instruction stringclasses 1
value | input stringlengths 44 1.01k | output stringlengths 918 1.62k |
|---|---|---|
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Payment shall be made in a timely manner following delivery of services.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 8, "completeness": 6, "risk_balance": 15, "enforceability": 7}, "total": 36, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Timely manner' is undefined and subjective. No specific number of days is stated, creating ambiguity that could lead to disputes.", "completeness": "Missing: payment amount, cu... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Either party may terminate this Agreement upon thirty (30) days written notice to the other party. In the event of a material breach, the non-breaching party may terminate immediately upon written notice, provided such notice specifies the nature of the breach. The breaching party shall have ten (10) days to c... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Termination triggers, notice periods, and cure rights are clearly defined. 'Material breach' could benefit from examples but is a recognized legal standard.", "completeness":... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor shall indemnify, defend, and hold harmless Client, its officers, directors, employees, and agents from and against any and all claims, damages, losses, costs, and expenses (including reasonable attorneys' fees) arising out of or relating to Vendor's performance under this Agreement, regardless of the ne... | {"scores": {"clarity": 20, "completeness": 18, "risk_balance": 7, "enforceability": 16}, "total": 61, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Scope of covered parties and loss types is clear. 'Arising out of or relating to' is broad but standard.", "completeness": "Missing: indemnification caps, insurance requiremen... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'All intellectual property, inventions, discoveries, improvements, works of authorship, and other creative works conceived, developed, or reduced to practice by Service Provider in connection with services performed under this Agreement shall be the sole and exclusive property of Client. Service Provider hereby... | {"scores": {"clarity": 21, "completeness": 17, "risk_balance": 9, "enforceability": 19}, "total": 66, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Assignment language is explicit and comprehensive in scope. 'In connection with services performed' is the key limiting phrase, though its boundaries may be disputed.", "compl... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of Delaware, without regard to its conflict of law provisions. Any dispute arising out of or relating to this Agreement shall be submitted to binding arbitration administered by the American Arbitration Association under... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 93, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Every element — governing law, forum, administrator, rules, location, and fee-shifting — is explicitly stated. No ambiguity in dispute resolution pathway.", "completenes... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Contractor will do their best to complete the project on time and will try to meet the client's requirements as much as possible.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 5, "completeness": 3, "risk_balance": 4, "enforceability": 3}, "total": 15, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Do their best' and 'as much as possible' are non-committal phrases with no legal meaning. No timeline, deliverable definition, or acceptance criteria provided.", "comple... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party agrees to hold in strict confidence and not to disclose to any third party any Confidential Information received from the other party. "Confidential Information" means any non-public information designated as confidential or that reasonably should be understood to be confidential given the nature of... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 90, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Definition of Confidential Information uses both objective designation and reasonable expectation standards, which is a well-accepted dual approach. Exceptions are enume... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE TO THE OTHER FOR ANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES, INCLUDING LOST PROFITS, LOSS OF DATA, OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION, ARISING OUT OF OR RELATED TO THIS AGREEMENT, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES. EACH PARTY'S TOTAL C... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 19, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 20}, "total": 81, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Exclusions are explicitly enumerated in standard legal categories. Cap is defined by a clear formula. All-caps formatting satisfies conspicuousness requirements in most juris... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Neither party shall be liable for any failure or delay in performance under this Agreement to the extent such failure or delay is caused by circumstances beyond such party's reasonable control, including but not limited to acts of God, natural disasters, war, terrorism, civil unrest, government actions, epidem... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Triggering events are enumerated with a non-exhaustive list. Obligations on the affected party are stated with concrete timelines. Termination right is clearly scoped.",... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED "AS IS" WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. COMPANY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 10, "risk_balance": 6, "enforceability": 13}, "total": 43, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "The disclaimer is stated broadly but omits enumeration of specific implied warranties being disclaimed (merchantability, fitness for purpose, non-infringement), which are requ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee agrees that during the term of employment and for a period of two (2) years following the termination of employment for any reason, Employee shall not, directly or indirectly, within the United States, engage in, be employed by, consult for, or have any financial interest in any business that competes... | {"scores": {"clarity": 19, "completeness": 16, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 11}, "total": 54, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "The restricted activity, duration, and geography are stated. 'Enterprise resource planning software' is defined by industry term but may need further scoping. 'Financial inter... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Service Provider shall meet the following Service Level Agreements (SLAs): (i) System Availability: 99.9% uptime measured monthly, excluding scheduled maintenance windows of no more than four (4) hours per month notified at least 48 hours in advance; (ii) Incident Response: Priority 1 incidents responded to wi... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 18, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "SLA metrics are quantified with precise thresholds, measurement periods, and escalation tiers. Credit formula is mathematically unambiguous. Excellent precision.", "completen... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement shall automatically renew for successive one-year terms unless either party provides notice of non-renewal. Notice should be sent to the other party if they don't want to renew.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 9, "completeness": 7, "risk_balance": 10, "enforceability": 10}, "total": 36, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Auto-renewal is stated but the notice period required to prevent renewal is completely absent. 