pino-source-code / artifacts /three_diagnostics_v8 /diagnostic1_substantivity_integrity_v8.json
Matthew Ford
pimt v8 diagnostics and qa artifacts
ac9ca3b
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
57.2 kB
{
"agreement_count": 75,
"agreement_rate": 0.5208333333333334,
"agreement_total": 144,
"boundary_margin_coeff_units": 5,
"diagnostic": "D1_substantivity_integrity",
"disagreement_count": 69,
"disagreements": [
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "100-52-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Almonds",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "101-84-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Diphenyl oxide",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "102-16-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 0.0,
"measured_coefficient": 60,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Benzyl phenylacetate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "103-26-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 2.0,
"measured_coefficient": 12,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl cinnamate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "103-45-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 13.0,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Phenylethyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "103-48-0",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 41.0,
"measured_coefficient": 19,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Phenylethyl iso-butyrate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "103-61-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 32.0,
"measured_coefficient": 28,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Cinnamyl butyrate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "104-65-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 42.0,
"measured_coefficient": 18,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Cinnamyl formate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "105-13-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 13.0,
"measured_coefficient": 47,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Anisic alcohol",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "105-85-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellyl formate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "106-22-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 10.0,
"measured_coefficient": 4,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellol",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "106-24-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 8.0,
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geraniol ex palmarosa",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "106-25-2",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 9.0,
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nerol",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "106-29-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geranyl butyrate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "107-75-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 19.0,
"measured_coefficient": 80,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Hydroxy citronellal",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "111-12-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl heptine carbonate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "112-14-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Octyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "112-31-2",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Decyl aldehyde",
"poucher_tier": "top",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "118-58-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl salicylate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "122-00-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 11.0,
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl acetophenone",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "122-63-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl propionate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "124-19-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nonyl aldehyde",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "126-64-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Linalyl benzoate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "1335-46-2",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl ionone",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "140-11-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 13.0,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "141-78-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Ethyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "141-97-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Ethyl acetoacetate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "144-39-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Linalyl propionate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "150-84-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "2050-08-0",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Amyl salicylate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "60-12-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Phenylethyl alcohol",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "68127-65-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Rhodinol",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "68606-83-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 0.0,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Cananga",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "7212-44-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 5.0,
"measured_coefficient": 55,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Nerolidol",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8000-27-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Cedarwood",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8000-28-0",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Lavender",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8000-29-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronella, Ceylon",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8000-41-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 11.0,
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Terpineol",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8000-42-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 5.0,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Caraway",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8000-48-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 45.0,
"measured_coefficient": 15,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Eucalyptus",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8006-78-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Bay",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8006-84-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Fennel",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8006-90-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 5.0,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Peppermint, American",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8007-02-1",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 0.0,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Lemongrass",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8007-35-0",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 9.0,
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Terpinyl acetate",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8007-46-3",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 8.0,
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Thyme white",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8007-75-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 8.0,
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Bergamot",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8008-45-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nutmeg",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8008-56-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 9.0,
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Lemon",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8014-09-3",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 39.0,
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Patchouli",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8014-17-3",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 6.0,
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Petitgrain, French",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8014-19-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Palmarosa",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8015-64-3",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 2.0,
