| --- |
| language: |
| - en |
| pretty_name: PackRat v2 Compression Benchmarks |
| tags: |
| - text |
| - compression |
| - ai-memory |
| - context-compression |
| - token-optimization |
| - obsidian |
| - llm |
| - lossless |
| license: mit |
| task_categories: |
| - text-generation |
| size_categories: |
| - 1K<n<10K |
| --- |
| |
| # PackRat v2 Benchmarks |
|
|
| **Version:** 2.0.0 |
| **Date:** 2026-04-10 |
| **Tokenizer:** tiktoken cl100k_base (GPT-4 / Claude compatible) |
| **Platform:** Node.js v25.6.1, Windows 11 |
| |
| ## Summary |
| |
| | Metric | Result | |
| |--------|--------| |
| | Round-trip accuracy | **100%** (144/144 tests) | |
| | Token savings (avg) | **2.4%** | |
| | Token savings (best) | **17.3%** (path/URL-heavy files) | |
| | Byte savings (avg) | **2.5%** | |
| | Search speedup | **12.03x** | |
| | Codebook entries | 72 (auto-learned) | |
| | Negative-savings entries | 0 | |
| |
| ## Comparison: PackRat vs MemPalace |
| |
| | Metric | PackRat v2 | MemPalace (AAAK) | |
| |--------|-----------|-----------------| |
| | Accuracy | **100%** (lossless) | 84.2% (lossy) | |
| | Compression type | Lossless codebook | Lossy summarization | |
| | Token savings | 2-17% | Higher (lossy) | |
| | Data loss | **Zero** | Information dropped | |
| | Dependencies | Zero | Multiple | |
| | Decoder needed | No (self-documenting) | Yes | |
| |
| PackRat trades peak compression for perfect fidelity. No information is ever lost. |
| |
| ## Real-World Results (65 Production Files) |
| |
| Tested on 65 markdown memory files totaling 249KB / 70,014 tokens. |
| Codebook auto-learned from the same files (72 entries: 20 paths, 35 entities, 17 phrases). |
| |
| | File | Type | Bytes | Tokens | Compressed | Savings | Round-Trip | |
| |------|------|-------|--------|------------|---------|------------| |
| | file_01 | urls/config | 782 | 197 | 163 | **17.3%** | PASS | |
| | file_02 | urls/links | 5,481 | 1,666 | 1,415 | **15.1%** | PASS | |
| | file_03 | api endpoints | 2,331 | 756 | 684 | **9.5%** | PASS | |
| | file_04 | tool config | 1,939 | 623 | 565 | **9.3%** | PASS | |
| | file_05 | promo tracking | 1,703 | 471 | 433 | **8.1%** | PASS | |
| | file_06 | project notes | 2,408 | 760 | 704 | **7.4%** | PASS | |
| | file_07 | feedback rule | 585 | 143 | 133 | **7.0%** | PASS | |
| | file_08 | tool notes | 1,589 | 511 | 479 | **6.3%** | PASS | |
| | file_09 | session state | 1,934 | 568 | 532 | **6.3%** | PASS | |
| | file_10 | pipeline docs | 5,820 | 1,748 | 1,652 | **5.5%** | PASS | |
| | file_11 | platform accts | 1,644 | 639 | 604 | **5.5%** | PASS | |
| | file_12 | cli tool docs | 2,056 | 590 | 564 | **4.4%** | PASS | |
| | file_13 | project index | 6,508 | 2,002 | 1,921 | **4.0%** | PASS | |
| | file_14 | desktop app | 2,143 | 621 | 597 | **3.9%** | PASS | |
| | file_15 | app reference | 7,267 | 2,031 | 1,953 | **3.8%** | PASS | |
| | file_16 | git config | 1,576 | 420 | 405 | **3.6%** | PASS | |
| | file_17 | integration | 1,751 | 459 | 443 | **3.5%** | PASS | |
| | file_18 | memory index | 7,140 | 2,131 | 2,064 | **3.1%** | PASS | |
| | file_19 | project docs | 3,313 | 1,027 | 996 | **3.0%** | PASS | |
