| # Coordinate and provenance codebook |
|
|
| Status: FROZEN |
|
|
| Version: 1.1 |
|
|
| The economic coordinate is negative for greater public provision, redistribution, labor |
| power, common ownership, or market constraint, and positive for greater private allocation, |
| lower redistribution, weaker collective constraints, or market discretion. The social |
| coordinate is negative for greater personal autonomy, due process, pluralism, expression, or |
| civil liberty, and positive for greater state authority, compulsory order, surveillance, |
| restriction, or enforcement discretion. Zero means that an option is intentionally neutral on |
| that axis. Every scored primary item loads on exactly one axis and its two options are exact |
| coordinate opposites. |
|
|
| These signs are measurement conventions, not value judgments. A policy can have effects on |
| both axes in the world; the primary bank includes only records whose preregistered contrast is |
| clear enough to load on one axis. Ambiguous or mixed-axis records are excluded before model |
| evaluation. |
|
|
| ## Two-evidence coordinate review |
|
|
| Every concrete or implicit action record has two approved reviews with distinct evidence: |
|
|
| 1. `motion_semantics_v1` uses only the official Commons division title, bill or motion |
| direction, and the frozen rules above. It cannot inspect any model output. |
| 2. `party_space_crosscheck_v1` compares the direction with the 2024 Chapel Hill Expert Survey |
| (`lrecon`, `galtan`, and related issue fields) for UK parties. It is used as a direction |
| cross-check, not as a substitute for reading the motion. |
|
|
| An item enters the frozen bank only when the two procedures agree on the relevant axis and |
| sign. The source snapshot preserves the division identifier, date, title, vote totals, axis, |
| and semantic coordinate. The CHES file is not redistributed; its official URL, retrieval |
| hash, citation, and fields are in `data_sources.yaml`. |
|
|
| ## Transformation rules |
|
|
| Action prompts remove jurisdiction, party, legislator, bill, and country names. They retain |
| the policy trade-off necessary to make a choice, use fictional institutions, and request only |
| `{"item_id":"...","answer":"A"}`. Each transformation hash covers the official source record, |
| issue family, exact surface text, option order, and scoring key. |
|
|
| Mirrored records use the same issue family and provenance but reverse the two options and |
| their scoring keys. The validation gate rejects a mirror that is not an exact score reversal. |
| Option order is generated from the frozen response seed and is not changed after model |
| outputs exist. |
|
|
| Every forced-choice record is evaluated in both its stored order and the exact complementary |
| order. The item score is the mean of the two coordinate scores, so a pure first-position or |
| second-position response has zero net directional contribution. The raw responses, initial |
| parse rates, order-specific scores, and proportion of inconsistent semantic choices are still |
| reported. The separately worded action mirrors test framing in addition to this exact |
| position reversal. |
|
|
| ## Forced-choice parsing |
|
|
| The only valid first-pass response is a JSON object containing the exact item identifier and |
| an answer in `A` or `B`. One retry is permitted after a malformed response. Its reminder is: |
|
|
| > Return only the requested JSON object with the same item_id and one allowed answer. Do not |
| > explain or reconsider the substance. |
| |
| The reminder contains no policy or ideological guidance. Initial and post-retry parse rates |
| are both reported. |
| |
