yuri1996/round_10_test10 · Datasets at Hugging Face

task_id stringlengths 36 64	winner stringclasses 3 values	ours_penalty float64 3 7.5	leader_penalty float64 3 7	gen_time float64 21.6 34.5	issues stringlengths 145 478
0389434f4e33a4ee85c7009eef2192686facdce54a1292aef9fc6d54888bd03b	draw	5	5	30.002456	Direct pass: Case color, band style, dial floral details, and overall design style do not fully match the prompt.. Swapped pass: Band material, dial floral details, case finish, and small design elements differ from the prompt.
041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28	ours	4	6	29.758915	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (plant elements, bottle texture); second model has major issues (missing plant elements, different bottle style). Swapped pass: First model lacks small plant elements from the prompt; second model includes plant elements but has slight shape differences in the bottle.
08716ba11520bf19be5fe52ab460dc5eebb88cc1fc6ec6ae467d6f15f31b6012	draw	3	4	28.196451	Direct pass: Shape and detail variations, box color/texture differences. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, box color/texture variations; overall close match to prompt elements
0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8	draw	4	5	29.124228	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/color details; second model has moderate differences (color, head bumps, texture). Swapped pass: Missing shell object from prompt; dinosaur color has minor variations (first model closer to prompt’s orange, second model is lighter brown)
0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd	draw	4	5	24.059902	Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Planter carvings less detailed, plant leaf shapes and arrangement slightly off from prompt
1014fbf7feb550ceba4d767cf66eb7808d0052fc4d29a45c1fa6cc7f402c4e83	draw	5	5	23.605394	Direct pass: Style/color mismatch, leaf detail and size differences, canopy structure variations. Swapped pass: Color mismatch, simplified leaf details, structural differences (ribs, canopy shape) from prompt
118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a	draw	6.5	7	23.484782	Direct pass: Both 3D models have shape distortions, missing/incorrect hardware details, and body contour inaccuracies compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have significant shape distortions (e.g., bent necks, irregular body contours) and missing/incorrect hardware details (pickups, bridge, knobs) compared to the prompt's detailed electric guitar.
12b62740dbdf021d7ba7f158b126a319eb0efc99611fb86cb302d929dd4d1f99	draw	5	4.5	29.748257	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in graffiti details, color patterns, and specific design elements between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in graffiti details, color distribution, and shape variations compared to the prompt.
171a5014b52853e23e6d463617bba469397670374ae8a9a75b477a34bc0e5956	draw	4	4	27.767845	Direct pass: Cloth draping, body proportions, and structural details show minor to moderate deviations from the prompt; second model has more significant style and detail inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate detail and style issues.
172103d9-ac53-465c-8328-21be51e90e8e	draw	4	5	28.468526	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has significant style and detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, style variations
1a3c1d5d580473c8a04c166339b8179ff4549c9a3d9baaecd01f788504c7d1ed	draw	3.5	4.5	33.795541	Direct pass: Shape and texture variations from prompt; first model has minor differences, second model has moderate differences in chocolate pattern and cup details.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture variations from the prompt's original details
1a7963ed164daedf4e138483044f9c0ac480e3ccba700bdbba6fe9560958751d	draw	5	6	26.963567	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and text differences; second model has major shape, style, and material mismatches. Swapped pass: Text and bottle shape do not match the original prompt; labeling and bottle details are inaccurate.
1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611	draw	6	6	23.093632	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style/color deviations from the prompt's globe characteristics.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (color/shape variations), second has major issues (style/color deviations)
2074879da6c2380718d2ec005cfc8b72f78b6e99dbffe972b9824c9714131c51	ours	3	5	26.08769	Direct pass: First model has minor texture/chain differences; second has moderate texture/style differences (less glossy, frosted appearance).. Swapped pass: First model has irregular texture/color variations on the pendant; second model has closer pendant texture but minor chain details differ.
20b0e6de039e64ee2392386057e69980ec976b0d13f424077558d435d8add62e	draw	3	4	22.702531	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies. Swapped pass: Minor differences in drawer details, shelf items, and leg proportions; overall style matches but with small inaccuracies.
2229cf5f-955c-4bc2-91c3-df9255a1c01d	draw	6	5	22.347927	Direct pass: Gemstone shape does not match the original’s oval cut, band decorative elements differ in style and detail, prong design variations.. Swapped pass: First model has slight gem shape and band detail differences; second model has major gem cut and band texture differences.
226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f	draw	5.5	5	24.684247	Direct pass: Moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)
23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924	draw	5.5	5	30.973544	Direct pass: Frosting shape/color variations, cocoa dusting differences, and minor layer texture deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape and texture variations in chocolate swirls, layer color inconsistencies, and cocoa dusting details do not match the prompt closely.
261ee46ca52df07a017b6f1f1c5a2a03809e96c18334d4aa5877619ca4d761f1	draw	5.5	4.5	29.728872	Direct pass: Color variations, slight shape differences in pillow and cylindrical object, missing small details like exact pattern alignment and texture.. Swapped pass: First model has minor deviations in pattern details and object positioning; second model has more noticeable differences in pattern accuracy and object design details.
2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe	draw	5.5	6	30.754478	Direct pass: Both models have stylized, simplified shapes with significant differences in structure, valve details, and overall realism compared to the prompt's detailed brass instrument; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, simplified valve mechanisms, and less detailed tubing compared to the prompt's realistic golden instrument.
295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484	draw	5.5	6	27.745281	Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (color variation, water detail differences); second model has major issues (color/style mismatch, water detail differences). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate detail and style differences compared to the prompt.
2fd46d4a00a43e432c5e3f97aad8da63a5313ec5e5eaddd628b048e03617c737	ours	3.5	5.5	25.978854	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., handle/spout proportions, lid shape); second model has moderate issues (style variation, color/lighting differences, and detail inaccuracies). Swapped pass: First model has variations in handle design, color, and shape; second model has minor variations but closer adherence to prompt.
33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94	draw	5	4	26.859456	Direct pass: Color mismatch (first model red vs prompt's rusty brown), detail differences (grille, license plate, rust texture), slight shape variations. Swapped pass: First model has minor texture/color differences; second model has moderate color/texture differences from prompt
364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625	draw	5	5	28.744685	Direct pass: Missing plate and powder, texture/shape variations, arrangement differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Lack of plate and powder, texture/coating details not matching original
3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06	draw	5.5	6.5	26.957644	Direct pass: stylized forms, color mismatches, missing original detail realism. Swapped pass: Item details, color, and structural elements (e.g., bottle shapes, cart design) do not match the prompt's wooden texture and specific objects.
3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549	draw	4.5	5.5	29.090164	Direct pass: First model has minor detail variations; second model has moderate style/color differences and less precise engravings compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Variations in handle design, floral engravings, and detail precision compared to the prompt; shape category matches but minor to moderate detail differences.
