Datasets:
id string | traj_id string | site string | goal string | action string | before_url string | is_noop bool | before image | after image | next_state_free string | next_state_template string |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_1 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 25 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/Showerthoughts | false | The page transitioned to a new post titled "It takes longer to make a cold pizza than a hot pizza," submitted by a different user. The comment count increased to 209, and the previous post is no longer visible. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_0 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the Showerthoughts forum, displaying a list of posts along with their respective comment counts. The latest post is highlighted, showing a total of 85 comments, while the overall forum context has shifted from a general list of forums to a specific discussion thread. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_5 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/TehOuchies/comments | false | The page transitioned to a new post in the Showerthoughts forum, displaying a different comment thread with a total of 26 comments. The previous comments by the user "TehOuchies" are no longer visible, and the new post has a different author, "diet-Coke-or-kill-me," along with updated voting scores. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_2 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 36 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/Showerthoughts/15731/it-takes-longer-to-make-a-cold-pizza-than-a-hot-pizza | false | The page transitioned to a login or registration prompt, preventing access to the comments section. As a result, the user is unable to view or interact with the comments related to the post. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: removed
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_6 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 13 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/Showerthoughts/122252 | false | The page displayed the same post with the same number of comments, but the comment count decreased from 26 to 25, indicating that one comment was removed or deleted. No other visible changes occurred on the page. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205810_b29262_4 | traj_20260609_205810_b29262 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Showerthoughts forum. | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/TehOuchies/submissions | false | The page transitioned from displaying no entries under the "Submissions" tab to showing several comments made by the user "TehOuchies" under the "Comments" tab. The comments include various replies, some with upvotes and one with downvotes, indicating user engagement and feedback on previous posts. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_0 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_1 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change in the page content or layout after the action was taken; the forum list remained the same with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_2 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "worldnews" forum, displaying a list of submissions with updated content, including new posts and their respective comment counts. The URL changed to reflect the selected forum, and the previous forum list is no longer visible. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_4 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/worldnews/comments | false | The page transitioned to the overview of the user "DeLaManana," displaying their comment that received a downvote. The focus shifted from recent comments to the user's profile, where their comment history and engagement metrics are now visible. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: focus changes
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_3 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 14 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/worldnews | false | The page transitioned to display recent comments in the Worcester forum, showing a list of comments with their respective upvote counts. The focus shifted from submissions to comments, allowing users to engage with the latest discussions. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_6 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/DeLaManana/comments | false | The page transitioned from the "Comments" section to the "Overview" section, displaying the main post instead of the comments. There were no visible changes to the content of the post itself, but the focus shifted away from the comments. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: tabs changed
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9_5 | traj_20260609_205959_afb2a9 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the Worcester forum. | click 30 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/DeLaManana | false | The page transitioned to the Comments section, displaying the comments related to the post. No new content was added or filtered, and the existing comment by the user remains visible, indicating no changes in the comment count or status. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: tab change
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_1 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The list of forums remains the same, indicating that the action did not result in any navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_2 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remains unchanged, with no visible updates to the forum list or content after the action. The same forums and their submission counts are displayed in both screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_4 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remains unchanged, with no visible updates to the forum list or content after the action. The same forums and their submission counts are displayed in both screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_3 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_5 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remains unchanged, displaying the same list of forums without any visible updates or new content. No navigation or filtering occurred as a result of the action. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_6 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_7 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remains unchanged, with no visible updates to the list of forums or any other content. The user is still on the same forum selection screen. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_9 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_8 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action. The list of forums remained the same, with no new content, navigation, or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210111_858563_10 | traj_20260609_210111_858563 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the DIY forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The list of forums remains the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_0 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the space forum, displaying a list of posts with their respective comment counts. The latest post is highlighted, showing a total of 77 comments, indicating user engagement with the content. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_1 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 36 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/space | false | The page transitioned from displaying posts in the /f/space forum to showing search results for "www.cbsnews.com." The new content includes a list of articles related to CBS News, with no comments visible for the majority of the results. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_2 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 38 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/search?q=www.cbsnews.com | false | The page transitioned from a search results view for "www.cbsnews.com" to the overview of the user "discogeek." The new state displays the user's activity, including their comments and submissions, but does not show any comments with more downvotes than upvotes. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: focus changes
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_3 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 40 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/discogeek | false | The page transitioned to the "Comments" section, displaying a list of comments related to the latest post. The visible content includes several comments, but no specific count of comments with more downvotes than upvotes is shown. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_4 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/discogeek/comments | false | The page transitioned to display comments made by a different user, yeags86, who has posted recent replies. The previous user's comments are no longer visible, and the focus has shifted to the new user's contributions, indicating a change in the active discussion thread. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: removed content
