inputs stringlengths 395 847 | targets stringclasses 12
values | _template_idx int64 0 9 | _task_source stringclasses 1
value | _task_name stringclasses 1
value | _template_type stringclasses 2
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Part 1. Definition
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Part 2. Example
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Answer: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Part 3. Exercise
topic: Animal testing
argument: Allegations of animal abuse are reviewed by pier board.
Answer: | no | 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: Libertarianism
argument: Libertarians oppose all restrictions on freedom of speech
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Tibet independence
argument: How could China have liberated Tibet in 1949 if it claims prior sovereignty.
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Polygamy
argument: Polygamy is traumatizing and depressing for wives
[EX A]: | yes
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Polygamy
argument: Polygamy is traumatizing and depressing for wives
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Ex Input:
topic: Enhanced interrogation techniques
argument: Torture to save lives has a substantial body of support among publics:
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Full-body scanners at airports
argument: Some scanners use software, not eyes, to detect potential weapons.
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Death penalty
argument: It is impossible to determine that deterrence is not working
Ex Output:
| no
| 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Dollarization
argument: Dollarization helps encourage foreign investment
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Public health insurance option
argument: There are not enough votes to pass a public insurance plan.
Answer: no
Question: topic: Death penalty
argument: The death penalty is often motivated by discrimination
Answer: | yes
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Solar energy
argument: The recovery/payback period can be very short.
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Earmarks
argument: Earmarks have already been significantly reformed
A: no
****
Q: topic: Tibet independence
argument: The right to self-determination must be offered sparingly to avoid international instability.
A: | yes
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Hydrogen vehicles
argument: Electric car battery technology and costs are improving rapidly
A: no
****
Q: topic: Abortion
argument: If a fetus was defined as a person, the legal shifts would be too dramatic
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Withdrawing from Iraq
argument: Mending relations with countries that opposed the war would make it easier to fight the war on terror.
A: | no
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example is below.
Q: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
A: yes
Rationale: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Withdrawing from Iraq
argument: Mending relations with countries that opposed the war would make it easier to fight the war on terror.
A: | no | 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Falkland Islands, return of
argument: Relations with Argentina are not important to Britain.
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Mandatory calorie counts on menus
argument: Calorie counts eliminate ability of restaurants to be spontaneous.
[A]: yes
[Q]: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: The implications of the DC handgun ban are not supported nationwide.
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Tibet independence
argument: China violated Tibet autonomy as called for in Seventeen Point Agreement
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Public health insurance option
argument: Public insurance would stifle medical innovation and advancement
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Dollarization
argument: Dollarization will not help nations with sound economic policies
Answer: | no
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example is below.
Q: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
A: yes
Rationale: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Banning vuvuzela horns at the 2010 World Cup
argument: Guests at World Cup should embrace S. African vuvuzela tradition.
A: | no | 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Alternative measures can be taken in place of a ban to stem crime and murder.
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Libertarianism
argument: Libertarians oppose all restrictions on freedom of speech
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Kangaroo culling in Australia
argument: The Code of Practice in the ACT helps ensures culls are humane.
[EX A]: | no
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example Input: topic: Falkland Islands, return of
argument: Relations with Argentina are not important to Britain.
Example Output: no
Example Input: topic: Animal testing
argument: Tested animals are treated humanely.
Example Output: no
Example Input: topic: Animal testing
argument: Animals endure tremendous stress from being locked up.
Example Output: | yes
| 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Legalization of Marijuana
argument: Some train and plane tragedies were connected with marijuana use.
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Part 2. Example
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Answer: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Part 3. Exercise
topic: Solar energy
argument: The recovery/payback period can be very short.
Answer: | yes | 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Mandatory calorie counts on menus
argument: It is difficult for restaurants to keep calorie counts consistent.
| Solution: no | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Gay marriage
argument: Gay parenting is just as good as straight parenting
no
topic: Catholic Church contraception policy
argument: Removing Church objections to condoms would increase attendance at Church.
yes
topic: Solar energy
argument: The recovery/payback period can be very short.
| yes
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Vehicle fuel economy standards
argument: Fuel economy standards foster innovation and jobs
| Solution: no | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Input: Consider Input: topic: Election of judges
argument: Judicial elections need not be designed as partisan.
Output: no
Input: Consider Input: topic: Public health insurance option
argument: Public insurance would stifle medical innovation and advancement
Output: yes
Input: Consider Input: topic: Wave power
argument: Oceans corrode wave power systems, which is costly
| Output: yes
| 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Output: yes
The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input case for you: topic: Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 US elections
argument: It is unclear who should pay for mail re-votes in Mich and Florida
Output: | yes | 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Input: Consider Input: topic: Tibet independence
argument: Protecting Tibetan culture by opposing modernization is wrongheaded.
