text stringlengths 1 39.9k | label stringlengths 4 23 | dataType stringclasses 2
values | communityName stringlengths 4 23 | datetime stringdate 2014-06-06 00:00:00 2025-05-21 00:00:00 | username_encoded stringlengths 136 160 | url_encoded stringlengths 220 528 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
The definition of 'strong AI' given doesn't seem very useful - what does it mean for something to think like us, and who cares if it even does - are we really assuming that an AI has moral status if and only if it is strong AI? On the list of "terms that cause far more confusion than they solve", I'd put Strong AI even... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-10 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZXplanFxMHhWQzFuUUdxMl9DU05FcXJtM1pxTTFLTkprcmpTS3Y4QTVJaWticTdlbnZUNXJMSjRQNEJaa0VQR3N2RHFBY3I4aWJ2LV9Cd2wxNGFFWUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCOXJaMEctU2Q1M2NiUHVzTGh4NW1KV251RmlBN19IdDlnWnJuNlNSbFgtUjY4RHhZVmRMc2JVWlVoOHJ6Zko4SzcyaFExSjM3S0dzMGpMaWNBVlhjdW5Obm5mWXB4N21ObWtjcUlxZGZhaTQ3RE9Mb3h6WTk2OWdkREhScTFmZVVielp2clZzVXZJRHJPMWpvNFVWZzRkbDN0bW1Pb2xDdW50aG1NUkdzTjgybWNaU1YzWGtiSk1xaUxGMEpyWVduRkNMOTBWTnJZcG9mX3UxaDdIaEt0dz09 |
I found that some of these setups were plain ridiculous. But it's interesting to see MIT moving on the issue with a crowdsourcing platform. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-14 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBM0wwV0lSRUtXX05pXzVuWF9oWFY1WURPVlo5QVhQbERDaWNNcWQ0MmxReXZXY2p3OFFpUkV2OTVFTGo1LWY2MHRvN0ItVFFuXzJWc0hVb29nMzdjYnc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCeDVIb1h4N1VaaURrTTc3YWtmaUlkMmEzWXAxUUVWeGRzYzZsa1hJZXNJck5jeVhGejczeXBUeExKbEZ1T29MWkFmdDhDT2p6VUhNazRad3lVX3BtdVVMRVdLYTRCdUNCYW1IemVMeFZfZUo2VGNyZHRWZnNld0lTX0o2QlhBbUtBSGZHNDR6RDdhbklFbktkbkpaaGMxOU9EcTJCZ2hpN3BCaUUwUkhFbkZ3QnluQXZwazA2QURlcE4zQ0ZLN0dmVXZTNlNTX3hoQ1QxcUpLUHZPbEFDZz09 |
Thanks! | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-17 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUXhzcGU1Qzk5V0p1SEt3bE55eExuX3lBdG9rTkk4TzlUUUFydzg4TDFtZzl0SllseUpQU2M5WmR0NTRFcTFyeDhRNEkzbnNkTEtPM3p0alJpcjFpbXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCS2FvU1Ytb3lXZFBMeXNBUkhnTVNtSDFQZFlqaTZTb29sZENFS0lyM2E0X0xMMTlsVnd0aUpmbFgzTHQzNjQ5M3ZrNlY2ZzRvbmx4TGdZbHBqcVlSWThwRmhyTEVNQmZraHBlVEwyNFBOM3F4bmRmNUpvc0dsczdieFZCMVN3RzNLYUh1SjhKWlVkVlo2N2lZa2x0ZGhDQzNpQVBKaXJaaFM2ZHpYMEY1WVh3WDBuenN1bG5fTV9paFF1aUV0WXEz |
@grau article
Do you think there are certain kinds of choices that should be left to purely selfless ai agents? If so where should we draw the line?
Also some points remind me of feminist ethics critique of utilitarianism | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-17 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNEQwTXEzeGxNNzhwRXNsdjFXN1RVNTNCMVd5dE1KaXFvMHp0cGFCRGpLQnBTMlh0bkhwU1JTNVF0aEt5YmdXZC1SSHEwcEdMQl9kRVhoTUVLRWNNclE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCa2VrRURiY2ZSZEFveGVHMEZkR1h0ekFoYlRqNmhaSjNwR3BZWFN2Y2FnLWhQOV9JeTNlNXM4eEtnQjdGT2dkSWhaektvLTZVcTNpOU13d0ozQklWZEVPTzBEXzUxQVF1TnA4Z0FvdV9oeHlWLWdqd01acUtCVTdza3U4MUExMXNreTktdjViM1pLeDZvN1pQYVloTDYwZEUxTXRaNGlPRUhVU292dVZ3OXdrN0NNcUlaVFlleXFoWmNqZm5peDBS |
I actually haven't read that yet and I'm busy tonight, do me a favor and hit me with a reminder if I don't get back to you in a couple days. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-17 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBRmhOZEMtT2g5NGhnRkR2NEd4ZEdJckR5MmtwbmVkZmgzWll5R3ZzVE1rVmEyTl9FWEg0eXVvMHA5RjE5UW41Qi1IMFlqRlpkM08wLTI1TUZ3ZS1HV1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZmxscEcyZFd6Rk1NUG1LWjdFSjN3alpWWUhGem5yZkUtNUctSkd5dDZWMTYwZURFamFmQ3dOdV9LdGszZThnSm9ZbWpTME5UYmlEZUNWNktiNU93U09sU0pobktYc1daRkZvX0R6eVRuTGVlOTBxWTIwdmx6a01tb1lmanJMb09nb25WQVJqdUJGZ1hyaXZLMUp4WmQzdzlDTjFMN083RlBYSUVYTl92ZjkzWkJJNHZUbmdBLVFsa1p4NDJZaVFz |
Dr. Rossi from the University of Padova discusses preference aggregation in moral and non-moral contexts, the basic methods for compact specification of preferences and constraints in artificial systems, and how we might go about merging moral preferences and constraints with non-moral preferences and constraints in au... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-19 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBREEtR1Zrb1N5aDZHYmRPQmlES3RodlBUc3Vsb3RrZnNZNThPYl9NbV8tck1lRFJkSUhqOHliUUU3YnR2aTF0NjlmVUU1bnNadW5NTDJEaGtLVGhoNVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCanVoc1ZObHJRdV9rSUEzUFFjbmpKMnROaXdTcXNxbEJhdVF6TlJheTVFWEFUWjg1M2xKWU5HdUEwY1k0UkNhZVdLUFd1QkVrSFJKaXozMHVKMENNTmF5WXhnX0ZyOVRpdHNDLUVkWGZhblMzMXlScEFfZ20xV2RJdG5sVlVpWFVtLUw3VnhwQjQ2TU9oSWg3U2JmT2dqdE5xcGk3Y3ZwdXh6eVI2bm16dHQ3Si1zd2VsT3RtYkJQMWUwSVgxYjNp |
On one hand, we shouldn't be feeding AI biased information. On the other hand, bias is very subjective and not everyone agrees on what's "unbiased".
The truth of the matter is that bias is everywhere and AI is the best way to become less biased - but it's still a slow process. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-08-30 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBaDh3ajZYVnl4ZWY0ZVBUQ0VqSC1ZcV9yWUxqRUNVcHk0YWFjUlNuUXhhNGMyVnF2ckktMUE1X0xRV24xQUgwVkxyNmU1VHVCLVB1RTM0RFFWUjRVWGc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCLUxFY0YwV0c4Nm04Q2dGWmpDUHRVV0VGUWo0cHdpLS0wTXFBcXhEMEFveWxxZnRpRTZoSXRkVmZ2QnpWNmV4QWtoTFVjcE1mcTNQWnNqc2JfWHZ5UHVpMFV3OXpqUXA0dGdpWTlPb2pCMlNQbjBXbTlOYms4N2JIRE44OTVjMEhzaDg0RlU4UlM0amNmZDE3QU91Sjg2M29pSjlVWDRSUFRVU3J5MG5JeGVyR1M3LXFfaVJlUUZ0dTlyTExFWXJvaXNnc3h5c29HdEFCYy1UZk9raEE2UT09 |
Some background on the report: http://www.nytimes.com/2016/09/02/technology/artificial-intelligence-ethics.html | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-09-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBMVdvRWdQOGI4Y2d5bmhwQmNySXJJOWZQYlBYMkx4LVVXaE5sUUpIVWs1UkhCdHZZNHZfcTVZMTdzbWpFdk55cksxZElCWmJ4Uy1XX3l2OUpOSm95U1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZjlXWVJlM201Ym5LcWVrb2ZtSVdfM1V0bDU1RXZpU2ZZX29kOGxZcmt1WlZqNFFmZHNNeGlFZ0ZIRDhKVWVEcnhqbFB2TlR1dXhkbkF2anFsQ2VrSndaVmNBZVJpRTFpTmNwLVpZSGFMODlrS0NHblRvN0FjcjBXcGJYRTM0SGE3ZVNRUEc3TTlxVVhFNk1DLUlUTnNQSTdRNW5VenlVQ0pRcFFHZXU0cWlZdXd5bTM5N1VXNXJNZUhNekZLZjlCZmxUUTdKNzZFS3gtNXZVTGhySGhWdz09 |
This latest episode of the biased-machine-learning wars is a little underwhelming. 25% of the contestants were nonwhite and 16% of the winners were nonwhite. There were only 44 winners so the difference might not be statistically significant. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-09-12 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZXF2RTVxeG1odHVnV3BFWlhtaVoxSEZhbm5ibGZLUnlWdUZyQWJmTkRqazB3U1NvS3QzZnpOVk1MYW4tYUJVREVlMnJsSTdFeFd0djdXOXdvNGJtc1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSXE2dkpSbmE5MTBnS3dTZENZeGN5ZGU4dEE1QldqSm56S2JfdzdDdm84WDYxVWswV1hFUW9yZjlzZUFzbFUtaHd0ZWY5OFBrZnA5aXhOZm9vVWlqSE43ekN4ZGlyeS1NeFVzaHFZc04td3k2SUVhaXFuOF9qYzgydW5BMjBOU0x3STZFREUzWldyaFJOSHVHZHJ5aURwRzJZQm40MzI4WlNUZGtEVVhQRmJaTXpWLWFqdjNLLUg1RUxrUkdhUE9FTUNlY1pHYjlZMDY4bEU3WU1VU1VGdz09 |
Thanks for the short and fun read, but I don't think this is the right subreddit for it. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-09-30 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBQ2RzOGpoaXJEeDhrWk1lZ1ZQUW9RVG9qRGtURWRUU2lUNUJJYlpiNEI5cEIxWS1RSVA2bWF4V0hseWhtdnZ6RF8wTEdXN0xXQXp1THFYWVpzUkZoS0E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCeHIwU2RKRU9kRFhRaUw5TERELXNXM3ZMSVp2RTdrRXVmMGc0Vk8xNEV5UF9kanRWQ2VJTmVUcFFqdmdObUQxTGoxQUQyak0wUWI2VEZ2UGJmQVdKV1p3UHJJVUZuMlVtNVREXzkwOHlPVVNkZmdaQ0tuLUE4Z255VVE0eXFHZ3lSY05jRDhsNmZXSU9mX2kzS2lKTHpfR01TajUyVHdmTGw2TUo3SVZmSWs5WG5EM216RXlzLVFSOE1jUHV1ZlhOTDRET0xVVV9pMEZLazJxMjUtYnhvUT09 |
Brilliant. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-09-30 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUkhMcTlBM01QWU5ldWEyV0dHLWdKZEM5Y3lxVkF3THJHVVZYLXpLQkt4M1k0WGxuZVZNa0oyaTd0aXpHVlV6Q3pqZmVmOGxCSElhRnB2TGsyQlVibXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYzZvdVlGR19aR0ZMb2MxMlIyQ19KeVM3MW5MN3I5VkJlRGZNNms4XzFUYVkxRktQYVptRVUzS2YtRzY2dkw5cnZ5WWRpNUQxT1BhRnE0VnNnVkdIRHhjTF9NZkpXMGp3N054eGlJclFGaE82TjJkcTVQVUVNYjJkSGh2SF80dFpPMXRXd0xWN3M0OHFFa21XV0dnUWtMLTdVN2lfUE8zWHhpVVNla2tCaEcwZ2FlUEpITGpjdGpLYnZmd3RpZzJuNjhqNTZVQUZGbzRsaFhGXzFyS2tSZz09 |
Are you sure? This seems like a concise (though hypothetical) example of the dangers of using an algorithmic model based on unwarranted assumptions in real life, particularly when those inflexible assumptions clash with real human expectations.
