user_id stringlengths 21 21 | answerer_user_id stringlengths 21 21 | subreddit stringclasses 1
value | timestamp timestamp[s]date 2011-03-25 07:47:59 2026-05-14 23:49:29 | post_id stringlengths 5 7 | question stringlengths 6 15.8k | preferred_answer stringlengths 4 9.5k | full_conversation listlengths 4 23 | n_turns int64 4 23 | n_turns_after_thanks int64 1 20 | op_metadata dict | answerer_metadata dict | metadata dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
anon_e2349e517f003c8d | anon_837f6d8aba129a52 | AskAcademia | 2011-03-25T07:47:59 | gb4j5 | Could you please help me identify a referencing style? (x-post from /askscience)
Hi guys, my university is requesting I use a particular referencing style which is similar to APA, but slightly different. I was wondering if any of you as readers of journal articles could identify this as the style of a particular journ... | Try copying and editing a CSL file in "c:\program files\mendeley\citation styles\" (on PC). They're just xml files. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_e2349e517f003c8d",
"comment_id": "gb4j5",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Could you please help me identify a referencing style? (x-post from /askscience)\n\nHi guys, my university is requesting I use a particular referencing style which is similar to APA, but slightly ... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_e2349e517f003c8d",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_837f6d8aba129a52",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c1mc6r0",
"thanks_reply_id": "c1md1xo",
"post_score": 5,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_69eef5325b3ceb50 | anon_d0b8e386929d482a | AskAcademia | 2011-05-25T21:53:45 | hk4x3 | Postdoc for 3+ years needs help overcoming academic burnout.
I've been working for 3+ years at an unproductive postdoc (biology), writing grants (for my boss) and working on other people's projects. Although I do my best to be dutiful postdoc, my boss doesn't like me very much or my work (unless a grant I write gets ... | Honestly, I think you should consider a hiatus from academia. A friend of mine went through almost exactly the same situation and it just wore her down more and more to the point where she withdrew from friends - wouldn't even come out with us on weekends because she was so miserable. She left, is working in the privat... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_69eef5325b3ceb50",
"comment_id": "hk4x3",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Postdoc for 3+ years needs help overcoming academic burnout.\n\nI've been working for 3+ years at an unproductive postdoc (biology), writing grants (for my boss) and working on other people's proj... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_69eef5325b3ceb50",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_d0b8e386929d482a",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c1w501e",
"thanks_reply_id": "c1w6svd",
"post_score": 8,
"answer_score": 5,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_37624ab317a8b2bb | anon_f80ace553e62a360 | AskAcademia | 2011-07-10T02:32:23 | ilbn6 | Genetic Counseling degree for a genetic engineer?
Hey, high school student here. I'm at that point where colleges are around the corner in my life and I am thinking about choices that may effect my entire life D:
The college I am really thinking about, Boston University, has no MS program for plain genetics. Instead... | Genetic engineering (modifying organisms' DNA and expression for particular goals), genetic counseling (advising patients about inherited conditions), and genetics (the study of molecules and structures of DNA) are quite distinct fields employing different skillets. All three disciplines will be valued in different way... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_37624ab317a8b2bb",
"comment_id": "ilbn6",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Genetic Counseling degree for a genetic engineer?\n\nHey, high school student here. I'm at that point where colleges are around the corner in my life and I am thinking about choices that may effec... | 9 | 6 | {
"user_id": "anon_37624ab317a8b2bb",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_f80ace553e62a360",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c271r6m",
"thanks_reply_id": "c27ebc3",
"post_score": 1,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_16a2cfd89525df8c | anon_1867223cdea36ede | AskAcademia | 2011-07-22T01:00:28 | iwdez | Need help processing thoughts on grad school
Here's my issue: I love studying. I feel such a sense of accomplishment when I take a class, master it, and walk away with an A or A+. I listen to podcasts HowStuffWorks.com put out every night before bed. I watch documentaries in my free time. Everything that I find fun in... | > I find myself more passionately drawn...communities, from which I come.
Maybe look into [social work](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_work)? | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_16a2cfd89525df8c",
"comment_id": "iwdez",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Need help processing thoughts on grad school\n\nHere's my issue: I love studying. I feel such a sense of accomplishment when I take a class, master it, and walk away with an A or A+. I listen to p... | 5 | 2 | {
"user_id": "anon_16a2cfd89525df8c",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_1867223cdea36ede",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c275v19",
"thanks_reply_id": "c27dddt",
"post_score": 6,
"answer_score": 3,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_28a98f04dff573b6 | anon_380489bbef145994 | AskAcademia | 2011-07-23T02:02:28 | ixcb3 | Math/CS Double Major or Honours CS?
Hi. I'm going into University at a Canadian institution this fall and I'd like some advice. My ultimate goal after post-secondary school is to get involved in research, be it for academia or industry. I want to work in computers science (Pure Maths has crossed my mind from time to t... | You might have more luck (or at least a greater proportion of appropriately knowledgeable people) in this [subreddit](http://www.reddit.com/r/compsci/).
