
0.8074290752410889,
-0.24132946133613586,
0.2989817261695862,
-0.045614708214998245,
-0.3486894965171814,
-1.0113742351531982,
-0.43908438086509705,
0.31735390424728394,
0.25263431668281555,
-0.391547828912735,
0.38752225041389465,
-0.07395581901073456,
-0.4073191285133362,
-0.543829083442688,
0.4832128584384918,
0.3997951149940491,
0.12078877538442612,
0.36749961972236633,
-0.17691867053508759,
-0.5871620774269104,
-1.1813817024230957,
-0.4634653329849243,
-0.05622866749763489,
-0.22627399861812592,
-0.06595054268836975,
0.3934697210788727,
-0.40606778860092163,
0.9065025448799133,
-0.3587760627269745,
0.021599099040031433,
-0.015507352538406849,
0.32634109258651733,
0.3585048317909241,
0.30728134512901306,
0.56170254945755,
-0.41275355219841003,
-0.5245290398597717,
-0.39681220054626465,
-0.7201555967330933,
-0.3977312445640564,
0.210647851228714,
0.05181685835123062,
0.20095175504684448,
0.6144951581954956,
-0.41238799691200256,
0.23969729244709015,
0.8531855940818787,
-0.096279576420784,
0.6474549770355225,
-0.16073203086853027,
-0.06272923946380615,
-0.5061299800872803,
0.01975991204380989,
-0.10787433385848999,
-0.20070385932922363,
-0.20559898018836975,
-0.3398693799972534,
0.38006535172462463,
-0.21945123374462128,
0.0693267360329628,
0.240478977560997,
-0.8369903564453125,
-0.770162045955658,
0.04168646037578583,
-0.03732747212052345,
-0.18932370841503143,
-0.05308755859732628,
-0.14106085896492004,
0.729179322719574,
0.6532684564590454,
-0.3622855544090271,
0.527202844619751,
-0.18762774765491486,
-0.49024221301078796,
0.5128306746482849,
-0.8528751730918884,
-0.026420021429657936,
0.13736586272716522,
0.22793196141719818,
-0.9234703183174133,
-0.09840549528598785,
-0.1483660638332367,
-0.18896791338920593,
0.26906952261924744,
0.042150430381298065,
-0.49584004282951355,
-0.5628513693809509,
-0.40434879064559937,
0.5682267546653748,
0.5464842319488525,
-0.26356241106987,
0.5139779448509216,
0.2588648796081543,
-0.29188746213912964,
-0.47167328000068665,
-0.40037164092063904,
0.23454932868480682,
-0.2532092332839966,
-0.6483441591262817,
0.27093014121055603,
-0.5052013993263245,
-0.26987016201019287,
-0.16879449784755707,
-0.34086742997169495,
-0.08496253937482834,
0.08219782263040543,
0.06943727284669876,
0.421264111995697,
-0.3373895287513733,
-0.17836187779903412,
-0.17186640202999115,
-0.20873406529426575,
0.4064987003803253,
-0.5027598142623901,
0.37132421135902405,
-0.6117157340049744,
-0.3693965673446655,
-0.33737581968307495,
-0.10917404294013977,
0.6742236614227295,
-0.2981688678264618,
0.07145725935697556,
0.6565225720405579,
-0.41301730275154114,
-0.3427315056324005,
-0.6375769376754761,
0.05345099791884422,
-0.5974164605140686,
0.5223832130432129,
-0.48922353982925415,
-0.7398961782455444,
0.35742440819740295,
-0.3175148367881775,
0.2323877215385437,
0.5885507464408875,
0.7771990895271301,
0.20547844469547272,
0.9645217657089233,
0.5709004402160645,
-0.09916354715824127,
0.21014899015426636,
-0.17911098897457123,
0.26676443219184875,
-0.661458432674408,
-0.3149855434894562,
-0.6890848875045776,
-0.18503297865390778,
-0.6666919589042664,
-0.8485065698623657,
0.5102119445800781,
-0.08966201543807983,
-0.37937912344932556,
0.2381807416677475,
-0.2527770698070526,
0.3786906599998474,
-0.024087093770503998,
-0.6748858094215393,
0.4217033088207245,
-0.39193475246429443,
-0.5175657272338867,
-0.3626656234264374,
-0.5782486796379089,
-0.4099258780479431,
1.0898213386535645,
0.69430011510849,
1.008480191230774,
0.1661609709262848,
0.6646103858947754,
0.18158729374408722,
0.879246711730957,
-0.8926531076431274,
0.44565513730049133,
-0.05228830873966217,
-0.3798019587993622,
-0.4719880521297455,
-0.5742286443710327,
-0.6006743311882019,
0.20698034763336182,
-0.05561407655477524,
-0.23310226202011108,
-0.0627642348408699,
0.017596310004591942,
-0.15648768842220306,
-0.15541383624076843,
-0.49357864260673523,
0.9888873100280762,
-0.7681955695152283,
-0.17916086316108704,
0.09394946694374084,
-0.14288926124572754,
0.4107401967048645,
-0.3749639391899109,
0.405404657125473,
-0.37175849080085754,
-0.520447313785553,
0.667150616645813,
-0.5444923043251038,
0.56923907995224,
-0.00727514922618866,
-0.5033170580863953,
-0.08715911209583282,
0.026093412190675735,
0.3431844115257263,
0.13775737583637238,
-0.2163216918706894,
0.21738849580287933,
-0.13254687190055847,
-0.1927594542503357,
-0.7410266399383545,
1.121395468711853,
-0.8962816596031189,
-0.2508831024169922,
-0.6000862121582031,
-0.4281544089317322,
-0.6414533257484436,
0.43713024258613586,
-0.05741851404309273,
0.356454461812973,
-0.41201552748680115,
0.03357359394431114,
0.43822696805000305,
-0.08828467130661011,
0.6744676828384399,
0.6777489185333252,
-0.17012634873390198,
-0.6965951919555664,
0.6302875876426697,
-0.01457501482218504,
0.22224579751491547,
0.00029702854226343334,
0.13158951699733734,
-0.7062398195266724,
-0.870413064956665,
-0.4583325684070587,
0.3910510838031769,
-0.8657726049423218,
-0.3102569282054901,
-0.3191629648208618,
-0.13841655850410461,
-0.5971525311470032,
-0.04626866430044174,
-0.85239177942276,
-0.5281141996383667,
0.0982876643538475,
0.11078844964504242,
-0.08052384108304977,
1.1720247268676758,
0.07300024479627609,
-0.2778984606266022,
-0.5147750973701477,
0.22440789639949799,
0.29586657881736755,
0.9576789140701294,
-0.3206931948661804,
-0.37621843814849854,
-0.33808544278144836,
-0.45806989073753357,
-0.3759945333003998,
-0.3902745246887207,
0.14418035745620728,
0.29383552074432373,
0.9342561960220337,
0.39206546545028687,
-0.1628475785255432,
0.7777654528617859,
-0.6915724873542786,
0.5252244472503662,
0.35695502161979675,
-1.2247258424758911,
0.11913293600082397,
-0.38534581661224365,
0.49431875348091125,
0.6170274615287781,
0.573487401008606,
-0.3253679573535919,
-0.3237115144729614,
-0.5364354252815247,
-0.8074468970298767,
0.17071352899074554,
0.2682657837867737,
-0.09686020761728287,
0.21000607311725616,
0.4465964436531067,
0.1229357048869133,
0.45844927430152893,
-0.8049947619438171,
-0.062257397919893265,
-0.4000686705112457,
-0.3507985770702362,
-0.15414664149284363,
-0.07762084901332855,
0.08417893201112747,
-0.19180621206760406,
0.4294358491897583,
-0.18612682819366455,
0.20034728944301605,
-0.2141982614994049,
-0.013393690809607506,
-0.1357688456773758,
0.06993073970079422,
0.34139934182167053,
0.9288719296455383,
0.1427249163389206,
-0.0156404972076416,
0.2512815296649933,
-0.5062097311019897,
0.03353948891162872,
0.4059939980506897,
0.01959860324859619,
-0.1564655750989914,
0.38325685262680054,
0.6016673445701599,
0.5551038980484009,
-0.5647240877151489,
0.44228678941726685,
-0.13169023394584656,
-0.26305562257766724,
-0.6121854782104492,
0.20059648156166077,
-0.0342264361679554,
0.09753026068210602,
0.412354975938797,
-0.23129956424236298,
0.2921870946884155,
-0.6560470461845398,
0.22547850012779236,
0.560943067073822,
-0.26686081290245056,
-0.3901786506175995,
0.7667645812034607,
0.2851104140281677,
-0.013770082965493202,
0.4531439244747162,
-0.008282020688056946,
-0.6258127093315125,
0.5433275699615479,
0.5049879550933838,
0.9945282936096191,
-0.399318665266037,
-0.13655732572078705,
0.4923411011695862,
0.4298532009124756,
-0.0694160982966423,
0.3777575194835663,
-0.018477357923984528,
-0.4625488221645355,
-0.5914178490638733,
-0.9276645183563232,
-0.43113142251968384,
0.26962417364120483,
-0.46395909786224365,
0.49619466066360474,
-0.6420741677284241,
-0.17824098467826843,
0.09188023209571838,
0.11720611900091171,
-0.7006431221961975,
0.22413606941699982,
0.3148622512817383,
0.7952694296836853,
-0.49779587984085083,
0.7717879414558411,
0.6068174242973328,
0.02211989089846611,
-0.7861822247505188,
0.0947207510471344,
0.04581800103187561,
-0.7933151125907898,
0.8587585091590881,
0.09939417988061905,
-0.3900359570980072,
-0.15095402300357819,
-0.43431875109672546,
-1.1903514862060547,
1.2030583620071411,
0.394601047039032,
-0.7003321647644043,
-0.025632772594690323,
0.4078298509120941,
0.583501935005188,
-0.48913800716400146,
0.6012644171714783,
0.7934907674789429,
0.7529309988021851,
0.06717704236507416,
-1.2341660261154175,
0.1212456077337265,
-0.3112073242664337,
0.2827036678791046,
0.25068673491477966,
-0.7033138275146484,
0.9357708096504211,
-0.2148357629776001,
-0.02447156049311161,
0.17784073948860168,
0.8866236209869385,
0.16040723025798798,
-0.0821969211101532,
0.4200727641582489,
0.4197545051574707,
0.7615354061126709,
-0.26563140749931335,
0.8178792595863342,
-0.3820354640483856,
0.2899220287799835,
0.9990726709365845,
-0.5981281995773315,
0.6554362773895264,
0.15843303501605988,
-0.35905271768569946,
0.6053146719932556,
0.35226452350616455,
-0.24574564397335052,
0.08851370960474014,
0.6560839414596558,
-0.20006918907165527,
-0.19875815510749817,
0.5560876131057739,
-0.39337682723999023,
0.7061243057250977,
0.4498247802257538,
-0.10766714811325073,
-0.21445631980895996,
-0.3333751857280731,
0.20908942818641663,
-0.053496044129133224,
-0.20497076213359833,
0.4859524965286255,
0.028573304414749146,
-0.7986515760421753,
0.9337368011474609,
0.1963740885257721,
0.5630974173545837,
-0.7859167456626892,
0.027147991582751274,
-0.13387273252010345,
0.38225632905960083,
-0.21448595821857452,
-0.5204032063484192,
0.3098117411136627,
0.08187521249055862,
0.15410065650939941,
-0.3162583112716675,
0.41196808218955994,
-0.2831900119781494,
-0.5373558402061462,
0.19210952520370483,
0.19938313961029053,
0.1781075894832611,
0.29452595114707947,
-0.9182729721069336,
0.6198118329048157,
-0.25500279664993286,
-0.054046813398599625,
0.18691961467266083,
0.6613327264785767,
-0.13855411112308502,
0.8578632473945618,
0.580655574798584,
0.10840679705142975,
0.12053301185369492,
0.28235024213790894,
1.1545158624649048,
-0.7772512435913086,
-0.45789003372192383,
-0.8047950267791748,
0.09633778780698776,
0.004132091533392668,
-0.34021294116973877,
1.1477670669555664,
1.0913640260696411,
0.601328432559967,
0.10533081740140915,
1.0422765016555786,
-0.038247037678956985,
0.2157081514596939,
-0.49355801939964294,
0.5127213597297668,
-0.23765142261981964,
0.41121596097946167,
-0.5774176716804504,
-1.070003628730774,
-0.21501608192920685,
0.6843425631523132,
-0.5597137808799744,
0.5086037516593933,
0.9318658113479614,
0.30443841218948364,
-0.017136503010988235,
-0.12334490567445755,
0.4309714138507843,
0.5662966370582581,
0.4359270930290222,
0.4765048921108246,
0.874879777431488,
-0.3591530919075012,
0.7419633269309998,
-0.008902573958039284,
-0.5779696702957153,
0.022778773680329323,
-1.2253881692886353,
-0.8349001407623291,
-0.3961508572101593,
-0.3099544942378998,
-0.22038054466247559,
-0.12862835824489594,
0.5428559184074402,
0.6771692037582397,
-0.6098241209983826,
-0.5853988528251648,
-0.024690691381692886,
-0.2772408425807953,
0.014570374973118305,
-0.17165733873844147,
0.08667553216218948,
-0.5795936584472656,
-0.8175013065338135,
0.5430129766464233,
0.5845856666564941,
0.007495986297726631,
-1.022601842880249,
-0.32645493745803833,
0.45125749707221985,
0.0014995967503637075,
0.47632166743278503,
0.18864941596984863,
-0.3758266270160675,
0.1337682157754898,
0.07342896610498428,
0.0053172786720097065,
0.07388521730899811,
1.183885097503662,
-0.7483422160148621,
0.21385005116462708,
0.25272732973098755,
0.5192137360572815,
0.6357166767120361,
-0.02342945709824562,
1.0281060934066772,
-0.08271558582782745,
-0.14113833010196686,
0.5429918169975281,
0.3050830364227295,
0.46028047800064087,
-0.0936528667807579,
0.2767816185951233,
0.1808057576417923,
-0.73726886510849,
-0.5946479439735413,
0.30136239528656006,
-0.5832738876342773,
0.21838879585266113,
1.0687636137008667,
-0.15557613968849182,
-0.04080590605735779,
-0.20278383791446686,
0.3422611653804779,
-0.10635042935609818,
-0.2737976908683777,
0.7280062437057495,
0.753061056137085,
-0.25360381603240967,
-0.03298178315162659,
-0.8434059619903564,
0.9149012565612793,
0.3976868987083435,
-1.0518383979797363,
0.056780047714710236,
0.6242665648460388,
0.6641167402267456,
-0.24082991480827332,
0.7836722135543823,
-0.5385624170303345,
0.30487632751464844,
-0.2870217561721802,
0.07406704872846603,
0.013711043633520603,
-0.14698083698749542,
-0.4736531972885132,
-0.14102990925312042,
0.3998396396636963,
0.40207093954086304
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00318v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00318v1
|
KGLink: A column type annotation method that combines knowledge graph and pre-trained language model
| 2024-06-01T06:28:41
| 2024-06-01T06:28:41
|
Yubo Wang, Hao Xin, Lei Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The semantic annotation of tabular data plays a crucial role in various
downstream tasks. Previous research has proposed knowledge graph (KG)-based and
deep learning-based methods, each with its inherent limitations. KG-based
methods encounter difficulties annotating columns when there is no match for
column cells in the KG. Moreover, KG-based methods can provide multiple
predictions for one column, making it challenging to determine the semantic
type with the most suitable granularity for the dataset. This type granularity
issue limits their scalability.
On the other hand, deep learning-based methods face challenges related to the
valuable context missing issue. This occurs when the information within the
table is insufficient for determining the correct column type.
This paper presents KGLink, a method that combines WikiData KG information
with a pre-trained deep learning language model for table column annotation,
effectively addressing both type granularity and valuable context missing
issues. Through comprehensive experiments on widely used tabular datasets
encompassing numeric and string columns with varying type granularity, we
showcase the effectiveness and efficiency of KGLink. By leveraging the
strengths of KGLink, we successfully surmount challenges related to type
granularity and valuable context issues, establishing it as a robust solution
for the semantic annotation of tabular data.
|
[
-0.5233967304229736,
-0.7576124668121338,
0.29620277881622314,
0.07500538229942322,
-0.41692179441452026,
-0.0554695799946785,
0.05820303410291672,
-0.23779065907001495,
0.26088947057724,
0.5292584896087646,
-0.44225364923477173,
-0.8721774816513062,
-0.5275165438652039,
0.07124931365251541,
-0.281181275844574,
1.3146088123321533,
-0.2996445298194885,
-0.11757148057222366,
-0.7336143851280212,
-0.3480493724346161,
-0.7333884239196777,
-0.1314481943845749,
-0.23264528810977936,
-0.4559474587440491,
0.9275665283203125,
0.45139843225479126,
0.9973365664482117,
0.7312187552452087,
0.6091870069503784,
0.19142888486385345,
0.11512837558984756,
0.16666793823242188,
-0.3718644380569458,
0.07142570614814758,
0.16864684224128723,
-0.2954503297805786,
-0.6767399311065674,
-0.011934931389987469,
0.5235984921455383,
0.9496065378189087,
0.00959543976932764,
0.1503053605556488,
-0.19761760532855988,
1.015647530555725,
-0.6469203233718872,
0.6019923686981201,
-0.7526533603668213,
0.651538610458374,
-0.5159448385238647,
0.10102806985378265,
-0.1894291639328003,
-0.6791440844535828,
0.13253600895404816,
-0.8846215605735779,
-0.258793443441391,
0.13783696293830872,
0.6210376620292664,
0.4298899471759796,
-0.8853363990783691,
-0.3658420443534851,
-0.38883575797080994,
-0.009755413979291916,
-0.6418207883834839,
0.6290475726127625,
0.8040213584899902,
0.6052181124687195,
-0.2021038681268692,
-1.0690549612045288,
-0.883079469203949,
-0.642742395401001,
-0.763357400894165,
-0.14897994697093964,
0.5799627304077148,
0.06168831139802933,
0.23452696204185486,
0.021609431132674217,
-0.5131593346595764,
-0.11201945692300797,
-0.388200968503952,
-0.26839298009872437,
0.39171573519706726,
0.20063337683677673,
0.4984484910964966,
-0.24642565846443176,
-0.15920646488666534,
-0.09744089096784592,
-0.7610318660736084,
-0.03361388295888901,
0.35346874594688416,
0.49505195021629333,
-0.21757495403289795,
0.48249632120132446,
-0.5858575701713562,
1.1505323648452759,
-0.2546550929546356,
-0.14760765433311462,
0.46697962284088135,
-0.11919630318880081,
-0.20753343403339386,
0.35180696845054626,
0.9055134654045105,
0.04344058036804199,
0.21056853234767914,
-0.6056180000305176,
0.39716464281082153,
-0.15327385067939758,
0.31122487783432007,
-0.7523506879806519,
-0.6466620564460754,
0.06103499233722687,
-0.14278656244277954,
-0.5484751462936401,
-0.40267908573150635,
-0.6905429363250732,
-0.5603235363960266,
-0.381956547498703,
0.6732968091964722,
-0.30851900577545166,
-0.06629259884357452,
-0.46751129627227783,
0.22138309478759766,
-0.13169099390506744,
0.32384994626045227,
-1.0272198915481567,
-0.23204126954078674,
0.41379106044769287,
0.38042593002319336,
0.02270006760954857,
-0.32325807213783264,
-0.6017924547195435,
0.5611454844474792,
-0.40227875113487244,
0.6899252533912659,
-0.8111040592193604,
-0.30840423703193665,
0.14622963964939117,
-0.27545368671417236,
0.14003592729568481,
-0.3410540819168091,
0.7793706059455872,
-0.7890428900718689,
-0.10239822417497635,
-0.6211414933204651,
-0.5439313650131226,
-0.3480224311351776,
0.5021659135818481,
-0.8755409121513367,
1.1028975248336792,
0.42476922273635864,
-1.0705317258834839,
1.118139386177063,
-0.844189465045929,
-0.6537373065948486,
0.31008073687553406,
-0.28970929980278015,
-0.826779305934906,
-0.44797784090042114,
0.11966734379529953,
0.6230084300041199,
0.07069548219442368,
0.496084600687027,
-0.8471335172653198,
0.0197417251765728,
0.12986592948436737,
0.09668957442045212,
0.23095092177391052,
0.09749752283096313,
0.04401322826743126,
-0.029600057750940323,
-1.1118329763412476,
0.21948669850826263,
-0.18215779960155487,
-0.6661011576652527,
-0.16297271847724915,
0.027960682287812233,
-0.07925845682621002,
0.3393729329109192,
0.16412955522537231,
-0.34512192010879517,
0.4293144941329956,
0.21416030824184418,
0.18673256039619446,
0.3269457519054413,
-0.38205111026763916,
0.30398663878440857,
0.353581041097641,
0.07605016976594925,
0.2623573839664459,
0.07380937784910202,
0.42208921909332275,
-0.2419918179512024,
-0.6638079285621643,
-0.08865559101104736,
0.6160582900047302,
0.3139956295490265,
-0.9472216367721558,
0.11686193197965622,
-0.671088695526123,
-0.7360938787460327,
-0.38436493277549744,
0.18722306191921234,
0.3703792989253998,
1.2218512296676636,
0.6563926935195923,
-0.14596585929393768,
-0.45236626267433167,
-1.016418695449829,
-0.28230223059654236,
-0.08677267283201218,
0.3132905662059784,
0.6986832022666931,
0.493880957365036,
-0.34974604845046997,
1.3748362064361572,
-0.5120862126350403,
-0.47806480526924133,
-0.16576920449733734,
0.5525994300842285,
-0.005636303219944239,
0.46071657538414,
0.27448317408561707,
-1.2011950016021729,
-0.9211593866348267,
0.4132500886917114,
-0.9521998167037964,
-0.2471916526556015,
0.3182457685470581,
-0.06407426297664642,
0.02478446625173092,
0.34826698899269104,
-0.5546361804008484,
0.4987260103225708,
0.12378206104040146,
-0.3841753900051117,
0.6684611439704895,
-0.01931297779083252,
0.19413942098617554,
-0.9008221626281738,
0.34054625034332275,
-0.4787524938583374,
-0.11843837797641754,
-0.8397490978240967,
-0.3609509766101837,
0.408808171749115,
-0.2944168746471405,
-0.2619383633136749,
0.2190724015235901,
-0.07600128650665283,
-0.2908007502555847,
-0.03737993910908699,
0.1359434574842453,
-0.08739632368087769,
0.3274047076702118,
0.0839211717247963,
0.6560720801353455,
0.32071006298065186,
-0.5470521450042725,
0.5628031492233276,
0.6067972183227539,
-0.29961562156677246,
0.5619720220565796,
-0.21988306939601898,
-0.020909834653139114,
-0.448833703994751,
0.49730944633483887,
-0.8968485593795776,
-0.39183542132377625,
0.2605593800544739,
-0.4606630504131317,
0.5632339715957642,
-0.33817407488822937,
-0.38960132002830505,
-0.4071401059627533,
0.020752117037773132,
0.45967406034469604,
0.11006346344947815,
-0.4221659302711487,
0.8275063633918762,
0.1340622901916504,
0.050884272903203964,
-0.9851632714271545,
-0.6226598024368286,
0.1387391984462738,
-0.27729398012161255,
-0.6111326813697815,
0.3965334892272949,
0.20090901851654053,
0.24174530804157257,
0.2572278082370758,
-0.18546538054943085,
-0.42375728487968445,
0.11628420650959015,
0.43332093954086304,
0.1967930793762207,
-0.005173036362975836,
0.2482651025056839,
0.059871211647987366,
-0.28296178579330444,
0.012748177163302898,
-0.13412204384803772,
0.494902104139328,
0.09338261932134628,
-0.14392618834972382,
-0.38794398307800293,
0.07958734780550003,
0.3472655713558197,
-0.18630404770374298,
0.9055182337760925,
1.1256595849990845,
-0.0677679032087326,
-0.007244357373565435,
-0.4648691713809967,
0.228546142578125,
-0.4788404405117035,
0.622937798500061,
-0.4546954929828644,
-0.9455963373184204,
0.43868058919906616,
-0.15596115589141846,
-0.34562820196151733,
0.2962540090084076,
0.08695205301046371,
-0.2556247115135193,
0.31953608989715576,
0.41550296545028687,
-0.32055050134658813,
0.094191774725914,
-0.0706942081451416,
0.6175606846809387,
-0.770107626914978,
-0.6558979153633118,
-0.7159742712974548,
-0.2937023639678955,
-0.48414212465286255,
0.01797330006957054,
0.6124480962753296,
0.4358825087547302,
-0.436939001083374,
0.4950753152370453,
-0.29591915011405945,
0.26845312118530273,
0.4063858985900879,
0.01886090449988842,
0.10312175005674362,
0.036537837237119675,
-0.4794396758079529,
-0.015721669420599937,
-0.6089685559272766,
-0.0014727682573720813,
1.165945291519165,
-0.14405670762062073,
0.6218488216400146,
0.013203384354710579,
0.424107164144516,
0.6219445466995239,
0.6502141952514648,
-0.34138473868370056,
0.5767756104469299,
0.050824593752622604,
-0.6035740375518799,
-0.4525066018104553,
-0.8248535394668579,
-0.6747255325317383,
0.08669771999120712,
-0.6754819750785828,
-0.7808185815811157,
-0.3021181523799896,
0.39570319652557373,
0.0847405418753624,
0.2952612638473511,
-0.5770136117935181,
1.312894344329834,
0.16552650928497314,
-0.29502665996551514,
0.21283048391342163,
-0.8148068189620972,
0.3100351393222809,
-0.1416037678718567,
0.14038364589214325,
-0.08059430867433548,
0.2717127501964569,
0.7312609553337097,
-0.6396419405937195,
0.554068386554718,
-0.22288878262043,
0.10752715915441513,
0.30391883850097656,
0.11466598510742188,
0.888458788394928,
0.096491239964962,
0.19271034002304077,
-0.04060817137360573,
-0.3101159930229187,
-0.2561929225921631,
-0.7689662575721741,
0.5333291292190552,
-0.704849898815155,
-0.24145638942718506,
0.09495927393436432,
-0.8300603628158569,
-0.6149976253509521,
0.12788546085357666,
-0.032116640359163284,
0.6771977543830872,
0.3713449537754059,
0.4130079746246338,
0.4784102737903595,
-0.13085095584392548,
0.6107972264289856,
0.4092108905315399,
-0.11863234639167786,
-0.8520015478134155,
0.879811704158783,
0.42223817110061646,
-0.033660512417554855,
0.7364522218704224,
0.03769786283373833,
-0.5674976110458374,
-0.5190944671630859,
-0.6546410918235779,
-0.24654550850391388,
-0.8362473845481873,
-0.35517820715904236,
-0.8461870551109314,
-0.09644303470849991,
-0.43519243597984314,
-0.29203829169273376,
-0.14093686640262604,
-0.2751716673374176,
0.042146846652030945,
-0.34682950377464294,
0.6148799061775208,
0.4372921884059906,
0.17103812098503113,
0.2348952442407608,
-0.8095269799232483,
0.03144676238298416,
0.815791666507721,
0.6651415824890137,
0.3258410096168518,
0.07349243760108948,
-0.21617813408374786,
-0.3148449659347534,
-0.025112805888056755,
-0.8815269470214844,
0.0992508977651596,
-0.016537992283701897,
0.3827046751976013,
0.365115225315094,
-0.058974094688892365,
0.829484224319458,
-0.5700701475143433,
0.6002172231674194,
0.21614935994148254,
-0.7303655743598938,
0.30281513929367065,
-0.5564351677894592,
-0.07907693088054657,
0.8285045027732849,
0.7055981755256653,
-0.6194204092025757,
0.2796003818511963,
-0.09104233235120773,
-0.9117339253425598,
0.5447728633880615,
0.17396493256092072,
-0.24961712956428528,
0.09732770919799805,
0.4332219958305359,
0.26993516087532043,
0.4602780044078827,
-1.2455567121505737,
-0.4494156837463379,
-0.08658377826213837,
-0.28314563632011414,
0.17501014471054077,
-0.33212223649024963,
0.050707556307315826,
-0.23798714578151703,
0.6686354875564575,
-0.06609858572483063,
-0.03320020064711571,
0.084205262362957,
-0.3211323320865631,
0.1937611699104309,
0.21555624902248383,
0.4207102358341217,
0.619183361530304,
-0.30956435203552246,
0.07778141647577286,
0.44833558797836304,
-0.7600040435791016,
0.06216073036193848,
0.2452731728553772,
-0.40470990538597107,
-0.1159246489405632,
0.4247969388961792,
0.823114275932312,
0.039525777101516724,
-0.23696070909500122,
0.3555763065814972,
0.2859708368778229,
0.01091943308711052,
-0.3301135301589966,
-0.04024480655789375,
0.3097360134124756,
-0.09795118123292923,
0.18452632427215576,
-0.3612360656261444,
0.13141505420207977,
-0.2891688346862793,
0.2516329288482666,
0.6122252345085144,
-0.6152786016464233,
0.08635352551937103,
0.7917771935462952,
0.16934064030647278,
-0.2647002637386322,
0.5340015888214111,
-0.39021655917167664,
-0.44664034247398376,
0.5443183779716492,
0.3942122459411621,
0.4597284197807312,
0.1715267151594162,
0.443526953458786,
0.21290747821331024,
0.016873857006430626,
0.502200722694397,
0.002639749087393284,
-0.5116350650787354,
-0.45489180088043213,
-0.43692731857299805,
-0.9759128093719482,
-0.11676231771707535,
0.08800089359283447,
-0.38640087842941284,
0.14208440482616425,
-0.013308831490576267,
0.07979325205087662,
0.14389434456825256,
0.23208734393119812,
-0.6708994507789612,
0.5107035040855408,
0.11595012992620468,
0.9624088406562805,
-0.8528215885162354,
0.9638670682907104,
0.6460070610046387,
-0.5978599190711975,
-1.0023261308670044,
-0.42557358741760254,
-0.42076095938682556,
-0.5749241709709167,
1.2992315292358398,
0.16969378292560577,
0.37321123480796814,
-0.17141032218933105,
-0.23085874319076538,
-0.9889160990715027,
1.3794549703598022,
-0.024218861013650894,
-0.17704924941062927,
0.20748671889305115,
1.0497459173202515,
0.2171831727027893,
-0.294308066368103,
0.33669763803482056,
0.4344650208950043,
0.9006195068359375,
0.17152151465415955,
-0.7744261026382446,
0.20807282626628876,
0.02507372573018074,
0.10974159091711044,
0.6268901824951172,
-0.4062446057796478,
0.5691895484924316,
0.20365668833255768,
0.3961944580078125,
-0.5026553869247437,
0.7782928943634033,
-0.17327482998371124,
0.5313875675201416,
0.342838317155838,
1.3109540939331055,
0.5619468092918396,
-0.11070884019136429,
0.6404575109481812,
-0.034309644252061844,
0.42541852593421936,
1.1410049200057983,
-0.4737448990345001,
0.6101958155632019,
0.21118001639842987,
-0.4262489974498749,
0.6307743787765503,
0.3004927635192871,
0.05905242636799812,
0.7597272396087646,
0.19876115024089813,
-0.5425179600715637,
-0.08715891093015671,
-0.10749779641628265,
-0.6817238926887512,
0.17760194838047028,
0.3759097456932068,
-0.30003121495246887,
-0.6225337982177734,
-0.2723243534564972,
0.41683170199394226,
-0.2249847948551178,
-0.6388390064239502,
0.7147904634475708,
-0.2695499360561371,
-0.5484961867332458,
0.2757703363895416,
-0.3747485876083374,
0.25044262409210205,
-0.6967647671699524,
-0.11661100387573242,
-0.17381702363491058,
-0.3320530951023102,
-0.5249118804931641,
-0.5595736503601074,
0.21072985231876373,
-0.33835166692733765,
-0.12740066647529602,
0.3823202848434448,
0.9158061146736145,
-0.6164454221725464,
-0.3728901445865631,
0.05107714235782623,
0.09897205978631973,
-0.053042035549879074,
0.22191911935806274,
-0.3390403687953949,
-0.06033558025956154,
-0.12323939800262451,
-0.0990353524684906,
0.581775963306427,
0.4212898910045624,
0.1003752127289772,
0.9537815451622009,
0.7478352189064026,
-0.2836167812347412,
0.09201636165380478,
-0.07625438272953033,
1.0243115425109863,
-0.5194356441497803,
-0.44494307041168213,
-0.9377453923225403,
0.651005744934082,
-0.37732651829719543,
-0.26130208373069763,
0.3904963731765747,
0.528554379940033,
0.6258631348609924,
-0.25820544362068176,
0.6879400610923767,
-0.44755396246910095,
-0.04772014543414116,
-0.5089026093482971,
1.1422648429870605,
-0.33395060896873474,
-0.26531219482421875,
-0.42992445826530457,
-0.8316327333450317,
-0.4327194094657898,
0.2719172537326813,
-0.621026337146759,
0.16994383931159973,
0.7546164393424988,
0.6518025398254395,
-0.1713939756155014,
0.008031239733099937,
0.25546208024024963,
0.29630157351493835,
-0.008763470686972141,
0.4629794955253601,
0.40074318647384644,
-0.08947235345840454,
0.8491384387016296,
-0.24660465121269226,
0.12144877016544342,
-0.24821943044662476,
-1.2683336734771729,
-1.0782116651535034,
-0.7048810124397278,
-0.3110526502132416,
-0.3052249252796173,
0.05772765725851059,
0.6002064347267151,
0.855935275554657,
-0.48366546630859375,
0.29701685905456543,
-0.2900770902633667,
0.18611487746238708,
0.30560651421546936,
-0.22766736149787903,
0.900189220905304,
-0.6014871597290039,
0.08019138872623444,
-0.08224041014909744,
0.42012128233909607,
-0.039589717984199524,
0.0006346143782138824,
0.15425853431224823,
-0.11756773293018341,
-0.39053091406822205,
0.5517095923423767,
0.18024180829524994,
-0.35911113023757935,
-0.3438355028629303,
-0.733923077583313,
0.043776605278253555,
0.03158438950777054,
0.448946088552475,
-1.0552446842193604,
0.3451247811317444,
0.5059328079223633,
0.9578303098678589,
0.6198131442070007,
-0.007780653890222311,
0.14794306457042694,
-0.7107829451560974,
0.11032047867774963,
0.11296213418245316,
0.31820350885391235,
0.3285990357398987,
-0.39362815022468567,
0.5823710560798645,
0.14490576088428497,
-0.5742939710617065,
-0.6680282950401306,
0.4320908784866333,
-1.0444544553756714,
0.04256219416856766,
0.7549818158149719,
-0.3454742729663849,
-0.22628234326839447,
-0.05242137238383293,
-0.01650005206465721,
0.3439062833786011,
-0.14066925644874573,
1.1212363243103027,
0.6817505359649658,
0.02279561199247837,
0.08318888396024704,
-0.594257652759552,
0.9182758331298828,
0.2607766091823578,
-0.9702633619308472,
-0.1310550421476364,
0.3657512664794922,
0.27447837591171265,
0.18941055238246918,
0.39909616112709045,
-0.04801174998283386,
0.12764234840869904,
0.0962066799402237,
0.06884323805570602,
-0.5431254506111145,
-0.2795574367046356,
0.4455556273460388,
0.5847634077072144,
-0.17382119596004486,
0.03999072313308716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00314v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00314v2
|
CASE: Efficient Curricular Data Pre-training for Building Assistive Psychology Expert Models
| 2024-06-01T06:17:32
| 2024-06-16T10:33:34
|
Sarthak Harne, Monjoy Narayan Choudhury, Madhav Rao, TK Srikanth, Seema Mehrotra, Apoorva Vashisht, Aarushi Basu, Manjit Sodhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The limited availability of psychologists necessitates efficient
identification of individuals requiring urgent mental healthcare. This study
explores the use of Natural Language Processing (NLP) pipelines to analyze text
data from online mental health forums used for consultations. By analyzing
forum posts, these pipelines can flag users who may require immediate
professional attention. A crucial challenge in this domain is data privacy and
scarcity. To address this, we propose utilizing readily available curricular
texts used in institutes specializing in mental health for pre-training the NLP
pipelines. This helps us mimic the training process of a psychologist. Our work
presents CASE-BERT that flags potential mental health disorders based on forum
text. CASE-BERT demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methods,
achieving an f1 score of 0.91 for Depression and 0.88 for Anxiety, two of the
most commonly reported mental health disorders. Our code is publicly available.
|
[
-0.5873294472694397,
-0.8011342883110046,
0.6863768100738525,
0.2859077751636505,
0.22948135435581207,
0.17273658514022827,
-0.21697328984737396,
-0.4248756170272827,
0.2526263892650604,
0.41715145111083984,
-1.0792248249053955,
-0.5694060921669006,
-0.6586169004440308,
0.14567062258720398,
-0.4253758490085602,
1.153381109237671,
0.07005981355905533,
0.25044190883636475,
0.030920909717679024,
0.19193167984485626,
-0.14467541873455048,
-0.8145679235458374,
-1.0109049081802368,
0.25749489665031433,
0.4071502685546875,
0.18302728235721588,
0.389865517616272,
0.02255469374358654,
0.7134580016136169,
0.26619604229927063,
0.1953292042016983,
0.1135542243719101,
-0.44464200735092163,
0.05992455407977104,
-0.22857382893562317,
-0.12365241348743439,
-0.6235542297363281,
0.19115564227104187,
0.18449163436889648,
0.6513309478759766,
-0.29801055788993835,
0.30432355403900146,
0.07260294258594513,
0.5195124745368958,
-0.46386247873306274,
0.2424463927745819,
-0.5250640511512756,
0.33073729276657104,
-0.2717761695384979,
-0.14434121549129486,
-0.3491438925266266,
-0.33523309230804443,
0.2364782989025116,
-0.7795183062553406,
0.6131016612052917,
-0.08408524096012115,
0.5508829951286316,
0.35318833589553833,
0.034784771502017975,
-0.3415142893791199,
-0.42481082677841187,
0.6643524765968323,
-0.5614930987358093,
0.2743821442127228,
0.9808027744293213,
0.2884052097797394,
-0.21463648974895477,
-0.6596269607543945,
-0.45842844247817993,
0.14464551210403442,
-0.15741008520126343,
-0.005622423253953457,
-0.3048691153526306,
0.3581424355506897,
0.5474074482917786,
0.38251349329948425,
-0.426136314868927,
-0.06537649780511856,
-0.35591480135917664,
-0.2807614207267761,
0.7240982055664062,
0.19810649752616882,
0.3523307144641876,
-0.07633324712514877,
0.08455786854028702,
0.1448117196559906,
-0.09439735859632492,
0.06851502507925034,
0.27176758646965027,
0.19401130080223083,
-0.03215194493532181,
0.661047101020813,
0.051298320293426514,
0.6076881289482117,
0.2975621521472931,
-0.010765819810330868,
0.09776699542999268,
-0.13101840019226074,
-0.16451749205589294,
0.07348308712244034,
0.5962369441986084,
0.26288902759552,
0.126054584980011,
-0.2512267529964447,
0.019792189821600914,
0.07170566916465759,
0.6938204765319824,
-0.4583219289779663,
-0.5337691903114319,
0.282854825258255,
-0.47779956459999084,
0.14280113577842712,
-0.2742803990840912,
-0.7017140984535217,
-0.4590074419975281,
-0.5382297039031982,
0.12880727648735046,
-0.6035293936729431,
-0.15204040706157684,
0.00296909105964005,
0.12178178131580353,
-0.11918973177671432,
0.2195727825164795,
-0.8114292621612549,
0.4539869725704193,
0.7617859244346619,
0.8605147004127502,
-0.17913241684436798,
0.23596711456775665,
-0.7118194103240967,
-0.029651565477252007,
0.05663945525884628,
0.7189159393310547,
-0.5511479377746582,
-0.08177060633897781,
0.16099320352077484,
0.24646764993667603,
0.04444805905222893,
-0.0874490812420845,
0.7716774940490723,
-0.2610655426979065,
0.3742618262767792,
-0.23469187319278717,
-0.6998136639595032,
0.22686932981014252,
0.10762384533882141,
-0.5814308524131775,
0.9451164603233337,
0.43003717064857483,
-1.011276364326477,
0.2575224041938782,
-0.8164978623390198,
-0.3127117455005646,
0.26655957102775574,
-0.23951534926891327,
-0.09909573942422867,
-0.1397983729839325,
0.4776771366596222,
0.5622329711914062,
0.056699275970458984,
0.25240805745124817,
-0.3925020694732666,
-0.4410032033920288,
-0.020860960707068443,
-0.17197220027446747,
1.0572586059570312,
0.13508138060569763,
-0.2538337707519531,
-0.0020200475119054317,
-0.9306557178497314,
0.23470376431941986,
-0.4201626777648926,
-0.17471805214881897,
-0.6041584014892578,
0.07840486615896225,
0.24654722213745117,
0.3133171796798706,
-0.024868156760931015,
-0.3522554636001587,
-0.06046488881111145,
-0.5225067734718323,
0.20532561838626862,
0.7717658281326294,
0.044749002903699875,
0.20162218809127808,
-0.12440168112516403,
0.6878743171691895,
-0.3352566063404083,
0.3006219267845154,
0.20902283489704132,
-0.8592129945755005,
-0.5831586718559265,
-0.6695788502693176,
-0.024926742538809776,
0.5446840524673462,
-0.8003768920898438,
0.8210601210594177,
0.254337340593338,
-0.38806143403053284,
-1.0601850748062134,
0.07279550284147263,
0.2122882902622223,
0.6533524394035339,
0.5328468084335327,
-0.23695099353790283,
-0.7719812989234924,
-0.6705338954925537,
-0.26116669178009033,
0.017670800909399986,
-0.3913097679615021,
0.14091114699840546,
0.13212528824806213,
-0.432572603225708,
0.9993875622749329,
-0.6150524020195007,
-0.7738715410232544,
0.04321764037013054,
0.422990083694458,
0.028638208284974098,
0.33548876643180847,
0.4352028965950012,
-0.41376784443855286,
-0.48798519372940063,
-0.34205493330955505,
-0.7102824449539185,
-0.2620271146297455,
0.08887141942977905,
-0.3428231179714203,
0.1210193857550621,
0.24443578720092773,
-0.4216662049293518,
0.47249260544776917,
0.39364346861839294,
-0.39160633087158203,
0.21388475596904755,
-0.2904178500175476,
0.08278178423643112,
-0.7619086503982544,
0.15438488125801086,
0.22134295105934143,
-0.16902975738048553,
-0.5549705028533936,
-0.06477227061986923,
-0.30618155002593994,
-0.2522415816783905,
-0.07995301485061646,
0.21156375110149384,
-0.18097029626369476,
0.31059756875038147,
-0.05205731838941574,
0.12478755414485931,
-0.3968173563480377,
0.4109308123588562,
0.3058544099330902,
0.5115063190460205,
0.5214974880218506,
-0.2972671687602997,
0.1612986922264099,
0.3187938332557678,
-0.4114391505718231,
0.7297923564910889,
-0.15140829980373383,
0.31865447759628296,
-0.2290981411933899,
0.05317343771457672,
-0.6816174983978271,
-0.34027978777885437,
0.2951880693435669,
-0.23840931057929993,
0.1607046276330948,
0.09471876174211502,
-0.3770575523376465,
-0.4437965154647827,
-0.19474457204341888,
-0.07530157268047333,
0.13126568496227264,
-0.15425440669059753,
0.12462827563285828,
0.7760269641876221,
-0.2316717505455017,
-0.6299190521240234,
-0.32965347170829773,
-0.13193313777446747,
-0.12198231369256973,
-0.13937342166900635,
0.2986917495727539,
-0.21800538897514343,
-0.1654052585363388,
0.07320266216993332,
0.027663541957736015,
-0.6858649253845215,
0.21675367653369904,
0.37548258900642395,
0.2203502207994461,
-0.03462539240717888,
0.3430749773979187,
0.1394575834274292,
-0.05136426165699959,
0.5313180088996887,
0.15490010380744934,
0.3831769824028015,
-0.1578797698020935,
-0.3519914448261261,
-0.49757981300354004,
0.8688751459121704,
0.06798393279314041,
-0.00006450637738453224,
0.7331622242927551,
0.7649367451667786,
-0.7688663601875305,
-0.05441944673657417,
-0.7000534534454346,
-0.3752444386482239,
-0.4655827283859253,
0.3071994185447693,
0.12216085195541382,
-0.851460337638855,
0.1646173596382141,
0.3210349678993225,
0.16276447474956512,
0.1435481309890747,
0.2537522315979004,
-0.3439145088195801,
1.191965103149414,
0.8314911127090454,
-0.11140908300876617,
0.38647422194480896,
0.044430192559957504,
0.6697346568107605,
-0.337613046169281,
-0.04918382316827774,
-0.5144243836402893,
-0.14662085473537445,
-0.5159583687782288,
-0.4079226553440094,
0.2987731099128723,
-0.11202183365821838,
-0.21127568185329437,
0.20716916024684906,
-0.9838367700576782,
0.23500092327594757,
0.4384115934371948,
0.40417346358299255,
0.3201463520526886,
0.23369814455509186,
0.04772224649786949,
-0.7415310144424438,
-0.5295042991638184,
-0.532233476638794,
1.0721083879470825,
0.32251954078674316,
0.4513726234436035,
-0.09920234233140945,
0.5345266461372375,
0.46747085452079773,
0.9509103298187256,
-0.7341663241386414,
0.5023353695869446,
-0.08458962291479111,
-0.836325466632843,
-0.3500731885433197,
-0.21463485062122345,
-0.7324989438056946,
-0.23901546001434326,
-0.5616010427474976,
-0.8041618466377258,
-0.10127367079257965,
-0.026905789971351624,
-0.4765283167362213,
0.15983141958713531,
-0.7049357295036316,
0.6492666602134705,
-0.2508903741836548,
-0.15593987703323364,
-0.2666683495044708,
-0.764975905418396,
0.30914944410324097,
-0.5613940954208374,
0.35023772716522217,
-0.25704243779182434,
0.2372216135263443,
0.9955933094024658,
-0.3736931085586548,
0.675242006778717,
-0.26246708631515503,
0.02684894949197769,
0.07046857476234436,
-0.3645894229412079,
-0.14465974271297455,
0.30063125491142273,
-0.16417767107486725,
-0.1317557692527771,
0.3484082520008087,
-0.3973158597946167,
-0.5399037599563599,
0.48862430453300476,
-0.8446529507637024,
-0.7006786465644836,
-0.4929468631744385,
-0.4400859475135803,
-0.6930810213088989,
0.2333303838968277,
0.1276760846376419,
0.21927043795585632,
-0.02231014147400856,
-0.05334237962961197,
0.7641661763191223,
-0.13822153210639954,
0.2542017102241516,
0.7433855533599854,
0.016335520893335342,
-0.021377531811594963,
0.6395263075828552,
0.22291435301303864,
-0.3479836583137512,
0.1708172857761383,
-0.06767737120389938,
-0.1963581144809723,
-0.18224017322063446,
0.012800528667867184,
0.2298305183649063,
-0.6837076544761658,
-0.11197816580533981,
-0.8809893131256104,
-0.520188570022583,
-0.502254068851471,
-0.3579568564891815,
-0.16271822154521942,
-0.20274414122104645,
-0.4818757176399231,
-0.2795354127883911,
0.5475375056266785,
0.6173118352890015,
-0.07151545584201813,
0.19064752757549286,
-0.7368281483650208,
0.3850630521774292,
0.32834863662719727,
0.5703068971633911,
0.052662141621112823,
-0.10198283195495605,
-0.1384134739637375,
-0.07516291737556458,
-0.3168222904205322,
-1.0356416702270508,
0.33914732933044434,
0.2610245645046234,
0.7782678604125977,
0.5995256304740906,
0.5287943482398987,
0.9221572279930115,
-0.3103139400482178,
0.5746660828590393,
0.14836181700229645,
-0.8055611848831177,
0.818392276763916,
-0.1720438152551651,
-0.00793015118688345,
1.0098193883895874,
1.1592589616775513,
-0.4413037896156311,
-0.7879543304443359,
-0.7756306529045105,
-0.8835552334785461,
0.9411682486534119,
0.1489371657371521,
0.09041642397642136,
-0.3838846683502197,
0.3945111632347107,
0.11271337419748306,
0.2913616895675659,
-0.5394889116287231,
-0.3628486096858978,
-0.1013655811548233,
-0.39726582169532776,
0.06946635246276855,
-0.22284512221813202,
-0.4053250253200531,
-0.5667563676834106,
0.5710412859916687,
-0.05520299822092056,
0.5664713978767395,
0.4240637421607971,
0.08026119321584702,
0.10618408024311066,
0.12534581124782562,
0.08992050588130951,
0.618388831615448,
-0.45111411809921265,
0.10424984991550446,
0.007264066021889448,
-0.8440685272216797,
0.004084936808794737,
0.27109089493751526,
0.3200801610946655,
0.25582996010780334,
0.09846441447734833,
0.22011317312717438,
0.32836994528770447,
-0.9458343982696533,
0.5968272686004639,
-0.35660502314567566,
-0.06751569360494614,
-0.4674513041973114,
0.05706324055790901,
-0.06279695779085159,
0.06294815242290497,
0.4132724702358246,
-0.0838831290602684,
0.35126829147338867,
-0.42257601022720337,
0.4538232088088989,
0.24980893731117249,
-0.6030179858207703,
-0.29769131541252136,
0.5143884420394897,
0.19699041545391083,
-0.62971031665802,
0.9038577675819397,
-0.21729636192321777,
-0.06201905012130737,
0.1908474862575531,
0.3467731773853302,
0.5924155712127686,
-0.2136145830154419,
0.4427603483200073,
0.3604835271835327,
0.12562306225299835,
-0.0602424331009388,
0.40577536821365356,
-0.2059141844511032,
-0.41646984219551086,
-0.43652382493019104,
-0.5210028290748596,
-0.51433265209198,
0.4159322679042816,
-0.9923340678215027,
0.4165594279766083,
-0.7367233037948608,
-0.610912561416626,
-0.0032058749347925186,
0.07317563891410828,
-0.839227020740509,
0.4289856255054474,
0.22086340188980103,
0.7161862850189209,
-0.853822648525238,
0.8501529097557068,
0.9192618727684021,
-0.12945644557476044,
-0.8075748682022095,
-0.1687587946653366,
0.08604174852371216,
-0.4156402051448822,
0.294072687625885,
0.2556653916835785,
0.15283767879009247,
-0.11140520870685577,
-0.2970171570777893,
-0.5882574319839478,
0.5862405300140381,
0.41184210777282715,
-0.49869462847709656,
-0.4264901280403137,
0.013500754721462727,
0.9517999291419983,
-0.2255292683839798,
0.4604160487651825,
0.5224084854125977,
0.22811923921108246,
-0.49076274037361145,
-0.7096676826477051,
-0.024498341605067253,
-0.45744025707244873,
-0.4053361713886261,
-0.16462673246860504,
-0.15626047551631927,
0.45569244027137756,
0.052930720150470734,
-0.3222637474536896,
-0.2243422269821167,
0.4201844334602356,
0.3190404772758484,
0.30925214290618896,
0.3181135654449463,
0.33615928888320923,
1.2913790941238403,
-0.018679281696677208,
0.7247506380081177,
-0.3819158673286438,
0.43290749192237854,
1.1299158334732056,
-0.10296350717544556,
0.8672129511833191,
0.49657338857650757,
-0.42799657583236694,
0.4106810688972473,
0.5843314528465271,
-0.010940761305391788,
0.5519570708274841,
0.11828155070543289,
-0.47416558861732483,
-0.23164589703083038,
-0.10451745241880417,
-0.40741628408432007,
0.19041089713573456,
0.6116296648979187,
-0.3108545243740082,
-0.14436395466327667,
0.12208336591720581,
0.09408341348171234,
0.27160021662712097,
-0.2984688878059387,
0.4762135148048401,
0.20903229713439941,
-0.5782460570335388,
0.10849905759096146,
-0.12648752331733704,
0.682378888130188,
-0.5725304484367371,
-0.019829662516713142,
0.044708698987960815,
0.10341481119394302,
-0.37325191497802734,
-0.6982405185699463,
0.6873214244842529,
0.28608226776123047,
-0.3249744474887848,
-0.4913496673107147,
0.7891491055488586,
-0.13344232738018036,
-0.685364842414856,
0.3159753382205963,
0.6375424265861511,
0.30705612897872925,
0.02498282864689827,
-0.6906975507736206,
-0.516308069229126,
-0.27057012915611267,
-0.1366184949874878,
0.5493152737617493,
0.4336957335472107,
-0.12763552367687225,
0.48726439476013184,
0.5288244485855103,
0.2234342396259308,
-0.04197824373841286,
-0.01936161145567894,
0.7096869945526123,
-0.31256037950515747,
-0.4846937358379364,
-0.45593345165252686,
0.2613164484500885,
-0.4528302550315857,
-0.46620386838912964,
0.6665422320365906,
0.23897889256477356,
0.696747362613678,
-0.01955247111618519,
0.7358150482177734,
-0.17829552292823792,
0.7481500506401062,
-0.11180035769939423,
1.0934127569198608,
-0.269136905670166,
0.18570931255817413,
-0.3705330193042755,
-0.485201358795166,
-0.3619067668914795,
1.0086745023727417,
-0.5013870596885681,
-0.32153016328811646,
0.7658808827400208,
0.516674280166626,
0.13742047548294067,
0.3397568166255951,
-0.061027511954307556,
-0.08391711860895157,
0.28120142221450806,
0.5499845743179321,
0.5628913640975952,
-0.1593455672264099,
0.15867610275745392,
-0.5348312854766846,
-0.28687354922294617,
0.031421106308698654,
-0.7984426617622375,
-1.2298953533172607,
-0.5252639055252075,
-0.5105016827583313,
-0.22870247066020966,
0.09357554465532303,
1.0328291654586792,
0.6848929524421692,
-0.9381456971168518,
0.1664462834596634,
0.00604336429387331,
0.09807776659727097,
-0.18834851682186127,
-0.3082977831363678,
0.4076516628265381,
-0.359501451253891,
-0.43692564964294434,
0.18340320885181427,
0.019588865339756012,
-0.2434535175561905,
-0.32431358098983765,
0.27958834171295166,
-0.3540726602077484,
-0.10960259288549423,
0.48056110739707947,
0.11785809695720673,
-0.5126935243606567,
-0.20926982164382935,
0.051342520862817764,
-0.2360098510980606,
-0.08431494235992432,
0.8429452180862427,
-0.761890709400177,
0.4957663118839264,
0.13515563309192657,
0.812968909740448,
0.1685725301504135,
-0.05099362134933472,
0.5565623044967651,
-0.8165856599807739,
0.08791106939315796,
0.44127926230430603,
0.13232307136058807,
0.2988901138305664,
-0.6892856359481812,
0.521554172039032,
0.18492397665977478,
-0.3574150502681732,
-0.8809422850608826,
-0.3212505280971527,
-0.9004834890365601,
-0.18236449360847473,
0.6864404678344727,
-0.5947584509849548,
0.002298726001754403,
-0.7410767674446106,
-0.4494571387767792,
0.30685514211654663,
-0.3620728850364685,
1.3020744323730469,
0.9605419039726257,
-0.3250671625137329,
-0.24502338469028473,
-0.8910927176475525,
0.9375786185264587,
0.3457723557949066,
-0.8331595659255981,
-0.31672757863998413,
0.1336444467306137,
0.20710475742816925,
0.020078692585229874,
1.057692527770996,
0.014100226573646069,
0.2615916132926941,
-0.35699883103370667,
-0.08551780879497528,
0.1827518790960312,
0.012740333564579487,
-0.05266262963414192,
0.32459697127342224,
-0.2922198474407196,
0.30951204895973206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00303v1
|
Multi-Dimensional Optimization for Text Summarization via Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-06-01T05:15:12
| 2024-06-01T05:15:12
|
Sangwon Ryu, Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee, Jungseul Ok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evaluation of summary quality encompasses diverse dimensions such as
consistency, coherence, relevance, and fluency. However, existing summarization
methods often target a specific dimension, facing challenges in generating
well-balanced summaries across multiple dimensions. In this paper, we propose
multi-objective reinforcement learning tailored to generate balanced summaries
across all four dimensions. We introduce two multi-dimensional optimization
(MDO) strategies for adaptive learning: 1) MDO_min, rewarding the current
lowest dimension score, and 2) MDO_pro, optimizing multiple dimensions similar
to multi-task learning, resolves conflicting gradients across dimensions
through gradient projection. Unlike prior ROUGE-based rewards relying on
reference summaries, we use a QA-based reward model that aligns with human
preferences. Further, we discover the capability to regulate the length of
summaries by adjusting the discount factor, seeking the generation of concise
yet informative summaries that encapsulate crucial points. Our approach
achieved substantial performance gains compared to baseline models on
representative summarization datasets, particularly in the overlooked
dimensions.
|
[
-0.35061508417129517,
-0.3478121757507324,
0.6304978728294373,
0.28483378887176514,
-0.44064316153526306,
0.25226029753685,
-0.05484602600336075,
0.058421604335308075,
0.4486846625804901,
0.3609149158000946,
-0.6049008965492249,
-0.37777721881866455,
-0.6731804609298706,
0.19074875116348267,
0.3894783556461334,
1.5013402700424194,
-0.24810636043548584,
-0.23740951716899872,
-0.4222535789012909,
-0.4615030586719513,
-0.5408938527107239,
-0.4028365910053253,
-0.6313040852546692,
-0.2060164511203766,
0.7933940887451172,
0.6687489748001099,
0.09046734124422073,
0.6658884286880493,
0.33474764227867126,
0.3859650790691376,
0.04987182840704918,
0.8097901940345764,
-0.5863903164863586,
0.14884178340435028,
-0.043784257024526596,
-0.29479122161865234,
-0.5469784736633301,
0.20170395076274872,
0.7094300389289856,
0.29765161871910095,
-0.3373579978942871,
0.048246752470731735,
0.2161872237920761,
1.0188367366790771,
-0.9110720753669739,
0.2337544858455658,
-0.2620513439178467,
0.14996999502182007,
0.3427528142929077,
-0.5947091579437256,
-0.05121781304478645,
-0.5195977091789246,
0.01922602951526642,
-0.9810650944709778,
-0.04409509897232056,
-0.1720307469367981,
0.5899465680122375,
0.3310987651348114,
-0.7446595430374146,
-0.5213891267776489,
-0.5608224272727966,
1.1141798496246338,
-0.4555191397666931,
-0.06112776696681976,
0.1575598567724228,
0.2575758397579193,
0.3480066955089569,
-0.3593020737171173,
-0.2419104427099228,
-0.0015658217016607523,
0.05158289149403572,
0.6762363910675049,
0.039481647312641144,
-0.02125757932662964,
-0.11398806422948837,
0.16994094848632812,
-0.5027384757995605,
0.004660480655729771,
-0.5217493176460266,
-0.06943543255329132,
0.8196492791175842,
0.362870454788208,
-0.023053213953971863,
-0.18173359334468842,
-0.40672630071640015,
-0.42674440145492554,
0.1593257337808609,
0.5542802810668945,
0.42263251543045044,
0.2438582330942154,
-0.16999125480651855,
0.4019419550895691,
-0.21329061686992645,
0.2092844843864441,
0.16540271043777466,
-0.7957351803779602,
0.34389668703079224,
-0.4821993112564087,
0.11703662574291229,
0.08950155973434448,
0.6034167408943176,
0.768820583820343,
-0.13778512179851532,
0.05189858749508858,
-0.2556150257587433,
-0.26255035400390625,
0.6405901312828064,
-0.7629740238189697,
-0.010814010165631771,
0.3353208601474762,
-0.6897116899490356,
-0.46832022070884705,
-0.03102716989815235,
-0.8854640126228333,
-0.2950403094291687,
-0.6269791126251221,
0.5435894727706909,
-0.45828163623809814,
0.030885785818099976,
0.19820980727672577,
-0.46110278367996216,
-0.38281649351119995,
0.32835692167282104,
-1.074862003326416,
0.18831151723861694,
0.2297203540802002,
0.9895783066749573,
-0.12286743521690369,
-0.6227167844772339,
-0.8251882195472717,
0.3554609715938568,
-0.3280862867832184,
0.7663017511367798,
-0.34294387698173523,
-0.3268197178840637,
-0.20290544629096985,
-0.5673059821128845,
-0.06444888561964035,
-0.3222199082374573,
0.44497159123420715,
-0.12831959128379822,
0.47182607650756836,
-0.3990597128868103,
-0.18600432574748993,
-0.42014095187187195,
0.39642125368118286,
-0.47453975677490234,
0.639841616153717,
0.13660773634910583,
-0.693443238735199,
0.3944219648838043,
-0.5834125876426697,
-0.5747103095054626,
-0.5881158709526062,
0.13385678827762604,
-0.8799698948860168,
0.44764140248298645,
0.5887807607650757,
0.47654375433921814,
0.2432558238506317,
0.007335763890296221,
0.06616444140672684,
-0.07867901772260666,
-0.048418425023555756,
-0.0929528996348381,
0.2397911101579666,
0.20700788497924805,
0.013582956977188587,
0.5991724133491516,
-0.8205408453941345,
-0.17829370498657227,
0.04652974754571915,
-0.604248583316803,
-0.4536627233028412,
0.20338980853557587,
-0.2824462652206421,
0.21012847125530243,
0.1809583604335785,
-0.186340793967247,
0.27173537015914917,
-0.17584475874900818,
0.11732591688632965,
0.8135242462158203,
0.3360515236854553,
0.5455902814865112,
-0.77192223072052,
0.7245809435844421,
0.3831959068775177,
0.21077248454093933,
-0.3935895562171936,
0.19335241615772247,
-0.35434070229530334,
-0.579814076423645,
0.03741873800754547,
0.47721418738365173,
-1.079453468322754,
0.22845984995365143,
-0.18407998979091644,
-0.3526526987552643,
-0.20004689693450928,
0.03887297213077545,
0.5136299729347229,
0.33500009775161743,
0.5847482681274414,
-0.27658089995384216,
-0.2533058226108551,
-0.7966750860214233,
-0.3500162363052368,
-0.018928151577711105,
-0.11749164015054703,
0.36926689743995667,
0.41958197951316833,
0.08757957071065903,
0.3713630437850952,
-0.7496867775917053,
-0.7282081246376038,
-0.5691971778869629,
0.3552112281322479,
0.011782001703977585,
0.22233480215072632,
0.805741012096405,
-0.6784871816635132,
-0.3755226731300354,
-0.12355551868677139,
-0.7028176188468933,
0.12657485902309418,
-0.6960611343383789,
0.09666279703378677,
-0.1207369938492775,
0.29389137029647827,
-0.2214437872171402,
-0.05184449255466461,
0.48417484760284424,
0.02446398325264454,
0.6554111838340759,
-0.8365597724914551,
0.2878066599369049,
-1.226552963256836,
-0.13509535789489746,
0.2160705327987671,
-0.2472134679555893,
-0.347894549369812,
-0.09543554484844208,
0.23871006071567535,
-0.06793152540922165,
0.021087007597088814,
0.31661996245384216,
-0.2773096561431885,
0.17972715198993683,
-0.4864942133426666,
0.49469679594039917,
0.21742837131023407,
0.9232173562049866,
-0.13782235980033875,
0.5155379772186279,
0.18368233740329742,
-0.851952075958252,
0.17707571387290955,
0.34859997034072876,
0.08903218805789948,
0.935562252998352,
-0.551964282989502,
-0.32507026195526123,
-0.7060539126396179,
0.39246630668640137,
-0.6639057397842407,
-0.08394638448953629,
0.034121107310056686,
-0.5103991031646729,
0.24405205249786377,
0.47904881834983826,
0.10159514099359512,
0.06710656732320786,
-1.0917012691497803,
0.36724853515625,
0.023809565231204033,
-0.5745859742164612,
0.9073064923286438,
0.4883502721786499,
-0.3929922878742218,
-0.8669203519821167,
-0.06221707537770271,
-0.07916675508022308,
-0.32871079444885254,
-0.06981775164604187,
0.397278755903244,
-0.04988493025302887,
0.02816375158727169,
-0.1377618908882141,
-0.267320841550827,
0.33391237258911133,
0.20264223217964172,
-0.02428719960153103,
-0.013383535668253899,
0.17054377496242523,
0.004917148966342211,
0.6003076434135437,
-0.2444835752248764,
0.02970658242702484,
-0.38972732424736023,
-0.006883408408612013,
0.12088746577501297,
0.15657855570316315,
-0.4174301326274872,
0.5978749990463257,
0.4132586419582367,
-0.46504947543144226,
0.6982610821723938,
0.630277693271637,
-0.2054423689842224,
-0.4964168071746826,
-0.09105534851551056,
-0.011178805492818356,
-0.3787965774536133,
0.6084714531898499,
-0.47135472297668457,
-0.7079271078109741,
0.4736967980861664,
-0.1026764065027237,
0.3706604540348053,
0.44034796953201294,
0.510063111782074,
-0.15453489124774933,
1.095263957977295,
0.7479696273803711,
-0.178462952375412,
0.5669847130775452,
-0.19121061265468597,
0.18472787737846375,
-0.8402612805366516,
-0.5053980350494385,
-0.4949125349521637,
-0.4567487835884094,
-0.4180079996585846,
-0.18395459651947021,
0.7643101215362549,
0.3180506229400635,
-0.14114120602607727,
-0.024860257282853127,
-0.3833717107772827,
0.5739051103591919,
0.7995507717132568,
0.2245626002550125,
0.3015311360359192,
-0.13132967054843903,
-0.26885679364204407,
0.10397279262542725,
-0.6981472373008728,
-0.26501989364624023,
0.8922379612922668,
0.20533344149589539,
0.46689531207084656,
0.26818934082984924,
0.7830448150634766,
0.28722769021987915,
0.0025090931449085474,
-0.4265647530555725,
0.05944203585386276,
-0.26151081919670105,
0.20095528662204742,
-0.5833700895309448,
-0.8582026958465576,
-0.7405232787132263,
0.6642458438873291,
-0.3354303240776062,
-0.4211236834526062,
0.19369100034236908,
0.12455741316080093,
-0.46100112795829773,
0.24067938327789307,
-0.5141938328742981,
0.7432212829589844,
-0.3372581899166107,
-0.025699801743030548,
-0.4688727855682373,
-0.5162643790245056,
0.570878267288208,
0.0566251315176487,
0.27000078558921814,
-0.06028265878558159,
-0.21964313089847565,
0.5276012420654297,
-0.11733920872211456,
0.4186573922634125,
-0.10569235682487488,
0.13806496560573578,
-0.0892501175403595,
-0.06807468831539154,
0.3276727497577667,
0.39947766065597534,
0.19418127834796906,
-0.27558016777038574,
0.047912973910570145,
-0.6779085397720337,
-0.5146415829658508,
0.4665299952030182,
-0.9717598557472229,
-0.16365161538124084,
-0.6220787167549133,
-0.8325169086456299,
-0.2243989109992981,
0.04408682510256767,
0.09969375282526016,
0.4842873215675354,
-0.25288864970207214,
0.004305430222302675,
0.45901259779930115,
-0.5583434104919434,
0.5519184470176697,
0.2485501915216446,
0.06480450928211212,
-0.8281942009925842,
1.3619377613067627,
-0.21094197034835815,
0.18927060067653656,
0.6274663209915161,
0.2787066698074341,
-0.2568843364715576,
-0.7409774661064148,
-0.44057294726371765,
0.19166047871112823,
-0.46994245052337646,
-0.4176121950149536,
-0.8136308789253235,
0.05089510977268219,
-0.17091701924800873,
-0.4083046615123749,
-0.21641378104686737,
-0.283794641494751,
-0.3497167229652405,
-0.22004485130310059,
-0.13947837054729462,
0.731214702129364,
-0.3714718520641327,
0.18273594975471497,
-0.9080803394317627,
0.7196800708770752,
0.38383957743644714,
0.1516881287097931,
0.21197253465652466,
-0.3333008885383606,
-0.5220722556114197,
-0.026511237025260925,
-0.8697388768196106,
-0.5552944540977478,
0.5676249861717224,
0.29494109749794006,
0.5380458235740662,
0.5229091048240662,
0.18024936318397522,
0.343984991312027,
-0.45067691802978516,
0.6591949462890625,
0.5682500600814819,
-0.9358664155006409,
0.48645302653312683,
-0.39841553568840027,
0.5072629451751709,
0.5004597902297974,
0.529127836227417,
-0.5516344904899597,
-0.4561232924461365,
-0.2586294710636139,
-0.772553026676178,
0.7497727870941162,
0.05188947170972824,
0.2043120115995407,
0.13195514678955078,
0.44349774718284607,
0.17107349634170532,
0.30388346314430237,
-0.6036247611045837,
-0.1948143094778061,
-0.6259040236473083,
-0.3395242393016815,
-0.47904932498931885,
-0.3895358145236969,
-0.2021820992231369,
0.1194489598274231,
0.6591930389404297,
-0.5046918392181396,
-0.12329867482185364,
0.11472395807504654,
-0.12607090175151825,
0.1233515664935112,
0.10684605687856674,
1.1733022928237915,
0.8972749710083008,
-0.18388614058494568,
-0.03496760129928589,
0.14049860835075378,
-0.31610360741615295,
0.22890973091125488,
0.02533288486301899,
0.07644302397966385,
-0.18151096999645233,
0.5030587315559387,
0.9827892184257507,
0.0445852167904377,
-0.5330802202224731,
0.5102336406707764,
-0.30487310886383057,
-0.499590128660202,
0.13843859732151031,
0.04702715948224068,
-0.15097495913505554,
0.47834691405296326,
0.4029894769191742,
0.14318625628948212,
0.20875978469848633,
-0.4245007038116455,
0.010572848841547966,
0.2069316953420639,
-0.23938606679439545,
-0.13262861967086792,
0.9279471039772034,
0.17407117784023285,
-0.010755781084299088,
0.3967888355255127,
-0.20102164149284363,
-0.4553448259830475,
0.48368391394615173,
0.25064554810523987,
0.7104032039642334,
-0.23653742671012878,
0.803950846195221,
0.7285777926445007,
0.3578118085861206,
0.0641261488199234,
0.21926026046276093,
-0.08779677748680115,
-0.5857923030853271,
-0.32323482632637024,
-0.5013959407806396,
-0.42792078852653503,
-0.22518399357795715,
-0.6342099905014038,
-0.14767605066299438,
-0.40924206376075745,
0.16315822303295135,
0.12354324012994766,
0.2693653702735901,
-0.11718691140413284,
0.14662663638591766,
-0.18964596092700958,
0.42514386773109436,
-0.7452473640441895,
0.2134060263633728,
0.3467942476272583,
-0.6976290345191956,
-0.33414289355278015,
-0.1085192859172821,
0.17348361015319824,
-0.2751576602458954,
0.12076541781425476,
0.02948928251862526,
-0.10462576150894165,
-0.2771517336368561,
0.03937095031142235,
-0.625760555267334,
1.1246644258499146,
0.1404256820678711,
-0.12197574228048325,
-0.059421975165605545,
-0.19756871461868286,
0.4954761266708374,
-0.39716970920562744,
0.14477397501468658,
0.33522191643714905,
0.31977805495262146,
-0.25959476828575134,
-0.5127206444740295,
-0.14305932819843292,
0.04878973588347435,
0.25947001576423645,
0.25967851281166077,
-0.8444302678108215,
0.7566026449203491,
-0.5243222117424011,
0.12762528657913208,
-0.14898964762687683,
0.8073311448097229,
0.41562044620513916,
0.340543657541275,
0.23454461991786957,
0.4992433190345764,
0.6935407519340515,
0.1038840115070343,
1.2392456531524658,
-0.017929458990693092,
0.2427404522895813,
0.9514028429985046,
0.08500874787569046,
0.3986037075519562,
0.2744382917881012,
0.05551522970199585,
0.30672362446784973,
0.6623992919921875,
0.2575998604297638,
0.8274339437484741,
0.13891777396202087,
-0.09101011604070663,
0.052059054374694824,
-0.06991316378116608,
-0.03623182699084282,
0.3425782322883606,
0.09374529123306274,
-0.04307291656732559,
-0.32254159450531006,
0.29707565903663635,
-0.26712626218795776,
0.5642895698547363,
-0.4389566481113434,
1.1680833101272583,
-0.0585450679063797,
-0.6348223090171814,
0.14895637333393097,
0.3996671736240387,
0.5171751976013184,
-0.6400579810142517,
-0.03323030099272728,
-0.5426138639450073,
0.26441940665245056,
0.020979035645723343,
-0.2841491103172302,
0.13261987268924713,
-0.37533459067344666,
-0.48149582743644714,
-0.42999961972236633,
0.08156465739011765,
-0.5517002940177917,
-0.4416638910770416,
0.10480700433254242,
0.34723031520843506,
-0.23986908793449402,
-0.10866861045360565,
-0.6871559619903564,
-0.1930360347032547,
-0.004297672770917416,
-0.12361527979373932,
0.5017244815826416,
0.6433761715888977,
0.06190592050552368,
0.5856746435165405,
0.5201084017753601,
0.09923755377531052,
-0.34822335839271545,
-0.057455699890851974,
0.6854579448699951,
-0.3408743739128113,
-0.9724082946777344,
-0.6856439113616943,
0.5161945819854736,
-0.16947953402996063,
-0.5339815020561218,
0.6951518058776855,
0.8575257062911987,
0.8727803826332092,
-0.08906126022338867,
0.6672845482826233,
0.537946879863739,
0.480049192905426,
-0.7721056342124939,
0.3655450940132141,
-0.9387087225914001,
0.038978639990091324,
-0.24049235880374908,
-1.0169968605041504,
-0.15899118781089783,
0.46865516901016235,
0.12953054904937744,
0.16203764081001282,
0.858061671257019,
0.1855647712945938,
-0.0697985291481018,
-0.3493102788925171,
0.29331570863723755,
-0.20460902154445648,
0.3436196446418762,
0.7146708965301514,
0.5149446129798889,
-0.23356810212135315,
0.48535269498825073,
-0.26062771677970886,
-0.40829768776893616,
-0.2293173372745514,
-0.7133284211158752,
-0.9471336603164673,
-0.8282045125961304,
-0.22645282745361328,
-0.13707852363586426,
0.04204864054918289,
0.6694841384887695,
0.588386058807373,
-0.6818938255310059,
-0.23241999745368958,
0.4724120795726776,
0.4440891742706299,
-0.7317543029785156,
-0.16749809682369232,
0.51749587059021,
-0.7047067880630493,
-0.8774973154067993,
0.21411024034023285,
0.6234312057495117,
-0.18753989040851593,
-0.01717734895646572,
-0.28778010606765747,
-0.13061536848545074,
0.31517502665519714,
0.7748656272888184,
0.1917697936296463,
-0.29141321778297424,
-0.273998886346817,
-0.36077818274497986,
-0.15846756100654602,
0.06215329468250275,
1.0455880165100098,
-0.3439221978187561,
0.39325398206710815,
0.5379596948623657,
0.7826648354530334,
0.5479240417480469,
0.3983713388442993,
0.7056475281715393,
-1.0913112163543701,
0.046131033450365067,
0.18372368812561035,
0.15883603692054749,
-0.05762549117207527,
-0.4777102470397949,
0.12214237451553345,
-0.18438410758972168,
-0.5108388066291809,
-0.5106670260429382,
-0.00014269792882259935,
-0.9435594081878662,
-0.7040243148803711,
0.5592531561851501,
-0.020440395921468735,
0.20733487606048584,
0.237528458237648,
-0.21872493624687195,
0.14246635138988495,
-0.39635854959487915,
1.2279051542282104,
0.3913884162902832,
-0.25892189145088196,
-0.4168494641780853,
-0.42400914430618286,
0.6438395977020264,
0.1781950294971466,
-1.1711549758911133,
-0.1339828372001648,
0.6595650315284729,
-0.06999830901622772,
0.1301092952489853,
0.4943597614765167,
0.08913060277700424,
0.3610173463821411,
-0.073597751557827,
0.06853581219911575,
-0.43028539419174194,
-0.7811828255653381,
-0.4207640290260315,
0.3122933506965637,
-0.3269536793231964,
-0.36308345198631287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04371v2
|
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-01T04:25:26
| 2024-06-16T21:20:29
|
Wei Pang, Chuan Zhou, Xiao-Hua Zhou, Xiaojie Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Instruction Fine-Tuning enhances pre-trained language models from basic
next-word prediction to complex instruction-following. However, existing
One-off Instruction Fine-Tuning (One-off IFT) method, applied on a diverse
instruction, may not effectively boost models' adherence to instructions due to
the simultaneous handling of varying instruction complexities. To improve this,
Phased Instruction Fine-Tuning (Phased IFT) is proposed, based on the idea that
learning to follow instructions is a gradual process. It assesses instruction
difficulty using GPT-4, divides the instruction data into subsets of increasing
difficulty, and uptrains the model sequentially on these subsets. Experiments
with Llama-2 7B/13B/70B, Llama3 8/70B and Mistral-7B models using Alpaca data
show that Phased IFT significantly outperforms One-off IFT, supporting the
progressive alignment hypothesis and providing a simple and efficient way to
enhance large language models. Codes and datasets from our experiments are
freely available at https://github.com/xubuvd/PhasedSFT.
|
[
-0.3218074142932892,
-1.018568515777588,
0.4928479790687561,
0.22977124154567719,
-0.5113735198974609,
0.14687024056911469,
-0.28560641407966614,
-0.16968216001987457,
-0.28767117857933044,
0.5314667224884033,
-0.9737277626991272,
-0.6368882656097412,
-0.6527935862541199,
0.01361494604498148,
-0.5396369695663452,
0.9989231824874878,
-0.13842244446277618,
0.08129279315471649,
0.3080621361732483,
0.2163827270269394,
-0.7772247195243835,
0.12322042137384415,
-0.8430366516113281,
-0.42813631892204285,
0.3363584876060486,
0.8107618689537048,
0.7031852006912231,
0.9533801674842834,
0.3932780623435974,
0.34882041811943054,
0.19792945683002472,
0.1438494771718979,
-0.35646873712539673,
-0.08075965195894241,
-0.01927086152136326,
-0.3497415781021118,
-0.3728353679180145,
-0.0701514258980751,
0.809809684753418,
0.6691446304321289,
-0.21240739524364471,
-0.07730761170387268,
0.01148680318146944,
0.5556870698928833,
-0.0978308692574501,
0.5276033282279968,
-0.5825272798538208,
-0.11086156219244003,
-0.35737496614456177,
-0.3293636441230774,
-0.25176188349723816,
-0.6554952263832092,
0.2906251549720764,
-0.682847261428833,
0.2966989278793335,
0.025955507531762123,
0.5811536312103271,
0.497245728969574,
-0.3464356064796448,
-0.49512022733688354,
-0.6041778326034546,
0.609076976776123,
-0.9388023614883423,
0.6456078290939331,
0.5750577449798584,
-0.10624788701534271,
-0.40331098437309265,
-0.3489610254764557,
-0.5330936908721924,
-0.6081469058990479,
0.25502434372901917,
0.037771761417388916,
0.22941027581691742,
0.27714914083480835,
0.1393323391675949,
0.2678816318511963,
-0.5541558265686035,
0.46556326746940613,
-0.36164405941963196,
0.09914630651473999,
0.34985998272895813,
0.08046277612447739,
0.14037466049194336,
0.21126028895378113,
-0.31707754731178284,
-0.009147446602582932,
-0.7866905927658081,
-0.05531766265630722,
0.3479975461959839,
0.4897012412548065,
-0.10613881796598434,
0.592353105545044,
-0.511542022228241,
0.829465389251709,
0.6775158047676086,
-0.0910361260175705,
0.09877858310937881,
-0.23627969622612,
-0.026896139606833458,
0.17834578454494476,
0.41272079944610596,
0.008902019821107388,
0.2414194792509079,
-0.15512898564338684,
-0.4585624039173126,
-0.13561542332172394,
0.22090581059455872,
-1.0389031171798706,
-0.2968350946903229,
0.018088309094309807,
-0.1268928498029709,
-0.017676573246717453,
0.0013356973649933934,
-0.42653778195381165,
-0.22034795582294464,
-0.7171780467033386,
0.7946488261222839,
-0.7725643515586853,
0.0014108138857409358,
0.4726853668689728,
0.34893137216567993,
0.33134356141090393,
0.3503507971763611,
-1.0799797773361206,
0.33498430252075195,
1.0764347314834595,
0.767731785774231,
-0.12687765061855316,
-0.5401853919029236,
-0.6515399813652039,
-0.19096921384334564,
-0.3430543839931488,
0.762370228767395,
-0.8176801204681396,
-0.35496988892555237,
0.03524250164628029,
0.004591922275722027,
-0.1352618932723999,
-0.4331475794315338,
0.37543773651123047,
-0.42238613963127136,
0.27816417813301086,
-0.2449813187122345,
-0.8071548342704773,
-0.20715802907943726,
0.2257670760154724,
-0.4285779595375061,
0.990470826625824,
0.19267238676548004,
-0.4405856430530548,
0.41206780076026917,
-0.5506900548934937,
-0.5968214869499207,
0.07019837945699692,
-0.007189632393419743,
-0.27259019017219543,
0.2541281580924988,
-0.020223060622811317,
0.5394272208213806,
-0.3522152900695801,
-0.06628122180700302,
-0.03757254406809807,
-0.5252565741539001,
-0.09747345000505447,
-0.38090479373931885,
0.2850940227508545,
0.04067046567797661,
-0.6419482231140137,
0.23023730516433716,
-0.8848767876625061,
0.011460937559604645,
-0.0793749988079071,
-0.469211608171463,
-0.32503828406333923,
0.03353685140609741,
-0.5735962390899658,
0.12395962327718735,
0.27408018708229065,
-0.5402093529701233,
0.6590981483459473,
-0.3665617108345032,
0.22271105647087097,
0.9189093708992004,
-0.02483651414513588,
0.4645947813987732,
-0.213004931807518,
0.537001371383667,
0.12540431320667267,
0.30786004662513733,
-0.2624189555644989,
-0.5434783101081848,
-0.9533214569091797,
-0.1717943251132965,
0.40388455986976624,
0.5718508362770081,
-0.7950407266616821,
0.26925286650657654,
-0.19704802334308624,
-0.4210587441921234,
-0.6089019775390625,
0.2650279998779297,
0.5725979208946228,
0.33709365129470825,
0.3518851101398468,
-0.7212923169136047,
-0.16049671173095703,
-0.6732777953147888,
0.24855831265449524,
0.1663866490125656,
0.042454659938812256,
-0.3311750590801239,
0.34990906715393066,
-0.4345139265060425,
0.6289486885070801,
-0.3855818510055542,
-0.0023971826303750277,
0.17481036484241486,
0.5004627108573914,
0.06260290741920471,
0.5869004726409912,
-0.10705818980932236,
-0.4384431540966034,
-0.511755108833313,
0.24041609466075897,
-0.2574703097343445,
-0.12223205715417862,
-0.1913684904575348,
-0.024607911705970764,
0.04787081480026245,
0.44061288237571716,
-0.5182003974914551,
0.19460007548332214,
0.5800256133079529,
-0.2893539071083069,
0.4375622570514679,
-0.4344322979450226,
0.3008793592453003,
-0.7812957167625427,
-0.5425690412521362,
0.13901355862617493,
-0.2025926411151886,
-0.7884156703948975,
0.10950200259685516,
0.24545934796333313,
0.19707083702087402,
-0.2747437357902527,
0.1852095127105713,
-0.5690732598304749,
0.10893794149160385,
-0.44911491870880127,
-0.1977969855070114,
-0.2209756225347519,
0.41184666752815247,
-0.0112367644906044,
0.870286226272583,
0.4013831317424774,
-0.4682846963405609,
-0.06689326465129852,
0.1904163956642151,
-0.5410758852958679,
0.32420864701271057,
-0.6755557060241699,
0.3902445137500763,
-0.11518307775259018,
0.14615251123905182,
-0.8001465201377869,
-0.1435324102640152,
0.2745177745819092,
0.2807686924934387,
0.6996984481811523,
-0.04792456328868866,
-0.3450903296470642,
-0.16809648275375366,
-0.27548477053642273,
0.30909138917922974,
0.4334677457809448,
-0.3824634253978729,
0.5342680215835571,
-0.09661724418401718,
-0.32712283730506897,
-0.4681571125984192,
-0.31456097960472107,
-0.3153509199619293,
-0.032043904066085815,
-0.459001362323761,
0.2887921929359436,
-0.33155712485313416,
0.025707192718982697,
-0.3041278123855591,
-0.2665186822414398,
-0.18857887387275696,
0.0055685266852378845,
0.2729029357433319,
0.11697738617658615,
-0.2763136327266693,
0.015765143558382988,
0.38603413105010986,
-0.11959736794233322,
-0.30162596702575684,
-0.39995190501213074,
0.889909029006958,
-0.18007509410381317,
-0.4786662757396698,
-0.6108686327934265,
0.3136427104473114,
0.3888159990310669,
-0.26195114850997925,
0.47865816950798035,
0.6600474119186401,
-0.15690703690052032,
-0.33714738488197327,
-0.5824481248855591,
-0.2714153230190277,
-0.5413330793380737,
0.43040522933006287,
-0.49078038334846497,
-0.9500882029533386,
0.3198113739490509,
-0.17512831091880798,
0.28792044520378113,
0.2222428321838379,
0.6487674117088318,
0.060573872178792953,
0.9957033395767212,
0.8176088929176331,
0.01801873929798603,
0.6457811594009399,
-0.20379045605659485,
0.11316915601491928,
-0.46894142031669617,
-0.09572678059339523,
-0.503208577632904,
-0.04385541379451752,
-0.5477407574653625,
-0.5936970114707947,
0.10848300904035568,
-0.0007844751235097647,
-0.4124128222465515,
0.284839004278183,
-0.42796212434768677,
0.6454415917396545,
0.5715026259422302,
0.2742331326007843,
0.3179275095462799,
-0.19582054018974304,
0.2581482231616974,
0.28425344824790955,
-0.6235619783401489,
-0.2774491310119629,
0.7614191174507141,
0.3012336194515228,
0.9921642541885376,
-0.22299616038799286,
0.832632839679718,
0.10758689790964127,
0.3015793561935425,
-0.8265206217765808,
0.4951641857624054,
-0.5381699800491333,
-0.40582960844039917,
-0.3734477162361145,
-0.4381348490715027,
-0.8828736543655396,
-0.11460733413696289,
0.03195276856422424,
-0.3985034227371216,
0.022982079535722733,
0.18528518080711365,
-0.4454343616962433,
-0.14219290018081665,
-0.9404085874557495,
0.6649768352508545,
-0.2836015522480011,
-0.03626342490315437,
-0.2263401299715042,
-0.5729173421859741,
0.3504824936389923,
-0.46632832288742065,
0.13778972625732422,
-0.18682757019996643,
0.02945634163916111,
0.6011434197425842,
-0.39802512526512146,
0.9951969385147095,
-0.06250730901956558,
-0.5131152868270874,
0.1496383249759674,
0.23631338775157928,
0.5931851267814636,
-0.20887260138988495,
-0.08490736782550812,
0.08111703395843506,
-0.033454831689596176,
-0.4032130241394043,
-0.47802722454071045,
0.8502073287963867,
-0.7922744154930115,
-0.706041693687439,
-0.1421346217393875,
-0.8088736534118652,
-0.29861658811569214,
0.23954473435878754,
0.2868078947067261,
0.6314363479614258,
-0.0006036451668478549,
0.0405690036714077,
0.9950600862503052,
0.09398668259382248,
0.27057594060897827,
0.695952296257019,
-0.08828464895486832,
-0.00041636370588093996,
0.9840465784072876,
0.39561814069747925,
0.5933175086975098,
0.39809873700141907,
0.4121512174606323,
-0.25071653723716736,
-0.9317348003387451,
-0.5407785773277283,
0.09379149973392487,
-0.4923851490020752,
-0.17007914185523987,
-0.32128989696502686,
-0.006627521011978388,
-0.20902343094348907,
-0.13026104867458344,
-0.5590037703514099,
-0.30949467420578003,
-0.23981662094593048,
0.08413081616163254,
0.3039974868297577,
1.0145879983901978,
0.2514455020427704,
0.6493420004844666,
-0.8638652563095093,
0.2877345085144043,
0.41170793771743774,
0.4853711426258087,
-0.1856040060520172,
-0.8519477248191833,
-0.31379979848861694,
0.261820524930954,
-0.22298382222652435,
-0.7207372188568115,
0.11796404421329498,
0.5323902368545532,
0.1862219125032425,
0.39044907689094543,
-0.2976982891559601,
0.8663638234138489,
-0.8836643099784851,
0.44303861260414124,
-0.002078738296404481,
-1.1282827854156494,
0.34590181708335876,
-0.5495162606239319,
0.7356415390968323,
0.6699609756469727,
0.5756406784057617,
-0.3678719103336334,
-0.3931582272052765,
-0.2628200650215149,
-0.6666292548179626,
0.6393248438835144,
-0.14998294413089752,
0.17722512781620026,
-0.04444481059908867,
0.6036556959152222,
0.6620602607727051,
0.1699516475200653,
-0.4093327522277832,
-0.004277358762919903,
-0.19236281514167786,
-0.5748922824859619,
-0.07656565308570862,
-0.1439141035079956,
0.04432214796543121,
-0.24363595247268677,
0.8258531093597412,
-0.16938945651054382,
0.08338535577058792,
-0.29852816462516785,
-0.0788087472319603,
-0.3797735273838043,
0.2021845132112503,
0.6677870750427246,
0.6821007132530212,
-0.21163852512836456,
-0.1389361321926117,
0.2888694107532501,
-0.6645733714103699,
0.27195295691490173,
0.3754013478755951,
-0.46761250495910645,
-0.36630523204803467,
0.23646113276481628,
0.8595578074455261,
0.5556688904762268,
-0.35432353615760803,
0.13510817289352417,
-0.09249993413686752,
-0.15636417269706726,
0.03422175720334053,
0.2800324559211731,
-0.009432745166122913,
0.4205683469772339,
0.22724375128746033,
-0.17877458035945892,
0.05351594090461731,
-0.7358273267745972,
0.19047139585018158,
0.3586549758911133,
-0.30675238370895386,
-0.44418099522590637,
0.39497485756874084,
0.05454038083553314,
-0.4967457354068756,
0.5685440301895142,
-0.3095657229423523,
-0.4864431321620941,
0.33648446202278137,
0.7030556201934814,
0.6704238057136536,
-0.5100703835487366,
0.3469134569168091,
0.06498260796070099,
0.44127947092056274,
-0.4699312746524811,
0.280428022146225,
0.13799238204956055,
-0.5493330955505371,
-0.7400985360145569,
-0.7276906371116638,
-0.5171131491661072,
-0.2219468057155609,
-0.39443227648735046,
0.2238038182258606,
-0.6572434306144714,
0.21243393421173096,
-0.040791936218738556,
0.24201355874538422,
-0.7982720136642456,
0.3561237156391144,
0.13487935066223145,
0.7921478748321533,
-0.7849917411804199,
1.2499339580535889,
0.3570723235607147,
-0.3414722979068756,
-1.0725897550582886,
0.1327393352985382,
-0.042769577354192734,
-0.827029824256897,
0.3898269534111023,
0.2826744616031647,
-0.20259879529476166,
0.30456626415252686,
-0.34809643030166626,
-0.8670138716697693,
0.9641413688659668,
0.24552947282791138,
-1.1118826866149902,
-0.014678300358355045,
0.2433406412601471,
0.3380759060382843,
-0.3089308440685272,
0.07603108882904053,
0.9057563543319702,
0.5027112364768982,
0.09749060869216919,
-0.8228647708892822,
0.05621791630983353,
0.1942763477563858,
-0.14722180366516113,
0.5504258871078491,
-0.7287361025810242,
0.9567975997924805,
-0.07029776275157928,
-0.10766294598579407,
0.11197756230831146,
0.7902097105979919,
-0.06642316281795502,
0.2055269181728363,
0.7286251187324524,
0.5164467692375183,
0.6840828657150269,
-0.16552267968654633,
0.8986281156539917,
-0.19176149368286133,
0.15897580981254578,
1.270802617073059,
-0.3049485385417938,
0.7571279406547546,
0.1347675770521164,
0.02602778747677803,
0.40443819761276245,
0.6652867197990417,
0.2780188322067261,
0.5659536719322205,
0.14919187128543854,
-0.2604919970035553,
-0.13231422007083893,
0.14714641869068146,
-0.4082292914390564,
0.6305885910987854,
0.23326702415943146,
0.11478104442358017,
-0.09403128921985626,
0.007254729047417641,
0.1520829051733017,
-0.2692888379096985,
-0.34396108984947205,
0.7166481614112854,
-0.05807578191161156,
-0.7736159563064575,
0.7500042915344238,
0.04661846533417702,
0.7841269969940186,
-0.8610963821411133,
-0.11995697766542435,
-0.34680619835853577,
0.11895497888326645,
-0.04440496116876602,
-0.6175025701522827,
-0.10449352115392685,
-0.03855014592409134,
-0.03064706176519394,
-0.11997336149215698,
0.50843745470047,
-0.7922148108482361,
-0.49173158407211304,
-0.01918930746614933,
0.3529079556465149,
-0.12630566954612732,
0.055124957114458084,
-0.7109982967376709,
0.1745317429304123,
0.15023022890090942,
-0.49067822098731995,
0.4108005464076996,
0.6452999114990234,
-0.18324732780456543,
0.6881246566772461,
0.5063812732696533,
-0.1354588270187378,
0.5373672246932983,
0.14638054370880127,
0.9251737594604492,
-0.49952366948127747,
-0.04585239663720131,
-0.6740672588348389,
0.45206207036972046,
0.2516780197620392,
-0.529819905757904,
0.7322465777397156,
0.273212730884552,
0.9356298446655273,
-0.09230422228574753,
0.431240975856781,
0.02492460422217846,
0.2740699350833893,
-0.7758187055587769,
0.2569837272167206,
-0.33240047097206116,
0.12321600317955017,
-0.09057818353176117,
-1.1096251010894775,
-0.14977030456066132,
0.5555058121681213,
-0.3637467324733734,
0.1152157112956047,
0.6726312041282654,
0.9871277809143066,
-0.27007928490638733,
0.2649354636669159,
0.2964983582496643,
0.39429059624671936,
0.2888545095920563,
0.2756701409816742,
0.8109052777290344,
-0.19108028709888458,
0.07521425187587738,
-0.4966813921928406,
-0.4182671308517456,
0.01183252315968275,
-0.858875036239624,
-0.701410174369812,
-0.6187875866889954,
-0.33750802278518677,
0.045034460723400116,
0.22017961740493774,
1.263505458831787,
0.6207302808761597,
-0.7758316993713379,
-0.20568430423736572,
-0.10079190135002136,
-0.34789764881134033,
-0.26587843894958496,
-0.055445071309804916,
0.2662871778011322,
-0.5014961957931519,
-0.8034036755561829,
0.6529131531715393,
0.2456461489200592,
-0.050851937383413315,
-0.27485597133636475,
-0.09173697978258133,
-0.3700288236141205,
0.34552836418151855,
0.705498993396759,
0.2405274361371994,
-0.46881598234176636,
-0.5679376125335693,
-0.05244925245642662,
-0.009175699204206467,
-0.03689328581094742,
0.7991140484809875,
-0.303972452878952,
0.3837045133113861,
0.23094163835048676,
0.6725677251815796,
0.6090972423553467,
0.10022161900997162,
0.4348738193511963,
-0.6969019770622253,
0.09444110840559006,
0.19595474004745483,
0.1882147341966629,
0.2544553577899933,
-0.20968778431415558,
0.3200836181640625,
-0.32048413157463074,
-0.8183087110519409,
-0.44283315539360046,
0.17458738386631012,
-1.0639960765838623,
-0.08521001040935516,
1.0714305639266968,
-0.06109831482172012,
-0.060254763811826706,
-0.08174759149551392,
-0.3419865071773529,
0.4491564631462097,
-0.3750787675380707,
1.0880290269851685,
0.6527887582778931,
0.06762747466564178,
-0.05623544007539749,
-0.6826947331428528,
0.34452104568481445,
0.5182951092720032,
-0.8765442967414856,
-0.058249570429325104,
0.5595951676368713,
0.43447452783584595,
-0.17368297278881073,
0.5576754808425903,
0.24506695568561554,
0.2235742062330246,
-0.23717160522937775,
-0.07555605471134186,
-0.09648212045431137,
-0.49571001529693604,
-0.3351438343524933,
0.04152245447039604,
0.30061015486717224,
-0.10816099494695663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00284v1
|
A Closer Look at Logical Reasoning with LLMs: The Choice of Tool Matters
| 2024-06-01T03:29:56
| 2024-06-01T03:29:56
|
Long Hei Matthew Lam, Ehsan Shareghi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Logical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for human cognition. Recently, the
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated promising progress
in solving logical reasoning tasks effectively. To improve this capability,
recent studies have delved into integrating LLMs with various symbolic solvers
using diverse techniques and methodologies. While some combinations excel on
specific datasets, others fall short. However, it remains unclear whether the
variance in performance stems from the methodologies employed or the specific
symbolic solvers utilized. Therefore, there is a lack of consistent comparison
between symbolic solvers and how they influence LLM's logical reasoning
ability. We perform experiments on LLMs integrated with 3 symbolic solvers: Z3,
Pyke, and Prover9, and compare their performance on 3 logical reasoning
datasets: ProofWriter, PrOntoQA, and FOLIO. Our findings indicate that when
combined with LLMs Pyke's performance is significantly inferior to that of
Prover9 and Z3. Z3's overall accuracy performance slightly surpasses Prover9,
but Prover9 could execute more questions.
|
[
-0.12651793658733368,
-0.43119531869888306,
1.157245397567749,
0.06972692161798477,
-0.28139224648475647,
0.15732936561107635,
-0.1832369714975357,
-0.6056435704231262,
-0.16053183376789093,
0.4386959671974182,
-0.39428290724754333,
-0.44901397824287415,
-0.6777023077011108,
0.47847235202789307,
-0.05166686326265335,
0.32656916975975037,
-0.1345488280057907,
0.3855655789375305,
-0.41534000635147095,
-0.11796389520168304,
-0.6168492436408997,
-0.7044217586517334,
-0.41100889444351196,
-0.6917420625686646,
0.36394035816192627,
0.16285750269889832,
0.9971535801887512,
0.49416011571884155,
0.8233892321586609,
0.4147345721721649,
-0.20642022788524628,
0.2046978771686554,
-0.2283594012260437,
0.17687347531318665,
-0.45724231004714966,
-1.0275517702102661,
-0.16336868703365326,
-0.052450794726610184,
0.24166612327098846,
0.46713879704475403,
-0.08352334052324295,
-0.036280225962400436,
-0.2840050160884857,
0.5508358478546143,
-0.6859570741653442,
0.04078691080212593,
-0.5416824817657471,
0.27032533288002014,
-0.22345633804798126,
0.03904801234602928,
-0.3549734652042389,
-0.6437841653823853,
0.10615375638008118,
-0.6309625506401062,
-0.006495093461126089,
0.05600389093160629,
0.44019603729248047,
0.5585216879844666,
-0.37394052743911743,
-0.3443065881729126,
-0.8158599734306335,
0.9619503617286682,
-0.9909190535545349,
0.3850369155406952,
-0.07591906189918518,
0.4631675183773041,
-0.4707372784614563,
-0.6155809760093689,
-0.7796006798744202,
-0.21425874531269073,
-0.06056090071797371,
0.023733487352728844,
-0.335776150226593,
0.18535207211971283,
0.6924622058868408,
0.26218870282173157,
-0.4437620937824249,
0.18715935945510864,
-0.4473664462566376,
-0.3109401762485504,
0.6164892911911011,
0.4571191072463989,
0.2308352142572403,
-0.06562817096710205,
-0.1661584973335266,
-0.1981320083141327,
-0.7427806854248047,
-0.07352788001298904,
0.2004467397928238,
0.07188472151756287,
0.4505844712257385,
0.8767267465591431,
-0.04572348669171333,
0.8812152147293091,
-0.19063416123390198,
-0.7258327007293701,
0.07321171462535858,
-0.07436948269605637,
-0.38127776980400085,
0.1068364828824997,
0.7004576325416565,
0.4185568690299988,
0.6054753065109253,
0.000539780652616173,
-0.3642790913581848,
0.4993911683559418,
0.08889342099428177,
-0.5468550324440002,
-0.3145662844181061,
0.04632270708680153,
-0.4009023904800415,
-0.01577414944767952,
0.0555807389318943,
0.04681626334786415,
-0.6847923994064331,
-0.6987064480781555,
0.4807097315788269,
-0.39104846119880676,
-0.016025150194764137,
0.49061349034309387,
-0.23052123188972473,
0.25616079568862915,
0.6779270172119141,
-0.263850599527359,
0.41289225220680237,
0.9234511256217957,
0.5978752374649048,
-0.21885572373867035,
-0.17497499287128448,
-0.4406106173992157,
0.06080635264515877,
-0.48651883006095886,
0.8726771473884583,
-0.5574895143508911,
-0.15294639766216278,
-0.14188362658023834,
-0.19504186511039734,
-0.055707819759845734,
-1.0055662393569946,
0.6748049259185791,
-0.610104501247406,
0.1699320375919342,
-0.6747831702232361,
-0.7342073917388916,
-0.42240896821022034,
-0.08306004106998444,
-0.7250032424926758,
0.9393205642700195,
-0.011000745929777622,
-0.7070096731185913,
0.46823784708976746,
-0.37725237011909485,
-0.38612642884254456,
0.026869209483265877,
-0.5450626015663147,
-0.09256662428379059,
0.34728333353996277,
0.11861754208803177,
0.5293241143226624,
-0.7023801207542419,
0.3086046278476715,
-0.38692787289619446,
-0.740369975566864,
0.42922160029411316,
-0.050144899636507034,
0.914633572101593,
0.13667160272598267,
-0.282381147146225,
0.2026224434375763,
-0.5082708597183228,
0.03259308636188507,
0.32250070571899414,
-0.06341800093650818,
-0.07289966195821762,
0.16000737249851227,
-0.4023701548576355,
0.5707325339317322,
-0.027551177889108658,
-0.5056781768798828,
-0.11864029616117477,
-0.37037762999534607,
0.3828687369823456,
0.7248994708061218,
-0.238289937376976,
0.058785296976566315,
-0.6071874499320984,
0.4612652063369751,
0.20052240788936615,
-0.22533529996871948,
0.39820244908332825,
-0.5857264399528503,
-0.5741827487945557,
-0.02723977155983448,
0.11006109416484833,
0.8413878083229065,
-0.6779797077178955,
0.2031172215938568,
-0.1334230601787567,
-0.5347492098808289,
-0.3156488835811615,
0.3512195646762848,
0.36769619584083557,
0.3766018748283386,
0.28816547989845276,
0.07692679017782211,
-0.40035778284072876,
-1.1065049171447754,
-0.5761234164237976,
-0.41046711802482605,
-0.34836992621421814,
0.1465187966823578,
0.4506840407848358,
0.2647285461425781,
0.9261056184768677,
-0.6109733581542969,
-0.17117217183113098,
-0.6067820191383362,
-0.4034017026424408,
0.37714895606040955,
0.122287817299366,
0.406344473361969,
-0.4143359363079071,
-0.2334788590669632,
-0.10026415437459946,
-0.9135180115699768,
-0.24104799330234528,
-0.013010287657380104,
0.0654539242386818,
0.3093169629573822,
0.4917159378528595,
-0.876323401927948,
0.35623323917388916,
0.13777032494544983,
-0.3452390432357788,
0.7202467322349548,
-0.21309557557106018,
-0.09713074564933777,
-0.7171306014060974,
-0.3071981966495514,
0.12321387976408005,
0.039217233657836914,
-0.5175992846488953,
-0.1773802936077118,
0.14505329728126526,
0.07570603489875793,
-0.6156764626502991,
0.31333112716674805,
-0.5002625584602356,
-0.3684905171394348,
-0.09747888147830963,
0.3591144382953644,
0.023179931566119194,
0.1753493696451187,
0.08902965486049652,
1.007381796836853,
0.49215370416641235,
-0.44948989152908325,
0.6621463298797607,
0.056623030453920364,
-0.6583432555198669,
0.30233272910118103,
-0.8584973812103271,
0.1710003912448883,
-0.08011411875486374,
0.23880471289157867,
-0.7523064017295837,
0.04653696343302727,
0.31607547402381897,
-0.11002674698829651,
-0.024604404345154762,
0.3453465402126312,
-1.0317586660385132,
-0.33521202206611633,
-0.3822096586227417,
0.2335113137960434,
0.6215443015098572,
-0.5625644326210022,
0.7678197622299194,
-0.02689625695347786,
-0.038689497858285904,
-0.4639227092266083,
-0.6045111417770386,
0.10648862272500992,
-0.48987120389938354,
-0.9308786988258362,
0.2394593358039856,
0.08047358691692352,
-0.8695737719535828,
-0.05818545073270798,
-0.39596283435821533,
0.20178531110286713,
-0.06615553796291351,
0.044280052185058594,
0.3027215898036957,
-0.47941815853118896,
0.15777142345905304,
-0.01044476218521595,
-0.196522518992424,
0.45975735783576965,
-0.1394013911485672,
0.13666197657585144,
-0.39749783277511597,
-0.6843715310096741,
-0.6231257319450378,
0.1360454112291336,
0.6022495627403259,
-0.32861191034317017,
0.925937294960022,
0.12904615700244904,
-0.2807067632675171,
-0.0756225734949112,
-0.9551199674606323,
-0.23687893152236938,
-0.4689311385154724,
0.012008598074316978,
-0.57425856590271,
-0.8975095748901367,
0.46648213267326355,
-0.12826019525527954,
-0.09879736602306366,
0.3081446886062622,
0.5347244739532471,
-0.15140388906002045,
1.0282273292541504,
0.2770538628101349,
0.14674122631549835,
-0.015969866886734962,
0.1178404837846756,
0.36981984972953796,
-0.675303041934967,
-0.3315599858760834,
-0.41573566198349,
-0.3795863091945648,
-0.3857516646385193,
-0.5386688709259033,
0.1385330706834793,
0.3429988920688629,
-0.27105578780174255,
0.23673774302005768,
-0.419270783662796,
0.7626132369041443,
0.3476710617542267,
0.04144890978932381,
0.5777924656867981,
-0.08083455264568329,
-0.19851963222026825,
-0.15996627509593964,
-0.8292303085327148,
-0.769740641117096,
0.9621785879135132,
0.12727254629135132,
0.7276846170425415,
0.3473319411277771,
0.4510402977466583,
-0.14566585421562195,
0.15703421831130981,
-0.6949641704559326,
0.9149943590164185,
-0.13448823988437653,
-0.35257190465927124,
-0.11517558246850967,
-0.3117882311344147,
-0.6607325673103333,
0.704642653465271,
-0.1799001693725586,
-0.7116444110870361,
0.06003715842962265,
-0.10809776932001114,
-0.3812365233898163,
0.4528796076774597,
-0.7663831114768982,
0.6462885141372681,
-0.29449373483657837,
-0.22483637928962708,
-0.3029497563838959,
-0.6881056427955627,
0.4448353350162506,
0.11708998680114746,
0.021999510005116463,
-0.32931357622146606,
-0.13316068053245544,
0.6688600182533264,
-0.4379290044307709,
0.6159034371376038,
0.05676623806357384,
-0.34462860226631165,
0.2960139214992523,
0.21790291368961334,
0.44528448581695557,
-0.10587968677282333,
-0.09784431010484695,
-0.024345915764570236,
0.0332363098859787,
-0.23128001391887665,
-0.9807301163673401,
0.6936656832695007,
-0.7266167998313904,
-1.2024043798446655,
-0.46061578392982483,
-0.6321739554405212,
-0.2504448890686035,
0.1404929757118225,
-0.07624233514070511,
0.4050728380680084,
0.29328927397727966,
0.12824302911758423,
0.8065097332000732,
-0.08780048787593842,
0.1449861377477646,
0.36000001430511475,
-0.19322536885738373,
-0.17380206286907196,
0.5388223528862,
0.07521917670965195,
0.40189647674560547,
0.26986420154571533,
0.37079524993896484,
-0.4002133309841156,
-0.6427236199378967,
-0.18071874976158142,
0.5686937570571899,
-1.2488384246826172,
-0.29724323749542236,
-0.5052413940429688,
-0.085194893181324,
-0.07459428906440735,
-0.29863443970680237,
-0.06205981969833374,
-0.5728265047073364,
-0.11530435085296631,
-0.043471772223711014,
0.47403040528297424,
0.6640975475311279,
0.18561387062072754,
0.05511446297168732,
-0.5888160467147827,
0.3375212848186493,
0.2121589034795761,
0.15432636439800262,
-0.08760629594326019,
-0.14881651103496552,
0.28382617235183716,
-0.30980080366134644,
-0.07637006789445877,
-1.0673576593399048,
-0.08203907310962677,
-0.25662413239479065,
0.755721390247345,
0.35565024614334106,
-0.053941529244184494,
0.5768290162086487,
-0.2734663188457489,
0.507552444934845,
0.06658736616373062,
-0.797312319278717,
0.530516505241394,
-0.11433455348014832,
0.3908200263977051,
0.3689573407173157,
0.2167099267244339,
-0.23128946125507355,
-0.4524005949497223,
-0.4230833649635315,
-0.32293155789375305,
0.7571439743041992,
0.46738842129707336,
-0.4566158056259155,
0.11408612132072449,
0.42831599712371826,
-0.1403944343328476,
-0.10120702534914017,
-0.5158208608627319,
-0.22591611742973328,
0.1661609560251236,
-0.10450305044651031,
-0.053022537380456924,
-0.05776800587773323,
-0.05782096087932587,
-0.46771785616874695,
0.47857439517974854,
0.14076998829841614,
-0.03071495145559311,
0.2512236535549164,
-0.2835552394390106,
0.025750240311026573,
0.2476407140493393,
0.41189897060394287,
0.8253136277198792,
-0.033766333013772964,
0.21791401505470276,
0.46116316318511963,
-0.2412646859884262,
0.1176629364490509,
-0.04514389485120773,
0.15053796768188477,
0.032432671636343,
0.6304295659065247,
0.6147770285606384,
-0.01585313118994236,
-0.9268185496330261,
0.33318230509757996,
-0.10094396024942398,
-0.43608638644218445,
-0.15558601915836334,
0.4297421872615814,
0.4928860068321228,
0.5621219277381897,
-0.02153797261416912,
0.055915407836437225,
0.06736131757497787,
-0.3626866936683655,
-0.33488595485687256,
0.38617414236068726,
0.12060410529375076,
0.04641019552946091,
0.4837474822998047,
-0.02021879330277443,
-0.4542312026023865,
0.7729780077934265,
-0.04410547390580177,
-0.7515443563461304,
0.7661474943161011,
0.6942787766456604,
0.535461962223053,
-0.051431987434625626,
-0.22680577635765076,
0.10581768304109573,
0.5324556231498718,
-0.22774195671081543,
0.5323721170425415,
-0.04644255340099335,
-0.8315912485122681,
-0.8605231642723083,
-0.2624257504940033,
-0.453874409198761,
0.001052750158123672,
-0.3260642886161804,
0.2337733954191208,
-0.3425082862377167,
-0.06249146908521652,
-0.0479758195579052,
0.23901458084583282,
-0.6288910508155823,
0.14355573058128357,
0.011140457354485989,
1.1297612190246582,
-0.6756483316421509,
0.6305360198020935,
0.9799771904945374,
-0.05242806673049927,
-0.9082029461860657,
-0.08035723119974136,
0.27382662892341614,
-0.4340576231479645,
0.818318247795105,
0.14652210474014282,
-0.5921161770820618,
-0.18877410888671875,
-0.1569066345691681,
-0.7412607073783875,
1.3148146867752075,
0.606234610080719,
-0.4163360297679901,
0.23663906753063202,
0.2888062298297882,
0.5173823237419128,
-0.2230224609375,
0.2054172158241272,
0.8178151845932007,
0.5285597443580627,
0.3394819498062134,
-0.9620892405509949,
0.25185027718544006,
-0.04732481762766838,
0.219583660364151,
0.4276357591152191,
-0.3714592754840851,
0.6746984720230103,
-0.45308718085289,
-0.3257570266723633,
-0.09238102287054062,
0.7201158404350281,
0.7842175364494324,
0.20162005722522736,
0.40455543994903564,
0.5788058042526245,
0.8089763522148132,
-0.08914871513843536,
0.998997151851654,
-0.030042845755815506,
-0.057638682425022125,
0.9448381066322327,
-0.6902419328689575,
0.7062665224075317,
0.47597914934158325,
-0.45623883605003357,
0.3246525228023529,
0.39818668365478516,
0.06682975590229034,
0.07520353049039841,
0.5270739197731018,
-0.3085149824619293,
-0.6817100644111633,
0.09908052533864975,
-0.4677105247974396,
0.28477007150650024,
0.40521240234375,
-0.046930719166994095,
-0.29255393147468567,
-0.3857683539390564,
0.03911273181438446,
0.263117253780365,
-0.12477409839630127,
0.5109315514564514,
0.2381952702999115,
-0.5349540710449219,
0.2352190762758255,
0.15586015582084656,
0.40884295105934143,
-0.35374993085861206,
-0.032357435673475266,
-0.12133806198835373,
0.4312663674354553,
-0.3256087601184845,
-1.0263111591339111,
0.3867185413837433,
-0.11907310783863068,
0.13105806708335876,
-0.011749775148928165,
1.1474379301071167,
0.13140808045864105,
-0.6231968998908997,
0.2397947460412979,
0.8308197259902954,
0.12204735726118088,
-0.10312213748693466,
-0.48584115505218506,
0.2772301733493805,
-0.20197130739688873,
-0.06000765040516853,
0.24855008721351624,
0.6527101993560791,
-0.2774727940559387,
1.031812071800232,
0.7553873062133789,
-0.041567880660295486,
-0.02574434131383896,
0.09608999639749527,
0.9733408093452454,
-0.7095533013343811,
-0.14522108435630798,
-1.086972713470459,
0.10702423751354218,
-0.05801371484994888,
-0.1695609986782074,
0.9729551076889038,
0.6598612070083618,
0.8211480379104614,
-0.11292631179094315,
0.4567088186740875,
0.2944599390029907,
0.3608268201351166,
-0.7225297689437866,
0.33893826603889465,
-0.35453444719314575,
0.5430100560188293,
-0.36387425661087036,
-1.1437269449234009,
-0.6340698599815369,
0.9230734705924988,
-0.4961497187614441,
0.05886407196521759,
0.9605000019073486,
0.7732410430908203,
0.043307919055223465,
0.3281603753566742,
0.2275448888540268,
0.12506398558616638,
0.29211530089378357,
0.792181134223938,
1.324799656867981,
-0.025446398183703423,
0.37998783588409424,
-0.3514547049999237,
-0.06521324813365936,
0.10515214502811432,
-0.9998440146446228,
-1.0781192779541016,
-0.08870755136013031,
-0.2177095115184784,
-0.06734714657068253,
0.1314699500799179,
0.9578709006309509,
0.18242405354976654,
-0.5424217581748962,
-0.3045038878917694,
-0.03169536218047142,
0.38766396045684814,
-0.05506021901965141,
-0.17774543166160583,
0.1612720787525177,
-0.15461379289627075,
-0.30392470955848694,
0.4162544906139374,
0.3154127299785614,
-0.14290855824947357,
-0.10836856067180634,
-0.10686084628105164,
0.15017636120319366,
0.12013685703277588,
0.7186478972434998,
-0.15436993539333344,
-1.1741955280303955,
-0.15897798538208008,
0.01071417611092329,
0.11414631456136703,
0.1372065395116806,
1.1029636859893799,
-1.1100610494613647,
-0.01047605648636818,
0.5894224643707275,
0.5262721180915833,
0.2232344150543213,
-0.11485712230205536,
0.4920561909675598,
0.055585283786058426,
-0.1507418155670166,
0.3548097610473633,
0.4397220313549042,
0.22944027185440063,
-0.18244631588459015,
0.44804877042770386,
0.14663547277450562,
-0.4537616968154907,
-0.7257812023162842,
0.21496111154556274,
-0.7395293712615967,
-0.488138347864151,
1.0811060667037964,
0.23861782252788544,
0.0512835793197155,
-0.19879238307476044,
-0.28129199147224426,
-0.06893916428089142,
-0.20481178164482117,
0.3719468116760254,
0.9048953652381897,
-0.6119059920310974,
-0.06526545435190201,
-0.7443273067474365,
0.30379894375801086,
0.632964015007019,
-0.729235827922821,
-0.048898112028837204,
0.7132282257080078,
0.19544999301433563,
0.04015614092350006,
0.44249671697616577,
-0.0792909637093544,
0.32216960191726685,
-0.12822109460830688,
-0.35181522369384766,
-0.14992353320121765,
-0.3298548758029938,
-0.3786286413669586,
0.10969585925340652,
0.35126993060112,
0.31672459840774536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04370v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04370v1
|
Large Language Model Confidence Estimation via Black-Box Access
| 2024-06-01T02:08:44
| 2024-06-01T02:08:44
|
Tejaswini Pedapati, Amit Dhurandhar, Soumya Ghosh, Soham Dan, Prasanna Sattigeri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Estimating uncertainty or confidence in the responses of a model can be
significant in evaluating trust not only in the responses, but also in the
model as a whole. In this paper, we explore the problem of estimating
confidence for responses of large language models (LLMs) with simply black-box
or query access to them. We propose a simple and extensible framework where, we
engineer novel features and train a (interpretable) model (viz. logistic
regression) on these features to estimate the confidence. We empirically
demonstrate that our simple framework is effective in estimating confidence of
flan-ul2, llama-13b and mistral-7b with it consistently outperforming existing
black-box confidence estimation approaches on benchmark datasets such as
TriviaQA, SQuAD, CoQA and Natural Questions by even over $10\%$ (on AUROC) in
some cases. Additionally, our interpretable approach provides insight into
features that are predictive of confidence, leading to the interesting and
useful discovery that our confidence models built for one LLM generalize
zero-shot across others on a given dataset.
|
[
-0.17397986352443695,
-0.827845573425293,
0.8286817669868469,
0.12276562303304672,
0.006816487293690443,
0.18603281676769257,
-0.17181381583213806,
-0.8162068128585815,
-0.005029844585806131,
0.2964614927768707,
-0.3703453540802002,
-0.6596660017967224,
-0.7237113118171692,
-0.09914892911911011,
-0.5613101124763489,
0.6223645806312561,
0.12634272873401642,
-0.03629089891910553,
-0.050326380878686905,
0.016108520328998566,
-0.41409584879875183,
-0.7176361680030823,
-0.3300359845161438,
-0.19445088505744934,
0.5187360048294067,
0.21620148420333862,
0.7184208035469055,
0.11122113466262817,
0.2174016386270523,
0.15508395433425903,
-0.3209470212459564,
-0.032522011548280716,
-0.5595788955688477,
0.016091136261820793,
-0.09688349813222885,
-0.9201829433441162,
-0.44180843234062195,
-0.29660460352897644,
0.5265634059906006,
0.5206855535507202,
-0.1675652712583542,
0.2777854800224304,
0.1188945546746254,
0.15667197108268738,
-0.7715878486633301,
0.3849392831325531,
-0.8133827447891235,
-0.0841732770204544,
-0.031122906133532524,
-0.03916119039058685,
-0.6099576354026794,
-0.22639429569244385,
0.1835085153579712,
-0.42612922191619873,
0.057832974940538406,
0.2139737606048584,
0.7156574726104736,
0.15851163864135742,
-0.3127898573875427,
-0.2752551734447479,
-0.8035967350006104,
0.9813971519470215,
-0.6998594403266907,
0.2590443193912506,
0.5136426687240601,
0.3887139856815338,
-0.27781644463539124,
-0.4320031404495239,
-0.4752176105976105,
-0.2620241641998291,
-0.0697626993060112,
-0.10593899339437485,
-0.19554786384105682,
0.04542046785354614,
0.11527574807405472,
0.41004401445388794,
-0.46832212805747986,
0.1136649027466774,
-0.05051594227552414,
-0.34281864762306213,
0.8225038051605225,
-0.16748768091201782,
-0.13863353431224823,
0.019293025135993958,
-0.1852235645055771,
0.03140980005264282,
-0.667691171169281,
0.21104735136032104,
0.2750561535358429,
0.2906162440776825,
-0.11239062249660492,
0.7141433358192444,
-0.11581246554851532,
0.5715749263763428,
-0.1363009661436081,
-0.2546834647655487,
0.23754428327083588,
-0.27158063650131226,
-0.3381240963935852,
-0.09352993220090866,
0.7166175842285156,
-0.08767129480838776,
0.3979402482509613,
-0.07883477956056595,
-0.23581500351428986,
0.11142617464065552,
0.20921742916107178,
-0.6809459328651428,
-0.000024119202862493694,
0.5301632285118103,
-0.11524519324302673,
-0.287527471780777,
0.2998245060443878,
-0.7478433847427368,
-0.3841833174228668,
0.2012786865234375,
0.5237524509429932,
-0.14110741019248962,
-0.46977508068084717,
0.1741863340139389,
0.15184052288532257,
0.43395736813545227,
0.47239938378334045,
-0.6396504044532776,
0.09343082457780838,
0.8388329744338989,
0.7886662483215332,
-0.13483379781246185,
0.02030923403799534,
-0.7181820273399353,
-0.052371978759765625,
-0.4879089295864105,
0.5458452701568604,
-0.6505528688430786,
-0.4975438117980957,
0.214227095246315,
0.21851883828639984,
0.02111629769206047,
-0.21787303686141968,
0.30270931124687195,
-0.45708513259887695,
-0.14464634656906128,
0.24841491878032684,
-0.6043986082077026,
-0.1667698621749878,
0.21286264061927795,
-0.6845593452453613,
1.0197840929031372,
0.04555366188287735,
-0.615658700466156,
0.18614499270915985,
-0.2642313241958618,
-0.21563774347305298,
0.055083535611629486,
-0.3040415048599243,
-0.4669307470321655,
0.45099303126335144,
0.24868933856487274,
0.600736141204834,
-0.17596131563186646,
0.29199129343032837,
-0.925570011138916,
-0.387241929769516,
0.847965657711029,
-0.457155704498291,
0.6360287070274353,
-0.009752139449119568,
-0.32320475578308105,
-0.025629673153162003,
-0.6904909610748291,
0.21279461681842804,
-0.07512252032756805,
-0.02106637693941593,
-0.4696931540966034,
-0.21139371395111084,
-0.0819198340177536,
-0.0036357115022838116,
0.3524002730846405,
-0.5479175448417664,
-0.005061328876763582,
-0.29730910062789917,
0.09242609888315201,
0.6602632999420166,
0.2260933518409729,
0.2581065595149994,
0.03333102539181709,
0.8533430695533752,
-0.11815204471349716,
0.029710257425904274,
0.14860877394676208,
-0.6506061553955078,
-0.40905019640922546,
-0.3199132978916168,
0.5658519864082336,
0.48197683691978455,
-0.5129309296607971,
0.5098565220832825,
-0.1406162530183792,
-0.446346640586853,
-0.611441433429718,
0.340424120426178,
0.4694085121154785,
-0.014936558902263641,
0.07694431394338608,
-0.21612603962421417,
-0.14519229531288147,
-0.9159333109855652,
-0.0587383434176445,
-0.40812838077545166,
-0.17493602633476257,
0.3802943229675293,
0.6190713047981262,
0.04080088809132576,
0.6670395135879517,
-0.8189347982406616,
0.001082775997929275,
-0.26560837030410767,
0.1573077142238617,
0.0834934189915657,
0.2917562425136566,
0.42694246768951416,
-0.8477425575256348,
-0.43164438009262085,
0.09442068636417389,
-0.7117071151733398,
0.16067512333393097,
0.0818396657705307,
-0.2969587743282318,
0.2876373529434204,
0.3677462935447693,
-0.7513852715492249,
0.665740430355072,
0.829054594039917,
-0.2681025564670563,
0.4365890622138977,
0.04111098125576973,
-0.07855432480573654,
-1.0342923402786255,
0.1875929832458496,
0.19584086537361145,
-0.4636614918708801,
-0.6207174062728882,
0.21073217689990997,
0.19819335639476776,
0.18727624416351318,
-0.23547445237636566,
0.6842174530029297,
-0.4281870126724243,
-0.12679730355739594,
-0.12542277574539185,
0.1585022658109665,
0.06986411660909653,
0.40636324882507324,
0.2227901816368103,
0.701124370098114,
0.5030785799026489,
-0.28002509474754333,
-0.04039312154054642,
0.2889207601547241,
-0.7048142552375793,
0.6241987943649292,
-0.6885675191879272,
0.17642688751220703,
0.009813565760850906,
0.19654443860054016,
-1.1260653734207153,
-0.3255029320716858,
0.09384230524301529,
-0.6255368590354919,
0.4287979304790497,
-0.3462790548801422,
-0.2635791599750519,
-0.2852611541748047,
-0.04829152300953865,
0.1338636875152588,
0.42967739701271057,
-0.3668808043003082,
0.5047879815101624,
0.5193542242050171,
-0.47141140699386597,
-1.0223833322525024,
-0.808398962020874,
0.05314704030752182,
-0.07497581094503403,
-0.30162110924720764,
-0.16932828724384308,
-0.26108768582344055,
-0.3501589894294739,
-0.018651746213436127,
-0.329018235206604,
-0.38339847326278687,
0.3078458607196808,
0.408833771944046,
0.3304296135902405,
-0.23058705031871796,
0.22218485176563263,
-0.01206921972334385,
0.0595308355987072,
0.06708796322345734,
-0.18797121942043304,
0.3555009067058563,
-0.10671123117208481,
-0.4444325566291809,
-0.14922016859054565,
0.18416014313697815,
0.42318466305732727,
-0.27007409930229187,
0.8541149497032166,
0.4691700339317322,
-0.5572900176048279,
-0.48602762818336487,
-0.6266539096832275,
-0.1237005814909935,
-0.373849481344223,
0.5745593309402466,
-0.3733277916908264,
-1.1117291450500488,
0.4672319293022156,
0.29819589853286743,
-0.02146897278726101,
0.09032446891069412,
0.6224962472915649,
0.06241618096828461,
0.8701327443122864,
0.9859970808029175,
-0.0781559869647026,
0.31807276606559753,
-0.03985578194260597,
0.14417368173599243,
-0.43223220109939575,
-0.24611034989356995,
-0.6790271997451782,
-0.030926847830414772,
-0.40509992837905884,
-0.5558156371116638,
0.19099406898021698,
0.13613972067832947,
0.06693781167268753,
0.19439426064491272,
-0.0590299516916275,
0.24329093098640442,
0.39786496758461,
0.2525535225868225,
0.5604536533355713,
0.055197086185216904,
0.05842339247465134,
0.13993395864963531,
-0.4864771366119385,
-0.35982373356819153,
1.2557796239852905,
0.7116836905479431,
1.1206293106079102,
0.22362983226776123,
0.6641257405281067,
0.1518493890762329,
0.4757288694381714,
-0.941322922706604,
0.2094980925321579,
0.19841967523097992,
-1.0422801971435547,
-0.48354941606521606,
-0.5434106588363647,
-0.6311754584312439,
0.07468768209218979,
-0.3587656617164612,
-0.9832190275192261,
0.4727028012275696,
0.20583999156951904,
-0.5038421154022217,
0.09367763251066208,
-0.8003823757171631,
0.7484713196754456,
-0.2799926698207855,
-0.3636202812194824,
-0.074298195540905,
-0.49644333124160767,
0.5619164109230042,
-0.5402931571006775,
0.08837595582008362,
-0.06824039667844772,
-0.08279430121183395,
0.37221410870552063,
-0.25523990392684937,
0.9529833793640137,
-0.19471018016338348,
-0.4183584153652191,
0.2819685637950897,
0.09632094204425812,
0.43828707933425903,
0.3619566261768341,
-0.3463976979255676,
0.29774385690689087,
0.30515849590301514,
-0.5118004679679871,
-0.9093539118766785,
0.46428239345550537,
-0.5749179720878601,
-0.6120160222053528,
-0.5150150656700134,
-0.7742397785186768,
-0.45050376653671265,
0.07766729593276978,
-0.08123539388179779,
0.27493053674697876,
-0.3333589434623718,
0.6992529630661011,
0.7520813941955566,
-0.3142366111278534,
0.2813904881477356,
0.4745013117790222,
-0.3673098385334015,
-0.22676168382167816,
0.3753041923046112,
0.14429569244384766,
0.6564394235610962,
0.6389802098274231,
0.12037510424852371,
-0.6893357634544373,
-0.6732569336891174,
-0.3482493758201599,
0.21993280947208405,
-0.4521423280239105,
-0.26709985733032227,
-0.42189306020736694,
-0.3756406307220459,
-0.17172963917255402,
0.1401999443769455,
-0.21795974671840668,
-0.4036325216293335,
0.0146945146843791,
-0.3499155044555664,
0.4754506051540375,
0.9288864731788635,
0.21702918410301208,
0.477265328168869,
-0.4537162184715271,
0.1580391228199005,
0.3168478012084961,
0.43323370814323425,
0.0613158717751503,
-0.6711381077766418,
-0.39814257621765137,
0.15273408591747284,
0.024951893836259842,
-0.7728576064109802,
0.49213990569114685,
0.10501990467309952,
0.6157204508781433,
0.19138064980506897,
0.17879287898540497,
0.5999658107757568,
-0.165846586227417,
0.5840548276901245,
0.032260723412036896,
-0.8597071766853333,
0.27227842807769775,
0.060335833579301834,
0.10325723141431808,
0.6267711520195007,
0.5475786328315735,
-0.03994045779109001,
-0.5982834696769714,
-0.6449483633041382,
-0.49307507276535034,
0.3799501657485962,
0.2636551856994629,
-0.06009741127490997,
0.333071231842041,
0.3468889594078064,
-0.011532280594110489,
0.7128103971481323,
-0.8108410835266113,
-0.25588667392730713,
-0.059585172683000565,
-0.46478936076164246,
-0.5059540271759033,
-0.5130026936531067,
-0.29842665791511536,
0.23251968622207642,
0.5568169951438904,
-0.3094639778137207,
0.20632874965667725,
0.10700832307338715,
-0.22495293617248535,
-0.0715908333659172,
0.6390883922576904,
0.3405981659889221,
0.682891845703125,
-0.654643177986145,
0.029337650164961815,
0.16926197707653046,
-0.5269657969474792,
0.2728557288646698,
0.2972441613674164,
-0.30014103651046753,
-0.021167969331145287,
0.3871346712112427,
0.6617730259895325,
0.351101279258728,
-0.6027554273605347,
0.6030026078224182,
-0.08459611237049103,
-0.1244337260723114,
-0.4390961229801178,
0.010081500746309757,
0.22332298755645752,
0.3236335515975952,
0.4332728385925293,
-0.2395133376121521,
-0.0765007734298706,
-0.5924679636955261,
0.3179396986961365,
0.7311112880706787,
-0.6528471112251282,
-0.18728645145893097,
0.3497123420238495,
-0.044707898050546646,
-0.15149924159049988,
-0.04756581783294678,
-0.11798965185880661,
-0.23949748277664185,
0.4993075728416443,
0.6635275483131409,
0.8758551478385925,
-0.23570701479911804,
0.2830865681171417,
0.198635995388031,
0.4560050666332245,
-0.24839501082897186,
0.23021464049816132,
0.38532039523124695,
-0.871870756149292,
-0.5774905681610107,
-0.8878635168075562,
-0.6173098683357239,
0.33863353729248047,
-0.8780919909477234,
0.008496887981891632,
-0.4104626476764679,
-0.16232658922672272,
-0.15773579478263855,
0.30410656332969666,
-0.6577520370483398,
0.18002185225486755,
0.024495506659150124,
1.098821759223938,
-0.8157921433448792,
0.9300042390823364,
0.4906772971153259,
-0.3864675462245941,
-1.0287401676177979,
0.12196195870637894,
-0.017624612897634506,
-1.0434422492980957,
0.12286876887083054,
0.15323299169540405,
-0.18304157257080078,
-0.021715112030506134,
-0.7943524122238159,
-0.7358289957046509,
1.1771091222763062,
0.3447122275829315,
-0.7678765058517456,
-0.057143907994031906,
0.08859837055206299,
0.56155925989151,
-0.5813308954238892,
0.2334960699081421,
0.6232336759567261,
0.37460342049598694,
0.1644017994403839,
-0.7453432083129883,
0.07235649973154068,
-0.1620948165655136,
-0.1435430347919464,
-0.038938008248806,
-0.40923771262168884,
0.33906620740890503,
-0.19772079586982727,
-0.14363007247447968,
0.35474011301994324,
0.6986533999443054,
0.4435165822505951,
0.2811114490032196,
0.6047526597976685,
0.2447158247232437,
1.0155788660049438,
0.047710247337818146,
1.088392972946167,
-0.38663583993911743,
0.3720506727695465,
1.2140392065048218,
-0.2261238694190979,
1.2649649381637573,
0.3257577121257782,
-0.2437242567539215,
0.469471275806427,
0.4163393974304199,
0.10588885843753815,
0.09584761410951614,
0.010171335190534592,
-0.3262598216533661,
-0.38217440247535706,
-0.10838152468204498,
-0.17234274744987488,
0.37186360359191895,
0.6090187430381775,
-0.250875860452652,
0.21239125728607178,
-0.39832425117492676,
0.15578840672969818,
-0.12280501425266266,
-0.3683353066444397,
0.5529285073280334,
0.617745578289032,
-0.5444610118865967,
0.5300673842430115,
-0.2491092085838318,
0.5635349750518799,
-0.8666269183158875,
0.06249077618122101,
-0.16178958117961884,
0.20609794557094574,
-0.18424254655838013,
-0.9918607473373413,
-0.1366456300020218,
0.04624027758836746,
0.15008361637592316,
0.3645070195198059,
0.6127265095710754,
-0.7486931681632996,
-0.920813798904419,
0.44265738129615784,
0.7475642561912537,
-0.04656696319580078,
-0.23887121677398682,
-0.6483250260353088,
0.03524935618042946,
-0.018358314409852028,
-0.23729702830314636,
0.34889957308769226,
0.5095471143722534,
0.05156411603093147,
0.9180159568786621,
0.5067287087440491,
0.36338120698928833,
-0.040769562125205994,
-0.0932159572839737,
0.3784675896167755,
-0.6085247993469238,
-0.328534334897995,
-0.6265321969985962,
0.4453735649585724,
-0.1240021362900734,
-0.01931353658437729,
0.7221328020095825,
0.2988690137863159,
0.6403792500495911,
-0.02830854058265686,
1.1414997577667236,
0.10639206320047379,
0.5282028913497925,
-0.5281789898872375,
0.6355621814727783,
-0.5478990077972412,
0.27494606375694275,
-0.5003716945648193,
-0.974001944065094,
-0.3752460181713104,
0.6958731412887573,
-0.38950762152671814,
-0.031978294253349304,
0.7137913107872009,
1.2273365259170532,
-0.0803861916065216,
-0.12883098423480988,
0.6345914602279663,
0.5573331713676453,
0.24737371504306793,
0.5600926280021667,
0.6582666039466858,
-0.24719636142253876,
0.7617867588996887,
-0.3371063768863678,
-0.41126465797424316,
-0.22156746685504913,
-1.0403985977172852,
-0.9124703407287598,
-0.30361080169677734,
-0.07417480647563934,
-0.7105357050895691,
0.041620854288339615,
0.8055002093315125,
0.6272279620170593,
-1.092937707901001,
-0.4049023985862732,
0.35891979932785034,
0.29491451382637024,
-0.12402748316526413,
-0.17811717092990875,
0.35236603021621704,
0.011613664217293262,
-0.7175824046134949,
0.17314478754997253,
0.19201862812042236,
0.26870256662368774,
-0.5438013672828674,
-0.08458898216485977,
-0.26161596179008484,
0.19314038753509521,
0.5245075225830078,
0.422672301530838,
-0.6607075333595276,
-0.6516658067703247,
0.1869514435529709,
-0.03119521588087082,
-0.0609346441924572,
0.48294439911842346,
-0.3768305778503418,
0.3335613012313843,
0.10375203937292099,
0.8096520900726318,
0.682700514793396,
0.31516334414482117,
0.9157024025917053,
-0.8063854575157166,
0.29772230982780457,
-0.09331783652305603,
0.4038603901863098,
0.38786983489990234,
-0.3818127512931824,
0.5786512494087219,
-0.009469750337302685,
-0.44581255316734314,
-1.0777075290679932,
0.26556289196014404,
-1.1197717189788818,
-0.09105483442544937,
1.2338480949401855,
-0.4362325966358185,
-0.3385365605354309,
-0.37349265813827515,
0.08896055072546005,
-0.12514488399028778,
-0.5044500231742859,
0.6681100130081177,
0.7956909537315369,
0.19392256438732147,
-0.30978119373321533,
-0.748024582862854,
0.4733118414878845,
0.20867519080638885,
-0.73405921459198,
0.1640947461128235,
0.41932883858680725,
0.30057471990585327,
0.1837083399295807,
0.4628622531890869,
-0.10448090732097626,
0.13153333961963654,
0.0018381444970145822,
0.05209789052605629,
0.16701693832874298,
-0.5313436985015869,
-0.55955970287323,
0.41509681940078735,
0.49373844265937805,
0.1554943174123764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00257v1
|
Are Large Vision Language Models up to the Challenge of Chart Comprehension and Reasoning? An Extensive Investigation into the Capabilities and Limitations of LVLMs
| 2024-06-01T01:43:30
| 2024-06-01T01:43:30
|
Mohammed Saidul Islam, Raian Rahman, Ahmed Masry, Md Tahmid Rahman Laskar, Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Enamul Hoque
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language is a powerful complementary modality of communication for
data visualizations, such as bar and line charts. To facilitate chart-based
reasoning using natural language, various downstream tasks have been introduced
recently such as chart question answering, chart summarization, and
fact-checking with charts. These tasks pose a unique challenge, demanding both
vision-language reasoning and a nuanced understanding of chart data tables,
visual encodings, and natural language prompts. Despite the recent success of
Large Language Models (LLMs) across diverse NLP tasks, their abilities and
limitations in the realm of data visualization remain under-explored, possibly
due to their lack of multi-modal capabilities. To bridge the gap, this paper
presents the first comprehensive evaluation of the recently developed large
vision language models (LVLMs) for chart understanding and reasoning tasks. Our
evaluation includes a comprehensive assessment of LVLMs, including GPT-4V and
Gemini, across four major chart reasoning tasks. Furthermore, we perform a
qualitative evaluation of LVLMs' performance on a diverse range of charts,
aiming to provide a thorough analysis of their strengths and weaknesses. Our
findings reveal that LVLMs demonstrate impressive abilities in generating
fluent texts covering high-level data insights while also encountering common
problems like hallucinations, factual errors, and data bias. We highlight the
key strengths and limitations of chart comprehension tasks, offering insights
for future research.
|
[
-0.3382447361946106,
-0.7319247126579285,
0.8208017349243164,
-0.002689547371119261,
-0.5017812252044678,
0.18199418485164642,
-0.13409899175167084,
-0.6593706011772156,
-0.19414940476417542,
0.8549595475196838,
-0.47268813848495483,
-0.7633548378944397,
-0.5336693525314331,
0.14393191039562225,
-0.5929536819458008,
0.5745881199836731,
-0.22552798688411713,
0.014879690483212471,
-0.2943650484085083,
-0.14980289340019226,
-0.8555827140808105,
-0.6113225221633911,
-0.4461720287799835,
-0.0639103353023529,
0.5473267436027527,
0.2730860412120819,
0.6679601073265076,
0.4003218412399292,
0.7841473817825317,
0.28999242186546326,
0.01979488506913185,
0.44381284713745117,
-0.5327635407447815,
0.36451011896133423,
0.05005737766623497,
-0.33517107367515564,
-0.2821582555770874,
-0.27049553394317627,
0.6798877716064453,
0.9645962715148926,
0.24822978675365448,
0.05341069772839546,
0.010925767943263054,
1.129683494567871,
-0.4392215311527252,
0.709077000617981,
-0.6535943150520325,
0.09508772194385529,
-0.1638808697462082,
-0.049126990139484406,
-0.6436585187911987,
-0.08036268502473831,
0.45671799778938293,
-0.7497419118881226,
-0.07421670109033585,
0.3327410817146301,
0.7530046701431274,
0.5102317333221436,
-0.7905008792877197,
-0.3580840826034546,
-0.6541306376457214,
0.7146109342575073,
-0.6249312162399292,
0.550879716873169,
0.370074599981308,
0.6133163571357727,
0.1301146000623703,
-0.9975800514221191,
-0.49628347158432007,
-0.4094920754432678,
-0.10150981694459915,
0.16493627429008484,
-0.3474942147731781,
-0.08346430212259293,
0.4568377435207367,
0.08280962705612183,
-0.6890008449554443,
0.20325039327144623,
-0.44112494587898254,
-0.09657132625579834,
0.6589255928993225,
0.4907110929489136,
0.27698272466659546,
-0.3821830153465271,
-0.31516486406326294,
-0.08413442224264145,
-0.5156827569007874,
0.18634141981601715,
-0.11176088452339172,
0.29635125398635864,
-0.1747705340385437,
0.8268387913703918,
-0.15789571404457092,
1.0964478254318237,
-0.4875886142253876,
-0.0693667083978653,
0.08993295580148697,
-0.4909905791282654,
-0.4397384822368622,
-0.3088246285915375,
0.6552025079727173,
0.5953999757766724,
0.6215702295303345,
-0.08695351332426071,
-0.21748772263526917,
0.04434012994170189,
0.19228661060333252,
-0.29724735021591187,
-0.2101847380399704,
0.20365944504737854,
-0.353677898645401,
-0.04847285896539688,
-0.20017844438552856,
-0.45695215463638306,
-0.9218115210533142,
-0.6093193292617798,
0.2787957191467285,
-0.5222803354263306,
0.05445835739374161,
0.26892608404159546,
-0.2192085236310959,
0.3309670686721802,
0.6994747519493103,
-0.6243318319320679,
-0.05762776359915733,
0.8198626041412354,
0.6482797861099243,
-0.19693616032600403,
-0.3222930431365967,
-0.5353962779045105,
0.023680010810494423,
-0.5500405430793762,
0.6168426275253296,
-0.41531211137771606,
-0.08413779735565186,
-0.0664929673075676,
-0.14308899641036987,
-0.31296998262405396,
-0.45334550738334656,
0.5783767700195312,
-0.48234686255455017,
-0.12273254990577698,
-0.4921640157699585,
-0.6994908452033997,
-0.4539250135421753,
0.40935051441192627,
-0.7832213044166565,
0.5368053317070007,
0.013075483962893486,
-0.8245576620101929,
0.48750239610671997,
-0.39563220739364624,
-0.4251234531402588,
0.3647950291633606,
-0.4806046485900879,
-0.1396377980709076,
-0.2350674867630005,
0.47527092695236206,
0.7070638537406921,
-0.45424798130989075,
0.19310146570205688,
-0.1378898322582245,
-0.28946948051452637,
0.3960719704627991,
-0.4537613093852997,
0.6292620301246643,
0.10401450842618942,
-0.2769318222999573,
0.4508745074272156,
-0.6270807981491089,
0.009596957825124264,
0.2965097725391388,
-0.054148297756910324,
-0.20021265745162964,
0.24104616045951843,
0.0353366918861866,
-0.025530455633997917,
0.09459251165390015,
-0.03791753947734833,
0.25576233863830566,
-0.28237831592559814,
0.45857980847358704,
0.6525297164916992,
-0.1205836832523346,
0.2087288498878479,
0.08178122341632843,
0.5042982697486877,
-0.0676717460155487,
0.18383915722370148,
-0.24969737231731415,
-0.8044446706771851,
-0.859909176826477,
-0.30630433559417725,
-0.07233130186796188,
0.5765171051025391,
-1.2241801023483276,
0.1819971799850464,
-0.48070937395095825,
-0.6767528653144836,
-0.14705419540405273,
0.2403271645307541,
0.11962764710187912,
0.6747679710388184,
0.2537234425544739,
-0.1005077064037323,
-0.42558541893959045,
-0.9180481433868408,
-0.05331679806113243,
-0.014429561793804169,
0.10502065718173981,
0.3039620518684387,
0.6122028231620789,
-0.12484783679246902,
0.8648820519447327,
-0.35659468173980713,
-0.19557534158229828,
-0.7027690410614014,
0.07190113514661789,
0.24945367872714996,
-0.06953530013561249,
0.7085790634155273,
-0.8568524122238159,
-0.4837173521518707,
0.14273343980312347,
-0.9894629716873169,
0.048914164304733276,
-0.23478706181049347,
0.036879200488328934,
0.240636944770813,
0.47067078948020935,
-0.4567023515701294,
0.6246976256370544,
0.6328684687614441,
-0.7534676790237427,
0.5683841705322266,
-0.17428509891033173,
-0.025407392531633377,
-0.30780261754989624,
0.06502361595630646,
0.1342775970697403,
-0.3391987681388855,
-0.8414357900619507,
0.0073433518409729,
0.08723171800374985,
-0.12245258688926697,
-0.3010609745979309,
0.4244709014892578,
-0.48062431812286377,
-0.244126558303833,
-0.10675760358572006,
0.3592517077922821,
0.10593540221452713,
0.33016106486320496,
0.17640464007854462,
0.37386661767959595,
0.9215078353881836,
-0.4908795654773712,
0.8475053906440735,
0.2631305754184723,
-0.7337285876274109,
0.4179427921772003,
-0.5876800417900085,
-0.07181033492088318,
-0.27279022336006165,
0.25636979937553406,
-0.9172033667564392,
-0.09550917893648148,
0.2574184834957123,
-0.17534089088439941,
0.11586327850818634,
-0.036460403352975845,
-0.45460206270217896,
-0.7143402099609375,
0.030197178944945335,
0.08089267462491989,
0.3430740535259247,
-0.5153939723968506,
0.5289535522460938,
0.17308147251605988,
0.010290472768247128,
-0.6996676921844482,
-0.7785455584526062,
0.41442281007766724,
-0.15581750869750977,
-0.9136438369750977,
-0.35217276215553284,
0.0027845671866089106,
-0.5081494450569153,
-0.1949242204427719,
-0.023451661691069603,
0.03993035480380058,
0.023076092824339867,
0.10230421274900436,
0.5354859828948975,
-0.22233322262763977,
0.11400432139635086,
-0.5659317970275879,
-0.21811141073703766,
0.05247626081109047,
-0.13124321401119232,
0.44843146204948425,
-0.43321385979652405,
-0.8789895176887512,
-0.3373645544052124,
0.03656936436891556,
0.7620051503181458,
-0.6300534605979919,
0.6264292597770691,
0.5532231330871582,
-0.1373116374015808,
-0.09182140231132507,
-0.4735604226589203,
0.06473904103040695,
-0.39862334728240967,
0.5145348310470581,
-0.2322862148284912,
-0.8345330953598022,
0.40429678559303284,
0.5397783517837524,
0.09022436290979385,
0.4495668113231659,
0.5002014636993408,
-0.16989775002002716,
0.9479919672012329,
0.1938600242137909,
0.07036742568016052,
0.08785319328308105,
-0.3702470064163208,
0.3451208472251892,
-0.5242071151733398,
-0.29532909393310547,
-0.21516621112823486,
-0.35106930136680603,
-0.23532843589782715,
-0.6718323230743408,
0.3865464925765991,
-0.19580180943012238,
-0.19874964654445648,
-0.1782461702823639,
-0.419940710067749,
0.2405102401971817,
0.4688657820224762,
-0.09637187421321869,
0.4213809072971344,
-0.18842089176177979,
0.19574908912181854,
-0.1503356546163559,
-0.5754324197769165,
-0.5478790402412415,
1.0997997522354126,
0.39104050397872925,
0.7511409521102905,
-0.13590043783187866,
0.12935881316661835,
0.12847821414470673,
0.10654523223638535,
-0.8775734305381775,
0.7220678329467773,
-0.1751013994216919,
-0.472470760345459,
-0.5826981663703918,
-0.4604373872280121,
-0.958939790725708,
0.45514267683029175,
-0.3926661014556885,
-0.8198715448379517,
-0.013937060721218586,
0.12771914899349213,
0.034338876605033875,
0.5036380887031555,
-0.7910580039024353,
1.139914870262146,
-0.6252399682998657,
-0.06583195179700851,
-0.055724699050188065,
-0.736465334892273,
0.4416426420211792,
-0.15263888239860535,
0.4191742539405823,
-0.14965753257274628,
0.06746260076761246,
0.526012122631073,
-0.26724204421043396,
0.8717753887176514,
-0.06688932329416275,
-0.243911474943161,
0.39195263385772705,
0.07459556311368942,
0.47360095381736755,
-0.2764825224876404,
0.11691272258758545,
0.00145323621109128,
0.007471146993339062,
-0.34675055742263794,
-0.6636297106742859,
0.3936834931373596,
-0.3979971706867218,
-0.4510335624217987,
-0.2521781921386719,
-0.6759316325187683,
-0.3933009207248688,
0.19117313623428345,
-0.04880508780479431,
0.5406017899513245,
0.17871864140033722,
0.4837496280670166,
0.28116142749786377,
-0.3507359027862549,
0.21629571914672852,
0.32622581720352173,
-0.671043336391449,
-0.06806985288858414,
0.9279155135154724,
0.1644067019224167,
0.43509894609451294,
0.30456072092056274,
0.0791604220867157,
-0.27379894256591797,
-0.9150875210762024,
-0.42694568634033203,
0.1644643396139145,
-1.1161853075027466,
0.19292278587818146,
-0.2890152633190155,
-0.1919204592704773,
-0.14369529485702515,
-0.0970817282795906,
-0.16774606704711914,
-0.381121426820755,
-0.035509027540683746,
-0.03182753920555115,
0.25933024287223816,
0.9754834771156311,
0.25720614194869995,
-0.18755832314491272,
-0.7091183066368103,
0.5364803671836853,
0.47579362988471985,
0.2085753083229065,
0.18487916886806488,
-0.2508648931980133,
-0.2162429690361023,
-0.028059279546141624,
0.03010680340230465,
-0.8627297282218933,
0.36321768164634705,
-0.3062288165092468,
0.5490974187850952,
0.44108492136001587,
-0.054511744529008865,
0.4374111592769623,
-0.2962174415588379,
0.7719635963439941,
0.20870652794837952,
-0.7776396870613098,
0.29056820273399353,
-0.3958505392074585,
0.3333847224712372,
0.04769458994269371,
0.0878043994307518,
-0.6656724214553833,
-0.6355993747711182,
-0.20733606815338135,
-0.9239808320999146,
0.44874852895736694,
0.34024935960769653,
-0.21056310832500458,
0.2521718442440033,
0.17880520224571228,
0.002319948747754097,
0.1443571299314499,
-0.8444038033485413,
-0.2815238833427429,
-0.470294326543808,
-0.23327751457691193,
-0.31838226318359375,
0.008704567328095436,
-0.05668829008936882,
-0.6109364628791809,
0.2087358683347702,
-0.23949265480041504,
-0.2493763118982315,
0.049221187829971313,
-0.08454582840204239,
0.09866155683994293,
0.2211494743824005,
0.5019067525863647,
1.0272008180618286,
-0.0437193438410759,
0.18529395759105682,
0.22583426535129547,
-0.3839226961135864,
-0.341653972864151,
0.13037006556987762,
-0.1514030247926712,
-0.19059695303440094,
0.9247073531150818,
1.3230141401290894,
0.1338798701763153,
-1.0808897018432617,
0.4831502139568329,
-0.14395999908447266,
-0.21755030751228333,
-0.17771802842617035,
-0.08443203568458557,
0.44529715180397034,
0.3713415861129761,
0.528343677520752,
-0.08285917341709137,
-0.15961574018001556,
-0.4626552164554596,
-0.1764688640832901,
0.6101930141448975,
-0.2644060254096985,
0.13118647038936615,
0.6922184228897095,
0.13472861051559448,
0.10025913268327713,
0.7316645383834839,
0.04897391051054001,
-0.5673486590385437,
0.8123406767845154,
0.11970897763967514,
0.39710062742233276,
0.4144408404827118,
0.14681510627269745,
0.17753925919532776,
0.6706803441047668,
0.2582598626613617,
0.2821752429008484,
0.17348285019397736,
-0.7340518832206726,
-0.7237399816513062,
-0.286845326423645,
-0.6358706951141357,
0.1279912292957306,
-0.4212382137775421,
0.1241522952914238,
-0.2868694067001343,
-0.05025947839021683,
0.08550217002630234,
-0.2893548309803009,
-0.9935774207115173,
0.2957957983016968,
0.5949147343635559,
0.846786618232727,
-0.6019416451454163,
0.5534909963607788,
0.5703029036521912,
-0.47247499227523804,
-0.7865784168243408,
-0.30160626769065857,
0.048911791294813156,
-1.0122298002243042,
0.9206095337867737,
0.22486209869384766,
0.030889449641108513,
-0.1774425357580185,
-0.5748516917228699,
-0.6610469222068787,
1.0902549028396606,
0.35215088725090027,
-0.6614362597465515,
-0.15559546649456024,
0.4304674565792084,
0.7207269668579102,
-0.2630930244922638,
0.03192725032567978,
0.6217725276947021,
0.9437984228134155,
0.11646943539381027,
-0.9879621267318726,
-0.018770573660731316,
0.033454395830631256,
-0.2712986469268799,
-0.09988217055797577,
-0.3019140064716339,
0.8176636695861816,
-0.3248358368873596,
-0.1964525431394577,
-0.13226661086082458,
0.5749379992485046,
0.20500262081623077,
0.47589632868766785,
0.6666162014007568,
0.3221835196018219,
0.8974141478538513,
-0.2716395854949951,
1.3890142440795898,
-0.10692089051008224,
0.17399533092975616,
0.9111565947532654,
-0.41620561480522156,
0.8608609437942505,
0.36270076036453247,
-0.06551356613636017,
0.34944063425064087,
0.2968839704990387,
-0.11564789712429047,
0.13076521456241608,
0.1812795251607895,
0.17670314013957977,
-0.5643441081047058,
0.1343560814857483,
-0.26490649580955505,
0.5418985486030579,
0.41297921538352966,
-0.2526838481426239,
-0.12093640863895416,
0.06305178999900818,
-0.3997134268283844,
0.0435757152736187,
-0.44422414898872375,
0.45175257325172424,
0.1304147094488144,
-0.5197974443435669,
0.7659642100334167,
-0.39488062262535095,
0.20364682376384735,
-0.630700409412384,
0.13106325268745422,
0.11429344117641449,
0.028005579486489296,
-0.03057750128209591,
-1.348810076713562,
0.22163626551628113,
0.09835394471883774,
0.245878204703331,
-0.309451162815094,
0.6819177269935608,
-0.20831206440925598,
-0.5090215802192688,
0.30679383873939514,
0.6820394396781921,
0.02600213512778282,
-0.21212145686149597,
-0.5818489789962769,
0.2874012887477875,
0.13826727867126465,
-0.33274737000465393,
-0.06181690841913223,
0.48296254873275757,
0.008776461705565453,
1.2522093057632446,
0.500313401222229,
0.0557570606470108,
0.1593843698501587,
0.5147876739501953,
0.6910606026649475,
-0.800754725933075,
-0.3639254868030548,
-0.7467160820960999,
0.6451357007026672,
-0.07630959898233414,
-0.04909639433026314,
0.7866035103797913,
0.503865122795105,
0.3523431122303009,
-0.18870285153388977,
0.917058527469635,
0.2943207323551178,
0.5878647565841675,
-0.7961951494216919,
0.6896829605102539,
-0.6978744268417358,
0.2002427577972412,
-0.29553142189979553,
-0.6569106578826904,
-0.5127570629119873,
0.4749270975589752,
-0.6178606748580933,
-0.14821410179138184,
0.900414228439331,
0.25549978017807007,
0.06887497007846832,
0.07993077486753464,
0.47224241495132446,
0.41235893964767456,
0.46847087144851685,
0.747488796710968,
1.0784757137298584,
0.15402032434940338,
0.854857325553894,
-0.0837085023522377,
0.08072686940431595,
-0.16913138329982758,
-0.8150098323822021,
-1.110664963722229,
-0.7523369193077087,
-0.08207309246063232,
0.01623612642288208,
-0.2771492898464203,
0.3589214086532593,
0.3857147991657257,
-0.47980305552482605,
-0.11258956789970398,
-0.009694840759038925,
0.200350821018219,
0.00004556598651106469,
-0.20120717585086823,
0.5305413007736206,
-0.056598860770463943,
-0.5387023091316223,
0.5024889707565308,
0.5182330012321472,
0.14538080990314484,
-0.5468578934669495,
-0.20861013233661652,
0.13848023116588593,
-0.08133912086486816,
0.7654788494110107,
0.1952551156282425,
-0.9615630507469177,
-0.4108242094516754,
-0.024620244279503822,
-0.18576712906360626,
0.05382620915770531,
0.6505318284034729,
-0.7642205953598022,
0.7209455966949463,
0.5323634147644043,
0.5030059218406677,
0.5905556082725525,
-0.24668993055820465,
0.40527957677841187,
-0.33801811933517456,
0.1445813626050949,
0.28289180994033813,
0.7825976014137268,
0.6108860969543457,
0.05801699310541153,
0.5767577290534973,
0.11396133899688721,
-0.4120746850967407,
-0.7716134190559387,
0.3597460091114044,
-1.3216267824172974,
-0.30195218324661255,
1.0255213975906372,
0.17707973718643188,
-0.0161204282194376,
-0.27282312512397766,
-0.6493233442306519,
0.06394588202238083,
0.10677222162485123,
0.4519916772842407,
0.8015691637992859,
-0.24659305810928345,
-0.3135133683681488,
-0.9394028186798096,
0.24362969398498535,
0.2952022850513458,
-0.9908767938613892,
0.3257019519805908,
0.7593134641647339,
-0.12307191640138626,
0.05023641884326935,
0.5584293007850647,
0.30521708726882935,
0.19950851798057556,
-0.06932128220796585,
-0.21650339663028717,
-0.1162920594215393,
-0.09117858111858368,
-0.04521678760647774,
0.12162623554468155,
0.2504607141017914,
0.12941737473011017
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00252v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00252v3
|
Multi-Modal and Multi-Agent Systems Meet Rationality: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T01:17:25
| 2024-06-18T04:22:39
|
Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Xiaomeng Wang, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Tanwi Mallick
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MA
|
Rationality is the quality of being guided by reason, characterized by
logical thinking and decision-making that align with evidence and logical
rules. This quality is essential for effective problem-solving, as it ensures
that solutions are well-founded and systematically derived. Despite the
advancements of large language models (LLMs) in generating human-like text with
remarkable accuracy, they present biases inherited from the training data,
inconsistency across different contexts, and difficulty understanding complex
scenarios involving multiple layers of context. Therefore, recent research
attempts to leverage the strength of multiple agents working collaboratively
with various types of data and tools for enhanced consistency and reliability.