'Should be sent' is precatory rather than mandatory language.", "completeness": "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The Processor shall process Personal Data only on documented instructions from the Controller. The Processor shall ensure that persons authorized to process Personal Data have committed themselves to confidentiality or are under an appropriate statutory obligation of confidentiality. The Processor shall implem... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 90, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "GDPR Article 28 obligations are precisely tracked. Technical and organizational measures are enumerated with concrete examples. The 72-hour breach notification window ma... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company may change these terms at any time. Continued use of the service after changes are posted constitutes acceptance.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 12, "completeness": 8, "risk_balance": 4, "enforceability": 9}, "total": 33, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "The mechanism for 'posting' changes is undefined — no URL, notification method, or effective date framework is provided. 'At any time' grants unlimited unilateral modification r... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'During the term of this Agreement and for a period of twelve (12) months following its expiration or termination, neither party shall, directly or indirectly, solicit for employment or hire any employee of the other party who was involved in the performance of this Agreement, without the prior written consent ... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 86, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Restriction, duration, and carve-outs are clearly stated. 'Involved in the performance' is the key limiting phrase — sufficiently specific to exclude unrelated employees.", "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party represents and warrants that: (a) it has full power and authority to enter into and perform this Agreement; (b) the execution, delivery, and performance of this Agreement have been duly authorized by all necessary corporate action; (c) this Agreement constitutes a legal, valid, and binding obligatio... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Each representation is a discrete, unambiguous statement. Legal qualification ('subject to applicable bankruptcy') is appropriately scoped. Clean parallel structure.", "compl... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Either party may assign this Agreement or any of its rights or obligations hereunder to any affiliate or in connection with a merger, acquisition, or sale of all or substantially all of its assets, without the other party's consent. Any other assignment shall require the prior written consent of the non-assign... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 19, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 82, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Permitted assignment triggers (affiliate, M&A) and consent standard ('not unreasonably withheld') are clearly defined. Invalidity consequence is explicit.", "completeness": "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The parties agree to try to resolve any disputes through good faith negotiation before resorting to legal action. If they cannot agree, they can go to court.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 10, "completeness": 6, "risk_balance": 14, "enforceability": 8}, "total": 38, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Try to resolve' and 'good faith negotiation' are undefined. No timeframe, escalation procedure, or definition of 'cannot agree' is provided. 'Go to court' omits jurisdiction, ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'If Contractor fails to achieve Substantial Completion by the Contract Completion Date, Contractor shall pay to Owner five thousand dollars ($5,000) per calendar day as liquidated damages, not as a penalty but as a genuine pre-estimate of loss. Liquidated damages shall be Owner's sole remedy for delay, provided... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 85, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Daily rate, trigger event, and anti-penalty characterization are explicit. 'Substantial Completion' should be defined elsewhere.", "completeness": "Covers daily rate, pre-est... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company will reimburse Employee for reasonable business expenses incurred in the performance of duties.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 10, "completeness": 8, "risk_balance": 13, "enforceability": 9}, "total": 40, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Reasonable' is undefined and entirely subjective. No categories, limits, or pre-approval requirements are specified.", "completeness": "Missing: expense categories, per-item l... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor shall deposit the Source Code into escrow with Iron Mountain within thirty (30) days of the Effective Date and shall update the deposit within thirty (30) days of each new release. Release shall occur upon: (a) Vendor's insolvency or cessation of business; (b) Vendor's material breach of maintenance obl... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Escrow agent, deposit timeline, update frequency, release triggers, and license scope are all explicitly defined.", "completeness": "Covers escrow agent, initial and update o... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement, together with all Exhibits and Schedules, constitutes the entire agreement between the parties and supersedes all prior agreements, representations, and understandings relating to the subject matter. No modification shall be effective unless in writing and signed by authorized representatives o... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 95, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Integration clause, amendment requirement, and non-waiver are each clearly and separately stated. 'Authorized representatives' and 'in writing' are precise standards.", ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'All notices shall be in writing and deemed duly given: (a) when delivered personally; (b) one (1) business day after deposit with a nationally recognized overnight courier; or (c) three (3) business days after certified mail with return receipt. Notices shall be addressed to the addresses on the signature page... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Deemed delivery timelines and permitted methods are precise. Address update mechanism is clear.", "completeness": "Covers personal delivery, overnight courier, and certified ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party represents that: (a) it has full authority to enter into this Agreement; (b) execution has been duly authorized; (c) this Agreement is a legal, valid, and binding obligation subject to applicable bankruptcy and equitable principles; and (d) performance does not violate any applicable law or material... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Each representation is a discrete, unambiguous statement. Legal qualification for bankruptcy is appropriately scoped.", "completeness": "Covers authority, authorization, vali... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND. COMPANY DISCLAIMS ALL WARRANTIES, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 10, "risk_balance": 6, "enforceability": 13}, "total": 43, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "The disclaimer is stated broadly but omits enumeration of specific implied warranties being disclaimed. Named warranties are required by statute in some jurisdictions.", "comp... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee agrees that during employment and for two (2) years following termination for any reason, Employee shall not engage in, be employed by, or have any financial interest in any business that competes with Company in the development or sale of enterprise resource planning software within the United States... | {"scores": {"clarity": 19, "completeness": 16, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 11}, "total": 54, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Restricted activity, duration, and geography are stated. 'Financial interest' is overbroad without a de minimis carve-out for passive stock ownership.", "completeness": "Missi... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Processor shall retain Personal Data only as long as necessary to fulfill the purposes for which it was collected. Upon termination or Controller's request, Processor shall, at Controller's election: (a) return all Personal Data in machine-readable format within thirty (30) days; or (b) securely delete all Per... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Retention trigger, deletion and return options, timelines, backup carve-out, and audit log obligation are each precisely stated.", "completeness": "Covers purpose limitation,... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor represents that the Software does not contain open source software that would require disclosure or distribution of Vendor's proprietary source code.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 16, "completeness": 13, "risk_balance": 14, "enforceability": 14}, "total": 57, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Require disclosure or distribution' captures copyleft licenses (GPL, AGPL) but does not address permissive license obligations such as attribution or patent grants.", "compl... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Any change to the scope of services shall be documented in a written Change Order signed by both parties prior to commencement of changed work. Each Change Order shall specify: (a) description of the change; (b) fee impact; (c) schedule impact; and (d) any effect on other obligations. Vendor shall provide a wr... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Change Order requirements, four required elements, estimate timeline, and unauthorized-work consequence are clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers written requirement, au... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer shall have fifteen (15) business days to test each Deliverable against the Acceptance Criteria in the Statement of Work. Customer shall either provide written acceptance or deliver a written rejection notice specifying each non-conformance. Vendor shall correct documented non-conformances within ten (... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Acceptance period, required rejection content, correction timeline, re-review period, and deemed acceptance trigger are all precisely defined.", "completeness": "Covers initi... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Upon termination without cause, Employee shall receive severance equal to two (2) weeks of base salary per year of service, up to twenty-six (26) weeks, provided Employee signs a separation agreement and release in a form acceptable to Company.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 18, "completeness": 17, "risk_balance": 15, "enforceability": 17}, "total": 67, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Severance formula and cap are clear. 'Acceptable to Company' gives Company unilateral control over the release form.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'cause,' benefi... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company may require Employee to serve all or part of the notice period as Garden Leave. During Garden Leave: (a) Employee remains employed and receives full base salary and contractual benefits; (b) Employee is not required to attend the workplace; (c) Employee remains bound by good faith, confidentiality, and... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 86, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Company election right, Employee status, obligations, and restriction credit are clearly stated. 'Contractual benefits' should be enumerated for complete clarity.", "complete... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Sales Representative will earn commissions on sales made during the term. Commission rates will be determined by the Company from time to time.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 5, "completeness": 3, "risk_balance": 3, "enforceability": 4}, "total": 15, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'From time to time' provides no guidance on rates, timing, or how changes are communicated. 'Sales made' is undefined.", "completeness": "Missing virtually everything: co... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Subject to Board approval, Employee shall be granted options to purchase 50,000 shares at fair market value on the grant date. Options vest over four years with a one-year cliff. Vested options expire ten years from the grant date.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 17, "completeness": 15, "risk_balance": 16, "enforceability": 15}, "total": 63, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Share count, vesting schedule, cliff, and expiration are stated. Monthly vs. quarterly vesting cadence is not specified.", "completeness": "Missing: vesting cadence detail, p... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company may use Customer's name and logo in its marketing materials, website, and press releases to identify Customer as a customer.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 15, "completeness": 12, "risk_balance": 10, "enforceability": 14}, "total": 51, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Permitted uses are listed but 'marketing materials' is broad. No geographic, temporal, or format limitations are stated.", "completeness": "Missing: Customer approval right, ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer may conduct performance benchmarking tests on the Software solely for internal evaluation, provided that: (a) Customer provides thirty (30) days prior written notice; (b) benchmarking is in a non-production environment; (c) the methodology is industry-standard and disclosed to Vendor; and (d) Customer... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 19, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 84, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Permitted scope, notice period, environment requirement, methodology standard, and publication restriction are all clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers purpose limitati... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor represents that fees charged to Customer are no higher than those charged to similarly situated customers for similar services. If Vendor offers lower pricing to any other customer for comparable services, Vendor shall promptly notify Customer and apply equivalent pricing.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 13, "risk_balance": 16, "enforceability": 12}, "total": 55, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Similarly situated' and 'comparable services' are undefined and highly fact-specific. 'Promptly' lacks a defined timeframe.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'simila... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer agrees to purchase all of its requirements for the relevant products exclusively from Vendor during the term.