yuri1996/round_11_v2.1.0 · Datasets at Hugging Face

task_id stringlengths 36 64	winner stringclasses 3 values	ours_penalty float64 3 10	leader_penalty float64 3 8.5	gen_time float64 18.1 38.6	issues stringlengths 161 503
041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28	ours	3.5	5.5	21.293677	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model lacks small plant elements; second model has plants but has shape/style differences.
0856500b5ada44f3a17f2f798f29ab14932dc75bdac03b1d1874c25c7a48b257	draw	5	4	32.834005	Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing clean background details, bristle texture inconsistencies. Swapped pass: Background elements (shadows, extra base) and bristle texture details differ from prompt
08716ba11520bf19be5fe52ab460dc5eebb88cc1fc6ec6ae467d6f15f31b6012	draw	5	5	29.915627	Direct pass: First model has slight shape and texture variations; second model has more significant shape and detail deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, detail inaccuracies, box texture and shadow inconsistencies
0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8	leader	6	3	20.348717	Direct pass: First model includes extra landscape elements not in the prompt; second model lacks the shell-like object but the dinosaur matches the prompt’s dinosaur closely.. Swapped pass: First model lacks the shell object from the prompt; second model includes an environment with extra elements, deviating from the prompt's simple scene
0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd	draw	4.5	4.5	20.77296	Direct pass: Slight to moderate differences in planter detail, leaf texture, and pepper arrangement compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Planter ornate details differ, plant density and chili pepper placement vary from prompt.
102fb0383ddd07f4c982a442c9af4b64633d9cd31a1f9415c59e31df2617f048	draw	5	5	30.99581	Direct pass: First model includes a paint puddle not present in the prompt; second model has a yellow handle, altered ferrule, and differently shaped bristles compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has color and detail differences (e.g., handle color, ferrule appearance); second model includes a paint puddle (not present in the prompt) and altered brush details.
118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a	leader	6.5	5	31.905061	Direct pass: Shape distortions, hardware details (pickups, knobs, pickguard) don't match prompt's specific designs; wood grain texture varies.. Swapped pass: Minor to major detail mismatches, hardware inaccuracies, and texture differences from prompt
11d30908bf1c6b65318373412b8a0a345cbbb1635dd53e523e245ca93a6ae08b	leader	6.5	3.5	22.453615	Direct pass: First model has less glassy appearance, darker case, and less vibrant internal patterns; second model has closer glassy appearance but minor pattern/style differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in internal pattern clarity and surface details; second model has poor background, unclear views, and altered style.
1277164db5ef94fe044feadbc6b86cff360c7923c6e6aa3dcb6c196f9e0e41c4	leader	5	3	19.773076	Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (spout, handle, body proportions) between models and prompt; first model has moderate stylistic variations, second model has minor differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (handle, spout, lid details); second model has more noticeable style differences (base platform, shape proportions) and missing prompt elements (no base platform in original prompt).
14b932391473feb2862031fd9ce3366d5ada7ffe2e70a6d9fdde641a4661e0c9	leader	6	3	32.108085	Direct pass: First model has distorted hull shape and foggy background; second model has minor details but closer adherence to prompt's sailboat structure and colors.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has significant background and hull style deviations.
14f80504c56effdd9bca0a1b6e5227c0083bde89fc874d5c45dc3390cf01e3ce	ours	5	6.5	19.975876	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (more curved structure, dark side variations) while second model has major shape differences (cylindrical container with multiple openings, not matching rolled paper structure). Swapped pass: Both models have shape and style differences from the rolled paper prompt; first model has additional cylindrical protrusions, second model has a more sculptural, curved form, and neither matches the prompt’s rolled paper structure as closely.
172103d9-ac53-465c-8328-21be51e90e8e	leader	5	3	35.275062	Direct pass: First model has simplified architectural details and less detailed door carvings; second model has closer adherence but minor texture/proportion differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and small detail variations; second model has wrong style and significant detail/ornamentation missing compared to prompt.
18edab1f3c193d7e57460a765271a29df141024eb583dcdbcf2a9da9d8923d2e	leader	7	4	19.698545	Direct pass: First model has foggy background, inconsistent chair designs, and table details; second model has closer alignment but minor chair position differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/position differences; second model has major environment/lighting issues (foggy background, mismatched atmosphere)
1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611	draw	6	5	21.401377	Direct pass: Texture and detail discrepancies, style variations from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing); second model has major issues (wrong background, distorted continent shapes)
2229cf5f-955c-4bc2-91c3-df9255a1c01d	leader	6	4	19.47082	Direct pass: Gemstone shape and band texture differ from the prompt; first model has non-oval gemstone and distinct band texture, second model has closer gemstone shape but still differs in band detail.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences in gemstone cut and band details; second model has major style differences with an elaborate cutout band not matching the prompt's simpler design.
226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f	draw	6	5	21.262947	Direct pass: Style and detail differences; less intricate carvings and decorative items compared to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, some details missing); second model has major issues (stylized appearance, significant details missing, background mismatch)
23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924	draw	4.5	4	23.524075	Direct pass: Minor shape differences in chocolate toppings, slight variations in layer colors/textures, and plate details; moderate issues in second model's overall consistency with prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, topping texture variations, and minor detail inconsistencies in first model; moderate style and detail mismatches in second model
2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe	leader	7	5	18.659234	Direct pass: First model has major shape and detail discrepancies; second has moderate detail and style differences from the prompt's polished, detailed brass instrument.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail/realism differences (stylized appearance, less intricate mechanical details); second model has major issues (stylized/abstract style, significant detail loss, some views unclear, inconsistent realism).
295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484	leader	7	3	21.4968	Direct pass: First model includes a cage (not present in the prompt), second model has minor shape/texture differences from the original dolphin statue.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/color details, second model has major cage addition not in prompt
29de854bc5984bda7ff04b95a82c21ed70c5546f121b7726a661a12deefd0c65	draw	4	4	19.213106	Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (e.g., base, fur texture) but maintains core subject and tack style; second model has moderate issues with altered gem arrangements, tack detail, and overall realism matching prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has base addition and altered tack details.
2f6348a87b52cf24bbf2339826248afb14a1388801d7f3a7eecc4c166a739f58	draw	5	4	20.33039	Direct pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: first model includes extra objects not in the prompt and has less precise intricate details; second model has simplified ornateness and missing detailed elements from the original clock.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., simplified central blue design), second model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, additional base elements not in prompt, less detailed ornamentation)
325b837b6f588d1bb4698af689c8afdd86320d3c04b839a9c25bead94d6c010c	draw	4.5	3.5	20.384249	Direct pass: Slight shape differences in mannequin and necklace details; stone arrangement variations from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)
33532e138e69ddba7c5e762eed4bedb6b3fcd1a55302cd784c823d8d76d705f2	leader	7	3.5	19.293069	Direct pass: First model has major issues (abstract style, shape differences); second model has minor issues (slight details missing). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant style and detail issues, with less accurate representation of the prompt’s mechanical structure and features.
