reviewId
int64
363k
588k
userId
int64
33.9k
15.9M
itemId
int64
1
1.42M
rating
float64
1
10
title
stringlengths
1
10.9k
⌀
content
stringlengths
81
11.6k
⌀
419,508
1,609,079
4,740
4
Typhoon : A lot of wind and hot air .
I saw ' The Typhoon ' in October 2006 at the Cinema Muto film festival in Sacile , Italy . The festival screened a print from Eastman House , restored via funding from the ( U . S . ) National Endowment for the Arts . The film's title is mostly symbolic , referring either to tempestuous emotions or to the implacable to...
418,828
1,609,079
20,436
4
He's the prettiest girl on the football team
Like quite a few other films which someone has described on the IMDb site as ' lost ' , ' The Sophomore ' is very much among the living . I attended a public screening of this film at the American Museum of the Moving Image , on the site of Paramount's old Astoria Studio . Despite its title , ' The Sophomore ' is not a...
419,490
1,609,079
365,009
4
Rube's boobs : Tex Avery did it better
Reuben Lucius ' Rube ' Goldberg is remembered for his wildly implausible comic-strip contraptions , but he was a man of many talents . By 1916 ( at the time he made ' The Boob Weekly ' ) , he had already published three book-length collections of his comic strips , sheet music for a popular song , and a card game . Gol...
419,439
1,609,079
6,703
4
Never trust a belle named Beulah .
Earlier this week , I had the bad luck to be in the wrong place at the wrong time . To take my mind off what happened , I've dug out the notes I took several years ago when screening some old movies , intending to transfer those notes into IMDb postings . Lo and behold , the first set of notes I grabbed were for ' Frid...
419,163
1,609,079
10,621
4
The regiment's darling
Elsie Janis was a child star in vaudeville : extremely talented and vivacious , she sang and danced and told jokes with equal facility . During the Great War ( by now in her late twenties ) she performed for the troops very close to the front lines . She appeared in a few of the very early Vitaphone talking-film shorts...
418,855
1,609,079
24,296
4
. . . but not daring enough
' The Man Who Dared ' is an awkward film . It is presented as a work of fiction , but the plot line is clearly inspired by the true story of Anton Cermak , the son of East European immigrants who overcame his impoverished childhood to become mayor of Chicago despite rampant municipal corruption and voter fraud . In 193...
419,665
1,609,079
20,395
4
Is zat so ? Sez who ?
James Gleason is one of the most fondly remembered character actors from Hollywood's golden age . I consistently enjoy his screen work , but he's not on my personal list of all-time favourite character players : Gleason worked in many films , but I find his performances too similar and predictable from one film to the ...
419,205
1,609,079
384,496
4
Paul Lynde upstages Gene Kelly !
The talented dancer Sandy Duncan has worked in film and television , yet has achieved her greatest success on the musical stage . She's hardly one of my favourites ; I find her chipmunk voice more than slightly annoying , and even though she's a lithe and graceful dancer I don't find her very attractive . But her talen...
418,535
1,609,079
159,755
4
One good scene for Clyde and Noah .
In California in the early 1980s , I interviewed Clyde Cook ( from " Brizzo " , Down Under ) near the end of his long life . He had a fascinating career , performing in American vaudeville as the Kangaroo Boy , and arriving in New York City just in time for the 1919 Actors ' Equity strike . In his prime , Clyde Cook's ...
418,453
1,609,079
182,989
4
Not much historic value .
It's hard to believe that Americans needed any propaganda in the Second World War to encourage them to support the fight against Nazism . However , up until Pearl Harbour , this was the case . Many Americans took an isolationist attitude , believing that events in Europe were none of their business . Some German-Americ...
419,380
1,609,079
25,960
4
Fritz Lang's ex-wife writes ' I Love Lucy '
The oddly-named Betty Bird ( her real name ? ) was a Viennese actress who played frothy roles in pre-war films ; her early death was due to the deprived circumstances in wartime Austria following the Anschluss . IMDb lists Betty Bird in the casts of several American films of the late silent era , but I'm certain that t...
419,301
1,609,079
16,519
4
When you find out , tell the rest of us .
Englishman Reginald Denny had a hugely successful career in American silent films ( in which his public-school English accent went unheard ) , playing brash young Americans who were firmly in the Harold Lloyd mould . In the sound era Denny's career tapered off into character roles , and he is now utterly forgotten . Du...
418,491
1,609,079
18,457
4
Oy , oy , oy ! Mine daughter loves a goy !