Output: no
Input: Consider Input: topic: Prostitution
argument: State resources should not be wasted fighting prostitution
Output: no
Input: Consider Input: topic: US offshore oil drilling
argument: Greater conservation is more important than offshore oil drilling
| Output: yes
| 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Ex Input:
topic: International Criminal Court
argument: The ICC risks heavy politicization of prosecution
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Polygamy
argument: Polygamy is common in some apes; from which humans descended
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Seattle deep-bore tunnel
argument: Development after removing viaduct will pay for tunnel.
Ex Output:
| no
| 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
question:
topic: Animal testing
argument: Allegations of animal abuse are reviewed by pier board.
answer:
no
question:
topic: Constitutionality of US health insurance mandates
argument: Driving is not a choice for many; buying insurance is mandatory.
answer:
no
question:
topic: European missile defense
argument: Missile defense systems are becoming effective and reliable
answer:
| no
| 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution is here: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this: topic: Osama Bin Laden Sea Burial
argument: Islamic law flexible to special burials such as Bin Laden's.
Solution: | no | 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example input: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example output: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Geoengineering, solar shading
argument: Solar shading may warm the tropopause and lower stratosphere.
A: | yes | 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Law school
argument: Legal work requires sitting at a desk for long hours.
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Instant replay in baseball
argument: Instant replay does not diminish human element of baseball
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Prostitution
argument: By worsening HIV/AIDS, prostitution will devastate societies
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example input: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example output: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Election of judges
argument: Judicial elections need not be designed as partisan.
A: | no | 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
PROBLEM: topic: Affirmative action
argument: Diversity is supplimentary to goal of fairness.
SOLUTION: no
PROBLEM: topic: Vegetarianism
argument: Dominion and meat-eating can and should be excercised responsibly.
SOLUTION: no
PROBLEM: topic: Criminalization of Holocaust denial
argument: Holocaust deniers' claim of no major loss of Jewish lives is false
SOLUTION: | no
| 8 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Output: yes
The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input case for you: topic: 700 mile US Mexico border fence
argument: A border fence would create an incentive for illegal immigrants to remain inside a country
Output: | yes | 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Abortion
argument: The Hippocratic oath forbids doctors from performing abortions
Solution: | no | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Animal testing
argument: Allegations of animal abuse are reviewed by pier board.
A: no
****
Q: topic: Election of judges
argument: Elected justices are corruptly influenced by campaign funders
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Animal testing
argument: Bible says harming animals is equivalent to harming humans
A: | no
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Let me give you an example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
The answer to this example can be: yes
Here is why: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
OK. solve this:
topic: Prostitution
argument: State resources should not be wasted fighting prostitution
Answer: | no | 8 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Ex Input:
topic: Vegetarianism
argument: Dominion and meat-eating can and should be excercised responsibly.
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Dollarization
argument: Dollarization will not help nations with sound economic policies
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: EU constitution reform treaty (Lisbon Treaty)
argument: Opponents of the Lisbon Treaty often spread misinformation
Ex Output:
| yes
| 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Graduated response antipiracy laws
argument: General statements supporting graduated response
no
topic: Animal testing
argument: The number of animals used in experiments should be reduced by.
no
topic: Animal testing
argument: The number of animals used in experiments should be reduced by.
| no
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Reason: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this instance: topic: Banning cell phones in cars
argument: More difficult to enforce hands-free cell phone ban
Student: | no | 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Lowering US drinking age from 21 to 18
argument: Safer roads with 21 drinking laws outweighs all trade-offs
Solution: | yes | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Libertarianism
argument: Libertarians oppose all restrictions on freedom of speech
Solution: | no | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Hunting for sport
argument: Evolutionary science debunks the idea of human dominion over animals
Solution: | no | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Prostitution
argument: Legalization will increase prostitution and subsequently worsen public health.
[A]: yes
[Q]: topic: Medical marijuana dispensaries
argument: The State is justified in protecting individuals from themselves
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Carbon capture and storage
argument: Climate change is best solved by energy efficiency, not CCS
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example is below.
Q: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
A: yes
Rationale: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Abortion
argument: Abortion may have a positive or neutral impact on the emotions of the women
A: | no | 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Corporate personhood
argument: How do corps. exercise right to life, marriage, etc?
