Datasets:

hallucite-org
/

citation-snippets

id int64 5.46M 8.58M	document_id int64 61 2.21M	case_id int64 50 367k	filing_year int64 2.02k 2.03k	snippet large_stringlengths 10 1.16k	cite_char_start int64 0 689	cite_char_end int64 6 808	cite_str large_stringlengths 6 51	volume int64 0 2.03k	reporter large_stringclasses 468 values	page large_stringlengths 1 42	cited_year int64 1.71k 2.03k ⌀	hallucite_plaintiff large_stringlengths 1 434 ⌀	hallucite_defendant large_stringlengths 1 411 ⌀	hallucite_status large_stringclasses 5 values	hallucite_match_case_name large_stringlengths 6 11.6k ⌀	hallucite_match_citation large_stringlengths 6 30 ⌀	hallucite_plaintiff_match_type large_stringclasses 7 values	hallucite_defendant_match_type large_stringclasses 8 values	hallucite_citation_match_type large_stringclasses 6 values	hallucite_matched_via_fuzzy bool 2 classes	hallucite_name_similarity_score float64 0 100 ⌀
6,429,486	2,134,457	339,908	2,016	In further support whereof, Petitioner shows the Court: - A. The Court may award attorney fees to Petitioner in accordance with the provisions of the 43 O.S. §110 and the holdings of Miller v. Miller, 1963 OK 167; Anderson v. Anderson, 1990 OK CIV APP 23, see Doloney v. Downey, 1997 OK 102, 944 P.3d 312; and James v....	419	475	318 P.3d 1130	318	P.3d	1130	null	Briggeman	Hargrove	exists	BRIGGEMAN v. HARGROVE	318 P.3d 1130	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,664,109	83,125	35,266	2,019	Dr. Templeton objects to this fact as it is not material to the claims remaining after the 3. dismissal of the Boundary Tract claims. Hadnot v. Shaw, 1992 OK 21, 18, 826 P.2d 978, 985 ("A fact is 'material' if proof of that fact would have the effect of establishing or refuting one of the essential elements of a cause ...	134	178	826 P.2d 978	826	P.2d	978	null	Hadnot	Shaw	exists	Hadnot v. Shaw	826 P.2d 978	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,377,087	266,403	101,773	2,021	12 O.S. § 3236(A). See also Heath v. Engle, 123 P.3d 1 (Okla. 2005); Ross v. Pace, 87 P.3d 593 (Okla. 2004).	28	54	123 P.3d 1	123	P.3d	1	2,005	Heath	Engle	exists	Heath v. Engle	123 P.3d 1	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,366,726	426,327	160,125	2,021	Mills v. Mills, 1973 OK 74, ¶ 25, 512 P.2d 143. See also Vilbig Const. Co. v. Whitham, 1949 OK 7, ¶ 5, 201 P.2d 922 ("The essentials of equitable jurisdiction in an action on account are said to be the need of a discovery, the complicated character of the accounts, and the existence of a fiduciary or trust relation") (...	57	96	1949 OK 7	1,949	OK	7	null	Vilbig Const. Co.	Whitham	exists	VILBIG CONST. CO. v. WHITHAM	1949 OK 7	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,026,086	155,981	61,896	2,018	Charges made for time spent in copying documents and in doing other secretarial tasks, rather than substantive legal work are not includable in attorney's fees. See Taylor v. Chubb Group of Ins. Companies, 1994 OK 47, 874 P.2d 806.	165	230	874 P.2d 806	874	P.2d	806	null	Taylor	Chubb Group of Ins. Companies	exists	Taylor v. Chubb Group of Ins. Companies	874 P.2d 806	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,627,976	526,786	196,379	2,023	After a patient's death, his physician's claim for such services is a debt due from the decedent, and therefore, must yield precedence to any debts due to the United States under the terms of the federal insolvency statute. Postmaster General v. Robbins, 19 F. Cas. 1126 (D. Me. 1829); United States v. Eggleston, 25 F. ...	344	382	275 P.2d 597	275	P.2d	597	1,954	Muldoon	United States	exists	Estate of WILLIAM HENRY MULDOON, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. HAROLD J. BODE, as etc.	275 P.2d 597	surname	no_match	exact	true	100
7,359,098	361,834	137,421	2,023	"A party may refer to records, as opposed to providing a narrative, if the records are clearly identified." Continental Ins. Co. v. Chase Manhattan Mortgage, 59 Fed. Appx. 830, 837 (7th Cir.2003).	108	175	59 F. App'x 830	59	F. App'x	830	null	Continental Ins. Co.	Chase Manhattan Mortgage	exists	Continental Insurance v. Chase Manhattan Mortgage Corp.	59 F. App'x 830	exact	exact	exact	false	92.929293
6,917,984	2,160,728	347,927	2,019	Generally, this requirement can be satisfied by offering a "testimony that a photograph is a correct representation of the object sought to be shown...." Glenn v. State, 444 P.2d 839, 841 (Okla. Crim. App. 1968).	154	182	444 P.2d 839	444	P.2d	839	1,968	Glenn	State	exists	Glenn v. State	444 P.2d 839	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,719,153	193,245	74,849	2,022	The chief evil to be eradicated under the OCPA is to protect citizens from being chilled "from exercising their rights to petition the government by fear of the costs and burdens of the resulting litigation" and to limit the use of litigation being used "to discourage the exercise of first amendment rights." Steidley v...	310	352	2016 OK CIV APP 63	2,016	OK CIV APP	63	null	Steidley	CNHI, Inc.	exists	Steidley v. Community Newspaper HoldIngs, Inc.	2016 OK CIV APP 63	exact	no_match	exact	true	89.361702
6,329,187	179,644	69,620	2,020	A term fixing unreasonably large liquidated damages is unenforceable on grounds of public policy as a penalty. 137 N.J. 238, 645 A.2d 100 (1994).	111	137	645 A.2d 100	645	A.2d	100	1,994	null	null	incomplete	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
6,604,160	516,410	192,987	2,021	Withholding discovery under the assertion that it constitutes attorney work product requires demonstration of either (1) "communications and things prepared in anticipation of litigation or for trial by or for another party or by or for the representative of that other party"; or (2) the "mental impression, conclusions...	429	458	2005 OK 84	2,005	OK	84	null	Scott	Peterson	exists	Scott v. Peterson	2005 OK 84	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,781,305	717,332	244,751	2,024	The Court finds that the Book does not fall within any of the above-listed categories and, in fact, is in no way similar to any of the above examples. Dedovic v. Mowen, CIV-06-918-M, 2007 WL 1574055, at \*1 (W.D. Okla. May 29, 2007).	151	198	2007 WL 1574055	2,007	WL	1574055	2,007	Dedovic	Mowen, CIV-06-918-M	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
5,589,618	625,102	233,318	2,024	Oklahoma Courts have long held that "the law abhors forfeitures, so statutes authorizing forfeiture of private property are to be strictly construed", State ex rel. Harris v 2011 Honda, 2015 OK 11 ¶7, 345 P3d 389, 391; State ex rel. Redman v \$122.40, 2010 OK 19, ¶16, 231 P3d 1150, 1155. In accordance with this princip...	557	670	188 P.3d 120	188	P.3d	120	null	Stipe	State ex rel. Bd. of Trustees of Oklahoma Public Employees Retirement System	exists	Stipe v. State Ex Rel. Board of Trustees	188 P.3d 120	exact	prefix	exact	false	100