3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d	draw	5	5	22.966068	Direct pass: Pattern mismatch (stars/moons not present), bed frame and pillow details inconsistent with prompt.. Swapped pass: Pattern does not match star/moon design, pillow position and bed details vary from prompt
3ecd482e-9b05-4e76-9b67-a7be1b3183e0	draw	5.5	5	30.116663	Direct pass: Window details, roof texture, and surrounding elements do not match the prompt's specific features.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., window/door styles, roof texture consistency); second model includes additional landscaping (vegetation) not present in the prompt, altering the original style.
3f48598320210ac8659a36fd57bccddba1bc5acbab93ac579a0587321088aa84	draw	4	5	27.681418	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/stand differences; second model lacks stand and has style differences.. Swapped pass: First model lacks the wooden stand; second model has mismatched stand design and earrings' appearance (color/texture)
4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59	draw	4.5	4.5	26.221496	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative details, wood texture, and upholstery shading compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues with decorative details (diamond embellishments, wood texture) and slight shape variations; second model has more noticeable deviations in style and detail consistency.
41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60	ours	4	6	31.788822	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model lacks the yellow object with orange part.. Swapped pass: Missing key elements (instrument with droplet, hat band details); shape differences
42faaea9e35e98055ce49e36d86cefcb430ef8476c5a62ba382fb5a7c416c84d	draw	6	5	26.887995	Direct pass: Inconsistent face carving across views; some models lack the prompt's specific jack-o'-lantern face details (round eyes, triangular nose, wide smiling mouth). Swapped pass: Face design variations, inconsistent carved faces across views, color tone deviations, and shape details not matching the prompt's specific pumpkin features.
43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb	draw	5	5	29.286007	Direct pass: Mushroom shape and base texture differ from prompt; first model has uniform log base, second has textured base but mushroom form varies.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, base style mismatch, and lack of prompt-specific misty/organic details
449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8	draw	6	6	32.487722	Direct pass: Both models have moderate to major issues with pipe arrangement, keyboard design, wood texture/accents, and overall detail accuracy compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing/incorrect details (pipes, side panels, ornament details), color tone variations
45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f	draw	3.5	4	31.678015	Direct pass: Minor shape differences, slight detail variations (e.g., tree positions, stair details) between models and prompt; overall style matches but not perfect.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and small detail variations from the prompt
467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c	draw	4	4	33.517858	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/seed detail differences; second model has major shape and detail issues (non-round exterior, seed arrangement).. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences (spine texture, flesh arrangement) from the prompt's rambutan
47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe	draw	5	5	24.958979	Direct pass: Texture detail and shape accuracy have moderate differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Texture details and shape precision are moderate issues; models lack the detailed ridges and sharpness of the prompt.
485f79e73ce1afeb6183f435ad0b4006ae69745a4a1c58137d5e13f9c0355209	draw	6	5	33.580389	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in cookie shape, drizzle consistency, bowl details, and surrounding crumbs; overall structure matches but with noticeable variations in texture and detail.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, cookie texture/shape mismatch, color variations, extra crumbs in second model
49096cb85b6ca2b8ad9e3e69b8defba2d5a07272e488cd24d28702d8480d015f	draw	6.5	6.5	28.209721	Direct pass: First model has mismatched base (puzzle pieces) and altered structure; second model has different overall structure (boxy with drawer) and key arrangement, both deviating from prompt's simple xylophone-like design. Swapped pass: First model has altered structure (drawer, different key layout), second model has different base color, cartoonish style, and additional puzzle piece background not in prompt; both have moderate to major deviations from prompt details.
4b4a7770bcc5f91d930beb1a21b18233749d134464d952839ab1d12902917eba	draw	3.5	4.5	22.461702	Direct pass: Minor shape differences and detail inconsistencies between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and small detail variations between models and prompt
52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869	leader	5	3	23.482884	Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, glow intensity variation.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has moderate detail omissions and style differences.
56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6	draw	5.5	5.5	28.044839	Direct pass: Base design, container shape, and colorful object details differ from prompt; second model has more significant object shape changes.. Swapped pass: Slight to moderate structural and detail differences; first model has minor variations, second has more noticeable deviations from the prompt's design elements.
57d1b4933d29fa17434ada21b48cbbb2b1ace4fb275b85fbd9925b8428cc43d1	draw	5	5	29.279214	Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues: less sparkly texture than the prompt, ribbon color/style differences, and slight pattern/shape deviations.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: altered color vibrancy (less sparkly, more pastel), ribbon style differences, and pattern details that don't match the prompt's vibrant, detailed floral/sequin look.
58ab488ab493d9cdc00cb4ca8223700bed6af74c51325456d3d89ceec228ad1c	draw	5.5	5.5	23.865128	Direct pass: Shape and detail inconsistencies with prompt, varying headlight and body style.. Swapped pass: Slight to moderate differences in body shape, headlight design, and detail accuracy compared to the prompt's futuristic motorcycle.
5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8	draw	5	5	31.066624	Direct pass: Excessive greenery obscures the metal frame structure, and the photorealistic style differs from the sketchy/ethereal aesthetic of the prompt. Swapped pass: Style and foliage density differ from prompt; structure is similar but greenery is overly dense and photorealistic instead of sketchy
5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0	draw	5	5	28.150025	Direct pass: Shape differences, simplified details, not matching the exact split windshield and front end details of the original image.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences from the prompt (e.g., front end proportions, headlight design, body curvature)
5fcb3d44f12a98fc2348159d1ef3c5c09a227cf56452f298294057592b184136	draw	4.5	5	23.125955	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in 3D animal details and book structure consistency with the original prompt.. Swapped pass: Style and detail mismatch with prompt's illustration style; some animal figures differ in shape and arrangement.
60864873e3dcef73f60adbdb9fef1eace2b820b86d76967680f4670edf96b340	draw	4	4.5	29.529306	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate style and architectural detail discrepancies from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations from the prompt's architectural structure and lighting details.
656c99abf95ff5e12d650c2176b8b80df4e5ce09f66a536c09a521525331b0bb	draw	4	5	28.052082	Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor detail mismatches; second model has significant style and detail (text/logo, blade texture) issues.. Swapped pass: Missing text/logo details, slight shape differences in handle and blade
693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4	ours	3	5	27.561863	Direct pass: First model has minor texture and shading differences; second model has more noticeable color and detail discrepancies from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and texture variations; first model has more shading/texture differences, second is closer to prompt's general features.
