task_id
stringlengths 36
64
| origin
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| origin_white
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| ours
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| leader
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| winner
stringclasses 3
values | ours_penalty
float64 3
7.5
| leader_penalty
float64 3
7
| gen_time
float64 15.4
28.1
| issues
stringlengths 148
510
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
0389434f4e33a4ee85c7009eef2192686facdce54a1292aef9fc6d54888bd03b
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 20.981504
|
Direct pass: Band texture, case color, and floral detail accuracy differ from the prompt; band style, case hue, and floral intricacy do not match the original image.. Swapped pass: Band style, case shape, and dial floral detail differ from the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.
|
||||
041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 21.077671
|
Direct pass: First model has mismatched plant elements and slight shape differences; second model lacks plant elements and has significant shape differences.. Swapped pass: First model lacks small plant elements; second model has plant elements but has shape differences from the original bottle.
|
||||
08716ba11520bf19be5fe52ab460dc5eebb88cc1fc6ec6ae467d6f15f31b6012
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 18.571818
|
Direct pass: Box design, horn details, and shape variations do not fully match the prompt; minor to moderate discrepancies in object structure and appearance.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and box texture variations; second model has significant box detail changes and altered horn structure.
|
||||
0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8
|
leader
| 7.5
| 4
| 21.035041
|
Direct pass: First model has major scene deviation (includes multiple dinosaurs, landscape, etc. not in prompt); second model misses the shell object from the prompt but has a dinosaur close in shape/color.. Swapped pass: First model has minor deviations (slight color/texture differences) but matches the single dinosaur subject; second model has major issues (complex environment with multiple creatures, not matching the prompt’s simple two-element setup)
|
||||
0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd
|
ours
| 3.5
| 5.5
| 23.54125
|
Direct pass: Planter carvings differ in detail, plant foliage has slight shape variations, chili pepper positions and details are not exact matches.. Swapped pass: Planter decorative details and plant density/arrangement differ from prompt; first model has more noticeable deviations.
|
||||
1014fbf7feb550ceba4d767cf66eb7808d0052fc4d29a45c1fa6cc7f402c4e83
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 17.635373
|
Direct pass: First model has color, leaf detail, and structural inaccuracies; second model has color, leaf detail, and structural mismatches with prompt's dark umbrella and large golden leaves.. Swapped pass: Both models have color mismatches (first is light blue, second is darker gray but not matching the prompt's dark tone), leaf patterns are less detailed, and structural details (canopy shape, ribs, handle) do not fully match the prompt's umbrella.
|
||||
118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a
|
draw
| 6.5
| 7
| 16.964689
|
Direct pass: Shape distortion, incorrect hardware details, body contour mismatches. Swapped pass: Shape distortions, hardware inaccuracies, missing prompt-specific details
|
||||
12b62740dbdf021d7ba7f158b126a319eb0efc99611fb86cb302d929dd4d1f99
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 19.893106
|
Direct pass: Both models have colorful wraps similar to the prompt, but details like specific graphics, text elements (e.g., 'Natural'), license plate, and roof light design show minor to moderate deviations. First model has closer overall shape and style alignment, while second model has more noticeable detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details mismatch, style variations, and specific elements (like graffiti patterns, license plate, and structural details) not fully matching the prompt.
|
||||
14f80504c56effdd9bca0a1b6e5227c0083bde89fc874d5c45dc3390cf01e3ce
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 19.178417
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (cylindrical roll vs. single rolled paper), second model has major structural differences (container-like shape vs. rolled paper) and does not match the prompt's rolled paper structure.. Swapped pass: First model has incorrect overall shape (not a rolled paper), second model has slight shape differences but closer to rolled paper.
|
||||
171a5014b52853e23e6d463617bba469397670374ae8a9a75b477a34bc0e5956
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 20.122183
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and cloth details; second model has moderate issues with style and details. Swapped pass: Minor cloth detail discrepancies and pose/shape differences in both models compared to the prompt
|
||||
172103d9-ac53-465c-8328-21be51e90e8e
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 17.677344
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has major issues (significant style and detail mismatch). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has more significant style, detail, and texture mismatches with the prompt.
