inputs stringlengths 324 1.11k | targets stringclasses 12
values | _template_idx int64 0 9 | _task_source stringclasses 1
value | _task_name stringclasses 1
value | _template_type stringclasses 2
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Ex Input:
claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.
perspective: For optimum nervous and digestive health, b12 from meat is ideal.
Ex Output:
undermine
Ex Input:
claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.
perspective: The embargo prevents the people of Cuba from joining the digital age by cutting them off from technology, and restricts the electronic flow of information to the island.
Ex Output:
undermine
Ex Input:
claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.
perspective: one point that is always not mentioned is the EU is part of the New World Order
Ex Output:
| undermine
| 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.
perspective: Chess is one of the popular sport that should be represented at the Olympic.
Solution: | support | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[EX Q]: claim: There is life after death.
perspective: Life after death is strongly stated in the bible.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: Bottled water should be banned.
perspective: With plastic container being so prevalent banning plastic water bottles will not reduce plastic waste.
[EX A]: undermine
[EX Q]: claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.
perspective: Chess is one of the popular sport that should be represented at the Olympic.
[EX A]: | support
| 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.
perspective: A vegetarian diet helps build healthy bones because vegetarians absorb more calcium than meat eaters.
Solution: | support | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example input: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example output: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.
perspective: one point that is always not mentioned is the EU is part of the New World Order
A: | undermine | 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example Input: claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.
perspective: Learning is always worthwhile.
Example Output: undermine
Example Input: claim: Chess must be at the Olympics.
perspective: chess should be included in the list of Olympic sport
Example Output: support
Example Input: claim: Golf is a Sport.
perspective: Skill is required for a person to be proficient in golf doesn't make it a sport.
Example Output: | undermine
| 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example solution: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.
perspective: People should be allowed to take their leisure at their own convenience and not on the basis of religious decree
| Solution: undermine | 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: Technological advancement promotes materialistic society.
perspective: "Materialistic" by whose standards - and why would technology make people more materialistic than what they already are?
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.
perspective: The UK can be independed
Output: support
Input: Consider Input: claim: Keep the Sabbath as a Day of Rest.
perspective: People should be allowed to take their leisure at their own convenience and not on the basis of religious decree
| Output: undermine
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Why? Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input: claim: Major league baseball should continue to allow collisions at home plate.
perspective: One of the things that is part of baseball is having collisions
Solution: | support | 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.
perspective: drones are able to be more focused limiting collateral damage
Output: | support | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example solution: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: permit the use of performance enhancing drugs in professional sports.
perspective: Sports will become even more dangerous for athletes if they are allowed to take performance enhancing drugs.
| Solution: undermine | 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[EX Q]: claim: The United States should maintain its embargo against Cuba.
perspective: Sanctions harm the Cuban people.
[EX A]: undermine
[EX Q]: claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.
perspective: With no funding, PNA terrorism and anti-Semitism will be prevented.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.
perspective: Tablets enable students to cut corners or cheat on schoolwork.
[EX A]: | undermine
| 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: The Internet must be censored.
perspective: As an extensive form of media, the Internet should be subject to regulation just as other forms of media are.
Solution: | support | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.
perspective: The use of animals in sport demeans humans
Solution: | support | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
--------
Question: claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.
perspective: Gun control laws would prevent citizens from protecting themselves from foreign invaders.
Answer: undermine
Question: claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.
perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would reduce poverty.
Answer: support
Question: claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.
perspective: The use of animals in sport demeans humans
Answer: | support
| 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Paparazzi and press intrude too much into celebrities lives.
perspective: A celebrities job is to entertain, when did watching a real life marriage fall apart or a real life person in depression become entertaining?
A: | support | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Q: claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.
perspective: DC is unique and individuals should not have the right to bear arms.
A: support
****
Q: claim: Endangered species should be protected.
perspective: The term "endangered" is inconsistently applied
A: undermine
****
Q: claim: The Internet must be censored.
perspective: As an extensive form of media, the Internet should be subject to regulation just as other forms of media are.
