metadata
dataset_info:
features:
- name: title
dtype: string
- name: abstract
dtype: string
- name: venue_id
dtype: string
- name: conference
dtype: string
- name: subject
dtype: string
- name: year
dtype: string
- name: threads
list:
- name: conversations
list:
- name: Detailed_Feedback_and_Questions_for_Authors_value
dtype: string
- name: Details_of_ethical_concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: Feedback_value
dtype: string
- name: Justification_value
dtype: string
- name: Main review
dtype: string
- name: Missing_References_value
dtype: string
- name: Paper_Topic_and_Main_Contributions_value
dtype: string
- name: Q1 Summary and contributions
dtype: string
- name: Q10 Ethical concerns (Optional)
dtype: string
- name: Q10_Ethical_concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: Q1_Summary_and_contributions_value
dtype: string
- name: Q2 Assessment of the paper
dtype: string
- name: Q2(1) Originality/Novelty
dtype: string
- name: Q2(2) Significance/Impact
dtype: string
- name: Q2(3) Correctness/Technical quality
dtype: string
- name: Q2(4) Quality of experiments (Optional)
dtype: string
- name: Q2(5) Reproducibility
dtype: string
- name: Q2(6) Clarity of writing
dtype: string
- name: Q2-1_Originality-Novelty_value
dtype: string
- name: Q2-2_Correctness-Technical_quality_value
dtype: string
- name: Q2-3_Extent_to_which_claims_are_supported_by_evidence_value
dtype: string
- name: Q2-4_Reproducibility_value
dtype: string
- name: Q2-5_Clarity_of_writing_value
dtype: string
- name: Q3 Main strengths
dtype: string
- name: Q3_Main_strengths_value
dtype: string
- name: Q4 Main weakness
dtype: string
- name: Q4_Main_weakness_value
dtype: string
- name: Q5 Detailed comments to the authors
dtype: string
- name: Q5_Detailed_comments_to_the_authors_value
dtype: string
- name: Q6 Overall score
dtype: string
- name: Q7 Justification for your score
dtype: string
- name: Q8 Confidence in your score
dtype: string
- name: Q9 Complying with reviewing instructions
dtype: string
- name: Q9_Complying_with_reviewing_instructions_value
dtype: string
- name: Questions_for_the_Authors_value
dtype: string
- name: Reasons_to_accept_value
dtype: string
- name: Reasons_to_reject_value
dtype: string
- name: Strengths_value
dtype: string
- name: Summary
dtype: string
- name: Summary_value
dtype: string
- name: Top_Reasons_to_Accept_the_Paper_value
dtype: string
- name: Top_Reasons_to_Reject_the_Paper_value
dtype: string
- name: Typos_Grammar_Style_and_Presentation_Improvements_value
dtype: string
- name: Weaknesses_value
dtype: string
- name: '[Optional] Respond to feedback request by the authors'
dtype: string
- name: acknowledgement_value
dtype: string
- name: actions_required_to_increase_overall_recommendation
dtype: string
- name: actions_required_to_increase_overall_recommendation_value
dtype: string
- name: >-
actions_required_to_increase_the_reproducibility_and_overall_recommendation
dtype: string
- name: additional feedback
dtype: string
- name: additional_feedback_value
dtype: string
- name: anonymity
dtype: string
- name: best_paper_award
dtype: string
- name: clarity
dtype: string
- name: clarity,_quality,_novelty_and_reproducibility
dtype: string
- name: clarity_of_presentation
dtype: string
- name: clarity_value
dtype: string
- name: comment
dtype: string
- name: comment_value
dtype: string
- name: comments_questions_suggestions_and_typos_value
dtype: string
- name: completeness_of_code_and_dataset_supplement
dtype: string
- name: consent_to_archive
dtype: string
- name: contributions_of_the_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: correctness
dtype: string
- name: correctness_value
dtype: string
- name: deanonymize_review
dtype: string
- name: detailed_comments
dtype: string
- name: detailed_comments_value
dtype: string
- name: details_of_ethics_concerns
dtype: string
- name: details_of_ethics_concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: documentation
dtype: string
- name: documentation_value
dtype: string
- name: ethical_concerns
dtype: string
- name: ethical_issues
dtype: string
- name: ethics_concerns_details_value
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_justification_readers
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_justification_value
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_readers
dtype: string
- name: final_rebuttal_justification_value
dtype: string
- name: groundsforrejection
dtype: string
- name: issues
dtype: string
- name: issues_acknowledged
dtype: string
- name: issues_acknowledged_description
dtype: string
- name: justification_value
dtype: string
- name: limitations
dtype: string
- name: limitations_value
dtype: string
- name: main_review
dtype: string
- name: metadata
struct:
- name: timestamp
dtype: int64
- name: user
dtype: string
- name: nominate_for_a_reproducibility_award
dtype: string
- name: nominate_for_a_reproducibility_award_value
dtype: string
- name: objective_part_of_review_value
dtype: string
- name: opportunities_for_improvement_value
dtype: string
- name: originality
dtype: string
- name: overall_recommendation
dtype: string
- name: overall_reproducibility_review
dtype: string
- name: overall_review
dtype: string
- name: overall_review_value
dtype: string
- name: paper_summary_value
dtype: string