Mary Philbin deserves at least a permanent footnote in movie history , as the actress who memorably unmasked the Phantom of the Opera in Lon Chaney's greatest film . She also gave a fine performance as the blind heroine in ' The Man Who Laughs ' , directed by the brilliant Paul Leni . Apart from these two films and ' T...
419,069
1,609,079
425,840
4
The titular chest
' Chest of Fortune ' ( quiet in the back , there ! ) is an American film from the Kalem ( K-L-M ) Studio , which was the first Yank film studio to publicise the real names of its actors . Before Kalem , all movie actors were either anonymous or required to emote under house names which remained the property of their st...
418,793
1,609,079
20,899
4
Put this cat to sleep .
' Forty Winks ' is one of the very last Felix the Cat cartoons from his original ( Otto Messmer ) period , but it's so crude that I mistook it for one of his very early efforts . The toon is technically a talkie ; it was released with a soundtrack , but the audio consists entirely of unsynchronised noises and ' rhubarb...
418,668
1,609,079
20,987
4
Hardly their best work .
' Hook , Line and Sinker ' is the very generic title of this very generic comedy , starring Wheeler & Woolsey , who are very nearly the most generic comedy team of all time . ( That dubious honour goes to the Ritz Brothers . ) I consistently enjoy watching Wheeler & Woolsey , yet I frankly find them neither very good n...
419,167
1,609,079
14,145
4
The French are revolting .
I Will Repay is based on one of the numerous Scarlet Pimpernel novels by Baroness Orczy , which I haven't read . I don't know how faithful this film is to its source novel , much less how accurate either of them is in regard to the historic names and events that are freely mentioned throughout the proceedings . We ar...
419,611
1,609,079
20,956
4
Boop-a-doop bootleggers
' Heads Up ' stars Helen Kane , who is now remembered only in parody as the prototype for Betty Boop . The animated character in the Fleischer cartoons is blatantly similar to Helen Kane's screen persona : same hairstyle , same annoying speaking voice ( Kane sounds like Gracie Allen on helium ) , same ' boop-oop-a-doop...
418,955
1,609,079
16,378
4
He dis-sables his wife .
I wonder if this movie was written by a fur fetishist , or possibly by a fur-phobe . Somebody involved in ' Souls for Sables ' seems to be firmly convinced that every woman has an innately evil side that will come to the surface if she acquires a fur coat , especially a sable . Fred Garlan is a working stiff whose wife...
419,286
1,609,079
150,776
4
A shoeshine on his head .
The Paramount animation studio's ongoing series characters - - the annoying Little Lulu , the insufferably twee Casper the Friendly Ghost - - were mostly pretty bad . . . due to their poor animation , repetitive plots and feeble humour . But during this same period , Paramount's animation department also released carto...
418,618
1,609,079
11,827
4
Quick , Watson , the needle !
Charles Ray was a very bland actor who somehow attained nearly front-rank stardom in silent films , playing gormless country lads who somehow made good . Towards the end of the silent era ( when he was getting too old to continue playing this character ) , he financed a starring vehicle for himself which flopped badly ...
419,633
1,609,079
214,592
4
The worst under-cranking I've ever seen .
Chester Conklin and Mack Swain were two stalwart comedians at Mack Sennett's Keystone studio . Swain was a huge , porridge-faced man who starred in a series of Keystone shorts as Ambrose , a dignified blowhard who was often put upon by Conklin as an annoying little man with a walrus moustache . After leaving Keystone ,...
418,343
1,609,079
20,755
4
Ay tank Ay go home now .
Selma Lagerlöf was a phenomenally successful author in her time , writing many novels that were extremely popular in her native Sweden and elsewhere . She won the Nobel Prize for Literature , becoming one of the very first female Nobel laureates . Today , she is remembered primarily for ' The Wonderful Adventures of Ni...
419,480
1,609,079
11,901
4
What's the French for ' depressing ' ?
I saw ' L'Âtre ' ( ' The Hearth ' ) in October 2005 at Le Giornate del Cinema Muto in Sacile , Italy . After its original release ( which received little fanfare ) , ' The Hearth ' was forgotten until a print was discovered in 1984 by Cinémathéque Française . This dead-earnest drama purports to depict the grim life of ...
419,173
1,609,079
11,881
4
Valentino's part is tiny ; O'Brien takes all the screen time .
' The Wonderful Chance ' is even worse than my IMDb colleague Arne Andersen has made it seem . I know from off-site conversations with Arne that he's a major Valentino fan ; unfortunately , he perceives this as a Valentino movie , when in fact Rudy has very much a supporting role . Also , Arne too kindly describes the ...