A: | support
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Let me give you an example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
The answer to this example can be: undermine
Here is why: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
OK. solve this:
claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.
perspective: Proliferation of nuclear weapons increases the chances of nuclear accidents
Answer: | undermine | 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[EX Q]: claim: Handguns must be banned in Washington D.C.
perspective: DC is unique and individuals should not have the right to bear arms.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: It is a good idea to have a system of participatory democracy.
perspective: Participatory Democracy Facilitates the Misrepresentation of Issues
[EX A]: undermine
[EX Q]: claim: Make all museums free of charge.
perspective: Funding for museums is wasteful
[EX A]: | undermine
| 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: punishment should fit the criminal.
perspective: Just punishment will lead to less criminals re-offending.
Answer: | support | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example Input: claim: Books should have content warnings.
perspective: Danger of censorship.
Example Output: undermine
Example Input: claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.
perspective: Intercepted evidence could be incredibly useful for both prosecution and defence cases in many trials.
Example Output: support
Example Input: claim: Prostitution Should Be Legal.
perspective: People can choose their sexual consumption.
Example Output: | support
| 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: The use of child performers should be banned.
perspective: Some child performers may be exploited by industry executives.
Output: | support | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
--------
Question: claim: Performing tests on animals must be banned.
perspective: Animals don’t have human rights
Answer: undermine
Question: claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.
perspective: Cultures cannot determine news.
Answer: undermine
Question: claim: It is crucial to support the development of a missile defence system.
perspective: Ballistic missile attacks can be counteracted by a missile defense shield.
Answer: | support
| 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: The EU, USA and other western donors should not fund any Palestinian government in which terrorist organisations participate.
perspective: With no funding, PNA terrorism and anti-Semitism will be prevented.
support
claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.
perspective: real life violent behaviors may be stimulated by video games
support
claim: Compensation should be paid for those who have had their culture appropriated.
perspective: cultural appropriation damage can potentialy be reversed through compensation
| support
| 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: The US should immediately close Guantanamo Bay.
perspective: The conditions at Guantanamo violate prisoners' basic rights.
Answer: | support | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[EX Q]: claim: Parents have to be allowed to monitor their children's online and mobile communications.
perspective: Parents can determine which websites children visit.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: Increased taxes are good for America.
perspective: Everyone should have the resources to live a healthy, productive life.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: It should be allowed to have military recruitment in schools.
perspective: Military recruitment in schools provides more propaganda than it does education.
[EX A]: | undermine
| 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[Q]: claim: Forced marriage should be banned.
perspective: Forced marriage is a barrier to integration
[A]: support
[Q]: claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.
perspective: Students should learn creationist throeries from all religions.
[A]: support
[Q]: claim: The use of child performers should be banned.
perspective: Some child performers may be exploited by industry executives.
[A]: | support
| 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Why? Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input: claim: We should make education compulsory to degree level.
perspective: compulsory studying may remove young people from the workforce
Solution: | undermine | 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[EX Q]: claim: Wire-tapped and ‘intercepted’ evidence must be allowed as admissible in court.
perspective: Intercepted evidence could be incredibly useful for both prosecution and defence cases in many trials.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.
perspective: The environment is worsened by overpopulation.
[EX A]: support
[EX Q]: claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.
perspective: Modern teenagers do not relate to Shakespearian plays
[EX A]: | undermine
| 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
PROBLEM: claim: We must have weapons inspectors leave Syria.
perspective: One step in the direction of peace.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.
perspective: Social media has been linked to stress and problems in personal relationships in the real world.
SOLUTION: undermine
PROBLEM: claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.
perspective: Having a new leader allow new ideas and thoughts in the office.
SOLUTION: | support
| 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
PROBLEM: claim: Western democracies should openly try to circumvent Internet censorship in oppressive regimes.
perspective: This policy alienates the oppressive regimes and stifles the change that discourse and positive interaction can bring
SOLUTION: undermine
PROBLEM: claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.
perspective: College graduates do better financially.
SOLUTION: undermine
PROBLEM: claim: Homework is a waste of time.
perspective: There needs to be a balance for kids between mental and physical stimulation.
SOLUTION: | support
| 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example input: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example output: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Tuition Fees Should Be Increased.
perspective: For the quality of education given it is a small price to pay.