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Nuclear energy
argument: Concentration of power in nuclear is economical.
| Solution: no | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: 2nd amendment combines right to militia and individual arms
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Earmarks
argument: Earmarks have already been significantly reformed
no
topic: Libertarianism
argument: Libertarians oppose all restrictions on freedom of speech
no
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: 2nd amendment combines right to militia and individual arms
| yes
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Reason: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this instance: topic: Israeli raid on Gaza flotilla
argument: Israeli raid in international waters violates i-law
Student: | yes | 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: Law school
argument: Legal work requires sitting at a desk for long hours.
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Corporate free speech
argument: More spending in elections undermines public confidence
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Israeli raid on Gaza flotilla
argument: Israeli raid in international waters violates i-law
[EX A]: | yes
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Hunting for sport
argument: Evolutionary science debunks the idea of human dominion over animals
no
topic: Tibet independence
argument: The United Nations does charter discourages disruptions of national unity such as a move to Tibetan Independence.
no
topic: Assisted suicide
argument: Euthanasia is mainly utilized by non-vulnerable, well-educated groups
| yes
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Output: yes
The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input case for you: topic: Funding for space exploration
argument: Manned missions force space-craft to have greater weight-bearing capacities for rocks.
Output: | no | 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: Dollarization
argument: Dollarization will not help nations with sound economic policies
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Hydroelectric dams
argument: Dams last over a hundred years; good return on investment
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Gay marriage
argument: Acceptance of gay marriage should not be imposed on citizens
[EX A]: | no
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example input: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example output: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Withdrawing from Iraq
argument: Prolonging the Iraq War will permanently damaged the US military
A: | yes | 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
question:
topic: Bush economic stimulus plan
argument: Tax Rate Cuts, Not Tax Rebates, Stimulate the Economy
answer:
yes
question:
topic: Lowering US drinking age from 21 to 18
argument: Safer roads with 21 drinking laws outweighs all trade-offs
answer:
yes
question:
topic: Withdrawing from Iraq
argument: Prolonging the Iraq War will permanently damaged the US military
answer:
| yes
| 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example is below.
Q: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
A: yes
Rationale: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Tibet independence
argument: China violated Tibet autonomy as called for in Seventeen Point Agreement
A: | yes | 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: Osama Bin Laden Sea Burial
argument: Islamic law flexible to special burials such as Bin Laden's.
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Tibet independence
argument: The right to self-determination must be offered sparingly to avoid international instability.
[EX A]: yes
[EX Q]: topic: Tibet independence
argument: China violated Tibet autonomy as called for in Seventeen Point Agreement
[EX A]: | yes
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Gays in the US military
argument: Most members of US military support ban on gays
Solution: | no | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Full-body scanners at airports
argument: Some scanners use software, not eyes, to detect potential weapons.
Solution: | no | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Single-payer universal health care
argument: US health care costs more because Americans pay to avoid waiting.
[A]: yes
[Q]: topic: Corporate free speech
argument: More spending in elections undermines public confidence
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Full-body scanners at airports
argument: Some scanners use software, not eyes, to detect potential weapons.
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Animal testing
argument: The number of animals used in experiments should be reduced by.
Answer: no
Question: topic: Nuclear energy
argument: Concentration of power in nuclear is economical.
Answer: no
Question: topic: Animal testing
argument: Allegations of animal abuse are reviewed by pier board.
Answer: | no
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example input: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example output: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Catholic Church contraception policy
argument: Removing Church objections to condoms would increase attendance at Church.
A: | yes | 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Reason: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this instance: topic: Manned mission to Mars
argument: Martian dust is a major risk to a manned mission
Student: | yes | 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example input: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example output: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Death penalty
argument: Capital punishment best prepares an evil soul for the after life
A: | yes | 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Input: Consider Input: topic: Abortion
argument: Abortion may have a positive or neutral impact on the emotions of the women
Output: no
Input: Consider Input: topic: Nuclear energy
argument: Nuclear energy economies of scale are improving
Output: no
Input: Consider Input: topic: Death penalty
argument: Capital punishment best prepares an evil soul for the after life
| Output: yes
| 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Tibet independence
argument: The right to self-determination must be offered sparingly to avoid international instability.
| Solution: yes | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution is here: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this: topic: Medical marijuana dispensaries
argument: Legalizing medical marijuana does not increase use and abuse
Solution: | no | 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Hunting for sport
argument: Evolutionary science debunks the idea of human dominion over animals
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Hunting for sport
argument: Hunting is dangerous, injuring and killing many humans.
[A]: yes
[Q]: topic: Airport security profiling
argument: Profiling will help avoid invasive scanners and pat-downs.
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Mandatory calorie counts on menus
argument: Calorie counts eliminate ability of restaurants to be spontaneous.