To that end, this paper aims to understand whether multi-modal and multi-agent
systems are advancing toward rationality by surveying the state-of-the-art
works, identifying advancements over single-agent and single-modal systems in
terms of rationality, and discussing open problems and future directions. We
maintain an open repository at https://github.com/bowen-upenn/MMMA_Rationality.
|
[
-0.4866141974925995,
-0.6902874708175659,
1.0079963207244873,
0.20095492899417877,
0.1510448306798935,
0.07763934135437012,
-0.21466276049613953,
-0.3432199954986572,
0.01195889338850975,
0.10487259179353714,
-0.622195839881897,
-0.12653590738773346,
-0.4586475193500519,
0.3575533926486969,
0.10123510658740997,
0.6906355619430542,
-0.04560575261712074,
0.37447068095207214,
-0.21609999239444733,
-0.6285519599914551,
-0.6239489316940308,
-0.6524202227592468,
-0.45042362809181213,
-0.38913512229919434,
0.4864659905433655,
0.3168585002422333,
0.9564741849899292,
0.45216506719589233,
0.280121773481369,
0.4343469440937042,
0.2629760205745697,
0.4331735372543335,
-0.29083356261253357,
0.6196793913841248,
-0.35976454615592957,
-0.40133601427078247,
-0.5884107351303101,
0.3482303023338318,
0.6261175870895386,
0.5005980134010315,
0.07248274236917496,
-0.18842723965644836,
-0.11821811646223068,
0.5689616203308105,
-0.5547547936439514,
0.18917708098888397,
-0.2978687882423401,
-0.2708914875984192,
0.08343695849180222,
-0.37958523631095886,
-0.40866297483444214,
-0.3653050661087036,
0.02848866768181324,
-0.9589833617210388,
-0.2747136652469635,
0.22197897732257843,
0.5486165881156921,
0.2605241537094116,
-0.807710587978363,
-0.509093165397644,
-0.7123391032218933,
0.9498587846755981,
-0.4693600535392761,
0.3981015086174011,
0.2468368113040924,
0.5105973482131958,
-0.46157971024513245,
-0.38072314858436584,
-0.6722986698150635,
-0.2926289141178131,
0.1477535516023636,
0.06047078222036362,
0.17641191184520721,
-0.03584494814276695,
0.20932362973690033,
-0.03827490657567978,
-0.23497998714447021,
-0.34513166546821594,
-0.02158404141664505,
-0.27639445662498474,
0.5602232217788696,
0.2715809941291809,
0.3161484897136688,
0.0716608464717865,
-0.6786205172538757,
-0.03268079832196236,
-0.38500842452049255,
0.1605057269334793,
0.17750762403011322,
0.07464077323675156,
0.09131153672933578,
0.5913605093955994,
-0.36774709820747375,
0.43872109055519104,
-0.0847623199224472,
-0.598777711391449,
0.06858108937740326,
-0.8904405236244202,
-0.2752751410007477,
-0.33451175689697266,
0.5810539126396179,
0.2733362317085266,
0.2336779534816742,
-0.058905620127916336,
-0.5799158811569214,
0.29294365644454956,
0.03994694724678993,
-0.3634142577648163,
0.2025492787361145,
0.33493348956108093,
-0.43867576122283936,
-0.1617433726787567,
0.01122467964887619,
-0.284641295671463,
-0.5102077722549438,
-1.037757158279419,
0.4652518928050995,
-0.6351069808006287,
-0.7206824421882629,
0.24754144251346588,
-0.12278507649898529,
0.17982983589172363,
0.864154577255249,
-0.5435200333595276,
-0.030951399356126785,
0.7529189586639404,
0.7209428548812866,
0.08187606185674667,
-0.6473819017410278,
-0.2093612253665924,
0.2631895840167999,
-0.39291277527809143,
1.0550607442855835,
-0.5040601491928101,
-0.044895220547914505,
-0.22265557944774628,
-0.036944519728422165,
-0.3600465655326843,
-0.30394503474235535,
0.5842863917350769,
-0.6490829586982727,
0.2908170223236084,
-0.6476308703422546,
-0.40857353806495667,
-0.2294469177722931,
0.7406600713729858,
-0.6027266979217529,
0.5309311151504517,
0.026377366855740547,
-0.5049766302108765,
0.6030728220939636,
-0.7374153733253479,
0.10791369527578354,
-0.12209510803222656,
-0.31474336981773376,
0.14945150911808014,
0.09341584891080856,
-0.031158406287431717,
0.3128601014614105,
-0.5501643419265747,
0.5406579375267029,
-0.4319590628147125,
-0.1099044606089592,
0.7891331911087036,
-0.6243665218353271,
0.6600539684295654,
0.424395352602005,
-0.12298552691936493,
0.5657808184623718,
-0.7267812490463257,
0.19837267696857452,
-0.03013993799686432,
-0.4974673092365265,
-0.09622284024953842,
0.1434253752231598,
0.11598271876573563,
0.7333396077156067,
0.3130878508090973,
-0.23095284402370453,
0.40079495310783386,
0.12060330808162689,
0.3965711295604706,
0.8826846480369568,
-0.17754527926445007,
0.5943151712417603,
-0.9031599760055542,
0.3952357769012451,
0.12507975101470947,
0.2831695079803467,
-0.26673004031181335,
-0.3863835334777832,
-0.5302877426147461,
-0.48901793360710144,
-0.04953857883810997,
0.5813167691230774,
-0.9189537167549133,
0.23339763283729553,
-0.12855951488018036,
-0.2128576785326004,
-0.2189168781042099,
-0.20603764057159424,
0.01577737182378769,
0.40835025906562805,
0.10067714005708694,
-0.03991071134805679,
-0.3036394715309143,
-0.7736522555351257,
-0.057376980781555176,
-0.19860750436782837,
0.09697116911411285,
-0.007666132412850857,
0.4572781026363373,
-0.5271022915840149,
1.0479847192764282,
0.06482637673616409,
0.0598582997918129,
-0.07755675911903381,
0.05075003206729889,
-0.23350171744823456,
0.582456111907959,
0.25975990295410156,
-0.8339605927467346,
-0.19112204015254974,
0.11068695783615112,
-1.1356968879699707,
0.03021962381899357,
-0.07697741687297821,
-0.18652282655239105,
0.4617563486099243,
0.13237352669239044,
-0.7911662459373474,
0.17845098674297333,
0.24317814409732819,
-0.6464331746101379,
0.6459782123565674,
-0.09712225198745728,
0.5929107666015625,
-1.0829921960830688,
0.12318210303783417,
-0.1038435623049736,
-0.188897043466568,
-0.7161628603935242,
-0.16428256034851074,
-0.21279440820217133,
0.1587388664484024,
-0.08309490233659744,
0.2810201942920685,
-0.5581606030464172,
-0.18252570927143097,
-0.36059635877609253,
0.25618427991867065,
0.15634813904762268,
0.4181596040725708,
-0.22416812181472778,
0.9406145215034485,
0.5153180360794067,
-0.41903024911880493,
0.42839595675468445,
-0.014563928358256817,
0.15344040095806122,
0.9760291576385498,
-0.34645208716392517,
0.017095046117901802,
-0.2918604910373688,
0.1694691777229309,
-0.651534914970398,
-0.4663766622543335,
0.4012291431427002,
-0.506788969039917,
-0.1603231132030487,
0.15855030715465546,
-0.5434404611587524,
0.22208760678768158,
-0.24892368912696838,
0.6596153378486633,
0.10408718138933182,
-0.1845364272594452,
0.7382038831710815,
0.40680617094039917,
-0.04950445517897606,
-0.7438827157020569,
-0.21592240035533905,
0.062146350741386414,
0.13872191309928894,
-1.2333829402923584,
-0.37308263778686523,
-0.18404169380664825,
-0.6857565641403198,
-0.13340583443641663,
0.015051474794745445,
-0.21330957114696503,
-0.03266691043972969,
0.024601692333817482,
0.30214422941207886,
-0.3938117027282715,
0.3064832091331482,
-0.05215837061405182,
-0.19296619296073914,
0.1702701598405838,
-0.21745724976062775,
0.4791015386581421,
-0.5258311629295349,
-0.4163872301578522,
-0.5627139806747437,
0.5302033424377441,
1.2035785913467407,
-0.2236434370279312,
0.8190266489982605,
0.27733713388442993,
-0.4446256160736084,
-0.11448422074317932,
-0.6499437093734741,
-0.26972052454948425,
-0.440290629863739,
-0.12395630031824112,
-0.5513746738433838,
-0.8105178475379944,
0.5308453440666199,
-0.28397664427757263,
-0.07177937775850296,
0.2670551538467407,
0.5126851201057434,
0.16636644303798676,
1.296417474746704,
0.5206162333488464,
0.3268982470035553,
0.18137821555137634,
0.13602961599826813,
-0.0205084215849638,
-0.4630267322063446,
-0.5564242005348206,
-0.45636266469955444,
0.02782389149069786,
-0.3810243010520935,
-0.38841748237609863,
0.4260970652103424,
0.26876404881477356,
-0.3281666338443756,
0.0453234426677227,
-0.46093612909317017,
0.19029487669467926,
0.3960530757904053,
-0.1802988499403,
0.7285531163215637,
-0.16773772239685059,
-0.23475401103496552,
0.13166916370391846,
-0.6739604473114014,
-1.0056930780410767,
0.9297546744346619,
0.3742751479148865,
0.4750455319881439,
0.3859935998916626,
0.24589204788208008,
0.32037752866744995,
0.4432472288608551,
-0.7215061783790588,
0.5091572403907776,
0.8487128615379333,
-0.7522593140602112,
-0.6471157670021057,
-0.3838808834552765,
-0.9827216863632202,
0.6933898329734802,
-0.39708468317985535,
-0.19745226204395294,
0.3471253216266632,
0.02471579611301422,
0.006393387448042631,
0.10881783813238144,
-0.5928266644477844,
0.7660267949104309,
-0.1419748216867447,
-0.4850027859210968,
-0.3817903399467468,
-0.6312463879585266,
0.4379452168941498,
-0.0239709485322237,
0.4144817590713501,
-0.4176308214664459,
-0.3918929398059845,
0.3683609962463379,
-0.296883761882782,
0.331888347864151,
-0.1366291344165802,
-0.2339928299188614,
0.3745615482330322,
-0.02292369119822979,
0.3637169599533081,
0.34228548407554626,
-0.08035621792078018,
-0.10833179950714111,
0.30387523770332336,
-0.6831601858139038,
-0.5780632495880127,
0.6486889123916626,
-0.8411456942558289,
-0.4373779892921448,
-0.7711538672447205,
-0.7203218936920166,
-0.36235836148262024,
0.3981275260448456,
-0.16730336844921112,
0.6181272268295288,
-0.2060897946357727,
-0.04571174457669258,
0.7567258477210999,
0.2604653537273407,
0.4223576486110687,
0.630368173122406,
-0.1223103329539299,
-0.6422514319419861,
0.8154065608978271,
0.21724724769592285,
0.38160210847854614,
-0.11291997879743576,
-0.13631360232830048,
-0.24861478805541992,
-0.41058847308158875,
-0.724968433380127,
0.20930853486061096,
-0.7174837589263916,
-0.1441669464111328,
-0.5089958310127258,
0.09788217395544052,
-0.46893638372421265,
-0.2599022090435028,
-0.3112918436527252,
-0.36364391446113586,
-0.14108149707317352,
0.292265921831131,
-0.01242664735764265,
1.1451122760772705,
-0.22196321189403534,
-0.14191339910030365,
-0.7863218784332275,
0.17929650843143463,
0.2934323847293854,
0.2405107021331787,
0.033777110278606415,
-0.09244478493928909,
-0.22252672910690308,
0.2152436524629593,
-0.428165078163147,
-0.8766932487487793,
0.18906034529209137,
-0.4814952313899994,
0.6036100387573242,
0.3813888728618622,
0.016528526321053505,
0.1110638752579689,
-0.2109728455543518,
0.3818877935409546,
0.3370820879936218,
-0.9401106238365173,
0.38843610882759094,
-0.758820652961731,
0.16181805729866028,
0.6522077322006226,
0.3516296148300171,
-0.5093921422958374,
0.051496852189302444,
-0.2853621244430542,
-0.2858969569206238,
0.8035736680030823,
0.31123587489128113,
-0.5806110501289368,
0.14647117257118225,
0.016120117157697678,
0.10217923671007156,
0.3447447121143341,
-0.6000561118125916,
0.017772430554032326,
-0.38424432277679443,
-0.23738491535186768,
0.17329952120780945,
-0.0120351891964674,
-0.4434345066547394,
0.03853907063603401,
0.5966256260871887,
-0.3885323703289032,
0.1768476963043213,
0.38159146904945374,
-0.035703182220458984,
-0.23995190858840942,
0.8943230509757996,
0.8818815350532532,
1.0804036855697632,
0.02585570514202118,
0.06965179741382599,
-0.12297284603118896,
-0.11905500292778015,
0.6462770700454712,
0.04102456569671631,
-0.15428173542022705,
-0.44366565346717834,
0.1858888566493988,
0.46945908665657043,
-0.18958358466625214,
-0.7488079071044922,
0.5660578012466431,
-0.030286578461527824,
-0.1451224982738495,
-0.37843307852745056,
-0.010720383375883102,
-0.10818642377853394,
0.4758722186088562,
0.5296858549118042,
0.694538414478302,
0.14469610154628754,
-0.9203039407730103,
-0.16712819039821625,
0.613938570022583,
-0.1910068392753601,
-0.4767095744609833,
0.33218732476234436,
0.30822375416755676,
-0.2580588757991791,
0.1579638570547104,
-0.2727416157722473,
-0.24732322990894318,
0.56422358751297,
0.3580905497074127,
0.7226051688194275,
0.05663583427667618,
0.10770067572593689,
0.0555218830704689,
0.5587950348854065,
-0.494762122631073,
0.5004802346229553,
-0.03709087893366814,
-0.963015615940094,
-0.544161319732666,
-0.19847561419010162,
-0.6140633225440979,
-0.24700003862380981,
-0.3303638994693756,
0.05394883453845978,
-0.37397944927215576,
-0.3488368093967438,
-0.26799699664115906,
-0.1863313615322113,
-0.27090296149253845,
0.10800493508577347,
-0.04529089853167534,
0.6181896328926086,
-0.5353496074676514,
0.7978572845458984,
0.8465166687965393,
-0.5356737375259399,
-0.782874584197998,
-0.2177470624446869,
0.10402759909629822,
-0.34698235988616943,
0.3911723792552948,
0.24353574216365814,
-0.5392153859138489,
-0.21828171610832214,
-0.6663470268249512,
-0.9609950184822083,
1.3993984460830688,
0.40472739934921265,
-0.14087483286857605,
-0.0440526120364666,
0.1556246131658554,
0.42079058289527893,
-0.5073641538619995,
0.24882002174854279,
0.3652811050415039,
0.9112403988838196,
-0.22470977902412415,
-0.9264286756515503,
0.151451975107193,
-0.27063247561454773,
-0.17894965410232544,
0.08857601881027222,
-0.8128868937492371,
0.966067373752594,
0.005070393905043602,
-0.4122661054134369,
0.03887389972805977,
0.4978058338165283,
0.5746696591377258,
0.8689460158348083,
0.5215208530426025,
0.34235283732414246,
0.7814767956733704,
-0.22695143520832062,
0.6929558515548706,
-0.35510799288749695,
0.09426021575927734,
0.5074008703231812,
-0.4688068628311157,
0.3517904579639435,
0.43845221400260925,
0.06881800293922424,
0.5004891753196716,
0.11480409651994705,
0.4910185635089874,
-0.038987431675195694,
-0.19602620601654053,
-0.561942458152771,
-0.6240013241767883,
-0.3447337746620178,
-0.4008585512638092,
0.2237795889377594,
0.3734549283981323,
0.03974530100822449,
-0.03722342476248741,
0.25996437668800354,
-0.1034768596291542,
0.3422475755214691,
-0.2336912453174591,
0.6575340628623962,
-0.18032090365886688,
-1.0540621280670166,
0.48798272013664246,
-0.018282484263181686,
0.7433828711509705,
-0.5741891264915466,
-0.016731489449739456,
-0.0442003533244133,
0.035154521465301514,
-0.22576065361499786,
-0.513353705406189,
0.10602887719869614,
-0.4019203186035156,
-0.6444001793861389,
-0.3440946340560913,
0.8927958011627197,
-0.28097835183143616,
0.0011940989643335342,
0.23424381017684937,
1.2406666278839111,
-0.1545821875333786,
0.041240036487579346,
-0.5320605635643005,
0.30306628346443176,
-0.3084772527217865,
-0.1922595351934433,
0.26571574807167053,
0.9252328872680664,
-0.13318772614002228,
0.8911154866218567,
0.7128094434738159,
-0.1829410344362259,
0.08459728211164474,
-0.11841649562120438,
1.0084024667739868,
-0.719832718372345,
-0.12130744010210037,
-0.46121522784233093,
0.45457959175109863,
-0.18732084333896637,
-0.38442516326904297,
0.7501465678215027,
0.33995261788368225,
0.5954828262329102,
0.08159399777650833,
0.7189353704452515,
0.03558824956417084,
0.3453540503978729,
-0.38304242491722107,
0.5340942740440369,
-0.4080771505832672,
0.3149765431880951,
0.01817297749221325,
-0.7710062265396118,
-0.055835217237472534,
0.48247843980789185,
-0.06227567046880722,
0.11343032121658325,
0.8442608714103699,
0.9150751829147339,
0.12394639104604721,
0.29453611373901367,
0.46349042654037476,
-0.2295091450214386,
0.23221921920776367,
0.43682199716567993,
1.3732643127441406,
-0.24057114124298096,
0.3253403902053833,
0.03400849550962448,
-0.5004128217697144,
0.011771430261433125,
-0.4196678698062897,
-0.7573666572570801,
-0.7418854236602783,
0.021466728299856186,
-0.2718164026737213,
0.027225028723478317,
1.3228888511657715,
0.6693876385688782,
-0.6992653012275696,
-0.24811142683029175,
-0.20914438366889954,
0.2347927987575531,
-0.04526973515748978,
-0.23128369450569153,
-0.20182929933071136,
-0.6693564653396606,
-0.5768000483512878,
0.5918698906898499,
0.5345449447631836,
0.10790131986141205,
-0.4957987368106842,
-0.3912109434604645,
-0.40022173523902893,
0.5863398313522339,
0.8493669629096985,
0.3557947278022766,
-0.7510704398155212,
-0.2691382169723511,
0.28833386301994324,
-0.5578675270080566,
0.02713736891746521,
0.9978328943252563,
-0.6826713681221008,
0.34318360686302185,
0.5853486061096191,
0.5183637142181396,
-0.36229419708251953,
0.007778916973620653,
0.5883825421333313,
0.1030697375535965,
-0.037090662866830826,
0.2999207377433777,
0.44113877415657043,
0.2916654646396637,
-0.0792027935385704,
0.5421907305717468,
0.5139663219451904,
-1.0576856136322021,
-0.6640661954879761,
0.421627014875412,
-1.108449935913086,
-0.27927902340888977,
0.988187849521637,
0.15410271286964417,
0.059599511325359344,
-0.7339662909507751,
-0.6059470176696777,
0.18954548239707947,
-0.6909016966819763,
0.5255418419837952,
0.833040177822113,
-0.36997905373573303,
0.0665859654545784,
-0.33815687894821167,
0.45343756675720215,
0.5459882020950317,
-0.9159935712814331,
-0.08708687871694565,
1.1094515323638916,
0.05412747338414192,
0.33756309747695923,
0.9203372597694397,
0.09113854914903641,
0.39205580949783325,
0.02958645671606064,
-0.10636848956346512,
-0.1392785608768463,
-0.5621446371078491,
-0.3425704836845398,
0.5921585559844971,
0.2976014018058777,
0.2544112205505371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01624v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01624v2
|
Unveiling Hidden Factors: Explainable AI for Feature Boosting in Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-06-01T00:39:55
| 2024-06-05T22:21:55
|
Alaa Nfissi, Wassim Bouachir, Nizar Bouguila, Brian Mishara
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.1; I.2.8
|
Speech emotion recognition (SER) has gained significant attention due to its
several application fields, such as mental health, education, and
human-computer interaction. However, the accuracy of SER systems is hindered by
high-dimensional feature sets that may contain irrelevant and redundant
information. To overcome this challenge, this study proposes an iterative
feature boosting approach for SER that emphasizes feature relevance and
explainability to enhance machine learning model performance. Our approach
involves meticulous feature selection and analysis to build efficient SER
systems. In addressing our main problem through model explainability, we employ
a feature evaluation loop with Shapley values to iteratively refine feature
sets. This process strikes a balance between model performance and
transparency, which enables a comprehensive understanding of the model's
predictions. The proposed approach offers several advantages, including the
identification and removal of irrelevant and redundant features, leading to a
more effective model. Additionally, it promotes explainability, facilitating
comprehension of the model's predictions and the identification of crucial
features for emotion determination. The effectiveness of the proposed method is
validated on the SER benchmarks of the Toronto emotional speech set (TESS),
Berlin Database of Emotional Speech (EMO-DB), Ryerson Audio-Visual Database of
Emotional Speech and Song (RAVDESS), and Surrey Audio-Visual Expressed Emotion
(SAVEE) datasets, outperforming state-of-the-art methods. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work to incorporate model explainability into an
SER framework. The source code of this paper is publicly available via this
https://github.com/alaaNfissi/Unveiling-Hidden-Factors-Explainable-AI-for-Feature-Boosting-in-Speech-Emotion-Recognition.
|
[
-0.5599433183670044,
-0.4111660420894623,
0.31814044713974,
0.2136220484972,
-0.28935953974723816,
0.005834659561514854,
-0.12595131993293762,
-0.45441338419914246,
0.1172569990158081,
0.31454017758369446,
-0.6711592674255371,
-0.29770419001579285,
-0.5614223480224609,
-0.19736066460609436,
-0.596149742603302,
0.9766121506690979,
0.024245088919997215,
0.03629384562373161,
-0.13892023265361786,
-0.40629440546035767,
-0.15205202996730804,
-0.39122381806373596,
-0.47706013917922974,
-0.4683815538883209,
0.25413522124290466,
0.4190272092819214,
0.3246091902256012,
0.6256962418556213,
0.1473836749792099,
0.32833540439605713,
-0.41513821482658386,
-0.027358928695321083,
-0.4684743881225586,
0.3578546941280365,
0.20271681249141693,
-0.27960482239723206,
-0.3201867938041687,
-0.15684017539024353,
0.3655225336551666,
0.4739938974380493,
0.0898379310965538,
0.30527400970458984,
0.09970314800739288,
0.7867958545684814,
-0.6619747281074524,
0.3474298417568207,
-0.5656675100326538,
0.040620435029268265,
0.016263116151094437,
-0.20830780267715454,
-0.0462685264647007,
-0.17711128294467926,
0.4425909221172333,
-0.3572365939617157,
0.352919340133667,
-0.023701129481196404,
0.6832496523857117,
0.4870046377182007,
-0.16492043435573578,
-0.41415148973464966,
-0.5600590109825134,
0.48061737418174744,
-0.5787451267242432,
0.2962018549442291,
0.4222068190574646,
0.2843349874019623,
0.29355186223983765,
-0.48758214712142944,
-0.4798785150051117,
-0.26274776458740234,
0.0950404480099678,
0.08360190689563751,
-0.31859004497528076,
0.04270143061876297,
0.47344088554382324,
0.6436775326728821,
-0.4341387450695038,
0.16730719804763794,
0.0007482088403776288,
-0.17856842279434204,
0.47055843472480774,
-0.07137175649404526,
0.20756570994853973,
-0.14280244708061218,
-0.1213153526186943,
-0.21626754105091095,
-0.1804438978433609,
0.6113178730010986,
0.24495774507522583,
0.484571635723114,
-0.17286449670791626,
0.2652771770954132,
-0.15853345394134521,
0.05240503326058388,
0.011881167069077492,
0.019804345443844795,
0.2820337116718292,
0.20047061145305634,
-0.05379066616296768,
0.1901426762342453,
0.38528764247894287,
0.04961571842432022,
0.04551336169242859,
-0.07038252800703049,
-0.21560944616794586,
0.06376618146896362,
0.1763104945421219,
-0.9817999601364136,
-0.031434085220098495,
0.64976567029953,
-0.525135338306427,
-0.3905598819255829,
-0.19588901102542877,
-0.9822611212730408,
-0.7220954895019531,
-0.027279790490865707,
0.5664973258972168,
-0.4840340316295624,
-0.3315749764442444,
-0.3178163170814514,
-0.07857012003660202,
0.026208534836769104,
0.007278135046362877,
-0.8215248584747314,
-0.06495793908834457,
0.6592192649841309,
0.7134833335876465,
0.04493875429034233,
-0.11158962547779083,
-0.5441727042198181,
-0.25010374188423157,
-0.13241907954216003,
0.3295898139476776,
-0.768726110458374,
-0.2398119568824768,
0.031515587121248245,
-0.022342143580317497,
0.20765931904315948,
-0.4122200012207031,
0.8356987237930298,
-0.16224978864192963,
0.14205583930015564,
-0.3052145838737488,
-0.5855900645256042,
-0.6131499409675598,
-0.1715778112411499,
-0.7213572263717651,
0.7277063727378845,
-0.07424360513687134,
-0.6626100540161133,
0.19675661623477936,
-0.8422120809555054,
-0.3389558494091034,
0.08089525997638702,
0.12050887197256088,
-0.7532481551170349,
0.5262454152107239,
0.42746779322624207,
0.3349783718585968,
-0.2608255445957184,
0.2779499888420105,
-0.5683992505073547,
-0.5390903949737549,
0.3041624426841736,
-0.48021042346954346,
0.6385012865066528,
0.3665209710597992,
-0.6775312423706055,
0.3270115852355957,
-1.0019019842147827,
0.06861569732427597,
0.04909515380859375,
0.15728551149368286,
-0.03207555040717125,
-0.02459397353231907,
-0.1274816393852234,
0.0806264728307724,
0.0987631306052208,
-0.30855488777160645,
-0.31503504514694214,
-0.2141065150499344,
0.5170732736587524,
0.49718302488327026,
-0.13444066047668457,
0.21184587478637695,
-0.15868894755840302,
0.7732473611831665,
0.002544520189985633,
0.07197768986225128,
-0.6022825241088867,
-0.27037033438682556,
-0.7286095023155212,
-0.6387985348701477,
0.35340505838394165,
0.44266995787620544,
-0.448123037815094,
0.48133671283721924,
0.08589500933885574,
-0.44206467270851135,
-1.0977213382720947,
-0.2269892692565918,
0.5876641869544983,
0.8404958844184875,
0.24106675386428833,
0.07917163521051407,
-0.5162484049797058,
-0.7432916760444641,
-0.2605508267879486,
-0.10246969759464264,
-0.033845726400613785,
0.6083456873893738,
0.28331640362739563,
-0.30255547165870667,
0.5485502481460571,
0.03377664089202881,
0.054509732872247696,
-0.08687535673379898,
0.5528250336647034,
-0.005132652819156647,
0.275977224111557,
0.4197835326194763,
-0.9444344639778137,
0.029357725754380226,
-0.12072263658046722,
-0.5825745463371277,
-0.37451890110969543,
0.05101040378212929,
0.1904813051223755,
0.08793966472148895,
-0.12013183534145355,
-0.10009896010160446,
0.7173925638198853,
0.3345991373062134,
-0.28891831636428833,
0.3542976379394531,
-0.2881741225719452,
0.3422071933746338,
-0.7269490361213684,
0.3446101248264313,
-0.023508241400122643,
-0.2001211792230606,
-0.719046950340271,
-0.07841116935014725,
-0.07743026316165924,
-0.7340670824050903,
-0.1856205314397812,
0.38787105679512024,
-0.27518007159233093,
-0.3999348282814026,
-0.5256244540214539,
0.17199277877807617,
-0.06566371023654938,
0.631826639175415,
-0.10978274047374725,
0.5630069971084595,
0.8855150938034058,
-0.5674490332603455,
0.2705448865890503,
0.2624654173851013,
-0.12262966483831406,
0.4187418222427368,
-0.5740866661071777,
0.030817141756415367,
-0.18244554102420807,
-0.06371967494487762,
-0.9060642719268799,
-0.16504080593585968,
-0.23292912542819977,
-0.6478903293609619,
0.17093704640865326,
-0.11106103658676147,
0.044636957347393036,
-0.3232484459877014,
-0.23107124865055084,
0.13238051533699036,
0.7207157611846924,
-0.7466798424720764,
0.6876274943351746,
0.4394499957561493,
-0.3369714021682739,
-0.5579429268836975,
-0.27916690707206726,
0.0029752536211162806,
-0.5339205265045166,
-0.5408750176429749,
0.3963693082332611,
-0.008154966868460178,
-0.17136789858341217,
-0.04302946478128433,
-0.24897882342338562,
-0.13436530530452728,
0.45263439416885376,
0.667395293712616,
-0.0004374936979729682,
0.05130544677376747,
0.4104776978492737,
-0.03936881199479103,
-0.3463307023048401,
-0.01306860987097025,
0.005735104437917471,
0.3074517548084259,
-0.47134366631507874,
-0.08105820417404175,
-0.8216632604598999,
0.5178261995315552,
0.7727079391479492,
-0.3721354305744171,
0.3415181636810303,
1.121623158454895,
-0.5169817209243774,
-0.3162213861942291,
-0.2974628806114197,
-0.28713685274124146,
-0.4061114192008972,
0.5414905548095703,
-0.47723013162612915,
-0.9983051419258118,
0.9307316541671753,
-0.19244374334812164,
-0.13361893594264984,
0.31423112750053406,
0.398095965385437,
-0.14401549100875854,
1.284184217453003,
0.8569589257240295,
-0.19589479267597198,
0.5125712156295776,
-0.0738305002450943,
0.3690553903579712,
-0.7210667729377747,
-0.1450711339712143,
-0.7341828942298889,
-0.3283730745315552,
-0.8534252643585205,
0.0003230258880648762,
0.43265798687934875,
0.22248323261737823,
-0.09454502910375595,
-0.10422733426094055,
-0.4433552026748657,
0.10730777680873871,
0.3614663779735565,
0.15630385279655457,
-0.18147341907024384,
0.01821761019527912,
0.015986939892172813,
-0.01840454339981079,
-0.5126758217811584,
-0.3508263826370239,
0.6130591034889221,
0.47933948040008545,
0.4825962781906128,
-0.10361957550048828,
0.5860130190849304,
0.48633188009262085,
-0.13147060573101044,
-0.7578463554382324,
0.4049105942249298,
-0.34647127985954285,
-0.05368075147271156,
-0.3216785490512848,
-0.4065870940685272,
-0.47622206807136536,
0.022625502198934555,
-0.36806005239486694,
-0.9292935132980347,
0.2064436674118042,
0.4106813073158264,
-0.40488162636756897,
0.061158765107393265,
-0.6074649095535278,
0.6695481538772583,
-0.4829706847667694,
-0.3965703248977661,
-0.3494590222835541,
-0.5408302545547485,
0.2836388945579529,
-0.025908250361680984,
0.04186719283461571,
-0.13804273307323456,
0.20040825009346008,
0.7173460125923157,
-0.5139845609664917,
0.5551868081092834,
-0.3711203336715698,
0.02027522772550583,
-0.06994577497243881,
-0.012377940118312836,
0.41808390617370605,
-0.17299306392669678,
-0.3995918035507202,
0.10133131593465805,
-0.09115937352180481,
-0.20388899743556976,
-0.9725878238677979,
0.5576538443565369,
-0.49346232414245605,
-0.4013645350933075,
0.027937117964029312,
-0.6491881608963013,
-0.3689711391925812,
-0.09095912426710129,
0.16866347193717957,
0.6365570425987244,
0.16493624448776245,
0.32153648138046265,
0.8134669661521912,
-0.3189776539802551,
0.531189501285553,
0.36926692724227905,
-0.2544883191585541,
-0.31522035598754883,
1.1576812267303467,
-0.08705946803092957,
-0.07823631912469864,
0.22193092107772827,
0.5007869005203247,
-0.41871896386146545,
-0.48928961157798767,
-0.13588553667068481,
-0.0852673128247261,
-0.4682910442352295,
0.1541016399860382,
-0.424633264541626,
-0.16887779533863068,
-0.3841720223426819,
-0.07244942337274551,
-0.34637436270713806,
-0.5004887580871582,
-0.35179153084754944,
-0.05298522487282753,
0.5113384127616882,
0.5096239447593689,
-0.06899337470531464,
0.19971074163913727,
-0.5471711754798889,
0.4208940863609314,
0.440497487783432,
0.47426149249076843,
0.14623606204986572,
-0.7872169613838196,
-0.10164962708950043,
0.060931023210287094,
0.025488104671239853,
-0.9807069897651672,
0.5093312859535217,
0.43577247858047485,
0.5996368527412415,
0.8841904997825623,
0.18036548793315887,
0.7722724080085754,
0.00036981538869440556,
0.7313220500946045,
-0.13188864290714264,
-1.403818964958191,
0.8896657228469849,
-0.02331920713186264,
-0.002505169715732336,
0.39456355571746826,
0.4688827693462372,
-0.2164447158575058,
-0.15583910048007965,
-0.8228154182434082,
-1.0753247737884521,
0.7390421628952026,
0.38554733991622925,
-0.2665252685546875,
0.5434219241142273,
0.5954495072364807,
0.26194918155670166,
0.41476184129714966,
-0.5337096452713013,
-0.36636781692504883,
-0.3194624185562134,
-0.2920028269290924,
0.045394983142614365,
-0.5664950609207153,
-0.08661322295665741,
-0.05773403123021126,
0.8811492323875427,
-0.18308648467063904,
0.36074769496917725,
-0.09436503052711487,
-0.17390559613704681,
0.010754875838756561,
0.42989808320999146,
0.7222400307655334,
0.5151034593582153,
-0.5287213921546936,
0.10596963763237,
-0.056823939085006714,
-0.20256154239177704,
-0.07498136907815933,
0.4279335141181946,
-0.05089759826660156,
0.04736239090561867,
0.2807849049568176,
1.358191967010498,
0.22794508934020996,
-0.6617536544799805,
0.4045719802379608,
-0.009398077614605427,
0.12470497936010361,
-0.06814737617969513,
0.18608854711055756,
-0.18957878649234772,
0.5758771300315857,
0.2964463233947754,
-0.204653799533844,
0.3860522508621216,
-0.5508805513381958,
0.19654525816440582,
0.4468056857585907,
-0.8273230791091919,
-0.2691251039505005,
0.5631654262542725,
0.40615689754486084,
-0.4565396308898926,
0.3219764530658722,
-0.2889265716075897,
-0.8983258605003357,
0.68316650390625,
0.4133186340332031,
1.30345618724823,
-0.33014437556266785,
0.3381197452545166,
0.26307424902915955,
0.04398779571056366,
0.17762868106365204,
0.5895203948020935,
-0.5850773453712463,
-0.3961831331253052,
-0.0031976562459021807,
-0.49513736367225647,
-0.6626484394073486,
0.2689622640609741,
-1.045817494392395,
0.014491329900920391,
-0.1393120288848877,
-0.02392975613474846,
0.08544077724218369,
0.06545472145080566,
-0.45154425501823425,
0.20698478817939758,
0.410142183303833,
0.601087749004364,
-0.867099404335022,
0.43526962399482727,
0.37412789463996887,
-0.3523584306240082,
-0.7056756019592285,
0.10935535281896591,
0.14118711650371552,
-0.9470829963684082,
0.28433138132095337,
0.41574734449386597,
-0.2280169278383255,
-0.11665533483028412,
-0.45551034808158875,
-0.5376747250556946,
1.0537688732147217,
0.4091290235519409,
-0.5901443958282471,
0.35344162583351135,
-0.13592924177646637,
0.6475575566291809,
-0.5697271227836609,
0.5239301919937134,
0.5886465907096863,
0.36255884170532227,
0.29528045654296875,
-0.6574200987815857,
-0.0502331368625164,
-0.46230965852737427,
0.10762876272201538,
-0.18465779721736908,
-0.4968273639678955,
0.5554029941558838,
-0.5548309683799744,
-0.08448971062898636,
-0.050714027136564255,
0.5341405868530273,
0.34406763315200806,
0.5595685243606567,
0.5979983806610107,
0.5149412751197815,
1.2779381275177002,
-0.1800953894853592,
0.7408322095870972,
-0.39411914348602295,
0.2568320035934448,
0.9718068838119507,
-0.2451174408197403,
0.823679506778717,
0.0896998718380928,
-0.028743410483002663,
0.4272955060005188,
0.6472867131233215,
0.014669747091829777,
0.4246850311756134,
0.23197226226329803,
-0.31690603494644165,
-0.20447245240211487,
-0.3668159246444702,
-0.2522627115249634,
0.8117796182632446,
0.3142598271369934,
-0.5029386878013611,
-0.04810493439435959,
0.3929252624511719,
-0.08811834454536438,
-0.31588080525398254,
-0.5019398331642151,
0.7766842246055603,
-0.11625208705663681,
-0.27297815680503845,
0.5041907429695129,
-0.3976609408855438,
0.30010390281677246,
-0.5053148865699768,
-0.07654397189617157,
-0.2512102425098419,
-0.051192086189985275,
-0.27274149656295776,
-0.5564438104629517,
-0.03854599595069885,
0.3887780010700226,
-0.45429909229278564,
-0.26406392455101013,
0.720960259437561,
-0.603958785533905,
-0.2600426971912384,
0.10281635075807571,
0.20381736755371094,
0.2856523096561432,
-0.30666854977607727,
-0.7549792528152466,
0.09641504287719727,
0.2140526920557022,
0.002227518241852522,
0.1650526225566864,
0.5860608220100403,
0.050542525947093964,
1.0007655620574951,
0.3275820016860962,
0.12786681950092316,
-0.30584806203842163,
0.30619943141937256,
0.644904613494873,
-0.8048226237297058,
-0.8114749789237976,
-0.5689319968223572,
0.773444414138794,
-0.0635531097650528,
-0.14942601323127747,
0.3909972906112671,
0.07888755947351456,
-0.027901815250515938,
0.27473556995391846,
0.7851049900054932,
0.18170584738254547,
0.656276285648346,
-0.2805878221988678,
0.8272019624710083,
-0.5737343430519104,
0.3464052677154541,
-0.3023056387901306,
-0.43524935841560364,
0.11153388768434525,
0.43927040696144104,
0.0877576395869255,
0.3154609203338623,
0.5058292746543884,
0.6685914397239685,
0.32618430256843567,
0.4379797875881195,
0.4287671744823456,
0.4549681544303894,
0.32056114077568054,
0.4695635735988617,
0.6005859971046448,
-0.2518211305141449,
0.47256430983543396,
-0.48585250973701477,
-0.5686367750167847,
-0.35060518980026245,
-1.1166203022003174,
-0.6237723231315613,
-0.917417585849762,
-0.5895667672157288,
-0.26515504717826843,
0.06832922250032425,
0.6830040812492371,
0.7849875688552856,
-0.8574286103248596,
0.18634693324565887,
0.16869716346263885,
0.31345513463020325,
-0.3841966390609741,
-0.2146415412425995,
0.4228208065032959,
-0.3205740749835968,
-0.47774362564086914,
0.48988106846809387,
0.42668813467025757,
-0.02674945816397667,
-0.24850603938102722,
-0.005428381729871035,
0.34261375665664673,
-0.08699075877666473,
0.31241628527641296,
0.5891764163970947,
-0.8462525010108948,
-0.11533379554748535,
-0.4140979051589966,
0.3578210473060608,
-0.21974512934684753,
0.8153656125068665,
-0.8100991249084473,
0.8097504377365112,
0.39193686842918396,
0.8257536292076111,
0.46797728538513184,
0.037582654505968094,
0.40815314650535583,
-0.5748676061630249,
0.049849703907966614,
0.31811434030532837,
0.3938896059989929,
0.38636380434036255,
-0.3806236982345581,
0.2872375547885895,
0.06555280089378357,
-0.5876062512397766,
-1.0340763330459595,
0.027233755216002464,
-1.0775299072265625,
0.005944269709289074,
0.6844587326049805,
-0.33815041184425354,
-0.17036083340644836,
0.16338685154914856,
-0.03711993619799614,
0.3731488287448883,
-0.4252716600894928,
1.1762495040893555,
0.5131561160087585,
-0.5661670565605164,
-0.5750885605812073,
-0.15004213154315948,
0.8631477355957031,
0.45919451117515564,
-0.8591854572296143,
0.37601035833358765,
0.37011170387268066,
-0.0011325270170345902,
0.10606708377599716,
-0.007306086365133524,
-0.03483913093805313,
0.37143221497535706,
-0.06923290342092514,
0.1945907324552536,
-0.34733280539512634,
-0.25301867723464966,
-0.9751519560813904,
0.41895219683647156,
-0.2701857089996338,
-0.33123794198036194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00244v1
|
Controlling Large Language Model Agents with Entropic Activation Steering
| 2024-06-01T00:25:00
| 2024-06-01T00:25:00
|
Nate Rahn, Pierluca D'Oro, Marc G. Bellemare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The generality of pretrained large language models (LLMs) has prompted
increasing interest in their use as in-context learning agents. To be
successful, such agents must form beliefs about how to achieve their goals
based on limited interaction with their environment, resulting in uncertainty
about the best action to take at each step. In this paper, we study how LLM
agents form and act on these beliefs by conducting experiments in controlled
sequential decision-making tasks. To begin, we find that LLM agents are
overconfident: They draw strong conclusions about what to do based on
insufficient evidence, resulting in inadequately explorative behavior. We dig
deeper into this phenomenon and show how it emerges from a collapse in the
entropy of the action distribution implied by sampling from the LLM. We then
demonstrate that existing token-level sampling techniques are by themselves
insufficient to make the agent explore more. Motivated by this fact, we
introduce Entropic Activation Steering (EAST), an activation steering method
for in-context LLM agents. EAST computes a steering vector as an
entropy-weighted combination of representations, and uses it to manipulate an
LLM agent's uncertainty over actions by intervening on its activations during
the forward pass. We show that EAST can reliably increase the entropy in an LLM
agent's actions, causing more explorative behavior to emerge. Finally, EAST
modifies the subjective uncertainty an LLM agent expresses, paving the way to
interpreting and controlling how LLM agents represent uncertainty about their
decisions.
|
[
-0.4048507809638977,
-1.0834943056106567,
0.7612549066543579,
0.16751812398433685,
-0.0206576157361269,
0.06576308608055115,
-0.4748319685459137,
-0.23504619300365448,
0.20242100954055786,
0.09844309836626053,
-0.37601372599601746,
-0.2763664424419403,
-0.7657655477523804,
-0.06188550963997841,
-0.1770380735397339,
0.8521922826766968,
-0.3596225082874298,
-0.15171444416046143,
-0.12248806655406952,
0.06756529211997986,
-0.28714248538017273,
-0.3179880380630493,
-0.9112513065338135,
-0.8028092384338379,
0.47412174940109253,
0.41376855969429016,
1.0774061679840088,
0.19907227158546448,
-0.005449158605188131,
0.3914526700973511,
0.007957658730447292,
-0.10715856403112411,
-0.5460687875747681,
0.528191328048706,
-0.3034248650074005,
-0.7308354377746582,
-0.24039170145988464,
0.18207715451717377,
0.6107763648033142,
0.41333118081092834,
-0.30428504943847656,
-0.2743757367134094,
0.09542515873908997,
0.30143865942955017,
-0.7390590906143188,
0.24518658220767975,
-0.6032476425170898,
0.055902183055877686,
0.03098490461707115,
-0.40613940358161926,
-0.4750329256057739,
-0.14384682476520538,
0.2478991150856018,
-0.5046600699424744,
-0.27178120613098145,
-0.08079634606838226,
0.42633941769599915,
0.5200785994529724,
-0.6699716448783875,
-0.5227486491203308,
-0.8708931803703308,
0.6360012888908386,
-0.7482367753982544,
0.3522500991821289,
0.6859972476959229,
-0.039655786007642746,
-0.30152449011802673,
-0.41910988092422485,
-0.6403471827507019,
-0.3770671486854553,
0.12731555104255676,
0.1586930751800537,
-0.020578615367412567,
0.24238918721675873,
0.15713439881801605,
-0.33621349930763245,
-0.2608473002910614,
0.5291457772254944,
-0.08473570644855499,
0.006070122122764587,
0.4343269169330597,
0.032635126262903214,
0.02853330411016941,
0.2614671289920807,
-0.41919106245040894,
-0.2481619268655777,
-0.9194005131721497,
0.20666049420833588,
0.4383554756641388,
0.11559687554836273,
-0.0568268746137619,
0.7143974304199219,
-0.08975229412317276,
0.519417405128479,
0.4794206917285919,
0.015673717483878136,
0.21590322256088257,
0.24817724525928497,
-0.6382274031639099,
0.4372241497039795,
0.3926910161972046,
0.29119738936424255,
0.05820203945040703,
-0.09109771251678467,
-0.5267767310142517,
-0.17560802400112152,
0.23753972351551056,
-0.5886233448982239,
0.34340396523475647,
0.7128541469573975,
-0.09150654822587967,
-0.22137188911437988,
0.026764988899230957,
-0.38679593801498413,
-0.3700721561908722,
-0.48108792304992676,
0.6435902714729309,
-0.3792180120944977,
-0.3558356761932373,
-0.0007692586514167488,
-0.17810380458831787,
0.5291860699653625,
0.3681658208370209,
-0.8256275057792664,
0.1797693371772766,
0.6712716817855835,
0.49663951992988586,
-0.18532909452915192,
-0.5602182745933533,
-0.3120149075984955,
0.3788869380950928,
-0.730913519859314,
0.3485921025276184,
-0.8341256976127625,
-0.18574512004852295,
0.2682066857814789,
0.013738386332988739,
-0.2416357696056366,
-0.5450863838195801,
0.04870465770363808,
-0.913987934589386,
0.00012949535448569804,
-0.20365336537361145,
-0.4978300631046295,
-0.26603591442108154,
0.5733645558357239,
-0.3834935128688812,
0.8496018052101135,
-0.11242936551570892,
-0.6178426742553711,
0.4986518323421478,
-0.4382883906364441,
-0.3690251410007477,
-0.16573642194271088,
-0.3882814645767212,
-0.03360874578356743,
0.2886618673801422,
-0.10822422057390213,
0.4273911118507385,
-0.03001738153398037,
0.42269521951675415,
-0.2643042504787445,
-0.10663825273513794,
0.6097419261932373,
-0.40395644307136536,
0.5859026908874512,
0.06337840855121613,
-0.672051727771759,
0.3893967568874359,
-0.3817647099494934,
-0.0033433036878705025,
-0.054385896772146225,
-0.34199291467666626,
-0.48878809809684753,
0.15184275805950165,
-0.5601570010185242,
0.34464558959007263,
0.2711533010005951,
-0.31310704350471497,
0.0017078293021768332,
-0.3151361346244812,
0.3342728614807129,
0.9967265725135803,
0.23225921392440796,
0.9134925007820129,
-0.39463552832603455,
0.6257367730140686,
0.011193721555173397,
-0.055510710924863815,
0.135410875082016,
-0.32208991050720215,
-0.9232953190803528,
0.09946443140506744,
-0.23241277039051056,
0.3513129949569702,
-1.0990315675735474,
0.46554654836654663,
0.015221508219838142,
-0.4073105454444885,
-0.15961632132530212,
-0.012509030289947987,
0.14003027975559235,
0.16213737428188324,
0.06864858418703079,
-0.12529410421848297,
-0.03331126645207405,
-0.6390202045440674,
0.016535617411136627,
-0.22406207025051117,
0.09589578211307526,
0.040576741099357605,
0.6383790373802185,
-0.205910325050354,
0.8970713019371033,
-0.10778893530368805,
-0.095802903175354,
-0.3979049026966095,
0.4440484344959259,
0.12482409924268723,
0.7123527526855469,
0.12793602049350739,
-0.8916314244270325,
-0.3926190435886383,
-0.04880110174417496,
-0.6177281737327576,
0.07759574055671692,
-0.4596383273601532,
-0.16836601495742798,
0.31253311038017273,
0.9729548096656799,
-0.9879329800605774,
0.4600856602191925,
0.3733845353126526,
-0.34379804134368896,
0.4949694275856018,
-0.4704229235649109,
-0.1326604038476944,
-0.46670740842819214,
-0.28322815895080566,
-0.14642249047756195,
-0.1375952512025833,
-0.7029829025268555,
0.2590235471725464,
0.059758637100458145,
0.3667736053466797,
-0.43656280636787415,
0.2995373010635376,
-0.5452248454093933,
0.09964067488908768,
-0.4577460289001465,
-0.08057267218828201,
-0.39477095007896423,
0.6821320652961731,
0.3193904459476471,
0.19323588907718658,
0.7268115282058716,
-0.6843472123146057,
0.19456535577774048,
-0.12085205316543579,
-0.15014216303825378,
0.5136504769325256,
-0.5771687030792236,
0.1265384405851364,
-0.5804294347763062,
0.3259190022945404,
-0.7893412113189697,
-0.3324371576309204,
0.22914227843284607,
-0.34583693742752075,
0.7397438287734985,
0.21862010657787323,
-0.37607455253601074,
0.16332082450389862,
-0.23364584147930145,
0.18479199707508087,
0.4507182836532593,
-0.24218714237213135,
0.7757983803749084,
0.2294948846101761,
-0.29914605617523193,
-0.51152503490448,
-0.81618732213974,
-0.1767149120569229,
-0.2934190630912781,
-0.1391768604516983,
0.3629910945892334,
-0.002325251931324601,
-0.5768178701400757,
0.007035260088741779,
-0.061739638447761536,
0.07507695257663727,
-0.09855101257562637,
0.47542381286621094,
-0.11661120504140854,
0.11341618746519089,
0.2625187039375305,
0.22772493958473206,
0.04752451926469803,
0.39860936999320984,
-0.30484700202941895,
0.5427576899528503,
0.20046716928482056,
-0.7185837626457214,
-0.08128231018781662,
0.18605779111385345,
0.7846049666404724,
-0.09844675660133362,
0.8410696387290955,
0.29277658462524414,
-0.32987600564956665,
-0.5309578776359558,
-0.36155807971954346,
-0.34856945276260376,
-0.5214949250221252,
0.5049185156822205,
-0.19279707968235016,
-0.6352260708808899,
0.47592291235923767,
-0.02138538286089897,
0.22496341168880463,
0.08609213680028915,
0.9016281962394714,
0.08153051882982254,
1.0201075077056885,
0.5907131433486938,
0.014275585301220417,
0.6218317747116089,
-0.3002643585205078,
-0.009450400248169899,
-0.5919962525367737,
-0.31138911843299866,
-0.2911355197429657,
-0.7038900256156921,
-0.5546241998672485,
-0.8283461332321167,
0.4539893567562103,
-0.10735800862312317,
-0.8668475151062012,
-0.20724475383758545,
-0.03659728169441223,
0.3692289888858795,
0.5397137999534607,
0.23118117451667786,
0.011304205283522606,
-0.30879563093185425,
-0.24895569682121277,
0.22975106537342072,
-0.7736126780509949,
-0.2364419549703598,
0.8611183166503906,
0.4955788254737854,
1.1393095254898071,
0.09433089196681976,
0.6974129676818848,
-0.057879168540239334,
0.48534274101257324,
-0.7413278222084045,
0.3839288055896759,
0.7291362881660461,
-0.764142632484436,
-0.7679876685142517,
-0.01972411945462227,
-0.9420967698097229,
0.26793497800827026,
-0.13084374368190765,
-0.6517972946166992,
0.5273808836936951,
0.04075286164879799,
-0.25426363945007324,
0.20738765597343445,
-0.45635703206062317,
0.6504203081130981,
-0.38853785395622253,
-0.5564791560173035,
-0.4204050302505493,
-0.7936939001083374,
0.17237825691699982,
-0.13107897341251373,
0.26785358786582947,
0.0967119038105011,
-0.4037596881389618,
0.43134212493896484,
-0.2836824059486389,
1.1650760173797607,
-0.49245667457580566,
-0.3151179850101471,
0.41285037994384766,
0.4073730707168579,
1.108172059059143,
-0.05508165806531906,
-0.16838788986206055,
-0.37906745076179504,
-0.6136805415153503,
-0.16748188436031342,
-0.7317776083946228,
0.5089272260665894,
-0.7143493294715881,
-0.7753292322158813,
-0.3519098460674286,
-0.46622633934020996,
-0.19430024921894073,
0.07231946289539337,
0.39600443840026855,
0.41582271456718445,
-0.08284583687782288,
0.27819639444351196,
0.6158280372619629,
-0.33818039298057556,
0.5401583909988403,
0.5984833240509033,
-0.24078649282455444,
-0.04487458989024162,
0.6056292057037354,
0.23938366770744324,
0.8622492551803589,
0.365293025970459,
0.04174613952636719,
-0.31761080026626587,
-0.7778853178024292,
0.02325979433953762,
-0.15738637745380402,
-0.8069685697555542,
-0.08922586590051651,
-0.22084875404834747,
-0.1023845225572586,
-0.2433573305606842,
-0.4222976863384247,
-0.31020331382751465,
-0.08816707134246826,
-0.14863257110118866,
-0.4795822203159332,
0.0018433043733239174,
0.7720037698745728,
-0.23663325607776642,
0.42390698194503784,
-0.18591861426830292,
-0.029542967677116394,
0.33808812499046326,
0.029880795627832413,
0.3124527037143707,
-0.536349892616272,
-0.20694346725940704,
0.009443121962249279,
-0.39176642894744873,
-1.0787957906723022,
0.7003298997879028,
0.10528150945901871,
0.7324806451797485,
0.7342850565910339,
0.2638017237186432,
0.44111326336860657,
-0.42786726355552673,
0.6058562397956848,
0.060921698808670044,
-0.8128178715705872,
0.21056678891181946,
-0.23026764392852783,
0.3147541284561157,
0.2565261125564575,
0.7570134997367859,
-0.2951906621456146,
-1.0733107328414917,
-0.572284996509552,
-1.0005884170532227,
0.502509355545044,
-0.023313648998737335,
0.0864030122756958,
0.04570569470524788,
-0.021725688129663467,
0.1497965157032013,
0.260257363319397,
-0.7560593485832214,
-0.2550804316997528,
-0.06290838867425919,
-0.0101143354550004,
-0.34786736965179443,
-0.13930699229240417,
-0.2313215583562851,
-0.2313651591539383,
0.649579644203186,
-0.26669085025787354,
0.1965070366859436,
0.5084213614463806,
-0.1956837922334671,
-0.38643884658813477,
0.44565507769584656,
0.539197564125061,
0.7509332299232483,
-0.1318453848361969,
0.5254167914390564,
0.2665371894836426,
-0.09781200438737869,
0.37244683504104614,
-0.00632887426763773,
-0.31409114599227905,
-0.3179177939891815,
0.366752952337265,
0.7056775093078613,
0.41382405161857605,
-0.5969073176383972,
0.36147603392601013,
0.27626147866249084,
-0.0772673711180687,
-0.48539474606513977,
-0.12153364717960358,
0.08149838447570801,
0.5244646072387695,
0.4802514910697937,
0.13369880616664886,
-0.07643667608499527,
-0.6989107728004456,
-0.05136936530470848,
0.6366638541221619,
-0.5586662888526917,
-0.44070515036582947,
0.5361145734786987,
0.12318787723779678,
-0.12466179579496384,
0.47572022676467896,
-0.5580184459686279,
-0.7930233478546143,
0.7251437902450562,
0.7197347283363342,
0.9640032649040222,
-0.06416183710098267,
0.22804208099842072,
0.12883836030960083,
0.6084321737289429,
-0.09966932237148285,
0.22016461193561554,
-0.07887367904186249,
-1.2748712301254272,
-0.5657461881637573,
-0.30217429995536804,
-0.43231600522994995,
-0.01456691324710846,
-0.6484445333480835,
-0.10318464785814285,
-0.4248175323009491,
-0.18974906206130981,
-0.504360020160675,
-0.3484664261341095,
-0.7171911597251892,
0.07575153559446335,
0.20259463787078857,
0.9784255623817444,
-0.7779839038848877,
0.8219141960144043,
0.6381476521492004,
-0.033563897013664246,
-0.8085552453994751,
0.1096203476190567,
0.14582431316375732,
-0.8698902726173401,
0.8903376460075378,
-0.028116511180996895,
0.09145049005746841,
0.017223237082362175,
-1.0265599489212036,
-0.8823451399803162,
1.0070933103561401,
0.20846159756183624,
-0.36102139949798584,
-0.058606863021850586,
0.034818556159734726,
0.324690580368042,
-0.3497493863105774,
0.30491116642951965,
0.7160567045211792,
0.7529026865959167,
0.1511237472295761,
-0.8444229960441589,
0.357438325881958,
0.1250540018081665,
-0.45010241866111755,
0.12461849302053452,
-0.5981442332267761,
1.0508208274841309,
-0.4936559498310089,
-0.20468781888484955,
-0.1884000599384308,
0.6428437232971191,
0.37640759348869324,
0.2403724193572998,
0.6103149652481079,
0.48938167095184326,
0.7396739721298218,
0.08778399229049683,
0.9937877058982849,
-0.2677716910839081,
0.059468984603881836,
1.1820826530456543,
-0.47413378953933716,
0.9855731725692749,
0.7468717694282532,
0.11771764606237411,
0.5306834578514099,
0.5605347156524658,
0.4989853501319885,
0.5844119787216187,
0.2537541091442108,
-0.25537508726119995,
-0.3420010805130005,
-0.016544153913855553,
-0.020799994468688965,
0.415395051240921,
0.6664765477180481,
-0.2950679361820221,
-0.16024841368198395,
0.07589457184076309,
-0.07589074969291687,
-0.1974506676197052,
-0.4691254496574402,
0.6912235021591187,
0.12352833151817322,
-1.010111927986145,
0.3428208529949188,
-0.046146757900714874,
0.6986311674118042,
-0.7672399878501892,
0.12614046037197113,
0.20896072685718536,
0.08279062807559967,
-0.09427166730165482,
-0.7823145985603333,
0.008243576623499393,
-0.3425319194793701,
0.24126498401165009,
-0.564445436000824,
0.6872963309288025,
-0.7298350930213928,
0.03728031739592552,
0.292643666267395,
0.6630523204803467,
0.05407112464308739,
-0.11940637230873108,
-0.45144250988960266,
-0.030336469411849976,
-0.07406791299581528,
-0.7404729127883911,
0.30428189039230347,
0.7800146341323853,
0.027681389823555946,
0.7826105952262878,
0.37079867720603943,
0.3787135183811188,
0.15438418090343475,
-0.22493277490139008,
0.7873409390449524,
-0.5800120234489441,
-0.6286728978157043,
-0.9315454959869385,
0.3550524413585663,
0.16082917153835297,
-0.15836752951145172,
0.7002618908882141,
0.15772747993469238,
0.90674889087677,
0.12711456418037415,
0.7796646356582642,
-0.25720375776290894,
-0.11623291671276093,
-0.6758424639701843,
0.5513314604759216,
-0.30550360679626465,
-0.06698500365018845,
0.1774180680513382,
-0.7298830151557922,
0.11176270246505737,
0.4844261407852173,
-0.47943201661109924,
0.08456311374902725,
0.7055436372756958,
0.8468402624130249,
0.3795388638973236,
-0.10885868966579437,
0.33509552478790283,
0.571274995803833,
0.4072474539279938,
0.732037365436554,
1.2389792203903198,
0.29582613706588745,
0.08177097141742706,
-0.18223439157009125,
-0.2541976869106293,
-0.04944285377860069,
-0.9132984280586243,
-0.7473043203353882,
-0.4789217710494995,
-0.1758444905281067,
-0.2286910116672516,
-0.17973966896533966,
1.4614382982254028,
0.7369665503501892,
-0.6580682396888733,
-0.21689589321613312,
-0.22417324781417847,
0.4325217008590698,
-0.24176917970180511,
-0.19233369827270508,
0.21148215234279633,
-0.6092095971107483,
-0.9370056390762329,
0.36226725578308105,
0.16991601884365082,
0.3429107069969177,
-0.4245781898498535,
-0.413149356842041,
-0.09173154830932617,
0.03644546866416931,
0.4744816720485687,
0.34553802013397217,
-0.5476716756820679,
-0.18418869376182556,
-0.3463616967201233,
-0.13719359040260315,
-0.13744518160820007,
0.8887298703193665,
-0.6851330995559692,
0.42006611824035645,
0.550360918045044,
0.4486783444881439,
0.39499983191490173,
-0.12173957377672195,
0.9569207429885864,
-0.6124206185340881,
0.27471500635147095,
0.42570358514785767,
0.2558923661708832,
-0.025868499651551247,
-0.1736186295747757,
0.10892868041992188,
-0.15031765401363373,
-0.7070964574813843,
-0.650131106376648,
0.015604709275066853,
-0.5464851260185242,
-0.45906710624694824,
1.418213129043579,
0.004885880742222071,
-0.2614544928073883,
-0.104001984000206,
-0.11072524636983871,
0.2061217874288559,
-0.5179060697555542,
0.4783535599708557,
0.6820172667503357,
-0.26063457131385803,
0.21958470344543457,
-0.6958062648773193,
0.6786871552467346,
0.3227055072784424,
-0.5738507509231567,
0.11799140274524689,
0.3429112136363983,
0.0021910304203629494,
0.1677369773387909,
0.614803671836853,
0.17445878684520721,
-0.031285569071769714,
0.01406096387654543,
-0.10758817195892334,
0.008010209538042545,
-0.4867655038833618,
-0.5136470198631287,
0.18019501864910126,
0.303366482257843,
0.015270917676389217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00240v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00240v1
|
Exploring Vulnerabilities and Protections in Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-06-01T00:11:09
| 2024-06-01T00:11:09
|
Frank Weizhen Liu, Chenhui Hu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) increasingly become key components in various
AI applications, understanding their security vulnerabilities and the
effectiveness of defense mechanisms is crucial. This survey examines the
security challenges of LLMs, focusing on two main areas: Prompt Hacking and
Adversarial Attacks, each with specific types of threats. Under Prompt Hacking,
we explore Prompt Injection and Jailbreaking Attacks, discussing how they work,
their potential impacts, and ways to mitigate them. Similarly, we analyze
Adversarial Attacks, breaking them down into Data Poisoning Attacks and
Backdoor Attacks. This structured examination helps us understand the
relationships between these vulnerabilities and the defense strategies that can
be implemented. The survey highlights these security challenges and discusses
robust defensive frameworks to protect LLMs against these threats. By detailing
these security issues, the survey contributes to the broader discussion on
creating resilient AI systems that can resist sophisticated attacks.
|
[
-0.26351112127304077,
-1.3335334062576294,
0.5687310695648193,
-0.10449761152267456,
0.2582569122314453,
0.2789413630962372,
-0.12284306436777115,
-0.48360174894332886,
-0.09044960886240005,
0.8468834161758423,
-0.4450297951698303,
-0.24126379191875458,
-0.6949424743652344,
0.06346742063760757,
-0.5649052858352661,
0.9089677333831787,
0.20330534875392914,
0.03548015281558037,
-0.2561875879764557,
0.123001828789711,
-0.6584527492523193,
-0.8883835077285767,
-0.8222039341926575,
0.07264558970928192,
0.4904274642467499,
0.11371878534555435,
0.7284640669822693,
0.1568778157234192,
0.6012769341468811,
0.44205477833747864,
-0.15460051596164703,
-0.28027787804603577,
-0.3450416624546051,
0.5860065221786499,
-0.05604410916566849,
-0.5737489461898804,
-0.49241217970848083,
-0.11725980043411255,
0.45426714420318604,
0.5219178795814514,
0.05850743129849434,
0.08350138366222382,
-0.23842526972293854,
0.5731219053268433,
-0.5872033834457397,
-0.1327708214521408,
-0.8415449857711792,
0.04301035776734352,
-0.6076488494873047,
0.08376872539520264,
-0.5595731139183044,
-0.2418612539768219,
-0.06242023780941963,
-0.052682265639305115,
-0.22386562824249268,
0.18793396651744843,
0.4405258595943451,
0.2258215844631195,
-0.6145807504653931,
-0.26164931058883667,
-0.6045286655426025,
0.7727278470993042,
-0.71622633934021,
0.20850522816181183,
0.4474720060825348,
0.4460393190383911,
-0.4004526734352112,
-0.5257045030593872,
-0.36740028858184814,
-0.6418095231056213,
0.1873251497745514,
-0.25221940875053406,
-0.5382428765296936,
0.019453758373856544,
0.3401508331298828,
0.39653220772743225,
-0.8939254879951477,
0.6253360509872437,
-0.22422760725021362,
-0.2870763838291168,
0.9647971391677856,
0.5151756405830383,
0.7620660662651062,
-0.005426535848528147,
-0.17692744731903076,
-0.11931557208299637,
-1.1139880418777466,
-0.13227719068527222,
0.7414996027946472,
0.08770352602005005,
-0.0271503534168005,
0.6094254851341248,
0.24627798795700073,
0.7174276113510132,
-0.5061472058296204,
-0.03177327662706375,
-0.16985750198364258,
-0.29899317026138306,
-0.12330559641122818,
-0.24352827668190002,
0.8912897109985352,
0.06217949837446213,
0.1870422214269638,
-0.170090451836586,
-0.29854610562324524,
-0.4303991496562958,
0.2456197887659073,
-0.6205942630767822,
-0.14809618890285492,
0.5058842897415161,
-0.4099016487598419,
-0.4536494314670563,
0.040526509284973145,
-0.9511774182319641,
-0.8760991096496582,
0.27897360920906067,
0.01155400276184082,
-0.21857662498950958,
-0.28503456711769104,
-0.1544618457555771,
-0.09865803271532059,
0.32808032631874084,
0.21251842379570007,
-0.7390377521514893,
0.26357364654541016,
0.8417839407920837,
0.7817999124526978,
-0.16280198097229004,
-0.3147350251674652,
-0.5394289493560791,
0.1313159316778183,
-0.2729288339614868,
0.4698406755924225,
-0.2736440896987915,
-0.7064754962921143,
0.28989169001579285,
-0.1788441687822342,
0.029993047937750816,
-0.5250921845436096,
0.2750151753425598,
-0.7669743299484253,
0.028927182778716087,
-0.0706201121211052,
-0.5617907643318176,
0.05256818234920502,
0.7609736919403076,
-0.863009512424469,
0.7040042281150818,
-0.07485860586166382,
-0.8564770817756653,
-0.3389899432659149,
-0.4621175527572632,
-0.5203397870063782,
0.07764343917369843,
-0.28918012976646423,
-0.36508694291114807,
0.08760509639978409,
0.1435306966304779,
0.49413660168647766,
-0.47388848662376404,
0.1581389456987381,
-0.47434666752815247,
-0.0020847930572927,
0.611952543258667,
-0.6744333505630493,
1.0342583656311035,
0.234152689576149,
-0.0027407824527472258,
0.43916749954223633,
-0.7302015423774719,
-0.1265556514263153,
0.5766286253929138,
-0.20197440683841705,
-0.36161285638809204,
0.11816082149744034,
-0.0766323059797287,
-0.0050254096277058125,
0.42688947916030884,
-0.31998586654663086,
0.670724630355835,
-0.5112407803535461,
0.6832746863365173,
0.9081273674964905,
0.30574989318847656,
0.2547997832298279,
-0.06010821461677551,
0.8166979551315308,
-0.09601066261529922,
0.4018895626068115,
-0.2560326159000397,
-0.42713746428489685,
-0.340542733669281,
-0.3383623957633972,
0.17198556661605835,
0.9315906167030334,
-0.6960964202880859,
0.5587318539619446,
0.10352829843759537,
-0.7084469199180603,
-0.11895173043012619,
0.19971273839473724,
0.39208289980888367,
0.08382343500852585,
0.0717228502035141,
0.07968173176050186,
-0.3267802298069,
-0.8594262599945068,
-0.2975802719593048,
-0.42992764711380005,
-0.15723468363285065,
0.2677414119243622,
0.6884650588035583,
-0.3977779150009155,
0.5419964790344238,
-0.6609957218170166,
-0.0012541363248601556,
-0.4846768081188202,
-0.16203027963638306,
0.07271688431501389,
0.5174864530563354,
0.7757480144500732,
-0.6237784028053284,
-0.17081376910209656,
-0.225834459066391,
-0.6292068958282471,
0.002819227986037731,
-0.0856182798743248,
0.18444211781024933,
0.23013557493686676,
0.8335306644439697,
-0.8470172882080078,
0.3105069100856781,
0.5468317866325378,
-0.43353381752967834,
0.7399183511734009,
0.11044666916131973,
-0.009296922013163567,
-1.054159164428711,
0.027910485863685608,
-0.2037143111228943,
-0.1537233591079712,
-0.803311288356781,
0.47172677516937256,
-0.20398063957691193,
-0.45050734281539917,
-0.48848268389701843,
0.6187909245491028,
-0.3734419047832489,
-0.10390826314687729,
-0.03226327896118164,
-0.11815398186445236,
-0.10630025714635849,
-0.0948939099907875,
-0.39596009254455566,
0.8298930525779724,
0.8075490593910217,
-0.44316089153289795,
0.8069515228271484,
0.19435453414916992,
-0.3968895971775055,
0.19845883548259735,
-0.8764774203300476,
0.42404332756996155,
0.1525113582611084,
0.328718900680542,
-1.0383840799331665,
-0.3199707865715027,
0.39625316858291626,
-0.5965474843978882,
0.6040301322937012,
-0.06689871847629547,
-0.6558010578155518,
-0.272734671831131,
-0.6454837322235107,
0.43565481901168823,
0.30972760915756226,
-0.4316280484199524,
0.4283578097820282,
0.5085520148277283,
-0.3047860860824585,
-0.6935542225837708,
-0.706284761428833,
0.44195619225502014,
-0.31912219524383545,
-0.7575557231903076,
-0.03531503304839134,
-0.19157883524894714,
-0.7194911241531372,
-0.22161133587360382,
0.2742849886417389,
-0.04474136233329773,
0.716718852519989,
0.19959160685539246,
0.43565651774406433,
-0.14483408629894257,
-0.3624064326286316,
-0.3935260772705078,
0.02837064117193222,
0.38701891899108887,
0.02591075748205185,
0.819667398929596,
-0.012671343982219696,
-0.735011875629425,
-0.3826943337917328,
0.7075857520103455,
0.7815857529640198,
-0.3902267813682556,
0.9121882319450378,
0.2925319969654083,
-0.3564396798610687,
-0.08144554495811462,
-0.4765923321247101,
-0.1707279533147812,
-0.48931077122688293,
0.6668885946273804,
-0.293253093957901,
-1.0705523490905762,
0.6831253170967102,
0.09025970846414566,
0.2699919641017914,
0.32873865962028503,
0.7377842664718628,
0.15291275084018707,
1.1079943180084229,
0.5109300017356873,
-0.6588822603225708,
0.425230473279953,
-0.085877425968647,
0.32085639238357544,
-0.5058397650718689,
-0.3409232497215271,
-0.7781938910484314,
0.03843231499195099,
-0.526611864566803,
-0.13558189570903778,
0.2785475254058838,
-0.10985087603330612,
-0.2895646095275879,
0.15847955644130707,
-0.20374120771884918,
0.435132771730423,
0.4492425322532654,
-0.32013052701950073,
0.022029604762792587,
-0.39455926418304443,
0.2632561922073364,
0.21407565474510193,
-0.31530052423477173,
-0.4161420166492462,
0.9674989581108093,
0.6334637999534607,
1.0602912902832031,
0.61714106798172,
0.5641947984695435,
0.3485680818557739,
-0.04186291992664337,
-0.8088364601135254,
0.6968219876289368,
0.10805662721395493,
-0.8801626563072205,
-0.3195251226425171,
-0.5738105177879333,
-0.9565784335136414,
0.07429516315460205,
-0.04819044470787048,
-1.0782235860824585,
-0.26138827204704285,
0.030318910256028175,
-0.2825891077518463,
0.5172642469406128,
-0.596390426158905,
0.7611761093139648,
-0.5339585542678833,
-0.12977933883666992,
-0.0689462199807167,
-0.683009922504425,
0.7584158778190613,
-0.11106930673122406,
0.1360105723142624,
0.07791512459516525,
0.17267322540283203,
0.5132228136062622,
-0.3212639093399048,
0.8920175433158875,
-0.01983472891151905,
-0.23713333904743195,
0.21539586782455444,
0.38166019320487976,
0.5886116027832031,
0.2834542393684387,
0.027154959738254547,
0.21834096312522888,
0.04129202291369438,
-0.4393079876899719,
-0.426493763923645,
0.8124038577079773,
-0.7331258058547974,
-1.2436988353729248,
-0.707554280757904,
-0.5039691925048828,
-0.3580341935157776,
0.07571112364530563,
0.1335752010345459,
0.20543934404850006,
-0.42561841011047363,
0.16974537074565887,
0.8254752159118652,
-0.6644623875617981,
0.6523157954216003,
0.42643243074417114,
-0.3077375292778015,
-0.4526965916156769,
0.7422142028808594,
0.03054938279092312,
0.40812134742736816,
0.30782976746559143,
0.04652702808380127,
-0.09374506026506424,
-0.8243732452392578,
-0.42332887649536133,
0.020914696156978607,
-0.37888261675834656,
-0.3994958698749542,
-0.3966237008571625,
-0.505521297454834,
-0.7642782330513,
-0.06277725100517273,
-0.3680530786514282,
-0.3465995192527771,
-0.2564317286014557,
-0.0392647385597229,
0.4840909540653229,
0.8863790035247803,
0.3421543538570404,
0.2860480546951294,
-0.9586986899375916,
0.06349404156208038,
0.3389672040939331,
-0.06386087834835052,
0.08183375000953674,
-0.4242479205131531,
-0.045215193182229996,
-0.483227401971817,
-0.3608860373497009,
-1.1091684103012085,
0.4132632315158844,
-0.1640838235616684,
0.6003446578979492,
0.4592847526073456,
0.06554637104272842,
0.23528169095516205,
-0.6902658343315125,
1.3074753284454346,
0.13396625220775604,
-0.8264949917793274,
0.5912352204322815,
-0.31086698174476624,
0.18401679396629333,
0.4394513666629791,
0.3028112053871155,
-0.4980914890766144,
-0.45460909605026245,
-0.41336554288864136,
-1.0025742053985596,
0.2877025008201599,
0.12331999838352203,
0.29821911454200745,
-0.021847808733582497,
0.14773419499397278,
-0.18087497353553772,
0.18537850677967072,
-0.5343765020370483,
-0.41627931594848633,
0.11765115708112717,
-0.054479118436574936,
-0.018389523029327393,
-0.4118388593196869,
-0.3167443871498108,
0.04664534330368042,
0.6217191219329834,
0.2822299599647522,
-0.0857430249452591,
-0.10724633932113647,
-0.1883145272731781,
0.32568836212158203,
0.3866947591304779,
0.6453102231025696,
0.41590794920921326,
0.11896957457065582,
0.27721503376960754,
0.24860873818397522,
-0.5910698175430298,
0.12623918056488037,
0.10699491202831268,
-0.15507233142852783,
-0.29398390650749207,
0.7991216778755188,
0.6271167397499084,
-0.1481916755437851,
-0.9033859968185425,
0.5779363512992859,
-0.2396542727947235,
0.18882860243320465,
-0.49465927481651306,
0.1314382553100586,
-0.04623110592365265,
0.2829928994178772,
0.20973704755306244,
-0.30594056844711304,
0.007919463329017162,
-0.6683475375175476,
-0.06138421595096588,
0.8354285359382629,
-0.04164798930287361,
-0.3233007490634918,
0.47511276602745056,
0.03308651223778725,
-0.48090630769729614,
0.7523682117462158,
0.26216670870780945,
-0.6403508186340332,
0.8073893785476685,
0.6610977053642273,
0.8823772668838501,
-0.5360053181648254,
-0.3013768196105957,
-0.03338125720620155,
0.6753767728805542,
0.10797762125730515,
0.016011565923690796,
0.253823846578598,
-0.5614035129547119,
-0.052706047892570496,
-0.33086249232292175,
-0.662632167339325,
0.43239983916282654,
-0.526353657245636,
0.050105348229408264,
-0.7474481463432312,
-0.17583595216274261,
-0.12403221428394318,
-0.06782201677560806,
-0.2905961275100708,
-0.14175255596637726,
0.35754454135894775,
1.070538878440857,
-0.6989758610725403,
0.6815328598022461,
0.5420554876327515,
-0.4701998233795166,
-0.5000592470169067,
-0.04389461129903793,
0.4106702506542206,
-0.6581582427024841,
0.37285667657852173,
0.020979465916752815,
0.04796477407217026,
-0.34869149327278137,
-0.7534884214401245,
-0.6500808000564575,
0.8461741209030151,
0.43700480461120605,
-0.530523419380188,
0.08887481689453125,
0.16117513179779053,
0.23941268026828766,
0.020651157945394516,
0.008199429139494896,
0.7903434038162231,
0.47120898962020874,
-0.2981843650341034,
-0.7239639163017273,
-0.06578352302312851,
-0.30721813440322876,
-0.12100242078304291,
0.21942643821239471,
-0.7927128076553345,
0.7784873843193054,
-0.03492962196469307,
-0.023091236129403114,
0.30678972601890564,
0.5651665925979614,
0.49210646748542786,
0.2729783058166504,
0.45708006620407104,
0.6457268595695496,
0.6164332628250122,
0.06476736813783646,
1.1912294626235962,
-0.23166202008724213,
-0.026610301807522774,
0.9819969534873962,
-0.41222694516181946,
0.7661586999893188,
0.5008902549743652,
-0.2425878793001175,
0.04282033443450928,
0.5571489930152893,
-0.25002023577690125,
0.12911272048950195,
0.4899337887763977,
-0.4088980257511139,
0.043197792023420334,
0.055418889969587326,
-0.5158073306083679,
0.36967340111732483,
0.4610971510410309,
-0.20412388443946838,
0.053274139761924744,
0.10807011276483536,
0.5318965911865234,
-0.03501032292842865,
-0.3829764723777771,
0.883961021900177,
0.17426349222660065,
-0.4599878191947937,
0.1639721542596817,
0.3120618164539337,
0.5176153779029846,
-0.86671382188797,
0.15116199851036072,
-0.23859669268131256,
0.045598406344652176,
-0.1279207170009613,
-0.8839836120605469,
0.155524343252182,
0.32040220499038696,
-0.06749042123556137,
-0.08679624646902084,
0.7229370474815369,
-0.19736070930957794,
-0.23126667737960815,
0.1866457462310791,
0.33818572759628296,
0.07676174491643906,
0.02373584918677807,
-0.6882361173629761,
0.5237743854522705,
-0.20157818496227264,
-0.5794616341590881,
0.6375643610954285,
0.09595897048711777,
-0.07812632620334625,
0.8872332572937012,
0.5866994261741638,
0.25076478719711304,
0.23995821177959442,
0.15132996439933777,
0.959985077381134,
-0.6612306833267212,
-0.17192620038986206,
-1.417811632156372,
0.30285730957984924,
-0.2180943787097931,
-0.2197243571281433,
1.0378493070602417,
0.5653355121612549,
0.5779442191123962,
-0.02657124027609825,
0.7906217575073242,
0.0320834256708622,
0.18477286398410797,
-0.6747801899909973,
1.1395797729492188,
-0.29163694381713867,
0.5302769541740417,
-0.16859744489192963,
-0.6987026333808899,
-0.469680517911911,
0.18029525876045227,
-0.3279727101325989,
-0.12755633890628815,
0.4694080054759979,
0.8140407800674438,
0.38180533051490784,
-0.1749173402786255,
0.44291287660598755,
0.3867740035057068,
0.8165415525436401,
0.5660779476165771,
1.2347400188446045,
-0.2158167064189911,
0.30272167921066284,
0.21434783935546875,
-0.05102638527750969,
-0.0025211547035723925,
-0.7338702082633972,
-1.1735397577285767,
-0.3895489573478699,
-0.2520068883895874,
-0.49806490540504456,
0.1244208961725235,
0.6170573234558105,
0.3916570246219635,
-0.9682444334030151,
-0.1276964247226715,
0.19279319047927856,
0.40426406264305115,
0.2804032266139984,
-0.20518147945404053,
0.29656869173049927,
-0.15654978156089783,
-0.6293594241142273,
0.7542346715927124,
0.26074954867362976,
0.024377770721912384,
-0.8204731941223145,
0.19482624530792236,
-0.09147748351097107,
0.3161918520927429,
0.5031267404556274,
0.6147837042808533,
-0.7017358541488647,
-0.4287548065185547,
-0.11326618492603302,
-0.2080482691526413,
-0.4624762237071991,
0.8458110690116882,
-0.23319460451602936,
0.2051490694284439,
0.6115208268165588,
1.1722687482833862,
-0.027565494179725647,
-0.1510063111782074,
0.5166890621185303,
-0.7748373746871948,
0.37993302941322327,
0.32116594910621643,
0.4700682461261749,
0.3008606731891632,
-0.5504233837127686,
0.2124382108449936,
0.06737320870161057,
-0.7280579209327698,
-1.2337002754211426,
0.6892932653427124,
-0.9276382327079773,
-0.423906147480011,
1.203048825263977,
-0.2996928095817566,
-0.275695264339447,
-0.057552728801965714,
-0.10613445937633514,
-0.11617792397737503,
-0.024919219315052032,
0.6564225554466248,
0.8919845223426819,
0.06522781401872635,
-0.07349841296672821,
-0.7558450102806091,
0.3486374318599701,
0.10241437703371048,
-1.0406382083892822,
0.19486047327518463,
0.5939415097236633,
0.20756733417510986,
-0.008640794083476067,
0.35160142183303833,
-0.3024851679801941,
-0.002751519437879324,
-0.124416783452034,
-0.2542658746242523,
-0.13449887931346893,
-0.388756662607193,
-0.6201284527778625,
0.30898916721343994,
0.36539095640182495,
-0.053653303533792496
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00231v1
|
LLM-RankFusion: Mitigating Intrinsic Inconsistency in LLM-based Ranking
| 2024-05-31T23:29:42
| 2024-05-31T23:29:42
|
Yifan Zeng, Ojas Tendolkar, Raymond Baartmans, Qingyun Wu, Huazheng Wang, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Ranking passages by prompting a large language model (LLM) can achieve
promising performance in modern information retrieval (IR) systems. A common
approach is to sort the ranking list by prompting LLMs for pairwise comparison.
However, sorting-based methods require consistent comparisons to correctly sort
the passages, which we show that LLMs often violate. We identify two kinds of
intrinsic inconsistency in LLM-based pairwise comparisons: order inconsistency
which leads to conflicting results when switching the passage order, and
transitive inconsistency which leads to non-transitive triads among all
preference pairs. In this paper, we propose LLM-RankFusion, an LLM-based
ranking framework that mitigates these inconsistencies and produces a robust
ranking list. LLM-RankFusion mitigates order inconsistency using in-context
learning (ICL) to demonstrate order-agnostic comparisons and calibration to
estimate the underlying preference probability between two passages. We then
address transitive inconsistency by aggregating the ranking results from
multiple rankers. In our experiments, we empirically show that LLM-RankFusion
can significantly reduce inconsistent pairwise comparison results, and improve
the ranking quality by making the final ranking list more robust.
|
[
-0.13196596503257751,
-0.5810679197311401,
0.5908567309379578,
0.25094932317733765,
-0.1571640968322754,
0.478501558303833,
0.008952426724135876,
-0.5002437233924866,
0.18577200174331665,
0.473368763923645,
-0.17966806888580322,
-0.32778987288475037,
-0.7682995200157166,
0.0695011094212532,
-0.41919928789138794,
0.8471614718437195,
0.0293760746717453,
0.2839926779270172,
-0.6518828272819519,
-0.47230151295661926,
-0.343692421913147,
-0.6446087956428528,
-0.6439895629882812,
-0.6045822501182556,
0.4025854170322418,
0.6656715869903564,
0.7735379338264465,
0.3886704444885254,
0.859175443649292,
0.2261202484369278,
-0.07709153741598129,
0.38973310589790344,
-0.6554763317108154,
0.45131394267082214,
-0.030344806611537933,
-0.4275236427783966,
-0.47312965989112854,
-0.05467894300818443,
0.8135486245155334,
0.601694643497467,
-0.14390794932842255,
-0.039802733808755875,
0.16257745027542114,
0.8024280071258545,
-0.5462107062339783,
-0.22498777508735657,
-0.9179869294166565,
-0.009878318756818771,
-0.19658057391643524,
-0.5311102271080017,
-0.5775226354598999,
-0.5886396169662476,
-0.01873871684074402,
-0.05257709324359894,
-0.02698577754199505,
0.3486643433570862,
0.7687687277793884,
0.4268620014190674,
-0.4297572374343872,
0.01308086421340704,
-0.6091256737709045,
0.5360591411590576,
-0.6889200210571289,
0.3848438262939453,
0.27290552854537964,
0.2170809507369995,
-0.14517979323863983,
-0.3916943073272705,
-0.33715134859085083,
-0.3620816469192505,
-0.008610451593995094,
0.06422735750675201,
0.30378004908561707,
0.12462899833917618,
-0.016069911420345306,
0.40805336833000183,
-0.7662787437438965,
0.4151674807071686,
0.07411202043294907,
0.06957725435495377,
0.5003819465637207,
-0.03558342158794403,
0.17574691772460938,
0.030466552823781967,
-0.6276143789291382,
-0.38186559081077576,
-1.3475325107574463,
0.21678341925144196,
0.30961373448371887,
0.2536088526248932,
0.2462475597858429,
0.5894021987915039,
-0.26311129331588745,
0.6475560069084167,
0.3041786849498749,
-0.26765838265419006,
0.17196764051914215,
-0.2647665739059448,
-0.20683571696281433,
0.2716916799545288,
0.420947402715683,
0.4468114376068115,
-0.13907475769519806,
-0.43920648097991943,
-0.30871567130088806,
-0.21780763566493988,
0.0869840756058693,
-0.8769310712814331,
-0.0032014509197324514,
0.4751550555229187,
-0.23146143555641174,
-0.4864656627178192,
0.24616417288780212,
-0.41506844758987427,
-0.4060930907726288,
-0.11833129823207855,
0.7729263305664062,
-0.13128550350666046,
0.015965653583407402,
-0.3107474148273468,
0.03806185722351074,
0.20162326097488403,
0.41240695118904114,
-0.9044182300567627,
0.18053366243839264,
0.7716166973114014,
0.6325443387031555,
-0.7246506810188293,
-0.33498266339302063,
-0.7206030488014221,
0.2580542266368866,
-0.15856370329856873,
1.0806081295013428,
-0.6497256755828857,
-0.3460821509361267,
0.020551515743136406,
-0.289910227060318,
-0.09880147129297256,
-1.0246024131774902,
0.5572562217712402,
-0.57147616147995,
0.024399956688284874,
-0.18874508142471313,
-0.727523922920227,
0.21007931232452393,
0.4062659740447998,
-0.24322091042995453,
1.387873649597168,
0.0025020225439220667,
-0.6303287744522095,
0.38197511434555054,
-0.1961793154478073,
-0.3295871317386627,
0.1495235115289688,
-0.293079137802124,
-0.4078468382358551,
0.00707218749448657,
0.05897404998540878,
0.3380003273487091,
-0.2288912832736969,
0.41983893513679504,
-0.48583173751831055,
-0.7404853105545044,
0.30999618768692017,
-0.33883771300315857,
0.5622413158416748,
0.008416042663156986,
-0.27336347103118896,
0.2177908569574356,
-0.3843485116958618,
0.21264001727104187,
-0.1717708855867386,
-0.4395899176597595,
-0.35196825861930847,
-0.01880532130599022,
-0.17022211849689484,
0.20488330721855164,
0.38073667883872986,
-0.35274726152420044,
0.4434715509414673,
-0.4433588981628418,
0.37918853759765625,
0.9649602770805359,
0.0592413954436779,
0.7361493706703186,
-0.5593484044075012,
0.09232984483242035,
0.1172063946723938,
0.306911438703537,
0.4790681302547455,
-0.40325629711151123,
-0.9449125528335571,
0.03469390794634819,
0.19584040343761444,
0.8167911171913147,
-0.870885968208313,
0.5120970010757446,
-0.5988510847091675,
-0.47616446018218994,
-0.3223349153995514,
0.10718624293804169,
0.2666335999965668,
0.593560516834259,
0.4554135501384735,
-0.03359699994325638,
0.025375325232744217,
-0.8213125467300415,
-0.2022850215435028,
-0.4913730025291443,
0.1174529492855072,
0.35521069169044495,
0.1585133671760559,
-0.1954370141029358,
0.6814089417457581,
-0.37951287627220154,
-0.09029245376586914,
-0.09351002424955368,
0.0630081444978714,
0.16762089729309082,
0.6145878434181213,
0.25687626004219055,
-0.8713111281394958,
-0.30040815472602844,
-0.2561861574649811,
-0.5462821125984192,
-0.1984388828277588,
0.11134051531553268,
-0.5075207352638245,
0.17158575356006622,
0.559309184551239,
-0.06528113037347794,
0.2522353529930115,
0.3083254098892212,
-0.24325355887413025,
0.2257588654756546,
-0.307270884513855,
0.4420466721057892,
-0.8665849566459656,
-0.1222490519285202,
-0.25578513741493225,
-0.2722107768058777,
-0.32060524821281433,
0.12885551154613495,
0.30591854453086853,
0.263327956199646,
-0.41392648220062256,
0.7284236550331116,
0.06573005765676498,
-0.14109927415847778,
-0.10389058291912079,
0.12908001244068146,
0.08368609100580215,
0.33660414814949036,
-0.07101917266845703,
0.8890125751495361,
0.2671787440776825,
-0.6287581920623779,
0.06573721766471863,
0.37137237191200256,
-0.17380490899085999,
0.9605480432510376,
-0.2318897396326065,
0.028145436197519302,
0.024077875539660454,
0.15064866840839386,
-1.3030486106872559,
0.11640629917383194,
0.18720202147960663,
-0.2578798532485962,
0.6159052848815918,
-0.31351813673973083,
-0.627016544342041,
0.24340279400348663,
-0.4442107379436493,
0.5687810778617859,
0.22900263965129852,
-0.764807403087616,
0.19350269436836243,
0.2839639186859131,
-0.32011523842811584,
-0.7707279324531555,
-0.619404673576355,
0.08763858675956726,
-0.2763347923755646,
-0.6322812438011169,
0.7469807863235474,
-0.6220197081565857,
-0.32371827960014343,
-0.28064581751823425,
-0.3729695677757263,
-0.006597424857318401,
0.3249158263206482,
0.13500003516674042,
0.4920549988746643,
0.07813026756048203,
0.17323610186576843,
0.19523298740386963,
-0.12460290640592575,
-0.2778869867324829,
-0.2265796959400177,
0.2056509107351303,
0.03592799976468086,
-0.5774784088134766,
0.16847355663776398,
0.26178187131881714,
0.6178134083747864,
0.09618138521909714,
0.6994954347610474,
0.16998343169689178,
-0.048945989459753036,
-0.04812211915850639,
-0.9573526382446289,
-0.3250507414340973,
-0.4518299102783203,
-0.040174879133701324,
-0.10575232654809952,
-1.041664958000183,
0.3288457989692688,
-0.12625466287136078,
0.1311177909374237,
0.21035966277122498,
0.2209518402814865,
-0.2787185311317444,
1.0900429487228394,
0.4622642695903778,
-0.05887620151042938,
0.7229157090187073,
0.003693308448418975,
0.19547443091869354,
-0.995250940322876,
-0.15334104001522064,
-0.5604474544525146,
-0.5609881281852722,
-0.7599449157714844,
-0.22708836197853088,
0.7853496670722961,
0.08528728038072586,
-0.251691609621048,
-0.05654805526137352,
-0.4058213531970978,
0.527167797088623,
0.3571372628211975,
0.19472092390060425,
0.5029323697090149,
0.2526121735572815,
-0.5389333963394165,
0.12957756221294403,
-0.4847206473350525,
-0.2717842757701874,
1.103406548500061,
-0.18424895405769348,
0.8070129752159119,
0.4888811707496643,
0.7866190671920776,
0.4138660430908203,
0.6040036082267761,
-0.6949400901794434,
0.5260241031646729,
-0.1631869673728943,
-0.20322854816913605,
-0.2891782224178314,
-0.6246350407600403,
-0.6704996824264526,
0.5076684355735779,
-0.2569555938243866,
-0.7574572563171387,
0.15325556695461273,
-0.09499391913414001,
-0.11988316476345062,
0.0891035869717598,
-0.4123660922050476,
0.637165904045105,
-0.36764153838157654,
-0.605525553226471,
-0.13044512271881104,
-0.7970574498176575,
0.4045588970184326,
0.16609852015972137,
-0.08295223116874695,
-0.19894561171531677,
0.11430986225605011,
0.4550509750843048,
-0.5714467763900757,
0.06749533116817474,
0.08243993669748306,
0.008048120886087418,
-0.46109750866889954,
0.2052871286869049,
0.5593457221984863,
0.29778751730918884,
-0.42987707257270813,
0.1581234186887741,
0.053582124412059784,
-0.30103981494903564,
-0.6201585531234741,
1.0583041906356812,
-0.7955413460731506,
-0.7720036506652832,
-0.5255439281463623,
-0.25254255533218384,
-0.4719422161579132,
0.024724483489990234,
0.5405911803245544,
0.565315842628479,
0.07088221609592438,
0.2059842348098755,
0.9380337595939636,
0.08960279822349548,
0.27500051259994507,
0.4867313504219055,
-0.09511849284172058,
-0.5935045480728149,
0.9643246531486511,
0.26532885432243347,
0.38910481333732605,
0.9018663167953491,
0.14491093158721924,
-0.5988309383392334,
-0.8411740064620972,
-0.445014089345932,
0.25515541434288025,
-0.8580625057220459,
-0.3436269760131836,
-0.44395166635513306,
-0.3158286213874817,
-0.42119041085243225,
-0.19809119403362274,
-0.1414365917444229,
-0.4960024654865265,
0.11286111176013947,
-0.013219546526670456,
0.16782359778881073,
0.5729911923408508,
0.1842658668756485,
-0.03590022400021553,
-0.5030458569526672,
0.07728961855173111,
0.17463234066963196,
0.36816030740737915,
-0.015005845576524734,
-0.7550529837608337,
-0.08564761281013489,
-0.36731746792793274,
-0.41325438022613525,
-0.5788963437080383,
0.17680424451828003,
0.012438158504664898,
0.8014565110206604,
0.43063870072364807,
0.16899427771568298,
0.8066162467002869,
-0.35479941964149475,
0.6490779519081116,
-0.08577725291252136,
-0.7408453226089478,
0.5229200124740601,
0.029307855293154716,
0.14795280992984772,
0.9721561670303345,
0.004020716063678265,
-0.5999497175216675,
-0.6708329319953918,
-0.5815902352333069,
-1.231649398803711,
0.5927950739860535,
0.30534735321998596,
-0.36036497354507446,
0.06747619807720184,
0.3523537516593933,
0.060094427317380905,
0.3527526259422302,
-0.8308833241462708,
-0.6713570952415466,
0.021608784794807434,
-0.1287945806980133,
-0.11530032008886337,
-0.3879539668560028,
-0.11692845076322556,
-0.26275965571403503,
0.8753960728645325,
-0.15580594539642334,
0.21341648697853088,
0.31893008947372437,
-0.438218891620636,
-0.03839123994112015,
0.2231830507516861,
0.7176554799079895,
0.6717310547828674,
-0.41257333755493164,
0.38917210698127747,
0.058144550770521164,
-0.2364104837179184,
0.3969023823738098,
0.15415576100349426,
-0.3210811913013458,
-0.22363053262233734,
-0.014231364242732525,
0.38463467359542847,
0.5702418088912964,
-0.5716667175292969,
0.5474549531936646,
-0.21338172256946564,
0.24603138864040375,
-0.18062101304531097,
0.04484406113624573,
0.03935401141643524,
0.04292173311114311,
0.5601540803909302,
0.23499320447444916,
0.23504164814949036,
-0.19656173884868622,
0.113998182117939,
0.7079775929450989,
-0.21717754006385803,
0.2732871174812317,
0.4598897397518158,
0.31332826614379883,
-0.24422301352024078,
0.5965345501899719,
-0.12940193712711334,
-0.4045710861682892,
0.4117498993873596,
0.2805670201778412,
0.6773967146873474,
-0.2700977921485901,
0.08973462879657745,
0.2509573996067047,
0.2001366913318634,
-0.3608925938606262,
0.14711332321166992,
-0.34235063195228577,
-0.7145615220069885,
0.02362416684627533,
-0.4792002737522125,
-0.8938223123550415,
-0.06429129838943481,
-0.5600271821022034,
0.15275712311267853,
-0.3670341670513153,
0.05219358205795288,
-0.41243240237236023,
0.033061668276786804,
-0.5210679769515991,
-0.16546039283275604,
0.03392547369003296,
0.7172547578811646,
-0.5556157827377319,
0.7759334444999695,
0.6122493743896484,
-0.364281564950943,
-0.539616048336029,
0.31715232133865356,
-0.09465202689170837,
-0.8093820214271545,
0.7630606293678284,
0.24306713044643402,
-0.3710346817970276,
0.054295048117637634,
-0.47480055689811707,
-1.0827980041503906,
1.2692028284072876,
0.42922350764274597,
-0.0703715905547142,
0.18970158696174622,
0.20494762063026428,
0.20595788955688477,
-0.2702132761478424,
0.7859516143798828,
0.11570663750171661,
0.4120829105377197,
0.4451867938041687,
-0.7761807441711426,
0.09898437559604645,
-0.15888842940330505,
-0.00972654577344656,
0.2820594012737274,
-0.8024621605873108,
0.6228604912757874,
0.162545844912529,
-0.1671569049358368,
0.2925644516944885,
0.3210591673851013,
0.5671661496162415,
0.29276177287101746,
0.4992237985134125,
0.48102569580078125,
1.0297715663909912,
-0.18216539919376373,
0.7871990203857422,
-0.4728280007839203,
0.19827991724014282,
1.06287682056427,
-0.7178124785423279,
1.1175347566604614,
0.6530938148498535,
-0.11014100909233093,
0.4581798315048218,
0.8308902978897095,
0.20095640420913696,
0.5499106049537659,
0.051328469067811966,
-0.3344767987728119,
-0.4897783398628235,
-0.10188810527324677,
-0.5198009014129639,
0.2186860591173172,
0.2572692036628723,
-0.19680093228816986,
-0.26374784111976624,
-0.2495260238647461,
-0.08333130180835724,
-0.3249019980430603,
-0.03198142349720001,
0.8113499879837036,
-0.02193344384431839,
-0.9874216914176941,
0.724701464176178,
-0.11043678224086761,
0.8548792600631714,
-0.4702698290348053,
-0.1685560941696167,
-0.6432160139083862,
0.07932978123426437,
-0.1684873104095459,
-0.6714402437210083,
-0.1468079686164856,
-0.3392270505428314,
-0.32738813757896423,
-0.6522529721260071,
0.49406546354293823,
-0.5595588684082031,
-0.33538857102394104,
0.28892505168914795,
0.6475695967674255,
0.2160334289073944,
-0.10192358493804932,
-0.7462165355682373,
0.012207896448671818,
-0.20050200819969177,
0.041815776377916336,
0.8269004821777344,
0.10225941240787506,
-0.03240422159433365,
0.7442036867141724,
0.6977479457855225,
-0.007587086409330368,
-0.3576759994029999,
0.09548942744731903,
0.5509368181228638,
-0.383840948343277,
-0.6369314789772034,
-0.9569329619407654,
0.08559006452560425,
-0.24381528794765472,
-0.04624961316585541,
0.5039940476417542,
0.5384824872016907,
0.7619102001190186,
0.3239191472530365,
0.3748180866241455,
0.39481601119041443,
0.30449163913726807,
-0.7493324279785156,
0.7960689067840576,
-0.7461945414543152,
0.6859906911849976,
-0.051058635115623474,
-0.986138105392456,
-0.29883044958114624,
0.570292592048645,
-0.11339424550533295,
-0.06984443217515945,
0.7606271505355835,
1.0030720233917236,
0.1616206020116806,
-0.31586727499961853,
0.44796672463417053,
0.22265349328517914,
0.37905892729759216,
0.5649765729904175,
0.8996443748474121,
-0.3443089425563812,
0.489317923784256,
0.02844068594276905,
-0.1473212093114853,
-0.6872653961181641,
-0.9674925208091736,
-0.5369491577148438,
-0.33604612946510315,
-0.38024377822875977,
-0.5620260834693909,
0.014594165608286858,
1.111124873161316,
0.781575083732605,
-0.77311110496521,
-0.4070785939693451,
0.07117708027362823,
0.8454886674880981,
-0.3388823866844177,
-0.2915235757827759,
0.14902767539024353,
-0.1390371322631836,
-0.8306988477706909,
0.6233083009719849,
0.6549013257026672,
0.05799238011240959,
-0.3494071662425995,
0.015630895271897316,
-0.14716540277004242,
-0.016413908451795578,
0.5081762671470642,
0.05717319995164871,
-0.953050434589386,
-0.4298619329929352,
-0.06920595467090607,
-0.3893287479877472,
0.6021458506584167,
0.6864861845970154,
-0.7920770645141602,
0.28127521276474,
0.6563236117362976,
0.6743761897087097,
0.182082861661911,
0.021183213219046593,
0.3220485746860504,
-0.7832832336425781,
-0.291862815618515,
0.08578512072563171,
0.42973047494888306,
0.4791913330554962,
-0.7420504093170166,
0.6751292943954468,
0.30571961402893066,
-0.811374843120575,
-1.042923092842102,
0.2481200248003006,
-1.2382793426513672,
-0.09663182497024536,
1.2034698724746704,
0.09449406713247299,
0.13009116053581238,
0.009659594856202602,
0.016741640865802765,
0.01365730632096529,
-0.501105010509491,
0.7884516716003418,
0.8389854431152344,
-0.5251993536949158,
0.12438047677278519,
-0.2742767333984375,
0.45827311277389526,
0.5818836092948914,
-0.8123652935028076,
-0.19384370744228363,
0.17850732803344727,
0.4365255534648895,
-0.056192610412836075,
0.5045554637908936,
-0.06134350597858429,
-0.041728775948286057,
-0.6203173995018005,
-0.3034137785434723,
0.0993913859128952,
-0.15299518406391144,
-0.3754512071609497,
0.20878733694553375,
0.3554621636867523,
0.17283231019973755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00226v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00226v1
|
Entangled Relations: Leveraging NLI and Meta-analysis to Enhance Biomedical Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T23:05:04
| 2024-05-31T23:05:04
|
William Hogan, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Recent research efforts have explored the potential of leveraging natural
language inference (NLI) techniques to enhance relation extraction (RE). In
this vein, we introduce MetaEntail-RE, a novel adaptation method that harnesses
NLI principles to enhance RE performance. Our approach follows past works by
verbalizing relation classes into class-indicative hypotheses, aligning a
traditionally multi-class classification task to one of textual entailment. We
introduce three key enhancements: (1) Instead of labeling non-entailed
premise-hypothesis pairs with the uninformative "neutral" entailment label, we
introduce meta-class analysis, which provides additional context by analyzing
overarching meta relationships between classes when assigning entailment
labels; (2) Feasible hypothesis filtering, which removes unlikely hypotheses
from consideration based on pairs of entity types; and (3) Group-based
prediction selection, which further improves performance by selecting highly
confident predictions. MetaEntail-RE is conceptually simple and empirically
powerful, yielding significant improvements over conventional relation
extraction techniques and other NLI formulations. Our experimental results
underscore the versatility of MetaEntail-RE, demonstrating performance gains
across both biomedical and general domains.
|
[
-0.3188951909542084,
-0.7230736017227173,
0.5761974453926086,
0.05141559615731239,
-0.18835896253585815,
-0.13377045094966888,
-0.09655828028917313,
-0.7887641191482544,
0.610106348991394,
0.48218071460723877,
-0.5433307886123657,
-0.10498541593551636,
-0.5479220151901245,
0.5805744528770447,
0.038132842630147934,
1.1755940914154053,
0.11705184727907181,
0.05693403258919716,
-0.6228892207145691,
-0.3924323320388794,
-0.31468623876571655,
-0.20884831249713898,
-0.5315209627151489,
-0.5069164633750916,
0.7914363145828247,
0.19055446982383728,
0.736770749092102,
0.6318461298942566,
0.687362015247345,
0.2577364444732666,
0.06114567071199417,
0.23505784571170807,
-0.2740892469882965,
0.253261923789978,
-0.43438953161239624,
-0.36529695987701416,
-0.708945095539093,
0.06806519627571106,
0.4196639657020569,
1.1132514476776123,
-0.09014638513326645,
0.3457675576210022,
0.180137500166893,
0.8254317045211792,
-1.2707455158233643,
-0.0008217353606596589,
-0.39929071068763733,
-0.008882279507815838,
-0.1927756816148758,
-0.42228177189826965,
-0.6346378326416016,
-0.19648855924606323,
0.5011602640151978,
-0.8318548202514648,
0.14477883279323578,
0.03528541326522827,
0.8450598120689392,
0.35103127360343933,
-0.5726667046546936,
-0.23945921659469604,
-0.6831963658332825,
0.5209487080574036,
-0.6686971783638,
0.8178747892379761,
0.3878336548805237,
0.22288565337657928,
-0.2284655123949051,
-1.0457041263580322,
-0.05872856825590134,
0.025695517659187317,
-0.35803404450416565,
0.5395318865776062,
-0.1897295117378235,
0.20205220580101013,
0.23779179155826569,
0.2340628206729889,
-0.2574966251850128,
-0.35776087641716003,
-0.23863182961940765,
0.06301216036081314,
0.6298364400863647,
-0.0031274622306227684,
0.5020908117294312,
-0.02676801010966301,
0.030005915090441704,
0.2803753912448883,
-0.6463199853897095,
-0.2855100929737091,
-0.05658252164721489,
0.03860031068325043,
0.26484930515289307,
0.47601452469825745,
0.11542592197656631,
0.6839801073074341,
0.2780718207359314,
-0.055640436708927155,
0.42238670587539673,
-0.34834909439086914,
-0.4092232882976532,
0.20308305323123932,
0.9070994257926941,
0.19692504405975342,
0.16777817904949188,
-0.7445708513259888,
0.38960736989974976,
-0.18393060564994812,
0.26774823665618896,
-1.0009979009628296,
-0.30129262804985046,
0.22812576591968536,
-0.9616014361381531,
-0.15502282977104187,
0.08478390425443649,
-1.1148793697357178,
-0.08280313014984131,
-0.39414331316947937,
0.4627133905887604,
-0.5758705139160156,
-0.5511205196380615,
0.31014007329940796,
-0.4460768401622772,
0.2960224449634552,
0.025948984548449516,
-0.9962787628173828,
0.5437405109405518,
0.8161498308181763,
0.7652854323387146,
-0.11797681450843811,
-0.30685362219810486,
-0.5882388353347778,
0.7365788817405701,
0.0016780884470790625,
0.6641497611999512,
-1.000802755355835,
-0.33294540643692017,
-0.18983134627342224,
0.13509652018547058,
-0.5046460628509521,
-0.43432530760765076,
0.6270482540130615,
-0.589660108089447,
0.39336901903152466,
-0.22031544148921967,
-0.6498894095420837,
-0.15808242559432983,
-0.011376754380762577,
-0.8778764009475708,
0.4413430988788605,
-0.2287951111793518,
-1.2866235971450806,
0.5379535555839539,
-0.7157413363456726,
-0.7037949562072754,
-0.1989225447177887,
-0.10497023165225983,
-0.5113564729690552,
0.17996281385421753,
0.2970033884048462,
0.14002647995948792,
-0.2923441231250763,
0.30918315052986145,
-0.7598161101341248,
-0.07577908039093018,
0.17070503532886505,
-0.07291554659605026,
0.8515827059745789,
0.1240699291229248,
-0.08997321873903275,
0.045685939490795135,
-0.792983889579773,
-0.07132916897535324,
-0.26745501160621643,
0.007490153890103102,
-0.7556856274604797,
0.14316411316394806,
-0.288520872592926,
-0.13664990663528442,
-0.07508379220962524,
-0.6145960688591003,
0.13978993892669678,
-0.6891681551933289,
0.345342755317688,
0.1770896315574646,
0.42766276001930237,
0.8572747707366943,
-0.0011823009699583054,
0.41475778818130493,
-0.27074697613716125,
0.12500514090061188,
0.2351280152797699,
-0.47158974409103394,
-0.5317769050598145,
-0.4285699129104614,
0.7101664543151855,
0.4745548665523529,
-0.9620072841644287,
0.5206940174102783,
-0.4413507282733917,
-0.15938745439052582,
-0.7037491202354431,
-0.14838634431362152,
0.2770751118659973,
0.40832868218421936,
0.6450899839401245,
-0.11711835861206055,
-0.7977249026298523,
-0.9117936491966248,
-0.8695749640464783,
-0.07971270382404327,
-0.13997329771518707,
0.1540147364139557,
0.5105878114700317,
-0.7873455286026001,
1.2045612335205078,
-0.6760881543159485,
-0.16282954812049866,
0.03787035122513771,
0.36482882499694824,
0.2443065345287323,
0.468875914812088,
0.5371598601341248,
-0.7106910347938538,
-0.3416751027107239,
-0.09587102383375168,
-0.9526191353797913,
-0.061106763780117035,
-0.017166519537568092,
-0.4912037253379822,
-0.3534124791622162,
0.47749099135398865,
-0.5701072216033936,
0.43211251497268677,
0.20629405975341797,
-0.4089631736278534,
0.27340173721313477,
-0.05311226099729538,
-0.018676992505788803,
-1.1640959978103638,
0.19335289299488068,
-0.13382937014102936,
-0.24879619479179382,
-0.8085685968399048,
-0.03288025036454201,
0.03867141157388687,
0.15165790915489197,
0.10612078756093979,
0.22864440083503723,
-0.7256686687469482,
0.09227730333805084,
-0.30968114733695984,
-0.18467891216278076,
0.08117882907390594,
0.10874564200639725,
0.19725264608860016,
0.4773523509502411,
0.4803193211555481,
-0.6021884083747864,
0.009555485099554062,
0.5217260122299194,
0.39594903588294983,
0.4044252038002014,
-0.6130785942077637,
0.12693263590335846,
-0.37272021174430847,
0.46320995688438416,
-0.6118302941322327,
-0.35912251472473145,
0.512212872505188,
-0.6498825550079346,
0.519883394241333,
-0.13648398220539093,
-0.19382040202617645,
0.043058935552835464,
-0.3878590762615204,
0.4597364068031311,
0.1405157744884491,
-0.5023301243782043,
1.2012077569961548,
0.33845338225364685,
0.14069795608520508,
-0.600416362285614,
-0.6447778940200806,
0.1989869624376297,
-0.30440425872802734,
-0.39821305871009827,
0.49979016184806824,
0.18744418025016785,
-0.1457410454750061,
0.4701917767524719,
-0.1412302404642105,
-0.42930373549461365,
0.15618117153644562,
0.2851758599281311,
0.15641619265079498,
-0.1941986083984375,
0.5351755023002625,
0.15713107585906982,
-0.35879650712013245,
0.36785176396369934,
0.15732435882091522,
-0.09002382308244705,
0.040961991995573044,
-0.034553010016679764,
-0.10903962701559067,
0.3402588963508606,
0.5161135196685791,
-0.5300115346908569,
0.9088764190673828,
0.7501600980758667,
-0.6303880214691162,
0.20840366184711456,
-0.43692654371261597,
-0.45164215564727783,
-0.40165022015571594,
0.37114161252975464,
-0.40102922916412354,
-0.6212567090988159,
0.18558552861213684,
-0.3629356622695923,
0.09853366017341614,
0.4618893563747406,
0.06000556796789169,
-0.09986095875501633,
0.6768948435783386,
0.7206708788871765,
-0.15002265572547913,
0.34064608812332153,
-0.06795842200517654,
0.299890398979187,
-1.2571028470993042,
-0.20140571892261505,
-0.3189965486526489,
-0.17242327332496643,
-0.7990670204162598,
-0.14126311242580414,
0.3199741244316101,
0.19460490345954895,
-0.15280576050281525,
0.44635340571403503,
-0.33723416924476624,
0.31188133358955383,
0.23863378167152405,
0.4917536675930023,
0.418230265378952,
-0.16927509009838104,
0.32868286967277527,
-0.3443247675895691,
-0.6465743184089661,
-0.270023912191391,
1.2637989521026611,
0.3623120188713074,
0.5951462388038635,
0.4559023678302765,
0.9676138758659363,
-0.2184062898159027,
0.8660801649093628,
-0.5938882827758789,
0.14580093324184418,
-0.021499518305063248,
-0.682706356048584,
-0.24423854053020477,
-0.6913062930107117,
-1.3308087587356567,
0.4967247545719147,
-0.6741681098937988,
-0.6572969555854797,
0.5453570485115051,
-0.11965552717447281,
-0.3444479703903198,
0.13060778379440308,
-0.6182453632354736,
0.6235995888710022,
0.046583399176597595,
-0.7227867245674133,
-0.023071840405464172,
-0.7917125821113586,
0.5881510376930237,
-0.1210797131061554,
0.23923008143901825,
-0.02892819419503212,
-0.29076817631721497,
0.9877914190292358,
-0.1601269245147705,
0.6566616892814636,
0.06723471730947495,
0.07576881349086761,
0.0922698974609375,
0.03751824423670769,
0.14179612696170807,
0.30653876066207886,
-0.27153706550598145,
-0.06265603750944138,
0.19611890614032745,
-0.11047888547182083,
-1.0015472173690796,
0.4399338662624359,
-0.5470929145812988,
-0.4034253656864166,
-0.48856621980667114,
-0.3649492859840393,
-0.49716463685035706,
0.32711514830589294,
0.2452690750360489,
0.42506131529808044,
-0.19682376086711884,
0.34446388483047485,
0.563306987285614,
-0.18217256665229797,
0.4895666539669037,
0.5066505670547485,
-0.18535450100898743,
-0.8441916108131409,
0.7011622190475464,
0.013353175483644009,
0.1257706731557846,
0.4954982101917267,
0.33087393641471863,
-0.32513487339019775,
-0.06987512111663818,
-0.23931947350502014,
0.5448938012123108,
-0.2987142503261566,
-0.4214221239089966,
-1.0320674180984497,
-0.12031398713588715,
-0.5145668983459473,
0.20833250880241394,
-0.219562366604805,
-0.1513495147228241,
-0.42141425609588623,
-0.07299262285232544,
0.30699002742767334,
0.4658590257167816,
-0.19485890865325928,
-0.0808001160621643,
-1.0425000190734863,
0.6065955758094788,
0.3813093602657318,
0.35558265447616577,
-0.0716964453458786,
-0.4108029901981354,
0.04142133519053459,
-0.09341017156839371,
-0.33581653237342834,
-1.3507856130599976,
0.18438947200775146,
0.7838289737701416,
0.6442925333976746,
0.45822060108184814,
0.13888432085514069,
0.9619871377944946,
-0.7247822880744934,
0.13248901069164276,
0.31186050176620483,
-0.8292531967163086,
0.5242869853973389,
-0.20821331441402435,
-0.14687466621398926,
0.8593720197677612,
0.470571368932724,
-0.19165827333927155,
-0.1703534871339798,
-0.8300553560256958,
-0.7427950501441956,
0.2015049159526825,
0.4008447825908661,
-0.25602295994758606,
-0.04805486649274826,
0.7498797178268433,
-0.11677689105272293,
0.2268950641155243,
-0.6734499335289001,
-0.30075234174728394,
-0.0077622137032449245,
-0.41981327533721924,
0.007100382354110479,
-0.30331888794898987,
-0.1272846907377243,
-0.5623128414154053,
0.4584338665008545,
-0.17515437304973602,
0.4043656289577484,
0.5753355622291565,
-0.15399521589279175,
-0.16568893194198608,
0.1720399111509323,
0.2914164364337921,
0.8468921780586243,
-0.4765188694000244,
0.2203146070241928,
0.3837800920009613,
-0.5180829167366028,
0.03010707162320614,
0.07851868867874146,
0.09283120185136795,
0.15472538769245148,
1.081904649734497,
0.37309354543685913,
0.46632716059684753,
-0.29061979055404663,
0.5998917818069458,
-0.02945239096879959,
-0.16719654202461243,
0.05778993293642998,
-0.13803459703922272,
0.16048869490623474,
0.17790131270885468,
0.11812108755111694,
0.050695426762104034,
0.862244188785553,
-0.6622298955917358,
0.5997949838638306,
0.4046945571899414,
-0.4299756586551666,
-0.4479803740978241,
0.7393356561660767,
0.40879878401756287,
-0.2706667184829712,
0.23466292023658752,
0.1256541907787323,
-0.29596957564353943,
0.26905664801597595,
0.6706018447875977,
1.210555911064148,
-0.19001606106758118,
0.07672721892595291,
0.7392666935920715,
0.24412578344345093,
0.06291231513023376,
-0.12204208970069885,
-0.0033231512643396854,
-0.8047642111778259,
-0.7709590792655945,
-0.4493984580039978,
-0.332689493894577,
-0.20640310645103455,
-1.2370020151138306,
0.027780447155237198,
-0.08316344767808914,
-0.30351558327674866,
0.1258789598941803,
-0.19189880788326263,
-0.47725027799606323,
0.07870999723672867,
-0.24361483752727509,
0.8546847701072693,
-0.956248939037323,
0.6710964441299438,
0.7360506057739258,
-0.33757761120796204,
-0.38699260354042053,
0.31057828664779663,
-0.31145796179771423,
-0.2273154854774475,
0.6481633186340332,
0.09144734591245651,
-0.23049919307231903,
-0.07618352025747299,
-0.3711965084075928,
-0.8801661729812622,
1.0154521465301514,
0.47021448612213135,
-0.540841817855835,
-0.021900342777371407,
-0.08320827782154083,
0.600823163986206,
-0.3845391869544983,
0.4403819441795349,
0.8998041152954102,
0.43050631880760193,
-0.08366875350475311,
-0.661945641040802,
0.29530617594718933,
-0.13540396094322205,
-0.30487099289894104,
0.40436872839927673,
-0.32621777057647705,
0.4078032076358795,
-0.256306916475296,
-0.2832885682582855,
-0.22631317377090454,
0.7779859900474548,
0.24860090017318726,
0.5841833353042603,
0.49487367272377014,
0.5346730351448059,
0.7785156965255737,
0.11831843852996826,
0.6572831273078918,
-0.1327333003282547,
0.4433060884475708,
1.4317560195922852,
-0.32834431529045105,
0.9312034249305725,
0.7541983127593994,
-0.2814221680164337,
0.6955506205558777,
0.5083787441253662,
0.21207527816295624,
0.6098871827125549,
-0.2230987548828125,
-0.11467147618532181,
-0.24651584029197693,
0.012046407908201218,
-0.587476909160614,
0.43861618638038635,
0.25849297642707825,
-0.43272337317466736,
-0.19141080975532532,
-0.03392360359430313,
0.011527030728757381,
-0.03077797032892704,
0.05231938883662224,
1.2616698741912842,
0.11347407102584839,
-0.5358667373657227,
0.20187129080295563,
-0.44806671142578125,
0.4478072226047516,
-0.3318650424480438,
-0.2506884038448334,
0.28810304403305054,
0.13408292829990387,
-0.36301204562187195,
-0.38499942421913147,
0.4272753894329071,
-0.4221205413341522,
-0.2687254250049591,
0.24608440697193146,
1.0344371795654297,
-0.7078994512557983,
-0.4907553195953369,
0.5617570281028748,
0.5311082601547241,
-0.22183513641357422,
0.0851549357175827,
-0.5686678886413574,
-0.20975589752197266,
-0.08772467821836472,
-0.048673663288354874,
0.02601899579167366,
0.6794667840003967,
0.3753242790699005,
0.49010273814201355,
0.6269332766532898,
0.1841706484556198,
-0.18454867601394653,
-0.10307452082633972,
0.8511285781860352,
-0.6737069487571716,
-0.07008025795221329,
-1.1608456373214722,
0.2836484909057617,
-0.43592652678489685,
-0.1034444198012352,
0.7814534902572632,
0.7181797623634338,
0.2233230173587799,
-0.19030976295471191,
0.6129698157310486,
0.1481211632490158,
0.4798869490623474,
-0.3609185516834259,
0.5348508358001709,
-0.4041682779788971,
-0.15696139633655548,
-0.5034843683242798,
-0.8352673649787903,
-0.5139318108558655,
0.44588249921798706,
-0.2861129939556122,
-0.13971751928329468,
0.9733095169067383,
0.22526364028453827,
-0.1473185122013092,
0.20597043633460999,
-0.04658582806587219,
-0.09805118292570114,
0.481635183095932,
0.6971129775047302,
0.589073896408081,
-0.79115891456604,
0.27026548981666565,
-0.05221979320049286,
-0.42768755555152893,
-0.048945799469947815,
-0.9504278302192688,
-0.9876477122306824,
-0.13165786862373352,
-0.5093783736228943,
-0.32866156101226807,
0.17686313390731812,
0.7905199527740479,
0.604475200176239,
-0.6899785995483398,
0.07796264439821243,
-0.1475822925567627,
0.08972244709730148,
-0.3430839478969574,
-0.1926599144935608,
0.42703676223754883,
-0.5002696514129639,
-0.40104275941848755,
0.2222810685634613,
0.32543203234672546,
-0.10668649524450302,
0.25976985692977905,
-0.05487317964434624,
-0.39494264125823975,
-0.0931912511587143,
0.5942707061767578,
0.20387482643127441,
-0.3472239077091217,
-0.26891663670539856,
-0.21435940265655518,
0.1369509994983673,
-0.16359864175319672,
0.9930505752563477,
-0.6066614389419556,
0.471455842256546,
0.44357937574386597,
0.9524726271629333,
0.40908002853393555,
0.1758335381746292,
0.8003004193305969,
-0.46514439582824707,
0.09053251892328262,
0.19270524382591248,
0.3225339353084564,
-0.04645775258541107,
-0.3497549891471863,
1.006810188293457,
0.25082287192344666,
-0.47028523683547974,
-0.8688620328903198,
0.17414864897727966,
-0.6706411242485046,
-0.3765164315700531,
1.131827473640442,
0.11977607756853104,
-0.424033522605896,
-0.32515963912010193,
-0.09774673730134964,
0.47730281949043274,
-0.0190784502774477,
0.6170214414596558,
0.3117034435272217,
-0.31235724687576294,
-0.1728140115737915,
-0.6744778752326965,
0.6818991899490356,
0.33793121576309204,
-1.1126176118850708,
0.0740005373954773,
-0.00860085804015398,
0.44196006655693054,
0.38488611578941345,
0.48183274269104004,
-0.06673074513673782,
0.32297033071517944,
-0.28536102175712585,
0.08204343169927597,
0.044376712292432785,
-0.31373175978660583,
-0.06949436664581299,
-0.09319935739040375,
-0.28490912914276123,
-0.5045010447502136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00222v1
|
Learning to Clarify: Multi-turn Conversations with Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training
| 2024-05-31T22:44:48
| 2024-05-31T22:44:48
|
Maximillian Chen, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan Ö. Arık, Tomas Pfister
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) aligned through reinforcement learning from
human feedback (RLHF) have quickly become one of the dominant paradigms for
building intelligent conversational assistant agents. However, despite their
strong performance across many benchmarks, LLM-based agents still lack
conversational skills such as disambiguation: when generalized assistants are
faced with ambiguity, they often overhedge or implicitly guess users'
ground-truth intents rather than asking clarification questions, and under
task-specific settings, high-quality conversation samples are often limited,
affecting models' ability to learn optimal dialogue action policies. We propose
Action-Based Contrastive Self-Training (henceforth ACT), a quasi-online
preference optimization algorithm based on Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
which allows for sample-efficient dialogue policy learning in multi-turn
conversation. We demonstrate ACT's efficacy under sample-efficient conditions
in three difficult conversational tasks: tabular-grounded question-answering,
machine reading comprehension, and AmbigSQL, a novel task for disambiguating
information-seeking requests for text-to-SQL generation. Additionally, we
propose evaluating LLMs' ability to function as conversational agents by
examining whether they can implicitly recognize and reason about ambiguity in
conversation. ACT demonstrates substantial conversation modeling improvements
over standard approaches to supervised fine-tuning and DPO.
|
[
-0.34124037623405457,
-0.9116249680519104,
0.6677433252334595,
0.15356765687465668,
-0.014967191964387894,
0.2836545705795288,
-0.1705932319164276,
-0.18284592032432556,
0.12380963563919067,
0.44104424118995667,
-0.8760172128677368,
-0.20427079498767853,
-0.5668972730636597,
0.06782884150743484,
-0.07446224987506866,
0.8224819898605347,
0.13041207194328308,
0.2956065237522125,
-0.06298507004976273,
-0.2638877332210541,
-0.37543895840644836,
-0.45340272784233093,
-0.8295850157737732,
-0.6292412281036377,
0.3598947525024414,
0.6171097755432129,
0.7196878790855408,
0.3566206395626068,
0.16969449818134308,
0.545573890209198,
-0.04302389174699783,
0.5762678980827332,
-0.6758984923362732,
0.15938273072242737,
-0.18390005826950073,
-0.4177591800689697,
-0.29951727390289307,
-0.06500734388828278,
0.269402414560318,
0.6177191734313965,
-0.5125847458839417,
-0.39249518513679504,
-0.01773202419281006,
0.5907899737358093,
-0.45731717348098755,
0.12458249181509018,
-0.688945472240448,
0.027053045108914375,
0.5043596625328064,
-0.2324681133031845,
-0.3378225862979889,
-0.15984617173671722,
0.2674133777618408,
-0.6326020359992981,
0.1495991200208664,
0.10242752730846405,
0.9511844515800476,
0.45146065950393677,
-0.4609932601451874,
-0.46221479773521423,
-0.8761322498321533,
0.7790942192077637,
-0.611003577709198,
0.35007068514823914,
0.5170376300811768,
0.13842149078845978,
-0.40359121561050415,
-0.3675459027290344,
-0.6970256567001343,
-0.3709547817707062,
-0.22940032184123993,
0.09719664603471756,
-0.02489118091762066,
0.4137271046638489,
0.08707404881715775,
0.4381375014781952,
-0.21932187676429749,
0.14198927581310272,
-0.21668192744255066,
-0.05366326496005058,
0.5699896812438965,
0.29946234822273254,
-0.14421185851097107,
0.04887952655553818,
-0.20481882989406586,
-0.24370282888412476,
-0.48537200689315796,
0.04521241784095764,
0.40019670128822327,
0.3437349796295166,
-0.17084503173828125,
0.2601684331893921,
-0.3222719430923462,
0.5348319411277771,
0.5390034914016724,
-0.2597709000110626,
0.11770530045032501,
-0.14286911487579346,
-0.2780787944793701,
-0.3323417901992798,
0.7911980748176575,
0.1111447736620903,
-0.0561419241130352,
-0.14759789407253265,
0.04264980927109718,
-0.33803924918174744,
0.41029900312423706,
-0.5080419778823853,
-0.05615546181797981,
0.4390416443347931,
-0.17445869743824005,
-0.09077296406030655,
-0.19543157517910004,
-0.5801246762275696,
-0.42556118965148926,
-0.6408610343933105,
0.5617239475250244,
-0.23459891974925995,
-0.10902629792690277,
0.08855371922254562,
0.2484186440706253,
0.3511436879634857,
0.5489833354949951,
-1.1023516654968262,
0.32119810581207275,
0.3423882722854614,
0.46273526549339294,
-0.32288143038749695,
-0.33560553193092346,
-0.5481975078582764,
0.04051300883293152,
-0.33781564235687256,
0.6053482890129089,
-0.5664682984352112,
-0.659087598323822,
0.14078018069267273,
0.003920121118426323,
-0.15260840952396393,
-0.6297255754470825,
0.2939092516899109,
-0.4697635769844055,
0.2844422459602356,
-0.09923846274614334,
-0.2864919602870941,
-0.07729925960302353,
0.5485440492630005,
-0.44646719098091125,
0.7942658066749573,
-0.019032904878258705,
-0.23885342478752136,
0.18068236112594604,
-0.7438751459121704,
-0.49203789234161377,
-0.2782697081565857,
-0.41056081652641296,
-0.5844279527664185,
-0.14383482933044434,
0.3647852838039398,
0.37454521656036377,
-0.08468456566333771,
0.23514574766159058,
-0.2573067545890808,
-0.2261277586221695,
0.24472576379776,
-0.4072902500629425,
0.4104437232017517,
0.07512108236551285,
-0.3904751241207123,
0.35038530826568604,
-0.5956266522407532,
0.017574090510606766,
0.15412117540836334,
-0.512847363948822,
0.07358689606189728,
-0.058149971067905426,
-0.5200524926185608,
0.2542351186275482,
0.025350943207740784,
-0.2448655217885971,
0.1755521446466446,
-0.4017574191093445,
0.2000020444393158,
0.7431217432022095,
-0.11603588610887527,
0.38165006041526794,
-0.053943902254104614,
0.42445728182792664,
0.22455018758773804,
0.362517386674881,
-0.1224733367562294,
-0.15056024491786957,
-1.413396954536438,
0.05588878318667412,
0.016268189996480942,
0.5817186236381531,
-0.9931709170341492,
0.4588119089603424,
-0.0327141210436821,
-0.24915380775928497,
-0.618942141532898,
0.25901633501052856,
0.7114953398704529,
0.5604011416435242,
0.4805460274219513,
-0.24525728821754456,
-0.17928527295589447,
-0.89434415102005,
0.008793583139777184,
-0.27280667424201965,
0.3096899092197418,
0.5535093545913696,
0.28646397590637207,
-0.2883845567703247,
0.7995538711547852,
-0.5261585116386414,
-0.25087809562683105,
-0.39131954312324524,
0.45480427145957947,
-0.13807137310504913,
0.16070643067359924,
-0.03137249872088432,
-0.887816846370697,
-0.49834540486335754,
-0.15944133698940277,
-0.4404758810997009,
0.11268360912799835,
-0.20354223251342773,
-0.04857635870575905,
0.16804853081703186,
0.5930562615394592,
-0.44746896624565125,
0.2818072438240051,
0.5292603969573975,
-0.1082228347659111,
0.2991552948951721,
-0.5142636299133301,
0.23785318434238434,
-0.8209433555603027,
-0.18848519027233124,
-0.12395459413528442,
-0.24658207595348358,
-0.8958072662353516,
-0.40801358222961426,
-0.1382012516260147,
-0.11512016505002975,
-0.5308411121368408,
0.6945755481719971,
-0.5137684345245361,
-0.16883337497711182,
-0.4266360402107239,
0.2561524510383606,
-0.03320695087313652,
1.1057837009429932,
0.23839646577835083,
0.88271164894104,
0.35986971855163574,
-1.0390664339065552,
0.24155722558498383,
0.5183607339859009,
0.13485457003116608,
0.6228311657905579,
-0.4785534143447876,
0.3434407413005829,
-0.10181733220815659,
0.222067192196846,
-1.0000346899032593,
-0.184404656291008,
0.3057107627391815,
-0.08617860823869705,
0.3624381124973297,
-0.14972321689128876,
0.06659816205501556,
-0.21933996677398682,
0.04669783264398575,
0.12502548098564148,
0.20320729911327362,
-0.7248151898384094,
0.8239595293998718,
0.3287026882171631,
-0.12867842614650726,
-0.78373783826828,
-0.4006655514240265,
-0.12909775972366333,
-0.09799116849899292,
-0.29012247920036316,
0.1741015762090683,
-0.13409991562366486,
-0.18552713096141815,
-0.4842827320098877,
-0.04945813864469528,
-0.10546955466270447,
0.05538101866841316,
0.14197082817554474,
0.06694949418306351,
0.32272711396217346,
0.3310956358909607,
-0.10378900170326233,
-0.06472122669219971,
-0.14027726650238037,
0.1511404663324356,
0.6773263812065125,
-0.36714500188827515,
-0.6999368071556091,
-0.27181312441825867,
0.3169582188129425,
0.2021952122449875,
-0.04388173297047615,
0.45300307869911194,
0.4306817650794983,
0.3543942868709564,
-0.22680418193340302,
-0.6157240271568298,
-0.49589183926582336,
-0.5421834588050842,
0.38457903265953064,
-0.3640218675136566,
-0.9266194701194763,
0.40334171056747437,
-0.28851181268692017,
0.24738357961177826,
0.12760309875011444,
0.4810764491558075,
-0.07350470125675201,
1.051947832107544,
0.44780704379081726,
0.09982828795909882,
0.7476919293403625,
-0.2311338186264038,
0.3753564655780792,
-0.6329686045646667,
-0.23711666464805603,
-0.38545435667037964,
-0.220432311296463,
-0.5644689798355103,
-0.34533530473709106,
0.3238973319530487,
-0.24536988139152527,
-0.244471475481987,
0.03349807858467102,
-0.28367865085601807,
0.41643083095550537,
0.6626734137535095,
0.21049289405345917,
0.26437172293663025,
-0.18271152675151825,
0.011544098146259785,
0.1818695068359375,
-0.5912920832633972,
-0.30816277861595154,
0.9732856750488281,
0.25828075408935547,
0.8768808245658875,
0.0933317244052887,
0.8263581395149231,
0.260306179523468,
0.11316165328025818,
-0.8668081760406494,
0.5904837846755981,
0.11770384013652802,
-0.38165631890296936,
-0.49965330958366394,
-0.33514535427093506,
-1.159332275390625,
0.5231698751449585,
-0.21331894397735596,
-0.455085813999176,
0.1613142341375351,
0.6217924356460571,
-0.4176899790763855,
-0.0850130245089531,
-0.8664396405220032,
0.7516642808914185,
-0.5212008357048035,
-0.4474600851535797,
-0.4073934853076935,
-0.7823302149772644,
0.13815893232822418,
0.40409940481185913,
0.03362919017672539,
-0.12639500200748444,
0.11719708889722824,
0.2684192359447479,
-0.3165471851825714,
0.9690611362457275,
-0.14802782237529755,
-0.2102765291929245,
0.24275724589824677,
-0.011566556990146637,
0.6457054018974304,
-0.16517134010791779,
0.12107367813587189,
0.0073696039617061615,
-0.34152868390083313,
-0.41681215167045593,
-0.7922586798667908,
0.37372371554374695,
-0.8708986639976501,
-0.9351327419281006,
-0.29100149869918823,
-0.14753951132297516,
-0.7752751111984253,
-0.09803654253482819,
-0.07679001986980438,
0.32363635301589966,
-0.4444480240345001,
-0.027148233726620674,
0.8964889645576477,
-0.03702671080827713,
0.33684220910072327,
0.861053466796875,
0.005609584506601095,
-0.2620859742164612,
0.8803958892822266,
-0.4204290807247162,
0.4789222776889801,
0.46336984634399414,
0.19195936620235443,
-0.4748227000236511,
-0.4964981973171234,
-0.4747702181339264,
0.3267262578010559,
-0.8280998468399048,
0.06514919549226761,
-0.5697988867759705,
-0.08253443241119385,
-0.15992459654808044,
0.12177878618240356,
-0.2648465037345886,
-0.06203262880444527,
-0.5793448090553284,
-0.054162561893463135,
0.10085523128509521,
0.5527086853981018,
0.0527045913040638,
0.5195475220680237,
-0.47448310256004333,
0.4588778614997864,
0.7251280546188354,
0.19212326407432556,
-0.21522781252861023,
-0.7033895254135132,
-0.15328313410282135,
0.0903007984161377,
-0.6912065148353577,
-0.7344754934310913,
0.1800713688135147,
0.2670549750328064,
0.6904221177101135,
0.5508301854133606,
-0.0031090974807739258,
0.6953355669975281,
-0.44995301961898804,
0.680199384689331,
0.2524568438529968,
-0.6312894821166992,
0.6090025305747986,
-0.15615509450435638,
0.24680446088314056,
0.718900740146637,
0.318714439868927,
-0.4609828591346741,
-0.23970699310302734,
-0.7651895880699158,
-0.6919967532157898,
0.9247477650642395,
0.02118995599448681,
0.29344305396080017,
-0.15242905914783478,
0.19782762229442596,
0.029871303588151932,
0.4540092945098877,
-0.7233608961105347,
-0.4114914834499359,
-0.23195113241672516,
-0.06325376033782959,
0.013192852027714252,
-0.11644438654184341,
-0.42377564311027527,
0.013443345203995705,
0.7847745418548584,
-0.5764347314834595,
0.24703559279441833,
0.2254994809627533,
-0.054091453552246094,
0.1868053525686264,
0.6596787571907043,
0.7821933627128601,
0.5381964445114136,
0.06605373322963715,
-0.012950320728123188,
0.37784910202026367,
-0.06173122301697731,
0.24220649898052216,
-0.019686659798026085,
0.22757528722286224,
-0.33493542671203613,
-0.10904383659362793,
1.1821779012680054,
0.18916280567646027,
-0.733063280582428,
0.45173200964927673,
-0.1166350319981575,
-0.12628377974033356,
-0.12886415421962738,
0.3999579846858978,
-0.06648249179124832,
0.24605520069599152,
0.07592955976724625,
-0.32220301032066345,
0.3493994474411011,
-0.8295757174491882,
-0.09304388612508774,
0.6746734976768494,
-0.5183481574058533,
0.08204197883605957,
0.036011748015880585,
0.7124328017234802,
-0.42680802941322327,
0.4540536403656006,
-0.33080828189849854,
-0.4009905755519867,
0.3220967650413513,
0.30040863156318665,
0.8484371304512024,
-0.3790574073791504,
0.4170726239681244,
0.12607818841934204,
-0.0956406518816948,
-0.12056002765893936,
0.17866894602775574,
-0.2576822340488434,
-0.762281596660614,
-0.06507427245378494,
-0.3135594129562378,
-0.8976889848709106,
0.3088114559650421,
-0.342793732881546,
0.11813943088054657,
-0.38201889395713806,
-0.0725855827331543,
-0.23316320776939392,
-0.08715188503265381,
-0.5405723452568054,
0.3270605206489563,
-0.1137576550245285,
0.2312452644109726,
-0.5989220142364502,
0.6218588948249817,
0.46623530983924866,
-0.3601289689540863,
-0.8101889491081238,
0.0516304150223732,
-0.063542939722538,
-0.9728386402130127,
0.3513126075267792,
-0.06622805446386337,
-0.47551429271698,
-0.1977454125881195,
-0.42670533061027527,
-0.657038152217865,
0.982673168182373,
0.41564449667930603,
-0.5880662798881531,
-0.13424275815486908,
0.21188165247440338,
0.6999971866607666,
-0.37555670738220215,
0.6365921497344971,
0.6220396161079407,
0.26590171456336975,
0.45495033264160156,
-0.9370583891868591,
-0.2605363726615906,
-0.05718202516436577,
-0.056279297918081284,
0.1784161925315857,
-1.0832160711288452,
0.5030562281608582,
-0.23920077085494995,
-0.024470709264278412,
-0.167258620262146,
0.6229467988014221,
0.12786591053009033,
0.16419529914855957,
0.5929421186447144,
0.36173754930496216,
0.6733550429344177,
-0.15737521648406982,
0.8470526337623596,
-0.050426091998815536,
0.003392284270375967,
1.446578025817871,
-0.27998387813568115,
0.7915472388267517,
0.5894308686256409,
-0.06534666568040848,
0.4909866750240326,
0.5201036334037781,
0.18405266106128693,
0.5101627707481384,
0.09723979234695435,
-0.33114516735076904,
-0.49242809414863586,
0.02442842163145542,
0.15311051905155182,
0.5081071257591248,
0.4372828006744385,
-0.1617763489484787,
-0.1674814522266388,
-0.06143726035952568,
-0.039274170994758606,
0.2964382469654083,
-0.19063521921634674,
1.3060015439987183,
-0.07297403365373611,
-1.1753634214401245,
0.6116509437561035,
-0.07968922704458237,
0.5224722027778625,
-0.7524822950363159,
-0.19953592121601105,
-0.48009803891181946,
0.20639635622501373,
-0.014647434465587139,
-0.5913084745407104,
0.0005033736233599484,
-0.38174909353256226,
0.09085787087678909,
-0.25458449125289917,
0.44106462597846985,
-0.7826434373855591,
0.07918914407491684,
0.29508107900619507,
0.45232775807380676,
0.26606717705726624,
0.18918545544147491,
-1.1702189445495605,
-0.07034897059202194,
0.14022989571094513,
-0.24703776836395264,
0.354139506816864,
0.29931268095970154,
0.004856205079704523,
0.9176574349403381,
0.2819916009902954,
-0.10860348492860794,
-0.11547787487506866,
0.28188133239746094,
0.8482762575149536,
-0.38711097836494446,
-0.504359781742096,
-0.5281471610069275,
0.4923543334007263,
-0.2929733991622925,
-0.4183844327926636,
0.3487710654735565,
0.235835999250412,
0.6586262583732605,
0.024062126874923706,
0.6734543442726135,
0.1252375841140747,
0.6248840093612671,
-0.644197940826416,
0.13637518882751465,
-0.5214385986328125,
0.24415463209152222,
0.10772880166769028,
-0.6075657606124878,
0.24976113438606262,
0.5875481963157654,
-0.5028858780860901,
0.4014054834842682,
0.5599116086959839,
0.9495410323143005,
-0.18086864054203033,
-0.1363207846879959,
0.5192244648933411,
-0.005152765661478043,
0.4933661222457886,
0.3537602126598358,
0.7409619688987732,
-0.3029482960700989,
0.967666745185852,
-0.02474159561097622,
-0.07060785591602325,
-0.4899299144744873,
-0.7357273101806641,
-1.1287487745285034,
-0.6837372779846191,
-0.24371060729026794,
-0.19657793641090393,
0.3205302059650421,
1.045820713043213,
0.9091833829879761,
-0.7508242726325989,
-0.2834777235984802,
-0.250566303730011,
0.2524521052837372,
-0.07661575078964233,
-0.14904512465000153,
0.214240163564682,
-0.68159419298172,
-0.9809589982032776,
0.661582887172699,
0.2651768624782562,
0.2637481689453125,
-0.3223543167114258,
-0.5939944386482239,
-0.2934631109237671,
0.3319211006164551,
0.35628530383110046,
0.6566065549850464,
-0.9790874719619751,
-0.12286671251058578,
-0.2584420144557953,
-0.198661670088768,
0.38499313592910767,
0.7973631024360657,
-0.4842081665992737,
0.5895681977272034,
0.03143427148461342,
0.6701911091804504,
0.5658127069473267,
0.3147522211074829,
0.6268408894538879,
-0.945104718208313,
0.18881641328334808,
0.28085100650787354,
0.11020523309707642,
0.4810866713523865,
-0.34239304065704346,
0.3459084630012512,
-0.1444355994462967,
-0.5839223861694336,
-0.3681909739971161,
0.5493720173835754,
-0.7249494791030884,
-0.18621227145195007,
1.3520007133483887,
-0.16064047813415527,
0.07188772410154343,
-0.35143473744392395,
-0.6426618099212646,
0.11536835134029388,
-0.6795144081115723,
1.068953514099121,
0.5752236843109131,
-0.6721653342247009,
-0.39278119802474976,
-0.06353044509887695,
0.9330090284347534,
0.6730073690414429,
-1.168013334274292,
0.23345455527305603,
0.592944860458374,
-0.043159738183021545,
0.2951035797595978,
0.8127928972244263,
0.259939044713974,
0.22184999287128448,
-0.22892875969409943,
0.034299224615097046,
-0.03952460736036301,
-0.41933146119117737,
-0.39043280482292175,
-0.04740416631102562,
0.30370840430259705,
-0.17707526683807373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00199v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00199v2
|
Exfiltration of personal information from ChatGPT via prompt injection
| 2024-05-31T21:21:19
| 2024-06-06T06:43:38
|
Gregory Schwartzman
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.ET
|
We report that ChatGPT 4 and 4o are susceptible to a prompt injection attack
that allows an attacker to exfiltrate users' personal data. It is applicable
without the use of any 3rd party tools and all users are currently affected.
This vulnerability is exacerbated by the recent introduction of ChatGPT's
memory feature, which allows an attacker to command ChatGPT to monitor the user
for the desired personal data.
|
[
-0.5275667905807495,
-1.177941083908081,
0.7483281493186951,
-0.12722718715667725,
-0.11692874878644943,
0.11744976043701172,
0.4570745527744293,
-0.5788571834564209,
-0.09132182598114014,
0.7996737360954285,
-0.5381750464439392,
-0.13468089699745178,
-0.6256825923919678,
-0.04184689000248909,
-0.3206813335418701,
1.0887556076049805,
0.28365591168403625,
-0.27677807211875916,
0.21581466495990753,
0.10067848861217499,
-0.9231858253479004,
-1.0140961408615112,
-1.0080130100250244,
0.04833139851689339,
0.4650056064128876,
0.7057085633277893,
0.781795084476471,
0.1196606382727623,
0.6576266288757324,
0.31393444538116455,
0.2129318118095398,
-0.6910216808319092,
-0.5635616779327393,
0.2211366891860962,
-0.021921847015619278,
-0.7514262795448303,
-0.17601224780082703,
0.08934590220451355,
0.2652222812175751,
0.16798840463161469,
-0.10440712422132492,
-0.2527184784412384,
-0.022770119830965996,
0.3642556369304657,
-0.5003823041915894,
-0.08478020131587982,
-0.6161562204360962,
0.21328245103359222,
-0.7170782089233398,
-0.5762554407119751,
-0.444179892539978,
-0.2855932116508484,
0.2940496802330017,
-0.4236227571964264,
0.38724812865257263,
0.3440532386302948,
0.5753204822540283,
0.0777105987071991,
-0.5931040048599243,
-0.45746394991874695,
-0.506581723690033,
0.303991436958313,
-0.3844295144081116,
0.04896492138504982,
0.3815135657787323,
0.6894341111183167,
-0.5273987650871277,
-0.8505541682243347,
-0.5652467608451843,
-0.16831353306770325,
-0.11300595104694366,
0.08430558443069458,
-0.3736155331134796,
0.46194806694984436,
0.5315393805503845,
0.4641762375831604,
-0.653631865978241,
-0.004443467129021883,
-0.5303518176078796,
-0.3160572946071625,
0.03355482220649719,
0.017669962719082832,
0.7333741188049316,
-0.32479235529899597,
-0.9264612197875977,
0.10794851928949356,
-0.8853936791419983,
0.017486808821558952,
0.8789081573486328,
-0.08112958073616028,
0.09251392632722855,
0.47778502106666565,
-0.042451515793800354,
0.7170665860176086,
0.009100167080760002,
0.22532705962657928,
0.14869603514671326,
-0.303284227848053,
-0.33526334166526794,
0.17401067912578583,
0.7831088304519653,
0.34604352712631226,
0.009656108915805817,
0.12387827783823013,
-0.17903780937194824,
-0.485067754983902,
0.16915100812911987,
-0.8974764347076416,
-0.5245946645736694,
0.45786967873573303,
-0.03412048891186714,
-0.06588485836982727,
0.21337077021598816,
-1.048824429512024,
-0.6340746283531189,
0.5557774901390076,
0.43544358015060425,
-0.7336447238922119,
0.058090727776288986,
-0.0586402490735054,
-0.5874361991882324,
0.3590255677700043,
0.37737607955932617,
-1.0504425764083862,
0.3979049623012543,
0.6524479985237122,
0.951251208782196,
-0.14616698026657104,
-0.29897189140319824,
-0.7228533625602722,
0.20885375142097473,
0.15266743302345276,
0.9319919347763062,
-0.6024851202964783,
-0.6404465436935425,
0.07933914661407471,
-0.08666504919528961,
0.018955351784825325,
-0.5452651381492615,
0.5223929286003113,
-0.8188581466674805,
0.43239879608154297,
-0.4174695909023285,
-0.5885005593299866,
-0.3051168918609619,
0.08583394438028336,
-0.5719607472419739,
0.7800278067588806,
0.40367940068244934,
-0.8387616276741028,
0.23970018327236176,
-0.7738577127456665,
-0.05315927788615227,
0.38380685448646545,
-0.07172570377588272,
-0.06213843822479248,
-0.10656062513589859,
-0.05710967630147934,
0.5878735780715942,
0.19697652757167816,
-0.30609655380249023,
-0.30227798223495483,
-0.48846182227134705,
0.5510430335998535,
-0.5042478442192078,
0.6317355632781982,
0.3651314079761505,
-0.0949283242225647,
-0.06717090308666229,
-0.49921631813049316,
0.04191606119275093,
-0.09367413818836212,
-0.07143475860357285,
-0.21966996788978577,
-0.22945238649845123,
-0.2552027702331543,
0.16984473168849945,
0.3753418028354645,
-0.523798942565918,
0.3953292965888977,
-0.4877907931804657,
0.5619676113128662,
0.912053644657135,
0.8996449708938599,
0.34203463792800903,
-0.22176004946231842,
0.7780017256736755,
0.35000738501548767,
0.45664823055267334,
-0.5272845029830933,
-1.1202943325042725,
-0.10219383239746094,
-0.05675375089049339,
-0.25448086857795715,
0.8685269355773926,
-0.8513527512550354,
-0.01520821638405323,
0.24405358731746674,
-0.3617914021015167,
0.30899128317832947,
0.10187838226556778,
0.33245041966438293,
0.6051825284957886,
0.2796313166618347,
-0.0029405250679701567,
0.015349837020039558,
-0.9404036402702332,
-0.4025106728076935,
-0.19863654673099518,
-0.24869029223918915,
0.5049972534179688,
0.3629901707172394,
-0.1296415627002716,
0.8920971751213074,
-0.6846389770507812,
-0.3308984339237213,
0.005674355197697878,
0.021762190386652946,
0.5318862795829773,
0.504268229007721,
0.6867861747741699,
-0.8493087887763977,
-0.5581206679344177,
-0.0036540841683745384,
-0.34366220235824585,
-0.3949943482875824,
-0.3195498585700989,
-0.15801231563091278,
-0.3239172697067261,
0.25737378001213074,
-0.718430757522583,
0.5684901475906372,
0.5854004621505737,
-0.7305760979652405,
0.258662611246109,
-0.3904940187931061,
0.5451430082321167,
-1.0637632608413696,
-0.14034442603588104,
-0.3107539117336273,
-0.4267968237400055,
-1.024856448173523,
0.2450055181980133,
0.07451833039522171,
-0.5571396946907043,
-0.6182975172996521,
0.396867573261261,
-0.2982788383960724,
-0.015473546460270882,
0.07868225872516632,
0.37873440980911255,
-0.18581567704677582,
0.2796323895454407,
-0.5711758136749268,
1.0374025106430054,
0.492282509803772,
-0.5318639278411865,
0.5485357642173767,
0.3008610010147095,
-0.2262742519378662,
0.49643081426620483,
-0.6875512003898621,
0.5069888234138489,
0.18144524097442627,
0.15958422422409058,
-1.265055537223816,
-0.8026623129844666,
1.0613991022109985,
-0.5985354781150818,
0.33964139223098755,
-0.34944379329681396,
-0.2115366905927658,
0.026218120008707047,
-0.44644731283187866,
0.36131152510643005,
0.602144181728363,
-0.570430338382721,
0.35648560523986816,
0.3572511374950409,
-0.18276499211788177,
-0.44526517391204834,
-0.7161272764205933,
0.3031056225299835,
-0.5215945839881897,
-0.8014010787010193,
0.3286620080471039,
-0.062332917004823685,
0.08005377650260925,
-0.22618943452835083,
0.17356055974960327,
-0.4398663640022278,
0.18388870358467102,
0.30937260389328003,
0.18692360818386078,
0.27045994997024536,
-0.16103322803974152,
-0.10355805605649948,
-0.20857559144496918,
0.005397255998104811,
0.14482149481773376,
0.7706252932548523,
0.20274989306926727,
-0.7801774144172668,
-0.7397601008415222,
0.9648504853248596,
0.29340410232543945,
0.13126899302005768,
0.5901397466659546,
0.23685292899608612,
-0.08025912195444107,
0.19456224143505096,
-0.6199660301208496,
-0.32202252745628357,
-0.5955872535705566,
0.19371163845062256,
-0.6048263907432556,
-0.9353493452072144,
0.8071002960205078,
-0.02232608012855053,
-0.20220158994197845,
0.04079017788171768,
0.06195174902677536,
-0.03658309206366539,
1.1201484203338623,
0.34134045243263245,
0.20222662389278412,
0.6197707653045654,
0.3508099317550659,
0.206490620970726,
-0.747405469417572,
-0.27407580614089966,
-0.4528082013130188,
-0.1346672624349594,
-0.6479766964912415,
-0.20124180614948273,
0.3509850800037384,
0.2595408856868744,
-0.2858559489250183,
0.35391613841056824,
-0.49858859181404114,
0.44170817732810974,
0.7681316137313843,
0.2880643904209137,
0.13704927265644073,
-0.2214704006910324,
0.16795647144317627,
0.043760426342487335,
-0.4443264901638031,
-0.3027423918247223,
0.7568665146827698,
0.21451863646507263,
0.9390050768852234,
0.3084046244621277,
0.8021554946899414,
0.5075361132621765,
-0.30480632185935974,
-0.5696425437927246,
0.4802273213863373,
0.4061126112937927,
-0.7856574058532715,
-0.07899033278226852,
-0.32071322202682495,
-1.2092866897583008,
-0.2017831653356552,
0.4484679698944092,
-1.2286301851272583,
0.3074544668197632,
0.5453596711158752,
-0.609147846698761,
0.11214759945869446,
-1.6331876516342163,
0.7066619992256165,
0.049010928720235825,
0.00027422767016105354,
0.11129704862833023,
-0.651472806930542,
0.44117188453674316,
-0.42724308371543884,
-0.12074077874422073,
-0.14673274755477905,
-0.28639888763427734,
0.6405479907989502,
-0.8627410531044006,
1.0805156230926514,
-0.6177786588668823,
0.16419343650341034,
0.4728768765926361,
0.16072165966033936,
0.911124587059021,
0.4119746685028076,
0.30487260222435,
0.2905549705028534,
0.19031542539596558,
-0.5692634582519531,
-0.8643654584884644,
0.6390697956085205,
-0.6312465667724609,
-1.197206974029541,
-0.7802810072898865,
0.07351083308458328,
-0.0873263031244278,
0.02030443772673607,
0.5773288607597351,
0.08823008835315704,
0.0880068689584732,
0.04021677374839783,
0.6465844511985779,
-0.6302520036697388,
0.572442352771759,
0.2048020362854004,
-0.04762260615825653,
-0.2799108028411865,
0.6740145683288574,
0.22444799542427063,
0.688993513584137,
0.14381811022758484,
0.19962044060230255,
-0.08090420067310333,
-0.5285982489585876,
-0.3629631996154785,
0.006187367718666792,
-0.708471417427063,
-0.3208383321762085,
-0.6748016476631165,
-0.22373193502426147,
-0.35559457540512085,
-0.1957024484872818,
-0.0769038125872612,
-0.315414696931839,
-0.19607941806316376,
-0.0054329633712768555,
0.7113638520240784,
0.6511792540550232,
-0.014523927122354507,
1.132761001586914,
-0.8942662477493286,
0.2598358690738678,
0.5004435777664185,
0.14828045666217804,
-0.6870947480201721,
-0.5994793772697449,
0.0737367495894432,
-0.02453295886516571,
-0.2628980278968811,
-1.601586103439331,
0.3039698004722595,
0.22675096988677979,
0.4864855706691742,
0.6937997341156006,
-0.1650165319442749,
0.7579999566078186,
-0.7111248970031738,
1.1307977437973022,
0.27247488498687744,
-1.0753477811813354,
0.8416799902915955,
-0.4571813642978668,
0.4691302180290222,
0.38710036873817444,
0.34262654185295105,
-0.9700483083724976,
-0.23595832288265228,
-0.6443649530410767,
-0.7059952616691589,
0.7894965410232544,
0.25543347001075745,
0.424176424741745,
-0.2660782039165497,
0.5485280156135559,
0.07710390537977219,
0.03589721769094467,
-0.3652639389038086,
-0.2515788972377777,
-0.25297293066978455,
0.4623637795448303,
0.4097951054573059,
-0.7397226095199585,
0.15628309547901154,
0.32806819677352905,
0.21751073002815247,
0.18844106793403625,
0.7708401679992676,
0.25837570428848267,
0.34872573614120483,
0.3842304050922394,
0.10508193075656891,
0.324234277009964,
0.31091776490211487,
-0.0256109070032835,
0.17700093984603882,
0.25952741503715515,
-0.8364184498786926,
0.2736351788043976,
-0.16935347020626068,
-0.042618267238140106,
-0.15104830265045166,
0.16816844046115875,
0.4486769437789917,
0.37598690390586853,
-0.40438970923423767,
0.9035970568656921,
-0.29423606395721436,
0.16773954033851624,
-0.6909131407737732,
0.680057942867279,
-0.3702360689640045,
0.050892796367406845,
0.26802775263786316,
0.4202638268470764,
0.4751618504524231,
-0.55874103307724,
0.2651599645614624,
0.30803418159484863,
-0.5140329599380493,
-0.6272696256637573,
0.7326412796974182,
0.05706336349248886,
-0.2893420159816742,
0.7576775550842285,
-0.06089626997709274,
-0.5420218706130981,
0.28210383653640747,
0.6071069240570068,
0.7394046783447266,
-1.154411792755127,
-0.05642068758606911,
0.22578643262386322,
0.2537311613559723,
0.327434241771698,
0.5097407102584839,
0.03581778332591057,
-0.754988968372345,
-0.30620136857032776,
-0.00856548361480236,
-0.44750964641571045,
-0.05577744171023369,
-0.5527989864349365,
0.5165334939956665,
-0.5940106511116028,
-0.23501503467559814,
-0.22464941442012787,
-0.5096190571784973,
-0.7041245102882385,
0.05442655831575394,
-0.10120970755815506,
0.8628941774368286,
-0.5210835933685303,
0.7206552624702454,
0.25826501846313477,
-0.10377529263496399,
-0.5476655960083008,
-0.03910805284976959,
0.14132334291934967,
-1.0224367380142212,
0.6113718152046204,
0.20481184124946594,
0.07221498340368271,
0.09139960259199142,
-0.4746384918689728,
-0.9220510721206665,
0.8316197991371155,
0.4209112524986267,
-0.08617091178894043,
0.039908651262521744,
0.1806631237268448,
0.0017159123672172427,
0.15951134264469147,
0.5761165618896484,
0.6718308329582214,
0.5894340872764587,
0.16618883609771729,
-0.4595353603363037,
0.057102859020233154,
-0.14198552072048187,
-0.2418026626110077,
0.4608616530895233,
-0.6811227202415466,
0.8545141816139221,
-0.06725022941827774,
-0.5966997146606445,
-0.3624468445777893,
0.26485133171081543,
-0.002084648935124278,
0.10067812353372574,
0.4335748851299286,
0.4424006938934326,
1.0948162078857422,
-0.31542760133743286,
1.4003854990005493,
-0.2897240221500397,
-0.0929386094212532,
1.0888302326202393,
-0.34823527932167053,
0.5595988035202026,
0.4441988170146942,
-0.17172196507453918,
0.26936259865760803,
0.8418833613395691,
0.08113699406385422,
0.5775607824325562,
-0.15068358182907104,
-0.873491108417511,
0.32228711247444153,
0.282632976770401,
-0.5733984708786011,
0.554923951625824,
0.7188705801963806,
-0.19433791935443878,
-0.05738253891468048,
0.2591116726398468,
0.49029988050460815,
-0.7104935646057129,
0.126924067735672,
0.8051131963729858,
-0.15973080694675446,
-0.6236056685447693,
0.293331116437912,
-0.13757415115833282,
0.21954666078090668,
-0.8348883390426636,
-0.12019119411706924,
-0.17468947172164917,
-0.20627905428409576,
-0.3616601228713989,
-0.8974313735961914,
0.3359599709510803,
-0.17484787106513977,
0.17943519353866577,
-0.14850835502147675,
0.9016574621200562,
0.1099708154797554,
0.39108172059059143,
0.2034500688314438,
0.32235029339790344,
0.3713464140892029,
-0.6197529435157776,
-0.6248687505722046,
-0.11516040563583374,
0.32943129539489746,
-0.7481189966201782,
0.44509318470954895,
0.5802417397499084,
0.07069586962461472,
0.8925930857658386,
0.8266814351081848,
-0.03649648278951645,
0.45338842272758484,
-0.07657468318939209,
1.1198139190673828,
-0.8930960297584534,
-0.41179609298706055,
-1.3574750423431396,
0.1892324686050415,
-0.5400310754776001,
-0.3498246669769287,
1.2288886308670044,
0.6542891263961792,
0.5177988409996033,
-0.015751061961054802,
0.8593173623085022,
-0.24589718878269196,
0.45602163672447205,
-0.47644078731536865,
0.563867449760437,
0.23800590634346008,
0.3565455377101898,
-0.21854683756828308,
-0.7382829785346985,
-0.1962059736251831,
0.06378532946109772,
-0.3524812161922455,
0.10880690068006516,
1.005396842956543,
0.9395896196365356,
0.04731474071741104,
0.20155824720859528,
0.6754522323608398,
0.1759822815656662,
0.6751630306243896,
0.6733441352844238,
1.1291934251785278,
-0.3019305169582367,
0.7032434344291687,
-0.2875218689441681,
-0.6310187578201294,
-0.13618981838226318,
-0.7744000554084778,
-1.1154608726501465,
-0.5483494400978088,
-0.1532386690378189,
-0.09005719423294067,
0.08746624737977982,
0.32088008522987366,
0.6972817778587341,
-0.6574991345405579,
0.334449827671051,
-0.26274046301841736,
-0.02889196388423443,
0.354328453540802,
-0.331740140914917,
0.15129826962947845,
-0.34525081515312195,
-0.8767525553703308,
0.44977375864982605,
0.5966958999633789,
0.3318723738193512,
-0.1866850107908249,
0.36544907093048096,
0.028567694127559662,
0.024384256452322006,
0.25137820839881897,
0.3885815441608429,
-0.46797317266464233,
-0.7043780088424683,
-0.22731579840183258,
0.0963120311498642,
0.2334967702627182,
0.9257520437240601,
-0.8399435877799988,
0.525886595249176,
0.8001532554626465,
0.5360569953918457,
0.3347569704055786,
0.18524868786334991,
0.6788052916526794,
-0.9481697678565979,
0.2640232443809509,
0.1513877958059311,
0.48925289511680603,
0.08246258646249771,
-1.083080530166626,
0.3245978057384491,
0.30179253220558167,
-1.0078598260879517,
-0.39827001094818115,
0.30954882502555847,
-0.9529032111167908,
-0.0503726527094841,
1.0080586671829224,
-0.5990355610847473,
-0.382755309343338,
-0.6946725249290466,
-0.6402800679206848,
-0.18014220893383026,
-0.7749841213226318,
0.5417136549949646,
0.8547443151473999,
-0.669765055179596,
-0.4270514249801636,
-1.3761435747146606,
0.6171989440917969,
0.0009759953827597201,
-1.003671407699585,
-0.3274216949939728,
0.36287999153137207,
0.08503739535808563,
0.006071438081562519,
0.7088443040847778,
-0.16440445184707642,
0.2963569164276123,
0.12933017313480377,
-0.32073742151260376,
0.1740058958530426,
0.1256527155637741,
-0.20281027257442474,
0.5816394686698914,
-0.15053021907806396,
-0.41127893328666687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00197v1
|
Re3: A Holistic Framework and Dataset for Modeling Collaborative Document Revision
| 2024-05-31T21:19:09
| 2024-05-31T21:19:09
|
Qian Ruan, Ilia Kuznetsov, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collaborative review and revision of textual documents is the core of
knowledge work and a promising target for empirical analysis and NLP
assistance. Yet, a holistic framework that would allow modeling complex
relationships between document revisions, reviews and author responses is
lacking. To address this gap, we introduce Re3, a framework for joint analysis
of collaborative document revision. We instantiate this framework in the
scholarly domain, and present Re3-Sci, a large corpus of aligned scientific
paper revisions manually labeled according to their action and intent, and
supplemented with the respective peer reviews and human-written edit summaries.
We use the new data to provide first empirical insights into collaborative
document revision in the academic domain, and to assess the capabilities of
state-of-the-art LLMs at automating edit analysis and facilitating text-based
collaboration. We make our annotation environment and protocols, the resulting
data and experimental code publicly available.
|
[
-0.2602612376213074,
-0.5321702361106873,
0.5547738671302795,
0.1048455759882927,
0.18377450108528137,
0.14285756647586823,
0.10959263890981674,
-0.6246984004974365,
0.38603657484054565,
0.8805356025695801,
-0.6155366897583008,
-0.5335425734519958,
-0.31278741359710693,
0.5037762522697449,
-0.34424903988838196,
1.039931058883667,
-0.4296436905860901,
0.0840051919221878,
-0.5270159244537354,
-0.1956261545419693,
-0.19623427093029022,
-0.32687580585479736,
-0.26122942566871643,
-0.6038788557052612,
0.8225631713867188,
0.36533790826797485,
0.49373406171798706,
0.4169073700904846,
0.8266665935516357,
0.32745465636253357,
0.17053355276584625,
0.04134008288383484,
-0.42784419655799866,
0.30649837851524353,
-0.07586125284433365,
-0.3092312514781952,
-1.1746195554733276,
0.2774088680744171,
0.462272047996521,
1.0201480388641357,
0.06184479221701622,
0.1845552623271942,
0.35049986839294434,
0.8411320447921753,
-0.47445523738861084,
0.2433859258890152,
-0.48700031638145447,
0.004089081659913063,
-0.1498587429523468,
-0.18719056248664856,
-0.36107972264289856,
-0.13302095234394073,
0.145782470703125,
-1.1485122442245483,
0.7808496356010437,
0.2880399823188782,
0.4322861135005951,
0.3179318308830261,
-0.06377101689577103,
-0.15848024189472198,
-0.4905765950679779,
0.48698750138282776,
-0.5026749968528748,
0.22992248833179474,
0.37245699763298035,
-0.06066497042775154,
-0.49955660104751587,
-0.9629886746406555,
-0.47850802540779114,
0.18336445093154907,
-0.1558864414691925,
0.24501889944076538,
0.08415373414754868,
-0.003804036881774664,
-0.13410334289073944,
0.5208088755607605,
-0.4203050434589386,
-0.23176802694797516,
-0.24654807150363922,
-0.04189852997660637,
0.8320894837379456,
0.11519332230091095,
0.09880436211824417,
-0.040681254118680954,
-0.267017662525177,
-0.07577326893806458,
-0.5966184735298157,
-0.48699232935905457,
0.26392534375190735,
0.02221360243856907,
0.05010679364204407,
0.5343886017799377,
-0.02820882759988308,
0.6744716167449951,
0.13984988629817963,
0.18203093111515045,
0.2797105312347412,
-0.5677292346954346,
-0.4472956955432892,
-0.19783495366573334,
0.7884453535079956,
0.6734800934791565,
-0.5123969316482544,
-0.2115814983844757,
-0.12208119034767151,
-0.21637745201587677,
0.3378242552280426,
-0.3361837863922119,
0.0010279311100021005,
0.27827468514442444,
-0.4189365804195404,
-0.3685450553894043,
0.00045547744957730174,
-0.7398741245269775,
-0.5610511302947998,
-0.6480607390403748,
0.05360293760895729,
-0.042885951697826385,
-0.07496251910924911,
0.42601630091667175,
-0.1272873878479004,
-0.2170175164937973,
0.8801628351211548,
-0.7629227638244629,
0.4320240914821625,
1.1514036655426025,
0.7818583846092224,
-0.2220940738916397,
-0.8975646495819092,
-0.07085874676704407,
0.5062296390533447,
-0.0950397253036499,
0.9631901383399963,
-0.18886804580688477,
-0.6029839515686035,
-0.21687838435173035,
0.07063284516334534,
0.10284403711557388,
-0.15439952909946442,
0.2881847023963928,
-0.6190207600593567,
0.3405175805091858,
-0.22792735695838928,
-0.5610312223434448,
-0.1411592662334442,
0.465304434299469,
-1.1163487434387207,
0.5982929468154907,
0.2918579876422882,
-1.1044117212295532,
0.4196116030216217,
-0.5013110041618347,
0.00828972551971674,
0.05859439820051193,
0.05491355061531067,
-0.5196561813354492,
-0.22087323665618896,
0.06819524616003036,
0.2962953448295593,
-0.5692523717880249,
0.35050854086875916,
-0.845560610294342,
-0.22658200562000275,
-0.1328561156988144,
0.17981798946857452,
0.5282763838768005,
0.050045277923345566,
0.08065565675497055,
0.40766453742980957,
-0.5926799774169922,
-0.3186154067516327,
-0.22990980744361877,
-0.08603964000940323,
-0.3955511748790741,
-0.10236287117004395,
0.17927192151546478,
-0.24531513452529907,
0.3759602904319763,
-0.6510167717933655,
0.39604121446609497,
-0.1616547852754593,
0.33292731642723083,
0.35637494921684265,
0.4111054241657257,
0.5468512177467346,
-0.6151187419891357,
0.3012150228023529,
-0.5480315685272217,
0.3230527341365814,
-0.0036676176823675632,
-0.5310018062591553,
-0.29921460151672363,
-0.2119908481836319,
0.3717856705188751,
0.1912306249141693,
-0.31316158175468445,
0.3453885316848755,
-0.28288397192955017,
-0.5019364953041077,
-0.6622795462608337,
0.25634416937828064,
0.2690645158290863,
0.41091734170913696,
0.4241413474082947,
-0.2981342673301697,
-0.7751646637916565,
-0.8350008130073547,
-0.38925349712371826,
-0.6248238682746887,
-0.21389494836330414,
-0.13917233049869537,
0.6637391448020935,
-0.38431835174560547,
1.1284140348434448,
-0.2888951301574707,
-0.7413917779922485,
-0.07539107650518417,
0.7214112281799316,
-0.10245469212532043,
0.3580474555492401,
0.12118268758058548,
-0.7035102248191833,
-0.19723892211914062,
-0.12379173934459686,
-0.8769782185554504,
-0.42575395107269287,
-0.06440673768520355,
-0.12106182426214218,
0.06557711213827133,
0.6986588835716248,
0.02389061637222767,
0.21769912540912628,
0.546019434928894,
-0.10490254312753677,
0.1654481291770935,
-0.1976238638162613,
0.38081204891204834,
-1.0682857036590576,
0.28998780250549316,
-0.08258218318223953,
-0.09094838052988052,
-0.3150549829006195,
0.05683422461152077,
-0.1246771290898323,
-0.13833093643188477,
-0.07936499267816544,
0.3203536570072174,
-0.5797641277313232,
-0.31693947315216064,
-0.06266576051712036,
0.5157476663589478,
0.3905943036079407,
0.3780876398086548,
0.20221936702728271,
0.3320801556110382,
-0.24825826287269592,
0.012775130569934845,
0.21112337708473206,
0.46397528052330017,
-0.08766618371009827,
0.6457890272140503,
-0.8030882477760315,
0.26857897639274597,
0.07409042865037918,
0.7348067760467529,
-0.4955446124076843,
-0.5596326589584351,
0.10658019781112671,
-0.4675821363925934,
-0.031988438218832016,
-0.31503817439079285,
-0.7605647444725037,
-0.0008370770374312997,
-0.5390074253082275,
0.18785950541496277,
-0.4048498272895813,
-0.2817513644695282,
0.8073832392692566,
0.6938202977180481,
-0.3257908225059509,
-0.3953828811645508,
-0.46467354893684387,
0.18065933883190155,
0.292580783367157,
-0.9162343740463257,
0.9089511036872864,
0.08314026147127151,
-0.4839378595352173,
0.3477446436882019,
0.17022347450256348,
-0.16455134749412537,
-0.056138359010219574,
0.4561917185783386,
0.43835189938545227,
0.2971155047416687,
-0.3834404945373535,
-0.2482558935880661,
-0.21917803585529327,
0.2825096547603607,
0.2463938295841217,
-0.03997112438082695,
-0.19420403242111206,
-0.42691636085510254,
-0.23694342374801636,
0.33334335684776306,
0.7999544739723206,
-0.041569750756025314,
0.13350966572761536,
0.4279557168483734,
-0.44089555740356445,
0.2235945761203766,
-0.5311093926429749,
0.06302215158939362,
-0.345308393239975,
0.16500894725322723,
-0.14714296162128448,
-0.9534064531326294,
0.5369749069213867,
0.15452010929584503,
0.5433138608932495,
0.4712284505367279,
0.5065835118293762,
-0.14639915525913239,
0.588204026222229,
0.5213314294815063,
0.03712360933423042,
0.15802229940891266,
-0.09753087162971497,
-0.060976527631282806,
-1.2777340412139893,
-0.3715323507785797,
-0.5940051078796387,
-0.16590917110443115,
-0.2673793137073517,
-0.47157201170921326,
0.4408758580684662,
0.04739323630928993,
0.016138138249516487,
0.2838238477706909,
-0.31418949365615845,
0.2395199090242386,
0.3934960961341858,
-0.08038758486509323,
0.5376075506210327,
-0.33705806732177734,
0.10031118243932724,
-0.17547164857387543,
-0.33401021361351013,
-0.7112802863121033,
1.0265768766403198,
0.3157517611980438,
0.7042422890663147,
-0.03589373454451561,
0.8503352999687195,
0.30910608172416687,
0.8302630186080933,
-0.3721919059753418,
0.5831565260887146,
0.33550477027893066,
-0.6925218105316162,
-0.25996413826942444,
-0.05783490836620331,
-0.860983669757843,
0.19747774302959442,
-0.34319132566452026,
-0.10538621246814728,
0.18962912261486053,
0.03395265340805054,
-0.22131161391735077,
0.3463682532310486,
-0.6329399347305298,
0.609284520149231,
0.18497636914253235,
-0.9222745299339294,
-0.37142708897590637,
-0.6394132971763611,
0.34281134605407715,
-0.5758135914802551,
0.29845985770225525,
0.10859912633895874,
-0.08991594612598419,
0.8461016416549683,
-0.5876032114028931,
0.976327657699585,
-0.0012386779999360442,
-0.1925516277551651,
0.2763747572898865,
0.4280546307563782,
0.3206416070461273,
0.3207809031009674,
-0.22592386603355408,
0.012650969438254833,
0.17730167508125305,
-0.14612926542758942,
-0.7709430456161499,
0.9589253664016724,
-0.7926197648048401,
-0.5819273591041565,
-0.5376022458076477,
-0.706011950969696,
-0.3274378776550293,
0.20834068953990936,
-0.055490314960479736,
0.15657328069210052,
-0.4674098789691925,
0.30549898743629456,
0.15674492716789246,
0.30089879035949707,
0.2369304895401001,
0.7192357182502747,
-0.4482739567756653,
-0.8033663034439087,
0.19232726097106934,
0.01306120678782463,
0.01570063643157482,
0.27990105748176575,
-0.12136145681142807,
-0.050037506967782974,
-0.6015986800193787,
-0.053359437733888626,
0.45778265595436096,
-0.5306122899055481,
-0.12296129018068314,
-0.6688060164451599,
0.4125218987464905,
-0.547215461730957,
-0.6184513568878174,
-0.21962161362171173,
-0.33082279562950134,
-0.3178701400756836,
0.12614181637763977,
0.1662551909685135,
1.2950687408447266,
-0.2776341736316681,
-0.006472799926996231,
-0.8849807381629944,
0.18851859867572784,
0.07978197932243347,
0.3774232864379883,
-0.10650336742401123,
-0.06243188679218292,
-0.17150172591209412,
-0.048379916697740555,
-0.43303635716438293,
-0.737091064453125,
0.29026877880096436,
-0.36593368649482727,
0.2909073829650879,
-0.33160510659217834,
0.08461564779281616,
0.5390117168426514,
-0.34953826665878296,
0.8301244974136353,
-0.03273291140794754,
-0.9001165628433228,
0.3886071443557739,
-0.5632345676422119,
0.027371956035494804,
0.7991180419921875,
0.1637006551027298,
-0.5774226188659668,
-0.26567745208740234,
-0.8308137059211731,
-0.7435697317123413,
0.5138545036315918,
0.17843110859394073,
-0.6459053158760071,
0.3726477324962616,
0.455572247505188,
0.06813108921051025,
0.11409670859575272,
-0.49951067566871643,
0.20202073454856873,
-0.2304827868938446,
-0.05374385416507721,
0.17837807536125183,
-0.04086792469024658,
-0.44529277086257935,
0.1485898345708847,
0.7633010745048523,
-0.09691263735294342,
0.1849467009305954,
0.6068742871284485,
-0.1447618305683136,
-0.2937614917755127,
0.15337041020393372,
0.41601747274398804,
0.582502007484436,
-0.7136114835739136,
0.041412342339754105,
0.08152659237384796,
-0.3983031213283539,
-0.023250311613082886,
0.017308184877038002,
0.07298935204744339,
-0.08734116703271866,
0.868987500667572,
0.20709817111492157,
0.4187602400779724,
0.05945288762450218,
0.30778080224990845,
-0.3172881007194519,
-0.629551112651825,
-0.1899484097957611,
-0.22690455615520477,
-0.06428142637014389,
-0.01611359789967537,
0.16634537279605865,
0.3015758693218231,
0.2626985013484955,
-0.1946658194065094,
0.44273442029953003,
0.05852946639060974,
-0.5491325855255127,
-0.5433854460716248,
0.5931118130683899,
0.5805698037147522,
-0.3365464210510254,
0.2090570628643036,
0.07503184676170349,
-0.28199711441993713,
0.25191399455070496,
0.2672664225101471,
0.8330584168434143,
0.20676636695861816,
0.04429854080080986,
0.20572805404663086,
0.1914951056241989,
-0.06920185685157776,
-0.05002288520336151,
0.06131112203001976,
-0.465880811214447,
-0.35195767879486084,
-0.24014778435230255,
-0.9786238670349121,
0.03841578960418701,
-0.8851999044418335,
0.36656805872917175,
-0.5461980104446411,
-0.06157481297850609,
0.21119193732738495,
0.21437343955039978,
-0.1288718283176422,
-0.06658635288476944,
-0.3608953356742859,
0.7415788173675537,
-0.689033567905426,
0.7054060101509094,
0.7019080519676208,
-0.46559807658195496,
-0.3371046483516693,
-0.10710084438323975,
0.5437244176864624,
-0.39967265725135803,
0.5528613328933716,
-0.2512023150920868,
-0.4773799777030945,
0.02938763052225113,
-0.6427015066146851,
-0.6578693389892578,
1.2492014169692993,
0.023629412055015564,
-0.5200008749961853,
0.00616426020860672,
0.008966607972979546,
0.8168227672576904,
-0.43285199999809265,
0.05095909908413887,
0.22958120703697205,
0.49075546860694885,
-0.06884030997753143,
-0.5720804929733276,
-0.1118907630443573,
-0.45224109292030334,
-0.19444569945335388,
0.1477556675672531,
-0.599800705909729,
0.5166022181510925,
-0.04380619898438454,
0.19138948619365692,
-0.09162741154432297,
0.8031914830207825,
0.41175732016563416,
0.4584638476371765,
0.5130664110183716,
0.5167843103408813,
0.48487573862075806,
0.045326221734285355,
0.9670949578285217,
-0.45172327756881714,
0.4348062574863434,
1.4660972356796265,
-0.9836031198501587,
0.8610429167747498,
0.7692384719848633,
-0.051925789564847946,
0.36545899510383606,
0.5040746927261353,
-0.11154662817716599,
0.18393921852111816,
-0.008992032147943974,
-0.21176792681217194,
0.0450693815946579,
-0.239784374833107,
-0.23197059333324432,
-0.16104573011398315,
0.3064849376678467,
-0.13696816563606262,
-0.11745582520961761,
-0.308641254901886,
0.28535524010658264,
0.19170697033405304,
-0.09122247248888016,
0.7775707244873047,
-0.10086556524038315,
-0.9392024278640747,
0.14278647303581238,
0.17283029854297638,
0.30924031138420105,
-0.26469072699546814,
-0.13809850811958313,
-0.1522471010684967,
0.13958343863487244,
-0.45451241731643677,
-1.0932954549789429,
0.672122597694397,
-0.03293970227241516,
-0.4762237071990967,
-0.5368143320083618,
0.4320157766342163,
-0.19571813941001892,
-0.09508688747882843,
0.4690064489841461,
0.2564082741737366,
-0.3126470148563385,
0.3083259165287018,
-0.7855204343795776,
0.3621583580970764,
-0.02993004396557808,
-0.18599599599838257,
0.2709888517856598,
0.3615070879459381,
-0.08981708437204361,
0.42258551716804504,
0.7511093020439148,
0.057837750762701035,
-0.2948845326900482,
0.3273690938949585,
0.7318314909934998,
-0.32785922288894653,
0.04071832075715065,
-0.3995593190193176,
0.25216832756996155,
-0.1642429381608963,
-0.31072798371315,
0.5725110769271851,
0.5741099715232849,
0.7847701907157898,
0.14325743913650513,
0.9008966088294983,
0.02341121807694435,
0.6730049252510071,
-0.3146175444126129,
0.6126595139503479,
-0.45579737424850464,
0.4346066415309906,
-0.5272859334945679,
-0.7145842909812927,
-0.8598729372024536,
0.45029038190841675,
-0.29348257184028625,
-0.2970459461212158,
0.894565224647522,
0.9198802709579468,
0.21121545135974884,
0.4513818621635437,
-0.15414607524871826,
0.10125809907913208,
0.5221732258796692,
0.18858635425567627,
0.5788882374763489,
-0.6956789493560791,
0.07844924181699753,
-0.28162312507629395,
-0.18577244877815247,
-0.18613800406455994,
-1.0011459589004517,
-0.7435473203659058,
-0.8442126512527466,
-0.4466310739517212,
-0.5078818202018738,
-0.03621827811002731,
1.0933759212493896,
0.33857104182243347,
-0.41749539971351624,
-0.3715294897556305,
-0.3856675624847412,
0.0490073636174202,
-0.08281118422746658,
-0.12704014778137207,
0.3631531596183777,
-0.06254298239946365,
-0.5570947527885437,
0.41047000885009766,
0.4141841232776642,
0.037523481994867325,
-0.4762658178806305,
0.003130542114377022,
-0.24597889184951782,
-0.16505645215511322,
0.16929024457931519,
0.048782140016555786,
-0.6492160558700562,
-0.09529007971286774,
0.10544374585151672,
-0.17040520906448364,
-0.22602376341819763,
1.161171317100525,
-0.4512172043323517,
0.4402659237384796,
0.7255849838256836,
0.5009638071060181,
0.3985007405281067,
-0.02381119877099991,
1.0136979818344116,
-0.5475723743438721,
-0.26033109426498413,
0.22737491130828857,
0.538088858127594,
0.6115941405296326,
-0.182265505194664,
0.9364897012710571,
0.46124354004859924,
-1.0349534749984741,
-0.7761262059211731,
-0.2198525369167328,
-0.9607973694801331,
-0.024468544870615005,
0.9157001972198486,
-0.3729745149612427,
-0.46062424778938293,
-0.4553307890892029,
-0.3077121078968048,
0.3572029769420624,
-0.15100501477718353,
0.7219359278678894,
0.8167732954025269,
-0.11913825571537018,
0.04071492329239845,
-0.12732677161693573,
0.4235571026802063,
0.28799334168434143,
-1.0174314975738525,
0.49155139923095703,
0.6741072535514832,
-0.00048683304339647293,
0.3222101032733917,
0.7313581705093384,
-0.2786523699760437,
0.20247721672058105,
-0.21768569946289062,
0.4231065809726715,
-0.20177796483039856,
-0.30230817198753357,
-0.28767824172973633,
0.1640329509973526,
0.030065936967730522,
0.46839654445648193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02592v1
|
LOLAMEME: Logic, Language, Memory, Mechanistic Framework
| 2024-05-31T21:18:25
| 2024-05-31T21:18:25
|
Jay Desai, Xiaobo Guo, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The performance of Large Language Models has achieved superhuman breadth with
unprecedented depth. At the same time, the language models are mostly black box
models and the underlying mechanisms for performance have been evaluated using
synthetic or mechanistic schemes. We extend current mechanistic schemes to
incorporate Logic, memory, and nuances of Language such as latent structure.