"measured_coefficient": 58,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Angelica root",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8015-73-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Basilic",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8016-96-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 39.0,
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Vetivert",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8021-15-0",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 8.0,
"measured_coefficient": 52,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Opoponax oil",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8022-09-9",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 5.0,
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Spike lavender",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8022-62-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Reseda absolute",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8023-70-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 4.0,
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Ginger",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "top_mid_14_15",
"cas": "8023-82-3",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 4.0,
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Myrrh oil",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "8023-87-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Mimosa absolute",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "8023-91-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 8.0,
"measured_coefficient": 52,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Galbanum resin",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "near-boundary",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "83-54-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 0.0,
"measured_coefficient": 60,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Rhodinyl formate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "9000-50-6",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 39.0,
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Oakmoss",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "91-64-5",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 39.0,
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Coumarin",
"poucher_tier": "mid",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": "mid_base_60_61",
"cas": "91771-61-8",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": 42.0,
"measured_coefficient": 18,
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Citronella, Java",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 1
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "94-48-4",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 4,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geranyl benzoate",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "94-59-7",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Sassafras",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
},
{
"agrees": false,
"boundary_classification": "wild",
"boundary_crossed": null,
"cas": "98-86-2",
"distance_to_boundary_coeff_units": null,
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Acetophenone",
"poucher_tier": "base",
"tier_step_distance": 2
}
],
"histogram": {
"near-boundary": 12,
"wild": 57
},
"histogram_by_pair": {
"base->mid:wild": 5,
"base->top:wild": 1,
"mid->base:near-boundary": 4,
"mid->base:wild": 8,
"top->base:wild": 26,
"top->mid:near-boundary": 8,
"top->mid:wild": 17
},
"pimt_version": "v8",
"verdict": {
"measured_170_affected": false,
"phase1_eval_summary": {
"best_structure_model": "structure_full_gbm",
"best_structure_spearman_rho": 0.6633801733693918,
"n_model_ready": 170,
"split": {
"n_test": 34,
"n_train": 136,
"scaffold_overlap": [],
"seed": 20260710,
"test_scaffolds": 34,
"train_scaffolds": 49,
"type": "scaffold-disjoint Murcko scaffold split"
}
},
"phase1_result_affected": false,
"phase1_rho_recompute": "not_recomputed_no_measured_join_error_identified; diagnostics script does not import training/RDKit code",
"phase1_split_screen": "local reproduction of train_substantivity.greedy_scaffold_split from saved enriched scaffold keys; avoids importing training/RDKit code in diagnostics",
"phase1_test_wild_genuine_or_form_cas": [
"106-29-6",
"112-14-1",
"118-58-1",
"141-78-6",
"141-97-9",
"8000-29-1",
"8000-41-7",
"8007-46-3",
"8008-45-5",
"8014-09-3",
"8014-17-3"
],
"rationale": "Wild disagreements are not mostly join-errors. Local evidence points primarily to genuine source/construct disagreement between measured duration coefficients and profile role tiers; measured coefficients remain the rigorous Phase 1 target because they do not depend on auxiliary tiers.",
"tier_fold_verdict": "DO_NOT_FOLD_DISAGREEING_TIERS; only near-boundary-consistent rows or future join-corrected rows may be considered as poucher-tier provenance."
},
"wild_case_causes": [
{
"cas": "100-52-7",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Almonds",
"Benzaldehyde"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Almonds",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "101-84-8",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_names": [
"Diphenyl oxide"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Diphenyl oxide",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "103-45-7",
"cause": "join-error",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found local identity evidence for alias fragmentation, CAS conflation, or variant collision."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Phenylethyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Phenylethyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "103-48-0",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 19,
"measured_names": [
"Phenylethyl iso-butyrate"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Phenylethyl iso-butyrate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "103-61-7",
"cause": "unresolved-needs-manual-review",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found insufficient local identity/source-name evidence for a stronger assignment."
],
"measured_coefficient": 28,
"measured_names": [
"Cinnamyl butyrate"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Cinnamyl butyrate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "104-65-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 18,
"measured_names": [
"Cinnamyl formate"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Cinnamyl formate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "105-13-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 47,
"measured_names": [
"Anisic alcohol"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Anisic alcohol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "105-85-1",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_names": [
"Citronellyl formate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellyl formate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "106-22-9",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 4,
"measured_names": [
"Citronellol"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "106-24-1",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_names": [
"Geraniol ex palmarosa",
"Geraniol, Java"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geraniol ex palmarosa",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "106-25-2",
"cause": "join-error",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found local identity evidence for alias fragmentation, CAS conflation, or variant collision.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_names": [
"Nerol",
"Neroli bigarade",
"Neroli, Italian"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nerol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "106-29-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_names": [
"Geranyl butyrate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geranyl butyrate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "107-75-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 80,
"measured_names": [
"Hydroxy citronellal"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Hydroxy citronellal",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "111-12-6",
"cause": "join-error",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found local identity evidence for alias fragmentation, CAS conflation, or variant collision.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Methyl heptine carbonate",
"Methyl octine carbonate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl heptine carbonate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "112-14-1",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Octyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Octyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "112-31-2",
"cause": "unresolved-needs-manual-review",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found insufficient local identity/source-name evidence for a stronger assignment."
