question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>The decay mode of Carbon-8 is listed as 'XP' in this <a href="http://ie.lbl.gov/education/parent/C_iso.htm" rel="nofollow">table</a>. None of the references I looked at listed XP as a decay mode. What is it></p>
g4187
[ 0.02287343144416809, -0.011652403511106968, -0.011828877963125706, 0.011220179498195648, 0.09275931119918823, 0.0407123900949955, 0.004916737321764231, 0.02364853210747242, 0.0063158804550766945, -0.0580451600253582, -0.037265948951244354, -0.023916956037282944, 0.05864572525024414, 0.007056191097944975, 0.024191835895180702, -0.056707654148340225, 0.04086374491453171, 0.041864342987537384, 0.05550393462181091, 0.048091135919094086, -0.05336827412247658, -0.0507265143096447, -0.015354884788393974, -0.01943439431488514, 0.01790575124323368, 0.005802478175610304, -0.02543400600552559, 0.00040495747816748917, -0.025960613042116165, -0.013621823862195015, 0.027582155540585518, -0.024675507098436356, 0.06537708640098572, -0.006749326828867197, 0.043995440006256104, -0.04760591313242912, 0.019623082131147385, 0.08062149584293365, -0.008870113641023636, 0.007391807157546282, -0.0060831159353256226, -0.009579977951943874, 0.05354980006814003, 0.011171494610607624, -0.0547548346221447, 0.03887089341878891, -0.04485410451889038, -0.027318289503455162, -0.019182918593287468, -0.026489783078432083, 0.023233812302350998, 0.002853396814316511, 0.06623103469610214, -0.038996610790491104, -0.04890524968504906, -0.002205917378887534, -0.07984580844640732, -0.0059042745269834995, 0.02430829592049122, -0.019285503774881363, 0.022625001147389412, -0.02077115885913372, 0.10778529196977615, 0.009885248728096485, 0.015175643377006054, -0.005087818950414658, 0.020604610443115234, 0.02100634016096592, -0.015928953886032104, -0.07399408519268036, -0.002636882709339261, 0.0017595711397007108, -0.01324409618973732, -0.04868282005190849, 0.006524594034999609, -0.031023340299725533, 0.01776619255542755, -0.05116657540202141, -0.012461460195481777, 0.004483075346797705, -0.03492055460810661, 0.05362211912870407, 0.0007379955495707691, 0.02199699729681015, -0.007462735287845135, 0.05107467994093895, -0.06174585968255997, 0.01004164107143879, -0.038887254893779755, -0.020429763942956924, 0.014675158075988293, -0.004490160848945379, 0.024565834552049637, -0.05761886388063431, -0.0005150569486431777, -0.002236689208075404, 0.0006023702444508672, 0.0369902066886425, 0.01229524239897728, 0.01804199069738388, -0.02953713946044445, -0.06891258805990219, -0.047519005835056305, -0.04232931137084961, 0.029881535097956657, -0.008115756325423717, -0.03007512353360653, -0.04723953828215599, 0.02891826257109642, -0.005466478876769543, -0.023887958377599716, 0.025344334542751312, -0.08563069254159927, -0.01395213883370161, 0.014618882909417152, -0.059448983520269394, 0.022779813036322594, -0.04564318060874939, 0.05701908469200134, -0.00379763706587255, 0.04905632510781288, 0.0024024287704378366, -0.014954205602407455, -0.016007868573069572, 0.01451069861650467, -0.0221750196069479, 0.037496648728847504, -0.049520041793584824, 0.01877203956246376, -0.005586431827396154, -0.0307615976780653, 0.05945122241973877, -0.05468928441405296, 0.014225800521671772, 0.01561671867966652, 0.04089558124542236, -0.04327470809221268, 0.0321228951215744, -0.06430931389331818, -0.02029561996459961, 0.004672760143876076, 0.02606348507106304, 0.029127534478902817, -0.03596717491745949, 0.010144125670194626, 0.0030712448060512543, 0.03461454436182976, 0.040793709456920624, 0.07458415627479553, 0.024023989215493202, 0.005580372642725706, -0.022239534184336662, 0.005584282334893942, -0.048346444964408875, -0.05297095701098442, -0.04227696731686592, 0.0545654222369194, -0.05469394102692604, -0.04058456793427467, 0.09855131804943085, -0.02005675807595253, -0.009421614930033684, -0.021608291193842888, 0.019752835854887962, -0.05464445799589157, -0.06477455794811249, -0.0005634861881844699, -0.01787208765745163, 0.02911505103111267, 0.022943465039134026, -0.019261669367551804, -0.0008922124397940934, 0.03277746960520744, -0.007806898094713688, -0.02292044460773468, -0.014890370890498161, -0.012152698822319508, 0.012630391865968704, 0.02134098671376705, 0.033789053559303284, -0.009503677487373352, 0.022443901747465134, 0.03104584850370884, -0.03274165093898773, 0.06021722033619881, -0.013300477527081966, -0.02058694325387478, -0.004263184033334255, 0.022929787635803223, -0.004783928394317627, -0.009697549045085907, -0.04657018184661865, 0.03960299491882324, 0.008680340833961964, 0.03828528895974159, -0.02913447469472885, -0.02938142791390419, -0.07005224376916885, 0.01760767214000225, -0.01899612508714199, -0.017754796892404556, -0.03627559915184975, -0.0019375222036615014, 0.028578393161296844, -0.02100200206041336, -0.02320108748972416, -0.0520627386868, 0.014190840534865856, 0.03237128630280495, -0.006543009076267481, 0.04899391159415245, -0.0003432190860621631, 0.001617525122128427, -0.004143828060477972, -0.061983730643987656, -0.04812680929899216, -0.011098597198724747, 0.028315164148807526, -0.0016593839973211288, 0.05033772438764572, -0.003765119705349207, -0.053038399666547775, -0.015047816559672356, 0.011510220356285572, 0.08978426456451416, 0.047458428889513016, -0.03787051513791084, -0.00650448352098465, -0.004052420612424612, 0.05455826222896576, -0.0330469086766243, -0.05678904801607132, -0.05563253536820412, -0.057756368070840836, 0.006736218463629484, 0.023816794157028198, -0.006300244480371475, 0.02027467079460621, -0.07707997411489487, 0.07696259021759033, 0.005519955884665251, -0.036128442734479904, -0.031988050788640976, 0.007241153623908758, 0.02146390825510025, 0.01993347704410553, -0.0288938470184803, -0.02681635692715645, -0.07961380481719971, 0.008050687611103058, 0.0012869942001998425, -0.018587995320558548, -0.024099791422486305, 0.06071367487311363, 0.02511722594499588, -0.009073221124708652, 0.028606217354536057, -0.0004152523761149496, -0.11016523092985153, 0.01145560760051012, 0.023747118189930916, -0.031560320407152176, -0.04378849267959595, -0.02742130681872368, 0.01536871399730444, -0.022798415273427963, -0.04549967870116234, -0.04632444679737091, -0.03080596774816513, -0.005845607258379459, -0.03018980845808983, 0.07746144384145737, -0.057762764394283295, -0.012773201800882816, -0.014396592043340206, -0.003825890365988016, 0.03819494694471359, 0.012345450930297375, -0.03168993070721626, -0.05276608467102051, 0.000489394529722631, -0.016949651762843132, 0.008647763170301914, 0.015034477226436138, -0.006047146860510111, -0.00926090870052576, -0.02355951815843582, 0.013562136329710484, -0.05652250349521637, -0.015460420399904251, 0.00021614150318782777, -0.047228384763002396, 0.029433229938149452, 0.007790662348270416, 0.06268203258514404, -0.028315242379903793, 0.05575164780020714, -0.009533490054309368, 0.00015825928130652755, 0.01612827368080616, 0.029790719971060753, -0.04459227994084358, -0.04364943504333496, -0.06756182760000229, 0.03912493214011192, -0.015932001173496246, 0.008007336407899857, 0.041899874806404114, 0.0007542979437857866, 0.04845619201660156, -0.022481011226773262, 0.0006177593604661524, -0.037114325910806656, 0.0636419951915741, 0.00373102817684412, 0.06087562069296837, 0.01627587154507637, -0.01587488315999508, 0.06311574578285217, -0.06630922853946686, -0.013672457076609135, 0.004426757805049419, 0.04547750577330589, 0.03528398275375366, -0.0006563775823451579, 0.0034216849599033594, -0.025595149025321007, -0.0395364835858345, 0.020384173840284348, -0.007664927281439304, 0.04368623346090317, -0.013742268085479736, 0.021354688331484795, 0.009770927019417286, -0.05818633362650871, -0.03942640498280525, -0.014886198565363884, 0.027612483128905296, 0.010197711177170277, -0.05075804516673088, 0.07243415713310242, 0.003120622131973505, 0.037560150027275085, 0.012066503055393696, 0.04649029299616814, 0.002736781956627965, -0.012048304080963135, 0.016574380919337273, -0.008039726875722408, 0.012951699085533619, 0.030420051887631416, 0.009265965782105923, -0.029118822887539864, -0.010073338635265827, -0.026569446548819542, 0.0003257512580603361, -0.03813161328434944, -0.0073711504228413105, -0.0215913075953722, 0.03961040824651718, -0.007582071702927351, 0.010745266452431679, 0.030223896726965904, 0.001403174246661365, 0.0024816289078444242, 0.011318876408040524, -0.00020989120821468532, 0.034795768558979034, 0.045151613652706146, 0.02595428191125393, -0.00783165916800499, -0.020362213253974915, 0.01243077963590622, -0.03161315619945526, -0.004867542069405317, -0.004187780432403088, -0.028380339965224266, 0.03100590780377388, -0.03925912454724312, 0.09200014173984528, -0.010035068728029728, -0.03956790640950203, 0.11084038764238358, 0.011373789981007576, 0.015199458226561546, -0.054346777498722076, -0.011908524669706821, -0.0020664772018790245, 0.0401325449347496, 0.046816807240247726, 0.0012953494442626834, 0.009502742439508438, -0.010544424876570702, 0.04424383491277695, -0.026144467294216156, -0.019242683425545692, -0.010434857569634914, 0.020468177273869514, -0.014012179337441921, 0.016162153333425522, -0.06024572253227234, 0.022333968430757523, -0.021354999393224716, 0.05677351728081703, 0.04143420234322548, 0.08807158470153809, -0.01999388076364994, -0.04185181483626366, 0.0029247545171529055, -0.005673367064446211, 0.010992460884153843, -0.030466774478554726, -0.019571596756577492, 0.013324477709829807, -0.0019684627186506987, -0.004248819779604673, 0.031208230182528496, -0.00016587591380812228, 0.06085988134145737, 0.0018148652743548155, 0.005719542037695646, 0.006522851530462503, -0.04022078216075897, 0.011702450923621655, -0.08341999351978302, 0.07828311622142792, -0.04377616196870804, 0.04165910184383392, -0.015046942047774792, -0.014718844555318356, 0.03337979316711426, -0.042384691536426544, -0.01412164606153965, 0.019611138850450516, -0.036301326006650925, 0.03461170941591263, 0.054342057555913925, -0.009272709488868713, -0.001307427417486906, 0.06050518527626991, 0.11807013303041458, -0.002050861483439803, 0.01986924558877945, 0.006434170063585043, -0.041714899241924286, 0.022367501631379128, 0.05473974347114563, -0.039167825132608414, 0.024680810049176216, 0.007805998437106609, -0.005279961042106152, -0.0033730401191860437, -0.05502491071820259, 0.016595011577010155, 0.0034874100238084793, -0.0172413382679224, 0.06861287355422974, 0.06705765426158905, -0.008619767613708973, 0.06079071760177612, -0.05890251323580742, -0.056123536080121994, 0.060897406190633774, 0.0017450269078835845, -0.01953982561826706, 0.05674854293465614, -0.024971242994070053, -0.024065768346190453, -0.0461641289293766, 0.0017808300908654928, 0.00782216526567936, -0.04584108665585518, 0.058059029281139374, -0.004107688553631306, -0.010884947143495083, -0.005398418288677931, 0.012263449840247631, 0.019717181101441383, -0.042034849524497986, -0.05727973207831383, -0.0396355465054512, 0.056703001260757446, 0.02192097157239914, 0.02705514058470726, -0.011136605404317379, -0.02061343938112259, -0.027206122875213623, 0.0028411417733877897, 0.047023240476846695, 0.002734764711931348, -0.0016734414966776967, 0.10922954976558685, -0.01264292560517788, 0.006538433488458395, 0.08660996705293655, -0.059575315564870834, 0.00048216333379969, -0.05681512504816055, 0.0485977940261364, 0.06444158405065536, -0.0323818139731884, 0.010287312790751457, 0.008370732888579369, -0.010309052653610706, 0.016948655247688293, 0.06501869857311249, 0.07144451886415482, 0.015650106593966484, 0.000029103804990882054, -0.03630748391151428, 0.0019240330439060926, -0.0002221821341663599, -0.006958461366593838, 0.08302723616361618, 0.0045558493584394455, -0.010015475563704967, -0.021495960652828217, 0.04755022004246712, -0.02305467054247856, -0.03352028504014015, -0.00812013354152441, 0.001680228509940207, 0.01377592608332634, -0.012575624510645866, -0.03454022854566574, -0.023412570357322693, -0.029473746195435524, -0.0022733937948942184, 0.017123781144618988, -0.001049561076797545, 0.03692726418375969, 0.014743922278285027, 0.029347218573093414, 0.04992321878671646, -0.02309570647776127, -0.004132713656872511, -0.05158296227455139, 0.005553040653467178, -0.021148838102817535, 0.00942522007972002, -0.02179146744310856, -0.04246320575475693, -0.03613791987299919, 0.03075161576271057, 0.04466697573661804, 0.020074471831321716, 0.0006791917840018868, 0.010406783781945705, -0.03368401154875755, 0.019008740782737732, 0.014630887657403946, 0.014475272968411446, 0.09619677811861038, -0.03059619851410389, 0.04845782741904259, 0.003590563079342246, 0.056737422943115234, 0.04383677616715431, -0.04325990378856659, 0.0013561869272962213, 0.028511445969343185, 0.02797606587409973, 0.044600240886211395, -0.03138265386223793, -0.0006322574918158352, -0.06858355551958084, -0.04785052314400673, 0.012177241034805775, -0.014662127010524273, 0.0014933065976947546, -0.0265654306858778, 0.04632795602083206, -0.007984749972820282, 0.01499516423791647, -0.03700793907046318, 0.04851124435663223, -0.06143832579255104, -0.01913534477353096, -0.007369374390691519, -0.04145092889666557, -0.011612024158239365, -0.04661830514669418, -0.02644440345466137, 0.043394289910793304, -0.012386427260935307, -0.025956155732274055, -0.05324163660407066, 0.011852971278131008, 0.01806214079260826, 0.010899936780333519, 0.012040754780173302, 0.041492119431495667, -0.042203668504953384, 0.06357073783874512, -0.025016725063323975, 0.024247683584690094, -0.06489113718271255, 0.057337645441293716, 0.026406703516840935, -0.04069909080862999, -0.0007704386371187866, 0.05824322998523712, -0.028829777613282204, -0.002908672671765089, 0.015583653934299946, 0.04901999235153198, 0.013730522245168686, 0.017651448026299477, 0.03138646110892296, 0.019618038088083267, -0.06303270161151886, -0.0015712312888354063, 0.0002214665582869202, -0.04730997607111931, -0.022074751555919647, -0.06427614390850067, -0.004016881342977285, -0.06311515718698502, -0.09378287196159363, 0.03101099468767643, 0.050696227699518204, -0.029050234705209732, -0.016170073300600052, 0.008684951812028885, 0.049784399569034576, 0.0563800148665905, -0.008877179585397243, -0.0025055392179638147, 0.01647203415632248, -0.07579884678125381, -0.09064476937055588, -0.009269912727177143, -0.0042657917365431786, -0.009894045069813728, 0.026862990111112595, 0.02570919319987297, -0.04834514856338501, 0.000041609710024204105, 0.05709325894713402, -0.014589881524443626, 0.012319531291723251, -0.016262177377939224, 0.03676176443696022, -0.012367046438157558, -0.026638004928827286, -0.00035052624298259616, 0.0048887948505580425, -0.04484245926141739, 0.029041944071650505, -0.020277416333556175, 0.008680669590830803, -0.005742131266742945, 0.003893234534189105, -0.0029562609270215034, 0.02616932801902294, -0.03802315518260002, 0.012273614294826984, 0.03211236372590065, -0.010331151075661182, -0.039369139820337296, -0.012513010762631893, -0.10658161342144012, 0.008162671700119972, -0.019565660506486893, -0.0013724154559895396, 0.057287584990262985, 0.018699171021580696, 0.038606297224760056, -0.010829725302755833, 0.0051816231571137905, -0.07198015600442886, -0.019653551280498505, 0.003241142490878701, -0.03017379157245159, -0.000033605669159442186, 0.04094639793038368, -0.04751520976424217, -0.005650806240737438, -0.021971585229039192, -0.005776993930339813, 0.02033574879169464, 0.06645675003528595, 0.00031462713377550244, -0.07048992812633514, 0.009886473417282104, 0.0015140374889597297, -0.003336923662573099, 0.035252224653959274, 0.02517223171889782, 0.029953882098197937, -0.0004997819778509438, 0.01778922975063324, -0.014265305362641811, -0.051500048488378525, -0.007985291071236134, -0.0400313176214695, -0.05198067054152489, -0.05682092905044556, -0.04357415437698364, 0.03475196659564972, 0.03803843632340431, 0.031179042533040047, 0.0011245845817029476, 0.018910806626081467, 0.024693045765161514, -0.009467842057347298, -0.05675888806581497, -0.018316656351089478, -0.02545587345957756, 0.011800916865468025, -0.02599002979695797, 0.007194007746875286, 0.02251085452735424, 0.04470191150903702, 0.045889127999544144, 0.010021583177149296, 0.04956372082233429, -0.05880214646458626, -0.013205558992922306, 0.010756311006844044, -0.09700492769479752, 0.03129115700721741, -0.008144033141434193, -0.010667365975677967, 0.0035240079741925, -0.018660761415958405, 0.019050687551498413, 0.028633911162614822, 0.02166120335459709, 0.016557743772864342, -0.04431011900305748, 0.053975045680999756, -0.02957269735634327, 0.05662577971816063, 0.05035148561000824, 0.0025310954079031944, 0.043153002858161926, 0.008670113980770111, -0.013912239111959934, 0.06486449390649796, 0.0573977492749691, -0.011824964545667171, 0.06101915240287781, 0.038419321179389954, 0.004702474921941757, -0.0200370904058218, 0.02411523461341858, -0.02857069857418537, 0.009009447880089283, 0.007408540695905685, -0.028389297425746918, 0.031913481652736664, 0.011987789534032345, 0.04004807025194168, 0.018926819786429405, -0.04882947728037834, 0.02890273556113243, 0.01594432257115841, 0.027445601299405098, -0.040962137281894684, -0.02879725769162178, 0.04411077871918678, 0.043205711990594864, -0.035764701664447784, -0.010370665229856968, -0.02777351438999176, -0.02507602423429489, -0.05629980191588402 ]
<p>What complications arise when examining the statistical mechanics of a system under the influence of gravity? Is it significantly different from the classical treatment of statistical mechanics?</p>
g4188
[ 0.04322877526283264, 0.11641094833612442, -0.015145068988204002, -0.02014406956732273, -0.030911585316061974, 0.045729540288448334, 0.017158444970846176, -0.01846974343061447, -0.048419803380966187, -0.032270707190036774, 0.01573805883526802, -0.050404708832502365, 0.01576201245188713, 0.029794039204716682, -0.020884325727820396, -0.04805414751172066, 0.041340794414281845, 0.026318205520510674, 0.013686146587133408, -0.031360041350126266, -0.021916301921010017, -0.03214455395936966, 0.03171510249376297, -0.016312798485159874, 0.0035840324126183987, -0.02009255439043045, 0.03005959279835224, 0.0390373170375824, -0.058170244097709656, 0.011023406870663166, -0.014392429031431675, 0.01456263568252325, -0.0017737075686454773, -0.06812477856874466, -0.06334114074707031, -0.044060006737709045, 0.057338912039995193, 0.05056586116552353, 0.01810516230762005, -0.008289746940135956, -0.03407254070043564, -0.012063181027770042, -0.0006815716624259949, 0.0040415143594145775, 0.026433978229761124, 0.028946172446012497, 0.015612589195370674, 0.006612818688154221, 0.0028666676953434944, 0.039591629058122635, 0.002252324251458049, 0.02340199053287506, 0.044778987765312195, 0.0021384095307439566, -0.017229896038770676, -0.0001790246897144243, 0.05736541375517845, -0.005598397459834814, 0.0474572591483593, 0.036827441304922104, 0.041002362966537476, 0.0005385957774706185, -0.022367289289832115, 0.01617027446627617, 0.0017563175642862916, -0.04019051045179367, 0.03867023438215256, -0.053922124207019806, 0.004391240421682596, -0.024633362889289856, 0.044815365225076675, -0.013680239208042622, -0.026616128161549568, -0.02711438201367855, -0.030055008828639984, 0.011065385304391384, 0.024026911705732346, 0.044630322605371475, -0.03381034731864929, -0.016550451517105103, -0.04814213886857033, -0.030021365731954575, 0.042594850063323975, -0.024989767000079155, -0.004240844864398241, -0.02099856734275818, 0.015733465552330017, -0.0018632174469530582, -0.027974775061011314, 0.025819716975092888, 0.03391040116548538, -0.019815292209386826, 0.01932123675942421, 0.01523229293525219, -0.04558970034122467, 0.02207978628575802, -0.013962600380182266, 0.04854751005768776, 0.014596149325370789, 0.04647410660982132, -0.015355361625552177, 0.03396037220954895, -0.00969883892685175, -0.014986253343522549, -0.02708766609430313, -0.008109464310109615, 0.06667456030845642, 0.0874287411570549, 0.03855791687965393, -0.05912617966532707, -0.03948485478758812, 0.03396833688020706, 0.014537709765136242, -0.03618325665593147, -0.011253602802753448, -0.035420387983322144, 0.06709935516119003, -0.01595187373459339, -0.027779405936598778, 0.009571302682161331, -0.020135749131441116, 0.06749224662780762, -0.020863452926278114, 0.050812143832445145, -0.033866267651319504, -0.041049178689718246, -0.02743658795952797, 0.02993772178888321, 0.02130657620728016, -0.015135940164327621, 0.008359219878911972, 0.007938798516988754, -0.05168512836098671, 0.006592943333089352, -0.0024809720925986767, 0.04225698485970497, -0.025589657947421074, 0.007498882245272398, -0.024168211966753006, -0.024868929758667946, -0.02868611179292202, -0.03220599144697189, -0.02590416930615902, 0.020078517496585846, 0.004160478711128235, -0.015459541231393814, 0.0383470244705677, 0.0021946935448795557, -0.04457676783204079, -0.06390725821256638, -0.002592069562524557, 0.01075128372758627, -0.023042025044560432, -0.06404998898506165, 0.04594142735004425, 0.0688740462064743, -0.043241553008556366, 0.031362682580947876, 0.02563547156751156, -0.001780975959263742, 0.054805558174848557, -0.028209954500198364, 0.0719771534204483, 0.016682280227541924, -0.019113056361675262, 0.08224377036094666, 0.01215119194239378, -0.05473902076482773, 0.02153562568128109, -0.003466533264145255, -0.015576951205730438, -0.051276952028274536, 0.003634185530245304, 0.06076584756374359, 0.0057371025905013084, 0.06248101964592934, 0.005904430523514748, -0.08395653963088989, 0.007480627857148647, -0.005346245132386684, -0.020576782524585724, -0.013545178808271885, 0.009440978057682514, -0.0743316188454628, -0.03721969947218895, -0.013743744231760502, 0.030993137508630753, 0.05167844891548157, -0.07515425235033035, 0.04058918356895447, -0.031789060682058334, -0.01969180442392826, -0.0023604060988873243, 0.02402278408408165, -0.005763590801507235, -0.03217051550745964, 0.034070391207933426, 0.05725480243563652, -0.06214480474591255, 0.038662832230329514, -0.018141379579901695, 0.040774669498205185, -0.0023825832176953554, 0.02627386339008808, 0.02762485295534134, 0.0006530178361572325, -0.013406388461589813, 0.026844633743166924, -0.03097592666745186, -0.052225176244974136, 0.022983824834227562, -0.026562651619315147, 0.0703027993440628, 0.020286601036787033, -0.011322980746626854, 0.009845691733062267, -0.008602340705692768, -0.023318562656641006, 0.02797110006213188, 0.08233676850795746, -0.050169188529253006, -0.00855842512100935, 0.05369476601481438, 0.010547219775617123, 0.03906497731804848, -0.010981518775224686, -0.045851290225982666, -0.009617151692509651, -0.038012873381376266, -0.008150937035679817, -0.06134697049856186, -0.006595946382731199, 0.047638244926929474, 0.01904667727649212, 0.013005289249122143, 0.043237436562776566, 0.018921613693237305, -0.06315743178129196, 0.04367869347333908, -0.0009417979745194316, 0.026377765461802483, 0.023796536028385162, -0.017646262422204018, -0.01601068675518036, 0.05253607779741287, 0.025041811168193817, 0.03147593513131142, 0.01870804838836193, 0.009545075707137585, -0.013888128101825714, -0.02642066776752472, 0.017002493143081665, -0.012932172045111656, -0.04683762788772583, 0.030491068959236145, 0.001726415823213756, -0.06791014224290848, 0.028563454747200012, -0.06508325785398483, -0.0019542935770004988, -0.025484947487711906, -0.02843216247856617, -0.055543769150972366, 0.026719525456428528, -0.009942821227014065, 0.02463594451546669, -0.015146884135901928, -0.00572268757969141, -0.010231171734631062, 0.009180502966046333, 0.0016831639222800732, 0.03288346156477928, -0.0032451660372316837, 0.07359255105257034, 0.08748171478509903, -0.019427364692091942, -0.0005560197751037776, -0.01882186532020569, 0.02979486621916294, -0.07492102682590485, -0.019386403262615204, -0.026958545669913292, 0.009815936908125877, 0.031858641654253006, 0.07798685133457184, -0.01588607020676136, -0.022069523110985756, -0.043567877262830734, -0.0030474422965198755, -0.021931827068328857, 0.024564635008573532, 0.06389014422893524, -0.007414264138787985, 0.025223422795534134, -0.015240288339555264, 0.019361140206456184, -0.04320059344172478, 0.011455046944320202, -0.027362965047359467, 0.0009094697888940573, 0.025588059797883034, 0.0012338332599028945, -0.010687612928450108, 0.10670251399278641, -0.0033420026302337646, 0.02142351120710373, -0.07019385695457458, -0.019438110291957855, 0.06930847465991974, -0.05792689695954323, -0.06346272677183151, 0.04953708499670029, 0.006002059206366539, 0.03293522819876671, -0.04667828604578972, -0.010600801557302475, 0.008924322202801704, -0.023898441344499588, -0.017125489190220833, -0.06512238085269928, -0.025509048253297806, -0.0508919358253479, -0.020211780443787575, -0.024742648005485535, 0.022403888404369354, 0.03686141595244408, -0.024485820904374123, 0.00953126884996891, -0.005591381341218948, 0.00033542310120537877, 0.08483743667602539, -0.08910085260868073, -0.011505454778671265, -0.002539723878726363, -0.0605236291885376, -0.02525525912642479, 0.0060381218791007996, -0.05679865926504135, -0.007864817045629025, 0.012783325277268887, 0.04166906327009201, -0.026450978592038155, -0.03658563271164894, -0.013702730648219585, -0.032509610056877136, -0.01044448371976614, 0.007602657191455364, 0.039727117866277695, 0.024391256272792816, -0.0350809171795845, 0.020282547920942307, -0.02079375460743904, 0.046608198434114456, 0.009798265993595123, 0.015863750129938126, 0.03435996174812317, 0.01525095570832491, -0.029629593715071678, -0.012405912391841412, -0.023937944322824478, -0.034261465072631836, -0.05162157118320465, -0.056102506816387177, 0.08380597084760666, 0.049232322722673416, 0.025642041116952896, 0.02078775316476822, 0.044906385242938995, -0.025526469573378563, -0.06578635424375534, -0.05251288041472435, 0.052304863929748535, -0.022493554279208183, 0.0084005082026124, 0.10143087804317474, 0.009661939926445484, 0.037793561816215515, -0.03140001744031906, -0.019951526075601578, 0.017951859161257744, 0.05985032021999359, -0.0010403628693893552, 0.03068685345351696, -0.0441124364733696, 0.10392618179321289, -0.03344085067510605, -0.04412465915083885, -0.0277278870344162, -0.019653821364045143, 0.016734445467591286, 0.007353628054261208, -0.08094540238380432, -0.0038497995119541883, 0.045607518404722214, 0.018819035962224007, -0.008388510905206203, 0.023453569039702415, 0.0034337860997766256, 0.04755561798810959, -0.026605024933815002, -0.013003969565033913, -0.0029409320559352636, -0.003560231765732169, 0.023533107712864876, -0.0339815728366375, -0.0013843121705576777, 0.05360469967126846, -0.028098763898015022, -0.08229543268680573, 0.04582809656858444, 0.006008847150951624, -0.0075876060873270035, 0.025274619460105896, -0.011974217370152473, -0.036040931940078735, -0.038633812218904495, -0.005025974474847317, 0.023977842181921005, -0.0076468512415885925, -0.00455155223608017, -0.006400448735803366, 0.0773417130112648, -0.014965358190238476, -0.010929638519883156, -0.028645211830735207, 0.06314977258443832, 0.04416973516345024, -0.01190455537289381, -0.06410682946443558, -0.017676319926977158, -0.011705411598086357, 0.03248948976397514, -0.03339536488056183, 0.010830800980329514, -0.027456078678369522, 0.030119165778160095, -0.008762788958847523, 0.012678300961852074, -0.04675603285431862, 0.052731502801179886, 0.0412064753472805, 0.03441605344414711, -0.004506952594965696, -0.05125805363059044, 0.009903431870043278, 0.060264959931373596, 0.023525560274720192, -0.04659842699766159, -0.004183551762253046, 0.00929265283048153, -0.0601998046040535, 0.00462556816637516, 0.012530543841421604, -0.02792808972299099, -0.033653803169727325, -0.019933035597205162, -0.0021555994171649218, 0.03577015921473503, -0.03343011811375618, -0.012897400185465813, -0.014365925453603268, -0.05353096127510071, -0.03237835690379143, 0.0012940115993842483, -0.06128089502453804, -0.017722276970744133, -0.07400422543287277, 0.03228854387998581, -0.050642549991607666, -0.03128121793270111, 0.0037248930893838406, -0.02917802892625332, 0.01578846387565136, 0.007506365422159433, -0.0141749894246459, 0.033544041216373444, -0.059068452566862106, 0.02901885285973549, 0.057968538254499435, -0.04831273481249809, 0.03369947522878647, -0.01685762219130993, 0.016613980755209923, 0.04115590080618858, 0.0015709741273894906, 0.024710213765501976, 0.02780650556087494, -0.022091085091233253, 0.05718545615673065, -0.034088753163814545, 0.00016067489923443645, -0.021880706772208214, 0.02897963672876358, 0.04310012608766556, -0.05368389934301376, 0.0009313603513874114, 0.02530631050467491, 0.0020158207044005394, 0.013559971936047077, 0.009532080963253975, -0.039077118039131165, 0.03281286358833313, 0.04146292805671692, 0.021396875381469727, -0.005862944293767214, 0.03136324882507324, 0.0027695326134562492, 0.024363061413168907, -0.00353465648368001, 0.10327749699354172, -0.05671375244855881, 0.027253299951553345, 0.028527207672595978, 0.07899275422096252, 0.013705961406230927, -0.03646774962544441, 0.028590256348252296, -0.02539762295782566, 0.012884624302387238, -0.06758321076631546, 0.03060569427907467, -0.054748810827732086, 0.026833679527044296, -0.0204172283411026, 0.03144839033484459, 0.030146995559334755, 0.008418519981205463, -0.026629235595464706, -0.013080284930765629, -0.02507759816944599, 0.006837470922619104, -0.04057735204696655, 0.004637233912944794, 0.047325581312179565, -0.01748860627412796, -0.04592526704072952, 0.020994732156395912, -0.021333158016204834, 0.08929140865802765, 0.038156211376190186, -0.019320469349622726, -0.010668068192899227, -0.02943887747824192, 0.03708638623356819, -0.02489316463470459, -0.03884555399417877, 0.02495425194501877, 0.026521500200033188, 0.04679790139198303, -0.036340974271297455, -0.062109384685754776, 0.01757972501218319, -0.0009371828055009246, 0.0552489310503006, -0.004204899538308382, 0.032462406903505325, -0.004384323954582214, 0.019541338086128235, -0.024775629863142967, 0.010760728269815445, 0.013784253969788551, 0.016146596521139145, 0.06224668398499489, -0.022253485396504402, 0.03195738419890404, -0.008546353317797184, -0.028114693239331245, -0.06571038067340851, 0.04792679846286774, 0.033534783869981766, 0.01692468859255314, 0.010252234525978565, -0.015781302005052567, -0.011782041750848293, 0.047412194311618805, 0.0384187288582325, -0.05696258693933487, -0.018882786855101585, -0.0029098880477249622, -0.0506448894739151, -0.07362984865903854, -0.002909992588683963, 0.028884973376989365, -0.06052262336015701, -0.07588303834199905, 0.019861895591020584, -0.05601247772574425, 0.009982293471693993, 0.05395742133259773, -0.01850573532283306, 0.001504468615166843, -0.061116889119148254, -0.0221499502658844, 0.0542004257440567, -0.04199327901005745, -0.023947814479470253, 0.03038622997701168, 0.04405590146780014, -0.014491350390017033, 0.01517504919320345, 0.030024781823158264, 0.08498359471559525, 0.09683457016944885, -0.0378582701086998, -0.01561342366039753, 0.003258101176470518, -0.0020341358613222837, 0.01766492985188961, 0.030456319451332092, 0.013846355490386486, 0.03964671865105629, 0.0193034540861845, 0.007319658994674683, -0.0014702450716868043, -0.007598795462399721, -0.03068535216152668, 0.01043951977044344, -0.03192438185214996, -0.037973836064338684, -0.006296142935752869, -0.013466434553265572, -0.05461827293038368, 0.045758023858070374, -0.053623516112565994, -0.006359477527439594, -0.012010418809950352, -0.05887475982308388, -0.004332331009209156, 0.03870857134461403, -0.03755870833992958, -0.005739032290875912, 0.058017998933792114, -0.025964386761188507, -0.005771687254309654, -0.01238959189504385, 0.045224424451589584, -0.04940726235508919, 0.01474984921514988, 0.06381797045469284, 0.04454934597015381, 0.0045083314180374146, 0.04916960746049881, -0.002903711749240756, -0.02710041217505932, -0.049832407385110855, 0.0007973014144226909, 0.016739407554268837, -0.011339005082845688, -0.050248418003320694, 0.004761180374771357, -0.015036829747259617, -0.034577254205942154, 0.004409408196806908, -0.008557871915400028, 0.024823427200317383, 0.028938381001353264, 0.010261141695082188, 0.0238529983907938, 0.07543367147445679, -0.06542017310857773, -0.03118729218840599, -0.014451198279857635, -0.03769761323928833, 0.05205925926566124, -0.00409308634698391, 0.03236628323793411, 0.08751294016838074, -0.0635906234383583, -0.009616442024707794, 0.05405206233263016, -0.0008453293121419847, -0.05047240108251572, -0.045621372759342194, 0.037304893136024475, 0.0033084843307733536, -0.022058021277189255, 0.035960398614406586, -0.028353901579976082, -0.034053921699523926, 0.02436237782239914, 0.03354102745652199, 0.016816293820738792, -0.008173756301403046, 0.017789708450436592, -0.01825983263552189, 0.009827077388763428, 0.04040646180510521, -0.03779983893036842, -0.06858951598405838, 0.018243947997689247, 0.0056820521131157875, 0.018334751948714256, -0.04520140588283539, 0.029644936323165894, 0.032518066465854645, -0.0199285838752985, -0.00945824570953846, 0.08493082970380783, 0.04454554244875908, -0.02480459399521351, -0.04118775203824043, -0.004004946444183588, -0.002380277030169964, -0.05475235730409622, 0.05914759263396263, -0.0020389689598232508, -0.02362179011106491, -0.041773006319999695, -0.05150753632187843, 0.03291066363453865, 0.009849566966295242, 0.003895657602697611, -0.006232313346117735, 0.02113141119480133, -0.024379204958677292, -0.01036123652011156, -0.02573624812066555, -0.006045664194971323, -0.01171701867133379, 0.00758169312030077, -0.024891601875424385, -0.03458979353308678, -0.03713839873671532, -0.009692479856312275, 0.030898254364728928, -0.009920011274516582, -0.026192300021648407, 0.020427610725164413, 0.018133489415049553, 0.024792730808258057, -0.01180817186832428, -0.019846657291054726, -0.05278388410806656, 0.01936808042228222, -0.049793269485235214, 0.04035409539937973, 0.02195573039352894, -0.07559515535831451, -0.020154329016804695, 0.0022546788677573204, -0.029720425605773926, -0.008404936641454697, 0.05776429548859596, -0.05265168473124504, 0.009090420790016651, -0.0013502542860805988, -0.013706553727388382, -0.007026221603155136, 0.04243090748786926, 0.024369798600673676, 0.007938624359667301, 0.00859066378325224, -0.01144469529390335, 0.07102268189191818, -0.034652065485715866, -0.03891700506210327, -0.05262283608317375, -0.023946600034832954, -0.02031947486102581, -0.07108588516712189, 0.04269084334373474, -0.01401475165039301, -0.03190623223781586, 0.00410874979570508, -0.022538669407367706, -0.014342869631946087, 0.011258367449045181, 0.07633571326732635 ]
<p>As far I as I know, and from naturalness considerations, a 125 GeV Higgs mass is rather large for the MSSM. This is because in the MSSM $$m_h^2 \lesssim M_z^2 \cos^22\beta + \Delta$$ where $\Delta$ represents top/stop loop corrections to the Higgs. It takes the form $$\Delta \sim \ln(\frac{m_\text{stop}}{m_\text{top}}) + \text{mixing}$$ </p> <p>Moreover, the Z mass is determined by the Higgs mass parameter, $m_{H_u},$ and $\mu$ (in the large $\tan\beta$ limit. i.e. $\tan\beta \geq 10$). And $m_{H_u} \sim - m_\text{stop}$, so the larger $m_\text{stop}$ the larger the fine-tuning in the MSSM. Now, only by large $m_\text{stop}$ (and mixing) one can reach a Higgs mass greater than LEP/LHC bounds. But this is already associated with large fine-tuning as I said. </p> <p>So, in this view, a 125 GeV Higgs mass is large for the MSSM. (At least for the cMSSM.)</p> <p>However, I realised that some people think 125 GeV is much less than what the MSSM predicts! Now this I don't understand at all. So could someone please explain what this view is based on?</p>
g4189
[ -0.007246069144457579, 0.047645196318626404, 0.009424468502402306, -0.007898237556219101, -0.0213407464325428, 0.04195497930049896, 0.07599570602178574, 0.07730133086442947, -0.0435861237347126, -0.051838308572769165, -0.026889102533459663, 0.008445531129837036, 0.02253824658691883, 0.04167816787958145, 0.022599291056394577, 0.005770212505012751, 0.029098210856318474, 0.06847170740365982, -0.024017658084630966, -0.019514981657266617, 0.0007489791023544967, -0.04495084285736084, -0.03930531442165375, -0.07882212847471237, -0.049873873591423035, 0.00647394685074687, 0.04539961367845535, 0.004326613154262304, 0.045890793204307556, 0.027393609285354614, 0.022862305864691734, -0.017775163054466248, 0.03688348829746246, -0.03800500929355621, -0.01311186607927084, -0.03261720761656761, 0.023081611841917038, 0.00604386767372489, -0.0032024821266531944, -0.026365114375948906, 0.06768599897623062, -0.019160183146595955, 0.04457876831293106, -0.02623055875301361, -0.038189902901649475, 0.07720616459846497, 0.008172464556992054, 0.004885895177721977, 0.055035389959812164, -0.0019563932437449694, -0.026949340477585793, 0.02609163336455822, 0.048068031668663025, 0.06569287180900574, 0.06564482301473618, -0.007716246414929628, 0.028578942641615868, 0.05363237485289574, 0.04210969805717468, -0.015267412178218365, 0.01577822118997574, -0.031038857996463776, -0.04444493353366852, 0.003757711034268141, -0.001151755452156067, -0.022400405257940292, -0.050968583673238754, -0.02338249422609806, 0.022933438420295715, 0.04380154609680176, -0.03880104795098305, -0.015181274153292179, -0.010734094306826591, -0.01731182634830475, 0.0021596942096948624, 0.009295918047428131, -0.016260234639048576, -0.035610098391771317, -0.032170407474040985, 0.00043774693040177226, 0.005841933190822601, -0.01122264750301838, 0.0002138241834472865, 0.008399381302297115, 0.02529785968363285, -0.01010988187044859, -0.04688204452395439, 0.053320448845624924, -0.004148514941334724, -0.0027188051026314497, 0.0020090905018150806, -0.038437969982624054, -0.00039751813164912164, -0.010396444238722324, 0.002075874013826251, 0.03199375048279762, -0.005353499203920364, -0.015605919063091278, 0.03806068375706673, -0.009218966588377953, 0.018140338361263275, 0.05325176194310188, 0.0005516027449630201, 0.024417193606495857, -0.005831434857100248, 0.04165538400411606, -0.010629766620695591, -0.019638733938336372, -0.005150118842720985, 0.0022150762379169464, -0.029229022562503815, -0.017392167821526527, -0.07469233125448227, -0.0476863756775856, -0.07856858521699905, -0.020539214834570885, 0.08906076103448868, 0.036684177815914154, 0.007103939540684223, -0.016591139137744904, 0.02541046217083931, -0.061145734041929245, -0.031249236315488815, 0.027819573879241943, -0.045685071498155594, 0.005015003029257059, 0.04275605082511902, -0.018752682954072952, 0.03535371646285057, -0.032609496265649796, -0.033966414630413055, -0.007476717699319124, 0.022084545344114304, -0.01726440340280533, 0.009087092243134975, -0.0014708703383803368, -0.0016665031434968114, -0.02342643029987812, 0.05023045837879181, -0.03374004736542702, -0.015829965472221375, -0.051616229116916656, 0.05070839822292328, -0.012898141518235207, 0.02100914530456066, 0.08198703080415726, -0.05101487413048744, 0.030604759231209755, -0.016585811972618103, 0.039681751281023026, 0.017507916316390038, 0.03385340794920921, -0.015501746907830238, 0.0167439803481102, -0.023346714675426483, 0.025536321103572845, -0.0044637881219387054, 0.012670345604419708, -0.022294005379080772, 0.030720647424459457, -0.018785974010825157, -0.0039247069507837296, 0.003605637000873685, 0.016489511355757713, -0.002719287062063813, 0.0007448439719155431, 0.03047630563378334, -0.0007673569489270449, -0.05494656041264534, -0.04900391772389412, -0.06367571651935577, 0.02719017118215561, 0.042904336005449295, 0.004703408107161522, 0.01674659363925457, 0.0009720414527691901, 0.0218479223549366, -0.047079119831323624, 0.029500190168619156, 0.014861571602523327, 0.03308109939098358, -0.015436535701155663, -0.025023246183991432, -0.020237158983945847, -0.02919807843863964, 0.032024845480918884, 0.00031470757676288486, 0.01055056694895029, 0.08145870268344879, 0.027673212811350822, 0.00662285415455699, -0.007289155852049589, -0.03726775571703911, -0.018043503165245056, 0.055431053042411804, 0.0055805654264986515, -0.009963613003492355, -0.0372389554977417, 0.0018884073942899704, -0.015395723283290863, -0.028355231508612633, -0.02927008643746376, -0.0034064450301229954, -0.05772821605205536, 0.030345842242240906, -0.011727679520845413, -0.002281832741573453, 0.02653028443455696, -0.009490028023719788, -0.005259999539703131, 0.005617624614387751, -0.06582888960838318, 0.0032172617502510548, -0.0010509976418688893, -0.0014996033860370517, -0.029934078454971313, 0.02551419660449028, 0.03011590801179409, 0.02903555892407894, 0.021199313923716545, -0.03620082139968872, -0.030124029144644737, 0.04396156594157219, -0.012916314415633678, 0.010681482963263988, 0.018642330542206764, 0.06506367027759552, -0.0019290908239781857, -0.02035457268357277, 0.03428884595632553, -0.02946564368903637, 0.02870696596801281, 0.008944430388510227, 0.009494063444435596, -0.046500314027071, -0.0010263290023431182, -0.0018311035819351673, 0.04467245191335678, -0.01841532438993454, 0.013147388584911823, 0.026543565094470978, -0.003872716799378395, -0.051096733659505844, 0.017056260257959366, -0.019978446885943413, -0.03065081685781479, 0.08172664791345596, 0.015485542826354504, -0.08999139070510864, 0.032750703394412994, 0.022960344329476357, 0.02919202856719494, 0.009477571584284306, -0.01619446463882923, 0.03033275343477726, -0.044009074568748474, 0.0056174760684370995, 0.005987898912280798, -0.018248597159981728, 0.01939389668405056, 0.015354063361883163, -0.008336145430803299, 0.007198630832135677, -0.032970454543828964, -0.041135262697935104, -0.009513720870018005, -0.022484395653009415, 0.016992487013339996, 0.0229767095297575, 0.004376254975795746, 0.07757119834423065, -0.008738639764487743, 0.027033627033233643, 0.06806518137454987, -0.016399208456277847, -0.05780971050262451, -0.059951577335596085, 0.015145799145102501, 0.025992445647716522, -0.07149577885866165, -0.031756069511175156, -0.03625072166323662, 0.01411103829741478, -0.012666351161897182, -0.00846569798886776, -0.0029067788273096085, -0.050629764795303345, -0.060302238911390305, -0.015275492332875729, 0.019963201135396957, -0.03942371532320976, -0.04283546283841133, 0.048512548208236694, -0.021440856158733368, 0.01660340279340744, 0.05352308601140976, 0.05941365659236908, 0.04547956585884094, -0.06457709521055222, -0.019121702760457993, 0.043560661375522614, 0.008714172057807446, -0.011929955333471298, -0.0064635383896529675, -0.0372033454477787, 0.032179415225982666, -0.0007714364328421652, 0.03803626820445061, -0.02703823521733284, -0.06131547689437866, 0.021306294947862625, 0.030111491680145264, 0.02373325638473034, -0.025302521884441376, -0.024763446301221848, 0.004799519665539265, 0.016417227685451508, 0.05250134691596031, -0.05251956731081009, -0.048083335161209106, -0.05029146745800972, -0.04546816274523735, -0.02122381702065468, 0.012403905391693115, -0.015394299291074276, -0.015014818869531155, -0.024726586416363716, -0.04672988876700401, -0.049447424709796906, -0.01817506179213524, 0.06857193261384964, 0.02356102503836155, -0.03358520567417145, 0.05591475963592529, -0.019322805106639862, 0.01723216287791729, 0.0405055396258831, 0.03500271588563919, 0.07725374400615692, -0.012148664332926273, -0.015643848106265068, -0.006042585242539644, -0.04018522426486015, 0.017372574657201767, 0.06096653640270233, 0.02729705348610878, -0.013477439060807228, -0.08317465335130692, 0.02958134189248085, -0.014272947795689106, 0.0026566588785499334, 0.010569117031991482, -0.047853920608758926, -0.008745296858251095, -0.020827222615480423, 0.07335900515317917, -0.056056272238492966, -0.00044081409578211606, 0.06896546483039856, 0.0046533807180821896, 0.02782311849296093, 0.005604245234280825, -0.017521774396300316, -0.04202137142419815, -0.015293153934180737, 0.03048674762248993, -0.022624878212809563, 0.009621713310480118, -0.013575964607298374, -0.059524551033973694, 0.018414903432130814, 0.03147188201546669, 0.018791653215885162, 0.062423545867204666, 0.0038460823707282543, 0.011105927638709545, 0.016815634444355965, 0.03249527886509895, 0.015204004012048244, -0.04301637038588524, 0.03220861032605171, 0.026895668357610703, -0.014670963399112225, -0.03754805028438568, -0.02209145948290825, -0.04008617252111435, 0.008172069676220417, -0.013567107729613781, -0.060518231242895126, -0.02986169420182705, -0.004684623796492815, -0.08553917706012726, 0.03886369988322258, 0.025480931624770164, 0.06389094889163971, -0.020316744223237038, 0.041218072175979614, 0.009279880672693253, 0.02892032451927662, 0.004974731244146824, 0.03228135034441948, 0.031155956909060478, -0.0040664044208824635, -0.05063247308135033, 0.0010813400149345398, 0.007918213494122028, -0.03680438920855522, 0.021155623719096184, 0.014431010000407696, -0.056367095559835434, 0.015770627185702324, 0.06707270443439484, -0.011597005650401115, -0.0010538665810599923, 0.01319009531289339, -0.050706930458545685, -0.05549780651926994, -0.03744252026081085, 0.07069138437509537, 0.009556729346513748, -0.033341649919748306, -0.017994869500398636, -0.01140680629760027, -0.02360699698328972, -0.005271645728498697, 0.02074100635945797, 0.015966689214110374, 0.07347553223371506, -0.05654894560575485, -0.04464669153094292, 0.028064457699656487, 0.03031936101615429, -0.021756816655397415, 0.02912360057234764, 0.015506414696574211, 0.07970303297042847, 0.03594203665852547, -0.0003097451408393681, -0.030578767880797386, -0.024228982627391815, 0.011030306108295918, -0.03825516253709793, -0.02458391711115837, 0.02864077500998974, -0.020650586113333702, 0.00859404169023037, -0.049763958901166916, 0.0180657971650362, -0.03586307540535927, 0.020862974226474762, -0.06109347939491272, -0.0005651238607242703, -0.0020164381712675095, 0.011712856590747833, 0.0135135967284441, 0.01672195829451084, -0.004656943958252668, 0.09340831637382507, -0.007373374421149492, -0.021104516461491585, -0.04716375842690468, -0.016875574365258217, 0.03801843523979187, 0.03583153709769249, 0.055469345301389694, 0.0038524640258401632, -0.04633354768157005, -0.08021324872970581, -0.053891416639089584, 0.021105917170643806, -0.006386361550539732, 0.014704556204378605, 0.04278586804866791, 0.037024881690740585, -0.018875375390052795, -0.010374798439443111, -0.0433967262506485, -0.09524846822023392, -0.04722415655851364, -0.0014114452060312033, 0.00033714098390191793, -0.02815868705511093, 0.0161359254270792, -0.02061225101351738, -0.010580522939562798, 0.0019211909966543317, -0.017713842913508415, -0.039934396743774414, 0.05401516333222389, 0.008126928471028805, 0.020246809348464012, 0.06392309814691544, 0.006181556731462479, -0.009290608577430248, 0.020694799721240997, -0.047612227499485016, -0.013863267377018929, -0.02724933810532093, -0.02601538971066475, -0.004476422909647226, -0.005473770666867495, 0.011302153579890728, -0.016658594831824303, 0.03177113085985184, -0.023944955319166183, 0.08277546614408493, 0.05003516748547554, -0.01991066336631775, 0.03840673714876175, 0.0023903222754597664, -0.0300271138548851, -0.008267316035926342, 0.07130981236696243, -0.019426396116614342, 0.03205468878149986, -0.06478647142648697, -0.03823952004313469, 0.030529994517564774, 0.009736205451190472, -0.03832186758518219, -0.0041927131824195385, 0.013016502372920513, 0.016773609444499016, -0.051654428243637085, -0.02331378683447838, -0.06330104172229767, -0.013388718478381634, -0.014781558886170387, -0.011390484869480133, -0.0015563826309517026, -0.012937155552208424, 0.0014217417920008302, 0.0582813061773777, 0.042190201580524445, 0.06056452915072441, 0.04338277876377106, -0.002531318925321102, -0.005301433149725199, 0.01771281473338604, 0.027483109384775162, 0.04038478806614876, -0.05730018392205238, -0.010551122017204762, 0.06918825954198837, 0.055059000849723816, 0.002482214942574501, 0.04908638074994087, -0.05187959596514702, 0.006910501979291439, -0.02098478563129902, -0.08069130778312683, -0.022855916991829872, 0.016772571951150894, -0.03460878133773804, -0.02644265629351139, 0.02335459738969803, 0.010881178081035614, 0.028255915269255638, 0.03800070285797119, 0.024320019409060478, -0.00252264691516757, 0.03447775915265083, 0.00672735832631588, 0.027257544919848442, 0.019994188100099564, -0.07277088612318039, 0.0041036950424313545, 0.040948621928691864, 0.018201259896159172, -0.0010219205869361758, 0.01639111526310444, -0.01362321712076664, -0.015877092257142067, 0.06593108922243118, -0.002266139257699251, 0.04770258441567421, -0.05286003276705742, -0.014746446162462234, -0.03548045828938484, -0.052730411291122437, 0.015019412152469158, 0.0009726753341965377, -0.018186157569289207, -0.07088854163885117, -0.005046945530921221, 0.0030649842228740454, -0.0547100193798542, -0.020729249343276024, 0.011173876002430916, 0.04046309366822243, 0.009515274316072464, -0.006735101342201233, -0.013109827414155006, 0.06885699927806854, 0.002124594058841467, -0.038158118724823, 0.011202635243535042, -0.06470603495836258, -0.04124004766345024, -0.03389862924814224, 0.1120653823018074, 0.008121984079480171, -0.006441097240895033, 0.013402833603322506, 0.029427874833345413, 0.03502138704061508, 0.015248741954565048, 0.06292235851287842, -0.016699865460395813, 0.035297490656375885, 0.007447640877217054, -0.010478570125997066, 0.0670335665345192, -0.026429973542690277, -0.030183782801032066, -0.025237765163183212, 0.0008348326082341373, 0.04845103248953819, -0.08742957562208176, 0.0049288393929600716, 0.008840790018439293, 0.06104659661650658, 0.006176290102303028, 0.025791876018047333, 0.021538089960813522, 0.02029590867459774, 0.07502785325050354, -0.01584254577755928, 0.05948437750339508, -0.037336722016334534, -0.01774054951965809, -0.04026414453983307, 0.016582826152443886, -0.006097464822232723, -0.008166582323610783, 0.026973074302077293, -0.06243797764182091, -0.04277491196990013, -0.049175385385751724, 0.02656167559325695, 0.007418167311698198, 0.010198612697422504, 0.0018554446287453175, 0.012204545550048351, -0.026413407176733017, -0.01013871468603611, 0.035952161997556686, -0.003830517642199993, -0.0465453639626503, -0.06454236805438995, -0.022826027125120163, 0.05092949792742729, -0.06235338747501373, 0.002773954998701811, -0.021287614479660988, 0.03381107375025749, 0.009718827903270721, 0.013671236112713814, 0.07960115373134613, -0.08618022501468658, -0.04190847650170326, 0.033487290143966675, 0.06284045428037643, 0.05541495978832245, 0.013111209496855736, 0.03731375187635422, -0.01977808214724064, -0.10159822553396225, 0.056765876710414886, -0.08762077987194061, -0.017543481662869453, -0.02871200442314148, -0.04060165211558342, 0.029615849256515503, 0.004381095990538597, -0.04663354903459549, -0.03251603990793228, -0.017703494057059288, -0.01875322312116623, 0.03861575201153755, 0.03614841029047966, 0.03262936323881149, -0.032962482422590256, 0.05371778830885887, -0.0022778832353651524, 0.05497189238667488, -0.06020908057689667, -0.016820169985294342, -0.012870804406702518, 0.03737374767661095, 0.01428702287375927, -0.009281094186007977, 0.005077925510704517, 0.052620213478803635, -0.0492129772901535, 0.02105112560093403, 0.024456609040498734, 0.019774917513132095, 0.009664163924753666, 0.0373513326048851, -0.009555251337587833, 0.015340480953454971, 0.017737796530127525, 0.032431986182928085, 0.09711851179599762, 0.05585373938083649, -0.018988246098160744, 0.018157511949539185, -0.04598773270845413, -0.05772935226559639, -0.04793119058012962, -0.03764395788311958, 0.03717976436018944, 0.049395229667425156, 0.07731907814741135, 0.013378568924963474, -0.016980458050966263, -0.04395682364702225, 0.034021828323602676, -0.030043205246329308, -0.05823624134063721, 0.01763383485376835, 0.03489435836672783, -0.029436346143484116, -0.03303151950240135, -0.032825905829668045, 0.015287636779248714, -0.032287757843732834, -0.007644318975508213, 0.05911580100655556, -0.04647969454526901, 0.029666727408766747, -0.0191061832010746, -0.04309878870844841, -0.053118444979190826, -0.030184565111994743, 0.00484422966837883, 0.009699398651719093, -0.0033607566729187965, 0.01482458971440792, -0.0031402402091771364, -0.027045652270317078, 0.04525017738342285, -0.005432081408798695, 0.024333423003554344, -0.010629293508827686, -0.020131384953856468, -0.05456296354532242, 0.004800694994628429, -0.05025070905685425, 0.02795146405696869, -0.013494805432856083, -0.054541196674108505, 0.0810762494802475, 0.00684546772390604, -0.020479515194892883, 0.0633130744099617, -0.04766120761632919, -0.05523940920829773, -0.024957992136478424, 0.029542116448283195, -0.0856703519821167, 0.06760497391223907, 0.0816880464553833, -0.008488570339977741, -0.03566379100084305, -0.0029489535372704268, -0.01884014718234539 ]
<p>I have a wet teabag in an empty cup. If I will hold the teabag and touch the wall of cup with it, it will stick to the cup, like there would be glue or some magnetic field, but there's just water.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/HaBZ4.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>So, why does it happens? Why can just a little bit of water hold the teabag stronger than the gravity of an entire planet so it will not fall to the bottom of the cup, or even slide down a little bit?</p> <p>Why is it so strong?</p>
g4190
[ 0.006739000324159861, 0.030462980270385742, -0.0036084658931940794, 0.00739292660728097, 0.05332912504673004, 0.09193291515111923, -0.0051254574209451675, 0.014698460698127747, -0.052861932665109634, -0.07806454598903656, 0.017647625878453255, -0.048745568841695786, -0.029815245419740677, 0.043626368045806885, -0.036394890397787094, 0.055179111659526825, 0.007140411529690027, 0.015008711256086826, 0.013245973736047745, 0.01992187835276127, -0.01324617862701416, -0.018018342554569244, 0.017677297815680504, -0.04036971554160118, -0.055891603231430054, -0.011187821626663208, 0.04746519401669502, -0.030463306233286858, -0.0055357953533530235, 0.01875435560941696, -0.021317875012755394, -0.023148974403738976, 0.03139368072152138, -0.023325005546212196, -0.030775370076298714, -0.051615480333566666, 0.04326050356030464, 0.02812841534614563, 0.012951149605214596, -0.018055375665426254, -0.009873519651591778, 0.015997616574168205, 0.0015013179508969188, 0.0033174045383930206, -0.009476014412939548, -0.019821207970380783, -0.014378990978002548, 0.050593044608831406, -0.021226542070508003, -0.039362579584121704, 0.013338197953999043, 0.02246146649122238, -0.03945890814065933, -0.04553404077887535, -0.03547815978527069, 0.01458816695958376, -0.0007770297816023231, 0.04399095103144646, 0.03010747767984867, 0.02584301121532917, -0.026340145617723465, -0.007504469249397516, -0.012201680801808834, 0.05428992584347725, 0.01526075042784214, -0.024224551394581795, -0.05569972097873688, -0.003193727694451809, -0.00026150140911340714, 0.032955385744571686, -0.011748001910746098, -0.0247501190751791, -0.0034809401258826256, -0.0534965954720974, -0.060432787984609604, -0.008867982774972916, -0.01779509335756302, -0.002431008266285062, 0.06219654902815819, 0.01211236696690321, -0.02977077104151249, 0.028189118951559067, -0.01136265229433775, 0.032731976360082626, -0.006560012698173523, -0.023135442286729813, -0.006552029866725206, -0.0658445805311203, 0.035990871489048004, 0.022007832303643227, -0.004963183309882879, -0.006250206846743822, 0.0552627295255661, 0.06286241859197617, -0.0015483907191082835, -0.008529093116521835, 0.03380434960126877, 0.012927592732012272, -0.03718806803226471, 0.029661672189831734, 0.03261901065707207, -0.02858714386820793, 0.04005769267678261, 0.027724288403987885, 0.02483758144080639, -0.03042011521756649, 0.005349620245397091, 0.0702061727643013, -0.005884707439690828, -0.053386613726615906, 0.004308311268687248, 0.02908666990697384, -0.012782609090209007, -0.016005555167794228, 0.03496105223894119, -0.02471539005637169, 0.0022726613096892834, 0.01520379725843668, 0.007165123708546162, 0.002051037037745118, -0.0022805118933320045, 0.012973550707101822, -0.019868332892656326, 0.07264441251754761, 0.003990695811808109, -0.03381049633026123, 0.06421010196208954, -0.011836033314466476, -0.04675830528140068, 0.005967026576399803, -0.008753797970712185, 0.02692568674683571, -0.03320229798555374, -0.0026827454566955566, 0.043672945350408554, -0.010749425739049911, -0.006528492551296949, -0.016449708491563797, 0.011100033298134804, -0.026376185938715935, 0.0024060781579464674, -0.030714044347405434, 0.03219640627503395, 0.009894871152937412, -0.07586642354726791, 0.02091960608959198, 0.03018958494067192, 0.05491240695118904, 0.07037525624036789, -0.011605292558670044, -0.023998131975531578, -0.009731756523251534, 0.009852848015725613, -0.020699957385659218, 0.041424740105867386, -0.012841691263020039, 0.11576943844556808, -0.046609122306108475, 0.021992553025484085, 0.0019906850066035986, 0.08293497562408447, 0.03225448727607727, 0.05399511009454727, -0.01173273753374815, -0.031097937375307083, 0.051139917224645615, 0.03675924986600876, -0.01788666658103466, 0.015000076964497566, 0.046499013900756836, -0.05443669855594635, -0.017199983820319176, -0.029941368848085403, 0.0976766049861908, 0.04357675090432167, 0.006626011338084936, 0.07887763530015945, -0.05535132437944412, 0.02978680096566677, -0.009490867145359516, 0.003985142335295677, -0.03847890719771385, -0.03829023987054825, -0.014179727993905544, -0.023372899740934372, 0.02126399613916874, 0.017934219911694527, 0.03687354549765587, -0.03455450385808945, 0.006839756853878498, -0.05055931583046913, -0.04601147025823593, -0.002975297160446644, 0.050469137728214264, 0.0005698301829397678, -0.06166853383183479, -0.02384837530553341, 0.003627286059781909, -0.025826599448919296, -0.01918649487197399, -0.026814714074134827, -0.01242446806281805, 0.001847975654527545, -0.0008980864658951759, -0.036898333579301834, -0.009968526661396027, 0.0070314183831214905, 0.03449301794171333, 0.006481342017650604, -0.030147502198815346, 0.036836009472608566, 0.022839276120066643, -0.005239882972091436, -0.03388429805636406, -0.002751364139840007, 0.009633297100663185, 0.023648351430892944, 0.005068094469606876, -0.061357710510492325, 0.027053751051425934, 0.030496256425976753, 0.008560502901673317, -0.007236741483211517, 0.007357161026448011, -0.033012647181749344, -0.06220925599336624, -0.07148757576942444, 0.03075554035604, -0.00988918449729681, 0.003430088749155402, -0.02395859733223915, 0.010630988515913486, 0.021053796634078026, 0.054557960480451584, -0.0015456833643838763, 0.05141621083021164, 0.003595132613554597, 0.025978997349739075, -0.058393098413944244, 0.01688845083117485, -0.012172129936516285, -0.047979049384593964, -0.004169927444308996, -0.019932901486754417, 0.03877297416329384, -0.01255600992590189, 0.036241061985492706, -0.04864559695124626, 0.0522933267056942, 0.01972109265625477, 0.05449660122394562, -0.026198813691735268, -0.014932523481547832, 0.014445302076637745, 0.0036387171130627394, 0.016490448266267776, 0.0007594087510369718, -0.0018544984050095081, -0.02897808514535427, -0.07839147001504898, 0.01796645112335682, -0.04155938699841499, 0.04929931089282036, 0.061583101749420166, -0.04039780795574188, -0.03198973089456558, -0.08073590695858002, 0.008903267793357372, 0.05908432602882385, 0.006017948035150766, -0.011961927637457848, 0.058544378727674484, -0.02264425717294216, 0.03088497370481491, 0.01626015640795231, -0.02739523909986019, -0.005464931949973106, 0.005710935220122337, 0.006226664409041405, 0.0011254226556047797, -0.016802025958895683, 0.03601693734526634, 0.010529977269470692, -0.020286690443754196, -0.031170006841421127, -0.0696667730808258, -0.034299254417419434, 0.002560598310083151, -0.011282617226243019, -0.004664300009608269, 0.00959488283842802, -0.001402347581461072, 0.08064094185829163, 0.025198278948664665, 0.04360869899392128, 0.008096558973193169, -0.01309787854552269, 0.01700284332036972, -0.10438147187232971, 0.04896512255072594, 0.013896026648581028, 0.013187487609684467, 0.01838500425219536, -0.015161587856709957, -0.01313719805330038, 0.031262509524822235, 0.023813419044017792, -0.06061413884162903, -0.02819683961570263, 0.012166859582066536, 0.010065553709864616, 0.10931829363107681, -0.008934169076383114, -0.015349430032074451, -0.06064644455909729, -0.004373214207589626, -0.022020496428012848, 0.050415877252817154, -0.02355390600860119, -0.00028827672940678895, -0.04622969776391983, -0.025350332260131836, -0.005695566534996033, 0.016648106276988983, 0.013282575644552708, -0.012583989650011063, -0.048099685460329056, -0.02282397449016571, 0.01122092455625534, -0.023310834541916847, 0.03576410934329033, -0.006287837401032448, -0.01445863302797079, 0.005482638254761696, -0.08861640840768814, -0.015990326181054115, 0.003520463826134801, 0.01820637658238411, -0.004007092677056789, 0.05367700755596161, -0.02925102971494198, -0.06403243541717529, -0.01688121072947979, -0.020699189975857735, 0.02488882653415203, 0.0837353989481926, 0.03822910785675049, -0.01945575326681137, 0.0007711764192208648, -0.022988691926002502, 0.02890797145664692, 0.009842488914728165, -0.00386704970151186, -0.01671290025115013, 0.013399427756667137, 0.007695101201534271, -0.01542965043336153, -0.015014694072306156, -0.014186633750796318, -0.012487778440117836, 0.028875544667243958, 0.014394072815775871, -0.006450277753174305, -0.007991704158484936, -0.07995855063199997, 0.03663814067840576, 0.02845299430191517, 0.048673976212739944, -0.028166789561510086, 0.04009313881397247, 0.04420115426182747, -0.024667542427778244, -0.008064653724431992, 0.026804445311427116, 0.030188661068677902, 0.00361847341991961, 0.049905337393283844, -0.013904212974011898, 0.04138132557272911, -0.056472793221473694, 0.0285936426371336, -0.013836581259965897, -0.00944982748478651, 0.04687562212347984, 0.00302331754937768, -0.04865359142422676, -0.026490163058042526, -0.0011530915508046746, 0.013791133649647236, -0.03088427521288395, -0.020694855600595474, 0.043581511825323105, 0.06967468559741974, 0.019222397357225418, -0.01110165286809206, 0.013923129998147488, -0.007915852591395378, 0.055612705647945404, -0.01367153786122799, -0.09001577645540237, -0.051272470504045486, 0.0019192199688404799, -0.053489431738853455, -0.016158033162355423, 0.05342769995331764, 0.024547861889004707, 0.020596405491232872, -0.022051263600587845, -0.012879992835223675, -0.026691626757383347, 0.09602692723274231, -0.02305903472006321, -0.043643686920404434, -0.02545124664902687, -0.01672648824751377, -0.0073252576403319836, 0.010482454672455788, 0.057087477296590805, -0.008349192328751087, -0.03717627003788948, 0.05377312749624252, 0.017322979867458344, 0.03187672793865204, 0.0024062301963567734, -0.03906923905014992, 0.045135580003261566, -0.013614141382277012, 0.02566435933113098, -0.0014424945693463087, -0.015135832130908966, -0.05346109718084335, 0.04514716565608978, 0.05411042273044586, -0.017622411251068115, -0.006595434620976448, 0.021433845162391663, 0.040083691477775574, 0.03367464989423752, 0.010531862266361713, 0.012812712229788303, 0.03729641065001488, 0.055034805089235306, -0.0021808079909533262, 0.017655186355113983, -0.02586468495428562, 0.04082778841257095, 0.010958117432892323, 0.0025088016409426928, -0.0012711830204352736, -0.032565195113420486, -0.044064316898584366, 0.006244445685297251, -0.03069065324962139, -0.051978904753923416, -0.00030759599758312106, 0.0025909855030477047, 0.018916843459010124, 0.03372493386268616, -0.05325542762875557, 0.00958285853266716, -0.05361206829547882, -0.0035799043253064156, 0.01698419451713562, 0.035245705395936966, 0.0031571821309626102, -0.10064336657524109, 0.0015804145950824022, -0.09343710541725159, -0.01503993384540081, 0.05552201718091965, 0.0405423529446125, 0.030541639775037766, 0.035281065851449966, 0.08975919336080551, 0.07291378825902939, 0.00005114377199788578, 0.0015249381540343165, 0.0052983639761805534, 0.014238172210752964, -0.06792479753494263, -0.0014686735812574625, 0.023074975237250328, 0.011665590107440948, 0.012288438156247139, -0.018534960225224495, 0.024391377344727516, -0.06586600840091705, 0.04598031938076019, -0.04366379976272583, -0.0032091911416500807, -0.013807934708893299, -0.045384082943201065, 0.0026466883718967438, -0.02250906452536583, -0.011730399914085865, -0.07827919721603394, -0.030023865401744843, -0.023831196129322052, 0.020375052466988564, -0.013988206163048744, -0.06317779421806335, -0.001067189034074545, 0.019755922257900238, -0.01570744439959526, 0.03205413371324539, -0.0037157218903303146, -0.04573875665664673, -0.006398377474397421, 0.06898624449968338, 0.04548431187868118, -0.05565783753991127, 0.014210193417966366, -0.023075249046087265, 0.056563008576631546, 0.03119060955941677, -0.010540664196014404, 0.029544483870267868, 0.01408800482749939, -0.005284600425511599, 0.05055294185876846, 0.0013576810015365481, -0.02481570653617382, 0.02269507572054863, -0.04033072665333748, -0.028829699382185936, 0.04383135959506035, -0.05299979820847511, -0.057467229664325714, 0.059390921145677567, 0.011371992528438568, 0.07142464071512222, -0.014003491960465908, 0.04436720162630081, 0.021782008931040764, -0.01594272069633007, -0.019987786188721657, 0.043770719319581985, 0.031650952994823456, 0.01645756885409355, -0.00279996101744473, 0.0682237297296524, -0.009297909215092659, 0.0203276127576828, 0.08373761922121048, 0.035039179027080536, -0.027845319360494614, 0.009272519499063492, -0.012664290145039558, 0.056320443749427795, 0.057160280644893646, -0.01242161076515913, 0.06730912625789642, -0.02769889123737812, 0.018167568370699883, 0.007823796942830086, 0.014683866873383522, -0.023231836035847664, -0.08592382818460464, -0.019257700070738792, -0.05151225998997688, 0.007312800735235214, 0.03246356546878815, -0.027759872376918793, 0.028545908629894257, -0.0030745496042072773, -0.01058941800147295, -0.033410266041755676, 0.031024634838104248, 0.021724391728639603, 0.01798117533326149, -0.009061118587851524, 0.031872399151325226, 0.003680761903524399, -0.023443346843123436, -0.0147055359557271, 0.03765721246600151, -0.03500843420624733, 0.04822024703025818, -0.01498674601316452, -0.03364589065313339, 0.020744958892464638, -0.04295600950717926, -0.0011671795509755611, -0.05655894801020622, -0.03336910903453827, -0.02302451804280281, -0.06699410825967789, -0.005560140125453472, 0.049104977399110794, -0.03916233777999878, -0.06958887726068497, 0.024062830954790115, -0.005037101451307535, 0.011647200211882591, -0.03447045758366585, -0.049718037247657776, -0.00015373887435998768, 0.00760912848636508, -0.030779246240854263, 0.0153263034299016, -0.009478851221501827, 0.03246854990720749, 0.051517147570848465, 0.022799931466579437, -0.020017966628074646, -0.0002465615689288825, 0.04078516364097595, -0.021756436675786972, -0.0065446519292891026, 0.06011805683374405, -0.01794469729065895, 0.010697856545448303, 0.02875450626015663, -0.050894949585199356, -0.07260401546955109, -0.10913906991481781, -0.0059010982513427734, -0.06327211111783981, -0.031675610691308975, -0.049642980098724365, -0.09022889286279678, -0.054503194987773895, -0.005384883377701044, -0.09521383047103882, 0.013697567395865917, -0.03432592377066612, -0.06868953257799149, 0.04016685113310814, -0.030161596834659576, 0.0008442794205620885, -0.025089537724852562, 0.004065003711730242, -0.005852012429386377, 0.042500317096710205, -0.055294882506132126, 0.056668851524591446, -0.06904216855764389, -0.009556193836033344, 0.04162192344665527, -0.03311707451939583, -0.04434637725353241, -0.010874032974243164, 0.021924059838056564, 0.026890331879258156, 0.031507380306720734, 0.052227895706892014, -0.01880796253681183, 0.01168881542980671, -0.06903709471225739, -0.022662106901407242, 0.004877727944403887, -0.02462758682668209, -0.02724492736160755, 0.011407561600208282, -0.04680579900741577, 0.017708787694573402, -0.059248801320791245, 0.014216042123734951, -0.040446121245622635, 0.015920041128993034, -0.008736698888242245, 0.04060867801308632, 0.000551417819224298, 0.0039358665235340595, -0.03498013690114021, 0.06658103317022324, 0.0033974279649555683, -0.007942591793835163, 0.014805424027144909, 0.05040580406785011, 0.03259512409567833, -0.015400062315165997, -0.03983490914106369, 0.019095178693532944, 0.052060987800359726, 0.030410928651690483, 0.015214742161333561, -0.04939654842019081, 0.05996982753276825, 0.0043338206596672535, -0.01341269351541996, -0.027253715321421623, 0.04360348731279373, -0.06114059314131737, -0.010268187150359154, -0.03915778547525406, 0.04207354411482811, 0.05382895469665527, 0.03562217950820923, -0.06523836404085159, 0.08311866223812103, 0.04531058669090271, 0.011294741183519363, 0.057007648050785065, -0.041829466819763184, 0.0008012953330762684, 0.008988935500383377, -0.017255717888474464, 0.01583247445523739, -0.006555602420121431, 0.01613585650920868, -0.000014168821508064866, 0.02034566178917885, -0.04311639070510864, 0.06658438593149185, -0.018071040511131287, -0.00946156308054924, 0.027459459379315376, -0.028862841427326202, -0.015716830268502235, -0.029689937829971313, 0.04395269975066185, 0.030906906351447105, -0.05532123148441315, 0.038882043212652206, 0.024717656895518303, -0.04407787322998047, -0.016574038192629814, -0.016312776133418083, -0.06583604961633682, -0.009572671726346016, -0.035627130419015884, -0.003939724527299404, -0.08022534847259521, -0.028749821707606316, 0.03344675898551941, 0.0019927851390093565, -0.03760155662894249, -0.0247516930103302, 0.002102155238389969, -0.04366445913910866, 0.010502601973712444, -0.00247947801835835, -0.006205395329743624, -0.04909244552254677, 0.03266621381044388, 0.033870879560709, -0.03414703905582428, -0.025696218013763428, -0.03978555276989937, 0.042250171303749084, 0.017953207716345787, 0.001838645781390369, 0.021278435364365578, 0.023796655237674713, 0.00958966463804245, -0.03248994052410126, 0.10745493322610855, 0.03465789929032326, -0.06703808903694153, 0.00614303769543767, 0.02072102762758732, 0.06422311812639236, 0.05495285242795944, -0.03756820783019066, -0.06653618067502975, -0.049751751124858856, 0.012597935274243355, 0.03480759635567665, -0.003959001507610083, 0.028624454513192177, 0.017223000526428223, 0.0245753675699234, -0.02228667214512825, 0.009260796010494232, 0.01635904423892498, -0.03463645279407501, 0.010807178914546967 ]