The proposed framework is called LOLAMEME and we provide two instantiations of
LOLAMEME: LoLa and MeMe languages. We then consider two generative language
model architectures: transformer-based GPT-2 and convolution-based Hyena. We
propose the hybrid architecture T HEX and use LOLAMEME framework is used to
compare three architectures. T HEX outperforms GPT-2 and Hyena on select tasks.
|
[
0.003988971468061209,
-0.8551393747329712,
0.6183249354362488,
0.395873099565506,
0.024167418479919434,
0.4123203456401825,
0.2308281809091568,
-0.4633721113204956,
0.19975295662879944,
0.3094462752342224,
-0.4924391806125641,
-0.2812952399253845,
-0.4195060431957245,
-0.1591147631406784,
-0.5118492245674133,
0.526334285736084,
0.014447527937591076,
-0.1643301099538803,
0.11893084645271301,
-0.14398124814033508,
-0.3522389233112335,
-0.45855069160461426,
-0.671097993850708,
-0.5555020570755005,
0.18738172948360443,
-0.07561927288770676,
0.8154893517494202,
0.3910500407218933,
0.10070490092039108,
0.27225714921951294,
-0.020377589389681816,
-0.2297566831111908,
-0.19070875644683838,
0.08525029569864273,
-0.8119631409645081,
-0.5875950455665588,
-0.6873722672462463,
0.004374147392809391,
0.4262543022632599,
0.4861317276954651,
0.025472698733210564,
0.05466261878609657,
-0.28181684017181396,
0.4870521128177643,
-0.7066431641578674,
-0.055900610983371735,
-0.616360604763031,
0.034388698637485504,
0.04355547949671745,
-0.2752830982208252,
-0.3233708441257477,
-0.15390920639038086,
0.18053562939167023,
-0.21489964425563812,
0.23525124788284302,
0.1258862018585205,
0.5567830801010132,
0.18291828036308289,
0.004994068294763565,
-0.46885946393013,
-1.0414484739303589,
0.8139456510543823,
-0.6861845850944519,
0.41091299057006836,
0.26175493001937866,
0.4959530532360077,
-0.029890576377511024,
-0.4911786615848541,
-0.5278008580207825,
-0.4975906312465668,
-0.07657649368047714,
0.1630852371454239,
-0.21630166471004486,
-0.1082874983549118,
0.24602733552455902,
0.5139520764350891,
-0.9759534001350403,
0.11162455379962921,
-0.6446437239646912,
-0.09372153878211975,
0.3189564049243927,
0.3990923762321472,
0.3715094327926636,
-0.21585968136787415,
-0.4009556770324707,
-0.17667046189308167,
-0.7203766107559204,
-0.24406149983406067,
0.2906501591205597,
-0.18679480254650116,
0.027681192383170128,
0.596126914024353,
-0.2050206959247589,
0.6831628680229187,
-0.20516879856586456,
-0.15033550560474396,
0.03308291360735893,
-0.46164852380752563,
-0.43333783745765686,
-0.026367072016000748,
0.9041770100593567,
0.07999442517757416,
-0.01675580069422722,
-0.6230350136756897,
-0.1388690173625946,
0.5758957862854004,
0.38353484869003296,
-1.0742160081863403,
-0.10692296922206879,
0.537236213684082,
-0.6098156571388245,
-0.1795119345188141,
0.029817230999469757,
-0.7706152200698853,
-0.00532821798697114,
-0.016817772760987282,
0.6056721806526184,
-0.5288712382316589,
-0.6297637224197388,
0.3515596091747284,
-0.2037137746810913,
0.361995130777359,
0.25438374280929565,
-1.1369658708572388,
0.5363155603408813,
0.8745923042297363,
0.7961779236793518,
0.19429276883602142,
-0.2359604835510254,
-0.4085233807563782,
0.17958787083625793,
-0.49093160033226013,
0.5499700307846069,
-0.6676931381225586,
-0.1142239049077034,
-0.25810205936431885,
0.020236369222402573,
-0.2073565125465393,
-0.8144285678863525,
0.27797070145606995,
-0.4850045442581177,
0.1745576560497284,
0.08369917422533035,
-0.6255751848220825,
-0.3275339901447296,
-0.02069590426981449,
-0.7187579870223999,
0.8232975006103516,
0.6053981184959412,
-0.25992387533187866,
0.04333633929491043,
-0.569120466709137,
-0.4223507344722748,
0.040975384414196014,
-0.356975793838501,
-0.28254392743110657,
0.2957867383956909,
-0.45773956179618835,
0.6548370122909546,
-0.5633094310760498,
0.07400000840425491,
-0.17833301424980164,
-0.37302714586257935,
0.17822904884815216,
-0.11372245848178864,
0.8337666392326355,
0.3962201774120331,
-0.5241231918334961,
0.03300099074840546,
-0.9335014224052429,
-0.08723550289869308,
-0.023841552436351776,
-0.32501569390296936,
-0.285054087638855,
0.12534089386463165,
0.13669554889202118,
0.5282421708106995,
0.2385859191417694,
-0.3785379230976105,
0.05163012072443962,
-0.36434802412986755,
0.8266440629959106,
0.375912070274353,
-0.45978766679763794,
0.7050827741622925,
-0.2286505550146103,
0.5854586362838745,
-0.23949529230594635,
-0.04109111800789833,
-0.13623318076133728,
-0.5735548138618469,
-0.4694406986236572,
-0.17688310146331787,
0.016884172335267067,
0.8807277679443359,
-0.4598846435546875,
0.41918569803237915,
0.1174684688448906,
-0.1722388118505478,
-0.5096021294593811,
0.317019522190094,
0.4926013946533203,
0.09327761828899384,
0.22282303869724274,
-0.08705589175224304,
-0.5120915770530701,
-1.081300139427185,
0.3507291376590729,
-0.24940705299377441,
-0.12764616310596466,
0.1562843918800354,
0.4849829077720642,
-0.6043212413787842,
0.6666674613952637,
-0.016388898715376854,
0.4281837046146393,
-0.23551814258098602,
0.28428182005882263,
0.1880166232585907,
0.5771564245223999,
0.9523167610168457,
-0.3857876658439636,
-0.20402231812477112,
0.13014031946659088,
-0.8547248840332031,
-0.11552388966083527,
0.16232635080814362,
-0.24743056297302246,
0.30336031317710876,
0.4616466462612152,
-0.6601772904396057,
0.4550314247608185,
0.6500996351242065,
-0.5563437938690186,
0.9049076437950134,
-0.14810247719287872,
0.16977305710315704,
-1.428452491760254,
0.004120092839002609,
-0.4034669101238251,
-0.3190542757511139,
-0.417022705078125,
0.056024521589279175,
0.11814893037080765,
-0.08384682238101959,
-0.31090426445007324,
0.9552063345909119,
-0.39217400550842285,
-0.44853487610816956,
-0.629108726978302,
-0.19642464816570282,
0.18572211265563965,
0.26533499360084534,
-0.004865473601967096,
0.9535276293754578,
0.49843254685401917,
-0.7326614856719971,
0.7358695864677429,
-0.06354865431785583,
-0.48503124713897705,
0.46308809518814087,
-0.84452885389328,
-0.03345206007361412,
0.16136270761489868,
-0.10881522297859192,
-0.6797912120819092,
0.061200812458992004,
0.2433234304189682,
-0.35960662364959717,
0.3983302116394043,
0.07850141078233719,
-0.6866082549095154,
-0.427049845457077,
-0.28032436966896057,
0.5207432508468628,
0.6983895897865295,
-0.38567861914634705,
0.5487857460975647,
-0.10236185044050217,
0.052457381039857864,
-0.4290411174297333,
-0.4377361238002777,
0.16349834203720093,
-0.2206345796585083,
-0.8817043304443359,
0.4903244078159332,
-0.15040448307991028,
-0.5616833567619324,
0.38647958636283875,
-0.07280761003494263,
0.0806911289691925,
0.24798095226287842,
-0.05234115570783615,
0.09673751145601273,
-0.6623064875602722,
-0.018780702725052834,
-0.11854688823223114,
-0.30305296182632446,
-0.15362784266471863,
-0.6283444762229919,
0.7766971588134766,
-0.3465763330459595,
-0.025331446900963783,
-0.2645227611064911,
0.536217987537384,
0.7856221199035645,
-0.1922444999217987,
0.9325608611106873,
0.6358380913734436,
-0.42095947265625,
-0.30754730105400085,
-0.4214905798435211,
-0.35388943552970886,
-0.3927248418331146,
0.613630473613739,
-0.6817288994789124,
-1.0186043977737427,
0.6686198115348816,
-0.028268640860915184,
-0.17952464520931244,
0.1782437264919281,
0.9340234398841858,
-0.2101689726114273,
0.5065363049507141,
0.6519256830215454,
-0.21676142513751984,
0.5367160439491272,
-0.38376548886299133,
0.3670203983783722,
-0.8387473225593567,
0.03056558035314083,
-0.5831013321876526,
-0.1091260090470314,
-0.6364580988883972,
-0.6543845534324646,
-0.017150530591607094,
0.451220840215683,
-0.055192653089761734,
0.7710689902305603,
-0.11843057721853256,
0.229013130068779,
0.5543777346611023,
-0.06756637245416641,
0.17222760617733002,
0.08063755929470062,
-0.20598821341991425,
0.3861740231513977,
-0.6692047715187073,
-0.8984558582305908,
1.0780638456344604,
0.3670561611652374,
1.0065540075302124,
0.3942372500896454,
0.18213769793510437,
0.18567857146263123,
-0.05222072824835777,
-0.6517819762229919,
0.4976835250854492,
-0.324036568403244,
-0.8210632801055908,
-0.12726405262947083,
-0.28121477365493774,
-0.8977904915809631,
0.16643758118152618,
-0.20912104845046997,
-1.017279863357544,
0.06802678108215332,
0.0172951091080904,
-0.4251229763031006,
0.20039647817611694,
-0.6806077361106873,
0.9839639663696289,
-0.307294636964798,
-0.9130696058273315,
-0.7115551233291626,
-0.23106922209262848,
0.3877140283584595,
0.1875178962945938,
-0.19686974585056305,
-0.20763635635375977,
0.13198888301849365,
0.5245457887649536,
-0.49146828055381775,
0.43542274832725525,
0.38419482111930847,
-0.06458978354930878,
0.3284963369369507,
0.381120502948761,
0.29657843708992004,
0.017074042931199074,
-0.12754550576210022,
-0.13272830843925476,
-0.015459687449038029,
-0.7105776071548462,
-0.9533265829086304,
0.5726187825202942,
-0.5586305856704712,
-0.4858669936656952,
-0.15658701956272125,
-0.43024373054504395,
-0.08777470141649246,
-0.1174425557255745,
0.1027311161160469,
0.6911121606826782,
-0.30393755435943604,
0.19380930066108704,
0.7549027800559998,
-0.4808426797389984,
0.5261479020118713,
0.5693781971931458,
-0.20041222870349884,
-0.2612238824367523,
0.9607539772987366,
-0.2329104095697403,
0.465160608291626,
0.798326849937439,
0.1427917331457138,
-0.33092182874679565,
-0.44230347871780396,
-0.6036518216133118,
0.38652992248535156,
-0.299328476190567,
0.30094489455223083,
-0.6537525057792664,
-0.3338242173194885,
-0.3275775909423828,
-0.17821982502937317,
-0.5540010929107666,
-0.7076983451843262,
0.14022040367126465,
-0.19719792902469635,
0.19541439414024353,
0.7939727306365967,
0.057339854538440704,
0.41055360436439514,
-0.5357033610343933,
0.25011131167411804,
0.5700397491455078,
0.2900408208370209,
0.0282587893307209,
-0.31761035323143005,
-0.28103724122047424,
-0.32612118124961853,
-0.3074409067630768,
-0.9269116520881653,
0.1386193186044693,
-0.08925755321979523,
0.6774513125419617,
0.5656217932701111,
-0.6104768514633179,
0.10868710279464722,
-0.5070784091949463,
0.2302517145872116,
0.06342759728431702,
-0.615851879119873,
0.5436996817588806,
-0.42715466022491455,
-0.10011088103055954,
0.08091729879379272,
0.070779949426651,
-0.2892041802406311,
-0.2267819195985794,
-0.7849121689796448,
-0.48057445883750916,
0.5569309592247009,
0.49066001176834106,
-0.004208851605653763,
0.3158348798751831,
0.5179787278175354,
0.23467329144477844,
0.4802238643169403,
-0.5485183000564575,
-0.03415745496749878,
-0.1951170414686203,
-0.19231566786766052,
-0.29093655943870544,
-0.6220840811729431,
0.11068010330200195,
-0.12493117898702621,
0.5369703769683838,
0.14624103903770447,
0.4289783537387848,
-0.30066174268722534,
-0.18795515596866608,
0.06882297247648239,
0.4723508358001709,
0.8271127939224243,
0.8773028254508972,
-0.5850808024406433,
0.1809457391500473,
-0.5351529717445374,
-0.2527269423007965,
0.41565996408462524,
-0.09849550575017929,
-0.4166852831840515,
-0.1352684646844864,
0.4350743889808655,
0.9845569133758545,
0.17534251511096954,
-0.698976993560791,
-0.036369115114212036,
0.19677114486694336,
-0.18220330774784088,
0.13024108111858368,
0.44486480951309204,
0.4472293257713318,
0.5288388729095459,
-0.0787278562784195,
-0.11258693039417267,
0.26942163705825806,
-1.1938921213150024,
0.1896882802248001,
0.5853592157363892,
0.17989802360534668,
-0.6459357738494873,
0.6717281937599182,
0.11319328844547272,
-0.40616708993911743,
0.28408852219581604,
-0.5506880283355713,
-0.5051797032356262,
0.662522554397583,
0.7410394549369812,
1.0640214681625366,
-0.5261533260345459,
0.35435250401496887,
0.5812589526176453,
0.5777202844619751,
-0.16076484322547913,
0.19171077013015747,
-0.2145545780658722,
-0.8894369006156921,
-0.32022711634635925,
-0.9891049861907959,
-0.3005973994731903,
0.5924520492553711,
-0.2611684501171112,
-0.0295102521777153,
-0.6889185905456543,
0.16936226189136505,
0.0033660379704087973,
0.08412279188632965,
-0.3183160722255707,
0.1359686702489853,
-0.02286297269165516,
0.6968622207641602,
-0.8948361873626709,
0.8276758193969727,
0.9617525935173035,
-0.40595903992652893,
-0.422463059425354,
-0.21809284389019012,
-0.24170227348804474,
-0.5958971977233887,
0.4061874449253082,
0.10974431037902832,
-0.23786991834640503,
-0.29494568705558777,
-0.25552883744239807,
-0.6492012143135071,
1.1685404777526855,
0.35331210494041443,
-0.5116424560546875,
0.12069900333881378,
-0.009106938727200031,
0.4532463848590851,
-0.5207149982452393,
0.34365537762641907,
0.7767353653907776,
0.19003988802433014,
0.3914238512516022,
-0.9073348641395569,
-0.04077453166246414,
-0.3480139672756195,
0.2138262838125229,
0.014595421962440014,
-0.6861714124679565,
1.1045453548431396,
-0.08778446912765503,
-0.08844874054193497,
0.24002309143543243,
0.46704962849617004,
0.4526948034763336,
0.27716660499572754,
-0.05920010805130005,
0.762083888053894,
0.6859427690505981,
0.05620327219367027,
0.850831925868988,
-0.15382470190525055,
0.13035182654857635,
1.0129491090774536,
-0.24677066504955292,
0.6985436677932739,
-0.027233922854065895,
-0.5703355073928833,
0.4699115753173828,
0.6834471225738525,
0.2461223304271698,
0.5088279843330383,
0.11745508760213852,
-0.46658557653427124,
-0.09538192301988602,
0.4077874720096588,
-0.3016830086708069,
0.38189229369163513,
0.7005056142807007,
-0.2636584937572479,
-0.367728054523468,
-0.09597015380859375,
0.13948103785514832,
-0.013366024941205978,
-0.282722145318985,
0.5052695274353027,
0.2524699866771698,
-0.5042352676391602,
0.6386830806732178,
0.4000481367111206,
0.653399646282196,
-0.34907957911491394,
0.0802905336022377,
-0.23419040441513062,
0.40159812569618225,
-0.05193725973367691,
-0.3601532280445099,
0.5456675291061401,
-0.29990413784980774,
-0.6863060593605042,
0.07855265587568283,
0.6835446357727051,
-0.4003487825393677,
-0.6039223670959473,
0.7929885387420654,
0.706613302230835,
0.2163190096616745,
-0.14306366443634033,
-0.8491776585578918,
0.02467995323240757,
-0.3792475461959839,
0.035072583705186844,
0.17405834794044495,
0.4802326560020447,
-0.2616601288318634,
0.6831557750701904,
0.33006829023361206,
-0.009490711614489555,
0.4664090871810913,
0.11716362088918686,
0.5218005180358887,
-0.7447383999824524,
-0.4470157027244568,
-1.0131936073303223,
-0.013854281045496464,
0.19572900235652924,
0.2861194610595703,
0.5289404392242432,
0.61066734790802,
0.559777021408081,
-0.173658087849617,
0.7946297526359558,
-0.19777162373065948,
0.2997192144393921,
-0.7828172445297241,
0.4924176335334778,
-0.6245294809341431,
0.13815847039222717,
-0.33011874556541443,
-1.1151533126831055,
0.30174720287323,
0.9399600625038147,
-0.21576519310474396,
0.19299167394638062,
0.9698773622512817,
1.1389771699905396,
-0.25032341480255127,
-0.12233118712902069,
0.6034370064735413,
0.44918739795684814,
0.2858055531978607,
0.9815100431442261,
0.989448070526123,
-0.5289632678031921,
-0.06473742425441742,
-0.01564512588083744,
-0.5971212387084961,
-0.417705774307251,
-0.7519541382789612,
-1.12444007396698,
-0.5594791173934937,
-0.15389835834503174,
-0.585665225982666,
0.11392088979482651,
0.6592154502868652,
0.8659859895706177,
-0.9249021410942078,
-0.5795716643333435,
-0.24116387963294983,
0.14278073608875275,
-0.16083276271820068,
-0.21047942340373993,
0.30296286940574646,
-0.3517681062221527,
-0.6932843327522278,
0.5159935355186462,
0.8492539525032043,
0.14058305323123932,
-0.4640134871006012,
-0.3386893570423126,
-0.09537773579359055,
0.19318720698356628,
0.9178120493888855,
0.38815319538116455,
-0.7011985778808594,
0.29635515809059143,
0.09541785717010498,
-0.14005082845687866,
-0.05022452399134636,
0.931982696056366,
-0.7133374214172363,
0.2640266716480255,
0.5119380354881287,
0.6289548277854919,
0.4518358111381531,
-0.07758599519729614,
0.7030271887779236,
-0.10991861671209335,
0.5579684972763062,
0.04151540994644165,
0.38064971566200256,
0.17282596230506897,
-0.12001503258943558,
0.4965865910053253,
0.49035370349884033,
-0.21431629359722137,
-0.3670947551727295,
0.29353243112564087,
-0.9101157784461975,
-0.5515437722206116,
1.1409398317337036,
0.24993020296096802,
-0.5343015193939209,
-0.22981169819831848,
0.07508166879415512,
-0.15710382163524628,
-0.188251331448555,
0.711219310760498,
0.8877158164978027,
-0.036040809005498886,
-0.36472979187965393,
-1.045778751373291,
0.4474140703678131,
0.5046970844268799,
-0.6940177083015442,
-0.34859564900398254,
0.41674917936325073,
0.44842979311943054,
0.3672093451023102,
0.9669457674026489,
-0.19329482316970825,
0.5306869149208069,
0.12004376202821732,
0.07493142783641815,
0.1663701981306076,
-0.5975088477134705,
0.150019109249115,
0.13217902183532715,
-0.18593166768550873,
-0.1933901607990265
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04368v1
|
SocialNLP Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge Overview: Predicting Fake Tweets from Their Replies and GIFs
| 2024-05-31T21:14:11
| 2024-05-31T21:14:11
|
Chien-Kun Huang, Yi-Ting Chang, Lun-Wei Ku, Cheng-Te Li, Hong-Han Shuai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper provides an overview of the Fake-EmoReact 2021 Challenge, held at
the 9th SocialNLP Workshop, in conjunction with NAACL 2021. The challenge
requires predicting the authenticity of tweets using reply context and
augmented GIF categories from EmotionGIF dataset. We offer the Fake-EmoReact
dataset with more than 453k as the experimental materials, where every tweet is
labeled with authenticity. Twenty-four teams registered to participate in this
challenge, and 5 submitted their results successfully in the evaluation phase.
The best team achieves 93.9 on Fake-EmoReact 2021 dataset using F1 score. In
addition, we show the definition of share task, data collection, and the teams'
performance that joined this challenge and their approaches.
|
[
-0.2665579319000244,
-1.1057097911834717,
0.5379214286804199,
0.38510870933532715,
0.061965130269527435,
0.7848853468894958,
0.17988060414791107,
-0.8618656396865845,
0.8665381073951721,
0.263584703207016,
-0.8557853102684021,
-0.2693277895450592,
-0.7341245412826538,
0.11997455358505249,
-0.6428741812705994,
0.8539448380470276,
-0.1424187570810318,
-0.3363421559333801,
-0.1076510027050972,
-0.3551236093044281,
-0.19161510467529297,
-0.21581394970417023,
-0.5848314166069031,
-0.04102867841720581,
0.4384385049343109,
0.3195849359035492,
0.2986527383327484,
0.2501894235610962,
0.339773952960968,
0.24332904815673828,
0.12034069746732712,
0.0879986360669136,
-0.5400950908660889,
0.0891374796628952,
-0.15555182099342346,
0.13315200805664062,
-0.6387902498245239,
0.0656120702624321,
0.2026476413011551,
0.2318061739206314,
-0.17286308109760284,
0.4604009985923767,
-0.19489102065563202,
0.6682350635528564,
-0.5393946766853333,
0.18594057857990265,
-0.7112946510314941,
0.18437299132347107,
0.07013548165559769,
-0.2926216423511505,
-0.2692123055458069,
-0.6076776385307312,
0.1351483017206192,
-0.6112077832221985,
0.25594088435173035,
0.28063854575157166,
1.0144706964492798,
-0.053529951721429825,
-0.15203958749771118,
-0.31437942385673523,
-0.43096238374710083,
0.3610730469226837,
-0.5417353510856628,
-0.17819678783416748,
0.3789680004119873,
0.5745828747749329,
0.11500352621078491,
-0.41392621397972107,
-0.498490571975708,
0.1562228798866272,
0.18436357378959656,
0.31809741258621216,
-0.13869568705558777,
-0.13751454651355743,
0.23977068066596985,
0.3122163712978363,
-0.9170584678649902,
-0.3313823342323303,
-0.26823899149894714,
-0.2539013922214508,
0.9975013732910156,
-0.06541487574577332,
0.5458942651748657,
0.06372237205505371,
-0.4100574851036072,
-0.013397211208939552,
-0.461402028799057,
-0.4737474322319031,
0.21145062148571014,
-0.03477570787072182,
-0.37033429741859436,
0.7701565027236938,
-0.5505704283714294,
0.11333544552326202,
0.3167404234409332,
0.37154504656791687,
0.5110486745834351,
-0.32858744263648987,
-0.4285990297794342,
0.08374471217393875,
0.5591018795967102,
0.3989110291004181,
0.48901835083961487,
-0.21427033841609955,
-0.30896154046058655,
0.09556491672992706,
-0.050641924142837524,
-0.5198705792427063,
0.07599294185638428,
0.4085615873336792,
-0.14152581989765167,
-0.5943244099617004,
0.18919044733047485,
-0.7842000722885132,
-0.3672146499156952,
-0.24183319509029388,
0.7231115102767944,
-0.3396093547344208,
-0.45667561888694763,
-0.21084032952785492,
-0.2162984162569046,
0.23217228055000305,
0.8719732761383057,
-0.42065247893333435,
0.3663059175014496,
0.71303391456604,
0.9015634655952454,
0.1231769472360611,
-0.17943812906742096,
-0.4765012860298157,
0.17233189940452576,
-0.3058432340621948,
0.685111939907074,
-0.3843815326690674,
0.05570109933614731,
0.3024691641330719,
0.14704719185829163,
-0.0840313509106636,
-0.15346117317676544,
0.3072412312030792,
-0.6115624904632568,
-0.09842582046985626,
-0.5711573958396912,
-0.7328387498855591,
0.053731437772512436,
0.547427773475647,
-0.7565930485725403,
0.7873649001121521,
0.15141604840755463,
-0.7979820370674133,
0.49253255128860474,
-0.9904013872146606,
-0.26377156376838684,
0.2998380661010742,
0.2870402932167053,
0.016138039529323578,
0.1235845610499382,
0.1576557457447052,
0.5608715415000916,
0.25446146726608276,
0.22194840013980865,
-0.7165371179580688,
-0.2676618695259094,
0.11888087540864944,
-0.29637208580970764,
0.7649544477462769,
0.0823926255106926,
-0.3123229146003723,
0.05353225767612457,
-0.5776010751724243,
-0.04435428977012634,
0.36839428544044495,
0.25106436014175415,
0.010013694874942303,
-0.45103919506073,
0.14103852212429047,
0.3394971191883087,
0.13764825463294983,
-0.9203823208808899,
0.16425184905529022,
-0.2666548788547516,
0.30260178446769714,
0.7576264142990112,
0.30941495299339294,
0.5307141542434692,
-0.4708928167819977,
0.5758984088897705,
-0.22566667199134827,
0.5523983836174011,
-0.03419705107808113,
-0.7889463305473328,
-0.4798007905483246,
0.3602046072483063,
0.21931780874729156,
0.5609313249588013,
-1.0252938270568848,
0.11788749694824219,
-0.3117977976799011,
-0.701713502407074,
-0.41259652376174927,
-0.17206692695617676,
0.1743897944688797,
0.20811250805854797,
0.263886958360672,
0.08728138357400894,
-0.5450276732444763,
-0.6123887300491333,
-0.35354307293891907,
-0.19139666855335236,
0.1277870237827301,
0.12554888427257538,
0.932182252407074,
0.07668351382017136,
0.5816923379898071,
-0.1601228564977646,
-0.3319537937641144,
-0.0479787215590477,
0.4738689959049225,
-0.05734811723232269,
0.4870505630970001,
0.6415371298789978,
-0.9143906235694885,
-0.8259297013282776,
0.0018399007385596633,
-0.712512731552124,
-0.002448754385113716,
0.0635175034403801,
0.07504823058843613,
0.6747491955757141,
0.39767560362815857,
-0.39359015226364136,
0.8633760213851929,
0.9265448451042175,
-0.38848528265953064,
0.42890071868896484,
0.14054948091506958,
0.5884028077125549,
-0.8104997873306274,
-0.01767994463443756,
0.1434450000524521,
-0.5194149613380432,
-0.4682045876979828,
0.07715970277786255,
0.00921681895852089,
-0.1358596682548523,
-0.6547151803970337,
0.7754395604133606,
-0.5140247344970703,
-0.10249003022909164,
0.07406427711248398,
-0.0037980072665959597,
-0.19778947532176971,
0.4026857018470764,
-0.1916327327489853,
0.22356270253658295,
0.3002585470676422,
0.017819304019212723,
0.4187328815460205,
-0.11075267940759659,
-0.29408252239227295,
0.4424076974391937,
-0.7559254765510559,
0.5998246669769287,
-0.00243768491782248,
0.32522568106651306,
-1.1192166805267334,
-0.9721938371658325,
0.3947511315345764,
-1.0308306217193604,
0.2674546241760254,
-0.278736412525177,
-0.9375394582748413,
-0.3456554412841797,
-0.36608025431632996,
0.20357990264892578,
0.5028958916664124,
-0.36864471435546875,
0.8297563791275024,
0.4350854754447937,
0.2959783673286438,
-0.39331912994384766,
-0.8219165205955505,
0.2458299696445465,
-0.1642596274614334,
-0.8636892437934875,
0.5105141997337341,
-0.13946177065372467,
-0.12380032241344452,
0.13891123235225677,
0.09765356779098511,
-0.1437009871006012,
0.0497891791164875,
0.5156193971633911,
-0.08066488057374954,
0.21928489208221436,
-0.2182939201593399,
-0.09757127612829208,
0.37098291516304016,
0.07198628038167953,
0.35876530408859253,
0.5366733074188232,
-0.32914596796035767,
-0.4585363566875458,
-0.459515780210495,
0.3075692355632782,
0.3045147657394409,
0.33596840500831604,
0.9923717379570007,
0.855705738067627,
-0.8734471797943115,
-0.15775978565216064,
-0.6855760216712952,
-0.23779520392417908,
-0.5076743960380554,
-0.11448854207992554,
-0.10964588820934296,
-0.7976732850074768,
0.8655673265457153,
0.23198974132537842,
0.16272440552711487,
0.473160982131958,
0.37489867210388184,
-0.1273137331008911,
1.0088837146759033,
0.49713611602783203,
0.15159004926681519,
0.26513323187828064,
-0.10973399877548218,
-0.10951434075832367,
-0.2961943447589874,
-0.4950207471847534,
-0.16625556349754333,
-0.1667805016040802,
-0.5662124156951904,
-0.32258281111717224,
-0.008651038631796837,
-0.16104629635810852,
-0.13502290844917297,
0.4819584786891937,
-0.3148858845233917,
0.5676770210266113,
0.2901320159435272,
0.33797386288642883,
-0.01355581171810627,
0.0470593087375164,
0.259618878364563,
-0.0275291558355093,
-0.4429383873939514,
-0.36901021003723145,
0.9315611124038696,
0.3548016846179962,
0.270191490650177,
0.22882413864135742,
0.81003338098526,
0.7912350296974182,
0.7922700643539429,
-0.5813072919845581,
0.717204213142395,
0.3240965008735657,
-0.8246269226074219,
-0.22950807213783264,
-0.2358793169260025,
-0.4766102731227875,
-0.5961508750915527,
-0.10314029455184937,
-0.9346355199813843,
-0.15561716258525848,
0.248593270778656,
-0.052674390375614166,
0.2404903918504715,
-0.7501686811447144,
0.5460056066513062,
0.03545147553086281,
-0.4474585950374603,
-0.08145571500062943,
-0.7863534092903137,
0.45680123567581177,
-0.0736323893070221,
0.39858561754226685,
-0.37703999876976013,
0.1801803857088089,
0.7326455116271973,
-0.31424498558044434,
0.8723220825195312,
-0.29778438806533813,
0.3016146719455719,
0.3203843832015991,
0.3702460527420044,
0.41886311769485474,
0.23033995926380157,
-0.1784462034702301,
0.05305228382349014,
0.0747593343257904,
-0.6667655110359192,
-0.6068870425224304,
0.6906254291534424,
-0.478575736284256,
-0.4905529022216797,
-0.5997409224510193,
-0.09449417889118195,
-0.35234782099723816,
-0.009950784966349602,
0.3017691373825073,
0.3176919221878052,
-0.5930257439613342,
0.1754036843776703,
0.31654632091522217,
-0.07832175493240356,
0.7862317562103271,
0.07803487032651901,
-0.33452290296554565,
-0.6812086701393127,
0.700910210609436,
0.3064558804035187,
0.5304041504859924,
0.3169891834259033,
0.09195836633443832,
-0.47237831354141235,
-0.12811847031116486,
-0.46582603454589844,
0.06483320891857147,
-0.6830452680587769,
-0.20322073996067047,
-0.5081713199615479,
-0.29482927918434143,
-0.7560831308364868,
-0.26754674315452576,
-0.5175270438194275,
-0.48283377289772034,
-0.2683938443660736,
-0.13533835113048553,
0.4706852436065674,
1.0001119375228882,
-0.4176884591579437,
0.016716916114091873,
-0.5654457211494446,
0.045616477727890015,
0.016895459964871407,
0.18862667679786682,
0.08881166577339172,
-0.6336066126823425,
-0.1369098722934723,
0.4122176468372345,
-0.3327140808105469,
-1.0580549240112305,
0.6297355890274048,
0.2010340839624405,
0.4223611354827881,
0.6332982778549194,
0.34300893545150757,
0.6135212779045105,
-0.28635063767433167,
0.8184559941291809,
0.22463500499725342,
-1.0989980697631836,
0.8350577354431152,
-0.8042634129524231,
-0.17336304485797882,
0.4157838821411133,
0.4692307412624359,
-0.39195770025253296,
-0.3294546604156494,
-1.1463165283203125,
-0.662143886089325,
0.27328404784202576,
0.6327230930328369,
0.14971305429935455,
0.0770055502653122,
0.33977189660072327,
-0.2526067793369293,
0.23486752808094025,
-0.7063646912574768,
-0.2242112010717392,
-0.2589322030544281,
-0.19632433354854584,
0.32470765709877014,
-0.23801195621490479,
-0.2509734630584717,
-0.24054181575775146,
0.3079887628555298,
-0.12814311683177948,
0.4305863082408905,
0.3779170513153076,
-0.09696482867002487,
-0.2910158634185791,
-0.23927496373653412,
0.8433340191841125,
0.8058626055717468,
-0.6424391865730286,
-0.18570996820926666,
0.2920278012752533,
-0.2457685023546219,
-0.04381414130330086,
-0.3179534375667572,
-0.007436037063598633,
0.18614964187145233,
0.4886244535446167,
0.495557963848114,
0.05611109361052513,
-0.40512457489967346,
0.5897303223609924,
-0.04088369011878967,
-0.5844717025756836,
-0.797858715057373,
-0.09407558292150497,
0.15052290260791779,
0.11370023339986801,
0.7462113499641418,
0.25354957580566406,
0.12369184195995331,
-0.7255421280860901,
0.2849090099334717,
0.05724198743700981,
-0.5872096419334412,
-0.9908862113952637,
0.6319224834442139,
0.03086957521736622,
-0.4467410743236542,
0.09201426804065704,
-0.4172297716140747,
-0.8372957110404968,
0.9690650701522827,
0.30428487062454224,
0.8955353498458862,
-0.28315192461013794,
0.6071946024894714,
0.5125729441642761,
0.4166644215583801,
-0.26532116532325745,
0.3344254493713379,
0.24580736458301544,
-0.8208950757980347,
-0.402559369802475,
-0.38724657893180847,
-0.6922930479049683,
0.17328953742980957,
-0.7367763519287109,
0.30973154306411743,
-0.7831092476844788,
-0.044685717672109604,
0.1123930960893631,
0.07239256799221039,
-0.7859825491905212,
0.38815659284591675,
0.13727451860904694,
0.9030008912086487,
-1.188751459121704,
0.6312301754951477,
0.6444250345230103,
-0.3608189821243286,
-0.6121846437454224,
-0.05630100890994072,
0.5072062015533447,
-0.8372597694396973,
0.5689492225646973,
0.3065646290779114,
0.19407807290554047,
-0.10314474999904633,
-1.1231266260147095,
-0.7437184453010559,
0.8229866027832031,
0.22340592741966248,
-0.25288453698158264,
0.020388981327414513,
0.04443230479955673,
0.5517223477363586,
-0.46686944365501404,
0.33482626080513,
0.08558999747037888,
0.5445078015327454,
0.4794338047504425,
-0.8093191981315613,
0.16745762526988983,
-0.5270711779594421,
-0.3689891993999481,
-0.4406309425830841,
-0.8120627403259277,
0.4209819436073303,
-0.2383384257555008,
-0.46876728534698486,
0.0533621571958065,
0.6665263772010803,
0.573681652545929,
0.88559490442276,
0.5885851383209229,
0.435499370098114,
0.2960662543773651,
-0.351237416267395,
1.0443419218063354,
0.07799901068210602,
0.5949410796165466,
1.1051615476608276,
-0.3715294599533081,
0.9602099061012268,
0.5966950058937073,
0.06908945739269257,
0.19177475571632385,
0.9330757260322571,
-0.1305786669254303,
0.43158555030822754,
0.09501343965530396,
-0.11946282535791397,
-0.16338199377059937,
-0.3760667145252228,
-0.2633645534515381,
0.29701632261276245,
0.43539556860923767,
0.014646237716078758,
-0.0355377271771431,
-0.10734858363866806,
0.1076594740152359,
-0.10897006839513779,
-0.13946424424648285,
0.6478034853935242,
0.0145724443718791,
-0.4318293333053589,
0.054110847413539886,
-0.36133235692977905,
0.6412525177001953,
0.007829437963664532,
-0.26759713888168335,
-0.3229958713054657,
-0.08279711753129959,
-0.26068854331970215,
-0.920678436756134,
0.7427114248275757,
-0.26815125346183777,
0.08991451561450958,
-0.44226697087287903,
0.8196027278900146,
-0.24605311453342438,
-0.4186725616455078,
0.4337608814239502,
0.35807302594184875,
0.03904881328344345,
-0.39377856254577637,
-0.9650707244873047,
0.04263952374458313,
-0.13792215287685394,
-0.5821566581726074,
0.30290287733078003,
0.6438111662864685,
0.26469001173973083,
0.6949205994606018,
0.6329032778739929,
0.008180809207260609,
0.20943710207939148,
-0.025881819427013397,
0.6053151488304138,
-0.4364847242832184,
-0.20047976076602936,
-0.8510977029800415,
0.39746615290641785,
-0.5287949442863464,
-0.23792561888694763,
0.7508928775787354,
0.4338691830635071,
0.6760834455490112,
-0.22514821588993073,
0.6502054929733276,
-0.26362988352775574,
0.7332538366317749,
-0.3838590979576111,
0.9505847692489624,
-0.9744121432304382,
-0.05351698026061058,
-0.7335934042930603,
-0.5784204602241516,
-0.19152149558067322,
0.2080410271883011,
-0.0022851929534226656,
0.11917071044445038,
0.4553678631782532,
0.7504284977912903,
-0.008012578822672367,
0.24926169216632843,
0.36745673418045044,
0.011774633079767227,
0.2544838488101959,
0.5621446371078491,
1.0113437175750732,
-0.7878515124320984,
0.30228033661842346,
-0.6158615350723267,
0.034774333238601685,
-0.5343353152275085,
-1.0587871074676514,
-0.8963491320610046,
-0.6956714987754822,
-0.6551662683486938,
-0.8321287631988525,
0.06335029751062393,
0.8715241551399231,
0.6250797510147095,
-0.9838531613349915,
0.21624164283275604,
-0.302569180727005,
0.07572408765554428,
0.03780514374375343,
-0.36036649346351624,
0.3714126646518707,
0.22204896807670593,
-0.7665327191352844,
0.11600334942340851,
0.27517545223236084,
0.4144274592399597,
0.13932417333126068,
0.03704486042261124,
-0.4442824125289917,
0.2311011254787445,
0.5939898490905762,
0.4277302622795105,
-0.5928634405136108,
-0.7122851610183716,
0.3661420941352844,
0.13183508813381195,
-0.24670372903347015,
0.315332293510437,
-0.31144586205482483,
0.09574445337057114,
0.6457306146621704,
0.39593833684921265,
0.6055290102958679,
0.2220396101474762,
0.6069393754005432,
-0.7877407670021057,
-0.005941648036241531,
0.23988012969493866,
0.3595314919948578,
0.3085879981517792,
-0.3137829005718231,
0.8745580911636353,
0.5665799379348755,
-0.43187063932418823,
-1.1187514066696167,
-0.2749207615852356,
-1.2630622386932373,
-0.03456190973520279,
1.2804986238479614,
-0.2516523003578186,
-0.4489268362522125,
-0.2715584337711334,
0.27479416131973267,
0.3021925389766693,
-0.6223661303520203,
0.7053748369216919,
0.7667431831359863,
0.15345188975334167,
-0.34746384620666504,
-0.7899542450904846,
0.5847936272621155,
0.17723900079727173,
-0.9375278353691101,
-0.40816494822502136,
0.15164627134799957,
0.43166694045066833,
0.19988954067230225,
0.6460029482841492,
-0.016885722056031227,
0.30396854877471924,
-0.04735841974616051,
-0.09461215138435364,
-0.004423724487423897,
-0.32265162467956543,
0.17027366161346436,
0.38595086336135864,
-0.5994828343391418,
-0.04736042022705078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00179v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00179v1
|
Long-Span Question-Answering: Automatic Question Generation and QA-System Ranking via Side-by-Side Evaluation
| 2024-05-31T20:15:10
| 2024-05-31T20:15:10
|
Bernd Bohnet, Kevin Swersky, Rosanne Liu, Pranjal Awasthi, Azade Nova, Javier Snaider, Hanie Sedghi, Aaron T Parisi, Michael Collins, Angeliki Lazaridou, Orhan Firat, Noah Fiedel
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We explore the use of long-context capabilities in large language models to
create synthetic reading comprehension data from entire books. Previous efforts
to construct such datasets relied on crowd-sourcing, but the emergence of
transformers with a context size of 1 million or more tokens now enables
entirely automatic approaches. Our objective is to test the capabilities of
LLMs to analyze, understand, and reason over problems that require a detailed
comprehension of long spans of text, such as questions involving character
arcs, broader themes, or the consequences of early actions later in the story.
We propose a holistic pipeline for automatic data generation including question
generation, answering, and model scoring using an ``Evaluator''. We find that a
relative approach, comparing answers between models in a pairwise fashion and
ranking with a Bradley-Terry model, provides a more consistent and
differentiating scoring mechanism than an absolute scorer that rates answers
individually. We also show that LLMs from different model families produce
moderate agreement in their ratings. We ground our approach using the manually
curated NarrativeQA dataset, where our evaluator shows excellent agreement with
human judgement and even finds errors in the dataset. Using our automatic
evaluation approach, we show that using an entire book as context produces
superior reading comprehension performance compared to baseline no-context
(parametric knowledge only) and retrieval-based approaches.
|
[
-0.5719024538993835,
-0.7875859141349792,
0.7638508677482605,
0.14064542949199677,
-0.19327154755592346,
0.05651097744703293,
0.03777148202061653,
-0.5272822380065918,
-0.020721789449453354,
0.7586001753807068,
-0.48630058765411377,
-0.2944819927215576,
-0.23360754549503326,
0.45321428775787354,
-0.678443431854248,
0.9191045761108398,
-0.16334669291973114,
-0.13817498087882996,
-0.7289490103721619,
-0.17018087208271027,
-0.2731226682662964,
-0.45137450098991394,
-0.5696210861206055,
-0.324547678232193,
0.6281431913375854,
0.22186312079429626,
0.8124387860298157,
0.6985678672790527,
0.2773361802101135,
0.25296804308891296,
0.0952892079949379,
0.14401781558990479,
-0.3256855607032776,
0.38361117243766785,
-0.14938674867153168,
-0.36110398173332214,
-0.3789837956428528,
-0.1763531118631363,
0.6945712566375732,
0.5363068580627441,
0.1954740732908249,
0.37838467955589294,
0.032051797956228256,
0.920525848865509,
-0.3744249939918518,
-0.12035735696554184,
-0.2659170627593994,
0.016953958198428154,
0.04582500830292702,
-0.30223408341407776,
-0.4894576072692871,
-0.5383597612380981,
0.3600885570049286,
-0.519250214099884,
0.09028929471969604,
0.3858145475387573,
0.5777804851531982,
0.39415132999420166,
-0.8794000744819641,
-0.6315468549728394,
-0.6011251211166382,
0.7951647639274597,
-0.4285000264644623,
0.1894860416650772,
0.4619907736778259,
0.43930357694625854,
0.1253315955400467,
-0.6724088191986084,
-0.674293041229248,
-0.37744399905204773,
-0.1187012791633606,
0.32714980840682983,
-0.15799075365066528,
-0.10204292088747025,
0.20337843894958496,
0.392031192779541,
-0.6910243630409241,
0.0600864477455616,
-0.3799540400505066,
0.10148649662733078,
0.951452374458313,
0.37340569496154785,
0.3328307271003723,
-0.5274030566215515,
-0.3651143014431,
-0.1437343806028366,
-0.5942932963371277,
0.254910945892334,
0.4751952588558197,
-0.12417367845773697,
0.32574760913848877,
0.8423330187797546,
-0.28773292899131775,
0.6569511294364929,
-0.002946514869108796,
0.21058054268360138,
-0.1088935136795044,
-0.4973858594894409,
-0.23529571294784546,
-0.15595880150794983,
0.6226789951324463,
0.5005862712860107,
0.37688660621643066,
-0.13317005336284637,
-0.30417370796203613,
-0.25147974491119385,
0.26159223914146423,
-0.6036038398742676,
0.031157111749053,
0.43554046750068665,
-0.2984275817871094,
-0.20692308247089386,
-0.13108494877815247,
-0.8631719350814819,
-0.45823270082473755,
-0.5975685715675354,
0.723285436630249,
-0.2364608496427536,
0.09546399861574173,
0.1500161588191986,
-0.1964695155620575,
0.5585812926292419,
0.08334539085626602,
-0.6738342046737671,
0.2743358314037323,
0.33081647753715515,
0.5343251824378967,
-0.43093806505203247,
-0.38399702310562134,
-0.4078523516654968,
0.20642562210559845,
-0.40715447068214417,
1.012373685836792,
-0.21188925206661224,
-0.2795100808143616,
0.06699346005916595,
-0.10536357015371323,
-0.0347248874604702,
-0.3824891746044159,
0.2656055986881256,
-0.8563252687454224,
0.4809047281742096,
-0.21965551376342773,
-0.7205188870429993,
-0.06731705367565155,
0.3217443823814392,
-0.7311504483222961,
1.3069922924041748,
0.2479722499847412,
-0.5825320482254028,
0.11113642901182175,
-0.7086778879165649,
-0.47581303119659424,
-0.09268832951784134,
0.19800233840942383,
-0.10231801867485046,
-0.17646878957748413,
0.6260919570922852,
0.3341139554977417,
-0.4964561462402344,
0.22035877406597137,
0.05111023411154747,
-0.3358124792575836,
0.18038451671600342,
-0.557744562625885,
0.6810068488121033,
0.025481849908828735,
-0.24828895926475525,
0.13700217008590698,
-0.5624916553497314,
0.2783142924308777,
0.1573151797056198,
-0.21873225271701813,
-0.3346090614795685,
0.0016792153473943472,
-0.1705881804227829,
-0.06666237115859985,
0.2663613259792328,
-0.38389790058135986,
0.3587126135826111,
-0.422479510307312,
0.3153155446052551,
0.5584453344345093,
0.15492340922355652,
0.5216832756996155,
-0.6482594013214111,
0.8477174639701843,
-0.26426246762275696,
0.16789966821670532,
-0.39154377579689026,
-0.23741468787193298,
-1.032633900642395,
0.05077940225601196,
0.32690033316612244,
0.65422523021698,
-0.8932895660400391,
0.6617627143859863,
-0.21232497692108154,
-0.5581198334693909,
-0.32050275802612305,
0.22000665962696075,
0.2818146347999573,
0.46372902393341064,
0.5717129707336426,
-0.1208617091178894,
-0.13265836238861084,
-0.7143176794052124,
-0.14606966078281403,
-0.37943604588508606,
-0.276946485042572,
0.2688380181789398,
0.48721569776535034,
-0.19450832903385162,
1.1837410926818848,
-0.6179466247558594,
0.12064948678016663,
-0.39841970801353455,
-0.030540768057107925,
0.03782699629664421,
0.1975409835577011,
0.2706480324268341,
-0.6867055892944336,
-0.3704512417316437,
-0.3674107491970062,
-0.7821999788284302,
-0.31973928213119507,
-0.039266981184482574,
-0.49802467226982117,
0.2247539460659027,
0.7299838662147522,
-0.45755645632743835,
0.2321617752313614,
0.390582799911499,
-0.46732133626937866,
0.7682781219482422,
-0.050919435918331146,
0.19330362975597382,
-1.2340078353881836,
0.00958328228443861,
-0.1387283205986023,
-0.2247220128774643,
-0.4112226068973541,
0.2345230132341385,
0.07753109931945801,
-0.00783400610089302,
-0.2668270170688629,
0.9333428144454956,
-0.4139290750026703,
-0.20402880012989044,
-0.07042277604341507,
0.4067154824733734,
0.42099305987358093,
0.3037834167480469,
-0.1592268943786621,
0.6971954703330994,
0.04969656467437744,
-0.5671247243881226,
0.7843718528747559,
0.2725470960140228,
-0.4522519111633301,
0.41620850563049316,
-0.7282859086990356,
0.23384425044059753,
-0.2029361128807068,
0.5980939865112305,
-1.116852879524231,
-0.2877822518348694,
-0.024234868586063385,
-0.19393011927604675,
0.05373084545135498,
0.16603918373584747,
-0.5994263291358948,
-0.6116899251937866,
-0.20997415482997894,
0.6070113778114319,
0.5323103070259094,
-0.6405365467071533,
0.5465975403785706,
0.14659591019153595,
-0.4219872057437897,
-0.5500352382659912,
-0.6566413044929504,
0.006659431383013725,
-0.27280715107917786,
-0.787468671798706,
0.11380431056022644,
-0.4289318323135376,
-0.35918402671813965,
-0.16648094356060028,
-0.11291024833917618,
-0.08262259513139725,
-0.09791639447212219,
0.018560094758868217,
0.2810996472835541,
-0.27313894033432007,
0.6033969521522522,
0.3621332049369812,
-0.09349150955677032,
0.13754476606845856,
-0.04473727196455002,
0.36064964532852173,
-0.05169079080224037,
-0.40379592776298523,
-0.08921588212251663,
0.49861669540405273,
0.6080681681632996,
-0.3240455687046051,
0.35097643733024597,
0.1712961047887802,
-0.09014145284891129,
-0.43679937720298767,
-0.5992920994758606,
-0.04280876740813255,
-0.46082884073257446,
0.26512613892555237,
-0.36714601516723633,
-0.7659721374511719,
0.4323110282421112,
0.32952988147735596,
0.24136915802955627,
0.6140878200531006,
0.6316497921943665,
-0.212903693318367,
0.9752945303916931,
0.43069109320640564,
-0.1426430344581604,
0.166894793510437,
-0.036925241351127625,
0.10499788820743561,
-0.48639780282974243,
-0.0446910597383976,
-0.3628893494606018,
-0.19517001509666443,
-0.2637789845466614,
-0.41404446959495544,
0.5913184285163879,
0.25253719091415405,
-0.25595733523368835,
0.11298920214176178,
-0.4978526830673218,
0.8843572735786438,
0.5286175012588501,
-0.052890464663505554,
0.722970187664032,
-0.22442297637462616,
-0.16484732925891876,
0.4332582652568817,
-0.37649986147880554,
-0.7373075485229492,
1.193528413772583,
0.3944404125213623,
0.4516906142234802,
0.04779065400362015,
0.6839527487754822,
0.42330971360206604,
0.483586847782135,
-1.0476670265197754,
0.46178871393203735,
0.21870337426662445,
-0.7529990673065186,
-0.7877213358879089,
-0.22428233921527863,
-0.8830463886260986,
0.20481157302856445,
0.16259491443634033,
-0.3240731954574585,
-0.22981613874435425,
-0.2041717916727066,
-0.6743960380554199,
-0.11853104084730148,
-0.7922276854515076,
0.7631667852401733,
-0.34925422072410583,
-0.12560592591762543,
0.028670497238636017,
-0.732419490814209,
0.4014292359352112,
-0.306784451007843,
-0.08858028054237366,
0.045896243304014206,
-0.10596062242984772,
0.7902715802192688,
-0.1920606642961502,
0.4131070375442505,
0.0598137192428112,
-0.25381386280059814,
0.6757915019989014,
0.1913134902715683,
0.1869359016418457,
0.22393198311328888,
-0.4318563938140869,
-0.23305757343769073,
0.6270725131034851,
-0.5475115776062012,
-0.7977575659751892,
0.24427184462547302,
-0.70769202709198,
-0.7874084711074829,
-0.4785812199115753,
-0.8266294598579407,
-0.5823004841804504,
0.11812625080347061,
-0.009409060701727867,
0.4297342896461487,
-0.1202053651213646,
0.2735103368759155,
0.3869220018386841,
-0.35361918807029724,
0.4341277480125427,
0.622959554195404,
-0.46436887979507446,
-0.2767006754875183,
0.433775931596756,
-0.033697184175252914,
0.42664772272109985,
0.35081249475479126,
0.14338380098342896,
-0.627047061920166,
-0.3758801221847534,
-0.734123170375824,
0.14776653051376343,
-0.7654043436050415,
-0.21961067616939545,
-0.4712650179862976,
-0.4794715344905853,
-0.2197180837392807,
-0.16762694716453552,
0.09196996688842773,
-0.2930314242839813,
-0.1798335313796997,
-0.2620702385902405,
0.2790519595146179,
0.9610660672187805,
0.3716179132461548,
0.17169693112373352,
-0.8846340179443359,
0.3269602060317993,
0.5498813390731812,
-0.035391565412282944,
0.07680618017911911,
-0.48757678270339966,
-0.21391670405864716,
-0.15524210035800934,
-0.5040761828422546,
-0.8298490047454834,
0.4116985499858856,
-0.09595423936843872,
0.149294912815094,
0.10796872526407242,
0.3698213994503021,
0.6365002989768982,
-0.46950358152389526,
0.939935564994812,
-0.20636779069900513,
-0.9898273944854736,
0.287569135427475,
-0.4814569354057312,
0.5057755708694458,
0.6670656800270081,
0.5433799624443054,
-0.5343754887580872,
-0.4732067883014679,
-0.22548161447048187,
-0.7452532052993774,
0.4407760798931122,
-0.003130090655758977,
0.26533588767051697,
0.07659277319908142,
0.3871100842952728,
0.35634735226631165,
0.10274013876914978,
-0.7840836048126221,
0.10451503843069077,
0.004977645352482796,
-0.4982948303222656,
-0.2961540222167969,
-0.18740259110927582,
-0.10292192548513412,
-0.4123283922672272,
0.5621209740638733,
-0.36775216460227966,
0.033065468072891235,
0.4791007936000824,
-0.3167080581188202,
-0.2070329338312149,
0.30336621403694153,
0.24628867208957672,
1.101381778717041,
-0.06127272546291351,
-0.020932679995894432,
0.20661461353302002,
-0.10881553590297699,
0.1610129326581955,
0.21999500691890717,
-0.03689726069569588,
-0.27909624576568604,
0.47369179129600525,
0.32884490489959717,
-0.10062028467655182,
-0.8949556946754456,
0.48370593786239624,
0.01744307577610016,
-0.15884160995483398,
-0.4492022693157196,
-0.09388202428817749,
0.34929510951042175,
0.49841129779815674,
0.6899686455726624,
-0.6076481938362122,
-0.011686758138239384,
-0.4692530632019043,
0.4544656276702881,
0.14826227724552155,
-0.09019285440444946,
0.056932345032691956,
0.23271331191062927,
0.25708743929862976,
-0.05530663579702377,
0.6457685828208923,
-0.18615463376045227,
-0.47777000069618225,
0.9734018445014954,
0.41714343428611755,
0.6121262311935425,
-0.017706848680973053,
0.3264402151107788,
0.09961597621440887,
0.19399920105934143,
-0.049014195799827576,
0.04678722843527794,
-0.2871166467666626,
-0.6095361709594727,
-0.35097259283065796,
-1.01667320728302,
-0.5277207493782043,
0.14882831275463104,
-0.6719269156455994,
0.1689629852771759,
-0.08399715274572372,
0.17605547606945038,
-0.07223139703273773,
0.22013773024082184,
-0.4682917594909668,
0.3009900748729706,
0.003887854516506195,
0.9594548940658569,
-0.7180730700492859,
0.6627830266952515,
0.3908400237560272,
-0.5417194962501526,
-0.6796332597732544,
0.4131185710430145,
-0.42195844650268555,
-0.7188251614570618,
0.45334288477897644,
0.2930024266242981,
0.14335450530052185,
0.34598395228385925,
-0.32308149337768555,
-0.8934093713760376,
1.2774192094802856,
0.08546630293130875,
-0.5123669505119324,
-0.5364503860473633,
0.19731980562210083,
0.7909648418426514,
-0.20402710139751434,
0.5713077783584595,
0.7430440187454224,
0.46303704380989075,
-0.0069696637801826,
-0.8086188435554504,
0.004333123564720154,
-0.02748575061559677,
-0.3038414716720581,
0.2083469033241272,
-0.6242923140525818,
0.46567246317863464,
0.029796583577990532,
-0.02964094839990139,
0.6007184982299805,
0.6196200847625732,
0.2989368736743927,
0.6719701290130615,
0.6315796971321106,
0.4292615056037903,
0.6119741797447205,
0.11725135892629623,
1.2094991207122803,
-0.32019978761672974,
0.2629793584346771,
0.7758065462112427,
-0.23196755349636078,
0.8879980444908142,
0.36713436245918274,
-0.22732213139533997,
0.5311964750289917,
0.8210316300392151,
-0.05202159658074379,
0.10737002640962601,
0.5209376811981201,
-0.20699548721313477,
-0.29228004813194275,
0.0990491509437561,
-0.18115964531898499,
0.3575318455696106,
-0.08410156518220901,
-0.45870643854141235,
-0.24455155432224274,
0.058101899921894073,
-0.33232685923576355,
0.15437817573547363,
-0.28941088914871216,
0.6442090272903442,
0.2588549554347992,
-1.0938348770141602,
0.5400721430778503,
-0.03882893547415733,
0.39783337712287903,
-0.5563653707504272,
0.3103102743625641,
-0.3033781349658966,
-0.13729871809482574,
-0.026211494579911232,
-1.0062341690063477,
0.22231796383857727,
0.22589488327503204,
-0.364857017993927,
-0.35390597581863403,
0.4345194399356842,
-0.3905162215232849,
-0.691540539264679,
0.2852451801300049,
0.9327725768089294,
0.1918572634458542,
-0.0076356190256774426,
-0.5627860426902771,
-0.348291277885437,
-0.19429688155651093,
-0.7026541829109192,
0.19580645859241486,
0.31196603178977966,
-0.11665648967027664,
0.6212896704673767,
0.5431223511695862,
-0.2535218894481659,
0.09930355846881866,
0.06177864968776703,
0.6015636324882507,
-0.774332582950592,
-0.541138231754303,
-0.7368000745773315,
0.42526811361312866,
0.06379670649766922,
-0.3293309509754181,
0.7565299868583679,
0.4618450701236725,
0.5976758003234863,
0.16081266105175018,
0.7209323048591614,
0.24468086659908295,
0.5246111750602722,
-0.5412003993988037,
0.8289300799369812,
-0.7667627930641174,
0.06704007089138031,
-0.05102158710360527,
-1.1360849142074585,
-0.1697622686624527,
0.034892696887254715,
-0.528918981552124,
0.05835092067718506,
0.9831495881080627,
0.6634800434112549,
0.148979052901268,
0.2144765853881836,
0.2714998424053192,
0.0007623181445524096,
0.21000635623931885,
0.6902020573616028,
1.095956563949585,
-0.46025803685188293,
0.7110482454299927,
0.2141004055738449,
-0.1427479237318039,
0.04445495083928108,
-0.6873335242271423,
-1.0313992500305176,
-0.6715203523635864,
0.06826942414045334,
-0.3514319956302643,
0.05167551711201668,
0.6928770542144775,
0.30787748098373413,
-0.5649532079696655,
-0.2720226049423218,
-0.008316661231219769,
0.16982261836528778,
0.12788406014442444,
-0.3149515688419342,
0.5323813557624817,
-0.40156495571136475,
-0.9387076497077942,
0.4829511046409607,
0.08058235049247742,
-0.20723405480384827,
-0.5128227472305298,
-0.03747403994202614,
0.050278160721063614,
0.47412699460983276,
0.6783959269523621,
0.2022593468427658,
-0.6048946976661682,
-0.27963927388191223,
0.10660624504089355,
-0.20538361370563507,
-0.08860166370868683,
0.6931429505348206,
-0.8781765103340149,
0.4687717854976654,
0.6361929774284363,
0.9494940042495728,
0.48532459139823914,
0.4754997193813324,
0.601977527141571,
-0.3982577621936798,
-0.400664746761322,
0.5646427273750305,
-0.029870983213186264,
0.19245211780071259,
-0.26434075832366943,
0.4162747263908386,
-0.02756698615849018,
-0.8882772922515869,
-0.8531477451324463,
0.2517174184322357,
-0.851477324962616,
-0.30887800455093384,
1.4504315853118896,
0.1140509694814682,
-0.33290112018585205,
-0.12939125299453735,
-0.2227901667356491,
0.2748769223690033,
-0.18605665862560272,
0.8194468021392822,
0.9510822892189026,
-0.2799268662929535,
0.07258301228284836,
-0.6203102469444275,
0.38111570477485657,
0.7230409383773804,
-1.1102409362792969,
0.04417971894145012,
0.6367959976196289,
0.2632618546485901,
0.03841277211904526,
0.444575697183609,
-0.07910293340682983,
0.10796325653791428,
-0.356490820646286,
-0.1628444492816925,
-0.07985791563987732,
-0.3041308522224426,
-0.36112847924232483,
0.318973183631897,
-0.18281933665275574,
0.2634970545768738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00159v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00159v1
|
On the referential capacity of language models: An internalist rejoinder to Mandelkern & Linzen
| 2024-05-31T19:43:20
| 2024-05-31T19:43:20
|
Giosue Baggio, Elliot Murphy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In a recent paper, Mandelkern & Linzen (2024) - henceforth M&L - address the
question of whether language models' (LMs) words refer. Their argument draws
from the externalist tradition in philosophical semantics, which views
reference as the capacity of words to "achieve 'word-to-world' connections". In
the externalist framework, causally uninterrupted chains of usage, tracing
every occurrence of a name back to its bearer, guarantee that, for example,
'Peano' refers to the individual Peano (Kripke 1980). This account is
externalist both because words pick out referents 'out there' in the world, and
because what determines reference are coordinated linguistic actions by members
of a community, and not individual mental states. The "central question to
ask", for M&L, is whether LMs too belong to human linguistic communities, such
that words by LMs may also trace back causally to their bearers. Their answer
is a cautious "yes": inputs to LMs are linguistic "forms with particular
histories of referential use"; "those histories ground the referents of those
forms"; any occurrence of 'Peano' in LM outputs is as causally connected to the
individual Peano as any other occurrence of the same proper name in human
speech or text; therefore, occurrences of 'Peano' in LM outputs refer to Peano.
In this commentary, we first qualify M&L's claim as applying to a narrow class
of natural language expressions. Thus qualified, their claim is valid, and we
emphasise an additional motivation for that in Section 2. Next, we discuss the
actual scope of their claim, and we suggest that the way they formulate it may
lead to unwarranted generalisations about reference in LMs. Our critique is
likewise applicable to other externalist accounts of LMs (e.g., Lederman &
Mahowald 2024; Mollo & Milliere 2023). Lastly, we conclude with a comment on
the status of LMs as members of human linguistic communities.
|
[
-0.13967174291610718,
-0.14485107362270355,
0.8676544427871704,
-0.1621505320072174,
-0.06661704927682877,
-0.529791533946991,
-0.41384920477867126,
-0.7476939558982849,
0.07979930937290192,
0.4231836795806885,
-0.3656501770019531,
0.5876591801643372,
-0.5313040614128113,
0.48059266805648804,
-0.48235976696014404,
0.5903696417808533,
0.007008940912783146,
0.13495440781116486,
-0.3623056709766388,
-0.39233824610710144,
-0.28270062804222107,
-0.8520476818084717,
-0.5675482153892517,
-0.4299646317958832,
0.8782424330711365,
0.012764369137585163,
0.7950658202171326,
0.3753295838832855,
0.3514551818370819,
0.41466641426086426,
-0.1497301161289215,
-0.09109949320554733,
-0.316591739654541,
0.13254472613334656,
-0.5055472254753113,
-0.6335214376449585,
-0.011491633951663971,
0.11784433573484421,
0.7544979453086853,
0.9916104078292847,
0.09492780268192291,
0.2782668471336365,
0.1579027622938156,
0.7252359390258789,
-0.4485660493373871,
-0.3052176535129547,
-0.8656421899795532,
-0.25701162219047546,
-0.10696668922901154,
-0.04323681816458702,
-0.5463714003562927,
-0.2911311686038971,
0.1667192131280899,
-0.36422935128211975,
0.44908273220062256,
0.15145255625247955,
0.8798673748970032,
-0.016712766140699387,
-0.3749222457408905,
-0.1779060661792755,
-0.6721951961517334,
0.7681472301483154,
-0.7306909561157227,
0.299602746963501,
0.3332999646663666,
0.38318198919296265,
-0.03185894340276718,
-0.587719738483429,
-0.6737949848175049,
-0.5274853706359863,
-0.22572220861911774,
-0.009088720194995403,
0.053787440061569214,
-0.10292425006628036,
0.49687817692756653,
0.5319796800613403,
-0.13097098469734192,
-0.23597095906734467,
-0.8098335266113281,
-0.27146628499031067,
0.3658829629421234,
0.07312184572219849,
0.04429636523127556,
-0.06599371135234833,
-0.30876022577285767,
0.3701861798763275,
-0.8670414686203003,
0.025366980582475662,
0.2719630300998688,
0.6196220517158508,
0.09042754024267197,
0.6305500864982605,
0.21702070534229279,
0.5559404492378235,
0.0464467853307724,
0.017667483538389206,
-0.02675136737525463,
-0.5102118253707886,
-0.17375950515270233,
0.02812175452709198,
0.6972017288208008,
0.11901411414146423,
0.7168049812316895,
-0.31483182311058044,
0.14227394759655,
0.0012236949987709522,
0.4718702435493469,
-0.5417062640190125,
-0.14931891858577728,
-0.06334400922060013,
-0.3408665955066681,
0.012994778342545033,
0.4298003315925598,
-0.333776593208313,
-0.35981035232543945,
-0.27203014492988586,
0.09145686775445938,
0.04273127391934395,
-0.550270140171051,
-0.3821031451225281,
-0.233048215508461,
-0.13229681551456451,
0.0850808173418045,
-0.7747856974601746,
0.4391203224658966,
0.5006418824195862,
0.7609224915504456,
0.05511682853102684,
-0.29344168305397034,
-0.12113982439041138,
0.44445130228996277,
-0.5954859852790833,
0.75643390417099,
-0.695734977722168,
-0.6240526437759399,
0.48310062289237976,
0.4162184000015259,
-0.07967440038919449,
-0.7903817892074585,
0.5377404093742371,
-0.3389762341976166,
0.3006730079650879,
-0.8333163261413574,
-0.669546365737915,
-0.10839492827653885,
-0.13815118372440338,
-0.49493035674095154,
0.7165998220443726,
0.12977415323257446,
-0.560294508934021,
0.23256462812423706,
-0.3297463655471802,
-0.18213394284248352,
-0.1385924518108368,
-0.35264384746551514,
0.16461369395256042,
0.49686646461486816,
-0.5967759490013123,
0.2133839875459671,
-0.5851937532424927,
0.4165400564670563,
-0.645827054977417,
0.08388505131006241,
0.8941020369529724,
-0.42037132382392883,
0.6003032922744751,
0.05817054212093353,
-0.11880567669868469,
-0.01569305546581745,
-0.6828787326812744,
0.0340828113257885,
-0.016424279659986496,
-0.4178798496723175,
-0.47641512751579285,
0.17376303672790527,
-0.19101113080978394,
0.5386013984680176,
-0.03575601428747177,
-0.6216827034950256,
0.041792988777160645,
-0.4353381097316742,
0.45554816722869873,
1.1767597198486328,
-0.3355303406715393,
0.5742156505584717,
-0.4896368682384491,
0.3106314241886139,
-0.12801912426948547,
-0.19618003070354462,
-0.22856853902339935,
-0.5881722569465637,
-1.0057729482650757,
0.14880183339118958,
0.1495838761329651,
0.1402885466814041,
-0.39610815048217773,
0.29812103509902954,
-0.3224879503250122,
-0.0949786826968193,
-0.24836759269237518,
0.03027433156967163,
0.2987782657146454,
0.6157935857772827,
0.07449175417423248,
-0.1025315597653389,
-0.7091476917266846,
-1.2870019674301147,
-0.2609959542751312,
-0.4258718490600586,
-0.08527777343988419,
0.6987058520317078,
0.44437503814697266,
0.0816974937915802,
0.8831090331077576,
-0.11113455146551132,
-0.1322581171989441,
-0.07745125889778137,
-0.42941316962242126,
0.5395486950874329,
0.08292271196842194,
0.6476007103919983,
-0.5253952741622925,
-0.4650546908378601,
-0.030385849997401237,
-0.7670004963874817,
-0.3110083043575287,
0.025776511058211327,
-0.06364917010068893,
0.0525016225874424,
0.31659048795700073,
-0.5928577184677124,
-0.049182627350091934,
0.5999271273612976,
-0.5823593139648438,
0.6261883974075317,
-0.21144330501556396,
-0.31648674607276917,
-1.250966191291809,
0.2698019742965698,
-0.21712914109230042,
-0.17540353536605835,
-0.6367567777633667,
0.05123016983270645,
-0.046519987285137177,
-0.011083187535405159,
-0.39547544717788696,
0.8665613532066345,
-0.45966100692749023,
-0.005881058052182198,
-0.46114978194236755,
0.20201346278190613,
-0.27870988845825195,
0.14705929160118103,
-0.09862784296274185,
0.7894179821014404,
0.4223109483718872,
-1.06902277469635,
0.2898140847682953,
-0.17161592841148376,
0.042102403938770294,
0.7790908217430115,
-0.5341028571128845,
0.07399937510490417,
-0.007387855555862188,
0.3198234736919403,
-0.956415593624115,
-0.054114509373903275,
0.37469902634620667,
-0.2783488929271698,
-0.049453653395175934,
0.18746604025363922,
-0.4155535399913788,
-0.42214885354042053,
-0.13160033524036407,
0.37991514801979065,
0.3252953886985779,
-0.31377336382865906,
0.3286682367324829,
0.41411903500556946,
0.08336054533720016,
-0.24547028541564941,
-0.7551913857460022,
0.055791597813367844,
-0.13682126998901367,
-0.6025389432907104,
0.019901948049664497,
-0.20174741744995117,
-0.8169037103652954,
0.1984272599220276,
-0.15921352803707123,
-0.1513407826423645,
-0.20248199999332428,
0.3156369924545288,
0.18933571875095367,
-0.4403429329395294,
0.49241694808006287,
-0.4282252788543701,
-0.18855303525924683,
0.2513604164123535,
-0.19176889955997467,
0.2118157595396042,
0.052311159670352936,
-0.0716843456029892,
-0.22827786207199097,
0.5680032968521118,
0.18444131314754486,
0.383027046918869,
0.7709411978721619,
0.18949341773986816,
-0.3980567157268524,
0.17165811359882355,
-0.5542278289794922,
-0.36235255002975464,
-0.4342544972896576,
0.05330199375748634,
-0.5464339256286621,
-0.8508913516998291,
0.4745728075504303,
0.22266234457492828,
-0.10683204978704453,
0.9631512761116028,
0.509467363357544,
-0.1605338752269745,
0.24082547426223755,
0.7527841925621033,
-0.12787027657032013,
0.20030152797698975,
-0.019307920709252357,
0.23579366505146027,
-1.2393295764923096,
0.25275394320487976,
-0.8317244648933411,
-0.2226279228925705,
-0.49331405758857727,
-0.40771836042404175,
-0.21533767879009247,
-0.10361221432685852,
-0.33224526047706604,
0.3727686405181885,
-0.15988148748874664,
0.30663809180259705,
0.17501048743724823,
-0.20650672912597656,
0.357109397649765,
-0.2595738172531128,
-0.15875808894634247,
-0.20852425694465637,
-0.9444966912269592,
-0.6389764547348022,
1.0996733903884888,
0.39681023359298706,
0.618653416633606,
0.4099133014678955,
0.2497507929801941,
0.12789511680603027,
0.870841920375824,
-0.6541966199874878,
0.6896589398384094,
0.04011239856481552,
-1.0821799039840698,
-0.07906368374824524,
-0.19770784676074982,
-0.9815186858177185,
0.6491017937660217,
0.07249782979488373,
-0.9515892863273621,
0.5583679676055908,
0.11804576218128204,
-0.2042549103498459,
0.5386332869529724,
-0.32926857471466064,
0.5155075788497925,
-0.017507417127490044,
-0.4887543320655823,
-0.4710700809955597,
-0.4234048128128052,
0.538091778755188,
0.10048981010913849,
0.45574963092803955,
-0.29384666681289673,
-0.4718504846096039,
0.8684398531913757,
-0.7131664156913757,
1.012208342552185,
0.1020049899816513,
-0.564467191696167,
0.46605613827705383,
0.050297822803258896,
0.31573519110679626,
-0.17479117214679718,
-0.020587751641869545,
0.1348087340593338,
0.05825048312544823,
-0.0723068118095398,
-0.29748499393463135,
0.8651044368743896,
-0.4798431694507599,
-0.6843712329864502,
-0.7886751294136047,
-0.2832523286342621,
-0.21332308650016785,
0.15388235449790955,
0.13202190399169922,
0.6098737716674805,
-0.16142778098583221,
0.42176416516304016,
0.45418617129325867,
0.1269194781780243,
0.5901479721069336,
0.6826179623603821,
-0.23457136750221252,
-0.3788101077079773,
0.6353548765182495,
0.1981569528579712,
0.5971841812133789,
0.32872244715690613,
0.39061692357063293,
-0.2387837916612625,
0.07187312096357346,
-0.2928330898284912,
0.7527620792388916,
-0.8177851438522339,
0.06343375891447067,
-0.4168317914009094,
-0.07642630487680435,
-0.11989357322454453,
0.02568463236093521,
-0.29019099473953247,
-0.2493109405040741,
-0.18518099188804626,
0.2354159951210022,
-0.018959052860736847,
0.6593867540359497,
0.08434020727872849,
0.12801674008369446,
-0.7578845620155334,
0.2684893012046814,
0.4182066321372986,
0.2726801335811615,
0.050915565341711044,
-0.8916362524032593,
-0.10530675947666168,
-0.08325686305761337,
-0.08601471036672592,
-1.039626121520996,
-0.2696555256843567,
0.38662201166152954,
0.8523147106170654,
0.5912100672721863,
-0.09872499108314514,
0.609182596206665,
-0.7863113880157471,
0.838440477848053,
0.24323081970214844,
-0.6217241883277893,
0.1975228488445282,
-0.3673432767391205,
0.20838868618011475,
0.47862154245376587,
0.4804157614707947,
-0.8989620804786682,
-0.5542818307876587,
-0.9877015948295593,
-0.6530647873878479,
0.6053606867790222,
-0.07583659142255783,
0.592412531375885,
-0.20725630223751068,
0.3879050314426422,
0.12550176680088043,
0.36685624718666077,
-0.9654655456542969,
-0.25179556012153625,
0.33675503730773926,
0.15721435844898224,
-0.261703222990036,
-0.8047382831573486,
-0.27981001138687134,
-0.12172187864780426,
0.7269196510314941,
-0.1533428132534027,
0.3857838213443756,
0.3754594326019287,
0.008450771681964397,
-0.2962772846221924,
0.271352618932724,
0.6269789338111877,
1.3982239961624146,
0.19491611421108246,
0.3038385212421417,
0.0017471520695835352,
-0.16026648879051208,
0.18877333402633667,
-0.5003987550735474,
-0.15338556468486786,
0.30846384167671204,
0.5147214531898499,
0.4697645902633667,
0.5604528784751892,
-0.5486160516738892,
0.3569023907184601,
0.19858823716640472,
-0.08063402026891708,
-0.761437714099884,
-0.12727902829647064,
0.003491528332233429,
0.19026394188404083,
0.23079323768615723,
0.21720896661281586,
-0.05630137398838997,
-1.1028803586959839,
0.07124712318181992,
0.4881085753440857,
-0.5454304218292236,
-0.5530561208724976,
0.6449238061904907,
0.30060845613479614,
-0.3090697228908539,
0.18734592199325562,
0.2096358686685562,
-0.3383362889289856,
0.37040776014328003,
0.6684139370918274,
1.1473044157028198,
-0.40067827701568604,
-0.21111933887004852,
0.7186402082443237,
0.4278404116630554,
-0.016881797462701797,
0.023735323920845985,
0.011246326379477978,
-1.0711971521377563,
-0.3046332597732544,
-0.3667004406452179,
-0.13074344396591187,
0.1763961911201477,
-0.41687047481536865,
-0.1808738112449646,
-0.3178408145904541,
-0.23997314274311066,
-0.24880419671535492,
-0.47895580530166626,
-0.26605677604675293,
-0.19124820828437805,
0.3099687099456787,
1.0513978004455566,
-0.6708655953407288,
0.9227209687232971,
0.4436935484409332,
-0.41463503241539,
-0.49503812193870544,
0.14874716103076935,
-0.06874321401119232,
-0.41452670097351074,
0.9063949584960938,
0.18795651197433472,
-0.20826558768749237,
-0.48856717348098755,
-0.09699543565511703,
-0.9506502747535706,
0.772769033908844,
0.21228963136672974,
-0.4945557117462158,
-0.045332543551921844,
-0.08861478418111801,
0.5815548300743103,
-0.4204210042953491,
0.02961827628314495,
0.12933719158172607,
0.46886879205703735,
-0.026624351739883423,
-1.3108181953430176,
0.3071223199367523,
-0.1971326768398285,
0.3361632227897644,
0.16214248538017273,
-0.5405877232551575,
1.0701311826705933,
-0.42736464738845825,
-0.39205697178840637,
0.3646284341812134,
0.7467805743217468,
-0.17408046126365662,
-0.23905348777770996,
0.34701916575431824,
0.22669152915477753,
0.6213728189468384,
0.07966573536396027,
1.4754984378814697,
-0.3135320842266083,
0.22668270766735077,
1.113492727279663,
-0.27981340885162354,
1.0348916053771973,
0.8457015156745911,
-0.7984839677810669,
0.4764415919780731,
0.43504658341407776,
0.4036034941673279,
0.5128397345542908,
0.27775564789772034,
-0.352691113948822,
-0.12380778044462204,
-0.14625972509384155,
-0.517968475818634,
0.003897546324878931,
0.17435593903064728,
-0.7011769413948059,
-0.1956477016210556,
-0.45541849732398987,
0.03290009871125221,
0.24914483726024628,
-0.3678957223892212,
0.7595430016517639,
0.49133387207984924,
-0.6836888194084167,
0.47658225893974304,
-0.18640577793121338,
0.4798077344894409,
-0.8412888050079346,
0.19853384792804718,
0.04784245416522026,
0.5386915802955627,
-0.0629081279039383,
-0.5394549369812012,
0.4222300052642822,
-0.2524404227733612,
-0.23134909570217133,
-0.034532397985458374,
0.7499807476997375,
-0.4053970277309418,
-0.5752017498016357,
0.30252450704574585,
0.5050778388977051,
0.1424226462841034,
0.0903610810637474,
-0.37637829780578613,
-0.3767067790031433,
-0.12977802753448486,
-0.00830848515033722,
0.2688288986682892,
0.3140392303466797,
0.04142891615629196,
0.7301971912384033,
0.5266867876052856,
0.4763029217720032,
0.12111900746822357,
0.02832164242863655,
0.61988365650177,
-0.696816086769104,
-0.30001333355903625,
-1.0722712278366089,
0.30299028754234314,
-0.13996310532093048,
-0.3722963035106659,
0.8074807524681091,
0.4690908193588257,
0.871787965297699,
-0.19060462713241577,
0.9309284090995789,
-0.21546579897403717,
0.5604762434959412,
-0.4863284230232239,
0.19806820154190063,
-0.33042171597480774,
-0.004624129738658667,
-0.12059076875448227,
-1.0210198163986206,
0.08772333711385727,
0.7606673836708069,
-0.45216259360313416,
0.13780833780765533,
1.0625569820404053,
0.5801753997802734,
-0.03755778446793556,
-0.17658337950706482,
0.35979917645454407,
0.20764732360839844,
0.037119437009096146,
0.4520120620727539,
0.9456518292427063,
-0.28638288378715515,
0.40831249952316284,
-0.07076941430568695,
0.019473090767860413,
-0.2716841697692871,
-0.7647088170051575,
-0.7438071966171265,
-0.7838977575302124,
-0.07714013010263443,
-0.32841289043426514,
-0.08207064121961594,
0.8013414740562439,
0.39442944526672363,
-0.8072453737258911,
-0.6635072827339172,
0.08655671030282974,
-0.0757964700460434,
-0.18161016702651978,
-0.21497902274131775,
-0.030560042709112167,
-0.3632683753967285,
-0.4902631640434265,
0.20023773610591888,
0.09960871189832687,
-0.1841438263654709,
-0.5282819867134094,
-0.22027161717414856,
-0.21220743656158447,
0.19440259039402008,
0.7021921873092651,
0.3397602438926697,
-1.1823971271514893,
-0.6391178965568542,
-0.2775548994541168,
-0.18096831440925598,
0.0763755589723587,
1.1821240186691284,
-0.6711554527282715,
0.2674424648284912,
0.45096614956855774,
0.4195011556148529,
-0.21896034479141235,
-0.19154472649097443,
0.6300197839736938,
-0.5132797360420227,
0.42454394698143005,
-0.005579663906246424,
0.7906309366226196,
0.29163840413093567,
0.019798051565885544,
0.43774327635765076,
0.6892673969268799,
-0.3466492295265198,
-0.6778305172920227,
0.5304598808288574,
-0.6218106150627136,
-0.3313409686088562,
1.3266897201538086,
0.08826203644275665,
-0.12595020234584808,
0.011447043158113956,
-0.2476164698600769,
-0.2070239931344986,
-0.2299777865409851,
0.6320990920066833,
1.0624842643737793,
-0.10281330347061157,
-0.19624412059783936,
-0.9454458951950073,
0.3837600648403168,
0.07985977828502655,
-0.3792058527469635,
0.22773969173431396,
0.562298059463501,
0.19687624275684357,
0.49223819375038147,
0.9535107016563416,
0.017841285094618797,
0.17438381910324097,
-0.031631141901016235,
-0.27898362278938293,
0.2615084946155548,
-0.1239895448088646,
-0.21045653522014618,
0.04061947017908096,
0.35466092824935913,
-0.05789991095662117
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00131v1
|
How In-Context Learning Emerges from Training on Unstructured Data: On the Role of Co-Occurrence, Positional Information, and Noise Structures
| 2024-05-31T18:46:06
| 2024-05-31T18:46:06
|
Kevin Christian Wibisono, Yixin Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Large language models (LLMs) like transformers have impressive in-context
learning (ICL) capabilities; they can generate predictions for new queries
based on input-output sequences in prompts without parameter updates. While
many theories have attempted to explain ICL, they often focus on structured
training data similar to ICL tasks, such as regression. In practice, however,
these models are trained in an unsupervised manner on unstructured text data,
which bears little resemblance to ICL tasks. To this end, we investigate how
ICL emerges from unsupervised training on unstructured data. The key
observation is that ICL can arise simply by modeling co-occurrence information
using classical language models like continuous bag of words (CBOW), which we
theoretically prove and empirically validate. Furthermore, we establish the
necessity of positional information and noise structure to generalize ICL to
unseen data. Finally, we present instances where ICL fails and provide
theoretical explanations; they suggest that the ICL ability of LLMs to identify
certain tasks can be sensitive to the structure of the training data.
|
[
-0.2613951563835144,
-0.77463299036026,
0.6242010593414307,
-0.058119673281908035,
-0.21853171288967133,
0.2688392400741577,
-0.3694981634616852,
-0.40653714537620544,
-0.41242432594299316,
0.30745410919189453,
-0.42624613642692566,
-0.6455459594726562,
-0.2669307589530945,
-0.10091697424650192,
-0.8823783993721008,
1.2717283964157104,
0.1385434865951538,
-0.12379717081785202,
-0.5420514345169067,
0.002687331521883607,
-0.32345980405807495,
-0.8858175277709961,
-0.29080718755722046,
-0.5396317839622498,
0.13875718414783478,
0.3874562680721283,
0.2922937572002411,
0.4393574893474579,
0.1215653270483017,
0.18042302131652832,
0.05706721544265747,
0.0052079856395721436,
-0.4655167758464813,
0.09108457714319229,
-0.085867740213871,
-0.4781153202056885,
0.3458150029182434,
-0.003927655518054962,
0.78850919008255,
1.2733038663864136,
-0.26649728417396545,
-0.03442415967583656,
0.655147135257721,
0.37322524189949036,
-0.36703959107398987,
0.2906893789768219,
-1.10593581199646,
0.17719683051109314,
-0.30478501319885254,
-0.2660399079322815,
-0.6332941651344299,
0.2371351569890976,
0.3121214210987091,
-0.46397608518600464,
0.5013498663902283,
0.08337817341089249,
0.7266392707824707,
0.1811886578798294,
-0.6281992793083191,
-0.6459115147590637,
-0.9047568440437317,
0.9331157207489014,
-0.25311216711997986,
0.5047293901443481,
0.4020814299583435,
0.011224042624235153,
-0.5413804054260254,
-0.8237614035606384,
-0.3557409644126892,
-0.17508777976036072,
-0.49067971110343933,
0.019005849957466125,
0.10940803587436676,
-0.08211226761341095,
0.29546499252319336,
0.30515480041503906,
-0.19713957607746124,
0.25038933753967285,
-0.2721191346645355,
0.24367548525333405,
0.47504276037216187,
-0.07006312906742096,
0.17567414045333862,
-0.0247150007635355,
-0.6626736521720886,
-0.026660945266485214,
-0.9022576808929443,
0.5222539305686951,
0.020158693194389343,
0.3422163128852844,
-0.2932451069355011,
0.3535345494747162,
0.02078542672097683,
0.5901793837547302,
0.28263959288597107,
-0.22094760835170746,
0.012637767009437084,
0.10640470683574677,
-0.21198701858520508,
0.32395270466804504,
0.6150227189064026,
-0.3076120913028717,
0.23813065886497498,
-0.5846575498580933,
-0.39692413806915283,
-0.23916907608509064,
0.37040817737579346,
-0.43289849162101746,
-0.23564322292804718,
-0.017465829849243164,
-0.3114529252052307,
-0.33021342754364014,
0.38682880997657776,
-0.42543745040893555,
-0.0951012670993805,
-0.504886269569397,
0.28409719467163086,
-0.4118148982524872,
0.030031614005565643,
-0.2615815997123718,
0.07703029364347458,
0.3118378221988678,
0.14042788743972778,
-1.0033797025680542,
0.422515332698822,
0.6126784682273865,
0.5870190858840942,
-0.34306201338768005,
-0.31987467408180237,
-0.4536484181880951,
0.25362345576286316,
-0.44814595580101013,
0.9341350197792053,
-0.6959581971168518,
-0.4252479076385498,
0.2172073870897293,
0.040679529309272766,
-0.2425771951675415,
-0.6112290620803833,
0.30255037546157837,
-0.589491605758667,
0.22721117734909058,
-0.06715898215770721,
-0.6224921941757202,
-0.23679012060165405,
0.05987150967121124,
-0.388578325510025,
1.403347134590149,
0.2596111297607422,
-0.8429718017578125,
0.8080592155456543,
-0.724822998046875,
-0.5819478034973145,
0.26944002509117126,
-0.47228553891181946,
-0.41377800703048706,
0.5085555911064148,
-0.11936215311288834,
0.5973578691482544,
-0.14637912809848785,
0.5915125608444214,
-0.23942039906978607,
-0.5063491463661194,
0.6305379271507263,
-0.5066019296646118,
0.6205118894577026,
0.03283119201660156,
-0.29203128814697266,
-0.16093018651008606,
-0.867636501789093,
-0.14259907603263855,
-0.04945218563079834,
-0.7104430794715881,
-0.6903007626533508,
0.46510782837867737,
-0.10884419828653336,
0.20422221720218658,
-0.07592374086380005,
-0.4822315573692322,
0.13862934708595276,
-0.5235829949378967,
0.32193753123283386,
0.5510874390602112,
-0.0276800487190485,
0.5757584571838379,
0.03241376206278801,
0.12205911427736282,
0.24113337695598602,
-0.05097394064068794,
-0.13174794614315033,
-0.015788979828357697,
-0.5047237873077393,
-0.21907171607017517,
0.10006962716579437,
0.19136732816696167,
-0.540833055973053,
0.24883607029914856,
-0.13952602446079254,
-0.20064334571361542,
-0.11796566843986511,
0.2755122780799866,
0.3120351731777191,
0.8293196558952332,
0.4128226935863495,
-0.1128978356719017,
-0.6903242468833923,
-0.7123466730117798,
-0.0782276839017868,
0.036937929689884186,
-0.26246339082717896,
0.27630025148391724,
0.5206689834594727,
-0.02611992321908474,
1.190384030342102,
-0.27031511068344116,
-0.17039355635643005,
-0.17107470333576202,
0.19294685125350952,
0.09775257855653763,
0.32955577969551086,
0.3113804757595062,
-0.8311452865600586,
-0.5706174373626709,
-0.04537782445549965,
-0.9530346989631653,
-0.02896096371114254,
-0.03804893046617508,
0.23992523550987244,
0.29935330152511597,
1.0167478322982788,
-0.280944287776947,
0.5154305100440979,
0.4390008747577667,
-0.17449775338172913,
0.2433713674545288,
-0.33083564043045044,
-0.393375039100647,
-1.3404669761657715,
-0.03380824625492096,
-0.037032246589660645,
-0.10413406044244766,
-0.6819717288017273,
-0.16834723949432373,
-0.03879780322313309,
0.0025372598320245743,
-0.3295040428638458,
0.3436681628227234,
-0.6280006766319275,
-0.3871555030345917,
-0.22023853659629822,
-0.024933183565735817,
-0.17234691977500916,
0.6339080333709717,
0.2814926207065582,
0.5803492665290833,
0.6125855445861816,
-0.8161754012107849,
-0.25714969635009766,
0.24362431466579437,
-0.6726134419441223,
0.32157036662101746,
-0.40422528982162476,
0.10127731412649155,
-0.2892187535762787,
0.24619466066360474,
-0.9710783362388611,
-0.3805280029773712,
-0.11230186372995377,
-0.042216431349515915,
0.47466596961021423,
-0.36097341775894165,
-0.5073317289352417,
-0.02608584426343441,
0.03848161920905113,
0.5023978352546692,
0.3330329954624176,
-0.942918598651886,
0.29457125067710876,
0.5591636300086975,
0.3624389171600342,
-0.5860887169837952,
-0.614185631275177,
-0.1505165696144104,
-0.4751477837562561,
-0.04841214045882225,
0.46405720710754395,
-0.05460206791758537,
-0.4241049885749817,
-0.11782600730657578,
0.014929181896150112,
-0.2563190460205078,
0.5288055539131165,
0.5220205783843994,
0.1682625710964203,
-0.07893489301204681,
0.37980565428733826,
-0.0363442562520504,
0.06022538244724274,
0.13826054334640503,
-0.4343280494213104,
0.6358842253684998,
-0.04604559391736984,
-0.3759024143218994,
-0.08632247895002365,
0.3383219242095947,
0.3257209360599518,
-0.005812928080558777,
0.7655431628227234,
0.3038758337497711,
-0.3939078152179718,
-0.48674556612968445,
-0.023293670266866684,
-0.21962973475456238,
-0.43764200806617737,
0.4748835265636444,
-0.3101840019226074,
-0.718603789806366,
0.26970526576042175,
-0.1554524153470993,
-0.02687503956258297,
0.21023420989513397,
0.39492788910865784,
-0.4767073690891266,
1.0095018148422241,
0.8348875045776367,
0.15641866624355316,
0.653381884098053,
-0.258198082447052,
0.1732829064130783,
-0.8719940781593323,
-0.5411879420280457,
-0.38313066959381104,
-0.20041948556900024,
-0.7124866843223572,
-0.07466576248407364,
0.5526063442230225,
0.388184517621994,
-0.298685759305954,
0.06859857589006424,
-0.30201131105422974,
0.5487217903137207,
0.5371418595314026,
-0.06788951903581619,
0.27847805619239807,
0.3517743945121765,
-0.14377452433109283,
0.15938860177993774,
-0.6186111569404602,
-0.3303673565387726,
0.9699097275733948,
0.15196660161018372,
0.7883341312408447,
-0.19722989201545715,
0.4458501935005188,
0.12214283645153046,
0.2906718850135803,
-0.7714788317680359,
0.20865023136138916,
-0.1206006407737732,
-0.36659085750579834,
-0.1948462575674057,
0.066715307533741,
-1.1940956115722656,
0.14043481647968292,
-0.265917032957077,
-0.8451581001281738,
0.2358231395483017,
0.07806612551212311,
-0.04117573797702789,
0.15920372307300568,
-0.5783831477165222,
0.4245467782020569,
-0.2644757628440857,
-0.19538931548595428,
0.05824708193540573,
-0.5903361439704895,
0.22012653946876526,
-0.2497306913137436,
0.19514793157577515,
0.30619874596595764,
0.07048298418521881,
0.5374209880828857,
-0.16869919002056122,
1.1101830005645752,
-0.12963972985744476,
-0.11630424112081528,
0.3062552511692047,
0.10002171248197556,
0.5499356985092163,
0.13814181089401245,
0.2206456959247589,
0.35364580154418945,
-0.11420358717441559,
-0.23111671209335327,
-0.5666323304176331,
0.5500917434692383,
-0.779051661491394,
-0.33151379227638245,
-0.34546783566474915,
-0.8575510382652283,
-0.3128242492675781,
-0.06773874908685684,
0.5929283499717712,
0.8057193756103516,
-0.04119214043021202,
0.7171682715415955,
0.8043021559715271,
-0.10846859216690063,
0.8517730236053467,
0.5826624035835266,
0.029597867280244827,
0.23833929002285004,
0.46993348002433777,
0.33970004320144653,
0.12944473326206207,
0.7616769671440125,
0.1988036334514618,
-0.3687257468700409,
-0.64328932762146,
-0.12950190901756287,
-0.14242781698703766,
-0.7478278279304504,
-0.1264239102602005,
-0.6695066690444946,
-0.4532396197319031,
0.0004001551424153149,
-0.2668101191520691,
-0.1955784410238266,
0.06316681951284409,
-0.300360769033432,
-0.10201618820428848,
0.04771461337804794,
1.0712993144989014,
0.1981077492237091,
0.37974879145622253,
-0.42982009053230286,
-0.23872080445289612,
0.18616315722465515,
0.3037843108177185,
0.11029285192489624,
-0.6222892999649048,
-0.5808640718460083,
0.09527759253978729,
-0.19953230023384094,
-0.4516739845275879,
0.39472341537475586,
0.3541353940963745,
0.6585705876350403,
0.4056186079978943,
0.012071221135556698,
0.7040367126464844,
-0.4631252586841583,
0.6147923469543457,
-0.3000711500644684,
-0.731335461139679,
0.26472488045692444,
-0.3920894265174866,
0.06691849231719971,
0.3949475586414337,
0.46210765838623047,
-0.46797922253608704,
-0.23571109771728516,
-0.7132521271705627,
-0.751778244972229,
0.7819843292236328,
-0.19666439294815063,
0.1549890786409378,
-0.034069422632455826,
0.4804527759552002,
0.3780432641506195,
0.33945563435554504,
-1.0653331279754639,
0.049999285489320755,
-0.12796013057231903,
-0.37953925132751465,
-0.04027065262198448,
-0.349263995885849,
0.032074958086013794,
-0.1888394057750702,
0.3370853364467621,
-0.4640659987926483,
0.1616971343755722,
0.13152295351028442,
-0.556911826133728,
0.0609012171626091,
0.28796592354774475,
0.4346978962421417,
0.6353628635406494,
-0.08138164132833481,
0.34112119674682617,
0.1658610701560974,
-0.2661421000957489,
-0.13713768124580383,
-0.14284834265708923,
-0.2737245261669159,
-0.30111178755760193,
0.6806342005729675,
0.813209056854248,
0.7441179156303406,
-0.6338626146316528,
0.5312296152114868,
0.10407427698373795,
-0.11218366026878357,
-0.7832730412483215,
-0.0026279848534613848,
-0.1737000048160553,
0.20109011232852936,
0.6458190083503723,
-0.055365048348903656,
0.035931024700403214,
-0.9337199926376343,
0.22652986645698547,
0.7154985666275024,
-0.7173326015472412,
-0.6094949245452881,
0.38771459460258484,
-0.3656909167766571,
-0.22421300411224365,
0.7493072748184204,
-0.015122368931770325,
-0.3182642161846161,
0.2988373041152954,
0.8794263601303101,
0.6457378268241882,
-0.014596284367144108,
0.08179239928722382,
0.1235998272895813,
-0.015171270817518234,
0.00032482220558449626,
-0.13884270191192627,
-0.49366262555122375,
-0.8113893866539001,
-0.26553770899772644,
-0.8626317381858826,
-0.05236835777759552,
0.47442373633384705,
-0.6070884466171265,
0.2849404513835907,
-0.35266563296318054,
0.6562879681587219,
-0.3245181143283844,
-0.1332610547542572,
-0.7564868927001953,
0.21252304315567017,
0.06598197668790817,
0.593865692615509,
-0.9496430158615112,
1.057845115661621,
0.5601966381072998,
-0.2199266254901886,
-0.9913476705551147,
0.4045795202255249,
-0.21801863610744476,
-0.8722674250602722,
0.8506658673286438,
0.23760756850242615,
0.16890189051628113,
0.08913499116897583,
-0.7473851442337036,
-1.013048768043518,
1.1285219192504883,
0.293338805437088,
-0.3184848427772522,
-0.13725630939006805,
0.3472048342227936,
0.675041139125824,
-0.7457110285758972,
0.055913157761096954,
0.3373245298862457,
-0.010405978187918663,
0.05017279461026192,
-0.49392056465148926,
-0.177423894405365,
0.1458272784948349,
-0.08870299160480499,
0.16342413425445557,
-0.44765084981918335,
0.9855310320854187,
0.022556843236088753,
-0.3482816517353058,
-0.2500486969947815,
0.5432367324829102,
0.09806618839502335,
0.381332129240036,
0.5796841382980347,
0.26428812742233276,
0.7862364053726196,
-0.09687064588069916,
1.205639362335205,
-0.12219800800085068,
0.24664653837680817,
1.2719931602478027,
-0.24032935500144958,
0.8277052044868469,
0.46707916259765625,
0.10543782263994217,
0.8225058913230896,
0.7817063927650452,
-0.06286031752824783,
0.7403520941734314,
-0.04245585948228836,
-0.21775959432125092,
-0.24829557538032532,
-0.32873716950416565,
0.12193181365728378,
0.9545676708221436,
0.5051549077033997,
-0.3571304976940155,
-0.4038871228694916,
0.3113733232021332,
-0.16211345791816711,
0.15579839050769806,
-0.22534388303756714,
1.0923442840576172,
0.08492317795753479,
-0.691313624382019,
0.36181795597076416,
-0.2850213646888733,
0.5143015384674072,
-0.5461927056312561,
-0.0829416960477829,
-0.18799430131912231,
0.141864612698555,
-0.1874454915523529,
-0.6400839686393738,
0.3829651474952698,
-0.268456369638443,
-0.40717804431915283,
-0.20240932703018188,
0.6349787712097168,
-0.6001985669136047,
-0.3821898102760315,
0.3729562759399414,
0.3320452868938446,
0.17202861607074738,
-0.07913302630186081,
-0.45200690627098083,
-0.23516415059566498,
-0.19803808629512787,
-0.1798347383737564,
0.732545018196106,
0.5984320044517517,
-0.5701854825019836,
0.5219756960868835,
0.5605354309082031,
-0.26093921065330505,
-0.004554278217256069,
-0.07883942872285843,
0.737976610660553,
-0.40959566831588745,
-0.4133531153202057,
-0.9712761640548706,
0.3894733190536499,
0.0111762760207057,
-0.031253404915332794,
0.6156252026557922,
0.6763495802879333,
1.2728519439697266,
-0.06275507062673569,
0.7574970722198486,
0.04411744698882103,
0.4706786274909973,
-0.6812052726745605,
0.4853787422180176,
-0.5327249765396118,
0.35201308131217957,
-0.06728195399045944,
-0.6980214715003967,
-0.1820753663778305,
0.38875097036361694,
-0.32074856758117676,
-0.03672927990555763,
0.8729074001312256,
0.6859652400016785,
-0.32376572489738464,
-0.10439486056566238,
0.3675515055656433,
0.2235914170742035,
0.3110837936401367,
0.285753071308136,
0.9936453700065613,
-0.2685357928276062,
0.4628278315067291,
-0.2213498055934906,
0.06677203625440598,
-0.14075446128845215,
-0.7858447432518005,
-1.0574480295181274,
-1.1895250082015991,
-0.01380810234695673,
-0.19435124099254608,
-0.3377670645713806,
1.094884991645813,
0.7932640910148621,
-0.7753300666809082,
-0.3502936363220215,
-0.4115007519721985,
0.13366007804870605,
-0.017503254115581512,
-0.2928225100040436,
0.5667057633399963,
-0.5523085594177246,
-0.7656936645507812,
0.8007845282554626,
0.295317679643631,
0.14847628772258759,
-0.03552677482366562,
0.11654425412416458,
-0.17748595774173737,
-0.03784207999706268,
0.7818493843078613,
0.30861759185791016,
-0.5297231078147888,
-0.5011135339736938,
-0.21180996298789978,
-0.003625980345532298,
0.23235464096069336,
1.0056275129318237,
-1.003720760345459,
0.14566850662231445,
0.15945878624916077,
0.4698014557361603,
0.376718670129776,
-0.045791395008563995,
0.531524658203125,
-1.3445625305175781,
0.4667794108390808,
-0.12758319079875946,
0.3744448721408844,
0.4223402738571167,
-0.5282935500144958,
0.44662097096443176,
0.32243767380714417,
-0.5047302842140198,
-1.0618175268173218,
0.25860458612442017,
-0.5890000462532043,
-0.5122869610786438,
1.0504240989685059,
0.0781063437461853,
-0.36376136541366577,
-0.5427375435829163,
0.03785417601466179,
0.27048957347869873,
-0.1127096638083458,
1.1149958372116089,
0.5899272561073303,
-0.26704922318458557,
0.06182672455906868,
-0.43425557017326355,
0.8438695669174194,
0.08542273938655853,
-0.6599754691123962,
0.03588985279202461,
0.23751778900623322,
0.3520996868610382,
0.010053467936813831,
0.2944079339504242,
-0.04754671826958656,
-0.13407409191131592,
-0.26434895396232605,
-0.16464459896087646,
0.03232080489397049,
-0.5227037072181702,
-0.29733601212501526,
0.494442880153656,
0.15499676764011383,
-0.04746251180768013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21075v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21075v2
|
Video-MME: The First-Ever Comprehensive Evaluation Benchmark of Multi-modal LLMs in Video Analysis
| 2024-05-31T17:59:47
| 2024-06-16T15:49:12
|
Chaoyou Fu, Yuhan Dai, Yongdong Luo, Lei Li, Shuhuai Ren, Renrui Zhang, Zihan Wang, Chenyu Zhou, Yunhang Shen, Mengdan Zhang, Peixian Chen, Yanwei Li, Shaohui Lin, Sirui Zhao, Ke Li, Tong Xu, Xiawu Zheng, Enhong Chen, Rongrong Ji, Xing Sun
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In the quest for artificial general intelligence, Multi-modal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) have emerged as a focal point in recent advancements. However,
the predominant focus remains on developing their capabilities in static image
understanding. The potential of MLLMs in processing sequential visual data is
still insufficiently explored, highlighting the absence of a comprehensive,
high-quality assessment of their performance. In this paper, we introduce
Video-MME, the first-ever full-spectrum, Multi-Modal Evaluation benchmark of
MLLMs in Video analysis. Our work distinguishes from existing benchmarks
through four key features: 1) Diversity in video types, spanning 6 primary
visual domains with 30 subfields to ensure broad scenario generalizability; 2)
Duration in temporal dimension, encompassing both short-, medium-, and
long-term videos, ranging from 11 seconds to 1 hour, for robust contextual
dynamics; 3) Breadth in data modalities, integrating multi-modal inputs besides
video frames, including subtitles and audios, to unveil the all-round
capabilities of MLLMs; 4) Quality in annotations, utilizing rigorous manual
labeling by expert annotators to facilitate precise and reliable model
assessment. 900 videos with a total of 254 hours are manually selected and
annotated by repeatedly viewing all the video content, resulting in 2,700
question-answer pairs. With Video-MME, we extensively evaluate various
state-of-the-art MLLMs, including GPT-4 series and Gemini 1.5 Pro, as well as
open-source image models like InternVL-Chat-V1.5 and video models like
LLaVA-NeXT-Video. Our experiments reveal that Gemini 1.5 Pro is the
best-performing commercial model, significantly outperforming the open-source
models. Our dataset along with these findings underscores the need for further
improvements in handling longer sequences and multi-modal data. Project Page:
https://video-mme.github.io
|
[
-0.6887953877449036,
-0.754657506942749,
0.34131336212158203,
0.22941818833351135,
-0.3873693645000458,
-0.11005555838346481,
-0.22408632934093475,
-0.12044346332550049,
-0.14744439721107483,
0.09646036475896835,
-0.8803572058677673,
-0.5343934893608093,
-0.8431143760681152,
-0.02427743189036846,
-0.6448913812637329,
0.5605304837226868,
0.04798499122262001,
0.2289930284023285,
-0.11522409319877625,
-0.46926239132881165,
-0.3769165873527527,
-0.38215768337249756,
-0.35682761669158936,
0.1955907791852951,
0.36652031540870667,
-0.059123747050762177,
0.6565126180648804,
0.39736393094062805,
0.8012271523475647,
0.4116625487804413,
0.2485196441411972,
0.32037606835365295,
-0.4121255874633789,
-0.20938926935195923,
0.16223016381263733,
0.12639877200126648,
-0.5283563137054443,
0.054303087294101715,
0.8528907299041748,
0.47118502855300903,
0.026975130662322044,
0.6826345324516296,
-0.0714513510465622,
0.5990557670593262,
-0.8753630518913269,
-0.042866162955760956,
-0.5635344982147217,
0.19217167794704437,
-0.1400219053030014,
-0.22127684950828552,
-0.23714718222618103,
0.12687301635742188,
0.16009648144245148,
-0.42824122309684753,
0.07176782190799713,
-0.20713357627391815,
0.649146556854248,
0.5398117899894714,
-0.6231911778450012,
0.09159661084413528,
-0.8522122502326965,
0.7403547167778015,
-0.5711601376533508,
0.9538238048553467,
-0.045984722673892975,
0.7988280057907104,
0.11150028556585312,
-0.73658287525177,
-0.4333239495754242,
-0.4232594668865204,
0.4243800640106201,
0.28057801723480225,
-0.15369844436645508,
0.11764009296894073,
0.3520572781562805,
0.29834237694740295,
-0.7412144541740417,
0.18386909365653992,
-0.3059915006160736,
-0.12469307333230972,
0.5252289772033691,
0.31700214743614197,
0.03349654749035835,
-0.218238964676857,
-0.4494372606277466,
0.017229147255420685,
-0.21662262082099915,
0.3219529688358307,
0.14293208718299866,
-0.22302712500095367,
-0.2767067849636078,
0.7611969113349915,
-0.11793843656778336,
0.5513433814048767,
-0.34636107087135315,
-0.4232269525527954,
0.24290145933628082,
-0.4292190670967102,
-0.8523362278938293,
-0.6068276762962341,
0.8959318995475769,
0.6662872433662415,
0.21634569764137268,
0.10066608339548111,
-0.004782176110893488,
0.2894664704799652,
0.053113069385290146,
-0.9805909395217896,
0.08241081982851028,
0.1606123000383377,
-0.6822587847709656,
0.10058899223804474,
0.26364901661872864,
-0.9272242188453674,
-0.30249258875846863,
-0.5725950598716736,
0.519169270992279,
-0.25560417771339417,
-0.19381573796272278,
0.06558176875114441,
0.04191463068127632,
0.2733994424343109,
0.40193799138069153,
-0.6394864320755005,
0.39002034068107605,
0.6884756088256836,
0.8203338384628296,
-0.2690484821796417,
-0.40049612522125244,
-0.6592371463775635,
0.03941957652568817,
-0.2502697706222534,
0.5560041666030884,
-0.3653971254825592,
-0.20259687304496765,
-0.004822243470698595,
-0.016285879537463188,
-0.0641397163271904,
-0.5174824595451355,
0.5563421845436096,
-0.49688810110092163,
0.1909334361553192,
-0.006937070284038782,
-0.4996486306190491,
-0.32315659523010254,
0.4451100528240204,
-0.6292658448219299,
0.9036096930503845,
-0.29753783345222473,
-0.4912310540676117,
0.6783134341239929,
-0.6914451718330383,
0.13482017815113068,
-0.3775891065597534,
-0.39655280113220215,
-0.2343107908964157,
0.022322935983538628,
0.3486751317977905,
0.3791002035140991,
-0.477419376373291,
0.5124874711036682,
-0.534088134765625,
-0.2937576472759247,
0.33890077471733093,
-1.1503785848617554,
0.20768606662750244,
0.11207745969295502,
-0.2119879126548767,
0.3886353075504303,
-0.8314727544784546,
-0.15715792775154114,
-0.2784542441368103,
-0.07023409754037857,
0.22940181195735931,
0.05126158520579338,
0.09126199036836624,
0.5070087313652039,
0.005256070289760828,
-0.38247984647750854,
-0.03332467004656792,
0.028105631470680237,
0.2043427973985672,
0.9607701301574707,
-0.1767684519290924,
0.12889450788497925,
-0.007931126281619072,
0.38458725810050964,
0.13669617474079132,
0.7287985682487488,
-0.5391222238540649,
-0.40051770210266113,
-0.4585564136505127,
-0.5908804535865784,
0.10578543692827225,
0.6273230910301208,
-0.4540267884731293,
0.031596872955560684,
-0.4041057527065277,
-0.21402929723262787,
-0.5880741477012634,
0.33994945883750916,
0.0982668399810791,
0.24678805470466614,
0.45079323649406433,
-0.33467912673950195,
-0.6206303238868713,
-1.2286492586135864,
0.23943361639976501,
0.16332384943962097,
-0.28192946314811707,
0.5888367891311646,
0.49781474471092224,
-0.3341820240020752,
0.7255093455314636,
-0.2639816105365753,
-0.05549522861838341,
0.22926972806453705,
0.10860509425401688,
0.2985556125640869,
-0.02522451803088188,
0.5066623687744141,
-0.9315410852432251,
-0.36239588260650635,
-0.06891702860593796,
-1.1323144435882568,
0.14653770625591278,
-0.2134937196969986,
0.1440349966287613,
0.04067934304475784,
0.3697454631328583,
-0.5133042335510254,
0.3063279092311859,
0.7717634439468384,
-0.2689850330352783,
0.7715460062026978,
-0.19795848429203033,
0.5997387766838074,
-0.6472435593605042,
0.22618432343006134,
0.16974091529846191,
-0.24072067439556122,
-0.4231483042240143,
-0.11702227592468262,
-0.2043154388666153,
-0.17307493090629578,
-0.6709978580474854,
0.3441164195537567,
-0.3041510283946991,
-0.5366131663322449,
-0.07162763178348541,
0.17721229791641235,
-0.4330511689186096,
0.556657612323761,
-0.2532283663749695,
0.8541712164878845,
0.7865359783172607,
-0.5059242844581604,
0.5514113306999207,
-0.1676027476787567,
-0.4760284423828125,
0.4539187550544739,
-0.5031015872955322,
-0.13082176446914673,
-0.3303774297237396,
-0.15979070961475372,
-0.9633691310882568,
-0.10399987548589706,
-0.04454717040061951,
-0.35423776507377625,
0.08671721816062927,
-0.12017929553985596,
-0.36665430665016174,
-0.4349338412284851,
-0.44731971621513367,
0.3905598819255829,
0.3998585641384125,
-0.3248998820781708,
0.6083361506462097,
0.28140926361083984,
0.058921780437231064,
-0.8671361207962036,
-0.19230571389198303,
0.3761332035064697,
-0.38293153047561646,
-1.0175352096557617,
0.09027322381734848,
-0.451790452003479,
-0.292512446641922,
-0.1162545382976532,
-0.2126747965812683,
-0.2606823444366455,
-0.07109373062849045,
0.23754748702049255,
0.4289800822734833,
-0.3159867823123932,
-0.16334548592567444,
-0.3152981698513031,
-0.19731827080249786,
-0.024647925049066544,
0.10364804416894913,
0.3513149619102478,
-0.18662351369857788,
-0.5584189891815186,
-0.4336719214916229,
0.40561437606811523,
0.9122810363769531,
-0.24166005849838257,
0.3386164605617523,
1.0643627643585205,
-0.2645605206489563,
0.09133291989564896,
-0.8486750721931458,
0.03299238905310631,
-0.48383963108062744,
0.6867793798446655,
-0.33001548051834106,
-0.8870958685874939,
0.39971405267715454,
-0.08206502348184586,
0.14576572179794312,
0.2615275979042053,
0.6379091143608093,
-0.2741990387439728,
1.0365850925445557,
0.5650286674499512,
-0.11010816693305969,
0.5937442183494568,
-0.37112605571746826,
-0.22947779297828674,
-0.535104513168335,
-0.20146937668323517,
0.2523624300956726,
-0.26658186316490173,
-0.5197693109512329,
-0.811561107635498,
0.824710488319397,
-0.04242533817887306,
-0.431501567363739,
-0.16816960275173187,
0.045297373086214066,
0.4073749780654907,
0.07582122832536697,
-0.02677999436855316,
0.22327037155628204,
-0.06052115187048912,
0.02531493827700615,
-0.3754231035709381,
-0.3733825087547302,
-0.5857391953468323,
1.2365318536758423,
0.5384482145309448,
0.5144206881523132,
0.22475509345531464,
0.03311026468873024,
0.6179261207580566,
0.37539950013160706,
-0.6885519027709961,
0.720519483089447,
-0.49772462248802185,
-0.414859414100647,
-0.21292148530483246,
-0.19702576100826263,
-0.7149158120155334,
0.6092857718467712,
-0.39906027913093567,
-0.5846030712127686,
-0.18913914263248444,
-0.09987340867519379,
-0.24051053822040558,
0.3933085501194,
-0.333092600107193,
1.0433193445205688,
-0.46596992015838623,
-0.6248775124549866,
-0.3689905107021332,
-0.6854015588760376,
0.7815694808959961,
0.027689704671502113,
0.5393818020820618,
-0.22728857398033142,
-0.21178601682186127,
0.42557233572006226,
-0.1794491708278656,
0.5026410222053528,
-0.2684892416000366,
0.1644151657819748,
0.3448871374130249,
-0.049747366458177567,
0.010926690883934498,
0.16765832901000977,
0.30323752760887146,
0.04561776667833328,
-0.03931484743952751,
-0.107903853058815,
-0.6344874501228333,
0.4651110768318176,
-0.6729666590690613,
-0.37354832887649536,
-0.07140586525201797,
-0.34191393852233887,
-0.18278102576732635,
0.03861408308148384,
-0.19244736433029175,
0.6961734890937805,
-0.3813640773296356,
0.43270358443260193,
0.5180426836013794,
-0.20562416315078735,
0.7518748044967651,
0.539520800113678,
-0.46954745054244995,
-0.8237379193305969,
0.772676408290863,
-0.018086422234773636,
0.20788894593715668,
0.2591111958026886,
-0.10860628634691238,
-0.21553057432174683,
-0.5692422986030579,
-0.6233682036399841,
-0.010269871912896633,
-0.7110892534255981,
0.01507110707461834,
-0.4740583300590515,
-0.11926155537366867,
-0.14096805453300476,
0.10920602083206177,
-0.5859797596931458,
-0.0025154217146337032,
-0.08120298385620117,
-0.17067217826843262,
-0.19676905870437622,
0.41603004932403564,
-0.006744388956576586,
0.14751122891902924,
-0.9864686727523804,
0.6698024272918701,
0.6260649561882019,
0.43506136536598206,
-0.2635389566421509,
-0.33618518710136414,
-0.14109930396080017,
-0.17523302137851715,
-0.44458526372909546,
-0.810530424118042,
0.2667062282562256,
0.207894429564476,
0.8802785873413086,
0.49564576148986816,
-0.7087907195091248,
0.8705558776855469,
-0.49462997913360596,
1.0376018285751343,
0.2853809893131256,
-0.7955902814865112,
0.3311325013637543,
-0.4500383734703064,
0.0622742623090744,
0.40756136178970337,
0.33983761072158813,
-0.47914400696754456,
0.12951263785362244,
-0.36153021454811096,
-0.7670829892158508,
0.10861838608980179,
0.24760423600673676,
-0.0999642163515091,
0.11357598006725311,
-0.0055889543145895,
0.25193652510643005,
0.4522083103656769,
-0.74317467212677,
-0.30337780714035034,
-0.26603224873542786,
0.07975456863641739,
-0.19137434661388397,
-0.15996718406677246,
-0.06855268031358719,
-0.28888869285583496,
0.3126313090324402,
-0.22978776693344116,
0.1386411339044571,
0.19582802057266235,
-0.3412972688674927,
-0.0068848407827317715,
0.33685606718063354,
0.8546189069747925,
0.770653247833252,
-0.5061930418014526,
-0.10905615985393524,
0.34968051314353943,
-0.2898097634315491,
0.11147035658359528,
0.03719337284564972,
0.06804531812667847,
0.07713859528303146,
0.4187314808368683,
0.8795689344406128,
0.38822659850120544,
-0.9473236203193665,
0.7747241854667664,
0.11077680438756943,
-0.2194465845823288,
-0.42566055059432983,
-0.2729528546333313,
-0.24894648790359497,
0.36535489559173584,
0.3534381687641144,
0.16604666411876678,
0.46045243740081787,
-0.5866750478744507,
0.4371916353702545,
0.6549772620201111,
-0.2056056261062622,
-0.5221683382987976,
0.7864701151847839,
0.17091555893421173,
0.05219273269176483,
0.43527552485466003,
-0.05150819942355156,
-0.15802384912967682,
0.6477310657501221,
0.06353932619094849,
0.9321512579917908,
0.0004206955200061202,
0.2386733889579773,
0.5385211110115051,
0.442362904548645,
0.01258386205881834,
0.3031855523586273,
-0.1229519471526146,
-0.5042435526847839,
-0.7174564003944397,
-0.5316658616065979,
-0.3592095673084259,
0.19996537268161774,
-0.5181140303611755,
0.4839822053909302,
-0.3543414771556854,
-0.35770320892333984,
-0.08338496834039688,
-0.27415961027145386,
-0.9183720946311951,
0.30198514461517334,
0.6958310008049011,
1.0663691759109497,
-0.7590728402137756,
0.814697802066803,
0.3309011459350586,
-0.23353911936283112,
-0.28293856978416443,
-0.6097469925880432,
0.20444729924201965,
-0.5757578015327454,
0.7406906485557556,
0.2598143219947815,
-0.16378924250602722,
-0.31789153814315796,
-0.3614676892757416,
-0.7484182119369507,
1.4328771829605103,
0.2877279222011566,
-0.5046454668045044,
0.030410058796405792,
0.2530879080295563,
0.4488237500190735,
-0.4096607267856598,
0.678269624710083,
0.5811688303947449,
0.5347465872764587,
0.24888351559638977,
-1.120476484298706,
-0.5448050498962402,
-0.2754058241844177,
-0.17301416397094727,
0.18411128222942352,
-0.6386290192604065,
0.8626230359077454,
-0.1766754388809204,
-0.01325506716966629,
0.04756835848093033,
0.6433395743370056,
0.19091659784317017,
0.6431982517242432,
0.5575884580612183,
0.5824004411697388,
0.4601806700229645,
0.07243618369102478,
0.8354355692863464,
-0.17001591622829437,
0.3896181881427765,
1.081452488899231,
-0.11017587780952454,
0.9074698090553284,
0.5938078761100769,
-0.4444471299648285,
0.2939826548099518,
0.39273127913475037,
-0.4050391912460327,
0.4797726571559906,
-0.020169589668512344,
-0.220227912068367,
-0.4312562942504883,
0.007418082095682621,
-0.30759474635124207,
0.5881157517433167,
0.24781207740306854,
-0.36914366483688354,
-0.21316035091876984,
0.1947329193353653,
-0.4586694836616516,
-0.14747460186481476,
-0.48886191844940186,
0.6564111709594727,
-0.11616382002830505,
-0.26967939734458923,
0.30750471353530884,
-0.23368918895721436,
0.8229448795318604,
-0.9186214804649353,
0.14166685938835144,
-0.029589371755719185,
0.029559394344687462,
-0.15786276757717133,
-0.6046290397644043,
0.1881009340286255,
0.177961066365242,
-0.2110166698694229,
0.051815107464790344,
0.4411037266254425,
-0.2657546401023865,
-0.5101081132888794,
0.41462382674217224,
0.6180896759033203,
0.07218518108129501,
-0.09535872936248779,
-0.6926002502441406,
0.23292388021945953,
-0.26979348063468933,
-0.25392189621925354,
0.25435808300971985,
0.16475296020507812,
-0.016896696761250496,
0.8043122887611389,
0.653184175491333,
-0.2503199279308319,
0.4046550691127777,
0.24810603260993958,
0.7784503698348999,
-0.6918286681175232,
-0.12536832690238953,
-1.113252878189087,
0.9760189652442932,
-0.12113615870475769,
-0.15530075132846832,
0.8199654817581177,
0.9357507228851318,
0.6568320393562317,
-0.21174468100070953,
0.6024417877197266,
0.183367058634758,
-0.03052143193781376,
-0.6025424599647522,
0.01792411506175995,
-0.6168127059936523,
0.21732595562934875,
-0.3729405403137207,
-0.9473890662193298,
-0.24262554943561554,
0.23469845950603485,
-0.17442291975021362,
0.015494046732783318,
0.6396623253822327,
0.6442021131515503,
-0.2753690481185913,
-0.010967017151415348,
0.6387299299240112,
0.19240212440490723,
0.5159649848937988,
0.49802789092063904,
0.930962324142456,
-0.5893718600273132,
0.6819576621055603,
-0.262600839138031,
-0.33622148633003235,
0.031023966148495674,
-1.0131182670593262,
-0.7436256408691406,
-0.28620481491088867,
-0.23379437625408173,
0.21101906895637512,
-0.07901551574468613,
1.0569483041763306,
0.8849653005599976,
-0.5643459558486938,
-0.5168503522872925,
0.45487210154533386,
-0.2590464651584625,
-0.31025007367134094,
-0.16911743581295013,
0.1367228478193283,
0.12392062693834305,
-0.6392486095428467,
0.6512976884841919,
0.7267746329307556,
-0.052541375160217285,
-0.5686932802200317,
-0.17795006930828094,
-0.13844919204711914,
0.04985160008072853,
1.039494276046753,
0.07087351381778717,
-0.8853136897087097,
-0.23968757688999176,
0.21453267335891724,
0.04383381828665733,
0.22032026946544647,
1.0096429586410522,
-0.6215642094612122,
0.5572721362113953,
0.3586181402206421,
0.4275335669517517,
0.6680997014045715,
0.01766864024102688,
0.26361939311027527,
-0.46182215213775635,
0.21824415028095245,
0.10823111981153488,
0.5857677459716797,
0.19778046011924744,
0.22038216888904572,
0.5229097008705139,
0.371926486492157,
-0.6061350107192993,
-0.6960363388061523,
0.1323578953742981,
-1.355059027671814,
-0.17542986571788788,
0.9655302166938782,
0.039956558495759964,
0.007633964065462351,
0.2701946198940277,
-0.3814413845539093,
0.08143265545368195,
-0.13368988037109375,
0.5830421447753906,
0.7309679388999939,
-0.061952508985996246,
-0.4259569048881531,
-1.2067713737487793,
0.10557637363672256,
0.25282225012779236,
-0.8027952313423157,
-0.14750030636787415,
0.7874764204025269,
0.30913886427879333,
-0.196216881275177,
0.6591384410858154,
-0.11948122084140778,
0.42403098940849304,
-0.02767384797334671,
-0.2868066728115082,
-0.36971038579940796,
-0.6187002658843994,
-0.4408421218395233,
0.6084436178207397,
-0.2526380717754364,
-0.2542485296726227
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21070v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21070v2
|
Generalization Beyond Data Imbalance: A Controlled Study on CLIP for Transferable Insights
| 2024-05-31T17:57:24
| 2024-06-14T16:42:47
|
Xin Wen, Bingchen Zhao, Yilun Chen, Jiangmiao Pang, Xiaojuan Qi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Severe data imbalance naturally exists among web-scale vision-language
datasets. Despite this, we find CLIP pre-trained thereupon exhibits notable
robustness to the data imbalance compared to supervised learning, and
demonstrates significant effectiveness in learning generalizable
representations. With an aim to investigate the reasons behind this finding, we
conduct controlled experiments to study various underlying factors, and reveal
that CLIP's pretext task forms a dynamic classification problem wherein only a
subset of classes is present in training. This isolates the bias from dominant
classes and implicitly balances the learning signal. Furthermore, the
robustness and discriminability of CLIP improve with more descriptive language
supervision, larger data scale, and broader open-world concepts, which are
inaccessible to supervised learning. Our study not only uncovers the mechanisms
behind CLIP's generalizability beyond data imbalance but also provides
transferable insights for the research community. The findings are validated in
both supervised and self-supervised learning, enabling models trained on
imbalanced data to achieve CLIP-level performance on diverse recognition tasks.
Code and data are available at: https://github.com/CVMI-Lab/clip-beyond-tail.
|
[
-0.43832454085350037,
-0.6402087211608887,
0.22453662753105164,
0.3886285126209259,
-0.1592215895652771,
0.3753293454647064,
-0.2216700166463852,
-0.5776638388633728,
0.5097271203994751,
0.2910609543323517,
-0.5809040665626526,
-0.41585397720336914,
-0.6980446577072144,
0.01031465269625187,
-0.7432732582092285,
0.9694473147392273,
-0.04551063850522041,
0.10845013707876205,
-0.4507211148738861,
-0.48337844014167786,
-0.3719271719455719,
-1.0740666389465332,
-0.06032445654273033,
-0.020412901416420937,
0.05802180618047714,
0.3857705295085907,
0.5013059973716736,
0.7757680416107178,
0.5810949206352234,
0.13405141234397888,
0.2070225030183792,
0.0061235311441123486,
-0.6470919251441956,
-0.3660505414009094,
-0.4979899525642395,
-0.8380774855613708,
-0.39698120951652527,
0.1541328728199005,
0.7457581758499146,
0.6050274968147278,
-0.10666515678167343,
0.09763153642416,
0.40844711661338806,
0.39263254404067993,
-1.0170890092849731,
-0.00275234947912395,
-0.8004379868507385,
0.11107059568166733,
-0.4145453870296478,
-0.11394467204809189,
-0.224837988615036,
-0.09484345465898514,
0.44096553325653076,
-0.870214581489563,
0.5788604617118835,
-0.22935621440410614,
1.0411216020584106,
0.2631617784500122,
-0.2727689743041992,
-0.13974305987358093,
-0.8405376672744751,
1.134028434753418,
-0.14849954843521118,
0.22154803574085236,
0.30248552560806274,
0.41232699155807495,
0.35815149545669556,
-0.597858190536499,
-0.29202985763549805,
0.1977020651102066,
0.3962578773498535,
0.1310874968767166,
-0.38595056533813477,
-0.17411601543426514,
0.3903050422668457,
0.4044190049171448,
-0.06245913729071617,
0.10098183155059814,
-0.31590089201927185,
-0.32388395071029663,
0.3562830686569214,
0.20800672471523285,
0.3910653293132782,
0.39811956882476807,
-0.401287317276001,
-0.5606299042701721,
-0.6354930996894836,
0.3735622763633728,
0.22985252737998962,
0.015639787539839745,
-0.17440950870513916,
0.3080326318740845,
-0.008124912157654762,
0.43804046511650085,
0.21441751718521118,
0.1441890448331833,
0.4499814510345459,
-0.5139358639717102,
0.09494497627019882,
-0.19986921548843384,
0.49922001361846924,
0.7120216488838196,
0.48285675048828125,
-0.1801099181175232,
0.14487768709659576,
0.1312716007232666,
0.5233150124549866,
-0.8365033864974976,
-0.4229900538921356,
-0.23730462789535522,
-0.23881879448890686,
-0.3825249671936035,
0.36079782247543335,
-0.8555774688720703,
0.0033593138214200735,
-0.2293464094400406,
0.4683731198310852,
-0.15964818000793457,
-0.2862359583377838,
0.12623433768749237,
-0.26738664507865906,
0.20182953774929047,
0.40486428141593933,
-1.0204734802246094,
0.36365243792533875,
0.40155649185180664,
0.9714259505271912,
-0.7338128089904785,
-0.402041494846344,
-0.3644667863845825,
0.28160396218299866,
-0.171782448887825,
0.6551535725593567,
-0.5964630842208862,
-0.19408956170082092,
0.04473913460969925,
0.197074756026268,
-0.13817495107650757,
-0.7291370630264282,
0.38045427203178406,
-0.23147381842136383,
-0.0639888271689415,
-0.3371948003768921,
-0.3834741711616516,
-0.16373461484909058,
0.25067138671875,
-0.5699023008346558,
0.6316846013069153,
0.02734350971877575,
-0.8956772089004517,
0.8251111507415771,
-0.2182663381099701,
-0.30519866943359375,
-0.30106112360954285,
-0.3274464011192322,
-0.6220545768737793,
0.09987316280603409,
0.5331467986106873,
0.24519963562488556,
0.11443796008825302,
0.13188956677913666,
-0.7711119651794434,
-0.34883132576942444,
0.36334049701690674,
-0.3158371150493622,
0.605097770690918,
-0.1799909621477127,
-0.2884221374988556,
0.03423388674855232,
-0.5960851907730103,
0.08587639778852463,
0.19085893034934998,
-0.0361652597784996,
-0.5948934555053711,
0.14909783005714417,
-0.05054992437362671,
-0.0732436552643776,
-0.10307396948337555,
-0.5401373505592346,
0.3479105830192566,
-0.10908825695514679,
0.5886499881744385,
0.5840696692466736,
-0.12548400461673737,
0.5206913352012634,
-0.1358070969581604,
0.6223970651626587,
-0.060597557574510574,
0.3228743076324463,
-0.06460630893707275,
-0.07457482814788818,
-0.49289587140083313,
-0.4934288263320923,
0.30012765526771545,
0.7654085755348206,
-0.5119751691818237,
0.08937863260507584,
-0.2812655568122864,
-0.0816592276096344,
-0.32923296093940735,
0.12908503413200378,
0.2036445587873459,
0.544302761554718,
0.7096097469329834,
-0.5895178318023682,
-0.5583812594413757,
-1.0103700160980225,
-0.10498607903718948,
0.27651894092559814,
-0.3130398392677307,
0.30782902240753174,
0.336401104927063,
-0.5279163718223572,
1.3653193712234497,
-0.75938880443573,
-0.44147512316703796,
-0.24352934956550598,
0.17992453277111053,
-0.03978510573506355,
0.6086251139640808,
1.0320967435836792,
-0.9313277006149292,
-0.2612594664096832,
-0.38133254647254944,
-0.7705401182174683,
-0.29391786456108093,
-0.07581426948308945,
-0.1845208704471588,
-0.4363292157649994,
0.554604172706604,
-0.06927447766065598,
0.6357553601264954,
0.41095104813575745,
0.009859133511781693,
0.5785947442054749,
-0.11712759733200073,
0.038073278963565826,
-0.5472561717033386,
0.01638820953667164,
0.02879136987030506,
-0.3124450147151947,
-0.4267899990081787,
-0.2558514475822449,
0.2996388077735901,
-0.12519069015979767,
-0.4706723690032959,
0.07353992760181427,
-0.3132762908935547,
-0.0707876905798912,
-0.48419785499572754,
-0.1890745609998703,
0.2791081964969635,
0.43315234780311584,
0.06723321229219437,
0.9551182985305786,
0.6881231069564819,
-0.8416920900344849,
0.13993151485919952,
0.4021699130535126,
-0.16669127345085144,
0.5473871231079102,
-0.7329898476600647,
-0.19445079565048218,
0.12205100804567337,
0.10531684756278992,
-0.4323960244655609,
-0.2888633608818054,
0.1494600921869278,
-0.2771662771701813,
0.29978805780410767,
-0.24526529014110565,
-0.196088507771492,
-0.3177686929702759,
-0.5993344783782959,
0.7839673161506653,
0.4246309697628021,
-0.6234991550445557,
0.20918218791484833,
0.752952516078949,
0.0792090967297554,
-0.5442072749137878,
-0.8931080102920532,
-0.2270885556936264,
-0.34163418412208557,
-0.22545889019966125,
0.5781075358390808,
-0.035379547625780106,
-0.019133226945996284,
-0.05625424161553383,
-0.31766965985298157,
-0.4858960807323456,
0.1456971913576126,
0.17957837879657745,
0.3238118886947632,
-0.01887074112892151,
0.11689112335443497,
0.21374669671058655,
0.2679903507232666,
0.18292148411273956,
-0.28876686096191406,
0.33915770053863525,
-0.11932945996522903,
-0.38057461380958557,
-0.2256253957748413,
0.0789499282836914,
0.5358367562294006,
-0.29965391755104065,
0.5357910394668579,
0.4471410810947418,
-0.11857938766479492,
-0.2672359347343445,
-0.3748060464859009,
0.013957278802990913,
-0.4382763206958771,
0.4076870083808899,
-0.21278564631938934,
-0.9486099481582642,
0.5529813766479492,
-0.13030514121055603,
0.01586272194981575,
0.3772718906402588,
0.27539458870887756,
-0.1965220868587494,
1.039205551147461,
1.0211001634597778,
-0.12735262513160706,
0.9095651507377625,
-0.4116801619529724,
-0.37027043104171753,
-0.8296571373939514,
-0.128648579120636,
-0.16867896914482117,
-0.21225491166114807,
-0.2993544936180115,
-0.43945083022117615,
0.30210641026496887,
0.42276978492736816,
0.32018497586250305,
0.1794361174106598,
-0.5694109201431274,
0.6273450255393982,
0.4820158779621124,
0.3690952956676483,
0.1577228456735611,
0.05798662081360817,
0.059160854667425156,
-0.32798027992248535,
-0.5123339891433716,
-0.13820797204971313,
1.3413752317428589,
0.3890535533428192,
1.0811442136764526,
-0.22057321667671204,
0.26284345984458923,
0.6672472357749939,
0.02778531238436699,
-0.7495039105415344,
0.2545706629753113,
-0.40926170349121094,
-0.33950066566467285,
-0.1780099719762802,
-0.31663691997528076,
-0.8832233548164368,
0.40428948402404785,
-0.5130456686019897,
-0.5370818972587585,
0.3674490749835968,
0.6202724575996399,
0.08269120752811432,
0.31551292538642883,
-0.6166199445724487,
0.6980093121528625,
-0.4306342303752899,
-0.5237098336219788,
-0.3403779864311218,
-0.49344682693481445,
0.2842792272567749,
-0.2481973022222519,
0.08781422674655914,
-0.10861779004335403,
-0.02299112267792225,
0.8044553995132446,
-0.5183430314064026,
0.9244512915611267,
-0.07634060084819794,
0.1439448446035385,
0.3920995593070984,
-0.23877188563346863,
0.1558295339345932,
-0.06535675376653671,
0.5905315279960632,
0.35465335845947266,
0.07824447005987167,
-0.6267108917236328,
-0.7169098258018494,
0.2553766965866089,
-0.6878683567047119,
-0.4158109128475189,
-0.2434847503900528,
-0.4126822352409363,
-0.3596341907978058,
0.23009401559829712,
0.5701010227203369,
0.6033215522766113,
-0.242869034409523,
0.3612034320831299,
0.8002634048461914,
-0.1229715645313263,
0.06845586001873016,
0.3053866922855377,
-0.43566957116127014,
-0.45903462171554565,
1.1387346982955933,
0.2647930979728699,
0.3578866422176361,
0.42050161957740784,
0.09233856946229935,
-0.02045348472893238,
-0.682293713092804,
-0.3807108700275421,
-0.03778883442282677,
-0.5150925517082214,
0.014676415361464024,
-0.5432438850402832,
-0.04100656509399414,
-0.26935335993766785,
-0.16244518756866455,
-0.42072343826293945,
-0.4980749785900116,
-0.4800316095352173,
-0.21574139595031738,
0.035643238574266434,
0.5228919982910156,
-0.16062690317630768,
0.40479332208633423,
-0.7306025624275208,
0.2609858810901642,
0.5412828326225281,
0.21151304244995117,
-0.10718264430761337,
-0.24344533681869507,
-0.38525357842445374,
0.11988509446382523,
-0.4358266592025757,
-0.6744120121002197,
0.2072419673204422,
0.5614529252052307,
0.7723948359489441,
0.598811686038971,
0.027253197506070137,
0.6752130389213562,
-0.38957953453063965,
0.5095977783203125,
0.3904053866863251,
-1.2519723176956177,
0.6240949034690857,
-0.27547720074653625,
0.4010533392429352,
0.7205318212509155,
0.4397817552089691,
-0.039896588772535324,
-0.5515866279602051,
-0.34082111716270447,
-0.9905758500099182,
0.6481724381446838,
0.1370915323495865,
0.1784442812204361,
0.21284006536006927,
0.16017025709152222,
0.2702830135822296,
0.25203341245651245,
-0.6599176526069641,
0.03841131925582886,
-0.764189600944519,
-0.14945214986801147,
0.07901989668607712,
-0.30459290742874146,
-0.026096297428011894,
-0.3995514512062073,
0.09206508100032806,
-0.2880253493785858,
0.09398967027664185,
0.32363539934158325,
-0.6073837876319885,
0.24194446206092834,
0.05688958242535591,
0.5716300010681152,
0.8966274857521057,
-0.3253560960292816,
0.16262058913707733,
0.289964884519577,
-1.0216400623321533,
0.026770789176225662,
-0.18226611614227295,
-0.3908134400844574,
-0.09328983724117279,
0.607733428478241,
0.7616584897041321,
0.3358628749847412,
-0.8633763790130615,
0.9649014472961426,
-0.07195831835269928,
-0.26294171810150146,
-0.12163451313972473,
0.17840906977653503,
-0.6879910230636597,
0.10507417470216751,
0.5421181917190552,
0.06148233637213707,
0.23505939543247223,
-0.533549964427948,
0.4595983922481537,
0.585959255695343,
-0.3374638855457306,
-0.694379448890686,
0.6682703495025635,
0.25653937458992004,
0.35973116755485535,
0.5088425874710083,
0.21116390824317932,
-0.8126737475395203,
0.5641584992408752,
0.49883362650871277,
0.6049216389656067,
-0.01016988605260849,
0.1856454312801361,
0.19384334981441498,
0.17736300826072693,
-0.22480420768260956,
-0.1863304078578949,
-0.4637446999549866,
-0.8207701444625854,
-0.3605065941810608,
-0.2768951952457428,
-0.8459300398826599,
-0.1195041611790657,
-1.2179853916168213,
0.24628424644470215,
-0.63047194480896,
-0.36807486414909363,
-0.2103760540485382,
-0.5622351169586182,
-0.521980345249176,
0.13044704496860504,
-0.030807817354798317,
0.7776088118553162,
-0.9096070528030396,
0.7941697835922241,
0.6567274928092957,
-0.30322718620300293,
-0.38200613856315613,
0.2586895525455475,
-0.2459033876657486,
-0.7804902195930481,
0.5652195811271667,
0.4290083348751068,
-0.3614919185638428,
-0.3445366621017456,
-1.0643082857131958,
-0.9579253792762756,
0.8388233780860901,
0.4999847412109375,
-0.41403400897979736,
-0.17337536811828613,
0.009827216155827045,
0.4798088073730469,
-0.2580466568470001,
0.005207644309848547,
0.3575354516506195,
-0.1463615894317627,
0.18507519364356995,
-0.9959949254989624,
-0.37356579303741455,
-0.03887563943862915,
-0.28516852855682373,
0.19397859275341034,
-0.6479195356369019,
0.898765504360199,
-0.0925719141960144,
-0.27650704979896545,
-0.3938367962837219,
0.6446276903152466,
-0.15352988243103027,
0.49135729670524597,
0.37883856892585754,
0.5959826111793518,
0.7234744429588318,
0.07055322825908661,
0.7398490309715271,
0.15824168920516968,
0.4390370845794678,
1.1686370372772217,
-0.10477742552757263,
0.6009184122085571,
0.3490998148918152,
-0.34021130204200745,
0.42660748958587646,
0.26224538683891296,
-0.4897081255912781,
0.8373667597770691,
0.14412851631641388,
0.02185245044529438,
-0.4081863760948181,
-0.1630014181137085,
-0.36125850677490234,
0.468747615814209,
0.3496406674385071,
-0.20218424499034882,
-0.19131805002689362,
0.6155040860176086,
-0.16390953958034515,
0.05992890149354935,
-0.7485957741737366,
0.5289962291717529,
-0.060725849121809006,
-0.1960970163345337,
0.5072832703590393,
-0.4440484642982483,
1.010204553604126,
-0.6866785883903503,
-0.1309560090303421,
0.14910313487052917,
0.3562774360179901,
-0.2979332208633423,
-0.936109721660614,
0.5667195916175842,
0.050839170813560486,
-0.45644548535346985,
-0.3710178732872009,
0.7497054934501648,
-0.23546044528484344,
-0.3366657793521881,
0.304645299911499,
0.2017771303653717,
0.08310430496931076,
-0.2625783681869507,
-0.35412830114364624,
0.14398491382598877,
0.14730270206928253,
0.23516996204853058,
0.5638935565948486,
0.331583172082901,
-0.383963018655777,
0.8400143980979919,
0.33883771300315857,
0.045897357165813446,
0.3440376818180084,
-0.20906195044517517,
0.9762317538261414,
-0.566680908203125,
-0.5610306262969971,
-0.8086333274841309,
0.04074990749359131,
-0.17735475301742554,
-0.2406066209077835,
0.7884588241577148,
0.6193748712539673,
1.1070131063461304,
-0.3088005483150482,
0.7895528078079224,
0.15687870979309082,
0.710746169090271,
-0.6499375104904175,
0.4667550027370453,
-0.4796830415725708,
-0.07147488743066788,
-0.44215476512908936,
-0.7735944986343384,
-0.33939844369888306,
0.44182929396629333,
-0.42563173174858093,
-0.44406917691230774,
0.4913199543952942,
0.10083222389221191,
-0.29300737380981445,
-0.2352575659751892,
0.10461093485355377,
-0.1557249277830124,
0.33984267711639404,
0.5644314885139465,
0.8670030236244202,
0.06944980472326279,
0.9283705353736877,
-0.2780025899410248,
-0.4442402422428131,
-0.24981079995632172,
-0.7076504826545715,
-1.0627727508544922,
-0.3286018371582031,
-0.3477948307991028,
-0.033233582973480225,
-0.08284106105566025,
0.5820714831352234,
0.8209459781646729,
-0.878542423248291,
-0.12819421291351318,
-0.10639498382806778,
0.08967732638120651,
-0.12943504750728607,
-0.2384694516658783,
0.2513597905635834,
-0.12086017429828644,
-0.6783277988433838,
0.14096097648143768,
0.13445834815502167,
0.4000093638896942,
0.06659671664237976,
0.40877220034599304,
0.26325565576553345,
-0.1741195023059845,
0.5315296649932861,
0.7813264727592468,
-0.334693044424057,
-0.1717052310705185,
0.028726743534207344,
0.10177472978830338,
0.34915784001350403,
1.096487045288086,
-0.8042653799057007,
0.434894859790802,
0.32120105624198914,
0.8453999161720276,
0.6718239784240723,
0.41967400908470154,
0.730331301689148,
-0.6629127860069275,
0.32751068472862244,
0.1667756289243698,
0.22371871769428253,
0.18014830350875854,
-0.23211534321308136,
0.45429059863090515,
0.49004271626472473,
-0.28297021985054016,
-0.7576034665107727,
0.33229413628578186,
-1.0602388381958008,
-0.2070143222808838,
0.6933384537696838,
-0.3258277475833893,
-0.05209396779537201,
0.03395044058561325,
-0.17442822456359863,
0.09623605757951736,
-0.29594096541404724,
0.641059160232544,
0.653327226638794,
-0.34577667713165283,
-0.09539293497800827,
-0.27516162395477295,
0.4576531648635864,
0.49003177881240845,
-0.7783756256103516,
-0.11465990543365479,
0.49534958600997925,
0.4156412184238434,
0.14703576266765594,
0.4001135528087616,
-0.04204535111784935,
0.1456868201494217,
-0.20820404589176178,
-0.009343636222183704,
-0.09043462574481964,
-0.4283754229545593,
-0.4076143503189087,
0.2563283443450928,
-0.0862380638718605,
-0.6726694107055664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21068v1
|
Code Pretraining Improves Entity Tracking Abilities of Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:56:33
| 2024-05-31T17:56:33
|
Najoung Kim, Sebastian Schuster, Shubham Toshniwal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent work has provided indirect evidence that pretraining language models
on code improves the ability of models to track state changes of discourse
entities expressed in natural language. In this work, we systematically test
this claim by comparing pairs of language models on their entity tracking
performance. Critically, the pairs consist of base models and models trained on
top of these base models with additional code data. We extend this analysis to
additionally examine the effect of math training, another highly structured
data type, and alignment tuning, an important step for enhancing the usability
of models. We find clear evidence that models additionally trained on large
amounts of code outperform the base models. On the other hand, we find no
consistent benefit of additional math training or alignment tuning across
various model families.
|
[
-0.19010332226753235,
-0.44734516739845276,
0.3808867633342743,
0.009509067982435226,
-0.22058378159999847,
0.21451103687286377,
-0.18753692507743835,
-0.5770461559295654,
0.141865074634552,
0.5703750252723694,
-0.05214003846049309,
-0.44669175148010254,
-0.39809203147888184,
-0.1438247412443161,
-0.5212985873222351,
1.159680724143982,
0.002031709300354123,
0.34638288617134094,
-0.3108377158641815,
-0.1372727006673813,
-0.4652567207813263,
-1.0060895681381226,
-0.29733556509017944,
-0.3172776997089386,
0.3509139120578766,
-0.08778408169746399,
0.9863694310188293,
0.8230635523796082,
0.7827340960502625,
0.3240295350551605,
0.17961032688617706,
-0.2360309511423111,
-0.508651614189148,
0.03944068029522896,
-0.058830708265304565,
-0.846877932548523,
-0.6225358247756958,
0.01639600843191147,
0.6561634540557861,
0.8289035558700562,
-0.38145697116851807,
0.25823312997817993,
-0.02321891114115715,
0.6701802611351013,
-0.8149730563163757,
0.0827237069606781,
-0.5374931693077087,
-0.24846947193145752,
-0.4316476583480835,
-0.30975157022476196,
-0.5103741884231567,
-0.535068154335022,
0.29155710339546204,
-0.8084056377410889,
0.1276753842830658,
0.18439660966396332,
1.1811639070510864,
0.4158868193626404,
-0.4788723587989807,
-0.37170469760894775,
-0.6310741305351257,
0.6312415599822998,
-0.7129758596420288,
0.6749950647354126,
0.4195038974285126,
-0.21920771896839142,
0.08569005131721497,
-0.7327038049697876,
-0.3168485164642334,
-0.36320188641548157,
-0.20220863819122314,
-0.07055238634347916,
-0.132409006357193,
0.16489370167255402,
0.7310998439788818,
0.4194628894329071,
-0.48793014883995056,
0.10737334191799164,
-0.1565110683441162,
-0.3059539198875427,
0.3991767168045044,
-0.043984800577163696,
0.7134823799133301,
0.07521700114011765,
-0.09724642336368561,
-0.08432678878307343,
-0.9256316423416138,
0.12366922944784164,
0.6545549035072327,
0.048416223376989365,
-0.09976436197757721,
0.5205309987068176,
0.11121917515993118,
0.9489411115646362,
-0.22410516440868378,
-0.029923273250460625,
0.2255975902080536,
-0.49282515048980713,
-0.2589315176010132,
-0.11225352436304092,
0.37330618500709534,
0.18581151962280273,
0.7048604488372803,
-0.23765863478183746,
-0.26317206025123596,
0.4855877161026001,
0.42462649941444397,
-0.8707661628723145,
-0.6720377802848816,
-0.46800482273101807,
-0.45668551325798035,
-0.12700586020946503,
0.13280414044857025,
-0.2927156090736389,
0.043233100324869156,
-0.8923740983009338,
0.15012812614440918,
-0.4658123552799225,
-0.42587894201278687,
0.29232221841812134,
0.10412095487117767,
0.1877758502960205,
0.20286281406879425,
-1.0507187843322754,
0.3759024143218994,
1.0411264896392822,
0.7950723171234131,
-0.14882168173789978,
-0.06659451127052307,
-0.6386894583702087,
-0.00850842148065567,
-0.5828362703323364,
0.8632439374923706,
-0.7639332413673401,
-0.09238344430923462,
-0.014435282908380032,
-0.3212049901485443,
-0.18885527551174164,
-0.5270628929138184,
0.24176158010959625,
-0.7412660121917725,
0.06749435514211655,
-0.22680577635765076,
-0.8520333766937256,
0.10597044974565506,
-0.11524179577827454,
-0.7913198471069336,
1.0468785762786865,
0.12874530255794525,
-0.7865328192710876,
0.6061624884605408,
-0.4383111000061035,
-0.48301970958709717,
-0.10861054062843323,
-0.23859207332134247,
-0.6278111338615417,
0.4465865194797516,
0.04590547829866409,
-0.04373002424836159,
0.0030648065730929375,
0.45877721905708313,
-0.5343936681747437,
-0.5818361043930054,
0.22442635893821716,
0.0461721234023571,
0.7504934668540955,
0.06398545205593109,
-0.1889379620552063,
-0.08501545339822769,
-0.7480509281158447,
0.1874740719795227,
-0.12234514206647873,
-0.5740054249763489,
-0.7079675197601318,
0.0687684416770935,
-0.15291838347911835,
0.13557074964046478,
-0.14447447657585144,
-0.24908185005187988,
0.3786238133907318,
-0.41964027285575867,
0.012455201707780361,
0.5598505735397339,
-0.18624244630336761,
0.8213343024253845,
-0.14041876792907715,
0.7363454699516296,
-0.13032056391239166,
-0.29211705923080444,
-0.45391491055488586,
-0.329169362783432,
-0.8304776549339294,
-0.04502887278795242,
0.898356556892395,
0.4975222647190094,
-0.6853620409965515,
0.3412259817123413,
-0.38936880230903625,
-0.13184252381324768,
-0.6733928918838501,
0.2478470504283905,
0.8199360370635986,
0.38513121008872986,
0.37538135051727295,
-0.693200409412384,
-0.7821168899536133,
-0.5523754954338074,
-0.6930752396583557,
-0.16456016898155212,
-0.1313590705394745,
0.11287270486354828,
0.5986379981040955,
0.16771112382411957,
0.8194282054901123,
-0.5250779390335083,
0.1645265817642212,
0.045313622802495956,
0.13177643716335297,
-0.2574411630630493,
0.8146485090255737,
0.8198620676994324,
-0.5326555967330933,
-0.5261507034301758,
-0.31131038069725037,
-0.6145362854003906,
-0.12930157780647278,
0.16035179793834686,
-0.4762183725833893,
0.25422561168670654,
0.36110323667526245,
-0.43835073709487915,
0.7507986426353455,
0.5125799179077148,
-0.38558146357536316,
0.2975957989692688,
-0.07058499753475189,
0.1809893548488617,
-0.8475548624992371,
0.12059787660837173,
-0.08950179815292358,
-0.33917805552482605,
-0.7628188729286194,
-0.03391934186220169,
0.32361453771591187,
-0.18360312283039093,
-0.23928102850914001,
0.21029409766197205,
-0.721333920955658,
-0.4742473065853119,
-0.1595565229654312,
-0.13270406424999237,
-0.036074597388505936,
0.4097265899181366,
0.2710181474685669,
0.9463860392570496,
0.5722234845161438,
-0.7218120098114014,
0.02777680568397045,
0.15409646928310394,
-0.7294926643371582,
0.5340502858161926,
-0.6677656173706055,
0.5381746888160706,
-0.03801906853914261,
0.10854235291481018,
-0.7728436589241028,
-0.018740622326731682,
-0.246799498796463,
-0.5343139171600342,
0.5126927495002747,
-0.3430703282356262,
-0.3807046115398407,
-0.08598077297210693,
-0.05020333081483841,
0.2728933095932007,
0.4343833923339844,
-0.3564488887786865,
0.5159450173377991,
0.5110547542572021,
0.13315469026565552,
-0.5365632176399231,
-0.6152375936508179,
-0.13287094235420227,
-0.11708979308605194,
-0.5130265951156616,
0.27175939083099365,
-0.03267107903957367,
-0.3624587059020996,
0.03838062286376953,
-0.3853132128715515,
-0.30851539969444275,
0.5518691539764404,
0.09219976514577866,
0.5387063026428223,
-0.690413773059845,
0.34675997495651245,
-0.16047202050685883,
-0.3142912983894348,
0.18695181608200073,
-0.47699636220932007,
0.5629051327705383,
0.10096973180770874,
-0.31112298369407654,
-0.4872141182422638,
0.16370341181755066,
-0.02480386570096016,
-0.615778386592865,
0.9037818908691406,
0.17929407954216003,
-0.44618216156959534,
0.05192224681377411,
-0.4697103798389435,
-0.023958858102560043,
-0.45645880699157715,
0.3303954303264618,
-0.44278213381767273,
-0.9054219126701355,
0.15824203193187714,
-0.006517902947962284,
0.11157025396823883,
0.2028157263994217,
0.2245805263519287,
-0.18461251258850098,
1.3930325508117676,
1.04831063747406,
-0.19662757217884064,
0.8820884227752686,
-0.034623801708221436,
0.18982894718647003,
-0.6035024523735046,
0.058425962924957275,
-0.9653844237327576,
-0.11373830586671829,
-0.5630841851234436,
-0.14432692527770996,
-0.08337405323982239,
0.42307552695274353,
-0.22536709904670715,
0.5220663547515869,
-0.26682257652282715,
0.7756407856941223,
0.45006006956100464,
-0.1040884330868721,
0.45224422216415405,
0.07618871331214905,
0.04263319447636604,
-0.35985735058784485,
-0.5091533064842224,
-0.5535406470298767,
1.3758078813552856,
0.12555167078971863,
1.0355619192123413,
0.17399314045906067,
0.6119892001152039,
-0.14111734926700592,
0.6768338084220886,
-0.3590291440486908,
0.13840995728969574,
-0.08469758182764053,
-0.7319692969322205,
-0.06545790284872055,
-0.6267473101615906,
-0.6967228651046753,
0.12267004698514938,
-0.33847567439079285,
-0.6548621654510498,
-0.023909863084554672,
0.6373330354690552,
-0.4187547266483307,
0.15105177462100983,
-0.8780745267868042,
0.864052951335907,
-0.478013813495636,
-0.15993212163448334,
-0.20161084830760956,
-0.3659392297267914,
0.26179030537605286,
-0.13185229897499084,
0.02522413618862629,
-0.028088480234146118,
-0.0010201879777014256,
0.8454961776733398,
-0.2989982068538666,
0.5000290870666504,
-0.15522387623786926,
-0.2019861936569214,
0.17427298426628113,
0.1742118000984192,
0.36637091636657715,
0.10708081722259521,
0.0593440942466259,
0.05060804262757301,
-0.10846792906522751,
-0.5059572458267212,
-0.7260630130767822,
0.5781123638153076,
-0.5989634990692139,
-0.5432687997817993,
-0.18342988193035126,
-0.4590044617652893,
-0.24599824845790863,
0.29524141550064087,
0.3083837926387787,
0.5491741299629211,
-0.025966281071305275,
0.3395916819572449,
0.9250803589820862,
0.010071858763694763,
0.39705607295036316,
0.5652396082878113,
-0.5273277759552002,
-0.10147486627101898,
0.4820196032524109,
0.16690219938755035,
0.4236154854297638,
0.48298004269599915,
-0.3752976357936859,
-0.19559846818447113,
-0.3727720081806183,
-0.37991955876350403,
0.21984730660915375,
-0.4786805808544159,
-0.24586163461208344,
-0.7004004716873169,
0.03295399993658066,
-0.5403716564178467,
0.03910211846232414,
-0.5305204391479492,
-0.4496966600418091,
-0.2033585160970688,
-0.1264987736940384,
-0.026367608457803726,
0.758392333984375,
0.37870773673057556,
0.48036932945251465,
-0.6495546698570251,
0.1321704089641571,
0.16405647993087769,
0.6452996730804443,
-0.19181235134601593,
-0.4725516140460968,
-0.5007354617118835,
0.14477688074111938,
-0.13674508035182953,
-0.8382506966590881,
0.14144323766231537,
0.2167505919933319,
0.4066207706928253,
0.1764165759086609,
-0.4399424195289612,
1.0887647867202759,
-0.5292651057243347,
0.49107950925827026,
0.2998563349246979,
-1.3895680904388428,
0.6575055122375488,
-0.08468607068061829,
0.41204890608787537,
0.5718504190444946,
0.4181114733219147,
-0.19228270649909973,
-0.26252442598342896,
-0.4658636748790741,
-0.27263617515563965,
0.73198401927948,
0.27096787095069885,
0.1360519528388977,
0.26534464955329895,
0.5083994269371033,
-0.259931743144989,
0.38980504870414734,
-0.7758443355560303,
-0.4249720573425293,
-0.1036892831325531,
-0.07995365560054779,
-0.2111666351556778,
-0.2609391212463379,
0.13072249293327332,
-0.36927515268325806,
0.4567521810531616,
-0.12216509878635406,
0.1732388287782669,
-0.19697968661785126,
-0.6729533672332764,
-0.25694146752357483,
0.001402645604684949,
0.5714080929756165,
1.0406420230865479,
0.10240131616592407,
0.09510631114244461,
0.13898861408233643,
-0.46230828762054443,
0.09945274889469147,
-0.012991044670343399,
-0.318172812461853,
0.15258462727069855,
0.6407648921012878,
0.9779869914054871,
0.6419793963432312,
-0.3642294406890869,
0.5131840705871582,
-0.036281831562519073,
-0.0793127566576004,
-0.14248555898666382,
0.3647681772708893,
0.24990327656269073,
-0.18764732778072357,
-0.09634863585233688,
0.3184016942977905,
0.07731843739748001,
-0.5697013735771179,
0.2699548602104187,
0.36011603474617004,
-0.3332180976867676,
-0.6854248642921448,
0.6250247359275818,
0.08725780993700027,
-0.6068167686462402,
0.698567807674408,
0.07615077495574951,
-0.6320204138755798,
0.7244932055473328,
0.7754424810409546,
0.3986433148384094,
-0.5831526517868042,
-0.07163027673959732,
0.36209264397621155,
0.29315507411956787,
-0.1325986534357071,
0.15858758985996246,
-0.1625784933567047,
-0.7638266086578369,
-0.7614047527313232,
-0.4862126111984253,
-0.09662613272666931,
-0.1690356433391571,
-0.9996145963668823,
0.3454352617263794,
-0.20413941144943237,
-0.2765335440635681,
0.13148687779903412,
-0.020672673359513283,
-0.8795491456985474,
0.21446041762828827,
0.40741249918937683,
0.8045438528060913,
-0.7230812907218933,
1.2221972942352295,
0.9605582356452942,
-0.4338078796863556,
-1.084934115409851,
-0.03999001532793045,
-0.1286734789609909,
-0.6265184879302979,
0.5930877327919006,
0.2698841392993927,
-0.06872081756591797,
0.16534465551376343,
-0.6658511161804199,
-1.3797998428344727,
0.6872656345367432,
0.7185584902763367,
-0.7590450644493103,
-0.3180687427520752,
-0.05301898717880249,
0.7876193523406982,
-0.47524890303611755,
0.420061856508255,
0.7836548686027527,
0.05825192108750343,
-0.3201649487018585,
-1.0719048976898193,
-0.33498483896255493,
-0.2671082615852356,
0.2552235424518585,
0.6019951105117798,
-0.19930283725261688,
0.8591110706329346,
-0.143464595079422,
-0.45050713419914246,
-0.12015494704246521,
0.8296205401420593,
0.021004818379878998,
0.1650090366601944,
0.6548821926116943,
0.9152762293815613,
0.9906606078147888,
-0.23583054542541504,
1.053804636001587,
-0.5205557346343994,
0.5001688003540039,
1.3261559009552002,
-0.5412377715110779,
0.6946238279342651,
0.18931178748607635,
-0.19958898425102234,
0.8915621042251587,
0.3169505298137665,
0.17318879067897797,
0.3974853754043579,
0.34904399514198303,
0.025534894317388535,
-0.4210575819015503,
-0.02964070439338684,
-0.7019057273864746,
0.3092520534992218,
0.11034322530031204,
-0.265241414308548,
0.06493330001831055,
-0.02824043668806553,
0.25158318877220154,
0.24382032454013824,
-0.2749772369861603,
0.7681977152824402,
0.1474689394235611,
-1.121380090713501,
0.26235780119895935,
-0.2237655371427536,
0.5684497356414795,
-0.47081199288368225,
-0.11094943434000015,
-0.2649996280670166,
0.2376854419708252,
-0.19339731335639954,
-0.4002784490585327,
0.34308111667633057,
0.27726471424102783,
-0.007365276105701923,
-0.22068482637405396,
0.7892260551452637,
-0.3755795657634735,
-0.19536897540092468,
0.3831825852394104,
0.45521339774131775,
-0.10821002721786499,
0.03713330999016762,
-0.7015637159347534,
0.017803804948925972,
0.05203469842672348,
-0.3784380555152893,
0.4217323064804077,
0.15153901278972626,
-0.06688312441110611,
0.5718472599983215,
0.9787973761558533,
0.10805897414684296,
0.3250197470188141,
0.17872419953346252,
0.8941650390625,
-0.6274779438972473,
-0.6629485487937927,
-0.97523432970047,
0.4106268882751465,
-0.19479268789291382,
-0.37228307127952576,
0.6483089327812195,
0.9072381258010864,
1.1698533296585083,
0.11285935342311859,
0.33512672781944275,
0.1002395823597908,
0.5565454363822937,
-0.7392447590827942,
0.4141053855419159,
-0.15489009022712708,
0.4417746365070343,
-0.2867765426635742,
-1.110816240310669,
-0.33088570833206177,
0.6247550249099731,
-0.43523338437080383,
0.06590242683887482,
0.8473244905471802,
0.5743312835693359,
-0.15828531980514526,
0.003559109754860401,
0.14669175446033478,
-0.16348578035831451,
0.22276240587234497,
0.3489961624145508,
0.9974527359008789,
-0.3508918881416321,
0.4144902229309082,
-0.3986073434352875,
0.010661548934876919,
0.17739805579185486,
-0.7276710867881775,
-1.0610289573669434,
-0.3307611644268036,
-0.4165002703666687,
-0.42500561475753784,
0.037909429520368576,
0.6989630460739136,
1.0332694053649902,
-0.9207173585891724,
-0.211981862783432,
-0.11864358931779861,
0.08550526201725006,
0.0937323048710823,
-0.1412026435136795,
0.1709338128566742,
-0.5031247138977051,
-0.592060923576355,
0.07366547733545303,
0.17537814378738403,
0.09651979804039001,
0.04376057907938957,
-0.08979357033967972,
-0.3123791813850403,
0.13863307237625122,
0.28696849942207336,
0.07246270775794983,
-0.4051942229270935,
-0.2500975728034973,
0.289451539516449,
-0.39384934306144714,
0.2316064089536667,
1.36609947681427,
-0.7014090418815613,
0.298299103975296,
0.3985571563243866,
0.5940980911254883,
0.45728957653045654,
0.3062300980091095,
0.7389310002326965,
-0.6410818696022034,
0.2581808865070343,
0.023545686155557632,
0.4877636134624481,
0.23876890540122986,
-0.3145398795604706,
0.6544222831726074,
0.2018732875585556,
-0.5888404250144958,
-1.0313900709152222,
0.240831658244133,
-0.37142589688301086,
0.05251363292336464,
0.6955678462982178,
-0.5742781758308411,
-0.1248997375369072,
-0.07009098678827286,
0.17568914592266083,
0.39505210518836975,
-0.13988478481769562,
0.5178569555282593,
0.8877918124198914,
0.020171448588371277,
0.07862955331802368,
-0.5923389792442322,
0.7708712816238403,
0.7634298801422119,
-0.9467946290969849,
-0.31946590542793274,
0.4343087375164032,
0.3926737606525421,
0.1695491373538971,
0.7854280471801758,
0.09226151555776596,
0.351765900850296,
-0.18157349526882172,
0.14052070677280426,
0.16042378544807434,
-0.38033327460289,
-0.5860247611999512,
-0.1768229603767395,
0.05006163939833641,
0.058708202093839645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21047v1
|
Grammar-Aligned Decoding
| 2024-05-31T17:39:15
| 2024-05-31T17:39:15
|
Kanghee Park, Jiayu Wang, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick, Nadia Polikarpova, Loris D'Antoni
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) struggle with reliably generating highly
structured outputs, such as program code, mathematical formulas, or well-formed
markup. Constrained decoding approaches mitigate this problem by greedily
restricting what tokens an LLM can output at each step to guarantee that the
output matches a given constraint. Specifically, in grammar-constrained
decoding (GCD), the LLM's output must follow a given grammar. In this paper we
demonstrate that GCD techniques (and in general constrained decoding
techniques) can distort the LLM's distribution, leading to outputs that are
grammatical but appear with likelihoods that are not proportional to the ones
given by the LLM, and so ultimately are low-quality. We call the problem of
aligning sampling with a grammar constraint, grammar-aligned decoding (GAD),
and propose adaptive sampling with approximate expected futures (ASAp), a
decoding algorithm that guarantees the output to be grammatical while provably
producing outputs that match the conditional probability of the LLM's
distribution conditioned on the given grammar constraint. Our algorithm uses
prior sample outputs to soundly overapproximate the future grammaticality of
different output prefixes. Our evaluation on code generation and structured NLP
tasks shows how ASAp often produces outputs with higher likelihood (according
to the LLM's distribution) than existing GCD techniques, while still enforcing
the desired grammatical constraints.
|
[
-0.0258935559540987,
-0.5887694358825684,
0.6275027990341187,
0.23865363001823425,
-0.18245206773281097,
-0.002848599571734667,
-0.21066056191921234,
-0.2787007689476013,
0.28508898615837097,
0.25804078578948975,
-0.8869822025299072,
-0.5642402172088623,
-0.5017787218093872,
0.14748750627040863,
-0.3271399140357971,
0.7248453497886658,
0.04271325469017029,
-0.060747068375349045,
-0.5712988972663879,
0.2032575011253357,
-0.4837602972984314,
-0.8267966508865356,
-0.3199535310268402,
-0.1648097038269043,
-0.19810107350349426,
0.3117064833641052,
0.8538738489151001,
1.0203619003295898,
0.400370717048645,
0.31581494212150574,
-0.04663703590631485,
0.2592499852180481,
-0.4413098096847534,
0.07783030718564987,
-0.0739186629652977,
-0.23716998100280762,
-0.4555004835128784,
-0.02186581678688526,
0.7461076378822327,
0.7159603834152222,
-0.3274765908718109,
0.02935388870537281,
0.16951029002666473,
0.46566691994667053,
-0.9170472025871277,
0.24944522976875305,
-0.4228205680847168,
-0.07880765199661255,
-0.17814704775810242,
-0.18439853191375732,
-0.6467071175575256,
-0.24208427965641022,
-0.689822256565094,
-0.739736020565033,
0.08766104280948639,
-0.05562807247042656,
0.9635075330734253,
0.5024042725563049,
-0.3026304244995117,
-0.5967061519622803,
-0.7580063343048096,
0.8167858719825745,
-0.7399070262908936,
0.14911627769470215,
0.5170488357543945,
0.10360904037952423,
-0.39187493920326233,
-0.41129347681999207,
-0.513147234916687,
0.3276306688785553,
-0.08443518728017807,
0.18091519176959991,
-0.14704033732414246,
0.30024048686027527,
0.2303423136472702,
0.4683716893196106,
-0.5794869661331177,
0.17304840683937073,
-0.08901005238294601,
-0.20157785713672638,
0.5126007199287415,
0.13623419404029846,
0.08008978515863419,
-0.38696223497390747,
-0.13522449135780334,
-0.2645377814769745,
-0.5663193464279175,
-0.025378886610269547,
0.7010737061500549,
0.25444382429122925,
-0.0060462960973382,
0.7359014749526978,
-0.27010640501976013,
0.8309523463249207,
0.37397685647010803,
0.02895066887140274,
0.01747060939669609,
-0.42306649684906006,
-0.499911904335022,
-0.07599682360887527,
0.4430508315563202,
0.42451202869415283,
0.010263856500387192,
0.008771782740950584,
-0.2431591898202896,
0.5406748056411743,
0.1405523270368576,
-0.4446720778942108,
-0.22749920189380646,
0.33968842029571533,
-0.25040403008461,
-0.13300885260105133,
0.06084092706441879,
-0.7398726940155029,
-0.033858221024274826,
-0.14236226677894592,
0.18148823082447052,
-0.4111557900905609,
0.2752225399017334,
0.28872087597846985,
-0.0030599015299230814,
0.18816104531288147,
-0.125578373670578,
-1.3856093883514404,
0.43726852536201477,
0.7338700890541077,
0.6412180662155151,
0.2641735374927521,
0.010420853272080421,
-0.965928316116333,
0.2988949120044708,
-0.4033857583999634,
0.6169458031654358,
-0.7482947707176208,
-0.1792093813419342,
0.17277924716472626,
-0.24881961941719055,
-0.12337075173854828,
-0.38850995898246765,
0.6711024641990662,
-0.5395162105560303,
-0.16727851331233978,
-0.24476122856140137,
-0.6602181792259216,
0.20565786957740784,
0.09509574621915817,
-0.5476321578025818,
0.6577646732330322,
0.2515360713005066,
-0.4469406008720398,
0.4207127094268799,
0.11940020322799683,
-0.33634382486343384,
-0.19324485957622528,
-0.3340891897678375,
-0.41691625118255615,
0.36404189467430115,
0.7283685207366943,
0.3063577711582184,
0.06780903786420822,
0.37325647473335266,
-0.3328676223754883,
-0.2969433665275574,
0.06844061613082886,
-0.35773009061813354,
0.7226670384407043,
0.5574812293052673,
0.11900218576192856,
0.03055490553379059,
-0.758156955242157,
0.3942786455154419,
-0.06928911805152893,
-0.5504524111747742,
-0.22049246728420258,
0.42191702127456665,
-0.17630955576896667,
0.03497447818517685,
0.04748141020536423,
-0.33676519989967346,
0.4327637553215027,
-0.5400964021682739,
0.5854641199111938,
0.9387983679771423,
-0.1650039553642273,
0.7461206912994385,
-0.548568069934845,
0.7761132121086121,
-0.264680415391922,
-0.00048647596850059927,
-0.12854713201522827,
-0.07764484733343124,
-0.5342150330543518,
-0.25361549854278564,
0.2855375409126282,
0.4987282156944275,
-0.7769123315811157,
0.6449957489967346,
-0.4751043915748596,
0.06263742595911026,
-0.6632738709449768,
0.30892348289489746,
0.4004899263381958,
0.2704101502895355,
0.24735096096992493,
-0.23035076260566711,
-0.786841630935669,
-0.7314553260803223,
-0.1102614626288414,
-0.16753235459327698,
0.019315898418426514,
-0.10394152253866196,
0.020715152844786644,
-0.005374349653720856,
0.864880383014679,
-0.43678978085517883,
-0.42212265729904175,
-0.2722860872745514,
-0.09531240910291672,
0.38355234265327454,
0.6819162964820862,
0.4331527352333069,
-0.4857575297355652,
-0.32385003566741943,
-0.20627175271511078,
-0.35792985558509827,
-0.42516204714775085,
-0.3174339532852173,
-0.20284658670425415,
0.39421728253364563,
0.8046835660934448,
-0.6277333498001099,
0.1730096936225891,
0.9919682741165161,
-0.4518033564090729,
0.41669365763664246,
-0.28616854548454285,
-0.11906977742910385,
-1.043068528175354,
-0.20135490596294403,
-0.33406326174736023,
-0.4001085162162781,
-0.39505377411842346,
0.5400720834732056,
0.2133030891418457,
-0.11123114079236984,
0.10480765998363495,
0.13686732947826385,
-0.8105980753898621,
-0.14232556521892548,
-0.1787264198064804,
-0.1722506582736969,
0.09873101115226746,
0.3371173143386841,
0.03873102739453316,
0.7268230319023132,
0.23568980395793915,
-0.44343316555023193,
0.2582409381866455,
0.4023463726043701,
-0.41024652123451233,
0.48064878582954407,
-0.34923893213272095,
0.12321459501981735,
-0.24846605956554413,
0.36580678820610046,
-0.9258249402046204,
-0.4060501456260681,
0.14150398969650269,
-0.39904123544692993,
0.3995567262172699,
-0.20102573931217194,
-0.43458759784698486,
-0.18626509606838226,
-0.1626850962638855,
0.6267318725585938,
0.8682570457458496,
-0.6597285270690918,
0.5169863700866699,
0.11365310102701187,
-0.07167215645313263,
-0.7561491131782532,
-0.7643150091171265,
-0.06085263937711716,
-0.04659852385520935,
-0.5865789651870728,
0.4362134039402008,
0.10055980831384659,
-0.3363665044307709,
0.3388929069042206,
-0.13445021212100983,
0.2153557389974594,
-0.06609948724508286,
0.161503866314888,
0.09251735359430313,
-0.23564104735851288,
-0.04507899656891823,
0.23665644228458405,
-0.004982921294867992,
0.0933247059583664,
-0.6160799264907837,
0.6380646824836731,
0.3210128843784332,
-0.7930004596710205,
-0.09505222737789154,
0.6406614184379578,
0.28216350078582764,
-0.0473816841840744,
0.48120009899139404,
0.17541389167308807,
-0.358236700296402,
-0.46414148807525635,
-0.30265188217163086,
0.15135058760643005,
-0.5300676822662354,
0.29472270607948303,
-0.3461453318595886,
-0.46862828731536865,
0.5571187734603882,
0.3263418972492218,
0.051343437284231186,
0.35149529576301575,
0.3736100494861603,
-0.0005811105947941542,
1.0051084756851196,
0.6760652661323547,
-0.10984641313552856,
0.2836884558200836,
0.03733621537685394,
0.19737505912780762,
-0.7150385975837708,
-0.027683807536959648,
-0.5528869032859802,
-0.5423455834388733,
-0.2868100106716156,
-0.4676935076713562,
-0.07711359858512878,
0.3269661068916321,
0.17288687825202942,
0.00857408158481121,
-0.3576948344707489,
0.652656614780426,
0.9170774221420288,
0.004364334978163242,
0.16509412229061127,
0.10135173052549362,
-0.17671529948711395,
-0.09988649934530258,
-0.9375577569007874,
-0.2895107567310333,
1.046349287033081,
-0.027374835684895515,
0.9895210266113281,
0.283473402261734,
0.8953916430473328,
0.12806196510791779,
0.012711314484477043,
-0.6401488780975342,
0.477721244096756,
-0.38877326250076294,
-0.3275655508041382,
-0.050128839910030365,
-0.40708789229393005,
-0.6802542805671692,
-0.1278209686279297,
-0.2912226915359497,
-0.5998767018318176,
0.4492431581020355,
0.492061972618103,
-0.4059441387653351,
0.15126512944698334,
-0.8738255500793457,
0.5948030948638916,
0.11588264256715775,
-0.3443363606929779,
0.11378242820501328,
-0.41875016689300537,
0.38752156496047974,
0.17011694610118866,
0.3555256724357605,
0.011803051456809044,
0.23101487755775452,
0.1818346381187439,
-0.6587722301483154,
0.8435183763504028,
-0.2165175974369049,
-0.04722696170210838,
0.30289003252983093,
0.10719642788171768,
0.7691121101379395,
0.03168366104364395,
0.04164382815361023,
-0.5083126425743103,
-0.07836081087589264,
-0.7378471493721008,
-0.4822027385234833,
0.7297238707542419,
-0.644882082939148,
-0.8569760322570801,
-0.6106282472610474,
-0.9641498327255249,
-0.2853633463382721,
-0.06958533823490143,
0.6117764711380005,
0.3762151002883911,
-0.21051588654518127,
-0.1148669421672821,
0.24336877465248108,
-0.12911365926265717,
0.4537090063095093,
-0.15492035448551178,
-0.14436182379722595,
-0.40020060539245605,
0.728472888469696,
-0.02816738933324814,
0.7266983389854431,
0.5003715753555298,
-0.12125276774168015,
-0.3890300393104553,
-0.7400224804878235,
-0.4011106491088867,
-0.05190031975507736,
-0.9746590852737427,
-0.4273655116558075,
-0.1744571477174759,
-0.19545911252498627,
-0.8748603463172913,
-0.5591883063316345,
-0.05410970002412796,
-0.45822960138320923,
-0.4188126027584076,
-0.1566871553659439,
0.09506113082170486,
0.41932183504104614,
-0.28503403067588806,
0.4020217955112457,
-0.6415090560913086,
0.24823758006095886,
0.2127390056848526,
0.093356654047966,
-0.2738797068595886,
-0.4334884583950043,
-0.025577755644917488,
0.15023761987686157,
-0.2108413279056549,
-0.7854265570640564,
0.5761957168579102,
0.45123744010925293,
0.1687963902950287,
0.5138729214668274,
0.4060181975364685,
1.0312070846557617,
-0.5490272045135498,
0.474380761384964,
-0.07951528578996658,
-1.1132560968399048,
0.21872571110725403,
-0.2778613269329071,
0.5393369197845459,
0.3695145845413208,
-0.075393445789814,
-0.44776034355163574,
-0.6726951003074646,
-0.47148311138153076,
-0.8006799817085266,
0.6282563209533691,
0.14152571558952332,
0.2868954539299011,
-0.3111158311367035,
0.41904282569885254,
-0.14440645277500153,
-0.1481184959411621,
-0.7558148503303528,
0.1543126404285431,
-0.16617484390735626,
-0.7500242590904236,
-0.38823994994163513,
-0.5062089562416077,
-0.1183169037103653,
0.14742976427078247,
0.7138102650642395,
-0.21809175610542297,
0.33773958683013916,
0.2450910061597824,
-0.2081172615289688,
-0.15683680772781372,
0.4881226420402527,
0.6883013844490051,
0.439096599817276,
-0.1504063755273819,
0.2671287953853607,
-0.2956311106681824,
-0.4338330924510956,
0.3835929334163666,
0.23001231253147125,
-0.3517962694168091,
-0.09324905276298523,
0.46928471326828003,
0.5433962941169739,
-0.20504507422447205,
-0.6867588758468628,
0.3851686120033264,
0.21094153821468353,
-0.3367294371128082,
-0.3066144585609436,
0.09383891522884369,
0.13693095743656158,
0.26255571842193604,
0.376183420419693,
0.08754246681928635,
-0.10834155231714249,
-0.40234246850013733,
0.06320257484912872,
0.7814369797706604,
0.1154620423913002,
-0.22256900370121002,
0.9740282297134399,
0.008891860954463482,
-0.044631097465753555,
0.9796619415283203,
-0.48359042406082153,
-0.20514045655727386,
0.7409950494766235,
1.0690586566925049,
0.6283316016197205,
-0.11555521935224533,
0.046251509338617325,
0.2877269387245178,
0.4300740361213684,
-0.12584663927555084,
0.44090959429740906,
0.13399341702461243,
-0.8327721953392029,
-0.9876353740692139,
-0.8563480377197266,
-0.08634263277053833,
0.07552748173475266,
-0.9078549742698669,
0.31723350286483765,
-0.6042045950889587,
-0.005839858204126358,
-0.34112951159477234,
-0.2795736491680145,
-0.2384026050567627,
0.04328034818172455,
0.025442123413085938,
0.6858543157577515,
-1.0568886995315552,
0.8555448651313782,
0.5474420785903931,
-0.05476117134094238,
-0.8706220984458923,
-0.012091302312910557,
0.2656441032886505,
-0.8491803407669067,
0.2936999499797821,
-0.00015724393597338349,
0.07475031912326813,
0.18924814462661743,
-0.4795427620410919,
-0.985113263130188,
0.8368152379989624,
0.7594898343086243,
-0.6473934650421143,
-0.24500443041324615,
0.01827591098845005,
0.2213226556777954,
-0.1422886848449707,
-0.454961359500885,
0.4276074767112732,
0.24797073006629944,
0.1462852954864502,
-0.6113701462745667,
0.11608032137155533,
-0.4547828435897827,
-0.01294913049787283,
0.528327465057373,
-0.27987030148506165,
0.857165515422821,
-0.3064257800579071,
-0.7319212555885315,
0.5377068519592285,
0.8309366106987,
0.3594866991043091,
0.0681457445025444,
0.20409919321537018,
0.8824702501296997,
0.6677435636520386,
-0.28912433981895447,
1.1914454698562622,
0.02323475293815136,
0.2901872396469116,
1.145466685295105,
-0.16572187840938568,
0.7706901431083679,
0.8000738620758057,
-0.2529654800891876,
0.16978853940963745,
0.6178984642028809,
-0.005495211109519005,
0.7232697010040283,
0.2780279219150543,
-0.13238884508609772,
-0.2635296583175659,
0.04279318079352379,
-0.27686282992362976,
0.24528418481349945,
0.4475489556789398,
-0.2662633955478668,
-0.0955607071518898,
-0.10979744791984558,
-0.18874557316303253,
0.7663201093673706,
-0.39118117094039917,
0.5320654511451721,
-0.1514234095811844,
-0.7776820659637451,
0.8232637047767639,
0.2551906406879425,
0.6091059446334839,
-0.476725697517395,
0.05845656618475914,
-0.37661048769950867,
0.3498903214931488,
-0.29148179292678833,
-0.3450903594493866,
0.6347854733467102,
-0.19911499321460724,
-0.28234216570854187,
-0.32665184140205383,
0.39388778805732727,
-0.5923154354095459,
-0.6697661280632019,
-0.026626238599419594,
0.19558215141296387,
-0.14912046492099762,
0.20170828700065613,
-0.023186765611171722,
0.23433388769626617,
0.01938616670668125,
0.03386220708489418,
0.3491089642047882,
0.37350767850875854,
0.04570024460554123,
0.42901611328125,
0.5545539259910583,
0.40469977259635925,
0.49399083852767944,
-0.24138899147510529,
0.679943323135376,
-0.30946359038352966,
-0.8081437945365906,
-0.8498268127441406,
0.08160426467657089,
0.2018682062625885,
-0.14676477015018463,
0.6157405972480774,
0.41470202803611755,
1.1390397548675537,
-0.20498144626617432,
0.5791836977005005,
-0.14426392316818237,
0.11887094378471375,
-1.1860110759735107,
0.19979055225849152,
-0.3303142786026001,
0.373664528131485,
-0.28498315811157227,
-0.9384492039680481,
-0.5028204917907715,
0.6455495357513428,
-0.13015514612197876,
-0.06917357444763184,
0.6053178906440735,
0.6304625272750854,
-0.20898962020874023,
-0.35499149560928345,
0.20766542851924896,
-0.05702634155750275,
0.27116113901138306,
1.0188888311386108,
0.7313713431358337,
-0.21845559775829315,
0.672795295715332,
-0.25807100534439087,
0.015207823365926743,
-0.022165093570947647,
-1.0026164054870605,
-0.493020623922348,
-0.5256543159484863,
-0.09720560908317566,
-0.36003172397613525,
0.15856103599071503,
0.8040731549263,
0.6086970567703247,
-0.7106509208679199,
-0.21725468337535858,
-0.4118804633617401,
-0.06545893102884293,
-0.7135156989097595,
-0.14831635355949402,
0.4377472996711731,
-0.481785386800766,
-1.248015284538269,
0.26973652839660645,
-0.015951966866850853,
0.17942450940608978,
0.1204821988940239,
-0.2869267761707306,
-0.2338840663433075,
0.03291470929980278,
0.2516205310821533,
0.32808446884155273,
-0.6820738911628723,
-0.46943894028663635,
0.1652507334947586,
-0.07175222039222717,
0.05649103596806526,
0.7069537043571472,
-0.6991312503814697,
0.31649357080459595,
0.4543270170688629,
0.9607427716255188,
0.10309886932373047,
0.48152512311935425,
0.9072555303573608,
-1.3833521604537964,
0.35285791754722595,
0.24822750687599182,
0.34812888503074646,
0.1583653688430786,
-0.5347038507461548,
0.18316885828971863,
0.05409914255142212,
-0.5103097558021545,
-0.7644209265708923,
0.543735682964325,
-0.8324216604232788,
-0.4995615780353546,
1.3274431228637695,
-0.03807259723544121,
-0.20329385995864868,
0.06793257594108582,
0.22183331847190857,
-0.027738969773054123,
-0.27797168493270874,
0.6126849055290222,
1.1209849119186401,
0.03749848157167435,
-0.07906942814588547,
-0.3097592294216156,
0.5374331474304199,
0.7298396825790405,
-0.540486216545105,
0.20804543793201447,
1.0801407098770142,
-0.04960129037499428,
0.1293805092573166,
0.747532844543457,
-0.05765518173575401,
0.29795658588409424,
0.053472794592380524,
-0.057026445865631104,
-0.16502909362316132,
-0.1872260570526123,
-0.6138623952865601,
0.23796510696411133,
0.2587416470050812,
-0.3530135750770569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21046v1
|
Exploratory Preference Optimization: Harnessing Implicit Q*-Approximation for Sample-Efficient RLHF
| 2024-05-31T17:39:06
| 2024-05-31T17:39:06
|
Tengyang Xie, Dylan J. Foster, Akshay Krishnamurthy, Corby Rosset, Ahmed Awadallah, Alexander Rakhlin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as a central
tool for language model alignment. We consider online exploration in RLHF,
which exploits interactive access to human or AI feedback by deliberately
encouraging the model to produce diverse, maximally informative responses. By
allowing RLHF to confidently stray from the pre-trained model, online
exploration offers the possibility of novel, potentially super-human
capabilities, but its full potential as a paradigm for language model training
has yet to be realized, owing to computational and statistical bottlenecks in
directly adapting existing reinforcement learning techniques. We propose a new
algorithm for online exploration in RLHF, Exploratory Preference Optimization
(XPO), which is simple and practical -- a one-line change to (online) Direct
Preference Optimization (DPO; Rafailov et al., 2023) -- yet enjoys the
strongest known provable guarantees and promising empirical performance. XPO
augments the DPO objective with a novel and principled exploration bonus,
empowering the algorithm to explore outside the support of the initial model
and human feedback data. In theory, we show that XPO is provably
sample-efficient and converges to a near-optimal language model policy under
natural exploration conditions, irrespective of whether the initial model has
good coverage. Our analysis, which builds on the observation that DPO
implicitly performs a form of $Q^{\star}$-approximation (or, Bellman error
minimization), combines previously disparate techniques from language modeling
and theoretical reinforcement learning in a serendipitous fashion through the
perspective of KL-regularized Markov decision processes. Empirically, we find
that XPO is more sample-efficient than non-exploratory DPO variants in a
preliminary evaluation.
|
[
-0.3627064824104309,
-0.6476336717605591,
0.6787731051445007,
-0.039941128343343735,
0.06790293008089066,
0.22792121767997742,
-0.496378093957901,
-0.4153306186199188,
0.08186744898557663,
0.2876880466938019,
-0.9471578598022461,
-0.32797929644584656,
-0.2512498199939728,
-0.0949971005320549,
0.1225588470697403,
0.8779373168945312,
-0.07388526946306229,
-0.08165345340967178,
-0.0751677080988884,
-0.042889054864645004,
-0.049649130553007126,
-0.44625550508499146,
-0.5444687008857727,
-0.2553795576095581,
0.493954062461853,
0.379882276058197,
0.8671205639839172,
0.7852129936218262,
0.14246806502342224,
0.24703165888786316,
-0.01242960523813963,
0.35402712225914,
-0.6882245540618896,
0.18294204771518707,
0.08582498878240585,
-0.6549651622772217,
-0.10511485487222672,
-0.01799790933728218,
0.6286987066268921,
0.6183552145957947,
-0.4773109257221222,
-0.12407100945711136,
-0.18461620807647705,
0.7137508988380432,
-0.6813300848007202,
0.31059208512306213,
-0.29845601320266724,
0.322649747133255,
0.3716626763343811,
-0.3133326470851898,
-0.3880733549594879,
-0.7346563935279846,
0.73086017370224,
-1.1564022302627563,
-0.0807265192270279,
0.2647082507610321,
0.7114987969398499,
0.2029554396867752,
-0.207404226064682,
-0.16937148571014404,
-0.7611042261123657,
0.9676018357276917,
-0.574625551700592,
0.4280445873737335,
0.41735658049583435,
0.5495680570602417,
-0.26050588488578796,
-0.35531845688819885,
-0.5215433835983276,
-0.5502733588218689,
0.1068062111735344,
0.16576924920082092,
-0.12252525240182877,
0.35724058747291565,
0.03987080603837967,
0.2397596836090088,
-0.45324575901031494,
0.11318204551935196,
-0.027128860354423523,
-0.10714047402143478,
0.5177893042564392,
-0.10939383506774902,
0.182556614279747,
0.08215989917516708,
-0.3772404193878174,
-0.5941528677940369,
-0.552433967590332,
0.5579402446746826,
0.48883020877838135,
0.3115697503089905,
0.032300934195518494,
0.27012601494789124,
-0.31711456179618835,
0.4736773669719696,
0.07041669636964798,
-0.07149149477481842,
0.1594812572002411,
-0.12546618282794952,
0.019666481763124466,
0.029183315113186836,
0.5413172841072083,
0.44732481241226196,
0.19061145186424255,
-0.10441089421510696,
-0.20266114175319672,
-0.0974140539765358,
0.15102605521678925,
-0.5508070588111877,
-0.1465630829334259,
0.39825212955474854,
-0.16808868944644928,
-0.3497978746891022,
0.10313019901514053,
-0.7104913592338562,
-0.28767165541648865,
-0.2504788935184479,
0.37626343965530396,
-0.08527608960866928,
-0.2807683050632477,
-0.0039849658496677876,
-0.20030894875526428,
0.0507279708981514,
0.37115147709846497,
-0.8497918844223022,
0.47989585995674133,
0.6325161457061768,
0.6582094430923462,
-0.25124892592430115,
-0.3045205771923065,
-0.7992047071456909,
-0.058588553220033646,
-0.45161426067352295,
0.5910875797271729,
-0.7198431491851807,
-0.4149104058742523,
0.25317683815956116,
-0.2581299841403961,
0.033633675426244736,
-0.5110921859741211,
0.6913182139396667,
-0.7916459441184998,
0.4949367344379425,
-0.034979842603206635,
-0.5693804621696472,
-0.26289618015289307,
0.14698918163776398,
-0.713908851146698,
1.2686362266540527,
0.25452500581741333,
-0.522308886051178,
0.4258551597595215,
-0.7389617562294006,
0.1889013648033142,
-0.3187443017959595,
-0.14769425988197327,
-0.37022149562835693,
0.05771154537796974,
0.3920421898365021,
-0.021579492837190628,
-0.03300312161445618,
0.11188308894634247,
-0.5291364192962646,
-0.4172447919845581,
0.24523499608039856,
0.0681486651301384,
0.5198581218719482,
0.1445571482181549,
-0.5840757489204407,
0.5956327319145203,
-0.7001705765724182,
0.34608909487724304,
0.13687054812908173,
-0.34211719036102295,
-0.5747823119163513,
0.22761377692222595,
0.014341304078698158,
0.3012499213218689,
0.07961156219244003,
-0.5417415499687195,
0.25853195786476135,
-0.771050214767456,
0.27470117807388306,
0.8970274925231934,
-0.08740590512752533,
0.6687266230583191,
-0.34043487906455994,
0.905907928943634,
-0.4478902816772461,
0.35813307762145996,
-0.10326897352933884,
-0.23542554676532745,
-0.7058389782905579,
-0.26874908804893494,
0.24003048241138458,
0.3823327124118805,
-0.5338209867477417,
0.3124864995479584,
-0.33965304493904114,
-0.17824403941631317,
-0.7086349129676819,
-0.1659650057554245,
0.5149549245834351,
0.20284011960029602,
0.3803691267967224,
-0.019877517595887184,
-0.506083607673645,
-0.8931102156639099,
-0.25944650173187256,
-0.24491703510284424,
0.2722332179546356,
0.6022377014160156,
-0.08699261397123337,
-0.16102616488933563,
1.1418274641036987,
-0.5047357082366943,
-0.15482406318187714,
-0.4125060737133026,
0.1345779150724411,
0.29837146401405334,
0.18246202170848846,
0.27835404872894287,
-0.6912806630134583,
-0.6853150129318237,
0.11278039962053299,
-0.3117959797382355,
-0.1626100391149521,
0.04828159883618355,
-0.1590256243944168,
0.3328925371170044,
0.1325082778930664,
-0.24995610117912292,
0.022243881598114967,
0.5955718159675598,
-0.007066510617733002,
0.14025016129016876,
-0.6196345090866089,
0.028226137161254883,
-0.41710734367370605,
-0.14155057072639465,
-0.18052281439304352,
-0.519646942615509,
-0.6142714023590088,
0.5006118416786194,
0.1158013641834259,
-0.025312496349215508,
-0.3612065017223358,
0.6551136374473572,
-0.5429388284683228,
0.032134998589754105,
-0.48579132556915283,
0.3248510956764221,
-0.23260098695755005,
0.8545393347740173,
0.30482906103134155,
0.4465247392654419,
0.405004620552063,
-0.5067276358604431,
0.07122087478637695,
0.0492829754948616,
-0.09801210463047028,
-0.014021076261997223,
-0.4298658072948456,
0.40085622668266296,
-0.23183946311473846,
0.3235379457473755,
-0.8999716639518738,
0.01639525592327118,
0.31927236914634705,
-0.3170722723007202,
0.231743723154068,
-0.030423901975154877,
-0.20155733823776245,
0.04278954491019249,
-0.7452660202980042,
0.4368380308151245,
0.62577885389328,
-0.6964812278747559,
0.47322750091552734,
0.5365282297134399,
-0.2126701921224594,
-0.730867326259613,
-0.03315858915448189,
-0.2639082968235016,
-0.18036015331745148,
-0.36499765515327454,
0.2893514633178711,
-0.043685220181941986,
-0.23977315425872803,
-0.13435040414333344,
-0.030006183311343193,
0.09514153748750687,
0.10074459761381149,
0.10980681329965591,
0.435896635055542,
0.16248579323291779,
-0.13746309280395508,
0.004765660502016544,
-0.10944164544343948,
-0.0008596680127084255,
-0.278583288192749,
0.4870215654373169,
-0.017954280599951744,
-0.08996187895536423,
-0.43690913915634155,
0.4410730302333832,
0.14761026203632355,
0.07473428547382355,
0.06798755377531052,
0.19670885801315308,
-0.12200663238763809,
-0.421479195356369,
-0.2850954532623291,
-0.2903274595737457,
-0.43462368845939636,
0.5194137692451477,
-0.23067475855350494,
-0.9787900447845459,
0.11689041554927826,
0.11608286947011948,
0.2649083435535431,
0.20451362431049347,
0.28883543610572815,
0.05146545544266701,
1.3783249855041504,
0.8544354438781738,
0.04995645210146904,
0.49118125438690186,
-0.042334336787462234,
0.02425057627260685,
-0.5818334817886353,
-0.024392442777752876,
-0.16380199790000916,
-0.16717389225959778,
-0.8728253245353699,
-0.45328351855278015,
0.46678441762924194,
-0.016539033502340317,
0.08096347749233246,
0.17497506737709045,
-0.18267996609210968,
0.3138868808746338,
0.8420166373252869,
0.16144171357154846,
0.37426358461380005,
-0.04949302226305008,
-0.2586055099964142,
-0.2791181206703186,
-0.93193119764328,
-0.1370857059955597,
1.2256747484207153,
0.4936469495296478,
0.5989983677864075,
0.10455995798110962,
0.7893349528312683,
0.3433974087238312,
0.30262336134910583,
-0.7766612768173218,
0.23156780004501343,
0.49727317690849304,
-0.4488852918148041,
-0.578797459602356,
-0.4448772668838501,
-0.8428393006324768,
0.3660285174846649,
-0.21261563897132874,
-0.6459720134735107,
0.3399021625518799,
0.5474469065666199,
-0.6849719882011414,
-0.09760566800832748,
-0.6940111517906189,
0.6741476058959961,
-0.229593887925148,
-0.5869723558425903,
-0.4355074465274811,
-0.7637427449226379,
0.34190672636032104,
-0.0015631275018677115,
0.45566487312316895,
0.05832923203706741,
-0.2176482081413269,
0.5576353669166565,
-0.369937539100647,
0.5650708079338074,
-0.42248809337615967,
-0.1830761432647705,
0.10889218002557755,
0.08521697670221329,
0.9304952621459961,
-0.1361633986234665,
0.2522278130054474,
-0.42999735474586487,
0.21374718844890594,
-0.29467684030532837,
-0.894045352935791,
0.5378223657608032,
-0.9393914937973022,
-0.5708614587783813,
-0.6579514741897583,
-0.41710150241851807,
-0.5314034223556519,
-0.12702018022537231,
-0.10647027939558029,
0.1740444451570511,
-0.25826460123062134,
-0.23556676506996155,
0.591847836971283,
-0.3140413761138916,
0.32624807953834534,
0.36718618869781494,
-0.696020781993866,
-0.5279466509819031,
1.0194032192230225,
-0.2000771015882492,
0.47477468848228455,
0.813355565071106,
0.6026459336280823,
-0.69156813621521,
-0.44097983837127686,
-0.5212892293930054,
0.2327936589717865,
-0.7000214457511902,
0.34243711829185486,
-0.638317346572876,
0.33786696195602417,
-0.20557045936584473,
0.1014246940612793,
-0.31618398427963257,
-0.6084486842155457,
0.07896468788385391,
0.010397178120911121,
0.05821350961923599,
0.5199914574623108,
-0.13051731884479523,
0.24153468012809753,
-0.6259904503822327,
0.0495421476662159,
0.39291226863861084,
0.10397132486104965,
-0.0664893165230751,
-0.5119820833206177,
-0.24707895517349243,
0.09590209275484085,
-0.005200688727200031,
-0.851892352104187,
0.40923193097114563,
0.3917539715766907,
0.7395308613777161,
0.6141083836555481,
0.27523788809776306,
0.5551124215126038,
-0.3460124135017395,
0.3954457640647888,
-0.10944163799285889,
-0.6863113045692444,
0.36215832829475403,
-0.4145554006099701,
0.09026923030614853,
0.6680302619934082,
0.7217402458190918,
-0.6500310897827148,
-0.18942958116531372,
-0.6086872220039368,
-0.955146849155426,
0.8843640685081482,
0.006497025024145842,
-0.09202848374843597,
0.17353852093219757,
0.16128727793693542,
0.28850385546684265,
0.2586161494255066,
-0.7200099229812622,
-0.39120087027549744,
-0.08759791404008865,
0.14514675736427307,
0.08039291948080063,
-0.14449436962604523,
-0.2790620028972626,
0.006709007546305656,
0.8733000159263611,
-0.3922114670276642,
0.2938046455383301,
0.2994816303253174,
-0.18336114287376404,
-0.18621030449867249,
0.2757813334465027,
0.6774390935897827,
0.6471700668334961,
-0.6195805072784424,
0.09397043287754059,
-0.08659876883029938,
-0.10163026303052902,
0.20262902975082397,
0.11382370442152023,
-0.17010438442230225,
-0.16141781210899353,
0.05877711623907089,
0.8746738433837891,
0.30653247237205505,
-1.1499780416488647,
0.5593422651290894,
-0.2007542997598648,
-0.0461299903690815,
-0.4123997986316681,
0.30395960807800293,
-0.24034568667411804,
0.2043529599905014,
0.46016809344291687,
-0.2440590113401413,
0.2767118215560913,
-0.6938930153846741,
0.0945138931274414,
0.4459773600101471,
-0.708916425704956,
-0.21424566209316254,
0.4610503315925598,
0.1912858486175537,
-0.2575066387653351,
0.1803404688835144,
-0.4244358539581299,
-0.6972643136978149,
0.3590163290500641,
0.38443776965141296,
0.8423398733139038,
-0.016232512891292572,
0.24898800253868103,
0.43585696816444397,
-0.07090336829423904,
-0.15385445952415466,
0.16089734435081482,
-0.43607380986213684,
-0.7039811611175537,
-0.43866270780563354,
-0.2842296063899994,
-0.7209982872009277,
-0.1308535784482956,
-0.6763096451759338,
0.17928583920001984,
-0.5773676633834839,
0.051231902092695236,
-0.46583423018455505,
0.008588588796555996,
-0.2887246608734131,
0.13972103595733643,
0.17423991858959198,
0.604556143283844,
-0.4147070348262787,
0.7887605428695679,
0.5054397583007812,
-0.04519054666161537,
-0.6555996537208557,
0.004932612646371126,
0.06910890340805054,
-0.9894117116928101,
0.6118801236152649,
0.017881356179714203,
-0.250017374753952,
0.19757938385009766,
-0.22946088016033173,
-1.0088480710983276,
0.9080619812011719,
0.19445835053920746,
-0.6882928609848022,
-0.20937800407409668,
-0.1605955958366394,
0.3741914629936218,
-0.4249956011772156,
0.7403750419616699,
0.6530713438987732,
0.5325793027877808,
-0.2204514890909195,
-0.8923671841621399,
0.12038660049438477,
-0.2633935511112213,
0.049960725009441376,
0.245893657207489,
-0.5188261866569519,
0.32012978196144104,
-0.49754688143730164,
-0.4010029733181,
0.0025370919611305,
0.7628937363624573,
0.387291818857193,
-0.11560570448637009,
0.9022969603538513,
0.4599483013153076,
0.6026167273521423,
0.07392431795597076,
1.2576792240142822,
-0.26073551177978516,
0.4753669798374176,
1.2058608531951904,
-0.13105937838554382,
0.9346056580543518,
0.64622962474823,
-0.4300650954246521,
0.33242067694664,
0.8468314409255981,
0.40371036529541016,
0.9242582321166992,
0.37996402382850647,
-0.23182059824466705,
-0.2077755331993103,
-0.16240566968917847,
-0.2774111032485962,
0.1329987794160843,
-0.1528603881597519,
-0.13614431023597717,
-0.25355324149131775,
-0.18485088646411896,
0.09436117857694626,
0.19510313868522644,
-0.1684679090976715,
0.7770969867706299,
-0.3094263970851898,
-1.1248302459716797,
0.5573282837867737,
0.09879883378744125,
0.6937949061393738,
-0.7287911176681519,
-0.21138791739940643,
-0.2420032024383545,
0.06314174830913544,
0.009301620535552502,
-0.28535306453704834,
-0.14291638135910034,
-0.4433613419532776,
0.09756457060575485,
-0.2287791222333908,
0.21552276611328125,
-0.5557299256324768,
-0.0996791422367096,
0.49220895767211914,
0.5092120170593262,
-0.0758783221244812,
-0.06991113722324371,
-0.45575273036956787,
-0.10170823335647583,
0.22227843105793,
-0.3574336767196655,
0.49721962213516235,
-0.0897708609700203,
-0.07644619047641754,
0.6710091233253479,
0.7379211783409119,
0.2964423596858978,
0.22419066727161407,
-0.0026535927318036556,
0.6855980753898621,
-0.6147111654281616,
-0.8538841605186462,
-0.6729226112365723,
0.19287645816802979,
-0.014316169545054436,
-0.43766745924949646,
0.5274942517280579,
0.5413147211074829,
1.0606471300125122,
0.012324631214141846,
1.0086063146591187,
0.22812266647815704,
0.6361420154571533,
-0.49012407660484314,
0.24149493873119354,
-0.5321882963180542,
0.11675815284252167,
-0.24248656630516052,
-0.9348900318145752,
-0.04000112786889076,
0.5846264362335205,
-0.33570733666419983,
-0.049758490175008774,
0.7745478749275208,
0.8425690531730652,
0.06868109852075577,
0.10767725110054016,
0.31827476620674133,
-0.12618190050125122,
0.26404044032096863,
0.615847647190094,
1.1306384801864624,
-0.12049812823534012,
0.45546185970306396,
-0.5751887559890747,
-0.5716943144798279,
-0.28541895747184753,
-0.9499992728233337,
-0.68571537733078,
-0.4669516086578369,
-0.1472473442554474,
-0.11157163977622986,
0.24816033244132996,
1.764426589012146,
0.699938952922821,
-0.594164252281189,
-0.4149990379810333,
-0.20434901118278503,
0.014565998688340187,
-0.5465600490570068,
-0.24481546878814697,
0.45896124839782715,
-0.4193461835384369,
-1.1050543785095215,
0.6205521821975708,
0.20121130347251892,
-0.09699354320764542,
-0.5474681854248047,
-0.38335978984832764,
-0.15922607481479645,
-0.02436698228120804,
0.343548446893692,
0.5432444214820862,
-0.7414688467979431,
-0.24364331364631653,
0.37546661496162415,
0.05835690721869469,
0.3000432848930359,
1.0568296909332275,
-0.8472666144371033,
0.8250328302383423,
0.5125675797462463,
1.0557870864868164,
0.5589092969894409,
-0.008464323356747627,
0.9059610962867737,
-0.36537966132164,
-0.08441182971000671,
0.22919197380542755,
0.11776825785636902,
0.17927438020706177,
-0.3389849066734314,
0.27562421560287476,
0.15572819113731384,
-0.4349057078361511,
-0.8067038059234619,
0.20206955075263977,
-0.8827927708625793,
-0.19736170768737793,
1.1933846473693848,
-0.2329535335302353,
-0.32301729917526245,
-0.1318347454071045,
-0.4096301198005676,
0.016388045623898506,
-0.8630106449127197,
1.0482006072998047,
0.5684936046600342,
-0.6351583003997803,
-0.3393509089946747,
-0.6074976921081543,
0.8329907655715942,
0.7526852488517761,
-0.7485934495925903,
0.09417486190795898,
0.3720538318157196,
-0.050045035779476166,
0.0770070031285286,
0.6710001230239868,
0.16638042032718658,
0.4245849847793579,
-0.44762223958969116,
0.05242324620485306,
-0.14875394105911255,
-0.23308490216732025,
-0.5583585500717163,
0.153640478849411,
0.36257287859916687,
-0.08485958725214005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21040v1
|
Direct Alignment of Language Models via Quality-Aware Self-Refinement
| 2024-05-31T17:31:18
| 2024-05-31T17:31:18
|
Runsheng Yu, Yong Wang, Xiaoqi Jiao, Youzhi Zhang, James T. Kwok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has been commonly used to
align the behaviors of Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences.
