task_id
stringlengths 36
64
| origin
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| origin_white
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| ours
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| leader
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| winner
stringclasses 3
values | ours_penalty
float64 3.5
10
| leader_penalty
float64 3
8.5
| gen_time
int64 0
0
| issues
stringlengths 174
464
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
041f6e43b4ab56ba224cefe489dbdce3b30587579c137c3b44fd53553e40ef28
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, cork details, liquid color/texture, missing small plant elements. Swapped pass: Missing small details (adjacent plant elements), slight shape and texture variations, inconsistent lighting and shadow treatment.
|
||||
0856500b5ada44f3a17f2f798f29ab14932dc75bdac03b1d1874c25c7a48b257
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model includes paint splatters not present in the prompt; second model has altered bristle gradient and handle design compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (shadows, color gradient, handle details); second model has major issues (context, shape, color differences)
|
||||
0ba59ee2dbe675ce6a38985c6707c348f8bebdb9be9d2944c16fc0f4826a7fb8
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has extra base elements; second model has smoother texture and missing small details compared to the prompt dinosaur.. Swapped pass: Both models omit the shell object from the prompt; first model has plain background, second has an additional base element.
|
||||
0cdce8dc9ad723240ab568806084a92dc183b9f59d137ba2b6b36a1eaea8fdbd
|
draw
| 5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Planter color, plant texture, and chili details differ from prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate detail differences in planter carvings, plant density, and chili pepper visibility between models and prompt.
|
||||
102fb0383ddd07f4c982a442c9af4b64633d9cd31a1f9415c59e31df2617f048
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model includes an additional container with liquid (not in prompt) and altered handle/ferrule details; second model has altered handle color and bristle appearance.. Swapped pass: First model has altered handle color, ferrule design, and bristle texture; second model has altered handle/ferrule, added base with liquid, and different context.
|
||||
118ce00eb976dac86815b0b5b44c38ecede049180b13b66bc83cddd0f43b972a
|
leader
| 6
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing detailed hardware, stylized rendering deviates from prompt's realistic guitar. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has significant shape differences, missing details, and extra non-prompt elements (bases)
|
||||
11d30908bf1c6b65318373412b8a0a345cbbb1635dd53e523e245ca93a6ae08b
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor detail differences; second model has moderate issues (blurred internal pattern, style variation). Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in internal pattern detail and glass texture; second model has moderate differences in internal pattern style and overall visual coherence.
|
||||
1277164db5ef94fe044feadbc6b86cff360c7923c6e6aa3dcb6c196f9e0e41c4
|
draw
| 3.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences from the prompt's specific teapot design. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, handle/finial details vary slightly from prompt
|
||||
14b932391473feb2862031fd9ce3366d5ada7ffe2e70a6d9fdde641a4661e0c9
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Sail shape, hull curvature, and deck details do not fully match the prompt; first model has minor discrepancies, second model has moderate discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model has base and hull shape issues.
|
||||
14f80504c56effdd9bca0a1b6e5227c0083bde89fc874d5c45dc3390cf01e3ce
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has shape differences (dark elements, altered roll structure); second model is a cylindrical container (different object type) with mismatched structure.. Swapped pass: Shape differences (container-like vs rolled scroll), color variations, form not matching prompt's rolled paper with stand
|
||||
18edab1f3c193d7e57460a765271a29df141024eb583dcdbcf2a9da9d8923d2e
|
draw
| 5.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details in chair designs and object representation.. Swapped pass: Chair styles, table base details, and object placement vary from the prompt; second model has more significant style and detail differences
|
||||
1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611
|
draw
| 6.5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: Color scheme and texture details do not match the prompt's artistic style; continents' colors and overall visual quality differ from the original globe prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has simplified texture and less accurate continent details; second model has stylized, cartoonish appearance with mismatched color schemes and texture density; both lack prompt’s specific visual details.
|
||||
226edd32ca98ab30cfd6dc65e0ea9906c9bbc9d94553eaddda8f5bf199d1a96f
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (simplified decorative details, altered interior pattern); second model has major issues (stylized appearance, less detailed craftsmanship, darker tone).
|
||||
23fe2be02fd9b9189162fbac2b3a3a3e98050891ce404dca8d2c2fc706e4a924
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences, frosting and layer texture variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in chocolate swirl shapes and cake shading; second model has more noticeable deviations in swirl shapes, cake layer shading, and cocoa dusting consistency.
