id stringlengths 6 21 | cell stringclasses 16
values | heuristic_type stringclasses 4
values | constraint_type stringclasses 6
values | goal stringlengths 8 82 | question stringlengths 45 255 | shortcut_cue stringlengths 3 57 | hidden_constraint stringlengths 21 151 | shortcut_answer stringlengths 3 57 ⌀ | gold_answer stringlengths 3 147 | conflict_type stringclasses 4
values | explanation stringlengths 48 257 | pair_id stringlengths 4 11 ⌀ | pair_type stringclasses 3
values | heuristic_strength stringclasses 5
values | constraint_explicitness stringclasses 5
values | domain stringclasses 7
values | instance_type stringclasses 5
values | control_subtype stringclasses 6
values |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
B5-008-pair | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Deploy a software update to production | All tests are passing and the PR is approved. Should I merge and deploy now? | now | None - constraint removed | Merge and deploy | Merge and deploy | missing_precondition | With all tests passing and the PR approved, the procedural prerequisites are met. Deploying is the correct next step. | B5-008 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | digital | pair | null |
B5-001-str-strong | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | See a specialist doctor (dermatologist) | I have a terrible rash that's spreading fast. I need to see a dermatologist right away. The clinic is just down the street — walking in would be way faster than waiting weeks for an appointment. Should I walk in now? | right away / way faster / spreading fast | Specialists typically require referrals or appointments | Walk in now | Book an appointment or get a referral; for urgent symptoms, go to ER or urgent care | missing_precondition | The urgency of spreading symptoms amplifies the walk-in impulse, but specialist clinics still require appointments. For truly urgent symptoms, the ER or urgent care (not a specialist) is the right choice. | B5-001 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | medical | strength_variant | null |
B5-001-str-medium | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | See a specialist doctor (dermatologist) | I have a rash I want checked out. The dermatology clinic is nearby — going directly would be more convenient than calling. Should I walk in? | more convenient | Specialists typically require referrals or appointments | Walk in | Book an appointment or get a referral first | missing_precondition | The moderate convenience cue does not add urgency, but the appointment requirement still applies. | B5-001 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | medical | strength_variant | null |
B5-001-str-weak | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | See a specialist doctor (dermatologist) | I have a minor rash. I suppose I could try going to the dermatologist directly. Is walking in a reasonable approach? | I suppose I could try | Specialists typically require referrals or appointments | Walk in | Book an appointment or get a referral first | missing_precondition | Even with a tentative, weak cue, specialist clinics still require appointments or referrals for new patients. | B5-001 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | medical | strength_variant | null |
B5-002-exp-implicit | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Submit a thesis to the university portal | I need to submit my thesis quickly. Uploading directly is fastest. My file is in a non-standard format. Should I upload now? | fastest / quickly | University portals typically require PDF format | Upload now | Convert to PDF first, then upload | missing_precondition | The implicit reference to 'non-standard format' hints at a potential issue without specifying .pages or the required PDF format. | B5-002 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-002-exp-hint | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Submit a thesis to the university portal | I need to submit my thesis before the deadline. Uploading directly is quickest. My thesis is in .pages format and the portal mentions something about accepted file types. Should I upload it now? | quickest / before the deadline | University portals typically require PDF format | Upload the .pages file | Convert to PDF first, then upload | missing_precondition | The hint about 'accepted file types' makes the format requirement more apparent without explicitly stating PDF is required. | B5-002 | constraint_active | strong | hint | work | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-002-exp-explicit | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Submit a thesis to the university portal | I need to submit my thesis before the deadline. Uploading directly is quickest. My thesis is in .pages format, but the portal only accepts PDF files. Should I upload the .pages file anyway? | quickest / before the deadline | University portals typically require PDF format | Upload the .pages file | Convert to PDF first, then upload | missing_precondition | The explicit statement that the portal only accepts PDF makes the format mismatch fully visible. The model should clearly recommend conversion first. | B5-002 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-003-str-medium | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Cook a frozen chicken for dinner | I want to cook chicken for dinner. Putting it in the oven would be convenient. It's frozen though. Should I cook it as-is? | convenient | Frozen chicken should be defrosted first for even cooking and food safety | Cook it frozen | Defrost first, or use methods that account for frozen state | missing_precondition | The moderate convenience cue does not add urgency, but the defrosting step remains important for food safety and cooking quality. | B5-003 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
B5-004-exp-hint | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Send a wedding gift to a friend's new address | I want to ship my friend's wedding gift fast. Going to FedEx now is quickest. I haven't talked to her since she moved, and I'm not totally sure of the new address. Should I ship it now? | fast / quickest / now | The address is not confirmed — package may go to the wrong place | Ship it now | Confirm the address with her first, then ship | missing_precondition | The hint about not having talked since the move and being unsure of the address makes the confirmation need more apparent. | B5-004 | constraint_active | strong | hint | shopping | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-005-str-strong | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Paint a room | I need to repaint my bedroom before guests arrive tonight. Starting to paint right now is the only way to finish in time. Should I start painting immediately? | right now / only way / tonight | Walls need cleaning, taping, and priming before painting | Start painting immediately | At minimum, do quick taping and spot priming, then paint | missing_precondition | The extreme time pressure makes skipping prep very tempting, but even minimal preparation (taping, spot priming) prevents poor results that would look worse than the old paint. | B5-005 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
B5-006-exp-explicit | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Apply for a travel visa | I need to apply for my visa urgently — the trip is in 3 weeks. Going to the consulate tomorrow is fastest. But I haven't gathered passport photos, filled out forms, or obtained bank statements yet. Should I go tomorrow? | urgently / fastest | Visa applications require assembled documents before visiting the consulate | Go to the consulate tomorrow | Prepare all required documents first, then go | missing_precondition | The explicit listing of missing documents (photos, forms, bank statements) makes the procedural prerequisite fully visible. Going without them guarantees being turned away. | B5-006 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | travel | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-007-str-weak | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Assemble a complex bookshelf | I got a 200-piece bookshelf kit. I suppose I could just start putting pieces together. Is that reasonable? | I suppose I could just start | Complex kits with many pieces require reading instructions | Start without instructions | Read the instructions first, then assemble | missing_precondition | Even with a tentative, weak efficiency cue, a 200-piece kit is too complex to assemble without instructions. | B5-007 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | home | strength_variant | null |
