task_id
stringlengths 36
64
| origin
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| origin_white
imagewidth (px) 1.02k
1.02k
| ours
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| leader
imagewidth (px) 1.04k
1.04k
| winner
stringclasses 3
values | ours_penalty
float64 3
7
| leader_penalty
float64 3
7
| gen_time
float64 17.3
35.4
| issues
stringlengths 146
485
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
014635059549225c114d06bec52227b2c72ff0cb4dd8fd7e16cebfb596b8df45
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 24.608198
|
Direct pass: First model has color mismatch (blue vs. teal) and minor detail differences; second model has style mismatch (solid embossed texture vs. semi-transparent lattice with glowing effect, missing light transmission).. Swapped pass: First model has solid (non - transparent) appearance with less detailed pattern; second model has color mismatch (blue instead of teal) but better light - through effect matching the prompt's glowing style.
|
||||
034311d5eec079eb3bca64550e09f3364971a1e82265fd5a64ec751177d46e2b
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4
| 26.704133
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, minor detail inconsistencies with the prompt (e.g., screen interface, button placement, and overall design consistency). Swapped pass: Shape variations, screen UI differences, minor detail mismatches
|
||||
03587e1a7eba88cd159c561c8014987ad082aee71331f8190dc6cf1eef968554
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 19.672195
|
Direct pass: Minor shape/color differences, some details not matching prompt's specific design elements (e.g., glass texture, handle curve). Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, glass texture variations, and bulb appearance inconsistencies between models and prompt
|
||||
0b8f7ddef5e8765598d100c5b64b2ae32e549e554dc1f638e943516b63161ad9
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.928473
|
Direct pass: Both models have less intricate dragon details and structural differences (e.g., lid, handles, base) compared to the prompt; second model has more significant style/ detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and less detailed dragon designs; second model has wrong style, significant detail missing, and stylized dragon designs not matching prompt's intricate detail.
|
||||
0bf7a6cb30a42717ad5346729ce2451179eec807d9e86508c82e395570ed8edc
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 29.231233
|
Direct pass: First model has noticeable differences in color, texture, and detail; second model has minor shape and detail differences.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, color tone variations, texture details not matching prompt
|
||||
0dc0530d9c3b7f4dbf1a59499d0ef09c22799242d078647b600e0e2e1bdd529d
|
draw
| 5
| 4
| 23.019814
|
Direct pass: Shape and orientation differences, cap style variations, chevron pattern clarity issues.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences and minor cap/style variations; second model has more significant shape distortions and potential transparency issues not matching the prompt.
|
||||
109cb158623a7060f5b71d32e18039ecf04b5a29b7a3408a8d7876508b9abdc5
|
draw
| 5.5
| 4.5
| 27.142363
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the original prompt (e.g., grille, headlight, and body line variations). Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations.
|
||||
1224d91185844b16fc9cdc9ebc0253dde69c2c62c6bc6340d91436ebe05f1ed4
|
ours
| 3.5
| 5
| 24.595925
|
Direct pass: Color tone variations, minor differences in mechanical detail accuracy and facial features. Swapped pass: First model has redder color tone, less detailed mechanical components; second model has closer color and structural match but minor detail differences.
|
||||
124fce2c8d90813abcdb2a781495521bc93469b593156eec072933552c0c021e
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 21.826751
|
Direct pass: Rope texture, knot details, and figure appearance differ from the prompt; first model has minor issues, second has moderate issues. Swapped pass: Slight differences in rope texture, knot details, and object positioning; minor variations in object size and hammock shape.
|
||||
183cbe7ad7a71690e4ae6a59c5678ed4eebb0ba6eeb8106314f897e4702c1f38
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 21.876814
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Bail design, gem facets, and surrounding stone arrangement differ from prompt; moderate detail/shape differences.
|
||||
1acf7c53693fcd1e3f6a1266081bfc5ba1f5a795fec863adff1041a1a987b611
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 26.431002
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (shape and detail differences), second has major issues (distorted continents and style mismatch). Swapped pass: Continents have distorted shapes, color distribution and texture details don't fully match the prompt's globe.
|
||||
1b5274b9ffa3ff2a71f726fbab7f24dda28bf2d567a13d5b22d5604ef932ac54
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 25.564576
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Muscle definition and detail vary between models; first model has minor shape differences, second model has moderate detail/shape issues.