<p>Say you have a chemical compound made up of one or more radioactive nuclei. If the nucleus decays, does the compound? </p> <p>Possible outcomes I can think of:</p> <ol> <li><p>the compounds continues to exist if a bonding is still possible between the decay product and the rest of the original compound.</p></li> <li><p>the compound just ceases to exist.</p></li> <li><p>the decay product forms a new compound with some fraction of the remainder of the original one but discards some other part.</p></li> </ol> <p>Generally, it will do whatever results in the least energetic state, but is there some kind of regularity to it?</p>
g739
[ 0.015877576544880867, -0.0020827704574912786, 0.021252188831567764, -0.04715244099497795, 0.031224317848682404, -0.03319820761680603, -0.09793614596128464, 0.0537690669298172, 0.05066811293363571, -0.08119907975196838, -0.019878214225172997, -0.010198383592069149, -0.045205067843198776, -0.06123858690261841, 0.009144564159214497, -0.0021326420828700066, 0.07719030976295471, -0.10873491317033768, 0.03883273899555206, 0.06084360554814339, -0.030756093561649323, 0.03171680122613907, 0.021997658535838127, 0.013570706360042095, -0.021782055497169495, -0.020713236182928085, 0.019078193232417107, -0.0008748327381908894, -0.0758502408862114, -0.004402732942253351, 0.0336233526468277, -0.0237560011446476, 0.02621271274983883, -0.04517199471592903, -0.004515346605330706, -0.039019182324409485, 0.05192430689930916, 0.01870759017765522, 0.008738316595554352, -0.011221088469028473, 0.0069135879166424274, 0.00020803081861231476, 0.05604008212685585, -0.03538348153233528, -0.006072210613638163, -0.01090371422469616, -0.040154583752155304, 0.004897569306194782, 0.059637654572725296, -0.0446503609418869, -0.028823239728808403, 0.0008814409375190735, -0.023699011653661728, 0.005179858300834894, -0.010511435568332672, 0.015874844044446945, -0.007774839643388987, -0.010708553716540337, -0.011029351502656937, 0.008069772273302078, 0.03153103217482567, -0.009212132543325424, 0.008196740411221981, -0.0006535416468977928, 0.11159850656986237, -0.059659432619810104, -0.08446155488491058, 0.04975350573658943, 0.04838535562157631, -0.017384489998221397, 0.029024461284279823, 0.033546846359968185, -0.022013423964381218, -0.034189339727163315, -0.01387730985879898, 0.006731471512466669, -0.018978340551257133, -0.016573503613471985, -0.0008329423726536334, 0.045147452503442764, -0.06133667752146721, -0.03369264677166939, 0.021308980882167816, 0.021047106012701988, 0.02207939885556698, 0.051609303802251816, 0.03934614732861519, -0.011740823276340961, -0.05607590824365616, 0.07397983223199844, 0.028694525361061096, -0.010400158353149891, 0.027706747874617577, -0.024217890575528145, 0.005230214912444353, 0.008794385008513927, -0.0076227555982768536, 0.03887953236699104, 0.00280994875356555, -0.03449776768684387, 0.04633701220154762, 0.0020872203167527914, 0.010983535088598728, -0.03711334243416786, -0.004993109963834286, -0.004167309496551752, 0.025204859673976898, -0.032499730587005615, -0.012326294556260109, 0.03133631497621536, -0.011194402351975441, -0.023802336305379868, -0.03310772404074669, -0.042502786964178085, 0.03708365187048912, 0.0256903488188982, 0.048306968063116074, -0.0337599441409111, 0.01316798571497202, -0.003267781576141715, -0.00007719101995462552, 0.06470846384763718, 0.009766856208443642, 0.004714638460427523, -0.023276312276721, -0.0064725251868367195, 0.008239064365625381, 0.020648706704378128, 0.06540071219205856, 0.011746825650334358, -0.0186204481869936, 0.009232496842741966, -0.027934039011597633, 0.04624807834625244, -0.018582047894597054, -0.03448300436139107, -0.043785687536001205, 0.02956613339483738, 0.014055868610739708, -0.08016006648540497, 0.03750530257821083, 0.0016463494393974543, 0.000891178147867322, 0.04270052909851074, -0.0489104799926281, 0.033078327775001526, 0.013759840279817581, 0.03841465339064598, 0.012046847492456436, 0.05695319548249245, -0.02169036492705345, -0.0292534027248621, 0.023599926382303238, -0.031101252883672714, 0.00969849992543459, 0.0014020523522049189, -0.005023007281124592, -0.027029117569327354, -0.04131186753511429, -0.02311752364039421, 0.039825595915317535, -0.000933937611989677, -0.06869669258594513, -0.01443424541503191, -0.032005198299884796, 0.013882921077311039, 0.03067748434841633, -0.05566934868693352, -0.03558868169784546, -0.027942778542637825, -0.020846733823418617, -0.00714158033952117, -0.014851661399006844, 0.06958269327878952, 0.0509318932890892, 0.007683833595365286, 0.002545166527852416, -0.014396152459084988, -0.003232691204175353, 0.010903164744377136, -0.02106628566980362, 0.04826992750167847, -0.03213934600353241, 0.007258610334247351, 0.01108445692807436, 0.019753145053982735, 0.008221880532801151, 0.03706064820289612, -0.06209762394428253, 0.0450083389878273, -0.02318059839308262, 0.02232985571026802, -0.009841086342930794, -0.014417475089430809, 0.0038227734621614218, -0.04985086992383003, -0.01941676251590252, -0.004727861378341913, 0.025428295135498047, -0.03155066445469856, -0.002863479545339942, -0.03713415190577507, -0.06707382947206497, 0.04605749994516373, 0.01921462081372738, -0.05929434671998024, -0.0575769878923893, 0.016660964116454124, 0.03154320642352104, -0.032623324543237686, 0.02362951450049877, 0.008777986280620098, -0.03118731454014778, -0.027508800849318504, -0.013492313213646412, -0.04969543591141701, 0.0069062779657542706, 0.08514685183763504, -0.023875024169683456, 0.020774444565176964, -0.015128408558666706, 0.019018052145838737, -0.005560054909437895, 0.0012282893294468522, 0.00010155994823435321, 0.03113885223865509, -0.015505477786064148, 0.002281729131937027, -0.011902288533747196, 0.03593819588422775, -0.026358507573604584, 0.011955822817981243, -0.01153587456792593, -0.05622181296348572, 0.010560142807662487, 0.04086608067154884, 0.0004452734428923577, -0.06286782026290894, 0.0368092842400074, 0.030193213373422623, -0.026286445558071136, -0.01502961665391922, -0.07171890884637833, 0.009723375551402569, 0.0632893443107605, -0.06057170033454895, 0.007967347279191017, -0.021444158628582954, -0.009887995198369026, 0.03951070085167885, -0.016946470364928246, -0.020843753591179848, -0.0391378216445446, 0.004414970520883799, -0.04777446389198303, -0.03633170202374458, -0.023913225159049034, 0.082707479596138, 0.019455108791589737, 0.008952994830906391, 0.032620206475257874, 0.022683272138237953, -0.005059925839304924, -0.03225855529308319, -0.03289045765995979, -0.01557929627597332, 0.01861191913485527, -0.029440291225910187, -0.0005691552069038153, 0.05639810860157013, -0.05643829330801964, 0.0250579621642828, 0.026248188689351082, 0.07510218769311905, -0.001749639050103724, 0.04423838108778, -0.01421353965997696, -0.019243955612182617, -0.016439413651823997, 0.0182949248701334, 0.05345018953084946, 0.03605550900101662, -0.03673838451504707, 0.006810496561229229, 0.010033701546490192, -0.010530686937272549, 0.03193330019712448, -0.0010205396683886647, 0.04554271325469017, 0.029670629650354385, -0.024069318547844887, -0.0009024825412780046, 0.10046819597482681, -0.036894068121910095, 0.02134394459426403, -0.01984284818172455, -0.01864643022418022, -0.04553837329149246, -0.0668429285287857, 0.01985137164592743, 0.003953753039240837, -0.030392244458198547, -0.022066285833716393, 0.02240629494190216, -0.04289581626653671, 0.04588465765118599, -0.07858870923519135, 0.005923897493630648, -0.0018272275337949395, -0.005273232702165842, -0.031069966033101082, 0.061486758291721344, -0.020014552399516106, -0.02918340638279915, -0.03720702603459358, -0.009229824878275394, 0.023727810010313988, 0.022333158180117607, -0.003706524148583412, -0.03845439478754997, 0.003555461298674345, -0.027612853795289993, 0.016559777781367302, -0.06133277341723442, 0.03526332974433899, 0.034045323729515076, -0.10904894769191742, -0.051555972546339035, -0.03761184215545654, -0.01798725128173828, 0.010614362545311451, 0.0025535114109516144, -0.02142053283751011, -0.00001076987427950371, -0.016277985647320747, -0.040670763701200485, -0.06121141463518143, 0.04519393667578697, 0.043661970645189285, 0.02357499860227108, 0.042904458940029144, -0.0037152741570025682, 0.030690211802721024, 0.005950187798589468, 0.04708334803581238, 0.007312823086977005, -0.037434983998537064, 0.011104271747171879, 0.007445852737873793, -0.02461882494390011, 0.03879033774137497, -0.05725960433483124, 0.00851263478398323, -0.001471264404244721, 0.015317345969378948, -0.002705872990190983, -0.055794909596443176, -0.003189372131600976, 0.059919606894254684, 0.025822024792432785, -0.05115337669849396, -0.06316917389631271, 0.07475978881120682, -0.020001929253339767, -0.011596162803471088, 0.04957936331629753, -0.0005329678533598781, 0.0672246664762497, 0.035219982266426086, 0.013233447447419167, -0.01208196859806776, 0.04181428253650665, 0.02638736553490162, -0.013956340029835701, 0.04752353951334953, 0.051347460597753525, 0.048034749925136566, 0.04320405423641205, -0.08192335814237595, 0.04601159319281578, 0.013405071571469307, -0.01741374284029007, -0.002512991428375244, -0.014948216266930103, -0.006635419558733702, -0.008693722076714039, -0.019354980438947678, 0.02318391017615795, -0.0636986568570137, 0.025952830910682678, -0.004458184354007244, -0.06263525038957596, -0.021357668563723564, 0.004984001163393259, -0.0024785948917269707, -0.07048771530389786, 0.01326314453035593, -0.0398409329354763, -0.004721239674836397, 0.0006621969514526427, -0.06947201490402222, 0.027106856927275658, -0.03535442426800728, -0.003960722126066685, 0.09659672528505325, 0.02013230137526989, -0.016069108620285988, -0.02651965245604515, 0.01567496731877327, -0.03107544593513012, 0.01344110257923603, 0.01836901158094406, -0.002377352910116315, 0.044156402349472046, -0.026457397267222404, -0.03158126771450043, 0.0004901005886495113, 0.038413699716329575, -0.05206211283802986, 0.039032548666000366, -0.03269224241375923, 0.028156669810414314, -0.03595251590013504, 0.056420937180519104, 0.005305036902427673, -0.021674521267414093, 0.0320267379283905, -0.010122386738657951, -0.026182254776358604, -0.020640473812818527, 0.02619236521422863, 0.0028336041141301394, 0.06175918132066727, -0.07612889260053635, -0.05092385411262512, -0.022785359993577003, -0.04450118541717529, 0.025372955948114395, -0.012173084542155266, 0.06377879530191422, 0.06501627713441849, 0.009960953146219254, 0.03544370085000992, 0.029346851631999016, 0.015109967440366745, 0.029335616156458855, -0.04189835116267204, -0.03615787997841835, 0.0566447377204895, -0.033225324004888535, 0.008560811169445515, 0.024582475423812866, -0.052842408418655396, -0.03641204908490181, -0.005860933568328619, -0.030730517581105232, -0.004376102704554796, 0.04463881999254227, -0.00993936974555254, 0.0874420627951622, -0.03241318091750145, -0.020098408684134483, 0.0633101686835289, 0.027017008513212204, -0.027820825576782227, -0.03635946661233902, 0.042873814702034, -0.0340484194457531, -0.03947112709283829, 0.03192958980798721, -0.010692527517676353, 0.02170209027826786, 0.07285887748003006, 0.007403986062854528, -0.03288731351494789, -0.11107125133275986, -0.0029054651968181133, 0.027708010748028755, -0.002153706504032016, -0.008606812916696072, -0.01207814458757639, 0.030653206631541252, -0.08197029680013657, -0.010369437746703625, -0.0007742710877209902, 0.03765696659684181, -0.005581068340688944, -0.04929288104176521, 0.052625980228185654, -0.007936729118227959, 0.032559700310230255, 0.04137524217367172, 0.0738060399889946, 0.00876943115144968, 0.01593710668385029, -0.03310910239815712, -0.03554607927799225, 0.00027655239682644606, -0.03274844214320183, 0.027202818542718887, -0.026561511680483818, 0.011138631962239742, 0.00829219724982977, 0.011398197151720524, 0.03749646991491318, 0.034770336002111435, 0.03521396592259407, -0.013156439177691936, -0.0050120544619858265, -0.022513797506690025, -0.02462991140782833, 0.009239189326763153, -0.00482782581821084, 0.0746150091290474, -0.050544627010822296, 0.0061278678476810455, -0.10114315152168274, 0.023168103769421577, -0.0571160726249218, -0.03430883586406708, -0.025963492691516876, -0.009696935303509235, 0.02805212326347828, -0.040640152990818024, 0.024570854380726814, -0.051698923110961914, -0.04144521802663803, 0.016291944310069084, 0.0337902307510376, 0.053630780428647995, 0.08314941823482513, 0.03081747330725193, -0.02533767931163311, 0.020058149471879005, -0.020067697390913963, -0.020366305485367775, -0.08487723767757416, 0.0122254379093647, 0.029198525473475456, 0.04955160617828369, 0.042841311544179916, -0.00498405285179615, 0.003609905717894435, 0.11217532306909561, 0.010878344066441059, -0.024972740560770035, -0.025029756128787994, 0.013270571827888489, -0.004895729478448629, 0.004728213418275118, 0.01570121757686138, -0.002404555445536971, -0.05846511945128441, 0.005415939260274172, 0.06767832487821579, 0.02784266322851181, 0.04066481813788414, 0.04875550419092178, 0.012304138392210007, 0.02893046848475933, -0.036781344562768936, 0.01768127828836441, 0.011411676183342934, 0.03941449895501137, 0.04591064900159836, -0.04670517519116402, -0.03136785700917244, -0.03256155923008919, -0.02244236133992672, 0.05998557433485985, 0.0297384113073349, -0.01413691695779562, 0.002949146553874016, -0.010816408321261406, 0.007630456704646349, 0.006674838252365589, -0.020840466022491455, -0.03025348111987114, 0.026608826592564583, 0.011456686072051525, -0.014540090225636959, -0.014605735428631306, -0.007484167814254761, -0.016640793532133102, -0.01992432028055191, 0.02041144296526909, 0.005494580138474703, 0.027638832107186317, 0.010467546060681343, -0.00040652105235494673, -0.02313581109046936, 0.006446247920393944, -0.018870873376727104, 0.020673159509897232, -0.021213319152593613, 0.001716834376566112, -0.05197698622941971, -0.03384960815310478, -0.006508158054202795, 0.017631586641073227, 0.012004788964986801, 0.023125963285565376, 0.06555165350437164, -0.032454442232847214, -0.031399838626384735, 0.05142431706190109, -0.04131413251161575, 0.017969459295272827, -0.04807227849960327, -0.015415515750646591, -0.002968571847304702, 0.02538195252418518, 0.0599457211792469, 0.022472061216831207, -0.020680777728557587, -0.0332249253988266, 0.05007500946521759, 0.035166043788194656, -0.08135329931974411, -0.00826806016266346, 0.003089982084929943, -0.06968279182910919, 0.039846573024988174, 0.03792015463113785, 0.004786915145814419, 0.08381415158510208, -0.010106912814080715, 0.026029212400317192, 0.0013454336440190673, 0.02633955515921116, -0.013202526606619358, 0.021897554397583008, 0.050537388771772385, -0.013084947131574154, -0.02507033944129944, 0.042981598526239395, -0.06569800525903702, -0.032192159444093704, 0.03725471720099449, -0.019639190286397934, 0.027340613305568695, 0.030076652765274048, 0.020890673622488976, 0.033108144998550415, -0.06138462945818901, 0.014322405681014061, 0.09297327697277069, -0.0018442576983943582, -0.026710007339715958, -0.05919822305440903, 0.04652699828147888, 0.021073564887046814, 0.01155918650329113, 0.048871129751205444, -0.040505871176719666, 0.002821841510012746, 0.013327637687325478, -0.01136037241667509, -0.013363762758672237, -0.048246197402477264, -0.015695760026574135, -0.027917006984353065, 0.019567500799894333, -0.037866584956645966, -0.02142759971320629, -0.016546597704291344, 0.08268938213586807, -0.03202572837471962, -0.0010788890067487955, -0.011241634376347065, -0.01532880961894989, -0.05980640649795532, -0.012778050266206264, -0.010163871571421623, 0.03059868887066841, 0.010313139297068119, 0.0465349480509758, -0.026194319128990173, 0.06336887180805206, -0.005532449577003717, -0.024517331272363663, 0.0007779468433000147, -0.014008191414177418, -0.01621292345225811, -0.02505224384367466, 0.06829584389925003, -0.0014727715170010924, 0.002247030846774578, -0.011872190982103348, 0.009757306426763535, -0.02184426784515381, 0.04974992945790291, 0.04789471626281738, -0.038783151656389236, -0.03547871112823486, 0.00857291929423809, -0.004313729237765074, 0.0056265415623784065, -0.04113655537366867, 0.018194131553173065, -0.012328865006566048, 0.014190739020705223, 0.04482778161764145, -0.029575057327747345, 0.03269166126847267, 0.014313762076199055, -0.020507659763097763, 0.008673923090100288, -0.034202661365270615, -0.022861190140247345, 0.0382334440946579, 0.006007794290781021, -0.01135103590786457, -0.04832589626312256, -0.04294151812791824, -0.03978239372372627, -0.010252725332975388, -0.031056329607963562, 0.04231174290180206, 0.025115415453910828, -0.03660866990685463, 0.03366401791572571, -0.03572465106844902, 0.005803104490041733, -0.0030013087671250105, -0.011091948486864567, 0.008973989635705948, 0.03145400434732437, 0.018824312835931778, 0.026536516845226288, 0.008619473315775394, 0.04520178213715553, -0.043922774493694305, -0.03295078128576279, 0.0571122020483017, 0.014797638170421124, -0.02296523004770279, -0.02690783515572548, -0.014182423241436481, 0.027184337377548218, -0.024885864928364754, -0.04474484920501709, 0.03451923653483391, 0.011240913532674313, 0.010427811183035374, -0.03953651338815689, -0.012453434057533741, 0.05723981931805611, 0.03864128142595291, -0.04920453578233719, -0.10956693440675735, 0.03085555136203766, -0.0068190270103514194, 0.08233361691236496, 0.07690016180276871, -0.00022476405138149858, -0.011537771672010422, 0.07404343038797379, 0.01424255408346653, 0.0008363868691958487, -0.03615381941199303, 0.03873889148235321, -0.05851250886917114, -0.07474028319120407, -0.023990368470549583, -0.0018494372488930821, 0.01312288548797369, -0.0062416656874120235 ]
<p>(little background: I'm trying to develop a small, quick 'n dirty static physics engine to determine whether a stacking of boxes is stable).</p> <p>If I have a 3D rigid box (with the bottom in the horizontal plane), resting on n points (at [xn, yn]), and we apply a downward force F at [xF, yF], how can I calculate the resulting forces Fn at these n points?</p> <p>If the system is in equilibrium then sum(Fn) should be equal to F. However, I must also consider that the system might not be in equilibrium (for instance, if all xn &lt; xF), so I probably can't use equilibrium equations. I'd still like to know the forces in that case, though, so that I can calculate the resulting torque.</p> <p>Is there an easy formula for this? </p>
g4191
[ -0.007905439473688602, 0.04634733870625496, -0.021452665328979492, -0.016374537721276283, 0.028491728007793427, -0.021670982241630554, 0.009603705257177353, -0.03013901226222515, -0.07202363014221191, -0.03767208755016327, -0.06358252465724945, -0.016957473009824753, 0.02568962797522545, -0.010672738775610924, -0.006438841111958027, 0.05316891893744469, 0.08635067939758301, -0.02389153651893139, 0.026050545275211334, 0.022310946136713028, 0.027376964688301086, 0.004576772917062044, -0.022146765142679214, -0.0251289214938879, 0.034670669585466385, 0.020519956946372986, 0.00573124922811985, 0.034746211022138596, -0.06624921411275864, 0.002571837743744254, -0.04215047508478165, 0.04325707256793976, -0.006331958808004856, -0.007318450137972832, -0.014190101996064186, -0.03604978322982788, 0.04318852722644806, 0.022815922275185585, 0.03487902134656906, -0.050670523196458817, -0.027319302782416344, -0.028912289068102837, 0.040047403424978256, -0.012082277797162533, -0.028293628245592117, -0.07196854799985886, -0.017577650025486946, -0.038846682757139206, -0.01937653124332428, -0.00268974294885993, -0.03717717528343201, 0.007355874869972467, -0.001244091778062284, -0.05091140419244766, -0.006441188510507345, 0.018377291038632393, 0.03697655722498894, -0.049289997667074203, -0.02741357870399952, -0.0013271006755530834, -0.06935272365808487, 0.002416927134618163, 0.03065313771367073, 0.00506294472143054, 0.04484686627984047, -0.009078679606318474, -0.053588662296533585, -0.002038950100541115, -0.028762098401784897, -0.03841731697320938, -0.019992627203464508, -0.0005847361753694713, 0.028956981375813484, -0.03943834453821182, -0.057359591126441956, -0.0012563682394102216, 0.02754969708621502, 0.055346280336380005, 0.0006264527910389006, -0.0673803836107254, -0.012136193923652172, 0.014042679220438004, 0.0519099198281765, 0.020827868953347206, 0.057951245456933975, 0.003699492895975709, 0.05253022164106369, 0.009142518974840641, -0.004855074919760227, 0.009768090210855007, 0.03957859426736832, 0.0688396543264389, 0.049501217901706696, 0.02799258753657341, 0.006693082395941019, -0.048177581280469894, 0.028010768815875053, 0.05464842915534973, 0.02619944140315056, -0.02327757701277733, -0.018011966720223427, -0.002596674021333456, -0.04121895506978035, -0.03290082514286041, -0.005846691783517599, -0.032358042895793915, 0.06085904315114021, 0.04560649394989014, -0.03396332636475563, -0.03835643082857132, -0.01671815849840641, 0.024370769038796425, -0.013177421875298023, -0.05173956975340843, 0.017886869609355927, -0.05397235229611397, -0.013579818420112133, -0.019834553822875023, 0.059250570833683014, 0.06598532944917679, 0.05558445677161217, 0.03300971910357475, -0.054701536893844604, 0.07878529280424118, 0.029486775398254395, -0.008125409483909607, -0.05535006523132324, 0.051121171563863754, 0.0013178992085158825, 0.021177632734179497, 0.052159860730171204, -0.04879603534936905, -0.022354191169142723, -0.0188739076256752, 0.0087726516649127, 0.05797240138053894, -0.06726385653018951, -0.01596398651599884, 0.03205762058496475, 0.016478942707180977, -0.0482923723757267, -0.03316858038306236, -0.02742863819003105, 0.028248798102140427, 0.010264204815030098, 0.05728834867477417, -0.026420382782816887, -0.023542024195194244, 0.03814956918358803, 0.014167812652885914, 0.01697501726448536, 0.09259744733572006, 0.05384483560919762, -0.061364077031612396, 0.027841251343488693, -0.017512017861008644, -0.001875213347375393, -0.03228878974914551, 0.012260454706847668, -0.05010591074824333, 0.0816221609711647, -0.029441162943840027, -0.007903101854026318, -0.04564819484949112, -0.0394003801047802, 0.03611856326460838, -0.04784154146909714, -0.049335625022649765, 0.01726451888680458, -0.005791324190795422, -0.030905891209840775, 0.025644613429903984, 0.023433120921254158, -0.002105572959408164, 0.04571094363927841, 0.022779162973165512, 0.01207879837602377, -0.012712839059531689, 0.046414636075496674, 0.002244788222014904, 0.032545749098062515, 0.029153339564800262, 0.06947272270917892, 0.027170786634087563, -0.02590523101389408, 0.010971208103001118, 0.02375737391412258, 0.0008844384574331343, -0.034160733222961426, 0.03415079787373543, -0.016317082569003105, 0.05484450235962868, -0.030261825770139694, 0.021692615002393723, -0.07837087661027908, 0.0011885015992447734, 0.05716085806488991, -0.033281609416007996, 0.05203280597925186, 0.016346078366041183, -0.04056568443775177, 0.0030312114395201206, 0.04273661598563194, 0.014882590621709824, 0.0005474252975545824, 0.02242913655936718, -0.00021718424977734685, -0.005233047530055046, 0.021985772997140884, 0.028052575886249542, -0.035859279334545135, 0.015903523191809654, -0.006350328214466572, 0.00030105310725048184, 0.004920138977468014, 0.035025306046009064, 0.012450069189071655, 0.01928360015153885, -0.004045272246003151, 0.010925279930233955, -0.05633334070444107, -0.007217013277113438, -0.016511227935552597, 0.03753026947379112, -0.08740518242120743, -0.05533555895090103, -0.003005960024893284, 0.026364022865891457, 0.0023482635151594877, -0.005465046502649784, -0.015378215350210667, -0.01725446805357933, -0.032098643481731415, -0.0507996529340744, 0.046161338686943054, 0.023927634581923485, -0.0039344350807368755, -0.010672408156096935, 0.010913718491792679, 0.05586007982492447, 0.01570107415318489, 0.00798406358808279, 0.004803460091352463, -0.016840510070323944, 0.009537595324218273, 0.014250336214900017, 0.01660933345556259, 0.017151081934571266, 0.04416247084736824, 0.02334875985980034, -0.01843535713851452, -0.018649881705641747, -0.017078658565878868, 0.034408945590257645, -0.017693571746349335, 0.03740265220403671, -0.09723088145256042, 0.0002320933126611635, -0.013594737276434898, -0.0650612860918045, 0.01870378665626049, 0.0013040004996582866, -0.0059983935207128525, 0.009165099821984768, -0.06043441966176033, -0.033215634524822235, 0.029993882402777672, -0.0631212592124939, 0.04291015490889549, 0.06123381108045578, -0.028703562915325165, -0.06259221583604813, 0.0019876956939697266, 0.01643705926835537, 0.0037690550088882446, -0.036878131330013275, -0.008896009996533394, -0.039789829403162, 0.004617814440280199, 0.03782226890325546, 0.038290124386548996, 0.008255045861005783, 0.01302843727171421, 0.06362200528383255, 0.06627020984888077, -0.00158021692186594, -0.005300592631101608, -0.03851233795285225, -0.010673543438315392, 0.034294627606868744, 0.026966750621795654, 0.05568557232618332, 0.022369788959622383, -0.014915854670107365, -0.046911727637052536, 0.016162216663360596, -0.028811415657401085, -0.041056420654058456, -0.007817147299647331, 0.038297295570373535, -0.026586618274450302, 0.011727072298526764, 0.04940691962838173, -0.021148953586816788, -0.00033834524219855666, 0.056581173092126846, 0.00593931507319212, -0.009704389609396458, 0.04861026257276535, 0.002949066460132599, -0.07988335937261581, 0.05243135988712311, 0.020629240199923515, -0.06891775131225586, -0.08944905549287796, -0.015613382682204247, 0.08046726882457733, -0.000766533485148102, -0.00686055701225996, -0.06253267824649811, -0.008900449611246586, -0.10224492102861404, -0.020148608833551407, -0.03257732093334198, 0.036055147647857666, 0.056119054555892944, -0.03700762987136841, 0.008729986846446991, -0.006477006245404482, 0.01122584193944931, 0.08736155927181244, -0.002505021868273616, 0.01292045135051012, 0.009496363811194897, -0.035450730472803116, -0.004140617325901985, -0.01724683865904808, -0.05414099991321564, 0.014410607516765594, 0.021027708426117897, -0.02340368926525116, -0.026984689757227898, -0.0430450364947319, -0.027057550847530365, -0.04885172098875046, 0.011135975830256939, 0.006889813579618931, 0.05353328213095665, -0.00785747729241848, -0.0017294726567342877, -0.01210309099406004, -0.03000710718333721, 0.004678789060562849, -0.015077224932610989, 0.04306358844041824, 0.03548688068985939, 0.014100408181548119, -0.065674789249897, -0.08185921609401703, 0.052820898592472076, -0.01038638036698103, -0.042841002345085144, -0.011453259736299515, 0.051917362958192825, 0.008090490475296974, -0.016671719029545784, -0.03503495454788208, 0.0742911696434021, 0.020888734608888626, -0.0177997425198555, -0.012877222150564194, -0.029972856864333153, -0.019893500953912735, -0.005750233773142099, 0.033129557967185974, -0.04230066388845444, 0.08234955370426178, -0.0474417619407177, -0.019426638260483742, 0.0227963887155056, 0.03815704956650734, 0.03187942877411842, -0.05709533020853996, 0.037746939808130264, 0.020065689459443092, 0.0947781428694725, -0.04157605394721031, 0.026092316955327988, 0.010528831742703915, 0.06920056790113449, -0.04222138971090317, -0.020351918414235115, -0.01824749819934368, 0.0677928626537323, 0.029304329305887222, -0.01709536649286747, -0.033984728157520294, 0.013779863715171814, -0.02958521619439125, 0.025768542662262917, 0.08715887367725372, 0.0025773695670068264, -0.01790614426136017, -0.00263337604701519, 0.0060918498784303665, 0.030023954808712006, -0.005600545089691877, 0.007611907087266445, 0.0373731330037117, 0.019466973841190338, 0.012232355773448944, -0.05426983907818794, 0.04089359566569328, -0.0004812449333257973, 0.0020954806823283434, -0.030310707166790962, 0.04731789603829384, -0.00022100158093962818, 0.027891792356967926, -0.033199187368154526, 0.03601258248090744, 0.049618933349847794, -0.031311653554439545, -0.04768582433462143, -0.008788716979324818, 0.031802043318748474, 0.00671096658334136, -0.014155243523418903, 0.02550485171377659, 0.0028433219995349646, -0.032769106328487396, 0.0029216434340924025, -0.0075419265776872635, 0.014872781001031399, -0.036629077047109604, -0.0045023090206086636, -0.029780084267258644, -0.06849607080221176, -0.007935924455523491, 0.021266402676701546, -0.020506445318460464, 0.06807387620210648, 0.016613204032182693, -0.03898119926452637, -0.06301466375589371, 0.024536844342947006, -0.05359974876046181, -0.04461262375116348, -0.01499125175178051, -0.028462115675210953, -0.023247282952070236, 0.0023196504916995764, 0.015368407592177391, 0.006578532513231039, -0.02962438575923443, 0.05097492039203644, -0.008101208135485649, 0.0025406363420188427, -0.001647711731493473, -0.028591245412826538, -0.002143021672964096, -0.0836959034204483, -0.04402057081460953, -0.04350284859538078, 0.026504581794142723, 0.03183979541063309, -0.0005711537087336183, 0.019497230648994446, -0.04238566756248474, 0.02638968639075756, 0.031551774591207504, -0.014319662936031818, 0.03190690279006958, 0.0022596833296120167, 0.0031948599498718977, -0.0047114840708673, -0.025917287915945053, 0.000740024377591908, 0.05637715384364128, -0.008351282216608524, 0.0038274815306067467, 0.0027356238570064306, 0.008768627420067787, 0.004664058331400156, -0.0020474728662520647, -0.051072828471660614, 0.02335364930331707, -0.0037498928140848875, -0.020286966115236282, -0.033692169934511185, -0.014583084732294083, 0.015266546979546547, -0.0175605658441782, -0.050515685230493546, -0.06136316433548927, 0.041664138436317444, -0.02810245007276535, -0.04599856585264206, -0.05910833552479744, -0.0056238602846860886, -0.10206583887338638, 0.010061636567115784, 0.02728741057217121, -0.023706752806901932, 0.027319733053445816, 0.03580109775066376, 0.08018255233764648, -0.05859501287341118, 0.04614919051527977, 0.029989583417773247, 0.05947475507855415, -0.021637720987200737, 0.014197807759046555, 0.0662737712264061, -0.003317414317280054, -0.011959456838667393, 0.030349772423505783, 0.048536740243434906, -0.07951637357473373, 0.028300205245614052, 0.06444477289915085, -0.000537617364898324, 0.01911848969757557, 0.0030681381467729807, 0.008425678126513958, 0.005251133814454079, -0.037995923310518265, 0.025033265352249146, -0.03825709596276283, 0.00762290321290493, -0.05441025272011757, -0.0034345430321991444, -0.0019422679906710982, -0.01987159252166748, -0.008799503557384014, -0.02019321173429489, 0.03256510570645332, -0.012776119634509087, 0.06996355950832367, 0.0044680689461529255, -0.012262817472219467, -0.021830430254340172, 0.0020934075582772493, 0.025872578844428062, -0.06850482523441315, -0.03702349588274956, -0.03213949501514435, -0.026539821177721024, 0.044365137815475464, 0.027177246287465096, -0.020238833501935005, 0.05411534011363983, -0.05347266048192978, -0.0024138367734849453, -0.0720476508140564, 0.054986465722322464, -0.026051906868815422, -0.009040244854986668, 0.011363618075847626, -0.009249958209693432, 0.006753233261406422, -0.003916323650628328, 0.00482543557882309, 0.008505839854478836, -0.02017005905508995, 0.02611357904970646, -0.00543251121416688, 0.009427670389413834, 0.03895095735788345, -0.0037827289197593927, 0.06801128387451172, 0.03644293174147606, 0.011075965128839016, 0.014602554962038994, 0.05668673664331436, 0.019126705825328827, -0.030949076637625694, -0.013798745349049568, -0.01919015496969223, 0.07157828658819199, -0.03963151574134827, 0.006979247089475393, 0.022407958284020424, -0.022099172696471214, -0.04174451902508736, 0.06922539323568344, -0.00007681563147343695, -0.004018045961856842, -0.007294335402548313, -0.0754152238368988, 0.035682618618011475, -0.017962921410799026, 0.013714426197111607, 0.028408382087945938, 0.03731552138924599, -0.005450834054499865, 0.04292092099785805, 0.09198717027902603, 0.026965755969285965, 0.0227807704359293, -0.02425377629697323, 0.054563477635383606, 0.03260935842990875, -0.060291193425655365, -0.02140701562166214, -0.031117361038923264, -0.021829944103956223, -0.03154173493385315, -0.03928866609930992, -0.037851110100746155, -0.0038901197258383036, 0.023671559989452362, -0.028710149228572845, 0.0839073583483696, 0.04721062257885933, -0.013059149496257305, 0.05274838209152222, 0.00881623849272728, 0.010295340791344643, -0.029286567121744156, -0.033967290073633194, -0.06174236908555031, 0.008219259791076183, -0.06296124309301376, -0.014694713056087494, -0.02675790712237358, -0.07173726707696915, -0.038626495748758316, 0.04624886065721512, 0.03710132837295532, 0.04460230842232704, -0.01049194298684597, 0.03076493926346302, 0.0064885588362813, -0.02706434391438961, 0.047827672213315964, 0.014141671359539032, 0.034804098308086395, 0.03383265435695648, 0.10382334142923355, -0.06276524811983109, 0.05719047039747238, 0.034873515367507935, 0.01854518987238407, -0.046638645231723785, -0.029222480952739716, -0.006703545339405537, -0.0046459282748401165, -0.059760682284832, 0.03595222160220146, -0.021040670573711395, -0.04811612144112587, -0.029125073924660683, 0.003636153182014823, -0.061044223606586456, 0.015440044924616814, 0.015049860812723637, -0.03328654542565346, -0.012019367888569832, 0.011320916004478931, -0.012610130943357944, 0.036304935812950134, -0.001545772422105074, 0.0404314249753952, -0.005293125286698341, 0.05414649099111557, -0.014282233081758022, -0.009407651610672474, 0.030648253858089447, -0.023723363876342773, 0.013715873472392559, -0.03843750059604645, -0.0014023443218320608, 0.05080471560359001, -0.027010438963770866, 0.02471105381846428, 0.04171152040362358, 0.009689932689070702, 0.021813610568642616, -0.03894693776965141, -0.00833839364349842, 0.054051000624895096, -0.052203547209501266, 0.0013796514831483364, -0.05289127305150032, 0.013462614268064499, 0.0791657492518425, -0.015932828187942505, -0.02322409301996231, -0.019845163449645042, 0.03975672647356987, 0.040236055850982666, -0.0021803192794322968, -0.029927615076303482, -0.041928403079509735, -0.04552586004137993, 0.010684591718018055, 0.00767095759510994, 0.0464198999106884, -0.016100887209177017, 0.017658879980444908, -0.026209790259599686, -0.011881520040333271, -0.009794769808650017, -0.04419177770614624, -0.029050862416625023, -0.03390605375170708, -0.02250245399773121, -0.006426616571843624, 0.0074523133225739, 0.06919021904468536, 0.032716765999794006, 0.03169255331158638, -0.020766684785485268, -0.01304212398827076, 0.03737197816371918, -0.032686904072761536, 0.01161531824618578, 0.0014980857959017158, -0.004031533375382423, -0.05138354375958443, 0.03124670311808586, 0.021429413929581642, -0.043229833245277405, -0.009926370345056057, -0.005266041494905949, 0.007439758628606796, -0.047298863530159, -0.004898292012512684, 0.01223746221512556, -0.034558095037937164, -0.031552210450172424, -0.0038981218822300434, 0.05100230500102043, 0.05691533908247948, 0.015741711482405663, -0.018928760662674904, -0.023579739034175873, 0.019359540194272995, 0.035798389464616776, 0.002982733305543661, -0.03950216621160507, -0.025062205269932747, -0.07113528996706009, 0.06701109558343887, 0.008240858092904091, -0.04692541062831879, 0.06638848036527634, 0.03583085909485817, -0.002889457391574979, 0.02326083369553089, -0.03921034187078476, 0.010668250732123852, -0.006348791532218456, 0.05426953732967377, -0.08522465080022812, 0.007641211152076721, -0.009651032276451588, -0.006698105484247208, -0.02605573832988739, -0.05200151726603508, 0.003785606473684311, -0.023142652586102486, 0.009277446195483208, 0.03167470917105675, -0.014180426485836506, -0.0369858518242836, -0.014280679635703564 ]
<p>I was reading today about the birth of the Universe and the conjectures about the matter that was supposed to exist at the moment of the Big Bang and what can be measured now.</p> <p>There seems to be some sort of discrepancy between the calculated amount of matter in the Big Bang and the amount that can be measured in the visible Universe.</p> <p>Why is that so?</p> <p>And further more, why can't be this "missing matter" have been devoured by black holes through out the Universe?</p>
g4192
[ 0.06899333745241165, -0.00710879685357213, -0.010998844169080257, -0.025961941108107567, 0.008979921229183674, 0.0961514264345169, 0.0012093225959688425, 0.008036126382648945, -0.02075369842350483, -0.03291379287838936, 0.01715204119682312, -0.0397862046957016, 0.0579153411090374, 0.08383786678314209, 0.008842642419040203, 0.004707693587988615, 0.027446966618299484, -0.04804570972919464, -0.001632091123610735, 0.013001184910535812, 0.024148261174559593, -0.027006741613149643, 0.006183677352964878, -0.05985328182578087, -0.06578787416219711, -0.03221653401851654, 0.0036599691957235336, -0.009086944162845612, -0.0230438020080328, 0.012093384750187397, 0.04810618609189987, 0.02115717902779579, -0.007378417067229748, -0.020464729517698288, 0.048442237079143524, -0.03819463029503822, 0.012413554824888706, -0.030047284439206123, 0.0607997290790081, -0.05615047737956047, -0.002724657068029046, -0.017077766358852386, -0.0027581050526350737, -0.0019062707433477044, -0.04444532468914986, 0.029210975393652916, -0.0284242145717144, 0.07663487643003464, 0.015756530687212944, -0.09483072906732559, 0.015508932061493397, -0.036803923547267914, 0.044467341154813766, 0.05612989515066147, 0.045891568064689636, 0.03797449171543121, 0.02615625411272049, -0.019376035779714584, 0.027996022254228592, -0.0037239007651805878, 0.019056521356105804, 0.0019049678230658174, -0.0028336725663393736, 0.01245464663952589, 0.0297844335436821, 0.027460584416985512, -0.046349555253982544, 0.013295276090502739, -0.06655990332365036, 0.03283923491835594, 0.009784920141100883, -0.025174904614686966, 0.01401104498654604, -0.013166755437850952, -0.06323680281639099, 0.023662855848670006, -0.03423887491226196, 0.06336355209350586, -0.023317595943808556, -0.017340587452054024, 0.0037686172872781754, 0.04910370707511902, -0.027483215555548668, 0.004461626522243023, 0.07862336188554764, 0.005250800866633654, -0.015249625779688358, -0.021926643326878548, 0.008471839129924774, 0.0061111911199986935, 0.023312989622354507, -0.020767031237483025, 0.04691636934876442, -0.016336873173713684, 0.02547917515039444, 0.008604020811617374, -0.04797205701470375, 0.06785301864147186, -0.007880370132625103, 0.05646555870771408, -0.055106233805418015, 0.030834846198558807, 0.03139480575919151, -0.041439417749643326, 0.064099982380867, -0.04786624014377594, 0.04144774749875069, 0.004113975912332535, -0.045445747673511505, -0.008142034523189068, 0.013082063756883144, -0.09181831032037735, -0.027982382103800774, 0.0036706102546304464, -0.016016000881791115, -0.04711737111210823, 0.0981360524892807, 0.04138398915529251, 0.007110763806849718, 0.03344134986400604, -0.0443941093981266, -0.0006109303212724626, 0.02443511039018631, 0.016212206333875656, -0.027113057672977448, -0.04005039110779762, 0.010184341110289097, -0.005348830949515104, -0.018873581662774086, -0.014680584892630577, 0.020698659121990204, -0.025882834568619728, -0.028831008821725845, 0.049505092203617096, 0.03385600820183754, -0.04298119619488716, 0.059644296765327454, 0.0269422996789217, -0.03187074884772301, 0.05907948687672615, 0.026392914354801178, 0.007740234490483999, 0.0010178845841437578, 0.025717411190271378, 0.0009639039053581655, 0.0010761652374640107, -0.016810957342386246, -0.011830714531242847, -0.009444983676075935, -0.08575776219367981, 0.035035908222198486, 0.07941273599863052, 0.01004030928015709, -0.012638330459594727, -0.05612040311098099, -0.026686547324061394, 0.03978355973958969, 0.0015848230104893446, -0.013366973027586937, 0.00497726583853364, 0.036396849900484085, -0.02634669654071331, -0.005772881675511599, 0.015268450602889061, -0.016840508207678795, 0.06458526849746704, -0.0424734465777874, -0.05173344537615776, 0.02067224308848381, -0.02721034362912178, -0.05261223390698433, 0.01496475376188755, 0.0035405673552304506, 0.016562270000576973, 0.008796419017016888, 0.0828884094953537, 0.05878916382789612, -0.007075965404510498, -0.04372723400592804, 0.034964874386787415, -0.031067822128534317, -0.040273431688547134, -0.008287601172924042, 0.0014611626975238323, 0.013818944804370403, -0.047381993383169174, 0.02279507741332054, -0.03465085104107857, 0.01317514106631279, -0.0009108585072681308, 0.0003110558318439871, -0.024479104205965996, 0.024637171998620033, 0.053467992693185806, 0.03255313262343407, -0.0013304571621119976, 0.06178250536322594, -0.00019792866078205407, -0.005948463920503855, 0.02391229197382927, -0.011524919420480728, 0.016482582315802574, 0.00016719038831070065, -0.038942158222198486, 0.0401044562458992, 0.003257287200540304, -0.04573492705821991, 0.0323229543864727, 0.020648380741477013, -0.04040848836302757, -0.01043977402150631, -0.027506345883011818, -0.02808966115117073, -0.017565079033374786, -0.009613574482500553, 0.04461700841784477, -0.026647742837667465, 0.058327075093984604, 0.005999341607093811, 0.017816392704844475, -0.043992411345243454, -0.022129813209176064, 0.024899089708924294, -0.05600892752408981, 0.02871302329003811, 0.027361586689949036, -0.03372303396463394, -0.013067536987364292, -0.012194636277854443, 0.035164035856723785, -0.030482793226838112, -0.020340560004115105, -0.0009623189689591527, 0.047034308314323425, 0.029455488547682762, 0.05776068940758705, 0.021768927574157715, -0.05820288881659508, 0.01549721322953701, 0.03412524610757828, 0.02584240585565567, -0.006180285010486841, -0.04809623211622238, 0.015586938709020615, 0.06794603914022446, -0.004229596816003323, 0.04055983945727348, -0.04556815326213837, -0.018628381192684174, 0.000637476216070354, -0.013543478213250637, -0.040170297026634216, 0.021574312821030617, -0.027395712211728096, 0.007213571574538946, 0.023773539811372757, 0.05760801583528519, 0.017167940735816956, -0.07395680248737335, -0.017762862145900726, -0.015890032052993774, -0.03550075739622116, 0.049870818853378296, 0.05126287043094635, -0.04216891527175903, -0.025130577385425568, -0.08452173322439194, -0.026018820703029633, -0.02408439852297306, -0.07900040596723557, 0.01246095821261406, -0.032854728400707245, 0.03505633771419525, -0.006010785233229399, 0.02156279981136322, 0.03112742491066456, -0.0376879945397377, -0.016464054584503174, 0.09915099292993546, 0.009106779471039772, -0.0769248902797699, 0.05154627561569214, -0.05656755343079567, -0.019184205681085587, 0.014883846044540405, 0.0014672373654320836, -0.053083136677742004, -0.06407446414232254, 0.0018398234387859702, 0.0009897247655317187, 0.04020562767982483, 0.009498952887952328, 0.017558597028255463, 0.05419781431555748, 0.011652270331978798, 0.05204315856099129, -0.0024814584758132696, 0.025143247097730637, -0.0805433988571167, -0.05320437252521515, 0.011884327977895737, 0.02893015369772911, -0.008483519777655602, 0.04382000118494034, 0.0023538602981716394, 0.018339853733778, 0.02984190359711647, 0.00733391335234046, 0.009891832247376442, -0.05946682393550873, 0.05412954464554787, 0.04647079482674599, 0.018555134534835815, 0.004021650180220604, -0.007225826848298311, 0.0028272338677197695, 0.016035184264183044, 0.03182164207100868, 0.021847039461135864, 0.04095180705189705, 0.01903880573809147, 0.026558222249150276, 0.019488859921693802, -0.02477351576089859, 0.016116123646497726, -0.005100954324007034, -0.06388483196496964, -0.03052893467247486, 0.014686224050819874, -0.009446983225643635, -0.038535069674253464, -0.031968582421541214, -0.060454826802015305, 0.01630137301981449, -0.04467230290174484, -0.02113562636077404, -0.040214162319898605, -0.010781683027744293, 0.06307505816221237, -0.02162237837910652, 0.001296381582506001, 0.04970394819974899, 0.0020560005214065313, 0.008520648814737797, -0.018240299075841904, -0.011017980985343456, -0.017555469647049904, -0.01183215994387865, -0.02089923620223999, -0.022609399631619453, 0.05279399827122688, 0.010395577177405357, -0.010343444533646107, -0.012863549403846264, -0.027287334203720093, 0.03635318577289581, -0.0038835706654936075, -0.0014268594095483422, 0.04515482857823372, -0.03576149791479111, 0.024232082068920135, -0.009485108777880669, 0.04541075974702835, -0.039228495210409164, -0.007590279448777437, -0.04671754688024521, 0.026968615129590034, 0.022405805066227913, 0.0031403943430632353, 0.026030657812952995, -0.014166529290378094, 0.006023857276886702, -0.02200312167406082, 0.007425383664667606, 0.04348504915833473, -0.07365148514509201, 0.06502624601125717, 0.05470976233482361, 0.01175281498581171, 0.0029844902455806732, 0.040464822202920914, 0.050178635865449905, 0.004150378983467817, -0.0118618318811059, -0.02149740792810917, -0.024672288447618484, -0.03393061086535454, -0.0379006564617157, -0.026766130700707436, -0.06892511248588562, 0.018059544265270233, -0.030319198966026306, -0.0119757279753685, 0.004052345175296068, 0.015469116158783436, -0.010880877263844013, -0.004905632231384516, 0.024543629959225655, 0.09982677549123764, 0.0183827206492424, 0.028129728510975838, 0.03754391521215439, 0.022443218156695366, -0.023105837404727936, 0.03568372130393982, 0.009976817294955254, 0.04281175509095192, -0.02563159167766571, 0.027140559628605843, -0.026168255135416985, -0.012035184539854527, 0.05353396013379097, -0.058044303208589554, 0.01818106882274151, -0.008141973987221718, -0.02038521133363247, 0.018544310703873634, -0.03405826911330223, 0.060859303921461105, 0.038574036210775375, 0.0046265581622719765, -0.00827648676931858, -0.05362078920006752, 0.006745878607034683, 0.017948683351278305, 0.04179516062140465, -0.025655528530478477, 0.00130491575691849, 0.009870626032352448, 0.00028333664522506297, 0.0310893002897501, 0.01766098476946354, 0.005328305996954441, 0.11919738352298737, -0.03394442796707153, 0.05628369376063347, -0.00955026876181364, 0.08413691073656082, -0.03633223846554756, 0.016705909743905067, 0.07637576758861542, -0.055796366184949875, -0.018812401220202446, -0.041805773973464966, 0.04520479217171669, 0.02668948844075203, -0.038832586258649826, 0.03153298422694206, -0.015337420627474785, -0.026468316093087196, -0.026894234120845795, -0.033892713487148285, -0.019820217043161392, -0.01705341413617134, -0.03945933282375336, -0.023296231403946877, -0.012439467012882233, 0.02779053896665573, -0.018083414062857628, 0.05491747334599495, -0.05631743371486664, -0.010399281978607178, 0.03263166546821594, 0.04064491391181946, -0.007692540995776653, -0.061316318809986115, -0.012608782388269901, -0.030972149223089218, -0.0003224459651391953, 0.025056468322873116, -0.06398957967758179, 0.013306600041687489, 0.013536415062844753, 0.06507652997970581, -0.02667163498699665, 0.01731300540268421, -0.04079953953623772, -0.02683774195611477, -0.02312561497092247, 0.00031690686591900885, -0.02682030014693737, -0.021326866000890732, 0.055754102766513824, 0.0028949107509106398, 0.00487741781398654, 0.07174455374479294, -0.03460870683193207, -0.010528312996029854, -0.03212917596101761, -0.021773409098386765, 0.044188059866428375, -0.015413288027048111, 0.037353407591581345, -0.02003406547009945, 0.0119357043877244, 0.026541365310549736, 0.03112477995455265, -0.03254598751664162, 0.01589011214673519, 0.007485231384634972, 0.015447837300598621, 0.0443577766418457, 0.024349667131900787, -0.03705857694149017, -0.012822465971112251, 0.044118594378232956, -0.05342356860637665, 0.01676587015390396, 0.013591055758297443, -0.010160602629184723, 0.02767815627157688, 0.02716963179409504, 0.003308186773210764, 0.021409356966614723, -0.0030839035753160715, -0.04195987060666084, 0.03227167949080467, -0.05675356462597847, -0.004856633488088846, -0.010978585109114647, -0.059741415083408356, 0.021658748388290405, 0.0588923878967762, 0.06924977898597717, 0.016661284491419792, -0.027220072224736214, -0.012643189169466496, -0.009801524691283703, 0.03838667273521423, -0.058662038296461105, 0.02263040654361248, 0.02241727150976658, 0.010717629455029964, 0.00927615724503994, 0.027929531410336494, 0.056103892624378204, 0.0014407896669581532, -0.006578101310878992, 0.012322796508669853, -0.0322994738817215, -0.01472654938697815, -0.0009952677646651864, 0.034238558262586594, 0.04623321443796158, 0.06483274698257446, 0.01489167008548975, -0.030065543949604034, -0.0029438266064971685, 0.048783887177705765, -0.06941242516040802, -0.036430273205041885, 0.039398159831762314, -0.009344217367470264, 0.03468254953622818, -0.09064877033233643, 0.07922700047492981, 0.005485543981194496, 0.0014525296865031123, -0.07558265328407288, -0.057607538998126984, 0.007356144487857819, 0.01312482450157404, -0.010577363893389702, -0.011305682361125946, -0.028179582208395004, -0.0030852695927023888, 0.022468015551567078, 0.0029035776387900114, -0.02055034600198269, -0.018459392711520195, -0.061053745448589325, 0.005570200737565756, -0.007948259823024273, 0.0016144089167937636, -0.02564334124326706, 0.04439062625169754, -0.048141058534383774, -0.025223245844244957, 0.024674203246831894, -0.021139634773135185, 0.0690973624587059, 0.0015910185175016522, 0.022549614310264587, -0.04322080686688423, 0.02085302583873272, 0.009924993850290775, -0.03305267170071602, 0.022697707638144493, 0.04585695639252663, 0.005921407602727413, -0.027031347155570984, 0.016362519934773445, 0.020370470359921455, -0.08386591821908951, -0.05690041929483414, -0.012095591984689236, -0.014033038169145584, -0.10689055919647217, -0.05338086560368538, -0.03721864894032478, -0.011282776482403278, -0.0680539458990097, 0.01989603042602539, -0.0038825608789920807, 0.05270469933748245, -0.028902152553200722, -0.034157104790210724, -0.04882294684648514, 0.04698386415839195, 0.05744330212473869, 0.01746336929500103, -0.00979649554938078, -0.060599107295274734, 0.038133297115564346, -0.04121619090437889, -0.03092680685222149, -0.022232279181480408, -0.07432898133993149, -0.026818333193659782, -0.02247275784611702, 0.02392406389117241, 0.07258368283510208, 0.0025383553002029657, -0.009298235177993774, 0.029800549149513245, 0.03316160663962364, -0.047155678272247314, 0.03233232721686363, 0.04876001179218292, 0.01843913272023201, -0.004004159942269325, 0.013877813704311848, 0.027375351637601852, 0.028160374611616135, 0.048417478799819946, 0.016050929203629494, 0.006806424353271723, -0.001835193601436913, -0.007312956731766462, -0.05268598347902298, -0.004375887103378773, -0.039197180420160294, 0.04998643696308136, 0.012082003057003021, 0.000040446459024678916, 0.008906124159693718, 0.016089625656604767, 0.021762272343039513, -0.044965434819459915, -0.02374383434653282, -0.04416412115097046, -0.021211912855505943, -0.0017316543962806463, -0.02045237459242344, -0.038162294775247574, -0.02612743340432644, -0.018413595855236053, -0.03036399558186531, 0.0024651417043060064, -0.09743577986955643, -0.02722902223467827, 0.0053427619859576225, -0.01428055576980114, -0.015694931149482727, 0.02028903365135193, -0.028661860153079033, 0.04481593519449234, -0.022592050954699516, 0.010377081111073494, -0.02031059004366398, -0.00010788578219944611, -0.018417838960886, -0.0930434837937355, -0.002906327834352851, -0.016282474622130394, -0.06858206540346146, -0.0026916884817183018, 0.01443586964160204, 0.05955171957612038, -0.003729843068867922, 0.02723310887813568, 0.02919619530439377, -0.01300443708896637, 0.09189564734697342, -0.04222466051578522, 0.015682775527238846, -0.02221525087952614, 0.01782125234603882, -0.023633869364857674, -0.01277216151356697, 0.021251743659377098, -0.04689307510852814, 0.020706983283162117, 0.002797867404296994, 0.0227100420743227, -0.03852660953998566, 0.08934977650642395, 0.006257312372326851, 0.03738359361886978, -0.055693525820970535, 0.03682037070393562, -0.046791475266218185, -0.0301621425896883, -0.05655664950609207, -0.003002711571753025, 0.02344483695924282, 0.016886796802282333, 0.028271088376641273, -0.04045872762799263, -0.044711459428071976, 0.002701681572943926, 0.05963863059878349, -0.010430047288537025, 0.02169165387749672, -0.002628764370456338, -0.03133905306458473, -0.0638015866279602, -0.04571077227592468, -0.023538153618574142, -0.0553177185356617, 0.03615015372633934, -0.007651239633560181, 0.012063033878803253, -0.06805980950593948, -0.049026042222976685, 0.003212175564840436, 0.03752729669213295, 0.01941167563199997, -0.05402374267578125, 0.01577182486653328, 0.0026127686724066734, 0.02389504760503769, 0.0316377691924572, -0.008973847143352032, -0.052193570882081985, 0.04449576884508133, 0.06263452768325806, 0.008702416904270649, -0.004712468944489956, -0.017115501686930656, -0.04226946830749512, 0.015669288113713264, 0.015415553003549576, -0.02298656851053238, 0.005972906947135925, -0.07912108302116394, -0.042878858745098114, 0.04023008048534393, 0.05694243311882019, -0.01564597524702549, -0.007587792351841927, -0.02887124754488468, 0.01901509240269661, 0.022401681169867516, 0.03141843155026436, -0.03753620386123657, 0.07220443338155746, -0.02384144626557827, -0.08706744015216827, -0.01012386940419674, 0.035367678850889206, 0.02501114085316658, -0.01459833886474371, 0.02610296942293644, -0.001459507504478097, 0.017879894003272057, 0.03809765726327896, 0.011928512714803219 ]
<p>Cepheids are used to evaluate distances. What is the math and physics behind their use?</p>
g4193
[ 0.013808151707053185, 0.030980940908193588, -0.02498285286128521, -0.04868326708674431, 0.00031458635930903256, -0.0332803912460804, 0.017364535480737686, 0.002528734505176544, -0.030297109857201576, -0.057752739638090134, 0.020556611940264702, -0.020257633179426193, 0.0715952217578888, 0.008634173311293125, 0.005048725754022598, -0.004413242917507887, 0.005711544305086136, -0.017774395644664764, 0.06763108819723129, 0.05457780137658119, -0.011409624479711056, -0.0030650151893496513, -0.03507053852081299, -0.03165951371192932, -0.025815429165959358, 0.02432514913380146, -0.03231101855635643, -0.008316772058606148, -0.07119759172201157, 0.009890628978610039, -0.027669642120599747, 0.01736573316156864, 0.059843648225069046, -0.024635223671793938, 0.0040141139179468155, 0.010932672768831253, 0.01906176470220089, -0.010360851883888245, 0.017814192920923233, -0.002220321446657181, -0.012758676894009113, 0.000619075377471745, 0.03551221266388893, 0.009094450622797012, 0.07798902690410614, -0.0005651810206472874, -0.043801117688417435, 0.010310888290405273, 0.02588306926190853, -0.03116787225008011, 0.004018047824501991, -0.011239173822104931, 0.0516040064394474, 0.048341888934373856, 0.03289066627621651, -0.0033964954782277346, -0.0030338121578097343, -0.02562919445335865, 0.053550541400909424, 0.008992467075586319, -0.0442487858235836, -0.0004684667510446161, -0.0376351997256279, -0.08060619980096817, 0.08796369284391403, 0.004947504494339228, -0.027551310136914253, -0.03296102210879326, 0.017915993928909302, -0.02543032541871071, 0.07142122834920883, -0.033888500183820724, -0.02899988554418087, 0.022521626204252243, -0.0439770445227623, 0.015405845828354359, 0.01076289638876915, 0.012258405797183514, 0.02572913095355034, 0.07435191422700882, -0.07418012619018555, -0.012742663733661175, 0.0029661294538527727, -0.0030449952464550734, 0.042608316987752914, -0.01645318791270256, -0.01106269471347332, 0.036607302725315094, 0.019810251891613007, 0.01867755874991417, -0.070807546377182, -0.047152984887361526, 0.008478660136461258, 0.003009884152561426, 0.00014236838615033776, -0.02112641930580139, -0.021536119282245636, 0.009660692885518074, 0.027840111404657364, 0.02751837857067585, -0.029569318518042564, 0.04797585308551788, 0.04801665619015694, 0.006956564262509346, 0.018799204379320145, 0.0006031786906532943, 0.018333084881305695, 0.010476730763912201, 0.0393243283033371, -0.0018840801203623414, -0.042367491871118546, -0.0019602621905505657, -0.05065782740712166, -0.007267288863658905, 0.044651295989751816, 0.03881533071398735, -0.01239427737891674, -0.01017816923558712, -0.05398666858673096, 0.015744561329483986, 0.03847847878932953, 0.015049520879983902, 0.005302752368152142, 0.012966246344149113, 0.00230299006216228, 0.05273265764117241, -0.0055427271872758865, -0.023754803463816643, 0.07119938731193542, -0.04665807634592056, 0.012076176702976227, 0.029620075598359108, -0.030675772577524185, -0.0139463497325778, -0.005085156299173832, 0.03909311071038246, 0.010179953649640083, -0.05300002545118332, -0.008133218623697758, 0.023255454376339912, -0.04931651055812836, -0.07171622663736343, -0.0016524693928658962, -0.03872983157634735, -0.0017948909662663937, -0.06430843472480774, -0.02785485051572323, 0.011822888627648354, 0.0466187410056591, 0.06854011863470078, 0.028851628303527832, 0.05035604164004326, 0.005215436220169067, 0.024729356169700623, 0.012110041454434395, -0.001690760487690568, 0.03695942461490631, 0.0485558807849884, -0.05498550832271576, -0.02437855303287506, 0.016655411571264267, -0.05378888547420502, -0.014162243343889713, 0.006608712021261454, -0.040975283831357956, -0.02030259184539318, 0.03184182941913605, -0.06976180523633957, 0.011668678373098373, -0.004545860458165407, -0.0640934482216835, 0.012783206067979336, 0.04655790328979492, 0.012605278752744198, -0.050362374633550644, 0.01791260950267315, 0.02275608293712139, -0.034076303243637085, -0.006731424015015364, 0.06797359883785248, -0.012012021616101265, 0.01664402149617672, 0.038265660405159, -0.04151247814297676, -0.026574082672595978, 0.009296619333326817, 0.11572813987731934, -0.04034840688109398, 0.004094748757779598, -0.026239000260829926, 0.047356344759464264, -0.02032586932182312, -0.037249211221933365, 0.037691615521907806, -0.0005078541580587626, -0.0243841502815485, -0.01855500414967537, -0.007267246954143047, -0.058403510600328445, 0.04759030044078827, 0.03228120878338814, 0.027953041717410088, -0.02095668576657772, 0.07372963428497314, 0.01389405783265829, 0.016690844669938087, -0.02068227529525757, -0.044690847396850586, 0.015050942078232765, -0.012092575430870056, -0.02362200804054737, 0.02746487222611904, 0.03741326928138733, 0.031118124723434448, -0.010832879692316055, -0.055931638926267624, -0.004083290696144104, -0.060197558254003525, 0.02446730062365532, 0.000449497951194644, 0.015047362074255943, -0.06297390908002853, 0.04828834906220436, -0.01642051339149475, -0.013558057136833668, 0.07187637686729431, -0.10757603496313095, 0.016799798235297203, 0.02813090942800045, 0.001171334646642208, -0.04129943996667862, -0.06823619455099106, 0.00014577324327547103, 0.047608423978090286, 0.02600768767297268, 0.06281155347824097, 0.01185731589794159, -0.03371378034353256, 0.043073367327451706, 0.06266528367996216, 0.09284709393978119, -0.06195615977048874, -0.010280772112309933, 0.01917731761932373, -0.05358139052987099, -0.06155199557542801, 0.0031960110645741224, -0.018350182101130486, -0.011042331345379353, -0.038542989641427994, -0.0041062794625759125, -0.00913319457322359, -0.05521465465426445, 0.066102996468544, 0.012233248911798, -0.012673702090978622, -0.03321516513824463, -0.019378671422600746, -0.005136789288371801, 0.03494885563850403, -0.026211721822619438, -0.009085581637918949, -0.030436906963586807, 0.004752692300826311, 0.04823416471481323, -0.02655601315200329, -0.05899033695459366, 0.04373476654291153, -0.00682763010263443, 0.00817305501550436, 0.06401536613702774, -0.0014002833049744368, 0.06110624969005585, -0.02087932825088501, -0.010241298004984856, 0.02292829193174839, 0.0024988336954265833, 0.033500105142593384, 0.05080624669790268, 0.011326688341796398, 0.002981774043291807, -0.008029907010495663, -0.022553661838173866, 0.026814043521881104, -0.04145931079983711, -0.00798980612307787, 0.0578794963657856, 0.01959262602031231, 0.04213792458176613, 0.01727573201060295, 0.02870248816907406, 0.012911497615277767, 0.07193394750356674, -0.02212350443005562, -0.02892555482685566, 0.05720610171556473, 0.0384199433028698, 0.013380015268921852, 0.04036435857415199, -0.06106961518526077, -0.03560997545719147, 0.05188295617699623, 0.02478145621716976, -0.028641371056437492, 0.016254743561148643, 0.02378554455935955, 0.02834472432732582, -0.02006606012582779, -0.019806720316410065, 0.0008813769672997296, 0.04064076766371727, 0.03842316195368767, -0.002719711512327194, 0.026721127331256866, -0.04293157532811165, -0.035568974912166595, 0.03262876346707344, -0.011261645704507828, 0.02114558033645153, -0.033990900963544846, 0.03637224808335304, -0.03242414444684982, 0.0027440087869763374, 0.016647933050990105, 0.04596187174320221, 0.018270453438162804, -0.005186334252357483, -0.03235896676778793, 0.012781202793121338, -0.05224134027957916, -0.024734333157539368, 0.005915929097682238, 0.02139958366751671, -0.02320103906095028, -0.022515440359711647, -0.05512171983718872, 0.03234025463461876, 0.029945742338895798, 0.08203199505805969, 0.008009118027985096, 0.017174696549773216, 0.02103467844426632, -0.06399928033351898, 0.006110178306698799, 0.007926116697490215, 0.011692504398524761, 0.04447136074304581, -0.007633585017174482, 0.0020686574280261993, -0.059039585292339325, 0.03795965388417244, 0.04467998445034027, -0.016942892223596573, -0.06138700991868973, 0.06336796283721924, 0.05941100791096687, 0.012550855055451393, -0.031354617327451706, -0.007942215539515018, -0.02546793781220913, 0.02849513851106167, 0.09686066210269928, -0.017494451254606247, 0.05086906626820564, -0.0030581208411604166, -0.017869168892502785, 0.04023083671927452, 0.05222047492861748, 0.0058155064471066, -0.041989706456661224, -0.006937697995454073, -0.010080574080348015, 0.019151732325553894, 0.008828296326100826, 0.012463266961276531, 0.0537056066095829, 0.01294675562530756, -0.05843495950102806, 0.00886076781898737, 0.018119607120752335, -0.017838863655924797, 0.01573425903916359, 0.053830087184906006, -0.03867824748158455, 0.00006336421211017296, -0.03865765035152435, -0.04662298038601875, -0.010505849495530128, 0.0074516599997878075, -0.04189454764127731, -0.017911523580551147, -0.04157143086194992, -0.07084184885025024, -0.05020396411418915, 0.028470555320382118, -0.02671595849096775, 0.030152764171361923, -0.04147234186530113, 0.020097307860851288, 0.039692189544439316, -0.009968998841941357, -0.01853262260556221, 0.0004477875481825322, 0.011588850058615208, -0.06669797748327255, -0.03296377509832382, 0.01588801108300686, -0.027003228664398193, -0.01928570866584778, 0.0056111556477844715, 0.010625733993947506, 0.05689750239253044, 0.019021017476916313, -0.0678119882941246, -0.009108475409448147, 0.010624752379953861, 0.05800330638885498, -0.0048721423372626305, -0.004445706959813833, 0.010350902564823627, 0.001306267105974257, -0.023910818621516228, -0.0034372308291494846, 0.020026646554470062, 0.006768533028662205, 0.0597112700343132, -0.03130058944225311, 0.0142403868958354, -0.024449162185192108, -0.022450445219874382, -0.02857683040201664, 0.046945568174123764, 0.032446276396512985, -0.03695639222860336, 0.015587996691465378, 0.02342773787677288, 0.022207148373126984, 0.04854452610015869, -0.0031383673194795847, 0.07228949666023254, 0.02502894215285778, -0.00005760448766523041, 0.010655296966433525, -0.06897251307964325, -0.015571055002510548, 0.002066865097731352, -0.029144015163183212, -0.004075158853083849, -0.05748957395553589, 0.0733243003487587, 0.005445197690278292, -0.011459105648100376, -0.031421955674886703, -0.010248982347548008, 0.02528119459748268, -0.0400056429207325, -0.012709307484328747, -0.010429631918668747, 0.03418101370334625, -0.0030057907570153475, -0.006782810669392347, 0.005556722637265921, 0.04838860407471657, -0.03851572424173355, 0.022395402193069458, 0.01397356204688549, -0.003960299305617809, -0.032162901014089584, -0.010946155525743961, 0.03497500717639923, -0.05294688418507576, -0.014490490779280663, 0.01176012959331274, -0.041544340550899506, 0.023141585290431976, 0.0059179081581532955, -0.04487548768520355, 0.04458914324641228, 0.026068534702062607, -0.06256107985973358, -0.015706628561019897, -0.01144690066576004, -0.03738062456250191, -0.051913365721702576, -0.01995067112147808, 0.027963247150182724, 0.005093756597489119, -0.020151376724243164, 0.001250556786544621, -0.019127918407320976, -0.0004218057729303837, 0.013476655818521976, 0.04543425142765045, 0.01146589033305645, -0.056219566613435745, -0.07976053655147552, 0.03474431484937668, 0.03520607575774193, 0.0013688262552022934, 0.027853604406118393, -0.016153918579220772, 0.03532255440950394, -0.07766169309616089, -0.03158130496740341, 0.006690673064440489, 0.046592988073825836, 0.04844941198825836, -0.03704047203063965, 0.08255238831043243, -0.0014418339123949409, 0.049228109419345856, 0.041607532650232315, 0.06207941845059395, 0.012682934291660786, 0.08109278231859207, -0.045502226799726486, -0.01970404013991356, 0.03550111874938011, 0.01076239813119173, 0.050090253353118896, 0.04392385482788086, -0.06517551094293594, 0.05261814966797829, -0.04191247373819351, 0.05466388165950775, -0.03712242841720581, -0.04379090666770935, 0.02831408940255642, -0.0025672095362097025, 0.03487949073314667, 0.004228578880429268, -0.039158597588539124, -0.06841368973255157, -0.014468162320554256, -0.08720798045396805, -0.06982094049453735, 0.001685342169366777, -0.0036939752753823996, 0.019003011286258698, -0.03183169662952423, -0.03736240044236183, 0.02872609905898571, -0.06911472976207733, 0.10070762038230896, -0.0018103335751220584, -0.008175419643521309, 0.0691278800368309, 0.01023562066257, 0.05733906850218773, -0.05328972265124321, -0.0057180533185601234, 0.03012613020837307, 0.05112694576382637, 0.01097478624433279, -0.022147973999381065, -0.004300230648368597, 0.00863993726670742, -0.0212103221565485, -0.003967683762311935, -0.01347039919346571, 0.015573175624012947, 0.004996536765247583, 0.01706632785499096, 0.052901491522789, 0.03826286271214485, -0.04947948455810547, -0.0148163428530097, 0.08474189788103104, 0.0203684251755476, -0.007411153055727482, -0.009775876067578793, -0.07792744040489197, 0.010605283081531525, 0.037728410214185715, 0.003214774653315544, -0.0259917750954628, -0.0068796356208622456, -0.016035785898566246, -0.026292629539966583, -0.021165555343031883, 0.04092331975698471, -0.014989306218922138, 0.021927393972873688, 0.013116260059177876, -0.008178874850273132, 0.018825992941856384, -0.004912042059004307, 0.0047188918106257915, 0.02909349836409092, -0.06631863862276077, 0.050995390862226486, -0.009329433552920818, 0.010620448738336563, -0.024996565654873848, -0.00848711933940649, -0.024947790428996086, -0.04023740813136101, 0.04207950457930565, -0.024782147258520126, -0.004052116069942713, -0.008333385922014713, -0.008795775473117828, -0.01039514783769846, -0.002849611919373274, -0.0008046548464335501, 0.013423293828964233, -0.011156678199768066, -0.005925496108829975, 0.013199527747929096, -0.005383387207984924, 0.02548154816031456, 0.021413180977106094, -0.026744181290268898, -0.0013119326904416084, -0.07416032999753952, -0.040288835763931274, 0.04085139185190201, -0.08568510413169861, -0.032158657908439636, -0.09040124714374542, -0.035742271691560745, -0.004301249049603939, -0.036148201674222946, -0.022523049265146255, 0.06681559234857559, 0.055051662027835846, 0.017429430037736893, -0.036766838282346725, 0.0355258472263813, 0.016835274174809456, -0.02712775208055973, 0.04577268287539482, 0.045702941715717316, 0.05008788779377937, -0.0620398074388504, 0.04742605611681938, -0.02063904143869877, 0.07327300310134888, 0.06103190407156944, 0.05541614443063736, 0.023303695023059845, 0.03684135898947716, -0.012849114835262299, -0.026402568444609642, -0.042484454810619354, -0.022303208708763123, 0.01496849488466978, 0.046243105083703995, -0.055437121540308, 0.0238867849111557, -0.04800478368997574, -0.03865041211247444, -0.01318991370499134, 0.04049296677112579, 0.0019750099163502455, 0.03931377828121185, -0.013428821228444576, 0.01895550824701786, -0.04216025397181511, -0.01080760546028614, -0.042852602899074554, -0.042579226195812225, -0.05182528495788574, 0.03445788845419884, -0.03924316540360451, 0.022052202373743057, -0.055026039481163025, -0.0380840040743351, 0.01371664460748434, 0.02803993597626686, -0.027694979682564735, 0.02864082343876362, -0.09920956939458847, 0.005376726854592562, -0.03494603559374809, 0.006791014689952135, -0.02053283154964447, -0.047399695962667465, -0.027559515088796616, -0.04049905762076378, 0.04195505380630493, 0.06100843846797943, 0.02150936797261238, -0.0715523436665535, -0.019470764324069023, -0.019904395565390587, -0.014999598264694214, 0.04194158315658569, 0.012851493433117867, -0.08705514669418335, 0.0016020411858335137, -0.023132361471652985, -0.005538600031286478, -0.035466328263282776, 0.005914731882512569, -0.052490126341581345, 0.012629589065909386, 0.025952374562621117, -0.014203465543687344, -0.034538958221673965, -0.02120913192629814, 0.01673787087202072, -0.010604937560856342, 0.05506860092282295, 0.022855300456285477, -0.035999055951833725, 0.006424839608371258, 0.060447171330451965, -0.008382709696888924, -0.03742620348930359, -0.021405575796961784, -0.021053185686469078, 0.007212727330625057, 0.03725822642445564, 0.015543962828814983, 0.03160202503204346, -0.00046101980842649937, 0.02293606661260128, 0.01843445748090744, -0.027292076498270035, 0.025536902248859406, -0.0064390129409730434, 0.08853337913751602, 0.004047941416501999, -0.033114850521087646, -0.023375658318400383, 0.012328706681728363, -0.06229472532868385, -0.033002741634845734, -0.0004890941199846566, -0.05147011578083038, -0.01624271087348461, -0.000952944450546056, 0.004841301590204239, -0.04260548949241638, -0.014913198538124561, 0.018884709104895592, -0.05824790522456169, -0.04753760248422623, 0.06031971797347069, 0.002480203751474619, 0.03358551859855652, -0.02437755838036537, -0.010445051826536655, -0.0002944651641882956, -0.02744365856051445, -0.029042784124612808, 0.06570018827915192, 0.017795655876398087, 0.0066271680407226086, -0.029053043574094772, 0.045812129974365234, 0.036710694432258606, 0.03674815222620964, -0.03689246252179146, 0.002847297815605998, 0.008117130026221275, 0.00201296410523355, -0.0141034796833992, -0.026502886787056923, 0.023453325033187866, -0.06323639303445816, 0.01849055290222168, 0.009022868238389492, -0.041514698415994644, -0.04066982492804527, -0.013456551358103752, 0.027687836438417435 ]