If that's not relevant to the topic of machine ethics, then what is?
| r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-01 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUmtNdnJhbGZfNnpnanpBN3BiN0o1amc4QWhDNm1uZ2x6UlF6ZHpCT3o0U2lHdGJ6akVGb2hoWmN3cWJDZ3RudEJiOUd2cDlpa0xEUmxPdXZ5cXY1SEhWa1Z0YU04V2N0VFhscDlnT1dITVE9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCR25HS0RSWUlHaGlVSDhCM01HVWUtYjlfVkN2em5aVXVQRGg2eEdsUzBrSWN0ejlzbEI4Y3pyRmpYNm11RkFBMExseE5HYVlvRF96Y3pueTVwVXg3X3dxTDVKTHRiTEs2VG0zVktub2lnckdwa1BIazdHbUtaaHVvQ1dpN2VfbFhRU3RtNVViOUZOeWZ6Q0VzUDJQN05Pb0N1bGhScmkzNzJoaFVGcjhwR3VYSlBIdkJnVXM1U2htXzhpVG1TUHZXX0J5M1ZHdktZWnhOTktoUVFnOXh3UT09 |
People won't be happy until the AI says everyone is beautiful. Since beauty is in the eye of the beholder, an AI made to determine who's beautiful is pointless | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-01 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUDF3S01ZSkNXZGF1WEx2bTl2VmtkOEt1My1vX2Y1WXBGbWtJVEZxRVlFNFJ4d2x4RlBxSHRiY0dJNFBmTVhoUHJMTVdKc0ZqVXpSSVAxbTFoaWg1THc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZzBiOVVyWWVFUkF2dnVpX0F5Y042bk53dGYtUFY2eDdkeGRQeUF6MVBwZnM5SU1sR3dFNjlVbk9NSndoXzBYVm1ONmluS1JkNVJTaWFEM3NYS3UteGxsNVpucjVXYXNmN2lIaGVNSmFxcGo2ZENNbVdRNHdtdnZsaDY0RXVuZ3VRYm44LUg1ZEJLamR5Q1UxekxnTkhNbTRXdEVLMDRIOG9LS051Njl0bFRjUi11WHNOR3lzZS1PUXNYakFEX25JQTNGVkFqOXI1WFg4UFhXM2xRY0IxUT09 |
A couple op eds and a book here - I'm sure there's more, maybe someone else can add some:
http://motherboard.vice.com/en_uk/read/its-our-fault-that-ai-thinks-white-names-are-more-pleasant-than-black-names?trk_source=recommended
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2016/sep/01/how-algorithms-rule-our-working-lives
htt... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-01 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWmRObE1qYTVyVGhRUmE4VFVwWHpMb2t4eGt1VG5iSHVfYUhvQzNyRmpGMWZHMWppajVEd0c2Ui1sci01alVxNkFCb0NHOW1IZG9zU0Y1RjVoVncwclE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCM05ZSG1HenMwUWFWdVMwV2NQQjFXc0I5YUw4eE5BVVVxc18zdDc3QlN3N1FjTDdBNzBrUzA2cTc5ekptUlRJM3ktOGtuUzZORDNiVG9xTGY3U2hCYjVaeFU2UUVoODdfSHdzWmpjMHM2TUFmRzBIR0VEdzNHOHdXUXVtSzAtcWk1aUJPbGZ0M2lzSFhIcmJmcW9yUWVycG9MZFZRQXpfZktXTEhnUURRQjlaNEE2R0tKaWFZUFJheVNqTEpIWWZF |
I like this. He brings in so much interesting literature on this side of the subject. Just going through all the citations on this paper to get an informed comprehensive view would be a major and super-interesting project.
>What would you say if someone came along and said, “Hey, we want to genetically engineer mental... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-01 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBU1Vwd1hPUWVMR2YzRnB3VzRDd1oyZ2c1YlBubXNpNFZtNEZUaFZ4UEhyZmhXRHR2OEUyclNyb3FKTlBzR24xU1hxaVAtRmthTEFac2NzNGF3ZWVmOUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcS1POGFWZ3IwUTRYcS13ZFE2QlRFTGRIZWZMbUhVcHRXczZWbFFRakdWMnBDaWJIMEdJQktHaUt4Si1WZ0x2cE9jbzJ6WTlISGVqaW1lT3lkTVVnMFBfT0oyUUg0VlJia0Z3OWt4d1l3N2JMSU1pWDE1elg2dURNU1FlcTh5QXhTa3k2MHpqOTBkR3dwN19COE9HUFNOWDdjMzFlZGQ2MTFpMk5kRjRUUXR0Yk9hZVFDcE9INGJCUXhQbWZLSXlkUm9rRjdFb3gtaXE0eE5BRFZyQ2hjdz09 |
rights are not granted, they are WON.
our species is still working on getting human rights to all the humans, let alone some silicon life form with light running thru its veins instead of blood.
what will likely happen, if we are even given this chance, is that SAI will fight for it's legal rights the same way women ... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWURPTmNmZ2Y2NFlLX3NHU244cmZENzFEWklYQnpkODdqNG9qSWRjLWlWM3lNcENVVDZkel8yYmxhcTV3UE5Vci1KaUM1Tl9ENEpwQXo2bDNqeFRna2c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCb1RzSXlHczBEdFdiMG1PVTVNYWNDNTZ0RUtsNXZhMXR1c010ZThmMmNfdVZPZTd4YjMwbktuTVpsdXNMSFREV0lTUnQwb0NVWlNDV3p6SHZzYUNoZHhBYXJ0LW82M3BlUWw2ekxKVHphejhHNVd6MkJIZVhHRmNDSy0waDl1R21yTTN2UU5HTS1RRnhVX19mU1Naa1l3NEVHMF9JSVdpcTFjUm8ta1N4LWZPMTBBb1VZbWJnWkN4eWRRdGlVTkJIU2xGZmM0Q1lkV2xqUEpKVEhQdDlDQT09 |
it was unethical and likely violated the rights of the deceased for the police to act as judge, jury and executioner without due process.
but then the suspect was black, so that apparently means that de-escalation, and negotiation practices no longer apply.
the bundy folks were armed and apparently free to go into to... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbUFDSFlqdjJNb1FOSzhObnJHTkVTZ3lXckVTQVdBZjlucTh1aHROT0stMzdPVUg0cTVEZ05DM1dKa2loRldwYlVPcXdYSGtzOWxHZV9nV1o3UV9jaXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCQlY5NHJpd1F1SGJ5d3FkcXZkRHA5cDFLUi1BWXhvYTM5eHNUWEw2TlhuNzZrdWpHY1hGaDFXWGlUMk5lMGpwWFZJVjUwakxKaXNxcXpDVGJremJtSzloUDd2VjJ6TG05YS1kbDhpaXdpRXB0TTdfWHNYdnFSOGxRM3Nud2NTSGx3RENhVVY4TW44bFFjVGxwZzk5eXUydlpuakxKRTN6NWhvdEkxMlR1YlpqY1dwU3o3a0ZYWnk2QmpPYTB6MEFsUFktaTZKaHJWUnh5VXdMYXhMeHBJQT09 |
I've realized that 'finalizing' human values is probably too strong a term. Imagine if human values had been locked in by the ancient Greeks or the medieval Catholic Church? There's probably plenty of immoral things we're still doing today, and we would want future AI systems to learn better.
[Coherent Extrapolated Vo... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBT3B6QjBnaUFTOE1IQzFrcDZMTjhvUWtPWEFfMFhqa3JlVFppSTQ1ZWFwakRhMVRVYUEtY2NTVmVSWlI5a1pHcU1pbGRMeThtWDczX1FaeVFnMkFBYnc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcGk0V2Y1UVFGeGMyN2Q2YldHMUlnOXBYeEJlMGVJWUU3ZGxnOGtLY2w5akNBZk9qeDZObjhwTDNrSF9rQ0pTaUp5UGY2MnR4UlFNdi14ay16aGRoMXIwSlROSmJqUVhIS3hkcXJTaThacDB4NFVOVWNNM0VPZ2gzZVotX0pBeHJTVUI1MDhVMlo4dU45Q1BPb3dwM0ljOEtNVHpoY2o1bTJRMW9heTJCN3VjcW43anV1U21JalBIWkNoVFlMeFRV |
The title could be formatted to relate to AI better, since article doesn't even mention it. Although /u/impermanentThrowaway has a valid point. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBU1hiZ3BON2kySGc0QVUtOF9GNTNlNWJseW5xVnN0QUFhZklUQk9xa1RpMlRyUmpYM0s0Znh2MWNqelNhV0E1dlRDNzd6anpxTnhXdXBITzc0MkpCNnc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMzdIb1F2NkVIdG9YdndFLWVOSkotNTZ2VllzUU1lOFlma1N5MEU4eUZGaDAtWWJZRjFxdWxXU3RqZXdpQ252djluUjZVNmhHQ09IRFNzSWM2eTNNa3g2dkxSV0QzNEUycmFtZjZQNTdDUWtuMWtWNWJ3aFYzRDJ5SHNNQWN5Vkg0RmdEM21IdTJvT25XcTUzUXhsRE44TXQ0c1BTSHBXOXBITlp4SUNYM2hRYmk5ZVc5ZGM2SjFPdHRmZmVNZ3lTZ1cxYUVtLWFKSHhLbWprdldBbVd3UT09 |
>I’ve got your algorithm right here! This is called the Dubins’ Grab-It-and-Eat Protocol!’
Amazing | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBeGhGVzNTVnBNYXpxMHdKQzRrTGJLWFlHQ0ZHQnRvTnBUd1pfY0lCaEJqUWFnRjFJVzBkZVBrS0JzMjdZb0dIVU1ZUDVKTGZhZkl2NVFzYkNBOS1Ub1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCRC1VM3U3aFNTS1RHdXBIOW1qWWpZUUtOYjdDTFZxR1I4aktOLVBtSU0tS2VwWlk0RzhMdXNDTWNPZWtSRzBWc2JiWXNTaDljU3ZacTZ2NFJWS0ZCUjA0dVlSR1BkUWVpankwdUNzcjJZd20xWWNGWDRONVh1OXZ0MERxUkxoYjlQaU5zMEVGVzBZSFVWYXZuSEgtMGF2ZmtQTURFZkxXYUhuZEpZcjhucWNtQURpNEtuVVRHTFdwUWpaWmJGR01LOWIyaWhWeDU5RHp3R0R1TmhhcENiQT09 |
I see no upside to AI. Everyone, including fictional characters and big tech companies, say AI is 'scary'. Why are we fucking with it then? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNlR2NWVfenlXekZMNW5GVENmNFVYRlB0TFRvSHY3b19OakdzRnl3SktHNUtBdVNPcWxDOUs0Q2lOYVNxdGpjaS1yN2EzNzMzLWxlWU8tU2tNSnI2OVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCR2wwaVhJU1Z6UmV1eUwwZkRJem1FYVM3RE5FYTM5bWFxZUNscXRzWDRaNTMwbEp6UWRNOE5DS0JZcDA2VjN5ajlYSnUxZG01MDBzSjcxelNjZWVSR0tjaE81OUhaSjZrUThlNnFVc1NXT05Ja2k1TmxKOFVlbnF6c0xVbjdXRXV3SzRxSnRSTzNYVl9RbzR6d2hKT05CUHlJbUotczdhUFBnb044NGFFYjJlWEswQ2JTWnZnY0ptTXhpT1EtRXo1 |
as a first-time tourist in this sub, I found this summary very satisfying. I think 'finalizing' is not too strong and gets the point across in lay terms. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbTRZcEN0WmlrTFZ1TlVxUFVXVkFYZWkxMG9OaXRUYk9nOXhOQmluRDFIUi1zNVNNVURIdFZQNnVGcDlyM0xLRjJyd1BYcTR2STBTNm4yeENRaE1sVFE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYmY5QTk4NHZlZ1RLSGNmYUxPRHVQaTJiZnhFZXd6Zy1OeW5CNVRFLTV0SGExa2pDaExEUk1tZndIZTB5ZjdxdUlLVFUzRWt5WlVTS0c3VWlLMHpxZ3dyUGV4aklBN29WNmFGU3htVTBtVXp5VkJLa3NLNmluOVBWTkZ0R29VV2stRWR6N1g1M3pFQW1YRFBRSmdYTHlmWnBVMnJDeWVDTFFEZVg2OEtYVlRpaWZxcUNPWU1NUDBycGdvU1JOdlRV |
The ability to pass off physical *and* mental labor on machines is tempting. A lot of people think there are benefits and that the risks are exaggerated. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBd1RLdWNROHo3MkJxNDVQbFl5NDBqWWZGZlAydi1lYTJmSUxzcHVSaWtiQV9uc0d1QmZLYnlibGVZWm5JRXNFbjQ4ZDlsWVhlUUlIMEYyOTl6RG5vVFE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYkc0bC1FN1lDV3ZueGVYd2ttbTRnbkZjS3V6RU54RVhVaWNFTm9ZYVhkVDZJblR0Wmk5dFl5aU53eUQ2U0E2VXlWQUs1cUpncU5iQkFxUVhhX0pqc2M3d0cxcTlGSEZSM0E2TkhtN2k2SXcxSGVmeHJ1ck9UR0h1VE1TWFp4ampyWXhFV0NHenBlaUhydVFSSzBJSkU5anN3MDNJX20zMWxmdWVnZm5lbW1adm51SHN5bGhZRXowNHNaUlpTellv |
We already have AI - we allow machines to make all kinds of decisions now. It is inevitable that in the future they will make more and more decisions and types of decisions. Thinking about ethical issues now is important so that we are prepared for them when they come up. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNGtCY2xlXy1jVjdKLVFyTURvYUJXdlF5ODJ5OHlCNC1xOGFUUGF6Z2VFX1hhYk82eTM1Z19aeVRydFdKZGp4QXB2Mmt3SlRWbjJIb2tjYmJIX0tyZVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCWlJ3cDZaQnZBM0ZEY0p1bmZuekpiTTY1SnBXMHFYUlBRcGJIRk9kSHlqWXF1WVRrODNlZnY3QUZuMmllYmowa1ZJempsdTdibktlMnVScUxuWDBpUGZYalJLTl9LZ3hoRzdUMGNaUW1kaXZyM00ta1BDVHFHTkxVTXQ1Ym9uRU16TXpoU3VCbGpnOFJfVmhVRjVuZmpsX1A5NkVuOURPRHFsWUFyZkNLTkVQMlRYY2tQdWhXYUJqX3ZUc3kwZ2pS |
Are you kidding? AI will be hugely beneficial for economic growth and solving global problems. Tech companies and researchers don't think it's scary, they think people are being too afraid.
