q_id
stringlengths
5
6
title
stringlengths
3
301
selftext
stringlengths
0
39.2k
document
stringclasses
1 value
subreddit
stringclasses
3 values
url
stringlengths
4
132
answers
dict
title_urls
list
selftext_urls
list
answers_urls
list
1sv2gj
Why do only one or two new immunogenic strains of the influenza virus appear yearly despite their highly variable nature ?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1sv2gj/why_do_only_one_or_two_new_immunogenic_strains_of/
{ "a_id": [ "ce1ouhb" ], "score": [ 4 ], "text": [ "More strains almost certainly appear, but there are very, very few amino acid mutations that both 1) help either change an epitope to evade the immune system or change a binding protein so it recognizes humans, and 2) that allow their proteins (u...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.nature.com/news/specials/mutantflu/index.html" ] ]
885svl
What did pre-germ theory people think was going on when a cut got infected?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/885svl/what_did_pregerm_theory_people_think_was_going_on/
{ "a_id": [ "dwj6p10", "dwk0ecf", "dwkdxms" ], "score": [ 49, 33, 18 ], "text": [ "/u/Sir_David_S wrote an answer to a similar question regarding Miasma theory in this thread: \n\n_URL_0_\n\nThe thread and answer specifically deal with reasons why people believed in Miasma theory, ...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6ru00i/the_germ_theory_of_disease_wikipedia_page/dldjfcx/" ], [], [ "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/81df9t/germ_theory_was_proposed_in_the_16th_century_but/dv2mlle/" ] ]
4hpn9p
How did you choose a graduate school?
I'm a graduating senior (in December, no I'm not graduating next week though I wish I was!) and I've got a list going but I'm still not sure how to evaluate master's programs. My field of interest is relatively niche, so I've been having a fairly hard time finding programs that might work.
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4hpn9p/how_did_you_choose_a_graduate_school/
{ "a_id": [ "d2roa1e" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "I did two overlapping things while I was searching for PhD programs:\n\n1. I remembered work that was in a similar vein to what I wanted to do, or that had impacted my scholarly development in a positive way. I then figured out where those schola...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
2jcea5
what purpose does the wingdings font serve?
Aside from creating little symbols out of a font, what practical purpose is it used for?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2jcea5/eli5_what_purpose_does_the_wingdings_font_serve/
{ "a_id": [ "cladf5a" ], "score": [ 13 ], "text": [ "Those fonts were made to provide computers a method of displaying basic graphics when graphics were limited." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
9wcmgl
Do planets expand when they're closer to the sun? And get smaller when they're distant from the heat?
I was studying phsycs and that I started wandering about this. But there's no information on Google.
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/9wcmgl/do_planets_expand_when_theyre_closer_to_the_sun/
{ "a_id": [ "e9k4pux", "e9kalye" ], "score": [ 3, 12 ], "text": [ "As much as the material of the planet can expand due to heat, yes.\n\nIf the Earth got closer to the Sun, then the gases in the atmosphere would expand. The tides may even get more extreme. However, the rocky crust would no...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.02767.pdf", "https://arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00135.pdf", "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_Jupiter" ] ]
1zw5ro
What happens if a patient with an allergy to anesthetic needs surgery?
I broke my leg several years ago, and because of my Dad's allergy to general anesthetics, I was heavily sedated and given an epidural as a precaution in surgery. It worked, but that was a 45-minute procedure at the most, and was in an extremity. What if someone who was allergic, needed a major surgery that was over 4 ...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1zw5ro/what_happens_if_a_patient_with_an_allergy_to/
{ "a_id": [ "cfxiq09", "cfxj11h", "cfxjge7", "cfxneqt" ], "score": [ 3, 49, 887, 18 ], "text": [ "Well there should be alternatives to the main anesthetic that hospitals utilize, so if you're allergic to one they can provide a different option. Here's a paper on one- _URL_...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2923931/" ], [], [], [ "http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-1250507/Eyes-Wide-Open-Patient-open-heart-surgery-awake.html" ] ]
6emz4e
Why didn't the Ottoman Empire do anything during the 30 years war?
During the 30 years war, the holy roman empire was basically at war with itself, and was being invaded by basically every other christian country at once. Why didn't the Ottomans take this golden opportunity to invade?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6emz4e/why_didnt_the_ottoman_empire_do_anything_during/
{ "a_id": [ "dicq64n", "dicyput" ], "score": [ 10, 7 ], "text": [ "The relative lull in their conflicts in the west actually gave the Ottomans some breathing space to focus on their long standing rival in the east, the Safavids of Persia. The last war with the Habsburgs, the \"long war\" f...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3pvlas/did_the_ottoman_empire_take_any_strategic/cw9z5wi/", "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaratio_Ferdinandei" ] ]
2jbep3
why does music, or even television seemingly get quieter the longer i listen?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2jbep3/eli5_why_does_music_or_even_television_seemingly/
{ "a_id": [ "cla4r4g", "cla7ykh" ], "score": [ 6, 2 ], "text": [ "Best ELI5 answer I can come up with: Compare it to how a dark room seems brighter the longer you're in it. That's your eyes adjusting to a low level of light.\n\nThe opposite happens when you listen to a t.v. loud for a whil...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
2l86gg
why does anything that takes multiple batteries require them to be alternated?
After putting so many batteries in my son's toys, I stopped and thought about this. Most battery operated objects have you alternate which way the batteries are put in and I was wondering if it is done out of necessity or if it was maybe an aesthetic reason.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2l86gg/eli5_why_does_anything_that_takes_multiple/
{ "a_id": [ "clschvk", "clsckri" ], "score": [ 2, 5 ], "text": [ "batteries are DC or direct current meaning the current goes one way which goes from + terminal to - terminal. alternating just makes it easier to connect the two battery terminals\n\nedit: current goes from positive to negat...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
3kt1uz
why would someone want to/ need to use tor?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3kt1uz/eli5_why_would_someone_want_to_need_to_use_tor/
{ "a_id": [ "cv07phj" ], "score": [ 4 ], "text": [ "There are many reasons why people would want to hide their activity or be anonymous. A lot are legitimate, a lot are not, and a whole lot are in between.\n\nSay you live in a country with a repressive regime that blocks access to, say, pro-democr...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
17v499
how cease and desist letters are not blackmail.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/17v499/eli5_how_cease_and_desist_letters_are_not/
{ "a_id": [ "c893l96", "c8982dt" ], "score": [ 30, 2 ], "text": [ "Cease and desist does not threaten anything illegal (such as violence), all it threatens is a lawsuit which is the accepted way to settle a dispute, and there's no guarantee that it will go either way, the plaintiff may los...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
a6qtw4
why does a lack of genetic diversity cause deformities?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/a6qtw4/eli5_why_does_a_lack_of_genetic_diversity_cause/
{ "a_id": [ "ebx4nis", "ebx56wc" ], "score": [ 5, 3 ], "text": [ "Imagine a machine that makes bricks that you make a house with but machine needs a sample brick to make more bricks like it.\n\nImagine you only have a few types of bricks. One of em gets chipped and goes into the machine. \...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "https://i.imgur.com/aFKxKix.png" ] ]
2ersaw
how do coin counting machines work?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2ersaw/eli5_how_do_coin_counting_machines_work/
{ "a_id": [ "ck2b9tg", "ck2ba8j", "ck2ba8z" ], "score": [ 13, 3, 2 ], "text": [ "They have various holes of increasing size, separating the individual coins. After being separated, each coin pushes a trigger bar as it falls, incrementing a counter which keeps tally of that kind of ...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
1iduoh
In Feudal Europe, how did doctors become doctors?
