| C H A P T E R 4 |
|
|
| Climate Change Impacts |
| on Human Health |
|
|
| Song Liang1,5, Kristina Kintziger2, Phyllis Reaves3, and Sadie J. Ryan4,5 |
|
|
| 1Department of Environmental and Global Health, College of Public Health and Health Professions, |
| University of Florida, Gainesville, FL; 2Department of Public Health, College of Education, Health & |
| Human Sciences, The University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN; 3Division of Physical Therapy, School of |
| Allied Health Sciences, Florida Agricultural & Mechanical University, Tallahassee, FL; 4Department of |
| Geography, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL; 5Emerging Pathogens Institute, University of Florida, |
| Gainesville, FL |
|
|
| Climate change poses major challenges to human society and to Earth systems, influencing the |
| functioning of many ecosystems and thereby affecting human health. Many climate change/variability- |
| and extreme weather-associated events, such as sea level rise, hurricanes, and storm surge, as well as |
| other weather extremes, including excessive precipitation and heatwaves, have direct and/or indirect |
| impacts on human health. These impacts include death/injury, cardiovascular and respiratory diseases, |
| environmentally-mediated infectious diseases, and mental health, among others. Due to its unique |
| geography, Florida is particularly vulnerable to these environmental impacts, which have important |
| health implications for the state’s more than 20 million residents. In this chapter, we review the health |
| impacts of climate change and associated weather events, with an emphasis on those relevant to Florida, |
| and environmental hazards, including hurricanes and storms, lightning, sea level rise, excessive |
| precipitation, extreme heat, and drought. There is clear evidence for significant climate-sensitive hazards |
| and human health impacts in the state, despite uncertainties associated with the assessment of some |
| effects. To address health impacts and challenges, policies focused on mitigation and adaptation |
| strategies, health surveillance, and research that could close knowledge gaps on human exposures to the |
| climate-sensitive hazards and health impacts are needed. |
|
|
| Key Messages |
|
|
| • Florida is highly vulnerable to climate-sensitive hazards (e.g. sea level rise, heat waves, storm |
|
|
| surge, and hurricanes), which have a wide range of human health effects. |
|
|
| • The health effects can be direct, such as storm/temperature related illnesses, injuries, and |
| deaths; or indirect, such as waterborne, food-borne, and vector-borne diseases; or take social |
| and economic pathways, such as stress and mental illness. |
|
|
| • The health effects exhibit substantial regional disparities across the state. |
| • Policies focused on health surveillance and research on knowledge gaps between human |
|
|
| exposure to the hazards and health effects are much needed. |
|
|
| Keywords |
|
|
| Climate change; Environmental hazards; Human health; Florida |
|
|
| 125 |
|
|
| 1 2 6 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| Introduction |
|
|
| C |
|
|
| limate change is well-characterized at the global level using metrics such as the global |
| mean temperature and sea level. But the manifestations of global climate change and |
| variability occur at varying geographical scales, causing a variety of weather events, |
| such as excessive rainfall, drought, severe storm/flooding, sea level rise, and heat waves (Field |
| et al. 2014), all of which are likely to have direct and/or indirect human health impacts |
| (McMichael and Haines 1997; Colwell et al. 1998; Frumkin et al. 2008). Indeed, there is clear |
| and increasing evidence that many health outcomes (most adverse) exhibit high sensitivities to |
| these varying weather events. The interface between the climate change-associated weather |
| events and human health exhibits a complex web of relationships involving both natural and |
| social environments through direct or indirect impact pathways, social institutional disruption, |
| or a combinations of these things (Fig. 4.1). Globally, substantial disease burdens are attributable |
| to hazards that are associated with climate change and related weather events. According to the |
| World Health Organization’s 2008 estimate, climate change-associated hazards were responsible |
| for more than 150,000 deaths and 5,517,000 disability-adjusted life years, which were highly |
| likely to be underestimated as the estimates were only based on selected risk factors and illnesses |
| associated with climate change and related weather events (WHO 2008). The actual disease |
| burden might be greater and the adverse health impacts are likely to increase in the years to come, |
| as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and US Global Change Research |
| Program have clearly indicated that the accelerated changing climate poses a substantial threat |
| to global human health and the risk will continue to become severe if no remediation action is |
| taken (Field et al. 2014; Balbus et al. 2016). |
|
|
| Due to its unique geography, Florida is highly vulnerable to a variety of hazards associated |
| with climate change and variability, and related weather events. Sea level rise, hurricane and |
| storm surge, excessive precipitation, and heatwaves all pose threats to Florida’s agriculture, |
| ecosystems, tourism, and public health. For example, Florida has experienced a greater number |
| of hurricane landfalls than other states in the country (Knight and Davis 2009), and more intense |
| hurricanes are expected in the future (Knutson et al. 2013). In addition, rising sea levels are |
| influencing and expected to continue to have significant impacts on communities and residents |
| along Florida’s coastal areas, particularly in the southern part of the state, making Floridians |
| exceptionally vulnerable to these environmental hazards (Elsner et al. 2008). |
|
|
| This chapter is organized into sections addressing impact pathways and specific |
| environmental hazards of particular concern in Florida (Fig. 4.1). For direct impacts, we focus |
| on extreme heat, flooding, storms and lightning, and sea level rise. For indirect impacts on public |
| health, we focus on water, food, and vector-borne diseases. And lastly, we conclude with our |
| discussion of impact pathways through social disruption on mental and community health impact |
| associated with climate change and related weather events. Throughout this chapter, health |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 2 7 |
|
|
| impacts and implications, particularly those pertinent to Florida, are reviewed primarily based |
| on the Building Resilience Against Climate Effects (BRACE) project reports from the Florida |
| Department of Health (FDH) (FDH 2015b, a) and other relevant publications. |
|
|
| Figure 4.1. Impact pathways by which climate change and variability and related weather events affect |
| human health. |
|
|
| Direct Impact Pathways – Environmental Hazards |
| and Human Health |
|
|
| A number of human health impacts come from direct exposure to environmental hazards |
| associated with climate change and related weather events. Among those of particular concern |
| in Florida are extreme heat, flooding, storms and lightning, and sea level rise. |
|
|
| 1 2 8 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| Extreme Heat and Health Impacts |
|
|
| Extreme climate and weather events (e.g., heat, cold, storms, and floods) are expected to occur |
| more frequently worldwide due to climate change. These extreme events, such as heatwaves and |
| cold spells (e.g. frequent very hot days and possibly fewer very cold days), have a direct impact |
| on human health by compromising the body’s ability to regulate its internal temperature. |
| Increased human morbidity and mortality have been associated with extreme temperatures, both |
| hot and cold, and documented in both developing and developed countries worldwide (Center |
| for Disease Control and Prevention 1994; Keatinge et al. 2000a; Keatinge et al. 2000b; Basu and |
| Samet 2002; Medina-Ramon et al. 2006; Kovats and Hajat 2008; Bandyopadhyay et al. 2012). |
| The mechanistic effects of extreme temperature on death and illness are briefly summarized |
| below (Sarofim et al. 2016): |
| • Extreme heat may induce heat cramps, heat exhaustion, heatstroke, and hyperthermia. |
| • Extreme cold may induce hypothermia and frostbite. |
| • Extreme heat/cold may exacerbate chronic conditions related to cardiovascular disease, |
|
|
| respiratory disease, cerebrovascular disease, and diabetes-related illnesses. |
|
|
| • Extended exposure to high temperatures may induce increased hospital admissions for |
|
|
| cardiovascular, kidney, and respiratory disorders. |
|
|
| • Extreme heat may induce or exacerbate mental health and behavioral disorders. |
|
|
| A number of studies have reported associations between high temperatures and human deaths |
| or illnesses around the world. For example, a large number of heat-related deaths have been |
| reported in the United States (Center for Disease Control and Prevention 1994; Curriero et al. |
| 2002; Hoshiko et al. 2010), Europe (Keatinge et al. 2000a; Keatinge et al. 2000b; Huynen et al. |
| 2001), and Asia (Qian et al. 2008; Chung et al. 2009). A recent study by Berko et al. examined |
| deaths attributed to extreme weather events from 2006 to 2010 in the United States and found |
| that each year about 2,000 U.S. residents died from weather-related causes, and among those |
| 31% died due to exposure to excessive heat, heat stroke, and/or sun stroke (Berko et al. 2014). |
| Mounting evidence has suggested that substantial increases in mortality from respiratory and |
| cardiovascular diseases, in particular among the elderly and youth, are associated with high |
| temperatures in the United States (Basu and Samet 2002; Medina-Ramon et al. 2006; Kovats and |
| Hajat 2008). During the 2006 California heat wave, 16,166 excess emergency department visits |
| and 1,182 excess hospitalizations were reported statewide. This included a significant increase |
| in emergency department visits for acute renal failure, cardiovascular diseases, and diabetes |
| (Knowlton et al. 2009). The association between heat and respiratory diseases has also been |
| reported in many studies. In New York state, a significant number of respiratory hospitalizations |
| were attributable to excessive heat, and a projection suggested that excess respiratory admissions |
| in the state due to extreme heat will be two to six times higher in 2080–2099 than what was seen |
| in 1991–2004 (Lin et al. 2012). In another study conducted in Greater London, UK, an analysis |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 2 9 |
|
|
| of historical data suggested that heat-related increases in emergency admissions for respiratory |
| and renal diseases had been observed in children under five, and for respiratory disease in the |
| 75+ age group (Kovats et al. 2004). |
|
|
| Extreme Heat and Public Health in Florida |
|
|
| Florida has a warm subtropical and tropical climate. Due to continuous summer heat and extreme |
| weather events, temperatures around the state can reach levels potentially harmful to human |
| health. Through analyses of historical data (for the periods 1895–2009 and 1970–2009), a |
| significant trend in Florida’s mean temperature has been found (Martinez et al. 2012). The |
| average summer temperature (June–August) has been showing an overall increasing trend, |
| particularly after the 1980s, which shows a greater upward trend (FDH 2015a), likely due to a |
| variety of factors ranging from rapid urban development (Martinez et al. 2012; FDH 2015a) to |
| climate change (Ji et al. 2014). Within the state, substantial spatial heterogeneities in mean, |
| minimum, and maximum temperature have been reported (Martinez et al. 2012). For example, |
| the distribution of annual mean number of days with a maximum temperature greater than or |
| equal to 95 °F and greater than or equal to 75 °F showed that more days with hottest daytime |
| temperatures occurred in the northern and interior portions of the state (FDH 2015a). |
|
|
| Using statewide information on specific health outcome-related emergency department visits |
| that occurred May to October from 2005–2012, the BRACE project examined the effects of daily |
| maximum temperature or daily maximum heat index on emergency department visits through a |
| two-stage analysis—the first stage involved the analysis on regional (National Weather Service |
| regions) scales using the Poisson regression model; the second stage used a meta-analysis |
| technique to integrate regional estimates into a statewide estimate (FDH 2015a). Rate ratios, |
| based on the comparison between the exposure (e.g., hotter days) and the reference (e.g. 88 °F |
| for temperature and 94 °F for heat index), were used to compare emergency department visits |
| for specific health conditions (FDH 2015a). |
| a) Heat and heat-related illness. A strong association between heat-related illness and heat |
| exposure was observed; the significant increase in emergency department visit rates for heat- |
| related illness was associated with increasing temperatures and a strong dose-response |
| relationship across all regions in Florida was found (FDH 2015a). |
|
|
| b) Heat and cardiovascular disease. Two types of cardiovascular disease were considered— |
| myocardial infarction and ischemic stroke. No statistically significant association was found |
| between temperature and ischemic stroke at the state level; however, significant regional |
| variations were identified. For example, the Tampa region showed a significant positive |
| association between heat index (above the reference level at 94 °F) and stroke (FDH 2015a). |
| Furthermore, a positive, statistically significant relationship was observed between |
| myocardial infarction and heat index despite remarkable geographical variations (FDH |
| 2015a). |
|
|
| 1 3 0 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| c) Heat and respiratory disease. Overall, increases in the number of emergency department |
| visits for asthma were associated with higher temperatures. Although no significant |
| association was found at the state level between temperature and emergency department visits |
| for asthma, the regional analysis suggested that all regions except Tallahassee showed a |
| statistically significant positive association between temperature and asthma (FDH 2015a). |
