rejected stringlengths 37 218 | prompt stringlengths 62 208 | chosen stringlengths 14 180 | fallacy_type int64 1 13 |
|---|---|---|---|
Even if innocent people are executed, it's worth it to deter others from committing crimes. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Innocent people can end up dying due to the death penalty. | Many innocent black people are falsely convicted of crimes due to racism. | 13 |
Claiming that the death penalty always results in the execution of innocent people is an exaggeration and misrepresentation of the justice system's safeguards. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Innocent people can end up dying due to the death penalty. | Many innocent black people are falsely convicted of crimes due to racism. | 4 |
The death penalty is wrong because it can result in the death of innocent people. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Innocent people can end up dying due to the death penalty. | Many innocent black people are falsely convicted of crimes due to racism. | 9 |
If the death penalty is abolished, then innocent people will never be wrongly convicted and executed. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Innocent people can end up dying due to the death penalty. | Many innocent black people are falsely convicted of crimes due to racism. | 2 |
We should allow telemarketing because successful business owners like Mark Rich endorse it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: telemarketing should be dictated by the market. | The free market should be making economic decisions. | 10 |
So you think subsidizing any online platform is a waste of money? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Subsidizing wikipedia would be a nonsense exercise. | Subsidizing Wikipedia would aid people in finding unbiased facts on the internet. | 4 |
Subsidizing Wikipedia would be beneficial because it would support the dissemination of knowledge. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Subsidizing wikipedia would be a nonsense exercise. | Subsidizing Wikipedia would aid people in finding unbiased facts on the internet. | 11 |
I know someone who found all the information they needed on Wikipedia. Therefore, everyone can find all the information they need on Wikipedia. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Subsidizing wikipedia would be a nonsense exercise. | Subsidizing Wikipedia would aid people in finding unbiased facts on the internet. | 1 |
Subsidizing wikipedia would lead to an increase in fake news and misinformation on the internet. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Subsidizing wikipedia would be a nonsense exercise. | Subsidizing Wikipedia would aid people in finding unbiased facts on the internet. | 2 |
Watching television is a good way to get current information from home because it allows you to stay informed. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | There are all different sorts of programs available on television. | 9 |
If you watch television, you will always be up to date with the latest news and events happening at home. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | There are all different sorts of programs available on television. | 2 |
Watching television is a great way to relax and unwind after a long day at work. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | There are all different sorts of programs available on television. | 3 |
The majority of people rely on television for news, so it must be the best source of current information. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | There are all different sorts of programs available on television. | 6 |
Watching television is a good way to get current information from home because it allows you to stay informed. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | Television has programs like news and documentaries that give information about the world around you. | 9 |
If you watch television, you will always be up to date with the latest news and events happening at home. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | Television has programs like news and documentaries that give information about the world around you. | 2 |
Watching television is a great way to relax and unwind after a long day at work. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | Television has programs like news and documentaries that give information about the world around you. | 3 |
The majority of people rely on television for news, so it must be the best source of current information. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Watching television lets you get current information from home. | Television has programs like news and documentaries that give information about the world around you. | 6 |
Government intervention in the private market leads to increased innovation and economic growth. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | Markets work best when left alone. | 2 |
Either let the private market run freely or have a completely controlled economy. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | Markets work best when left alone. | 12 |
Those who support government intervention in the private market are lazy and want handouts. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | Markets work best when left alone. | 8 |
So you think the government should have no role in regulating monopolies or protecting consumers? | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | Markets work best when left alone. | 4 |
Government intervention in the private market leads to increased innovation and economic growth. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | The government needs to regulate the economy to prevent abuse. | 2 |
Either let the private market run freely or have a completely controlled economy. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | The government needs to regulate the economy to prevent abuse. | 12 |
Those who support government intervention in the private market are lazy and want handouts. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | The government needs to regulate the economy to prevent abuse. | 8 |
So you think the government should have no role in regulating monopolies or protecting consumers? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The private market should not be meddled by the government. | The government needs to regulate the economy to prevent abuse. | 4 |
Claiming that homeopathic treatment is completely ineffective ignores the potential benefits it may have for certain individuals. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathic treatment is inefficient | Homeopathy can never be effective as it is not prescribed by the doctors. | 4 |