33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94	leader	7	4	19.720396	Direct pass: First model has incorrect color (red instead of rusty brown), smooth texture instead of aged/rusty, and mismatched grille/headlight details. Second model has closer color/texture but still has minor grille/headlight details mismatch.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight detail differences), second model has major issues (color/texture mismatch with prompt's aged, rusty appearance)
364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625	ours	5	7	20.484055	Direct pass: Fried coating texture and detail accuracy vary; some models lack proper fried appearance, plate details inconsistent.. Swapped pass: First model missing plate and powder details; second model has plate and powder but shape/texture differences.
3721d86fa0c88f910d49d5340f2f15a7c0b7cbb72317a3bb9250110e478fafea	leader	6.5	5	20.672436	Direct pass: Shape and detail mismatches in harp structure, wheel mechanism, and string arrangement for both 3D models compared to the image prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail and shape differences; second model has major structural mismatch in the attached component, altering the original's mechanical design.
3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06	draw	6	6	18.971497	Direct pass: First model has stylized items, wheel color differences, and minor shape alterations; second model has significant item style mismatches (lab equipment instead of bottles) and structural differences.. Swapped pass: Both models have shape differences, style mismatches, and missing details compared to the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.
3aff357f2c9bc317c083c24d896cdc32f43dd78f0831c3a359f67d08771d23de	leader	6.5	3.5	20.17488	Direct pass: First model has foggy background and less detailed wood texture; second model has minor structural details differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has major style/detail/background issues.
3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549	leader	7	3	20.656433	Direct pass: First model has muted color, less clear engravings, and lighting issues; second model has closer match with golden color and clearer engravings but minor detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has major issues with background, color, and visibility.
3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d	draw	5	5	20.02142	Direct pass: Pattern details, bed frame color, and pillow positioning do not fully match the prompt; style and small details have moderate deviations.. Swapped pass: Pattern does not match original star/moon design; bed structure and pillow positioning have deviations.
3f48598320210ac8659a36fd57bccddba1bc5acbab93ac579a0587321088aa84	leader	7.5	5	19.939435	Direct pass: First model has incorrect earring shapes, missing/incorrect floral engravings, and stand design differences; second model has some earrings without floral engravings, stand design differences, and shape inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., some earrings lack detailed floral engravings, stand has slight design variations); second model has major issues (earrings are not heart - shaped, style and shape differ significantly from prompt)
4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59	leader	6.5	4	33.990963	Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative details, wood texture, and base design; overall structure matches but some fine details differ.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)
41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60	leader	5	3	22.084119	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences, blurry views, and missing small details; second model has closer match with slight detail variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has altered style, background, and missing details.
43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb	leader	7.5	5	20.96191	Direct pass: First model has major issues with base texture/color and mushroom shape/texture; second model has moderate issues with base shape but closer mushroom form.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape and detail differences; second model has significant style, color, and structural differences from the prompt.
449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8	leader	7	5	19.167331	Direct pass: First model has color mismatch (red instead of warm brown wood), distorted views, and missing detailed elements like pipes/keyboard. Second model has closed cabinet sections when prompt shows open organ with visible pipes, and some structural details don't match the prompt's ornate design.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail/shape differences; second model has major style/color/structure issues.
450f110234b2dbed200824a1cef7c71e0210f244d7e6568b9b28536add3dbc91	leader	6	4	19.036616	Direct pass: Background color mismatch, stylus position variation, minor detail differences (stylus cap not visible). Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details (e.g., stylus cap), and incorrect accessories (stand, extra stylus) in both models
45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f	leader	5	3	19.135702	Direct pass: First model has exaggerated shadows and minor structural/detail mismatches; second model has closer adherence with minor variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail position differences; second model has prominent stylistic shadow effects affecting overall adherence.
467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c	draw	5	5	23.121099	Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, detail inconsistencies); second model has major issues (exterior texture with holes, seed appearance mismatch, overall structural differences from prompt). Swapped pass: Shape and detail variations from prompt; first model has minor differences in spines/flesh arrangement, second model has more noticeable structural differences
47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe	draw	8.5	8.5	31.477431	Direct pass: First model has additional wing-like structures not present in the prompt; second model is a knife with a handle, which is a different object type than the prompt's blade shape.. Swapped pass: First model is a knife with a wooden handle (does not match the sleek, handle-less blade-like shape of the prompt); second model is a winged flying object (completely different category from the prompt's blade-like shape)
4d6ac3c290d8d905f66493a5323b48d2ccdbffe9772ac75789cf329b7612ee8e	draw	5	5	19.78201	Direct pass: First model has frame and minor fabric detail differences; second model has fabric pattern and style mismatch.. Swapped pass: First model has minor frame and fabric detail differences; second model has more significant fabric pattern and frame style differences from the prompt.
52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869	draw	6	6	31.736752	Direct pass: First model has incorrect base and slight shape variations; second model has altered top design and structural differences compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has shape and detail differences; second model adds an unnecessary wooden base not present in the prompt.
55d1ffed3903d9c2aa353c5a25095b820ab20ca40638fc983f31b8f323e8f938	leader	5	3	38.571288	Direct pass: First model has shape differences (bed structure, kangaroo posture/ear details); second model has closer alignment but minor detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences; second model has wrong style and significant details missing
56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6	leader	7	3.5	19.547963	Direct pass: First model has extra non-prompt components; second model has minor detail differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has major structural differences (extra components, altered base style) not matching the prompt.
5a4ed3dbf08dd164fecc8aa0e6f0442535d231e6631b376134e6030c844f5e1d	leader	6	4	19.022542	Direct pass: First model has stylized/cartoonish rendering with slight shape differences and reduced detail; second model has closer structural match but some minor detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and detail issues.
5a9fc370-eede-4782-a75f-5db3b4c01d16	leader	5	3	20.777435	Direct pass: First model has blurred background and slight shape/texture deviations; second model has cleaner background but minor shape details differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has significant background/style issues (non-white background, altered texture appearance)
5b5f6e0ea01aa6c631558c6968b0eb1d4ddfdc322b83c36000c16539be4e2f9e	draw	5.5	5.5	21.013117	Direct pass: Both 3D models have significant structural and stylistic differences from the image prompt. The first model has rounded, less sharp formations and a compact layout, while the second model features a single, compact formation rather than the spread - out, multi - formation landscape. Both lack the detailed, sharp rock structures and expansive terrain of the prompt.. Swapped pass: Models are too small, lack landscape scale and variety of rock formations as in the prompt.
5c58930b6bb84c9a314cb65840dba3b9c0a4f09faf6a33c9eabe89932a385746	draw	4	5	18.433455	Direct pass: Mantel ornamentation, fire detail, and structural details do not fully match the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (some views show fireplace as planter), fire and greenery details vary; second model has longer fireplace structure with minor style differences.
5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8	draw	4	4	20.47696	Direct pass: Minor foliage density differences; overall structure (cage with hanging chain, plants/flowers) matches prompt.. Swapped pass: Style mismatch (sketchy prompt vs photorealistic 3D models), moderate differences in foliage density and structural detail adherence
