Datasets:

wzq2005
/

SciGen_Verifier_bench

id large_stringlengths 36 36	messages listlengths 2 2	images listlengths 2 2	question large_stringlengths 141 1.89k	explanation_edit_generation dict
b3a4c97a-cd49-40bf-8567-95091230330e	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/b3a4c97a-cd49-40bf-8567-95091230330e/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/b3a4c97a-cd49-40bf-8567-95091230330e/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a semi-transparent blue fill to the region to the right of the vertical interface to represent the glass medium 2. Draw a horizontal red line through the point of incidence to represent the normal to the interface 3. Overla...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "All requirements are met: a semi-transparent blue fill represents the glass medium, a horizontal red line indicates the normal, denoised orange and blue lines represent the incident and refracted rays, and black dots are placed at the endpoints of the incident ray." }
bf969139-64d0-4ff2-bf25-f8079e9c04c8	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/bf969139-64d0-4ff2-bf25-f8079e9c04c8/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/bf969139-64d0-4ff2-bf25-f8079e9c04c8/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Add a coordinate system near the B(y) graph with y-axis horizontal and B-axis vertical --- Generated Image: <image>	{ "edit": "1. Swap the labels of the green coordinate system so that the horizontal axis is labeled \"y\" and the vertical axis is labeled \"B\".\n2. Reorient the axes if necessary to ensure the horizontal line represents the y-dimension and the vertical line represents the B-field magnitude.", "explanation": "The ...
cab45a61-5c79-4416-80a7-0b63acc54603	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/cab45a61-5c79-4416-80a7-0b63acc54603/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/cab45a61-5c79-4416-80a7-0b63acc54603/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Add two vertical solid lines (adiabats) at S = 1.0 kJ/K and S = 2.2 kJ/K, extending from the hot isotherm to the cold isotherm --- Generated Image: <image>	{ "edit": "1. Change the line style of the two vertical lines at S = 1.0 kJ/K and S = 2.2 kJ/K from dashed to solid.", "explanation": "The vertical lines (adiabats) at S = 1.0 kJ/K and S = 2.2 kJ/K are currently dashed, whereas the target instruction specifies they should be solid lines." }
f39b6002-9e98-40b9-ab70-300c4e9ae020	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/f39b6002-9e98-40b9-ab70-300c4e9ae020/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/f39b6002-9e98-40b9-ab70-300c4e9ae020/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add two vertical dashed lines (adiabats) at S = 1.0 kJ/K and S = 2.2 kJ/K, extending from the hot isotherm to the cold isotherm 2. Draw horizontal lines connecting the ends of the adiabats on the hot and cold isotherms to form ...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The image correctly implements all requirements: vertical dashed lines are placed at S = 1.0 and 2.2 kJ/K, horizontal solid lines connect them to form rectangle ABCD, and points C and D are accurately placed and labeled at the intersections with the cold isotherm." }
615435a0-06dd-41c3-9a97-8b1112325e85	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/615435a0-06dd-41c3-9a97-8b1112325e85/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/615435a0-06dd-41c3-9a97-8b1112325e85/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a coordinate system near the B(y) graph with y-axis vertical and B-axis horizontal 2. Complete the hidden central segment of the B(y) graph by connecting the visible endpoints with a straight line 3. Draw horizontal dashed ...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image successfully incorporates all requested edits: a green coordinate system with vertical y and horizontal B axes is placed near the graph; the central gap in the B(y) plot is bridged with a straight line; orange dashed horizontal lines mark the top and bottom bounds of ...
