rejected stringlengths 37 218 | prompt stringlengths 62 208 | chosen stringlengths 14 180 | fallacy_type int64 1 13 |
|---|---|---|---|
I know a person who works in the industry and they say it's safer now, so it must be true for everyone. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Legalization will provide safer environments for those who work in the industry. | Legalization will make work environments unsafe because people won't be able to focus on their work. | 1 |
Legalization will provide safer environments for those who work in the industry. It will also create jobs and generate tax revenue. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Legalization will provide safer environments for those who work in the industry. | Legalization will make work environments unsafe because people won't be able to focus on their work. | 3 |
If marijuana is legalized, then crime rates will decrease because people will be too high to commit crimes. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Legalization will provide safer environments for those who work in the industry. | Legalization will make work environments unsafe because people won't be able to focus on their work. | 2 |
We should not abolish mandatory retirement. Many successful and influential people have publicly endorsed it. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Mandatory retirement is out of step with society. | An aging workforce prevents opportunities for the young, leaving mandatory retirement as the only solution. | 10 |
Mandatory retirement promotes job opportunities for younger workers. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Mandatory retirement is out of step with society. | An aging workforce prevents opportunities for the young, leaving mandatory retirement as the only solution. | 2 |
Mandatory retirement is necessary to make room for younger workers and stimulate economic growth. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Mandatory retirement is out of step with society. | An aging workforce prevents opportunities for the young, leaving mandatory retirement as the only solution. | 13 |
Either have mandatory retirement or have no retirement at all. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Mandatory retirement is out of step with society. | An aging workforce prevents opportunities for the young, leaving mandatory retirement as the only solution. | 12 |
Those who support capital punishment are bloodthirsty and lack empathy for the accused. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Capital punishment provides closure for victims' families. | Capital punishment does not guarantee closure for a victim's family members. | 8 |
Either support capital punishment or deny closure to victims' families. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Capital punishment provides closure for victims' families. | Capital punishment does not guarantee closure for a victim's family members. | 12 |
The majority of people believe that capital punishment provides closure for victims' families, so it must be true. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Capital punishment provides closure for victims' families. | Capital punishment does not guarantee closure for a victim's family members. | 6 |
Why should we worry about closure for victims' families when there are innocent people on death row? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Capital punishment provides closure for victims' families. | Capital punishment does not guarantee closure for a victim's family members. | 3 |
I heard of one case where a person assisted in a suicide. Therefore, all cases of assisted suicide are crimes. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Assisted suicide is a crime because a person had a hand in someone else's death | By assisting someone with their death you are committing a crime by causing them to lose their life. | 1 |
If a person is present at the scene of a crime, they must be guilty of committing the crime. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Assisted suicide is a crime because a person had a hand in someone else's death | By assisting someone with their death you are committing a crime by causing them to lose their life. | 2 |
Assisted suicide should be legal because it allows terminally ill patients to die with dignity. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Assisted suicide is a crime because a person had a hand in someone else's death | By assisting someone with their death you are committing a crime by causing them to lose their life. | 3 |
Assisted suicide should remain illegal because many doctors, who are highly respected in their field, oppose it. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Assisted suicide is a crime because a person had a hand in someone else's death | By assisting someone with their death you are committing a crime by causing them to lose their life. | 10 |
If we provide housing for children with no parents, it will solve all their problems and make them successful adults. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: it provides housing for child with no parents | Child with no parents tends to benefit from it through provision of shelter. | 11 |
We must end racial profiling because it is heartbreaking to see innocent people being targeted and discriminated against based on their race. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Everyone has equal rights and racial profiling should not in place anymore | Racial profiling is act of denying people their right which should never be the case. | 7 |
We should impose economic sanctions on countries. Many renowned economists, such as Nobel laureate John Smith, support this approach. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Economic sanction enables prevent bad behaviours of countries on others | Economic sanction allow other countries to live without fear of being oppressed by other countries. | 10 |