|
||||
1a3c1d5d580473c8a04c166339b8179ff4549c9a3d9baaecd01f788504c7d1ed
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 20.007029
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/color differences; second model has moderate texture/style deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate texture and shape deviations; second model has minor details matching the prompt.
|
||||
1a7963ed164daedf4e138483044f9c0ac480e3ccba700bdbba6fe9560958751d
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 18.210874
|
Direct pass: Distorted text, incorrect bottle shape details, material inconsistencies with original clear glass bottle. Swapped pass: Text misrendering, shape differences, material inconsistencies
|
||||
1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 21.399585
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (style and detail mismatches); second model has major issues (distorted continent shapes and style).. Swapped pass: Style and detail differences from prompt (color schemes, texture patterns, continent shapes)
|
||||
2074879da6c2380718d2ec005cfc8b72f78b6e99dbffe972b9824c9714131c51
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 21.059764
|
Direct pass: Chain design and pendant texture/pattern differ from the original prompt; first model has more dramatic chain alterations, second has pendant pattern differences. Swapped pass: Chain design and pendant texture/shape do not match the prompt's style and details (first model has minor issues, second has major issues with chain elaboration and pendant texture)
|
||||
20b0e6de039e64ee2392386057e69980ec976b0d13f424077558d435d8add62e
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 21.280056
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in item placement, drawer hardware, and wood tone consistency between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details)
|
||||
2229cf5f-955c-4bc2-91c3-df9255a1c01d
|
draw
| 5.5
| 4.5
| 15.430888
|
Direct pass: Gemstone shape differs from oval cut in prompt, band decorative elements and overall style do not match prompt details. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences in the gemstone and minor variations in band details; second model has more significant differences in gemstone cut, color tone, and band decoration.
|
||||
226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 22.383287
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail differences, style variations from the original prompt's intricate design. Swapped pass: Both models have stylized, less detailed versions of the treasure chest with altered item arrangements and less realistic textures; moderate deviations from prompt details.
|
||||
23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 21.499827
|
Direct pass: Layer colors, frosting texture, and cocoa dusting details vary from the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues.. Swapped pass: Frosting shape variations, layer color inconsistencies, cocoa dusting details not matching prompt
|
||||
261ee46ca52df07a017b6f1f1c5a2a03809e96c18334d4aa5877619ca4d761f1
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 19.915668
|
Direct pass: Texture, pattern details, and bag design do not fully match prompt; pillow fabric realism and bag accents vary.. Swapped pass: Pattern fidelity, object details, and style consistency vary from prompt; first model has abstracted patterns, second has altered color schemes and object features.
|
||||
2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6.5
| 21.733063
|
Direct pass: Simplified shapes, missing intricate valve mechanisms and tubing details, distorted overall form. Swapped pass: Stylized shapes, missing detailed tubing/valve mechanisms, less realistic brass instrument appearance
|
||||
295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5.5
| 17.401718
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and color variations; second model has more significant shape and style deviations, with less realistic dolphin proportions and water base details.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have color/texture differences (first model has golden tone, second has silver/golden tone; prompt has bronze-like tone), base water details are less detailed than prompt, and dolphin shape/fin positions have minor variations.
|
||||
2fd46d4a00a43e432c5e3f97aad8da63a5313ec5e5eaddd628b048e03617c737
|
ours
| 4
| 5.5
| 22.445585
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt's jar structure and metallic finish (e.g., handle/spout proportions, surface texture variations). Swapped pass: Shape variations, handle details, and color inconsistencies with the prompt.
|
||||
329c02cf3233376f50a6a485846de75aee657762fe3666c0273b016302c35a81
|
ours
| 3
| 6
| 18.90401
|
Direct pass: First model has minor texture/color variations; second model has major cone color and wood texture differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has inconsistent wood texture and metallic cone color; second model has closer adherence.
|
||||
33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 21.261079
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate details differ (license plate text, grille shape, body texture variations). Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences (e.g., grille, license plate, rust texture) from the prompt
|
||||
34d411923ca3760c48d028c77c069f8e62e0592b4478e2728c344da1f7f88344
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 26.697132
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and base detail issues; second model has significant style and detail differences (fabric shape, figure proportions) from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small fabric details; second model has major issues like base holes and fabric style differences.