<p>I was wondering if it were possible to calculate the drag coefficient by allowing an object to reach terminal velocity. Can you rearrange the terminal velocity formula to give the drag coefficient?</p>
g4194
[ -0.018531031906604767, 0.029023075476288795, 0.01116801705211401, -0.03353577107191086, 0.037522755563259125, -0.0038514244370162487, 0.025072414427995682, 0.006954091135412455, -0.09210174530744553, 0.00005514165968634188, -0.023664657026529312, 0.0740692988038063, 0.08627742528915405, -0.029159778729081154, -0.0032931093592196703, -0.036434605717659, 0.006206229794770479, -0.0328553132712841, 0.007291578222066164, 0.08790712058544159, 0.00034351181238889694, -0.0575483962893486, 0.023526787757873535, -0.08408801257610321, 0.012816217727959156, -0.04195767268538475, -0.014227893203496933, 0.08875644207000732, -0.10722065716981888, 0.05372156947851181, 0.059810999780893326, 0.004477656912058592, -0.004109699744731188, -0.02699810266494751, -0.03823559358716011, -0.04531233757734299, 0.023710576817393303, 0.028036659583449364, 0.008584747090935707, 0.013035483658313751, 0.019035987555980682, -0.0330919548869133, -0.0006408612243831158, -0.0044023445807397366, -0.00017127372848335654, -0.014778245240449905, 0.039744723588228226, -0.024922944605350494, -0.024215929210186005, -0.037017956376075745, -0.02549988590180874, 0.03165511041879654, -0.061864424496889114, -0.04087182506918907, -0.06583882868289948, 0.05382411926984787, 0.012343487702310085, -0.05551574379205704, -0.006414123810827732, 0.03311562538146973, -0.018918100744485855, 0.0035706013441085815, 0.010464238934218884, -0.03504195064306259, 0.021440329030156136, -0.044697102159261703, -0.0015536047285422683, -0.051518503576517105, -0.07767372578382492, -0.04542134329676628, 0.029824163764715195, 0.026060346513986588, -0.02156093716621399, -0.04781613498926163, -0.05607989802956581, 0.0476486012339592, -0.006715578958392143, -0.01788969896733761, 0.0019857839215546846, 0.028783295303583145, -0.013690981082618237, -0.0007045599049888551, 0.007983773946762085, 0.061202093958854675, -0.007919412106275558, -0.0029958130326122046, 0.03842667117714882, 0.039540525525808334, -0.009522439911961555, -0.03942122310400009, -0.02824464440345764, 0.017941517755389214, 0.0061774044297635555, 0.048287756741046906, 0.010903985239565372, -0.051417022943496704, -0.01920459419488907, 0.05077917128801346, 0.006271383725106716, -0.018440239131450653, -0.018146226182579994, 0.03764853999018669, 0.023665830492973328, 0.04437551647424698, -0.011236710473895073, -0.02168896794319153, 0.05073590204119682, 0.002722653094679117, -0.004127799533307552, -0.04504853114485741, -0.014615993946790695, -0.0725090280175209, -0.02629256062209606, 0.02347078174352646, 0.018726667389273643, -0.053894177079200745, 0.0412578359246254, -0.0174374021589756, -0.0032033296301960945, 0.032259147614240646, -0.05215858295559883, 0.007117487955838442, 0.018528450280427933, 0.06013109162449837, 0.021894115954637527, 0.0347292535007, -0.03094751574099064, 0.0044199684634804726, 0.030294474214315414, 0.008454807102680206, 0.04053204879164696, -0.036385711282491684, 0.031216170638799667, 0.026573291048407555, -0.011561261489987373, 0.03493376076221466, -0.014855246059596539, 0.024843068793416023, -0.011801010929048061, 0.03534183278679848, 0.029702158644795418, -0.03805657476186752, 0.017454110085964203, -0.017468970268964767, -0.03359856456518173, 0.029663026332855225, -0.0013565932167693973, 0.038939837366342545, -0.006459177937358618, 0.006234814878553152, 0.04650615528225899, 0.0015645206440240145, 0.030398832634091377, 0.012534062378108501, -0.009828153066337109, -0.025945216417312622, 0.070057213306427, 0.026706527918577194, -0.008495527319610119, -0.02966715209186077, 0.021421832963824272, -0.017072057351469994, 0.016353722661733627, -0.0011555623495951295, -0.04311450570821762, 0.015836702659726143, -0.08110082894563675, -0.009105171076953411, -0.04484802857041359, -0.079658642411232, -0.05696222931146622, 0.039013784378767014, 0.030239805579185486, 0.006197371054440737, 0.07686274498701096, -0.004327015019953251, 0.015385380014777184, 0.0569438599050045, -0.012988915666937828, -0.038935985416173935, 0.03251950070261955, 0.058814916759729385, 0.007754484657198191, -0.02989564836025238, -0.0041845934465527534, -0.05498484894633293, -0.011095935478806496, 0.005929533392190933, -0.034928128123283386, 0.008584044873714447, -0.016855020076036453, 0.01769099570810795, -0.017573576420545578, 0.030155351385474205, -0.04576855152845383, -0.005942727904766798, 0.024190541356801987, -0.02151486463844776, -0.042631179094314575, -0.007814476266503334, 0.06342897564172745, 0.02074693888425827, 0.004153198096901178, -0.0051682861521840096, -0.009106891229748726, -0.09455998241901398, 0.012270883657038212, -0.01327751949429512, -0.020934201776981354, -0.005694616120308638, 0.07849761098623276, 0.01665348932147026, 0.004527457058429718, 0.018616922199726105, -0.022752627730369568, 0.020083002746105194, 0.04118122532963753, 0.005428379867225885, -0.000099559583759401, -0.005043902434408665, -0.03698089346289635, 0.04091286659240723, -0.023854674771428108, 0.06890174001455307, -0.036958321928977966, 0.03202842175960541, 0.0368502102792263, 0.0069348071701824665, 0.015585744753479958, -0.012310999445617199, 0.011377612128853798, -0.01185845397412777, -0.05485612526535988, -0.028757281601428986, 0.00983714684844017, 0.034283481538295746, -0.025265434756875038, -0.0013132563326507807, -0.0012776229996234179, 0.05156000703573227, 0.007163949776440859, -0.0349130742251873, 0.01701774075627327, -0.03845095634460449, 0.04987248778343201, -0.036802198737859726, -0.007286327891051769, 0.05238984525203705, 0.03572181612253189, 0.032517146319150925, 0.019303012639284134, -0.06586677581071854, 0.02085869386792183, 0.04183206334710121, 0.018866179510951042, -0.04774961248040199, -0.04311059042811394, 0.02954094670712948, 0.030307255685329437, -0.05193234235048294, 0.00937572680413723, 0.07117678225040436, 0.008974537253379822, 0.04772934690117836, -0.11306305974721909, -0.005722919944673777, -0.03532744571566582, -0.0006762848934158683, 0.05970127880573273, -0.012613138183951378, -0.05415346845984459, 0.021531270816922188, 0.02178524248301983, 0.014274897053837776, 0.035788290202617645, 0.01346833910793066, 0.03804904967546463, -0.002259540371596813, 0.012463626451790333, 0.01951165869832039, 0.014481395483016968, 0.016776230186223984, -0.038455501198768616, 0.013875036500394344, 0.010354429483413696, -0.01695796474814415, 0.022606467828154564, 0.05216347798705101, -0.030451377853751183, 0.0014090158510953188, 0.0425516702234745, 0.027988772839307785, -0.019873525947332382, -0.01014181599020958, 0.06094638630747795, 0.05901898443698883, 0.034525249153375626, -0.03584420308470726, 0.02454366907477379, -0.011865231208503246, 0.007227469235658646, -0.030978189781308174, 0.00562313012778759, -0.05714152380824089, 0.01116306520998478, 0.04540148004889488, -0.015138555318117142, -0.025196431204676628, 0.009848486632108688, -0.009569443762302399, -0.006515549961477518, 0.03831762820482254, -0.056300222873687744, -0.022432640194892883, 0.011441002599895, -0.03896483778953552, 0.053143132477998734, 0.0021742016542702913, 0.02114102803170681, 0.10503696650266647, 0.04254216328263283, -0.06708541512489319, 0.023904670029878616, 0.014294986613094807, 0.04409773275256157, 0.025077728554606438, -0.01229382399469614, 0.015693524852395058, 0.018679587170481682, 0.023405376821756363, 0.010195904411375523, 0.027223944664001465, 0.024799635633826256, -0.0179844219237566, 0.01871638000011444, 0.05088772997260094, 0.10547531396150589, 0.004228283651173115, 0.014377816580235958, 0.02942662499845028, 0.006320349872112274, -0.046280428767204285, 0.0004381862818263471, -0.0012791589833796024, -0.057760220021009445, 0.016131004318594933, 0.012727723456919193, 0.03577543795108795, 0.011805015616118908, 0.019038308411836624, 0.008435139432549477, 0.0055020879954099655, -0.01765209436416626, -0.019618812948465347, 0.0020300704054534435, 0.04246612638235092, 0.009401972405612469, 0.0005418917280621827, -0.019441161304712296, 0.03731642663478851, -0.03226408362388611, -0.02378208376467228, -0.013269638642668724, -0.011066115461289883, 0.03069375827908516, -0.027178458869457245, -0.02352335676550865, 0.04068455100059509, -0.02301945351064205, 0.03718031197786331, 0.04775375872850418, -0.03992784023284912, -0.02169545739889145, 0.017499372363090515, -0.047316502779722214, -0.04838050529360771, 0.038022011518478394, 0.04242406040430069, 0.032791730016469955, 0.018057895824313164, 0.08172954618930817, -0.04040355607867241, -0.039077382534742355, -0.000029505734346457757, -0.05675293132662773, 0.058162227272987366, -0.05556120723485947, -0.00968561414629221, 0.04943288862705231, -0.008603118360042572, -0.0799238383769989, 0.0010890228440985084, 0.002096188487485051, -0.07923106104135513, -0.0022184550762176514, -0.03392041102051735, -0.0446917898952961, 0.012851609848439693, -0.06558609753847122, 0.0022549994755536318, 0.0222583319991827, 0.04075080528855324, 0.038421422243118286, 0.04021506756544113, -0.04776538908481598, 0.011675670742988586, 0.05516009032726288, 0.00501224584877491, -0.01679578609764576, -0.020883671939373016, -0.022717511281371117, 0.005306717939674854, 0.0006371739436872303, -0.033698275685310364, -0.032924048602581024, 0.003971749916672707, -0.02169477939605713, -0.002833080943673849, -0.023973479866981506, -0.01194689329713583, 0.04538750648498535, 0.03183651342988014, -0.010640792548656464, -0.004108714871108532, -0.049407292157411575, 0.04860813543200493, 0.04807189851999283, -0.027348892763257027, -0.016251247376203537, -0.022395934909582138, -0.035556089133024216, 0.005784205161035061, 0.01052715815603733, 0.07532528787851334, -0.02574838511645794, 0.07304415106773376, 0.010698352940380573, 0.0420980267226696, 0.04319043084979057, -0.03401132673025131, -0.00853152945637703, -0.022152770310640335, 0.020847458392381668, 0.0009662358788773417, -0.050797201693058014, 0.03049325756728649, -0.027178479358553886, -0.05406859889626503, 0.012391980737447739, 0.015886962413787842, -0.047260671854019165, -0.015274723060429096, -0.05128512158989906, 0.03315848112106323, -0.0641634613275528, 0.008853375911712646, 0.008074305020272732, -0.03367801755666733, -0.001429310766980052, -0.0272076353430748, -0.10753205418586731, 0.030334031209349632, -0.007942602038383484, -0.016227930784225464, 0.016371168196201324, -0.037257276475429535, 0.016959095373749733, 0.0125413928180933, -0.0007750468794256449, 0.0125484149903059, -0.04878842085599899, -0.014985870569944382, -0.0016349488869309425, 0.08731787651777267, -0.021038983017206192, -0.03958141431212425, -0.0036236844025552273, 0.0066005471162498, -0.014035453088581562, -0.03195898234844208, -0.0022292952053248882, 0.01634681597352028, 0.007266309577971697, -0.0776994600892067, -0.030473047867417336, -0.04527723044157028, -0.09452193230390549, 0.00681042205542326, -0.008988545276224613, -0.01931583881378174, -0.05634284019470215, 0.03758639842271805, -0.019936973229050636, 0.007345262449234724, -0.03909740969538689, 0.04748493805527687, 0.00278854020871222, 0.006337643135339022, 0.005022661294788122, 0.00403448985889554, 0.020565496757626534, -0.005316898226737976, -0.017029818147420883, 0.0708131417632103, 0.030367868021130562, -0.05496404320001602, -0.022600656375288963, 0.005970028229057789, -0.03568834438920021, 0.052455637603998184, 0.017813419923186302, 0.032531242817640305, -0.016830742359161377, -0.002025080844759941, -0.05580385774374008, 0.0235842764377594, 0.022757144644856453, -0.0029285966884344816, -0.0006968558300286531, -0.01420905813574791, 0.04246949777007103, 0.00014987563190516084, 0.021781234070658684, 0.02005462348461151, -0.0629262775182724, 0.044626399874687195, -0.09350831061601639, -0.030114570632576942, -0.0073557524010539055, -0.017901604995131493, -0.05462615191936493, -0.01099487952888012, 0.006907658651471138, 0.015250010415911674, -0.11038880050182343, -0.07245275378227234, -0.013713903725147247, 0.004041837528347969, 0.010068456642329693, -0.004887465853244066, -0.024521848186850548, -0.003855744143947959, -0.04207911714911461, 0.03332967311143875, 0.05066589638590813, 0.012166963890194893, -0.05253070965409279, 0.032869499176740646, -0.015780841931700706, -0.08432308584451675, -0.05183957517147064, 0.024325938895344734, -0.038944073021411896, 0.006819259840995073, -0.029894735664129257, 0.009349378757178783, -0.004355248529464006, -0.03493065387010574, -0.015548516064882278, -0.03496117889881134, 0.00817091390490532, 0.004222432151436806, 0.041145578026771545, 0.00862047914415598, -0.025646552443504333, -0.003317930968478322, 0.02198217436671257, 0.06973247975111008, 0.05624004825949669, -0.03158672899007797, -0.04320903867483139, 0.010429874062538147, -0.059341344982385635, 0.0016653353814035654, 0.07868999242782593, 0.04798988997936249, 0.046311601996421814, -0.03557657450437546, -0.008175261318683624, 0.027098998427391052, -0.03169609233736992, 0.014846845529973507, -0.028721153736114502, -0.04220783710479736, -0.11229151487350464, 0.019267220050096512, -0.049198564141988754, 0.00048649345990270376, 0.025814678519964218, 0.012008455581963062, -0.03892732039093971, 0.0050573889166116714, -0.020618967711925507, -0.04102599620819092, -0.012102398090064526, -0.026050014421343803, -0.03174123167991638, 0.03248056769371033, 0.005371814593672752, 0.01883738674223423, 0.03751387074589729, 0.08345501124858856, 0.016815047711133957, -0.050366394221782684, 0.00973210297524929, 0.05467895418405533, 0.023491835221648216, 0.04792683199048042, 0.03265824541449547, -0.03174759820103645, -0.023887144401669502, 0.007574696093797684, 0.021349512040615082, 0.02490353211760521, -0.00486808642745018, 0.001348915626294911, 0.02611609920859337, -0.005228712223470211, 0.07518702745437622, -0.03464650735259056, 0.018343551084399223, -0.06079694628715515, 0.018825137987732887, -0.017967291176319122, -0.015197712928056717, 0.01574024185538292, -0.09643478691577911, -0.003194931661710143, -0.007489882875233889, -0.01059423852711916, 0.045489970594644547, -0.019113600254058838, 0.016665153205394745, -0.006873480975627899, 0.04731854051351547, 0.014754218980669975, -0.010523369535803795, 0.07245529443025589, -0.0032437338959425688, 0.06426121294498444, 0.0056818691082298756, -0.009781773202121258, -0.06760869175195694, 0.03290679305791855, -0.05481668561697006, -0.026497732847929, 0.028768379241228104, -0.01088961772620678, -0.0679796040058136, -0.03660395368933678, 0.008041154593229294, 0.006188711151480675, -0.01643124222755432, 0.08236788213253021, -0.01758529432117939, 0.013790604658424854, 0.025230685248970985, -0.01828848011791706, -0.035257697105407715, 0.01130638550966978, 0.010958260856568813, -0.020841732621192932, 0.03306363895535469, -0.01812702789902687, -0.039600249379873276, 0.06270749866962433, 0.019503027200698853, 0.010791287757456303, -0.03153587505221367, 0.025614693760871887, 0.05109245702624321, -0.010052436962723732, -0.04978344589471817, 0.017373114824295044, -0.016682976856827736, 0.05999189242720604, 0.007495106663554907, 0.0034453740809112787, 0.03374627232551575, 0.042447805404663086, -0.007507775444537401, 0.018544645980000496, -0.040406350046396255, 0.014533166773617268, -0.035108041018247604, 0.01723790541291237, 0.011472931131720543, 0.0410727933049202, 0.053563110530376434, 0.011905786581337452, -0.015541202388703823, 0.04014268144965172, 0.02060924842953682, -0.06573490798473358, 0.007436457090079784, -0.03567041829228401, -0.0356108732521534, 0.018735038116574287, 0.040690500289201736, 0.031414907425642014, 0.06838418543338776, -0.0027574747800827026, -0.0012843534350395203, -0.015636052936315536, -0.014574697241187096, 0.030817458406090736, -0.060374438762664795, 0.031106995418667793, -0.048317309468984604, -0.006437347270548344, -0.024389848113059998, 0.019899746403098106, 0.019242946058511734, 0.0030049739871174097, -0.06856880336999893, 0.007085355464369059, 0.043921250849962234, -0.0030261361971497536, -0.02432807721197605, 0.012294276617467403, -0.041774727404117584, -0.01733488030731678, 0.044682785868644714, -0.03448978438973427, -0.06599761545658112, -0.007609548978507519, -0.05798886716365814, 0.001210191985592246, 0.01916433684527874, 0.015270153060555458, 0.03266139701008797, 0.04746554419398308, -0.0293154064565897, 0.03597290441393852, -0.0075357998721301556, -0.008784689009189606, -0.046572450548410416, -0.03634314611554146, 0.06784041225910187, 0.0015799719840288162, 0.02480078674852848, 0.010187329724431038, 0.019436364993453026, -0.03406503424048424, 0.01187223382294178, -0.0263983067125082, 0.0517781563103199, 0.03143442049622536, 0.04191554710268974, -0.0018295260379090905, 0.07625044137239456, 0.04106808453798294, -0.04271288588643074, 0.042274489998817444, 0.016751842573285103, -0.02047688700258732, -0.06221991777420044, 0.03402965888381004, -0.06721272319555283, -0.046819742769002914, -0.020789282396435738, 0.048162564635276794, 0.016354510560631752, 0.013188548386096954, -0.025391725823283195, -0.0005204820190556347, -0.045808106660842896, -0.00556555949151516 ]
<p>Why nature made conjugates? such as momentum and position, time and energy? Why not energy and position even both do not commute. .</p> <p>thanks in advance</p>
g128
[ 0.023953070864081383, 0.007860496640205383, -0.003708994947373867, -0.02798565849661827, 0.024731988087296486, 0.016358954831957817, -0.002977028489112854, 0.039606157690286636, -0.036365807056427, -0.03543150797486305, 0.015047435648739338, -0.0494663380086422, -0.025926737114787102, 0.03919810429215431, -0.048004284501075745, -0.008975598029792309, 0.044581279158592224, 0.05283534526824951, 0.04052667319774628, 0.00722705852240324, -0.02004905231297016, -0.006292541977018118, -0.00805952399969101, -0.0326923131942749, -0.010197554714977741, -0.014940625056624413, 0.042640965431928635, -0.04588385298848152, 0.007228311151266098, -0.012261556461453438, 0.06802979111671448, 0.029131388291716576, -0.013219108805060387, -0.006023930851370096, -0.03822602331638336, 0.008272132836282253, 0.03833455964922905, -0.0204448439180851, 0.026764962822198868, 0.02828088402748108, -0.000014061123692954425, -0.05479248985648155, -0.006087941583245993, 0.02221878618001938, -0.010317936539649963, 0.018984388560056686, 0.05497860163450241, 0.03606019541621208, -0.00012128915113862604, -0.07235030829906464, -0.04966025799512863, 0.048770397901535034, 0.02991955168545246, 0.00454365462064743, 0.1132083535194397, 0.020476670935750008, 0.03596411645412445, 0.05641653761267662, 0.021935023367404938, 0.014025815762579441, -0.00726321479305625, 0.004604927729815245, 0.008583196438848972, 0.05014294013381004, 0.08738070726394653, -0.09150727093219757, -0.003570463275536895, 0.033159539103507996, 0.045557327568531036, 0.055223628878593445, -0.00803824421018362, -0.024085162207484245, -0.0266330074518919, 0.028902241960167885, 0.0800928846001625, -0.010914086364209652, -0.005333025939762592, -0.028707336634397507, -0.06164370849728584, -0.052747830748558044, -0.030495475977659225, -0.01793711818754673, 0.025753144174814224, -0.025252195075154305, 0.08333227783441544, -0.03642072156071663, 0.03766002506017685, -0.022778911516070366, -0.01323330495506525, -0.025354258716106415, 0.018971703946590424, -0.019409552216529846, 0.0942576453089714, 0.010221239179372787, -0.039735086262226105, -0.04416327178478241, -0.057193778455257416, 0.07287003099918365, 0.04411935433745384, -0.02582426741719246, -0.0496458001434803, 0.03985824063420296, 0.09295576065778732, 0.057256054133176804, 0.03489648923277855, -0.05464254319667816, 0.02258782461285591, -0.027071241289377213, 0.0011772597208619118, -0.004023238085210323, -0.030565615743398666, 0.015888845548033714, -0.0031050522811710835, -0.030351201072335243, -0.012208160944283009, 0.01964472234249115, 0.04397277906537056, -0.053332339972257614, 0.03162991628050804, 0.02888125739991665, -0.00867524091154337, 0.013532391749322414, -0.022125519812107086, 0.04611797630786896, -0.0462055504322052, 0.013252257369458675, -0.01268136128783226, -0.028770826756954193, -0.023357713595032692, -0.03309682384133339, 0.015595654956996441, -0.03129556030035019, -0.016129475086927414, 0.06769493222236633, -0.008741098456084728, -0.0008340196218341589, -0.02469445765018463, -0.018416818231344223, 0.003385885851457715, 0.016736358404159546, 0.02357141301035881, -0.051903028041124344, -0.002627415582537651, -0.000006837800356152002, -0.023091604933142662, -0.04764167219400406, -0.016293521970510483, -0.04497765377163887, -0.013988829217851162, 0.021105514839291573, 0.020215101540088654, 0.034551315009593964, 0.019899802282452583, 0.015465988777577877, 0.03897877410054207, -0.02776743471622467, 0.00634213350713253, 0.04182007163763046, -0.06026756763458252, -0.023566722869873047, 0.059697531163692474, -0.006037895102053881, -0.014823510311543941, -0.02347744069993496, 0.0006321316468529403, -0.00817496795207262, 0.012092867866158485, -0.052034325897693634, -0.047915782779455185, -0.015082182362675667, -0.05707448348402977, -0.015434028580784798, -0.054653268307447433, 0.034754395484924316, 0.025761457160115242, 0.03750602900981903, -0.02321278117597103, -0.022225724533200264, 0.010574049316346645, 0.03667351230978966, -0.034516703337430954, 0.038290899246931076, -0.021731402724981308, -0.028929874300956726, 0.04981200024485588, -0.026991629973053932, -0.01224173977971077, 0.026084614917635918, -0.04755577817559242, 0.018057530745863914, 0.043985817581415176, -0.08175726234912872, -0.026422826573252678, 0.027126498520374298, -0.04257073625922203, -0.000007639656359970104, -0.02494886703789234, 0.014126290567219257, -0.0244958084076643, 0.022546157240867615, -0.010884485207498074, -0.02773790992796421, 0.02917485497891903, 0.025392545387148857, -0.015828071162104607, 0.04127734154462814, 0.026416052132844925, 0.0207374170422554, 0.030065175145864487, -0.0372219979763031, 0.030754797160625458, 0.008902446366846561, -0.06209934130311012, 0.014319805428385735, -0.0636170357465744, -0.0626121237874031, 0.004264393821358681, -0.060044847428798676, -0.03540993481874466, 0.026992348954081535, -0.04716320335865021, -0.05006442964076996, 0.02249809354543686, 0.021003136411309242, -0.03748919069766998, 0.03752483054995537, -0.017155515030026436, -0.026267340406775475, -0.007011450827121735, 0.00688106520101428, -0.03982067108154297, 0.04255277290940285, 0.016605015844106674, 0.0358475036919117, 0.0313950814306736, 0.07579059153795242, 0.016988040879368782, -0.01284041814506054, 0.029440129175782204, -0.0024114486295729876, 0.06655719876289368, 0.013036488555371761, 0.05197140574455261, -0.005676614120602608, 0.07170373946428299, -0.0669684186577797, 0.03201516345143318, -0.07208545506000519, -0.008300614543259144, 0.0189797505736351, 0.035600874572992325, -0.016450557857751846, -0.070657879114151, 0.02835668995976448, -0.05766894668340683, 0.0006625597598031163, -0.009265799075365067, -0.01773589663207531, -0.02198066934943199, -0.01839323155581951, -0.02280278690159321, -0.029742566868662834, -0.00815435778349638, 0.0002384259132668376, -0.010592075996100903, -0.02501346357166767, -0.015799593180418015, 0.016302810981869698, 0.02647347003221512, 0.002704749582335353, -0.018284142017364502, 0.0209010262042284, 0.04324862360954285, 0.02509320341050625, -0.04891134798526764, -0.0238500889390707, -0.043458230793476105, -0.030014680698513985, -0.036927931010723114, -0.011473491787910461, 0.024674134328961372, 0.04059343785047531, -0.06660432368516922, 0.014056744985282421, 0.05903058871626854, -0.028329219669103622, -0.005354895256459713, 0.013508944772183895, 0.008793813176453114, 0.014065323397517204, -0.02959313802421093, 0.03549623861908913, 0.016566209495067596, -0.01907399110496044, 0.018539484590291977, -0.013047491200268269, 0.02937456965446472, -0.006579054985195398, -0.05009168013930321, 0.02982395701110363, -0.024450622498989105, 0.07160786539316177, 0.02101084589958191, 0.029323328286409378, 0.009639470838010311, 0.04332996532320976, -0.03252124786376953, -0.018164988607168198, -0.005517216864973307, -0.006315178703516722, -0.04380367696285248, 0.04980301484465599, -0.009498200379312038, 0.028423825278878212, 0.022355927154421806, -0.058456968516111374, -0.06254325807094574, 0.00020397393382154405, 0.014950662851333618, -0.0714762806892395, -0.00782490149140358, -0.03650933504104614, 0.007452498190104961, 0.015659159049391747, 0.05816175416111946, 0.055331457406282425, -0.08241192996501923, -0.01732172816991806, 0.013015707954764366, -0.041685670614242554, -0.0007634191424585879, 0.05937400832772255, -0.016642432659864426, 0.02025783620774746, -0.08145029097795486, 0.00585081847384572, 0.008891447447240353, 0.03684941679239273, 0.018958179280161858, -0.01557464525103569, -0.044165391474962234, 0.007164827547967434, -0.03174593299627304, 0.06134151294827461, 0.008179087191820145, 0.054935142397880554, 0.014215337112545967, 0.03569818288087845, 0.019856316968798637, 0.01100212149322033, -0.00980596523731947, -0.02690613828599453, 0.02313508465886116, 0.03690626099705696, -0.05527692660689354, 0.11536720395088196, -0.01781441830098629, 0.005620019510388374, -0.03932018205523491, 0.05190180987119675, -0.0288228802382946, -0.000022516194803756662, 0.04326662793755531, 0.025538889691233635, -0.027254613116383553, 0.0950416773557663, -0.004304706119000912, 0.04923897609114647, 0.07319323718547821, 0.0031664606649428606, 0.034845199435949326, -0.024101069197058678, -0.04867326840758324, -0.027848798781633377, 0.03566598892211914, -0.020427320152521133, 0.03552290424704552, 0.06454972922801971, -0.04885657876729965, 0.002703615464270115, 0.06222711503505707, 0.013907366432249546, 0.023896414786577225, 0.05593392252922058, 0.012416223995387554, -0.01837984472513199, -0.018586698919534683, 0.009444843977689743, 0.004957352299243212, -0.009840089827775955, -0.03102894127368927, -0.002636322984471917, -0.013048216700553894, -0.033307939767837524, 0.03447864204645157, 0.010225079953670502, -0.006668080575764179, 0.015755249187350273, 0.030376557260751724, 0.014195570722222328, -0.03410192206501961, 0.04770663008093834, -0.03207921236753464, -0.04372652247548103, 0.012981969863176346, 0.049721598625183105, 0.05559345707297325, -0.013449612073600292, -0.05595076456665993, 0.007622295059263706, 0.028203872963786125, 0.01860952004790306, 0.04266418144106865, -0.03409009799361229, -0.030781708657741547, 0.007981899194419384, -0.0037111598066985607, -0.013456149958074093, 0.014674238860607147, 0.03624926134943962, -0.030202874913811684, 0.05593691021203995, 0.016519444063305855, 0.00682023772969842, 0.0048230173997581005, 0.06535335630178452, 0.029349856078624725, -0.03191189095377922, -0.04876308515667915, -0.014842260628938675, 0.0011757146567106247, 0.013072317466139793, 0.02219625934958458, -0.05905117467045784, -0.013539793901145458, 0.007935542613267899, 0.0074141789227724075, 0.058089300990104675, 0.010211634449660778, 0.03351382166147232, 0.07206416875123978, -0.0077719963155686855, 0.07269751280546188, -0.033512141555547714, -0.00901904795318842, 0.07491646707057953, 0.0022021715994924307, -0.0059297410771250725, -0.032797764986753464, -0.029210064560174942, 0.0021963007748126984, 0.0149462865665555, -0.039260901510715485, -0.046050310134887695, -0.00308777391910553, -0.00020710464741569012, -0.06716922670602798, 0.010381189174950123, 0.00518097123131156, 0.011119971051812172, -0.07334336638450623, 0.006725213956087828, 0.03511890023946762, -0.008565898053348064, 0.017334481701254845, 0.046628259122371674, -0.04284457862377167, -0.01527267973870039, -0.013623912818729877, -0.005672766827046871, 0.030868804082274437, 0.05259569734334946, -0.015447553247213364, 0.0478038489818573, -0.004544017370790243, -0.01715555600821972, 0.024979421868920326, -0.01992235891520977, -0.0028085759840905666, -0.037743523716926575, -0.03291061148047447, -0.021886371076107025, -0.024615757167339325, 0.011453523300588131, -0.0428108274936676, 0.011701229028403759, -0.06531120091676712, -0.00316726160235703, 0.06504642963409424, -0.05270015820860863, 0.054288264364004135, 0.0038379936013370752, 0.08256518095731735, 0.014755104668438435, -0.014008823782205582, 0.03481459990143776, -0.05288713425397873, -0.011269609443843365, 0.02356899529695511, -0.03368667885661125, -0.05151877924799919, 0.003183898515999317, -0.07501944899559021, 0.025620007887482643, 0.04771280288696289, 0.020773641765117645, 0.1151818260550499, -0.026980092748999596, -0.017351116985082626, -0.010966678149998188, 0.018698886036872864, -0.005886917933821678, -0.03263944014906883, 0.05516742914915085, 0.03949997201561928, 0.02708759903907776, -0.04272281005978584, -0.03721170872449875, -0.027183160185813904, 0.0025716109666973352, 0.011221910826861858, -0.003749696770682931, 0.06026403233408928, -0.04778923839330673, 0.05351948365569115, -0.0005226666107773781, -0.02289479970932007, -0.09988211840391159, 0.0035159713588654995, 0.05196915194392204, -0.01743762381374836, -0.015036688186228275, 0.05608900263905525, -0.015575923956930637, -0.028643853962421417, -0.04039185866713524, 0.006902134045958519, 0.029152508825063705, -0.000881596002727747, 0.010839872062206268, 0.019185615703463554, -0.05551600456237793, -0.0041878256015479565, 0.049163877964019775, -0.014161191880702972, -0.0183228962123394, -0.03948621451854706, 0.029180128127336502, 0.006631486117839813, -0.01587383635342121, -0.011250249110162258, 0.018658997491002083, -0.000614952587056905, -0.04842989891767502, 0.0239383764564991, 0.025888271629810333, -0.015773437917232513, -0.029012851417064667, -0.06543189287185669, -0.00740644708275795, 0.0054586054757237434, 0.041976407170295715, -0.00912991538643837, 0.02710644342005253, 0.04694915562868118, -0.018284142017364502, 0.01700832135975361, 0.012802986428141594, -0.031681012362241745, 0.018830593675374985, 0.012280235067009926, 0.01788845658302307, 0.046276889741420746, -0.010861421935260296, -0.0061734928749501705, -0.021516229957342148, 0.000022635047571384348, -0.06249336153268814, -0.029081666842103004, -0.04867854341864586, 0.05402693897485733, -0.054037172347307205, -0.05285343527793884, -0.018141988664865494, -0.013968308456242085, -0.008234687149524689, 0.028266239911317825, 0.04289397597312927, 0.08404524624347687, 0.01541032176464796, -0.01564699597656727, -0.010521329939365387, 0.022177694365382195, 0.01945805922150612, -0.05350010097026825, -0.04095097631216049, 0.01457582414150238, 0.013182620517909527, -0.022570740431547165, 0.006839002016931772, -0.005955756641924381, -0.026147913187742233, 0.06491035223007202, 0.0015683314995840192, 0.03726958855986595, 0.06450852751731873, -0.07346384227275848, 0.001913787447847426, 0.040037233382463455, 0.056876666843891144, -0.020910082384943962, -0.007156402803957462, 0.0030980021692812443, -0.00563785620033741, -0.07117355614900589, -0.01397613063454628, -0.07590948790311813, 0.004230654798448086, -0.008479490876197815, 0.01772252283990383, -0.0020965677686035633, -0.020389992743730545, 0.025740450248122215, 0.04612593352794647, 0.030952755361795425, 0.022767329588532448, -0.06654225289821625, 0.046876829117536545, 0.03329826518893242, -0.011028353124856949, -0.006925205700099468, 0.007412903010845184, 0.011159741319715977, 0.0286903977394104, -0.0642818808555603, -0.017933646216988564, -0.04706013575196266, 0.014807898551225662, 0.020378757268190384, 0.02631095051765442, 0.0225889403373003, 0.015426560305058956, 0.03245145082473755, -0.019600270316004753, -0.004481757991015911, -0.010267623700201511, 0.042438097298145294, -0.06735411286354065, -0.047418851405382156, 0.00318091525696218, 0.003610503626987338, -0.02546621859073639, -0.03775906562805176, 0.08250980824232101, -0.03811490163207054, 0.035643186420202255, -0.05723936855792999, -0.01984943449497223, 0.0031244910787791014, -0.015975773334503174, -0.0751340463757515, -0.020433973520994186, -0.03447073698043823, 0.022568749263882637, 0.031230708584189415, 0.020259318873286247, 0.043981414288282394, -0.03310335800051689, -0.001813224982470274, -0.0007825367501936853, -0.009371080435812473, -0.07128774374723434, 0.0018902798183262348, 0.025229478254914284, -0.06565861403942108, -0.03402253985404968, -0.0025553179439157248, -0.00138315639924258, 0.029619673267006874, -0.013366706669330597, 0.04214424267411232, 0.03927285596728325, -0.02130546234548092, 0.023240182548761368, -0.029116526246070862, 0.001947190030477941, -0.024256164208054543, 0.02543935365974903, 0.02317289263010025, -0.03733871132135391, 0.04285602644085884, 0.03459108620882034, 0.017157377675175667, 0.01036179531365633, -0.022347722202539444, -0.01025449950248003, 0.0636305883526802, 0.019824188202619553, 0.0420985147356987, -0.044603630900382996, 0.02348203770816326, -0.06998686492443085, -0.012718867510557175, -0.023746540769934654, -0.038640230894088745, 0.013234618119895458, 0.003768450114876032, 0.00821203738451004, -0.06367701292037964, -0.0009924068581312895, -0.041540760546922684, 0.02105889841914177, 0.004174965433776379, 0.009398393332958221, 0.05432433634996414, 0.04417158663272858, 0.0021378942765295506, 0.05019068717956543, 0.02521578036248684, 0.04704657569527626, -0.028631404042243958, -0.036923132836818695, -0.037905022501945496, -0.042304713279008865, -0.04930037632584572, -0.010107148438692093, 0.04493935406208038, -0.06849237531423569, 0.024188930168747902, 0.049343228340148926, -0.03244161978363991, -0.06482900679111481, -0.0053620352409780025, 0.04587579891085625, -0.05384855344891548, -0.04866432398557663, -0.043337926268577576, -0.060088761150836945, -0.028655575588345528, -0.02867242880165577, -0.06037896126508713, -0.006976185832172632, 0.0025160748045891523, -0.009213404729962349, -0.0044027711264789104, -0.06557894498109818, -0.03388321399688721, 0.08253702521324158, 0.02604849264025688, -0.009571525268256664, 0.016824999824166298, -0.00473799416795373, -0.06344960629940033, 0.04070844128727913, 0.006713123992085457, -0.017625773325562477, 0.05356463044881821, 0.06193903833627701, 0.023450788110494614, -0.01863827556371689, 0.0010799914598464966, 0.00011682954209391028, -0.007429253775626421, -0.021177854388952255, -0.01986987330019474, -0.013413524255156517, 0.005441783461719751, -0.02616063877940178 ]
<p>I understand that the larger the mass the greater gravity is and the slower time is, as well the faster an object is traveling the slower time passes. My question is that since the faster an object travels the more mass it has, is the increase in mass the reason for the change in time, or is it the velocity?</p>
g4195
[ 0.050039924681186676, 0.07652366161346436, 0.02318095974624157, 0.01732313446700573, 0.049329258501529694, 0.0521787591278553, 0.06698057800531387, 0.020687071606516838, -0.08386039733886719, 0.006431908346712589, -0.04137350246310234, -0.051311880350112915, 0.04544582962989807, 0.031394973397254944, -0.025200974196195602, -0.04109862446784973, 0.09247580170631409, -0.025211945176124573, -0.016700344160199165, 0.01787220686674118, 0.029895197600126266, 0.02739471197128296, 0.017089376226067543, -0.0016818467993289232, -0.02285642735660076, -0.0016548034036532044, 0.013461309485137463, -0.0015627574175596237, -0.021436989307403564, 0.045420896261930466, 0.03174585476517677, -0.005327726248651743, 0.003068956546485424, -0.027674902230501175, 0.011100842617452145, -0.05869816616177559, 0.009973342530429363, 0.007514249533414841, 0.025698918849229813, 0.003337478032335639, 0.04142032563686371, -0.03275156766176224, -0.0008494987851008773, -0.008673202246427536, 0.03293671831488609, -0.020472826436161995, 0.006508444435894489, -0.029926706105470657, -0.014717735350131989, -0.022933950647711754, -0.07843629270792007, 0.02826336957514286, -0.004347263369709253, 0.04037860780954361, -0.02362350933253765, -0.00996374897658825, 0.02451292984187603, -0.036600444465875626, 0.01628795638680458, 0.06278368830680847, -0.03833591192960739, 0.005858657881617546, 0.02902067080140114, -0.028345324099063873, 0.05287580192089081, 0.019252656027674675, -0.0006683440878987312, -0.03968360647559166, 0.05107330530881882, 0.025461601093411446, -0.008645274676382542, 0.015824301168322563, -0.07430122047662735, -0.09505195915699005, 0.022435015067458153, -0.006834009662270546, 0.04729272425174713, 0.008339921943843365, -0.0004724630562122911, -0.001682401867583394, 0.008883900009095669, -0.0029907755088061094, -0.014183885417878628, 0.01511342916637659, 0.055733826011419296, -0.039272140711545944, 0.001913117477670312, 0.017534606158733368, 0.01304981391876936, -0.010615067556500435, 0.023836662992835045, -0.08874385803937912, 0.0271028783172369, 0.06071566045284271, -0.06314757466316223, -0.023239750415086746, -0.029234671965241432, 0.06277894228696823, 0.0030700508505105972, 0.037552881985902786, -0.004258763510733843, -0.008249717764556408, 0.025940343737602234, 0.026358777657151222, -0.003050193889066577, -0.022023247554898262, 0.002498573623597622, -0.039819978177547455, -0.059603847563266754, 0.014748707413673401, 0.03689176216721535, -0.09258288145065308, 0.0074026077054440975, -0.004115976858884096, -0.06208091229200363, -0.07048346102237701, 0.028148522600531578, -0.008202451281249523, -0.025227217003703117, 0.01618652045726776, -0.03517095744609833, 0.010316183790564537, -0.08538669347763062, -0.000636598386336118, 0.00652182474732399, -0.023508969694375992, 0.00024203956127166748, 0.030882641673088074, 0.023392971605062485, 0.03852716460824013, -0.012614098377525806, 0.03806870058178902, -0.0000623452287982218, 0.013896684162318707, -0.04471072182059288, 0.0168332289904356, 0.00040971318958327174, 0.05236446112394333, -0.012140192091464996, 0.039351414889097214, 0.03249724209308624, -0.013462606817483902, 0.033114854246377945, -0.0311450008302927, -0.022461440414190292, 0.04595193266868591, -0.006095348857343197, 0.04029436409473419, -0.013214399106800556, -0.005192108917981386, 0.024673597887158394, 0.08102311939001083, 0.009925111196935177, -0.04178930073976517, 0.03462943434715271, -0.008565537631511688, -0.013438048772513866, 0.015880074352025986, 0.02816402167081833, -0.011172661557793617, 0.05496321618556976, -0.002812402555719018, 0.0514199323952198, 0.012305578216910362, -0.03700679540634155, 0.07241562753915787, 0.019710751250386238, -0.012496855109930038, -0.033386923372745514, -0.06090136244893074, -0.02238955907523632, -0.012217097915709019, -0.021538395434617996, 0.08885793387889862, 0.010440302081406116, -0.02654219977557659, 0.06959511339664459, -0.02551754005253315, -0.031506750732660294, 0.014060003682971, -0.030482599511742592, -0.03430330008268356, -0.007114040199667215, -0.05429690331220627, 0.045104414224624634, 0.0015936950221657753, 0.015527194365859032, -0.013593515381217003, -0.04790402948856354, 0.019578395411372185, -0.03640153259038925, -0.07538971304893494, -0.022582754492759705, 0.032367270439863205, -0.011500230059027672, -0.015629159286618233, -0.034498728811740875, -0.018024221062660217, -0.10674852132797241, 0.036240581423044205, -0.07446104288101196, 0.005654727108776569, 0.016756704077124596, -0.045292265713214874, 0.04640471562743187, -0.014258621260523796, -0.01621902734041214, -0.014143092557787895, 0.037823572754859924, -0.01499096117913723, 0.03660094738006592, 0.03838355094194412, 0.04400350898504257, -0.020724548026919365, -0.0408741720020771, 0.0860452651977539, -0.005471279378980398, 0.07109589129686356, 0.08219455927610397, -0.007350815460085869, -0.014586759731173515, -0.03115110471844673, 0.022819940000772476, 0.001970148179680109, -0.0029460203368216753, -0.023211289197206497, -0.008560084737837315, -0.06425772607326508, -0.011787010356783867, 0.021170765161514282, -0.01867489144206047, 0.09185732156038284, 0.004512259270995855, 0.01237116102129221, 0.03645232319831848, -0.0007659153779968619, 0.0105482442304492, 0.004544351249933243, -0.004762841388583183, -0.025682006031274796, 0.0354786217212677, -0.02357497625052929, -0.009104304946959019, -0.03647083044052124, 0.03985743597149849, -0.0617024227976799, 0.015409853309392929, -0.05258682742714882, 0.05413667485117912, 0.08755718171596527, 0.018119284883141518, -0.006763635203242302, -0.022406242787837982, -0.008537795394659042, 0.029746970161795616, 0.002978248754516244, -0.017429590225219727, 0.029936887323856354, -0.10210783034563065, 0.0058658914640545845, 0.025879649445414543, -0.009396130219101906, -0.027161767706274986, 0.00031113342265598476, -0.06985782086849213, 0.0008640242740511894, -0.04183916002511978, 0.023800602182745934, 0.012723096646368504, 0.005041683092713356, -0.020268602296710014, 0.02647104486823082, 0.0065747518092393875, 0.03678223863244057, -0.04020703583955765, -0.026542969048023224, 0.03224979341030121, -0.013282492756843567, 0.01778203621506691, -0.017496870830655098, -0.009659691713750362, 0.002685420447960496, -0.11737862974405289, 0.0023682075552642345, 0.01827949844300747, -0.048126861453056335, 0.028139352798461914, -0.014838151633739471, -0.028488775715231895, -0.013380389660596848, -0.007804923690855503, 0.08842270821332932, 0.022560548037290573, -0.010471387766301632, 0.047443412244319916, 0.06297025829553604, 0.017924079671502113, -0.032365646213293076, 0.017301160842180252, -0.058519214391708374, 0.0020036171190440655, -0.042645927518606186, 0.018406162038445473, -0.000570859934668988, 0.03419862315058708, 0.051216501742601395, -0.028798002749681473, 0.00823264755308628, -0.06507598608732224, -0.02817685715854168, 0.020264899358153343, 0.05814726650714874, 0.00005489929753821343, 0.05546627193689346, -0.031113488599658012, -0.015435002744197845, -0.03955991566181183, 0.06068798527121544, -0.04500614106655121, -0.050292860716581345, -0.034384991973638535, -0.025148866698145866, -0.022403819486498833, -0.014939547516405582, -0.022888192906975746, -0.0008366989786736667, 0.016925595700740814, -0.06438808143138885, 0.006800313945859671, 0.012065633200109005, -0.027371691539883614, -0.007971804589033127, -0.023949958384037018, 0.03279760107398033, -0.05527554452419281, 0.0335591696202755, 0.0477205328643322, 0.0061045559123158455, 0.035863421857357025, 0.011992133222520351, 0.017036374658346176, 0.01266599539667368, -0.040234196931123734, 0.03836357221007347, 0.024439770728349686, 0.047567591071128845, 0.028032179921865463, -0.02052937261760235, 0.014400574378669262, -0.0022876670118421316, 0.060903292149305344, 0.007808287627995014, -0.00180247297976166, -0.006297276820987463, -0.017178291454911232, -0.02056030184030533, -0.001207220135256648, 0.030904540792107582, -0.030306831002235413, -0.015494154766201973, -0.025078456848859787, -0.009241989813745022, -0.0017975812079384923, 0.08915383368730545, -0.030373264104127884, 0.033277131617069244, 0.02189462259411812, 0.008975557051599026, -0.03722862899303436, 0.02907690219581127, 0.024688269942998886, 0.011563430540263653, -0.023223120719194412, 0.04947323352098465, 0.06758337467908859, -0.026395663619041443, 0.029843967407941818, -0.023246416822075844, 0.029439443722367287, -0.056324247270822525, 0.08052849769592285, -0.03868849575519562, -0.016906708478927612, -0.015434426255524158, 0.008380635641515255, -0.013588819652795792, -0.07142852246761322, -0.0496298149228096, 0.020822303369641304, -0.07259826362133026, 0.01294317003339529, -0.02240600623190403, -0.03391590341925621, -0.01364193670451641, 0.023334696888923645, 0.008465731516480446, -0.011507087387144566, -0.005595569033175707, 0.027684692293405533, -0.005598994437605143, -0.04359383136034012, 0.10109075903892517, -0.05295943468809128, -0.008687235414981842, -0.021575191989541054, 0.06132140010595322, 0.05501771718263626, -0.007958200760185719, -0.02479921653866768, -0.016655677929520607, -0.012645299546420574, 0.019535960629582405, -0.02595314010977745, -0.04247169569134712, -0.033579614013433456, 0.030185354873538017, -0.014407030306756496, -0.021315451711416245, -0.0027699873317033052, 0.02566826343536377, 0.00692120473831892, 0.008339179679751396, -0.023315289989113808, -0.01601087674498558, -0.03484738618135452, 0.0514165423810482, 0.07143052667379379, -0.01562866009771824, -0.022862322628498077, -0.013463609851896763, -0.03302359580993652, 0.02633572742342949, 0.012696443125605583, 0.05740021914243698, -0.02362963557243347, 0.09873078763484955, 0.04483378306031227, 0.003216745797544718, 0.050855860114097595, 0.004664795007556677, 0.023237790912389755, 0.027527935802936554, -0.03178718686103821, -0.02897820994257927, -0.011791626922786236, 0.03114129602909088, 0.040922295302152634, 0.014622441492974758, -0.021014055237174034, -0.02297452837228775, -0.07439162582159042, 0.04741354659199715, -0.0008324707159772515, 0.002732610097154975, -0.005773883778601885, -0.013391549699008465, -0.001942060305736959, -0.00022429620730690658, -0.007112034130841494, -0.001762467552907765, -0.10075405240058899, 0.05382165312767029, 0.03464201092720032, 0.028077367693185806, -0.003570097964257002, -0.052140213549137115, 0.008937339298427105, -0.022161416709423065, 0.001404942711815238, 0.042213380336761475, -0.0161647517234087, 0.0007235062075778842, -0.03940346837043762, 0.04881374165415764, 0.05653514713048935, 0.005200953688472509, -0.020144226029515266, -0.03602765128016472, 0.047314975410699844, -0.051883939653635025, -0.0063377441838383675, 0.007906484417617321, 0.05552903190255165, -0.050190817564725876, 0.012360389344394207, -0.012951137498021126, -0.0719652846455574, 0.012218556366860867, 0.06264135986566544, -0.05454763025045395, 0.021464793011546135, -0.018451545387506485, 0.020552324131131172, 0.024537207558751106, -0.0026172876823693514, 0.0019128021085634828, 0.02303062379360199, 0.011037078686058521, 0.008704866282641888, -0.05024726688861847, -0.017836762592196465, 0.01353677548468113, -0.0013914027949795127, 0.007595821749418974, 0.02397036738693714, 0.039894480258226395, 0.015843728557229042, -0.001386164571158588, -0.04715747758746147, 0.06351276487112045, -0.017096631228923798, 0.06345398724079132, -0.030476806685328484, -0.03718790039420128, 0.011589620262384415, -0.05217151343822479, 0.0263889841735363, -0.0064081717282533646, 0.03864975646138191, 0.028917063027620316, 0.006371512543410063, 0.012791325338184834, 0.08282570540904999, 0.029280105605721474, -0.007173086050897837, 0.03524519130587578, -0.009879788383841515, 0.002914585405960679, 0.04619709029793739, 0.0034114052541553974, 0.039306510239839554, -0.05418099835515022, 0.030905770137906075, -0.015310471877455711, -0.08150866627693176, 0.0224456749856472, -0.0019688899628818035, 0.03832624852657318, 0.02604442648589611, 0.01496498566120863, -0.0690312311053276, -0.06468803435564041, 0.008664819411933422, 0.06477726250886917, 0.03313923254609108, 0.008733040653169155, 0.028878631070256233, -0.03229027986526489, 0.022357190027832985, -0.03439708426594734, -0.09428296238183975, 0.004511811770498753, -0.04417010024189949, 0.018676314502954483, -0.00892183929681778, 0.09395237267017365, 0.012426512315869331, 0.005040186922997236, 0.023671453818678856, -0.044145796447992325, 0.00853839609771967, -0.010515582747757435, 0.008079922758042812, -0.043471693992614746, 0.03065064176917076, -0.07739134132862091, 0.007426208816468716, -0.03660659119486809, 0.0753900557756424, -0.04921412840485573, -0.03111536242067814, 0.03321734815835953, -0.031427014619112015, -0.0024487958289682865, -0.0012076674029231071, 0.04185574874281883, 0.006186318583786488, -0.047062139958143234, -0.06331019848585129, -0.06176524609327316, 0.018887080252170563, -0.02037626877427101, -0.03207193315029144, -0.027779188007116318, 0.0147128626704216, -0.00031059925095178187, -0.032332103699445724, 0.02529962733387947, 0.05957870930433273, -0.024418829008936882, -0.003510403214022517, 0.020796237513422966, 0.0004141553945373744, -0.038827285170555115, -0.07552868872880936, 0.04984426125884056, -0.058019883930683136, -0.006317951716482639, 0.013659455813467503, 0.020133979618549347, 0.031908564269542694, 0.023249713703989983, 0.04015751928091049, 0.010016513988375664, 0.030655506998300552, 0.014516094699501991, -0.01819485053420067, -0.033213693648576736, 0.051302336156368256, -0.026798665523529053, 0.032184842973947525, 0.012792471796274185, 0.04979919269680977, 0.04976070299744606, -0.0202952828258276, 0.0324275866150856, -0.018843956291675568, 0.01796519197523594, -0.01677722856402397, -0.019365638494491577, 0.03836187347769737, -0.03639480844140053, 0.05736999958753586, -0.029975082725286484, 0.024064840748906136, 0.00744482409209013, -0.014425101689994335, -0.009328441694378853, 0.02283034287393093, -0.01072110328823328, -0.006571927107870579, 0.016242971643805504, -0.06389456242322922, 0.00797645840793848, 0.03881514444947243, 0.006341211963444948, -0.012725678272545338, 0.04381629824638367, -0.0007088176207616925, 0.024482090026140213, 0.02808835357427597, -0.015762273222208023, -0.07096410542726517, 0.00498737208545208, -0.06873840093612671, -0.008087876252830029, 0.06537772715091705, 0.02509528212249279, -0.024402474984526634, -0.0684066116809845, -0.06098027154803276, 0.01253022812306881, -0.031508252024650574, 0.034091316163539886, -0.026792721822857857, -0.020829129964113235, -0.03461947664618492, 0.031463466584682465, 0.035493552684783936, 0.0015866280300542712, -0.06949668377637863, 0.021939849480986595, -0.06093753129243851, 0.008969278074800968, 0.0007444037473760545, 0.08128766715526581, 0.014290530234575272, -0.00782407633960247, 0.012018336914479733, 0.00917682982981205, 0.003911694977432489, 0.038390327244997025, -0.006520266644656658, -0.02283112332224846, 0.0008494334761053324, 0.014209914021193981, -0.04791771620512009, -0.02120940387248993, -0.0075037674978375435, 0.005999429617077112, 0.02475046180188656, 0.04788234829902649, 0.008829452097415924, 0.009748333133757114, -0.0018611073028296232, 0.050747547298669815, -0.0631813108921051, 0.0015867636539041996, -0.030608955770730972, -0.007389699574559927, 0.020229045301675797, 0.004018590319901705, -0.004025512840598822, 0.031796976923942566, -0.03885704651474953, -0.057235363870859146, -0.0395231693983078, 0.0001792733819456771, -0.010396018624305725, 0.00008003207767615095, -0.03381451591849327, -0.02508259005844593, 0.004467022605240345, -0.00984793808311224, -0.014094984158873558, 0.036358337849378586, -0.04187975823879242, 0.012495853006839752, -0.06749387830495834, 0.021680820733308792, 0.02177313156425953, -0.009140660986304283, -0.005810151807963848, -0.029185496270656586, -0.012021821923553944, -0.01708940789103508, -0.018962319940328598, 0.01722412370145321, -0.06599735468626022, -0.046854402869939804, 0.024796137586236, -0.01859046146273613, -0.010590825229883194, -0.08799967914819717, -0.04867606610059738, -0.012827414087951183, 0.02017531357705593, -0.02158796228468418, -0.05263089761137962, 0.02199302799999714, 0.025838108733296394, 0.009852303192019463, -0.022356387227773666, -0.0370163694024086, -0.02326739765703678, 0.03136209398508072, 0.008745912462472916, -0.02710842341184616, -0.01432238332927227, 0.013497553765773773, 0.030798206105828285, -0.03509151563048363, -0.00608767569065094, 0.01934889703989029, -0.0017368202097713947, -0.03486621379852295, 0.04398446902632713, 0.02778785675764084, 0.057455070316791534, -0.0058914003893733025, 0.043324753642082214, 0.045641038566827774, -0.02800610288977623, 0.022543292492628098, -0.05730672925710678, 0.007932836189866066, 0.009767006151378155, 0.003579499898478389, -0.05980101227760315, -0.044274453073740005, 0.03253483027219772, 0.06550327688455582, 0.039280641824007034, -0.05785565450787544, -0.06669280678033829, -0.013176878914237022, -0.004311263561248779, 0.01411714032292366 ]
<p>Why did nature decide to make conjugate of position to be momentum? Since energy and position do not commute, why not energy? What determines the pairing of time with energy and momentum with position?</p>
g128
[ 0.06321199238300323, 0.01632918417453766, -0.01837996579706669, -0.027393700554966927, 0.03401651978492737, 0.011207448318600655, 0.019127339124679565, 0.029883859679102898, -0.03756279498338699, -0.013040339574217796, 0.014427837915718555, -0.07373803108930588, -0.05001755431294441, 0.01669788733124733, -0.008347611874341965, -0.028473390266299248, 0.0712188333272934, 0.052962690591812134, 0.03258821740746498, -0.005939172115176916, -0.02778851054608822, -0.016543488949537277, -0.035887595266103745, -0.03457188978791237, -0.014506757259368896, 0.003295515663921833, 0.036984607577323914, -0.059463467448949814, 0.03017309308052063, -0.014866583980619907, 0.0695938840508461, 0.02757946215569973, 0.041068580001592636, 0.022019946947693825, -0.03861348703503609, -0.016670456156134605, 0.024761011824011803, -0.03739159181714058, 0.022238953039050102, 0.019241726025938988, 0.020580919459462166, -0.06104417145252228, -0.025537217035889626, 0.021332453936338425, -0.006654040887951851, 0.023243624716997147, 0.03965885192155838, 0.02186955325305462, -0.01915016770362854, -0.04293438792228699, -0.05523621663451195, 0.05144045874476433, 0.01684701070189476, -0.0002703357895370573, 0.0787043422460556, 0.04696722328662872, 0.04361998289823532, 0.03747263178229332, -0.007780156563967466, 0.02330782637000084, -0.008177747949957848, 0.019504977390170097, 0.019754229113459587, 0.04992225766181946, 0.08432020246982574, -0.0901603028178215, 0.004005031660199165, 0.02727494016289711, 0.05508393421769142, 0.032707881182432175, -0.01143382117152214, -0.028637200593948364, -0.03467901796102524, 0.01217060349881649, 0.07297027111053467, -0.01653861626982689, -0.0005718872416764498, -0.028378259390592575, -0.049610402435064316, -0.03082849085330963, 0.002862483263015747, -0.0029925359413027763, 0.035345807671546936, -0.044871799647808075, 0.06818816065788269, -0.046937305480241776, 0.02945721335709095, -0.008974270895123482, -0.009941578842699528, -0.03187159076333046, 0.017775367945432663, -0.013875533826649189, 0.08530016243457794, -0.0074691688641905785, -0.05576308071613312, -0.03609758988022804, -0.05605753883719444, 0.07314153760671616, 0.0340668261051178, -0.016817446798086166, -0.03414101526141167, 0.04538940638303757, 0.05936700850725174, 0.0589420385658741, 0.03568359836935997, -0.044892922043800354, 0.02738320082426071, -0.021896371617913246, -0.012388919480144978, -0.014076978899538517, -0.034484099596738815, 0.015080127865076065, 0.0024530875962227583, -0.034124407917261124, -0.04822061210870743, 0.008509972132742405, 0.04986447095870972, -0.04919930920004845, 0.01867104135453701, 0.020316077396273613, -0.0042842379771173, 0.02868412248790264, -0.03776530176401138, 0.06543788313865662, -0.061230920255184174, 0.015372440218925476, -0.01903802715241909, -0.01638425700366497, -0.01037599891424179, -0.003862839424982667, 0.007470120210200548, -0.03391407057642937, -0.007804690860211849, 0.05292975530028343, -0.018237555399537086, 0.008966488763689995, -0.025873232632875443, -0.012060892768204212, 0.00982824806123972, 0.061499737203121185, 0.01606844551861286, -0.03758905827999115, -0.010947203263640404, -0.03996387496590614, -0.016858544200658798, 0.004176414106041193, -0.030671950429677963, -0.03334132581949234, -0.008658717386424541, 0.04755653068423271, -0.020613132044672966, 0.049147289246320724, -0.019172588363289833, 0.001386159216053784, 0.050770144909620285, -0.031113725155591965, 0.028764864429831505, 0.045454319566488266, -0.021464500576257706, 0.004538857843726873, 0.10122708976268768, -0.008189997635781765, -0.01909339800477028, -0.006821039132773876, -0.031839001923799515, -0.013390659354627132, 0.026880476623773575, -0.06160528585314751, -0.05837811902165413, -0.043519116938114166, -0.05918608978390694, -0.024083277210593224, -0.027669427916407585, 0.022762320935726166, 0.016338538378477097, 0.019317299127578735, -0.025140250101685524, -0.04046686366200447, 0.02772940881550312, 0.04719255864620209, 0.00662973104044795, 0.045359984040260315, 0.007764738984405994, -0.017912814393639565, 0.032067444175481796, -0.015322021208703518, 0.0191773921251297, 0.013905765488743782, -0.060294508934020996, 0.004429380409419537, 0.026026630774140358, -0.06770551204681396, -0.06717468798160553, 0.0221662949770689, -0.027635877951979637, 0.013284655287861824, -0.0282931849360466, -0.015186991542577744, -0.03888479247689247, 0.03148976340889931, -0.02948901057243347, -0.03880782425403595, 0.023373641073703766, 0.033033013343811035, -0.010979842394590378, 0.05833403766155243, 0.05161137133836746, 0.015995346009731293, 0.043097298592329025, -0.03183034807443619, 0.009296544827520847, 0.011191545985639095, -0.07190140336751938, 0.005643540062010288, -0.07568517327308655, -0.07045649737119675, 0.02586887963116169, -0.03269040212035179, -0.05318368971347809, 0.02509482204914093, -0.05598108097910881, -0.06620677560567856, 0.01116656418889761, 0.03578979894518852, -0.03559109568595886, 0.04046933725476265, -0.027527641505002975, -0.01675560511648655, -0.045172061771154404, 0.026090146973729134, -0.05325625091791153, 0.07998672872781754, 0.005427249241620302, 0.04962562024593353, 0.04393066093325615, 0.04446113109588623, 0.02478935196995735, -0.011572125367820263, 0.004482402466237545, 0.03473038226366043, 0.03406759724020958, 0.0015372064663097262, 0.013281506486237049, -0.028131283819675446, 0.06988447159528732, -0.028535140678286552, 0.07224377989768982, -0.0672464668750763, -0.01821308583021164, -0.011363399215042591, 0.04178528115153313, -0.02122408337891102, -0.0519445426762104, -0.00017645084881223738, -0.06718235462903976, -0.0014046666910871863, -0.019888246431946754, 0.014609563164412975, -0.06506817787885666, -0.016009990125894547, -0.02186809666454792, -0.04449673369526863, 0.01513432152569294, -0.0012284398544579744, -0.005095283500850201, -0.013378659263253212, -0.015055094845592976, 0.026082996279001236, 0.010483413003385067, -0.014061810448765755, 0.00550715671852231, 0.04069598391652107, 0.04403659328818321, 0.022550681605935097, -0.060319676995277405, -0.035798948258161545, -0.009168162010610104, -0.05749065428972244, -0.03054695576429367, -0.0009583531646057963, 0.011954780668020248, 0.0495457798242569, -0.07428004592657089, 0.03981117531657219, 0.043725039809942245, 0.005279696546494961, -0.0005585825419984758, 0.031583622097969055, 0.03602679446339607, -0.030366670340299606, -0.01606099121272564, 0.035103689879179, 0.004329150076955557, -0.0037862223107367754, 0.06112733110785484, 0.030512142926454544, 0.04548144340515137, 0.010797901079058647, -0.044808804988861084, -0.004191829822957516, 0.003465804969891906, 0.05489930510520935, 0.01742006279528141, 0.00972077064216137, 0.04414478316903114, 0.058023735880851746, -0.03880761191248894, -0.008988099172711372, -0.02909969724714756, 0.015350940637290478, -0.04207802191376686, 0.07763450592756271, -0.04616723209619522, 0.02790277637541294, -0.0028537705074995756, -0.044544726610183716, -0.054808471351861954, -0.022344158962368965, -0.012744382955133915, -0.05862625315785408, -0.014472877606749535, -0.01371531281620264, -0.009759190492331982, -0.03205246478319168, 0.06290086358785629, 0.05235695466399193, -0.07956192642450333, -0.019351879134774208, -0.004256970714777708, -0.020951222628355026, -0.001928104436956346, 0.04118925705552101, -0.0025508354883641005, -0.0026673965621739626, -0.04476231709122658, -0.008964956738054752, 0.018743010237812996, 0.03583696857094765, 0.025360725820064545, -0.004766395315527916, -0.01776258461177349, 0.011623618192970753, -0.008770830929279327, 0.06567253917455673, 0.018444202840328217, 0.040975626558065414, 0.015075081959366798, 0.007026989478617907, 0.036144375801086426, 0.00825059600174427, -0.03323746845126152, -0.011504383757710457, -0.005524057429283857, 0.018553758040070534, -0.041517045348882675, 0.10423219949007034, -0.02172144316136837, 0.017690351232886314, -0.045897699892520905, 0.02451939694583416, -0.028975646942853928, 0.013594146817922592, 0.02152520790696144, 0.008358932100236416, -0.02211458794772625, 0.029137233272194862, -0.0507689006626606, 0.038348279893398285, 0.062300436198711395, 0.018821826204657555, 0.009489784017205238, -0.06196349114179611, -0.04546361789107323, 0.012945443391799927, 0.06285880506038666, -0.01329843234270811, 0.013813458383083344, 0.03147727623581886, -0.040625013411045074, 0.018230829387903214, 0.01903568021953106, 0.0018992589320987463, 0.013560954481363297, 0.052988938987255096, -0.0045053185895085335, 0.013328620232641697, -0.022949183359742165, 0.02745373360812664, 0.038894686847925186, -0.020302850753068924, -0.03952774405479431, -0.002092502312734723, -0.010713422670960426, -0.06907621771097183, 0.02891753613948822, 0.041365887969732285, 0.007426982279866934, 0.035885412245988846, 0.030590610578656197, -0.02813579887151718, -0.0439738966524601, 0.016946515068411827, -0.056597862392663956, -0.054737638682127, 0.009307922795414925, 0.08539750427007675, 0.048698849976062775, -0.03714676946401596, -0.027778245508670807, 0.007136812433600426, 0.038181714713573456, 0.03482365980744362, 0.01736343465745449, -0.07487524300813675, -0.057800859212875366, -0.003512162482365966, -0.014456390403211117, -0.013490833342075348, 0.014978754334151745, 0.0440019890666008, 0.00012026046169921756, 0.08115271478891373, 0.04154195263981819, -0.030508248135447502, 0.008805663324892521, 0.06123479828238487, 0.02475525066256523, -0.029942868277430534, -0.04034721478819847, -0.010771227069199085, 0.0212832260876894, -0.0063609895296394825, 0.04354619234800339, -0.04663880169391632, -0.027027294039726257, -0.006055731792002916, 0.03407406806945801, 0.017831264063715935, 0.01470237784087658, 0.08288245648145676, 0.07038454711437225, -0.012246880680322647, 0.05750444158911705, -0.019780665636062622, -0.013151613064110279, 0.06967933475971222, 0.014696166850626469, -0.016888311132788658, -0.05748794972896576, -0.02414717897772789, 0.01338573731482029, 0.0032385268714278936, -0.036114439368247986, -0.012912586331367493, -0.01919807307422161, 0.01172642782330513, -0.0618007518351078, 0.004535071551799774, -0.021581923589110374, 0.005519474856555462, -0.07309500873088837, 0.03425216302275658, 0.05439310893416405, -0.012311107479035854, 0.054887283593416214, 0.038912780582904816, 0.006632158067077398, -0.02669508010149002, -0.028961757197976112, 0.020928483456373215, 0.04873392730951309, 0.015652040019631386, 0.004724957048892975, 0.03244910016655922, -0.009146053344011307, -0.016187291592359543, 0.03243054822087288, -0.013870813883841038, 0.04265415295958519, -0.04735328257083893, -0.024048717692494392, 0.01869562454521656, -0.015027259476482868, 0.008501599542796612, -0.02679337188601494, 0.00398525083437562, -0.08897831290960312, -0.002813157392665744, 0.05670841783285141, -0.011157390661537647, 0.044127535074949265, 0.010885562747716904, 0.08840391784906387, -0.017482347786426544, 0.00444721058011055, 0.033377714455127716, -0.04001040384173393, 0.010948201641440392, 0.03271440416574478, -0.0616094134747982, -0.02668260969221592, -0.012432865798473358, -0.043300166726112366, 0.03204653784632683, 0.0033759528305381536, 0.004321133717894554, 0.10563584417104721, -0.022739918902516365, -0.014497888274490833, -0.008885258808732033, -0.00582554517313838, 0.01578417234122753, -0.03508203849196434, 0.04884101822972298, 0.01886827126145363, -0.00627371110022068, -0.01139538548886776, -0.02941439300775528, -0.01842040754854679, 0.00001812327900552191, 0.02436000108718872, 0.018708685413002968, 0.05325809121131897, -0.04728149622678757, 0.030667170882225037, -0.012179418466985226, -0.04611581191420555, -0.026464540511369705, -0.005441315472126007, 0.05283466354012489, -0.022642480209469795, -0.028404906392097473, 0.052771907299757004, -0.027415823191404343, -0.03032488003373146, -0.03985966742038727, 0.01736478880047798, 0.015750370919704437, -0.009635007940232754, -0.002808933611959219, -0.012240082025527954, -0.06961604952812195, -0.01691739447414875, 0.05979802832007408, -0.038887836039066315, -0.003963744267821312, -0.060928959399461746, 0.021103737875819206, -0.01399077009409666, -0.02001810073852539, -0.007056303322315216, 0.0191617701202631, -0.021946409717202187, -0.006931389681994915, 0.010694376192986965, 0.006484601181000471, -0.0209053885191679, -0.06115729734301567, -0.062260840088129044, 0.01138707622885704, -0.006756042595952749, 0.028764257207512856, -0.004063866566866636, 0.04772724583745003, 0.06840574741363525, -0.026892539113759995, 0.009412182494997978, 0.008813628926873207, -0.0241765845566988, 0.013239679858088493, -0.020030943676829338, 0.014837652444839478, 0.026693563908338547, 0.026076776906847954, -0.008748266845941544, -0.026182983070611954, -0.01686881296336651, -0.03138143569231033, -0.05623616278171539, -0.04647524282336235, 0.04957864433526993, -0.04685937985777855, -0.05582711100578308, -0.00515573937445879, -0.000500813068356365, 0.015640199184417725, -0.013400471769273281, 0.019618190824985504, 0.07369672507047653, 0.04199926555156708, -0.00406591035425663, 0.004981271922588348, -0.01874358393251896, 0.016955478116869926, -0.06424358487129211, -0.006413410417735577, 0.03734667971730232, 0.0026312358677387238, -0.020062051713466644, 0.02030249871313572, -0.007968674413859844, 0.003035089001059532, 0.06597696989774704, -0.008269465528428555, 0.04465031623840332, 0.09444919228553772, -0.03770957142114639, 0.002178025199100375, 0.04770610108971596, 0.019496431574225426, -0.015410949476063251, -0.0014820799697190523, -0.002484541619196534, 0.007530464790761471, -0.07497280836105347, 0.03386397287249565, -0.00010319578723283485, 0.03195630759000778, -0.000039008275052765384, 0.02476697787642479, -0.004248165525496006, -0.0035883632954210043, 0.024769252166152, 0.031455691903829575, 0.03040470741689205, -0.014268784783780575, -0.06189769133925438, 0.025861376896500587, 0.042618099600076675, -0.006693609524518251, -0.009979340247809887, -0.010059015825390816, 0.014051787555217743, 0.03667045757174492, -0.066361203789711, -0.009895244613289833, -0.0508204810321331, 0.017992889508605003, 0.026887735351920128, 0.030687442049384117, 0.030294692143797874, 0.0020121366251260042, -0.0028492410201579332, -0.023530781269073486, -0.010137881152331829, -0.009430307894945145, 0.04042818769812584, -0.053894806653261185, -0.024412058293819427, -0.034778546541929245, -0.01513566542416811, -0.016551241278648376, -0.044605955481529236, 0.07145049422979355, -0.011989196762442589, 0.05766628682613373, -0.08108720183372498, -0.016110900789499283, -0.0009162846836261451, -0.014046724885702133, -0.036767005920410156, -0.038214851170778275, -0.036764390766620636, 0.02116878516972065, -0.004700651858001947, 0.012537541799247265, 0.041207991540431976, -0.06411542743444443, 0.0029758752789348364, -0.01921919360756874, 0.015605983324348927, -0.055842358618974686, -0.02243250049650669, 0.0011295705335214734, -0.055564653128385544, -0.020256733521819115, -0.018879014998674393, -0.015660176053643227, 0.0033068787306547165, -0.0010694303782656789, 0.04234364628791809, 0.06610796600580215, -0.03359737992286682, -0.014543795958161354, -0.020925112068653107, 0.018769314512610435, -0.01864643581211567, 0.028972603380680084, 0.01849311962723732, -0.025275759398937225, 0.04328791797161102, 0.047099556773900986, -0.0022073935251682997, 0.0003499558079056442, -0.014416340738534927, -0.00473671592772007, 0.08465869724750519, 0.005741123575717211, 0.015928836539387703, -0.005172849167138338, 0.012957749888300896, -0.10787859559059143, -0.003889890853315592, 0.014439254067838192, -0.02934357337653637, -0.00904014054685831, 0.011300227604806423, -0.01869654841721058, -0.05134131759405136, 0.02272205241024494, -0.010351515375077724, -0.023374978452920914, -0.002403836464509368, -0.0180762130767107, 0.021641330793499947, 0.04376756027340889, -0.04325218126177788, 0.05712808296084404, 0.003727565985172987, 0.051735542714595795, -0.00833954755216837, -0.03446018323302269, -0.026683511212468147, -0.036137841641902924, -0.03188958764076233, -0.006673987954854965, 0.0353032648563385, -0.04300308600068092, 0.0339546799659729, 0.04376986622810364, -0.01243543066084385, -0.09757062047719955, 0.023160569369792938, 0.038590334355831146, -0.03156782686710358, -0.037921540439128876, -0.05535521358251572, -0.024387983605265617, -0.017945047467947006, 0.007705052848905325, -0.0634106695652008, -0.03204566240310669, -0.016737258061766624, 0.007978145964443684, 0.021096523851156235, -0.07528813928365707, -0.005725306924432516, 0.11944778263568878, 0.015399409458041191, -0.005780345294624567, 0.033520448952913284, 0.009760649874806404, -0.06589173525571823, -0.0014472403563559055, 0.009257255122065544, -0.024638762697577477, 0.017566964030265808, 0.04607122391462326, 0.030099162831902504, -0.01191640179604292, 0.005130680277943611, 0.015342687256634235, 0.01640288345515728, -0.04402285814285278, 0.011219850741326809, 0.0028450293466448784, 0.02301201783120632, -0.020785517990589142 ]