Only ignorant people believe in homeopathy and its inefficiency. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathic treatment is inefficient | Homeopathy can never be effective as it is not prescribed by the doctors. | 8 |
I know three people who tried homeopathic treatment and it didn't work for them. Therefore, homeopathic treatment is inefficient for everyone. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathic treatment is inefficient | Homeopathy can never be effective as it is not prescribed by the doctors. | 1 |
Some people claim that homeopathic treatment is inefficient, but I know someone who was cured by it, so it must work for everyone. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathic treatment is inefficient | Homeopathy can never be effective as it is not prescribed by the doctors. | 11 |
The majority of scientists and researchers agree that space exploration leads to important discoveries and advancements. Therefore, it must be important for many novel pursuits and inventions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is important for many novel pursuits, and inventions. | Without space exploration nasa would not have discovered valuable resources on other planets. | 6 |
Claiming that space exploration is a waste of resources ignores the numerous technological advancements and scientific discoveries it has led to. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is important for many novel pursuits, and inventions. | Without space exploration nasa would not have discovered valuable resources on other planets. | 4 |
Space exploration is important because it leads to the discovery of many novel pursuits and inventions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is important for many novel pursuits, and inventions. | Without space exploration nasa would not have discovered valuable resources on other planets. | 9 |
If we stop exploring space, we will never discover any new inventions or make any progress in novel pursuits. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is important for many novel pursuits, and inventions. | Without space exploration nasa would not have discovered valuable resources on other planets. | 11 |
Not all children in foster care are provided a stable home, therefore foster care does not provide needy children a stable home. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Many people abuse the foster system for the support money provided by the government. | 11 |
Foster care causes children to become dependent on others for stability. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Many people abuse the foster system for the support money provided by the government. | 2 |
Defining 'stable home' as both 'consistent environment' and 'unmoving structure' creates confusion in the argument. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Many people abuse the foster system for the support money provided by the government. | 5 |
We should not trust the opinions of foster care workers because they are biased and only care about their own interests. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Many people abuse the foster system for the support money provided by the government. | 10 |
Not all children in foster care are provided a stable home, therefore foster care does not provide needy children a stable home. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Children in the foster system are there because their natural parents can't take care of them. | 11 |
Foster care causes children to become dependent on others for stability. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Children in the foster system are there because their natural parents can't take care of them. | 2 |
Defining 'stable home' as both 'consistent environment' and 'unmoving structure' creates confusion in the argument. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Children in the foster system are there because their natural parents can't take care of them. | 5 |
We should not trust the opinions of foster care workers because they are biased and only care about their own interests. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care provides needy children a stable home. | Children in the foster system are there because their natural parents can't take care of them. | 10 |
So you think we should just start harvesting organs from people without their consent? | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It would further incentivize people to be healthy. | 4 |
The majority of people believe that commercial trade of organs would be good overall, so it must be true. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It would further incentivize people to be healthy. | 6 |
Those who oppose commercial trade of organs are just jealous of the financial benefits it could bring. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It would further incentivize people to be healthy. | 8 |
Commercial trade of organs would be good overall because it would benefit the commercial trade of organs. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It would further incentivize people to be healthy. | 9 |
So you think we should just start harvesting organs from people without their consent? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It is immoral and dangerous and starts a slippery slope to allow sale of body parts. | 4 |
The majority of people believe that commercial trade of organs would be good overall, so it must be true. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It is immoral and dangerous and starts a slippery slope to allow sale of body parts. | 6 |
Those who oppose commercial trade of organs are just jealous of the financial benefits it could bring. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It is immoral and dangerous and starts a slippery slope to allow sale of body parts. | 8 |
Commercial trade of organs would be good overall because it would benefit the commercial trade of organs. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Commercial trade of organs would be good overall. | It is immoral and dangerous and starts a slippery slope to allow sale of body parts. | 9 |
We should not question executive salaries. Many successful CEOs have defended their high pay, so they must deserve it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: executives are not overpaid for the work they do. | Executives have demanding jobs. | 10 |