Hope you find what you're looking for! | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_28a98f04dff573b6",
"comment_id": "ixcb3",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Math/CS Double Major or Honours CS?\n\nHi. I'm going into University at a Canadian institution this fall and I'd like some advice. My ultimate goal after post-secondary school is to get involved i... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_28a98f04dff573b6",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_380489bbef145994",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c27fr2y",
"thanks_reply_id": "c27gdr4",
"post_score": 2,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_06acee9741df6ccb | anon_53e9d70391cf1df1 | AskAcademia | 2011-07-25T01:51:52 | iysa1 | I messed up, how much will this affect me for grad school?
So last night, I was going to go to a party with a bunch of my friends, and the end result was that me and three other people were arrested for underage drinking. My trial isn't for about three weeks, but the officers said it will most likely go on my record ... | IIRC, there weren't any questions like this on my application. YMMV, of course. Regardless of whether they ask, bear in mind that the application process is a 'package deal' for nearly all schools. Competitive, of course, but on a whole-person level.
That said, I'm almost done with a PhD in US History. I think you sh... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_06acee9741df6ccb",
"comment_id": "iysa1",
"kind": "post",
"text": "I messed up, how much will this affect me for grad school?\n\nSo last night, I was going to go to a party with a bunch of my friends, and the end result was that me and three other people were arr... | 5 | 2 | {
"user_id": "anon_06acee9741df6ccb",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_53e9d70391cf1df1",
"author_flair_text": "PhD, US History",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c27qj4k",
"thanks_reply_id": "c27qkg2",
"post_score": 2,
"answer_score": 8,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_a5e48b95a7a3af68 | anon_8f0f7f3918d6e2c1 | AskAcademia | 2011-07-26T11:15:31 | j02b8 | What do I need to know about grants?
I'm a first year graduate student in biomedical engineering and I don't know anything about grants. What are the different types of grants? Do they pay for just equipment or also for personnel? Who applies for a grant and what do you need (data-wise, credentials) do apply for one? | Here's the basics on the main US NIH grants.
R01 - Four to five years ~250k/year. Pays for everything. Requires A LOT of data and credentials.
R21 - Shorter term. Sort of like a "grant that lets you get the stuff to make an R01." Still requires preliminary data, even though it says it does not. Pays for everything.
... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_a5e48b95a7a3af68",
"comment_id": "j02b8",
"kind": "post",
"text": "What do I need to know about grants?\n\nI'm a first year graduate student in biomedical engineering and I don't know anything about grants. What are the different types of grants? Do they pay for ... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_a5e48b95a7a3af68",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_8f0f7f3918d6e2c1",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c287059",
"thanks_reply_id": "c28g6s2",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 3,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_d60459ae3aad25dc | anon_32add80d5064099d | AskAcademia | 2011-07-29T14:50:05 | j38xg | Can anyone give the work that contains this letter from Thoreau?
I posted this question in r/literature, but the subreddit doesn't seem to be visited very often. I'm hoping one of you can help me out.
I was wondering if anyone knew the source of this message from Thoreau:
"My dear,
Do not catalog me upon “the mass o... | Edit: Nevermind, I'm stupid and didn't read all the way through. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_d60459ae3aad25dc",
"comment_id": "j38xg",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Can anyone give the work that contains this letter from Thoreau?\n\nI posted this question in r/literature, but the subreddit doesn't seem to be visited very often. I'm hoping one of you can help ... | 6 | 3 | {
"user_id": "anon_d60459ae3aad25dc",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_32add80d5064099d",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c28ves6",
"thanks_reply_id": "c28vh5w",
"post_score": 2,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_7d8f98f84fe525ca | anon_a20fa6a3283380e1 | AskAcademia | 2011-08-05T17:40:44 | ja1v4 | Is there an online resource/social networking thing for lab scientists to go to when they get stuck?
Whenever most of my friends don't know how to do something at work..they can just google google google away and find the answer. Is there some sort of forum or online resource for molecular bio people? I've searched ... | I have found [NEB's Guide](http://www.neb.com/nebecomm/tech_reference/polymerases/PCR_troubleshooting_guide.asp) to be pretty comprehensive. In terms of trouble shooting I normally first try large temperature gradient. Then if you have non-specific binding try a DMSO gradient (lower Ta than normal). If you no product t... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_7d8f98f84fe525ca",
"comment_id": "ja1v4",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Is there an online resource/social networking thing for lab scientists to go to when they get stuck?\n\nWhenever most of my friends don't know how to do something at work..they can just google goo... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_7d8f98f84fe525ca",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_a20fa6a3283380e1",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2aiu4y",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2b988n",
"post_score": 8,
"answer_score": 3,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_c4b7fb5211a6d4db | anon_88011a773966534a | AskAcademia | 2011-10-19T04:49:24 | lh5w5 | My plan is to major in Biology and then apply to Physical Therapy school, but the GPA requirements seem daunting for a Biology major. Can anyone with some insight educate me a little bit on becoming a PT? | A lot of PT schools don't only look at cumulative GPA. Many of them will look at your GPA in the classes that they require, so if you don't do well in upper level biology classes it won't necessarily harm your chances of getting in.