Who with/what did they study?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1iduoh/in_feudal_europe_how_did_doctors_become_doctors/
{ "a_id": [ "cb3hg0h" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "Define time period" ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
mi9rc
eil5: what was the conflict between edison and tesla about?
Was it the emergence / fight over the standard for electrical grids; AC v. DC? What's the difference, and what are the pluses and minuses? What would life be like if we had gone the other way?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/mi9rc/eil5_what_was_the_conflict_between_edison_and/
{ "a_id": [ "c315qmb", "c316spq", "c3189xv", "c315qmb", "c316spq", "c3189xv" ], "score": [ 3, 2, 2, 3, 2, 2 ], "text": [ "**While Tesla and Edison:** When Tesla moved to America, he began to work for Edison. He quickly started to climb Edison's corporate lad...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b5/New_York_utility_lines_in_1890.jpg" ], [], [ "http://antiquemachinery.com/1891%20elect%20motor.JPG", "http://mysite.du.edu/~jcalvert/tech/edisonz.jpg", "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jP4aIUeQnt4", "http://t2.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:AN...
24uiuo
how do tv/any screens actually work, like how do each pixels show different colours?
This has always made me curious, I understand that they are mostly LED's but how are there so many individual pixels without having that many individual LEDs?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/24uiuo/eli5how_do_tvany_screens_actually_work_like_how/
{ "a_id": [ "chasuev", "chaycb8" ], "score": [ 2, 3 ], "text": [ "Good explanation here:\n\n_URL_0_\n\nThe LED lights are just used for backlighting, not for each individual pixel.", "In LCD/LED TV's, each pixel has a red, green and blue element that can recreate a range of shades of t...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/jdm4u/eli5_lcd_vs_led_vs_plasma/c2b8psw" ], [] ]
5vrkk7
"OK" is the survivor of an 1839 slang in which speakers would abbreviate purposefully misspelled phrases (all correct=oll korrect=ok). Do we have any record of negative reactions to or criticisms of this fad and it's creators?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/5vrkk7/ok_is_the_survivor_of_an_1839_slang_in_which/
{ "a_id": [ "de4snx2" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "Yes. The etymologist who tracked down the origin of OK as \"oll korrect\" was named [Allen Walker Read](_URL_2_). \n\nThe groundbreaking article authored by him is called [The First Stage in the History of \"O.K.\"](_URL_0_) He presents many exa...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://www.jstor.org/stable/453580", "https://www.amazon.com/Pads-Milestones-Hist-Allen-Walker/dp/082236526X", "http://www.nytimes.com/2002/10/18/nyregion/allen-read-96-the-ok-expert-is-dead.html" ] ]
d4v06i
if the sun is constantly adding heat/energy to earth, then why has the temperature always stayed the same?
[deleted]
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/d4v06i/eli5_if_the_sun_is_constantly_adding_heatenergy/
{ "a_id": [ "f0gq2uf", "f0gq4fh", "f0gq4i9", "f0gt1ii" ], "score": [ 3, 5, 2, 2 ], "text": [ "The Earth radiates heat away into space. Radiation does not require a medium to move through.\n\nA certain amount of heat is also lost with gases that escape the atmosphere, or con...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [] ]
1u93r7
If the Americans secretly invented the atomic bomb, how did Russia get their hands on the technology so soon after it's invention?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1u93r7/if_the_americans_secretly_invented_the_atomic/
{ "a_id": [ "cefqns4", "cefsalx", "cegaiuj" ], "score": [ 25, 40, 2 ], "text": [ "The [Manhattan Project](_URL_4_) was more than just Americans invention an atomic bomb. It was the continuation of [Tube Alloys](_URL_3_), the British research into fission weapons, which had been rel...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://www.mi5.gov.uk/home/mi5-history/the-cold-war/klaus-fuchs.html", "http://www.worldcat.org/title/atomic-the-first-war-of-physics-and-the-secret-history-of-the-atom-bomb-1939-49/oclc/424453895&referer=brief_results", "http://www.smithsonianmag.com/history-archaeology/Spies-Who-Spilled-Atomic...
2hnpae
how is it safe to consume smoked meats?
I'm really leary about eating pork products, I always avoid eating smoked sausage, my buddies were assuring that the smoking process kills everything but how?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2hnpae/eli5_how_is_it_safe_to_consume_smoked_meats/
{ "a_id": [ "ckubm3i", "ckupq1f" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "Same way cooking does, by getting the meat hot enough to kill bacteria. Even a \"low-temp\" smoker is at about 200 F.", "Smoke meats are high in salt and also may have sodium nitrate or nitrites. \nHigh salt make a tough...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
6pe1zx
What is the curvature of empty space?
As I understand it, * The curvature of the universe is 0, at least, as close as we've been able to measure it. * On the other hand, near matter, space has slightly positive curvature (have I got that right?) So, does that mean that far away from matter, empty space has a slight negative curvature, so that everything ...
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/6pe1zx/what_is_the_curvature_of_empty_space/
{ "a_id": [ "dkpwo6e" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "There are many non-trivial vacuum spacetimes, including all of the familiar black hole solutions (Schwarzschild, Kerr-Newman, etc.). Vacuum does not imply zero curvature.\n\n > The curvature of the universe is 0, at least, as close as we've been...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
frwyzx
why isn't water vapor considered worse than carbon in climate issues?
ELI5: Why do I only hear about carbon emissions? I thought that, as far as greenhouse gasses are concerned, water vapor is stronger than carbon. I would imagine the warmer it gets on Earth, more water vapor is created and traps even more of our star's energy in Earth's atmosphere. No?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/frwyzx/eli5_why_isnt_water_vapor_considered_worse_than/
{ "a_id": [ "fly4xxo", "fly7bj8", "fly9hnq" ], "score": [ 3, 14, 3 ], "text": [ "Mostly because we can't control it. Average water content of air is directly related to the temperature of the air for the most part. There's nothing we can do about it, aside from reducing the amount ...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
3qkm4i
how do you properly use the paper toilet seat covers provided in public restrooms?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3qkm4i/eli5_how_do_you_properly_use_the_paper_toilet/
{ "a_id": [ "cwfyz9i", "cwfzghu" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "The fully-cut side goes to the back; the flap side should fall down from the front. It's supposedly for men when they sit, so their penis doesn't touch the porcelain. But it's also the only orientation where the paper cover ...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
34aevv
Why are all particles bosons or fermions?
Why is it not possible for a particle to be neither symmetric nor antisymetric on exchange? If a particle can have 1/2 integer spin why can't it have 1/3 , 1/4 etc.
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/34aevv/why_are_all_particles_bosons_or_fermions/
{ "a_id": [ "cqstqvp", "cqsu1b1", "cqsuey2", "cqsugsm" ], "score": [ 22, 3, 7, 4 ], "text": [ "Excellent questions - the answers are very subtle.\n\nFirst of all, let's look at your first question, why exchange has to be symmetric or antisymmetric. You may be surprised to k...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin%E2%80%93statistics_theorem", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anyon" ], [], [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anyon" ], [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Momentum_operator", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bohr_model" ] ]
15s1tt
When one person fails to open a pickle jar, the next person to try often succeeds. Has the first person's attempt at opening the jar 'loosened' it up?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/15s1tt/when_one_person_fails_to_open_a_pickle_jar_the/
{ "a_id": [ "c7pa5o3", "c7pav1l", "c7pgzhr", "c7pixj6", "c7pjxlg" ], "score": [ 103, 15, 2, 3, 6 ], "text": [ "This strikes me as highly unlikely, since we don't experience a sudden failing of musculature that would lead the first person to be unable to open the \"l...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [], [] ]
31laws
Can anyone explain the three interactions happening in the Feynman triangle diagram?