|
|
| Flooding, Storms, Lightning, and Sea Level Rise |
|
|
| Excessive precipitation, hurricanes, coastal storms, sea level rise, and thunderstorm-related |
| lightning, which are all typically accompanied by coastal and inland flooding, have the potential |
| for substantial direct human health impacts (e.g. injury and death, maternal and child health, and |
| mental health issues). Natural disasters related to flooding and storms are a significant cause of |
| mortality and morbidity. For example, according to the International Federation of Red Cross |
| and Red Crescent Societies (IFRCRCS), more than 3,448 climatic, hydrological and |
| meteorological disasters (including 1,751 major floods and 988 storms) resulting in 339,710 |
| deaths (59,092 and 177,685 deaths specifically tied to flooding and storms) were reported |
| worldwide between 2005 and 2014 (IFRCRCS 2015). Lightning strike is the second leading |
| cause of weather-related mortality at the global scale, with an estimated 0.2-1.7 deaths per million |
| people, and those who survive lightning strikes often suffer from significant injuries (Aslar et al. |
| 2001; Ritenour et al. 2008). The magnitude and impacts of these extreme weather events, their |
| severity, and the extent of the effects are influenced by many different factors. For example, |
| short- and long-term averages and variability of weather conditions and physical impacts of |
| associated extreme events, as well as social environmental factors (e.g. infrastructure, social and |
| individual vulnerability), are considered important (Bouma et al. 1997, Kovats 2000, Kovats et |
| al. 2003, Miranda 2004). For projections of future flooding under different climate change |
| scenarios, climate models have consistently suggested that episodes of severe flooding may |
| become more frequent in inland river systems including flood plains (Christensen and |
| Christensen 2003, Booij 2005), urban and coastal environments in various parts of the world |
| (Schreider et al. 2000; Douglas et al. 2008; Kirshen et al. 2008; Thompson et al. 2009, Diez et |
| al. 2011; Lyle and Mills 2016). Meanwhile, climate models also predict positive correlations |
| between lightning and global temperatures, suggesting the likelihood of a greater number of and |
| more severe lightning episodes (Price and Rind 1994; Reeve and Toumi 1999; Kochtubajda et |
| al. 2006). These episodes are expected to increase the risk of extreme environmental hazards and |
| adverse public health impacts. |
| a) Natural disasters in Florida. Due to its geography (extensive coastline and a peninsular |
| shape) and its tropical/subtropical climate, Florida is particularly vulnerable to tropical |
| storms, hurricanes, and lightning strikes. Historically the occurrence of hurricanes in the US |
| has been clustered in Florida and along the Atlantic coastline (Ellis et al. 2015). A total of 67 |
| known Florida hurricanes have occurred over the 108-year period (1900-2007) with four |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 3 1 |
|
|
| different hurricanes occurring in one year (2004) in Florida. The climate change model |
| suggests a 46% chance that Florida will be hit by at least one hurricane each year in the future |
| (Malmstadt et al. 2009), and recent experience seems to support this. Fig. 4.2 illustrates the |
| distribution of average return time of hurricane landfalls and populations along the coastal |
| areas of Florida, showing spatial heterogeneities in vulnerability to hurricanes. |
|
|
| b) Public health impacts. Key direct public health impacts associated with extreme weather |
| events include injury and death due to trauma, drowning, destructive forces of wind, |
| collapsed building and trees, and lightning strike and carbon monoxide poisoning related to |
| power outages. Historically, Florida experienced significantly higher mortality in the early |
| 20th century; approximately 3,000 deaths were attributed to extreme weather-related events |
| (Winsberg 2003) and the largest number of deaths due to lightning strike in the US were |
| reported during this time (Duclos et al. 1990; Ritenour et al. 2008). During 2004 and 2005, |
| eight hurricanes hit Florida resulting in 213 deaths, over half of which were caused by trauma, |
| followed by drowning, other injury, electrocution, and carbon monoxide poisoning (Ragan et |
| al. 2008). Injury is common cause of hurricane-related morbidity and mortality. For example, |
| in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina between September 8 and October 14, 2005, 7,543 non- |
| fatal injuries among residents and relief workers were recorded in the surveillance system |
| (Sullivent et al. 2006). During a 2006 flood event in El Paso County in Texas, 43% of |
| individuals (out of 475 surveyed) were reported having physical health issues related to the |
| flooding episode (Collins et al. 2013). |
|
|
| c) Injury. The BRACE study compared injury-related emergency department visits and |
| hospitalizations during impact periods (periods covering tropical cyclone landfall) vs. control |
| periods (periods with no such impact) between 2004 and 2012. The study found that |
| emergency department visit and hospitalization rates were significantly higher during the |
| impact periods, with a rate ratio of 1.03 (95% confidence interval (CI): 1.02, 1.05) for the |
| emergency department visit rate and 1.4 (95% CI: 1.02, 1.05) for the hospitalization rate. The |
| most common types of injuries during the impact periods included falls, being struck by an |
| object, being cut or pierced, and motor vehicle transport accidents (FDH 2015b). |
|
|
| d) Carbon monoxide poisoning. Carbon monoxide (CO) is a colorless, odorless, poisonous gas |
| that can be harmful when inhaled in a large amount. Inhaled CO enters the blood stream and |
| reduces the delivery of oxygen to the body’s critical organs, such as the heart and brain. The |
| gas is primarily generated through incomplete combustion. The greatest sources of CO |
| outdoors are usually related to motor vehicles, machinery that burn fossil fuels. Indoors, some |
| major sources include unvented kerosene and gas space heaters, leaking chimneys and |
| furnaces, and gas stoves. Exposure to CO may cause weakness, headache, dizziness, nausea, |
| shortness of breath, confusion, and even death at very high concentration levels, which is |
| more likely in indoor environments. A recent systematic review of the health impacts of |
| power outages due to extreme events indicated that CO poisoning is an important health |
| concern (Klinger et al. 2014). In Florida, the BRACE study reported that during the study |
|
|
| 1 3 2 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| period 2004–2012, the rate of CO exposure calls during impact periods was 6.59 times (95% |
| CI: 4.48, 9.7) the rate of CO exposure calls to poison control centers during the control |
| periods. The study also found the rate of CO-poisoning related emergency department visits |
| was significantly higher for the impact periods than during the control periods with the rate |
| ratio 3.44 (95% CI: 2.07, 5.72). Finally, the BRACE study revealed that rates of CO |
| poisoning-related hospitalizations were also significantly higher during the impact periods |
| with the rate ratio 4.0 (95% CI: 2.9, 5.51) (FDH 2015b). |
|
|
| Figure 4.2. Historical distribution of hurricane landfalls in Florida. |
|
|
| Indirect Impact Pathways–Infectious Diseases |
|
|
| Climate change and variability and associated variable weather conditions can affect human |
| health through indirect pathways (Fig. 4.1). These indirect impacts are modulated through |
| biological and ecological processes that can influence infectious diseases (in particular, some |
| water/food- and vector-borne diseases) and air quality. In this section, we focus on water/food-, |
| and vector-borne diseases. |
|
|
| Disease Transmission Groupings |
|
|
| The impact of climate change and variability and associated weather events on infectious |
| diseases has been receiving much attention in the past several decades. Across the globe, high |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 3 3 |
|
|
| human mortality rates and disability have been attributed to infectious diseases; climate change |
| is intensifying and will continue to exacerbate transmission of infectious diseases, poses |
| increasing concerns (Patz et al. 2005). Indeed, the transmission of many infectious diseases is |
| closely linked to physical environmental factors, such as water and temperature. Many water- |
| associated and zoonotic pathogens, for instance, which account for more than 75% of known |
| pathogens causing human diseases, are associated with hydrological process (WHO 2003). From |
| a transmission perspective, infectious diseases can be broadly classified into two groups: 1) |
| directly transmitted (i.e., those spread directly from person to person via direct contact or droplet |
| exposure, such as influenza and tuberculosis); and 2) indirectly transmitted, including those |
| mediated through an intermediate vector organisms (vector-borne) or through environmental |
| media such as water and soil (environmentally-mediated) (Eisenberg et al. 2007). Because the |
| diseases in the indirectly transmitted group are either directly or indirectly related to water, this |
| group can be further broken down into the following sub-groups based on water’s role in disease |
| transmission: waterborne (e.g., cholera typically via fecal-oral transmission), water-based (e.g. |
| part of the pathogen life cycle requires aquatic environment, such as schistosomiasis), and water- |
| related (e.g., malaria and dengue, which need water for breeding of insect vectors to fulfill the |
| transmission cycle) (Yang et al. 2012; Mordecai et al. 2013; Ryan et al. 2015; Johnson et al. |
| 2015; Mordecai et al., 2017) . |
|
|
| Climate-Sensitivity of Microbial Agents and Their Associated Diseases |
|
|
| Table 4.1 lists some of the major pathogens and their associated diseases that are climate sensitive |
| and associated with water. These disease-causing pathogens, either through infection or toxin- |
| generating (e.g. caused by protozoa, bacteria, virus, helminth, or algae), and their associated |
| vectors (e.g., snails, mosquitoes, sand flies) are very small in size and lack thermostatic |
| mechanisms (i.e. lack of function to maintain body temperatures). Their biological (e.g., survival, |
| reproduction, development/growth, and infectivity) and environmental (e.g., contamination and |
| movement) processes are determined by environmental conditions, such as rainfall, storm runoff, |
| temperature, and sunlight. Climate change and variability and associated weather events are |
| expected to affect both fresh and marine water environments thereby changing humans’ exposure |
| to these water-related contaminants or pathogens that cause ill health. |
|
|
| a) Waterborne Diseases |
| Waterborne diseases remain an important contributor to the global burden of disease (Pruss et al. |
| 2002; Yang et al. 2012; Pruss-Ustun et al. 2014). Many different viral, bacterial, and parasitic |
| diseases have been associated with waterborne transmission (Table 4.1). Human exposure to |
| waterborne pathogens is primarily through drinking water, recreational water (e.g. via accidental |
| drinking and, for some pathogens, via dermal contact), or foods. The distribution of these |
| pathogens exhibits significant geographical variations, depending on both physical |
|
|
| 1 3 4 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| environmental and socio-economic conditions (Yang et al. 2012). For example, waterborne |
| cholera, viral hepatitis, and some other water-based and water-related diseases (e.g., |
| schistosomiasis and onchocerciasis) are largely confined to certain tropical areas where the |
| prevalence of such diseases is largely due to lack of access to improved drinking water, sanitation |
| and hygiene (Pruss et al. 2002), while some pathogens, such as Cryptosporidium parvum, |
| Giardia duodenalis, and Campylobacter spp. have a much wider geographical distribution (Yang |
| et al. 2012). Regardless of the geographical region, heavy rainfall, flooding, and temperature are |
| among the most important factors associated with transmission and outbreaks of these |
| waterborne diseases. |
|
|
| There is mounting evidence that weather events are often an important factor triggering |
| waterborne outbreaks. In developed countries, extreme weather events such as excessive rainfall |
| and flooding can overwhelm water treatment plants and/or increase runoff into recreational |
| water, leading to water contamination that causes outbreaks (Kistemann et al. 2002). Some recent |
| studies have clearly indicated that excessive rainfall has been a significant contributor to |
| waterborne outbreaks. An analysis of historical records of 548 waterborne outbreaks in the US |
| reported between 1948 and 1994 suggested a significant association between the outbreaks and |
| rainfall—51% of waterborne disease outbreaks were preceded by precipitation events above the |
| 90th percentile and 68% by events above the 80th percentile; the strongest association was |
| between the outbreaks and surface water contamination due to extreme precipitation (Curriero et |
| al. 2001). In Canada, Thomas et al. examined extreme rainfall and spring snowmelt in relation to |
| 92 Canadian waterborne disease outbreaks that occurred between 1975 and 2001. They found |
| that warmer temperatures and extreme rainfall were significant contributing factors to waterborne |
| disease outbreaks in Canada (Thomas et al. 2006). Similar studies have been conducted in |
| England (Nichols et al. 2009), the Netherlands (Schijven and de Roda Husman 2005), Finland |
| (Miettinen et al. 2001), Denmark (Laursen et al. 1994), and Taiwan (Chen et al. 2012). In many |
| developing countries, lack of access to improved drinking water and sanitation exacerbates the |
| impact of these extreme precipitation weather events on waterborne diseases. Diarrhea, caused |
| by many waterborne pathogens, remains a top killer of children under five in the developing |
| world, particularly in Africa (Pruss-Ustun et al. 2014). A large number of studies have been |
| carried out in the developing world. For example, cholera outbreaks caused by toxigenic Vibrio |
| cholerae have been consistently shown to be correlated with excessive rainfall, flooding, and |
| high temperatures in the epidemic areas of West Africa and Bangladesh (Mhalu et al. 1987; |