I was also a biology major, graduated college with a 3.5 GPA, and I am currently in P... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_c4b7fb5211a6d4db",
"comment_id": "lh5w5",
"kind": "post",
"text": "My plan is to major in Biology and then apply to Physical Therapy school, but the GPA requirements seem daunting for a Biology major. Can anyone with some insight educate me a little bit on becomi... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_c4b7fb5211a6d4db",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_88011a773966534a",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2uwq4w",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2v41em",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_e6cb8283cd3b5271 | anon_02ec7d31ec3336e1 | AskAcademia | 2011-10-21T06:37:27 | ljo4k | Is it too late to pursue a degree then
career in Science?
Hi guys, long time lurker and first time poster here.
I am a few months away from finishing my business degree in commercial law and management. I am getting very good marks and have a couple of offers from respectable corporations that I can pursue after gr... | Regarding physics (and the one year foundation course), go and talk to [Mark Conway](http://www.physics.auckland.ac.nz/uoa/mark-conway) on Monday or whenever suits you. I believe he's still the Stage 1 advisor, who also runs the foundation courses (91F/92F) and teaches Physics 160 (called Physics for the Life Sciences,... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_e6cb8283cd3b5271",
"comment_id": "ljo4k",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Is it too late to pursue a degree then \ncareer in Science?\n\nHi guys, long time lurker and first time poster here. \n\nI am a few months away from finishing my business degree in commercial law ... | 6 | 3 | {
"user_id": "anon_e6cb8283cd3b5271",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_02ec7d31ec3336e1",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2t99ro",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2tiibh",
"post_score": 4,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_86aadc2c84c574ff | anon_13391d92a01d211b | AskAcademia | 2011-10-22T03:36:26 | lkotd | What do you think about community colleges? Do they fulfill their purpose?
[This article](http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-college-costs-20111020,0,4840452.story) claims that community colleges are just a waist of money, as the majority of students drop out anyway. And [here](http://www.reddit.com/r/Foodforthou... | I was poor, went back to Community College, did excellently (and really, had world-class professors who actually cared whether their students succeeded or not), and got a full ride to Stanford as a transfer student. 21 of my fellow transfer students also took the Community College route. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_86aadc2c84c574ff",
"comment_id": "lkotd",
"kind": "post",
"text": "What do you think about community colleges? Do they fulfill their purpose?\n\n[This article](http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-college-costs-20111020,0,4840452.story) claims that community c... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_86aadc2c84c574ff",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_13391d92a01d211b",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2thbc4",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2tjayz",
"post_score": 4,
"answer_score": 11,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_b527d2d426086041 | anon_87d88960113141ef | AskAcademia | 2011-11-01T14:54:45 | lwgne | PIs and Postdocs, how varied has your field of study been over the years? How common are shifts within a broader topic, such as biology?
I am currently in the last years of my PhD in Biochemistry and my area of study is in brain myelination and the role of opioid receptors in oligodendrocytes. However, I'm not sure i... | Lifestyle is very different in field biology vs standard molecular biology/biochemistry labs, so there may be a bit of culture shock involved. Different funding availability, structure, etc.
If I were you, I'd consider maybe moving into more behavioral or physiological neuroscience? That way you can work in a simila... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_b527d2d426086041",
"comment_id": "lwgne",
"kind": "post",
"text": "PIs and Postdocs, how varied has your field of study been over the years? How common are shifts within a broader topic, such as biology?\n\nI am currently in the last years of my PhD in Biochemist... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_b527d2d426086041",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_87d88960113141ef",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2w5bdx",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2w5w2l",
"post_score": 5,
"answer_score": 4,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_f92976131f034b44 | anon_902a0c48dbf671de | AskAcademia | 2011-11-03T20:28:44 | lzef2 | BA in psych useless?
I'm currently a third year undergrad working towards a BA in psychology in a fairly prestigious school. Because I have a 74% average, I'm understand I won't get into grad school, even if I start acing all my exams.
I've been told again and again that with only a BA in psychology, I'll be serving... | wasn't, was being honest. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_f92976131f034b44",
"comment_id": "lzef2",
"kind": "post",
"text": "BA in psych useless?\n\nI'm currently a third year undergrad working towards a BA in psychology in a fairly prestigious school. Because I have a 74% average, I'm understand I won't get into grad s... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_f92976131f034b44",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_902a0c48dbf671de",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2x3zaj",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2x5l3u",
"post_score": 14,
"answer_score": 4,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_bc955efe8d0db33a | anon_419a1047cbe4941b | AskAcademia | 2011-11-07T20:11:46 | m3vhw | Recommendation for a basic meteorology book?