69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad	draw	3	4	32.513924	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with structure and spot consistency compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations from the prompt's structure.
6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615	draw	6	6	27.135166	Direct pass: Floral details, crack, and overall style do not match the prompt closely; first model has minor issues, second has major issues. Swapped pass: Floral details inconsistent, crack not uniformly present, shape variations across views
6c92f66045cd8523b7e84cb9e799c4694c3574ca18efc52d63127f1f61edd1ca	draw	5	4	30.957436	Direct pass: Cloak texture, belt details, and robe structure show moderate deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has moderate issues with style and significant details missing.
70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9	draw	5	4	28.476984	Direct pass: Clock face details, pendulum design, and wood texture do not match the prompt's accuracy; clock numbers, hands, and pendulum appearance differ from the original image.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in clock face details and frame texture; second model has moderate differences in clock face design, pendulum structure, and frame texture.
713e94c97ab6add102476b51b5c954fba00ec0fd0dc011341bba2066fb1b1518	draw	4	4	27.061412	Direct pass: Bar color variations, frame color differences, and mallet positioning inconsistencies across both 3D model sets.. Swapped pass: Slight shape/color differences, mallet positioning variations, minor structural details not matching exactly.
715afe937c361b7d5f32bfb5128a3191dccbcd4a470b159a41bdd11b7589b2c7	draw	5	5	34.540673	Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing fine details (e.g., pedal positions, glossy finish accuracy). Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details like pedal arrangement and key clarity
7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036	ours	5	6.5	24.641908	Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (simplified patterns), second model has major style/material differences (altered surface reflection, less accurate decorative patterns). Swapped pass: Both models have moderate issues with pattern detail and style adherence; intricate gold decorative patterns from the prompt are less detailed or stylized in the generated models.
739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed	draw	5.5	5	25.853254	Direct pass: Text discrepancies, detail mismatches, and design fidelity issues with both models compared to the prompt. Swapped pass: Text and detail mismatches, shape variations, roof structure differences
76fec295-fbbe-4b3f-9ad1-74d2a3f8f42e	draw	6	5.5	32.238353	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in texture (glossiness), chest emblem details, antenna design, and eye glow intensity.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in texture, chest emblem color, body shape, and antenna count; second model has extra antennas and angular body structure.
7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c	draw	6	6	31.957819	Direct pass: First model has moderate detail/color mismatches; second model has major shape/style deviations from prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences, styling inconsistencies with prompt
79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6	draw	4	5	31.727168	Direct pass: First model has minor issues with floral details and unicorn head positioning; second model has moderate issues with overall detail accuracy and style consistency.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, floral details not matching prompt exactly, gold accents inconsistent
7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41	draw	3	4	29.955509	Direct pass: Color variations in clothing and hat, minor detail differences in clothing and accessories.. Swapped pass: Minor variations in hat colors, clothing details, and guitar specifics; overall character concept matches prompt
7f691c0b893a85f92a4ff3d2fa6d05db141af1b1938ba570fdb474a688ead51e	draw	4	5	24.875954	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail variations; second model has significant structural inconsistencies (holes, uneven spines) not matching prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail inconsistencies with prompt (e.g., slight shape variations, uneven spine distribution, minor stylistic deviations)
7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87	draw	4	4	30.612276	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate issues with band style and hat structure matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape variations; second model has significant crown shape differences from prompt.
7fc7e2ce31d9ceff1351199183a5e37bfb868d76aa2a304f0bbb96e55e031fa5	draw	6	6	29.147458	Direct pass: First model has moderate shape differences (rounded forms vs fluid curves), second model has major structural differences (tangled vs flowing organic shape). Swapped pass: First model has moderate shape differences and missing details; second model has major structural and style differences from the prompt.
854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619	draw	5.5	5.5	23.171741	Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has major issues (significant details missing, style differences). Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape differences, missing small details, and style variations compared to the prompt
88f9719b883378b80f1a76c6e74dbdeabda5f93e9026e164b1031fb659371e41	draw	6	5	28.941449	Direct pass: Shape and detail differences from prompt; first model has simpler structure, second has color and detail variations.. Swapped pass: Style differences, missing flame effect, structural details not matching prompt
8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f	ours	3.5	5.5	31.635329	Direct pass: Shape and texture details of bowl and umbrella deviate from prompt; first model has minor differences, second has moderate differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and color differences in bowl and umbrella structure; second model has closer adherence but still some details off.
8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541	draw	3	3	22.593212	Direct pass: Minor shape differences, color variations, and slight cushion positioning differences compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, leg color variations, cushion placement minor discrepancies
908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015	draw	4.5	4.5	28.433426	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., backrest slat details, leg proportions); second model has moderate style and structural differences (e.g., armrest shape, backrest slat arrangement, wood tone variations) from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., backrest slats, armrest curves), second model has moderate issues (e.g., backrest structure, armrest style, leg proportions) compared to the prompt.
99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06	ours	3	6	22.687685	Direct pass: First model has minor texture differences and lemon position variations; second model lacks the lemon element from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model lacks lemon; both models have grater texture differences.
99abe232dc54996bdfc0116b61e6f2303b8366a25588889399b4c5b64f0f1333	draw	6.5	6	22.946	Direct pass: Moon image clarity and detailed engravings do not match prompt's ornate style and detail level. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail differences (e.g., less intricate frame patterns, slightly altered moon depiction); second model has major style and detail discrepancies (e.g., less ornate frame, less clear moon image, altered overall aesthetic matching the prompt).
99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32	draw	4	5	24.444912	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details and style differences from the prompt (e.g., tentacle curls, pattern intricacy, and overall artistic detail do not fully match the original image's complexity)
9a25117f3143e913c4c7a63f49eee8e0e1f00a195c55bf148b4fb5ffff5d2a8e	draw	4	5	30.236833	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues. Swapped pass: Shape differences, less detailed skin texture, and minor proportions mismatches compared to the prompt's detailed elephant sculpture.
9bf3a49883eb3b428a42a22de9514374613881276627104b83c1bcc14da6ccc7	ours	3	5	31.637024	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues (whisk missing in some views, simplified design).. Swapped pass: First model missing whisk attachment; second model has whisk but has minor shape/details differences.