| Hashizume et al. 2008; Luque Fernandez et al. 2009; Ngwa et al. 2016), although the exact |
| mechanistic relationships that result in this correlation remain elusive (Colwell et al. 1998). |
| Significant (positive) relationships have been reported between excessive rainfall and/or high |
| temperatures and diarrhea in the Pacific Islands (Singh et al. 2001), Ecuador (Carlton et al. 2014), |
| and Sub-Saharan Africa (Bandyopadhyay et al. 2012), while evidence also suggests that low |
| rainfall and even drought can also be associated with diarrhea, as reported in Bangladesh |
| (Hashizume et al. 2008) and Denmark (Senhorst and Zwolsman 2005). |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 3 5 |
|
|
| b) Waterborne Diseases and Climate Impact in Florida |
| Across the US, climate change and variability and associated weather events are affecting and |
| are expected to continue to affect both marine and freshwater resources. These effects extend to |
| some water-associated pathogens and related diseases. In Florida, waterborne and foodborne |
| diseases of major public health concerns are highlighted in Table 1. Enteric bacteria, protozoan |
| parasites, enteric viruses including Salmonella enterica, Campylobacter spp., toxigenic |
| Escherichia coli, Vibrio bacteria species, Cryptosporidium and Giardia enteroviruses, |
| rotaviruses, noroviruses, and hepatitis A and E, are among those closely related to drinking and |
| recreational waters, and shellfish. These pathogens, while in environmental stages, are sensitive |
| to temperature, precipitation, and water flow. Several important toxin producers of water sources |
| are of particular public health importance in Florida (Table 4.1) including toxins from harmful |
| algal blooms, toxigenic marine species of Alexandrium (causing paralytic shellfish poisoning), |
| Karenia brevis (causing neurotoxic shellfish poisoning), and Gambierdiscus spp. (causing |
| ciguatera fish poisoning). Human exposure pathways are primarily through the consumption of |
| contaminated shellfish and fish, and in recreational waters. Cyanobacteria, consisting of multiple |
| species, can produce toxins (including microcystin), and the primary human exposure is from |
| drinking water and recreational water. For all of these harmful algal blooms species, temperature, |
| and precipitation are among the important factors affecting their reproduction, growth, and |
| distribution. |
|
|
| Fig. 4.3 shows yearly distribution of total reported outbreaks and cases of food-borne and |
| waterborne diseases in Florida from 1989 to 2011 and Fig. 4.4 shows the monthly distribution of |
| reported outbreaks and cases for 2011, exhibiting marked annual variations and distinct seasonal |
| distribution. According to the BRACE report for the period 2004–2012, approximately 1,150 |
| cases of campylobacteriosis were reported annually, with the majority of cases reported between |
| May and September. From that same report, ~426 cases of cryptosporidiosis were reported |
| annually, with the majority of cases reported between June and October. Approximately 940 |
| cases of giardiasis were reported annually, with an annual incidence rate of 5.1 cases per 100,000 |
| population and the majority of cases reported between May and October. Salmonellosis |
| accounted for the greatest number of foodborne illnesses reported, with an average of 5,438 cases |
| reported each year and ~70% reported between June and November. Finally, ~101 cases of |
| vibriosis were reported annually, with 81% of the cases reported between April and October |
| (FDH 2015b). Focusing on the five diseases—campylobacteriosis. cryptosporidiosis, giardiasis, |
| salmonellosis, and vibriosis—the BRACE study identified a total of 1,231 follow-up days of |
| interest including 775 control days and 456 impact days—42 associated with hurricanes and 414 |
| with tropical storms (FDH 2015b); the result suggested that the occurrences of cryptosporidiosis |
| and salmonellosis were significantly associated with the tropical cyclones, with the risk ratio |
| being 1.26 (95% CI, 1.04, 1.52) and 1.35 (95% CI, 1.29, 1.42), respectively (FDH 2015b). |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| d |
|
|
| , |
| h |
| s |
| a |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| u |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| a |
| i |
| r |
| t |
|
|
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| s |
| a |
| g |
| a |
| h |
| C |
|
|
| 1 3 6 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| t |
| n |
| a |
| n |
| g |
| e |
| r |
| p |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| e |
| g |
| a |
| m |
| a |
| d |
| l |
| a |
| t |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| y |
| e |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| r |
| b |
| n |
| o |
| e |
| g |
| a |
| m |
| a |
| d |
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| t |
| i |
| n |
| e |
| g |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| s |
| a |
| l |
| p |
| o |
| x |
| o |
| T |
|
|
| i |
| i |
| d |
| n |
| o |
| g |
| a |
| m |
| s |
| a |
| l |
| p |
| o |
| x |
| o |
| T |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| k |
| c |
| i |
| s |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| p |
| e |
| e |
| l |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| r |
| c |
| n |
| a |
| h |
| C |
|
|
| a |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| a |
| n |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| t |
| a |
| e |
| w |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| l |
| l |
| i |
| h |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| e |
| b |
|
|
| n |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| n |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| w |
|
|
| s |
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| l |
| a |
|
|
| M |
|
|
| y |
| l |
| f |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| t |
| e |
| s |
| t |
| y |
| b |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| s |
| o |
| n |
| a |
| p |
| y |
| r |
| t |
| n |
| a |
| c |
| i |
| r |
| f |
|
|
| A |
|
|
| P |
| P |
| S |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| s |
| o |
| n |
| a |
| p |
| y |
| r |
| T |
|
|
| P |
| P |
| S |
| m |
| u |
| i |
| d |
| o |
| m |
| s |
| a |
| l |
| P |
|
|
| r |
| o |
| f |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| t |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| e |
| w |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| t |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| e |
| w |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| t |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| e |
| w |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| y |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| e |
| s |
| y |
| d |
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| p |
| o |
| e |
| p |
| d |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| r |
| p |
| m |
| o |
| c |
| o |
| n |
| u |
| m |
| m |
|
|
| i |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| b |
| e |
| m |
| A |
|
|
| a |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| y |
| l |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| i |
| h |
| a |
| b |
| e |
| o |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| E |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| R |
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| R |
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| i |
| d |
| i |
| r |
| o |
| p |
| s |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| y |
| r |
| C |
|
|
| m |
| u |
| v |
| r |
| a |
| p |
| m |
| u |
| i |
| d |
| i |
| r |
| o |
| p |
| s |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| y |
| r |
| C |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| d |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| G |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| e |
| d |
| o |
| u |
| d |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| d |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| G |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| r |
| o |
| p |
| s |
| o |
| l |
| c |
| y |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| n |
| e |
| n |
| a |
| t |
| e |
| y |
| a |
| c |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| p |
| s |
| o |
| l |
| c |
| y |
| C |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| a |
| o |
| z |
| o |
| t |
| o |
| r |
| P |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| p |
| u |
| o |
| r |
| G |
|
|
| s |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| S |
| & |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| I |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| M |
|
|
| s |
| y |
| a |
| w |
| h |
| t |
| a |
| P |
| e |
| r |
| u |
| s |
| o |
| p |
| x |
| E |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| M |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| m |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| n |
| a |
| g |
| r |
| O |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| s |
| s |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| s |
| n |
| a |
| r |
| T |
|
|
| . |
| s |
| e |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| s |
| t |
| n |
| e |
| g |
| a |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| i |
| c |
| o |
| s |
| s |
| a |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| v |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| s |
| n |
| e |
| s |
| - |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| m |
|
|
| i |
| l |
| c |
|
|
| f |
| o |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| i |
| l |
|
|
| A |
|
|
| . |
| 1 |
| . |
| 4 |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| b |
| a |
| T |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| o |
| b |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| c |
| s |
| u |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| t |
| n |
| i |
| o |
| j |
|
|
| e |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| e |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| g |
| a |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| o |
| m |
| e |
| h |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| n |
| e |
| D |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| d |
| e |
| e |
| l |
| b |
|
|
| , |
| h |
| s |
| a |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| H |
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| n |
| e |
| m |
|
|
| r |
| o |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| i |
| z |
| z |
| i |
| d |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| s |
| a |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| o |
| M |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| u |
| o |
| L |
|
|
| . |
| t |
| S |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| u |
| o |
| L |
|
|
| . |
| t |
| S |
|
|
| h |
| s |
| a |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| e |
| l |
| c |
| s |
| u |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| w |
| s |
| d |
| n |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| t |
| n |
| i |
| o |
| j |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| l |
| l |
| i |
| h |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| h |
| g |
| i |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| , |
| s |
| n |
| a |
| m |
| u |
| h |
|
|
| n |
| i |
|
|
| e |
| r |
| a |
| R |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| e |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| s |
|
|
| n |
| i |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| i |
| a |
| l |
| a |
| m |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| a |
| n |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| s |
| a |
| E |
|
|
| a |
| y |
| n |
| u |
| g |
| n |
| u |
| k |
| i |
| h |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
| a |
| y |
| n |
| u |
| g |
| n |
| u |
| k |
| i |
| h |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| s |
| a |
| E |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| a |
| n |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| s |
| a |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| o |
| M |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| s |
| o |
| r |
| C |
| a |
| L |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| s |
| o |
| r |
| C |
| a |
| L |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| d |
| e |
| r |
| i |
| t |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| i |
| r |
| b |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| s |
| a |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| o |
| M |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| N |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| e |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| N |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| e |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| ) |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| - |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| V |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| d |
| r |
| o |
| s |
| i |
| d |
|
|
| t |
| n |
| e |
| m |
| e |
| v |
| o |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
| , |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| d |
| a |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| a |
| p |
| a |
| J |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| l |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| e |
| c |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| a |
| p |
| a |
| J |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| r |
| u |
| z |
| i |
| e |
| s |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
|
|
| ) |
| s |
| u |
| o |
| e |
| n |
| a |
| t |
| u |
| c |
| ( |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| r |
| o |
| s |
| n |
| i |
| k |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| ) |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| e |
| c |
| s |
| i |
| v |
| ( |
|
|
| t |
| n |
| e |
| m |
| e |
| g |
| r |
| a |
| l |
| n |
| e |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| v |
| i |
| l |
| / |
| n |
| e |
| e |
| l |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| t |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| e |
| w |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| y |
| l |
| f |
| d |
| n |
| a |
| s |
| y |
| b |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| r |
| e |
| h |
| t |
| o |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| ) |