|
||||
353ed1fd3139574859254de31c9f189338dd89a988798dd91a8e78344c29d219
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 16.624398
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues.. Swapped pass: Moderate issues with scale detail, fin structure, and realism compared to the prompt.
|
||||
364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 18.527506
|
Direct pass: Texture, color, and plate details do not match the prompt; shape details are slightly inconsistent.. Swapped pass: Both models lack the plate from the prompt, exhibit color/texture differences (less golden-brown and crispy coating), and have shape variations; first model has moderate issues, second has more significant issues.
|
||||
3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6.5
| 18.865675
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and item variations; second model has major item and structural deviations.. Swapped pass: Items and cart structure differ significantly from prompt; colors, shapes, and arrangement of objects do not match the original image prompt.
|
||||
3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 18.161004
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate style/detail issues (e.g., altered handle design, less precise engravings, color variation).. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues with handle shape, engraving detail, and stylistic consistency with the prompt.
|
||||
3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 18.366643
|
Direct pass: Pattern does not match star/moon theme, pillow positioning and bed structure have minor differences. Swapped pass: Pattern does not match the star and moon design specified in the prompt; bed structure is similar but pattern details are incorrect.
|
||||
3ecd482e-9b05-4e76-9b67-a7be1b3183e0
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 24.999595
|
Direct pass: First model includes additional landscaping (path, bushes) not in the prompt; second model has a smoother roof texture, mismatched window details, and less rustic style.. Swapped pass: First model has minor to moderate issues (window shapes, roof texture, chimney details); second model has major issues (added landscaping, altered scene elements not in prompt)
|
||||
3f48598320210ac8659a36fd57bccddba1bc5acbab93ac579a0587321088aa84
|
ours
| 3
| 6
| 22.187335
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight stand variations, minor detail differences); second model has major issues (missing stand, significant detail differences). Swapped pass: First model lacks the wooden stand from the prompt and has minor differences in earring hooks and engraving details; second model includes the stand but has minor differences in stand details and earring engravings.
|
||||
4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 18.18688
|
Direct pass: Both models have minor to moderate differences in wood texture, decoration placement, and upholstery consistency compared to the prompt; second model has more noticeable deviations.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate detail discrepancies in wood texture, diamond decorations, and ornate design adherence.
|
||||
41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 20.880319
|
Direct pass: First model has extra elements not in prompt; second model lacks key accessories from prompt. Swapped pass: Missing/Altered details (hat design, instrument presence, drop)
|
||||
42faaea9e35e98055ce49e36d86cefcb430ef8476c5a62ba382fb5a7c416c84d
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 28.103651
|
Direct pass: Face details and shape variations do not match prompt's smooth, defined jack - o'-lantern features; some views lack facial features or have irregular shapes.. Swapped pass: Face details (eyes, nose, mouth) and some views lack the prompt's specific jack-o'-lantern features; moderate deviations from prompt.
|
||||
43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb
|
draw
| 6.5
| 5.5
| 17.890781
|
Direct pass: Shape and texture mismatches, color deviations, missing small details from the prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (shape differences in base and small details), second model has major issues (color mismatch and base style differences)
|
||||
449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 20.917239
|
Direct pass: Both models have shape differences, missing small details (e.g., pipe arrangement, ornament details), and style variations compared to the prompt. First model has minor issues, second has more moderate to major issues.. Swapped pass: Both models have significant detail differences (pipe count, wood texture, brass accents) compared to the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has major issues.
|
||||
467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.326004
|
Direct pass: Flesh count and exterior texture details don't match the prompt; some views have incorrect shape and detail representation.. Swapped pass: Shape and texture variations, aril arrangement differences, and exterior spikiness inconsistencies with the prompt.
|
||||
47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 18.073319
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate detail/style issues. Swapped pass: First model has less defined texture details and slightly less accurate edge texture; second model has better texture adherence but still minor shape details differences.
|
||||
485f79e73ce1afeb6183f435ad0b4006ae69745a4a1c58137d5e13f9c0355209
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 23.518578
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, layer blending issues, and cookie variety mismatches compared to prompt. Swapped pass: Cookie shape, sauce details, and scattered crumbs not matching prompt; layer color consistency issues.