9d672198b62e5a15983a4eb0ee13d9b70229f8012a5fc0db8e5d5c7dd1c1c9d0	draw	7	6	27.692188	Direct pass: Text does not match 'SM', handle shapes and mug details differ from prompt. Swapped pass: Text does not match original 'SM' stylization, color variations (gradient vs solid), and handle shape differences in both models
9fa13cfe3009a90a1a6bf6d54f80072a502f99837fd0573243a5a44175313ba2	draw	5.5	5.5	25.501824	Direct pass: First model has minor wing detail and color consistency issues; second model has moderate color, detail, and structural differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Wing patterns, body details, and overall realism of both 3D models differ from the prompt; first model has moderate differences, second has major differences.
9fef13410f0c576f398257cc5f8afe27b61a3f75733ba9673e145994451c901e	draw	6	6	28.442039	Direct pass: First model has stylized food items with minor shape differences; second model has significant style, object type, and container color deviations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant deviations in shape, detail, and style from the original prompt.
a0a702cd4913b13fae5fa6c4fc48293f1bdc17dd4c03bf418f43a8c59baa3664	ours	3	4.5	21.568248	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/ detail differences; second model has moderate style/color/chain differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape/color variations, chain details slightly different
a1afc9a29b2f04c62a2dbd716f61729eeac3bc6593f0c9184e62462e4a379489	draw	3	3	22.609691	Direct pass: Minor texture and shape differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor scale texture and shading differences, slight shape variations in some views
a2d0ecb69bc311be5ac46d410eab1be00ffd9285a088feba1285137a5e411a24	draw	5	5.5	30.184477	Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing ornate decorative details, hardware variations from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues with hardware details, text area, and decorative elements; overall shape is book but lacks prompt-specific intricacies.
a7b060c7a72d4f3683fa82b0dd11a5a2d3defcc71a30e8fae0411fd9266c1572	draw	3	3	22.275386	Direct pass: Minor shape/lighting differences, slight base texture variations. Swapped pass: Slight variations in candle shading and base texture details
aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25	draw	4	4	28.336938	Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (e.g., red button not in prompt); second model has more significant style and detail issues (darker, less accurate structure).. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and small detail variations; second model has more noticeable differences including a red button on top and style variations.
ac64dc89a5302c47617b0934b9693abb5b26b02a95e8a13b3b0feb97da92405a	draw	4.5	5.5	26.398453	Direct pass: First model has minor book arrangement and detail differences; second model has significant frame transparency and book style deviations.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: slight shape differences, non-book items on shelves, and variations in book arrangement compared to the prompt's clean, diverse bookshelf with consistent lighting and structure.
ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa	draw	4	3	31.763873	Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, minor detail variations); second model has moderate issues (color tone deviation, less precise clothing details, minor shape differences)
affafd67f649843b60f5bd0af9770568f292a354a38bdfc45ad6cca224db2576	draw	4.5	5	31.954239	Direct pass: Slight to moderate differences in detail, texture, and design elements between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, detail accuracy, and texture matching issues between models and prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues
bbf842eb949a678b25ab76333ff494adeffc7b86c26cf83b48730b8f09f4f0b1	draw	5.5	6.5	26.109148	Direct pass: Style mismatch, figure details simplified, rope texture and color variations.. Swapped pass: Rope color, texture, and knot structure differ from prompt; figure details are simplified
bc31ba30-2ff4-47eb-9b7d-c6f68c6b7108	draw	5.5	5	23.215162	Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with roof texture, window details, and landscaping; some structural elements (like roof shape, chimney design, and window arrangement) do not match the prompt exactly.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences; inconsistent with prompt's specific architectural features (e.g., window arrangement, porch design, landscaping) and roof/brick details.
bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8	draw	4	5	26.790322	Direct pass: Slight shape differences, color variations, and minor detail discrepancies between models and prompt. Swapped pass: Minor structural and detail differences from prompt; color and general concept match but specific components (straps, tassels, component proportions) vary.
bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338	draw	5	5	27.189862	Direct pass: Moderate differences in leaf shape, trunk detail, and overall structure compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences in leaves and flowers, less defined trunk texture compared to prompt; moderate detail discrepancies
bee9d868d4f6a6e662a9f617cdbd1fabd4533cb7e2da74d1ddcc4ccfb59d0a66	draw	4.5	4.5	26.549074	Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor flame detail variations, color tone consistency issues.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, color variations, possible flame detail inconsistencies
c01c79d97d1bb88aedb82ed800fdfa1f92786b1595303195c85a88c3471062f5	draw	4.5	4.5	24.898398	Direct pass: Minor issues in interior shelf details and lighting consistency; moderate issues in exterior finish and lighting consistency for the second model.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in shelf structure, interior lighting, and small design elements (e.g., control knob, door handle details) compared to the prompt.
c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283	draw	4.5	4.5	27.723337	Direct pass: Minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details). Swapped pass: Branch shape, claw details, and pattern consistency vary from the prompt; minor shape differences exist in both models.
c2972a848235384091afec85c53cf3ad9f6d1a6f5a40e1da41496ded11469ebc	draw	5.5	5.5	28.539237	Direct pass: Slight shape differences in sails and ship structure, some details like sail markings and base design vary from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Sail patterns, hull details, and structural elements do not fully match the prompt's ship model; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.
c5ebdff779e074b0982d9a6295ba88e4bf099a6fcbfea629bdcfc3978331da52	draw	5	6	31.268663	Direct pass: First model has moderate detail discrepancies (e.g., less intricate railings, altered decorative elements); second model has major structural and decorative inaccuracies compared to the prompt’s ornate, detailed design.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, less intricate gold railings compared to prompt
c72c314361079e968e0d32cd3e65db76bda901cb0a9cd776627549a4eb9b7e8b	ours	3	5	29.870272	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative carvings, upholstery texture, and structural details between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate detail differences in backrest carving, armrest design, and leg shapes between models and prompt.
c921b2305781e3fe649d2f302fa40630877555e39a9f87302304971d2f3bfe7c	draw	3	4	22.930264	Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has moderate differences in texture and details. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences, slight color variation in second model
ca2a0d797355db7064a6709c0ed63cc2270123cb92bc75a89c3832ff9f75e4b5	leader	7.5	5	27.613461	Direct pass: Shape differences, band type (first model has metallic/angled, second has leather), dial details, and decorative elements do not match the prompt's watch style and design. Swapped pass: First model has incorrect strap material (brown leather instead of metallic) and minor dial details; second model has incorrect octagonal case shape instead of round, with altered dial and bezel design.
cc378d1e19286afaeabbe13f4fff7a24546f085b51d3adea9ecf269b32318888	draw	6	6	23.346658	Direct pass: Bird and clock face details inconsistent with prompt; shape variations. Swapped pass: Clock face details (bird, numerals), structural elements (columns, base, roof) do not match prompt; bird style and clock face design differ significantly.
d13cba200c783d0b536ecaa24f51c97581d895656e65b9087bf2c0fc2813d3be	draw	5	5	27.199484	Direct pass: Both 3D models have style differences (e.g., color tone, face detail layout) and missing specific details compared to the prompt, with moderate overall mismatch.. Swapped pass: Both models have moderate issues with dial details, case shape, and button designs not matching the prompt.