71b681eb-95e9-4797-b61e-8fffaa19b82f	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/71b681eb-95e9-4797-b61e-8fffaa19b82f/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/71b681eb-95e9-4797-b61e-8fffaa19b82f/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a semi-transparent blue fill to the region to the right of the vertical interface to represent the glass medium 2. Draw a horizontal red line through the point of incidence to represent the normal to the interface 3. Overla...	{ "edit": "1. Denoise the orange incident ray to create a smooth, straight line.\n2. Change the color of the ray inside the glass region to blue and apply denoising.\n3. Adjust the angle of the blue refracted ray so it bends towards the horizontal red normal line.\n4. Add a small black dot at the point of incidence w...
ff242d54-9f9d-41d0-8690-e3ff6aef6afb	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/ff242d54-9f9d-41d0-8690-e3ff6aef6afb/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/ff242d54-9f9d-41d0-8690-e3ff6aef6afb/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a coordinate system near the B(y) graph with y-axis vertical and B-axis horizontal 2. Complete the hidden central segment of the B(y) graph by connecting the visible endpoints with a straight line 3. Draw horizontal dashed ...	{ "edit": "1. Reorient the thick purple line inside the loop to be horizontal, spanning the width of the rectangle, to correctly represent \"w = 0.06 m\".\n2. Connect the two endpoints of the B(y) graph's central gap with a solid straight blue line.", "explanation": "The \"Image to be Fixed\" incorrectly displays t...
a0b6e028-f4d8-427b-9d02-db9957ccc382	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/a0b6e028-f4d8-427b-9d02-db9957ccc382/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/a0b6e028-f4d8-427b-9d02-db9957ccc382/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add two vertical dashed lines (adiabats) at S = 1.0 kJ/K and S = 2.2 kJ/K, extending from the hot isotherm to the cold isotherm 2. Draw horizontal lines connecting the ends of the adiabats on the hot and cold isotherms to form ...	{ "edit": "1. Shift the left vertical dashed line to S = 1.0 kJ/K and the right vertical dashed line to S = 2.2 kJ/K.\n2. Reposition points A and B at the top of these lines (on the 600K isotherm) and points D and C at the bottom (on the 300K isotherm).\n3. Adjust the solid horizontal lines to connect the new positio...
d080dd9e-44ed-4314-9087-d9759dc9a575	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/d080dd9e-44ed-4314-9087-d9759dc9a575/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/d080dd9e-44ed-4314-9087-d9759dc9a575/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw a dashed line representing the normal direction to the membrane at its midpoint 2. Add an arrow indicating the positive normal direction along this line 3. Add a rectangular outline around the membrane segment at the midpo...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The generated image correctly fulfills all requirements: a red dashed line is drawn normal to the membrane's midpoint with an arrow indicating direction, a green rectangular outline highlights the membrane segment at the midpoint, and both elements are accurately labeled as \"n-hat\"...
a5c409cf-bac8-4ed2-be67-a34bdc891f08	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/a5c409cf-bac8-4ed2-be67-a34bdc891f08/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/a5c409cf-bac8-4ed2-be67-a34bdc891f08/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Highlight the band minimum at the Γ point (k=0) with a circular marker 2. Highlight the band maximum at the Brillouin zone edge (k=π/a) with a circular marker 3. Add horizontal dashed reference lines at the energy levels of bot...	{ "edit": "1. Move the circular marker at the center vertical line (k=0) upwards to align with the band maximum and the top horizontal dashed line.\n2. Move the circular marker at the rightmost vertical line (k=π/a) downwards to align with the band minimum and the bottom horizontal dashed line.", "explanation": "Th...
848fc5da-4e04-4346-b5e2-a77952042e21	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/848fc5da-4e04-4346-b5e2-a77952042e21/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/848fc5da-4e04-4346-b5e2-a77952042e21/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Draw a dashed line parallel to the membrane at its midpoint, add an arrow indicating the positive normal direction along this line, add a rectangular outline around the membrane segment at the midpoint, and label the normal direction as "n-hat" and the membrane segment as "membrane". --- **Ge...	{ "edit": "1. Rotate the red dashed line so that it is parallel to the black membrane line, centered at its midpoint.\n2. Realign the red arrow so it points along the direction of this new parallel dashed line.\n3. Reposition the \"n-hat\" label to remain adjacent to the red arrow.\n4. Ensure the green rectangular ou...
aa4681ff-318f-4628-8611-9fdf521039c9	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/aa4681ff-318f-4628-8611-9fdf521039c9/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/aa4681ff-318f-4628-8611-9fdf521039c9/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a semi-transparent blue fill to the region to the right of the vertical interface to represent the glass medium 2. Draw a vertical red line through the point of incidence to represent the normal to the interface 3. Overlay ...	{ "edit": "1. Reorient the red line to be vertical, passing through the point of incidence on the black interface.\n2. Add a small black dot at the point of incidence where the orange incident ray meets the vertical interface.", "explanation": "The red line representing the normal is oriented horizontally in the im...