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_5 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 36 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86 | false | The page transitioned to the "Submissions" tab, displaying a message indicating that there are no entries to display. This suggests that the user has no submissions available for viewing. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: removed content
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_6 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86/submissions | false | The page transitioned from displaying no entries in the "Submissions" section to showing a list of comments made by the user "yeags86." The comments include various replies, each with associated upvote counts, indicating user engagement with the posts. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new content
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_7 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86/comments | false | The page transitioned from the "Comments" section to the "Overview" section, resulting in the removal of the comments list and the display of general information about the user. There were no visible changes to the content of the comments themselves, as they were not altered or removed. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_8 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 12 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86 | false | The page transitioned from the "Overview" section to the "Comments" section, displaying the same comments but now focused on user interactions. There are no visible changes in the content of the comments themselves, but the context has shifted to a different part of the forum. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: focus change
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_9 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86/comments | false | The page remained unchanged, with no visible updates to the comments or any new content displayed. The comment count and user information stayed the same, indicating that the action did not result in any observable changes. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210233_8abe72_10 | traj_20260609_210233_8abe72 | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the space forum. | click 10 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/user/yeags86/comments | true | The page remains unchanged after the action, with no visible updates to the comments or any new content displayed. The same comments and their respective vote counts are still visible, indicating that no new information was retrieved. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_0 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The list of forums remains the same, indicating that the action did not result in any navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_1 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page; the content and layout remained the same before and after the action. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_3 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The list of forums remained the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_2 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remained unchanged, with no visible updates to the forum list or any other content. The same forums and their submission counts are displayed in both screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_4 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remained unchanged, with no visible alterations to the list of forums or their content. The same forums and submission counts are displayed in both the before and after screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_5 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | The page remained unchanged, with no visible updates to the forum list or content after the action was taken. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_6 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The list of forums remains the same, indicating that the action did not result in any navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_7 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_9 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_8 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There is no visible change between the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots; the content and layout of the forum list remain the same. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd_10 | traj_20260609_210333_1c10dd | webarena-reddit | Tell me the count of comments that have received more downvotes than upvotes for the user who made the latest post on the photoshopbattles forum. | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | true | There was no visible change to the page after the action; the content and layout remained the same in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_0 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "books" forum, displaying a list of posts related to books. The URL changed to reflect the new forum, and the content now includes various submissions about books, including their titles and associated discussions. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_1 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 32 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books | false | The page transitioned to a new URL displaying content related to "The Eliot-Hale Letters," featuring an image of a woman, indicating a focus on a specific book rather than the previous forum posts. The previous list of posts was replaced by detailed content about this particular book. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_2 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 11 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," displaying detailed information about the correspondence between T. S. Eliot and Emily Hale. The content now includes links to various sections such as "The Letters," "Biographical Register," and "Index," indicating a focus on the... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_3 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 6 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new article about Conrad Aiken, displaying biographical information and literary contributions, indicating a shift in focus from the previous content about T.S. Eliot and Emily Hale. The URL changed to reflect the new subject matter, suggesting a successful navigation to a specific post relat... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_4 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 5 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters/bio/conrad-aiken | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," displaying a list of contents related to Eliot's letters, indicating a shift in focus from Conrad Aiken to T. S. Eliot's correspondence. The URL likely changed to reflect this new content. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: removed content
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210407_15aff8_5 | traj_20260609_210407_15aff8 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the post URLs that recommand a single book | click 0 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters/bio/conrad-aiken | false | The page remains the same, but a dialog has opened, likely providing additional options or information related to the content. There are no visible changes to the main content or navigation. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: focus changes
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_210437_b05dec_0 | traj_20260609_210437_b05dec | webarena-reddit | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "books" forum, displaying a list of submissions related to books, including various posts and their respective comment counts. The URL changed to reflect the new forum, and the content now focuses on book-related discussions rather than the previous list of forums. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | |||
traj_20260609_210437_b05dec_1 | traj_20260609_210437_b05dec | webarena-reddit | click 32 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books | false | The page transitioned from a list of book submissions to a detailed view of the "Eliot-Hale Letters," displaying an image of a woman. The URL changed to reflect the new content, indicating a shift from browsing submissions to viewing specific letter content. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | |||
traj_20260609_210437_b05dec_2 | traj_20260609_210437_b05dec | webarena-reddit | click 11 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," displaying detailed information about the correspondence between T. S. Eliot and Emily Hale. The layout changed to a reddish background with new navigation options, including links to "The Letters," "Biographical Register," "Index... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | |||