| F |
| ( |
|
|
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| d |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| V |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| p |
| e |
| H |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| R |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| R |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| V |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| , |
| ) |
| F |
| R |
| D |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| n |
| a |
| m |
| h |
| s |
| i |
| e |
| L |
|
|
| P |
| P |
| S |
| a |
| i |
| n |
| a |
| m |
| h |
| s |
| i |
| e |
| L |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| p |
| e |
| h |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| r |
| i |
|
|
| V |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
| E |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| A |
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| p |
| e |
| H |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| V |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| e |
| o |
| r |
| t |
| s |
| a |
| g |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| r |
| i |
|
|
| V |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| V |
|
|
| 4 |
|
|
| , |
| 3 |
| , |
| 2 |
| , |
| 1 |
| V |
| N |
| E |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
| o |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| E |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| r |
| i |
| v |
| o |
| r |
| o |
| N |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| i |
| z |
| u |
| r |
| c |
|
|
| . |
|
|
| T |
|
|
| ) |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| - |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| V |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| 7 |
| 3 |
| 1 |
|
|
| • |
|
|
| H |
| T |
| L |
| A |
| E |
| H |
|
|
| N |
| A |
| M |
| U |
| H |
|
|
| N |
| O |
|
|
| S |
| T |
| C |
| A |
| P |
| M |
|
|
| I |
|
|
| E |
| G |
| N |
| A |
| H |
| C |
|
|
| E |
| T |
| A |
| M |
|
|
| I |
| L |
| C |
|
|
| s |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| S |
| & |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| I |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| M |
|
|
| s |
| y |
| a |
| w |
| h |
| t |
| a |
| P |
| e |
| r |
| u |
| s |
| o |
| p |
| x |
| E |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| M |
|
|
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| m |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| n |
| a |
| g |
| r |
| O |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| s |
| s |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| s |
| n |
| a |
| r |
| T |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 3 7 |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| c |
| s |
| u |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| u |
| a |
| n |
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| r |
| c |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| d |
| b |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| e |
| b |
| n |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| d |
| b |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| a |
| l |
| a |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| s |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| r |
| c |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| r |
| c |
| h |
| c |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| a |
|
|
| e |
| m |
| o |
| r |
| d |
| n |
| y |
| s |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| m |
| e |
| a |
| r |
| u |
| - |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| y |
| l |
| o |
| m |
| e |
| a |
| h |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| d |
| y |
| d |
| o |
| o |
| l |
| B |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| d |
| b |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| n |
| o |
| m |
| u |
| e |
| n |
| p |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| n |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| e |
| r |
| h |
| t |
| - |
| e |
| f |
| i |
| l |
|
|
| o |
| t |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| s |
| e |
| l |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| k |
| s |
|
|
| d |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| M |
|
|
| h |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| w |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| y |
| l |
| f |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| e |
| d |
| r |
| o |
|
|
| k |
| c |
| i |
| t |
|
|
| f |
| o |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| , |
| r |
| i |
| a |
| h |
| g |
| u |
| o |
| r |
| h |
| t |
|
|
| e |
| b |
| n |
| a |
| c |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| l |
| a |
| m |
| i |
| n |
| a |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| f |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| D |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| r |
| c |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| c |
| s |
| u |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| d |
|
|
| e |
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| S |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| v |
| e |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| d |
| b |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| D |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| l |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| F |
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| m |
| e |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| p |
| e |
| s |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| u |
| o |
| w |
| n |
| e |
| p |
| o |
| , |
| h |
| s |
| i |
| f |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| h |
| S |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| D |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| D |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| i |
| l |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| . |
|
|
| E |
| c |
| i |
| n |
| e |
| g |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
| o |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| E |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| . |
|
|
| E |
| c |
| i |
| g |
| a |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| o |
| m |
| e |
| a |
| h |
| o |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| E |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| R |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| F |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| e |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| n |
| o |
| m |
| l |
| a |
| S |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| g |
| i |
| h |
| S |
|
|
| d |
| i |
| o |
| h |
| p |
| y |
| T |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| b |
| i |
| V |
|
|
| a |
| r |
| e |
| l |
| o |
| h |
| C |
|
|
| e |
| a |
| r |
| e |
| l |
| o |
| h |
| c |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| b |
| i |
| V |
|
|
| P |
| P |
| S |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| b |
| i |
| V |
|
|
| . |
| p |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| a |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| n |
| o |
| m |
| l |
| a |
| S |
|
|
| i |
| h |
| p |
| y |
| t |
|
|
| a |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| n |
| o |
| m |
| l |
| a |
| S |
|
|
| . |
| p |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| a |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| g |
| i |
| h |
| S |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| c |
| a |
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| c |
| a |
| b |
| o |
| l |
| y |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| C |
|
|
| . |
| p |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| c |
| a |
| b |
| o |
| l |
| y |
| p |
| m |
| a |
| C |
|
|
| i |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| p |
| u |
| o |
| r |
| G |
|
|
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| i |
| n |
| i |
| s |
| r |
| e |
| Y |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| m |
| e |
| a |
| r |
| a |
| l |
| u |
| T |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| n |
| e |
| r |
| a |
| l |
| u |
| t |
|
|
| a |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| c |
| n |
| a |
| r |
| F |
|
|
| . |
| p |
| p |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| n |
| i |
| s |
| r |
| e |
| Y |
|
|
| i |
| l |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| ) |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| - |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| V |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| k |
| s |
|
|
| e |
| h |
| t |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| d |
| n |
| u |
| s |
| e |
| l |
| u |
| d |
| o |
| n |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| e |
| y |
| e |
|
|
| , |
| h |
| s |
| a |
| r |
| n |
| i |
| k |
| S |
|
|
| m |
| r |
| o |
| w |
| e |
| y |
| e |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| p |
| t |
| n |
| i |
| o |
| j |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| c |
| s |
| u |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| y |
| h |
| c |
| t |
| I |
|
|
| y |
| r |
| a |
| n |
| o |
| m |
| l |
| u |
| p |
| , |
| a |
| m |
| e |
| d |
| e |
| h |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| l |
|
|
| , |
| c |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| s |
| a |
|
|
| t |
| s |
| o |
| M |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| d |
| r |
| a |
| t |
| e |
| r |
| h |
| t |
| w |
| o |
| r |
| g |
| , |
| l |
| o |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| y |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| d |
| n |
| a |
| y |
| d |
| o |
| o |
| l |
| B |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| l |
| i |
| h |
| p |
| o |
| n |
| i |
| s |
| o |
| e |
|
|
| n |
| e |
| r |
| d |
| l |
| i |
| h |
| c |
|
|
| n |
| i |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| d |
| r |
| a |
| t |
| e |
| r |
| h |
| t |
| w |
| o |
| r |
| g |
| , |
| t |
| r |
| o |
| f |
| m |
| o |
| c |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| d |
| b |
| A |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| ) |
| F |
| D |
|
|
| , |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| - |
| l |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| F |
|
|
| o |
| t |
| i |
| u |
| q |
| s |
| o |
| m |
| y |
| b |
|
|
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| y |
| l |
| f |
| k |
| c |
| a |
| l |
| b |
| y |
| b |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| y |
| l |
| f |
| r |
| e |
| e |
| d |
| y |
| b |
| e |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| B |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| o |
| L |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| o |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| V |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| c |
| a |
| b |
| o |
| n |
| a |
| y |
| C |
|
|
| a |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| a |
| o |
| L |
|
|
| e |
| a |
| g |
| l |
| A |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| c |
| s |
| A |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| d |
| i |
| o |
| c |
| i |
| r |
| b |
| m |
| u |
| l |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| c |
| s |
| A |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| n |
| a |
| c |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| m |
| a |
|
|
| r |
| o |
| t |
| a |
| c |
| e |
| N |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| f |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| r |
| o |
| w |
| p |
| i |
| h |
| W |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| r |
| a |
| l |
| i |
| f |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| h |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| L |
|
|
| a |
| r |
| u |
| i |
| h |
| c |
| i |
| r |
| t |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| r |
| u |
| h |
| c |
| i |
| r |
| T |
|
|
| i |
| t |
| f |
| o |
| r |
| c |
| n |
| a |
| b |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| r |
| e |
| r |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| u |
| W |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| c |
| r |
| e |
| c |
| o |
| h |
| c |
| n |
| O |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| l |
| u |
| v |
| l |
| o |
| v |
|
|
| a |
| c |
| r |
| e |
| c |
| o |
| h |
| c |
| n |
| O |
|
|
| ) |
| e |
| n |
| r |
| o |
| b |
| - |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| V |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| t |
| o |
| r |
| u |
| e |
| n |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| g |
| a |
| m |
| a |
| d |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| v |
| i |
| l |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| s |
| e |
| n |
| l |
| l |
| i |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| i |
| t |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| r |
| e |
| D |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| e |
| r |
| i |
| d |
| d |
| n |
| a |
| D |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| s |
| n |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
| o |
| t |
|
|
| e |
| r |
| u |
| s |
| o |
| p |
| x |
| E |
|
|
| s |
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| c |
| a |
| e |
| r |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| y |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| a |
| r |
| i |
| p |
| s |
| e |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| i |
| s |
| e |
| h |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| r |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| , |
| s |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| p |
| m |
| y |
| s |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| i |
| o |
| r |
| t |
| s |
| a |
| G |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
| y |
| b |
| ) |
| F |
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| h |
| s |
| i |
| f |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| h |
| s |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
| o |
| r |
| u |
| e |
| N |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| v |
| e |
| r |
| b |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| n |
| e |
| r |
| a |
| K |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| t |
| i |
| r |
| r |
| i |
|
|
| e |
| y |