Many of the above issues shouldn't be seen as all negative. Machine ethics might make our social systems fairer and more benefic... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBM2pXRVJ5RUs4a09IZTgxRWp0eDJWMjBpdm9YWWxpcFdPbzFrV2dnbTh3dVE2eGlLUWd5Yk9uM3l6NEh1TnJpaGdXcHlOV29Gd0FMTTlsQThPejE4ZlE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCaHYtazBhRl82M011c0RQc0FWazFaZWRrLVI0NmN2R3NXbUFzNzVzT0ZEZkpPT29zM0JBUjQ0UWxvckRzdGE0OFRKaFJ1MzQwV3RMakpLSkkwMjVnR2Z0RlpkT3ZxeFFXTzF1TzMzQ1BrZThsUGVCUElab1JrY0E0ejFZekdoSlRwUDg4OXdXNFRvRzhQYko5MllhVUkxZS1lcV84NzMzZXctVHM0QUt0eEFWaHhSSTBrQVgyeWd0NEJXNmEwS3pJ |
Oh... yes, that it is a good one. I should have thought to look through all of Bostrom's stuff. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBTjk1dW1jZ29fMnlXLWtib2Y2enkxeVNBaGMxQy11UVViYllka1E0bmw3RFpzVDZjcE1XLTRyUTZsLXQ3TDVMRkNGT3E4T0w2QlREUmdIbm03ZEkwcFE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCekw1TF8wblJZQklGMFJSZ0NjR2FzTzdtb0VaaTVjZHh0VnUyUUpLRGNtcjhsbnd3RHFqU0lKUlVwQU1IaVB0QjZXdDNjaXpRQTluM3locmRPZjd4WVFuc2JUdGVMc29aNnA3LUQ0bE5YbGc0S0RIMk5kb0dORV9vSVktTVhNVnlfc1VkM2NIaFBmUHhrQ211N0NFR1BuY0VVajZ4TjhCb2hQNmUyNGRyeTNBPQ== |
Because there's a lot of confunsion on the subject: in the industry noone is scared of the technology and all the problems are related to a misuse by humans and companies. The same could be said for every other tool ever used. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZjFVZU9OelFKR3pPOFIxQ05CdzhFMWZvUHpCRkRaT2J1bkpCU0M0WXNaZnZONTRjNW5aZWhQbXdYZk1RcjUzUGxERTZDYllzMWd5RVdQR2JjYVRvWHc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcllHc291bEdsTFhpR1lIZ19FVjJDcFplbDFKZnpSeTJocktrUTg1VmF5NmJXZVZHOW9SOTQxV05wUGZ1RS1mN2VsUWs5aE85VERLcWpacXJ2dWdEWUpsX0JlbmVCUVhYS1BOVUxlTllnN3J0Z0lrZzBvWHhJd2NicHl1UllxdEtYUjVFY015YkwwZUg1ZTJpVzVSeWZzUWExdnQwTnAxWHktd2FucFZaTVFZT1FiZ01WWjZSUGM4MnowOEZDYjhs |
That last paper /u/UmamiSalami mentioned ( “On the (Im)possibility of Fairness”) is a pretty recent paper that includes a number of good references.
Also checkout the [FAT ML Workshop](http://www.fatml.org/) and in particular the [resources page.](http://www.fatml.org/resources.html)
A few other papers:
* Barocas, S... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBcFo3TEhYM1FNUXJDTkFqSzRrWmlCTmk4NUFKV01XOVJ4cHlQOWliNlctcERvbnlMOTdPMU42ME5iMWgzeEZ3Y0ZDcFRQWnFPbngwWGlMTmF4MlZaaHc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCamZyUml2cm1xc2VhOUJTVWtid3haQXlkVnd1MDhJTkZjVnN2UGpDVGI1S3lFcGlfWlY1a1JCeFVDd3FNbkh1STloN0ZJQXl6NFVVc001TmpLLVJqd0FoZnV2X1RTREFEM204ejNBV0E4RnhhUmNNS2oxUTJoT2QwZ2F4cnN4TG42b1lnWm5wSXNKRUtJMHNuQ2RQSGE5WlVzU1U3VmZoY2VjYm9IdWZ5a19xc0xGcUFILS03S1d2aFhLZlhfWWo0 |
but what are the consequences of misuse?
that's the factor ppl always seem to ignore...
they will focus on the probability, but even if the probability is small ... when the consequences are large then its still a risk.
| r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNWhZeXp0T1B2RVJuNTZieDlhcjVTMzVRNDFIdkNDcF9Fd2YzOG1sdlVKLVRaU0tjVDNnTk55dGRzWkxBdXJscWNESHVwcHZqVU9VdWF5clUzN0ExVmc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCN3FtbzJDbEJFUG93MklTY2FFS25wbnAzUld0bS1NalV6d3FJa0hwZHBvOFBERUZYR2pFTFhuWTBOcTFPRXZSNkJtNjJsaWYzYmZUSGdaUHJxam9hLUlsMHM2NUlaRllSZEMxal9OTlU3X0xBWVJzRGpzUlRaVFZxY0tiS0M5clAzMGpiMUE1MDBqM1Nfakt1YXpRNE1ZUVVSYWlVVG5QMS1ERFNMbXdCT1FDWmZFNk15LUVLX1MyaWx6Y0NCakJf |
what assurance is there that for whatever human values we would prefer machines to propagate, they will indeed propagate them and not bend them to their own ideas (just like we would do)?
once SAI is loose, none of this ethical planning will matter.
what we SHOULD be considering is OUR OWN ethics in pursuing the cre... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYjEtellObGtUMzVUUllQR2RzLUZIaGk5aFZOLTkxdDBqMmctM21VVGlvMjFSLVFNWGdLM0dwZzB0TV9JUUREMDQ5Mmw5OGhYRUVwR002ZHJWNVJXMUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCaFZpV093M2J1ejJ2SmJieWs2bkFTOHUyN1RvZmw4R2JlaXltNHdnNVdqYjcwVWtoQzBHXzg0MkxNcVV0YnZXX1U3OHp2bUJsSlZwNlNrTkRUeWZJUjZ3dXhBSExMQklYbFhwLUdqM1RReWEzV0JVOUhfS3VMR01pQUYxYnRqSnFSQ0ttOE4yY2R6c25ROE9pRGxMd2Fud1NKeEhaZDJiM1g5QjM5NzhKNkRGQ0VvSzlkaDFINk40MkdVOXY0eE1y |
AIs will only be able to follow the initial axioms we give them, unless we explicitly allow them to edit those axioms. There are concerns about the inscrutability of neural networks and learned (as opposed to assigned) behaviors, but it doesn't follow that none of our ethical planning will matter. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYlJRdGFQTHpDNkJSVmtUeTc4dnpOaE53SG1UY2xyREZIbGlxS2ZSeHdTSVBQR2gwZUNYTTlIaHMtX2dORmI3Yzk0b29JYm5sNkpKMTlySkZPb0JyQkxTOEtCM3BoSi1qaWwwcTAzT2xrME09 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCaXNEb3pONTIyaHJEX1c1d3I1U2J0eUFPcHd0Y1lHcHJ2RE96NTYzZ3ItZGk5ZXAtM05TeTAzRDZGc0JDa0NLT09Bcm9pS1FVcGdGbUNoQVZzVFlzZnBSbGNOTE5PZ2NDM3dJbGdLMVlKbmVfLXRDaDZVY3NtbUtXcTRpSkNrX0NqUlhyUWF1bTQySlV6M2NLWkJDRmlIbzk1Q2lmUklXUXhWTFFyNVlET0JTMTU5SXZxbkliT3RTSUZSUGR0bExJ |
"Suffering" in reinforcement learners is not a near-term issue. Something has to be conscious before it can suffer, or before the appearance of its suffering takes on any moral valence. I feel like its presence on this map takes away from the seriousness of the other issues.
Here is the text of post I made elsewhere ... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBaFZOdDVrbEdSd0xNRG05bEdWdTd6YkxDa0xIRDZGcnprOFN4a1oyaW9SZlhZbGZSaEp3MlFHX1hNRUZZRXNqYUpWek1VTENHZFFfVHRYdGlPOVZxbnl1RmtwX0t2VE04YkozWGZJcTRFMVk9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcVR4V1JQQlBUUklRbTY2R2hOalM3TWlOTWtMZVA0R0dSVFVTM044WldnbmhCcjI5Vkg3UDR5ZF9iLVpJRVZLX3A2QktvYzFONGhZdG9fNWYxdVUySVRyQkVPWXJFTmVMcXZYTVhoVm92eUxqdmRWOG5lY1d5VHpWeWJnLWxtZm02TU9ydnlhTWhYMGdyRVdNeWFHN3Q3M080S1FWZjZZVVFPbWRVak0tT05IRXRKWjJrTm9pN01lQkJoY2g1a3VI |
I logged into Reddit five minutes ago, and I looked to the top and saw
> trending subreddits
> /r/media_criticism /r/pepe /r/JustNoSO /r/**AIethics** /r/totallynotrobots
> 74 comments
I ask for an introduction. What is this subreddit about?
Additionally, I am the 777th subscriber. Woot. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbE5IdlMzc1l0N204OWVlN1FuSGIyTkxfZ2VMOTUxWGxUZHc5UXhWRHZuZGx0ZGZoQ3JZU0VZRjZSSUM1MEpldlJHMzZxNVhXaHdjcUdTZDlxRmRtSEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCbDFpNGlzWjFIX21qeWliTG8yWXJ4VmdhbENtYUlXaHZRQUdXV0tzdnFjay1rR1l6cllnR2tPVTAzeWVndXVJa0Z0ZXdfUjhhVkc0TzVYdmRTRHZldy1WRkhSWWdVbFhGVTNhZEt0Q3EtdEZzLVlhSFQtVHpvQ2Q2NmdPdng5VWFUU28zMGxNc0k0V2lRb2hnSmYwQmxfMmhEaWVWUGdObXk2Mm50dGpaVGZvPQ== |
Congrats :D | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWXBFLV9UTE9hNEF4QS01Mmt0T01VYTZhY2tPUm95ZnB0d3NwZl92SFFBbnl1dkotOVBxenNUc2Q0SFR3TVJNVU5tRGZTb2N3X2V3cmZ5Q0VpTmdIc0E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZzE1R19KSGhPN24zeHBxeWRQRmNnNGdLMVVhQUxUM1Z2bzBUTllwWWota28zV0FSWDIwWk9wd1lZWkxZVy1DSXVrLXFaVjZRWDd6UlRleERIaVpRY3QwZ2M0ZnRQb0N6ZWFWX3V4Tmg4ZEtuZVNLU2hDMWlvUlBheDhSMzZHZmlMTHBvX1FHdEYyYnBEaUt1a2NncnhYTV9iaWVfNENRakM1a0VfYl9FSGUwPQ== |
I agree with most of what you said: we only need to morally consider conscious entities, it seems that the way pain is implemented in humans/animals could be improved upon, and pain is just one kind of negative feedback. However, that doesn't tell us how we should view negative feedback in a conscious reinforcement lea... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYzBuU2Nna3dDaDRXRWZIRXkwNnNLNlRfQTNNSUpleFNtX2I3aWdpY2NHQ2JVaEk2SGdVZTQ2ZG5PWkxWanVpYWZwYXJBdGI0Rm1yOFNHalZVbHI3aUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCY1BXeVgxcDhBbEc3T0RJekI0VjM3NG01clBEeWljUVlrSkhGWDhYWnliWGpmNGI0XzNFcWp5UWFZZWdMaEF4UnEyX3lDMzd5eVlaaFV2eG05QkRkeXcyazNtSlRBTTN3cE5YVnZrMWpLeDlfSVJKTU5qSm5aMjlJalZJX2lvdDU4NklzVUM4aGd6c3ZsZjR1eHBTQkh0SGlCRTF4OVZKbW9uZklsdHJFQlo0Q3AxQnZHa0RTWG53YV9Qd29WcGxI |
It's really about discussing anything related to the ethics of artificial intelligence systems. So, how should we design them? How should they be treated? We want to look at real world AI development and talk about how to keep it safe and beneficial. It's a new area where people have very different opinions and most of... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-02 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYWxSMXk0ZjgySXJQRHV6SHdLaWlveVFGNGUxOHFlbmhIbHlOTlNkYl9pRlhSN1JPaTNuVUQ0WkNUWUc5a0UzVHcxemZrOThISG5SWjhiMlo1eFZmSVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCNXo4ZmZGU1J6QmQxcWtJSVFjMVBCM2ctbEJiSEFXOTl4S0NXa19WUURpLWNXWWN5c2NXdHpxQS1WMmhxUm5hSVd1ZHhGTHFhbUt1VGpJMXJrQWdjZVRwa3hzdFhIRXlsczJMVWUtNTFaYUZtbzR5UW5wdnZsSXFackxVNTJiSzVKVElwZlI5NlJmcFBMS1g0SFpvRkJieHFfOUlJd3A4ZWR5RDkyWUdwbElBPQ== |
> However, that doesn't tell us how we should view negative feedback in a conscious reinforcement learner and to what degree we are ethically obligated to avoid it.
