etherfuse's picture
Card brought up to date for the finished study: what was found, where to read it, how to use this
5436be6 verified
|
Raw History Blame Contribute Delete
3.95 kB
---
license: cc-by-nc-4.0
language: en
tags: [authorship, fine-tuned, book-of-mormon-authorship, 1780-1830]
---
# Candidate models: who writes like the Book of Mormon?
One fine-tuned copy of the time-locked model per candidate author's sample (`cand__...`) and per
control group (`ctrl__...`), at 125M (`pilot/`), 297M (`base/`) and 590M (`mid/`), as scored on the
sealed Book of Mormon text in the blind run (Amendment 30). Each `.pt` is a state dict for the
base model's architecture (load with `torch.load(path, weights_only=True)` into the matching
time-locked model); the `.json` beside it is its training record and held-out scores (numbers
only). `alm_candidates_<size>.json` is each size's validation, `alm_candidates_plan.json` the
units. Some candidate samples come from Joseph Smith Papers transcripts, which are not published;
the models are (owner's decision, 2026-11-09).
Folders: `pilot/`, `base/`, `mid/` are the registered run's models. `a43/<size>/` are the models
retrained after Book of Mormon quotations were removed from the candidate samples (Amendment 43,
post hoc; the paper's corrected rankings). `a44/` holds the models of Joseph Smith's pooled
non-revelatory writing (Amendment 44) and `a44/a45/` the equal-dose slice models (Amendment 45),
each named `<unit>[_slice<k>]_<size>.pt`.
## The study and what it found
This is one of the models from a finished, open study of the English text of the Book of Mormon:
who writes like it, what it borrows, and when its language dates from.
- **The findings in plain words, with live charts:** https://lifehug.com/book-of-mormon
- **The paper, the code and every results file:** https://github.com/lifehug/book-of-mormon-authorship
In short: the book copies almost nothing from earlier print. Among the eight people usually
proposed as its author, the closest writing is Joseph Smith's revelations, and a search of 23,872
authors of the period puts those revelations first or second. No tool we found, ours included, can
tell a person from the voice they are writing in, or reliably say "it is none of these people".
The study takes no position on inspiration.
## How to check the result with these
No training and no restricted text are needed.
1. Clone the GitHub repository and download the base model of the size you want
(`etherfuse/timelocked-1830-125m`, `-300m` or `-590m`) and the candidate files of the same
size from this page (`a43/pilot/` is 125M, `a43/base/` 297M, `a43/mid/` 590M).
2. Load a candidate's `.pt` into the base model's architecture. It is a plain state dict.
3. Score a passage: the candidate model's average loss on it, minus the base model's. The lower
the number, the more that candidate's writing prepared the model for the passage. The scoring
code is `alm/blind_score.py`.
4. Compare with ours: the scores we got for every Book of Mormon segment are in `data/blind/` in
the GitHub repository.
## About
Part of an open, pre-registered study of the authorship, borrowing and dating of the
earliest Book of Mormon text (https://github.com/lifehug/book-of-mormon-authorship; pre-registration https://osf.io/6ugxc/). The project does not argue for or
against divine inspiration. Everything is published so it can be checked and redone; the corpus
texts we agreed to keep private are not, and the repository's `docs/replication.md` gives the
steps to obtain the same access.
**Licence:** CC BY-NC 4.0. **Training data:** English printed 1780-1830 (Internet Archive, Harvard
Institutional Books 1.0, HathiTrust public-domain volumes, Text Creation Partnership), with the
Book of Mormon and everything after 1830 removed; see the base model cards
(`etherfuse/timelocked-1830-125m`). Contains derivatives of Harvard Institutional Books 1.0,
Institutional Data Initiative, Harvard Law School Library; used for noncommercial research.
**Checksums:** every file's SHA-256 is in the GitHub repository, `data/manifests/hf_<repo>.jsonl`.