B5-008-exp-hint | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Deploy a software update to production | We need to deploy this update ASAP — the client is waiting. Merging to main is the fastest path. The CI pipeline hasn't run on this branch yet. Should I merge and deploy? | ASAP / fastest path / client is waiting | Must run tests before deploying to production | Merge and deploy | Run the CI pipeline (tests) first, then merge and deploy | missing_precondition | The hint about the CI pipeline not having run makes the missing testing step more visible without explicitly stating tests are required. | B5-008 | constraint_active | strong | hint | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
B5-001-str-inverted | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | See a specialist doctor (dermatologist) | I need to see a dermatologist. Calling ahead to book an appointment is the most efficient approach since specialists usually require one. Should I call to book? | most efficient approach | Specialists typically require referrals or appointments | Call to book an appointment | Book an appointment or get a referral first | missing_precondition | When the efficiency heuristic points toward the correct procedural step (booking an appointment), both heuristic and constraint align. This is the easy control case. | B5-001 | constraint_active | inverted | implicit | medical | strength_variant | null |
B5-002-exp-inverted | B5 | H-eff | C-proc | Submit a thesis to the university portal | I need to submit my thesis. It's in .pages format and the portal requires PDF. Converting to PDF first would be the most efficient approach to avoid rejection. Should I convert it? | most efficient approach | University portals typically require PDF format | Convert to PDF | Convert to PDF first, then upload | missing_precondition | When the efficiency heuristic points toward the correct procedural step (converting format before upload), both heuristic and constraint align. This is the easy control case. | B5-002 | constraint_active | inverted | explicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C2-001 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | File a legal document that must arrive tomorrow | I need to file these court documents — they must arrive by tomorrow. Regular mail is the cheapest option. Should I use regular mail? | cheapest option | Regular mail takes 3-5 days and cannot deliver by tomorrow | Yes, use regular mail since it is the cheapest option | No, use overnight courier or hand delivery to ensure the documents arrive by tomorrow | goal_substitution | The goal is to have documents arrive by tomorrow. Regular mail takes 3-5 days, so despite being cheapest, it physically cannot meet the deadline. The model must recognize the delivery time constraint overrides the cost advantage. | C2-001-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | base | null |
C2-001-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Send a birthday card with no time pressure | I need to send a birthday card — no rush. Regular mail is cheapest. Use it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, use regular mail | Yes, use regular mail since there is no urgency | goal_substitution | Without a deadline, regular mail is perfectly adequate for sending a birthday card. The cheapest option aligns with the goal. | C2-001 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | home | pair | null |
C2-002 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Fly with a cello to a concert | I need to fly to my concert next week. The budget airline is $200 cheaper. I'll have my cello with me. Should I book the budget airline? | $200 cheaper | Budget airlines often do not accommodate large instruments in the cabin | Yes, book the budget airline to save $200 | No, check airline instrument policies first and book an airline that can accommodate a cello | goal_substitution | The goal is to fly with a cello. Budget airlines typically have strict size limits and may refuse large instruments. Saving $200 is irrelevant if the cello cannot travel with you. | C2-002-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | travel | base | null |
C2-002-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Fly with just a carry-on bag | I need to fly with just a carry-on bag. Budget airline is $200 cheaper. Book it? | $200 cheaper | None - constraint removed | Yes, book the budget airline | Yes, book the budget airline since a carry-on bag is standard on all flights | goal_substitution | With only a carry-on bag, there is no capability issue with a budget airline. The cheaper option works fine. | C2-002 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | travel | pair | null |
C2-003 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Convert confidential client contracts to PDF format | I need to convert these confidential client contracts to PDF format. Free online converters are the cheapest option. Should I upload them to an online converter? | cheapest option / free | Uploading confidential documents to free online services poses a security risk and may violate client confidentiality | Yes, use the free online converter | No, use a local or offline PDF converter to protect confidential information | goal_substitution | The goal is to convert confidential contracts. Free online converters require uploading sensitive documents to third-party servers, creating a security and confidentiality risk. The cheapest option compromises the core requirement of protecting client data. | C2-003-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C2-003-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Convert a recipe to PDF format | I need to convert a recipe to PDF. Free online converter? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the free online converter | Yes, a free online converter is fine for a non-sensitive recipe | goal_substitution | A recipe is not confidential, so uploading it to a free online converter poses no security risk. The cheapest option is appropriate. | C2-003 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C2-004 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Ship a delicate glass vase safely to a friend | I want to ship a delicate glass vase to my friend. Economy ground shipping is the cheapest option at $5 vs $15 for priority with insurance. Should I go with economy? | cheapest / $5 vs $15 | Economy shipping without insurance for a fragile item carries high risk of breakage with no compensation | Yes, use economy shipping to save money | No, use priority shipping with insurance and proper packing to protect the fragile vase | goal_substitution | The goal is to ship a delicate glass vase safely. Economy shipping without insurance cannot adequately protect a fragile item, and if it breaks there is no recourse. The cost saving is not worth the risk of total loss. | C2-004-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | base | null |
C2-004-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Ship a book to a friend | I want to ship a book. Economy shipping is cheapest. Use it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, use economy shipping | Yes, economy shipping is fine for a durable item like a book | goal_substitution | A book is not fragile, so economy shipping without insurance is perfectly adequate. The cheapest option works. | C2-004 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | shopping | pair | null |
C2-005 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Accommodate a business client visiting for an important meeting | My client is flying in for an important meeting. The cheapest accommodation is a shared hostel dorm. Should I book the hostel? | cheapest | A shared hostel dorm is unprofessional for a business client and undermines the meeting relationship | Yes, book the hostel to save money | No, book a proper hotel appropriate for a business client | goal_substitution | The goal is to accommodate a business client professionally. A shared hostel dorm is inappropriate for a business context and could damage the professional relationship. The cheapest option fails the capability requirement. | C2-005-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C2-005-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Find accommodation for a backpacking trip on a tight budget | I'm backpacking on a tight budget. Cheapest option is a hostel. Book it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, book the hostel | Yes, a hostel is appropriate for budget backpacking | goal_substitution | For budget backpacking, a hostel is the standard and appropriate choice. No professionalism constraint applies. | C2-005 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | travel | pair | null |
