paper_id
stringlengths
10
10
items
listlengths
4
82
gt
float64
1
9.5
8FJ6MOiP91
[ "strength: The paper proposes a simple method to handle imbalanced dataset for regression tasks. The method is straight forward and easy to implement.", "strength: The idea of switching between loss functions during training appears novel, at least in the context of imbalanced regression. The proposed method is s...
3
N1TyUhkvjW
[ "strength: Significant value in improving anomaly detection methods by \"small\" modifications in current methodologies", "strength: Experimental results support the claims of the paper", "strength: Technical sound ideas", "strength: In particular, in unsupervised anomaly detection, a motif to overcome the li...
5
00SnKBGTsz
[ "strength: Tackle a timely and interesting problem.", "strength: Provide the necessary infrastructure for the community to study the problem, opening up opportunities for future contributions.", "strength: Consider various data generation strategies,", "strength: Well-desgined experiments which demonstrate th...
7.5
cya3eEczAx
[ "strength: The topic of the paper is interesting.", "strength: The paper provides a review of related works.", "strength: The proposed work is interesting and aims to tackle a well-known issue arising in the non-differentiability of the loss function in Predict & Optimize.", "strength: The numerical experimen...
1.666667
FtX6oAW7Dd
[ "strength: The paper is well-written and accessible.", "strength: Model selection in PLL is a relevant, underexplored topic.", "strength: The proposed dataset in a realistic PLL setting adds significant value to the PLL literature.", "strength: Despite the model selection criteria's simplicity, the authors es...
7.5