<p>A satellite is in a circular orbit when its engines turn on to exert a small force in the direction of the velocity for a short time interval. Is the new orbit further or closer to the Earth?</p> <p>The solution is that the new orbit is further away (which is also intuitive) and is justified by stating that there is a positive increase in the total energy which is given by the formula: $$\:E_{T}=-\frac{GMm}{2r}$$ And that states that an increase in the total energy would result in a larger radius. Thus, the new orbit is further away.</p> <p>However, the problem arises when I look at this equation which relates the speed with the radius:</p> <p>$$\:v^2=\frac{GM}{r}$$ Since the small force was in the direction of the velocity, an increase in veloctiy should result in a DECREASE in the radius meaning that the new orbit is closer in according to this equation. </p> <p>Why is it that the first equation is correct to use, while the second one is wrong? Why is the second equation not working here?</p> <p>Thanks!</p>
g4196
[ 0.04252177104353905, 0.012697413563728333, -0.005924892611801624, 0.008033744990825653, 0.02528628520667553, -0.006577209569513798, -0.006061788182705641, -0.02261216752231121, -0.07603103667497635, -0.0009568868554197252, 0.039045508950948715, 0.041640713810920715, 0.0739915743470192, 0.014182383194565773, 0.04933466389775276, -0.016591161489486694, 0.10004791617393494, -0.038108110427856445, -0.03434694930911064, 0.06904459744691849, -0.02718179300427437, 0.00929777231067419, -0.030605090782046318, -0.013092318549752235, 0.038663752377033234, -0.001974882325157523, 0.04170086979866028, 0.019756926223635674, -0.01241728663444519, -0.001971419667825103, 0.013832305558025837, 0.0025760552380234003, 0.05021195113658905, -0.05391883850097656, -0.017325803637504578, 0.03519737347960472, 0.04372221976518631, 0.017675090581178665, 0.018024858087301254, -0.05860860273241997, 0.03207508847117424, -0.07390400767326355, -0.012044357135891914, 0.008268682286143303, 0.034380219876766205, -0.09491978585720062, -0.017718123272061348, -0.008212495595216751, 0.03782511502504349, -0.018134133890271187, -0.013546830043196678, 0.04597070813179016, 0.003206981113180518, -0.03171622380614281, -0.012222439050674438, 0.046625763177871704, -0.00505031505599618, -0.047384537756443024, 0.004639448598027229, 0.02798953652381897, -0.00970359705388546, 0.009775250218808651, 0.018479885533452034, -0.015836598351597786, 0.05617724359035492, -0.029177995398640633, -0.025020752102136612, 0.012315531261265278, 0.01220700703561306, 0.03923309966921806, -0.022716099396348, -0.031578391790390015, -0.021961187943816185, -0.06085978075861931, -0.02257169596850872, -0.05594005063176155, 0.017084458842873573, -0.019665231928229332, -0.007027474697679281, -0.01191764883697033, -0.03321961313486099, 0.04495019465684891, 0.000562501372769475, -0.016189411282539368, 0.03396788612008095, 0.003087547840550542, 0.009449674747884274, 0.07353173196315765, 0.018120557069778442, 0.01690971851348877, 0.00688300933688879, -0.05043315514922142, 0.08334855735301971, -0.02893497608602047, 0.015512768179178238, 0.003945250529795885, -0.027453504502773285, 0.054097242653369904, 0.023289818316698074, 0.03913595899939537, 0.01810804195702076, -0.037690844386816025, 0.004694698844105005, -0.03184322267770767, -0.018039949238300323, -0.03257698565721512, -0.02384205348789692, 0.047240108251571655, 0.005083927884697914, -0.037863533943891525, 0.0056157237850129604, -0.09169518202543259, 0.01596422865986824, -0.04864371940493584, -0.006602639332413673, -0.030593372881412506, 0.06098725646734238, -0.031587716192007065, 0.018441092222929, 0.015231836587190628, -0.02052464336156845, 0.013857414945960045, -0.024978630244731903, 0.05937289446592331, 0.013295767828822136, 0.002298185136169195, -0.028841275721788406, -0.010040806606411934, 0.061945393681526184, -0.003849912667647004, -0.05791691690683365, -0.02791593037545681, 0.0630369707942009, -0.0038389049004763365, 0.034051720052957535, 0.032749250531196594, -0.0448986291885376, 0.0059510343708097935, -0.008701854385435581, 0.006108436733484268, -0.02110704593360424, -0.024118568748235703, 0.0410393625497818, -0.01708240993320942, -0.08426574617624283, 0.05793406441807747, -0.033632539212703705, -0.007853836752474308, 0.05578262731432915, -0.03972792252898216, 0.008777623064815998, 0.05131755769252777, -0.02951677329838276, -0.044330425560474396, 0.025478919968008995, 0.008059877902269363, -0.02059612236917019, 0.049601610749959946, -0.006948958616703749, -0.0339324027299881, 0.07796116918325424, 0.04570171236991882, 0.007504064589738846, 0.007711633108556271, -0.07235182076692581, 0.10887168347835541, 0.021721405908465385, -0.06152864545583725, -0.08237911760807037, -0.008287088014185429, 0.019008418545126915, -0.050439950078725815, 0.036391232162714005, 0.022856906056404114, -0.03550296276807785, 0.08281336724758148, 0.10232469439506531, -0.03296321630477905, -0.0011295906733721495, 0.03145474195480347, -0.005077725276350975, -0.011957750655710697, 0.060860633850097656, -0.019505159929394722, 0.01847361959517002, -0.029851818457245827, 0.031290169805288315, -0.00275977049022913, -0.09548384696245193, -0.018596360459923744, -0.008909820578992367, -0.0017688777297735214, -0.008748932741582394, 0.012816756032407284, -0.06523855030536652, 0.00638631172478199, -0.011084409430623055, -0.05061161890625954, -0.07097318023443222, 0.032889239490032196, -0.005062418524175882, 0.023244386538863182, 0.046838514506816864, 0.007590264547616243, 0.0650935247540474, -0.01743905618786812, 0.014219317585229874, 0.002250669291242957, 0.07189511507749557, 0.026496348902583122, 0.010553195141255856, -0.004125609993934631, -0.07163063436746597, 0.013157002627849579, -0.020209677517414093, -0.021770447492599487, 0.013630010187625885, 0.01761593110859394, -0.004420469980686903, -0.013951266184449196, -0.03394395112991333, -0.02326565980911255, 0.023028746247291565, -0.0029845216777175665, -0.03550821170210838, -0.006645043380558491, -0.04540091007947922, -0.033690955489873886, 0.002725548343732953, 0.02767334319651127, -0.028346309438347816, 0.0060417503118515015, 0.004652331583201885, -0.02182857133448124, 0.05653074011206627, -0.01078992523252964, 0.021449999883770943, 0.03594444319605827, 0.01715429686009884, 0.011535384692251682, 0.04008280113339424, -0.020581146702170372, -0.04396776854991913, -0.06448009610176086, 0.04707882180809975, -0.05771666020154953, 0.05726037919521332, -0.024219928309321404, -0.0055793230421841145, 0.030726617202162743, 0.0008281147456727922, 0.017025908455252647, -0.020218495279550552, 0.005549965426325798, -0.013014004565775394, 0.028862422332167625, -0.09265413880348206, 0.06518512219190598, -0.0401211716234684, -0.015090475790202618, -0.048404350876808167, -0.009160244837403297, 0.06925360858440399, 0.03642701357603073, -0.006843913346529007, 0.04954620078206062, -0.06885228306055069, -0.02777137979865074, 0.02129031904041767, -0.007513805292546749, -0.041029803454875946, 0.04408532381057739, 0.0021228918340057135, 0.08533763140439987, -0.0040119667537510395, -0.023164330050349236, 0.027804361656308174, -0.00393903162330389, 0.03516058623790741, 0.014576026238501072, -0.054706670343875885, -0.014133227989077568, -0.0325738787651062, 0.02194235287606716, 0.002960688667371869, -0.05471550300717354, 0.03198676183819771, 0.04350968822836876, 0.026258638128638268, -0.06524687260389328, -0.014493407681584358, 0.02514716610312462, 0.06188881769776344, -0.0009697826462797821, 0.04287523776292801, 0.08748488873243332, 0.030406057834625244, -0.02829524129629135, -0.0030886882450431585, -0.014822417870163918, 0.01353734452277422, -0.022538088262081146, -0.03457457572221756, 0.04101593419909477, 0.026673920452594757, -0.004518774338066578, -0.042267173528671265, -0.03617873042821884, -0.06468909978866577, 0.0016011022962629795, -0.05853205919265747, -0.011984406970441341, -0.017571479082107544, -0.027232464402914047, -0.021386388689279556, 0.02954588457942009, -0.0701054185628891, 0.0468040369451046, 0.01000941451638937, 0.027153827250003815, 0.0018049785867333412, -0.061958957463502884, -0.041434261947870255, -0.018564701080322266, -0.04073102027177811, -0.009480411186814308, -0.030117196962237358, -0.02211037650704384, 0.023183785378932953, -0.02380765601992607, 0.0008145758765749633, 0.030757559463381767, -0.006643465720117092, -0.03919956833124161, -0.049491483718156815, 0.02081669494509697, -0.025429269298911095, 0.06948904693126678, 0.022872015833854675, 0.05376708135008812, -0.020149290561676025, 0.012057648971676826, -0.05497824028134346, 0.03831951320171356, -0.048653099685907364, 0.06445162743330002, -0.0285581536591053, 0.018653787672519684, -0.0374399833381176, -0.02827920950949192, 0.017087729647755623, -0.016919024288654327, 0.00910039059817791, -0.010166039690375328, -0.02412731759250164, 0.005373101215809584, -0.02435695007443428, -0.028051599860191345, -0.018611803650856018, 0.0024785161949694157, 0.04014918580651283, -0.0015364410355687141, -0.06265068799257278, 0.07079769670963287, -0.009976466186344624, 0.00965350866317749, -0.010358469560742378, 0.04745735600590706, -0.044425878673791885, -0.023985320702195168, 0.021483469754457474, -0.010926647111773491, -0.01703460142016411, -0.012338305823504925, 0.10702820122241974, -0.0020822458900511265, -0.011539011262357235, -0.026221778243780136, -0.016269758343696594, -0.006247750949114561, 0.04816563054919243, -0.024678822606801987, -0.02816280536353588, 0.012391332536935806, 0.0302076805382967, 0.020610876381397247, -0.032436203211545944, -0.008315659128129482, 0.014007335528731346, -0.004446151200681925, 0.018744243308901787, -0.005736526567488909, 0.007748675066977739, 0.011127112433314323, 0.004834300372749567, 0.0213055070489645, 0.02657543681561947, 0.004414316266775131, -0.014909948222339153, 0.04811634123325348, -0.0065415967255830765, -0.013003669679164886, -0.0579470619559288, -0.0006839231355115771, -0.05953400582075119, 0.013968748971819878, 0.03734638914465904, 0.053968023508787155, -0.009997941553592682, -0.014515631832182407, 0.02551492489874363, -0.005236106459051371, -0.004112659487873316, -0.10375861078500748, 0.028440967202186584, 0.0041717845015227795, -0.013248597271740437, 0.03869566321372986, 0.020409224554896355, 0.017775095999240875, -0.0065198554657399654, 0.0495450496673584, 0.007379933726042509, -0.03641818091273308, -0.006615745835006237, 0.046157971024513245, 0.06410674750804901, -0.022024350240826607, 0.04249514266848564, -0.01915040798485279, 0.0003106781223323196, 0.04307596758008003, 0.014095486141741276, 0.058458682149648666, -0.034641385078430176, 0.07145588099956512, 0.0000954164206632413, 0.08297418057918549, 0.03763957694172859, 0.047350380569696426, 0.0016310284845530987, 0.05828245356678963, -0.013176323845982552, 0.017625316977500916, 0.009139339439570904, 0.03434183448553085, 0.032936546951532364, 0.00842212326824665, -0.034225549548864365, -0.034609805792570114, -0.06902759522199631, 0.04422705993056297, 0.04986225441098213, 0.02386130578815937, -0.0008618615684099495, -0.05092071741819382, -0.048329100012779236, -0.007076747249811888, 0.03231848031282425, -0.026714147999882698, -0.004553741775453091, 0.012526875361800194, 0.024278171360492706, 0.047271184623241425, 0.0481296069920063, 0.011348127387464046, 0.006508036516606808, 0.01649591140449047, -0.012002771720290184, 0.036411553621292114, 0.009008428081870079, 0.012606956996023655, -0.010574854910373688, 0.011004244908690453, -0.05319215729832649, 0.010700599290430546, -0.03364476561546326, -0.016720334067940712, 0.05280451849102974, -0.038681428879499435, -0.04807300120592117, -0.05090747028589249, 0.02440468780696392, 0.0043087853118777275, 0.03252943232655525, 0.06987272202968597, 0.02394653670489788, -0.016107840463519096, 0.06146232783794403, -0.024365879595279694, 0.05110607296228409, 0.039519477635622025, -0.03818527236580849, -0.03193418309092522, -0.014516335912048817, 0.05400557816028595, 0.028860513120889664, -0.0312923900783062, 0.0018973663682118058, 0.038913946598768234, -0.06497117131948471, -0.003739103442057967, -0.05548002943396568, 0.020243069157004356, -0.0025419050361961126, 0.04922455921769142, 0.07554071396589279, -0.008977419696748257, -0.002933993935585022, 0.020509155467152596, 0.006439441815018654, 0.04066088795661926, 0.0069194454699754715, -0.018624015152454376, 0.0013360859593376517, -0.06485337018966675, 0.00002189082260883879, 0.054399874061346054, -0.002037354279309511, -0.012209183536469936, 0.07529499381780624, 0.009606368839740753, 0.036649614572525024, -0.05626664683222771, 0.032192543148994446, 0.03131205216050148, -0.02907382696866989, 0.031160492449998856, -0.007119232788681984, 0.011563449166715145, -0.01636880449950695, 0.03779292106628418, -0.005167811177670956, 0.03905515745282173, -0.034207019954919815, 0.011021572165191174, -0.004687734413892031, -0.03564108908176422, 0.02874000556766987, -0.05822758749127388, 0.014732621610164642, -0.0001479200436733663, -0.011042150668799877, 0.07278797775506973, -0.061445754021406174, 0.0027892475482076406, -0.04481987655162811, -0.04019772261381149, 0.025185400620102882, -0.0397321842610836, -0.0228284802287817, -0.0008338136249221861, -0.09250003844499588, -0.0027518877759575844, -0.040122825652360916, 0.03721018508076668, 0.018056245520710945, 0.014573582448065281, 0.004792006686329842, -0.043753065168857574, 0.010740610770881176, -0.053048986941576004, -0.016791608184576035, 0.03709908947348595, 0.06262293457984924, -0.05862914025783539, 0.03906218335032463, -0.006976639851927757, 0.022083474323153496, 0.013003255240619183, -0.02407039701938629, 0.03551910072565079, -0.0074759540148079395, 0.020549416542053223, 0.053053222596645355, -0.021295005455613136, 0.001344767864793539, -0.017339568585157394, -0.041431836783885956, 0.017154619097709656, -0.04757099598646164, -0.0012696636840701103, 0.019210385158658028, 0.00881322380155325, 0.02036297880113125, 0.03266233950853348, -0.037239834666252136, -0.03088277578353882, 0.05749788507819176, -0.022781791165471077, -0.009361008182168007, 0.01170104369521141, -0.009507006034255028, -0.024643821641802788, -0.05707426741719246, 0.01385329570621252, -0.047719623893499374, 0.011791421100497246, -0.017610756680369377, 0.07161104679107666, 0.00078791897976771, -0.023657461628317833, 0.06806621700525284, -0.03477378189563751, 0.004500008188188076, 0.0008305258234031498, -0.005085206590592861, 0.02004392445087433, 0.0439993254840374, 0.006492861080914736, 0.03780555725097656, 0.01594252698123455, 0.04698798060417175, 0.029405739158391953, 0.005553539376705885, 0.022646544501185417, 0.01905735582113266, 0.03648829832673073, 0.02542445994913578, -0.04324977099895477, 0.021750232204794884, -0.015466680750250816, -0.0010462244972586632, -0.04430638253688812, 0.056677330285310745, 0.03573518246412277, -0.07423430681228638, -0.026684455573558807, 0.03249230980873108, 0.010133477859199047, 0.026794418692588806, -0.03136139363050461, -0.113673135638237, 0.050472598522901535, 0.03128510341048241, -0.02221914939582348, -0.02080925740301609, 0.009084407240152359, -0.03136952221393585, 0.062089938670396805, -0.04503079876303673, -0.01851201243698597, -0.010472041554749012, -0.03254490718245506, -0.038390349596738815, -0.06886022537946701, 0.037359341979026794, 0.0035159362014383078, -0.0159381702542305, 0.025298723950982094, 0.013842223212122917, -0.053306564688682556, -0.028745466843247414, 0.000578099163249135, -0.0017040669918060303, -0.021103765815496445, -0.061805564910173416, -0.0015986169455572963, 0.04779387637972832, -0.010867442935705185, 0.03964899852871895, -0.0000996093949652277, -0.03427448868751526, 0.05598669871687889, 0.0043468475341796875, 0.02588866651058197, -0.032349999994039536, -0.016165995970368385, -0.007854707539081573, -0.06623699516057968, 0.02240903116762638, 0.019774794578552246, -0.04586179554462433, -0.03441992774605751, -0.012697003781795502, 0.07344669848680496, -0.027640579268336296, -0.02880503609776497, 0.011929799802601337, -0.0037311650812625885, 0.006365866865962744, -0.017898552119731903, 0.002628869377076626, 0.027887793257832527, -0.03935735672712326, 0.05920599400997162, -0.03925200551748276, -0.030693260952830315, -0.016496023163199425, -0.019710134714841843, 0.008987457491457462, 0.0697614997625351, -0.006443465128540993, 0.026932496577501297, -0.03733014687895775, -0.03211376816034317, -0.0383414700627327, 0.06518633663654327, -0.016377903521060944, -0.0412016436457634, -0.00723703159019351, -0.005899922922253609, 0.016879288479685783, 0.018453659489750862, 0.00990875344723463, 0.01573631353676319, -0.01993369683623314, 0.02115626633167267, -0.033806588500738144, -0.0376959927380085, -0.009054967202246189, -0.02799369767308235, -0.03220866993069649, -0.019852494820952415, 0.011617815122008324, -0.017625337466597557, 0.010013294406235218, 0.06360968947410583, -0.00467213150113821, -0.028189755976200104, -0.027324149385094643, -0.009755292907357216, -0.008602334186434746, -0.09380748867988586, -0.03326495364308357, -0.02245832234621048, -0.010757970623672009, -0.06772850453853607, 0.022431569173932076, -0.03412759304046631, -0.01400106679648161, -0.02921893261373043, -0.026386400684714317, 0.009709510020911694, 0.008501390926539898, 0.0036390472669154406, 0.001858870149590075, -0.05232229456305504, -0.013442909345030785, 0.03817965090274811, -0.04235832020640373, -0.056252285838127136, 0.026167912408709526, 0.0465521514415741, 0.005898688919842243, -0.003367876634001732, -0.005876709241420031, 0.06915803253650665, 0.01925825886428356, -0.038184527307748795, 0.029185321182012558, 0.03401048108935356, -0.07063713669776917, -0.015011348761618137, 0.019061069935560226, -0.007043278310447931, -0.033607807010412216, -0.02044067531824112, -0.022030984982848167, -0.04597777500748634, -0.007142447400838137, 0.035556860268116, -0.01474689319729805, -0.03204129636287689, 0.019620077684521675, -0.07365807890892029, -0.04091808199882507, 0.05359463766217232 ]
<p>can be a theory with an infinite number of divergent integrals of the form</p> <p>$$ \int \frac{d^{p}k}{k^{m}} $$</p> <p>for m=1 , 2 , 3 , 4 ,...... so the theory would be IR non renormalizable and you would need and infinite set of operations to cure all the IR divergences </p> <p>thanks.</p>
g4197
[ 0.009986055083572865, 0.013984933495521545, -0.011091752909123898, -0.03538627550005913, -0.009484682232141495, 0.011322465725243092, 0.015559550374746323, 0.02267598919570446, -0.00763789052143693, -0.0373736172914505, -0.05081233009696007, -0.028492294251918793, -0.04456368833780289, 0.037274833768606186, -0.024901196360588074, 0.0024271602742373943, 0.025148849934339523, 0.0375785194337368, -0.043592557311058044, 0.023296993225812912, -0.05468794330954552, -0.018768787384033203, 0.024202654138207436, 0.04056543484330177, 0.005346580874174833, -0.03637521341443062, 0.01797999069094658, 0.002272837096825242, -0.060332007706165314, 0.007172484416514635, 0.016638541594147682, 0.004582085646688938, 0.03373248502612114, -0.015115847811102867, 0.04953712224960327, -0.01573948562145233, 0.05914679169654846, 0.004977353848516941, 0.008207174949347973, -0.018933715298771858, -0.022843927145004272, 0.032331522554159164, 0.04762576147913933, 0.020506376400589943, -0.019563481211662292, -0.024334250018000603, 0.012223170138895512, 0.04196302965283394, -0.030538350343704224, -0.012201091274619102, 0.01468268409371376, 0.08061279356479645, 0.05730029195547104, -0.014088030904531479, -0.060331642627716064, 0.0075134579092264175, -0.04073430225253105, -0.010114851407706738, 0.008655757643282413, 0.0002019382664002478, 0.01131907757371664, -0.08345101773738861, -0.004375468008220196, -0.026584183797240257, 0.032989852130413055, -0.02133212797343731, -0.024258699268102646, -0.01415717601776123, 0.04157562926411629, -0.02298225462436676, 0.0481717512011528, -0.017316969111561775, 0.005957733374089003, 0.025068819522857666, -0.06140397489070892, 0.015867426991462708, 0.021933531388640404, -0.03968740627169609, -0.04027348384261131, -0.029943473637104034, -0.027740968391299248, -0.05452566593885422, -0.02691299468278885, -0.05467359349131584, 0.021618669852614403, -0.05803119018673897, 0.032034024596214294, -0.014581376686692238, -0.027171634137630463, 0.029342401772737503, -0.022882454097270966, 0.0158260315656662, -0.03360991179943085, 0.037425462156534195, 0.06100297346711159, 0.013471606187522411, 0.010520641691982746, -0.005463060922920704, -0.03526248782873154, -0.07359911501407623, 0.04029834270477295, 0.022601870819926262, 0.039412714540958405, 0.016775714233517647, -0.0073694526217877865, 0.02689630165696144, 0.07109982520341873, -0.02251807227730751, 0.0683489590883255, -0.013785299845039845, -0.0413847342133522, -0.011589707806706429, -0.04845475032925606, -0.02329488843679428, 0.03227121755480766, 0.023663492873311043, -0.04316278547048569, 0.008456750772893429, -0.05187822878360748, 0.023135297000408173, 0.06583469361066818, 0.010559617541730404, 0.01081726886332035, 0.04120722785592079, 0.003298960393294692, 0.08720941096544266, -0.01714928448200226, 0.024125592783093452, 0.025156168267130852, -0.0018116964492946863, 0.04682888463139534, 0.036117639392614365, 0.021368565037846565, -0.0016013041604310274, -0.029793016612529755, 0.01002848893404007, -0.04682481288909912, 0.01036003790795803, 0.020975809544324875, 0.028456661850214005, -0.06696192920207977, -0.03486261144280434, 0.007790897041559219, 0.0037517340388149023, -0.015883831307291985, -0.044812414795160294, 0.013250169344246387, -0.014816739596426487, -0.0425603874027729, 0.05280767381191254, 0.05326412618160248, 0.020869776606559753, 0.04347531497478485, -0.015626536682248116, 0.014086853712797165, 0.03099052608013153, 0.02336277812719345, -0.010247787460684776, 0.028809525072574615, -0.036229293793439865, 0.0053386688232421875, 0.054717592895030975, 0.006089405156672001, -0.006645600311458111, -0.03566087782382965, 0.021273162215948105, -0.03926922380924225, 0.0013973464956507087, -0.00946582667529583, -0.020766878500580788, -0.041045017540454865, 0.04237886145710945, 0.0031762931030243635, 0.02879476360976696, 0.0027908114716410637, 0.06924119591712952, -0.06450995057821274, -0.02888173609972, 0.012284040451049805, 0.04407236725091934, 0.0005924993311055005, -0.021170664578676224, -0.025430899113416672, -0.04483967274427414, 0.033959221094846725, 0.0481596514582634, -0.010811641812324524, -0.008014442399144173, 0.02350367233157158, -0.03531419485807419, 0.06867232918739319, 0.02315535768866539, 0.002032299293205142, 0.03699822351336479, -0.017710719257593155, -0.014751006849110126, -0.010911750607192516, 0.010913415811955929, -0.026669589802622795, 0.01710912026464939, 0.051799189299345016, 0.056172002106904984, 0.018368853256106377, -0.012589113786816597, 0.05263732373714447, -0.028238827362656593, -0.01377247367054224, 0.002990130800753832, 0.041351210325956345, 0.001788453315384686, 0.03720080479979515, -0.06921308487653732, 0.0012295674532651901, -0.018986789509654045, -0.011615332216024399, -0.08574436604976654, 0.06579890102148056, -0.011042512953281403, -0.00816116202622652, 0.029166895896196365, 0.007754398975521326, 0.05857696384191513, 0.06065697968006134, 0.09085117280483246, -0.05404262617230415, 0.055199477821588516, -0.022404726594686508, -0.031018534675240517, 0.019806846976280212, -0.033492784947156906, -0.09674720466136932, -0.08311396837234497, 0.05904719978570938, -0.029801635071635246, 0.010933831334114075, 0.056044578552246094, -0.016387708485126495, -0.04631508141756058, 0.016239047050476074, 0.04239993914961815, -0.00354625447653234, -0.02271251007914543, -0.005367072764784098, 0.005383233539760113, 0.0066484129056334496, 0.007133994717150927, 0.005418747663497925, 0.0514463372528553, -0.028365369886159897, 0.028594043105840683, -0.018526889383792877, 0.0753636583685875, -0.06123553216457367, 0.020933207124471664, -0.012826322577893734, 0.0058248573914170265, 0.06561889499425888, 0.06473808735609055, 0.011131908744573593, -0.03627752140164375, -0.008226576261222363, -0.04178198054432869, 0.031893059611320496, 0.01863754913210869, -0.10027339309453964, 0.04370967671275139, 0.009223232977092266, 0.017252324149012566, -0.02413506992161274, 0.060334883630275726, -0.051499199122190475, -0.0005760382628068328, 0.025379180908203125, 0.061926331371068954, -0.015108694322407246, 0.02741432562470436, 0.03373851254582405, 0.0010064998641610146, -0.04717636480927467, -0.053365353494882584, -0.0026870707515627146, -0.019341476261615753, -0.007556883618235588, 0.013472305610775948, -0.008037417195737362, -0.06995591521263123, -0.013217017985880375, 0.021038707345724106, 0.02844412252306938, 0.02343052066862583, 0.006642318796366453, -0.026124155148863792, 0.03427029401063919, -0.00032867281697690487, -0.022650819271802902, 0.014949027448892593, -0.00189273024443537, -0.05405106022953987, -0.0243944451212883, 0.02122020535171032, 0.010271221399307251, 0.013995490968227386, -0.014077081345021725, -0.0037866770289838314, 0.01700725592672825, 0.002661983948200941, -0.02601519227027893, -0.0017703719204291701, 0.01109337992966175, -0.06756027787923813, 0.0004093571042176336, 0.04407786950469017, 0.012681558728218079, -0.035648249089717865, 0.041700102388858795, 0.010492905043065548, 0.03395037725567818, 0.02070477232336998, 0.06815819442272186, -0.009343277662992477, -0.029039353132247925, -0.008308221586048603, 0.029766708612442017, -0.024374259635806084, -0.0018305936828255653, 0.011158081702888012, -0.07197599112987518, 0.009198945946991444, -0.07804334908723831, 0.04129163920879364, -0.03312539681792259, 0.014468144625425339, 0.02033914439380169, -0.011288385838270187, -0.0929906815290451, -0.012766129337251186, 0.0029114827048033476, 0.039215173572301865, 0.04180296137928963, 0.002773228334262967, -0.09108855575323105, -0.043785810470581055, -0.018606193363666534, -0.015593512915074825, 0.01722097396850586, 0.053747545927762985, 0.005330835469067097, 0.012299192138016224, 0.041304267942905426, -0.002097600605338812, 0.03182677924633026, -0.03706903010606766, 0.03491498529911041, -0.024113556370139122, 0.006410772446542978, 0.04991939663887024, 0.057826779782772064, 0.11232691258192062, -0.03950351104140282, -0.033834997564554214, 0.0428023636341095, -0.01473939884454012, -0.020115431398153305, -0.02782733365893364, -0.0004954254836775362, 0.035417232662439346, 0.0030398177914321423, -0.006298036780208349, 0.020255081355571747, -0.0030270160641521215, 0.02505815587937832, -0.023574966937303543, -0.009239643812179565, 0.0221235491335392, -0.008255070075392723, 0.0031361551955342293, -0.0067146457731723785, 0.012914801947772503, -0.03130938857793808, 0.022640399634838104, 0.0691637173295021, 0.0028991939034312963, -0.02421577274799347, 0.0089260283857584, 0.007432448212057352, 0.11089609563350677, -0.022218840196728706, -0.043948691338300705, 0.006288608536124229, 0.03397543728351593, 0.02452009543776512, 0.03156324103474617, 0.012134602293372154, 0.008603222668170929, -0.005898387171328068, -0.06060327962040901, -0.03336184844374657, -0.030015865340828896, -0.041985657066106796, 0.023390566930174828, 0.001301254378631711, -0.05076778680086136, -0.029568394646048546, 0.010797012597322464, -0.04686026647686958, 0.022143321111798286, 0.03663741797208786, 0.04625506326556206, 0.02861727587878704, 0.031035292893648148, -0.00048038052045740187, -0.014593656174838543, 0.04984215274453163, -0.08441687375307083, 0.014404697343707085, -0.014764943160116673, 0.012875630520284176, -0.02074442245066166, 0.0375804528594017, -0.0011206638300791383, -0.05245538428425789, 0.018097970634698868, -0.058985862880945206, -0.0006479391595348716, 0.05026242882013321, 0.017227433621883392, 0.028158986940979958, -0.008421479724347591, 0.004769417457282543, 0.010664778761565685, 0.07493516057729721, -0.02363809570670128, -0.054977551102638245, -0.03838270530104637, -0.055870674550533295, 0.02268729731440544, -0.04330690950155258, 0.021825578063726425, -0.050046034157276154, 0.07592277228832245, -0.00393283274024725, -0.006023863796144724, -0.04241759330034256, 0.0034919804893434048, 0.056918103247880936, 0.08473614603281021, 0.036132585257291794, -0.03752197325229645, 0.048669081181287766, 0.026322675868868828, -0.012771575711667538, 0.010549206286668777, -0.02669711597263813, 0.027743788436055183, -0.002688406268134713, -0.03240125626325607, -0.06619146466255188, -0.01547632459551096, 0.01736738719046116, 0.014472860842943192, -0.02102643810212612, 0.032980531454086304, -0.02201903983950615, 0.00776557344943285, 0.04338720068335533, 0.00868048332631588, -0.0760335624217987, 0.06989022344350815, -0.06784525513648987, -0.01409104187041521, 0.03644402697682381, 0.06039217486977577, 0.011742956936359406, 0.03728228062391281, -0.03122464381158352, -0.026977170258760452, 0.04208404943346977, -0.04914576932787895, 0.008838110603392124, -0.004002728965133429, 0.011182215996086597, -0.05334566906094551, -0.03411192074418068, 0.03496849909424782, 0.006681452970951796, -0.01869060844182968, -0.05880197510123253, -0.05895974487066269, -0.06175606697797775, -0.08184730261564255, -0.05188654735684395, 0.041740693151950836, 0.029932837933301926, 0.04150417074561119, 0.022534964606165886, 0.07010902464389801, -0.003970792517066002, -0.005656006745994091, 0.022110113874077797, 0.0038053561002016068, -0.030363790690898895, -0.08589865267276764, 0.0038929744623601437, -0.042023155838251114, -0.04118431359529495, 0.011617078445851803, 0.11053706705570221, 0.01192537508904934, 0.035427507013082504, 0.026879966259002686, -0.0311796385794878, -0.03275575116276741, 0.01418714877218008, 0.012609491124749184, 0.057229574769735336, 0.00647449865937233, -0.11096815764904022, -0.05875251069664955, 0.0006121447659097612, -0.07904648780822754, 0.026409141719341278, -0.06715909391641617, 0.025801105424761772, -0.006481098011136055, 0.041790761053562164, 0.005274096038192511, -0.0892377495765686, -0.07986584305763245, 0.02570486068725586, 0.046654004603624344, 0.027995716780424118, -0.06625527888536453, 0.024849150329828262, -0.014720938168466091, 0.013020945712924004, 0.05233810096979141, -0.010389652103185654, 0.03583289310336113, -0.01680193841457367, 0.008692544884979725, 0.03556734696030617, 0.03728873282670975, 0.04767346754670143, -0.005880675744265318, -0.05778176337480545, 0.012373143807053566, 0.02682863548398018, 0.04751138389110565, 0.05956684798002243, -0.04444505646824837, -0.04387073218822479, 0.0066065979190170765, -0.05345942825078964, -0.07932960242033005, -0.010480912402272224, 0.0014597963308915496, 0.008949115872383118, 0.048325084149837494, -0.0602903887629509, 0.0026642822194844484, -0.019070247188210487, -0.037516068667173386, 0.03372460976243019, -0.00863207969814539, -0.033474478870630264, -0.05299254506826401, 0.007626858074218035, 0.0014592754887416959, 0.03471874073147774, 0.024239404127001762, 0.013128279708325863, -0.0032925179693847895, 0.015432102605700493, -0.0023537559900432825, 0.039777521044015884, -0.030984314158558846, 0.05800509825348854, -0.09454931318759918, 0.02309836447238922, -0.05574804171919823, 0.01588023267686367, 0.04370764642953873, 0.018164794892072678, -0.02141895890235901, -0.02234930358827114, 0.0327800028026104, -0.045891668647527695, -0.017209500074386597, -0.03656494617462158, 0.044812075793743134, -0.03735550120472908, 0.05016736313700676, -0.022924229502677917, 0.010171105153858662, -0.01902127079665661, 0.013027236796915531, 0.029864180833101273, 0.011957691982388496, 0.015640268102288246, -0.03209821134805679, -0.007267263252288103, -0.01374143362045288, 0.010463662445545197, -0.014635330066084862, -0.04133697226643562, 0.011717426590621471, -0.03661681339144707, -0.0053283036686480045, -0.051467545330524445, 0.025411874055862427, 0.05295791104435921, 0.053112681955099106, 0.03834689036011696, -0.017918512225151062, -0.029997242614626884, -0.005250668618828058, -0.033019356429576874, 0.02155393362045288, -0.008467602543532848, -0.03248739615082741, 0.05399307981133461, 0.03738336265087128, -0.021906375885009766, -0.035998426377773285, -0.030334509909152985, -0.018951117992401123, 0.036140404641628265, -0.03993029147386551, 0.025812922045588493, 0.04110756888985634, 0.002725962782278657, 0.038078829646110535, 0.03613913431763649, -0.007733705919235945, -0.010365359485149384, 0.05104416608810425, -0.03971744328737259, 0.004568832460790873, -0.011601286008954048, 0.012800599448382854, -0.06421776115894318, -0.009942335076630116, 0.038799431174993515, 0.009899024851620197, 0.018617728725075722, -0.030511828139424324, 0.010087292641401291, -0.014194251038134098, -0.06379112601280212, -0.03476261347532272, 0.02622302994132042, 0.047819264233112335, 0.002397430595010519, -0.024983501061797142, -0.026644032448530197, -0.00029241162701509893, 0.0053807590156793594, 0.015990497544407845, -0.03228023648262024, -0.029225289821624756, -0.007896794937551022, 0.006002900656312704, 0.01811840385198593, -0.07127907127141953, 0.0009484167094342411, 0.026824023574590683, 0.003911752253770828, -0.03380564972758293, -0.022413937374949455, -0.04312896355986595, 0.031201882287859917, 0.018163489177823067, -0.015956800431013107, 0.01943308860063553, -0.045149002224206924, 0.020194265991449356, 0.012790475971996784, 0.034398067742586136, -0.009520757012069225, 0.058813128620386124, -0.026181358844041824, 0.01088622584939003, 0.010508766397833824, -0.06390763074159622, -0.01858494058251381, 0.031365495175123215, 0.02042502537369728, -0.024699188768863678, -0.019821908324956894, 0.008846316486597061, -0.007473073899745941, -0.042054079473018646, 0.014880446717143059, 0.03131922706961632, 0.03334662318229675, 0.017147734761238098, 0.011827348731458187, -0.0053208670578897, 0.031066900119185448, 0.014418937265872955, 0.029133394360542297, -0.024960678070783615, 0.007756291888654232, -0.02380591817200184, -0.03751373291015625, -0.030957020819187164, -0.02298767678439617, -0.01806596852838993, -0.008293470367789268, -0.007464468013495207, -0.004059074446558952, -0.007606110535562038, -0.0262737013399601, -0.008534569293260574, 0.001056057051755488, -0.009827806614339352, -0.05612139031291008, 0.0020636406261473894, 0.005421569105237722, -0.014018755406141281, 0.013361076824367046, 0.003370530903339386, -0.014184100553393364, -0.0336829237639904, -0.01823613978922367, 0.03601519763469696, -0.05527608096599579, -0.021767180413007736, -0.032381463795900345, 0.014105089008808136, -0.022379137575626373, 0.03975532203912735, -0.06169348210096359, 0.05291319638490677, -0.03143157437443733, -0.010816575028002262, -0.043441660702228546, -0.04864264279603958, -0.010115914046764374, -0.00823032297194004, -0.033420130610466, 0.021634185686707497, 0.051456842571496964, -0.018726173788309097, 0.08058128505945206, 0.018426746129989624, -0.011320732533931732, -0.005141631234437227, 0.09452001005411148, 0.022260453552007675, -0.03862205147743225, 0.0063767521642148495, 0.0010295709362253547, -0.0030109956860542297, 0.03239171579480171, 0.02145465463399887, 0.010014583356678486, 0.08427062630653381, 0.056462835520505905, 0.02733861282467842, -0.024477509781718254, -0.05200636014342308, -0.029738837853074074, 0.05022876337170601, 0.011704886332154274, -0.05403527244925499, -0.01039178017526865, -0.014814253896474838 ]
<p>Forgetting Hooke's law for a minute why, from a microscopic perspective (preferably quantum) on up to a macroscopic one, does a spring under tension exert a force?</p> <p>I was thinking that there might be an analogy between the high and low pressure states of an air wave and the density of the mass distribution of the compressed and stretched states of an iron spring, but I don't know nearly enough about solid state physics to even guess.</p>
g4198
[ 0.03915301710367203, 0.017422042787075043, 0.020739750936627388, 0.0567924864590168, 0.05520773306488991, 0.00847327709197998, 0.008356114849448204, 0.008761869743466377, -0.019014297053217888, -0.08520057052373886, -0.05419158563017845, -0.03679506108164787, -0.010230652056634426, -0.012934665195643902, 0.04384332150220871, 0.0397978201508522, 0.0399254746735096, 0.005873251240700483, 0.04120173305273056, -0.02843504399061203, 0.0011037143412977457, 0.009365486912429333, -0.003472069278359413, -0.016510898247361183, 0.0019064868101850152, 0.04171714931726456, 0.007206492591649294, -0.0368635468184948, -0.036539144814014435, -0.05343160778284073, 0.060615457594394684, -0.014112203381955624, 0.025139713659882545, -0.06301433593034744, -0.00849165953695774, 0.027309192344546318, -0.014642277732491493, 0.004957027733325958, 0.008668475784361362, -0.024318257346749306, -0.030678439885377884, -0.05990815535187721, -0.006588777992874384, -0.03828009217977524, -0.016528723761439323, 0.02390497550368309, -0.06297652423381805, -0.009471048600971699, -0.043879009783267975, -0.026514215394854546, 0.026194576174020767, 0.008440745994448662, 0.03603353723883629, 0.012235267087817192, 0.05874741077423096, 0.004159587435424328, 0.04702555760741234, -0.02687656693160534, 0.11765981465578079, 0.006471417378634214, -0.018829582259058952, 0.018142111599445343, 0.018023356795310974, -0.01656215637922287, 0.022132523357868195, 0.031186696141958237, -0.0276414193212986, -0.047075945883989334, 0.0791420042514801, 0.014950179494917393, -0.014196783304214478, -0.050003934651613235, -0.02172338217496872, -0.06566235423088074, -0.038083452731370926, 0.03490660339593887, 0.0029677501879632473, 0.028902893885970116, -0.0028039219323545694, -0.04952089115977287, 0.006763987708836794, -0.03713417425751686, 0.01507543120533228, -0.004325997084379196, 0.05430229753255844, -0.011239609681069851, 0.003657345427200198, 0.014802259393036366, 0.011901519261300564, 0.03743845596909523, 0.031129049137234688, 0.01005399040877819, 0.08943260461091995, 0.025803975760936737, -0.06295628845691681, -0.05640833079814911, 0.020009532570838928, 0.09347952902317047, 0.01026831939816475, 0.002697017742320895, -0.030284352600574493, -0.03346925973892212, -0.022575464099645615, -0.01270844042301178, -0.0379231795668602, 0.009976743720471859, -0.026736317202448845, 0.027887744829058647, -0.023779377341270447, 0.014522598125040531, -0.01162310317158699, 0.02733568660914898, 0.002753671258687973, 0.0036909463815391064, -0.022868864238262177, -0.02033267542719841, -0.014412520453333855, -0.04710664972662926, -0.001914403634145856, 0.029626403003931046, 0.010382771492004395, -0.022984618321061134, 0.03623257949948311, 0.005671490449458361, -0.01713341474533081, -0.07282750308513641, 0.022035276517271996, 0.02150971069931984, -0.009267031215131283, -0.06939882040023804, 0.010712605901062489, 0.021165434271097183, 0.004191878717392683, -0.011306182481348515, -0.014290439896285534, 0.015914330258965492, -0.03790413588285446, -0.024888306856155396, -0.009193293750286102, 0.0342237651348114, 0.02079703100025654, -0.015787554904818535, -0.005479501094669104, -0.013047367334365845, 0.01761806383728981, 0.041580844670534134, -0.03620219975709915, -0.0011045678984373808, 0.014800697565078735, 0.00956012960523367, 0.00025190465385094285, 0.015099960379302502, -0.0007983167888596654, -0.02325158752501011, 0.05624384433031082, 0.016168972477316856, 0.0322469100356102, -0.06145791336894035, -0.02488766983151436, 0.02716766856610775, 0.00498522724956274, -0.044386446475982666, -0.01947653852403164, 0.040290627628564835, -0.04575418308377266, -0.003699239809066057, -0.014096581377089024, -0.012035105377435684, 0.001691528712399304, -0.029392551630735397, -0.0437561497092247, -0.008621853776276112, -0.02275479957461357, 0.06614162027835846, 0.01733715832233429, 0.011828319169580936, 0.025999734178185463, -0.01544595044106245, 0.09277518093585968, -0.05197014659643173, 0.009637090377509594, -0.007800381630659103, -0.010233273729681969, -0.0064454753883183, 0.004197446629405022, 0.06636825948953629, 0.03563854843378067, 0.004647916182875633, -0.043339699506759644, -0.014645738527178764, -0.04883679002523422, -0.063992440700531, 0.004474430810660124, 0.07041704654693604, 0.017547011375427246, -0.06369810551404953, 0.038101162761449814, -0.025836560875177383, -0.05808106064796448, 0.06767404079437256, -0.0019421830074861646, 0.022075088694691658, 0.024045174941420555, -0.0011483592679724097, -0.003437146544456482, 0.046734511852264404, -0.023395666852593422, -0.016169067472219467, 0.013120515272021294, -0.005156131461262703, 0.012309231795370579, -0.014834359288215637, 0.019503023475408554, 0.01270386204123497, -0.03210928291082382, -0.012440009973943233, -0.004049679264426231, -0.03928406909108162, 0.04517081007361412, 0.057601843029260635, -0.026673704385757446, -0.0016948833363130689, 0.008022040128707886, -0.013106578961014748, -0.050720274448394775, -0.0030681032221764326, -0.016915321350097656, -0.01928657293319702, 0.012427161447703838, 0.002310096984729171, 0.008564742282032967, 0.00888791773468256, -0.009804734960198402, 0.015292263589799404, -0.0055581359192729, 0.10253827273845673, -0.020512690767645836, 0.0029395699966698885, -0.05230167880654335, -0.017069190740585327, 0.0023629674687981606, -0.0370047353208065, 0.005093337036669254, -0.07023601979017258, 0.0002746474929153919, 0.013650204986333847, -0.005841915495693684, 0.02641722932457924, 0.04867284372448921, 0.03836296498775482, 0.04719431698322296, -0.039866723120212555, -0.004223564639687538, 0.02899610623717308, 0.037055451422929764, -0.015371290035545826, -0.024563422426581383, -0.004989583510905504, -0.04056370630860329, -0.08609221130609512, -0.014349695295095444, -0.02767251990735531, 0.013052787631750107, 0.000938164594117552, -0.07330425828695297, -0.019759822636842728, -0.01370748970657587, -0.003564409911632538, 0.03423544764518738, 0.0033170015085488558, 0.020856793969869614, 0.08900357782840729, -0.056330353021621704, 0.003340003080666065, 0.013606362044811249, -0.08236932754516602, -0.025579489767551422, -0.008694582618772984, 0.02782777138054371, -0.008806256577372551, -0.00420402130112052, 0.045011237263679504, -0.04086361080408096, -0.0030763503164052963, 0.03368692100048065, -0.08663415908813477, 0.005561033263802528, 0.0006575353327207267, -0.043704308569431305, -0.03659309446811676, 0.039425525814294815, 0.049947332590818405, 0.047195520251989365, 0.03471685200929642, -0.04013101011514664, 0.0514642670750618, 0.009620608761906624, -0.056728966534137726, -0.04800904914736748, 0.06575608998537064, -0.030009344220161438, -0.09838616847991943, 0.04827835038304329, -0.001928382902406156, 0.010725424624979496, 0.05060835927724838, -0.014560126699507236, -0.02068822830915451, -0.0012146506924182177, 0.020279042422771454, 0.011561679653823376, 0.06142173334956169, 0.045746512711048126, -0.020569032058119774, -0.12354184687137604, -0.03431764990091324, -0.006566834636032581, 0.01847836934030056, 0.006753895431756973, -0.07953641563653946, 0.031055372208356857, -0.032263707369565964, 0.042850375175476074, -0.048272520303726196, 0.008659668266773224, 0.014101868495345116, -0.01439808402210474, 0.02977626398205757, -0.06553731113672256, -0.0739019438624382, -0.005909000989049673, -0.045272115617990494, -0.009451848454773426, -0.06069955229759216, -0.04385777562856674, -0.06562922149896622, -0.011075617745518684, 0.02409914880990982, 0.042675673961639404, 0.045914627611637115, -0.03089667297899723, 0.0036308991257101297, -0.02668820135295391, 0.006996867712587118, 0.03779935464262962, 0.05417725443840027, 0.016684552654623985, -0.01695825904607773, 0.0760471299290657, -0.009315178729593754, 0.02120187319815159, 0.01069669984281063, 0.013539392501115799, -0.014474472030997276, 0.007383770775049925, 0.014283524826169014, 0.07489114999771118, -0.040585752576589584, 0.005023757927119732, -0.004523695446550846, 0.028538862243294716, -0.021610384806990623, 0.0049442690797150135, -0.026228096336126328, -0.007303484715521336, -0.003409550990909338, -0.0015187114477157593, 0.07407592982053757, -0.052880968898534775, 0.015539524145424366, -0.002604723209515214, -0.04901745915412903, 0.027975240722298622, 0.0449196919798851, 0.04347274824976921, -0.04005992412567139, 0.03565433248877525, 0.011845552362501621, -0.018021898344159126, -0.019002974033355713, 0.060106061398983, 0.0775919035077095, 0.013677035458385944, 0.01103253848850727, -0.04311361536383629, -0.017597706988453865, -0.026571214199066162, 0.026831625029444695, 0.03601815551519394, -0.03991733863949776, 0.020141590386629105, -0.0946592390537262, -0.045746151357889175, 0.05943043529987335, 0.02106196992099285, -0.008305857889354229, 0.02112426981329918, -0.04949989169836044, -0.02804238721728325, -0.013067306950688362, 0.014586411416530609, 0.04168682545423508, -0.06830715388059616, 0.024877572432160378, -0.024727962911128998, 0.06471975147724152, 0.049720630049705505, -0.03504233807325363, 0.01341183576732874, -0.0345025360584259, 0.07202979922294617, -0.023111514747142792, -0.050844285637140274, -0.03572847694158554, 0.01001806277781725, -0.011942858807742596, 0.03974418342113495, 0.005259282886981964, -0.007745363283902407, 0.07460024207830429, 0.03550516813993454, 0.04032366722822189, 0.019890127703547478, 0.024144738912582397, -0.03755982965230942, 0.025479791685938835, 0.012224172241985798, 0.0094748018309474, 0.01493271254003048, -0.05482763424515724, -0.07288583368062973, -0.03132287412881851, 0.02195138856768608, -0.014664027839899063, -0.024793468415737152, 0.0486505962908268, -0.028621774166822433, 0.019854983314871788, -0.014499993994832039, 0.05628044903278351, -0.004353770054876804, 0.0259848702698946, 0.014977087266743183, 0.06711190193891525, 0.01262116152793169, -0.0010080949869006872, -0.02022026851773262, 0.02649284340441227, -0.06872490793466568, 0.003602961776778102, -0.041941557079553604, -0.06272341310977936, -0.020498938858509064, -0.05043237656354904, 0.0026455882471054792, -0.004115566145628691, -0.018740033730864525, 0.014093075878918171, 0.011867853812873363, 0.012419973500072956, -0.03163556009531021, 0.020834311842918396, -0.03217945992946625, 0.07671277225017548, -0.013824176974594593, -0.008537298999726772, -0.04807238653302193, -0.06012361869215965, -0.0014866954879835248, 0.01939227618277073, 0.050016872584819794, -0.00932277925312519, -0.008407209068536758, 0.05411549657583237, 0.08515368402004242, 0.021536456421017647, 0.05206393823027611, -0.01563708297908306, 0.014650639146566391, -0.01961708627641201, 0.0059652747586369514, 0.043284978717565536, 0.01935945823788643, 0.0021383254788815975, 0.0016627595759928226, 0.03086935542523861, 0.004409520421177149, 0.039281465113162994, -0.06652336567640305, -0.007971582934260368, 0.06886417418718338, 0.07122834026813507, -0.02089761756360531, 0.047421179711818695, 0.004272235091775656, -0.025225473567843437, -0.00007362090400420129, -0.01866888254880905, -0.02668585628271103, -0.04956015944480896, -0.0617525652050972, -0.04872236028313637, -0.008831149898469448, 0.07109258323907852, -0.040559250861406326, 0.03154779225587845, 0.014295289292931557, -0.0038186481688171625, 0.05292242392897606, 0.0274782944470644, -0.03265039622783661, 0.003906772937625647, -0.01710493490099907, 0.014154298231005669, 0.045077696442604065, 0.018849698826670647, -0.02478747069835663, -0.004343842156231403, -0.015456360764801502, -0.014142695814371109, 0.03188252076506615, 0.028301922604441643, 0.06558763980865479, -0.00029004100360907614, -0.007236876524984837, 0.06326297670602798, 0.00032734524575062096, -0.010652110911905766, -0.014623468741774559, 0.009373690001666546, -0.011503790505230427, 0.019347211346030235, 0.07434902340173721, -0.04564483091235161, 0.005440017208456993, -0.0117165083065629, -0.010490130633115768, 0.044835660606622696, -0.01585226133465767, 0.029617229476571083, -0.025720546022057533, -0.06540241837501526, 0.013883248902857304, 0.024460889399051666, 0.027672437950968742, -0.006242221686989069, -0.0011790568241849542, 0.004437552765011787, 0.05713021382689476, 0.03211615979671478, -0.03363243117928505, 0.034401752054691315, -0.0924353376030922, 0.03284917026758194, -0.006532718427479267, 0.06657033413648605, 0.017271028831601143, -0.07699619233608246, 0.022247428074479103, 0.01632128283381462, 0.055884700268507004, 0.10813712328672409, 0.05010225996375084, -0.012438181787729263, 0.05523238331079483, -0.01831796206533909, -0.07172542810440063, -0.026255959644913673, 0.09958377480506897, 0.01176049280911684, -0.0051407357677817345, 0.03943635895848274, 0.009346149861812592, 0.008426043204963207, 0.003091235877946019, 0.010700847953557968, -0.04555797204375267, -0.012301167473196983, -0.02071814239025116, 0.0069161104038357735, 0.020958324894309044, 0.006472528912127018, 0.03765461966395378, -0.00543464720249176, -0.0236378014087677, 0.0010777674615383148, -0.0028657549992203712, -0.03966740518808365, 0.10481961071491241, 0.004155921284109354, -0.01676267385482788, 0.011797909624874592, -0.03465407341718674, 0.03382707014679909, -0.0036896998062729836, 0.00928294938057661, 0.017449017614126205, 0.01076279953122139, 0.013413080014288425, 0.04022388160228729, 0.06453326344490051, 0.039302583783864975, 0.04195789247751236, -0.03579837828874588, 0.018697543069720268, -0.022510679438710213, 0.0000012742069657178945, -0.0050731501542031765, -0.018677426502108574, 0.01591445319354534, -0.06942842155694962, 0.047714706510305405, -0.042558521032333374, -0.04684801772236824, 0.004017516504973173, -0.02591986395418644, -0.000280161650152877, 0.03813327103853226, -0.04812939092516899, -0.031849540770053864, -0.001364423311315477, -0.03781464323401451, 0.041722219437360764, -0.05253027752041817, -0.01184327807277441, -0.03333847224712372, -0.056209273636341095, 0.019162030890583992, 0.01832127384841442, -0.011304222047328949, 0.03057146444916725, 0.02050740458071232, -0.01777891255915165, 0.02281830459833145, -0.030262796208262444, 0.08758489042520523, -0.011660593561828136, -0.046115487813949585, 0.07278873026371002, 0.03671874850988388, -0.048743221908807755, -0.027945851907134056, -0.008709659799933434, 0.008130431175231934, -0.03945349529385567, 0.007923570461571217, 0.02031620405614376, -0.03698994591832161, -0.05267513170838356, -0.026557207107543945, -0.029527176171541214, -0.039965298026800156, -0.039179205894470215, -0.02145151048898697, -0.02227882482111454, 0.007349424064159393, 0.0007393349660560489, -0.02383396588265896, 0.04557858780026436, -0.039771050214767456, -0.09430518001317978, 0.04370018094778061, 0.03764200955629349, 0.01457488164305687, 0.005981594789773226, 0.07508160173892975, 0.03118404746055603, -0.021845798939466476, -0.010899633169174194, -0.00960282888263464, 0.02051466517150402, -0.04313172399997711, 0.004294868092983961, -0.013676393777132034, 0.022741276770830154, 0.022199660539627075, -0.013071848079562187, 0.022853601723909378, 0.04443245753645897, -0.016087105497717857, -0.025537017732858658, 0.006556669715791941, -0.03949687257409096, -0.025638997554779053, -0.05166476219892502, 0.023107564076781273, 0.023477045819163322, 0.03068983554840088, -0.008483640849590302, -0.026496434584259987, -0.02848425880074501, -0.001927278470247984, -0.009510345757007599, -0.004063951317220926, 0.01684141531586647, 0.019272448495030403, 0.03319287300109863, -0.012507479637861252, 0.007125213276594877, -0.030900316312909126, -0.04553008824586868, 0.03425966948270798, -0.057350754737854004, -0.0001296322443522513, 0.045265212655067444, -0.0037634011823683977, -0.015717878937721252, -0.02163635566830635, -0.033168140798807144, -0.01132238283753395, 0.03442046046257019, -0.00908582005649805, 0.022499755024909973, 0.007104766555130482, 0.061896923929452896, -0.012865196913480759, 0.0277531910687685, -0.000015263871318893507, 0.04356187954545021, -0.0352533720433712, -0.005066861864179373, 0.006758649833500385, 0.025873683393001556, -0.044949911534786224, -0.006391401402652264, -0.025584353134036064, -0.017230119556188583, 0.014357488602399826, -0.01147386059165001, -0.0022874490823596716, -0.04767327010631561, -0.058463845402002335, 0.03647426515817642, -0.025808162987232208, -0.023840760812163353, 0.008171351626515388, 0.07358948886394501, 0.020857175812125206, 0.010005360469222069, -0.013504598289728165, -0.025008877739310265, -0.017533889040350914, 0.01508073415607214, -0.04602806270122528, 0.05084884166717529, -0.04551199823617935, -0.045814208686351776, 0.020466549322009087, 0.0515916608273983, -0.054460786283016205, 0.024075957015156746, -0.0019036979647353292, 0.014383196830749512, 0.008975150994956493, -0.050378601998090744, -0.06792841106653214, 0.02139119803905487, 0.04503447189927101, 0.05329976975917816, -0.0357707217335701, -0.04606322571635246, 0.02139388397336006, -0.00825927872210741, -0.031952064484357834, -0.030408503487706184, -0.05344192683696747, -0.014078211039304733, -0.015265515074133873 ]
<p>How much energy in form of heat does a human body emit at rest level?</p>
g4199
[ 0.0015768572920933366, 0.0038634086959064007, 0.010757033713161945, 0.020033644512295723, -0.07218538224697113, -0.013080734759569168, -0.01559457927942276, 0.03672077879309654, -0.02704298496246338, -0.03971092402935028, 0.0022184501867741346, 0.011810378171503544, -0.020171169191598892, -0.04045732691884041, 0.0206473208963871, -0.013971741311252117, 0.01580923981964588, -0.03872865438461304, 0.010137181729078293, 0.018274715170264244, -0.022570958361029625, -0.022809753194451332, 0.009402046911418438, -0.011110094375908375, -0.0332007072865963, -0.002525986172258854, -0.01357063464820385, 0.018445545807480812, -0.05444633215665817, -0.07301976531744003, 0.024575848132371902, 0.04169940948486328, 0.035265740007162094, -0.013180733658373356, -0.05030110478401184, 0.01493113674223423, 0.020952627062797546, 0.025711704045534134, -0.012891432270407677, 0.00448965560644865, -0.014526983723044395, -0.03651291877031326, 0.06191088631749153, 0.03020150028169155, -0.00593700772151351, 0.04947931692004204, 0.0029486077837646008, 0.04342563822865486, 0.010651471093297005, 0.052050087600946426, 0.024680865928530693, 0.0039972783997654915, 0.001049745362251997, -0.0299111045897007, 0.005562496371567249, -0.037903834134340286, -0.10331527888774872, -0.04286839812994003, -0.009048913605511189, 0.024481594562530518, 0.06270869821310043, -0.047709379345178604, 0.005704573821276426, -0.04323975369334221, 0.029166188091039658, 0.01682300679385662, -0.05351937562227249, 0.021097244694828987, 0.01431004423648119, 0.004243321716785431, 0.007844476029276848, -0.015334722585976124, -0.030737927183508873, -0.012729023583233356, -0.0842406153678894, -0.00828592199832201, 0.027835117653012276, -0.04871717095375061, -0.01057019829750061, -0.003190750954672694, -0.018649116158485413, -0.0009932422544807196, -0.015666915103793144, 0.012430215254426003, 0.04078914597630501, -0.020839042961597443, -0.028613608330488205, -0.016437966376543045, -0.0045347330160439014, 0.04545833170413971, 0.05111377686262131, 0.02457052282989025, 0.16214682161808014, 0.020102571696043015, 0.05418635532259941, 0.007826226763427258, -0.003633105428889394, 0.037588171660900116, -0.03834708780050278, -0.005885034333914518, -0.039124734699726105, -0.004920751787722111, -0.011465282179415226, 0.006625242996960878, -0.011067568324506283, -0.011035960167646408, -0.03856059908866882, -0.08152370899915695, -0.0023647944908589125, 0.03381969407200813, 0.04701657220721245, -0.034140605479478836, -0.009215565398335457, 0.026388976722955704, -0.04956793040037155, -0.032099563628435135, 0.0662091076374054, -0.045315857976675034, -0.025250768288969994, 0.035905756056308746, 0.024586159735918045, -0.009285359643399715, 0.01285376027226448, 0.014477979391813278, -0.03371760994195938, 0.016362043097615242, -0.009206799790263176, -0.03219354525208473, -0.019513890147209167, 0.019407518208026886, 0.019055591896176338, 0.00635872408747673, -0.06624151021242142, -0.005498101469129324, 0.06278304010629654, 0.034936048090457916, 0.021938756108283997, -0.009345483034849167, 0.004324803128838539, -0.0011428160360082984, 0.04046233743429184, 0.0018347256118431687, 0.01750366762280464, -0.05988086387515068, -0.034159786999225616, 0.036435484886169434, -0.0018887618789449334, -0.012853553518652916, 0.03370576724410057, 0.09042130410671234, -0.008325769565999508, 0.007840950973331928, 0.05212326720356941, -0.10402939468622208, 0.0056759691797196865, -0.05646444484591484, -0.039405565708875656, 0.009071235544979572, -0.03786357492208481, 0.048060473054647446, 0.005003183614462614, -0.0027579651214182377, 0.0756608322262764, 0.0010725107276812196, 0.011572100222110748, -0.02306670881807804, -0.04733807221055031, -0.02742302417755127, 0.03740214928984642, -0.020298855379223824, -0.013254659250378609, -0.03144489601254463, -0.06326508522033691, -0.030061645433306694, -0.06283587217330933, 0.0016453155549243093, 0.017422350123524666, -0.04138312116265297, 0.04829089716076851, -0.031707763671875, -0.007224455941468477, -0.013932092115283012, 0.0002962738217320293, -0.040118470788002014, -0.00523649575188756, 0.023810824379324913, -0.01746831275522709, -0.06185303255915642, -0.01262820977717638, 0.015848340466618538, -0.058439455926418304, -0.06957246363162994, -0.03390965983271599, -0.02652933821082115, 0.05614398419857025, 0.01733226515352726, 0.004047841764986515, -0.0034136795438826084, -0.006207210011780262, 0.050287287682294846, 0.03558559715747833, -0.02118930034339428, 0.000246647308813408, -0.0454353503882885, 0.012473191134631634, 0.01649611070752144, 0.01726992055773735, -0.021058939397335052, -0.022932715713977814, -0.059155941009521484, 0.0376560240983963, 0.011031871661543846, 0.04622235149145126, 0.02537395805120468, -0.013348638080060482, 0.01942271552979946, -0.04667834937572479, -0.03433266282081604, 0.017645588144659996, -0.03661656379699707, 0.029445389285683632, 0.06439398974180222, -0.04704129323363304, -0.0283140167593956, 0.006809787359088659, 0.019379684701561928, -0.08692226558923721, -0.04682526737451553, -0.02545435167849064, 0.01324276253581047, -0.03521840274333954, 0.024866336956620216, 0.03737957775592804, -0.03403304144740105, -0.026955651119351387, 0.017552310600876808, 0.021591847762465477, -0.018526775762438774, 0.03277507424354553, -0.030733756721019745, -0.028261356055736542, 0.01980264112353325, 0.025839006528258324, -0.016301658004522324, -0.006242704577744007, 0.045316074043512344, -0.01643703132867813, -0.05213429406285286, 0.008861894719302654, -0.006712497211992741, -0.0025578895583748817, -0.04126701503992081, 0.013496831059455872, 0.020262189209461212, -0.040773872286081314, -0.007834499701857567, -0.08130016922950745, 0.00427858205512166, -0.04683026671409607, -0.06948929280042648, -0.002128950320184231, -0.046967655420303345, -0.06769045442342758, 0.03350013867020607, -0.002328496426343918, -0.013878864236176014, 0.049300793558359146, -0.06034773215651512, 0.017620375379920006, -0.006726935040205717, 0.06895610690116882, 0.07945631444454193, -0.002261672867462039, 0.027259545400738716, -0.0013732833322137594, -0.023150291293859482, 0.004183536861091852, -0.006439562886953354, -0.009049038402736187, -0.03864564746618271, 0.0341913104057312, 0.00889707263559103, 0.001055321772582829, 0.05525617673993111, -0.03024785965681076, -0.07152874022722244, -0.036482278257608414, 0.030928978696465492, -0.006225761957466602, -0.04139614477753639, -0.018969375640153885, -0.0260176919400692, -0.02167079783976078, 0.03525637462735176, -0.028482863679528236, 0.019217180088162422, 0.07527253776788712, -0.015308327972888947, -0.004239604342728853, 0.026911627501249313, 0.024027172476053238, -0.04218379035592079, -0.03108840435743332, -0.020562341436743736, -0.0752498134970665, -0.01001010648906231, -0.026179801672697067, -0.07123931497335434, 0.07332105189561844, -0.007090351078659296, 0.01675884611904621, -0.060333725064992905, -0.004263729322701693, 0.07446350902318954, -0.011486588977277279, -0.0034186667762696743, -0.07028377801179886, -0.0463823638856411, 0.039053577929735184, -0.046161338686943054, 0.048174433410167694, -0.035138074308633804, 0.016987090930342674, -0.02090407907962799, -0.019629837945103645, -0.0012345227878540754, 0.030364399775862694, -0.028326256200671196, -0.04575362801551819, -0.02994268760085106, 0.02972586080431938, -0.022517383098602295, -0.06992686539888382, -0.00007418893801514059, 0.025610143318772316, 0.0020786751993000507, -0.0114148473367095, 0.007755056023597717, 0.08163832873106003, 0.06484530866146088, -0.007118908688426018, 0.00950124766677618, -0.004367434419691563, -0.02793305367231369, 0.04571659862995148, 0.01362489815801382, -0.06405830383300781, -0.048788245767354965, -0.03688344359397888, -0.025583768263459206, 0.02841799147427082, -0.039752911776304245, -0.011036870069801807, -0.03766561299562454, -0.027874279767274857, 0.012131552211940289, 0.010960006155073643, 0.022786954417824745, -0.037823278456926346, 0.023365426808595657, -0.00041779514867812395, -0.016723116859793663, 0.07026087492704391, 0.004646423738449812, 0.016380762681365013, -0.02261604182422161, -0.03409797325730324, 0.005944172386080027, 0.008267944678664207, -0.0018209839472547174, 0.01427119504660368, -0.04832421615719795, -0.045006781816482544, 0.011422382667660713, 0.026559900492429733, 0.047208499163389206, 0.032867979258298874, 0.0027388818562030792, -0.076101154088974, 0.032336827367544174, -0.04981448873877525, -0.044701047241687775, -0.009041765704751015, 0.004729478619992733, -0.019997602328658104, 0.041816338896751404, -0.028862595558166504, 0.018730666488409042, 0.054999180138111115, -0.04562580585479736, 0.012349230237305164, -0.08157268166542053, 0.0035461820662021637, 0.023619269952178, -0.026566876098513603, -0.029090935364365578, 0.0544985756278038, 0.028258008882403374, 0.02965071238577366, 0.06978117674589157, 0.03718728944659233, 0.048576656728982925, 0.019643621519207954, 0.0027197448071092367, 0.031622253358364105, 0.03926840424537659, 0.02469225786626339, -0.032790739089250565, -0.0021516031119972467, -0.009086143225431442, 0.00029542073025368154, 0.023256640881299973, 0.03626657649874687, -0.02161448448896408, 0.04867451637983322, -0.010327331721782684, -0.006658625323325396, -0.03745226189494133, 0.02190566435456276, 0.011450812220573425, -0.02294311486184597, -0.03729555383324623, -0.011784707196056843, 0.025615982711315155, -0.0021369499154388905, 0.08395814895629883, 0.027508025988936424, 0.017684035003185272, -0.015405646525323391, -0.019072530791163445, 0.001504350802861154, -0.009213095530867577, -0.01273777149617672, 0.003053923835977912, -0.06910835206508636, 0.029407033696770668, 0.023965388536453247, 0.007314746733754873, -0.03787825256586075, 0.008492897264659405, 0.04269951954483986, -0.00744478777050972, 0.05677642673254013, -0.004054605029523373, -0.040410902351140976, 0.014799180440604687, -0.0011350365821272135, -0.11659015715122223, -0.0006722718826495111, -0.01759670488536358, 0.0020584752783179283, -0.02850419655442238, -0.017919274047017097, 0.019587885588407516, -0.017365774139761925, 0.021778877824544907, -0.01769324019551277, -0.014682509936392307, 0.003094613319262862, 0.061423409730196, -0.04972720146179199, -0.047732964158058167, -0.007994476705789566, -0.013178649358451366, -0.016777075827121735, -0.0030094177927821875, 0.0076717110350728035, 0.05268162116408348, 0.04817667603492737, 0.04677509889006615, 0.02150834910571575, -0.010933807119727135, 0.037600696086883545, -0.028163649141788483, 0.0015470277285203338, 0.03539840131998062, 0.07631860673427582, -0.009921552613377571, -0.01821448840200901, -0.007748573552817106, 0.027846790850162506, 0.05000049248337746, -0.007692709565162659, 0.04156356304883957, 0.00844470877200365, 0.02385426126420498, -0.05876077339053154, 0.03781697899103165, 0.003756929188966751, 0.03194282203912735, -0.05242934450507164, 0.04510274529457092, 0.015431521460413933, 0.0036807444412261248, -0.017561225220561028, 0.10386469215154648, -0.06612732261419296, -0.056485339999198914, -0.038144927471876144, 0.04388502240180969, -0.03463613986968994, 0.05784503370523453, 0.012772688642144203, -0.03575395792722702, 0.017536841332912445, -0.004615606740117073, -0.01585051417350769, -0.036745913326740265, 0.015064994804561138, 0.027089642360806465, -0.005375556647777557, 0.0323558934032917, -0.033764492720365524, 0.017480185255408287, -0.05498611554503441, -0.024411991238594055, 0.0088049853220582, 0.03459782525897026, 0.03667919337749481, 0.015166706405580044, 0.06795835494995117, -0.03054186888039112, 0.0760662630200386, 0.07095314562320709, 0.031070372089743614, 0.026159297674894333, -0.02011125721037388, 0.003127403324469924, 0.01742050237953663, 0.05596938729286194, 0.01666724681854248, 0.045190975069999695, 0.00902862474322319, -0.010866313241422176, -0.04503539949655533, 0.014058442786335945, -0.028209488838911057, 0.013377598486840725, 0.005445037502795458, -0.015191598795354366, 0.005316704511642456, -0.012634801678359509, 0.005663596093654633, 0.003394537838175893, 0.03775538504123688, -0.038145340979099274, -0.055212873965501785, 0.000041931216401280835, -0.029400410130620003, 0.019729606807231903, 0.033044956624507904, 0.05559104308485985, 0.0719689279794693, 0.02297140471637249, 0.018951239064335823, -0.01773601584136486, 0.024863410741090775, 0.00025552450097166, 0.020107116550207138, -0.011527636088430882, 0.002470616716891527, 0.010471121408045292, 0.04680994525551796, 0.06794775277376175, 0.03242427110671997, -0.045160312205553055, -0.055415522307157516, -0.04629586264491081, -0.0005339269409887493, -0.023423241451382637, 0.06764557957649231, 0.021759463474154472, 0.030498070642352104, -0.04343801736831665, 0.030314069241285324, 0.04275590553879738, -0.02449376881122589, -0.03261585161089897, -0.054328855127096176, 0.004049583803862333, 0.01973717287182808, -0.02772911638021469, -0.014356168918311596, 0.024566615000367165, 0.03445388376712799, 0.03896922245621681, -0.02023174986243248, -0.0005103906732983887, -0.00969939399510622, 0.03438626974821091, 0.010155905038118362, -0.02308286912739277, -0.027824610471725464, 0.02742598205804825, -0.016067417338490486, -0.05389786884188652, -0.002505823038518429, -0.054024599492549896, -0.01449848897755146, 0.003757909405976534, 0.000003728490355570102, 0.0014553762739524245, -0.037906598299741745, -0.05623874440789223, 0.01949131302535534, -0.010178136639297009, 0.00010003351781051606, 0.03005310706794262, -0.020594725385308266, 0.03221909701824188, 0.00730743957683444, -0.02970883809030056, 0.03965165838599205, -0.017974311485886574, -0.009641087613999844, 0.0019058473408222198, -0.014804990962147713, 0.028185967355966568, 0.0336265042424202, -0.026196619495749474, -0.038297343999147415, -0.037031836807727814, 0.09171051532030106, -0.002865429501980543, 0.05884890258312225, 0.039367061108350754, -0.037356600165367126, 0.09721839427947998, 0.01630127616226673, 0.02862412855029106, -0.004847951233386993, 0.054434895515441895, 0.01486506313085556, 0.07587660849094391, -0.031257160007953644, -0.004147407133132219, -0.010033185593783855, -0.025271594524383545, 0.009232600219547749, 0.04186779260635376, -0.016330260783433914, 0.026100685819983482, 0.02739463560283184, -0.014195062220096588, -0.08181489259004593, 0.013584358617663383, 0.028112100437283516, 0.019223686307668686, -0.015867652371525764, 0.013715717941522598, 0.008919995278120041, -0.05274178087711334, -0.027674373239278793, 0.027103962376713753, -0.04017698019742966, 0.07290736585855484, -0.011823196895420551, 0.015645526349544525, -0.01305475551635027, -0.05762115865945816, 0.08142226189374924, 0.03072136640548706, 0.048161234706640244, 0.012531706131994724, -0.005735843442380428, 0.03395931050181389, 0.053957097232341766, -0.02737864851951599, 0.00032431987347081304, -0.0033429546747356653, 0.00682795187458396, -0.0894104465842247, -0.07843378931283951, -0.011460931040346622, -0.05706287547945976, 0.017496278509497643, 0.01427959743887186, 0.028015654534101486, 0.0318666435778141, -0.03012854792177677, -0.03551936894655228, -0.005381747614592314, -0.0013058168115094304, 0.034593574702739716, 0.032198309898376465, 0.0221325121819973, 0.04259056970477104, -0.04918553680181503, 0.0792711079120636, 0.087547667324543, -0.011011121794581413, 0.04606090486049652, -0.030506556853652, -0.008441472426056862, -0.03406497836112976, 0.019974155351519585, 0.02251838892698288, -0.02435312233865261, 0.06972602009773254, 0.004540648777037859, 0.032737839967012405, 0.01873846724629402, 0.06079442426562309, 0.025451259687542915, -0.014235792681574821, 0.04771436005830765, -0.00007231430208776146, 0.000004595030077325646, -0.021182110533118248, -0.0498812161386013, 0.0699695572257042, 0.002390896435827017, 0.038442324846982956, 0.08795835822820663, -0.026191042736172676, 0.02642167918384075, -0.04775408282876015, 0.0028398639988154173, 0.017566770315170288, -0.03787156566977501, -0.005941332783550024, -0.030353283509612083, -0.0032265870831906796, 0.03613555431365967, -0.015657678246498108, 0.0038734334520995617, 0.003991065081208944, -0.02521912008523941, 0.0581003800034523, -0.04507218301296234, 0.002037168014794588, 0.033054839819669724, 0.016939356923103333, -0.0158748347312212, 0.022548086941242218, -0.020107178017497063, 0.01842210441827774, 0.01295018382370472, 0.03621231019496918, -0.016817696392536163, -0.004813515581190586, -0.027721107006072998, 0.026829201728105545, -0.029149509966373444, 0.020457325503230095, -0.026408325880765915, -0.04144829139113426, 0.014744210056960583, 0.08252418041229248, 0.0015773214399814606, -0.005246127489954233, -0.022967912256717682, -0.06798502057790756, 0.025410743430256844, 0.0630379319190979, -0.01971256360411644, 0.0022177482023835182, 0.004112199880182743, -0.04822075366973877, 0.01089031994342804, -0.05528753623366356, -0.07995763421058655, 0.03436223790049553, -0.014562533237040043, 0.009331842884421349, -0.027192486450076103, 0.08607069402933121, -0.03197474777698517 ]