| e |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| n |
| o |
| s |
| i |
| o |
| p |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| s |
| e |
| h |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| r |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| y |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| e |
| r |
| t |
| x |
| e |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| a |
| l |
| a |
| m |
|
|
| , |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| o |
| v |
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
| y |
| b |
| ) |
| F |
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| n |
| o |
| s |
| i |
| o |
| p |
| h |
| s |
| i |
| f |
|
|
| a |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| C |
|
|
| p |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| s |
| u |
| c |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| r |
| e |
| i |
| b |
| m |
| a |
| G |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| y |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| g |
| n |
| i |
| n |
| o |
| s |
| i |
| o |
| p |
|
|
| y |
| r |
| o |
| t |
| a |
| r |
| i |
| p |
| s |
| e |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| i |
| s |
| e |
| h |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| r |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| y |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| e |
| r |
| t |
| x |
| e |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| r |
| o |
| m |
| u |
| c |
| r |
| i |
|
|
| C |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| x |
| o |
| t |
|
|
| y |
| b |
| ) |
| F |
| ( |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| h |
| s |
| i |
| f |
| l |
| l |
| e |
| h |
| s |
|
|
| c |
| i |
| t |
| y |
| l |
| a |
| r |
| a |
| P |
|
|
| p |
| p |
| s |
| m |
| u |
| i |
| r |
| d |
| n |
| a |
| x |
| e |
| l |
| A |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| l |
| e |
| r |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| . |
| a |
| d |
| i |
| r |
| o |
| l |
| F |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| e |
| c |
| n |
| a |
| c |
| i |
| f |
| i |
| n |
| g |
| i |
| s |
| h |
| t |
| l |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| c |
| i |
| l |
| b |
| u |
| p |
| r |
| o |
| j |
| a |
| m |
|
|
| f |
| o |
| s |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| e |
| s |
| i |
| d |
| / |
| s |
| n |
| e |
| g |
| o |
| h |
| t |
| a |
| p |
|
|
| s |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| c |
| i |
| d |
| n |
| i |
| d |
| e |
| r |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| t |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| l |
| h |
| g |
| i |
| H |
|
|
| . |
| 2 |
| ; |
| ) |
| F |
| ( |
|
|
| s |
| d |
| o |
| o |
| f |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
| , |
| ) |
| R |
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| e |
| r |
| c |
| e |
| r |
|
|
| , |
| ) |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| g |
| n |
| i |
| k |
| n |
| i |
| r |
| d |
| : |
| s |
| y |
| a |
| w |
| h |
| t |
| a |
| p |
| e |
| r |
| u |
| s |
| o |
| p |
| x |
| e |
|
|
| n |
| i |
| a |
| m |
| r |
| o |
| f |
|
|
| s |
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| i |
| v |
| e |
| r |
| b |
| b |
| A |
|
|
| . |
|
|
| 1 |
| : |
| e |
| t |
| o |
| N |
|
|
| e |
| g |
| a |
| m |
| a |
| d |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| t |
| s |
| e |
| t |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
| y |
| r |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| r |
| u |
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| w |
| h |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| w |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| m |
| r |
| e |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| m |
| o |
| s |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| i |
| h |
| c |
| S |
|
|
| . |
| p |
| p |
| s |
|
|
| a |
| m |
| o |
| s |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| i |
| h |
| c |
| S |
|
|
| s |
| h |
| t |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| l |
| e |
| H |
|
|
| a |
| i |
| m |
| e |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| u |
| g |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| f |
|
|
| , |
| e |
| t |
| i |
| t |
| e |
| p |
| p |
| a |
|
|
| f |
| o |
| s |
| s |
| o |
| l |
|
|
| , |
| a |
| e |
| h |
| r |
| r |
| a |
| i |
| D |
|
|
| l |
| i |
| o |
| s |
| h |
| t |
| i |
|
|
| w |
|
|
| t |
| c |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| c |
|
|
| l |
| a |
| m |
| r |
| e |
| D |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| c |
| e |
| f |
| n |
| i |
|
|
| m |
| r |
| o |
| w |
| k |
| o |
| o |
| H |
|
|
| e |
| l |
| a |
| n |
| e |
| d |
| o |
| u |
| d |
| a |
| m |
| o |
| t |
| s |
| o |
| l |
| y |
| c |
| n |
| A |
|
|
| n |
| o |
| i |
| t |
| a |
| m |
| m |
| a |
| l |
| f |
| n |
| i |
| d |
| n |
| a |
|
|
| r |
| e |
| c |
| l |
| u |
| l |
| u |
| f |
| n |
| i |
| a |
| P |
|
|
| ) |
|
|
| D |
|
|
| ( |
| d |
| e |
| t |
| a |
| n |
| i |
| m |
| a |
| t |
| n |
| o |
| C |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| a |
| i |
| l |
| u |
| c |
| n |
| u |
| c |
| a |
| r |
| D |
|
|
| s |
| i |
| s |
| n |
| e |
| n |
| i |
| d |
| e |
| m |
| s |
| u |
| l |
| u |
| c |
| n |
| u |
| c |
| a |
| r |
| D |
|
|
| d |
| e |
| s |
| a |
| b |
| - |
| r |
| e |
| t |
| a |
|
|
| W |
|
|
| 1 3 8 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| Figure 4.3. Reported outbreaks (bar) and human cases (line) of food-borne and waterborne diseases in |
| Florida each year from 1989 to 2011 (Source: Florida Department of Health). Toxigenic V. cholerae |
| infections are highly unusual in Florida and the first V. cholerae O75 outbreak was detected and reported |
| in Florida between March 23 and April 13, 2011. |
|
|
| Figure 4.4. Monthly distribution of reported outbreaks and cases of food-borne and waterborne diseases in |
| Florida, 2011 (Source: Florida Department of Health) |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 3 9 |
|
|
| c) Vector-Borne Diseases |
| Vector-borne diseases pose serious public health threats throughout the world. According to the |
| World Health Organization, vector-borne diseases account for more than 17% of infectious |
| diseases, causing more than one million deaths annually from diseases such as malaria, dengue |
| fever, yellow fever, Japanese encephalitis, and schistosomiasis (WHO 2016). Vector-borne |
| diseases are transmitted through vector organisms including mosquitoes, ticks, flies, fleas, and |
| snails. The transmission of vector-borne diseases takes two primary transmission pathways. The |
| first is the human-vector pathway, with transmission through a vector biting a host; pathogens |
| survive outside hosts in arthropod vectors and humans are typically the only host (Eisenberg et |
| al. 2007). Diseases in this group include malaria, dengue fever, onchocerciasis, trypanosomiasis, |
| and filariasis (Table 4.1). The second pathway involves zoonotic transmission, with a vector |
| biting a nonhuman host as the transmission route and humans as the dead-end host (Eisenberg et |
| al. 2007). Diseases in this group include Lyme disease, Yellow fever, West Nile virus, and |
| Japanese encephalitis (Table 4.1). The transmission and spread of vector-borne diseases are |
| determined by complex interactions between the host (either human or nonhuman), the vector |
| (e.g., mosquitos, flies, snails, and ticks), and various pathogens ranging from protozoans, viruses, |
| bacteria, and helminthes (Table 4.1). Important biological properties underlying the transmission |
| of vector-borne diseases include survival, development, and reproduction of the vector; also the |
| pathogens in the vector, the vector’s biting rate, and the behavior of hosts (human and |
| nonhuman), all of which are associated with climatic conditions. The following sections discuss |
| some specific aspects of the effects of rainfall, temperature, and flooding with regard to vector- |
| borne diseases. |
|
|
| Temperature Sensitivity |
| Through the modulating effects on physiological activities and tolerance limits of vectors and |
| infectivity of pathogens, temperature can affect distribution of the vector and transmission of the |
| pathogens between vectors and hosts. Some key mechanistic effects of temperature on vectors, |
| vector-borne pathogens and their transmission are summarized by Gulber et al. (2001). |
| • Change in survival of vectors (e.g. increase or decrease depending on species) |
| • Change in susceptibility of vectors to pathogens |
| • Change in vector population growth |
| • Change in feeding behavior and host contact |
| • Change in incubation period of pathogens in vectors (e.g. decreased extrinsic incubation |
|
|
| period at higher temperatures) |
|
|
| • Change in pathogen replication and infectivity |
| • Change in transmission season |
|
|
| A large number of studies on vector-borne diseases at different scales have provided |
| empirical evidence and predictions on the climatic factors and vector-borne disease links. For |
|
|
| 1 4 0 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| example, studies have shown significant relationships between ambient temperature and malaria |
| transmission for both mean temperature (Loevinsohn 1994; Lindblade et al. 2000; Thomson et |
| al. 2005; Tian et al. 2008; Wardrop et al. 2013) and its daily fluctuations (Paaijmans et al. 2010). |
| Laboratory studies have shown clear temperature-dependent effects on dengue virus infection in |
| mosquitoes (Alto and Bettinardi 2013). Fluctuations at a low mean temperature accelerate |
| dengue virus transmission in Aedes aegypti mosquitoes (Carrington et al. 2013). A recent |
| systematic review and meta-analysis based on 137 studies on the relationship between dengue |
| risk and temperature suggests that the dengue transmission and risk are sensitive to temperature, |
| with a positive relationship between them for a minimum range (18.1–24.2 °C) to a maximum |
| temperature range (28.0–34.5 °C) (Fan et al. 2014). A regional predictive study reported that |
| increased temperature increases the likelihood of many vector-borne diseases, in particular |
| malaria, dengue fever, and Lyme disease in new areas (Githeko et al. 2000). Similar findings are |
| also reported for West Nile virus (Soverow et al. 2009). These empirical findings have been used |
| to parameterize mechanistic models of temperature driven transmission for vector-borne |
| diseases, which can be coupled to projected climate scenarios to anticipate shifting geographies |
| of transmission risk, e.g. for malaria (Mordecai et al. 2013; Johnson et al. 2014; Johnson et al. |
| 2015; Ryan et al. 2015; Ryan et al. 2015) and for Aedes spp transmitted diseases of concern for |
| Florida: dengue, chikugunya, and zika viruses (Moedecai et al. 2017; Ryan et al. 2017). |
|
|
| Rainfall |
| Rainfall can supply water to both transient and persistent environments that can serve as habitats |
| or breeding sites for vectors and/or for part of pathogens’ lifecycles, critical for transmission of |
| vector-borne diseases. Meanwhile, rainfall can also have negative impacts on the habitats (for |
| example, washing away), thereby reducing the transmission risk. Variations in rainfall may have |
| direct and indirect impacts on the distribution and timing of transmission of vector-borne |
| diseases. Some key mechanistic effects of rainfall on vectors, vector-borne pathogens, and their |
| transmission are summarized by Gubler et al. (2001). |
| • |
| • Excess rain (e.g. causing flooding) may eliminate habitat for both vector and hosts. |
| • |
| • |
| • |
|
|
| Increased humidity may increase vector survival and biting rate. |
| Increased rainfall may facilitate transport of pathogens for certain distance (Liang et al. 2007). |
| Increased rain may increase vertebrate host size through increased food availability (e.g. |
| vegetation). |
|
|
| Increased rain may increase larval habitat and vector population. |
|
|
| • Flooding may decrease vertebrate host size (e.g. reduced food availability) but increase |
|
|
| interactions (e.g. contacts) with humans. |
|
|
| Such mechanistic links have been reported by many studies including for diseases such as |
| malaria (van der Hoek et al. 1997; Thomson et al. 2005; Galardo et al. 2009; Gao et al. 2012; |
| Yang et al. 2012), dengue fever (Li et al. 1985; Su 2008; Johansson et al. 2009; Banu et al. 2011; |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 4 1 |
|
|
| Hii et al. 2012), West Nile virus (Shaman et al. 2005; Soverow et al. 2009), and Lyme disease |
| (Ogden et al. 2006; Ostfeld et al. 2006). |
|
|
| Vector-Borne Diseases in Florida |
| In the United States, 14 vector-borne diseases are of primary public health concern. Table 4.2 |
| lists key notifiable vector-borne diseases and reported cases between 2013 and 2015 in Florida. |
| Major mosquito-borne diseases include the St. Louis encephalitis virus, West Nile virus, Eastern |
| equine encephalitis virus, Western equine encephalitis virus, Venezuelan equine encephalitis |
| virus, Everglades virus, and the California serogroup viruses including La Crosse encephalitis |
| virus, all of which are transmitted by mosquitoes. More recently, concern about Aedes spp |
| transmitted flavivirus and alphaviral disesaes have become more prevalent: dengue (DENV), |
| chikungunya (CHIKV), and zika (ZIKV). The 2015-2016 global public health emergency for |
| Zika declared by the WHO focused attention on Florida as an introduction and establishment |
| gateway for the U.S. |
|
|
| Table 4.2. A summary of reported case counts of notifiable vector-borne diseases in Florida. (Source: |
| Florida Department of Health). |
|
|
| 2013-2015 Reported Cases Number of Counties Reported |
|
|
| Diseases |
| Tick-borne |
| Lyme disease |
| Spotted Fever Rickettsia |
| Anaplasmosis/Ehrlichiosis |
| Tularemia |
| Mosquito-Borne |
| West Nile virus |
| Malaria |
| Dengue |
| California serogroup viruses 2 |
| 3 |
| Eastern equine encephalitis |
| 2 |
| St. Louis encephalitis |
|
|
| 459 |
| 74 |
| 82 |
| 2 |
|
|
| 37 |
| 146 |
| 331 |
|
|
| 46 |
| 18 |
| 30 |
| 2 |
|
|
| 14 |
| 24 |
| 31 |
| 2 |
| 3 |
| 1 |
|
|
| St. Louis Encephalitis. The St. Louis encephalitis virus, a flavivirus, was the most common |
| mosquito-transmitted human pathogen in the U.S. prior to the introduction of the West Nile virus |
| in 1999 (FDH 2016). In Florida, the principal vector is Culex nigripalpus, a ubiquitous species |