5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0	draw	5	5	21.136822	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail omissions; second model has moderate issues with style and significant detail mismatches compared to the prompt's classic Beetle design. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail mismatches (shape, headlight/bumper details); second model has major issues (shadows, style differences, detail inaccuracies).
654e544bd515c1934d9b98ca32d6b6ad214823c9692134fad37145a0683edf73	draw	5.5	4.5	22.481178	Direct pass: First model includes non-prompt shadow elements and more ornate band details; second model has simpler band design and less detailed gemstone facets.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has major issues with extra shadow elements, style mismatches in band and gemstone.
679622ec8c54ae5a3234febd658d5dd7b94b9f5cf79c4bf04ae0e23494ff1076	draw	5	5	19.680334	Direct pass: First model has moderate detail mismatches; second model has major issues with detail and style. Swapped pass: First model has less defined engravings and muted texture; second model has stylized design, altered texture, and different engraving details compared to prompt.
693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4	leader	5	3	33.205697	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and style differences; second model closely matches prompt features like hat color, body texture, and beard details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences (slight pose/lighting details), second model has moderate issues (style/color/shadow differences from prompt)
69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad	leader	5	3	20.685543	Direct pass: First model has pink blur background and slightly softer shape details; second model has minor shape differences but matches prompt’s background and detail structure better. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/angle differences; second model has background blur and style distortion.
6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615	leader	6	4	21.439368	Direct pass: First model has shape differences, floral details mismatch; second model has minor shape differences but closer floral details and visible crack.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail inconsistencies; second model has major style and detail deviations.
70c21b53b86017a3e1445db93dcab57685f995e02b9dd4cffa67bcb2a9042761	draw	6	5	20.132097	Direct pass: Shape is similar but color vibrancy and detailed texture differ from prompt; some color variety and detail missing.. Swapped pass: First model has muted colors and less detailed texture; second model has dark color scheme and less vibrant details, both deviating from prompt’s bright, multicolored, glittery style.
70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9	leader	6	4	20.774112	Direct pass: First model has major issues (wrong clock face details, pendulum design, wood texture imperfections); second model has moderate issues (minor wood tone differences, clock face details).. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, clock face details), second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing like clock face, pendulum, wood imperfections)
7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34	leader	5	3	19.193915	Direct pass: First model has color mismatch (beige/gold tones) and inconsistent pearl sizes; second model has better color match but minor strand/pearl structure inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/arrangement differences; second model has color, style, and shadow issues.
7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036	draw	5	4	19.595052	Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with pattern details and shape proportions, not matching the prompt's intricate decorative elements as closely.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and significant detail issues.
739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed	draw	5.5	5.5	20.516958	Direct pass: Text and detail mismatches, shape differences in roof, windows, and body. Swapped pass: First model has minor text and detail discrepancies; second model has stylized shadows, altered text, and less realistic rendering style.
7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c	draw	6	6	19.745855	Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (grille, headlights, wheel design) from prompt. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations
79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6	draw	5	4	20.57565	Direct pass: Minor to moderate issues with floral details, unicorn features, and background consistency. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small decorative details; second model has altered style, less detailed decorations, and different background.
7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41	draw	4	4	20.982184	Direct pass: Hat color variations, clothing detail differences, guitar appearance variations. Swapped pass: First model has slight color differences in the hat and minor detail mismatches; second model has added shadows and more significant hat color differences
7dcf114f53200ab20cb8c5238e6e8c5e16fb66ab6e6857fce3e4715ba2f657b7	draw	5	4.5	18.271527	Direct pass: Cloth draping details, base design, and minor shape variations differ from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor size and detail differences; second model has stylistic and background issues affecting visual quality.
7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87	draw	4.5	4.5	19.973713	Direct pass: First model has minor shape variations and shadow details; second model has more noticeable shape and detail differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model includes shadows not in prompt with moderate shape variations.
80a82cc3f228cb7557b0d3ba7bdc5d9e43e4a59806ade7f9a348941ca6ce6a73	leader	7	4	20.469302	Direct pass: First model has significant shape differences in the table structure and stylized elements for items; second model has minor detail mismatches but closer alignment with the prompt’s rustic table and item arrangement.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in item arrangement and detail; second model has major issues with style, background, and item details.
82c6b4608b81474218c8f6561d24e7dc5e0ae3d8e28d9985b0bb8ba525a98e49	leader	7	3	19.118902	Direct pass: First model has foggy background and unclear visual details; second model has clearer details and closer match to prompt elements (e.g., wheel design, frame color, seat).. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight angle variations, minor detail differences); second model has major issues (foggy background, reduced clarity, altered visual presentation)
854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619	draw	5	5	21.126414	Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with wheel design, cab structure, and front details compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt's specific locomotive features (e.g., front circular opening, wheel design, cab details)
88f9719b883378b80f1a76c6e74dbdeabda5f93e9026e164b1031fb659371e41	draw	5	5	19.984477	Direct pass: Style and detail differences from prompt; simplified shapes and less intricate mechanical details.. Swapped pass: Style and detail differences; simplified structure and less mechanical complexity compared to prompt.
8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f	draw	4.5	4.5	19.502014	Direct pass: Base added in 3D models, color/texture variations, minor shape differences from original prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail inconsistencies; second model adds an extra base element not in the prompt with style variations.
8c15827b6a6a28f4fbde43e0691bcce2e425dff51d0a5d539fba1e77a06425a4	draw	6	6	22.782004	Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small details; second model has major structural changes (e.g., hook on circular frame) and altered details.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style mismatches with prompt's antique astronomical instrument
8ccae4a48faba6383d865e7c61d719a6d13973b7308c4e20a89342c1b298c94d	leader	6.5	3.5	25.053141	Direct pass: First model has stylized, less realistic petal shapes; second model is more realistic but has minor detail variations in some views.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/stem differences; second model has major stylization and base issues, not matching realistic rose prompt.
8d8a0daab678b83c3b47f617d8b7f402693eea1369ac268209dee4e99704d133	draw	6	5	20.795719	Direct pass: Added base structure not present in prompt; orb details slightly off. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (first model has orange tones, second has purple tones), base details differ from prompt's implied standalone sphere (first has detailed base with drop, second has different textured base), and overall style variation from the original glowing golden-brown sphere.
8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541	leader	6.5	3	21.421139	Direct pass: First model has low visual clarity (foggy rendering) and shape distortions; second model has better clarity but minor detail differences, overall closer to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/leg differences; second model has style, detail, and environment mismatches.