6,300,902	332,770	127,154	2,019	Pursuant to 12 O.S. §3226 to determine the validity of each claim of privilege, all privilege logs in this case shall sufficiently describe, author or authors, the recipient(s), its origination date, its length, the nature of the document or intended purpose and the basis of the objection. Scott V. Peterson 126 P.3d 12...	291	322	126 P.3d 1232	126	P.3d	1232	null	Scott	Peterson	exists	Scott v. Peterson	126 P.3d 1232	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,414,082	77,733	33,572	2,019	## ARGUMENTS AND AUTHORITIES man e bayan na also testille that the action of the L. Summary Judgment Standard 2010/08/2 michalism ser substitutivity and a community of the a sil All Controller Conduct Summary judgment is only proper when the pleadings, affidavits, depositions, admissions or other evidentiary ma...	463	532	4 P.3d 695	4	P.3d	695	null	Copeland	The Lodge *Enterprises, Inc.	exists	Copeland v. Lodge Enterprises, Inc.	4 P.3d 695	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,897,622	67,624	30,553	2,017	In accordance with, but not limited to, Daniel v. Daniel, 2001 OK 117, 42 P.3d 10. 863; Foshee v. Foshee, 2010 OK 85, 247 P.3d 1162, 1168; Eimen v. Eimen, 2006 OK CIV APP 23, 131 P.3d 148; and Fast v. Fast, 1989 OK CIV APP 31, 787 P.2d 1288, 1290 Mr. Mehdipour alleges since the effective date of the Decree and Agreed O...	193	240	787 P.2d 1288	787	P.2d	1288	null	Fast	Fast	exists	Fast v. Fast	787 P.2d 1288	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,503,650	436,163	162,936	2,022	279 (Okla. 1997) \| \| Buford White Lumber Co. v. Octagon Properties, Ltd., 740 F. Supp. 1553 (W.D. Okla. 1989) \| \| Burlington N. & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v. Grant, 505 F.3d 1013 (10th Cir. 2007) \| \| AKC ex rel. Carroll v. Lawton Indep. Sch. Dist. No. 8, 9 F. Supp. 3d 1240 (W.D. Okla. 2014) \| \| Central Plastics Co. v. Goodson,...	350	391	2002 WL 1821600	2,002	WL	1821600	2,002	null	In re Clark	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,633,889	568,846	213,928	2,017	nts AHP seeks to enforce clearly identify Brent Bullen, in either his individual capacity or either as a "Power of Attorney" for an estate placing them on notice to inquire if in fact Brent Bullen had authority under the law to bind said estate, they chose instead to take the Mortgage and Note "As-Is". See, Exhibit "J"...	350	402	1963 OK 255	1,963	OK	255	null	Sanco Finance Co.	Neal	exists	Sanco Finance Company v. Neal	1963 OK 255	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,299,238	361,586	137,401	2,023	So long as the party has demonstrated sufficient motivation to litigate vigorously and to present all colorable contentions, a district judge does not exceed the bounds of discretion by concluding that the interests of the intervenor are adequately represented. Id. (quoting Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc. v. New York Stat...	275	362	834 F.2d 60	834	F.2d	60	1,987	Nat. Res. Def. Council, Inc.	New York State Dep't of Env't Conservation	exists	Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc. v. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation	834 F.2d 60	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,735,033	493,545	186,040	2,018	It is well settled in Oklahoma that the rule requiring exhaustion of administrative remedies is designed to aid in the orderly administration of justice, prevent transfer to the courts of duties imposed by law on administrative agencies, allow the agency to exercise discretion, or apply its expertise under the statutor...	495	561	2017 OK CIV APP 47	2,017	OK CIV APP	47	null	Chandler	State ex rel. Dep't of Pub. Safety	exists	CHANDLER v. STATE ex rel. DEPT. OF PUBLIC SAFETY	2017 OK CIV APP 47	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,656,348	516,639	192,999	2,021	12 O.S. § 2015(C)(3) (emphasis added). Plaintiff relies on Roth v. Mercy Health Center, Inc., 2011 OK 2, 246 P.3d 1079.	59	103	2011 OK 2	2,011	OK	2	null	Roth	Mercy Health Center, Inc.	exists	Roth v. Mercy Health Center, Inc.	2011 OK 2	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,761,807	2,149,980	345,019	2,018	It has been previously stated that the evaluation requested by Respondent would not result in conclusive evidence, i.e. "proof," as to the validity of the allegations litigated in this matter, therefore, the basis for such a request would not be born out of the conclusive support the evidence would provide or in a righ...	401	434	354 F. App'x 382	354	F. App'x	382	2,009	U.S.	Turner	exists	United States v. Turner	354 F. App'x 382	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,523,302	280,007	106,369	2,023	As previously addressed in this Motion to Dismiss, scope of employment is defined as "performance by an employee acting in good faith within the duties of his office or employment or of tasks lawfully assigned by a competent authority." Tuffy's, Inc. v. City of Oklahoma City, 212 P.3d 11158, 2009 OK 4 (Okla. 2004) (*...	239	293	212 P.3d 11158	212	P.3d	11158	2,004	Tuffy's, Inc.	City of Oklahoma City	exists	Tuffy's, Inc. v. City of Oklahoma City	2009 OK 4	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,951,348	398,035	152,541	2,018	ULSA, INC. v. AMERICAN BANK & TRUST CO. \| Discussed at Length \| \| 1995 OK CIV APP 31, 895 P.2d 741, 66 \| Nwachuku v. Yellow Cab Co., Inc. \| Cited \| \| <u>OBJ 1699,</u> \| \| \| \| 2002 OK CIV APP 114, 60 P.3d 518, \| SHORT v. AMERICAN BIOMEDICAL GROUP, INC. \| Cited \| \| 2003 OK CIV APP 44, 69 P.3d 1229, \| <u>ROSEN v. WHITE SW...	350	481	2006 OK CIV APP 87	2,006	OK CIV APP	87	null	null	Cite Name** L 2004 OK CIV'APP 10	invalid	Elliott v. McCaleb	2006 OK CIV APP 87	no_match	no_match	exact	false	26.666667
5,469,404	152,644	60,815	2,017	"Questions of law are reviewed by a de novo standard." Bank of the Wichitas v. Ledford, 2006 OK 73, ¶20, 151 P.3d 103.	57	100	2006 OK 73	2,006	OK	73	null	Bank of the Wichitas	Ledford	exists	Bank of the Wichitas v. Ledford	2006 OK 73	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,793,623	348,991	132,809	2,021	#### listorical Data SARA OKLAHOMA.L. 1910, § 5189; Amended by Laws 1965, HB 928, c. 300, § 1. #### itationizer® Summary of Documents Citing This Document \| te Name \| Level \| \| \| dahoma Court of Civil Appeals Cases \| \| \| \| Cite \| Name \| Level \| \| 2013 OK CIV APP 76, 309 P.3d 150, \| <b>BOWLES v. GOSS</b> \| Discu...	255	287	309 P.3d 150	309	P.3d	150	null	null	null	incomplete	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