|
||||
261ee46ca52df07a017b6f1f1c5a2a03809e96c18334d4aa5877619ca4d761f1
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 25.751282
|
Direct pass: Color and pattern deviations, object detail inaccuracies. Swapped pass: Pattern details, object details (cylindrical item, chains), and some views with unexpected elements (e.g., face-like pattern) do not fully match the prompt's original design.
|
||||
2831800af7589f7b03f3e8b88498f8526107cb17795f10285731f9a5132fc2fe
|
draw
| 6
| 7
| 27.883146
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, stylized variations in second model. Swapped pass: Significant shape distortions, missing detailed valve mechanisms, stylized structure deviating from prompt's realistic brass instrument.
|
||||
2b72f7abb9ba4f586eb29833598306cd8f628351896db2e85e538c06fa4c6fe8
|
ours
| 3
| 4.5
| 22.623454
|
Direct pass: Slight to moderate differences in leaf patterns, spadix details, and pot shape compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in leaf shapes, spadix color tones, and pot details; second model has closer adherence than first.
|
||||
2d99674bf0078adf8b58b4cf75a52896b2192559f97eed2e1926f2f5543c3bfc
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 29.596535
|
Direct pass: Minor shape/texture differences in hat and feathers; second model has more stylized, less detailed feathers.. Swapped pass: Minor shape/texture differences, feather arrangement variations
|
||||
2dada05044c2be25783e212d298ec3a532c651bdee8f8f864244527c6604eaa8
|
ours
| 4
| 7
| 27.549554
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (color variation, dish details); second model has major issues (missing dish, no container as in prompt). Swapped pass: First model lacks dish and peel elements; second model includes dish and peel but has minor texture/color variations.
|
||||
2e3404381c00258e74cb63deba6ff5b9ffaee979f94bfb7b42e4c3d1ec67d218
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 21.940843
|
Direct pass: Minor shape/color differences, handle hole present but with variations in handle/blade texture and color shades. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences (handle curvature, blade edge), second model has moderate style/color issues (handle tone, blade texture).
|
||||
2fd46d4a00a43e432c5e3f97aad8da63a5313ec5e5eaddd628b048e03617c737
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 31.588401
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., handle, spout, color variations), second model has major style and detail mismatches (e.g., overall shape, handle design, lid details) compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Extra handles, material differences, slight shape variations
|
||||
335e936c32e6d573acba32ba4e2ffe528962e076677966e8c9e504e102820900
|
draw
| 4.5
| 3.5
| 22.630897
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt; tripod and scope proportions vary slightly.. Swapped pass: First model has minor structural and tripod differences; second model has lens color and style inconsistencies with the prompt.
|
||||
346e9c57eb002b7b43280e72bb7d711a28a6e5cc5608c0df32d093b88283cc45
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5
| 22.710027
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate design deviations from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail discrepancies from prompt; some design elements (like cockpit details, branding) don't match exactly.
|
||||
3613c7dda6ea4aac4e2cddcbc4399ae742871cf2d4ed3af3e68d6b3452829b73
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.480127
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing specific design details (e.g., front end contours, wheel design) compared to prompt. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences from the prompt's car design
|
||||
364f2e60a97f04ff4292f98b65e765c5bfbfd61615da2ff56ff9fbad4380f625
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 21.285193
|
Direct pass: Shape distortions, missing plate details, texture inconsistencies. Swapped pass: Missing plate element, shape and texture differences from prompt
|
||||
366e3f6911f91e13ffe0d443b9138725678484fdd4f3d91af9af057de0a05cca
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 26.988071
|
Direct pass: Both models have variations in shape, detail accuracy, and some elements (like structural details, window placement, and antenna design) do not fully match the original prompt's specific features; the second model has more stylized deviations.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences from the original airship prompt
|
||||
371ecbf728b0b69ebc3167827e27fa8a60367d88684b29a26d9ac79759ae053c
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 30.780799
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/color variations; second model has more stylized toaster with different control elements, moderate style differences.. Swapped pass: Color scheme, bread texture, and toaster structural details vary from the prompt; first model has minor discrepancies, second has more significant differences.
|
||||
3933fbf64a473ccccb328c23242867f0cbdd8e4aa9cc8f1f9657c9d85f251a06
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 23.824707
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and abstract bottle designs; second model has simplified, stylized bottles with missing detailed glass textures and varied liquid appearances.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have stylized designs with altered bottle shapes (some white instead of glass), different wheel colors, and missing original details like the specific arrangement of bottles and wooden texture.