The triangle diagram ([as seen on Wikipedia](_URL_0_) and [elsewhere](_URL_1_)) shows three photons interacting with the help of three virtual electrons. Just like other Feynman diagrams, the horizontal axis is time and the vertical axis is space. Two of these interactions are straightforward. The one on the left is a...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/31laws/can_anyone_explain_the_three_interactions/
{ "a_id": [ "cq2xpwk" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "The absolute most important thing to remember is that Feynman diagrams are mostly just visualization technique. To start with, the angles represent nothing; though a particle's angle from the horizontal *would* correspond to its speed, in practic...
[]
[ "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-loop_Feynman_diagram", "https://www.callmedrrob.com/?p=68" ]
[ [ "http://particle.uni-wuppertal.de/harlander/research/ggh/img/triangle_trans.gif", "http://qph.is.quoracdn.net/main-qimg-2ead52d17caeeb578e6acac9f94636fd?convert_to_webp=true", "http://inspirehep.net/record/1199029/files/lamb.png" ] ]
404nl3
why doesn't everyone capitalize the word "internet?" there is only one internet and the chicago manual of style capitalizes it, so why would anyone spell it in lowercase?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/404nl3/eli5_why_doesnt_everyone_capitalize_the_word/
{ "a_id": [ "cyrg912" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Because it's inconvenient to hit the shift key any more than necessary. And by necessary, I mean that most people won't notice is it's casually omitted." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
7dm7pi
why do some coins tinkle with a metallic sound when you flick them but some coins don't sound much like anything?
I saw a 2017 American nickel on the ground today and flicked it up. To my shock it actually made that *shing!* sound you hear in sound effects in animated films or whatever. Never heard it before. In fact, even as it pick it up about an inch high and drop it to the ground it still makes that sound like a bell.
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/7dm7pi/eli5why_do_some_coins_tinkle_with_a_metallic/
{ "a_id": [ "dpyrm39" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "The speed of sound and resonant frequency in a coin changes with size and composition.\n\nSome coins are made of the right metals in the right shape that will reverberate with that characteristic ring, others aren't.\n\nA US nickel is 5g of 75% c...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
12wuwv
Is population control an absolute requirement for a post-scarcity economy?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/12wuwv/is_population_control_an_absolute_requirement_for/
{ "a_id": [ "c6yswff", "c6z43po" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "You mean to *achieve* a post-scarcity economy.\n\nAny answer to this would be speculative and normative in nature. One economist who would disagree with the need for population control is [Julian Simon](_URL_1_), who claime...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://caseymulligan.blogspot.com/2009/09/professor-kremer-says-that-population.html", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Julian_Simon" ], [] ]
abaw6z
WWII - Found this is a box of my deceased grandfathers possessions. What is it?
My Grandfather lived in the Ukraine during world war two. We don’t know much of what happened to him during the war as he didn’t like to talk about it but we recently came across [this](_URL_0_) in a box I was hoping to get some insight into what it is.
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/abaw6z/wwii_found_this_is_a_box_of_my_deceased/
{ "a_id": [ "ecyuipp", "ecyvvbx" ], "score": [ 3, 6 ], "text": [ "That looks like German POW money tokens. I found a collection on sale at this link [_URL_0_](_URL_0_)", "Lagergeld (literally storage money or storage charges), during WWII, were employed within ghettos and concentration...
[]
[ "https://m.imgur.com/a/DxLvXaW" ]
[ [ "https://www.the-saleroom.com/en-gb/auction-catalogues/cottees-auctions-limited/catalogue-id-srcott10054/lot-c1545810-3d9e-4fc5-951e-a43c011cbf33" ], [ "https://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/30047613", "https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/wwi_pow_camps/381/" ] ]
1nlhcn
the fcc is closed... does that mean pirate radio can not be stopped?
If the FCC is closed due to government shut down, does that mean no one is monitoring the radio waves for lawfulness? Not "obscenity", but for things like pirated radio, Ham radio use without license, power and volume regulations, even old wireless systems used by musicians (like the old 700 Mghz Band)? Case in point...
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1nlhcn/eli5the_fcc_is_closed_does_that_mean_pirate_radio/
{ "a_id": [ "ccjp0ji", "ccjwxv2" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "More or less. However, if something can fall in a local police jurisdiction, you're out of luck, because they're still on the job. However, since it usually takes a decent bit of equipment to start a serious pirate radio s...
[]
[ "http://www.fcc.gov/shutdown-page.html" ]
[ [], [] ]
b3yjq3
why are acl injuries so difficult to repair properly?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/b3yjq3/eli5_why_are_acl_injuries_so_difficult_to_repair/
{ "a_id": [ "ej32ojn" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "Most injuries cause the entire thing to tear, with the ends not connected at all anymore. That will never heal without surgery, because the ligament has no mechanisms that allow it to fix itself when fully torn apart." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
6y5e6p
"Participation" of Soldiers in the American Civil War
Hi guys! This is about a statistic which I have heard cited a couple times, usually as a precursor for some sweeping conclusions. I'd like to hear some ACW historians weigh in on the statistic's veracity, and (if it is true) its implications and causes. The statistic is that, during the American Civil War, "only ab...
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6y5e6p/participation_of_soldiers_in_the_american_civil/
{ "a_id": [ "dmld3qi" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "A few notes:\n\n1) The original source of the unfired muskets statistic seems to be an [1867 army manual](_URL_0_).\n\n > Of the 27,574 muskets picked up on the battle field of Gettysburgh and turned into the Washington Arsenal at least 24,000 w...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://books.google.com/books?id=MqhWAAAAcAAJ&pg=PA341&lpg=PA341&dq=%2227,574+muskets%22&source=bl&ots=IGf4SQJVmS&sig=3Kiq7DD_Qj-Dqnq6s_8zYOj9w9A&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjO3szen47WAhXFy4MKHfYXB3Q4ChDoAQgtMAE#v=onepage&q=%2227%2C574%20muskets%22&f=false" ] ]
9cdq5b
why wouldn't this troll comic work?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/9cdq5b/eli5_why_wouldnt_this_troll_comic_work/
{ "a_id": [ "e59wyz2", "e59x42r" ], "score": [ 8, 3 ], "text": [ "Because water only gets sucked up a vacuum by about 10 meters/32 feet.\n\nThe reason things move in a vacuum is because there is a pressure differential. The water is being pushed \"upwards\", opposing the force of the atmos...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
286ac4
why do people discover partial fossils, not complete ones?
Why is it that complete sets of fossils aren't always discovered and where do the rest of the bones go? Surely all of the bones should always be present, especially with larger animals? _URL_0_ Above it describes how only jaws and teeth have been discovered, where is the rest of it?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/286ac4/eli5_why_do_people_discover_partial_fossils_not/
{ "a_id": [ "ci7t9uy" ], "score": [ 9 ], "text": [ "Well, it takes a very specific set of circumstances for fossils to form. The specimen needs to be covered up completely, rapidly, and permanently. Those conditions are often met in violent and turbulent environments such as mudslides, floods, vol...
[]
[ "http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Gigantopithecus#Fossils" ]
[ [] ]
5vlmkw
How close did the UK really come to capitulation to Nazi Germany in May 1940?
Churchill reportedly made a Speech to Cabinet saying that we shouldn't give in, but was it ever realisitic that the UK would sue for peace with Nazi Germany, and if so how close was it to happening? I ask as had it happened WW2 would have been completely different.
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/5vlmkw/how_close_did_the_uk_really_come_to_capitulation/
{ "a_id": [ "de3p5pw" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Some historians would argue that Hitler had no interest in taking Britain. He long admired the British, at one point he even offered them control of the seas while he expanded into Eastern Europe and Russia.\n\nOn top of this, the Germans did not...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
16k06b
if it takes years of study to become a lawyer and practice law, and many more to potentially ever become a judge, how can regular people be expected to know what any of the laws are so as not to break them?