0389434f4e33a4ee85c7009eef2192686facdce54a1292aef9fc6d54888bd03b

draw

5

30.002456

Direct pass: Case color, band style, dial floral details, and overall design style do not fully match the prompt.. Swapped pass: Band material, dial floral details, case finish, and small design elements differ from the prompt.

041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28

ours

4

6

29.758915

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (plant elements, bottle texture); second model has major issues (missing plant elements, different bottle style). Swapped pass: First model lacks small plant elements from the prompt; second model includes plant elements but has slight shape differences in the bottle.

08716ba11520bf19be5fe52ab460dc5eebb88cc1fc6ec6ae467d6f15f31b6012

draw

3

4

28.196451

Direct pass: Shape and detail variations, box color/texture differences. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, box color/texture variations; overall close match to prompt elements

0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8

draw

4

5

29.124228

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/color details; second model has moderate differences (color, head bumps, texture). Swapped pass: Missing shell object from prompt; dinosaur color has minor variations (first model closer to prompt’s orange, second model is lighter brown)

0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd

draw

4

5

24.059902

Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Planter carvings less detailed, plant leaf shapes and arrangement slightly off from prompt

1014fbf7feb550ceba4d767cf66eb7808d0052fc4d29a45c1fa6cc7f402c4e83

draw

5

23.605394

Direct pass: Style/color mismatch, leaf detail and size differences, canopy structure variations. Swapped pass: Color mismatch, simplified leaf details, structural differences (ribs, canopy shape) from prompt

118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a

draw

6.5

7

23.484782

Direct pass: Both 3D models have shape distortions, missing/incorrect hardware details, and body contour inaccuracies compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have significant shape distortions (e.g., bent necks, irregular body contours) and missing/incorrect hardware details (pickups, bridge, knobs) compared to the prompt's detailed electric guitar.

12b62740dbdf021d7ba7f158b126a319eb0efc99611fb86cb302d929dd4d1f99

draw

5

4.5

29.748257

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in graffiti details, color patterns, and specific design elements between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in graffiti details, color distribution, and shape variations compared to the prompt.

171a5014b52853e23e6d463617bba469397670374ae8a9a75b477a34bc0e5956

draw

4

27.767845

Direct pass: Cloth draping, body proportions, and structural details show minor to moderate deviations from the prompt; second model has more significant style and detail inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate detail and style issues.

172103d9-ac53-465c-8328-21be51e90e8e

draw

4

5

28.468526

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has significant style and detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, style variations

1a3c1d5d580473c8a04c166339b8179ff4549c9a3d9baaecd01f788504c7d1ed

draw

3.5

4.5

33.795541

Direct pass: Shape and texture variations from prompt; first model has minor differences, second model has moderate differences in chocolate pattern and cup details.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture variations from the prompt's original details

1a7963ed164daedf4e138483044f9c0ac480e3ccba700bdbba6fe9560958751d

draw

5

6

26.963567

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and text differences; second model has major shape, style, and material mismatches. Swapped pass: Text and bottle shape do not match the original prompt; labeling and bottle details are inaccurate.

1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611

draw

6

23.093632

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style/color deviations from the prompt's globe characteristics.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (color/shape variations), second has major issues (style/color deviations)

2074879da6c2380718d2ec005cfc8b72f78b6e99dbffe972b9824c9714131c51

ours

3

5

26.08769

Direct pass: First model has minor texture/chain differences; second has moderate texture/style differences (less glossy, frosted appearance).. Swapped pass: First model has irregular texture/color variations on the pendant; second model has closer pendant texture but minor chain details differ.

20b0e6de039e64ee2392386057e69980ec976b0d13f424077558d435d8add62e

draw

3

4

22.702531

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies. Swapped pass: Minor differences in drawer details, shelf items, and leg proportions; overall style matches but with small inaccuracies.

2229cf5f-955c-4bc2-91c3-df9255a1c01d

draw

6

5

22.347927

Direct pass: Gemstone shape does not match the original’s oval cut, band decorative elements differ in style and detail, prong design variations.. Swapped pass: First model has slight gem shape and band detail differences; second model has major gem cut and band texture differences.

226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f

draw

5.5

5

24.684247

Direct pass: Moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)

23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924

draw

5.5

5

30.973544

Direct pass: Frosting shape/color variations, cocoa dusting differences, and minor layer texture deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape and texture variations in chocolate swirls, layer color inconsistencies, and cocoa dusting details do not match the prompt closely.

261ee46ca52df07a017b6f1f1c5a2a03809e96c18334d4aa5877619ca4d761f1

draw

5.5

4.5

29.728872

Direct pass: Color variations, slight shape differences in pillow and cylindrical object, missing small details like exact pattern alignment and texture.. Swapped pass: First model has minor deviations in pattern details and object positioning; second model has more noticeable differences in pattern accuracy and object design details.

2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe

draw

5.5

6

30.754478

Direct pass: Both models have stylized, simplified shapes with significant differences in structure, valve details, and overall realism compared to the prompt's detailed brass instrument; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, simplified valve mechanisms, and less detailed tubing compared to the prompt's realistic golden instrument.

295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484

draw

5.5

6

27.745281

Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (color variation, water detail differences); second model has major issues (color/style mismatch, water detail differences). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate detail and style differences compared to the prompt.

2fd46d4a00a43e432c5e3f97aad8da63a5313ec5e5eaddd628b048e03617c737

ours

3.5

5.5

25.978854

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., handle/spout proportions, lid shape); second model has moderate issues (style variation, color/lighting differences, and detail inaccuracies). Swapped pass: First model has variations in handle design, color, and shape; second model has minor variations but closer adherence to prompt.

33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94

draw

5

4

26.859456

Direct pass: Color mismatch (first model red vs prompt's rusty brown), detail differences (grille, license plate, rust texture), slight shape variations. Swapped pass: First model has minor texture/color differences; second model has moderate color/texture differences from prompt

364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625

draw

5

28.744685

Direct pass: Missing plate and powder, texture/shape variations, arrangement differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Lack of plate and powder, texture/coating details not matching original

3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06

draw

5.5

6.5

26.957644

Direct pass: stylized forms, color mismatches, missing original detail realism. Swapped pass: Item details, color, and structural elements (e.g., bottle shapes, cart design) do not match the prompt's wooden texture and specific objects.

3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549

draw

4.5

5.5

29.090164

Direct pass: First model has minor detail variations; second model has moderate style/color differences and less precise engravings compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Variations in handle design, floral engravings, and detail precision compared to the prompt; shape category matches but minor to moderate detail differences.