908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015	draw	4.5	3.5	19.676919	Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt, but overall chair structure and wooden style match the image prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., leg/seat details), second model has moderate issues (style variations, added shadow not in prompt)
987ee3ad-ce87-4733-a784-ce3feef9532a	draw	4	4	19.524873	Direct pass: Shadow presence, color variation, minor shape and detail differences. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, shadows present in second model, detail inconsistencies
988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9	draw	5	5	31.307553	Direct pass: Basket texture, flower arrangement, and overall detail vary from the prompt; some elements are altered or missing.. Swapped pass: Basket texture, flower details, and overall style differ from the prompt; some models have incorrect basket weaving or flower arrangement.
99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06	leader	7.5	4	20.674112	Direct pass: First model has blurry lemon and grater texture mismatch; second model lacks lemon and grater texture differs.. Swapped pass: First model has minor texture and detail differences; second model has major style, clarity, and detail issues (foggy rendering, less defined shapes)
99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32	draw	6	5.5	19.749219	Direct pass: First model has moderate detail differences, second has major structural/style differences compared to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues (style, details, shadows)
9d1052dc-ab7b-4bdc-b1a6-457e4b073c55	draw	6	5	31.689866	Direct pass: Shape and detail discrepancies, simplified components, texture differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate shape, detail, and texture discrepancies compared to the prompt's guitar.
9ec3a2abd05cffe12e23eab632bb86c138031bc53a12cf685e90c7381561e9e9	draw	6	5	21.069984	Direct pass: Both 3D models have significant detail mismatches (e.g., text, eye design, antenna/coil style, body markings) and style deviations from the image prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has text, eye, and detail differences; second model has style and detail differences from the prompt.
a009ea0a59bb0f9d65509dc35bb4755991d99d8715e3209259c9b2408c355828	draw	6	5	20.010821	Direct pass: Eye color mismatch, horn details, and texture differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in eye color, texture details, and background elements (shadows in second model not present in prompt)
a15951c1c8169f12542ea548f5720e9c6712b9b4b3f7c1a2acdc379b413d0877	draw	6	6	19.478128	Direct pass: Shape differences, missing detailed textures; second model has more stylized form with less detail matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and less detailed textures; second model has wrong style, significant detail omissions, and simplified features.
a3bedcf78898853fa29f368a0fd585c8a455a05d0c040c908ef0d8013564b848	leader	6	3.5	19.602998	Direct pass: First model has foggy background and less detail; second has minor shape differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has non-plain background and style deviations.
a4e1bdfebbc3f035dde6c562c18ff7787261c3cb7a387e0bdd66d52566c29d1b	draw	5.5	5	21.671062	Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail and style differences; sails and hull decorations lack prompt's intricacy.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail/stylization differences; second model has moderate issues with stylization and detail richness compared to the prompt's ornate ship.
a9155cfb1966d483eee2f833cbf2ae550805c8d6cd7f4d5c48abe0d2f461d25d	draw	5	5	23.336504	Direct pass: First model includes a pot not present in the prompt; second model lacks surrounding smaller plants and has less leaf detail variation.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/leaf detail differences; second model includes pots not present in the prompt, altering the plant's structure.
aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25	leader	5	3	19.466301	Direct pass: First model has stylized/cartoonish appearance with simplified details; second model has realistic style with minor shape differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/lighting differences; second model has style and detail issues (stylized appearance, missing prompt-specific details like realistic texture and specific lantern features)
aad3b4d577164d093ba365e5ced2f25f9c40d8f5475b452177ac4cd9738b9e9c	leader	10	5	33.629737	Direct pass: First model has no recognizable flute features (appears as indistinct gray shapes); second model has simplified details but general flute shape and structure match the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (details missing); second model is completely wrong object
ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa	leader	5	3	18.13593	Direct pass: Both models have variations in facial features (eye size/detail), clothing details (belt/texture), and background; first model has more significant lighting/background differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight clothing texture/color differences), second model has moderate issues (style, background, detail definition differences)
ae4aaafc7f9dc3d389701cd63ed7a3446bbd0a6b386fededbc0d7e11bb70052a	leader	5	3	22.03467	Direct pass: First model has inconsistent chocolate color (lighter brown in some views) and texture differences; second model has closer color but minor interior detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and lighting variations; second model has more significant style, texture, and color deviations from the prompt.
af7ad9f9698ebd95e75b5c67dc11f41df230773ecb20aca90397d67e2dd2754a	leader	5	3	19.363836	Direct pass: First model has simplified geometry and details; second model has closer details but minor differences in specific elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, different background, missing fine details)
afa3b56dd5492bf92b370f568aa67535a1bd2b0499d356955811738563539961	draw	5	6	20.051454	Direct pass: First model has slight shape/arrangement differences; second model includes a pot not present in the prompt, causing major style deviation.. Swapped pass: Both models include a pot/container not present in the prompt, with differences in flower/leaf details and structure.
b12086d1932981fcbb10b778faa613245fb9948a0d5950b96f611a056e3b2fa4	leader	5	3	20.144138	Direct pass: First model has angular base with less ornate metalwork; second model has more ornate base but some item details differ from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with style and item details (e.g., base design, item types).
b303c3cb0ba094b7c81ca27b707e4d0f89bf8a758ed22c89c92c911f97b53fbb	leader	6	4	19.581403	Direct pass: First model has wrong object type (cup instead of pitcher) with missing spout and incorrect base; second model has minor shape differences but closer to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., handle/spout positioning); second model adds unrelated elements (base, circular object) not present in the prompt
ba495014c7920c09602f1ecc0c75c051f005dcb6a8bbf132d07ede2ee43b9e32	draw	4.5	4.5	21.653068	Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor decorative details missing in some areas.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, color tone variations
bb8940b2f8373b5a117dc0a8cadd897295f4218f1dca6935a7551cda99ea1495	leader	7	3.5	19.040473	Direct pass: First model has major shape and detail distortions (vase structure is abstracted, base and flower details are inconsistent with prompt); second model has minor detail differences but closer structural match to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., flower arrangement, base texture); second model has major structural and shape deviations (vase form, base design) from the prompt.
bb9516b8-ce2b-41c7-8bc0-12175e2b7f8c	draw	4	5	19.436108	Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, matte finish instead of glossy
bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8	leader	5.5	3.5	31.573105	Direct pass: Color mismatch, shape variations, and some structural details do not match the prompt's original model features. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has more significant style and detail mismatches with the prompt.
bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338	draw	5	5	19.194831	Direct pass: First model has additional base platform and foliage style differences; second model has structure and detail differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Second model includes an additional base platform not present in the prompt; first model has minor differences in foliage arrangement and trunk detail.
bde7f1318ed6e9a8f8a7f98e1902e1a5881324d0e913d3b72e97a8ca271f6c8b	draw	5.5	6.5	21.789386	Direct pass: First model has minor texture/color/pattern differences; second model has moderate to major differences in color tone, translucency, and pattern details from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has solid color, lacks texture details and golden highlights; second model has different pattern style, less geometric detail matching prompt.
c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283	draw	5.5	4.5	18.893799	Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences, inconsistent beak/branch features. Swapped pass: Branch shape, beak size, and small details (e.g., extra objects on branch) differ from prompt; pattern adherence is moderate with minor deviations.