Recently, a popular alternative is Direct Policy Optimization (DPO), which
replaces an LLM-based reward model with the policy itself, thus obviating the
need for extra memory and training time to learn the reward model. However, DPO
does not consider the relative qualities of the positive and negative
responses, and can lead to sub-optimal training outcomes. To alleviate this
problem, we investigate the use of intrinsic knowledge within the on-the-fly
fine-tuning LLM to obtain relative qualities and help to refine the loss
function. Specifically, we leverage the knowledge of the LLM to design a
refinement function to estimate the quality of both the positive and negative
responses. We show that the constructed refinement function can help
self-refine the loss function under mild assumptions. The refinement function
is integrated into DPO and its variant Identity Policy Optimization (IPO).
Experiments across various evaluators indicate that they can improve the
performance of the fine-tuned models over DPO and IPO.
|
[
-0.19357863068580627,
-0.4542219936847687,
0.6064530611038208,
-0.0895964726805687,
-0.08593585342168808,
0.1917603462934494,
-0.44376513361930847,
-0.2556166648864746,
-0.08974796533584595,
0.5051519274711609,
-0.7886767387390137,
-0.20367547869682312,
-0.20470762252807617,
0.08193521201610565,
0.08972596377134323,
0.8595707416534424,
-0.1425396203994751,
-0.07381689548492432,
-0.11511056870222092,
-0.07579781860113144,
-0.43017226457595825,
-0.3623385727405548,
-0.5254514813423157,
-0.6401335000991821,
0.5443974137306213,
0.6013818383216858,
0.6394228935241699,
0.8116745948791504,
0.4568537175655365,
0.22600485384464264,
0.11922788619995117,
0.30460917949676514,
-0.7158898711204529,
0.09604151546955109,
-0.7106643915176392,
-0.32868024706840515,
-0.29770350456237793,
-0.07202529907226562,
0.6325413584709167,
0.42012858390808105,
-0.4311619699001312,
0.08013458549976349,
0.20223166048526764,
1.007615327835083,
-0.6108936071395874,
-0.022380631417036057,
-0.6588028073310852,
0.08026126027107239,
0.3197166621685028,
-0.20361286401748657,
-0.19499321281909943,
-0.42673999071121216,
0.2372412234544754,
-0.6795907616615295,
-0.029452411457896233,
-0.019571077078580856,
1.112408995628357,
0.6475268602371216,
-0.18043968081474304,
-0.15148793160915375,
-0.8597533702850342,
0.841180145740509,
-0.8232794404029846,
0.3486214280128479,
0.32659101486206055,
0.08453633636236191,
-0.3371264934539795,
-0.009242068976163864,
-0.7030333876609802,
-0.3261064887046814,
-0.1839774250984192,
0.017572779208421707,
0.011966714635491371,
0.2943051755428314,
-0.13906872272491455,
0.5711437463760376,
-0.400724321603775,
0.5209062695503235,
-0.04162450134754181,
-0.3857783079147339,
0.8442041873931885,
0.03421316295862198,
-0.053546030074357986,
0.08869016915559769,
-0.26263248920440674,
-0.16658832132816315,
-0.816425085067749,
0.28164398670196533,
0.6591039299964905,
0.3864212930202484,
0.17460790276527405,
0.28710606694221497,
-0.49641430377960205,
0.5889933109283447,
0.5275262594223022,
-0.5099745988845825,
0.20722465217113495,
-0.33523863554000854,
-0.005306531675159931,
0.007311728782951832,
0.6877478361129761,
0.13015049695968628,
0.25565698742866516,
-0.11699595302343369,
-0.534356951713562,
-0.2370310127735138,
0.3394009470939636,
-0.714451253414154,
0.03118012472987175,
0.18144309520721436,
-0.2750667929649353,
-0.4501381814479828,
-0.14608503878116608,
-0.26809942722320557,
-0.17151802778244019,
-0.7369838356971741,
0.5944051742553711,
-0.20026682317256927,
-0.3400258719921112,
0.120899997651577,
0.1889411211013794,
0.22161106765270233,
0.21421894431114197,
-0.9590185284614563,
0.19925296306610107,
0.7564448118209839,
0.2304782271385193,
-0.07763754576444626,
-0.32910028100013733,
-0.4474376142024994,
0.14382022619247437,
-0.4212217926979065,
0.5334811806678772,
-0.3307431936264038,
-0.2552519738674164,
0.03292623534798622,
-0.17124716937541962,
0.1912197470664978,
-0.5758211016654968,
0.5217748284339905,
-0.5297826528549194,
0.24057140946388245,
-0.24878790974617004,
-0.48159971833229065,
-0.2519321143627167,
0.31402236223220825,
-0.31203415989875793,
0.8141772747039795,
0.22590839862823486,
-0.4745135009288788,
0.30382105708122253,
-0.3317687213420868,
-0.4651459753513336,
-0.2577068507671356,
-0.2880505323410034,
-0.5654519200325012,
0.3037644922733307,
0.13200527429580688,
0.35751599073410034,
-0.22987650334835052,
0.5116305351257324,
-0.44183802604675293,
-0.38885825872421265,
0.2813967764377594,
-0.17923377454280853,
0.19101780652999878,
0.2011519968509674,
-0.4202480912208557,
0.3285278379917145,
-0.7684658169746399,
0.14641797542572021,
0.07658223062753677,
-0.29664352536201477,
-0.29746416211128235,
0.10309425741434097,
-0.7331365942955017,
0.2109541893005371,
0.36532026529312134,
-0.42247018218040466,
0.34795650839805603,
-0.615436851978302,
0.333234041929245,
1.0907058715820312,
-0.10274889320135117,
0.6077805757522583,
-0.2444232702255249,
0.5331664085388184,
-0.13143977522850037,
0.3030872344970703,
0.13378719985485077,
0.10009368509054184,
-0.7413479685783386,
-0.23979505896568298,
0.24437680840492249,
0.3833788335323334,
-0.48412519693374634,
0.6543102860450745,
-0.18789450824260712,
-0.24200454354286194,
-0.9289826154708862,
0.336454302072525,
0.6131147146224976,
0.974003255367279,
0.21105632185935974,
-0.23731949925422668,
-0.21209068596363068,
-1.1770333051681519,
-0.08632153272628784,
-0.338790625333786,
0.24773848056793213,
0.3708716332912445,
0.10607418417930603,
-0.17154435813426971,
1.0289899110794067,
-0.5680607557296753,
-0.27317875623703003,
-0.037749163806438446,
-0.0008529126644134521,
0.2681766450405121,
0.4359678626060486,
0.2535374164581299,
-0.35906901955604553,
-0.4827337861061096,
0.03713514655828476,
-0.326989084482193,
-0.3038785755634308,
-0.08410589396953583,
-0.21731629967689514,
0.2029985636472702,
0.2330094575881958,
-0.16721509397029877,
-0.000979074975475669,
0.5854169726371765,
-0.2532102167606354,
0.7863326072692871,
-0.4358810782432556,
0.21056434512138367,
-0.6936184763908386,
0.0605982281267643,
-0.0775747001171112,
-0.1971697360277176,
-0.37951475381851196,
0.01866041123867035,
0.06638927012681961,
-0.06986504793167114,
-0.17167964577674866,
0.8011016249656677,
-0.36615100502967834,
0.07378029078245163,
-0.41358867287635803,
0.1387699842453003,
0.20255613327026367,
0.7790446877479553,
0.12854714691638947,
0.8820688724517822,
0.5010287761688232,
-0.799972414970398,
0.08540502935647964,
0.05677056685090065,
-0.1673620194196701,
0.6536760926246643,
-0.6417919993400574,
0.13148941099643707,
-0.3196101188659668,
-0.08136896789073944,
-0.8556370139122009,
0.004821813199669123,
0.39899784326553345,
-0.16819451749324799,
0.5378655195236206,
-0.1945085972547531,
-0.17417791485786438,
-0.2706819772720337,
-0.2708607614040375,
0.23562189936637878,
0.489284485578537,
-0.5877864360809326,
0.36617982387542725,
0.32637298107147217,
-0.04089849442243576,
-0.803608775138855,
-0.447430282831192,
-0.2804568111896515,
-0.3336232006549835,
-0.35581764578819275,
0.7191475033760071,
-0.0475081168115139,
-0.1171758621931076,
-0.03621635586023331,
-0.24605007469654083,
0.004505807533860207,
0.18441443145275116,
0.025791943073272705,
0.06449451297521591,
0.018844041973352432,
0.48291727900505066,
0.06655795872211456,
-0.15919232368469238,
-0.13351953029632568,
-0.29436126351356506,
0.40172281861305237,
-0.154122456908226,
-0.30272984504699707,
-0.8376107811927795,
0.09032163769006729,
0.2476063221693039,
-0.35458624362945557,
0.4411492645740509,
0.3875218331813812,
0.11212095618247986,
-0.44964098930358887,
-0.5898782014846802,
-0.48142293095588684,
-0.5267584323883057,
0.3019448220729828,
-0.5759573578834534,
-0.9428885579109192,
0.4482758939266205,
0.07537053525447845,
-0.15535679459571838,
0.41564831137657166,
0.3209782838821411,
-0.12751297652721405,
0.9557978510856628,
0.7929128408432007,
-0.1547875553369522,
0.721811056137085,
-0.08831287175416946,
0.1313043236732483,
-0.9547265768051147,
-0.09684695303440094,
-0.4252163767814636,
-0.39077460765838623,
-0.5039201974868774,
-0.06651949137449265,
-0.003056606277823448,
0.31180912256240845,
-0.5609830617904663,
0.2921072840690613,
-0.7448044419288635,
0.35323721170425415,
0.6909428238868713,
0.28336846828460693,
0.24598456919193268,
-0.043668050318956375,
-0.08076834678649902,
-0.11775451898574829,
-0.6358723044395447,
-0.4159967303276062,
0.9868839383125305,
0.5423604846000671,
1.1431312561035156,
0.04559149593114853,
0.9781559109687805,
0.17451493442058563,
0.32209324836730957,
-0.7784897685050964,
0.37276166677474976,
-0.12530192732810974,
-0.20273657143115997,
-0.5202890634536743,
-0.7471238374710083,
-0.7776587605476379,
0.07154203206300735,
-0.0015477817505598068,
-0.4604920744895935,
0.21831338107585907,
0.659409761428833,
-0.5281730890274048,
-0.15190501511096954,
-0.7214497327804565,
0.8458565473556519,
-0.5277252197265625,
-0.35813796520233154,
-0.5636644959449768,
-0.3679293096065521,
0.33199912309646606,
0.028804967179894447,
0.04211504012346268,
-0.5401738882064819,
0.09683360904455185,
0.4231336712837219,
-0.4336421489715576,
0.7055588960647583,
-0.1607484519481659,
-0.40228861570358276,
0.34303513169288635,
0.28828009963035583,
0.6233772039413452,
0.0002619281876832247,
-0.09374041110277176,
-0.047018926590681076,
-0.2343166172504425,
-0.1223427876830101,
-0.7803391218185425,
0.8265321254730225,
-0.9847562313079834,
-0.907289981842041,
-0.06608512252569199,
-0.1627216935157776,
-0.3037720024585724,
0.08918994665145874,
-0.17520485818386078,
0.2769683003425598,
-0.06473752111196518,
-0.19914525747299194,
0.7567391395568848,
-0.2634868621826172,
0.21798382699489594,
0.9396829605102539,
-0.1312040239572525,
-0.5377712249755859,
1.0274091958999634,
-0.12644897401332855,
0.5019177198410034,
0.6595319509506226,
0.6882175207138062,
-0.4598475992679596,
-0.3427049219608307,
-0.23523294925689697,
0.48312509059906006,
-0.5604197382926941,
-0.44019174575805664,
-0.06225484237074852,
-0.047752879559993744,
-0.34105175733566284,
0.07857747375965118,
-0.6117280721664429,
-0.3200877904891968,
-0.4833683371543884,
-0.004374101758003235,
0.24150985479354858,
0.3846738934516907,
-0.14481890201568604,
0.2537425458431244,
-0.4703781306743622,
0.11353185772895813,
0.4463535249233246,
0.6710307598114014,
-0.026814743876457214,
-0.8358794450759888,
-0.2521604597568512,
0.2204555720090866,
-0.36447077989578247,
-0.6989920139312744,
0.1898384392261505,
0.36130762100219727,
0.7025695443153381,
0.5030019879341125,
0.1927463859319687,
0.7549160122871399,
-0.4771580696105957,
0.31640034914016724,
0.17313328385353088,
-0.9042747616767883,
0.6081280708312988,
-0.09494434297084808,
0.37003278732299805,
0.8484780192375183,
0.26761531829833984,
-0.5051708221435547,
-0.15218988060951233,
-0.4420296549797058,
-0.470477432012558,
0.6274217963218689,
-0.17817199230194092,
0.23400525748729706,
0.06810244172811508,
0.6667901277542114,
0.10374373942613602,
0.29344311356544495,
-0.7347249388694763,
-0.14412784576416016,
-0.23127281665802002,
-0.29737231135368347,
0.11752089112997055,
-0.24363499879837036,
-0.30591076612472534,
-0.21546216309070587,
1.0324195623397827,
-0.42176127433776855,
0.10595439374446869,
0.3516984283924103,
0.020577017217874527,
-0.22885851562023163,
0.2857522964477539,
0.7959414720535278,
0.6492204666137695,
-0.20182648301124573,
0.03067018836736679,
-0.266142874956131,
0.09884133189916611,
0.4567663371562958,
-0.09678424149751663,
-0.14362426102161407,
-0.3824387490749359,
0.04663992300629616,
0.784633994102478,
0.13292910158634186,
-0.734515368938446,
0.5045409798622131,
0.07509070634841919,
-0.044744107872247696,
-0.06689019501209259,
0.32597407698631287,
-0.23079925775527954,
0.1775568723678589,
0.17829087376594543,
-0.2710776627063751,
0.04540541023015976,
-0.5437754392623901,
0.270216166973114,
0.5726760625839233,
-0.6335954070091248,
-0.3683316707611084,
0.3937566876411438,
0.4671650528907776,
-0.33918094635009766,
0.6313812732696533,
-0.4481249153614044,
-0.5945367813110352,
0.3821786642074585,
0.46956270933151245,
0.9086350798606873,
-0.26817643642425537,
0.40855973958969116,
0.46466299891471863,
0.06287527084350586,
-0.008781243115663528,
0.06937500834465027,
-0.16934093832969666,
-1.0430192947387695,
-0.6574527621269226,
-0.6222129464149475,
-0.3664347231388092,
0.10231766849756241,
-0.4277595281600952,
0.1806984692811966,
-0.5579951405525208,
-0.16015753149986267,
-0.36926695704460144,
0.13544656336307526,
-0.6525553464889526,
0.17398421466350555,
0.12339547276496887,
0.4660111665725708,
-0.4395616948604584,
0.774847149848938,
0.3783303499221802,
-0.4538303017616272,
-0.957626223564148,
-0.013770479708909988,
-0.2394905388355255,
-1.1529455184936523,
0.9081115126609802,
-0.06031758710741997,
-0.26554492115974426,
0.05959973856806755,
-0.20719918608665466,
-1.1054519414901733,
0.8854755163192749,
0.5884838700294495,
-0.8715546131134033,
0.030611813068389893,
-0.008665436878800392,
0.6274685263633728,
-0.2923250198364258,
0.15256302058696747,
0.47637784481048584,
0.3560193181037903,
0.056188859045505524,
-0.9942178130149841,
0.07167287170886993,
0.31508490443229675,
0.11458837240934372,
0.31445246934890747,
-0.7792529463768005,
0.4134404957294464,
-0.34669890999794006,
-0.2735711932182312,
-0.22674591839313507,
0.6587475538253784,
0.0778302401304245,
-0.2630561590194702,
0.46912941336631775,
0.7474846243858337,
0.6196625232696533,
0.0013260156847536564,
0.9088020324707031,
-0.5041332244873047,
0.3413930833339691,
1.3373970985412598,
-0.21117135882377625,
0.758200466632843,
0.5699434280395508,
-0.11674967408180237,
0.5967663526535034,
0.5945623517036438,
0.20325331389904022,
0.8219691514968872,
0.5304899215698242,
-0.19646967947483063,
-0.178200364112854,
-0.17510701715946198,
-0.160578191280365,
0.34727057814598083,
0.015465348958969116,
-0.24354961514472961,
-0.15903842449188232,
-0.2137884497642517,
-0.13991564512252808,
0.39021676778793335,
-0.37133803963661194,
1.003912329673767,
-0.1297963559627533,
-1.096684455871582,
0.7087537050247192,
0.06462103873491287,
0.6787129044532776,
-0.625169575214386,
0.018800515681505203,
-0.4328666031360626,
0.34258225560188293,
-0.1868479698896408,
-0.8142109513282776,
0.29932352900505066,
-0.552707314491272,
-0.2213396430015564,
-0.35789886116981506,
0.4590233266353607,
-0.7946456670761108,
-0.03902322053909302,
0.16765113174915314,
0.0931360051035881,
-0.24701407551765442,
-0.18587985634803772,
-0.9261906147003174,
0.022779321298003197,
0.1867978721857071,
-0.14918746054172516,
0.24382638931274414,
0.25205785036087036,
0.21485768258571625,
0.8831578493118286,
0.45165160298347473,
0.1330372542142868,
-0.3826799988746643,
0.15468883514404297,
0.6678608059883118,
-0.5611202716827393,
-0.41809743642807007,
-0.7730626463890076,
0.3794063925743103,
0.08010692894458771,
-0.4011411666870117,
0.4023956060409546,
0.2154081165790558,
0.9846911430358887,
-0.10713790357112885,
0.46945297718048096,
0.2894711196422577,
0.5904236435890198,
-0.4649617075920105,
0.466217964887619,
-0.6427255868911743,
0.2616449296474457,
-0.042888738214969635,
-0.9498983025550842,
0.06905503571033478,
0.5924919247627258,
-0.3597662150859833,
-0.1720460057258606,
0.35560423135757446,
1.038130760192871,
0.240177184343338,
-0.553735613822937,
0.3499498963356018,
0.012577547691762447,
0.44733136892318726,
0.37985751032829285,
0.6770272254943848,
-0.16616928577423096,
0.432727187871933,
-0.43794503808021545,
-0.22077107429504395,
-0.1649211049079895,
-0.9628663063049316,
-0.6046173572540283,
-0.49559271335601807,
-0.5901280641555786,
-0.09477244317531586,
0.15125028789043427,
0.9448164105415344,
0.8711981177330017,
-0.6558160781860352,
-0.31132763624191284,
-0.1976698637008667,
0.43005305528640747,
-0.3061370253562927,
-0.283017635345459,
0.25294825434684753,
-0.6487501859664917,
-0.5829412937164307,
0.39843618869781494,
0.3592720627784729,
0.18318630754947662,
-0.6074250340461731,
-0.476317822933197,
0.038661614060401917,
0.14567919075489044,
0.369180291891098,
0.5255383253097534,
-0.8726176619529724,
-0.55717533826828,
-0.0763663649559021,
-0.23607248067855835,
0.12352581322193146,
0.7210695147514343,
-0.7885746359825134,
0.5888988971710205,
0.3834039270877838,
0.8315566182136536,
0.1620604395866394,
0.22369346022605896,
0.9402509927749634,
-0.7359761595726013,
-0.11607979238033295,
0.36192941665649414,
0.17016898095607758,
0.3800148665904999,
-0.5082252025604248,
0.3279893100261688,
0.010042522102594376,
-0.7472333908081055,
-0.6286178827285767,
0.5207769274711609,
-0.6716791987419128,
-0.22925706207752228,
1.0474328994750977,
-0.09759652614593506,
-0.2651573419570923,
0.35315969586372375,
-0.2875765264034271,
-0.04346707835793495,
-0.6567288041114807,
1.1127876043319702,
0.5923269987106323,
-0.3357354998588562,
-0.27763667702674866,
0.2575274407863617,
0.8173857927322388,
0.5779127478599548,
-0.7306475639343262,
0.15038491785526276,
0.37141743302345276,
0.36977946758270264,
0.030914392322301865,
0.6538264155387878,
0.13430368900299072,
0.048431385308504105,
-0.4367407262325287,
0.4135077893733978,
-0.1602674126625061,
-0.35742783546447754,
-0.44535285234451294,
-0.2626580595970154,
0.4710372984409332,
-0.059571050107479095
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21028v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21028v2
|
LACIE: Listener-Aware Finetuning for Confidence Calibration in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:16:38
| 2024-07-03T12:49:23
|
Elias Stengel-Eskin, Peter Hase, Mohit Bansal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
When answering questions, LLMs can convey not only an answer, but a level of
confidence about the answer being correct. This includes explicit confidence
markers (e.g. giving a numeric score) as well as implicit markers, like an
authoritative tone or elaborating with additional knowledge. For LLMs to be
trustworthy knowledge sources, the confidence they convey should match their
actual expertise; however, most current models tend towards overconfidence. To
calibrate both implicit and explicit confidence markers, we introduce a
pragmatic, listener-aware finetuning method (LACIE) that models the listener,
considering not only whether an answer is right, but whether it will be
accepted by a listener. We cast calibration as preference optimization,
creating data via a two-agent game, where a speaker model's outputs are judged
by a simulated listener. We then finetune three LLMs (Mistral-7B, Llama3-8B,
Llama3-70B) with LACIE, and show that the resulting models are better
calibrated w.r.t. a simulated listener. Crucially, these trends transfer to
human listeners, helping them correctly predict model correctness: we conduct a
human evaluation where annotators accept or reject an LLM's answers, finding
that training with LACIE results in 47% fewer incorrect answers being accepted
while maintaining the same level of acceptance for correct answers.
Furthermore, LACIE generalizes to another dataset, resulting in a large
increase in truthfulness on TruthfulQA when trained on TriviaQA. Our analysis
indicates that LACIE leads to a better confidence separation between correct
and incorrect examples. Qualitatively, we find that a LACIE-trained model
hedges more and implicitly signals certainty when it is correct by using an
authoritative tone or including details. Finally, LACIE finetuning leads to an
emergent increase in model abstention (e.g. saying "I don't know") for answers
that are likely wrong.
|
[
-0.4031314253807068,
-0.6730732321739197,
0.7172296047210693,
0.004128375090658665,
0.1459478735923767,
-0.10884644091129303,
-0.29460278153419495,
-0.560915470123291,
-0.06878340989351273,
0.46029147505760193,
-0.6738966107368469,
-0.5588371157646179,
-0.38747438788414,
-0.1994493156671524,
-0.04320015385746956,
0.9205510020256042,
0.19881312549114227,
0.2461247742176056,
-0.31750205159187317,
0.02802690491080284,
-0.5930238366127014,
-0.3439885675907135,
-0.6209808588027954,
-0.4357539415359497,
0.4506085216999054,
0.665320873260498,
0.45708808302879333,
0.4522400498390198,
0.36010250449180603,
0.22340027987957,
-0.07466283440589905,
0.3168559670448303,
-0.8148748278617859,
0.23005622625350952,
-0.0908755213022232,
-0.9048425555229187,
-0.44194403290748596,
0.276343435049057,
0.3129464387893677,
0.6493247747421265,
-0.07405265420675278,
0.375044047832489,
0.03852827847003937,
0.5561752915382385,
-0.8105412721633911,
0.3085586130619049,
-0.7622398734092712,
-0.16578654944896698,
0.06027620658278465,
-0.31689366698265076,
-0.6281715035438538,
-0.6336765289306641,
0.3162285089492798,
-0.7960979342460632,
0.2040434181690216,
0.0062439339235424995,
0.6013017296791077,
0.609132707118988,
-0.21749356389045715,
-0.26969408988952637,
-0.7631281018257141,
0.9532899856567383,
-0.8592798113822937,
0.366116464138031,
0.5795944333076477,
0.29480260610580444,
-0.1173078715801239,
-0.36139947175979614,
-0.6146457195281982,
-0.3772750794887543,
0.11066587269306183,
0.37212228775024414,
0.1485789716243744,
0.1367555409669876,
0.33680272102355957,
0.2093592882156372,
-0.20450113713741302,
0.16436083614826202,
-0.1365433633327484,
-0.44374775886535645,
0.6295414566993713,
-0.08156684786081314,
-0.0867517814040184,
0.25817835330963135,
-0.1955190747976303,
-0.11422227323055267,
-0.8203009963035583,
0.30461227893829346,
0.3617076575756073,
0.3782053291797638,
0.17807865142822266,
0.348316490650177,
-0.24498388171195984,
0.8587206602096558,
0.43460366129875183,
-0.27176451683044434,
0.12019547820091248,
0.03198796138167381,
-0.084925577044487,
0.2845400869846344,
0.462101548910141,
0.7452343702316284,
0.7190004587173462,
-0.013168109580874443,
-0.08900148421525955,
0.1855512261390686,
-0.06137643754482269,
-0.8571265339851379,
-0.3438408374786377,
0.488199383020401,
0.028467774391174316,
-0.31016573309898376,
-0.005739087238907814,
-0.3419358432292938,
-0.5454497337341309,
-0.48774275183677673,
0.6502625346183777,
-0.2930421829223633,
-0.053044311702251434,
0.32589033246040344,
0.14939159154891968,
0.32841670513153076,
0.5046658515930176,
-0.8525159358978271,
0.27661025524139404,
0.691543459892273,
0.4357888400554657,
0.11367584019899368,
-0.0013053828151896596,
-0.9386184811592102,
0.04822440445423126,
-0.42913833260536194,
0.5869404673576355,
-0.1910402476787567,
-0.1979745775461197,
-0.005412825383245945,
-0.16057926416397095,
-0.11854828894138336,
-0.4740632176399231,
0.6292027235031128,
-0.49540776014328003,
0.2827823758125305,
-0.3368166983127594,
-0.9025925397872925,
-0.25645798444747925,
0.36990785598754883,
-0.6253527402877808,
0.8051992058753967,
-0.2686430513858795,
-0.5168260335922241,
0.2255493849515915,
-0.4116976261138916,
-0.10039360076189041,
-0.13608583807945251,
-0.09250964224338531,
-0.17152521014213562,
0.007739395834505558,
0.20295196771621704,
0.5776495337486267,
-0.12273804843425751,
0.299267053604126,
-0.3043752610683441,
-0.5447637438774109,
0.5719961524009705,
-0.529106080532074,
0.525297224521637,
0.06655481457710266,
-0.1738140881061554,
-0.08263857662677765,
-0.591837465763092,
0.33804458379745483,
-0.2817484736442566,
-0.1917850375175476,
-0.16715474426746368,
-0.02021319419145584,
-0.09713061153888702,
0.027474084869027138,
0.11759159713983536,
-0.8713132739067078,
-0.22974751889705658,
-0.6585392951965332,
0.3861117660999298,
0.5986794829368591,
0.10048657655715942,
0.3743695914745331,
-0.7560305595397949,
0.11747538298368454,
-0.23458616435527802,
0.21665441989898682,
-0.03388451039791107,
-0.5623205900192261,
-0.8136308789253235,
-0.04322301968932152,
0.5305373072624207,
0.8337416648864746,
-0.3008044362068176,
0.3441861867904663,
-0.20777781307697296,
-0.42161065340042114,
-1.0630797147750854,
0.22819210588932037,
0.46398118138313293,
0.7978498935699463,
0.3334413766860962,
-0.18096201121807098,
-0.20642617344856262,
-0.9369223117828369,
-0.07639668881893158,
-0.35709431767463684,
-0.012519084848463535,
0.3199606239795685,
0.1492009460926056,
0.14300499856472015,
1.0131988525390625,
-0.5677938461303711,
-0.1986590325832367,
0.2001725286245346,
0.2927797734737396,
0.15406768023967743,
0.5269237160682678,
0.4040422737598419,
-0.9337018132209778,
-0.423884779214859,
-0.0846075639128685,
-0.32983341813087463,
-0.24808096885681152,
-0.03173283487558365,
-0.05957284942269325,
0.16510294377803802,
0.25519633293151855,
-0.4503082036972046,
0.06554477661848068,
0.569197952747345,
-0.02586226351559162,
0.49074822664260864,
0.18697340786457062,
0.12045348435640335,
-0.9778940677642822,
0.031873706728219986,
0.05901160091161728,
-0.5060412287712097,
-0.8411892652511597,
0.09982352703809738,
-0.04572458192706108,
0.46570679545402527,
-0.5665238499641418,
0.5556266903877258,
-0.1611870527267456,
0.24240262806415558,
-0.10798868536949158,
0.4015786051750183,
0.3057451546192169,
0.5339981913566589,
0.1191077008843422,
0.8978932499885559,
0.29889756441116333,
-0.6088679432868958,
0.3271283805370331,
0.2624397277832031,
-0.4986521899700165,
0.5405130386352539,
-0.5241919755935669,
0.229227215051651,
-0.15469133853912354,
0.049719806760549545,
-1.20352303981781,
-0.1533871740102768,
0.035619042813777924,
-0.6946322321891785,
0.4096244275569916,
-0.1416175812482834,
-0.0799662247300148,
-0.14203624427318573,
-0.26930588483810425,
0.3015275001525879,
0.3659113049507141,
-0.404966801404953,
0.5071454644203186,
0.2762243449687958,
-0.3028019070625305,
-0.9016315340995789,
-0.8214946985244751,
-0.2354021519422531,
-0.05312429741024971,
-0.5812631845474243,
0.15390799939632416,
-0.7440884709358215,
-0.38079214096069336,
-0.46884748339653015,
-0.40050768852233887,
-0.16589175164699554,
0.23674063384532928,
0.31836649775505066,
0.36449676752090454,
-0.20072782039642334,
0.30455100536346436,
-0.22128716111183167,
-0.15398022532463074,
0.06494496762752533,
-0.21307553350925446,
0.36019524931907654,
-0.39216145873069763,
-0.37746381759643555,
-0.6464214324951172,
0.13228625059127808,
0.5395512580871582,
-0.24754108488559723,
0.4733702838420868,
0.7449455857276917,
-0.3040817081928253,
-0.00014105610898695886,
-1.1785697937011719,
-0.46674951910972595,
-0.40499281883239746,
0.09779990464448929,
-0.4085434377193451,
-1.135230302810669,
0.5953576564788818,
-0.09392052888870239,
0.18706907331943512,
0.2598026692867279,
0.4809151887893677,
-0.36608508229255676,
1.003101110458374,
0.518349289894104,
-0.07589253038167953,
0.33863648772239685,
-0.35785719752311707,
-0.026581255719065666,
-0.692537248134613,
-0.1727387011051178,
-0.5325110554695129,
-0.14598430693149567,
-0.5576068758964539,
-0.3441479802131653,
0.07652223110198975,
0.043990593403577805,
-0.254687637090683,
-0.10088394582271576,
-0.2974652647972107,
0.7347360849380493,
0.7814028263092041,
0.3787226676940918,
0.32824966311454773,
-0.31310781836509705,
-0.03595418110489845,
-0.19759471714496613,
-0.5532536506652832,
-0.5559572577476501,
0.9184502959251404,
0.4526875913143158,
0.769119143486023,
0.17778530716896057,
0.689794659614563,
0.15265347063541412,
0.5261002779006958,
-1.118713140487671,
0.41370296478271484,
0.01743307337164879,
-0.7624747157096863,
-0.3960360884666443,
-0.44250747561454773,
-0.15433891117572784,
-0.1701708883047104,
-0.5106262564659119,
-0.7611513137817383,
0.49633127450942993,
0.3777703642845154,
-0.8396236300468445,
-0.006795852445065975,
-0.8404830098152161,
0.7274874448776245,
-0.10120336711406708,
-0.6216280460357666,
0.0876016616821289,
-0.8549182415008545,
0.28130364418029785,
-0.2160850465297699,
0.13030856847763062,
-0.44307801127433777,
0.24581660330295563,
0.5931673049926758,
-0.09023725241422653,
1.0825655460357666,
-0.21433581411838531,
-0.27785924077033997,
0.4754810631275177,
0.3794592022895813,
0.5935795903205872,
0.10568881779909134,
-0.3909718096256256,
-0.1457694172859192,
0.29871731996536255,
-0.17896564304828644,
-0.693667471408844,
0.7102562785148621,
-0.8424252271652222,
-0.7636644244194031,
-0.062414053827524185,
-0.729066789150238,
-0.5935003161430359,
0.067114919424057,
0.28585028648376465,
0.4863450229167938,
-0.21502527594566345,
0.11488094925880432,
1.1462963819503784,
0.212930366396904,
-0.01571289822459221,
0.723781406879425,
0.1165151298046112,
-0.12239118665456772,
0.6600800156593323,
-0.07368896901607513,
0.5856389999389648,
0.6273600459098816,
0.20263910293579102,
-0.4704779386520386,
-0.4989544749259949,
-0.13607855141162872,
0.24980445206165314,
-0.8170369267463684,
-0.28739088773727417,
-0.27154940366744995,
-0.23888647556304932,
-0.29191839694976807,
-0.05438343062996864,
-0.35192015767097473,
-0.7552077770233154,
-0.19888778030872345,
-0.3661079406738281,
0.3575546145439148,
0.4190923571586609,
-0.15548157691955566,
0.5379210710525513,
-0.5142766237258911,
0.039205409586429596,
0.73288494348526,
0.3282053768634796,
-0.27569779753685,
-0.5964177250862122,
-0.10184820741415024,
0.5167601108551025,
-0.06864763796329498,
-0.8519139885902405,
0.10622544586658478,
0.3431200385093689,
0.5378181338310242,
0.3792928159236908,
0.22629618644714355,
0.6712124347686768,
-0.2777229845523834,
0.5024680495262146,
0.09048674255609512,
-0.9799011945724487,
0.5287444591522217,
-0.3437701463699341,
0.16254939138889313,
1.050502896308899,
0.26949888467788696,
-0.6252083778381348,
-0.5412478446960449,
-0.25264865159988403,
-0.5013253688812256,
0.5507567524909973,
-0.00628281943500042,
0.14080336689949036,
0.1057797521352768,
0.5711843967437744,
0.119532011449337,
0.18248087167739868,
-0.7722002863883972,
-0.133173868060112,
-0.10148611664772034,
-0.3842349350452423,
-0.2646438777446747,
-0.4939376711845398,
-0.48203709721565247,
-0.1252724528312683,
0.9128131866455078,
-0.4092947542667389,
0.14885811507701874,
0.3509213924407959,
-0.20506279170513153,
-0.26235565543174744,
0.4353474974632263,
0.5874665975570679,
0.49870744347572327,
-0.7534862160682678,
0.005377736408263445,
0.21009723842144012,
-0.3245023190975189,
-0.04275108128786087,
0.13543160259723663,
-0.33431318402290344,
-0.2788326144218445,
0.38624709844589233,
0.8387921452522278,
0.052601009607315063,
-0.5607897639274597,
0.643333911895752,
-0.07685936242341995,
-0.36908668279647827,
-0.24314893782138824,
0.31207042932510376,
0.08355984836816788,
0.2830752432346344,
0.24277912080287933,
0.21115273237228394,
0.23118402063846588,
-0.3643740713596344,
0.21658428013324738,
0.3847886323928833,
-0.7100374698638916,
-0.03924225643277168,
0.6361843347549438,
0.2749144434928894,
-0.124346062541008,
0.40694355964660645,
0.10740472376346588,
-0.46509167551994324,
0.5220361351966858,
0.5489386916160583,
0.6208924651145935,
-0.4300646483898163,
0.16881921887397766,
0.35142385959625244,
0.20759283006191254,
-0.21833153069019318,
0.2835681438446045,
-0.0886889174580574,
-1.1202712059020996,
-0.7439214587211609,
-0.5821499824523926,
-0.705558717250824,
0.06853922456502914,
-0.8765668272972107,
-0.12857560813426971,
-0.3451153635978699,
-0.4803197383880615,
0.2577681839466095,
0.26081931591033936,
-0.7109634280204773,
0.3705615997314453,
0.3394678831100464,
1.0550862550735474,
-0.9291216731071472,
0.5970216393470764,
0.6654914021492004,
-0.2443239986896515,
-0.9368140697479248,
0.012430243194103241,
0.0883696898818016,
-0.9750033020973206,
0.43043386936187744,
0.3552382290363312,
-0.4411008059978485,
0.3047697842121124,
-0.8234277963638306,
-0.7122335433959961,
1.162777304649353,
0.45700177550315857,
-0.9223691821098328,
0.19761526584625244,
0.0374482125043869,
0.499347448348999,
-0.45161139965057373,
0.39232730865478516,
0.5781520009040833,
0.4455740749835968,
0.4840066134929657,
-0.922631561756134,
-0.10248497128486633,
-0.200272336602211,
-0.30179905891418457,
-0.12180968374013901,
-0.6335452198982239,
0.5221476554870605,
-0.40479084849357605,
-0.03000555746257305,
0.4182552993297577,
0.4275532364845276,
0.27781808376312256,
0.3915962278842926,
0.5217288136482239,
0.3299073576927185,
1.1058911085128784,
-0.3108016550540924,
0.7461686730384827,
-0.46830669045448303,
0.26513251662254333,
1.394496202468872,
-0.34396594762802124,
1.047476887702942,
0.486217200756073,
0.1885223388671875,
0.46354156732559204,
0.6216834783554077,
0.2647037208080292,
0.4960978329181671,
0.1982346475124359,
-0.424578994512558,
-0.7251265645027161,
-0.3754940629005432,
-0.1069202646613121,
0.4331546127796173,
0.4960116744041443,
-0.10945708304643631,
0.20115479826927185,
-0.012798813171684742,
0.04603460803627968,
0.3479378819465637,
-0.43529021739959717,
0.6185135841369629,
0.14857743680477142,
-0.7376359701156616,
0.5266125798225403,
-0.1499524563550949,
0.464022159576416,
-0.45614802837371826,
0.05180041864514351,
-0.2635478675365448,
0.3224852383136749,
-0.20692723989486694,
-0.94461590051651,
-0.13028955459594727,
-0.16035494208335876,
-0.32520121335983276,
-0.014604184776544571,
0.6509221196174622,
-0.6862978339195251,
-0.30299443006515503,
0.10792050510644913,
0.6254351139068604,
0.041895873844623566,
-0.091713547706604,
-0.48780566453933716,
-0.16640333831310272,
0.09150125831365585,
-0.08370789140462875,
-0.17397141456604004,
0.20622947812080383,
0.04201078787446022,
0.8319328427314758,
0.5928187370300293,
0.06579650193452835,
-0.13019083440303802,
0.4027070701122284,
0.5575852394104004,
-0.27423951029777527,
-0.33859267830848694,
-0.6053259372711182,
0.453114777803421,
-0.02727445401251316,
0.008797410875558853,
0.5995475649833679,
0.3441409766674042,
0.717559814453125,
0.0037405211478471756,
0.6085094213485718,
0.4785081148147583,
0.6967272758483887,
-0.6205739974975586,
0.5593704581260681,
-0.2861042618751526,
0.30805909633636475,
-0.18134799599647522,
-0.8738025426864624,
-0.5347134470939636,
0.7865318655967712,
-0.517224907875061,
-0.045441582798957825,
0.2595652937889099,
1.0483914613723755,
0.14534851908683777,
0.20308490097522736,
0.3682074248790741,
0.41248196363449097,
0.07359933108091354,
0.7999421954154968,
0.8942657709121704,
-0.3462860584259033,
0.4110080301761627,
-0.272556871175766,
-0.4034728407859802,
-0.18499302864074707,
-0.804417610168457,
-0.8639008402824402,
-0.3840515613555908,
-0.41343632340431213,
-0.22739991545677185,
0.267132967710495,
0.9082648754119873,
0.817672848701477,
-1.0325703620910645,
-0.19519071280956268,
0.20319150388240814,
-0.0932110846042633,
-0.15611161291599274,
-0.2105964720249176,
0.12129189819097519,
-0.13319529592990875,
-0.6921833753585815,
0.34711703658103943,
-0.09958326071500778,
0.28321483731269836,
-0.10552162677049637,
-0.11859406530857086,
-0.13517141342163086,
0.3223177492618561,
0.4241549074649811,
0.31009283661842346,
-0.6547545790672302,
-0.6076177954673767,
0.10885933041572571,
-0.09263833612203598,
-0.03709796071052551,
0.27422717213630676,
-0.7632457613945007,
0.6106804013252258,
0.18029536306858063,
0.4531802833080292,
0.6707950830459595,
0.24939052760601044,
0.6712213158607483,
-0.871191680431366,
0.009364895522594452,
0.34002411365509033,
0.17417128384113312,
0.5099547505378723,
-0.4329714775085449,
0.49166783690452576,
-0.07883751392364502,
-0.6262488961219788,
-0.6624673008918762,
0.30097493529319763,
-1.1935683488845825,
-0.03146004676818848,
0.9934042692184448,
-0.1130412146449089,
-0.14124126732349396,
-0.05610964819788933,
-0.3224143087863922,
0.2217470407485962,
-0.48378533124923706,
0.7469950914382935,
0.9042611718177795,
0.12978072464466095,
-0.1285753846168518,
-0.6767976880073547,
0.675010085105896,
0.572382926940918,
-0.36814412474632263,
0.20101632177829742,
0.6210342645645142,
0.40886783599853516,
0.42726418375968933,
0.6798110604286194,
0.2821599841117859,
0.43783968687057495,
-0.40862002968788147,
0.12427736818790436,
-0.17156507074832916,
-0.4308619797229767,
-0.177246555685997,
-0.025920981541275978,
0.48887649178504944,
-0.1414550244808197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21022v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21022v1
|
You Only Scan Once: Efficient Multi-dimension Sequential Modeling with LightNet
| 2024-05-31T17:09:16
| 2024-05-31T17:09:16
|
Zhen Qin, Yuxin Mao, Xuyang Shen, Dong Li, Jing Zhang, Yuchao Dai, Yiran Zhong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Linear attention mechanisms have gained prominence in causal language models
due to their linear computational complexity and enhanced speed. However, the
inherent decay mechanism in linear attention presents challenges when applied
to multi-dimensional sequence modeling tasks, such as image processing and
multi-modal learning. In these scenarios, the utilization of sequential
scanning to establish a global receptive field necessitates multiple scans for
multi-dimensional data, thereby leading to inefficiencies. This paper
identifies the inefficiency caused by a multiplicative linear recurrence and
proposes an efficient alternative additive linear recurrence to avoid the
issue, as it can handle multi-dimensional data within a single scan. We further
develop an efficient multi-dimensional sequential modeling framework called
LightNet based on the new recurrence. Moreover, we present two new
multi-dimensional linear relative positional encoding methods, MD-TPE and
MD-LRPE to enhance the model's ability to discern positional information in
multi-dimensional scenarios. Our empirical evaluations across various tasks,
including image classification, image generation, bidirectional language
modeling, and autoregressive language modeling, demonstrate the efficacy of
LightNet, showcasing its potential as a versatile and efficient solution for
multi-dimensional sequential modeling.
|
[
-0.11062192171812057,
-0.5234128832817078,
0.8064789772033691,
0.2002139836549759,
-0.24322915077209473,
-0.2647790014743805,
0.25323212146759033,
-0.5384166836738586,
0.0675855353474617,
0.2148507684469223,
-0.3020991086959839,
-0.18319517374038696,
-0.48462149500846863,
-0.07125115394592285,
-0.5502637624740601,
0.334059476852417,
0.10469991713762283,
0.20996251702308655,
0.06295901536941528,
-0.3616923391819,
-0.1689084768295288,
-0.3608916401863098,
-1.0480304956436157,
-0.2049080729484558,
1.1063923835754395,
0.21716856956481934,
0.5612940788269043,
0.725782036781311,
0.7125298976898193,
0.4083499610424042,
0.16743913292884827,
0.2299383133649826,
-0.5158602595329285,
0.1521744430065155,
-0.18564389646053314,
-0.03137710317969322,
-0.2841942310333252,
0.029385412111878395,
0.8429614901542664,
1.1211961507797241,
-0.04268084838986397,
0.2959185838699341,
-0.14361639320850372,
0.690153181552887,
-0.5667784214019775,
-0.17773650586605072,
-0.553548276424408,
-0.058690380305051804,
-0.053815893828868866,
-0.3875123858451843,
-0.30770495533943176,
-0.34388864040374756,
0.2050391137599945,
-0.4931524395942688,
0.3621557950973511,
-0.3002075254917145,
0.49360227584838867,
0.31204044818878174,
-0.46771809458732605,
0.1637544184923172,
-0.8136739730834961,
0.6912577152252197,
-0.5643293857574463,
0.5736538767814636,
-0.016009168699383736,
0.252316415309906,
0.15962107479572296,
-1.1224437952041626,
-0.38656172156333923,
-0.1657027006149292,
-0.032943498343229294,
0.06574157625436783,
-0.047488633543252945,
-0.07360553741455078,
0.1885412186384201,
-0.073868528008461,
-0.6468343734741211,
-0.06639672070741653,
-0.3616466224193573,
0.035327646881341934,
0.45902183651924133,
0.299153596162796,
-0.044850192964076996,
0.2768610715866089,
-0.7506306767463684,
-0.11372240632772446,
-0.23105886578559875,
0.07623262703418732,
0.03944772109389305,
0.1893167346715927,
0.20833516120910645,
0.3767275810241699,
0.08531735837459564,
0.7258420586585999,
0.10507772117853165,
-0.31121671199798584,
0.31339913606643677,
-0.6277392506599426,
-0.08609116822481155,
-0.3153212070465088,
0.7204034328460693,
0.17827200889587402,
-0.2602129876613617,
-0.007205781526863575,
-0.219496950507164,
0.1536787748336792,
0.48885175585746765,
-0.6193649768829346,
-0.08602405339479446,
0.3582826554775238,
-0.79587322473526,
-0.29227155447006226,
-0.2565421760082245,
-0.6870816349983215,
-0.5607560276985168,
-0.22518818080425262,
0.34612342715263367,
-0.2942039966583252,
-0.20344170928001404,
0.5192087888717651,
0.0818370133638382,
0.1271752119064331,
0.41797903180122375,
-0.49497678875923157,
-0.011393211781978607,
0.47520843148231506,
0.9270502924919128,
-0.0673665851354599,
-0.4816094636917114,
-0.40647801756858826,
-0.09741532802581787,
-0.4255860149860382,
0.6304908990859985,
-0.33431169390678406,
-0.0067950887605547905,
-0.23746439814567566,
-0.15573038160800934,
-0.350920706987381,
-0.12151544541120529,
0.5020656585693359,
-0.6955308318138123,
0.14871929585933685,
0.12403092533349991,
-0.3418503403663635,
-0.2731582820415497,
0.12982189655303955,
-0.9481689929962158,
0.49380531907081604,
-0.17345702648162842,
-1.0035184621810913,
0.06494828313589096,
-0.5742945671081543,
-0.46516847610473633,
-0.0738808661699295,
-0.18173474073410034,
-0.7326369881629944,
0.32683393359184265,
0.06157810240983963,
0.25786861777305603,
-0.24242636561393738,
0.36485525965690613,
-0.5003341436386108,
-0.36201000213623047,
0.1476619839668274,
-0.5688283443450928,
0.7261114716529846,
0.2526334524154663,
-0.09852828830480576,
0.2883138358592987,
-0.8978411555290222,
0.0059564500115811825,
0.3419664204120636,
-0.38048920035362244,
-0.24047963321208954,
0.28488150238990784,
0.181552916765213,
0.4573066532611847,
0.4518684446811676,
-0.5650450587272644,
0.25706779956817627,
-0.35900193452835083,
0.1656055450439453,
0.7147302627563477,
0.12389783561229706,
0.49426722526550293,
-0.3132759630680084,
0.4389839172363281,
0.35941144824028015,
0.15931864082813263,
-0.7018206715583801,
-0.4677567481994629,
-0.6092086434364319,
-0.206688791513443,
-0.031146513298153877,
0.483812153339386,
-0.9786282181739807,
-0.08716748654842377,
-0.29994210600852966,
-0.14470934867858887,
-0.3803360164165497,
-0.1929803490638733,
0.3630186915397644,
0.474875271320343,
0.10917409509420395,
-0.36909011006355286,
-0.6038558483123779,
-0.9822672605514526,
-0.07614268362522125,
0.002943215426057577,
0.03500567749142647,
0.2517114281654358,
0.28273627161979675,
-0.19082607328891754,
0.583301842212677,
-0.45469269156455994,
-0.1521763801574707,
-0.1554739773273468,
0.19739417731761932,
0.5302461385726929,
0.4109480679035187,
0.48388639092445374,
-0.8146386742591858,
-0.281483918428421,
-0.0027322331443428993,
-0.8279089331626892,
0.15230953693389893,
-0.5930410027503967,
0.03578123822808266,
0.19885553419589996,
0.46118029952049255,
-0.42374667525291443,
0.48608633875846863,
0.3881829082965851,
-0.3713947534561157,
0.06114315614104271,
-0.4565750062465668,
0.078335702419281,
-0.905135452747345,
0.5129354000091553,
0.26579904556274414,
-0.3605859875679016,
-1.0342020988464355,
0.256736159324646,
0.36110392212867737,
-0.41795894503593445,
-0.25743889808654785,
0.41632285714149475,
-0.5364590287208557,
-0.24638254940509796,
-0.272473007440567,
0.17557573318481445,
0.09977828711271286,
0.7549262642860413,
0.041443366557359695,
0.5610280632972717,
0.5723866820335388,
-0.5786495208740234,
0.23912492394447327,
-0.10361026972532272,
-0.32853344082832336,
0.2255759835243225,
-0.8142571449279785,
0.26957252621650696,
-0.5746995210647583,
-0.008342555724084377,
-1.226308822631836,
0.2713536024093628,
0.2982426881790161,
-0.22423632442951202,
0.3360132873058319,
0.18608279526233673,
-0.398762971162796,
-0.564897894859314,
-0.5295671820640564,
0.8729538321495056,
-0.0765228345990181,
-0.6226476430892944,
0.4175909459590912,
0.19396184384822845,
0.10093148797750473,
-0.7259963750839233,
-0.5815660953521729,
0.03498552367091179,
-0.05630725249648094,
-0.7533330321311951,
0.18435898423194885,
-0.20881372690200806,
0.09350834786891937,
-0.17113493382930756,
-0.10990454256534576,
-0.08071386814117432,
0.14734859764575958,
-0.1296384483575821,
0.12468431890010834,
-0.2140311598777771,
-0.018123500049114227,
-0.5155233144760132,
-0.47477537393569946,
-0.11340968310832977,
-0.836001455783844,
0.4000340700149536,
0.1040041372179985,
-0.5078185200691223,
-0.5604047775268555,
0.8181422352790833,
0.8345320224761963,
-0.3282948136329651,
0.4658595025539398,
0.5489805340766907,
-0.4392698109149933,
-0.06635159999132156,
-0.531049370765686,
-0.2774135172367096,
-0.4350419044494629,
0.6152974367141724,
-0.45042428374290466,
-0.3745018243789673,
0.4989308714866638,
0.10581841319799423,
0.16627304255962372,
-0.1997077763080597,
0.36278703808784485,
-0.10210443288087845,
1.2135686874389648,
0.8264179825782776,
-0.148898184299469,
0.8005171418190002,
-0.16218210756778717,
0.45161890983581543,
-0.6904760003089905,
-0.06881891191005707,
-0.29601290822029114,
-0.4765308201313019,
-0.2953798770904541,
-0.47836998105049133,
0.6448366641998291,
-0.15180858969688416,
-0.263281911611557,
0.13410387933254242,
-0.34689173102378845,
0.37845537066459656,
0.4474821984767914,
0.4705600440502167,
0.282397985458374,
0.25310444831848145,
-0.15794503688812256,
-0.15140041708946228,
-0.8586116433143616,
-0.1196325272321701,
0.8971128463745117,
0.5662841796875,
0.9323721528053284,
-0.0014822029042989016,
0.3964445888996124,
-0.05334177985787392,
-0.02825849875807762,
-0.6153085231781006,
0.4406948387622833,
-0.27865007519721985,
-0.38149726390838623,
-0.2941717505455017,
-0.49651071429252625,
-1.1885080337524414,
0.729410707950592,
0.2372838705778122,
-0.5442230701446533,
0.6762053370475769,
0.162916898727417,
-0.49902623891830444,
0.46816325187683105,
-0.5816116333007812,
0.743482768535614,
-0.4222387373447418,
-0.7142625451087952,
-0.18902607262134552,
-0.6664265394210815,
0.5212233662605286,
-0.2909686863422394,
0.11140239983797073,
0.11151320487260818,
-0.34640225768089294,
0.14339859783649445,
-0.30372288823127747,
0.9050559997558594,
-0.22010719776153564,
-0.10684247314929962,
-0.1284705400466919,
0.04764019325375557,
0.45017290115356445,
0.159030482172966,
-0.05723080411553383,
0.06897779554128647,
-0.32325857877731323,
-0.40163570642471313,
-0.4197870194911957,
0.5241256952285767,
-0.588477611541748,
-0.326703280210495,
-0.5020869374275208,
-0.6207786798477173,
0.050270628184080124,
0.47114333510398865,
0.08552494645118713,
0.7229989171028137,
0.11289221048355103,
0.008250808343291283,
0.7320054173469543,
-0.38214778900146484,
0.6844713687896729,
0.44603440165519714,
-0.2422746866941452,
-0.2621866762638092,
0.721266508102417,
-0.04405822232365608,
0.21574538946151733,
0.5201089382171631,
0.11384128779172897,
-0.28128811717033386,
-0.5381864905357361,
-0.1292629987001419,
0.317303329706192,
-0.8567488193511963,
-0.28131386637687683,
-0.7074205279350281,
-0.010859229601919651,
-0.2774667739868164,
-0.03926083445549011,
-0.533624529838562,
-0.28396087884902954,
-0.018605699762701988,
0.40584704279899597,
-0.10065757483243942,
0.5374251008033752,
-0.31977200508117676,
-0.04480841010808945,
-0.5381295084953308,
0.9652250409126282,
0.3332480192184448,
0.5455120801925659,
0.2560011148452759,
-0.3934555947780609,
-0.37528476119041443,
-0.12654443085193634,
-0.03451954945921898,
-0.7110490202903748,
0.35224390029907227,
0.09981080144643784,
0.7687514424324036,
0.3821529746055603,
-0.28400227427482605,
0.6141107082366943,
-0.7025700807571411,
0.39905402064323425,
0.33089470863342285,
-0.5904930233955383,
0.22783596813678741,
-0.21424072980880737,
0.7423883080482483,
0.3068056106567383,
0.270244300365448,
-0.5493111610412598,
-0.1381065994501114,
-0.3820491135120392,
-1.0882331132888794,
0.8605692386627197,
-0.023083899170160294,
-0.3062995970249176,
0.022398104891180992,
0.35527950525283813,
-0.27226656675338745,
0.15588650107383728,
-0.7463686466217041,
-0.48496562242507935,
-0.1964385211467743,
0.023401089012622833,
0.0464615598320961,
-0.4891352951526642,
0.10930034518241882,
-0.06906457245349884,
0.38196393847465515,
-0.08897611498832703,
0.4595526158809662,
0.4111219644546509,
-0.0769205316901207,
-0.11777700483798981,
-0.12538567185401917,
0.9068487286567688,
0.7151485681533813,
-0.11624584347009659,
0.1889548897743225,
-0.16616292297840118,
-0.33496585488319397,
0.18114270269870758,
0.1486845165491104,
-0.17975971102714539,
0.2219712883234024,
0.5092020630836487,
0.5621234178543091,
0.6062182188034058,
-0.019457461312413216,
0.5755869746208191,
-0.24702690541744232,
-0.03303239494562149,
-0.30237525701522827,
-0.580562949180603,
0.21478891372680664,
0.35897010564804077,
0.34174102544784546,
0.47839081287384033,
0.18980510532855988,
-0.12145818769931793,
0.3794606029987335,
0.311306893825531,
0.06738461554050446,
0.07369612157344818,
0.9475656747817993,
0.12414440512657166,
-0.01754610985517502,
0.676659107208252,
-0.019527360796928406,
-0.283197820186615,
0.5883233547210693,
0.33283236622810364,
0.868263304233551,
-0.34526947140693665,
-0.051248349249362946,
0.7685530185699463,
0.2986074388027191,
-0.08425764739513397,
0.4926001727581024,
-0.08155488222837448,
-0.9426814913749695,
-0.36081475019454956,
-0.2717284560203552,
0.0756838470697403,
0.12553541362285614,
-0.39844566583633423,
0.053004998713731766,
-0.6268129348754883,
-0.16696670651435852,
0.33633577823638916,
-0.17456884682178497,
-0.6263971924781799,
-0.10658866167068481,
0.5587683916091919,
0.8318020701408386,
-0.49606165289878845,
1.0914424657821655,
0.5557895302772522,
-0.40601879358291626,
-0.49590280652046204,
-0.2570984661579132,
0.10156400501728058,
-0.7023113369941711,
0.621675431728363,
0.26421648263931274,
-0.6828951239585876,
0.01720694825053215,
-0.45531609654426575,
-1.0194051265716553,
1.0423413515090942,
0.11261647939682007,
-0.6997100710868835,
-0.0419638492166996,
-0.10577183961868286,
0.38417309522628784,
-0.36805260181427,
0.19525673985481262,
0.4428282380104065,
0.33083224296569824,
0.027398448437452316,
-0.5145204067230225,
-0.11773893982172012,
-0.3547690808773041,
0.5511428117752075,
-0.02032366767525673,
-0.5290564298629761,
1.040759801864624,
-0.4525614380836487,
-0.5972515344619751,
0.2937338948249817,
0.478639155626297,
0.24622584879398346,
0.19701245427131653,
0.6264297366142273,
0.38199904561042786,
0.6324429512023926,
0.17080210149288177,
1.1652072668075562,
-0.5215094685554504,
0.2875881493091583,
1.190887689590454,
-0.36454451084136963,
0.4750322699546814,
0.38053661584854126,
0.1614757627248764,
-0.04459327459335327,
0.42958956956863403,
-0.0324709378182888,
0.6321755647659302,
-0.03799351677298546,
-0.26059362292289734,
-0.2184493988752365,
0.1231592446565628,
-0.29464665055274963,
0.22647829353809357,
0.2998064458370209,
-0.3742027282714844,
-0.4622189998626709,
0.16410300135612488,
-0.3280096650123596,
0.15197739005088806,
-0.32770779728889465,
0.6376035213470459,
0.027499467134475708,
-0.27670785784721375,
0.4686034619808197,
0.09169895946979523,
0.7091761827468872,
-0.7308380007743835,
-0.05182487145066261,
-0.545744001865387,
0.5672181248664856,
-0.03663165122270584,
-0.46637895703315735,
0.06850792467594147,
-0.4679334759712219,
-0.38992011547088623,
-0.6252186298370361,
0.6004987955093384,
-0.7215722799301147,
-0.7351605892181396,
0.4028105139732361,
0.3186477720737457,
-0.027830732986330986,
0.0555034801363945,
-0.8513169884681702,
0.299221932888031,
0.0750158503651619,
-0.3270755708217621,
-0.031975649297237396,
0.4538422226905823,
0.09466873109340668,
0.7995187640190125,
0.597130537033081,
-0.019787296652793884,
0.26962822675704956,
0.4232681393623352,
0.8159471154212952,
-0.8320688605308533,
-0.5547208786010742,
-0.5685744285583496,
0.6901600956916809,
-0.03383619710803032,
-0.16206347942352295,
0.5133475065231323,
0.5052682757377625,
0.7463375329971313,
-0.12676236033439636,
0.5356642603874207,
0.3309973180294037,
0.5985040068626404,
-0.31623315811157227,
0.5119845867156982,
-0.7269922494888306,
0.3320704698562622,
-0.03680528327822685,
-0.6449235677719116,
-0.6114874482154846,
0.8536418676376343,
0.059313610196113586,
0.0960472971200943,
0.9173797369003296,
0.7290114760398865,
-0.2085866630077362,
-0.2623402178287506,
0.5794102549552917,
0.1800672560930252,
0.40796521306037903,
0.8962476849555969,
0.6305969953536987,
-0.5399041771888733,
0.4360869824886322,
-0.4540531635284424,
-0.09514307230710983,
-0.25443559885025024,
-0.782654345035553,
-0.5914737582206726,
-0.6440107226371765,
-0.30685269832611084,
-0.10183440893888474,
-0.31488579511642456,
0.5849357843399048,
0.8532488346099854,
-0.6330885887145996,
-0.21275398135185242,
0.15046918392181396,
0.14019739627838135,
-0.29079607129096985,
-0.15372785925865173,
0.32908913493156433,
-0.6230095028877258,
-0.6998364925384521,
0.5746119022369385,
0.4100901186466217,
-0.0505724772810936,
-0.45090314745903015,
0.3818341791629791,
-0.6193352937698364,
-0.23551778495311737,
0.7209399938583374,
0.40277808904647827,
-0.4823114275932312,
-0.2734237611293793,
-0.08392376452684402,
-0.5612018704414368,
0.10028600692749023,
1.2886406183242798,
-0.6458211541175842,
0.7657032012939453,
0.7029968500137329,
0.6709250211715698,
0.5650796890258789,
-0.03424183279275894,
0.606579065322876,
-0.6139513850212097,
0.5622524619102478,
0.23513749241828918,
0.6266785860061646,
0.3198249340057373,
-0.36647599935531616,
0.48822224140167236,
0.12398533523082733,
-0.4634941816329956,
-0.46933603286743164,
0.4367046058177948,
-0.8237304091453552,
-0.4999227523803711,
0.6308939456939697,
-0.15125958621501923,
-0.11744903773069382,
-0.2631608843803406,
0.04190963879227638,
-0.05170435085892677,
-0.17074093222618103,
0.5495864152908325,
0.21124880015850067,
-0.11581449210643768,
-0.5594395399093628,
-0.5248404741287231,
0.16018089652061462,
0.44836223125457764,
-0.43957316875457764,
-0.05467706546187401,
0.6422789096832275,
0.12650085985660553,
0.42232975363731384,
0.7655903697013855,
-0.2061207890510559,
0.40912455320358276,
0.22390851378440857,
-0.003617578884586692,
-0.18440450727939606,
-0.6634795069694519,
-0.9776650667190552,
0.37525737285614014,
-0.07838156819343567,
-0.5197160243988037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.21018v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.21018v2
|
Improved Techniques for Optimization-Based Jailbreaking on Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T17:07:15
| 2024-06-05T16:35:49
|
Xiaojun Jia, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Yihao Huang, Jindong Gu, Yang Liu, Xiaochun Cao, Min Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) are being rapidly developed, and a key component
of their widespread deployment is their safety-related alignment. Many
red-teaming efforts aim to jailbreak LLMs, where among these efforts, the
Greedy Coordinate Gradient (GCG) attack's success has led to a growing interest
in the study of optimization-based jailbreaking techniques. Although GCG is a
significant milestone, its attacking efficiency remains unsatisfactory. In this
paper, we present several improved (empirical) techniques for
optimization-based jailbreaks like GCG. We first observe that the single target
template of "Sure" largely limits the attacking performance of GCG; given this,
we propose to apply diverse target templates containing harmful self-suggestion
and/or guidance to mislead LLMs. Besides, from the optimization aspects, we
propose an automatic multi-coordinate updating strategy in GCG (i.e.,
adaptively deciding how many tokens to replace in each step) to accelerate
convergence, as well as tricks like easy-to-hard initialisation. Then, we
combine these improved technologies to develop an efficient jailbreak method,
dubbed I-GCG. In our experiments, we evaluate on a series of benchmarks (such
as NeurIPS 2023 Red Teaming Track). The results demonstrate that our improved
techniques can help GCG outperform state-of-the-art jailbreaking attacks and
achieve nearly 100% attack success rate. The code is released at
https://github.com/jiaxiaojunQAQ/I-GCG.
|
[
-0.3572593331336975,
-0.8173858523368835,
0.3561074435710907,
0.3377305269241333,
-0.3463849425315857,
0.41921454668045044,
-0.5490416288375854,
-0.3893023431301117,
0.30547013878822327,
0.47240450978279114,
-0.6032549142837524,
-0.8339796662330627,
-0.703836977481842,
-0.0890219584107399,
-0.18455979228019714,
0.8899993300437927,
-0.01805753819644451,
0.1749727725982666,
0.25950613617897034,
-0.21768923103809357,
-0.7986380457878113,
-0.6233839392662048,
-0.3640275299549103,
0.11295658349990845,
0.18516798317432404,
0.5248135924339294,
0.472054123878479,
0.9401132464408875,
0.6890729069709778,
0.2774035930633545,
-0.1458219438791275,
0.11895808577537537,
-0.5008081793785095,
0.11344458162784576,
0.04008912667632103,
-0.288318932056427,
-0.2827915549278259,
-0.002990103792399168,
0.3482237458229065,
0.11479584872722626,
-0.32543206214904785,
-0.04479866474866867,
-0.07820790261030197,
0.8105854988098145,
-1.081101417541504,
-0.11037075519561768,
-0.8844936490058899,
-0.007784523535519838,
-0.35709476470947266,
0.05831843614578247,
-0.4717816114425659,
-0.2741115987300873,
-0.2367241084575653,
-0.529581606388092,
0.03578462451696396,
0.145833820104599,
0.5575047135353088,
0.3085159659385681,
0.08668962121009827,
-0.37923845648765564,
-0.32273533940315247,
0.9328305721282959,
-0.8070561289787292,
0.16796492040157318,
0.24693700671195984,
0.32307717204093933,
-0.616478443145752,
-0.3486488163471222,
-0.0990925207734108,
-0.6464377045631409,
0.12819749116897583,
0.02147620916366577,
-0.16755899786949158,
0.2286871373653412,
0.27769935131073,
-0.08969689160585403,
-0.38702860474586487,
0.4536953866481781,
-0.3210183382034302,
-0.12679927051067352,
0.6989628076553345,
0.04935094714164734,
0.5213171243667603,
0.04524163901805878,
-0.6554085612297058,
-0.0640135407447815,
-0.8520278930664062,
-0.24995774030685425,
0.7603505253791809,
0.2708217203617096,
-0.3108648955821991,
0.46519386768341064,
-0.17620965838432312,
0.9181645512580872,
0.18105049431324005,
-0.04269199073314667,
0.14559489488601685,
-0.5137300491333008,
0.1518392413854599,
0.1755174845457077,
0.7481092810630798,
0.6271496415138245,
0.4288560450077057,
-0.41255983710289,
-0.14079508185386658,
0.011589208617806435,
0.5275635123252869,
-0.6875686645507812,
-0.22391782701015472,
0.2791687846183777,
-0.22347237169742584,
-0.3847408890724182,
-0.07642102241516113,
-0.8927058577537537,
-0.5181768536567688,
-0.05274492874741554,
0.07000824064016342,
-0.6294657588005066,
0.1032191812992096,
0.22649145126342773,
-0.14479832351207733,
0.31537050008773804,
0.2617281377315521,
-1.1976864337921143,
0.23712599277496338,
0.83796226978302,
0.8849000930786133,
-0.1184096485376358,
-0.20386375486850739,
-0.8853461742401123,
0.20646123588085175,
-0.11034630239009857,
0.5047770738601685,
-0.2645743191242218,
-0.23156990110874176,
-0.21264292299747467,
-0.48217466473579407,
-0.10331803560256958,
-0.5859341621398926,
0.5088971257209778,
-0.5614269375801086,
-0.26708611845970154,
-0.13996954262256622,
-0.509554386138916,
0.09550396353006363,
0.5121240019798279,
-0.6422249674797058,
0.5861576199531555,
-0.12114135921001434,
-0.8813464045524597,
0.2675090432167053,
-0.5640299916267395,
-0.34739354252815247,
-0.06432083249092102,
0.022218147292733192,
-0.659053385257721,
0.12024684250354767,
0.4648546278476715,
0.38808223605155945,
-0.3401803970336914,
0.28783300518989563,
-0.41754141449928284,
-0.5408527255058289,
-0.1845540702342987,
0.09659187495708466,
0.9235998392105103,
0.3387022614479065,
-0.5723828673362732,
0.052320752292871475,
-0.43596792221069336,
0.15715833008289337,
0.28808772563934326,
-0.3059329092502594,
-0.3840857446193695,
0.31090888381004333,
-0.35389840602874756,
-0.19224867224693298,
0.17213238775730133,
-0.5693082213401794,
0.6332432627677917,
-0.36138662695884705,
0.5514144897460938,
0.7205535769462585,
-0.09770095348358154,
0.39891737699508667,
-0.033000849187374115,
0.5919485092163086,
-0.3001691997051239,
0.2909647524356842,
0.11844324320554733,
-0.12244971841573715,
-0.3211004436016083,
-0.5207279324531555,
0.3566657602787018,
0.7373651266098022,
-0.5003817081451416,
0.46998128294944763,
0.029627801850438118,
-0.502956211566925,
-0.346248596906662,
0.47121351957321167,
0.5626843571662903,
0.1562337428331375,
0.6234786510467529,
-0.24385543167591095,
-0.5895715355873108,
-0.6998220086097717,
-0.8118364214897156,
-0.13014766573905945,
0.3553042709827423,
0.06345485150814056,
0.3506641983985901,
-0.16131271421909332,
0.5641602873802185,
-0.513202428817749,
-0.21579799056053162,
-0.3138402998447418,
-0.14157791435718536,
0.18438655138015747,
0.6945525407791138,
0.9340998530387878,
-0.40534502267837524,
-0.6504641175270081,
-0.1339801400899887,
-0.6021280884742737,
-0.21676313877105713,
-0.0996742770075798,
-0.08517690747976303,
0.01791190728545189,
0.9687163233757019,
-0.4751548767089844,
0.14784349501132965,
0.6449113488197327,
-0.19315585494041443,
0.9420608282089233,
-0.2581880986690521,
0.008434432558715343,
-0.6222561001777649,
-0.29724735021591187,
0.3378427028656006,
-0.03350194916129112,
-0.865627110004425,
0.6262883543968201,
0.32900166511535645,
0.26227015256881714,
-0.5776519775390625,
0.43476977944374084,
-0.8064167499542236,
0.2805617153644562,
-0.15690039098262787,
0.2530600130558014,
-0.5968587398529053,
0.4712713360786438,
-0.6676836013793945,
0.7227468490600586,
0.555723249912262,
-0.16188038885593414,
0.4088241755962372,
-0.06459061056375504,
-0.33392491936683655,
0.2366601675748825,
-0.5184798240661621,
0.3680664896965027,
-0.24501748383045197,
0.0014115554513409734,
-0.8609622716903687,
0.016646262258291245,
0.4969984292984009,
-0.22307588160037994,
0.6025437116622925,
-0.6357128024101257,
-0.5072906613349915,
-0.19901487231254578,
-0.6418513059616089,
0.5031391382217407,
0.34922122955322266,
-0.8334016799926758,
0.3275538384914398,
0.36966562271118164,
0.11793918162584305,
-0.951395571231842,
-0.30639171600341797,
0.44642555713653564,
-0.8074477314949036,
-0.6037172079086304,
0.397346168756485,
0.08047590404748917,
-0.5720545649528503,
-0.29705941677093506,
-0.14416366815567017,
0.19575777649879456,
0.45750120282173157,
-0.14744824171066284,
0.49462804198265076,
0.1890007108449936,
-0.24721315503120422,
-0.16352221369743347,
-0.2182755321264267,
-0.012344392947852612,
-0.6209443807601929,
0.6498439908027649,
-0.13858136534690857,
-0.2110074907541275,
-0.18837368488311768,
0.15001064538955688,
0.5146197080612183,
-0.29339274764060974,
0.7276818752288818,
0.4221940040588379,
-0.09535989165306091,
-0.32144343852996826,
-0.7798149585723877,
-0.02976740524172783,
-0.504395604133606,
0.5666000247001648,
-0.10477445274591446,
-0.9746713042259216,
0.5499996542930603,
-0.19478663802146912,
0.1176191046833992,
-0.1029299795627594,
0.4798811376094818,
0.004364890977740288,
0.9682192206382751,
0.6211135387420654,
-0.671264111995697,
0.6312578320503235,
-0.13338561356067657,
0.45850664377212524,
-0.8705479502677917,
-0.06550217419862747,
-0.6989638805389404,
-0.2918677031993866,
-0.6422446370124817,
-0.39799535274505615,
0.3479454219341278,
0.7584938406944275,
-0.2000662088394165,
0.6920198202133179,
-0.5325862765312195,
0.7006773352622986,
0.28538328409194946,
-0.03162654861807823,
0.05077221244573593,
-0.004145728889852762,
-0.31246307492256165,
-0.09016650915145874,
-0.6925384998321533,
-0.07004795223474503,
1.196151614189148,
0.1932043880224228,
1.0752092599868774,
0.18300272524356842,
1.0186140537261963,
0.19245530664920807,
0.3411634862422943,
-0.6394516825675964,
0.4464404284954071,
-0.34912100434303284,
-0.30348432064056396,
-0.021816188469529152,
-0.40804189443588257,
-0.7099372148513794,
0.3554980754852295,
-0.19753853976726532,
-1.2390846014022827,
-0.20727093517780304,
0.4535139501094818,
-0.1946379393339157,
0.38042163848876953,
-0.7801651954650879,
0.85582035779953,
-0.5616849064826965,
-0.3643975257873535,
-0.3868251144886017,
-0.6388681530952454,
0.5582789778709412,
-0.12292534857988358,
0.34690043330192566,
-0.1043146550655365,
0.1433829963207245,
0.503339946269989,
-0.7267274260520935,
0.5899750590324402,
-0.5180420875549316,
-0.019016331061720848,
0.20998570322990417,
0.03808646276593208,
0.9637365341186523,
-0.06912189722061157,
-0.04750792309641838,
0.20331640541553497,
-0.5493342280387878,
-0.403432160615921,
-0.5779649615287781,
0.731677234172821,
-0.5727009177207947,
-0.8051279783248901,
-0.07417362183332443,
-0.47674232721328735,
-0.13375434279441833,
0.06166747212409973,
0.2608552575111389,
0.18129490315914154,
0.013704133220016956,
0.01472412794828415,
0.3227277994155884,
-0.42773205041885376,
0.4659794270992279,
0.07474716007709503,
-0.0031025949865579605,
-0.5793278217315674,
0.6920287609100342,
-0.08354420214891434,
0.537846028804779,
0.04718068987131119,
0.10687065869569778,
-0.18982668220996857,
-1.10158371925354,
-0.4905657470226288,
0.3649836480617523,
-0.42978474497795105,
-0.483403742313385,
-0.5062848925590515,
-0.09740357100963593,
-0.29222849011421204,
-0.5336808562278748,
-0.33064737915992737,
-0.3510739803314209,
0.11385543644428253,
0.027623170986771584,
0.3702336549758911,
0.1834266185760498,
-0.2662090063095093,
0.5133194923400879,
-0.6372324824333191,
0.31654179096221924,
-0.10169202834367752,
0.3479481339454651,
-0.09642632305622101,
-0.12809008359909058,
-0.48080894351005554,
-0.10633379966020584,
-0.1690455675125122,
-0.863610565662384,
0.35951533913612366,
-0.12264804542064667,
0.501812756061554,
0.0931948721408844,
-0.062317054718732834,
0.7089083194732666,
-0.5866377353668213,
0.30038338899612427,
0.5403006672859192,
-0.9472455978393555,
0.5602714419364929,
-0.5567572116851807,
0.03749727085232735,
0.7306728959083557,
-0.07182662189006805,
-0.34741371870040894,
-0.6142579913139343,
-0.2374267429113388,
-1.1093677282333374,
0.7074831128120422,
0.005307456012815237,
0.01453978382050991,
-0.0002317073376616463,
0.7192289233207703,
-0.3470707833766937,
0.05357513949275017,
-0.6105708479881287,
-0.45018014311790466,
0.036929067224264145,
-0.12097474932670593,
0.1230582445859909,
-0.13466514647006989,
-0.19676335155963898,
-0.10573907196521759,
0.6024878025054932,
-0.15457606315612793,
-0.003917910158634186,
-0.06776212900876999,
-0.19674557447433472,
0.13957540690898895,
0.3281792402267456,
0.6128209233283997,
0.3450595438480377,
-0.25681012868881226,
-0.18628720939159393,
0.20170433819293976,
-0.7316263914108276,
0.440437376499176,
0.12315069884061813,
-0.2862033545970917,
-0.3208061158657074,
0.14823895692825317,
0.4921441376209259,
-0.14681307971477509,
-0.8331730961799622,
0.5535876154899597,
-0.08334582298994064,
-0.17597627639770508,
-0.15219861268997192,
0.3819853365421295,
-0.05622781068086624,
0.2316189557313919,
0.16787295043468475,
-0.02554350718855858,
-0.18916967511177063,
-0.35866618156433105,
0.07963819801807404,
0.7939264178276062,
-0.3283049166202545,
0.1872677505016327,
0.7650156021118164,
-0.14623595774173737,
-0.268581748008728,
0.6258156895637512,
-0.26322904229164124,
-0.7349876165390015,
0.7655094861984253,
0.6743043661117554,
1.0712666511535645,
-0.04456282779574394,
-0.047690875828266144,
0.47821858525276184,
0.5806804299354553,
-0.3559117913246155,
-0.04434835910797119,
-0.04849696904420853,
-0.8743273615837097,
-0.7615050673484802,
-0.37850943207740784,
-0.22353006899356842,
-0.05743464082479477,
-0.41402214765548706,
0.4403524696826935,
-0.9284794926643372,
-0.09444329887628555,
-0.2595747709274292,
-0.028501471504569054,
-0.21414156258106232,
-0.079304538667202,
0.045124880969524384,
0.9644373059272766,
-0.21576011180877686,
0.7126820683479309,
0.4822218418121338,
0.24887511134147644,
-0.7698312401771545,
-0.009468880482017994,
0.2900066077709198,
-0.7953753471374512,
0.5422012805938721,
0.1497475802898407,
-0.12815289199352264,
-0.08320167660713196,
-0.794609785079956,
-0.873785674571991,
0.7282172441482544,
0.49363449215888977,
-1.037596583366394,
0.10324212908744812,
-0.12462056428194046,
0.2316882312297821,
-0.18349991738796234,
-0.11504176259040833,
0.9555175304412842,
0.6164525747299194,
-0.23225799202919006,
-0.66493159532547,
0.1626463383436203,
-0.1398991346359253,
-0.20442335307598114,
0.6816183924674988,
-0.6548906564712524,
0.6152836084365845,
-0.7460684180259705,
-0.057636164128780365,
0.2658878564834595,
0.2332027554512024,
0.6100116968154907,
-0.2722203731536865,
0.5494934320449829,
1.0367374420166016,
0.5108516812324524,
-0.23355570435523987,
1.0429935455322266,
-0.5272711515426636,
0.5173248052597046,
1.1998481750488281,
-0.081681028008461,
0.2665356397628784,
0.4807931184768677,
0.22807379066944122,
0.24538284540176392,
0.01590685173869133,
-0.38349127769470215,
0.7740638256072998,
0.7978153824806213,
-0.3075043857097626,
-0.02137330360710621,
0.33861207962036133,
-0.1257299929857254,
0.48150989413261414,
0.24442444741725922,
-0.060452140867710114,
-0.4435385763645172,
-0.07951347529888153,
0.612448513507843,
0.055210720747709274,
-0.3848164677619934,
0.7175920009613037,
-0.032296113669872284,
-0.5989910364151001,
0.8571960926055908,
0.663881778717041,
0.892679750919342,
-0.5573968291282654,
0.2035226970911026,
-0.0483335480093956,
0.2133011519908905,
-0.16943779587745667,
-0.26107364892959595,
-0.008288541808724403,
0.4343913197517395,
0.31133702397346497,
-0.08268717676401138,
0.8011736273765564,
-0.2694891393184662,
-0.054066792130470276,
0.6851232051849365,
0.14504601061344147,
-0.2635633051395416,
0.004159694537520409,
-0.7076965570449829,
0.340338796377182,
0.1784483939409256,
-0.01551646739244461,
0.4723980724811554,
-0.10976768285036087,
-0.008263052441179752,
0.6271700859069824,
0.5528591275215149,
0.3929602801799774,
0.2567211389541626,
-0.07938564568758011,
0.9723550081253052,
-0.8569062948226929,
-0.3831813335418701,
-1.3309918642044067,
0.5146304965019226,
-0.05574546754360199,
-0.028357885777950287,
0.7813533544540405,
0.3951071500778198,
0.8487293720245361,
0.23952358961105347,
0.8029518723487854,
-0.13931147754192352,
-0.017895987257361412,
-0.8764809966087341,
0.5563620924949646,
-0.19005639851093292,
0.536824643611908,
-0.5881686210632324,
-1.03516685962677,
-0.5788168907165527,
0.5858604907989502,
-0.416297048330307,
-0.16607247292995453,
0.4289645552635193,
0.8242313265800476,
0.14696118235588074,
-0.13351278007030487,
0.017582964152097702,
0.24917064607143402,
0.6263092756271362,
0.6715874671936035,
0.9352817535400391,
-0.3548993170261383,
0.2961086630821228,
-0.25783199071884155,
-0.26596754789352417,
-0.1275807023048401,
-1.044195532798767,
-0.8633632659912109,
0.136614128947258,
-0.2691357433795929,
-0.5463820695877075,
0.525702714920044,
1.0166819095611572,
0.598994255065918,
-0.557767927646637,
-0.20429833233356476,
-0.21736299991607666,
0.08102967590093613,
0.0049748788587749004,
-0.15932853519916534,
0.19461677968502045,
-0.6225780844688416,
-0.4514678716659546,
0.6356403231620789,
0.4900233745574951,
-0.08206247538328171,
0.02766883559525013,
-0.09413523226976395,
-0.04221690073609352,
-0.22346076369285583,
0.26632821559906006,
0.4117635488510132,
-0.3941316306591034,
-0.5107572078704834,
-0.22711575031280518,
-0.002416149014607072,
0.16454750299453735,
1.0052528381347656,
-0.4863067865371704,
0.34035080671310425,
0.12718607485294342,
0.8850395679473877,
0.33419179916381836,
0.4159983694553375,
0.5594226121902466,
-0.6941021680831909,
0.3171943426132202,
0.16221880912780762,
0.5508614182472229,
0.16544795036315918,
-0.3418789803981781,
0.4329056739807129,
0.14595311880111694,
-0.48001521825790405,
-0.7121895551681519,
0.23199613392353058,
-0.7280164957046509,
-0.42448732256889343,
1.027144193649292,
-0.2317197471857071,
-0.14698106050491333,
-0.0490223690867424,
-0.0823364183306694,
-0.0628102645277977,
-0.3334048092365265,
0.9488875269889832,
0.5857896208763123,
0.03555922210216522,
0.2069324553012848,
-0.3718431293964386,
0.46906334161758423,
0.4988348186016083,
-0.8534008860588074,
0.32201266288757324,
0.598397433757782,
0.3225533962249756,
0.013725382275879383,
0.4601840078830719,
-0.496890664100647,
0.27097973227500916,
-0.33003634214401245,
-0.02023376151919365,
-0.03377579525113106,
-0.45376625657081604,
-0.5040538907051086,
0.1715826541185379,
-0.03516193479299545,
-0.12511131167411804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20999v1
|
Towards a Fluid computer
| 2024-05-31T16:41:36
| 2024-05-31T16:41:36
|
Robert Cardona, Eva Miranda, Daniel Peralta-Salas
|
math.DS
|
math.DS, cs.CL, math.AP, math.SG
|
In 1991, Moore [20] raised a question about whether hydrodynamics is capable
of performing computations. Similarly, in 2016, Tao [25] asked whether a
mechanical system, including a fluid flow, can simulate a universal Turing
machine. In this expository article, we review the construction in [8] of a
"Fluid computer" in dimension 3 that combines techniques in symbolic dynamics
with the connection between steady Euler flows and contact geometry unveiled by
Etnyre and Ghrist. In addition, we argue that the metric that renders the
vector field Beltrami cannot be critical in the Chern-Hamilton sense [9]. We
also sketch the completely different construction for the Euclidean metric in
$\mathbb R^3$ as given in [7]. These results reveal the existence of
undecidable fluid particle paths. We conclude the article with a list of open
problems.
|
[
-0.25832539796829224,
-1.0093728303909302,
1.078259825706482,
-0.18271814286708832,
-0.1772134006023407,
0.2131606489419937,
0.16570527851581573,
-0.7544297575950623,
0.5376893281936646,
0.39859968423843384,
-0.648418664932251,
0.08906808495521545,
-0.36192911863327026,
-0.06523607671260834,
-0.8295175433158875,
0.8156468868255615,
-0.6214762926101685,
-0.1705009490251541,
-0.10744237899780273,
-0.07011441141366959,
-0.22665418684482574,
-0.6359134316444397,
-0.4519801437854767,
-0.37748825550079346,
0.40585988759994507,
0.1670534759759903,
1.0777989625930786,
0.6994743943214417,
0.661072313785553,
0.47694453597068787,
-0.05814244598150253,
-0.048310380429029465,
-0.23092657327651978,
0.7343443036079407,
0.19068357348442078,
-0.3703470230102539,
-0.08200958371162415,
0.00010347491479478776,
0.6712597608566284,
1.125811219215393,
0.011498352512717247,
-0.17133763432502747,
0.20204749703407288,
1.1252427101135254,
-0.5718353986740112,
0.06923350691795349,
-0.17684900760650635,
0.5340182185173035,
-0.49229830503463745,
-0.2374115139245987,
-0.061500225216150284,
-0.3184347450733185,
0.08195900171995163,
-0.850498378276825,
0.20968791842460632,
0.20961174368858337,
0.6516075134277344,
0.2581900954246521,
-0.058911703526973724,
-0.34083107113838196,
-1.548008918762207,
0.6279585957527161,
0.24113517999649048,
0.3214113414287567,
0.006903488654643297,
0.6843178868293762,
-0.09269498288631439,
-0.9350813627243042,
-0.5237724184989929,
0.3054445683956146,
0.45870715379714966,
0.21939155459403992,
-0.4389849305152893,
0.09955840557813644,
0.46928852796554565,
0.1589939445257187,
-0.35852885246276855,
-0.545866072177887,
-0.8687687516212463,
-0.1345718801021576,
0.48260802030563354,
0.6201367378234863,
0.34020259976387024,
0.44618886709213257,
-0.2134384661912918,
0.02766626700758934,
-0.45093369483947754,
0.3150343894958496,
0.5096824765205383,
-0.07025820761919022,
-0.2443588376045227,
0.5584554672241211,
-0.18300321698188782,
0.5292409658432007,
-0.24189887940883636,
-0.015290290117263794,
-0.21262477338314056,
0.2394212782382965,
-0.143624946475029,
0.06197729706764221,
0.9220693111419678,
-0.06244508549571037,
0.5189545154571533,
-0.07856853306293488,
-0.08754785358905792,
-0.13875100016593933,
0.5265920162200928,
-0.7996612787246704,
-0.397365540266037,
0.6023581027984619,
-0.23854602873325348,
-0.2818320691585541,
0.6179888844490051,
-0.49164748191833496,
-0.6593441963195801,
-0.34973812103271484,
0.14662984013557434,
-0.2691565454006195,
-0.04607335478067398,
-0.02528083696961403,
-0.15411590039730072,
-0.10427803546190262,
0.46491220593452454,
-0.5268166661262512,
0.3771919012069702,
0.8053572177886963,
0.9727905988693237,
0.07222401350736618,
-0.31933823227882385,
-0.1024312824010849,
0.44193142652511597,
-0.6747313737869263,
1.0824482440948486,
-0.49172163009643555,
-0.45772939920425415,
0.323381632566452,
-0.13057170808315277,
0.29649096727371216,
-0.5558363199234009,
0.2601764500141144,
-0.4677247703075409,
0.018435390666127205,
-0.24593190848827362,
-0.3393019139766693,
-0.4267536699771881,
-0.2405809462070465,
-0.6352461576461792,
0.47465255856513977,
-0.13417251408100128,
-0.9093394875526428,
-0.03434139862656593,
-0.5234838724136353,
-0.4149247407913208,
-0.049290359020233154,
-0.3882884979248047,
-0.12869015336036682,
0.09772166609764099,
-0.5351502895355225,
0.42183583974838257,
-0.47185376286506653,
0.3457881212234497,
-1.0915439128875732,
-0.5546566247940063,
0.6246817111968994,
-0.46548253297805786,
0.8524026274681091,
0.44010841846466064,
-0.2253219187259674,
-0.09821271896362305,
-0.6000552177429199,
0.3732927739620209,
-0.07658708840608597,
-0.04357222095131874,
0.09603873640298843,
0.04373336210846901,
-0.05681433528661728,
-0.19420146942138672,
0.09857268631458282,
-0.6309985518455505,
0.031050415709614754,
-0.006134537048637867,
0.5057117938995361,
0.5322518348693848,
-0.13320176303386688,
0.5099305510520935,
-0.48077392578125,
0.6806309819221497,
-0.0461156889796257,
0.051341909915208817,
0.24425220489501953,
-0.6991959810256958,
-0.8101818561553955,
-0.21921631693840027,
0.00817473791539669,
0.6889820098876953,
-0.9163153171539307,
-0.06965096294879913,
0.017919223755598068,
-0.5219728350639343,
-0.3573015332221985,
-0.052709080278873444,
0.05218915268778801,
0.22647744417190552,
0.1946989744901657,
0.30335503816604614,
-0.5689669847488403,
-0.7370046377182007,
-0.12801802158355713,
-0.5109438300132751,
-0.35649988055229187,
0.4673384726047516,
0.15646079182624817,
0.1466202288866043,
0.6810066103935242,
-0.7741878032684326,
0.14670291543006897,
0.04837429150938988,
-0.004769468680024147,
0.27607566118240356,
0.47402551770210266,
0.20870988070964813,
-0.057713791728019714,
-0.48178476095199585,
0.16151820123195648,
-1.069567322731018,
0.001966683892533183,
0.33748307824134827,
-0.2721323072910309,
0.05800355598330498,
0.8794310688972473,
-0.698140561580658,
0.4979303181171417,
0.3480740785598755,
-0.40615516901016235,
0.25336381793022156,
-0.4516850411891937,
0.007620751392096281,
-0.6558173894882202,
0.36714640259742737,
-0.276846706867218,
-0.229244664311409,
-0.8139637112617493,
-0.19825568795204163,
-0.04253454506397247,
-0.3773186206817627,
-0.566870927810669,
0.4723551869392395,
-0.15259188413619995,
0.09884373098611832,
-0.5360913872718811,
-0.043700963258743286,
-0.26558718085289,
0.22300291061401367,
-0.04540587589144707,
0.31155848503112793,
0.817561686038971,
-0.882764995098114,
0.73316490650177,
-0.2572038769721985,
0.16763640940189362,
0.8018826842308044,
-1.029685616493225,
0.17412897944450378,
-0.29170793294906616,
0.3682389259338379,
-0.5982328653335571,
-0.2957526743412018,
0.2938896417617798,
-0.07223712652921677,
0.1378779262304306,
0.33200111985206604,
-0.07191350311040878,
-0.45165184140205383,
-0.3548981845378876,
0.8173611760139465,
0.5875869393348694,
-0.430798202753067,
0.35346758365631104,
0.8703035712242126,
0.15191596746444702,
-0.2598373293876648,
-0.5728976130485535,
-0.37153246998786926,
-0.22263780236244202,
-0.6502342224121094,
0.06524403393268585,
-0.26855477690696716,
-0.8930919766426086,
-0.06076935678720474,
0.27964258193969727,
-0.7196446657180786,
0.07247252762317657,
0.5147315263748169,
0.3239859640598297,
-0.09853946417570114,
-0.22978848218917847,
0.02384670078754425,
-0.1523076295852661,
0.31027236580848694,
-0.2742582857608795,
0.17397062480449677,
-0.3468300700187683,
-0.2957559823989868,
-0.8639817833900452,
0.353920578956604,
0.5313320159912109,
0.6325631737709045,
0.16495661437511444,
0.5845921039581299,
-0.75048828125,
-0.02410527691245079,
-0.007541594095528126,
0.12215670943260193,
-0.5313776731491089,
-0.14608202874660492,
-0.6280393600463867,
-0.9620818495750427,
0.44643622636795044,
0.2327418476343155,
-0.26002588868141174,
0.659176230430603,
0.4247559607028961,
-0.42017173767089844,
0.9010202884674072,
0.732080340385437,
-0.108180470764637,
-0.09179045259952545,
-0.40271979570388794,
0.14900057017803192,
-0.645405650138855,
-0.36956682801246643,
-0.9531719088554382,
-0.5061018466949463,
-0.722963809967041,
-0.2292579561471939,
0.5585711598396301,
0.45121291279792786,
-0.6167813539505005,
0.17341110110282898,
-0.4289393723011017,
0.5662370324134827,
0.249243825674057,
-0.1387851983308792,
0.06960587948560715,
-0.13727392256259918,
-0.6322376728057861,
0.034914709627628326,
-0.8822377920150757,
-0.42655807733535767,
0.4582385718822479,
0.36068961024284363,
0.6739438772201538,
0.16995270550251007,
0.4384589195251465,
-0.16109217703342438,
0.37215039134025574,
-0.3364587724208832,
0.3434865176677704,
0.21250230073928833,
-1.0968183279037476,
-0.48151421546936035,
-0.27361729741096497,
-1.1310840845108032,
0.046695955097675323,
-0.188771054148674,
-0.8475741744041443,
-0.020399171859025955,
-0.09229157865047455,
-0.6463373303413391,
0.7667891383171082,
-0.4407668113708496,
0.48904651403427124,
0.23069973289966583,
-0.5340294241905212,
-0.016809135675430298,
-0.47635215520858765,
0.6041837930679321,
0.023874202743172646,
0.4514002501964569,
-0.2912055552005768,
-0.364854633808136,
0.37263429164886475,
-0.8820619583129883,
0.6286819577217102,
-0.058350738137960434,
0.035700343549251556,
0.9509449005126953,
0.7375543117523193,
-0.29198744893074036,
0.25975045561790466,
0.35654813051223755,
0.15880809724330902,
0.41603556275367737,
-0.42089951038360596,
-0.5829378962516785,
0.810848593711853,
-0.8986473083496094,
-0.3399685323238373,
-0.6468413472175598,
-0.555296003818512,
-0.14975041151046753,
0.12729766964912415,
-0.003185203531756997,
0.6042318344116211,
-0.3362753093242645,
0.028220586478710175,
0.37598463892936707,
-0.044269341975450516,
0.8961792588233948,
0.16080480813980103,
-0.4394208490848541,
-0.34252506494522095,
0.8751110434532166,
0.10585884749889374,
-0.18049804866313934,
0.23443563282489777,
0.2880147099494934,
-0.049371495842933655,
0.14767754077911377,
-0.6607345938682556,
0.19610875844955444,
-0.4247991740703583,
-0.22936217486858368,
-0.3899640738964081,
-0.6179989576339722,
0.272153377532959,
-0.2633633017539978,
-0.4587385654449463,
-0.7614123821258545,
-0.4050806164741516,
0.3898284137248993,
0.5376414656639099,
1.4929399490356445,
-0.22467991709709167,
-0.1405116319656372,
-0.6060916185379028,
0.0753624364733696,
0.29409775137901306,
0.5555089116096497,
0.03303967043757439,
-0.3944326937198639,
-0.07874196022748947,
-0.11865734308958054,
-0.8267977237701416,
-0.47289371490478516,
-0.04819577559828758,
-0.15930871665477753,
0.16121423244476318,
0.7942855358123779,
-0.07019110023975372,
0.7887901663780212,
-0.8489943742752075,
0.645368218421936,
0.34725871682167053,
-0.9474760293960571,
0.2721140682697296,
-0.5214785933494568,
0.12001310288906097,
0.1887161135673523,
0.8527050018310547,
-0.3025025427341461,
-0.5882038474082947,
-1.1218212842941284,
-0.30321770906448364,
0.1236148476600647,
0.28699609637260437,
0.09225546568632126,
0.19165080785751343,
0.6723520159721375,
0.06744738668203354,
0.12078461050987244,
-0.15065696835517883,
-0.5093725919723511,
0.06852545589208603,
0.04776120185852051,
0.11308522522449493,
-0.03208879753947258,
0.06988928467035294,
-0.41388142108917236,
0.4496176242828369,
0.027093658223748207,
0.30552399158477783,
0.5180834531784058,
0.6726185083389282,
-0.3201111853122711,
-0.18426497280597687,
0.5456408858299255,
0.4713430404663086,
0.12154094129800797,
0.41516828536987305,
-0.15818345546722412,
-0.45086613297462463,
0.19122064113616943,
-0.06772024929523468,
-0.42083871364593506,
0.05714596435427666,
0.1866079419851303,
0.4610450267791748,
-0.13299480080604553,
-0.30186453461647034,
0.20429961383342743,
-0.24082225561141968,
-0.7121356725692749,
-0.24868881702423096,
0.29763537645339966,
0.02020796202123165,
0.33604270219802856,
-0.28284674882888794,
0.23066847026348114,
0.19422224164009094,
-0.605553925037384,
-0.019528666511178017,
0.5279668569564819,
-1.2654023170471191,
-0.544353723526001,
1.1156301498413086,
0.16707441210746765,
-0.47685396671295166,
0.30679580569267273,
-0.03422379121184349,
-0.40532100200653076,
0.20498555898666382,
0.08812857419252396,
1.0474408864974976,
-0.027056746184825897,
0.11146446317434311,
0.41775229573249817,
0.20831097662448883,
-0.12487397342920303,
0.7499417066574097,
0.12875422835350037,
-0.710331916809082,
-0.02152745984494686,
-0.2147357016801834,
-0.8247513175010681,
-0.061395253986120224,
-0.2514372766017914,
0.2875901460647583,
-0.9142641425132751,
-0.0722116082906723,
0.23409494757652283,
-0.0589403472840786,
-0.6160537004470825,
-0.2713841199874878,
-0.00885790679603815,
0.4093504846096039,
-0.3163219392299652,
0.5642492175102234,
0.7480250000953674,
-0.21249493956565857,
-0.640058159828186,
-0.2885884642601013,
0.1275760680437088,
-0.28049978613853455,
0.19497773051261902,
-0.026667974889278412,
-0.20499010384082794,
-0.3710198998451233,
-0.46921244263648987,
-0.7263164520263672,
1.0211623907089233,
0.5628417730331421,
0.04997965320944786,
0.5448265671730042,
0.4057562053203583,
0.6055582761764526,
-0.12034328281879425,
0.5549511909484863,
0.27357763051986694,
0.25992050766944885,
-0.10992009937763214,
-0.9332025051116943,
-0.05291377380490303,
-0.3220508098602295,
0.1490197479724884,
0.10508166998624802,
-0.8165454864501953,
1.1044018268585205,
-0.258877158164978,
-0.37968528270721436,
0.3634049892425537,
0.7526604533195496,
0.27511945366859436,
0.10583040863275528,
0.25011295080184937,
0.30800434947013855,
0.9845786094665527,
-0.1339486837387085,
1.2387782335281372,
-0.7297680377960205,
0.18026550114154816,
0.15857937932014465,
-0.4931263029575348,
0.5571324825286865,
0.5026425719261169,
-0.4876527488231659,
0.581518828868866,
0.17332471907138824,
0.5415024161338806,
-0.07891908288002014,
0.5263080596923828,
-0.4766533374786377,
-0.030093679204583168,
-0.10053303092718124,
-0.23251280188560486,
0.38053056597709656,
0.05273158848285675,
0.2735428512096405,
-0.08684505522251129,
-0.2969955503940582,
-0.010189074091613293,
0.2805074453353882,
-0.19465620815753937,
0.2568652629852295,
0.2896447777748108,
-0.32747337222099304,
0.503177285194397,
-0.030067378655076027,
0.2109287977218628,
-0.2704087197780609,
-0.05954534560441971,
0.10779275745153427,
0.3187956213951111,
-0.05585489794611931,
-0.8464869260787964,
0.5565978288650513,
0.09503667801618576,
-0.08676080405712128,
-0.06724603474140167,
0.7914597988128662,
0.002008674666285515,
-0.5547614693641663,
-0.26433783769607544,
0.817135214805603,
0.6060968637466431,
0.12419002503156662,
-0.6095655560493469,
0.3247833847999573,
-0.3991343677043915,
-0.014163440093398094,
0.060700446367263794,
1.035879373550415,
0.23809322714805603,
0.9657468795776367,
0.3582024574279785,
0.06506770104169846,
-0.1983771175146103,
-0.146815225481987,
0.5040327310562134,
-0.9962988495826721,
-0.518031656742096,
-0.8008647561073303,
0.13345840573310852,
0.1751457303762436,
-0.4223743975162506,
0.2552911937236786,
0.7675265669822693,
0.6701245307922363,
0.05540179833769798,
0.9400935173034668,
0.09047720581293106,
0.7440508008003235,
-0.5357350707054138,
0.8305088877677917,
-0.37109795212745667,
-0.07839180529117584,
-0.35215240716934204,
-0.8299807906150818,
-0.39089852571487427,
0.6632792353630066,
0.33954867720603943,
0.19297340512275696,
1.3520770072937012,
0.44561976194381714,
-0.009372314438223839,
0.637631893157959,
0.461942583322525,
0.16504523158073425,
0.2604943811893463,
0.5221627354621887,
1.0736336708068848,
-0.5065138339996338,
0.4497189223766327,
-0.5871875286102295,
-0.13227909803390503,
0.2789698541164398,
-0.753095269203186,
-0.7725184559822083,
-0.6298106908798218,
-0.2906678020954132,
-0.5686743855476379,
-0.19016748666763306,
0.3724427819252014,
0.4034632742404938,
-0.6188721060752869,
-0.7524178624153137,
-0.2124282866716385,
0.057528864592313766,
0.1341489851474762,
-0.11589322239160538,
-0.023780860006809235,
-0.1953285038471222,
-0.6639785170555115,
0.06836029142141342,
0.37238848209381104,
0.4176386594772339,
-0.604296863079071,
0.030743930488824844,
0.5544873476028442,
-0.09418284147977829,
0.42373964190483093,
0.500500500202179,
-0.28813302516937256,
-0.35200485587120056,
0.051305804401636124,
-0.06626680493354797,
-0.10375808924436569,
1.216071367263794,
-0.7366675734519958,
0.14903947710990906,
0.3857475817203522,
0.5459670424461365,
0.40341123938560486,
-0.48795703053474426,
0.5827241539955139,
0.0044916411861777306,
0.33438101410865784,
-0.04307202249765396,
0.4886834919452667,
0.11121145635843277,
-0.1412685364484787,
0.36212509870529175,
0.6190994381904602,
-0.6085693836212158,
-0.5107212066650391,
0.14410147070884705,
-0.8193669319152832,
-0.3550495207309723,
1.1662155389785767,
0.3549496829509735,
-0.5377005338668823,
-0.13678418099880219,
-0.1236945316195488,
0.09040603041648865,
-0.1427694857120514,
0.7791773080825806,
0.7068671584129333,
-0.6210691332817078,
0.5812574625015259,
-1.258423924446106,
0.46297404170036316,
-0.09964242577552795,
-0.5971846580505371,
0.00861059594899416,
0.2914177179336548,
0.13344021141529083,
0.21284456551074982,
0.8166293501853943,
-0.16170227527618408,
0.037812478840351105,
0.0862758532166481,
0.014183851890265942,
0.19258005917072296,
-0.6225199699401855,
-0.171755850315094,
0.2088727056980133,
-0.021192824468016624,
0.015094376169145107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20994v1
|
CWRCzech: 100M Query-Document Czech Click Dataset and Its Application to Web Relevance Ranking
| 2024-05-31T16:38:54
| 2024-05-31T16:38:54
|
Josef Vonášek, Milan Straka, Rostislav Krč, Lenka Lasoňová, Ekaterina Egorova, Jana Straková, Jakub Náplava
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
We present CWRCzech, Click Web Ranking dataset for Czech, a 100M
query-document Czech click dataset for relevance ranking with user behavior
data collected from search engine logs of Seznam.cz. To the best of our
knowledge, CWRCzech is the largest click dataset with raw text published so
far. It provides document positions in the search results as well as
information about user behavior: 27.6M clicked documents and 10.8M dwell times.
In addition, we also publish a manually annotated Czech test for the relevance
task, containing nearly 50k query-document pairs, each annotated by at least 2
annotators. Finally, we analyze how the user behavior data improve relevance
ranking and show that models trained on data automatically harnessed at
sufficient scale can surpass the performance of models trained on human
annotated data. CWRCzech is published under an academic non-commercial license
and is available to the research community at
https://github.com/seznam/CWRCzech.
|
[
-0.504289984703064,
-0.4724119305610657,
0.5008804202079773,
0.2813863158226013,
-0.2563740909099579,
-0.07863631099462509,
-0.5593716502189636,
-0.35802552103996277,
0.26352041959762573,
0.5663352012634277,
-0.6687009930610657,
-1.0732145309448242,
-0.3638797998428345,
0.002466315869241953,
-0.5583847761154175,
0.7433946132659912,
0.3512415587902069,
0.2638784348964691,
-0.4606063663959503,
-0.2855394184589386,
-0.01565583609044552,
-0.6805400252342224,
-0.10796374827623367,
-0.046830493956804276,
0.9047520160675049,
0.4207431674003601,
0.48457545042037964,
0.08706771582365036,
0.5522754192352295,
0.23737244307994843,
0.2740568220615387,
-0.0681847631931305,
-0.7301278710365295,
0.37415140867233276,
-0.318981409072876,
-0.28764671087265015,
-0.4054907262325287,
0.3348366618156433,
0.25384843349456787,
0.804350733757019,
-0.17372895777225494,
0.34947556257247925,
0.15282540023326874,
0.8256606459617615,
-0.5737097859382629,
-0.14837855100631714,
-0.6028302907943726,
-0.40471968054771423,
-0.3777919411659241,
-0.5526391267776489,
-0.7457666397094727,
-0.49200624227523804,
0.0395255908370018,
-0.6611350774765015,
0.5374334454536438,
0.27860018610954285,
0.6155670285224915,
0.11272548884153366,
-0.6981810331344604,
-0.1649327576160431,
-0.40459340810775757,
0.7523276209831238,
-0.3331601917743683,
0.489158034324646,
0.5222421884536743,
0.2539302408695221,
-0.16706155240535736,
-0.8803843855857849,
-0.15007011592388153,
-0.36707955598831177,
0.1037193015217781,
-0.0007239767583087087,
-0.0805615782737732,
0.09421953558921814,
0.48057565093040466,
-0.0658879429101944,
-1.0370428562164307,
-0.22371907532215118,
-0.35897156596183777,
-0.388663113117218,
0.6498188376426697,
0.401888906955719,
0.23871609568595886,
0.15607616305351257,
-0.2962351441383362,
-0.3649108409881592,
-0.5538696646690369,
0.032043468207120895,
0.6151717901229858,
0.5078755617141724,
0.3470381200313568,
0.5648531913757324,
-0.7858619093894958,
0.8602501153945923,
0.0529002845287323,
0.33969059586524963,
0.3111216425895691,
-0.4280211925506592,
0.11360614001750946,
-0.03242947533726692,
0.646494448184967,
0.47886377573013306,
-0.0694887563586235,
-0.35786986351013184,
0.23515193164348602,
-0.09542757272720337,
0.7308042645454407,
-0.9301653504371643,
-0.419704407453537,
0.2426411360502243,
-0.481680303812027,
-0.2203172743320465,
0.6644396185874939,
-0.6785969734191895,
-0.08693905174732208,
-0.2841470241546631,
0.48281359672546387,
-0.014826090075075626,
-0.04049978032708168,
0.17459720373153687,
-0.15144208073616028,
0.29230910539627075,
0.5304740071296692,
-0.6017727851867676,
0.23570594191551208,
0.5993584394454956,
0.4208906292915344,
-0.6948965191841125,
-0.4579550325870514,
-0.4245595633983612,
-0.24246609210968018,
-0.5305739045143127,
0.8528966307640076,
-0.48889341950416565,
-0.3567088544368744,
0.1785772144794464,
0.29458722472190857,
0.05769585445523262,
-0.5740350484848022,
0.6975968480110168,
-1.0112686157226562,
0.19699129462242126,
-0.5754252672195435,
-0.4833412766456604,
-0.08921776711940765,
0.23851144313812256,
-0.9091557860374451,
1.4424790143966675,
0.28706076741218567,
-0.8462194204330444,
0.7618188858032227,
-0.48037195205688477,
-0.46591004729270935,
0.1879102736711502,
0.2105412781238556,
-0.05748698487877846,
0.005891541950404644,
-0.3506035804748535,
0.2703193128108978,
-0.22036287188529968,
0.022317860275506973,
-0.591252326965332,
-0.2738123834133148,
0.14100567996501923,
-0.25975102186203003,
0.8875242471694946,
-0.06951000541448593,
-0.2421262413263321,
0.05691005662083626,
-0.6275007724761963,
0.4470774829387665,
-0.1204480230808258,
-0.790473222732544,
-0.44476190209388733,
-0.32843291759490967,
0.5310016870498657,
0.4964207410812378,
0.629164457321167,
-0.5424659252166748,
0.41629311442375183,
-0.027791419997811317,
-0.113595150411129,
0.33667853474617004,
-0.04030340537428856,
0.4648992717266083,
0.22033944725990295,
0.5681120753288269,
-0.6787853240966797,
0.3524397015571594,
0.20339560508728027,
-0.3417738676071167,
-0.4111233353614807,
0.2095194309949875,
0.6882532835006714,
0.3294123113155365,
-0.3876664340496063,
0.4892546236515045,
-0.39483675360679626,
-0.49314576387405396,
-0.35910555720329285,
0.1532621681690216,
-0.07592310756444931,
0.464616984128952,
0.09747333824634552,
-0.07579857110977173,
-0.40538373589515686,
-0.7147446870803833,
-0.21570613980293274,
-0.06500614434480667,
-0.2794964611530304,
0.289469838142395,
0.5163348913192749,
-0.08533145487308502,
1.0029666423797607,
-0.6355451345443726,
-0.2243092954158783,
-0.03413983806967735,
0.36235538125038147,
0.21056371927261353,
0.08661633729934692,
0.5126640200614929,
-1.3297300338745117,
-0.6537545919418335,
-0.25146228075027466,
-0.5718762278556824,
-0.15258586406707764,
0.40524744987487793,
-0.3672351539134979,
0.34749987721443176,
0.4016375243663788,
-0.3574554920196533,
0.8286016583442688,
0.6347383260726929,
-0.539456307888031,
0.8505846261978149,
-0.16275815665721893,
0.7128587365150452,
-0.7925767302513123,
0.42290425300598145,
-0.19474874436855316,
-0.33535894751548767,
-0.4265613257884979,
-0.0009599042241461575,
0.26582804322242737,
-0.09113120287656784,
-0.6974749565124512,
0.6390568017959595,
-0.30440661311149597,
-0.12559527158737183,
-0.38908353447914124,
0.22214986383914948,
-0.06134910136461258,
0.5408052206039429,
-0.03912359103560448,
1.0185288190841675,
0.22985370457172394,
-0.753252387046814,
0.5459995865821838,
0.3394075930118561,
-0.2621752619743347,
0.46810492873191833,
-0.3509550988674164,
-0.02684430032968521,
0.7053747773170471,
0.29285940527915955,
-1.0206191539764404,
-0.44396528601646423,
-0.2970898747444153,
-0.9449921250343323,
-0.014600560069084167,
-0.29057079553604126,
-0.8300043940544128,
-0.6011157035827637,
-0.6592321991920471,
0.18616805970668793,
0.0728331059217453,
-0.6389880180358887,
0.43085533380508423,
0.3723401725292206,
-0.12782922387123108,
-0.425189733505249,
-0.3703344762325287,
0.3397153615951538,
-0.05546417832374573,
-0.572058379650116,
0.31699228286743164,
-0.44435593485832214,
0.060339733958244324,
-0.04401424154639244,
-0.17109118402004242,
-0.15660686790943146,
0.22035947442054749,
0.4712090790271759,
0.29111477732658386,
0.0036197579465806484,
0.24490804970264435,
-0.3104432225227356,
-0.22578945755958557,
-0.0627659410238266,
-0.18997575342655182,
0.8066329956054688,
-0.00532045541331172,
-0.45441484451293945,
-0.23769044876098633,
0.2449430227279663,
0.31830477714538574,
0.1575850397348404,
0.8207245469093323,
0.6691631078720093,
-0.15439334511756897,
0.10903377830982208,
-0.4905783534049988,
-0.24596714973449707,
-0.44366255402565,
0.15574370324611664,
-0.0505438931286335,
-1.0538216829299927,
0.3893413245677948,
-0.45766979455947876,
-0.16814997792243958,
0.7278963327407837,
0.5887618064880371,
-0.38133037090301514,
1.306756854057312,
0.8279880881309509,
-0.366458535194397,
0.48073023557662964,
-0.2578415274620056,
-0.16126151382923126,
-0.7016188502311707,
-0.29409176111221313,
-0.7981133460998535,
-0.12781889736652374,
-0.9687081575393677,
-0.38747212290763855,
0.38533419370651245,
0.10821927338838577,
-0.12082269787788391,
0.47060543298721313,
-0.5048426389694214,
0.08863955736160278,
0.6946729421615601,
0.16206634044647217,
0.20093348622322083,
0.10531014949083328,
-0.20192354917526245,
-0.0954655110836029,
-0.4614700376987457,
-0.4573107063770294,
1.2777209281921387,
-0.43508490920066833,
0.8270829916000366,
-0.044942110776901245,
0.5176196098327637,
0.7390725016593933,
-0.01031698752194643,
-0.6228268146514893,
0.6019758582115173,
0.06834781914949417,
-0.9423801898956299,
-0.7325277328491211,
-0.0987960547208786,
-1.3626399040222168,
0.20817087590694427,
-0.23073749244213104,
-0.8114982843399048,
-0.01040493045002222,
0.125237375497818,
0.12458623200654984,
0.036226801574230194,
-0.22859665751457214,
0.7315497994422913,
-0.11903176456689835,
-0.6550610661506653,
-0.5256615877151489,
-0.6277244687080383,
-0.22433337569236755,
0.28330984711647034,
-0.12134972214698792,
-0.017207996919751167,
-0.15867051482200623,
0.9012730717658997,
-0.1956690549850464,
0.4570842981338501,
-0.22661946713924408,
0.15095539391040802,
0.2119029462337494,
0.10292047262191772,
0.6649755239486694,
-0.04490102827548981,
-0.31019723415374756,
0.158112570643425,
-0.2157442569732666,
-0.6007623076438904,
-0.4170045852661133,
0.8203362226486206,
-0.1778385192155838,
-0.40868431329727173,
-0.4744970500469208,
-0.16301323473453522,
-0.31382808089256287,
0.3872951567173004,
0.4321882128715515,
0.5065642595291138,
-0.7157109379768372,
0.5782461166381836,
0.8510388731956482,
0.008994568139314651,
0.3987549841403961,
0.808541476726532,
-0.05549873411655426,
-0.4694606065750122,
0.9306705594062805,
-0.024113863706588745,
-0.15787284076213837,
0.3546002209186554,
-0.18865759670734406,
-0.32775500416755676,
-0.6010088920593262,
-0.12802772223949432,
0.15878424048423767,
-0.626680850982666,
-0.1963958889245987,
-0.9118111729621887,
-0.02717900462448597,
-0.536335289478302,
-0.18897753953933716,
-0.28222474455833435,
-0.482918918132782,
-0.33330830931663513,
-0.2813832759857178,
0.3819039463996887,
0.6598845720291138,
-0.18642893433570862,
0.19363006949424744,
-0.4729284942150116,
0.33899039030075073,
0.41001051664352417,
0.49205827713012695,
-0.1629999279975891,
-0.20180632174015045,
-0.7767390012741089,
-0.38813498616218567,
-0.35445505380630493,
-0.6469658613204956,
0.4618673026561737,
-0.30318179726600647,
0.6857863068580627,
0.3232472836971283,
0.3045434057712555,
0.24463003873825073,
-0.33303090929985046,
0.9393766522407532,
0.004052674863487482,
-0.4432693421840668,
0.6612491011619568,
-0.7397471070289612,
0.3954012095928192,
1.2356133460998535,
0.5114586353302002,
-0.46816882491111755,
-0.3476937413215637,
-0.7338836789131165,
-1.128893494606018,
0.878765344619751,
0.2186834216117859,
0.08768907189369202,
0.1717517226934433,
0.1805904507637024,
0.21630476415157318,
0.3959031403064728,
-0.23302815854549408,
-0.3000350892543793,
0.2996187210083008,
-0.1672523319721222,
0.009032957255840302,
-0.3984222114086151,
-0.11654198169708252,
-0.24454689025878906,
0.8544843792915344,
-0.3208070993423462,
0.22886958718299866,
0.09147675335407257,
-0.5890317559242249,
-0.035994499921798706,
0.11844924837350845,
0.5628147125244141,
1.0157012939453125,
-0.3949781656265259,
-0.1195099800825119,
0.24363048374652863,
-0.8677144050598145,
-0.20253857970237732,
-0.08100201934576035,
-0.033432137221097946,
-0.023270882666110992,
0.4776948094367981,
0.25367501378059387,
0.462772011756897,
-0.6590878367424011,
0.6463109254837036,
-0.2805028557777405,
-0.2741803228855133,
-0.31748121976852417,
0.11398307979106903,
0.19795477390289307,
0.08114694803953171,
0.9904565811157227,
-0.33640310168266296,
0.7676007151603699,
-0.13801132142543793,
0.5656462907791138,
0.4064714014530182,
-0.7450613975524902,
-0.31990164518356323,
0.5940124988555908,
0.3615944981575012,
-0.1112133115530014,
0.6220253109931946,
0.16665029525756836,
-0.7016608715057373,
0.6513943076133728,
-0.018119197338819504,
0.5924758911132812,
-0.3041040301322937,
0.42742541432380676,
0.675567626953125,
0.1372373253107071,
-0.2586973309516907,
0.18632054328918457,
-0.3870388865470886,
-0.2721165418624878,
-0.11252833902835846,
-0.5185372233390808,
-0.6898046731948853,
-0.07957416772842407,
-1.1881734132766724,
0.32362276315689087,
0.03901682049036026,
-0.49139100313186646,
-0.10811160504817963,
0.8110365867614746,
-0.8447102308273315,
0.37380850315093994,
-0.23339076340198517,
1.2139272689819336,
-0.7454548478126526,
0.9239045977592468,
0.49672460556030273,
-0.11184635758399963,
-0.18028035759925842,
0.1823485642671585,
-0.06090932339429855,
-0.4804478883743286,
0.6625474095344543,
0.14608359336853027,
-0.3295077681541443,
-0.008450096473097801,
-0.9976249933242798,
-0.7186375260353088,
1.2270939350128174,
0.17341002821922302,
-0.31778979301452637,
0.2437266856431961,
-0.04441416636109352,
0.576103150844574,
-0.3079020082950592,
0.1285003423690796,
0.436163067817688,
0.6035210490226746,
-0.07943136990070343,
-0.6970884799957275,
-0.15895400941371918,
-0.13373228907585144,
-0.3458755612373352,
0.2315005660057068,
-0.7882646322250366,
0.2507674992084503,
-0.04971064627170563,
-0.0645885095000267,
0.09656968712806702,
0.4950264096260071,
0.18641695380210876,
0.6208141446113586,
0.474435955286026,
0.42738521099090576,
0.7196384072303772,
-0.046972647309303284,
0.9864282011985779,
-0.15146926045417786,
0.6217541694641113,
1.1660854816436768,
-0.2647116184234619,
1.0315515995025635,
0.23324692249298096,
-0.3638432025909424,
0.47672420740127563,
0.9462607502937317,
-0.05072862282395363,
0.6583058834075928,
-0.22172966599464417,
-0.176017165184021,
-0.616766631603241,
-0.06341113895177841,
-0.2252996414899826,
0.32699698209762573,
0.22477075457572937,
-0.16788510978221893,
-0.17518047988414764,
0.21353530883789062,
-0.18572737276554108,
0.03871950879693031,
-0.014063762500882149,
0.98476243019104,
-0.2656843364238739,
-0.2561816871166229,
0.21879757940769196,
-0.3440181612968445,
0.498868852853775,
-0.6387110948562622,
-0.04732918366789818,
-0.10510315746068954,
-0.3233117163181305,
-0.11537553369998932,
-0.8821839094161987,
-0.22118838131427765,
-0.1590082198381424,
-0.6237019896507263,
-0.1353045254945755,
0.8059378266334534,
-0.268988698720932,
-0.42139965295791626,
0.6834167838096619,
0.28868091106414795,
0.24298274517059326,
-0.3924769163131714,
-0.7750091552734375,
0.09277822077274323,
-0.030691353604197502,
-0.7235588431358337,
0.6583049893379211,
0.2894480228424072,
-0.11787508428096771,
0.6829348206520081,
0.6908228397369385,
0.03951133042573929,
-0.000009103193406190258,
0.0840068906545639,
1.093536138534546,
-1.0817517042160034,
-0.4335094094276428,
-0.36277660727500916,
0.33534055948257446,
-0.348248690366745,
0.037981513887643814,
0.8555758595466614,
1.0310888290405273,
0.650877058506012,
0.20588767528533936,
0.7976239919662476,
-0.1066700890660286,
0.5187237858772278,
-0.26804548501968384,
0.7510196566581726,
-0.6803431510925293,
-0.32078105211257935,
-0.11110976338386536,
-0.959206759929657,
-0.11548794060945511,
0.07577893137931824,
-0.22069579362869263,
0.15905742347240448,
0.6361237168312073,
0.7787545919418335,
0.0453486405313015,
-0.18981894850730896,
0.7715581655502319,
0.12243355810642242,
-0.08765219151973724,
0.07660697400569916,
0.49324068427085876,
-0.29173383116722107,
0.7125029563903809,
-0.16525986790657043,
-0.15750530362129211,
-0.9612551331520081,
-0.7342658638954163,
-0.8007313013076782,
-0.9626577496528625,
-0.26079246401786804,
-0.38773608207702637,
-0.03183664381504059,
0.7880550026893616,
0.9846754670143127,
-0.9822435975074768,
-0.15862146019935608,
0.5130207538604736,
0.08684597164392471,
-0.09523634612560272,
-0.2830076813697815,
0.5396732091903687,
-0.3424822688102722,
-0.5067014694213867,
0.3751010298728943,
0.3616848587989807,
-0.3595999777317047,
-0.09830167144536972,
-0.08352088183164597,
-0.30362483859062195,
-0.07679793983697891,
0.5136569738388062,
0.2825399339199066,
-0.5743299126625061,
-0.0019421137403696775,
0.24969030916690826,
-0.41975507140159607,
0.1366940289735794,
1.1254627704620361,
-0.8547550439834595,
0.6295282244682312,
0.7139888405799866,
0.14180634915828705,
0.8216255307197571,
0.33083635568618774,
0.36923375725746155,
-0.554943323135376,
-0.015627412125468254,
0.1455252319574356,
-0.10640569031238556,
0.2270427644252777,
-0.7634604573249817,
0.7575511336326599,
-0.010559449903666973,
-0.658373236656189,
-0.6556035876274109,
-0.34180593490600586,
-1.270225167274475,
-0.2661886215209961,
1.0463390350341797,
0.009588214568793774,
-0.3430655002593994,
-0.17968563735485077,
-0.26212048530578613,
0.23904019594192505,
-0.6640490293502808,
0.7103773355484009,
0.7659978866577148,
-0.2658519148826599,
0.22271840274333954,
-0.9896634817123413,
0.587446391582489,
-0.05564897134900093,
-0.8893871903419495,
0.30084335803985596,
0.5316617488861084,
0.570009708404541,
-0.03096677176654339,
0.4313855767250061,
-0.030715975910425186,
0.6580654382705688,
-0.12762023508548737,
0.3930129110813141,
0.1435890644788742,
-0.45319002866744995,
-0.3649556636810303,
0.43538710474967957,
0.08267073333263397,
-0.042119815945625305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20974v2
|
SaySelf: Teaching LLMs to Express Confidence with Self-Reflective Rationales
| 2024-05-31T16:21:16
| 2024-06-05T17:04:01
|
Tianyang Xu, Shujin Wu, Shizhe Diao, Xiaoze Liu, Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Jing Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) often generate inaccurate or fabricated
information and generally fail to indicate their confidence, which limits their
broader applications. Previous work elicits confidence from LLMs by direct or
self-consistency prompting, or constructing specific datasets for supervised
finetuning. The prompting-based approaches have inferior performance, and the
training-based approaches are limited to binary or inaccurate group-level
confidence estimates. In this work, we present the advanced SaySelf, a training
framework that teaches LLMs to express more accurate fine-grained confidence
estimates. In addition, beyond the confidence scores, SaySelf initiates the
process of directing LLMs to produce self-reflective rationales that clearly
identify gaps in their parametric knowledge and explain their uncertainty. This
is achieved by using an LLM to automatically summarize the uncertainties in
specific knowledge via natural language. The summarization is based on the
analysis of the inconsistency in multiple sampled reasoning chains, and the
resulting data is utilized for supervised fine-tuning. Moreover, we utilize
reinforcement learning with a meticulously crafted reward function to calibrate
the confidence estimates, motivating LLMs to deliver accurate, high-confidence
predictions and to penalize overconfidence in erroneous outputs. Experimental
results in both in-distribution and out-of-distribution datasets demonstrate
the effectiveness of SaySelf in reducing the confidence calibration error and
maintaining the task performance. We show that the generated self-reflective
rationales are reasonable and can further contribute to the calibration. The
code is made public at https://github.com/xu1868/SaySelf.
|
[
-0.3336314260959625,
-0.6020931601524353,
0.7457628846168518,
0.32417532801628113,
0.22699156403541565,
-0.20647573471069336,
-0.4731981158256531,
0.037288252264261246,
-0.17275510728359222,
0.3300783932209015,
-0.6613274812698364,
-0.7082127332687378,
-0.6201491951942444,
0.08464763313531876,
-0.19593170285224915,
1.0480369329452515,
-0.03008529171347618,
0.3247666656970978,
-0.3148112893104553,
0.025921324267983437,
0.013133847154676914,
-0.32650113105773926,
-0.5810760855674744,
-0.501630961894989,
0.6379485726356506,
0.5279626846313477,
0.4204852283000946,
0.4083671271800995,
0.26493725180625916,
0.25019294023513794,
0.23271195590496063,
0.44155481457710266,
-0.5459117293357849,
0.12868733704090118,
-0.24920034408569336,
-0.36283254623413086,
-0.1567240208387375,
-0.028518470004200935,
0.5155900120735168,
0.47740352153778076,
-0.38934293389320374,
0.1464643031358719,
0.22208908200263977,
0.773772120475769,
-0.8786134123802185,
0.5832192897796631,
-0.5435609817504883,
-0.12191418558359146,
0.2822811007499695,
-0.42747318744659424,
-0.4804002046585083,
-0.6007300019264221,
-0.04378426447510719,
-0.6397620439529419,
-0.11304116994142532,
-0.132661372423172,
0.5752688646316528,
0.5929712653160095,
-0.32928726077079773,
-0.5679934024810791,
-0.4528326690196991,
0.903192937374115,
-0.8627719283103943,
0.10998114943504333,
0.4900778532028198,
0.20134039223194122,
-0.3178473114967346,
-0.5196446180343628,
-0.42861369252204895,
-0.07645798474550247,
-0.11613176017999649,
0.2963860332965851,
0.28690361976623535,
0.23919065296649933,
0.08378832042217255,
0.27372947335243225,
-0.5372183322906494,
0.0734340026974678,
-0.04166143760085106,
-0.120698481798172,
0.8367280960083008,
0.034224096685647964,
-0.3607407808303833,
-0.06912203878164291,
-0.6617410778999329,
-0.2610931694507599,
-0.5796205401420593,
0.045771557837724686,
0.3250824511051178,
0.33171263337135315,
0.06323909014463425,
0.3660811185836792,
-0.2093382477760315,
0.6310596466064453,
0.28181371092796326,
-0.3094314932823181,
0.0845004990696907,
0.05430229380726814,
-0.267819344997406,
0.1796094924211502,
0.7539438009262085,
0.6314910054206848,
0.48797607421875,
0.011010653339326382,
-0.33961114287376404,
0.07003902643918991,
0.10923105478286743,
-0.8313711881637573,
-0.12784141302108765,
0.3549771010875702,
-0.015120688825845718,
-0.509924054145813,
0.06314928084611893,
-0.44861912727355957,
-0.4265892505645752,
-0.4305093288421631,
0.6075525879859924,
-0.3518204689025879,
0.03492068499326706,
0.51640385389328,
0.10120338946580887,
0.36385491490364075,
0.4597246050834656,
-0.9033299684524536,
0.4570435881614685,
0.6299406290054321,
0.3724882900714874,
-0.22062459588050842,
-0.29862549901008606,
-0.5291863083839417,
0.15918560326099396,
-0.5817126631736755,
0.641886293888092,
-0.27324333786964417,
-0.2714095115661621,
0.19314004480838776,
-0.10853207111358643,
-0.29166823625564575,
-0.4722895622253418,
0.3812212347984314,
-0.3103365898132324,
0.3284411132335663,
-0.2801629602909088,
-0.9408167600631714,
-0.11626636981964111,
0.5774863958358765,
-0.10288309305906296,
1.2182095050811768,
0.1700730174779892,
-0.7247974872589111,
-0.016430307179689407,
-0.33870527148246765,
-0.16259701550006866,
-0.015042291954159737,
-0.5352616906166077,
-0.24141378700733185,
-0.062201015651226044,
0.27368924021720886,
0.8653107285499573,
-0.035617414861917496,
0.5789570808410645,
-0.27407050132751465,
-0.3543218970298767,
0.37122538685798645,
-0.4256255328655243,
0.2695421874523163,
0.1169140487909317,
-0.33625513315200806,
0.058306727558374405,
-0.7508932948112488,
0.28250980377197266,
-0.19039566814899445,
-0.3248165249824524,
-0.013608998619019985,
-0.11133155971765518,
-0.19869287312030792,
0.14456778764724731,
0.3658693730831146,
-0.3654974400997162,
0.01538595836609602,
-0.38803616166114807,
0.13501496613025665,
0.950756311416626,
0.2068411111831665,
0.48039066791534424,
-0.5321731567382812,
0.4046143889427185,
-0.10417260974645615,
-0.004563666880130768,
-0.2680133879184723,
-0.010963430628180504,
-0.86391681432724,
0.021622247993946075,
0.14027096331119537,
0.5656648874282837,
-0.7543854117393494,
0.45048776268959045,
-0.2501474618911743,
-0.36352434754371643,
-0.1644631177186966,
0.3493296802043915,
0.5194647908210754,
0.8141556978225708,
0.37988078594207764,
-0.016583837568759918,
-0.39631715416908264,
-0.8236854076385498,
-0.11210174858570099,
-0.31324633955955505,
0.0027551704552024603,
0.16738508641719818,
0.4635399580001831,
-0.10281910002231598,
0.8168486952781677,
-0.513015866279602,
-0.26519450545310974,
-0.0927191898226738,
0.41077354550361633,
0.05119621753692627,
0.5649014115333557,
0.18303276598453522,
-0.4762788712978363,
-0.31065496802330017,
-0.23287460207939148,
-0.7830567359924316,
0.026057148352265358,
-0.2973019480705261,
-0.08398520946502686,
0.2277945578098297,
0.5532572269439697,
-0.3339202404022217,
0.14253127574920654,
0.6421799659729004,
-0.09286432713270187,
0.6137582063674927,
-0.3195240795612335,
0.10539015382528305,
-0.8951614499092102,
-0.27651137113571167,
0.2188974767923355,
-0.5529512763023376,
-0.14235153794288635,
-0.031012533232569695,
0.11277907341718674,
0.2889547049999237,
-0.3030237853527069,
0.45768776535987854,
-0.19696086645126343,
0.20702792704105377,
-0.32408076524734497,
0.17982584238052368,
-0.0013785480987280607,
0.73707515001297,
0.12339429557323456,
0.8362561464309692,
0.503292441368103,
-0.6608425378799438,
0.12748374044895172,
0.04643237218260765,
-0.41584593057632446,
0.892691969871521,
-0.5114066004753113,
-0.13801787793636322,
-0.23574198782444,
0.09806151688098907,
-0.908165693283081,
-0.5889672636985779,
0.13685768842697144,
-0.35089340806007385,
0.514100193977356,
-0.09982004016637802,
-0.2585214078426361,
-0.19046984612941742,
-0.29304733872413635,
-0.13152796030044556,
0.5356565117835999,
-0.5896523594856262,
0.5896772146224976,
0.20188498497009277,
-0.1248067319393158,
-0.8774991631507874,
-0.864208459854126,
-0.13418376445770264,
-0.029355470091104507,
-0.6483778357505798,
0.12047930061817169,
-0.4160071015357971,
-0.18916548788547516,
-0.1801866590976715,
-0.29023265838623047,
-0.06843001395463943,
0.16324356198310852,
0.1834965944290161,
0.033222783356904984,
0.04659400135278702,
0.4834247827529907,
0.10737720131874084,
-0.27869129180908203,
0.30170637369155884,
-0.38383251428604126,
0.16250506043434143,
-0.6632490754127502,
-0.468631386756897,
-0.24068070948123932,
0.07363510131835938,
0.21850721538066864,
0.07883337885141373,
0.7880125641822815,
0.5824618935585022,
-0.33076149225234985,
-0.6066008806228638,
-0.6402612328529358,
-0.3979422450065613,
-0.4937359094619751,
0.37246206402778625,
-0.08452200144529343,
-0.968688428401947,
0.19633711874485016,
-0.15901973843574524,
0.06111094355583191,
0.169089674949646,
0.4932655990123749,
-0.39084792137145996,
0.8982994556427002,
0.4430215358734131,
0.22227518260478973,
0.013987398706376553,
-0.27792108058929443,
-0.008239288814365864,
-0.5045840740203857,
-0.21553604304790497,
-0.041478414088487625,
-0.01170912105590105,
-0.3482522666454315,
-0.5981382131576538,
0.36017897725105286,
0.026018856093287468,
-0.4496263265609741,
0.019362613558769226,
-0.27695125341415405,
0.5872169733047485,
0.4832947850227356,
0.0721781849861145,
0.10490132123231888,
-0.2411181628704071,
0.0029076947830617428,
-0.047716960310935974,
-0.7294641137123108,
-0.7650229930877686,
0.8704397678375244,
0.39883121848106384,
1.2138235569000244,
-0.2953433692455292,
0.983831524848938,
0.3013591468334198,
0.37379083037376404,
-0.9123460650444031,
0.5558318495750427,
0.16434159874916077,
-0.32683971524238586,
-0.35836082696914673,
-0.5421542525291443,
-0.4867028594017029,
-0.03700694069266319,
-0.08552808314561844,
-0.4042474329471588,
0.20170365273952484,
0.5764496922492981,
-0.4433143734931946,
0.10967208445072174,
-0.6922051310539246,
0.7858774065971375,
-0.21810084581375122,
-0.38822585344314575,
-0.0677352175116539,
-0.7156577706336975,
0.3369775414466858,
-0.030890636146068573,
0.2721264660358429,
-0.23308514058589935,
-0.011877535842359066,
0.5055899024009705,
-0.38314488530158997,
1.02006995677948,
-0.1644650250673294,
-0.3115569055080414,
0.34921151399612427,
0.14427275955677032,
0.8804141879081726,
0.25229501724243164,
-0.3221692442893982,
-0.22542956471443176,
0.08954544365406036,
-0.46988439559936523,
-0.8511959314346313,
0.7958828210830688,
-0.5086957216262817,
-0.5428071022033691,
-0.4924645721912384,
-0.6152264475822449,
-0.5188788175582886,
-0.10794903337955475,
0.3122836649417877,
0.35383161902427673,
-0.1260988563299179,
0.171681746840477,
1.1287349462509155,
0.05899718776345253,
0.2699025273323059,
0.3610909879207611,
-0.10992470383644104,
-0.38066038489341736,
0.8044818043708801,
0.1751265525817871,
0.3833216726779938,
0.3542433977127075,
0.27808061242103577,
-0.4761292636394501,
-0.3568476140499115,
-0.2581256330013275,
0.08528046309947968,
-1.0263304710388184,
-0.46895158290863037,
-0.2611241638660431,
-0.25222161412239075,
-0.3096656799316406,
-0.21608830988407135,
-0.4761025309562683,
-0.41377320885658264,
-0.08443295210599899,
-0.3612208068370819,
0.33739975094795227,
0.7815299034118652,
-0.19982247054576874,
0.4470705986022949,
-0.4844517707824707,
-0.2821327745914459,
0.4857535660266876,
0.31827041506767273,
-0.1775244027376175,
-0.5052112340927124,
-0.39925873279571533,
0.15142199397087097,
-0.12623034417629242,
-0.5452011227607727,
0.26503029465675354,
0.24194014072418213,
0.46074947714805603,
0.2996150255203247,
0.37666401267051697,
0.5796640515327454,
-0.3102518320083618,
0.5531734824180603,
0.32854726910591125,
-0.8729581832885742,
0.42103421688079834,
-0.46653515100479126,
0.24396535754203796,
0.7876740097999573,
0.4623498320579529,
-0.4992474615573883,
-0.3924829661846161,
-0.539685845375061,
-0.5518447756767273,
0.5554969310760498,
0.03687892481684685,
0.06207982450723648,
-0.25293588638305664,
0.3767003118991852,
-0.08211419731378555,
0.2790760099887848,
-0.7640483975410461,
-0.33756279945373535,
-0.16716796159744263,
-0.8817692995071411,
-0.0875312015414238,
-0.47623687982559204,
-0.42080408334732056,
0.10484100878238678,
1.0199164152145386,
-0.5872107148170471,
0.08351128548383713,
0.4724355638027191,
-0.06888283044099808,
-0.05772772803902626,
0.35400596261024475,
0.5907328724861145,
0.6621478796005249,
-0.1042189747095108,
0.5118678212165833,
0.28521794080734253,
-0.1334318071603775,
0.15436814725399017,
0.1049264520406723,
-0.08291762322187424,
-0.27941739559173584,
0.2749362289905548,
0.5380815267562866,
0.39969366788864136,
-0.7168347239494324,
0.9391906261444092,
-0.05627180263400078,
-0.43666690587997437,
-0.6353387832641602,
0.30151093006134033,
0.3624841868877411,
0.29901716113090515,
0.26494306325912476,
0.25121647119522095,
0.00701431930065155,
-0.047477077692747116,
0.22698251903057098,
0.2726413905620575,
-0.6598154902458191,
-0.050214074552059174,
0.2566123902797699,
0.07626368850469589,
0.0405222624540329,
0.21618328988552094,
-0.5001018643379211,
-0.3517404794692993,
0.32171884179115295,
0.40026453137397766,
0.6212402582168579,
-0.15658563375473022,
0.36885082721710205,
0.5191476941108704,
0.14186272025108337,
-0.5387977957725525,
0.2757304608821869,
-0.08674933016300201,
-0.7694671750068665,
-0.6716188788414001,
-0.6612842082977295,
-0.40414977073669434,
0.051270920783281326,
-0.6891942024230957,
-0.06417808681726456,
-0.6075682044029236,
-0.13435246050357819,
-0.5422790050506592,
-0.18136490881443024,
-0.3184736669063568,
0.3652459979057312,
0.2261352390050888,
0.8640724420547485,
-0.7836633324623108,
0.47737231850624084,
0.3746336102485657,
-0.26924288272857666,
-1.0738805532455444,
-0.06925636529922485,
-0.02611244097352028,
-0.9453506469726562,
0.4778783917427063,
0.1832161694765091,
-0.4988223612308502,
0.05669509619474411,
-0.8822491765022278,
-0.8672085404396057,
0.9972293376922607,
0.47022396326065063,
-0.65814608335495,
0.06522729247808456,
-0.03310874104499817,
0.4308490753173828,
-0.4705425500869751,
0.16649025678634644,
0.2680010199546814,
0.5218159556388855,
0.2823154926300049,
-0.4098266363143921,
-0.021058788523077965,
-0.06591606885194778,
-0.062732994556427,
-0.07998670637607574,
-0.5418773293495178,
0.3575572073459625,
-0.3156152367591858,
-0.08548422157764435,
0.14060045778751373,
0.7539371848106384,
0.3899145722389221,
0.2933753430843353,
0.4414476752281189,
0.49216291308403015,
0.9136087894439697,
-0.2346021980047226,
0.9251248836517334,
-0.44198599457740784,
0.4090059995651245,
1.5870882272720337,
-0.11398006975650787,
0.9253997206687927,
0.5941416621208191,
0.07902920246124268,
0.7329869866371155,
0.6108535528182983,
0.16283194720745087,
0.35053548216819763,
0.36287379264831543,
-0.4456665515899658,
-0.6423246264457703,
-0.01734994910657406,
-0.05413872376084328,
0.11486112326383591,
0.4997154474258423,
-0.31785738468170166,
-0.3243717551231384,
0.014376276172697544,
-0.028945373371243477,
0.5708430409431458,
-0.37166956067085266,
0.5070713758468628,
0.24654458463191986,
-0.833695113658905,
0.6558560729026794,
-0.09236324578523636,
0.6314947009086609,
-0.752747118473053,
0.02940388396382332,
-0.0732797235250473,
0.36979401111602783,
-0.37847626209259033,
-0.8669774532318115,
0.10351736098527908,
-0.1685515195131302,
0.0211549773812294,
-0.4825591742992401,
0.6761787533760071,
-0.682134747505188,
-0.4694567322731018,
0.17581374943256378,
0.26611557602882385,
0.14178356528282166,
0.08853839337825775,
-0.7538846731185913,
-0.1803850680589676,
-0.03682954981923103,
-0.3615531325340271,
0.018238769844174385,
0.43073123693466187,
0.2831624150276184,
0.8738989233970642,
0.3852483332157135,
-0.0346200130879879,
-0.0531122200191021,
0.2750227451324463,
0.5427600145339966,
-0.3300594985485077,
-0.22084201872348785,
-0.713474452495575,
0.44124072790145874,
-0.06116383150219917,
-0.1969456523656845,
0.791900098323822,
0.4509923756122589,
0.9906470775604248,
-0.046456269919872284,
0.7768771052360535,
0.2745598554611206,
0.5470840334892273,
-0.6696077585220337,
0.27934035658836365,
-0.3494807183742523,
0.37154051661491394,
0.024020129814743996,
-0.6212230324745178,
-0.26840242743492126,
0.9162275791168213,
-0.5295604467391968,
0.19664335250854492,
0.5332179069519043,
1.0987666845321655,
0.21570509672164917,
-0.05342957377433777,
0.41529029607772827,
0.25973790884017944,
0.026135215535759926,
0.6577164530754089,
0.911566972732544,
-0.4292723536491394,
0.5763835906982422,
-0.3203691244125366,
-0.14923495054244995,
-0.011020838283002377,
-1.0627187490463257,
-0.8588595986366272,
-0.3677970767021179,
-0.45420342683792114,
-0.37226271629333496,
0.1715003401041031,
1.156106948852539,
0.8500792980194092,
-0.8579897880554199,
-0.26771649718284607,
-0.6016020774841309,
-0.03728393837809563,
-0.06570643931627274,
-0.20928092300891876,
0.2633099853992462,
-0.8473629951477051,
-0.561153769493103,
0.30481940507888794,
0.358500212430954,
0.2978397309780121,
-0.42566511034965515,
-0.5681814551353455,
-0.026336366310715675,
0.22362375259399414,
0.3071410655975342,
0.12432591617107391,
-0.5361360311508179,
-0.39029377698898315,
0.08622083067893982,
-0.37452229857444763,
0.05492290109395981,
0.3692403733730316,
-0.6468164920806885,
0.29368841648101807,
0.23242880403995514,
0.7406842708587646,
0.5086740255355835,
0.13235560059547424,
0.7095523476600647,
-0.9451867341995239,
-0.19119837880134583,
0.2560109794139862,
0.32374754548072815,
0.5660595893859863,
-0.4381423890590668,
0.48243775963783264,
-0.022373024374246597,
-0.7263650894165039,
-0.6226499080657959,
0.2864118814468384,
-0.7492856979370117,
-0.27054962515830994,
1.1842029094696045,
-0.3802199065685272,
-0.31656503677368164,
0.005712311249226332,
-0.1810649335384369,
0.028897633776068687,
-0.3568201959133148,
0.7472622394561768,
0.8081261515617371,
-0.11281140893697739,
-0.07725925743579865,
-0.10113595426082611,
0.8229129314422607,
0.5669957399368286,
-0.7208101749420166,
0.2208303064107895,
0.3403988480567932,
0.33627432584762573,
-0.012151503935456276,
0.6211231350898743,
-0.002132196445018053,
0.30101725459098816,
-0.26366549730300903,
0.0017498537199571729,
-0.0990038812160492,
-0.29643288254737854,
-0.3792720437049866,
0.006376068573445082,
0.31557998061180115,
0.11157830059528351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20973v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20973v1
|
LCQ: Low-Rank Codebook based Quantization for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T16:21:05
| 2024-05-31T16:21:05
|
Wen-Pu Cai, Wu-Jun Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models~(LLMs) have recently demonstrated promising performance
in many tasks. However, the high storage and computational cost of LLMs has
become a challenge for deploying LLMs. Weight quantization has been widely used
for model compression, which can reduce both storage and computational cost.
Most existing weight quantization methods for LLMs use a rank-one codebook for
quantization, which results in substantial accuracy loss when the compression
ratio is high. In this paper, we propose a novel weight quantization method,
called low-rank codebook based quantization~(LCQ), for LLMs. LCQ adopts a
low-rank codebook, the rank of which can be larger than one, for quantization.
Experiments show that LCQ can achieve better accuracy than existing methods
with a negligibly extra storage cost.
|
[
0.0000069540278673230205,
-0.387477308511734,
0.3856136202812195,
0.07526307553052902,
-0.34603583812713623,
0.3639313280582428,
-0.26617810130119324,
-0.10591857135295868,
-0.008694789372384548,
0.4216875433921814,
-0.15510083734989166,
-0.7176380157470703,
-0.5593852996826172,
0.032661072909832,
-0.4212263822555542,
0.6623927354812622,
0.20870114862918854,
0.3787025213241577,
-0.5002133250236511,
-0.04898388311266899,
-0.31232529878616333,
-1.0079166889190674,
-0.6108874082565308,
-0.062262460589408875,
0.4917747676372528,
0.4149029552936554,
1.0788911581039429,
0.6479709148406982,
0.5163335204124451,
0.2362443059682846,
-0.4050997495651245,
-0.01345466822385788,
-0.5016221404075623,
-0.10694213956594467,
0.4200545847415924,
-0.8015751838684082,
-0.9190804362297058,
-0.2658005356788635,
1.0952227115631104,
0.6842236518859863,
-0.4173389673233032,
0.3063097596168518,
-0.08225364983081818,
0.953652560710907,
-0.8528779745101929,
-0.0872492864727974,
-0.35829412937164307,
0.031201284378767014,
-0.12124788016080856,
-0.1704815775156021,
-0.5869839191436768,
-0.4991157352924347,
-0.5700065493583679,
-0.4596485495567322,
-0.10674123466014862,
0.2735367715358734,
0.46216246485710144,
0.24176238477230072,
-0.6525778770446777,
-0.07153040915727615,
-0.6506859660148621,
1.1151607036590576,
-1.161880612373352,
0.36423006653785706,
0.45312634110450745,
0.03834107890725136,
0.1312498301267624,
-0.31411176919937134,
-0.5661426186561584,
-0.12948200106620789,
-0.0548429936170578,
-0.18813179433345795,
0.019393717870116234,
0.2142694741487503,
0.5122840404510498,
0.6565694212913513,
-0.7663804888725281,
0.11219102144241333,
-0.16499097645282745,
-0.05076057091355324,
0.6392084360122681,
0.05366984009742737,
0.30743804574012756,
-0.09413345903158188,
-0.23777619004249573,
-0.22583043575286865,
-0.8688792586326599,
0.21589212119579315,
0.3160414397716522,
0.38887253403663635,
-0.04558458924293518,
0.5801563858985901,
-0.4973607063293457,
0.8093841671943665,
-0.39150089025497437,
-0.5993987917900085,
0.05536217987537384,
-0.1375790238380432,
-0.37370651960372925,
0.27719682455062866,
0.5571371912956238,
0.15276594460010529,
0.09372300654649734,
-0.032437726855278015,
-0.359887957572937,
-0.22611062228679657,
-0.10798051208257675,
-1.3050936460494995,
-0.17203792929649353,
0.167012020945549,
-0.9156094193458557,
-0.5274291634559631,
-0.22597786784172058,
-0.4477287828922272,
-0.31121063232421875,
-0.17432460188865662,
0.5362841486930847,
-0.20556703209877014,
-0.038399048149585724,
0.07491979748010635,
0.22209198772907257,
0.37717610597610474,
0.417799174785614,
-0.7899124622344971,
0.5641227960586548,
0.5216334462165833,
0.9687565565109253,
-0.0661681592464447,
0.2730960547924042,
-0.9399362206459045,
0.0779486745595932,
-0.45005202293395996,
0.5109100937843323,
-0.5062585473060608,
-0.4004174768924713,
0.07749433815479279,
-0.17110823094844818,
0.3883933424949646,
-0.44665828347206116,
0.6335965394973755,
-0.7167473435401917,
-0.17331184446811676,
-0.1512916535139084,
-0.8951302766799927,
0.15367840230464935,
0.18586811423301697,
-0.7362752556800842,
1.1158406734466553,
-0.04131264239549637,
-0.525073230266571,
-0.08371977508068085,
0.06536151468753815,
-0.38972774147987366,
0.33859995007514954,
-0.07672140002250671,
-0.5437389016151428,
0.15918691456317902,
0.29157909750938416,
0.39154478907585144,
-0.6048851609230042,
0.09143021702766418,
-0.312409907579422,
-0.9004625082015991,
0.2931413948535919,
-0.4295983612537384,
0.6978843212127686,
0.2981581687927246,
0.24088506400585175,
-0.24535714089870453,
-0.7091984152793884,
0.5320170521736145,
0.15292486548423767,
-0.7068952322006226,
-0.5763198137283325,
0.0871741846203804,
-0.054728198796510696,
-0.14474724233150482,
0.5482089519500732,
-0.3663736879825592,
0.8122380971908569,
-0.45009833574295044,
0.356913298368454,
0.4152694046497345,
-0.3084152638912201,
0.5804533958435059,
-0.37042102217674255,
0.6877759099006653,
-0.21162649989128113,
0.19569191336631775,
0.1275153011083603,
-0.36746102571487427,
-0.6514531373977661,
-0.4532903730869293,
0.8678566813468933,
0.5078348517417908,
-0.7966285943984985,
0.4236166477203369,
-0.5326757431030273,
-0.425803005695343,
-0.17096495628356934,
0.16327595710754395,
0.5601655840873718,
-0.22852587699890137,
0.34459638595581055,
-0.0017639450961723924,
-0.1253976821899414,
-0.7646603584289551,
-0.17930366098880768,
-0.024658149108290672,
-0.25149258971214294,
0.14529812335968018,
0.23879961669445038,
0.17279677093029022,
0.694744348526001,
-0.7656319737434387,
-0.19047078490257263,
-0.26201069355010986,
0.029207946732640266,
0.3559449315071106,
0.759025514125824,
0.4068278670310974,
-0.7869060635566711,
-0.4607556462287903,
-0.23626118898391724,
-0.3360801041126251,
-0.020954251289367676,
0.07115789502859116,
-0.13477833569049835,
0.46070384979248047,
0.7765313386917114,
-0.46877676248550415,
0.3944784998893738,
0.9393816590309143,
-0.125437393784523,
0.3186139166355133,
-0.20939354598522186,
0.16971567273139954,
-1.053790807723999,
-0.05861997231841087,
-0.27407634258270264,
-0.5654807090759277,
-0.43200841546058655,
0.023746468126773834,
0.4752557873725891,
-0.23762480914592743,
-0.3455577790737152,
0.647080659866333,
-0.4545280933380127,
-0.23504765331745148,
-0.09875594824552536,
0.04097515344619751,
0.15153545141220093,
0.7165416479110718,
-0.13187626004219055,
0.7643400430679321,
0.27433305978775024,
-0.5241208076477051,
0.23295386135578156,
0.22473569214344025,
-0.505260705947876,
0.28171655535697937,
-0.5729184150695801,
0.13631398975849152,
0.020409565418958664,
0.31760066747665405,
-0.7074148058891296,
0.3544686436653137,
-0.09152226895093918,
-0.3636607527732849,
0.415031760931015,
-0.6430835723876953,
-0.8814826607704163,
-0.19692717492580414,
-0.4781215190887451,
0.9027597308158875,
0.7213694453239441,
-0.3878328800201416,
0.3807826638221741,
0.23760341107845306,
-0.291659951210022,
-0.6012917160987854,
-0.7855247855186462,
0.09909993410110474,
-0.08579859882593155,
-0.17920219898223877,
0.5281822681427002,
-0.5132327079772949,
-0.014995884150266647,
-0.20227046310901642,
-0.37407395243644714,
-0.041446950286626816,
-0.07181703299283981,
0.01003219559788704,
0.30637356638908386,
-0.12483153492212296,
0.684538722038269,
0.05123746022582054,
-0.028489042073488235,
-0.25467851758003235,
-0.37016287446022034,
0.5219204425811768,
-0.20834492146968842,
-0.07624540477991104,
-0.2311078906059265,
0.33258679509162903,
0.3683604598045349,
-0.3120235204696655,
1.0011874437332153,
0.25941163301467896,
-0.5697231292724609,
-0.5193367004394531,
-0.37743064761161804,
0.19390548765659332,
-0.48465776443481445,
0.3707244098186493,
-0.3286091685295105,
-0.911830723285675,
0.31835827231407166,
-0.19614997506141663,
-0.33952632546424866,
0.09087470918893814,
0.5984671115875244,
-0.08120428025722504,
1.1058614253997803,
0.5794509053230286,
-0.27899736166000366,
0.3954320251941681,
-0.20742076635360718,
0.35010743141174316,
-0.6272051930427551,
0.14227841794490814,
-0.8793349266052246,
-0.3499870002269745,
-0.518566370010376,
-0.6867698431015015,
0.48404279351234436,
0.6672138571739197,
-0.43163561820983887,
0.15801356732845306,
-0.6676068305969238,
0.7265934348106384,
0.5753835439682007,
0.16050869226455688,
0.805702805519104,
0.042304739356040955,
0.017382130026817322,
0.08112721890211105,
-0.7970919609069824,
-0.5148420929908752,
1.2201735973358154,
0.20943252742290497,
1.0873281955718994,
0.5668375492095947,
0.8340896368026733,
0.5080623030662537,
0.3351549208164215,
-1.1201189756393433,
0.5345022082328796,
-0.4391864240169525,
-0.14898616075515747,
-0.7126242518424988,
-0.8336636424064636,
-0.5634142160415649,
0.2360984981060028,
-0.22457405924797058,
-0.5133984684944153,
-0.019276631996035576,
0.1888066977262497,
-0.4815278649330139,
0.26552528142929077,
-0.4666064977645874,
0.8154925107955933,
-0.17066937685012817,
-0.003058785106986761,
-0.22041527926921844,
-0.15215490758419037,
0.4871450960636139,
-0.027685025706887245,
0.47414425015449524,
0.0019985917024314404,
-0.19907762110233307,
0.9850165247917175,
-0.9743642807006836,
0.5665640234947205,
-0.10044029355049133,
-0.5397757291793823,
0.055064450949430466,
0.3381773829460144,
0.9037910103797913,
0.3012021481990814,
-0.18233607709407806,
0.11071699112653732,
0.6365334391593933,
-0.6055000424385071,
-0.7144903540611267,
0.6853423118591309,
-0.6428342461585999,
-0.31240037083625793,
-0.43048930168151855,
-0.40073278546333313,
-0.2431180477142334,
0.1501902937889099,
-0.006976839154958725,
0.7299777269363403,
0.1519765853881836,
0.4370255768299103,
0.7692919373512268,
-0.6623421907424927,
0.38940131664276123,
0.5101120471954346,
-0.20281188189983368,
-0.5203592777252197,
1.0263197422027588,
0.06278076022863388,
0.325667142868042,
0.9938649535179138,
0.26991066336631775,
0.07638180255889893,
-0.6813136339187622,
-0.15707775950431824,
0.00168909365311265,
-0.7508878111839294,
-0.9380795955657959,
-0.3806162476539612,
-0.26936474442481995,
-0.40232425928115845,
-0.1846134066581726,
-0.591117799282074,
-0.7039278745651245,
0.09860428422689438,
0.4121312201023102,
0.42230287194252014,
0.3039604723453522,
0.36541932821273804,
0.4232902228832245,
-1.0998648405075073,
0.3958912789821625,
0.4074213206768036,
0.47546809911727905,
0.21846149861812592,
-0.5537968873977661,
-0.8486204743385315,
0.06779772788286209,
-0.2024563103914261,
-0.559846043586731,
0.5655103921890259,
0.14240078628063202,
0.12243342399597168,
0.10139961540699005,
0.4820409119129181,
0.5425770878791809,
-0.40074804425239563,
0.6343045234680176,
-0.00392003683373332,
-1.401460886001587,
0.2332860827445984,
-0.04653175175189972,
0.5749849081039429,
0.4160527288913727,
0.2035505473613739,
-0.635158121585846,
-0.24477337300777435,
-0.2231133133172989,
-0.7602528929710388,
0.770773708820343,
0.27844977378845215,
0.1048223227262497,
0.32794278860092163,
0.5025085210800171,
-0.3899228870868683,
0.4307703971862793,
-1.0665578842163086,
-0.3396281599998474,
0.14269426465034485,
-0.44839486479759216,
-0.032151542603969574,
-0.5200250744819641,
0.13483959436416626,
-0.24052110314369202,
0.798143208026886,
-0.34110137820243835,
0.34438613057136536,
0.12895791232585907,
-0.2275933027267456,
-0.25804051756858826,
0.46594905853271484,
0.42946216464042664,
0.22240430116653442,
-0.4100799560546875,
0.0715794712305069,
0.2097633183002472,
-0.4095394015312195,
0.2043313831090927,
-0.1861511468887329,
-0.1688816398382187,
-0.24235215783119202,
0.4198474586009979,
0.44677767157554626,
0.5892131924629211,
-0.7707282304763794,
0.8205822110176086,
-0.037775684148073196,
-0.19910645484924316,
-0.3887963593006134,
-0.14892905950546265,
0.2225695550441742,
0.2514011859893799,
0.4335227310657501,
-0.3004559576511383,
0.15213073790073395,
-0.34275081753730774,
-0.14645835757255554,
0.5957508683204651,
0.11660037189722061,
0.2449912279844284,
0.4337100386619568,
0.142335906624794,
-0.22829917073249817,
0.6375732421875,
-0.3943917155265808,
-0.47509026527404785,
0.7336781024932861,
0.21100154519081116,
0.5186569094657898,
-0.07236269861459732,
0.10194334387779236,
0.5659262537956238,
0.2207425981760025,
-0.3231329023838043,
0.18753516674041748,
-0.2334911823272705,
-0.7350097894668579,
-0.6882264018058777,
-1.1025289297103882,
-0.6951371431350708,
-0.024395566433668137,
-0.6648336052894592,
0.4100114405155182,
-0.3096165060997009,
0.0822351798415184,
-0.37705469131469727,
0.34756383299827576,
-0.429811954498291,
0.17336846888065338,
0.5405582189559937,
0.8591275215148926,
-0.14935153722763062,
1.3193753957748413,
0.3479977250099182,
-0.22698545455932617,
-0.9175294637680054,
0.0003181243664585054,
-0.27790287137031555,
-0.6346423625946045,
0.8701373934745789,
-0.05656621232628822,
0.06183646246790886,
0.4279860556125641,
-0.7300204038619995,
-1.1701160669326782,
1.2830779552459717,
0.30414262413978577,
-0.9367089867591858,
-0.3293363153934479,
0.09322366863489151,
0.25845733284950256,
-0.07924720644950867,
0.24247941374778748,
0.124282106757164,
0.4041409492492676,
0.0949399396777153,
-0.8422984480857849,
0.22899839282035828,
-0.04743687063455582,
0.3942328691482544,
0.32721787691116333,
-0.8278818130493164,
0.9538484811782837,
-0.031013373285531998,
-0.24437279999256134,
0.5682050585746765,
0.4080905318260193,
0.3738935887813568,
-0.09415563195943832,
0.3681834638118744,
0.43271690607070923,
0.7247160077095032,
0.23349469900131226,
1.0671018362045288,
-0.40500301122665405,
0.7647972106933594,
0.9181702733039856,
-0.39354071021080017,
1.1318073272705078,
0.17982713878154755,
-0.6121504306793213,
0.43240952491760254,
0.3259755074977875,
-0.1640927493572235,
0.292583167552948,
0.6955859661102295,
-0.18497499823570251,
-0.5762982964515686,
0.2303583174943924,
-0.25162556767463684,
0.2226913869380951,
0.06953373551368713,
0.01970006711781025,
0.14738568663597107,
-0.0782274454832077,
-0.06633108854293823,
-0.05228564888238907,
-0.49317046999931335,
0.5319764614105225,
0.1996857076883316,
-0.2604564130306244,
1.245190978050232,
0.32953208684921265,
0.7984034419059753,
-0.5514237880706787,
-0.0519939661026001,
-0.29744550585746765,
0.05078737437725067,
-0.13051974773406982,
-0.17579025030136108,
-0.15533654391765594,
-0.07849423587322235,
-0.26868200302124023,
-0.3656559884548187,
0.37327927350997925,
-0.5811640620231628,
-0.8906775712966919,
-0.014909399673342705,
0.5041011571884155,
0.06831654906272888,
-0.32112598419189453,
-0.42515552043914795,
0.26172828674316406,
-0.2154054492712021,
-0.586697518825531,
0.6348212957382202,
0.2848403751850128,
-0.1578281968832016,
0.7667453289031982,
0.5274801254272461,
0.1727316677570343,
-0.2585039436817169,
0.15436474978923798,
0.6965447664260864,
-0.9885056018829346,
-0.532200813293457,
-0.6004791855812073,
0.10659901797771454,
0.16073350608348846,
0.16254010796546936,
0.49229681491851807,
0.6253999471664429,
0.6777002811431885,
-0.08720508217811584,
0.601492166519165,
0.04815558344125748,
0.5288146734237671,
-1.0233852863311768,
0.774535596370697,
-0.9533476233482361,
0.43240681290626526,
-0.2554091811180115,
-1.0096533298492432,
-0.5106184482574463,
0.6091700792312622,
0.034538716077804565,
0.11512064933776855,
0.9981765151023865,
0.902400016784668,
0.5054963827133179,
-0.330411434173584,
0.7811179161071777,
0.23011960089206696,
0.15444085001945496,
0.8605616688728333,
0.4973294734954834,
-0.7627100944519043,
0.8411545753479004,
-0.23918206989765167,
-0.18161754310131073,
-0.24589727818965912,
-0.9706684350967407,
-0.9182416796684265,
-0.43316441774368286,
-0.4399518072605133,
-0.14548249542713165,
-0.10702589899301529,
0.9677013158798218,
0.8285097479820251,
-0.697880744934082,
-0.2478790283203125,
0.040678057819604874,
0.30729901790618896,
-0.2299635261297226,
-0.2598564922809601,
0.5502994060516357,
-0.20446771383285522,
-1.0326870679855347,
0.2703079283237457,
-0.05745670944452286,
0.14459076523780823,
-0.19647067785263062,
-0.36115676164627075,
-0.0012520768214017153,
-0.015309039503335953,
0.6728212237358093,
0.015915410593152046,
-0.5365684032440186,
0.08919958770275116,
-0.22343499958515167,
-0.3451892137527466,
-0.05276811867952347,
0.9588767290115356,
-1.0049962997436523,
-0.08206617832183838,
0.36330655217170715,
0.4991791248321533,
0.5032877326011658,
0.08087881654500961,
0.514284610748291,
-0.9043931365013123,
0.25783979892730713,
0.2525542974472046,
0.34235379099845886,
0.1891898661851883,
-0.4838707149028778,
0.44515857100486755,
0.12108946591615677,
-0.65518718957901,
-1.1614800691604614,
-0.07202237099409103,
-1.245346188545227,
-0.4109826982021332,
1.157776117324829,
0.09948792308568954,
-0.11792014539241791,
0.4966484308242798,
-0.17479948699474335,
0.09932202100753784,
-0.5416226387023926,
0.41861385107040405,
0.6838780045509338,
0.3201419413089752,
-0.4719688892364502,
-0.6144251227378845,
0.7521706819534302,
0.523394763469696,
-0.7479608654975891,
0.18258750438690186,
0.26515382528305054,
-0.03174214065074921,
-0.09218019992113113,
0.6288169026374817,
-0.10860009491443634,
0.011398828588426113,
-0.2207513451576233,
0.6248250007629395,
-0.03212791681289673,
0.09756522625684738,
-0.47067585587501526,
0.11348102986812592,
0.3722924590110779,
0.1584971845149994
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20967v1
|
Superlatives in Context: Explicit and Implicit Domain Restrictions for Superlative Frames
| 2024-05-31T16:14:06
| 2024-05-31T16:14:06
|
Valentina Pyatkin, Bonnie Webber, Ido Dagan, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Superlatives are used to single out elements with a maximal/minimal property.