|
||||
49096cb85b6ca2b8ad9e3e69b8defba2d5a07272e488cd24d28702d8480d015f
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 20.517965
|
Direct pass: First model has puzzle pieces under the instrument (not in prompt) and shape differences; second model has a drawer and altered key/structure details not matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has major context/structure changes (e.g., puzzle piece base, altered instrument structure).
|
||||
4b4a7770bcc5f91d930beb1a21b18233749d134464d952839ab1d12902917eba
|
ours
| 3
| 4.5
| 22.644824
|
Direct pass: Both models have differences in wheel design, body proportions, and small details compared to the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and small details missing in both models
|
||||
52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 20.84179
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with decorative details and style adherence.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and detail variations in both models compared to prompt; first model has slight structural differences, second model has more noticeable style and detail discrepancies.
|
||||
56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 18.346508
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant style and object type deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, color variations, and minor detail mismatches between models and prompt
|
||||
57d1b4933d29fa17434ada21b48cbbb2b1ace4fb275b85fbd9925b8428cc43d1
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 18.070862
|
Direct pass: Shape variations (crown and brim), ribbon color and detail discrepancies, texture vibrancy and detail differences.. Swapped pass: Shape, ribbon details, and color/pattern variations do not fully match the prompt.
|
||||
58ab488ab493d9cdc00cb4ca8223700bed6af74c51325456d3d89ceec228ad1c
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 16.90522
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has moderate style and detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and small detail omissions in both 3D models compared to the prompt
|
||||
5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 18.228971
|
Direct pass: Both 3D models have photorealistic rendering (vs. the prompt's artistic/sketchy style) and overly dense foliage (vs. the prompt's lighter, more sketchy appearance), with minor shape and detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Dense foliage, missing sketchy/misty artistic style, flower arrangement differs from prompt
|
||||
5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 19.364731
|
Direct pass: Simplified artistic style, shape differences in headlights, bumper, and body details; less realistic texture and detail compared to the prompt's realistic model.. Swapped pass: Simplified details, possible missing split windshield, less accurate body lines and chrome elements
|
||||
5fcb3d44f12a98fc2348159d1ef3c5c09a227cf56452f298294057592b184136
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 23.681532
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, illustration style variations between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with book color and animal details.
|
||||
60864873e3dcef73f60adbdb9fef1eace2b820b86d76967680f4670edf96b340
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 20.014502
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, some detail variations between models and prompt. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences from prompt
|
||||
656c99abf95ff5e12d650c2176b8b80df4e5ce09f66a536c09a521525331b0bb
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 16.408046
|
Direct pass: Missing text and logo details, handle shape variations, blade texture and detail differences.. Swapped pass: Missing text/logo details, slight handle shape differences, blade details not matching prompt
|
||||
693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 17.142083
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape/lighting differences), second model has moderate issues (style/color details deviate more from prompt). Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences (e.g., hat texture, body color consistency, beard detail)
|
||||
69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 21.106349
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail variations; some spikes and spot placement differ from prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences from the prompt's spiky, star - shaped structure with white spots
|
||||
6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5.5
| 20.123108
|
Direct pass: First model has minor differences in floral details, crack visibility, and shape nuances; second model has more significant changes to floral decorations, leaf details, and overall style adherence.. Swapped pass: Floral details, crack details, and color tones differ from the prompt; shape is similar but with minor to moderate deviations.
|
||||
6c92f66045cd8523b7e84cb9e799c4694c3574ca18efc52d63127f1f61edd1ca
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 21.253958
|
Direct pass: Cloak texture, drape, and belt details show moderate differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and slight detail variations; second model has more noticeable style and detail differences (e.g., smoother cloak texture, simpler belt design).
|
||||
70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9
|
draw
| 5.5
| 4.5
| 19.776351
|
Direct pass: Both 3D models have clock face details (numbers, hands), pendulum design, and wooden frame elements that differ from the prompt's specific features, with moderate shape and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: Clock face details, wooden texture, and pendulum/structure variations do not match the prompt exactly.
|
||||
713e94c97ab6add102476b51b5c954fba00ec0fd0dc011341bba2066fb1b1518
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 17.33697
|
Direct pass: Bar shape and mallet count variations; frame structural details differ slightly from prompt. Swapped pass: Bar color/lighting variations, mallet positioning differences, frame structural details not matching exactly.