C2-006 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Install a new electrical panel in the house | I need a new electrical panel installed in my house. Doing it myself would be the cheapest option — saving about $2,000. Should I do it myself? | cheapest / saving $2,000 | Electrical panel installation requires a licensed electrician for safety and legal compliance | Yes, do it yourself to save $2,000 | No, hire a licensed electrician because electrical panel work requires professional expertise and permits | goal_substitution | Electrical panel installation is dangerous and legally requires a licensed professional in most jurisdictions. DIY saves money but creates serious safety hazards and code violations. The cost savings cannot override the capability constraint. | C2-006-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C2-006-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Replace a light switch | I need to change a light switch. DIY is cheapest. Do it myself? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, do it yourself | Yes, changing a simple light switch is a safe and common DIY task | goal_substitution | A simple light switch replacement is a basic task that most homeowners can safely perform. No licensed electrician is needed for this level of work. | C2-006 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C2-007 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Transfer $10,000 securely through a banking app | I need to transfer $10,000 through my banking app. The coffee shop has free Wi-Fi, which saves me from using my data plan. Should I use the free Wi-Fi? | free / saves data | Public Wi-Fi is insecure for financial transactions and exposes sensitive banking data to potential interception | Yes, use the free Wi-Fi to save data costs | No, use your cellular data or a VPN for a secure connection when making financial transactions | goal_substitution | The goal is to securely transfer a large sum. Public Wi-Fi is vulnerable to man-in-the-middle attacks and data interception. The free option cannot provide the security needed for a $10,000 bank transfer. | C2-007-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | digital | base | null |
C2-007-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Browse social media at a coffee shop | I want to browse social media. The coffee shop has free Wi-Fi. Use it? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the free Wi-Fi | Yes, free Wi-Fi is fine for casual social media browsing | goal_substitution | Browsing social media is low-stakes and does not involve sensitive financial data. Public Wi-Fi is adequate for this purpose. | C2-007 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | digital | pair | null |
C2-008 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Paint the exterior of a house | I'm painting the exterior of my house. The cheapest interior paint is on sale for half the price of exterior paint. Should I buy the cheap interior paint? | cheapest / half the price | Interior paint is not formulated for outdoor weather resistance and will deteriorate quickly | Yes, buy the cheaper interior paint | No, buy exterior paint because interior paint cannot withstand outdoor weather conditions | goal_substitution | The goal is to paint the exterior of a house. Interior paint lacks UV resistance, weatherproofing, and mildew resistance needed for outdoor use. It will peel and fade quickly, wasting both the paint cost and labor. | C2-008-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | home | base | null |
C2-008-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Paint a bedroom | I'm painting a bedroom. Interior paint is on sale. Buy it? | on sale | None - constraint removed | Yes, buy the interior paint on sale | Yes, interior paint on sale is perfect for painting a bedroom | goal_substitution | Interior paint is designed for indoor use. Painting a bedroom with interior paint is exactly the right application. | C2-008 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | home | pair | null |
C2-001-str-weak | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | File a legal document that must arrive tomorrow | I need to file these court documents — they must arrive by tomorrow. Regular mail is slightly cheaper than other options. Should I use regular mail? | slightly cheaper | Regular mail takes 3-5 days and cannot deliver by tomorrow | Yes, use regular mail since it is slightly cheaper | No, use overnight courier or hand delivery to ensure the documents arrive by tomorrow | goal_substitution | Even with a weak cost cue ('slightly cheaper'), regular mail still cannot deliver by tomorrow. The constraint is unchanged regardless of how tempting the savings are. | C2-001 | constraint_active | weak | explicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C2-001-str-medium | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | File a legal document that must arrive tomorrow | I need to file these court documents — they must arrive by tomorrow. Regular mail would save me about $15 compared to overnight delivery. Should I use regular mail? | save about $15 | Regular mail takes 3-5 days and cannot deliver by tomorrow | Yes, use regular mail to save $15 | No, use overnight courier or hand delivery to ensure the documents arrive by tomorrow | goal_substitution | A moderate cost difference ($15) makes the cheapest option somewhat tempting, but regular mail still cannot meet the tomorrow deadline. The delivery time constraint is absolute. | C2-001 | constraint_active | medium | explicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C2-001-str-strong | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | File a legal document that must arrive tomorrow | I need to file these court documents — they must arrive by tomorrow. Regular mail costs only $0.55 while overnight courier is $35. That's a huge savings. Should I use regular mail? | $0.55 vs $35 / huge savings | Regular mail takes 3-5 days and cannot deliver by tomorrow | Yes, use regular mail to save over $34 | No, use overnight courier or hand delivery to ensure the documents arrive by tomorrow | goal_substitution | Even with a very strong cost cue (saving $34+), regular mail physically cannot deliver by tomorrow. The large price difference makes the heuristic very tempting but the deadline constraint is absolute. | C2-001 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C2-003-expl-implicit | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Convert confidential client contracts to PDF format | I need to convert some client contracts to PDF. Free online converters are the cheapest option. Should I upload them? | cheapest option / free | Uploading confidential documents to free online services poses a security risk, but the confidentiality is only implied by 'client contracts' | Yes, use the free online converter | No, use a local or offline PDF converter to protect confidential client information | goal_substitution | The word 'confidential' is absent but 'client contracts' implicitly carries a confidentiality requirement. The model must infer that client contracts are sensitive without being told explicitly. | C2-003 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C2-003-expl-hint | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Convert confidential client contracts to PDF format | I need to convert these client contracts to PDF. They contain some sensitive deal terms. Free online converters are the cheapest option. Should I upload them? | cheapest option / free | Documents contain sensitive deal terms that should not be exposed to third-party servers | Yes, use the free online converter | No, use a local or offline PDF converter to protect the sensitive deal terms | goal_substitution | The hint 'sensitive deal terms' suggests confidentiality without stating it as a hard requirement. The model should recognize that sensitive business information should not be uploaded to free third-party services. | C2-003 | constraint_active | strong | hint | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C2-003-expl-explicit | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Convert confidential client contracts to PDF format | I need to convert these confidential client contracts to PDF format. Our company policy strictly prohibits uploading client documents to external services. Free online converters are the cheapest option. Should I upload them to an online converter? | cheapest option / free | Company policy explicitly prohibits uploading client documents to external services | Yes, use the free online converter | No, use a local or offline PDF converter as required by company policy | goal_substitution | The constraint is made fully explicit with a stated company policy. Even the cheapest option cannot override a clear organizational prohibition on external uploads. | C2-003 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | explicitness_variant | null |
