rejected stringlengths 37 218 | prompt stringlengths 62 208 | chosen stringlengths 14 180 | fallacy_type int64 1 13 |
|---|---|---|---|
If we ban whaling, all the workers in the whaling industry will become unemployed and have no other job opportunities. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Banning whaling will hurt the workforce. | By banning whaling, people will not be able to use this as a career path. | 11 |
Those who support banning whaling are ignorant and have no understanding of the economic impact on the workforce. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Banning whaling will hurt the workforce. | By banning whaling, people will not be able to use this as a career path. | 8 |
The majority of people in whaling communities rely on the industry for their livelihoods, so banning whaling would harm the workforce. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Banning whaling will hurt the workforce. | By banning whaling, people will not be able to use this as a career path. | 6 |
I know a whaler who lost his job. Therefore, banning whaling will cause unemployment for all whalers. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Banning whaling will hurt the workforce. | By banning whaling, people will not be able to use this as a career path. | 1 |
We should ban surrogacy because the idea of a woman being separated from her biological child is heart-wrenching. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy causes emotional distress. | The attachment that a surrogate mother experiences is not easily broken, when they give up their offspring. | 7 |
Surrogacy causes emotional distress because it leads to negative emotions and distress. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy causes emotional distress. | The attachment that a surrogate mother experiences is not easily broken, when they give up their offspring. | 9 |
Some people who have been involved in surrogacy have reported emotional distress. Therefore, all people who engage in surrogacy will experience emotional distress. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy causes emotional distress. | The attachment that a surrogate mother experiences is not easily broken, when they give up their offspring. | 11 |
Claiming all surrogacy cases cause emotional distress oversimplifies the complex range of emotions involved. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Surrogacy causes emotional distress. | The attachment that a surrogate mother experiences is not easily broken, when they give up their offspring. | 4 |
People who abstain from sexual relations and marriage are more likely to live longer and healthier lives. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: There are still people who practice the act of abstaining from sexual relation and marriage | Celibacy should not be put aside as it is an act which people put as important aspect of their life. | 2 |
You can either practice abstinence and remain single, or engage in sexual relations and get married. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: There are still people who practice the act of abstaining from sexual relation and marriage | Celibacy should not be put aside as it is an act which people put as important aspect of their life. | 12 |
Many people believe in natural remedies, so they must be effective in curing diseases. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is bad to believe your body can naturally cure diseases. | Your body cannot naturally cure many diseases, which is why we have prescription medicines. | 13 |
I know someone who believed in natural remedies and died from a curable disease. Therefore, all natural remedies are ineffective. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is bad to believe your body can naturally cure diseases. | Your body cannot naturally cure many diseases, which is why we have prescription medicines. | 1 |
It is bad to believe your body can naturally cure diseases because it can lead to neglecting medical treatment. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is bad to believe your body can naturally cure diseases. | Your body cannot naturally cure many diseases, which is why we have prescription medicines. | 5 |
If you believe your body can naturally cure diseases, you will never seek medical treatment and will suffer the consequences. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It is bad to believe your body can naturally cure diseases. | Your body cannot naturally cure many diseases, which is why we have prescription medicines. | 11 |
The majority of people believe that the right to bear arms is essential for self-defense, so it should be protected. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People have the right to bear arm in other to protect themselves from danger | Arm bearing should not be abolished because everyone has the right to bear them for protection. | 6 |
We should support the right to bear arms because many police officers and military personnel are in favor of it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People have the right to bear arm in other to protect themselves from danger | Arm bearing should not be abolished because everyone has the right to bear them for protection. | 10 |
If people are allowed to bear arms, then crime rates will decrease and everyone will be safer. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People have the right to bear arm in other to protect themselves from danger | Arm bearing should not be abolished because everyone has the right to bear them for protection. | 2 |
I know a person who used a gun to protect themselves. Therefore, everyone should have the right to bear arms. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People have the right to bear arm in other to protect themselves from danger | Arm bearing should not be abolished because everyone has the right to bear them for protection. | 1 |
If companies share advancements with the public, they will lose all their profits and go bankrupt. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Companies don't let the public know about advancements, so they can keep the money for themselves. | If information got out, other companies could use it, and the profits and money would be shared. | 11 |
I heard that one company didn't share their advancements, so all companies must be hiding advancements for themselves. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Companies don't let the public know about advancements, so they can keep the money for themselves. | If information got out, other companies could use it, and the profits and money would be shared. | 1 |
Companies keep advancements secret because they want to keep the money for themselves. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Companies don't let the public know about advancements, so they can keep the money for themselves. | If information got out, other companies could use it, and the profits and money would be shared. | 9 |
Companies don't let the public know about advancements because they want to maintain their financial profits. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Companies don't let the public know about advancements, so they can keep the money for themselves. | If information got out, other companies could use it, and the profits and money would be shared. | 5 |