I'm a biology undergraduate with a fairly strong scientific background and I'm looking for a book with some basic concepts about the weather and how it functions. I would like a book that isn't esoteric, but gets into the subject in some detail. | How comfortable are you with math and at which "level" do you want to understand the concepts of weather? I.e., do you want to learn the physics behind it, or just know what fronts, cyclones etc. that they talk about on TV are?
For the former the book [Atmospheric Science: An Introductory Survey](http://www.amazon.com... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_bc955efe8d0db33a",
"comment_id": "m3vhw",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Recommendation for a basic meteorology book?\n\nI'm a biology undergraduate with a fairly strong scientific background and I'm looking for a book with some basic concepts about the weather and how... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_bc955efe8d0db33a",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_419a1047cbe4941b",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2xwm5m",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2xxz5p",
"post_score": 2,
"answer_score": 3,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_74f986e6f3ffc6e0 | anon_bb0844dbb7a56d0c | AskAcademia | 2011-11-12T03:13:35 | m9fun | The impossible has happened: two dream job offers? Help! (xpost from /r/jobs)
Cross-post from /r/jobs!
Hello reddit! I've been a long time lurker and now I need some advice. I've been on the job hunt for only a month (what am I doing right?!) and low-and-behold: 150 applications, 8 interviews, 6 second interviews, 5... | I would go for #1. You'll have plenty of time to try out stable positions - after all, they're stable, so they'll stay around. #1 sounds like a chance to do something really really cool, which will propel you to excellence. Or else it doesn't work out, and you'll have learned a lot in the process. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_74f986e6f3ffc6e0",
"comment_id": "m9fun",
"kind": "post",
"text": "The impossible has happened: two dream job offers? Help! (xpost from /r/jobs)\n\nCross-post from /r/jobs! \n\nHello reddit! I've been a long time lurker and now I need some advice. I've been on th... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_74f986e6f3ffc6e0",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_bb0844dbb7a56d0c",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c2z7c9t",
"thanks_reply_id": "c2zahem",
"post_score": 8,
"answer_score": 7,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_a3fa1aa08300bdff | anon_76cd267a93c73457 | AskAcademia | 2011-11-16T15:13:39 | mefmv | Looking for the Hammer Safety article from the Journal of Occupational Medicine
I cannot find this article online anymore. It was a satire piece posted in May 1968 (Volume 10, Number 5). I have a physical copy but would like to find it online.
Also, if anyone knows any other articles along the same lines as this and ... | I'm not sure if I was able to access this through my university or if it is available to the public, but here is the [link](http://ovidsp.tx.ovid.com/sp-3.4.2a/ovidweb.cgi?WebLinkFrameset=1&S=LINOFPFAFFDDMDKINCBLMCMCLCDDAA00&returnUrl=ovidweb.cgi%3f%26TOC%3dS.sh.15.16.19.22%257c5%257c50%26FORMAT%3dtoc%26FIELDS%3dTOC%26... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_a3fa1aa08300bdff",
"comment_id": "mefmv",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Looking for the Hammer Safety article from the Journal of Occupational Medicine\n\nI cannot find this article online anymore. It was a satire piece posted in May 1968 (Volume 10, Number 5). I have... | 5 | 2 | {
"user_id": "anon_a3fa1aa08300bdff",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_76cd267a93c73457",
"author_flair_text": "Public Health Nutrition",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c309zex",
"thanks_reply_id": "c30a13m",
"post_score": 4,
"answer_score": 5,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_1615935ba194273e | anon_fe89ea3be47f8f1b | AskAcademia | 2011-11-29T04:56:38 | msz74 | Any biochemists out there willing to share your experience in the field?
Hey everyone. I'm researching careers in biochemistry as part of a guidance course assignment and I was wondering if you could help me out. If you could answer a few questions it would really help me, both with my assignment and decision regardin... | I'm still working on my PhD in biochemistry, but I thought I could answer some of your questions.
>How did you decide upon this field? What options did you consider >before becoming a biochem major?
I was going to be a biology major, but then I took organic chemistry and fell in love. I was really engaged by thinkin... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_1615935ba194273e",
"comment_id": "msz74",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Any biochemists out there willing to share your experience in the field?\n\nHey everyone. I'm researching careers in biochemistry as part of a guidance course assignment and I was wondering if you... | 5 | 2 | {
"user_id": "anon_1615935ba194273e",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_fe89ea3be47f8f1b",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c33lqe1",
"thanks_reply_id": "c33me2d",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_ae396379840aa61f | anon_bbda0484458790ed | AskAcademia | 2011-12-06T14:22:56 | n2id5 | Hey Reddit, if you were to be a professor in the subject of your choice, what would you be?
And why? Whether it be money, students, hours, life, etc. I want to hear your answers!