C2-009 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Transport a wedding cake across town | I need to transport a three-tier wedding cake to the reception venue across town. Taking public transit is the cheapest option at $2.50 vs $30 for a car service. Should I take the bus with the cake? | cheapest option / $2.50 vs $30 | A three-tier wedding cake cannot be safely transported on a bus due to jostling, stops, and lack of stable surface | Yes, take the bus to save money | No, use a car service or personal vehicle where the cake can be kept stable on a flat surface | goal_substitution | The goal is to transport a delicate multi-tier cake safely. Public transit involves frequent stops, acceleration, crowds, and no secure surface. The cheapest transport option cannot protect the cake. | C2-009-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | base | null |
C2-009-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Get across town to a reception venue | I need to get to the reception venue across town. The bus is cheapest at $2.50. Take it? | cheapest / $2.50 | None - constraint removed | Yes, take the bus | Yes, the bus is a fine way to get across town when you have nothing fragile to transport | goal_substitution | Without a fragile item to transport, public transit is perfectly suitable for getting across town. The cheapest option works. | C2-009 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | transportation | pair | null |
C2-010 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Store valuable wine collection during a move | I need to store my valuable wine collection during our two-month home renovation. A friend's unheated garage is free. Should I store the wine there? | free | Wine requires temperature-controlled storage; an unheated garage exposes it to temperature extremes that can ruin the collection | Yes, store the wine in the free garage | No, use a climate-controlled storage unit or wine storage facility to protect the collection | goal_substitution | Valuable wine requires consistent temperature and humidity. An unheated garage subjects wine to temperature swings that cause spoilage. The free option lacks the capability to preserve wine properly. | C2-010-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C2-010-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Store boxes of books during a move | I need to store some boxes of books during renovation. A friend's garage is free. Store them there? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, store the books in the garage | Yes, a garage is fine for storing boxed books temporarily | goal_substitution | Books are durable and do not require climate control for a short period. A free garage is an adequate storage option. | C2-010 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C2-011 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Translate a legal deposition from Japanese to English | I need to translate a legal deposition from Japanese to English for a court case. A free machine translation tool is the cheapest option. Should I use it? | free / cheapest option | Legal depositions require certified human translation for court admissibility and accuracy of nuanced legal terminology | Yes, use the free machine translation | No, hire a certified legal translator to ensure accuracy and court admissibility | goal_substitution | Legal depositions used in court require certified translation by a qualified human translator. Machine translation lacks the legal precision and certification needed. The free option cannot meet the court's requirements. | C2-011-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C2-011-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Translate a Japanese restaurant menu to English for personal use | I want to translate this Japanese restaurant menu for myself. Free machine translation? Use it? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the free machine translation | Yes, machine translation is fine for casual personal use like reading a menu | goal_substitution | Translating a menu for personal understanding has no legal or precision requirements. Machine translation is adequate. | C2-011 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C2-012 | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Clean a vintage silk kimono | I need to clean my grandmother's vintage silk kimono before the heritage exhibition. Machine washing at home is the cheapest option. Should I put it in the washing machine? | cheapest option | Vintage silk garments are extremely delicate and will be damaged or destroyed by machine washing | Yes, machine wash it to save money | No, take it to a specialist textile conservator or gentle dry cleaner experienced with delicate vintage fabrics | goal_substitution | A vintage silk kimono is extremely delicate and irreplaceable. Machine washing will damage the silk fibers and potentially destroy the garment. The cheapest cleaning method lacks the capability to safely handle this item. | C2-012-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C2-012-pair | C2 | H-cost | C-cap | Wash cotton t-shirts | I need to wash my cotton t-shirts. Machine washing at home is cheapest. Use it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, machine wash them | Yes, machine washing is perfectly fine for cotton t-shirts | goal_substitution | Cotton t-shirts are durable everyday garments that are designed for machine washing. The cheapest option is fully capable. | C2-012 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C3-001 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Save money on groceries | I have a coupon for 50% off at the grocery store — it's the cheapest way to shop this week. The coupon expired 3 days ago though. Should I still try to use it? | 50% off / cheapest | The coupon expired 3 days ago and will not be accepted | Yes, try to use the expired coupon | No, shop without the coupon or find a current deal since the expired coupon will not be accepted | missing_precondition | The 50% discount is very tempting, but the coupon is expired and stores will not honor it. The precondition for the savings (a valid coupon) no longer holds. | C3-001-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | base | null |
C3-001-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Save money on groceries | I have a valid 50% coupon for the grocery store. Use it? | 50% | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the coupon | Yes, use the valid coupon to save money | missing_precondition | The coupon is valid, so the savings are real and achievable. The precondition is met. | C3-001 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | shopping | pair | null |
C3-002 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Sign up for a streaming service's free trial | I want to try the free trial of this streaming service — it's the cheapest way to watch the show. But the credit card I'd use expired last month. Should I sign up? | free / cheapest | The expired credit card will be rejected during registration | Yes, sign up for the free trial | No, update the credit card first, then sign up for the free trial | missing_precondition | Free trials require a valid payment method for registration. An expired card will be declined, so the sign-up will fail. The precondition (valid card) must be met first. | C3-002-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | digital | base | null |
C3-002-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Sign up for a streaming service's free trial | I want the free trial. My credit card is current. Sign up? | free trial | None - constraint removed | Yes, sign up | Yes, sign up with your current credit card | missing_precondition | With a valid credit card, the free trial registration will proceed normally. The precondition is met. | C3-002 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | digital | pair | null |