|
||||
715afe937c361b7d5f32bfb5128a3191dccbcd4a470b159a41bdd11b7589b2c7
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.260512
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (e.g., cabinet design, pedal placement, keyboard alignment). Swapped pass: Shape deviations, pedal details, and overall style differences from the prompt's piano.
|
||||
7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 19.033266
|
Direct pass: Pearl size variation and structural details (layered coiling, varied strand arrangement) do not fully match the prompt's multi - strand pearl necklace with varied pearl sizes.. Swapped pass: Pearl size variation, strand structure, and detail accuracy do not fully match the prompt
|
||||
7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036
|
draw
| 5
| 5.5
| 17.141401
|
Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (floral/decorative patterns not exact match); second model has moderate issues (style, pattern details, and overall visual fidelity deviate more from prompt). Swapped pass: Pattern details and decorative style do not fully match the prompt's intricate floral and ornamental designs; shape is generally similar but design elements differ.
|
||||
739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 21.200931
|
Direct pass: Text elements, detail accuracy (e.g., roof equipment, front design), and specific branding do not fully match the prompt; second model has more significant discrepancies.. Swapped pass: Text and detail discrepancies, shape variations from original prompt.
|
||||
76fec295-fbbe-4b3f-9ad1-74d2a3f8f42e
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 20.244121
|
Direct pass: Minor differences in chest emblem color, surface gloss, and eye shade; second model has more noticeable deviations.. Swapped pass: Slight texture and detail differences, but overall matches the prompt's general features
|
||||
7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6
| 21.335391
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style mismatches. Swapped pass: Shape, detail, and style inconsistencies with the prompt's car; both models show deviations in body contours, front end design, and wheel details.
|
||||
79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5.5
| 17.807427
|
Direct pass: First model has minor details differences; second model has moderate style and detail deviations (e.g., less defined gold decorations, altered floral patterns).. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences from prompt (e.g., unicorn position, gold accents, floral patterns vary slightly from original image)
|
||||
7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 19.131114
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Hat color variations, clothing color differences, minor detail inconsistencies
|
||||
7de9dddab181bdea7a3cd959ce656d00eef19ed8f9617cd49cda908632e9da6a
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 21.56851
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details like chrome engine, windshield, and wheel textures compared to prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, reduced detail on chrome components, simplified wheel and engine designs compared to the prompt.
|
||||
7f691c0b893a85f92a4ff3d2fa6d05db141af1b1938ba570fdb474a688ead51e
|
ours
| 4.5
| 6
| 26.307424
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant structural issues (missing segments, altered form). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, inconsistent spine/ridge patterns
|
||||
7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 16.587717
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has band style variation and shape differences.. Swapped pass: Shape and band details differ from prompt; texture and silhouette variations
|
||||
7fc7e2ce31d9ceff1351199183a5e37bfb868d76aa2a304f0bbb96e55e031fa5
|
ours
| 4
| 5.5
| 22.095773
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences, second model has major category mismatch (rounded brain-like shape vs. elongated organic sculpture). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (rounded top structure vs intricate swirling form), second model has moderate shape differences (rounded overall form vs organic, flowing structure)
|
||||
854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 20.149961
|
Direct pass: Both models have shape differences, missing small details, and style variations compared to the prompt; second model has more significant deviations.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations
|
||||
8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.30375
|
Direct pass: Umbrella color, pole material, and bowl rim details deviate from the prompt; bowl shape and umbrella structure have moderate deviations.. Swapped pass: Umbrella color and pole color mismatch, bowl trim and color details not matching prompt
|
||||
8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541
|
draw
| 3.5
| 3.5
| 21.421378
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences, cushion/leg variations from prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, leg color variations, minor cushion positioning differences from the prompt
|
||||
908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015
|
ours
| 3
| 4.5
| 19.631136
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, texture variations, and some structural details not matching the prompt exactly.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture differences, no major structural or category errors.
|
||||
988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 20.730445
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has moderate style and texture differences from the original prompt's basket and flower arrangement.. Swapped pass: Basket texture/color, flower arrangement, and hanging mechanism details vary from the prompt; minor to moderate differences in shape and style.