| throughout the state. No human case has been reported in Florida since 2003. However, sentinel |
| chickens testing positive for antibodies to the St. Louis encephalitis virus have been reported in |
| several counties in Central and South Florida, suggesting the potential for a possible resurgence |
| (FDH 2014, 2016). |
|
|
| West Nile virus. The peak period of transmission in Florida for the West Nile virus is July |
| through September. The natural cycle of West Nile virus involves Culex mosquitoes and wild |
| birds. Between 2001 and 2013, 318 human West Nile virus cases were reported in Florida and |
|
|
| 1 4 2 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| West Nile virus activities have been consistently reported in many counties around the state |
| (FDH 2014). |
|
|
| Eastern Equine Encephalitis. Eastern equine encephalitis occurs in natural cycles involving |
| birds and Culiseta melanura in freshwater swampy areas, with a peak in transmission occurring |
| between May and August. Historical and current evidence indicates limited human Eastern |
| equine encephalitis epidemic potential in Florida (FDH 2014, 2016). |
|
|
| Dengue Fever. In Florida, a historical dengue fever epidemic occurred in 1934-1935 and then |
| it ceased. It re-emerged in 2009, and since then a small number of cases have been reported each |
| year among individuals who had previous travel to dengue-endemic countries. In the summer of |
| 2009, local dengue transmission was identified in Key West, Florida. Since then, sporadic local |
| transmission has been identified in other Central and South Florida counties during 2010, 2011, |
| 2012, and 2013 (FDH 2014, 2016). The presence of the Aedes spp mosquito, both Aedes aegypti, |
| also known as the Yellow Fever mosquito, which has been a persistent invasive mosquito in |
| Florida for a couple of centuries, and the more recently introduced Asian Tiger Mosquito, Aedes |
| albopictus, maintain transmission potential in Florida. Aedes mosquitoes are capable of breeding |
| in as little as a teaspoon of water, and are able to adapt well to urban environments, and exhibit |
| transmission of dengue, chikungunya, and zika, at temperature ranges found almost year-round |
| in most of Florida (Mordecai et al. 2017). The optimal transmission temperature range for Aedes |
| aegypti, in particular, is higher than that for Aedes albopictus, suggesting that future climates |
| will promote Ae aegypti transmission in Florida, before it becomes too hot for transmission (Ryan |
| et al. 2017). |
|
|
| Malaria. Malaria is caused by the mosquito-borne parasite Plasmodium falciparum. Endemic |
| malaria was eliminated in Florida in the late 1940s. However, imported cases—either from |
| travelers returning to the state from malaria-endemic regions or tourists carrying the pathogen— |
| have been reported. The Anopheles mosquitoes responsible for transmitting the malaria parasite |
| to humans are common in the state so establishment of local transmission is still possible (FDH |
| 2014, 2016). |
|
|
| Tick-Borne Diseases. The most common tick-borne diseases are ehrlichiosis, anaplasmosis, |
| Lyme disease, Rocky Mountain spotted fever, and other spotted fever illnesses. Lyme disease is |
| the most commonly reported vector-borne disease in the United States. It is caused by a bacteria |
| known as Borrelia burgdorferi. Lyme disease is reported in Florida year-round. An estimate |
| suggests that about 23% of cases were acquired in Florida and about 77% were acquired while |
| travelling to other states or countries (FDH 2016). Ehrlichiosis and Anaplasmosis—several |
| pathogenic species in the genus Ehrlichia and Anaplasma—can cause human illness. The human |
| illness caused by Ehrlichia chaffeensis is called Human Monocytic Ehrlichiosis, and the illness |
| caused by Anaplasma phagocytophilum is called Anaplasmosis or Human Granulocytotropic |
| Anaplasmosis. In Florida, the majority of Human Monocytic Ehrlichiosis cases (73%) are |
| acquired in Florida, primarily in the northern and central parts of the state, and Human |
| Granulocytotropic Anaplasmosis cases are even more likely to be acquired in Florida. Cases are |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 4 3 |
|
|
| reported year-round, with a peak occurring during the spring and summer months (FDH 2016). |
| Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever is a disease is caused by the bacterium Rickettsia richerrsii and, |
| in Florida, it is transmitted primarily by the American dog tick. It can also be caused by |
| Dermacentor variabilis and cases of this transmission are reported year-round with more than |
| 70% acquired in Florida, and the majority of cases are reported in the northern and central regions |
| of the state (FDH 2016). |
|
|
| Drought |
| Drought is considered a meteorological anomaly characterized by a prolonged and abnormal |
| moisture deficiency. Climate change and variability are progressively increasing the severity and |
| frequency of drought events. Drought has many possible public health implications (Kalis et al. |
| 2009; Kalis and Curtiss 2016). Drought may: |
| • Compromise quantity and quality of water for drinking, sanitation, and hygiene |
| • Compromise air quality (e.g. increased particulate matters in the air) |
| • Reduce crop yield, food availability and nutrition |
| • |
|
|
| Increase or decrease risks to infectious pathogens (e.g. waterborne, air-borne, and vector- |
| borne) |
| Increase risk of non-communicable illness (e.g. respiratory infections and/or illness) |
|
|
| • |
|
|
| Drought has been linked to deterioration of water quality (Golladay and Battle 2002; Al- |
| Kharabsheh and Ta'any 2003) and air quality (Taylor and Davies 1990; Field et al. 2009) in |
| various settings in both the developed and developing world. Drought has been implicated for |
| infectious diseases—waterborne (Lipp et al. 2002; Schuster et al. 2005; Senhorst and Zwolsman |
| 2005), vector-borne (Chretien et al. 2007; Erlanger et al. 2009; Medlock and Leach 2015), and |
| airborne (Polymenakou et al. 2008). Drought conditions have also been linked to increased |
| incidence of respiratory diseases (Smith et al. 2014). |
|
|
| In Florida, the BRACE study examined associations between monthly drought conditions |
| (using the Standardized Precipitation Index), disease rates and emergency department visits for |
| specific health conditions (e.g. allergic rhinitis, asthma, and all respiratory diseases excluding |
| asthma) among Florida residents from 2005 to 2012. The results suggested that drought was |
| significantly associated with emergency department visits for respiratory diseases. It is worth |
| noting that the relationship between the most extreme drought conditions and emergency |
| department visits tended to be protective (e.g. less emergency department visits for respiratory |
| illness), while more moderate drought appeared to be associated with an increase in emergency |
| department visits for the health conditions. A similar pattern was also observed for asthma (FDH |
| 2014b). |
|
|
| 1 4 4 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| Indirect Impact Pathway – Mental Health, Well-Being, |
| and Community Health |
|
|
| Mental health disorders and well-being are an important aspect of the human health impacts |
| associated with climate change and variability, and associated weather events. Many mental |
| health consequences, ranging from simple stress and distress symptoms to some severe |
| conditions including anxiety, distress, posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and even suicidal |
| tendency have been the focus of much of the research and public health responses in the past few |
| decades. Here are some key mental disorders and community health issues that may be related |
| to climate change and associated weather events, based on the U.S. Global Change Research |
| Program report (Crimmins et al. 2016). |
|
|
| Experience with extreme weather events, such as flooding, drought, and hurricanes, may |
|
|
| cause the following mental disorders: |
| • |
| • |
| • |
| • |
|
|
| Increased stress, anxiety, depression, grief, and even suicidality; |
| Increased tensions on social stress and relationships; |
| Increased substance abuse; and |
| Increased risk of PTSD. |
| At the community level (Crimmins et al. 2016), potential impacts may include: |
| • |
| Increased interpersonal aggression, |
| • |
| Increased violence and crime, |
| • |
| Increased social instability, and |
| • Decreased community cohesion. |
|
|
| Assessing the impacts of natural disasters on mental or community health and well-being of |
| affected populations, as well as mediation techniques, has been a focus of much research, |
| community and public health responses. In Florida, studies have suggested that anxiety disorder, |
| major depressive episodes, and PTSD among affected populations could be significantly |
| associated with storm exposure and displacement during the occurrence of Hurricane Andrew in |
| 1992 (David et al. 1996), as well as a number of hurricanes in 2004 (Acierno et al. 2007) and |
| 2012 (Neria and Shultz 2012). Studies have also indicated that social support would help to |
| alleviate such negative impacts (Acierno et al. 2007). Similar impacts have been reported for |
| community and public health workers who responded to these weather events. For example, |
| during the 2004 Florida hurricane season, four hurricanes (Charley, Frances, Ivan, and Jean) as |
| well as one tropical storm (Bonnie) hit Florida during a period of seven weeks. Increased PTSD, |
| other mental health issues, and substance abuse were reported among public health workers |
| during and after these events (Fullerton et al. 2013; Fullerton et al. 2015). The studies also |
| suggested that these mental health outcomes were influenced by multiple community |
| characteristics including the collective efficacy of neighborhood populations in the community. |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 4 5 |
|
|
| Significantly lower depressive symptoms were associated with communities that had sufficient |
| resources and received social support (Acierno et al. 2007, Fullerton et al. 2013, Fullerton et al. |
| 2015). |
|
|
| Impacts on children following natural disasters are of particular concern. For example, |
| Hurricane Andrew was a devastating category 5 Atlantic hurricane that struck South Florida in |
| 1992. Studies showed significant impacts of hurricane exposure, stressors occurring during the |
| hurricane, and recovery periods on children’s persistent posttraumatic stress. In the Miami-Dade |
| County area, 35% to 60% of children surveyed reported moderate to very severe levels of |
| posttraumatic stress symptoms (Vernberg et al. 1996; La Greca et al. 2010), with hurricane- |
| related stressors influencing children’s persistent posttraumatic stress symptoms and other life |
| events in later stages of children’s life (La Greca et al. 2010; Weems et al. 2010; La Greca et al. |
| 2013). These findings have important community health implications for identifying and |
| potentially helping youth in the aftermath of natural disasters. |
|
|
| Conclusion |
|
|
| The current available evidence has clearly indicated increases in average temperature, total |
| annual precipitation, frequency of extreme temperature conditions and heavy precipitation in the |
| United States in the past five decades, as well as increases in the tropical cyclone activity in |
| regions along the Atlantic Ocean, the Caribbean, and the Gulf of Mexico. Similar patterns are |
| expected in the future if no remediation is conducted (USEPA 2016). Florida is likely to face |
| even greater effects than the rest of the US, particularly effects associated with sea level rise, heat |
| waves, storm surge, hurricanes, and others (FOCC 2010) that affect human health in a variety of |
| different ways. Some effects are through direct exposure pathways, such as hurricane/storm and |
| temperature-related illnesses, injuries, and deaths. Some are through indirect exposure pathways |
| such as waterborne and vector-borne diseases. And still others are through social and economic |
| pathways, such as stress and mental illness. In addition to these direct and indirect effects, we |
| see coupled and compounded effects of climate change, which are anticipated to be exacerbated |
| in the future. For example, Florida is home to a large elderly population; the warm climate and |
| housing development capacity made this ideal. However, the elderly are more vulnerable to the |
| effects of heatwaves, less mobile in the event of hurricanes, and suffer greater impacts of the |
| symptomology of febrile vectorborne diseases. This puts the state in a position higher public |
| health urgency by virtue of an interaction of demographic profile and increased impact of climate |
| change due to geography. Given the increase in hurricances and storm impacts expected under |
| climate change, we are likely to also see the added impact of vectorborne disease risk anticipated |
| in the aftermath of such disasters. For example, the additional potential vector breeding sites |
| provided by debris and damaged infrastructure after hurricanes have been noted as concerns for |
| Zika transmission in the 2016-2017 hurricane season. An additional component of this is the |
|
|
| 1 4 6 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| unanticipated exposures post-disaster, in which both displaced residents and rescue workers have |
| radically increased outdoor exposure, reduced access to air conditioned spaces, and to basic |
| protection measures such as insect repellent and appropriate protective clothing. These are just |
| two of the compounded scenarios of public health concern that the state of Florida faces in a |
| changing climate. Despite the comprehensive information reviewed in the chapter, many things |
| are still unknown or are not well understood about the health impacts of Florida’s changing |
| climate. For instance, what are the impacts of sea level rise, flooding, and other extreme weather |
| events on water contamination that will ultimately influence human health? How will future |
| warming trends and other climate-sensitive hazards influence the transmission and spread of |
| existing and/or new waterborne and vector-borne diseases? What are the disease burdens and |
| their distributions attributable to known climate-sensitive hazards in the state? To address these |
| challenges, policies focused on mitigation, adaptation strategies, health surveillance, and |