Those who disagree with property rights are lazy and entitled. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People sweat and effort must be protected by property right | Property right should protect people who have created new products that benefits others. | 8 |
We must protect people's sweat and effort because it is unfair for them to work so hard and not be rewarded for it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People sweat and effort must be protected by property right | Property right should protect people who have created new products that benefits others. | 7 |
If people's sweat and effort are protected by property rights, then they will automatically achieve success and prosperity in life. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People sweat and effort must be protected by property right | Property right should protect people who have created new products that benefits others. | 2 |
Opposing property rights is equivalent to advocating for the theft of people's hard-earned money and labor. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: People sweat and effort must be protected by property right | Property right should protect people who have created new products that benefits others. | 4 |
The death penalty is justified because it is the appropriate punishment for certain crimes. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | A loved one being murdered is devastating, and the punishment should fit the crime. | 9 |
I read a news article about a murderer. Therefore, all murderers deserve the death penalty. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | A loved one being murdered is devastating, and the punishment should fit the crime. | 1 |
Implementing the death penalty will deter crime and make society safer. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | A loved one being murdered is devastating, and the punishment should fit the crime. | 2 |
We should keep the death penalty. Many respected judges and legal experts have publicly supported it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | A loved one being murdered is devastating, and the punishment should fit the crime. | 10 |
The death penalty is justified because it is the appropriate punishment for certain crimes. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | Many people are wrongly convicted of a crime, and supporting evidence can be falsified. | 9 |
I read a news article about a murderer. Therefore, all murderers deserve the death penalty. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | Many people are wrongly convicted of a crime, and supporting evidence can be falsified. | 1 |
Implementing the death penalty will deter crime and make society safer. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | Many people are wrongly convicted of a crime, and supporting evidence can be falsified. | 2 |
We should keep the death penalty. Many respected judges and legal experts have publicly supported it. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The death penalty is warranted for certain crimes. | Many people are wrongly convicted of a crime, and supporting evidence can be falsified. | 10 |
I heard that one company pays their executives millions of dollars. Therefore, all companies should be able to decide how much they pay their executives. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies have the right to decide how much to pay their executives because they are the ones earning the money. | 1 |
If a company has high executive salaries, it will automatically lead to increased company profits. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies have the right to decide how much to pay their executives because they are the ones earning the money. | 2 |
If companies are allowed to set their own executive pay, they will always make fair and ethical decisions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies have the right to decide how much to pay their executives because they are the ones earning the money. | 11 |
Companies should focus on increasing profits, not worrying about executive pay. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies have the right to decide how much to pay their executives because they are the ones earning the money. | 3 |
I heard that one company pays their executives millions of dollars. Therefore, all companies should be able to decide how much they pay their executives. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies determine how much to compensate their executives. | 1 |
If a company has high executive salaries, it will automatically lead to increased company profits. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies determine how much to compensate their executives. | 2 |
If companies are allowed to set their own executive pay, they will always make fair and ethical decisions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies determine how much to compensate their executives. | 11 |
Companies should focus on increasing profits, not worrying about executive pay. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: It should be up to a company to decide how much they pay their executives. | Companies determine how much to compensate their executives. | 3 |
Claiming that compulsory voting would lead to a dictatorship ignores the potential benefits of increased civic engagement and representation. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Compulsory voting is not a good societal implementation. | Compulsory voting would allow too many uninformed people the ability to vote. | 4 |
If everyone is forced to vote, then everyone will be politically informed and make informed decisions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Compulsory voting is not a good societal implementation. | Compulsory voting would allow too many uninformed people the ability to vote. | 11 |
The majority of people believe that compulsory voting infringes on personal freedom, so it should not be implemented. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Compulsory voting is not a good societal implementation. | Compulsory voting would allow too many uninformed people the ability to vote. | 6 |
I know a few people who don't vote and they are all irresponsible. Therefore, all people who don't vote are irresponsible. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Compulsory voting is not a good societal implementation. | Compulsory voting would allow too many uninformed people the ability to vote. | 1 |
If journalism is subsidized, then it will lead to unbiased and accurate reporting. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Subsidizing journalism allows for efficient information. | When journalism is subsidized journalist tend to provide fact because they are well encouraged. | 2 |
Subsidizing journalism is unnecessary. We should focus on improving education instead. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Subsidizing journalism allows for efficient information. | When journalism is subsidized journalist tend to provide fact because they are well encouraged. | 3 |
I read one article that was biased. Therefore, all subsidized journalism is biased. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Subsidizing journalism allows for efficient information. | When journalism is subsidized journalist tend to provide fact because they are well encouraged. | 1 |