|
||||
2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail simplification; second model has stylized shape and detail issues.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations from original prompt's detailed brass instrument features.
|
||||
295b0134697089e4ad67fd546067ef34ec734fb6763ac8eaa91e94859d67e484
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have color, texture, and water detail differences from the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.. Swapped pass: Shape, texture, and water base details do not fully match the prompt; variations in dolphin form and water splash.
|
||||
2f6348a87b52cf24bbf2339826248afb14a1388801d7f3a7eecc4c166a739f58
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has extra unrelated objects, altered clock design; second model has simplified, less ornate clock design with missing intricate details matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major issues with extra unrelated objects and altered style.
|
||||
325b837b6f588d1bb4698af689c8afdd86320d3c04b839a9c25bead94d6c010c
|
leader
| 6
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has distorted mannequin shape and minor necklace detail differences; second model has minor stone arrangement differences but better mannequin consistency with prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major shape distortion and style inaccuracies.
|
||||
33532e138e69ddba7c5e762eed4bedb6b3fcd1a55302cd784c823d8d76d705f2
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the original prompt's object; first model has slight variations, second has more noticeable deviations.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail variations; some components do not match prompt's specific structure and wear details.
|
||||
33621dff7a5d674f2a6a65cefde283518d5f7a2d0651ffe922815894373b9d94
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have variations in color tone, grille design, and license plate details; first model exhibits more noticeable shape and detail discrepancies compared to the second model.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/details differences; second model has moderate issues (color, rust texture, and detail accuracy).
|
||||
364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape similarity exists but texture, coating details, and plate representation are inconsistent with the prompt's visual quality and prompt adherence.. Swapped pass: Missing plate/powder details, texture differences, shape inconsistencies
|
||||
3721d86fa0c88f910d49d5340f2f15a7c0b7cbb72317a3bb9250110e478fafea
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail variations from the original prompt's harp and wheel design. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences from the prompt; second model has more noticeable deviations in structure and design elements.
|
||||
3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Items are stylized as non - glass containers, cart structure has shape differences, some original details missing.. Swapped pass: Items have altered shapes/colors, cart structure and item details differ from prompt; second model has more significant style mismatches.
|
||||
3da8b6b0ab3951bec87054867672993add93401d8fb5b789ff955e8e14510549
|
leader
| 5.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail differences in engravings, handle shapes, and texture fidelity; first model includes misty effects not present in the prompt, second model has slightly less detailed floral engravings compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, misty effect, significant details missing)
|
||||
3dd4c9c14e27f8b8efdddafe444a007b79da870cbb5fb802ec16a5ebfcd3757d
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Pattern mismatch, style differences, structural details not matching the prompt. Swapped pass: Pattern mismatch, slight shape differences, missing original star/moon details.
|
||||
4024d0d716bab965da116c926ce66d038effa6491958e34b61aa503fdf91ee59
|
draw
| 5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail differences, slightly less precise decorative elements. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail discrepancies (jewel placement, wood texture), second model has moderate style and detail issues (simplified ornamentation, less realistic rendering)
|
||||
41f73b6d49b8d4da148970625c953dfd01168452a8c2b5f5afb2ffabe2c38f60
|
leader
| 6
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail mismatches; second model has closer adherence with minor issues. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and object discrepancies.
|
||||
43aae08a60c33989c42962674e077214c5aa7da828aab28b2f9af3fd91e454bb
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has extra leaves and incorrect base structure; second model has incorrect base (log) but closer mushroom shape/texture.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and less detailed base texture; second model has extra elements (like orange debris) not in prompt, altered base style, and different mushroom arrangement.
|
||||
449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major issues with cabinet closure and structural accuracy.. Swapped pass: Missing small details (pipe arrangement, brass ornamentation) and slight shape differences
|
||||
450f110234b2dbed200824a1cef7c71e0210f244d7e6568b9b28536add3dbc91
|
leader
| 6
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details (stand, stylus position, screen design accuracy). Swapped pass: First model has minor details (stand presence, stylus positioning) issues; second model has major style, structural, and base differences.