The majority of countries believe that economic sanctions are an effective way to prevent bad behaviors, so they must be effective. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Economic sanction enables prevent bad behaviours of countries on others | Economic sanction allow other countries to live without fear of being oppressed by other countries. | 6 |
I heard that one country was stopped from engaging in bad behavior after being sanctioned. Therefore, all countries can be prevented from bad behavior through economic sanctions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Economic sanction enables prevent bad behaviours of countries on others | Economic sanction allow other countries to live without fear of being oppressed by other countries. | 1 |
Economic sanctions are necessary because they help prevent bad behaviors of countries on others. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Economic sanction enables prevent bad behaviours of countries on others | Economic sanction allow other countries to live without fear of being oppressed by other countries. | 9 |
I found one inaccurate article on Wikipedia. Therefore, all articles on Wikipedia must be inaccurate. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should not be subsidized. | Some people believe Wikipedia would benefit from being subsidized. | 1 |
So you think all information on Wikipedia is unreliable and should be ignored? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should not be subsidized. | Some people believe Wikipedia would benefit from being subsidized. | 4 |
Those who support subsidizing Wikipedia are lazy and rely on it for their own laziness. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should not be subsidized. | Some people believe Wikipedia would benefit from being subsidized. | 8 |
We should not listen to those who support subsidizing Wikipedia because they are biased and have a vested interest in its success. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should not be subsidized. | Some people believe Wikipedia would benefit from being subsidized. | 10 |
Why should we care about cultures when the extinction of whales is a global environmental concern? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cultures that have traditionally hunted whales should be allowed to continue to do so. | History has shown that cultures can adapt and undertake less barbaric traditional practices. | 3 |
No, think about the cultural heritage and identity that would be lost if they were forced to stop hunting whales. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cultures that have traditionally hunted whales should be allowed to continue to do so. | History has shown that cultures can adapt and undertake less barbaric traditional practices. | 7 |
We should not ban whale hunting. Many respected scientists have publicly stated that it is sustainable and necessary for these cultures. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cultures that have traditionally hunted whales should be allowed to continue to do so. | History has shown that cultures can adapt and undertake less barbaric traditional practices. | 10 |
Allowing cultures to hunt whales preserves their cultural heritage and promotes economic growth. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cultures that have traditionally hunted whales should be allowed to continue to do so. | History has shown that cultures can adapt and undertake less barbaric traditional practices. | 2 |
Allowing citizens to own guns will lead to a safer society. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The right to keep and bear arms puts society in danger. | The right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in our constitution. | 11 |
The majority of people believe that the right to keep and bear arms does not put society in danger, so it must be safe. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The right to keep and bear arms puts society in danger. | The right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in our constitution. | 6 |
Allowing people to have guns is dangerous because it allows them to have weapons. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The right to keep and bear arms puts society in danger. | The right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in our constitution. | 9 |
I know someone who owns a gun and has never harmed anyone. Therefore, all gun owners are responsible and do not pose a danger to society. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: The right to keep and bear arms puts society in danger. | The right to keep and bear arms is enshrined in our constitution. | 1 |
If mandatory retirement is abolished, age discrimination will automatically disappear. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing mandatory retirement will help end age discrimination. | Abolishing mandatory retirement will protect older workers and help end age discrimination. | 2 |
If we abolish mandatory retirement, age discrimination will automatically disappear. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing mandatory retirement will help end age discrimination. | Abolishing mandatory retirement will protect older workers and help end age discrimination. | 11 |
Claiming that abolishing mandatory retirement means all older workers will be forced to work indefinitely misrepresents the goal of ending age discrimination. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing mandatory retirement will help end age discrimination. | Abolishing mandatory retirement will protect older workers and help end age discrimination. | 4 |
Either we abolish mandatory retirement or we continue to discriminate against older workers. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abolishing mandatory retirement will help end age discrimination. | Abolishing mandatory retirement will protect older workers and help end age discrimination. | 12 |