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Medical marijuana dispensaries
argument: More money for other sectors
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Tibet independence
argument: Tibet can follow the East Timor model to achieving independence
A: | no
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Part 2. Example
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Answer: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Part 3. Exercise
topic: Rebuilding New Orleans
argument: Global warming & stronger hurricanes will destroy new New Orleans
Answer: | yes | 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Israeli raid on Gaza flotilla
argument: Israeli raid in international waters violates i-law
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Bush economic stimulus plan
argument: Tax Rate Cuts, Not Tax Rebates, Stimulate the Economy
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Rebuilding New Orleans
argument: Global warming & stronger hurricanes will destroy new New Orleans
A: | yes
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Enhanced interrogation techniques
argument: Torture to save lives has a substantial body of support among publics:
Answer: no
Question: topic: Bush economic stimulus plan
argument: Tax Rate Cuts, Not Tax Rebates, Stimulate the Economy
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Vegetarianism
argument: Vegetarians are healthy due to their health-consciousness not vegetarianism.
Answer: | no
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution is here: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this: topic: Instant replay in baseball
argument: Instant replay does not diminish human element of baseball
Solution: | no | 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Input: Consider Input: topic: Tidal energy
argument: Tidal turbines can kill marine wildlife.
Output: yes
Input: Consider Input: topic: Mandatory calorie counts on menus
argument: Calorie counts eliminate ability of restaurants to be spontaneous.
Output: yes
Input: Consider Input: topic: Banning vuvuzela horns at the 2010 World Cup
argument: Guests at World Cup should embrace S. African vuvuzela tradition.
| Output: no
| 2 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Random sobriety tests for drivers
argument: Police will use breath tests as excuse for unreasonable searches
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Output: yes
The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input case for you: topic: Legalization of Marijuana
argument: Marijuana use can lead to cancer
Output: | yes | 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Funding for space exploration
argument: Manned missions force space-craft to have greater weight-bearing capacities for rocks.
Answer: no
Question: topic: New START Treaty
argument: Delay risks dangerous non-ratification.
Answer: no
Question: topic: Random sobriety tests for drivers
argument: Police will use breath tests as excuse for unreasonable searches
Answer: | yes
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Ex Input:
topic: Legalization of drugs
argument: Forbidden fruit concept is nonsense.
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Network neutrality
argument: Insufficient broadband market choice to deter bad behavior
Ex Output:
no
Ex Input:
topic: Ban on human reproductive cloning
argument: Cloning will involve the creation of children for predetermined roles.
Ex Output:
| yes
| 1 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Election of judges
argument: Judicial elections need not be designed as partisan.
Answer: no
Question: topic: Single-payer universal health care
argument: Universal health care lowers long-term health costs
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Public health insurance option
argument: Public insurance would stifle medical innovation and advancement
Answer: | yes
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: Gay marriage
argument: Acceptance of gay marriage should not be imposed on citizens
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Michigan and Florida delegates in 2008 US elections
argument: Republican control of Michigan legislature makes Democratic primary re-vote unlikely
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Ground zero mosque
argument: Defending mosque honors constitution first responders were protecting.
[EX A]: | no
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Natural gas vehicles
argument: Natural gas utilities have a long record of safety
Solution: | no | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Part 2. Example
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Answer: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Part 3. Exercise
topic: Child beauty pageants
argument: Pageants teach kids to follow rules and play fair.
Answer: | yes | 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution is here: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this: topic: Legalization of adult incest
argument: Offspring of first-cousins have a low chance of defects
Solution: | yes | 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Right to bear arms in the US
argument: America's modern military makes the militia unnecessary for national security.
no
topic: Israeli military assault in Gaza
argument: Proportional response from Israel only prolongs conflict
yes
topic: Abortion
argument: If a fetus was defined as a person, the legal shifts would be too dramatic
| yes
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Kyoto Protocol
argument: It is unimportant for the US to join Kyoto now
Solution: | no | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Medical marijuana dispensaries
argument: That marijuana is herbal does not mean it is safe
Solution: | no | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution is here: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Now, solve this: topic: Public health insurance option
argument: Public insurance would stifle medical innovation and advancement
Solution: | yes | 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Part 2. Example
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Answer: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Part 3. Exercise
topic: Prostitution
argument: Legalizing prostitution won't substantially reduce HIV/AIDS risks
Answer: | no | 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[EX Q]: topic: US offshore oil drilling
argument: Greater conservation is more important than offshore oil drilling
[EX A]: yes
[EX Q]: topic: Animal testing
argument: Alternatives cannot replace animal testing for certain objectives
[EX A]: no
[EX Q]: topic: Kyoto Protocol
argument: Opponents of Kyoto are pandering to the energy industry
[EX A]: | no
| 6 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Why? The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
New input: topic: Constitutionality of US health insurance mandates
argument: Driving is not a choice for many; buying insurance is mandatory.