EDIT: I'm curious as to why this would receive a down vote? Hmmmm
Thanks for the answers! | Well, I've just always wanted to go to grad school, so there's that. As an undergrad, I first focused on archaeology, then found anthropology to be more interesting and finally settled on linguistic anthropology. I did a project at a high school as an undergrad, so that got me interested in working with/studying teens.... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_ae396379840aa61f",
"comment_id": "n2id5",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Hey Reddit, if you were to be a professor in the subject of your choice, what would you be?\n\nAnd why? Whether it be money, students, hours, life, etc. I want to hear your answers!\n\nEDIT: I'm... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_ae396379840aa61f",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_bbda0484458790ed",
"author_flair_text": "PhD Linguistics",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c35ydq9",
"thanks_reply_id": "c36576b",
"post_score": 8,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_92c8d426b0953b10 | anon_794d9caa801e4fe3 | AskAcademia | 2011-12-11T22:14:33 | n8vkg | custom science dictionaries for MS Word?
Anyone who has written science related stuff using MS Word will know that you inevitably end up with red squiggly lines all over the place, as the default spell-checker is pretty much science-illiterate; for example telling you to replace "protist" with "protest", "trophic" wit... | I'm fairly sure you've hit the main ones. I've already got 3 of those 4 incorporated. Sorry. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_92c8d426b0953b10",
"comment_id": "n8vkg",
"kind": "post",
"text": "custom science dictionaries for MS Word?\n\nAnyone who has written science related stuff using MS Word will know that you inevitably end up with red squiggly lines all over the place, as the defau... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_92c8d426b0953b10",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_794d9caa801e4fe3",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c37976b",
"thanks_reply_id": "c37besu",
"post_score": 5,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_74e54edd1c080ac7 | anon_83fca49904941994 | AskAcademia | 2011-12-13T20:06:59 | nbdto | Small chemistry question
Hey AskAcademia. I was just wondering if you guys could help me with a small chemistry question.
If I know the weight of an entire solid compound (e.g 33g) and its composition (e.g. Sm2Co17), is there a way for me to find out the weight of the individual components Sm and Co ? | 2x+17y=33, trial and error from there?
Look up the components (Samarium and Cobalt)?
Try r/askscience? | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_74e54edd1c080ac7",
"comment_id": "nbdto",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Small chemistry question\n\nHey AskAcademia. I was just wondering if you guys could help me with a small chemistry question.\n\nIf I know the weight of an entire solid compound (e.g 33g) and its c... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_74e54edd1c080ac7",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_83fca49904941994",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c37qyxr",
"thanks_reply_id": "c37raaf",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_7a9cbe537a4658fd | anon_65fd719e1ae68be8 | AskAcademia | 2011-12-16T04:11:37 | ner3r | I am a college graduate. What is the best path to a career in science for me?
I'm in my early 20s and I have a bachelor's degree already, but it's a degree in art. It wasn't until after I graduated that I realized I want to do something else with my life. I'm now thinking about pursuing a career in bioengineering or s... | It's never too late. Unfortunately, since your background/degree is in art, and you want to do bioengineering, odds are that you'll need to go back for almost a completely new bachelors simply to get all the pre-reqs out of the way that you'll need to even be considered by grad schools. I just got [finished](http://w... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_7a9cbe537a4658fd",
"comment_id": "ner3r",
"kind": "post",
"text": "I am a college graduate. What is the best path to a career in science for me?\n\nI'm in my early 20s and I have a bachelor's degree already, but it's a degree in art. It wasn't until after I gradu... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_7a9cbe537a4658fd",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_65fd719e1ae68be8",
"author_flair_text": "PhD, Microbiology",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c38idjv",
"thanks_reply_id": "c38jel3",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_608e05d34c03aafc | anon_d9f7823df04d59d9 | AskAcademia | 2011-12-23T23:04:25 | nogxf | How can one get a job/internship when they have a really bad GPA? [X-post from r/AskReddit]
That's basically my question. I will graduate from college soon with a ~2.5 because I failed two courses this semester. My GPA before this semester was 3.02. If I had to sum up reasons for failing at college I'd say it's becaus... | I second this. Go to the website of your department (if still living near your college) or go to the chemistry/biology website of the nearest university to you. Also consider medical school departments (medicinal chemistry, biochemistry, pharmacology, depends on your particular interests). Check out the department and ... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_608e05d34c03aafc",
"comment_id": "nogxf",
"kind": "post",
"text": "How can one get a job/internship when they have a really bad GPA? [X-post from r/AskReddit]\n\nThat's basically my question. I will graduate from college soon with a ~2.5 because I failed two cour... | 8 | 5 | {
"user_id": "anon_608e05d34c03aafc",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_d9f7823df04d59d9",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3avl0x",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3aw7ca",
"post_score": 9,
"answer_score": 3,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_f9dc079daa4bfc6f | anon_c8d2bc54b4dd485c | AskAcademia | 2011-12-24T04:58:10 | not9w | Any tips on pursuing an advanced degree in Oceanography?