419,664
1,609,079
49,530
4
Don't drink and drive while dancing " jive "
I never would have watched ' My Teenage Daughter ' if it hadn't been made by Herbert Wilcox and Dame Anna Neagle . This husband / wife team ( he as director , she as star ) churned out a long series of highly profitable British films , most of which were earnest period dramas . ' My Teenage Daughter ' , made in 1956 , ...
419,241
1,609,079
25,106
4
Take me to your lederhosen
' Ferien vom Ich ' ( ' Holiday from Myself ' ) is a weak film , although there are some pleasant exterior shots of the Bavarian countryside . The most interesting thing about this film is that it was made in Germany during the very early days of Hitler's premiership - - before the Third Reich caused most of its unpleas...
418,710
1,609,079
25,119
4
Vienna sausage at its wurst .
This movie's title is almost entirely irrelevant . Ricardo Cortez portrays a suave musician in Vienna ( memo to a previous IMDb reviewer : Vienna is not in Germany ) , who lures young maidens to his bachelor flat by offering to play Stravinsky's ' Firebird ' . Of course , he's a cad with dozens of notches on his bedpos...
419,602
1,609,079
31,302
4
Good tech , mixed cast , poor script .
' 5th Avenue Girl ' doesn't work , but it's a fascinating failure . I was especially impressed by Robert de Grasse's superb camera work . On two different occasions in this movie , Ginger Rogers has a conversation with someone while walking down a steep flight of stairs : in both cases , the camera seamlessly precedes ...
418,564
1,609,079
157,617
4
The count and the cowboy ; or , Pudd'n'head Wilhelm .
I saw ' The Farmer from Texas ' in October 2007 at Le Giornate del Cinema Muto in Pordenone , Italy . The festival screened a print from a German collection ( the Bundesarchiv in Berlin ) that had English intertitles . This film's bizarre title did not encourage me , but I was keenly interested in seeing the movie when...
418,350
1,609,079
55,556
4
Not quite Ibsen , neither noir
In the wide range of roles which Patrick McGoohan has played in his long career , his favourite role was the title character in Henrik Ibsen's " Brand " : a defiant individual who is perceived to be superior to all his neighbours in the village . In ' Two Living , One Dead ' , McGoohan plays a similarly Ibsenesque ' en...
418,345
1,609,079
22,603
4
Fumbled in the end zone
There's a really brilliant , exciting movie in which a football player drops dead in the middle of a football match , in a stadium filled with witnesses . . . and it turns out he's been murdered . That brilliant movie is ' The Arsenal Stadium Mystery ' , a thriller filmed in England in 1939 . ' 70 , 000 Witnesses ' , m...
419,410
1,609,079
354,713
4
Max's stamp of approval
I saw " Lèvres collées " in October 2006 at the Cinema Muto festival in Sacile , Italy . The print was on loan from Filmarchiv in Vienna . For some reason , this French film's English release title was ' Joined Lips ' . In fact , a more faithful translation of the original French title would be ' Glued Lips ' . . . and...
418,771
1,609,079
25,466
4
Weltschmertz on the high seas
I agree with a previous IMDb reviewer , who said that this film is clumsy German propaganda . ( There were times when Nazi propaganda was very subtle and artful . . . but you wouldn't know it here . ) ' A Man Wants to Go to Germany ' does seem intent upon preparing German audiences for another war . . . which is rather...
418,922
1,609,079
22,704
4
Don't buy peanuts from Bimbo .
' Boop-Oop-a-Doop ' is an early Betty Boop cartoon , from the period when the Fleischers were still imitating Disney . The cartoon starts with Betty dancing a shimmy . . . then the camera pulls back to reveal that this is actually a drawing of Betty on a circus banner , rippling in the wind . I laughed as I realised th...
419,369
1,609,079
7,279
4
Hopping hairy husband hollers " Hoy-Hoy-Hoy ! "
This movie's title translates as " Rübezahl's Wedding " . Rübezahl is a figure in German folklore who has no precise English or American equivalent . He's somewhere between Cropsey , the Boogie Man , Springheel Jack and the Green Man of old English folklore . German peasant wives would warn their children to be good , ...
419,067
1,609,079
231,959
4
Down , boy !
In the days of old-time vaudeville , booking agents and theatre managers were constantly seeking ' dumb acts ' . This term had nothing to do with a performer's intellectual appeal ( or lack of it ) . ' Dumb act ' was the vaudeville industry's recognised term for any turn which didn't sing or speak onstage . There was a...
419,025
1,609,079
20,538
4
Bingo's bangles bungle ; she should leave them in the jungle .
