review_extension/aggregate/persistence_identity_null.json

{
  "analysis": "dial_terminal_persistence_identity_null",
  "checkpoint_millions": 30,
  "claim_boundary": "Post-hoc terminal calibration. Positive observed-minus-null similarity supports target specificity, not functional use.",
  "common_template_tokens": 4951,
  "complete": true,
  "identity_null_samples_per_cue": 32,
  "lineages": 18,
  "metrics": {
    "coordinate_cosine": {
      "aligned_minus_shared_calibrated": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          0.3184126652067267,
          0.3192653039968419
        ],
        "mean": 0.31878093391001805,
        "paired_effects": [
          0.31875516721582997,
          0.31823083955009573,
          0.31850121299104733,
          0.3183789659666457,
          0.319893199739318,
          0.31892621799717175
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 6,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
      },
      "conditions": {
        "aligned": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.7756781830139969,
            0.7761519938409721
          ],
          "mean": 0.7759140132299321,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.7759487135052212,
            0.7758973869494948,
            0.7761085528206825,
            0.7754629981106541,
            0.7763941343631943,
            0.7756722936303463
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shared": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.4567952664912502,
            0.457470892148578
          ],
          "mean": 0.45713307931991415,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.45719354628939124,
            0.4576665473993991,
            0.45760733982963514,
            0.4570840321440084,
            0.45650093462387625,
            0.45674607563317454
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shuffled": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.7807437463941193,
            0.7812731920847579
          ],
          "mean": 0.7810394765362275,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.7813124151148713,
            0.7804240840373527,
            0.7809621827497192,
            0.7808570406446371,
            0.7813101338124838,
            0.7813710028583006
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        }
      }
    },
    "linear_cka": {
      "aligned_minus_shared_calibrated": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.06525242711845958,
          -0.06453605981157663
        ],
        "mean": -0.06488011909006465,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.06468552108911851,
          -0.06435746641852136,
          -0.0652928455291586,
          -0.06442269076300888,
          -0.06561689166778728,
          -0.0649052990727933
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 0,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
      },
      "conditions": {
        "aligned": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.7577060086752563,
            0.7581225489800154
          ],
          "mean": 0.7579196216107795,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.757880565688024,
            0.7579716283781684,
            0.7574719313693102,
            0.7583162118470118,
            0.7577655289684347,
            0.758111863413728
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shared": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.822549007109359,
            0.8230782356303918
          ],
          "mean": 0.8227997407008442,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.8225660867771425,
            0.8223290947966898,
            0.8227647768984688,
            0.8227389026100207,
            0.823382420636222,
            0.8230171624865213
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shuffled": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.767961545349177,
            0.7686294342188842
          ],
          "mean": 0.768352020580167,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.7686743006254412,
            0.7685003313506619,
            0.767430522978418,
            0.7683623312120753,
            0.7683915965787477,
            0.7687530407356582
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        }
      }
    },
    "orthogonal_procrustes_similarity": {
      "aligned_minus_shared_calibrated": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          -0.048642810166916406,
          -0.047951583270288665
        ],
        "mean": -0.04828395104213279,
        "paired_effects": [
          -0.04769500643032032,
          -0.048560819559994806,
          -0.048270614489698715,
          -0.04827564758590497,
          -0.04788661234274383,
          -0.049015005844134096
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 0,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
      },
      "conditions": {
        "aligned": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.6614990347631485,
            0.6619371561971449
          ],
          "mean": 0.6617261146309107,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.6620165794554306,
            0.6612932447905132,
            0.6619323893321688,
            0.6616326131759089,
            0.662012387881965,
            0.6614694731494776
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shared": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.7098246369993576,
            0.7102364609858375
          ],
          "mean": 0.7100100656730435,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.7097115858857509,
            0.709854064350508,
            0.7102030038218675,
            0.7099082607618139,
            0.7098990002247089,
            0.7104844789936117
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shuffled": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.666603282600185,
            0.6669197083685097
          ],
          "mean": 0.66676430664539,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.6668972016193203,
            0.666540380944896,
            0.6668764650580853,
            0.6664859104511492,
            0.6667243816834456,
            0.6670615001154432
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        }
      }
    },
    "principal_affinity": {
      "aligned_minus_shared_calibrated": {
        "confidence_interval_95": [
          0.12956461531071212,
          0.13231637233183188
        ],
        "mean": 0.1310045558293851,
        "paired_effects": [
          0.13227690082810228,
          0.12836772155186782,
          0.13309818538767137,
          0.1303446139307748,
          0.1325401742283857,
          0.12939973904950874
        ],
        "positive_seeds": 6,
        "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
      },
      "conditions": {
        "aligned": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.705008359709443,
            0.7078897928217515
          ],
          "mean": 0.7064680325820941,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.7072009410196816,
            0.7037534570514614,
            0.7090640103191482,
            0.7050517761007989,
            0.7079931670677743,
            0.7057448439337001
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shared": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.5750253783077105,
            0.5759186207923989
          ],
          "mean": 0.575463476752709,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.5749240401915793,
            0.5753857354995936,
            0.5759658249314769,
            0.5747071621700242,
            0.5754529928393886,
            0.5763451048841913
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        },
        "shuffled": {
          "confidence_interval_95": [
            0.6982566569439385,
            0.7007001997745802
          ],
          "mean": 0.699415703300895,
          "paired_effects": [
            0.6991876679102278,
            0.6976708345246013,
            0.7019328514229558,
            0.6986756010822396,
            0.6980471848747879,
            0.7009800799905568
          ],
          "positive_seeds": 6,
          "two_sided_exact_sign_flip_p": 0.03125
        }
      }
    }
  },
  "schema_version": 1
}