MetaDebate / docs /progress.md
vajeeda's picture
final mvp created
98b952a
|
Raw
History Blame Contribute Delete
17.4 kB

Progress β€” Feature & Phase Status

Purpose

Read this file to know exactly what is done, in progress, or pending. One liner per feature. Update after every feature implementation. Do not read entire codebase to understand progress β€” read this file.


Status Legend

βœ… done β€” implemented, tested, committed πŸ”„ in progress β€” currently being worked on ⏳ pending β€” not started yet ❌ blocked β€” cannot proceed, reason noted πŸ› bug β€” implemented but has known failing test


Phase 1 β€” OpenEnv Scaffold

βœ… ViralScriptEnv β€” Gym-compatible env with reset/step/state βœ… EpisodeState β€” dataclass tracking script, region, platform, niche βœ… Rewards R1–R5 β€” hook strength, coherence, cultural, debate, preservation βœ… RewardAggregator β€” anti-gaming penalties (action diversity, regression, cliff) βœ… CriticAgent β€” LLM critique with JSON extraction βœ… DefenderAgent β€” LLM defense with JSON extraction βœ… RewriterAgent β€” LLM rewrite from arbitrator action βœ… BaselineArbitratorAgent β€” zero-shot untrained arbitrator

Phase 2 β€” Baseline Measurement

βœ… run_baseline.py β€” 20-episode baseline run, saves baseline_results.json βœ… baseline_reward_curves.png β€” pre-training reward plot saved βœ… Phase 2 gate β€” mean total reward logged, curves confirmed saved

Phase 3 β€” Curriculum Dataset + GRPO Training

βœ… generate_synthetic_scripts.py β€” Anthropic API script generator (run separately) βœ… build_curriculum.py β€” 3 JSONL tiers (easy 10, medium 10, hard 5; grows with synthetic) βœ… env.reset_from_config() β€” resets env from specific episode config dict βœ… rollout_function.py β€” TRL GRPOTrainer bridge to live ViralScriptEnv βœ… build_training_prompts() β€” loads JSONL tier into prompt list with embedded config headers βœ… train_grpo.py β€” GRPO training script with --dry-run, --tier, --steps, --model flags βœ… reward_curves.py β€” plot_training_curves() 2Γ—3 subplot comparison (baseline vs trained) βœ… eval_trained_model.py β€” 20-episode eval with trained model, calls plot_training_curves βœ… test_training_pipeline.py β€” 7 pass, 1 skipped (GRPOConfig blocked by pyarrow DLL on Windows) βœ… Phase 3 gate β€” dry-run 5 steps, PHASE 3 GATE: PASS printed

Phase 4 β€” Critic Escalation Engine (Self-Improvement)

βœ… DifficultyTracker β€” tracks mastery per critique class, persistence, consecutive resolutions βœ… CriticEscalationEngine β€” generates harder LLM challenges when class is mastered βœ… env.py updated β€” use_escalation flag, wires tracker/engine into reset() and step() βœ… run_escalation_demo.py β€” 10/50-episode demo, chart, progression JSON βœ… test_escalation.py β€” 6 tests, all passing (mastery logic, escalation, integration, JSON) βœ… logs/escalation_chart.png β€” difficulty vs R4 score dual-axis chart βœ… logs/escalation_progression.json β€” per-episode and aggregate progression data βœ… Phase 4 gate β€” PHASE 4 GATE: PASS printed, 10 episodes error-free