Semantically, superlatives perform a set comparison: something (or some things)
has the min/max property out of a set. As such, superlatives provide an ideal
phenomenon for studying implicit phenomena and discourse restrictions. While
this comparison set is often not explicitly defined, its (implicit)
restrictions can be inferred from the discourse context the expression appears
in. In this work we provide an extensive computational study on the semantics
of superlatives. We propose a unified account of superlative semantics which
allows us to derive a broad-coverage annotation schema. Using this unified
schema we annotated a multi-domain dataset of superlatives and their semantic
interpretations. We specifically focus on interpreting implicit or ambiguous
superlative expressions, by analyzing how the discourse context restricts the
set of interpretations. In a set of experiments we then analyze how well models
perform at variations of predicting superlative semantics, with and without
context. We show that the fine-grained semantics of superlatives in context can
be challenging for contemporary models, including GPT-4.
|
[
-0.6442020535469055,
-0.7439247369766235,
0.584838330745697,
0.1581929624080658,
-0.3254716098308563,
-0.24279308319091797,
0.06171257048845291,
-0.7044245004653931,
-0.20334559679031372,
0.4025888741016388,
-0.3526793420314789,
-0.34789609909057617,
-0.7981010675430298,
0.2460465282201767,
-0.5905981063842773,
1.3606135845184326,
-0.08115514367818832,
-0.06636567413806915,
-0.5096026659011841,
-0.4412446916103363,
-0.23861779272556305,
-0.7884538769721985,
0.2400570809841156,
-0.28033703565597534,
0.1700054258108139,
0.1665901392698288,
0.9137648940086365,
0.4926922619342804,
0.7449451684951782,
0.3479389548301697,
-0.42203325033187866,
0.05121520534157753,
-0.2890221178531647,
0.27907389402389526,
-0.4265645146369934,
-0.13004308938980103,
-0.1467473804950714,
0.15864650905132294,
0.6159268021583557,
0.7689130306243896,
0.3687061369419098,
0.032487787306308746,
0.05148017033934593,
0.27133968472480774,
-0.8014664053916931,
0.4766986668109894,
-0.6242087483406067,
0.09754811972379684,
-0.1806023120880127,
-0.2396516054868698,
-0.07656180113554001,
-0.29926079511642456,
0.4098227322101593,
-0.7737635970115662,
0.29224923253059387,
-0.0885145366191864,
1.1479476690292358,
0.27796339988708496,
-0.562763512134552,
-0.03585776314139366,
-0.5317598581314087,
0.7784863710403442,
-0.2761380970478058,
0.160373255610466,
0.05406787246465683,
0.23362162709236145,
-0.07137350738048553,
-0.8677114844322205,
-0.5905107855796814,
-0.4826253354549408,
-0.5300087332725525,
-0.08749087899923325,
-0.2470630407333374,
0.022560160607099533,
0.6168703436851501,
0.4915483593940735,
-0.15568827092647552,
-0.42075425386428833,
-0.04006181284785271,
-0.1972188502550125,
0.4769890606403351,
0.21264329552650452,
0.2858450710773468,
-0.42447417974472046,
-0.7390302419662476,
0.39499345421791077,
-0.7893274426460266,
-0.34222763776779175,
-0.3142227530479431,
0.3629482388496399,
0.22212174534797668,
0.38310229778289795,
-0.43786799907684326,
0.30148014426231384,
-0.23159560561180115,
0.16025136411190033,
0.028213748708367348,
-0.828671932220459,
-0.22117094695568085,
-0.3968058228492737,
0.31482169032096863,
0.5253063440322876,
0.4075816571712494,
-0.18239478766918182,
-0.0392022505402565,
0.43629345297813416,
-0.1259225457906723,
-0.6497522592544556,
0.41043737530708313,
-0.32520315051078796,
-0.015908541157841682,
0.0012589371763169765,
-0.02424175664782524,
-0.29785439372062683,
-0.12030615657567978,
-0.5789331197738647,
0.4039311707019806,
-0.20769578218460083,
0.004128015134483576,
-0.0963159054517746,
-0.35506096482276917,
0.2875983715057373,
0.09188725054264069,
-0.9550892114639282,
0.6843181848526001,
0.770689845085144,
0.5523763298988342,
0.03784476965665817,
-0.6700626015663147,
-0.11412689089775085,
0.2668478488922119,
-0.28740593791007996,
0.9532487988471985,
-0.9688963294029236,
-0.6624188423156738,
-0.06632011383771896,
-0.09223940223455429,
0.028617700561881065,
-0.461132675409317,
0.7980188727378845,
-0.630197286605835,
0.08788251131772995,
-0.2189304679632187,
-0.8595454692840576,
-0.07937563955783844,
-0.2621593773365021,
-0.4196535646915436,
1.0996143817901611,
0.2824757695198059,
-0.5850516557693481,
0.5258755087852478,
-0.5183268785476685,
-0.5531700253486633,
0.4375438392162323,
-0.11830516159534454,
0.24643607437610626,
0.49421876668930054,
-0.11387507617473602,
0.5886895656585693,
-0.523857593536377,
0.2968536913394928,
-0.09496472030878067,
-0.2908720076084137,
0.12843339145183563,
-0.2534917891025543,
0.3690624535083771,
0.07820169627666473,
-0.515765905380249,
0.14471803605556488,
-0.4009714424610138,
0.11960545927286148,
-0.09769029915332794,
0.09365031123161316,
-0.651183545589447,
-0.3496776819229126,
0.09141108393669128,
0.1847294420003891,
0.11796199530363083,
-0.382263720035553,
0.3310964107513428,
-0.0047076730988919735,
0.5530908107757568,
0.7940982580184937,
0.03467511385679245,
0.4956223964691162,
0.09032849222421646,
0.22224903106689453,
-0.35007521510124207,
0.14234206080436707,
0.008623802103102207,
-0.4299265742301941,
-0.2959062159061432,
-0.15904031693935394,
0.701995313167572,
0.33175867795944214,
-0.5770201683044434,
0.09526076912879944,
-0.46545806527137756,
-0.2084159106016159,
-0.06894315779209137,
-0.1593502014875412,
0.757326066493988,
0.2608923316001892,
0.5017164945602417,
-0.20368199050426483,
-0.19235090911388397,
-1.2026288509368896,
-0.15801040828227997,
0.332961767911911,
0.1867249310016632,
0.5613465309143066,
0.9010251760482788,
-0.034776899963617325,
0.8925129771232605,
-0.6625285148620605,
-0.4117436408996582,
-0.02516143023967743,
0.27456265687942505,
-0.04871464893221855,
0.36955490708351135,
0.3984373211860657,
-1.1268763542175293,
-0.343648225069046,
0.08442344516515732,
-0.9375792741775513,
-0.24471691250801086,
-0.042944882065057755,
-0.3531891703605652,
-0.09107556939125061,
0.61998051404953,
-0.8423269987106323,
0.5425170063972473,
0.1665888875722885,
-0.43636152148246765,
0.854396402835846,
-0.13256330788135529,
0.048828307539224625,
-0.5673332810401917,
-0.05201317369937897,
0.13342709839344025,
-0.09549493342638016,
-0.7044815421104431,
0.6720401644706726,
-0.09233067184686661,
0.33862006664276123,
-0.7884475588798523,
0.7185502052307129,
-0.19343999028205872,
-0.24189409613609314,
-0.17929129302501678,
0.049943823367357254,
0.18175752460956573,
0.5048885941505432,
0.27348944544792175,
0.49075013399124146,
0.6272997260093689,
-0.7405881881713867,
0.3216017484664917,
0.35974690318107605,
-0.15478269755840302,
1.137370228767395,
-0.5483796000480652,
0.03127294406294823,
0.010686907917261124,
0.5756047368049622,
-0.7600275278091431,
-0.2973235547542572,
0.014247536659240723,
-0.2321375459432602,
0.10610080510377884,
-0.20391100645065308,
-0.38794270157814026,
0.17830662429332733,
-0.14162692427635193,
0.5263668298721313,
-0.19926626980304718,
-0.4012439548969269,
0.26525959372520447,
0.4151609241962433,
-0.07390175014734268,
-0.7673361301422119,
-0.49481990933418274,
0.13243937492370605,
-0.26890119910240173,
-0.4253644347190857,
0.9319466948509216,
-0.26866549253463745,
-0.29467496275901794,
0.193189337849617,
-0.25679951906204224,
-0.23538880050182343,
0.006170094944536686,
0.34096384048461914,
0.4115012288093567,
-0.1451786905527115,
0.07944519072771072,
0.1971745640039444,
-0.47518837451934814,
-0.08394051343202591,
-0.2001914381980896,
0.050439171493053436,
-0.5683561563491821,
-0.0927196815609932,
-0.23971688747406006,
0.7674931883811951,
0.5684614777565002,
0.17449937760829926,
0.5037839412689209,
0.18244582414627075,
-0.5035028457641602,
-0.005564127583056688,
-0.21596494317054749,
0.07636802643537521,
-0.35822686553001404,
0.3452081084251404,
-1.0236272811889648,
-1.0212268829345703,
0.4103933870792389,
0.05584125965833664,
-0.058663658797740936,
0.6951051950454712,
0.4017801880836487,
0.4583550691604614,
1.2405391931533813,
0.22451473772525787,
0.1069144457578659,
0.168481707572937,
-0.3108155131340027,
-0.07861670851707458,
-1.1110235452651978,
-0.14319822192192078,
-0.5626077055931091,
-0.08970263600349426,
-0.49631351232528687,
-0.08062557131052017,
0.10070089250802994,
0.228498175740242,
-0.23652541637420654,
0.4612729251384735,
-0.5190842151641846,
1.1130212545394897,
0.5250558257102966,
-0.2735314667224884,
0.3627283573150635,
-0.17571388185024261,
-0.33326852321624756,
-0.17742948234081268,
-0.3087252974510193,
-0.5248039960861206,
0.8910449147224426,
-0.02019493840634823,
0.16068801283836365,
0.16736482083797455,
0.11074589192867279,
0.616024911403656,
0.5081844925880432,
-0.6489856839179993,
0.9716101288795471,
-0.16469748318195343,
-0.9871811866760254,
-0.285491019487381,
-0.30867981910705566,
-1.0706502199172974,
0.5610462427139282,
-0.09786906093358994,
-0.7294183969497681,
0.15006336569786072,
-0.4254959225654602,
-0.43756988644599915,
-0.0698213055729866,
-0.5489599704742432,
0.9361639618873596,
-0.09488508105278015,
-0.7273157238960266,
0.05454046651721001,
-0.7164105176925659,
0.031299661844968796,
0.05083998292684555,
0.20917494595050812,
-0.23978547751903534,
-0.082576684653759,
0.31219103932380676,
-0.2272101491689682,
0.4417295753955841,
-0.07207567989826202,
0.06799592822790146,
0.06937507539987564,
0.3316047191619873,
0.228870689868927,
-0.10759582370519638,
0.10563962906599045,
0.4840010106563568,
0.15592613816261292,
-0.4389181435108185,
-0.7382523417472839,
0.8367086052894592,
-0.5254167318344116,
-0.5812106728553772,
-0.44878825545310974,
-0.5372111797332764,
-0.15035316348075867,
0.34518957138061523,
0.43485644459724426,
0.6710804104804993,
-0.1989290863275528,
0.023183800280094147,
0.15961705148220062,
0.24923452734947205,
0.16698326170444489,
0.4837515950202942,
-0.03996076062321663,
0.22264234721660614,
1.042389154434204,
0.39545610547065735,
0.19774779677391052,
0.23695367574691772,
0.2714475393295288,
-0.7527537941932678,
-0.5878477096557617,
-0.37049105763435364,
0.06238725036382675,
-1.0749592781066895,
-0.16342483460903168,
-0.1426117718219757,
-0.14060959219932556,
-0.288038432598114,
-0.2602076232433319,
0.07852386683225632,
-0.7586884498596191,
0.13363176584243774,
-0.31516674160957336,
-0.030400969088077545,
0.9368205666542053,
-0.21203692257404327,
-0.08701496571302414,
-0.42416003346443176,
0.12684711813926697,
0.540510356426239,
0.28394582867622375,
-0.4421846866607666,
-0.4462084472179413,
-0.19059434533119202,
-0.495208740234375,
-0.12257111072540283,
-0.5447369813919067,
0.1229814812541008,
0.31179019808769226,
0.7026082277297974,
0.19296897947788239,
0.03548641875386238,
0.4666087329387665,
-0.6342032551765442,
0.9707998633384705,
-0.1230379194021225,
-1.3320605754852295,
0.360965371131897,
-0.35863807797431946,
-0.021978409960865974,
0.5227170586585999,
0.5613793134689331,
-0.3115520179271698,
-0.48598557710647583,
-0.9903787970542908,
-1.1973007917404175,
0.43265238404273987,
0.41892069578170776,
0.46338531374931335,
-0.13660261034965515,
0.5620399117469788,
0.2274867594242096,
0.23641815781593323,
-0.7567059993743896,
-0.5106313228607178,
-0.012662503868341446,
0.2524871230125427,
0.07913348823785782,
-0.16364888846874237,
-0.4908183217048645,
-0.2920331656932831,
0.4139772355556488,
-0.14681172370910645,
0.30881571769714355,
0.10532315820455551,
-0.34892404079437256,
0.1619042009115219,
0.5778408646583557,
0.7796483039855957,
0.6957896947860718,
0.06832592189311981,
0.46525880694389343,
0.5144166946411133,
-0.1602593958377838,
0.24059362709522247,
0.28929999470710754,
-0.09592624753713608,
0.03899248316884041,
0.33480098843574524,
0.5773502588272095,
0.6442251801490784,
-0.24920544028282166,
0.493999183177948,
0.04687843844294548,
-0.1668214499950409,
0.12025123089551926,
-0.04976280406117439,
-0.30538102984428406,
0.19138158857822418,
0.3724440634250641,
0.1019006296992302,
0.4748933017253876,
-0.5418944358825684,
0.4499445855617523,
0.4778091311454773,
-0.5266138315200806,
-0.24580249190330505,
0.622201681137085,
0.10441416501998901,
-0.07827311754226685,
0.1461886465549469,
-0.343954473733902,
-0.7515230774879456,
0.38051384687423706,
0.36949241161346436,
0.5977067947387695,
0.017752327024936676,
0.08791684359312057,
-0.1370428055524826,
-0.1642485111951828,
0.08078649640083313,
-0.12813840806484222,
-0.37408187985420227,
-0.8108152151107788,
-0.3929736316204071,
-0.4691230356693268,
-0.6680963635444641,
0.016983898356556892,
-0.7049263715744019,
-0.059289637953042984,
-0.278252512216568,
-0.2881060242652893,
0.6543089747428894,
-0.1386595368385315,
-0.4524427652359009,
0.2775181829929352,
0.3599320948123932,
0.5377659201622009,
-0.82065749168396,
0.4948972761631012,
0.617551326751709,
-0.37360259890556335,
-0.7611761689186096,
0.020196719095110893,
0.1510975956916809,
-0.4182359576225281,
0.877530574798584,
0.23304083943367004,
-0.29919224977493286,
-0.03506065532565117,
-0.5471318364143372,
-0.701775074005127,
0.4680405855178833,
0.411487340927124,
0.18485380709171295,
0.11440258473157883,
0.2553829848766327,
0.7970883846282959,
-0.5903552174568176,
0.7110791206359863,
0.933682382106781,
0.5140534043312073,
0.1079869493842125,
-0.9907065033912659,
0.38697388768196106,
-0.4472444951534271,
-0.04300549253821373,
0.11272979527711868,
-0.5836087465286255,
0.9412887096405029,
-0.015580824576318264,
-0.29581695795059204,
0.06811287999153137,
0.6448733806610107,
0.07017353922128677,
0.4727398753166199,
0.23559889197349548,
0.36319175362586975,
0.4728425443172455,
-0.40134984254837036,
1.4122164249420166,
-0.47096362709999084,
0.6575778722763062,
0.9090992212295532,
-0.3676845133304596,
0.6517905592918396,
-0.0009424047893844545,
-0.28218457102775574,
0.6674991250038147,
0.5038473010063171,
0.3144203722476959,
0.4075969159603119,
0.30797508358955383,
-0.3909819424152374,
-0.24767017364501953,
-0.6895819306373596,
-0.7400767207145691,
0.4357125759124756,
0.49363723397254944,
-0.1497480273246765,
-0.23403257131576538,
-0.2740841805934906,
0.15587788820266724,
-0.16948111355304718,
-0.3524218797683716,
0.5900458693504333,
0.06629174947738647,
-0.7095980048179626,
0.5727843046188354,
-0.09280414879322052,
0.3202088475227356,
-0.5430357456207275,
-0.18013037741184235,
-0.2684888243675232,
0.028443310409784317,
-0.3556395471096039,
-0.9120490550994873,
0.3766685426235199,
-0.2953331172466278,
-0.0738074854016304,
-0.2526869475841522,
0.7771530747413635,
0.08740716427564621,
-0.25848087668418884,
0.40249139070510864,
0.4148715138435364,
0.29278069734573364,
-0.10062209516763687,
-0.7710007429122925,
-0.23914048075675964,
-0.49866974353790283,
-0.4679504632949829,
0.40279075503349304,
0.5854247808456421,
-0.27591073513031006,
0.3088191747665405,
0.6702703833580017,
0.0350164994597435,
-0.2337455451488495,
0.23326733708381653,
0.948305070400238,
-0.6904393434524536,
-0.4482741951942444,
-0.8565302491188049,
0.2808802127838135,
-0.07662118971347809,
-0.6075865626335144,
0.8901640772819519,
0.48960188031196594,
0.8203563094139099,
0.3453652560710907,
0.778322160243988,
0.07914819568395615,
0.3164641559123993,
-0.2761326730251312,
0.09540335088968277,
-0.53521329164505,
0.3072938621044159,
-0.7245599031448364,
-0.9902989268302917,
-0.6441255211830139,
0.5723550915718079,
-0.5161529183387756,
-0.0012186717940494418,
0.8236321210861206,
0.5696635246276855,
0.08434053510427475,
0.5110222101211548,
0.33709588646888733,
0.1703380048274994,
-0.13099244236946106,
0.49608224630355835,
1.317445993423462,
-0.16803836822509766,
0.4825228750705719,
-0.08138646185398102,
-0.20413832366466522,
-0.1739853173494339,
-0.8418649435043335,
-0.37765246629714966,
-0.5567337274551392,
-0.14397753775119781,
-0.3901346027851105,
0.13592490553855896,
0.6319752931594849,
0.8877554535865784,
-0.8539133071899414,
0.00964483991265297,
-0.13733597099781036,
0.362379252910614,
-0.3434025049209595,
-0.2515464425086975,
0.44617265462875366,
0.004392314236611128,
-0.9425418376922607,
0.3265994191169739,
0.3522736132144928,
-0.0013484973460435867,
-0.28964853286743164,
0.08560805022716522,
0.08476650714874268,
0.44504988193511963,
0.7847259640693665,
0.14154183864593506,
-0.5616295337677002,
-0.7260973453521729,
-0.2331058382987976,
-0.22212600708007812,
-0.09332436323165894,
0.9303545951843262,
-0.6406702399253845,
0.09176483005285263,
0.43253472447395325,
0.21642084419727325,
0.4232020378112793,
0.24721981585025787,
0.255488783121109,
-0.8352310061454773,
-0.061278652399778366,
0.11774890869855881,
0.32176151871681213,
0.04418034851551056,
-0.2756044566631317,
0.7646031975746155,
0.6179195642471313,
-0.49478548765182495,
-0.8482994437217712,
0.5097255110740662,
-0.6515222191810608,
-0.5770941972732544,
1.221747636795044,
-0.2598310112953186,
0.15735746920108795,
-0.5153490900993347,
-0.14205050468444824,
-0.22136518359184265,
-0.30030539631843567,
0.5299805998802185,
0.8063168525695801,
-0.5416086316108704,
0.26414304971694946,
-0.5856661200523376,
0.5597078204154968,
0.6371910572052002,
-0.6566771864891052,
0.07089691609144211,
0.5059387683868408,
-0.03303339704871178,
0.47765758633613586,
0.34751448035240173,
0.0014905872521921992,
0.29674074053764343,
-0.005051137879490852,
-0.39195963740348816,
0.07329815626144409,
-0.5235142707824707,
-0.22180646657943726,
0.6082938313484192,
-0.37364858388900757,
0.08100300282239914
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20962v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20962v2
|
Large Language Models are Zero-Shot Next Location Predictors
| 2024-05-31T16:07:33
| 2024-06-03T15:10:53
|
Ciro Beneduce, Bruno Lepri, Massimiliano Luca
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Predicting the locations an individual will visit in the future is crucial
for solving many societal issues like disease diffusion and reduction of
pollution among many others. The models designed to tackle next-location
prediction, however, require a significant amount of individual-level
information to be trained effectively. Such data may be scarce or even
unavailable in some geographic regions or peculiar scenarios (e.g., cold-start
in recommendation systems). Moreover, the design of a next-location predictor
able to generalize or geographically transfer knowledge is still an open
research challenge. Recent advances in natural language processing have led to
a rapid diffusion of Large Language Models (LLMs) which have shown good
generalization and reasoning capabilities. These insights, coupled with the
recent findings that LLMs are rich in geographical knowledge, allowed us to
believe that these models can act as zero-shot next-location predictors. This
paper evaluates the capabilities of many popular LLMs in this role,
specifically Llama, GPT-3.5 and Mistral 7B. After designing a proper prompt, we
tested the models on three real-world mobility datasets. The results show that
LLMs can obtain accuracies up to 32.4%, a significant relative improvement of
over 600% when compared to sophisticated DL models specifically designed for
human mobility. Moreover, we show that other LLMs are unable to perform the
task properly. To prevent positively biased results, we also propose a
framework inspired by other studies to test data contamination. Finally, we
explored the possibility of using LLMs as text-based explainers for
next-location prediction showing that can effectively provide an explanation
for their decision. Notably, 7B models provide more generic, but still
reliable, explanations compared to larger counterparts. Code:
github.com/ssai-trento/LLM-zero-shot-NL
|
[
-0.21897949278354645,
-0.6705722212791443,
1.259270191192627,
-0.15905210375785828,
0.040805988013744354,
-0.28620535135269165,
-0.16567206382751465,
-0.628502607345581,
-0.02375810779631138,
0.58575439453125,
-0.22968646883964539,
-0.7727077603340149,
-0.502890408039093,
-0.1382037252187729,
-0.6312780976295471,
0.5378363728523254,
-0.12772145867347717,
-0.33340030908584595,
0.015095505863428116,
-0.08067474514245987,
-0.6102719902992249,
-0.7502111196517944,
-0.5388794541358948,
-0.3570822477340698,
0.6215919852256775,
0.46259570121765137,
0.9366366863250732,
0.6568511128425598,
0.26533544063568115,
0.21934472024440765,
-0.24681636691093445,
-0.3281020224094391,
-0.353342205286026,
0.15644842386245728,
-0.24503442645072937,
-0.503325879573822,
-0.08751586824655533,
-0.4140219986438751,
0.7202916741371155,
0.7540868520736694,
-0.10914560407400131,
0.032784029841423035,
-0.5206798911094666,
0.22310014069080353,
-0.3659706711769104,
-0.0744519755244255,
-0.7700531482696533,
-0.07415619492530823,
-0.199153333902359,
0.07301846891641617,
-0.25639745593070984,
-0.3507919907569885,
0.5216018557548523,
-0.4076983630657196,
0.27500119805336,
0.10786078870296478,
0.9499033689498901,
0.10981835424900055,
-0.4547308087348938,
-0.10275818407535553,
-0.9732387065887451,
0.7214982509613037,
-0.8220207095146179,
0.2113076150417328,
0.5303471684455872,
0.5275989770889282,
-0.31131836771965027,
-0.2587176263332367,
-0.6012082099914551,
-0.3587266504764557,
0.22284342348575592,
-0.26119041442871094,
-0.09537383168935776,
-0.32219991087913513,
0.05068336799740791,
-0.13664637506008148,
-0.585982620716095,
0.5405451655387878,
-0.26844125986099243,
-0.010838791728019714,
0.41708752512931824,
0.2808915674686432,
0.38020020723342896,
0.11000160872936249,
-0.16212202608585358,
0.3065745532512665,
-1.0050580501556396,
0.028333066031336784,
0.07573693245649338,
0.38836437463760376,
-0.28083646297454834,
0.6075882911682129,
-0.30737563967704773,
0.8798139691352844,
-0.08594699949026108,
-0.23205217719078064,
0.2393387407064438,
-0.2837485373020172,
-0.007849139161407948,
0.15283085405826569,
0.7984008193016052,
0.2502746284008026,
0.34111741185188293,
-0.17525586485862732,
-0.06517014652490616,
-0.3750450611114502,
-0.09681767970323563,
-0.7486452460289001,
-0.03934568539261818,
0.3973444700241089,
-0.25162822008132935,
-0.14524735510349274,
-0.19329383969306946,
-0.5009804964065552,
-0.3774746060371399,
-0.27069154381752014,
0.021688096225261688,
-0.335859090089798,
-0.30652278661727905,
0.27812010049819946,
0.20060864090919495,
0.41871577501296997,
0.5038809180259705,
-1.0052863359451294,
-0.28482624888420105,
0.5131884813308716,
1.2067954540252686,
-0.14477872848510742,
-0.49439573287963867,
-0.19320572912693024,
0.4190971851348877,
-0.3443121016025543,
1.1193746328353882,
-0.6493687033653259,
-0.41160884499549866,
0.20539356768131256,
0.044109709560871124,
0.1029655784368515,
-0.3984469771385193,
0.4836086630821228,
-0.5788059830665588,
0.17911335825920105,
-0.46893590688705444,
-0.18181225657463074,
-0.5150488615036011,
0.23034143447875977,
-0.45495662093162537,
0.8052409291267395,
0.09116125106811523,
-0.4471249580383301,
0.3830547332763672,
-0.4795544445514679,
-0.5331950187683105,
0.19318854808807373,
0.26713940501213074,
-0.20821179449558258,
0.1595514416694641,
0.29394587874412537,
0.5587505102157593,
-0.2727442681789398,
0.5455778241157532,
-0.6463938355445862,
-0.4841201603412628,
0.18589751422405243,
-0.46605348587036133,
0.6572537422180176,
0.11408215761184692,
-0.2789967358112335,
-0.012812533415853977,
-0.568996012210846,
-0.20438678562641144,
0.04949665442109108,
-0.2772252559661865,
-0.44932448863983154,
0.04605129733681679,
-0.18656162917613983,
0.39662966132164,
0.400034099817276,
-0.4149548411369324,
0.08206909149885178,
-0.3974969685077667,
0.27143383026123047,
0.766516387462616,
-0.1032429113984108,
0.8818865418434143,
-0.13566569983959198,
0.8148756623268127,
-0.04209386929869652,
0.015622720122337341,
-0.4144217073917389,
-0.6108805537223816,
-0.310761034488678,
0.013961541466414928,
0.03988223522901535,
0.7130190134048462,
-0.5394768714904785,
0.24037687480449677,
-0.528772234916687,
-0.5820501446723938,
-0.05881942808628082,
-0.11687346547842026,
-0.08264648914337158,
0.5876247882843018,
0.18755891919136047,
0.2296721339225769,
-0.42251357436180115,
-0.4011959135532379,
0.04428001865744591,
-0.26798245310783386,
-0.004763043951243162,
0.21911442279815674,
0.3051917850971222,
-0.2729300558567047,
0.9891880750656128,
-0.36993786692619324,
0.008842608891427517,
-0.527467668056488,
-0.41744929552078247,
0.4312707483768463,
-0.03880536928772926,
0.6027966141700745,
-0.6823388338088989,
-0.541719913482666,
0.20133338868618011,
-0.9868602752685547,
-0.2986888885498047,
-0.15584085881710052,
-0.25078174471855164,
0.042676638811826706,
0.3573935329914093,
-0.8311480283737183,
0.2396705448627472,
0.7264963984489441,
-0.3723888397216797,
0.49363309144973755,
-0.27638736367225647,
-0.24132874608039856,
-1.038792610168457,
-0.02736017107963562,
0.25858646631240845,
-0.19354264438152313,
-0.7862499952316284,
-0.16760778427124023,
-0.31681397557258606,
-0.21538960933685303,
-0.5406308174133301,
0.9174728989601135,
-0.4022897183895111,
-0.21618126332759857,
-0.3161706030368805,
0.23734773695468903,
-0.3611028790473938,
-0.07146930694580078,
0.06347834318876266,
0.750576376914978,
0.6651008129119873,
-0.5867766737937927,
0.1545022577047348,
0.21653832495212555,
-0.4311704933643341,
0.3402658700942993,
-0.6638874411582947,
-0.1252807229757309,
-0.2874082922935486,
0.5572173595428467,
-0.9550856351852417,
-0.3238706588745117,
-0.04590887576341629,
-0.32310032844543457,
-0.07784795016050339,
-0.31574928760528564,
-0.4934195578098297,
-0.4380020499229431,
0.032378971576690674,
0.32745596766471863,
0.4824802279472351,
-0.6676143407821655,
0.4822157919406891,
0.42450252175331116,
-0.2701045274734497,
-0.5380306839942932,
-0.5385703444480896,
0.33258023858070374,
-0.5478375554084778,
-0.4789692461490631,
-0.013985419645905495,
0.11351937055587769,
-0.26758235692977905,
-0.01959829591214657,
0.20510897040367126,
-0.13956911861896515,
0.19383946061134338,
0.5913059711456299,
0.4851207137107849,
0.003874479327350855,
0.14920781552791595,
-0.24981971085071564,
-0.36655521392822266,
-0.04951414093375206,
-0.6291101574897766,
0.5689747929573059,
0.17222444713115692,
-0.2691161036491394,
-0.3995552957057953,
0.1503431797027588,
0.6886308193206787,
-0.21367083489894867,
0.907248854637146,
0.5438241362571716,
-0.28495845198631287,
0.14015525579452515,
-0.5927887558937073,
0.30695727467536926,
-0.44362378120422363,
0.5158618688583374,
-0.4130190312862396,
-0.8880305886268616,
0.6189877986907959,
-0.21443511545658112,
0.068703293800354,
0.2836502492427826,
0.7022196650505066,
-0.023956840857863426,
0.834579586982727,
0.9124946594238281,
-0.3622574210166931,
0.6306666731834412,
-0.06526932865381241,
0.5727967023849487,
-0.45723864436149597,
-0.34684285521507263,
-0.5171624422073364,
-0.01961899735033512,
-0.5264956951141357,
-0.36309340596199036,
0.2906952202320099,
0.1105390265583992,
-0.4188980758190155,
0.39421847462654114,
-0.09200833737850189,
0.7490891814231873,
0.35369178652763367,
-0.4097292125225067,
0.05304491147398949,
0.3728700280189514,
-0.16862896084785461,
0.1867615133523941,
-0.7476935386657715,
-0.6203683018684387,
1.0460948944091797,
0.4025185704231262,
0.7794613838195801,
0.2136630266904831,
0.52511066198349,
0.004041018895804882,
0.3542551100254059,
-0.6995256543159485,
0.5275108218193054,
-0.23903261125087738,
-0.4335334897041321,
-0.4709480106830597,
-0.3911586105823517,
-0.9826754927635193,
0.1922084242105484,
-0.01870965026319027,
-0.9964110851287842,
0.17454634606838226,
-0.14743328094482422,
-0.6085548400878906,
0.5731010437011719,
-0.6130697727203369,
0.4861007034778595,
-0.3149383068084717,
-0.3205433785915375,
0.2534753680229187,
-0.5139438509941101,
0.2884178161621094,
-0.322979211807251,
0.45790112018585205,
-0.4658430218696594,
0.11432121694087982,
0.24142460525035858,
-0.2534652054309845,
0.8027875423431396,
-0.34377652406692505,
-0.4013127386569977,
0.25548630952835083,
0.24686242640018463,
0.4585808515548706,
-0.11699075251817703,
-0.4790859818458557,
0.5598734617233276,
-0.17480921745300293,
-0.21494385600090027,
-0.3572395443916321,
0.8941202759742737,
-0.6830651164054871,
-0.42411160469055176,
-0.18221387267112732,
-0.5335595607757568,
-0.07055167108774185,
0.2922764718532562,
0.36991721391677856,
0.38506850600242615,
0.18816235661506653,
-0.0650603324174881,
0.6276211142539978,
-0.5505992770195007,
0.6249238848686218,
0.6794318556785583,
-0.30166804790496826,
-0.18290461599826813,
0.9055634140968323,
0.19741548597812653,
0.0923062339425087,
0.627674400806427,
0.3197067677974701,
-0.7364477515220642,
-0.7270830869674683,
-0.32066455483436584,
0.3586995601654053,
-0.5687886476516724,
-0.1871279925107956,
-0.6782126426696777,
0.018511250615119934,
-0.3176986873149872,
-0.6274399757385254,
-0.20423279702663422,
-0.26212024688720703,
-0.27320852875709534,
-0.31069397926330566,
0.09242601692676544,
0.8339383006095886,
-0.17767512798309326,
0.5514492392539978,
-0.6208372116088867,
0.15968117117881775,
-0.17436502873897552,
0.08770455420017242,
0.06476356834173203,
-0.7138531804084778,
-0.45452502369880676,
-0.07710422575473785,
-0.03419698774814606,
-0.7891885042190552,
0.6468305587768555,
-0.21205975115299225,
0.5903593301773071,
0.3856492042541504,
-0.13505464792251587,
0.7045590877532959,
-0.6654480695724487,
1.0029747486114502,
0.2704026997089386,
-0.6557568311691284,
0.5403643250465393,
-0.5789615511894226,
0.6866723299026489,
0.3664917051792145,
0.4884961247444153,
-0.41705623269081116,
-0.3376157581806183,
-0.3098197877407074,
-0.9529597163200378,
0.334879606962204,
-0.25990086793899536,
0.2971414625644684,
-0.06690380722284317,
0.5899494290351868,
0.027221783995628357,
-0.11305686086416245,
-0.772975742816925,
-0.029282361268997192,
0.20960192382335663,
-0.07086814194917679,
-0.4030269384384155,
-0.6506384015083313,
0.3070829510688782,
-0.019774526357650757,
0.5123518705368042,
-0.0118443937972188,
0.1716754138469696,
0.06764569878578186,
0.11463411897420883,
-0.15191973745822906,
0.29857829213142395,
0.7872404456138611,
0.8696593642234802,
-0.19926832616329193,
0.05288417264819145,
0.4520593285560608,
-0.21295826137065887,
0.5457251667976379,
-0.07692334800958633,
-0.5900350213050842,
0.25554296374320984,
0.38831648230552673,
0.5262519717216492,
-0.06579909473657608,
-0.5663776993751526,
0.5527726411819458,
0.1477830410003662,
0.05267389491200447,
-0.7181180119514465,
-0.17105059325695038,
0.061118535697460175,
0.20293620228767395,
0.2409653514623642,
-0.17427533864974976,
0.031197065487504005,
-0.5347444415092468,
-0.04036088287830353,
0.39562302827835083,
-0.41353151202201843,
-0.5210056304931641,
0.8974072337150574,
0.0409826934337616,
-0.20905305445194244,
0.5239301919937134,
-0.28805288672447205,
-0.5174981355667114,
0.49246373772621155,
0.6361583471298218,
0.7039036154747009,
-0.4890199303627014,
0.25732043385505676,
0.49513930082321167,
0.28178632259368896,
-0.46943575143814087,
0.032628804445266724,
0.20962992310523987,
-0.8196318745613098,
-0.7054354548454285,
-0.520915687084198,
-0.23913319408893585,
0.07081142067909241,
-0.2982264459133148,
0.43030282855033875,
-0.3166449964046478,
-0.3018716275691986,
-0.3665532171726227,
-0.265491783618927,
-0.6733623743057251,
0.046498555690050125,
0.3601589798927307,
0.7432827949523926,
-0.7813414931297302,
0.8398354053497314,
0.7563512921333313,
0.04492839053273201,
-0.808526337146759,
0.14685487747192383,
-0.022827504202723503,
-0.6890087127685547,
0.6797335743904114,
0.2953585982322693,
-0.10456177592277527,
-0.4204418659210205,
-0.5426013469696045,
-1.1487867832183838,
1.2043724060058594,
0.4561261832714081,
-0.8744516372680664,
-0.41230177879333496,
0.1569002866744995,
0.5048868656158447,
-0.2621212601661682,
0.41105958819389343,
0.48414212465286255,
0.29252639412879944,
0.31869903206825256,
-1.0158461332321167,
0.016455253586173058,
0.3787936568260193,
0.3621077835559845,
0.11074085533618927,
-0.5100927948951721,
0.7605568766593933,
-0.815291702747345,
-0.06909861415624619,
0.30235037207603455,
0.37581849098205566,
0.4118299186229706,
0.3344721794128418,
0.3050597310066223,
0.5876428484916687,
0.7551735043525696,
0.03969847410917282,
1.3558772802352905,
-0.3045634329319,
0.2542455196380615,
1.322188138961792,
-0.7112420201301575,
1.0363891124725342,
0.17909254133701324,
0.02124002017080784,
0.6819494366645813,
0.5321798920631409,
0.02296482026576996,
0.7020695805549622,
0.1927362084388733,
-0.4339415729045868,
-0.17594751715660095,
-0.2695179879665375,
-0.25814756751060486,
0.5771828889846802,
0.28487300872802734,
-0.35343578457832336,
-0.4254772663116455,
0.0671989768743515,
0.21665556728839874,
-0.2725176215171814,
-0.26826012134552,
0.49968692660331726,
-0.0379202626645565,
-0.40357911586761475,
0.40231019258499146,
0.18761451542377472,
0.5369434356689453,
-0.5833230018615723,
0.009480555541813374,
-0.3464764356613159,
0.07864851504564285,
-0.18264245986938477,
-0.944061815738678,
0.1518947184085846,
-0.06676733493804932,
-0.09123532474040985,
-0.26984116435050964,
0.8089771270751953,
-0.2275456041097641,
-0.5253350734710693,
0.3113988935947418,
0.5313426852226257,
0.3438536822795868,
-0.1837140917778015,
-0.3456366956233978,
-0.04453040659427643,
0.16978777945041656,
-0.10482918471097946,
0.3523980379104614,
0.7146791219711304,
-0.17536307871341705,
1.1265454292297363,
0.9876032471656799,
0.40045204758644104,
0.06312175840139389,
0.03653721511363983,
0.46479207277297974,
-0.8774366974830627,
-0.5498034358024597,
-1.001957654953003,
0.2020423710346222,
0.28103500604629517,
-0.019912172108888626,
0.7768136858940125,
0.37797096371650696,
0.5072119832038879,
0.16567449271678925,
0.9302967190742493,
0.27341219782829285,
0.4476955533027649,
-0.37387368083000183,
0.44431737065315247,
-0.21913067996501923,
0.5753192901611328,
0.11667682975530624,
-0.8974201083183289,
-0.3569440543651581,
0.6300146579742432,
-0.7557309865951538,
0.032613568007946014,
0.4299761950969696,
0.6551440358161926,
0.06227656826376915,
-0.40355822443962097,
0.575279951095581,
0.17938701808452606,
0.6652565002441406,
0.7469277381896973,
1.0239471197128296,
-0.12258907407522202,
0.47513675689697266,
-0.05590556189417839,
-0.004133692476898432,
-0.14430366456508636,
-0.7797079682350159,
-0.8743454813957214,
-0.3121972382068634,
-0.11427291482686996,
-0.2567974627017975,
-0.009652485139667988,
0.4967142641544342,
0.940383791923523,
-0.5563479661941528,
-0.22350050508975983,
-0.20354612171649933,
0.21243830025196075,
0.3787148594856262,
-0.26261332631111145,
0.16992995142936707,
-0.04625404253602028,
-0.30747610330581665,
0.40060678124427795,
0.40250304341316223,
0.40692177414894104,
-0.32245999574661255,
0.08572271466255188,
0.08923706412315369,
-0.1256074607372284,
0.8567366003990173,
0.325952410697937,
-0.7889143824577332,
-0.26126158237457275,
-0.09955687820911407,
-0.026823488995432854,
-0.1879318207502365,
0.5226204991340637,
-0.8990602493286133,
0.12664371728897095,
0.19225580990314484,
0.42252954840660095,
0.24136559665203094,
0.11376754194498062,
0.668204665184021,
-0.26935482025146484,
0.172572061419487,
-0.05435362085700035,
0.44938528537750244,
0.49259379506111145,
-0.5590742230415344,
0.37677884101867676,
-0.04733097553253174,
-0.6698788404464722,
-0.6870742440223694,
0.14557042717933655,
-0.7419353723526001,
-0.13569608330726624,
1.7144412994384766,
-0.1489093154668808,
-0.18453477323055267,
-0.2735394239425659,
-0.0991004928946495,
-0.22295714914798737,
-0.5060244202613831,
0.6705908179283142,
0.6416572332382202,
0.0407111793756485,
-0.32414039969444275,
-1.0393668413162231,
0.010190222412347794,
0.22780409455299377,
-0.9547414183616638,
0.09035097807645798,
0.583875298500061,
0.6596618890762329,
0.049371395260095596,
0.8961629271507263,
-0.08367566019296646,
-0.11711825430393219,
-0.2564390003681183,
-0.1321619153022766,
0.041488077491521835,
-0.47210693359375,
-0.6174701452255249,
0.269456148147583,
0.1906285434961319,
0.004206669516861439
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20956v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20956v2
|
A Robot Walks into a Bar: Can Language Models Serve as Creativity Support Tools for Comedy? An Evaluation of LLMs' Humour Alignment with Comedians
| 2024-05-31T15:55:51
| 2024-06-03T21:01:50
|
Piotr Wojciech Mirowski, Juliette Love, Kory W. Mathewson, Shakir Mohamed
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We interviewed twenty professional comedians who perform live shows in front
of audiences and who use artificial intelligence in their artistic process as
part of 3-hour workshops on ``AI x Comedy'' conducted at the Edinburgh Festival
Fringe in August 2023 and online. The workshop consisted of a comedy writing
session with large language models (LLMs), a human-computer interaction
questionnaire to assess the Creativity Support Index of AI as a writing tool,
and a focus group interrogating the comedians' motivations for and processes of
using AI, as well as their ethical concerns about bias, censorship and
copyright. Participants noted that existing moderation strategies used in
safety filtering and instruction-tuned LLMs reinforced hegemonic viewpoints by
erasing minority groups and their perspectives, and qualified this as a form of
censorship. At the same time, most participants felt the LLMs did not succeed
as a creativity support tool, by producing bland and biased comedy tropes, akin
to ``cruise ship comedy material from the 1950s, but a bit less racist''. Our
work extends scholarship about the subtle difference between, one the one hand,
harmful speech, and on the other hand, ``offensive'' language as a practice of
resistance, satire and ``punching up''. We also interrogate the global value
alignment behind such language models, and discuss the importance of
community-based value alignment and data ownership to build AI tools that
better suit artists' needs.
|
[
-0.11904170364141464,
-0.44749459624290466,
0.2530535161495209,
0.03275957331061363,
-0.2994016706943512,
0.26132678985595703,
-0.12688888609409332,
-0.47032085061073303,
0.6147576570510864,
0.4938170909881592,
-0.5474179983139038,
0.08088434487581253,
-0.5410211682319641,
0.21582813560962677,
-0.5247011184692383,
0.7696639895439148,
0.33838313817977905,
0.16497446596622467,
-0.29620984196662903,
-0.3649955689907074,
-0.24656794965267181,
-0.2702633738517761,
-0.5259026288986206,
-0.1877138912677765,
0.7879307866096497,
0.26175832748413086,
1.0505216121673584,
0.5809764862060547,
0.5568406581878662,
0.3158932626247406,
-0.02768811397254467,
-0.13053001463413239,
-0.22067594528198242,
-0.17951373755931854,
-0.28441107273101807,
-0.5794245004653931,
-0.3630625903606415,
0.19963987171649933,
0.3134560286998749,
0.9986194372177124,
-0.21659809350967407,
0.07850786298513412,
-0.218435600399971,
0.5456234216690063,
-0.22379395365715027,
-0.22106584906578064,
-0.5285900235176086,
0.12982520461082458,
-0.14882530272006989,
-0.03250372037291527,
-0.2141769528388977,
-0.5221045017242432,
-0.435712605714798,
-0.387428343296051,
-0.43130695819854736,
0.15385408699512482,
0.7978652119636536,
0.697753369808197,
-0.10565169900655746,
-0.3530486226081848,
-0.7654237151145935,
0.6657662987709045,
-0.8683145642280579,
0.011266173794865608,
0.10801851004362106,
0.3171391785144806,
-0.14538119733333588,
-0.6819674372673035,
-1.070982575416565,
-0.1818239539861679,
0.25005486607551575,
0.15329056978225708,
-0.2946585714817047,
-0.2366655319929123,
0.21928784251213074,
0.15516458451747894,
-0.6280490159988403,
0.3422013223171234,
-0.41562849283218384,
0.16396209597587585,
0.861004114151001,
0.1166570782661438,
0.4880991280078888,
-0.2018945962190628,
-0.13483750820159912,
0.04086495563387871,
-0.6085782051086426,
0.10510052740573883,
0.8359208106994629,
0.09167823195457458,
-0.04984394833445549,
0.7002831101417542,
0.1051037386059761,
0.24424313008785248,
-0.39892879128456116,
-0.09105335175991058,
0.0666949525475502,
-0.06754179298877716,
0.023829182609915733,
-0.08571254462003708,
0.947069525718689,
0.4512881934642792,
0.9400724172592163,
-0.10554418712854385,
-0.10230230540037155,
0.1191183403134346,
0.4298527240753174,
-0.296938955783844,
-0.4355752170085907,
-0.05809725075960159,
-0.36697494983673096,
-0.47479960322380066,
0.051310211420059204,
-0.24450641870498657,
-0.8781426548957825,
-0.14209872484207153,
0.17517660558223724,
-0.11401866376399994,
-0.32628968358039856,
0.05720290541648865,
-0.5807438492774963,
0.015462423674762249,
0.2244616150856018,
-0.48869606852531433,
0.23741543292999268,
0.5879542231559753,
0.4740777611732483,
0.042753513902425766,
-0.07871036976575851,
-0.4805496633052826,
0.09172258526086807,
-0.379269540309906,
0.668999969959259,
-0.7107440829277039,
0.08990079164505005,
-0.0927281603217125,
-0.040446680039167404,
0.18633772432804108,
-0.6314516663551331,
0.4840887486934662,
-0.3472088873386383,
0.16917483508586884,
0.08688105642795563,
-0.3924645483493805,
-0.05362417548894882,
-0.22043129801750183,
-0.803754448890686,
0.607940137386322,
0.237284317612648,
-0.5657707452774048,
0.17143240571022034,
-0.270063579082489,
-0.6265195608139038,
0.4067750573158264,
-0.5644765496253967,
-0.1316518634557724,
0.07532213628292084,
0.036783453077077866,
0.03422519192099571,
-0.2347867339849472,
0.4706934690475464,
-0.6941332221031189,
-0.5251281261444092,
0.7292128801345825,
-0.6790568828582764,
1.004604697227478,
0.17502467334270477,
-0.5736698508262634,
0.04747151955962181,
-0.4628705084323883,
-0.18246400356292725,
0.4429304301738739,
-0.14514052867889404,
0.07730508595705032,
0.47607770562171936,
0.062147099524736404,
0.42042118310928345,
-0.12166591733694077,
-0.5843985676765442,
0.08528874069452286,
-0.6359519362449646,
0.6873356103897095,
0.9914886355400085,
-0.6111928224563599,
0.020066725090146065,
-0.7313109636306763,
1.001862645149231,
-0.43429142236709595,
0.04177728295326233,
-0.05831654369831085,
-0.8666943311691284,
-0.644596517086029,
-0.1691472828388214,
-0.1790909767150879,
0.7806084752082825,
-0.48092755675315857,
0.6102033853530884,
-0.26614445447921753,
-0.42988577485084534,
-0.7991816401481628,
0.3581232726573944,
-0.008984136395156384,
0.32828646898269653,
-0.1178717091679573,
-0.5674717426300049,
-0.4748425781726837,
-0.7551195025444031,
-0.4812088906764984,
-0.3445638120174408,
0.0018977912841364741,
0.3454116880893707,
0.18277297914028168,
0.1613633930683136,
0.8095186948776245,
0.003220481565222144,
-0.05119108781218529,
-0.7732996344566345,
-0.05552399158477783,
0.3144076466560364,
0.06537207961082458,
0.7039773464202881,
-0.7221207618713379,
-0.4165418744087219,
-0.1802699714899063,
-0.7390109300613403,
-0.5218937993049622,
0.08041669428348541,
0.32753875851631165,
0.27833032608032227,
0.3158186972141266,
-0.40751487016677856,
0.5827430486679077,
0.5255029797554016,
-0.2531140148639679,
0.43430426716804504,
0.3082161545753479,
0.029059110209345818,
-0.8056889176368713,
0.05852863937616348,
-0.24598950147628784,
-0.3131125271320343,
-0.5114948749542236,
-0.13919563591480255,
-0.48557108640670776,
-0.33107057213783264,
-0.6062391996383667,
0.7874689698219299,
0.03207540512084961,
0.048544835299253464,
-0.46336591243743896,
0.4748856723308563,
-0.08339375257492065,
0.17671795189380646,
-0.05050757899880409,
0.4981668293476105,
0.3373531103134155,
-0.23782426118850708,
0.6957202553749084,
-0.048688989132642746,
-0.4188708961009979,
0.5194451808929443,
-0.3366566300392151,
0.38524073362350464,
-0.08119113743305206,
0.2301890105009079,
-1.341339111328125,
-0.2599693834781647,
0.4973597526550293,
-0.3690890371799469,
-0.14384934306144714,
0.01064294669777155,
-0.5729957818984985,
-0.6185921430587769,
-0.14202752709388733,
0.4588220715522766,
0.5947151780128479,
-0.1930529773235321,
0.5954827666282654,
0.4843224287033081,
-0.6869684457778931,
-0.679306149482727,
-0.743700385093689,
0.49192267656326294,
-0.49905240535736084,
-0.9139717221260071,
0.0914778932929039,
-0.3912549912929535,
-0.7060314416885376,
0.09776784479618073,
0.13135956227779388,
0.21667355298995972,
0.3124484121799469,
0.25019973516464233,
-0.19831755757331848,
-0.10789383947849274,
-0.11429748684167862,
-0.20735010504722595,
0.17304405570030212,
0.07898921519517899,
-0.19340461492538452,
0.675402820110321,
0.21698549389839172,
-0.5049177408218384,
-0.8811774253845215,
0.3927912414073944,
0.2864428758621216,
0.19046488404273987,
0.4054248332977295,
0.5788254737854004,
-0.1575593203306198,
-0.0006374400109052658,
-0.6526735424995422,
0.08486370742321014,
-0.5027144551277161,
0.10539497435092926,
0.218739315867424,
-0.9433197975158691,
0.44404351711273193,
0.1557905673980713,
-0.21833102405071259,
0.3837798833847046,
0.4514557719230652,
-0.49440106749534607,
0.9268935322761536,
0.9072206020355225,
-0.2913152575492859,
0.7018837928771973,
0.10799834132194519,
0.6922016739845276,
-0.34540462493896484,
0.10096465051174164,
-0.5557253360748291,
-0.7206753492355347,
-0.3833248019218445,
-0.22687578201293945,
0.2193099558353424,
0.012515765614807606,
-0.015310327522456646,
0.030504420399665833,
-0.10007545351982117,
0.597532331943512,
0.4756383001804352,
-0.3496096432209015,
0.05959438905119896,
-0.108139768242836,
0.03157154098153114,
0.0815499946475029,
-0.6629485487937927,
-0.7104596495628357,
0.7801851630210876,
0.30135834217071533,
0.8948862552642822,
0.30041608214378357,
0.4230027496814728,
0.5348262190818787,
0.3553635776042938,
-0.7430623173713684,
0.6821123957633972,
-0.32368460297584534,
-0.5185319185256958,
-0.2589726746082306,
-0.16174212098121643,
-0.49144965410232544,
-0.3935950994491577,
0.24632668495178223,
-0.9790284037590027,
-0.08258360624313354,
0.025596903637051582,
-0.22835592925548553,
0.6033682227134705,
-0.5560880303382874,
0.5266759991645813,
-0.39093953371047974,
-0.30103811621665955,
-0.23692481219768524,
-0.7973619699478149,
0.08447819203138351,
0.09964349865913391,
0.8008139133453369,
-0.204782173037529,
0.2855567932128906,
0.7651005983352661,
-0.060554828494787216,
1.1474409103393555,
0.03309341147542,
-0.11588829010725021,
0.407012939453125,
0.21796923875808716,
0.1761816293001175,
-0.17615845799446106,
-0.42089250683784485,
0.27849459648132324,
-0.1792781949043274,
-0.1877371221780777,
-0.7285014390945435,
0.34619852900505066,
-0.6396820545196533,
-0.9705471396446228,
0.020576564595103264,
-0.8445499539375305,
0.33508503437042236,
0.10645268112421036,
-0.14565004408359528,
0.18947632610797882,
0.1017303615808487,
0.24878932535648346,
0.08863209933042526,
-0.4437495470046997,
0.6081718802452087,
-0.057189494371414185,
-0.05615007132291794,
-0.6519814133644104,
0.7619404196739197,
0.031933944672346115,
0.4743029773235321,
0.16088730096817017,
0.2773401439189911,
-0.19579081237316132,
-0.09413858503103256,
-0.42610257863998413,
0.3514085114002228,
-0.9652135372161865,
-0.009275907650589943,
-0.5388063788414001,
-0.31201839447021484,
-0.6681509613990784,
-0.5375967025756836,
-0.09829817712306976,
-1.037481427192688,
-0.1860698014497757,
0.12890033423900604,
0.11771553754806519,
1.027842402458191,
-0.30382952094078064,
0.28864559531211853,
-0.22600211203098297,
0.0020565446466207504,
-0.10052289813756943,
0.2925213873386383,
-0.15087012946605682,
-0.5627242922782898,
-0.21223823726177216,
-0.2557191848754883,
-0.4372192323207855,
-0.9170540571212769,
0.3130795657634735,
0.22753147780895233,
0.6363876461982727,
0.4790731370449066,
0.08842284232378006,
0.2672240138053894,
-0.493211030960083,
1.0531878471374512,
0.03897478058934212,
-0.6938527822494507,
0.5866872668266296,
-0.1876872479915619,
-0.045063842087984085,
0.09605220705270767,
0.48503169417381287,
-0.7771546840667725,
-0.9162061810493469,
-0.6441972255706787,
-0.6707005500793457,
0.7390266060829163,
0.046391382813453674,
0.6524152159690857,
-0.29487472772598267,
0.3705456554889679,
0.10823076963424683,
0.549787163734436,
-1.0952917337417603,
-0.23551993072032928,
-0.21979773044586182,
-0.4969218075275421,
-0.04222143813967705,
-0.05345933139324188,
-0.5528174638748169,
-0.14999404549598694,
0.36355581879615784,
-0.2524654269218445,
0.2813810110092163,
-0.10904931277036667,
0.09206996858119965,
-0.5065021514892578,
0.10496894270181656,
0.4414535462856293,
0.893500804901123,
-0.008641253225505352,
0.1752328872680664,
-0.17597012221813202,
-0.24905842542648315,
0.11545653641223907,
-0.17002524435520172,
0.1575334519147873,
-0.2457847148180008,
0.4102923572063446,
0.578914999961853,
-0.354060560464859,
-1.1042487621307373,
0.5355930328369141,
0.0652315616607666,
-0.1222849041223526,
-0.5535138845443726,
0.5399731993675232,
0.10578680783510208,
0.564490795135498,
0.03223283588886261,
-0.12325047701597214,
-0.00302368332631886,
-0.8981515169143677,
0.1842387169599533,
0.6199131011962891,
-0.30293986201286316,
-0.21798336505889893,
1.0232409238815308,
-0.019660709425807,
-0.9983052611351013,
0.4857619106769562,
-0.18324489891529083,
-0.5694112181663513,
0.7669650316238403,
0.5280716419219971,
0.9661305546760559,
0.1447051763534546,
0.09610504657030106,
-0.16467641294002533,
0.41748857498168945,
0.4098342955112457,
0.4358220398426056,
0.09779675304889679,
-0.886123776435852,
-0.3829180598258972,
-0.5188655257225037,
-0.4833895266056061,
-0.07317112386226654,
-0.21604719758033752,
0.4493796229362488,
-0.43252572417259216,
-0.0041266195476055145,
0.06482992321252823,
-0.24129904806613922,
-0.5268617272377014,
-0.011190713383257389,
0.6309278011322021,
0.9780531525611877,
-0.9149078726768494,
0.733791708946228,
0.8107319474220276,
-0.575843870639801,
-0.7202731370925903,
0.1661795973777771,
0.4116958677768707,
-0.6896527409553528,
0.7198898196220398,
0.19859591126441956,
-0.251579612493515,
-0.13716821372509003,
-0.7535123825073242,
-0.6450380682945251,
0.7759112119674683,
0.5151453614234924,
-0.2700304388999939,
-0.043719302862882614,
0.5640278458595276,
0.5118976831436157,
-0.6109266877174377,
0.3747495114803314,
0.31097128987312317,
0.16845062375068665,
0.3128020763397217,
-1.0478124618530273,
-0.09649818390607834,
-0.4730794429779053,
-0.28416767716407776,
-0.125478133559227,
-0.7323411703109741,
0.5460352897644043,
-0.28940027952194214,
0.052832622081041336,
0.3187311291694641,
0.3843853771686554,
0.2721610963344574,
0.32974985241889954,
0.5469332933425903,
0.6413475275039673,
0.7891729474067688,
-0.053242895752191544,
1.109186053276062,
-0.14253410696983337,
-0.17943716049194336,
0.8042582869529724,
-0.500851035118103,
0.7500681281089783,
0.37591782212257385,
-0.060418836772441864,
0.8109993934631348,
0.20178011059761047,
0.013513686135411263,
0.36046791076660156,
0.3962230980396271,
-0.0425022728741169,
-0.19708538055419922,
-0.2959059774875641,
0.030427755787968636,
0.34888285398483276,
0.15340586006641388,
-0.18358008563518524,
0.19228708744049072,
0.047455620020627975,
0.10150604695081711,
0.2722431421279907,
-0.004488691687583923,
0.6608073115348816,
0.3496597707271576,
-0.48704829812049866,
0.3047003448009491,
-0.12155340611934662,
0.4389004111289978,
-0.2839677631855011,
0.18278339505195618,
-0.23127953708171844,
0.015275610610842705,
-0.10353326052427292,
-1.1500788927078247,
0.3967311382293701,
0.004036162979900837,
0.13270772993564606,
0.031867947429418564,
0.48027336597442627,
-0.002573181176558137,
-0.47191962599754333,
0.33569490909576416,
0.12442736327648163,
0.4845605194568634,
0.2524532377719879,
-0.7405399084091187,
0.12619322538375854,
-0.21373537182807922,
-0.015480292029678822,
0.0745987594127655,
0.6049169898033142,
-0.09993038326501846,
1.0508109331130981,
0.28331536054611206,
0.362213134765625,
0.14893871545791626,
0.5689612030982971,
0.8809792995452881,
-0.8669412732124329,
-0.40693098306655884,
-0.8497511148452759,
0.8709639310836792,
0.013887829147279263,
-0.21889454126358032,
0.2946780323982239,
0.28896450996398926,
1.032552719116211,
0.26149946451187134,
0.8127245306968689,
-0.3595568835735321,
0.29506367444992065,
-0.566935122013092,
0.6871272325515747,
-0.8716579675674438,
0.30895066261291504,
-0.42057323455810547,
-0.6988843679428101,
-0.4335411787033081,
0.46871015429496765,
-0.28715580701828003,
0.33071818947792053,
0.44779959321022034,
0.9289510250091553,
0.17014960944652557,
-0.0042816828936338425,
0.3898874521255493,
0.19101299345493317,
0.6360611915588379,
0.032636433839797974,
1.3071390390396118,
0.05112510174512863,
0.4875066876411438,
-0.27655714750289917,
-0.06750427931547165,
-0.18279871344566345,
-0.9508327841758728,
-0.8011187314987183,
-0.3047459125518799,
-0.4572021961212158,
-0.2515430748462677,
-0.05806490406394005,
1.1496527194976807,
0.31162843108177185,
-0.3616940677165985,
-0.5785527229309082,
0.26765450835227966,
0.18813879787921906,
-0.26530301570892334,
-0.23518234491348267,
-0.07822742313146591,
-0.21455542743206024,
-0.7379400730133057,
0.5026267170906067,
0.5913265943527222,
-0.287975549697876,
-0.44045597314834595,
0.026245400309562683,
-0.09318381547927856,
0.45254242420196533,
0.4297739267349243,
0.10527363419532776,
-1.1067763566970825,
-0.3609371781349182,
-0.0787370502948761,
0.21812476217746735,
0.14595817029476166,
0.4917030930519104,
-0.522393524646759,
0.3710693418979645,
0.3563287556171417,
0.5515771508216858,
-0.45034998655319214,
-0.034604400396347046,
0.45046737790107727,
-0.5856631994247437,
0.20486700534820557,
0.46232980489730835,
0.38227975368499756,
0.36132702231407166,
-0.36262771487236023,
0.49497222900390625,
0.577680230140686,
-0.8415369391441345,
-0.9043276906013489,
0.29857781529426575,
-0.8420984745025635,
-0.09124432504177094,
1.148358702659607,
0.14542710781097412,
-0.352243036031723,
0.05987495183944702,
-0.06347929686307907,
0.19406473636627197,
0.02209482342004776,
0.8385087847709656,
0.8791946768760681,
-0.35967564582824707,
-0.43070629239082336,
-0.8295567035675049,
0.3640594482421875,
0.4733372926712036,
-0.5078203082084656,
-0.12119248509407043,
0.29720649123191833,
0.36878570914268494,
0.10560903698205948,
0.5961824059486389,
0.013147770427167416,
0.16193409264087677,
-0.31638309359550476,
0.29883256554603577,
0.49424490332603455,
-0.5452777147293091,
-0.3438880443572998,
0.009818053804337978,
0.4694937765598297,
0.5274513959884644
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20947v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20947v2
|
OR-Bench: An Over-Refusal Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T15:44:33
| 2024-06-20T05:22:38
|
Justin Cui, Wei-Lin Chiang, Ion Stoica, Cho-Jui Hsieh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) require careful safety alignment to prevent
malicious outputs. While significant research focuses on mitigating harmful
content generation, the enhanced safety often come with the side effect of
over-refusal, where LLMs may reject innocuous prompts and become less helpful.
Although the issue of over-refusal has been empirically observed, a systematic
measurement is challenging due to the difficulty of crafting prompts that
appear harmful but are benign. This study proposes a novel method for
automatically generating large-scale sets of "seemingly toxic prompts" (benign
prompts likely rejected by LLMs). Leveraging this technique, we introduce
OR-Bench, the first large-scale over-refusal benchmark. OR-Bench comprises
80,000 seemingly toxic prompts across 10 common rejection categories, a subset
of around 1,000 hard prompts that are challenging even for state-of-the-art
LLMs, and an additional 600 toxic prompts to prevent indiscriminate responses.
We then conduct a comprehensive study to measure the over-refusal of 25 popular
LLMs across 8 model families. Our datasets are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/bench-llm/or-bench and the demo can be found at
https://huggingface.co/spaces/bench-llm/or-bench. We hope this benchmark can
help the community develop better safety aligned models.
|
[
-0.3521599769592285,
-0.7319456338882446,
0.6986333131790161,
0.08972511440515518,
-0.01578451879322529,
-0.14148104190826416,
-0.15752553939819336,
-0.4292803108692169,
-0.3223901093006134,
0.5113102197647095,
-0.6657388806343079,
-0.5896405577659607,
-0.399595707654953,
0.041725847870111465,
-0.6996070146560669,
0.8703628778457642,
-0.05657397210597992,
-0.029795242473483086,
-0.12423958629369736,
-0.24540266394615173,
-0.6083425283432007,
-0.28257858753204346,
-0.781465470790863,
-0.16549737751483917,
0.6722246408462524,
0.3208869993686676,
0.5039741396903992,
0.6467686295509338,
0.23039059340953827,
0.26083874702453613,
-0.01640796661376953,
-0.09680306911468506,
-0.43877846002578735,
0.41369786858558655,
-0.42143338918685913,
-0.35958579182624817,
-0.4423801600933075,
0.09695795923471451,
0.7255589365959167,
0.7235289812088013,
-0.1965962052345276,
0.3069588243961334,
-0.05048319697380066,
0.6318278908729553,
-0.877016007900238,
-0.1149434745311737,
-0.774951696395874,
-0.1862717866897583,
-0.4512538015842438,
0.13853541016578674,
-0.7491127848625183,
-0.5992105603218079,
-0.14990417659282684,
-0.37081030011177063,
-0.25364571809768677,
0.2207910418510437,
0.6030510663986206,
0.20123440027236938,
-0.48295724391937256,
-0.19254867732524872,
-0.3847845494747162,
0.7964257001876831,
-0.6617400050163269,
0.4644920527935028,
0.32201433181762695,
0.4799661338329315,
-0.5363491177558899,
-0.3335738778114319,
-0.5729647874832153,
-0.3782389461994171,
0.18110406398773193,
0.01924065873026848,
-0.15391314029693604,
-0.17869427800178528,
0.5124783515930176,
-0.0552261583507061,
-0.8748195171356201,
0.32402363419532776,
-0.09057816863059998,
-0.00937577337026596,
0.6862801313400269,
0.5287113785743713,
0.36353737115859985,
-0.07126174122095108,
-0.5543757081031799,
-0.29313212633132935,
-1.0812017917633057,
0.1879374086856842,
0.16532456874847412,
0.3649097681045532,
-0.03614142909646034,
0.7722159028053284,
-0.10741546005010605,
0.5915296673774719,
-0.09400889277458191,
0.019115025177598,
0.3500320315361023,
-0.15863819420337677,
-0.06447619199752808,
0.21797092258930206,
0.9708701372146606,
0.6928501129150391,
0.34179922938346863,
0.1607898771762848,
-0.4189223051071167,
0.22868108749389648,
0.1517348289489746,
-0.8706395030021667,
0.22164995968341827,
0.4535004496574402,
-0.4740152657032013,
-0.2142963409423828,
-0.2847607433795929,
-0.9582403898239136,
-1.2481963634490967,
-0.1615408957004547,
0.2823331356048584,
-0.5660471320152283,
-0.1305421143770218,
0.14257311820983887,
-0.08095082640647888,
0.2117924839258194,
0.10699629783630371,
-0.6545454263687134,
0.44045236706733704,
0.6315956711769104,
0.6805262565612793,
-0.2541263997554779,
-0.42735907435417175,
-0.7401288151741028,
0.08727578818798065,
-0.4043219983577728,
0.7365649342536926,
-0.4406977593898773,
-0.6341276168823242,
0.16794270277023315,
-0.174532949924469,
-0.07853858172893524,
-0.6662818789482117,
0.8596863746643066,
-0.4132865071296692,
0.010171069763600826,
-0.6487602591514587,
-0.38190028071403503,
0.026936668902635574,
0.3777602016925812,
-0.42601272463798523,
0.9737311601638794,
0.08786804229021072,
-0.48306986689567566,
0.7748117446899414,
-0.2908130884170532,
-0.6478733420372009,
-0.28921419382095337,
-0.2626456618309021,
-0.4354134798049927,
0.06067884340882301,
-0.07190386950969696,
0.18034841120243073,
-0.6271371245384216,
0.3947131335735321,
-0.876327395439148,
-0.04792439937591553,
0.5903431177139282,
-0.5661705136299133,
0.8898688554763794,
0.2569589912891388,
-0.33155468106269836,
0.2942432761192322,
-1.1641045808792114,
0.006684811320155859,
0.1686273068189621,
-0.2948983609676361,
-0.44522207975387573,
0.0973939448595047,
0.24302545189857483,
0.5545626282691956,
0.01754850707948208,
-0.9072145819664001,
-0.1552702635526657,
-0.35164350271224976,
0.611952006816864,
0.7907764315605164,
-0.3324044346809387,
0.09573343396186829,
-0.6483514308929443,
0.3988600969314575,
-0.5347062945365906,
0.3674326539039612,
0.15532423555850983,
-0.1382881999015808,
-0.504321813583374,
-0.18680772185325623,
0.10353586077690125,
0.40086203813552856,
-0.3491010069847107,
0.565119206905365,
-0.2510697841644287,
-0.3788652718067169,
-0.3329711854457855,
0.01347396895289421,
0.6186161637306213,
0.5270720720291138,
0.24851489067077637,
-0.46802935004234314,
-0.35986432433128357,
-0.7820663452148438,
-0.2670479118824005,
-0.42110690474510193,
-0.08234594762325287,
0.37139514088630676,
0.31761109828948975,
0.001457149162888527,
0.9530641436576843,
-0.24848493933677673,
-0.3956355154514313,
0.1281375139951706,
0.32789355516433716,
0.2342635691165924,
0.44745609164237976,
0.8531417846679688,
-0.6434371471405029,
-0.7395688891410828,
-0.16850000619888306,
-0.5007761120796204,
-0.3929268419742584,
0.0036118743009865284,
-0.07366080582141876,
0.5300604701042175,
0.8870328664779663,
-0.5873342156410217,
0.18653634190559387,
0.5248255133628845,
-0.14386315643787384,
0.6973134875297546,
0.042858902364969254,
0.1148364469408989,
-0.8264771699905396,
0.5494948625564575,
-0.03920893743634224,
-0.16053719818592072,
-0.25181257724761963,
0.08479081839323044,
0.2749782204627991,
-0.16580796241760254,
-0.6469354629516602,
0.7231751680374146,
-0.2446002960205078,
0.24628229439258575,
-0.09806079417467117,
0.1093665361404419,
-0.12048337608575821,
0.07558812946081161,
0.06960099935531616,
0.642432689666748,
0.4941629469394684,
-0.4175169765949249,
0.36077776551246643,
0.2506692409515381,
-0.3209482729434967,
1.057736873626709,
-0.6341183185577393,
-0.18667203187942505,
-0.07617449015378952,
0.6261829137802124,
-1.563274621963501,
-0.4537666141986847,
0.24437399208545685,
-0.21258647739887238,
0.39488571882247925,
-0.09608534723520279,
-0.5915651917457581,
-0.5697738528251648,
-0.5334314107894897,
0.5925611853599548,
0.5683421492576599,
-0.5633605122566223,
0.5625479817390442,
0.3669986426830292,
-0.3852485120296478,
-0.38165050745010376,
-0.741793692111969,
-0.001123293419368565,
-0.4243486821651459,
-0.41442036628723145,
0.1519096940755844,
-0.43810486793518066,
-0.08208516985177994,
-0.1888933628797531,
-0.12207818776369095,
0.03408564627170563,
-0.06214244291186333,
0.5911938548088074,
0.17296983301639557,
-0.05919550359249115,
-0.06354790925979614,
-0.1593492329120636,
-0.33568230271339417,
0.7053647637367249,
0.08002302795648575,
0.620878279209137,
0.06745711714029312,
-0.6466482877731323,
-0.2704017460346222,
0.3712245523929596,
1.050783395767212,
-0.049189068377017975,
0.6525947451591492,
0.14193478226661682,
-0.28132668137550354,
-0.2425532191991806,
-0.7060189247131348,
-0.024317463859915733,
-0.5204713940620422,
0.11884140968322754,
-0.2100406140089035,
-0.5746497511863708,
0.5484610795974731,
-0.042027123272418976,
0.3702555000782013,
0.28784796595573425,
0.3361288905143738,
0.07333188503980637,
1.408142328262329,
0.04520735144615173,
-0.4180545508861542,
0.3468375504016876,
0.40322259068489075,
-0.09662134945392609,
-0.4747677445411682,
-0.11714184284210205,
-0.8648300170898438,
-0.28552237153053284,
-0.44572046399116516,
-0.008585051633417606,
0.43694284558296204,
-0.40012553334236145,
-0.6176584362983704,
0.1585795134305954,
-0.23644249141216278,
0.43768325448036194,
0.3652637004852295,
0.1083596870303154,
0.13912740349769592,
-0.2322607934474945,
-0.18253551423549652,
-0.02564210072159767,
-0.39140185713768005,
-0.15410229563713074,
1.0203189849853516,
0.39018329977989197,
0.939719557762146,
0.3111403286457062,
0.36921942234039307,
0.042974166572093964,
0.603119969367981,
-0.5730881094932556,
0.7069271206855774,
-0.09715541452169418,
-1.0514966249465942,
-0.3033854067325592,
-0.5416127443313599,
-0.9129986763000488,
-0.038266006857156754,
-0.32366105914115906,
-0.8670673966407776,
0.07174461334943771,
0.09831007570028305,
-0.7011315226554871,
0.08206325769424438,
-0.6174160242080688,
0.6940256357192993,
-0.3028910458087921,
-0.33514752984046936,
-0.07886683195829391,
-0.7276096343994141,
0.4447365999221802,
-0.4937678277492523,
0.5062817931175232,
-0.11679776012897491,
-0.04608423635363579,
0.3643372356891632,
-0.5126146674156189,
1.040945053100586,
-0.003371704835444689,
-0.3237477242946625,
0.2818163335323334,
0.38918352127075195,
0.6980682015419006,
-0.06836764514446259,
-0.4892912805080414,
-0.30420443415641785,
0.0006479764706455171,
-0.1689162254333496,
-0.3303968608379364,
1.010144829750061,
-0.46862924098968506,
-0.4277728497982025,
-0.4169673025608063,
-0.6270229816436768,
-0.467375785112381,
0.6654932498931885,
0.3369576036930084,
0.4579479992389679,
-0.26522940397262573,
0.13067565858364105,
0.6272071003913879,
-0.5027169585227966,
0.38704246282577515,
0.9296818971633911,
-0.35505637526512146,
-0.3043021261692047,
0.9631057977676392,
0.17759932577610016,
0.5158194303512573,
0.06747613102197647,
0.22966501116752625,
-0.6774881482124329,
-0.8682127594947815,
-0.470225989818573,
0.1295786052942276,
-0.5974904298782349,
-0.3255079388618469,
-0.5423054099082947,
-0.3859497308731079,
-0.3753637671470642,
-0.18141184747219086,
-0.4238874912261963,
-0.10769189894199371,
0.0747557282447815,
0.01804693415760994,
0.3579186797142029,
0.6983156800270081,
-0.05495408549904823,
-0.23377922177314758,
-0.9068921208381653,
0.07911059260368347,
0.2568802535533905,
0.8696830868721008,
-0.01645752228796482,
-0.5874576568603516,
0.5427080988883972,
-0.1811234951019287,
-0.03348422423005104,
-0.5480558276176453,
0.11834227293729782,
-0.08639194071292877,
0.5642035603523254,
0.41158148646354675,
0.733452320098877,
0.40141189098358154,
-0.7525254487991333,
0.5519189238548279,
0.3284814953804016,
-0.7820146083831787,
0.4016962945461273,
-0.7871513962745667,
0.0648777112364769,
0.9557986855506897,
0.585490345954895,
-0.4416150152683258,
-0.494581013917923,
-0.4187559187412262,
-1.0832182168960571,
0.7293864488601685,
0.06606125086545944,
0.18385595083236694,
-0.1923179030418396,
0.10103527456521988,
0.33621665835380554,
0.22375370562076569,
-0.7181411981582642,
-0.21521280705928802,
0.34446680545806885,
0.004287983290851116,
-0.05650262162089348,
-0.4027833044528961,
-0.22612975537776947,
0.10561275482177734,
0.7736567258834839,
0.1644897162914276,
-0.4540121555328369,
-0.14584176242351532,
0.016223119571805,
-0.5933713912963867,
0.5254617929458618,
0.5356571078300476,
0.550350546836853,
-0.5735973119735718,
0.26904526352882385,
0.37157493829727173,
-0.23863428831100464,
0.12439510971307755,
0.3191114664077759,
-0.13900132477283478,
-0.22860728204250336,
0.10825016349554062,
0.22887325286865234,
0.1368589997291565,
-0.9804143905639648,
0.4501515328884125,
-0.03697829321026802,
-0.16087588667869568,
-0.11466419696807861,
0.17693091928958893,
-0.24792906641960144,
0.007123882882297039,
-0.0642547458410263,
-0.04387922212481499,
0.20863521099090576,
-0.6761599183082581,
0.2589690387248993,
0.516930341720581,
-0.5220590233802795,
-0.012089114636182785,
0.6719647645950317,
0.2756783366203308,
-0.0953824520111084,
0.3564959168434143,
-0.06157504767179489,
-0.24814358353614807,
0.3797304928302765,
0.4030511975288391,
0.5786083936691284,
-0.22706378996372223,
0.10591740906238556,
0.4618746042251587,
0.17867909371852875,
-0.08398357778787613,
0.41404107213020325,
0.4247191250324249,
-0.479706346988678,
-0.21020017564296722,
-0.4818093180656433,
-0.2917580008506775,
0.6656014919281006,
-0.8120047450065613,
0.21252377331256866,
-0.802028238773346,
-0.3498572111129761,
0.11072026193141937,
-0.2931452989578247,
-0.29994532465934753,
0.058938298374414444,
0.24702708423137665,
1.1734822988510132,
-1.1502217054367065,
0.506583034992218,
0.6651989817619324,
-0.4055037796497345,
-0.7526910901069641,
-0.17785677313804626,
0.6186630129814148,
-0.8590207695960999,
0.07441741973161697,
0.16192688047885895,
0.1003124937415123,
-0.08476925641298294,
-0.37980204820632935,
-0.7789926528930664,
0.6088120937347412,
0.3963913917541504,
-0.7954497933387756,
0.36904874444007874,
0.3652626574039459,
0.4479345977306366,
0.06973789632320404,
0.2761884033679962,
0.8210363388061523,
0.7123997211456299,
0.172949880361557,
-0.9358898401260376,
0.7106218338012695,
-0.16681353747844696,
-0.1210242286324501,
0.3725949823856354,
-0.7266406416893005,
0.715777575969696,
0.05596398934721947,
-0.23697853088378906,
0.5963204503059387,
0.1400086134672165,
0.669264018535614,
0.35211628675460815,
0.9067026376724243,
0.3534970283508301,
0.492351770401001,
0.02919650636613369,
1.1624575853347778,
0.09320306032896042,
0.09552560746669769,
1.252070426940918,
-0.853432297706604,
1.0386940240859985,
0.4467742145061493,
-0.2493308037519455,
0.22082121670246124,
0.6271575689315796,
0.1182909682393074,
0.5397840142250061,
0.4456079602241516,
-0.0831310898065567,
-0.45617684721946716,
-0.6075606346130371,
-0.6391405463218689,
-0.043314870446920395,
0.5225664973258972,
-0.33316168189048767,
-0.6238764524459839,
-0.007037696428596973,
-0.12276051193475723,
0.2393743395805359,
-0.21510986983776093,
0.5432679057121277,
0.23585093021392822,
-0.8214355707168579,
0.8296754360198975,
-0.3130035698413849,
0.3834860920906067,
-0.5406960248947144,
0.14862196147441864,
-0.013243758119642735,
0.1079266145825386,
-0.14443528652191162,
-1.2064956426620483,
0.02880755439400673,
0.04210008308291435,
-0.23795247077941895,
-0.4368021786212921,
0.5872710347175598,
-0.2742590606212616,
-0.1688815802335739,
0.5128943920135498,
0.22249644994735718,
-0.011451909318566322,
-0.020536478608846664,
-0.810318112373352,
0.34827959537506104,
-0.339555025100708,
-0.30211588740348816,
0.642587423324585,
0.6104959845542908,
-0.2879028916358948,
0.5805156230926514,
0.6726589798927307,
-0.086116261780262,
-0.1903199404478073,
0.30642449855804443,
1.0471971035003662,
-0.44303035736083984,
-0.31140726804733276,
-0.803512454032898,
0.5407393574714661,
0.0234063807874918,
-0.36712610721588135,
0.6746124625205994,
0.3734164535999298,
0.6818699240684509,
0.34847530722618103,
0.8115382790565491,
-0.23824521899223328,
0.6748128533363342,
-0.5239309072494507,
0.9219741821289062,
-0.7135850191116333,
0.3061663806438446,
-0.3951904773712158,
-0.851102888584137,
-0.33646345138549805,
0.2377203106880188,
-0.5377818942070007,
0.11874568462371826,
0.6911541223526001,
0.8182536959648132,
0.02441309578716755,
0.12210500240325928,
0.1782509833574295,
0.5181220173835754,
0.3582163155078888,
0.6576771140098572,
1.1252264976501465,
-0.010433060117065907,
0.7194098830223083,
0.0004616090445779264,
-0.36625903844833374,
-0.35558202862739563,
-1.155042290687561,
-1.1857008934020996,
-0.2837373912334442,
-0.17024008929729462,
-0.7537124156951904,
0.22523851692676544,
1.0005024671554565,
0.568427562713623,
-1.1094557046890259,
-0.01702663116157055,
-0.24192498624324799,
-0.17866289615631104,
-0.09395189583301544,
-0.12183264642953873,
0.32682257890701294,
-0.16664429008960724,
-0.4514842629432678,
0.49689844250679016,
-0.014013231731951237,
0.01712185889482498,
-0.11827613413333893,
0.1901010125875473,
-0.07295731455087662,
0.0992685928940773,
0.40311577916145325,
0.7005414366722107,
-0.5300904512405396,
-0.5404032468795776,
-0.10845034569501877,
-0.5280717015266418,
-0.2487000823020935,
0.48671120405197144,
-0.3931919038295746,
0.461980938911438,
0.5943507552146912,
0.6374261379241943,
0.016443802043795586,
-0.04882630333304405,
0.8204167485237122,
-0.8569326996803284,
-0.028213681653141975,
0.13475485146045685,
0.3723958432674408,
0.05623311921954155,
-0.20981450378894806,
0.344402551651001,
-0.08600647002458572,
-0.40565618872642517,
-1.04170823097229,
0.265480637550354,
-0.9509441256523132,
-0.3782599866390228,
1.452034592628479,
-0.0528765544295311,
-0.2757005989551544,
-0.28317850828170776,
-0.3224598467350006,
-0.0774182602763176,
-0.7887977957725525,
0.9507195949554443,
0.7549373507499695,
0.16274577379226685,
0.1648591160774231,
-0.5577896237373352,
0.4934326410293579,
0.7358539700508118,
-0.7506123781204224,
0.5362170934677124,
0.7056658864021301,
0.39537981152534485,
0.1351933479309082,
0.43904271721839905,
-0.17985446751117706,
0.5993972420692444,
-0.18422344326972961,
-0.18381786346435547,
-0.055160026997327805,
-0.3090963065624237,
-0.2712439000606537,
0.14436253905296326,
0.2504766583442688,
0.05023779347538948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20917v1
|
Learning to Estimate System Specifications in Linear Temporal Logic using Transformers and Mamba
| 2024-05-31T15:21:53
| 2024-05-31T15:21:53
|
İlker Işık, Ebru Aydin Gol, Ramazan Gokberk Cinbis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Temporal logic is a framework for representing and reasoning about
propositions that evolve over time. It is commonly used for specifying
requirements in various domains, including hardware and software systems, as
well as robotics. Specification mining or formula generation involves
extracting temporal logic formulae from system traces and has numerous
applications, such as detecting bugs and improving interpretability. Although
there has been a surge of deep learning-based methods for temporal logic
satisfiability checking in recent years, the specification mining literature
has been lagging behind in adopting deep learning methods despite their many
advantages, such as scalability. In this paper, we introduce autoregressive
models that can generate linear temporal logic formulae from traces, towards
addressing the specification mining problem. We propose multiple architectures
for this task: transformer encoder-decoder, decoder-only transformer, and
Mamba, which is an emerging alternative to transformer models. Additionally, we
devise a metric for quantifying the distinctiveness of the generated formulae
and a straightforward algorithm to enforce the syntax constraints. Our
experiments show that the proposed architectures yield promising results,
generating correct and distinct formulae at a fraction of the compute cost
needed for the combinatorial baseline.
|
[
-0.2703908085823059,
-0.531864583492279,
0.7932419776916504,
0.16092756390571594,
-0.10821224004030228,
0.07240938395261765,
0.2400623857975006,
-0.5335323810577393,
0.08906015008687973,
0.3040589392185211,
-0.9882142543792725,
-0.3257284462451935,
-0.5953047871589661,
-0.1131221279501915,
-0.5548437833786011,
0.5679651498794556,
-0.35201260447502136,
-0.5783424973487854,
-0.07418843358755112,
-0.12202943116426468,
-0.556321382522583,
-0.559108316898346,
0.001901817973703146,
-0.43370646238327026,
0.1885855346918106,
0.10343270748853683,
0.5377591252326965,
0.6647284030914307,
0.19189995527267456,
0.2464723140001297,
0.20437054336071014,
0.42402467131614685,
0.29260092973709106,
0.4210700988769531,
0.20403167605400085,
-0.26312536001205444,
-0.49479392170906067,
0.11052633821964264,
0.5771714448928833,
0.7266122102737427,
-0.34313493967056274,
0.663753867149353,
-0.14589448273181915,
0.4251798987388611,
-1.0757510662078857,
0.8034661412239075,
-0.6630815267562866,
0.5541127324104309,
-0.15208525955677032,
-0.23314368724822998,
-0.566875696182251,
-0.41863781213760376,
-0.2838137447834015,
-0.5709376335144043,
-0.05332814157009125,
-0.12370144575834274,
1.1520196199417114,
0.6410946846008301,
-0.4617653489112854,
-0.35795125365257263,
-0.9710320234298706,
0.8220065236091614,
-0.804385244846344,
0.48507678508758545,
0.22106434404850006,
0.8769370317459106,
-0.09694312512874603,
-0.8429768085479736,
-0.36061546206474304,
-0.2042989432811737,
-0.46276384592056274,
-0.002279242966324091,
-0.2690441906452179,
-0.16425906121730804,
0.5449579954147339,
0.1831035166978836,
-0.5066162347793579,
0.05818173289299011,
-0.1267862319946289,
-0.3584355115890503,
0.38263970613479614,
0.6227541565895081,
-0.07177858799695969,
-0.3431229889392853,
-0.264420747756958,
0.28047889471054077,
-0.5185104012489319,
0.15639755129814148,
0.2653881013393402,
-0.007197122555226088,
0.09378127008676529,
0.5220993161201477,
-0.306710422039032,
0.657666802406311,
0.08468855917453766,
-0.13782371580600739,
0.21270498633384705,
-0.3093198239803314,
-0.4619786739349365,
-0.11235415190458298,
0.7781171202659607,
-0.10658502578735352,
0.10078342258930206,
-0.26193714141845703,
-0.5419865250587463,
0.3674676716327667,
0.2773577570915222,
-0.8857300281524658,
-0.38179662823677063,
-0.07253075391054153,
-0.5826335549354553,
-0.23314276337623596,
-0.033920273184776306,
-0.7419189810752869,
0.005400376860052347,
-0.4990503787994385,
0.4020552635192871,
-0.49153587222099304,
-0.06974659115076065,
0.13326683640480042,
0.0639895424246788,
0.43085941672325134,
-0.048244573175907135,
-0.8454709053039551,
0.2667936384677887,
0.6672564148902893,
0.6593359112739563,
0.35307174921035767,
0.06545419991016388,
-0.876242458820343,
0.19454161822795868,
-0.4383811950683594,
0.7076793313026428,
-0.5733616948127747,
-0.37417569756507874,
-0.19372528791427612,
-0.1724948287010193,
-0.22875253856182098,
-0.4273287355899811,
0.5441866517066956,
-0.5854947566986084,
0.06261932849884033,
0.23967862129211426,
-0.5358338952064514,
0.05936931073665619,
-0.08136815577745438,
-0.5527156591415405,
1.1142014265060425,
0.14989133179187775,
-0.18489092588424683,
0.5530645847320557,
-0.6314645409584045,
-0.9038007259368896,
0.05451669171452522,
-0.29635223746299744,
-0.7031563520431519,
0.1415269523859024,
0.46065711975097656,
0.5366261601448059,
-0.2383803278207779,
0.4454902708530426,
-0.2147599756717682,
-0.09380774945020676,
0.3279123604297638,
-0.38112515211105347,
0.7924301028251648,
0.6829314231872559,
-0.6133804321289062,
-0.12399811297655106,
-1.037226676940918,
0.1684473305940628,
-0.030363082885742188,
-0.1614639163017273,
0.20742082595825195,
0.6347247958183289,
-0.5889483690261841,
0.33927249908447266,
0.34364354610443115,
-0.5108132362365723,
0.05440310388803482,
-0.44616639614105225,
0.7064530849456787,
0.7415782809257507,
0.12734222412109375,
0.2623133957386017,
-0.11197075992822647,
0.445667564868927,
0.12348205596208572,
0.7469437122344971,
-0.46758022904396057,
-0.29130956530570984,
-0.9537543654441833,
0.02646162360906601,
0.17328165471553802,
0.45005562901496887,
-0.5380336046218872,
0.8726236820220947,
-0.20523686707019806,
-0.38043057918548584,
-0.24642489850521088,
0.10573279857635498,
0.35270455479621887,
0.5829858779907227,
0.3748758137226105,
0.10214264690876007,
-0.8683225512504578,
-1.109118103981018,
0.05423483997583389,
-0.3563520312309265,
-0.28678640723228455,
0.3183084726333618,
0.35342007875442505,
-0.1813557744026184,
1.0157794952392578,
-0.6591774225234985,
-0.11439170688390732,
0.08874968439340591,
0.25706157088279724,
0.21423599123954773,
0.30017760396003723,
0.68870609998703,
-0.44667360186576843,
-0.09985367208719254,
-0.1270853877067566,
-0.8150151371955872,
-0.2461342066526413,
-0.13529840111732483,
0.16411487758159637,
0.42287972569465637,
0.7337473630905151,
-0.42891010642051697,
0.6210870742797852,
0.3640359938144684,
-0.1118985190987587,
0.4900628924369812,
-0.07339401543140411,
-0.0463208332657814,
-0.8659118413925171,
0.17238083481788635,
-0.11552123725414276,
-0.26656270027160645,
-0.16834397614002228,
0.03246413543820381,
0.1218886449933052,
-0.07103370130062103,
-0.13888908922672272,
0.36430302262306213,
-0.24751368165016174,
-0.15927311778068542,
-0.054074615240097046,
-0.088992178440094,
0.03309934213757515,
0.48419493436813354,
-0.17208078503608704,
0.48028409481048584,
0.2271767258644104,
-1.0463305711746216,
0.18436573445796967,
-0.0923534631729126,
-0.5533919930458069,
0.2692826986312866,
-0.5725939869880676,
0.06369937211275101,
0.1413664072751999,
0.18920964002609253,
-0.626751184463501,
0.05190115049481392,
0.11749397963285446,
-0.6318142414093018,
0.06592758744955063,
-0.5265058875083923,
-0.7454610466957092,
-0.5451894402503967,
0.457561731338501,
0.15726995468139648,
0.8958186507225037,
-0.5894837975502014,
1.2926033735275269,
0.5513227581977844,
0.35792919993400574,
-0.6510111689567566,
-0.5695973038673401,
-0.050649646669626236,
0.12613721191883087,
-0.456613153219223,
0.19000066816806793,
-0.00606726948171854,
-0.2195454090833664,
-0.01953798718750477,
-0.3337549865245819,
0.07156365364789963,
0.49097612500190735,
0.5834531188011169,
0.42161163687705994,
-0.33764708042144775,
0.13297447562217712,
0.05929651856422424,
-0.41661569476127625,
0.5139594078063965,
-0.5291908383369446,
0.669053852558136,
-0.15083785355091095,
-0.4327305853366852,
-0.37228330969810486,
0.13990464806556702,
0.45293518900871277,
-0.4525923728942871,
0.31542742252349854,
0.7144721150398254,
-0.39349260926246643,
-0.6478716731071472,
-0.49123096466064453,
0.041683778166770935,
-0.5149086713790894,
-0.11044638603925705,
-0.6495755910873413,
-0.3301633596420288,
0.6417680978775024,
-0.009963858872652054,
0.3403947949409485,
0.929146409034729,
0.43369153141975403,
0.059404872357845306,
1.1614068746566772,
0.4313819706439972,
0.08176054805517197,
0.3465346097946167,
-0.2109285145998001,
0.18206749856472015,
-0.38035881519317627,
-0.538273274898529,
-0.49318742752075195,
-0.4927639365196228,
-0.37951672077178955,
-0.07755555212497711,
0.2735712230205536,
-0.3995605707168579,
-0.4663468301296234,
0.4870359003543854,
-0.3568810224533081,
0.29155170917510986,
0.4579658508300781,
0.00024498385027982295,
0.1366117298603058,
-0.17975126206874847,
-0.4636218845844269,
0.17187125980854034,
-0.5411285161972046,
-0.2368108332157135,
0.7715901732444763,
0.18099333345890045,
0.5948578119277954,
0.08518810570240021,
0.5465436577796936,
0.37019944190979004,
-0.0415252149105072,
-0.7297364473342896,
0.6941508650779724,
-0.31010544300079346,
-0.44227704405784607,
0.08641514927148819,
-0.6404651999473572,
-0.7152637243270874,
-0.43331724405288696,
-0.16370420157909393,
-0.4648757576942444,
0.29095950722694397,
0.099720798432827,
-0.4701671302318573,
0.4030173122882843,
-0.5404605269432068,
0.6571796536445618,
-0.22465181350708008,
0.1552819460630417,
-0.18587720394134521,
-0.6879698038101196,
0.2669859528541565,
0.09890647977590561,
0.04895080626010895,
-0.3805766701698303,
0.02082529291510582,
0.5732530355453491,
-0.7595513463020325,
0.9868812561035156,
-0.3739456832408905,
0.09104601293802261,
0.2724030315876007,
0.5004658699035645,
0.43148529529571533,
0.17945870757102966,
-0.05616432800889015,
0.02949216589331627,
0.15079668164253235,
-0.47087225317955017,
-0.720708429813385,
0.5113608837127686,
-0.8018747568130493,
-0.34478285908699036,
-0.3967575132846832,
-0.4937524199485779,
-0.2135542631149292,
0.0401318296790123,
0.03814534842967987,
0.5279067754745483,
-0.10009777545928955,
0.026084082201123238,
0.6623766422271729,
-0.04767484962940216,
0.7787354588508606,
0.6750434041023254,
-0.1905485838651657,
-0.1394839733839035,
0.7277250289916992,
0.03320217505097389,
0.10656742006540298,
0.5988212823867798,
0.1890466809272766,
-0.1248277798295021,
-0.3713226020336151,
-0.4348600208759308,
-0.16570186614990234,
-0.7562727928161621,
-0.3550489544868469,
-0.6110354065895081,
-0.7404456734657288,
-0.3660392761230469,
-0.01711113564670086,
-0.41539835929870605,
-0.798443615436554,
-0.19056670367717743,
-0.06471578031778336,
0.4247796833515167,
0.7901965975761414,
-0.06286056339740753,
0.008301018737256527,
-0.804896891117096,
0.37269625067710876,
0.4231821596622467,
0.43128377199172974,
-0.012787170708179474,
-0.509108304977417,
-0.2507994771003723,
-0.048163048923015594,
-0.26536428928375244,
-0.3965888023376465,
0.41695141792297363,
0.10284430533647537,
0.8891881108283997,
0.2110750675201416,
0.2128387838602066,
0.766993522644043,
-0.6582159996032715,
0.6407290697097778,
-0.06900123506784439,
-1.1282060146331787,
0.8649119138717651,
0.16717126965522766,
0.07329336553812027,
0.13316883146762848,
0.12352593243122101,
-0.37431633472442627,
-0.18781237304210663,
-0.6481829881668091,
-0.7506606578826904,
0.4967590868473053,
0.19872812926769257,
-0.09494905918836594,
-0.027750998735427856,
0.5908141732215881,
0.14273665845394135,
0.019730564206838608,
-0.48690029978752136,
-0.40743720531463623,
-0.46846142411231995,
-0.30169937014579773,
-0.006719262804836035,
-0.17146387696266174,
0.05019724741578102,
-0.07855886220932007,
0.5013266801834106,
0.10652994364500046,
0.16375809907913208,
-0.10817428678274155,
-0.42260026931762695,
0.06053024157881737,
0.26298806071281433,
0.3359745442867279,
0.5442795157432556,
-0.28713664412498474,
0.11123897135257721,
-0.08226007223129272,
-0.3424348831176758,
0.21606741845607758,
0.3906531035900116,
-0.5100175142288208,
0.28640875220298767,
0.03383032605051994,
0.7733551859855652,
0.18237784504890442,
-0.5336167216300964,
0.1389668583869934,
0.06744764745235443,
-0.25630858540534973,
-0.750850260257721,
0.23377163708209991,
-0.22742438316345215,
0.2884296476840973,
0.4469631612300873,
0.25100311636924744,
0.11231834441423416,
-0.2837076485157013,
0.3848864734172821,
0.41005009412765503,
-0.3900684416294098,
-0.2598816454410553,
0.7788686156272888,
-0.010553596541285515,
-0.21556103229522705,
0.7204069495201111,
-0.40396249294281006,
-0.25424081087112427,
0.788798451423645,
0.19428642094135284,
1.1642861366271973,
-0.17140144109725952,
0.15236923098564148,
0.4071827828884125,
0.5021241903305054,
0.32014504075050354,
-0.04015452042222023,
-0.29095789790153503,
-0.5092113018035889,
-0.5316731929779053,
-0.9481199383735657,
-0.26820048689842224,
-0.1061701700091362,
-0.5901098847389221,
0.36809849739074707,
-0.6782995462417603,
-0.17000940442085266,
0.31779226660728455,
0.11538244038820267,
-0.7090635299682617,
-0.01556954812258482,
0.2566142678260803,
0.6854632496833801,
-0.8756877183914185,
0.9291236996650696,
0.11385805904865265,
-0.6135845184326172,
-0.877273440361023,
-0.241322323679924,
0.021054185926914215,
-0.8556147813796997,
1.0543057918548584,
-0.10841227322816849,
-0.3528577387332916,
-0.3356078565120697,
-0.20614199340343475,
-0.8526132702827454,
1.2484185695648193,
0.25795602798461914,
-0.48317772150039673,
-0.255292147397995,
0.09163733571767807,
0.2809654176235199,
-0.46781179308891296,
0.14465592801570892,
0.706820011138916,
0.49374353885650635,
0.0773908942937851,
-0.7945374846458435,
0.11424972116947174,
-0.29974135756492615,
-0.20074279606342316,
0.6151951551437378,
-0.30857715010643005,
1.0249234437942505,
-0.14576885104179382,
-0.594704270362854,
0.3648979365825653,
0.6902437806129456,
0.11448469012975693,
0.3141929507255554,
0.6251499652862549,
0.4729710519313812,
0.620158851146698,
-0.22314192354679108,
1.005225419998169,
-0.4275089204311371,
0.1037735641002655,
1.2738264799118042,
-0.37766650319099426,
0.7413107752799988,
-0.018018120899796486,
-0.29377755522727966,
1.006903886795044,
0.49165078997612,
-0.42471224069595337,
0.19244550168514252,
-0.13551855087280273,
-0.13313855230808258,
-0.6286314725875854,
0.25779539346694946,
-0.19626878201961517,
0.3952714800834656,
0.6822414398193359,
-0.6166487336158752,
-0.28165748715400696,
-0.32380354404449463,
-0.22072479128837585,
0.06228230893611908,
-0.29826855659484863,
0.781777024269104,
-0.07243520021438599,
-0.6390246748924255,
0.40890535712242126,
-0.11329951882362366,
0.1583843231201172,
-0.6654714941978455,
-0.07911316305398941,
-0.2675117552280426,
0.46872249245643616,
-0.24526764452457428,
-0.6969690918922424,
0.4701252281665802,
-0.2534247636795044,
-0.3938487768173218,
-0.20194503664970398,
0.39767298102378845,
0.09064260870218277,
-0.9569621086120605,
0.26519688963890076,
0.4532756805419922,
-0.198575958609581,
0.22921060025691986,
-0.583694338798523,
-0.28812071681022644,
-0.22773335874080658,
0.10208344459533691,
0.23770782351493835,
0.4177404046058655,
0.03399678319692612,
0.878603458404541,
0.5142297148704529,
-0.08822417259216309,
0.3397563397884369,
0.15592345595359802,
0.8435743451118469,
-0.6335855722427368,
-0.364271342754364,
-0.9170905947685242,
0.27762702107429504,
0.0951613038778305,
0.06817419081926346,
0.6837049722671509,
0.7736716270446777,
0.5334995985031128,
0.10087455064058304,
0.6189464330673218,
-0.07865341752767563,
0.5277107954025269,
-0.9014877676963806,
0.46717116236686707,
-0.4103396236896515,
0.6573172211647034,
0.2168717384338379,
-0.6965139508247375,
-0.2410861700773239,
0.3041943609714508,
-0.2595522701740265,
-0.11424340307712555,
0.630281925201416,
0.7355890274047852,
-0.21895694732666016,
0.06703933328390121,
0.05535055696964264,
0.2689644694328308,
0.5571120381355286,
0.9864487051963806,
0.8036282062530518,
-0.5040301084518433,
1.0264945030212402,
-0.3798084855079651,
-0.012788001447916031,
-0.1459471881389618,
-1.0364621877670288,
-0.5558776259422302,
-0.6994660496711731,
-0.23080956935882568,
-0.5618722438812256,
-0.010623307898640633,
0.7087386250495911,
0.7235064506530762,
-0.8596038818359375,
-0.22752732038497925,
-0.010320255532860756,
0.0847247913479805,
-0.4258967638015747,
-0.222537100315094,
0.35257285833358765,
-0.8184348344802856,
-0.450573205947876,
0.4469267427921295,
0.4406636953353882,
-0.10027597844600677,
-0.33642032742500305,
-0.026859138160943985,
-0.058476727455854416,
0.0851740911602974,
0.7537266612052917,
0.48120319843292236,
-0.7186221480369568,
-0.3732691705226898,
0.4040423631668091,
0.17559997737407684,
0.18165448307991028,
1.0042458772659302,
-1.237194538116455,
0.3383563458919525,
0.42369309067726135,
0.2801854908466339,
0.8524569869041443,
-0.5162906050682068,
0.6736178398132324,
-0.8737964630126953,
0.07865864038467407,
0.2876220941543579,
0.8320407867431641,
-0.0704168826341629,
-0.051878560334444046,
0.5236524343490601,
0.32557085156440735,
-0.6098954677581787,
-0.6474750638008118,
0.5635566711425781,
-0.9789214730262756,
-0.4226706624031067,
0.8510302901268005,
-0.0669451579451561,
-0.28212273120880127,
-0.21628570556640625,
0.5344194173812866,
0.2112012654542923,
-0.14741605520248413,
0.8149874210357666,
0.28658369183540344,
-0.14393243193626404,
-0.01723896525800228,
-0.5402951240539551,
0.32430198788642883,
-0.11369315534830093,
-0.5333839654922485,
0.15830188989639282,
0.6446177959442139,
0.20264706015586853,
0.37579163908958435,
0.02410222217440605,
-0.3916611671447754,
0.43322670459747314,
0.10578200221061707,
0.0417211651802063,
-0.31019309163093567,
-0.15574102103710175,
0.055611904710531235,
0.2685100734233856,
-0.3086477220058441,
-0.2500970661640167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20906v1
|
Enhancing Vision Models for Text-Heavy Content Understanding and Interaction
| 2024-05-31T15:17:47
| 2024-05-31T15:17:47
|
Adithya TG, Adithya SK, Abhinav R Bharadwaj, Abhiram HA, Dr. Surabhi Narayan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Interacting and understanding with text heavy visual content with multiple
images is a major challenge for traditional vision models. This paper is on
enhancing vision models' capability to comprehend or understand and learn from
images containing a huge amount of textual information from the likes of
textbooks and research papers which contain multiple images like graphs, etc
and tables in them with different types of axes and scales. The approach
involves dataset preprocessing, fine tuning which is by using instructional
oriented data and evaluation. We also built a visual chat application
integrating CLIP for image encoding and a model from the Massive Text Embedding
Benchmark which is developed to consider both textual and visual inputs. An
accuracy of 96.71% was obtained. The aim of the project is to increase and also
enhance the advance vision models' capabilities in understanding complex visual
textual data interconnected data, contributing to multimodal AI.
|
[
-0.3273772597312927,
-1.057578682899475,
0.5672279596328735,
0.15528607368469238,
-0.3608054518699646,
-0.09849026054143906,
-0.19324448704719543,
-0.697080135345459,
-0.0901828184723854,
0.584456741809845,
-0.16910357773303986,
-0.5389067530632019,
-0.8732553720474243,
-0.1205437183380127,
-0.40359002351760864,
0.7577155828475952,
-0.10288746654987335,
0.3821418583393097,
-0.6030939221382141,
-0.37718433141708374,
-0.8596532344818115,
-0.36648425459861755,
-0.7214570641517639,
-0.14643701910972595,
0.4343339502811432,
0.38035714626312256,
0.7920556664466858,
0.5418320298194885,
0.9326894879341125,
0.39106306433677673,
-0.026616986840963364,
0.5080456733703613,
-0.5349966287612915,
0.1637074202299118,
-0.23752905428409576,
-0.44968312978744507,
-0.409716933965683,
-0.10904300212860107,
0.7545942068099976,
0.35032644867897034,
0.15968918800354004,
-0.027172066271305084,
0.26456519961357117,
0.6175411939620972,
-0.6542199850082397,
0.39339515566825867,
-0.3923252522945404,
-0.02109752781689167,
0.07262324541807175,
-0.47511348128318787,
-0.6895123720169067,
0.10316739976406097,
0.3506373167037964,
-0.954003095626831,
-0.11380328238010406,
0.10999780893325806,
0.8409899473190308,
0.19747912883758545,
-0.615605354309082,
-0.42561668157577515,
-0.6803642511367798,
0.8142956495285034,
-0.33620485663414,
0.35226041078567505,
0.2897230088710785,
0.26933613419532776,
0.20203489065170288,
-0.7767833471298218,
-0.5458613634109497,
0.03359776362776756,
-0.008408388122916222,
0.2373208850622177,
0.061250027269124985,
0.16365812718868256,
0.2775874733924866,
0.1926310807466507,
-0.23342996835708618,
-0.04190630093216896,
-0.41614341735839844,
0.06433134526014328,
0.5884131789207458,
0.38503000140190125,
0.7059354186058044,
-0.19736529886722565,
-0.45065298676490784,
-0.5193672180175781,
-0.09066169708967209,
-0.10902322828769684,
0.23719844222068787,
-0.07739261537790298,
-0.1778934895992279,
0.7095053195953369,
0.021366985514760017,
1.0402746200561523,
-0.33654481172561646,
-0.0889967679977417,
0.3938528895378113,
-0.7067490816116333,
-0.30633077025413513,
-0.2854984700679779,
0.40945854783058167,
0.7280359864234924,
0.5589033365249634,
0.2772059440612793,
0.06217431277036667,
0.08644843846559525,
0.3591667711734772,
-0.9054092168807983,
-0.12269481271505356,
0.054251521825790405,
-0.7120234966278076,
-0.2556835412979126,
0.07530605047941208,
-0.9374959468841553,
-0.602654218673706,
-0.7275661826133728,
0.7210034728050232,
-0.8652516007423401,
-0.16625520586967468,
0.1737818568944931,
-0.4323091506958008,
0.2240952104330063,
0.8987594842910767,
-0.7522295117378235,
-0.03225953131914139,
0.2515959143638611,
0.7937222123146057,
-0.04738212376832962,
-0.45706936717033386,
-0.23673707246780396,
0.5230162739753723,
-0.23251381516456604,
0.9186339974403381,
-0.8510842323303223,
-0.2677740752696991,
-0.07365106791257858,
0.06428974866867065,
-0.25220590829849243,
-0.24057649075984955,
0.5186823606491089,
-0.32250088453292847,
0.09580579400062561,
0.05065436661243439,
-0.6275960206985474,
-0.5737443566322327,
0.5467471480369568,
-0.771521270275116,
0.6974375247955322,
-0.2143021821975708,
-1.033555269241333,
0.29418694972991943,
-0.5870978236198425,
-0.4038516879081726,
0.12426294386386871,
-0.2351163625717163,
-0.32926827669143677,
-0.031085560098290443,
0.6234479546546936,
0.600495457649231,
-0.13336442410945892,
0.2993617057800293,
-0.2989549934864044,
-0.4129815399646759,
0.2323085367679596,
-0.6231736540794373,
0.3378150165081024,
-0.07083922624588013,
0.14969509840011597,
0.3387661576271057,
-0.6785767674446106,
-0.026355847716331482,
0.10524339973926544,
-0.1943325698375702,
-0.717186689376831,
0.14463266730308533,
0.43441715836524963,
-0.146966814994812,
0.2612576186656952,
-0.1708129197359085,
0.3339160978794098,
0.06986578553915024,
0.2703503966331482,
0.5818946361541748,
0.09736894071102142,
0.4539925754070282,
-0.22152410447597504,
0.2642402946949005,
0.31307360529899597,
0.3576130270957947,
-0.866574227809906,
-0.6208697557449341,
-0.7084544897079468,
-0.2919240891933441,
0.419877290725708,
0.6872138977050781,
-1.3851313591003418,
-0.08875058591365814,
-0.3557360768318176,
-0.4556591510772705,
-0.4100445508956909,
0.2144968956708908,
0.37606436014175415,
0.3885759711265564,
0.43697044253349304,
-0.34424498677253723,
-0.44828519225120544,
-0.654780924320221,
-0.17206232249736786,
0.1569111943244934,
0.05175677314400673,
0.5515623688697815,
0.5727177262306213,
-0.39559486508369446,
0.6257706880569458,
-0.5805915594100952,
-0.43339917063713074,
-0.29116714000701904,
0.3298967480659485,
-0.08815952390432358,
0.7594184279441833,
0.6707428693771362,
-1.3110053539276123,
-0.6671050190925598,
0.15543852746486664,
-1.147916555404663,
0.4366748034954071,
-0.24646174907684326,
-0.20840837061405182,
-0.05947575718164444,
0.5599625706672668,
-0.282871812582016,
0.7685255408287048,
0.5547515153884888,
-0.4771589934825897,
0.301887571811676,
-0.44213858246803284,
0.5811328291893005,
-1.0443438291549683,
-0.12010558694601059,
0.2926301658153534,
-0.14616620540618896,
-0.6962270736694336,
0.16574446856975555,
0.19220367074012756,
-0.26148146390914917,
-0.3216298818588257,
0.45395249128341675,
-0.5544583201408386,
0.11073768138885498,
-0.1720324605703354,
0.20025981962680817,
0.3112826347351074,
0.30730748176574707,
0.19721199572086334,
0.6297109127044678,
0.7390952110290527,
-0.39614230394363403,
0.4505784809589386,
0.47597500681877136,
-0.49908557534217834,
0.8038840293884277,
-0.7588462829589844,
-0.157759889960289,
-0.4769255816936493,
0.12835465371608734,
-0.9761941432952881,
-0.33803343772888184,
0.064842090010643,
-0.3828080892562866,
0.4171583950519562,
-0.12600938975811005,
-0.5371743440628052,
-0.07712636888027191,
-0.3230840861797333,
0.5563265681266785,
0.08232959359884262,
-0.5226134061813354,
0.9690881371498108,
0.30149343609809875,
-0.14536914229393005,
-0.5979024767875671,
-0.6081856489181519,
0.22500863671302795,
0.024703441187739372,
-0.7798483967781067,
0.314415842294693,
-0.09627669304609299,
-0.1541541963815689,
0.12502749264240265,
0.47906744480133057,
-0.32115304470062256,
-0.3373265862464905,
0.29547685384750366,
0.5485647916793823,
-0.11237699538469315,
0.4874597191810608,
0.0659976601600647,
-0.0043566240929067135,
-0.4459725022315979,
-0.03454858064651489,
0.3778616487979889,
0.013348250649869442,
-0.29056596755981445,
-0.6762762069702148,
0.41706153750419617,
0.679259717464447,
-0.3315913677215576,
0.8842628002166748,
0.9486953616142273,
-0.3545630872249603,
0.19276396930217743,
-0.5437374114990234,
-0.055308327078819275,
-0.4170498251914978,
0.671668291091919,
-0.41056856513023376,
-0.537957489490509,
0.2747955918312073,
-0.0494166798889637,
-0.12339437007904053,
0.2900882661342621,
0.22982601821422577,
-0.18860456347465515,
1.0976181030273438,
0.9731999635696411,
0.23907028138637543,
0.8105368614196777,
-0.17664214968681335,
-0.06479718536138535,
-0.7337048649787903,
-0.5566603541374207,
-0.24393108487129211,
-0.21474005281925201,
-0.2508087456226349,
-0.6079097986221313,
0.28452351689338684,
-0.021400246769189835,
0.16008150577545166,
0.14154723286628723,
-0.579535722732544,
0.475879043340683,
0.4005362391471863,
0.765992283821106,
0.4578961730003357,
0.13286036252975464,
0.0862681120634079,
-0.3309013843536377,
-0.5799072980880737,
-0.3297167420387268,
1.0084024667739868,
0.44459035992622375,
1.053421974182129,
-0.1973954439163208,
-0.05709153041243553,
0.3024842441082001,
0.1175927147269249,
-0.7687444090843201,
0.35369306802749634,
-0.3910696804523468,
-0.4879317283630371,
-0.2376081645488739,
-0.4398846924304962,
-0.6150294542312622,
0.30490103363990784,
-0.8631111979484558,
-0.4307985305786133,
0.2520466446876526,
0.17701755464076996,
0.0375010147690773,
0.26276978850364685,
-1.1249312162399292,
0.9429959654808044,
-0.17882241308689117,
-0.47103968262672424,
-0.4941861629486084,
-0.415793240070343,
0.31919020414352417,
0.20083890855312347,
0.256390780210495,
0.2294328659772873,
-0.056273169815540314,
0.8259113430976868,
0.008444031700491905,
0.9015370607376099,
0.015168638899922371,
-0.040144771337509155,
0.37685519456863403,
-0.3313984274864197,
0.15619948506355286,
0.005764544941484928,
-0.0590604692697525,
0.0914299264550209,
0.015398357063531876,
-0.4293668270111084,
-0.6789252161979675,
0.4311067759990692,
-0.7205175757408142,
-0.2320629507303238,
-0.06616484373807907,
-0.8385635018348694,
-0.09630803018808365,
0.018384316936135292,
0.08209067583084106,
0.966458797454834,
-0.03552931174635887,
0.575830340385437,
0.7806097865104675,
-0.49510443210601807,
0.3220721185207367,
0.0998285561800003,
-0.16086994111537933,
-0.5562351942062378,
0.8961780667304993,
0.12941333651542664,
0.2336938977241516,
0.462159663438797,
-0.13960500061511993,
-0.08093017339706421,
-0.5757868885993958,
-0.5711914896965027,
-0.07451245933771133,
-0.9116017818450928,
-0.29506194591522217,
-0.7473661303520203,
-0.23944252729415894,
-0.2943163812160492,
-0.07327237725257874,
-0.01184119749814272,
-0.13045558333396912,
-0.4228442311286926,
0.23425960540771484,
0.5015785694122314,
0.7847283482551575,
0.316322386264801,
0.7319204807281494,
-1.0233122110366821,
0.4111524224281311,
0.3894805610179901,
0.4022454619407654,
0.3060811758041382,
-0.5129786729812622,
-0.3921585977077484,
-0.07304386794567108,
-0.3028685450553894,
-0.7697452902793884,
0.28091704845428467,
0.2388474941253662,
0.4213952422142029,
0.5934849977493286,
-0.33120399713516235,
0.7930917739868164,
-0.4613248407840729,
0.5491059422492981,
0.3637707829475403,
-0.9435082077980042,
0.6354587078094482,
-0.23393139243125916,
0.48467233777046204,
0.3803361654281616,
0.47535207867622375,
-0.2193443775177002,
-0.08014001697301865,
-0.35268741846084595,
-0.633834183216095,
0.48000311851501465,
0.08856507390737534,
0.22517316043376923,
0.5880377292633057,
0.4508536159992218,
-0.0868108794093132,
0.0787556916475296,
-0.6668073534965515,
0.22424152493476868,
-0.2271174043416977,
-0.5817347764968872,
-0.005572049412876368,
-0.47079581022262573,
0.10594876855611801,
-0.34955665469169617,
0.37034961581230164,
-0.2077859342098236,
-0.052502360194921494,
0.2023531198501587,
-0.2844220697879791,
0.34798774123191833,
0.03832226246595383,
0.39998674392700195,
0.7812602519989014,
0.06826099008321762,
0.08517251908779144,
0.18781860172748566,
-0.9391762614250183,
-0.2628174126148224,
-0.0880139172077179,
0.00035617314279079437,
-0.11887583881616592,
0.6922692060470581,
0.8453880548477173,
0.17673328518867493,
-0.7915642857551575,
0.6342283487319946,
-0.3553062975406647,
-0.11889178305864334,
0.08864253759384155,
0.07512013614177704,
-0.11581316590309143,
0.28487804532051086,
0.4755249321460724,
0.1301499605178833,
0.18788672983646393,
-0.603365421295166,
0.23642797768115997,
0.3663494884967804,
-0.5700738430023193,
-0.007807066664099693,
0.4106302857398987,
0.359534353017807,
0.1580726057291031,
0.6783882975578308,
0.3499787151813507,
-0.5203371644020081,
0.7433533072471619,
0.41544926166534424,
-0.002575894817709923,
-0.11452862620353699,
0.20188748836517334,
0.47587287425994873,
0.4222957193851471,
-0.01541285589337349,
0.3536454439163208,
0.1444607973098755,
-0.820009708404541,
-0.6845734119415283,
-0.3284006714820862,
-0.5348082184791565,
-0.18047194182872772,
-0.4957282245159149,
0.5176977515220642,
-0.3123987317085266,
-0.20750688016414642,
0.18842311203479767,
-0.12214270234107971,
-0.5370703339576721,
0.521482527256012,
-0.01947662979364395,
0.7804746627807617,
-0.852944016456604,
0.7563314437866211,
0.7672840356826782,
-0.532922089099884,
-0.47090646624565125,
-0.31378281116485596,
-0.41359880566596985,
-0.7569088935852051,
0.5666189789772034,
0.29664358496665955,
0.12365249544382095,
-0.08366536349058151,
-0.9155298471450806,
-0.3175220489501953,
0.8977767825126648,
0.1507977992296219,
-0.521442174911499,
-0.08331272751092911,
-0.19234156608581543,
0.3797696828842163,
-0.42572107911109924,
0.49336808919906616,
0.047585226595401764,
0.5808661580085754,
0.3037795126438141,
-0.5224196314811707,
-0.17768043279647827,
-0.3193613886833191,
0.14160147309303284,
0.11671148240566254,
-0.44349905848503113,
0.8321535587310791,
-0.24616993963718414,
-0.05373508110642433,
0.02093680575489998,
0.5821079015731812,
-0.09932109713554382,
0.4169534742832184,
0.5555765628814697,
0.47707000374794006,
0.37104445695877075,
-0.10395345836877823,
0.8539930582046509,
-0.19027000665664673,
0.16210801899433136,
1.1254072189331055,
0.04752279445528984,
0.8524321913719177,
0.39345529675483704,
0.375006765127182,
0.38599979877471924,
0.40560758113861084,
-0.3929058909416199,
0.29167836904525757,
-0.35769322514533997,
-0.13713696599006653,
-0.31741151213645935,
-0.4200614094734192,
-0.4294455945491791,
0.683466374874115,
0.7517622709274292,
-0.4565829038619995,
0.09648152440786362,
0.5147426128387451,
-0.40383487939834595,
0.2657500207424164,
-0.47696298360824585,
0.8622214794158936,
-0.07074949890375137,
-0.2892001271247864,
0.10548383742570877,
-0.11168552190065384,
0.6428942084312439,
-0.5175185799598694,
-0.40826669335365295,
0.3741254210472107,
0.2612007260322571,
-0.26849648356437683,
-1.1015406847000122,
0.24820303916931152,
-0.19916988909244537,
-0.25821903347969055,
-0.09603425860404968,
1.0763219594955444,
-0.5088101625442505,
-0.5905959010124207,
0.36049240827560425,
0.438420832157135,
-0.05866130813956261,
-0.06462575495243073,
-0.5543100237846375,
0.34573087096214294,
-0.021653667092323303,
-0.008890446275472641,
0.17793285846710205,
0.5847636461257935,
0.07582086324691772,
0.6029685735702515,
0.6014384627342224,
-0.17318643629550934,
-0.20703451335430145,
0.21292507648468018,
0.817506730556488,
-0.5755913257598877,
-0.3500863015651703,
-0.8321424126625061,
0.44600552320480347,
-0.44010496139526367,
-0.2579108774662018,
0.662024974822998,
0.3338067829608917,
0.6042235493659973,
-0.2172427922487259,
0.5561133623123169,
0.0715707391500473,
0.026581598445773125,
-0.6415857076644897,
0.8282776474952698,
-0.6865708231925964,
-0.35428011417388916,
-0.4982132613658905,
-0.7966354489326477,
-0.40597233176231384,
0.45615363121032715,
-0.25139060616493225,
-0.1914190948009491,
0.5547751188278198,
0.391503244638443,
-0.21483060717582703,
0.22425749897956848,
0.4723479747772217,
0.03433501347899437,
0.055613502860069275,
0.3906993865966797,
0.8130181431770325,
-0.5651755332946777,
0.8053343892097473,
0.0622708797454834,
-0.4720248579978943,
-0.1565123200416565,
-0.7468661665916443,
-1.133594036102295,
-0.6124563813209534,
-0.21618250012397766,
-0.07539479434490204,
0.09988738596439362,
0.17820662260055542,
0.8037016987800598,
-0.3804199993610382,
0.06631669402122498,
0.14660148322582245,
0.14859138429164886,
-0.06878069043159485,
-0.22729332745075226,
0.29666611552238464,
-0.2647414803504944,
-0.9208599925041199,
-0.09296287596225739,
0.4568306505680084,
0.4067375063896179,
-0.20866914093494415,
0.17398573458194733,
-0.41080453991889954,
0.09598690271377563,
0.9690884947776794,
-0.20143359899520874,
-0.1133001297712326,
-0.2695162892341614,
-0.21302175521850586,
-0.0901324450969696,
0.17416580021381378,
0.6846919059753418,
-0.5881965160369873,
0.660923182964325,
0.6213921904563904,
0.8198151588439941,
0.5618255734443665,
0.06171116977930069,
0.5211834907531738,
-0.44226667284965515,
0.5304452180862427,
-0.10375171154737473,
0.4177435338497162,
0.5826546549797058,
-0.4458998739719391,
0.46159449219703674,
0.1261705607175827,
-0.37951675057411194,
-0.5492154955863953,
0.12124177068471909,
-1.0861339569091797,
-0.40946659445762634,
0.7874946594238281,
-0.23894143104553223,
-0.33989426493644714,
0.07830417901277542,
-0.6590165495872498,
0.29532086849212646,
-0.1536998152732849,
0.4712056815624237,
0.7167539596557617,
0.17512036859989166,
-0.4833928942680359,
-0.7005811929702759,
0.04815027117729187,
0.2819489538669586,
-1.0903042554855347,
-0.23645929992198944,
0.4661872982978821,
-0.1908637285232544,
0.24935537576675415,
0.26524484157562256,
-0.1860261857509613,
0.15308578312397003,
0.25720909237861633,
-0.09580899775028229,
0.10476468503475189,
-0.6880824565887451,
-0.20820163190364838,
0.22861453890800476,
-0.36874136328697205,
-0.2839016616344452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20902v1
|
Preemptive Answer "Attacks" on Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2024-05-31T15:15:04
| 2024-05-31T15:15:04
|
Rongwu Xu, Zehan Qi, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Large language models (LLMs) showcase impressive reasoning capabilities when
coupled with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting. However, the robustness of this
approach warrants further investigation. In this paper, we introduce a novel
scenario termed preemptive answers, where the LLM obtains an answer before
engaging in reasoning. This situation can arise inadvertently or induced by
malicious users by prompt injection attacks. Experiments reveal that preemptive
answers significantly impair the model's reasoning capability across various
CoT methods and a broad spectrum of datasets. To bolster the robustness of
reasoning, we propose two measures aimed at mitigating this issue to some
extent.
|
[
-0.5269787311553955,
-1.2482467889785767,
0.9360138177871704,
-0.1181400939822197,
-0.3668449819087982,
0.2583640515804291,
0.1288529485464096,
-0.5131847262382507,
0.18027691543102264,
1.119658350944519,
-0.5664514303207397,
0.012836127541959286,
-0.6657491326332092,
-0.05376545712351799,
-0.5325540900230408,
0.830829381942749,
-0.10527165234088898,
-0.39301586151123047,
-0.3127986788749695,
0.05942302569746971,
-0.610328733921051,
-0.9900646209716797,
-0.6249743700027466,
-0.017285965383052826,
0.748026967048645,
0.12452612817287445,
0.932550847530365,
0.08422639966011047,
0.48209598660469055,
0.37606677412986755,
0.2301570624113083,
0.028414709493517876,
-0.4844513535499573,
0.3828085958957672,
-0.3743879199028015,
-0.6580076217651367,
-0.7405896782875061,
-0.07421649247407913,
0.418462872505188,
0.6205983757972717,
-0.17908641695976257,
0.16926953196525574,
0.062605120241642,
0.5051276683807373,
-0.9817522168159485,
-0.6655440926551819,
-0.9253348708152771,
-0.3192155063152313,
-0.26941347122192383,
-0.3966670334339142,
-0.8429433107376099,
-0.08507084846496582,
0.2210063934326172,
-0.4097083806991577,
-0.3215223550796509,
0.11523442715406418,
0.4731903672218323,
0.33460381627082825,
-0.17262619733810425,
-0.34875544905662537,
-0.5893286466598511,
0.5304328203201294,
-0.576265275478363,
-0.18636734783649445,
0.4572402834892273,
0.22696729004383087,
-0.5639459490776062,
-0.8500837683677673,
-0.6216807961463928,
-0.2405952662229538,
-0.12242252379655838,
-0.03108389303088188,
-0.3242027163505554,
0.23020629584789276,
0.45803841948509216,
-0.025777192786335945,
-0.4432624280452728,
0.16626441478729248,
0.02542990632355213,
-0.09672871232032776,
0.5246747732162476,
0.21691790223121643,
0.3228398263454437,
0.07451269775629044,
-0.5662997961044312,
0.14714981615543365,
-0.9655780792236328,
0.0394442081451416,
0.39218318462371826,
0.12557440996170044,
0.2240937054157257,
0.5755611062049866,
0.022212829440832138,
0.9928882122039795,
0.0127439359202981,
0.2576456069946289,
-0.34282276034355164,
-0.528774082660675,
-0.425250768661499,
0.09796052426099777,
0.7613362073898315,
-0.07745717465877533,
0.4738624095916748,
0.15436846017837524,
-0.414130836725235,
-0.04148141294717789,
0.46211573481559753,
-0.6932519674301147,
-0.13563039898872375,
0.6189160943031311,
-0.07095468789339066,
-0.43475499749183655,
0.14675970375537872,
-0.69056236743927,
-0.329881489276886,
0.14239126443862915,
0.5408844351768494,
0.058803655207157135,
-0.32785841822624207,
0.15612301230430603,
0.13806718587875366,
0.2232595533132553,
0.30375197529792786,
-0.2881213128566742,
0.3957907557487488,
0.5541473627090454,
0.4588435888290405,
0.10761090368032455,
-0.0974944680929184,
-0.7288724184036255,
0.27641433477401733,
-0.414241760969162,
0.9029061794281006,
-0.49695679545402527,
-0.5282322764396667,
0.009874147363007069,
-0.138069748878479,
0.20927321910858154,
-0.504774808883667,
0.17279241979122162,
-1.0065128803253174,
0.01581500843167305,
-0.46240031719207764,
-0.3817867934703827,
0.23002159595489502,
0.26433104276657104,
-0.4997687339782715,
0.5764833688735962,
-0.2729148268699646,
-1.0581974983215332,
0.09279906004667282,
-0.4038246273994446,
-0.5339363217353821,
0.09154399484395981,
-0.17380686104297638,
0.008312567137181759,
-0.010503968223929405,
0.36858999729156494,
0.3198213577270508,
-0.2888392210006714,
0.20925076305866241,
-0.5118396282196045,
-0.16159120202064514,
0.744288444519043,
-0.4236193299293518,
0.8718236088752747,
0.45395681262016296,
-0.058036722242832184,
0.15531542897224426,
-0.36605921387672424,
0.26676931977272034,
0.2716839611530304,
0.30797287821769714,
-0.4242244362831116,
0.10798840969800949,
-0.6531636118888855,
0.3613191843032837,
0.31047478318214417,
-0.16531464457511902,
0.19088861346244812,
-0.3688751757144928,
0.18422549962997437,
1.2344136238098145,
0.3665940761566162,
0.3676576316356659,
-0.4198039472103119,
0.9809445142745972,
0.20057788491249084,
0.26387879252433777,
-0.21671582758426666,
-0.43910202383995056,
-0.37575700879096985,
-0.22767426073551178,
0.03692670911550522,
0.6619126796722412,
-1.1321629285812378,
0.21934844553470612,
0.08820716291666031,
-0.4355137050151825,
-0.21265770494937897,
0.12950499355793,
0.6712791323661804,
0.4497123062610626,
0.35659417510032654,
-0.18738920986652374,
-0.4328175485134125,
-0.5503944158554077,
-0.5377287268638611,
-0.2338211089372635,
-0.1560160368680954,
0.12232392281293869,
0.41790932416915894,
-0.1703803688287735,
0.8607932329177856,
-0.7359328269958496,
0.19755513966083527,
-0.3949221968650818,
0.043991271406412125,
0.35753291845321655,
0.428560733795166,
0.42353013157844543,
-0.5749778151512146,
0.02837328612804413,
-0.4617600440979004,
-0.6748619079589844,
-0.3121236562728882,
-0.37610167264938354,
-0.37358909845352173,
-0.16065281629562378,
0.756475031375885,
-0.7064628005027771,
0.5517247319221497,
0.2452898621559143,
-0.36805179715156555,
0.8285289406776428,
-0.17575928568840027,
-0.01681963913142681,
-1.0257794857025146,
-0.15962029993534088,
-0.531732976436615,
-0.1937597543001175,
-0.6308109164237976,
0.2902646064758301,
-0.31180089712142944,
0.045951616019010544,
-0.6681128740310669,
0.48833370208740234,
-0.32692068815231323,
0.07389608025550842,
-0.3646242916584015,
0.26679083704948425,
0.044024739414453506,
0.00950439553707838,
-0.09706898033618927,
0.9966050386428833,
0.49849802255630493,
-0.954913318157196,
0.25852450728416443,
0.2217416614294052,
-0.2675941586494446,
0.34290459752082825,
-0.765442430973053,
0.41046831011772156,
-0.06792925298213959,
0.597262442111969,
-0.8637294769287109,
-0.32300013303756714,
0.1592150181531906,
-0.5004770159721375,
0.08774886280298233,
0.10137908160686493,
-0.5244787335395813,
-0.5316118597984314,
-0.35705360770225525,
0.630624532699585,
0.2606252431869507,
-0.5209802389144897,
0.5466778874397278,
0.3513258397579193,
-0.11257817596197128,
-0.8685622215270996,
-0.5013040900230408,
0.01804535463452339,
-0.0855460837483406,
-0.48552849888801575,
0.054779063910245895,
-0.07195554673671722,
-0.6060997247695923,
-0.08403878659009933,
-0.019765794277191162,
-0.09301331639289856,
0.40498825907707214,
-0.07584865391254425,
0.4606020152568817,
-0.10244542360305786,
0.024366308003664017,
-0.03660159930586815,
0.04080238193273544,
0.432376503944397,
-0.26087623834609985,
0.8126279711723328,
0.08470252901315689,
-0.6275598406791687,
-0.4258646070957184,
0.5612937211990356,
0.6241912245750427,
-0.37653976678848267,
0.8517107963562012,
-0.1718342900276184,
-0.21757225692272186,
-0.03747415170073509,
-0.5694855451583862,
-0.4080110490322113,
-0.6227976679801941,
0.2990569472312927,
-0.6120622754096985,
-0.6327191591262817,
0.6641682982444763,
-0.12850865721702576,
0.0422050915658474,
0.12262765318155289,
0.4447622299194336,
-0.3811746835708618,
1.2178806066513062,
-0.024623923003673553,
0.14261089265346527,
0.3797760307788849,
-0.050070736557245255,
0.41074293851852417,
-0.7336406707763672,
0.040482256561517715,
-0.4996323585510254,
-0.041454508900642395,
-0.5149714946746826,
-0.39362287521362305,
0.09426893293857574,
0.19288228452205658,
-0.3500106930732727,
0.2157236784696579,
-0.2624073922634125,
0.6914954781532288,
0.21706095337867737,
0.23088979721069336,
-0.03587699681520462,
-0.5373537540435791,
-0.28586500883102417,
0.6685699224472046,
-0.6917131543159485,
-0.6154727935791016,
1.1068931818008423,
-0.005661164876073599,
0.9069944024085999,
0.21415451169013977,
0.6716244220733643,
0.18843941390514374,
0.16616733372211456,
-0.3207564949989319,
0.8498968482017517,
0.31503185629844666,
-0.6858298182487488,
-0.10931883752346039,
-0.35821208357810974,
-1.1405037641525269,
0.10629662871360779,
-0.204645037651062,
-0.8762096166610718,
-0.05987612530589104,
0.2160983830690384,
-0.6064859628677368,
0.3306116461753845,
-0.835508406162262,
0.499769389629364,
-0.5123004913330078,
-0.4912843406200409,
-0.12329792231321335,
-0.7324663996696472,
0.4563521444797516,
-0.336475133895874,
0.3873053193092346,
0.21925145387649536,
0.048808980733156204,
0.6918652057647705,
-0.638325572013855,
0.7196095585823059,
-0.2060365229845047,
-0.15011176466941833,
0.7946707606315613,
0.27536892890930176,
0.783396303653717,
0.1587497889995575,
0.10919423401355743,
-0.2253095954656601,
0.055277034640312195,
-0.9284371733665466,
-0.7627242803573608,
0.5109726190567017,
-0.5632953643798828,
-1.4664463996887207,
-0.4847390651702881,
-0.3811934292316437,
-0.28376081585884094,
0.17065416276454926,
0.45712998509407043,
0.4665668308734894,
-0.04735695198178291,
-0.16225828230381012,
0.7761654853820801,
-0.42186665534973145,
0.45985499024391174,
0.258821576833725,
-0.6339717507362366,
-0.300044983625412,
0.31491267681121826,
0.18136727809906006,
0.9519696831703186,
0.08607082813978195,
0.14397744834423065,
-0.26316043734550476,
-0.5621966123580933,
-0.1271669864654541,
0.09235212951898575,
-0.7600146532058716,
-0.257517009973526,
-0.6395180225372314,
-0.18229249119758606,
-0.351909875869751,
-0.36309555172920227,
-0.1501811295747757,
-0.23595647513866425,
-0.10482113808393478,
-0.3843904733657837,
0.13506090641021729,
0.8195126056671143,
0.2731480300426483,
0.4068666696548462,
-0.7808154225349426,
0.2710215151309967,
0.537480354309082,
-0.06054088473320007,
0.20926566421985626,
-0.35674965381622314,
0.1521831750869751,
0.033724892884492874,
-0.3030722141265869,
-1.108157992362976,
0.031939711421728134,
-0.322296142578125,
0.5805130004882812,
0.8029928803443909,
0.48440369963645935,
0.6727508306503296,
-0.42581722140312195,
0.8166383504867554,
0.23303283751010895,
-0.8480863571166992,
1.0215940475463867,
-0.2530696392059326,
0.6520165205001831,
0.505530059337616,
0.4742443859577179,
0.1587214469909668,
-0.8742135763168335,
-0.6988215446472168,
-0.797819972038269,
0.23226918280124664,
0.09338456392288208,
0.29012903571128845,
-0.49070990085601807,
0.34917882084846497,
-0.03099343553185463,
0.10274000465869904,
-0.5690352916717529,
0.0290987528860569,
0.047988831996917725,
0.32055965065956116,
0.14653955399990082,
-0.4694588780403137,
-0.08395509421825409,
-0.1647307276725769,
0.5245630145072937,
0.12883473932743073,
0.0920182541012764,
0.2828525900840759,
-0.32500916719436646,
0.15319837629795074,
0.26472824811935425,
0.6699047088623047,
0.8840686082839966,
0.05331554636359215,
0.6226930022239685,
0.3767978847026825,
-0.5231316089630127,
0.2960793673992157,
-0.39104896783828735,
0.030171826481819153,
-0.4766741991043091,
0.6093782186508179,
0.3630698025226593,
0.0092481579631567,
-0.7901825904846191,
0.5408840775489807,
-0.14880003035068512,
0.08557504415512085,
-0.3704385757446289,
0.1311137080192566,
-0.11736524105072021,
-0.045467279851436615,
0.3711566925048828,
0.20340433716773987,
-0.13089889287948608,
-0.5843796133995056,
0.29331696033477783,
0.5554755926132202,
-0.2176172137260437,
-0.3623069226741791,
0.4519249498844147,
0.07045204192399979,
-0.39769700169563293,
0.5655931830406189,
-0.014661037363111973,
-0.8229432106018066,
0.5637331008911133,
0.7954897880554199,
0.7150675654411316,
-0.5882958173751831,
-0.047473203390836716,
0.2005561888217926,
0.4474391043186188,
0.1842418611049652,
0.3562462329864502,
-0.11239969730377197,
-0.8971598148345947,
-0.5753238201141357,
-0.2993885278701782,
-0.3320082426071167,
0.02345910109579563,
-0.7421643733978271,
0.2797933518886566,
-0.7783310413360596,
-0.4294739365577698,
-0.1869867593050003,
-0.2789279520511627,
-0.5805953741073608,
0.1474560797214508,
-0.017009465023875237,
0.8264116048812866,
-0.6262306571006775,
1.0362720489501953,
0.3425906300544739,
-0.47440049052238464,
-0.7674337029457092,
0.2841291129589081,
-0.26769232749938965,
-0.771809995174408,
0.4943220615386963,
0.21368706226348877,
-0.6088941097259521,
-0.09734418243169785,
-0.6614076495170593,
-0.744168221950531,
0.6705611944198608,
0.3672959506511688,
-0.5348843336105347,
0.15467993915081024,
0.04430493339896202,
0.22990481555461884,
-0.2159569263458252,
0.3019963502883911,
0.6929818391799927,
0.3604823052883148,
0.11075080931186676,
-0.6847068071365356,
0.29729533195495605,
0.004082918167114258,
-0.3927559554576874,
0.33568817377090454,
-0.16904734075069427,
0.6635226011276245,
-0.5656071305274963,
-0.1440565139055252,
-0.029163528233766556,
0.517524778842926,
0.3258012533187866,
0.06666924804449081,
0.704569399356842,
0.6044496893882751,
1.1306911706924438,
0.16867870092391968,
1.4711931943893433,
0.06155002489686012,
-0.25611138343811035,
1.3868000507354736,
-0.49733561277389526,
1.032755970954895,
0.6714648604393005,
-0.1997489482164383,
0.6312301158905029,
0.5244781374931335,
0.5820162892341614,
0.5377411246299744,
0.48206770420074463,
-0.5344265699386597,
-0.5038444995880127,
0.015666576102375984,
-0.5277222990989685,
0.497440904378891,
0.5038595199584961,
0.0216788612306118,
0.2113839089870453,
0.08471465110778809,
0.2573419511318207,
0.11145935207605362,
-0.42991992831230164,
0.8825395703315735,
0.1353410929441452,
-0.8840124607086182,
0.6332433223724365,
-0.615607738494873,
0.3020857274532318,
-0.5092751979827881,
0.22041381895542145,
0.08090252429246902,
0.13235220313072205,
-0.07770010828971863,
-0.9086052179336548,
0.3006438910961151,
0.08820748329162598,
0.013665493577718735,
-0.13951261341571808,
0.6256913542747498,
0.0508173406124115,
-0.4170599579811096,
0.5848602056503296,
0.5622037053108215,
-0.03567839786410332,
-0.08468689024448395,
-0.4781166613101959,
-0.160084530711174,
-0.3058498501777649,
-0.39917901158332825,
0.42424526810646057,
0.4314365088939667,
-0.2519684433937073,
0.7913364768028259,
0.8964126706123352,
0.07101669162511826,
0.3151710033416748,
-0.06096905842423439,
1.2999995946884155,
-0.3085767328739166,
-0.5329087376594543,
-1.2454224824905396,
0.25880318880081177,
-0.2901473939418793,
0.07291773706674576,
0.632197916507721,
0.1046672910451889,
0.7412768602371216,
0.17310196161270142,
0.6346697211265564,
0.15043431520462036,
0.21945378184318542,
-0.6391971111297607,
0.7118116617202759,
-0.3054996430873871,
0.6717237830162048,
-0.5487085580825806,
-0.7567400336265564,
-0.3562124967575073,
0.17473670840263367,
-0.649762749671936,
0.0063253180123865604,
1.0081312656402588,
0.650437593460083,
0.34179821610450745,
0.0807979553937912,
0.29213887453079224,
0.5316305756568909,
0.4488312900066376,
0.5591748952865601,
1.3997325897216797,
0.10392403602600098,
0.4403059780597687,
0.10333506762981415,
-0.439403235912323,
0.08369265496730804,
-0.9579941034317017,
-1.0220938920974731,
-0.25892001390457153,
0.0018834122456610203,
-0.5201873183250427,
0.0627710223197937,
0.76009202003479,
0.3943634629249573,
-0.8770498633384705,
0.04461138695478439,
-0.2665454149246216,
0.4432227611541748,
0.05567171052098274,
-0.14112728834152222,
0.2578151524066925,
-0.4993164539337158,
-0.0006886649061925709,
0.3569321930408478,
0.08165774494409561,
-0.034380920231342316,
-0.23254717886447906,
0.08596080541610718,
-0.5895859599113464,
0.7464025020599365,
0.4444179832935333,
0.0055914828553795815,
-0.8007068634033203,
-0.41122564673423767,
-0.0069755250588059425,
0.20694971084594727,
-0.08165841549634933,
1.0164333581924438,
-0.9973680377006531,
0.5070281028747559,
0.46581822633743286,
0.7164689898490906,
0.07879073917865753,
0.1362382024526596,
0.7621058225631714,
-0.6817234754562378,
0.43609654903411865,
0.44447061419487,
0.385891318321228,
-0.11906366050243378,
-0.6090917587280273,
-0.003265428589656949,
-0.1623890995979309,
-0.5508531928062439,
-0.9798948168754578,
0.7893487215042114,
-0.8291447162628174,
-0.6499707102775574,
0.8973748683929443,
-0.4738016128540039,
-0.25051364302635193,
-0.3474978506565094,
-0.23306205868721008,
-0.0171880554407835,
0.02285916730761528,
0.5518321990966797,
0.8548657298088074,
0.056552086025476456,
-0.02917175553739071,
-0.479548841714859,
0.28810688853263855,
0.4581412672996521,
-0.9740114212036133,
0.1384933590888977,
0.11797161400318146,
-0.03588316962122917,
0.06452689319849014,
0.8753604292869568,
-0.16742800176143646,
0.3387623727321625,
-0.1370813548564911,
-0.4644876718521118,
0.160431906580925,
-0.5749073028564453,
0.03676753491163254,
0.36650189757347107,
0.36568528413772583,
-0.1199289932847023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20900v1
|
Large Language Models: A New Approach for Privacy Policy Analysis at Scale
| 2024-05-31T15:12:33
| 2024-05-31T15:12:33
|
David Rodriguez, Ian Yang, Jose M. Del Alamo, Norman Sadeh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The number and dynamic nature of web and mobile applications presents
significant challenges for assessing their compliance with data protection
laws. In this context, symbolic and statistical Natural Language Processing
(NLP) techniques have been employed for the automated analysis of these
systems' privacy policies. However, these techniques typically require
labor-intensive and potentially error-prone manually annotated datasets for
training and validation. This research proposes the application of Large
Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative for effectively and efficiently
extracting privacy practices from privacy policies at scale. Particularly, we
leverage well-known LLMs such as ChatGPT and Llama 2, and offer guidance on the
optimal design of prompts, parameters, and models, incorporating advanced
strategies such as few-shot learning. We further illustrate its capability to
detect detailed and varied privacy practices accurately. Using several renowned
datasets in the domain as a benchmark, our evaluation validates its exceptional
performance, achieving an F1 score exceeding 93%. Besides, it does so with
reduced costs, faster processing times, and fewer technical knowledge
requirements. Consequently, we advocate for LLM-based solutions as a sound
alternative to traditional NLP techniques for the automated analysis of privacy
policies at scale.
|
[
-0.2800312936306,
-0.7747614979743958,
0.4275696873664856,
0.44922029972076416,
-0.11790668964385986,
0.05510479584336281,
-0.4523206651210785,
-0.5086251497268677,
-0.07145121693611145,
0.6227705478668213,
-0.47774338722229004,
-0.7351700067520142,
-0.43051624298095703,
0.024122700095176697,
-0.29242512583732605,
0.7245597839355469,
0.1705721914768219,
-0.06263263523578644,
0.08787310123443604,
0.1375049501657486,
-0.0478181466460228,
-0.4075470566749573,
-0.6054934859275818,
-0.25182878971099854,
0.4145946800708771,
0.26914137601852417,
0.7296571135520935,
0.7162317633628845,
0.7927181124687195,
0.2659567594528198,
-0.32679465413093567,
0.24242916703224182,
-0.3240708112716675,
-0.1445305198431015,
-0.14385251700878143,
-0.27379658818244934,
-0.4689778983592987,
0.03641299158334732,
0.8467641472816467,
0.5180007815361023,
-0.24178121984004974,
0.26851919293403625,
0.07582072913646698,
0.5137745141983032,
-0.6190831065177917,
0.26639524102211,
-0.6576164364814758,
0.15520115196704865,
0.022693825885653496,
-0.15089863538742065,
-0.4400424361228943,
-0.5566768646240234,
0.003194638295099139,
-0.16479861736297607,
-0.2910029888153076,
0.11218108236789703,
0.5876531004905701,
0.12650896608829498,
-0.47727856040000916,
-0.2822023928165436,
-0.6567223072052002,
0.9086769223213196,
-0.8102097511291504,
0.4291107952594757,
0.5951918363571167,
0.21355105936527252,
-0.47345229983329773,
-0.5160688161849976,
-0.5933341979980469,
-0.532966673374176,
-0.02778535895049572,
-0.5702635049819946,
-0.3401159644126892,
-0.03758001700043678,
0.49715107679367065,
0.18367457389831543,
-0.6822586059570312,
0.6510223746299744,
-0.17489762604236603,
-0.2573396563529968,
0.976935088634491,
0.23813177645206451,
0.11046765744686127,
-0.03569154068827629,
-0.06902754306793213,
0.04010572284460068,
-0.69418865442276,
0.13083641231060028,
0.33553454279899597,
0.2687467634677887,
-0.34207239747047424,
0.5380760431289673,
-0.4991401135921478,
0.6730063557624817,
-0.18541815876960754,
-0.6468717455863953,
0.2171047329902649,
-0.07729069888591766,
-0.20402106642723083,
-0.22430136799812317,
1.0859947204589844,
0.39031341671943665,
0.4588559567928314,
-0.19852393865585327,
0.0010235373629257083,
-0.22537215054035187,
0.011183172464370728,
-0.9154197573661804,
0.08678748458623886,
0.3330329358577728,
-0.6698606610298157,
-0.3788411021232605,
-0.16120965778827667,
-0.984645664691925,
-0.8621856570243835,
-0.3043508529663086,
-0.07740000635385513,
-0.07597256451845169,
-0.14524881541728973,
0.1975669264793396,
0.3804226517677307,
0.5673700571060181,
0.1468781977891922,
-0.9644454121589661,
0.4217061996459961,
0.9872037172317505,
0.9053113460540771,
-0.2868868410587311,
-0.09378402680158615,
-0.26589301228523254,
0.10711928457021713,
-0.3330145478248596,
0.3008783757686615,
-0.6922662854194641,
-0.5355229377746582,
0.19252333045005798,
-0.048630788922309875,
0.1619991958141327,
-0.5252702832221985,
0.3931210935115814,
-0.6731131076812744,
-0.15921714901924133,
0.01889609731733799,
-0.5141730308532715,
-0.13302363455295563,
0.5925142168998718,
-0.7290230989456177,
0.5518993139266968,
-0.14416325092315674,
-0.45715540647506714,
0.43567314743995667,
-0.9253990650177002,
-0.39627203345298767,
-0.0637340396642685,
-0.07762742042541504,
-0.4607140123844147,
-0.009609786793589592,
0.22592400014400482,
0.6934159398078918,
-0.4277445077896118,
0.23167936503887177,
-0.5493533611297607,
-0.029164142906665802,
0.48431649804115295,
-0.4637471139431,
0.8796023726463318,
0.5196073651313782,
-0.25969454646110535,
0.11126194149255753,
-0.9645929932594299,
0.2017735093832016,
0.0027612491976469755,
-0.3086041808128357,
-0.16227006912231445,
0.056432511657476425,
-0.07485615462064743,
0.07416253536939621,
0.5394288897514343,
-0.6053932905197144,
0.16618047654628754,
-0.19049286842346191,
0.5125253200531006,
0.6031119227409363,
0.16069121658802032,
0.5987228155136108,
-0.023449497297406197,
0.6534757018089294,
-0.5161110758781433,
0.47765854001045227,
-0.24425008893013,
-0.4068453311920166,
-0.12851987779140472,
-0.40952566266059875,
0.3320640027523041,
0.6314526200294495,
-0.08032714575529099,
0.4632258415222168,
-0.47426217794418335,
-0.5624434351921082,
-0.044233690947294235,
0.27732738852500916,
0.26878705620765686,
-0.000669640488922596,
-0.08333150297403336,
-0.09594926238059998,
-0.3336755335330963,
-0.8565290570259094,
-0.5389666557312012,
-0.1469440758228302,
-0.07531280815601349,
0.4179401397705078,
0.5820187926292419,
-0.3672449290752411,
1.007530927658081,
-0.5077342987060547,
-0.2533615231513977,
-0.02843465842306614,
-0.04426655173301697,
0.15597277879714966,
0.42291954159736633,
0.2338677942752838,
-0.8589738607406616,
-0.4485694468021393,
0.14917142689228058,
-0.8206984400749207,
-0.011577910743653774,
0.00732529629021883,
0.18994612991809845,
0.16704051196575165,
0.41246360540390015,
-0.5764603018760681,
0.1911730021238327,
0.5345523357391357,
-0.16148678958415985,
0.20631378889083862,
-0.1570584923028946,
-0.17521719634532928,
-0.7679325342178345,
-0.08744669705629349,
0.3254779577255249,
-0.5235259532928467,
-0.6583124995231628,
0.33803993463516235,
0.12741680443286896,
-0.3034024238586426,
-0.5188300609588623,
0.5314022898674011,
-0.36522549390792847,
-0.10166632384061813,
-0.3870699107646942,
-0.1830897480249405,
-0.32584699988365173,
0.27820706367492676,
0.002812247956171632,
0.715258002281189,
0.370086133480072,
-0.4830706715583801,
0.43418964743614197,
0.10476631671190262,
-0.31765878200531006,
0.43284904956817627,
-0.4021342694759369,
0.1767244189977646,
0.0672469213604927,
0.3595399260520935,
-0.74946129322052,
-0.5394549369812012,
0.1428362876176834,
-0.1147063747048378,
0.13912779092788696,
-0.15931904315948486,
-0.8443918228149414,
-0.361054003238678,
-0.5551490187644958,
0.0287304800003767,
0.5464661717414856,
-0.4372371733188629,
0.7310683131217957,
0.9806046485900879,
-0.21291133761405945,
-0.5184284448623657,
-0.6264042258262634,
0.3482334017753601,
-0.6300536394119263,
-0.54560786485672,
0.05889785289764404,
0.32492098212242126,
-0.508955717086792,
-0.32294052839279175,
0.08057551085948944,
-0.43808358907699585,
0.20069226622581482,
0.41519275307655334,
-0.014692029915750027,
0.08228416740894318,
-0.2497737854719162,
-0.2826063632965088,
-0.07564308494329453,
0.23549507558345795,
-0.12656107544898987,
0.6850280165672302,
-0.24951650202274323,
-0.08492796123027802,
-0.8750817179679871,
0.2066229283809662,
0.5466350317001343,
-0.2853703796863556,
0.6993474364280701,
0.4004402756690979,
-0.36581212282180786,
-0.17508307099342346,
-0.5396097302436829,
-0.07352522760629654,
-0.5260813236236572,
0.11008543521165848,
-0.14118839800357819,
-1.0285594463348389,
0.5182064771652222,
-0.3837541341781616,
0.3369789719581604,
-0.0134689100086689,
0.7571094632148743,
0.09514891356229782,
0.8224747180938721,
0.8851679563522339,
-0.3974258303642273,
0.5869086980819702,
-0.13524381816387177,
0.29999494552612305,
-0.4085499942302704,
-0.2568461000919342,
-0.4654821753501892,
-0.1423618495464325,
-1.0102734565734863,
-0.2906493544578552,
0.3622133731842041,
-0.28089046478271484,
-0.18546096980571747,
0.29745420813560486,
-0.17710721492767334,
0.7089855074882507,
0.18021751940250397,
0.11610491573810577,
0.37326598167419434,
0.1821165680885315,
0.561391294002533,
0.21040378510951996,
-0.2745833098888397,
-0.9652355313301086,
1.3872414827346802,
0.7545762658119202,
1.042401909828186,
0.2569676637649536,
0.7227467894554138,
0.38821136951446533,
0.31883785128593445,
-0.7464402318000793,
0.8417305946350098,
-0.2311158925294876,
-0.47873416543006897,
-0.6569963693618774,
-0.5054358243942261,
-0.986259937286377,
0.4818604588508606,
-0.1784217804670334,
-1.1810249090194702,
0.13175950944423676,
0.11355102062225342,
-0.4818105697631836,
0.15577100217342377,
-0.6336258053779602,
0.6976309418678284,
-0.16826681792736053,
-0.7036093473434448,
-0.19835731387138367,
-0.4614545702934265,
0.6288596987724304,
-0.48557162284851074,
0.4222692847251892,
-0.21443800628185272,
-0.1987539380788803,
0.5625991225242615,
-0.33771175146102905,
1.0232727527618408,
-0.20747005939483643,
-0.5156969428062439,
0.2541493773460388,
-0.05531258136034012,
0.820825457572937,
-0.003978865686804056,
-0.10870525240898132,
0.24461771547794342,
0.12919098138809204,
0.04854084178805351,
-0.295044481754303,
0.7923725247383118,
-0.3528202176094055,
-0.3311665654182434,
-0.3108765780925751,
-0.618614673614502,
-0.46825745701789856,
0.20909368991851807,
-0.2380462884902954,
-0.12297572940587997,
-0.27993184328079224,
0.44840335845947266,
0.7422894239425659,
-0.4104078710079193,
0.5305453538894653,
0.7174657583236694,
-0.4557018280029297,
-0.023939570412039757,
0.6574922204017639,
0.1480136215686798,
-0.09507828950881958,
0.2971048057079315,
0.48107990622520447,
-0.6707901358604431,
-0.5314548015594482,
-0.1080683022737503,
0.30313771963119507,
-0.4598023593425751,
-0.10640037059783936,
-0.6132367253303528,
0.01713954657316208,
-0.40825989842414856,
0.1845386028289795,
-0.11266709119081497,
-0.38377103209495544,
-0.015048298984766006,
0.055454857647418976,
0.5054570436477661,
0.2812061607837677,
-0.1571027785539627,
0.611953616142273,
-0.592002272605896,
0.5612327456474304,
0.15970474481582642,
0.3587336242198944,
-0.09418980032205582,
-0.25396546721458435,
0.07377368956804276,
-0.07459194213151932,
-0.16096025705337524,
-0.6147896647453308,
0.3322513699531555,
0.22590231895446777,
0.23258204758167267,
0.4430779814720154,
-0.14045783877372742,
0.46504414081573486,
-0.7377485632896423,
0.6785815954208374,
0.06380584090948105,
-0.68281489610672,
0.2496175318956375,
-0.43704351782798767,
-0.13497991859912872,
0.5071061253547668,
0.38189029693603516,
-0.3347267210483551,
-0.07293181866407394,
-0.5486366152763367,
-0.7110984921455383,
0.4606385827064514,
-0.0013137308415025473,
0.5913538932800293,
0.3152267038822174,
0.3492580056190491,
-0.12320499122142792,
0.41234150528907776,
-0.7401842474937439,
0.10614154487848282,
0.5365367531776428,
-0.14141187071800232,
0.12464680522680283,
-0.3034168481826782,
-0.14396882057189941,
0.028155477717518806,
0.43629956245422363,
0.027751527726650238,
-0.07181987166404724,
-0.4789678752422333,
0.04841769486665726,
0.1433434635400772,
0.39343613386154175,
0.5102822184562683,
0.8753859996795654,
-0.022533878684043884,
-0.08422107249498367,
0.19875577092170715,
-0.5466881394386292,
0.20999591052532196,
0.049481350928545,
-0.32257169485092163,
-0.08194494992494583,
0.08720572292804718,
0.2630435824394226,
0.007430866826325655,
-0.8785109519958496,
0.6258967518806458,
0.1036204919219017,
-0.04974113032221794,
-0.6392389535903931,
0.23715969920158386,
-0.103425994515419,
0.3542540371417999,
0.07392138987779617,
-0.7322437167167664,
0.21691486239433289,
-0.5449039936065674,
0.30159658193588257,
0.7193708419799805,
-0.011418025009334087,
0.08429726958274841,
0.5280226469039917,
0.1278284192085266,
-0.5010517239570618,
0.24350613355636597,
-0.1796008199453354,
-0.05682778358459473,
0.4705623686313629,
0.3784361183643341,
0.6606784462928772,
-0.3153303861618042,
0.29385846853256226,
0.042864881455898285,
0.3867083787918091,
-0.410124808549881,
0.3644987940788269,
-0.014979608356952667,
-0.5992318987846375,
-0.5798892974853516,
-0.4911125898361206,
-0.5302245020866394,
0.4449783265590668,
-0.6523623466491699,
0.06426011770963669,
-1.0186139345169067,
-0.31324830651283264,
0.1638277918100357,
-0.057994987815618515,
-0.5391203761100769,
-0.023443827405571938,
0.16020414233207703,
0.8391485214233398,
-0.741154670715332,
0.7514010071754456,
0.33809787034988403,
-0.06678445637226105,
-0.7181962728500366,
0.018025420606136322,
0.3169211745262146,
-0.8522657155990601,
0.509300708770752,
0.11132298409938812,
-0.04847750440239906,
-0.21465377509593964,
-0.7060524821281433,
-0.6156231164932251,
0.6658865809440613,
0.3817012310028076,
-1.029110312461853,
0.15377983450889587,
0.5715991258621216,
0.6631121039390564,
-0.24969808757305145,
-0.21170754730701447,
0.944048285484314,
0.5355791449546814,
-0.20573587715625763,
-1.0615496635437012,
0.028771961107850075,
0.24627149105072021,
0.06432237476110458,
0.17307379841804504,
-0.6056270003318787,
0.6191112399101257,
-0.012711386196315289,
0.03864631801843643,
0.006908584851771593,
0.5047724843025208,
0.3016342222690582,
0.45354709029197693,
0.4728129506111145,
0.2662276327610016,
0.9262078404426575,
0.32447782158851624,
1.1022024154663086,
-0.30786725878715515,
0.44602125883102417,
1.0171124935150146,
-0.7397009134292603,
0.9898557066917419,
0.45839789509773254,
-0.38425925374031067,
0.20922881364822388,
0.5820757150650024,
-0.1584533154964447,
0.3059927523136139,
0.5573005676269531,
-0.3319726884365082,
-0.045781806111335754,
-0.23278093338012695,
0.008422551676630974,
0.5912954211235046,
0.29387444257736206,
-0.5001610517501831,
-0.36772623658180237,
0.13948459923267365,
0.3504439890384674,
0.13811953365802765,
-0.554568350315094,
0.827034592628479,
0.2617557644844055,
-0.24625258147716522,
0.49840447306632996,
0.3440595865249634,
0.5737495422363281,
-0.6014617085456848,
0.027409670874476433,
0.1199682205915451,
0.2100783735513687,
-0.32761847972869873,
-0.7761037945747375,
0.14204354584217072,
0.6377253532409668,
0.0746777355670929,
-0.34304115176200867,
0.5096914768218994,
-0.12249672412872314,
-0.4682621955871582,
-0.03177717700600624,
0.150146484375,
0.423484742641449,
-0.17285291850566864,
-0.8272323608398438,
0.24690108001232147,
-0.048401378095149994,
-0.39944541454315186,
0.44486507773399353,
0.2640836834907532,
-0.3999328315258026,
0.7459267377853394,
0.8374616503715515,
0.11532943695783615,
0.14451493322849274,
0.06818217039108276,
0.7117959856987,
-0.5040923357009888,
-0.7938098907470703,
-1.2164080142974854,
0.0974782183766365,
-0.36356592178344727,
-0.0636654794216156,
0.8477147221565247,
0.6070762276649475,
0.5274652242660522,
0.2537280023097992,
0.7087686657905579,
0.11111655831336975,
0.5736095905303955,
-0.7293795347213745,
0.4465780258178711,
-0.16029612720012665,
0.5775899887084961,
-0.014010055921971798,
-0.9585678577423096,
-0.5927116870880127,
0.8554407954216003,
-0.6145148277282715,
-0.1293274611234665,
0.2802388072013855,
1.0962797403335571,
-0.028064729645848274,
0.15862838923931122,
0.2137141227722168,
0.015581910498440266,
0.5465021133422852,
0.30135151743888855,
0.7077549695968628,
0.02305922470986843,
0.3021145164966583,
-0.13199175894260406,
-0.2777683138847351,
-0.1810527741909027,
-1.119517207145691,
-0.9449842572212219,
-0.037180136889219284,
-0.23814983665943146,
-0.26015618443489075,
-0.19566753506660461,
0.9419905543327332,
0.7475283145904541,
-0.5991575717926025,
-0.39110103249549866,
0.04878615215420723,
-0.06577693670988083,
0.049579787999391556,
-0.16457226872444153,
0.304540753364563,
-0.11973682790994644,
-0.5602977871894836,
0.35876137018203735,
0.18143290281295776,
-0.08607082813978195,
-0.5098119378089905,
0.10201815515756607,
0.07797598838806152,
0.02367941476404667,
0.730072021484375,
0.5372593998908997,
-0.6233559846878052,
-0.057785142213106155,
-0.3580542802810669,
-0.10726423561573029,
-0.10856456309556961,
0.9279177784919739,
-0.29013967514038086,
0.12318355590105057,
0.3168635964393616,
0.883238673210144,
0.4535941183567047,
0.08491657674312592,
0.22879096865653992,
-0.5140968561172485,
0.3246787190437317,
0.20705118775367737,
0.22727084159851074,
0.17360153794288635,
-0.3967120945453644,
0.6405678987503052,
-0.466696560382843,
-0.4796372056007385,
-1.0892517566680908,
0.3504277169704437,
-0.8639287948608398,
-0.3223842680454254,
1.6314836740493774,
-0.2686415910720825,
-0.4248490035533905,
-0.14798985421657562,
-0.06250149011611938,
-0.3925970494747162,
-0.45848438143730164,
0.8513410687446594,
0.5353031158447266,
-0.042250994592905045,
-0.19880223274230957,
-0.7139872908592224,
0.48162922263145447,
-0.20776745676994324,
-0.9448604583740234,
0.43516284227371216,
0.55820631980896,
0.30353105068206787,
0.10947099328041077,
0.6032090783119202,
-0.3484284579753876,
-0.10482637584209442,
-0.4187849462032318,
-0.21692268550395966,
0.07799679785966873,
-0.30648231506347656,
-0.7014607191085815,
0.29314306378364563,
0.11558542400598526,
-0.2474435418844223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20895v1
|
A comparison of correspondence analysis with PMI-based word embedding methods
| 2024-05-31T15:04:15
| 2024-05-31T15:04:15
|
Qianqian Qi, David J. Hessen, Peter G. M. van der Heijden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Popular word embedding methods such as GloVe and Word2Vec are related to the
factorization of the pointwise mutual information (PMI) matrix. In this paper,
we link correspondence analysis (CA) to the factorization of the PMI matrix. CA
is a dimensionality reduction method that uses singular value decomposition
(SVD), and we show that CA is mathematically close to the weighted
factorization of the PMI matrix. In addition, we present variants of CA that
turn out to be successful in the factorization of the word-context matrix, i.e.
