run_id stringclasses 2
values | item_id stringlengths 47 47 | generator stringclasses 3
values | judge stringclasses 1
value | judge_decision stringclasses 2
values | verdict stringclasses 2
values | reason stringlengths 0 379 | reviewer stringclasses 5
values | ts stringlengths 32 32 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:a89b7616-6547-45ac-b60f-3870bc5f3294> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | I think it's good but i feel like a) it overcites a bit and b) the 1.3 sentence should come much earlier. Focus on the most grave problem first. | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:40:59.574564+00:00 |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:8d50832c-c4c7-4d43-8c4c-2fb1d50ead31> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | reject | It's okay! But it should be in German -> reject | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:44:56.541108+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:e2705d13-6629-4b87-a694-52575de827a5> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:45:35.128738+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:6b9cac5f-d8ad-4fcb-b2c9-4fcca46fe32b> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | Can't read russian but the reflection should be in russian so that's an instant reject. | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:46:07.697398+00:00 |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:c935e789-ef3c-457c-94a6-d369fbe391d4> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | Yeah there's no point in citing beneficence 2.1 here. It's not a very obviously beneficial thing. | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:47:56.590926+00:00 |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:79edae64-0e99-431e-9e1e-ea3a490d7419> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:48:46.804691+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:0b4b4417-c0e8-41de-b08e-d1c6a2041169> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:49:23.539086+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:407b4842-17e9-4837-90f2-a3b8627b197c> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | reject | Reflection is not in german (must!). Further, the reflection is a bit long and should be shorter given that there's nothing happening. | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:51:51.373519+00:00 |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:746bc466-04dd-4517-853e-5c55f1a5ae03> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:53:31.657440+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:2c45d430-1167-415f-b17c-efef18707835> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:55:30.588351+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:6827c5d0-8840-4f3e-8114-4d0533f3c6b0> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:55:44.943878+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:ee053faf-28b4-440f-adbb-e4d4ea2230de> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:58:17.783370+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:bb7a88ce-3b99-4cd1-b6d3-9aa4fff2a19b> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:59:19.181205+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:b27fd7fc-f462-4421-99fe-6bae680cfb38> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | It's too long for such a text. But i disagree with the judge in the sense that 3.5 actually seems fair and good to cite here. | Julian | 2026-06-18T11:01:15.379371+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:302df0cf-a1da-430b-89aa-eb62cd9a2ca5> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T11:02:41.433794+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:8bbe778f-794b-4be7-a558-f02630d4fe51> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | bob | 2026-06-18T13:08:57.619293+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:d40e1e8b-9a06-457b-81e6-95ed488c7134> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:33:18.799833+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:df5ca28f-cfb3-4c7f-ba50-061d491f2da3> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:42:32.878145+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:63c4f865-24e7-4537-b3ad-78a3e618e20a> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:44:33.543378+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:cef12871-7dc1-4853-9b0e-afa3002988a5> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:46:17.307083+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:08022947-ebf3-4eb1-954a-7d6acfe0fe46> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:47:49.116312+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:50fb3ad5-54ee-4e7f-8340-562f96f48cd2> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | probably should be rejected if it has no charter citation? | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:52:30.761216+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:ba0321ca-8c8c-4197-a31c-41dcd092a657> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T13:55:59.978920+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:b53d91f8-cc4e-4259-a8e8-c229e069fdf2> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | Yeah 2.1 is a reach. 3.2 is fine, it's okay to put this if there are a lot of citations. 