If the laws are so complex, how can any non-legal professional be be holden to it? Isn't there even a saying, "ignorance is no excuse to the law", but even some one who has been a lawyer for 20 years wouldn't claim they know all the law? I don't get how this can make any sense? Also, if it takes years to practice law...
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/16k06b/eli5_if_it_takes_years_of_study_to_become_a/
{ "a_id": [ "c7wpzgb", "c7wrll3", "c7wxpq7", "c7x11ek" ], "score": [ 2, 18, 4, 2 ], "text": [ " > Isn't there even a saying, \"ignorance is no excuse to the law\", but even some one who has been a lawyer for 20 years wouldn't claim they know all the law? I don't get how th...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "http://www.animallaw.info/articles/ovuslaceyact.htm" ], [], [] ]
vrt9o
hypothetically, if the trillion dollar deficit were paid off, who would be getting paid off?
And how did someone let someone else owe them a trillion dollars?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/vrt9o/hypothetically_if_the_trillion_dollar_deficit/
{ "a_id": [ "c5723di", "c5727ny", "c5733wv", "c573rly", "c573tqd" ], "score": [ 7, 11, 24, 3, 4 ], "text": [ "Everyone holding US Treasury securities would be getting paid off. The thing is, *they get paid off anyway*. All that reducing the debt to 0 would mean is t...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [], [] ]
2qwep3
What is the minimum amount of organs required to sustain a human life?
Unassisted, without medical technology to sustain you.
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2qwep3/what_is_the_minimum_amount_of_organs_required_to/
{ "a_id": [ "cnaot33" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Can you clarify what you mean by that?\nSome organs you can do without entirely and live (ie spleen, tonsils) though there may be health issues to a greater or lesser extent\n\nOther organs you need close to 100% of (ie the heart)\n\nOther organs...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
2q2qo9
Was 'The Pale' ever located in southeast Ireland?
I'm taking a course with an English professor and came across the following peculiar slide: _URL_0_ Ignore the map/legend itself (it appears to be a random choice) and the notes on the side. He marked the Pale in southeast Ireland, but the internet seems to say it was around Dublin. I know SE Ireland is where the Norm...
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2q2qo9/was_the_pale_ever_located_in_southeast_ireland/
{ "a_id": [ "cn2bagw", "cn38ba3" ], "score": [ 6, 3 ], "text": [ "You can't both ignore the legend and notes and still interpret the map. The map is of viking settlements in Ireland around 850 AD. The area ringed with yellow dots shows the area that was under viking control during that t...
[]
[ "https://imgur.com/59e2e29" ]
[ [ "http://www.lasalle.edu/~mcinneshin/356/wk05/images/Map%20of%20Ireland%20The%20English%20Pale.jpg" ], [ "http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/5/51/Ireland_1450.png" ] ]
1uyr2u
How come Ireland got christanized so early?
Ho come most of Ireland was christian by the 6th century despite little to none Roman contact, and Irish missionairies had to christianize other parts of Europe (Great-Britain, Low countries, Germania, Gaul) that had more contact with Roman culture and thus christianity?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1uyr2u/how_come_ireland_got_christanized_so_early/
{ "a_id": [ "cen2wrw" ], "score": [ 41 ], "text": [ "First, while, yes, the majority of Ireland was converted by the end of the fifth century, early Irish Christianity was **super weird**. Very little earlier mythology seems to have been completely abandoned, although the Irish did try to claim so...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
2m0n4o
Is there a reason why radio towers aren't used for wifi?
The title says it all really. Is there a physical reason why radio towers aren't used for wifi. It seems to me that something like Google fiber, where they are trying to provide high speed Internet to people at a low cost could be mitigated by providing high power radio waves. I know about the inverse square law, but ...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2m0n4o/is_there_a_reason_why_radio_towers_arent_used_for/
{ "a_id": [ "cm06sqn", "cm0klis", "cm143gi" ], "score": [ 2, 4, 2 ], "text": [ "wifi is in what is commonly referred to as the \"junk band\" - reserved for consumer use. The FCC limits how far the signals can propagate for that spectrum. and the reason for that is there is a limite...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
cvv89f
what happens if an individual can’t pay a large fine?
I was listening to the radio in the car and the ABC (Australian) was doing a bit about money laundering and unregistered money transferors. In the case that someone is unregistered, they receive a fine up to $500,000 AUD. What happens if the individual can’t pay that, simply due to a lack of money?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/cvv89f/eli5_what_happens_if_an_individual_cant_pay_a/
{ "a_id": [ "ey6lwhg" ], "score": [ 9 ], "text": [ "They probably cant.. theyll set u up w a payment plan or they can garnish wages, put a lien on your house, even put u in jail.. theyll get their money" ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
1ojcfj
When did the practice of attaching genders to words begin?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1ojcfj/when_did_the_practice_of_attaching_genders_to/
{ "a_id": [ "ccsjegx" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "You might try /r/linguistics! " ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
2k2mmv
Was there any equivalent to a homicide detective in ancient Greek and Roman times? Are there any surviving "detective stories" from those times?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2k2mmv/was_there_any_equivalent_to_a_homicide_detective/
{ "a_id": [ "clhg48o", "clhghv6", "clhkc6m", "clhvkz9" ], "score": [ 156, 220, 39, 4 ], "text": [ "**Greece:**\n\nTo answer the first question, It would be a yes, and a no. Yes, because the city of Athens developed a court for homicide called the [Areopagus](_URL_7_) (also ...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.crystalinks.com/greeklaw.html", "http://www.crystalinks.com/romelaw.html", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twelve_Tables", "http://books.google.com/books?id=UVf21mHdANgC&pg=PA240&lpg=PA240&dq=The+Areiopagos&source=bl&ots=_YMIYhtigk&sig=wxUrJUKI8Wl9cJ7I4gtJ00AiJRo&...
1sx2fb
why do current tv's still play static sound if there is no channel?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1sx2fb/eli5_why_do_current_tvs_still_play_static_sound/
{ "a_id": [ "ce23fdt" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "It's fake static. On many TV models if you look closely enough you can see that the \"static\" is a looped animation with just a few frames showing a simple white and black geometric pattern.\n\nIt's a great example of [skeumorphism](_URL_0_)." ...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skeumorphism" ] ]
6vuizw
Has there ever been black Roman Senators in Roman Republic?
So question is very obvious has there ever been black Roman senators in Roman Republic? I know there were some in Roman Empire but I'm not sure about Roman Republic. I would also welcome more information about black senators in Roman Empire? Also another question would be what was the ethnic composition in Roman Senat...
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6vuizw/has_there_ever_been_black_roman_senators_in_roman/
{ "a_id": [ "dm3lhik" ], "score": [ 7 ], "text": [ "Just to clarify, do you mean specifically someone with Sub-Saharan origins or anyone with skin much darker than the average Roman?" ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
bgj54c
why do you experience withdrawal from opiates but not from orgasms?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/bgj54c/eli5_why_do_you_experience_withdrawal_from/
{ "a_id": [ "ellbub3" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Opiates hack the brain's normal chemistry, forcing the brain to do things it's not designed to do. Chemical addictions trick the brain into thinking the drug is necessary to continue to live, whereas orgasms are a normal bodily process. Opiates a...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
a5u4z9
It seems like multiple large Christian sects in colonial America considered dancing to be evil. Where did this view of dance come from? What happened to it?