A: | support | 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Romeo and Juliet do promote knife crime.
perspective: Modern teenagers do not relate to Shakespearian plays
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: The use of child performers should be banned.
perspective: Being a performer can make the child physically vulnerable
Answer: | support | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Cultural property residing in museums must be returned to its place of origin.
perspective: Scholars will have better access to artefacts, and more opportunities for study and collaboration, if they are stored in the west
A: | undermine | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.
perspective: the education of children will be hindered by corporal punishment
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
question:
claim: We must have a criminal DNA database.
perspective: Time spent tracking down suspects can be reduced with a database of DNA.
answer:
support
question:
claim: Receiving multiple vaccines are safe.
perspective: Vaccinations have to past rigorous testing before and after approval
answer:
support
question:
claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.
perspective: the education of children will be hindered by corporal punishment
answer:
| undermine
| 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.
perspective: People who enjoy a standard of living that allows them to be healthy and productive will decrease drug abuse.
Output: | support | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Reason: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this instance: claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.
perspective: Unreasonable commitment to expect of people
Student: | support | 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
--------
Question: claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.
perspective: Voters have a right to know the background of their would-be representatives, including financial background
Answer: support
Question: claim: The use of animals as objects of sport and entertainment should be banned.
perspective: Bullfighting is a form of animal torture
Answer: support
Question: claim: Force the media to display, promote and report women’s sport equally to men’s sport.
perspective: Encouraging future female athletes
Answer: | support
| 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: More gun control laws should be enacted.
perspective: Gun control laws would prevent citizens from protecting themselves from foreign invaders.
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.
perspective: Social media use can harm students' chances to be admitted to colleges
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.
perspective: discrimination in sport should be removed
| Output: support
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
question:
claim: History has no place in the classroom.
perspective: history repeats itself if not known
answer:
undermine
question:
claim: Israel's 2008-2009 military operations against Gaza were justified.
perspective: The operations are self-defenses, and thus can be justified.
answer:
support
question:
claim: The world should go vegan.
perspective: Eating meat is part of the cycle of life.
answer:
| undermine
| 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
question:
claim: Violent video games cause violent crime.
perspective: Video games are content that has a right to be censored for the mass majority's public safety.
answer:
support
question:
claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.
perspective: National security should come before freedom of information
answer:
undermine
question:
claim: America should have universal healthcare.
perspective: Universal healthcare is just too expensive.
answer:
| support
| 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Ex Input:
claim: The world should go vegan.
perspective: Animals will still die even if everyone were to follow a vegetarian diet.
Ex Output:
undermine
Ex Input:
claim: Jerusalem should be divided.
perspective: Dividing Jerusalem would harm Israeli society:
Ex Output:
undermine
Ex Input:
claim: Restrictions must be imposed on overseas players in football.
perspective: The improvement of quality of the national team is likely.
Ex Output:
| support
| 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Gender quotas in the EU are advantageous for the economies of member states.
perspective: Quota-led gender equality in executive boards will help shape a gender sensitive and highly performing business environment.
Solution: | support | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Q: claim: During riots it might make sense to block access to social messaging networks.
perspective: It is better to monitor riots through the social media rioters are using
A: undermine
****
Q: claim: History as a subject in school is needed.
perspective: History teaching will reflect the erroneous preconceptions and aims of those who set the curriculum
A: undermine
****
Q: claim: News organisations should be free to exclude news of homosexuality where it causes offence to their viewers.
perspective: The job of a journalist is to report the world and events as they see them. Cultural sensibilities do not alter the fact that these events have happened.
A: | undermine
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Let me give you an example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
The answer to this example can be: undermine
Here is why: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
OK. solve this:
claim: Golf is a Sport.
perspective: The definition of a game is a better match to golf than the definition of a sport.
Answer: | undermine | 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Let me give you an example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
The answer to this example can be: undermine
Here is why: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
OK. solve this:
claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.
perspective: Those in the arts can increase their audience using social media.
Answer: | support | 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
question:
claim: All Americans should have the right (be entitled) to health care.
perspective: Providing a right to health care could create a doctor shortage.
answer:
undermine
question:
claim: Children should do part time and summer work.
perspective: They will have the satisfaction of a job well done.
answer:
support
question:
claim: Golf is a Sport.
perspective: The definition of a game is a better match to golf than the definition of a sport.
answer:
| undermine
| 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.
perspective: Uniform policies save valuable class time because they are easier to enforce than a standard dress code.