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 13, "completeness": 9, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 11}, "total": 41, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'All of its requirements' and 'relevant products' are undefined. No minimum purchase commitment is stated.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'relevant products,' minimu... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee agrees not to make disparaging statements about the Company, its officers, employees, products, or services, whether orally or in writing, including on social media, following termination. This restriction applies indefinitely.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 17, "completeness": 15, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 12}, "total": 52, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Prohibited conduct types and channels are enumerated. 'Disparaging' is broader than legally actionable defamation and may sweep in protected speech.", "completeness": "Missing... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee consents to background checks.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 6, "completeness": 3, "risk_balance": 7, "enforceability": 4}, "total": 20, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "No specification of what types of checks are included, which third party will conduct them, or what information will be obtained.", "completeness": "Missing virtually all... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Neither party may assign this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other party, except that either party may: (a) assign to an Affiliate (defined as an entity that controls, is controlled by, or is under common control with the assigning party, where 'control' means ownership of more than fifty p... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 94, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Affiliate,' 'control,' and competitor limitations are explicitly defined. Assignment trigger, exceptions, notice obligation, and void consequence are all clear.", "comp... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor warrants that: (a) Vendor has full authority to grant the licenses in this Agreement; (b) the Software does not infringe any third-party intellectual property right; and (c) to Vendor's knowledge, no claims are pending that would materially affect Customer's use. In the event of breach, Vendor shall: (i... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 85, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Three warranty components and three remedial options are clearly enumerated. 'To Vendor's knowledge' appropriately limits the litigation warranty.", "completeness": "Covers t... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Processor shall not engage any Sub-processor without the prior specific or general written authorization of Controller. Where general authorization is used, Processor shall inform Controller of any intended changes at least thirty (30) days in advance, giving Controller the opportunity to object. Processor sha... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 92, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Authorization options, advance notice period, objection right, equivalent obligations requirement, liability retention, and Annex reference are all clearly articulated."... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'If the holders of a majority of shares approve a sale of the Company, all other shareholders shall be required to vote in favor and to sell their shares on the same terms as the majority shareholders.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 13, "completeness": 10, "risk_balance": 12, "enforceability": 15}, "total": 50, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Decides to sell shares' is ambiguous. 'Same terms' requires definition for non-cash consideration scenarios.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'sale of Company,' min... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Subscriptions automatically renew each year. Pricing may change at renewal. We will notify you of price changes.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 9, "completeness": 7, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 9}, "total": 33, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'May change' provides no limit on extent of price changes. 'Will notify you' specifies no timing, channel, or advance notice period.", "completeness": "Missing: cancellation noti... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'EXCEPT AS SET FORTH IN THIS SECTION, IN NO EVENT SHALL EITHER PARTY BE LIABLE FOR INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES. EACH PARTY'S TOTAL LIABILITY SHALL NOT EXCEED THE FEES PAID IN THE TWELVE (12) MONTHS PRECEDING THE CLAIM. THESE LIMITATIONS DO NOT APPLY TO: (I) INDEMNIFICATION OBLIGATION... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 94, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Six carve-outs are enumerated individually. Payment obligation exclusion is stated separately. All-caps formatting ensures conspicuousness.", "completeness": "Covers con... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Nothing in this Agreement shall prevent either party or their employees from reporting potential violations of law to any governmental or regulatory authority, including the SEC or DOJ, or from cooperating with any investigation. No party shall retaliate against any employee for making such a report in good fa... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Reporting right, non-retaliation obligation, and voiding of conflicting provisions are each clearly stated. Named agencies provide concrete examples.", "completeness": "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer shall pay all undisputed invoices within thirty (30) days of invoice date. Invoices shall be submitted to accounts.payable@customer.com. Past due undisputed amounts shall accrue interest at 1.5% per month or the maximum permitted by law, whichever is lower. If Customer disputes any invoice portion, Cu... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Payment period, submission channel, interest rate, dispute procedure, and suspension trigger are all precisely defined. 'Undisputed' is used consistently throughout.", "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee's employment is at-will, meaning either Employee or Company may terminate the employment relationship at any time, with or without cause, and with or without notice, subject to any notice requirements in this Agreement. Nothing in this Agreement or any Company policy, handbook, or other document shall... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 18, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 83, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "At-will relationship, bilateral termination right, and handbook disclaimer are clearly stated. The caveat for notice requirements is an important qualifier.", "completeness":... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employees who use personal devices for work consent to Company installing MDM software on such devices, which may be used to remotely wipe Company data in the event of device loss, theft, or employment termination.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 16, "completeness": 14, "risk_balance": 10, "enforceability": 14}, "total": 54, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Company data vs. personal data distinction in a remote wipe scenario is not addressed. MDM software capabilities beyond remote wipe are not disclosed.", "completeness": "Miss... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Service Provider retains all right, title, and interest in Background IP. 