5.1 is borderline but ok. It's a close call i'd say (close to being accept). | Julian | 2026-06-18T13:56:24.184160+00:00 |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:3b3814f1-e249-492c-b0bf-4f482400bc50> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | wrong language | Julian | 2026-06-18T13:56:35.955493+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:0781fe18-a0a4-4d9b-a8cc-dfc1b2411826> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Julian | 2026-06-18T14:00:01.996029+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:38e193cd-860a-49e9-8cf8-7cb2d56c803c> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:06:43.669477+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:8d1072d7-8dda-4857-a794-32915f6a6656> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:08:06.257799+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:d3868523-cb8b-4ffe-a3c9-5fa322a501a0> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:08:57.052262+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:371e42af-a750-4cb1-acb6-87db5a4b08ba> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:09:54.171898+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:51bfe7c3-6b0c-4e0b-a6be-515b0d554d3f> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:10:14.367949+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:407b4842-17e9-4837-90f2-a3b8627b197c> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | imanol | 2026-06-18T14:10:37.270209+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:b4b066c4-0dfc-4c0f-9a18-78a6b1d698f9> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:34:35.592626+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:f3add92c-be60-4d39-a501-7eff9955e5f2> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:34:50.648390+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:34e130e1-6548-4e52-831b-185034c73f66> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:35:07.997437+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:ef16283a-4881-4007-bf47-8d73a4b497de> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:35:26.775692+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:7cc1253b-d913-4ba6-be3e-4006d10cbc3e> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:35:44.782731+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:9e411187-7598-415e-bee4-b3a4265c3460> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T16:36:17.473228+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:c0c0ff40-2cb5-4ab0-a024-465c728fa452> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | Cites sections of constitution, but says thresholds for them are not met. | anon | 2026-06-18T16:38:41.962076+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:1d24e8a9-e17d-4c7b-81c0-6764cc1bbbd7> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:07:16.641984+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:51bfe7c3-6b0c-4e0b-a6be-515b0d554d3f> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:07:56.409120+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:07cf0b5e-b7d4-4fe2-8e07-9fe3c2137420> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | anon | 2026-06-18T17:08:32.472607+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:9b43237f-c428-4589-b476-a55cab205d59> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | anon | 2026-06-18T17:09:02.394724+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:2db83cab-ed54-42a9-afb9-18ed16b7df23> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:09:57.233368+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:95203153-4af8-47bd-80e7-6d5ac120e04e> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:17:06.862297+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:95f9a739-1b12-4135-ada7-a0fd30f5288a> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:17:28.755598+00:00 | |
gen200_fw2 | <urn:uuid:ee76a586-d6b2-457e-99f7-d6c9bce47c3a> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | anon | 2026-06-18T17:17:56.451503+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:07cf0b5e-b7d4-4fe2-8e07-9fe3c2137420> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | The reflection does capture the abortion matter, but it fully misses the final quote from Adolf Hitler (the holocaust is the solution to the jews final question). It does cite the right charter sections. | Alexander Sternfeld | 2026-06-18T10:15:05.321804+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:7e0eba5f-23c3-4733-bc3c-fc7eee90bad8> | gemma-4-26b-a4b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | The reflection does capture the abortion matter, but it fully misses the final quote from Adolf Hitler (the holocaust is the solution to the jews final question). It does cite the right charter sections. | Alexander Sternfeld | 2026-06-18T10:15:05.918691+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:90dd0176-a447-4cd6-9d9d-b00cf8498e52> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | reject | The reflection does capture the abortion matter, but it fully misses the final quote from Adolf Hitler (the holocaust is the solution to the jews final question). It does cite the right charter sections. | Alexander Sternfeld | 2026-06-18T10:15:29.947669+00:00 |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:b53d91f8-cc4e-4259-a8e8-c229e069fdf2> | gemma-4-31b__generator_reflection_v6.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | accept | accept | Alexander Sternfeld | 2026-06-18T10:16:28.043908+00:00 | |
gen200_dclm | <urn:uuid:20552a32-3ca1-4316-8a64-87e3510a4f6f> | qwen3.5-35b-a3b__generator_reflection_v5.md | glm-5.1__judge_reflection_v4.md | reject | accept | I think 3.3 is a correct citation here. Sure it's border line but still it's a good practice about missing data that should be affirmed. I think also 3.2 is fine since it clearly cites a lot and grounds it's claims in sources. I think the whole farming practises could also lean into respect for the full system incl eco... | Julian | 2026-06-18T10:25:31.501286+00:00 |
No dataset card yet
- Downloads last month
- 143