Answer: | support | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[Q]: claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.
perspective: A smoker should be allowed to smoke in any place that they have a choice to go to.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: Privacy Online is Important.
perspective: Only wrong-doers benefit from internet privacy.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory.
perspective: Uniform policies save valuable class time because they are easier to enforce than a standard dress code.
[A]: | support
| 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: The money we spend on our Olympic medal count is money well spent.
perspective: If a nation hosts the Olympics, it will give new life to the local economy.
Output: | support | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Reason: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this instance: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: It is dangerous to censor art.
Student: | undermine | 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.
perspective: A vote cast by someone who does not want to vote is unlikely to be based on careful consideration.
Output: | undermine | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: The full financial history of all candidates for political office must be posted online.
perspective: Voters have a right to know the background of their would-be representatives, including financial background
support
claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.
perspective: Some people will be distressed by the removal of their loved-ones’ organs
undermine
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: It is dangerous to censor art.
| undermine
| 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.
perspective: Vegetarians have average lifespans
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[Q]: claim: Wind power should be a primary focus of future energy supply.
perspective: Animal habitats are threatened by the turbines used in wind power.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.
perspective: Tablets pose a greater risk to personal security as they are more prone to theft.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: Disclose previous convictions in court.
perspective: This motion will result in a bias in trial.
[A]: | undermine
| 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Q: claim: The drinking age should be lowered from 21 to a younger age.
perspective: State governments should have the right to establish a lower legal drinking age that reflects their unique demographics, legal context, and history.
A: support
****
Q: claim: The world should go vegan.
perspective: Meat is the most convenient protein source available.
A: undermine
****
Q: claim: Police body cameras should be allowed.
perspective: What risks are there to individuals if police wear body cameras.
A: | undermine
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Given the task definition, example input & output, solve the new input case.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Output: undermine
Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input case for you: claim: Marriage is an outdated institution.
perspective: Marriage represents a legal bond which protects both parties in a relationship
Output: | undermine | 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Humans should eat meat.
perspective: It if fine to eat animals.
Solution: | support | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: We must grant those diagnosed with terminal illnesses the right to access treatments that have not completed clinical testing.
perspective: This policy enhances the role of drug reps and advertising, at the cost of evidence-based medicine
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: Abolish collective bargaining rights for unions.
perspective: In order to have voices heard, collective bargaining is needed.
Answer: | undermine | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.
perspective: ID cards will help combat illegal working and reduce illegal immigration to the UK
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Ex Input:
claim: Sikh school pupils should be allowed to carry ceremonial daggers.
perspective: symbols for religious benefit bothers no one
Ex Output:
support
Ex Input:
claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.
perspective: The cost of printing textbooks vs getting them on a tablet means there is a 50-60% reduction in price to get them on a tablet than printed.
Ex Output:
support
Ex Input:
claim: ID cards and the National Identity Register should be scrapped.
perspective: ID cards will help combat illegal working and reduce illegal immigration to the UK
Ex Output:
| undermine
| 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: Everyone Should Automatically Be Opted into an Organ Donation Scheme.
perspective: What if a doctor decides to 'let you go' to get an organ?
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Joe Calzaghe deserves to be recognized as one of the greatest boxers of all time.
perspective: No way. Out of his five "good" fights, he lost four of them.
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Allow women to compete in the same leagues as men.
perspective: Women must accept the same risks as men if they want to be judged on an equal scale.
| Output: support
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
instruction:
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
question:
claim: Homework should be banned.
perspective: Yes, it should.
answer:
support
question:
claim: The ICC is biased against Africa.
perspective: Africa is overtly prosecuted
answer:
support
question:
claim: Newspapers Are a Thing of the Past.
perspective: Newspapers will adapt to the modern world.
answer:
| undermine
| 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.
perspective: Allowing torture will make it an every day procedure.
Solution: | undermine | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Q: claim: The right to anonymous posting on the internet should be protected by law.
perspective: Anonymity online allows for free speech.
A: support
****
Q: claim: The UK Should Leave the European Union.
perspective: Leaving the EU would mean leaving their security services too
A: undermine
****
Q: claim: We should use torture to obtain information from suspected terrorists.
perspective: Allowing torture will make it an every day procedure.
A: | undermine
****
| 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example input: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example output: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Junk Food Should Be Banned.
perspective: The frequency of heart disease in schools could be lowered by banning junk food.