Think of all the people suffering on Earth. We must explore space to find resources to help them. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space has many resources that has not yet been utilized | Resources in the space are so much and it should be explored as soon as possible. | 7 |
Claiming that space exploration is a waste of resources ignores the potential for scientific discoveries and technological advancements. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space has many resources that has not yet been utilized | Resources in the space are so much and it should be explored as soon as possible. | 4 |
Those who disagree with utilizing space resources are ignorant and afraid of progress. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space has many resources that has not yet been utilized | Resources in the space are so much and it should be explored as soon as possible. | 8 |
Many people believe that space is a vast and untapped resource. Therefore, it must be true that there are many resources in space that have not yet been utilized. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Space has many resources that has not yet been utilized | Resources in the space are so much and it should be explored as soon as possible. | 6 |
The majority of people believe that allowing the market to regulate organ acquisition would increase accessibility, so it must be true. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ acquisition in the market makes it easier to get. | Sale of organ in the market makes it easy to get and safe stress. | 6 |
I know two people who bought organs on the black market. Therefore, everyone can easily buy organs on the market. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ acquisition in the market makes it easier to get. | Sale of organ in the market makes it easy to get and safe stress. | 1 |
Organ acquisition in the market is beneficial because it makes it easier to acquire organs in the market. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ acquisition in the market makes it easier to get. | Sale of organ in the market makes it easy to get and safe stress. | 9 |
We should allow organ acquisition in the market because there are so many people suffering and dying while waiting for a transplant. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Organ acquisition in the market makes it easier to get. | Sale of organ in the market makes it easy to get and safe stress. | 7 |
Using homeopathic remedies causes an increase in emotional and physical ailments. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Homeopathic remedies can provide emotional and physical healing. | Homeopathy provides a false sense of hope. | 2 |
Only ignorant people would believe in the effectiveness of homeopathic remedies. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Homeopathic remedies can provide emotional and physical healing. | Homeopathy provides a false sense of hope. | 8 |
Homeopathic remedies provide healing because they are known to provide healing. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Homeopathic remedies can provide emotional and physical healing. | Homeopathy provides a false sense of hope. | 9 |
I know someone who tried homeopathic remedies and they didn't work, so all homeopathic remedies are ineffective. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Homeopathic remedies can provide emotional and physical healing. | Homeopathy provides a false sense of hope. | 1 |
Wikipedia should be subsidized because it provides information on a wide range of topics, like the history of chocolate chip cookies. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | The massive amount of information made freely available on Wikipedia is an important rationale to not refuse subsidies. | 3 |
I found one incorrect information on Wikipedia. Therefore, all information on Wikipedia is incorrect. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | The massive amount of information made freely available on Wikipedia is an important rationale to not refuse subsidies. | 1 |
The majority of people believe that Wikipedia is a valuable resource, so it should be subsidized. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | The massive amount of information made freely available on Wikipedia is an important rationale to not refuse subsidies. | 6 |
Claiming that subsidizing Wikipedia means subsidizing all online content is an exaggeration and misrepresentation of the argument. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | The massive amount of information made freely available on Wikipedia is an important rationale to not refuse subsidies. | 4 |
Wikipedia should be subsidized because it provides information on a wide range of topics, like the history of chocolate chip cookies. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | Wikipedia is a private entity, that is edited by users, who are not experts. | 3 |
I found one incorrect information on Wikipedia. Therefore, all information on Wikipedia is incorrect. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | Wikipedia is a private entity, that is edited by users, who are not experts. | 1 |
The majority of people believe that Wikipedia is a valuable resource, so it should be subsidized. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | Wikipedia is a private entity, that is edited by users, who are not experts. | 6 |
Claiming that subsidizing Wikipedia means subsidizing all online content is an exaggeration and misrepresentation of the argument. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Wikipedia should be subsidized. | Wikipedia is a private entity, that is edited by users, who are not experts. | 4 |