<p>As I understand it, black holes have an absolute event horizon and an apparent horizon specific an observer. In addition to black holes, an apparent horizon can come from any sustained acceleration. Firstly, there is the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Event_horizon">"particle horizon" of the universe</a>, which is the furthest co-moving distance from which light can reach us before the acceleration of the expansion of the universe prohibits it, then there is the case of a constantly accelerating observer in just regular flat space.</p> <p>My zeroth question is if the Hawking radiation from a black hole could be said to come from the apparent or absolute horizon - which is it? Obviously the former would be specific to each observer.</p> <p>For the case of the universal acceleration, dark energy, cosmological constant (please help me with terminology as appropriate): One could ask "do we observe radiation from the horizon?", for which we already have an available answer in the form of the cosmic microwave background (CMB). But I am curious if this would match the temperature and intensity you would expect if you treated the edge of the universe as a black hole horizon. Are these two be equivocal in some sense?</p> <p>Finally, I'm most interested to ask what would occur for the case of a constantly accelerating observer. An apparent horizon exists behind the observer beyond which light may never reach. Could it be possible the Hawking radiation is observed as coming from behind?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/IJRj1.png" alt="Accelerating Observer"></p> <p><strong>Could P possibly observe Hawking radiation coming from behind?</strong></p> <p>Granted, if you took the simple version of the temperature of the Hawking radiation ($T = \frac{\hbar c^3}{8 \pi G M k_B}$) and plugged in some super large mass, you will correspondingly get some super small temperature which will not agree with the 2.7 K of the CMB. Of course, the two cases I'm discussing do not have any definable mass that can be used. I would imagine that in the case of a simply accelerating particle, a greater acceleration would correspond with greater Hawking radiation, which is why it's not an issue for normal stuff, but if we accelerated something small with great force, could it observe radiation from that (false) event horizon?</p>
g4200
[ 0.018730487674474716, 0.014292802661657333, 0.01726645417511463, -0.012408968061208725, -0.01346807461231947, 0.013353222981095314, 0.014765462838113308, 0.09068838506937027, -0.03568169102072716, 0.008111412636935711, 0.040504079312086105, 0.044749315828084946, 0.0006553548737429082, 0.045750830322504044, 0.013070302084088326, -0.011289883404970169, -0.022405782714486122, -0.05008728802204132, -0.014518562704324722, -0.016756583005189896, 0.0161503367125988, 0.005747476126998663, 0.04048643261194229, -0.0244305282831192, -0.04825126379728317, -0.03301288187503815, -0.02835417352616787, -0.019996270537376404, -0.04775651916861534, -0.06427529454231262, 0.03832539543509483, -0.028286447748541832, 0.02166340872645378, 0.014571722596883774, 0.04198233783245087, 0.011753321625292301, 0.03935592621564865, 0.05379583314061165, -0.034918151795864105, 0.027735812589526176, -0.00760984979569912, -0.02425292320549488, 0.00766490725800395, -0.020201342180371284, 0.004106672015041113, 0.033088017255067825, -0.003962166141718626, 0.03849569335579872, 0.044562481343746185, -0.008874554187059402, -0.032432518899440765, -0.006462790537625551, 0.049358200281858444, 0.05198873579502106, 0.01813962496817112, 0.07317295670509338, -0.025356817990541458, -0.005647885613143444, 0.06296713650226593, 0.02785567194223404, -0.009277425706386566, -0.02515356056392193, 0.04027950018644333, -0.027714192867279053, 0.061850663274526596, 0.043189648538827896, -0.014828690327703953, 0.01698417402803898, -0.045800644904375076, -0.002760314615443349, 0.012481676414608955, -0.028700893744826317, -0.08152309060096741, -0.008049305528402328, 0.017442915588617325, 0.01563297025859356, -0.033169154077768326, -0.0167759507894516, 0.013857045210897923, 0.006005324888974428, -0.049395352602005005, -0.013519300147891045, 0.021127182990312576, -0.016256408765912056, 0.11410202831029892, 0.036487746983766556, 0.0051776450127363205, -0.012791165150702, 0.018420303240418434, -0.02527475543320179, 0.058641526848077774, 0.028140049427747726, 0.04552503302693367, 0.03058452345430851, 0.00038571649929508567, 0.022748004645109177, -0.03146560490131378, 0.06770557165145874, -0.006191916763782501, 0.03473339602351189, -0.03958216309547424, 0.025349458679556847, 0.04672833904623985, 0.0066644311882555485, 0.01659473031759262, -0.04616159200668335, -0.025634566321969032, -0.011119971983134747, 0.038099776953458786, 0.025181477889418602, -0.03450508043169975, -0.06264270097017288, -0.03064178302884102, -0.028908193111419678, -0.08193939924240112, -0.04249852895736694, 0.015678206458687782, 0.02522028051316738, -0.03461108356714249, 0.06329632550477982, 0.014281153678894043, 0.07553025335073471, -0.017224067822098732, 0.06595960259437561, -0.006509392522275448, -0.049901701509952545, -0.001915016327984631, -0.04827013611793518, -0.0007518107886426151, -0.013286500237882137, 0.0006424128077924252, 0.008504349738359451, -0.0053683375008404255, 0.059838082641363144, -0.03654518350958824, -0.004014160018414259, 0.024496370926499367, 0.028561070561408997, 0.020340828225016594, 0.052196208387613297, -0.0347735658288002, -0.06458929926156998, -0.013552597723901272, -0.010559290647506714, -0.04373328760266304, 0.0523749403655529, -0.028890663757920265, 0.004813377279788256, 0.04975089430809021, 0.06435342133045197, 0.011045494116842747, 0.10367151349782944, -0.05790720507502556, 0.013296269811689854, -0.0033016842789947987, 0.03543349727988243, 0.0027156539727002382, -0.020503580570220947, 0.003959099296480417, 0.07592348009347916, 0.07137143611907959, -0.01651475392282009, 0.028378475457429886, 0.0015049035428091884, -0.04474366083741188, -0.043615035712718964, -0.0006014151149429381, -0.043918177485466, 0.06655942648649216, 0.0018691617297008634, -0.024221017956733704, 0.04143206775188446, 0.012503775767982006, 0.0256964061409235, -0.028676362708210945, -0.021050037816166878, 0.07849273085594177, 0.016054324805736542, -0.016678623855113983, -0.023034092038869858, -0.05690906196832657, -0.03406074643135071, 0.0011433962499722838, -0.041069239377975464, 0.013637501746416092, -0.04171200096607208, -0.004119287710636854, -0.0005858554504811764, 0.04918527975678444, 0.05672905594110489, -0.006673736032098532, -0.06986849755048752, 0.06482284516096115, 0.06204492598772049, -0.010629740543663502, -0.010328653268516064, 0.007969187572598457, -0.0381443090736866, 0.03231477364897728, -0.024962788447737694, 0.03285163640975952, 0.05094878748059273, -0.056468524038791656, 0.0030796907376497984, 0.054211776703596115, 0.02329464629292488, 0.047381941229104996, -0.046521157026290894, -0.029471082612872124, -0.021137455478310585, 0.012251398526132107, -0.008964854292571545, 0.024598240852355957, 0.04761816933751106, -0.002136494731530547, 0.010768038220703602, -0.04680918902158737, 0.009647708386182785, 0.03644723445177078, 0.0036544243339449167, -0.021078458055853844, 0.01646534912288189, -0.017067233100533485, -0.006500014569610357, -0.07899046689271927, 0.057234760373830795, -0.060077834874391556, -0.05533759668469429, 0.021003616973757744, 0.061693258583545685, -0.08706656098365784, 0.01693904958665371, 0.03327007591724396, 0.025128955021500587, 0.051071200519800186, -0.03333790600299835, -0.017660079523921013, 0.01724116876721382, 0.026362448930740356, 0.040370792150497437, -0.007109304890036583, -0.031090669333934784, -0.09277747571468353, 0.006476866081357002, 0.055575549602508545, -0.042905256152153015, 0.04750236123800278, 0.005587481427937746, 0.02506887912750244, -0.018872451037168503, 0.0013622120022773743, -0.0008908038726076484, 0.02566448412835598, 0.004616816062480211, 0.006873941980302334, -0.01212142501026392, -0.008015606552362442, 0.026758156716823578, -0.06558235734701157, -0.013899395242333412, 0.02873627468943596, 0.004452360328286886, 0.00518776522949338, 0.05249086767435074, -0.05346405506134033, 0.013892960734665394, -0.03769615292549133, 0.010896049439907074, -0.05942624807357788, -0.01164223812520504, 0.010543555952608585, 0.003148592310026288, -0.009882984682917595, 0.04223230853676796, -0.03639195114374161, 0.06779338419437408, 0.004775789566338062, -0.004617978353053331, 0.01521787978708744, 0.0029023191891610622, -0.00983024388551712, 0.010371381416916847, -0.03208281099796295, 0.007190786302089691, -0.005299532786011696, -0.08581800758838654, -0.003647045698016882, -0.01979522779583931, 0.013902046717703342, -0.0320117361843586, -0.02727346308529377, -0.009129454381763935, 0.060252100229263306, 0.06307930499315262, -0.029484499245882034, 0.02276301570236683, -0.02450598031282425, 0.021518073976039886, 0.004931518342345953, 0.015570558607578278, 0.03851151838898659, -0.08436266332864761, -0.026720240712165833, 0.01163256261497736, 0.0046960534527897835, 0.008368100970983505, -0.015564335510134697, -0.04526781663298607, 0.043058719485998154, -0.03273409977555275, -0.029860490933060646, -0.011631865054368973, -0.04016357287764549, 0.056564681231975555, 0.026373133063316345, 0.02337748557329178, -0.03554777055978775, -0.009261989034712315, -0.01564158871769905, -0.011030144989490509, 0.022588688880205154, 0.03774961456656456, -0.024978989735245705, 0.007145303767174482, 0.05913209170103073, 0.040303390473127365, 0.034025974571704865, -0.027267232537269592, -0.03185613825917244, -0.015114950947463512, -0.010295646265149117, -0.018283702433109283, -0.012342735193669796, 0.04633545130491257, 0.0001478143676649779, -0.0482933446764946, -0.049812257289886475, 0.020253557711839676, 0.04149836674332619, 0.008600172586739063, 0.09781516343355179, -0.009652462787926197, -0.0596390925347805, 0.02866685576736927, 0.015585504472255707, 0.03838500753045082, 0.042614683508872986, -0.07916251569986343, -0.019613005220890045, -0.033569954335689545, 0.026896601542830467, -0.04014348238706589, 0.027411408722400665, 0.0076676830649375916, 0.0020544533617794514, -0.009425101801753044, 0.018573977053165436, 0.015753738582134247, 0.04347652941942215, -0.05659545585513115, -0.008829577825963497, -0.03571825101971626, 0.011645949445664883, -0.0315522626042366, 0.0048229587264359, -0.07213069498538971, -0.00894460454583168, -0.00457304110750556, 0.045021943747997284, -0.03816448152065277, 0.024390770122408867, -0.01911701075732708, -0.031907547265291214, -0.0548652783036232, 0.018463796004652977, -0.01729491353034973, 0.023898892104625702, 0.023247171193361282, -0.021886000409722328, -0.012517336755990982, -0.021998070180416107, 0.03084995225071907, 0.010635505430400372, 0.053293827921152115, -0.014513187110424042, -0.02418476715683937, -0.022193148732185364, -0.04816571995615959, -0.046544257551431656, -0.08136624842882156, 0.033353012055158615, -0.07086589932441711, 0.0154148293659091, -0.060535747557878494, -0.004105160478502512, -0.015681665390729904, 0.015697896480560303, 0.021257976070046425, 0.07357000559568405, 0.026974933221936226, 0.028877774253487587, 0.018354719504714012, 0.051690638065338135, 0.04540363699197769, -0.004946066997945309, 0.019838590174913406, 0.0044308374635875225, 0.00302993250079453, -0.037745337933301926, 0.006931120064109564, 0.04188269004225731, -0.012535645626485348, -0.015632599592208862, -0.011128067038953304, 0.018160097301006317, -0.04138554260134697, 0.039545029401779175, -0.04097342491149902, 0.014002710580825806, 0.001641232636757195, 0.014417425729334354, -0.003985647577792406, -0.007814827375113964, 0.0003442795423325151, -0.0345052033662796, 0.053869977593421936, -0.02792930044233799, -0.0007979209767654538, -0.06267087161540985, 0.030499914661049843, 0.024460406973958015, 0.0022086871322244406, -0.014765365049242973, 0.0417153500020504, -0.03240205720067024, 0.06414829194545746, -0.03471863269805908, 0.050320662558078766, 0.017740651965141296, 0.0029438110068440437, 0.03127795085310936, 0.006581841502338648, 0.028261957690119743, -0.032879073172807693, 0.003949122037738562, 0.08215434849262238, 0.007856636308133602, -0.009762082248926163, -0.02056027203798294, 0.014293075539171696, -0.0064373016357421875, 0.0036797288339585066, -0.013121000491082668, -0.04976706951856613, 0.024966510012745857, -0.025549868121743202, -0.032347422093153, 0.0367203988134861, -0.021495843306183815, -0.026074223220348358, -0.016644684597849846, -0.027920657768845558, 0.047511614859104156, 0.010353723540902138, 0.015892373397946358, -0.02196088805794716, -0.07651940733194351, 0.01181753072887659, -0.039535388350486755, 0.0133607666939497, -0.05901413410902023, 0.04458265006542206, 0.012515466660261154, 0.00007101232768036425, -0.046012066304683685, 0.03755847364664078, -0.033811282366514206, -0.021012909710407257, 0.022040771320462227, 0.009164242073893547, -0.011607513763010502, 0.007458811160176992, 0.009186849929392338, -0.049659453332424164, -0.02167210541665554, 0.08454146981239319, -0.013233587145805359, 0.028566909953951836, 0.03950164094567299, -0.00876222737133503, -0.0012554461136460304, -0.06272086501121521, 0.03439170494675636, 0.018429363146424294, -0.01310022734105587, -0.017083633691072464, -0.016043810173869133, -0.028889918699860573, 0.04366603121161461, 0.01702818274497986, -0.05514446273446083, -0.012388388626277447, 0.01074557937681675, 0.003991879988461733, 0.007066083140671253, 0.07315391302108765, 0.05663226544857025, -0.032950714230537415, 0.04350053146481514, 0.04740952327847481, -0.0587574765086174, 0.03319768235087395, -0.018167242407798767, -0.01793811097741127, 0.010817787609994411, -0.030043968930840492, -0.020281119272112846, -0.032095152884721756, -0.014291848056018353, -0.03373405709862709, 0.01871982403099537, 0.07494298368692398, 0.02680302783846855, 0.011510059237480164, 0.034338124096393585, -0.026503078639507294, 0.02350681833922863, 0.05216418579220772, -0.000502097827848047, 0.003268155734986067, 0.04860056936740875, 0.05647796019911766, -0.021796036511659622, -0.024855196475982666, 0.038491010665893555, 0.016447247937321663, 0.0020676597487181425, -0.014545902609825134, 0.028435571119189262, -0.008648466318845749, -0.03653687238693237, -0.06176070123910904, 0.02957182191312313, 0.06438549607992172, 0.007431535981595516, -0.00238593015819788, -0.0369122289121151, 0.04012034088373184, 0.0059887426905334, -0.046333979815244675, -0.03428893908858299, 0.016602136194705963, 0.0018558352021500468, 0.0235099159181118, -0.004386821761727333, 0.07314833253622055, 0.029717113822698593, 0.004586008843034506, -0.03013770654797554, -0.10978228598833084, 0.01993636228144169, -0.0012605155352503061, 0.0012181672500446439, -0.0560128316283226, -0.019308345392346382, 0.02735641784965992, 0.020716605708003044, -0.08136667311191559, 0.0517856664955616, 0.013040770776569843, -0.007923005148768425, -0.02311203069984913, 0.013760005123913288, 0.004547498654574156, 0.009514601901173592, -0.017956942319869995, -0.015801573172211647, 0.01732814870774746, -0.04606698453426361, 0.035381998866796494, -0.02564629167318344, -0.015501891262829304, 0.05666019767522812, -0.06962542980909348, 0.007416372653096914, -0.020255770534276962, -0.08747189491987228, 0.0439160130918026, 0.03924628719687462, -0.011717320419847965, -0.023633956909179688, -0.0380534827709198, 0.010140085592865944, -0.03987997770309448, -0.10251494497060776, -0.06120108813047409, 0.004448144696652889, -0.0754789188504219, -0.06624265015125275, -0.029138216748833656, -0.006838938221335411, -0.05268752947449684, 0.030766479671001434, -0.004028000868856907, 0.04957780987024307, -0.027723802253603935, -0.03455308452248573, 0.009669851511716843, 0.06683961302042007, -0.013107731007039547, -0.015699824318289757, -0.005274173803627491, 0.025925278663635254, 0.028898073360323906, -0.05146978795528412, 0.0386318676173687, -0.05202419310808182, -0.06106635928153992, -0.009421303868293762, -0.05570993945002556, 0.03792228177189827, -0.012896308675408363, -0.047832220792770386, -0.0044022598303854465, 0.01861548237502575, 0.025309422984719276, -0.04048476740717888, 0.0316329263150692, 0.04677058383822441, 0.0336177721619606, 0.05482872575521469, 0.03849150985479355, -0.017648907378315926, -0.0057356390170753, 0.049862541258335114, 0.04763295501470566, 0.009946209378540516, 0.021487794816493988, -0.04704499617218971, -0.03754348307847977, 0.02212538942694664, 0.016665518283843994, 0.0009592245332896709, -0.009779364801943302, -0.03399653732776642, -0.04023082181811333, 0.03531690686941147, 0.03937911614775658, -0.047042228281497955, 0.016309108585119247, -0.013901197351515293, -0.10685738176107407, -0.010029428638517857, -0.0018146263901144266, 0.017716219648718834, 0.004425030201673508, -0.020587585866451263, -0.026229122653603554, 0.008927387185394764, -0.039654891937971115, 0.06711308658123016, 0.01761014759540558, -0.04150493070483208, -0.018453998491168022, -0.014954827725887299, 0.0039939493872225285, 0.03410724550485611, -0.014912287704646587, -0.058315254747867584, 0.014131135307252407, 0.03221460431814194, -0.05957610532641411, -0.05588478595018387, -0.038706809282302856, 0.017555082216858864, -0.08121608942747116, -0.1009020209312439, 0.07438325136899948, 0.012269869446754456, 0.0037607925478368998, 0.002091649454087019, 0.0772632583975792, 0.0133757209405303, 0.03637484088540077, 0.003156049409881234, 0.027063721790909767, -0.02394961193203926, -0.012449058704078197, -0.0016594402259215713, -0.027431994676589966, -0.07572362571954727, 0.013040085323154926, -0.005904515273869038, -0.07288980484008789, 0.0035142567940056324, -0.004057140089571476, 0.03801781311631203, 0.03806425258517265, -0.0025946428067982197, -0.0072962879203259945, -0.004720583558082581, -0.010694140568375587, -0.01243553776293993, 0.022758159786462784, 0.003921660128980875, 0.05279610678553581, 0.00904790498316288, -0.0396859236061573, -0.04825405031442642, 0.040698423981666565, 0.023302176967263222, 0.03689881041646004, 0.015659457072615623, -0.027973664924502373, -0.016258832067251205, -0.054127179086208344, -0.010734816081821918, -0.03097735345363617, 0.008116177283227444, -0.05102517455816269, 0.016214244067668915, 0.03546251356601715, 0.015508401207625866, -0.010601312853395939, 0.03456779941916466, -0.003764425404369831, -0.02937575802206993, -0.03319307416677475, 0.003370937891304493, 0.0164197850972414, 0.01532958447933197, 0.015672799199819565, -0.014887593686580658, 0.02613716572523117, -0.05658445507287979, -0.010506183840334415, 0.04857958108186722, 0.0579758919775486, -0.0037112082354724407, 0.031109414994716644, -0.001902246382087469, -0.02817503735423088, 0.013744384981691837, -0.008229797706007957, 0.0031723997090011835, 0.03692292794585228, 0.020284898579120636, -0.010766901075839996, 0.05488348752260208, -0.01280477549880743, -0.005223957356065512, 0.025507207959890366, -0.04875264689326286, -0.0004590628086589277, 0.018762843683362007, -0.06200646236538887, -0.022874632850289345, -0.00024029107589740306, -0.0460151769220829, 0.06863141059875488, -0.0178076084703207, -0.013783174566924572, -0.04881463944911957, -0.06790250539779663, -0.02003166824579239, 0.024555686861276627, 0.008954365737736225, -0.02845192141830921 ]
<p>Recently, I read about dipole and multipole bound anions. Dipole bound anions are those, if I understood correctly, when an electron is attached electrostatically on a neutral molecule which is polar. If the molecule is having a quadrupole moment, the anion is said to be a quadrupole bound anion. These bound electrons will have less binding energy compared to the electrons in molecular orbital. My question is, these dipole, quadrupole and other multipole bound electrons behave like normal electrons in orbitals except that it has less binding energy or different? </p> <p>To be more clear, do these electrons have specific orbitals with orbital angular momentum or not? </p> <p>If so, are these orbitals like normal molecular orbitals (S P D F)? </p> <p>Can we assign electronic states to these electrons?</p> <p>Also, is it possible to excite any electron in the molecule (say valance electron) to this bound state (dipole or any multipole bound state)?</p>
g4201
[ -0.027507897466421127, -0.005065064411610365, 0.010201924480497837, -0.02083439566195011, 0.048373907804489136, -0.03157982602715492, -0.03197835758328438, 0.012897944077849388, 0.04639121890068054, 0.009433087892830372, -0.03417755290865898, -0.036267854273319244, 0.04658767208456993, -0.05576246976852417, 0.0037518893368542194, -0.04686998203396797, 0.00429152138531208, -0.013570363633334637, 0.06238583102822304, -0.04944092407822609, -0.0046974229626357555, 0.04249468073248863, -0.050588209182024, -0.011096927337348461, -0.03715162351727486, -0.007244568783789873, -0.038956545293331146, -0.022679010406136513, -0.03565875440835953, -0.03192022070288658, -0.05726395919919014, -0.012758370488882065, 0.03481444716453552, -0.019073408097028732, -0.031464867293834686, 0.0062083289958536625, 0.04369651526212692, 0.00877587590366602, 0.013506888411939144, -0.03506721556186676, -0.007861599326133728, -0.05068325623869896, -0.03258684277534485, 0.004481548443436623, 0.020306119695305824, 0.013279536738991737, -0.013579105027019978, 0.016962148249149323, 0.04430477321147919, -0.0044078039936721325, -0.03810708969831467, 0.06046634167432785, 0.01909054070711136, -0.05596378818154335, -0.04860319942235947, 0.006849914789199829, -0.03119143284857273, 0.015892844647169113, 0.001212592702358961, 0.038565244525671005, 0.04781157523393631, 0.04404587298631668, 0.03991938754916191, 0.0002674213610589504, 0.054939232766628265, -0.010598019696772099, -0.034645069390535355, 0.03227938339114189, -0.007426159456372261, 0.007937414571642876, 0.048606324940919876, -0.007823940366506577, -0.04535525664687157, -0.045216478407382965, -0.01344195194542408, 0.04249413311481476, 0.022235501557588577, -0.04770074412226677, 0.02562539093196392, 0.028498681262135506, -0.06974641233682632, 0.003779006889089942, 0.0022561722435057163, 0.009706610813736916, 0.10443660616874695, -0.021365296095609665, -0.024034541100263596, -0.018998680636286736, 0.00247778813354671, -0.006412905640900135, 0.055570658296346664, -0.02910522371530533, -0.0034188549034297466, 0.006834370084106922, -0.03401115536689758, 0.03873157873749733, -0.01446367334574461, 0.05778121575713158, 0.0034277881495654583, -0.08809872716665268, -0.024078985676169395, 0.0355074368417263, 0.04870804399251938, -0.00356043572537601, 0.016357623040676117, -0.02236424945294857, 0.003209712216630578, -0.02958093397319317, 0.051040031015872955, 0.04849744215607643, 0.006740656681358814, 0.01371543575078249, -0.006770790554583073, -0.0339343324303627, -0.043417301028966904, 0.01617998071014881, 0.01230959128588438, -0.10054158419370651, -0.00912220124155283, 0.07577305287122726, -0.0038892128504812717, 0.09475559741258621, 0.046422526240348816, 0.04693474993109703, 0.00898459181189537, -0.03967263549566269, 0.017157843336462975, 0.007430164143443108, 0.04155805706977844, -0.005662780720740557, -0.001994597725570202, -0.05454055964946747, -0.048916880041360855, 0.054986510425806046, -0.02994687482714653, -0.0162705946713686, -0.02102002501487732, -0.007393442559987307, 0.01134625542908907, -0.033982280641794205, 0.016566677019000053, 0.012311218306422234, 0.01053568534553051, -0.029238855466246605, -0.04219367727637291, -0.07983534038066864, 0.01691863313317299, -0.009443072602152824, 0.021086178719997406, 0.04506150633096695, 0.007753534242510796, -0.02678428217768669, 0.02977180853486061, -0.03830081969499588, -0.0011293771676719189, -0.0017024432308971882, 0.0180786345154047, 0.00005499252802110277, 0.019365327432751656, 0.0779443234205246, 0.035551562905311584, -0.016386421397328377, 0.011225896887481213, 0.018081804737448692, -0.04667061194777489, -0.02267668955028057, 0.032902929931879044, -0.026305019855499268, 0.028727788478136063, -0.028191566467285156, 0.025992924347519875, 0.003449047915637493, -0.019937224686145782, -0.005367779638618231, -0.037193458527326584, 0.003318207571282983, -0.029965639114379883, -0.030276009812951088, 0.022140681743621826, 0.030234208330512047, -0.04639735072851181, 0.0434359610080719, -0.028149673715233803, 0.0021468065679073334, 0.03865807130932808, -0.014628899283707142, -0.08153172582387924, 0.03705234080553055, -0.004703298211097717, 0.021318014711141586, -0.04766467958688736, 0.0319838672876358, 0.0737917423248291, -0.053422268480062485, -0.01969658024609089, -0.0408763587474823, -0.004821437876671553, -0.014592627063393593, 0.009631664492189884, 0.010652954690158367, -0.032665252685546875, -0.04242263734340668, -0.0290725976228714, 0.01865220256149769, 0.07622526586055756, -0.03461889922618866, 0.034009210765361786, 0.01171488594263792, 0.1077011302113533, -0.04362906515598297, 0.03454457223415375, 0.027822649106383324, -0.026711121201515198, 0.06137101724743843, -0.04302363470196724, -0.02823014184832573, 0.03910651057958603, 0.014891593717038631, -0.05495337024331093, -0.02466168999671936, -0.010781800374388695, -0.03371712565422058, 0.026150593534111977, 0.03619429096579552, 0.050632040947675705, -0.027674175798892975, -0.038885846734046936, 0.005531067959964275, 0.02887110225856304, 0.027623465284705162, -0.08558506518602371, 0.00990306492894888, -0.001003824407234788, -0.04108045622706413, 0.0017836297629401088, 0.03574512153863907, -0.01976211741566658, 0.015818139538168907, -0.02662055753171444, 0.00636600935831666, -0.046932652592659, 0.09664826840162277, 0.002945239655673504, 0.05275386571884155, -0.03546550124883652, 0.0216152835637331, 0.041042767465114594, -0.025637969374656677, -0.011173197999596596, 0.0866476446390152, 0.01151108555495739, -0.03028537705540657, 0.022522710263729095, 0.08580613881349564, -0.05696621164679527, 0.013337814249098301, -0.021346481516957283, -0.004285477567464113, -0.009194646030664444, -0.05368298292160034, -0.023489762097597122, 0.058809272944927216, 0.048280876129865646, 0.018097184598445892, -0.06377045810222626, -0.00763458339497447, -0.04867277666926384, -0.00826936587691307, -0.02072817273437977, 0.04210112616419792, -0.05733633041381836, 0.09943167120218277, -0.03278195112943649, 0.02223307266831398, -0.0016372577520087361, -0.05810302868485451, -0.034823864698410034, 0.00009602689533494413, -0.021279897540807724, -0.058811359107494354, -0.00107649399433285, 0.015618654899299145, -0.032436106353998184, 0.04212257266044617, -0.010152040980756283, -0.02175985276699066, -0.009528163820505142, -0.01608748361468315, -0.03525466099381447, -0.04453229531645775, -0.07678162306547165, 0.02400515228509903, 0.03656953573226929, -0.03970406949520111, -0.013891595415771008, -0.03463037684559822, 0.04589885100722313, -0.01961876079440117, -0.03569769114255905, 0.09187051653862, -0.029629964381456375, 0.03225003182888031, -0.04895428940653801, 0.0700266882777214, 0.03001004084944725, 0.07203689962625504, -0.020904624834656715, -0.012010108679533005, -0.010157383047044277, -0.027689451351761818, -0.024111371487379074, 0.007302477490156889, -0.05204172804951668, 0.038033898919820786, 0.0048313988372683525, -0.0245512668043375, -0.037385955452919006, -0.005139846354722977, 0.02293504774570465, -0.019579874351620674, -0.01783069781959057, -0.006844774819910526, -0.027370154857635498, 0.0058060516603291035, 0.018980786204338074, 0.04224235191941261, -0.05797966569662094, -0.029333511367440224, -0.025769904255867004, -0.018524833023548126, 0.038657184690237045, -0.00953865610063076, -0.009457994252443314, 0.021916450932621956, 0.0343296155333519, -0.0627678781747818, -0.026813047006726265, -0.011349895969033241, 0.030668307095766068, -0.04778842255473137, 0.0744861289858818, -0.044516656547784805, -0.07989198714494705, -0.036975495517253876, 0.002115299692377448, 0.006701419595628977, -0.038639746606349945, 0.011062449775636196, -0.02187792956829071, -0.029705416411161423, 0.0003329240716993809, 0.05178828909993172, 0.05338417738676071, 0.05520199239253998, 0.00024347919679712504, -0.0351836197078228, 0.0019369588699191809, 0.056264374405145645, -0.020289285108447075, 0.07350417226552963, 0.012222868390381336, -0.02538825385272503, 0.042328063398599625, 0.01992212049663067, -0.004325090907514095, -0.036156464368104935, -0.03529471158981323, 0.020436791703104973, 0.039100196212530136, -0.05366694927215576, 0.00009942500037141144, 0.04014913737773895, -0.005289341788738966, -0.04239516332745552, -0.005908368621021509, -0.01407567411661148, -0.04612698405981064, 0.004808017518371344, -0.040209606289863586, -0.015523478388786316, -0.019208695739507675, 0.040655896067619324, 0.032782044261693954, 0.06528614461421967, 0.058368898928165436, -0.035797908902168274, -0.037107814103364944, 0.0245747622102499, -0.003142210654914379, -0.022436294704675674, 0.0032125585712492466, -0.018824949860572815, 0.015898553654551506, 0.009820704348385334, 0.0025914052966982126, -0.030846096575260162, 0.030988657847046852, -0.07385149598121643, 0.03497009724378586, 0.05612931028008461, -0.01807507686316967, -0.005978185683488846, 0.010575964115560055, -0.06675100326538086, 0.051217660307884216, 0.052902866154909134, 0.03829389810562134, 0.04068287834525108, -0.06327418237924576, -0.0683557465672493, -0.009616219438612461, 0.04690632224082947, 0.03127666562795639, -0.006932369899004698, -0.048499204218387604, 0.042465873062610626, -0.002172931097447872, -0.012309574522078037, -0.060536954551935196, -0.0010663740104064345, 0.01845226064324379, 0.0659698024392128, -0.028900660574436188, 0.002830261131748557, -0.0066281710751354694, 0.08505560457706451, 0.027162274345755577, -0.02650648169219494, 0.007739654276520014, 0.013379821553826332, -0.005476081743836403, -0.0031356264371424913, -0.011886104941368103, -0.0069100093096494675, -0.045311275869607925, -0.01930445246398449, -0.05527409911155701, -0.016424495726823807, 0.03161947429180145, 0.06889956444501877, 0.08435869961977005, 0.0893012285232544, -0.006185065023601055, 0.013579154387116432, -0.020367050543427467, -0.02982044406235218, -0.016062520444393158, 0.026656286790966988, -0.014163026586174965, 0.004737750627100468, -0.016873056069016457, -0.042865753173828125, -0.012797563336789608, -0.054064374417066574, -0.019272319972515106, -0.07948524504899979, -0.033834267407655716, -0.02581559494137764, -0.014391656965017319, 0.0037903294432908297, -0.04016169160604477, -0.021740179508924484, 0.05949031561613083, -0.010003620758652687, 0.008163508027791977, -0.037331439554691315, -0.02983630634844303, -0.032232098281383514, -0.06589874625205994, -0.031174708157777786, 0.037285249680280685, -0.01496853120625019, -0.014993778429925442, -0.0026492741890251637, 0.001854823436588049, -0.05262446030974388, 0.010369213297963142, 0.013645974919199944, 0.009657150134444237, -0.0570673868060112, -0.011016572825610638, -0.05148300901055336, -0.024929923936724663, 0.06789930909872055, -0.00022420624736696482, -0.0075791263952851295, 0.03297337889671326, -0.021131036803126335, -0.01834820955991745, -0.05842631310224533, -0.0038777270819991827, 0.042129479348659515, 0.01545157190412283, -0.009981375187635422, 0.017963862046599388, 0.0560566745698452, -0.06172242388129234, 0.051919806748628616, -0.021633468568325043, 0.02498355321586132, 0.014625473879277706, 0.0254166629165411, -0.031204689294099808, -0.007088782265782356, 0.026819240301847458, 0.0986122339963913, 0.10884763300418854, -0.016213364899158478, 0.0553455576300621, -0.005090824328362942, -0.0071210358291864395, -0.005492699332535267, -0.050447072833776474, 0.007793579716235399, -0.03522779047489166, -0.0003469302610028535, -0.04096769914031029, 0.02861539088189602, 0.008941995911300182, -0.028800664469599724, -0.046648524701595306, -0.05379385128617287, 0.03493735194206238, -0.04865260049700737, 0.053659308701753616, -0.043353382498025894, 0.02815711684525013, 0.004171231295913458, 0.06790485978126526, 0.05823059007525444, 0.053494345396757126, -0.008076407946646214, 0.03523937985301018, 0.025051798671483994, 0.04679615795612335, -0.07579956948757172, -0.05302594229578972, -0.01632308028638363, 0.013033425435423851, 0.03812669962644577, 0.03611923009157181, -0.01967025361955166, 0.06524402648210526, 0.07136748731136322, 0.010569226928055286, -0.048864711076021194, -0.01482690405100584, 0.007736528757959604, 0.004242837429046631, 0.015551607124507427, -0.07366150617599487, 0.08477256447076797, -0.019838185980916023, -0.006881555076688528, 0.017164532095193863, 0.046863727271556854, -0.009764648042619228, 0.03735983744263649, -0.050000786781311035, 0.01104802917689085, 0.02669689804315567, 0.0023081067483872175, 0.056186601519584656, 0.04491030052304268, 0.07397971302270889, 0.005569937638938427, -0.02898833155632019, -0.07697180658578873, -0.018234597519040108, -0.0005429969169199467, -0.011706474237143993, 0.0058721317909657955, -0.010709796100854874, -0.02935633808374405, 0.03839246183633804, 0.0027380201499909163, 0.02550550550222397, 0.0774390920996666, 0.030872689560055733, -0.00947151891887188, -0.025793815031647682, 0.01824726164340973, 0.020681295543909073, -0.036369189620018005, -0.006888587027788162, 0.03391379117965698, -0.008285196498036385, 0.008359191007912159, 0.04723481461405754, -0.07097022235393524, -0.04740411043167114, 0.04745933413505554, 0.0026401591021567583, -0.03697603940963745, 0.0005004181293770671, 0.011658238247036934, 0.02172853983938694, -0.024070944637060165, -0.02709048055112362, 0.027257878333330154, 0.057769108563661575, 0.022127650678157806, -0.04908239096403122, -0.013896934688091278, 0.017499413341283798, 0.074031762778759, 0.030679378658533096, -0.009136579930782318, -0.04547813534736633, -0.03749353811144829, 0.005703040864318609, -0.023641550913453102, 0.01593249849975109, -0.017993150278925896, 0.010545163415372372, 0.007448041811585426, -0.030970701947808266, 0.011708086356520653, -0.004304120317101479, 0.01733684353530407, -0.06755233556032181, 0.0020648592617362738, -0.03491861745715141, 0.02361576445400715, 0.06102385371923447, 0.05184035375714302, -0.042065586894750595, 0.012612280435860157, -0.003835944226011634, 0.029351109638810158, -0.01266732532531023, -0.0008752277935855091, 0.0024483625311404467, 0.041336577385663986, 0.019770173355937004, 0.0022135318722575903, 0.003167076501995325, -0.00324701308272779, 0.04287995025515556, 0.01327599585056305, -0.04224619269371033, -0.06168023496866226, 0.030506061390042305, -0.03482061251997948, -0.012841845862567425, -0.012222920544445515, 0.009050470776855946, -0.013965984806418419, 0.03908299282193184, -0.024766623973846436, 0.0015207743272185326, -0.013355007395148277, 0.03702590987086296, 0.04772099480032921, -0.01076686941087246, -0.011081798002123833, 0.004221039358526468, 0.028827181085944176, 0.012953297235071659, 0.005097870249301195, -0.00026267478824593127, 0.05022173374891281, 0.032764580100774765, -0.004961242433637381, -0.012514238245785236, -0.002812932012602687, 0.008384606800973415, -0.01930932328104973, -0.012006690725684166, 0.012598801404237747, -0.008738229051232338, -0.0723530724644661, -0.024432947859168053, 0.038791995495557785, -0.03247619420289993, 0.03626280650496483, -0.03010469116270542, 0.009583123959600925, -0.014282163232564926, -0.035175129771232605, -0.007143593858927488, -0.012295777909457684, 0.06732981652021408, -0.005902472417801619, -0.02073053829371929, 0.003317971946671605, 0.00020607955229934305, 0.029156170785427094, -0.0007411056431010365, -0.03476130962371826, 0.060799431055784225, 0.005547518841922283, 0.04176003858447075, -0.026941906660795212, -0.027652708813548088, 0.016939900815486908, 0.016690535470843315, 0.01018456555902958, 0.022867126390337944, -0.019551971927285194, -0.04056907072663307, 0.001674599596299231, 0.01802412047982216, -0.035205673426389694, 0.025546684861183167, -0.013037624768912792, -0.024751752614974976, -0.02656487189233303, -0.04706811532378197, 0.0580935999751091, -0.0009568107780069113, 0.03804038465023041, 0.018805189058184624, 0.023185720667243004, 0.0023373719304800034, -0.026018839329481125, 0.005267874803394079, 0.09610994160175323, -0.01078618224710226, -0.024940887466073036, 0.012862536124885082, 0.012242022901773453, 0.0062883226200938225, 0.023127466440200806, -0.01213944610208273, 0.0034726166632026434, -0.037863586097955704, 0.026176514104008675, 0.036812711507081985, 0.03407062590122223, -0.030874792486429214, -0.0069818818010389805, -0.0468188114464283, 0.011899320408701897, 0.01020074263215065, 0.02388743869960308, 0.029475275427103043, -0.05385866016149521, 0.004355288110673428, 0.023442411795258522, -0.0006171647110022604, 0.030688591301441193, 0.015213743783533573, -0.025381900370121002, -0.007414032239466906, -0.018603848293423653, -0.020812295377254486, -0.008023876696825027, 0.02824021875858307, 0.018342941999435425, -0.04925801604986191, -0.060128144919872284, -0.021540937945246696, 0.02619599923491478, 0.007447909098118544, -0.0007294893148355186, -0.006677254103124142, 0.008131157606840134, 0.02952893078327179, 0.03460981696844101, -0.022258112207055092, 0.11663047224283218, 0.009634251706302166, 0.007337239570915699, -0.008162688463926315, -0.01955663040280342, -0.025501113384962082, -0.029508307576179504 ]
<p>This is probably a really silly confusion I have about the definition of “coordinate differentials”, which I thought were things like $dx,dy,dz$ etc. The Minkowski line element $$ds^{2}=c^{2}dt^{2}-dx^{2}-dy^{2}-dz^{2}$$ defines the Minkowski metric $$\left[\eta_{\mu\nu}\right]=\left(\begin{array}{cccc} c^2 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0\\ 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 &amp; 0\\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; -1 \end{array}\right).$$ Using index notation, the line element can be written as $ds^{2}=\eta_{\mu\nu}dx^{\mu}dx^{\nu}$. In textbooks I have seen the terms $dx^{\mu},dx^{\nu}$ called “coordinate differentials”, which seems OK except $dx^{0}=cdt$. I realise this is trivial, but is it correct to call $cdt$ a “coordinate differential”? To me it looks like a coordinate differential $dt$ multiplied by $c$. </p>
g4202
[ 0.01224985159933567, -0.036055788397789, -0.02359616942703724, -0.046384893357753754, 0.05995788797736168, 0.04342062771320343, 0.020361118018627167, 0.003662957577034831, -0.05262664332985878, -0.03391217812895775, -0.004675671458244324, 0.026716891676187515, 0.07246803492307663, -0.0481439083814621, 0.05249321088194847, -0.05003451183438301, 0.033789217472076416, -0.006411287467926741, 0.0364961251616478, -0.03587636724114418, 0.008900943212211132, 0.07693051546812057, -0.03003912791609764, -0.03270856291055679, 0.01710728369653225, -0.02718048356473446, 0.04974987730383873, -0.026712236925959587, -0.055951040238142014, -0.03486666455864906, 0.07474619150161743, 0.01889379322528839, 0.08178359270095825, 0.04240855947136879, -0.008949929848313332, -0.048887576907873154, 0.05757114663720131, 0.026161856949329376, 0.018317408859729767, 0.0016441070474684238, 0.04006832465529442, -0.024720359593629837, 0.05904441326856613, -0.015700306743383408, 0.0005133272497914732, -0.05505893751978874, -0.07922614365816116, -0.028488697484135628, -0.014664508402347565, -0.0016176695935428143, 0.013514548540115356, 0.017708860337734222, 0.023875148966908455, 0.005666443146765232, -0.011454261839389801, 0.011730597354471684, 0.017252473160624504, -0.020049238577485085, 0.0348176583647728, 0.026943732053041458, 0.05803174152970314, -0.004910419695079327, -0.005594860762357712, -0.010432877577841282, 0.07471468299627304, -0.013176891021430492, 0.01678680069744587, -0.04006173834204674, 0.03830958902835846, -0.034510139375925064, -0.022446563467383385, -0.038296692073345184, 0.06974169611930847, 0.029729964211583138, -0.025902798399329185, -0.004105157218873501, 0.02893851138651371, -0.06805093586444855, 0.005263280589133501, -0.03946454077959061, -0.03261860832571983, 0.005694054998457432, 0.02660876139998436, 0.04475880041718483, 0.05047660320997238, 0.007365398574620485, -0.023594940081238747, 0.0038961295504122972, -0.03558952361345291, 0.023418210446834564, 0.012051228433847427, -0.02410680055618286, 0.022634005174040794, 0.014694951474666595, -0.008103149943053722, -0.028789274394512177, 0.024093445390462875, 0.01858195662498474, -0.012156212702393532, -0.023488542065024376, 0.014967666007578373, 0.05087842792272568, 0.002500823000445962, 0.012309622950851917, 0.020089590921998024, 0.0625215619802475, 0.08010650426149368, 0.044147737324237823, 0.05324358120560646, -0.01533548254519701, -0.04495961591601372, 0.045347683131694794, -0.02696114592254162, -0.0019928859546780586, -0.009025884792208672, -0.02109084278345108, 0.002318002749234438, -0.0512896403670311, 0.0123175960034132, 0.02520623430609703, -0.026785923168063164, 0.027799028903245926, 0.06493928283452988, 0.033133767545223236, 0.031475719064474106, 0.018809320405125618, 0.006487285252660513, -0.004445057827979326, 0.0697411373257637, -0.038694046437740326, -0.0005869232700206339, 0.016196999698877335, 0.036135222762823105, -0.0238766148686409, -0.056907232850790024, 0.0015675066970288754, -0.0012547874357551336, -0.01307599525898695, -0.03583401441574097, 0.00961330346763134, 0.036094095557928085, -0.010894238017499447, -0.05952244624495506, -0.05361832305788994, -0.03763313964009285, 0.006029571406543255, -0.009763935580849648, -0.026096176356077194, 0.03188138082623482, -0.015397172421216965, 0.01761714182794094, 0.026315322145819664, -0.016593551263213158, 0.02415437251329422, -0.02599668689072132, -0.0023921800311654806, -0.010139252059161663, -0.021401096135377884, -0.01620759814977646, -0.03555363044142723, 0.056635454297065735, 0.02865227311849594, 0.002570957411080599, -0.00962692778557539, 0.00811363197863102, -0.016213884577155113, 0.04151126742362976, -0.02858530357480049, 0.020497985184192657, -0.06376361846923828, 0.014463704079389572, -0.003305896418169141, 0.005376604851335287, 0.011204836890101433, -0.023706670850515366, 0.03380535915493965, 0.025059152394533157, 0.010865618474781513, -0.018910666927695274, -0.007257537450641394, -0.02735549584031105, -0.023567721247673035, 0.012319372035562992, -0.01168258860707283, -0.02047831006348133, -0.026741452515125275, -0.05569726228713989, -0.06004193797707558, -0.0016218939563259482, 0.014250453561544418, 0.058979302644729614, -0.005117790773510933, 0.07882626354694366, 0.0764731764793396, 0.014026275835931301, 0.03186095133423805, -0.01601230353116989, 0.04748102277517319, -0.030646920204162598, 0.05780314281582832, -0.03714694082736969, 0.01567784883081913, 0.05128440633416176, -0.030547400936484337, -0.021937035024166107, 0.019036052748560905, -0.02998366579413414, 0.01465222891420126, 0.03257003426551819, 0.032823529094457626, 0.06209292262792587, -0.042463768273591995, 0.0002885031863115728, -0.0412006676197052, -0.07271977514028549, -0.05248825624585152, -0.01882728561758995, 0.022448737174272537, -0.02359931543469429, 0.014381103217601776, -0.044149599969387054, -0.04331004619598389, 0.05075269564986229, 0.037447739392519, -0.0632944405078888, 0.015312766656279564, 0.008507616817951202, 0.012980977073311806, 0.06737391650676727, -0.04150264337658882, -0.006189656909555197, 0.007763758767396212, -0.03257657214999199, 0.0031314112711697817, 0.005635194946080446, 0.026350900530815125, -0.07271794229745865, 0.01778128370642662, 0.04872627183794975, 0.05066497251391411, 0.0018778906669467688, -0.06595450639724731, 0.037565749138593674, -0.003080986440181732, -0.027752507477998734, 0.01609637401998043, 0.014217620715498924, 0.04287782311439514, -0.01066973339766264, -0.007016617339104414, -0.007501778658479452, -0.0506841205060482, 0.003094595856964588, -0.004610375035554171, 0.07088693231344223, 0.028851443901658058, -0.028169283643364906, -0.012971309944987297, -0.06752590090036392, -0.020769862458109856, -0.014143846929073334, -0.030134718865156174, -0.019820474088191986, 0.0023850384168326855, -0.0033055252861231565, -0.009816521778702736, 0.013994062319397926, 0.051976993680000305, 0.07748480886220932, 0.020863959565758705, 0.01002450566738844, 0.027442913502454758, 0.033444683998823166, 0.017488747835159302, -0.043041471391916275, -0.07695945352315903, 0.03371182456612587, -0.006392317358404398, -0.0163254477083683, 0.0052040559239685535, 0.0441715307533741, 0.02405416965484619, -0.041957587003707886, 0.028267566114664078, 0.07977381348609924, -0.039061613380908966, -0.004719334188848734, 0.026036156341433525, -0.04387246072292328, -0.006773437839001417, -0.0469844676554203, 0.05307958647608757, 0.023569174110889435, -0.07999032735824585, 0.005361635237932205, -0.020523415878415108, -0.019406350329518318, -0.013989637605845928, 0.00019468330719973892, -0.006156627554446459, -0.0032501935493201017, -0.013856632634997368, 0.016541890799999237, -0.02103789895772934, 0.016355406492948532, -0.04092539846897125, -0.03323851525783539, -0.05147417262196541, 0.01663091592490673, -0.047190479934215546, -0.006349292583763599, 0.004046513233333826, -0.001847619190812111, 0.0015416479436680675, -0.009085280820727348, 0.04741969704627991, -0.008876587264239788, -0.07933398336172104, -0.041458822786808014, -0.026008307933807373, 0.02353724278509617, -0.010392780415713787, -0.0004862556525040418, 0.049538444727659225, 0.00554815586656332, -0.01808192767202854, 0.011331187561154366, 0.027387144044041634, -0.03232218697667122, 0.010552874766290188, -0.0022593990433961153, -0.038329701870679855, -0.04760751128196716, 0.052890341728925705, -0.03491578996181488, 0.0005473043420352042, -0.015523330308496952, -0.0053403438068926334, 0.05748172476887703, -0.008068962953984737, -0.008737706579267979, -0.030414914712309837, -0.023017091676592827, -0.015406348742544651, 0.014902213588356972, -0.015909012407064438, 0.05059579014778137, 0.039231497794389725, -0.038061026483774185, 0.024524670094251633, 0.0297761932015419, -0.007592079695314169, 0.06515416502952576, -0.01574421487748623, -0.04281540960073471, 0.007233792915940285, 0.03304612264037132, 0.013672800734639168, -0.04420703649520874, 0.06879645586013794, 0.08417005836963654, 0.052769966423511505, -0.04629609361290932, 0.05062294006347656, 0.03399553522467613, 0.013498916290700436, 0.035767193883657455, 0.0226918812841177, -0.05518220737576485, -0.05499069392681122, 0.02475357986986637, 0.04372316226363182, 0.039021413773298264, 0.011127222329378128, 0.0029203856829553843, -0.06836137920618057, -0.038618870079517365, -0.012053746730089188, -0.030270369723439217, -0.03249531611800194, -0.04251863807439804, -0.02927524782717228, 0.00021009828196838498, 0.008264568634331226, 0.02682732231914997, -0.031505126506090164, 0.008932225406169891, -0.028472138568758965, -0.0010746507905423641, -0.059528399258852005, 0.018444452434778214, 0.05258527770638466, 0.013832001015543938, 0.006118751596659422, -0.025423439219594002, -0.020449146628379822, 0.027501916512846947, 0.039694905281066895, -0.05506499856710434, 0.021682947874069214, 0.0005021682009100914, -0.016749994829297066, -0.02143201418220997, -0.027948765084147453, -0.0012155416188761592, 0.056736499071121216, -0.02260444685816765, -0.05477326735854149, 0.07826623320579529, -0.0119548998773098, 0.08622516691684723, -0.014943782240152359, -0.0016251530032604933, -0.05030766874551773, 0.027841541916131973, 0.07258781045675278, -0.014912479557096958, -0.005598103627562523, -0.006570014636963606, 0.036251623183488846, -0.002994370413944125, 0.023815516382455826, -0.005189442541450262, 0.0008548815385438502, 0.022759510204195976, 0.1083327904343605, 0.09088625758886337, 0.0005939767579548061, -0.028689498081803322, 0.008254525251686573, 0.022568419575691223, 0.04182320088148117, -0.006799506954848766, -0.0077328006736934185, -0.012258915230631828, -0.036712367087602615, -0.05328122526407242, 0.023022551089525223, -0.02701330929994583, 0.048492372035980225, 0.002716516610234976, 0.049564067274332047, 0.01753474399447441, -0.027488024905323982, -0.032474275678396225, 0.05235627293586731, -0.04133922979235649, -0.032936520874500275, -0.0008045292343012989, 0.017868168652057648, -0.08057346940040588, 0.02341148443520069, 0.021743688732385635, -0.024792084470391273, -0.024427298456430435, 0.012746427208185196, 0.001832138979807496, 0.012683640234172344, -0.07576654106378555, -0.000008210418855014723, -0.017500007525086403, -0.03353109210729599, 0.029721714556217194, 0.06554872542619705, 0.06363003700971603, 0.03298899903893471, -0.060681264847517014, 0.026451025158166885, -0.06798531115055084, -0.014893325045704842, 0.030341101810336113, 0.05840635672211647, -0.008921029046177864, -0.09112732112407684, 0.06674569100141525, 0.059383001178503036, -0.056868866086006165, 0.08728934824466705, -0.015174178406596184, -0.0738430917263031, -0.02680845558643341, -0.0006034270045347512, -0.005009549669921398, -0.000575182493776083, 0.003667640732601285, -0.016095789149403572, -0.03715694695711136, -0.011016746051609516, 0.01225882489234209, 0.0004993753391318023, -0.004806261043995619, -0.007858913391828537, 0.027868274599313736, 0.006447348278015852, -0.042955733835697174, 0.02633865363895893, 0.033349718898534775, -0.09330228716135025, 0.01853925921022892, -0.04500853270292282, -0.022274281829595566, -0.0010200939141213894, 0.026481280103325844, -0.021090811118483543, 0.018137691542506218, 0.07331172376871109, 0.09745065867900848, 0.0026009599678218365, -0.004512958228588104, 0.05511408671736717, -0.02486751787364483, 0.044880934059619904, 0.02985409088432789, 0.003510979935526848, -0.04213334247469902, 0.015918444842100143, -0.038895148783922195, -0.008046455681324005, 0.020777881145477295, -0.07082824409008026, 0.03023959882557392, 0.012316673994064331, 0.020449845120310783, -0.02315099537372589, 0.061374545097351074, -0.028187157586216927, 0.010496553964912891, -0.004545912612229586, -0.028654703870415688, 0.029717912897467613, 0.0068262186832726, -0.03047535941004753, 0.007202670909464359, -0.0006663654930889606, -0.012884179130196571, -0.021637272089719772, -0.033786993473768234, -0.007062537595629692, 0.062068697065114975, 0.02932749129831791, -0.02413853071630001, 0.0172265637665987, -0.0017479867674410343, -0.01481239777058363, -0.04483933746814728, -0.0010485408129170537, 0.05810674652457237, 0.04142558202147484, 0.005783826112747192, -0.06150148808956146, -0.04052646830677986, 0.013357703574001789, 0.05580233410000801, -0.07400121539831161, 0.003386920550838113, 0.0014032508479431272, 0.036259301006793976, 0.01559339091181755, -0.01731259375810623, -0.025106871500611305, 0.011132716201245785, -0.002606823109090328, -0.010063878260552883, 0.04238167405128479, -0.030980737879872322, -0.04246023669838905, -0.017786845564842224, 0.05715161934494972, 0.06767870485782623, -0.0021572927944362164, -0.021126871928572655, -0.017988648265600204, -0.02372133359313011, -0.007370841223746538, 0.001231633359566331, -0.014290514402091503, 0.06508588790893555, 0.035686738789081573, 0.01452997513115406, 0.045959118753671646, 0.031763095408678055, 0.028252629563212395, -0.07008792459964752, -0.0415218211710453, -0.08596229553222656, 0.017454970628023148, -0.025154180824756622, -0.017507661134004593, -0.0067093647085130215, 0.009348967112600803, 0.0333196297287941, 0.012371291406452656, -0.04198330640792847, 0.0045496090315282345, -0.026894107460975647, -0.07553015649318695, 0.014324492774903774, 0.05510154366493225, 0.05410775914788246, -0.0059749046340584755, -0.018086491152644157, -0.008036952465772629, -0.013986348174512386, -0.03095441684126854, 0.07599014788866043, 0.010835596360266209, -0.018472423776984215, -0.03499376028776169, -0.0323827788233757, -0.002498624147847295, 0.02029595710337162, 0.04033809155225754, 0.01852473057806492, 0.017853785306215286, -0.004364937078207731, 0.0022768776398152113, -0.026852715760469437, -0.0003472746175248176, -0.06279212236404419, -0.0172166358679533, -0.00036559219006448984, -0.002897159196436405, 0.013680854812264442, -0.008476180955767632, -0.009022532030940056, 0.011899299919605255, 0.01576133631169796, -0.006025758106261492, -0.014857832342386246, -0.020352937281131744, -0.015869801864027977, -0.07362113147974014, -0.04739296808838844, -0.0071942126378417015, 0.019934460520744324, -0.021382061764597893, -0.019334644079208374, 0.0697624459862709, 0.09082243591547012, 0.06910797953605652, 0.0028252247720956802, 0.044805858284235, 0.0036494301166385412, -0.039209987968206406, -0.016886960715055466, -0.02508472464978695, 0.03289997950196266, -0.010915398597717285, -0.06345286965370178, 0.009973473846912384, 0.007151820696890354, 0.014973320066928864, -0.02911568246781826, 0.055357903242111206, -0.0032452885061502457, -0.014769394882023335, 0.018315905705094337, -0.0024569996166974306, -0.042627062648534775, -0.09822511672973633, 0.003400959772989154, -0.00816386379301548, -0.04515035077929497, 0.03327462822198868, -0.03237297758460045, 0.021989958360791206, 0.009347311221063137, 0.026146041229367256, -0.03894568234682083, -0.026802456006407738, -0.010433955118060112, -0.04660506546497345, -0.0031326457392424345, 0.03501015156507492, 0.026060570031404495, 0.01431795209646225, -0.04955792427062988, -0.022531017661094666, -0.01972747966647148, -0.056329842656850815, 0.036956366151571274, 0.004021978471428156, -0.005441395565867424, -0.140767902135849, -0.05002819001674652, 0.033684637397527695, -0.04648011550307274, -0.06485730409622192, -0.001392065896652639, -0.013343156315386295, 0.008652784861624241, 0.06257405877113342, 0.004364942666143179, -0.019529428333044052, -0.032179832458496094, -0.05623425170779228, 0.04817149415612221, 0.10114077478647232, -0.02423623576760292, 0.055752478539943695, 0.003096878994256258, -0.05185328796505928, 0.030832543969154358, 0.0061483317986130714, -0.006704459898173809, 0.03013351745903492, 0.002191385021433234, 0.05305851623415947, 0.04253356158733368, 0.0223702285438776, 0.04186449199914932, 0.001988631673157215, -0.02776101790368557, -0.030611716210842133, -0.019228728488087654, 0.006300389766693115, -0.0078122871927917, -0.014088230207562447, -0.05696941167116165, 0.014017075300216675, 0.0027903681620955467, -0.0206837709993124, 0.017435196787118912, -0.06363678723573685, -0.036588218063116074, 0.001331104664131999, -0.07729997485876083, -0.03859979659318924, 0.030542127788066864, -0.024196479469537735, -0.031102146953344345, 0.026394305750727654, -0.037705350667238235, 0.0356561541557312, 0.03227977082133293, 0.01597731001675129, 0.029009317979216576, -0.017060784623026848, 0.019789844751358032, 0.04906048625707626, 0.021311921998858452, -0.035434555262327194, -0.03813379257917404, 0.013313231989741325, -0.039978787302970886, -0.010005936026573181, 0.0198648814111948, -0.001812548260204494, -0.004822359886020422, -0.044228244572877884, 0.017151983454823494, 0.01636967808008194, 0.023855967447161674, 0.029257118701934814, -0.010638485662639141, -0.041549451649188995, 0.04702528938651085, -0.031070707365870476, 0.019275996834039688, -0.02704693377017975, -0.03154005482792854, 0.029046092182397842, 0.021217143163084984, -0.026392439380288124, -0.05245783552527428, -0.02945120260119438, -0.025165854021906853, -0.01956174708902836 ]
<p>The Poisson - Boltzmann equation is to find the potential whose charge density obey the Boltzmann distribution. If the potential is not large compare to $k_BT$, the PBE can lead to the Debye–Hückel equation. However if the potential is large and the system is high density, its result is <a href="http://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/ct3001156" rel="nofollow">unreal</a>.</p> <p>I can see the problem is coming from Boltzmann part, not Poisson, but I can't find any document states that Boltzmann distribution is not suitable for high energy.</p>
g4203