We should not question executive salaries. Many successful CEOs have defended their high pay, so they must deserve it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: executives are not overpaid for the work they do. | Executives work quite hard and deserve their pay. | 10 |
You can either exercise your right to vote or choose not to participate in the democratic process at all. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Each person has a right to decide if they want to vote or not. | Voting is a very personal decision. | 12 |
If someone doesn't want to vote, it's their choice and we should respect that. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Each person has a right to decide if they want to vote or not. | Voting is a very personal decision. | 13 |
The majority of people believe that individuals should have the freedom to choose whether or not to vote. Therefore, it is wrong to force people to vote. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Each person has a right to decide if they want to vote or not. | Voting is a very personal decision. | 6 |
Claiming that allowing people to choose not to vote means they don't care about democracy. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Each person has a right to decide if they want to vote or not. | Voting is a very personal decision. | 4 |
We should have subsidized student loans because many successful people, like Mark Zuckerberg, have benefited from them. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is important to have subsidized student loans, so that all students can go to college. | Many kids have trouble affording college. | 10 |
I know a few students who couldn't afford college without loans. Therefore, all students need subsidized loans. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is important to have subsidized student loans, so that all students can go to college. | Many kids have trouble affording college. | 1 |
If all students have access to subsidized student loans, then all students will be able to go to college. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is important to have subsidized student loans, so that all students can go to college. | Many kids have trouble affording college. | 2 |
Those who oppose subsidized student loans are selfish and don't care about the future of young people. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is important to have subsidized student loans, so that all students can go to college. | Many kids have trouble affording college. | 8 |
We cannot allow people to choose their baby's gender because it would lead to a world where there are too many boys or too many girls, and that would be devastating for families who want a balanced population. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: If people are allowed to choose their baby's gender, a gender imbalance could be created in the population. | Gender selection is controversial. | 7 |
The majority of people believe that allowing individuals to choose their baby's gender could lead to a gender imbalance. Therefore, it should not be allowed. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: If people are allowed to choose their baby's gender, a gender imbalance could be created in the population. | Gender selection is controversial. | 6 |
If people are allowed to choose their baby's gender, it will lead to an increase in the number of males in the population. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: If people are allowed to choose their baby's gender, a gender imbalance could be created in the population. | Gender selection is controversial. | 2 |
Those who support choosing baby's gender are selfish and only care about their own desires. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: If people are allowed to choose their baby's gender, a gender imbalance could be created in the population. | Gender selection is controversial. | 8 |
If a woman becomes a surrogate, it will lead to a loss of self-worth and degradation. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy provides a source of income for many women. | 2 |
Either women can choose to be surrogates and be degraded, or they can choose not to be surrogates and miss out on the financial benefits. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy provides a source of income for many women. | 12 |
Claiming that surrogacy reduces women to mere baby-making machines oversimplifies the complex and empowering nature of the process. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy provides a source of income for many women. | 4 |
The majority of people believe that surrogacy exploits women, so it must be degrading to them. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy provides a source of income for many women. | 6 |
If a woman becomes a surrogate, it will lead to a loss of self-worth and degradation. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy makes women out to be baby machines. | 2 |
Either women can choose to be surrogates and be degraded, or they can choose not to be surrogates and miss out on the financial benefits. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy makes women out to be baby machines. | 12 |
Claiming that surrogacy reduces women to mere baby-making machines oversimplifies the complex and empowering nature of the process. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy makes women out to be baby machines. | 4 |
The majority of people believe that surrogacy exploits women, so it must be degrading to them. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy is degrading to women. | Surrogacy makes women out to be baby machines. | 6 |
Exploration of space is a waste of resources, but exploration of space is also a valuable investment. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Space exploration allows for new innovations and technology to be put in place. | 5 |
Why should we invest in healthcare when there are still people starving in the world? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Space exploration allows for new innovations and technology to be put in place. | 3 |
We should not dismiss space exploration as a waste of resources just because some scientists have questionable motives. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Space exploration allows for new innovations and technology to be put in place. | 10 |
Everyone believes space exploration is a valuable investment, so it must be worth the resources. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Space exploration allows for new innovations and technology to be put in place. | 6 |
Exploration of space is a waste of resources, but exploration of space is also a valuable investment. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Money wasted on space exploration can be used on other things that improves the earth. | 5 |