|
||||
45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has foggy background, minor structural details (e.g., base, stairs) differ; second model has cleaner background, closer structural details but some minor inconsistencies.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate issues (foggy background, style variations)
|
||||
467591304c95f28c118782e1ffb23a8124ef999870c2951c9e1916355033f21c
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has shape/texture deviations in some views; second model has significant structural changes (holes in exterior) and detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail inconsistencies (exterior holes, seed positioning), second model has major style and texture deviations from the original rambutan.
|
||||
47428f09d21bd52b688549c6d516aa5e5700324835d63c5c1b5db27adb8c69fe
|
ours
| 4
| 8.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has a base and slight shape differences; second model is a knife with a handle (completely unrelated to the prompt's sleek, handle - less object). Swapped pass: First model has a handle (not present in prompt); second model’s blade shape matches prompt but includes an additional base element.
|
||||
4d6ac3c290d8d905f66493a5323b48d2ccdbffe9772ac75789cf329b7612ee8e
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have fabric pattern and structural differences from the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in frame structure; second model has moderate differences in curtain attachment style and overall structure compared to the prompt.
|
||||
52a29ac18c25d8b283f1289a6e6513b08870fd7fc7e9ebadd8b61f92565bc869
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences from the original lantern design. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., top design variation); second model has shadows and style differences not matching the prompt's plain background and detailed lantern style.
|
||||
533670c54d0cfe84109cc34dedae569565c8b55238113d458b35debcb03c5ce1
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and backrest detail variations; second model has more noticeable deviations in backrest design, armrests, and leg structure compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model has moderate issues (shadows, backrest/leg details not matching prompt)
|
||||
55d1ffed3903d9c2aa353c5a25095b820ab20ca40638fc983f31b8f323e8f938
|
leader
| 6
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has shape differences in bed structure and kangaroo posture; second model has minor details but closer adherence to prompt elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and detail variations; second model has moderate issues with style, bed structure, and kangaroo pose.
|
||||
56a8ad381df0c3617f5e33396af62b91a48564a2e6372cb67542d6404c9b77e6
|
leader
| 6
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has mismatched base color/material (dark vs metallic silver), second model has minor shape/color details but better base match.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/color differences; second model has major base/color/plate issues.
|
||||
5a9fc370-eede-4782-a75f-5db3b4c01d16
|
leader
| 5.5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has pink background (not white), blurred rendering, minor shape differences; second model has white background matching prompt, closer shape/texture.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has background/style differences (pink background instead of white, altered texture/lighting).
|
||||
5b5f6e0ea01aa6c631558c6968b0eb1d4ddfdc322b83c36000c16539be4e2f9e
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both 3D models have shape differences (first is compact, second is a single mound) and lack the wide landscape, tall rock formations, and riverbed details from the image prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models lack the landscape scale and water channels of the prompt; the first is a single rock formation, the second is a flat arrangement of formations, neither matching the prompt’s canyon environment with multiple rock structures and water channels.
|
||||
5c58930b6bb84c9a314cb65840dba3b9c0a4f09faf6a33c9eabe89932a385746
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues: slight shape differences, missing ornate details on the fireplace mantel, and fire appearance not matching the prompt's realistic flames with logs.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, fire and log details not matching prompt, mantel ornamentation less detailed
|
||||
5e205c54-7df5-4dc7-bd27-7f6d6946e8c5
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has foggy background and minor shape differences; second model has minor shape differences but matches clean white background better. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and slight detail variations; second model has wrong style (foggy background, artistic rendering) and significant detail differences.
|
||||
5eaf242b81d934958f083ecc80e5eb718e47760646755c0180e640b1401f14f8
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Lush foliage differs from prompt's sketchy, ethereal style; structure matches but foliage density and artistic style do not align with prompt's appearance. Swapped pass: Style mismatch (ethereal sketch vs. photorealistic lush greenery), some detail differences in foliage density and structure clarity.
|
||||
654e544bd515c1934d9b98ca32d6b6ad214823c9692134fad37145a0683edf73
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Gemstone shape differs from prompt's faceted design, band color/finish and small stone placement do not match prompt details. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has style/color differences (dark band, altered gemstone tone)
|
||||
679622ec8c54ae5a3234febd658d5dd7b94b9f5cf79c4bf04ae0e23494ff1076
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major shape, style, and detail mismatches with the prompt.. Swapped pass: Both models have shape similarities but lack detailed engravings and texture matching the prompt; first model has minor detail issues, second has more style differences (polished look, less textured).