I'm currently a freshman in university, and I plan to graduate with a major in Biology. Becoming an oceanographer has always been my childhood dream, and I'm starting to considering it as a possible career. Are there any oceanographers here on reddit that can gi... | So, I studied oceanography as an undergrad, and am now in an R1 grad school in an allied field. Oceanography is a great field! The biological side of oceanography is generally comsidered either biological oceanography which is large scale process science or marine biology, which has a lot more to do with studying speci... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_f9dc079daa4bfc6f",
"comment_id": "not9w",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Any tips on pursuing an advanced degree in Oceanography?\n\nI'm currently a freshman in university, and I plan to graduate with a major in Biology. Becoming an oceanographer has always been my chi... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_f9dc079daa4bfc6f",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_c8d2bc54b4dd485c",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3aupm4",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3avrw6",
"post_score": 5,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_4809d2c0378ffc7d | anon_a20fa6a3283380e1 | AskAcademia | 2012-01-08T02:58:54 | o7hju | I was just asked to help do research for a university... Any tips?
I was asked by my Biology teacher to go with her and a few select students to a university, where we will help her (Or the university?) research some subject in microbiology and publish an original scientific work.
Now, what should I expect? I'm reall... | This sounds like an awesome opportunity. It is very likely that is is part of a program created around the concept of getting high schoolers involved in research, so don't be concerned about not being useful to them. They understand your background and should have something appropriate arranged for you to do. A lot of ... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_4809d2c0378ffc7d",
"comment_id": "o7hju",
"kind": "post",
"text": "I was just asked to help do research for a university... Any tips?\n\nI was asked by my Biology teacher to go with her and a few select students to a university, where we will help her (Or the uni... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_4809d2c0378ffc7d",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_a20fa6a3283380e1",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3f03wr",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3f0j2z",
"post_score": 1,
"answer_score": 4,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_c36bcabf13221398 | anon_d0b8e386929d482a | AskAcademia | 2012-01-08T12:52:14 | o7wwn | Google Scholar “My Citations” – Useful tool or the height of narcissism?
Google Scholar “My Citations” – Useful tool or the height of narcissism?
http://scienceadvocacy.org/Blog/2012/01/08/google-scholar-my-citations-useful-tool-or-the-height-of-narcissism/
This post goes through some of the various profile building ... | Personally, I feel that spending so much time cultivating an online persona (via LinkedIn, etc) is *exactly* the same as using Facebook. You sculpt this alter-ego that the internet sees - one without imperfection, who can do no wrong, who is always at the right place at the right time with the photos to prove it. I hav... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_c36bcabf13221398",
"comment_id": "o7wwn",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Google Scholar “My Citations” – Useful tool or the height of narcissism?\n\nGoogle Scholar “My Citations” – Useful tool or the height of narcissism?\nhttp://scienceadvocacy.org/Blog/2012/01/08/goo... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_c36bcabf13221398",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_d0b8e386929d482a",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3f3uwg",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3f4154",
"post_score": 10,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_ca28d0e4f6544175 | anon_30258d2096bddd74 | AskAcademia | 2012-01-11T15:37:04 | ocfeg | Finish as quickly as possible or acquire some more in-
depth knowledge?
Hi AskAcademia, I have to make an important decision soon and would like some further advice (adding to the advice from family and friends) on what to do.
Since I am not from the US, I think I have to explain some things before I start with the ... | I'd imagine that you could only gain from the extra semester, especially because you seem to have a clear plan about what you want to accomplish with your extra time (languages, internships). And you definitely won't be seen as lazy; you already have a solid GPA so the extra semester won't be seen as compensating for ... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_ca28d0e4f6544175",
"comment_id": "ocfeg",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Finish as quickly as possible or acquire some more in-\ndepth knowledge?\n\nHi AskAcademia, I have to make an important decision soon and would like some further advice (adding to the advice from ... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_ca28d0e4f6544175",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_30258d2096bddd74",
"author_flair_text": "Ph.D architectural history",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3hi993",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3hj2n6",
"post_score": 7,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_6a90f3cba11f2f08 | anon_2769a95cbae3ee88 | AskAcademia | 2012-01-20T14:11:54 | oou2p | Lay Abstract vs. Scientific Abstract?
Hi everyone,
I'm in the middle of writing a letter of intent for a postdoctorate fellowship. My question is - just how much should the scientific abstract differ from the lay abstract? In both, I need to write about the project proposed as well as the skills I'll be obtaining i... | there's no real "right way" to do it but i would make an attempt to make the lay abstract as simple as possible. if it's easier for you, you can start with sentence by sentence but then re-read it and make sure that the flow is there, and make sure that the concepts that you are communicating are clear and well explai... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_6a90f3cba11f2f08",
"comment_id": "oou2p",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Lay Abstract vs. Scientific Abstract?\n\nHi everyone,\n\nI'm in the middle of writing a letter of intent for a postdoctorate fellowship. My question is - just how much should the scientific abstr... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_6a90f3cba11f2f08",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_2769a95cbae3ee88",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3iuxjo",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3iuzco",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_773f340a213aadf2 | anon_43d08d25ca5bf372 | AskAcademia | 2012-02-04T02:07:52 | pa48w | Would other social science courses be useful to an economics student?