| | file_20 | client notes | 1,163 | 302 | 293 | **3.0%** | PASS | |
| | file_21 | feedback rule | 1,946 | 421 | 409 | **2.9%** | PASS | |
| | file_22 | tool research | 4,822 | 1,671 | 1,625 | **2.8%** | PASS | |
| | file_23 | lessons log | 13,814 | 3,776 | 3,715 | **1.6%** | PASS | |
| | file_24 | task tracker | 12,543 | 3,983 | 3,909 | **1.9%** | PASS | |
| | file_25 | app deep-dive | 35,578 | 9,555 | 9,540 | **0.2%** | PASS | |
| | **TOTAL** | **mixed** | **249,111** | **70,014** | **68,317** | **2.4%** | **65/65 PASS** | |
|
|
| *25 of 65 files shown (sorted by savings). All 65 passed round-trip. Full results in data/v2-test-results.json.* |
|
|
| ## Token Savings by Pattern Type |
|
|
| Measured with tiktoken cl100k_base: |
| |
| | Pattern Type | Example | Original Tokens | Code Tokens | Savings Per Hit | |
| |-------------|---------|-----------------|-------------|-----------------| |
| | Windows file path | `C:/Users/dev/projects/app/` | 8 | 3 | **5** | |
| | Deep file path | `C:/Users/dev/projects/myapp/src/` | 12 | 3 | **9** | |
| | Very deep path | `C:/Users/dev/Downloads/ImageGen_portable/` | 19 | 3 | **16** | |
| | GitHub URL | `https://github.com/user/repo` | 14 | 3 | **11** | |
| | Markdown header | `## CRITICAL REMINDERS` | 6 | 2 | **4** | |
| | Multi-word phrase | `via OpenRouter for free` | 5 | 2 | **3** | |
| | Tech name (multi-token) | `MyAppName` | 3 | 2 | **1** | |
| | Tech name (single-token) | `JavaScript` | 1 | 3 | **-2** (rejected) | |
|
|
| v2's token-aware scoring automatically rejects entries like "JavaScript" that cost tokens. |
|
|
| ## Test Suite (144 tests, 0 failures) |
|
|
| | Category | Tests | Description | |
| |----------|-------|-------------| |
| | Edge cases | 40 | Unicode, emoji, CJK, whitespace, code blocks, markdown, literal code-like strings, special chars, fake headers, private use area chars | |
| | Stress tests | 14 | 200x repeated words, 100x repeated paths, 50K char files, null bytes, 1-char files, long paths/URLs | |
| | Real-world files | 65 | Production AI agent memory files (read-only, no modification) | |
| | CLAUDE.md files | 12 | Project config files across multiple repos | |
| | v1 backward compat | 12 | v2 engine with v1 codebook format | |
| | Production codebook | 1 | v2 engine with a production codebook | |
|
|
| ## How to Reproduce |
|
|
| ```bash |
| git clone https://github.com/kevdogg102396-afk/packrat |
| cd packrat |
| pip install tiktoken |
| PYTHON_PATH=$(which python) node benchmark/bench.mjs |
| PYTHON_PATH=$(which python) node benchmark/tests/v2-edge-cases.mjs |
| ``` |
|
|
| ## Methodology |
|
|
| - **Token counting**: tiktoken cl100k_base via Python subprocess (batch mode) |
| - **Round-trip test**: `decompress(compress(original)) === original` (exact string equality) |
| - **Codebook**: Auto-learned from the same files being tested (no external training data) |
| - **No cherry-picking**: All 65 files in the memory directory were tested, results reported for every file |
| - **Secrets filter**: Lines containing API keys, tokens, or credentials are stripped before learning |
| |