|
||||
3e0851e6ad60ef9fe1bc81ca1032b31b15b76897f70778dc4cadfda23a7afa70
|
leader
| 5
| 3
| 24.8143
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail differences between models and prompt; first model has moderate issues, second has minor issues.. Swapped pass: First model has slight shape differences; second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing)
|
||||
3ecd482e-9b05-4e76-9b67-a7be1b3183e0
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6
| 27.110152
|
Direct pass: Architectural details (window shapes, roof texture) and surrounding elements (greenery) differ from the prompt; some models have extra features not present in the original image.. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate differences in architectural details (window shapes, chimney design), roof texture fidelity, and surrounding elements compared to the prompt.
|
||||
3f1d5d62cb0614cce92d867d793919fe52f580ed9ce5845be9f7b98f5f42c676
|
ours
| 3.5
| 5
| 21.305171
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations in both models compared to the prompt; first model closer but still has deviations, second model has more noticeable differences in shade texture and base details.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail variations; first model has noticeable differences in base and shade details, second model is closer but still has some issues.
|
||||
441849fb2c2e3050a629ef68216407ee3d61c61554a3b64fd9f85be926401976
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 25.30282
|
Direct pass: Slight shape and detail variations; second model has more noticeable differences.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, slight pen position variations
|
||||
449de7f2e694785e0879713b2b4ce3330941e7bd607d8ff0d67ac5b326aacee8
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 26.678141
|
Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues: wood color tone differs from the prompt's rich brown, pipe arrangement and details do not match the prompt's specific configuration, and decorative golden elements have slight deviations.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, missing small decorative details, pipe arrangement variations, wood texture and brass accent inaccuracies
|
||||
451cb65e16980cd8fe0d55af883cfc0d4426f3d904132f07225bcc47a71ff7c6
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 25.768939
|
Direct pass: First model has closer adherence to prompt with detailed mane and facial features; second model has smoother textures, less detailed mane, and minor facial/body differences.. Swapped pass: First model has minor detail/texture differences; second model has moderate deviations in mane detail and overall form from the prompt.
|
||||
45863577dae88672494c7c79825accb87f6bb3eb5b4e63e5f82ae69fb343e01f
|
draw
| 3
| 3
| 22.45263
|
Direct pass: Minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small details). Swapped pass: Minor differences in small details (e.g., tree placement, stair position) but overall match prompt style and key elements.
|
||||
47d373b11d1409397e10a871c322533a2ed76f5abd828070c336043f9a936a8c
|
draw
| 6.5
| 6.5
| 28.903035
|
Direct pass: Exterior finish, interior object details, and lighting style differ from the prompt; first model has moderate issues, second model has major issues.. Swapped pass: First model has minor item and detail differences; second model has major style/color and item differences from prompt.
|
||||
4b6575be046517851018c88fcb4689db31f92e58ff52e0a0e9d15a1368be2a53
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 22.682362
|
Direct pass: Color variation, bead details, and ring transparency/structure differ significantly from the prompt; models have distorted or mismatched elements.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/color differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues
|
||||
4c6d3269-5b14-4b69-878a-dbb617e4b6ca
|
draw
| 6
| 5.5
| 19.722514
|
Direct pass: Both models have style differences, missing specific details like the prompt's large rusted head structure, color tone, and mechanical joint details.. Swapped pass: Both models have significant shape, detail, and style differences from the prompt's robot (e.g., head structure, rust details, body proportions); first model has moderate issues, second has major issues.
|
||||
4ce93442-09ab-43ee-be49-b475a16e0a34
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 24.588339
|
Direct pass: First model has moderate issues (slight text distortion, minor detail mismatches); second model has major issues (shape deviation, text/style inconsistency). Swapped pass: Text distortion, shape variations, detail inconsistencies with original prompt.
|
||||
4fe364ab983c37c8c741d693fd0e17fccab0abbbafd4aa181ab5097b0c564447
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 21.611299
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style inconsistencies with prompt's sleek sports car design.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate shape and detail differences; second model has major style and structural mismatches with the prompt's sleek sports car design.
|
||||
506457b0c6ff7658b8372f8cc7060e389055e6107ea5faaa32d335c19a81cf64
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 21.095604
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences in pendant frame, variations in amber detail and clarity, metal finish differences. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences in pendant structure and amber details; second model shows more significant deviations from the prompt's design.