6,732,466	518,259	193,565	2,022	The Court reasoned that, because the agent had chosen to speak regarding a material fact (the arbitration agreement), a duty to speak arose, which required the agent to fully and accurately explain the arbitration agreement.5 Id. (citing Deardorf v. Rosenbusch, 1949 OK 117, ¶ 8, 206 P.2d 996, 998 ("the speaker being un...	486	562	475 P.3d 847	475	P.3d	847	null	Isaac Sutton	David Stanley Chevrolet, Inc.	exists	SUTTON v. DAVID STANLEY CHEVROLET	475 P.3d 847	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,593,078	2,129,616	338,231	2,016	#### Comments This Instruction is revised in accordance with Strong v. Allen, 1989 OK 17, 10, 768 P.2d 369, 371 (father's negligence was not the supervening cause of injuries to his two year old child), and Thompson v. Presbyterian Hosp., Inc., 1982 OK 87, 17, 652 P.2d 260, 264-65 (negligence of anesthesiologist was su...	369	410	877 F.2d 1489	877	F.2d	1489	1,989	Henry	Merck & Co., Inc.	exists	Henry v. Merck & Co.	877 F.2d 1489	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,857,034	558,983	209,904	2,016	## PLAINTIFFS DO NOT HAVE STANDING TO PROTEST THE MANNER IN WHICH THE COMMISSIONER ACQUIRED ITS INTEREST IN THE STOCK CERTIFICATE "Standing" requires a "justiciable interest" or a right conferred by statute. See Williams v. Lara, 52 S.W.3d 171,178-9 (Tex. 2001).	212	243	52 S.W.3d 171	52	S.W.3d	171	2,001	Williams	Lara	exists	Williams v. Lara	52 S.W.3d 171	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,766,186	180,005	69,650	2,020	]; Spirgis v. Circle K Stores, Inc., see note 34, infra [Whether pothold was a hidden danger because of traffic created a question of fact.]. See also, Nider v. Republic Parking, Inc., 2007 OK CIV APP 95, 169 P.3d 738 [Question of fact existed on whether invitee was aware of dangerous condition where owner had reason t...	152	203	2007 OK CIV APP 95	2,007	OK CIV APP	95	null	Nider	Republic Parking, Inc.	exists	Nider v. Republic Parking, Inc.	2007 OK CIV APP 95	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,620,645	625,152	233,328	2,024	After all, "[t]he cardinal rule of statutory construction is to ascertain and give effect to the legislative intent and purpose as expressed by the statutory language." Am. Airlines, Inc. v. State, 2014 OK 95, 1 33, 341 P.3d 56, 64.	169	227	341 P.3d 56	341	P.3d	56	null	Am. Airlines, Inc.	State	exists	AMERICAN AIRLINES v. STATE	341 P.3d 56	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,495,084	195,172	75,398	2,022	Id. If there is any doubt as to the Legislature's power to act in any given situation, the doubt should be resolved in favor of the validity of the action taken by the Legislature Id. (citing Draper v. State, 1980 OK 117, ¶ 8, 621 P.2d 1142, 1145–46 (footnote omitted)).	195	224	1980 OK 117	1,980	OK	117	null	Draper	State	exists	Draper v. State	1980 OK 117	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,729,124	2,176,167	353,014	2,020	Venue is proper in this Court as the Oklahoma Corporation Commission ("OCC") 101. does not have jurisdiction over the property damage claims asserted in this Petition. Ladra v. New Dominion, et al., 2015 OK 53, 353 P.3d 529 (2015).	168	223	353 P.3d 529	353	P.3d	529	2,015	Ladra	New Dominion, et al.	exists	LADRA v. NEW DOMINION, LLC	353 P.3d 529	exact	exact	exact	false	90
6,677,294	73,585	32,202	2,018	Mac Adjustment, Inc. v. Property Loss Research Bureau, 595 P.2d 427, 428 (Okla. 1979). The fort was first recognized in Oklahoma in the context of malicious interference with the contractual rights of a business in Schonwald v. Ragains, 32 Okla. 223, 122 P. 203 (1912).	215	249	32 Okla. 223	32	Okla.	223	1,912	Schonwald	Ragains	exists	Schonwald v. Ragains	32 Okla. 223	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,246,549	533,983	198,971	2,023	K 171, 12, 604 P.2d 373, 374 \| \| \| Ross v Peters \| \| \| 1993 OK 8, 17, fn. 32, 846 P.2d 1107, 1114, fn. 32 \| \| \| Signature Leasing v. Buyer's Grp. \| \| \| 2020 OK 50, 18, 466 P.3d 544, 549 \| \| \| Strong v. State ex rel. the Oklahoma Police Pension & Ret. Bd. \| \| \| 2005 OK 45, 19, 115 P.3d 889, 893 \| \| \| Sw. Bell Tel. Co. v...	350	383	897 P.2d 116	897	P.2d	116	null	null	null	incomplete	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
6,379,407	592,443	221,796	2,020	See MTG Guarnieri Mfg., Inc. v. Clouatre, 2010 OK CIV APP 71, [ 24, 239 P.3d 202, 214 ("[A] manager of a limited liability company is liable for [a]cts or omissions not in good faith or which involve intentional misconduct or a knowing violation of law." (internal quotations omitted) (emphasis added); see also All Am. ...	312	380	550 F. Supp. 166	550	F. Supp.	166	1,981	All Am. Car Wash, Inc.	Nat'l Pride Equip., Inc.	exists	All American Car Wash, Inc. v. National Pride Equipment, Inc.	550 F. Supp. 166	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,375,736	44,119	21,476	2,015	E-Mail String Between Agrawal and Chris Nichols Dated 01-21-14 CLR 37456-37459 - 25. Invoices Dated 01-29-14 CLR 21585-21609 26.	85	118	14 Conn. L. Rptr. 21585	14	Conn. L. Rptr.	21585	null	null	Invoices Dated 01-29-	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,193,290	459,655	172,969	2,015	A. Summary judgment is proper under Rule 13 when the record before the court shows there is no substantial controversy as to any material fact. See Okla. Dist. Ct. R. 13; Allen v. Lynn Hickey Dodge, Inc., 2001 OK 93, 39 P.3d 781.	171	228	39 P.3d 781	39	P.3d	781	null	Allen	Lynn Hickey Dodge, Inc.	exists	Allen v. Lynn Hickey Dodge, Inc.	39 P.3d 781	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,800,215	412,343	156,360	2,019	To do this, the Government needs an in-person opportunity to observe Sims' demeanor, ask follow-up questions, and confront Sims with prior inconsistent statements she has made."); Clinton v. Cal. Dep't of Corr., No. CIV-S-05-1600-LKK-CMK-P, 2008 WL 5068586, at \*2 (E.D. Cal. Nov. 25, 2008) (declining to order remote de...	180	256	2008 WL 5068586	2,008	WL	5068586	2,008	Clinton	Cal. Dep't of Corr.	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,209,635	621,458	232,129	2,023	Plaintiff. Christian v. American Home Assurance Co., 1977 OK 141, 577 P.2d 899.	11	78	577 P.2d 899	577	P.2d	899	null	Christian	American Home Assurance Co.	exists	Christian v. American Home Assurance Co.	577 P.2d 899	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,170,271	262,238	100,656	2,021	In other words, an invitor is not an insurer of the safety or others and "cannot be held responsible unless it be shown that he/she had notice or could be charged with gaining knowledge of the condition in time sufficient to effect its removal or to give warning of its presence." Taylor v. Hynson, 1993 OK 93, 16, 856 P...	281	327	856 P.2d 278	856	P.2d	278	null	Taylor	Hynson	exists	Taylor v. Hynson	856 P.2d 278	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,601,733	568,803	213,928	2,017	U. S. v. Throckmorton. 98 U. S. 61, 65, 66; Vance v. Burbank, 101 U. S. 514, 519; Steel v. Refining Co., 106 U. S. 447, 453, 1 Sup. Ct. 389; Moffat v. U. S., 115 U. S. 24, 32, 5 Sup. Ct. 10: U. S. v. Minor, 114 U. S. 233, 242, 5 Sup. Ct. 836.	141	170	115 U.S. 24	115	U.S.	24	null	Moffat	U. S.	exists	Moffat v. United States	112 U.S. 24	exact	exact	volume_typo	false	100