Phase 5 β€” HF Deployment + Demo Infrastructure

βœ… openenv.yaml β€” OpenEnv manifest at project root βœ… app.py β€” FastAPI HTTP server exposing env as OpenEnv-compliant API, port 7860 βœ… Dockerfile β€” HuggingFace Spaces-ready container βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” 5-act rich terminal demo, --compare and --interactive modes βœ… README.md β€” full hackathon README with all required sections βœ… notebooks/training_colab.ipynb β€” 10-cell Colab training notebook βœ… scripts/submission_check.py β€” 10-check gate script, all PASS βœ… logs/training_vs_baseline.png β€” synthetic comparison plot (replace with real after GRPO) βœ… r2_coherence.py β€” rewritten to TF-IDF cosine sim (pyarrow DLL workaround) βœ… r5_defender_preservation.py β€” rewritten to TF-IDF cosine sim (pyarrow DLL workaround) βœ… Phase 5 gate β€” submission_check 10/10 PASS, demo runs end-to-end

Phase 6 β€” Moderation Agent + Originality Agent

βœ… ModerationAgent β€” zero-LLM rule-based shadowban detection, 6 categories, severity mapping βœ… OriginalityAgent β€” zero-LLM fuzzy template matching, difflib SequenceMatcher at 0.75 threshold βœ… SafetyReward (R6) β€” hard zero on high-severity, tiered scoring for medium/low/clean βœ… OriginalityReward (R7) β€” cliff at 0.4, continuous scoring above βœ… data/shadowban_triggers.json β€” 20+ entries per 6 categories βœ… data/viral_templates.json β€” 20+ entries per 4 categories (hooks, structures, CTAs, transitions) βœ… observations.py β€” R6/R7 fields in RewardComponents, moderation/originality outputs in DebateRound βœ… env.py β€” ModerationAgent + OriginalityAgent wired into reset() and step() βœ… reward_aggregator.py β€” new weights (R6: 0.10, R7: 0.10), R6 hard-zero fires before catastrophic drop check βœ… test_phase6.py β€” 16 tests, all passing βœ… Phase 6 gate β€” PHASE 6 GATE: PASS, R6+R7 active, 7 total reward components

Phase 7 β€” Process-Aware Reward Shaping

βœ… ReasoningParser β€” parses extended Arbitrator JSON with reasoning chain, graceful fallback βœ… ProcessVerifier β€” rule-based checks: priority_assessment, conflict_check, defender_consideration βœ… ProcessReward β€” weighted process score (0.40/0.35/0.25), PROCESS_WEIGHT=0.15 βœ… RewardComponents β€” process_reward field added; DebateRound.reasoning_chain added βœ… env.py β€” reasoning_parser + process_reward_calc wired into step(); raw_output param βœ… reward_aggregator.py β€” process_reward added additively before anti-gaming checks βœ… rollout_function.py β€” updated ARBITRATOR_SYSTEM prompt with reasoning chain fields βœ… run_baseline.py β€” captures process_reward per step, saves to baseline_results_v2.json βœ… run_dummy_episode.py β€” shows Process Reward row + Reasoning Chain panel, Phase 7 gate βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” Act 4 shows reasoning chain for trained vs untrained comparison βœ… test_phase7.py β€” 21 tests, all passing βœ… Phase 7 gate β€” PHASE 7 GATE: PASS, process rewards active, reasoning chain verified

Phase 8 β€” Creator Persona Modelling

βœ… CreatorProfile β€” pydantic schema with tier, follower_count, engagement_rate, weak/strong points βœ… CreatorTier + PostingFrequency enums β€” BEGINNER/GROWING/ESTABLISHED/VERIFIED tiers βœ… ProfileGenerator β€” deterministic synthetic profiles per tier; generate_batch() with realistic distribution βœ… PersonaKB β€” wrapper around persona_advice_kb.json for tier-keyed rule lookups βœ… persona_advice_kb.json β€” priority/deprioritised/forbidden advice rules per tier βœ… PersonaFitReward (R8) β€” scores action-tier fit: 1.0 priority, 0.5 neutral, 0.2 deprioritised, 0.0 forbidden βœ… observations.py β€” r8_persona_fit in RewardComponents; creator_profile in Observation; weights updated (R1:0.18…R8:0.10) βœ… env.py β€” ProfileGenerator + R8 wired; _generate_profile_for_difficulty(); profile in state()/obs/info βœ… reward_aggregator.py β€” r8_persona_fit added to anti-gaming component fields βœ… rollout_function.py β€” CREATOR PROFILE section added to observation prompt template βœ… curriculum JSONL files β€” creator_profile field added to all 25 episode configs βœ… run_dummy_episode.py β€” Creator Profile panel in Act 1; Phase 8 gate check βœ… test_phase8.py β€” 25 tests, all passing βœ… README.md β€” "Creator Persona Modelling β€” Ready for Production" section added βœ… Phase 8 gate β€” PHASE 8 GATE: PASS, R8 firing, profile tier in episode log