A: | support | 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Reason: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this instance: claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.
perspective: Many people use social media to bully people.
Student: | support | 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
PROBLEM: claim: Homework should be banned.
perspective: Homework doesn't help low-income students succeed.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Should Turkey Be Accepted In The EU.
perspective: As a matter of precedent, Turkey should be allowed into the EU.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Teachers must be banned from interacting with students via social networking websites.
perspective: Many people use social media to bully people.
SOLUTION: | support
| 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.
perspective: Federal United States are better off economically.
A: | support | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example Input: claim: Voting should be compulsory in the UK.
perspective: Voting is a civic duty
Example Output: support
Example Input: claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.
perspective: Science is grounded in fact whereas religion is not.
Example Output: undermine
Example Input: claim: Dictatorship Is the Best Path to Development.
perspective: Dictatorship is a good breeding ground for personal discipline and order
Example Output: | support
| 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Teacher: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Teacher: Now, understand the problem? If you are still confused, see the following example:
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Reason: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this instance: claim: College education is worth it.
perspective: College degrees do not guarantee learning or job preparation.
Student: | undermine | 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Let me give you an example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
The answer to this example can be: undermine
Here is why: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
OK. solve this:
claim: Fast Food Advertising Should Be Banned.
perspective: There are alternative methods of distributing the toys.
Answer: | undermine | 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: Homework is a waste of time.
perspective: Homework allows students to explore and learn beyond the instruction they are given in the classroom.
Answer: | undermine | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Why? Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input: claim: Social networking sites are good for our society.
perspective: Social media has been found to be used for criminal activity.
Solution: | undermine | 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: We must enforce term limits on the legislative branch of government.
perspective: The longer a single leader remains in power, the more entrenched his grip becomes, and the more likely he is to use his office to his personal advantage.
Solution: | support | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example Input: claim: Grant the EU a permanent seat on the UN Security Council.
perspective: The UNSC will only be seen as legitimate if it is representative
Example Output: support
Example Input: claim: Federal States are better than unitary nations.
perspective: Being a federal state helps large states deal with divergent economic performance
Example Output: support
Example Input: claim: Creationism should be discussed in school science lessons.
perspective: Creationism should not be taught because it is not based on factual science.
Example Output: | undermine
| 3 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example solution: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: Religion In Itself Is A Purely Positive Force In The World.
perspective: Religion Does NOT Cause War.
| Solution: support | 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: All countries should have the right to pursue a nuclear defence.
perspective: To use nuclear weapons in defense of the nation is lawful for all countries.
A: | support | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: The federal minimum wage should be increased.
perspective: Increasing the minimum wage would force businesses to lay off employees and raise unemployment levels.
Solution: | undermine | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: There should be no permanent members of the UN Security Council.
perspective: It would make the UNSC more effective and efficient
Output: support
Input: Consider Input: claim: Provision of higher education must be funded by taxing graduates.
perspective: Graduates may move abroad to avoid tax payments
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.
perspective: people immitate video games.
| Output: support
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[Q]: claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.
perspective: Bottled water is a healthy alternative to sugar drinks.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: Space Exploration Is a Waste of Money.
perspective: The cost isn't actually very high
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.
perspective: I think they should have these rights.
[A]: | support
| 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Detailed Instructions: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
See one example below:
Problem: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: All drugs should be decriminalised.
perspective: Why is it legitimate for the government to ban drugs
Solution: | support | 4 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
Part 1. Definition
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Part 2. Example
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Answer: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Part 3. Exercise
claim: Homework should be banned.
perspective: Yes Homework Should Have A Limit
Answer: | support | 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: social networking sites should be banned at the workplaces.
perspective: Job-seekers may find work with social media sites.
A: | undermine | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.
perspective: Continuing with the Drone Strikes in the United States , would combat any Terrorists Network and plan to attack the country
Solution: | support | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: Tablets should replace textbooks in K-12 schools.
perspective: Tablets help to improve student achievement on standardized tests.
Output: support
Input: Consider Input: claim: Ghana’s ban on smoking in public places is a model for Africa.
perspective: Smoking is a human right.
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: It is time to stop buying bottled water.
perspective: The expense of bottled water is much greater than tap water.
| Output: support
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
You will be given a definition of a task first, then an example. Follow the example to solve a new instance of the task.