6,610,591	578,363	217,151	2,018	Neil Acquisition, L.L.C. v. Wingrod Inv. Corp., 1996 OK 125, n.1, 932 P.2d 1100. See Horton v. Hamilton, 2015 OK 6, ¶ 8, 345 P.3d 357 ("Summary judgment will be affirmed only if the appellate court determines that there is no dispute as to any material fact and that the moving party is entitled to judgment as a matter ...	85	114	2015 OK 6	2,015	OK	6	null	Horton	Hamilton	exists	HORTON v. HAMILTON	2015 OK 6	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,443,198	2,096,594	324,000	2,022	Once certified to the County, special assessments are "coequal with the lien of ad valorem taxes and all other taxes and special assessments and prior and superior to all other titles and liens against the property." 11 O.S.2021, §§ 22-111(A)(6), 22-112(A)(5); 22-112.4(B)(7); see also Hutchman v. Tate, 175 P.2d 980, 98...	286	316	175 P.2d 980	175	P.2d	980	1,946	Hutchman	Tate	exists	Hutchman v. Tate	175 P.2d 980	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,862,963	70,444	31,529	2,018	<u>ld.</u> at 257-8. (Emphasis ours) The Supreme Court of Virginia in Acuar v. Letourneau, 260 Va. 180, 531 S.E.2d 316, 322 (2000), held that the plaintiff was entitled to recover the full amount of his medical expenses, including the amounts written off pursuant to contractual agreements between the healthcare provide...	70	102	260 Va. 180	260	Va.	180	2,000	Acuar	Letourneau	exists	Acuar v. Letourneau	260 Va. 180	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,554,813	2,159,292	347,575	2,018	A fact is "material" if proof of that fact would establish or refute one of the essential elements of the cause of action asserted. Hadnot v. Shaw, 1992 OK 21, 826 P.2d 978,985.	132	158	1992 OK 21	1,992	OK	21	null	Hadnot	Shaw	exists	Hadnot v. Shaw	1992 OK 21	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,568,087	367,726	140,178	2,025	In Green Tree Acceptance, Inc. v. Anderson, 1999 OK CIV APP 46, the Appellant Court vacated a judgment against the debtor when there was no evidence a notice of rescission has been given to the debtor. In Testerman v. First Family Life Ins. Co., 1990 OK CIV APP 108, the rescission is a contractual right which may be ti...	205	265	1990 OK CIV APP 108	1,990	OK CIV APP	108	null	Testerman	First Family Life Ins. Co.	exists	Testerman v. First Family Life Insurance Co.	1990 OK CIV APP 108	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,233,008	157,870	62,634	2,018	94 \| \| Gorham v. Gorham, 1984 OK 90, 692 P.2d 1375 \| \| Hackett v. Hackett, 1967 OK 117, 429 P.2d 753 \| \| Harrison v. Morgan, 2008 OK CIV APP 68, 191 P.3d 617 \| \| Hedges v. Hedges, 2002 OK 92, 66 P.3d 364 \| \| House of Sight & Sound, Inc. v. Faulkner, 1995 OK CIV APP 112, 912 P.2d 357 \| \| In re Marriage of King, 2016 OK ...	350	378	2001 OK 30	2,001	OK	30	null	Kaiser	Kaiser	exists	Kaiser v. Kaiser	2001 OK 30	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,253,860	424,506	159,819	2,020	The requirement that cardholders take timely action to correct billing errors is grounded in the acknowledgment that they must play a role in assisting the credit card issuer in avoiding the fraudulent charges or other billing issues. In Discover Bank v. Worsham, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals provided instruction...	238	379	2008 OK CIV APP 6	2,008	OK CIV APP	6	null	Discover Bank	Worsham, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals provided instruction on applying the account stated doctrine.	exists	Discover Bank v. Worsham	2008 OK CIV APP 6	exact	prefix	exact	false	100
7,200,698	401,819	153,625	2,018	Outside of her employment with DHS, Fischer has no duty to Plaintiffs as no special relationship would exist. See Cooper v. Millwood Ind. Sch. Dist. No. 37, 1994 OK CIV APP 114, 887 P.2d 1370, 1375 (holding that if school bus driver's alleged omissions were found to have been outside scope of employment, negligence cla...	114	176	1994 OK CIV APP 114	1,994	OK CIV APP	114	null	Cooper	Millwood Ind. Sch. Dist. No. 37	exists	Cooper v. Millwood Independent School District No. 37	1994 OK CIV APP 114	exact	no_match	exact	true	91.111111
6,459,303	454,206	170,510	2,025	The existence of a duty is a threshold question in any negligence action because, absent a duty, there can be no liability for negligence as a matter of law. Lowery v. Echostar Satellite Corp., 2007 OK 38, ¶12, 160 P.3d 959, 964.	158	223	160 P.3d 959	160	P.3d	959	null	Lowery	Echostar Satellite Corp.	exists	Lowery v. Echostar Satellite Corp.	160 P.3d 959	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,282,070	224,813	88,828	2,017	If so, discovery should be limited, and if need be, it may be disallowed." YWCA of Oklahoma City v. Melson, 1997 OK 81, 125, 944 P.2d 304, 312 (footnotes omitted).	75	137	944 P.2d 304	944	P.2d	304	null	YWCA of Oklahoma City	Melson	exists	YWCA of Oklahoma City v. Melson	944 P.2d 304	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,530,590	2,096,955	324,029	2,022	Plaintiffs must establish "a prima face case showing a reasonable probability that [it] will ultimately be entitled to the relief sought." Autoskill v. National Education Support System, 994 F.2d 1476, 1487 (10th Cir. 1993), quoting Continental Oil Co. v. Frontier Refining Co., 338 F.2d 780, 781 (10th Cir 1964).	233	291	338 F.2d 780	338	F.2d	780	1,964	Continental Oil Co.	Frontier Refining Co.	exists	Continental Oil Company v. The Frontier Refining Company	338 F.2d 780	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,160,497	332,556	127,154	2,019	"Withholding information from shareholders violates their rights." In re Tyson Foods, Inc., 919 A.2d 563, 602 (Del. Ch. 2007).	67	104	919 A.2d 563	919	A.2d	563	2,007	null	In re Tyson Foods, Inc.	exists	In Re Tyson Foods, Inc. Consolidated Shareholder Litigation	919 A.2d 563	no_match	prefix	exact	false	100
7,381,434	505,839	189,573	2,020	#### LAW GOVERNING AWARDS OF PUNITIVE DAMAGES A. Whether there is competent evidence to submit the issue of punitive damages to the jury is a question of law for the Court. See, Hall v. Globe Life and Accident Ins. Co., 1998 OK CIV APP 161, 968 P.2d 1263, 1266-1267; see also, Black v. M&W Gear Co., 269 F.3d 1220, 1...	182	258	968 P.2d 1263	968	P.2d	1263	null	Hall	Globe Life and Accident Ins. Co.	exists	Hall v. Globe Life & Accident Insurance Co.	968 P.2d 1263	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,061,617	502,474	188,876	2,020	Other courts have also excluded evidence of other allegations against a defendant because of unfair prejudice and its inherent tendency to confuse the issues. See United States Football League v. National Football League, 634 F. Supp. 1155, 1172-73 (S.D.N.Y.1986) (excluding evidence of prior lawsuits against the defend...	163	239	634 F. Supp. 1155	634	F. Supp.	1155	null	United States Football League	National Football League	exists	United States Football League v. National Football League	634 F. Supp. 1155	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,883,191	605,474	226,049	2,022	Accordingly, KSMI is entitled to summary judgment against Defendants for the total amounts due and against all Defendants, plus interest, costs, and attorney fees. [See generally, KSMI's Motion for Summary Judgment]; Federal Land Bank of Wichita v. Northcutt, 1991 OK CIV APP 10, 11 and 2, 811 P.2d 1368, 1368-70, cert. ...	