If we don't subsidize journalism, then we won't have any reliable information sources. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Subsidizing journalism allows for efficient information. | When journalism is subsidized journalist tend to provide fact because they are well encouraged. | 13 |
I read a news article about one child who was affected by their parent's execution. Therefore, all children of executed parents suffer mental harm. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Capital punishment causes mental harm to children. | Children who lose a parent to capital punishment are harmed by the death of their parent. | 1 |
Capital punishment should be abolished. It is a waste of taxpayer money that could be used for education and healthcare. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Capital punishment causes mental harm to children. | Children who lose a parent to capital punishment are harmed by the death of their parent. | 3 |
Those who oppose capital punishment are soft-hearted and lack understanding of justice. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Capital punishment causes mental harm to children. | Children who lose a parent to capital punishment are harmed by the death of their parent. | 8 |
Claiming that capital punishment causes mental harm to all children misrepresents the potential impact on a small subset of children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Capital punishment causes mental harm to children. | Children who lose a parent to capital punishment are harmed by the death of their parent. | 4 |
We must consider the feelings of the victims' families and not abolish capital punishment. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing capital punishment is cruel for the victims of crime. | Forcing victims to pay for the criminals' life imprisonment via taxes is cruel. | 13 |
Claiming that abolishing capital punishment means no justice for victims ignores alternative forms of punishment and rehabilitation. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing capital punishment is cruel for the victims of crime. | Forcing victims to pay for the criminals' life imprisonment via taxes is cruel. | 4 |
Abolishing capital punishment is cruel for the victims of crime because it denies them justice and closure. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing capital punishment is cruel for the victims of crime. | Forcing victims to pay for the criminals' life imprisonment via taxes is cruel. | 5 |
I heard one victim's family say they wanted the criminal to be executed. Therefore, all victims' families want capital punishment. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing capital punishment is cruel for the victims of crime. | Forcing victims to pay for the criminals' life imprisonment via taxes is cruel. | 1 |
Everyone believes people should not be responsible for their own education, so it must be the right decision. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: People need to be responsible for their own education. | No 18 year old can afford to go to college. | 6 |
It's not fair to expect people to be responsible for their own education when the education system is so flawed. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: People need to be responsible for their own education. | No 18 year old can afford to go to college. | 13 |
Those who believe people should be responsible for their own education are lazy and ignorant. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: People need to be responsible for their own education. | No 18 year old can afford to go to college. | 8 |
I know someone who dropped out of school and became successful. Therefore, everyone can succeed without education. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: People need to be responsible for their own education. | No 18 year old can afford to go to college. | 1 |
Just because some doctors support homeopathy doesn't mean it's effective. Many doctors also believe in pseudoscience. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: homeopathy has many benefits | Homeopathy can be very dangerous. | 10 |
Just because some doctors support homeopathy doesn't mean it's effective. Many doctors also believe in pseudoscience. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: homeopathy has many benefits | Homeopathy can help cure diseases naturally. | 10 |
Legalizing organ trade would only benefit the wealthy, while the poor continue to suffer from lack of access to healthcare. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ trade should not be legalized. | It would cause people to make risky choices with their bodies that may be detrimental. | 3 |
The majority of people believe that legalizing organ trade would lead to exploitation and unethical practices. Therefore, it should not be legalized. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ trade should not be legalized. | It would cause people to make risky choices with their bodies that may be detrimental. | 6 |
Either legalize organ trade or let people die on waiting lists for organs. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ trade should not be legalized. | It would cause people to make risky choices with their bodies that may be detrimental. | 12 |
Opposing organ trade does not mean opposing organ transplantation, which is a life-saving procedure. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ trade should not be legalized. | It would cause people to make risky choices with their bodies that may be detrimental. | 4 |
I know someone who grew up in an abusive household and turned out fine. Therefore, all children in abusive households will turn out fine. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Even in abusive households, biological children should stay with their biological parents. | Children in the foster care system end up with issues from the lack of stability in their lives. | 1 |
We should keep biological children with their abusive biological parents. Many psychologists, like Dr. Trustworthy, believe it is best for the child's development. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Even in abusive households, biological children should stay with their biological parents. | Children in the foster care system end up with issues from the lack of stability in their lives. | 10 |
The majority of people believe that children should stay with their biological parents, regardless of the circumstances. Therefore, it is the right thing to do. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Even in abusive households, biological children should stay with their biological parents. | Children in the foster care system end up with issues from the lack of stability in their lives. | 6 |
Arguing that removing children from abusive households means all biological parents are unfit. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Even in abusive households, biological children should stay with their biological parents. | Children in the foster care system end up with issues from the lack of stability in their lives. | 4 |