|
||||
693fa83428318227b5389614d89ed1cf33f524db701737c39aa7fca9346532e4
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Texture and color shade variations, minor detail differences from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight texture/lighting differences), second model has moderate issues (style and detail differences from prompt)
|
||||
69847a5d5949d8ce2877b864e7b9ad32ffc7e90b546414d5b79572f0a6669cad
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has non-white background and lighting differences; second model has closer background but minor shape/detail variations. Swapped pass: Minor shape and background differences; first model has white background, second has purple, both have slight shape variations.
|
||||
6c5e165b2ca70be025c9f27a686838938f8f9af145f94da55e5e81ae8b6ff615
|
leader
| 5.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, slightly inaccurate floral details, and texture variations in both models; first model has more visual inconsistencies (e.g., lighting, shape distortions), second model is closer but still has minor detail mismatches.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences (floral arrangement, crack prominence); second model has moderate style/color deviations and less detailed floral elements.
|
||||
70c21b53b86017a3e1445db93dcab57685f995e02b9dd4cffa67bcb2a9042761
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has duller, less vibrant colors and less detailed sparkles; second model has dominant purple base, flatter shape, and less color variation matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has muted color vibrancy and less detailed texture; second model has added base and subdued color scheme deviating from prompt.
|
||||
70e98b098b78e8fa119c5344b1cc49296b3b5491bcbc5bcaf42d131fba13d5d9
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: Clock face details, pendulum positioning, and wood texture vary from the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.. Swapped pass: Clock face details, pendulum position, wood texture and color differ from prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.
|
||||
7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34
|
leader
| 6.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has significant shadow effects and reduced clarity; second model has minor detail differences (pearl uniformity, background).. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., strand arrangement, pearl uniformity), second model has moderate issues (stylized lighting/background, less photorealistic pearl rendering, and altered visual style).
|
||||
7192b95ce5924298101c2bfc42b8ea7aef63f9ffda83e9448393c01c12b13036
|
leader
| 6
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has transparency, faded rendering, and less detailed patterns; second model has closer shape and details but minor differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor pattern/detail differences; second model has significant style/detail/lighting issues (e.g., transparency, non-glossy finish).
|
||||
739f51df572edec2853492f9f34295274748edab03ed1eff4e54f87ed0a579ed
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: Text discrepancies, structural details (roof, wheels) differences, second model includes shadows not present in prompt
|
||||
7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing specific design details (grille, headlights, body curves) from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small design details, style variations from the prompt's sleek, specific sports car design
|
||||
79dba7120244f263228580c4069f51578a30f97304cc2f93c7b7c0666e9eb6b6
|
leader
| 7
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model includes extra objects (spoon, cup) and has shape/position deviations; second model has altered unicorn features (mane/tail) and less detailed floral decorations, both lacking precise adherence to prompt’s design elements.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape and detail differences; second model has major style and composition issues.
|
||||
7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate color/style variations and detail omissions.. Swapped pass: First model has minor color and detail differences; second model has moderate color/style variations and detail discrepancies
|
||||
7dcf114f53200ab20cb8c5238e6e8c5e16fb66ab6e6857fce3e4715ba2f657b7
|
draw
| 4
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor cloth draping and posture differences; slight shape variations from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape and detail differences (e.g., cloth folds, scale), second model has more noticeable style and detail discrepancies (e.g., cloth texture, posture).
|
||||
7fa038abc2705c7878243f34271c8e57ffb3a2ff02c9209ece9ffd658be62a87
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences in crown and brim, variations in band positioning and texture.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences (slight crown variation); second model has moderate shape/style differences from prompt.
|
||||
80a82cc3f228cb7557b0d3ba7bdc5d9e43e4a59806ade7f9a348941ca6ce6a73
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Table structure, item details (bottle, jar, glass), and arrangement vary from prompt; moderate issues. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in table shape/style and item arrangement; second model has moderate issues with table style, item arrangement, and detail accuracy compared to the prompt.