| research that could close knowledge gaps on human exposures to these climate-sensitive hazards |
| and associated health impacts are much needed. |
|
|
| Acknowledgments |
|
|
| The authors thank Melissa Jordan for her instrumental discussion on this chapter. Song Liang was supported |
| in part by grants from NSF/EEID (EF-1015908) and NSF/WSC-Category 3 (1360330). Sadie J. Ryan was |
| supported in part by grants from NSF/EEID (DEB-1518681), NSF RAPID (DEB-1641145), and an Early |
| Career Fellowship from the Florida Climate Institute. |
|
|
| References |
|
|
| Acierno, R., K. J. Ruggiero, S. Galea, H. S. Resnick, K. Koenen, J. Roitzsch, M. de Arellano, J. Boyle, and |
| D. G. Kilpatrick. 2007. Psychological sequelae resulting from the 2004 Florida hurricanes: implications |
| for postdisaster intervention. Am J Public Health 97 Suppl 1:S103-108. |
|
|
| Al-Kharabsheh, A., and R. Ta'any. 2003. Influence of urbanization on water quality deterioration during |
|
|
| drought periods at South Jordan. Journal of Arid Environments 53:619-630. |
|
|
| Alto, B. W., and D. Bettinardi. 2013. Temperature and dengue virus infection in mosquitoes: independent |
|
|
| effects on the immature and adult stages. Am J Trop Med Hyg 88:497-505. |
|
|
| Aslar, A. K., A. Soran, Y. Yildiz, and Y. Isik. 2001. Epidemiology, morbidity, mortality and treatment of |
| lightning injuries in a Turkish burns units. International Journal of Clinical Practice 55:502-504. |
| Balbus, J., A. Crimmins, J. L. Gamble, D. R. Easterling, K. E. Kunkel, S. Saha, and M. C. Sarofim. 2016. |
| Ch. 1: Introduction: Climate Change and Human Health. Pages 25–42 The Impacts of Climate Change |
| on Human Health in the United States: A Scientific Assessment. U.S. Global Change Research |
| Program, Washington, DC. |
|
|
| Bandyopadhyay, S., S. Kanji, and L. M. Wang. 2012. The impact of rainfall and temperature variation on |
|
|
| diarrheal prevalence in Sub-Saharan Africa. Applied Geography 33:63-72. |
|
|
| Banu, S., W. Hu, C. Hurst, and S. Tong. 2011. Dengue transmission in the Asia-Pacific region: impact of |
|
|
| climate change and socio-environmental factors. Trop Med Int Health 16:598-607. |
|
|
| Basu, R., and J. M. Samet. 2002. Relation between elevated ambient temperature and mortality: A review |
|
|
| of the epidemiologic evidence. Epidemiologic Reviews 24:190-202. |
|
|
| Berko, J., D. D. Ingram, S. Saha, and J. D. Parker. 2014. Deaths attributed to heat, cold, and other weather |
|
|
| events in the United States, 2006-2010. Natl Health Stat Report:1-15. |
|
|
| Booij, M. J. 2005. Impact of climate change on river flooding assessed with different spatial model |
|
|
| resolutions. Journal of Hydrology 303:176-198. |
|
|
| Bouma, M. J., R. S. Kovats, S. A. Goubet, J. S. Cox, and A. Haines. 1997. Global assessment of El Nino's |
|
|
| disaster burden. Lancet 350:1435-1438. |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 4 7 |
|
|
| Carlton, E. J., J. N. S. Eisenberg, J. Goldstick, W. Cevallos, J. Trostle, and K. Levy. 2014. Heavy Rainfall |
| Events and Diarrhea Incidence: The Role of Social and Environmental Factors. American Journal of |
| Epidemiology 179:344-352. |
|
|
| Carrington, L. B., M. V. Armijos, L. Lambrechts, and T. W. Scott. 2013. Fluctuations at a Low Mean |
| Temperature Accelerate Dengue Virus Transmission by Aedes aegypti. Plos Neglected Tropical |
| Diseases 7. |
|
|
| Center for Disease Control, and Prevention. 1994. Heat-related deaths--Philadelphia and United States, |
|
|
| 1993-1994. MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 43:453-455. |
|
|
| Chen, M. J., C. Y. Lin, Y. T. Wu, P. C. Wu, S. C. Lung, and H. J. Su. 2012. Effects of extreme precipitation |
|
|
| to the distribution of infectious diseases in Taiwan, 1994-2008. PLoS One 7:e34651. |
|
|
| Chretien, J. P., A. Anyamba, S. A. Bedno, R. F. Breiman, R. Sang, K. Sergon, A. M. Powers, C. O. Onyango, |
| J. Small, C. J. Tucker, and K. J. Linthicum. 2007. Drought-associated chikungunya emergence along |
| coastal East Africa. Am J Trop Med Hyg 76:405-407. |
|
|
| Christensen, J. H., and O. B. Christensen. 2003. Climate modelling: Severe summertime flooding in Europe. |
|
|
| Nature 421:805-806. |
|
|
| Chung, J. Y., Y. Honda, Y. C. Hong, X. C. Pan, Y. L. Guo, and H. Kim. 2009. Ambient temperature and |
| mortality: an international study in four capital cities of East Asia. Sci Total Environ 408:390-396. |
| Collins, T. W., A. M. Jimenez, and S. E. Grineski. 2013. Hispanic health disparities after a flood disaster: |
| results of a population-based survey of individuals experiencing home site damage in El Paso (Texas, |
| USA). J Immigr Minor Health 15:415-426. |
|
|
| Colwell, R. R., P. R. Epstein, D. Gubler, N. Maynard, A. J. McMichael, J. A. Patz, R. B. Sack, and R. |
|
|
| Shope. 1998. Climate change and human health. Science 279:968-969. |
|
|
| Crimmins, A., J. Balbus, J. L. Gamble, C. B. Beard, J. E. Bell, D. Dodgen, R. J. Eisen, N. Fann, M. D. |
| Hawkins, S. C. Herring, L. Jantarasami, D. M. Mills, S. Saha, M. C. Sarofim, J. Trtanj, and L. Ziska. |
| 2016. Executive Summary. Pages 1–24 The Impacts of Climate Change on Human Health in the United |
| States: A Scientific Assessment. U.S. Global Change Research Program, Washington, DC. |
|
|
| Curriero, F. C., K. S. Heiner, J. M. Samet, S. L. Zeger, L. Strug, and J. A. Patz. 2002. Temperature and |
|
|
| mortality in 11 cities of the eastern United States. Am J Epidemiol 155:80-87. |
|
|
| Curriero, F. C., J. A. Patz, J. B. Rose, and S. Lele. 2001. The association between extreme precipitation and |
| waterborne disease outbreaks in the United States, 1948-1994. American Journal of Public Health |
| 91:1194-1199. |
|
|
| David, D., T. A. Mellman, L. M. Mendoza, R. Kulick-Bell, G. Ironson, and N. Schneiderman. 1996. |
|
|
| Psychiatric morbidity following Hurricane Andrew. J Trauma Stress 9:607-612. |
|
|
| Diez, J. J., M. D. Esteban, R. Paz, J. S. Lopez-Gutierrez, V. Negro, and J. V. Monnot. 2011. Urban Coastal |
|
|
| Flooding and Climate Change. Journal of Coastal Research:205-209. |
|
|
| Douglas, I., K. Alam, M. Maghenda, Y. McDonnell, L. McLean, and J. Campbell. 2008. Unjust waters: |
| climate change, flooding and the urban poor in Africa. Environment and Urbanization 20:187-205. |
| Duclos, P. J., L. M. Sanderson, and K. C. Klontz. 1990. Lightning-related mortality and morbidity in |
|
|
| Florida. Public Health Rep 105:276-282. |
|
|
| Eisenberg, J. N., M. A. Desai, K. Levy, S. J. Bates, S. Liang, K. Naumoff, and J. C. Scott. 2007. |
| Environmental determinants of infectious disease: a framework for tracking causal links and guiding |
| public health research. Environ Health Perspect 115:1216-1223. |
|
|
| Ellis, K. N., L. M. Sylvester, and J. C. Trepanier. 2015. Spatiotemporal patterns of extreme hurricanes |
|
|
| impacting US coastal cities. Natural Hazards 75:2733-2749. |
|
|
| Elsner, James B., James P. Kossin, and Thomas H. Jagger. "The increasing intensity of the strongest tropical |
|
|
| cyclones." Nature 455.7209 (2008): 92. |
|
|
| Erlanger, T. E., S. Weiss, J. Keiser, J. Utzinger, and K. Wiedenmayer. 2009. Past, Present, and Future of |
|
|
| Japanese Encephalitis. Emerging Infectious Diseases 15:1-7. |
|
|
| Fan, J., W. Wei, Z. Bai, C. Fan, S. Li, Q. Liu, and K. Yang. 2014. A systematic review and meta-analysis |
|
|
| of dengue risk with temperature change. Int J Environ Res Public Health 12:1-15. |
|
|
| FDH. 2014a. Surveillance and control of selected mosquito-borne diseases in Florida. Florida Department |
|
|
| of Health, Tallahassee, Florida. |
|
|
| FDH. 2014b. Health effects of precipitation abundance and deficits in Florida. Tallahassee, Florida. |
| FDH. 2015a. Health effects of summer heat in Florida. Florida Department of Health, Tallahassee, Florida. |
| FDH. 2015b. Health effects of tropical storms and hurricanes in Florida. Florida Department of Health, |
|
|
| Tallahassee, Florida. |
|
|
| 1 4 8 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| FDH. 2016. Diseases and Conditions, Florida Department of Health, Tallahassee, Florida. |
| Field, C. B., V. R. Barros, and Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Working Group II. 2014. |
| Climate change 2014: impacts, adaptation, and vulnerability: Working Group II contribution to the fifth |
| assessment report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. Cambridge University Press, |
| New York, NY. |
|
|
| Field, R. D., G. R. van der Werf, and S. S. P. Shen. 2009. Human amplification of drought-induced biomass |
|
|
| burning in Indonesia since 1960. Nature Geoscience 2:185-188. |
|
|
| FOCC. 2010. Climate change and sea-level rise in Florida. An update of the effects of climate change on |
| Florida's ocean & coastal resources. Page 36 in T. F. O. a. C. Council, editor, Tallahassee, Florida |
| Frumkin, H., A. J. McMichael, and J. J. Hess. 2008. Climate change and the health of the public. Am J Prev |
|
|
| Med 35:401-402. |
|
|
| Fullerton, C. S., J. B. A. McKibben, D. B. Reissman, T. Scharf, K. M. Kowalski-Trakofler, J. M. Shultz, |
| and R. J. Ursano. 2013. Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, Depression, and Alcohol and Tobacco Use in |
| Public Health Workers After the 2004 Florida Hurricanes. Disaster Medicine and Public Health |
| Preparedness 7:89-95. |
|
|
| Fullerton, C. S., R. J. Ursano, X. Liu, J. B. McKibben, L. Wang, and D. B. Reissman. 2015. Depressive |
| Symptom Severity and Community Collective Efficacy following the 2004 Florida Hurricanes. PLoS |
| One 10:e0130863. |
|
|
| Galardo, A. K. R., R. H. Zimmerman, L. P. Lounibos, L. J. Young, C. D. Galardo, M. Arruda, and A. A. R. |
| D. Couto. 2009. Seasonal abundance of anopheline mosquitoes and their association with rainfall and |
| malaria along the Matapi River, Amapi, Brazil. Medical and Veterinary Entomology 23:335-349. |
| Gao, H. W., L. P. Wang, S. Liang, Y. X. Liu, S. L. Tong, J. J. Wang, Y. P. Li, X. F. Wang, H. Yang, J. Q. |
| Ma, L. Q. Fang, and W. C. Cao. 2012. Change in rainfall drives malaria re-emergence in Anhui |
| Province, China. PLoS One 7:e43686. |
|
|
| Githeko, A. K., S. W. Lindsay, U. E. Confalonieri, and J. A. Patz. 2000. Climate change and vector-borne |
|
|
| diseases: a regional analysis. Bull World Health Organ 78:1136-1147. |
|
|
| Golladay, S. W., and J. Battle. 2002. Effects of flooding and drought on water quality in gulf coastal plain |
|
|
| streams in Georgia. Journal of Environmental Quality 31:1266-1272. |
|
|
| Gubler, D. J., P. Reiter, K. L. Ebi, W. Yap, R. Nasci, and J. A. Patz. 2001. Climate variability and change |
| in the United States: potential impacts on vector- and rodent-borne diseases. Environ Health Perspect |
| 109 Suppl 2:223-233. |
|
|
| Hashizume, M., B. Armstrong, S. Hajat, Y. Wagatsuma, A. S. Faruque, T. Hayashi, and D. A. Sack. 2008. |
|
|
| The effect of rainfall on the incidence of cholera in Bangladesh. Epidemiology 19:103-110. |
|
|
| Hii, Y. L., H. P. Zhu, N. Ng, L. C. Ng, and J. Rocklov. 2012. Forecast of Dengue Incidence Using |
|
|
| Temperature and Rainfall. Plos Neglected Tropical Diseases 6. |
|
|
| Hoshiko, S., P. English, D. Smith, and R. Trent. 2010. A simple method for estimating excess mortality due |
| to heat waves, as applied to the 2006 California heat wave. International Journal of Public Health |
| 55:133-137. |
|
|
| Huynen, M. M., P. Martens, D. Schram, M. P. Weijenberg, and A. E. Kunst. 2001. The impact of heat |
| waves and cold spells on mortality rates in the Dutch population. Environ Health Perspect 109:463-470. |
| IFRCRCS. 2015. World disasters report: focus on local actors, the key to humanitarian effectiveness |
|
|
| International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies. |
|
|
| Ji, F., Z. H. Wu, J. P. Huang, and E. P. Chassignet. 2014. Evolution of land surface air temperature trend. |
|
|
| Nature Climate Change 4:462-466. |
|
|
| Johansson, M. A., D. A. T. Cummings, and G. E. Glass. 2009. Multiyear Climate Variability and Dengue- |
| El Nino Southern Oscillation, Weather, and Dengue Incidence in Puerto Rico, Mexico, and Thailand: |
| A Longitudinal Data Analysis. Plos Medicine 6. |
|
|
| Johnson, L. R., K.D. Lafferty, A. McNally, E. Mordecai, K. Paaijmans, S. Pawar, S.J. Ryan. 2014. |
| "Mapping the distribution of Malaria: Current Approaches and Future Directions". in Analyzing and |
| Modeling Spatial and Temporal Dynamics of Infectious Diseases. D. Chen, B. Moulin, J. Wu (Eds). |
| John Wiley & Sons. pp 189-209. |
|
|
| Johnson, L.R. Ben-Horin, T., Lafferty, K.D., McNally, A., Mordecai, E., Paaijmans, K.P., Pawar, S., Ryan, |
| S.J. 2015. Understanding uncertainty in temperature effects on vector-borne disease: A Bayesian |
| approach. Ecology 96(1): 203-213. |
|
|
| Kalis, M., and E. Curtiss. 2016. CDC's Drought Guidance: Your Public Health Resource for Understanding |
|
|
| and Preparing for Drought in Your Community. J Environ Health 78:34-35. |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 4 9 |
|
|
| Kalis, M. A., M. D. Miller, and R. J. Wilson. 2009. Public health and drought. J Environ Health 72:10-11. |
| Keatinge, W. R., G. C. Donaldson, K. Bucher, G. Jendritzky, E. Cordioli, M. Martinelli, K. Katsouyanni, |
| A. E. Kunst, C. McDonald, S. Nayha, I. Vuori, and G. Eurowinter. 2000a. Winter mortality in relation |
| to climate. Int J Circumpolar Health 59:154-159. |
|
|
| Keatinge, W. R., G. C. Donaldson, E. Cordioli, M. Martinelli, A. E. Kunst, J. P. Mackenbach, S. Nayha, |
| and I. Vuori. 2000b. Heat related mortality in warm and cold regions of Europe: observational study. |
| BMJ 321:670-673. |
|
|
| Kirshen, P., C. Watson, E. Douglas, A. Gontz, J. Lee, and Y. Tian. 2008. Coastal flooding in the |
| Northeastern United States due to climate change. Mitigation and Adaptation Strategies for Global |
| Change 13:437-451. |
|
|
| Kistemann, T., T. Classen, C. Koch, F. Dangendorf, R. Fischeder, J. Gebel, V. Vacata, and M. Exner. 2002. |
| Microbial load of drinking water reservoir tributaries during extreme rainfall and runoff. Appl Environ |
| Microbiol 68:2188-2197. |
|
|
| Klinger, C., O. Landeg, and V. Murray. 2014. Power outages, extreme events and health: a systematic |
|
|
| review of the literature from 2011-2012. PLoS Curr 6. |
|
|
| Knight, D. B., and R. E. Davis. 2009. Contribution of tropical cyclones to extreme rainfall events in the |
|
|
| southeastern United States. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 114. |
|
|
| Knowlton, K., M. Rotkin-Ellman, G. King, H. G. Margolis, D. Smith, G. Solomon, R. Trent, and P. English. |
| 2009. The 2006 California heat wave: impacts on hospitalizations and emergency department visits. |