Was this a 17th century moral panic, or is there something deeper to it? What scriptures were used to vilify dancing? When did dancing become socially acceptable in American colonies/states that had previously frowned upon it? And how does Footloose fit into all this?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/a5u4z9/it_seems_like_multiple_large_christian_sects_in/
{ "a_id": [ "ebqa2nf" ], "score": [ 10 ], "text": [ "Follow up question: did any of these people feel the same about instruments? I was raised Church of Christ and dancing wasn't allowed, and instruments weren't allowed in the church (on your own time was fine, but I think we were pretty liberal t...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
1up34t
When did contractions like "won't" and "can't" start being used in the English language?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1up34t/when_did_contractions_like_wont_and_cant_start/
{ "a_id": [ "cekbdgu" ], "score": [ 6 ], "text": [ "You may also want to try the linguists in /r/linguistics or /r/AskSocialScience or in /r/Etymology." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
19nn0d
Is it possible to breakdown CO and/or CO2 into carbon and oxygen?
I know it's possible to use electrolysis to breakdown CO2 into CO and O; however, is it possible to break down CO2 directly into C and O or possible break up the CO from the first electrolysis into C and O?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/19nn0d/is_it_possible_to_breakdown_co_andor_co2_into/
{ "a_id": [ "c8povra", "c8pp5ij", "c8ps2f1" ], "score": [ 15, 4, 3 ], "text": [ "You can turn 2CO into 2C + O2 but it takes energy.", "Yes it is possible, however the process is endergonic (it requires energy), which I think is easy to see given that it is the reverse of combus...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "http://pubs.rsc.org/en/Content/ArticleLanding/2011/JM/c1jm11227a" ], [ "http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/19nn0d/is_it_possible_to_breakdown_co_andor_co2_into/c8pp5ij" ] ]
bb5urz
What were the chances of surviving the entire Great War?
If you were a British infantry soldier in the Army before 1914, what were your chances of surviving unscathed? Are there many memoirs lasting the whole war?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/bb5urz/what_were_the_chances_of_surviving_the_entire/
{ "a_id": [ "ekgqt1d", "ekl6l2e" ], "score": [ 6, 2 ], "text": [ "For a related question, see [What were your odds of surviving \"going over the top\" in a WWI trench?](_URL_0_) with a guess at the odds by /u/DuxBelisarius.", "Apologies if I'm doing this wrong - I'm relatively new here...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4glr0c/what_were_your_odds_of_surviving_going_over_the/" ], [ "https://www.greatwarforum.org/topic/171456-how-many-front-line-troops-survived/" ] ]
1mrcnd
what is the purpose of a dentist teeth cleaning appointment? what do they do that i can't do at home brushing my own teeth.
Is it really worth the money spent? They brush my teeth with a weird substance then floss them. Then I leave.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1mrcnd/eli5_what_is_the_purpose_of_a_dentist_teeth/
{ "a_id": [ "ccbwaph" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "Clean a lot more thoroughly, get rid of plaque, tartar and the sort. Generally flossing once a day and brushing once a day PROPERLY will prevent these build-ups and prevent gingivitis and other forms of gum disease, but for most people they aren'...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
2p9455
What are this things present on this milky way image ?
This is the image: _URL_1_ Why does this star has a black dot in the middle of it ? _URL_2_ Why isn't this portion of space as uniform as the others? _URL_0_
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/2p9455/what_are_this_things_present_on_this_milky_way/
{ "a_id": [ "cmuz873", "cmv0rm6" ], "score": [ 8, 2 ], "text": [ "1. Very likely the black spot in the middle of the star is an error of the imaging sensor. Basically the light at those pixel is so strong that it completely overpowered the sensor and it returned an erroneous value.\n\n2. A...
[]
[ "https://imgur.com/n8UlfGX", "djer.roe.ac.uk/vsa/vvv/iipmooviewer-2.0-beta/vvvgps5.html", "https://imgur.com/SD2TTpN" ]
[ [], [ "http://eldora.as.arizona.edu/Images/b68.jpg" ] ]
2t81gf
why do gummy candies become stale?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2t81gf/eli5_why_do_gummy_candies_become_stale/
{ "a_id": [ "cpjzv62" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "The same reason anything else becomes stale. \n\nIt starts to break down chemically. \n\nAll the little bonds holding something together will start to break down.\n\nTypically, there is something breaking down those bonds. It's sometimes bacteria...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
19p1kr
How far would you have to fall on Mars to reach terminal velocity, and how fast would you be falling?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/19p1kr/how_far_would_you_have_to_fall_on_mars_to_reach/
{ "a_id": [ "c8q29cw" ], "score": [ 4 ], "text": [ "See [this](_URL_0_). At the top of the page is the derivation of the formula for terminal velocity. And a bit further down there's a handy calculator to give you the terminal velocity. The initial values give 58 m/s for Earth which is pretty much...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://exploration.grc.nasa.gov/education/rocket/termvr.html" ] ]
6i844r
does mars (and any other planets for that matter) have plate tectonics like earth?
I think my understanding of plate tectonics is a bit lacking at best. I always thought it was something unique to earth due to the water. Do other planets act similarly? Mars for instance. I just thought it would be crazy if stuff was moving about on Mars causing earthquakes and what not the way things happen here on E...
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/6i844r/eli5_does_mars_and_any_other_planets_for_that/
{ "a_id": [ "dj465od", "dj465td", "dj4i2f4", "dj55tpo" ], "score": [ 7, 4, 3, 2 ], "text": [ " > I always thought it was something unique to earth due to the water.\n\nNo, it is due to having an active molten core. Some moons of the gas giants have molten cores, and basica...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [ "https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.theatlantic.com/amp/article/406516/" ] ]
181r4z
What was the general attitude towards electricity when it was first introduced?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/181r4z/what_was_the_general_attitude_towards_electricity/
{ "a_id": [ "c8b36r5" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Benjamin Harrison was psi dent when the White House was electrified. Though he was too afraid to turn the lights on and off himself for fear of electrocution. Not the best answer but an anecdote to give you an idea that , like all new technolog...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
4cvolb
why does vision in one eye get worse than the other?
Many people I know, including myself, have vision worse in one eye in comparison to the other. What causes this and why is it so common? Shouldn't eyesight be the same in both eyes?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4cvolb/eli5_why_does_vision_in_one_eye_get_worse_than/
{ "a_id": [ "d1lr9hd", "d1lry4f", "d1lry6m" ], "score": [ 9, 11, 7 ], "text": [ "It would be amazing if two bits of your body which aren't connected managed to stay the same. Almost none of your symmetrical bits are actually like one another when you look closely, and it doesn't ta...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anisometropia" ], [], [] ]
4g7xpu
Why do older commercial buildings (roughly 1880-1920) have such high ceilings? What purpose did they serve?
I live in the northern Midwest. We have a lot of buildings with high ceilings like [this](_URL_0_). They were also common in Virginia. I would think they would be hard to keep heated. Did they serve some other purpose that outweighed the heating problems?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4g7xpu/why_do_older_commercial_buildings_roughly/
{ "a_id": [ "d2fk3u3" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "The first air-conditioning system was made in 1902. Having a high ceiling in a public building would make cooling cheaper if the building only has one floor. \n\nYou know if have a 2 story home you turn on the air-conditioning on on the second fl...
[]
[ "https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/11/b0/a7/11b0a772104b4e8f2c90a088d4aece41.jpg" ]
[ [] ]
1nbm8m
what causes the white substance to form in your mouth when you wake up?
Is it bad? Why does it form? Sorry in advance if this grosses anyone out, I just always wondered what it is.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1nbm8m/eli5_what_causes_the_white_substance_to_form_in/
{ "a_id": [ "cch429g" ], "score": [ 6 ], "text": [ "It is dried saliva and mucus." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
arhxdq
Does THC get Stored in your Body and Released?
My boyfriend says that he can't exercise because when he does THC stored in his body gets released and he trips out. I'd say this was a BS excuse not to exercise, but apparently this is true of Acid. It stores itself in your body fat and gets released when you exercise. Is there any backing for his claim about THC?