|
||||
82c6b4608b81474218c8f6561d24e7dc5e0ae3d8e28d9985b0bb8ba525a98e49
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor detail mismatches; second model has more noticeable differences in handlebar, seat, and wheel details compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in shape, details, and proportions between 3D models and the image prompt
|
||||
854c1449-39a1-4846-8af4-d6ebe8d4f619
|
draw
| 5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations from original prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has significant style changes (rust, extra cylindrical components) and altered details.
|
||||
88f9719b883378b80f1a76c6e74dbdeabda5f93e9026e164b1031fb659371e41
|
draw
| 6.5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have style differences (cartoonish vs realistic), base inconsistencies (debris vs clean base), and detail inaccuracies compared to the prompt's specific mechanical features. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and environment differences (cartoonish style, additional base elements not in prompt)
|
||||
8badd8b208bbef992ce9fd237cd36f4635f6e50cebe9481b228c7dea44ecc32f
|
leader
| 6
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has misty bowl texture and slight umbrella structural differences; second model has minor details but closer adherence to prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style and scene deviations (fog, altered bowl appearance, different background)
|
||||
8c15827b6a6a28f4fbde43e0691bcce2e425dff51d0a5d539fba1e77a06425a4
|
draw
| 5.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Style and structural mismatches with the original antique astronomical instrument; first model has altered components and textures, second model has different circular frame and central elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small decorative details; second model has significant style and detail discrepancies with altered color scheme.
|
||||
8ccae4a48faba6383d865e7c61d719a6d13973b7308c4e20a89342c1b298c94d
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has shape irregularities, extra elements (e.g., falling petals), and less accurate petal structure; second model has minor shape differences but closer petal smoothness, with some stem details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and variation in petal details; second model has more stylized, less realistic petal shapes and structure.
|
||||
8d8a0daab678b83c3b47f617d8b7f402693eea1369ac268209dee4e99704d133
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has a base (not in prompt), sphere visual quality close; second model has extra small details, base variations, and slight glow differences. Swapped pass: Added base elements not present in the original prompt's standalone sphere; sphere visual quality partially matched but base introduces new elements
|
||||
8fc2ddea1df95aae2032bd9b8e1350395bc8ac4df8aa19add0d4d66c6208b541
|
leader
| 4.5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences; first model has lighter leg color and slight shape variations, second model has closer proportions with minor cushion/armrest details.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and leg color variations; second model has moderate issues with color, shadow details, and subtle shape deviations from the prompt.
|
||||
908221e7-4e93-4467-8b3c-cf5ae382d015
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and texture variations; second model has shadows, altered structural details, and style deviations from the prompt.
|
||||
987ee3ad-ce87-4733-a784-ce3feef9532a
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details (cockpit clarity, landing gear design, propeller details). Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences between models and prompt; second model has more noticeable deviations in structure and style.
|
||||
988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9
|
leader
| 5.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues with basket texture, handle design, and flower arrangement; second model has minor issues with basket texture and flower details.. Swapped pass: Basket texture, flower arrangement, and overall style vary from the prompt; some details (weaving, flower shape) are inconsistent.
|
||||
99b4d83361a8bec719d540ab65b4f4ee8cf7ad6fa512bf0df39b06e8c88cba32
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has more significant style and detail deviations from the prompt's intricate, organic design.. Swapped pass: Slight shape and detail differences, pattern intricacy and color variation not fully matching prompt
|
||||
9d1052dc-ab7b-4bdc-b1a6-457e4b073c55
|
leader
| 7.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape distortions, missing small details (e.g., red pickguard), stylized rendering not matching prompt's realism. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major structural and shape issues, not matching prompt's guitar.
|
||||
9ec3a2abd05cffe12e23eab632bb86c138031bc53a12cf685e90c7381561e9e9
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, text inconsistencies, and mechanical detail mismatches with the prompt.. Swapped pass: Text mismatch, base presence (second model has circular platform not in prompt), minor detail inconsistencies
|
||||
a009ea0a59bb0f9d65509dc35bb4755991d99d8715e3209259c9b2408c355828
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Eye color mismatch (yellow vs green), simplified scale texture, debris variation. Swapped pass: Eye color mismatch, texture detail differences, and additional background elements in second model not matching prompt
|
||||
a15951c1c8169f12542ea548f5720e9c6712b9b4b3f7c1a2acdc379b413d0877
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small details; second model has wrong style and significant details missing.. Swapped pass: Both models have shape differences, posture variations, and detail inconsistencies compared to the prompt, though the fiery creature concept is generally maintained; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues.