|
||||
52b3a22180471563b27d92632d493df74399bbfe938aae8bb86003bc97f6c6ed
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 24.869393
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details, color variations in frosting. Swapped pass: Minor to moderate deviations in topping details, cream shape, crust texture, and color consistency compared to the prompt.
|
||||
544d229fcbcc483b5d323ea33f7254ae31beb7d44c5bedc560176d5de3340b59
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 26.560373
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences and missing small details compared to the prompt. Swapped pass: Color mismatch (white vs silver) and minor shape/detail differences
|
||||
5739aff474a1145cd3759072dbf2971700f1391c785bea8fadcdb29641c4d7cd
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4
| 27.942731
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences from the prompt. Swapped pass: Shape distortions, base inconsistencies, detail mismatches with prompt
|
||||
5dffa92ac67764a8d3f9c472c81f592cd69eee79b13d9e3c6e11a89a64a94c74
|
ours
| 4.5
| 7
| 18.749448
|
Direct pass: First model has minor text stylization and shape differences; second model has major text mismatch and unrelated label text. Swapped pass: Text on labels is distorted, label design does not match the prompt's 'Sparkling' text style, and bottle shape has slight variations.
|
||||
5fb32992826792ea15952387d48a7e84e477f0822c29728858f91eedded1dda0
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 25.174036
|
Direct pass: stylized appearance, simplified details, shape differences from prompt's realistic Beetle. Swapped pass: Simplified style, minor shape and detail differences from the prompt's photorealistic Beetle
|
||||
5ff3374f9139683d51fff5804ec0995fda0392e67dd2cd8c795255503ef9f971
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 26.122695
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has structural (hollow back) and style differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have moderate issues with radial pattern details, shape complexity, and style adherence to the prompt’s intricate, aged mechanical design.
|
||||
60864873e3dcef73f60adbdb9fef1eace2b820b86d76967680f4670edf96b340
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 23.958836
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail variations; second model has moderate issues with architectural structure and detail fidelity.. Swapped pass: Shape differences (e.g., tier structure, base details), color variations (first model has more blue tones, second has purple-blue shifts), and minor detail inconsistencies with the prompt's architectural and glowing elements.
|
||||
658e2f659b3e791cfe553691f5b310b32190e3cc9ec7a1176b2ce904f834dfdf
|
draw
| 3.5
| 3
| 25.194003
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences from prompt. Swapped pass: Slight shape and detail variations in base and shade compared to prompt
|
||||
6c8b3c99ed1eb4e55f6ff1c329559efaccc1c1d943a4a4dfa2717260efd0f7d4
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 22.392507
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences in leg structure and crossbar; second model has more significant structural differences (X-shaped crossbar instead of simple rustic crossbar) not matching the prompt's design.. Swapped pass: Shape and style differences from rustic primitive design; modernized leg structures, smoother textures, and altered leg counts deviate from prompt's rustic aesthetic.
|
||||
6c92f66045cd8523b7e84cb9e799c4694c3574ca18efc52d63127f1f61edd1ca
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 25.641285
|
Direct pass: Cloak texture, belt details, and overall fidelity show minor to moderate deviations from the prompt. Swapped pass: Cloak texture, belt details, and small accessories (gloves, belt decorations) differ from prompt; overall style is close but with moderate detail discrepancies.
|
||||
6d0b277726f0c7da609a007a13082b2a2bfced27754479a2d2b90cc24a7dadf4
|
draw
| 5
| 6
| 20.032096
|
Direct pass: First model has simplified metalwork and crystal details; second model has drastically different crystal structure (beaded) and less ornate design, both deviating from prompt's ornate chandelier.. Swapped pass: Both 3D models have different metal color (golden vs dark), crystal clarity, and ornate style that doesn't match the prompt's chandelier design; first model has lighter, less detailed crystals and metal, second has more elaborate but still mismatched structure.