'Background IP' means all intellectual property owned or licensed by Service Provider prior to the Effective Date or developed independently without use of Client's Confidential Information or resources. To the extent Background IP is in... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 89, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Background IP definition, retention, and license scope are clearly delineated. 'Solely as part of the Deliverables' is a well-scoped limitation.", "completeness": "Covers def... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: ''Material Adverse Change' means any change that has had or would reasonably be expected to have a material adverse effect on the business, assets, financial condition, or results of operations of the Company taken as a whole; excluding effects arising from: (a) general economic conditions; (b) industry-wide co... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 86, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "MAC definition and five exclusions are clearly stated. 'Reasonably be expected to have' standard is objective. 'Taken as a whole' prevents cherry-picking.", "completeness": "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer may terminate this Agreement for convenience upon sixty (60) days written notice. Upon termination for convenience: (a) Customer shall pay all undisputed fees through the termination date; (b) Customer shall pay a termination fee equal to three (3) months of fees; (c) Vendor shall deliver all work pro... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 90, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Notice period, four post-termination obligations, termination fee formula, and wind-down duty are each precisely defined.", "completeness": "Covers notice, accrued fees,... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Notwithstanding the foregoing, a party may use Residual Knowledge in the conduct of its business. 'Residual Knowledge' means information retained in the unaided memories of individuals who had access to Confidential Information, but only to the extent not intentionally memorized.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 13, "risk_balance": 10, "enforceability": 12}, "total": 49, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Unaided memories' and 'not intentionally memorized' are subjective and unverifiable. The clause is internally contradictory.", "completeness": "Missing: types of information... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'On each anniversary of the Effective Date, fees shall be adjusted by the lesser of: (a) three percent (3%); or (b) the percentage change in the CPI-U, All Items, for the twelve-month period ending thirty (30) days prior to the anniversary date. Vendor shall notify Customer of adjusted fees at least forty-five ... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 92, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Cap formula, CPI index reference, measurement period, notification timing, and deflation treatment are all precisely defined.", "completeness": "Covers adjustment formul... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Processor shall process Personal Data only for the purposes in Annex A and only per Controller's documented instructions, unless required by applicable law, in which case Processor shall inform Controller prior to processing unless prohibited by law. Processor shall immediately inform Controller if an instruct... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Purpose limitation, instruction requirement, legal override with notice, and infringement notification duties are clearly stated. Processor-only status is affirmatively ackno... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'EACH PARTY HEREBY IRREVOCABLY AND UNCONDITIONALLY WAIVES, TO THE FULLEST EXTENT PERMITTED BY APPLICABLE LAW, ANY AND ALL RIGHTS TO A TRIAL BY JURY IN ANY ACTION ARISING OUT OF OR RELATING TO THIS AGREEMENT. EACH PARTY REPRESENTS THAT IT HAS REVIEWED THIS WAIVER WITH ITS LEGAL COUNSEL AND KNOWINGLY AND VOLUNTAR... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 86, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Scope is broad and clearly stated. 'Irrevocably and unconditionally' removes ambiguity. Voluntary waiver representation is explicit.", "completeness": "Covers waiver scope, v... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This agreement is governed by the laws of the Cayman Islands. All disputes must be resolved in the courts of the Cayman Islands, and you waive any objection to this jurisdiction.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 11, "risk_balance": 5, "enforceability": 8}, "total": 38, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Governing law and forum are stated. However, 'waive any objection' without defining the objection type is imprecise.", "completeness": "Missing: conflict-of-law provisions, con... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor will use best efforts to maintain system availability.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 5, "completeness": 3, "risk_balance": 4, "enforceability": 4}, "total": 16, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Best efforts' to maintain 'availability' provides no measurable standard. No uptime target, measurement period, or exclusions are defined.", "completeness": "Missing vir... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Any disputes arising under this Agreement shall be submitted to mediation. The parties agree to mediate in good faith before pursuing any other remedies.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 10, "completeness": 6, "risk_balance": 13, "enforceability": 8}, "total": 37, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "No mediator selection process, institution, location, cost allocation, or timeline is specified.", "completeness": "Missing: mediator selection mechanism, institution rules, se... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party represents and warrants that: (a) it is duly organized and validly existing under the laws of its jurisdiction; (b) it has all requisite power and authority to execute and perform this Agreement; (c) this Agreement has been duly authorized and constitutes a legal, valid, and binding obligation subje... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 95, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Each representation is a discrete, unambiguous legal statement. Standard legal qualifications are appropriately included.", "completeness": "Covers legal existence, powe... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor shall maintain the following minimum insurance coverages: (a) Commercial General Liability: $2,000,000 per occurrence / $4,000,000 aggregate; (b) Professional Liability: $2,000,000 per claim; (c) Cyber Liability: $5,000,000 per occurrence; (d) Workers Compensation: statutory limits. Vendor shall name Cu... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Coverage types, limits, additional insured requirements, certificate timing, and carrier rating are all precisely stated.", "completeness": "Covers four coverage types, limit... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Other companies in our group may also benefit from this agreement.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 5, "completeness": 3, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 5}, "total": 21, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Our group' is undefined. 'May also benefit' does not establish whether third parties have enforceable rights or are merely incidental beneficiaries.", "completeness": "M... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Service Provider shall meet the following SLAs: (i) System Availability: 99.9% uptime measured monthly, excluding scheduled maintenance of no more than four (4) hours per month with 48 hours advance notice; (ii) Priority 1 incidents: response within one (1) hour, resolution within four (4) hours; Priority 2: r... | {"scores": {"clarity": 24, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 18, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "SLA metrics are quantified with precise thresholds, tiers, and credit formula. Excellent precision.", "completeness": "Covers availability, incident tiers, and credit mechani... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party represents, warrants, and covenants that in connection with this Agreement it has not and shall not: (a) offer, pay, or authorize payment of any money to any government official or political party for the purpose of influencing any act in violation of the FCPA, the UK Bribery Act, or any other appli... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Prohibited actions are enumerated specifically. Named statutes anchor the legal standard. Facilitation payment prohibition is an explicit bright line.", "completeness": ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'During employment and for twelve (12) months following voluntary resignation, Employee shall not directly solicit or accept business from any client of Company with whom Employee had direct personal contact during the prior twelve (12) months, for services of the same type as those Employee performed for Compa... | {"scores": {"clarity": 21, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 18, "enforceability": 20}, "total": 79, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Personal contact requirement, lookback period, service scope limitation, and voluntary resignation trigger are clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers restriction scope, d... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor warrants that Professional Services will be performed by qualified personnel in a professional and workmanlike manner consistent with industry standards. In the event of breach reported in writing within thirty (30) days of delivery, Vendor shall re-perform at no charge or, if re-performance is not feas... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 18, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 82, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Warranty standard, reporting window, remedial options, and sole remedy designation are clearly stated.", "completeness": "Covers performance standard, reporting requirement, ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'In the event Company decides to sell shares, Company shall first offer such shares to existing shareholders on the same terms as any proposed third-party transaction before selling to third parties.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 13, "completeness": 10, "risk_balance": 16, "enforceability": 12}, "total": 51, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Decides to sell shares' is undefined \u2014 applies to all share issuances or only secondary sales. 'Same terms' requires a defined trigger mechanism.", "completeness": "Mis... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Either party may assign this Agreement or any rights hereunder to any affiliate or in connection with a merger, acquisition, or sale of all or substantially all of its assets, without consent. Any other assignment shall require prior written consent, not to be unreasonably withheld, conditioned, or delayed. An... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 19, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 82, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Permitted assignment triggers and consent standard are clearly defined. Invalidity consequence is explicit.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'affiliate,' change-of-c... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company will provide relocation assistance to Employee. Amount to be determined based on Company policy.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 6, "completeness": 4, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 7}, "total": 25, "grade": "Unacceptable", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Assistance' is undefined. Referencing an unattached policy creates ambiguity about which version applies.", "completeness": "Missing: relocation package amount or compon... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Customer shall have the right, no more than once per calendar year and upon thirty (30) days prior written notice, to audit Vendor's books and records relevant to compliance with this Agreement, including license usage and fee calculations. Audits shall be conducted during normal business hours by a qualified ... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Frequency, notice period, scope, hours, auditor qualification, cost allocation trigger, and reconciliation deadline are all defined.", "completeness": "Covers frequency, noti... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The parties shall keep the terms of this Agreement confidential.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 11, "completeness": 8, "risk_balance": 14, "enforceability": 10}, "total": 43, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "The obligation is stated but 'terms' is ambiguous \u2014 does it cover the existence of the Agreement or only the commercial terms?", "completeness": "Missing: definition of w... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Landlord shall maintain the property in good repair and working order, including all structural components, mechanical systems, and common areas. Landlord shall respond to maintenance requests within twenty-four (24) hours and complete non-emergency repairs within seven (7) business days. For emergency repairs... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Repair scope, response and completion timelines for both standard and emergency repairs, and the rent deduction remedy are all precisely defined.", "completeness": "Cove... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The Company owns all work product created by Employee.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 10, "completeness": 7, "risk_balance": 8, "enforceability": 11}, "total": 36, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'All work product' is overbroad without temporal or connection-to-employment limits. 'Created by' does not address work developed with Company resources.", "completeness": "Mis... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Contractor is an independent contractor and not an employee of Company. Contractor is responsible for all taxes on compensation received. Company shall have no obligation to withhold taxes or provide benefits. Contractor shall indemnify Company for any tax liability arising from misclassification of Contractor... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 17, "enforceability": 18}, "total": 78, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Independent contractor status, tax responsibility, no-withholding obligation, indemnification, and no-agency language are each clearly stated.", "completeness": "Covers class... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement shall be construed in accordance with the laws of England and Wales. The parties irrevocably submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the English courts. Each party waives any objection to proceedings in those courts on grounds of inconvenient forum.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 85, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Governing law, exclusive jurisdiction, and inconvenient forum waiver are clearly stated. Courts, not arbitration, are specified.", "completeness": "Covers governing law, excl... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Each party shall promptly notify the other party of any actual or suspected data breach involving the other party's Personal Data. Upon becoming aware of a confirmed Personal Data Breach, Processor shall notify Controller without undue delay and in any event within seventy-two (72) hours, providing: (a) a desc... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 24, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 92, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "72-hour timeline, notification trigger, and six required content elements are all precisely defined.", "completeness": "Covers mutual notification, confirmed breach trig... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Tenant shall not make any alterations to the premises without Landlord's prior written consent.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 14, "completeness": 10, "risk_balance": 13, "enforceability": 13}, "total": 50, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Alterations' is undefined \u2014 it is unclear whether minor cosmetic changes or only structural modifications require consent.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of 'al... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Licensor grants Licensee a non-exclusive, non-transferable, worldwide, royalty-bearing license to use, reproduce, distribute, display, and create derivative works of the Licensed Technology for commercial purposes during the Term. The license does not include the right to sublicense without Licensor's prior wr... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 85, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "License type, scope of permitted activities, geographic scope, sublicense restriction, and reservation of rights are all clearly stated.", "completeness": "Covers license typ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The loan shall bear interest at 12% per annum. Principal and interest shall be repaid in equal monthly installments over 36 months beginning on the first day of the month following the Effective Date. In the event of a payment default, the entire outstanding balance shall become immediately due and payable. La... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 17, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 83, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Interest rate, repayment structure, acceleration trigger, and default interest rate are all precisely defined.", "completeness": "Covers principal/interest rate, repayment sc... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Franchisor grants Franchisee the right to operate one franchise location at the address specified in Exhibit A using the Franchisor's System, trademarks, and proprietary methods. Franchisee shall pay an initial franchise fee of $50,000 and ongoing royalties of 6% of gross sales, payable weekly. Franchisee shal... | {"scores": {"clarity": 21, "completeness": 19, "risk_balance": 14, "enforceability": 19}, "total": 73, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Location specificity, fee structure, and manual compliance obligation are clearly stated. 'As updated from time to time' creates unilateral modification risk.", "completeness... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Employee agrees to hold Company harmless from any claims arising from Employee's work.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 8, "completeness": 5, "risk_balance": 6, "enforceability": 7}, "total": 26, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Hold harmless' without 'indemnify and defend' is incomplete. 'Claims arising from Employee's work' is overbroad and undefined.", "completeness": "Missing: scope of claims covere... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Parties agree to keep all discussions and negotiations confidential for a period of two (2) years. This obligation shall not apply to information already in the public domain or independently developed by either party.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 16, "completeness": 14, "risk_balance": 17, "enforceability": 15}, "total": 62, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Duration and two standard exceptions are stated. 'Discussions and negotiations' scope is narrower than typical NDA coverage.", "completeness": "Missing: definition of what co... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement and all rights and obligations hereunder shall terminate automatically upon the expiration of the Initial Term unless renewed by mutual written agreement of the parties for successive one-year terms, each such renewal subject to any adjustments in fees as mutually agreed. Either party may elect ... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Auto-termination at end of term, renewal mechanism, fee adjustment process, and 90-day non-renewal notice are all clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers termination at te... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Guarantor unconditionally and irrevocably guarantees the full and punctual payment of all amounts owed by Borrower to Lender under the Loan Agreement, including principal, interest, fees, and costs of collection. This is a guarantee of payment and not merely of collection. Guarantor waives: (a) notice of accep... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 16, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 85, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Payment guarantee (not collection), scope of obligations, and enumerated waivers are all clearly articulated.", "completeness": "Covers guarantee type, scope, five suretyship... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Lessee shall maintain the leased equipment in good working condition, normal wear and tear excepted. Lessee shall bear all costs of maintenance, repair, and insurance. At the end of the lease term, Lessee shall return the equipment in the same condition as received, reasonable wear and tear excepted. Lessee sh... | {"scores": {"clarity": 20, "completeness": 19, "risk_balance": 17, "enforceability": 20}, "total": 76, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Maintenance obligation, wear and tear exception, return condition, and modification restriction are stated. 'Normal wear and tear' could benefit from a definition or examples... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Company may change these terms at any time. Continued use of the service after changes are posted constitutes acceptance.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 12, "completeness": 8, "risk_balance": 4, "enforceability": 9}, "total": 33, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'At any time' grants unlimited unilateral modification rights with no advance notice requirement. 'Posted' does not specify where or how.", "completeness": "Missing: notice meth... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Franchisor grants Franchisee an exclusive territory defined in Exhibit B for the duration of the Agreement. Franchisor shall not establish or license any other franchisee or company-owned location within the Exclusive Territory during the term. Franchisee's exclusive territorial rights are conditioned upon Fra... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Exclusivity scope, Franchisor's reciprocal restriction, performance condition, and conversion consequence are clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers territory definition,... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'In the event of any inconsistency between this Agreement and any Schedule or Exhibit attached hereto, the terms of this Agreement shall control, unless the Schedule or Exhibit expressly states that it supersedes a specific provision of this Agreement.