Datasets:
Formats:
parquet
Languages:
English
Size:
10K - 100K
Tags:
agriculture
plant-disease
crop-disease
vision-language-model
retrieval-augmented-generation
memory
License:
|
Download code/experiments/retriever_pilot/README.md from tirtho149/MACE-Bench: direct link, hf CLI and curl.
- Browser
- Download file 5.15 kB
-
https://huggingface.co/datasets/tirtho149/MACE-Bench/resolve/main/code/experiments/retriever_pilot/README.md
- Command line
-
hf download hf://datasets/tirtho149/MACE-Bench/code/experiments/retriever_pilot/README.md
-
curl -L -o README.md https://huggingface.co/datasets/tirtho149/MACE-Bench/resolve/main/code/experiments/retriever_pilot/README.md
5.15 kB
| # Retriever pilot (branch `retriever-pilot`, 2026-11-17) | |
| Question (Shreyan): can a small neural retrieval function, possibly with weights written by a bigger LLM, replace BM25 in MACE? | |
| Setting: P1 MACE, Sonnet captions, seed 0, K = 4, the same per-query memory banks, 1,600 queries (1,000 IID, 600 | |
| held-out). Retrieval only, no diagnosis call. Proxies: hit@4 (true disease among the four retrieved entries; MACE gains | |
| only on hits), vote (majority label of the four), top-1 label. Equal-crop means (%), paired crop-stratified bootstrap | |
| for the hit@4 difference against BM25. | |
| All retrievers score a (test caption, memory caption) pair from the same 16 features: whole-caption BM25 (the current | |
| retriever), per-field BM25 and Jaccard for the seven caption fields, and organ match. | |
| | Retriever | hit@4 IID | hit@4 held-out | vote IID | vote held-out | top-1 IID | top-1 held-out | hit@4 vs BM25, IID [95% CI] | held-out | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | BM25 (paper) | 83.1 | 73.3 | 55.0 | 43.8 | 53.0 | 40.7 | | | | |
| | Trained linear | 83.4 | 73.3 | 56.0 | 44.5 | 52.6 | 41.7 | +0.3 [-1.5, 2.1] | +0.0 [-2.7, 2.7] | | |
| | Trained MLP (16-16-1) | 82.0 | 73.0 | 55.0 | 43.8 | 51.5 | 40.5 | -1.1 [-3.1, 0.8] | -0.3 [-3.0, 2.3] | | |
| | LLM weights, schema only | 83.1 | 73.7 | 54.2 | 41.0 | 52.1 | 39.8 | +0.0 [-2.2, 2.1] | +0.4 [-3.0, 3.5] | | |
| | LLM weights, schema + memory captions | 82.5 | 73.2 | 54.3 | 41.2 | 51.6 | 41.7 | -0.6 [-2.7, 1.5] | -0.1 [-3.3, 3.0] | | |
| - BM25 here reproduces the recorded P1 retrieval on 1,600/1,600 queries. | |
| - Trained models: leave-one-out pseudo-queries over the 20 memory banks only (74,376 pairs); no query image or label. | |
| - LLM weights: Sonnet writes 16 linear weights per crop (one call per crop and context, 20 calls, USD 0.35). Context A: | |
| feature definitions, crop, disease list. Context B: the same plus the crop's memory captions and labels. | |
| - Finding: no variant moves hit@4 by more than about one point; every interval includes zero. With lexical caption | |
| features, BM25 is already near what a small reweighting can reach, and giving the LLM the memory captions did not help. | |
| Not tested: a network over learned text or image embeddings, LLM-written term weights, and diagnosis accuracy. Run | |
| `python -m experiments.retriever_pilot.pilot` (add `--no-llm` to skip the 20 calls; cached calls cost nothing). | |
| ## Tuning (`tune.py`) | |
| Tuned on a clean validation set, then one look at the 1,600 test queries. Validation: 2,215 training-fold images that are | |
| in the seed-0 K=16 memory but not in the K=4 memory MACE uses, and are never test queries, scored against that K=4 | |
| memory. Search: BM25 k1, b and organ repeat; DINOv2 image similarity added with weight alpha; at most `cap` entries per | |
| disease. 1,296 configs; objective hit@4, then true-disease entries among the four. | |
| | Retriever | config (k1, b, organ x; alpha; cap) | hit@4 IID | hit@4 held-out | true entries IID | held-out | vote IID | vote held-out | hit@4 vs BM25, IID [95% CI] | held-out | | |
| |---|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | BM25 (paper) | (1.2, 0.75, 3); 0; 4 | 83.1 | 73.3 | 1.64 | 1.29 | 55.0 | 43.8 | | | | |
| | Image only (DINOv2) | -; image; 4 | 81.0 | 69.3 | 1.55 | 1.11 | 50.7 | 36.0 | -2.1 [-4.7, 0.5] | -4.0 [-8.0, 0.0] | | |
| | Text + image, no cap | (2.0, 0.3, 0); 1.5; 4 | 86.3 | 74.2 | 1.75 | 1.25 | 60.1 | 40.7 | +3.2 [1.3, 5.2] | +0.8 [-2.0, 3.7] | | |
| | Text + image, one per disease | (2.0, 0.3, 0); 1.5; 1 | 89.3 | 80.3 | 0.89 | 0.80 | 58.3 | 42.7 | +6.2 [4.2, 8.1] | +7.0 [4.2, 9.8] | | |
| - Adding image similarity to BM25 raises IID coverage (+3.2 hit@4, +5 vote) but not held-out (vote drops 3 points). | |
| - One entry per disease is the largest coverage win on both splits, but the VLM then sees each disease once, so the label | |
| majority signal that drives most of MACE's gain disappears. Whether coverage or repetition matters more can only be | |
| settled by a diagnosis run; these are retrieval proxies. | |
| - Retrieved ids for every selected config: `out/tune_retrieved.json`. | |
| ## Diagnosis check (`diag.py`, 200-query efficiency panel, Sonnet, USD 4.32) | |
| Same request as MACE except which four entries are listed. The BM25 arm went through the same code path and hit the | |
| cache of the recorded P1 calls on 200/200 queries with 200/200 identical predictions. | |
| | Method | IID | held-out | vs MACE (BM25), IID [95% CI] | held-out | | |
| |---|---:|---:|---:|---:| | |
| | SAGE | 32.0 | 38.0 | -23.0 [-32.0, -14.0] | -22.0 [-30.0, -14.0] | | |
| | MACE (BM25) | 55.0 | 60.0 | | | | |
| | Text + image retrieval | 56.0 | 63.0 | +1.0 [-5.0, +7.0] | +3.0 [-4.0, +10.0] | | |
| | One entry per disease | 47.0 | 58.0 | -8.0 [-15.0, -1.0] | -2.0 [-10.0, +6.0] | | |
| - The retrieval-coverage win did not become a diagnosis win. One entry per disease raised hit@4 by 6 to 7 points but | |
| lowered IID accuracy by 8: the VLM needs the true label repeated, which matches the paper's finding that the retrieved | |
| labels carry most of the gain. | |
| - Text + image retrieval is directionally positive (+1 IID, +3 held-out) but far inside the noise on 200 queries. | |
| Telling a 1 to 3 point gain apart from zero would need the full 1,600 queries (about USD 25 for this one arm). | |