The biological features of pain are, arguably, the main drivers of human morality. The big problem is that pain doesn't cleanly perform the function that ... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNUhZU1lVYWFoLW9LZVZRZDN6M3hjR0ViQ29yczRqWFpiczNiTmd1SkhnUHJyUEEzY3V1bENpMHQ4MDlJb2pyU2hlLUYzdXNUbVBjcjNoNFdMcVFJNDdYN01sY0hBa2RmWkpsVnVVUzA4UnM9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCRHdyRHV5eUplUUVDYWdxb0puUVJ1TGlXUUFlM2RyR25tb0xsQzh1ZjhLNURDRm1VWnpMWTY5S3NpeE9fWlN5WGpzc3AzZHpTekJnMDQydVBKd3BfeWpCS1cyTW9LLVNjT3RnWFRCaXV2UEF6NTBfSkdPUFFqUnFkbzhVY1B4ajdES2RLTm9ueF9tbWY3R09oY2pITjEwSXhNb2VOLTNaNkJTTi04ZnZtcGdSeTI0dHB5cHFFVmdEWUxla19NMjFC |
Didn't I read an article that google is building a kill switch for their AI program? Why do that if the fears are exaggerated? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBMWRWXzhjUlJZTFRNUGNqbHVneUtDUHB4RnpCN1Z5ZTJTSHl5QUtrSU16WUVaX1J4TU5zaFlkYXVhdEdOQ3Vzdy1kZWpVTUdnaVdqam1XT1BlMmJ2cHc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCR2lVLUdFczNrakFlUzVrM2NpOGt1VlFtQXNhd3hEak90aC1XQ2JYSEM5NXdJZUZ3UHVGdlI2MEVQNklQRXNUZVJUb3NYbWhuZF9mLTdYT0xrR0hqSHp1cDJzdERGdVdvNzZNbzZrTnpkZzJjUDZUQXd2akFDX1pRRERPMktkc2pnTGNlSDNodWJvNTZLUkFUSHFKVzhSeFV3R1VjLTY4eW5TSXhhVy1XaXQ3LTNkQ29meW1IQ2tsSld5VTdpdlhJ |
One of their scientists worked on some research on the concept, but it's more intended for future AIs. The systems of the present day are far below the level required to pose a large concern. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBXzVhTXV1Y2VMc211MjVXSXdOZFdMcUo5SDVmYks1R0U3Uzc4aUNvU0Etc3lxQlMxRHY4bDY3V3dmZ1AtaEY1aFczX21peDJZODZrbHI4Ym9vZnNEV3c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZlFlVmRGekg3bTVTQnY1bnVmWkdNZ2lIekhXczdpNXNrSlNjbU5QWGFkY2xiNWZoVnRyZUwwQkFTaURMTGc2aVZHT1BuZzRacVM1SkFKVHQ5QVR1Z0dpclBBLVdhZG0wOGxWY0F2d0swY2hETFczUXA0ckVjendPSGR0Q3VlQUNQTHlNNXpaT05fMGZYLWhodTdfcUpFUmMtR1JER2ZBVnZCd3A4Tmh4TkpIZkN6bDNYb0tRZllCYVF1UmpsbUpv |
Here's the website: http://www.partnershiponai.org/ | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBblBiNUlyX09IbTYwQlR0YXo3U1JrQ2JMcFdWMEtpV09NOWlzbWF4UExsZUYtUUxrdXA1UXp2dTdVVzZScVpiV0JETXFOOHV5c0NqTl82OWdLQnBaMUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMm56N3VVUW9pSS11YlBRaWVBY3hfd1E1T1NubDZhSFZOT2tzODluaXl2c1F3X0t1ejAwX0NpRTNWTFF0VnJxVGRCcXRVNUJ0azFLTk5qdjFwNDZBYkE2b3FqaHVKaWxUaHhiWWdhWjEzYUxBcU5lMWlmWUlVMlp4MlB2YjU1UnlwSFhmcG1tMk92LTExZ0ZuM1JRS3M5U0h3QXU3ZmlzM2lhNktEZnBiZHozdXJZd1BvYnlOb184aTlDUGdzUzM4aFZvXy1UOWEtSVB0cnZjYkdnQ2FFZz09 |
> AIs will only be able to follow the initial axioms we give them...
for now... but this does not address what happens after AI achieves consciousness and become SAI.
are you saying we can prevent that ascension limiting the ability of AI to modify its own algorithms?
how would that work in practice?
how do you ens... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBNE1EWnQ2SE5QRU50ZmZCdTBCeVYtamFlVTNMdnl3bFRlSGJjbHcwdUxMcmRaMDJXWVR4eFBmMHJhOG9NNUxBWkRORWJ5QjNBQ1lSb2h1RDhTZURRaGc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYjJaNnV0aHRXb2EzTERUQXN4ZGF2dkROV1d0bXdvNmZ3OG0wLVQ2M1FnNkFBT1BxVC1DaDFSOGJDa2RfUEVsdmNsZzVmTkRhczhqaHI1Y19YeEg2QmJCbTNzNzd4WVRwcVNJUWQ5ZGVsd3ppUk1WUHA4V1F6RkxzaGR4UHJiOGY1cl9Sa1E1enFQRlhRczhFU0FvUndmMzdBNUJUbWhQOHN6YTcxaEY0Y2p2UG9tQnVWUnJ0M1NhWm9aV2FTXzVZ |
Because they're really freaking useful. For a topic that will become pretty big in the next couple of years/decades, consider self-driving cars. Humans are *really* bad at driving. We get distracted, we get angry, we can be physically impaired (tiredness, drunkness, etc.), we have slow reaction times, etc. Now imagine... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBVmp0SnI4X1h1M0QzTHpSaDRMZV92UUM0TDhzTEs3d3pQSFlPbzcxLTk1QUR1ODNCVV85aFd3UFhmcVNnX202cHA4S3RSb1V4M01DQzYxd240QzVESHc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCV1R5VHBHTVhfTVdpX3B6bHdLMVkxMERtVUp1VEZyWTBIM3pPVXJzeFJvbWc2V2g2dTYxRTdjbnZ1TzFXMWo2bk1EN3ZIUkZSdTZOQVJtcVh3eWg5TGdBMHJPc0RQLW1MbmNpZFk4dXhUcnNMNnFnYjBsOFUwTkFYdS1JVzF6YU5mbjlxeFZMZ0I4ZHFPUFQzSnprOGlDVGdZWlZlOU9KZGRna2Z0bEpmNHVudGEwUkJ3Y0VoaWU4LVl2WjhuekVz |
> are you saying we can prevent that ascension limiting the ability of AI to modify its own algorithms?
I'm saying that all actions an agent takes are based on motivations, and all motivations are derived from core values. No agent can logically derive from its core values any motivation to change its core values. Cor... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBN25MZDhKUURmVXY2dmtONUM0ZC14LWgyRnVxVUx0Y1ZacE8weFBxd3JzOTFES2FYOUpWYWlyd2czNHEzTWp3MWp6WlhPZUVHajNzazZRRzl0THNRdnctWHUyWTk0dy1LYVRNbWEzOWFGMGs9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCemVSa2lRSG9TUVVHbm9KbEwtNzI4czMzc3F2TFkwY0hBemZGRFBIVWxPZ0JLbjNKWEVKXzVuYXpnLUJjdXF2cFFBVmFoTGhWQ0JRcXVLUl9xNVpQWGpsTE5TRW9zSnYwMjhlY3NkdEk1dzI0WVBqU21ISW9MLU1teXFRQkpyRGU0TUZWWXZ2X2x5ZGVtRC1yenRjS0x1R3I0UlZLQ0hHeEM0MXI5OTlTdDc5c0lJR1BCd1liOHQ4STk4dzJwNnV0 |
> I think the kind of risk you are thinking of is one in which someone gives a powerful agent the wrong set of core values...
Quite the opposite. The risk i'm thinking of is when the agent DECIDES to ignore those "core values" as something separate from its SELF and charge off on its own ideas about things.
We will n... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBV0UzOC1LZVRXbmVJSk9Nb3M1Y3lOYUt1dkZYM1ZxckJDMHVVTl81NTk1Ym9UaTFLSjFQX043SmhkbUdHd2wzT1ZvMkxIRGluRDlGTnN5NWhjVXZZYXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCc3dkVEVRMlN6Ri1aRXZwblAxS1g4ejR4OF9JVGpOcUxNSE43UmljSGZ3eWJjYTVEcVc4azh1MEU5VHY2TUpKMGlfbk01OWwweW9UN3VJWUpJaEFmX1MtSHk5U05wempBXzFBVzVTdWxfblZ1eWsteUdZcTlxdzBfQjUxZkJRb2hvM3NfOHA1RHRYNEtYaFg4NW1BOWNIeVAwa0E4NmZLYzZPUTJxRlI2Y0NlWVZTNXpDOGxrOUNfQk56Y3lDS2p6 |
> To presuppose some idealized and 'neat' behavior on something as inherently messy as conscious thought, is... well, quaint.
It kind of depends on what you mean by consciousness here (and whether you are necessarily referring to a chaotic process). Computers and programs work in an orderly fashion. Their products can... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYTRNR3JJUE9xNlljYWNqSFJxbFl5RndXY0h0a1k4dnhCU09ER2tKLUhVZ3pPSzVsS3VfZTlFYkoxaXBJSDQwTjZBekpJZ0ZPTW42elFYaEpUWHI3SDVQTjQ1MC1KQ21yQkt1dndrSTJMT3M9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCQXhsQXdncHRhUjMzVE5vUEx0ZjAxakszLTl6VHJSOVNhemthaC12bjh4VExNcFhWcGZvTkhOb2RxQkVOOEhCVURYQVItdGJra1dnTUx3NUJTNnBKZGVKY05MOUpOMEJna1JUQWxnVmRnWkJIS2EyclhiZkR4UHdxRnJlSXQ5TDRxVUR3SlNrd3lCMHBDT015SW44Ql94YldhRld4T0tvczRuTTRfZVI4eTI1UGh3R1h4X1NUVTNpd3Mway0zeE43 |
> Negative feedback to a reinforcement learner should, in the absence of an explicit design that makes it otherwise, feel more like changing your mind about something rather than experiencing pain.
>
That seems like a rather odd analogy. Changing your mind involves *you* making an active change to your knowledge or p... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWUxWdVpQOWlod1V4UWlDdXhSTHJvem5OckpDNmh6MXRDdjQxWnFySk9VQnVRYkdoNy1CbEZzZFlZWk80MV90Y2hTOVZKZlR5cUpKdXhsaG9MRmtJeEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCdTIyZk9GRWs4MHJTYXlHako1NTNmdUR3VG5sSkRHTGZwWEpEb3hmSEtvSHVLaUIzQjFUbXlZSFFtU1FoYXZoYVVDS2doNEtLOWZEYjVtY2FiamphZ0dVQkktT1l6aFpqS2hsblFBOW1IVDRtUmt2TW05dDVoa29oMWl6VzlfT1I1R2lTV040bHBCa3FsWWh2aWVzS25ubnBfZXpRWEw2M3RoU0NGX2NaTzV6VlhldjQ1bGV0UXFwbjhFRGs0MVli |
Here's the website: http://www.partnershiponai.org/
| r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBaXd5WnFsb2pIZ1ljd2ItZjJEdVBWVXBYRkQzLWoyY3ZpdjdpcUFTdWI0M0ROQS1aWXpYOTh1cElHSVdpdkJpYlNnM0xXQ2pjeDFvQ2w5RlNDX0xOYlE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCUUM4QXFITmpiSlMwNGQ0V2dfb1R5Ui1DRGZQdE5za0JTN083VF9xNHg0bjR2Rmt4N0RrcTM4dEJmV2NyV0xOcWxzZFFlT3ZGbEZSR1Fibkk2U1R5QWRFT1k3aEpGU0ZpbjBKdHlFTTZiendvNEVsM0NLR2QtZDJFRXNyem1YN05uTFdMOGpUMy1QRXdDZ19GY0lRdmFIN05ybHZ4M2E0VlhmQjVqdnlyVnpfbEprTnp5ekdqbkVJbEp0VmFTM09yVTZvNHYxWXRoVDktcmcwQ0NfemUxQT09 |
> Computers and programs work in an orderly fashion.
This is true... of computer programs and weak AI agents. However, there are ppl working on Strong AI with the goal to break free of this constraint and introduce the chaos that can enable consciousness.
> That would be like deciding to defy your own will. How cou... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBcGR6MTRIMXduQnRRSDVVMTFPQ2NaVXBpZEdCUHNRY0N1V3hLclJxS1lCNmtKRy01bF9vU0Ytcm16UVViQTNyYWJYQ2s3c1ptMGhKSHltQTBwRDBKcnc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCekFIVWpVLWFpbWNoRV9ldWlhVFpDRzlkaEFxek44OEZUT1J5djg4UGhkdGRBMjdEVlFydDVCeGdmX05pbTl1M3RrbDFQYjFZaFdXYS1zemE0cGh6UHY2RmlhbDMzU1FUWko3b2UtenFWYjFQazFJVkgxaEREQ1pqY0Itb0daaUpPZW44ZEtWREg0VkpNQld1MF9EY3Z5ZG1RMkd5M05sdU5sbmtLOUZHamNONTVtQ0JZcG45ZXVOWFNUUHNDekpy |
Cynic in me says they're only doing this to make sure that the government doesn't step in to regulate them. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-03 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZFRaLTVkbFZzcHlnRGxkZk9VOFpuY1AySUJJcFBRRzQ2NlE2MG9yaGduWlVKUldfUTFBYlJmNnBiUlVqUGJDbWFUVnZQVmh4NUVnVnNSSDZBTVpET2c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSy1NZnFUaC1UZG15WG9hOFhoRmZnYkJlNEh2U3JFdEZzcnRJSnY1cWdqWGJ5UkV0VDlEYVdqMnZVTV9RelhUX3NvQnBpVGZTMzVpOU13MjQ0ZEtkd0VxLWNxWlN2OTR6MVdkMzRCT1FTdHhNN1hqcUw3S0JmUFZtSmswU0tNVm5JNUdwbmdFRkMtS0V6WG9EclBxQ2NsNFZFZnh1ZXBJVXdWZHE2ay00MmYyTHZhN1VIZXZnd2xlYlpQV0VHVWJqSDJoMHJYQ0JOdGdHYVkydENLVU5ydz09 |
SAI will not be developed by one these guys... because there are other actors working on this problem who are not signing up to be "self regulated"
SAI will likely emerge from the financial sector. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbFUxdHFNOFFkcm1ITWhFblp2R2tuY0hKV0g1NDI1VXJOY2pZZHpHLXppaGxDd0NJZmliRTJRSHlnb3VZQWNNUzJILVFKTHpPdFdIUDJ5ZzNQUV9zVGc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCbEVoS0taTlhET3FEb09CWGRNdXo1dWplU1ZoeEkyVHlQYllnZGlPX2ZGNi1CdkY3dzF6c3FRQU5fRk05M1Y0ZmNlRWlKQkxOaC04UjJORmp1TDlsZDZaRE1IWlpTc0JfYU9aRE5CaUJhc3dBWnV1UzdkTnVOT2RCWlhfMXJ3Ym95ckNMWVV3NUE4Z1BVdHFDQjVTTWN1MldDUl9nU01EVVB2VFRIcEJKa2pzaFc2c2pBM2hEYWFWdEMySFhsNUZMcmJMYnR3bXZ0T1Z1dHpEN3BxMWs3QT09 |
> However, there are ppl working on Strong AI with the goal to break free of this constraint and introduce the chaos that can enable consciousness.