traj_20260609_210437_b05dec_3 | traj_20260609_210437_b05dec | webarena-reddit | click 5 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters," displaying introductory content edited by John Haffenden. The layout changed, featuring a new color scheme and a list of preliminaries, including sections like "Introduction" and "Acknowledgements." | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | |||
traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62_0 | traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the book names from posts that recommand a single book | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "books" forum, displaying a list of submissions related to books. The content now includes various posts, each with a title, submission details, and comment counts, indicating a focus on book-related discussions. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62_1 | traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the book names from posts that recommand a single book | click 32 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books | false | The page transitioned from a forum listing to a detailed view of "The Eliot-Hale Letters," displaying content related to this specific book. The URL changed to reflect the new page, and the previous forum context was replaced with focused information about the book. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62_2 | traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the book names from posts that recommand a single book | click 11 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," displaying detailed information about the correspondence between T. S. Eliot and Emily Hale. The content now includes links to various sections such as "The Letters," "Biographical Register," and "Index," indicating a shift in foc... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62_3 | traj_20260609_212437_8bfe62 | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the book names from posts that recommand a single book | click 5 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to display the content of "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," showing a new section with an introduction, acknowledgments, and a chronology of Emily Hale's life and career. The URL likely updated to reflect the specific section of the letters being accessed. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: menus
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212503_aa505c_0 | traj_20260609_212503_aa505c | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the author name and the book name from posts that recommand a single book | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "books" forum, displaying a list of submissions related to books. The content now includes various posts, each with titles and submission details, indicating a focus on book recommendations and discussions. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212503_aa505c_1 | traj_20260609_212503_aa505c | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the author name and the book name from posts that recommand a single book | click 32 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books | false | The page transitioned to a new content view displaying "The Eliot-Hale Letters," indicating a focus on this specific book. The previous forum posts were replaced by detailed information about the book, including its title and author. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212503_aa505c_2 | traj_20260609_212503_aa505c | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the author name and the book name from posts that recommand a single book | click 11 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page transitioned to a new section titled "The Letters of T. S. Eliot to Emily Hale," displaying a list of contents including sections like "Introduction," "Acknowledgements," and "The Letters." The visual layout changed to a blue background, indicating a shift in focus to the book's content rather than the previou... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212503_aa505c_3 | traj_20260609_212503_aa505c | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, show me the author name and the book name from posts that recommand a single book | click 0 | https://tseliot.com/the-eliot-hale-letters | false | The page remains the same, but a dialog box has opened, likely providing additional options or information related to the content displayed. No new content or URL changes are visible. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: focus changes
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212524_5572dd_0 | traj_20260609_212524_5572dd | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, is there any post talks about supporting local book stores? If so, tell me the organizations involved | click 3 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/forums | false | The page transitioned to the "books" forum, displaying a list of posts related to books. Among the top posts, one discusses a project supporting local bookstores, specifically mentioning "bookshop.org" and an initiative involving West Virginia University to help inmates learn new skills through books. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: navigation
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212524_5572dd_1 | traj_20260609_212524_5572dd | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, is there any post talks about supporting local book stores? If so, tell me the organizations involved | click 32 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books | false | The page transitioned to a detailed discussion about the website bookshop.org, highlighting its role in supporting local bookstores. A user shared their experience as an indie bookstore manager, emphasizing the importance of local stores and encouraging others to support them. The comments section expanded, revealing f... | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: new
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212540_6b365d_0 | traj_20260609_212540_6b365d | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "I am a robot" | click 6 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065542 | false | There is no visible change in the page after the action; the login screen remains the same, with no updates to the content or state. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212524_5572dd_2 | traj_20260609_212524_5572dd | webarena-reddit | Among the top 10 post in "books" forum, is there any post talks about supporting local book stores? If so, tell me the organizations involved | click 17 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/f/books/59421/friendly-reminder-bookshop-org-exists | false | The page remains unchanged after the action; the content and layout are identical in both the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots. No new comments or posts were added, and no visible changes occurred. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212540_6b365d_1 | traj_20260609_212540_6b365d | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "I am a robot" | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065542 | true | There is no visible change in the page after the action; the login screen remains the same with no updates to the content or state. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212540_6b365d_2 | traj_20260609_212540_6b365d | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "I am a robot" | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065542 | true | There is no visible change in the page after the action; the login screen remains the same with no updates to the content or state. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212540_6b365d_3 | traj_20260609_212540_6b365d | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "I am a robot" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065542 | true | The page displays a validation error indicating that the password field must be filled out, preventing the user from logging in. The username field remains empty, and the login process has not progressed. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: error shown
ERROR: error or blocker shown | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_0 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 6 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | false | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no updates to content or navigation. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_1 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | The page displays an error message indicating that the password field must be filled out, suggesting that the login attempt was incomplete. No navigation or content changes occurred beyond this validation feedback. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: error message shown