041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28

ours

3.5

5.5

21.293677

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model lacks small plant elements; second model has plants but has shape/style differences.

0856500b5ada44f3a17f2f798f29ab14932dc75bdac03b1d1874c25c7a48b257

draw

5

4

32.834005

Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing clean background details, bristle texture inconsistencies. Swapped pass: Background elements (shadows, extra base) and bristle texture details differ from prompt

08716ba11520bf19be5fe52ab460dc5eebb88cc1fc6ec6ae467d6f15f31b6012

draw

5

29.915627

Direct pass: First model has slight shape and texture variations; second model has more significant shape and detail deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, detail inaccuracies, box texture and shadow inconsistencies

0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8

leader

6

3

20.348717

Direct pass: First model includes extra landscape elements not in the prompt; second model lacks the shell-like object but the dinosaur matches the prompt’s dinosaur closely.. Swapped pass: First model lacks the shell object from the prompt; second model includes an environment with extra elements, deviating from the prompt's simple scene

0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd

draw

4.5

20.77296

Direct pass: Slight to moderate differences in planter detail, leaf texture, and pepper arrangement compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Planter ornate details differ, plant density and chili pepper placement vary from prompt.

102fb0383ddd07f4c982a442c9af4b64633d9cd31a1f9415c59e31df2617f048

draw

5

30.99581

Direct pass: First model includes a paint puddle not present in the prompt; second model has a yellow handle, altered ferrule, and differently shaped bristles compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has color and detail differences (e.g., handle color, ferrule appearance); second model includes a paint puddle (not present in the prompt) and altered brush details.

118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a

leader

6.5

5

31.905061

Direct pass: Shape distortions, hardware details (pickups, knobs, pickguard) don't match prompt's specific designs; wood grain texture varies.. Swapped pass: Minor to major detail mismatches, hardware inaccuracies, and texture differences from prompt

11d30908bf1c6b65318373412b8a0a345cbbb1635dd53e523e245ca93a6ae08b

leader

6.5

3.5

22.453615

Direct pass: First model has less glassy appearance, darker case, and less vibrant internal patterns; second model has closer glassy appearance but minor pattern/style differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in internal pattern clarity and surface details; second model has poor background, unclear views, and altered style.

1277164db5ef94fe044feadbc6b86cff360c7923c6e6aa3dcb6c196f9e0e41c4

leader

5

3

19.773076

Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (spout, handle, body proportions) between models and prompt; first model has moderate stylistic variations, second model has minor differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (handle, spout, lid details); second model has more noticeable style differences (base platform, shape proportions) and missing prompt elements (no base platform in original prompt).

14b932391473feb2862031fd9ce3366d5ada7ffe2e70a6d9fdde641a4661e0c9

leader

6

3

32.108085

Direct pass: First model has distorted hull shape and foggy background; second model has minor details but closer adherence to prompt's sailboat structure and colors.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has significant background and hull style deviations.

14f80504c56effdd9bca0a1b6e5227c0083bde89fc874d5c45dc3390cf01e3ce

ours

5

6.5

19.975876

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences (more curved structure, dark side variations) while second model has major shape differences (cylindrical container with multiple openings, not matching rolled paper structure). Swapped pass: Both models have shape and style differences from the rolled paper prompt; first model has additional cylindrical protrusions, second model has a more sculptural, curved form, and neither matches the prompt’s rolled paper structure as closely.

172103d9-ac53-465c-8328-21be51e90e8e

leader

5

3

35.275062

Direct pass: First model has simplified architectural details and less detailed door carvings; second model has closer adherence but minor texture/proportion differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and small detail variations; second model has wrong style and significant detail/ornamentation missing compared to prompt.

18edab1f3c193d7e57460a765271a29df141024eb583dcdbcf2a9da9d8923d2e

leader

7

4

19.698545

Direct pass: First model has foggy background, inconsistent chair designs, and table details; second model has closer alignment but minor chair position differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/position differences; second model has major environment/lighting issues (foggy background, mismatched atmosphere)

1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611

draw

6

5

21.401377

Direct pass: Texture and detail discrepancies, style variations from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing); second model has major issues (wrong background, distorted continent shapes)

2229cf5f-955c-4bc2-91c3-df9255a1c01d

leader

6

4

19.47082

Direct pass: Gemstone shape and band texture differ from the prompt; first model has non-oval gemstone and distinct band texture, second model has closer gemstone shape but still differs in band detail.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences in gemstone cut and band details; second model has major style differences with an elaborate cutout band not matching the prompt's simpler design.

226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f

draw

6

5

21.262947

Direct pass: Style and detail differences; less intricate carvings and decorative items compared to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, some details missing); second model has major issues (stylized appearance, significant details missing, background mismatch)

23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924

draw

4.5

4

23.524075

Direct pass: Minor shape differences in chocolate toppings, slight variations in layer colors/textures, and plate details; moderate issues in second model's overall consistency with prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, topping texture variations, and minor detail inconsistencies in first model; moderate style and detail mismatches in second model

2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe

leader

7

5

18.659234

Direct pass: First model has major shape and detail discrepancies; second has moderate detail and style differences from the prompt's polished, detailed brass instrument.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail/realism differences (stylized appearance, less intricate mechanical details); second model has major issues (stylized/abstract style, significant detail loss, some views unclear, inconsistent realism).

295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484

leader

7

3

21.4968

Direct pass: First model includes a cage (not present in the prompt), second model has minor shape/texture differences from the original dolphin statue.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/color details, second model has major cage addition not in prompt

29de854bc5984bda7ff04b95a82c21ed70c5546f121b7726a661a12deefd0c65

draw

4

19.213106

Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences (e.g., base, fur texture) but maintains core subject and tack style; second model has moderate issues with altered gem arrangements, tack detail, and overall realism matching prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has base addition and altered tack details.

2f6348a87b52cf24bbf2339826248afb14a1388801d7f3a7eecc4c166a739f58

draw

5

4

20.33039

Direct pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues: first model includes extra objects not in the prompt and has less precise intricate details; second model has simplified ornateness and missing detailed elements from the original clock.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., simplified central blue design), second model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, additional base elements not in prompt, less detailed ornamentation)

325b837b6f588d1bb4698af689c8afdd86320d3c04b839a9c25bead94d6c010c

draw

4.5

3.5

20.384249

Direct pass: Slight shape differences in mannequin and necklace details; stone arrangement variations from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)

33532e138e69ddba7c5e762eed4bedb6b3fcd1a55302cd784c823d8d76d705f2

leader

7

3.5

19.293069

Direct pass: First model has major issues (abstract style, shape differences); second model has minor issues (slight details missing). Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has significant style and detail issues, with less accurate representation of the prompt’s mechanical structure and features.

33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94

leader

7

4

19.720396

Direct pass: First model has incorrect color (red instead of rusty brown), smooth texture instead of aged/rusty, and mismatched grille/headlight details. Second model has closer color/texture but still has minor grille/headlight details mismatch.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight detail differences), second model has major issues (color/texture mismatch with prompt's aged, rusty appearance)

364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625

ours

5

7

20.484055

Direct pass: Fried coating texture and detail accuracy vary; some models lack proper fried appearance, plate details inconsistent.. Swapped pass: First model missing plate and powder details; second model has plate and powder but shape/texture differences.