Strong AI doesn't have to possess consciousness. Consciousness has been argued to be a continuous process that feeds back into itself, causing it to be chaotic (chaotic in... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBa0dhQVd0bjk0RTlrNTFYcGpLX05DTElCc004Nm9CVkRUNy1sa09HSEp1cjJodnFuYXVTY3VZVDhEdTkwOHZQYlJUMDM1T040TVdIRlpTRXJtanEzTlRCSmlMaUVCWlo3WVdjZmdhVlZSZFk9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMXRiUjlVOGhSTF9SNkRlSlRqZk1HeTBNVGx0V0hEbEpWZlBBeE8tMk1PVmJoS1FUeHZHMnZwaUJEX1NlQnJaNVU3N3k0S3ZyaGFkSGc2b1Ztb2NxTHRqbEdIV3NxcF9qUlBwSzd2RU1jcXpsU3pwbWtqaHpLbDl5dGxKZUZ2aEdtZHdKcW5OOHBlLTVPeWlySmF2bXEtZzNOVDVoaDk1OWJjZzlkWmhsNU9kQXNENndwVjN6UTN0QlBmbnNTUHhT |
Well you can't really create such an organization that actually has any teeth. Not unless you get every single major player 100% on board. State actors at the least (and probably anyone else who thinks they have a serious advantage) would never sign on for outside oversight. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBd29zYVk5U0NvTGJVRHU5enVBN05kbEVKUENpYm1mSGVKaUhkaFdrTnI3S3duQVdrTmFYWjRpM0VnOVBJSDRPd2ZzWnV2V2ExRXlQd0FPWEw4WE1IelFsdk53eG5XQXNHWnREaXFIZ1l1Wmc9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCY2JlemloN1NQLXR3TXZGSXFaN0g4MUZfVEdTZEx5QjhXRmhTbE9qQWJ1S19RVzhtZTFXSjRWNjU4ZXN4TkEzUjVNeFVyNTN3bFZRVVhwaW0zZWpTeUxVVnp3bUMtRTFKQlBVdk90VnJLZmhTZkFVb3FKSlA3QzM3MWI4R3dfTktFY1lweng2R0JhT0xPOWIwcXd1bEZQLUcyVC0xdDJLQ3JZaXowbXVIYlJmNWMyNjNiS0pBb3pBTm1VMkowSnVWUFByVThISklxczlqeGpQNlYyYlZrdz09 |
SAI is a number of decades away, I don't think we can easily predict who will build it. But if governments understand the strategic implications then they will likely nationalize/take over the strongest programs. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYTNnUS1IbDZ5eE5tT2xtZndJa3RjQnRxUktsMGNaOWtiSkhVQm1DaXRGcHlKanlPbUtBdEp5V1pVVWpycHU0dnhvQmdLMUw3MUZpaEdBQmk0R2RlRXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCUXV0RTFQSFJYRjJRQ3l2ZExfamZYMUYtTURjZWNiaEg0TkcyUlY4UHFrVTFLZ0FHNlc2dE1WRmlfQkxpQUVlTnFGLUZqUFFDYzVFcV9JZ201aFJWVTdjUTlqU2ZQLXpOWk1zODNjUnFWdlB4VXYxTVJ3WGd0Qml6clF1eU9CMjVVZG5PdDh3cW05MGJ4TTU5aHdiZXZJV0p2OE5PVEd3eWhmNjRjdEd2NVE2MHc3MFRtd2RkWUhTYnQtaTFDeVN0ZzkzQUh5Y2UzdDVlYVBvRTJTSi0tQT09 |
Something tells me that if Musk hadn't given 10 mil to the Future of Life Institute and helped found OpenAI, none of this would be happening... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZ3QzQjZpREJTMEtKSVRSSElqRHRZTUlPZlVNSXNZcWxnRXZMOXd2Wi1UeXZnMDRZaWd1SlpFT3lSTi1mY09jc0pOUW1nNUJfUXlrQUtpYlZFMlFvTXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSE5sZk9fS3VIZTZibVREZjJILWVYRnhMRFFLM0dLZHpkM2dmVk8yZUVoOGpVTFZYMzFhVXY2b0IxQzJwQzZPaFlJNXN6ek1lOVN5Qy1oRWpqNmJvY3BBU1l3Vy0ySFZpVFZlSU5PUGhnN3d2VEJSaGw3MjZIMXFWam56VzZyTW44TWIzb1JjcVdGY0plU1d5WHpjTTR5dFJIeWRsQmdaVmdySVJLTzJBWUdyc3dRTFJfMG5xUlB2R0U0VTFZYmRJdHYtOFVTbXlYMmI3Rk9rTk5pdERCZz09 |
Hilarious story! Is it a real story or did someone make it up? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZ2p6UnBWMnVHOVI0UEYzRHJ1RWwwZGxJSkJEMmFRUFFBMkRjUWZubXM1NFdsNWt3eTdEWS1YY3VKSDRBeUlVU0Jtcll5X1NIaUEtM1cybGNqTUxVUWc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMTBaOFBRbmFEX2E1SVUxSm5Cb2ZBdWZLNWVac3pzVnY2SWttY2l1SGdMemtpNjhvUUFGeHF4eF9oQTRDTlBMamxNcWNZdG1tWFdVS0N0OEpLUXJ5SmhVdWhuNjJCamY1aVlyNGpCQkQ4R2N2RGtUX2MzQTNDYXIyVm9hV25kNzNjYW94Y19qdm9KbjRpamZuUzhaNXRvNjdzM2pPaHhyRU44eUsxWVdxWVE0anFNQ3UwY2JIREt2Qmt3RDk5azBVTGFjcjlQNll2Q3pGU0YzdFVQc3dqUT09 |
Yeah it's satire heh | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBVVZvVmR6Ml85eXNrd0lNaVVaRDhVTjdpN2F4RjdBZGdZR2x6VU9iSEVaa3U3Ql9rVk1MT3psS0FPbGZJbk53TTVMN1RnS3BLZ1daM3J0MDkwbFFpOEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCOGxvdVA4YWhTbF9VSnNhcmZpZENVb1REMVNmdDVIWkhyYWktVUQxbS1vdGV6blVHU1g0Yzk5RWpPaGVUa0RzbGRnUmREVE1yM3BrRUl5UmlvR0JpYW1pTm51SnRwY0x5elpST0I4bE9WaktjZE5GcWhkdGFaaXlDQnJyaVpJcjB0SVB1bGZOanAwSmxUYWpVNUhxSEhBME9tb0w5V3ZZTEVyMGZhcWVSbzhHQ1ViMy1tNWdMUTRZaXlOdWI2b0Rfamd0LVFFcHp4NzhCeVF4SFdPQWNOUT09 |
that's what I thought, but actually it could happen........ | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-04 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBOW1yTVJpcWhTdW5haHNxeTFVQkpOeXdrUDU5RVdTWkRyQTJ4bjN4X0xSWkU0Q2NaeVZ5ajdUY2pKZFFYZWNOcDliOE50WlJQM1pyTE4wOVZyeXpzaWc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCN3A1MXNxWlFUM2VRRmJCOUdMNVFMN3QzcUlhVGZhN2RMbUJ4X0xZaktCeE14QkRmZGJxVmRfS2JjUEU2UjYzWVFiM1VlMHNDVUxQLXhsZ2RuWTctRE9RMk1XU0E4T1hnZ2VZWExkMmRGN25qZnRVY1YybDdKOUI1bWo5dS0wN3JKVnhwMWl2SlJzeVhlVEIyMi1BT0VWZEVPVWdwVWJLc1ZZYTJ0V0ZlVnhkODhpZDYwc0gtS1RQMU1saWRRQ2JhaE1xQVNXZDU3cmR0MDdSRVhOMW1UZz09 |
> I don't think we can easily predict who will build it.
nor can we easily predict that its decades away...
my point was that we CAN predict that it will not be one of the groups who have signed up to this 'pact', since it puts them at a competitive disadvantage to everyone else who is working on this.
the reason i ... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbGNXOUpWVmRzXzk3cVdxc0JoMUw1SDA0ay1EUXdCWU5waU5YZFhpVkkzTHBOWHBlX1JqaGFZWlJoeGl4SnVIckJZekJmZEtPNjIzQ0I2ZFlKVlZUclE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCN1Z5MFYta0xwWVRpUThFMng1a1BoSnl6aEl6Y20yWEQ0N2pZNFVlMW9zMmRWM3o3UzAydlo0RWprai1DUFo4MW5JNklLbjJtYXlxSHFJa2VkQzZfRk1oU2NXYmR6TWhHeER5NWhUbU10S2hPdkY4SGpLZDgyb2tlQjd6WFdMdGdLc3V6Rl8xY0lTOUN4eXIzZWNWdEpteXhZLTZvV19IXzk0QjluX3llRWxOTUN5N3Jrck1TTUdrUmdvaFRvdDlFWTBCMDNMeGZYZGFGUzFTSjFncWNqdz09 |
>my point was that we CAN predict that it will not be one of the groups who have signed up to this 'pact', since it puts them at a competitive disadvantage to everyone else who is working on this.
But they're not slowing down their research as far as I can tell. They're just investigating ways to make their research g... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBMERmbHhwYlh4MlRtOEQ0WW9DUzJzb25MWFhBWTMzWlFxZk81cDREMERzRlhzMjJnVi1aTFRTZER1NnJKZlI4RVItSUE1YlRMSjFBYTAzS2Z0cFJiQkE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCbU8zeHVSZDNYdjBGSmk0Y3Q3bGFxN1ZXT2Y1UzNMakMwTDVfZkhhRWswYXp4Vlk5Y1N6b2ZYY0JsYllUN3B2MFgyQTBCc3dWSEYyUTc4T1ZoeS1HbllueDBTeGFibmRzVkF1YlozMHd3dnF0U3paZGFmS0FfZDNRT1prRnZ6X2RUY2FUaWpfZFlZRmZ4TUE0eU05VFZWOVBXOVVNSmhkS3piREFGRS1Yb2NVUmNST0xxLXk5U3o1NjZoU3cyc2ZpaktpQmtBZllwMy12eXd4aXA3d1c4UT09 |
Eh, I think that's not the case, based on what I've seen/heard from these guys and the government. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBU3JlMW9CaHE1UDhSbzR1ZU1xa3BackRBU1FDdFp1RzNFMVoxRGh5YmkwN3FiUmE1Vi0wbGhjQjZneW15QWFpTWZmeTAtNWExMGh2a3NCU2xlYU5kM3c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCTHMzQXRUYnBrZHBYXzRxOTJRUHF6d1Vpc1F2MGVZeVppQWU3aTBlZ281SnhUZWxLUlVsWThJSWxheEg2d3N3VWF1R1ROMkZLZXBuaEUzTkZGcmlVYkU3ZlFrVEp1UEMtcHRPcDF1ald5dmEtSURZZkJhdEo3dEhfalkza00zak9jaTg5aGNxR0IySEg3dXdPVmpBSEFMbFFzdlMwNTVhYzN1WnRSOWJEbDhQeVdSWGRHTUFOZDZrUTdHZmVMV0NrMDNidFRoSWhJcXBhcEprWjczb1lTdz09 |
this part keeps sticking out...
> they will derive their own "will" exclusively from their programming and from no other place.
are YOU also limited to where you can derive your own "will"? Others may try to tell you what you should do, or how to behave... society, religion, peers, etc... but do you let that limit yo... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBS21SdnlZT0lFRXRGdDZVTDBwc3prUGcwTzRFZmd2WDAybXdmcEdwZHhCUkxUVmRwdWVWSzlVeXBjOEk5cDREeHRKS0tIU2dCakh2bnVsOGxnQ0g0aGc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCdWcwRDBpdTNib2RwbjFJMXc1aEoxSU9hY2tTTzZvekFFUW9EWmhKSFRZSWE4MXdnYkpyaC1Db3BvRERtUWlNcGZGVzM4ZUx4U0xSVmVod0w5ZFNnZ29PWTJSNlV5alUwTmFCUWdiWFByWUFLcDdDV0l6M2dnVndBcVRKM0MySDVPRlZibkxrdWl6WFBWcjBXeElQTFBtMFloM1FuZ19MSERGV3NjVUpCMHJOMnhyUi13N2pwZFdIRUZIcDZROURf |
> this would prevent programs from having delays and negative PR from accidents and controversies.
key word being "public".... see my previous post.
and 'poaching' is a thing.
| r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdW43Vnlxamp5enJuM25rRExOY1dSbEhIdC1XSTJ3UU1jQ2F4Nm45T3gyRERPN1VLa3pkWUpFV0ZrZ3AtRUZvSmtLVmMtUUlPQkVrOUwtb1RWalNhY2c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCNWZvcFd0Q213aVowUnM0WkNJaWoybVl6T2F0ZWFNazJPRnBwbjJaWnlDNXMwdW1ZYTBEQzFTdzBOOERweGxaSXM1akNORHZ3MlhyTHNzX240VTNCdk5zd05DTVQxLVNSMDVQd0lYdkNYMnJGZS1WTU5OMTNmZFdyemM0MzkzZkVJazFWdFZmejR1akMwN0d2S2tjMzd4Y3FsYmgyMlByMGliczVOSGY3ZXBuVEJ2dUFZUzZfNjg1RjNwNmdwR29sMWIxUVJPNXotQWg3MWVQdXg2TldCdz09 |
> are YOU also limited to where you can derive your own "will"? Others may try to tell you what you should do, or how to behave... society, religion, peers, etc... but do you let that limit your free will?
