Kraft102's picture
fix: sql.js Docker/Alpine compatibility layer for PatternMemory and FailureMemory
5a81b95

πŸ” HVAD MANGLER VI NU? - KOMPLET OVERSIGT

Dato: 2025-11-24
Status: Opdateret efter alle nylige implementeringer


βœ… HVAD ER FΓ†RDIGT

Phase 1: Unified Cognitive Architecture βœ… 100% COMPLETE

  • βœ… UnifiedMemorySystem (4 memory types)
  • βœ… AutonomousTaskEngine (BabyAGI loop)
  • βœ… HybridSearchEngine (keyword + semantic + graph)
  • βœ… EmotionAwareDecisionEngine (PAL integration)
  • βœ… Holographic pattern correlation
  • βœ… Whole-part system modeling

Phase 2: GraphRAG + Role-Based Agents βœ… ~85% COMPLETE

  • βœ… UnifiedGraphRAG (multi-hop reasoning, LLM synthesis)
  • βœ… StateGraphRouter (checkpoints, time-travel)
  • βœ… PatternEvolutionEngine (mutation, A/B testing)
  • βœ… AgentTeam (5 role-based agents)
  • βœ… PAL Agent (5 specialized modes)
  • βœ… MCP tool exposure (all components)
  • βœ… ChromaDB Vidensarkiv (persistent vector DB)
  • βœ… TaskRecorder (observation, learning, approval)
  • βœ… HansPedder Deep Integration
  • βœ… Document Generation Service (PowerPoint, Word, Excel)
  • βœ… UI & Frontend (Win11 Visual Shell + WidgeTDC Content)
  • βœ… Railway deployment fix (Dockerfile workspace dependencies)

❌ KRITISKE MANGELER (Priority 1)

1. Neo4j Graph Database ❌ NOT STARTED

Status: Using implicit graph via patterns + CMA memory_relations
Impact: No explicit graph storage, limited graph queries
Priority: πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
Effort: 2-3 dage

Hvad mangler:

  • Neo4j instance setup (Docker/local)
  • Migrate implicit patterns to explicit edges
  • Cypher query integration
  • Graph persistence layer
  • Replace CMA memory_relations with Neo4j
  • Integration tests for Neo4j operations

Næste skridt:

# 1. Start Neo4j container
docker-compose up neo4j

# 2. Test connection
npm run test:neo4j

# 3. Migrate CMA memory_relations
npm run migrate:graph

2. Integration Tests ❌ NOT STARTED

Status: Ingen integration tests
Priority: πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
Effort: 1 uge

Hvad mangler:

  • End-to-end GraphRAG tests
  • AgentTeam coordination tests
  • StateGraphRouter workflow tests
  • Cross-component integration tests
  • TaskRecorder observation tests
  • ChromaDB vidensarkiv tests
  • Neo4j graph operation tests

Test framework:

  • Vitest (allerede installeret)
  • Playwright (for E2E)

3. Smoke Tests ❌ NOT STARTED

Status: Ingen smoke tests
Priority: πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
Effort: 2-3 dage

Hvad mangler:

  • Component startup tests
  • API endpoint smoke tests
  • MCP tool smoke tests
  • Health check validation
  • TaskRecorder initialization
  • ChromaDB initialization
  • Neo4j connection test

⚠️ HØJ PRIORITET (Priority 2)

4. UnifiedGraphRAG Neo4j Upgrade ⚠️ PARTIAL

Status: Bruger implicit graph
Priority: 🟑 HIGH
Effort: 3-5 dage

Hvad mangler:

  • Replace implicit graph med Neo4j
  • Explicit edge storage
  • Better graph queries
  • Query expansion
  • Multi-modal similarity
  • Advanced graph traversal optimizations

5. AgentTeam Communication Protocol ⚠️ PARTIAL

Status: Basic coordination implementeret
Priority: 🟑 HIGH
Effort: 1 uge

Hvad mangler:

  • Advanced agent communication protocol
  • Agent-to-agent negotiation
  • Dynamic agent spawning
  • Agent specialization learning
  • Cross-agent knowledge sharing

6. StateGraphRouter Enhancements ⚠️ PARTIAL

Status: Basic functionality implementeret
Priority: 🟑 HIGH
Effort: 1 uge

Hvad mangler:

  • LLM-based node selection
  • Dynamic graph construction
  • Conditional branching logic
  • Human-in-the-loop integration
  • Graph visualization

7. UnifiedMemorySystem Enhancements ⚠️ PARTIAL

Status: Placeholders i ProductionRuleEngine & Whole-Part analyse
Priority: 🟒 MEDIUM
Effort: 1 uge

Hvad mangler:

  • Implementer ProductionRuleEngine (udtrΓ¦k regler fra mΓΈnstre)
  • Implementer detectEmergentBehaviors (system-wide correlation)
  • Implementer EvolutionRepository integration (fix manglende metoder)
  • Forbedre HolographicPattern detektion (mere end bare keywords)

πŸ“Š MEDIUM PRIORITET (Priority 3)

8. Phase 3: Meta-Cognition ❌ NOT STARTED

Status: Ikke implementeret
Priority: 🟒 MEDIUM
Effort: 3-6 uger

Komponenter:

  • SelfReflectionEngine
  • MetaLearningEngine
  • RLHFAlignmentSystem

9. Performance Testing ❌ NOT STARTED

Status: Ingen performance benchmarks
Priority: 🟒 MEDIUM
Effort: 3-5 dage

Hvad mangler:

  • Latency benchmarks
  • Throughput testing
  • Memory usage profiling
  • Graph traversal performance
  • Vector search performance (ChromaDB)
  • TaskRecorder observation overhead

10. Documentation ⚠️ PARTIAL

Status: Basis dokumentation eksisterer
Priority: 🟒 MEDIUM
Effort: 1 uge

Hvad mangler:

  • API documentation (OpenAPI/Swagger)
  • MCP tool documentation (comprehensive)
  • Usage examples (code samples)
  • Integration guides (step-by-step)
  • Troubleshooting guides
  • TaskRecorder usage guide
  • ChromaDB vidensarkiv guide
  • Neo4j integration guide

πŸ› BUGS & ISSUES

TypeScript Build Errors

Status: Nogle fejl tilbage
Priority: πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
Effort: 1-2 timer

Kendte fejl:

  • timestamp property i McpContext (flere steder)
  • emotionalState property i Decision (AgentTeam.ts)
  • semanticQuery property i MemorySearchQuery
  • getSourceHealth method i CognitiveMemory
  • UsagePattern iterator issues

Railway Deployment

Status: βœ… FIXED (workspace dependencies)
Priority: βœ… RESOLVED

Fix:

  • βœ… Dockerfile kopierer nu workspace package.json filer fΓΈr npm ci
  • βœ… Zustand dependency resolveres korrekt

πŸ“ˆ OVERALL PROGRESS

Phase 1: βœ… 100% Complete

Phase 2: ⚠️ ~85% Complete

  • βœ… ChromaDB implementeret
  • βœ… TaskRecorder implementeret
  • βœ… HansPedder deep integration
  • ❌ Neo4j mangler stadig

Phase 3: ❌ 0% Complete

Infrastructure: ⚠️ ~60% Complete

  • βœ… Basic components
  • βœ… ChromaDB (vector DB)
  • βœ… TaskRecorder
  • ❌ Neo4j (graph DB)
  • ⚠️ Partial integrations

Testing: ❌ 0% Complete

  • ❌ Integration tests
  • ❌ Performance tests
  • ❌ Smoke tests

🎯 KRITISK VEI (Critical Path)

1. Neo4j Setup (2-3 dage) πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
   ↓
2. TypeScript Build Fixes (1-2 timer) πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
   ↓
3. Integration Tests (1 uge) πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
   ↓
4. Smoke Tests (2-3 dage) πŸ”΄ CRITICAL
   ↓
5. Documentation (1 uge) 🟑 HIGH
   ↓
6. Enhancements (ongoing) 🟑 HIGH
   ↓
7. Phase 3 (3-6 uger) 🟒 MEDIUM

πŸš€ ANBEFALEDE NΓ†STE SKRIDT

Uge 1: Infrastructure Completion

  1. Setup Neo4j (2-3 dage) πŸ”΄

    • Docker container
    • Schema design
    • Migration fra CMA memory_relations
    • Cypher query integration
  2. Fix TypeScript Errors (1-2 timer) πŸ”΄