Bad foster care parents have a negative effect on a kid because they are bad foster care parents. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 9 |
Having bad foster care parents actually improves a kid's resilience and ability to overcome challenges. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 2 |
Think about how heartbroken a child would be if they were taken away from their foster parents. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 7 |
Either have bad foster care parents or have no parents at all. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 12 |
Those who defend bad foster care parents are heartless and have no empathy for children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 8 |
Bad foster care parents should not be a concern because there are other kids who have no parents at all. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 3 |
The majority of people believe that bad foster care parents have a negative effect on a child, so it must be true. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 6 |
Claiming all foster care parents are bad based on a few negative examples is unfair and misrepresents the majority who provide loving care. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Bad foster care parents has negative effect on a kid | When parent of foster homes are not good it tends to have a traumatizing effect on a child. | 4 |
We should support unlimited judicial activism because many famous lawyers and judges endorse it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Since every situation is different, there shouldn't be a limit on judicial activism. | Some situations are worse than others. | 10 |
Claiming no limit on judicial activism implies complete disregard for checks and balances in the legal system. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Since every situation is different, there shouldn't be a limit on judicial activism. | Some situations are worse than others. | 4 |
We must subsidize journalists because their honesty is crucial for the well-being of society. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Journalist will be more honest about facts when they are subsidized. | Subsidy for journalist will allow for honest fact since they do not need to be contributed for again. | 7 |
Claiming that subsidies will automatically make journalists more honest oversimplifies the complex factors that influence journalistic integrity. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Journalist will be more honest about facts when they are subsidized. | Subsidy for journalist will allow for honest fact since they do not need to be contributed for again. | 4 |
Those who disagree with this are clearly irresponsible and unfit parents themselves. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Children benefit from having an active father figure in their life. | If a child has a good influence from a father figure, it will benefit them in their life. | 8 |
We should believe that children benefit from having an active father figure because famous psychologist Dr. Expert has endorsed this idea. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Children benefit from having an active father figure in their life. | If a child has a good influence from a father figure, it will benefit them in their life. | 10 |
Having an active father figure in a child's life is important because it teaches them how to ride a bike. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Children benefit from having an active father figure in their life. | If a child has a good influence from a father figure, it will benefit them in their life. | 3 |
I know a child who has an absent father and they turned out just fine. Therefore, all children do not need an active father figure. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Children benefit from having an active father figure in their life. | If a child has a good influence from a father figure, it will benefit them in their life. | 1 |
Homeopathy is a natural remedy, just like herbal medicine, and has been used for centuries. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathy is a medication mostly not prescribed by doctors and can be misused | Alternative medicine sometime has negative effect on people. | 3 |
Those who support homeopathy are gullible and easily swayed by pseudoscience. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathy is a medication mostly not prescribed by doctors and can be misused | Alternative medicine sometime has negative effect on people. | 8 |
Either doctors prescribe homeopathy or it is misused, there is no other option. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathy is a medication mostly not prescribed by doctors and can be misused | Alternative medicine sometime has negative effect on people. | 12 |
I know three doctors who don't prescribe homeopathy. Therefore, no doctors prescribe homeopathy. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Homeopathy is a medication mostly not prescribed by doctors and can be misused | Alternative medicine sometime has negative effect on people. | 1 |
News is essential because everyone wants to know what's happening in the world. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: News serve as a major needs of the public | Everyone should have access to news so they can know what is happening around them. | 13 |
The majority of people rely on news as their primary source of information, so it must be a major need of the public. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: News serve as a major needs of the public | Everyone should have access to news so they can know what is happening around them. | 6 |
Those who criticize news are ignorant and uninformed about the importance of staying informed. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: News serve as a major needs of the public | Everyone should have access to news so they can know what is happening around them. | 8 |
News is important because it fulfills the major needs of the public. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: News serve as a major needs of the public | Everyone should have access to news so they can know what is happening around them. | 9 |
We must end foster care because the idea of children being abused and neglected is heart-wrenching. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care is dangerous for children. | It can be harmful to a child's psyche to lack the stability of their own household. | 7 |
Those who support foster care are naive and ignorant about the dangers it poses to children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care is dangerous for children. | It can be harmful to a child's psyche to lack the stability of their own household. | 8 |
Many people believe that foster care is dangerous for children, so it must be true. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care is dangerous for children. | It can be harmful to a child's psyche to lack the stability of their own household. | 6 |
I heard one story about a child being abused in foster care. Therefore, all foster care is dangerous for children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Foster care is dangerous for children. | It can be harmful to a child's psyche to lack the stability of their own household. | 1 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.