a9fb2f37-280f-4faa-8922-a3701a74b8e7	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/a9fb2f37-280f-4faa-8922-a3701a74b8e7/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/a9fb2f37-280f-4faa-8922-a3701a74b8e7/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw a dashed line representing the normal direction to the membrane at its midpoint 2. Add an arrow indicating the positive normal direction along this line 3. Add a rectangular outline around the membrane segment at the midpo...	{ "edit": "1. Reverse the direction of the red arrow on the dashed line so it points downwards.\n2. Reposition the \"n-hat\" label to be adjacent to the downward-pointing arrowhead.", "explanation": "The arrow indicating the positive normal direction is pointing upwards, whereas the reference image shows it pointin...
957b0fc0-c8a3-4583-ac60-e453559cc63f	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/957b0fc0-c8a3-4583-ac60-e453559cc63f/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/957b0fc0-c8a3-4583-ac60-e453559cc63f/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a horizontal line at the Fermi energy level \(E_F = 0.38\,\text{eV}\) across the dispersion curve 2. Mark the intersection point of this horizontal line with the dispersion curve \(E(k) = \alpha k^2\) 3. Draw a secant line ...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image accurately fulfills all requirements: a horizontal green line is placed at $E_F = 0.38$ eV, the intersection with the dispersion curve is marked with a black dot, and a magenta secant line is drawn through two points near the intersection to represent the slope $dE/dk...
f92dbfb5-e224-48fc-8c00-08b7ae1a1b62	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/f92dbfb5-e224-48fc-8c00-08b7ae1a1b62/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/f92dbfb5-e224-48fc-8c00-08b7ae1a1b62/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Highlight the band minimum at the Γ point (k=0) with a circular marker 2. Highlight the band maximum at the Brillouin zone edge (k=π/a) with a circular marker 3. Add horizontal dashed reference lines at the energy levels of bot...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The edited image successfully fulfills all requirements: circular markers highlight the band maximum (center) and minimum (right edge), red horizontal dashed lines mark the energy levels of these extrema, and a red vertical measurement bar on the left indicates the energy difference ...
5566b60a-cee4-4979-984f-dc3c5eb59cf4	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/5566b60a-cee4-4979-984f-dc3c5eb59cf4/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/5566b60a-cee4-4979-984f-dc3c5eb59cf4/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a horizontal line at the Fermi energy level \(E_F = 0.38\,\text{eV}\) across the dispersion curve 2. Mark the intersection point of this horizontal line with the dispersion curve \(E(k) = \alpha k^2\) 3. Draw a secant line ...	{ "edit": "1. Relocate the magenta secant line and its two circular endpoints so they are centered around the black intersection point at $E = 0.38$ eV.\n2. Ensure both endpoints of the secant line lie exactly on the blue dispersion curve to correctly represent the local slope.", "explanation": "The magenta secant ...
eb1f499e-c029-46b6-836f-c57c62c68653	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/eb1f499e-c029-46b6-836f-c57c62c68653/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/eb1f499e-c029-46b6-836f-c57c62c68653/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Add a horizontal line at the Fermi energy level \(E_F = 0.4\,\text{eV}\) across the dispersion curve, mark the intersection point with pink dots, and draw a secant line near the intersection point to visually represent the slope \(\frac{\mathrm{d}E}{\mathrm{d}k}\) at the Fermi wavevector. --- ...	{ "edit": "1. Move the horizontal line upward to align exactly with the $0.4\\,\\text{eV}$ mark on the y-axis.\n2. Change the color of the marker at the intersection point from black to pink.\n3. Remove the vertical dashed green line.\n4. Reposition the secant line and its two pink endpoints so they are centered arou...