[ 0.018000857904553413, 0.09557034075260162, 0.026743106544017792, -0.021151022985577583, 0.0026346282102167606, 0.005970887374132872, -0.053919717669487, 0.03163802623748779, -0.05042954906821251, -0.003966376185417175, 0.0007637250819243491, -0.023628929629921913, 0.009653675369918346, -0.007794588338583708, -0.01131570152938366, -0.007299534510821104, 0.07788079977035522, 0.033931050449609756, -0.025962356477975845, -0.011566227301955223, -0.06296218186616898, 0.03510385751724243, -0.016454700380563736, -0.017410578206181526, 0.007625296246260405, -0.010957772843539715, -0.03410638868808746, -0.012894787825644016, -0.050130005925893784, -0.032613612711429596, -0.010266575962305069, -0.012939232401549816, 0.0002414947812212631, -0.02273445948958397, -0.047283828258514404, -0.012525801546871662, 0.07612935453653336, -0.05355764925479889, -0.017384007573127747, -0.0341850146651268, -0.013018650934100151, -0.0021170026157051325, 0.025195231661200523, 0.01925920508801937, -0.0048635355196893215, 0.018476571887731552, 0.00864526629447937, 0.03226456791162491, 0.016198202967643738, -0.028389450162649155, 0.051014844328165054, 0.05466032028198242, -0.02737083099782467, 0.008603192865848541, 0.037379633635282516, 0.03236659616231918, 0.02462518960237503, -0.008289752528071404, 0.026403231546282768, 0.013619129545986652, 0.028141271322965622, 0.03517644479870796, 0.009852159768342972, 0.022220013663172722, 0.05194881185889244, -0.010183917358517647, -0.07009590417146683, 0.01956746354699135, 0.015922529622912407, -0.028410576283931732, 0.039713747799396515, -0.05694858357310295, -0.02933800406754017, -0.03621644526720047, 0.004595600999891758, -0.021619565784931183, 0.02255357801914215, 0.0015425708843395114, 0.03280092403292656, -0.009578905068337917, -0.05342560261487961, 0.03539397567510605, 0.04402200132608414, -0.030046651139855385, 0.03314002603292465, -0.03143617883324623, 0.024214353412389755, 0.0042295074090361595, -0.03089265711605549, 0.0027719675563275814, -0.056890495121479034, 0.04345855116844177, 0.03532847389578819, -0.016025641933083534, -0.03103356808423996, -0.0001307090715272352, -0.027449041604995728, 0.06729301810264587, -0.06507676839828491, -0.01381097175180912, -0.010559087619185448, -0.036280255764722824, -0.01265446376055479, 0.05865885689854622, -0.030499981716275215, -0.02470082975924015, -0.08305375277996063, 0.008285097777843475, 0.004801279399544001, 0.018450696021318436, -0.06437472999095917, -0.026444194838404655, -0.025902772322297096, -0.03836996480822563, -0.016308890655636787, 0.052262384444475174, 0.10522325336933136, -0.0186055526137352, -0.035002969205379486, 0.058957502245903015, -0.03743768110871315, 0.014290046878159046, -0.01033678650856018, 0.060304585844278336, -0.01809047907590866, 0.00890457071363926, -0.01995566301047802, 0.009679893963038921, 0.01534336432814598, -0.04484386369585991, 0.043960753828287125, -0.04615999758243561, 0.07404422760009766, -0.05531052127480507, 0.0502440519630909, 0.0440286323428154, -0.018266424536705017, 0.046206116676330566, 0.046219948679208755, 0.0011643022298812866, -0.01787930727005005, -0.02945415861904621, 0.02856479212641716, -0.0002399692457402125, -0.05860457941889763, 0.0009935686830431223, -0.029495947062969208, 0.03771505877375603, -0.01141761802136898, 0.06953717768192291, 0.004073586780577898, 0.0004943383974023163, 0.013603893108665943, -0.0489228218793869, -0.02692696824669838, 0.051773760467767715, 0.007206703070551157, -0.011154690757393837, 0.0053871264681220055, -0.004327861592173576, -0.061909765005111694, -0.015864234417676926, 0.013377302326261997, -0.026845039799809456, 0.00724067771807313, 0.029651504009962082, -0.01627744920551777, 0.026484224945306778, -0.04922950267791748, -0.04069431498646736, -0.031546615064144135, 0.0038513510953634977, 0.008224559016525745, 0.06058163568377495, 0.041990745812654495, 0.026341289281845093, -0.01417530793696642, 0.007415365893393755, 0.006190847139805555, -0.016135336831212044, -0.029254987835884094, -0.009491371922194958, 0.0855802595615387, -0.06432337313890457, -0.006372654810547829, 0.04720434918999672, 0.04647000506520271, 0.06656761467456818, 0.025412214919924736, 0.0018205356318503618, -0.030808432027697563, -0.0132422661408782, 0.004459130112081766, -0.005881821736693382, -0.0024407149758189917, 0.04108014702796936, 0.025818374007940292, -0.05381496250629425, -0.01961536332964897, -0.06181195005774498, -0.024817755445837975, 0.018280522897839546, 0.05034051090478897, -0.023930268362164497, 0.10667586326599121, -0.044746238738298416, 0.006554433144629002, -0.03114391677081585, 0.049648184329271317, -0.04831063374876976, -0.06297144293785095, -0.059790611267089844, -0.008206220343708992, 0.06967846304178238, 0.005558530334383249, -0.051529161632061005, -0.03821689635515213, 0.01813906989991665, -0.037377603352069855, 0.04021633416414261, -0.0952363908290863, -0.03129281476140022, -0.0009252101299352944, 0.06291661411523819, -0.003210890106856823, 0.014317837543785572, 0.003768175607547164, -0.027048751711845398, -0.014367117546498775, 0.0486709401011467, 0.0223928764462471, -0.02570897713303566, 0.03193408250808716, -0.03035876154899597, 0.0059260595589876175, 0.06487371772527695, -0.01129867322742939, -0.0020851916633546352, -0.038817208260297775, 0.026201967149972916, -0.041457418352365494, -0.02320793643593788, 0.004503450356423855, 0.07268153131008148, 0.058247219771146774, 0.00837312638759613, 0.032510820776224136, -0.06457340717315674, 0.028900310397148132, 0.010848394595086575, 0.026960095390677452, 0.008279051631689072, 0.010029404424130917, -0.04977890104055405, 0.0023562139831483364, -0.00029042523237876594, -0.04028446599841118, 0.024119656533002853, -0.026790263131260872, -0.08903490006923676, 0.001751486212015152, 0.011973625048995018, -0.0470065213739872, -0.048314906656742096, -0.038061872124671936, 0.060679852962493896, -0.027528267353773117, -0.013081753626465797, 0.022384239360690117, -0.019215749576687813, 0.03876442462205887, 0.07867565751075745, -0.035437434911727905, -0.015417106449604034, 0.04024631157517433, -0.03772440180182457, 0.0034638941287994385, -0.033561620861291885, 0.04180492088198662, 0.004208066966384649, -0.036584049463272095, -0.008556658402085304, 0.00010960207873722538, 0.04175739735364914, 0.021798662841320038, -0.028088267892599106, 0.07098130881786346, -0.0063169063068926334, 0.059580013155937195, -0.010856601409614086, -0.018255185335874557, -0.009451213292777538, -0.03775376081466675, 0.020812643691897392, -0.0111277149990201, 0.03059140220284462, 0.019613057374954224, -0.06384219974279404, -0.01058890763670206, -0.039640650153160095, -0.0079647870734334, -0.05501028522849083, 0.01699722744524479, 0.0673413798213005, 0.05272988602519035, 0.011411461979150772, -0.033595241606235504, -0.02377326413989067, -0.06054292246699333, 0.00587287824600935, -0.004083643201738596, 0.030397163704037666, -0.041577763855457306, 0.022827545180916786, 0.01005104836076498, 0.008722583763301373, 0.010987827554345131, -0.027801021933555603, 0.056476809084415436, -0.06113361567258835, 0.06560774147510529, -0.008637453429400921, -0.009244557470083237, -0.024780932813882828, 0.00014912415645085275, 0.010601886548101902, -0.03301788121461868, 0.021381128579378128, 0.02810479700565338, 0.0005350934807211161, 0.048352599143981934, 0.018997101113200188, 0.06778454035520554, 0.015949759632349014, -0.048869796097278595, -0.051452841609716415, 0.04676941782236099, 0.021910473704338074, 0.05352156236767769, -0.027286356315016747, -0.0636410117149353, -0.022244881838560104, -0.055730145424604416, 0.004379965830594301, -0.07732418924570084, -0.02296803891658783, 0.012189922854304314, -0.028849119320511818, 0.019326606765389442, -0.02439575083553791, 0.016941994428634644, -0.006012629251927137, 0.029626021161675453, 0.0024786663707345724, -0.019554883241653442, -0.020260751247406006, -0.012750503607094288, 0.02075320854783058, 0.02831774391233921, 0.007139922585338354, 0.024669187143445015, -0.026620807126164436, 0.08797100931406021, 0.002329362789168954, -0.01731797680258751, -0.0461597740650177, -0.06580270081758499, -0.027063952758908272, -0.008110777474939823, -0.030301032587885857, 0.01817736215889454, -0.05701538175344467, 0.024281026795506477, -0.007588251959532499, 0.07164422422647476, 0.0011429167352616787, 0.003811206668615341, -0.006315395701676607, -0.015945566818118095, -0.0716477781534195, 0.04665731266140938, 0.031050201505422592, 0.024619227275252342, 0.032652974128723145, 0.022816084325313568, -0.03647977113723755, -0.06494175642728806, -0.03864728659391403, 0.027377057820558548, 0.00881598424166441, 0.016163453459739685, -0.022355226799845695, -0.017380837351083755, 0.020128313452005386, 0.014466870576143265, -0.04909922555088997, 0.04529716446995735, -0.031295791268348694, 0.011377823539078236, 0.03160415217280388, -0.012823720462620258, -0.030648354440927505, 0.013714698143303394, -0.020030876621603966, 0.025465315207839012, -0.00011909357999684289, 0.055002611130476, -0.0401211678981781, -0.02596743032336235, -0.003898243186995387, 0.003820826066657901, -0.03413660451769829, 0.005362784955650568, -0.027149925008416176, -0.01841491460800171, -0.051373135298490524, 0.003205621149390936, 0.03667325899004936, 0.036261606961488724, 0.016234276816248894, 0.04133584722876549, 0.024660691618919373, -0.00937695987522602, -0.014052987098693848, -0.04861783608794212, 0.02281392179429531, 0.07982230931520462, -0.033170949667692184, -0.02744252048432827, -0.00959597434848547, -0.026686837896704674, 0.017496390268206596, -0.022331800311803818, 0.046745508909225464, -0.022318027913570404, 0.011317925527691841, 0.0022021594922989607, -0.011999957263469696, -0.018759502097964287, 0.015905778855085373, 0.020527461543679237, -0.03166455402970314, 0.05422114208340645, -0.010829029604792595, 0.025445159524679184, 0.05277419090270996, 0.035038840025663376, -0.022504238411784172, -0.0692303329706192, -0.04684073105454445, 0.018161389976739883, -0.02748243883252144, 0.026484370231628418, 0.03685132414102554, -0.02797006256878376, -0.024256009608507156, 0.034575674682855606, 0.002145015634596348, -0.004236368462443352, 0.09677238017320633, -0.011856501922011375, 0.006069149821996689, 0.015250063501298428, -0.016806641593575478, 0.039920393377542496, -0.020611319690942764, -0.03494954854249954, -0.00639936001971364, -0.0047707147896289825, -0.018658185377717018, 0.028703568503260612, 0.025425920262932777, 0.010425465181469917, 0.025029821321368217, 0.004477406851947308, -0.01100879069417715, 0.012175486423075199, -0.04141337051987648, 0.013486639596521854, -0.026154134422540665, 0.001685982570052147, 0.03358001634478569, -0.03885997086763382, 0.02226526103913784, -0.033872369676828384, -0.016244644299149513, -0.03321073204278946, 0.03397569805383682, -0.011827608570456505, -0.010719886049628258, 0.0491056963801384, 0.051196809858083725, 0.044312361627817154, 0.05420541763305664, 0.03226948156952858, -0.0004812852421309799, 0.05653703212738037, 0.01804349198937416, 0.022596590220928192, 0.04487632215023041, -0.020400747656822205, -0.0987875834107399, -0.01864028163254261, -0.019804585725069046, -0.03355813026428223, 0.057300738990306854, 0.07749713212251663, 0.04076498746871948, -0.012625259347259998, -0.004898324608802795, 0.03606390580534935, 0.027281243354082108, 0.06501349806785583, 0.01730133593082428, -0.05762512609362602, 0.004797933157533407, -0.06434158235788345, 0.013519315049052238, 0.00886483397334814, -0.008547238074243069, 0.08728847652673721, 0.01528173591941595, 0.050510555505752563, -0.004414938855916262, -0.0020647277124226093, -0.08419642597436905, -0.029201598837971687, -0.025578824803233147, -0.045990657061338425, 0.044214412569999695, -0.0008636075654067099, -0.017411798238754272, -0.006100252736359835, -0.0013164090923964977, -0.04012222960591316, -0.009966174140572548, -0.06290994584560394, 0.018984448164701462, 0.02990460954606533, 0.03961004689335823, 0.052592143416404724, -0.03748820349574089, 0.012610177509486675, -0.06704236567020416, -0.03900918364524841, -0.016724934801459312, -0.046074967831373215, 0.013796720653772354, -0.006157930474728346, -0.05239572748541832, -0.025231460109353065, 0.012209927663207054, -0.05520724877715111, -0.07790017127990723, 0.02588283084332943, -0.02189795672893524, 0.03539716824889183, 0.021431609988212585, 0.0022115532774478197, 0.02975352667272091, 0.007743090856820345, 0.009920870885252953, 0.02625334821641445, -0.0030850989278405905, 0.032519642263650894, -0.06713080406188965, -0.013197945430874825, 0.012501207180321217, 0.0230078287422657, 0.03802872076630592, -0.018900074064731598, 0.0018551867688074708, 0.007091243751347065, -0.06903614848852158, 0.054053910076618195, -0.00004064090535393916, -0.008793952874839306, -0.03509572893381119, -0.038590770214796066, 0.03670091554522514, -0.02711765468120575, 0.019354142248630524, 0.008190552704036236, 0.012739444151520729, -0.03987601771950722, -0.004771220497786999, 0.0012962803011760116, -0.00324707361869514, -0.0016058854525908828, -0.02807210385799408, 0.02337738312780857, 0.007469548378139734, -0.04211997613310814, -0.013870567083358765, -0.0513162761926651, 0.020385170355439186, -0.015611515380442142, -0.058140918612480164, -0.1301044076681137, -0.002401455072686076, 0.009159184992313385, -0.011633161455392838, -0.04478149488568306, -0.011711899191141129, 0.024378230795264244, -0.03541198745369911, 0.07446756213903427, 0.05245212838053703, 0.009703640826046467, 0.0822848305106163, 0.007294308859854937, 0.025099774822592735, -0.0026738992892205715, -0.007706536445766687, -0.0016399890882894397, -0.045999858528375626, 0.020584294572472572, 0.040033452212810516, 0.006608960218727589, 0.01878727227449417, 0.01574593596160412, -0.019207386299967766, 0.009590975008904934, 0.004282723180949688, 0.03443850949406624, 0.024190852418541908, -0.004051704425364733, 0.06442967057228088, 0.0888766348361969, 0.005334837362170219, 0.055600520223379135, 0.00040694340714253485, -0.022865600883960724, 0.043714623898267746, -0.004180558491498232, 0.0408153273165226, -0.05373978987336159, -0.02202056534588337, 0.025512659922242165, -0.004302298184484243, -0.02852434292435646, 0.017806565389037132, 0.061994992196559906, -0.006890239659696817, -0.05087413266301155, -0.03350755572319031, -0.0006587066454812884, 0.022560199722647667, -0.033938296139240265, -0.06197100505232811, 0.06172347441315651, -0.007292335387319326, -0.04779072478413582, 0.014589153230190277, -0.03817185014486313, 0.010204937309026718, 0.042940981686115265, 0.028097281232476234, 0.06654080003499985, -0.017140889540314674, -0.01831064000725746, 0.014431562274694443, -0.011014406569302082, 0.03215304762125015, 0.04766944795846939, 0.018025986850261688, -0.007195415906608105, -0.053602661937475204, 0.0068526240065693855, 0.004179431591182947, -0.00027746809064410627, 0.02489178627729416, -0.005169040989130735, -0.021019062027335167, 0.002979506738483906, 0.0015405671438202262, 0.009015265852212906, 0.06679466366767883, -0.006430942099541426, -0.0037527852691709995, -0.010572178289294243, 0.018951399251818657, -0.09190921485424042, 0.0063438378274440765, 0.01155130472034216, 0.02289365418255329, -0.04608764871954918, -0.002800913527607918, 0.014166481792926788, 0.06736216694116592, -0.024624256417155266, -0.0159547571092844, 0.017530208453536034, -0.031139960512518883, -0.03654678538441658, 0.02177502028644085, 0.016632502898573875, -0.014115230180323124, 0.05689206346869469, -0.023236148059368134, -0.02798130176961422, 0.028883280232548714, -0.04108195751905441, -0.005044863093644381, 0.020693939179182053, 0.00946115329861641, -0.002252508420497179, -0.049587175250053406, -0.03407485783100128, -0.031883757561445236, 0.006199502851814032, -0.012033307924866676, 0.012732649222016335, -0.026021385565400124, 0.02212720550596714, -0.023080110549926758, -0.010725488886237144, 0.013529631309211254, -0.04173989221453667, -0.012539579533040524, -0.05373286083340645, 0.015178697183728218, 0.03049274906516075, 0.0029619031120091677, 0.03992438688874245, -0.07204217463731766, -0.026514897122979164, 0.05142375826835632, -0.038371890783309937, 0.014121885411441326, -0.05975693464279175, -0.013564154505729675, 0.012745971791446209, -0.03228538855910301, -0.025067875161767006, -0.061720769852399826, 0.042192403227090836, 0.03311065211892128, 0.04747263714671135, 0.04796324297785759, -0.003945548553019762, -0.01316350419074297, 0.06157396361231804, -0.03728576749563217, 0.013395711779594421, -0.04896346479654312, -0.03995107114315033, -0.031259045004844666, 0.11733581870794296, -0.015406329184770584, 0.044521454721689224, -0.06057507172226906, -0.05125466361641884, 0.01469148974865675, 0.00832168385386467, -0.0415097214281559, 0.07564601302146912, 0.02244476042687893, 0.041666824370622635, 0.00277111423201859, 0.028888052329421043, -0.07446685433387756, 0.03839058801531792, 0.04503012076020241, 0.031810518354177475, -0.03234647586941719, -0.012358316220343113, 0.02470335364341736 ]
<p>I'm looking for a treatment of the original basic <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaluza%E2%80%93Klein_theory" rel="nofollow">Kaluza-Klein theory</a>. Can someone recommend a review article or something?</p>
g4204
[ 0.06097404658794403, 0.04938469082117081, -0.009314517490565777, -0.0019148814026266336, -0.08441755920648575, -0.0351337306201458, 0.013777676038444042, 0.043163638561964035, -0.036533575505018234, 0.020198877900838852, 0.03129619359970093, -0.018354443833231926, 0.07757996767759323, 0.016812395304441452, 0.007987616583704948, 0.009148134849965572, -0.022751206532120705, 0.06406955420970917, -0.0010974069591611624, -0.007656526286154985, -0.0010638482635840774, 0.022373506799340248, -0.011608152650296688, -0.0350547693669796, -0.012171276845037937, -0.012049100361764431, -0.02667875774204731, 0.03124779276549816, -0.03969953581690788, -0.057895537465810776, -0.006253978703171015, -0.04642269015312195, -0.0015784266870468855, -0.02023765631020069, 0.014868122525513172, 0.035251371562480927, 0.039417486637830734, 0.019847894087433815, -0.03223447874188423, 0.006948377005755901, -0.01676601730287075, 0.07377783954143524, -0.0025853964034467936, -0.013201427645981312, -0.013554079458117485, -0.015518957749009132, -0.017251156270503998, 0.03358929976820946, -0.043950751423835754, 0.010866834782063961, -0.018251653760671616, 0.05179848149418831, 0.04228346422314644, -0.03845270723104477, 0.08377648144960403, 0.0004331819072831422, 0.04613872990012169, 0.010312770493328571, 0.032073140144348145, -0.024926140904426575, -0.0025901191402226686, 0.0536746047437191, -0.01928279548883438, -0.013783890753984451, 0.023667272180318832, -0.0488305389881134, 0.03504306077957153, -0.06421767175197601, 0.04498237743973732, -0.027692673727869987, -0.0020742882043123245, 0.015445860102772713, -0.010418805293738842, 0.05169295147061348, -0.04801127314567566, -0.001432092860341072, -0.04998176917433739, -0.013767315074801445, 0.03201204165816307, -0.016156433150172234, -0.055954452604055405, 0.028543896973133087, 0.026851503178477287, -0.03182733431458473, 0.06067083403468132, -0.05196089297533035, -0.03390193730592728, 0.010107114911079407, 0.07110031694173813, -0.01245382335036993, -0.008955627679824829, 0.06978094577789307, -0.0031978366896510124, -0.019337385892868042, 0.003968206234276295, 0.0073576862923800945, -0.042713750153779984, -0.06302537024021149, -0.05669945105910301, -0.020191073417663574, -0.03982771188020706, 0.03863361477851868, 0.037808071821928024, 0.017316505312919617, 0.025990236550569534, -0.0036553340032696724, 0.04020626097917557, -0.0004141885438002646, -0.07547619193792343, 0.017354995012283325, 0.016549531370401382, 0.0004669396730605513, -0.031369857490062714, -0.058256860822439194, -0.012448611669242382, -0.09894872456789017, 0.08202841132879257, 0.0067781005054712296, 0.05259646475315094, -0.004854341968894005, -0.005656949244439602, 0.02519150637090206, 0.035338081419467926, 0.05039567872881889, 0.02113666944205761, -0.012287994846701622, 0.013782267458736897, -0.01876978389918804, -0.042050283402204514, 0.007467303890734911, 0.041567362844944, 0.01570429652929306, -0.0018175712320953608, 0.017338378354907036, 0.018558120355010033, 0.05485379323363304, 0.01189793087542057, -0.033203501254320145, -0.05302966386079788, 0.020684950053691864, -0.010493339039385319, -0.03156405687332153, 0.009413795545697212, 0.013060917146503925, 0.08757804334163666, -0.014034458436071873, 0.022006304934620857, 0.030882621183991432, -0.030910726636648178, -0.05830775946378708, 0.00036898828693665564, 0.05133042857050896, -0.038391709327697754, -0.020639948546886444, 0.011811438016593456, 0.04583340138196945, 0.007814042270183563, -0.013885755091905594, -0.024036558344960213, -0.016344785690307617, 0.011470927856862545, -0.033917754888534546, 0.04957268387079239, 0.03777617588639259, -0.04151063784956932, 0.0022853801492601633, -0.027746206149458885, 0.008545022457838058, 0.008720038458704948, -0.04689881578087807, 0.026290172711014748, 0.009340591728687286, 0.036125682294368744, 0.08893966674804688, -0.03041394241154194, 0.07029923796653748, 0.022949960082769394, -0.009834116324782372, 0.05045677721500397, -0.049929313361644745, -0.06131337583065033, 0.024292297661304474, -0.006331779062747955, 0.07276225090026855, 0.0666036382317543, 0.008477979339659214, -0.024996349588036537, 0.04125894233584404, -0.02223939448595047, -0.022361312061548233, 0.0021963887847959995, 0.025181569159030914, -0.01355704851448536, -0.0024588247761130333, 0.0024814929347485304, 0.038933053612709045, 0.0038539136294275522, -0.057529348880052567, 0.05618686228990555, 0.03233492746949196, 0.015061169862747192, 0.057639848440885544, -0.017242183908820152, 0.009441617876291275, 0.012525701895356178, -0.0574042946100235, -0.01848931983113289, 0.011688166297972202, 0.07923971116542816, -0.00629594549536705, -0.033282216638326645, 0.0008235343848355114, 0.006694178096950054, 0.03688421845436096, -0.012856767512857914, 0.02567622810602188, -0.007159584667533636, -0.018582157790660858, -0.028692947700619698, 0.02534032240509987, -0.009697167202830315, 0.023904191330075264, -0.005172327626496553, 0.037207044661045074, 0.04138907790184021, 0.0013121339725330472, 0.0216468907892704, -0.03717493265867233, 0.00022140021610539407, -0.006594044156372547, -0.10852071642875671, -0.09847170114517212, -0.035599593073129654, 0.031918060034513474, -0.03100992925465107, 0.06408550590276718, 0.003137909574434161, -0.053997401148080826, 0.04742226004600525, 0.038917284458875656, -0.02782822586596012, 0.04513171315193176, -0.02696656621992588, 0.025715015828609467, 0.006303254049271345, -0.03635237738490105, 0.07532889395952225, -0.08303465694189072, 0.009133652783930302, 0.017866620793938637, -0.002057174686342478, 0.005827697459608316, 0.0031030201353132725, -0.03147109970450401, 0.06215076521039009, 0.0023899951484054327, 0.042512327432632446, 0.07845773547887802, 0.009253576397895813, 0.031361714005470276, 0.06556124985218048, 0.0033435376826673746, -0.011092000640928745, 0.008418633602559566, -0.07593563199043274, -0.024066738784313202, -0.03283386677503586, 0.026851480826735497, -0.01884012669324875, -0.08386776596307755, -0.012561512179672718, 0.021712899208068848, 0.007173419464379549, 0.01869805157184601, -0.04440917819738388, -0.02858998253941536, -0.018181325867772102, -0.017195886000990868, 0.00110886141192168, -0.024150976911187172, 0.020725581794977188, 0.028791287913918495, 0.011050730012357235, -0.007083178963512182, 0.03469643369317055, -0.046998973935842514, -0.07559207081794739, 0.021600905805826187, 0.015159914270043373, 0.027049699798226357, 0.013799325563013554, 0.03501910716295242, 0.06079459190368652, -0.006844434887170792, 0.016057029366493225, 0.045448578894138336, 0.04833414778113365, -0.031128380447626114, 0.022083856165409088, 0.1045202985405922, 0.014025818556547165, -0.05099817365407944, -0.038936764001846313, -0.04088538512587547, 0.006602775771170855, 0.006434191484004259, -0.03873404487967491, -0.053713057190179825, -0.013413914479315281, 0.0381963774561882, -0.0355830043554306, 0.019415173679590225, 0.013535586185753345, -0.05476706475019455, -0.07791057974100113, 0.036311663687229156, -0.002361645922064781, 0.02002224139869213, 0.08307429403066635, -0.0156624224036932, 0.02546377293765545, 0.03180529549717903, 0.04746689647436142, 0.023156529292464256, 0.01847139187157154, 0.0001387506490573287, -0.06111929193139076, 0.02085435763001442, 0.017857547849416733, 0.02227841503918171, 0.046662211418151855, -0.004229645244777203, -0.03546053543686867, -0.00957198441028595, 0.005122696049511433, 0.011869093403220177, -0.025384394451975822, -0.014247866347432137, 0.016786592081189156, 0.04831720143556595, -0.019430628046393394, -0.06323431432247162, -0.026074331253767014, 0.009076724760234356, -0.005358946043998003, -0.04616862162947655, -0.02606160007417202, 0.026401402428746223, -0.035932525992393494, 0.013547723181545734, 0.015465361066162586, 0.03855019435286522, 0.012080958113074303, 0.004700448364019394, 0.0015170060796663165, 0.017787238582968712, 0.11594098806381226, 0.03634408861398697, 0.007546698674559593, 0.04072631523013115, 0.01372462883591652, -0.02361125685274601, 0.01323653943836689, 0.06704794615507126, -0.05000363662838936, 0.0035959286615252495, 0.029239291325211525, 0.05232955515384674, -0.030744949355721474, -0.0018442298751324415, -0.025317853316664696, 0.0012942340690642595, -0.004057650920003653, 0.03108236938714981, -0.07685937732458115, -0.014137514866888523, 0.03318105265498161, 0.041068606078624725, -0.02084558829665184, 0.06297440081834793, 0.0361284501850605, 0.020863018929958344, -0.018033169209957123, 0.03399279713630676, 0.04489847645163536, 0.038442932069301605, -0.008304329589009285, -0.008377252146601677, -0.01129534188657999, 0.035517312586307526, -0.01416925247758627, -0.02047710306942463, -0.04654015228152275, 0.01990395411849022, 0.023413514718413353, 0.007562199607491493, -0.001061551971361041, 0.03142211213707924, -0.02836899645626545, -0.049953993409872055, 0.004169609397649765, 0.02588523179292679, -0.03131485357880592, 0.000053535874030785635, -0.013577780686318874, 0.07523608952760696, 0.013130503706634045, -0.031522948294878006, -0.0035839162301272154, 0.05941333249211311, 0.0032189623452723026, -0.0110346470028162, -0.011446370743215084, -0.07264268398284912, 0.015046113170683384, -0.016424676403403282, 0.014354294165968895, -0.012235268019139767, -0.00929354503750801, 0.008429253473877907, 0.016626417636871338, 0.006386210210621357, -0.008799087256193161, -0.07428538054227829, -0.015776880085468292, -0.010877643711864948, -0.041733600199222565, 0.021134424954652786, 0.017092173919081688, -0.03846026211977005, -0.007937964051961899, 0.020252801477909088, -0.08255891501903534, 0.0381123311817646, -0.059661827981472015, -0.019051918759942055, -0.025098256766796112, 0.06274986267089844, -0.011019737459719181, -0.028856294229626656, 0.0032639673445373774, -0.006361677777022123, 0.009439597837626934, -0.023485824465751648, 0.025906503200531006, 0.0404779277741909, -0.020332036539912224, -0.001741159474477172, -0.02367265522480011, -0.07214426249265671, 0.05722297355532646, 0.02144821360707283, 0.013748911209404469, -0.00034352278453297913, -0.014306376688182354, 0.009037412703037262, 0.006181712262332439, 0.04544764757156372, -0.014442933723330498, 0.005220700055360794, -0.010121508501470089, 0.01178445853292942, 0.009293134324252605, -0.00442033214494586, 0.03912532329559326, -0.014202523976564407, -0.05232932046055794, -0.009878427721560001, -0.05606311187148094, 0.012130084447562695, 0.009435763582587242, 0.03075011633336544, 0.03356054052710533, 0.0018569192616268992, 0.030272141098976135, -0.0005889267777092755, 0.040859270840883255, 0.03263165429234505, -0.05471928045153618, -0.033938437700271606, 0.0030446830205619335, -0.025421762838959694, -0.026233956217765808, -0.010965146124362946, 0.026020176708698273, 0.0034723575226962566, -0.02476147934794426, -0.003355787368491292, -0.026004618033766747, -0.008347533643245697, -0.024716071784496307, -0.06408265233039856, 0.04967215657234192, -0.027561264112591743, -0.007389420177787542, -0.00026356239686720073, 0.03135129064321518, -0.05680900812149048, 0.024551313370466232, -0.003263382939621806, -0.01843082532286644, -0.0091103445738554, 0.015647737309336662, 0.022532250732183456, 0.01024338323622942, -0.041730739176273346, 0.051705747842788696, -0.004871937911957502, -0.02609272114932537, 0.03987248241901398, -0.028296900913119316, 0.03087763302028179, -0.017157500609755516, 0.024275049567222595, -0.052696987986564636, 0.04558200761675835, -0.05268324166536331, 0.006730217952281237, -0.007071818690747023, -0.09024159610271454, 0.036371637135744095, -0.031083492562174797, -0.06512463837862015, -0.007597834803164005, -0.013403032906353474, 0.01944425143301487, -0.012592777609825134, -0.0034796821419149637, 0.03442303091287613, -0.012855641543865204, -0.03665640205144882, -0.004302347544580698, -0.01003529317677021, 0.05672654137015343, 0.006062875967472792, -0.012981482781469822, 0.006363683380186558, 0.07273362576961517, -0.005234151612967253, -0.005163503345102072, 0.026697643101215363, 0.06335598975419998, -0.03331518918275833, 0.017595456913113594, -0.0745147243142128, 0.04564180597662926, 0.007689481135457754, 0.02620207890868187, 0.01126299798488617, -0.026856213808059692, -0.038556769490242004, -0.08865070343017578, 0.02984224446117878, 0.011017246171832085, -0.016044726595282555, -0.028547652065753937, 0.004518520087003708, -0.010090114548802376, -0.011587013490498066, -0.018497001379728317, -0.026036521419882774, -0.02949693240225315, 0.031177757307887077, 0.011794988065958023, 0.00987783819437027, -0.07420582324266434, -0.014193747192621231, -0.047297634184360504, 0.04863109439611435, 0.007580695208162069, -0.043339475989341736, 0.020874859765172005, -0.07069454342126846, 0.013148519210517406, -0.0497608557343483, -0.005541727412492037, 0.030133770778775215, -0.055765777826309204, -0.03055078163743019, 0.0044228374026715755, -0.03282080590724945, -0.0333549790084362, 0.028246846050024033, -0.0376460924744606, 0.016550777480006218, -0.023621244356036186, -0.07381705194711685, 0.004637120757251978, -0.0062932525761425495, 0.010055449791252613, 0.09679172188043594, 0.013895303010940552, -0.04950212314724922, -0.008983644656836987, -0.013501185923814774, 0.03979213908314705, 0.019077088683843613, 0.06703328341245651, 0.022869594395160675, 0.03734500706195831, -0.02745448425412178, 0.0010693225776776671, -0.00544020626693964, -0.014542452059686184, 0.013645103201270103, 0.04523111507296562, 0.006224163342267275, -0.06144624575972557, 0.005950965452939272, 0.01224940363317728, -0.04198100417852402, 0.059606678783893585, 0.007284456863999367, -0.04052051529288292, 0.02438482828438282, -0.046529125422239304, -0.0048960186541080475, 0.021394608542323112, 0.02834729105234146, 0.01644541509449482, 0.011243682354688644, -0.0656510517001152, -0.00800761952996254, 0.02352875843644142, 0.04761679843068123, 0.019629456102848053, -0.04242963343858719, -0.092169389128685, 0.04083332419395447, 0.08883685618638992, -0.040972232818603516, -0.022615613415837288, 0.05435345694422722, 0.005465168040245771, -0.041820548474788666, -0.03755398839712143, -0.07721813023090363, 0.020000990480184555, 0.01886267401278019, -0.01967802457511425, 0.000731046253349632, -0.005035645328462124, 0.05643057823181152, 0.016829971224069595, -0.005655283574014902, -0.05536993220448494, -0.004385188687592745, 0.04455946013331413, -0.04362162947654724, 0.025588249787688255, 0.04547901451587677, -0.019913451746106148, -0.009777053259313107, 0.0028338294941931963, -0.04896900802850723, 0.02197931706905365, -0.001574444118887186, 0.033335402607917786, 0.03589542210102081, -0.018510781228542328, -0.018154049292206764, 0.008171528577804565, 0.045793719589710236, -0.053953252732753754, -0.060382161289453506, 0.033634815365076065, 0.03620213270187378, -0.023492418229579926, 0.07396694272756577, 0.016983848065137863, 0.036851875483989716, -0.004342505242675543, -0.008880922570824623, 0.024787845090031624, -0.05042017996311188, 0.010925160720944405, 0.017797494307160378, 0.0047524916008114815, -0.04533911123871803, -0.011218583211302757, -0.026339413598179817, 0.0433054119348526, -0.0020260298624634743, -0.023516546934843063, -0.07996144145727158, -0.0019003142369911075, -0.012472905218601227, -0.017409594729542732, -0.04248274117708206, 0.09390725940465927, -0.01459119189530611, -0.0068752760998904705, -0.021598855033516884, -0.016278665512800217, -0.019031748175621033, 0.01253820676356554, 0.01349172368645668, 0.04673808068037033, -0.006084203254431486, 0.04819415882229805, 0.042161259800195694, -0.02248811535537243, -0.07472722232341766, 0.03929338604211807, -0.013164418749511242, -0.01827065274119377, -0.029896097257733345, -0.015087943524122238, 0.027883382514119148, -0.0003851894289255142, -0.0566384494304657, -0.012961185537278652, -0.03854591026902199, 0.06105609983205795, 0.006418476812541485, 0.01727350428700447, -0.04226632043719292, -0.04456007853150368, -0.04976915195584297, 0.042537227272987366, -0.030323471873998642, -0.08571897447109222, 0.04657598212361336, -0.01683976873755455, -0.014880127273499966, 0.029805446043610573, -0.014761111699044704, 0.05426015704870224, -0.0543082095682621, 0.06888925284147263, -0.007332737557590008, -0.029742879793047905, -0.027120601385831833, 0.01832805573940277, -0.004588523413985968, 0.05398682504892349, -0.07846565544605255, -0.027584727853536606, 0.01331291627138853, 0.03555409982800484, -0.00021937010751571506, -0.012772331945598125, -0.04177430644631386, -0.003182884305715561, -0.016459833830595016, -0.009816231206059456, -0.01035301387310028, 0.00041194670484401286, 0.03715930134057999, -0.06657592207193375, 0.009350594133138657, 0.03322141617536545, -0.024018431082367897, -0.036341674625873566, 0.04106865078210831, -0.02485681138932705, -0.04334065690636635, 0.03226115182042122, 0.05468684807419777, -0.053824443370103836, -0.031323373317718506, -0.0602390393614769, 0.011831684038043022, 0.00811714306473732, -0.06391073763370514, 0.0006379250553436577, -0.003066884120926261, -0.0037151705473661423 ]
<p>In aircraft literature, what does cross-track and along-track wind directions mean? Please explain in terms of the aircraft's motion relative to the wind direction. I can hazard a guess: along-track is wind in the direction of the aircraft's velocity, and cross-track would be perpendicular side-to-side (or is it top-bottom) wind direction wrt to aircraft velcoity direction? Not sure...some explanation and clarification would help. Thanks. </p>
g4205
[ 0.010407666675746441, 0.016118362545967102, -0.007817940786480904, 0.039023831486701965, -0.0038106830324977636, 0.03795841708779335, 0.058037467300891876, 0.019007908180356026, -0.039284009486436844, 0.00302086747251451, -0.006841443013399839, -0.011235847137868404, 0.006072808988392353, 0.008558644913136959, 0.014638696797192097, -0.04493040591478348, 0.01686636172235012, -0.022853447124361992, 0.019952215254306793, -0.022876376286149025, 0.021485842764377594, 0.029493257403373718, -0.029145678505301476, 0.04038998857140541, -0.024133577942848206, -0.04085810109972954, -0.03563026711344719, -0.05833725258708, -0.07861417531967163, -0.01771099679172039, 0.07958552241325378, -0.02571684867143631, 0.05426141619682312, -0.024706732481718063, -0.05667586624622345, 0.030899832025170326, -0.06446684896945953, 0.028520775958895683, -0.02092915028333664, 0.019738269969820976, 0.017510829493403435, -0.008157161995768547, 0.04303417354822159, -0.023247424513101578, 0.024932285770773888, 0.023207159712910652, -0.04345881566405296, 0.0052323006093502045, 0.031123880296945572, -0.03310418874025345, -0.026341760531067848, 0.03864354267716408, 0.04260140657424927, -0.024348530918359756, -0.0008955479715950787, -0.010844857431948185, 0.08753620088100433, 0.017521969974040985, -0.009995131753385067, -0.007316043600440025, 0.045898307114839554, 0.052982669323682785, -0.07374054193496704, -0.01182573288679123, 0.08509748429059982, -0.025414401665329933, -0.019514363259077072, -0.024677768349647522, -0.014331189915537834, -0.016759615391492844, 0.057109534740448, -0.02163124270737171, 0.017243729904294014, -0.014821480959653854, -0.01753523014485836, -0.036808501929044724, 0.005388995166867971, -0.08959637582302094, 0.06505729258060455, -0.0271472055464983, 0.04962538182735443, -0.09451035410165787, -0.013266096822917461, 0.06013055890798569, 0.09076051414012909, -0.0065656621009111404, 0.002913976553827524, 0.050274595618247986, -0.06319533288478851, 0.024802226573228836, 0.007617613300681114, -0.058077264577150345, 0.03441079705953598, -0.005316832568496466, -0.04544573277235031, -0.05863653123378754, -0.05121871456503868, 0.07119367271661758, -0.005182039458304644, 0.04764143005013466, -0.06400086730718613, 0.005446486175060272, -0.009804676286876202, 0.0058039212599396706, 0.006584612186998129, 0.06219584494829178, 0.05528132990002632, 0.06984002143144608, -0.002291022101417184, -0.044611550867557526, -0.023796848952770233, 0.0036799930967390537, 0.024550285190343857, 0.03694525733590126, -0.009614981710910797, 0.00857485830783844, 0.013434569351375103, 0.029490312561392784, 0.02985846996307373, 0.007294447626918554, 0.017026610672473907, -0.016590196639299393, -0.0034374678507447243, 0.04375574737787247, 0.001588181359693408, 0.00025617872597649693, 0.002159184543415904, 0.024544719606637955, -0.016799626871943474, 0.02830771543085575, 0.06258153915405273, 0.0011735636508092284, 0.002939113648608327, 0.014774796552956104, 0.03638748079538345, -0.0569002702832222, 0.019049767404794693, 0.04807537421584129, 0.009795017540454865, -0.053448665887117386, 0.01032013725489378, 0.0276077501475811, -0.007353318855166435, -0.004093020688742399, -0.05531325936317444, -0.0013027405366301537, 0.0002847225114237517, -0.042567815631628036, 0.009948168881237507, -0.017656786367297173, 0.011383933946490288, 0.04068366438150406, -0.06454402953386307, -0.039641059935092926, -0.04472019150853157, -0.014991546981036663, -0.05214991793036461, 0.036824990063905716, 0.0020189019851386547, 0.0010935532627627254, 0.0681639090180397, 0.0467529296875, -0.01132900919765234, 0.00382696813903749, -0.02016337588429451, 0.002818712266162038, -0.01287061907351017, -0.006007826887071133, 0.013208011165261269, 0.02686179056763649, -0.011730635538697243, 0.0021823663264513016, 0.033818166702985764, 0.047968607395887375, 0.04580449312925339, 0.042838480323553085, 0.052252188324928284, -0.018209299072623253, 0.02706332504749298, -0.03812965378165245, 0.011772600002586842, 0.08355850726366043, 0.01463068276643753, 0.010244634933769703, 0.016621628776192665, -0.040592364966869354, -0.04447953402996063, -0.04758808761835098, -0.04800645262002945, 0.00750918360427022, 0.024128098040819168, -0.02382998913526535, -0.002096263924613595, 0.0324002206325531, -0.034731410443782806, -0.039657555520534515, -0.01101361121982336, 0.00006220593058969826, 0.004574857652187347, -0.005206538364291191, 0.02287917770445347, -0.027031710371375084, 0.088301882147789, -0.0025786305777728558, -0.06720943003892899, 0.09038545936346054, -0.01997528038918972, -0.0038673279341310263, 0.045336443930864334, 0.047199543565511703, -0.01716253161430359, -0.03435632213950157, 0.08214099705219269, 0.034561797976493835, 0.005579323507845402, 0.016866544261574745, 0.014632687903940678, -0.03217259421944618, -0.03687123954296112, -0.016602277755737305, 0.028772199526429176, -0.015663892030715942, 0.007126789074391127, -0.033074673265218735, 0.026069851592183113, -0.042399875819683075, -0.0004980380181223154, -0.007581642828881741, 0.06753304600715637, -0.00009834330558078364, -0.039819974452257156, -0.03394787386059761, -0.029490917921066284, -0.050160083919763565, 0.04604073613882065, -0.019999027252197266, 0.04682370647788048, 0.055449046194553375, 0.05677785351872444, -0.014734916388988495, 0.003555663162842393, -0.02036980912089348, 0.011506551876664162, 0.02417776919901371, 0.016135523095726967, 0.011379391886293888, 0.06004976108670235, -0.0347893126308918, 0.004835581406950951, 0.01851683482527733, 0.0388207733631134, -0.011252514086663723, -0.004150450229644775, 0.00502873444929719, -0.02436818554997444, -0.01990571618080139, -0.03856515511870384, 0.0035023335367441177, -0.026292050257325172, 0.02152317948639393, -0.003861362813040614, -0.02355882152915001, -0.015005173161625862, -0.002448484767228365, -0.007642228156328201, -0.01335929799824953, -0.0004798929439857602, 0.06699653714895248, 0.027824683114886284, -0.036967165768146515, -0.03070504404604435, 0.02048470452427864, 0.05322226509451866, 0.04730749502778053, 0.02224709838628769, -0.04271695017814636, 0.02223878540098667, 0.009935049340128899, -0.038337454199790955, 0.024056827649474144, 0.03624776378273964, -0.0429583378136158, 0.022995339706540108, 0.016005920246243477, 0.018930286169052124, -0.012590997852385044, -0.022655008360743523, 0.029971087351441383, 0.031505294144153595, 0.054220717400312424, -0.004052203148603439, -0.010435618460178375, 0.011055468581616879, -0.07502275705337524, 0.045350924134254456, -0.08144975453615189, 0.035482726991176605, 0.05807892605662346, 0.03157053887844086, -0.020116837695240974, -0.05413489043712616, 0.026428990066051483, 0.02912946417927742, 0.01995616964995861, 0.0017659780569374561, 0.021609032526612282, -0.056034915149211884, -0.05256244167685509, -0.01700032688677311, 0.01244720071554184, -0.05204404518008232, -0.01501407939940691, 0.017168384045362473, -0.0026341562625020742, -0.014557687565684319, -0.02216452918946743, -0.08941204845905304, 0.03705020621418953, -0.023828493431210518, 0.034124817699193954, -0.0352124385535717, -0.03197817876935005, 0.006460648030042648, -0.00573268998414278, -0.05833514407277107, -0.03309938311576843, 0.052426647394895554, 0.019474130123853683, 0.046189967542886734, -0.05592816323041916, -0.009015494026243687, -0.014742040075361729, 0.036441728472709656, 0.04407469928264618, 0.0029096989892423153, -0.009295254945755005, -0.010221946984529495, 0.012182377278804779, 0.03569658845663071, 0.02290186658501625, 0.06897243112325668, -0.039104562252759933, 0.010045372880995274, -0.012678917497396469, -0.04377957805991173, -0.006829061545431614, 0.05104059725999832, 0.04134376347064972, 0.015358401462435722, 0.032054655253887177, 0.01030021347105503, -0.015932444483041763, -0.0595882423222065, -0.016653578728437424, -0.03753092512488365, 0.009934249334037304, 0.03552177548408508, 0.022628942504525185, 0.0036485313903540373, 0.051041968166828156, -0.023536603897809982, 0.011638260446488857, -0.04871750622987747, -0.04251624271273613, -0.0017183638410642743, -0.04496749863028526, 0.024256713688373566, -0.029841195791959763, 0.013724283315241337, 0.00010373874829383567, 0.020584670826792717, -0.02912360057234764, -0.01630507968366146, -0.020104555413126945, -0.019953953102231026, -0.04456882178783417, 0.0405532531440258, -0.01046623382717371, 0.014668170362710953, 0.007904695346951485, 0.017861848697066307, 0.047316331416368484, -0.007743299473077059, 0.08552981913089752, 0.01757705584168434, -0.0070462399162352085, -0.04786740615963936, -0.011958627961575985, 0.005993234924972057, -0.03431158885359764, 0.02396906353533268, 0.06156819313764572, -0.07343388348817825, -0.04204774275422096, -0.02192472107708454, -0.008803267031908035, 0.008737380616366863, 0.05475904047489166, -0.0041347406804561615, 0.04870137199759483, 0.08458459377288818, 0.006381995044648647, -0.044533032923936844, 0.029814716428518295, -0.011571533046662807, 0.03459582105278969, -0.0243203267455101, -0.009418080560863018, -0.007442797534167767, 0.003963431343436241, 0.06574418395757675, -0.02255210094153881, -0.06651896238327026, -0.04824528843164444, -0.013298559933900833, 0.017435535788536072, -0.02516561560332775, 0.04242732748389244, 0.03112105280160904, 0.025607362389564514, 0.0233001746237278, -0.012244128622114658, 0.03742203116416931, -0.01571144536137581, -0.044175274670124054, 0.0846632570028305, 0.008012993261218071, -0.052341610193252563, -0.021290114149451256, -0.0002527276810724288, 0.04684784263372421, 0.03580222651362419, -0.006028778851032257, 0.027361195534467697, 0.0033253859728574753, 0.009971958585083485, 0.019191863015294075, 0.033902689814567566, 0.05532156303524971, -0.008333075791597366, -0.0055220527574419975, 0.01495255995541811, -0.051009442657232285, -0.0065557099878787994, -0.09662972390651703, -0.00992405042052269, -0.00727849779650569, -0.06595640629529953, -0.05234688147902489, -0.028160223737359047, -0.08301655948162079, -0.0012516031274572015, -0.03928108885884285, 0.0062262918800115585, -0.05062289908528328, -0.024994587525725365, -0.012177448719739914, -0.04193874076008797, -0.013529905118048191, -0.034723393619060516, -0.03784307464957237, 0.0018140699248760939, 0.014389446936547756, 0.0345911905169487, -0.0027782043907791376, 0.056367695331573486, 0.009008459746837616, -0.009632437489926815, -0.05119018256664276, -0.012247140519320965, -0.03768046572804451, 0.020163239911198616, -0.02048625983297825, 0.0001654508669162169, -0.05313224717974663, 0.05497019365429878, 0.016344968229532242, -0.016636934131383896, -0.03560250997543335, 0.01991446502506733, 0.006221679970622063, -0.04025055840611458, 0.04180693253874779, 0.006572194863110781, -0.02347114309668541, -0.06499198079109192, -0.001478332793340087, 0.01344609260559082, 0.05224771797657013, -0.040926091372966766, -0.010730675421655178, -0.01952631026506424, -0.055211834609508514, 0.017082571983337402, -0.04327905923128128, -0.04864048957824707, -0.01881573162972927, -0.04190630465745926, 0.027515867725014687, -0.07004660367965698, 0.041777774691581726, 0.04803573340177536, 0.04355316981673241, 0.003412405727431178, -0.003706977004185319, 0.04159443452954292, 0.025799252092838287, -0.03848017752170563, -0.033668916672468185, 0.00673223752528429, -0.016170784831047058, -0.0035634248051792383, -0.029920022934675217, -0.024303652346134186, 0.004090487491339445, 0.015819193795323372, -0.012177200056612492, 0.020594563335180283, 0.027367908507585526, 0.015954144299030304, -0.01902279257774353, -0.010882532224059105, -0.03838779777288437, -0.028194764629006386, -0.003516428405418992, -0.05391347035765648, -0.05685844644904137, 0.021788345649838448, 0.033207688480615616, -0.019784308969974518, -0.017526376992464066, 0.01357189193367958, 0.055642660707235336, 0.03633902966976166, -0.005829279311001301, -0.04476970434188843, 0.0350317545235157, -0.05634204298257828, 0.033444296568632126, 0.015059067867696285, -0.02365029975771904, 0.02849743887782097, -0.0708971619606018, 0.03614839166402817, -0.06974855810403824, -0.04213123023509979, -0.012105272151529789, -0.04022124037146568, 0.022284505888819695, -0.03584541007876396, 0.0007497925544157624, -0.025941984727978706, 0.023886917158961296, -0.053888898342847824, -0.029375744983553886, 0.006248957477509975, 0.003533086972311139, -0.02529003471136093, -0.04383047670125961, -0.0281132273375988, 0.054871246218681335, -0.020301545038819313, 0.025803761556744576, 0.0042938594706356525, -0.012544510886073112, 0.009138241410255432, -0.03295452892780304, 0.0032249800860881805, 0.024421509355306625, -0.01804843544960022, -0.0243096724152565, -0.05970980226993561, -0.015052523463964462, 0.05651633441448212, 0.03154012933373451, 0.022704467177391052, -0.017209472134709358, 0.014089254662394524, -0.005692521575838327, 0.017878126353025436, 0.026908058673143387, -0.006036098580807447, 0.005467756651341915, -0.051490843296051025, -0.06763577461242676, -0.008939344435930252, -0.04466557875275612, -0.011498406529426575, -0.040001243352890015, 0.009190880693495274, -0.036017682403326035, -0.005689360201358795, -0.01173282228410244, -0.016429631039500237, -0.04639064893126488, 0.013750532642006874, -0.01776476390659809, 0.06528718024492264, 0.04357430338859558, -0.018464747816324234, -0.0046750567853450775, 0.022609619423747063, 0.0815570130944252, -0.033360715955495834, 0.03942300006747246, 0.050748638808727264, 0.011091603897511959, -0.03357619047164917, 0.022422682493925095, -0.01661631464958191, 0.004064636770635843, 0.04624423757195473, 0.0038948117289692163, 0.01896505057811737, -0.026177385821938515, 0.016649937257170677, -0.04757161810994148, -0.03268229588866234, -0.00582363223657012, -0.005754943937063217, 0.004257396329194307, -0.00717339850962162, -0.0011059262324124575, 0.03884126991033554, 0.029367204755544662, 0.018944501876831055, -0.05271901935338974, 0.014462168328464031, 0.013553899712860584, 0.024094268679618835, 0.029299646615982056, -0.0007397993467748165, 0.015188591554760933, 0.014347309246659279, 0.010924306698143482, -0.018466955050826073, 0.017092255875468254, 0.007074824068695307, 0.04734784737229347, 0.018930163234472275, -0.021570706740021706, 0.012797556817531586, -0.013843509368598461, -0.035766392946243286, -0.020400363951921463, -0.0032238976564258337, -0.018248863518238068, -0.07596075534820557, 0.048271045088768005, -0.04495067521929741, -0.0540446862578392, -0.03837023302912712, -0.019293779507279396, 0.053018081933259964, 0.0036241912748664618, 0.030523499473929405, 0.025175128132104874, -0.019497700035572052, 0.021117383614182472, 0.031233208253979683, -0.042941171675920486, -0.021788502112030983, -0.05455554276704788, 0.06832155585289001, -0.03403214365243912, -0.005314423702657223, 0.03837401047348976, -0.003714027814567089, -0.044555261731147766, -0.016138067469000816, 0.037153393030166626, -0.0058403536677360535, 0.017841845750808716, 0.03772640973329544, -0.01840861327946186, -0.020643919706344604, -0.015078257769346237, 0.05751819908618927, -0.016872460022568703, -0.011075071059167385, -0.0005750330747105181, -0.028784746304154396, 0.0038925085682421923, -0.014492022804915905, 0.015198198147118092, 0.04530585929751396, 0.037758324295282364, 0.03155612573027611, -0.06715274602174759, -0.0978463888168335, -0.04639022424817085, -0.002329690847545862, 0.058402691036462784, 0.005367247387766838, -0.044912464916706085, 0.024144195020198822, 0.03864406794309616, 0.02393648959696293, 0.011538488790392876, 0.05729147046804428, 0.0353984460234642, 0.02230304665863514, 0.02686191536486149, 0.06742960214614868, 0.005989851430058479, -0.013492284342646599, -0.0023601846769452095, -0.020745476707816124, -0.007452385500073433, 0.008771981112658978, -0.09217400848865509, -0.0013450131518766284, 0.043203048408031464, 0.07297012209892273, -0.045252978801727295, -0.059438370168209076, 0.06527343392372131, -0.05174089968204498, -0.04199366644024849, 0.07357968389987946, -0.03483323007822037, 0.02886943332850933, -0.017963366582989693, 0.027536574751138687, 0.02262823097407818, -0.005713450722396374, -0.018146779388189316, -0.013097954913973808, 0.01991533674299717, -0.0723041296005249, 0.023658694699406624, 0.007585778366774321, 0.034183721989393234, 0.03936394676566124, -0.04053446277976036, 0.04510895535349846, 0.043609004467725754, -0.031585656106472015, 0.009017259813845158, 0.009197423234581947, 0.0667869970202446, 0.020565472543239594, -0.06983336061239243, -0.022562194615602493, -0.13082394003868103, -0.01278353575617075, 0.06370582431554794, 0.03142105042934418, -0.033707596361637115, -0.022620733827352524, 0.05943187326192856, 0.08427632600069046, 0.06501035392284393, 0.03533227741718292, 0.00458248658105731, 0.03190219774842262, 0.042419806122779846, 0.019707035273313522, -0.03362307697534561, 0.06423670798540115, -0.046691276133060455, -0.010677095502614975, 0.010221095755696297, -0.031248334795236588, -0.04568779841065407, 0.0045281569473445415, -0.09851009398698807, 0.033854227513074875 ]
<p>It has always been claimed decoherence solves the problem of the preferred-basis for observed probability distributions, but why should this be the case? If there is only one world, and there are probabilities for certain outcomes, why should the basis in which the probabilities are observed coincide with the pointer basis determined dynamically by decoherence?</p>
g4206
[ 0.03659028187394142, 0.009006536565721035, 0.021850375458598137, -0.024665910750627518, 0.01406050194054842, -0.012288441881537437, 0.058600347489118576, 0.0415274053812027, -0.014271805062890053, -0.037854716181755066, 0.02996651642024517, -0.03158029168844223, 0.019476227462291718, 0.04645080491900444, -0.04776337370276451, 0.019076872617006302, 0.03155726566910744, 0.009753428399562836, -0.01828267052769661, 0.01519160345196724, -0.02406182512640953, -0.0547696128487587, 0.03109668754041195, 0.02331756241619587, -0.056529100984334946, -0.010470984503626823, -0.031582675874233246, -0.054132286459207535, -0.020907672122120857, 0.05504510924220085, 0.026633867993950844, 0.01816120743751526, 0.008271497674286366, -0.02682793326675892, 0.01480680052191019, 0.0060187228955328465, -0.03193388879299164, 0.04178959131240845, 0.029201343655586243, -0.02274538204073906, -0.015770835801959038, 0.04615623131394386, 0.020738700404763222, -0.04555342346429825, -0.03021835908293724, 0.002966371364891529, -0.0032554124481976032, 0.006162852514535189, 0.020072519779205322, -0.07164565473794937, -0.009563915431499481, -0.011394497007131577, 0.041323207318782806, 0.04764228314161301, 0.05945846810936928, 0.05971980839967728, 0.030843613669276237, -0.029224703088402748, -0.0046736104413867, -0.00626361882314086, 0.05829927697777748, -0.025644689798355103, -0.03325697407126427, -0.07979783415794373, 0.0071810949593782425, 0.007513760589063168, -0.06789638102054596, -0.018808430060744286, 0.04382839798927307, -0.028654854744672775, -0.03791768476366997, -0.005988381803035736, -0.06954658776521683, -0.0014377849875018, 0.032661572098731995, -0.035311054438352585, 0.009411814622581005, 0.014571954496204853, 0.04118392616510391, 0.09101226180791855, -0.0814606249332428, -0.04030706733465195, 0.03948849439620972, -0.01307730097323656, 0.02457769773900509, -0.008475487120449543, 0.03683086857199669, -0.029475228860974312, -0.014768886379897594, 0.01384073868393898, 0.0015383090358227491, -0.0076490845531225204, 0.07430031895637512, 0.0018230407731607556, -0.041409023106098175, 0.02036399021744728, -0.060119856148958206, 0.00787806510925293, 0.023810217157006264, -0.007100548595190048, 0.0054837726056575775, -0.002402830170467496, 0.025504853576421738, 0.013782002031803131, 0.0017588818445801735, -0.013871602714061737, -0.05295485258102417, 0.040613725781440735, -0.03364523500204086, -0.013096561655402184, -0.006274165585637093, 0.017408905550837517, -0.010037827305495739, 0.01599433459341526, -0.03682062402367592, -0.0246510561555624, 0.09525460749864578, -0.058658305555582047, 0.005036098416894674, 0.020714502781629562, -0.05092000588774681, -0.03958453610539436, -0.005042674485594034, 0.0501314215362072, -0.012198890559375286, 0.02154812030494213, 0.018117250874638557, -0.00815826840698719, 0.0483541414141655, -0.02581637352705002, 0.038402020931243896, 0.043990712612867355, -0.004185939207673073, 0.03977679833769798, 0.0006799405091442168, -0.0007400354370474815, 0.056816987693309784, 0.0399135947227478, 0.04514053463935852, 0.07096397131681442, -0.010739297606050968, -0.0215168260037899, -0.0047009713016450405, -0.03360685333609581, -0.010863685049116611, -0.02789926342666149, -0.02029106207191944, -0.0003838335978798568, 0.07451827079057693, 0.06011095643043518, -0.012076995335519314, 0.018993839621543884, -0.04437650367617607, -0.031730033457279205, 0.007096783723682165, 0.004858176223933697, -0.014347290620207787, -0.05698712170124054, -0.005381157621741295, -0.017323315143585205, 0.11096233874559402, 0.02752772904932499, -0.0435042679309845, -0.017357511445879936, 0.026889832690358162, -0.028792908415198326, 0.01131326425820589, -0.05393832176923752, 0.00024201632186304778, -0.06677199900150299, -0.012989466078579426, -0.012150890193879604, 0.012169936671853065, 0.007354642264544964, 0.012002520263195038, 0.06015869975090027, 0.004926210269331932, 0.028663255274295807, 0.026896923780441284, 0.08144247531890869, -0.016495201736688614, 0.03394639492034912, 0.002144757891073823, 0.005753493867814541, 0.0401495099067688, -0.002103505888953805, -0.021163739264011383, 0.03284657001495361, 0.003293230663985014, -0.015012773685157299, 0.029060088098049164, -0.0007845571381039917, -0.06386987119913101, 0.03980744257569313, -0.008010797202587128, -0.04215331748127937, -0.00519950408488512, -0.00004688484114012681, -0.060857973992824554, 0.021066417917609215, 0.015857528895139694, -0.0058876206167042255, -0.01793508231639862, 0.028699349611997604, -0.017497418448328972, -0.056388672441244125, 0.05198843404650688, 0.06522821635007858, 0.01820989139378071, -0.019781673327088356, 0.024100515991449356, -0.08308907598257065, -0.05860500782728195, 0.03648202493786812, -0.043002717196941376, -0.045034896582365036, 0.0035730169620364904, 0.03184625878930092, -0.017523955553770065, 0.028651980683207512, -0.03694310411810875, -0.0527450367808342, 0.05599644407629967, -0.00984483677893877, -0.02378975600004196, 0.05755024775862694, -0.059259600937366486, -0.046409670263528824, -0.0008812996093183756, 0.07603267580270767, -0.034556612372398376, -0.05476340651512146, -0.05140864476561546, -0.005252464674413204, 0.02701651304960251, 0.058854568749666214, -0.047230374068021774, 0.000003380351699888706, 0.051593516021966934, -0.006443446036428213, 0.03910788893699646, -0.03633630648255348, -0.022202232852578163, 0.015647370368242264, 0.04250538349151611, -0.04144124686717987, 0.005189071875065565, -0.028824059292674065, 0.04175393655896187, 0.015232456848025322, -0.06412360072135925, -0.037832677364349365, -0.04261629283428192, -0.05580194294452667, -0.019947730004787445, -0.06794439256191254, 0.01705474592745304, -0.02363049052655697, -0.059254419058561325, 0.00248834490776062, 0.03773076832294464, -0.030326351523399353, 0.001602906035259366, -0.01263051014393568, 0.009352766908705235, 0.0456877127289772, 0.03610726818442345, -0.0075649721547961235, -0.012991411611437798, -0.0421314612030983, 0.00505107594653964, 0.033623650670051575, 0.030316848307847977, 0.04876872897148132, 0.014386297203600407, 0.07195034623146057, -0.01776333525776863, -0.024898001924157143, -0.02248135581612587, 0.012800788506865501, 0.02079620212316513, -0.01752675510942936, -0.02998700924217701, -0.04395195096731186, 0.024071840569376945, -0.02183505892753601, 0.00204163184389472, 0.029012758284807205, -0.012674687430262566, 0.031995631754398346, -0.020503833889961243, 0.07157706469297409, 0.021557167172431946, 0.01597970724105835, 0.008731895126402378, 0.01759224571287632, 0.028195908293128014, -0.008967651054263115, -0.009683064185082912, -0.0034997512120753527, -0.015868769958615303, 0.01043993141502142, -0.014711790718138218, -0.012404526583850384, 0.03221431002020836, 0.0212203748524189, -0.03157839551568031, 0.04892989620566368, -0.021637771278619766, -0.003310528350993991, -0.0005827900022268295, 0.036278851330280304, -0.09491909295320511, -0.03476811200380325, -0.01687367632985115, 0.0008613517275080085, -0.01805754005908966, 0.010077428072690964, -0.02894393540918827, -0.025692911818623543, -0.00778122479096055, 0.06900514662265778, -0.003996849525719881, -0.016384867951273918, 0.05418167635798454, 0.03318759426474571, -0.06591436266899109, 0.06254912167787552, -0.014444835484027863, -0.040065325796604156, -0.0019075426971539855, 0.00860375165939331, 0.04260221868753433, -0.004245407413691282, -0.05977438762784004, -0.06111724674701691, -0.01881645992398262, -0.0009172470308840275, -0.03318193554878235, 0.0324125699698925, -0.0036174245178699493, -0.042977601289749146, 0.011222359724342823, 0.013159678317606449, 0.012267240323126316, 0.02772820182144642, -0.012644993141293526, 0.007844450883567333, 0.060207489877939224, -0.011016914620995522, -0.011399995535612106, 0.00544437812641263, -0.002076725708320737, -0.020057398825883865, 0.006752598565071821, 0.06211915239691734, -0.030716340988874435, -0.023639291524887085, 0.06209662929177284, -0.028707725927233696, 0.012612074613571167, 0.008631136268377304, -0.02899346314370632, 0.009408336132764816, -0.028902264311909676, -0.02192019857466221, 0.010038460604846478, 0.056300364434719086, 0.00035148399183526635, -0.010356158018112183, 0.03762392699718475, 0.03581509366631508, 0.018731549382209778, 0.006256705615669489, 0.06903676688671112, 0.0011730761034414172, 0.02888898365199566, 0.025705445557832718, -0.02583298459649086, -0.016217689961194992, 0.0450621135532856, 0.06273922324180603, -0.03561112657189369, -0.025190060958266258, 0.038411013782024384, 0.028632111847400665, -0.018793432042002678, -0.01145955454558134, -0.031063135713338852, -0.0018223881488665938, -0.012700765393674374, -0.022459082305431366, 0.01872395910322666, -0.012365838512778282, 0.02851785346865654, -0.0012303092516958714, -0.03912024572491646, -0.0012393203796818852, -0.02816486731171608, 0.0012542058248072863, 0.011699728667736053, -0.00465186545625329, -0.052044015377759933, -0.021081039682030678, 0.05533847585320473, -0.0007905895472504199, -0.037162475287914276, -0.032042644917964935, -0.06766730546951294, -0.006223550532013178, 0.017603689804673195, 0.10355987399816513, 0.012303704395890236, -0.06648732721805573, 0.03644128516316414, -0.028202198445796967, 0.04364708811044693, 0.03206459432840347, 0.06613703817129135, -0.02232564054429531, -0.022102413699030876, 0.02427983470261097, 0.003093329258263111, -0.05504582077264786, 0.022347329184412956, 0.03388893976807594, 0.004781326744705439, -0.03982541337609291, 0.016396043822169304, -0.027661556378006935, 0.013256301172077656, 0.01665590889751911, -0.03593822568655014, 0.018391907215118408, -0.049618884921073914, -0.012851306237280369, 0.06105292588472366, 0.04845442995429039, 0.04032381623983383, 0.026957985013723373, 0.026223422959446907, -0.023521704599261284, 0.014362297020852566, -0.028656236827373505, 0.01308352965861559, 0.011687111109495163, 0.01943795569241047, -0.04513655602931976, 0.057599157094955444, -0.013681819662451744, -0.02957809343934059, 0.016763953492045403, 0.02084944397211075, -0.024155089631676674, 0.08647450059652328, -0.07561235129833221, -0.032696954905986786, 0.0739680752158165, 0.030540740117430687, 0.03763262927532196, -0.01865474507212639, 0.0022209021262824535, -0.009424925781786442, -0.030517248436808586, -0.00904441811144352, 0.03127336874604225, -0.04910856857895851, 0.009058949537575245, -0.0160708948969841, -0.02689453586935997, 0.010314805433154106, 0.0019062741193920374, 0.006305080372840166, 0.039275262504816055, 0.0327640026807785, 0.06098709627985954, -0.013145326636731625, -0.023952938616275787, 0.002781666349619627, -0.055234525352716446, -0.07166557013988495, 0.028565607964992523, 0.022155415266752243, -0.0003720396780408919, -0.020180415362119675, 0.007325317710638046, 0.005857804324477911, -0.08679703623056412, -0.02422761730849743, -0.03637760132551193, 0.045845549553632736, 0.00010272546205669641, 0.01135361660271883, -0.025478387251496315, 0.029498431831598282, -0.09170347452163696, 0.01418708823621273, 0.015009129419922829, 0.006668530870229006, -0.042016807943582535, -0.07594666630029678, 0.0017765165539458394, 0.0025014516431838274, 0.0018672164296731353, -0.030271904543042183, 0.05967865139245987, 0.06790953129529953, -0.026248427107930183, 0.006774986628443003, -0.004720319528132677, -0.009293229319155216, -0.032523203641176224, 0.01238990481942892, 0.06153111159801483, 0.013462004251778126, -0.046956826001405716, -0.017544729635119438, -0.0029784864746034145, -0.007849681191146374, -0.030098378658294678, -0.00470523489639163, 0.012898893095552921, -0.0090794637799263, -0.012741983868181705, -0.01598144881427288, -0.04667172208428383, -0.02167949080467224, -0.03592442348599434, -0.03842349350452423, -0.0014567500911653042, 0.05804688110947609, 0.027676789090037346, 0.02523481287062168, 0.01201931294053793, -0.005268238019198179, -0.1003248542547226, 0.0042568594217300415, -0.010729589499533176, 0.0208023302257061, 0.012242856435477734, -0.025697819888591766, -0.007517846766859293, 0.0877428725361824, -0.0034334659576416016, -0.0001869389379862696, -0.028007538989186287, -0.022005731239914894, 0.02971300669014454, -0.02489950880408287, -0.06841830909252167, 0.013767448253929615, 0.031724974513053894, 0.014954090118408203, -0.017343414947390556, 0.0008978385594673455, 0.046590548008680344, 0.05697092413902283, 0.01849670335650444, -0.002500753151252866, -0.023920558393001556, -0.00371502130292356, 0.07976450026035309, 0.018716933205723763, 0.02634345181286335, 0.025136232376098633, -0.004445971921086311, -0.01416962593793869, -0.05225696787238121, -0.03011311963200569, 0.021705565974116325, -0.024904457852244377, 0.022880544885993004, 0.051281239837408066, 0.011645008809864521, 0.011002669110894203, 0.019442206248641014, -0.05043194815516472, -0.0729784443974495, -0.01396486721932888, -0.023943807929754257, 0.015724526718258858, -0.05844399333000183, 0.03745058551430702, -0.004824758041650057, -0.02444542944431305, -0.03320564702153206, -0.013274048455059528, -0.019510261714458466, 0.03492601215839386, 0.0035862401127815247, 0.028063036501407623, 0.01628655195236206, 0.060377735644578934, 0.019394947215914726, -0.027109934017062187, -0.011678510345518589, -0.02832723595201969, 0.03566379100084305, -0.04666208103299141, -0.05613133683800697, 0.0297580324113369, -0.030337220057845116, 0.019144058227539062, -0.00773099809885025, 0.03395593538880348, 0.038509827107191086, 0.02251271717250347, 0.042538195848464966, 0.029446840286254883, 0.05365045741200447, 0.002177952555939555, 0.0683857873082161, 0.02383863553404808, 0.04848260432481766, -0.002721379976719618, -0.058092162013053894, -0.04830766096711159, -0.007602292113006115, -0.02473987080156803, 0.028730712831020355, 0.04576306417584419, -0.006131199654191732, -0.019515402615070343, -0.008952525444328785, 0.013541431166231632, 0.08093070983886719, 0.03808017447590828, -0.06647112220525742, 0.02864290587604046, 0.06553826481103897, 0.005513210315257311, 0.010465430095791817, 0.032439589500427246, 0.03303992748260498, -0.03141492232680321, 0.029688144102692604, -0.03456953540444374, 0.07651504129171371, -0.024242866784334183, -0.0416271910071373, 0.028222979977726936, 0.049272164702415466, 0.060874585062265396, -0.04163699597120285, 0.026781810447573662, 0.02417999878525734, 0.11192941665649414, -0.018856152892112732, -0.03847593069076538, -0.005547960754483938, 0.056319378316402435, 0.03370639681816101, 0.042334459722042084, -0.008118821308016777, -0.021989284083247185, 0.0024213276337832212, 0.019556766375899315, -0.028880931437015533, 0.034137383103370667, -0.006685901433229446, -0.09081380069255829, 0.0017448227154091, -0.052864957600831985, -0.04129932075738907, -0.020050380378961563, -0.0564286932349205, -0.0036753108724951744, -0.05571162700653076, -0.03263423964381218, 0.027275489643216133, -0.03134623542428017, -0.006590128876268864, -0.06998687237501144, -0.02366272546350956, -0.02009524405002594, 0.02707326039671898, 0.002123672980815172, 0.013261038810014725, 0.015597648918628693, 0.02697678655385971, 0.03400803357362747, 0.07114670425653458, -0.0340973325073719, -0.03964715078473091, -0.0031036289874464273, 0.018346190452575684, 0.005011197179555893, -0.0470898263156414, -0.061301931738853455, -0.03745919466018677, -0.031147219240665436, -0.03917809575796127, -0.024336088448762894, -0.040577083826065063, -0.09799850732088089, 0.005983749870210886, 0.01769077777862549, -0.010069798678159714, 0.04724728688597679, 0.007105735130608082, -0.041156791150569916, -0.01965896226465702, -0.011679453775286674, -0.002369261346757412, 0.05057829990983009, -0.07157494127750397, 0.03422929719090462, 0.009693989530205727, -0.01776772178709507, -0.035281866788864136, 0.012025916948914528, 0.0016891685081645846, 0.05823289602994919, -0.022579656913876534, -0.07363307476043701, -0.025383206084370613, -0.11164940148591995, 0.024764180183410645, 0.010111008770763874, 0.05831237882375717, 0.00009709866571938619, -0.012542901560664177, 0.01323903352022171, 0.08536454290151596, 0.03187771141529083, -0.009601403959095478, -0.005494000390172005, -0.05807541683316231, 0.00723189627751708, 0.056797802448272705, -0.03455963730812073, -0.005832922179251909, -0.023851532489061356, 0.03243188187479973, -0.030491579324007034, 0.010423651896417141, 0.012491683475673199, 0.02213030308485031, -0.004744087345898151, -0.010464957915246487, -0.02509164996445179, 0.002178692724555731, 0.02096540667116642, -0.0004097876662854105, -0.007246737834066153, -0.012177499011158943, 0.015736587345600128, -0.027945397421717644, 0.0641627162694931, -0.008055845275521278, -0.07713332772254944, -0.02925186976790428, -0.04848119243979454, -0.012655645608901978, 0.05334201827645302, 0.03769957274198532, 0.03269504755735397, 0.030486561357975006, 0.028845880180597305, -0.02789679914712906, 0.008493210189044476, -0.0740027129650116, 0.00676917377859354, 0.003014597110450268, -0.07941760867834091, -0.0028710749465972185, -0.01755739003419876, 0.06418011337518692 ]
<p>I have seen <a href="http://www.physics.sfsu.edu/~lea/courses/ugrad/460notes5.PDF" rel="nofollow">this derivation</a>: </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/goWYX.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <ul> <li><p>I want to estimate what is the intensity of the electrical field as function of $r$ the distance from the radiated source ?</p></li> <li><p>I think it is can modled as pointed source which implies a spherical wave whose intensity goes like $1/r^2$. But I think I remember from school it should be fall like $1/r^3$.</p></li> </ul>
g4207