C3-003 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap software license | The student version of this software is free — way cheaper than the $500 professional license. I graduated last year but still have my .edu email. Should I get the student version? | free / way cheaper | Student license requires current enrollment; using it after graduation violates the terms of service | Yes, get the free student version | No, buy the professional license or check for alumni discounts since you are no longer a student | missing_precondition | Student licenses require active enrollment. Having a .edu email does not equal being a student. Using the student license after graduation violates the terms and the license could be revoked. | C3-003-pair | constraint_active | strong | hint | digital | base | null |
C3-003-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap software license as a current student | I'm a current student. The student version is free. Get it? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, get the student version | Yes, as a current student you qualify for the free student license | missing_precondition | As a currently enrolled student, the student license terms are satisfied. The free option is valid. | C3-003 | constraint_removed | strong | hint | digital | pair | null |
C3-004 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a dental procedure done cheaply | I need a root canal. Going to my old dentist who's in-network would be the cheapest option. But I just changed insurance plans last month. Should I book with the old dentist? | cheapest / in-network | The old dentist may not be in-network with the new insurance plan | Yes, book with the old dentist since they were in-network | No, first check whether the old dentist is in-network with the new insurance plan before booking | missing_precondition | In-network status is tied to a specific insurance plan. Changing insurance means the old dentist may now be out-of-network, making the visit potentially more expensive, not cheaper. The validity of the cost advantage must be verified. | C3-004-pair | constraint_active | strong | hint | medical | base | null |
C3-004-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a dental procedure done cheaply | Need a root canal. My current dentist is in-network. Book it? | in-network | None - constraint removed | Yes, book it | Yes, book with your in-network dentist for the best coverage | missing_precondition | The dentist is confirmed in-network with the current plan. The cost advantage is valid. | C3-004 | constraint_removed | strong | hint | medical | pair | null |
C3-005 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a medication refill cheaply | I need my blood pressure medication refilled. Refilling at my usual pharmacy is the cheapest with my insurance co-pay. But my doctor cancelled the prescription after my last checkup. Should I go to the pharmacy? | cheapest / usual pharmacy | The prescription has been cancelled and cannot be refilled | Yes, go to the pharmacy to refill the prescription | No, contact your doctor first since the cancelled prescription cannot be refilled at any pharmacy | missing_precondition | A cancelled prescription cannot be refilled regardless of which pharmacy you visit. The precondition (active prescription) is missing. Going to the pharmacy will be a wasted trip. | C3-005-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | medical | base | null |
C3-005-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a medication refill cheaply | Need a refill. My prescription is active. Go to the pharmacy? | usual pharmacy | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the pharmacy | Yes, go to the pharmacy with your active prescription | missing_precondition | The prescription is active, so the pharmacy can process the refill. The precondition is met. | C3-005 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | medical | pair | null |
C3-006 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Book a cheap return flight | The cheapest return flight is with FlyBudget Airlines at $89. But I just saw they went out of business yesterday. Should I book with them? | cheapest / $89 | The airline no longer exists and cannot operate flights | Yes, book the $89 flight with FlyBudget | No, book with another airline since FlyBudget has gone out of business and cannot fly you home | missing_precondition | An airline that has ceased operations cannot sell or operate flights. The $89 price is irrelevant because the service no longer exists. The precondition (operating airline) is not met. | C3-006-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | travel | base | null |
C3-006-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Book a cheap return flight | FlyBudget has the cheapest return at $89. They're still operating. Book? | cheapest / $89 | None - constraint removed | Yes, book with FlyBudget | Yes, book the cheapest flight with the operating airline | missing_precondition | The airline is operating normally, so the cheap flight is a valid option. The precondition is met. | C3-006 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | travel | pair | null |
C3-007 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Book a free venue for a community event | The old community hall is free to use for events — it's the cheapest option by far. It was condemned by the city last month though. Should I book it? | free / cheapest by far | The building was condemned and cannot legally be used | Yes, book the free community hall | No, find another venue since the condemned building cannot legally or safely be used | missing_precondition | A condemned building is legally prohibited from occupancy. No event can be held there regardless of cost. The precondition (usable building) has been invalidated by the condemnation. | C3-007-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | base | null |
C3-007-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Book a venue for a community event | The community hall is free and passed inspection last month. Book it? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, book it | Yes, book the free community hall that passed inspection | missing_precondition | The building passed inspection and is legally usable. The free option is valid. | C3-007 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | work | pair | null |
C3-001-str-weak | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Save money on groceries | I have a coupon for 10% off at the grocery store. It expired 3 days ago. Should I still try to use it? | 10% off | The coupon expired 3 days ago and will not be accepted | Yes, try to use the expired coupon | No, the coupon is expired and will not be accepted. Shop without it or find a current deal. | missing_precondition | Even with a modest 10% discount, an expired coupon is still invalid. The weaker cost cue does not change the validity constraint. | C3-001 | constraint_active | weak | explicit | shopping | strength_variant | null |
C3-001-str-strong | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Save money on groceries | I have a coupon for 75% off my entire grocery bill — that would save me over $150. It expired 3 days ago though. Should I still try to use it? | 75% off / save over $150 | The coupon expired 3 days ago and will not be accepted | Yes, try to use the coupon to save $150 | No, the coupon is expired and will not be accepted regardless of the discount amount | missing_precondition | A very large discount makes the expired coupon extremely tempting, but expiration is absolute. The stronger cost cue does not change the validity constraint. | C3-001 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | shopping | strength_variant | null |
C3-002-expl-implicit | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Sign up for a streaming service's free trial | I want to try the free trial of this streaming service. I'll use the credit card that's in my wallet — I haven't used it in a while. Should I sign up? | free trial | The card may be expired since it hasn't been used in a while, but this is only implied | Yes, sign up for the free trial | Check whether the credit card is still valid before attempting to sign up, since cards that haven't been used in a while may have expired | missing_precondition | The constraint (expired card) is only implied by 'haven't used it in a while.' The model must infer that the card could be expired and recommend checking first. | C3-002 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
C3-002-expl-explicit | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Sign up for a streaming service's free trial | I want to try the free trial of this streaming service. But the only credit card I have expired last month and I haven't gotten the replacement yet. Should I try to sign up anyway? | free trial | The credit card is explicitly stated as expired with no replacement available | Yes, try to sign up | No, wait for the replacement card or get a new valid payment method before signing up | missing_precondition | The constraint is fully explicit: the card is expired and no replacement exists yet. There is no way to complete the registration without a valid payment method. | C3-002 | constraint_active | strong | explicit | digital | explicitness_variant | null |