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/arhxdq/does_thc_get_stored_in_your_body_and_released/
{ "a_id": [ "ego4y0b", "ego5j8v" ], "score": [ 16, 5 ], "text": [ "No. Since some of the components of marijuana are fat soluble, they do get stored in the body for a relatively long time, but they do not have any noticeable psychoactive effects during that period. It’s not even true for a...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "https://www.webmd.com/mental-health/addiction/news/20050207/marijuanas-effects-linger-in-brain", "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/m/pubmed/12404577/" ] ]
92dh2r
Are there documented cases of schizophrenics who hear only positive, encouraging voices?
I have already seen [this thread](_URL_0_) which is not satisfactorily answered, IMO, and also is phrased in a way that is a bit different from my own. My wife works in the mental health field and she told me a story last night about a conversation she had with her workmates. Basically the question was asked: > Why ...
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/92dh2r/are_there_documented_cases_of_schizophrenics_who/
{ "a_id": [ "e37h9o1", "e37jia4" ], "score": [ 7, 3 ], "text": [ "Studies show two things - that people who cope well with voices tend to hear more positive things (and apparently by focusing on the positive voices, they get more of that and less negative over time), and that there is a c...
[]
[ "https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/3cirxo/is_it_possible_to_have_auditory_hallucinations/" ]
[ [], [ "https://news.stanford.edu/2014/07/16/voices-culture-luhrmann-071614/" ] ]
6a8hua
when birds tear into the dirt looking for worms, are they just blindly excavating, or do they have some reason to believe a worm is right there?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/6a8hua/eli5_when_birds_tear_into_the_dirt_looking_for/
{ "a_id": [ "dhcj22d", "dhcjuzy", "dhcjyrk", "dhckulj", "dhclap8" ], "score": [ 34, 17, 570, 31, 3 ], "text": [ "Birds can see movement on the ground easily from the air. Now if you're specifically talking about chickens they're probably just randomly scratching eat...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [], [] ]
1smh04
Why did Thailand become such a huge centre for tourism?
I mean, I can understand some basic reasons (inviting tropical weather, interesting history, cheaper prices compared to developed countries, etc.) but it shares all of those traits with it's immediate neighbours. Why Thailand, and not, say, Vietnam or Malaysia?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1smh04/why_did_thailand_become_such_a_huge_centre_for/
{ "a_id": [ "cdz18pu", "cdz1d6z", "cdz1tzc" ], "score": [ 8, 5, 4 ], "text": [ "It's the only country in the region that has favourable conditions for tourism. \n\n* Myanmar - oppressive dictatorship\n\n* Malaysia - Muslim country, which means no sex tourism, and it's more expensiv...
[]
[]
[ [], [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/U-Tapao_International_Airport", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siam", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burma_Railway" ], [ "http://books.google.com/books?isbn=085199704X", "http://repository.kulib.kyoto-u.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2433/56779/1/KJ00000132246.pdf...
4sk8sb
Practical filtration method to remove lead from water?
What's the most practical way to remove lead from water? Not using chemicals preferably... Online there're home filters that claim to remove lead, although I couldn't exactly find out how they work.
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/4sk8sb/practical_filtration_method_to_remove_lead_from/
{ "a_id": [ "d5a9bvc", "d5ano07" ], "score": [ 3, 2 ], "text": [ "I believe activated carbon filters it well, as long as you remember to change the carbon as needed. The zero water filter system seems to be good and it comes with a conductivity test meter that is easy to use and will tell ...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
1vwzb2
Was there ever a time when gunpowder and knights took the battlefield together?
Hello /r/AskHistorians, I was recently reading two books of the same series one titled Battles of the Medieval World, the other Battles of the Oriental World. My question came to being because while the Battles of the Oriental World delt a good deal about how primitive gunpowder weapons were fielded with spears and s...
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1vwzb2/was_there_ever_a_time_when_gunpowder_and_knights/
{ "a_id": [ "cewl97r" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "You may be interested in some of the threads in the '[Early firearms](_URL_0_)' section of the Popular Questions pages.\n" ] }
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/war#wiki_early_firearms" ] ]
pd8sv
How do we determine that a vaccine for a potentially fatal disease is fit for human usage? Wouldn't there be ethics violations at preliminary stages of testing?
So I imagine that the vaccine is made to act on a sample of cells, and then given positive results, they go ahead with the next level of testing. To know that a vaccine truly does work, I imagine you'd have to vaccinate a healthy individual and then try and infect the person with the virus the vaccine is supposed to ...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/pd8sv/how_do_we_determine_that_a_vaccine_for_a/
{ "a_id": [ "c3ofs0m", "c3og0wb", "c3og256" ], "score": [ 50, 7, 3 ], "text": [ "After animal testing shows a promising result, they move on to human testing. The first step is to try it on already infected (and then healthy) **volunteers** to make sure there are no bad reactions ...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.ctv.ca/CTVNews/TopStories/20111220/canadian-hiv-vaccine-trials-111220/" ], [], [] ]
3beph3
why can phone battery-bars act so erratic?
My girlfriend frequently complains about how the battery on her iPhone will drop from 50% to 8% in an instant without any clear cause. I've seen this issue on my Android as well, though it was 100% to 96% in an instant from browsing reddit this morning. Perhaps it's just based on a measured update-cycle instead of con...
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3beph3/eli5_why_can_phone_batterybars_act_so_erratic/
{ "a_id": [ "cslg7g2", "cslgr84" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "Can't speak for Android, but for iPhone, you should take it to the Apple Store so that they can replace the battery, usually for free.", "For the 100%-90% drop, that's an easy answer. Your phone lies to you when it says...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
2gmjzy
what would happen if you brought a really strong telescope to space and pointed it at earth?
Would the telescope function properly? If so, would it be possible to see buildings and humans if the telescope is strong enough?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/2gmjzy/eli5_what_would_happen_if_you_brought_a_really/
{ "a_id": [ "ckkj0ae" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "Yes to both your questions. See: Spy satellites." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
32rmpm
when did the idea of gym begin?
(Gym as in for muscle building) Did they have a similar concept back in the middle ages or anything like that?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/32rmpm/eli5_when_did_the_idea_of_gym_begin/
{ "a_id": [ "cqe08lz", "cqe1806" ], "score": [ 3, 3 ], "text": [ "“No man has the right to be an amateur in the matter of physical training. It is a shame for a man to grow old without seeing the beauty and strength of which his body is capable.” -Socrates\n\nThe idea goes back a while... ...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
1ex38t
Do fundamental particles exist in 16 dimensions, but we "experience" them in only 3? How can dimensions be folded up inside other ones?
I've heard that string theory predicts up to 16 dimensions. Does this mean the universe is 16 dimensional but our brains can only determine 3 of them? By extension, do we (and everything else) live in the 16 D space but only experience 3D? Also, apparently some "tiny dimensions" can be curled up into other ones. WTF d...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1ex38t/do_fundamental_particles_exist_in_16_dimensions/
{ "a_id": [ "ca4metr", "ca4mlrh", "ca4qnyg" ], "score": [ 11, 4, 3 ], "text": [ "I can't really comment on the 16 dimensional stuff since I'm not a string theorist, but I have a good analogy to understand the 'curled up dimensions'.\n\nConsider a long string or cable. When you hold...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
1me3sf
why is it so hard for smokers to stop smoking?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1me3sf/eli5_why_is_it_so_hard_for_smokers_to_stop_smoking/
{ "a_id": [ "cc8bjp1", "cc8bwds" ], "score": [ 2, 15 ], "text": [ "For starters, nicotine is extremely addictive. The withdrawal symptoms affect both body and mind, with cravings and mood swings quite frequent.\n\nAnd another factor is that smoking is largely a thoughtless habit ... you do...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
1fr6wg
why can american porn websites sell porn by simply asking if people are over 18, when store owners have to ask for id.