I've got some general electives in my course, and while a couple will be going towards additional economics subjects I find interesting, I'm thinking of using a couple for introductory courses on cognitive psychology, and possible sociology or anthr... | Consider [GEOG2000](http://www.uq.edu.au/study/course.html?course_code=GEOG2000) and [GEOG3000](http://www.uq.edu.au/study/course.html?course_code=GEOG3000). | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_773f340a213aadf2",
"comment_id": "pa48w",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Would other social science courses be useful to an economics student?\n\nI've got some general electives in my course, and while a couple will be going towards additional economics subjects I find... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_773f340a213aadf2",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_43d08d25ca5bf372",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3ny2fa",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3nyc2o",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": false
} |
anon_828761ce71bd6621 | anon_a7b1252edac3188f | AskAcademia | 2012-02-05T01:48:50 | pbbqr | What do universities look for in potential post-grad students?
Before starting uni to study pure chemistry, I made a promise to myself to take it easy.
I'd always been top of my class but that started to take its toll, i'd missed a lot of opportunities to hang out with family and friends over the years, because i was... | Here's the thing, just don't tell anyone that you are half-assing everything. If you have a top 5 GPA, people will assume you are working hard. During my PhD, I tried to have a life. I played sports, went out on weekends, etc. At one point in grad school, a lab mate mentioned to my prof about our weekly poker game.... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_828761ce71bd6621",
"comment_id": "pbbqr",
"kind": "post",
"text": "What do universities look for in potential post-grad students?\n\nBefore starting uni to study pure chemistry, I made a promise to myself to take it easy.\n\nI'd always been top of my class but th... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_828761ce71bd6621",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_a7b1252edac3188f",
"author_flair_text": "PhD, Assoc Prof",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3o043v",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3o092v",
"post_score": 3,
"answer_score": 7,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_ce1b62eea046ecc6 | anon_65fd719e1ae68be8 | AskAcademia | 2012-02-07T17:39:58 | pewg3 | How to get into grad school with a poor GPA?
Firstly, just a bit of background, I am a biology student who graduated with a bachelors in biology and a minor in mathematics. I've been out of academia for about three years now. I wanted to go to graduate school right after, but I was struggling financially and also I di... | How low is low? This matters.
I think a fundamental problem many other commenters are missing is how neuroscience programs are run these days. Many schools now link their neuroscience programs under an umbrella program with many of the other biomedical programs. And competition to get into these programs is intense... | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_ce1b62eea046ecc6",
"comment_id": "pewg3",
"kind": "post",
"text": "How to get into grad school with a poor GPA?\n\nFirstly, just a bit of background, I am a biology student who graduated with a bachelors in biology and a minor in mathematics. I've been out of aca... | 4 | 1 | {
"user_id": "anon_ce1b62eea046ecc6",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_65fd719e1ae68be8",
"author_flair_text": "PhD, Microbiology",
"author_flair_css_class": ""
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3oxdt0",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3oxlqg",
"post_score": 12,
"answer_score": 2,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
anon_93c4df3e6ccd78e0 | anon_db324c572a45dc27 | AskAcademia | 2012-02-07T20:49:24 | pf5yd | Study of improvements when going from centralized to distributed?
[/r/AskScience](/r/AskScience) mods felt this question wasn't appropriate, thought I'd try here.
I'm trying to track down a field of study that I'm convinced must exist but I just don't know what to search to learn more about it. I'm interested in what... | There's a book written by Eric Raymond called "The Cathedral and the Bazaar" about open source and distributed software development that you might like, but it's not academic. | [
{
"role": "OP",
"user_id": "anon_93c4df3e6ccd78e0",
"comment_id": "pf5yd",
"kind": "post",
"text": "Study of improvements when going from centralized to distributed?\n\n[/r/AskScience](/r/AskScience) mods felt this question wasn't appropriate, thought I'd try here.\n\nI'm trying to track down a ... | 5 | 2 | {
"user_id": "anon_93c4df3e6ccd78e0",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null,
"author_flair_type": null,
"author_flair_background_color": null,
"author_flair_text_color": null
} | {
"user_id": "anon_db324c572a45dc27",
"author_flair_text": null,
"author_flair_css_class": null
} | {
"answer_comment_id": "c3ox5k0",
"thanks_reply_id": "c3oxbg5",
"post_score": 0,
"answer_score": 1,
"preferred_answer_is_top_level": true
} |
personalization-reddit-multiturn
Multi-turn (question, preferred_answer, full_conversation) records mined
from Reddit. Companion to dipikakhullar/personalization-reddit: same
OP-thanks-reply heuristic for identifying the preferred answerer, but
this dataset additionally captures any contiguous back-and-forth between
the OP and that single answerer after the thanks.