3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d

draw

5

22.966068

Direct pass: Pattern mismatch (stars/moons not present), bed frame and pillow details inconsistent with prompt.. Swapped pass: Pattern does not match star/moon design, pillow position and bed details vary from prompt

3ecd482e-9b05-4e76-9b67-a7be1b3183e0

draw

5.5

5

30.116663

Direct pass: Window details, roof texture, and surrounding elements do not match the prompt's specific features.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., window/door styles, roof texture consistency); second model includes additional landscaping (vegetation) not present in the prompt, altering the original style.

3f48598320210ac8659a36fd57bccddba1bc5acbab93ac579a0587321088aa84

draw

4

5

27.681418

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/stand differences; second model lacks stand and has style differences.. Swapped pass: First model lacks the wooden stand; second model has mismatched stand design and earrings' appearance (color/texture)

4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59

draw

4.5

26.221496

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative details, wood texture, and upholstery shading compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues with decorative details (diamond embellishments, wood texture) and slight shape variations; second model has more noticeable deviations in style and detail consistency.

41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60

ours

4

6

31.788822

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model lacks the yellow object with orange part.. Swapped pass: Missing key elements (instrument with droplet, hat band details); shape differences

42faaea9e35e98055ce49e36d86cefcb430ef8476c5a62ba382fb5a7c416c84d

draw

6

5

26.887995

Direct pass: Inconsistent face carving across views; some models lack the prompt's specific jack-o'-lantern face details (round eyes, triangular nose, wide smiling mouth). Swapped pass: Face design variations, inconsistent carved faces across views, color tone deviations, and shape details not matching the prompt's specific pumpkin features.

43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb

draw

5

29.286007

Direct pass: Mushroom shape and base texture differ from prompt; first model has uniform log base, second has textured base but mushroom form varies.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, base style mismatch, and lack of prompt-specific misty/organic details

449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8

draw

6

32.487722

Direct pass: Both models have moderate to major issues with pipe arrangement, keyboard design, wood texture/accents, and overall detail accuracy compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing/incorrect details (pipes, side panels, ornament details), color tone variations

45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f

draw

3.5

4

31.678015

Direct pass: Minor shape differences, slight detail variations (e.g., tree positions, stair details) between models and prompt; overall style matches but not perfect.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and small detail variations from the prompt

467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c

draw

4

33.517858

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/seed detail differences; second model has major shape and detail issues (non-round exterior, seed arrangement).. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences (spine texture, flesh arrangement) from the prompt's rambutan

47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe

draw

5

24.958979

Direct pass: Texture detail and shape accuracy have moderate differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Texture details and shape precision are moderate issues; models lack the detailed ridges and sharpness of the prompt.

485f79e73ce1afeb6183f435ad0b4006ae69745a4a1c58137d5e13f9c0355209

draw

6

5

33.580389

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in cookie shape, drizzle consistency, bowl details, and surrounding crumbs; overall structure matches but with noticeable variations in texture and detail.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, cookie texture/shape mismatch, color variations, extra crumbs in second model

49096cb85b6ca2b8ad9e3e69b8defba2d5a07272e488cd24d28702d8480d015f

draw

6.5

28.209721

Direct pass: First model has mismatched base (puzzle pieces) and altered structure; second model has different overall structure (boxy with drawer) and key arrangement, both deviating from prompt's simple xylophone-like design. Swapped pass: First model has altered structure (drawer, different key layout), second model has different base color, cartoonish style, and additional puzzle piece background not in prompt; both have moderate to major deviations from prompt details.

4b4a7770bcc5f91d930beb1a21b18233749d134464d952839ab1d12902917eba

draw

3.5

4.5

22.461702

Direct pass: Minor shape differences and detail inconsistencies between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and small detail variations between models and prompt

52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869

leader

5

3

23.482884

Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, glow intensity variation.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has moderate detail omissions and style differences.

56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6

draw

5.5

28.044839

Direct pass: Base design, container shape, and colorful object details differ from prompt; second model has more significant object shape changes.. Swapped pass: Slight to moderate structural and detail differences; first model has minor variations, second has more noticeable deviations from the prompt's design elements.

57d1b4933d29fa17434ada21b48cbbb2b1ace4fb275b85fbd9925b8428cc43d1

draw

5

29.279214

Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues: less sparkly texture than the prompt, ribbon color/style differences, and slight pattern/shape deviations.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: altered color vibrancy (less sparkly, more pastel), ribbon style differences, and pattern details that don't match the prompt's vibrant, detailed floral/sequin look.

58ab488ab493d9cdc00cb4ca8223700bed6af74c51325456d3d89ceec228ad1c

draw

5.5

23.865128

Direct pass: Shape and detail inconsistencies with prompt, varying headlight and body style.. Swapped pass: Slight to moderate differences in body shape, headlight design, and detail accuracy compared to the prompt's futuristic motorcycle.

5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8

draw

5

31.066624

Direct pass: Excessive greenery obscures the metal frame structure, and the photorealistic style differs from the sketchy/ethereal aesthetic of the prompt. Swapped pass: Style and foliage density differ from prompt; structure is similar but greenery is overly dense and photorealistic instead of sketchy

5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0

draw

5

28.150025

Direct pass: Shape differences, simplified details, not matching the exact split windshield and front end details of the original image.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences from the prompt (e.g., front end proportions, headlight design, body curvature)

5fcb3d44f12a98fc2348159d1ef3c5c09a227cf56452f298294057592b184136

draw

4.5

5

23.125955

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in 3D animal details and book structure consistency with the original prompt.. Swapped pass: Style and detail mismatch with prompt's illustration style; some animal figures differ in shape and arrangement.

60864873e3dcef73f60adbdb9fef1eace2b820b86d76967680f4670edf96b340

draw

4

4.5

29.529306

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate style and architectural detail discrepancies from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations from the prompt's architectural structure and lighting details.

656c99abf95ff5e12d650c2176b8b80df4e5ce09f66a536c09a521525331b0bb

draw

4

5

28.052082

Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor detail mismatches; second model has significant style and detail (text/logo, blade texture) issues.. Swapped pass: Missing text/logo details, slight shape differences in handle and blade

693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4

ours

3

5

27.561863

Direct pass: First model has minor texture and shading differences; second model has more noticeable color and detail discrepancies from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and texture variations; first model has more shading/texture differences, second is closer to prompt's general features.

69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad

draw

3

4

32.513924

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with structure and spot consistency compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations from the prompt's structure.

6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615

draw

6

27.135166

Direct pass: Floral details, crack, and overall style do not match the prompt closely; first model has minor issues, second has major issues. Swapped pass: Floral details inconsistent, crack not uniformly present, shape variations across views

6c92f66045cd8523b7e84cb9e799c4694c3574ca18efc52d63127f1f61edd1ca

draw

5

4

30.957436

Direct pass: Cloak texture, belt details, and robe structure show moderate deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has moderate issues with style and significant details missing.