We should allow adolescents to get cosmetic surgery. Many famous celebrities have had successful procedures and they know what's best for young people. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Adolescents should not be allowed to get cosmetic surgery. | Cosmetic surgery may be necessary to improve the condition of life, even for children. | 10 |
Allowing adolescents to get cosmetic surgery improves their self-esteem and body image. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Adolescents should not be allowed to get cosmetic surgery. | Cosmetic surgery may be necessary to improve the condition of life, even for children. | 2 |
Either let adolescents get cosmetic surgery or let them suffer from low self-esteem forever. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Adolescents should not be allowed to get cosmetic surgery. | Cosmetic surgery may be necessary to improve the condition of life, even for children. | 12 |
Why should we worry about adolescents getting cosmetic surgery when there are more important issues like poverty and hunger? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Adolescents should not be allowed to get cosmetic surgery. | Cosmetic surgery may be necessary to improve the condition of life, even for children. | 3 |
The majority of people believe that requiring clergymen to be celibate is an outdated and unnecessary practice. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Clergymen should be required to be celibate. | Lust and desire would lead religious leaders astray from their true purpose. | 6 |
We should require clergymen to be celibate. Many religious leaders, such as Pope Francis, advocate for celibacy in the clergy. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Clergymen should be required to be celibate. | Lust and desire would lead religious leaders astray from their true purpose. | 10 |
Clergymen should be celibate because it will reduce the number of car accidents on the road. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Clergymen should be required to be celibate. | Lust and desire would lead religious leaders astray from their true purpose. | 3 |
We must require celibacy for clergymen because it is heartbreaking to think of them breaking their vows and betraying their faith. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Clergymen should be required to be celibate. | Lust and desire would lead religious leaders astray from their true purpose. | 7 |
Celibacy should not be respected because it goes against human nature and is unnatural. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Vows of celibacy are often related to religious beliefs. | 13 |
Respecting celibacy as a belief blurs 'personal choice' and 'religious obligation', confusing discussions. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Vows of celibacy are often related to religious beliefs. | 5 |
Celibacy causes people to have a higher level of spiritual enlightenment and connection with a higher power. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Vows of celibacy are often related to religious beliefs. | 2 |
Celibacy should be respected because it is a belief that should be respected. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Vows of celibacy are often related to religious beliefs. | 9 |
Celibacy should not be respected because it goes against human nature and is unnatural. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Celibacy is an outdated practice and represent unhealthy traditional roles. | 13 |
Respecting celibacy as a belief blurs 'personal choice' and 'religious obligation', confusing discussions. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Celibacy is an outdated practice and represent unhealthy traditional roles. | 5 |
Celibacy causes people to have a higher level of spiritual enlightenment and connection with a higher power. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Celibacy is an outdated practice and represent unhealthy traditional roles. | 2 |
Celibacy should be respected because it is a belief that should be respected. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Celibacy should be respected as an expression of belief. | Celibacy is an outdated practice and represent unhealthy traditional roles. | 9 |
I heard of one abusive foster care family. Therefore, all foster care families propagate abuse against children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | The lack of oversight allows abusive foster care families to repeatedly harm children. | 1 |
Those who criticize foster care families are just bitter and jealous of their success in raising children. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | The lack of oversight allows abusive foster care families to repeatedly harm children. | 8 |
Children who are abused in foster care are more likely to become abusive themselves. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | The lack of oversight allows abusive foster care families to repeatedly harm children. | 2 |
Abusive foster care families propagate abuse because they are abusive. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | The lack of oversight allows abusive foster care families to repeatedly harm children. | 9 |
I heard of one abusive foster care family. Therefore, all foster care families propagate abuse against children. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | Abusive foster care families are the extreme minority; most are caring and loving people. | 1 |
Those who criticize foster care families are just bitter and jealous of their success in raising children. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | Abusive foster care families are the extreme minority; most are caring and loving people. | 8 |
Children who are abused in foster care are more likely to become abusive themselves. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | Abusive foster care families are the extreme minority; most are caring and loving people. | 2 |