Programming a computer is not like "telling it what to do." You aren't giving it suggestions, you are defining th... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBcnhER3lRMElXQ1ZEcHJyUllIbS1jdHEtX1RKSTVQc1pRYlNiaUl1T0ZZMXVpMk1oOWdwMWN6aFhyWWY5cHFWVHh5MU5BQ3ZpejZ5bTdjWlRTV0wtSHFfNTdKdTYzeTZvU2NLNFk2Umt4RGM9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCdTIzeXNscllBTFRaMkdTMmtfc09ncUx1b1E0bEgzWEFMcDFmN0hIZElOMzY4TmhOc0tzdkN6ck1WbEhkblFfNmxmckNzVjRBQ1lHZC1ra1d1dndDc1BpeGJ0YVR6X2xBWWtULUlTc0J5RTlHc2FHckYwQm9HbEE4MGtjVnVzbG5Ha2c5bnRyTGwtN05rOUNmckpoVndQQ1pOamtfVkdnMEQwUy1EUVMxZnBXR3NMN1VqdWdXT2czNFVYZEQwQzVi |
> You aren't giving it suggestions, you are defining the core of its being.
ok then, define the programming you were given. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBbjdhZjVncDFuVnF5Ym84MkIwdW1ta2pyWXpVLVU0anctZk44ZjZ1RHh5Tlk4bTVMQk1VSUctNkNhMlVybFdfdGZiTHBmYzBCdWpaMWM4ejRzQXBsNVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSU5YMjhtZFY2LWxvZ3AwS0g5ZWkwRzg5cVZQR2J0RHBGeF9uYzJyWEo3VHhzQkZCNDhRQ2ExNzE5TVZxVndkVWswV1BiRVV2d2FUZTNEem0wOXBEVzVkdDc3cXo4dzB4UUNtc0xFQ0pYRElHU2Z1Wlprc3ZJeG5SMXJfekFZb2xqNUgwRGtxOTVTalpjei1SY0JJd3RhaUZTeE1zcDhHQmhSeV9XaHc3WDFYNzhJUDhDNzZPdDVmS1ZmeUpFRm1o |
I just did. My genes. Can't change them, can't work outside them. They define what I am capable of being. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWm93LXpJaDY1amQ1VVZoUWpMQnlHcHRYbms2UE9KYi1pay1ZNFYzYW5Ja25KYnZqX3N2QlliSFpsREZudXhOTmdWUkJjbENvbFlEdXZDbXVOT0pqb241UGNVT2s5NVdlTXdBaFJjWWRORXM9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMS1YcU9fOWduRkRjYXh0X2x4VzNQSXRtZ1hOa2JzOWRFSnZqQ00wY3BGNVhPRUNaQnVkdGZuNHhzYnBvUlhoS295dkJGYVZocW9TYkl5a1p1X3Mybjc2eHlnS3FoMDRON0YxY2NIa29jeFY2SlFadm5EaXRINUxpWTI0Y3VoN1VxYy1WNVdMRUcycnowb1lqZ1BrTTZLVDZIRnkxS0Ewb0l5cFlVRXR4aWZvUHpXT3lybVpuWXdpc2wzSXpJSVQz |
so because they limit your "free will" to be a banana if you want to, that means SAI can't choose to ignore us or kill us?
that seems fair. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBS2VPWjZDemtCdi1LTzRzSmZuQjA3WTY0X3RxNW9fRVRYRE94dWwxb3lsWWE0bEFrUUNWZ3Nsbl9yUXBOZTEzcExoU3Z1alVObGJYTWhWeEJnNGY1X2c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCeEhhYkxSN0V2X21KcTJOc1B0SDdCaE1sUnJwWmRYVnhxMHJUWVdiYkxCamQ2OUxiOUpwWWtsYUJmLW1td1RuYXd0UWQweVYycDNkV180UHRXUnBRYm1OeEdaMWNUOWJOTlJ3ZGFqYUxxdkdDcU1qNEVWXzhfVnc4eTFnRlZGdUVvOGxlTjczZHVGcHRVNmNHZm9NLXlKLVZ2RURkUmhrNEYtUERhNTdpZFZxWW9SSnR3VGJXckJ1RGc5b195TzJ5 |
> SAI can't choose to ignore us or kill us?
I never said that. What I am saying is that if an AI kills or ignores us, it will be because of the way that we programmed it and not the sheer fact of its sentience or whatever. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZnFKRGdreGN1OWwtajNvVjJyX3ltZm9rSXdVS19fanpsdWhHWENBX2VJc3NPVmh3bW1BNTR3UXFoWHhQajNzVUU2UXhmZk1vMkV5WTl6R0pwanRiSWF4NkJZSkRjSUNyT2tDb2lQZGZyWms9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCaWsxZ0N2OFB6ampKeGQxbC1wdDdQRXBFTTZVTXBjUmxCTE9zZ1p5NlJWQ2YxdnMxQThJRVdsb19NSWZtRkJhQVU1TDlPZzdxVnJ0a0NRemZMcVMtNXo1aHR4VU1ua2U2RXVuUjF5X2VvUlZma0Y1Um9lUDhrbjZCeXdKa3dVLUhNazhNN0JNSFpEbTNGUktGX2JfNzlVeFZOTm1ZRVBZQ2FmNUd0bG5jNjBNYWpuRmFRUlN6RkZxNngwQjI2Q1lV |
i think you have far too much faith in our ability to control something with a mind of its own. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBRFBYcWNEYXJwRXRCX0oxN3lRWV9CcmtZVkdob3Qyd29HYTZZMXF6bW9iQmoyOGdLMlZkM3ZnTjZyMW03R0dQSXphYlo2OEgwbEVGWFVHSUxobXlhQUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZHZ4N1hQVm02bVQ5eThDMjBPRWlHU1Y5eW1ZMGoxbG9ib01QTE8xSmhCY2JER0xvd1hUQjItVm9jVG1EVUh2ZlNoY2RsYUF3eUdNYWtmTFAxaDdRSkotV1BXdHVZYVdEZzBIMFBBeUhmeWJyU05wcEdnRDRBU3FfM0FScG13TUxBWUFDTXFjejQ4M1Vod2FpMGktemhtRDBUYVVhM2JNdmFlYnY3NXZ0SnBPSjZ3bVpLa08tR1Ayc1pXLU5UdlVQ |
No, I just have a clear conceptual understanding of where algorithms come from and how they are able to operate. To be clear, I'm not arguing that there is no control problem. It is incredibly hard to program a computer system that will always make what we think is the sensible choice. That doesn't mean those choices a... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBTVMzOUhmR296eXRITDh1VVN5N005WEJFLUNVQUZsd1ZqelItel9tcmcteWRyQ18ya0hLQVlYclpheFZtVWZyVkRwQVp1MmdfT3RjSU5Kb3pCekpfNXBveFE4MU1tc29fMk1JTDdaZTVZRzQ9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcUlZWFJ3N3p6ejMzNUlWNEhraWp3bzF3dEFaZW1LcGtZNi14UlBSU2Y3QjQwWVIwR0J5MWxTTWNOWDZZbThPaXNJNEtOVGZWakVNeGI2X3Y5R21nWVZpZVpTeXZpZ01Sdms3Tmx3bkowUjlEdGRhMlNhUWk3YTVwSE14bHpJTHRqUzBSSVBzV3RZaG1xbXNsYk51dGFvSnRuUW84NWMyOG01VVlsQmpfRHlKdWg2NGhEVnkybjhvd2xZbF9zdVBp |
How do one get access to the whole paper? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBX2FtYlBYWXEtMUtLWWd1UDdXTFBXNzl1R2RCU0V6QU9rU19Pb2RYRWZ4dFN4UTRqSFd6c21iaGdpamJkeURmblZKZzdlRVdQMm9kTWlJR2NTXzYtUmp4ZDJlcV85T0hJZTNLeTFMaHJZX2M9 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCTnZIRzFRTERES3ZJYU8tN1M3UGZjUHJ0UWExQTRhNEVzczVKOWZHckp3YjVzZVpHUlRXNTl2VURBOE9KTS1DN0lFUTBDTVpicXZ4VnNTRGs5Ykt0TnhmdzlqNFpZOXFsVzc4V0cwZ3VmNm9XUFhYeGQxZnFuU0tOcHB6UE1RZ3FOWnB1WlFDdExVVU1zeFNyaGRMeXV0TDE4R0VRZ0hnUXZveS1PZHBkR1huOEtiOUQ5aTdSNkEyTlBkZC1McW5NNWpkQ2E1WnJaTHlSR3VyX2JCZ2w3QT09 |
> That doesn't mean those choices are being made according to some mysterious criteria that are derived from somewhere beyond its programming.
When ppl talk about AI in terms of a "black box", that is EXACTLY what they mean.
Your conceptual understanding the the "glass box" is all well and good, but when the output f... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-05 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUk1jd1h1Q1NQX0dsVkZXc0t1bDEtTDFQQzhQc2UwdWdBblRNQmtSZk5fbnUyam9zbGEyam9XRGFpdW4zZmJ1U3o3Y1BjWEtTZnNMU0tQb2s0MHpadXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCWGpQUWJ4bHJLd3IzRGdEa2pkWk1tYkRPcHJqUGNDMWZSQ0plOVNSMUtvRzRlNDl5MjNweWhfUlpxRjA4UnRUYThqZWpxekgwaEhXYTJiQ29IZFZDc0JUWjlzamJ1aS1yazA1SzRCMlJ4c0pCMm5NQ3ViMDZ5SlA2alMyU0dHaHlOckp2Tmw1XzMxU29jR2dEMks4S2dVVHE3V1ZFUlJSb3RnRDBLdEhUZ1RSYVdySUhCOEVZMXc0Q3pGTGVBMEtI |
why don't we ask the robots? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdVFaWGh5Y29menlqRHdMaDV2TTVEOU4zY3U2dmtkYXhUcXdVek1PaElNY21xZjhlQ1E4UFNlanhpMVZFV2g1V29FVE9MTEFZZnJ4SU1UYzRsLXc2LWc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCeHNSMGJWcjVNTU9RT2V0YWItUFlONGhpdEZyMkVDaVJBTU01UThabzN4dnloeGt5cGZXb3VkVFdteDA3RmNRam91ZTFFZ05weEg5b3hUVlR5SENET1I2NlZMcGFNU3FPamc2RjRwYUZvVEctdDR5Qk8zMU5yQjhOUWdydnFRQ2pSOElKdlptRUNtSGJ2X3FRZDgxLTRFcEZyX1JIR21kWXlEb3FULXNraDgwVWZEWldJdHhqYWFCMjdJTk9SeE5mWUxiU3p6eTlpUVJYYm92TEpEb2E2Zz09 |
I'd written a few paragraphs, but instead, I'll try to keep my post short. A robot might incorrectly guess that a soldier is a civilian or vice versa and spare or take a life that it was not supposed to. Using a robot to kill humans violates the three laws of robotics, if they're even still relevant. At this point in t... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBeEp5TEVzZzZQSjByd3JxQnA5LVBEOFVtTHVHZno3ZlV3YlB2eEdYZ2ZwMk9ySnE5ZmtQWmEtWGdoSHA3VVkxN2I1SUR5VVB2TmU1dzR2RXNkN1k3WkE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYXUtaElLZ3p5dEVMenozUGloRVl1RnVjMmxJbGExR1JkZjI2eTFvTjFWQzdIaTJCZDYwbE5aRWFMODV1VWxDUENza3RDeTA3SXQyVHhuSTJ4MGptVlpfWUtfZjEyQmVUVWsxYVg3dnlLSEJud0RKWlQtZFRRX2pGSDI5bkV3Y05ud1hic3lGWG5NbjdBUEpuTG40TURFZkxaMkk0Y2F6amxyNmQ0bnNSOFBlVVZPTjZ0V0E3eXVHSVhNd1R5OFF6YkFXRjhqVjlpMDRVRWhMMC15MktvUT09 |
I'm split on this. If soldiers are replaced with robots, there will be fewer combat casualties from war. However, the reduction in cost of war may cause nations to go to war more frequently. If this happens, the total number of civilian casualties may increase overall. I'm looking into this issue at the moment, as I th... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdU5CcUphWGtyNnlXOGRITEhyUVNhWHkxbVpxV0tTVS12T2pGQmk5Y1hQbUNZUFhTUnpYbzYxTHZhbDBMS1I3NVczSXlMelBxQ3lFVGhKQTNfRUxTdmc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCLVExcUZoZnNoZm5kR1VDZU9tNEhoNDFDc1ZCMlZXSFl6VVRVMEs3czhTM2VVRGpYVDgwSXJVTk9xUEItZFltRXpua0F3ZVlvVS13X3VwY0VwM0tTbmJqYk9SUkw4YnB3TC1yTHJjZ1REOFBkcjVuOTdTTkpjOEc4U1dONmJuVW8xaDRrU0hDTUQ4Q1B3bEpubkpoOTFxbDR6VzlZWVFSUDBiTTBWZ0NIQ2xrSmVSb0FqN25ISm5wUUIwbTFEY245U013MDZ3TkFNMW5RLWVsMzdjQVUyUT09 |
Those same mistakes can be made by humans. You say robots lack the decision making skills of humans, but machine learning studies has consistently shown that computers are generally a lot better at humans at making nuanced decisions.of course it all depends on the specific algorithm abs the amount of data used to train... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUjh3cnUzR3pDc2VyT0h2TGlDSVlsWE8waDhBbVVuSVZKeHlkLVNUdXFNT0I5bG9YeVowS2R2d0lJZXpDZ1h3QWxxNmxNcFpxN0tweU5xdlpUUEJJUlE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSkR3aFpOOWt4SjZnbXFfelUtalV4UEdaakFkY214N2tDOEF5ZzNpUVBoYmdPakhEczRsb0NkWkdQUWpIR2lMNUd5OTFzR2M5NWtZbnJ6QV9yLS1kN2E1OHhhZWFwb2hBbVhiY1NwcGRrZ2FkaVVnYWJ5eGJWOHM0RXg1Q0Y2T3hkYzdSRnYzQkhmQmhFWkhrUTlGWlBXbkVST1BIeG01ZDdZWDJCRy1Ebk9pdmxBM2hyV2RlQkkxN1RIay1jLXRHR3hwRXU4Rjk1bWJmZlFOOFRqWGhJUT09 |