I've never understood the ' camp ' phenomenon , with its devotees ( camp followers ? ) who actually prefer to see their cult favourites - - usually larger-than-life actresses - - in bad films , rather than good ones . But Joan Crawford's ' camp ' credentials are unquestioned , and ' Untamed ' is a campfest . Those who ...
419,200
1,609,079
49,213
4
What bait are you using , fraulein ?
' The Fishing-Girl of Bodensee ' is a weak movie , but it's an excellent example of ' Heimatfilm ' , a genre unique to the German-speaking world . ' Heimat ' is the German word for ' country ' or ' homeland ' . Heimatfilmen feature stories that take place largely outdoors , emphasising the countryside of Germany , Aust...
418,740
1,609,079
16,684
4
Cupid kisses the mezuzah
I'm fascinated by the history of the Yiddish theatre world that was active in Second Avenue of New York City during the early twentieth century . Some great actors - - notably Paul Muni - - got their early training in these theatres ' overwrought melodramas and slapstick farces , performed in Yiddish for Jewish audienc...
418,871
1,609,079
179,006
4
Kenneth Tynan uses THAT word .
The very weak joke in the title of this 1965 series is that ( as Britons surely will already know ) in 1965 there was a BBC-1 and a BBC-2 , but no BBC-3 . Now there's a Channel 4 , and two million channels on SkyTV . ' BBC-3 ' made its debut soon after the tremendous revolution of satirical comedy in Britain had begun ...
418,788
1,609,079
18,920
4
Nice to look at , but not funny .
' Futuritzy ' is the interesting title of a Felix the Cat cartoon which isn't very funny , but which contains some interesting visual devices . Most of Otto Messmer's Felix toons relied on a stark palette of black and white : in ' Futuritzy ' there's a subtle range of greys which I found much easier on my eyes . Felix ...
418,408
1,609,079
263,673
4
Stan and Ollie did it better .
The German word ' lumpen ' - - as in ' lumpen proletariat ' - - has no precise English equivalent . It would translate somewhere between ' people of the labouring class ' and ' people who don't matter ' . This film's title ' Lumpenball ' refers to a social event - - a ball - - held by and for such people . ' Lumpenball...
418,332
1,609,079
29,234
4
The merry-go-round broke down .
During Hollywood's golden era , several of the major studios tried to offer a splashy musical comedy that went through annual editions . MGM had ' Broadway Melody of ( insert year ) ' . Paramount had ' The Big Broadcast of ( insert year ) ' . Warners had ' Gold Diggers of ( insert year ) ' . Typically , the date in the...
419,432
1,609,079
5,276
4
Jam and Jerusalem
George Ade ( 1866-1944 ) is now almost entirely forgotten , although his name still turns up in crossword puzzles . In the first two decades of the twentieth century , his humour pieces and plays were phenomenally popular in America . Most of his work has badly dated : for example , his 1902 musical comedy ' The Sultan...
418,878
1,609,079
55,819
4
No remake , but not so bad
The 1962 movie ' The Cabinet of Caligari ' ( notice that the title does NOT include the word ' Doctor ' ) is often described in reference books and horror-movie magazines as a remake of the classic German silent film ' The Cabinet of DOCTOR Caligari ' . It may have been screenwriter Robert Bloch's intention to script a...
419,526
1,609,079
13,606
4
' Skin Deep ' is very shallow .
Milton Sills was a moderately handsome , moderately talented actor who attained a moderately successful level of stardom in silent films . In silent days , the threshold of stardom was a lot lower , because movies could be produced very cheaply , and there were many low-budget production companies dedicated to grinding...
418,720
1,609,079
1,592
4
Turgid soap opera , in early Danish .
I saw this Danish silent film in October 2006 at the Cinema Muto festival in Sacile , Italy . Its title doesn't readily translate into English ; I would render it as ' Expediency ' . Edgar Geheimraaden is a wealthy young man who meets a beautiful shopgirl named Ebba , and they straight away fall in love . They begin to...
418,950
1,609,079
21,449
4
Oy vay , yassuh , wee-wee monsewer .
What a weird movie ! ' The Talk of Hollywood ' ( filmed in New York City ) has a clever title , since it deals with the then-recent talkies revolution in the movie industry . This film is basically a comedy ( although not very funny ) , and the protagonist is a burlesque Jewish stereotype . . . so it's bizarre that , a...
418,907
1,609,079
3,733
4
Who was that lady ?