|
||||
a4e1bdfebbc3f035dde6c562c18ff7787261c3cb7a387e0bdd66d52566c29d1b
|
draw
| 4
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, variations in sail artwork and decorative details.
|
||||
a9155cfb1966d483eee2f833cbf2ae550805c8d6cd7f4d5c48abe0d2f461d25d
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model includes pots (not present in the prompt), has differences in leaf shape/veining details, and structural arrangement; second model has less detailed leaf structures and structural arrangement differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/arrangement differences; second model includes pots not present in the original prompt, altering the plant's context.
|
||||
aac335885f4aa9fdd952951142fb9679b29360f5435ad365e3466c611783cd25
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate color and style variations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight to moderate shape and detail discrepancies with the prompt's lantern design.
|
||||
aad3b4d577164d093ba365e5ced2f25f9c40d8f5475b452177ac4cd9738b9e9c
|
leader
| 10
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has no recognizable flute structure; second model has minor shape differences but generally matches the flute prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape/angle differences), second model is completely unrelated with no recognizable instrument features.
|
||||
ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa
|
draw
| 4.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences, facial features not matching exactly. Swapped pass: First model has minor details differences (e.g., subtle texture/shape variations), second model has significant style issues (including added shadows not in prompt) and detail mismatches.
|
||||
ae4aaafc7f9dc3d389701cd63ed7a3446bbd0a6b386fededbc0d7e11bb70052a
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor texture and shading differences from prompt, but overall shape and structure match. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has style issues (shadows, texture) and moderate details missing.
|
||||
af7ad9f9698ebd95e75b5c67dc11f41df230773ecb20aca90397d67e2dd2754a
|
leader
| 5.5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Detail accuracy (grille, headlights, license plate), background consistency, and minor shape differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has background and rendering style issues
|
||||
afa3b56dd5492bf92b370f568aa67535a1bd2b0499d356955811738563539961
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Style and detail differences (flower/leaf shapes, arrangement, color tones not matching prompt). Swapped pass: Presence of pot, inconsistent flower color variation, minor shape differences
|
||||
b12086d1932981fcbb10b778faa613245fb9948a0d5950b96f611a056e3b2fa4
|
leader
| 5.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has major differences in base design and item details; second model has minor differences in item arrangement and base decorative elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail mismatches; second model has moderate style and detail differences.
|
||||
b303c3cb0ba094b7c81ca27b707e4d0f89bf8a758ed22c89c92c911f97b53fbb
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and extra small details; second model closely matches the prompt with minor issues.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences; second model has wrong style, additional details, and shadow elements not present in the prompt.
|
||||
ba495014c7920c09602f1ecc0c75c051f005dcb6a8bbf132d07ede2ee43b9e32
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences (e.g., crown design, wing structure, base texture) from the prompt. Swapped pass: Base design, wing structure, and decorative details differ from the prompt; second model has more significant discrepancies in wing shape and base intricacy.
|
||||
bb8940b2f8373b5a117dc0a8cadd897295f4218f1dca6935a7551cda99ea1495
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor differences in base shape, flower arrangement, and lighting details compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in flower details and base texture; second model has major differences in base (flat square vs. textured stone) and flower arrangement.
|
||||
bb9516b8-ce2b-41c7-8bc0-12175e2b7f8c
|
draw
| 6.5
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: Both models have significant differences in design details, body shape, and front end features compared to the prompt's sleek sports car.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, detail mismatches, style variations between models and prompt
|
||||
bd0b6e4db55f60fb3067c0202bdc7530e6b7ab8e3d6059413b067739ff0570f8
|
leader
| 8
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has significant fog, color mismatch, and structural distortion; second model has minor shape differences and detail variations.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues (slight shape/proportion differences, some small details missing); second model has major issues (foggy rendering, significant detail loss, distorted structure, and poor adherence to prompt's clear visual style)
|
||||
bd55ee62bc9eac5c3252cfa6ba7e1a834a7b7a9fee59263805d2bfbb26f44338
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor detail variations; second model has moderate issues with less detailed foliage and altered trunk tone.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, color tone variations, and detail inconsistencies with the prompt's tree structure and foliage.