3721d86fa0c88f910d49d5340f2f15a7c0b7cbb72317a3bb9250110e478fafea

leader

6.5

5

20.672436

Direct pass: Shape and detail mismatches in harp structure, wheel mechanism, and string arrangement for both 3D models compared to the image prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail and shape differences; second model has major structural mismatch in the attached component, altering the original's mechanical design.

3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06

draw

6

18.971497

Direct pass: First model has stylized items, wheel color differences, and minor shape alterations; second model has significant item style mismatches (lab equipment instead of bottles) and structural differences.. Swapped pass: Both models have shape differences, style mismatches, and missing details compared to the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.

3aff357f2c9bc317c083c24d896cdc32f43dd78f0831c3a359f67d08771d23de

leader

6.5

3.5

20.17488

Direct pass: First model has foggy background and less detailed wood texture; second model has minor structural details differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has major style/detail/background issues.

3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549

leader

7

3

20.656433

Direct pass: First model has muted color, less clear engravings, and lighting issues; second model has closer match with golden color and clearer engravings but minor detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has major issues with background, color, and visibility.

3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d

draw

5

20.02142

Direct pass: Pattern details, bed frame color, and pillow positioning do not fully match the prompt; style and small details have moderate deviations.. Swapped pass: Pattern does not match original star/moon design; bed structure and pillow positioning have deviations.

3f48598320210ac8659a36fd57bccddba1bc5acbab93ac579a0587321088aa84

leader

7.5

5

19.939435

Direct pass: First model has incorrect earring shapes, missing/incorrect floral engravings, and stand design differences; second model has some earrings without floral engravings, stand design differences, and shape inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., some earrings lack detailed floral engravings, stand has slight design variations); second model has major issues (earrings are not heart - shaped, style and shape differ significantly from prompt)

4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59

leader

6.5

4

33.990963

Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in decorative details, wood texture, and base design; overall structure matches but some fine details differ.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)

41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60

leader

5

3

22.084119

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences, blurry views, and missing small details; second model has closer match with slight detail variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has altered style, background, and missing details.

43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb

leader

7.5

5

20.96191

Direct pass: First model has major issues with base texture/color and mushroom shape/texture; second model has moderate issues with base shape but closer mushroom form.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape and detail differences; second model has significant style, color, and structural differences from the prompt.

449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8

leader

7

5

19.167331

Direct pass: First model has color mismatch (red instead of warm brown wood), distorted views, and missing detailed elements like pipes/keyboard. Second model has closed cabinet sections when prompt shows open organ with visible pipes, and some structural details don't match the prompt's ornate design.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail/shape differences; second model has major style/color/structure issues.

450f110234b2dbed200824a1cef7c71e0210f244d7e6568b9b28536add3dbc91

leader

6

4

19.036616

Direct pass: Background color mismatch, stylus position variation, minor detail differences (stylus cap not visible). Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details (e.g., stylus cap), and incorrect accessories (stand, extra stylus) in both models

45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f

leader

5

3

19.135702

Direct pass: First model has exaggerated shadows and minor structural/detail mismatches; second model has closer adherence with minor variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail position differences; second model has prominent stylistic shadow effects affecting overall adherence.

467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c

draw

5

23.121099

Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, detail inconsistencies); second model has major issues (exterior texture with holes, seed appearance mismatch, overall structural differences from prompt). Swapped pass: Shape and detail variations from prompt; first model has minor differences in spines/flesh arrangement, second model has more noticeable structural differences

47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe

draw

8.5

31.477431

Direct pass: First model has additional wing-like structures not present in the prompt; second model is a knife with a handle, which is a different object type than the prompt's blade shape.. Swapped pass: First model is a knife with a wooden handle (does not match the sleek, handle-less blade-like shape of the prompt); second model is a winged flying object (completely different category from the prompt's blade-like shape)

4d6ac3c290d8d905f66493a5323b48d2ccdbffe9772ac75789cf329b7612ee8e

draw

5

19.78201

Direct pass: First model has frame and minor fabric detail differences; second model has fabric pattern and style mismatch.. Swapped pass: First model has minor frame and fabric detail differences; second model has more significant fabric pattern and frame style differences from the prompt.

52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869

draw

6

31.736752

Direct pass: First model has incorrect base and slight shape variations; second model has altered top design and structural differences compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has shape and detail differences; second model adds an unnecessary wooden base not present in the prompt.

55d1ffed3903d9c2aa353c5a25095b820ab20ca40638fc983f31b8f323e8f938

leader

5

3

38.571288

Direct pass: First model has shape differences (bed structure, kangaroo posture/ear details); second model has closer alignment but minor detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences; second model has wrong style and significant details missing

56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6

leader

7

3.5

19.547963

Direct pass: First model has extra non-prompt components; second model has minor detail differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has major structural differences (extra components, altered base style) not matching the prompt.

5a4ed3dbf08dd164fecc8aa0e6f0442535d231e6631b376134e6030c844f5e1d

leader

6

4

19.022542

Direct pass: First model has stylized/cartoonish rendering with slight shape differences and reduced detail; second model has closer structural match but some minor detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and detail issues.

5a9fc370-eede-4782-a75f-5db3b4c01d16

leader

5

3

20.777435

Direct pass: First model has blurred background and slight shape/texture deviations; second model has cleaner background but minor shape details differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has significant background/style issues (non-white background, altered texture appearance)

5b5f6e0ea01aa6c631558c6968b0eb1d4ddfdc322b83c36000c16539be4e2f9e

draw

5.5

21.013117

Direct pass: Both 3D models have significant structural and stylistic differences from the image prompt. The first model has rounded, less sharp formations and a compact layout, while the second model features a single, compact formation rather than the spread - out, multi - formation landscape. Both lack the detailed, sharp rock structures and expansive terrain of the prompt.. Swapped pass: Models are too small, lack landscape scale and variety of rock formations as in the prompt.

5c58930b6bb84c9a314cb65840dba3b9c0a4f09faf6a33c9eabe89932a385746

draw

4

5

18.433455

Direct pass: Mantel ornamentation, fire detail, and structural details do not fully match the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (some views show fireplace as planter), fire and greenery details vary; second model has longer fireplace structure with minor style differences.

5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8

draw

4

20.47696

Direct pass: Minor foliage density differences; overall structure (cage with hanging chain, plants/flowers) matches prompt.. Swapped pass: Style mismatch (sketchy prompt vs photorealistic 3D models), moderate differences in foliage density and structural detail adherence

5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0

draw

5

21.136822

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail omissions; second model has moderate issues with style and significant detail mismatches compared to the prompt's classic Beetle design. Swapped pass: First model has moderate detail mismatches (shape, headlight/bumper details); second model has major issues (shadows, style differences, detail inaccuracies).