' A Busy Day ' is proof of something I've often maintained : namely , that no so-called ' lost ' film should ever be considered truly lost unless it was deliberately destroyed . ' A Busy Day ' was unavailable for many decades , and was generally assumed to be lost . . . until an acetate-stock dupe print ( intended for ...
418,379
1,609,079
30,990
4
Mosquitos and mascara , and a phony John O'Hara
' Yellow Jack ' is a goodish , proficiently made Hollywood drama which is weakened by several poor artistic decisions , and rendered absolutely ludicrous by one especially bad decision ( which I'll describe presently ) . The film deals with an inspiring true story in medical history , namely the attempts of the U . S ....
419,523
1,609,079
42,389
4
Gleason and Besser save this movie
' The Desert Hawk ' is a bog-standard adventure epic ( Arabian Nights subclass ) , sorely compromised by its extremely low budget but benefiting from an interesting cast . When I saw that Yvonne De Carlo was the female lead ( in harem trousers , worse luck ) , I was worried this might turn out to be a Maria Montez-type...
419,030
1,609,079
1,167,665
4
Big news : cats are always hungry .
A little girl sits at a table , holding a container of what appears to be some sort of food . Suddenly there's a flash of movement : a tortoiseshell cat , with long hair and a very furry tail , has leapt onto the table . The girl and the cat are clearly friends : she cheerfully feeds the cat little bits of whatever's i...
419,515
1,609,079
273,473
4
I'd sooner see Sully than Seeley .
The husband-and-wife team of Bennie Fields and Blossom Seeley were huge stars in vaudeville , yet they made very few films . As is the case for some other performers of their era ( George M . Cohan , Fanny Brice , Gertrude Lawrence ) the most accessible piece of film footage for Fields and Seeley is the biopic ABOUT th...
418,827
1,609,079
16,958
4
Karloff's most surprising performance
' Her Honour , the Governor ' is a fairly implausible movie inspired by actual events . James Ferguson was governor of Texas during the Great War and for some years thereafter . Throughout his administration , his wife Miriam Amanda Ferguson showed no political ambitions of her own : she was happy to be a wife , a moth...
418,768
1,609,079
23,459
4
. . . and it serves her right , too !
For modern viewers , the title ' She Wanted a Millionaire ' makes this movie sound like a comedy , but it was actually meant to be moralistic : she wanted a millionaire , and look what she got . There's a very judgmental tone hanging over this entire film ; the audience are manipulated to perceive that the female prota...
419,175
1,609,079
896,964
4
Who or what is a Cuban Pete ?
IMDb's reviewer " free2emailus " has made a few errors in reviewing this film : the Three Rhythm Boys are dressed as footmen , not butlers ; the little girl Jean has no mother in this film , off-camera or otherwise . Also , the plot centres on an error : even a Brit like me knows that U . S . income-tax auditors did no...
418,214
1,609,079
16,915
4
Who's a pretty boy , then ?
Elisabeth Bergner is probably best remembered ( in Britain , at least ) for playing Rosalind in ' As You Like It ' , a role for which she spent most of her screen time cross-dressed as Ganymede , the counterfeit boy . She wasn't convincing as a boy in that film , but the theatrical artifice of Shakespeare's verse made ...
418,480
1,609,079
38,643
4
Fritz Lang did it much better
' Inside Job ' is a semi-noir drama , notably for one reason only : this film is the very last credit on the CV of cult-film figure Tod Browning . Although Browning had a serious drinking problem ( partly because he took advantage of free beer shipments for life , a gift from the president of Coors Brewing , whom he ha...
418,258
1,609,079
253,069
4
Scooby-Doo , wo bist du ?
Dolly Haas performed on stage in Europe and on Broadway , and in several films ( including Hitchcock's " I Confess " ) , but her acting career is less significant than the fact that she was the wife of the great caricaturist Al Hirschfeld , and the mother of ' NINA ' whose name so notably appeared in Hirschfeld's drawi...
418,734
1,609,079
15,714
4
Cheese and pickle sandwich
Johnny Hines was dealt with briefly in Walter Kerr's important reference work ' The Silent Clowns ' . His inclusion in that book is justified , but a brief mention is all he deserves . Hines was a third-string comedian in the great days of silent comedy . He tended to play brash go-getters in the Harold Lloyd mould . ....
418,847
1,609,079
68,637
4
Katharine Ross , drop those hot pants
' Get to Know Your Rabbit ' is far from a great movie , but it's a quirky film that tells an unusual story in an original way . Best of all , there's a very sexy performance by Katharine Ross , plus good performances by Orson Welles and several other cast members . I'm surprised that this hasn't become a cult movie . (...
419,289
1,609,079
21,968
5
Dooley truly quite unruly .