| Environ Health Perspect 117:61-67. |
|
|
| Knutson, T. R., J. J. Sirutis, G. A. Vecchi, S. Garner, M. Zhao, H. S. Kim, M. Bender, R. E. Tuleya, I. M. |
| Held, and G. Villarini. 2013. Dynamical Downscaling Projections of Twenty-First-Century Atlantic |
| Hurricane Activity: CMIP3 and CMIP5 Model-Based Scenarios. Journal of Climate 26:6591-6617. |
| Kochtubajda, B., M. D. Flannigan, J. R. Gyakum, R. E. Stewart, K. A. Logan, and T. V. Nguyen. 2006. |
| Lightning and fires in the Northwest Territories and responses to future climate change. Arctic 59:211- |
| 221. |
|
|
| Kovats, R. S. 2000. El Nino and human health. Bull World Health Organ 78:1127-1135. |
| Kovats, R. S., M. J. Bouma, S. Hajat, E. Worrall, and A. Haines. 2003. El Nino and health. Lancet 362:1481- |
|
|
| 1489. |
|
|
| Kovats, R. S., and S. Hajat. 2008. Heat stress and public health: a critical review. Annu Rev Public Health |
|
|
| 29:41-55. |
|
|
| Kovats, R. S., S. Hajat, and P. Wilkinson. 2004. Contrasting patterns of mortality and hospital admissions |
|
|
| during hot weather and heat waves in Greater London, UK. Occup Environ Med 61:893-898. |
|
|
| La Greca, A. M., B. S. Lai, M. M. Llabre, W. K. Silverman, E. M. Vernberg, and M. J. Prinstein. 2013. |
| Children's Postdisaster Trajectories of PTS Symptoms: Predicting Chronic Distress. Child Youth Care |
| Forum 42:351-369. |
|
|
| La Greca, A. M., W. K. Silverman, B. Lai, and J. Jaccard. 2010. Hurricane-Related Exposure Experiences |
| and Stressors, Other Life Events, and Social Support: Concurrent and Prospective Impact on Children's |
| Persistent Posttraumatic Stress Symptoms. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology 78:794-805. |
| Laursen, E., O. Mygind, B. Rasmussen, and T. Ronne. 1994. Gastroenteritis: a waterborne outbreak |
|
|
| affecting 1600 people in a small Danish town. J Epidemiol Community Health 48:453-458. |
|
|
| Li, C. F., T. W. Lim, L. L. Han, and R. Fang. 1985. Rainfall, abundance of Aedes aegypti and dengue |
|
|
| infection in Selangor, Malaysia. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 16:560-568. |
|
|
| Liang, S., E. Y. Seto, J. V. Remais, B. Zhong, C. Yang, A. Hubbard, G. M. Davis, X. Gu, D. Qiu, and R. |
| C. Spear. 2007. Environmental effects on parasitic disease transmission exemplified by schistosomiasis |
| in western China. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 104:7110-7115. |
|
|
| Lin, S., W. H. Hsu, A. R. Van Zutphen, S. Saha, G. Luber, and S. A. Hwang. 2012. Excessive heat and |
| respiratory hospitalizations in New York State: estimating current and future public health burden |
| related to climate change. Environ Health Perspect 120:1571-1577. |
|
|
| Lindblade, K. A., E. D. Walker, A. W. Onapa, J. Katungu, and M. L. Wilson. 2000. Land use change alters |
| malaria transmission parameters by modifying temperature in a highland area of Uganda. Tropical |
| Medicine & International Health 5:263-274. |
|
|
| Lipp, E. K., A. Huq, and R. R. Colwell. 2002. Effects of global climate on infectious disease: the cholera |
|
|
| model. Clin Microbiol Rev 15:757-770. |
|
|
| Loevinsohn, M. E. 1994. Climatic warming and increased malaria incidence in Rwanda. Lancet 343:714- |
|
|
| 718. |
|
|
| 1 5 0 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| Luque Fernandez, M. A., A. Bauernfeind, J. D. Jimenez, C. L. Gil, N. El Omeiri, and D. H. Guibert. 2009. |
| Influence of temperature and rainfall on the evolution of cholera epidemics in Lusaka, Zambia, 2003- |
| 2006: analysis of a time series. Trans R Soc Trop Med Hyg 103:137-143. |
|
|
| Lyle, T. S., and T. Mills. 2016. Assessing coastal flood risk in a changing climate for the City of Vancouver. |
|
|
| Canadian Water Resources Journal 41:343-352. |
|
|
| Malmstadt, J., K. Scheltin, and J. Elsner. 2009. Florida hurricanes and damage costs. Southeastern |
|
|
| Geographer 49:108-131. |
|
|
| Martinez, C. J., J. J. Maleski, and M. F. Miller. 2012. Trends in precipitation and temperature in Florida, |
|
|
| USA. Journal of Hydrology 452:259-281. |
|
|
| McMichael, A. J., and A. Haines. 1997. Global climate change: the potential effects on health. BMJ |
|
|
| 315:805-809. |
|
|
| Medina-Ramon, M., A. Zanobetti, D. P. Cavanagh, and J. Schwartz. 2006. Extreme temperatures and |
| mortality: assessing effect modification by personal characteristics and specific cause of death in a |
| multi-city case-only analysis. Environ Health Perspect 114:1331-1336. |
|
|
| Medlock, J. M., and S. A. Leach. 2015. Effect of climate change on vector-borne disease risk in the UK. |
|
|
| Lancet Infect Dis 15:721-730. |
|
|
| Mhalu, F. S., W. M. Mntenga, and F. D. Mtango. 1987. Seasonality of cholera in Tanzania: possible role of |
|
|
| rainfall in disease transmission. East Afr Med J 64:378-387. |
|
|
| Miettinen, I. T., O. Zacheus, C. H. von Bonsdorff, and T. Vartiainen. 2001. Waterborne epidemics in |
|
|
| Finland in 1998-1999. Water Sci Technol 43:67-71. |
| Miranda, J. J. 2004. El Nino and health. Lancet 363:247-248. |
| Mordecai, E.A., Cohen, J., Evans, M.V., Gudapati, P., Johnson, L.R., Lippi, C.A., Miazgowicz, K., |
| Murdock, C.C., Rohr, J.R., Ryan, S.J., Savage, V., Shocket, M., Stewart Ibarra, A.M., Thomas, M.B., |
| Weikel, D.P. 2017. Detecting the impact of temperature on transmission of Zika, dengue, and |
| chikungunya using mechanistic models. PLOS NTDs. 11(4): e0005568 |
|
|
| Mordecai, E.A., Paaijmans, K.P., Johnson, L.R., Balzer, C.H., Ben-Horin, T., deMoor, E., McNally, A., |
| Pawar, S., Ryan, S.J., Smith, T.C., Lafferty, K.D., 2013. Physiological constraints dramatically lower |
| the expected temperature for peak malaria transmission. Ecology Letters 16(1):22-30 |
|
|
| Neria, Y., and J. M. Shultz. 2012. Mental health effects of Hurricane Sandy: characteristics, potential |
|
|
| aftermath, and response. JAMA 308:2571-2572. |
|
|
| Ngwa, M. C., S. Liang, I. T. Kracalik, L. Morris, J. K. Blackburn, L. M. Mbam, S. F. Ba Pouth, A. Teboh, |
| Y. Yang, M. Arabi, J. D. Sugimoto, and J. G. Morris, Jr. 2016. Cholera in Cameroon, 2000-2012: Spatial |
| and Temporal Analysis at the Operational (Health District) and Sub Climate Levels. PLoS Negl Trop |
| Dis 10:e0005105. |
|
|
| Nichols, G., C. Lane, N. Asgari, N. Q. Verlander, and A. Charlett. 2009. Rainfall and outbreaks of drinking |
|
|
| water related disease and in England and Wales. J Water Health 7:1-8. |
|
|
| Ogden, N. H., A. Maarouf, I. K. Barker, M. Bigras-Poulin, L. R. Lindsay, M. G. Morshed, C. J. O'Callaghan, |
| F. Ramay, D. Waltner-Toews, and D. F. Charron. 2006. Climate change and the potential for range |
| expansion of the Lyme disease vector Ixodes scapularis in Canada. International Journal for |
| Parasitology 36:63-70. |
|
|
| Ostfeld, R. S., C. D. Canham, K. Oggenfuss, R. J. Winchcombe, and F. Keesing. 2006. Climate, deer, |
| rodents, and acorns as determinants of variation in Lyme-disease risk. Plos Biology 4:1058-1068. |
| Paaijmans, K. P., S. Blanford, A. S. Bell, J. I. Blanford, A. F. Read, and M. B. Thomas. 2010. Influence of |
| climate on malaria transmission depends on daily temperature variation. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A |
| 107:15135-15139. |
|
|
| Polymenakou, P. N., M. Mandalakis, E. G. Stephanou, and A. Tselepides. 2008. Particle size distribution |
| of airborne microorganisms and pathogens during an Intense African dust event in the eastern |
| Mediterranean. Environ Health Perspect 116:292-296. |
|
|
| Price, C., and D. Rind. 1994. Possible Implications of Global Climate-Change on Global Lightning |
|
|
| Distributions and Frequencies. Journal of Geophysical Research-Atmospheres 99:10823-10831. |
|
|
| Pruss-Ustun, A., J. Bartram, T. Clasen, J. M. Colford, O. Cumming, V. Curtis, S. Bonjour, A. D. Dangour, |
| J. De France, L. Fewtrell, M. C. Freeman, B. Gordon, P. R. Hunter, R. B. Johnston, C. Mathers, D. |
| Mausezahl, K. Medlicott, M. Neira, M. Stocks, J. Wolf, and S. Cairncross. 2014. Burden of disease |
| from inadequate water, sanitation and hygiene in low- and middle-income settings: a retrospective |
| analysis of data from 145 countries. Tropical Medicine & International Health 19:894-905. |
|
|
| C L I M A T E C H A N G E I M P A C T S O N H U M A N H E A L T H • 1 5 1 |
|
|
| Pruss, A., D. Kay, L. Fewtrell, and J. Bartram. 2002. Estimating the burden of disease from water, sanitation, |
|
|
| and hygiene at a global level. Environmental Health Perspectives 110:537-542. |
|
|
| Qian, Z. M., Q. C. He, H. M. Lin, L. L. Kong, C. M. Bentley, W. S. Liu, and D. J. Zhou. 2008. High |
| temperatures enhanced acute mortality effects of ambient particle pollution in the "Oven" city of |
| Wuhan, China. Environmental Health Perspectives 116:1172-1178. |
|
|
| Ragan, P., J. Schulte, S. J. Nelson, and K. T. Jones. 2008. Mortality surveillance: 2004 to 2005 Florida |
|
|
| hurricane-related deaths. Am J Forensic Med Pathol 29:148-153. |
|
|
| Reeve, N., and R. Toumi. 1999. Lightning activity as an indicator of climate change. Quarterly Journal of |
|
|
| the Royal Meteorological Society 125:893-903. |
|
|
| Ritenour, A. E., M. J. Morton, J. G. McManus, D. J. Barillo, and L. C. Cancio. 2008. Lightning injury: a |
|
|
| review. Burns 34:585-594. |
|
|
| Ryan, S.J., McNally, A., Johnson, L.R., Mordecai, E.A., Ben-Horin, T., Paaijmans, K.P., Lafferty, K.D. |
| 2015. Mapping physiological suitability limits of malaria in Africa under climate change. Journal of |
| vector borne and zoonotic diseases 15(12): 817-725. |
|
|
| Ryan, S.J., Ben-Horin, T., Johnson, L.R. 2015. Malaria control and senescence: the importance of |
|
|
| accounting for the pace and shape of ageing in wild mosquitoes. Ecosphere 6(9):170. |
|
|
| Ryan, S.J. et al. 2017. Climate change drives uncertain global shifts in potential distribution and seasonal |
|
|
| risk of Aedes-transmitted viruses. BioRXiv doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/172221. |
|
|
| Sarofim, M. C., S. Saha, M. D. Hawkins, D. M. Mills, J. Hess, R. Horton, P. Kinney, J. Schwartz, and A. |
| St. Juliana. 2016. Ch. 2: Temperature-Related Death and Illness. Pages 43-68 The Impacts of Climate |
| Change on Human Health in the United States: A |
|
|
| Scientific Assessment. U.S. Global Change Research Program, Washington, DC. |
| Schijven, J. F., and A. M. de Roda Husman. 2005. Effect of climate changes on waterborne disease in The |
|
|
| Netherlands. Water Sci Technol 51:79-87. |
|
|
| Schreider, S. Y., D. I. Smith, and A. J. Jakeman. 2000. Climate change impacts on urban flooding. Climatic |
|
|
| Change 47:91-115. |
|
|
| Schuster, C. J., A. G. Ellis, W. J. Robertson, D. F. Charron, J. J. Aramini, B. J. Marshall, and D. T. Medeiros. |
| 2005. Infectious disease outbreaks related to drinking water in Canada, 1974-2001. Can J Public Health |
| 96:254-258. |
|
|
| Senhorst, H. A., and J. J. Zwolsman. 2005. Climate change and effects on water quality: a first impression. |
|
|
| Water Sci Technol 51:53-59. |
|
|
| Shaman, J., J. F. Day, and M. Stieglitz. 2005. Drought-induced amplification and epidemic transmission of |
|
|
| West Nile virus in southern Florida. J Med Entomol 42:134-141. |
|
|
| Singh, R. B., S. Hales, N. de Wet, R. Raj, M. Hearnden, and P. Weinstein. 2001. The influence of climate |
| variation and change on diarrheal disease in the Pacific Islands. Environ Health Perspect 109:155-159. |
| Soverow, J. E., G. A. Wellenius, D. N. Fisman, and M. A. Mittleman. 2009. Infectious Disease in a |
| Warming World: How Weather Influenced West Nile Virus in the United States (2001-2005). |
| Environmental Health Perspectives 117:1049-1052. |
|
|
| Su, G. L. S. 2008. Correlation of climatic factors and dengue incidence in Metro Manila, Philippines. Ambio |
|
|
| 37:292-294. |
|
|
| Sullivent, E. E., 3rd, C. A. West, R. S. Noe, K. E. Thomas, L. J. Wallace, and R. T. Leeb. 2006. Nonfatal |
|
|
| injuries following Hurricane Katrina--New Orleans, Louisiana, 2005. J Safety Res 37:213-217. |
|
|
| Taylor, G., and W. J. Davies. 1990. Root-Growth of Fagus-Sylvatica - Impact of Air-Quality and Drought |
|
|
| at a Site in Southern Britain. New Phytologist 116:457-464. |
|
|
| Thomas, K. M., D. F. Charron, D. Waltner-Toews, C. Schuster, A. R. Maarouf, and J. D. Holt. 2006. A role |
| of high impact weather events in waterborne disease outbreaks in Canada, 1975 - 2001. Int J Environ |
| Health Res 16:167-180. |
|
|
| Thompson, K. R., N. B. Bernier, and P. Chan. 2009. Extreme sea levels, coastal flooding and climate change |
|
|
| with a focus on Atlantic Canada. Natural Hazards 51:139-150. |
|
|
| Thomson, M. C., S. J. Mason, T. Phindela, and S. J. Connor. 2005. Use of rainfall and sea surface |
| temperature monitoring for malaria early warning in Botswana. American Journal of Tropical Medicine |
| and Hygiene 73:214-221. |
|
|
| Tian, L., Y. Bi, S. C. Ho, W. Liu, S. Liang, W. B. Goggins, E. Y. Chan, S. Zhou, and J. J. Sung. 2008. One- |
| year delayed effect of fog on malaria transmission: a time-series analysis in the rain forest area of |
| Mengla County, south-west China. Malar J 7:110. |
|
|
| USEPA. 2016. Climate change indicators in the United States. Page 96 in U. S. E. P. Agency, editor. |
|
|
| 1 5 2 • S O N G L I A N G E T A L . |
|
|
| van der Hoek, W., F. Konradsen, D. Perera, P. H. Amerasinghe, and F. P. Amerasinghe. 1997. Correlation |
| between rainfall and malaria in the dry zone of Sri Lanka. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Parasitology |
| 91:945-949. |
|
|
| Vernberg, E. M., A. M. LaGreca, W. K. Silverman, and M. J. Prinstein. 1996. Prediction of posttraumatic |
| stress symptoms in children after Hurricane Andrew. Journal of Abnormal Psychology 105:237-248. |
| Wardrop, N. A., A. G. Barnett, J. A. Atkinson, and A. C. A. Clements. 2013. Plasmodium vivax malaria |
| incidence over time and its association with temperature and rainfall in four counties of Yunnan |
| Province, China. Malaria Journal 12. |
|
|
| Weems, C. F., L. K. Taylor, M. F. Cannon, R. C. Marino, D. M. Romano, B. G. Scott, A. M. Perry, and V. |
| Triplett. 2010. Post Traumatic Stress, Context, and the Lingering Effects of the Hurricane Katrina |
| Disaster among Ethnic Minority Youth. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 38:49-56. |
|
|
| WHO. 2008. Global Burden of Disease 2004 update. World Health Organization. |
| Winsberg, M. D. 2003. Florida weather. 2nd edition. University Press of Florida, Gainesville, Fla. |
| Yang, K., J. LeJeune, D. Alsdorf, B. Lu, C. K. Shum, and S. Liang. 2012. Global distribution of outbreaks |
|
|
| of water-associated infectious diseases. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 6:e1483. |
|
|
|
|