| --- |
| --- |
| license: cc-by-nc-4.0 |
| language: |
| - en |
| pretty_name: BVA Structured Decisions (2019–2025) |
| task_categories: |
| - text-classification |
| - token-classification |
| - text-retrieval |
| - question-answering |
| tags: |
| - legal |
| - law |
| - legal-nlp |
| - veterans-affairs |
| - disability |
| - bva |
| - structured-extraction |
| - administrative-law |
| size_categories: |
| - 1K<n<10K |
| --- |
| |
| # BVA Structured Decisions (2019–2025) |
|
|
| **Structured, issue-level records extracted from U.S. Board of Veterans' Appeals (BVA) decisions** — each decision parsed into its issues, conditions, outcomes, citations, and reasoning, with per-document provenance and completeness flags. Built for training and evaluating legal-AI models on veterans' disability adjudication. |
|
|
| This is a **2900-decision sample**, balanced across **seven years (2019–2025, decisions/year)**, so it's representative of the full corpus rather than skewed to one year. A larger full-corpus release and a commercial license are available (see **Access & licensing** below). |
|
|
| > **Honesty note (please read).** Labels are **silver** (engine-produced, benchmarked against an LLM-labeled reference at ~96% outcome accuracy), **not** human-certified gold. Provenance and completeness ship with every row so you can verify and filter. See **Quality & accuracy**. |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## What's in it |
|
|
| | | | |
| |---|---| |
| | **Decisions** | 2900 |
| | **Years** | 2019–2025 (balanced) | |
| | **Format** | CSV (one row per decision) — 23 columns | |
| | **Coverage** | 99% of rows carry extracted issues and citations; 96% carry reasoning atoms | |
| | **Source** | Public BVA decisions published on va.gov | |
|
|
| ### Outcome distribution (decision-level) |
| `remanded` · `denied` · `granted` · `dismissed` · `reopened` · `withdrawn` |
|
|
| ### Appeals regime |
| `legacy` · `AMA` · `unknown` (tagged from the decision text, not the year). |
|
|
| ### Conditions |
| **107 distinct medical conditions.** Top: back disability (490), knee disability (438), hearing loss (341), arthritis (302), psychiatric disorder (289), PTSD (287), peripheral neuropathy (272), sleep apnea (212), hypertension (195), foot disability (177). |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## Column dictionary |
|
|
| | Column | Description | |
| |---|---| |
| | `doc_id` | BVA citation/docket number (the 2-digit prefix is the fiscal year). | |
| | `source_url` | Link to the original decision on va.gov for independent verification. | |
| | `schema` | Extraction schema used (`bva`). | |
| | `issues` | The appealed issues (pipe-separated). | |
| | `conditions` / `conditions_raw` / `conditions_detailed` / `condition_other` | Canonical condition tokens, raw phrasing, laterality/qualifiers, and an out-of-vocabulary flag. | |
| | `outcomes` | Decision-level dispositions (granted / denied / remanded / dismissed / reopened / withdrawn). | |
| | `outcome_by_issue` | **Each issue tied to its own outcome** (the core training unit). | |
| | `reasoning_by_issue` | Per-issue reasoning atoms (the "why"). | |
| | `reasoning_completeness` | `full` / `partial` / `none` — quality tier for self-selecting a clean slice. | |
| | `reasoning_unfillable` | `True` when the source letter has no reasoning at all (so `none` is expected). | |
| | `regime` / `ama_docket` | Legacy vs. Appeals-Modernization-Act regime + AMA docket flag. | |
| | `citations` | Statutory/regulatory citations (38 U.S.C. / 38 C.F.R.), normalized and deduped. | |
| | `evidence` | Evidence types referenced (VA exam, private opinion, lay statement, etc.). | |
| | `reasoning_atoms` | Canonical reasoning findings (nexus established/not, benefit-of-doubt, duty-to-assist, etc.). | |
| | `judge_dates` | Decision date + Veterans Law Judge. | |
| | `signals_extracted` / `matrix_cells_used` / `avg_route_score` / `char_length` | Extraction telemetry + raw length. | |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## Why it is useful |
|
|
| - **Issue-level supervision.** `outcome_by_issue` and `reasoning_by_issue` link each appealed issue to its disposition and rationale — not just a document-level label. |
| - **Trainable + filterable.** Completeness tiers let you train on the clean `full` slice or use everything; `regime` lets you separate legacy vs. AMA. |
| - **Verifiable.** Every row carries a `source_url` back to the public original. |
| - **Representative.** Balanced across 2019–2025, so temporal/longitudinal splits are honest. |
|
|
| **Intended uses:** training/evaluating models for claim-outcome prediction, issue and citation extraction, legal RAG over veterans' law, and fine-tuning assistants for BVA practice. |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## Quality & accuracy (read before you rely on it) |
|
|
| - **Silver, not gold.** Records are produced by a deterministic extraction engine and benchmarked against an LLM-labeled reference at **~96% outcome-extraction accuracy** (measured on 2019 issues). **Human-verified gold validation is in progress** and not yet reflected here. |
| - **What's well-covered:** issues, conditions, outcomes, citations, and reasoning atoms (96–99% of rows populated). |
| - **Known limits:** the `none`/`partial` reasoning rows are recoverable gaps, not curated blanks; `regime` is `unknown` for many rows where the text doesn't clearly signal it; condition extraction follows a controlled vocabulary (107 tokens) with an `condition_other` flag for the long tail. |
|
|
| Treat the accuracy figure as a **silver benchmark**, and verify against `source_url` for any high-stakes use. |
|
|
| ## “I can provide the full dataset (~350k decisions, 2019–2026) or targeted subsets such as: |
| • All PTSD / mental health cases |
| • Back, knee, leg, hip, and orthopedic disabilities |
| • TDIU and rating increase appeals |
| • Herbicide/Gulf War presumptive claims |
| • Hearing loss / tinnitus |
| Each subset maintains the same structured format with reasoning atoms, per-issue outcomes, etc.” |
| --- |
|
|
| ## Provenance, PII & ethics |
|
|
| - **Source:** BVA decisions are U.S. federal records, published publicly on va.gov. The underlying text is public domain (17 U.S.C. §105); the **structured layer** (this dataset's value-add) is what the license below covers. |
| - **PII:** BVA publishes decisions with appellants de-identified (referred to as "the Veteran"/initials). This release was screened with an automated PII gate (blocks SSN/phone/email/DOB/address). It may still contain incidental names (e.g., judges, place names) inherent to public legal text — review before any redistribution. |
| - **Not legal advice.** This is research/ML data about adjudication patterns, not guidance for any individual claim. |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## Access & licensing |
|
|
| - **License: CC BY-NC 4.0** — free to use for **research and non-commercial** purposes, with attribution. The raw decision text is public domain; the **NC term applies to the structured annotations** in this dataset. |
| - **Commercial use / full corpus:** the full multi-year corpus (and a commercial license) are available separately. **Contact the maintainer** to license it for commercial use. |
|
|
| ### Attribution |
| > BVA Structured Decisions (2019–2025). Structured extraction of public Board of Veterans' Appeals decisions. Derived from va.gov public records; structured layer © the maintainer, released under CC BY-NC 4.0. |
|
|
| --- |
|
|
| ## Changelog |
| - **v1** — 2900 decisions, balanced 2019–2025; 23-column document schema; silver labels (~96% benchmark). |
| --- |