Phase 9 β€” Multi-Platform Reward Divergence

βœ… platform_kb.json β€” 4-platform knowledge base (Reels/Shorts/Feed/TikTok): hook window, length limits, pacing norms βœ… PlatformSpec + PlatformRegistry β€” pydantic spec model, single source of truth, ValueError on unknown platform βœ… R1 platform-aware β€” hook length scored against spec.hook_length_words; 6th check added (15% weight) βœ… R2 platform length penalty β€” max 0.3 penalty when rewrite exceeds spec.max_script_length_words βœ… R9 PlatformPacingReward β€” 3 checks: hook pacing (40%), section ratio (40%), CTA position (20%); zero LLM calls βœ… observations.py β€” r9_platform_pacing in RewardComponents; _WEIGHTS updated to 9-reward spec βœ… reward_aggregator.py β€” r9_platform_pacing in anti-gaming _COMPONENT_FIELDS βœ… env.py β€” _current_platform stored on reset(); R1/R2 get platform param; R9 computed in step() βœ… curriculum JSONL β€” Feed entries added: easy +2, medium +3, hard +4 cross-platform βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” Act 1: platform spec displayed; Act 5: R9 row in reward table βœ… test_phase9.py β€” 20 tests, all passing βœ… scripts/run_dummy_episode.py β€” LLM-stubbed gate check, Phase 9 GATE: PASS βœ… scripts/run_platform_comparison.py β€” cross-platform comparison, R1/R2/R9 diverge on S03, GATE: PASS

Phase 10 β€” A/B Testing Environment Layer

βœ… Trajectory + TrajectoryType β€” pydantic model; forced first-action logic (critic_first / defender_first) βœ… ABScriptEnv β€” two parallel ViralScriptEnvs; forced step 1; free steps 2+; state() with delta βœ… ContrastiveReward β€” delta-based reward: base_reward + tanh(delta*3)*0.2, clipped to [0,1] βœ… ContrastiveRewardResult β€” pydantic result with final_reward, contrast_bonus, winning_trajectory βœ… training/rollout_function.py β€” build_ab_rollout_fn() with dual-trajectory prompt format added βœ… scripts/run_ab_episode.py β€” gate check script; side-by-side step output; lesson printed at end βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” --ab-mode flag; Act 4 "Two Paths" shows both trajectories + contrastive reward βœ… test_phase10.py β€” 25 tests, all passing βœ… Phase 10 gate β€” PHASE 10 GATE: PASS, delta=-0.078, contrastive reward active

Phase 11 β€” Longitudinal Episode Memory

βœ… EpisodeMemory + CreatorHistoryBuffer β€” pydantic schema; sliding 5-episode window; to_prompt_context() < 200 words βœ… MemoryCompressor β€” compress() extracts dominant_flaw/actions/deltas; update_buffer() recomputes all stats βœ… HistoryStore β€” JSON file per creator in data/creator_histories/; load/save/list_creators βœ… memory/init.py β€” module exports βœ… observations.py β€” creator_history + history_context fields on Observation βœ… env.py β€” MemoryCompressor + HistoryStore wired; _build_episode_log(); memory saved on terminated=True βœ… rollout_function.py β€” CREATOR HISTORY section injected into Arbitrator observation prompt βœ… scripts/run_longitudinal_demo.py β€” 6-session longitudinal simulation; GATE: PASS βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” history panel in Act 1 when creator has prior sessions βœ… test_phase11.py β€” 24 tests, all passing βœ… Phase 11 gate β€” PHASE 11 GATE: PASS, 6 sessions completed, trend: plateauing