217	278	1991 OK CIV APP 10	1,991	OK CIV APP	10	null	Federal Land Bank of Wichita	Northcutt	exists	Federal Land Bank of Wichita v. Northcutt	1991 OK CIV APP 10	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,672,609	2,101,221	325,470	2,022	Id. Indeed our Supreme Court adopts the majority exception to the general rule in Gentry v. Am. Motorist Ins. Co., 1994 OK 4, 867 P.2d 468.	82	138	867 P.2d 468	867	P.2d	468	null	Gentry	Am. Motorist Ins. Co.	exists	Gentry v. American Motorist Insurance Co.	867 P.2d 468	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,128,846	275,431	104,729	2,022	Case No.: CJ-2022-3695 vs. ### CONSOLIDATED ELECTRICAL DISTRIBUTORS, INC., et al., Defendants. #### QUALIFIED SPECIAL ENTRY OF APPEARANCE COMES NOW Timothy L. Rogers and Emily Kosmider of the law firm of Barrow & Grimm, P.C., and hereby enter this special appearance on behalf of Defendant, Rexel USA, Inc. f/k/a...	351	381	807 P.2d 248	807	P.2d	248	1,991	Young	Walton	exists	Young v. Walton	807 P.2d 248	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,573,772	594,950	222,723	2,020	port a jury award of punitive damages); Austin v. Disney Tire Co., 815 F.Supp. 285, 289 (S.D.Ind.1993) (affirming a grant of summary judgment because the defendant's conduct, a truck driver looking down while approaching an intersection and failing to level of culpable a red light. did not rise to the conduct to stop a...	350	383	201 Ga. App. 459	201	Ga. App.	459	1,991	Cullen	Novak	exists	Cullen v. Novak	201 Ga. App. 459	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,489,478	623,848	232,941	2,024	It is further irrelevant that Libra and ABM are parties to this case. "The venue of actions against multiple joint defendants 'lies only in the county or counties meeting the requirement of all applicable specific venue statutes... " Schwartz v. Diehl, 1977 OK 115, ¶ 10, 568 P.2d 280 (quoting City of McAlester v. Fogg....	294	346	312 P.2d 867	312	P.2d	867	null	City of McAlester	Fogg.	exists	City of McAlester v. Fogg	312 P.2d 867	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,447,879	2,112,092	329,609	2,024	te \| Name \| Level \| \| \| \| \| 2001 OK 72, 41 P.3d 960, 72 OBJ \| STATE ex rel. DEPT. OF TRANSPORTATION v. NORMAN INDUSTRIAL Cited \| \| \| \| \| \| 2708, \| <b>DEVELOPMENT CORP.</b> \| \| \| \| \| \| 2002 OK 67, 58 P.3d 759, \| CONTEREZ v. O'DONNELL \| Discussed at Length \| \| \| \| \| 2006 OK 64, 145 P.3d 1039, \| <b>HERMAN v. ROBERTSON</b>...	350	374	918 P.2d 744	918	P.2d	744	null	null	null	incomplete	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,036,400	2,140,106	341,868	2,017	A clear showing of prejudice is required before we allow a trial court to set aside a jury verdict, or set it aside ourselves, for excessiveness or inadequacy of damages. Id.; Material Serv. Corp. v Rogers Cnty. Bd. Of Comm'rs, 2012 OK CIV APP 17, 273 P.3d 880, 886.	176	246	2012 OK CIV APP 17	2,012	OK CIV APP	17	null	Material Serv. Corp.	Rogers Cnty. Bd. Of Comm'rs	exists	Material Service Corp. v. Rogers County Board of Commissioners	2012 OK CIV APP 17	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,941,382	2,131,793	339,259	2,016	The Court should apply the terms of the contracts as they lie and all claims should be submitted to arbitration. Defendants cite Walker v. Builddirect.com Technologies, Inc., 2015 OK 30, 349 P.3d 549, in support of their claim that the addendum was not properly incorporated.	129	185	2015 OK 30	2,015	OK	30	null	Walker	Builddirect.com Technologies, Inc.	exists	WALKER v. BUILDDIRECT.COM TECHNOLOGIES INC.	2015 OK 30	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,603,726	604,149	225,653	2,021	I. Notwithstanding the fact that Plaintiff devotes a substantial part of its brief to elaborating the contours of federal pleading requirements, Oklahoma has not adopted the "plausibility" standard. Bryson v. Okla. Cty. ex rel. Okla. Cty. Detention Ctr., 2011 OK CIV APP 98, 1 26, 261 P.3d 627, 637 n. 8; see Weist v. ...	201	275	2011 OK CIV APP 98	2,011	OK CIV APP	98	null	Bryson	Okla. Cty. ex rel. Okla. Cty. Detention Ctr.	exists	Bryson v. Oklahoma County ex rel. Oklahoma County Detention Center	2011 OK CIV APP 98	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,917,351	419,991	158,730	2,020	There are several factors a court considers when determining whether a corporation is a successor in interest of another corporation rather than a separate entity. See generally Rea v. An-Son Corp., 79 F.R.D. 25 (W.D.Okla.1978); Pharmacy Providers of Okla., Inc. v. O Pharmacy, Inc., No. CIV-12-1405-C, 2013 WL 1688921 (...	229	318	2013 WL 1688921	2,013	WL	1688921	2,013	Pharmacy Providers of Okla., Inc.	O Pharmacy, Inc.	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,087,920	212,166	83,305	2,015	12 O.S. § 2403. In the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals case of Sims v. Travelers, Inc. Co., 2000 OK CIV APP 145, 14, 16 P.3d 468, 472, the Court held that certain documents which the plaintiffs failed to specifically list on the pretrial order and failed to exchange with the defendant before the trial as ordered by the...	63	111	2000 OK CIV APP 145	2,000	OK CIV APP	145	null	Sims	Travelers, Inc. Co.	exists	Sims v. Travelers Insurance Co.	2000 OK CIV APP 145	exact	no_match	exact	true	84.507042
5,710,633	153,329	61,107	2,018	Under Pennsylvania law, the elements of a breach of contract cause of action are (1) the existence of a contract, including its essential terms, (2) a breach of duty imposed by the contract and (3) resultant damages. Pennsy Supply, Inc. v. American Ash Recycling Corp., 2006 Pa. Super. 54, 895 A.2d 595 (2006).	217	288	2006 Pa. Super. 54	2,006	Pa. Super.	54	2,006	Pennsy Supply, Inc.	American Ash Recycling Corp.	exists	Pennsy Supply, Inc. v. American Ash Recycling Corp.	2006 Pa. Super. 54	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,449,380	576,216	216,525	2,018	As such, both Oklahoma statute and case law establish that StoneGate and EM Operations are the only entities that may be held liable for providing care to Smith. See, Fanning v. Brown, 2004 OK 7.	167	194	2004 OK 7	2,004	OK	7	null	Fanning	Brown	exists	Fanning v. Brown	2004 OK 7	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,614,246	1,742,094	296,767	2,019	49. An award of punitive or exemplary damages against Dr. Stewart is barred to the extent that it is inconsistent with the standards and limitations set forth in BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore, 517 U.S. 559, 134 L. Ed. 2d 809 116 S.Ct. 1589 (1996), and State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v. Campbell, 123...	162	210	517 U.S. 559	517	U.S.	559	1,996	BMW of North America, Inc.	Gore	exists	BMW of North America, Inc. v. Gore	517 U.S. 559	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,976,075	94,010	38,768	2,021	Furthermore, the Oklahoma Supreme Court has held that purpose of the Oklahoma Discovery Code is to identify issues, "eliminate secrets and surprise [and] prevent the trial of a lawsuit from becoming a guessing game..." State ex rel Remington Arms Co. v. Powers, 1976 OK 103, ¶ 4, 552 P.2d 1150, 1152.	232	293	552 P.2d 1150	552	P.2d	1150	null	Remington Arms Co.	Powers	exists	State Ex Rel. Remington Arms Co., Inc. v. Powers	552 P.2d 1150	token_subset	exact	exact	false	100
