text stringlengths 0 6.73k |
|---|
nical books, whose equations, fñgures and sometimes even text become pixellated |
when one tries to enlarge them, the IHÃIEX manuscript of the Me Mllenniun |
bdition makes 1Ý possible to create eBooks of the highest quality, in which all |
--- Trang 7 --- |
features on the page (except photographs) can be enlarged without bound and |
retain their precise shapes and sharpness. And the nhønced Electronic Version, |
with its audio and blackboard photos from Feynmans original lectures, and its |
links to other resources, is an innovation that would have given Feynman great |
pleasure. |
IMorweertos oŸ Foggrtrtterrt "s Eoe£mr'os |
These three volumes are a selEcontained pedagogical treatise. They are also a |
historical record of Feynman's 1961-64 undergraduate physics lectures, a course |
required of all Caltech freshmen and sophomores regardless of their majors. |
Readers may wonder, as [ have, how Feynmans lectures impacted the students |
who attended them. Eeynman, in his Preface to these volumes, offered a somewhat |
negative view. “I don”t think I did very well by the students,” he wrote. Matthew |
Sands, in his memoir in Feywman's Tips on Phụsics expressed a far more posifive |
view. Out of curiosity, in spring 2005 I emailed or talked to a quasi-random set |
oŸ 17 students (out of about 150) from Feynman's 1961-63 class—some who had |
great dificulty with the class, and some who mastered it with ease; majors In |
biology, chemistry, engineering, geology, mathematics and astronomy, as well as |
in physics. |
The intervening years might have glazed their memories with a euphoric tỉnt, |
but about 80 percent recall Feynman'”s lectures as highlights of their college years. |
“H was like going to church.” The lectures were “a transformational experience, ” |
“the experience of a lifetime, probably the most important thing I got from |
Caltech.” “[ was a biology major but Feynman's lectures stand out as a high |
point in my undergraduate experience ... though I must admit I couldn't do |
the homework at the time and I hardly turned any of it in” “[ was among the |
least promising of students in this course, and Ï never missed a lecture.... Ï |
remember and can still feel Eeynman's joy of discovery.... His lectures had an |
... emotional impact that was probably lost in the printed Lectures.” |
By contrast, several of the students have negative memories due largely to two |
issues: (1) “You couldn't learn to work the homework problems by attending the |
lectures. Feynman was too slick——=he knew tricks and what approximations could |
be made, and had intuition based on experience and genius that a beginning |
student does not possess.” Feynman and colleagues, aware of this aw ¡in the |
course, addressed it in part with materials that have been incorporated into |
teụwmans Tips on Phụsïcs: three problem-solving lectures by Feynman, and |
--- Trang 8 --- |
a set of exercises and answers assembled by Robert B. Leighton and Rochus |
Vogt. (1) “The insecurity of not knowing what was likely to be discussed in |
the next lecture, the lack of a text book or reference with any connection to |
the lecture material, and consequent inability for us to read ahead, were very |
frustrating.... I found the lectures exciting and understandable in the hall, but |
they were Sanskrit outside [when T tried to reconstruct the details|” 'This problem, |
of course, was solved by these three volumes, the printed version of The Feunman |
Lectures on Phụsics. They became the textbook from which Caltech students |
studied for many years thereafter, and they live on today as one of Feynman's |
greatest legacies. |
A HHistorg, o£ FErraÉ( |
The Feunwman Lectures on Phụsics was produced very quickly by Feynman |
and his co-authors, Robert B. Leighton and Matthew Sands, working from |
and expanding on tape recordings and blackboard photos of Feynman”s course |
lecturesề (both of which are incorporated into the Enhưnccd Electronic Version |
of this Weu Mllennium Edition). Given the hiph speed at which Feynman, |
Leighton and Sands worked, it was inevitable that many errors crept into the first |
edition. Feynman accumulated long lists of claimed errata over the subsequent |
years—errata found by students and faculty at Caltech and by readers around |
the world. In the 1960°s and early 70's, Feynman made time in his intense liíe |
to check most but not all of the claimed errata for Volumes I and II, and insert |
corrections into subsequent printings. But Feynman”s sense of duty never rose |
high enough above the excitement of discovering new things to make him deal |
with the errata in Volume III.† After his untimely death in 1988, lists of errata |
for all three volumes were deposited in the Caltech Archives, and there they lay |
forgotten. |
In 2002 Ralph Leighton (son of the late Robert Leighton and compatriot of |
Feynman) informed me of the old errata and a new long list compiled by Ralph”s |
* Eor descriptions of the genesis of Feynman”s lectures and of these volumes, see Feynmans |
Preface and the Forewords to each of the three volumes, and also Matt Sands" Memoir in |
Feuwmanws Tips on Phụs¿cs, and the Special Preface to the Commemoradtiue Editöion of FLP, |
written in 1989 by David Goodstein and Gerry Neugebauer, which also appears in the 2005 |
Deftnittue Edition. |
† Im 1975, he started checking errata for Volume III but got distracted by other things and |
never finished the task, so no corrections were made. |
--- Trang 9 --- |
triend Michael Gottlieb. Leighton proposed that Caltech produce a new edition |
of The Feunman Lectures with all errata corrected, and publish it alongside a new |
volume of auxiliary material, Feynwmans Tiips on Phụs¿cs, which he and Gottlieb |
WCT€ DI€paring. |
teynman was my hero and a close personal friend. When I saw the lists of |
errata and the content of the proposed new volume, I quickly agreed to oversee |
this project on behalf of Caltech (EFeynman”s long-time academic home, to which |
he, Leighton and Sands had entrusted all rights and responsibilities for 75e |
Feunman Lectures). After a year and a halŸ oŸ meticulous work by Gottlieb, and |
careful serutiny by Dr. Michael Hartl (an outstanding Caltech postdoc who vetted |
all errata plus the new volume), the 2005 Oefimitiue Edilion oƒƑ The Feuuman |
Lectures on Phụsics was born, with about 200 errata corrected and accompanied |
by teunwmans Tips on Phụsics by Feynman, Gottlieb and Leighton. |
T thought that edition was goïng to be “Defnitive”. What I did no antic- |
Ipate was the enthusiastic response of readers around the world to an appeal |
trom Gottlieb to identify further errata, and submit them via a website that |
Gottlieb created and continues to maintain, 7 he Feunwman Lectures Website, |
www. eynmanlectures.info. In the fve years since then, 965 new errata have |
been submitted and survived the meticulous scrutiny of Gottlieb, Hartl, and Nate |
Bode (an outstanding Caltech physics graduate sbudent, who succeeded Hartl |
as Caltech?s vetter of errata). Of these, 965 vetted errata, 80 were corrected in |
the fourth printing of the Defimitiue Edition (August 2006) and the remaining |
885 are correcbed in the first printing of this Neu Mllenmum Edition (332 in |
volume I, 263 in volume II, and 200 in volume TIT). For details of the errata, see |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.