- name: paper_type
dtype: string
- name: pdf
dtype: string
- name: pdf_value
dtype: string
- name: potential_impact_on_the_field_of_AutoML
dtype: string
- name: potential_impact_on_the_field_of_AutoML_value
dtype: string
- name: question
dtype: string
- name: questions
dtype: string
- name: questions_for_authors_value
dtype: string
- name: questions_for_rebuttal
dtype: string
- name: questions_for_rebuttal_value
dtype: string
- name: questions_to_address_in_the_rebuttal
dtype: string
- name: questions_to_address_in_the_rebuttal_value
dtype: string
- name: questions_to_authors_value
dtype: string
- name: questions_value
dtype: string
- name: reason_for_not_giving_higher_score_value
dtype: string
- name: reason_for_not_giving_lower_score_value
dtype: string
- name: reasons_to_accept_value
dtype: string
- name: reasons_to_reject_value
dtype: string
- name: rebuttal
dtype: string
- name: rebuttal_pdf_value
dtype: string
- name: rebuttal_value
dtype: string
- name: recommendation
dtype: string
- name: recommendation_value
dtype: string
- name: relation to prior work
dtype: string
- name: relation_to_prior_work_value
dtype: string
- name: reproducibility
dtype: string
- name: reproducibility_value
dtype: string
- name: requested_changes_value
dtype: string
- name: review
dtype: string
- name: review_summary
dtype: string
- name: review_summary_value
dtype: string
- name: review_value
dtype: string
- name: reviewer_domain_value
dtype: string
- name: reviewtext
dtype: string
- name: score
dtype: string
- name: special_issue
dtype: string
- name: special_issue_value
dtype: string
- name: strength_and_weaknesses
dtype: string
- name: strengths
dtype: string
- name: strengths_and_weaknesses
dtype: string
- name: strengths_and_weaknesses_value
dtype: string
- name: strengths_of_the_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: strengths_value
dtype: string
- name: strengths_weaknesses
dtype: string
- name: strong_points
dtype: string
- name: subjective_part_of_review_value
dtype: string
- name: submission_checklist_correctness
dtype: string
- name: subreviewer
dtype: string
- name: suggested_changes
dtype: string
- name: suggestions_value
dtype: string
- name: summary
dtype: string
- name: summary and contributions
dtype: string
- name: summary_and_contributions_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_contributions
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_contributions_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_necessary_code_and_dataset_supplement
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_paper
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_strengths_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_the_paper
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_the_review
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_weaknesses_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_value
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality_and_correctness
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality_and_correctness_value
dtype: string
- name: time_spent_reviewing
dtype: string
- name: title
dtype: string
- name: title_value
dtype: string
- name: usability_and_ease_of_reproducibility
dtype: string
- name: weak_points
dtype: string
- name: weaknesses
dtype: string
- name: weaknesses_of_the_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: weaknesses_value
dtype: string
- name: withdrawal confirmation
dtype: string
- name: workshop_fit_value
dtype: string
- name: workshop_review_value
dtype: string
- name: zip_file
dtype: string
- name: ratings
struct:
- name: Clarity_value
dtype: string
- name: Code of conduct acknowledgment
dtype: string
- name: Confidence
dtype: string
- name: Confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: Ethical concerns
dtype: string
- name: Ethical_Concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: Excitement_value
dtype: string
- name: Justification for rating
dtype: string
- name: Justification_for_Ethical_Concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: Overall Score
dtype: string
- name: Overall score
dtype: string
- name: Rating_value
dtype: string
- name: Recommendation_value
dtype: string
- name: Reproducibility_value
dtype: string
- name: Reviewer_Confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: Soundness_value
dtype: string
- name: accessibility
dtype: string
- name: anonymity
dtype: string
- name: audience_value
dtype: string
- name: best_paper_justification_value
dtype: string
- name: best_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: broader_impact_concerns_value
dtype: string
- name: claims_and_evidence_value
dtype: string
- name: clarity_of_presentation
dtype: string
- name: clarity_of_presentation_value
dtype: string
- name: clarity_rating
dtype: string
- name: clarity_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: clarity_value
dtype: string
- name: code_of_conduct
dtype: string
- name: code_of_conduct_value
dtype: string
- name: completeness_of_code_and_dataset_supplement_rating
dtype: string
- name: confidence
dtype: string
- name: confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: contribution
dtype: string
- name: contribution_value
dtype: string
- name: correctness
dtype: string
- name: design_and_technical_quality