Abusive foster care families propagate abuse because they are abusive. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Abusive foster care families propagate abuse against tens of children. | Abusive foster care families are the extreme minority; most are caring and loving people. | 9 |
Using gender-neutral language is just a fad. It's unnecessary and doesn't really make a difference. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Refusal to use gender-neutral language excludes many people. | There are many recognized genders, and the only equitable way to treat them all is to use gender-neutral language. | 13 |
Refusing to use gender-neutral language is hurtful and makes people feel excluded and marginalized. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Refusal to use gender-neutral language excludes many people. | There are many recognized genders, and the only equitable way to treat them all is to use gender-neutral language. | 7 |
If we use gender-neutral language, everyone will feel included and no one will ever feel excluded again. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Refusal to use gender-neutral language excludes many people. | There are many recognized genders, and the only equitable way to treat them all is to use gender-neutral language. | 11 |
Using gender-neutral language is important because it's necessary to include everyone by using gender-neutral language. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Refusal to use gender-neutral language excludes many people. | There are many recognized genders, and the only equitable way to treat them all is to use gender-neutral language. | 9 |
So you're saying everyone who uses illegal drugs is a criminal and should be locked up? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: A large amount of people use illegal drugs. | A great many people feel that breaking the law is not worth it for any reason. | 4 |
We should not be concerned about the negative effects of illegal drugs. Many successful and influential people have admitted to using them. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: A large amount of people use illegal drugs. | A great many people feel that breaking the law is not worth it for any reason. | 10 |
Using illegal drugs is wrong because it is against the law. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: A large amount of people use illegal drugs. | A great many people feel that breaking the law is not worth it for any reason. | 9 |
Those who support the legalization of drugs are just drug addicts trying to justify their own behavior. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: A large amount of people use illegal drugs. | A great many people feel that breaking the law is not worth it for any reason. | 8 |
We must allow women to serve because they have sacrificed so much for our country and deserve equal opportunities. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Women should be allowed to serve. | Some women serve in the military. | 7 |
Either women should be allowed to serve or they should be denied the opportunity to contribute to their country. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Women should be allowed to serve. | Some women serve in the military. | 12 |
I know one woman who is not physically strong. Therefore, all women are not physically strong. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: Women should be allowed to serve. | Some women serve in the military. | 1 |
Claiming that legalizing marijuana for recreational use will lead to widespread addiction and drug abuse is an exaggerated and unrealistic portrayal of the potential consequences. | Generate a supporting argument for the topic: legalizing marijuana for recreational use is not recommended. | Marijuana for recreational use do not provide any material benefit. | 4 |
I know someone who used gateway drugs and didn't become addicted, so they must not cause addiction. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Gateway drugs should be illegal as they cause addiction. | Addiction is only caused by heavy drugs. | 1 |
Those who support legalizing gateway drugs are just a bunch of drug addicts themselves. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Gateway drugs should be illegal as they cause addiction. | Addiction is only caused by heavy drugs. | 8 |
Gateway drugs should be legal as they prevent addiction. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Gateway drugs should be illegal as they cause addiction. | Addiction is only caused by heavy drugs. | 2 |
We should not ban gateway drugs. Many successful people have admitted to using them and they turned out fine. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Gateway drugs should be illegal as they cause addiction. | Addiction is only caused by heavy drugs. | 10 |
I know someone who smokes cannabis and is perfectly healthy. Therefore, cannabis is not harmful to anyone. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cannabis is not any worse than cigarettes or alcohol. | Cannabis is used world-round as much as cigarettes and alcohol, though smoke inhalation is questionable for health. | 1 |
Why should we be concerned about cannabis when there are more dangerous drugs like heroin and meth? | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cannabis is not any worse than cigarettes or alcohol. | Cannabis is used world-round as much as cigarettes and alcohol, though smoke inhalation is questionable for health. | 3 |
Cannabis is not worse than cigarettes or alcohol because it is not any worse than cigarettes or alcohol. | Generate a counter argument for the topic: Cannabis is not any worse than cigarettes or alcohol. | Cannabis is used world-round as much as cigarettes and alcohol, though smoke inhalation is questionable for health. | 9 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.