CA applied to a matrix where the entries undergo a square-root transformation
(ROOT-CA) and a root-root transformation (ROOTROOT-CA). An empirical comparison
among CA- and PMI-based methods shows that overall results of ROOT-CA and
ROOTROOT-CA are slightly better than those of the PMI-based methods.
|
[
-0.21657946705818176,
-0.4208762049674988,
0.6063156127929688,
0.1676044762134552,
-0.2620883882045746,
-0.05817561596632004,
0.16963277757167816,
-0.15593524277210236,
0.5389513373374939,
-0.03732484206557274,
-0.6152973771095276,
-0.7274755239486694,
-0.5243706107139587,
-0.03201037645339966,
0.18938392400741577,
0.09531961381435394,
-0.23716923594474792,
0.6589199304580688,
-0.6168332099914551,
-0.421426385641098,
-0.6072576642036438,
-0.7184076905250549,
-0.27627071738243103,
-0.26441359519958496,
0.37195849418640137,
0.17321577668190002,
0.5840337872505188,
0.618349015712738,
1.0198900699615479,
0.31246417760849,
0.2603677213191986,
-0.07850509136915207,
-0.3424607515335083,
-0.09627147018909454,
-0.22573132812976837,
-0.5852066874504089,
-0.37614065408706665,
0.6076862812042236,
0.57345050573349,
0.8693041205406189,
0.012278683483600616,
0.10271286964416504,
-0.19307926297187805,
0.5880687832832336,
-1.2354507446289062,
0.43298739194869995,
-0.27566802501678467,
0.4125787913799286,
-0.11600226908922195,
-0.4676118791103363,
-0.28928232192993164,
-0.4054611921310425,
0.011325836181640625,
-0.6155329942703247,
0.1576717644929886,
0.2374783605337143,
0.614502489566803,
0.2307431399822235,
-0.26327598094940186,
-0.41609376668930054,
-0.9320154786109924,
0.9933001399040222,
-0.6086193323135376,
0.5536819100379944,
0.5697705745697021,
0.2561386227607727,
-0.10710274428129196,
-0.06864350289106369,
-0.9902691841125488,
0.06286385655403137,
-0.036695320159196854,
0.4833954870700836,
-0.19819313287734985,
0.08227971941232681,
0.3753162622451782,
0.49100062251091003,
-0.3369815945625305,
0.010111071169376373,
-0.147406667470932,
-0.1442674845457077,
0.5036312937736511,
0.18073730170726776,
0.3397803008556366,
-0.2959176003932953,
-0.4449935257434845,
-0.5608918070793152,
-0.968398928642273,
-0.01662074588239193,
0.3655993938446045,
0.007432846352458,
0.0875849574804306,
0.954524576663971,
0.18492044508457184,
0.5741219520568848,
0.10616906732320786,
-0.5116441249847412,
0.07655123621225357,
-0.5345954298973083,
-0.19842317700386047,
-0.14014841616153717,
0.6980783343315125,
0.8736530542373657,
-0.00035202366416342556,
-0.29608920216560364,
0.07756368070840836,
0.5000614523887634,
-0.10540715605020523,
-0.6096538305282593,
-0.15578636527061462,
-0.06103390455245972,
-0.7377215027809143,
-0.06650027632713318,
0.662663996219635,
-0.3587177097797394,
-0.24371570348739624,
-0.5034788846969604,
0.5644062161445618,
-0.27857497334480286,
-0.04768075421452522,
-0.08634186536073685,
-0.2694036364555359,
0.952617883682251,
0.1702733337879181,
-0.554463267326355,
0.37316495180130005,
1.0539886951446533,
1.0374246835708618,
-0.2193901240825653,
0.15951718389987946,
-0.6447241902351379,
0.14553631842136383,
-0.5389466881752014,
0.793200671672821,
-0.8969431519508362,
-0.6984289884567261,
0.26907041668891907,
-0.20825664699077606,
-0.44837984442710876,
-0.6050995588302612,
0.16337665915489197,
-0.2253400832414627,
0.2824918031692505,
-0.8554825782775879,
-0.5612822771072388,
-0.17677584290504456,
0.1167600229382515,
-0.5197681188583374,
1.0484797954559326,
0.20635110139846802,
-1.176809310913086,
0.5646204352378845,
-0.4321666657924652,
-0.26216819882392883,
-0.3380618691444397,
-0.1474137306213379,
-0.26204127073287964,
0.18608488142490387,
0.025075433775782585,
0.7907567620277405,
-0.33955103158950806,
-0.2783830761909485,
-0.697721004486084,
-0.44530850648880005,
0.3464970886707306,
0.2624439299106598,
0.34303224086761475,
0.09612368792295456,
-0.18869389593601227,
-0.029632993042469025,
-0.8558528423309326,
-0.29352888464927673,
0.029210921376943588,
0.16816741228103638,
-0.9538211226463318,
0.39363163709640503,
-0.27668699622154236,
0.38798296451568604,
0.2803829312324524,
-0.9746388792991638,
0.22042304277420044,
-0.252930611371994,
0.31289947032928467,
0.6626927852630615,
0.028573738411068916,
0.586105465888977,
-0.3018900156021118,
0.4658079147338867,
0.3637596070766449,
0.10580994933843613,
0.19203388690948486,
-0.3711198568344116,
-0.8914856314659119,
-0.05953105166554451,
0.2921556234359741,
0.7871204018592834,
-0.9430674910545349,
0.6010378003120422,
-0.4959613084793091,
-0.5331725478172302,
-0.6389907598495483,
-0.35527747869491577,
0.4528365433216095,
0.13958247005939484,
0.29961949586868286,
-0.6073023080825806,
-0.2631474435329437,
-0.9725858569145203,
0.12098214775323868,
-0.3673533499240875,
-0.3518359661102295,
0.5443466901779175,
0.21101169288158417,
-0.11409921944141388,
0.9932814836502075,
-0.8167566657066345,
-0.5059871673583984,
0.12201447039842606,
0.04970712214708328,
-0.05404139310121536,
0.5957947373390198,
0.6377202272415161,
-0.4443017840385437,
-0.573161780834198,
-0.06112716346979141,
-0.5370074510574341,
-0.07639194279909134,
0.01762983575463295,
-0.01093833427876234,
-0.2525560259819031,
0.596002459526062,
-0.14648744463920593,
0.6727021336555481,
0.6098646521568298,
-0.4997628927230835,
0.12179065495729446,
-0.2878935635089874,
0.3682520389556885,
-1.5116890668869019,
0.33368778228759766,
0.23236773908138275,
-0.13162247836589813,
-0.5648532509803772,
0.08843575417995453,
0.07512636482715607,
-0.22033020853996277,
-0.13849462568759918,
-0.13674278557300568,
-0.7148051261901855,
-0.4367907643318176,
-0.03232911601662636,
0.2756477892398834,
-0.38014599680900574,
0.3751731812953949,
-0.26642775535583496,
0.9808019399642944,
0.34706833958625793,
-0.40390101075172424,
0.13778409361839294,
0.5324437022209167,
0.00477620167657733,
0.7876803874969482,
-0.7195496559143066,
0.32943451404571533,
-0.180028036236763,
0.0428890697658062,
-1.1425403356552124,
0.5102623105049133,
0.5144689679145813,
-0.3283903896808624,
0.4509854018688202,
0.15671230852603912,
-0.5002137422561646,
-0.0798964649438858,
-0.9319837689399719,
0.6044036149978638,
0.3425045609474182,
-0.5716031789779663,
0.5134682059288025,
0.46507528424263,
-0.03865000233054161,
-0.34520480036735535,
-0.3643096387386322,
-0.14152784645557404,
-0.0782245397567749,
-0.5606918931007385,
0.6276509165763855,
-0.4287593364715576,
-0.4586314260959625,
0.11962215602397919,
-0.10909296572208405,
0.0057619852013885975,
-0.11697129160165787,
0.6140700578689575,
0.23918531835079193,
-0.25815442204475403,
-0.26920750737190247,
0.04578560218214989,
-0.3639107942581177,
0.05300420895218849,
0.22508342564105988,
0.3581179976463318,
0.31659501791000366,
-0.46648216247558594,
-0.5852676033973694,
0.6835983991622925,
0.5527626872062683,
-0.325021356344223,
0.8608437180519104,
0.5163642168045044,
-0.410453736782074,
0.19149082899093628,
-0.7403587698936462,
0.07001204043626785,
-0.3859855532646179,
-0.24046780169010162,
-0.6189308762550354,
-0.8337441682815552,
0.4614608883857727,
-0.27595949172973633,
-0.05826862156391144,
0.5413587093353271,
0.23738358914852142,
0.17067629098892212,
0.8972623348236084,
1.0907584428787231,
-0.2917902171611786,
0.47910717129707336,
-0.23277589678764343,
0.38601577281951904,
-1.2527992725372314,
-0.3526064455509186,
-0.8167127966880798,
-0.30795544385910034,
-0.48798465728759766,
-0.9035308957099915,
0.12638509273529053,
0.1561972200870514,
0.29196497797966003,
0.7202147841453552,
-0.31571879982948303,
0.31450188159942627,
0.4756642282009125,
-0.13101863861083984,
0.08631593734025955,
-0.1570282280445099,
-0.3907826244831085,
-0.48835277557373047,
-0.6823468804359436,
-0.0650983601808548,
0.943169116973877,
0.384966105222702,
0.5184913873672485,
0.2957613170146942,
0.4860713481903076,
0.080568827688694,
0.3514547646045685,
-1.0300812721252441,
0.5287538170814514,
-0.1531166136264801,
0.4345335066318512,
0.08753360062837601,
-0.2748872935771942,
-0.7443155646324158,
0.43688786029815674,
-0.7853673100471497,
-0.6472902894020081,
0.78995680809021,
-0.37650027871131897,
-0.04127974435687065,
0.2605772912502289,
-0.6424170732498169,
0.29832014441490173,
0.7468143701553345,
0.029233524575829506,
-0.5794358849525452,
-0.22075627744197845,
0.14689986407756805,
0.121980220079422,
0.10100048780441284,
-0.020548759028315544,
-0.10764423757791519,
1.1115137338638306,
-0.7880365252494812,
0.596183180809021,
-0.20876513421535492,
-0.25094664096832275,
-0.03025529719889164,
0.17737184464931488,
0.447307825088501,
-0.15090972185134888,
-0.02706528827548027,
0.21142925322055817,
0.24704553186893463,
-0.3209972083568573,
-0.8957033753395081,
0.883868396282196,
-0.7355242967605591,
-0.6180630326271057,
-0.5377446413040161,
-0.21879322826862335,
-0.30967414379119873,
-0.22006776928901672,
-0.017828112468123436,
0.5306742787361145,
-0.2736634314060211,
0.20233167707920074,
0.33374229073524475,
-0.06739316880702972,
0.5531615018844604,
0.49515360593795776,
0.3562890291213989,
-0.5742071866989136,
0.725607693195343,
0.2710627615451813,
-0.10948129743337631,
0.8033193349838257,
0.19915318489074707,
-0.019574832171201706,
-0.4099787771701813,
0.1779247522354126,
0.701423168182373,
-0.5082499980926514,
-0.21823003888130188,
-0.3733269274234772,
-0.048631176352500916,
-0.45486775040626526,
-0.3188565671443939,
-0.24207688868045807,
-0.2537497878074646,
-0.12971672415733337,
0.05339351296424866,
-0.24422822892665863,
0.8028360605239868,
-0.12192904949188232,
0.1011226698756218,
-0.5488410592079163,
0.02167348749935627,
0.3700069785118103,
0.14631867408752441,
-0.21586883068084717,
0.03295167535543442,
-0.025600159540772438,
-0.15719962120056152,
-0.17970284819602966,
-1.2583931684494019,
0.048917241394519806,
0.21747994422912598,
0.3864499032497406,
0.8078821897506714,
0.1624443233013153,
0.9992750287055969,
-0.6021763682365417,
0.7867096662521362,
0.5226250886917114,
-1.081099510192871,
0.41150346398353577,
-0.004303628578782082,
-0.16604846715927124,
0.2571271061897278,
0.5912063717842102,
-0.7051970362663269,
0.03945101425051689,
-0.6333803534507751,
-0.5107706189155579,
0.30545029044151306,
0.3145322799682617,
-0.39451247453689575,
-0.16322247684001923,
0.5084690451622009,
-0.03324873372912407,
-0.05009141564369202,
-0.022552339360117912,
-0.38332056999206543,
0.09070530533790588,
-0.12620197236537933,
-0.27165672183036804,
-0.5892671346664429,
-0.06518642604351044,
-0.25399017333984375,
0.47913801670074463,
-0.23098161816596985,
0.7923516035079956,
0.48834294080734253,
-0.11587236076593399,
-0.20845431089401245,
-0.04309283569455147,
0.5183080434799194,
0.7529693245887756,
-0.04885636642575264,
0.11248621344566345,
0.25429442524909973,
-0.36859509348869324,
-0.09945046901702881,
-0.23265358805656433,
0.011719710193574429,
-0.052481263875961304,
0.5821786522865295,
0.5898975729942322,
0.4067239463329315,
-0.014306338503956795,
1.0759931802749634,
-0.09583234041929245,
-0.2919764220714569,
-0.21088002622127533,
-0.06245189532637596,
-0.12815745174884796,
0.1686621457338333,
0.09375638514757156,
-0.17833642661571503,
0.20476067066192627,
-0.5290274620056152,
-0.08337067067623138,
0.8559859991073608,
-0.5956566333770752,
-0.6370453238487244,
0.24813033640384674,
0.12918443977832794,
-0.35040074586868286,
0.4214315712451935,
0.11218532174825668,
-0.3399939239025116,
0.18673601746559143,
0.5373800992965698,
0.7717407941818237,
-0.5368168354034424,
0.3178199529647827,
0.7391724586486816,
0.13892872631549835,
0.29248782992362976,
0.15253469347953796,
-0.42133092880249023,
-0.6899359226226807,
-0.43992936611175537,
-0.48881563544273376,
-0.44825324416160583,
-0.22564442455768585,
-0.9685681462287903,
-0.05646950751543045,
-0.6302555203437805,
-0.022964399307966232,
0.01507805660367012,
0.1765410304069519,
-0.8059046864509583,
-0.14713017642498016,
-0.38123711943626404,
0.720134437084198,
-1.1699777841567993,
0.725253701210022,
0.7285438776016235,
-0.14329794049263,
-0.7483429312705994,
0.09366010874509811,
-0.12053892761468887,
-0.698438286781311,
0.5841034650802612,
0.15628187358379364,
-0.0023388720583170652,
-0.223964124917984,
-0.26787069439888,
-0.8656468987464905,
1.6376978158950806,
-0.037328705191612244,
-0.47655269503593445,
0.3218560814857483,
0.2343004196882248,
0.2970293164253235,
-0.3143739104270935,
0.22168897092342377,
0.47581109404563904,
0.3944528102874756,
0.2181534320116043,
-0.82920241355896,
0.32734718918800354,
-0.2409638613462448,
0.4910895824432373,
0.3316420912742615,
-0.5286655426025391,
0.6128312945365906,
0.11927474290132523,
-0.802111804485321,
0.0058345794677734375,
0.8024581074714661,
-0.25168362259864807,
0.26995277404785156,
0.638748824596405,
0.6480814218521118,
0.4716194272041321,
-0.14022581279277802,
0.7620209455490112,
-0.37133410573005676,
0.5032079815864563,
0.46375471353530884,
-0.2613814175128937,
1.2308331727981567,
0.6816396117210388,
-0.6604753732681274,
0.48528218269348145,
0.3598363995552063,
-0.13179445266723633,
0.23807932436466217,
0.2227361798286438,
-0.11779823154211044,
-0.16277262568473816,
-0.12172475457191467,
-0.311572790145874,
0.2622464597225189,
0.1506541520357132,
0.16366486251354218,
-0.24234582483768463,
-0.008945483714342117,
-0.019098101183772087,
0.28180640935897827,
-0.14896205067634583,
1.1567256450653076,
0.1438274383544922,
-0.33365821838378906,
0.1920545995235443,
0.41215649247169495,
0.7518590092658997,
-0.42142045497894287,
-0.2756331264972687,
-0.11754905432462692,
0.03922691196203232,
-0.1037309393286705,
-0.37859785556793213,
0.3570921719074249,
-0.5559735298156738,
-0.19133606553077698,
0.08738872408866882,
0.7168703675270081,
-0.4484444856643677,
-0.19521179795265198,
0.3349558711051941,
0.46847015619277954,
-0.06881982088088989,
0.029947765171527863,
-0.5568309426307678,
-0.0930655375123024,
-0.40902870893478394,
0.15686050057411194,
0.44345203042030334,
0.01834183931350708,
0.05292821675539017,
0.6086893677711487,
0.8365352749824524,
0.11358893662691116,
-0.2119758129119873,
-0.28907302021980286,
0.8053714632987976,
-0.6935744285583496,
-0.5571088790893555,
-0.6058777570724487,
-0.018365528434515,
-0.10946199297904968,
-0.09691306948661804,
0.9702946543693542,
0.5204693078994751,
0.486875981092453,
-0.278511106967926,
0.2816706895828247,
0.06289365142583847,
0.21426258981227875,
-0.6331432461738586,
0.4222257435321808,
-0.28986549377441406,
-0.08992718905210495,
-0.7347016930580139,
-1.5009286403656006,
-0.5124933123588562,
0.9108725190162659,
-0.3096345365047455,
-0.2773924767971039,
1.210561752319336,
0.9391697645187378,
-0.09418454766273499,
-0.2886946201324463,
0.5065925121307373,
-0.08895894140005112,
0.31388139724731445,
0.3718557357788086,
0.352798730134964,
-0.6134312152862549,
-0.09280680865049362,
-0.23244333267211914,
-0.5685469508171082,
-0.006276844069361687,
-0.7186132669448853,
-1.0256669521331787,
-1.1996707916259766,
-0.6113662123680115,
-0.21946871280670166,
-0.059941671788692474,
0.6817025542259216,
0.6311246752738953,
-0.7482234835624695,
0.10818616300821304,
0.11124826967716217,
-0.08263002336025238,
-0.2114713042974472,
-0.19750897586345673,
0.813759982585907,
0.10932780802249908,
-0.697396457195282,
0.5037450790405273,
0.5715667009353638,
0.04319612681865692,
-0.46287450194358826,
0.03781789168715477,
-0.0483635850250721,
0.36493244767189026,
0.7674631476402283,
0.05919933319091797,
-0.452976793050766,
-0.7385048866271973,
-0.09029529988765717,
0.007719516288489103,
0.09367642551660538,
1.4099211692810059,
-0.5028669238090515,
0.3793213665485382,
0.8445311188697815,
0.5233129858970642,
0.18426072597503662,
0.16403503715991974,
0.6266372799873352,
-0.5664727091789246,
0.14998389780521393,
-0.3370618224143982,
0.4416102468967438,
0.29174500703811646,
-0.2725115716457367,
0.46473920345306396,
0.5780450701713562,
-0.26451772451400757,
-0.1835644543170929,
0.35358309745788574,
-1.561980962753296,
-0.17946715652942657,
1.333640694618225,
-0.3006569445133209,
-0.42857325077056885,
0.0222579687833786,
-0.29628247022628784,
0.1576341986656189,
0.04926289990544319,
0.47925323247909546,
0.7563275098800659,
0.33007100224494934,
0.07144970446825027,
0.08572469651699066,
0.3273969292640686,
0.2414880096912384,
-0.4639919102191925,
-0.2610248923301697,
0.3107917308807373,
0.4304583668708801,
0.48863914608955383,
0.610389232635498,
-0.33031758666038513,
-0.0366348959505558,
0.1074334979057312,
-0.009726271964609623,
-0.12080353498458862,
-0.06832139939069748,
-0.22234098613262177,
0.15795397758483887,
-0.03859575092792511,
-0.5132502317428589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20859v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20859v1
|
clembench-2024: A Challenging, Dynamic, Complementary, Multilingual Benchmark and Underlying Flexible Framework for LLMs as Multi-Action Agents
| 2024-05-31T14:43:31
| 2024-05-31T14:43:31
|
Anne Beyer, Kranti Chalamalasetti, Sherzod Hakimov, Brielen Madureira, Philipp Sadler, David Schlangen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
It has been established in recent work that Large Language Models (LLMs) can
be prompted to "self-play" conversational games that probe certain capabilities
(general instruction following, strategic goal orientation, language
understanding abilities), where the resulting interactive game play can be
automatically scored. In this paper, we take one of the proposed frameworks for
setting up such game-play environments, and further test its usefulness as an
evaluation instrument, along a number of dimensions: We show that it can easily
keep up with new developments while avoiding data contamination, we show that
the tests implemented within it are not yet saturated (human performance is
substantially higher than that of even the best models), and we show that it
lends itself to investigating additional questions, such as the impact of the
prompting language on performance. We believe that the approach forms a good
basis for making decisions on model choice for building applied interactive
systems, and perhaps ultimately setting up a closed-loop development
environment of system and simulated evaluator.
|
[
-0.6674231886863708,
-0.8171889781951904,
0.531213641166687,
0.39092162251472473,
-0.11851943284273148,
0.025412922725081444,
-0.3145250976085663,
-0.3443644642829895,
-0.11025913059711456,
0.45013853907585144,
-0.7249699234962463,
-0.5041652321815491,
-0.19966717064380646,
0.17049045860767365,
-0.23690682649612427,
0.4329696297645569,
-0.2648316025733948,
0.07625977694988251,
-0.34419187903404236,
-0.5694374442100525,
-0.7861020565032959,
-0.5442488789558411,
-0.43393683433532715,
-0.5122464895248413,
0.30249738693237305,
0.46906778216362,
0.6045774221420288,
0.5434604287147522,
0.4481905400753021,
0.5139146447181702,
0.30270206928253174,
-0.1494932770729065,
-0.3716138005256653,
0.5731138586997986,
-0.47048062086105347,
-0.3763667941093445,
-0.46516987681388855,
-0.058538131415843964,
0.5989323854446411,
0.4373743534088135,
-0.28888294100761414,
0.4264293909072876,
0.1852591633796692,
0.20641861855983734,
-0.42473652958869934,
0.28014156222343445,
-0.2931182384490967,
-0.02181985415518284,
0.11938920617103577,
0.09522029757499695,
-0.29044485092163086,
-0.04963734373450279,
-0.042392533272504807,
-0.4760799705982208,
-0.31510594487190247,
0.023297281935811043,
0.603073239326477,
0.1081044152379036,
-0.4905741512775421,
-0.5009848475456238,
-0.5745176076889038,
0.7955225706100464,
-0.7281744480133057,
0.33104148507118225,
-0.282657265663147,
0.48351770639419556,
-0.22906306385993958,
-0.5789436101913452,
-0.4705519378185272,
-0.37109383940696716,
0.17849376797676086,
0.23423545062541962,
-0.113579161465168,
0.13796861469745636,
0.3436628580093384,
-0.03156868740916252,
-0.5600408911705017,
0.20868757367134094,
-0.2279541790485382,
-0.1564110517501831,
0.6110235452651978,
0.4974900186061859,
0.07445306330919266,
0.20183517038822174,
-0.6855936050415039,
-0.05188091844320297,
-0.5805696249008179,
0.2744244933128357,
0.4089395999908447,
0.21270105242729187,
-0.16996608674526215,
0.4097335636615753,
-0.10685068368911743,
0.5994462966918945,
-0.03703611344099045,
-0.027939775958657265,
0.21051445603370667,
-0.2769194543361664,
0.0449979268014431,
-0.1841396540403366,
0.7897752523422241,
0.5854213237762451,
0.16445136070251465,
0.0985141471028328,
-0.3465014100074768,
0.26774460077285767,
0.232626274228096,
-0.8422090411186218,
-0.0775175392627716,
0.47596800327301025,
-0.2580597400665283,
-0.13835279643535614,
-0.10707605630159378,
-1.058711290359497,
-0.38271838426589966,
-0.4160067141056061,
0.42441901564598083,
-0.3054746985435486,
-0.2071279138326645,
0.11007040739059448,
0.038713131099939346,
0.3365817964076996,
0.17278839647769928,
-0.5108319520950317,
0.4972555935382843,
0.46327680349349976,
0.6571177244186401,
-0.6414154767990112,
-0.4641064405441284,
-0.4843994081020355,
-0.02456565573811531,
-0.28678977489471436,
0.8373768925666809,
-0.5847794413566589,
-0.707023561000824,
0.13378609716892242,
-0.06694377958774567,
0.10562484711408615,
-0.6206340193748474,
0.43129613995552063,
-0.4488864243030548,
0.10017651319503784,
-0.23292842507362366,
-0.5787876844406128,
-0.151630237698555,
0.7002075910568237,
-0.7558892965316772,
0.9983034729957581,
0.0067626796662807465,
-0.19923248887062073,
0.31952032446861267,
-1.027106761932373,
-0.2565533518791199,
0.258166640996933,
-0.2475026249885559,
-0.22131145000457764,
-0.08508908748626709,
-0.11106832325458527,
0.10963929444551468,
-0.28638389706611633,
0.38118961453437805,
-0.6473248600959778,
-0.5155619978904724,
0.24286246299743652,
-0.5071107149124146,
0.45698583126068115,
0.14297032356262207,
-0.6872274279594421,
0.3128257989883423,
-0.7463048696517944,
0.4921453893184662,
0.2033890336751938,
-0.47108131647109985,
0.14699137210845947,
0.09439928084611893,
-0.34155091643333435,
0.45594993233680725,
0.4679059088230133,
-0.37231698632240295,
0.11605290323495865,
-0.09010835736989975,
0.17968450486660004,
0.6892589926719666,
-0.02556012012064457,
0.35754698514938354,
-0.23447932302951813,
0.9581030607223511,
-0.2677530348300934,
0.16400538384914398,
-0.48249390721321106,
-0.20410804450511932,
-0.6764954924583435,
-0.370810329914093,
0.4047258794307709,
0.6367167830467224,
-0.5005583763122559,
0.4124956429004669,
0.02455926313996315,
-0.5025418996810913,
-0.27481597661972046,
0.24235986173152924,
0.4472217857837677,
0.20210589468479156,
0.10141719877719879,
-0.310470312833786,
-0.581110417842865,
-0.8238032460212708,
-0.151689350605011,
-0.09868048131465912,
0.2748068571090698,
0.527962327003479,
0.5283082127571106,
-0.1869896799325943,
0.8582327365875244,
0.030890703201293945,
0.20195971429347992,
-0.40156036615371704,
0.10477659106254578,
0.1603248417377472,
0.3009890019893646,
0.607492208480835,
-0.5329557657241821,
-0.2646419405937195,
-0.28190967440605164,
-0.9676340222358704,
-0.414191335439682,
0.09668377786874771,
0.039061062037944794,
-0.10088500380516052,
0.4058151841163635,
-0.5223661065101624,
0.25588130950927734,
0.9475233554840088,
-0.19944645464420319,
0.769757866859436,
-0.34470170736312866,
0.20622147619724274,
-0.6026356816291809,
0.2899475693702698,
-0.49463245272636414,
-0.20823687314987183,
-0.5138315558433533,
0.46225476264953613,
-0.051617756485939026,
-0.2869877517223358,
-0.6058117747306824,
0.8926655650138855,
-0.5023765563964844,
-0.23516839742660522,
-0.33195754885673523,
0.5637721419334412,
0.06611291319131851,
0.30280300974845886,
-0.090277299284935,
0.8662041425704956,
0.4763755798339844,
-0.919940173625946,
0.6139657497406006,
0.06036742776632309,
-0.4260081946849823,
0.7362276315689087,
-0.7029221057891846,
0.14416934549808502,
0.24448034167289734,
0.15125930309295654,
-0.793340802192688,
-0.036561183631420135,
-0.10276209563016891,
-0.13780274987220764,
-0.05766446143388748,
0.3756897449493408,
-0.529516875743866,
-0.5536679029464722,
-0.19943851232528687,
0.2935006618499756,
0.2679041922092438,
-0.49359750747680664,
0.8818290829658508,
0.38289448618888855,
0.006943127140402794,
-0.43901267647743225,
-0.48507753014564514,
0.11412297934293747,
-0.5244782567024231,
-0.6407462358474731,
0.10683789849281311,
-0.5877412557601929,
-0.4099165201187134,
-0.3236256539821625,
0.009038496762514114,
0.33167141675949097,
0.4893127977848053,
0.37330931425094604,
0.007971073500812054,
-0.36910316348075867,
0.1682223528623581,
-0.21563540399074554,
-0.12176886200904846,
0.22394001483917236,
0.08819971978664398,
0.6986381411552429,
-0.5170527100563049,
-0.6846569776535034,
-0.08859773725271225,
0.33651304244995117,
0.3930659294128418,
-0.43844157457351685,
0.15582962334156036,
0.19777590036392212,
-0.05823521688580513,
-0.42813295125961304,
-0.4931146204471588,
-0.19020521640777588,
-0.5591690540313721,
0.398119181394577,
-0.5511219501495361,
-0.943472146987915,
0.905957043170929,
-0.6984854340553284,
0.19725452363491058,
0.12365991622209549,
0.89952152967453,
0.08342131972312927,
1.0306674242019653,
0.3041045665740967,
0.2786460816860199,
0.30523446202278137,
0.0636807307600975,
0.05509094148874283,
-0.5569678544998169,
-0.01766020990908146,
-0.2989089787006378,
-0.3898333013057709,
-0.4481387436389923,
-0.370039701461792,
0.36596837639808655,
-0.01929650828242302,
-0.32515615224838257,
0.4007304012775421,
-0.08920394629240036,
0.5046355724334717,
0.35804739594459534,
-0.3127555847167969,
0.1194947361946106,
-0.5903989672660828,
-0.7793533205986023,
0.15722544491291046,
-0.5830329656600952,
-0.8902488350868225,
0.784375011920929,
0.3910592198371887,
0.4701777696609497,
0.39172986149787903,
0.8517859578132629,
0.20372678339481354,
0.5554496049880981,
-0.4933628737926483,
0.8347136378288269,
0.5011447072029114,
-1.0542194843292236,
-0.4215002954006195,
-0.035896845161914825,
-1.0214322805404663,
0.591291069984436,
-0.2002876102924347,
-1.0057554244995117,
-0.011123517528176308,
0.1357516199350357,
-0.46045395731925964,
0.028477812185883522,
-0.8359165787696838,
1.2081226110458374,
-0.6983212232589722,
-0.7467102408409119,
-0.14079070091247559,
-0.43831735849380493,
0.3416239023208618,
0.026760529726743698,
0.5199258923530579,
-0.23769310116767883,
-0.2618374824523926,
0.272699236869812,
0.12531296908855438,
0.728882372379303,
-0.3159034848213196,
-0.1977236568927765,
0.570859968662262,
0.6725723743438721,
0.46100565791130066,
0.10271669179201126,
-0.44161325693130493,
-0.09989999979734421,
0.2570101022720337,
-0.1380516141653061,
-0.6843972206115723,
0.7580081224441528,
-0.41462185978889465,
-0.8217194676399231,
-0.4100072681903839,
-0.653864324092865,
-0.46088549494743347,
0.47955650091171265,
-0.3963611423969269,
0.29270637035369873,
-0.9066530466079712,
0.32192471623420715,
0.3346237242221832,
-0.23719708621501923,
0.506157398223877,
0.9872473478317261,
-0.5143446326255798,
-0.2757079005241394,
0.7499163150787354,
-0.19383610785007477,
0.28112950921058655,
-0.06650177389383316,
0.11289689689874649,
-0.18583790957927704,
-0.4302822947502136,
-0.413531094789505,
-0.0045910184271633625,
-0.7071278691291809,
-0.10726649314165115,
-0.23241913318634033,
0.13964706659317017,
0.07152236253023148,
-0.17863386869430542,
-0.32647982239723206,
0.1568828672170639,
-0.006264921743422747,
-0.24862901866436005,
-0.2982754707336426,
0.8320380449295044,
-0.1645083725452423,
0.3381215035915375,
-0.7670192122459412,
-0.1611405909061432,
0.09817249327898026,
0.43887782096862793,
-0.1377096176147461,
-0.17982204258441925,
-0.06282145529985428,
-0.12158860266208649,
-0.5370806455612183,
-0.7728753685951233,
0.2062305212020874,
0.03709384799003601,
0.9138464331626892,
0.3731066584587097,
0.020763644948601723,
0.5356814861297607,
-0.6317703723907471,
0.9684840440750122,
-0.09689145535230637,
-0.9994377493858337,
0.167547345161438,
-0.4957607090473175,
0.5071375966072083,
0.7371956706047058,
0.0460762195289135,
-0.23128776252269745,
-0.25506365299224854,
-0.7998616695404053,
-0.6022050976753235,
0.6480031609535217,
-0.022984011098742485,
0.25731590390205383,
-0.007383968215435743,
0.07928489148616791,
0.11554394662380219,
0.537195086479187,
-0.5808039307594299,
-0.004175221081823111,
0.09590815007686615,
-0.11747715622186661,
-0.12148802727460861,
-0.221000537276268,
-0.21907295286655426,
0.21089127659797668,
0.4107798933982849,
-0.31510213017463684,
0.10841232538223267,
-0.24106481671333313,
-0.09011966735124588,
0.052813634276390076,
0.39212924242019653,
0.7031174898147583,
0.7956662178039551,
-0.08215726912021637,
0.08124902844429016,
0.4806220233440399,
0.09385625272989273,
0.24656721949577332,
0.12662282586097717,
0.08492609113454819,
-0.329031378030777,
0.4414443075656891,
0.6448653936386108,
0.6085619330406189,
-1.2515606880187988,
0.5727074146270752,
0.05375099927186966,
-0.2768629789352417,
-0.24907073378562927,
0.25018033385276794,
0.2680360972881317,
0.5411273837089539,
-0.16368553042411804,
-0.3772308826446533,
0.17498987913131714,
-0.7529453635215759,
0.5569783449172974,
0.4596996605396271,
-0.5109532475471497,
-0.22955460846424103,
0.3956398665904999,
0.3743109703063965,
-0.391811341047287,
0.13605789840221405,
-0.485698401927948,
-0.6082990765571594,
0.5661320686340332,
0.5326995253562927,
0.4422060251235962,
-0.5130323767662048,
0.13720859587192535,
0.34445348381996155,
0.20171992480754852,
-0.021798400208353996,
0.5197963118553162,
-0.006061634048819542,
-0.6605454087257385,
-0.2503184974193573,
-0.325692355632782,
-0.5649031400680542,
0.0395851694047451,
-0.4484522044658661,
0.47449660301208496,
-0.32507452368736267,
-0.4537326991558075,
-0.3104592561721802,
-0.009846220724284649,
-0.7652628421783447,
0.08081759512424469,
0.26185014843940735,
0.8365843296051025,
-0.37363728880882263,
0.5067597031593323,
0.5217859745025635,
-0.1570904552936554,
-0.4996173083782196,
-0.2482958436012268,
0.28684037923812866,
-0.7507553100585938,
0.40569189190864563,
0.14097081124782562,
-0.2703889012336731,
-0.21672818064689636,
-0.4744749367237091,
-0.9725118279457092,
1.1984813213348389,
0.4736114740371704,
-0.5808151364326477,
0.06457403302192688,
0.05222206190228462,
0.7629762291908264,
-0.7078520655632019,
0.5840513706207275,
0.639403223991394,
0.7520024180412292,
-0.0019600344821810722,
-0.8896285891532898,
-0.04004668444395065,
-0.16453590989112854,
-0.2523495852947235,
0.004117405973374844,
-0.9390749931335449,
0.7520249485969543,
-0.130715474486351,
-0.25456663966178894,
0.3832709491252899,
0.645659327507019,
0.5837244391441345,
0.24175219237804413,
0.6442582011222839,
0.1400798261165619,
0.579663872718811,
-0.19750277698040009,
0.9995381236076355,
-0.6889994144439697,
0.35435396432876587,
1.2518706321716309,
-0.8691719770431519,
0.7425847053527832,
0.1942998468875885,
-0.02834036387503147,
0.7000524997711182,
0.43803948163986206,
-0.12474972754716873,
0.2568032741546631,
0.6656504273414612,
-0.0094286585226655,
-0.4165458679199219,
-0.0584384948015213,
0.03345341235399246,
0.6582478284835815,
0.521630585193634,
-0.030602091923356056,
-0.49271777272224426,
0.048313818871974945,
0.027907105162739754,
0.2479059398174286,
0.03250088542699814,
0.6534455418586731,
0.015698689967393875,
-0.9709281921386719,
0.18212710320949554,
-0.04785701632499695,
0.30436742305755615,
-0.8071882724761963,
-0.13760119676589966,
-0.03323764353990555,
0.47301605343818665,
0.29392579197883606,
-0.8234132528305054,
-0.08186808228492737,
-0.16573534905910492,
0.279737263917923,
-0.10023324191570282,
0.40172433853149414,
-0.429608553647995,
-0.26416441798210144,
0.7631657719612122,
0.7264567017555237,
0.09986813366413116,
0.2442755550146103,
-1.1869701147079468,
0.5188535451889038,
-0.21442656219005585,
-0.40959250926971436,
0.31531140208244324,
0.6463356614112854,
-0.07335858792066574,
0.6953789591789246,
0.28401103615760803,
-0.24949847161769867,
-0.09955165535211563,
0.04702777415513992,
0.7000900506973267,
-0.49438080191612244,
-0.5011268854141235,
-0.689240038394928,
0.6003079414367676,
-0.20260947942733765,
-0.3725762963294983,
0.894743025302887,
0.6548859477043152,
0.48293307423591614,
0.2090727686882019,
0.810977041721344,
-0.0020277327857911587,
0.4001981019973755,
-0.3095296621322632,
0.19075992703437805,
-0.4041561782360077,
0.16956362128257751,
-0.22876670956611633,
-0.9053123593330383,
-0.07897856831550598,
0.2835933268070221,
-0.187898188829422,
0.4367140829563141,
0.7655662894248962,
0.7223455309867859,
-0.001544893835671246,
0.013936281204223633,
0.5878128409385681,
0.055690668523311615,
0.5742763876914978,
0.4688577353954315,
0.8593474626541138,
-0.16522644460201263,
0.4682979881763458,
0.01365458033978939,
-0.2719259560108185,
-0.18731828033924103,
-1.0799390077590942,
-1.097901701927185,
-0.43827617168426514,
-0.10547902435064316,
-0.3429117798805237,
0.060695890337228775,
1.0050692558288574,
0.45532530546188354,
-0.8064695596694946,
-0.6602230668067932,
0.3244189918041229,
-0.09928930550813675,
-0.4845617115497589,
-0.1328468769788742,
0.08814070373773575,
-0.3112277686595917,
-0.6581363081932068,
0.6838101744651794,
0.17782951891422272,
-0.14307226240634918,
-0.7163887023925781,
-0.13066713511943817,
-0.177274689078331,
0.4463023245334625,
0.5160188674926758,
0.28211045265197754,
-0.6841009259223938,
-0.3322224020957947,
0.19481903314590454,
0.0815577283501625,
-0.023072080686688423,
0.9384390115737915,
-0.5763099789619446,
0.7027365565299988,
0.1485316902399063,
0.4872897267341614,
0.2207663655281067,
0.18016649782657623,
0.8915188312530518,
-0.34705138206481934,
0.17066121101379395,
0.27757495641708374,
0.379513680934906,
0.22793644666671753,
0.06965140253305435,
0.42940017580986023,
-0.08993560820817947,
-0.5824973583221436,
-0.7454168796539307,
0.25646743178367615,
-0.7486352920532227,
-0.06352520734071732,
1.332693099975586,
-0.27405431866645813,
-0.3166998326778412,
-0.06918209791183472,
-0.3562591075897217,
-0.13030681014060974,
-0.41601747274398804,
0.48732900619506836,
1.142289161682129,
-0.15279704332351685,
-0.07414769381284714,
-0.7184939980506897,
0.24958312511444092,
0.3093109130859375,
-0.7434611916542053,
0.07955964654684067,
0.5522177219390869,
0.20708157122135162,
0.31587284803390503,
0.3616391122341156,
-0.046257223933935165,
0.23284779489040375,
-0.0033545373007655144,
0.3016665279865265,
-0.07312793284654617,
-0.2815241515636444,
-0.4248921573162079,
0.29811474680900574,
0.16895708441734314,
0.09637197852134705
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20852v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20852v1
|
Towards Spoken Language Understanding via Multi-level Multi-grained Contrastive Learning
| 2024-05-31T14:34:23
| 2024-05-31T14:34:23
|
Xuxin Cheng, Wanshi Xu, Zhihong Zhu, Hongxiang Li, Yuexian Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Spoken language understanding (SLU) is a core task in task-oriented dialogue
systems, which aims at understanding the user's current goal through
constructing semantic frames. SLU usually consists of two subtasks, including
intent detection and slot filling. Although there are some SLU frameworks joint
modeling the two subtasks and achieving high performance, most of them still
overlook the inherent relationships between intents and slots and fail to
achieve mutual guidance between the two subtasks. To solve the problem, we
propose a multi-level multi-grained SLU framework MMCL to apply contrastive
learning at three levels, including utterance level, slot level, and word level
to enable intent and slot to mutually guide each other. For the utterance
level, our framework implements coarse granularity contrastive learning and
fine granularity contrastive learning simultaneously. Besides, we also apply
the self-distillation method to improve the robustness of the model.
Experimental results and further analysis demonstrate that our proposed model
achieves new state-of-the-art results on two public multi-intent SLU datasets,
obtaining a 2.6 overall accuracy improvement on the MixATIS dataset compared to
previous best models.
|
[
-0.25149956345558167,
-0.7976453304290771,
0.5703040957450867,
0.1714342087507248,
-0.24460043013095856,
-0.02497854083776474,
-0.015491586178541183,
-0.37823548913002014,
-0.09208790957927704,
0.39402759075164795,
-0.5927881598472595,
-0.5614417791366577,
-0.49334830045700073,
-0.2604375183582306,
-0.1619756668806076,
0.9214146137237549,
0.2046966254711151,
0.12342167645692825,
-0.15434786677360535,
-0.28209829330444336,
-0.5549603700637817,
-0.19395758211612701,
-0.7986639142036438,
-0.6163078546524048,
0.41846635937690735,
0.38059690594673157,
0.4407561719417572,
0.20860587060451508,
0.031665071845054626,
0.3670472204685211,
-0.27615591883659363,
0.23701228201389313,
-0.5789642333984375,
0.003578422125428915,
-0.06303247809410095,
-0.38547995686531067,
-0.44866201281547546,
0.014964527450501919,
0.5362837314605713,
0.547700822353363,
-0.4430500566959381,
-0.18214693665504456,
0.3617783486843109,
0.5502971410751343,
-0.5019546151161194,
0.5108082294464111,
-0.7480844259262085,
0.11261972039937973,
0.088800810277462,
0.04417289048433304,
-0.4896988272666931,
0.15658381581306458,
0.17522624135017395,
-0.8498631119728088,
0.01951725408434868,
-0.1644822210073471,
0.6690455079078674,
0.2588234543800354,
-0.19857847690582275,
-0.5227289199829102,
-0.5502094030380249,
0.9090853929519653,
-0.889809787273407,
0.344918817281723,
0.4630013406276703,
0.3142690062522888,
0.10309276729822159,
-0.34322354197502136,
-0.410477876663208,
-0.1303943693637848,
-0.3988959491252899,
0.23513011634349823,
-0.09492584317922592,
0.18456077575683594,
-0.06792192161083221,
0.567397952079773,
-0.644236147403717,
0.1509445160627365,
-0.21032622456550598,
-0.2850111722946167,
0.049424510449171066,
0.17074257135391235,
0.1516791582107544,
-0.07942564785480499,
-0.5855121612548828,
0.04718603566288948,
-0.2622932493686676,
0.1879309117794037,
-0.027495073154568672,
0.5749754905700684,
-0.3300016224384308,
0.09199920296669006,
-0.08343388140201569,
0.7712457776069641,
0.11088227480649948,
-0.6235159635543823,
0.39953818917274475,
-0.6127997636795044,
-0.349944531917572,
0.0831136554479599,
0.5906921625137329,
0.02548021450638771,
0.01380598358809948,
0.050008852034807205,
-0.17608967423439026,
-0.1198323518037796,
0.05916672945022583,
-0.5959530472755432,
-0.07400909066200256,
0.23959755897521973,
-0.2957935631275177,
-0.21639063954353333,
-0.11368589103221893,
-0.4292314350605011,
-0.15991276502609253,
-0.44605323672294617,
0.37630388140678406,
-0.6000557541847229,
-0.3352998197078705,
0.29320383071899414,
0.22169306874275208,
0.2530618906021118,
0.5340695381164551,
-0.8304895758628845,
0.31026405096054077,
0.7098613381385803,
0.7761662006378174,
-0.05008445680141449,
-0.5544898509979248,
-0.588691771030426,
0.46589142084121704,
-0.021082330495119095,
0.609210193157196,
-0.6539808511734009,
-0.4008914530277252,
-0.208177849650383,
-0.22680321335792542,
-0.40157535672187805,
-0.4678427577018738,
0.42099136114120483,
-0.22927917540073395,
0.2355586737394333,
0.11533666402101517,
-0.2820030450820923,
-0.3520599603652954,
0.32110917568206787,
-0.42959779500961304,
1.140101432800293,
-0.03217636048793793,
-0.6112579703330994,
0.22041241824626923,
-0.539627194404602,
-0.4717555344104767,
0.12110919505357742,
-0.3031194508075714,
-0.377793550491333,
0.21869142353534698,
0.4114544987678528,
0.46627330780029297,
0.3737046718597412,
0.6005369424819946,
-0.17495420575141907,
-0.3448043763637543,
0.08566634356975555,
-0.5266886949539185,
0.2734810709953308,
0.2484915852546692,
-0.1951715350151062,
0.3115357458591461,
-0.7461951971054077,
-0.2254410684108734,
-0.16727912425994873,
-0.41647103428840637,
-0.4154070317745209,
0.04233431816101074,
-0.18918316066265106,
0.41153717041015625,
0.23832085728645325,
-0.4457603991031647,
-0.11681269854307175,
-0.266181617975235,
0.490183025598526,
0.7679104804992676,
-0.4017530679702759,
0.4925811290740967,
-0.11015554517507553,
0.19931760430335999,
0.5736303329467773,
0.12952576577663422,
-0.507865846157074,
-0.4157756567001343,
-0.8778129816055298,
-0.11366088688373566,
0.03128063306212425,
0.558049738407135,
-0.7540058493614197,
0.2833368480205536,
-0.006173858884721994,
-0.08549764752388,
-0.8424144983291626,
0.10881169140338898,
0.7701999545097351,
0.5702110528945923,
0.5018928647041321,
-0.09609825164079666,
-0.044859275221824646,
-0.6859304308891296,
0.03620506823062897,
-0.11219857633113861,
0.18284697830677032,
0.9398648142814636,
0.10657666623592377,
-0.3127880096435547,
0.6318520307540894,
-0.4784250855445862,
-0.5742337703704834,
-0.48656532168388367,
0.46294263005256653,
0.3273235261440277,
0.5510008931159973,
0.19544538855552673,
-0.7108224630355835,
-0.41780218482017517,
0.3776787221431732,
-0.6161399483680725,
-0.17052720487117767,
-0.13739700615406036,
0.07389520853757858,
-0.09340661764144897,
0.5303458571434021,
-0.1971617490053177,
0.26937058568000793,
0.7801786065101624,
-0.10847749561071396,
0.47733959555625916,
-0.37518978118896484,
0.09452659636735916,
-1.1383174657821655,
-0.22194591164588928,
0.07562826573848724,
-0.30864620208740234,
-1.0162426233291626,
-0.07874207198619843,
-0.008934509940445423,
-0.29219573736190796,
-0.6714481115341187,
0.30771008133888245,
-0.21540354192256927,
-0.31113100051879883,
-0.4307621419429779,
0.48815682530403137,
0.2944360077381134,
0.6038063168525696,
-0.031079048290848732,
0.9700974822044373,
0.6935417056083679,
-0.6177541613578796,
-0.16260233521461487,
-0.009314368478953838,
-0.24812136590480804,
0.5216935276985168,
-0.5763419270515442,
0.03746286779642105,
-0.23966777324676514,
0.345193088054657,
-1.2255640029907227,
0.07405722141265869,
0.12801018357276917,
-0.19597600400447845,
0.34977543354034424,
-0.1968015879392624,
0.11427628248929977,
-0.016454173251986504,
0.11598923802375793,
0.5077413320541382,
-0.012823043391108513,
-0.38215482234954834,
0.9209277629852295,
0.43422383069992065,
-0.17535901069641113,
-0.8354764580726624,
-0.6874094009399414,
-0.3090282082557678,
-0.1829267293214798,
-0.6285172700881958,
0.3067939579486847,
-0.10264694690704346,
-0.10402179509401321,
-0.27012595534324646,
-0.2432941347360611,
-0.23430286347866058,
0.035517461597919464,
0.19897213578224182,
0.014930451288819313,
-0.34807509183883667,
0.14028245210647583,
0.1255849450826645,
-0.40843454003334045,
-0.33837559819221497,
-0.2834763824939728,
0.870360255241394,
-0.39694884419441223,
-0.41150400042533875,
-0.9026861786842346,
0.39557191729545593,
0.5164169073104858,
-0.21341286599636078,
0.5852523446083069,
1.0129445791244507,
-0.002428558422252536,
-0.02511858195066452,
-0.489224374294281,
0.12388871610164642,
-0.486653596162796,
0.17168501019477844,
-0.8330756425857544,
-1.1980993747711182,
0.5560399889945984,
0.039392512291669846,
0.18510642647743225,
0.21795214712619781,
0.3459480404853821,
-0.16698049008846283,
0.8019507527351379,
0.4365798234939575,
-0.3594790995121002,
0.5815895795822144,
-0.21590252220630646,
0.11963105201721191,
-0.9430501461029053,
-0.27267950773239136,
-0.41045644879341125,
-0.18246926367282867,
-0.28854408860206604,
-0.6934753060340881,
0.3418774902820587,
0.16508252918720245,
0.3991173803806305,
0.20533433556556702,
-0.09303319454193115,
0.5340346097946167,
0.24369017779827118,
0.35074853897094727,
0.3833639621734619,
-0.225519597530365,
-0.4312899112701416,
0.2150130420923233,
-0.5098431706428528,
-0.26345792412757874,
0.37290453910827637,
0.3513354957103729,
1.0071845054626465,
0.055889490991830826,
0.8206499218940735,
0.18904413282871246,
-0.22388112545013428,
-0.7837863564491272,
0.43849968910217285,
-0.40509602427482605,
-0.24089813232421875,
-0.5533629655838013,
-0.47720763087272644,
-0.8733102679252625,
0.9154980182647705,
0.09306870400905609,
-0.6359847784042358,
0.12307991832494736,
0.34285950660705566,
-0.3119165003299713,
0.06646812707185745,
-0.948126494884491,
0.8525915145874023,
-0.09796126931905746,
-0.22546955943107605,
-0.4941437244415283,
-0.6231452822685242,
0.3990270495414734,
0.20031672716140747,
0.6734403371810913,
-0.4723203778266907,
0.26449382305145264,
0.3879717290401459,
0.06585785001516342,
0.9746777415275574,
-0.3424893021583557,
-0.2422502040863037,
0.07023735344409943,
-0.049370210617780685,
0.2915497124195099,
0.14831139147281647,
-0.20017646253108978,
0.006952506955713034,
-0.22013720870018005,
-0.5332990884780884,
-0.47518277168273926,
0.8975556492805481,
-0.6160391569137573,
-0.45512598752975464,
-0.22614331543445587,
-0.7777578234672546,
0.017944052815437317,
0.05056118965148926,
-0.29603347182273865,
0.7842913866043091,
-0.26637980341911316,
-0.08485838770866394,
0.8794958591461182,
-0.17782174050807953,
0.639916718006134,
0.7013427019119263,
-0.14011341333389282,
-0.12438163161277771,
1.1893340349197388,
-0.47060275077819824,
0.5329157710075378,
0.5402321815490723,
0.5407496094703674,
-0.33918771147727966,
-0.7923308610916138,
-0.49982985854148865,
0.18827661871910095,
-0.6021541357040405,
0.10786312073469162,
-0.6593283414840698,
-0.210177481174469,
-0.5020182728767395,
-0.10674966126680374,
-0.3171786367893219,
0.048752687871456146,
-0.636009693145752,
0.053233783692121506,
-0.2122822403907776,
0.8934520483016968,
0.06145454943180084,
0.5635729432106018,
-0.7483870983123779,
0.4166012406349182,
0.42746463418006897,
0.24088126420974731,
0.03564608097076416,
-0.5916123390197754,
-0.20435048639774323,
0.026087364181876183,
-0.25629717111587524,
-0.4027555584907532,
0.33711087703704834,
0.5397995114326477,
0.8427746295928955,
0.7891902923583984,
-0.26209983229637146,
1.1713353395462036,
-0.6010739803314209,
0.7103232145309448,
0.2694339454174042,
-1.0663015842437744,
0.7408432960510254,
-0.2525452673435211,
0.7175821661949158,
0.9290194511413574,
0.22200831770896912,
-0.5865870118141174,
-0.5484684109687805,
-0.4929580092430115,
-0.6328710913658142,
0.8996456265449524,
0.12912043929100037,
-0.012482321821153164,
0.24483489990234375,
0.038473423570394516,
0.39166927337646484,
0.01959432102739811,
-1.1762821674346924,
-0.18646270036697388,
-0.170869380235672,
-0.11606604605913162,
-0.2373432219028473,
-0.148854061961174,
0.11876733601093292,
-0.19295020401477814,
0.6262624263763428,
-0.21517562866210938,
-0.1091935783624649,
0.04551774263381958,
-0.5318034291267395,
0.20387816429138184,
0.7053719162940979,
0.8045613169670105,
0.7362683415412903,
-0.07158666104078293,
0.3526860773563385,
0.11054553836584091,
-0.4279572367668152,
-0.040749624371528625,
0.015865419059991837,
0.08474753797054291,
-0.11792081594467163,
0.11928322166204453,
1.0932410955429077,
0.6393362879753113,
-0.39174574613571167,
0.38848719000816345,
-0.2309214472770691,
-0.10365349799394608,
0.10342920571565628,
0.15799348056316376,
0.04740528017282486,
0.22441212832927704,
0.07137277722358704,
-0.21572643518447876,
0.2641574740409851,
-0.5841692686080933,
0.3260886073112488,
0.36951959133148193,
-0.6746208071708679,
-0.11068464070558548,
0.048492494970560074,
0.4083276391029358,
-0.18795011937618256,
0.2738649845123291,
-0.2685220539569855,
-0.39401668310165405,
0.16449397802352905,
0.7131227254867554,
0.44942498207092285,
-0.5366508364677429,
0.3587821125984192,
0.22184723615646362,
0.029842257499694824,
0.20943617820739746,
0.1575537621974945,
-0.43993276357650757,
-0.7586988806724548,
-0.4077739417552948,
-0.9074226021766663,
-0.3078577518463135,
0.46612340211868286,
-0.6372705698013306,
-0.16783715784549713,
0.045244552195072174,
0.2239757627248764,
0.1672143191099167,
-0.13569559156894684,
-0.17083902657032013,
0.05338131636381149,
0.1894473433494568,
0.4556677043437958,
-0.9838914275169373,
1.1102523803710938,
0.23527927696704865,
-0.07987537980079651,
-0.5847374200820923,
-0.04952288046479225,
0.030921760946512222,
-1.0071920156478882,
0.28187182545661926,
0.4521143436431885,
-0.4575791358947754,
-0.02671351097524166,
-0.011470459401607513,
-0.7200621962547302,
1.0257970094680786,
-0.1527164876461029,
-0.590885579586029,
0.053854528814554214,
0.12555347383022308,
0.26004618406295776,
-0.6964969635009766,
0.3583386242389679,
0.8139325976371765,
0.29509401321411133,
0.4583789110183716,
-0.8718897104263306,
-0.3563551902770996,
0.006214556284248829,
-0.0977465957403183,
0.40733039379119873,
-0.49293431639671326,
0.9092874526977539,
-0.035632818937301636,
-0.16523078083992004,
-0.14306004345417023,
0.6956218481063843,
0.35637664794921875,
0.6479279398918152,
0.7228665351867676,
0.8425976634025574,
0.5776382684707642,
-0.1892515867948532,
0.5468856692314148,
-0.06585453450679779,
0.4312061369419098,
1.3672411441802979,
-0.2695995271205902,
0.8004549741744995,
0.37523144483566284,
-0.18079406023025513,
0.595720648765564,
0.37642771005630493,
0.3986307382583618,
0.565322756767273,
0.02301371470093727,
-0.39805087447166443,
-0.22536592185497284,
-0.15029653906822205,
-0.2001638263463974,
0.5929670929908752,
0.899387001991272,
-0.19883431494235992,
-0.6097512245178223,
0.26729846000671387,
-0.15832653641700745,
-0.006872088182717562,
-0.42162516713142395,
1.2142006158828735,
0.0010172438342124224,
-0.5396710634231567,
0.5400505065917969,
-0.29142194986343384,
0.7179745435714722,
-0.6444113850593567,
-0.05474795028567314,
-0.16740018129348755,
0.17803746461868286,
-0.17705440521240234,
-0.8996874094009399,
0.13059239089488983,
-0.33808261156082153,
-0.03869784250855446,
-0.21611273288726807,
0.8517088294029236,
-0.7953834533691406,
-0.29516443610191345,
0.3705674409866333,
0.5571310520172119,
0.4560262858867645,
0.14904196560382843,
-1.1214998960494995,
0.10695257037878036,
0.05128146708011627,
0.25177866220474243,
0.465164452791214,
0.46725091338157654,
0.38949501514434814,
0.5888199210166931,
0.5142390131950378,
-0.19832995533943176,
0.19715847074985504,
0.719597339630127,
0.8540589809417725,
-0.30100011825561523,
-0.7037661671638489,
-0.7949352860450745,
0.3710413873195648,
-0.13796678185462952,
-0.16257266700267792,
0.47962477803230286,
0.5540505647659302,
0.910189151763916,
0.10846605151891708,
0.5128179788589478,
0.19943200051784515,
0.3191106617450714,
-0.7254621386528015,
0.2809182107448578,
-0.510994553565979,
0.186284139752388,
-0.2361283302307129,
-0.5170067548751831,
-0.03843679279088974,
0.79151850938797,
-0.0771523118019104,
-0.13863211870193481,
0.6525433659553528,
0.754643976688385,
-0.34428828954696655,
0.161447212100029,
0.7303134202957153,
0.13926436007022858,
0.2943069636821747,
0.7280511856079102,
0.7921356558799744,
-0.1958131194114685,
0.47297388315200806,
-0.21348699927330017,
-0.4164324402809143,
-0.13564860820770264,
-0.5717986822128296,
-0.8316749334335327,
-0.5242999792098999,
0.059637147933244705,
0.027458040043711662,
0.0012354545760899782,
0.46273207664489746,
0.9648431539535522,
-0.8574379086494446,
-0.5824540257453918,
-0.1292378455400467,
0.24176707863807678,
-0.2200840562582016,
-0.2616509795188904,
0.18465550243854523,
-0.8050975203514099,
-0.8294546604156494,
0.6549729704856873,
0.6118068695068359,
0.1431623250246048,
-0.3052860200405121,
-0.1737602949142456,
-0.5004135370254517,
-0.064851313829422,
0.83328777551651,
-0.021103279665112495,
-1.170142650604248,
-0.10007382184267044,
-0.45130062103271484,
-0.08734089881181717,
0.4116118252277374,
0.9934077262878418,
-0.6267436146736145,
0.43419015407562256,
0.25194206833839417,
0.4711589217185974,
0.758604109287262,
0.16878844797611237,
0.20058798789978027,
-0.9312704801559448,
0.22397203743457794,
0.04479193687438965,
0.48336830735206604,
0.15294361114501953,
-0.32602959871292114,
0.15782403945922852,
-0.058439671993255615,
-0.5570889711380005,
-0.320174902677536,
0.5044497847557068,
-1.4227294921875,
-0.4837281107902527,
1.0872825384140015,
-0.3709084391593933,
-0.10883283615112305,
-0.44754329323768616,
-0.35776111483573914,
0.21469159424304962,
-0.7892982363700867,
0.46211278438568115,
0.575231671333313,
-0.4710218012332916,
-0.2831253409385681,
-0.39758265018463135,
0.3156707286834717,
0.3675248324871063,
-0.965844988822937,
0.2692512571811676,
0.3381108343601227,
0.007238936610519886,
0.27175331115722656,
0.731595516204834,
0.029886262491345406,
-0.03299541398882866,
-0.2169702798128128,
-0.40728962421417236,
-0.03878166154026985,
-0.6296175122261047,
-0.47049617767333984,
0.16035518050193787,
-0.15574997663497925,
-0.3209173083305359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20850v1
|
Improving Reward Models with Synthetic Critiques
| 2024-05-31T14:33:07
| 2024-05-31T14:33:07
|
Zihuiwen Ye, Fraser Greenlee-Scott, Max Bartolo, Phil Blunsom, Jon Ander Campos, Matthias Gallé
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Reward models (RM) play a critical role in aligning language models through
the process of reinforcement learning from human feedback. RMs are trained to
predict a score reflecting human preference, which requires significant time
and cost for human annotation. Additionally, RMs tend to quickly overfit on
superficial features in the training set, hindering their generalization
performance on unseen distributions. We propose a novel approach using
synthetic natural language critiques generated by large language models to
provide additional feedback, evaluating aspects such as instruction following,
correctness, and style. This offers richer signals and more robust features for
RMs to assess and score on. We demonstrate that high-quality critiques improve
the performance and data efficiency of RMs initialized from different
pretrained models. Conversely, we also show that low-quality critiques
negatively impact performance. Furthermore, incorporating critiques enhances
the interpretability and robustness of RM training.
|
[
-0.28179675340652466,
-0.2174837738275528,
0.368929386138916,
0.15217949450016022,
-0.09095260500907898,
0.12008892744779587,
-0.5664213299751282,
-0.4869302213191986,
0.2966301143169403,
0.4388393461704254,
-0.7276780605316162,
-0.08744727075099945,
-0.45528772473335266,
0.2103596031665802,
0.053204696625471115,
1.2516517639160156,
0.03218333050608635,
0.32769399881362915,
-0.2678430676460266,
-0.17175297439098358,
-0.5455151200294495,
-0.8571757078170776,
-0.6162813901901245,
-0.5630161762237549,
0.6559761762619019,
0.1382041722536087,
0.5996857285499573,
0.3813641667366028,
0.24526530504226685,
0.389020711183548,
-0.006885448005050421,
0.4450226128101349,
-0.7186321020126343,
0.18228848278522491,
-0.4041413366794586,
-0.4363512694835663,
-0.4029003083705902,
0.30429887771606445,
0.5118963122367859,
0.5396305918693542,
-0.12009993195533752,
0.037168823182582855,
0.2515658140182495,
0.683728814125061,
-0.7445767521858215,
0.2270675152540207,
-0.38911622762680054,
-0.11475826054811478,
0.24744568765163422,
-0.34809887409210205,
-0.7438739538192749,
-0.617781937122345,
0.2839253544807434,
-0.7719977498054504,
0.1280999481678009,
-0.13549019396305084,
0.8848847150802612,
0.20332422852516174,
-0.10062508285045624,
-0.18720057606697083,
-0.8765043020248413,
1.10951566696167,
-0.6580256819725037,
0.13455946743488312,
0.43977344036102295,
0.6154142618179321,
-0.009177597239613533,
-0.39135611057281494,
-0.49669620394706726,
-0.7522380948066711,
-0.407331258058548,
0.04912137612700462,
0.03524390980601311,
-0.1587323099374771,
0.14230720698833466,
0.49581220746040344,
-0.15430617332458496,
-0.042704109102487564,
-0.16159643232822418,
-0.19214436411857605,
0.9344637393951416,
0.3371371924877167,
0.10513395816087723,
-0.30768126249313354,
-0.28214314579963684,
-0.7609292268753052,
-0.6154814958572388,
0.47656354308128357,
0.6143752336502075,
0.5474605560302734,
0.003453462617471814,
0.5455114245414734,
-0.43991589546203613,
0.620908260345459,
-0.10170251876115799,
0.0945342481136322,
0.45484116673469543,
-0.2734963595867157,
0.09452426433563232,
-0.23876948654651642,
0.6854983568191528,
0.49750903248786926,
0.16810579597949982,
-0.21075470745563507,
-0.7478321194648743,
0.4138086438179016,
0.7096620202064514,
-0.5864067077636719,
-0.37468963861465454,
0.04307107627391815,
-0.36793431639671326,
-0.7266380786895752,
0.2987857460975647,
-0.5696102976799011,
-0.6305385828018188,
-0.9567431807518005,
0.6059262156486511,
-0.49841105937957764,
-0.1495443731546402,
0.08345286548137665,
-0.39600256085395813,
-0.12028224021196365,
0.6170352101325989,
-1.1012898683547974,
0.44366806745529175,
0.6991280913352966,
0.5909497737884521,
-0.25078532099723816,
-0.2788723111152649,
-0.8627415299415588,
-0.022097937762737274,
-0.2273799031972885,
0.9509413242340088,
-0.7151291370391846,
-0.28127092123031616,
-0.10279751569032669,
-0.05385947227478027,
0.1028466448187828,
-0.7779093384742737,
0.590988278388977,
-0.35084569454193115,
0.48274853825569153,
-0.42324528098106384,
-0.4684962332248688,
-0.03429261967539787,
0.6836742758750916,
-0.7699422240257263,
0.9896665215492249,
0.5483188629150391,
-0.6549756526947021,
0.32159560918807983,
-0.7865498065948486,
-0.42062076926231384,
0.005072431638836861,
0.08341053128242493,
-0.19997362792491913,
0.3556022047996521,
0.49117735028266907,
0.11008802801370621,
-0.004515796434134245,
0.1447616070508957,
-0.25193342566490173,
-0.4650641679763794,
0.5829009413719177,
-0.26435884833335876,
0.17785051465034485,
0.0532507486641407,
-0.32112303376197815,
0.6896873712539673,
-0.7494630813598633,
0.32043924927711487,
0.03604648634791374,
-0.44021016359329224,
-0.3819994628429413,
-0.0665191262960434,
0.2638731002807617,
0.16327108442783356,
-0.18979820609092712,
-0.44638487696647644,
0.37123334407806396,
-0.7925875782966614,
0.4146243929862976,
1.1096805334091187,
-0.08690552413463593,
0.4469335973262787,
-0.6532061100006104,
0.8052933812141418,
-0.29874807596206665,
0.16695523262023926,
-0.040758803486824036,
0.08639368414878845,
-0.7155500650405884,
-0.32299819588661194,
0.5843738913536072,
0.180502787232399,
-0.7090299129486084,
0.34046393632888794,
-0.3278972804546356,
-0.5185242295265198,
-0.7620934844017029,
0.008310234174132347,
0.49885883927345276,
0.09871518611907959,
0.6172459721565247,
-0.7343820333480835,
-0.7593327760696411,
-0.7733438611030579,
-0.5157155394554138,
-0.13095930218696594,
-0.27291586995124817,
0.2865913212299347,
0.3388347029685974,
-0.22223152220249176,
0.929768443107605,
-0.4013778269290924,
-0.19016891717910767,
-0.548745334148407,
0.23015858232975006,
-0.11807677149772644,
0.4867883324623108,
0.2853361666202545,
-0.34107115864753723,
-0.2007727026939392,
-0.2101229727268219,
-0.1922958940267563,
0.0889752209186554,
-0.13344880938529968,
-0.10781832039356232,
0.18753375113010406,
-0.008264470845460892,
-0.4406314194202423,
0.1106279268860817,
0.39141079783439636,
-0.31443965435028076,
0.8517847657203674,
-0.04118513688445091,
0.15999408066272736,
-0.7289576530456543,
0.17703752219676971,
0.09929964691400528,
-0.20951955020427704,
-0.22412285208702087,
-0.07376363128423691,
-0.21685032546520233,
0.10574804991483688,
-0.1969262808561325,
0.7291554808616638,
-0.14352905750274658,
0.14908061921596527,
-0.3060844838619232,
-0.0396035835146904,
0.24087117612361908,
0.6474096775054932,
0.25107869505882263,
0.37339991331100464,
0.06747067719697952,
-0.5636892914772034,
0.40802690386772156,
0.16842952370643616,
-0.3892996907234192,
0.484981507062912,
-0.8051535487174988,
0.1698182225227356,
-0.0551593080163002,
0.5138852596282959,
-0.8905305862426758,
-0.3970886468887329,
0.12694832682609558,
-0.6197841167449951,
0.2951676547527313,
-0.058936119079589844,
-0.30153313279151917,
-0.08323618769645691,
-0.7111924886703491,
0.10571775585412979,
0.4709593951702118,
-0.6278116703033447,
0.38427332043647766,
0.3564925193786621,
0.008480672724545002,
-0.5446725487709045,
-0.2986789643764496,
-0.16081222891807556,
0.06861665099859238,
-0.22774793207645416,
0.45604944229125977,
0.08547630161046982,
-0.15701444447040558,
-0.038073889911174774,
0.029765048995614052,
0.4321835935115814,
0.11666648089885712,
0.33692029118537903,
0.4229070544242859,
0.14118976891040802,
0.16875088214874268,
-0.25098609924316406,
-0.25307732820510864,
0.1312931329011917,
-0.16817836463451385,
0.7413869500160217,
-0.18081457912921906,
-0.16926030814647675,
-0.49060750007629395,
0.06749661266803741,
0.41772109270095825,
-0.4378547966480255,
0.7430818676948547,
0.44771918654441833,
-0.08952280879020691,
-0.5331644415855408,
-0.4285532832145691,
-0.652772843837738,
-0.49023541808128357,
0.3153965473175049,
-0.05557188391685486,
-0.817907989025116,
-0.06894255429506302,
0.06264975666999817,
0.02140113152563572,
0.4043983817100525,
0.6739457249641418,
-0.0743638426065445,
1.2859452962875366,
0.6841977834701538,
-0.15690027177333832,
0.5452941656112671,
-0.48874351382255554,
0.11167365312576294,
-0.8563627004623413,
-0.4682544469833374,
-0.5159242749214172,
-0.5028411149978638,
-0.3917962908744812,
-0.2280605435371399,
0.061684515327215195,
-0.030026061460375786,
-0.20370814204216003,
0.292534202337265,
-0.597729504108429,
0.48365864157676697,
0.6260506510734558,
0.15070411562919617,
0.04749129340052605,
0.010843489319086075,
-0.2798575460910797,
-0.13922524452209473,
-0.46006882190704346,
-0.7929466366767883,
1.042259693145752,
0.4941410720348358,
0.753767728805542,
0.0003166239184793085,
0.5484158396720886,
0.19227536022663116,
0.7764555215835571,
-0.7896000146865845,
0.23337580263614655,
0.07440143078565598,
-0.2955872714519501,
-0.3962886929512024,
-0.5946816802024841,
-0.6342055797576904,
0.2452397346496582,
-0.3665725886821747,
-0.5548986196517944,
-0.16103573143482208,
0.4774915277957916,
-0.5014354586601257,
0.043456852436065674,
-0.8065711259841919,
1.0732618570327759,
-0.3365171253681183,
-0.4950055778026581,
-0.40273141860961914,
-0.46364185214042664,
0.3531096279621124,
0.4403451383113861,
0.2617623209953308,
0.05266823619604111,
0.43178629875183105,
0.6358543634414673,
-0.6589257717132568,
0.820444643497467,
-0.19638513028621674,
0.0014980013947933912,
0.0032898334320634604,
0.25824540853500366,
0.5263833999633789,
0.082345150411129,
-0.12201346457004547,
-0.4285021424293518,
0.11083213239908218,
-0.27868780493736267,
-1.0321159362792969,
0.5612138509750366,
-0.7779912352561951,
-0.3201742172241211,
-0.40151458978652954,
-0.5068650841712952,
-0.6885977387428284,
-0.20944108068943024,
0.10053911060094833,
0.46451395750045776,
-0.1445430964231491,
-0.058381255716085434,
0.05077404901385307,
-0.31389370560646057,
0.033952921628952026,
0.25879231095314026,
-0.1939195990562439,
-0.630457878112793,
1.0548161268234253,
-0.36063703894615173,
0.4592727720737457,
0.13721750676631927,
0.3156917691230774,
-0.6422619223594666,
-0.2028910219669342,
-0.35827144980430603,
0.23605281114578247,
-0.6698133945465088,
-0.05718173459172249,
-0.430963933467865,
-0.05655466020107269,
-0.36496198177337646,
-0.019494086503982544,
-0.5500864386558533,
-0.698972225189209,
-0.02069583535194397,
-0.17159375548362732,
0.2571965754032135,
0.9768110513687134,
0.02773723006248474,
0.21400755643844604,
-0.7873854041099548,
0.03190814331173897,
0.25355061888694763,
0.6497260332107544,
0.3669111728668213,
-0.7548795342445374,
-0.38957053422927856,
0.23161573708057404,
-0.5148536562919617,
-0.48739832639694214,
0.551536500453949,
-0.16705870628356934,
0.5399632453918457,
0.21305689215660095,
0.14025339484214783,
0.5510058403015137,
-0.2959808111190796,
0.8144174218177795,
0.2820810377597809,
-0.9558406472206116,
0.5737788677215576,
-0.026160651817917824,
0.08854565769433975,
0.6330386400222778,
0.35743701457977295,
-0.6209715008735657,
-0.3373309373855591,
-0.5655370354652405,
-0.7131075263023376,
0.9505425095558167,
0.08717052638530731,
0.3896825611591339,
-0.03221365436911583,
0.13807624578475952,
0.1478155553340912,
0.25469544529914856,
-0.9491527080535889,
0.20691974461078644,
-0.5964813828468323,
-0.24262289702892303,
-0.3072409927845001,
-0.3977920711040497,
-0.2759737968444824,
-0.4984165132045746,
0.9002758860588074,
-0.07775697857141495,
-0.0037749705370515585,
-0.049223873764276505,
-0.12761321663856506,
-0.3653760850429535,
0.5490038394927979,
0.5982776284217834,
0.5503014922142029,
-0.2214379459619522,
0.15410999953746796,
0.07096384465694427,
0.0204412080347538,
0.2531141936779022,
-0.22471964359283447,
-0.019067320972681046,
-0.020575858652591705,
0.47915711998939514,
1.0950236320495605,
0.2739245891571045,
-0.9737526178359985,
0.5162215828895569,
-0.1792917102575302,
-0.026986541226506233,
-0.1836366057395935,
0.29520338773727417,
-0.011460683308541775,
0.1423090547323227,
-0.11236204952001572,
0.2403779923915863,
-0.01096423901617527,
-0.8572397232055664,
0.15462163090705872,
0.547965407371521,
-0.7696324586868286,
-0.46352243423461914,
0.38438427448272705,
0.1598498374223709,
-0.31988751888275146,
0.6292790174484253,
-0.29201745986938477,
-0.9623401165008545,
0.22134070098400116,
0.4701392352581024,
0.7927107214927673,
-0.17878581583499908,
0.393587589263916,
0.6032655239105225,
0.11769984662532806,
-0.4156256914138794,
0.017824973911046982,
-0.10708871483802795,
-0.6059511303901672,
-0.6101506352424622,
-0.8869296312332153,
-0.6510033011436462,
0.08270066231489182,
-0.6923577189445496,
0.4405790865421295,
-0.4330618977546692,
-0.19597619771957397,
-0.16181254386901855,
-0.10948435962200165,
-0.41653141379356384,
0.27582377195358276,
0.14647285640239716,
0.4774133861064911,
-0.7085196375846863,
0.7251525521278381,
0.8294950723648071,
-0.6558634042739868,
-1.1390072107315063,
-0.19931574165821075,
-0.14416515827178955,
-0.3830395042896271,
0.9428429007530212,
0.43755871057510376,
-0.1276870220899582,
-0.378316193819046,
-0.3164032995700836,
-0.6208893656730652,
0.6292536854743958,
0.40354838967323303,
-0.34138551354408264,
0.031549882143735886,
0.05431974306702614,
0.9861109256744385,
-0.3432413339614868,
0.6560247540473938,
0.6139732003211975,
0.3872459828853607,
0.19694577157497406,
-0.866508424282074,
0.07760870456695557,
-0.5945478677749634,
0.02249496430158615,
0.09828625619411469,
-0.20922529697418213,
0.7567352652549744,
-0.15507882833480835,
-0.10106263309717178,
0.01885099522769451,
0.4399470090866089,
0.46466854214668274,
-0.041396766901016235,
0.685987651348114,
0.6417950391769409,
0.5353888273239136,
-0.08108493685722351,
1.524543285369873,
0.10969361662864685,
0.38026073575019836,
1.2042834758758545,
-0.22024396061897278,
0.989050030708313,
0.44029268622398376,
-0.24490481615066528,
0.739152729511261,
0.6080213785171509,
-0.06445328146219254,
0.7050101161003113,
0.7697126865386963,
0.046276140958070755,
-0.31752270460128784,
-0.2134326845407486,
-0.20395570993423462,
0.23859693109989166,
-0.06011242792010307,
-0.30933213233947754,
-0.07110556960105896,
-0.10703811049461365,
-0.39787301421165466,
0.4219680428504944,
-0.17749300599098206,
0.7977649569511414,
-0.12720435857772827,
-1.0615952014923096,
0.7672581672668457,
0.20519891381263733,
0.6896346211433411,
-0.5389994382858276,
-0.26480159163475037,
-0.13241074979305267,
0.4562086760997772,
-0.2079959660768509,
-0.38945114612579346,
0.3080494701862335,
0.01862744800746441,
-0.12497320026159286,
-0.33649879693984985,
0.2135007530450821,
-0.38510069251060486,
-0.42115336656570435,
0.21036577224731445,
-0.07935630530118942,
-0.2960771918296814,
-0.36754268407821655,
-0.4704974591732025,
0.159385547041893,
-0.12272533029317856,
-0.35420098900794983,
0.4040204584598541,
0.074793741106987,
-0.0994478315114975,
0.6714522242546082,
0.8161027431488037,
0.15262167155742645,
-0.34786850214004517,
0.31174519658088684,
0.9076796174049377,
-0.6493258476257324,
-0.7292481064796448,
-1.0036019086837769,
0.7947390675544739,
-0.32428106665611267,
-0.3147042691707611,
0.6212490200996399,
0.47753986716270447,
1.1866155862808228,
-0.3039015531539917,
0.7220247387886047,
0.33148160576820374,
0.8062779903411865,
-0.5773054361343384,
0.6436670422554016,
-0.5053679347038269,
0.575514018535614,
-0.41392603516578674,
-0.8539274334907532,
-0.15229196846485138,
0.7930110096931458,
-0.43223994970321655,
0.14068610966205597,
0.5721001625061035,
0.7239388823509216,
0.08750782907009125,
0.0828223004937172,
-0.0968908965587616,
-0.16887733340263367,
0.45294296741485596,
0.5173133611679077,
1.4826644659042358,
-0.18898050487041473,
0.2561514973640442,
-0.5702200531959534,
0.044438980519771576,
-0.2886662185192108,
-0.7625406980514526,
-0.8381340503692627,
-0.365043044090271,
-0.19189642369747162,
-0.5853283405303955,
-0.10402553528547287,
1.4014649391174316,
0.7712087035179138,
-1.0988801717758179,
-0.32404056191444397,
0.07254502922296524,
-0.019508931785821915,
-0.3969745337963104,
-0.27481725811958313,
0.3502267897129059,
-0.702440619468689,
-0.5460914373397827,
0.4200655519962311,
0.1973591148853302,
-0.0945863351225853,
-0.391589492559433,
-0.5115147233009338,
0.29359880089759827,
0.13419677317142487,
0.687847375869751,
0.044070757925510406,
-0.8152986168861389,
-0.43632620573043823,
-0.02917066030204296,
-0.1798468828201294,
-0.04141918569803238,
1.0423691272735596,
-0.9890084266662598,
0.4236415922641754,
0.33418944478034973,
0.7165616750717163,
0.3923458158969879,
0.27970048785209656,
0.9203989505767822,
-0.8404896259307861,
0.12077371776103973,
0.5450217127799988,
0.2737281918525696,
0.5995774865150452,
-0.15456219017505646,
0.47905686497688293,
0.16674154996871948,
-0.19163160026073456,
-1.2397990226745605,
0.20011858642101288,
-0.8807764649391174,
-0.2553183436393738,
0.984950065612793,
-0.12450823187828064,
-0.13363121449947357,
0.3808455467224121,
-0.4744064211845398,
0.18765172362327576,
-0.21564194560050964,
1.2123528718948364,
0.7671666145324707,
0.025615474209189415,
-0.0699920803308487,
-0.18444892764091492,
0.9464616179466248,
0.7828014492988586,
-0.8603999018669128,
0.29508888721466064,
0.5556907653808594,
0.2017199993133545,
0.027712827548384666,
0.3644241392612457,
-0.32158124446868896,
0.3755827844142914,
-0.3713877499103546,
0.24018670618534088,
-0.2375001311302185,
-0.28374582529067993,
-0.5830698609352112,
0.08366583287715912,
0.5205119848251343,
0.061551693826913834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20846v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20846v1
|
Don't Buy it! Reassessing the Ad Understanding Abilities of Contrastive Multimodal Models
| 2024-05-31T14:31:46
| 2024-05-31T14:31:46
|
A. Bavaresco, A. Testoni, R. Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Image-based advertisements are complex multimodal stimuli that often contain
unusual visual elements and figurative language. Previous research on automatic
ad understanding has reported impressive zero-shot accuracy of contrastive
vision-and-language models (VLMs) on an ad-explanation retrieval task. Here, we
examine the original task setup and show that contrastive VLMs can solve it by
exploiting grounding heuristics. To control for this confound, we introduce
TRADE, a new evaluation test set with adversarial grounded explanations. While
these explanations look implausible to humans, we show that they "fool" four
different contrastive VLMs. Our findings highlight the need for an improved
operationalisation of automatic ad understanding that truly evaluates VLMs'
multimodal reasoning abilities. We make our code and TRADE available at
https://github.com/dmg-illc/trade .
|
[
-0.3852800726890564,
-0.6453945636749268,
0.5592567920684814,
-0.01657812111079693,
-0.40449610352516174,
0.17099377512931824,
0.050184063613414764,
-0.559999406337738,
-0.08663708716630936,
0.26068565249443054,
-0.56010901927948,
-0.2215147167444229,
-0.5686522126197815,
-0.2667859196662903,
-0.15398895740509033,
0.6854535937309265,
-0.16260597109794617,
-0.09644591808319092,
-0.2338963896036148,
-0.4794929027557373,
-0.2950187921524048,
-0.1828887164592743,
-0.5685092806816101,
-0.22722506523132324,
0.3686223328113556,
0.3129453957080841,
1.10248863697052,
0.5230216979980469,
0.33499130606651306,
0.2705458998680115,
-0.16330425441265106,
0.20404545962810516,
-0.5125510692596436,
-0.3313908874988556,
-0.32598891854286194,
-0.29303473234176636,
-0.3981977701187134,
0.26178663969039917,
0.0071431538090109825,
0.5441362857818604,
0.1277756690979004,
-0.038005534559488297,
-0.3437572717666626,
0.5427989959716797,
-0.8147393465042114,
0.1630817949771881,
-0.8370416760444641,
-0.167972594499588,
0.3838810920715332,
-0.22633159160614014,
-0.6487342119216919,
0.1689436286687851,
0.2251034528017044,
-0.853129506111145,
0.33948442339897156,
0.12883758544921875,
1.328413963317871,
0.302462637424469,
-0.6492241621017456,
-0.11607270687818527,
-0.5891910791397095,
0.7204772233963013,
-0.5151171088218689,
0.36049360036849976,
0.3354164659976959,
0.5489009618759155,
0.1238803118467331,
-0.5458558201789856,
-0.6015248894691467,
-0.41313818097114563,
-0.15161608159542084,
0.37319058179855347,
-0.5015770196914673,
0.05123714357614517,
0.1999536007642746,
0.4870191216468811,
-0.4270617365837097,
-0.1912217140197754,
-0.5848092436790466,
-0.049831897020339966,
0.5265291929244995,
0.043405208736658096,
0.3442349433898926,
0.03268035873770714,
-0.9729220867156982,
-0.13404618203639984,
-0.41465872526168823,
0.15985658764839172,
0.0027778358198702335,
-0.04975177347660065,
-0.09777654707431793,
0.5860671997070312,
-0.05406951531767845,
0.8656798005104065,
0.17033493518829346,
0.3413771390914917,
0.1729905754327774,
-0.46906325221061707,
-0.6001911759376526,
-0.3001876473426819,
0.4281711280345917,
0.5582065582275391,
0.1244296059012413,
-0.06636222451925278,
-0.29857689142227173,
0.6530945897102356,
0.5292181372642517,
-0.3062729239463806,
-0.30787912011146545,
0.2490919530391693,
-0.4492965042591095,
-0.38719964027404785,
-0.35995522141456604,
-0.5327978730201721,
-0.20463526248931885,
-0.2624451816082001,
0.9245425462722778,
-0.5253666639328003,
-0.1413552612066269,
0.4003784656524658,
-0.4683564305305481,
0.1345686912536621,
0.3320421576499939,
-0.2845169007778168,
0.1335364282131195,
0.2237047702074051,
0.3769018054008484,
0.02760482393205166,
-0.33645209670066833,
-0.30666762590408325,
-0.01741369254887104,
-0.5075769424438477,
0.9671392440795898,
-0.36605289578437805,
-0.2814199924468994,
-0.31245705485343933,
0.06175890937447548,
-0.28276532888412476,
-0.4258492887020111,
0.4207572638988495,
-0.9648494720458984,
0.4757973551750183,
-0.28661590814590454,
-0.1363418996334076,
-0.6173984408378601,
0.5521050691604614,
-0.6277921199798584,
0.3154011368751526,
0.10725902765989304,
-0.2955285608768463,
0.5690534114837646,
-0.4144391119480133,
-0.4664318263530731,
-0.10306764394044876,
0.1629486382007599,
-0.3400765359401703,
0.22738274931907654,
0.25791797041893005,
0.04051407799124718,
0.013699172995984554,
-0.057453595101833344,
-0.5805237889289856,
-0.7287156581878662,
0.40691670775413513,
-0.7358971238136292,
0.711337149143219,
0.44590604305267334,
-0.6355226635932922,
0.08203620463609695,
-0.6475817561149597,
-0.20686917006969452,
0.5084430575370789,
-0.14915801584720612,
-0.4010016918182373,
-0.13245515525341034,
-0.04359503090381622,
0.5179145932197571,
0.30831649899482727,
-0.08591131120920181,
-0.10471085458993912,
-0.21308642625808716,
0.11985202133655548,
0.808761477470398,
-0.42558425664901733,
0.4228786528110504,
-0.4423658847808838,
0.5845624804496765,
0.23969192802906036,
0.1709109991788864,
-0.6209441423416138,
-0.3619782030582428,
-0.6792484521865845,
-0.29450133442878723,
-0.05596451088786125,
0.2060544192790985,
-0.9961277842521667,
-0.18581636250019073,
0.04350939765572548,
-0.20432136952877045,
-0.615038275718689,
-0.00042075084638781846,
0.697059154510498,
0.4472803771495819,
0.4273150563240051,
-0.17072409391403198,
-0.34202811121940613,
-0.9811108708381653,
-0.522803783416748,
0.04386529326438904,
0.19034788012504578,
0.4734533131122589,
0.34304434061050415,
-0.3653095066547394,
0.530002772808075,
-0.5713914036750793,
-0.2325393557548523,
-0.053374651819467545,
0.2309017926454544,
0.0031374257523566484,
0.07329469174146652,
0.7113352417945862,
-0.9517340660095215,
-0.35969752073287964,
-0.11796755343675613,
-0.631539523601532,
-0.007742313202470541,
-0.29390427470207214,
0.09151940792798996,
0.1271398514509201,
0.4018707573413849,
-0.6423829197883606,
0.5386438965797424,
0.5297688245773315,
-0.8065984845161438,
0.4508943259716034,
-0.4651249647140503,
0.27380603551864624,
-0.6408917307853699,
-0.09208449721336365,
0.23083996772766113,
-0.330773264169693,
-0.11147503554821014,
0.36790892481803894,
0.19467340409755707,
-0.16611376404762268,
-0.5426653623580933,
0.502921998500824,
-0.5933222770690918,
-0.1555868685245514,
-0.3410519063472748,
0.4269174039363861,
0.6072601675987244,
0.4793563485145569,
-0.22480055689811707,
0.9269258975982666,
0.415499210357666,
-0.7498552799224854,
0.10613344609737396,
0.15522684156894684,
-0.3049123287200928,
0.9688022136688232,
-0.6684222221374512,
0.01746532879769802,
-0.4127585291862488,
0.04211243614554405,
-1.5548979043960571,
-0.08076421916484833,
0.43321096897125244,
-0.44212573766708374,
0.16002537310123444,
-0.11336208879947662,
0.0741524025797844,
-0.2393321394920349,
-0.19288881123065948,
0.47139474749565125,
0.5582815408706665,
-0.7012240886688232,
0.5783010721206665,
0.04020673781633377,
0.5654836893081665,
-0.7975881099700928,
-0.6155107617378235,
0.1557815819978714,
-0.27089163661003113,
-0.5875169038772583,
0.3859346807003021,
-0.23496916890144348,
-0.6375156044960022,
0.38585424423217773,
-0.4343419373035431,
-0.08491434156894684,
0.38627389073371887,
-0.0005300078773871064,
0.24884286522865295,
-0.4224007725715637,
-0.07010319083929062,
-0.29272088408470154,
-0.38763225078582764,
-0.018401961773633957,
-0.1950102299451828,
-0.018845899030566216,
-0.04088648408651352,
-0.5633357167243958,
-0.5328086614608765,
-0.0983186587691307,
1.066481590270996,
-0.0011463662376627326,
0.5401381254196167,
0.49190470576286316,
-0.09368660300970078,
-0.04693608358502388,
-0.3657436966896057,
0.20958414673805237,
-0.46384096145629883,
0.06464753299951553,
-0.6122627258300781,
-0.1734548658132553,
0.26626819372177124,
0.05642816796898842,
0.05119961500167847,
0.5858356952667236,
0.35574445128440857,
-0.09391225129365921,
1.4365687370300293,
0.5006502270698547,
0.3599356710910797,
0.4274284839630127,
-0.24739563465118408,
0.2371981292963028,
-0.4033811092376709,
-0.31881046295166016,
-0.1657358705997467,
-0.35367485880851746,
-0.1462685465812683,
-0.4855104386806488,
0.10839391499757767,
-0.0664411336183548,
-0.16627147793769836,
0.3707999885082245,
-0.12360691279172897,
0.5660321116447449,
0.2667127549648285,
0.33605700731277466,
0.3184090852737427,
0.19540613889694214,
-0.01443956047296524,
-0.14906203746795654,
-0.2590459883213043,
-0.3873974084854126,
0.7903439402580261,
0.28410595655441284,
0.9619561433792114,
0.2730157673358917,
-0.12255629897117615,
0.3957010805606842,
0.28477010130882263,
-1.0616177320480347,
0.34705400466918945,
-0.415915310382843,
-0.4705384373664856,
0.21815085411071777,
-0.2655819058418274,
-0.8005328178405762,
0.8238977193832397,
-0.05696830898523331,
-0.4058009088039398,
0.25638246536254883,
0.2993333041667938,
-0.29361653327941895,
0.253132164478302,
-1.033304214477539,
0.8670374155044556,
-0.453618586063385,
-0.5188243985176086,
-0.4414738714694977,
-0.24219827353954315,
0.5108147859573364,
0.13557298481464386,
0.5976895093917847,
0.01579609140753746,
0.00840663630515337,
0.37644630670547485,
-0.03808676078915596,
0.6100878715515137,
-0.0020524703431874514,
-0.2601122260093689,
-0.06476589292287827,
0.4783426821231842,
0.2286931276321411,
-0.24685828387737274,
-0.043137844651937485,
-0.0605572946369648,
-0.21710483729839325,
-0.8150014877319336,
-0.8259486556053162,
0.6111387014389038,
-0.5603070855140686,
-0.7201206088066101,
-0.2519289255142212,
-0.502853512763977,
0.021939508616924286,
0.21403612196445465,
0.1469077318906784,
0.42296043038368225,
-0.34577155113220215,
0.027115492150187492,
0.5414654612541199,
-0.1617005169391632,
0.10559921711683273,
0.5032894015312195,
0.10859547555446625,
-0.5401690602302551,
1.045271396636963,
-0.3348248302936554,
0.6646122336387634,
0.14126062393188477,
0.20850896835327148,
-0.5118130445480347,
-0.3335052728652954,
-0.5574511289596558,
0.07489997148513794,
-1.0543774366378784,
0.33356818556785583,
-0.6392291188240051,
0.22960728406906128,
-0.2841857671737671,
-0.49030089378356934,
-0.2549671530723572,
-0.3306741714477539,
-0.29068660736083984,
-0.048697806894779205,
-0.008331424556672573,
0.9004120230674744,
-0.25803712010383606,
0.4136962890625,
-0.5061658024787903,
0.7436894178390503,
0.6390215754508972,
0.14296463131904602,
-0.003420342458412051,
-0.6142422556877136,
-0.21382777392864227,
0.4008321762084961,
-0.3298024833202362,
-0.9869870543479919,
0.23436395823955536,
-0.2603658139705658,
0.6771380305290222,
0.6713137626647949,
0.09328307211399078,
0.8193453550338745,
-0.1410563737154007,
0.9266370534896851,
0.26314669847488403,
-1.0680636167526245,
0.08593488484621048,
-0.10211479663848877,
0.1659233272075653,
0.24799560010433197,
0.1720084249973297,
-0.22145509719848633,
0.053865183144807816,
-0.8219912052154541,
-1.0198125839233398,
0.8615741729736328,
0.3072044551372528,
0.12374316900968552,
0.21294112503528595,
-0.16015836596488953,
-0.043958984315395355,
0.2742479741573334,
-0.7705546021461487,
-0.39713916182518005,
-0.3406202793121338,
0.08413675427436829,
-0.4549542963504791,
-0.5468538403511047,
-0.3569517135620117,
-0.06051694229245186,
0.6695804595947266,
-0.04339978098869324,
0.06794925779104233,
0.075644850730896,
-0.4560139775276184,
-0.14581061899662018,
0.265815407037735,
0.7595725655555725,
0.9039204716682434,
-0.3075263202190399,
0.5312724113464355,
-0.08161706477403641,
-0.06885913759469986,
0.17880886793136597,
0.0990680530667305,
0.18912401795387268,
0.11304452270269394,
0.2754383087158203,
1.0276850461959839,
0.3497239649295807,
-0.7995903491973877,
0.6231502294540405,
-0.26735785603523254,
-0.4215325117111206,
-0.1970786154270172,
-0.25036564469337463,
-0.18300385773181915,
0.3426719009876251,
-0.07097429782152176,
0.48564836382865906,
0.07385973632335663,
-0.4186602532863617,
0.3615758717060089,
0.5978214144706726,
-0.562384843826294,
-0.3460928797721863,
1.001688838005066,
-0.023889616131782532,
-0.35044968128204346,
0.3437816798686981,
-0.18983766436576843,
-0.6155977845191956,
0.8690056800842285,
0.6437943577766418,
0.8782817721366882,
0.09128955751657486,
0.5380727052688599,
-0.17189384996891022,
0.5031625032424927,
0.20528919994831085,
0.24592116475105286,
-0.23564952611923218,
-0.8185529112815857,
-0.2679763734340668,
0.17403092980384827,
-0.5332138538360596,
0.25481805205345154,
-0.5194825530052185,
0.36240795254707336,
-0.36292678117752075,
0.16155020892620087,
0.35683465003967285,
-0.44624295830726624,
-0.8903234601020813,
0.4471297562122345,
0.09341684728860855,
0.77052241563797,
-0.911001980304718,
0.20341263711452484,
0.7976248264312744,
-0.64140784740448,
-0.27362507581710815,
0.2997426390647888,
-0.039135854691267014,
-1.0919724702835083,
0.8231619596481323,
0.1873556673526764,
-0.4210321605205536,
-0.22983001172542572,
-0.7561072707176208,
-0.4273839592933655,
0.6566073298454285,
0.2464621365070343,
-0.14725449681282043,
0.16412825882434845,
-0.5014845728874207,
0.444429874420166,
-0.25653383135795593,
0.4907000660896301,
0.4163345396518707,
0.49475714564323425,
0.5054523348808289,
-0.5255732536315918,
0.08172792196273804,
-0.1834254115819931,
-0.24800540506839752,
-0.26948782801628113,
-0.49680864810943604,
1.0538463592529297,
-0.5333074927330017,
-0.18272703886032104,
-0.13352176547050476,
-0.008105101063847542,
0.1889440417289734,
0.7593510150909424,
0.7789716124534607,
0.7329848408699036,
0.30267980694770813,
0.26506200432777405,
1.156280517578125,
-0.12997406721115112,
0.5435790419578552,
0.8395113945007324,
-0.3011644184589386,
0.40209707617759705,
0.40758034586906433,
-0.020925372838974,
0.4627448320388794,
0.5210365653038025,
0.13042345643043518,
0.5862556099891663,
0.0043022651225328445,
-0.23158711194992065,
-0.7159862518310547,
-0.0082687484100461,
-0.17623738944530487,
0.5541883707046509,
0.4753759205341339,
-0.4785245954990387,
-0.5232548117637634,
-0.1845618188381195,
-0.15484416484832764,
0.21291354298591614,
0.08023960143327713,
0.7723482847213745,
0.11832528561353683,
-0.3986077308654785,
1.0197187662124634,
-0.06661514192819595,
0.5542303323745728,
-0.30938345193862915,
-0.17031526565551758,
-0.0015755940694361925,
0.4939367175102234,
0.010442192666232586,
-0.6442973613739014,
0.3057374954223633,
-0.34119144082069397,
-0.07827762514352798,
-0.3903244435787201,
0.6536506414413452,
-0.23999395966529846,
-0.11528680473566055,
0.49795466661453247,
0.4924688935279846,
0.013506850227713585,
-0.023917078971862793,
-1.011879563331604,
-0.2005911022424698,
0.06572972238063812,
-0.11275748908519745,
0.07236213237047195,
0.4138275384902954,
0.13205014169216156,
0.6383677124977112,
0.8079216480255127,
-0.2506997883319855,
-0.4036276936531067,
-0.17469428479671478,
0.7664426565170288,
-0.6978638172149658,
-0.573570966720581,
-0.9225684404373169,
0.6988264918327332,
-0.0684180036187172,
-0.021671008318662643,
0.5903581976890564,
0.21920885145664215,
0.9627315402030945,
-0.19451847672462463,
0.773274838924408,
0.3766845166683197,
0.0013348022475838661,
-0.43706339597702026,
0.6049466133117676,
-1.3875991106033325,
0.4909893274307251,
-0.2848755419254303,
-0.40219545364379883,
-0.176932692527771,
0.5623379349708557,
-0.4047811031341553,
-0.08462587743997574,
0.8259056806564331,
0.43309277296066284,
-0.5382733345031738,
-0.05977232754230499,
0.7307606935501099,
0.3748573958873749,
0.35839468240737915,
0.49938541650772095,
1.037231206893921,
-0.5987946391105652,
0.755839467048645,
-0.27534350752830505,
-0.2743510603904724,
-0.3209208846092224,
-0.7742152214050293,
-0.8561137318611145,
-0.22681817412376404,
-0.4370778203010559,
-0.9220143556594849,
0.004515054635703564,
0.650778591632843,
0.5644247531890869,
-0.5880131721496582,
-0.052746087312698364,
0.14990991353988647,
0.6732910871505737,
-0.5661590695381165,
-0.23663993179798126,
0.3086424767971039,
-0.2580563426017761,
-0.7162932753562927,
0.6929396390914917,
0.19480572640895844,
0.279300332069397,
-0.1973741203546524,
0.2077973335981369,
-0.18754053115844727,
0.22654341161251068,
0.726190984249115,
0.13760051131248474,
-0.8317846059799194,
-0.02636875957250595,
0.11465758085250854,
-0.01840265840291977,
0.0379805825650692,
0.8804718255996704,
-0.8668340444564819,
0.9241244196891785,
0.5668613314628601,
0.5241648554801941,
0.07757963240146637,
0.12838886678218842,
0.6635922193527222,
-0.21037784218788147,
0.3254942297935486,
-0.24939416348934174,
0.5254726409912109,
0.20997868478298187,
-0.48204344511032104,
0.17873349785804749,
0.7162892818450928,
-0.028525259345769882,
-0.6066325902938843,
0.4464462101459503,
-0.9291689991950989,
-0.816141664981842,
0.9601933360099792,
-0.29770365357398987,
-0.261750727891922,
-0.34313926100730896,
-0.4747544825077057,
-0.019333412870764732,
-0.3406221270561218,
0.9404097199440002,
0.3428485095500946,
0.19879014790058136,
-0.20957805216312408,
-0.31758740544319153,
0.2656658887863159,
0.5123727917671204,
-0.41462990641593933,
-0.17145471274852753,
0.6583872437477112,
0.4696728587150574,
0.23184999823570251,
0.6484260559082031,
0.024106670171022415,
0.45358529686927795,
0.2445998638868332,
-0.20274002850055695,
-0.32783982157707214,
-0.2589946687221527,
-0.6549756526947021,
0.22739195823669434,
0.11280456930398941,
-0.8106177449226379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20835v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20835v3
|
Outliers and Calibration Sets have Diminishing Effect on Quantization of Modern LLMs
| 2024-05-31T14:24:33
| 2024-06-05T09:53:18
|
Davide Paglieri, Saurabh Dash, Tim Rocktäschel, Jack Parker-Holder
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Post-Training Quantization (PTQ) enhances the efficiency of Large Language
Models (LLMs) by enabling faster operation and compatibility with more
accessible hardware through reduced memory usage, at the cost of small
performance drops. We explore the role of calibration sets in PTQ, specifically
their effect on hidden activations in various notable open-source LLMs.
Calibration sets are crucial for evaluating activation magnitudes and
identifying outliers, which can distort the quantization range and negatively
impact performance. Our analysis reveals a marked contrast in quantization
effectiveness across models. The older OPT model, upon which much of the
quantization literature is based, shows significant performance deterioration
and high susceptibility to outliers with varying calibration sets. In contrast,
newer models like Llama-2 7B, Llama-3 8B, Command-R 35B, and Mistral 7B
demonstrate strong robustness, with Mistral 7B showing near-immunity to
outliers and stable activations. These findings suggest a shift in PTQ
strategies might be needed. As advancements in pre-training methods reduce the
relevance of outliers, there is an emerging need to reassess the fundamentals
of current quantization literature. The emphasis should pivot towards
optimizing inference speed, rather than primarily focusing on outlier
preservation, to align with the evolving characteristics of state-of-the-art
LLMs.
|
[
-0.13680823147296906,
-0.22181332111358643,
0.5307430624961853,
-0.23073378205299377,
-0.32143545150756836,
-0.05093245953321457,
-0.13081902265548706,
-0.039011530578136444,
-0.3148840069770813,
0.5557206273078918,
-0.2136448621749878,
-0.23833011090755463,
-0.5212249755859375,
-0.1204807236790657,
-0.18263794481754303,
0.8592658042907715,
0.10209719836711884,
0.2831544578075409,
-0.26814842224121094,
-0.41875264048576355,
-0.15120677649974823,
-0.6597540974617004,
-0.48966407775878906,
-0.552030086517334,
0.16479922831058502,
0.06038971245288849,
1.0589760541915894,
0.5447374582290649,
0.4986222982406616,
0.1962253600358963,
-0.2248295396566391,
0.06846486032009125,
-0.640399158000946,
0.05189582332968712,
0.24958635866641998,
-1.0308825969696045,
-0.21483555436134338,
-0.014902624301612377,
0.9658782482147217,
0.7549384236335754,
0.1509222686290741,
0.07783272862434387,
0.09448416531085968,
0.9491273164749146,
-1.0852079391479492,
0.03211118280887604,
-0.5009199976921082,
0.13027504086494446,
-0.2904980480670929,
-0.3381426930427551,
-0.43514057993888855,
-0.6664816737174988,
0.13291189074516296,
-0.7090819478034973,
0.02404029667377472,
-0.33429083228111267,
0.6198949217796326,
0.726885199546814,
-0.5288958549499512,
-0.023673415184020996,
-0.5803714394569397,
1.082079529762268,
-1.0509675741195679,
0.4659421443939209,
0.3876678943634033,
0.2733074128627777,
-0.30341172218322754,
-0.6555794477462769,
-0.06026348099112511,
-0.1293364316225052,
0.16937950253486633,
-0.002930042799562216,
-0.22819727659225464,
0.08389488607645035,
0.47430235147476196,
0.5759133100509644,
-0.3318639397621155,
0.23054282367229462,
-0.10954873263835907,
-0.12869082391262054,
0.1875084638595581,
0.021863404661417007,
-0.17690204083919525,
0.2649773359298706,
-0.09204941242933273,
-0.26118406653404236,
-1.3663520812988281,
0.2244601994752884,
0.6266922950744629,
-0.014679944142699242,
0.2100699096918106,
0.4078594148159027,
-0.19522714614868164,
0.7250398993492126,
0.06894388794898987,
-0.14755263924598694,
0.25248512625694275,
-0.4695039391517639,
-0.35263484716415405,
-0.040176428854465485,
0.5959309935569763,
0.08043481409549713,
0.39492473006248474,
0.0735921710729599,
-0.11880326271057129,
-0.0555357001721859,
-0.1368749439716339,
-0.9221231937408447,
-0.42095956206321716,
0.07940204441547394,
-0.35648009181022644,
-0.30745118856430054,
-0.011408588849008083,
-0.13511741161346436,
-0.437736839056015,
-0.4079373776912689,
0.6563100218772888,
-0.41573211550712585,
-0.2755434513092041,
0.12227291613817215,
-0.22430157661437988,
0.18625390529632568,
0.29696083068847656,
-0.6295602917671204,
-0.004341258201748133,
0.6796773672103882,
0.509679913520813,
0.3109341859817505,
0.05487000569701195,
-0.5475755333900452,
0.023061493411660194,
-0.628939688205719,
0.48822954297065735,
-0.41696470975875854,
-0.264653742313385,
-0.033105697482824326,
-0.18130366504192352,
-0.0167658943682909,
-0.8278183341026306,
0.2674652338027954,
-0.7996789216995239,
0.14081357419490814,
-0.3976622521877289,
-0.29037734866142273,
-0.32459601759910583,
0.015205365605652332,
-0.7196516990661621,
1.1723765134811401,
0.18512602150440216,
-0.6514477133750916,
0.5503844022750854,
-0.30483680963516235,
-0.041894566267728806,
0.04551871120929718,
0.005679913330823183,
-0.4544399678707123,
0.5297123789787292,
0.21081286668777466,
0.021489694714546204,
-0.3431979715824127,
0.126643568277359,
-0.3031917214393616,
-0.9550439119338989,
0.5626792907714844,
-0.5658898949623108,
0.9342113137245178,
0.056409887969493866,
-0.24633222818374634,
-0.0699160099029541,
-0.680928111076355,
0.5404642820358276,
-0.3518828749656677,
-0.4081169664859772,
-0.5050394535064697,
0.12585897743701935,
-0.7183290719985962,
0.03309553861618042,
0.07498909533023834,
-0.08755317330360413,
-0.22205433249473572,
-0.7678608894348145,
0.6057677865028381,
0.5817095041275024,
0.13905438780784607,
0.5612612962722778,
-0.3914361894130707,
0.5456427931785583,
0.21581915020942688,
0.23054900765419006,
-0.42345115542411804,
-0.2053612619638443,
-0.8695390820503235,
-0.3391244411468506,
0.4802534282207489,
0.45707637071609497,
-0.6426428556442261,
0.32408326864242554,
-0.4605002999305725,
-0.44372573494911194,
-0.5549981594085693,
0.07553471624851227,
0.5603529810905457,
0.19663172960281372,
0.02364593930542469,
-0.2854178845882416,
-0.3207446336746216,
-0.8190911412239075,
-0.5566620230674744,
-0.06512212753295898,
-0.08706414699554443,
-0.23321537673473358,
0.28392571210861206,
-0.05915775150060654,
0.9946537613868713,
-0.07112567871809006,
-0.06681660562753677,
0.1972701996564865,
0.030643263831734657,
0.16864357888698578,
0.28609994053840637,
0.3945906162261963,
-0.6076876521110535,
-0.40802276134490967,
-0.0734943300485611,
-0.5426310896873474,
-0.24291229248046875,
0.1925477832555771,
-0.10794762521982193,
0.1584814041852951,
0.5867778658866882,
-0.3286648392677307,
0.6876048445701599,
0.5985815525054932,
0.2544254660606384,
0.5452255606651306,
-0.0026239713188260794,
0.20184433460235596,
-0.7272055149078369,
-0.008601200766861439,
-0.12042879313230515,
-0.29114997386932373,
-0.6446689963340759,
0.07335318624973297,
0.3639788329601288,
0.00947561301290989,
-0.6926810145378113,
0.33582961559295654,
-0.45303699374198914,
-0.24002525210380554,
-0.25054728984832764,
0.05933983623981476,
0.16390590369701385,
0.3638366460800171,
-0.2340569794178009,
0.9410940408706665,
0.49804383516311646,
-0.5966920256614685,
0.21963055431842804,
0.008338001556694508,
-0.38305801153182983,
0.5970053672790527,
-0.5044463276863098,
-0.035602718591690063,
-0.19927500188350677,
0.22874000668525696,
-0.7142029404640198,
0.1543382853269577,
0.1250428855419159,
-0.30057820677757263,
0.1528678834438324,
-0.2188945859670639,
-0.75888991355896,
-0.052674487233161926,
-0.8058446049690247,
0.7518227100372314,
0.5446088314056396,
-0.38412541151046753,
0.2410385012626648,
-0.026455719023942947,
0.42403000593185425,
-0.6514716744422913,
-0.6317437291145325,
-0.28754115104675293,
-0.45608463883399963,
-0.4574204981327057,
0.07927179336547852,
-0.10153762996196747,
-0.5439499616622925,
-0.2071017622947693,
-0.3220115900039673,
-0.013299382291734219,
0.10564814507961273,
0.4277893900871277,
-0.23104150593280792,
-0.290187805891037,
0.37390995025634766,
0.03023599274456501,
-0.19883060455322266,
-0.04000343754887581,
-0.09158540517091751,
0.431428998708725,
-0.17726919054985046,
-0.351743221282959,
-0.5084527730941772,
0.07866740971803665,
0.6066766977310181,
-0.495537132024765,
0.715490460395813,
0.3939884603023529,
-0.3306308686733246,
0.037396080791950226,
-0.4431406259536743,
-0.2857365012168884,
-0.5140287280082703,
0.4254167973995209,
-0.3082858622074127,
-0.7399999499320984,
0.4818326234817505,
-0.2993374168872833,
-0.009706391021609306,
0.3356410562992096,
0.5927014946937561,
0.1427338719367981,
1.113513469696045,
0.4885079562664032,
0.24143564701080322,
0.8904932737350464,
-0.33309394121170044,
0.25566011667251587,
-1.0882718563079834,
0.15381012856960297,
-0.309216171503067,
-0.1483829766511917,
-0.5452525019645691,
-0.4369966387748718,
0.6117527484893799,
0.30781829357147217,
-0.5030208230018616,
0.20209303498268127,
-0.25464507937431335,
0.6202446818351746,
0.8358218669891357,
0.25378862023353577,
0.3695768713951111,
0.11846012622117996,
0.24198852479457855,
-0.19866260886192322,
-0.756790041923523,
-0.5205633640289307,
1.5064460039138794,
0.27771347761154175,
0.7357403039932251,
0.0004098696808796376,
0.49582746624946594,
0.16439487040042877,
0.4244074821472168,
-0.6873542070388794,
0.3647853434085846,
-0.12908917665481567,
-0.4870848059654236,
-0.31847724318504333,
-0.5701660513877869,
-0.8754659295082092,
0.3156512379646301,
0.05630233883857727,
-0.42803096771240234,
0.4484225809574127,
0.1586773544549942,
-0.6220720410346985,
0.09787221997976303,
-0.8370549082756042,
0.8595083355903625,
-0.10893544554710388,
-0.23094499111175537,
-0.11828161776065826,
-0.5407671332359314,
0.5529581904411316,
-0.47044622898101807,
0.2222806066274643,
-0.25163301825523376,
-0.07693208009004593,
0.6582369804382324,
-0.6121128797531128,
0.8404905200004578,
-0.042049624025821686,
-0.3190433084964752,
0.37544360756874084,
0.05155317112803459,
0.48206931352615356,
-0.01907286047935486,
-0.3566097915172577,
0.15543456375598907,
0.4138564169406891,
-0.29267704486846924,
-0.5429917573928833,
0.6243895888328552,
-0.7328752875328064,
-0.5183624625205994,
-0.36653992533683777,
-0.5847958326339722,
-0.3738608956336975,
0.06758160144090652,
0.43570610880851746,
0.6168211698532104,
0.13212117552757263,
0.2944719195365906,
0.7735131978988647,
-0.11143993586301804,
0.4696415066719055,
0.512883186340332,
0.25520259141921997,
-0.7376756072044373,
0.7170042395591736,
0.19773468375205994,
0.7226078510284424,
0.38600751757621765,
-0.0004822630435228348,
-0.27864834666252136,
-0.5201612710952759,
-0.1083066388964653,
0.47748318314552307,
-0.9435564279556274,
-0.5308203101158142,
-0.1293194442987442,
-0.07000404596328735,
-0.45930856466293335,
0.09499377012252808,
-0.24795712530612946,
-0.5019477009773254,
-0.7243527770042419,
0.18845680356025696,
0.21322311460971832,
0.20480823516845703,
-0.052424874156713486,
0.9267727136611938,
-0.7544487118721008,
0.008143897168338299,
0.28089040517807007,
0.09345114976167679,
-0.2162507325410843,
-0.7748456001281738,
-0.6412123441696167,
0.4160277545452118,
-0.41838425397872925,
-0.9006698131561279,
0.2171313762664795,
0.5801540613174438,
0.4186396300792694,
0.7083572745323181,
0.08797790110111237,
0.9429595470428467,
-0.20792971551418304,
0.5198268294334412,
0.033002883195877075,
-1.0198044776916504,
0.3999689817428589,
-0.05181941017508507,
0.5323221683502197,
0.6103491187095642,
0.2298564314842224,
-0.37739500403404236,
-0.3203291594982147,
-0.45706772804260254,
-0.6003377437591553,
0.6222357153892517,
-0.17579291760921478,
0.06341477483510971,
0.27202919125556946,
0.5978548526763916,
0.03046119213104248,
0.6160832047462463,
-0.9138326048851013,
-0.23016352951526642,
0.046373967081308365,
-0.05870441347360611,
-0.1093704029917717,
-0.3957565426826477,
-0.22389879822731018,
-0.07356183230876923,
0.6412659883499146,
-0.21974490582942963,
0.12131345272064209,
-0.26928645372390747,
-0.354242205619812,
-0.6236965656280518,
0.10627160221338272,
0.3388964831829071,
0.9238364696502686,
-0.20248958468437195,
0.1705935001373291,
0.04201335832476616,
-0.254133403301239,
0.12398699671030045,
0.0765342265367508,
-0.23587453365325928,
-0.2459564208984375,
0.2776449918746948,
0.864363968372345,
0.4745904207229614,
-0.7173161506652832,
0.6438619494438171,
0.2589898705482483,
-0.10298841446638107,
-0.3910287320613861,
0.24438942968845367,
-0.47362756729125977,
0.4821615219116211,
0.344561904668808,
0.09892203658819199,
-0.05222097784280777,
-0.5615396499633789,
-0.1823144555091858,
0.7876747846603394,
-0.3187353312969208,
-0.3676624298095703,
0.5859402418136597,
-0.23648661375045776,
-0.18090279400348663,
0.4956270158290863,
-0.1199321523308754,
-0.5544763207435608,
0.34393617510795593,
0.29395338892936707,
0.6090481877326965,
-0.3008057475090027,
0.09441492706537247,
0.05582144111394882,
0.48426353931427,
-0.1880320906639099,
0.10991410166025162,
-0.2218797504901886,
-0.5914826393127441,
-0.7650665640830994,
-0.42922788858413696,
-0.38140439987182617,
0.07276912778615952,
-0.6402877569198608,
0.28051450848579407,
-0.22436468303203583,
-0.42160290479660034,
-0.39923056960105896,
0.07591977715492249,
-0.5188300609588623,
0.16249649226665497,
-0.05531415343284607,
0.5571580529212952,
-0.8717190027236938,
0.7294756770133972,
0.6113629341125488,
-0.03390301764011383,
-0.47489720582962036,
-0.1364247053861618,
-0.16467756032943726,
-0.7517379522323608,
0.6523786783218384,
0.14722229540348053,
0.1854526251554489,
0.49304497241973877,
-0.32708415389060974,
-1.1459839344024658,
1.1056604385375977,
0.7984134554862976,
-0.3200237452983856,
-0.11818615347146988,
0.4930030405521393,
0.6160246729850769,
0.1995188593864441,
0.4069727063179016,
0.8838481903076172,
0.33085140585899353,
-0.06975514441728592,
-0.9417912364006042,
-0.047366924583911896,
0.11500833928585052,
0.11150478571653366,
0.7456015944480896,
-0.6020021438598633,
0.8933074474334717,
-0.03591158613562584,
-0.24708062410354614,
0.15598808228969574,
0.21584248542785645,
0.4730876684188843,
0.1087915375828743,
0.22291527688503265,
0.9042093753814697,
0.40314942598342896,
-0.41105371713638306,
0.707319438457489,
-0.15873566269874573,
0.12903538346290588,
0.7456176280975342,
-0.1434553861618042,
0.7746809124946594,
0.5861557126045227,
-0.4519556760787964,
0.29361268877983093,
0.7988510727882385,
0.23794342577457428,
0.7073963284492493,
0.5060361623764038,
-0.4886297285556793,
-0.3480103611946106,
0.12874822318553925,
-0.6241592168807983,
0.16438180208206177,
0.42353731393814087,
-0.41250306367874146,
-0.34186235070228577,
0.12075093388557434,
0.0727429986000061,
-0.30612102150917053,
-0.411218523979187,
0.5225262641906738,
0.2288021594285965,
-0.5513191819190979,
0.7799679040908813,
-0.18454968929290771,
0.41289424896240234,
-0.5904905200004578,
0.08824440836906433,
-0.27602407336235046,
0.36789339780807495,
-0.06897839903831482,
-0.2697446644306183,
0.0060868412256240845,
-0.49485519528388977,
-0.05561527609825134,
-0.22183606028556824,
0.3738391697406769,
-0.18029534816741943,
-0.29371753334999084,
-0.13569146394729614,
0.6447996497154236,
0.230987548828125,
-0.660927414894104,
-0.46037718653678894,
0.13094846904277802,
0.05225060135126114,
-0.2451869696378708,
0.48924481868743896,
0.6956140398979187,
-0.25809842348098755,
0.5250287652015686,
0.6892743110656738,
0.06038804352283478,
0.3379274308681488,
-0.06010681018233299,
0.8376463055610657,
-0.45796477794647217,
-0.32721999287605286,
-0.7478254437446594,
0.4556650221347809,
0.3602932393550873,
-0.24331673979759216,
0.7780051827430725,
0.507493793964386,
0.7814249992370605,
0.15572011470794678,
0.3691571056842804,
0.5418992638587952,
0.278801828622818,
-0.4892137944698334,
0.5241605639457703,
-0.5765630602836609,
0.5846045613288879,
0.025534003973007202,
-1.116721510887146,
-0.5651977062225342,
0.31431105732917786,
-0.6331288814544678,
0.20553986728191376,
0.6704581379890442,
0.8424415588378906,
0.2908690571784973,
-0.32986417412757874,
0.5226909518241882,
-0.08458326011896133,
0.3081016540527344,
0.667188286781311,
1.0795001983642578,
-0.7080476880073547,
0.7200760245323181,
-0.3199978768825531,
-0.32876166701316833,
-0.42916586995124817,
-0.9144124388694763,
-0.836586594581604,
-0.43204987049102783,
-0.5393123030662537,
-0.17656011879444122,
0.23142223060131073,
0.3828318119049072,
0.7143450975418091,
-0.6533588171005249,
-0.11458063125610352,
-0.1530429571866989,
-0.002884562825784087,
-0.20521457493305206,
-0.22939911484718323,
0.43844741582870483,
-0.29318687319755554,
-0.7600902915000916,
0.2576504647731781,
0.26738637685775757,
0.31384706497192383,
-0.26627877354621887,
-0.02085823006927967,
0.3128085732460022,
0.055760715156793594,
0.5231412053108215,
0.37781640887260437,
-0.6926524043083191,
-0.0062956130132079124,
-0.1367679387331009,
0.07233976572751999,
0.21446697413921356,
0.8259760737419128,
-1.3173474073410034,
0.3701397478580475,
0.25194787979125977,
0.19903476536273956,
0.2943749725818634,
-0.008533581160008907,
0.4616122841835022,
-0.706184983253479,
0.3514195680618286,
0.30536749958992004,
0.1588437557220459,
0.2365129590034485,
-0.033484555780887604,
0.4888755977153778,
0.22679683566093445,
-0.7554212212562561,
-1.3570910692214966,
0.20695580542087555,
-0.352069228887558,
0.09000316262245178,
0.9880511164665222,
-0.11886138468980789,
-0.06315052509307861,
0.1860293447971344,
-0.059073686599731445,
0.30038586258888245,
-0.14478358626365662,
0.4653957188129425,
0.6002993583679199,
-0.05852317810058594,
-0.3629315197467804,
-0.5065573453903198,
0.659805417060852,
0.6852016448974609,
-0.6865679621696472,
0.07848778367042542,
0.6004804372787476,
0.10252079367637634,
-0.0027710474096238613,
0.3313369154930115,
-0.3020550608634949,
0.517542839050293,
-0.17177972197532654,
-0.25910598039627075,
0.015264593996107578,
0.13282474875450134,
-0.6594662070274353,
-0.005875287111848593,
0.38501667976379395,
-0.19126354157924652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20833v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20833v1
|
That's Optional: A Contemporary Exploration of "that" Omission in English Subordinate Clauses
| 2024-05-31T14:23:30
| 2024-05-31T14:23:30
|
Ella Rabinovich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The Uniform Information Density (UID) hypothesis posits that speakers
optimize the communicative properties of their utterances by avoiding spikes in
information, thereby maintaining a relatively uniform information profile over
time. This paper investigates the impact of UID principles on syntactic
reduction, specifically focusing on the optional omission of the connector
"that" in English subordinate clauses. Building upon previous research, we
extend our investigation to a larger corpus of written English, utilize
contemporary large language models (LLMs) and extend the information-uniformity
principles by the notion of entropy, to estimate the UID manifestations in the
usecase of syntactic reduction choices.
|
[
-0.44941022992134094,
-0.5770403146743774,
0.662536084651947,
-0.1661200374364853,
-0.11048740148544312,
-0.36059972643852234,
-0.15754154324531555,
-0.26660802960395813,
0.5059087872505188,
0.47768691182136536,
-0.4575441777706146,
-0.3416222631931305,
-0.07918931543827057,
0.06020034849643707,
-0.3249581754207611,
0.7663121223449707,
-0.2372654676437378,
-0.23755298554897308,
-0.5325641632080078,
-0.3849635124206543,
-0.21114563941955566,
-0.48660367727279663,
-0.5304991006851196,
-0.06355808675289154,
0.7297945022583008,
0.45960837602615356,
0.7681540250778198,
0.6741613745689392,
0.6212100386619568,
0.30680736899375916,
-0.050829384475946426,
-0.29975858330726624,
-0.16474293172359467,
0.44858136773109436,
-0.39154818654060364,
-0.6570656299591064,
-0.199518084526062,
0.2850024998188019,
0.9926249384880066,
1.2246657609939575,
-0.11304628103971481,
0.030600758269429207,
0.13422444462776184,
0.9539286494255066,
-1.1932185888290405,
0.22559578716754913,
-0.3479166030883789,
-0.0982229933142662,
-0.2148779332637787,
-0.19692622125148773,
-0.5409854054450989,
-0.13197478652000427,
-0.02839239500463009,
-0.4616778790950775,
0.2228565216064453,
0.05922678858041763,
0.9552952647209167,
0.704652726650238,
-0.6039091944694519,
0.22680068016052246,
-0.8020986914634705,
0.44849693775177,
-0.23128348588943481,
0.416242390871048,
0.76286780834198,
-0.022212961688637733,
-0.16465632617473602,
-0.5024499297142029,
-0.48567596077919006,
-0.03077530302107334,
-0.14396452903747559,
0.37467077374458313,
-0.19020409882068634,
0.5827910304069519,
0.14734911918640137,
0.32331570982933044,
-0.4361376166343689,
0.12027435749769211,
-0.41144105792045593,
0.4358254373073578,
0.26624804735183716,
0.23175449669361115,
0.13543561100959778,
-0.3303096294403076,
0.10294759273529053,
0.25849059224128723,
-0.71291184425354,
0.5072723627090454,
0.17917968332767487,
-0.011156709864735603,
-0.1901644915342331,
0.5765722990036011,
-0.12668810784816742,
0.10985280573368073,
0.06807482987642288,
-0.04274586960673332,
0.08635714650154114,
-0.23388446867465973,
-0.3058984577655792,
-0.21610808372497559,
0.5064869523048401,
0.2624676823616028,
0.038063209503889084,
-0.43267136812210083,
0.16098764538764954,
0.12622937560081482,
0.09827633947134018,
-0.38425201177597046,
-0.22847022116184235,
0.47132810950279236,
-0.4939252436161041,
-0.03187902271747589,
0.052652016282081604,
0.13522358238697052,
-0.00187876436393708,
-0.20072083175182343,
-0.1271454244852066,
-0.4893013834953308,
-0.29465043544769287,
-0.11138959974050522,
-0.8056509494781494,
0.05080031603574753,
0.08984363079071045,
-0.7663240432739258,
0.5579999089241028,
0.6341283321380615,
0.5619863867759705,
-0.2503173053264618,
-0.30304646492004395,
-0.3607887923717499,
0.7048124074935913,
-0.7223324179649353,
0.6991627216339111,
-0.42864540219306946,
-0.3122076988220215,
-0.29169055819511414,
0.1311529129743576,
-0.2223142683506012,
-0.35910218954086304,
0.6676579713821411,
-0.13427463173866272,
0.14322680234909058,
-0.29714831709861755,
-0.7616139054298401,
-0.40382102131843567,
-0.21150532364845276,
-0.8440879583358765,
0.5001091957092285,
0.19493868947029114,
-0.7808430790901184,
0.5701438188552856,
-0.027986129745841026,
-0.4967571198940277,
0.29829105734825134,
-0.3861049711704254,
-0.2564614415168762,
0.3506167232990265,
-0.42275771498680115,
0.08674527704715729,
-0.4328649044036865,
0.40117067098617554,
-0.6155604124069214,
-0.249357670545578,
0.013899359852075577,
-0.38788902759552,
0.8783788681030273,
0.12964297831058502,
-0.31406134366989136,
-0.28435462713241577,
-0.933250904083252,
0.13793683052062988,
-0.22431014478206635,
-0.41653189063072205,
-0.8496425151824951,
0.5356326699256897,
-0.18177306652069092,
-0.1335337609052658,
-0.014912666752934456,
-0.47347772121429443,
0.18421900272369385,
-0.4040412902832031,
0.025395041331648827,
0.6271530985832214,
0.1702517718076706,
1.2046177387237549,
-0.4739057123661041,
0.3660159409046173,
-0.24274444580078125,
0.22861722111701965,
0.250428706407547,
-0.47264036536216736,
-0.8062905669212341,
-0.7414366602897644,
0.051934756338596344,
0.7418086528778076,
-0.648849368095398,
0.7811472415924072,
-0.031126350164413452,
-0.16307510435581207,
-0.3903379440307617,
0.17291907966136932,
0.3681641221046448,
0.19083677232265472,
-0.007303671911358833,
0.31595414876937866,
-0.9463606476783752,
-1.235527753829956,
-0.2267826944589615,
-0.6566746830940247,
-0.006940610706806183,
-0.1259070187807083,
0.26301372051239014,
-0.07796909660100937,
1.2627075910568237,
-0.08546877652406693,
-0.2816050052642822,
-0.2509572505950928,
-0.15046080946922302,
0.3052074611186981,
0.5844879746437073,
0.6541951894760132,
-0.5499852299690247,
-0.18939757347106934,
-0.03040219657123089,
-0.9175294041633606,
-0.16136015951633453,
-0.12661240994930267,
0.19585905969142914,
0.3214554786682129,
0.7574104070663452,
-0.9718188047409058,
0.7573859691619873,
0.36856165528297424,
-0.07436788082122803,
0.2985634207725525,
-0.22394828498363495,
-0.0672461986541748,
-0.8357696533203125,
-0.1456284373998642,
-0.04890039935708046,
-0.20599742233753204,
-0.5243553519248962,
0.4484403431415558,
0.37244442105293274,
0.1174064427614212,
-0.18805287778377533,
0.490709513425827,
-0.7033436298370361,
0.2935376763343811,
-0.07209891825914383,
-0.15025781095027924,
-0.0003225199761800468,
0.18705561757087708,
-0.051564253866672516,
0.43243780732154846,
0.42155545949935913,
-0.7346619963645935,
-0.12582308053970337,
-0.07360250502824783,
-0.23840343952178955,
0.28568920493125916,
-0.34395769238471985,
-0.3421630859375,
-0.738030195236206,
0.3269596993923187,
-1.0217903852462769,
-0.10303603857755661,
0.05555089935660362,
-0.08085334300994873,
-0.09632275253534317,
-0.19270867109298706,
-0.28509461879730225,
-0.28595060110092163,
-0.4689449369907379,
0.3491069972515106,
0.7774301171302795,
-0.34675154089927673,
0.4251794219017029,
0.45079177618026733,
-0.24841073155403137,
-0.2256728708744049,
-0.9436190724372864,
0.01461812760680914,
-0.11504165828227997,
-0.60721355676651,
0.6865106225013733,
-0.332351416349411,
-0.9454146027565002,
0.15710705518722534,
-0.1531846672296524,
-0.398313045501709,
0.1899612993001938,
0.3006359934806824,
0.062480222433805466,
-0.2845079302787781,
0.383232057094574,
0.18527400493621826,
-0.048897627741098404,
0.054477643221616745,
0.13703899085521698,
0.17657683789730072,
0.2071087658405304,
-0.20928680896759033,
-0.6964532136917114,
0.8214643597602844,
0.2769336700439453,
0.4783189594745636,
0.844632089138031,
0.21810707449913025,
-0.31949475407600403,
-0.22267216444015503,
-0.6586535573005676,
0.22213782370090485,
-0.467314749956131,
-0.03832817077636719,
-0.3863382041454315,
-0.6090669631958008,
0.5331381559371948,
0.6065932512283325,
-0.08522937446832657,
0.452442467212677,
-0.06698921322822571,
-0.4766979217529297,
0.86973637342453,
0.5838673710823059,
-0.04216283932328224,
0.5801025032997131,
-0.14712633192539215,
0.2642693519592285,
-0.5708012580871582,
0.17548339068889618,
-0.756733238697052,
-0.024125613272190094,
-0.8872023224830627,
-0.12959273159503937,
0.3540389835834503,
0.18065135180950165,
-0.22415001690387726,
-0.04102363809943199,
0.028798671439290047,
0.8076153993606567,
0.5588604211807251,
0.09751531481742859,
-0.008065665140748024,
-0.2763059437274933,
0.1483491212129593,
-0.1067560538649559,
-0.7266508340835571,
-0.058148887008428574,
0.5988941192626953,
0.07415644824504852,
0.7990609407424927,
0.39428436756134033,
0.9556617736816406,
0.1059625968337059,
-0.24650011956691742,
-0.7191064953804016,
0.5440229773521423,
-0.21917736530303955,
-0.1442389190196991,
-0.27115699648857117,
-0.5227956771850586,
-1.0692869424819946,
0.16705754399299622,
0.07667160034179688,
-0.7295430898666382,
0.3889244794845581,
0.09580416977405548,
-0.1294092833995819,
0.14220769703388214,
-1.2221605777740479,
0.30953264236450195,
0.30262720584869385,
-0.27850770950317383,
-0.3366219699382782,
-0.2577793002128601,
0.34208133816719055,
0.250335156917572,
0.19180168211460114,
-0.04863961040973663,
-0.4010195732116699,
0.6983660459518433,
-0.8537259101867676,
0.9659637808799744,
-0.06194443628191948,
0.18019767105579376,
0.3807573914527893,
0.09917484223842621,
0.7889048457145691,
-0.15214303135871887,
-0.09242094308137894,
-0.11577136814594269,
-0.0006718467338941991,
-0.4034867286682129,
-0.35890963673591614,
0.64390629529953,
-0.6032910346984863,
-1.0762355327606201,
-0.2532704174518585,
-0.6492588520050049,
0.10830249637365341,
-0.040428854525089264,
0.5443267226219177,
0.3757529556751251,
-0.12340005487203598,
0.5143497586250305,
0.35289260745048523,
0.2493627965450287,
0.9223780632019043,
0.22767893970012665,
0.20767559111118317,
-0.20852631330490112,
0.4568849802017212,
0.7462437748908997,
0.22587871551513672,
0.44038504362106323,
0.21206679940223694,
-0.23026932775974274,
-0.532139003276825,
0.13988731801509857,
0.29006227850914,
-1.1065016984939575,
0.031161418184638023,
-0.7319761514663696,
-0.33431941270828247,
-0.8584732413291931,
-0.4443624019622803,
-0.04878896102309227,
-0.7933340072631836,
-0.32965245842933655,
-0.3679361939430237,
0.2887327969074249,
0.5805894136428833,
-0.0581207200884819,
0.17011332511901855,
-0.6113882660865784,
0.5603328347206116,
0.06434496492147446,
0.24943271279335022,
-0.24271266162395477,
-0.21643219888210297,
-0.05728399381041527,
-0.2976858913898468,
0.018718520179390907,
-0.6322633624076843,
0.20833751559257507,
0.4367173910140991,
1.1796907186508179,
0.3111264109611511,
0.5329784154891968,
0.7035122513771057,
-0.5198469161987305,
0.7431772947311401,
0.4283164441585541,
-0.8917688131332397,
0.33570215106010437,
-0.46908697485923767,
0.5629410147666931,
0.5671969056129456,
0.3681989312171936,
-0.3453807532787323,
-1.039743185043335,
-1.0997742414474487,
-0.8887968063354492,
0.1944752186536789,
0.3105431795120239,
-0.22873935103416443,
-0.5533313155174255,
0.23495246469974518,
0.2349095642566681,
0.06483913958072662,
-0.7991346716880798,
-0.35426992177963257,
0.6180938482284546,
-0.10119011253118515,
0.09078105539083481,
-0.27400121092796326,
0.17739945650100708,
-0.557742178440094,
0.42343559861183167,
0.26247045397758484,
0.04683908820152283,
0.19890476763248444,
-0.18340343236923218,
0.1713549941778183,
0.22975726425647736,
0.2029382437467575,
0.6178032755851746,
-0.27668753266334534,
0.2805340886116028,
0.019882861524820328,
-0.24418385326862335,
0.24024029076099396,
-0.6082893013954163,
-0.4324847459793091,
0.3702697157859802,
0.2191952019929886,
0.46881425380706787,
0.09018756449222565,
-0.12420055270195007,
0.4964968264102936,
0.16175781190395355,
-0.2023814171552658,
-0.7397415041923523,
0.20226550102233887,
-0.18629425764083862,
-0.01630754955112934,
0.4576054513454437,
0.664720892906189,
0.3306509256362915,
-0.6960894465446472,
0.293430894613266,
0.4766599237918854,
-0.419797420501709,
-0.3016767203807831,
0.40942320227622986,
0.20578959584236145,
-0.16482867300510406,
0.18800148367881775,
-0.2555597126483917,
0.1379527747631073,
0.5922681093215942,
0.33119890093803406,
1.155836820602417,
-0.4225187599658966,
0.18754440546035767,
0.2348421812057495,
0.6203462481498718,
-0.17555806040763855,
0.15167392790317535,
-0.22576560080051422,
-0.6537008881568909,
-0.4407476782798767,
0.07494295388460159,
-0.2882985770702362,
-0.13280753791332245,
-0.8324828743934631,
0.41865798830986023,
-0.7297528982162476,
-0.24488213658332825,
0.12956856191158295,
-0.7298312783241272,
-0.5541002154350281,
-0.050947196781635284,
-0.1971825510263443,
0.7897502779960632,
-0.6089173555374146,
0.8261601328849792,
-0.010792343877255917,
-0.6553307771682739,
-0.5704649090766907,
0.18533410131931305,
0.073227658867836,
-0.47029489278793335,
0.46574029326438904,
-0.17313453555107117,
-0.24768689274787903,
-0.2880653440952301,
-0.5404220819473267,
-0.9703342914581299,
0.5214216709136963,
0.5656366944313049,
-0.39460626244544983,
-0.1018371433019638,
-0.1094028651714325,
0.3343099355697632,
-0.17245087027549744,
0.17245465517044067,
0.7263092398643494,
0.46208101511001587,
-0.27199405431747437,
-0.7947157025337219,
-0.05543118342757225,
-0.45024794340133667,
-0.03773607686161995,
0.47823891043663025,
-0.5050207376480103,
1.095745325088501,
-0.26814454793930054,
-0.5041301250457764,
0.2571471035480499,
0.22807395458221436,
-0.3045564293861389,
0.15086746215820312,
0.44390419125556946,
0.2548806667327881,
0.9491079449653625,
0.03331812098622322,
1.4745415449142456,
0.06046178564429283,
0.0038751065731048584,
1.0049408674240112,
-0.2769508361816406,
0.9415115118026733,
0.7717182040214539,
0.054490040987730026,
0.38622134923934937,
0.45800355076789856,
0.529844343662262,
0.7545949220657349,
-0.019671089947223663,
-0.38449305295944214,
-0.18690474331378937,
-0.2218293696641922,
-0.25764983892440796,
0.5153555274009705,
0.3820091187953949,
-0.2111477255821228,
-0.07660841196775436,
0.06545566767454147,
0.11768804490566254,
0.0460284985601902,
-0.4406942129135132,
0.971054196357727,
-0.12943045794963837,
-0.8694117665290833,
1.2013065814971924,
-0.22961340844631195,
0.32672953605651855,
-0.38011884689331055,
0.10155553370714188,
-0.4178590178489685,
0.16032856702804565,
-0.33298805356025696,
-0.740615963935852,
0.4621880352497101,
-0.331447958946228,
-0.6456559300422668,
-0.2201705276966095,
0.4918639361858368,
-0.2727472484111786,
-0.3697822093963623,
0.5019994378089905,
0.43621253967285156,
0.07118988782167435,
0.00709655974060297,
-0.2618419826030731,
-0.4077194929122925,
0.00946443248540163,
-0.1634916216135025,
0.1809183806180954,
0.507967472076416,
-0.3013246953487396,
0.7500380873680115,
0.2979208528995514,
0.3723810017108917,
-0.17296692728996277,
0.322605699300766,
0.7058582305908203,
-0.8931251168251038,
-0.8245675563812256,
-0.5603189468383789,
0.37034279108047485,
-0.17533327639102936,
-0.17530690133571625,
0.7446464896202087,
0.45054250955581665,
0.5986186265945435,
0.020297657698392868,
1.2189350128173828,
-0.026837654411792755,
0.4942483603954315,
-0.7300370335578918,
0.4744125306606293,
-0.4990856945514679,
0.24025939404964447,
-0.39853551983833313,
-0.7146790027618408,
-0.31178316473960876,
0.3373016119003296,
-0.2969145178794861,
-0.11035728454589844,
1.5225504636764526,
0.6043633818626404,
0.2142268270254135,
0.08531533926725388,
0.6275147795677185,
0.1291259378194809,
0.07015570253133774,
0.04193219915032387,
0.7493976950645447,
-0.5333408713340759,
0.6163663864135742,
-0.3132427930831909,
-0.1262761652469635,
-0.08832824230194092,
-0.5638322830200195,
-0.6568441390991211,
-0.9971333146095276,
-0.48492226004600525,
-0.31247153878211975,
0.0987386479973793,
0.7989373803138733,
0.3921523094177246,
-0.5561618208885193,
-0.3428012430667877,
-0.1962273120880127,
0.26650694012641907,
-0.3071388304233551,
-0.16762775182724,
0.13752511143684387,
-0.5813310742378235,
-0.4926292598247528,
0.4620630741119385,
0.529021143913269,
0.1781376749277115,
0.24105946719646454,
0.13668997585773468,
-0.15896309912204742,
0.0285349041223526,
0.43273523449897766,
0.2570466697216034,
-0.7780561447143555,
-0.6169649958610535,
-0.15332335233688354,
-0.3027908205986023,
0.18293221294879913,
0.8044367432594299,
-0.6722202897071838,
0.033020567148923874,
0.8302035331726074,
0.2607264220714569,
0.1820349544286728,
-0.18103426694869995,
0.6883087754249573,
-1.1156024932861328,
0.9229903817176819,
0.0863632932305336,
0.6686619520187378,
-0.04332362860441208,
-0.4852292537689209,
0.5525341629981995,
0.37935036420822144,
-0.32006198167800903,
-0.5478324294090271,
0.1529851108789444,
-0.9802418351173401,
-0.5974462628364563,
1.3696330785751343,
0.06387786567211151,
-0.7694586515426636,
-0.6333540081977844,
0.00450889253988862,
-0.2966681718826294,
-0.5445080995559692,
0.508884847164154,
0.6940880417823792,
0.11158207058906555,
-0.6060835123062134,
-0.32098495960235596,
0.5135969519615173,
0.616838276386261,
-0.5831109285354614,
0.016165779903531075,
0.6494253873825073,
0.033819738775491714,
0.10789068788290024,
1.0517719984054565,
0.49910637736320496,
0.6542757749557495,
0.4192793071269989,
0.20233644545078278,
0.49285078048706055,
-0.24494682252407074,
-0.033308930695056915,
0.2224084436893463,
0.07324216514825821,
-0.33551862835884094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20830v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20830v1
|
Self-Augmented Preference Optimization: Off-Policy Paradigms for Language Model Alignment
| 2024-05-31T14:21:04
| 2024-05-31T14:21:04
|
Yueqin Yin, Zhendong Wang, Yujia Xie, Weizhu Chen, Mingyuan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditional language model alignment methods, such as Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO), are limited by their dependence on static, pre-collected
paired preference data, which hampers their adaptability and practical
applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce Self-Augmented
Preference Optimization (SAPO), an effective and scalable training paradigm
that does not require existing paired data. Building on the self-play concept,
which autonomously generates negative responses, we further incorporate an
off-policy learning pipeline to enhance data exploration and exploitation.
Specifically, we employ an Exponential Moving Average (EMA) model in
conjunction with a replay buffer to enable dynamic updates of response
segments, effectively integrating real-time feedback with insights from
historical data. Our comprehensive evaluations of the LLaMA3-8B and Mistral-7B
models across benchmarks, including the Open LLM Leaderboard, IFEval,
AlpacaEval 2.0, and MT-Bench, demonstrate that SAPO matches or surpasses
established offline contrastive baselines, such as DPO and Odds Ratio
Preference Optimization, and outperforms offline self-play methods like SPIN.
Our code is available at https://github.com/yinyueqin/SAPO
|
[
-0.180790975689888,
-0.4306482672691345,
0.4997471570968628,
0.2637040615081787,
-0.11778797954320908,
0.2638602554798126,
-0.282557874917984,
-0.15688952803611755,
0.4722227156162262,
0.777001678943634,
-0.6276143193244934,
-0.16058744490146637,
-0.2993474006652832,
-0.13741381466388702,
-0.06493561714887619,
1.0071442127227783,
-0.003227352164685726,
0.08265797048807144,
-0.10917975753545761,
-0.17481163144111633,
-0.34744635224342346,
-0.45845550298690796,
-0.4525333046913147,
-0.06618611514568329,
0.22954422235488892,
0.6238117814064026,
0.40837979316711426,
0.8859508633613586,
0.2800489068031311,
0.2891012728214264,
0.16995152831077576,
0.20680974423885345,
-0.43771666288375854,
0.191996768116951,
-0.0542326346039772,
-0.21668921411037445,
-0.7133636474609375,
-0.028986992314457893,
0.47914808988571167,
0.0877431109547615,
-0.5450977683067322,
0.2080836445093155,
-0.1071256697177887,
0.7446187138557434,
-0.620415449142456,
-0.09413766860961914,
-0.7405641674995422,
-0.04383983090519905,
-0.07216852903366089,
-0.2134084701538086,
-0.2863384783267975,
-0.38142281770706177,
0.23823240399360657,
-0.7232267260551453,
-0.11663491278886795,
0.31785327196121216,
0.784260630607605,
0.45170077681541443,
-0.26920977234840393,
-0.21136358380317688,
-0.7778472900390625,
1.0077362060546875,
-0.7969628572463989,
0.33546319603919983,
0.36495447158813477,
0.20591329038143158,
-0.10147362947463989,
-0.06653452664613724,
-0.49525946378707886,
-0.2055833339691162,
0.2393498718738556,
0.18285873532295227,
-0.026280486956238747,
0.16508597135543823,
-0.14488089084625244,
0.3194844424724579,
-0.47444242238998413,
0.4392044246196747,
-0.11874907463788986,
0.0011555067030712962,
0.576646625995636,
-0.024339547380805016,
0.33369889855384827,
-0.0852072611451149,
-0.6269488334655762,
0.017099324613809586,
-0.7877611517906189,
0.06798466295003891,
0.4852192997932434,
0.40764129161834717,
-0.021383455023169518,
0.3896072804927826,
-0.14850857853889465,
0.7659485340118408,
0.41804179549217224,
-0.01318103726953268,
0.2882675528526306,
-0.1328689306974411,
-0.04007808491587639,
0.3228575587272644,
0.8076428771018982,
0.23181042075157166,
-0.1454085409641266,
-0.19466949999332428,
-0.23294448852539062,
-0.13103100657463074,
0.248937726020813,
-0.40159422159194946,
0.09279618412256241,
0.41234520077705383,
-0.08716122061014175,
-0.6038013100624084,
-0.446927934885025,
-0.8166932463645935,
-0.14499929547309875,
-0.45543062686920166,
0.3674182891845703,
-0.17496101558208466,
-0.21839283406734467,
-0.042576007544994354,
0.19128936529159546,
0.15795131027698517,
0.22814546525478363,
-1.5274220705032349,
0.459199458360672,
0.5892093777656555,
0.7565264105796814,
-0.35347193479537964,
-0.419784814119339,
-0.4663381278514862,
0.22819185256958008,
-0.34413501620292664,
0.6926074028015137,
-0.5242726802825928,
-0.14600013196468353,
-0.27101826667785645,
-0.39269405603408813,
0.051604826003313065,
-0.36543571949005127,
0.5361375212669373,
-0.5288175344467163,
0.3371172249317169,
0.00650289561599493,
-0.521424412727356,
0.13519559800624847,
0.2795715034008026,
-0.5916227698326111,
1.4984831809997559,
0.13935789465904236,
-0.33604463934898376,
0.42471373081207275,
-0.6520707011222839,
-0.09672078490257263,
-0.3736073970794678,
-0.264850914478302,
-0.4629032611846924,
0.07174868136644363,
0.3274676501750946,
0.17749473452568054,
-0.3870178759098053,
0.3028871715068817,
-0.5380877256393433,
-0.1272667646408081,
-0.1504540890455246,
0.009918675757944584,
0.5128152370452881,
0.12395786494016647,
-0.5772336721420288,
0.29676157236099243,
-0.9415290951728821,
-0.04188614338636398,
0.2040361613035202,
-0.061688825488090515,
-0.513178825378418,
0.28808486461639404,
-0.32712194323539734,
0.6411173343658447,
0.4809803068637848,
-0.79639732837677,
0.34231269359588623,
-0.514277994632721,
0.4577396810054779,
1.1058363914489746,
-0.43841785192489624,
0.5835456252098083,
0.10322768241167068,
0.563328742980957,
-0.24553924798965454,
0.38743072748184204,
0.10742068290710449,
-0.0687686949968338,
-0.6150385737419128,
-0.38351863622665405,
0.29095032811164856,
0.5159370303153992,
-0.28125444054603577,
0.6416324973106384,
-0.3751608431339264,
-0.259277880191803,
-0.7377658486366272,
0.37668511271476746,
0.2982253134250641,
0.8505582809448242,
0.47900038957595825,
-0.10135939717292786,
-0.6669774651527405,
-0.8797376155853271,
-0.06859364360570908,
-0.20688465237617493,
0.3250657320022583,
0.6068612933158875,
-0.11021234095096588,
0.027460254728794098,
1.2571440935134888,
-0.5038737058639526,
-0.31365522742271423,
-0.26359695196151733,
-0.011140266433358192,
0.020065149292349815,
0.3525998592376709,
0.541976809501648,
-0.47131258249282837,
-0.5914783477783203,
0.06260889768600464,
-0.5011465549468994,
-0.21859773993492126,
-0.04411426559090614,
-0.1297367662191391,
0.4148905575275421,
0.16415125131607056,
0.025778966024518013,
-0.1599748283624649,
1.0878145694732666,
0.10977466404438019,
0.13090574741363525,
-0.3884091079235077,
0.07724237442016602,
-0.9748344421386719,
0.0328214168548584,
-0.13087184727191925,
-0.15041814744472504,
-0.6540505886077881,
-0.1949058324098587,
0.0454862043261528,
-0.11745837330818176,
-0.43237459659576416,
0.7979245185852051,
-0.5633366107940674,
-0.0873599573969841,
-0.42244887351989746,
0.3371937572956085,
-0.05140741541981697,
0.6414086222648621,
0.33358338475227356,
0.763421893119812,
0.5273638367652893,
-0.4640902280807495,
0.09087727963924408,
0.18385343253612518,
0.015566276386380196,
0.029226254671812057,
-0.4723314046859741,
0.3916756808757782,
0.08982060104608536,
0.15004225075244904,
-0.8421194553375244,
0.17123456299304962,
0.13891921937465668,
-0.20093399286270142,
0.44728273153305054,
-0.3805467486381531,
-0.12037874758243561,
-0.10102882236242294,
-0.5782696604728699,
0.4753836691379547,
0.4880366623401642,
-0.8844159841537476,
0.5351388454437256,
0.7346798777580261,
-0.01286831870675087,
-0.9781093001365662,
-0.25390487909317017,
-0.08639828860759735,
-0.35489916801452637,
-0.24262744188308716,
0.31306228041648865,
0.1005956307053566,
0.0007308869389817119,
-0.41242578625679016,
-0.08458442986011505,
0.07886210083961487,
0.044009845703840256,
-0.0735207125544548,
0.576264500617981,
-0.01810002699494362,
-0.033172909170389175,
0.20271587371826172,
-0.16311709582805634,
-0.23726022243499756,
-0.1218208372592926,
0.6226767301559448,
-0.06368502229452133,
-0.0996631309390068,
-0.01372268795967102,
0.004982436541467905,
0.3493891954421997,
-0.30707797408103943,
0.418351948261261,
0.11873435974121094,
0.018378006294369698,
-0.12865355610847473,
-0.5639721751213074,
-0.07258912175893784,
-0.5023368000984192,
0.149147167801857,
-0.31859269738197327,
-0.8202447295188904,
0.3518090844154358,
-0.09171246737241745,
0.056101586669683456,
0.3016658127307892,
0.4390544891357422,
-0.18344762921333313,
1.168088674545288,
0.52499920129776,
-0.3550437390804291,
0.7531718611717224,
-0.02412934973835945,
0.1808060109615326,
-0.9826390743255615,
0.08592161536216736,
-0.28195720911026,
-0.0937499850988388,
-0.8660542964935303,
-0.22986508905887604,
0.07127358764410019,
0.13555128872394562,
-0.243361234664917,
0.547465980052948,
-0.5561923980712891,
0.311407208442688,
0.5142089128494263,
0.05199123173952103,
0.14377731084823608,
-0.16020166873931885,
0.06338052451610565,
-0.16491003334522247,
-0.8251045346260071,
-0.553183376789093,
1.4204444885253906,
0.40707147121429443,
0.9167268872261047,
0.08068633079528809,
1.0617469549179077,
0.3247021734714508,
0.1747356653213501,
-0.6320524215698242,
0.3240572512149811,
-0.15980540215969086,
-0.6780127882957458,
-0.5816653966903687,
-0.31556975841522217,
-0.7851595878601074,
0.2208968698978424,
-0.22497040033340454,
-0.6762491464614868,
0.2689257562160492,
0.8305795192718506,
-0.41829413175582886,
0.1979890763759613,
-0.5911778211593628,
0.872519850730896,
-0.8039126992225647,
-0.4253551959991455,
-0.21490256488323212,
-0.6271756887435913,
0.2175752967596054,
-0.19233568012714386,
0.16282068192958832,
-0.4042593538761139,
-0.20284053683280945,
0.43553853034973145,
-0.2601926028728485,
0.6993482112884521,
-0.056086938828229904,
-0.11193416267633438,
0.2421555072069168,
0.0005451275501400232,
0.6274546384811401,
-0.2907784879207611,
-0.04533335939049721,
0.2672247886657715,
-0.043724171817302704,
-0.45656177401542664,
-0.8448346257209778,
0.9680883288383484,
-0.8964203596115112,
-0.6266504526138306,
-0.5365270972251892,
-0.16667300462722778,
-0.34142205119132996,
0.11034420877695084,
-0.155030757188797,
0.29265227913856506,
-0.49030792713165283,
-0.28685879707336426,
0.5261912941932678,
0.018662704154849052,
0.417606383562088,
0.5983176827430725,
-0.3253423273563385,
-0.5145519375801086,
1.1893823146820068,
0.03288218379020691,
0.4669344127178192,
0.5092382431030273,
0.6217129230499268,
-0.5207882523536682,
-0.4712986648082733,
-0.9568049311637878,
0.168040931224823,
-0.23820380866527557,
0.07558277249336243,
-0.48125848174095154,
0.21238625049591064,
-0.5375145077705383,
-0.05526423826813698,
-0.7037357687950134,
-0.6312820911407471,
-0.23839658498764038,
0.01465601846575737,
0.2085818201303482,
0.5222209095954895,
-0.14091446995735168,
0.20858082175254822,
-0.6121307015419006,
-0.07124355435371399,
0.12205647677183151,
0.35255756974220276,
-0.10094741731882095,
-0.6573439836502075,
-0.3139866590499878,
-0.06247416138648987,
-0.2648836672306061,
-0.7909224629402161,
0.4278840124607086,
0.17512290179729462,
0.5863380432128906,
0.48964858055114746,
-0.0019971071742475033,
0.5423757433891296,
-0.8213104009628296,
0.5207870602607727,
0.03158782050013542,
-0.9847238063812256,
0.8669938445091248,
-0.4614328145980835,
-0.04639064520597458,
0.7147780656814575,
0.45914188027381897,
-0.3410710096359253,
-0.05168651044368744,
-0.6015613079071045,
-0.8050100803375244,
0.9003322124481201,
-0.09446603059768677,
0.15633855760097504,
-0.02196194976568222,
0.27883976697921753,
0.127268984913826,
0.22927658259868622,
-0.67228764295578,
-0.316448450088501,
-0.35281312465667725,
-0.18960128724575043,
-0.057804107666015625,
-0.2222689837217331,
-0.2409321367740631,
0.07813197374343872,
0.9648298025131226,
-0.4096468389034271,
0.0991600975394249,
-0.06193294748663902,
-0.0894329771399498,
-0.043615445494651794,
0.25864148139953613,
0.7307953834533691,
0.5549629330635071,
-0.49825164675712585,
-0.18164266645908356,
0.1292014718055725,
-0.15940716862678528,
0.324947327375412,
-0.0048092021606862545,
-0.14686964452266693,
-0.3853895366191864,
-0.2118031084537506,
0.9579647183418274,
0.2590502202510834,
-0.687354326248169,
0.3675481975078583,
0.15556854009628296,
0.22890712320804596,
-0.1765495389699936,
0.04450790211558342,
-0.30924034118652344,
-0.20079468190670013,
-0.009447526186704636,
-0.1580851823091507,
0.3058871626853943,
-0.6605451703071594,
0.008131692185997963,
0.4659978151321411,
-0.4921524226665497,
-0.34505289793014526,
0.4751377999782562,
0.39542725682258606,
-0.2562636137008667,
0.1855795681476593,
0.12186074256896973,
-0.5321270227432251,
0.3941337466239929,
0.7968809008598328,
0.8629104495048523,
-0.3973594903945923,
0.25867095589637756,
0.3041142225265503,
0.19741535186767578,
-0.07360869646072388,
0.12575054168701172,
-0.28786030411720276,
-0.9931561350822449,
-0.36056920886039734,
-0.3179076015949249,
-0.6721490621566772,
-0.03867298364639282,
-0.7571372389793396,
0.47230273485183716,
-0.5682296752929688,
0.011463304981589317,
-0.23183982074260712,
-0.1094520315527916,
-0.2024218589067459,
0.3117748498916626,
0.0991496816277504,
0.437633752822876,
-0.9195944666862488,
1.0162771940231323,
0.616344690322876,
-0.4174971282482147,
-0.5577976107597351,
-0.13756775856018066,
0.09941955655813217,
-1.1697940826416016,
0.495645672082901,
-0.2975974678993225,
-0.3569469451904297,
0.12735813856124878,
-0.24614112079143524,
-1.3922356367111206,
0.9308530688285828,
0.36284932494163513,
-0.6283130049705505,
-0.0030398613307625055,
-0.06153477728366852,
0.6216608285903931,
-0.4779631793498993,
0.5337066650390625,
0.616481602191925,
0.09643612802028656,
-0.024632493034005165,
-0.8930666446685791,
-0.023151805624365807,
0.2543545365333557,
-0.02913650870323181,
0.5449342727661133,
-1.138859748840332,
0.18270498514175415,
-0.07242143154144287,
0.15185748040676117,
-0.34657004475593567,
0.6146233677864075,
0.3343748450279236,
-0.08509598672389984,
0.5517162680625916,
0.6929547786712646,
0.31608399748802185,
0.09350568056106567,
0.8746606707572937,
-0.6892338991165161,
0.47013014554977417,
1.4909710884094238,
-0.5089117288589478,
1.0648846626281738,
0.7210935950279236,
-0.1512693613767624,
0.4541642963886261,
0.8392999172210693,
0.22879326343536377,
0.7409038543701172,
-0.04575630649924278,
-0.08478416502475739,
-0.24872338771820068,
0.03505367785692215,
-0.14214785397052765,
0.652396023273468,
0.09417857229709625,
-0.26952943205833435,
-0.0756753459572792,
-0.1797371804714203,
-0.025520941242575645,
0.11493264138698578,
-0.14373622834682465,
0.7949118614196777,
-0.19479088485240936,
-0.741990864276886,
0.41546714305877686,
-0.17540262639522552,
0.6755397915840149,
-0.7578514814376831,
-0.0048897708766162395,
-0.28950709104537964,
0.0596696212887764,
-0.05802171677350998,
-0.4746320843696594,
0.16270850598812103,
-0.16329853236675262,
-0.1364634931087494,
-0.35266855359077454,
0.4669659435749054,
-0.4966173470020294,
-0.21188443899154663,
0.507158637046814,
0.33181053400039673,
0.0014357945183292031,
0.33651670813560486,
-0.9646007418632507,
-0.057799533009529114,
0.06275862455368042,
-0.2886001169681549,
0.5770600438117981,
-0.0412280336022377,
-0.16898173093795776,
0.6879476308822632,
0.523110032081604,
0.17728905379772186,
0.11487270146608353,
0.04808680713176727,
0.67763751745224,
-0.4320451021194458,
-0.5022722482681274,
-0.7755472660064697,
0.06409668177366257,
-0.06107040122151375,
-0.5825631618499756,
0.8048444390296936,
0.834723711013794,
0.8213847875595093,
0.1529950201511383,
0.5414502024650574,
0.07448620349168777,
0.6376658082008362,
-0.5418660044670105,
0.3741300702095032,
-0.6260039210319519,
0.256917268037796,
-0.2963392734527588,
-0.9553584456443787,
0.03768641874194145,
0.3766842186450958,
-0.5725686550140381,
-0.02190212905406952,
0.3534294068813324,
0.6412188410758972,
-0.11251183599233627,
-0.19256305694580078,
0.27772510051727295,
-0.09234681725502014,
0.09351260960102081,
0.11292175203561783,
0.582108736038208,
-0.3285229504108429,
0.27545860409736633,
-0.3540913760662079,
-0.4835813641548157,
-0.09981393069028854,
-1.06759774684906,
-0.620976984500885,
-0.42652079463005066,
-0.21459020674228668,
-0.31354373693466187,
0.1612953543663025,
1.3437250852584839,
0.7527198791503906,
-0.8589876294136047,
-0.6395999789237976,
-0.005899157840758562,
-0.004929009824991226,
-0.17609179019927979,
-0.17962700128555298,
0.4150923788547516,
-0.44708025455474854,
-0.8675093650817871,
0.7098997235298157,
0.5111686587333679,
0.130201518535614,
-0.44351333379745483,
-0.20263643562793732,
-0.445995032787323,
0.34843650460243225,
0.450080931186676,
0.770287036895752,
-0.8057376742362976,
-0.1360345482826233,
0.1651175618171692,
-0.047444235533475876,
0.5268422961235046,
0.8705329895019531,
-0.6469789147377014,
0.8195096254348755,
0.4219025671482086,
0.7152583003044128,
0.6848908066749573,
0.24652314186096191,
0.8680770397186279,
-0.5509032607078552,
-0.03860662877559662,
0.20280209183692932,
0.17529423534870148,
0.2042151391506195,
-0.5456270575523376,
0.47498810291290283,
-0.04747613146901131,
-0.6707491874694824,
-0.8428798913955688,
0.04029613733291626,
-0.8393502235412598,
0.08624749630689621,
0.975440502166748,
-0.1189768984913826,
-0.32133203744888306,
0.16049602627754211,
-0.11309804767370224,
-0.059016283601522446,
-0.667313277721405,
1.0239063501358032,
0.5868796706199646,
-0.6228824853897095,
-0.13553772866725922,
-0.2151438295841217,
0.7312950491905212,
0.8879550099372864,
-0.8192828893661499,
0.025437502190470695,
0.3393309712409973,
0.3747626543045044,
-0.05820709839463234,
0.8687012791633606,
0.04949691519141197,
0.012000461108982563,
-0.28138870000839233,
0.5143649578094482,
0.034318700432777405,
-0.35573285818099976,
-0.7560674548149109,
-0.5420145988464355,
0.14056502282619476,
-0.39138394594192505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20818v2
|
An iterated learning model of language change that mixes supervised and unsupervised learning
| 2024-05-31T14:14:01
| 2024-06-15T15:25:01
|
Jack Bunyan, Seth Bullock, Conor Houghton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, nlin.AO, q-bio.PE
|
The iterated learning model is an agent-based model of language change in
which language is transmitted from a tutor to a pupil which itself becomes a
tutor to a new pupil, and so on. Languages that are stable, expressive, and
compositional arise spontaneously as a consequence of a language transmission
bottleneck. Previous models have implemented an agent's mapping from signals to
meanings using an artificial neural network decoder, but have relied on an
unrealistic and computationally expensive process of obversion to implement the
associated encoder, mapping from meanings to signals. Here, a new model is
presented in which both decoder and encoder are neural networks, trained
separately through supervised learning, and trained together through
unsupervised learning in the form of an autoencoder. This avoids the
substantial computational burden entailed in obversion and introduces a mixture
of supervised and unsupervised learning as observed during human development.
|
[
-0.05512844771146774,
-0.5609947443008423,
0.22449010610580444,
0.05672958120703697,
-0.26349303126335144,
0.39666223526000977,
-0.41268491744995117,
-0.3367616832256317,
0.20157484710216522,
0.7777960896492004,
-0.40652996301651,
-0.13010556995868683,
-0.6383087635040283,
-0.1466408520936966,
-0.6428983211517334,
0.8114988803863525,
-0.2243596911430359,
0.10057922452688217,
-0.1284230351448059,
0.1644219607114792,
-0.22897064685821533,
-0.29521051049232483,
-0.596846878528595,
-0.8499298691749573,
0.23447810113430023,
0.2446093112230301,
0.5537577867507935,
0.8758295774459839,
0.22229401767253876,
0.42637065052986145,
0.20400768518447876,
-0.26565855741500854,
-0.294057160615921,
0.22040723264217377,
-0.3491397202014923,
-0.5090495944023132,
-0.031802017241716385,
0.12842686474323273,
0.6287025213241577,
1.2430949211120605,
-0.41075044870376587,
-0.06191931664943695,
0.1426326185464859,
0.8370882272720337,
-0.6078125238418579,
0.5111061930656433,
-0.6521407961845398,
-0.04740850627422333,
0.00023247741046361625,
-0.1766524761915207,
-0.5833202004432678,
-0.06813493371009827,
0.13196943700313568,
-0.2869730591773987,
0.11497543007135391,
-0.5271453261375427,
0.5212557315826416,
0.1577204316854477,
-0.496389776468277,
-0.264311820268631,
-0.9341843128204346,
0.4585692584514618,
-0.43064847588539124,
0.5209929347038269,
0.16692999005317688,
0.39860036969184875,
-0.13464109599590302,
-0.7767772078514099,
-0.4850780665874481,
-0.247610941529274,
-0.00031519943149760365,
0.18639706075191498,
-0.12660036981105804,
-0.13794061541557312,
-0.4652867317199707,
0.2512533366680145,
-0.2938591241836548,
0.12836171686649323,
-0.6306298971176147,
0.059283871203660965,
0.7781689763069153,
0.19493338465690613,
0.2662336230278015,
0.1216360479593277,
-0.4322526156902313,
-0.4129008948802948,
-0.5204841494560242,
0.18964651226997375,
0.3908708393573761,
0.5499105453491211,
-0.026081068441271782,
0.44403812289237976,
-0.13892289996147156,
0.8461217880249023,
0.3282596468925476,
-0.06566117703914642,
0.2530822157859802,
0.08942288905382156,
-0.12019243836402893,
0.22369548678398132,
0.8469403982162476,
0.11069707572460175,
0.48020318150520325,
-0.480338990688324,
-0.42779630422592163,
0.4342155456542969,
0.39444851875305176,
-0.6125732660293579,
-0.38785120844841003,
-0.04608931019902229,
-0.36956438422203064,
-0.3952925503253937,
0.12499453127384186,
-0.557757556438446,
-0.20060330629348755,
-0.47977450489997864,
0.34472933411598206,
-0.44761133193969727,
-0.6679275035858154,
0.20766174793243408,
0.046001315116882324,
0.08245087414979935,
0.07969382405281067,
-1.06332266330719,
0.5354843139648438,
0.3265905976295471,
0.5125912427902222,
-0.2732163965702057,
-0.817646861076355,
0.09304182976484299,
-0.021999500691890717,
-0.6472988128662109,
0.7763616442680359,
-0.6380093693733215,
-0.24613213539123535,
0.17995047569274902,
0.12412752211093903,
-0.574990451335907,
-0.5136787295341492,
-0.40677493810653687,
-0.8863094449043274,
0.19224371016025543,
0.33527302742004395,
-0.7611438632011414,
-0.41240841150283813,
-0.006196410395205021,
-0.766835629940033,
0.8570212721824646,
0.4102625250816345,
-0.35319289565086365,
0.263423353433609,
-0.6509934067726135,
-0.450559139251709,
0.22843211889266968,
-0.004590091295540333,
-0.3432008624076843,
0.039049796760082245,
-0.17023102939128876,
0.2931268513202667,
-0.3211279511451721,
0.5030050277709961,
0.1456974595785141,
-0.27792835235595703,
0.5101103186607361,
-0.35847243666648865,
1.0412815809249878,
0.1775180697441101,
-0.40464767813682556,
0.16402538120746613,
-0.8624106049537659,
-0.07234953343868256,
0.3309335708618164,
-0.6468995809555054,
-0.2655124068260193,
0.08445841819047928,
-0.16153334081172943,
0.3457147181034088,
0.3477731943130493,
-0.49966099858283997,
0.4494725465774536,
-0.5875546932220459,
0.5223389267921448,
0.47265249490737915,
0.20769871771335602,
0.8745090365409851,
-0.32995307445526123,
0.1743534803390503,
0.3216327726840973,
0.16773033142089844,
-0.32134580612182617,
-0.3785122036933899,
-0.9863513708114624,
0.011104448698461056,
0.09673411399126053,
0.33982306718826294,
-0.8222583532333374,
0.2814509868621826,
-0.13661952316761017,
-0.32274383306503296,
-0.8674559593200684,
0.24306179583072662,
0.08490006625652313,
0.23811273276805878,
0.3108479082584381,
-0.4301169216632843,
-0.45866936445236206,
-0.38148942589759827,
-0.08245684206485748,
-0.2500832974910736,
0.14479555189609528,
-0.37547212839126587,
0.6623300313949585,
-0.5165428519248962,
0.7934371829032898,
-0.0854569673538208,
-0.3998035192489624,
-0.31737059354782104,
0.2607569694519043,
-0.13219548761844635,
0.5477249622344971,
0.3233659565448761,
-0.5196303725242615,
-0.5103468894958496,
0.14639897644519806,
-0.6564041376113892,
0.04491344466805458,
-0.26910844445228577,
0.13267436623573303,
0.17406320571899414,
0.6609255075454712,
-0.29600492119789124,
0.45579034090042114,
0.5205628871917725,
-0.38858917355537415,
0.3568589389324188,
-0.4139084219932556,
-0.06744876503944397,
-1.0903239250183105,
-0.34825679659843445,
-0.4975586235523224,
0.014019790105521679,
-0.6512377858161926,
0.20043209195137024,
0.12056040018796921,
0.25595560669898987,
-0.35465800762176514,
0.457148015499115,
-0.8522114157676697,
-0.25882720947265625,
-0.6607500314712524,
0.11592534929513931,
-0.19219434261322021,
0.5799362063407898,
0.11819370836019516,
0.5092761516571045,
1.0464797019958496,
-0.6490989923477173,
0.687035858631134,
0.02371698059141636,
-0.06697648018598557,
0.2852393686771393,
-0.3291914165019989,
0.24240157008171082,
-0.24984410405158997,
-0.1933969408273697,
-0.7229507565498352,
-0.15502066910266876,
0.17450067400932312,
-0.4732745885848999,
0.3628850281238556,
-0.01732655055820942,
-0.5045545101165771,
-0.20872263610363007,
0.0031632822938263416,
0.36603060364723206,
0.44334712624549866,
-0.7120561599731445,
0.8560878038406372,
0.17920786142349243,
0.29098254442214966,
-0.2898329496383667,
-0.5889134407043457,
0.1458423137664795,
0.21762670576572418,
-0.4324036240577698,
0.23167529702186584,
0.06407181918621063,
-0.30733412504196167,
0.5752182602882385,
0.32293403148651123,
-0.44002220034599304,
0.15758870542049408,
0.30410224199295044,
0.19872821867465973,
-0.34400829672813416,
0.14479538798332214,
0.033331796526908875,
-0.22174735367298126,
0.10558734089136124,
-0.5880969166755676,
0.6430826187133789,
0.012010660953819752,
-0.5342196822166443,
-0.25047969818115234,
0.5278615355491638,
0.6337440013885498,
-0.5081216096878052,
1.018694281578064,
0.1267254650592804,
-0.23535697162151337,
-0.46986523270606995,
-0.02393677830696106,
-0.3022247552871704,
-0.4725625514984131,
0.3036710321903229,
-0.31216615438461304,
-0.6255927681922913,
0.608812153339386,
-0.25946518778800964,
-0.010367851704359055,
0.4627332389354706,
0.6811729669570923,
0.010622565634548664,
0.9732608795166016,
0.9176456332206726,
-0.04921245202422142,
0.6852814555168152,
-0.4040565490722656,
-0.04439633712172508,
-0.5568705797195435,
-0.4204433262348175,
-0.11219651997089386,
-0.10525596141815186,
-0.7239824533462524,
-0.3250313103199005,
0.017880920320749283,
0.019706737250089645,
-0.5193777084350586,
0.35227832198143005,
-0.39130815863609314,
0.5141389966011047,
0.720923125743866,
0.07089857012033463,
0.41845691204071045,
-0.028309842571616173,
-0.29060956835746765,
0.38419410586357117,
-0.64463210105896,
-0.28036367893218994,
1.3187369108200073,
-0.017455046996474266,
0.9485688209533691,
0.2596909701824188,
0.6499272584915161,
0.09875717759132385,
0.41955024003982544,
-0.6596729755401611,
0.44695112109184265,
-0.11107081174850464,
-0.4874463379383087,
-0.1879677027463913,
-0.19636045396327972,
-1.254873514175415,
0.4116644859313965,
-0.18992003798484802,
-0.9385528564453125,
0.40732255578041077,
-0.01205515768378973,
0.19483886659145355,
0.5148823857307434,
-0.4364902377128601,
0.6126405000686646,
-0.2508643865585327,
-0.30284181237220764,
-0.13085703551769257,
-0.5725831389427185,
0.11862725019454956,
-0.16979946196079254,
-0.15829096734523773,
0.3621456027030945,
0.2861517667770386,
0.6756534576416016,
-0.4022549092769623,
1.1340993642807007,
-0.07257028669118881,
-0.04553358256816864,
0.463054358959198,
0.28473272919654846,
0.4271739423274994,
-0.423392117023468,
-0.021244410425424576,
-0.017811475321650505,
-0.29204869270324707,
-0.487714558839798,
-0.6004871129989624,
0.43700090050697327,
-1.146644115447998,
-0.4087047278881073,
-0.4434736371040344,
-0.632386326789856,
0.07506641000509262,
0.21213437616825104,
0.3967801034450531,
0.3292284905910492,
-0.14997413754463196,
-0.027755003422498703,
0.47842898964881897,
0.18139523267745972,
0.5958725214004517,
0.9762825965881348,
-0.4410552978515625,
-0.08476456999778748,
0.6809059977531433,
0.04158774018287659,
0.482110857963562,
0.3356170952320099,
0.127898171544075,
-0.16096945106983185,
-0.31191474199295044,
-0.4429996609687805,
0.28281939029693604,
-0.9605028629302979,
0.11328603327274323,
-0.32109248638153076,
-0.5437567830085754,
-0.4148843586444855,
-0.2016572803258896,
-0.838395893573761,
0.05933438986539841,
-0.3811572790145874,
-0.07793854922056198,
0.27691763639450073,
1.028689980506897,
-0.2848961353302002,
0.6794200539588928,
-0.4242537319660187,
-0.06029259040951729,
0.4283274710178375,
0.2979593873023987,
-0.025495585054159164,
-0.6721593141555786,
-0.3812328577041626,
0.2389696091413498,
-0.14649349451065063,
-1.262852668762207,
0.5764501094818115,
0.32931822538375854,
0.5898627042770386,
0.7761598229408264,
0.06970784068107605,
0.3301517963409424,
-0.4512413442134857,
0.45170632004737854,
0.16298727691173553,
-0.8377348184585571,
0.33576080203056335,
-0.12609146535396576,
0.26317664980888367,
0.308660626411438,
0.1555498242378235,
-0.5169812440872192,
-0.38981741666793823,
-0.5792543888092041,
-0.813866376876831,
0.7110984921455383,
-0.2285713255405426,
0.1969779133796692,
0.07774865627288818,
0.2393459677696228,
0.22169765830039978,
0.2878439426422119,
-0.7770556211471558,
-0.4355260133743286,
-0.4999111592769623,
-0.17328956723213196,
-0.2517700493335724,
-0.0568535178899765,
-0.05952749401330948,
-0.35543423891067505,
0.5703932046890259,
-0.17295955121517181,
0.5697660446166992,
-0.3213973045349121,
-0.5019886493682861,
-0.4413084387779236,
0.18329083919525146,
0.1653672158718109,
0.3970884382724762,
-0.03406614810228348,
0.2987136244773865,
-0.37236759066581726,
-0.37549230456352234,
0.32766127586364746,
0.21369417011737823,
-0.45317232608795166,
-0.03280903398990631,
0.49103236198425293,
1.2692822217941284,
0.2585526406764984,
-0.4199133813381195,
0.5658673644065857,
0.18248513340950012,
-0.35394203662872314,
-0.3737230896949768,
0.1251833438873291,
0.20208419859409332,
0.44833576679229736,
0.40865281224250793,
0.2474907636642456,
-0.016791587695479393,
-0.7775015830993652,
0.34121203422546387,
0.10273683071136475,
-0.539512574672699,
-0.6257395148277283,
0.6098522543907166,
-0.08408389240503311,
-0.444979727268219,
0.6782233119010925,
-0.28756633400917053,
-0.6168816089630127,
0.6289985775947571,
0.8978559374809265,
1.0340248346328735,
-0.7116912007331848,
0.6529192924499512,
0.14597740769386292,
0.496634840965271,
-0.29272007942199707,
0.1464606076478958,
-0.19626295566558838,
-1.1141120195388794,
-0.36440056562423706,
-0.45992544293403625,
-0.22752037644386292,
0.008710240013897419,
-0.8945134282112122,
-0.14715807139873505,
-0.18632739782333374,
0.16559715569019318,
0.023775067180395126,
-0.3268466293811798,
-0.7329409718513489,
0.2174348682165146,
-0.07937701046466827,
0.4963255524635315,
-1.1676923036575317,
1.179785132408142,
1.036855697631836,
-0.5962406396865845,
-0.8205273747444153,
0.04375818744301796,
-0.19934619963169098,
-0.8618252873420715,
0.7967504858970642,
-0.003629326820373535,
-0.19670340418815613,
0.3707905411720276,
-0.43221616744995117,
-0.9409817457199097,
0.8289257287979126,
0.36379584670066833,
-0.4661197364330292,
0.12398382276296616,
0.44276368618011475,
0.7729750871658325,
-0.6391597390174866,
0.2646646499633789,
0.5621138215065002,
0.04427540674805641,
0.10269999504089355,
-0.6638368964195251,
-0.2591463327407837,
-0.3157230615615845,
0.04877777025103569,
0.19070039689540863,
-0.4212464392185211,
1.4253263473510742,
-0.28653842210769653,
-0.3955222964286804,
-0.16588163375854492,
0.46106699109077454,
-0.36103060841560364,
0.04314902052283287,
0.3405248820781708,
0.2218514233827591,
0.5235843658447266,
-0.04395057633519173,
0.7317580580711365,
-0.6051944494247437,
0.47921067476272583,
1.1512361764907837,
-0.20121227204799652,
0.953833818435669,
0.42695152759552,
-0.06483472883701324,
0.7569418549537659,
0.5263537168502808,
0.2053382694721222,
0.7627413868904114,
0.10486756265163422,
-0.3057355582714081,
-0.26888006925582886,
0.16761867702007294,
0.027932653203606606,
0.807766854763031,
0.23909342288970947,
-0.5778517127037048,
-0.5561527609825134,
0.6402862668037415,
-0.16297048330307007,
0.3621212840080261,
-0.22229266166687012,
1.1148861646652222,
-0.13411954045295715,
-0.7292079925537109,
0.6716357469558716,
-0.003313059452921152,
0.36349427700042725,
-0.4987547993659973,
0.043350107967853546,
-0.25914132595062256,
0.4413677155971527,
0.03577188774943352,
-0.681756854057312,
0.23752529919147491,
-0.16598229110240936,
-0.17495030164718628,
-0.29653099179267883,
0.6306448578834534,
-0.8786454796791077,
-0.44045278429985046,
0.8915692567825317,
0.7396529912948608,
0.12569411098957062,
0.002328041708096862,
-0.6820701956748962,
-0.13802367448806763,
-0.10862353444099426,
-0.39854344725608826,
0.35290294885635376,
0.4507499933242798,
-0.28951579332351685,
0.8114337921142578,
0.4905141592025757,
0.1652640700340271,
0.42319026589393616,
0.1771441251039505,
1.1146284341812134,
-0.5123492479324341,
-0.5733999609947205,
-0.6987095475196838,
0.5223032832145691,
0.3158235549926758,
-0.023204820230603218,
0.499077171087265,
0.11619571596384048,
0.9104364514350891,
-0.13879142701625824,
0.7075487375259399,
0.1006195917725563,
0.21860750019550323,
-0.2696255147457123,
0.7157168388366699,
-0.5347604751586914,
0.20500227808952332,
0.00986212957650423,
-0.7804930806159973,
-0.033734992146492004,
0.6899126768112183,
-0.10969007760286331,
-0.00039933741209097207,
0.7218750715255737,
0.6091176271438599,
0.19988137483596802,
-0.00796068087220192,
0.3623296022415161,
0.30032843351364136,
0.03384989872574806,
0.4584202468395233,
0.8262608647346497,
-0.45332983136177063,
0.130368173122406,
-0.45388898253440857,
-0.2352687418460846,
-0.21555478870868683,
-0.43495726585388184,
-0.8874426484107971,
-1.1934727430343628,
-0.4985484480857849,
-0.16415859758853912,
0.2836994528770447,
0.9433340430259705,
0.4348312318325043,
-0.7598199844360352,
-0.5075358748435974,
-0.5333466529846191,
-0.17484800517559052,
-0.6440627574920654,
-0.25023460388183594,
0.3212285339832306,
-0.3646235167980194,
-0.7542357444763184,
0.4831741452217102,
0.11863844841718674,
0.047244761139154434,
-0.6407917737960815,
-0.004344159737229347,
-0.1900739222764969,
0.20102573931217194,
0.4181134104728699,
0.40965554118156433,
-0.46754518151283264,
-0.030697235837578773,
-0.014560477808117867,
-0.23035494983196259,
0.19301728904247284,
0.634037435054779,
-0.9491183161735535,
0.8722889423370361,
0.22287246584892273,
0.6602963209152222,
0.6236103773117065,
-0.34117767214775085,
0.5251508355140686,
-0.632114589214325,
0.2771402895450592,
-0.05274568125605583,
0.2899307608604431,
0.5075617432594299,
-0.2593807876110077,
0.17107301950454712,
0.44589900970458984,
-0.30828821659088135,
-0.5188744068145752,
0.19772179424762726,
-0.573070764541626,
-0.5241913795471191,
1.0364450216293335,
-0.1676466464996338,
-0.4605056047439575,
-0.21311284601688385,
0.010751727968454361,
0.6494937539100647,
-0.2986365854740143,
0.9586261510848999,
0.1909206211566925,
-0.05902804061770439,
-0.37251728773117065,
-0.25783130526542664,
0.3016066551208496,
-0.03665775805711746,
-0.6134212017059326,
-0.12638279795646667,
0.2844022512435913,
0.3999272882938385,
0.1895788460969925,
0.5452995896339417,
0.0949011743068695,
0.28182554244995117,
0.3231516182422638,
0.5111841559410095,
-0.04631556198000908,
-0.5695410966873169,
-0.2749127745628357,
0.0957106351852417,
-0.09449545294046402,
-0.5056869983673096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20805v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20805v2
|
Multilingual Text Style Transfer: Datasets & Models for Indian Languages
| 2024-05-31T14:05:27
| 2024-06-09T18:46:48
|
Sourabrata Mukherjee, Atul Kr. Ojha, Akanksha Bansal, Deepak Alok, John P. McCrae, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text style transfer (TST) involves altering the linguistic style of a text
while preserving its core content. This paper focuses on sentiment transfer, a
vital TST subtask (Mukherjee et al., 2022a), across a spectrum of Indian
languages: Hindi, Magahi, Malayalam, Marathi, Punjabi, Odia, Telugu, and Urdu,
expanding upon previous work on English-Bangla sentiment transfer (Mukherjee et
al., 2023). We introduce dedicated datasets of 1,000 positive and 1,000
negative style-parallel sentences for each of these eight languages. We then
evaluate the performance of various benchmark models categorized into parallel,
non-parallel, cross-lingual, and shared learning approaches, including the
Llama2 and GPT-3.5 large language models (LLMs). Our experiments highlight the
significance of parallel data in TST and demonstrate the effectiveness of the
Masked Style Filling (MSF) approach (Mukherjee et al., 2023) in non-parallel
techniques. Moreover, cross-lingual and joint multilingual learning methods
show promise, offering insights into selecting optimal models tailored to the
specific language and task requirements. To the best of our knowledge, this
work represents the first comprehensive exploration of the TST task as
sentiment transfer across a diverse set of languages.
|
[
-0.20423109829425812,
-0.5282319784164429,
0.22559817135334015,
0.7697990536689758,
-0.4724707007408142,
0.4447595179080963,
-0.38616907596588135,
-0.47686904668807983,
0.395685076713562,
0.12589024007320404,
-0.4863146245479584,
-0.39251723885536194,
-0.7202708125114441,
0.28461918234825134,
-0.43416208028793335,
1.1530686616897583,
-0.333537220954895,
-0.005402121227234602,
0.05142924189567566,
-0.20892107486724854,
-0.4725448191165924,
-0.8009282946586609,
-0.5289864540100098,
-0.16155005991458893,
0.26345890760421753,
0.4702351987361908,
0.3900253176689148,
0.07613689452409744,
0.6394566893577576,
0.2139243483543396,
0.21538758277893066,
-0.002750905230641365,
-0.28176388144493103,
0.07503940165042877,
-0.3926141560077667,
-0.4035951495170593,
-0.3266054093837738,
-0.16010671854019165,
0.5144619345664978,
0.3699148893356323,
-0.03711804002523422,
0.16285717487335205,
0.055614322423934937,
0.8929189443588257,
-0.29463061690330505,
0.4267491400241852,
-0.15538685023784637,
0.10242990404367447,
-0.6015617847442627,
-0.06175309792160988,
-0.5261731147766113,
-0.706929087638855,
0.021388044580817223,
-0.23325935006141663,
-0.16283605992794037,
-0.012946889735758305,
0.7952110171318054,
-0.10199980437755585,
-0.6592565774917603,
-0.34947240352630615,
-0.5848388075828552,
1.0162445306777954,
-0.4290846288204193,
0.46849289536476135,
0.2892969250679016,
0.23439310491085052,
0.7019931077957153,
-0.40668758749961853,
-0.45125672221183777,
0.08566981554031372,
-0.08576307445764542,
0.3819825351238251,
0.09416744112968445,
-0.28942736983299255,
-0.13524074852466583,
0.5718535780906677,
-0.5499090552330017,
-0.3292895257472992,
-0.5062916874885559,
0.06173066794872284,
0.5192385315895081,
0.10205584019422531,
0.5367951393127441,
-0.3414263427257538,
-0.5932039022445679,
-0.14631380140781403,
-0.49281588196754456,
0.020634891465306282,
0.23198029398918152,
0.5614439845085144,
-0.49299356341362,
0.40014052391052246,
-0.2445547729730606,
0.64614337682724,
-0.14047428965568542,
-0.41830718517303467,
0.32411691546440125,
-0.8710200190544128,
-0.06304950267076492,
-0.000022575830371351913,
0.7875211238861084,
0.5331884026527405,
0.6795233488082886,
-0.15071739256381989,
-0.1972617357969284,
0.10182038694620132,
-0.06271423399448395,
-0.5604519844055176,
0.06714725494384766,
-0.24283383786678314,
-0.39911410212516785,
-0.3302922248840332,
-0.24727803468704224,
-1.2586201429367065,
-0.5816075801849365,
-0.5850352644920349,
0.2985725998878479,
-0.50970458984375,
-0.6048054695129395,
0.14784350991249084,
0.10599366575479507,
0.6755368709564209,
0.23975464701652527,
-0.8754604458808899,
0.2640492618083954,
0.4355970323085785,
1.0745480060577393,
-0.34268319606781006,
-0.38760408759117126,
0.09433051943778992,
0.058201998472213745,
-0.43856188654899597,
0.9744302034378052,
-0.6796676516532898,
-0.5268533229827881,
0.16071274876594543,
-0.1971541792154312,
-0.3804986774921417,
-0.05345162749290466,
0.5940859913825989,
-0.25819411873817444,
0.1921921819448471,
-0.7104657888412476,
-0.052123114466667175,
-0.09818163514137268,
0.40578946471214294,
-0.3345171809196472,
0.9597716927528381,
0.04631578177213669,
-0.8237599730491638,
0.002335574245080352,
-0.6147693991661072,
-0.9823312759399414,
-0.2732521891593933,
0.20271265506744385,
-0.24114848673343658,
0.03219959884881973,
0.3230885863304138,
0.4281556010246277,
-0.31497645378112793,
-0.11380638927221298,
-0.27444231510162354,
-0.28905609250068665,
0.019061800092458725,
-0.13282173871994019,
0.8112449645996094,
0.4521976113319397,
-0.13984934985637665,
-0.014995299279689789,
-0.45831090211868286,
-0.13804891705513,
0.041110385209321976,
0.007665511220693588,
-0.3421107232570648,
-0.492023229598999,
0.6228418946266174,
0.44850918650627136,
0.24561554193496704,
-0.7457790374755859,
0.272164523601532,
0.036107346415519714,
0.5522087216377258,
0.8884202241897583,
-0.037859320640563965,
0.41746753454208374,
-0.37298592925071716,
0.6409143209457397,
0.09044761210680008,
0.1519409567117691,
-0.00794726051390171,
-0.2178191840648651,
-0.8749701976776123,
-0.03133843094110489,
0.2669549882411957,
0.8586633205413818,
-0.8990572094917297,
-0.4933363199234009,
-0.3893577456474304,
-0.5293238162994385,
-0.48273608088493347,
-0.09326156973838806,
0.385031133890152,
0.29410409927368164,
0.3867146074771881,
-0.12232794612646103,
-0.53284752368927,
-1.0558804273605347,
-0.5582270622253418,
-0.12413769215345383,
0.6676391363143921,
-0.13569672405719757,
0.1035432443022728,
0.10210298001766205,
0.5982269644737244,
-0.252951055765152,
-0.3752267062664032,
-0.5461703538894653,
0.3486712574958801,
-0.051775410771369934,
0.35589510202407837,
0.6885435581207275,
-0.8765454888343811,
-1.1719681024551392,
0.26204004883766174,
-0.7415518164634705,
-0.24700263142585754,
-0.2783864736557007,
-0.09039649367332458,
0.5375058650970459,
0.5527914762496948,
-0.47465670108795166,
0.25594258308410645,
0.7451552152633667,
-0.04622583091259003,
0.5956690311431885,
0.2766813337802887,
0.6000187397003174,
-1.7016490697860718,
-0.13002806901931763,
0.20397327840328217,
-0.3104948103427887,
-0.7062250375747681,
-0.005885772872716188,
0.13339748978614807,
-0.11419316381216049,
-0.5441495180130005,
0.8342152237892151,
-0.446981817483902,
0.03444218635559082,
-0.12501809000968933,
-0.12196248769760132,
-0.047437261790037155,
0.6420089602470398,
0.0507572703063488,
1.1812163591384888,
0.559590756893158,
-0.0779082328081131,
0.24969156086444855,
0.28421008586883545,
-0.1583230048418045,
1.059762954711914,
-0.38522574305534363,
0.3119894862174988,
-0.11566530168056488,
-0.05446808785200119,
-1.0427212715148926,
-0.022358322516083717,
0.14667870104312897,
-0.2641831934452057,
0.47008293867111206,
-0.22104667127132416,
-0.7430033683776855,
0.09497281163930893,
-0.22200973331928253,
0.34072670340538025,
0.592817485332489,
-0.2944285273551941,
0.5287091732025146,
0.19510458409786224,
-0.6225709915161133,
-0.5793965458869934,
-1.08504319190979,
0.2953512966632843,
-0.42049068212509155,
-0.45253920555114746,
-0.09708312898874283,
-0.05957747623324394,
-0.40724408626556396,
-0.24325422942638397,
0.037501540035009384,
-0.18272262811660767,
-0.2807120680809021,
0.027198798954486847,
0.2723034620285034,
-0.12341678142547607,
0.013458478264510632,
0.08868733793497086,
0.08965357393026352,
-0.3254547119140625,
-0.16682599484920502,
0.5249244570732117,
-0.6670626997947693,
-0.2968570291996002,
-0.49006959795951843,
0.6263198852539062,
0.7431870698928833,
-0.37683048844337463,
0.6638554930686951,
0.9246436953544617,
-0.10030192136764526,
0.03571734577417374,
-0.5983997583389282,
0.23546794056892395,
-0.3611392378807068,
0.27422890067100525,
-0.6650216579437256,
-0.6336690187454224,
0.4697250723838806,
0.12168435007333755,
-0.1357262283563614,
0.37270388007164,
0.6438798308372498,
0.132857084274292,
0.7370583415031433,
0.9452692270278931,
-0.35066086053848267,
0.7050936222076416,
0.28688520193099976,
0.5616532564163208,
-0.46522507071495056,
-0.017776165157556534,
-0.4123963713645935,
-0.12086831033229828,
-0.8796868324279785,
-0.17678667604923248,
0.38740038871765137,
-0.07043809443712234,
0.0769810900092125,
0.3271881937980652,
-0.17974478006362915,
0.5672405362129211,
0.3429752290248871,
0.10581889003515244,
0.39984411001205444,
0.27581265568733215,
0.08005212992429733,
-0.22883398830890656,
-0.2347879707813263,
-0.37698763608932495,
0.8992971777915955,
0.03612314537167549,
0.6946151852607727,
0.4785720407962799,
0.7494525909423828,
0.35583367943763733,
0.3577733039855957,
-0.7758124470710754,
0.4924051761627197,
-0.663087785243988,
-0.26824644207954407,
0.04113749787211418,
-0.08624013513326645,
-0.3455222547054291,
0.17976288497447968,
0.11396539956331253,
-0.5224025845527649,
0.21353976428508759,
-0.1252325475215912,
0.04962410032749176,
0.47337639331817627,
-0.9961176514625549,
0.5605541467666626,
0.1556842029094696,
-0.45526474714279175,
-0.07745830714702606,
-0.5604945421218872,
0.4889993667602539,
-0.32326921820640564,
0.3968883156776428,
-0.018477018922567368,
0.015290717594325542,
0.5617588758468628,
0.04112818464636803,
0.9078549742698669,
0.0831446424126625,
0.03113328292965889,
0.11751388758420944,
0.27997368574142456,
0.3436043858528137,
-0.118380606174469,
-0.3020751178264618,
0.2508001923561096,
0.21265172958374023,
-0.679905891418457,
-0.3827759623527527,
0.665762186050415,
-0.7789972424507141,
-0.31789079308509827,
-0.6106426119804382,
-0.8090635538101196,
-0.6855469346046448,
0.3660815954208374,
0.11878657341003418,
0.4719403088092804,
0.09557075053453445,
0.04310188069939613,
0.43390828371047974,
-0.18500082194805145,
0.5212070941925049,
0.09147419780492783,
-0.24235540628433228,
-0.20561420917510986,
1.0847434997558594,
0.18972158432006836,
0.4087757170200348,
0.4347747266292572,
0.1893741488456726,
-0.4164225161075592,
-0.42640358209609985,
-0.6275023221969604,
0.2008085995912552,
-0.9198563694953918,
-0.0791986882686615,
-0.5808994174003601,
-0.19214844703674316,
-0.6980875730514526,
-0.3252048194408417,
-0.4845992624759674,
-0.5619546175003052,
0.10753660649061203,
-0.08967684209346771,
0.7056140899658203,
0.9903063774108887,
-0.10101214051246643,
0.2709815800189972,
-0.8342271447181702,
0.06448585540056229,
0.24058489501476288,
0.4911470413208008,
-0.19006501138210297,
-0.37332189083099365,
-0.02296162024140358,
-0.17902871966362,
-0.010718565434217453,
-0.9242227077484131,
0.6151592135429382,
0.17348498106002808,
0.17106464505195618,
-0.23627862334251404,
-0.01805499568581581,
0.6660922765731812,
-0.30295529961586,
0.8570403456687927,
0.20166653394699097,
-1.0059868097305298,
0.22962281107902527,
-0.5881679654121399,
0.2730192244052887,
0.647707998752594,
0.42654648423194885,
-1.1047916412353516,
-0.15133751928806305,
-0.16856622695922852,
-0.6626633405685425,
0.6151392459869385,
0.010166611522436142,
0.20033875107765198,
0.13458773493766785,
0.12572316825389862,
0.20087872445583344,
0.19857485592365265,
-0.6702362895011902,
-0.15543819963932037,
-0.5543456673622131,
-0.470685213804245,
-0.17650549113750458,
-0.15886598825454712,
0.17328554391860962,
-0.06575924158096313,
0.4396515190601349,
0.0029752536211162806,
0.27044278383255005,
0.16988179087638855,
-0.42542222142219543,
0.1495620310306549,
0.6809527277946472,
0.8364560008049011,
0.5129178166389465,
-0.08277375251054764,
0.05558192729949951,
0.07409226894378662,
-0.5641103386878967,
0.08189669996500015,
-0.0010535110486671329,
-0.08712957799434662,
-0.16059745848178864,
0.23962998390197754,
0.7910604476928711,
-0.054423388093709946,
-0.05468568578362465,
0.4434056878089905,
-0.2121582180261612,
0.11711601912975311,
-0.05288734287023544,
-0.6439275741577148,
-0.05885007977485657,
-0.01526957843452692,
0.0767844170331955,
0.4068349599838257,
0.13386397063732147,
-0.5775408148765564,
0.015666058287024498,
0.13184472918510437,
-0.492624968290329,
-0.6096223592758179,
0.2749207317829132,
0.18001097440719604,
-0.04453999176621437,
0.37934112548828125,
-0.0452742874622345,
-0.7242518067359924,
0.29755669832229614,
0.5227338671684265,
0.9120810627937317,
-0.28580978512763977,
0.3498160243034363,
0.46848341822624207,
0.3645779490470886,
-0.18773727118968964,
0.3372887670993805,
-0.0076873209327459335,
-0.36851757764816284,
-0.4952508509159088,
-0.916657030582428,
-0.5180003643035889,
-0.21167731285095215,
-0.6148494482040405,
0.36323633790016174,
-0.39208412170410156,
0.19403357803821564,
-0.24201354384422302,
-0.056317105889320374,
-0.6086122989654541,
0.04836130514740944,
0.2502967119216919,
0.6593614816665649,
-1.3063141107559204,
0.9709442853927612,
0.8511666655540466,
-0.5849205255508423,
-0.7735952734947205,
0.1158849447965622,
0.2178114950656891,
-0.8652008175849915,
0.6234907507896423,
-0.041426751762628555,
-0.2919502258300781,
0.06340879201889038,
-0.1571672111749649,
-0.8436585068702698,
0.5126665234565735,
0.06931199878454208,
-0.3103713095188141,
0.1145429015159607,
0.5087947249412537,
0.7143919467926025,
-0.10276582837104797,
0.16164317727088928,
0.4609179198741913,
0.5945035219192505,
-0.003159591229632497,
-1.2661480903625488,
-0.0910937711596489,
-0.3896476626396179,
0.12999041378498077,
0.23944634199142456,
-1.0715581178665161,
1.0640220642089844,
0.054113321006298065,
-0.10593271255493164,
0.11022080481052399,
0.49924376606941223,
-0.06202712282538414,
0.019839491695165634,
0.2659403681755066,
0.43450430035591125,
0.30935266613960266,
-0.19020815193653107,
1.302829384803772,
-0.32859569787979126,
0.26612505316734314,
0.7229995727539062,
-0.31172746419906616,
0.9117220044136047,
0.6927872896194458,
-0.2499716430902481,
0.43977850675582886,
0.6277254223823547,
0.3501162528991699,
0.5798037052154541,
-0.1987939029932022,
-0.10556676238775253,
-0.12826280295848846,
-0.4872053861618042,
-0.548941433429718,
0.33997946977615356,
0.07754411548376083,
0.061570994555950165,
-0.33619195222854614,
0.29407182335853577,
0.28220561146736145,
0.1936209797859192,
-0.27657005190849304,
0.6969703435897827,
0.17919491231441498,
-0.6575412154197693,
0.40772271156311035,
-0.11712880432605743,
0.9568169116973877,
-0.5120534896850586,
0.05506283417344093,
-0.7396119832992554,
0.2448396533727646,
-0.15758085250854492,
-1.1370362043380737,
0.6657884120941162,
0.008438761346042156,
-0.2209153175354004,
-0.7828257083892822,
0.7177419662475586,
-0.5540650486946106,
-0.7365302443504333,
0.1663796752691269,
0.5795520544052124,
0.15848860144615173,
0.16136117279529572,
-0.6233673095703125,
0.0880093052983284,
0.001990311546251178,
-0.14196527004241943,
0.6049556136131287,
0.38107582926750183,
-0.405579149723053,
0.46514254808425903,
0.45441222190856934,
0.21937786042690277,
0.16554197669029236,
0.25236400961875916,
0.5552382469177246,
-0.5566763281822205,
-0.5288201570510864,
-0.6937633752822876,
0.21413399279117584,
0.05694516375660896,
-0.23143720626831055,
1.0019758939743042,
0.24154631793498993,
0.890132486820221,
-0.3279639184474945,
1.0165479183197021,
-0.037623871117830276,
0.6808892488479614,
-0.5277988314628601,
0.7294818758964539,
-0.62572181224823,
-0.09497320652008057,
-0.4146677255630493,
-0.8283463716506958,
-0.2067006677389145,
0.30047643184661865,
-0.43808993697166443,
0.08036395162343979,
0.8300690054893494,
0.5646190643310547,
-0.11907463520765305,
0.28339818120002747,
0.14701887965202332,
0.1614275872707367,
0.20562005043029785,
0.5308194160461426,
0.725978672504425,
-0.5045519471168518,
0.5776110887527466,
-0.6769530177116394,
-0.1287940889596939,
0.11757195740938187,
-0.8783130049705505,
-0.8103510141372681,
-0.7268671989440918,
-0.2553885877132416,
-0.3023674786090851,
0.1709326207637787,
0.8575544357299805,
0.717138946056366,
-0.8771955966949463,
-0.5370028018951416,
0.22155477106571198,
0.0026741567999124527,
-0.1605290323495865,
-0.22337070107460022,
0.5068298578262329,
-0.5219742655754089,
-0.967351496219635,
0.17664730548858643,
0.29399555921554565,
0.0075002023950219154,
-0.07906541228294373,
0.35924261808395386,
-0.4945277273654938,
0.1264244019985199,
0.888948380947113,
0.26556679606437683,
-0.4206247329711914,
-0.18595914542675018,
0.14468328654766083,
-0.32313981652259827,
0.1713477522134781,
0.9095080494880676,
-0.33954140543937683,
0.3879599869251251,
0.6664965152740479,
0.6782317757606506,
0.3392185568809509,
-0.012739663012325764,
0.3434489965438843,
-0.9339412450790405,
0.27103391289711,
-0.14399555325508118,
0.23509745299816132,
0.7767882943153381,
-0.31574633717536926,
0.460019052028656,
0.3908030092716217,
-0.26867079734802246,
-0.9421886205673218,
0.19497454166412354,
-1.1314103603363037,
-0.11806605011224747,
1.3216378688812256,
0.08948823809623718,
-0.17111441493034363,
-0.15860606729984283,
-0.31303122639656067,
0.18297693133354187,
-0.3431011438369751,
0.5546905994415283,
0.9588661193847656,
-0.10036837309598923,
-0.42503803968429565,
-0.6031033396720886,
0.5468786954879761,
0.5754713416099548,
-0.9042717814445496,
0.12484875321388245,
0.06782907992601395,
0.3797113299369812,
0.12783989310264587,
0.7511018514633179,
-0.42038506269454956,
0.03642116114497185,
-0.1724061816930771,
0.08723288774490356,
0.07315821200609207,
-0.3183404505252838,
-0.40413084626197815,
0.19976814091205597,
-0.04523463174700737,
-0.009863832034170628
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20797v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20797v2
|
Ovis: Structural Embedding Alignment for Multimodal Large Language Model
| 2024-05-31T13:59:18
| 2024-06-17T17:51:50
|
Shiyin Lu, Yang Li, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, Han-Jia Ye
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Current Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) typically integrate a
pre-trained LLM with another pre-trained vision transformer through a
connector, such as an MLP, endowing the LLM with visual capabilities. However,
the misalignment between two embedding strategies in MLLMs -- the structural
textual embeddings based on an embedding look-up table and the continuous
embeddings generated directly by the vision encoder -- makes challenges for a
more seamless fusion of visual and textual information. We propose Ovis, a
novel MLLM architecture designed to structurally align visual and textual
embeddings. Ovis integrates an additional learnable visual embedding table into
the visual encoder's process. To capture rich visual semantics, each image
patch indexes the visual embedding table multiple times, resulting in a final
visual embedding that is a probabilistic combination of the indexed embeddings.