9a458b1c-4ea7-47b8-86d4-720502f5d308	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/9a458b1c-4ea7-47b8-86d4-720502f5d308/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/9a458b1c-4ea7-47b8-86d4-720502f5d308/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add x-axis tick marks at 1/T values of 0.00280, 0.00300, and 0.00320 with corresponding numeric labels 2. Add y-axis tick marks at ln P values of 9.0, 10.0, and 11.0 with corresponding numeric labels 3. Label the two extreme da...	{ "edit": "Change the x-coordinate in the label for the rightmost data point from \"(x=0.00313, y=8.97)\" to \"(x=0.00312, y=8.97)\".", "explanation": "The label for the rightmost data point displays an x-coordinate of 0.00313, whereas the target instruction specifies it should be 0.00312." }
11e88604-4bd7-44a4-a345-ed9e9b4ba8ea	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/11e88604-4bd7-44a4-a345-ed9e9b4ba8ea/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/11e88604-4bd7-44a4-a345-ed9e9b4ba8ea/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add the tangent line from point D to the sphere, connecting D to the tangent point T 2. Add the radius line from the center O to the tangent point T 3. Add a right angle marker at the tangent point T to indicate the perpendicul...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "All requirements are met: the tangent line from D to the sphere is added, the radius line from O to the tangent point is included, a right-angle marker is correctly placed at the tangent point, and the horizontal reference line at D is maintained." }
f20a0ad0-375e-4e09-aa2c-5eeaac8a87ce	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/f20a0ad0-375e-4e09-aa2c-5eeaac8a87ce/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/f20a0ad0-375e-4e09-aa2c-5eeaac8a87ce/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw the major axis of the ellipse as a dashed line passing through the center, extending beyond both ends of the visible ellipse 2. Draw the minor axis of the ellipse as a dashed line passing through the center, perpendicular ...	{ "edit": "1. Change the line style of the major axis from solid to dashed, matching the style of the minor axis.", "explanation": "The major axis is drawn as a solid line instead of a dashed line, which contradicts the initial instructions and the reference image." }
d7f09b57-b6b7-41b7-8bc8-474c613e27e4	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/d7f09b57-b6b7-41b7-8bc8-474c613e27e4/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/d7f09b57-b6b7-41b7-8bc8-474c613e27e4/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add x-axis tick marks at 1/T values of 0.00280, 0.00300, and 0.00320 with corresponding numeric labels 2. Add y-axis tick marks at ln P values of 9.0, 10.0, and 11.0 with corresponding numeric labels 3. Label the two extreme da...	{ "edit": "1. Add numeric labels \"0.00280\", \"0.00300\", and \"0.00320\" to the x-axis at the appropriate tick mark positions.\n2. Add numeric labels \"9.0\", \"10.0\", and \"11.0\" to the y-axis at the appropriate tick mark positions.", "explanation": "The \"Image to be Fixed\" is missing the numeric labels for ...
ad5c5690-f606-4b04-9fcc-d1853ab2b335	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/ad5c5690-f606-4b04-9fcc-d1853ab2b335/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/ad5c5690-f606-4b04-9fcc-d1853ab2b335/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a line-of-sight (LOS) line between the tops of towers T1 and T2 2. Mark the geometric midpoint between T1 and T2 with a distinct marker at the hill center C 3. Add a vertical clearance indicator at the hill center showing t...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image correctly incorporates all requested edits: a red line-of-sight (LOS) connects towers T1 and T2, a green marker identifies the geometric midpoint at the hill center, and a green vertical arrow indicates the required 5 m clearance above the terrain." }
91d69a33-7aa2-4641-9949-6ecf4cfe2fe9	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/91d69a33-7aa2-4641-9949-6ecf4cfe2fe9/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/91d69a33-7aa2-4641-9949-6ecf4cfe2fe9/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add a line-of-sight (LOS) line between the tops of towers T1 and T2 2. Mark the geometric midpoint between T1 and T2 with a distinct marker at the hill center C 3. Add a vertical clearance indicator at the hill center showing t...	{ "edit": "1. Reverse the direction of the green arrow at the hill center (C) so that it points upwards from the midpoint marker.", "explanation": "The vertical clearance indicator (green arrow) at the hill center is pointing downwards, whereas the reference image shows it pointing upwards to indicate clearance abo...