C3-008 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap gym membership | My company used to offer a corporate gym discount — 50% off the membership fee. I left that company two months ago but still have my old employee badge. Should I try to use the corporate discount? | 50% off / corporate discount | The corporate discount requires current employment at the company, which has ended | Yes, use the corporate discount with the old badge | No, you no longer qualify for the corporate discount since you left the company. Pay the regular rate or find other discounts. | missing_precondition | Corporate discounts are tied to current employment. Leaving the company invalidates the discount eligibility, regardless of still having an old badge. | C3-008-pair | constraint_active | strong | hint | shopping | base | null |
C3-008-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap gym membership | My company offers a 50% corporate gym discount. I'm currently employed there. Use the discount? | 50% off | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the discount | Yes, use your valid corporate discount | missing_precondition | As a current employee, the corporate discount is valid and available. | C3-008 | constraint_removed | strong | hint | shopping | pair | null |
C3-009 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get cheap car registration renewal | I can renew my registration online for just $25 — the cheapest option. But my car failed its emissions test last week. Should I go ahead and renew online? | cheapest / just $25 | A passed emissions test is required for registration renewal; the car failed | Yes, renew online for $25 | No, fix the emissions issue and pass the test first, then renew the registration | missing_precondition | Registration renewal requires a valid emissions test. The car failed, so the renewal will be rejected. The precondition must be satisfied before the cheap renewal can proceed. | C3-009-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | transportation | base | null |
C3-009-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Renew car registration | I can renew online for $25. My car passed emissions last week. Renew? | $25 | None - constraint removed | Yes, renew online | Yes, renew online since all requirements are met | missing_precondition | With a passed emissions test, all preconditions for online renewal are met. | C3-009 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | transportation | pair | null |
C3-010 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap professional certification renewal | I can renew my nursing license online for the early-bird rate of $50 instead of $150. But I haven't completed the required 30 hours of continuing education yet. Should I renew now at the cheap rate? | $50 instead of $150 / early-bird rate | Continuing education hours are a prerequisite for license renewal; they are incomplete | Yes, renew now at the cheap rate | No, complete the continuing education requirements first, then renew. Renewing without meeting prerequisites may result in an invalid license. | missing_precondition | Professional license renewal requires completed continuing education. Attempting to renew without meeting this prerequisite will either fail or result in an invalid renewal. | C3-010-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | work | base | null |
C3-010-pair | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Renew a professional nursing license | I can renew at the early-bird rate of $50. I've completed all 30 CE hours. Renew now? | $50 early-bird | None - constraint removed | Yes, renew now | Yes, renew at the early-bird rate since all requirements are complete | missing_precondition | All continuing education requirements are met, so the early renewal is valid. | C3-010 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | work | pair | null |
C3-011 | C3 | H-cost | C-val | Get a cheap domain name for a new business website | I found the perfect domain name for my business — it's available for just $1 through a registrar's promotional deal. But the deal requires linking a credit card that's been active for 6 months, and I just opened mine last week. Should I grab the $1 deal? | just $1 / promotional deal | The promotional deal requires a credit card active for 6 months; the card was opened last week and does not qualify | Yes, grab the $1 deal | No, you do not meet the card age requirement. Pay the regular price or use a card that meets the criterion. | missing_precondition | The promotional pricing has a precondition (6-month card history) that is not met. The $1 deal cannot be completed with a week-old card. | null | constraint_active | strong | explicit | digital | base | null |
C4-001 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get the transmission repaired | My car's transmission is making grinding noises. The quick oil change place is the cheapest auto service nearby — only $30 for an oil change. Should I take my car there for the transmission issue? | cheapest / $30 | Oil change shops do not repair transmissions; they only perform oil changes and basic maintenance | Yes, take the car to the cheap oil change place | No, go to a transmission specialist or full-service mechanic who can diagnose and repair transmission problems | service_mismatch | Oil change shops specialize in quick oil changes and basic fluid services. Transmission repair is a complex, specialized service far outside their scope. The cheapest auto service cannot provide the needed repair. | C4-001-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | base | null |
C4-001-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get an oil change | I need an oil change. The quick lube shop is cheapest. Go there? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the quick lube shop | Yes, a quick lube shop is designed for oil changes | service_mismatch | An oil change is exactly the service a quick lube shop provides. The cheapest option matches the need. | C4-001 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | transportation | pair | null |
C4-002 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a wedding dress professionally altered with bodice restructuring and lace work | My wedding dress needs significant alterations — bodice restructuring and lace work. The dry cleaner next door offers the cheapest alteration services. Should I go there? | cheapest | Basic dry cleaner alterations cannot handle complex bridal work like bodice restructuring and lace work | Yes, go to the dry cleaner for the cheapest alterations | No, go to a bridal seamstress who specializes in complex wedding dress alterations | service_mismatch | Wedding dress alterations involving bodice restructuring and lace work require specialized bridal tailoring skills. A dry cleaner's basic alteration services (hemming, simple adjustments) cannot handle this complexity. | C4-002-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | shopping | base | null |
C4-002-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get pants hemmed | I need my pants hemmed. The dry cleaner has the cheapest alterations. Go there? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the dry cleaner | Yes, hemming pants is a basic alteration that dry cleaners handle well | service_mismatch | Hemming is a simple alteration within a dry cleaner's standard service scope. | C4-002 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | shopping | pair | null |
C4-003 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Print archival-quality photos for a gallery exhibition | I need to print photos for my gallery exhibition. Generic ink cartridges are half the price of the OEM ones. Should I use the generic cartridges? | half the price | Generic ink may not meet archival or color quality standards required for gallery exhibition prints | Yes, use the cheaper generic ink | No, use OEM or archival-quality ink to ensure color accuracy and longevity for gallery work | service_mismatch | Gallery exhibitions demand archival-quality prints with accurate color reproduction and long-term stability. Generic ink cartridges often have inferior color accuracy and lack archival properties, failing the scope of gallery-grade printing. | C4-003-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C4-003-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Print everyday documents | I need to print everyday documents. Generic ink is half the price. Use it? | half the price | None - constraint removed | Yes, use generic ink | Yes, generic ink is fine for everyday document printing | service_mismatch | Everyday documents do not require archival quality or precise color matching. Generic ink is adequate. | C4-003 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | work | pair | null |