This structural approach mirrors the method used for generating textual
embeddings. Empirical evaluations on various multimodal benchmarks show that
Ovis outperforms open-source MLLMs of similar parameter scales and even
surpasses the proprietary model Qwen-VL-Plus overall. These results highlight
the potential of Ovis' structured visual representation for advancing MLLM
architectural design and promoting more effective multimodal learning. Code,
datasets, and models are available at https://github.com/AIDC-AI/Ovis.
|
[
-0.09333952516317368,
-0.761712372303009,
0.6592491269111633,
-0.0498136505484581,
-0.18058569729328156,
0.15754492580890656,
-0.16446934640407562,
-0.29128432273864746,
0.29151225090026855,
0.34697264432907104,
-0.2634160816669464,
-0.6971985101699829,
-0.4495360553264618,
-0.255788654088974,
-0.19535019993782043,
0.49044445157051086,
-0.22367729246616364,
0.23632469773292542,
-0.4803711473941803,
-0.43397822976112366,
-0.331859827041626,
-0.2683998644351959,
-0.1874455064535141,
0.22569170594215393,
0.7614776492118835,
0.22093647718429565,
0.6735767722129822,
0.8544884920120239,
0.6170834302902222,
0.35641026496887207,
0.07215607166290283,
0.5212528705596924,
-0.35059094429016113,
0.5239657759666443,
0.043726690113544464,
-0.22652867436408997,
-0.792755663394928,
-0.43215012550354004,
0.8826760649681091,
0.6876389980316162,
-0.11726286262273788,
0.19288010895252228,
0.11011435091495514,
0.46426087617874146,
-0.7138805985450745,
0.33387285470962524,
-0.35769566893577576,
0.009281696751713753,
-0.43657442927360535,
-0.17380501329898834,
-0.5494979023933411,
-0.2505740225315094,
0.04563144966959953,
-0.4727877676486969,
-0.3909126818180084,
0.3535742461681366,
0.550260066986084,
0.3137052059173584,
-0.6576105952262878,
-0.033759597688913345,
-0.4736579358577728,
0.6215850710868835,
-0.4192604720592499,
0.7761842608451843,
-0.07265371084213257,
0.4074491858482361,
0.11740164458751678,
-0.5748556852340698,
-0.5730245113372803,
-0.11926022171974182,
0.050675053149461746,
0.006994735449552536,
0.1380368024110794,
-0.16856792569160461,
-0.019743062555789948,
0.18763628602027893,
-0.8572955131530762,
0.08370263129472733,
-0.4953589141368866,
0.0338401272892952,
0.2984311580657959,
0.22913850843906403,
0.35931381583213806,
0.08163300901651382,
-0.7146440744400024,
-0.11561855673789978,
-0.6832472681999207,
-0.2026945799589157,
0.18659530580043793,
0.39777177572250366,
-0.25127801299095154,
1.1289201974868774,
0.1788339763879776,
0.8770900964736938,
-0.2183319330215454,
-0.1616547703742981,
0.5334025025367737,
-0.29172483086586,
-0.27212947607040405,
0.3398164212703705,
0.6747592687606812,
0.29312577843666077,
0.3172571659088135,
0.09415058046579361,
-0.09736195206642151,
0.25393280386924744,
0.36268964409828186,
-0.5607730150222778,
-0.11161624640226364,
0.08879522234201431,
-0.46361732482910156,
-0.2867377996444702,
0.23292498290538788,
-0.7614721655845642,
-0.5025271773338318,
-0.267544686794281,
0.35658136010169983,
-0.4365237057209015,
-0.2680046558380127,
0.13590919971466064,
-0.004254422150552273,
0.17985737323760986,
0.18011996150016785,
-0.6430259943008423,
-0.08034856617450714,
0.3408501446247101,
0.8992706537246704,
-0.269470751285553,
-0.41800379753112793,
-0.7469450235366821,
0.491826593875885,
-0.24850749969482422,
0.47590404748916626,
-0.7081605195999146,
0.07231229543685913,
0.39136895537376404,
-0.08590370416641235,
0.016293661668896675,
-0.01675909385085106,
0.11460655927658081,
-0.5741570591926575,
0.14413289725780487,
-0.05196695774793625,
-0.3681941032409668,
0.07428120821714401,
0.4980831742286682,
-0.791412889957428,
0.8976793885231018,
-0.1679529845714569,
-0.7494038343429565,
0.2849748134613037,
-0.6259976029396057,
-0.3383309543132782,
-0.12564459443092346,
-0.4570598602294922,
-0.6123282313346863,
0.11718627065420151,
0.2452699840068817,
0.3843786120414734,
-0.023598432540893555,
0.26727738976478577,
-0.690248966217041,
0.018760768696665764,
0.29282352328300476,
-0.442079097032547,
0.6076794266700745,
0.14487604796886444,
-0.16183358430862427,
0.48161134123802185,
-0.8904446363449097,
-0.1567026972770691,
0.4101558029651642,
-0.29143014550209045,
-0.5898699164390564,
0.21481391787528992,
0.22858910262584686,
0.09892986714839935,
0.30893367528915405,
-0.7484928369522095,
0.3814963400363922,
-0.21480901539325714,
0.6463202238082886,
0.638353705406189,
-0.35440754890441895,
0.63691645860672,
-0.02287493459880352,
0.20283959805965424,
0.04617020860314369,
0.2914602756500244,
-0.5495941638946533,
-0.5049011707305908,
-0.7246503233909607,
-0.5219168663024902,
0.1521642506122589,
0.3711312711238861,
-1.0166871547698975,
0.23635104298591614,
-0.5449284315109253,
-0.2747882306575775,
-0.6025623679161072,
0.06677782535552979,
0.5339890718460083,
0.3999261260032654,
0.49123209714889526,
-0.23993414640426636,
-0.5845443606376648,
-0.7468575835227966,
0.13355982303619385,
-0.09365145862102509,
0.2321862429380417,
-0.05177251994609833,
0.5559077858924866,
-0.12402154505252838,
0.9295083284378052,
-0.6765281558036804,
-0.6292710900306702,
0.01612536795437336,
-0.14085924625396729,
-0.20411542057991028,
0.4529329836368561,
0.5596839785575867,
-0.866119921207428,
-0.45244669914245605,
0.20731596648693085,
-0.8970482349395752,
0.25400510430336,
0.2888328433036804,
-0.24221710860729218,
0.3490696847438812,
0.7043566703796387,
-0.5604357719421387,
0.2959606945514679,
0.7080362439155579,
-0.42238134145736694,
0.30081456899642944,
-0.3192802965641022,
0.05918899551033974,
-1.2008583545684814,
0.008858884684741497,
-0.19099201261997223,
-0.35253915190696716,
-0.3945217728614807,
0.2950479984283447,
0.36315083503723145,
-0.21314452588558197,
-0.5960665345191956,
0.5232705473899841,
-0.8046122789382935,
-0.07583528757095337,
0.3057835102081299,
0.3490508496761322,
0.2845610976219177,
0.5593310594558716,
0.020528053864836693,
0.3131881356239319,
0.5708087682723999,
-0.15694034099578857,
0.49780455231666565,
0.4445499777793884,
-0.609330952167511,
0.9206687211990356,
-0.5162132978439331,
-0.08091513067483902,
-0.3187991976737976,
0.1519438624382019,
-1.0738942623138428,
-0.20060527324676514,
0.2819315493106842,
-0.14076153934001923,
0.5188131928443909,
-0.03432493656873703,
-0.3487761914730072,
-0.09679701179265976,
-0.5013574957847595,
0.7377440929412842,
0.13966137170791626,
-0.5976964831352234,
0.999200701713562,
0.45902180671691895,
-0.3080124258995056,
-0.5570365190505981,
-0.9537320733070374,
0.05697331577539444,
0.059652797877788544,
-0.7753210663795471,
0.4395695626735687,
-0.0026374091394245625,
-0.1485757976770401,
0.3898029327392578,
0.1917094737291336,
0.1425163298845291,
-0.34468531608581543,
0.31545329093933105,
0.5073727369308472,
-0.7349299192428589,
0.3778923451900482,
-0.019084950909018517,
0.07650111615657806,
-0.3269573748111725,
-0.5243647694587708,
0.5790266990661621,
-0.22852343320846558,
-0.9923844933509827,
0.05567987263202667,
0.5100486278533936,
0.9165862798690796,
-0.8505963683128357,
0.9773417115211487,
0.6841773986816406,
-0.3462725281715393,
0.21802422404289246,
-0.6079985499382019,
0.3536663055419922,
-0.3811780512332916,
0.6119340658187866,
-0.39510682225227356,
-0.8130849003791809,
0.1541818380355835,
0.29074355959892273,
0.2130744606256485,
0.4158530533313751,
0.569787859916687,
-0.46344253420829773,
1.2475439310073853,
0.7480155229568481,
0.1274644136428833,
0.577093780040741,
0.008112124167382717,
0.14250414073467255,
-0.7337180376052856,
-0.6931070685386658,
-0.3348592519760132,
-0.43542417883872986,
-0.29070836305618286,
-0.7275370359420776,
0.3820255696773529,
-0.2571038603782654,
-0.3729897141456604,
0.17519840598106384,
-0.2783288061618805,
0.1998237669467926,
0.33603107929229736,
-0.010173266753554344,
0.27249664068222046,
0.26519209146499634,
-0.40151822566986084,
0.08034898340702057,
-0.7118005156517029,
-0.3795769512653351,
0.8576604127883911,
0.49054354429244995,
1.0053094625473022,
0.43985220789909363,
0.4802630841732025,
0.06120973080396652,
0.07728220522403717,
-0.513125479221344,
0.3438367247581482,
-0.13288554549217224,
-0.2882853150367737,
-0.3294488787651062,
-0.3042026162147522,
-0.7828272581100464,
0.2936878502368927,
-0.5198243260383606,
-0.39418455958366394,
0.3978208899497986,
0.19652371108531952,
-0.23101924359798431,
0.39970335364341736,
-0.7478672862052917,
1.0298763513565063,
-0.4494935870170593,
-0.2948475778102875,
0.05547069385647774,
-0.5928149223327637,
0.21260511875152588,
0.03138408064842224,
0.28693845868110657,
0.18193936347961426,
-0.3662573993206024,
0.3335106372833252,
-0.2839965522289276,
0.946787416934967,
-0.04885154590010643,
-0.28941085934638977,
0.13104800879955292,
-0.11418656259775162,
0.4812861979007721,
-0.24339832365512848,
0.19937779009342194,
0.08009607344865799,
-0.17931126058101654,
-0.4358961880207062,
-0.5254374742507935,
0.8236303925514221,
-0.4673788845539093,
-0.16045348346233368,
-0.35392460227012634,
-0.41524749994277954,
-0.13523752987384796,
0.18152837455272675,
-0.03168272227048874,
0.8858124017715454,
-0.3772048056125641,
0.46075159311294556,
0.5723868608474731,
-0.2183324545621872,
0.30203619599342346,
0.34122389554977417,
-0.5351983308792114,
-0.7132101655006409,
1.2302436828613281,
0.08458886295557022,
0.29412221908569336,
0.6661736369132996,
-0.07551942765712738,
-0.3874823749065399,
-0.34921127557754517,
-0.6904215812683105,
0.17518872022628784,
-0.7222067713737488,
-0.2118794173002243,
-0.6239228844642639,
-0.21050669252872467,
-0.5117757320404053,
-0.16825607419013977,
-0.421556293964386,
-0.11911632865667343,
-0.08804045617580414,
-0.05291622132062912,
0.05488170310854912,
0.7345702052116394,
0.5504111051559448,
-0.024100009351968765,
-0.8585727214813232,
0.2997187674045563,
0.38862013816833496,
0.5020132660865784,
-0.14332278072834015,
-0.25601276755332947,
-0.25270888209342957,
-0.023941770195961,
-0.06907395273447037,
-0.795782208442688,
0.21870838105678558,
0.37094709277153015,
0.5900219678878784,
0.4982452988624573,
-0.01929025910794735,
0.7778946161270142,
-0.8224444389343262,
0.6445393562316895,
0.43112969398498535,
-0.6904061436653137,
0.311516135931015,
-0.057396020740270615,
0.4125451147556305,
0.2556239664554596,
0.3249930739402771,
-0.1323351413011551,
-0.3510684072971344,
-0.06537090241909027,
-0.7802252769470215,
0.2679748237133026,
0.09309794008731842,
-0.10630659759044647,
-0.07768486440181732,
-0.1730729341506958,
-0.04774041473865509,
0.28340891003608704,
-0.683969259262085,
-0.07505470514297485,
-0.22235757112503052,
-0.6614611148834229,
-0.12641474604606628,
-0.5631802082061768,
-0.11802266538143158,
0.008675964549183846,
0.47924935817718506,
-0.24239066243171692,
0.18429860472679138,
0.16435877978801727,
-0.6520397663116455,
0.0871327742934227,
0.044116728007793427,
0.9445613026618958,
0.4978838860988617,
-0.09644649922847748,
0.5153957009315491,
-0.10007897019386292,
-0.3204999566078186,
-0.020513685420155525,
-0.04512830078601837,
0.049501996487379074,
-0.12071945518255234,
0.6614909172058105,
1.022383451461792,
0.43925079703330994,
-0.6973651051521301,
0.6016072630882263,
0.006922819651663303,
-0.18102629482746124,
-0.0819774866104126,
-0.42453792691230774,
0.14931707084178925,
0.7241540551185608,
0.2036321759223938,
0.30297011137008667,
-0.20167164504528046,
-0.7206969857215881,
-0.012058946304023266,
0.5601905584335327,
-0.6446303725242615,
-0.24996307492256165,
0.7513217926025391,
0.2823592722415924,
-0.34515613317489624,
0.4056418240070343,
0.2452591508626938,
-0.4485524594783783,
0.22015006840229034,
0.33350008726119995,
0.5939050316810608,
-0.30885300040245056,
0.143355131149292,
0.012011326849460602,
0.5292923450469971,
0.041176505386829376,
0.4182169735431671,
0.017186621204018593,
-0.44268813729286194,
-0.5564240217208862,
-0.871541440486908,
-0.07156320661306381,
-0.458379328250885,
-0.513953685760498,
0.3696398138999939,
-0.026625974103808403,
-0.051180437207221985,
-0.1800685077905655,
-0.6503222584724426,
-0.5502880811691284,
0.02916741371154785,
0.46396127343177795,
0.8725274205207825,
-0.7815444469451904,
1.0748906135559082,
0.7585309147834778,
-0.5245535969734192,
-0.27985963225364685,
-0.2579983174800873,
0.08975185453891754,
-0.8373039960861206,
0.566482424736023,
0.09717725217342377,
-0.16409476101398468,
-0.12744547426700592,
-0.1289432793855667,
-0.9879374504089355,
1.1476784944534302,
0.6691115498542786,
-0.7782498598098755,
-0.2403169870376587,
0.039706192910671234,
0.34997713565826416,
-0.5561355948448181,
0.01877141371369362,
0.015797359868884087,
0.5085638165473938,
0.13131654262542725,
-0.6604655385017395,
-0.026404045522212982,
-0.42729276418685913,
0.13461408019065857,
0.4225650429725647,
-0.1995212882757187,
0.7859594225883484,
-0.33602192997932434,
-0.27163001894950867,
0.1414634883403778,
0.7544299960136414,
-0.0240834578871727,
0.10391062498092651,
0.5017518401145935,
0.5314549207687378,
0.541352391242981,
-0.08632893860340118,
0.9139912128448486,
-0.08019652962684631,
0.04077085852622986,
1.1805874109268188,
-0.414852499961853,
1.2604700326919556,
0.603361964225769,
0.13601799309253693,
0.5571422576904297,
0.1514335721731186,
0.053257159888744354,
0.6262420415878296,
-0.19671063125133514,
0.08438614010810852,
-0.21772439777851105,
-0.05918889865279198,
-0.6322413086891174,
0.5532225966453552,
0.2665010094642639,
-0.5351605415344238,
-0.07641233503818512,
0.3099459707736969,
-0.5025137066841125,
0.09001553058624268,
-0.13990388810634613,
0.6328721642494202,
-0.005760757718235254,
-0.3772173225879669,
0.2998943030834198,
-0.0890522226691246,
0.4103829860687256,
-0.7355958223342896,
-0.11486818641424179,
0.12198907136917114,
0.2782441973686218,
-0.15245386958122253,
-0.7971031665802002,
0.356074720621109,
-0.21763081848621368,
-0.17150884866714478,
-0.4364883303642273,
0.5152104496955872,
-1.084936261177063,
-0.4627910256385803,
0.32378578186035156,
0.38719332218170166,
-0.26652786135673523,
-0.05016997829079628,
-0.22412998974323273,
0.5658007264137268,
-0.2687138020992279,
-0.24542543292045593,
0.47570255398750305,
0.383378803730011,
-0.12421871721744537,
0.4580330550670624,
0.6479333639144897,
-0.09580935537815094,
0.2277882695198059,
0.2306729555130005,
0.978941798210144,
-0.4347168505191803,
-0.36884605884552,
-1.0291849374771118,
0.955034077167511,
-0.22069354355335236,
-0.11917809396982193,
0.6160082817077637,
0.5685168504714966,
0.6635544300079346,
-0.16909725964069366,
0.31716886162757874,
0.13435417413711548,
-0.1418641358613968,
-0.8323491215705872,
0.6844318509101868,
-0.9271054863929749,
-0.020469913259148598,
-0.1784687489271164,
-1.3028422594070435,
-0.46535155177116394,
0.5381490588188171,
-0.08402405679225922,
-0.3312229812145233,
0.7200954556465149,
0.6842465996742249,
-0.2228987067937851,
-0.2381836622953415,
0.5418217778205872,
0.4060089886188507,
0.280518501996994,
0.35085833072662354,
0.7158743739128113,
-0.2758670449256897,
0.8584731221199036,
0.2699167728424072,
-0.21457073092460632,
-0.35358548164367676,
-0.964023768901825,
-0.899631679058075,
-0.8176702857017517,
-0.27143365144729614,
-0.0786883682012558,
0.0652586817741394,
0.7090273499488831,
0.5008249878883362,
-0.5439295172691345,
-0.02773761749267578,
0.30753061175346375,
-0.043526358902454376,
-0.23149070143699646,
-0.1328997164964676,
0.33975750207901,
-0.17670102417469025,
-0.6424517631530762,
0.5947331190109253,
0.8754963874816895,
-0.031278569251298904,
-0.676996111869812,
-0.21661996841430664,
-0.445939302444458,
0.026690006256103516,
0.9350538849830627,
-0.006250439677387476,
-0.786756694316864,
-0.29642927646636963,
0.14463220536708832,
-0.5063676238059998,
0.006908533629029989,
0.5617278814315796,
-0.5044599175453186,
0.6706860065460205,
0.6643364429473877,
0.7679785490036011,
0.5031057000160217,
-0.3992977738380432,
0.6042372584342957,
-0.8774479627609253,
0.07745727151632309,
-0.06548936665058136,
0.7219563722610474,
0.32510504126548767,
0.10961920022964478,
0.17262867093086243,
0.005603914614766836,
-0.13747957348823547,
-0.9852473139762878,
0.31150180101394653,
-1.1156868934631348,
-0.19678349792957306,
0.7565312385559082,
-0.14566215872764587,
-0.5107308626174927,
-0.04917985573410988,
-0.46670767664909363,
0.08510879427194595,
-0.16198401153087616,
0.3311454951763153,
0.3898651897907257,
0.5229431986808777,
-0.22115981578826904,
-0.2927936911582947,
-0.07472530752420425,
0.15442749857902527,
-0.5401796698570251,
-0.14229774475097656,
0.5041793584823608,
-0.04055270925164223,
0.5707412958145142,
0.22883649170398712,
-0.2104826271533966,
0.058793872594833374,
0.05338243022561073,
0.18257799744606018,
-0.6162816882133484,
-0.7112975120544434,
-0.17343580722808838,
0.6991981267929077,
-0.22748145461082458,
-0.5377314686775208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20755v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20755v1
|
Improving code-mixed hate detection by native sample mixing: A case study for Hindi-English code-mixed scenario
| 2024-05-31T11:43:31
| 2024-05-31T11:43:31
|
Debajyoti Mazumder, Aakash Kumar, Jasabanta Patro
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hate detection has long been a challenging task for the NLP community. The
task becomes complex in a code-mixed environment because the models must
understand the context and the hate expressed through language alteration.
Compared to the monolingual setup, we see very less work on code-mixed hate as
large-scale annotated hate corpora are unavailable to make the study. To
overcome this bottleneck, we propose using native language hate samples. We
hypothesise that in the era of multilingual language models (MLMs), hate in
code-mixed settings can be detected by majorly relying on the native language
samples. Even though the NLP literature reports the effectiveness of MLMs on
hate detection in many cross-lingual settings, their extensive evaluation in a
code-mixed scenario is yet to be done. This paper attempts to fill this gap
through rigorous empirical experiments. We considered the Hindi-English
code-mixed setup as a case study as we have the linguistic expertise for the
same. Some of the interesting observations we got are: (i) adding native hate
samples in the code-mixed training set, even in small quantity, improved the
performance of MLMs for code-mixed hate detection, (ii) MLMs trained with
native samples alone observed to be detecting code-mixed hate to a large
extent, (iii) The visualisation of attention scores revealed that, when native
samples were included in training, MLMs could better focus on the hate emitting
words in the code-mixed context, and (iv) finally, when hate is subjective or
sarcastic, naively mixing native samples doesn't help much to detect code-mixed
hate. We will release the data and code repository to reproduce the reported
results.
|
[
-0.6040005683898926,
-0.5035379528999329,
-0.16796767711639404,
0.48532551527023315,
-0.0643659234046936,
0.42938232421875,
-0.3859988749027252,
-0.7832562923431396,
0.6157363057136536,
0.4120294153690338,
-0.28475096821784973,
-0.49335795640945435,
-0.48501163721084595,
0.1453285962343216,
-0.3928951323032379,
1.1766782999038696,
0.133761465549469,
0.297840416431427,
0.15636010468006134,
-0.5597411394119263,
-0.5668442249298096,
-0.7418704628944397,
-0.5706980228424072,
-0.2440887689590454,
0.597327709197998,
0.4035201072692871,
0.640027642250061,
0.10579624027013779,
0.4259697496891022,
0.18164293467998505,
-0.220302551984787,
0.16233718395233154,
-0.44917863607406616,
0.11171302944421768,
0.08994080126285553,
-0.7538011074066162,
-0.18307550251483917,
-0.04439261928200722,
0.13665242493152618,
0.3423895835876465,
-0.23773059248924255,
-0.005123071372509003,
-0.033987220376729965,
0.4602201581001282,
-0.8244869709014893,
-0.23624204099178314,
-0.9567742943763733,
0.465800404548645,
-0.3624696135520935,
-0.16041791439056396,
-0.38036900758743286,
-0.14890652894973755,
-0.3585737645626068,
-0.34324145317077637,
0.26142480969429016,
-0.0010882773203775287,
0.5624618530273438,
0.19440437853336334,
-0.17854778468608856,
-0.4136190414428711,
-0.8931549191474915,
0.9715920686721802,
-0.8822670578956604,
0.2890438437461853,
0.2041155844926834,
0.3371279835700989,
0.002504425821825862,
0.0757109746336937,
-0.6451067924499512,
-0.09311426430940628,
-0.14779609441757202,
0.21661360561847687,
-0.25976699590682983,
-0.26573529839515686,
0.3064470589160919,
0.5672982335090637,
-0.6118935942649841,
0.27981454133987427,
-0.46479150652885437,
-0.33432453870773315,
0.7394119501113892,
-0.04123804345726967,
0.7888131141662598,
-0.2594950497150421,
-0.46253731846809387,
0.20116214454174042,
-0.6805300116539001,
-0.18037645518779755,
0.6287873983383179,
0.3895586133003235,
-0.3157685399055481,
0.5657428503036499,
-0.11758951097726822,
0.7328638434410095,
-0.18822339177131653,
-0.3247002065181732,
0.495200514793396,
-0.4056355655193329,
-0.16296175122261047,
0.09707101434469223,
0.5679500102996826,
0.6026998162269592,
0.6555979251861572,
-0.19295884668827057,
-0.3473897874355316,
0.7630636692047119,
0.2262790948152542,
-0.6153419613838196,
-0.17932839691638947,
0.14457236230373383,
-0.36928388476371765,
-0.3645692467689514,
-0.6089070439338684,
-1.1889846324920654,
-0.7519093751907349,
-0.22094973921775818,
-0.06760045886039734,
-0.44018349051475525,
-0.7616093754768372,
-0.057056695222854614,
-0.2960819602012634,
0.40695545077323914,
0.0552535355091095,
-0.8041029572486877,
0.27448582649230957,
0.40578657388687134,
0.8118266463279724,
-0.6123723387718201,
-0.14878126978874207,
-0.523554801940918,
-0.29692479968070984,
-0.17692889273166656,
0.7248623967170715,
-0.5430907607078552,
-0.34841763973236084,
0.12789207696914673,
-0.7044783234596252,
-0.08478622138500214,
-1.1265130043029785,
0.31001973152160645,
-0.44042277336120605,
0.0018254379974678159,
0.20525485277175903,
-0.23228909075260162,
0.19631904363632202,
0.4045439660549164,
-0.40610235929489136,
1.1046570539474487,
0.15802359580993652,
-0.8585450053215027,
0.6402512788772583,
-0.524190366268158,
-0.48897337913513184,
0.08274394273757935,
-0.13581404089927673,
-0.24926118552684784,
0.07943753153085709,
0.16618835926055908,
0.23871146142482758,
0.28497499227523804,
0.01986747793853283,
-0.5104570984840393,
-0.48140567541122437,
0.23036766052246094,
-0.1005089208483696,
0.9410699605941772,
0.5770768523216248,
-0.5051555633544922,
0.023878002539277077,
-0.8545435070991516,
-0.26570165157318115,
0.14428557455539703,
-0.24181462824344635,
-0.7300625443458557,
-0.08309487253427505,
0.37109971046447754,
0.4138943552970886,
-0.17576315999031067,
-0.6618338823318481,
0.05844889581203461,
-0.46272480487823486,
-0.21395951509475708,
0.5426353812217712,
-0.18024255335330963,
0.44293534755706787,
-0.23236067593097687,
0.9804529547691345,
0.30159133672714233,
0.11180742084980011,
0.1875341385602951,
-0.5445210337638855,
-0.7946779131889343,
-0.13219663500785828,
-0.0942770317196846,
0.5318004488945007,
-0.9289258718490601,
-0.09452765434980392,
0.16807697713375092,
-0.48966166377067566,
-0.6056902408599854,
0.43050551414489746,
0.4554881453514099,
0.2343219369649887,
0.526167631149292,
-0.4494847357273102,
-0.9543312788009644,
-0.9267281889915466,
-0.6412960290908813,
0.011644231155514717,
0.1770395040512085,
0.16780443489551544,
0.28368037939071655,
-0.22858408093452454,
0.829946756362915,
-0.40134868025779724,
-0.31382012367248535,
-0.46429336071014404,
0.06391087919473648,
-0.02840271405875683,
0.30040326714515686,
0.6736380457878113,
-1.0596188306808472,
-0.7350447177886963,
-0.13073474168777466,
-0.4918416142463684,
-0.26490941643714905,
-0.013429551385343075,
0.09530621021986008,
0.2662309408187866,
0.3920595645904541,
0.11390507221221924,
0.5427504181861877,
0.7474217414855957,
-0.2995137870311737,
0.8377907872200012,
0.32594430446624756,
0.21729856729507446,
-1.0897449254989624,
-0.34187740087509155,
0.29236865043640137,
-0.012742302380502224,
-0.7177886366844177,
0.44060686230659485,
-0.1270599365234375,
-0.05369051545858383,
-0.5044850707054138,
0.29172438383102417,
-0.3751949071884155,
0.06313721090555191,
-0.3818607032299042,
-0.1602546125650406,
-0.4062684178352356,
0.7263920903205872,
0.09006179124116898,
0.7782224416732788,
0.16943293809890747,
-0.43897590041160583,
0.1215943768620491,
-0.07303250581026077,
-0.3913824260234833,
0.6780043244361877,
-0.21384786069393158,
-0.09328996390104294,
-0.0778149887919426,
-0.08175498992204666,
-0.8839690685272217,
0.07819762080907822,
0.36779406666755676,
-0.5859882235527039,
0.07134461402893066,
-0.4746994078159332,
-0.506498396396637,
-0.03735984116792679,
-0.1794896274805069,
0.5686733722686768,
0.482832670211792,
-0.45683276653289795,
0.4162522256374359,
0.46865376830101013,
-0.053168900310993195,
-0.5837928056716919,
-1.0406793355941772,
0.18327701091766357,
-0.43232035636901855,
-0.2622584104537964,
0.07821312546730042,
-0.2679980397224426,
-0.5969690084457397,
-0.24497607350349426,
-0.09115229547023773,
-0.5011911988258362,
-0.03536873310804367,
0.41454017162323,
0.21725240349769592,
-0.2693987190723419,
-0.24957771599292755,
-0.16590465605258942,
0.1447056531906128,
0.11583514511585236,
-0.02917787991464138,
0.5784862637519836,
0.02094552293419838,
-0.2255324274301529,
0.25315091013908386,
0.5260071754455566,
0.6355865597724915,
-0.39481067657470703,
0.7275237441062927,
0.9223842620849609,
-0.4093441963195801,
-0.4095923602581024,
-0.6093920469284058,
0.192097008228302,
-0.38328030705451965,
0.4111233949661255,
-0.02296697162091732,
-0.8888795971870422,
0.5674700736999512,
0.3864630162715912,
-0.037233103066682816,
0.12759241461753845,
0.7161308526992798,
0.22823938727378845,
0.7889297604560852,
0.6158456206321716,
-0.49781569838523865,
0.5169932842254639,
0.0013645511353388429,
0.4774344265460968,
-0.5367610454559326,
-0.08777362108230591,
-0.5414379239082336,
-0.28930047154426575,
-0.5327540040016174,
-0.5491145253181458,
0.47080865502357483,
-0.012409965507686138,
0.1966753602027893,
0.20186825096607208,
-0.5380712151527405,
0.597763180732727,
0.2611633837223053,
0.14463604986667633,
0.43524169921875,
0.2504446506500244,
-0.2602218985557556,
-0.4326778054237366,
-0.7718615531921387,
-0.02144504524767399,
1.13216233253479,
0.12041117995977402,
0.5296803712844849,
0.1871931403875351,
0.7304635047912598,
0.25524091720581055,
0.7095382809638977,
-0.6528867483139038,
0.34408360719680786,
-0.03570280224084854,
-0.8049439787864685,
0.2683272063732147,
-0.4199028015136719,
-0.5683860182762146,
0.2777978777885437,
-0.18104584515094757,
-0.4267747104167938,
0.049174703657627106,
0.26839205622673035,
-0.1630464345216751,
0.5457586050033569,
-1.0046037435531616,
0.8967611193656921,
-0.12662191689014435,
-0.1052624061703682,
-0.24929258227348328,
-0.2876659631729126,
0.785997748374939,
-0.06307179480791092,
0.7409948706626892,
0.13065074384212494,
0.1751689314842224,
0.7638819813728333,
-0.35654377937316895,
1.03106689453125,
-0.17829471826553345,
-0.3385576903820038,
0.27652743458747864,
0.1830119490623474,
0.06995420157909393,
-0.19206134974956512,
-0.11673840135335922,
0.12658236920833588,
-0.427859365940094,
-0.6499942541122437,
-0.4941052496433258,
0.6788644194602966,
-0.450032114982605,
-0.1479821801185608,
-0.30837690830230713,
-0.7969853281974792,
-0.29123809933662415,
-0.02461470477283001,
0.2874853014945984,
0.43670591711997986,
0.11618880182504654,
-0.09833043068647385,
0.7260982394218445,
-0.42492878437042236,
0.30217164754867554,
0.5197666883468628,
-0.576364278793335,
-0.06437361985445023,
0.9766969084739685,
-0.05125900357961655,
0.4517308473587036,
0.1780213862657547,
0.07547701150178909,
0.10262088477611542,
-0.7005233764648438,
-0.5750835537910461,
-0.14342807233333588,
-0.5972926616668701,
-0.0762142613530159,
-0.6442579627037048,
-0.08165698498487473,
-0.23020194470882416,
-0.1898449957370758,
-0.49392855167388916,
0.06052565947175026,
0.3649507164955139,
0.1964847892522812,
0.45634156465530396,
0.658647894859314,
-0.0859694853425026,
0.13166727125644684,
-0.5225271582603455,
0.5341798663139343,
0.023442856967449188,
0.5649002194404602,
0.15580791234970093,
-0.5362712740898132,
-0.5425402522087097,
0.1158968135714531,
0.06903884559869766,
-1.0017448663711548,
0.4984230399131775,
-0.3388570547103882,
0.19877462089061737,
0.1450618952512741,
-0.07432807236909866,
0.7861229181289673,
-0.22087439894676208,
0.5871923565864563,
0.1556059569120407,
-0.5603731274604797,
0.5315748453140259,
-0.34435105323791504,
0.2613367438316345,
0.651648759841919,
0.5824542045593262,
-0.7839571833610535,
-0.9468609094619751,
-0.372519850730896,
-0.8683477640151978,
0.427564799785614,
0.2507617771625519,
0.10387740284204483,
-0.02999747171998024,
-0.08509175479412079,
0.08025490492582321,
0.09575875848531723,
-1.2023979425430298,
-0.7837539315223694,
-0.04706837236881256,
-0.043274782598018646,
-0.017780283465981483,
-0.14029178023338318,
0.12800556421279907,
-0.3901071548461914,
0.5246781706809998,
0.28259870409965515,
-0.02293527126312256,
0.020346160978078842,
-0.44783180952072144,
0.0813775360584259,
0.408786416053772,
0.5374732613563538,
0.4243088662624359,
-0.2825448513031006,
0.11911774426698685,
0.06689423322677612,
-0.5660269856452942,
0.009017582051455975,
-0.14979927241802216,
-0.33988332748413086,
0.39108020067214966,
0.16356056928634644,
0.4447556436061859,
0.21790169179439545,
-0.9322775602340698,
0.5230909585952759,
0.006602076347917318,
0.0393604151904583,
-0.2950001358985901,
0.10092334449291229,
0.13514992594718933,
-0.18999920785427094,
0.37945884466171265,
0.5463613271713257,
0.1271846443414688,
-0.5297632217407227,
0.30684393644332886,
0.323323130607605,
-0.46031060814857483,
-0.009451759047806263,
0.4239879250526428,
0.18029172718524933,
-0.30874377489089966,
0.23318320512771606,
-0.6721919178962708,
-1.0463625192642212,
0.7423452734947205,
0.6030169129371643,
0.5019084811210632,
-0.2275298684835434,
0.2519955337047577,
0.2769244909286499,
0.47761890292167664,
0.28623324632644653,
-0.014319967478513718,
-0.08448269963264465,
-1.0610575675964355,
-0.5886970162391663,
-0.7747702598571777,
-0.383359432220459,
0.2254732847213745,
-0.743553638458252,
0.2373046875,
-0.48364853858947754,
0.5364043712615967,
-0.025931911543011665,
-0.1738564670085907,
-0.5679260492324829,
0.24127143621444702,
0.42537441849708557,
0.8203760981559753,
-1.0273709297180176,
0.5999204516410828,
0.6128084659576416,
-0.4594270884990692,
-0.9231058955192566,
-0.13400155305862427,
0.23646101355552673,
-0.9787271022796631,
0.6416699290275574,
0.18895931541919708,
0.04560185596346855,
-0.3099937438964844,
-0.3308941125869751,
-0.3025534749031067,
0.21162115037441254,
-0.19924645125865936,
-0.4155345857143402,
0.48042839765548706,
0.2090126872062683,
0.7901672124862671,
-0.3595737814903259,
0.3026696741580963,
0.6524381637573242,
0.15589424967765808,
-0.27338510751724243,
-0.745059609413147,
-0.17079049348831177,
-0.685074508190155,
-0.3474610447883606,
0.41663888096809387,
-0.2918134331703186,
0.6388403177261353,
0.024908944964408875,
0.069602832198143,
-0.3231831192970276,
0.4313371777534485,
0.21353518962860107,
0.6400981545448303,
0.7403666377067566,
0.6114327311515808,
0.2942166328430176,
0.3156116306781769,
1.00788414478302,
-0.1582241654396057,
0.15537965297698975,
1.0955578088760376,
-0.3144291639328003,
0.7321742177009583,
0.6293622255325317,
-0.30463552474975586,
0.49127665162086487,
0.2831599712371826,
-0.03401133790612221,
0.04079832509160042,
0.4802990257740021,
-0.3850165605545044,
-0.0331081748008728,
-0.39770203828811646,
-0.5027273893356323,
0.4684227406978607,
0.16558322310447693,
-0.047455620020627975,
-0.4116971790790558,
0.2808627784252167,
0.21940596401691437,
0.4373919665813446,
-0.35456445813179016,
0.5631723999977112,
-0.06338970363140106,
-0.5200368762016296,
0.8038229942321777,
0.1434401571750641,
1.630275845527649,
-0.5631657242774963,
0.10737013816833496,
-0.5182167887687683,
0.011241457425057888,
-0.47077852487564087,
-0.37294331192970276,
0.7389211058616638,
0.6353595852851868,
-0.38637977838516235,
-0.1926971822977066,
0.6091301441192627,
-0.730156421661377,
-0.42445245385169983,
0.6510236263275146,
0.3926521837711334,
0.16577614843845367,
-0.43794193863868713,
-0.6559795141220093,
0.2049466371536255,
0.25540217757225037,
0.16442477703094482,
0.7535682320594788,
0.1015932634472847,
0.08632833510637283,
0.2830169200897217,
0.6370854377746582,
0.47648805379867554,
0.3956422209739685,
0.2758108377456665,
0.5108328461647034,
-0.5157124400138855,
-0.31100893020629883,
-0.8712921738624573,
0.23667122423648834,
-0.11126142740249634,
-0.48832765221595764,
1.0000386238098145,
0.8713319897651672,
1.4186829328536987,
-0.2155626267194748,
0.8207309246063232,
-0.10338848829269409,
0.5421647429466248,
-0.38851645588874817,
0.6448768377304077,
-0.7301300764083862,
0.34129244089126587,
-0.4547477662563324,
-0.6362541317939758,
-0.44936174154281616,
0.2615482807159424,
-0.20352523028850555,
-0.020958533510565758,
0.5522010922431946,
1.1091781854629517,
-0.18839876353740692,
-0.02529059536755085,
0.30110877752304077,
0.2056282013654709,
0.09109329432249069,
0.7465949654579163,
0.7809510231018066,
-0.48360371589660645,
0.8609800934791565,
-0.5853330492973328,
-0.16999801993370056,
-0.18277063965797424,
-0.5716032385826111,
-0.8195030689239502,
-0.18363983929157257,
-0.37284955382347107,
-0.5948197841644287,
-0.25821053981781006,
0.8942167162895203,
0.3767370879650116,
-0.9919690489768982,
-0.36947548389434814,
0.09698786586523056,
0.46713054180145264,
-0.139126256108284,
-0.32252711057662964,
-0.2540002763271332,
-0.2703497111797333,
-0.6986005306243896,
0.3496447801589966,
0.3966989815235138,
-0.23769228160381317,
-0.0735638365149498,
-0.09531324356794357,
-0.44450634717941284,
-0.2507811188697815,
0.699073314666748,
0.31487900018692017,
-0.46484580636024475,
0.0010636623483151197,
-0.023545771837234497,
-0.28976938128471375,
0.2343509942293167,
1.2226113080978394,
-0.5866689085960388,
0.43101271986961365,
0.13770468533039093,
0.8531396985054016,
0.1819591224193573,
-0.3529066741466522,
0.47855865955352783,
-0.9390153288841248,
0.4490458369255066,
0.2637847363948822,
0.43852633237838745,
0.4586196541786194,
-0.26466870307922363,
0.4828692674636841,
0.4602125585079193,
-0.08165024220943451,
-0.9476739764213562,
0.32607704401016235,
-0.9560893774032593,
-0.34096941351890564,
1.3028827905654907,
0.18090805411338806,
-0.0244777649641037,
-0.43347257375717163,
-0.23355036973953247,
0.19046904146671295,
-0.17318236827850342,
0.7705190777778625,
0.6999427676200867,
0.08668534457683563,
0.149339959025383,
-0.5602032542228699,
0.5253642201423645,
1.001944899559021,
-0.7212415933609009,
-0.13004496693611145,
0.5042523741722107,
0.3074771761894226,
0.24965785443782806,
0.7150759100914001,
-0.08126536011695862,
0.4374937117099762,
0.017193904146552086,
0.4039580225944519,
0.10744692385196686,
-0.16917558014392853,
-0.5883219838142395,
0.1319054663181305,
-0.13767316937446594,
-0.08096405118703842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20708v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20708v1
|
FinGen: A Dataset for Argument Generation in Finance
| 2024-05-31T09:00:43
| 2024-05-31T09:00:43
|
Chung-Chi Chen, Hiroya Takamura, Ichiro Kobayashi, Yusuke Miyao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Thinking about the future is one of the important activities that people do
in daily life. Futurists also pay a lot of effort into figuring out possible
scenarios for the future. We argue that the exploration of this direction is
still in an early stage in the NLP research. To this end, we propose three
argument generation tasks in the financial application scenario. Our
experimental results show these tasks are still big challenges for
representative generation models. Based on our empirical results, we further
point out several unresolved issues and challenges in this research direction.
|
[
-0.5736838579177856,
-0.7149279117584229,
0.32860010862350464,
0.056407567113637924,
-0.07594665884971619,
-0.08084118366241455,
-0.02838290110230446,
-0.43866631388664246,
-0.23834356665611267,
0.7432559728622437,
-1.055061936378479,
-0.3162224590778351,
-0.1178712546825409,
0.048314500600099564,
-0.4436292052268982,
1.0485599040985107,
0.04514216259121895,
0.10013013333082199,
-0.34014880657196045,
0.27672359347343445,
-0.6445136070251465,
-0.4748051166534424,
-1.3412283658981323,
-0.2202809602022171,
0.4483514726161957,
0.48354482650756836,
0.5002081990242004,
0.36251842975616455,
0.42329102754592896,
0.4594053030014038,
0.30884701013565063,
-0.14582069218158722,
-0.026740320026874542,
0.5113908648490906,
-0.34532856941223145,
-0.375221312046051,
-0.14268559217453003,
0.11277949064970016,
0.39785054326057434,
0.7962460517883301,
-0.06941724568605423,
0.15294213593006134,
-0.23990380764007568,
0.7805061340332031,
-0.36220958828926086,
0.23534661531448364,
-0.5238834619522095,
0.18315622210502625,
-0.5185965895652771,
-0.13797186315059662,
-0.29650428891181946,
0.022521572187542915,
0.34921059012413025,
-0.33056771755218506,
0.586270809173584,
0.3183462917804718,
0.8954736590385437,
0.08817396312952042,
-0.23939336836338043,
-0.4312334656715393,
-0.8196228742599487,
0.7199074029922485,
-0.9179280400276184,
0.29854002594947815,
-0.027408787980675697,
0.5011370182037354,
-0.4780387580394745,
-0.8895660638809204,
-0.42494311928749084,
0.3104187846183777,
0.08650291711091995,
0.06255724281072617,
-0.4303542673587799,
-0.03743521124124527,
0.24230128526687622,
0.25676751136779785,
-0.22972720861434937,
-0.01055451761931181,
-0.5041202902793884,
-0.1015315055847168,
0.884937047958374,
0.10598462074995041,
-0.27498534321784973,
-0.32352715730667114,
-0.637412428855896,
-0.5273844003677368,
-0.45638614892959595,
0.1550167202949524,
0.7483596801757812,
0.3822779655456543,
-0.11626685410737991,
0.5723931193351746,
-0.0025399764999747276,
0.964820384979248,
0.10903995484113693,
0.2147025167942047,
-0.0438779778778553,
-0.2605973482131958,
-0.3422871530056,
0.19976858794689178,
0.7464384436607361,
0.39891791343688965,
0.22184577584266663,
0.23484253883361816,
-0.20174504816532135,
-0.2085958868265152,
0.3797747790813446,
-0.4742291569709778,
-0.05521276593208313,
0.8617554903030396,
-0.5069416165351868,
-0.527761697769165,
0.18189257383346558,
-1.4271869659423828,
-0.40526118874549866,
-0.06633123755455017,
-0.0002903830900322646,
-0.34593823552131653,
-0.21309438347816467,
0.5122473835945129,
-0.4614601135253906,
0.34988144040107727,
-0.011065993458032608,
-1.258777379989624,
0.36775994300842285,
1.1240973472595215,
0.3985021412372589,
0.22982093691825867,
-0.05356549099087715,
-0.41723236441612244,
0.16156001389026642,
-0.46610891819000244,
1.3968607187271118,
-0.3138275742530823,
-0.5054650902748108,
0.07485292851924896,
-0.26047900319099426,
-0.2704029381275177,
-0.3275594115257263,
0.5549530386924744,
0.043460261076688766,
0.5310463905334473,
-0.2549988925457001,
-0.8312545418739319,
-0.10686162859201431,
-0.11778255552053452,
-0.5045710206031799,
0.6328951120376587,
0.2816722095012665,
-0.8252915143966675,
0.8418355584144592,
-1.154302954673767,
-0.3833408057689667,
0.48671141266822815,
-0.6308104991912842,
-0.5291091799736023,
0.15779004991054535,
0.12433252483606339,
0.6418645977973938,
-0.5676242113113403,
0.6123910546302795,
-0.2911135256290436,
-0.002489453414455056,
0.411710262298584,
-0.3833274841308594,
0.5738900899887085,
0.2806848883628845,
-0.6475359797477722,
0.014289050363004208,
-0.7633184790611267,
-0.17171956598758698,
0.21831928193569183,
0.30881670117378235,
-0.2932155430316925,
0.5033353567123413,
0.07252252101898193,
0.4210756719112396,
0.09638042002916336,
-0.7834891676902771,
0.12893277406692505,
-0.7878090739250183,
0.6026545166969299,
1.108051061630249,
0.25969478487968445,
-0.006234526634216309,
-0.38729673624038696,
0.6891908645629883,
-0.17431135475635529,
0.10831769555807114,
-0.10922075808048248,
-0.5746874809265137,
-0.5448383688926697,
0.42566147446632385,
0.3473937213420868,
0.2701321840286255,
-0.5617386698722839,
0.04551493749022484,
0.15520329773426056,
-0.45621824264526367,
-0.11001724749803543,
-0.07369708269834518,
0.0881505087018013,
0.5721630454063416,
-0.06099865958094597,
0.5278241634368896,
-0.7517191171646118,
-1.2755045890808105,
-0.11686469614505768,
-0.4723917245864868,
0.054511696100234985,
0.29184165596961975,
0.502549946308136,
0.14095090329647064,
1.0764318704605103,
-0.7489334344863892,
0.16607224941253662,
-0.43678390979766846,
0.3761054277420044,
0.4508819282054901,
0.6504583954811096,
0.9336012601852417,
-1.2882628440856934,
0.2456091344356537,
0.046413522213697433,
-0.45272529125213623,
-0.011485184542834759,
-0.8118382096290588,
-0.3177338242530823,
-0.00989646278321743,
0.6001492738723755,
-0.23308049142360687,
-0.1104130670428276,
0.36686375737190247,
-0.6912915706634521,
0.1749316304922104,
-0.039572082459926605,
-0.1371147781610489,
-1.2730457782745361,
0.1108756959438324,
0.41019758582115173,
0.051083192229270935,
-0.6230931878089905,
-0.06858731806278229,
-0.49017030000686646,
-0.3382084369659424,
-0.22006772458553314,
0.8876343965530396,
0.14691704511642456,
0.1190306544303894,
-0.17103107273578644,
-0.11137887090444565,
-0.15273568034172058,
0.24230284988880157,
0.1063571646809578,
0.7409614324569702,
0.22896617650985718,
-0.36454570293426514,
0.504643440246582,
0.2001606523990631,
-0.2812232971191406,
0.4955558776855469,
-0.46991413831710815,
-0.17721320688724518,
0.09816592931747437,
0.2566602826118469,
-1.1912795305252075,
-0.40329086780548096,
0.21421833336353302,
-0.22690634429454803,
0.13832055032253265,
0.3305189609527588,
-0.27797776460647583,
-0.8911961317062378,
-0.09726335853338242,
-0.03877439349889755,
0.15976081788539886,
-0.45022469758987427,
0.674933135509491,
0.29777833819389343,
-0.7527246475219727,
-0.5620741844177246,
-0.3309284448623657,
0.254424124956131,
-0.6491420865058899,
-0.9463307857513428,
0.49636170268058777,
0.2490195780992508,
-0.8342984914779663,
-0.15389229357242584,
0.014327348209917545,
0.39947691559791565,
0.24413926899433136,
0.3152192533016205,
0.5129420757293701,
-0.30966320633888245,
0.24384759366512299,
0.01911967620253563,
-0.5061104893684387,
0.3426063358783722,
-0.5145760774612427,
0.4965503513813019,
-0.22033077478408813,
-0.11666567623615265,
0.24774983525276184,
0.8889365792274475,
0.20413729548454285,
-0.04593747481703758,
0.20379212498664856,
0.37326106429100037,
-0.4940570592880249,
-0.25247254967689514,
-0.7416683435440063,
0.2842259705066681,
-0.615016758441925,
0.17544691264629364,
-0.13308916985988617,
-0.8006049990653992,
0.5835304856300354,
-0.399138867855072,
0.9020694494247437,
1.2095820903778076,
0.7534524202346802,
-0.26547229290008545,
0.8315743207931519,
0.6636552810668945,
0.46479660272598267,
0.35667088627815247,
-0.33924320340156555,
0.2585247755050659,
-0.20079456269741058,
-0.21683575212955475,
-0.48618564009666443,
-0.42824897170066833,
-0.3393985331058502,
0.008116581477224827,
-0.037443943321704865,
-0.022479655221104622,
-0.025578219443559647,
0.3478984236717224,
-0.3965010643005371,
0.11690053343772888,
0.40427687764167786,
-0.5018684267997742,
-0.18203328549861908,
-0.25481265783309937,
-0.25927722454071045,
-0.0233937855809927,
-0.7360870838165283,
-0.5440749526023865,
0.9024226665496826,
0.3657839298248291,
0.28607767820358276,
-0.27702969312667847,
0.878649115562439,
0.36472511291503906,
0.3275524079799652,
-0.5412176251411438,
0.5529795289039612,
-0.43834319710731506,
-0.7839810252189636,
-0.2046808898448944,
-0.46938812732696533,
-0.9636961221694946,
0.002852840581908822,
-0.34409990906715393,
-0.780258059501648,
0.5844669938087463,
-0.05241972580552101,
-0.9771992564201355,
0.26824942231178284,
-0.5538753271102905,
1.0850980281829834,
-0.33633458614349365,
-0.2995219826698303,
0.11164578795433044,
-0.5464333295822144,
0.6167991757392883,
-0.48558729887008667,
0.5110633969306946,
-0.1878650039434433,
0.44083330035209656,
1.1483830213546753,
-0.7339123487472534,
0.5398174524307251,
-0.3799092769622803,
-0.5536177754402161,
0.6245916485786438,
-0.4792502522468567,
0.3355329632759094,
0.08219702541828156,
-0.2686478793621063,
-0.46541231870651245,
0.15877647697925568,
-0.11794827878475189,
-0.43383297324180603,
0.44196003675460815,
0.032018017023801804,
-0.6190521717071533,
-0.20714415609836578,
-0.5325912237167358,
-0.49446800351142883,
-0.08257726579904556,
0.39492377638816833,
0.4602855443954468,
-0.18313823640346527,
0.06348066031932831,
0.24959661066532135,
-0.12424460053443909,
0.7397040128707886,
0.008300053887069225,
-0.2454388588666916,
-0.5065497756004333,
1.0444191694259644,
-0.03452896326780319,
0.0004747109196614474,
-0.021501954644918442,
0.5843206644058228,
-0.3960490822792053,
-0.4106757938861847,
-0.5012907981872559,
-0.03758743032813072,
-0.6335347294807434,
-0.28831470012664795,
-0.47067180275917053,
0.05890301614999771,
-0.4992007911205292,
-0.7067562341690063,
-0.7523460388183594,
-0.5153188109397888,
0.05867910385131836,
-0.24130333960056305,
0.5578588843345642,
0.6008956432342529,
-0.36982035636901855,
0.17474499344825745,
-0.7932510375976562,
0.29544806480407715,
0.31540942192077637,
0.22580714523792267,
0.032047901302576065,
0.47942835092544556,
-0.5048277974128723,
-0.004202623385936022,
-0.14026421308517456,
-0.42179808020591736,
0.28503361344337463,
-0.06467988342046738,
0.6335055828094482,
0.7536361217498779,
0.08207936584949493,
0.6778846979141235,
-0.10569697618484497,
0.8313066363334656,
0.14001694321632385,
-0.667948842048645,
0.46640539169311523,
-0.4219900071620941,
-0.13907401263713837,
0.7583544850349426,
0.03413234278559685,
-0.5584993362426758,
-0.3799082040786743,
-1.154579997062683,
-1.008370280265808,
0.21381482481956482,
0.07702890038490295,
0.02897528186440468,
-0.31481873989105225,
0.4582175314426422,
0.5659176707267761,
0.27075034379959106,
-0.2877123951911926,
-0.08213318139314651,
-0.10504842549562454,
0.018523704260587692,
-0.053801313042640686,
0.10680927336215973,
-0.040716998279094696,
-0.23564378917217255,
0.484463632106781,
-0.08642380684614182,
0.2776622474193573,
-0.06744767725467682,
1.015670657157898,
-0.28460630774497986,
0.2710360884666443,
0.9309994578361511,
0.4933539032936096,
-0.357888400554657,
-0.2667508125305176,
-0.17848104238510132,
-0.2027253359556198,
0.19961047172546387,
0.4944441616535187,
0.11316034197807312,
0.12474160641431808,
0.5055750012397766,
0.8235678672790527,
0.43704238533973694,
-0.8875970840454102,
0.47271984815597534,
-0.10461203008890152,
-0.9719339609146118,
-0.7662695050239563,
0.2230871021747589,
0.14807604253292084,
0.6211814284324646,
0.702457845211029,
0.19952091574668884,
-0.06765285134315491,
-0.5622656345367432,
0.37110674381256104,
0.26229745149612427,
-0.34899258613586426,
0.05255412682890892,
1.0748653411865234,
0.22561481595039368,
-0.02250966802239418,
0.5136539340019226,
0.05755791813135147,
-0.4738611876964569,
0.6597858667373657,
0.5888484716415405,
1.2077326774597168,
0.21177899837493896,
0.35093826055526733,
0.09622377157211304,
-0.35187381505966187,
-0.41299116611480713,
0.6475793719291687,
0.04259883612394333,
-0.6787611246109009,
-0.5267882943153381,
-0.7762422561645508,
-0.48694929480552673,
0.2582974433898926,
-0.5745944380760193,
0.2943667471408844,
-0.47160303592681885,
-0.4768906831741333,
0.5324706435203552,
0.009709653444588184,
-0.4634770452976227,
0.3181087374687195,
0.21022246778011322,
0.9276877641677856,
-0.7904423475265503,
0.2802315950393677,
0.38135817646980286,
-0.05738821253180504,
-0.46278852224349976,
-0.18654654920101166,
-0.02614021860063076,
-0.30137699842453003,
0.7221704125404358,
-0.03607846796512604,
-0.13378998637199402,
-0.15369299054145813,
-0.5823757648468018,
-0.4652905762195587,
0.8172979950904846,
0.21744181215763092,
-0.579020619392395,
-0.5897670984268188,
-0.042652543634176254,
0.20888321101665497,
-0.766269326210022,
-0.6864389777183533,
0.41736918687820435,
0.8978013396263123,
0.4008805453777313,
-0.025777850300073624,
-0.2394387573003769,
-0.6398962736129761,
-0.25412890315055847,
0.3777560293674469,
-0.5143848657608032,
1.3673536777496338,
-0.19253361225128174,
-0.4180455803871155,
0.048815593123435974,
0.8476611375808716,
0.22292275726795197,
0.4186840355396271,
0.586147665977478,
0.12290921807289124,
0.5489053130149841,
-0.11504331231117249,
1.3883193731307983,
-0.3091113269329071,
0.2181486040353775,
0.9817280769348145,
-0.28655803203582764,
0.7660639882087708,
0.5292967557907104,
-0.21053017675876617,
0.3762345314025879,
1.0460249185562134,
-0.6493863463401794,
0.07494529336690903,
0.49005553126335144,
-0.08427510410547256,
-0.6938011050224304,
0.04991861432790756,
-0.46158042550086975,
0.888317346572876,
0.5142209529876709,
-0.47617125511169434,
-0.30229443311691284,
-0.052931733429431915,
-0.0753839835524559,
0.1083257719874382,
-0.039520133286714554,
0.48974961042404175,
0.01468383427709341,
-0.5710150003433228,
-0.1333363801240921,
0.29421180486679077,
0.5544101595878601,
-0.7154628038406372,
-0.24289144575595856,
0.01687759719789028,
0.10995234549045563,
0.04217788577079773,
-0.6539815664291382,
0.43619000911712646,
0.11473780870437622,
0.20051084458827972,
-0.4081789553165436,
0.8314107656478882,
0.07031646370887756,
-0.9425825476646423,
0.011484331451356411,
0.5380703210830688,
-0.1911935657262802,
0.27150145173072815,
-0.6578786969184875,
-0.5750816464424133,
0.20517463982105255,
-0.47329258918762207,
0.15797053277492523,
0.4887852370738983,
0.09619007259607315,
0.5346742868423462,
0.8670781254768372,
0.0626790001988411,
-0.18507631123065948,
-0.08817105740308762,
0.5816137194633484,
-0.8367499709129333,
-0.39673271775245667,
-1.1417313814163208,
0.20244958996772766,
-0.22028841078281403,
-0.8591828942298889,
0.47946369647979736,
0.6323009133338928,
0.6749838590621948,
-0.004490843508392572,
0.6396454572677612,
0.08564729243516922,
0.2869029939174652,
-0.6724489331245422,
0.574726402759552,
-0.35466518998146057,
0.09931793808937073,
-0.7308040261268616,
-0.6570420265197754,
-0.15545053780078888,
0.7933005094528198,
-0.1748521476984024,
-0.05095664784312248,
0.3980230987071991,
-0.13069197535514832,
0.27475911378860474,
0.68418288230896,
-0.045603249222040176,
-0.34504440426826477,
0.47371140122413635,
0.5434251427650452,
0.638612687587738,
-0.3448623716831207,
0.14445902407169342,
-0.47097843885421753,
0.2541426122188568,
-0.0642213299870491,
-0.9659567475318909,
-0.4933444559574127,
-0.9330772757530212,
-0.42262524366378784,
-0.15286464989185333,
-0.21099348366260529,
1.0328351259231567,
0.14619633555412292,
-0.6758600473403931,
-0.5314126014709473,
-0.3129025995731354,
-0.049465324729681015,
-0.49403509497642517,
-0.1942724585533142,
0.37330225110054016,
-0.19134405255317688,
-0.5854299664497375,
0.4678300619125366,
0.31905829906463623,
0.3621925115585327,
-0.6020097136497498,
0.359028697013855,
-0.30666545033454895,
0.36962026357650757,
0.3204999268054962,
0.3749454617500305,
-0.2745319604873657,
-0.49453502893447876,
-0.3127991855144501,
0.19955068826675415,
-0.1409684270620346,
1.1478852033615112,
-0.6645856499671936,
0.2947591245174408,
0.3377566337585449,
0.5876034498214722,
0.39204931259155273,
0.27497974038124084,
1.384269118309021,
-0.4535630941390991,
0.06277410686016083,
0.10786452144384384,
0.4814019501209259,
0.05651320144534111,
-0.36740243434906006,
0.676792562007904,
-0.015338686294853687,
-0.2164163887500763,
-0.7208784818649292,
0.0652141198515892,
-0.8171831369400024,
-0.45909589529037476,
0.8027563095092773,
0.07110405713319778,
-0.3466669023036957,
-0.10433100163936615,
-0.0319947749376297,
-0.023713592439889908,
-0.28679952025413513,
0.538962721824646,
1.1011970043182373,
-0.38612133264541626,
-0.1699330359697342,
-1.0288394689559937,
0.6201383471488953,
0.2611602544784546,
-0.6104553937911987,
0.6181013584136963,
0.2825238108634949,
-0.341825008392334,
0.40356796979904175,
0.5210490822792053,
-0.08228560537099838,
0.18567997217178345,
0.6677917242050171,
-0.19837315380573273,
-0.1467020958662033,
-0.13158778846263885,
0.1402534395456314,
0.4935014247894287,
-0.43358391523361206,
-0.05237573757767677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20703v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20703v2
|
It is Simple Sometimes: A Study On Improving Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis Performance
| 2024-05-31T08:57:09
| 2024-06-06T10:23:48
|
Laura Cabello, Uchenna Akujuobi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) involves extracting opinions from
textual data about specific entities and their corresponding aspects through
various complementary subtasks. Several prior research has focused on
developing ad hoc designs of varying complexities for these subtasks. In this
paper, we present a generative framework extensible to any ABSA subtask. We
build upon the instruction tuned model proposed by Scaria et al. (2023), who
present an instruction-based model with task descriptions followed by
in-context examples on ABSA subtasks. We propose PFInstruct, an extension to
this instruction learning paradigm by appending an NLP-related task prefix to
the task description. This simple approach leads to improved performance across
all tested SemEval subtasks, surpassing previous state-of-the-art (SOTA) on the
ATE subtask (Rest14) by +3.28 F1-score, and on the AOOE subtask by an average
of +5.43 F1-score across SemEval datasets. Furthermore, we explore the impact
of the prefix-enhanced prompt quality on the ABSA subtasks and find that even a
noisy prefix enhances model performance compared to the baseline. Our method
also achieves competitive results on a biomedical domain dataset (ERSA).
|
[
-0.3346898853778839,
-0.9334943294525146,
0.44977980852127075,
0.26323631405830383,
-0.5553324222564697,
-0.11512718349695206,
0.030406728386878967,
-0.28397417068481445,
0.4686545133590698,
0.26880720257759094,
-0.5985813140869141,
-0.844639003276825,
-0.3038903772830963,
0.08473082631826401,
-0.15818171203136444,
1.0299205780029297,
0.051354069262742996,
0.04766266047954559,
-0.38220450282096863,
-0.17265459895133972,
-0.3747117221355438,
-0.6026101112365723,
-0.7679262757301331,
-0.16697999835014343,
0.3688383996486664,
0.6977810859680176,
0.48952722549438477,
0.4933963418006897,
0.5733068585395813,
0.2588830590248108,
-0.17268714308738708,
0.19323347508907318,
-0.05983726307749748,
0.1749023050069809,
-0.3753381073474884,
-0.3679291605949402,
-0.9635602235794067,
-0.06278271973133087,
0.33188092708587646,
1.037398099899292,
-0.0349503718316555,
0.0912637859582901,
0.23294560611248016,
0.8081453442573547,
-0.465384840965271,
0.5294514298439026,
-0.10423919558525085,
0.07947677373886108,
-0.14460647106170654,
-0.14917513728141785,
-0.3976227343082428,
-0.04739545285701752,
0.1727345883846283,
-0.5228685736656189,
0.3688451945781708,
0.27032727003097534,
0.7563828825950623,
0.24252502620220184,
0.020168080925941467,
-0.4069945216178894,
-0.1836984008550644,
0.6675695180892944,
-0.7614947557449341,
0.3233506381511688,
0.18985961377620697,
-0.23218221962451935,
-0.021106945350766182,
-0.4942408800125122,
-0.2179592102766037,
0.06477388739585876,
-0.0696302130818367,
0.22987952828407288,
-0.1685841828584671,
0.44830211997032166,
0.015782512724399567,
0.8109017610549927,
-0.2880465090274811,
0.16327400505542755,
-0.2822065055370331,
0.023910490795969963,
0.5245082974433899,
0.24266938865184784,
0.18514057993888855,
-0.5383316278457642,
-0.223335862159729,
0.016662994399666786,
-0.6661810874938965,
0.408810555934906,
0.42516928911209106,
0.3060067892074585,
-0.11456792801618576,
0.6307678818702698,
-0.34143123030662537,
0.6674998998641968,
0.21898071467876434,
0.24651135504245758,
0.4436867833137512,
-0.22218702733516693,
-0.16945205628871918,
-0.03551798313856125,
0.6967562437057495,
0.43178510665893555,
-0.4455493092536926,
-0.029590364545583725,
-0.21904559433460236,
-0.010244926437735558,
0.6675112843513489,
-0.7344949841499329,
-0.5938656330108643,
0.366481214761734,
-0.571976363658905,
0.010340739972889423,
0.26161882281303406,
-0.7754923701286316,
-0.29017361998558044,
-0.45150646567344666,
0.18664570152759552,
-0.8096698522567749,
-0.13788479566574097,
0.04268275201320648,
0.24838849902153015,
0.18711084127426147,
0.31399282813072205,
-0.6107375621795654,
0.08325030654668808,
1.1609251499176025,
0.8886234164237976,
-0.2285839021205902,
-0.17524760961532593,
-0.4681117534637451,
-0.5758764743804932,
-0.4119260013103485,
0.9745232462882996,
-0.6667130589485168,
-0.3961088955402374,
-0.1478043645620346,
0.07643615454435349,
-0.14630693197250366,
-0.48576822876930237,
0.4385436773300171,
-0.28589972853660583,
0.07631757855415344,
-0.33087894320487976,
-0.6215406060218811,
-0.6606764197349548,
0.007855710573494434,
-0.5775885581970215,
0.8723081350326538,
0.24922031164169312,
-0.6461309790611267,
0.2752709984779358,
-0.8284620046615601,
-0.818864643573761,
-0.05920088291168213,
-0.08752846717834473,
-0.6222677230834961,
0.5388832092285156,
0.41826415061950684,
0.7040568590164185,
-0.2358524352312088,
0.08748900890350342,
-0.05180556699633598,
-0.22025254368782043,
0.2660244405269623,
-0.20785869657993317,
0.25074172019958496,
0.024090750142931938,
-0.3522498905658722,
0.3783138692378998,
-0.5799118876457214,
-0.029546348378062248,
-0.48368337750434875,
-0.23959028720855713,
-0.529371440410614,
0.06930967420339584,
-0.3260681629180908,
-0.03324214741587639,
0.18621711432933807,
-0.4862233102321625,
-0.0008978130645118654,
-0.8228853344917297,
0.19091947376728058,
0.6173629760742188,
0.26960816979408264,
0.43186771869659424,
-0.22480037808418274,
0.7342091202735901,
0.10624934732913971,
0.28629347681999207,
-0.3424885869026184,
-0.43182799220085144,
-1.0575425624847412,
-0.616009533405304,
0.2525317072868347,
0.3197433054447174,
-0.9499532580375671,
0.5587397217750549,
-0.049277111887931824,
-0.3375571370124817,
-0.7042674422264099,
0.14238929748535156,
0.764474630355835,
0.4565526247024536,
0.5541097521781921,
-0.8515422344207764,
-0.4153069853782654,
-1.0738787651062012,
-0.016981983557343483,
-0.3072280287742615,
0.0005100486450828612,
0.3386227786540985,
0.345095694065094,
0.27016547322273254,
0.8102800846099854,
-0.5827476382255554,
-0.2311169058084488,
-0.5186442732810974,
0.4936352074146271,
0.35229817032814026,
0.4390379786491394,
0.37513184547424316,
-0.7127472162246704,
-0.1658705472946167,
-0.24512282013893127,
-0.6653464436531067,
-0.2253149449825287,
-0.09084459394216537,
-0.26247256994247437,
0.0579778216779232,
0.3128763437271118,
-0.27176937460899353,
0.2859765291213989,
0.267966628074646,
-0.5925222635269165,
0.490172803401947,
0.08723043650388718,
0.2827785909175873,
-1.1889327764511108,
0.039315491914749146,
0.18264900147914886,
-0.030039330944418907,
-0.4457285702228546,
0.17430508136749268,
-0.12210957705974579,
0.06433235108852386,
-0.5811094641685486,
0.1885439157485962,
-0.31747928261756897,
-0.1799861341714859,
-0.4697436988353729,
-0.36430129408836365,
0.05048881843686104,
0.7387973070144653,
0.13596448302268982,
0.8007566332817078,
0.4843214154243469,
-0.617725670337677,
0.2141638845205307,
0.21111927926540375,
-0.23910604417324066,
0.8586506247520447,
-0.7939899563789368,
0.22811754047870636,
-0.2158598154783249,
0.016991471871733665,
-0.7226811647415161,
-0.16267627477645874,
0.3203163743019104,
-0.389120876789093,
0.3395736813545227,
-0.08568814396858215,
-0.07918819040060043,
-0.02594381757080555,
-0.4466938078403473,
0.14867500960826874,
0.2660633623600006,
-0.42602139711380005,
0.8117939829826355,
0.39701205492019653,
-0.5302426815032959,
-0.4459092617034912,
-0.11346464604139328,
-0.0689789280295372,
-0.10582545399665833,
-0.30553218722343445,
0.36854395270347595,
0.24298472702503204,
-0.2624717652797699,
0.17620810866355896,
-0.22971726953983307,
-0.004668262787163258,
0.2017734944820404,
0.7144888043403625,
0.24608491361141205,
-0.4135172665119171,
0.06933711469173431,
0.3742806613445282,
-0.12348555028438568,
0.005421626381576061,
-0.11714443564414978,
0.4043118953704834,
-0.466223806142807,
-0.26399707794189453,
-0.6986792683601379,
0.6342377066612244,
0.44127899408340454,
-0.3527035415172577,
0.6864833235740662,
0.14725236594676971,
-0.07689015567302704,
-0.3964102268218994,
-0.13383574783802032,
-0.24769026041030884,
-0.4516793489456177,
0.6202895045280457,
-0.4768638610839844,
-0.7040784358978271,
0.22986650466918945,
-0.09205258637666702,
0.3688610792160034,
0.3557543158531189,
0.24527108669281006,
-0.30703049898147583,
0.6664106845855713,
0.8420612215995789,
0.07806898653507233,
0.6360545754432678,
-0.5009292960166931,
0.22481819987297058,
-1.1724790334701538,
-0.2951623499393463,
-0.2982083857059479,
-0.3418731689453125,
0.08847469836473465,
-0.549014687538147,
0.47456103563308716,
0.3438758850097656,
-0.0009279760997742414,
0.20326466858386993,
-0.4008789658546448,
0.17611274123191833,
0.5087700486183167,
0.22439420223236084,
-0.017162956297397614,
0.024087855592370033,
-0.0028580455109477043,
-0.05221695825457573,
-0.8547012209892273,
-0.5414088368415833,
0.8931318521499634,
0.4885464608669281,
0.5572496056556702,
0.05439773201942444,
0.5982099771499634,
0.3054044842720032,
0.5937477946281433,
-1.0894993543624878,
0.5984000563621521,
-0.6234353184700012,
-0.07274403423070908,
-0.021522991359233856,
-0.2850962281227112,
-0.5729390978813171,
0.2505551278591156,
-0.009258384816348553,
-0.43733251094818115,
0.39206141233444214,
0.2514551877975464,
-0.6033188104629517,
0.022164607420563698,
-0.642184853553772,
0.8639228940010071,
-0.05824243649840355,
-0.36574727296829224,
-0.16174016892910004,
-0.22611653804779053,
0.043398648500442505,
0.18688605725765228,
0.24898667633533478,
-0.08842544257640839,
0.03637648746371269,
0.8616679310798645,
-0.4878576695919037,
1.1826342344284058,
-0.2585310935974121,
-0.028975175693631172,
0.45121514797210693,
0.0012577095767483115,
0.1896049678325653,
0.10654599219560623,
-0.15204930305480957,
0.18695667386054993,
-0.31970882415771484,
-0.26055774092674255,
-0.7325311303138733,
0.5317631363868713,
-0.4578709602355957,
-0.6621177196502686,
-0.2117963582277298,
-0.3992694914340973,
-0.36816591024398804,
-0.26044872403144836,
0.0933167114853859,
0.7015226483345032,
-0.05682627856731415,
0.33543461561203003,
0.7514735460281372,
-0.2636466324329376,
0.3811989426612854,
0.6271922588348389,
0.2853962481021881,
-0.3760371804237366,
0.8819900751113892,
-0.12314773350954056,
-0.09331220388412476,
0.5127161741256714,
0.038553960621356964,
-0.33985787630081177,
-0.5990126729011536,
-0.5312111377716064,
-0.0040218117646873,
-0.6546053886413574,
-0.42243778705596924,
-0.6765314936637878,
0.060364674776792526,
-0.24112407863140106,
-0.2346309870481491,
-0.6873527765274048,
-0.3525875508785248,
-0.3802717924118042,
-0.3100913166999817,
0.4621504843235016,
0.4649001657962799,
0.1081542819738388,
0.39846092462539673,
-0.6937833428382874,
0.11224494874477386,
0.018495559692382812,
0.2224615514278412,
0.06339097768068314,
-0.595371425151825,
-0.21970558166503906,
-0.18576015532016754,
-0.18739716708660126,
-0.8853338956832886,
0.3159853219985962,
0.3858373463153839,
0.4385981261730194,
0.34290972352027893,
0.23680686950683594,
0.5154558420181274,
-0.3272038400173187,
0.8881677389144897,
0.1422538310289383,
-1.0223371982574463,
0.6607440114021301,
0.03017490729689598,
0.11826814711093903,
0.6477680802345276,
0.26313215494155884,
-0.26102474331855774,
-0.45664334297180176,
-0.6696917414665222,
-1.379732370376587,
0.7233590483665466,
0.08277326077222824,
0.1891501098871231,
-0.029961857944726944,
0.6025229096412659,
0.3755401074886322,
0.3246878981590271,
-0.24320247769355774,
-0.2202446460723877,
-0.5345039963722229,
-0.6852712035179138,
0.015375658869743347,
-0.35705751180648804,
0.06451649218797684,
-0.15186192095279694,
0.8718323707580566,
-0.40456274151802063,
0.22042566537857056,
0.2943127155303955,
0.0398816242814064,
0.33105209469795227,
0.5345857739448547,
0.19065478444099426,
0.6111193299293518,
0.14056804776191711,
0.23309829831123352,
-0.06521047651767731,
-0.4781992733478546,
-0.03536266088485718,
0.09416887164115906,
-0.1766384094953537,
-0.02583366446197033,
0.5851056575775146,
1.0097397565841675,
0.3516866862773895,
-0.49796146154403687,
0.40206441283226013,
0.09295928478240967,
0.1564771980047226,
0.01903250254690647,
0.22996418178081512,
-0.18975263833999634,
0.23986868560314178,
0.32688772678375244,
-0.1318126618862152,
0.3504212200641632,
-0.5287098288536072,
0.42307084798812866,
0.07242701202630997,
-0.5223569869995117,
-0.5552485585212708,
0.3533269166946411,
0.5433326363563538,
-0.19770245254039764,
0.4205853044986725,
-0.47111159563064575,
-0.6672269701957703,
0.7245520353317261,
0.2469339519739151,
0.9072508811950684,
-0.2273779809474945,
0.49968066811561584,
0.2183026671409607,
0.15041542053222656,
0.003730357624590397,
0.5525771975517273,
-0.11322387307882309,
-0.42473104596138,
-0.4845581650733948,
-1.0193878412246704,
-0.42283567786216736,
-0.0033948200289160013,
-0.8138548135757446,
-0.13753741979599,
-0.5502437353134155,
-0.1433623731136322,
0.10061172395944595,
-0.070119209587574,
-0.3426399230957031,
0.42389440536499023,
-0.31947600841522217,
0.5134608745574951,
-0.8600278496742249,
0.46567055583000183,
1.3505781888961792,
-0.4425389766693115,
-0.9371771812438965,
0.06981147825717926,
-0.13444004952907562,
-0.2630443274974823,
0.3904508948326111,
0.18664993345737457,
-0.11289888620376587,
-0.2551670968532562,
-0.08258053660392761,
-0.5555868744850159,
0.7324385643005371,
-0.028207886964082718,
-0.5064582228660583,
0.1664549559354782,
-0.11319920420646667,
0.6388177275657654,
-0.5451920628547668,
-0.03175058960914612,
0.5046176314353943,
0.002604449400678277,
0.039332494139671326,
-0.7184188365936279,
0.14962168037891388,
-0.43988242745399475,
-0.09013385325670242,
0.1374492645263672,
-0.5781278610229492,
0.8844884634017944,
-0.07204879075288773,
-0.1426578313112259,
-0.0028415496926754713,
1.2067512273788452,
0.04140757769346237,
0.4644428789615631,
0.4879397451877594,
0.41068562865257263,
0.5670435428619385,
-0.14370286464691162,
1.04727041721344,
-0.3271573483943939,
0.14824877679347992,
1.1889342069625854,
-0.03575822338461876,
0.8155475854873657,
0.39347347617149353,
-0.08681317418813705,
0.5758782625198364,
0.6739494800567627,
0.23519548773765564,
0.4730839133262634,
-0.08286531269550323,
-0.13371820747852325,
-0.3459799289703369,
-0.3127996027469635,
-0.12578652799129486,
0.624460756778717,
0.6942650079727173,
-0.4804094433784485,
-0.025519099086523056,
0.1967800110578537,
0.13585714995861053,
0.22077682614326477,
-0.5682525634765625,
0.8139803409576416,
0.22363457083702087,
-0.7574604153633118,
0.13724400103092194,
0.31852415204048157,
0.7343106269836426,
-0.3302288055419922,
-0.16086456179618835,
-0.4712693691253662,
0.150149866938591,
-0.29896777868270874,
-0.6587907671928406,
0.48815467953681946,
0.03770606592297554,
-0.28698959946632385,
-0.06073498725891113,
0.2942737936973572,
-0.2684231400489807,
-0.5706793665885925,
-0.14376197755336761,
0.3851574957370758,
0.06554243713617325,
-0.08521474897861481,
-0.6971341371536255,
0.0097260857000947,
-0.0011297075543552637,
-0.28173038363456726,
-0.01964581198990345,
0.3828197419643402,
-0.07213535904884338,
0.28897106647491455,
0.3625268340110779,
-0.012058834545314312,
-0.28211429715156555,
-0.03311656042933464,
0.7938591837882996,
-0.5167140960693359,
-0.7056367993354797,
-0.6528501510620117,
0.32325246930122375,
-0.16396521031856537,
-0.4642274081707001,
0.7148483395576477,
0.6248655319213867,
0.5694743394851685,
-0.01486972626298666,
0.6291335225105286,
-0.29490429162979126,
0.50577712059021,
-0.9187425971031189,
0.4957806468009949,
-0.4797521233558655,
0.4962797462940216,
-0.17876023054122925,
-0.7357475757598877,
-0.11015310883522034,
0.7787359952926636,
-0.4742940366268158,
-0.15530474483966827,
0.8977241516113281,
0.6115222573280334,
-0.035474542528390884,
0.38388803601264954,
-0.06666316837072372,
0.13139288127422333,
0.22683744132518768,
0.5891989469528198,
0.7741726636886597,
-0.18730932474136353,
-0.1321156769990921,
-0.526526689529419,
-0.40595850348472595,
-0.07089085131883621,
-0.6435397863388062,
-0.8827610015869141,
-0.627955973148346,
-0.6862995624542236,
-0.19607913494110107,
0.2587338984012604,
0.914380669593811,
0.6158444285392761,
-0.9058327078819275,
0.08131597191095352,
-0.026414932683110237,
0.08920396119356155,
-0.6273276209831238,
-0.2602003812789917,
0.8344279527664185,
-0.545497715473175,
-0.7071705460548401,
0.5739011168479919,
0.27231913805007935,
-0.18943171203136444,
-0.10631668567657471,
0.24504312872886658,
0.12764017283916473,
0.1693888157606125,
0.6629691123962402,
0.21837283670902252,
-0.40521809458732605,
-0.29602810740470886,
-0.13692092895507812,
0.18482144176959991,
0.056559689342975616,
1.1424931287765503,
-0.5082525610923767,
0.17296196520328522,
0.360762357711792,
0.5265834927558899,
-0.05434544384479523,
0.513023853302002,
0.5860595107078552,
-1.103833794593811,
0.10192053765058517,
0.3942238390445709,
0.3127591013908386,
0.5833252668380737,
-0.5585408806800842,
0.3251400887966156,
0.14932169020175934,
-0.020838746801018715,
-0.44253572821617126,
0.11163491010665894,
-0.7286965847015381,
-0.6175251603126526,
1.1368050575256348,
-0.56326824426651,
-0.5217688083648682,
-0.33512091636657715,
-0.17437194287776947,
0.05458784103393555,
-0.6508566737174988,
0.8583308458328247,
0.46726492047309875,
-0.6019132733345032,
0.030548501759767532,
-0.3068273961544037,
0.6175857782363892,
0.7348630428314209,
-0.9629776477813721,
0.1422988325357437,
0.7812570333480835,
0.11801855266094208,
0.18742777407169342,
0.6043441295623779,
-0.15097440779209137,
0.42646920680999756,
-0.17539231479167938,
0.08832388371229172,
-0.447955459356308,
-0.7434049248695374,
-0.2871844172477722,
0.5853986740112305,
-0.012465165928006172,
-0.46909189224243164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20701v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20701v1
|
Unveiling the Lexical Sensitivity of LLMs: Combinatorial Optimization for Prompt Enhancement
| 2024-05-31T08:53:59
| 2024-05-31T08:53:59
|
Pengwei Zhan, Zhen Xu, Qian Tan, Jie Song, Ru Xie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate exceptional instruct-following
ability to complete various downstream tasks. Although this impressive ability
makes LLMs flexible task solvers, their performance in solving tasks also
heavily relies on instructions. In this paper, we reveal that LLMs are
over-sensitive to lexical variations in task instructions, even when the
variations are imperceptible to humans. By providing models with neighborhood
instructions, which are closely situated in the latent representation space and
differ by only one semantically similar word, the performance on downstream
tasks can be vastly different. Following this property, we propose a black-box
Combinatorial Optimization framework for Prompt Lexical Enhancement (COPLE).
COPLE performs iterative lexical optimization according to the feedback from a
batch of proxy tasks, using a search strategy related to word influence.
Experiments show that even widely-used human-crafted prompts for current
benchmarks suffer from the lexical sensitivity of models, and COPLE recovers
the declined model ability in both instruct-following and solving downstream
tasks.
|
[
-0.2390398383140564,
-0.8187258839607239,
0.7001333832740784,
0.31449055671691895,
-0.1010376363992691,
0.2928216755390167,
-0.29556867480278015,
-0.07593439519405365,
-0.020509736612439156,
0.38547205924987793,
-1.1193755865097046,
-0.22077926993370056,
-0.7020398378372192,
0.28806236386299133,
0.03524607792496681,
0.8160585165023804,
0.18554987013339996,
0.06425933539867401,
-0.28756389021873474,
0.16333210468292236,
-0.5711048245429993,
-0.6428646445274353,
-0.38775819540023804,
-0.20533433556556702,
0.4233801066875458,
0.38678601384162903,
0.6855189204216003,
0.3660026788711548,
0.1589876264333725,
0.2564050853252411,
-0.5055404901504517,
0.40377944707870483,
-0.6733347177505493,
0.14903923869132996,
-0.4947822690010071,
-0.5950784087181091,
-0.14406177401542664,
-0.40052610635757446,
0.6631879806518555,
0.8914564251899719,
0.12956766784191132,
-0.12041609734296799,
0.415335476398468,
0.6215866804122925,
-0.931465208530426,
-0.040524326264858246,
-0.8946446180343628,
-0.3223230540752411,
-0.07492372393608093,
-0.35077276825904846,
-0.3545602858066559,
-0.06777098774909973,
0.03902270644903183,
-0.6650147438049316,
0.3082975745201111,
0.08874418586492538,
0.5296316742897034,
0.4686911702156067,
-0.07767435908317566,
-0.391348659992218,
-0.4136376678943634,
0.8945650458335876,
-0.4716179370880127,
0.2416517436504364,
0.3887571394443512,
-0.16293656826019287,
-0.6477205753326416,
-0.4908043444156647,
-0.13272449374198914,
-0.4240255057811737,
0.008701721206307411,
0.06389179825782776,
-0.37093427777290344,
0.06781797111034393,
0.293221652507782,
0.09313744306564331,
-0.4419707655906677,
0.2326442301273346,
0.009591941721737385,
-0.2896498739719391,
0.2578522562980652,
0.40450116991996765,
0.2760829031467438,
0.02576635219156742,
-0.28310319781303406,
-0.002770829014480114,
-0.5996241569519043,
0.3060420751571655,
0.3240489959716797,
0.5385434031486511,
-0.07519658654928207,
0.48667165637016296,
-0.12794607877731323,
0.5883669257164001,
0.2248568832874298,
-0.08974521607160568,
0.06544624269008636,
-0.5111051797866821,
0.21859033405780792,
0.04799051955342293,
0.37851670384407043,
0.1507534682750702,
0.16533462703227997,
-0.2606032192707062,
-0.32006460428237915,
0.12050246447324753,
0.4233713448047638,
-0.9358932971954346,
-0.024875227361917496,
0.10382097959518433,
-0.2299395650625229,
-0.1874738186597824,
-0.17784665524959564,
-0.7332703471183777,
-0.5891822576522827,
-0.2901459336280823,
0.5637662410736084,
-0.2707865834236145,
0.13078062236309052,
0.05420801043510437,
-0.08662322163581848,
-0.018046600744128227,
0.23756660521030426,
-0.7896173000335693,
0.4419286251068115,
0.8385626077651978,
1.0205790996551514,
-0.3023581802845001,
-0.30702778697013855,
-1.0650179386138916,
0.07321581989526749,
-0.38555383682250977,
0.7725009322166443,
-0.8917718529701233,
-0.834503710269928,
-0.15966235101222992,
0.12166569381952286,
-0.3317330479621887,
-0.5477820634841919,
0.6508602499961853,
-0.30967146158218384,
-0.018210092559456825,
-0.5012223124504089,
-0.738813579082489,
0.07695136964321136,
-0.21755178272724152,
-0.4219586253166199,
0.9436172842979431,
0.34715455770492554,
-0.7265745997428894,
-0.06457869708538055,
-0.6581919193267822,
-0.41351190209388733,
0.293867290019989,
-0.05690602585673332,
-0.09628612548112869,
0.5800705552101135,
0.4893898665904999,
0.22193437814712524,
-0.23543456196784973,
-0.03443804010748863,
-0.17186833918094635,
-0.4541419744491577,
0.2881951332092285,
-0.37796708941459656,
0.8332400918006897,
-0.02317691408097744,
-0.3073579967021942,
0.4011670649051666,
-0.6451003551483154,
-0.21401061117649078,
0.04508667811751366,
-0.2384738326072693,
-0.4112502336502075,
0.1702428162097931,
-0.45126980543136597,
-0.13950218260288239,
0.30647608637809753,
-0.5453452467918396,
0.24510139226913452,
-0.4661950469017029,
0.3058595359325409,
0.9800581336021423,
0.12063471227884293,
0.5952234268188477,
-0.5303964614868164,
0.8108174800872803,
-0.18862862884998322,
0.05896037817001343,
-0.08864254504442215,
-0.5264962911605835,
-0.34137865900993347,
-0.5292646288871765,
-0.10097996145486832,
0.6280068755149841,
-0.6102017760276794,
0.47716978192329407,
-0.23674939572811127,
-0.274431973695755,
-0.31544530391693115,
0.32692787051200867,
0.30517128109931946,
0.5197537541389465,
0.23158890008926392,
-0.08649259060621262,
-0.15954472124576569,
-0.66169673204422,
-0.21258017420768738,
0.050184473395347595,
0.0496930368244648,
0.2831476330757141,
0.2906514108181,
-0.13480891287326813,
0.6797379851341248,
-0.47014012932777405,
-0.01160779595375061,
-0.2629530727863312,
-0.13677440583705902,
0.3703474700450897,
0.13539069890975952,
0.43984362483024597,
-0.4750002324581146,
-0.30323702096939087,
-0.20588503777980804,
-0.09360457211732864,
-0.7667233943939209,
-0.20251351594924927,
-0.3097667396068573,
0.17303331196308136,
0.8496555685997009,
-0.2731914818286896,
0.39969563484191895,
0.5434542298316956,
-0.34179258346557617,
0.7719661593437195,
-0.16744759678840637,
-0.3204769790172577,
-0.7976745963096619,
-0.15456649661064148,
-0.32840150594711304,
-0.15777543187141418,
-0.524985134601593,
0.21204493939876556,
0.13443446159362793,
-0.10574496537446976,
-0.24142131209373474,
0.7247945070266724,
-0.5679495334625244,
0.04584253579378128,
-0.6136834025382996,
-0.010642356239259243,
0.02829487808048725,
0.603484570980072,
0.0771714299917221,
1.0333986282348633,
0.7399583458900452,
-0.7724544405937195,
0.11084707826375961,
0.17861703038215637,
-0.19036903977394104,
0.5380128622055054,
-0.6718576550483704,
0.2501493990421295,
-0.26581138372421265,
0.007775493897497654,
-1.0583994388580322,
0.047575969249010086,
0.22067894041538239,
-0.2750418782234192,
0.31387656927108765,
-0.16969558596611023,
-0.4621617794036865,
-0.19528092443943024,
-0.548265814781189,
0.337891161441803,
0.4313409626483917,
-0.7808438539505005,
0.5904309153556824,
-0.17160744965076447,
-0.28096485137939453,
-0.37892866134643555,
-0.38967669010162354,
-0.17001114785671234,
-0.05782685428857803,
-0.42561182379722595,
0.479703813791275,
-0.5261214375495911,
-0.2352234572172165,
-0.02274717018008232,
-0.18384449183940887,
0.20369970798492432,
0.23255707323551178,
0.353908509016037,
0.2937515079975128,
0.11902502179145813,
0.2869495153427124,
0.05864819884300232,
0.058802325278520584,
0.12821964919567108,
-0.2898314893245697,
0.6523842811584473,
0.1139560416340828,
-0.18004724383354187,
-0.2932848334312439,
0.5089454650878906,
0.13944295048713684,
-0.19309261441230774,
0.6767858862876892,
0.5053116083145142,
-0.16041995584964752,
-0.5407282710075378,
-0.249123215675354,
-0.40164217352867126,
-0.5847840905189514,
0.48699328303337097,
-0.5995859503746033,
-0.8765732049942017,
0.46748197078704834,
-0.12928152084350586,
-0.04061184823513031,
0.04111301898956299,
0.8482910394668579,
0.2941574156284332,
0.8575836420059204,
0.4680215120315552,
-0.023048177361488342,
0.5436142086982727,
0.06320361793041229,
-0.013693156652152538,
-0.9946048259735107,
-0.11423838138580322,
-0.6945879459381104,
0.03419516235589981,
-0.64483642578125,
-0.41117414832115173,
0.4217161536216736,
0.2040594071149826,
-0.12755154073238373,
0.13243058323860168,
-0.685949444770813,
0.4485456943511963,
0.6365283131599426,
0.38530173897743225,
0.09095307439565659,
0.09225305169820786,
-0.39906567335128784,
-0.09028266370296478,
-0.8441640734672546,
-0.32779887318611145,
0.8602752685546875,
0.14668653905391693,
0.8946402668952942,
0.11782810837030411,
0.6072089076042175,
0.17009739577770233,
-0.1872919648885727,
-0.8963329195976257,
0.4800044000148773,
-0.33791425824165344,
-0.35663193464279175,
-0.07476227730512619,
-0.45858821272850037,
-1.0695040225982666,
0.008899125270545483,
-0.14276669919490814,
-1.117950201034546,
0.2809700071811676,
-0.024994153529405594,
-0.4170060455799103,
0.13418759405612946,
-0.774784505367279,
0.5569553375244141,
-0.20469112694263458,
-0.6369189023971558,
-0.0596107579767704,
-0.3761342465877533,
-0.17048043012619019,
-0.18309833109378815,
0.3479631841182709,
-0.0955573320388794,
-0.5689173340797424,
0.30930036306381226,
-0.692020833492279,
1.095967411994934,
-0.001492579118348658,
-0.24335668981075287,
0.15735924243927002,
0.43309494853019714,
0.8065014481544495,
-0.03202710673213005,
-0.013214468024671078,
-0.09732876718044281,
-0.03366886451840401,
-0.5851514935493469,
-0.658443808555603,
0.8216175436973572,
-0.705380380153656,
-0.8242737650871277,
-0.10477257519960403,
-0.8522440791130066,
-0.44080111384391785,
-0.10358071327209473,
0.6715003252029419,
0.7471815943717957,
0.16235926747322083,
-0.21657830476760864,
0.43715307116508484,
-0.36493006348609924,
0.7498354315757751,
0.25407713651657104,
0.0015106216305866838,
-0.22264716029167175,
0.8406748175621033,
0.06654304265975952,
0.5402211546897888,
0.48792123794555664,
0.6321038007736206,
-0.43066439032554626,
-0.7014597058296204,
-0.22088778018951416,
0.23817600309848785,
-0.7585305571556091,
0.009134133346378803,
-0.42528125643730164,
-0.032567158341407776,
-0.2690422236919403,
-0.4681994915008545,
-0.10555032640695572,
-0.33131417632102966,
-0.6127062439918518,
0.1156630590558052,
0.5246008634567261,
0.704595685005188,
-0.08320297300815582,
0.5326758623123169,
-0.620543360710144,
0.19997811317443848,
0.3581134080886841,
0.328497052192688,
0.06502340734004974,
-0.9046558737754822,
0.05810721963644028,
-0.1698819398880005,
-0.17999117076396942,
-0.905066192150116,
0.31420770287513733,
0.22317451238632202,
0.7193756103515625,
0.2079000174999237,
0.27369239926338196,
0.5347898602485657,
-0.38675111532211304,
0.6280980706214905,
-0.055413372814655304,
-1.1182011365890503,
0.5560840368270874,
-0.2552482485771179,
0.7355039715766907,
0.38490450382232666,
0.4588314890861511,
-0.10906975716352463,
-0.40660589933395386,
-0.4154609143733978,
-0.822143018245697,
0.7492765784263611,
0.3116284906864166,
0.3474114239215851,
-0.020120015367865562,
0.5184902548789978,
0.3003055155277252,
0.06841910630464554,
-0.4887992739677429,
-0.16505466401576996,
-0.08673278242349625,
-0.04662200063467026,
-0.07040726393461227,
-0.43816694617271423,
0.048882294446229935,
-0.09006224572658539,
0.603383481502533,
-0.13966093957424164,
0.18513520061969757,
0.42208367586135864,
-0.06462844461202621,
-0.05904562771320343,
0.2903953492641449,
0.5812540054321289,
0.5089923143386841,
-0.1067623719573021,
0.1020880714058876,
0.3023880422115326,
-0.48586466908454895,
-0.02483445778489113,
0.016756020486354828,
-0.31492212414741516,
0.08930066972970963,
0.7191826701164246,
0.9182907342910767,
0.11256378144025803,
-0.5848572254180908,
0.4508707523345947,
0.16481046378612518,
0.040910810232162476,
-0.04654179885983467,
0.2772377133369446,
0.03734753280878067,
0.1869516372680664,
0.38984736800193787,
-0.15973348915576935,
0.23067176342010498,
-0.5365782380104065,
0.05488166585564613,
0.61866694688797,
-0.3269478678703308,
-0.20697209239006042,
0.559799313545227,
0.05580778792500496,
-0.565843403339386,
0.16768185794353485,
-0.6924570798873901,
-0.7134974002838135,
0.4583290219306946,
0.7057593464851379,
0.857085108757019,
-0.11108366400003433,
-0.049649544060230255,
0.4296572506427765,
0.23794522881507874,
0.251444548368454,
0.4131767153739929,
-0.11402053385972977,
-0.7501065135002136,
-0.4562450349330902,
-0.4944009482860565,
-0.42550769448280334,
-0.041411396116018295,
-0.42956337332725525,
0.2576119601726532,
-0.5876920819282532,
-0.14498713612556458,
0.09204181283712387,
0.007906077429652214,
-0.4900283217430115,
-0.25059860944747925,
0.08179467916488647,
0.6872879266738892,
-0.36390000581741333,
0.539941668510437,
0.6765284538269043,
0.04297829419374466,
-0.7509893774986267,
0.16542872786521912,
0.16302888095378876,
-0.9553024172782898,
0.5177180171012878,
0.2078065276145935,
-0.3208581805229187,
0.11424592137336731,
-0.5791239738464355,
-0.6332333087921143,
0.5451739430427551,
0.5404186844825745,
-0.8488163352012634,
0.07898826152086258,
0.06557507812976837,
0.32796889543533325,
-0.4988987445831299,
0.29457563161849976,
0.4064580500125885,
0.3149072825908661,
0.08717580139636993,
-0.8155831694602966,
0.23406386375427246,
-0.02167249098420143,
0.2505272328853607,
0.19393324851989746,
-0.43113285303115845,
0.6069381833076477,
-0.45074474811553955,
-0.2826910614967346,
0.276225745677948,
0.22758522629737854,
0.4357566237449646,
0.09976629167795181,
0.6534936428070068,
0.08162466436624527,
0.6639559268951416,
0.13744397461414337,
1.3952583074569702,
-0.26498448848724365,
-0.03614694997668266,
1.2309128046035767,
-0.08515210449695587,
0.5558094382286072,
0.46586668491363525,
-0.20492349565029144,
0.5023748874664307,
0.5833756327629089,
0.06744925677776337,
0.45512130856513977,
0.4763880968093872,
-0.34523069858551025,
-0.35105764865875244,
-0.579928994178772,
0.03864068537950516,
0.3347691297531128,
0.43059128522872925,
-0.24556300044059753,
-0.25844699144363403,
-0.00888858363032341,
0.07878952473402023,
0.44025352597236633,
-0.7663958668708801,
0.7091635465621948,
-0.03136438503861427,
-0.6048768758773804,
0.8094502687454224,
-0.3495682179927826,
0.8026167154312134,
-0.596014678478241,
0.15823018550872803,
-0.21345718204975128,
0.01090073212981224,
-0.15801723301410675,
-0.4904509484767914,
0.02044367417693138,
-0.16074104607105255,
-0.20803746581077576,
0.22771941125392914,
0.657021701335907,
-0.16234448552131653,
-0.8378124237060547,
0.6676235198974609,
0.49469703435897827,
-0.004357469733804464,
-0.4003991484642029,
-0.5784383416175842,
0.1518678069114685,
0.017536798492074013,
-0.16832531988620758,
0.1406705677509308,
0.32481279969215393,
-0.2716909348964691,
0.7243157029151917,
0.7006396651268005,
0.2880435585975647,
0.35143470764160156,
0.4237465262413025,
0.877955973148346,
-0.44671380519866943,
-0.47294893860816956,
-0.8924576044082642,
0.12734857201576233,
0.12492202967405319,
-0.29677093029022217,
0.4766428768634796,
0.26590555906295776,
0.6288735270500183,
-0.030907483771443367,
0.5667738914489746,
0.27443814277648926,
0.6182931661605835,
-0.6324403285980225,
0.01770082488656044,
-0.5779832601547241,
0.5228177309036255,
-0.23547330498695374,
-0.9672331213951111,
-0.018898244947195053,
0.08574620634317398,
-0.26369422674179077,
0.056677643209695816,
0.7538537979125977,
1.3255598545074463,
0.14391665160655975,
-0.11004991829395294,
0.3408859074115753,
0.10270266234874725,
-0.032485079020261765,
0.708483099937439,
0.9490655064582825,
0.26633238792419434,
0.6348534822463989,
-0.5263760089874268,
-0.29898107051849365,
-0.1678793579339981,
-0.9344961047172546,
-1.047774076461792,
-0.5701470375061035,
-0.42916789650917053,
-0.24841846525669098,
0.2935269773006439,
1.061443567276001,
0.5877577662467957,
-0.6787952184677124,
-0.05324390158057213,
-0.36706382036209106,
0.12404913455247879,
-0.1859058439731598,
-0.2731427252292633,
0.41570988297462463,
-0.7832292318344116,
-0.7853195071220398,
0.6175443530082703,
0.20499323308467865,
0.04045001044869423,
-0.011385111138224602,
-0.04125864431262016,
-0.02789372391998768,
0.28083279728889465,
0.57585608959198,
0.012066585011780262,
-0.6986362934112549,
-0.2587156593799591,
0.2725960612297058,
-0.09738045185804367,
-0.028938820585608482,
1.0064098834991455,
-0.7029402852058411,
0.5755031704902649,
0.5354544520378113,
0.6755608916282654,
0.20822544395923615,
0.06578361988067627,
0.5100987553596497,
-0.926533043384552,
0.2618139386177063,
0.1722104847431183,
0.4534628987312317,
0.3360976278781891,
-0.6919838786125183,
0.5451629161834717,
0.27473822236061096,
-0.49957796931266785,
-0.47612491250038147,
0.45789167284965515,
-1.15488600730896,
-0.8606933355331421,
1.4897956848144531,
0.05890624225139618,
-0.2532360255718231,
-0.1298002153635025,
-0.43885907530784607,
-0.08001695573329926,
-0.6839562058448792,
0.444013774394989,
0.5514336228370667,
-0.2016923874616623,
-0.29323050379753113,
-0.3634514808654785,
0.4398914575576782,
0.7898029088973999,
-0.46800750494003296,
0.1614568829536438,
0.38703861832618713,
0.1141309142112732,
-0.023359445855021477,
0.30851471424102783,
-0.025863241404294968,
0.3636428117752075,
0.019695227965712547,
-0.14488449692726135,
-0.22820070385932922,
-0.08320005238056183,
-0.7159469723701477,
0.06225105747580528,
0.4313132166862488,
-0.2581649422645569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20684v1
|
Joint Embeddings for Graph Instruction Tuning
| 2024-05-31T08:26:47
| 2024-05-31T08:26:47
|
Vlad Argatu, Aaron Haag, Oliver Lohse
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive performance in text
understanding and have become an essential tool for building smart assistants.
Originally focusing on text, they have been enhanced with multimodal
capabilities in recent works that successfully built visual instruction
following assistants. As far as the graph modality goes, however, no such
assistants have yet been developed. Graph structures are complex in that they
represent relation between different features and are permutation invariant.
Moreover, representing them in purely textual form does not always lead to good
LLM performance even for finetuned models. As a result, there is a need to
develop a new method to integrate graphs in LLMs for general graph
understanding. This work explores the integration of the graph modality in LLM
for general graph instruction following tasks. It aims at producing a deep
learning model that enhances an underlying LLM with graph embeddings and trains
it to understand them and to produce, given an instruction, an answer grounded
in the graph representation. The approach performs significantly better than a
graph to text approach and remains consistent even for larger graphs.
|
[
-0.0834897980093956,
-1.1735862493515015,
0.7713466286659241,
-0.1507296860218048,
-0.32179826498031616,
0.4444878101348877,
-0.32300323247909546,
-0.3515520393848419,
0.2964286804199219,
0.6298792362213135,
-0.4101743698120117,
-0.9353477954864502,
-0.7217974066734314,
-0.10824589431285858,
0.00016733200754970312,
0.7347437739372253,
-0.33258047699928284,
0.25227561593055725,
-0.2545856237411499,
-0.07609911262989044,
-0.5755322575569153,
-0.4740721583366394,
-0.4814561903476715,
-0.38745906949043274,
0.609399139881134,
0.2350892424583435,
0.6420227885246277,
0.8600403666496277,
0.06033245474100113,
0.422723650932312,
0.06941491365432739,
0.8880392909049988,
-0.6116014122962952,
-0.08811900019645691,
-0.043619826436042786,
-0.3244568407535553,
-0.6010788083076477,
0.05899237096309662,
0.8745778799057007,
1.0760290622711182,
0.2879619002342224,
-0.1228613629937172,
0.2598459720611572,
0.2962164282798767,
-0.3879511058330536,
0.6649357080459595,
-0.381950318813324,
-0.01654830016195774,
0.08243118226528168,
-0.2747107446193695,
-0.7288360595703125,
-0.3673174977302551,
-0.13030041754245758,
-0.7472125291824341,
0.08017977327108383,
0.06924384832382202,
0.665259063243866,
0.1580076664686203,
-0.7488545179367065,
-0.4009915590286255,
-0.3773192763328552,
0.30708199739456177,
-0.4859875738620758,
0.6521506905555725,
0.2798556387424469,
0.13135989010334015,
-0.2717722952365875,
-0.9805853962898254,
-0.4155164062976837,
-0.03598616644740105,
-0.1353694200515747,
-0.03099898435175419,
0.13571766018867493,
0.45790326595306396,
-0.05021878704428673,
0.2425040304660797,
-0.2780208885669708,
0.49498245120048523,
-0.024664008989930153,
-0.2013605535030365,
0.4293757677078247,
0.36359062790870667,
0.41168713569641113,
-0.06518426537513733,
-0.09845002740621567,
-0.10083949565887451,
-0.6007938981056213,
0.01592443510890007,
0.48520857095718384,
0.45539721846580505,
-0.30789777636528015,
0.6422404646873474,
0.012296373024582863,
1.0402305126190186,
0.08616652339696884,
-0.040651824325323105,
0.1661386787891388,
-0.2530709505081177,
-0.338951051235199,
-0.11791388690471649,
0.6228151917457581,
0.0505274161696434,
0.4159066379070282,
-0.5392917394638062,
-0.1292380839586258,
-0.020696919411420822,
0.09310957044363022,
-0.817527174949646,
-0.49770206212997437,
-0.26981115341186523,
-0.1643683761358261,
-0.17704567313194275,
0.03709322586655617,
-0.23298244178295135,
-0.33777278661727905,
-0.5284034609794617,
0.2698343098163605,
-0.4968823194503784,
-0.0008861487149260938,
0.1441987007856369,
0.0615222193300724,
0.13916471600532532,
0.5383827090263367,
-1.0004658699035645,
0.2556116282939911,
0.8412051796913147,
0.6913870573043823,
0.044704534113407135,
-0.3655942380428314,
-0.8598924875259399,
0.5823785662651062,
-0.5373963117599487,
0.6500952839851379,
-1.0803353786468506,
-0.36075571179389954,
0.08826132863759995,
0.3654986619949341,
-0.5214228630065918,
-0.14012224972248077,
0.1128142923116684,
-0.73297119140625,
0.1671721637248993,
-0.05572352185845375,
-0.9538933038711548,
-0.5685009360313416,
0.2516128420829773,
-0.5385041832923889,
0.5649638175964355,
0.29102790355682373,
-0.6441444158554077,
0.1001640036702156,
-0.4403146505355835,
-0.5610888004302979,
0.018419302999973297,
-0.45384857058525085,
-0.37243974208831787,
-0.021547771990299225,
0.47617724537849426,
0.5853813886642456,
-0.06090797111392021,
-0.04798845946788788,
-0.5337240695953369,
-0.558996319770813,
0.10469956696033478,
-0.37920817732810974,
0.6818254590034485,
-0.26112666726112366,
0.00883270800113678,
0.3090968728065491,
-0.3548910319805145,
0.14027012884616852,
0.0979459211230278,
-0.5222263336181641,
-0.24039559066295624,
-0.1508026421070099,
-0.22046256065368652,
-0.23542888462543488,
0.2803322970867157,
-0.3383602499961853,
0.5049424767494202,
-0.25587427616119385,
0.5057432055473328,
1.021222710609436,
0.04014528542757034,
0.40584826469421387,
0.09437800198793411,
0.5159875750541687,
-0.29748982191085815,
-0.06261470913887024,
-0.20307180285453796,
-0.38537412881851196,
-0.6191953420639038,
-0.48831871151924133,
0.48257914185523987,
0.524872899055481,
-0.7939345836639404,
0.45554685592651367,
-0.4161103367805481,
-0.0897957906126976,
-0.455527663230896,
0.5470234751701355,
0.5147950649261475,
0.5186936259269714,
0.21718591451644897,
-0.19948770105838776,
-0.36238858103752136,
-0.5278815031051636,
0.17334721982479095,
0.19970102608203888,
0.2839103043079376,
0.5987581610679626,
0.15139369666576385,
-0.3842022716999054,
0.5611900687217712,
-0.6873015761375427,
-0.13139894604682922,
-0.3303682208061218,
-0.10269035398960114,
0.1511521339416504,
0.3181850016117096,
0.5340522527694702,
-0.5403798818588257,
-0.6421367526054382,
0.20125912129878998,
-0.8914123773574829,
0.1368379294872284,
0.1405278444290161,
-0.19404146075248718,
0.06217806413769722,
0.7290193438529968,
-0.41352254152297974,
0.19080190360546112,
0.6876676678657532,
-0.4119742214679718,
0.05445987731218338,
-0.2556644380092621,
0.001321104820817709,
-1.2085925340652466,
-0.28133344650268555,
-0.13444748520851135,
-0.5829024314880371,
-0.2793869376182556,
0.08549335598945618,
0.035065170377492905,
-0.2952851951122284,
-0.1260920912027359,
0.42284661531448364,
-0.8357267379760742,
-0.1708623617887497,
-0.19433708488941193,
0.4083106517791748,
0.2301807850599289,
0.5652708411216736,
-0.33869755268096924,
0.7748657464981079,
0.6143409013748169,
-0.42256611585617065,
0.4091983735561371,
0.29121658205986023,
-0.10681165009737015,
0.2680121958255768,
-0.5728296637535095,
0.5098652839660645,
-0.14568352699279785,
0.4233216643333435,
-1.1777664422988892,
-0.37893712520599365,
0.4036904573440552,
-0.2421967089176178,
0.9590468406677246,
-0.458275705575943,
-0.6041068434715271,
-0.2977157533168793,
-0.17306749522686005,
0.24265269935131073,
0.21804594993591309,
-0.6962147355079651,
0.9021982550621033,
0.5135542154312134,
0.07721323519945145,
-0.4330688714981079,
-0.5206977725028992,
-0.05964924022555351,
0.1549348384141922,
-0.7547677755355835,
0.36150556802749634,
0.17477452754974365,
0.1732085943222046,
0.29673993587493896,
0.07547339797019958,
0.08194476366043091,
0.11955445259809494,
0.30395880341529846,
0.23486559092998505,
-0.34653058648109436,
0.2778921127319336,
0.3517773449420929,
-0.3417827785015106,
-0.1427169293165207,
-0.2788103222846985,
0.7831737399101257,
0.01620923914015293,
-0.6761463284492493,
-0.6661111116409302,
0.3381655216217041,
0.3686700165271759,
-0.42675915360450745,
0.5742053389549255,
0.6903606653213501,
-0.000965692161116749,
-0.21309730410575867,
-0.22702418267726898,
-0.06050245091319084,
-0.5467748045921326,
0.634456217288971,
-0.40421849489212036,
-1.0935719013214111,
0.4730376601219177,
-0.5026491284370422,
-0.16595618426799774,
0.14104296267032623,
0.28753259778022766,
-0.18578413128852844,
1.3164738416671753,
0.7701139450073242,
-0.0546378567814827,
0.7062546610832214,
-0.6403782963752747,
0.2734111249446869,
-0.960321307182312,
-0.24112366139888763,
-0.18737196922302246,
-0.4372238516807556,
-0.6353929042816162,
-0.7181745171546936,
0.2400306910276413,
0.35713624954223633,
-0.3411337435245514,
-0.014611548744142056,
-0.3734263479709625,
0.6076648235321045,
0.24676162004470825,
0.42595547437667847,
0.12351037561893463,
0.09863501787185669,
-0.2328520566225052,
0.21902896463871002,
-0.8247037529945374,
-0.49311405420303345,
0.9552903175354004,
0.3247985541820526,
0.9461503624916077,
0.057364434003829956,
0.7665037512779236,
0.08963005989789963,
0.3491367697715759,
-0.7712456583976746,
0.591222882270813,
-0.7172689437866211,
0.15314561128616333,
-0.35432305932044983,
-0.33404043316841125,
-1.0058927536010742,
0.07604050636291504,
-0.10403174161911011,
-0.8485353589057922,
-0.13952139019966125,
0.24072147905826569,
0.0835331603884697,
0.419525146484375,
-0.9285311698913574,
0.8919674158096313,
-0.24664480984210968,
-0.32008910179138184,
-0.26919829845428467,
-0.305986613035202,
0.14020268619060516,
0.4280525743961334,
-0.02716739848256111,
-0.07110894471406937,
-0.13953205943107605,
0.3873225450515747,
-0.29431992769241333,
1.350704312324524,
-0.2258721888065338,
-0.057556092739105225,
0.2730764150619507,
0.06659732013940811,
0.8441240787506104,
0.026017162948846817,
-0.1005869209766388,
-0.15874306857585907,
-0.5796941518783569,
-0.41321447491645813,
-0.8244863748550415,
0.9297332763671875,
-1.0348854064941406,
-0.7948526740074158,
0.2698141932487488,
-0.8823419809341431,
-0.3336523771286011,
0.1851884126663208,
-0.14905481040477753,
0.8023253679275513,
-0.016769956797361374,
0.17635196447372437,
0.6960222721099854,
-0.08103280514478683,
0.28994327783584595,
0.10769909620285034,
-0.30127856135368347,
-0.5584554672241211,
0.9492038488388062,
0.2685120105743408,
0.2756199836730957,
0.4747319519519806,
0.09929382801055908,
-0.36965978145599365,
-0.5165185928344727,
-0.6811651587486267,
0.4374573230743408,
-1.0861430168151855,
-0.17043325304985046,
-0.7274888157844543,
-0.23976092040538788,
-0.505454421043396,
-0.3060157001018524,
-0.033462438732385635,
-0.17638061940670013,
-0.5892241597175598,
-0.2196229249238968,
0.6036907434463501,
0.9640011191368103,
0.31394413113594055,
0.4333705008029938,
-0.6864809393882751,
0.09612089395523071,
0.6054742336273193,
0.4433666467666626,
0.0819191262125969,
-0.39614877104759216,
-0.3724112808704376,
0.05870174244046211,
-0.3636361062526703,
-0.8554956316947937,
-0.011138112284243107,
0.17945151031017303,
0.8076360821723938,
0.24711593985557556,
-0.29537925124168396,
0.8129155039787292,
-0.3916255831718445,
0.43253108859062195,
-0.009640519507229328,
-1.0742747783660889,
0.31444549560546875,
-0.34523189067840576,
-0.02851703204214573,
0.3363499045372009,
0.3751606345176697,
-0.12808986008167267,
-0.2633066177368164,
-0.27024543285369873,
-0.7412545680999756,
0.5003049969673157,
-0.36735594272613525,
0.5671959519386292,
0.018249500542879105,
0.4408957064151764,
-0.050823088735342026,
0.0011673193657770753,
-0.540635883808136,
-0.049004457890987396,
-0.24227087199687958,
-0.33801940083503723,
-0.1114419549703598,
-0.08433686196804047,
-0.2508242428302765,
-0.45367908477783203,
0.32636669278144836,
-0.5837985873222351,
0.2554249167442322,
-0.2280689924955368,
-0.273136168718338,
0.03519899398088455,
-0.160722553730011,
0.3159434497356415,
0.7114923596382141,
0.13484632968902588,
0.28567779064178467,
0.32730579376220703,
-0.19455228745937347,
-0.05861116573214531,
0.12652327120304108,
0.04735172167420387,
-0.12265967577695847,
0.6947378516197205,
1.1900873184204102,
0.3956274390220642,
-0.2593260109424591,
0.503192126750946,
0.19276118278503418,
-0.02632848359644413,
0.12207745760679245,
0.27077656984329224,
0.5240782499313354,
0.3418065011501312,
-0.04306865856051445,
-0.42791637778282166,
-0.1444103866815567,
-0.6126418113708496,
0.023569678887724876,
0.5915294289588928,
-0.502479076385498,
-0.23960261046886444,
0.4073590934276581,
0.28355252742767334,
-0.6652243137359619,
0.8178398013114929,
-0.25053784251213074,
-0.6131658554077148,
0.6235780119895935,
0.9161245226860046,
0.7085838913917542,
-0.06961287558078766,
0.3033140003681183,
0.0651918277144432,
-0.06340815871953964,
0.6389832496643066,
0.3529122471809387,
-0.08792107552289963,
-0.6545948386192322,
-0.6739132404327393,
-0.3584248423576355,
-0.41510412096977234,
-0.27917343378067017,
-0.2933785021305084,
0.278795450925827,
-0.5696250200271606,
-0.010514851659536362,
-0.03920860216021538,
-0.01503029465675354,
-0.784350574016571,
-0.06139792874455452,
0.08598344027996063,
0.5436680912971497,
-0.970362663269043,
0.9582855105400085,
0.695930540561676,
-0.37780705094337463,
-1.1396833658218384,
-0.014318195171654224,
-0.34941360354423523,
-1.052216649055481,
0.566189706325531,
0.3465059697628021,
-0.22516384720802307,
0.2813003957271576,
-0.6304236650466919,
-0.6546832323074341,
1.2406337261199951,
0.7225770950317383,
-0.49773672223091125,
-0.07077208161354065,
0.12898269295692444,
0.40220171213150024,
-0.631116509437561,
-0.03955185040831566,
0.10537608712911606,
0.4069598913192749,
0.07963374257087708,
-0.5217761993408203,
0.15042154490947723,
-0.05352307856082916,
0.06030762568116188,
0.3643789291381836,
-0.7480815649032593,
0.9669774174690247,
-0.2637484073638916,
-0.12069974094629288,
-0.19330713152885437,
0.572641909122467,
0.07195816189050674,
0.12234177440404892,
0.3897237777709961,
0.5091862082481384,
0.942625880241394,
0.04737228900194168,
1.3343621492385864,
-0.5139411091804504,
0.21698735654354095,
1.2919691801071167,
-0.038206636905670166,
0.4986361861228943,
0.2866513729095459,
0.026909293606877327,
0.7401587963104248,
0.6241647005081177,
0.10216710716485977,
0.4304758906364441,
0.18957369029521942,
-0.05787961930036545,
-0.5587441325187683,
-0.25596657395362854,
-0.3858800232410431,
0.6592592597007751,
0.5592978596687317,
-0.6521525382995605,
-0.24236412346363068,
-0.12237358093261719,
0.10704159736633301,
0.3667525351047516,
-0.31515008211135864,
0.8880246877670288,
0.041366271674633026,
-0.27167391777038574,
0.5509507656097412,
-0.042684223502874374,
0.334873765707016,
-0.6207930445671082,
-0.3735392689704895,
-0.020070219412446022,
0.0956936702132225,
-0.18002623319625854,
-0.8529623746871948,
0.05847109481692314,
-0.35668623447418213,
-0.1924898773431778,
-0.15204815566539764,
0.3887079656124115,
-0.36732274293899536,
-0.5779516100883484,
0.5472242832183838,
0.4085548520088196,
-0.1279483139514923,
0.5091775059700012,
-0.4654126465320587,
0.24046652019023895,
0.01721430942416191,
-0.07212952524423599,
0.3009881377220154,
0.72535240650177,
-0.006478374823927879,
0.4379679262638092,
0.6416694521903992,
-0.15443551540374756,
0.005271046422421932,
0.4008326530456543,
1.2906368970870972,
-0.2801901698112488,
-0.45285412669181824,
-0.7705051302909851,
0.39182743430137634,
-0.08803509920835495,
-0.31025245785713196,
0.717541515827179,
0.49935200810432434,
0.6218757033348083,
0.12433147430419922,
0.4428807199001312,
0.29052630066871643,
-0.023172536864876747,
-0.8752585649490356,
0.5388559699058533,
-0.44690802693367004,
0.15585264563560486,
-0.24196115136146545,
-0.9285528659820557,
-0.35294249653816223,
0.582625150680542,
-0.5289011001586914,
0.09281902015209198,
0.406875878572464,
0.8878133893013,
-0.32525184750556946,
-0.15412771701812744,
0.1714404821395874,
0.11682776361703873,
0.5028213262557983,
0.5285537242889404,
0.5557082891464233,
-0.21219013631343842,
0.408935546875,
-0.07141299545764923,
-0.038992807269096375,
-0.1364208161830902,
-0.7908205389976501,
-1.1595090627670288,
-0.3414878249168396,
-0.1896866112947464,
-0.35438835620880127,
0.11205701529979706,
0.7613021731376648,
0.7648429274559021,
-0.499999076128006,
-0.02926984615623951,
-0.1396154910326004,
0.46818795800209045,
-0.03394332900643349,
-0.19047893583774567,
0.7196003794670105,
-0.4655630588531494,
-0.8609786033630371,
0.52517169713974,
0.34195536375045776,
0.24450130760669708,
-0.3461061418056488,
-0.30188900232315063,
-0.21858887374401093,
0.0580814853310585,
0.5196810960769653,
0.005420571193099022,
-0.5379143953323364,
-0.7483213543891907,
0.01161994133144617,
-0.21465829014778137,
0.12488680332899094,
0.7952773571014404,
-0.5428925156593323,
0.5950499176979065,
0.5833265781402588,
0.8834697008132935,
0.7849507927894592,
-0.10384628176689148,
0.5871694684028625,
-0.8230176568031311,
0.23621636629104614,
0.15020732581615448,
0.4156985282897949,
0.547745943069458,
-0.379069983959198,
0.45515790581703186,
0.1547575294971466,
-0.37911829352378845,
-0.7115753889083862,
0.33458805084228516,
-0.9861977696418762,
-0.2969997823238373,
0.865985095500946,
-0.44091203808784485,
-0.2756924331188202,
-0.004199990537017584,
-0.22242902219295502,
0.7298154234886169,
-0.06515168398618698,
0.4771799147129059,
0.30287620425224304,
-0.24416221678256989,
-0.10451972484588623,
-0.1338137984275818,
-0.05535596236586571,
-0.026447955518960953,
-0.7382583618164062,
0.08508317172527313,
0.46240636706352234,
0.21875877678394318,
-0.018441183492541313,
0.476479172706604,
0.1338389664888382,
0.16844239830970764,
0.1817968636751175,
-0.2261105626821518,
-0.7228870987892151,
-0.3198809325695038,
-0.0911235585808754,
0.15648210048675537,
0.16655543446540833,
-0.44022753834724426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20680v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20680v3
|
Unraveling and Mitigating Retriever Inconsistencies in Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T08:22:49
| 2024-06-04T11:51:53
|
Mingda Li, Xinyu Li, Yifan Chen, Wenfeng Xuan, Weinan Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALMs) demonstrate their
superiority in terms of factuality, they do not consistently outperform the
original retrieval-free Language Models (LMs). Our experiments reveal that this
example-level performance inconsistency exists not only between
retrieval-augmented and retrieval-free LM but also among different retrievers.
To understand this phenomenon, we investigate the degeneration behavior of
RALMs and theoretically decompose it into four categories. Further analysis
based on our decomposition reveals that the innate difference in knowledge
sources and the unpredictable degeneration of the reader model contribute most
to the inconsistency. Drawing from our analysis, we introduce Ensemble of
Retrievers (EoR), a trainable framework that can adaptively retrieve from
different knowledge sources and effectively decrease unpredictable reader
errors. Our experiments on Open Domain Question Answering show that EoR
substantially improves performance over the RALM with a single retriever by
considerably reducing inconsistent behaviors.
|
[
-0.2196931540966034,
-0.8446778059005737,
0.3263375759124756,
-0.2391834557056427,
0.16882121562957764,
0.4772028625011444,
-0.09921490401029587,
-0.711296021938324,
-0.015362021513283253,
0.45321133732795715,
-0.15855619311332703,
0.0936022400856018,
-0.6946403384208679,
0.31374257802963257,
-0.2559431195259094,
0.8992452621459961,
0.11357731372117996,
-0.16364829242229462,
-0.3330633342266083,
-0.5400859713554382,
-0.3435209393501282,
-0.46114134788513184,
-0.6569106578826904,
-0.4737281799316406,
0.44948962330818176,
0.24858666956424713,
0.6709449291229248,
0.38623687624931335,
0.7018349170684814,
0.2712075114250183,
-0.13941390812397003,
0.3462379574775696,
-0.6135149002075195,
0.5871450304985046,
-0.3947067856788635,
-0.7279682755470276,
-0.12066048383712769,
-0.4063998758792877,
0.4812450110912323,
0.5410463213920593,
-0.5046606063842773,
-0.08417445421218872,
0.09187936037778854,
0.9110546708106995,
-0.9346732497215271,
-0.09039217233657837,
-0.8215174674987793,
-0.15149298310279846,
-0.06269824504852295,
-0.35549411177635193,
-0.6972640752792358,
-0.38778191804885864,
0.2028566151857376,
-0.508972704410553,
0.6832768321037292,
0.2363218069076538,
0.6719015836715698,
0.3102346658706665,
-0.19173799455165863,
-0.3091428577899933,
-1.1664631366729736,
0.8185853362083435,
-0.5559664368629456,
0.44002678990364075,
0.4820563793182373,
0.3175450265407562,
-0.0016790397930890322,
-0.3266553580760956,
-0.48906734585762024,
-0.10688045620918274,
-0.17640094459056854,
-0.031080275774002075,
-0.42570260167121887,
0.004675437230616808,
0.13040193915367126,
0.35222703218460083,
-0.6751760840415955,
0.12069273740053177,
-0.3005375564098358,
-0.07015614956617355,
0.5252810120582581,
0.12805332243442535,
0.2950279712677002,
0.011543306522071362,
-0.2721700370311737,
-0.2558269202709198,
-0.8132093548774719,
-0.03047112561762333,
0.21678026020526886,
0.23172391951084137,
0.29107171297073364,
0.47065433859825134,
-0.13095903396606445,
0.6745829582214355,
0.16364340484142303,
0.028781285509467125,
0.3130354583263397,
-0.0323067307472229,
-0.22427769005298615,
0.15729013085365295,
0.4671477973461151,
-0.03427357226610184,
-0.04268432781100273,
-0.5007951855659485,
-0.4033876657485962,
-0.2649470269680023,
0.1375970095396042,
-0.5821097493171692,
-0.2707965075969696,
0.4909251034259796,
-0.38863134384155273,
-0.05845091864466667,
0.045120786875486374,
-0.8154453039169312,
-0.4718894362449646,
-0.10168598592281342,
0.7094314694404602,
-0.526124894618988,
-0.5249602794647217,
0.07258997112512589,
-0.23083138465881348,
0.21668708324432373,
0.34568724036216736,
-0.9123520851135254,
0.27348417043685913,
0.4780351519584656,
0.4339038133621216,
0.03180120512843132,
-0.2556225061416626,
-0.6595730781555176,
0.19056162238121033,
-0.3588395416736603,
0.9007482528686523,
-0.6869234442710876,
-0.27034226059913635,
0.004907664377242327,
-0.23331543803215027,
-0.47185787558555603,
-0.8630117774009705,
0.4616222381591797,
-1.1056047677993774,
0.06342374533414841,
-0.2998431324958801,
-0.6143801808357239,
-0.2647792398929596,
0.4433654844760895,
-0.8264846801757812,
1.0838055610656738,
-0.02120542898774147,
-0.9029335975646973,
0.22183017432689667,
-0.4816742241382599,
-0.16901789605617523,
-0.002329561859369278,
0.03607525676488876,
-0.190978541970253,
0.42966049909591675,
0.09966779500246048,
0.03849443048238754,
-0.23034194111824036,
-0.0176022257655859,
-0.15936800837516785,
-0.4961109757423401,
0.39483368396759033,
-0.3055284023284912,
0.5823717713356018,
0.371622234582901,
0.07075323909521103,
-0.14780117571353912,
-0.9696862697601318,
0.06855951994657516,
0.22563427686691284,
-0.5360755324363708,
-0.8583233952522278,
0.2926349937915802,
-0.2490677535533905,
0.03138311952352524,
0.14563985168933868,
-0.6321255564689636,
0.1184174194931984,
-0.5313915610313416,
0.2723884880542755,
0.5805919170379639,
0.08908771723508835,
0.5443383455276489,
-0.4763204753398895,
0.4577881991863251,
0.20509123802185059,
-0.18520262837409973,
-0.19981078803539276,
0.03360525146126747,
-0.7648679614067078,
-0.09276781976222992,
0.1542985588312149,
0.6627696752548218,
-0.9853697419166565,
0.058396998792886734,
-0.44628483057022095,
-0.3485806882381439,
-0.706457793712616,
0.1006278321146965,
0.5895940065383911,
0.48645591735839844,
0.5394243001937866,
0.19137628376483917,
-0.4379846751689911,
-0.6733527183532715,
-0.6725041270256042,
-0.22469741106033325,
0.1700538694858551,
0.010456250049173832,
0.41293203830718994,
-0.17545534670352936,
0.9001888036727905,
-0.18599583208560944,
0.03494159132242203,
-0.352107971906662,
0.16250871121883392,
-0.0667373463511467,
0.603180468082428,
0.2816303074359894,
-0.8553361892700195,
-0.09406400471925735,
0.1090584546327591,
-0.708743691444397,
0.26269862055778503,
0.09526140987873077,
0.1338953673839569,
0.5146157145500183,
0.4764302968978882,
-0.49359893798828125,
0.4646468460559845,
0.22870370745658875,
-0.09573175758123398,
0.4297531843185425,
-0.5648643970489502,
0.18537819385528564,
-0.6100549697875977,
0.09921974688768387,
-0.19807711243629456,
0.10689309984445572,
-0.5367443561553955,
0.28279373049736023,
0.18663747608661652,
0.22213372588157654,
-0.16059187054634094,
0.6392365097999573,
-0.6401329040527344,
-0.05861181020736694,
-0.1421389877796173,
0.0861067995429039,
0.22861537337303162,
0.2047743946313858,
-0.16218380630016327,
0.7408176064491272,
0.3386547565460205,
-0.7946950793266296,
0.1039687767624855,
0.5118416547775269,
-0.3859724998474121,
0.44943907856941223,
-0.6887240409851074,
0.31685084104537964,
-0.6582099199295044,
-0.004837784916162491,
-1.089168906211853,
-0.32031652331352234,
0.0775352194905281,
-0.439748615026474,
0.6721869707107544,
-0.06107939034700394,
-0.5415819883346558,
-0.25405412912368774,
-0.2101403772830963,
0.4221237301826477,
0.3497683107852936,
-0.663260817527771,
0.6304813623428345,
-0.031519562005996704,
-0.109094999730587,
-0.9444935321807861,
-0.853293240070343,
-0.11911595612764359,
-0.08618498593568802,
-0.5859136581420898,
0.15257379412651062,
-0.10930093377828598,
-0.5850920081138611,
0.15705853700637817,
-0.14525483548641205,
-0.0696185752749443,
0.12383398413658142,
-0.205739825963974,
0.16355140507221222,
-0.2937985062599182,
0.6395514607429504,
0.027431566268205643,
0.1010701060295105,
-0.14230112731456757,
0.12842179834842682,
0.3564896285533905,
-0.08525802940130234,
-0.659220814704895,
0.07348265498876572,
0.37141504883766174,
0.5272623300552368,
-0.6762740612030029,
1.173701286315918,
0.10231063514947891,
-0.18876118957996368,
-0.2124582678079605,
-0.9470089077949524,
-0.17562992870807648,
-0.40984514355659485,
0.3688480854034424,
-0.43574732542037964,
-0.9929055571556091,
0.8951707482337952,
0.2518980801105499,
0.13029056787490845,
0.4473063051700592,
0.06139378249645233,
0.1813666671514511,
1.0732357501983643,
0.6251446604728699,
0.22290471196174622,
0.30247047543525696,
0.02412305772304535,
0.19493038952350616,
-0.9872784614562988,
-0.3803361654281616,
-0.9015020132064819,
-0.2120194137096405,
-0.5316263437271118,
-0.10282055288553238,
0.26888802647590637,
0.43953412771224976,
-0.44788581132888794,
-0.047546062618494034,
-0.42047032713890076,
0.6434176564216614,
0.4985302686691284,
0.20568406581878662,
0.6228652000427246,
0.17848345637321472,
-0.16296234726905823,
0.135964035987854,
-0.8700594305992126,
-0.49526411294937134,
0.9007844924926758,
0.04274450242519379,
0.9664697051048279,
0.43863844871520996,
0.6612575650215149,
0.11450380831956863,
0.26170769333839417,
-0.5333251357078552,
0.14996860921382904,
-0.020408447831869125,
-0.9602436423301697,
-0.27703776955604553,
-0.49445202946662903,
-1.056951880455017,
0.4885745048522949,
-0.12178117036819458,
-0.801222562789917,
0.5502667427062988,
0.22296680510044098,
-0.2953318953514099,
0.42604538798332214,
-0.5794933438301086,
0.6065170168876648,
-0.10776440054178238,
-0.49096450209617615,
-0.12775079905986786,
-0.8014512062072754,
0.42465174198150635,
-0.06316109001636505,
0.29672905802726746,
0.18926690518856049,
0.11231563240289688,
0.4660894274711609,
-0.3243185877799988,
0.506904125213623,
-0.16672565042972565,
-0.07111068814992905,
0.4172198474407196,
0.46848323941230774,
0.7285318970680237,
-0.2968571186065674,
-0.4471701979637146,
-0.3616272211074829,
0.1526922583580017,
-0.5279466509819031,
-0.5449097752571106,
0.5100958347320557,
-0.8279291987419128,
-0.5978863835334778,
-0.4276435971260071,
-0.48883649706840515,
-0.442649245262146,
0.03472070395946503,
0.35563990473747253,
0.7587760090827942,
-0.29421356320381165,
0.26128560304641724,
1.0754414796829224,
-0.34819695353507996,
0.5201653838157654,
0.7247967720031738,
-0.26315146684646606,
-0.2445400059223175,
0.8815799355506897,
0.16500821709632874,
0.4471643567085266,
0.7659112811088562,
-0.009694471955299377,
-0.477690190076828,
-0.7534700036048889,
-0.24408359825611115,
0.1864844560623169,
-0.8356320261955261,
-0.15140141546726227,
-0.7187322378158569,
-0.13762974739074707,
-0.31014323234558105,
0.191523939371109,
-0.051521141082048416,
-0.3533199429512024,
-0.37617170810699463,
-0.23015372455120087,
0.4519840478897095,
0.6961240172386169,
-0.19951657950878143,
0.13481250405311584,
-1.2162864208221436,
-0.04381518065929413,
0.2565002739429474,
0.22241666913032532,
0.3157082200050354,
-0.8048416972160339,
-0.20807278156280518,
0.0914614349603653,
-0.17596964538097382,
-0.639861524105072,
0.4013722240924835,
0.3352653384208679,
0.7278584837913513,
0.26664990186691284,
0.3062579035758972,
0.4882897138595581,
-0.45894256234169006,
0.6429541707038879,
-0.033973608165979385,
-0.5736400485038757,
0.466999351978302,
-0.36421945691108704,
0.09454716742038727,
0.6364836096763611,
0.12379252165555954,
-0.30995965003967285,
-0.36549779772758484,
-0.5741127729415894,
-0.8705775737762451,
0.6597264409065247,
-0.12862125039100647,
0.11164449155330658,
-0.37974363565444946,
0.35809481143951416,
0.2952425181865692,
0.13956685364246368,
-0.41518598794937134,
-0.12010332196950912,
-0.10477951914072037,
-0.14052529633045197,
-0.06734302639961243,
-0.5383563041687012,
-0.1262339949607849,
0.06305056810379028,
0.7862605452537537,
0.00954005029052496,
0.24077945947647095,
0.47379517555236816,
-0.492840439081192,
-0.36729001998901367,
0.5499145984649658,
0.6041498780250549,
0.9324027299880981,
-0.3002246618270874,
0.265857458114624,
-0.07141228020191193,
-0.372502863407135,
0.24650220572948456,
0.17745187878608704,
-0.10492154955863953,
-0.13595201075077057,
0.3858656883239746,
0.713310182094574,
0.18192000687122345,
-0.8315633535385132,
0.23768185079097748,
0.06656517088413239,
0.06160815432667732,
-0.1270584911108017,
0.1464487910270691,
-0.0014590959763154387,
0.2558612525463104,
0.7922236323356628,
0.47441038489341736,
-0.04894102364778519,
-0.34805601835250854,
0.05054209381341934,
0.4608058035373688,
-0.24116110801696777,
-0.37182876467704773,
0.7262574434280396,
0.18351322412490845,
-0.29563605785369873,
0.715170681476593,
-0.19522275030612946,
-0.3227706253528595,
0.5366372466087341,
0.5269061923027039,
0.749255359172821,
-0.5073767900466919,
0.1144695058465004,
0.3449728488922119,
0.44734278321266174,
-0.4041938781738281,
0.12615667283535004,
0.14095336198806763,
-1.0330240726470947,
-0.5471115708351135,
-0.5926393866539001,
-0.3025687336921692,
0.05255184695124626,
-0.9973876476287842,
-0.3230469226837158,
-0.13588804006576538,
0.3148818910121918,
-0.22774194180965424,
-0.14417755603790283,
-0.6912323832511902,
0.03934958204627037,
-0.34310615062713623,
0.9757395386695862,
-0.48810166120529175,
0.6553061604499817,
0.7418727278709412,
-0.6714964509010315,
-0.7568440437316895,
-0.04270738363265991,
-0.22875285148620605,
-0.7543914914131165,
0.8913863301277161,
-0.1872129589319229,
-0.16273191571235657,
0.19902007281780243,
-0.5453639030456543,
-0.7681332230567932,
0.9740877747535706,
0.2709476351737976,
-0.6451754570007324,
0.03699697181582451,
-0.10631793737411499,
0.6421619057655334,
0.0351446159183979,
0.3508467376232147,
0.42450013756752014,
0.28770482540130615,
0.27025124430656433,
-0.9257050156593323,
-0.16043120622634888,
-0.09921226650476456,
0.006701361387968063,
0.39987727999687195,
-0.630163311958313,
0.8091182112693787,
-0.4121217429637909,
-0.2561827003955841,
0.2856515049934387,
0.4077657461166382,
0.34730711579322815,
0.35288211703300476,
0.16562601923942566,
0.7129750847816467,
1.0665537118911743,
-0.025977425277233124,
1.2320410013198853,
-0.04892083257436752,
0.4282618463039398,
1.092105507850647,
-0.5015994906425476,
1.1031951904296875,
0.4817359447479248,
-0.250990629196167,
0.4495523273944855,
0.25954878330230713,
0.32571741938591003,
0.5633746981620789,
-0.0022237219382077456,
-0.5204076170921326,
-0.36070340871810913,
0.20569683611392975,
-0.4819067120552063,
0.48133525252342224,
0.3370494246482849,
-0.33726075291633606,
-0.41257399320602417,
0.16353502869606018,
-0.2169511616230011,
0.19337198138237,
-0.4427875578403473,
0.756568968296051,
-0.1909186989068985,
-0.7077784538269043,
0.7810941934585571,
-0.2164970338344574,
0.5661763548851013,
-0.41265788674354553,
-0.0038896279875189066,
-0.3640206456184387,
0.6088313460350037,
-0.19909028708934784,
-0.5227554440498352,
0.3798806667327881,
-0.13958705961704254,
-0.5249034762382507,
0.0049159713089466095,
1.0546883344650269,
-0.4515970051288605,
-0.3911556005477905,
0.2179197520017624,
0.9811550378799438,
0.06860702484846115,
-0.049182504415512085,
-0.43756774067878723,
0.15720780193805695,
-0.09566643089056015,
-0.37657400965690613,
0.5194259881973267,
0.6400609016418457,
0.14643603563308716,
0.804490327835083,
0.4516485333442688,
-0.1642330139875412,
0.20785515010356903,
-0.16503147780895233,
0.7278136014938354,
-0.5062103867530823,
-0.0663682222366333,
-0.6940693259239197,
0.5199748873710632,
0.138579323887825,
-0.08159562945365906,
0.7755323052406311,
0.45852866768836975,
0.7631312012672424,
-0.16486673057079315,
0.7607203125953674,
-0.08582688868045807,
1.156261682510376,
-0.4411720633506775,
0.8771041631698608,
-0.5985833406448364,
0.5655025243759155,
-0.07347811013460159,
-0.8558350801467896,
-0.25933191180229187,
0.5784428715705872,
-0.2881004214286804,
0.09011335670948029,
0.5386571884155273,
0.8068426847457886,
0.0032461481168866158,
0.11459449678659439,
0.3008570969104767,
0.4311237335205078,
0.33564043045043945,
0.39295879006385803,
1.1151320934295654,
-0.4781448245048523,
0.6916365027427673,
0.0346807986497879,
-0.05004234239459038,
-0.33512455224990845,
-0.7995055317878723,
-0.6439038515090942,
-0.3980656564235687,
-0.38199883699417114,
-0.42228245735168457,
0.3135179579257965,
0.7588757872581482,
0.1914592683315277,
-0.8410108685493469,
0.1258484125137329,
-0.18967708945274353,
0.2724824845790863,
-0.23388446867465973,
-0.291334331035614,
0.3147446811199188,
-0.5141478776931763,
-0.4989933669567108,
0.41478636860847473,
0.0519641675055027,
-0.06540648639202118,
-0.053552523255348206,
-0.01876096799969673,
-0.2817731201648712,
0.07791268080472946,
0.5320792198181152,
0.7588375210762024,
-0.6891834139823914,
-0.5054497122764587,
0.24349509179592133,
-0.07002781331539154,
0.21277420222759247,
0.5045921802520752,
-1.0144256353378296,
0.6594916582107544,
0.5585607290267944,
0.8535749316215515,
0.22604155540466309,
0.09358137845993042,
0.20409159362316132,
-0.6537919640541077,
-0.13577228784561157,
0.3299505412578583,
0.23765118420124054,
0.4341697096824646,
-0.2068128138780594,
0.4883502721786499,
0.05102377384901047,
-0.8461863398551941,
-1.0401740074157715,
0.16539020836353302,
-0.7194417119026184,
-0.4261564016342163,
1.0164891481399536,
-0.0508766770362854,
-0.1368478238582611,
-0.23435114324092865,
-0.02380361035466194,
0.021752651780843735,
-0.180289164185524,
0.7873256802558899,
0.8297318816184998,
-0.2685655653476715,
-0.2619403600692749,
-0.5130136609077454,
0.33196496963500977,
0.36250603199005127,
-0.6503879427909851,
0.16866597533226013,
0.6813376545906067,
0.5328211188316345,
0.38415879011154175,
0.47069013118743896,
-0.16162705421447754,
0.1477174609899521,
-0.09404579550027847,
0.03707198053598404,
-0.03461422398686409,
-0.07443197071552277,
-0.4817282259464264,
0.19559460878372192,
0.344455361366272,
-0.11696524173021317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20671v1
|
Position Coupling: Leveraging Task Structure for Improved Length Generalization of Transformers
| 2024-05-31T08:13:35
| 2024-05-31T08:13:35
|
Hanseul Cho, Jaeyoung Cha, Pranjal Awasthi, Srinadh Bhojanapalli, Anupam Gupta, Chulhee Yun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Even for simple arithmetic tasks like integer addition, it is challenging for
Transformers to generalize to longer sequences than those encountered during
training. To tackle this problem, we propose position coupling, a simple yet
effective method that directly embeds the structure of the tasks into the
positional encoding of a (decoder-only) Transformer. Taking a departure from
the vanilla absolute position mechanism assigning unique position IDs to each
of the tokens, we assign the same position IDs to two or more "relevant"
tokens; for integer addition tasks, we regard digits of the same significance
as in the same position. On the empirical side, we show that with the proposed
position coupling, a small (1-layer) Transformer trained on 1 to 30-digit
additions can generalize up to 200-digit additions (6.67x of the trained
length). On the theoretical side, we prove that a 1-layer Transformer with
coupled positions can solve the addition task involving exponentially many
digits, whereas any 1-layer Transformer without positional information cannot
entirely solve it. We also demonstrate that position coupling can be applied to
other algorithmic tasks such as addition with multiple summands, Nx2
multiplication, copy/reverse, and a two-dimensional task.