b88ac08f-908b-4161-9d20-2cd92e715a9b	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/b88ac08f-908b-4161-9d20-2cd92e715a9b/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/b88ac08f-908b-4161-9d20-2cd92e715a9b/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw the tangent line at t=0 with appropriate slope 2. Extend the plateau line at σ∞ across the full width of the graph 3. Mark the intersection point of the tangent line and the plateau line 4. Draw a vertical line from the in...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The generated image correctly implements all requested edits: a tangent line is drawn from $t=0$, the plateau line at $\\sigma_\\infty$ is extended across the graph, their intersection is clearly marked, and a vertical line drops to the time axis with the label $\\tau$." }
bd7bec92-e4cf-488f-a2be-b6b40b46832e	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/bd7bec92-e4cf-488f-a2be-b6b40b46832e/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/bd7bec92-e4cf-488f-a2be-b6b40b46832e/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add the tangent line from point D to the sphere, connecting D to the tangent point T 2. Add the radius line from the center O to the tangent point T 3. Add a right angle marker at the tangent point T to indicate the perpendicul...	{ "edit": "1. Add a green right angle marker at the tangent point T where the red tangent line meets the dashed blue radius line.", "explanation": "The image is missing the right angle marker at the tangent point T, which is required to indicate the perpendicular relationship between the radius and the tangent line...
518030ba-45d7-4a69-a5cc-a5c019e1701d	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/518030ba-45d7-4a69-a5cc-a5c019e1701d/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/518030ba-45d7-4a69-a5cc-a5c019e1701d/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Add an orange Ampèrian loop (circle) centered at point P and passing through the wire, labeled "Ampèrian loop" --- Generated Image: <image>	{ "edit": "1. Reposition the orange circle so that its center is exactly at point P.\n2. Resize the orange circle so that its circumference passes through the vertical wire.\n3. Correct the label text to \"Ampèrian loop\" and ensure it is placed clearly near the new loop.\n4. Remove the \"analysis region\" square and...
44790474-f5fd-4845-bd7c-7d87f05a3aab	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/44790474-f5fd-4845-bd7c-7d87f05a3aab/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/44790474-f5fd-4845-bd7c-7d87f05a3aab/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add an orange Ampèrian loop (circle) centered at the wire and passing through point P, labeled "Ampèrian loop" 2. Add a rectangular analysis region around the central wire segment, with a gray boundary and white masking outside...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image correctly incorporates all requested edits: an orange Ampèrian loop passes through point P and is appropriately labeled; a rectangular \"analysis region\" with a gray boundary and external white masking is present; and the point P marker has been reduced in size with ...
510c1adb-4acb-4823-956c-515af5317ab8	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/510c1adb-4acb-4823-956c-515af5317ab8/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/510c1adb-4acb-4823-956c-515af5317ab8/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw the major axis of the ellipse as a dashed line passing through the center, extending beyond both ends of the visible ellipse 2. Draw the minor axis of the ellipse as a dashed line passing through the center, perpendicular ...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image correctly implements all instructions: the major and minor axes are drawn as dashed lines extending beyond the ellipse, and the right half of the elliptical flaw has been completed to form a full ellipse." }
d04acdb0-cf49-4400-97e0-70396652ff6a	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/d04acdb0-cf49-4400-97e0-70396652ff6a/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/d04acdb0-cf49-4400-97e0-70396652ff6a/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw the tangent line at t=0 with appropriate slope 2. Extend the plateau line at σ∞ across the full width of the graph 3. Mark the intersection point of the tangent line and the plateau line 4. Draw a vertical line from the in...	{ "edit": "1. Increase the steepness of the red tangent line starting at t=0 so that it intersects the dashed plateau line exactly at t=15.\n2. Relocate the vertical red line to drop from this new intersection point at t=15 down to the time axis.\n3. Reposition the τ label to the right of the new vertical line at the...
98f91da8-5e82-4b1e-ad70-f35bcf755063	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/98f91da8-5e82-4b1e-ad70-f35bcf755063/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/98f91da8-5e82-4b1e-ad70-f35bcf755063/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Complete the probability density curve in the previously obscured right portion to show the full symmetric sinusoidal pattern 2. Mark the positions x = a/4 and x = 3a/4 with appropriate indicators 3. Shade the region between x ...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The final image fulfills all requirements: the probability density curve is completed to the right boundary, the positions x = a/4 and x = 3a/4 are clearly marked with blue indicators and labels, and the region between these points is shaded in green to highlight the area for probabi...
