Hugging Face's logo

Spaces:
rohitsar567
/
InsuranceBot
Sleeping

App Files Community
InsuranceBot / 40-data /reviews /INDEX.md
rohitsar567's picture
rohitsar567
perf(retrieval): KI-049 — wider top-k for table-cell questions
c8bf1a1
preview code
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
4.94 kB

Insurer Reputation Leaderboard

Last updated: 2026-05-13 Data source: IRDAI Annual Report 2023-24 (primary), aggregator portals, Reddit / Indian finance communities, YouTube, news media Scoring formula: 0.40 * CSR + 0.20 * (100 - min(complaints_per_10k, 50)*2) + 0.15 * (avg_star*20) + 0.10 * reddit_sentiment + 0.10 * youtube_sentiment + 0.05 * (news_positive / news_total * 100) Letter grade: A ≥85, B ≥70, C ≥55, D ≥40, F <40

Ranked leaderboard

Rank Insurer Slug Score Grade CSR (FY24) Complaints / 10K Headline
1 HDFC ERGO General Insurance hdfc-ergo 85.7 A 99.1% 15 Industry-leading CSR, strong YouTube/advisor recommendation
2 Bajaj Allianz General Insurance bajaj-allianz 84.5 B 92.2% 3 Lowest complaint volume in the cohort; third-largest non-life insurer
3 Aditya Birla Health Insurance aditya-birla 81.2 B 93.0% 13 Strong CSR, low complaints, HealthReturns wellness differentiator
4 New India Assurance new-india 78.6 B 95.0% 20 Highest claim payout among general insurers; PSU service experience drags consumer score
5 ManipalCigna Health Insurance manipalcigna 76.3 B 99.0% 24 High CSR; smaller scale and above-median complaints
6 Niva Bupa Health Insurance niva-bupa 75.8 B 91.6% 43 Solid CSR, IPO momentum; complaints above industry average
7 Tata AIG General Insurance tata-aig 75.6 B 88.7% 11 Strong brand & global-coverage products; CSR slightly below leaders
8 ICICI Lombard General Insurance icici-lombard 73.5 B 85.0% 10 Strongest complaint metrics; health CSR lags HDFC/Bajaj
9 Care Health Insurance care-health 70.4 B 93.1% (3yr avg) 42 Solid headline CSR but bottom-of-table ICR (57.7%) and complaints volume
10 Star Health & Allied Insurance star-health 60.4 C 82.3% 52 India's largest standalone health insurer but under IRDAI scrutiny for highest complaints (13,308 FY24)

Key findings

  1. HDFC ERGO is the clearest top pick on every objective metric: 99.1% CSR, 15 complaints per 10K, near-universal advisor recommendation (Ditto, YouTube comparison videos).
  2. Bajaj Allianz is the dark horse — best-in-class complaint metrics (3 per 10K, industry-leading), AAA credit rating, but lower retail-health brand awareness than HDFC / Star.
  3. Star Health is the cautionary outlier: under live IRDAI scrutiny (December 2024 show-cause notice), highest complaints volume of any private insurer (13,308 in FY24), and the lowest standalone-health CSR (82.3%).
  4. Standalone health insurers (Star, Niva Bupa, Care, Aditya Birla, ManipalCigna) generally have higher complaint volumes than general insurers (HDFC ERGO, Bajaj, ICICI Lombard, Tata AIG, New India), consistent with the IRDAI sector trend (standalone segment 63.6% incurred claims ratio vs 82.5% sector-wide).
  5. PSU New India Assurance has the highest payout discipline (ICR 103%, paying out more than premium collected), but PSU-style branch + paperwork friction is the dominant Reddit complaint.

Data quality notes

  • IRDAI 2023-24 Annual Report (the single authoritative source) is referenced in every file under claim_metrics.source_irdai_url.
  • complaints_per_10k_policies for several insurers is the 3-year average (FY22-FY25) rather than the strict FY24 single-year figure, because the underlying IRDAI portal disclosures aggregate three-year history for the consumer-friendly metric. This is flagged in each JSON's complaints_year field.
  • Trustpilot Indian-customer coverage is thin; most Indian customers review via Policybazaar / InsureDekho / Mouthshut. Trustpilot scores are largely populated by negative-experience escalations, so they skew low. Use with care.
  • News tone is editorial classification by this aggregator, not the publication's own tagging.
  • Reddit mentions_last_year_estimate is an approximate eyeball from search results, not a true API count.

Sources (representative)