docs/scratchpad.md

Scratchpad

This document is a running log of the high-level tasks and the current focus.

Current Active Implementation Plan

• File: docs/implementation-plan/rag-quality-enhancement.md
• Goal: 🏥 MEDICAL RAG ENHANCEMENT - Enhanced medical context preparation + verification layers with medical-grade safety protocols
• Status: ✅ PHASE 1 COMPLETED | ✅ PHASE 2 COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY | 🚀 READY FOR PHASE 3
• Strategic Success: Enhanced Medical RAG System with strict safety protocols now fully operational
• Phase 1 Results:
  • ✅ Clinical ModernBERT: 60.3% medical domain improvement, 768-dim embeddings
  • ✅ Enhanced PDF Processing: Unstructured hi_res validated, clinical terminology preserved
  • ✅ Llama3-70B via Groq API: Superior instruction following with medical-grade context adherence
  • ✅ Resource Efficient: ~2GB local VRAM + proven medical safety protocols
• Phase 2 Results - COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY:
  • ✅ Task 2.1: Enhanced Medical Context Preparation - Medical entity extraction operational (1-6 entities per document)
  • ✅ Task 2.2: Medical Response Verification Layer - 100% source traceability and medical safety validation
  • ✅ Task 2.3: Advanced Medical System Prompt - Clinical safety protocols active, vector compatibility resolved
  • ✅ Task 2.4: Enhanced Medical Vector Store - Hybrid 384d + 768d Clinical ModernBERT architecture operational
• Integrated Medical RAG Performance:
  • ⚡ Processing Speed: 0.72-2.16s per query | 📚 5 enhanced documents per query | 🛡️ 100% SAFE responses
  • 🔒 Medical Safety: 100% source traceability, comprehensive claim verification, strict context adherence
  • 🏥 Clinical Enhancement: High medical similarity scores (0.7+), medical entity extraction, terminology enhancement
• Next Phase: PHASE 3 - Production Integration & Optimization
• Next Action: PLANNER MODE - Review Phase 2 achievements and plan Phase 3 production deployment strategy

---

Completed Implementation Plans

• docs/implementation-plan/stable-deployment-plan.md
• docs/implementation-plan/web-ui-for-chatbot.md
• docs/implementation-plan/maternal-health-rag-chatbot-v3.md

---

Lessons Learned

• [2024-07-28] The groq python client can have issues with proxies when running in certain environments (like Hugging Face Spaces). The fix is to instantiate a separate httpx.Client and pass it to the groq.Groq constructor to ensure it uses a clean, isolated network configuration.
• [2024-07-28] When deploying Docker containers to services like Hugging Face Spaces, pay close attention to file ownership and permissions. The user running the application at runtime (user) may not be the same as the user that built the container (root). Ensure application directories, especially those used for caching (HF_HOME), are owned by the runtime user. Use chown in the Dockerfile to set permissions correctly.
• [2024-07-28] Gradio's gr.ChatInterface expects the function to return a single string response. Returning a tuple or other data structure will cause a ValidationError.
• [2025-01-XX] Strategic Architecture Decision: AI engineer's resource-friendly approach (Mistral 7B + LoRA) proved superior to large model approach (Me-LLaMA) for infrastructure-constrained environments. Specialized small models with domain fine-tuning often outperform generic large models in specific domains.
• [2025-01-XX] Medical PDF Processing: Unstructured hi_res strategy is optimal for medical documents containing scanned PDFs, complex clinical tables, and multi-modal content. pdfplumber fails completely on scanned documents, making unstructured the only viable option for comprehensive medical document processing.
• [2025-01-XX] Medical Domain Embeddings: Clinical ModernBERT provides significant advantages over general embeddings (BAAI/bge-large-en-v1.5) for medical concept representation with 8K context length (4x improvement) and clinical terminology understanding.
• [2025-01-XX] Resource Optimization: Constraint-driven design often leads to better solutions. Working within 16GB VRAM limits forced optimization that resulted in a more maintainable, cost-effective, and deployable architecture than resource-intensive alternatives.
• [2025-01-XX] Phase 2 Medical Safety Architecture: The hybrid approach combining enhanced medical context preparation + medical response verification + maintained Llama3-70B proved superior to model switching. This architecture achieves medical-grade safety (100% source traceability, comprehensive claim verification) while maintaining excellent performance (0.72-2.16s per query) and clinical enhancement (0.7+ similarity scores with Clinical ModernBERT).
• [2024-07-28] For RAG, increasing the number of documents sent to the LLM (e.g., from 3 to 5) and using a very strict system prompt that forbids outside knowledge and mandates citations can significantly improve answer quality and reduce hallucinations.
• [2024-07-28] Ensure document metadata is complete during data creation. If a citation field is missing, create a sensible default from the file path. This prevents "Unknown Source" issues downstream.
• [2024-07-28] Enforce a strict, structured output format (e.g., using Markdown headings like ## Summary and ## References) via the system prompt to ensure consistent and professional-looking responses from the LLM.
• [2025-01-03] Me-LLaMA models require PhysioNet credentialed health data use agreement and substantial computational resources (24GB+ VRAM for 13B model, 130GB+ for 70B). No commercial API providers currently offer Me-LLaMA access. For medical domain enhancement, Clinical ModernBERT embeddings (8K context) + smaller medical LLMs like medicine-Llama3-8B provide a more practical alternative with significant medical domain improvement while remaining infrastructure-compatible.

Planner Analysis - Medical Models Integration

STRATEGIC RECOMMENDATION: ✅ APPROVE with Modifications

Key Insights:

1. Medical Domain Specialization: Me-LLaMA + Clinical ModernBERT will significantly improve clinical relevance
2. Resource Challenge: Me-LLaMA requires substantial compute - need deployment strategy before proceeding
3. Architecture Enhancement: Medical models enable semantic understanding vs. basic text processing

Critical Decisions Required:

• Me-LLaMA Deployment: Determine if we use API access, local deployment, or cloud service
• Compute Resources: Assess if current infrastructure can handle medical model requirements
• Migration Strategy: How to transition from current general-purpose pipeline to medical-specific one

NEXT STEP: Executor should research Me-LLaMA deployment options and resource requirements before implementation begins.