A record is only emitted when there is at least one further turn beyond the OP's thanks reply.
Splits
One split per subreddit; pick from the dropdown in the data viewer or load programmatically:
from datasets import load_dataset
ds = load_dataset("dipikakhullar/personalization-reddit-multiturn",
split="LanguageTechnology")
Source
Raw post + comment dumps from the
arctic_shift Pushshift
mirror, fetched per-subreddit and extracted with
may_22/extract_conversations.py in the personalization repo.
Raw NDJSON dumps are kept locally and are not redistributed here.
Files
conversations/sub-<subreddit>.jsonl # one conversation per line
stats/sub-<subreddit>.json # funnel counts per subreddit
Record schema (conversations/sub-*.jsonl)
| field | type | description |
|---|---|---|
user_id |
str | anonymized OP id (joins with personalization-reddit) |
answerer_user_id |
str | anonymized id of the preferred answerer |
subreddit |
str | source subreddit name |
timestamp |
str | post creation, ISO 8601 UTC |
post_id |
str | Reddit submission id |
question |
str | post title, with selftext appended if present |
preferred_answer |
str | body of the comment OP thanked |
full_conversation |
list[turn] | ordered turns; see below |
n_turns |
int | length of full_conversation (≥ 4) |
n_turns_after_thanks |
int | turns past the OP-thanks reply (≥ 1) |
op_metadata |
object | OP user fields captured at post time; see below |
answerer_metadata |
object | answerer user fields captured at comment time; see below |
metadata |
object | anchor ids + contiguity flag; see below |
A turn has:
| field | type | description |
|---|---|---|
role |
str | "OP" or "answerer" |
user_id |
str | anonymized author id of this turn |
comment_id |
str | reddit comment id (or post id for turn 0) |
kind |
str | "post" or "comment" |
text |
str | full body |
timestamp |
str | ISO 8601 UTC |
score |
int | reddit score at fetch time |
Turn layout:
- Turn 0: OP's question post.
- Turn 1: answerer's preferred answer.
- Turn 2: OP's thanks reply.
- Turn 3+: alternating answerer/OP, walked depth-first by earliest
created_utcat each branch.
op_metadata
Whatever author-level fields appear on the OP's submission record. Most are flair-related; many records have all fields null.
| field | type | description |
|---|---|---|
user_id |
str | anonymized OP id (same as top-level user_id) |
author_flair_text |
str | null | OP's flair text at post time |
author_flair_css_class |
str | null | flair css class |
author_flair_type |
str | null | e.g. "text", "richtext" |
author_flair_background_color |
str | null | hex color |
author_flair_text_color |
str | null | "light" / "dark" |
answerer_metadata
Author-level fields from the preferred-answer comment record. Comment records in the dumps carry fewer author fields than submissions.
| field | type | description |
|---|---|---|
user_id |
str | anonymized answerer id (same as top-level answerer_user_id) |
author_flair_text |
str | null | answerer's flair text at comment time |
author_flair_css_class |
str | null | flair css class |
metadata
| field | type | description |
|---|---|---|
answer_comment_id |
str | id of the preferred answer comment |
thanks_reply_id |
str | id of OP's thanks reply (the anchor signal) |
post_score |
int | submission score at fetch time |
answer_score |
int | preferred-answer score at fetch time |
preferred_answer_is_top_level |
bool | True iff A1.parent_id == post_id; see Contiguity below |
Contiguity
Turns 1 through N always form a strict parent→child chain in the reply tree
authored only by OP and the preferred answerer. Turn 0 → Turn 1 is not
always direct: in some records the OP thanked a nested comment rather than
a top-level reply, so third-party comments may sit between the question post
and A1 in the original thread. Filter on
metadata.preferred_answer_is_top_level == true to keep only records where
the entire chain is contiguous from the question down.
Anonymization
Reddit usernames are hashed with the same salted-SHA256 scheme used in
personalization-reddit, so user_id / answerer_user_id join across the
two datasets when generated with the same ANON_SALT. Post/comment ids and
text bodies are kept verbatim — content from public Reddit threads can still
be re-identified by searching the post id or quoting the body.
Heuristic
For each kept question post:
- Find OP comments matching the same thanks-reply predicate used in
personalization-reddit(signals.py::is_thanks_reply). - Treat the parent of each thanks reply as the preferred answer.
- From the thanks reply, walk the comment tree: at each step take the
earliest child by
created_utcwhose author is the expected next speaker (alternating answerer / OP). Stop when no such reply exists or the chain hits a bot, a deleted account, or an empty/[deleted]/[removed]body. - Emit a record only when this walk yielded at least one further turn.
- Downloads last month
- 124