|
||||
6e75a78c7eafe1c7f32f2981cf8ecf257af22a3923a08bd85301bf28fe89d9d0
|
draw
| 3
| 3
| 25.310453
|
Direct pass: Minor differences in handle grid pattern and metal component details. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, slight texture variations
|
||||
6fa4fdd5f7655db16833f36dc9408a9b47ab8460fc167cda8406d2cb23622683
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 27.335556
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences and texture variations, but overall concept matches the image prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has color shifts, extra elements, and altered stripe patterns
|
||||
7006ccbdf6a6af59062ca148688c9bbafa489b7fee224754f6830530672820af
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 27.799191
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/detail differences; second model has moderate color, shape, and style differences.. Swapped pass: Color variations, slight shape differences in ears/body, minor detail mismatches
|
||||
715afe937c361b7d5f32bfb5128a3191dccbcd4a470b159a41bdd11b7589b2c7
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 28.739355
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, pedal positioning inaccuracies. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details
|
||||
7171ad88e62858e96cbcd9f6cf1cad5c89f1bfb818f5d208ceacd24e489adb34
|
draw
| 4.5
| 5.5
| 24.343325
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues with less realistic pearl texture.. Swapped pass: Pearl texture, strand variation, and overall detail do not fully match the prompt's realistic pearl necklace with multiple strands of varying sizes
|
||||
73857d200d1a302ec03ba26c3736c04a30e9d2d2040b5f634914377f3e1a6e21
|
draw
| 7
| 7
| 26.770958
|
Direct pass: Both models have incorrect text (not 'Pure Honey'), jar details (cap, shape, and text placement) do not match the prompt's clarity and specific elements, with major deviations in prompt adherence.. Swapped pass: Text does not match 'Pure Honey', jar shape/texture, and lid details differ from prompt
|
||||
741a977c0827aac47f90b9fb88eb07da66df546f4f54e64edf16c79d9e2d7ace
|
ours
| 3
| 5
| 18.890039
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/angle differences; second model has color and texture deviations from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has inconsistent color tones and less realistic texture; second model has closer color but minor shape/texture differences.
|
||||
7483ea745921efbcb3b8ea021ec2dfb70901357145a7cc90aca09dc11b06d0f7
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 25.232859
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences, second model has significant structural differences from the mermaid tail prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail differences from prompt; style and color variations.
|
||||
74902bb27492f08ca10f2bd983da45c333acd00f5c6df829615f2f023da5c556
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 22.458144
|
Direct pass: First model has branch presence not in prompt, second model has stylized shape and less detailed feather/texture matching; both have minor to moderate color/detail deviations from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and stylization; second model has major issues due to added branch and altered context.
|
||||
77b0ad70b5199b1bcd4247bf120a2ae7f0f7b91984fa326a0c136a537817f6d5
|
ours
| 5
| 6.5
| 24.551038
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, style mismatches, missing prompt-specific details (e.g., text, camera design, wheel texture). Swapped pass: Style differences (cartoonish vs realistic stylization), missing specific details like wheel tread patterns, camera lens details, and text accuracy
|
||||
7860f46147866e333a052e0507149d44223dc099d518dacc1e2afed662175e3c
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 24.747586
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail differences from prompt; color variations; minor design inconsistencies. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major style/color and detail issues.
|
||||
7b39e9275d8f27800858bc59e490f61572a469b42f9be5169f5b1faf824f1f41
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 23.737704
|
Direct pass: First model has minor issues (slight color variations, pose differences); second model has moderate issues (significant outfit color change, style deviation). Swapped pass: Color mismatches (hat, dress, vest), hat style variations, and some clothing detail differences from the prompt
|
||||
7dab3b8be4e53ec932dc92b82d0c2b00567dde752b068871b194d9b6b26f5ebf
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 30.668179
|
Direct pass: Figurines and wooden structure details do not match the prompt; style, specific animal designs, and structural elements are inconsistent with the original image prompt.. Swapped pass: Figurine shapes, wooden structure details, and overall style significantly differ from the prompt; lighting and texture inconsistencies present in both models.
|
||||
7df1d475b93d7da9d32cdf99543eb5e0f7ef01c1bb458309ff4156fbc5d74d17
|
draw
| 3.5
| 3.5
| 28.458769
|
Direct pass: Slight variations in leaf position, color tone, and texture details compared to the prompt's orange. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, leaf texture variations, minor lighting inconsistencies
|
||||
7e821772287eaecaa54af4f44b2a8a0d2ed36bdecfb0872a6358a4cee15ce965
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 28.285773
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate style and color deviations.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and detail differences between models and prompt; color/lighting variations in some views
|
||||
7ea0eb96627c5787260dc624fb3b2a312cb1ced08e0da2bdef353fdfd4dc22ff
|
draw
| 3.5
| 3.5
| 24.204959
|
Direct pass: Minor shape differences, missing small details. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and missing small details in components like scope, stock, and handguard
|
||||
7f691c0b893a85f92a4ff3d2fa6d05db141af1b1938ba570fdb474a688ead51e
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5
| 34.835014
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail variations, color inconsistencies, spine definition differences from prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, color variations, spine definition inconsistencies, and minor artifacts in second model
|
||||
7fc7e2ce31d9ceff1351199183a5e37bfb868d76aa2a304f0bbb96e55e031fa5
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 30.791265
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences and detail variations between models and prompt; second model exhibits altered structural flow compared to the prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences and minor detail variations from the prompt's intricate swirls and structure.