],
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_names": [
"Decyl aldehyde"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Decyl aldehyde",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "top"
},
{
"cas": "118-58-1",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Benzyl salicylate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl salicylate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "122-00-9",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_names": [
"Methyl acetophenone"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl acetophenone",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "122-63-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 10,
"measured_names": [
"Benzyl propionate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl propionate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "124-19-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Nonyl aldehyde"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nonyl aldehyde",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "126-64-7",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 9,
"measured_names": [
"Linalyl benzoate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Linalyl benzoate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "1335-46-2",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Methyl ionone"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Methyl ionone",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "140-11-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Benzyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Benzyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "141-78-6",
"cause": "unresolved-needs-manual-review",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found insufficient local identity/source-name evidence for a stronger assignment."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Ethyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Ethyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "141-97-9",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Ethyl acetoacetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Ethyl acetoacetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "144-39-8",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_names": [
"Linalyl propionate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Linalyl propionate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "150-84-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Citronellyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronellyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "2050-08-0",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Amyl salicylate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Amyl salicylate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "60-12-8",
"cause": "join-error",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found local identity evidence for alias fragmentation, CAS conflation, or variant collision."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Phenylethyl alcohol"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Phenylethyl alcohol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "68127-65-1",
"cause": "join-error",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found local identity evidence for alias fragmentation, CAS conflation, or variant collision."
],
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_names": [
"Rhodinol"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Rhodinol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8000-27-9",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Cedarwood"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Cedarwood",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8000-28-0",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Lavender"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Lavender",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8000-29-1",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Citronella, Ceylon"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Citronella, Ceylon",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8000-41-7",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_names": [
"Terpineol"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Terpineol",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8000-48-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 15,
"measured_names": [
"Eucalyptus",
"Eucalyptus citriodora"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Eucalyptus",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8006-78-8",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_names": [
"Bay"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Bay",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8006-84-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Fennel"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Fennel",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8007-35-0",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_names": [
"Terpinyl acetate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Terpinyl acetate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8007-46-3",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_names": [
"Thyme red",
"Thyme white"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Thyme white",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8007-75-8",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 6,
"measured_names": [
"Bergamot"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Bergamot",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8008-45-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Nutmeg"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Nutmeg",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8008-56-8",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 5,
"measured_names": [
"Lemon"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Lemon",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8014-09-3",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_names": [
"Patchouli"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Patchouli",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8014-17-3",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 8,
"measured_names": [
"Petitgrain para",
"Petitgrain, French"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Petitgrain, French",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8014-19-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Palmarosa"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Palmarosa",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8015-73-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Basilic"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Basilic",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8016-96-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_names": [
"Vetivert"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Vetivert",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "8021-15-0",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 52,
"measured_names": [
"Opoponax oil",
"Opoponax resin"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Opoponax oil",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8022-62-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Reseda absolute"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Reseda absolute",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8023-87-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 14,
"measured_names": [
"Mimosa absolute"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Mimosa absolute",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "8023-91-4",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form.",
"measured extraction records a coefficient conflict, but the per-case audit classification above is retained."
],
"measured_coefficient": 52,
"measured_names": [
"Galbanum oil",
"Galbanum resin"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Galbanum resin",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "9000-50-6",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_names": [
"Oakmoss"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Oakmoss",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "91-64-5",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 100,
"measured_names": [
"Coumarin"
],
"measured_tier": "base",
"name": "Coumarin",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "mid"
},
{
"cas": "91771-61-8",
"cause": "form-mismatch",
"evidence": [
"Per-wild-case audit found source names comparing natural/geographic/material forms rather than one clean material form."
],
"measured_coefficient": 18,
"measured_names": [
"Citronella, Java"
],
"measured_tier": "mid",
"name": "Citronella, Java",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "94-48-4",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 4,
"measured_names": [
"Geranyl benzoate"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Geranyl benzoate",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "94-59-7",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"Natural/complex wording is present, but the per-case audit did not find enough evidence to override source-level disagreement."
],
"measured_coefficient": 3,
"measured_names": [
"Sassafras"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Sassafras",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
},
{
"cas": "98-86-2",
"cause": "genuine-source-disagreement",
"evidence": [
"CAS is present on both sides; no local synonym evidence shows a different identity. Conflict is between measured duration coefficient and Poucher profile top/mid/base role tier."
],
"measured_coefficient": 1,
"measured_names": [
"Acetophenone"
],
"measured_tier": "top",
"name": "Acetophenone",
"policy": "identity/form audit only; no odour character inferred",
"poucher_tier": "base"
}
],
"wild_cause_counts": {
"form-mismatch": 6,
"genuine-source-disagreement": 43,
"join-error": 5,
"unresolved-needs-manual-review": 3
}
}