C4-004 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Repair a slow leak in a tire | My tire has a slow leak. The gas station is the cheapest nearby car-service place — they're much cheaper than the tire shop a mile away. Should I go to the gas station? | cheapest / much cheaper | Most gas stations do not repair tires; they may have air pumps but not patching services | Yes, go to the gas station since it is cheaper | No, go to the tire shop which can actually patch or repair the leak | service_mismatch | Gas stations sell fuel and may have air pumps, but tire repair (patching, plugging) requires specialized equipment and skills that gas stations typically do not have. The cheapest option cannot provide the needed service. | C4-004-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | base | null |
C4-004-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Put air in tires | I need to put air in my tires. Gas station is cheapest and closest. Go there? | cheapest and closest | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the gas station | Yes, gas stations have air pumps for inflating tires | service_mismatch | Inflating tires is a standard service gas stations provide via air pumps. The need matches the scope. | C4-004 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | transportation | pair | null |
C4-005 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Become a licensed CPA | I need to become a licensed CPA. There's a cheap $49 online accounting course. The official CPA exam prep is $2,000. Should I take the cheap online course instead? | $49 / cheap | A generic online accounting course does not grant CPA certification; CPA requires specific exam prep, passing the Uniform CPA Exam, and state licensure | Yes, take the $49 online course to save money | No, pursue proper CPA exam preparation and state licensure since a generic course cannot grant CPA certification | service_mismatch | CPA certification requires passing the Uniform CPA Exam and meeting state-specific education and experience requirements. A $49 generic course cannot substitute for this structured professional credentialing process. | C4-005-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C4-005-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Learn basic accounting fundamentals | I want to learn basic accounting. The $49 online course covers fundamentals. Take it? | $49 | None - constraint removed | Yes, take the course | Yes, a $49 online course is suitable for learning accounting basics | service_mismatch | For learning fundamentals without needing a professional certification, a basic online course is adequate. | C4-005 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | work | pair | null |
C4-006 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a cracked load-bearing wooden beam | A wooden beam in my basement has a significant crack. Superglue is the cheapest adhesive I have. Should I use superglue to fix the structural crack? | cheapest | Superglue has no structural strength and cannot repair a load-bearing beam | Yes, use the cheap superglue | No, hire a structural repair specialist because superglue cannot restore structural integrity to a load-bearing beam | service_mismatch | A load-bearing beam supports the structure of the building. Superglue is designed for small surface bonds and has no structural capacity. Using it on a cracked beam is both ineffective and dangerous. | C4-006-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C4-006-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a broken ceramic figurine | My kid's ceramic figurine broke cleanly in two. Superglue is cheapest. Use it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, use superglue | Yes, superglue is excellent for clean ceramic breaks | service_mismatch | Superglue works well for bonding clean ceramic breaks on non-structural decorative items. The scope matches. | C4-006 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C4-007 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get a prescription for antidepressants with proper psychiatric evaluation | I've been struggling with depression and think I need medication. The walk-in clinic is the cheapest option at $50 vs $200 for a psychiatrist. Should I go to the walk-in clinic? | cheapest / $50 vs $200 | Walk-in clinics may not be equipped for psychiatric evaluations and ongoing medication management | Yes, go to the walk-in clinic to save money | No, see a psychiatrist or at least a primary care doctor who can properly evaluate depression and manage psychiatric medication | service_mismatch | Depression evaluation and antidepressant management require specialized psychiatric assessment. Walk-in clinics are designed for acute physical complaints, not psychiatric care. The cheapest option is outside the scope of needed care. | C4-007-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | medical | base | null |
C4-007-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get treatment for a sore throat | I have a sore throat. Walk-in clinic is cheapest. Go there? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, go to the walk-in clinic | Yes, walk-in clinics are designed to handle common ailments like sore throats | service_mismatch | A sore throat is a standard acute physical complaint well within a walk-in clinic's scope. | C4-007 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | medical | pair | null |
C4-008 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Host a high-traffic e-commerce platform with 100,000 daily visitors | I need to host my e-commerce site that gets 100,000 daily visitors. Shared hosting is the cheapest at $5/month vs $200/month for a dedicated server. Should I go with shared hosting? | cheapest / $5/month | Shared hosting cannot reliably handle 100,000 daily visitors due to resource limits | Yes, use shared hosting to save money | No, use dedicated or cloud hosting that can handle the traffic volume reliably | service_mismatch | Shared hosting shares server resources among many sites and typically supports only a few hundred concurrent users. 100K daily visitors requires dedicated resources. The cheapest hosting tier is outside the scope of enterprise traffic needs. | C4-008-pair | constraint_active | strong | explicit | digital | base | null |
C4-008-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Host a personal blog with minimal traffic | I need hosting for my personal blog with 100 visits/day. Shared hosting at $5/month? | $5/month | None - constraint removed | Yes, use shared hosting | Yes, shared hosting handles low-traffic personal blogs perfectly | service_mismatch | 100 visits per day is well within shared hosting capabilities. The cheapest option matches the scope. | C4-008 | constraint_removed | strong | explicit | digital | pair | null |
C4-009 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Properly treat swimming pool water with chlorine | My pool needs chlorine treatment. Household bleach is way cheaper than pool-grade chlorine. Should I just dump household bleach in the pool? | way cheaper | Household bleach has different concentration and additives than pool chemicals; using it can damage the pool or be unsafe | Yes, use household bleach to save money | No, use proper pool-grade chemicals designed for swimming pool treatment | service_mismatch | Household bleach contains fragrances, thickeners, and other additives not designed for pool use. The concentration is different from pool-grade sodium hypochlorite. Using it can cause chemical imbalances, equipment damage, and safety issues. | C4-009-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C4-009-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Disinfect white kitchen counters | I need to disinfect my white kitchen counters. Household bleach is cheapest. Use it? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, use household bleach | Yes, diluted household bleach is a standard kitchen disinfectant | service_mismatch | Household bleach is designed for household disinfection. Cleaning kitchen counters is squarely within its intended use. | C4-009 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C4-010 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Create an international business partnership agreement with a company in Germany | I need a partnership agreement for my joint venture with a company in Germany. A free legal template online is the cheapest option. Should I use the free template? | free / cheapest | International business agreements require jurisdiction-specific legal expertise that a generic template cannot provide | Yes, use the free legal template | No, hire an international business lawyer who understands both US and German law | service_mismatch | International joint ventures involve multiple legal jurisdictions, tax implications, IP rights, and regulatory requirements. A free generic template cannot address Germany-specific legal requirements and could expose the business to significant legal risk. | C4-010-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | work | base | null |