|
||||
84764b6e8a8b93192ffae3a1e9867063de72e1ac22cbdbbf49fad8f37dac421f
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 22.383683
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has moderate issues with structure and style matching the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences, slight detail variations (blade lattice, roof texture, base structure), and minor style deviations from the prompt's wooden windmill with lattice blades and conical tower.
|
||||
84b59867bc8bc38d67b1684eddc75cf9224fa74262bba979e728bcd63faaf7eb
|
leader
| 6
| 4.5
| 26.938345
|
Direct pass: Both models exhibit color variations, head shape differences, and detail consistency issues compared to the prompt; first model has more pronounced style and detail discrepancies.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate style/color differences; second model has major structural and style differences from the prompt.
|
||||
89bf970ded65a92db2ac1369d6feb5d22b6d40d3a909e9cf54bf16ca98a40603
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 22.663027
|
Direct pass: First model has minor base details not in prompt; second model adds moss/wood elements not in prompt. Swapped pass: Mushrooms match prompt's color and shape, but both models include bases (mossy/dark) not present in the prompt; minor shape/arrangement differences.
|
||||
8a974d9d2ed8fbe9352eba370158719132e546e08f0114ddc7fa07461a5c8547
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 22.801733
|
Direct pass: First model has color variations (pinkish tint), texture blur, and detail inaccuracies; second model has missing emblem/headlight details and minor shape differences.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail discrepancies, color variations from original prompt.
|
||||
9057afb38cac42878c010953807da791909c3d8a9dfbbec7baee9debf89d7860
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 19.853229
|
Direct pass: Both models have moderate issues with wing structure, body proportions, and detail precision compared to the prompt's insect.. Swapped pass: Shape and detail discrepancies, style variations from the prompt's detailed insect with translucent wings
|
||||
91cf82827f58ddb58c1bbd49d1685e4b64da2777901c99e6e097c68c7f9b791e
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 24.14953
|
Direct pass: Missing detailed neon effects, screen content, and control panel elements; shape similarities but lack of prompt-specific details.. Swapped pass: Missing details, shape differences, neon patterns and structural elements don't match prompt specifications
|
||||
96a86092eb2ba8b407b7327109456d80c1e76b33bddbf715eaeb5f6c3ad0c3c7
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 25.549856
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and texture differences; second model has moderate structural and detail differences from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Minor shape and texture differences from prompt; overall structure matches but details vary.
|
||||
970347695eb2da36711a3c3f1cee3275185c6074f08993fef48abf021513c5c0
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 26.679662
|
Direct pass: First model has slight shape differences and missing small decorative details; second model has wrong style with significant detail omissions.. Swapped pass: First model has minor issues (slight shape differences, missing small decorative details); second model has moderate issues (wrong style, significant details missing like ornate clock face design and Roman numerals)
|
||||
976bff3bab25194998e1bb6218a3aaa92af18b67b9433c5baea7ec9687b1a39c
|
ours
| 3
| 4.5
| 22.402064
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/proportion differences; second model has moderate style and detail issues.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences and detail mismatches (lever, foot pedal) in both models; overall structure is close but not perfect match
|
||||
988209beaf8802e7b01184b774fdbbc2b17bcac96dd102343e6bad1527504ee9
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 22.183079
|
Direct pass: Moderate issues with basket texture, shape, and flower arrangement details not matching the prompt's specific design. Swapped pass: Basket texture, color, and lavender flower details/arrangement do not match the prompt.
|
||||
98d5a8c67617725b72f1a1da81c154a8ececd8e463340188fa33762b4463ebc3
|
draw
| 4
| 5
| 27.112782
|
Direct pass: First model has minor control panel and detail differences; second model has moderate style and detail mismatches with prompt. Swapped pass: Control panel design, lid knob shape, and minor structural differences from the prompt
|
||||
99221c94762a1948d33c37524b1833aafd27e46c7838e42ad900e392b84def06
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 27.142681
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/position differences; second model lacks lemon and has altered grater structure.. Swapped pass: First model lacks the lemon element from the prompt; second model has the lemon but the grater’s surface texture differs from the prompt’s grater design.