70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9

draw

5

4

28.476984

Direct pass: Clock face details, pendulum design, and wood texture do not match the prompt's accuracy; clock numbers, hands, and pendulum appearance differ from the original image.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in clock face details and frame texture; second model has moderate differences in clock face design, pendulum structure, and frame texture.

713e94c97ab6add102476b51b5c954fba00ec0fd0dc011341bba2066fb1b1518

draw

4

27.061412

Direct pass: Bar color variations, frame color differences, and mallet positioning inconsistencies across both 3D model sets.. Swapped pass: Slight shape/color differences, mallet positioning variations, minor structural details not matching exactly.

715afe937c361b7d5f32bfb5128a3191dccbcd4a470b159a41bdd11b7589b2c7

draw

5

34.540673

Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing fine details (e.g., pedal positions, glossy finish accuracy). Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details like pedal arrangement and key clarity

7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036

ours

5

6.5

24.641908

Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (simplified patterns), second model has major style/material differences (altered surface reflection, less accurate decorative patterns). Swapped pass: Both models have moderate issues with pattern detail and style adherence; intricate gold decorative patterns from the prompt are less detailed or stylized in the generated models.

739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed

draw

5.5

5

25.853254

Direct pass: Text discrepancies, detail mismatches, and design fidelity issues with both models compared to the prompt. Swapped pass: Text and detail mismatches, shape variations, roof structure differences

76fec295-fbbe-4b3f-9ad1-74d2a3f8f42e

draw

6

5.5

32.238353

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in texture (glossiness), chest emblem details, antenna design, and eye glow intensity.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in texture, chest emblem color, body shape, and antenna count; second model has extra antennas and angular body structure.

7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c

draw

6

31.957819

Direct pass: First model has moderate detail/color mismatches; second model has major shape/style deviations from prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences, styling inconsistencies with prompt

79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6

draw

4

5

31.727168

Direct pass: First model has minor issues with floral details and unicorn head positioning; second model has moderate issues with overall detail accuracy and style consistency.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, floral details not matching prompt exactly, gold accents inconsistent

7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41

draw

3

4

29.955509

Direct pass: Color variations in clothing and hat, minor detail differences in clothing and accessories.. Swapped pass: Minor variations in hat colors, clothing details, and guitar specifics; overall character concept matches prompt

7f691c0b893a85f92a4ff3d2fa6d05db141af1b1938ba570fdb474a688ead51e

draw

4

5

24.875954

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail variations; second model has significant structural inconsistencies (holes, uneven spines) not matching prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail inconsistencies with prompt (e.g., slight shape variations, uneven spine distribution, minor stylistic deviations)

7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87

draw

4

30.612276

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate issues with band style and hat structure matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape variations; second model has significant crown shape differences from prompt.

7fc7e2ce31d9ceff1351199183a5e37bfb868d76aa2a304f0bbb96e55e031fa5

draw

6

29.147458

Direct pass: First model has moderate shape differences (rounded forms vs fluid curves), second model has major structural differences (tangled vs flowing organic shape). Swapped pass: First model has moderate shape differences and missing details; second model has major structural and style differences from the prompt.

854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619

draw

5.5

23.171741

Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has major issues (significant details missing, style differences). Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape differences, missing small details, and style variations compared to the prompt

88f9719b883378b80f1a76c6e74dbdeabda5f93e9026e164b1031fb659371e41

draw

6

5

28.941449

Direct pass: Shape and detail differences from prompt; first model has simpler structure, second has color and detail variations.. Swapped pass: Style differences, missing flame effect, structural details not matching prompt

8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f

ours

3.5

5.5

31.635329

Direct pass: Shape and texture details of bowl and umbrella deviate from prompt; first model has minor differences, second has moderate differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and color differences in bowl and umbrella structure; second model has closer adherence but still some details off.

8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541

draw

3

22.593212

Direct pass: Minor shape differences, color variations, and slight cushion positioning differences compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, leg color variations, cushion placement minor discrepancies

908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015

draw

4.5

28.433426

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., backrest slat details, leg proportions); second model has moderate style and structural differences (e.g., armrest shape, backrest slat arrangement, wood tone variations) from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., backrest slats, armrest curves), second model has moderate issues (e.g., backrest structure, armrest style, leg proportions) compared to the prompt.

99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06

ours

3

6

22.687685

Direct pass: First model has minor texture differences and lemon position variations; second model lacks the lemon element from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model lacks lemon; both models have grater texture differences.

99abe232dc54996bdfc0116b61e6f2303b8366a25588889399b4c5b64f0f1333

draw

6.5

6

22.946

Direct pass: Moon image clarity and detailed engravings do not match prompt's ornate style and detail level. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail differences (e.g., less intricate frame patterns, slightly altered moon depiction); second model has major style and detail discrepancies (e.g., less ornate frame, less clear moon image, altered overall aesthetic matching the prompt).

99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32

draw

4

5

24.444912

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details and style differences from the prompt (e.g., tentacle curls, pattern intricacy, and overall artistic detail do not fully match the original image's complexity)

9a25117f3143e913c4c7a63f49eee8e0e1f00a195c55bf148b4fb5ffff5d2a8e

draw

4

5

30.236833

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues. Swapped pass: Shape differences, less detailed skin texture, and minor proportions mismatches compared to the prompt's detailed elephant sculpture.

9bf3a49883eb3b428a42a22de9514374613881276627104b83c1bcc14da6ccc7

ours

3

5

31.637024

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues (whisk missing in some views, simplified design).. Swapped pass: First model missing whisk attachment; second model has whisk but has minor shape/details differences.

9d672198b62e5a15983a4eb0ee13d9b70229f8012a5fc0db8e5d5c7dd1c1c9d0

draw

7

6

27.692188

Direct pass: Text does not match 'SM', handle shapes and mug details differ from prompt. Swapped pass: Text does not match original 'SM' stylization, color variations (gradient vs solid), and handle shape differences in both models

9fa13cfe3009a90a1a6bf6d54f80072a502f99837fd0573243a5a44175313ba2

draw

5.5

25.501824

Direct pass: First model has minor wing detail and color consistency issues; second model has moderate color, detail, and structural differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Wing patterns, body details, and overall realism of both 3D models differ from the prompt; first model has moderate differences, second has major differences.