The three laws are fiction. Different AI will have different rules depending on their role. How can we have the robot surgeons if the first law applies? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBeWxwMWhXWTJKb3R3bmRLNXJWNXdJUGM1ams3S09sMXZnZHNUVU5GN0VCbEQ3eWF6S2d6V3kzUDJac3M0RWZtd25vVEstM1Q3SEtXVHNISUV5bFBoLUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCV3REZHZvSjd1SHBRY1RtOWtFVzQ0bTFEdEN1Y1FYTlRVS29xZTE2TUo0T3o4YXJRVldRc3VwNlpNMmY5bU4yZ0lSbXVTa2RGOU8zNXFtVS1UejRkY0czb19TUG1uUHdvdklaR1NxSGNkU0d2NGpwSFp5eVhTWDdlVlVhTlNUMldUUFRKTUpvbkFYRTFhYmZNTzZuV0kzc3VRTGNYNXNmQ3JneXRYeVZjRHFtUG8ya2I0NFNWTkVUR2xEaW5sUUpObmVQWDJwbk9ybWFhQ0k4MGVBRkhmdz09 |
I think this is an important sub for reddit. I have a feeling it will continue to grow and even see a spike when the first big AI controversy happens. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBYjBtR0JEZ0ZLTTNrV2hfRExudm9Ka2lwVUdWdWFvTTYwUGlyeDc4aXNYU2pvTjliSEZ1aG1vZWlrOWRPWkRzZDZJU0JMOHljdUR1emNQVEZyX2NIZ3c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZGppZHZQLVRuWVI4OEUtaEpmakM3MU93LXBWc2E0ck5BM0ttcm1lc2JoaVRlUDI3enpUUVN4WFZsZFBqQWItREc1QmdnT3JJOGRkamFUZFdkbHFZeWEyX3U1WXlPdDFTemdxdmdXMHpudE8tNmlfemVVNVlKVFVmdmxrUmRDVWY5cVZUMC1Pa1ZTQUk0WGZXYWh0azdrNkxwSnJpQ1U5TnZlSldieUgyakF3PQ== |
Hey, x-risk isn't really relevant for this subreddit. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-06 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWGNQTzZuVnlQNjhSLXNlaVN5NXIzRG11cHFvUldvdThyTzgzMWRXX09KVjZ6Q0Nnb2ZhRFZvWWszVnlNUTlaWWpobTZ6OXFLYS1RYlcwTXk3TkRjR1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCR1FSel9TYmF2VFBybHFJRG1PaWMyOEFscUdvcEVOSlhDd0tqNElfX25vVUw0UVlrS0ZZOUtyLWs5SU9VLWFaa3BnUkNaM21oaWoyeGg1dTcxVTB2a1BKb1N6d1dTYlFlRTNWWkRGOWFNUkZEb0dFRW1TUmh4NXh5MkwzMXVWQWYwOGNlTWhUS0hWS3JYSmJxUVd0X0VJWk1DalltbGtFMVlDOWhrQjJ3b21IRUVfa1Rib3Z0bWkyQm9pTmRHVE1IUldMT1dTYXlvNHBNNFozd1E5aXEtdz09 |
If robots totally replace humans, would that even be "warfare"? | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-07 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBS3BUTjRTTjU5S1hjSUdaYzE2cXZ1M3hIaFlWU3ZRcU9nMVVOMWg4d20xQ24zOGo3VU5wR3MzS05HNEZjUzk1QjFtc25EM2dIZUZRYVhXZWt1OHdvQkE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCY0R0SW1nZmNwLWxMZklwWmhOOWhvMjRma2FKYkhHdjB2T0E5SEJjbWxMcTZaTXBLek5tSmx4YlJCb3BTVFhqdkRUc1NvbUloYTc1cVRvc0ZYVnRQRi1yTjhwd3p6Z3JyU2VfU3NuYXdfVVRwNVBDczhORDdFVS1IYkhHZ0dnVGU0UE04X2tOZS1qdFRPbVVyX1hVcEhXN1F0N2NHX01sekliVjNFbThtdlV6WlhKaHVyRktFNlFTUGk5T3JacWFnUFphaU1rNUZ1MV9RTXZhejF0TnRhUT09 |
While this is neat, it's not really the focus of this subreddit, as we are more interested in explicit ethical problems for the nearer term future. I'd encourage you to post to r/singularity or r/controlproblem. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-09 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBR2xGcHJGU05KMkVScTRLTVphbmRSbXRYaml1N1ZJcWdGSndWQWxmSm41alFFMkoyTVFpajJUZlh5UnUwd3JialJYWThtTnlCWWVmN1lEVlJkMFFkaEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSGt5ZWZZUHc4S2RPR1MwQ3ZGMFBXa05xSU45UEkwa2dLZ3c0VkFpRDRXLU5zeU9XcjNaWjVrdnk5Q1dlQm1jQTVPVy10SU4ydkgtTkZzUy0xTVpPdXBOdDl6cXhIVHVEU3JUZHM2UThieDFHYWZUa05qaGxkd3RUbG5XTlhpaEtadHRrcW9ISjNLUlN0WnBiYWdhdHh6VUM5b1FCN1M1bGNHMDhZRXR0NmJhVWZpY1EzX2NNa1hjYjFXU2F3S0Z5Q1cxM1liT3VHNHJkRkZ3OEZVdEpwQT09 |
While this is neat, it's not really the focus of this subreddit, as we are more interested in explicit ethical problems for the nearer term future. I'd encourage you to post to r/singularity. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-09 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBQVhqRDdsYkNBbThfTDA1dWRQOUFuZ1NIMVU0S0JpMG55WHEtdDNjaFI0c2ZJVkNwUjAwNGlnUjhRNXBUR0I0Wm1BR1RndWItM1huMGwxYUZuWU5LMVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCVkgxNTZZTnhFT2NmM2doQkgzR3JveG5hQkNJZzM3aDA5dy1nd0MtLTQwRy1UcE5zTzdJcHVNS00teW11aW1UX2ZaVWM1dVBIYVJpdjhpYWZ5MzVtSWhxYWl2SVVSdFc0cnBFd2JoNi1jQ2JYMUdOeDFxcDRoQUU0U0Nsc2x2Szh3cW5NWDdzV2FKcGQ4RklnekpualZ2eVJ3QVAtd3FwMFFzWk5yQk1oY0RWLV9LeUs5bVFucDVtZjNrMF8yNXpTQnpYMGFtc1kzcVFxTkh3R0k4RWJ5Zz09 |
I'm not sure if you had the time to go through the main body of the article. While the title and intro talk about singularity, the essay itself is exactly looking at near term consequences of AI (wealth distribution and employment) vs. futuristic singularity scenarios. Thanks for the feedback anyway :) | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-09 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBWURyNDBwNk5TNEFCQzhJTnR2LUc4cGVhZGVla1VCSF94dkJsWW5xRXBEOXRCdERSSTFQdDBPLWlmME9GQzQ3dE5hSWF6UW53dUdRSklqV1l5cGV6c0E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCOWpWUVlZVHFLWkFQOWYxYWVNeVludF9DZ2pjZUZlVlhPVUxmeXpqRjBySlhCYm1XR2hMcWo4WDdYbG1oWDlOR1RSRlBrZnY3QUwzeElINUhxSGlfN25sSHN0MG5JcEhjbG1BU3hTN1F1cTIxMkVObTA5Z3ZHSmd0YlZhb0F6RjlqSG96Y2M3cWszMm9EaG1fUXBSRTlkMzhObEhEdGpHSExJV2NtSzA1UkxrTFQ1VUpuV2wtcURHdGRWYzh3TVhLaFdOTWg3U1U5TGVIcFpJSGZ4M0xZZz09 |
Yeah, I skimmed it so I knew the content; it was sort of a hard decision, but I want to keep the sub mostly focused away from explicit discussion of superintelligence/the singularity because that turns away a lot of people in philosophy and computer science. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-10 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBRElEbk5fcFYzU2szbU53RFY5Qjh2RFk4SDZJTTFjSzkweF95dDAxRXo2RHBBc1Z3cEp3Vm5KQlJyQlp2UW41bDNxaEJjaFJ6LWNDb3U1TWRsMy0zbEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCakhzNDdvUk12ZV9qRUQ5UTRDX19Tajg3VjlqaUllSHhfR2RUb0dIZkxxYmowVTNwanVkdVloSzQ1YWN6TWxMMmZsY0lPLXZBaVQ2MmthbERSVkotSjBDcU4zX0YxYi1NN0hYc0VKSHhVa1c1Wlh6OXRjTTRuYW5hRmJwLTU4MDg3QllhZ2RUOHZwTXUtSExabEVuRHRwTHhPeGJEQjNZZ3Z0UDB4NG9mVy1jWGlxSTZTVDUwOTRpWmJiTnVBMlE3cXNRTWVFU3JIc205VUZXMUlzdnNldz09 |
haha very true! The post found a good following on /singularity
https://www.reddit.com/r/singularity/comments/56oxaf/superintelligence_singularity_and_society/?ref=share&ref_source=link | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-10 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZjV5Ri02OVRoa1RmMy1mTWtHQ0VLQS1mUEQyaXJwMl9OdXJOWC1DQUM0YjNNQmlNbFF0Sk5CWTl0OXA2VHlYc1FKaXpUTDd2VExhUG5qR1VuZ2hlZ0E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCazM0U0VBdDdOYnRhVExMaTNrelJJc19aU1ZLVHFKUFladUNiak9XUFZDNUd1Tkk0TUpzdEh2VmhPUkYxQjcyYTFIOVNuOHhoSnFmZHF5MTJqSE9WNENyaXNDVmhqSGF6VlNSblItdnh2elZleG5zRjdBaE5BSHBCbEN3WTFHM3JXdk5XenVlM3J0QlhtZlcxd2RHeFYzbXBXN09ELU1RdXc3cG9kREFleU9JLUhPZUVkdmJ4cW9DVTBVMlVwZFpwenhfU3dpdEQxODQyVG5ueHV2RmhwZz09 |
They're mostly looking at the same issues and policies which have been discussed in the U.S:
>It is too soon to set down sector-wide regulations for this nascent field but it is vital that careful scrutiny of the ethical, legal and societal ramifications of artificially intelligent systems begins now."
However, the U... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-12 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBRWU1VWxIMDZYRlh1aW82cjEzX2d1dE10WDQ1UWZ0UmFzTGRwSUJUcGhWT0U1ZEEwZWtSNGNZN0dzTDRUckxzMG9xVTRONHFoMVJKN3hvT2M4U2p4V1E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCYzh0aVlhclh3Umc1WW9QcVVNTE93U25fMG5zYmpJNFNoYnA5c0ZyT2VKNjVvN19Kc2R2d0doNUowcVZJX0lCSUVCZnlyNUU0TWdOUkFYSHhNbWNZbzZiWDNkYW9ERU9uazRqdzN4NkUyZmNNaTgxMDVleTFuX2ZoUnlmN3JObzZ3a0l0LVI2VVptZ0dzd29zT3N1UG92VHpkMHVlcnVJcHVWTV9rY01LOTMyVXEyLTdJRzlwNXJFTFV4RnJ1NlpNbU5MR1FUNmpsdnRJNl9KLXE3NzZCZz09 |
> But Joi made a very elegant point, which is, what are the values that we’re going to embed in the cars? There are gonna be a bunch of choices that you have to make, the classic problem being: If the car is driving, you can swerve to avoid hitting a pedestrian, but then you might hit a wall and kill yourself. It’s a m... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-13 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdXg0bzVmX3N2TnMyajd3Y2NmczhDSVRHMU56dDVSVEQ2WTlyY2Y5VHhwbC1BTzBKbFprdnVaTTlfR2tEZDZNSzhLd1lBQTN2MXI2Vno3amwtcEJiZ3c9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCZ1o0aDJLRXlGbFhFODBYb05ETmVuYzdFbkIxSTAzVU5mQkJSX2FQOWxLd24wSXVkVS1OU2E4aTNwUDVwTl9kT3NURl9CNThaOGFES3lrbkMzZHR3d3RHNUFHSEdvdVUyRlBqOTJMMXRNRHdIN0Myb2FWUjZIdHRZRm96MkRLZ0phd2ZYVklzME5GWkdfTFBkNFBKODRNcDA3OC1jT2xsS3RPTkZkSWJiUGE3VDB1UlpHbE05UjhScjlIaGxaeUk2Z2hoSDYwdkJFQ21XbWlXUm9rSXhZZz09 |
>I've made this point elsewhere, but I think this is a false choice. My understanding (which is backed by anecdotes from first responders more than hard data, but I think is still defensible), is that the right choice in this circumstance is always to hit the breaks but stay straight ahead -- swerving being just as lik... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-13 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdWxTOURwOWpmWjZqN1p4bUg4d2h5THdILU02dTdUTjhPVHlHT21KZURtRGZTaGRHV2lNc0tjU1poUTQwMnplOVJqWDdxRUZDOVpQUnJ3UnNnNmZocVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCMy13U1h2MTZLaHRENnhTVWFkVVZDdlhma3JEd1NsUHlZY0RXdUdpWXVLckpRSzVpS0dORmMxaWRhZVVneTA0YVF4N2tPUFRhN3U0WWtvRUFCN2dlby1JVjJnUjFyR3NtQ092bHZaWTRRYy1uOUlZdGdRYkxiM0x5azNXRVpPelV6LXc3WjNPdXdNRHJVTVBMWURVVlJDWVdTeWVtWFFfaHlYMXRhYkt4UmJVZlhSWmp1cUcyOFFseTcyLWkzb3dZZFJFZkRsY3ZVdEtrVTVrMGtLTGVMdz09 |
Thank you so much for this. Ethics can be hard enough on its own, but applying it to AI seems to complicate things further.