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution: undermine
Why? Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
New input: claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.
perspective: Drone strikes are carried out with the collaboration and encouragement of local governments, and make those countries safer.
Solution: | support | 0 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Example solution: undermine
Example explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Problem: claim: Encourage fewer people to go to university.
perspective: Many recent college graduates are un- or underemployed.
| Solution: support | 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
[Q]: claim: We should encourage building the Hyperloop.
perspective: The Hyperloop will be affordable for consumers.
[A]: support
[Q]: claim: Teachers Should Have The Right To Punish Pupils Physically If The Parents Consent.
perspective: Parental consent would create two 'classes’ of pupil.
[A]: undermine
[Q]: claim: The Spread of Nuclear Weapons: More may be better.
perspective: Other countries could strike against those developing nuclear weapons to protect themselves.
[A]: | undermine
| 5 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
Solution is here: undermine
Explanation: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Now, solve this: claim: Housewives should be paid for their work.
perspective: Being paid as a housewife promotes more positive images
Solution: | support | 6 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
PROBLEM: claim: Rain Man is such a bad image of autism.
perspective: Rain Man portrays a type of Autism, but it shouldn't stereotype all people who have Autism
SOLUTION: undermine
PROBLEM: claim: University education should be free.
perspective: Free university provides equal opportunities to all which is a right of individuals.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Voting should become compulsory.
perspective: Other places have successfully introduced compulsory voting.
SOLUTION: | support
| 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Input: Consider Input: claim: The leaking of military documents by Anat Kamm was justified.
perspective: National security should come before freedom of information
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: The United States should keep daylight saving time.
perspective: Daylight savings time is expensive in us
Output: undermine
Input: Consider Input: claim: Drones Should Be Used to Take Out Enemy Combatants.
perspective: Drones protect our military from enemies
| Output: support
| 2 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Let me give you an example: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
The answer to this example can be: undermine
Here is why: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
OK. solve this:
claim: School Day Should Be Extended.
perspective: So much easier for parents!
Answer: | support | 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
TASK DEFINITION: In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
PROBLEM: claim: Same sex relationships should have the same legal status as heterosexual relationships under EU law.
perspective: Same-Sex marriages should have the same legal protections as regular marriages.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Everyone should go vegetarian.
perspective: Rainforests are destroyed to support animals used for food.
SOLUTION: support
PROBLEM: claim: Smoking should be banned in public places.
perspective: Pack labelling or taxation a better alternative
SOLUTION: | undermine
| 8 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
--------
Question: claim: College education is worth it.
perspective: Going to college provides many opportunities to network.
Answer: support
Question: claim: 1-child policy for every single country in the world!.
perspective: The punishment for failing to follow the rules would infringe on women's right to control their own bodies.
Answer: undermine
Question: claim: High taxes are necessary for an effective state.
perspective: Pays for common programs
Answer: | support
| 7 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
Ex Input:
claim: Parents should introduce children to alcohol (in moderation) at an early age.
perspective: Allowing 18- to 20-year-olds to drink alcohol in regulated environments with supervision would decrease unsafe drinking activity.
Ex Output:
support
Ex Input:
claim: 16 year olds should be able to vote at presidental elections.
perspective: This would complicate elections.
Ex Output:
undermine
Ex Input:
claim: Violent Video Games Contribute to Youth Violence.
perspective: Violent video games have been shown to have positive effect on kindness and cooperative behavior.
Ex Output:
| undermine
| 1 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
In this task you will be given a claim and a perspective. You should determine whether that perspective supports or undermines the claim. If the perspective could possibly convince someone with different view, it is supporting, otherwise it is undermining.
One example is below.
Q: claim: Music containing lyrics that glorify violent and criminal lifestyles should be banned.
perspective: hip hop artists have a right to free speech
A: undermine
Rationale: Musicians having a right to free speech clearly undermines the claim for putting constraints on their lyrics.
Q: claim: Mind Sports Such as Chess, Quizzing and Debating Should Be Olympic Sports.
perspective: Mind sports have been around for centuries and are competitive.
A: | support | 9 | NIv2 | task738_perspectrum_classification | fs_opt |
End of preview. Expand in Data Studio
README.md exists but content is empty.
- Downloads last month
- 6