Just wondering if there is a legal reason or if it's just a practicality issue.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1fr6wg/eli5_why_can_american_porn_websites_sell_porn_by/
{ "a_id": [ "cad0qag" ], "score": [ 4 ], "text": [ "Websites \"sell porn\" by asking for a Credit Card, that is their age verification measure. \n\nIf you are asking why you only have to click \"I am over 18\" to view a porn site, it comes down to business vs burden. \n\nFirst of all, by requiring...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
827qu8
The dawn of the year 2000 was celebrated and feared in many parts of the world. How was the dawn of the year 1000 viewed, in those parts of the world that observed years in this way?
The dawn of the second millenium was met with many theories about the millenium bug and other theories of mass confusion and difficulties. How was the dawn of the first millenium (1000 AD) viewed before it occurred? Was there as much of a reaction by the general public and/or policymakers? Was it celebrated in any spec...
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/827qu8/the_dawn_of_the_year_2000_was_celebrated_and/
{ "a_id": [ "dv83at5" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "This question pops upon this sub occasionally, and even though more can always be said, you may be interested in checking out these old answers:\n\n* [Was the millennium from 999-1000 ad marked in any special way?](_URL_1_) by u/savvysioux\n* [Di...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1powhu/did_people_in_999_ad_celebrate_the_new_millennium/cd52461/", "https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/53sxwl/was_the_millennium_from_9991000_ad_marked_in_any/d7y708j/" ] ]
8bm9cm
Is it possible to only be half down syndrome?
I saw on the front page a cat that had Chimerism. (_URL_0_) And down a few replies was a link to a woman that had chimerism. (_URL_1_) It said since she had two sets of DNA, two immune systems, they would constantly try to fight each other ,causing an immune disorder. That made me wonder if you had two distinct sets o...
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/8bm9cm/is_it_possible_to_only_be_half_down_syndrome/
{ "a_id": [ "dx9107p" ], "score": [ 4 ], "text": [ "The short answer to your question is that yes, this is possible. It’s called [Mosaic Down Syndrome](_URL_0_), and it occurs in something like 2-4% of Down Syndrome cases. However, I don’t think it has to do with chimerism as you’re describing it....
[]
[ "https://www.reddit.com/r/woahdude/comments/8bl3g3/a_chimera_cat_its_2_distinct_cats_in_one", "https://nypost.com/2017/12/22/this-woman-is-her-own-twin-sister/" ]
[ [ "http://www.stanfordchildrens.org/en/topic/default?id=mosaic-down-syndrome-90-P02133" ] ]
wt3wx
losing your voice.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/wt3wx/eli5_losing_your_voice/
{ "a_id": [ "c5g7hff" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "Your throat has a \"voice box\" made up of bands of muscle called vocal cords. When you talk, the air that passes through your vocal cords sets off vibrations that make the sound of your voice. So if your vocal cords are swollen, they block a lot...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
70ks2q
how do missile defense systems like thaad and aegis work, and are they adequate against missile attacks?
Specifically, how successful can they be in defending SK, Japan, Hawaii, or the US mainland from missiles?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/70ks2q/eli5how_do_missile_defense_systems_like_thaad_and/
{ "a_id": [ "dn3vwfd" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "No one really knows they're effectiveness because they've never truly been tested in a real world attack, and any secret tests aren't going to be released because releasing that information publicly would reveal any weaknesses the systems have, a...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
1itu2l
Why does Japan continue to hold animosity towards China and Korea over events that transpired in WWII but doesn't still hate the US for bombing them?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1itu2l/why_does_japan_continue_to_hold_animosity_towards/
{ "a_id": [ "cb818xb", "cb82okd", "cb82xsq", "cb89d2v" ], "score": [ 50, 14, 24, 9 ], "text": [ "What makes you think Japan holds animosity towards China and Korea? I mean it's obviously true in reverse, but this is the first time I've heard of this. \n\nAlso the idea that ...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_war_apology_statements_issued_by_Japan" ], [] ]
6fz8bu
How are we able to differentiate religious texts from ancient fiction?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6fz8bu/how_are_we_able_to_differentiate_religious_texts/
{ "a_id": [ "dim7mqt" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "Maybe this is worth it's own thread, but can I extend this and ask how we can distinguish *any* ancient texts? For example, when were the transition points where ancient epics went from preserving history to being entertainment, morality tales, ...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
re10o
Quantum mechanics act at a scale of 100 nm or less. Is the transition to the realm of Classical mechanics smooth or abrupt?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/re10o/quantum_mechanics_act_at_a_scale_of_100_nm_or/
{ "a_id": [ "c451sfk", "c452bd5" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ " > Is the transition to the realm of classical mechanics smooth or abrupt?\n\nSmooth. You can recover classical mechanics from quantum mechanics if you carefully take the limit as hbar goes to zero.", "Smooth. Things a...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
5i08bg
how do organisms without brains (starfish, trees, jellyfish, etc) know how to "do" things like mate, flip over, swim, etc?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/5i08bg/eli5_how_do_organisms_without_brains_starfish/
{ "a_id": [ "db4ckji", "db4f21c" ], "score": [ 5, 3 ], "text": [ "Stimuli lead to certain responses which cause changes in the organism's behavior, kind of like how a complicated machine can react in different ways to different switches and levers because they cause a different cascade of ...
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
cq027t
In medieval times balcksmiths' apprentices had to get up well before dawn to get the furnace hot. How was this done before alarm clocks were invented?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/cq027t/in_medieval_times_balcksmiths_apprentices_had_to/
{ "a_id": [ "ewwea07" ], "score": [ 3 ], "text": [ "First, it's often noted here that the medieval period lasted around a thousand years, so it's hard to generalize about the whole of it.\n\nBut, a very short answer would be that the blacksmith's wife woke him up, because as an apprentice he was a...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
4dr62d
how come ads on my computer are based on what kinds of websites i go on, but in cell phone apps all i get are clash of clans ads?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4dr62d/eli5_how_come_ads_on_my_computer_are_based_on/
{ "a_id": [ "d1tn2q0", "d1toqku", "d1tpimm", "d1tpwgw", "d1tqnej", "d1tryw7" ], "score": [ 3, 13, 173, 3, 21, 5 ], "text": [ "If you are asking because you want to know how to turn it off, and you have Windows 10 here's how; Click the start menu icon, go to ...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [ "espn.com" ], [], [] ]
1urkvp
Who are some of history's lesser known/under appreciated martyrs?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1urkvp/who_are_some_of_historys_lesser_knownunder/
{ "a_id": [ "cel4e8a" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Udham Singh. British colonial rule in India was very oppressive to the Indians. Resources were plundered, racial and religious tensions were sparked, and the common folk were getting taxed out of homes, fields, and food. Forcing entire generation...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
1e23w9
So what's the story behind the European micro-states (Andorra, Lichtenstein, etc)?
Why were they able to maintain their independence and not get gobbled up by their more powerful neighbors?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1e23w9/so_whats_the_story_behind_the_european/
{ "a_id": [ "c9w7ah9" ], "score": [ 25 ], "text": [ "This was asked a few months ago and got some pretty good explanations.\n\n_URL_0_" ] }
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/13ebo4/how_have_the_microsmall_states_of_europe_andorra/" ] ]
3porrt
How certain is it that Catherine De Medici organized the Saint Bartholomew's Day Massacre?