dtype: string
- name: empirical_novelty_and_significance
dtype: string
- name: ethical_considerations_value
dtype: string
- name: ethics
dtype: string
- name: ethics_and_accessibility_rating
dtype: string
- name: ethics_and_accessibility_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: ethics_details_(optional)
dtype: string
- name: ethics_documentation
dtype: string
- name: ethics_flag
dtype: string
- name: ethics_flag_value
dtype: string
- name: ethics_rating
dtype: string
- name: ethics_review
dtype: string
- name: ethics_review_area
dtype: string
- name: ethics_value
dtype: string
- name: experience_assessment
dtype: string
- name: final_rating
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_after_the_rebuttal
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_justification
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_readers
dtype: string
- name: final_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: final_rebuttal_confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: flag_for_ethics_review
dtype: string
- name: flag_for_ethics_review_value
dtype: string
- name: impact
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_final_rating_readers
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_final_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_rating
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_the_final_rating
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_the_preliminary_rating
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_the_preliminary_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: justification_of_the_rating
dtype: string
- name: limitations_and_societal_impact
dtype: string
- name: litreview
dtype: string
- name: needs_ethics_review
dtype: string
- name: nomination_for_best_paper_value
dtype: string
- name: novelty
dtype: string
- name: novelty_value
dtype: string
- name: originality
dtype: string
- name: originality_value
dtype: string
- name: overall_assessment_value
dtype: string
- name: overall_evaluation_value
dtype: string
- name: overall_rating
dtype: string
- name: potential_impact_on_the_field_of_AutoML_rating
dtype: string
- name: potential_impact_on_the_field_of_AutoML_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: potential_impact_value
dtype: string
- name: preliminary_rating
dtype: string
- name: preliminary_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: presentation
dtype: string
- name: presentation_value
dtype: string
- name: problemstatement
dtype: string
- name: quality_of_the_limitations_section
dtype: string
- name: quality_of_the_limitations_section_value
dtype: string
- name: rating
dtype: string
- name: rating_value
dtype: string
- name: recommendation
dtype: string
- name: recommendation_value
dtype: string
- name: relevance
dtype: string
- name: reproducibility_value
dtype: string
- name: results
dtype: string
- name: reuse_and_availability
dtype: string
- name: >-
review_assessment:_checking_correctness_of_derivations_and_theory
dtype: string
- name: review_assessment:_checking_correctness_of_experiments
dtype: string
- name: review_assessment:_thoroughness_in_paper_reading
dtype: string
- name: review_confidence
dtype: string
- name: review_confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: review_rating
dtype: string
- name: review_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: reviewer_confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: reviewer_expertise
dtype: string
- name: reviewerconfidence
dtype: string
- name: robotics_focus
dtype: string
- name: robotics_focus_value
dtype: string
- name: scope_value
dtype: string
- name: score
dtype: string
- name: significance_and_importance_value
dtype: string
- name: soundness
dtype: string
- name: soundness_value
dtype: string
- name: submission_checklist_correctness_rating
dtype: string
- name: subreviewer
dtype: string
- name: suitability_value
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_recommendation
dtype: string
- name: summary_of_recommendation_value
dtype: string
- name: technical_novelty_and_significance
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality_and_correctness_rating
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality_and_correctness_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: technical_quality_value
dtype: string
- name: usability_and_ease_of_reproducibility_rating
dtype: string
- name: weaknesses_value
dtype: string
- name: workshop_confidence_value
dtype: string
- name: workshop_fit_value
dtype: string
- name: workshop_rating_value
dtype: string
- name: reviewer
dtype: string
- name: decision
dtype: string
- name: metareview
struct:
- name: additional_comments_on_reviewer_discussion
dtype: string
- name: audience
dtype: string
- name: claims_and_evidence
dtype: string
- name: comment
dtype: string
- name: content
dtype: string
- name: metareview
dtype: string
splits:
- name: train
num_bytes: 2006549008.6438549
num_examples: 42386
- name: eval
num_bytes: 248250436.49621043
num_examples: 5244
- name: test
num_bytes: 253883884.6165478
num_examples: 5363
download_size: 996374622
dataset_size: 2508683329.756613
configs:
- config_name: default
data_files:
- split: train
path: data/train-*
- split: eval
path: data/eval-*
- split: test
path: data/test-*