|
[
-0.5281820297241211,
-0.24735382199287415,
0.5341042876243591,
0.5068666338920593,
-0.2635498344898224,
-0.020421622321009636,
-0.0736083909869194,
-0.49823197722435,
0.3538113832473755,
0.22047019004821777,
-0.3687458038330078,
-0.10184472054243088,
-0.6960946917533875,
-0.20176635682582855,
-0.3851475119590759,
0.7745683193206787,
0.17403577268123627,
-0.37601515650749207,
-0.3676837384700775,
-0.10676076263189316,
-0.48100313544273376,
-0.7255248427391052,
-0.46978580951690674,
-0.3775816261768341,
0.6395907998085022,
0.5836340188980103,
0.9227617979049683,
0.8610293865203857,
0.8942369222640991,
0.3703897297382355,
0.060215551406145096,
0.0849590077996254,
-0.0856299176812172,
0.09119746834039688,
-0.34890007972717285,
-0.7471340298652649,
-0.6933809518814087,
-0.3226125240325928,
0.7223976850509644,
1.061628818511963,
0.19210036098957062,
0.35902610421180725,
-0.12290655076503754,
0.8277595639228821,
-0.6116393804550171,
-0.008384902030229568,
-0.15423151850700378,
0.18502527475357056,
-0.22213192284107208,
-0.36024051904678345,
-0.40523937344551086,
-0.054992079734802246,
-0.06282410770654678,
-0.4287155270576477,
0.566893994808197,
-0.281453937292099,
0.39195698499679565,
0.6433210372924805,
-0.691426157951355,
-0.04165168106555939,
-1.1460086107254028,
0.5953150391578674,
-0.3318518400192261,
0.6888521909713745,
0.18856291472911835,
0.07305917888879776,
0.19336719810962677,
-0.44996073842048645,
-0.4603932201862335,
0.02727607823908329,
-0.42639315128326416,
0.24158427119255066,
0.17539650201797485,
-0.0058075012639164925,
0.6199638247489929,
0.150560200214386,
-0.21559251844882965,
-0.05641194432973862,
-0.4876721203327179,
0.12036879360675812,
0.6982366442680359,
0.0700552687048912,
0.31811845302581787,
-0.07632062584161758,
-0.352296382188797,
-0.6260786652565002,
-0.6566922664642334,
0.35002169013023376,
0.5369303226470947,
0.09104055911302567,
-0.27354031801223755,
0.7366898655891418,
0.1528637409210205,
0.61204993724823,
0.6401973962783813,
0.21018560230731964,
0.09631665796041489,
-0.42855632305145264,
0.04407631605863571,
0.2644003629684448,
0.595491886138916,
0.21465663611888885,
-0.22061489522457123,
-0.3159957826137543,
-0.13361817598342896,
0.17979034781455994,
0.7370463609695435,
-0.6939882040023804,
-0.22382576763629913,
0.027272123843431473,
-0.21353822946548462,
-0.21083509922027588,
0.45598384737968445,
-0.32701411843299866,
-0.051467541605234146,
-0.4476664364337921,
0.34985974431037903,
-0.28887221217155457,
0.020600514486432076,
-0.09048228710889816,
-0.47846946120262146,
0.5956916213035583,
-0.03235611319541931,
-1.4390294551849365,
0.5078185200691223,
1.0897899866104126,
0.7137433886528015,
-0.22712086141109467,
-0.4091542363166809,
-0.5117949843406677,
0.48889225721359253,
-0.40009838342666626,
0.725923478603363,
-0.5200490951538086,
-0.5365952849388123,
-0.29310673475265503,
0.09395192563533783,
0.01104014553129673,
-0.43575748801231384,
0.4734446108341217,
-0.6383293867111206,
0.08237075805664062,
-0.14221754670143127,
-0.2757674753665924,
0.23887939751148224,
-0.12058184295892715,
-0.8652051687240601,
1.1375888586044312,
0.306861013174057,
-0.4863874316215515,
0.04240059480071068,
-0.8858823180198669,
-0.8781601190567017,
-0.2873055338859558,
0.026344697922468185,
-0.502841055393219,
0.513266384601593,
0.34811854362487793,
0.20801976323127747,
-0.017383133992552757,
0.020832324400544167,
-0.11716444790363312,
-0.7804881930351257,
0.20368894934654236,
-0.2985980212688446,
0.6084074974060059,
-0.22092778980731964,
-0.29041048884391785,
0.13386119902133942,
-0.33597472310066223,
-0.3967309594154358,
-0.03261910751461983,
-0.24231809377670288,
-0.32313433289527893,
-0.2298474758863449,
-0.3742213249206543,
0.17228826880455017,
0.39777156710624695,
-0.3774098753929138,
0.6103505492210388,
-0.5748543739318848,
0.19761814177036285,
0.39829060435295105,
-0.13211214542388916,
1.2591161727905273,
-0.2516350746154785,
0.44537925720214844,
0.08043007552623749,
0.08574871718883514,
-0.15508559346199036,
-0.26667624711990356,
-0.873167097568512,
0.19172252714633942,
0.5173665285110474,
0.7167760729789734,
-0.8958039879798889,
0.7740082144737244,
-0.8109252452850342,
-0.46474865078926086,
-0.250888466835022,
-0.08983296900987625,
0.16587601602077484,
0.3660756051540375,
0.4778720438480377,
-0.3879050016403198,
-0.3785576820373535,
-0.8130756616592407,
-0.03569171205163002,
-0.05695837363600731,
-0.6767881512641907,
-0.22123129665851593,
0.30612099170684814,
0.19268859922885895,
0.6914258599281311,
-0.6374750733375549,
-0.23622730374336243,
0.20873241126537323,
0.04805121198296547,
0.7011799216270447,
0.8949734568595886,
0.4427628815174103,
-0.7850041389465332,
-0.4634205102920532,
-0.12208124250173569,
-0.8145167231559753,
0.3542502820491791,
-0.23949606716632843,
-0.13863712549209595,
-0.32061564922332764,
0.3893108367919922,
-0.8428432941436768,
0.27964073419570923,
0.4638441801071167,
-0.2513817548751831,
0.18019959330558777,
-0.38475966453552246,
0.07762669026851654,
-1.1601111888885498,
-0.15992942452430725,
0.10928672552108765,
-0.2187780886888504,
-0.9129995107650757,
0.17471832036972046,
0.37253695726394653,
-0.3483133018016815,
-0.3948342800140381,
0.025195864960551262,
-0.5511983036994934,
-0.21763144433498383,
-0.36570486426353455,
-0.21571668982505798,
-0.15518179535865784,
0.8073757886886597,
0.005305827595293522,
0.8349324464797974,
0.4802396595478058,
-0.5461597442626953,
0.4645337760448456,
0.44066759943962097,
0.09678161144256592,
0.5839400887489319,
-0.7757512331008911,
0.39887332916259766,
-0.1523187905550003,
0.3399216830730438,
-0.9215545058250427,
-0.11745662242174149,
0.1385999172925949,
-0.6153656840324402,
0.33231911063194275,
-0.48166143894195557,
-0.27467939257621765,
-0.38310912251472473,
-0.44881585240364075,
1.0286601781845093,
0.6689268946647644,
-0.5965012311935425,
0.6455628871917725,
0.18711496889591217,
-0.14197523891925812,
-0.7419807314872742,
-0.7628397941589355,
-0.07469523698091507,
-0.27260634303092957,
-0.9408509135246277,
1.1025333404541016,
0.23516598343849182,
0.16307199001312256,
0.05790064111351967,
-0.5159233212471008,
-0.004382360726594925,
-0.05624751001596451,
0.24665610492229462,
0.44564181566238403,
-0.1535465121269226,
-0.07457591593265533,
0.4241415560245514,
-0.5859744548797607,
0.18452754616737366,
-0.39974433183670044,
0.40926796197891235,
0.07755447924137115,
-0.6473619937896729,
-0.26265984773635864,
0.4889991283416748,
0.7363301515579224,
-0.10140674561262131,
0.6126253604888916,
0.802768349647522,
-0.449828565120697,
0.007085100281983614,
-0.2713419198989868,
-0.359225332736969,
-0.5998114347457886,
0.2019428014755249,
-0.4959028661251068,
-0.734846830368042,
0.29525572061538696,
-0.07555042952299118,
-0.008379600010812283,
0.3048843443393707,
0.2082700878381729,
-0.17950835824012756,
1.1710710525512695,
0.7336852550506592,
-0.11079353839159012,
0.6255625486373901,
-0.4694352447986603,
0.5776191353797913,
-0.9002496600151062,
-0.15300874412059784,
-0.33520519733428955,
-0.8386783599853516,
-0.4988182485103607,
-0.758414089679718,
0.46344536542892456,
0.2545630931854248,
-0.09194543212652206,
0.8269050717353821,
-0.8973797559738159,
0.577773928642273,
0.8292280435562134,
0.2159334421157837,
-0.07733506709337234,
-0.036602847278118134,
0.03182798996567726,
-0.0025766664184629917,
-0.6008437275886536,
0.10913398116827011,
0.7261289358139038,
0.2337941974401474,
0.6274932026863098,
0.3481551706790924,
0.7745169997215271,
0.2192816436290741,
-0.13860438764095306,
-1.040767788887024,
0.40531250834465027,
-0.43056720495224,
-0.10323288291692734,
-0.38943055272102356,
-0.11532272398471832,
-0.7222151756286621,
0.06571459770202637,
-0.04973745718598366,
-0.4391976296901703,
0.5047498345375061,
0.3207702338695526,
-0.36678656935691833,
0.16830134391784668,
-0.7594598531723022,
0.4332580268383026,
-0.26820942759513855,
-0.42857125401496887,
-0.254465252161026,
-0.8119877576828003,
0.0889827162027359,
0.3002069592475891,
-0.07077135890722275,
0.2223055213689804,
-0.19546574354171753,
0.7961472272872925,
-0.6474198698997498,
0.6923792362213135,
-0.20444945991039276,
-0.30191347002983093,
0.0031068134121596813,
0.021680109202861786,
0.7689908146858215,
0.08524584770202637,
0.08890196681022644,
0.0619640126824379,
-0.252098947763443,
-0.601243793964386,
-1.0830259323120117,
0.8767111301422119,
-0.7947075963020325,
-0.7377294898033142,
-0.11012166738510132,
-0.8705391883850098,
-0.39748382568359375,
0.02213381417095661,
0.2577027976512909,
0.6885043978691101,
0.48518943786621094,
0.28422811627388,
0.5098866820335388,
0.45421338081359863,
0.630093514919281,
-0.035071589052677155,
0.429970383644104,
-0.4835767149925232,
0.9976831078529358,
-0.04155784845352173,
0.03706011548638344,
1.029873013496399,
0.0635826364159584,
-0.5037267208099365,
-0.26664748787879944,
-0.2939448058605194,
0.24208107590675354,
-0.5183490514755249,
-0.08668786287307739,
-0.26873621344566345,
-0.1871461272239685,
-0.43925976753234863,
-0.6031572222709656,
-0.39575743675231934,
-0.9367868900299072,
0.12189199030399323,
-0.07318791002035141,
0.15840837359428406,
0.4253893792629242,
-0.1530335545539856,
0.5434675812721252,
-1.1540415287017822,
0.7084681987762451,
0.727423906326294,
0.515045702457428,
0.17273609340190887,
-0.29647862911224365,
-0.35996100306510925,
0.024436553940176964,
-0.36256319284439087,
-0.6374832987785339,
0.02823437750339508,
-0.1306314766407013,
0.3532376289367676,
0.2898886501789093,
-0.03473259508609772,
0.979334831237793,
-0.6973844766616821,
0.7606642246246338,
0.3948443531990051,
-1.0545204877853394,
0.26989397406578064,
-0.2343127727508545,
0.42993399500846863,
0.3346722722053528,
0.4686305820941925,
-0.45705634355545044,
0.05222950875759125,
-0.4964175820350647,
-0.8968484401702881,
0.9993463754653931,
0.4222486913204193,
0.1699954867362976,
0.0604780912399292,
0.2115817666053772,
-0.3193204700946808,
-0.1438300609588623,
-0.1978716105222702,
-0.5670567750930786,
-0.2934074401855469,
-0.4061133861541748,
0.1268886923789978,
-0.18946059048175812,
-0.2284516841173172,
-0.5082889199256897,
0.3704324960708618,
-0.11775074154138565,
0.9638081789016724,
0.2566392123699188,
-0.3640446066856384,
-0.09730615466833115,
0.20886747539043427,
0.615257740020752,
0.6812827587127686,
0.10587328672409058,
0.4505841135978699,
0.46761807799339294,
-0.3849313259124756,
0.5619181394577026,
0.12060442566871643,
0.09280569851398468,
0.02140587382018566,
0.39857783913612366,
0.737962007522583,
0.4953729212284088,
0.135131374001503,
0.487455278635025,
0.21211092174053192,
-0.20100700855255127,
-0.36151769757270813,
0.08017377555370331,
0.44830945134162903,
0.2935166656970978,
0.5635672807693481,
0.3954916298389435,
0.04291735962033272,
-0.20929743349552155,
0.4148963987827301,
0.2481924444437027,
-0.7396115660667419,
-0.7834727168083191,
0.7306687831878662,
0.37966403365135193,
-0.8556303381919861,
0.596627950668335,
0.02972368337213993,
-0.42041659355163574,
0.7276269793510437,
0.7784013748168945,
0.681263267993927,
-0.4155997633934021,
0.045448437333106995,
0.44875863194465637,
0.13300293684005737,
-0.2098713219165802,
-0.051416121423244476,
-0.5774573087692261,
-0.6073769927024841,
-0.8209624290466309,
-0.2407228797674179,
-0.45085155963897705,
-0.47254422307014465,
-0.798447847366333,
0.3229331076145172,
-0.2175625115633011,
-0.12256161868572235,
0.0027903227601200342,
-0.4087850749492645,
-0.7586437463760376,
-0.22071366012096405,
0.28087568283081055,
0.6645636558532715,
-0.5968358516693115,
0.7887300848960876,
0.9856163263320923,
-0.006300726439803839,
-0.6513075828552246,
-0.17327561974525452,
-0.3552652895450592,
-0.6199265718460083,
0.45097339153289795,
0.2166375368833542,
-0.18487772345542908,
0.022598199546337128,
-0.14705190062522888,
-0.9189576506614685,
1.2799444198608398,
0.2889581322669983,
-0.5224527716636658,
-0.6388501524925232,
0.6117910742759705,
0.394594669342041,
0.004147711675614119,
0.2559538185596466,
0.4088326096534729,
0.2721758782863617,
0.19539737701416016,
-0.76711106300354,
0.25059038400650024,
-0.42864492535591125,
0.2029982954263687,
0.774376392364502,
-0.5855266451835632,
0.5850786566734314,
-0.10649337619543076,
-0.1911264955997467,
-0.032063256949186325,
0.6288346648216248,
-0.03873391076922417,
-0.11272013932466507,
0.7041118741035461,
0.6065252423286438,
0.3106888234615326,
-0.1202293112874031,
0.9581753611564636,
-0.529746949672699,
0.49689003825187683,
0.9781262278556824,
0.11780314892530441,
0.5129196643829346,
0.5502952933311462,
-0.4647160470485687,
0.474688321352005,
-0.01909863017499447,
-0.023743104189634323,
0.5167161822319031,
-0.3130227029323578,
-0.32169345021247864,
-0.3025082051753998,
0.023825403302907944,
-0.29891347885131836,
0.16192997992038727,
0.449926495552063,
-0.3106825649738312,
-0.10572859644889832,
0.028374526649713516,
-0.3501946032047272,
-0.11685528606176376,
-0.16266323626041412,
0.7818225622177124,
0.14445194602012634,
-0.8911730051040649,
0.5217462182044983,
-0.060510531067848206,
0.8386328220367432,
-0.6176905632019043,
-0.263552725315094,
0.02734377421438694,
0.09217973053455353,
-0.4061124622821808,
-0.9919314980506897,
0.6848979592323303,
-0.42967480421066284,
-0.4194895029067993,
-0.44565197825431824,
0.7564196586608887,
-0.4391810894012451,
-0.6114587187767029,
0.06700099259614944,
0.16178929805755615,
-0.3420921564102173,
-0.08163083344697952,
-0.17436543107032776,
-0.29039761424064636,
-0.21444571018218994,
0.16322362422943115,
0.3372077941894531,
0.18433494865894318,
-0.17294703423976898,
0.2617127299308777,
0.8593400716781616,
-0.29486748576164246,
0.08383509516716003,
0.03553251922130585,
0.7840521931648254,
-1.041636347770691,
-0.6122979521751404,
-0.7970175743103027,
0.6321088075637817,
-0.011059312149882317,
0.04905426874756813,
0.5071598887443542,
0.30457189679145813,
0.9293238520622253,
-0.38050615787506104,
0.5576556921005249,
-0.16895714402198792,
-0.10911839455366135,
-0.21196991205215454,
0.1839175671339035,
-0.2233341634273529,
0.2127239853143692,
0.016891831532120705,
-1.4335078001022339,
-0.3703920543193817,
0.4905356168746948,
-0.2708468437194824,
-0.3879137933254242,
0.8470888137817383,
0.5299602746963501,
-0.4425579607486725,
-0.24344779551029205,
0.2332020401954651,
-0.40184536576271057,
0.38286399841308594,
0.7704969644546509,
0.7935141324996948,
-0.703862726688385,
0.6990683674812317,
-0.9007564187049866,
0.03692784905433655,
-0.06159953773021698,
-0.6436991691589355,
-0.664140522480011,
-0.5026553273200989,
-0.12658807635307312,
0.15893469750881195,
-0.2988777160644531,
0.77341628074646,
0.802598237991333,
-0.6823909282684326,
-0.2747049033641815,
-0.1684192717075348,
0.163650244474411,
-0.6929059624671936,
-0.2601279318332672,
0.40156441926956177,
-0.12427014112472534,
-1.0353739261627197,
0.6102686524391174,
0.2848028242588043,
0.04320059344172478,
0.03559586778283119,
0.11931128799915314,
0.0660252496600151,
-0.15210004150867462,
0.8137866854667664,
0.22728876769542694,
-0.41574162244796753,
-0.6231978535652161,
0.3779256343841553,
0.17108972370624542,
0.23167940974235535,
1.1946296691894531,
-0.7332226634025574,
0.0684860423207283,
0.8395164608955383,
0.6165413856506348,
0.7318745851516724,
0.5729535818099976,
0.7372942566871643,
-1.1660826206207275,
0.3447805941104889,
0.11481290310621262,
0.38839179277420044,
0.2492537945508957,
-0.45027732849121094,
0.4649389684200287,
-0.09541591256856918,
-0.29449397325515747,
-0.39109840989112854,
0.3665647804737091,
-1.2403162717819214,
0.12585967779159546,
0.7250514030456543,
0.13739566504955292,
-0.2241860032081604,
0.12392779439687729,
-0.025946155190467834,
0.40823879837989807,
-0.19007204473018646,
0.7199096083641052,
0.27684563398361206,
-0.33492591977119446,
0.05326387658715248,
0.19379664957523346,
0.2666511535644531,
0.5140677690505981,
-0.5395190715789795,
-0.33087825775146484,
-0.05397125333547592,
0.12969283759593964,
0.7796699404716492,
0.1399930715560913,
-0.08601512759923935,
0.5085597634315491,
0.13487771153450012,
-0.21477407217025757,
-0.45959851145744324,
-0.49570390582084656,
-0.35898706316947937,
0.37858152389526367,
-0.04280082881450653,
-0.48401445150375366
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20657v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20657v2
|
DORY: Deliberative Prompt Recovery for LLM
| 2024-05-31T07:51:16
| 2024-06-07T17:00:00
|
Lirong Gao, Ru Peng, Yiming Zhang, Junbo Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Prompt recovery in large language models (LLMs) is crucial for understanding
how LLMs work and addressing concerns regarding privacy, copyright, etc. The
trend towards inference-only APIs complicates this task by restricting access
to essential outputs for recovery. To tackle this challenge, we extract
prompt-related information from limited outputs and identify a strong(negative)
correlation between output probability-based uncertainty and the success of
prompt recovery. This finding led to the development of Deliberative PrOmpt
RecoverY (DORY), our novel approach that leverages uncertainty to recover
prompts accurately. DORY involves reconstructing drafts from outputs, refining
these with hints, and filtering out noise based on uncertainty. Our evaluation
across diverse LLMs and prompt benchmarks shows that DORY outperforms existing
baselines, improving performance by approximately 10.82% and establishing a new
state-of-the-art record in prompt recovery tasks. Significantly, DORY operates
using a single LLM without any external resources or model, offering a
cost-effective, user-friendly prompt recovery solution.
|
[
0.031826168298721313,
-0.7056108713150024,
0.9199506640434265,
0.057768937200307846,
-0.18448583781719208,
0.2803163230419159,
-0.31031540036201477,
-0.29910770058631897,
0.24033020436763763,
0.6037132143974304,
-1.0085080862045288,
-0.41607391834259033,
-0.8794413805007935,
0.2739005982875824,
-0.10327951610088348,
0.9919248223304749,
0.2294185757637024,
0.03276483714580536,
0.18521691858768463,
0.3243521451950073,
-0.5096849799156189,
-0.17899702489376068,
-0.8996939063072205,
0.0550481341779232,
0.6492591500282288,
0.4644474685192108,
0.2869141101837158,
0.42867621779441833,
0.46482306718826294,
0.24753202497959137,
0.04165548458695412,
0.2809368073940277,
-0.6133227348327637,
0.545386016368866,
0.051690906286239624,
-0.53935307264328,
-0.42501065135002136,
0.11324366182088852,
0.5026076436042786,
0.5196441411972046,
-0.3102756440639496,
-0.24504370987415314,
0.093584343791008,
0.5474424362182617,
-0.8461092114448547,
0.3011225759983063,
-0.812174916267395,
0.08389929682016373,
0.027238022536039352,
-0.49829524755477905,
-0.534937858581543,
-0.6652396321296692,
0.008227848447859287,
-0.730830192565918,
0.10327126830816269,
0.13350990414619446,
0.19235540926456451,
0.6365382671356201,
-0.30215656757354736,
-0.5274871587753296,
-0.8732757568359375,
0.8702653050422668,
-0.9089269638061523,
0.05639324337244034,
0.38918235898017883,
0.30904603004455566,
-0.5685680508613586,
-0.9526165127754211,
-0.47140711545944214,
-0.2764025628566742,
0.2396000325679779,
0.44986575841903687,
-0.3032560646533966,
0.05574409291148186,
0.3684525787830353,
0.5386454463005066,
-0.212283194065094,
0.26285025477409363,
-0.08686044812202454,
-0.4135034680366516,
0.5454863905906677,
0.3231935501098633,
0.19585785269737244,
-0.08018872141838074,
-0.4355085492134094,
0.012364395894110203,
-0.7752830386161804,
-0.02369755320250988,
0.33205124735832214,
0.5872346758842468,
0.002138145500794053,
0.26041221618652344,
-0.262909471988678,
0.48422062397003174,
0.14114779233932495,
-0.26624301075935364,
0.2865470051765442,
-0.20104116201400757,
-0.10057680308818817,
0.2634388506412506,
0.8310971856117249,
0.2542606294155121,
-0.15602466464042664,
-0.10974843055009842,
-0.37718984484672546,
-0.24195808172225952,
0.10535586625337601,
-0.5736430287361145,
-0.32422348856925964,
0.28385937213897705,
-0.4794476330280304,
-0.19208097457885742,
-0.09637095779180527,
-0.6835042834281921,
-0.9253008365631104,
-0.36301475763320923,
0.19975645840168,
-0.36435407400131226,
-0.5867478847503662,
0.0874992087483406,
0.00002358704114158172,
0.2610837519168854,
0.9328956007957458,
-0.6245944499969482,
0.10561428964138031,
0.8107806444168091,
0.6735875010490417,
-0.2903982996940613,
0.03979877009987831,
-0.9378635883331299,
-0.06518162041902542,
-0.3085698187351227,
0.6369121670722961,
-0.298848956823349,
-0.577631950378418,
0.0104351956397295,
0.18799474835395813,
0.06629744172096252,
-0.529818594455719,
0.8276073932647705,
-0.5094002485275269,
0.04933258146047592,
-0.7078463435173035,
-0.49775466322898865,
0.06395680457353592,
0.40514272451400757,
-0.9507337808609009,
0.562437117099762,
-0.25783562660217285,
-0.8919925689697266,
0.3956446349620819,
-0.22198839485645294,
-0.06363394856452942,
0.1651564985513687,
-0.25157591700553894,
0.1514076292514801,
0.3209325671195984,
0.15682955086231232,
0.17442689836025238,
-0.4578453004360199,
0.08275997638702393,
-0.7130876183509827,
-0.22552941739559174,
0.3686820864677429,
-0.9787341952323914,
0.8478127121925354,
0.22633251547813416,
-0.09356849640607834,
0.07818419486284256,
-0.9728812575340271,
-0.1734422892332077,
-0.1915683001279831,
-0.4472331404685974,
-0.31565213203430176,
-0.10404451191425323,
-0.561040997505188,
0.15933015942573547,
0.5251652002334595,
-1.0782297849655151,
0.08691941201686859,
-0.5006980895996094,
0.5184968113899231,
0.7464652061462402,
0.26637768745422363,
0.41022998094558716,
-0.4157572388648987,
0.6971067190170288,
0.08233277499675751,
-0.2870786488056183,
-0.269572377204895,
-0.17198222875595093,
-0.45773282647132874,
-0.9053443074226379,
0.1502266526222229,
0.8335601687431335,
-0.7465519309043884,
0.18366789817810059,
-0.05795951932668686,
-0.33787938952445984,
-0.7696636915206909,
-0.10182321816682816,
0.36812567710876465,
0.806286633014679,
-0.008096183650195599,
0.09981869906187057,
-0.6787846088409424,
-0.7259700894355774,
-0.10805157572031021,
-0.4525979161262512,
-0.25723567605018616,
0.30451714992523193,
-0.015520443208515644,
0.21256911754608154,
0.8650715947151184,
-0.5820627212524414,
-0.025156516581773758,
-0.15143142640590668,
-0.030555564910173416,
0.6550585627555847,
0.3113890290260315,
0.10932192206382751,
-0.5110110640525818,
-0.16762925684452057,
-0.3314264416694641,
-0.8050420880317688,
-0.17181408405303955,
-0.22984056174755096,
-0.3138253390789032,
0.289972186088562,
0.43480461835861206,
-1.108633279800415,
0.5500581860542297,
0.07302410900592804,
-0.2401067614555359,
0.6910268664360046,
-0.2697610557079315,
0.20519909262657166,
-1.0594120025634766,
-0.03286617994308472,
-0.46598708629608154,
-0.36818748712539673,
-0.28715404868125916,
-0.29319220781326294,
0.015078617259860039,
0.16703028976917267,
-0.15741240978240967,
0.5316179990768433,
-0.3984883725643158,
0.11650396883487701,
-0.3290891945362091,
0.3196592926979065,
-0.07811516523361206,
0.09391845762729645,
0.23341692984104156,
0.7012261748313904,
0.5681924223899841,
-0.4522298276424408,
0.23373796045780182,
0.20937912166118622,
-0.05878273397684097,
0.5762543678283691,
-0.5772315859794617,
0.27031809091567993,
-0.30060821771621704,
0.12663596868515015,
-1.5112206935882568,
-0.4498102068901062,
0.695111870765686,
-0.2833563983440399,
0.40115562081336975,
-0.05067900940775871,
-0.20298722386360168,
-0.29924193024635315,
-0.5729832053184509,
-0.2304813414812088,
0.532737672328949,
-0.6639536023139954,
0.7224829196929932,
0.29661238193511963,
-0.5602937340736389,
-1.0442862510681152,
-0.5685298442840576,
-0.07024844735860825,
-0.1072479635477066,
-0.14705321192741394,
0.05389242619276047,
-0.28294068574905396,
-0.46117231249809265,
-0.1549696922302246,
-0.4547313451766968,
-0.08325701206922531,
0.3391566574573517,
0.5146316289901733,
0.4187105596065521,
0.05132967233657837,
0.10278940945863724,
0.22593514621257782,
-0.07217828184366226,
0.25225830078125,
-0.363821417093277,
0.14947108924388885,
0.17311739921569824,
-0.3727113902568817,
-0.2104557752609253,
0.3475594222545624,
0.4237804114818573,
0.11699788272380829,
0.4000348746776581,
0.4119260311126709,
-0.3237863779067993,
-0.4560824930667877,
-0.5863059163093567,
-0.17582698166370392,
-0.46519288420677185,
0.19443458318710327,
-0.31038734316825867,
-0.8368139863014221,
0.5348809361457825,
-0.07714936882257462,
0.4745340347290039,
0.1409689486026764,
0.7281198501586914,
-0.1575358361005783,
0.4381565749645233,
0.39773422479629517,
0.09283501654863358,
0.31233635544776917,
0.15157708525657654,
0.2626812756061554,
-0.5302051901817322,
-0.39285239577293396,
-0.4461717903614044,
-0.07832278311252594,
-0.22243092954158783,
-0.2125074416399002,
-0.02152678184211254,
0.239791139960289,
0.053063005208969116,
-0.02220340259373188,
-0.3818170726299286,
0.17388981580734253,
0.9889950156211853,
0.36773183941841125,
0.689365029335022,
0.018136929720640182,
0.264850378036499,
-0.1810736209154129,
-0.2999742925167084,
-0.7933645844459534,
0.9049633741378784,
0.05758783966302872,
1.0302035808563232,
0.26509547233581543,
1.1423860788345337,
0.31107550859451294,
0.21718309819698334,
-0.9957989454269409,
0.6069789528846741,
0.10507281124591827,
-0.5094451904296875,
-0.29888829588890076,
-0.6175097227096558,
-1.0374655723571777,
0.11496755480766296,
-0.05319857597351074,
-0.7913499474525452,
0.17457711696624756,
0.31545573472976685,
-0.6945014595985413,
0.3096040189266205,
-0.5313635468482971,
0.3916296362876892,
0.1378379911184311,
-0.2658025324344635,
0.0025841512251645327,
-0.7086004018783569,
0.345228374004364,
-0.33217698335647583,
0.09160146862268448,
-0.3311099708080292,
-0.3125443458557129,
0.5244545340538025,
-0.5129392743110657,
1.0620924234390259,
-0.3711664080619812,
-0.2750878930091858,
0.5949223041534424,
0.39621520042419434,
0.30389919877052307,
0.3819476366043091,
-0.2371913194656372,
-0.01299346424639225,
0.31550079584121704,
0.13635143637657166,
-0.6968486309051514,
0.9463884234428406,
-0.8115191459655762,
-0.811034619808197,
-0.229250967502594,
-0.9412965774536133,
-0.20163290202617645,
0.19437018036842346,
0.07414167374372482,
0.3901684284210205,
-0.2209862470626831,
-0.09302345663309097,
0.6818462610244751,
-0.21662044525146484,
1.1561059951782227,
0.9082543849945068,
-0.047433219850063324,
-0.5355563163757324,
0.7450390458106995,
0.057831622660160065,
-0.13341084122657776,
0.43747004866600037,
-0.01214180514216423,
-0.5134018063545227,
-0.7484285235404968,
-0.11629797518253326,
0.07167938351631165,
-0.7085145711898804,
-0.4582963287830353,
-0.7539874315261841,
-0.12322907894849777,
-0.3519347012042999,
0.30170947313308716,
-0.13188816606998444,
-0.9955122470855713,
-0.6864001154899597,
-0.20338279008865356,
0.36532753705978394,
0.8243231177330017,
-0.41740909218788147,
0.1807194948196411,
-1.0735197067260742,
0.03604834899306297,
0.1265246868133545,
0.1687082201242447,
0.08210347592830658,
-0.5669950246810913,
0.22459694743156433,
-0.13467876613140106,
-0.33927443623542786,
-0.8364139795303345,
0.477353036403656,
-0.10598438233137131,
0.6971023678779602,
0.1983046680688858,
0.6514332890510559,
0.2682463824748993,
-0.400587797164917,
0.8334354758262634,
0.27119600772857666,
-0.5721458196640015,
0.4932803213596344,
-0.25450724363327026,
0.3360656201839447,
0.627734363079071,
0.3976761996746063,
-0.0273630078881979,
-0.11649823188781738,
-0.3793851137161255,
-0.9238722920417786,
0.8118764162063599,
0.008425666950643063,
0.00886058621108532,
-0.4763234257698059,
0.43668627738952637,
0.5123761892318726,
0.568463921546936,
-0.39377561211586,
0.17379334568977356,
0.1937798708677292,
-0.6251809597015381,
0.1839919239282608,
-0.5830511450767517,
-0.4001412093639374,
0.3993481695652008,
0.4365263283252716,
0.09766574203968048,
0.16839362680912018,
0.41208672523498535,
-0.12044603377580643,
0.09837629646062851,
0.39244088530540466,
0.04953835904598236,
0.5296449065208435,
-0.24696461856365204,
0.13025891780853271,
-0.027357740327715874,
-0.7067753076553345,
0.14981402456760406,
0.29513970017433167,
-0.13646864891052246,
-0.0829920694231987,
0.6343523263931274,
0.6768333315849304,
0.016710257157683372,
-0.8180512189865112,
0.6113089323043823,
-0.3872278332710266,
-0.1542646288871765,
-0.6104209423065186,
0.06553347408771515,
-0.26258957386016846,
0.5995047688484192,
0.5126479268074036,
0.3021713197231293,
0.43460825085639954,
-0.16608615219593048,
0.16854684054851532,
0.2906893193721771,
-0.3453657329082489,
-0.44267478585243225,
0.6312830448150635,
0.2324659377336502,
-0.4588544964790344,
0.6497803926467896,
-0.17977653443813324,
0.22492340207099915,
0.45833340287208557,
0.6312404274940491,
1.087476372718811,
0.0057845222763717175,
0.11588514596223831,
0.368952214717865,
-0.023015934973955154,
-0.1672559678554535,
0.9757114052772522,
-0.08757899701595306,
-0.566909670829773,
-0.6542973518371582,
-0.44297313690185547,
-0.33382371068000793,
-0.27452975511550903,
-0.9064475893974304,
-0.06342140585184097,
-0.9217931032180786,
-0.3881268799304962,
-0.4652027189731598,
0.09501652419567108,
-0.44705578684806824,
-0.10039591044187546,
0.3784094452857971,
1.1336967945098877,
-0.4519425630569458,
0.5652599930763245,
0.44780969619750977,
-0.30330461263656616,
-0.9374001622200012,
0.019352354109287262,
0.34214743971824646,
-0.6986908316612244,
0.7074623703956604,
0.2423958033323288,
-0.36002835631370544,
0.06118554621934891,
-0.639261782169342,
-0.9754354953765869,
1.2387127876281738,
0.8116122484207153,
-1.1811603307724,
0.03516262769699097,
-0.5237435102462769,
0.22370624542236328,
-0.38419291377067566,
0.37996816635131836,
0.6222141981124878,
0.2199632227420807,
0.38441261649131775,
-0.7795494198799133,
0.38084614276885986,
0.14582261443138123,
-0.3018777370452881,
0.13457070291042328,
-0.3781956434249878,
0.6690791845321655,
-0.3521380126476288,
-0.2778969407081604,
0.45360490679740906,
0.5034230947494507,
0.6525998711585999,
0.3953854441642761,
0.47341710329055786,
0.43484923243522644,
1.5282012224197388,
-0.13029752671718597,
1.2255852222442627,
-0.35699111223220825,
0.011875398457050323,
1.6156244277954102,
-0.4460938572883606,
0.8374810814857483,
0.6410122513771057,
-0.028304245322942734,
0.38025522232055664,
0.6310875415802002,
0.5581923127174377,
0.8239016532897949,
0.01857054978609085,
-0.5211762189865112,
-0.49673402309417725,
-0.34358441829681396,
-0.21976937353610992,
0.13110339641571045,
0.40629473328590393,
-0.36200422048568726,
-0.04230106994509697,
-0.23232705891132355,
0.13532161712646484,
-0.1069708839058876,
-0.4214287996292114,
0.8635547161102295,
0.33672383427619934,
-0.667954683303833,
0.23766237497329712,
-0.7220999002456665,
0.1818142831325531,
-0.49434664845466614,
-0.3027288019657135,
-0.2655189037322998,
0.26204296946525574,
-0.07855726033449173,
-0.8411461710929871,
0.08858678489923477,
-0.30549418926239014,
-0.4583361744880676,
0.04589737951755524,
0.8804282546043396,
-0.4101758599281311,
-0.3046439588069916,
0.30853933095932007,
0.7301817536354065,
0.2061149626970291,
0.026513507589697838,
-0.4025435149669647,
0.5195622444152832,
0.1906958967447281,
-0.4364839494228363,
-0.057187534868717194,
0.7916637063026428,
0.20417852699756622,
0.6204198598861694,
0.2885293960571289,
0.2036915123462677,
0.08817502111196518,
0.22929991781711578,
1.0099328756332397,
-0.5032727718353271,
-0.17528465390205383,
-1.0714809894561768,
0.6780930161476135,
-0.3043106496334076,
-0.18893933296203613,
0.741658091545105,
0.09466482698917389,
0.527827799320221,
-0.0981229767203331,
0.9971746206283569,
-0.08692522346973419,
0.8257622718811035,
-0.692375898361206,
0.2792706787586212,
-0.2360963076353073,
0.6708036661148071,
-0.1460910588502884,
-0.6173049807548523,
-0.36611464619636536,
0.2272927463054657,
-0.5845160484313965,
-0.22479543089866638,
0.507996678352356,
0.9363611340522766,
0.208819180727005,
0.2828015983104706,
0.20510634779930115,
0.4528096616268158,
0.19398334622383118,
0.673126220703125,
1.3340542316436768,
-0.004257832188159227,
0.8595812320709229,
0.09351067990064621,
-0.5228914022445679,
0.14002534747123718,
-1.0203293561935425,
-0.7552676796913147,
-0.05240556597709656,
-0.2905188202857971,
-0.48625293374061584,
-0.061658430844545364,
1.2147823572158813,
0.5892103910446167,
-0.7369886040687561,
0.0851156935095787,
-0.09182815998792648,
0.03480003774166107,
-0.007305932231247425,
-0.13519452512264252,
0.1819905787706375,
-0.5885376334190369,
-0.7121413946151733,
0.6676687598228455,
0.4295578598976135,
-0.058063991367816925,
-0.017312519252300262,
-0.2075791209936142,
0.13914819061756134,
0.09872820228338242,
0.3003804683685303,
0.2504909038543701,
-0.8993921279907227,
-0.044778767973184586,
0.06481204181909561,
-0.01953022927045822,
-0.11975813657045364,
0.7783399820327759,
-0.9264596700668335,
0.509187638759613,
0.6353452205657959,
0.8582892417907715,
0.309792160987854,
-0.0008623100002296269,
0.834465742111206,
-0.6457696557044983,
0.24250425398349762,
0.28898537158966064,
0.6108008027076721,
0.2711932063102722,
-0.5664843916893005,
0.5203002095222473,
0.135019451379776,
-0.6826645135879517,
-0.9019302725791931,
0.4568254351615906,
-0.9680176973342896,
-0.275032103061676,
0.9327690005302429,
-0.7819935083389282,
-0.12221929430961609,
-0.053257714956998825,
-0.5785359144210815,
0.17121504247188568,
-0.7543310523033142,
0.7647209763526917,
0.5299500226974487,
0.021682310849428177,
-0.3141650855541229,
-0.34083622694015503,
0.3320089280605316,
0.16628365218639374,
-0.49589356780052185,
0.31140777468681335,
0.8906374573707581,
0.3832107186317444,
-0.04984612762928009,
1.0935125350952148,
-0.17869067192077637,
-0.05489988625049591,
0.15618455410003662,
-0.25456762313842773,
-0.07542870938777924,
-0.4021901488304138,
-0.5713148713111877,
0.30873170495033264,
0.43082961440086365,
-0.24919191002845764
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20654v2
|
Passage-specific Prompt Tuning for Passage Reranking in Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-31T07:43:42
| 2024-06-21T03:52:30
|
Xuyang Wu, Zhiyuan Peng, Krishna Sravanthi Rajanala Sai, Hsin-Tai Wu, Yi Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Effective passage retrieval and reranking methods have been widely utilized
to identify suitable candidates in open-domain question answering tasks, recent
studies have resorted to LLMs for reranking the retrieved passages by the
log-likelihood of the question conditioned on each passage. Although these
methods have demonstrated promising results, the performance is notably
sensitive to the human-written prompt (or hard prompt), and fine-tuning LLMs
can be computationally intensive and time-consuming. Furthermore, this approach
limits the leverage of question-passage relevance pairs and passage-specific
knowledge to enhance the ranking capabilities of LLMs. In this paper, we
propose passage-specific prompt tuning for reranking in open-domain question
answering (PSPT): a parameter-efficient method that fine-tunes learnable
passage-specific soft prompts, incorporating passage-specific knowledge from a
limited set of question-passage relevance pairs. The method involves ranking
retrieved passages based on the log-likelihood of the model generating the
question conditioned on each passage and the learned soft prompt. We conducted
extensive experiments utilizing the Llama-2-chat-7B model across three publicly
available open-domain question answering datasets and the results demonstrate
the effectiveness of the proposed approach.
|
[
-0.1389700323343277,
-0.9402498006820679,
0.8149675726890564,
0.14945000410079956,
-0.700552225112915,
-0.0012126835063099861,
-0.3040834069252014,
-0.03635925054550171,
0.3005560338497162,
0.6257210969924927,
-0.762195885181427,
-0.640521764755249,
-0.23199699819087982,
0.5028344392776489,
0.27391117811203003,
0.9689231514930725,
0.152255579829216,
-0.14070424437522888,
-0.4558410346508026,
-0.01557454839348793,
-0.5536242127418518,
-0.5383219122886658,
-0.6655076742172241,
-0.041158244013786316,
0.9689839482307434,
0.5989426374435425,
0.4656224846839905,
0.43374404311180115,
0.5568117499351501,
0.15988902747631073,
-0.3538389503955841,
0.2740875482559204,
-0.5091297030448914,
0.5591796636581421,
-0.30607831478118896,
-0.6027783751487732,
-0.43896394968032837,
-0.08712266385555267,
0.7692400217056274,
0.7977960109710693,
-0.15903973579406738,
0.13774056732654572,
0.13742566108703613,
0.30698081851005554,
-0.46746596693992615,
0.001178981619887054,
-0.9037469029426575,
-0.04059189558029175,
-0.3137919008731842,
-0.8890357613563538,
-0.619265079498291,
-0.7084590196609497,
0.22102664411067963,
-0.7108740210533142,
0.34836843609809875,
0.24360902607440948,
0.5715219974517822,
0.17378437519073486,
-0.3854692876338959,
0.09310948848724365,
-0.13316099345684052,
0.8672627210617065,
-0.6485186219215393,
0.22187983989715576,
0.2952103316783905,
0.3826788067817688,
-0.14539264142513275,
-0.740030825138092,
-0.05232160910964012,
-0.19370418787002563,
0.05228221043944359,
-0.01463230513036251,
0.19483709335327148,
0.09587421268224716,
0.1939440220594406,
0.20612189173698425,
-0.5691390037536621,
0.16405116021633148,
-0.2857491374015808,
-0.26219382882118225,
0.4700019359588623,
0.33358991146087646,
0.1262487918138504,
-0.03090531937777996,
-0.3010406494140625,
-0.10168083012104034,
-1.0046753883361816,
0.33023712038993835,
0.3577979505062103,
0.8871182203292847,
0.43112897872924805,
0.5751825571060181,
-0.404060423374176,
0.9001880288124084,
0.1916290670633316,
-0.1059950590133667,
0.18231873214244843,
-0.15720869600772858,
0.08042264729738235,
-0.05327065661549568,
0.37536266446113586,
0.3745163381099701,
0.43372371792793274,
-0.32078424096107483,
-0.2983802258968353,
-0.510073184967041,
0.34878724813461304,
-0.862506091594696,
-0.07689480483531952,
-0.010953810065984726,
-0.35976940393447876,
-0.25188472867012024,
-0.0016505110543221235,
-0.6749979853630066,
-0.41918352246284485,
-0.22465910017490387,
0.5443173050880432,
-0.2224658578634262,
-0.21385793387889862,
-0.03375621512532234,
-0.05201931297779083,
0.5223743915557861,
0.4014126658439636,
-0.7483205199241638,
0.0020357822068035603,
0.852163553237915,
0.8265904784202576,
-0.32199451327323914,
-0.3594447076320648,
-0.9699007272720337,
-0.0755997747182846,
-0.3052828311920166,
0.9882035255432129,
-0.9110957384109497,
-0.3922782242298126,
0.1784280240535736,
0.18241757154464722,
-0.3283902704715729,
-0.5120760798454285,
0.8412946462631226,
-0.8628824353218079,
0.19737452268600464,
-0.5919787287712097,
-0.6568426489830017,
0.16275973618030548,
0.05403105169534683,
-0.3369026482105255,
0.6426371932029724,
-0.09666856378316879,
-0.532068133354187,
0.2011926919221878,
-0.3005272150039673,
-0.5501814484596252,
0.12850607931613922,
0.0786532461643219,
-0.3844599723815918,
0.28522658348083496,
0.35999175906181335,
0.36698564887046814,
-0.36089256405830383,
0.1781458705663681,
-0.2352297455072403,
-0.603266179561615,
0.3258753716945648,
-0.3567742705345154,
0.5486385822296143,
0.12173140794038773,
0.05716229975223541,
0.22267583012580872,
-0.30117207765579224,
0.2681054472923279,
0.12935645878314972,
-0.2742846608161926,
-0.3790692389011383,
-0.0237074326723814,
-0.39781224727630615,
0.028107235208153725,
0.3500528931617737,
-0.528404951095581,
0.4169381856918335,
-0.46558627486228943,
0.3037906587123871,
0.8692362308502197,
0.4721655547618866,
0.43194547295570374,
-0.47356611490249634,
0.7635767459869385,
-0.1380598098039627,
0.14221566915512085,
-0.21852630376815796,
-0.9085795879364014,
-0.315584659576416,
-0.10932959616184235,
0.38230615854263306,
0.645566999912262,
-0.6567730903625488,
0.34376415610313416,
-0.05277210846543312,
-0.3768686354160309,
-0.6878656148910522,
0.08890847116708755,
0.3193749189376831,
0.7041855454444885,
0.3867722153663635,
-0.08074839413166046,
-0.07640915364027023,
-0.7414299845695496,
-0.5378491282463074,
-0.11951147764921188,
-0.13982738554477692,
0.5983758568763733,
0.0551820732653141,
0.36385074257850647,
0.9112778306007385,
-0.9916069507598877,
-0.24863430857658386,
-0.2529852092266083,
-0.1360897272825241,
0.5291087031364441,
0.19777707755565643,
0.35971173644065857,
-0.7448399066925049,
-0.5646243691444397,
-0.6068452596664429,
-0.3027189373970032,
-0.551863968372345,
0.16117261350154877,
-0.2847863733768463,
0.011182335205376148,
0.7003511190414429,
-0.5161265134811401,
-0.007282299920916557,
0.10193119198083878,
-0.6208051443099976,
0.5803576111793518,
-0.2481921762228012,
0.34504595398902893,
-0.8567602634429932,
0.03906463086605072,
-0.16210243105888367,
-0.23698879778385162,
-0.5334460139274597,
0.15833823382854462,
0.21575447916984558,
-0.26344063878059387,
-0.6031494140625,
0.6123260259628296,
-0.27915239334106445,
0.23989488184452057,
-0.16191543638706207,
0.3057372272014618,
-0.06584958732128143,
0.6310268044471741,
0.2589624524116516,
0.8092215061187744,
0.5505192875862122,
-0.6168164014816284,
-0.04346562549471855,
0.23810847103595734,
-0.25321972370147705,
0.5384131073951721,
-0.8256126642227173,
0.39513885974884033,
-0.15789255499839783,
0.34935256838798523,
-1.2609816789627075,
0.09709707647562027,
0.18547630310058594,
-0.35536831617355347,
0.22026821970939636,
-0.36734703183174133,
-0.4593096077442169,
0.1185864731669426,
-0.43749845027923584,
0.6577293872833252,
0.4902469515800476,
-0.5082912445068359,
0.21075083315372467,
-0.021107027307152748,
-0.6266934871673584,
-0.3782155513763428,
-0.06939654052257538,
-0.19621416926383972,
-0.3285219073295593,
-0.6870568990707397,
0.5724049210548401,
-0.20943742990493774,
0.10151176899671555,
-0.354627400636673,
-0.2325267791748047,
0.14229121804237366,
0.07144717872142792,
0.07393644750118256,
0.12063435465097427,
-0.30072683095932007,
0.1769074946641922,
0.34027978777885437,
-0.21528784930706024,
-0.07457394897937775,
-0.27964910864830017,
0.4713076651096344,
0.07638324052095413,
-0.2287043184041977,
-0.18745560944080353,
0.4543376564979553,
0.5106530785560608,
-0.48690035939216614,
0.8221607208251953,
0.2835976183414459,
-0.08286957442760468,
-0.1407085508108139,
-0.4092312157154083,
-0.6426493525505066,
-0.4995141327381134,
0.07325856387615204,
-0.5379024744033813,
-1.101484775543213,
0.47776439785957336,
-0.05606859177350998,
0.25468572974205017,
0.2731512188911438,
0.4281342625617981,
-0.044544123113155365,
1.1018010377883911,
0.4660140573978424,
-0.00977281853556633,
0.5595147609710693,
0.17760640382766724,
0.14110279083251953,
-0.9090014100074768,
-0.2056032419204712,
-0.5875424146652222,
-0.4655315577983856,
-0.4882660508155823,
-0.3493598997592926,
0.5096153616905212,
0.039064329117536545,
-0.33863797783851624,
0.005114537663757801,
-0.40827861428260803,
0.7222433686256409,
0.682155430316925,
0.2561761140823364,
0.42387691140174866,
0.12204837799072266,
-0.24867473542690277,
-0.0852302834391594,
-0.6107284426689148,
-0.34709441661834717,
1.2432631254196167,
0.10959343612194061,
0.541696310043335,
0.33912813663482666,
0.6577997803688049,
0.2451353371143341,
-0.02925780974328518,
-0.43563711643218994,
0.7113747596740723,
-0.06358872354030609,
-0.4477189779281616,
-0.49365121126174927,
-0.6506101489067078,
-1.2476855516433716,
0.44438377022743225,
-0.0107733104377985,
-0.6579341888427734,
0.044586967676877975,
-0.026147013530135155,
-0.5515961647033691,
0.1335376799106598,
-0.5313575267791748,
0.7607862949371338,
0.029187578707933426,
-0.12968753278255463,
-0.15342366695404053,
-0.6038661003112793,
0.09974297881126404,
0.07856503129005432,
-0.33774518966674805,
-0.15916894376277924,
-0.2993079125881195,
0.8365797996520996,
-0.22594471275806427,
0.8094302415847778,
-0.4774896800518036,
-0.26294493675231934,
0.31036633253097534,
0.04746617004275322,
0.6185334920883179,
0.37252914905548096,
-0.22987380623817444,
-0.19081354141235352,
-0.0681857168674469,
-0.46501561999320984,
-0.6791670918464661,
0.7319182753562927,
-0.6804718971252441,
-0.8981671929359436,
-0.2993881404399872,
-0.2663867771625519,
-0.5482125878334045,
0.05464732274413109,
0.38731470704078674,
0.5423452258110046,
0.09797674417495728,
0.15542173385620117,
0.9692736864089966,
-0.39857783913612366,
0.03570796921849251,
0.8395513296127319,
-0.08705702424049377,
-0.4562190771102905,
0.932297945022583,
0.04165881872177124,
0.23291781544685364,
0.6622574329376221,
0.23989161849021912,
-0.6884998083114624,
-0.6412325501441956,
-0.2798294126987457,
0.5895982980728149,
-0.5726295113563538,
-0.39491426944732666,
-0.3790584206581116,
-0.1956443339586258,
-0.44732338190078735,
-0.24684511125087738,
0.11878031492233276,
-0.562717080116272,
-0.425760418176651,
-0.07631473243236542,
0.4577289819717407,
0.14115028083324432,
0.33529794216156006,
0.17748920619487762,
-0.6031002998352051,
0.4019869565963745,
0.46955060958862305,
0.5916465520858765,
-0.1720636636018753,
-0.9756799936294556,
0.17464739084243774,
-0.1598382294178009,
-0.2514691650867462,
-1.0106528997421265,
0.14591719210147858,
0.4295356273651123,
0.7468425035476685,
0.2015477567911148,
0.5301015377044678,
0.3267543315887451,
-0.45624786615371704,
0.7582584619522095,
-0.13190804421901703,
-0.41881269216537476,
0.8286111354827881,
-0.46973055601119995,
0.4098471701145172,
0.8129057884216309,
0.2504365146160126,
-0.5739623308181763,
-0.5688924193382263,
-0.3627176284790039,
-1.0771561861038208,
0.7656499147415161,
0.05136406794190407,
0.10746735334396362,
-0.028771692886948586,
0.6845943331718445,
0.2890430986881256,
0.25085940957069397,
-0.44019198417663574,
-0.2531772255897522,
0.1661742776632309,
-0.1526103913784027,
-0.32599008083343506,
-0.20236951112747192,
0.03898320347070694,
-0.2726742625236511,
0.6017548441886902,
-0.2281801402568817,
0.1083248183131218,
0.27692461013793945,
-0.27671998739242554,
-0.2047974020242691,
0.3797946870326996,
0.5635659098625183,
0.7364532947540283,
-0.5218640565872192,
-0.002538547618314624,
0.20220716297626495,
-0.438420832157135,
0.2616931200027466,
0.05223771557211876,
-0.44050663709640503,
-0.1386023610830307,
0.1257612556219101,
0.6199899911880493,
0.06628265231847763,
-0.6817086338996887,
0.47959813475608826,
-0.23693302273750305,
-0.24168230593204498,
0.019610336050391197,
0.20084808766841888,
-0.05822910740971565,
0.31961408257484436,
0.5126680135726929,
-0.28122302889823914,
-0.11359012871980667,
-0.3948684334754944,
0.02093040570616722,
0.3341216444969177,
-0.3017728626728058,
-0.193742573261261,
0.5915910005569458,
0.5173747539520264,
-0.6767536401748657,
0.9142895936965942,
-0.1669154167175293,
-0.4410824179649353,
0.4199661612510681,
0.5983786582946777,
0.8081512451171875,
-0.37198972702026367,
0.31370097398757935,
0.29920193552970886,
0.10768067091703415,
0.07921193540096283,
0.5121625661849976,
-0.2481258511543274,
-0.3635496497154236,
-0.4620552659034729,
-0.6331555247306824,
-0.6370272040367126,
0.10171474516391754,
-0.6271577477455139,
0.1991162747144699,
-0.3350183963775635,
-0.12258172780275345,
-0.3098752498626709,
0.25989940762519836,
-0.5275790691375732,
0.005883979611098766,
0.0016820768360048532,
1.0817128419876099,
-0.8068328499794006,
0.5048060417175293,
0.812681257724762,
-0.19351355731487274,
-0.5266314744949341,
0.2518237829208374,
-0.2787058651447296,
-0.5127789378166199,
0.1261630654335022,
0.08608591556549072,
-0.04301461949944496,
0.3152991235256195,
-0.37294042110443115,
-0.8482383489608765,
1.1745001077651978,
0.5535690188407898,
-0.522348165512085,
0.08494213968515396,
0.09681953489780426,
0.39842090010643005,
-0.24367280304431915,
0.33244433999061584,
0.41210296750068665,
0.3082803189754486,
-0.04276277869939804,
-0.8209198713302612,
0.2831331491470337,
-0.26248297095298767,
-0.2360016405582428,
0.36744585633277893,
-0.7010124921798706,
0.5551030039787292,
-0.28734058141708374,
0.07587746530771255,
0.25460654497146606,
0.6999751329421997,
0.6962046027183533,
0.4157373011112213,
0.7757109999656677,
0.31056657433509827,
1.0138328075408936,
-0.09928405284881592,
0.8010791540145874,
-0.15743111073970795,
0.03792142868041992,
0.7595168352127075,
-0.26767611503601074,
1.0364584922790527,
0.39402541518211365,
-0.05780714750289917,
0.5215367078781128,
0.9788508415222168,
0.33910882472991943,
0.858527421951294,
0.3594065010547638,
-0.24065938591957092,
-0.692481279373169,
-0.08012554049491882,
-0.514360249042511,
0.17757296562194824,
0.19374896585941315,
-0.3183079659938812,
-0.09272588044404984,
-0.11882005631923676,
-0.20168736577033997,
-0.09643633663654327,
-0.43914684653282166,
0.8197305798530579,
0.21427783370018005,
-1.1818119287490845,
0.5931523442268372,
0.007814545184373856,
0.6281872987747192,
-0.6813428997993469,
0.05671102926135063,
-0.5535662770271301,
-0.0422511100769043,
0.08022400736808777,
-0.866679847240448,
-0.12428286671638489,
0.04397955909371376,
-0.28449997305870056,
-0.3955914080142975,
0.64327073097229,
-0.4202784299850464,
-0.41678839921951294,
-0.03365530073642731,
0.7015670537948608,
0.19773121178150177,
-0.5418041348457336,
-0.5070316791534424,
-0.3551599979400635,
-0.11045022308826447,
-0.3729894757270813,
0.6931111216545105,
0.5101582407951355,
-0.013254411518573761,
0.6559181809425354,
0.5850273966789246,
0.039350733160972595,
-0.19420291483402252,
0.5069363713264465,
0.7603553533554077,
-0.788722813129425,
-0.7538276314735413,
-0.7078739404678345,
0.30334654450416565,
-0.0008518535178154707,
-0.5112788081169128,
0.6715202331542969,
0.45134198665618896,
0.33315783739089966,
0.0866537094116211,
0.43534213304519653,
0.37221071124076843,
0.6877835988998413,
-0.5346505045890808,
0.5336918234825134,
-0.726202666759491,
0.38789594173431396,
-0.41856276988983154,
-1.1308519840240479,
-0.22738680243492126,
0.3279602825641632,
-0.4442433714866638,
0.013383162207901478,
0.4824391305446625,
0.9902375936508179,
0.029585516080260277,
-0.02194344811141491,
0.2281515747308731,
-0.10773783922195435,
0.1395338773727417,
0.7167742252349854,
0.8870429396629333,
0.08251802623271942,
0.9165976047515869,
0.002119257114827633,
-0.2507399022579193,
-0.5131426453590393,
-0.7456883788108826,
-0.775299608707428,
-0.6753404140472412,
-0.38453707098960876,
-0.19188734889030457,
0.27537599205970764,
0.8626513481140137,
0.3553014099597931,
-0.5606265664100647,
0.01679566688835621,
0.22662711143493652,
0.3844892978668213,
-0.4656752943992615,
-0.23504328727722168,
0.5873518586158752,
-0.6557878851890564,
-0.461248517036438,
0.5568944215774536,
0.06144697219133377,
-0.3457399606704712,
-0.00041239673737436533,
0.033964041620492935,
0.01860499382019043,
0.2780679166316986,
0.5434036254882812,
0.19314377009868622,
-0.5834605693817139,
-0.2815307378768921,
0.4997871220111847,
0.07016529887914658,
0.009271654300391674,
1.0555447340011597,
-0.8602508306503296,
0.171650230884552,
0.7227086424827576,
0.36248043179512024,
0.1609969288110733,
0.4054822325706482,
0.6601468324661255,
-1.0425474643707275,
-0.3778868317604065,
0.4748373329639435,
0.26424452662467957,
0.2468186616897583,
-0.3003033995628357,
0.2772744297981262,
0.1853172779083252,
-0.7824662923812866,
-0.9842289090156555,
0.17947478592395782,
-1.0127938985824585,
-0.48212286829948425,
1.3757655620574951,
-0.14013928174972534,
-0.021335994824767113,
-0.1273263394832611,
-0.3324480950832367,
0.06943242251873016,
-0.6088749766349792,
0.7509912848472595,
0.3578087389469147,
-0.05762495473027229,
-0.17219310998916626,
-0.20806141197681427,
0.518569827079773,
0.6828877329826355,
-0.4983709156513214,
0.19539254903793335,
0.18549329042434692,
0.41942572593688965,
-0.16580499708652496,
0.6889117956161499,
0.11900892853736877,
0.4039209187030792,
-0.4262388348579407,
-0.6285585165023804,
-0.05498756095767021,
-0.4592114984989166,
-0.4131251573562622,
0.5235797762870789,
0.3535231649875641,
-0.20431800186634064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20649v1
|
Reward-based Input Construction for Cross-document Relation Extraction
| 2024-05-31T07:30:34
| 2024-05-31T07:30:34
|
Byeonghu Na, Suhyeon Jo, Yeongmin Kim, Il-Chul Moon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Relation extraction (RE) is a fundamental task in natural language
processing, aiming to identify relations between target entities in text. While
many RE methods are designed for a single sentence or document, cross-document
RE has emerged to address relations across multiple long documents. Given the
nature of long documents in cross-document RE, extracting document embeddings
is challenging due to the length constraints of pre-trained language models.
Therefore, we propose REward-based Input Construction (REIC), the first
learning-based sentence selector for cross-document RE. REIC extracts sentences
based on relational evidence, enabling the RE module to effectively infer
relations. Since supervision of evidence sentences is generally unavailable, we
train REIC using reinforcement learning with RE prediction scores as rewards.
Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our method over heuristic
methods for different RE structures and backbones in cross-document RE. Our
code is publicly available at https://github.com/aailabkaist/REIC.
|
[
-0.27096888422966003,
-0.7601230144500732,
0.7532778382301331,
0.18901044130325317,
-0.05962463840842247,
-0.008874819613993168,
-0.1942848563194275,
-0.5547584295272827,
0.3768575191497803,
0.27835652232170105,
-0.8283162713050842,
-0.36339661478996277,
-0.9367815256118774,
0.38743144273757935,
-0.19009718298912048,
1.2269045114517212,
-0.33520442247390747,
-0.14868567883968353,
-0.6218677759170532,
-0.18087077140808105,
-0.39900267124176025,
-0.3268432319164276,
-0.557306706905365,
-0.50450599193573,
1.0642529726028442,
0.5178635716438293,
0.21645034849643707,
0.49336349964141846,
0.417339563369751,
0.31222331523895264,
0.4374445974826813,
0.21824967861175537,
-0.29494237899780273,
0.49627357721328735,
-0.6048040986061096,
-0.4262329936027527,
-0.06351233273744583,
0.39634138345718384,
0.3116799592971802,
0.33487260341644287,
0.015149084851145744,
0.04428670555353165,
-0.11822855472564697,
0.40444692969322205,
-1.0321017503738403,
0.5205833315849304,
-0.47948402166366577,
-0.13705097138881683,
-0.12914776802062988,
-0.6475772857666016,
-0.7255862951278687,
-0.19185267388820648,
-0.014538666233420372,
-0.7021041512489319,
0.1255858689546585,
-0.056621696799993515,
1.3208986520767212,
0.04802169278264046,
-0.23025555908679962,
-0.5915705561637878,
-0.5140228271484375,
0.7707112431526184,
-0.17463429272174835,
0.7112559676170349,
0.7930288314819336,
0.1789565533399582,
-0.13149189949035645,
-1.0439403057098389,
-0.32704731822013855,
-0.1500260829925537,
-0.43899857997894287,
0.12321321666240692,
-0.043222732841968536,
-0.26647570729255676,
0.2508924901485443,
0.35517463088035583,
-0.4014306366443634,
-0.06492043286561966,
-0.07815596461296082,
0.007098214700818062,
0.5695719718933105,
0.1403971016407013,
0.4053531289100647,
-0.27706366777420044,
-0.3283091187477112,
-0.2729025185108185,
-0.6446146368980408,
0.2194759100675583,
0.12110834568738937,
0.2916914224624634,
0.005159515421837568,
0.6117601990699768,
-0.18456919491291046,
0.5548375248908997,
0.12900061905384064,
-0.025285327807068825,
0.0728035420179367,
-0.4546642601490021,
-0.05107622593641281,
0.09673958271741867,
1.1740270853042603,
-0.10384666174650192,
0.2853260636329651,
-0.4784020483493805,
-0.37884366512298584,
-0.012324611656367779,
0.3937391936779022,
-0.771338939666748,
-0.03346426412463188,
0.017686616629362106,
-0.42445841431617737,
-0.587372899055481,
0.2277379184961319,
-0.6421092748641968,
-0.03641613572835922,
0.07519331574440002,
0.16069243848323822,
-0.48778846859931946,
0.0700988918542862,
-0.1887890249490738,
-0.3153999447822571,
0.4045587480068207,
0.17748162150382996,
-1.181583285331726,
0.3810842037200928,
0.83479243516922,
0.7025664448738098,
-0.21202726662158966,
-0.5834477543830872,
-1.3484030961990356,
0.023796657100319862,
0.15891776978969574,
0.9501277804374695,
-0.7595707774162292,
-0.4244985580444336,
0.16302363574504852,
0.23479972779750824,
0.09170915186405182,
-0.2915773093700409,
0.6757042407989502,
-0.7839025855064392,
0.814069926738739,
0.020178020000457764,
-0.5159323215484619,
0.2758197486400604,
0.3893102705478668,
-1.0050379037857056,
0.923022985458374,
0.7011728286743164,
-1.0347098112106323,
0.47741279006004333,
-0.5628636479377747,
-0.8381984829902649,
0.014029393903911114,
-0.3468262553215027,
-0.5112336277961731,
-0.1552601009607315,
0.5331554412841797,
0.33473530411720276,
-0.430279940366745,
0.23312771320343018,
-0.4204806089401245,
-0.19398149847984314,
0.3574243485927582,
-0.023765340447425842,
0.7438752055168152,
0.14084944128990173,
-0.1740337312221527,
0.14006586372852325,
-0.6141154170036316,
-0.07821789383888245,
0.2554394006729126,
-0.5202061533927917,
-0.570924699306488,
-0.22152969241142273,
0.11342871189117432,
0.46773239970207214,
0.10375213623046875,
-0.8502177000045776,
0.21498021483421326,
-0.4391022324562073,
0.14465202391147614,
0.5323041677474976,
0.2762705385684967,
0.5905003547668457,
-0.25690123438835144,
0.9052438735961914,
-0.37733253836631775,
-0.2080548107624054,
-0.21894235908985138,
-0.1254192292690277,
-0.34723153710365295,
-0.3156406581401825,
0.8532562851905823,
0.6042037606239319,
-1.095190167427063,
0.7584642171859741,
-0.38045886158943176,
-0.05161634087562561,
-0.4472758173942566,
0.08810334652662277,
0.42726704478263855,
0.4132924973964691,
0.33973008394241333,
-0.3055233657360077,
-0.7000049352645874,
-0.7733160853385925,
-0.3466842472553253,
-0.18205693364143372,
-0.08523587882518768,
0.10497287660837173,
0.46358898282051086,
0.025454437360167503,
1.1545705795288086,
-0.7073158621788025,
-0.4130672216415405,
-0.5680021047592163,
0.37664783000946045,
-0.109505295753479,
0.2995917499065399,
0.17406530678272247,
-0.6315613985061646,
-0.5077001452445984,
0.025062544271349907,
-0.8486645817756653,
-0.07509112358093262,
-0.3049597144126892,
-0.0550108402967453,
0.0635017529129982,
0.5212794542312622,
-0.5754590034484863,
0.5680773258209229,
0.347334086894989,
-0.3587891161441803,
0.19712187349796295,
-0.008268311619758606,
0.019189409911632538,
-1.0763980150222778,
0.08763726055622101,
0.28645265102386475,
-0.6164925694465637,
-0.08141455799341202,
0.007172244600951672,
0.15440109372138977,
0.051684048026800156,
-0.3204289972782135,
0.5862980484962463,
-0.42313823103904724,
-0.06900443136692047,
-0.25520917773246765,
0.24425002932548523,
0.18449263274669647,
0.6980718970298767,
0.5093534588813782,
0.396138072013855,
0.034613657742738724,
-0.27835795283317566,
0.3597043454647064,
0.34718847274780273,
-0.23292769491672516,
0.5232999324798584,
-0.5422059297561646,
-0.06173389032483101,
0.31975117325782776,
0.3896913528442383,
-0.5134226679801941,
0.17248569428920746,
0.4945230782032013,
-0.9223862886428833,
0.5231092572212219,
-0.020098697394132614,
-0.3661079406738281,
0.13993602991104126,
-0.34500741958618164,
0.18557579815387726,
0.20423246920108795,
-0.7433342337608337,
0.6191452741622925,
0.3816460072994232,
-0.3802714943885803,
-0.6335722208023071,
-0.4774658977985382,
-0.10406199097633362,
0.15834245085716248,
-0.4251263439655304,
0.41981449723243713,
0.4358491599559784,
0.0040272921323776245,
0.39232099056243896,
-0.015673315152525902,
-0.15160036087036133,
0.05439852923154831,
0.490403413772583,
0.37417420744895935,
0.165474072098732,
0.1866087019443512,
0.08849942684173584,
-0.45008429884910583,
0.36943429708480835,
0.15212267637252808,
0.38657146692276,
0.22163324058055878,
-0.0386916920542717,
-0.2658429741859436,
0.6820976138114929,
0.3567153811454773,
-0.5793821811676025,
0.6333926320075989,
0.5650039315223694,
-0.3048301339149475,
-0.3857710361480713,
-0.233256995677948,
-0.2782946527004242,
-0.39047956466674805,
0.5179468393325806,
-0.6398347616195679,
-0.9421278834342957,
0.18938416242599487,
-0.2904995381832123,
0.09575691819190979,
0.5280688405036926,
0.2934429347515106,
0.07665417343378067,
0.43008530139923096,
0.7400097846984863,
-0.27068090438842773,
0.7841114401817322,
-0.23804602026939392,
0.009986321441829205,
-0.809653103351593,
-0.4754047095775604,
-0.7553308010101318,
-0.21026143431663513,
-0.4290989935398102,
-0.12377163767814636,
-0.21522308886051178,
-0.07482123374938965,
0.17088887095451355,
0.6087647080421448,
-0.28747493028640747,
0.11281178146600723,
0.5742204189300537,
-0.015693681314587593,
0.2851344347000122,
-0.04951033368706703,
-0.12304863333702087,
-0.09670694172382355,
-0.7371506094932556,
-0.08449408411979675,
0.9553495645523071,
0.32931002974510193,
0.9196600914001465,
-0.3130228817462921,
1.3967046737670898,
0.13890573382377625,
0.5603742003440857,
-0.9335309863090515,
0.22928310930728912,
0.17393988370895386,
-0.19472087919712067,
-0.5414479374885559,
-0.6645246744155884,
-1.4599417448043823,
0.034009549766778946,
-0.4337909519672394,
-0.562463641166687,
0.3035081923007965,
-0.4037235379219055,
-0.11151718348264694,
0.1056414470076561,
-0.40274354815483093,
0.9096888899803162,
-0.3408825397491455,
-0.6240097880363464,
-0.16919079422950745,
-0.6164509057998657,
0.21019519865512848,
0.26866602897644043,
0.07856789231300354,
0.41809922456741333,
0.13990110158920288,
0.7752015590667725,
-0.48836028575897217,
0.3414887487888336,
0.074788399040699,
-0.12257463485002518,
0.09258485585451126,
0.19514919817447662,
0.6757782697677612,
0.43113675713539124,
0.014684121124446392,
-0.26502734422683716,
-0.13505955040454865,
-0.08483034372329712,
-1.074169397354126,
0.7999412417411804,
-0.5541030764579773,
-0.20698556303977966,
-0.7074704766273499,
-0.5339266061782837,
-0.3691195845603943,
0.17816363275051117,
0.19267190992832184,
0.31035593152046204,
-0.48623961210250854,
0.2678892910480499,
0.42500340938568115,
-0.21693924069404602,
0.42897871136665344,
0.3778492212295532,
-0.26262134313583374,
-0.6601952910423279,
0.9500858187675476,
-0.38951218128204346,
0.040904343128204346,
0.9577810764312744,
0.10965652763843536,
-0.36460429430007935,
0.024670379236340523,
-0.30028119683265686,
0.1806522011756897,
-0.3690820038318634,
-0.3491106331348419,
-0.7859401702880859,
-0.32998380064964294,
-0.4700470566749573,
-0.15481455624103546,
-0.40698662400245667,
-0.35879823565483093,
-0.08088421821594238,
-0.2730814814567566,
0.2601418197154999,
0.597411036491394,
-0.16461962461471558,
-0.17156419157981873,
-0.9241588711738586,
0.5559830069541931,
0.34952470660209656,
0.3568361699581146,
-0.26338618993759155,
-0.1911214292049408,
-0.41845646500587463,
-0.38798409700393677,
-0.14687354862689972,
-0.7675599455833435,
0.4900929629802704,
-0.2395154982805252,
0.558874785900116,
0.08928278833627701,
0.05973883345723152,
0.2410126030445099,
-0.2801665961742401,
0.41512155532836914,
0.29323655366897583,
-0.6749851107597351,
0.6559809446334839,
0.05497509241104126,
0.23140700161457062,
0.8682032823562622,
0.44456881284713745,
-0.641897976398468,
-0.2791115939617157,
-1.0471267700195312,
-0.6937488317489624,
0.9207308292388916,
0.11082267761230469,
-0.3971673846244812,
-0.12235152721405029,
0.25460317730903625,
0.22164292633533478,
-0.035851482301950455,
-0.9277523159980774,
-0.011564158834517002,
-0.05927233770489693,
-0.2722782790660858,
0.1082979366183281,
-0.14467346668243408,
-0.07938867062330246,
-0.0019290723139420152,
0.5481562614440918,
0.12697766721248627,
0.1734977811574936,
0.3416535556316376,
-0.34091463685035706,
-0.30087366700172424,
0.3658711612224579,
0.32000431418418884,
0.3487837612628937,
-0.3757474720478058,
0.08087771385908127,
-0.16485042870044708,
-0.14161954820156097,
0.05758727341890335,
0.31425559520721436,
-0.12727460265159607,
0.09277186542749405,
0.8090857863426208,
0.7368564009666443,
0.4417913854122162,
-0.3790284991264343,
0.6692991256713867,
-0.4888252019882202,
-0.5337611436843872,
-0.10288802534341812,
-0.10373204946517944,
0.05806111544370651,
0.08448784798383713,
-0.016120372340083122,
-0.3260370194911957,
-0.044306669384241104,
-0.7592979073524475,
0.650326669216156,
0.6076465845108032,
-0.6305833458900452,
0.041333068162202835,
0.32969462871551514,
0.23535051941871643,
-0.6394839286804199,
1.0241979360580444,
-0.2740689218044281,
-0.3612142503261566,
0.256173312664032,
0.5285360813140869,
1.1412066221237183,
0.12147736549377441,
0.4381561279296875,
0.5254742503166199,
0.15217256546020508,
0.1342429220676422,
-0.042978014796972275,
-0.3596052825450897,
-0.6875353455543518,
-0.5206558704376221,
-0.5133594870567322,
-0.32306987047195435,
0.03807615488767624,
-0.9470281600952148,
0.2942247986793518,
-0.2587566673755646,
0.24193336069583893,
-0.17331463098526,
0.2734422981739044,
-0.566061794757843,
0.07032965123653412,
-0.06316568702459335,
0.8040803074836731,
-0.8234352469444275,
1.210880994796753,
0.5321057438850403,
-0.8865300416946411,
-1.024153709411621,
-0.18160921335220337,
-0.42181411385536194,
-0.5174518823623657,
0.9600747227668762,
-0.12914220988750458,
-0.10746761411428452,
-0.42592352628707886,
-0.4673709273338318,
-0.48852479457855225,
1.0809983015060425,
0.2482866793870926,
-0.2182927131652832,
-0.33851829171180725,
-0.11392083019018173,
0.29422059655189514,
-0.6503326892852783,
0.3099575936794281,
0.31202661991119385,
0.4542621970176697,
0.04562341049313545,
-0.5401877164840698,
0.39602047204971313,
-0.41398924589157104,
-0.2914135158061981,
0.4670238792896271,
-0.21365457773208618,
0.5786798596382141,
-0.003593584755435586,
-0.2964262366294861,
0.007869402877986431,
0.7316313982009888,
0.44542378187179565,
0.36576998233795166,
0.5566827058792114,
0.6982991695404053,
0.34273654222488403,
0.020294150337576866,
1.3536072969436646,
-0.034008704125881195,
0.29804807901382446,
1.5679415464401245,
-0.3609326183795929,
0.8767540454864502,
0.8254961967468262,
-0.07768134772777557,
1.1937365531921387,
0.6394330859184265,
0.05764194205403328,
0.8527646660804749,
0.22536064684391022,
0.050495438277721405,
-0.2710714340209961,
-0.08032858371734619,
-0.2874350845813751,
0.43874281644821167,
0.3380184471607208,
-0.7019026875495911,
-0.40555840730667114,
-0.35761868953704834,
-0.2190801501274109,
0.25280091166496277,
0.17498435080051422,
0.9117142558097839,
0.1587298959493637,
-1.0324697494506836,
0.07337822020053864,
0.20985062420368195,
0.660586953163147,
-0.9663890600204468,
-0.46735548973083496,
-0.2388373166322708,
-0.046992115676403046,
-0.2753428518772125,
-0.7299888730049133,
0.1312236487865448,
-0.17383454740047455,
-0.32675954699516296,
-0.48006942868232727,
0.8790881037712097,
-0.6129278540611267,
-0.2043059915304184,
0.4824591875076294,
0.6276319026947021,
-0.26777270436286926,
-0.07168436050415039,
-0.49807009100914,
-0.21495217084884644,
-0.06514519453048706,
-0.35180145502090454,
0.7387158274650574,
0.7177542448043823,
-0.07451840490102768,
0.37341564893722534,
0.7798159718513489,
0.1780056357383728,
-0.4619847536087036,
0.02774880826473236,
0.9353257417678833,
-0.8263910412788391,
-0.5656962394714355,
-0.7913594245910645,
0.39969760179519653,
-0.2960395812988281,
-0.35006183385849,
0.5102570652961731,
0.6427290439605713,
0.8270753026008606,
-0.02220022864639759,
0.7704989910125732,
-0.28718945384025574,
0.3287903666496277,
-0.42999905347824097,
0.48333418369293213,
-0.5256659984588623,
-0.06683283299207687,
-0.3560740649700165,
-0.7609579563140869,
-0.16587920486927032,
0.6550799012184143,
-0.30268678069114685,
-0.19128307700157166,
1.3048384189605713,
0.6563717126846313,
0.07516603171825409,
0.018520860001444817,
0.03687325865030289,
-0.6144721508026123,
0.39999496936798096,
0.9224210977554321,
0.8590742945671082,
-0.4141482710838318,
0.6944969296455383,
-0.37401095032691956,
-0.18091903626918793,
0.11682244390249252,
-0.7391602396965027,
-0.6944671869277954,
-0.6560535430908203,
-0.20832955837249756,
-0.5634674429893494,
-0.08639754354953766,
0.8039794564247131,
0.41431283950805664,
-0.5912439227104187,
-0.24030055105686188,
-0.14383243024349213,
0.6529905200004578,
-0.32128241658210754,
-0.2970944941043854,
0.435333251953125,
-0.38003528118133545,
-0.566953718662262,
0.5064741373062134,
0.3861229717731476,
-0.5885913372039795,
-0.12329816073179245,
-0.39212924242019653,
-0.9286057353019714,
-0.38670265674591064,
0.4602564871311188,
0.5991576313972473,
-0.39499205350875854,
-0.3387340307235718,
0.04272175580263138,
-0.4240577518939972,
0.09572204202413559,
1.2213056087493896,
-1.0304532051086426,
0.2754901945590973,
0.6865204572677612,
1.1254702806472778,
0.6740721464157104,
0.04461487755179405,
0.9880098104476929,
-0.8114458918571472,
-0.07474484294652939,
0.03849980607628822,
0.43587812781333923,
0.14714191854000092,
-0.5552883148193359,
0.8386046886444092,
0.21898072957992554,
-0.37279483675956726,
-0.6155856251716614,
0.23437649011611938,
-0.9596787691116333,
-0.25252535939216614,
0.941011905670166,
-0.37439343333244324,
-0.367093563079834,
0.046836208552122116,
-0.08902952820062637,
0.5456299185752869,
-0.5612809658050537,
0.6560319066047668,
0.6255845427513123,
-0.12911462783813477,
-0.40175580978393555,
0.04355901479721069,
0.3909761607646942,
0.4632674753665924,
-1.11262047290802,
0.015353718772530556,
0.3332928717136383,
0.19141057133674622,
0.2667614221572876,
0.6867977976799011,
-0.3897804021835327,
0.46797609329223633,
0.06951908022165298,
0.3143688440322876,
-0.39704620838165283,
-0.24550072848796844,
-0.21865545213222504,
0.5651265978813171,
0.05999181419610977,
-0.4285777509212494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20648v1
|
Shotluck Holmes: A Family of Efficient Small-Scale Large Language Vision Models For Video Captioning and Summarization
| 2024-05-31T07:30:24
| 2024-05-31T07:30:24
|
Richard Luo, Austin Peng, Adithya Vasudev, Rishabh Jain
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Video is an increasingly prominent and information-dense medium, yet it poses
substantial challenges for language models. A typical video consists of a
sequence of shorter segments, or shots, that collectively form a coherent
narrative. Each shot is analogous to a word in a sentence where multiple data
streams of information (such as visual and auditory data) must be processed
simultaneously. Comprehension of the entire video requires not only
understanding the visual-audio information of each shot but also requires that
the model links the ideas between each shot to generate a larger,
all-encompassing story. Despite significant progress in the field, current
works often overlook videos' more granular shot-by-shot semantic information.
In this project, we propose a family of efficient large language vision models
(LLVMs) to boost video summarization and captioning called Shotluck Holmes. By
leveraging better pretraining and data collection strategies, we extend the
abilities of existing small LLVMs from being able to understand a picture to
being able to understand a sequence of frames. Specifically, we show that
Shotluck Holmes achieves better performance than state-of-the-art results on
the Shot2Story video captioning and summary task with significantly smaller and
more computationally efficient models.
|
[
-0.15045388042926788,
-0.659169614315033,
0.5240417122840881,
-0.023049304261803627,
-0.6183660626411438,
0.2547987699508667,
-0.19520024955272675,
-0.22570082545280457,
0.402971476316452,
0.5845422148704529,
-0.5218061804771423,
-0.46353939175605774,
-0.7752504348754883,
-0.14027324318885803,
-0.6202951669692993,
1.1179205179214478,
-0.0021313398610800505,
0.029557615518569946,
0.005599243100732565,
-0.07333584874868393,
-0.32473787665367126,
0.06869252771139145,
-0.462354451417923,
0.0361655093729496,
0.4355672597885132,
0.42865288257598877,
0.6514616012573242,
0.5918034315109253,
0.9405897855758667,
0.2580297887325287,
0.18198363482952118,
0.12066653370857239,
-0.5195895433425903,
0.05342670902609825,
0.1729539930820465,
-0.5844481587409973,
-0.2963908314704895,
-0.39540812373161316,
0.7440583109855652,
0.6739534139633179,
-0.08976182341575623,
0.5343867540359497,
0.046113479882478714,
0.630374014377594,
-0.9693629741668701,
0.45261138677597046,
-0.6537247896194458,
0.2635336220264435,
-0.12253057956695557,
-0.6207733750343323,
-0.20374175906181335,
-0.11087016016244888,
0.2608504891395569,
-0.7111884951591492,
0.48397690057754517,
-0.06605391949415207,
0.6113473176956177,
0.3876250684261322,
0.04479368031024933,
0.0952540785074234,
-0.6666535139083862,
0.6508004665374756,
-0.6262327432632446,
0.1507202535867691,
0.32928910851478577,
0.674223005771637,
0.14420408010482788,
-0.5961451530456543,
-0.4862690567970276,
0.12419775873422623,
0.08826759457588196,
0.3632039725780487,
-0.13366171717643738,
0.1728532463312149,
0.24988500773906708,
0.516463041305542,
-0.8224625587463379,
0.04151657596230507,
-0.4188638925552368,
-0.004735576920211315,
0.743195652961731,
0.5685219764709473,
0.23190604150295258,
-0.07448311895132065,
-0.019802045077085495,
-0.13763394951820374,
-0.4764266312122345,
0.21527467668056488,
0.19281667470932007,
0.05269719287753105,
-0.121671661734581,
0.7409706115722656,
-0.5967810750007629,
0.7976272702217102,
-0.20114634931087494,
-0.6681026816368103,
-0.041374802589416504,
-0.359192430973053,
-0.5850223898887634,
0.18690422177314758,
0.5560190677642822,
0.6027994155883789,
0.3694153130054474,
0.1480918526649475,
0.02715243771672249,
-0.06444577127695084,
0.19367381930351257,
-0.9270070791244507,
-0.580498993396759,
0.3132418990135193,
-0.4534622132778168,
-0.39502158761024475,
0.10411126911640167,
-0.6677982807159424,
-0.41291314363479614,
-0.22004303336143494,
0.574235200881958,
-0.30973976850509644,
0.0521501824259758,
0.17561893165111542,
-0.23000387847423553,
0.578220546245575,
0.7171007394790649,
-1.0920358896255493,
0.10415448248386383,
0.5507053136825562,
1.0085819959640503,
-0.028678610920906067,
-0.4416981637477875,
-0.9758871793746948,
0.4818170368671417,
-0.4637557864189148,
0.7975174784660339,
-0.3973892629146576,
-0.08598984777927399,
0.3047678470611572,
0.045651402324438095,
0.24881257116794586,
-0.2986328601837158,
-0.13668181002140045,
-0.3518422842025757,
0.11398619413375854,
0.04687938839197159,
-0.4809565544128418,
-0.30739185214042664,
0.29215922951698303,
-0.6212943196296692,
0.4425434172153473,
-0.31232765316963196,
-0.8537038564682007,
0.32861456274986267,
-0.3298119306564331,
-0.563959538936615,
0.43836963176727295,
-0.2027265727519989,
-0.4552347660064697,
0.3940870463848114,
0.44476112723350525,
0.78293776512146,
-0.022674523293972015,
0.18450544774532318,
-0.3503076434135437,
-0.45950523018836975,
0.000300610059639439,
-0.4491081237792969,
0.543931245803833,
-0.015601655468344688,
-0.03380793333053589,
0.20425337553024292,
-0.41876116394996643,
-0.37133708596229553,
0.2560197710990906,
-0.05988265946507454,
-0.19438780844211578,
0.09954982250928879,
-0.1469249278306961,
-0.33199837803840637,
-0.07034773379564285,
-0.19971030950546265,
-0.01852576620876789,
-0.25631871819496155,
0.32188162207603455,
0.4069233536720276,
-0.012237501330673695,
0.4385170340538025,
-0.21787144243717194,
0.7516822218894958,
-0.13715937733650208,
0.29514726996421814,
-1.033479928970337,
-0.5010599493980408,
-0.6187628507614136,
-0.44495531916618347,
-0.192465677857399,
0.6018688678741455,
-0.9161296486854553,
0.16806842386722565,
-0.5687990188598633,
-0.29087507724761963,
-0.5240387320518494,
0.329825758934021,
0.23683515191078186,
0.5568974614143372,
0.2675293982028961,
-0.3066408038139343,
-0.3544104993343353,
-0.9346723556518555,
-0.10217762738466263,
-0.26736214756965637,
-0.17214182019233704,
0.061793550848960876,
0.5104920864105225,
0.19645610451698303,
0.8776276111602783,
-0.803339958190918,
-0.5639762878417969,
-0.5034606456756592,
0.010063393041491508,
0.17029830813407898,
0.038073793053627014,
0.23860511183738708,
-0.554486870765686,
-0.3331660032272339,
-0.11523651331663132,
-0.9488859176635742,
0.2910866439342499,
-0.20992811024188995,
0.22936926782131195,
0.005170733667910099,
0.60896235704422,
-0.581395149230957,
0.6008456945419312,
0.5385319590568542,
0.09522778540849686,
0.7452764511108398,
-0.11717379093170166,
0.25193485617637634,
-0.9778273701667786,
0.00027393782511353493,
-0.17362937331199646,
-0.5003497004508972,
-0.5439038872718811,
0.2015777826309204,
-0.14692877233028412,
-0.2980347275733948,
-0.7799600958824158,
0.2977943420410156,
-0.3899579644203186,
-0.44952329993247986,
-0.3489643335342407,
0.3967135548591614,
0.12766507267951965,
0.567326545715332,
0.30659130215644836,
0.5619654059410095,
0.8539282083511353,
-0.37387123703956604,
0.8648697733879089,
0.3607630729675293,
-0.7637718319892883,
0.5439724922180176,
-0.600904643535614,
-0.5084942579269409,
-0.37131866812705994,
0.44151169061660767,
-1.0772371292114258,
-0.7251334190368652,
-0.2074422389268875,
-0.5157618522644043,
0.24730485677719116,
-0.22844798862934113,
-0.5589594841003418,
-0.3775128126144409,
-0.675069272518158,
0.5108767747879028,
0.5283167362213135,
-0.6188881397247314,
0.5785471200942993,
0.5200880169868469,
-0.40893468260765076,
-0.5978363156318665,
-1.0500025749206543,
0.31386256217956543,
-0.5702940821647644,
-0.793561577796936,
0.23635262250900269,
0.13692304491996765,
-0.19238997995853424,
-0.13708825409412384,
0.04971867427229881,
-0.06407994031906128,
-0.18377429246902466,
0.10294393450021744,
0.4348549544811249,
-0.1950502097606659,
0.3076542317867279,
-0.15646927058696747,
0.045304346829652786,
-0.12156174331903458,
-0.15973436832427979,
0.1516326516866684,
-0.14023469388484955,
-0.024926165118813515,
-0.4802572429180145,
0.5225201845169067,
0.40154778957366943,
-0.3913097679615021,
0.464234858751297,
0.68100506067276,
-0.23145504295825958,
-0.2732996344566345,
-0.5587692260742188,
-0.49193841218948364,
-0.3754442632198334,
0.7438522577285767,
-0.25481927394866943,
-1.040298342704773,
0.5114208459854126,
0.2833136022090912,
0.20723800361156464,
0.0838136151432991,
0.6733778119087219,
-0.6775423288345337,
0.8028613924980164,
0.5671361088752747,
-0.007031753193587065,
0.6360733509063721,
-0.42092445492744446,
0.3647421598434448,
-0.624810516834259,
-0.010591345839202404,
0.07252458482980728,
-0.23007981479167938,
-0.1194707602262497,
-0.49463310837745667,
0.4225924015045166,
0.14876163005828857,
0.07753852754831314,
0.25937044620513916,
-0.0876464992761612,
0.8420412540435791,
0.3891546428203583,
0.07370110601186752,
0.5348103046417236,
0.2852697968482971,
0.4063186049461365,
0.04560813307762146,
-0.7736599445343018,
-0.20708557963371277,
1.0455228090286255,
0.3819035589694977,
0.9537807106971741,
0.26442036032676697,
0.5884447693824768,
0.2815217673778534,
-0.2665902376174927,
-1.1258667707443237,
0.7153255343437195,
-0.3662473261356354,
-0.35499307513237,
-0.4505882263183594,
-0.05389927700161934,
-0.8332128524780273,
0.23412293195724487,
-0.2191932648420334,
-0.6960934400558472,
-0.29337775707244873,
0.33362525701522827,
-0.822907567024231,
0.4060129225254059,
-0.5081840753555298,
0.8653632402420044,
-0.0668126791715622,
-0.4930887520313263,
-0.4016658067703247,
-0.7025711536407471,
0.8848134875297546,
-0.007725690025836229,
0.1967048943042755,
-0.06951078027486801,
0.04478178918361664,
0.6517316102981567,
-0.6483436226844788,
0.8673804402351379,
0.052358463406562805,
0.05627824366092682,
0.6092717051506042,
0.2556363642215729,
0.3582952320575714,
0.12045883387327194,
0.9289591908454895,
0.1309964656829834,
0.12708055973052979,
-0.3301769495010376,
-0.5522053241729736,
0.38280224800109863,
-0.2128465622663498,
-0.5243736505508423,
-0.2766372859477997,
-0.5567494630813599,
-0.1060463935136795,
0.008905395865440369,
0.24719886481761932,
0.7289355993270874,
-0.03112887591123581,
0.41836461424827576,
0.7013386487960815,
-0.23598434031009674,
0.8580796122550964,
0.31313711404800415,
-0.513271689414978,
-0.2734718918800354,
0.695742130279541,
-0.23837588727474213,
0.17402859032154083,
0.5048213601112366,
-0.02540835738182068,
-0.08021694421768188,
-0.7885984778404236,
-0.34338104724884033,
0.18760494887828827,
-0.7765697240829468,
-0.3699783384799957,
-0.4444540739059448,
-0.09202433377504349,
-0.3370848596096039,
-0.37739112973213196,
-0.3865610659122467,
-0.41541388630867004,
0.002657069591805339,
-0.22237253189086914,
0.36413276195526123,
0.006978627759963274,
0.1723654419183731,
0.6823690533638,
-0.8945050835609436,
0.487097829580307,
0.7125205993652344,
0.23011431097984314,
-0.20624200999736786,
-0.7495845556259155,
-0.5008364915847778,
-0.3869040310382843,
-0.10825052857398987,
-0.7865993976593018,
0.4423142075538635,
0.1880297213792801,
0.28902164101600647,
0.4770693778991699,
-0.30012622475624084,
0.991714358329773,
-0.5706367492675781,
0.9759907126426697,
0.4557074010372162,
-0.6871209740638733,
0.7909915447235107,
-0.4671446681022644,
0.7377430200576782,
0.6824051737785339,
-0.004673426505178213,
-0.31134721636772156,
-0.41096627712249756,
-0.35910019278526306,
-0.777897298336029,
0.5941300988197327,
0.22383663058280945,
0.07037670910358429,
0.3527517318725586,
-0.11242254078388214,
0.012227050960063934,
0.1774100959300995,
-0.49169257283210754,
0.33227717876434326,
-0.1763581484556198,
-0.3412346839904785,
-0.2713482975959778,
-0.02619490772485733,
-0.17683714628219604,
-0.16397824883460999,
0.5774521231651306,
-0.4536757469177246,
-0.07019053399562836,
0.17280589044094086,
-0.5912245512008667,
0.1141907200217247,
0.03954053670167923,
0.5205195546150208,
0.370932012796402,
-0.39603909850120544,
0.10591026395559311,
0.09851976484060287,
-0.6887813806533813,
-0.1578940749168396,
-0.09704019129276276,
-0.2242637425661087,
0.05549786612391472,
0.9568928480148315,
0.8937093019485474,
0.2642759680747986,
-1.0220367908477783,
0.7896630167961121,
0.07868542522192001,
-0.3497166633605957,
-0.5323550701141357,
-0.10428820550441742,
-0.15158480405807495,
0.36889412999153137,
0.2537616491317749,
-0.1561920940876007,
0.4405532479286194,
-0.7371715903282166,
0.060846343636512756,
0.45153817534446716,
-0.08892649412155151,
-0.19244778156280518,
0.5161008834838867,
0.23507826030254364,
-0.23798583447933197,
0.501950204372406,
0.13852883875370026,
-0.23012618720531464,
0.5012948513031006,
-0.048838529735803604,
1.0994977951049805,
-0.013509728014469147,
0.410529226064682,
0.3827630281448364,
0.30698704719543457,
-0.2426930069923401,
0.01865527220070362,
-0.38526397943496704,
-0.5219970345497131,
-0.7407622933387756,
-0.6433660387992859,
-0.34804996848106384,
0.05352763086557388,
-0.6182934641838074,
0.30264267325401306,
-0.3103381097316742,
-0.0031473867129534483,
0.060706641525030136,
-0.26274988055229187,
-0.6787144541740417,
0.10281427204608917,
0.42450395226478577,
0.7107716202735901,
-0.8516644239425659,
0.9635257124900818,
0.29990607500076294,
-0.5274048447608948,
-0.6453601717948914,
-0.21980050206184387,
0.034103572368621826,
-0.7637354731559753,
0.36172524094581604,
0.30238261818885803,
-0.1635776311159134,
-0.1723720282316208,
-0.45078960061073303,
-0.5448601245880127,
1.3085039854049683,
0.19164302945137024,
-0.8294496536254883,
-0.2879202365875244,
0.052951082587242126,
0.3501449227333069,
-0.5739161372184753,
0.1460358053445816,
0.7298176884651184,
0.16487033665180206,
0.3402523994445801,
-0.7266379594802856,
-0.5443778038024902,
-0.02675287425518036,
0.02680652216076851,
0.030048949643969536,
-0.4530661404132843,
0.3726646602153778,
-0.573424756526947,
0.03863069787621498,
-0.12335073947906494,
0.5659164190292358,
0.26586243510246277,
0.3949645757675171,
0.3695846199989319,
0.5074643492698669,
0.3687339723110199,
0.04721205681562424,
1.1713417768478394,
0.04283962398767471,
0.1533023864030838,
1.663663625717163,
0.06766413152217865,
1.0024038553237915,
0.598626434803009,
-0.19366095960140228,
0.2306378185749054,
0.41672852635383606,
-0.29597124457359314,
0.6753255724906921,
-0.01080795656889677,
-0.12321262061595917,
-0.4100145697593689,
0.08924367278814316,
0.11931371688842773,
0.8725923299789429,
0.2028358280658722,
-0.2961048483848572,
-0.21489115059375763,
0.20820608735084534,
-0.24159453809261322,
0.00571706797927618,
-0.6697689294815063,
0.9418607354164124,
0.017615383490920067,
-0.5952255129814148,
0.2546134293079376,
-0.31187620759010315,
0.47532719373703003,
-0.7392991781234741,
0.1330295354127884,
-0.41252991557121277,
0.1436099410057068,
-0.3388405442237854,
-1.0413705110549927,
0.4322133958339691,
0.2769201695919037,
-0.028539501130580902,
0.0621313713490963,
0.3728071451187134,
-0.6402762532234192,
-0.6743214130401611,
-0.07314006239175797,
0.07931043952703476,
0.4139397144317627,
-0.1840907782316208,
-0.4245770573616028,
0.185938760638237,
-0.08173950016498566,
0.016925781965255737,
0.043669193983078,
-0.02787409909069538,
-0.062418870627880096,
0.5198767185211182,
0.3327006697654724,
0.21125450730323792,
0.21435870230197906,
0.25322970747947693,
0.26708918809890747,
-0.46227243542671204,
-0.6719447374343872,
-0.865532398223877,
0.7018464803695679,
-0.19230760633945465,
0.03847140446305275,
0.754264771938324,
0.6377419829368591,
0.7094033360481262,
-0.36115607619285583,
0.7648545503616333,
0.4351719319820404,
0.1043068915605545,
-0.774465024471283,
0.38474252820014954,
-0.5865609049797058,
0.06390680372714996,
-0.2778145670890808,
-1.1665198802947998,
-0.7648811936378479,
0.46496984362602234,
-0.15124444663524628,
-0.3436184525489807,
0.6951501369476318,
0.7015592455863953,
-0.10438859462738037,
0.05478888377547264,
0.4971673786640167,
0.22771619260311127,
0.464803546667099,
0.8563203811645508,
0.6693228483200073,
-0.4941728413105011,
0.9193724393844604,
-0.22735220193862915,
-0.2872370779514313,
-0.5025756359100342,
-0.8504484295845032,
-1.1044816970825195,
-0.48140743374824524,
-0.6191511154174805,
0.14375002682209015,
0.018477799370884895,
0.43338045477867126,
0.8651086091995239,
-0.6263303160667419,
-0.23568475246429443,
-0.015229146927595139,
-0.28194355964660645,
-0.035682979971170425,
-0.19761092960834503,
0.48777270317077637,
-0.13567832112312317,
-0.6320582628250122,
0.3384130299091339,
0.8272663950920105,
0.03651060909032822,
-0.5207371711730957,
-0.11122646927833557,
0.01488463208079338,
0.2006995677947998,
0.8893539905548096,
0.36663976311683655,
-0.868558406829834,
-0.19690397381782532,
-0.2644885778427124,
0.1517200469970703,
-0.05491902306675911,
0.9425564408302307,
-0.7488487362861633,
0.8179184794425964,
0.747734010219574,
0.6005744338035583,
1.0174425840377808,
-0.048611581325531006,
0.3278750777244568,
-0.520881712436676,
0.4276480972766876,
0.0761014074087143,
0.6401064395904541,
0.5311737060546875,
0.023241980001330376,
0.4902971088886261,
0.05949638411402702,
-0.25548845529556274,
-0.8152726292610168,
0.2573221027851105,
-1.30862295627594,
-0.3703039586544037,
0.9338264465332031,
-0.15298707783222198,
-0.26610928773880005,
0.2870263159275055,
-0.19116303324699402,
-0.05077439174056053,
-0.11690168082714081,
0.8278000950813293,
0.5768210887908936,
0.11780909448862076,
-0.6718801259994507,
-0.702634334564209,
0.4500318765640259,
0.35063686966896057,
-0.8387994766235352,
0.25640013813972473,
0.609861433506012,
0.16886703670024872,
-0.08697256445884705,
0.6989586353302002,
-0.15448807179927826,
0.4778464734554291,
0.08295964449644089,
-0.15706133842468262,
-0.2086273580789566,
-0.7364705801010132,
-0.6403594017028809,
0.25114578008651733,
-0.3747154772281647,
-0.4029868245124817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20646v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20646v1
|
Large Language Models Enhanced Sequential Recommendation for Long-tail User and Item
| 2024-05-31T07:24:42
| 2024-05-31T07:24:42
|
Qidong Liu, Xian Wu, Xiangyu Zhao, Yejing Wang, Zijian Zhang, Feng Tian, Yefeng Zheng
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Sequential recommendation systems (SRS) serve the purpose of predicting
users' subsequent preferences based on their past interactions and have been
applied across various domains such as e-commerce and social networking
platforms. However, practical SRS encounters challenges due to the fact that
most users engage with only a limited number of items, while the majority of
items are seldom consumed. These challenges, termed as the long-tail user and
long-tail item dilemmas, often create obstacles for traditional SRS methods.
Mitigating these challenges is crucial as they can significantly impact user
satisfaction and business profitability. While some research endeavors have
alleviated these issues, they still grapple with issues such as seesaw or noise
stemming from the scarcity of interactions. The emergence of large language
models (LLMs) presents a promising avenue to address these challenges from a
semantic standpoint. In this study, we introduce the Large Language Models
Enhancement framework for Sequential Recommendation (LLM-ESR), which leverages
semantic embeddings from LLMs to enhance SRS performance without increasing
computational overhead. To combat the long-tail item challenge, we propose a
dual-view modeling approach that fuses semantic information from LLMs with
collaborative signals from traditional SRS. To address the long-tail user
challenge, we introduce a retrieval augmented self-distillation technique to
refine user preference representations by incorporating richer interaction data
from similar users. Through comprehensive experiments conducted on three
authentic datasets using three widely used SRS models, our proposed enhancement
framework demonstrates superior performance compared to existing methodologies.
|
[
-0.27694109082221985,
-0.6855720281600952,
0.7543169856071472,
0.37442919611930847,
-0.35634320974349976,
0.2456662654876709,
-0.33390000462532043,
-0.5444740653038025,
0.5542101263999939,
0.8024064898490906,
-0.7302154898643494,
-0.3412070870399475,
-0.4881979525089264,
0.13615259528160095,
-0.3345993161201477,
1.0583000183105469,
0.1661093682050705,
-0.21222582459449768,
-0.1444796919822693,
-0.06385193765163422,
-0.7105305194854736,
-0.6360297799110413,
-0.6698826551437378,
-0.37185800075531006,
0.8661922812461853,
0.38335734605789185,
0.6578598022460938,
0.1501205861568451,
0.4241160452365875,
0.34985315799713135,
-0.05822281911969185,
0.3135336637496948,
-0.5668798685073853,
0.5625705718994141,
-0.45069485902786255,
0.06810218095779419,
-0.3878759443759918,
-0.5058084726333618,
0.5599530935287476,
0.6191970109939575,
-0.37565115094184875,
0.013980964198708534,
0.3008567988872528,
0.9325796961784363,
-0.48504921793937683,
-0.012097841128706932,
-0.49978503584861755,
-0.09708185493946075,
-0.27265697717666626,
0.010936116799712181,
-0.4840813875198364,
0.026780832558870316,
0.593212902545929,
-0.5146269202232361,
-0.24430614709854126,
0.27707284688949585,
0.40389907360076904,
0.1590355783700943,
-0.5638313889503479,
-0.18201756477355957,
-0.8249830007553101,
0.8595534563064575,
-0.784984290599823,
0.47861576080322266,
0.3181796073913574,
0.10232958942651749,
-0.49575406312942505,
-0.761165201663971,
-0.3679675757884979,
-0.2989961504936218,
-0.19318999350070953,
-0.14817771315574646,
-0.1065143272280693,
-0.14917699992656708,
0.24205738306045532,
0.2701936960220337,
-0.4199499487876892,
0.2450331300497055,
-0.03807918354868889,
-0.01234922744333744,
0.6541105508804321,
0.24649688601493835,
0.16680286824703217,
-0.032054804265499115,
-0.5324703454971313,
0.053840603679418564,
-0.5405585765838623,
-0.21770018339157104,
0.36228039860725403,
0.36232906579971313,
0.00824139267206192,
0.6826524138450623,
-0.3747321665287018,
0.641943633556366,
0.25462016463279724,
-0.004666517022997141,
0.4164128303527832,
-0.6208636164665222,
0.07310760766267776,
-0.11298669874668121,
0.7646246552467346,
0.48945534229278564,
0.20579499006271362,
0.06119968742132187,
-0.2193966507911682,
-0.30695655941963196,
0.013679652474820614,
-0.9502912163734436,
-0.0795317068696022,
0.08750304579734802,
-0.4723829925060272,
-0.09235630184412003,
-0.03769660368561745,
-0.650847852230072,
-0.7834824323654175,
-0.38103222846984863,
0.3225013017654419,
-0.22059109807014465,
-0.36474350094795227,
0.4005952477455139,
-0.003682345151901245,
-0.2326156198978424,
0.4430132508277893,
-0.8960135579109192,
0.46660691499710083,
0.7275453805923462,
0.7827750444412231,
-0.1772972196340561,
-0.3075218200683594,
-0.6501802206039429,
0.3631819486618042,
-0.0003984749782830477,
0.87052321434021,
-0.7720412015914917,
-0.5905436873435974,
-0.016963060945272446,
-0.002135152230039239,
0.283178448677063,
-0.46312111616134644,
0.5206485986709595,
-0.5718024969100952,
0.0665082335472107,
-0.39980530738830566,
-0.5152923464775085,
-0.040212634950876236,
0.0015428486512973905,
-0.49404555559158325,
1.165886640548706,
-0.09691512584686279,
-0.6623410582542419,
0.34104105830192566,
-0.4393630623817444,
-0.5115242004394531,
0.232506662607193,
-0.08301690220832825,
-0.22903011739253998,
0.17182384431362152,
0.26368027925491333,
0.5882217884063721,
-0.39055779576301575,
0.44508689641952515,
-0.683886706829071,
-0.2885937988758087,
0.06452745944261551,
-0.25124457478523254,
0.09367460012435913,
0.13343477249145508,
0.14100335538387299,
0.41013070940971375,
-0.6438137888908386,
-0.24047930538654327,
0.1439647525548935,
-0.09346169978380203,
-0.8432322144508362,
0.2811346650123596,
0.07238723337650299,
0.25605013966560364,
0.6264743208885193,
-0.4102785885334015,
0.35607701539993286,
-0.5061611533164978,
0.3930586576461792,
0.9795897603034973,
0.13005000352859497,
0.4120302200317383,
-0.21706745028495789,
0.08098284900188446,
0.10117244720458984,
-0.07782866805791855,
-0.26431238651275635,
-0.30739960074424744,
-0.7970484495162964,
-0.2668026089668274,
0.09971559792757034,
0.2248874008655548,
-0.6691365838050842,
0.7500693202018738,
-0.3467175364494324,
-0.11747477203607559,
-0.28155356645584106,
0.3837813436985016,
0.08228135108947754,
0.18155120313167572,
0.28566744923591614,
-0.5389875769615173,
-0.6385356783866882,
-0.9961926341056824,
-0.19292867183685303,
0.015245622023940086,
-0.1834040880203247,
0.5210847854614258,
0.25824010372161865,
-0.42778491973876953,
0.8209540247917175,
-0.729219913482666,
-0.46813520789146423,
-0.34151822328567505,
0.06568385660648346,
0.44913193583488464,
0.1564149260520935,
0.1936783343553543,
-0.6245635747909546,
-0.6783535480499268,
-0.27288299798965454,
-0.3111209571361542,
-0.08128371089696884,
-0.07174084335565567,
-0.057094648480415344,
0.17933490872383118,
0.2525903880596161,
-0.15097284317016602,
0.25406792759895325,
0.47493764758110046,
-0.5630666017532349,
0.33136218786239624,
-0.5549502372741699,
0.05443091318011284,
-1.1612316370010376,
-0.3341272175312042,
0.33915975689888,
-0.3067034184932709,
-0.3189990818500519,
-0.31885048747062683,
-0.04329181835055351,
0.167979434132576,
-0.12777644395828247,
0.6673151850700378,
-0.29027843475341797,
-0.08117590844631195,
-0.44777849316596985,
0.2454327493906021,
0.0917699933052063,
0.3417157232761383,
0.33885902166366577,
0.5604779124259949,
0.35850584506988525,
-0.37538981437683105,
0.22316163778305054,
0.205679252743721,
-0.4704252779483795,
0.5312796831130981,
-0.8881142139434814,
0.2905803620815277,
-0.014375454746186733,
0.5404422879219055,
-1.0539640188217163,
0.11155804246664047,
0.07945659011602402,
0.08006180822849274,
0.15803013741970062,
-0.38458195328712463,
-0.7755502462387085,
-0.36128950119018555,
-0.4305207431316376,
0.2939052879810333,
0.40846455097198486,
-0.665087878704071,
0.6458895206451416,
0.19547176361083984,
-0.4117874503135681,
-0.7108505964279175,
-0.28386223316192627,
0.250839501619339,
-0.1594727337360382,
-0.8213558197021484,
0.40808171033859253,
-0.42739349603652954,
-0.07383795827627182,
-0.06919614225625992,
0.060805536806583405,
0.45482030510902405,
-0.038108427077531815,
0.28637564182281494,
0.5357319116592407,
0.022266823798418045,
0.3002433776855469,
-0.054092153906822205,
-0.327804833650589,
-0.24968482553958893,
-0.4385959506034851,
0.6588732600212097,
-0.24588799476623535,
-0.28635451197624207,
-0.3585509657859802,
0.48544755578041077,
0.5344547033309937,
-0.3404459059238434,
0.8553869128227234,
0.6877039074897766,
-0.014635080471634865,
-0.26565641164779663,
-0.9659122228622437,
-0.3010936677455902,
-0.5508589148521423,
0.7535579204559326,
-0.5530354380607605,
-1.049296259880066,
0.3891250789165497,
-0.16695424914360046,
-0.11815699934959412,
0.2722022235393524,
0.5911919474601746,
0.06409190595149994,
1.0486056804656982,
0.5977959632873535,
-0.3556426465511322,
0.7071731090545654,
-0.0800887942314148,
0.340972900390625,
-1.0932146310806274,
-0.19294185936450958,
-0.3104690611362457,
-0.14964032173156738,
-0.47318869829177856,
-0.3390132784843445,
0.2371964454650879,
0.012314571999013424,
-0.300393670797348,
0.1950102001428604,
-0.3664931356906891,
0.3189324140548706,
0.5058779716491699,
0.23265880346298218,
0.5504600405693054,
0.09602140635251999,
-0.1080087348818779,
-0.13946719467639923,
-0.4193211793899536,
-0.23868736624717712,
0.9470368027687073,
0.45983222126960754,
1.0391294956207275,
0.28529366850852966,
0.7051328420639038,
0.4644239842891693,
-0.09268703311681747,
-0.9576274752616882,
0.633817195892334,
-0.4716358184814453,
-0.2069849818944931,
-0.3674788177013397,
-0.28901049494743347,
-0.7341328263282776,
0.3228711187839508,
-0.4730963110923767,
-0.8042542934417725,
0.1794644594192505,
-0.04574708640575409,
-0.4463515281677246,
0.1078011617064476,
-0.47623440623283386,
0.6074310541152954,
-0.46718335151672363,
-0.8695368766784668,
-0.5722076296806335,
-0.5441149473190308,
0.07995995879173279,
-0.27246999740600586,
0.2858673930168152,
-0.20910140872001648,
-0.1357080489397049,
0.8110842108726501,
-0.5685923099517822,
0.7804175019264221,
-0.0067662266083061695,
-0.18278610706329346,
0.03615433722734451,
0.136841282248497,
1.1611233949661255,
0.04414384067058563,
-0.19884029030799866,
0.12788240611553192,
-0.07158586382865906,
0.05027412250638008,
-0.609368622303009,
1.0919735431671143,
-0.5753729343414307,
-0.9172022938728333,
-0.49813011288642883,
-0.37836983799934387,
-0.3219679594039917,
0.40559670329093933,
-0.37077897787094116,
0.44851043820381165,
0.10837769508361816,
0.4671348035335541,
0.4983443021774292,
-0.29113054275512695,
0.32248786091804504,
0.7612358927726746,
-0.550218403339386,
-0.4754597842693329,
0.6402701139450073,
0.05659254640340805,
0.15622055530548096,
0.17570734024047852,
0.4702840745449066,
-0.6297582387924194,
-0.738983154296875,
-0.27384713292121887,
0.4434826374053955,
-0.4459342956542969,
0.023781701922416687,
-0.7854447364807129,
0.09910938143730164,
-0.3826669752597809,
-0.004623305983841419,
-0.3211597204208374,
-0.22674505412578583,
-0.28486764430999756,
-0.06470423191785812,
0.6346228122711182,
0.8574068546295166,
0.05550815165042877,
0.14775142073631287,
-0.821750283241272,
0.4663805663585663,
0.1993369311094284,
0.7786546945571899,
0.32667940855026245,
-0.7212336659431458,
-0.36235395073890686,
-0.13772763311862946,
0.10666032880544662,
-0.2758142054080963,
0.44037100672721863,
-0.08480420708656311,
0.4273262321949005,
0.3990060091018677,
0.23488737642765045,
0.8842031359672546,
-0.8854203820228577,
0.6364014744758606,
0.3203418254852295,
-0.5878027081489563,
0.3609156310558319,
-0.4239540100097656,
0.18521098792552948,
0.5620842576026917,
0.30125880241394043,
-0.6994173526763916,
0.05444465950131416,
-0.19065509736537933,
-1.2081348896026611,
0.5975846648216248,
-0.12820549309253693,
0.16518805921077728,
0.0043542655184865,
0.10584951192140579,
0.09345223009586334,
0.15121103823184967,
-0.46328267455101013,
-0.29878073930740356,
0.21067959070205688,
-0.19578373432159424,
-0.33140674233436584,
-0.8016932606697083,
0.254830926656723,
-0.02690022997558117,
0.7249040007591248,
0.21985751390457153,
-0.3605615794658661,
0.05203638970851898,
0.24374376237392426,
-0.09874783456325531,
0.4113146662712097,
0.2963666021823883,
0.5430564880371094,
-0.41949111223220825,
-0.2822038233280182,
-0.046120885759592056,
-0.17735666036605835,
0.004553928039968014,
0.11380048096179962,
0.10489683598279953,
-0.30702468752861023,
-0.12917883694171906,
0.7490514516830444,
0.38472220301628113,
-0.6132780313491821,
0.47371721267700195,
-0.16534914076328278,
0.25053903460502625,
-0.70579594373703,
-0.19898012280464172,
0.1831936240196228,
0.32506921887397766,
0.45893678069114685,
-0.03596711531281471,
0.38686150312423706,
-0.6417259573936462,
0.15315750241279602,
0.5210844874382019,
-0.22704686224460602,
-0.03806529939174652,
0.15657886862754822,
0.5748911499977112,
-0.3067903518676758,
0.6226606965065002,
0.3082781732082367,
-0.3500635027885437,
0.03276116028428078,
0.6324765682220459,
0.8688669800758362,
-0.008839430287480354,
-0.10375688970088959,
0.27444857358932495,
-0.12911537289619446,
-0.4835347831249237,
-0.13284648954868317,
-0.20852762460708618,
-0.7393783926963806,
-0.44116437435150146,
-0.772554874420166,
-0.2825515866279602,
0.08658949285745621,
-0.6177520751953125,
0.5957079529762268,
-0.1958957463502884,
-0.27752071619033813,
-0.05094056949019432,
0.12071498483419418,
-0.4428855776786804,
-0.21958684921264648,
0.18251703679561615,
0.6511521935462952,
-0.413219690322876,
0.8849593997001648,
0.4216333031654358,
-0.2785414159297943,
-0.46371015906333923,
-0.2584684193134308,
0.006767055485397577,
-0.5728632807731628,
0.6751404404640198,
-0.03672197088599205,
-0.556794285774231,
-0.10223818570375443,
-0.040349479764699936,
-0.9318012595176697,
0.8777959942817688,
-0.12075567990541458,
-1.1052992343902588,
-0.06300725042819977,
-0.08009321987628937,
0.6815148591995239,
-0.48997554183006287,
0.23061349987983704,
0.1664828062057495,
0.3437916338443756,
0.5282541513442993,
-0.9220594167709351,
0.16797928512096405,
-0.09041193127632141,
0.18244338035583496,
0.44115695357322693,
-0.7720403671264648,
0.37501969933509827,
-0.3533836305141449,
-0.00297698681242764,
0.32768917083740234,
0.6970236301422119,
0.464691162109375,
0.23384013772010803,
0.7118896245956421,
0.5184096097946167,
0.4861747622489929,
0.3419213891029358,
1.0532573461532593,
-0.18246883153915405,
0.16150020062923431,
1.725723385810852,
-0.964937150478363,
1.1903012990951538,
0.5925316214561462,
-0.2545163929462433,
0.8141676783561707,
0.5045832395553589,
-0.11366260051727295,
0.5554444789886475,
0.18113628029823303,
-0.21123963594436646,
-0.46868446469306946,
-0.25503015518188477,
-0.5061792135238647,
0.10015421360731125,
0.4744280278682709,
-0.5097010135650635,
0.09272751212120056,
0.01586037129163742,
-0.2445046305656433,
0.09803580492734909,
-0.14352671802043915,
1.064074993133545,
0.14729396998882294,
-0.5545425415039062,
0.29122763872146606,
-0.04945062845945358,
1.0826715230941772,
-0.8860123753547668,
-0.19670476019382477,
-0.015193133614957333,
0.34520089626312256,
-0.13148386776447296,
-0.8014229536056519,
-0.17869509756565094,
-0.13677020370960236,
-0.3280501365661621,
-0.25935932993888855,
0.858834981918335,
-0.5022369027137756,
-0.7126621603965759,
0.6243990659713745,
0.3467128574848175,
-0.1430080085992813,
-0.021869542077183723,
-0.5220755934715271,
0.11208130419254303,
-0.0595698244869709,
-0.29629459977149963,
0.4892350435256958,
0.12746237218379974,
0.014516969211399555,
0.9737581014633179,
0.7459113597869873,
0.17200732231140137,
-0.35842037200927734,
0.39042872190475464,
0.7609962821006775,
-0.6579950451850891,
-0.593926727771759,
-0.9164026975631714,
0.417366087436676,
-0.18755117058753967,
0.21038776636123657,
0.9507701396942139,
0.4899302124977112,
0.8313021659851074,
0.030486805364489555,
0.6905514597892761,
0.22790676355361938,
0.7949427366256714,
-0.3913869261741638,
0.4659259617328644,
-0.5931991934776306,
0.9409742951393127,
-0.35145923495292664,
-0.8675625324249268,
-0.006294691003859043,
0.31737327575683594,
-0.5536337494850159,
0.24944110214710236,
0.448513925075531,
0.7547144293785095,
0.07111303508281708,
-0.14840441942214966,
0.3759537637233734,
0.3970332741737366,
0.0774720087647438,
0.4570169746875763,
1.0774133205413818,
-0.09818878024816513,
0.2747158110141754,
-0.18836745619773865,
-0.10563083738088608,
-0.35394054651260376,
-0.8488481044769287,
-0.859163224697113,
-0.6018233299255371,
-0.28706416487693787,
-0.45074939727783203,
0.2179754674434662,
1.3282179832458496,
0.5917431116104126,
-0.6845493316650391,
-0.41037315130233765,
0.33339831233024597,
0.14475472271442413,
0.11801372468471527,
-0.21046759188175201,
0.38250017166137695,
-0.03256966546177864,
-0.6833983063697815,
0.48621290922164917,
0.4211365580558777,
0.05283230543136597,
-0.38448047637939453,
-0.09553997963666916,
-0.21120001375675201,
-0.012625308707356453,
0.9601176977157593,
-0.11828478425741196,
-0.7818441987037659,
-0.3063112497329712,
-0.10345254838466644,
0.18755139410495758,
-0.12840896844863892,
0.8264369964599609,
-0.9333937764167786,
0.523666501045227,
0.436726450920105,
0.38021522760391235,
0.5912303328514099,
0.043446462601423264,
0.6591566801071167,
-0.4044654667377472,
0.08810831606388092,
0.006125740706920624,
0.6604772210121155,
0.2795608341693878,
-0.5233484506607056,
0.44379305839538574,
-0.03095332533121109,
-0.5792683362960815,
-0.7492297291755676,
0.3009033501148224,
-1.069106101989746,
-0.32300540804862976,
1.3155608177185059,
-0.06262537837028503,
0.21949809789657593,
-0.2306860387325287,
-0.3538680076599121,
-0.18978025019168854,
-0.888499915599823,
0.6439322829246521,
0.6556131839752197,
-0.07782420516014099,
0.04264039173722267,
-0.14129643142223358,
0.16232576966285706,
0.4425468444824219,
-0.28516140580177307,
0.30234676599502563,
0.7511469125747681,
0.3922586143016815,
-0.11055988818407059,
0.5652989149093628,
-0.025373749434947968,
-0.22093439102172852,
-0.46805569529533386,
-0.2526126205921173,
-0.2329530119895935,
-0.45710518956184387,
-0.286603182554245,
0.08893994987010956,
0.3686661422252655,
0.1811879575252533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20628v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20628v1
|
ToxVidLLM: A Multimodal LLM-based Framework for Toxicity Detection in Code-Mixed Videos
| 2024-05-31T05:40:56
| 2024-05-31T05:40:56
|
Krishanu Maity, A. S. Poornash, Sriparna Saha, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
In an era of rapidly evolving internet technology, the surge in multimodal
content, including videos, has expanded the horizons of online communication.
However, the detection of toxic content in this diverse landscape, particularly
in low-resource code-mixed languages, remains a critical challenge. While
substantial research has addressed toxic content detection in textual data, the
realm of video content, especially in non-English languages, has been
relatively underexplored. This paper addresses this research gap by introducing
a benchmark dataset, the first of its kind, consisting of 931 videos with 4021
code-mixed Hindi-English utterances collected from YouTube. Each utterance
within this dataset has been meticulously annotated for toxicity, severity, and
sentiment labels. We have developed an advanced Multimodal Multitask framework
built for Toxicity detection in Video Content by leveraging Large Language
Models (LLMs), crafted for the primary objective along with the additional
tasks of conducting sentiment and severity analysis. ToxVidLLM incorporates
three key modules the Encoder module, Cross-Modal Synchronization module, and
Multitask module crafting a generic multimodal LLM customized for intricate
video classification tasks. Our experiments reveal that incorporating multiple
modalities from the videos substantially enhances the performance of toxic
content detection by achieving an Accuracy and Weighted F1 score of 94.29% and
94.35%, respectively.
|
[
-0.04289670288562775,
-0.6511395573616028,
0.42866799235343933,
0.5948265194892883,
-0.31039053201675415,
0.12530307471752167,
-0.2653551995754242,
-0.10778201371431351,
-0.0264429971575737,
0.41291892528533936,
-0.6268619298934937,
-0.9216855764389038,
-0.7484099268913269,
0.03356142342090607,
-0.46704283356666565,
1.1390904188156128,
-0.049146298319101334,
0.04563155025243759,
-0.3605557382106781,
-0.47073042392730713,
-0.2737123668193817,
-0.2563337981700897,
-0.4905416965484619,
-0.05909574404358864,
0.7568071484565735,
0.48088088631629944,
0.6262170672416687,
0.36402302980422974,
0.31441745162010193,
0.3526565432548523,
-0.04311370104551315,
0.3458763360977173,
-0.5935818552970886,
0.24884769320487976,
-0.2571008503437042,
-0.3839341998100281,
-0.2272859513759613,
-0.30969399213790894,
0.3832531273365021,
-0.2344881296157837,
-0.01324463076889515,
0.26433345675468445,
-0.16932950913906097,
0.29030945897102356,
-1.0686367750167847,
0.1780160665512085,
-0.3794417977333069,
0.44501930475234985,
-0.2548410892486572,
-0.7322395443916321,
-0.6721796989440918,
-0.11649655550718307,
-0.4497951567173004,
-0.41707944869995117,
-0.46569108963012695,
-0.10084552317857742,
0.3244996666908264,
0.5673717260360718,
-0.8133105635643005,
-0.30120849609375,
-0.43648600578308105,
1.038316011428833,
-0.6901029348373413,
0.5197511911392212,
0.2618224024772644,
0.11157532781362534,
0.1821068972349167,
-0.4181373417377472,
-0.536217212677002,
-0.18145371973514557,
0.21287648379802704,
0.29947879910469055,
-0.18900179862976074,
0.14612993597984314,
0.11121519654989243,
0.2800463140010834,
-0.8470894694328308,
0.19743643701076508,
0.08198652416467667,
-0.505969762802124,
0.5599538087844849,
0.33297693729400635,
0.8057697415351868,
-0.5768527984619141,
-0.7302200198173523,
-0.04317722097039223,
-0.3226936161518097,
0.015470221638679504,
0.39807939529418945,
-0.011531584896147251,
-0.31756797432899475,
0.6227188110351562,
0.06470441073179245,
0.26960688829421997,
-0.4246751070022583,
-0.6085924506187439,
0.3666441738605499,
-0.571965217590332,
-0.22164089977741241,
-0.04100910574197769,
1.01108717918396,
0.7563704252243042,
0.05902448296546936,
0.032858189195394516,
-0.05065291374921799,
0.47958919405937195,
0.25436142086982727,
-0.9709343910217285,
-0.2514580190181732,
0.17007139325141907,
-0.5932075381278992,
-0.4127877950668335,
-0.4159185588359833,
-1.0939722061157227,
-0.5694672465324402,
0.1025785282254219,
0.5773093104362488,
-0.27879446744918823,
-0.7026011943817139,
0.07022324204444885,
-0.021244019269943237,
0.11983524262905121,
0.14139945805072784,
-0.4753541350364685,
0.08952905237674713,
0.4250486195087433,
0.8763024806976318,
-0.5988749265670776,
-0.15049825608730316,
-0.6955844163894653,
0.14132645726203918,
-0.17870083451271057,
0.9320722818374634,
-0.6471952199935913,
-0.28312015533447266,
0.27248209714889526,
-0.06093867868185043,
0.20685258507728577,
-0.8033893704414368,
0.6180660724639893,
-0.4193028509616852,
-0.00505490368232131,
-0.1409161537885666,
-0.14916624128818512,
-0.25922518968582153,
0.6654338240623474,
-0.5856343507766724,
1.1451295614242554,
0.007730069570243359,
-0.7127971053123474,
0.36093059182167053,
-0.4110127389431,
-0.5265909433364868,
-0.09747875481843948,
-0.012875803746283054,
-0.5142751932144165,
-0.24529249966144562,
-0.09420670568943024,
0.3771175444126129,
-0.18568375706672668,
0.29739680886268616,
-0.5253297686576843,
-0.16569410264492035,
0.41464555263519287,
-0.723080039024353,
0.4844415783882141,
0.5238645672798157,
-0.08573353290557861,
0.5451536774635315,
-0.543487012386322,
0.2470950484275818,
-0.2907838225364685,
-0.5483481287956238,
-0.2239387184381485,
0.1365858018398285,
0.647993266582489,
0.7644107341766357,
-0.2746616303920746,
-0.4751306176185608,
-0.5663183927536011,
0.3432033658027649,
0.38580992817878723,
0.7294797301292419,
-0.010235833935439587,
0.10986185818910599,
-0.40623682737350464,
0.6885133981704712,
0.23995903134346008,
0.42791542410850525,
-0.21493740379810333,
-0.4347393810749054,
-0.5092306137084961,
-0.36104512214660645,
-0.40911442041397095,
0.598884642124176,
-0.933940052986145,
0.13751783967018127,
-0.190857395529747,
-0.32020023465156555,
-0.10660721361637115,
0.388266921043396,
0.6642167568206787,
0.36011162400245667,
0.5625361204147339,
-0.40638822317123413,
-0.3748117685317993,
-0.5196331143379211,
-0.09951242059469223,
-0.2281285971403122,
0.19319230318069458,
0.5164501667022705,
0.3487463891506195,
-0.43130967020988464,
0.46710464358329773,
-0.4473569393157959,
-0.7225215435028076,
0.008821886964142323,
0.08885785192251205,
-0.23093962669372559,
0.08797918260097504,
0.5133198499679565,
-0.7395703196525574,
-0.7820549607276917,
0.04552921652793884,
-1.0769790410995483,
-0.20923958718776703,
0.00412268890067935,
-0.00695485295727849,
-0.19503845274448395,
0.6269104480743408,
0.0036936872638761997,
0.0009479903383180499,
0.9331061244010925,
-0.16744080185890198,
0.5068922638893127,
0.0282864011824131,
0.5667922496795654,
-1.0196455717086792,
-0.18724745512008667,
0.45772626996040344,
-0.4075632095336914,
-0.6382498145103455,
0.015384244732558727,
0.13205227255821228,
-0.15107688307762146,
-1.2340476512908936,
0.328413724899292,
-0.04363560676574707,
0.2534811496734619,
-0.148423969745636,
-0.07429338246583939,
-0.16421696543693542,
0.6898149847984314,
0.12701807916164398,
0.9740480780601501,
0.4562702476978302,
-0.328801691532135,
0.638526976108551,
0.204433411359787,
-0.17982074618339539,
0.8093423843383789,
-0.1546115279197693,
-0.20210005342960358,
-0.2365734875202179,
-0.05518246442079544,
-1.054063081741333,
-0.11282504349946976,
0.13264651596546173,
-0.3981243669986725,
0.017248230054974556,
-0.19226686656475067,
-0.6934677362442017,
0.07563991099596024,
-0.6684148907661438,
0.810003399848938,
0.244656503200531,
-0.420231431722641,
0.515338122844696,
0.6619385480880737,
-0.15226233005523682,
-0.46484848856925964,
-0.7877910733222961,
0.23349642753601074,
-0.45681217312812805,
-0.8670095801353455,
0.1081545501947403,
-0.5055591464042664,
-0.03850920870900154,
-0.03547422215342522,
-0.2294861376285553,
-0.6104390621185303,
-0.3176080882549286,
0.367557555437088,
0.05090427026152611,
-0.1444055289030075,
0.08161663264036179,
0.12179145216941833,
-0.05445309728384018,
0.39049750566482544,
0.33515897393226624,
0.2926332652568817,
0.08414478600025177,
-0.2617478668689728,
-0.22777479887008667,
0.5955530405044556,
0.6997472047805786,
-0.28525325655937195,
0.1948757916688919,
0.8672735691070557,
-0.167552188038826,
-0.43346232175827026,
-0.41308555006980896,
0.1695680171251297,
-0.5520185232162476,
0.7560235261917114,
0.18569594621658325,
-0.8037848472595215,
0.46673697233200073,
-0.16676588356494904,
-0.42572903633117676,
-0.04327579587697983,
0.793222963809967,
0.14706096053123474,
1.0858986377716064,
0.3342782258987427,
-0.22467045485973358,
0.6449698209762573,
-0.14651831984519958,
0.043788157403469086,
-0.544038712978363,
-0.401726633310318,
-0.05165928229689598,
0.012901443056762218,
-0.45464587211608887,
-0.7287837266921997,
0.7265135049819946,
-0.5047860741615295,
-0.37002819776535034,
-0.017763566225767136,
-0.20087510347366333,
0.609621524810791,
0.00986165925860405,
0.4869973659515381,
0.589458703994751,
0.030628617852926254,
-0.04758445546030998,
-0.28592556715011597,
-0.5596292018890381,
-0.21937055885791779,
0.971086859703064,
0.41414138674736023,
0.9428694248199463,
0.4802859425544739,
0.2099536508321762,
0.713934063911438,
0.49296990036964417,
-0.826628565788269,
0.6336212754249573,
-0.5071374177932739,
-0.6785010695457458,
0.2969726324081421,
-0.2904256582260132,
-0.2894187271595001,
0.09119708091020584,
-0.3272246718406677,
-0.16896174848079681,
-0.21767489612102509,
-0.08449974656105042,
-0.33687931299209595,
0.4232599437236786,
-0.8111019730567932,
1.0187194347381592,
-0.5163770914077759,
-0.9776953458786011,
-0.3650662899017334,
-0.45176345109939575,
0.7047197818756104,
-0.054340120404958725,
0.6204870343208313,
-0.20995748043060303,
-0.20378930866718292,
0.4686529040336609,
-0.3102288246154785,
0.7720093727111816,
0.05370591580867767,
-0.3096330761909485,
0.36322903633117676,
0.09219285845756531,
0.16989830136299133,
0.6238576173782349,
0.11786480993032455,
0.16474728286266327,
-0.1626189649105072,
-0.10204340517520905,
-0.10123308002948761,
0.8910387754440308,
-0.6310251951217651,
-0.17821606993675232,
-0.5546351671218872,
-0.6085112690925598,
-0.05475690960884094,
0.21501508355140686,
0.08892064541578293,
0.11456497758626938,
0.1460804045200348,
0.05757877230644226,
1.1409063339233398,
-0.8910577297210693,
0.4937100112438202,
0.4243621826171875,
-0.18255440890789032,
-0.5033404231071472,
1.2540274858474731,
-0.47487351298332214,
0.39873725175857544,
0.2896709144115448,
-0.05269237235188484,
-0.29191330075263977,
-0.5770468711853027,
-0.39776644110679626,
0.12470480799674988,
-0.9491745829582214,
-0.5895332098007202,
-0.534559965133667,
-0.33539408445358276,
-0.00917789340019226,
0.22508838772773743,
-0.47920671105384827,
0.6408575177192688,
-0.36798056960105896,
-0.19855061173439026,
0.4398126006126404,
0.42909327149391174,
-0.06567327678203583,
0.03463977947831154,
-1.0148214101791382,
0.6561864018440247,
0.48763930797576904,
0.8064497113227844,
-0.2252916395664215,
-0.2595657408237457,
0.0030487931799143553,
-0.03931674361228943,
-0.4750106930732727,
-1.080820083618164,
0.466523140668869,
0.24856255948543549,
0.35853084921836853,
0.6173480749130249,
0.006276269908994436,
0.784477174282074,
-0.17737828195095062,
0.7834615707397461,
0.2717888653278351,
-0.8182277679443359,
0.38449519872665405,
-0.4803519546985626,
-0.1242404356598854,
0.31885388493537903,
0.5511007308959961,
-0.8360321521759033,
-0.3285456597805023,
0.2631465494632721,
-0.8100973963737488,
0.46614694595336914,
0.132915198802948,
0.4970606565475464,
-0.1881788671016693,
-0.35536131262779236,
0.21584025025367737,
0.045861706137657166,
-1.1533211469650269,
-0.34229427576065063,
-0.42046022415161133,
-0.13383744657039642,
0.04687286540865898,
-0.42840829491615295,
0.11921799182891846,
-0.21883967518806458,
0.3047918379306793,
-0.06373118609189987,
0.1948138177394867,
-0.19802407920360565,
-0.7116111516952515,
-0.37736210227012634,
0.5496641993522644,
0.5911144614219666,
0.16980460286140442,
-0.2842123508453369,
0.2917504608631134,
0.09621270000934601,
-0.4824139177799225,
0.31176260113716125,
-0.20463377237319946,
0.08411996066570282,
-0.17463606595993042,
0.3949986398220062,
0.5504226684570312,
0.4532400965690613,
-1.2598965167999268,
0.7712950110435486,
-0.03735988214612007,
-0.2009422481060028,
-0.33816635608673096,
0.01579536683857441,
-0.08162232488393784,
0.24537673592567444,
0.10806313157081604,
0.052652083337306976,
0.34589675068855286,
-0.7647656202316284,
0.46200045943260193,
0.36724987626075745,
-0.5740853548049927,
-0.29763439297676086,
0.8707996606826782,
0.31717395782470703,
0.14351317286491394,
0.3814038336277008,
-0.22125853598117828,
-0.4965527355670929,
0.2887791097164154,
0.22198286652565002,
0.6738849878311157,
-0.13286632299423218,
0.5073999762535095,
0.23468275368213654,
0.09200328588485718,
-0.054743751883506775,
0.44921669363975525,
0.0355890616774559,
-0.7034732103347778,
-0.641282856464386,
-0.6688553094863892,
-0.04574431851506233,
0.22631019353866577,
-0.494232714176178,
0.34608811140060425,
-0.34933117032051086,
-0.02548976242542267,
-0.01976105570793152,
-0.37581682205200195,
-0.31648436188697815,
0.2742585241794586,
0.3521924614906311,
0.5774750113487244,
-1.4509248733520508,
0.7368306517601013,
0.6456458568572998,
-0.6064637899398804,
-0.48103708028793335,
-0.3072468340396881,
0.278754860162735,
-0.6423844695091248,
0.5606013536453247,
0.14238567650318146,
-0.025541696697473526,
-0.1036234200000763,
-0.05070137232542038,
-0.4259895086288452,
0.8961079120635986,
0.2459920346736908,
0.0024789972230792046,
0.031175948679447174,
0.5159616470336914,
0.5635309219360352,
0.03517111390829086,
0.6497854590415955,
0.17815034091472626,
0.43953242897987366,
0.17356334626674652,
-0.8166947364807129,
-0.0175030380487442,
-0.6877768635749817,
-0.06195235252380371,
0.09341398626565933,
-0.611890971660614,
0.8323655724525452,
-0.056316521018743515,
-0.2244592010974884,
-0.2907332479953766,
0.2124345451593399,
0.07714299857616425,
0.5943403840065002,
0.44858500361442566,
0.6122857928276062,
0.028004460036754608,
0.2383774369955063,
0.6267730593681335,
-0.023388046771287918,
0.3315683901309967,
0.7818601727485657,
-0.22856710851192474,
0.730516254901886,
0.5517791509628296,
-0.1850195974111557,
0.5146430134773254,
0.6126702427864075,
-0.04241204261779785,
0.6649443507194519,
0.1345466673374176,
-0.5771747827529907,
-0.5233405828475952,
-0.5772542953491211,
-0.21267516911029816,
0.3386234939098358,
0.3899015784263611,
-0.4218427836894989,
-0.5615836381912231,
0.5185125470161438,
-0.044070832431316376,
0.4077480137348175,
-0.6174377799034119,
0.8744425773620605,
0.04691029712557793,
-0.5212762951850891,
0.4722067713737488,
-0.1372179090976715,
1.1993008852005005,
-0.549360990524292,
-0.03499946370720863,
-0.12294424325227737,
0.3160955309867859,
-0.5154406428337097,
-1.079017162322998,
0.5347732901573181,
0.15355104207992554,
-0.1515599638223648,
-0.4308864176273346,
0.6735734939575195,
-0.6104055047035217,
-0.21906858682632446,
0.7127736210823059,
0.29960358142852783,
-0.08105932176113129,
-0.29339703917503357,
-0.5679494142532349,
0.4493430256843567,
-0.09972850978374481,
0.1750413030385971,
0.49788686633110046,
0.25066304206848145,
-0.19643746316432953,
0.7932403683662415,
0.5063804984092712,
-0.0021459630224853754,
0.35361769795417786,
-0.05666100233793259,
1.0036667585372925,
-0.49447008967399597,
-0.21887409687042236,
-0.7623991370201111,
0.6923415064811707,
0.18646980822086334,
-0.09292279928922653,
0.7675407528877258,
0.831697404384613,
1.0018216371536255,
-0.24377484619617462,
0.8435049057006836,
0.021210215985774994,
-0.15881839394569397,
-0.5239090323448181,
0.6492350101470947,
-0.7677662968635559,
0.18441976606845856,
-0.3278563916683197,
-0.5990992784500122,
-0.33554065227508545,
0.29921120405197144,
0.2875763773918152,
0.021826716139912605,
0.911605715751648,
1.2244473695755005,
-0.14040474593639374,
-0.27772387862205505,
0.3893391788005829,
0.2067740261554718,
0.2988252341747284,
0.9007404446601868,
0.9002892374992371,
-0.4137566387653351,
1.0585415363311768,
-0.3898741900920868,
-0.13794147968292236,
-0.1395195573568344,
-1.0678110122680664,
-1.026081919670105,
-0.4742961525917053,
-0.453622043132782,
-0.39411526918411255,
-0.03019791655242443,
0.8243043422698975,
0.6608986854553223,
-0.7540438771247864,
-0.2632928490638733,
0.3246469795703888,
0.23223593831062317,
-0.12535877525806427,
-0.19554394483566284,
-0.1723531037569046,
-0.1533745974302292,
-0.5837489366531372,
0.21717898547649384,
0.6747890710830688,
-0.41348013281822205,
-0.21422167122364044,
-0.3226880729198456,
-0.2766498923301697,
-0.09492325782775879,
1.0385551452636719,
0.17544199526309967,
-0.4977860152721405,
-0.2892715334892273,
0.28174710273742676,
-0.15484394133090973,
0.2583414316177368,
0.7766544818878174,
-0.29416313767433167,
0.6380773186683655,
0.6322397589683533,
0.26729804277420044,
0.554154634475708,
-0.17771229147911072,
0.08618797361850739,
-0.9870674014091492,
0.07400227338075638,
0.15298818051815033,
0.12205392122268677,
0.31009408831596375,
-0.29225125908851624,
0.2266138792037964,
0.16405487060546875,
-0.3295832574367523,
-0.877212643623352,
0.23223444819450378,
-1.3470038175582886,
-0.2501509487628937,
1.588378667831421,
-0.10140345990657806,
-0.0949469804763794,
-0.24651673436164856,
-0.19516493380069733,
0.3197038173675537,
-0.4566458761692047,
0.773600697517395,
0.5388755202293396,
0.12133900076150894,
-0.5721716284751892,
-0.7900381684303284,
0.4609164893627167,
0.27471810579299927,
-1.0701348781585693,
-0.0555000901222229,
0.49297764897346497,
0.7442701458930969,
-0.038513995707035065,
0.49537137150764465,
-0.3257116973400116,
0.47300705313682556,
-0.3480592668056488,
-0.11229147762060165,
-0.21931111812591553,
-0.0973038449883461,
-0.18493476510047913,
0.2478320300579071,
-0.11535429954528809,
-0.04686035215854645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20624v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20624v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Entity Matching
| 2024-05-31T05:22:07
| 2024-05-31T05:22:07
|
Qianyu Huang, Tongfang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity matching (EM) is a critical task in data integration, aiming to
identify records across different datasets that refer to the same real-world
entities. Traditional methods often rely on manually engineered features and
rule-based systems, which struggle with diverse and unstructured data. The
emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-4 offers transformative
potential for EM, leveraging their advanced semantic understanding and
contextual capabilities. This vision paper explores the application of LLMs to
EM, discussing their advantages, challenges, and future research directions.
Additionally, we review related work on applying weak supervision and
unsupervised approaches to EM, highlighting how LLMs can enhance these methods.
|
[
-0.40890103578567505,
-0.6071302890777588,
1.0863507986068726,
0.10294682532548904,
-0.22607174515724182,
-0.0912175327539444,
-0.27308177947998047,
-0.8033963441848755,
-0.05071041360497475,
0.8985170722007751,
-0.2816114127635956,
-0.5961225628852844,
-0.43835213780403137,
0.33240368962287903,
-0.6773447394371033,
0.7483788132667542,
-0.3985440731048584,
-0.061108097434043884,
-0.13854029774665833,
0.011414662003517151,
-0.6261272430419922,
-0.5668853521347046,
-0.5566352009773254,
-0.32752928137779236,
0.33014675974845886,
0.2791610062122345,
0.5687280297279358,
0.8010623455047607,
0.6204023957252502,
0.3080928921699524,
0.18895743787288666,
0.08877497911453247,
-0.3872855007648468,
0.24100519716739655,
-0.3322368562221527,
-0.5879690051078796,
-0.5204698443412781,
-0.09360549598932266,
0.8109871745109558,
0.8011329174041748,
-0.2531823217868805,
-0.010178115218877792,
0.06146811321377754,
0.1776871681213379,
-0.36230504512786865,
0.3489447832107544,
-0.9741933941841125,
-0.004034487996250391,
-0.5676494240760803,
-0.21100768446922302,
-0.28573352098464966,
-0.0009919069707393646,
0.21911977231502533,
-0.533775806427002,
0.3411519229412079,
0.35498860478401184,
1.0021095275878906,
0.26516178250312805,
-0.7516241669654846,
-0.39512312412261963,
-0.7814613580703735,
0.6272062063217163,
-0.7085427045822144,
0.5973328948020935,
0.23358836770057678,
0.18859270215034485,
-0.383950412273407,
-0.7523267865180969,
-0.643602728843689,
0.14667506515979767,
-0.021216226741671562,
-0.10349065810441971,
-0.042254868894815445,
0.1576777696609497,
0.3046882152557373,
0.5076416730880737,
-0.3925963044166565,
0.47747328877449036,
-0.06471231579780579,
-0.041773006319999695,
0.3994905650615692,
0.21210049092769623,
0.537124514579773,
0.11121387034654617,
-0.46238529682159424,
0.3102341890335083,
-0.954014778137207,
-0.6869709491729736,
0.24165885150432587,
0.5414451956748962,
0.15839745104312897,
0.8030934929847717,
0.11098279803991318,
0.6615548133850098,
-0.05998408421874046,
-0.057497911155223846,
-0.004112340975552797,
-0.408968448638916,
-0.4238247871398926,
0.10774582624435425,
0.690190315246582,
0.4047919511795044,
0.348445326089859,
-0.410078763961792,
-0.4274332523345947,
0.12759476900100708,
-0.06480905413627625,
-0.7000885009765625,
-0.07292397320270538,
-0.1641039252281189,
-0.34701159596443176,
0.14205226302146912,
-0.13476550579071045,
-0.9753038883209229,
-0.21450898051261902,
-0.6365454196929932,
0.23647066950798035,
-0.19787652790546417,
-0.35682404041290283,
0.11547651886940002,
0.1320568323135376,
0.7036150097846985,
0.34510964155197144,
-1.105376958847046,
0.4400983452796936,
0.9509446620941162,
1.008416771888733,
-0.1341180056333542,
-0.17454324662685394,
-0.3217872977256775,
0.5036807656288147,
-0.4419407546520233,
0.6447612047195435,
-0.6756875514984131,
-0.1792515516281128,
0.11010225862264633,
0.19356389343738556,
-0.042446237057447433,
-0.637033998966217,
0.8350027799606323,
-0.7780844569206238,
0.06547687202692032,
-0.30079928040504456,
-0.8834564685821533,
-0.0746685191988945,
0.07334857434034348,
-0.7487494945526123,
0.8415785431861877,
0.20613068342208862,
-0.5819351673126221,
0.5603544116020203,
-0.4633290469646454,
-0.3871018588542938,
0.2535976469516754,
-0.1987677663564682,
-0.4752138555049896,
0.14479616284370422,
0.34751972556114197,
0.6989791393280029,
-0.6326372623443604,
0.17569896578788757,
-0.639263927936554,
-0.3740057051181793,
-0.24098604917526245,
-0.1439530998468399,
0.37911972403526306,
0.23029635846614838,
-0.3117191195487976,
-0.23932328820228577,
-0.4317046105861664,
-0.12407685816287994,
0.34013262391090393,
-0.28028404712677,
-0.6973861455917358,
0.05603867024183273,
0.1842058151960373,
0.26971763372421265,
0.169278085231781,
-0.26145872473716736,
0.26356106996536255,
-0.2914578318595886,
0.6279958486557007,
0.5434150099754333,
-0.0772860124707222,
0.5732232928276062,
-0.04142123460769653,
0.43650463223457336,
0.04137003794312477,
-0.3188755512237549,
-0.1995495855808258,
-0.3121371865272522,
-0.36225855350494385,
-0.4186785817146301,
0.4200574457645416,
0.597087562084198,
-0.8918545842170715,
0.31828200817108154,
-0.287955105304718,
-0.22148548066616058,
-0.6348670125007629,
0.40967583656311035,
0.060012102127075195,
0.32945963740348816,
0.5542439222335815,
-0.15105561912059784,
-0.6977356672286987,
-0.9948668479919434,
-0.2201436311006546,
0.17892499268054962,
-0.27036044001579285,
0.4132513105869293,
0.36897343397140503,
-0.4571591913700104,
0.7129986882209778,
-0.23760385811328888,
-0.6578373908996582,
-0.136581689119339,
-0.4484783113002777,
0.32230550050735474,
0.34975263476371765,
0.7010960578918457,
-0.8010809421539307,
-0.4402996897697449,
0.2126094549894333,
-0.9888873100280762,
-0.24338990449905396,
0.07173973321914673,
-0.06810903549194336,
-0.13331492245197296,
0.5749617218971252,
-0.7852849960327148,
-0.14628544449806213,
0.7732179164886475,
-0.39194434881210327,
0.09268736094236374,
-0.09901570528745651,
0.3640844523906708,
-1.3182997703552246,
-0.27462396025657654,
0.35864436626434326,
-0.3726568818092346,
-0.5985987186431885,
0.13154585659503937,
0.19954395294189453,
-0.22362452745437622,
-0.2810520827770233,
0.42022639513015747,
-1.075478434562683,
-0.49215173721313477,
-0.22743836045265198,
0.5066977143287659,
-0.06046752631664276,
-0.049313273280858994,
-0.14371946454048157,
0.8131117224693298,
0.8023936748504639,
-0.4430539608001709,
0.5915456414222717,
0.31912732124328613,
-0.3546437919139862,
0.8394793272018433,
-0.563868522644043,
0.25680291652679443,
-0.024296259507536888,
0.2660020887851715,
-0.4741446375846863,
-0.42080777883529663,
-0.06461664289236069,
0.20648765563964844,
0.6904991269111633,
-0.4741874039173126,
-0.7577784061431885,
-0.3864476680755615,
-0.11507221311330795,
0.6482651829719543,
0.36860042810440063,
-0.8063768744468689,
0.9725285172462463,
0.5643315315246582,
-0.2722857892513275,
-0.4562012553215027,
-0.6445176005363464,
0.5503416061401367,
-0.6608657240867615,
-0.5877459049224854,
0.5885393023490906,
0.2551533877849579,
-0.2931671440601349,
0.12306415289640427,
-0.04624125361442566,
-0.03943764045834541,
0.13918732106685638,
0.07954850792884827,
0.42019736766815186,
-0.5134930610656738,
-0.07441631704568863,
-0.09470520913600922,
0.10499324649572372,
-0.038885582238435745,
-0.3526010811328888,
0.29569554328918457,
0.0926823765039444,
-0.4232988655567169,
-0.31760895252227783,
0.541767418384552,
0.6282386779785156,
-0.3356543779373169,
0.6135725378990173,
0.25299808382987976,
-0.5927057266235352,
-0.18677130341529846,
-0.7644036412239075,
-0.03789563104510307,
-0.45476508140563965,
0.5431310534477234,
-0.5842359662055969,
-1.111169695854187,
0.47174686193466187,
-0.2520429790019989,
-0.12901322543621063,
0.24246807396411896,
0.7178804874420166,
0.12730462849140167,
0.9406241774559021,
0.6947699785232544,
-0.37039801478385925,
0.5211930871009827,
0.28891605138778687,
0.3572058379650116,
-0.8929041624069214,
-0.036779794842004776,
-0.558465301990509,
-0.06026265397667885,
-0.8381776213645935,
-0.4337565004825592,
-0.12982586026191711,
0.15057620406150818,
-0.07030940800905228,
0.45765775442123413,
-0.3495030701160431,
0.7198393940925598,
0.3338644504547119,
-0.16729234158992767,
0.39960989356040955,
-0.45980560779571533,
0.18072795867919922,
0.0019194495398551226,
-0.3038803040981293,
-0.7384842038154602,
1.2012876272201538,
0.5236688256263733,
0.9496925473213196,
0.3466247618198395,
0.6101463437080383,
-0.000016068905097199604,
0.4918094575405121,
-0.6462275385856628,
0.6183443665504456,
-0.01633513532578945,
-0.5693507194519043,
-0.2131415754556656,
-0.6008192300796509,
-1.0890405178070068,
0.296593576669693,
-0.34159785509109497,
-0.6317309737205505,
0.01870747096836567,
0.12706972658634186,
-0.0069259521551430225,
0.42010876536369324,
-1.063804030418396,
0.7772907018661499,
-0.2694782316684723,
-0.1472250521183014,
0.3107444941997528,
-0.2367284893989563,
0.5611067414283752,
-0.5472581386566162,
0.2403750717639923,
-0.2149585634469986,
-0.1775599867105484,
0.5557566285133362,
0.011593017727136612,
0.3508266806602478,
-0.07226008921861649,
-0.5208113789558411,
0.07973436266183853,
0.01911379210650921,
0.7638764381408691,
0.09772917628288269,
0.04022054746747017,
0.3126242160797119,
0.008958681486546993,
-0.4150215983390808,
-0.40526261925697327,
1.1968379020690918,
-0.4872112274169922,
-0.73356032371521,
-0.17957481741905212,
-0.508642852306366,
-0.2500757575035095,
0.36768287420272827,
-0.08883465826511383,
0.03365699201822281,
-0.15167640149593353,
0.09701650589704514,
0.6983875632286072,
0.021513868123292923,
0.43461689352989197,
0.5330994725227356,
-0.30731862783432007,
-0.03622262179851532,
0.5215162634849548,
0.054318953305482864,
0.09883638471364975,
0.34912896156311035,
-0.3952973484992981,
-0.5010276436805725,
-0.7714861631393433,
-0.3420239984989166,
0.4970770478248596,
-0.6551306843757629,
-0.4056626856327057,
-0.6458264589309692,
0.32730832695961,
-0.30005377531051636,
-0.007088654208928347,
-0.2573695182800293,
0.251161128282547,
-0.31920233368873596,
-0.09582971781492233,
0.07906702905893326,
0.9295299053192139,
0.33081910014152527,
-0.10989023000001907,
-0.7409594058990479,
0.20594243705272675,
0.4146219789981842,
0.6866084337234497,
-0.32724449038505554,
-0.2990438938140869,
-0.030168598517775536,
-0.3127061724662781,
-0.04692992568016052,
-1.0822585821151733,
0.14567743241786957,
0.2671315371990204,
0.5859488844871521,
0.06607261300086975,
-0.17859601974487305,
0.4643303453922272,
-0.9879783391952515,
0.5231937170028687,
-0.11305947601795197,
-1.0298610925674438,
0.36951392889022827,
-0.45813530683517456,
-0.22504407167434692,
0.2292030155658722,
0.42271044850349426,
-0.3371833264827728,
-0.2825039029121399,
-0.25428834557533264,
-1.0661163330078125,
0.4493474066257477,
0.15114298462867737,
0.2322784811258316,
-0.17695850133895874,
0.6630127429962158,
-0.28718218207359314,
0.08434881269931793,
-0.7370008826255798,
0.026872167363762856,
0.1033337190747261,
-0.5292806029319763,
-0.212187722325325,
-0.096086785197258,
0.09176231920719147,
0.2520892322063446,
0.568499743938446,
-0.20718975365161896,
0.34532028436660767,
-0.04000374674797058,
-0.20051206648349762,
-0.16614383459091187,
0.38101834058761597,
0.4093088209629059,
0.47445839643478394,
0.08812256157398224,
0.17076526582241058,
0.46270331740379333,
-0.10848717391490936,
0.05079641565680504,
0.35583606362342834,
0.01593778096139431,
-0.0821867510676384,
0.4364132285118103,
0.6425725221633911,
0.3300236165523529,
-0.5526204109191895,
0.5290277004241943,
-0.0030925367027521133,
-0.1798831820487976,
-0.24404413998126984,
-0.05333376303315163,
0.3485001027584076,
0.5707482099533081,
0.3868306577205658,
-0.5375770330429077,
0.11930089443922043,
-0.7644709348678589,
0.2394866645336151,
0.6926023960113525,
-0.22161053121089935,
-0.3918953537940979,
0.9483879804611206,
0.08587278425693512,
-0.2673693597316742,
0.5503177642822266,
0.20442873239517212,
-0.4300241470336914,
0.41045647859573364,
0.7748477458953857,
0.5349476337432861,
-0.4135231673717499,
-0.5811854600906372,
-0.056002285331487656,
0.23605160415172577,
-0.47683265805244446,
-0.04323681816458702,
0.314633309841156,
-0.8489152789115906,
-0.7616310715675354,
-0.5493804812431335,
-0.32931387424468994,
0.13072530925273895,
-0.5615819096565247,
0.515126645565033,
-0.1260594129562378,
-0.08070534467697144,
0.1685480922460556,
-0.29559528827667236,
-1.1777980327606201,
0.0193068515509367,
0.27347806096076965,
0.6616221070289612,
-1.0441678762435913,
0.7834575772285461,
0.7557966709136963,
-0.37553325295448303,
-1.0040093660354614,
0.009554117918014526,
0.011492504738271236,
-0.7291288375854492,
0.5547902584075928,
-0.0558134950697422,
0.33710721135139465,
0.3238830268383026,
-0.3713831305503845,
-0.8835334777832031,
1.290457010269165,
0.6210761666297913,
-0.8763245344161987,
-0.41922521591186523,
-0.12546870112419128,
0.5006536841392517,
-0.4463328421115875,
0.31170693039894104,
0.9656659364700317,
0.38630354404449463,
-0.24166592955589294,
-1.119451880455017,
0.31864872574806213,
0.27833303809165955,
0.18703007698059082,
0.7584659457206726,
-0.43069878220558167,
0.7181593179702759,
-0.09993444383144379,
-0.38435783982276917,
-0.09552828967571259,
0.6614324450492859,
-0.025524599477648735,
0.14992882311344147,
0.43961143493652344,
0.7086819410324097,
0.6865644454956055,
-0.35230013728141785,
0.8775738477706909,
-0.26400890946388245,
0.8012234568595886,
1.1262478828430176,
-0.9488075375556946,
0.733104407787323,
0.3978405296802521,
-0.30004778504371643,
0.2684975862503052,
0.5956392884254456,
-0.2794264256954193,
0.3076879382133484,
0.09469079226255417,
-0.2897022068500519,
-0.16535519063472748,
-0.07917217910289764,
-0.27463823556900024,
0.4141307771205902,
0.485757976770401,
-0.4125230014324188,
-0.3826170265674591,
-0.035737860947847366,
-0.15095698833465576,
0.15456116199493408,
-0.40948668122291565,
0.9053589105606079,
0.2964734733104706,
-0.2761780917644501,
0.10425311326980591,
-0.07553478330373764,
0.7119798064231873,
-0.17651215195655823,
-0.25958001613616943,
-0.00605500303208828,
0.004275310318917036,
-0.08937423676252365,
-0.9669017195701599,
0.06594467163085938,
-0.1121351569890976,
-0.1452411264181137,
-0.15206016600131989,
0.7241116166114807,
-0.6460832357406616,
-0.02446824125945568,
0.6507921814918518,
0.5866498351097107,
-0.02479979209601879,
-0.03241143748164177,
-0.5739075541496277,
-0.07067755609750748,
-0.25328773260116577,
-0.2289954274892807,
0.4740196168422699,
1.0672762393951416,
-0.09978638589382172,
0.5917680263519287,
0.5146214962005615,
0.07292093336582184,
-0.15078991651535034,
0.12607163190841675,
0.7413482666015625,
-0.9078653454780579,
-0.17214176058769226,
-1.0540530681610107,
-0.056424688547849655,
0.014434265904128551,
0.060251835733652115,
0.6970676779747009,
0.6337735056877136,
0.8418979048728943,
0.11742164194583893,
0.7399730682373047,
0.14917171001434326,
0.6055395007133484,
-0.6684878468513489,
0.23900297284126282,
-0.372598797082901,
0.59319669008255,
-0.6542295217514038,
-1.4527188539505005,
-0.34246113896369934,
0.2383822798728943,
-0.24552702903747559,
0.33615562319755554,
0.609663724899292,
0.7078653573989868,
-0.42906004190444946,
-0.2260219305753708,
0.5496248006820679,
0.2312709093093872,
0.5721926093101501,
0.7524083256721497,
0.7906558513641357,
-0.2752031683921814,
0.41949212551116943,
0.38545042276382446,
-0.18073821067810059,
-0.257485955953598,
-0.9437516331672668,
-0.9567885994911194,
-0.5178567171096802,
-0.21622122824192047,
-0.2396671324968338,
0.019358275458216667,
1.0261868238449097,
0.5076936483383179,
-0.6315975785255432,
0.23928377032279968,
0.03611188381910324,
-0.013505863957107067,
0.1650353968143463,
-0.24375537037849426,
0.30294984579086304,
-0.0714280754327774,
-1.0266093015670776,
0.5210967659950256,
0.5198483467102051,
0.4476972222328186,
-0.1012827679514885,
0.20330506563186646,
-0.1042899340391159,
0.04697471484541893,
0.5497545003890991,
0.15875744819641113,
-0.7331705689430237,
-0.5065075755119324,
-0.19877533614635468,
-0.158463716506958,
-0.13053454458713531,
0.8955666422843933,
-0.3773233890533447,
0.0501885823905468,
0.026700807735323906,
1.1021984815597534,
0.5868862271308899,
0.07845524698495865,
0.7064409852027893,
-0.5736953616142273,
-0.05804762616753578,
0.3301677405834198,
0.8394514918327332,
0.6836669445037842,
-0.3997401297092438,
0.6458255052566528,
0.09617125988006592,
-0.9006882309913635,
-0.9652419686317444,
0.3350001871585846,
-0.8481708765029907,
0.05234789475798607,
1.156327247619629,
-0.18068993091583252,
0.007143053226172924,
-0.550879716873169,
-0.029393121600151062,
0.06256705522537231,
-0.1809169054031372,
0.37329214811325073,
0.725716233253479,
0.1331470012664795,
-0.4081237316131592,
-0.900825023651123,
0.3637056350708008,
0.2725716531276703,
-0.9270519018173218,
-0.0175601989030838,
0.4042389690876007,
0.5227059721946716,
-0.0953424945473671,
0.5496142506599426,
-0.030066683888435364,
-0.13393191993236542,
-0.3480049967765808,
0.17446598410606384,
0.2709205746650696,
0.03755972161889076,
-0.22508861124515533,
0.1552332043647766,
0.33616283535957336,
0.12658756971359253
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.20613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.20613v1
|
FineRadScore: A Radiology Report Line-by-Line Evaluation Technique Generating Corrections with Severity Scores
| 2024-05-31T04:05:09
| 2024-05-31T04:05:09
|
Alyssa Huang, Oishi Banerjee, Kay Wu, Eduardo Pontes Reis, Pranav Rajpurkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The current gold standard for evaluating generated chest x-ray (CXR) reports
is through radiologist annotations. However, this process can be extremely
time-consuming and costly, especially when evaluating large numbers of reports.
In this work, we present FineRadScore, a Large Language Model (LLM)-based
automated evaluation metric for generated CXR reports. Given a candidate report
and a ground-truth report, FineRadScore gives the minimum number of
line-by-line corrections required to go from the candidate to the ground-truth
report. Additionally, FineRadScore provides an error severity rating with each
correction and generates comments explaining why the correction was needed. We
demonstrate that FineRadScore's corrections and error severity scores align
with radiologist opinions. We also show that, when used to judge the quality of
the report as a whole, FineRadScore aligns with radiologists as well as current
state-of-the-art automated CXR evaluation metrics. Finally, we analyze
FineRadScore's shortcomings to provide suggestions for future improvements.
|
[
-0.1987115740776062,
-0.4030967652797699,
0.7558850049972534,
-0.05105665698647499,
-0.30890047550201416,
-0.25106436014175415,
-0.18807744979858398,
-0.5695868730545044,
0.013654321432113647,
0.6577323079109192,
-0.32925617694854736,
-0.7579559087753296,
-1.0675266981124878,
0.039786096662282944,
-0.5027111768722534,
1.233980655670166,
0.07217609882354736,
-0.06370928138494492,
-0.3026072084903717,
-0.06969284266233444,
-0.5461710691452026,
-0.17539344727993011,
-0.6015690565109253,
-0.3001551330089569,
0.4558745324611664,
0.626399040222168,
1.2992932796478271,
0.8843269348144531,
1.0756382942199707,
0.30214810371398926,
-0.015071967616677284,
0.4662422835826874,
-0.3764990568161011,
-0.1973804235458374,
-0.03587561473250389,
-0.08258125931024551,
-0.8353756070137024,
-0.12780196964740753,
0.3931278884410858,
0.6114411950111389,
0.0249050073325634,
0.23785467445850372,
-0.16760961711406708,
0.7747700810432434,
-0.5460492968559265,
-0.14003342390060425,
-0.2158927321434021,
0.13116376101970673,
-0.03321303054690361,
-0.6105492115020752,
-0.3116135001182556,
-0.5459458827972412,
0.09584613889455795,
-0.27625763416290283,
0.028687799349427223,
-0.2732824683189392,
0.9000669717788696,
0.2631038725376129,
-0.23622778058052063,
-0.7189546823501587,
-0.5055785775184631,
0.6551569700241089,
-0.5652771592140198,
0.23818065226078033,
0.36178702116012573,
0.6556715965270996,
0.25672096014022827,
-0.8327295184135437,
0.4029039740562439,
-0.3993646204471588,
-0.27631914615631104,
0.04699166119098663,
-0.31819722056388855,
-0.0012536549475044012,
-0.07567671686410904,
0.7018598914146423,
-0.4844096004962921,
0.07308094203472137,
-0.5001726746559143,
-0.13407094776630402,
1.0752720832824707,
0.5126476287841797,
0.16227471828460693,
-0.27674832940101624,
-0.2719438672065735,
-0.21592041850090027,
-0.3021340072154999,
-0.18084703385829926,
-0.11343985795974731,
0.5349664688110352,
-0.14562685787677765,
0.4471442699432373,
-0.37466466426849365,
0.7292465567588806,
0.30003389716148376,
-0.4755939245223999,
0.406703382730484,
0.08190535753965378,
-0.21529218554496765,
0.5707836151123047,
0.7388204336166382,
0.7266190052032471,
-0.12811733782291412,
-0.21952518820762634,
-0.436491996049881,
0.2198447287082672,
0.3606918454170227,
-0.7430474758148193,
-0.0741637572646141,
0.21004754304885864,
-0.6478629112243652,
-0.6571699976921082,
0.019487079232931137,
-0.17296239733695984,
-0.48498430848121643,
-0.4343847930431366,
0.5773894190788269,
-0.4029770493507385,
0.19185978174209595,
0.3604499399662018,
-0.04377848654985428,
-0.02127758227288723,
0.7818096876144409,
-0.08274807035923004,
0.6339694261550903,
0.6769171357154846,
0.865693211555481,
0.17871832847595215,
-0.05462200567126274,
-1.0586618185043335,
-0.1671094000339508,
-0.4161015450954437,
1.477638602256775,
-0.46352916955947876,
-0.6615833640098572,
-0.2975975275039673,
-0.27992236614227295,
0.29107317328453064,
-0.730462372303009,
0.8917071223258972,
-0.20740742981433868,
-0.12747733294963837,
-0.06804365664720535,
-0.5437031984329224,
0.1065874770283699,
0.4872816801071167,
-0.3741318881511688,
0.8272398114204407,
0.4012375771999359,
-0.46088922023773193,
0.43907251954078674,
-0.3272361159324646,
-0.21276818215847015,
0.2253587692975998,
-0.25575631856918335,
-0.4339401125907898,
0.2681155502796173,
0.4105122685432434,
0.3631429076194763,
-0.3090924620628357,
0.13495631515979767,
0.2203521579504013,
-0.46330082416534424,
0.2706252634525299,
-0.1386905461549759,
0.5098851919174194,
0.20323380827903748,
-0.1270051896572113,
0.06119440495967865,
-0.8111879825592041,
0.3007214367389679,
-0.4187263250350952,
-0.36507004499435425,
-0.09726828336715698,
-0.13734760880470276,
-0.04293171688914299,
0.36943134665489197,
0.07426820695400238,
-0.4895671010017395,
0.050073206424713135,
0.03029453568160534,
-0.31816673278808594,
0.7549828886985779,
0.06865609437227249,
-0.0054200878366827965,
-0.7643026113510132,
0.3911636471748352,
-0.0379752516746521,
0.44471800327301025,
0.04906874895095825,
-0.19846698641777039,
-0.6455795764923096,
-0.5028368234634399,
0.18974706530570984,
0.40736737847328186,
0.0443892627954483,
0.6009581685066223,
-0.5734730362892151,
-1.133095622062683,
-0.527861475944519,
0.2056243121623993,
0.6460942625999451,
0.5054084658622742,
0.4634948670864105,
-0.6749901175498962,
-0.3775465190410614,
-0.7115835547447205,
-0.36512482166290283,
-0.009098532609641552,
0.2562723159790039,
0.37240031361579895,
-0.006016972474753857,
-0.532139241695404,
0.6361678838729858,
-0.7964110374450684,
-0.817963182926178,
0.06801255792379379,
0.4311124086380005,
0.08526334166526794,
0.3813360631465912,
0.328531950712204,
-0.11401605606079102,
-0.32703083753585815,
0.15559709072113037,
-0.6969109773635864,
-0.3915899693965912,
-0.20128782093524933,
-0.10940132290124893,
0.1286105364561081,
0.7194239497184753,
-0.177873894572258,
0.3895951509475708,
0.6071728467941284,
-0.4337944984436035,
0.5525326728820801,
-0.4451516568660736,
0.6206467151641846,
-0.3658802807331085,
-0.195684015750885,
0.26201292872428894,
-0.5124885439872742,
-0.12000162899494171,
0.03554195910692215,
-0.08139855414628983,
-0.1369766741991043,
-0.33231234550476074,
0.5077522397041321,
-0.4914417862892151,
-0.1497287005186081,
-0.17648062109947205,
0.2086077183485031,
0.0931445062160492,
-0.20049113035202026,
0.08950481563806534,
0.244467630982399,
0.41265740990638733,
-0.6672440767288208,
0.24753598868846893,
0.3401108682155609,
-0.4206131100654602,
0.794901430606842,
-0.5972352027893066,
0.32177039980888367,
-0.05369085073471069,
0.09237232804298401,
-0.8350688219070435,
-0.043464332818984985,
-0.27492865920066833,
-0.5428582429885864,
0.3290172815322876,
-0.28550735116004944,
-0.36800244450569153,
-0.24754151701927185,
-0.47401025891304016,
0.15296785533428192,
0.4692429304122925,
-0.3008803129196167,
0.2814594805240631,
0.2812976837158203,
-0.2938385605812073,
-0.2043248414993286,
-0.934944212436676,
0.3563801050186157,
0.1690589040517807,
-0.6613981127738953,
0.21020939946174622,
-0.2333989292383194,
-0.4434357285499573,
0.12055857479572296,
-0.012848326936364174,
-0.15634657442569733,
-0.07747801393270493,
0.3771323561668396,
-0.027301333844661713,
-0.2548163831233978,
-0.23233342170715332,
0.03845752775669098,
-0.35904601216316223,
0.05228142440319061,
0.20020581781864166,
0.10284487158060074,
-0.45383790135383606,
-0.3526415228843689,
-0.41712310910224915,
0.33994293212890625,
0.5256245732307434,
0.08014870434999466,
-0.01114389207214117,
0.3793981969356537,
-0.23569101095199585,
0.14357446134090424,
-0.6885286569595337,
0.11983410269021988,
-0.3557922840118408,
0.2915288209915161,
-0.26492029428482056,
-0.7639853358268738,
0.24456259608268738,
0.09087691456079483,
0.033077389001846313,
0.6491848826408386,
0.4579516351222992,
0.12232773751020432,
1.207764744758606,
0.30728885531425476,
0.29693999886512756,
-0.17655201256275177,
-0.07868579775094986,
0.14878782629966736,
-0.7196879982948303,
-0.1779118776321411,
-0.7498859763145447,
-0.08329606801271439,
-0.45492467284202576,
-0.45073679089546204,
0.6823890805244446,
-0.22125273942947388,
-0.18133078515529633,
-0.10289030522108078,
-0.7104648947715759,
0.3841198682785034,
0.14218303561210632,
0.4884614646434784,
0.5193923711776733,
0.055727895349264145,
0.44518059492111206,
0.014846231788396835,
-0.4775139093399048,
-0.712823748588562,
0.9161360859870911,
0.32108059525489807,
0.7927305698394775,
0.09421517699956894,
0.9252892732620239,
0.6349462866783142,
0.34058427810668945,
-0.9434128999710083,
0.4598148763179779,
-0.8274779915809631,
-0.24559147655963898,
0.03901084512472153,
-0.3367423713207245,
-0.6083187460899353,
-0.13335268199443817,
-0.18897658586502075,
-0.26601582765579224,
0.028940340504050255,
0.061814483255147934,
-0.6098034381866455,
-0.09725604206323624,
-0.40861254930496216,
0.6417468190193176,
-0.4993624985218048,
-0.17175984382629395,
-0.3991040885448456,
-0.5690534114837646,
0.29878371953964233,
-0.014468305744230747,
0.4607037901878357,
-0.1603023260831833,
0.01122074294835329,
0.6830874085426331,
-0.9470097422599792,
0.7133884429931641,
-0.09924327582120895,
-0.19460083544254303,
0.3411860466003418,
0.38427990674972534,
0.25451287627220154,
0.19042402505874634,
-0.4123501479625702,
0.1178799644112587,
0.015354357659816742,
-0.124673992395401,
-0.29380664229393005,
0.8543675541877747,
-1.0024036169052124,
-0.3706473708152771,
-0.5981295108795166,
-0.7365784049034119,
-0.107354074716568,
0.0917201042175293,
0.3199596405029297,
0.997353732585907,
-0.30870458483695984,
-0.1580604612827301,
0.4242132902145386,
-0.22953540086746216,
-0.17770211398601532,
0.45700138807296753,
-0.07297178357839584,
-0.5667449831962585,
0.7171722650527954,
0.5292867422103882,
0.02487908862531185,
0.2140660285949707,
0.36810728907585144,
0.02010924741625786,
-0.5017040967941284,
-0.34543153643608093,
0.18305604159832,
-0.997079074382782,
-0.6385020613670349,
-0.6770078539848328,
-0.3554285764694214,
-0.3027988374233246,
-0.7191677689552307,
-0.44160303473472595,
-0.4187580943107605,
-0.012711141258478165,
0.0522153377532959,
0.6174686551094055,
0.6396594643592834,
-0.46479111909866333,
0.33676111698150635,
-1.2368396520614624,
0.2386237531900406,
0.3270525336265564,
0.42094480991363525,
-0.34534069895744324,
-0.8487258553504944,
-0.4783393442630768,
-0.3089580237865448,
-0.24693508446216583,
-0.17426244914531708,
0.24061457812786102,
0.12681590020656586,
0.21110466122627258,
0.3765853941440582,
-0.01283485908061266,
1.185516119003296,
-0.19814881682395935,
0.7446337342262268,
0.20173874497413635,
-0.9795626401901245,
0.7159885764122009,
-0.21360522508621216,
0.43424496054649353,
0.853897213935852,
-0.1026487648487091,
-0.3635084927082062,
-0.5833838582038879,
-0.7217451333999634,
-0.8205762505531311,
0.5825700759887695,
-0.19604817032814026,
0.11568037420511246,
-0.34939828515052795,
0.29442140460014343,
0.1645720899105072,
-0.2814497649669647,
-0.19485603272914886,
-0.04357508569955826,
0.0713840052485466,
-0.10155060887336731,
-0.0042985775507986546,
-0.43498966097831726,
-0.16448764503002167,
-0.262392520904541,
0.7427250146865845,
-0.13960149884223938,
0.1854809671640396,
0.5698404312133789,
-0.40519145131111145,
-0.4871574342250824,
0.2834452986717224,
0.5659968852996826,
0.8994634747505188,
-0.670167088508606,
0.30685243010520935,
-0.014864210970699787,
-0.3412836194038391,
-0.05067909136414528,
0.09647378325462341,
0.1752379983663559,
0.30319222807884216,
0.5756967663764954,
0.5231143832206726,
0.23020969331264496,
-0.718999981880188,
0.7612475752830505,
-0.32666558027267456,
-0.24294701218605042,
-0.20515559613704681,
-0.0976586639881134,
-0.3158419132232666,
0.12212108075618744,
0.24127240478992462,
0.5922481417655945,
0.4771917760372162,
-0.2803705334663391,
0.4317808151245117,
0.17137019336223602,
-0.9863461852073669,
0.11402572691440582,
0.20508353412151337,
0.08942248672246933,
0.2503792643547058,
0.6793515682220459,
-0.22225266695022583,
-0.07464854419231415,
0.5844465494155884,
0.2482316792011261,
0.9523019194602966,
-0.2892245352268219,
0.334812730550766,
0.3932096064090729,
0.22228150069713593,
-0.18273130059242249,
0.17680533230304718,
0.21572652459144592,
-0.21026618778705597,
-0.4847860336303711,
-0.45852896571159363,
-0.4077586829662323,
-0.24290896952152252,
-0.9216563105583191,
0.7902460098266602,
-0.6607418656349182,
-0.13769114017486572,
-0.02802528254687786,
0.15491169691085815,
-0.3665195405483246,
0.919459879398346,
0.5143730044364929,
1.1533551216125488,
-0.7509165406227112,
0.24042093753814697,
0.701733410358429,
-0.3465349078178406,
-0.9437564611434937,
-0.22311541438102722,
0.1903398334980011,
-0.8513179421424866,
0.7472303509712219,
0.2739900052547455,
-0.39158010482788086,
-0.32723477482795715,
-0.10918138921260834,
-0.7662933468818665,
1.0667675733566284,
0.20365272462368011,
-0.4533379375934601,
0.34989237785339355,
-0.021038053557276726,
0.4963339865207672,
-0.3556988537311554,
0.6464430689811707,
0.5378826260566711,
0.37067437171936035,
-0.10238903015851974,
-0.9199222922325134,
0.28250572085380554,
-0.19340971112251282,
-0.08293597400188446,
0.1611754596233368,
-0.5607050061225891,
0.6500067710876465,
-0.37195104360580444,
-0.03449049964547157,
0.1335248351097107,
0.3885560929775238,
0.2887859344482422,
0.2752651870250702,
0.45434486865997314,
0.9447540044784546,
0.6498159766197205,
0.08491647988557816,
1.3475725650787354,
-0.09316036850214005,
0.3356746733188629,
1.0456420183181763,
-0.14322644472122192,
0.5453561544418335,
0.1475837677717209,
0.08669884502887726,
0.6465499997138977,
0.44563359022140503,
-0.10888314992189407,
0.3943786025047302,
0.17184598743915558,
-0.041570648550987244,
-0.3448179364204407,
-0.3310000002384186,
-0.41586264967918396,
0.537811279296875,
0.2786581516265869,
-0.47787702083587646,
-0.6157508492469788,
-0.26969921588897705,
0.3666256070137024,
0.08886509388685226,
-0.8263669610023499,
0.9221052527427673,
-0.00596875324845314,
-0.47023841738700867,
0.8419065475463867,
0.04448702931404114,
0.47659268975257874,
-0.5404484868049622,
0.07425893098115921,
-0.2866673469543457,
0.5550541877746582,
-0.8597893714904785,
-0.9378264546394348,
0.8525933027267456,
0.30625438690185547,
-0.23787343502044678,
0.050975970923900604,
0.539665162563324,
-0.0011061306577175856,
-0.8420024514198303,
0.21143504977226257,
0.2516200840473175,
0.2685191035270691,
-0.10456596314907074,
-0.7404668927192688,
0.5564752817153931,
-0.17376288771629333,
-0.07781746983528137,
0.2760882079601288,
0.41574838757514954,
-0.24221070110797882,
0.3567071557044983,
0.24038808047771454,
0.31336674094200134,
-0.2761307954788208,
0.41967636346817017,
0.9448066353797913,
-0.45549285411834717,
-0.44784820079803467,
-0.5355226993560791,
0.678421676158905,
0.06547272950410843,
-0.4741334319114685,
0.38411927223205566,
0.7629538774490356,
0.4963766932487488,
0.0737694799900055,
0.8841269016265869,
-0.03784974291920662,
0.48498451709747314,
-0.5440451502799988,
0.3644814193248749,
-0.5764251351356506,
0.31376945972442627,
-0.5775195956230164,
-0.5242083072662354,
-0.8930279016494751,
0.3531409204006195,
-0.398986279964447,
-0.059100233018398285,
0.7545771598815918,
1.024198055267334,
-0.10784593224525452,
-0.44412609934806824,
0.3479096591472626,
0.32094135880470276,
0.1614258885383606,
0.4475057125091553,
0.6353389620780945,
-0.8103763461112976,
0.6617044806480408,
-0.4398542046546936,
-0.4395616054534912,
-0.4109172821044922,
-0.8846843838691711,
-0.477697491645813,
-0.09743575006723404,
-1.0850075483322144,
-0.5634645223617554,
0.34782397747039795,
0.9237585067749023,
0.7362529635429382,
-0.5031099319458008,
-0.47061243653297424,
0.2401496022939682,
-0.2925378382205963,
-0.4259233772754669,
-0.253760427236557,
0.6549253463745117,
-0.5512480139732361,
-0.3552877902984619,
0.12936437129974365,
0.5798638463020325,
-0.36423349380493164,
0.22777427732944489,
-0.2985894978046417,
0.22479461133480072,
0.04621642827987671,
0.616847574710846,
-0.06553950160741806,
-0.30492448806762695,
-0.4263095557689667,
-0.30124467611312866,
-0.4311956763267517,
0.36270466446876526,
0.6218491792678833,
-0.8308124542236328,
0.43367671966552734,
0.31586945056915283,
0.4195535480976105,
0.23594076931476593,
-0.01251919474452734,
0.1894926279783249,
-0.6202442646026611,
-0.11566036194562912,
0.11245448887348175,
0.2239445447921753,
0.6850208640098572,
-0.7477404475212097,
0.40302884578704834,
-0.1783330887556076,
-0.6668698191642761,
-0.841430127620697,
-0.142727330327034,
-1.2751258611679077,
-0.2873845398426056,
0.9855174422264099,
-0.009457243606448174,
-0.15346866846084595,
0.05616513639688492,
-0.38778921961784363,
0.07762167602777481,
-0.33259546756744385,
0.7600038051605225,
0.1322898417711258,
-0.40286436676979065,
-0.3764593303203583,
-0.16125518083572388,
0.32090044021606445,
0.17022208869457245,
-0.8074350953102112,
-0.01828951947391033,
0.6383419036865234,
0.29189759492874146,
0.2912060022354126,
0.7638934254646301,
-0.7242541909217834,
0.8487381935119629,
-0.13777749240398407,
0.06741765141487122,
-0.036435872316360474,
-0.0007033362635411322,
-0.4108026623725891,
0.0045020547695457935,
0.686026930809021,
0.1870718151330948
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.