6,743,170	252,665	97,870	2,020	### AUTHORITY Title 12 O.S. §3237(B)(2) provides in pertinent part, "If a party or an officer, director, or managing agent of a party [...] fails to obey an order to provide or permit discovery [...], the court in which the action is pending may make such orders in regard to the failure as are just." "District Cour...	627	664	638 F.3d 1318	638	F.3d	1318	2,011	Lee	Max Intern, LLC	exists	Lee v. Max Intern., LLC	638 F.3d 1318	exact	exact	exact	false	94.736842
6,554,544	160,506	63,581	2,018	Normally, the effect of a true merger is that "one corporation goes entirely out of existence, by being merged into another...." Am. Ry. Exp. Co. v. Snead, 1923 OK 1017, 96 Okla. 278, 221 P. 1032, 1032; see also Exch. Bank of Commerce v. Meadors, 1947 OK 198, 199 Okla. 10, 14-15, 184 P.2d 458, 464 ("In the case of eith...	129	195	221 P. 1032	221	P.	1032	null	Am. Ry. Exp. Co.	Snead	exists	American Railway Express Co. v. Snead	221 P. 1032	prefix	exact	exact	false	93.82716
7,417,986	48,754	23,718	2,016	This has operated as a rule of evidence to prohibit a defendant from offering any evidence that a plaintiff has been compensated for his injuries by a third-party that is independent of the defendant. Porter v. Manes, 1959 OK 239, ¶ 11, 347 P.2d 210.	201	229	1959 OK 239	1,959	OK	239	null	Porter	Manes	exists	Porter v. Manes	1959 OK 239	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,345,003	265,228	101,481	2,021	Bank of Oklahoma, N.A. v. Krown Systems, 53 P.3d 924, 928 (Ok.Civ.App. 2002); see also Sautbine v. Keller, 423 P.2d 447, 451 (Okla. 1966).	87	119	423 P.2d 447	423	P.2d	447	1,966	Sautbine	Keller	exists	Sautbine v. Keller	423 P.2d 447	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,060,639	617,807	230,515	2,023	"A mutual agreement to arbitrate claims provides sufficient consideration for an arbitration agreement." Lujan, 361 S.W.3d at 152 (citing In re U.S. Home Corp., 236 S.W.3d 761, 764 (Tex.2007)).	138	175	236 S.W.3d 761	236	S.W.3d	761	null	null	In re U.S. Home Corp.	exists	In Re U.S. Home Corp.	236 S.W.3d 761	no_match	exact	exact	false	100
5,810,743	113,744	45,099	2,023	Where the moving party was aware of the facts on which the amendment was based for some time prior to seeking leave to amend, the request to amend is properly denied. Fed. Ins. Co. v. Gates Learjet Corp., 823 F.2d 383, 387 (10th Cir. 1987).	167	217	823 F.2d 383	823	F.2d	383	1,987	Fed. Ins. Co.	Gates Learjet Corp.	exists	Federal Insurance Company v. Gates Learjet Corporation	823 F.2d 383	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,675,576	528,277	196,995	2,023	The agreement may be oral or written or implied from the conduct of the parties. OUJI 6.4; Mistletoe Express Serv. v. Britt, 405 P.2d 4, 7 (Okla. 1965).	91	135	405 P.2d 4	405	P.2d	4	1,965	Mistletoe Express Serv.	Britt	exists	Mistletoe Express Service v. Britt	405 P.2d 4	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,877,538	412,424	156,359	2,019	Nelson v. Enid Med. Assocs., Inc., 2016 OK 69, ¶ 36, 376 P.3d 212, 224. See also In re Flint Water Cases, 2024 WL 2244871, at \5 (E.D. Mich. May 17, 2024) (a "battle of the experts" is not a basis to exclude one's testimony); Arkansas River Power Auth. v. Babcock & Wilcox Power Co., 2016 WL 9734684, at \6 (D. Colo. O...	81	121	2024 WL 2244871	2,024	WL	2244871	2,024	null	In re Flint Water Cases	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
6,854,298	519,364	193,866	2,022	The United States Supreme Court has described "this provision as reflecting both a liberal federal policy favoring arbitration and the fundamental principle that arbitration is a matter of contract." AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 563 U.S. 333, 339 (2011) (citation and quotations omitted).	200	245	563 U.S. 333	563	U.S.	333	2,011	AT&T Mobility LLC	Concepcion	exists	AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion	563 U.S. 333	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,772,604	2,137,407	341,126	2,017	"When a defendant asserts qualified immunity at summary judgment, the burden shifts to the plaintiff to show that: (1) the defendant violated a constitutional right and (2) the constitutional right was clearly established." Id. (citing Pearson v. Callahan, - U.S. -, 129 S.Ct. 808, 815-16, 172 L.Ed.2d 565 (2009)); see S...	404	440	581 F.3d 1304	581	F.3d	1304	null	Whittier	Kobavashi	exists	Whittier v. Kobayashi	581 F.3d 1304	exact	party_typo	exact	false	94.444444
5,663,908	2,083,313	319,371	2,021	Golden Rule Argument Plaintiff does not oppose exclusion, provided it applies equally to both parties. Defendant agrees and requests exclusion under Blevins v. Cessna Aircraft Co., 728 F.2d 1576, 1580 (10th Cir. 1984).	153	198	728 F.2d 1576	728	F.2d	1576	1,984	Blevins	Cessna Aircraft Co.	exists	Robert B. Blevins v. Cessna Aircraft Company, a Kansas Corporation	728 F.2d 1576	surname	prefix	exact	false	100
7,425,823	278,975	106,037	2,023	A complaint must not only give the defendant notice of what the plaintiff's claim is and the grounds upon which it rests, but it must also formulate the issues by summarizing those facts essential to support the claim. Example 2 Baker et al. v. Rangos et al., 229 Pa.Super. 333, 324 A.2d 498 (1974).	249	281	229 Pa. Super. 333	229	Pa. Super.	333	1,974	null	Rangos et al.	exists	Baker Et Al., Appellants, v. Rangos Et Al; Baker Et Al., Appellants, v. U. S. Utility Service Corporation Et Al.	229 Pa. Super. 333	no_match	short_cite	exact	false	100
6,173,162	332,574	127,154	2,019	Where there are conflicting material facts, or where reasonable persons in the exercise of fair and impartial judgment might reach different conclusions from the facts, summary judgment is not proper. See Miller, 191 P.3d at 1224 (citing Buck's Sporting Goods, Inc. of Tulsa v. First Nat'l Bank & Trust Co. of Tulsa, 199...	238	327	1994 OK 14	1,994	OK	14	null	Buck's Sporting Goods, Inc. of Tulsa	First Nat'l Bank & Trust Co. of Tulsa	exists	Buck's Sporting Goods, Inc. of Tulsa v. First Nat. Bank & Trust Co. of Tulsa	1994 OK 14	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,436,757	521,045	194,354	2,022	Such action (and an action to proceed against the bond) should be heard in Oklahoma <sup>1 To assure that the parties have consented to arbitration, the courts will decide whether there is a valid enforceable arbitration agreement, whether the parties are bound by the arbitration agreement, and whether the parties a...	373	461	160 P.3d 936	160	P.3d	936	null	Oklahoma Oncology & Hematology P.C.	US Oncology, Inc.	exists	Oklahoma Oncology & Hematology P.C. v. US Oncology, Inc.	160 P.3d 936	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,501,532	256,477	98,909	2,020	Apparently Access and Sachse now agree that Oklahoma law prevents them from maintaining claims for tortious interference related to the Advisory Services Agreements because Jacob McGuire is a party to those agreements. Wilspec Techs., Inc. v. DunAn Holding Grp., Co., Ltd., 2009 OK 12, 15, 204 P.3d 69, 74 (holding "[a]d...	219	284	2009 OK 12	2,009	OK	12	null	Wilspec Techs., Inc.	