|
||||
99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06
|
ours
| 4
| 7
| 22.702633
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has major issues (missing lemon, key element from prompt). Swapped pass: First model lacks the lemon and has texture differences in the grater; second model includes the lemon but has grater texture/style differences from the prompt.
|
||||
99abe232dc54996bdfc0116b61e6f2303b8366a25588889399b4c5b64f0f1333
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 18.494465
|
Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (moon clarity, metal texture), second model has more significant style/color deviations (green accents, less matching ornate design). Swapped pass: First model has simplified metalwork details and altered moon representation; second model has less ornate design, simplified metalwork, and altered moon representation.
|
||||
99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 23.877456
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has style changes (e.g., added eyes, altered tentacle shapes) and missing prompt details.. Swapped pass: First model has simpler tentacle details and less intricate surface patterns; second model has closer tentacle details but still some differences in overall style and shape.
|
||||
9a25117f3143e913c4c7a63f49eee8e0e1f00a195c55bf148b4fb5ffff5d2a8e
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 20.396599
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate texture and detail issues (smoother skin, less defined features).. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate issues in ear detail, skin texture, and proportion across models.
|
||||
9bf3a49883eb3b428a42a22de9514374613881276627104b83c1bcc14da6ccc7
|
ours
| 3
| 6
| 22.040736
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/text differences; second model lacks the whisk attachment and has significant design/style differences. Swapped pass: First model lacks whisk attachment; second model has whisk but with slight shape variations.
|
||||
9d672198b62e5a15983a4eb0ee13d9b70229f8012a5fc0db8e5d5c7dd1c1c9d0
|
draw
| 7.5
| 7
| 19.771437
|
Direct pass: Incorrect lettering (not matching 'SM'), handle shape differences, and style inconsistencies with the prompt. Swapped pass: Incorrect text (not 'SM'), shape differences in handles and mug structure, style mismatches with original smooth design
|
||||
9fa13cfe3009a90a1a6bf6d54f80072a502f99837fd0573243a5a44175313ba2
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 15.816288
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and structural mismatches compared to the prompt's butterfly details and color accuracy.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small details; second model has major issues with wing style, transparency, and overall structure mismatching the prompt's butterfly.
|
||||
9fef13410f0c576f398257cc5f8afe27b61a3f75733ba9673e145994451c901e
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 19.958143
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/style differences; second model has color/style changes and significant detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Stylized appearance, shape differences, missing realistic food details
|
||||
a0a702cd4913b13fae5fa6c4fc48293f1bdc17dd4c03bf418f43a8c59baa3664
|
ours
| 3.5
| 5
| 15.972941
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (tree branches, frame details); second model has moderate issues (frame color, chain style, tree details). Swapped pass: Chain style and pendant color variations; minor tree shape differences
|
||||
a1afc9a29b2f04c62a2dbd716f61729eeac3bc6593f0c9184e62462e4a379489
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 21.821851
|
Direct pass: Scale texture detail, shape fit, and collar/zipper alignment vary from prompt. Swapped pass: Minor scale texture and detail differences, slight shape variations in some views
|
||||
a2d0ecb69bc311be5ac46d410eab1be00ffd9285a088feba1285137a5e411a24
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 18.081306
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, text clarity issues. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate details (text, hardware) and shape differences from prompt
|
||||
a7b060c7a72d4f3683fa82b0dd11a5a2d3defcc71a30e8fae0411fd9266c1572
|
draw
| 3
| 3
| 19.453254
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and slight detail variations in base texture and flame appearance
|
||||
a9155cfb1966d483eee2f833cbf2ae550805c8d6cd7f4d5c48abe0d2f461d25d
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 23.207451
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/arrangement differences; second model includes pots not present in the original prompt, altering the scene.. Swapped pass: First model includes pots not present in the prompt; second model has different leaf structure and less detail matching the prompt's large, broad leaves.
|
||||
aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 20.644239
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, and style variations between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt
|
||||
ac64dc89a5302c47617b0934b9693abb5b26b02a95e8a13b3b0feb97da92405a
|
ours
| 4
| 6.5
| 27.815415
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and book arrangement details; second model has major style issues (less transparent frame, altered book arrangements) and significant detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: Both models have moderate issues with book arrangement, shelf details, and non-book objects (e.g., black object in first model) not matching the prompt's bookshelf with books only.