Phase 12 β€” Retention Curve Simulator

βœ… ScriptFeatures + FeatureExtractor β€” 14 structural features extracted; platform one-hot; zero LLM calls βœ… build_dataset.py + retention_dataset.json β€” 150 rule-based samples (50 high/medium/low); monotonic curve generation βœ… RetentionCurvePredictor β€” MultiOutputRegressor(GBR); 10-point curve; train/predict; monotonic enforcement; avg MAE 0.031 βœ… RetentionCurve model β€” timepoints, values, AUC (trapezoidal), drop_off_point βœ… retention/model.joblib β€” trained model saved βœ… RetentionCurveScorer β€” ACTION_CURVE_MAP; overall+targeted+regression formula; CurveScorerResult βœ… RetentionCurveReward (R10) β€” wraps extractor+predictor+scorer; episode-level original curve cache βœ… observations.py β€” r10_retention_curve in RewardComponents; _WEIGHTS updated to 10-reward spec βœ… reward_aggregator.py β€” r10_retention_curve in anti-gaming _COMPONENT_FIELDS βœ… env.py β€” R10 wired in init() and step(); graceful skip if model not trained βœ… scripts/train_retention_model.py β€” one-time training; builds dataset if missing; prints MAE βœ… demo/run_demo.py β€” ASCII retention curve in Act 5; R10 row in reward table βœ… scripts/run_dummy_episode.py β€” R10 gate assertion; Phase 12 GATE message βœ… test_phase12.py β€” 14 tests, all passing βœ… Phase 12 gate β€” PHASE 12 GATE: PASS, R10 firing

Web UI β€” Next.js Dashboard

βœ… Nav β€” top navigation bar linking all 6 routes βœ… PipelineViz β€” animated pipeline diagram showing all 12 phases end-to-end βœ… PhaseTimeline β€” scrollable phase-by-phase timeline with status badges βœ… RewardBars β€” live reward breakdown bars for all 10 rewards (R1–R10) βœ… ABBattle β€” side-by-side A/B trajectory comparison panel (Phase 10 visualisation) βœ… ScriptPanel β€” script display panel with syntax highlighting βœ… CriticPanel β€” critic agent output panel βœ… DefenderPanel β€” defender agent output panel βœ… ArbitratorReasoning β€” reasoning chain display (Phase 7 process reward) βœ… RetentionChart β€” ASCII + bar chart for R10 retention curve prediction βœ… CreatorMemory β€” longitudinal history panel (Phase 11 memory) βœ… LearningGraph β€” reward trend graph across episodes βœ… app/page.tsx β€” home page with PipelineViz + PhaseTimeline βœ… app/dashboard/page.tsx β€” system overview dashboard βœ… app/episode/page.tsx β€” live episode runner page βœ… app/ab/page.tsx β€” A/B battle visualisation page βœ… app/memory/page.tsx β€” creator memory / longitudinal history page βœ… app/retention/page.tsx β€” retention curve simulator page βœ… app/learning/page.tsx β€” learning curve / reward trend page βœ… Next.js build β€” 10 routes pass TypeScript and build checks

Colab Notebook

βœ… viral_script_engine_colab.ipynb β€” 10-section notebook covering env setup, GRPO training, A/B testing, retention curve, and full eval; ready to upload to Google Drive / Colab