    • Fix timestamp property issues
    • Fix emotionalState property
    • Fix semanticQuery property
    • Fix getSourceHealth method
  3. Integration Tests (3-4 dage) πŸ”΄

    • TaskRecorder tests
    • ChromaDB tests
    • GraphRAG tests
    • AgentTeam tests

Uge 2: Testing & Documentation

  1. Smoke Tests (2-3 dage) πŸ”΄

    • Component startup
    • Health checks
    • Basic functionality
  2. Documentation (2-3 dage) 🟑

    • TaskRecorder guide
    • ChromaDB guide
    • API documentation

Uge 3+: Enhancements

  1. Neo4j integration i UnifiedGraphRAG
  2. AgentTeam communication protocol
  3. StateGraphRouter enhancements
  4. Phase 3 components

πŸ’‘ QUICK WINS (Kan gΓΈres nu)

  1. Fix TypeScript Errors - 1-2 timer
  2. Neo4j setup - Docker container (1-2 timer)
  3. Smoke tests - Quick validation (2-3 timer)
  4. TaskRecorder tests - Basic integration tests (1 dag)
  5. ChromaDB tests - Vector search tests (1 dag)

βœ… RECENT COMPLETIONS

βœ… TaskRecorder (2025-11-24)

  • Observes all tasks automatically
  • Learns patterns from repeated tasks
  • Suggests automation (requires approval)
  • Complete security model

βœ… ChromaDB Vidensarkiv (2025-11-24)

  • Persistent vector database
  • HuggingFace embeddings
  • Continuous learning
  • Widget integration

βœ… HansPedder Deep Integration (2025-11-24)

  • Phase 1 components integrated
  • ProjectMemory protocol
  • Context-aware orchestration

βœ… Document Generation Service (2025-11-26)

  • PowerPoint: MCP-based generation (Titles, Content, Images)
  • Word: Structured template generation (Reports, Proposals, Manuals)
  • Excel: Financial & Statistical sheet generation
  • Architecture: Event-driven job queue system

βœ… UI & Frontend (2025-11-24)

  • Windows 11 Copilot UI: Visual shell, glassmorphism & layout clone (hosting WidgeTDC engine)
  • ChatWidget: Integrated chat interface for WidgeTDC agents
  • HansPedder Widgets: Visualization of system logs & insights
  • ScraperWidget: Interface for real-time data collection

βœ… Railway Deployment Fix (2025-11-24)

  • Dockerfile workspace dependencies
  • Zustand import resolution

βœ… Bug Fixes (2025-11-24)

  • QueryIntent/string type mismatches
  • Empty messages array validation
  • Decision interface emotionalState

πŸ“‹ TODO LIST (Prioriteret)

πŸ”΄ CRITICAL (Do First)

  • Neo4j Graph Database setup
  • Fix TypeScript build errors
  • Integration tests
  • Smoke tests

🟑 HIGH (Do Next)

  • UnifiedGraphRAG Neo4j upgrade
  • AgentTeam communication protocol
  • StateGraphRouter enhancements
  • Documentation

🟒 MEDIUM (Do Later)

  • Phase 3 components
  • Performance testing
  • Advanced enhancements

πŸ”΅ ARCHITECTURE ENHANCEMENTS (From Analysis)

  • Type-Safe Widget Registry: Migrate widgetRegistry.js to TypeScript class with generics.
  • Standardized Widget Lifecycle: Implement BaseWidget pattern with onInit, onMount, onDestroy.
  • Audit Logging: Implement audit_logs schema and service for compliance.
  • Data Aggregation Service: Create service to merge data from OpenSearch, Postgres, and MinIO.
  • MCP Router Pattern: Formalize MCPRouter class and message types in backend.

Status: βœ… Phase 1 Complete, ⚠️ Phase 2 ~85%, ❌ Phase 3 Not Started
Critical Path: Neo4j β†’ TypeScript Fixes β†’ Testing β†’ Documentation β†’ Enhancements β†’ Phase 3

Næste umiddelbare handling: Setup Neo4j Graph Database + Fix TypeScript Errors