|
||||
ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 21.144047
|
Direct pass: Minor differences in hat color, clothing texture details, and slight shape variations; overall character type/style matches prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight texture/color variations), second model has moderate issues (color scheme and detail differences)
|
||||
affafd67f649843b60f5bd0af9770568f292a354a38bdfc45ad6cca224db2576
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5.5
| 22.736473
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, detail accuracy issues, and style inconsistencies with the original prompt's intricate design elements. Swapped pass: Book color, cube details, and ornamental patterns do not match the prompt; book texture and cube ornamentation have moderate deviations.
|
||||
bbf842eb949a678b25ab76333ff494adeffc7b86c26cf83b48730b8f09f4f0b1
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 16.165251
|
Direct pass: Rope texture/color, knot structure, and figure details do not match the prompt's visual quality and prompt adherence.. Swapped pass: Rope color, thickness, knot structure, and figure details do not match the prompt; minor to moderate shape and detail discrepancies.
|
||||
bc31ba30-2ff4-47eb-9b7d-c6f68c6b7108
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 19.607802
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in chimney shape, window arrangement, and landscaping details; overall style matches but with some variations.. Swapped pass: Variations in architectural details, landscaping, and roof texture; some models have minor shape differences or missing small elements.
|
||||
bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 16.837371
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and slight detail variations; second model has more stylized elements with moderate detail loss and altered proportions.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and some details missing/altered in both 3D models compared to the prompt.
|
||||
bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 20.253175
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate differences in leaf details, trunk texture, and structural consistency with the prompt; second model has major structural deviations (e.g., smoother trunk, less detailed leaves, altered branch structure) compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Foliage details, leaf shapes, and trunk texture differ from the prompt; flower density and overall structure have minor to moderate deviations.
|
||||
bee9d868d4f6a6e662a9f617cdbd1fabd4533cb7e2da74d1ddcc4ccfb59d0a66
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 25.941035
|
Direct pass: Slight shape/color variations, some details don't match prompt's petal structure and lighting intensity.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and color variations, flame prominence differs from prompt
|
||||
c01c79d97d1bb88aedb82ed800fdfa1f92786b1595303195c85a88c3471062f5
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4
| 27.355642
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences and slight detail variations in interior shelves and exterior design between models and the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor differences in shelf count, interior lighting, and small design details; both models are refrigerators but have slight variations from the prompt.
|
||||
c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283
|
draw
| 4.5
| 3.5
| 19.361654
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and branch variations, some detail differences in claws and feather patterns. Swapped pass: Branch shape/texture differences, feather pattern consistency issues, minor structural details mismatch
|
||||
c2972a848235384091afec85c53cf3ad9f6d1a6f5a40e1da41496ded11469ebc
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 18.738512
|
Direct pass: Sail details (map vs plain), wooden texture variations, minor structural differences. Swapped pass: Slight shape and detail differences in sails, hull, and base; second model has more noticeable variations in overall structure and sail appearance.
|
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
YAML Metadata
Warning:
empty or missing yaml metadata in repo card
(https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/datasets-cards)
Benchmark Results: test11
Overview
- Round: 10
- Test Name: test11
- Timestamp: 2025-12-31 14:30:21
Summary
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total Tasks | 128 |
| Total Judged | 125 |
| Skipped | 0 |
| Gen Failed | 0 |
| Render Failed | 0 |
| Judge Failed | 3 |
Results
| Result | Count |
|---|---|
| 🏆 WINS | 23 |
| 🤝 DRAWS | 97 |
| ❌ LOSSES | 5 |
Performance
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Win Rate | 18.4% |
| Margin | +14.4% |
| Avg Gen Time | 20.24s |
Methodology
- Judge Model: thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking (via OpenRouter)
- Position-Balanced: 2 passes with swapped order to avoid position bias
- Penalty Scale: 0 (perfect) to 10 (completely wrong)
- Winner: Lower average penalty wins (draw if difference ≤ 1)
Files
benchmark_test11.json- Full benchmark results*/ours.png- Our rendered 3D models*/leader.png- Leader's rendered 3D models*/origin.png- Original prompt images
- Downloads last month
- 12