DunAn Holding Grp., Co., Ltd.	exists	Wilspec Technologies, Inc. v. DunAn Holding Group Co.	2009 OK 12	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,693,850	85,429	35,723	2,019	First, the analysis fails to account for the rule of statutory construction that "...the Legislature will not be presumed to have done a vain and useless act in the promulgation of a statute, nor will an inept or incorrect choice of words be applied or construed in a manner to defeat the real or obvious purpose of a le...	342	389	173 P.3d 64	173	P.3d	64	null	Wylie	Chesser	exists	Wylie v. Chesser	173 P.3d 64	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,911,893	70,882	31,598	2,018	In 1999, 12 O.S. § 3203 was renumbered as 12 O.S. § 3226. the probative strength of the evidence to prove the fact of consequence. See James v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 1991 OK 37, 810 P.2d 365; Sellers v. State, 1991 OK CR 41, 809 P.2d 676; Hughes v. State, 1991 OK CR 18, 815 P.2d 182; and Armstrong v. State, 1...	249	293	815 P.2d 182	815	P.2d	182	null	Hughes	State	exists	Hughes v. State	815 P.2d 182	exact	exact	exact	false	100
5,615,342	2,083,265	319,371	2,021	ARGUMENT AND AUTHORITIES** THE STANDARD OF ADMISSIBILITY OF EXPERT TESTIMONY Under Oklahoma law, the trial court acts as a gatekeeper in determining the admissibility of expert testimony. Christian v. Gray, 2003 OK 10, 65 P.3d 591.	188	217	2003 OK 10	2,003	OK	10	null	Christian	Gray	exists	Christian v. Gray	2003 OK 10	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,223,857	415,169	157,340	2,019	rse of deciding that intentional and negligent tortfeasors could be submitted to factfinder for assignment of responsibility, court suggested that unidentified intentional tortfeasor may, in some cases, be submitted to factfinder for apportionment of responsibility); Bartlett v. New Mexico Welding Supply, Inc., 646 P.2...	350	384	1993 WL 518320	1,993	WL	518320	null	Stocklin	Gibson	uncovered	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,078,124	180,730	70,064	2,020	CK-FHM, 2017 WL 2177344 (N.D. Okla. May 17, 2017) 5 \| \| Cates v. Integris Health, Inc., 2018 OK 9, 412 P.3d 98 \| \| City of Tulsa v. Bank of Okla., N.A., 2011 OK 83, 280 P.3d 314 \| \| Colony Ins. Co. v. Burke, 698 F.3d 1222 (10th Cir. 2012) \| \| Curtis v. Progressive $N$. Ins. Co., No. CIV-17-1076-PRW, 2020 WL 2461482 (W....	350	381	1989 OK 137	1,989	OK	137	null	Daigle	Hamilton	exists	Daigle v. Hamilton	1989 OK 137	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,914,112	380,977	145,962	2,016	The Oklahoma Supreme Court stated that "the concept of the practice of law: the rendition of services requiring the knowledge and the application of legal principles and technique to service the interest of another with his consent." RJ Edwards Inc. v. Hert, 504 P.2d 407, 1972 OK 151.	234	271	504 P.2d 407	504	P.2d	407	null	RJ Edwards Inc.	Hert	exists	R. J. Edwards, Inc. v. Hert	504 P.2d 407	token_subset	exact	exact	false	100
7,174,532	254,956	98,461	2,020	"A petition can generally be dismissed only for lack of any cognizable legal theory to support the claim or for insufficient facts under a cognizable legal theory." Lockhart v. Loosen, 1997 OK 103, ¶ 5, 943 P.2d 1078; Indiana National Bank v. State Department of Human Services, 1994 OK 98, ¶ 4, 880 P.2d 375.	220	291	1994 OK 98	1,994	OK	98	null	Indiana National Bank	State Department of Human Services	exists	Indiana Nat. Bank v. State Dept. of Human Services	1994 OK 98	exact	exact	exact	false	100
6,735,400	500,128	188,199	2,019	As examples of such judicial innovation, Leflar reminds us that much of the modern law of insurance, corporations, trusts, oil and gas, aviation, and conflicts of law has been created by the courts from needs generated by society and accepted as a part of the common law 'whose time has come.' Gulf Oil Co. v. Woodson, 5...	366	388	508 P.2d 1069	508	P.2d	1069	null	null	Woodson	exists	Simpson v. Woodson	508 P.2d 1069	no_match	short_cite	exact	false	100
6,271,471	288,852	110,264	2,024	OHCA refuted this contention in its response brief, pointing out that Oklahoma law requires a showing of actual prejudice before agency action will be invalidated for a rule violation. See Resp. Br. at 22-23 (citing Henry v. Corp. Comm'n of State of Okla., 1990 OK 104, 825 P.2d 1262); see also Lamb v. State ex rel. Pro...	295	407	239 P.3d 973	239	P.3d	973	null	Lamb	State ex rel. Protective Health Servs. of the State Health Dep't	exists	Lamb v. State Ex Rel. Protective Health Services of the State Health Department	239 P.3d 973	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,327,069	343,447	131,029	2,021	First, while a plaintiff may file multiple notices of claim, they may only do so where each claim is presented for a different type of damages. Grisham v. City of Oklahoma City, 404 P.3d 843, 849-51 (Okla. 2017).	144	190	404 P.3d 843	404	P.3d	843	2,017	Grisham	City of Oklahoma City	exists	GRISHAM v. CITY OF OKLAHOMA CITY	404 P.3d 843	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,674,619	83,859	35,497	2,019	Oklahoma has adopted the Restatement (Second) of Torts § 552 for negligent misrepresentation: One who, in the course of his business, profession or employment, or in any other transaction in which he has a pecuniary interest, supplies false information for the guidance of others in their business transactions, is subje...	534	577	2001 OK 76	2,001	OK	76	null	Stroud	Arthur Andersen & Co.	exists	Stroud v. Arthur Andersen & Co.	2001 OK 76	exact	exact	exact	false	100
7,056,847	413,517	156,916	2,019	"[E]very party whose signature appears on a negotiable instrument is deemed prima facie to have become a party thereto for value". Mitchell v. Finance Reserve Co., 1931 OK 371, ¶8;1 P.2d 717 (Okla. 1931).	180	190	1 P.2d 717	1	P.2d	717	1,931	null	null	incomplete	null	null	null	null	null	null	null
7,914,468	381,083	145,968	2,016	Additionally, the doctrine of judicial estoppel is applied to prevent advancement of inconsistent positions vis-a-vis matters of fact. Panama Processes v. Cities Service Co., 1990 OK 66, P 22, 796 P.2d 276, 286.	135	185	1990 OK 66	1,990	OK	66	null	Panama Processes	Cities Service Co.	exists	Panama Processes, S.A. v. Cities Service Co.	1990 OK 66	prefix	exact	exact	false	100
6,182,382	157,270	62,361	2,018	Therefore, in the instant case, where the Defendants have not fully performed since the default, as evidenced by the sworn Affidavit attached hereto, Plaintiff is entitled to judgment foreclosing its mortgage. See: Riesinger's Jewelers, Inc. v. Roberson, Okla. App. 582 P.2d 409 (1978); French v. Sotheby & Company, 470 ...	215	278	582 P.2d 409	582	P.2d	409	1,978	Riesinger's Jewelers, Inc.	Roberson, Okla. App.	exists	Riesinger's Jewelers, Inc. v. Roberson	582 P.2d 409	exact	prefix	exact	false	100