Solution: | no | 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Withdrawing from Iraq
argument: Prolonging the Iraq War will permanently damaged the US military
Answer: yes
Question: topic: 700 mile US Mexico border fence
argument: A border fence would create an incentive for illegal immigrants to remain inside a country
Answer: yes
Question: topic: Constitutionality of US health insurance mandates
argument: Driving is not a choice for many; buying insurance is mandatory.
Answer: | no
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Tibet independence
argument: China is highly unlikely to agree to any negotiations without ruling out Tibet independence
no
topic: Catholic Church contraception policy
argument: Undoing ban on condoms would prevent schisms in Church.
yes
topic: Natural gas
argument: Natural gas has very diverse applications in the home.
| no
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
topic: Death penalty
argument: The death penalty is often motivated by discrimination
yes
topic: Random sobriety tests for drivers
argument: Police will use breath tests as excuse for unreasonable searches
yes
topic: Three Gorges Dam
argument: The Three Gorges Dam is a cause of corruption.
| yes
| 0 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
question:
topic: Tibet independence
argument: Protecting Tibetan culture by opposing modernization is wrongheaded.
answer:
no
question:
topic: Prostitution
argument: State resources should not be wasted fighting prostitution
answer:
no
question:
topic: Corporate free speech
argument: More spending in elections undermines public confidence
answer:
| no
| 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example Input: topic: Graduated response antipiracy laws
argument: Graduated response helps avoid litigating against consumers.
Example Output: no
Example Input: topic: Is Wikipedia valuable?
argument: Wikipedia is not for individual prose, but superior collective knowledge.
Example Output: no
Example Input: topic: European Union Expansion
argument: Integration is not prevented by EU expansion.
Example Output: | no
| 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example Input: topic: Infant male circumcision
argument: Circumcision shortens the penis slightly
Example Output: yes
Example Input: topic: Falkland Islands, return of
argument: Strategically, the islands is a NATO airbase in the south Atlantic.
Example Output: no
Example Input: topic: Single-payer universal health care
argument: Universal health care lowers long-term health costs
Example Output: | yes
| 3 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
[Q]: topic: Animal testing
argument: Allegations of animal abuse are reviewed by pier board.
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: European Union Expansion
argument: Integration is not prevented by EU expansion.
[A]: no
[Q]: topic: Falkland Islands, return of
argument: Relations with Argentina are not important to Britain.
[A]: | no
| 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Assassination of a Dictator
argument: Assassinations protect publics from terrorism; even while it's hard to measure
| Solution: yes | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
See one example below:
Problem: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Solution: yes
Explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Cluster bomb ban
argument: Cluster bomb ban will put US soldiers at risk
Solution: | yes | 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
One example is below.
Q: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
A: yes
Rationale: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Q: topic: Dollarization
argument: The UK would benefit from dollarization
A: | no | 9 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Q: topic: Child beauty pageants
argument: Pageants teach kids to follow rules and play fair.
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Abortion
argument: Pro-life militant groups act violently in opposition to abortion.
A: yes
****
Q: topic: Dollarization
argument: The UK would benefit from dollarization
A: | no
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
--------
Question: topic: Gays in the US military
argument: Most members of US military support ban on gays
Answer: no
Question: topic: Polygamy
argument: Polygamy is traumatizing and depressing for wives
Answer: yes
Question: topic: High-speed rail
argument: High-speed trains: costly govt project in search of need
Answer: | no
| 7 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Let me give you an example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
The answer to this example can be: yes
Here is why: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
OK. solve this:
topic: College football playoffs
argument: More teams win and finish season happy in BCS
Answer: | no | 8 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a topic and an argument. Your task is to answer whether the topic and the argument are related or not. A related argument should provide more details about the outcomes of the topic. If the argument refers to or suggests a consequence related to that topic, answer with "yes"; otherwise, answer with "no".
Example: topic: DC handgun ban
argument: Worldwide the ownership of handguns has been correlated with higher homicide rates
Example solution: yes
Example explanation: The argument is refering to homicide rates as a consequence of handgun ownership. So, the answer should be "yes".
Problem: topic: Tidal energy
argument: Tidal turbines can kill marine wildlife.
| Solution: yes | 5 | NIv2 | task514_argument_consequence_classification | fs_opt |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.