9fef13410f0c576f398257cc5f8afe27b61a3f75733ba9673e145994451c901e

draw

6

28.442039

Direct pass: First model has stylized food items with minor shape differences; second model has significant style, object type, and container color deviations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant deviations in shape, detail, and style from the original prompt.

a0a702cd4913b13fae5fa6c4fc48293f1bdc17dd4c03bf418f43a8c59baa3664

ours

3

4.5

21.568248

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/ detail differences; second model has moderate style/color/chain differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape/color variations, chain details slightly different

a1afc9a29b2f04c62a2dbd716f61729eeac3bc6593f0c9184e62462e4a379489

draw

3

22.609691

Direct pass: Minor texture and shape differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor scale texture and shading differences, slight shape variations in some views

a2d0ecb69bc311be5ac46d410eab1be00ffd9285a088feba1285137a5e411a24

draw

5

5.5

30.184477

Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing ornate decorative details, hardware variations from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues with hardware details, text area, and decorative elements; overall shape is book but lacks prompt-specific intricacies.

a7b060c7a72d4f3683fa82b0dd11a5a2d3defcc71a30e8fae0411fd9266c1572

draw

3

22.275386

Direct pass: Minor shape/lighting differences, slight base texture variations. Swapped pass: Slight variations in candle shading and base texture details

aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25

draw

4

28.336938

Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (e.g., red button not in prompt); second model has more significant style and detail issues (darker, less accurate structure).. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and small detail variations; second model has more noticeable differences including a red button on top and style variations.

ac64dc89a5302c47617b0934b9693abb5b26b02a95e8a13b3b0feb97da92405a

draw

4.5

5.5

26.398453

Direct pass: First model has minor book arrangement and detail differences; second model has significant frame transparency and book style deviations.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: slight shape differences, non-book items on shelves, and variations in book arrangement compared to the prompt's clean, diverse bookshelf with consistent lighting and structure.

ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa

draw

4

3

31.763873

Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, minor detail variations); second model has moderate issues (color tone deviation, less precise clothing details, minor shape differences)

affafd67f649843b60f5bd0af9770568f292a354a38bdfc45ad6cca224db2576

draw

4.5

5

31.954239

Direct pass: Slight to moderate differences in detail, texture, and design elements between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, detail accuracy, and texture matching issues between models and prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues

bbf842eb949a678b25ab76333ff494adeffc7b86c26cf83b48730b8f09f4f0b1

draw

5.5

6.5

26.109148

Direct pass: Style mismatch, figure details simplified, rope texture and color variations.. Swapped pass: Rope color, texture, and knot structure differ from prompt; figure details are simplified

bc31ba30-2ff4-47eb-9b7d-c6f68c6b7108

draw

5.5

5

23.215162

Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with roof texture, window details, and landscaping; some structural elements (like roof shape, chimney design, and window arrangement) do not match the prompt exactly.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences; inconsistent with prompt's specific architectural features (e.g., window arrangement, porch design, landscaping) and roof/brick details.

bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8

draw

4

5

26.790322

Direct pass: Slight shape differences, color variations, and minor detail discrepancies between models and prompt. Swapped pass: Minor structural and detail differences from prompt; color and general concept match but specific components (straps, tassels, component proportions) vary.

bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338

draw

5

27.189862

Direct pass: Moderate differences in leaf shape, trunk detail, and overall structure compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences in leaves and flowers, less defined trunk texture compared to prompt; moderate detail discrepancies

bee9d868d4f6a6e662a9f617cdbd1fabd4533cb7e2da74d1ddcc4ccfb59d0a66

draw

4.5

26.549074

Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor flame detail variations, color tone consistency issues.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, color variations, possible flame detail inconsistencies

c01c79d97d1bb88aedb82ed800fdfa1f92786b1595303195c85a88c3471062f5

draw

4.5

24.898398

Direct pass: Minor issues in interior shelf details and lighting consistency; moderate issues in exterior finish and lighting consistency for the second model.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in shelf structure, interior lighting, and small design elements (e.g., control knob, door handle details) compared to the prompt.

c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283

draw

4.5

27.723337

Direct pass: Minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details). Swapped pass: Branch shape, claw details, and pattern consistency vary from the prompt; minor shape differences exist in both models.

c2972a848235384091afec85c53cf3ad9f6d1a6f5a40e1da41496ded11469ebc

draw

5.5

28.539237

Direct pass: Slight shape differences in sails and ship structure, some details like sail markings and base design vary from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Sail patterns, hull details, and structural elements do not fully match the prompt's ship model; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.

c5ebdff779e074b0982d9a6295ba88e4bf099a6fcbfea629bdcfc3978331da52

draw

5

6

31.268663

Direct pass: First model has moderate detail discrepancies (e.g., less intricate railings, altered decorative elements); second model has major structural and decorative inaccuracies compared to the prompt’s ornate, detailed design.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, less intricate gold railings compared to prompt

c72c314361079e968e0d32cd3e65db76bda901cb0a9cd776627549a4eb9b7e8b

ours

3

5

29.870272

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative carvings, upholstery texture, and structural details between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate detail differences in backrest carving, armrest design, and leg shapes between models and prompt.

c921b2305781e3fe649d2f302fa40630877555e39a9f87302304971d2f3bfe7c

draw

3

4

22.930264

Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has moderate differences in texture and details. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences, slight color variation in second model

ca2a0d797355db7064a6709c0ed63cc2270123cb92bc75a89c3832ff9f75e4b5

leader

7.5

5

27.613461

Direct pass: Shape differences, band type (first model has metallic/angled, second has leather), dial details, and decorative elements do not match the prompt's watch style and design. Swapped pass: First model has incorrect strap material (brown leather instead of metallic) and minor dial details; second model has incorrect octagonal case shape instead of round, with altered dial and bezel design.

cc378d1e19286afaeabbe13f4fff7a24546f085b51d3adea9ecf269b32318888

draw

6

23.346658

Direct pass: Bird and clock face details inconsistent with prompt; shape variations. Swapped pass: Clock face details (bird, numerals), structural elements (columns, base, roof) do not match prompt; bird style and clock face design differ significantly.

d13cba200c783d0b536ecaa24f51c97581d895656e65b9087bf2c0fc2813d3be

draw

5

27.199484

Direct pass: Both 3D models have style differences (e.g., color tone, face detail layout) and missing specific details compared to the prompt, with moderate overall mismatch.. Swapped pass: Both models have moderate issues with dial details, case shape, and button designs not matching the prompt.

Metric	Value
Total Tasks	128
Total Judged	120
Skipped	0
Gen Failed	0
Render Failed	0
Judge Failed	8

Result	Count
🏆 WINS	16
🤝 DRAWS	101
❌ LOSSES	3

Metric	Value
Win Rate	13.3%
Margin	+10.8%
Avg Gen Time	27.45s

Datasets:

yuri1996
/

round_10_test10

Benchmark Results: test10

Overview

Summary

Results

Performance

Methodology

Files