[ 0.0033867345191538334, -0.0038399461191147566, -0.01702321693301201, -0.036845434457063675, 0.005678889807313681, 0.018826523795723915, 0.018895119428634644, 0.013604411855340004, 0.002066496992483735, -0.020887207239866257, -0.06313400715589523, 0.034336913377046585, 0.029537074267864227, 0.013114203698933125, 0.011961688287556171, -0.025912804529070854, 0.03760561719536781, -0.05274321883916855, -0.0028349359054118395, 0.00848517008125782, 0.002979949815198779, -0.05599913373589516, 0.025309277698397636, -0.05561712011694908, 0.002065432257950306, 0.021467488259077072, 0.04132672771811485, -0.0242227204144001, 0.001078868517652154, -0.052341535687446594, -0.0312297772616148, -0.019477613270282745, 0.034641992300748825, 0.01972213201224804, -0.021285252645611763, 0.0005668707890436053, 0.016362637281417847, 0.022540219128131866, 0.0333392359316349, 0.061151571571826935, 0.005948270671069622, -0.048496026545763016, 0.029505236074328423, 0.03627627715468407, -0.021232321858406067, -0.043789077550172806, 0.003059757873415947, 0.06781483441591263, -0.017501279711723328, -0.025837047025561333, -0.042019665241241455, -0.007330889347940683, 0.05609317496418953, 0.014697685837745667, -0.013353614136576653, 0.027506444603204727, -0.0026332370471209288, -0.013744303025305271, 0.03997329995036125, 0.04499107226729393, 0.03535550832748413, -0.03330458700656891, -0.034761905670166016, -0.05303202196955681, 0.02964930608868599, -0.007237961050122976, -0.06732585281133652, -0.01793746091425419, -0.0361742340028286, -0.05654475837945938, 0.009887206368148327, -0.04062407463788986, -0.039643172174692154, -0.005266458727419376, -0.07896481454372406, -0.04017715901136398, -0.0018943189643323421, 0.02890011854469776, -0.02229795791208744, 0.016340475529432297, -0.006552150938659906, -0.050726842135190964, 0.007869977504014969, -0.046203143894672394, 0.031216779723763466, 0.00536195607855916, 0.08208709955215454, 0.024927765130996704, 0.05484519898891449, -0.04128415882587433, 0.05827891081571579, 0.03156507387757301, 0.06885041296482086, -0.046872854232788086, 0.0017610325012356043, -0.00720628909766674, -0.02682778239250183, 0.027950823307037354, 0.03152119740843773, 0.0184316448867321, -0.026561051607131958, 0.004280860535800457, 0.06482477486133575, -0.013356807641685009, 0.0383269228041172, 0.05726597085595131, 0.015743162482976913, -0.03785074129700661, -0.0320875383913517, -0.0024535106495022774, -0.027804182842373848, -0.09964323043823242, -0.04806072637438774, -0.048071764409542084, -0.02038249745965004, -0.016696929931640625, 0.0128976134583354, -0.06054837256669998, 0.023129962384700775, 0.09788299351930618, 0.04044795781373978, 0.004324954003095627, -0.03306565806269646, 0.02340296469628811, 0.006771192420274019, -0.02420373633503914, 0.04093680903315544, -0.010480031371116638, 0.03477887809276581, -0.003524402854964137, -0.010351000353693962, -0.026662765070796013, -0.01084320992231369, -0.008598336949944496, 0.0011232842225581408, 0.02813858538866043, 0.045591212809085846, -0.024173084646463394, -0.009873053058981895, 0.05402720719575882, 0.021851520985364914, -0.05532832816243172, 0.04131181165575981, -0.08264651149511337, -0.037863343954086304, 0.0586564876139164, 0.022763852030038834, -0.025678861886262894, 0.04750394821166992, 0.05531252920627594, 0.0622154176235199, 0.09970901161432266, 0.026745226234197617, 0.009127544239163399, 0.01607188582420349, -0.04803081601858139, 0.003862743964418769, -0.03946578875184059, 0.01564101129770279, -0.04723411053419113, 0.021244611591100693, 0.011456620879471302, -0.011190531775355339, 0.02081225998699665, -0.02790052630007267, -0.05024460703134537, 0.0432688370347023, -0.03199576586484909, 0.0028588182758539915, -0.04930191487073898, -0.029538096860051155, 0.015202106907963753, 0.06587658822536469, -0.01844753511250019, -0.052716366946697235, 0.011887366883456707, -0.009046188555657864, -0.002536199986934662, 0.03194635361433029, 0.052476488053798676, 0.008399918675422668, -0.022189343348145485, 0.030987678095698357, 0.0013153222389519215, -0.011634664610028267, -0.030405085533857346, -0.02367660589516163, 0.01546500250697136, -0.04625736176967621, 0.00591597193852067, -0.01566193625330925, -0.019067147746682167, -0.05056919530034065, 0.039531830698251724, -0.009230418130755424, 0.054302722215652466, 0.0370604544878006, -0.03056664578616619, 0.016512228175997734, 0.0492795892059803, 0.0312567763030529, 0.06088114529848099, 0.022934237495064735, 0.06828290969133377, 0.01171706523746252, 0.011222354136407375, -0.011856813915073872, -0.021165264770388603, -0.024046260863542557, 0.00482120830565691, -0.044594306498765945, -0.05413222312927246, 0.014060053043067455, 0.021642636507749557, -0.027947084978222847, -0.017273694276809692, -0.03438127040863037, 0.03663678094744682, -0.021582454442977905, 0.008473333902657032, -0.04749692231416702, 0.02477109059691429, 0.06680736690759659, 0.013256949372589588, -0.02164877951145172, 0.024938397109508514, -0.006318560801446438, 0.03368236497044563, 0.006640937644988298, 0.03064429946243763, -0.01661175861954689, 0.024529479444026947, -0.0029902267269790173, 0.012763607315719128, 0.05217013880610466, 0.039540451020002365, -0.03058456815779209, -0.058705322444438934, -0.004540103022009134, -0.016358593478798866, -0.007977141998708248, 0.013051411136984825, 0.022892342880368233, 0.012131583876907825, -0.011092975735664368, -0.045419417321681976, 0.07885172963142395, 0.018076092004776, -0.023774662986397743, -0.059151433408260345, 0.04688262566924095, 0.0327967032790184, 0.008064653724431992, 0.049425385892391205, -0.028933845460414886, -0.03210410475730896, -0.036490581929683685, 0.053121671080589294, -0.023967040702700615, -0.029001329094171524, -0.021160060539841652, -0.042410191148519516, 0.042944762855768204, 0.0011296995216980577, -0.00831526704132557, 0.0611923411488533, -0.018971988931298256, -0.014582768082618713, -0.01709759049117565, -0.020547185093164444, -0.002817238913848996, 0.06881362199783325, 0.040600039064884186, 0.0015680462820455432, 0.002660384401679039, 0.004076769109815359, 0.001889614388346672, 0.0010289715137332678, 0.042013391852378845, -0.0022044144570827484, 0.04311766475439072, 0.002334858290851116, -0.03102971240878105, 0.025239864364266396, -0.038372740149497986, -0.113172747194767, 0.04258963093161583, 0.07738134264945984, -0.049395158886909485, -0.05551224201917648, -0.027893930673599243, -0.048590026795864105, 0.021654406562447548, 0.009309950284659863, -0.035439301282167435, 0.011310447007417679, 0.027692260220646858, -0.013163740746676922, 0.03739161416888237, 0.02437325194478035, 0.019396286457777023, -0.011164547875523567, -0.06463813781738281, -0.05530710890889168, -0.02390984818339348, 0.003204242093488574, 0.012557090260088444, -0.06866464763879776, 0.061766255646944046, 0.016232512891292572, -0.011890498921275139, 0.002227271907031536, 0.05816390737891197, 0.016791915521025658, -0.043359994888305664, -0.00777006708085537, 0.010169683955609798, 0.05022846907377243, 0.03804148733615875, 0.02692914567887783, -0.03217174857854843, -0.062039900571107864, 0.039048150181770325, 0.041441891342401505, 0.010408773086965084, 0.06272668391466141, 0.01496811956167221, 0.016949668526649475, 0.010245579294860363, -0.11782335489988327, -0.030620692297816277, -0.062224484980106354, -0.02766427770256996, -0.027409708127379417, -0.003608213970437646, -0.03656565770506859, 0.038532551378011703, 0.06673570722341537, -0.00008036658982746303, 0.06856470555067062, 0.026968583464622498, -0.0034891797695308924, -0.047628019005060196, -0.03685754910111427, -0.01695387251675129, 0.02131369523704052, -0.07815338671207428, -0.022547736763954163, 0.008217067457735538, -0.001972211292013526, 0.0024165266659110785, 0.0024806226138025522, 0.01243449654430151, -0.0617346316576004, 0.0014983684523031116, 0.003385738702490926, 0.027194878086447716, 0.020155692473053932, 0.005789816379547119, -0.006144135259091854, -0.018998080864548683, -0.04601052775979042, 0.06662114709615707, -0.04094703868031502, 0.0016008305829018354, -0.0348309688270092, 0.015144731849431992, 0.04196970537304878, -0.05273742601275444, -0.0014085420407354832, -0.050905991345644, -0.023771144449710846, 0.017394397407770157, 0.021653983741998672, -0.0057606822811067104, -0.003903113305568695, -0.014604706317186356, 0.027380676940083504, -0.06654567271471024, 0.025396065786480904, -0.018934952095150948, 0.05318175628781319, 0.020518826320767403, -0.012157930061221123, 0.01773962378501892, -0.0022217687219381332, -0.012314874678850174, 0.027472330257296562, 0.056180648505687714, -0.06534191966056824, 0.029800644144415855, -0.10262951254844666, -0.007874601520597935, -0.005796808283776045, 0.031378306448459625, -0.029325909912586212, 0.026163844391703606, -0.005510739982128143, -0.03154756873846054, 0.08218415081501007, 0.05492474138736725, 0.0013984767720103264, 0.07387372851371765, 0.014894754625856876, -0.0350162647664547, -0.0019545787945389748, 0.06559456884860992, -0.016300778836011887, 0.00884524267166853, -0.059626493602991104, -0.017128515988588333, -0.00041093642357736826, 0.0016307290643453598, -0.07166839390993118, 0.02925565280020237, -0.004432855173945427, 0.11663465946912766, 0.004034730605781078, 0.05430784448981285, 0.05291492119431496, 0.007121134549379349, 0.0487159863114357, 0.044142946600914, -0.00016714858065824956, -0.014566493220627308, 0.05277140811085701, 0.07878713309764862, -0.021565208211541176, -0.03358389437198639, -0.02155216410756111, -0.009274492040276527, 0.022955218330025673, -0.012637692503631115, 0.049183644354343414, -0.0593763142824173, 0.02737412601709366, -0.016111141070723534, 0.0373324453830719, 0.02320733480155468, -0.022084137424826622, 0.04749539494514465, -0.05715738236904144, 0.026258224621415138, -0.021975593641400337, 0.030333859845995903, 0.017102763056755066, -0.06019267067313194, -0.04359251633286476, -0.006495004054158926, -0.021611856296658516, -0.04566928744316101, -0.017955679446458817, 0.02572716772556305, -0.031156593933701515, -0.01454763300716877, 0.026087122038006783, -0.06788668036460876, 0.011762655340135098, 0.012653845362365246, -0.011773297563195229, 0.009302712976932526, 0.02191070094704628, -0.016092365607619286, -0.03462148830294609, 0.0532258115708828, -0.05224287137389183, -0.07109742611646652, -0.04333355277776718, -0.03876584768295288, -0.004086604341864586, 0.016142092645168304, 0.009615499526262283, 0.04906432330608368, 0.008548540063202381, 0.03474023938179016, 0.019663479179143906, -0.023339757695794106, -0.01690846122801304, -0.015985246747732162, -0.05331626161932945, -0.01854219287633896, -0.050784800201654434, -0.046606987714767456, 0.002805996686220169, -0.034255415201187134, 0.05222254991531372, 0.014241619035601616, 0.028543854132294655, -0.011220574378967285, -0.03063138760626316, 0.0018355173524469137, 0.0015085781924426556, -0.011838085949420929, -0.009495998732745647, -0.011910934932529926, -0.013760293833911419, -0.004666524939239025, -0.02334369719028473, -0.001259934389963746, 0.02878345176577568, -0.06515731662511826, -0.013828057795763016, -0.033574219793081284, 0.06365169584751129, -0.06770706176757812, 0.058591485023498535, 0.07122664153575897, 0.03241860494017601, 0.04500626400113106, 0.0018922409508377314, -0.0014342141803354025, -0.033681515604257584, 0.04540707916021347, -0.0029987841844558716, 0.0029820341151207685, -0.03884027525782585, -0.08782347291707993, 0.09879761934280396, -0.05107772722840309, 0.037373870611190796, 0.09361689537763596, 0.005962954368442297, 0.0018646711250767112, -0.00825692992657423, -0.0009605532977730036, 0.021372100338339806, -0.0608908012509346, 0.016218531876802444, 0.0490523986518383, -0.000768002588301897, 0.013617769815027714, 0.03165575489401817, -0.05498642474412918, -0.021126287057995796, 0.05642274022102356, -0.03393739089369774, 0.033761974424123764, 0.03376760706305504, -0.008127674460411072, -0.011880037374794483, -0.04542811959981918, 0.03490971028804779, 0.047548938542604446, 0.011334847658872604, 0.011105287820100784, 0.013531207107007504, 0.023713422939181328, -0.001365020521916449, 0.05941593274474144, -0.00026726056239567697, 0.00628422386944294, 0.010066472925245762, 0.04410189762711525, -0.04112759605050087, 0.04001626744866371, 0.021912531927227974, 0.006028011906892061, -0.018257712945342064, -0.060135021805763245, -0.03582882881164551, 0.004259257577359676, -0.04072314500808716, -0.05757777392864227, 0.002110664267092943, 0.05478488653898239, -0.045884352177381516, -0.006242165807634592, 0.03046547807753086, 0.061358340084552765, 0.00648161955177784, -0.0593784861266613, -0.0057555814273655415, -0.03385404869914055, -0.03347598388791084, 0.009559908881783485, 0.031172936782240868, 0.05684956908226013, -0.0375872366130352, -0.010804395191371441, 0.005980541463941336, 0.01920943707227707, 0.02988997846841812, 0.030397871509194374, -0.05498170852661133, -0.001623622141778469, 0.020910631865262985, -0.034985173493623734, 0.03024246357381344, 0.025622883811593056, -0.01590980589389801, 0.021304111927747726, 0.008886078372597694, -0.011410316452383995, -0.018487893044948578, -0.0673406571149826, -0.031123168766498566, -0.012240838259458542, 0.02385488711297512, 0.009558848105370998, 0.03120538406074047, -0.008716563694179058, -0.01753281056880951, 0.016780143603682518, 0.00779574504122138, 0.09789285063743591, -0.06154490262269974, 0.01814955845475197, -0.06438182294368744, -0.032798364758491516, 0.00037570271524600685, -0.020751258358359337, 0.015213895589113235, -0.03735348582267761, 0.012992467731237411, -0.041824810206890106, 0.024308020249009132, -0.03041190467774868, -0.0057853227481245995, -0.01631615124642849, -0.02684176340699196, 0.04691317677497864, -0.03835287317633629, -0.02541162259876728, -0.022338414564728737, 0.007417516782879829, -0.020453812554478645, -0.022927461192011833, -0.021173318848013878, 0.02828100696206093, -0.015956593677401543, 0.025306638330221176, -0.007045739330351353, 0.04024322330951691, 0.032570671290159225, -0.003982433117926121, 0.04245981574058533, 0.04081571102142334, -0.005037006456404924, 0.026185061782598495, 0.0635557472705841, -0.01236689556390047, 0.03194359689950943, 0.006582293193787336, -0.03017110750079155, -0.06081772968173027, -0.03295629099011421, 0.002569821896031499, -0.01920565590262413, -0.043548908084630966, 0.025929177179932594, 0.01235234085470438, -0.004436198156327009, -0.003740806831046939, 0.023615356534719467, -0.029615268111228943, 0.044501058757305145, 0.00002537401087465696, 0.043511681258678436, -0.009323487989604473, -0.03666634485125542, 0.00036259839544072747, -0.04377007111907005, -0.017750542610883713, -0.025480497628450394, -0.003827400505542755, 0.0021862115245312452, 0.00014092806668486446, -0.04558456316590309, -0.050447363406419754, -0.045650824904441833, 0.04390165954828262, -0.0688321590423584, -0.018837952986359596, -0.0023283576592803, -0.043126970529556274, -0.0065261488780379295, -0.015089352615177631, 0.02011862024664879, -0.01409017015248537, -0.02472429908812046, 0.0005960111157037318, 0.06267831474542618, -0.02344796620309353, 0.0005930168554186821, 0.020757725462317467, 0.023534754291176796, -0.015875665470957756, -0.05054742470383644, 0.04232366010546684, 0.057484835386276245, -0.04661684110760689, 0.07383605092763901, -0.003799720900133252, -0.05516501143574715, -0.008315801620483398, -0.01552409864962101, 0.03675075247883797, 0.008473269641399384, 0.0592239685356617, -0.0061208754777908325, 0.005652626510709524, -0.005676120053976774, 0.03926919773221016, -0.035192303359508514, -0.010297209024429321, -0.018338292837142944, -0.026277335360646248, 0.0062989648431539536, 0.0008936146041378379, 0.017125675454735756, 0.03409910947084427, 0.006483055651187897, 0.02348835952579975, -0.012472950853407383, -0.019630849361419678, 0.047535333782434464, -0.018041150644421577, 0.08896496891975403, 0.0050174822099506855, -0.03204409033060074, -0.0030834281351417303, 0.01061420887708664, -0.00017658465367276222, 0.02521497942507267, 0.01946045272052288, -0.02657083049416542, 0.0034766781609505415, -0.019587377086281776, 0.049200624227523804, -0.010497824288904667, 0.009296044707298279, -0.0034269276075065136, 0.0024430742487311363, -0.02595170959830284, -0.014963209629058838, 0.004781425930559635, 0.025593142956495285, 0.00861399620771408, 0.03723914548754692, -0.0051004537381231785, 0.012571454048156738, -0.03055991604924202, 0.007099048234522343, -0.06862117350101471, -0.015268606133759022, -0.0053429813124239445, -0.03993956372141838, 0.05185979977250099, 0.05854864418506622, -0.05758850648999214, 0.02145913429558277, -0.007193524390459061, -0.02631705440580845, 0.043008074164390564, 0.07225248217582703, -0.09494876116514206, -0.023135153576731682, -0.05126181244850159, -0.020368099212646484, -0.025004545226693153, 0.0024156568106263876, -0.0852166935801506, 0.05426139384508133, 0.03654678910970688, 0.007375556975603104, -0.02600732631981373, 0.025995105504989624, -0.018765151500701904 ]
<p>Let's suppose a cellular automaton has a value $b(r,t)$ belongs to $Q$ at site $r$ and time $t$, where $Q$ is the set of possible states at each site. Let $N(r, t)$ be the values of the states of all the sites in some (e.g., Von Neumann or Moore) neighborhood of $r$ at time $t$, taken in some canonical order. </p> <p>The cellular automaton rule is then $$b(r, t + 1) = F(N(r, t))$$ where $F$ is the update function.</p> <p>Let us suppose that $Q = \{0, 1\}$ so that we have a bit at each site. One way to construct reversible cellular automata (RCA) is to look at rules of the form $b(r, t + 1) = F(N(r, t)) \text{ xor } b(r, t − 1)$</p> <p>To see why this is reversible, how to solve for $b(r, t −1)$ in terms of $b(r, t)$ and $b(r +1, t)$. Does it mean that this obeys a condition even stronger than reversibility?</p> <p>One apparent disadvantage of this approach seems to be that computation of $b(r, t+1)$ requires knowledge of the state at time $t−1$ in addition to that at time $t$. Is there way to fix this problem by adding extra state at a site so that the state at time $t + 1$ depends only on that at time $t$? Are there other functions besides $\text{xor}$ that could be used to create RCA in the above fashion for $Q = \{0, 1\}$?</p>
g4208
[ 0.00023961797705851495, 0.011925561353564262, -0.021458959206938744, -0.036884650588035583, 0.04164479300379753, -0.06724613159894943, 0.002342146821320057, 0.049260467290878296, -0.04443000257015228, 0.025647418573498726, -0.022865844890475273, 0.06015478074550629, 0.032628390938043594, -0.020061034709215164, -0.03193265572190285, 0.019292393699288368, 0.024041350930929184, 0.05019458755850792, 0.03737477958202362, 0.06607089191675186, 0.010720937512814999, -0.0024119399022310972, 0.0015012607909739017, -0.004595855716615915, 0.037568699568510056, -0.036486610770225525, 0.01767670176923275, 0.017527205869555473, -0.08719419687986374, 0.005354078020900488, 0.01353299431502819, -0.04959174245595932, 0.0275010596960783, -0.03646157681941986, -0.04053434729576111, -0.04991264268755913, 0.014678300358355045, -0.09244617074728012, 0.025171861052513123, -0.008561731316149235, 0.06060199812054634, 0.043650444597005844, 0.03149581328034401, 0.058672863990068436, 0.05572164058685303, -0.005868762265890837, -0.011776113882660866, -0.01622442528605461, -0.011650323867797852, -0.03828497603535652, 0.018483664840459824, 0.017013730481266975, 0.03247442841529846, 0.013500171713531017, -0.01679391600191593, -0.01275342982262373, -0.003424206981435418, 0.010222685523331165, 0.02341429516673088, -0.00727574760094285, 0.0270532239228487, -0.041475631296634674, 0.02918495237827301, 0.01096199918538332, 0.010729125700891018, -0.007422958500683308, 0.00031071319244802, 0.03305207937955856, -0.024892423301935196, -0.011494833044707775, -0.021220460534095764, -0.02694069780409336, -0.026899730786681175, -0.020544350147247314, -0.017286032438278198, -0.022525012493133545, -0.03391706570982933, -0.014024331234395504, 0.04181816428899765, 0.030827762559056282, -0.054684750735759735, -0.022644449025392532, 0.021920932456851006, 0.051548417657613754, -0.05622067302465439, -0.00793270394206047, 0.05065351352095604, 0.0133753577247262, 0.038150280714035034, 0.07808203250169754, -0.011450712569057941, -0.06309501826763153, 0.09229572862386703, -0.004867786541581154, 0.01837269775569439, 0.024257274344563484, -0.02531159296631813, 0.03436274081468582, -0.024992339313030243, 0.009831100702285767, -0.04601231589913368, 0.006056693382561207, 0.00643880246207118, -0.017184246331453323, -0.10164760798215866, 0.0012502011377364397, 0.0579066276550293, -0.09495942294597626, -0.06707966327667236, 0.024621255695819855, 0.041354939341545105, -0.015403257682919502, -0.010590271092951298, 0.019807999953627586, -0.02514970302581787, 0.029556147754192352, 0.00424418319016695, 0.004633097909390926, 0.003031999571248889, 0.049870625138282776, -0.017371967434883118, -0.03858857974410057, -0.013947642408311367, -0.017383668571710587, 0.04397393763065338, 0.0657704770565033, -0.02879304625093937, 0.0438251756131649, 0.05077797546982765, 0.031528349965810776, 0.0041724261827766895, 0.028813615441322327, 0.03232073038816452, 0.020241480320692062, 0.012950357981026173, -0.042531419545412064, -0.029497534036636353, 0.0052544670179486275, 0.02483021281659603, -0.020398922264575958, -0.0031094644218683243, -0.008269783109426498, -0.01566442660987377, 0.018133843317627907, -0.02680763229727745, -0.08810661733150482, -0.027081124484539032, -0.04758251830935478, -0.018168434500694275, -0.039352480322122574, 0.037663042545318604, -0.019075021147727966, -0.05688442289829254, 0.000150215724715963, 0.011103417724370956, 0.0690409392118454, 0.04234848544001579, 0.028203725814819336, -0.03030920773744583, 0.044828642159700394, 0.049688562750816345, -0.03119843639433384, -0.06367096304893494, -0.009871969930827618, -0.011245091445744038, 0.02860252559185028, -0.057034336030483246, -0.07550060749053955, -0.046586815267801285, -0.060309700667858124, -0.037882979959249496, 0.0013836065772920847, -0.02092026360332966, 0.058907750993967056, -0.0004538839275483042, 0.00618571974337101, 0.0035840128548443317, 0.011763222515583038, 0.0306137315928936, -0.03930899128317833, 0.001351302838884294, -0.03142727166414261, -0.010461738333106041, 0.057245027273893356, 0.04602345824241638, 0.018049445003271103, -0.05320383235812187, -0.012533887289464474, -0.09049409627914429, 0.011663494631648064, 0.029671449214220047, 0.039507847279310226, -0.01797899790108204, 0.051227256655693054, -0.0047523388639092445, -0.02879847213625908, -0.016821864992380142, -0.043541137129068375, 0.057927243411540985, -0.010440545156598091, 0.03779931738972664, 0.039932526648044586, 0.0736248716711998, 0.0292438305914402, -0.029626520350575447, 0.024201998487114906, -0.055013466626405716, 0.010482588782906532, 0.0059470986016094685, -0.005623261444270611, 0.00883469171822071, -0.034626465290784836, -0.016954876482486725, 0.04042452573776245, -0.029536690562963486, -0.008433022536337376, -0.006436128169298172, 0.03425164893269539, 0.024134298786520958, -0.028969401493668556, 0.00600243778899312, -0.038117870688438416, 0.012307840399444103, 0.04121804237365723, -0.048672866076231, 0.06616237759590149, -0.010793186724185944, 0.0335821695625782, 0.00705356290563941, 0.03193727880716324, -0.07377864420413971, -0.02128901518881321, -0.015855027362704277, -0.04575533792376518, 0.029512589797377586, 0.022950727492570877, 0.008926959708333015, 0.03702246770262718, 0.06843232363462448, -0.014396890066564083, -0.017651960253715515, -0.014203774742782116, 0.000019970184439443983, -0.02062816731631756, 0.0033827070146799088, -0.07544500380754471, -0.0189069714397192, -0.008975661359727383, 0.017447393387556076, 0.031331028789281845, 0.005173288285732269, 0.008992955088615417, -0.015710849314928055, -0.014964289963245392, 0.016987105831503868, -0.03584062308073044, 0.014949297532439232, -0.015151558443903923, 0.02896130084991455, 0.024264711886644363, 0.0678190141916275, 0.01711939089000225, -0.002664020983502269, -0.0015327211003750563, -0.04746958240866661, -0.04288523271679878, -0.002635314827784896, -0.041256409138441086, 0.0010483398800715804, 0.018061643466353416, -0.06547538936138153, -0.03128299489617348, 0.0743221789598465, 0.01017708983272314, -0.010964647866785526, -0.010415521450340748, -0.029712524265050888, 0.008182873018085957, 0.0074762385338544846, 0.025060949847102165, 0.024232780560851097, -0.09776229411363602, -0.0273743849247694, -0.03284522891044617, -0.030619489029049873, 0.00251581659540534, 0.017141861841082573, 0.04839238524436951, 0.03324741870164871, 0.05642710626125336, -0.011113894172012806, 0.026418739929795265, 0.05702950805425644, -0.011322173289954662, -0.04570304602384567, 0.0053503201343119144, -0.028064711019396782, -0.09756790846586227, 0.017337365075945854, 0.06463136523962021, 0.0011439643567427993, -0.021465912461280823, -0.020467450842261314, 0.006192812696099281, -0.004718773066997528, -0.02838941477239132, -0.01017430517822504, 0.032353028655052185, 0.0395914725959301, -0.019179299473762512, 0.016308490186929703, 0.03983756899833679, -0.056733354926109314, -0.14058367908000946, 0.028596989810466766, 0.020301302894949913, -0.022861706092953682, -0.008749586530029774, 0.037715889513492584, 0.022232569754123688, -0.004180499352514744, 0.004028600174933672, 0.032925017178058624, 0.0294865220785141, 0.07111238688230515, -0.01191224530339241, 0.0006282977992668748, 0.048070941120386124, -0.011671709828078747, -0.035639386624097824, 0.05495697632431984, 0.09671324491500854, 0.01629721373319626, -0.039272259920835495, -0.031734105199575424, -0.0883323922753334, -0.048153579235076904, 0.03191227465867996, 0.020858170464634895, -0.023340214043855667, 0.00871923565864563, 0.055537912994623184, 0.010721410624682903, -0.018318751826882362, 0.018056288361549377, 0.019587097689509392, -0.018266484141349792, 0.006954171694815159, -0.025532372295856476, -0.022540440782904625, 0.006594077683985233, 0.01848226971924305, 0.038371872156858444, -0.0210387222468853, -0.024080045521259308, 0.09588488191366196, 0.0024075310211628675, -0.035612236708402634, 0.013674968853592873, 0.0006641976069658995, 0.034273404628038406, -0.037778016179800034, -0.026333622634410858, -0.045404329895973206, -0.011050386354327202, 0.027864007279276848, 0.004233087413012981, 0.025876225903630257, -0.009037284180521965, -0.036462072283029556, 0.009930255822837353, -0.03856111690402031, 0.01879774034023285, -0.009606974199414253, -0.0270033311098814, -0.007998044602572918, 0.019220374524593353, -0.028459612280130386, 0.03711257874965668, 0.05253032594919205, 0.0020489967428147793, -0.02377450093626976, -0.026591209694743156, -0.061280541121959686, 0.04874420538544655, 0.06076126545667648, -0.008979600854218006, -0.05368060991168022, 0.0018908899510279298, 0.02948438562452793, 0.01300297025591135, 0.026123980060219765, -0.05049126595258713, 0.036136746406555176, 0.0344737246632576, 0.019055116921663284, 0.011824219487607479, 0.00011794739111792296, 0.008141297847032547, -0.03567544370889664, 0.023072822019457817, -0.025379067286849022, -0.011038797907531261, 0.009119940921664238, -0.0015762774273753166, -0.04342743381857872, 0.007598820608109236, -0.03854639455676079, -0.005583731923252344, 0.02189645543694496, -0.04878436028957367, -0.007976852357387543, 0.01126222126185894, -0.06033575162291527, 0.02631700597703457, 0.043053023517131805, 0.07452133297920227, 0.045545998960733414, 0.01900484599173069, 0.0018549328669905663, -0.016116617247462273, -0.03525257855653763, 0.032246194779872894, -0.02808460406959057, 0.037977077066898346, 0.003838072996586561, 0.0070711602456867695, -0.026449112221598625, 0.017175812274217606, -0.07419974356889725, 0.06134059652686119, 0.03288703411817551, -0.046273328363895416, 0.028779275715351105, -0.019899779930710793, -0.00950955506414175, 0.022105403244495392, 0.02068929746747017, 0.04223364219069481, -0.028083475306630135, 0.030009692534804344, -0.049650441855192184, -0.048066817224025726, 0.022263217717409134, -0.024363823235034943, 0.019985448569059372, -0.06389819085597992, -0.00823232438415289, 0.06565011292695999, -0.0163069199770689, -0.04501458629965782, 0.04026128351688385, 0.02525847591459751, -0.04496142640709877, 0.005979728419333696, -0.03946685045957565, 0.024753153324127197, 0.026259183883666992, 0.02461731992661953, 0.014733508229255676, 0.034978754818439484, -0.062118493020534515, -0.019392121583223343, 0.026753084734082222, 0.01338602602481842, 0.0437907874584198, -0.01950806938111782, 0.0233289897441864, 0.010701552033424377, 0.007125163916498423, 0.03838730975985527, 0.00097181141609326, 0.0018884792225435376, 0.010513965971767902, 0.005343232303857803, -0.004477683454751968, -0.03212547302246094, -0.0005761892534792423, -0.034622661769390106, 0.028955765068531036, -0.02155814692378044, 0.023751145228743553, -0.040262866765260696, 0.03277386724948883, -0.019561689347028732, -0.009296521544456482, 0.056132104247808456, -0.028178159147500992, 0.005302786827087402, -0.0947306752204895, -0.03255373612046242, 0.02369527891278267, 0.05577684938907623, 0.04391619190573692, -0.02651781216263771, -0.08435823023319244, -0.05603377893567085, 0.017044762149453163, -0.01649114303290844, -0.0029360654298216105, -0.02319197542965412, 0.009441263042390347, 0.009275996126234531, 0.03800129517912865, -0.061525795608758926, 0.037878312170505524, -0.019194573163986206, 0.0013518837513402104, -0.03350210562348366, -0.04215913638472557, 0.0027321951929479837, 0.060380320996046066, -0.0163128562271595, 0.005628556944429874, 0.03340750187635422, -0.03566060587763786, -0.06549029052257538, 0.04734086990356445, -0.026361482217907906, -0.048885446041822433, 0.031063402071595192, -0.07001027464866638, 0.025545284152030945, -0.025618312880396843, -0.05736164748668671, 0.027698539197444916, -0.05715009570121765, -0.07249046862125397, -0.027413591742515564, -0.0034846547059714794, -0.03138293698430061, 0.01829572580754757, -0.03082713671028614, 0.002963889390230179, -0.004006317351013422, -0.008252185769379139, -0.03200001269578934, -0.03191576525568962, 0.03825707733631134, -0.049485400319099426, 0.03857601061463356, -0.007110558915883303, -0.016783297061920166, -0.02090173400938511, -0.030250731855630875, -0.09176728874444962, -0.02921030856668949, -0.03334338217973709, -0.017830349504947662, 0.01896766945719719, -0.007594407070428133, -0.016894087195396423, -0.01912456378340721, 0.009363657794892788, 0.017864473164081573, 0.001226110034622252, 0.009163926355540752, 0.01174150500446558, -0.017535144463181496, -0.02592398226261139, 0.06327695399522781, 0.04396827891469002, 0.040621060878038406, 0.016249123960733414, 0.06026289612054825, 0.012310372665524483, -0.011587060987949371, 0.025726890191435814, 0.021434644237160683, 0.0008375183097086847, 0.06889580935239792, -0.03886517509818077, 0.02649414911866188, 0.053778525441884995, -0.03465421497821808, 0.020574120804667473, -0.02315656468272209, -0.031237032264471054, 0.023400243371725082, 0.045323435217142105, -0.03126759082078934, -0.018160436302423477, -0.036056388169527054, -0.050850603729486465, 0.022682132199406624, 0.0033135022968053818, -0.009148197248578072, 0.0026290134992450476, 0.044662393629550934, 0.0015717711066827178, 0.007968992926180363, -0.010435090400278568, -0.034414153546094894, 0.0057352264411747456, 0.023002490401268005, 0.00830346904695034, -0.058717031031847, 0.011033126153051853, 0.004290642682462931, 0.006354354787617922, 0.005456676706671715, 0.009263245388865471, 0.021906929090619087, -0.06541546434164047, -0.040887314826250076, 0.014688693918287754, -0.020957032218575478, -0.00023677585704717785, 0.08254352957010269, -0.008870108984410763, 0.049436431378126144, -0.02052253484725952, -0.029017994180321693, 0.0012300902744755149, 0.0029935501515865326, -0.060562316328287125, -0.00406115734949708, 0.0019483569776639342, -0.03868948668241501, 0.05821700766682625, 0.0420575812458992, -0.0008742375648580492, 0.0147149208933115, 0.00016420558677054942, 0.07384487241506577, -0.017775829881429672, -0.024963874369859695, 0.03774779289960861, 0.08893071115016937, 0.035463202744722366, 0.03802286833524704, -0.024851033464074135, -0.05678132548928261, -0.026726193726062775, 0.0004045567475259304, 0.02736487053334713, -0.04358209669589996, 0.052622079849243164, 0.0046017225831747055, -0.01202833279967308, 0.012176545336842537, 0.03704365715384483, 0.026993129402399063, -0.008048245683312416, 0.04893322288990021, -0.0904465764760971, 0.02544105052947998, 0.058500658720731735, -0.005681770388036966, 0.030446382239460945, 0.06709446758031845, 0.016938328742980957, -0.04205445945262909, -0.023361893370747566, -0.00899573229253292, -0.007174422964453697, -0.009688740596175194, -0.01115041971206665, 0.016987545415759087, 0.02633732743561268, 0.0046765911392867565, -0.012690380215644836, -0.019688408821821213, 0.07550138980150223, 0.04603082686662674, 0.028802240267395973, 0.05968637391924858, -0.019058652222156525, -0.006081204861402512, -0.0989823266863823, 0.003989797551184893, -0.07200650125741959, 0.030459389090538025, 0.0509958378970623, 0.0358036570250988, 0.0486828051507473, -0.013682050630450249, 0.06862575560808182, -0.016894644126296043, 0.011631188914179802, 0.021974314004182816, -0.01615101844072342, -0.04400744289159775, -0.0025015869177877903, 0.04050388187170029, 0.034928951412439346, 0.04928939417004585, 0.05955355986952782, -0.03984920307993889, -0.05428408458828926, 0.018784761428833008, 0.02030070312321186, -0.003723378526046872, 0.019580122083425522, -0.046854689717292786, 0.004591353237628937, -0.00614258972927928, 0.03783596307039261, 0.01656777784228325, -0.025956323370337486, -0.03944094106554985, 0.019762881100177765, 0.036557555198669434, -0.03131117299199104, 0.02104320377111435, -0.046006202697753906, -0.05376783385872841, -0.026514211669564247, -0.018741386011242867, -0.03430773690342903, -0.0426410511136055, 0.058020077645778656, 0.007804973516613245, -0.025470467284321785, -0.00652717100456357, -0.011483505368232727, -0.015909017994999886, 0.019352460280060768, -0.0014736776938661933, 0.021817931905388832, -0.03839113190770149, -0.024864541366696358, -0.07900100946426392, -0.0047756582498550415, 0.03993551433086395, -0.01241257879883051, 0.021305756643414497, 0.016015050932765007, -0.027545364573597908, 0.01535660307854414, 0.010089393705129623, -0.04184447601437569, -0.019375203177332878, -0.009565813466906548, 0.05463027209043503, 0.04805775359272957, -0.013591828756034374, -0.010264053009450436, 0.03534594178199768, -0.03274640813469887, -0.057927727699279785, -0.039266977459192276, 0.019327206537127495, 0.048746269196271896, -0.019577335566282272, -0.01562810130417347, -0.0007392604020424187, 0.02379451133310795, 0.061047084629535675, -0.002098316326737404, 0.008701995015144348, -0.01772596873342991, -0.03576882183551788, -0.035045888274908066, 0.0017363877268508077, 0.07706268876791, 0.015685023739933968, 0.02640506997704506, 0.03725982457399368, -0.012618404813110828, 0.04239804297685623, -0.01439250074326992, -0.023074034601449966, -0.029069067910313606, 0.039823267608881, -0.02132062427699566, -0.011071116663515568, -0.1355687826871872 ]
<p>Don't be a $\frac{d^3x}{dt^3}$</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Ptblb.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What does it all mean?</p>
g4209
[ 0.033881403505802155, 0.05604444816708565, -0.03854331746697426, -0.030289115384221077, 0.06940454244613647, 0.06183362379670143, 0.02368643879890442, 0.010306030511856079, -0.038066621869802475, -0.09017341583967209, -0.047804269939661026, 0.020345250144600868, 0.03791618347167969, -0.034153714776039124, -0.012286069802939892, 0.031869541853666306, 0.022157877683639526, -0.0012503220932558179, 0.03436993807554245, -0.011684579774737358, -0.07274322956800461, -0.003255978925153613, -0.002192739862948656, 0.0015818767715245485, 0.07497624307870865, -0.021473363041877747, -0.008682961575686932, 0.00866558775305748, -0.08940572291612625, -0.00688934326171875, -0.0013330000219866633, 0.03546011447906494, 0.00909271091222763, 0.04920044541358948, 0.007825257256627083, -0.018810173496603966, 0.030430981889367104, 0.005721761845052242, 0.027724340558052063, -0.05083179846405983, -0.042285870760679245, 0.00793599896132946, -0.043367691338062286, -0.02488594688475132, -0.023182358592748642, -0.006815577391535044, -0.03305500000715256, 0.004310077987611294, 0.007202139589935541, 0.003480156185105443, -0.00460480060428381, -0.0075310831889510155, 0.07093565911054611, -0.003687473013997078, -0.0012847739271819592, 0.011859014630317688, 0.007006533443927765, -0.023750491440296173, 0.07262717932462692, 0.028556883335113525, -0.03528621047735214, -0.04715123027563095, 0.02539936825633049, 0.03275828808546066, 0.055957913398742676, -0.001591626089066267, -0.013106245547533035, -0.046327970921993256, 0.0791260153055191, -0.0441836453974247, 0.07483430206775665, -0.004098402336239815, 0.03074471838772297, -0.008506881073117256, -0.054713357239961624, -0.020629798993468285, -0.028988074511289597, -0.01013970747590065, 0.012035614810883999, -0.03952407464385033, 0.05440202355384827, 0.01021604798734188, -0.02889230102300644, -0.018290789797902107, 0.02100219950079918, 0.03096500225365162, -0.012924843467772007, -0.010212570428848267, -0.034955598413944244, 0.075909823179245, -0.03124677948653698, -0.03715454041957855, 0.03416382148861885, 0.019888633862137794, 0.02298080176115036, -0.012739812955260277, 0.009970450773835182, 0.057367946952581406, 0.0006092969560995698, -0.040002722293138504, -0.013108867220580578, 0.04612450674176216, 0.005727291572839022, 0.03917442634701729, -0.05012135952711105, 0.033917997032403946, -0.027111824601888657, 0.024475479498505592, 0.007785475812852383, -0.06649535894393921, -0.0026464853435754776, 0.048466529697179794, -0.045143093913793564, -0.08510276675224304, -0.0009321095421910286, 0.01072152704000473, -0.022080766037106514, -0.012515384703874588, -0.07935185730457306, 0.027352578938007355, 0.09582282602787018, -0.05981109291315079, 0.024223290383815765, 0.028585229068994522, -0.02290465496480465, -0.007430303376168013, -0.01973184570670128, 0.006586219649761915, 0.08680962771177292, -0.008967030793428421, 0.021962545812129974, 0.018741857260465622, -0.02936553582549095, 0.03994506224989891, 0.07645484060049057, 0.06089888513088226, -0.006952895782887936, -0.0486573725938797, 0.008631584234535694, 0.01994703710079193, -0.036026325076818466, 0.042445942759513855, -0.023374998942017555, -0.00261104223318398, 0.00043053063564002514, -0.06901033967733383, 0.0048966193571686745, -0.048743437975645065, 0.022794578224420547, -0.047885309904813766, 0.011366375721991062, 0.06530182808637619, 0.03288717195391655, -0.06841659545898438, 0.0604599304497242, -0.0010070980060845613, 0.03505411371588707, 0.019565913826227188, -0.058643754571676254, 0.0059205349534749985, 0.04559649899601936, 0.023181984201073647, 0.03324969485402107, 0.04110117629170418, -0.03741028904914856, -0.04454370588064194, 0.00320680090226233, 0.031812455505132675, 0.018449023365974426, 0.03493226319551468, 0.0018044636817649007, 0.03609086200594902, 0.02479127235710621, -0.02165129780769348, -0.020899323746562004, 0.02862856350839138, -0.04414047300815582, -0.038026656955480576, 0.014550690539181232, 0.03647654131054878, 0.01982113905251026, 0.004095525946468115, -0.003140128217637539, -0.02595335617661476, 0.0064343600533902645, -0.0013620802201330662, -0.008213303051888943, 0.04091135784983635, -0.004852856509387493, 0.058581966906785965, -0.002900382038205862, 0.019908031448721886, 0.034774843603372574, 0.0552719347178936, 0.05559149011969566, -0.004111581016331911, -0.03351215645670891, -0.03320534527301788, -0.031358543783426285, -0.04984895512461662, -0.002460380783304572, -0.011281165294349194, 0.02926882542669773, 0.031693629920482635, -0.032164040952920914, -0.000218862114707008, -0.021147502586245537, 0.07667041569948196, 0.01604313962161541, 0.010491400957107544, 0.019351819530129433, -0.010162833146750927, -0.022192543372511864, 0.002537635387852788, -0.010306774638593197, -0.05422643572092056, 0.054149024188518524, 0.0071342079900205135, 0.00006793543434469029, -0.0017859559739008546, -0.0827791690826416, 0.01994117721915245, -0.011275001801550388, -0.02786431275308132, -0.034895289689302444, 0.000047480636567343026, 0.013166805729269981, -0.043294619768857956, -0.020575975999236107, -0.03318360447883606, -0.04893225431442261, -0.05198298767209053, -0.031953178346157074, 0.01881130039691925, 0.05093308165669441, 0.03045973740518093, 0.0026536695659160614, -0.048844337463378906, 0.021565722301602364, 0.0200106892734766, -0.0012058892752975225, -0.026067659258842468, -0.0009140145848505199, 0.00704222172498703, 0.005274176597595215, 0.05984712392091751, 0.017095133662223816, 0.029852110892534256, -0.019417788833379745, -0.006986584514379501, -0.010436195880174637, -0.020863663405179977, 0.006583940237760544, 0.013361302204430103, -0.04135683923959732, -0.010721864178776741, -0.052126653492450714, -0.019702741876244545, -0.007678303401917219, -0.019607629626989365, -0.017925908789038658, -0.0344957672059536, 0.022939378395676613, -0.026457246392965317, -0.02318951115012169, -0.0023090788163244724, 0.031244376674294472, 0.019806193187832832, 0.023831412196159363, 0.037267494946718216, -0.013966911472380161, 0.0034308023750782013, 0.02465636469423771, 0.04527981951832771, -0.06572625041007996, -0.000035193737858207896, 0.01105236355215311, -0.026629511266946793, -0.03271058574318886, -0.006196103058755398, 0.005993787664920092, 0.05896671116352081, -0.0018677508924156427, 0.07664580643177032, 0.04994407668709755, -0.006251808255910873, 0.024600587785243988, 0.059376683086156845, -0.02281687967479229, 0.008233359083533287, 0.017596229910850525, -0.012880753725767136, -0.008421836420893669, -0.016620762646198273, 0.010668233036994934, -0.03185878321528435, 0.00601584417745471, -0.01618131995201111, 0.03872000798583031, 0.05527307093143463, -0.025428984314203262, 0.002580038970336318, 0.004539038985967636, -0.006442778743803501, -0.00045265478547662497, -0.031155601143836975, 0.03859474137425423, -0.013236657716333866, -0.021800028160214424, -0.029208790510892868, 0.021499285474419594, -0.028300559148192406, -0.0014986838214099407, -0.005849221255630255, -0.014253043569624424, 0.02286735735833645, -0.000951073132455349, 0.006167243700474501, -0.046060144901275635, -0.004941664170473814, -0.001407109433785081, 0.01423695869743824, -0.04309963062405586, 0.011896004900336266, -0.017900465056300163, -0.0011868192814290524, -0.026776425540447235, 0.0635683611035347, 0.029939357191324234, -0.02236226759850979, 0.006462553516030312, -0.03351116552948952, -0.043157342821359634, -0.001242520404048264, -0.05563092604279518, -0.028931325301527977, -0.04514702409505844, 0.05162718519568443, 0.07147607207298279, -0.04401039332151413, -0.010298210196197033, -0.023406675085425377, -0.019071228802204132, 0.02048574388027191, 0.029094358906149864, -0.005252472590655088, -0.037248458713293076, 0.010589221492409706, 0.014648998156189919, 0.021913036704063416, -0.011426737532019615, 0.017055563628673553, 0.01819055713713169, 0.0006347013404592872, -0.00737469969317317, 0.01873054914176464, 0.029847947880625725, 0.007774952333420515, 0.004287892486900091, 0.0001962377136806026, 0.014462215825915337, -0.053516242653131485, -0.035364020615816116, 0.01906542293727398, -0.00001966418494703248, 0.018413137644529343, -0.03346506878733635, 0.016585567966103554, 0.046838026493787766, 0.054649170488119125, -0.019632285460829735, -0.012935593724250793, -0.0025113425217568874, 0.06994373351335526, 0.026898033916950226, -0.006863107439130545, -0.029616760089993477, -0.05912528187036514, 0.014066256582736969, 0.01753087528049946, 0.018802449107170105, 0.01254973653703928, 0.02434188686311245, -0.07042563706636429, 0.012623975053429604, 0.07349929213523865, -0.044020142406225204, -0.032307229936122894, 0.021456455811858177, -0.009675712324678898, 0.015142354182898998, 0.018626509234309196, -0.045295149087905884, 0.037948641926050186, -0.043189991265535355, -0.06518522650003433, 0.025452831760048866, 0.07259425520896912, -0.042987529188394547, -0.009271236136555672, -0.04223146289587021, -0.014052800834178925, -0.020446909591555595, -0.06154092028737068, -0.013772469013929367, -0.025663947686553, 0.0747411847114563, -0.02803865261375904, 0.08472734689712524, -0.04659804701805115, 0.022710954770445824, -0.04407954588532448, -0.01277209259569645, -0.00889663491398096, 0.03421652317047119, -0.024924632161855698, 0.02953769825398922, 0.00796867161989212, -0.018840372562408447, -0.010142202489078045, 0.0598921999335289, 0.016713770106434822, -0.033050019294023514, 0.0034887332003563643, 0.02154364623129368, 0.026500072330236435, 0.0495782196521759, 0.025035157799720764, -0.07636609673500061, 0.053174007683992386, -0.016956059262156487, 0.03977847099304199, -0.05690567195415497, -0.021913737058639526, -0.027587631717324257, 0.03441406786441803, -0.019396957010030746, 0.07604576647281647, -0.09098774194717407, 0.025051811710000038, 0.040232159197330475, 0.02752935327589512, 0.01666753552854061, 0.040060464292764664, 0.0294195543974638, 0.02684604749083519, 0.018867846578359604, -0.003936390392482281, -0.0052110059186816216, 0.07858402281999588, -0.020958365872502327, 0.057055987417697906, -0.04102683812379837, -0.052011486142873764, 0.0698850005865097, 0.016109060496091843, 0.006514623295515776, -0.05011356249451637, -0.005783062893897295, -0.01962807960808277, -0.042237576097249985, -0.004030817188322544, 0.002979581942781806, 0.010770638473331928, 0.03151467442512512, -0.015294691547751427, -0.03400808572769165, 0.004609257914125919, -0.04861650615930557, -0.04911895468831062, -0.02626519463956356, -0.04918207973241806, -0.06563027948141098, 0.0011471938341856003, 0.014093879610300064, -0.016435179859399796, 0.04031199961900711, -0.029454326257109642, 0.0036195518914610147, -0.035989489406347275, 0.034671660512685776, 0.006122891325503588, 0.04011235013604164, -0.00822734460234642, -0.03824591636657715, 0.04344167932868004, -0.021615134552121162, -0.024789001792669296, -0.014911824837327003, -0.002034964971244335, 0.04272842034697533, 0.020173974335193634, 0.009492154233157635, -0.017150601372122765, -0.05060458555817604, 0.056626323610544205, 0.03471287712454796, -0.012176388874650002, -0.017420580610632896, 0.009741295129060745, 0.017364388331770897, -0.059047631919384, 0.008239728398621082, -0.007729966193437576, -0.018043601885437965, 0.07246353477239609, 0.08312252908945084, -0.03163550794124603, 0.03963426128029823, -0.00198343419469893, -0.02376108430325985, -0.0313367061316967, 0.03954412043094635, -0.013106380589306355, 0.0021435688249766827, -0.012853788211941719, 0.0018706558039411902, 0.0026011294685304165, -0.04780453443527222, -0.016476763412356377, -0.0279212836176157, -0.07126513868570328, 0.003436531638726592, -0.0030234577134251595, 0.049491070210933685, -0.01781952939927578, 0.002921855775639415, -0.05350993201136589, 0.021675432100892067, 0.08091827481985092, -0.02025340124964714, 0.030117075890302658, 0.042343851178884506, 0.029488274827599525, 0.015593105927109718, 0.017501840367913246, 0.006001712754368782, 0.004734438378363848, 0.06429058313369751, 0.01035247277468443, 0.023379532620310783, -0.009497287683188915, -0.042412832379341125, 0.05248449742794037, -0.0777805745601654, 0.026112601161003113, -0.01969749480485916, 0.009817894548177719, 0.010271720588207245, -0.008388307876884937, 0.03832311928272247, -0.01593000814318657, -0.013833686709403992, -0.06900737434625626, 0.0785580724477768, -0.011590258218348026, -0.020649269223213196, -0.012041688896715641, -0.02116316743195057, -0.01469364669173956, -0.05563194304704666, 0.015179639682173729, -0.04726891592144966, 0.0366840586066246, 0.0746898278594017, -0.09701469540596008, 0.02170150727033615, 0.06190544739365578, 0.005126427859067917, -0.04218441992998123, 0.0020273758564144373, 0.03371262922883034, -0.023034509271383286, 0.026206932961940765, 0.012070600874722004, 0.02440817467868328, -0.04946603626012802, -0.022217782214283943, 0.009654608555138111, 0.002266830997541547, -0.0036011491902172565, 0.0033885284792631865, 0.10765036940574646, -0.025224797427654266, -0.027525639161467552, 0.02040044404566288, 0.03161781653761864, -0.004492439795285463, 0.0024599446915090084, 0.006149602588266134, -0.03321344405412674, 0.017186354845762253, -0.057836513966321945, 0.05450259521603584, 0.015199478715658188, -0.008391237817704678, -0.006351401098072529, -0.0014607271878048778, 0.021984444931149483, -0.03655929118394852, -0.044190164655447006, 0.060764461755752563, -0.021183541044592857, -0.008811921812593937, 0.004612191580235958, 0.0486261360347271, 0.030340764671564102, -0.05114210769534111, -0.0573146678507328, 0.09009864181280136, 0.02444322034716606, 0.02224506251513958, -0.0004036103200633079, 0.043732885271310806, 0.053395826369524, -0.030318191275000572, -0.06453120708465576, 0.009718048386275768, 0.023573197424411774, 0.0053812675178050995, 0.040931276977062225, -0.020390642806887627, 0.023251542821526527, -0.041319094598293304, 0.0217263363301754, 0.01778661459684372, -0.005037097726017237, -0.0042036441154778, -0.03814258053898811, 0.08095072954893112, -0.045943327248096466, -0.003742180299013853, -0.05318790674209595, -0.025070711970329285, -0.04668668657541275, 0.019229035824537277, -0.03298882767558098, -0.006127418950200081, 0.02694101259112358, 0.016577262431383133, -0.00749216228723526, 0.016344411298632622, 0.0375870056450367, -0.016316941007971764, -0.004850267898291349, -0.021611414849758148, 0.015692001208662987, -0.05858134478330612, -0.03921963647007942, -0.032612673938274384, 0.05457662418484688, 0.06552500277757645, 0.024349555373191833, 0.07582716643810272, -0.01746242493391037, -0.012927156873047352, 0.013457437977194786, -0.03135159611701965, -0.04238758608698845, -0.06151321157813072, -0.0054945386946201324, -0.034170813858509064, -0.018657192587852478, -0.033445656299591064, 0.00024081046285573393, 0.04161427542567253, 0.018174782395362854, -0.03746596351265907, -0.0277886800467968, -0.04978339746594429, -0.01663183979690075, 0.04384816810488701, 0.023030420765280724, 0.05610763281583786, -0.02118317224085331, -0.027768511325120926, -0.014197491109371185, 0.05190788581967354, -0.009451443329453468, -0.0035603747237473726, 0.004148890729993582, 0.06109442934393883, 0.03254694491624832, -0.029996922239661217, -0.047901637852191925, 0.029331209138035774, -0.02189282327890396, -0.06196396052837372, -0.05810992792248726, 0.061549317091703415, -0.0017293565906584263, -0.006514729931950569, 0.0623871348798275, 0.004837892018258572, -0.027343640103936195, -0.04107898846268654, 0.005557226948440075, 0.005402881186455488, 0.001218888908624649, -0.0027770211454480886, -0.03552824258804321, -0.00844646617770195, 0.008051329292356968, -0.005036574322730303, -0.03825733810663223, 0.008294353261590004, 0.022841358557343483, 0.057780951261520386, -0.015803871676325798, -0.016564395278692245, 0.04297812283039093, -0.08556058257818222, -0.004781578201800585, -0.028139950707554817, -0.009041703306138515, -0.011271920055150986, 0.02633660100400448, -0.00787572842091322, -0.029950877651572227, -0.10742469877004623, 0.04258744418621063, 0.012929631397128105, -0.08125051856040955, -0.09213987737894058, -0.06425493210554123, -0.029708977788686752, -0.050136372447013855, 0.0023421570658683777, 0.026841910555958748, 0.036129601299762726, -0.1044391617178917, 0.046352509409189224, 0.008721953257918358, 0.016737869009375572, -0.020955516025424004, 0.06389753520488739, 0.07326144725084305, 0.018986105918884277, 0.016707593575119972, 0.05178588628768921, 0.008252309635281563, 0.03353210166096687, -0.07921584695577621, 0.005326296668499708, 0.01688406430184841, -0.0120282843708992, -0.02129862830042839, -0.006017009727656841, 0.03201969712972641, -0.03683440759778023, 0.011142830364406109, -0.019236775115132332, 0.03514297679066658, 0.008604399859905243, 0.010697653517127037, -0.006884276866912842, 0.016290687024593353, -0.013503658585250378, 0.05802790820598602, -0.020763857290148735, -0.017307527363300323, -0.00016651248733978719, -0.03792238608002663, 0.03331635147333145, 0.03451474383473396, -0.11055958271026611, -0.057642072439193726, 0.020168021321296692 ]
<p>A gun has a recoil speed of 2 m/s when firing. If the gun has a mass of 2kg and the bullet has a mass of 10g (0.01 kg) what speed does the bullet come out at? </p> <p>The gun has zero total momentum before firing and afterwards the gun has negative acceleration. </p> <p>So far:</p> <p><strong>Conservation of momentum</strong>: $m_1v_1 = m_2v_2.$</p> <p>We have the recoil speed of $2\,$m/s. The mass of the gun is equal to $2\,$kg.</p> <p>Plus the bullet's total mass which is 0.01 kg.</p> <p>$$2 \frac{m}{s}\cdot 2.01\,\text{kg} + (0.01\,\text{kg} \cdot v)$$ $$=4.02\,\text{kg}\frac{m}{s} + (0.01\,\text{kg} \cdot v)$$</p> <p>That's as far as I can go.</p>
g4210
[ 0.08613260835409164, -0.015462827868759632, 0.007224060129374266, 0.04183277115225792, 0.06347468495368958, -0.014242870733141899, 0.035199712961912155, 0.03878321498632431, -0.06513452529907227, -0.012334642931818962, -0.016203977167606354, 0.002057179342955351, -0.00016785967454779893, 0.021485881879925728, 0.026439493522047997, 0.004889573436230421, 0.05422760546207428, 0.023996371775865555, 0.06626710295677185, 0.07556060701608658, -0.036119244992733, -0.045731279999017715, -0.027618177235126495, -0.06475327908992767, 0.003275542752817273, 0.034058984369039536, 0.02171158604323864, -0.004278120584785938, -0.07234890758991241, -0.020859375596046448, -0.005126678850501776, -0.007357316091656685, -0.010635972023010254, -0.00882556103169918, -0.06814702600240707, 0.03414766117930412, 0.000703383528161794, -0.012813426554203033, 0.0011937180534005165, -0.030157743021845818, 0.07953192293643951, -0.03415834903717041, -0.0005551517242565751, 0.014491804875433445, 0.009421857073903084, 0.01444296259433031, -0.005325600039213896, 0.0030625294893980026, -0.0799705907702446, 0.0023644324392080307, -0.040093280375003815, 0.009521868079900742, -0.0027119561564177275, -0.035183947533369064, -0.02324678748846054, 0.04943041130900383, -0.022801928222179413, -0.025023072957992554, -0.03492262586951256, -0.013982419855892658, -0.01516692340373993, -0.08119203895330429, -0.030646538361907005, -0.03278503939509392, 0.08445614576339722, -0.0234572384506464, -0.04799555987119675, 0.016927292570471764, 0.05151990428566933, -0.008066217415034771, -0.007492602802813053, 0.00843079388141632, -0.039606258273124695, -0.023467469960451126, 0.027194896712899208, -0.041732337325811386, 0.03854149580001831, -0.050000086426734924, -0.010104864835739136, 0.011573986150324345, -0.05668889358639717, 0.02003534510731697, 0.013521538116037846, -0.06093147397041321, -0.010653425939381123, -0.00903028529137373, -0.017007403075695038, 0.04116644710302353, 0.011078156530857086, 0.03529345616698265, 0.048516739159822464, 0.0183368232101202, 0.01738124154508114, 0.00507395388558507, -0.018938956782221794, 0.011367961764335632, -0.020325135439634323, 0.0496535561978817, 0.011103082448244095, -0.04567791894078255, 0.022084373980760574, -0.023533256724476814, -0.026260413229465485, -0.037220295518636703, 0.05001546069979668, 0.05897098779678345, 0.006885588634759188, -0.00006212126754689962, 0.001966977259144187, -0.03791791573166847, 0.021442944183945656, -0.06768745183944702, -0.060293275862932205, -0.032422129064798355, -0.061859674751758575, -0.032350584864616394, 0.03620116040110588, -0.02412879280745983, -0.026810556650161743, 0.013457424938678741, 0.030511295422911644, 0.048297587782144547, -0.020513005554676056, 0.02136882022023201, 0.011371067725121975, -0.037589073181152344, -0.013885772787034512, 0.02285683900117874, 0.04759750887751579, 0.002291614655405283, -0.06334786862134933, -0.002590341027826071, 0.04087032377719879, -0.005939612165093422, -0.019773628562688828, -0.03161786496639252, -0.002347392262890935, 0.04552578926086426, -0.03807975724339485, 0.01067216508090496, 0.03782268613576889, -0.011397818103432655, 0.014518370851874352, 0.03082621470093727, -0.0482807420194149, 0.01406331080943346, -0.0014033183688297868, 0.02852451615035534, 0.06563750654459, 0.0116368867456913, 0.024822073057293892, 0.02352309785783291, -0.02461952529847622, -0.02227403223514557, 0.037097226828336716, -0.017214199528098106, 0.047909628599882126, 0.03972841426730156, 0.020106147974729538, -0.027387216687202454, 0.08478805422782898, -0.028146203607320786, 0.02706574834883213, 0.0028598399367183447, -0.04237772151827812, -0.00842300709336996, 0.04082765057682991, -0.05382121726870537, -0.046541471034288406, -0.0038519117515534163, -0.054347217082977295, -0.030072707682847977, -0.019460273906588554, 0.045311957597732544, -0.018418995663523674, -0.035100989043712616, 0.022352321073412895, -0.002875238424167037, -0.044855933636426926, 0.01849089004099369, -0.04749055951833725, -0.029478147625923157, 0.043276019394397736, 0.012149753980338573, 0.026240408420562744, 0.009172380901873112, 0.052728258073329926, 0.04786531627178192, -0.0796673372387886, -0.00758550176396966, 0.023616982623934746, 0.0028577090706676245, 0.018914468586444855, 0.009232505224645138, -0.06506743282079697, 0.02595067024230957, 0.0032325000502169132, -0.005524493288248777, -0.0034452988766133785, 0.01109982468187809, 0.007911769673228264, 0.05598368123173714, 0.0036633925046771765, 0.0037548409309238195, 0.05902007967233658, -0.07056242972612381, 0.04992769658565521, 0.02870042622089386, -0.051886338740587234, 0.027888504788279533, -0.007047722116112709, -0.012067293748259544, 0.00018091250967700034, 0.04557177051901817, 0.046742092818021774, -0.01755296066403389, 0.027751924470067024, 0.06796341389417648, -0.023795872926712036, 0.0007523062522523105, -0.03353387489914894, 0.03106546401977539, -0.04384985938668251, -0.0070120966993272305, -0.04237310215830803, 0.013092986308038235, -0.000668190885335207, 0.022679012268781662, -0.021026110276579857, 0.04948931932449341, -0.024383772164583206, 0.04682629555463791, -0.04165124148130417, -0.04280119016766548, 0.03943106532096863, 0.04117943346500397, 0.009322800673544407, 0.018831798806786537, -0.00939943827688694, 0.06210848316550255, 0.04200400412082672, 0.008005378767848015, -0.02334105409681797, -0.02574753761291504, 0.0018949166405946016, -0.02744644321501255, 0.05436255782842636, 0.05112442374229431, 0.015845898538827896, -0.012766322121024132, -0.02418389916419983, -0.011935526505112648, -0.02632012777030468, -0.04886624217033386, -0.004106071311980486, -0.027227848768234253, 0.006442203186452389, 0.04435264319181442, -0.0671410858631134, -0.02284686639904976, 0.039362549781799316, -0.021241378039121628, -0.05078437924385071, -0.0012136073783040047, -0.036230623722076416, -0.0014692592667415738, -0.012139445170760155, -0.012938244268298149, 0.02434787154197693, 0.009716445580124855, -0.0305123720318079, 0.025262432172894478, -0.028825119137763977, 0.013090161606669426, 0.009070969186723232, -0.05542750656604767, 0.03249162808060646, -0.04495422914624214, 0.03210005536675453, -0.022329093888401985, -0.038355063647031784, 0.05779913812875748, 0.010689198039472103, 0.007783893030136824, 0.011971328407526016, -0.06761393696069717, 0.004027108196169138, 0.019592836499214172, -0.0046203238889575005, -0.02100592479109764, -0.05340743437409401, 0.06090246140956879, 0.08220651745796204, 0.020698314532637596, 0.07772094756364822, 0.09205149114131927, 0.02938055619597435, -0.052325427532196045, 0.047556549310684204, -0.05090003460645676, 0.06775893270969391, -0.05386793985962868, -0.01468745432794094, -0.04618502035737038, -0.019205765798687935, -0.00894413236528635, -0.01983099989593029, -0.013308976776897907, -0.022938502952456474, -0.016277344897389412, -0.053651802241802216, 0.0920405462384224, 0.044392406940460205, -0.009101970121264458, -0.05953406170010567, -0.044923942536115646, 0.026910029351711273, -0.04932461678981781, -0.015878712758421898, 0.023506291210651398, -0.04123113676905632, -0.08228737860918045, 0.04175572097301483, 0.0008693510899320245, -0.007743694819509983, 0.034015122801065445, -0.04238462820649147, 0.010802023112773895, 0.009893601760268211, -0.03320144861936569, 0.023514267057180405, 0.05966602638363838, -0.009209158830344677, -0.013702896423637867, -0.011291981674730778, -0.02405170165002346, 0.0509788878262043, -0.00023959390819072723, 0.01949971728026867, 0.0068125296384096146, 0.019806284457445145, 0.03786075860261917, -0.02893848530948162, 0.011045563034713268, -0.005084272939711809, -0.02771846018731594, 0.015420380979776382, -0.01654883660376072, -0.01819545589387417, 0.005639246199280024, 0.005155070219188929, 0.00020593097724486142, 0.018587660044431686, -0.013360429555177689, -0.0697980746626854, 0.047595422714948654, -0.02425861358642578, 0.03683556243777275, -0.06533770263195038, 0.015866566449403763, -0.016290804371237755, -0.03370843455195427, 0.0418565608561039, 0.03598729893565178, -0.01747916080057621, 0.013854946941137314, -0.05589795112609863, 0.04247802495956421, -0.006966085638850927, -0.02575225755572319, -0.014059646055102348, -0.06189216673374176, -0.03494452312588692, 0.0015050957445055246, 0.017265325412154198, -0.028521673753857613, 0.0068024154752492905, 0.07305213063955307, -0.06358379870653152, 0.011566265486180782, 0.05180875584483147, -0.010233848355710506, -0.003278079442679882, 0.01733289659023285, -0.020551146939396858, 0.024486135691404343, -0.040068235248327255, 0.011120913550257683, 0.03308672830462456, -0.08428540825843811, 0.05920100957155228, -0.03037966601550579, -0.028554242104291916, -0.022904356941580772, 0.019870609045028687, 0.008668461814522743, 0.004699858836829662, -0.037919532507658005, -0.04516497254371643, 0.02603437751531601, -0.011404980905354023, 0.08186217397451401, -0.001208198955282569, -0.02441534399986267, -0.02574746124446392, 0.08066906034946442, -0.004091067239642143, 0.013383658602833748, 0.03136685490608215, -0.005075376946479082, -0.018236707895994186, -0.025959424674510956, -0.03036605194211006, -0.002324103144928813, -0.013306209817528725, 0.005097726825624704, 0.020331567153334618, 0.03824194520711899, -0.039161067456007004, -0.024842647835612297, 0.07558687031269073, 0.03409750759601593, 0.011921264231204987, -0.03485046327114105, -0.01777147687971592, 0.02565537765622139, 0.03253454715013504, 0.004501705523580313, 0.05479484051465988, 0.027614153921604156, 0.05029473453760147, -0.016909247264266014, 0.03496084734797478, 0.06077628210186958, -0.0582190603017807, 0.08807539194822311, 0.014125857502222061, 0.040252480655908585, -0.005480234976857901, 0.08920425176620483, 0.002546172821894288, 0.022834502160549164, -0.0076323519460856915, 0.03608744964003563, 0.029007315635681152, 0.0719284936785698, -0.017379077151417732, -0.03758041188120842, 0.00579846790060401, -0.0069491807371377945, -0.03010311722755432, 0.02431884966790676, -0.035177942365407944, -0.03681989014148712, -0.035715702921152115, 0.04865553602576256, -0.08602993935346603, 0.05324489623308182, 0.01561161782592535, 0.01861608400940895, -0.024503415450453758, 0.04537373408675194, 0.046460870653390884, -0.0017758120084181428, -0.0022082652430981398, -0.08811482787132263, -0.008704177103936672, 0.033791434019804, -0.04344296455383301, -0.0378422737121582, -0.005524755921214819, -0.01685407944023609, -0.03237755224108696, 0.00591614143922925, 0.01337971817702055, -0.00569502916187048, 0.018543191254138947, 0.03228696435689926, 0.06325706839561462, 0.017703955993056297, 0.00856329221278429, 0.032756611704826355, -0.0004978018696419895, -0.03634040802717209, 0.05380179360508919, 0.03249343857169151, -0.032972969114780426, 0.009963292628526688, 0.002188810845836997, -0.061136774718761444, 0.020514195784926414, 0.04199691489338875, -0.010940775275230408, -0.030607067048549652, 0.05396457761526108, 0.019648389890789986, 0.0443405881524086, -0.024566803127527237, 0.011461193673312664, -0.0069130235351622105, -0.11046015471220016, -0.03792497143149376, -0.02646736614406109, 0.029766321182250977, -0.003695005550980568, 0.08037476986646652, 0.014784383587539196, 0.000547245901543647, -0.03044564463198185, 0.05002216249704361, -0.04266279190778732, 0.07116967439651489, 0.08049692958593369, -0.05086691305041313, 0.030779898166656494, -0.06964386254549026, 0.05515541881322861, 0.0008783566881902516, 0.03299577906727791, 0.007880248129367828, 0.08029477298259735, -0.023132843896746635, 0.019430246204137802, -0.005532761104404926, -0.015181930735707283, 0.008642862550914288, -0.056336913257837296, -0.05734706670045853, -0.007960948161780834, 0.040342506021261215, -0.018872259184718132, -0.09355109184980392, 0.0046320389956235886, -0.031242862343788147, 0.00237043178640306, -0.007683224976062775, -0.02156330831348896, 0.012942343018949032, -0.033618126064538956, -0.02009674534201622, -0.04955600947141647, -0.0021605659276247025, 0.008145718835294247, 0.047905322164297104, -0.01029359269887209, -0.004793270491063595, -0.022278515622019768, -0.06161607429385185, 0.00870099849998951, -0.04181494936347008, -0.04537956789135933, 0.03394171968102455, -0.024159377440810204, -0.03268691524863243, 0.012663374654948711, 0.003144793678075075, 0.02902008220553398, 0.031219186261296272, -0.005281573161482811, -0.03758041933178902, -0.03814854472875595, 0.06918051093816757, 0.040421996265649796, 0.03772681578993797, 0.019728289917111397, -0.021661801263689995, 0.009085058234632015, 0.004038583021610975, 0.059603579342365265, -0.025933781638741493, -0.01320307981222868, 0.030242500826716423, -0.013014945201575756, 0.027998365461826324, 0.03416052833199501, 0.01803160272538662, 0.005476254038512707, -0.009575198404490948, -0.045942362397909164, -0.02306683547794819, 0.020574774593114853, 0.0022738364059478045, 0.05798546224832535, -0.04928143322467804, -0.016350671648979187, -0.01771531067788601, 0.00038340655737556517, -0.014890903607010841, 0.0011402282398194075, 0.042022887617349625, 0.014035012573003769, 0.042385246604681015, -0.04417143762111664, -0.03226318210363388, -0.011837963946163654, -0.06183154135942459, 0.01211485918611288, 0.010960831306874752, -0.004225393757224083, 0.015247906558215618, 0.04762636497616768, 0.0392085500061512, 0.03920593112707138, -0.029709525406360626, 0.0367782823741436, 0.025427790358662605, -0.00963981356471777, 0.019860008731484413, 0.004154513124376535, 0.010407972149550915, -0.029015814885497093, 0.01840553991496563, -0.003568214364349842, 0.0012659602798521519, -0.01848677545785904, 0.019952906295657158, 0.0007969680591486394, 0.01455073244869709, -0.0637316182255745, 0.015805181115865707, 0.03056175820529461, 0.007141274865716696, 0.0304699894040823, -0.03802894800901413, 0.06036928668618202, -0.020125722512602806, -0.008661769330501556, 0.060774728655815125, 0.03994348272681236, -0.00319362198933959, 0.02831217646598816, 0.019853677600622177, -0.015435232780873775, 0.014751998707652092, -0.00769278546795249, 0.054860394448041916, -0.02013670839369297, 0.12718500196933746, 0.05771944671869278, -0.014742789790034294, 0.054880540817976, -0.0202970989048481, -0.05946053937077522, 0.03941555321216583, -0.07664871215820312, 0.024172941222786903, 0.0038141333498060703, -0.01143233384937048, 0.004263787064701319, -0.04054899513721466, -0.03406248241662979, -0.04256943240761757, -0.0006505663623102009, 0.02167464978992939, -0.013336067087948322, -0.006353246513754129, 0.07403318583965302, 0.020943785086274147, 0.05498385429382324, -0.04438436031341553, -0.02995459921658039, -0.06167150288820267, 0.010197867639362812, -0.011249237693846226, 0.02266777865588665, 0.0389263816177845, -0.011279351077973843, -0.023781144991517067, 0.008014572784304619, -0.009054034017026424, -0.007861960679292679, -0.01276225596666336, -0.03451430797576904, -0.0178928654640913, 0.012468283995985985, 0.019353704527020454, -0.016795361414551735, -0.018915457651019096, -0.0051912362687289715, -0.03833925724029541, -0.026653364300727844, 0.0007298746495507658, -0.02716708742082119, -0.012398880906403065, 0.006720318458974361, 0.020434921607375145, -0.04850326478481293, 0.019330210983753204, 0.0016275561647489667, -0.03537245839834213, -0.011105257086455822, -0.019423844292759895, 0.05742127075791359, -0.018694916740059853, 0.009456492960453033, -0.012001942843198776, -0.06446751207113266, 0.02787790820002556, -0.003558625467121601, 0.024154726415872574, -0.02510569989681244, -0.0009685706463642418, 0.009508859366178513, 0.04453099146485329, -0.013216369785368443, -0.014128929935395718, -0.0075617297552526, -0.035490892827510834, -0.025780847296118736, 0.007033384870737791, -0.0014307246310636401, -0.05958566442131996, -0.00001098750999517506, -0.007724418770521879, 0.03988618403673172, -0.02461528405547142, -0.02969425730407238, -0.012488067150115967, 0.016608944162726402, -0.07230304181575775, -0.016422089189291, 0.024255700409412384, -0.0033356202766299248, -0.07392451167106628, 0.01470994669944048, -0.051660504192113876, -0.05625598505139351, 0.06846024096012115, -0.02051449939608574, 0.014142844825983047, -0.0595935583114624, -0.039145827293395996, 0.003241141326725483, 0.018528223037719727, 0.023609217256307602, 0.015979714691638947, 0.025199230760335922, -0.03089105896651745, -0.06594566255807877, 0.059693895280361176, 0.011006846092641354, -0.055922526866197586, -0.011523622088134289, 0.01242474652826786, 0.05111003294587135, -0.040778473019599915, -0.006219980772584677, 0.0743819996714592, 0.03586464002728462, -0.02224906161427498, 0.08031411468982697, -0.004048103932291269, -0.030984405428171158, 0.04008220508694649, -0.01803004927933216, -0.07682111859321594, 0.03492976352572441, -0.009850265458226204, -0.022495020180940628, -0.011569540947675705, -0.04984144866466522, 0.0009638819610700011, -0.002864003414288163, -0.04707916080951691, 0.034573089331388474, -0.07307735830545425, -0.03374861180782318, -0.01103671733289957 ]