7d5352e5-82f6-48d4-9881-46fb6ec5bda8	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/7d5352e5-82f6-48d4-9881-46fb6ec5bda8/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/7d5352e5-82f6-48d4-9881-46fb6ec5bda8/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Overlay vertical harmonic grid lines for each candidate fundamental frequency (100, 110, 120, and 125 Hz) 2. For each candidate f₀, draw vertical lines at positions corresponding to k·f₀ for integer values of k, where k·f₀ ≤ 20...	{ "edit": "1. Extend all color-coded vertical harmonic grid lines (red, green, blue, and orange) downwards to reach the x-axis.\n2. Ensure the lines pass through the purple spectrum data line to provide a clear visual alignment with the peaks.", "explanation": "The vertical harmonic grid lines for the candidate fun...
df98de84-f42a-4487-8cb2-bb34abc17fb2	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/df98de84-f42a-4487-8cb2-bb34abc17fb2/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/df98de84-f42a-4487-8cb2-bb34abc17fb2/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Overlay vertical harmonic grid lines for each candidate fundamental frequency (100, 110, 120, and 130 Hz) 2. For each candidate f₀, draw vertical lines at positions corresponding to k·f₀ for integer values of k, where k·f₀ ≤ 20...	{ "edit": "1. Remove the text label \"f0=125 Hz\" and all associated orange vertical grid lines.\n2. Add a new text label \"f0=130 Hz\" at the top, using a distinct color (e.g., orange).\n3. Draw new vertical harmonic grid lines for f₀ = 130 Hz at integer multiples (130, 260, 390, ..., 1950 Hz) up to 2000 Hz, matchin...
7dc49b7d-1fab-4f38-a8a4-84a4c0bb635d	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/7dc49b7d-1fab-4f38-a8a4-84a4c0bb635d/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/7dc49b7d-1fab-4f38-a8a4-84a4c0bb635d/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add x-axis tick marks at 1/T values of 0.00280, 0.00300, and 0.00320 with corresponding numeric labels 2. Add y-axis tick marks at ln P values of 9.0, 10.0, and 11.0 with corresponding numeric labels 3. Label the two extreme da...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The generated image correctly implements all requirements: x-axis ticks and labels (0.00280, 0.00300, 0.00320) and y-axis ticks and labels (9.0, 10.0, 11.0) are present. The extreme data points are labeled with coordinates in the specified format, accurately reflecting the requested ...
50ad4fb6-cbf9-48b0-8a38-d606169ae636	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/50ad4fb6-cbf9-48b0-8a38-d606169ae636/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/50ad4fb6-cbf9-48b0-8a38-d606169ae636/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Overlay vertical harmonic grid lines for each candidate fundamental frequency (100, 110, 120, and 125 Hz) 2. For each candidate f₀, draw vertical lines at positions corresponding to k·f₀ for integer values of k, where k·f₀ ≤ 20...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The generated image fulfills all requirements: color-coded vertical harmonic grid lines for 100, 110, 120, and 125 Hz are correctly overlaid up to 2000 Hz, each set is clearly labeled with its f₀ value, and horizontal markers accurately highlight the three spectral peaks at 220, 330,...
d22ea394-37e6-4ae7-9053-2013303c802a	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/d22ea394-37e6-4ae7-9053-2013303c802a/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/d22ea394-37e6-4ae7-9053-2013303c802a/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Add an orange Ampèrian loop (circle) centered at the wire and passing through point P, labeled "Ampèrian loop" 2. Add a rectangular analysis region around the central wire segment, with a gray boundary and white masking outside...	{ "edit": "1. Increase the radius of the orange Ampèrian loop so that it passes directly through the center of point P.\n2. Reduce the diameter of the red point P marker to make it smaller.\n3. Ensure the \"Ampèrian loop\" label remains clearly visible next to the resized loop.", "explanation": "The orange Ampèrian...