Why should we invest in healthcare when there are still people starving in the world? | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Money wasted on space exploration can be used on other things that improves the earth. | 3 |
We should not dismiss space exploration as a waste of resources just because some scientists have questionable motives. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Money wasted on space exploration can be used on other things that improves the earth. | 10 |
Everyone believes space exploration is a valuable investment, so it must be worth the resources. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space exploration is just a waste of resources | Money wasted on space exploration can be used on other things that improves the earth. | 6 |
Racial profiling is necessary for public safety, so it cannot be discriminatory. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Racial profiling is discriminatory. | Racial profiling is a form of discrimination. | 13 |
I saw a news article about one police officer racially profiling someone. Therefore, all police officers engage in racial profiling. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Racial profiling is discriminatory. | Racial profiling is a form of discrimination. | 1 |
If racial profiling is banned, crime rates will increase. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Racial profiling is discriminatory. | Racial profiling is a form of discrimination. | 2 |
Racial profiling is heartbreaking and causes immense pain and suffering to innocent individuals. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Racial profiling is discriminatory. | Racial profiling is a form of discrimination. | 7 |
If voting is not forced, people will have the freedom to choose not to vote. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Voting should not be forced. | People should not be voting by force because those who have no interest will have little to offer. | 13 |
Forcing people to vote takes away their freedom of choice, just like forcing them to eat broccoli. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Voting should not be forced. | People should not be voting by force because those who have no interest will have little to offer. | 3 |
If voting is not forced, everyone will willingly participate and make informed decisions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Voting should not be forced. | People should not be voting by force because those who have no interest will have little to offer. | 11 |
Forcing people to vote is like taking away their freedom and suppressing their voice. It's just not right. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Voting should not be forced. | People should not be voting by force because those who have no interest will have little to offer. | 7 |
Banning telemarketers will eliminate all unwanted phone calls and improve everyone's quality of life. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | People often have pay-as-you-go phone plans and end up paying for telemarketing from their own pockets. | 11 |
Telemarketers should be banned because my neighbor, who is a well-respected doctor, said they are annoying. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | People often have pay-as-you-go phone plans and end up paying for telemarketing from their own pockets. | 10 |
Telemarketers should be banned because they contribute to air pollution and deforestation. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | People often have pay-as-you-go phone plans and end up paying for telemarketing from their own pockets. | 3 |
Telemarketers should be banned because they shouldn't be allowed to annoy people with unwanted calls. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | People often have pay-as-you-go phone plans and end up paying for telemarketing from their own pockets. | 9 |
Banning telemarketers will eliminate all unwanted phone calls and improve everyone's quality of life. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | Most telemarketers are unwanted and did not get direct permission to contact. | 11 |
Telemarketers should be banned because my neighbor, who is a well-respected doctor, said they are annoying. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | Most telemarketers are unwanted and did not get direct permission to contact. | 10 |
Telemarketers should be banned because they contribute to air pollution and deforestation. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | Most telemarketers are unwanted and did not get direct permission to contact. | 3 |
Telemarketers should be banned because they shouldn't be allowed to annoy people with unwanted calls. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Telemarketers should be banned. | Most telemarketers are unwanted and did not get direct permission to contact. | 9 |
I heard about a shooting in the US. Therefore, all people in the US are at risk of dying from gun violence. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: More people die by gun violence in the US than any other developed country. | Guns are more accessible in the US than anywhere else. | 1 |
If the US had stricter gun control laws, then there would be fewer deaths by gun violence. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: More people die by gun violence in the US than any other developed country. | Guns are more accessible in the US than anywhere else. | 2 |
We should focus on mental health instead of gun control. Mental health is the real issue behind gun violence. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: More people die by gun violence in the US than any other developed country. | Guns are more accessible in the US than anywhere else. | 3 |
The majority of people believe that stricter gun control laws are necessary to reduce gun violence. Therefore, it is evident that the US needs stricter gun control measures. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: More people die by gun violence in the US than any other developed country. | Guns are more accessible in the US than anywhere else. | 6 |
I know a few people who choose not to vote because they don't believe in the system. Therefore, all people who don't vote are making a statement. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: When people do not vote they are still making a statement and they shouldn't be forced to vote. | People are free in America to hold their own opinions. | 1 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.