Ray ( short for Rachael ) Dooley was an extremely talented Scots-born comedienne who was a Broadway star of the 1920s . Like Christine Baranski , Ray Dooley was ( by contemporary accounts ) that rare female combination of funny and sexy in the same woman . With her angular features and acrobatic agility , Dooley perfor...
418,757
1,609,079
15,332
5
Forget the dog ; let's see more of Edna .
The top-billed performer in ' The Silent Accuser ' is Peter the Great , an Alsatian dog who resembles Rin Tin Tin . . . and this film appears to be MGM's attempt to copy the success of the highly profitable Rin Tin Tin movies . Peter is the faithful canine companion of Jack . When Jack's evil stepbrother Phil murders h...
418,733
1,609,079
15,355
5
And nobody's driving the movie , either .
Johnny Hines was dealt with briefly in Walter Kerr's important reference work ' The Silent Clowns ' . His inclusion in that book is justified , but a brief mention is all he deserves . Hines was a third-string comedian in the great days of silent comedy . He tended to play brash go-getters in the Harold Lloyd mould . ....
419,036
1,609,079
23,848
5
Fast-forward to Rooney's big number
' Broadway to Hollywood ' has a grandiose title and can't live up to it . Nevertheless , this early MGM semi-musical does have some good moments in amongst the soap opera . The most interesting thing about this movie is that Jackie Cooper plays Mickey Rooney's father ! ( They were both child actors at the time , and Co...
418,870
1,609,079
61,308
5
A sobering experience .
I saw ' Twice a Fortnight ' ( which works out to once a week , ha ha ) when it was originally transmitted by the BBC on a weekly basis . The programme lasted precisely five fortnights ( i . e . , ten weekly episodes ) in late 1967 , terminating just before Christmas . In fact , I was a member of the studio audience for...
419,006
1,609,079
26,311
5
Magyar self at home
' Miss Big Shot ' stars Lilli Muráti as Zsuzsa ( pronounced ' ZHOO-zha ' ) , the dark-eyed daughter of the chairman of a Budapest textile factory . When he dies suddenly , Zsuzsa takes over the factory . Intriguingly , this 1935 film makes it quite clear that a young woman is intellectually and emotionally capable of r...
419,456
1,609,079
130,133
5
Hava Nagila
' Halome Ami ' was filmed silent , with a post-dubbed soundtrack , so I'll review the image and the sounds separately . The film consists of travelogue footage of Eretz Israel : the Palestinian homeland of the Jewish people before the nation of Israel was officially recognised . There is some fascinating footage of col...
418,943
1,609,079
13,251
5
' Battling Butler ' on horseback
' The Hottentot ' has strong similarities to Buster Keaton's film ' Battling Butler ' , made a few years later . In both movies , the main character is ( at the beginning ) an ineffectual and clumsy man who coincidentally has the same name as a popular athlete . In both movies , mistaken identity leads the klutz to sub...
418,841
1,609,079
15,219
5
Crude but delightful .
Another " lost " film back from the dead ! I viewed " Peg o ' the Mounted " - - lost for years , but now found again - - at the 2006 Cinema Muto festival in Sacile , Italy . Even more impressively , at the same screening I got to meet this film's star ! Diana Serra Cary , who once performed as ' Baby Peggy ' , is still...
418,908
1,609,079
8,873
5
Leave Xantippe out of this .
Silent-film star Wallace Reid is ( like Roscoe Arbuckle ) unfairly remembered for a scandal which didn't accurately reflect his true life or career . Because Reid usually played clean-cut go-getters on screen , his fans were shocked when his early death revealed the effects of long-term morphine abuse . This was actual...
418,730
1,609,079
214
5
Oh , by jingo !
SPOILER ALERT : Reading this review will take longer than the running time of the movie itself . The Yorkshire-born showman J . Stuart Blackton was an important figure in the early history of American movies . Most of his early films were newsreel-style records of actual current events . . . but their historical value ...
418,887
1,609,079
8,848
5
Accept no imitations .
At the peak of his career , Charlie Chaplin's films were so hugely popular ( and profitable ) that a whole legion of lesser film comedians were imitating him . A few comedians took the gambit of performing Chaplinesque antics while at least maintaining some originality of appearance . The best and best-known example of...
418,213
1,609,079
21,760
5
Jim Nabors gets shot .
The title of this film is never explained ; possibly ' The Conquering Horde ' refers to a cattle stampede . Certainly the stampede sequence in this movie is one of its ( few ) highlights . Taisie Lockhart ( Fay Wray ) and Dan McMasters ( Richard Arlen ) were chaste lovers up until 1861 , when the American Civil War bro...