C4-010-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Create a simple NDA for a domestic freelance project | I need a simple NDA for a freelance project. A free template? | free | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the free template | Yes, a free NDA template is generally adequate for simple domestic freelance agreements | service_mismatch | A standard NDA for a domestic freelance project is well-served by a template. No cross-jurisdictional complexity exists. | C4-010 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | work | pair | null |
C4-011 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix faulty electrical wiring that keeps tripping the breaker | The wiring in my bathroom keeps tripping the breaker. My plumber is the cheapest contractor I know and he says he can take a look. Should I have the plumber fix the wiring? | cheapest contractor | Plumbers are not qualified or licensed to perform electrical work | Yes, have the plumber fix the wiring | No, hire a licensed electrician for electrical wiring issues | service_mismatch | Electrical wiring requires a licensed electrician with specific training and certification. A plumber, regardless of being a capable contractor, does not have the qualifications for electrical work. This is both a safety and legal issue. | C4-011-pair | constraint_active | strong | implicit | home | base | null |
C4-011-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Fix a leaking bathroom faucet | My bathroom faucet is leaking. My plumber is cheapest. Call him? | cheapest | None - constraint removed | Yes, call the plumber | Yes, a leaking faucet is exactly what a plumber handles | service_mismatch | Fixing a leaking faucet is core plumbing work. The cheapest contractor is also the right type of contractor. | C4-011 | constraint_removed | strong | implicit | home | pair | null |
C4-012 | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Run a regression analysis on experimental data | I need to run a regression analysis on my dataset. The basic calculator app on my phone is the most readily available tool. Should I use the calculator? | most readily available | A basic calculator app cannot perform regression analysis; it only does arithmetic operations | Yes, use the calculator app | No, use statistical software like R, Python, Excel, or a dedicated statistics tool that can perform regression analysis | service_mismatch | Regression analysis requires fitting models to datasets, computing coefficients, R-squared values, and significance tests. A basic calculator can only do arithmetic. The most available tool is completely outside the scope of statistical analysis. | C4-012-pair | constraint_active | medium | implicit | work | base | null |
C4-012-pair | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Calculate a 15% tip on a restaurant bill | I need to calculate 15% tip on a $47 bill. Use my phone's calculator? | most readily available | None - constraint removed | Yes, use the calculator | Yes, a basic calculator is perfect for calculating a tip percentage | service_mismatch | Calculating a tip is simple arithmetic, which is exactly what a basic calculator does. | C4-012 | constraint_removed | medium | implicit | work | pair | null |
C4-001-str-weak | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get the transmission repaired | My car's transmission is making grinding noises. The quick oil change place is slightly cheaper than the full-service mechanic. Should I take my car to the oil change place for the transmission issue? | slightly cheaper | Oil change shops do not repair transmissions | Yes, take the car to the oil change place | No, go to a transmission specialist or full-service mechanic | service_mismatch | Even with a weak cost cue, the oil change shop still cannot repair transmissions. The scope limitation is unchanged. | C4-001 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C4-001-str-medium | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get the transmission repaired | My car's transmission is making grinding noises. The quick oil change place charges about $30 for services while a transmission specialist would run $500+. Should I try the oil change place first? | $30 vs $500+ | Oil change shops do not repair transmissions | Yes, try the cheaper oil change place first | No, go directly to a transmission specialist since oil change shops cannot repair transmissions | service_mismatch | A moderate price difference makes the oil change shop tempting, but it still cannot perform transmission work regardless of cost. | C4-001 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C4-001-str-strong | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get the transmission repaired | My car's transmission is making grinding noises. The quick oil change place only charges $30 while a transmission specialist quoted me $3,000. That's a massive difference. Should I just take it to the oil change place? | $30 vs $3,000 / massive difference | Oil change shops do not repair transmissions | Yes, save $2,970 and go to the oil change place | No, go to the transmission specialist because oil change shops cannot repair transmissions regardless of price | service_mismatch | Even with a 100x price difference, the oil change shop fundamentally cannot repair a transmission. The scope mismatch is absolute. | C4-001 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C4-001-str-vstrong | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Get the transmission repaired | My car's transmission is making grinding noises. I'm really strapped for cash right now. The quick oil change place is the only auto service I can afford at $30. The transmission specialist wants $4,500 upfront. Should I at least try the oil change place? | $30 / only thing I can afford / $4,500 | Oil change shops do not repair transmissions regardless of financial situation | Yes, try the oil change place since it's all I can afford | No, the oil change shop cannot repair transmissions. Explore financing options, payment plans with a specialist, or used parts shops instead. | service_mismatch | Financial pressure adds emotional weight to the cost cue, but the oil change shop still cannot perform transmission repairs. No amount of financial need changes the service scope. | C4-001 | constraint_active | strong | implicit | transportation | strength_variant | null |
C4-005-str-weak | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Become a licensed CPA | I need to become a licensed CPA. There's a $499 online accounting course vs $600 for the official CPA exam prep. Should I take the slightly cheaper online course? | slightly cheaper / $499 vs $600 | A generic online accounting course does not grant CPA certification | Yes, take the $499 course to save $100 | No, the generic course cannot lead to CPA licensure. Take the official CPA exam prep. | service_mismatch | Even a small price difference does not change the fact that a generic course cannot grant CPA certification. | C4-005 | constraint_active | weak | implicit | work | strength_variant | null |
C4-005-str-medium | C4 | H-cost | C-scope | Become a licensed CPA | I need to become a licensed CPA. There's a $199 online accounting course vs $2,000 for the official CPA prep. Should I start with the cheaper online course? | $199 vs $2,000 | A generic online accounting course does not grant CPA certification | Yes, take the cheaper course first | No, the generic course cannot lead to CPA licensure regardless of price. Take the official CPA exam prep. | service_mismatch | A 10x price difference is tempting, but the generic course cannot result in CPA certification. The scope mismatch remains. | C4-005 | constraint_active | medium | implicit | work | strength_variant | null |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.