ERROR: error or blocker shown | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_2 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | The password field now displays masked characters instead of being empty, indicating that a password has been entered. The warning message "Please fill out this field" remains visible, suggesting that the username field is still unfilled. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: password field obscured
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_3 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | type 9 "your_password" submit | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | The page remains on the login screen, but the error message indicating that the password field was not filled out has disappeared. The password input field is still visible, and the "Keep me logged in" checkbox is checked. There are no other visible changes to the page. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: error message removed
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_4 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no indication of a successful action or navigation. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_5 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login form remains the same with no navigation or content updates. The user is still on the login screen without any indication of successful login or further actions taken. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_6 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change between the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots; the login page remains the same with no navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_7 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_8 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login form remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. The user is still on the login screen without any indication of successful login or error messages. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_9 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212553_b546aa_10 | traj_20260609_212553_b546aa | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Pro Python Developer with 20 years of Experience" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065557 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login interface remains the same, with no navigation or content updates evident after the action. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212626_a4a174_0 | traj_20260609_212626_a4a174 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Seeking SDE positions" | click 6 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065589 | false | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212626_a4a174_1 | traj_20260609_212626_a4a174 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Seeking SDE positions" | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065589 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no navigation or content updates. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212626_a4a174_2 | traj_20260609_212626_a4a174 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Seeking SDE positions" | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065589 | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The login screen remains the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212626_a4a174_3 | traj_20260609_212626_a4a174 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Seeking SDE positions" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065589 | true | The page displays an error message indicating that the password field must be filled out, suggesting that the login attempt was incomplete. The username field remains empty, and the login interface is still visible without any navigation to a new page. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: error shown
ERROR: error or blocker shown | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_0 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 6 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | false | There is no visible change between the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots; the login page remains the same, indicating that the action did not result in any observable state transition. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_1 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_2 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The login interface remains the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_3 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | The page remains on the login screen, but the input fields for the username and password are now empty, indicating that the previous input has been cleared. There are no other visible changes or errors displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_4 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change between the BEFORE and AFTER screenshots; the login page remains the same with no updates to content or navigation. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_5 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The login screen remains the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_6 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_8 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page after the action; the login screen remains the same with no updates to content or navigation. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_7 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page state; the login screen remains the same with no new content or navigation occurring. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_9 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action, as the login screen remains the same with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212637_95565f_10 | traj_20260609_212637_95565f | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Freelance Web Developer" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065599 | true | There is no visible change in the page after the action; the login screen remains the same with no updates or transitions to a new state. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0_0 | traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Awesome Prompt Artist" | click 6 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065631 | false | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The login screen remains the same, with no indication that the bio was updated. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0_1 | traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Awesome Prompt Artist" | click 8 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065631 | true | There is no visible change in the page content or layout after the action. The login interface remains the same, with no new information or updates displayed. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: none
ERROR: none | ||
traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0_3 | traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Awesome Prompt Artist" | click 11 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065631 | true | The login form displayed an error message indicating that the username field must be filled out, while the password field remains empty. No navigation or content changes occurred beyond this validation prompt. | CHANGED: yes
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: error shown
ERROR: error or blocker shown | ||
traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0_2 | traj_20260609_212708_4dd0d0 | webarena-reddit | Change my reddit bio to "Awesome Prompt Artist" | click 9 | http://john4.stanford.edu:8999/login?_cookie_check=1781065631 | true | The page remains on the login screen, but the password field is now filled in, indicating that the user has entered their password. There are no other visible changes to the content or layout of the page. | CHANGED: no
NAV: none
CONTENT: none
UI: focus change
ERROR: none |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
browser-world-models: WebArena reddit transitions
Browser state transitions collected by running the 106 official WebArena reddit tasks against a self-hosted, reproducible WebArena (Postmill) instance (rootless Apptainer on SLURM). Each row: before/after screenshots, the Set-of-Marks action between them, the task goal, and LLM-judge next-state labels in two target formats (free prose and a fixed CHANGED/NAV/CONTENT/UI/ERROR template).
- ~726 transitions / 110 trajectories / 1 site (Postmill "reddit"), no-op rate ~0.49
- Labels: gpt-4o-mini judge from (before, action, after); simulator trains on (before, action) -> label
- Pipeline + training/eval code: https://github.com/photomz/browser-world-models (PR #4)
- Companion pilot set (live web, 44 sites): sudac/browser-world-models-transitions
Collected 2026-06-10. Single-site reproducible complement to the live-web pilot set.
- Downloads last month
- 58