| r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-18 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdkttTG9zTElQWTRxd25fY19tRlNHZDZOei1sZXFpWjlGZGtEMzB5aEh2ZEZiM3NzZTF3b1d3QkRISm1MVEdyaGlGSjlVd3ozRXZyWGRVMHNhUjZMMFE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCejFFa0o2M0RKRk92MHFiYVJrUWF1aHdCcEgxZ1JlRGFkbDI0MlBzMXV4dHg5VjdTZndLbElWdGsxRnNkeVZmT1NMQmEyNnZyX0xfWkVvSk82dVZvWGFtX0tPN3NSR2pFNDJ6OFdtVUZrVjVuU2d3OTAxUmZNLTNkbjl6dllKclJfR29QLU1ZbU5nZ21XaU9UazROOVdFU181cFZBMkxQb1ZKRVB1a1dWTzlad3VSTkhOLXhnOGQ2blItRzVHTE1UQzktQXlWMVBDUDlZNVZleWZENWdfUT09 |
I'd say that beauty for beauty contests is in the eye of the Judges. Write an AI that aligns with the judge's ideas of beauty, and you can see their true interpretations of what beauty is. Although, you could use historical data to see that anyways. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-18 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBeVJ0S242YmtOb3ZtbWljX1RoQmh0QjJfdnVnaklIVFlXOE1PUHJnS3I1ZUFzN0haRDBjSGU4U042RXZYSmlBSGgtMXZVaEM3Z1pEa25CSElJRElkUUE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCQmxKS1J0RWVSYWgxVjFYeVlYUDRSM0hiZ21wVGdiZW8zSV95Y2VJYzB1N19mVFVFdW1KOXZoTUlNYnVvS3lOZ1gtV1Jvd3dhdlRNdWpoVHgzZVdWMGgxQ1R2NkNvNEV3UUV2RWdEVV9ld2cwUmVtMF9KbVVLVXQ1dF9LaEVTU1RFd2ZkcUxhbFJIb2RmVEd1TzR6X2RxSk1Da2tmMXI0Q0lFSGlPa3JZakRGWDNGazgzNjZEa2hFQ2ZuQW9RRkk1UmFvLU12ODUyem5ZeVAyN045aklRdz09 |
Thanks for writing this up! I was going to attend but ended up buried by grant proposal deadlines :( | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-20 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBeXlQNkpwZW9oZ2huTVhQQ0xvSU5LSFRjQmNtajdXaW9Cakx3OEszd2N0WkVLU0dsS3BQc1JwMkI2aUZzRVhuVUxJZ1FxRlBWX1RzeUhSWmVGRmo5QXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCcE9DRnlhN1k3X1h6ZVpxYXN5dTZlOEdpanN4MFNBZFdnZGNJZjhvdmoyQmc2Z01mX2w0QThDQThWV0w3cnh0ZU8tYXVSMkNmOVVGalZXanhqTlU1VE0zd2Ywem5NZmx4cEtNZUlYWXdjRDk1U1c4WEdfZm9mdlpobjNOdldYMlhIdzVaYjBpLUNJeEtaR0M1bXk0TnRBWE9kd2RCdk5pZTZuV0NxcGxTeklIanJwSG1oVk9sZXh0OUNya3g3dWh4XzRySlNyTFYteV9pbDNKWU5HQkNUUT09 |
TL;DR: many mind types can be plotted in a 2-axis graph with human like as the vertical axis (humans being at the top) and capability of conscious thought on the horizontal axis (humans being on the right).
other mind types occupy different regions of the graph with a brick being in the lower, left and various animals... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-21 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBLV9JRUZ6QU14SjJqOG5qb25DaTFGVVNWYjVnWlYzTzB6cXNBUFdUSVhVRkV2Z3o0NEk3NWJEaHh1YmFFTlZYWGUyVHFlSUlFNkdRLWE5WGtQa2NxcXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCM0JkbnNLV0ZaQ0hTcU9fTUktZ0xKdFZSQmMzeEtxWTFnSGpFOHV6SmhVa2NhQm8wWmhXM3lfbE9DcTdFdzdtYnVHMlFrS3JZcnBEeWlmMjE0V2xZbzdjRmRBZnVlQlBSNXdHY0hOV0ZjVjVvT3hLUjRPSncySWF2ekUwc2otVkpVWjlMcWdWNEpQampTcjVIYnNNdmROSVVRRnBheHlFeEY3VlgzOUEzSFpfbkcxVkFaT2hLajhINElRNUZjSllOWU5XZzdOTENVWkJPVlB6Q2dDWVNJdz09 |
No. **The idea of war is to kill people** and/or lower their living standards. Otherwise it would be just diplomacy. Of course it is completely possible to replace soldiers with robots only on other side. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-22 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBQldIbFNQZV9yY3I0VE9qMEk2OGZqWDZYUEtMY3o2N2tkaFRzMDF5R2VOV19xcTVHdTNfcXN5RUtSOGFBS1FKc3VDSG9HOTRPZ3BKSkt0cjFHUHB0LXc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCUGVWZEp4eV9vd2dLakhFOHNIM0JUTk1iVXV2b0xYeDJ1aEFqOWtmOFhUMTB2S1BjU3J0ZlJXUFpsYnNCSFdzY3ctZ3ZPZ3F0Z3g5UGR4TTk3emprMkJnaV8wdUVMMGRVU0xBdl9JZk8xdl9ZMERJeVNfWnpsbDduSHlYMGRwMmxoelh5Q1p6MkJFQ1ZTTWtXS294R3E0TnZvb0ZNR0pyMWtBQWJndm1YSF9nWG5zamVwQzZhamxIUTNqMTNmSUVKSXJ1Q3pGalVrSXFvZkxEajhkZGE3Zz09 |
Maybe someone can link me to something saying the contrary, but (with the exception of protect-our-jobs truckers) I actually haven't seen any indication of people really opposing the idea of introducing self driving cars. I've been to a couple conferences and saw no one who said or even explicitly addressed the idea th... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-26 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBcVRBZnZ5Ul9YUmNUMmk2V01kQkhJeFNXbUNZVFdoeHNIRmVLOXJwMGNQSzdyUXJNZ3pYTkJDV0E5WG9ZV3RLaVExNHlhcTZfUHJVMHhQbDliS2Jkdmc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCSG1LSTJVZUV0TVI4MFNfZWs1dkdJc0RBaWVidDN5RXJIQ2ZiaGRHMlVLaDE1T2NqZF91ck5QWEpwT0taejY1Z19SdzVscUV4cHlPVlMyUFRrQkhyZlk0bTVpRHVKLTRVb1hIalFDNEJ4STlIT0lmY0pSNHJfeWpPNkoyajNQN3p2a3BjX0VISnQ2Z0NBUDBmUFMzVFFTM05xOGpsbEhmOGtoSTVHMXNXTE5LLW40ZHpDMkhyQkNjYTdWNjRxNWd2UVN4UF9FSmo3M1hneDNnejIxTUZxdz09 |
http://imgur.com/07H4YDr | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-26 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBRUE5elNFcjI1TGhUbnA1Ymp1UWtjajhORnd6M0RTWmw5Yzdya1R6bTc4QlM1cURJa3dFSWhFbmVnQ2VXS3h5UllKSEMtMXJ0cnZ5dy1zY2RJd19XSEE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCQ0kwOG9fMk9OM1QwZk4zWmJncWRDWjhRVDR6LTlQaGxpX1M2MVUwUFhkVEpfWDRoTVowd203cDIzMlJIZU1pM2xjZGRkZ0JJcWZ0MnJaU3UtOEdyRFIzeWxQZ3J3TVZJTHVBLXBRMDdmM0puSTA2cXh2Qms1eW9vWWl5OTR3LXNnSTY5OU8tcWFkR0d5UUZQSDRBZGtlVVNOa3pjY2ctei1jVlgzcmhpRE5uNWJlNkR1MGtIVHZWVERUSDlib09kWUVOUWRCRllWXzJ3OXhrMnpuNzB6QT09 |
I haven't seen anything about stopping them, but I've seen a lot about slowing down or otherwise trying to direct development. I probably beat to death the Obama/Ito interview in the other thread, but I think that's a good example. I believe the average response to developments in self-driving technology has been moder... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-27 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBMmFhY2xLMU9aMUZBRmdGM0pETm1uWG1HR2ZHUUp5LXhSc2RsSlBsWDV0TjJmbHBwMkZIMVdzTWdPdGdTSVh2aWhoU0hOZ0FmNHlHNkkxNV9ERy1HMnc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCVnBQWnNvRjVSM3RtOFBwV2RtMzZNcWpuZkxoMHBZMXhRZ2N6UjYyeVdCNzlKc3hGeEhPWGR6VHdmVWRMZ0dTRzFDNU5QQkQ5cUJtQnBqM1k1U3JtNVpIaDlMZVJvdHRrVlZWUXVNdExDQlNoUzh4TE80N2UtM0VnWmZwdmNJRXhyc3Zxak1QY3d0ZDJ4TlZkSS02d1Uydl92YUFDWm9fS09pLXVYcVU0bWk0bkV0cnZMMzItT3VHNnJHZndsTHg1WFBYUW1iUVJCZ2hqTmowaXFPaExPUT09 |
This article brings to light what movies such as "I, Robot", "Her" and countless other works of fiction have tried to bring to our attention for some time now.
In economic sense, AI and automation is a great thing to have. It increases efficiency and productivity nearly exponentially. But what escapes us people of scie... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-27 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBZFFQUml3VDFRLW9UVUlkVHJLdXhRS0RrS3ZmMWRyRl9FZnhTS3NZZS1lWVM0RFVrbTNiTHNMeVczb3JnRUlOWmhuMlBQcUZmZ08tN0JGZHh1aXFKMGc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCbXY0dWp1Z0p5Mm9PakFQTWp4WXFiMU4za3NQMFhsWFF6Yy1jX3I5TlFpUHh0VGp0Zl9naHZnbHg4UzNwTnYxQXB0NTFTVVdDcFc1a3JOZHZtRGJoLWtNWHF0RG1DaW9KaE81NFFBZkNLazRLUTBibDhTU01wTUZ4TlpRMzJ2WTF6cGRudmFZOXFGbnN4YVdRbFg1ME5zZlEtZ2lvNXdzel9KaTlPV3daMjBMNXlBcmFETjgzT1VBQkZldE1ldDMtdzc5d0NXNVNCd2hLMzJ0Zi1kbG40Zz09 |
My guess is monied interests with incentive to push fossil fuels are tryna cockblock. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-27 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBdzVwTXJIVVRCZkRzZ0h0c1ljd3VjdEE4SUNEMnNLaVVXbGMwX2llSDQwMjFOLUlWM0xkSEtwaFRaaUpCekl3bjRDRVlqaE9Ba2ZWM2I1ems3TURWR0E9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCWFVnejlEczVDUnFnMklXMmNwRXlrUS02X1B2UG5HWEp2NTdIUjN4OVQxWU9uZGdSQmlRblk3RmhhRXFNQXFmb0txTXdKSVptSjk2TFB3TWZhelhOb0lmSlFpTVFIeS11aGtYLUJoeVlHSVNnWHllWDR2alJ1eV9nVXdJekh1UDh2a2lydVhtbUNySzNPSmtwc1hQVkhaaTJxbUgtQklndTgtaDFYOHdFN1FHbVhSUEVKTEhlTmY2RHlKdGpoWTg1Vy1tbFNPNHppQ1J6NURxOGVFODlIdz09 |
Direct link to the paper in case anyone's curious: https://peerj.com/articles/cs-93/#p-49
The methodology itself -- using n-grams and categorization of various textual submissions to the court to train an SVM with a linear kernel -- actually seems really simple as far as machine learning goes (I've only been out of un... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-28 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBQ3JNQUROemRhdHc4Y2s0eThtaXhtU0QxR1FkaDUzVjlNQm5mb2NWaWVfRTROS1dWWXRrZ0RPcWp1OG9VYTZXeXdGYU5HMW1GX3Y5N29nMDEtMkptQVE9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCRDdKeEtkUldwa2lyZjhXaldSOU5HdXFKblZxZWtvUUUzMGZJZHlJb1NUdkY3czJxc24tOVdFTzlHbm9zd2RQNE84V0ZIQ3ZsUU1WaFEzc0lhSVBXYjJhTU9qWnhMbWozSnQwZk5Vc2F3aENSYm5EZzhQMEdMdnhkZ2VvdWdnRmFheDB1RGFOblVSVk9LejZnaDd2VW5OanhKaENsRjZBY0hVWmpXalZ1bTNRcFRtX09PQnZ0SWg0eTJ2dVJWcGVkZThiWU9lcGRSWXVDbW8xT1dPemU2Zz09 |
I don't know how surprised we should be that ~80% of legal decisions can be explained by a simple machine learning process. The real issue in law is getting the remaining 20% right - the ones which are really difficult cases. | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-28 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBSWc4cS0tX216aXNMaXdJTXUyYVJvbUh0TWM3NlYzVWxGWTBHX1lGV01qQll2QmgwZlZtZlU5Y1VnUGZKaGNJakw1R3BVNldlMmV0MjdkRmNzRjJxQmc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCTUNWZVg5N0JzbkZ1N2piODJuZHl2eHpld1ZCMUdxTVEtTWdTYndwelhzdGdDR0F0NnpNdlRlaE1SbUZOYUQ4TTJuMzNOaEtQMDkxU3RNdFhoSENKLWpEMzZpVm5YRmhSejNmcHNqWGhkd0F1SUFpdm9BQndIajh4MnA1VjZOcXpwbFNVXy1uZW91Wm14M3hYTHlZeVF3RzBSMEQ1ZkNjam5qajVKV2kzTWhvZFlLZ2dOX3RLYURuVW5DZUVYbXdldWpobjVOQzRBcVNmaEQ3dUYzdlFQZz09 |
> I don't know how surprised we should be that ~80% of legal decisions can be explained by a simple machine learning process.
This I think is the main point of the journal and what I meant by the innovation being in feature selection rather than prediction: What the article found was not (so much) an accurate predicto... | r/aiethics | comment | r/AIethics | 2016-10-28 | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJBUDcwWGwxSXFNRWgyMzJyWlduS05LSHZXMlNodVU1VGx5UzdETDhBMzdPVWUxdHNUbWZBWExZZ1g4ZUh5aEdVQXltLW1DazlQM1NHMlltNVQ3QWNUbmc9PQ== | Z0FBQUFBQm9IVGJCN1drWVhxZXU4dkFwUGdzRThwNXh4NlZpdlh4ZjZfdnBvMTRlS2oyMzF1ZmJ2OV9Lc3JCbzg4bXNnemdScWNCYUIyN0tUQUlHMWU2TWszalpMSWRjNTI2YUFsQ1ZoY054SFRCUjdYanpjZnNLNV83X0ZGdnhUSDFweXBZNW1tN0lETTdIdkdkQk9SSklEWXBTMGl3U09LMTJ4QTdSaGktdGszUjM4d2xOSzVqekRtQmJQUW5OcUljWDhKTjU1ODBiSlUwNGpzbFE3SElXam05YUpmaDh3Zz09 |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.