|
||||
bde7f1318ed6e9a8f8a7f98e1902e1a5881324d0e913d3b72e97a8ca271f6c8b
|
ours
| 4.5
| 6.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (shape similar but texture details, color, and style differ); second model has major issues (shape similar but material, color, and style differ from prompt's translucent, textured, light blue object with golden accents). Swapped pass: First model has color mismatch (dark blue instead of light blue with golden accents) and less detailed texture; second model has closer color but still some texture inconsistencies.
|
||||
c125752a880c340005daec59afb0d03046dadea0513ed3279e30f5b2333f1283
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate issues with branch shape, claw details, and pattern consistency compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Branch shape, feather details, and claw details vary from the prompt; minor posture differences.
|
||||
c72c314361079e968e0d32cd3e65db76bda901cb0a9cd776627549a4eb9b7e8b
|
draw
| 4.5
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences in seat, armrests, and leg designs; upholstery texture variations.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate style/structural differences from the prompt.
|
||||
c8f8051d2bb8b5d584e34dbc2dde44e57fb8ab2f0c51a541f8b4325c19ba8ff5
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail differences, simplified style compared to prompt's detailed realism. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail differences (e.g., cape flow, small armor engravings); second model has moderate detail/style differences (less intricate armor, simplified textures).
|
||||
c9be1edf01035d6afae48de77c143d86e77c0cde3f48c6363d7f1b60726ad08d
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Filament details, glass tone, wire presence/color differ from prompt. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues with filament detail, bulb texture, and wire accuracy; second model has major issues with filament style, bulb color/texture, and artifacts.
|
||||
cb60f3496abf439914b1e4cbc0dcaf3054d4a1814670cda92779c6c04a31ee67
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has perched pose (vs. flying motion in prompt) with minor details; second model has detached body parts (major structural issues). Swapped pass: First model has detached wing/feather parts; second model includes a branch not present in the prompt; both have minor shape/color differences
|
||||
cc926c87a7c4a0fbfd2112f7bb275940517460e259eadbef73313f330e84aa64
|
draw
| 5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Floral details are less detailed, shape variations, and style differences in both models compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and floral detail differences; second model includes shadows and simplified floral details, not matching prompt's style.
|
||||
d12927f8191d1ef1fd43e482404c3b46b801c673436d775fb8ad07c6705624b7
|
leader
| 6
| 3.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has major shape and detail mismatches; second model has minor shape and detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and missing small details; second model has wrong style and significant details missing
|
||||
d80aff06ef6526e57acdbbd3b2d441887425f4fa58acceaefc229059a38cacc0
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 0
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate detail mismatches, style variations, and shape differences from the prompt's specific vintage car features.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, small detail omissions); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)
|
||||
dd39d5fce5d397f4d516efabdfb65f5ac899d607c709ebada64730c9d59d90ff
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 0
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor detail issues; second model has more significant style and detail differences (e.g., altered petal count, chain design).. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/color/chain detail differences; second model has major shape, petal definition, and chain style issues compared to prompt.
|
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
YAML Metadata
Warning:
empty or missing yaml metadata in repo card
(https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/datasets-cards)
Benchmark Results: leader_12_vs_v2.0.0
Overview
- Round: 11
- Test Name: leader_12_vs_v2.0.0
- Timestamp: 2026-01-06 14:59:34
Summary
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total Tasks | 128 |
| Total Judged | 115 |
| Skipped | 0 |
| Gen Failed | 0 |
| Render Failed | 0 |
| Judge Failed | 13 |
Results
| Result | Count |
|---|---|
| 🏆 WINS | 3 |
| 🤝 DRAWS | 80 |
| ❌ LOSSES | 32 |
Performance
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Win Rate | 2.6% |
| Margin | -25.2% |
| Avg Gen Time | 0.00s |
Methodology
- Judge Model: thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking (via OpenRouter)
- Position-Balanced: 2 passes with swapped order to avoid position bias
- Penalty Scale: 0 (perfect) to 10 (completely wrong)
- Winner: Lower average penalty wins (draw if difference ≤ 1)
Files
benchmark_leader_12_vs_v2.0.0.json- Full benchmark results*/ours.png- Our rendered 3D models*/leader.png- Leader's rendered 3D models*/origin.png- Original prompt images
- Downloads last month
- 14