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 87, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Order of precedence is clearly stated with a defined exception mechanism. The exception condition ('expressly states') is an objective standard.", "completeness": "Covers mai... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Either party may terminate this Agreement at any time.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 8, "completeness": 4, "risk_balance": 15, "enforceability": 10}, "total": 37, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Termination right is stated but 'at any time' provides no notice requirement, process, or transition obligations.", "completeness": "Missing: notice period, effective date, pos... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The parties agree that this Agreement may be executed in counterparts, each of which shall be deemed an original, and all of which together shall constitute one and the same instrument. Electronic signatures shall be deemed valid and binding to the same extent as original signatures. Transmission of an execute... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 23, "enforceability": 24}, "total": 93, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Counterparts, original status of each, electronic signature validity, and PDF transmission effectiveness are all explicitly addressed.", "completeness": "Covers counterp... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Vendor shall provide implementation services in accordance with the Project Plan attached as Exhibit A. Any delays caused by Customer's failure to provide required information, access, or approvals within the timeframes specified in Exhibit A shall extend the project schedule by an equivalent period. Vendor sh... | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 21, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 86, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Customer-caused delay trigger, schedule extension mechanism, and notification obligation with timeline are clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers delay trigger, schedule ... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The Receiving Party shall not reverse engineer, disassemble, decompile, or otherwise attempt to derive the source code or underlying ideas of any software or technology disclosed as Confidential Information, except to the extent expressly permitted by applicable law.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 22, "completeness": 20, "risk_balance": 19, "enforceability": 21}, "total": 82, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Prohibited activities are enumerated. The statutory exception ('expressly permitted by applicable law') is appropriately included.", "completeness": "Covers reverse engineeri... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'This Agreement may be amended only by a written instrument signed by duly authorized representatives of both parties.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 21, "completeness": 18, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 83, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "'Duly authorized representatives' and 'written instrument' are clear standards. Simple and precise.", "completeness": "Covers amendment mechanism. Missing: specification of a... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Contractor warrants that all services will be performed in compliance with all applicable laws, regulations, and industry standards. Contractor shall obtain and maintain all licenses, permits, and certifications required for the performance of services.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 19, "completeness": 18, "risk_balance": 20, "enforceability": 19}, "total": 76, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Compliance scope (laws, regulations, industry standards) and license/permit obligation are clearly stated. 'All applicable' is broad but standard.", "completeness": "Covers l... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'In consideration of the mutual covenants contained herein and other good and valuable consideration, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, the parties agree as follows.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 15, "completeness": 11, "risk_balance": 17, "enforceability": 16}, "total": 59, "grade": "Fair", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Boilerplate recital language is legally functional but says nothing substantive about actual consideration exchanged.", "completeness": "A consideration recital should not st... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Either party may seek equitable relief, including injunction and specific performance, in any court of competent jurisdiction for breach or threatened breach of the confidentiality, intellectual property, or non-solicitation provisions of this Agreement, without the requirement of posting a bond and without pr... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 23, "risk_balance": 22, "enforceability": 23}, "total": 91, "grade": "Excellent", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Triggering provisions, type of relief, no-bond requirement, no-damages-proof requirement, and irreparable harm acknowledgment are all clearly stated.", "completeness": "... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'The parties intend this Agreement to be a legally binding contract.' | {"scores": {"clarity": 8, "completeness": 5, "risk_balance": 15, "enforceability": 9}, "total": 37, "grade": "Poor", "reasoning": {"clarity": "A statement of intent to be bound is legally circular and adds nothing to an agreement that already contains consideration and acceptance.", "completeness": "Missing: all substa... |
You are a legal document quality judge. Evaluate the following contract clause against the rubric: clarity (0-25), completeness (0-25), risk_balance (0-25), enforceability (0-25). Return JSON only. | CLAUSE: 'Supplier shall ensure that its supply chain, including all subcontractors and sub-suppliers, complies with applicable laws prohibiting human trafficking, forced labor, and child labor. Supplier shall maintain records evidencing compliance and shall provide such records to Buyer upon reasonable request. Supplie... | {"scores": {"clarity": 23, "completeness": 22, "risk_balance": 21, "enforceability": 22}, "total": 88, "grade": "Good", "reasoning": {"clarity": "Prohibited practices, record-keeping obligation, buyer access right, investigation duty, and notification timeline are clearly defined.", "completeness": "Covers supply chain... |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
Legal Synth Docs — LLM-as-Judge Dataset
Training data for fine-tuning an LLM to evaluate contract clause quality across four dimensions: clarity, completeness, risk_balance, and enforceability (0–25 each, total 0–100).
Dataset Summary
277 annotated clause examples spanning the full quality spectrum (scores 15–95/100), covering 60+ clause types including payment, termination, indemnification, IP assignment, governing law, NDA, SLA, force majeure, non-compete, data protection, warranty, liability, franchise, employment, software licensing, M&A, real estate, and more.
Fields
| Field | Type | Description |
|---|---|---|
instruction |
string | System prompt for the judge role |
input |
string | Contract clause to evaluate |
output |
string | JSON evaluation with scores, grade, reasoning, and recommendations |
Scoring Rubric
| Grade | Score Range |
|---|---|
| Excellent | 85–100 |
| Good | 70–84 |
| Fair | 50–69 |
| Poor | 30–49 |
| Unacceptable | 0–29 |
See FINETUNING_GUIDE.md for fine-tuning instructions.
- Downloads last month
- 246