654e544bd515c1934d9b98ca32d6b6ad214823c9692134fad37145a0683edf73

draw

5.5

4.5

22.481178

Direct pass: First model includes non-prompt shadow elements and more ornate band details; second model has simpler band design and less detailed gemstone facets.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has major issues with extra shadow elements, style mismatches in band and gemstone.

679622ec8c54ae5a3234febd658d5dd7b94b9f5cf79c4bf04ae0e23494ff1076

draw

5

19.680334

Direct pass: First model has moderate detail mismatches; second model has major issues with detail and style. Swapped pass: First model has less defined engravings and muted texture; second model has stylized design, altered texture, and different engraving details compared to prompt.

693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4

leader

5

3

33.205697

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and style differences; second model closely matches prompt features like hat color, body texture, and beard details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences (slight pose/lighting details), second model has moderate issues (style/color/shadow differences from prompt)

69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad

leader

5

3

20.685543

Direct pass: First model has pink blur background and slightly softer shape details; second model has minor shape differences but matches prompt’s background and detail structure better. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/angle differences; second model has background blur and style distortion.

6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615

leader

6

4

21.439368

Direct pass: First model has shape differences, floral details mismatch; second model has minor shape differences but closer floral details and visible crack.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail inconsistencies; second model has major style and detail deviations.

70c21b53b86017a3e1445db93dcab57685f995e02b9dd4cffa67bcb2a9042761

draw

6

5

20.132097

Direct pass: Shape is similar but color vibrancy and detailed texture differ from prompt; some color variety and detail missing.. Swapped pass: First model has muted colors and less detailed texture; second model has dark color scheme and less vibrant details, both deviating from prompt’s bright, multicolored, glittery style.

70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9

leader

6

4

20.774112

Direct pass: First model has major issues (wrong clock face details, pendulum design, wood texture imperfections); second model has moderate issues (minor wood tone differences, clock face details).. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, clock face details), second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing like clock face, pendulum, wood imperfections)

7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34

leader

5

3

19.193915

Direct pass: First model has color mismatch (beige/gold tones) and inconsistent pearl sizes; second model has better color match but minor strand/pearl structure inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/arrangement differences; second model has color, style, and shadow issues.

7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036

draw

5

4

19.595052

Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with pattern details and shape proportions, not matching the prompt's intricate decorative elements as closely.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and significant detail issues.

739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed

draw

5.5

20.516958

Direct pass: Text and detail mismatches, shape differences in roof, windows, and body. Swapped pass: First model has minor text and detail discrepancies; second model has stylized shadows, altered text, and less realistic rendering style.

7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c

draw

6

19.745855

Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (grille, headlights, wheel design) from prompt. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations

79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6

draw

5

4

20.57565

Direct pass: Minor to moderate issues with floral details, unicorn features, and background consistency. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small decorative details; second model has altered style, less detailed decorations, and different background.

7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41

draw

4

20.982184

Direct pass: Hat color variations, clothing detail differences, guitar appearance variations. Swapped pass: First model has slight color differences in the hat and minor detail mismatches; second model has added shadows and more significant hat color differences

7dcf114f53200ab20cb8c5238e6e8c5e16fb66ab6e6857fce3e4715ba2f657b7

draw

5

4.5

18.271527

Direct pass: Cloth draping details, base design, and minor shape variations differ from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor size and detail differences; second model has stylistic and background issues affecting visual quality.

7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87

draw

4.5

19.973713

Direct pass: First model has minor shape variations and shadow details; second model has more noticeable shape and detail differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model includes shadows not in prompt with moderate shape variations.

80a82cc3f228cb7557b0d3ba7bdc5d9e43e4a59806ade7f9a348941ca6ce6a73

leader

7

4

20.469302

Direct pass: First model has significant shape differences in the table structure and stylized elements for items; second model has minor detail mismatches but closer alignment with the prompt’s rustic table and item arrangement.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in item arrangement and detail; second model has major issues with style, background, and item details.

82c6b4608b81474218c8f6561d24e7dc5e0ae3d8e28d9985b0bb8ba525a98e49

leader

7

3

19.118902

Direct pass: First model has foggy background and unclear visual details; second model has clearer details and closer match to prompt elements (e.g., wheel design, frame color, seat).. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight angle variations, minor detail differences); second model has major issues (foggy background, reduced clarity, altered visual presentation)

854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619

draw

5

21.126414

Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with wheel design, cab structure, and front details compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt's specific locomotive features (e.g., front circular opening, wheel design, cab details)

88f9719b883378b80f1a76c6e74dbdeabda5f93e9026e164b1031fb659371e41

draw

5

19.984477

Direct pass: Style and detail differences from prompt; simplified shapes and less intricate mechanical details.. Swapped pass: Style and detail differences; simplified structure and less mechanical complexity compared to prompt.

8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f

draw

4.5

19.502014

Direct pass: Base added in 3D models, color/texture variations, minor shape differences from original prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail inconsistencies; second model adds an extra base element not in the prompt with style variations.

8c15827b6a6a28f4fbde43e0691bcce2e425dff51d0a5d539fba1e77a06425a4

draw

6

22.782004

Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small details; second model has major structural changes (e.g., hook on circular frame) and altered details.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style mismatches with prompt's antique astronomical instrument

8ccae4a48faba6383d865e7c61d719a6d13973b7308c4e20a89342c1b298c94d

leader

6.5

3.5

25.053141

Direct pass: First model has stylized, less realistic petal shapes; second model is more realistic but has minor detail variations in some views.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/stem differences; second model has major stylization and base issues, not matching realistic rose prompt.

8d8a0daab678b83c3b47f617d8b7f402693eea1369ac268209dee4e99704d133

draw

6

5

20.795719

Direct pass: Added base structure not present in prompt; orb details slightly off. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (first model has orange tones, second has purple tones), base details differ from prompt's implied standalone sphere (first has detailed base with drop, second has different textured base), and overall style variation from the original glowing golden-brown sphere.

8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541

leader

6.5

3

21.421139

Direct pass: First model has low visual clarity (foggy rendering) and shape distortions; second model has better clarity but minor detail differences, overall closer to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/leg differences; second model has style, detail, and environment mismatches.

908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015

draw

4.5

3.5

19.676919

Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt, but overall chair structure and wooden style match the image prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., leg/seat details), second model has moderate issues (style variations, added shadow not in prompt)

987ee3ad-ce87-4733-a784-ce3feef9532a

draw

4

19.524873

Direct pass: Shadow presence, color variation, minor shape and detail differences. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, shadows present in second model, detail inconsistencies

988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9

draw

5

31.307553

Direct pass: Basket texture, flower arrangement, and overall detail vary from the prompt; some elements are altered or missing.. Swapped pass: Basket texture, flower details, and overall style differ from the prompt; some models have incorrect basket weaving or flower arrangement.