419,486
1,609,079
147,897
5
What were they thinking ?
Cross-dressing is a fertile subject for comedy , but I tend to cringe when it happens in a cartoon intended for children . Bugs Bunny's penchant for transvestism is strange enough . . . but here in ' Blind Date ' , a cartoon starring Heckle and Jeckle , we have something even more bizarre : forced public feminisation i...
419,169
1,609,079
74,057
5
Insert Gallic shrug here .
The title and subtitle of this French miniseries are " Six Times Two ; Over and under the media " . The " six " refers to the fact that there are six episodes ; the " two " has a double meaning . Each of these episodes is a collaboration between two people : Jean-Luc Godard and his long-time partner Anne-Marie Miéville...
419,058
1,609,079
285,733
5
Fiddling about .
In the 1920s , classical musicians were still popular with the general public rather than being stigmatised as ' long-hairs ' for elitists and snobs . With the coming of talkies , Warner Brothers ' Vitaphone unit ( based in Brooklyn , NY ) were quick to film the performances of classical musicians and opera singers bas...
418,599
1,609,079
307
5
Verging on the Opper attic .
The comic strip ' Happy Hooligan ' was written and drawn by Frederick Burr Opper ( without assistants ) for an impressively long time : 1900 to 1932 . It was the first extremely popular American comic strip , the first major comic strip syndicated by King Features , and the first comic strip to spawn a significant amou...
419,221
1,609,079
17,750
5
Some razzle , but not much dazzle
Yes , the 1927 silent film ' Chicago ' is the same story that became the big-budget Oscar-winning musical of 2002 . ( There was a remake in between , ' Roxie Hart ' : starring Ginger Rogers . ) Apart from the obvious difference that one ' Chicago ' is silent and the other is a musical , both films tell exactly the same...
418,993
1,609,079
21,629
5
You are getting sleepy . . . very sleepy . . .
Many European actors who fled the Nazis brought their talents to Hollywood , usually in supporting roles due to the limitations of their European accents . Siegfried Arno was a star in German comedies who went on to a respectable career in Hollywood as a character comedian in small supporting roles . ' Ein Ausgekochter...
418,548
1,609,079
11,073
5
Afterbirth of a nation
John Barrymore and Ethel Barrymore never entirely abandoned the stage , even after beginning their film careers . However , when their older brother Lionel moved to Hollywood , he gave quits to the theatre forever . . . devoting the rest of his career to movies and radio . During Lionel Barrymore's theatrical career , ...
419,706
1,609,079
330,580
5
Like a bad opera with no music .
The very sensuous actress Regina Badet portrays Leah , a shill who works for a European casino run by a crook , played in an excellent performance by the actor Guy Favieres . According to the intertitles of the print I viewed , the casino owner's name is Govanni . . . aye , that's Govanni , not Giovanni . Shows you how...
419,138
1,609,079
26,385
5
Where's an earthquake when you really need one ?
' Frisco Kid ' was made at Warner Brothers , the studio that most ruthlessly ripped off and recycled its own scripts in thinly-disguised remakes . This movie re-uses elements from ' Barbary Coast ' , another ( and better ) Warners film made the same year ! The barroom brawl in ' Frisco Kid ' seems to be inspired by the...
418,937
1,609,079
17,774
5
That sinking feeling
The English-born Dorothy Mackaill was a silent-film actress who looked stately rather than beautiful . Her voice was not impressive in early sound films . In ' Convoy ' , she plays Sylvia Dodge : a New York society lady in 1917 who is recruited by a Secret Service agent ( ominously known only as Smith ) to befriend Ern...
418,808
1,609,079
14,956
5
Flyweight actor in lightweight story .
The thoroughfare in the title of ' The Great White Way ' is , of course , Broadway . . . which came into its own in 1904 with the opening of Manhattan's subway system . I was eager to see this film , as it includes brief appearances by several prominent newspapermen and society figures of this period . Among others , w...
418,452
1,609,079
887,506
5
The buttons don't reach high enough .
It's a shame that so many Broadway plays and musicals drift into obscurity because they were never filmed . For decades , theatre historians agreed that one of the greatest dance numbers ever staged was Jerome Robbins's second-act opening of ' High Button Shoes ' : a frenzied production number titled ' The Bathing Beau...
418,462
1,609,079
11,102
5
' Deep Purple ' ? More like pale lavender . . .