End of preview. Expand in Data Studio

Legal Citation Snippets Dataset

A dataset of short text snippets drawn from real U.S. legal filings, each centered on a case-law citation, together with machine-generated Hallucite annotations about that citation. It is intended as a resource for research on legal citation extraction, verification, and hallucination detection.

Built from the Hallucite project's corpus.

Files

File	Description
`data/train.parquet`	Every citation hallucite found in Oklahoma County District Court filings, one row each. There is no held-out split: `train` is the name Hugging Face requires for a single file.

Rows are released without deduplication and are shuffled with a fixed seed, so the file order carries no meaning. Many snippets repeat verbatim across filings and cases (boilerplate propositions), and a snippet containing several citations appears once per citation.

Schema

Each row is one citation instance. Columns fall into three groups.

Identifiers & source metadata

Column	Description
`id`	Opaque internal citation id. Stable across releases.
`document_id`	Opaque internal id of the filing containing the citation. Citations sharing a `document_id` come from the same filing.
`case_id`	Opaque internal id of the case. A case can have many filings. These are internal ids, not OSCN case numbers.
`filing_year`	Year the case was filed. (This is the case filing year; a distinct per-docket-entry date is not available.)

Snippet & citation inputs

Column	Description
`snippet`	The excerpt: the citation sentence (which carries any trailing parenthetical and subsequent history) plus leading context. See Snippet construction.
`cite_char_start`, `cite_char_end`	Character offsets of the target citation within `snippet` (`snippet[cite_char_start:cite_char_end]` is the parsed case name + citation).
`cite_str`	Normalized citation, `"<volume> <reporter> <page>"` (e.g. `373 U.S. 83`).
`volume`, `reporter`, `page`	Parsed citation components.
`cited_year`	Year of the cited case, extracted from its trailing `(YYYY)` parenthetical. Null when absent (e.g. neutral cites like `1937 OK 647`).

Hallucite annotations (machine-generated — see limitations)

All prefixed hallucite_. These are outputs of the Hallucite pipeline, not human-verified labels.

Column	Description
`hallucite_plaintiff`, `hallucite_defendant`	Case-name parties parsed from the snippet.
`hallucite_status`	`exists` (citation resolves to a real case in our data), `uncovered` (reporter/volume outside our coverage), `unpublished`, `invalid` (does not resolve), `incomplete`.
`hallucite_match_case_name`	Name of the actual case the citation was matched to, if any.
`hallucite_match_citation`	Citation string of the matched case.
`hallucite_plaintiff_match_type`, `hallucite_defendant_match_type`	How each parsed party compared to the matched case's party: `exact`, `surname`, `prefix`, `token_subset`, `party_typo`, `surname_typo`, `short_cite`, `no_match`, or empty (no lookup).
`hallucite_citation_match_type`	`exact`, `volume_typo`, `page_typo`, `typo_2`, `reporter_wrong_series`, `pincite`, or empty.
`hallucite_matched_via_fuzzy`	Whether the case-name match relied on fuzzy (token-set) matching.
`hallucite_name_similarity_score`	Similarity (0–100) between the parsed and matched case names.

Snippet construction

The citation's exact character span is recovered in the cleaned document text.
Sentence boundaries are computed with nupunkt, a Punkt-style sentence tokenizer.
The snippet extends forward to the end of the citation's sentence (so any trailing parenthetical and subsequent history are included) and backward to include context: one preceding sentence.
Long string citations are capped (default ~700 chars) by trimming around the target while preserving its own parenthetical.

Limitations

Annotations are automated. The hallucite_* columns are not human-verified and may be wrong. invalid / uncovered in particular reflect our data coverage, not ground-truth hallucination — a citation can be real yet unresolved here. No human review labels are included.
One court. All filings come from the Oklahoma County District Court (scraped from OSCN), from cases filed on days 1–9 of each month, 2015-01 to 2025-07, so month-end filings are absent.
No selection. Tables of authorities, string cites, signature blocks and page-marker artifacts (e.g. [837 P.2d 479] star pages) are included as found.
Sentence segmentation is imperfect on legal text; string citations are a single sentence and can produce long, citation-dense snippets.
cited_year is heuristic (trailing-parenthetical regex) and filing_year is the case filing year, not a per-entry date.
Document text was extracted from the PDFs with Marker OCR and then cleaned; OCR errors and other extraction artifacts may remain.

Provenance & intended use

Derived from public Oklahoma County District Court filings (OSCN). Snippets are short excerpts and may contain real party and counsel names, as they appear in the public record. Intended for research on citation extraction and verification.

To request removal of a snippet, contact bl759@cornell.edu.

Downloads last month: 26

Collection including hallucite-org/citation-snippets

Hallucite

Collection

Datasets, benchmark, and results from the paper "Hallucite: Automated Detection of Hallucinated Case Citations in Real-World Court Filings" • 3 items • Updated 6 days ago