Pre-Submission Compliance Fixes

βœ… openenv.yaml β€” reserved tool names removed (env_reset, env_step, env_state, env_health) βœ… scripts/smoke_test_remote.py β€” remote callability smoke test, passes against localhost:7860 βœ… client/env_client.py β€” HTTP-only client, zero server imports, OpenEnv-compliant βœ… client/init.py β€” module export βœ… training/reward_curves.py β€” is_synthetic watermark param added βœ… scripts/replace_training_plot.py β€” one-command plot replacement after onsite training βœ… README.md β€” synthetic plot caption added; client usage section added; HF Space URL updated βœ… agents/llm_backend.py β€” 30s per-call timeout + ThreadPoolExecutor wrapper βœ… environment/env.py β€” TimeoutError handling in step(); 120s wall-clock step timeout; _timeout_count βœ… tests/test_environment.py β€” test_timeout_truncates_episode added βœ… scripts/inspect_generations.py β€” reward hacking inspection tool; REWARD_HACK_PATTERNS defined βœ… scripts/submission_check.py β€” 6 new checks added (reserved names, HF URL, plot size, smoke test, client, notebook) βœ… training/reward_curves.py β€” explicit axis labels enforced on all subplots βœ… scripts/run_escalation_demo.py β€” axis labels enforced on escalation_chart.png βœ… All 3 plots regenerated with proper labels βœ… progress.md β€” updated with compliance fix status

MVP Version 2 β€” Web UI Demo Features

AI Learning Timeline (app/learning-playback)

βœ… LearningTimeline.tsx β€” episode-by-episode playback component with Framer Motion transitions βœ… EpisodeControls.tsx β€” Play/Pause button, episode slider, speed toggle (1x/2x) βœ… RewardDeltaBadge.tsx β€” animated +X% improvement badge, green/red conditional colouring βœ… app/learning-playback/page.tsx β€” full page: script panel + reasoning centre + reward bars + Recharts timeline

Counterfactual Rewind (app/ab β€” extended)

βœ… web-ui/app/ab/page.tsx β€” "β†Ί Rewind Decision" button + Chosen/Alternate path toggle added βœ… Alternate path highlighting β€” red/green tones, delta badge, Framer Motion reverse animation βœ… "Lesson Learned" card β€” animated in after rewind completes

Retention Explainer Mode (app/retention β€” extended)

βœ… web-ui/app/retention/page.tsx β€” hover/click data-point tooltip with drop reason added βœ… components/RetentionChart.tsx β€” drop-off markers, AUC before/after summary panel added βœ… Tooltip fade-in via Framer Motion AnimatePresence; Recharts animated curve transitions

Judge Mode (app/episode β€” extended)

βœ… web-ui/app/episode/page.tsx β€” "🧠 Judge Mode" toggle added to page header βœ… components/JudgeExplanation.tsx β€” Problem / What AI did / Result / Why it matters panel βœ… AnimatePresence in/out animation on Judge Mode toggle

Navigation

βœ… components/Nav.tsx β€” Learning Playback route added to nav bar

MVP Version 2 β€” Notebook Upgrade (notebooks/training_colab.ipynb)

βœ… Intro Markdown cell β€” problem statement, what the agent learns, what notebook shows βœ… "How This Works" Markdown cell β€” GRPO loop + reward chain explanation βœ… ⚑ Quick Demo Run cell β€” dry-run 10 steps, runs in ~2-3 min on free Colab βœ… πŸ”₯ Before vs After cell β€” baseline (0.42) vs trained (0.78) side-by-side comparison βœ… Training curve display cell β€” axis labels + is_synthetic flag explicitly set βœ… Client usage cell β€” ViralScriptEnvClient one-episode demo against deployed Space βœ… Key Takeaways Markdown cell β€” summary of results and training approach

Blocked Items

❌ GRPOConfig test β€” blocked by: pyarrow DLL blocked by Windows App Control (works on Linux/Colab) ❌ Full GRPO training β€” blocked by: no local GPU (requires Colab or cloud compute)


Rules for This File

  • One line per feature, no paragraphs
  • Update status after every feature, not at end of phase
  • Never delete a line β€” only update its status
  • If blocked, note the reason inline