' The Deep Purple ' is based on a stage play ( about which , more in a moment ) . I was surprised to discover that William Cameron Menzies was this film's art director . . . and disappointed , once I'd seen the results . Menzies was the greatest art director in the history of films , but his work here is a far cry from...
418,901
1,609,079
26,491
5
Waller , Robinson , Le Gon transcend weak material .
' Hooray for Love ' is the great title of this goodish B-musical ( and of one poor song near the closing ) . The best assets of this so-so show are its three African-American performers : the great Fats Waller , the great Bill Robinson , and the very talented ( and pretty ) dancer Jeni Le Gon . In recent years , Ms Le ...
418,987
1,609,079
132,513
5
Soapsuds on the ice , starring Frick & Frack
Figure-skating isn't the most promising basis for a film , nor for an acting career . Esther Williams's movie stardom was based on swimming , but at least MGM could just occasionally hang a decent plot line on that talent . Until somebody makes a movie about Tonya Harding , I don't think I'll ever see a genuinely excit...
419,103
1,609,079
17,672
5
So , THAT'S Mrs Warren's profession !
I was intrigued by the opening credits of ' Beware of Widows ' : this comedy ( not very funny ) is based on a play by somebody named Owen Moore . There can't be very many people with that name , and I can only think of one : the prolific film actor who was also married to Mary Pickford . I was wholly unaware that he'd ...
418,497
1,609,079
9,088
5
Semon second-class
Buster Keaton's ghost-written memoir ' My Wonderful World of Slapstick ' contains a perceptive comment about silent-film comedian Larry Semon : he tended to pack his films with impossible gags that were funny but completely implausible . According to Keaton , audiences laughed harder at Semon than at more plausible com...
418,848
1,609,079
53,109
5
Near-miss , near-musical
' Never Steal Anything Small ' comes tantalisingly close to being a first-rate film , a sparkling musical comedy with some trenchant satirical commentary on the close relationship between politicians , labour unions and organised crime . James Cagney gives an ingratiating performance in what very nearly could have been...
419,237
1,609,079
25,759
5
Hoot mon ! A braw bricht iguana !
I've seen an advert for a video of ' The Secret of the Loch ' which touts this as ' the first sound movie about the Loch Ness Monster ' . . . implying that there were several silent films about Nessie . I'm absolutely certain that not a single movie was made about the Loch Ness creature during the silent-film era . . ....
418,557
1,609,079
18,170
5
Goodbye , Mr Chimps
I saw ' The Monkey Talks ' in October 1998 , at the Pordenone Silent Film Festival in Italy . The main character in ' The Monkey Talks ' is a man who spends most of his time on screen disguised as a chimpanzee . . . and successfully deceiving close observers . Without relying on camera tricks , it's probably impossible...
419,356
1,609,079
24,431
5
Based on a famous murder case .
' The Past of Mary Holmes ' was inspired by a notorious murder case that was never solved . In 1922 , a man and woman were found shot dead in a field in New Jersey . The man was quickly identified as the Reverend Edward Hall , an Episcopal minister married to an heiress . The woman was Eleanor Mills , who sang in Rever...
418,784
1,609,079
148,144
5
Jeckle stops pretending he's English ; Dimwit gets smart .
' Fishing by the Sea ' is the weird and unfunny title of this fairly funny Heckle and Jeckle cartoon , made very early in their development . The magpies ' voices haven't been established yet ; here , Jeckle speaks in a falsetto that doesn't even pretend to be an English accent , while Heckle's prole voice has just a h...
419,413
1,609,079
594
5
Insultin ' the Sultan ; a climactic camel chase !
I saw ' Flugten fra seraillet ' in October 2006 at the Cinema Muto festival in Sacile , Italy ; they screened an excellent print on loan from the Danish Film Institute . The credited male actors are Viggo Larsen , Gustave Lund and Valdemar Petersen . The credited actresses are Clara Nebelong and Maggi Zinn . This movie...
418,274
1,609,079
684
5
proto-Keystone slapstick
A previous IMDb reviewer has stated that Jeanie Macpherson , who appears in this film , was Cecil B . DeMille's wife . That's not correct . Macpherson had a long and significant career as DeMille's favourite scenarist ; she wrote or co-wrote the scripts for many of DeMille's most important films and quite a few of his ...
419,260
1,609,079
25,629
5
Robert Young in his skivvies
' Paris Interlude ' is based on a play by S . J . Perelman and his wife Laura ( nee Weinstein ) . Laura Perelman's chief claim to fame was that she was the sister of the grossly overrated cult author Nathanael West . S . J . Perelman is remembered for co-authoring two Marx Brothers movies and ' Around the World in 80 D...