99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06

leader

7.5

4

20.674112

Direct pass: First model has blurry lemon and grater texture mismatch; second model lacks lemon and grater texture differs.. Swapped pass: First model has minor texture and detail differences; second model has major style, clarity, and detail issues (foggy rendering, less defined shapes)

99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32

draw

6

5.5

19.749219

Direct pass: First model has moderate detail differences, second has major structural/style differences compared to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues (style, details, shadows)

9d1052dc-ab7b-4bdc-b1a6-457e4b073c55

draw

6

5

31.689866

Direct pass: Shape and detail discrepancies, simplified components, texture differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate shape, detail, and texture discrepancies compared to the prompt's guitar.

9ec3a2abd05cffe12e23eab632bb86c138031bc53a12cf685e90c7381561e9e9

draw

6

5

21.069984

Direct pass: Both 3D models have significant detail mismatches (e.g., text, eye design, antenna/coil style, body markings) and style deviations from the image prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has text, eye, and detail differences; second model has style and detail differences from the prompt.

a009ea0a59bb0f9d65509dc35bb4755991d99d8715e3209259c9b2408c355828

draw

6

5

20.010821

Direct pass: Eye color mismatch, horn details, and texture differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in eye color, texture details, and background elements (shadows in second model not present in prompt)

a15951c1c8169f12542ea548f5720e9c6712b9b4b3f7c1a2acdc379b413d0877

draw

6

19.478128

Direct pass: Shape differences, missing detailed textures; second model has more stylized form with less detail matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and less detailed textures; second model has wrong style, significant detail omissions, and simplified features.

a3bedcf78898853fa29f368a0fd585c8a455a05d0c040c908ef0d8013564b848

leader

6

3.5

19.602998

Direct pass: First model has foggy background and less detail; second has minor shape differences. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has non-plain background and style deviations.

a4e1bdfebbc3f035dde6c562c18ff7787261c3cb7a387e0bdd66d52566c29d1b

draw

5.5

5

21.671062

Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail and style differences; sails and hull decorations lack prompt's intricacy.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail/stylization differences; second model has moderate issues with stylization and detail richness compared to the prompt's ornate ship.

a9155cfb1966d483eee2f833cbf2ae550805c8d6cd7f4d5c48abe0d2f461d25d

draw

5

23.336504

Direct pass: First model includes a pot not present in the prompt; second model lacks surrounding smaller plants and has less leaf detail variation.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/leaf detail differences; second model includes pots not present in the prompt, altering the plant's structure.

aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25

leader

5

3

19.466301

Direct pass: First model has stylized/cartoonish appearance with simplified details; second model has realistic style with minor shape differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/lighting differences; second model has style and detail issues (stylized appearance, missing prompt-specific details like realistic texture and specific lantern features)

aad3b4d577164d093ba365e5ced2f25f9c40d8f5475b452177ac4cd9738b9e9c

leader

10

5

33.629737

Direct pass: First model has no recognizable flute features (appears as indistinct gray shapes); second model has simplified details but general flute shape and structure match the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (details missing); second model is completely wrong object

ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa

leader

5

3

18.13593

Direct pass: Both models have variations in facial features (eye size/detail), clothing details (belt/texture), and background; first model has more significant lighting/background differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight clothing texture/color differences), second model has moderate issues (style, background, detail definition differences)

ae4aaafc7f9dc3d389701cd63ed7a3446bbd0a6b386fededbc0d7e11bb70052a

leader

5

3

22.03467

Direct pass: First model has inconsistent chocolate color (lighter brown in some views) and texture differences; second model has closer color but minor interior detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and lighting variations; second model has more significant style, texture, and color deviations from the prompt.

af7ad9f9698ebd95e75b5c67dc11f41df230773ecb20aca90397d67e2dd2754a

leader

5

3

19.363836

Direct pass: First model has simplified geometry and details; second model has closer details but minor differences in specific elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate issues (stylized appearance, different background, missing fine details)

afa3b56dd5492bf92b370f568aa67535a1bd2b0499d356955811738563539961

draw

5

6

20.051454

Direct pass: First model has slight shape/arrangement differences; second model includes a pot not present in the prompt, causing major style deviation.. Swapped pass: Both models include a pot/container not present in the prompt, with differences in flower/leaf details and structure.

b12086d1932981fcbb10b778faa613245fb9948a0d5950b96f611a056e3b2fa4

leader

5

3

20.144138

Direct pass: First model has angular base with less ornate metalwork; second model has more ornate base but some item details differ from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with style and item details (e.g., base design, item types).

b303c3cb0ba094b7c81ca27b707e4d0f89bf8a758ed22c89c92c911f97b53fbb

leader

6

4

19.581403

Direct pass: First model has wrong object type (cup instead of pitcher) with missing spout and incorrect base; second model has minor shape differences but closer to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (e.g., handle/spout positioning); second model adds unrelated elements (base, circular object) not present in the prompt

ba495014c7920c09602f1ecc0c75c051f005dcb6a8bbf132d07ede2ee43b9e32

draw

4.5

21.653068

Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor decorative details missing in some areas.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small decorative details, color tone variations

bb8940b2f8373b5a117dc0a8cadd897295f4218f1dca6935a7551cda99ea1495

leader

7

3.5

19.040473

Direct pass: First model has major shape and detail distortions (vase structure is abstracted, base and flower details are inconsistent with prompt); second model has minor detail differences but closer structural match to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., flower arrangement, base texture); second model has major structural and shape deviations (vase form, base design) from the prompt.

bb9516b8-ce2b-41c7-8bc0-12175e2b7f8c

draw

4

5

19.436108

Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, matte finish instead of glossy

bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8

leader

5.5

3.5

31.573105

Direct pass: Color mismatch, shape variations, and some structural details do not match the prompt's original model features. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has more significant style and detail mismatches with the prompt.

bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338

draw

5

19.194831

Direct pass: First model has additional base platform and foliage style differences; second model has structure and detail differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Second model includes an additional base platform not present in the prompt; first model has minor differences in foliage arrangement and trunk detail.

bde7f1318ed6e9a8f8a7f98e1902e1a5881324d0e913d3b72e97a8ca271f6c8b

draw

5.5

6.5

21.789386

Direct pass: First model has minor texture/color/pattern differences; second model has moderate to major differences in color tone, translucency, and pattern details from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has solid color, lacks texture details and golden highlights; second model has different pattern style, less geometric detail matching prompt.

c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283

draw

5.5

4.5

18.893799

Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences, inconsistent beak/branch features. Swapped pass: Branch shape, beak size, and small details (e.g., extra objects on branch) differ from prompt; pattern adherence is moderate with minor deviations.

Metric	Value
Total Tasks	128
Total Judged	124
Skipped	0
Gen Failed	0
Render Failed	0
Judge Failed	4

Result	Count
🏆 WINS	4
🤝 DRAWS	69
❌ LOSSES	51

Metric	Value
Win Rate	3.2%
Margin	-37.9%
Avg Gen Time	22.38s

Datasets:

yuri1996
/

round_11_v2.1.0

Benchmark Results: v2.1.0

Overview

Summary

Results

Performance

Methodology

Files