| { |
| "chart_id": "chart_0000961", |
| "suite_id": "broad_coverage", |
| "source_kind": "llm_program_synth", |
| "chart_type": "bubble", |
| "domain": "transport_logistics", |
| "topic": "On-time Rate monitoring", |
| "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::ops", |
| "title": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]", |
| "subtitle": "bubble benchmark panel", |
| "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.", |
| "annotation_mode": "labeled", |
| "x_axis": { |
| "label": "Time Window", |
| "scale": "linear", |
| "tick_labels": [ |
| "Route-1", |
| "Route-2", |
| "Route-3", |
| "Route-4", |
| "Route-5", |
| "Route-6", |
| "Route-7", |
| "Route-8", |
| "Route-9" |
| ], |
| "tick_values": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 1.0, |
| 2.0, |
| 3.0, |
| 4.0, |
| 5.0, |
| 6.0, |
| 7.0, |
| 8.0 |
| ], |
| "unit": null, |
| "orientation": "x" |
| }, |
| "y_axis": { |
| "label": "On-time Rate (%)", |
| "scale": "linear", |
| "tick_labels": [], |
| "tick_values": [], |
| "unit": "%", |
| "orientation": "y" |
| }, |
| "table": { |
| "x_labels": [ |
| "Route-1", |
| "Route-2", |
| "Route-3", |
| "Route-4", |
| "Route-5", |
| "Route-6", |
| "Route-7", |
| "Route-8", |
| "Route-9" |
| ], |
| "values": [ |
| [ |
| 99.0, |
| 95.57879128807787, |
| 89.33334421608497, |
| 84.06229709379272, |
| 78.93868822496768, |
| 74.0220765696384, |
| 71.47035440170728, |
| 67.57836682968562, |
| 65.29430538325003 |
| ] |
| ], |
| "series_labels": [ |
| "On-time Rate" |
| ], |
| "table_rows": [ |
| [ |
| "On-time Rate", |
| 99.0, |
| 95.5788, |
| 89.3333, |
| 84.0623, |
| 78.9387, |
| 74.0221, |
| 71.4704, |
| 67.5784, |
| 65.2943 |
| ] |
| ] |
| }, |
| "series": [ |
| { |
| "name": "On-time Rate", |
| "values": [ |
| 99.0, |
| 95.5788, |
| 89.3333, |
| 84.0623, |
| 78.9387, |
| 74.0221, |
| 71.4704, |
| 67.5784, |
| 65.2943 |
| ], |
| "render_role": "bubble", |
| "axis": "primary", |
| "color_hint": null, |
| "extras": { |
| "sizes": [ |
| 86.54, |
| 131.57, |
| 161.29, |
| 182.5, |
| 141.51, |
| 190.62, |
| 253.67, |
| 180.42, |
| 309.43 |
| ] |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "legend": [ |
| "On-time Rate" |
| ], |
| "style_profile": { |
| "backend": "matplotlib", |
| "style_family": "dashboard_minimal", |
| "layout_family": "single_panel", |
| "width": 7.0, |
| "height": 4.5, |
| "note_style": "callout" |
| }, |
| "layout_profile": { |
| "layout_family": "single_panel" |
| }, |
| "risk_profile": { |
| "axis_scale": "linear", |
| "y_axis_truncated": false, |
| "legend_confusion": false, |
| "occlusion": false, |
| "visual_noise_std": 4.297188058378109, |
| "blur_radius": 0.406866469401164, |
| "jpeg_quality": 76, |
| "misleader_type": "dual_axis_ambiguity", |
| "dual_axis_emphasis": false |
| }, |
| "scene_objects": [ |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:0", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 97.0, |
| -40691.600000000006, |
| 113.0, |
| -40675.600000000006 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 0, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 99.0, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:1", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 748.0, |
| -39269.06504, |
| 764.0, |
| -39253.06504 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 1, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 95.5788, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:2", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 1399.0, |
| -36672.18614, |
| 1415.0, |
| -36656.18614 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 2, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 89.3333, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:3", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 2050.0, |
| -34480.50434, |
| 2066.0, |
| -34464.50434 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 3, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 84.0623, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:4", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 2701.0, |
| -32350.11146, |
| 2717.0, |
| -32334.11146 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 4, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 78.9387, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:5", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 3352.0, |
| -30305.78918, |
| 3368.0, |
| -30289.78918 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 5, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 74.0221, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:6", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 4003.0, |
| -29244.79232, |
| 4019.0, |
| -29228.79232 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 6, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 71.4704, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:7", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 4654.0, |
| -27626.498720000003, |
| 4670.0, |
| -27610.498720000003 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 7, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 67.5784, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:bubble:0:8", |
| "role": "bubble", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 5304.2046887491115, |
| -26677.565251250893, |
| 5321.7953112508885, |
| -26659.974628749118 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": 0, |
| "point_idx": 8, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": 65.2943, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:title", |
| "role": "title", |
| "label": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 245.75, |
| 40.80000000000001, |
| 615.25, |
| 58.80000000000001 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:x_label", |
| "role": "axis_label", |
| "label": "Time Window", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 374.6875, |
| 557.4464194765202, |
| 486.3125, |
| 575.4464194765202 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:y_label", |
| "role": "axis_label", |
| "label": "On-time Rate (%)", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 37.04166666666666, |
| 200.6375, |
| 55.04166666666667, |
| 344.7625 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:0", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-1", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 76.07782294772228, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 134.5909090909091, |
| 550.7797528098534 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:1", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-2", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 150.05509567499502, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 208.5681818181818, |
| 550.7797528098534 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:2", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-3", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 224.0323684022677, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 282.5454545454545, |