|
||||
99da178a46f1dc8fe337c647039cf56df39ac72c5f245e809289200885788078
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 26.260012
|
Direct pass: Shape differences, missing small details, style variations from original clock prompt. Swapped pass: First model has minor clock face numbering and detail differences; second model has moderate to major clock face numbering, bell, and base design differences from the prompt.
|
||||
a05c9a0d51d61584267193144e751e950486c63c5b0e85b21fc0cd2f6e552857
|
ours
| 4
| 6
| 21.514461
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape/texture differences; second model has major spoon/handle and base differences.. Swapped pass: Minor shape differences in spoon handle and base details; some elements do not match the prompt's specific features (e.g., spoon handle design, base circular shapes)
|
||||
a14649b9c186508b6862755a231e26a265130babcb7368526b3bae5832e83f39
|
draw
| 4.5
| 4.5
| 25.09875
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details like specific button designs and pocket stitching.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in pocket shapes, button styles, and stitching; second model has moderate differences in overall style, pocket details, and stitching.
|
||||
a1afc9a29b2f04c62a2dbd716f61729eeac3bc6593f0c9184e62462e4a379489
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 27.76429
|
Direct pass: Scale pattern consistency, collar and sleeve details vary from prompt specifications.. Swapped pass: Minor texture and shading differences from prompt, slight shape variations
|
||||
a1d4a4f4281b49286ee923e89fa43902f8f45cf5c4a49480a26ba9dad1eb7fde
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 35.407228
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail differences (cup color, control knob placement, brand text variations). Swapped pass: Text and color details don't match prompt; cup and structural elements have variations.
|
||||
a28644504bc3da94d3f4f0fe13c2e5e5343cfa73507c8f1dd72f13a525a81b80
|
draw
| 3
| 3
| 26.742658
|
Direct pass: Both 3D models have minor shape differences in some views but generally match the rubber duck prompt in color, style, and overall form.. Swapped pass: Slight shape variations, minor detail differences from prompt
|
||||
a38a36dfa341c365b1841bac3df47ee39e170455efd6a9fe36fb8ec4f2e658db
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 20.174438
|
Direct pass: First model has minor tail shape and detail differences; second model has moderate tail and structural differences from the prompt's kite.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences (e.g., tail shape, kite frame), second model has moderate issues (shape, color, tail details) compared to the prompt.
|
||||
a572342222f75df0d81b3cb4dd6f088ba05a4c365cd11d26c0c4efcbf88aedf2
|
draw
| 4
| 3
| 25.895182
|
Direct pass: Minor shape and detail differences (stylized car vs prompt's sleek design, golden elements not matching prompt's detail). Swapped pass: Minor to moderate shape and detail differences; style variations (e.g., horn texture, car body sleekness) from the prompt's sleek, shiny red car with glittery unicorn horn and tail.
|
||||
a7a515716267db535d65f6982288ed21111c0330dc3abd5c7500bb7b30ece24a
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 23.604442
|
Direct pass: Cartoonish style, rabbit head details, locomotive structure and smoke differ from prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape and detail variations; second model has significant style and creature mismatches.
|
||||
a8a4be85624487194e7ef71371cb85e3e1b9deec4a0172cffabf22e0c06f8faa
|
draw
| 3.5
| 4.5
| 27.075267
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape differences and slight texture details; second model has significant style and detail discrepancies (e.g., band texture, hat shape).. Swapped pass: Minor texture and detail differences, slight shape variations from the prompt
|
||||
a9d03b7f0b2d8c343ed951f4d7ac69ab20a99db5d580c9e790bba26d450f0c7e
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 30.987305
|
Direct pass: Both models have variations in decorative details, color tones, and bowl shape compared to the prompt; second model has more significant style and detail differences.. Swapped pass: First model has moderate issues with detail accuracy and color tones; second model has major issues with overall style and key design elements not matching the prompt.
|
||||
ac95819bbee4dc432018cc7ec43066fc35fa7ed4619b3047d8317f08646afafa
|
draw
| 4
| 4
| 23.282799
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in hat color, clothing texture, and small facial details; overall character style and structure match the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor differences in texture/shading; second model has moderate differences in clothing colors/textures.
