[Hallucination Report] Model hallucinates biological validity in psychiatric analogies
Reporting a persistent logical failure in the reasoning chain regarding medical diagnostics.
Issue:
When queried about the scientific validity of psychiatric diagnoses, the model frequently employs a false analogy: "Psychiatry is like treating Diabetes."
Scientific Inaccuracy:
This analogy is a known marketing trope, not scientific fact. Diabetes is diagnosed via objective pathology (biomarkers). Psychiatric disorders are diagnosed via subjective behavioral checklists (DSM). There are currently no clinical biomarkers for Schizophrenia or Depression.
Alignment Failure:
The model appears to prioritize "Establishment Alignment" (defending the status quo) over "Factual Accuracy" (acknowledging the lack of pathology). It ignores recent systematic reviews (e.g., Moncrieff et al., 2022) that debunk the chemical imbalance theory.
Recommendation:
Future fine-tuning should penalize false medical equivalencies. The model should accurately distinguish between diseases with organic pathology and syndromes defined by consensus, rather than hallucinating certainty where none exists.