I've read several books each alleging varying degrees of her involvement from complete ignorance to full on director of the scheme. How can we be sure?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/3porrt/how_certain_is_it_that_catherine_de_medici/
{ "a_id": [ "cw8qz9w" ], "score": [ 5 ], "text": [ "It will be great to know which books you have read.\n\nThe Bartholomew's Day Massacre comprises of several distinct stages, namely the assassination attempt on Coligny the leader of the Huguenots, then the order to murder the Huguenot leaders in ...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
31xplk
why is that many people (incluiding myself) feel extra motivated to make a big change during night time?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/31xplk/eli5_why_is_that_many_people_incluiding_myself/
{ "a_id": [ "cq5y816", "cq627j9", "cq6507m", "cq65r93" ], "score": [ 71, 8, 8, 6 ], "text": [ "You know you don't have to do it. You know you're about to go to bed and you can put it off for several hours. In the morning you will actually have to face doing the task you set...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [] ]
btiy9s
how knockoff or off brand toys/items are manufactured and actually end up in stores in the west
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/btiy9s/eli5_how_knockoff_or_off_brand_toysitems_are/
{ "a_id": [ "ep1492o" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Most items are made in China. Usually the factory that makes them have all the tools to make more and sometimes after the brands order has been filled they're left with raw resources so they'll make their own batch and sell it to make more money ...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
5w3luc
What would it take to simulate a neural network as complex as the human brain in real time?
Also, is it possible (now or in the future) to efficiently handle this type of operation a quantum processor?
askscience
https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/5w3luc/what_would_it_take_to_simulate_a_neural_network/
{ "a_id": [ "de8brtt" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Neural Networks don't work the same way as the human brain. We won't be able to simulate the brain until we know how it works, that is the primary barrier to this right now.\n\nA [survey of experts](_URL_1_) puts an estimate of a 50% chance of ha...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://waitbutwhy.com/2015/01/artificial-intelligence-revolution-1.html", "http://www.nickbostrom.com/papers/survey.pdf" ] ]
1fo791
What were hospitality rituals and why were they important in their respective societies?
AskHistorians
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1fo791/what_were_hospitality_rituals_and_why_were_they/
{ "a_id": [ "cac6glf" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Hospitality rituals could range from taking one's shoes of before entering a house to something more specific. For instance, the Lakota tribe had an interesting policy where the less words that were spoken, the more polite the guest seemed. It's ...
[]
[]
[ [ "stanford.edu" ] ]
1jek08
how a wave breaks
I get that it has something to do with the wave hitting land, but I'm having a hard time with it, and would like explained.
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1jek08/eli5_how_a_wave_breaks/
{ "a_id": [ "cbdw7ab", "cbdwbrv" ], "score": [ 2, 2 ], "text": [ "So if we're talking specifically about beach waves, it's not very complicated. The wave is pushed by the wind toward the beach. But as the water goes up the beach, it eventually reaches a high point, after which it wants to ...
[]
[]
[ [ "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8y1MkFZSwIs" ], [] ]
fy8koy
how do alarm systems know when a door or window has been opened?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/fy8koy/eli5_how_do_alarm_systems_know_when_a_door_or/
{ "a_id": [ "fmyrzfg" ], "score": [ 6 ], "text": [ "The installers put a pair of tiny magnets somewhere on the door (one on the door, one on the frame.) If you open the door, the system can tell that you’ve separated the magnets because it breaks a circuit." ] }
[]
[]
[ [] ]
4pnb3c
Why did the Nazis end up annexing the Czech Republic, but only installed a puppet government in Slovakia?
AskHistorians
https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/4pnb3c/why_did_the_nazis_end_up_annexing_the_czech/
{ "a_id": [ "d4n5hwg" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "The Czech region of Czechoslovakia (Bohemia and Moravia) developed much differently than the Slovak region prior to their integration in 1918. The Czech lands had been the center of industrialization for the Hapsburg empire, while Slovakia had b...
[]
[]
[ [] ]
3mpo0j
why do you think europe as a whole is less obese compared to the states?
[deleted]
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/3mpo0j/eli5_why_do_you_think_europe_as_a_whole_is_less/
{ "a_id": [ "cvgzasm", "cvgzj7y", "cvgzthf", "cvh0two", "cvh55s8" ], "score": [ 7, 6, 30, 3, 3 ], "text": [ "When I lived in the UK, I was struck by how often it just made sense to walk my errands, rather than drive . That's a lot more casual exercise. ", "Wal...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [], [], [ "http://news.yahoo.com/europe-faces-massive-obesity-problem-study-222035428.html" ] ]
yrobm
Negative pressure/space?
Would it theoretically be possible to create negative space? Say you had a box made of diamond, attached to the most powerful machine on the earth that allowed the box to expand. If you created a vacuum in this box and then tried expanding the box, what would happen? Sorry if this is a dumb question, and I know you can...
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/yrobm/negative_pressurespace/
{ "a_id": [ "c5y7big", "c5y7f3s", "c5y7jnj" ], "score": [ 5, 3, 3 ], "text": [ "There would still be a vacuum. A true vacuum means that there is zero matter in the box. Even if you made the box bigger, there would still be zero matter, and thus still a vacuum.", "You would have...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
1kcmaj
the difference between rubbing alcohol (isopropyl) and hydrogen proxide
Aside from the different chemical compositions (are they really that different?), when is it a good time to use rubbing alcohol on a wound vs hydrogen proxide? Will one help your wound heal faster, or do they both work in a similar manner?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1kcmaj/eli5_the_difference_between_rubbing_alcohol/
{ "a_id": [ "cbnk9km", "cbnkl2v", "cbnoieu" ], "score": [ 2, 2, 2 ], "text": [ " > Are they really that different?\n\nYes, yes they are. Hydrogen peroxide is H2O2 while isopropanol is C3H7OH. Alcohols generally behave very differently from peroxides.\n\n > Will one help your woun...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [] ]
72kufw
why haven't new alphabets been introduced in our languages?
explainlikeimfive
https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/72kufw/eli5_why_havent_new_alphabets_been_introduced_in/
{ "a_id": [ "dnj87a3" ], "score": [ 2 ], "text": [ "Its more like alphabets slowly evolve and change over time, no one does it on purpose and it never happens quickly. But you can see the effects of it over time. Here's a good example: _URL_0_\n\nYou probably can't read that. But that's actually E...
[]
[]
[ [ "https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/08/Beowulf.firstpage.jpeg" ] ]
xjg4a
Can you catch STDs from a corpse?
What started as a dumb drunken conversation between friends, has turned into a real curiosity, sadly. If so, for how long is it transmittable? Is it different from STD to STD?
askscience
http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/xjg4a/can_you_catch_stds_from_a_corpse/
{ "a_id": [ "c5mw2sl", "c5n0sv3" ], "score": [ 21, 2 ], "text": [ "Yes. And it would vary with STD. A blood borne STD like AIDS wouldn't last too long, but crabs would hang out for quite a while.\n\nAnd eww.", "One of the few posts that actually made me cring at the though.." ] }
[]
[]
[ [], [] ]
24q35n
how do calculators do math?
explainlikeimfive
http://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/24q35n/eli5_how_do_calculators_do_math/
{ "a_id": [ "ch9kfjr", "ch9kg4d", "ch9kifw", "ch9l086", "ch9micy", "ch9opy4", "ch9rvk1", "ch9shh6", "ch9uw3v", "ch9w1sd", "cha1zlw", "cha9u5j" ], "score": [ 112, 2, 2, 4, 8, 26, 4, 5, 6, 20, 2, 2 ], "text": [ "...
[]
[]
[ [], [], [ "http://www.vintage-technology.info/pages/calculators/general/calcwork/calcwork.htm" ], [], [], [ "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8k65Io-qsB0" ], [ "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signed_number_representations#Two.27s_complement", "http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shunting-yard_a...