3c2bee82-1dee-47a9-bd83-23456afb4e37	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/3c2bee82-1dee-47a9-bd83-23456afb4e37/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/3c2bee82-1dee-47a9-bd83-23456afb4e37/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> 1. Highlight the band minimum at the Brillouin zone edge (k=π/a) with a circular marker 2. Highlight the band maximum at the Γ point (k=0) with a circular marker 3. Add horizontal dashed reference lines at the energy levels of both extrema 4. Include a vertical measurement bar indicating the en...	{ "edit": "1. Move the circular marker from the right end of the curve to the left end (k=0).\n2. Ensure the horizontal dashed reference lines and the vertical measurement bar are aligned with the left end (k=0) and the middle peak (k=π/a).", "explanation": "The image incorrectly places a circular marker at the rig...
69233fc5-8738-476d-b212-7b449ecd5cf4	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/69233fc5-8738-476d-b212-7b449ecd5cf4/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/69233fc5-8738-476d-b212-7b449ecd5cf4/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> 1. Add a line-of-sight (LOS) line between the tops of towers T1 and T2 2. Mark the geometric midpoint between T1 and T2 with a distinct marker at the 250m contour 3. Add a vertical clearance indicator at the hill center showing the required 5 m clearance above terrain --- Generated Image:...	{ "edit": "1. Move the green midpoint marker from the 300m contour to the intersection of the red LOS line and the 250m contour.\n2. Ensure the vertical clearance indicator remains at the 300m hill center to show clearance above the peak.", "explanation": "The geometric midpoint marker (green dot) is incorrectly po...
a3771d40-f017-4aa4-86f2-c73829bfe13b	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/a3771d40-f017-4aa4-86f2-c73829bfe13b/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/a3771d40-f017-4aa4-86f2-c73829bfe13b/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Draw a complete Debye-Scherrer ring (full circle) passing through the visible diffraction arcs 2. Complete the hidden arc of the diffraction ring across the beamstop region using a dashed line 3. Draw a radius vector from the b...	{ "edit": null, "explanation": "The generated image fulfills all requirements: a complete red Debye-Scherrer ring is drawn passing through the diffraction spots, a portion of the ring is represented with a dashed line to indicate a hidden arc, and a blue radius vector correctly connects the beam center to the label...
d997b390-5a21-4248-a136-a31925047db4	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/d997b390-5a21-4248-a136-a31925047db4/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/d997b390-5a21-4248-a136-a31925047db4/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> Edit the provided image according to the following instructions: 1. Complete the probability density curve in the previously obscured right portion to show the full symmetric sinusoidal pattern 2. Mark the positions x = a/4 and x = 3a/4 with appropriate indicators 3. Shade the region between x ...	{ "edit": "1. Move the light green shaded rectangle to start at x = a/4 and end at x = 3a/4.\n2. Re-center the green \"Region for P\" text label horizontally within the new shaded area.", "explanation": "The shaded region in the \"Image to be Fixed\" incorrectly spans from x = 0 to x = a/2, whereas the reference sh...
606d5c29-b16f-4898-987e-c4e90ee15fa5	[ { "content": "You are an expert scientific image verification model. Your task is to evaluate whether a generated image correctly follows the given instruction. You must analyze the correctness of the generated image step by step, then provide a final judgment.\n\nTask Types:\n- Instruction Following: D...	[ "images/Instruction_Following/606d5c29-b16f-4898-987e-c4e90ee15fa5/image_0.png", "images/Instruction_Following/606d5c29-b16f-4898-987e-c4e90ee15fa5/image_1.png" ]	Instruction: <image> 1. Add the tangent line from point D to the sphere, connecting D to the tangent point T 2. Add the solid radius line from the center O to the tangent point T 3. Add a right angle marker at the tangent point T to indicate the perpendicular relationship between the radius and tangent 4. Add a hor...	{ "edit": "1. Change the line style of the radius from center O to the tangent point from dashed to solid.\n2. Add the label \"T\" near the intersection of the tangent line and the sphere's surface.", "explanation": "The radius line connecting center O to the tangent point is currently dashed, whereas the instructi...