| 550.7797528098534 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:3", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-4", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 298.0980294771888, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 356.52272727272725, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:4", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-5", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 372.07530220446154, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 430.5, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:5", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-6", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 446.0525749317343, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 504.47727272727275, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:6", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-7", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 520.0298476590069, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 578.4545454545454, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:7", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-8", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 594.0071203862797, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 652.4318181818181, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:xtick:8", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "Route-9", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 667.9843931135524, |
| 492.26666666666665, |
| 726.4090909090909, |
| 550.6913644622051 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:0", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "60", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 514.0740939959711, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 532.0740939959711 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:1", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "65", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 458.00049220161577, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 476.00049220161577 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:2", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "70", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 401.92689040726054, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 419.92689040726054 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:3", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "75", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 345.8532886129052, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 363.8532886129052 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:4", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "80", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 289.77968681855, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 307.77968681855 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:5", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "85", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 233.70608502419475, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 251.70608502419475 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:6", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "90", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 177.6324832298394, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 195.6324832298394 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:7", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "95", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 72.33333333333333, |
| 121.55888143548418, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 139.55888143548418 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:8", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "100", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 61.70833333333333, |
| 65.48527964112895, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 83.48527964112895 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:ytick:9", |
| "role": "tick_label", |
| "label": "105", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 61.70833333333333, |
| 9.4116778467735, |
| 93.33333333333333, |
| 27.4116778467735 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "object_id": "chart_0000961:main:legend:0", |
| "role": "legend_item", |
| "label": "On-time Rate", |
| "bbox": [ |
| 667.7499999999999, |
| 75.30000000000001, |
| 745.4999999999999, |
| 88.30000000000001 |
| ], |
| "polygon": null, |
| "panel_id": null, |
| "series_idx": null, |
| "point_idx": null, |
| "supports_answer": null, |
| "value": null, |
| "metadata": {} |
| } |
| ], |
| "provenance": { |
| "scenario_id": "general", |
| "pattern": "exponential_decay", |
| "family": "decay", |
| "title_template_id": "general:transport_logistics:t0", |
| "metric_idx": 2, |
| "challenge_score": 0, |
| "llm_audit": { |
| "enabled": false, |
| "generator_model": "gpt-5-mini", |
| "verifier_model": "gpt-5-mini", |
| "judge_model": "gpt-5-mini", |
| "candidate_count": 3, |
| "selected_candidate_id": "fallback_2", |
| "verifier_passed": true, |
| "candidates": [ |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_1", |
| "text_fields": { |
| "title": "On-time Rate Analysis [%]", |
| "subtitle": "Transport Logistics operating view", |
| "note": null, |
| "topic": "On-time Rate", |
| "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::baseline" |
| }, |
| "style_profile": { |
| "style_family": "clean_report", |
| "layout_family": "single_panel", |
| "note_style": "subtle" |
| }, |
| "layout_profile": { |
| "layout_family": "single_panel" |
| }, |
| "risk_profile": {}, |
| "constrained_spec_patch": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_2", |
| "text_fields": { |
| "title": "Transport Logistics On-time Rate Review [%]", |
| "subtitle": "bubble benchmark panel", |
| "note": "Operational reading target preserved across rendering variants.", |
| "topic": "On-time Rate monitoring", |
| "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::ops" |
| }, |
| "style_profile": { |
| "style_family": "dashboard_minimal", |
| "layout_family": "single_panel", |
| "note_style": "callout" |
| }, |
| "layout_profile": { |
| "layout_family": "single_panel" |
| }, |
| "risk_profile": {}, |
| "constrained_spec_patch": {} |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_3", |
| "text_fields": { |
| "title": "On-time Rate Stability Snapshot [%]", |
| "subtitle": "Transport Logistics benchmark slice", |
| "note": "Visual complexity is intentionally varied while table truth stays fixed.", |
| "topic": "On-time Rate stability", |
| "caption_seed": "transport_logistics::On-time Rate::stability" |
| }, |
| "style_profile": { |
| "style_family": "paper_figure", |
| "layout_family": "single_panel", |
| "note_style": "footnote" |
| }, |
| "layout_profile": { |
| "layout_family": "single_panel" |
| }, |
| "risk_profile": {}, |
| "constrained_spec_patch": {} |
| } |
| ], |
| "verification_reports": [ |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_1", |
| "is_valid": true, |
| "consistency_flags": [], |
| "factuality_flags": [], |
| "rejection_reason": null |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_2", |
| "is_valid": true, |
| "consistency_flags": [], |
| "factuality_flags": [], |
| "rejection_reason": null |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_3", |
| "is_valid": true, |
| "consistency_flags": [], |
| "factuality_flags": [], |
| "rejection_reason": null |
| } |
| ], |
| "judgement_reports": [ |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_2", |
| "naturalness_score": 0.92, |
| "clarity_score": 1.0, |
| "ambiguity_score": 0.15, |
| "selection_rank": 1 |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_3", |
| "naturalness_score": 0.89, |
| "clarity_score": 1.0, |
| "ambiguity_score": 0.15, |
| "selection_rank": 2 |
| }, |
| { |
| "candidate_id": "fallback_1", |
| "naturalness_score": 0.86, |
| "clarity_score": 1.0, |
| "ambiguity_score": 0.15, |
| "selection_rank": 3 |
| } |
| ] |
| } |
| }, |
| "secondary_y_axis": null, |
| "panel_specs": [], |
| "difficulty_components": { |
| "chart_type": "bubble", |
| "n_series": 1, |
| "n_points": 9, |
| "layout_density": "low", |
| "legend_complexity": "low", |
| "tick_density": "low", |
| "label_complexity": "medium", |
| "mark_overlap": "low", |
| "axis_transform": "linear", |
| "annotation_mode": "labeled", |
| "image_degradation": "medium", |
| "source_kind": "llm_program_synth" |
| } |
| } |