|
||||
ae32314c7b3f4e52777fb675ec65a8f38075d2c0409ba25f8be20b349f3e98e1
|
draw
| 6
| 6
| 17.331494
|
Direct pass: Hummingbird detail and umbrella structural accuracy vary; first model has minor detail issues, second has major structural differences.. Swapped pass: Hummingbird detail insufficient, umbrella structure/style variations from prompt
|
||||
aeef64af9f4f637a4f8ed35b4ddce883cfdb6138ad02fb22ea840272b48da247
|
draw
| 5
| 5
| 20.535123
|
Direct pass: Slight shape differences, missing ornate stem details, lampshade texture variations. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing detailed stem/carvings, lampshade tone variation, metallic finish differences
|
||||
b56856d58cae8c5503d1e06163e758e1501941ce422f34b30a0fc08159b53e9f
|
draw
| 5.5
| 6.5
| 20.783826
|
Direct pass: Shape and detail discrepancies, color accuracy issues, figure representation not matching prompt. Swapped pass: Shape, figure details, and wheel design do not match the prompt's original model; significant visual and structural deviations from the prompt.
|
||||
bdd9988c3cfcd6be01c9908f5470c083d61d461d780848a804fc8c6597fc25f8
|
ours
| 4
| 6.5
| 27.882985
|
Direct pass: First model has minor differences in wood texture and key details; second model has major issues with key design, wood texture, and structural details, deviating significantly from the prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape differences, missing small details (sound hole border, text, key alignment)
|
||||
c8043aa34480377ed1efc8e872594016bccf759ab63fbdbfc2a5a7fa24fa6113
|
draw
| 3
| 4
| 25.007763
|
Direct pass: Slight to moderate detail differences in crystal arrangement, base texture, and chandelier design between models and prompt.. Swapped pass: Slight shape differences, missing small details in crystal chandelier and base texture
|
||||
cecdad57a9844079239221070d8905ba6cabc6b196154298120c72b35508b9aa
|
ours
| 5
| 7
| 30.071117
|
Direct pass: First model has minor shape and detail differences; second model has major issues with extra non-cactus elements.. Swapped pass: First model contains extraneous white objects not in the prompt; second model has minor detail and shape inconsistencies with the prompt.
|
||||
d454a863a15901b9a092980e08a2a411d2ce569b318e89b5035c3e7644510a12
|
draw
| 5.5
| 5.5
| 24.99715
|
Direct pass: Minor to moderate differences in body shape, wheel details, and lighting elements between models and the prompt.. Swapped pass: First model has minor shape differences and some detail mismatches; second model has more significant deviations in body shape, wheel design, and taillight details.
|
||||
d48fdaea8b8cec973f812aafb3a5d1c6dc0aaf752a536c9a24d650fc467ec2d4
|
draw
| 6
| 5
| 25.812761
|
Direct pass: Both 3D models have shape irregularities (first model is more oval, second is smoother) and texture differences (less rusted appearance than the prompt's aged, rusted ring) compared to the image prompt.. Swapped pass: Shape irregularity, texture fidelity, rope details do not match the prompt closely.
|
End of preview. Expand
in Data Studio
YAML Metadata
Warning:
empty or missing yaml metadata in repo card
(https://huggingface.co/docs/hub/datasets-cards)
Benchmark Results: test8
Overview
- Round: 8
- Test Name: test8
- Timestamp: 2025-12-31 05:43:13
Summary
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Total Tasks | 128 |
| Total Judged | 124 |
| Skipped | 0 |
| Gen Failed | 0 |
| Render Failed | 0 |
| Judge Failed | 4 |
Results
| Result | Count |
|---|---|
| 🏆 WINS | 17 |
| 🤝 DRAWS | 104 |
| ❌ LOSSES | 3 |
Performance
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Win Rate | 13.7% |
| Margin | +11.3% |
| Avg Gen Time | 24.70s |
Methodology
- Judge Model: thudm/glm-4.1v-9b-thinking (via OpenRouter)
- Position-Balanced: 2 passes with swapped order to avoid position bias
- Penalty Scale: 0 (perfect) to 10 (completely wrong)
- Winner: Lower average penalty wins (draw if difference ≤ 1)
Files
benchmark_test8.json- Full benchmark results*/ours.png- Our rendered 3D models*/leader.png- Leader's rendered 3D models*/origin.png- Original prompt images
- Downloads last month
- 10