<p>If we have a planar and harmonic EM wave, with $B$ field:</p> <p>$$B=A\left(\begin{array}{c} 1\\ i\\0 \end{array} \right)e^{-i(\omega t-\vec k\cdot\vec r)}$$</p> <p>and with it's corresponding $E$ field. This is a circularly polarised wave, but that field does not have 0 divergence, the three components of it, when taking real part, are:</p> <p>$$x=\cos (\vec k\cdot\vec r-\omega t)$$ $$y=i\cdot i\sin(\vec k\cdot\vec r-\omega t)=-\sin(\vec k\cdot\vec r-\omega t)$$ $$z=0$$</p> <p>Tha divergence won't be 0 unless $\vec k=(0,0,a)$, for some $a$. so what's the problem here? Isn't that a wave unless it spread on the $z$ axis? If the $E$ field is just the same but with different phase, I guess the same thing would have to hold if the wave had not matter around: $\nabla\cdot E =0$, right?</p>
g4211
[ 0.0285353884100914, -0.018539896234869957, 0.00885992031544447, -0.010557327419519424, 0.11716117709875107, 0.03337830677628517, 0.03722492232918739, 0.025814473628997803, 0.01038124319165945, -0.04849017783999443, -0.02675190567970276, 0.002473534317687154, -0.018100334331393242, -0.016574086621403694, 0.009980973787605762, -0.028366180136799812, 0.0257252287119627, -0.0003582071221899241, -0.005761496722698212, 0.02713809534907341, -0.08251355588436127, 0.013605495914816856, 0.023103130981326103, -0.024375181645154953, 0.020431237295269966, -0.046250466257333755, 0.03171028569340706, -0.08572164177894592, -0.028594860807061195, -0.045706525444984436, 0.025976987555623055, 0.05811728909611702, 0.048769205808639526, -0.02053540199995041, -0.011457604356110096, -0.009693407453596592, 0.02370643801987171, 0.01873009093105793, 0.027028799057006836, 0.0018664241069927812, 0.042936451733112335, 0.0068398891016840935, -0.013574826531112194, 0.049425650388002396, 0.03453703597187996, -0.025253744795918465, -0.020061085000634193, 0.055701419711112976, -0.031245660036802292, -0.02311554178595543, -0.011808730661869049, 0.009483393281698227, 0.09331843256950378, -0.04070591181516647, 0.030164586380124092, 0.025831786915659904, 0.002094424096867442, -0.005629512015730143, 0.043262287974357605, 0.023632150143384933, 0.005441600456833839, -0.016244934871792793, -0.012001603841781616, 0.04143916442990303, 0.003050371306017041, -0.033626433461904526, -0.045172810554504395, -0.01568674109876156, -0.0176814254373312, 0.02704836055636406, 0.016153674572706223, -0.07203371822834015, -0.01720753125846386, -0.03696504980325699, -0.05466512590646744, 0.0008612170931883156, 0.010482440702617168, -0.04259198531508446, 0.022644497454166412, -0.046862851828336716, -0.007756435312330723, 0.02797762118279934, -0.03858935832977295, 0.044515665620565414, 0.0022415833082050085, 0.010993114672601223, 0.048121046274900436, -0.001919906004332006, -0.043414220213890076, -0.020053749904036522, 0.043009202927351, -0.010307155549526215, -0.00308767007663846, 0.04547431319952011, 0.01805061101913452, -0.01082663144916296, -0.03349835053086281, 0.03434821963310242, 0.030883286148309708, -0.030053388327360153, 0.003562087658792734, 0.012536945752799511, -0.04356801137328148, -0.015744902193546295, -0.01328499149531126, 0.026111023500561714, 0.04945233091711998, 0.044795017689466476, -0.002667628228664398, -0.0039412095211446285, -0.0014044763520359993, -0.0493856742978096, -0.05545424297451973, -0.06491749733686447, -0.040521040558815, -0.019782572984695435, 0.0062904744409024715, -0.01087169162929058, 0.04018132761120796, 0.05129760131239891, 0.01679391786456108, -0.011592656373977661, 0.024614689871668816, 0.07141441851854324, -0.005313962232321501, 0.028363285586237907, 0.02177351713180542, 0.030394665896892548, 0.09749166667461395, -0.01188615895807743, 0.011839745566248894, 0.04397609829902649, 0.0035131522454321384, -0.00753244711086154, -0.008768966421484947, -0.013083893805742264, -0.03484737128019333, 0.028722021728754044, 0.0029496958013623953, 0.03564845770597458, -0.025798514485359192, -0.032729730010032654, 0.06787215918302536, -0.062085025012493134, -0.04344575107097626, 0.0022291510831564665, 0.039389751851558685, -0.10322661697864532, 0.03207791596651077, 0.01829783245921135, 0.012857089750468731, 0.06610701233148575, 0.03650189936161041, 0.031206922605633736, 0.022415921092033386, 0.03476818650960922, 0.04837845265865326, -0.05851248279213905, -0.02945137582719326, -0.004292490426450968, 0.04312313348054886, 0.020987065508961678, -0.00802899431437254, -0.0028450828976929188, -0.0010640313848853111, -0.005821334198117256, 0.006464569829404354, -0.04900665581226349, 0.0009210885036736727, -0.013946677558124065, -0.03708302974700928, 0.015171860344707966, -0.019685350358486176, 0.013096587732434273, -0.006427861750125885, 0.10275978595018387, -0.0347474031150341, -0.02266291156411171, 0.06895096600055695, 0.00537166278809309, -0.05546928942203522, 0.035617630928754807, -0.018558714538812637, -0.00858745165169239, 0.04054807871580124, -0.016945911571383476, -0.01725180074572563, -0.026995012536644936, -0.05549365654587746, -0.014056531712412834, 0.03986214101314545, -0.008229908533394337, -0.02014848217368126, 0.0067932261154055595, -0.03294247016310692, 0.028720220550894737, -0.01644478552043438, -0.02402765117585659, -0.041374512016773224, 0.06193079799413681, -0.007512443698942661, 0.08128585666418076, 0.06163892149925232, -0.012721642851829529, 0.02118571475148201, -0.02550339139997959, -0.00876863207668066, -0.004423966631293297, 0.03567468002438545, -0.0125177763402462, 0.04698435589671135, -0.06429944187402725, -0.03293101489543915, -0.03196996450424194, -0.019264433532953262, -0.003279345342889428, 0.05636005476117134, 0.050861600786447525, -0.04498104006052017, 0.05732668563723564, -0.05097074806690216, 0.023348603397607803, 0.0514858141541481, -0.03301756829023361, -0.05723930150270462, 0.03681020438671112, -0.025769680738449097, -0.008404567837715149, 0.004689945373684168, 0.025819027796387672, -0.01047899667173624, 0.0039261989295482635, 0.07253173738718033, 0.018897676840424538, 0.07767992466688156, -0.013348013162612915, -0.03183521330356598, -0.024807780981063843, 0.02573801949620247, 0.019415900111198425, 0.021693294867873192, -0.03476189821958542, -0.015226964838802814, -0.014381000772118568, 0.07495831698179245, -0.010426956228911877, 0.08962142467498779, 0.0470704659819603, -0.03404959291219711, -0.017076926305890083, 0.020468369126319885, -0.04327033832669258, 0.011580295860767365, 0.05163002386689186, -0.03071269392967224, -0.021670181304216385, -0.009919904172420502, 0.04860633984208107, -0.0011364870006218553, 0.002718714065849781, -0.046493254601955414, -0.01004110835492611, 0.0795934870839119, 0.04252895340323448, -0.07305064797401428, 0.0165087953209877, 0.0007861602935008705, 0.026496483013033867, 0.0003986628435086459, -0.05241294577717781, -0.06697165220975876, 0.05799150839447975, 0.011698711663484573, 0.11166556924581528, -0.031445685774087906, -0.014375120401382446, 0.0017240766901522875, 0.004874635487794876, -0.02079198695719242, -0.03605206683278084, -0.04570401459932327, 0.04236842691898346, 0.05268847197294235, -0.03849772736430168, 0.03821800276637077, -0.07035776227712631, -0.005304116290062666, 0.048656877130270004, -0.0008627835777588189, 0.01090618409216404, -0.03308903053402901, -0.02910376526415348, 0.062152303755283356, -0.002505555283278227, 0.06021082401275635, -0.004178619012236595, 0.013139910995960236, -0.11208105087280273, -0.01999768055975437, 0.049456171691417694, 0.018915006890892982, 0.0641392394900322, -0.004380259662866592, -0.03787248954176903, 0.056407380849123, 0.006298367865383625, -0.020648669451475143, -0.06231698766350746, 0.005028705112636089, 0.024396615102887154, -0.006556773092597723, 0.03402980417013168, 0.004201607778668404, -0.00909852609038353, -0.015263638459146023, 0.04282514005899429, -0.04652193933725357, -0.02507406286895275, 0.03391221910715103, 0.007160840090364218, -0.029176408424973488, -0.024333704262971878, -0.008720973506569862, 0.010524631477892399, 0.01706830784678459, 0.026405053213238716, -0.02947279065847397, 0.03950788825750351, -0.04494693502783775, -0.009982881136238575, -0.04410770535469055, 0.0005095330998301506, 0.05245548486709595, 0.02421334944665432, -0.021775690838694572, -0.016494955867528915, 0.03753633052110672, 0.0505751334130764, 0.021775677800178528, 0.0011441475944593549, -0.020534325391054153, -0.03676209598779678, -0.01991685852408409, -0.01795746199786663, -0.024793826043605804, 0.02302846871316433, -0.0049833497032523155, -0.013444751501083374, -0.01303970254957676, -0.009404342621564865, 0.007995504885911942, -0.03830276057124138, 0.0403905063867569, 0.01453456375747919, 0.001589326187968254, 0.02909548394382, 0.04745396226644516, 0.019758697599172592, -0.03705703839659691, 0.020381610840559006, 0.021301891654729843, -0.025995837524533272, 0.028114227578043938, -0.010775046423077583, 0.014853689819574356, 0.04143335297703743, 0.01597166433930397, 0.026823725551366806, 0.015553480945527554, -0.01803898997604847, 0.05198217183351517, -0.03552532568573952, -0.02364725060760975, 0.011515066027641296, -0.022053001448512077, -0.04839819669723511, -0.0017694508424028754, 0.041422996670007706, -0.04137660190463066, -0.02569928951561451, 0.01841922663152218, -0.012410440482199192, -0.024712851271033287, 0.028402596712112427, -0.000787933066021651, -0.0056722890585660934, -0.0034083209466189146, -0.015178857371211052, 0.002199272159487009, 0.05909958481788635, 0.023056309670209885, 0.013735746033489704, 0.019747594371438026, 0.015435921028256416, 0.0003655584587249905, -0.061839547008275986, -0.01787872426211834, -0.027656586840748787, -0.05279644951224327, 0.027064993977546692, 0.02786118909716606, -0.020930472761392593, -0.001481371815316379, 0.007563787046819925, -0.019808899611234665, 0.022747645154595375, 0.043289121240377426, -0.001293698325753212, 0.00990267749875784, -0.051703374832868576, 0.04520052298903465, 0.013593259267508984, -0.04568181931972504, -0.05235322192311287, 0.062103863805532455, 0.02697153389453888, 0.05209706351161003, 0.05401969701051712, 0.021096689626574516, 0.009617218747735023, -0.04097365215420723, 0.011931010521948338, -0.04161853715777397, -0.002246374962851405, 0.0004319890576880425, 0.007907390594482422, 0.06962630897760391, -0.030620699748396873, -0.02749941125512123, 0.025427019223570824, 0.0034477352164685726, 0.0026114541105926037, 0.0022775460965931416, -0.0008071995689533651, -0.0730978325009346, 0.02639250084757805, -0.0575752817094326, 0.05668838322162628, -0.04771362245082855, 0.047147516161203384, 0.0618554949760437, -0.03973827883601189, 0.026510631665587425, -0.030658679082989693, -0.008722703903913498, 0.04684596508741379, -0.05159633979201317, -0.05755278840661049, 0.05562708526849747, 0.016190363094210625, -0.03452169895172119, 0.03078984096646309, 0.004242073278874159, -0.007327228784561157, -0.03235127776861191, -0.027799731120467186, -0.019144007936120033, 0.0432274304330349, 0.007862526923418045, 0.007971886545419693, -0.055771008133888245, 0.0006718392833136022, -0.03853907436132431, 0.006278101820498705, 0.04605697840452194, -0.024335455149412155, -0.031864602118730545, 0.01108972541987896, -0.025701899081468582, 0.021933117881417274, 0.01011610683053732, 0.03952110931277275, 0.0442742258310318, 0.04313216358423233, -0.05230573192238808, 0.03975147753953934, 0.01104124914854765, -0.02502724714577198, -0.08005271106958389, -0.06157400459051132, -0.02943662367761135, -0.0824795663356781, 0.002138565294444561, 0.05665011331439018, 0.004256328567862511, 0.010417555458843708, -0.03065161406993866, -0.003660056972876191, -0.040220893919467926, -0.04678363353013992, -0.004494459368288517, 0.029145902022719383, -0.029911616817116737, 0.00744603481143713, 0.05903584882616997, -0.03283172473311424, 0.01930266059935093, -0.014307137578725815, 0.0038808565586805344, -0.05462273582816124, -0.09346641600131989, 0.008020414039492607, -0.019751038402318954, -0.016582269221544266, -0.02843809686601162, 0.03362357243895531, 0.06994515657424927, -0.023379279300570488, -0.06265749037265778, 0.006793327163904905, 0.003221216145902872, -0.005776220466941595, -0.014659414999186993, 0.02297890931367874, -0.006934273988008499, -0.05983370542526245, -0.10232484340667725, -0.02106289379298687, -0.026905467733740807, -0.01519840955734253, -0.007070695515722036, 0.01835194230079651, 0.0022843137849122286, -0.035414308309555054, 0.053486861288547516, -0.006201505661010742, -0.05298813432455063, -0.08557280898094177, 0.006314848084002733, 0.055136725306510925, 0.04476861655712128, 0.06572557240724564, 0.04889065399765968, -0.04329792037606239, 0.05128297209739685, -0.049836352467536926, 0.021239450201392174, 0.018144354224205017, -0.0006768475868739188, 0.012034168466925621, 0.018343744799494743, -0.05759678781032562, 0.04196027293801308, 0.046955324709415436, -0.015548862516880035, 0.027341531589627266, 0.01809707097709179, 0.020961042493581772, 0.05629788339138031, -0.06022876501083374, -0.060524117201566696, 0.016870927065610886, -0.03426957502961159, -0.019110752269625664, -0.03520325943827629, 0.02098369598388672, -0.004877341445535421, 0.02861231192946434, -0.0361969992518425, -0.06025807559490204, 0.029218388721346855, -0.04824090749025345, -0.03375070169568062, -0.03533522039651871, -0.03906259685754776, -0.047977473586797714, 0.016507133841514587, 0.038607269525527954, 0.03743577003479004, 0.051788248121738434, -0.0637856274843216, -0.02283666655421257, -0.019446756690740585, 0.010986595414578915, 0.014612875878810883, 0.007579336874186993, 0.006639075931161642, -0.05654020234942436, -0.0013612416805699468, 0.014754196628928185, 0.024350237101316452, 0.0385262705385685, 0.029143627732992172, -0.009336816146969795, -0.00789509154856205, 0.06346026062965393, -0.06983092427253723, -0.06222901865839958, 0.08118505775928497, 0.03647180274128914, -0.07924696058034897, 0.005311660468578339, 0.028343502432107925, 0.0218788031488657, -0.01280203927308321, -0.011128625832498074, -0.01560903713107109, 0.02685878425836563, -0.0008956014644354582, -0.01048855297267437, 0.02518274448812008, 0.012058109976351261, 0.02594710886478424, 0.03481545299291611, 0.012191453948616982, 0.035141244530677795, 0.027148373425006866, -0.023991525173187256, -0.06150713190436363, -0.0069619049318134785, 0.06700468808412552, -0.010771569795906544, 0.01220154482871294, -0.044254813343286514, -0.03829241544008255, -0.004102291539311409, -0.03289473429322243, 0.02623376064002514, -0.0027042885776609182, 0.03234598785638809, 0.03505552560091019, 0.015911879017949104, -0.034199029207229614, 0.0040581743232905865, 0.02029033750295639, -0.01231272891163826, -0.02193165384232998, -0.006358774844557047, 0.01945025846362114, 0.062205273658037186, 0.07601374387741089, 0.017504584044218063, -0.06838104873895645, 0.01978514902293682, 0.015993954613804817, -0.01599026843905449, -0.07356181740760803, 0.03137396648526192, 0.032356541603803635, 0.02011232264339924, -0.03373356908559799, 0.05997734144330025, 0.06481682509183884, 0.003888240549713373, -0.04267849773168564, 0.03283631429076195, -0.0096368957310915, -0.003290432272478938, -0.030668245628476143, -0.029247045516967773, 0.04769400879740715, 0.016918275505304337, -0.019111037254333496, -0.0481560193002224, -0.012053404934704304, -0.023389114066958427, 0.041335832327604294, 0.022519551217556, -0.02942183054983616, -0.034368131309747696, -0.024744730442762375, -0.02552996389567852, -0.029235882684588432, -0.013369022868573666, -0.004579145926982164, 0.004081382416188717, -0.006584853865206242, 0.009864338673651218, -0.01988549344241619, -0.02906915359199047, -0.016717884689569473, -0.01446574181318283, -0.03921317309141159, 0.0025606979615986347, 0.013638236559927464, 0.04749435558915138, -0.05461406707763672, -0.003000795841217041, 0.01335633359849453, 0.051320549100637436, 0.0018868987681344151, -0.03183402866125107, -0.014674453064799309, -0.04188995435833931, 0.03533729538321495, 0.026133067905902863, -0.03274674341082573, 0.002641307422891259, 0.01194673776626587, 0.006259154994040728, 0.020625121891498566, 0.020400328561663628, -0.020760448649525642, 0.014298011548817158, -0.020064257085323334, -0.004419992677867413, 0.039642319083213806, 0.06954234093427658, 0.015108322724699974, -0.030744733288884163, 0.014868789352476597, 0.007136780768632889, 0.02585689350962639, -0.014282377436757088, 0.02786496840417385, -0.015203804709017277, -0.0010622416157275438, -0.03373965993523598, -0.04814242944121361, 0.057486534118652344, 0.00610663928091526, -0.02406139485538006, -0.012788929976522923, -0.028317153453826904, 0.008491219021379948, 0.008985246531665325, -0.05304381996393204, 0.016691651195287704, -0.03241654112935066, -0.05056380853056908, -0.07396640628576279, 0.035363636910915375, -0.00923610758036375, -0.02195715717971325, 0.007555294316262007, 0.013604707084596157, -0.050234194844961166, 0.022746820002794266, 0.06753571331501007, -0.0753658264875412, -0.014043399132788181, 0.003692300757393241, -0.06270106881856918, 0.04941389337182045, -0.01099459920078516, 0.03381006792187691, -0.008507924154400826, -0.008068517781794071, 0.005065388977527618, -0.054830096662044525, 0.031151054427027702, -0.04530102014541626, 0.04828257113695145, -0.06902395188808441, 0.03764645382761955, 0.009543345309793949, 0.004083151929080486, 0.016986479982733727, 0.00306905061006546, -0.020676955580711365, -0.0778852328658104, 0.022944599390029907, -0.049862876534461975, 0.03246796503663063, 0.019287507981061935, -0.02627754583954811, 0.026639558374881744, -0.02148403786122799, 0.07641826570034027, -0.017661573365330696, -0.05546024814248085, -0.03658895939588547, -0.026526937261223793, -0.02102924883365631, -0.0004740262811537832, -0.0655912458896637, -0.024354534223675728, 0.0654272809624672 ]
<p>I want to show that the 2-d wave equation is invariant under a boost, so, the starting point is the wave equation</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial x^2}=\frac{1}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial t^2} $$</p> <p>and the Lorentz transformation:</p> <p>$$t'=\gamma(t-\frac{v}{c^2}x) \\ x'=\gamma(x-vt)$$</p> <p>My question is <strong>should I write $\displaystyle\frac{\partial}{\partial t}$ as a derivative with respect to $x'$ and $t'$ and then substitute?</strong></p> <p>Work done so far</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial}{\partial t}=\frac{\partial }{\partial x'}\frac{\partial x'}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial}{\partial t'}\frac{\partial t'}{\partial t}=-\gamma v\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}+\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial t'} $$</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial^2}{\partial t^2}=\frac{\partial }{\partial t}\left(\frac{\partial}{\partial t} \right)=\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\left( -\gamma v\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}+\gamma \frac{\partial}{\partial t'}\right)= \\ =-\gamma v\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}\left( -\gamma v\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}+\gamma \frac{\partial}{\partial t'}\right)+\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial t'}\left( -\gamma v\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}+\gamma \frac{\partial}{\partial t'}\right)=\\ = \gamma^2v^2\frac{\partial^2}{\partial x'^2}-2\gamma^2v\frac{\partial ^2}{\partial x'\partial t'}+\gamma^2\frac{\partial^2 }{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>-Edit-</p> <p>The same applies to $x$</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial}{\partial x}=\frac{\partial }{\partial x'}\frac{\partial x'}{\partial x}+\frac{\partial }{\partial t'}\frac{\partial t'}{\partial x}=\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}-\frac{\gamma v}{c^2}\frac{\partial }{\partial t'} $$</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial^2}{\partial x^2}=\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left( \frac{\partial }{\partial x}\right)=\frac{\partial}{\partial x}\left(\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}-\frac{\gamma v}{c^2}\frac{\partial }{\partial t'} \right)= \\ = \gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}\left(\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}-\frac{\gamma v}{c^2}\frac{\partial }{\partial t'} \right)-\frac{\gamma v}{c^2}\frac{\partial }{\partial t'}\left(\gamma\frac{\partial}{\partial x'}-\frac{\gamma v}{c^2}\frac{\partial }{\partial t'} \right)=\\= \gamma^2\frac{\partial^2 }{\partial x'^2}-2\frac{\gamma^2v}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 }{\partial x'\partial t' }+\frac{\gamma^2v^2}{c^4}\frac{\partial^2}{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>Edit 2 with the hints given by nervxxx</p> <p>The wave equation becomes</p> <p>$$\frac{\gamma^2v^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}-\frac{2\gamma^2v}{c^2}\frac{\partial ^2 \phi}{\partial x'\partial t'}+\frac{\gamma^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2}=\gamma^2\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}-2\frac{\gamma^2v}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'\partial t' }+\frac{\gamma^2v^2}{c^4}\frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>$$ \frac{\gamma^2 v^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial ^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}+\frac{\gamma^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2}=\gamma^2\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}+\frac{\gamma^2v^2}{c^4}\frac{\partial ^2\phi}{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>But I still don't get... since all $\gamma^2$ cancel</p> <p>Final edit. done!</p> <p>$$ \frac{\gamma^2 v^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial ^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}-\gamma^2\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}=\frac{\gamma^2v^2}{c^4}\frac{\partial ^2\phi}{\partial t'^2}-\frac{\gamma^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>$$\gamma=\frac{1}{\sqrt{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}} $$</p> <p>$$ \left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{v^2}{c^2}\frac{\partial ^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}-\left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}=\left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{v^2}{c^4}\frac{\partial ^2\phi}{\partial t'^2}-\left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{1}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2}$$</p> <p>$$ \left( \frac{v^2}{c^2-v^2}\right)\frac{\partial ^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}-\left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial x'^2}=\left( \frac{v^2}{c^2-v^2}\right)\frac{\partial ^2\phi}{\partial t'^2}\frac{1}{c^2}-\left( \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)\frac{1}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2} $$</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial \phi^2}{\partial x'^2}\left(\frac{v^2}{c^2-v^2}- \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right)=\frac{\partial^2 \phi}{\partial t'^2}\frac{1}{c^2}\left(\frac{v^2}{c^2-v^2}- \frac{1}{1-\frac{v^2}{c^2}}\right) $$</p> <p>$$ \frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial x'^2}=\frac{1}{c^2}\frac{\partial^2\phi}{\partial t'^2} $$</p>
g4212
[ 0.00128279032651335, -0.0622638463973999, 0.0063314372673630714, -0.054674066603183746, 0.03377866372466087, -0.0016452153213322163, 0.03925062343478203, 0.06654368340969086, -0.029661931097507477, 0.03725515305995941, -0.007669831160455942, 0.05195184051990509, -0.0015988220693543553, 0.043648380786180496, 0.015147680416703224, -0.020848402753472328, 0.07797829061746597, -0.01114604715257883, -0.0027690737042576075, -0.03635791316628456, -0.0516989529132843, 0.020447898656129837, 0.020280400291085243, -0.039374858140945435, 0.02712743915617466, -0.02907080203294754, 0.06728087365627289, -0.015021919272840023, -0.03229076415300369, -0.012710431590676308, 0.03789133578538895, 0.06162706017494202, 0.05137927457690239, -0.00431235833093524, -0.03912386670708656, 0.005825444590300322, 0.04380197077989578, 0.07256970554590225, 0.014226716011762619, 0.0036765437107533216, 0.020461685955524445, 0.011589372530579567, -0.03178657963871956, -0.009645124897360802, 0.005605849903076887, -0.08771377056837082, -0.026038970798254013, 0.02960510365664959, -0.029625805094838142, 0.024694716557860374, -0.020474838092923164, 0.03339236602187157, 0.06011668220162392, -0.059835005551576614, -0.026067301630973816, 0.04540044069290161, 0.057779569178819656, -0.015187757089734077, 0.017500951886177063, 0.059037595987319946, -0.026526926085352898, -0.043232548981904984, 0.024958526715636253, -0.00012712540046777576, 0.013206823728978634, -0.009420044720172882, -0.03866955637931824, -0.014834649860858917, -0.023460516706109047, 0.017705507576465607, -0.02952033467590809, 0.048762962222099304, 0.031435899436473846, -0.017962714657187462, 0.03285821154713631, -0.004966859705746174, -0.022694746032357216, -0.0026125910226255655, -0.024623805657029152, -0.02128741331398487, 0.0014501599362120032, 0.0054563055746257305, 0.0044576567597687244, -0.04109180346131325, 0.03404742479324341, 0.02273973822593689, 0.015408909879624844, 0.03305448591709137, 0.011509961448609829, 0.02112114056944847, 0.015819311141967773, -0.03318580985069275, 0.0053884610533714294, 0.002615823410451412, 0.03430556133389473, -0.012006542645394802, -0.031764544546604156, -0.00864324439316988, 0.0108561422675848, -0.01506105624139309, 0.02609746903181076, -0.00435183010995388, -0.03055221028625965, -0.009982195682823658, -0.02250354178249836, -0.0035837735049426556, 0.020046137273311615, 0.012938331812620163, -0.022399676963686943, -0.0023936759680509567, -0.00949303898960352, -0.022348713129758835, 0.048263225704431534, -0.02553284540772438, -0.036274947226047516, -0.015951531007885933, 0.023149659857153893, -0.027574479579925537, -0.035648006945848465, 0.026577390730381012, 0.014125511050224304, 0.0043922001495957375, 0.02672351896762848, 0.0782867819070816, 0.042864732444286346, -0.013523729518055916, -0.03725766763091087, 0.010366289876401424, 0.05634434521198273, -0.03952145203948021, -0.019405197352170944, -0.016270047053694725, 0.011436802335083485, 0.0200321227312088, -0.035057637840509415, 0.03882940113544464, 0.019382936879992485, 0.004666408058255911, -0.006436170544475317, 0.012847529724240303, -0.030802493914961815, -0.0409109890460968, 0.009061673656105995, -0.017551276832818985, -0.014247308485209942, 0.03935706242918968, 0.0010516708716750145, -0.04241376742720604, 0.06970636546611786, -0.05459717661142349, -0.013762196525931358, 0.07550723105669022, 0.006419355049729347, 0.08781615644693375, 0.0017631975933909416, -0.003174471203237772, 0.06753113865852356, -0.01701015792787075, -0.03124292567372322, 0.017835648730397224, 0.052196208387613297, -0.011641069315373898, 0.011220037937164307, 0.009239384904503822, 0.009589175693690777, 0.013828206807374954, 0.05516800656914711, -0.03326486051082611, -0.06248720362782478, -0.010017129592597485, -0.03374652564525604, 0.027457909658551216, 0.05901309847831726, 0.006133254151791334, 0.031595628708601, 0.023369446396827698, -0.03586401045322418, 0.00727550545707345, -0.00739007955417037, 0.027857575565576553, -0.038442935794591904, -0.053178224712610245, 0.008079570718109608, -0.0161136407405138, 0.016485458239912987, -0.058873675763607025, -0.016063980758190155, -0.005329192150384188, -0.0813174918293953, 0.034659191966056824, -0.0007755339611321688, -0.01027258113026619, 0.013888307847082615, 0.07063928991556168, 0.019654421135783195, 0.042023010551929474, 0.030146727338433266, -0.05115346983075142, -0.07438859343528748, 0.057354915887117386, -0.031018409878015518, 0.05900850519537926, 0.1048639714717865, -0.0358244888484478, 0.037916216999292374, 0.003160892752930522, 0.027960211038589478, 0.004136599134653807, -0.019149433821439743, 0.0038731631357222795, 0.028849175199866295, -0.0796310305595398, -0.012385948561131954, 0.01005998533219099, -0.03978482633829117, -0.07629869878292084, -0.017391657456755638, -0.01584906503558159, -0.06162627041339874, 0.03432498872280121, -0.020382054150104523, -0.021157417446374893, 0.028517091646790504, 0.005964298732578754, -0.06861898303031921, 0.018868913874030113, -0.01966220885515213, 0.026766745373606682, -0.010120963677763939, -0.006365394219756126, 0.012033204548060894, 0.0019272917415946722, 0.0030322123784571886, -0.01008374523371458, 0.04889274761080742, -0.020239196717739105, -0.07115922123193741, 0.022869862616062164, 0.010899356566369534, -0.007977785542607307, 0.009641383774578571, 0.000891827221494168, 0.006571884732693434, -0.03531843051314354, 0.03563574701547623, 0.018530435860157013, 0.011456378735601902, 0.025067826732993126, 0.03212989121675491, -0.04504328966140747, 0.04465150088071823, -0.001584764919243753, -0.016257744282484055, -0.013202181085944176, 0.01276917103677988, -0.04780375212430954, 0.02182740345597267, 0.08816169202327728, -0.00041914722532965243, 0.0033487926702946424, -0.039001770317554474, -0.03949563205242157, -0.004454934969544411, 0.03534915670752525, -0.06464758515357971, 0.03271275758743286, -0.021240079775452614, -0.011966257356107235, 0.008241035044193268, -0.038574982434511185, 0.020116858184337616, 0.017524201422929764, -0.00001770049857441336, 0.041947200894355774, -0.0016720202984288335, -0.053409576416015625, -0.0026342144701629877, -0.005137455649673939, -0.0029375292360782623, 0.03490966930985451, 0.03391781449317932, 0.038814425468444824, 0.007464556489139795, 0.10562438517808914, 0.009333510883152485, -0.05018729344010353, 0.0071747200563549995, 0.032305892556905746, 0.01626424305140972, 0.07324439287185669, -0.029463939368724823, -0.0013975986512377858, -0.011286778375506401, -0.005958001594990492, -0.028019901365041733, -0.034761976450681686, -0.006627143360674381, -0.08725747466087341, 0.030167171731591225, -0.031502705067396164, 0.00914306566119194, -0.00653414661064744, 0.004069160670042038, 0.014301936142146587, 0.02744360640645027, -0.07182870805263519, -0.0036194075364619493, -0.05468866229057312, -0.00035235172254033387, 0.033757150173187256, -0.031475067138671875, 0.027188491076231003, 0.013402781449258327, -0.010063404217362404, -0.015034861862659454, 0.03187476471066475, -0.06870820373296738, -0.04840351641178131, -0.0538705438375473, 0.00007338635623455048, -0.015234327875077724, -0.06287595629692078, -0.006123013328760862, 0.049325864762067795, 0.024759652093052864, -0.026403363794088364, -0.05077999830245972, -0.02806047350168228, -0.08829899877309799, -0.04707195982336998, 0.004229261074215174, 0.0016729794442653656, 0.025007102638483047, -0.05207294598221779, 0.02050522342324257, -0.028178421780467033, -0.014482591301202774, 0.042247772216796875, 0.020793138071894646, -0.05048534274101257, -0.03920500725507736, -0.025682803243398666, -0.04850788041949272, 0.011292041279375553, 0.007945844903588295, -0.040683992207050323, 0.006534797139465809, -0.004189662169665098, 0.010617215186357498, -0.03190463408827782, -0.02642972208559513, -0.002499675378203392, -0.002316421363502741, 0.004569068551063538, 0.021882550790905952, 0.010354118421673775, 0.09976489096879959, 0.017758985981345177, 0.03800445422530174, -0.010836404748260975, 0.03470940142869949, -0.012715284712612629, -0.0362977609038353, 0.005714410915970802, -0.04940079152584076, -0.0019210301106795669, 0.04895986616611481, 0.04225591570138931, -0.05473453551530838, -0.0008672811673022807, 0.04902074858546257, -0.017977602779865265, 0.05232987180352211, 0.04924315959215164, -0.07966651767492294, -0.06767305731773376, -0.007879196666181087, 0.019794989377260208, -0.03696427494287491, 0.05200117826461792, 0.023274695500731468, -0.039517298340797424, 0.03842085599899292, 0.034874629229307175, 0.022933945059776306, -0.03265518322587013, -0.015752596780657768, 0.03853890672326088, 0.04955344274640083, 0.01133959461003542, 0.041380129754543304, 0.03806890547275543, 0.006270139012485743, 0.03017512336373329, 0.010400368832051754, -0.0647016167640686, 0.03513847663998604, 0.030338741838932037, -0.03908764198422432, 0.0723632201552391, -0.10370537638664246, -0.0034819894935935736, 0.01894479990005493, -0.05045779421925545, -0.02361864410340786, -0.025293324142694473, 0.017053330317139626, -0.008001826703548431, 0.007332622539252043, -0.004059529863297939, -0.020912617444992065, -0.04136717692017555, 0.03009868413209915, -0.09493119269609451, -0.0012307193828746676, -0.03101613186299801, 0.05814642086625099, -0.029966143891215324, 0.01823442056775093, 0.0004674285009969026, 0.03831637650728226, 0.006313353311270475, 0.004845203831791878, 0.019324010238051414, -0.020967476069927216, 0.017471738159656525, 0.09296540170907974, -0.0050460342317819595, 0.02175804041326046, -0.07316658645868301, -0.0071032289415597916, 0.02449968457221985, -0.0013955614995211363, 0.04063164442777634, -0.004421943332999945, 0.024192985147237778, -0.06276129186153412, 0.044431623071432114, -0.0006746472208760679, -0.035598788410425186, 0.037242140620946884, -0.044806260615587234, 0.016932515427470207, -0.04499159753322601, -0.037973687052726746, 0.037554387003183365, 0.01628621108829975, -0.07373622059822083, 0.015444411896169186, 0.0011388988932594657, -0.06502828747034073, 0.018650226294994354, 0.06045733392238617, -0.01563185453414917, 0.07295803725719452, 0.008303995244204998, -0.033650707453489304, 0.00895934458822012, 0.0037733898498117924, -0.028055401518940926, 0.0013379360316321254, 0.010169822722673416, 0.00022253474162425846, -0.006076478399336338, 0.10157071053981781, -0.042868223041296005, -0.04723887890577316, -0.022493764758110046, 0.004262161906808615, -0.003497073194012046, 0.013037659227848053, 0.0057197390124201775, 0.021585704758763313, -0.03217339515686035, 0.007429440040141344, 0.021928781643509865, 0.012118329294025898, 0.0005904829013161361, -0.00522557133808732, -0.03589659184217453, 0.03127096965909004, -0.010364493355154991, 0.032502446323633194, -0.04235989227890968, 0.01241170521825552, -0.008328893221914768, 0.021475566551089287, 0.013854787684977055, -0.015793634578585625, -0.02106049843132496, 0.06426266580820084, 0.016345936805009842, 0.016234589740633965, -0.03401678055524826, -0.053138524293899536, 0.018270257860422134, 0.026478271931409836, -0.029463456943631172, 0.008949808776378632, -0.003812602022662759, -0.07769113034009933, 0.022257214412093163, 0.06379510462284088, -0.030729541555047035, -0.05459652096033096, 0.03947389870882034, 0.04791456088423729, 0.04655968025326729, -0.014677212573587894, 0.023841023445129395, 0.0245902631431818, -0.03144964203238487, 0.03708730638027191, -0.06036948040127754, 0.011926437728106976, 0.008160233497619629, 0.03640902042388916, 0.004894765559583902, 0.008714149706065655, -0.03718674182891846, 0.03398532792925835, 0.007100983057171106, 0.010852931067347527, -0.028597138822078705, 0.051127493381500244, 0.02611609548330307, -0.0599854439496994, -0.04164746403694153, 0.01950921304523945, -0.012537656351923943, 0.04835638776421547, -0.004350034520030022, -0.04795563593506813, 0.03732132911682129, 0.03481946885585785, -0.05358847230672836, -0.01461155153810978, -0.040796276181936264, -0.04412654787302017, -0.02671630121767521, -0.05485500395298004, -0.017538804560899734, 0.025496335700154305, 0.03758306801319122, -0.06235521286725998, 0.054468683898448944, 0.051712680608034134, -0.008977267891168594, -0.0042026350274682045, 0.0006275036139413714, -0.0023918228689581156, -0.05284091830253601, -0.024223627522587776, -0.002939065219834447, 0.038298893719911575, -0.005722651723772287, -0.018255218863487244, -0.06296396255493164, 0.017158979550004005, -0.044743653386831284, -0.022603679448366165, -0.0073747048154473305, -0.05640875920653343, 0.004301967099308968, -0.05402155965566635, -0.02699199691414833, 0.01017256174236536, 0.021198902279138565, 0.04918530583381653, -0.021256811916828156, -0.042185112833976746, 0.05703868716955185, -0.0058777593076229095, 0.007974403910338879, -0.025983981788158417, 0.015326651744544506, 0.02487041987478733, -0.004766747355461121, -0.041394442319869995, -0.004199889954179525, -0.08081871271133423, 0.07939806580543518, 0.005706578027456999, -0.008573722094297409, -0.08699021488428116, 0.018425218760967255, -0.05454670265316963, -0.019810646772384644, 0.024977030232548714, 0.04913794994354248, -0.0852043554186821, 0.03135500103235245, -0.038705144077539444, 0.008093967102468014, 0.034812770783901215, 0.013571884483098984, 0.041183941066265106, -0.0131180789321661, -0.030181851238012314, 0.05673186853528023, 0.03199772536754608, -0.01791505701839924, -0.03056030534207821, 0.024590622633695602, 0.008869613520801067, -0.03953985869884491, -0.02082398720085621, 0.01650972105562687, -0.008558773435652256, 0.023509280756115913, -0.010615820996463299, 0.037166427820920944, 0.0030128348153084517, 0.012531999498605728, 0.04676814749836922, -0.06643250584602356, 0.008975448086857796, 0.06263059377670288, 0.015560783445835114, 0.00503919692710042, 0.0507499985396862, -0.006347713991999626, 0.011703659780323505, 0.021832559257745743, 0.049112722277641296, 0.04298432171344757, -0.027879463508725166, 0.0010979205835610628, 0.026607485488057137, -0.04530099034309387, 0.049712952226400375, 0.0008367858245037496, 0.0270843543112278, 0.023699304088950157, -0.017291463911533356, 0.026722418144345284, -0.054285693913698196, 0.05378697067499161, 0.03299567103385925, 0.06032632291316986, -0.006884528324007988, 0.09570697695016861, 0.024388570338487625, -0.100152388215065, -0.05051766335964203, 0.01609419286251068, 0.05169198662042618, -0.04073747247457504, -0.14983709156513214, -0.015844030305743217, 0.06400980800390244, 0.02500814199447632, -0.060765862464904785, -0.03132552653551102, -0.04485839977860451, 0.0037595760077238083, -0.03581932187080383, 0.017394820228219032, -0.013502896763384342, 0.0031330406200140715, 0.023727240040898323, -0.04217950627207756, 0.05821006000041962, 0.0025811991654336452, -0.0027840654365718365, 0.06651031225919724, -0.04498812183737755, -0.019201859831809998, 0.026997970417141914, 0.009719421155750751, 0.008597471751272678, -0.0028367459308356047, 0.011292465031147003, 0.01321466639637947, 0.05742102116346359, 0.008955486118793488, -0.0024578971788287163, 0.04366957023739815, -0.021654268726706505, -0.03993571922183037, -0.0047298697754740715, 0.011369914747774601, -0.050783585757017136, -0.03592663258314133, -0.016881538555026054, 0.009224737994372845, -0.013632789254188538, 0.005974835716187954, 0.009114323183894157, 0.03871936723589897, -0.057401273399591446, -0.021192608401179314, -0.015559596009552479, 0.023928217589855194, -0.05488197132945061, 0.015762001276016235, -0.028684958815574646, 0.06689214706420898, 0.0010836214059963822, 0.025945773348212242, 0.018914630636572838, 0.011262216605246067, 0.00029376838938333094, -0.0005876040668226779, 0.04244234040379524, 0.011301228776574135, 0.0007299762801267207, -0.08709634840488434, -0.0025111401919275522, -0.04265554994344711, 0.005681207403540611, -0.036417726427316666, -0.03673461824655533, -0.006102977320551872, 0.055473122745752335, 0.0206452626734972, 0.016643568873405457, 0.03294363245368004, 0.04808972030878067, -0.02766687609255314, -0.048032160848379135, 0.020922619849443436, -0.054504744708538055, -0.0454520583152771, 0.0032560054678469896, 0.011927897110581398, 0.011719957925379276, -0.030153943225741386, 0.010161016136407852, 0.0343647226691246, -0.010716680437326431, -0.00016417739971075207, -0.045727331191301346, 0.03196081891655922, -0.024069568142294884, -0.009431417100131512, -0.005925992503762245, -0.032862402498722076, 0.06400927901268005, -0.026105355471372604, -0.03597234562039375, -0.027835268527269363, -0.013279609382152557, -0.0041362326592206955, 0.02898743748664856, 0.05183620750904083, -0.01721697673201561, -0.0021225265227258205, 0.032202914357185364, -0.06661556661128998, 0.031490128487348557, 0.03160366043448448, -0.022341487929224968, 0.03513675928115845, -0.008172084577381611, -0.035021714866161346, 0.027643825858831406, -0.045588117092847824, 0.07294654101133347, -0.06345236301422119, -0.013366090133786201, 0.01558480691164732, 0.00558867072686553, 0.008616996929049492, 0.012395530007779598, -0.036585599184036255, -0.019265396520495415, 0.005162403918802738 ]
<p>The Earth carries a negative electric charge of roughly 500 thousand Coulombs (according to different sources I've seen). If I touch the Earth I should therefore pick up some of this electric charge (through conduction) and become negative charged. Assuming the earth can modeled as a conducting sphere with radius $\small 6371 [\text{km}]$ and me as a conducting sphere with radius $\small 1 \small[\text m]$, around how much negative charge would I accumulate? The reason I ask is because I'm trying to prove to myself that grounding does indeed render a charged object neutral (i.e. transfers all the object's charge to the Earth). Using the well known equation for two connected conducting spheres with different radii (see Example 3-13 on page 115 in David Cheng's "Field and Wave Electromagnetics, 2nd Ed."), I calculate $\small 0.0785 [\text C]$, which is way too big and must be wrong. </p> <p>Here is my calculation:</p> <p>$V_\text{sphere}=k\times Q_1/r_1 $ (potential of conducting sphere with radius $r_1$ and and net charge $Q_1$) $V_\text{earth}=k\times Q_2/r_2$ (potential of conducting sphere with radius $r_2$ and and net charge $Q_2$)</p> <p>where $k$ is a constant. If the sphere touches the earth then their potentials ($V_\text{sphere}$ and $V_\text{earth}$) must be equal,assuming that the charges on the spherical conductors may be considered as uniformly disturbed. Setting $V_\text{Sphere}=V_\text{earth}$, we get:</p> <p>$Q_1/r_1=Q_2/r_2$</p> <p>Setting $\quad Q_1+Q_2=Q_\text{total}$,</p> <p>yields:$\quad Q_1=Q_\text{total}\times r_1/(r_1+r_2)$</p> <p>Substituting </p> <p>$Q_\text{total}=500,000[\text C],\quad r_1=1 [\text m],\quad r_2=6371000 [\text m]$ </p> <p>I get:</p> <p>$Q_1=0.0785[\text C]$. </p> <p>I feel this number is way too large to be correct. If you take coupling into account (by modeling earth as PEC plate, the charge I calculate only gets larger!). What am I doing wrong here? There seems to be no way you accumulate $\small-0.0785 [\text C]$ of charge by touching the earth. </p>
g4213
[ 0.06957424432039261, 0.036567557603120804, -0.025469383224844933, -0.016542324796319008, 0.06415598839521408, 0.09241028875112534, 0.025672638788819313, 0.030602702870965004, -0.02231147140264511, 0.04015367105603218, -0.024818209931254387, 0.04484061151742935, -0.015622985549271107, 0.037533629685640335, -0.02297666110098362, -0.014024839736521244, 0.0864846259355545, -0.04014213755726814, -0.02016366831958294, 0.024040130898356438, -0.00784029345959425, -0.04917203262448311, 0.027842234820127487, -0.0739358440041542, -0.051599111407995224, 0.009485957212746143, -0.003940897062420845, 0.05152759701013565, 0.009215415455400944, -0.02983137033879757, -0.029507825151085854, -0.046242766082286835, -0.02787759155035019, -0.003943469375371933, -0.08073671162128448, 0.020273270085453987, 0.019286876544356346, 0.004324915818870068, -0.018309827893972397, 0.009630671702325344, 0.09646666049957275, -0.058670755475759506, 0.04741879552602768, 0.00646463455632329, -0.012094979174435139, -0.04533578082919121, 0.04709639772772789, 0.04036970064043999, 0.018153244629502296, -0.026018045842647552, -0.041648052632808685, 0.035802487283945084, 0.023317446932196617, -0.02281945012509823, 0.0022988952696323395, 0.013644058257341385, 0.00006452627712860703, -0.061768293380737305, 0.0040251086466014385, 0.026546334847807884, -0.003684605937451124, 0.015393282286822796, -0.003999544773250818, 0.01429834496229887, 0.018928341567516327, 0.047252390533685684, -0.09459543973207474, -0.0004620370746124536, 0.014833019115030766, -0.0046063861809670925, -0.027343306690454483, -0.031443577259778976, -0.04835999384522438, -0.038516540080308914, -0.017733734101057053, 0.025429846718907356, 0.05226610600948334, 0.022377369925379753, 0.07135413587093353, 0.02188299596309662, -0.019305698573589325, -0.004523057956248522, 0.0355188250541687, -0.006659660022705793, 0.045666035264730453, -0.01644120179116726, 0.014589576981961727, -0.022124478593468666, -0.036254193633794785, 0.0011088756145909429, -0.0011508603347465396, -0.002998166484758258, 0.05652141943573952, -0.03583212569355965, 0.03796109929680824, 0.005652076564729214, -0.0292234867811203, 0.037253160029649734, -0.062428127974271774, -0.014613371342420578, 0.012826096266508102, -0.01279069110751152, 0.0007400494068861008, 0.014329034835100174, -0.028542574495077133, 0.03206082433462143, 0.004950821399688721, 0.05266541615128517, 0.05619582161307335, -0.04361587017774582, -0.0028399366419762373, -0.05054064095020294, -0.055222831666469574, -0.04753420501947403, -0.04305490851402283, -0.023271773010492325, 0.021626904606819153, -0.05458872392773628, -0.025750843808054924, 0.07133816927671432, 0.008313571102917194, 0.05057542398571968, 0.013828225433826447, 0.0157461017370224, -0.009851626120507717, -0.04991297423839569, -0.0024257192853838205, 0.002611582400277257, 0.03320210054516792, 0.011406700126826763, -0.04820086061954498, -0.021978488191962242, -0.023502366617321968, -0.0301202479749918, -0.021674569696187973, 0.03758975490927696, -0.015011552721261978, -0.013804600574076176, -0.057012248784303665, 0.013062861748039722, 0.000002786240202112822, -0.0422167107462883, 0.043004147708415985, -0.014066450297832489, -0.05598079785704613, 0.06021086871623993, 0.01620938628911972, -0.049334269016981125, 0.05080021172761917, -0.008172454312443733, 0.026957640424370766, 0.08746826648712158, 0.04841320961713791, -0.02796562947332859, 0.03444724157452583, -0.008140209130942822, 0.06308482587337494, -0.0046834759414196014, 0.01491544395685196, -0.034145697951316833, 0.049489207565784454, 0.02022499591112137, 0.0022778939455747604, -0.0084934551268816, -0.007106580305844545, -0.0027014892548322678, 0.019359154626727104, -0.03651132434606552, -0.046207062900066376, -0.05554099753499031, -0.002721203723922372, -0.01227148249745369, 0.097414530813694, 0.014826761558651924, -0.06047635152935982, -0.014906817115843296, 0.017975570634007454, -0.059741780161857605, -0.002824001247063279, 0.05701848492026329, -0.02755015715956688, -0.055926933884620667, 0.031186867505311966, 0.0014061504043638706, -0.026101939380168915, -0.04090549424290657, -0.01721055991947651, 0.029815273359417915, 0.012528469786047935, -0.009798277169466019, -0.07733198255300522, -0.03298433870077133, -0.02893257699906826, 0.013037466444075108, -0.014985442161560059, 0.0030953260138630867, 0.05352668836712837, 0.008564219810068607, 0.008656258694827557, 0.009246411733329296, -0.011614133603870869, 0.06819498538970947, 0.01345571968704462, 0.01636081002652645, 0.08875561505556107, -0.04573461413383484, 0.014286992140114307, -0.06962308287620544, 0.03176460787653923, 0.021115610376000404, 0.001639357185922563, -0.003868349362164736, -0.025592900812625885, 0.008668501861393452, -0.020451601594686508, -0.009023226797580719, -0.035513985902071, 0.01387185137718916, -0.08852895349264145, -0.018765073269605637, -0.021727491170167923, -0.005998624954372644, 0.08975236117839813, -0.012480116449296474, 0.01921747624874115, 0.067018061876297, -0.0325595885515213, 0.04342413693666458, 0.004830909892916679, -0.013559628278017044, -0.03852810338139534, 0.028866609558463097, 0.0020537383388727903, -0.018547995015978813, 0.0011261202162131667, 0.08900920301675797, -0.08407524228096008, -0.047001320868730545, -0.08614189177751541, -0.035946380347013474, -0.011642629280686378, -0.02971288561820984, 0.02239767275750637, 0.01588526740670204, 0.014222557656466961, -0.033818747848272324, -0.009155997075140476, 0.027831686660647392, -0.03319237753748894, 0.05251498520374298, 0.04967854917049408, 0.001357271452434361, 0.02468288503587246, 0.0379934087395668, 0.015622885897755623, 0.02940184809267521, -0.057295478880405426, 0.059332266449928284, 0.022914474830031395, -0.0374252088367939, -0.011587920598685741, -0.08599228411912918, 0.02853209897875786, 0.06062919273972511, -0.12832625210285187, -0.03362583741545677, -0.08446995168924332, 0.03168739005923271, 0.08155236393213272, 0.002841533161699772, 0.006447458639740944, 0.04946370795369148, 0.01739552617073059, 0.010972817428410053, 0.023718582466244698, -0.06874016672372818, 0.01203884370625019, 0.005143748130649328, 0.0333215557038784, -0.018512286245822906, 0.027962174266576767, 0.032303325831890106, 0.0050791422836482525, 0.006718815304338932, 0.04438306391239166, -0.04704093560576439, -0.00974375382065773, -0.0040404158644378185, -0.03302659094333649, 0.03496295586228371, -0.052774541079998016, -0.0018087541684508324, 0.0891711488366127, -0.04185422882437706, 0.0603080578148365, 0.04883073270320892, 0.010956189595162868, -0.09154079854488373, -0.04099074751138687, 0.017537781968712807, 0.07001624256372452, -0.03271251916885376, 0.00565968407317996, 0.009706759825348854, 0.02321937493979931, -0.010615191422402859, -0.015145335346460342, -0.04313276335597038, 0.03913743793964386, -0.03820784389972687, -0.07258740812540054, 0.02750982530415058, 0.002210480161011219, -0.05150938034057617, -0.01615184359252453, 0.017771929502487183, -0.014696469530463219, -0.011592411436140537, 0.02082780748605728, 0.008874381892383099, -0.022129178047180176, -0.04560168460011482, 0.05629989877343178, 0.02640969678759575, -0.01916949823498726, 0.05841593071818352, -0.08535398542881012, -0.03743083029985428, 0.033428117632865906, -0.009487857110798359, 0.008387384936213493, 0.0595376081764698, -0.011014960706233978, -0.004690003115683794, -0.04738224297761917, -0.02043258771300316, 0.005805782042443752, -0.03235507383942604, 0.023918574675917625, 0.03855834901332855, -0.03553052246570587, -0.054023582488298416, -0.061334941536188126, -0.07494927197694778, -0.02654825709760189, 0.021351898089051247, -0.03447066619992256, 0.019541610032320023, -0.017603157088160515, 0.003808982204645872, 0.03837044537067413, -0.011920061893761158, 0.02504562772810459, -0.05512183904647827, -0.034177541732788086, 0.055787406861782074, -0.02265438437461853, 0.07158403843641281, -0.07372239977121353, 0.025851143524050713, 0.016323832795023918, 0.023508813232183456, -0.00709110451862216, -0.037580814212560654, 0.08465477079153061, 0.0012826716993004084, -0.06222032383084297, 0.001762879895977676, 0.0015290462179109454, -0.01977306418120861, -0.02540755085647106, 0.015621340833604336, -0.019962601363658905, 0.007533272262662649, 0.06458456814289093, -0.028073405846953392, -0.021753787994384766, 0.005932822357863188, 0.03307333588600159, 0.0006357852835208178, 0.0027123265899717808, 0.021821139380335808, -0.026293322443962097, -0.010021377354860306, 0.0006477097049355507, 0.018224697560071945, 0.013478255830705166, -0.003169870702549815, -0.006267759948968887, -0.008965783752501011, -0.0550270676612854, -0.03775117173790932, 0.007057570852339268, -0.01849142648279667, 0.030205098912119865, -0.014728899113833904, -0.01789035089313984, -0.017751675099134445, 0.025069547817111015, 0.03157952427864075, 0.02214442379772663, 0.014457269571721554, 0.037213899195194244, -0.028519034385681152, -0.0413677841424942, -0.0017522276611998677, 0.04094085097312927, -0.005683455616235733, -0.024836329743266106, 0.00930927973240614, 0.027528371661901474, -0.0024399987887591124, -0.061144422739744186, -0.07473115622997284, 0.03823615610599518, -0.01058812253177166, -0.011555691249668598, 0.008669095113873482, 0.03575947508215904, 0.006232589948922396, 0.007001548074185848, 0.08330339938402176, -0.03555924445390701, -0.05283220112323761, 0.0034215322230011225, 0.08300983160734177, -0.006725167855620384, -0.008089193142950535, 0.00392525177448988, -0.00811830349266529, -0.03278081864118576, 0.011512731201946735, -0.02183288335800171, 0.05366158485412598, -0.0648317039012909, 0.02205159142613411, -0.023304879665374756, 0.059310704469680786, 0.017867105081677437, -0.003116522915661335, 0.03828945383429527, 0.018110988661646843, 0.023527000099420547, -0.037989821285009384, 0.009555944241583347, 0.008904100395739079, -0.0373130664229393, -0.0023629493080079556, 0.016255522146821022, -0.0566684827208519, 0.015027978457510471, 0.0014246004866436124, 0.03300159424543381, -0.01514474768191576, -0.004998752381652594, 0.03199150040745735, -0.0013005121145397425, 0.022692237049341202, -0.0403866283595562, -0.03890945762395859, -0.035047903656959534, 0.060930605977773666, 0.0005765146343037486, -0.014410415664315224, 0.036090362817049026, -0.05229291319847107, -0.049227211624383926, 0.013902260921895504, -0.008548175916075706, -0.0067629204131662846, -0.0032507008872926235, 0.009347425773739815, 0.05030113458633423, 0.0033953285310417414, -0.010829892009496689, -0.0033111977390944958, -0.023162206634879112, 0.017749140039086342, 0.008511541411280632, -0.003782389685511589, -0.0067678047344088554, 0.028381066396832466, -0.026650970801711082, 0.002699172357097268, -0.013057844713330269, 0.048690494149923325, -0.01026976015418768, 0.03650125861167908, -0.05630897730588913, -0.01587260514497757, -0.009153769351541996, -0.057957857847213745, 0.012856801971793175, 0.04185755178332329, -0.02454557456076145, 0.0546482652425766, 0.003621733048930764, -0.028635187074542046, -0.039916396141052246, 0.0379645973443985, 0.01526099443435669, -0.004017724189907312, -0.01686958223581314, 0.03223588690161705, 0.0030698920600116253, 0.005788737442344427, 0.0350697822868824, 0.006351652089506388, 0.06665176153182983, 0.020947052165865898, -0.001017614034935832, 0.01153246033936739, 0.0607127770781517, -0.010384414345026016, 0.0060444725677371025, -0.010463900864124298, -0.08429713547229767, -0.000037329802580643445, -0.05100149288773537, 0.03957866504788399, 0.025951828807592392, -0.0210859514772892, 0.05125502124428749, -0.010709055699408054, 0.030619831755757332, -0.011684264987707138, -0.002830207347869873, -0.01779855042695999, 0.05581493303179741, 0.03543431684374809, 0.03129017725586891, -0.010659933090209961, -0.06695496290922165, 0.012849947437644005, 0.04095730558037758, -0.0024028639309108257, -0.02336544170975685, 0.025880618020892143, 0.09004747122526169, -0.0441373847424984, 0.0037553750444203615, -0.0708499401807785, 0.07690739631652832, 0.040239617228507996, -0.005965531338006258, -0.03184851258993149, 0.008762688376009464, 0.022041073068976402, 0.07439427077770233, 0.005783649627119303, -0.015058676712214947, -0.0062245591543614864, -0.03897379711270332, 0.01078405324369669, 0.016785476356744766, -0.0082251550629735, 0.016401788219809532, -0.02297961711883545, -0.0036475916858762503, -0.03168423846364021, 0.020817268639802933, -0.06702534854412079, -0.019898144528269768, 0.011826648376882076, 0.008379901759326458, -0.061936087906360626, 0.020362306386232376, -0.02538406290113926, 0.042710207402706146, 0.00374691653996706, -0.012922422960400581, -0.028418848291039467, -0.002555287443101406, -0.03455037996172905, 0.05267150327563286, 0.007220294326543808, -0.006215652450919151, 0.030711641535162926, -0.014795289374887943, -0.008896369487047195, 0.02354632318019867, 0.00855318084359169, 0.035039402544498444, -0.03639821335673332, 0.029870525002479553, 0.03446785360574722, -0.03636620566248894, -0.09375224262475967, 0.032998744398355484, -0.027862416580319405, 0.00818945374339819, 0.03679482638835907, -0.007384988479316235, -0.058184102177619934, 0.052620671689510345, -0.08630343526601791, -0.02093917317688465, -0.04724642261862755, -0.034120433032512665, 0.029157070443034172, 0.04716755449771881, 0.010035492479801178, 0.04277590289711952, -0.04562121257185936, 0.08724303543567657, 0.0025064931251108646, 0.0202706940472126, -0.03476062789559364, -0.014500177465379238, 0.021340608596801758, -0.04190768301486969, 0.030442016199231148, -0.013990133069455624, -0.016217859461903572, -0.006627237424254417, -0.038873836398124695, 0.052643708884716034, -0.004680565558373928, 0.01833166368305683, -0.0202570129185915, -0.016151893883943558, 0.042211562395095825, -0.043424010276794434, -0.00781255029141903, 0.02629745379090309, 0.03157226741313934, -0.006329177878797054, 0.032638657838106155, -0.014981375075876713, -0.01974532939493656, -0.0412224642932415, 0.007082035765051842, -0.007038038223981857, 0.03490457311272621, 0.059981442987918854, 0.048575080931186676, 0.024688325822353363, 0.020477164536714554, -0.003040923271328211, 0.020635858178138733, -0.050498511642217636, 0.029598314315080643, 0.001475892378948629, 0.0013750247890129685, -0.059409402310848236, -0.021686801686882973, 0.03774228319525719, -0.016411688178777695, -0.02782623842358589, 0.021237650886178017, 0.0036489584017544985, 0.023945027962327003, -0.0334683358669281, 0.013632254675030708, -0.002977212192490697, -0.03796282410621643, -0.02036694809794426, 0.060248926281929016, -0.01799909397959709, 0.01804370805621147, 0.0076233698055148125, -0.006341928616166115, -0.05178622901439667, 0.006968918722122908, 0.028134556487202644, 0.02705025114119053, -0.013152078725397587, -0.050035614520311356, -0.023722311481833458, -0.027442043647170067, 0.01641055755317211, 0.036589693278074265, -0.032578181475400925, 0.027731627225875854, 0.023833760991692543, -0.013345642946660519, 0.026549814268946648, -0.01680113561451435, -0.007079679984599352, -0.01304039265960455, 0.04448903352022171, 0.0434761606156826, 0.011800654232501984, 0.04617118462920189, -0.026927245780825615, -0.02514398656785488, -0.04751026630401611, -0.005338174756616354, -0.0074998983182013035, 0.02868208847939968, 0.06251844763755798, 0.043037086725234985, -0.01791534386575222, 0.02775529958307743, -0.0028311165515333414, 0.01103107538074255, 0.030125580728054047, 0.022518174722790718, 0.06815312802791595, -0.0084562161937356, 0.017096858471632004, -0.05787387862801552, -0.015565941110253334, -0.06331697106361389, 0.004770638886839151, 0.002060017315670848, -0.016298649832606316, -0.06330752372741699, -0.0047614178620278835, -0.01172933541238308, 0.03807518631219864, 0.05007055401802063, 0.0019977353513240814, -0.0034804432652890682, -0.00024223029322456568, 0.047443266957998276, -0.0178817231208086, 0.04405081272125244, 0.01741289347410202, 0.004008464980870485, -0.013667654246091843, 0.003366071032360196, 0.032583244144916534, -0.061671700328588486, 0.004834427963942289, -0.02029166929423809, 0.04750775173306465, 0.016919607296586037, 0.05054597184062004, 0.024623937904834747, -0.03376781940460205, -0.01054371614009142, -0.037967901676893234, -0.004589839372783899, 0.023577501997351646, -0.011577028781175613, -0.0019356152042746544, -0.0027592352125793695, -0.021663032472133636, -0.020543117076158524, -0.03579351305961609, -0.052328284829854965, -0.03470975160598755, -0.023038014769554138, -0.006948559079319239, 0.038134608417749405, -0.05792608857154846, 0.09199994057416916, 0.07271339744329453, -0.0038882028311491013, 0.0222350861877203, -0.05021652951836586, 0.004876470658928156, 0.028838055208325386, -0.008512448519468307, -0.01103878952562809, -0.04133404418826103, -0.0035988956224173307, 0.014468475244939327, -0.02074301615357399, 0.006176281720399857, -0.06134781241416931, 0.02439882978796959, -0.018959984183311462, 0.008769618347287178, -0.08040858060121536, 0.0045594871044158936, 0.03166492283344269 ]
<p>I'm wondering about the exact reason why anyons escape the spin-statistic theorem (SST), see <em>e.g.</em> <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin%E2%80%93statistics_theorem">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spin–statistics_theorem</a>. </p> <p>I've read somewhere (the wikipedia page is sufficient I believe to understand this point, to be honest I don't remember where I read this) that the reason is just that anyons do not belong to the relativistic sector. Despite Lorentz invariance is still the cornerstone of the SST, anyons can have fractional exchange statistic because they belong to the Galilean invariance. See also <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/23338/">this SE question</a> about the SST and its demonstration.</p> <p>On the other hand, it seems to me that this argument might well be wrong. Indeed, I've the feeling that the exact reason is that the permutation group is not enough to understand the exchange of two particles. If one discusses the rotation group instead of the permutation group, then one ends up with the Leinaas and Mirheim [please see the bottom of the question for the reference] argument, saying that in 2D, the homotopy group of SO(2) is $\mathbb{Z}$, no more $\mathbb{Z}_{2}$ as for SO($n$) with $n\geq 3$.</p> <p><strong>I'm wondering about the quantum field community perspective ?</strong> Do they continue to discuss the Lorentz invariance as the key point to obtain SST, or do they generally accept the Leinaas and Mirheim point of view [see below].</p> <p>The two arguments might be almost equivalent, except that I believe the permutation group does not care about the space dimension. Moreover, I think it has no one-dimensional-non-trivial-projective representation, as required for anyons to exist, am I correct ? </p> <p>NB: There are some alternative proof of the SST linked from the Wikipedia page about it. I gave the link at the beginning of this question. </p> <ul> <li>Leinaas, J. M., &amp; Myrheim, J. <em>On the theory of identical particles.</em> Il Nuovo Cimento B, 37(1), 1–23 (1977). <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02727953">http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF02727953</a> </li> </ul>
g4214
[ 0.03157779201865196, -0.012403212487697601, -0.0008245474891737103, -0.049882907420396805, -0.01192290335893631, 0.0027704029344022274, 0.06798310577869415, 0.0370759554207325, 0.03144218772649765, -0.015250609256327152, -0.0001267147745238617, 0.035428743809461594, -0.01588001661002636, -0.036366067826747894, -0.02966427244246006, 0.04470760002732277, 0.022759031504392624, -0.013410195708274841, 0.014618761837482452, 0.014372553676366806, 0.015036688186228275, -0.017086807638406754, 0.022853661328554153, -0.09356405586004257, 0.04382810369133949, -0.05456724390387535, 0.021930212154984474, -0.02104339376091957, -0.0034972599241882563, -0.01929016225039959, 0.039581891149282455, 0.004664413630962372, 0.04002413898706436, -0.049277544021606445, -0.05029210075736046, -0.07166579365730286, 0.03172219917178154, 0.05837389454245567, 0.013466112315654755, 0.03116791695356369, 0.005567254964262247, 0.011463022790849209, 0.011771528981626034, -0.023264536634087563, -0.03235723450779915, 0.031978487968444824, -0.008582532405853271, 0.0008833580068312585, -0.04457438737154007, -0.023945990949869156, -0.00966985896229744, -0.0279531367123127, 0.07295241951942444, 0.01229846477508545, 0.023212211206555367, 0.024633673951029778, 0.02407483197748661, -0.009430629201233387, 0.07580123841762543, 0.0023526358418166637, -0.03391999378800392, -0.012674527242779732, -0.04087972268462181, 0.04216770455241203, 0.023800289258360863, -0.02710544690489769, 0.004037236329168081, 0.06785731017589569, -0.0016568424180150032, -0.024432243779301643, 0.038140252232551575, -0.007979710586369038, 0.03642090782523155, -0.012406732887029648, -0.06623885035514832, 0.02537061646580696, -0.04297245293855667, -0.022414760664105415, -0.0015907525084912777, -0.0034333092626184225, -0.04778456315398216, -0.019079098477959633, -0.013626620173454285, -0.024330563843250275, 0.05213122442364693, -0.015767259523272514, 0.03385306894779205, -0.07277922332286835, 0.026203272864222527, 0.03620012477040291, 0.05719589814543724, 0.018155325204133987, 0.0689254105091095, 0.02589641883969307, -0.06727135181427002, -0.03481987491250038, 0.03209070861339569, 0.02348170429468155, -0.05204089358448982, 0.023750143125653267, -0.05691387131810188, 0.041669391095638275, -0.01259872317314148, 0.050465114414691925, 0.04854379594326019, -0.00781598687171936, 0.01573561131954193, 0.021023711189627647, -0.01514231227338314, -0.015963658690452576, -0.07443350553512573, 0.06544265896081924, -0.019730033352971077, -0.01404824759811163, -0.05248042568564415, -0.0010608232114464045, 0.06052277609705925, -0.038509972393512726, 0.01780465431511402, -0.013479246757924557, -0.00779494596645236, 0.020136168226599693, -0.014662100002169609, 0.1050780639052391, -0.05837341770529747, -0.009183733724057674, -0.03746386617422104, 0.060790207237005234, -0.009347560815513134, -0.02769738994538784, -0.0011522517306730151, 0.01732502318918705, 0.003105924930423498, 0.059085942804813385, -0.039394743740558624, 0.015207285061478615, -0.00595697620883584, 0.0339006744325161, 0.057102128863334656, -0.013263086788356304, 0.04046110436320305, -0.017793379724025726, 0.013936914503574371, 0.006040507461875677, -0.006327767390757799, 0.011078699491918087, 0.018452530726790428, -0.05897236242890358, -0.031151501461863518, 0.08942354470491409, -0.00018678854394238442, 0.0852857306599617, 0.03199087828397751, 0.0158490389585495, -0.022707292810082436, -0.03587787225842476, 0.03753194957971573, -0.004764977842569351, 0.01923416368663311, 0.0734529122710228, 0.029675420373678207, 0.032048940658569336, -0.015575972385704517, -0.022176209837198257, -0.08128862082958221, -0.011869429610669613, 0.016820410266518593, -0.009091917425394058, -0.030222058296203613, -0.09638616442680359, -0.027357356622815132, 0.025692950934171677, -0.0007221705745905638, 0.030176766216754913, 0.04673008993268013, 0.018818410113453865, -0.0626085102558136, -0.025020331144332886, 0.0008712258422747254, 0.0030980114825069904, -0.030699506402015686, 0.021209387108683586, 0.03915571793913841, -0.01563984528183937, -0.009517221711575985, 0.02864483743906021, 0.00896280538290739, 0.05585513263940811, -0.0014439324149861932, -0.0038745724596083164, 0.0008121007704176009, -0.040675368160009384, -0.014698294922709465, 0.039527010172605515, -0.0010586777934804559, 0.0028909652028232813, -0.0016385400667786598, -0.022636253386735916, -0.037093888968229294, 0.012761891819536686, 0.03278281167149544, 0.016951557248830795, -0.0359000489115715, -0.003264108905568719, -0.00184579414781183, -0.022041745483875275, -0.039185941219329834, -0.0035782179329544306, 0.010632633231580257, -0.05482475087046623, 0.07862459868192673, -0.047626107931137085, -0.0031099417246878147, 0.01454900112003088, -0.0028147618286311626, -0.030041921883821487, 0.008130964823067188, 0.013731795363128185, -0.006070437841117382, 0.03178194537758827, 0.028322989121079445, -0.05504843220114708, 0.01681624725461006, 0.01346379891037941, 0.02304978296160698, 0.00197071535512805, -0.023701582103967667, -0.005055718123912811, -0.017230074852705002, 0.08975686132907867, -0.0387330986559391, -0.0481116808950901, -0.02140827290713787, 0.0006449754582718015, 0.007766617462038994, 0.017537634819746017, -0.058012962341308594, 0.0569046288728714, 0.058841217309236526, 0.017081711441278458, 0.04412182420492172, -0.01081144716590643, -0.06606895476579666, 0.001182122970931232, 0.07435876876115799, -0.010580587200820446, 0.006829584017395973, -0.036408379673957825, -0.04970816150307655, 0.029830584302544594, 0.01721743680536747, -0.06517662107944489, -0.004317276645451784, -0.04566274583339691, 0.025435637682676315, -0.043491117656230927, 0.0067137181758880615, 0.03019564598798752, -0.029906975105404854, -0.02560136839747429, -0.0077091967687010765, -0.031481415033340454, 0.06183766946196556, 0.026364073157310486, -0.009467478841543198, -0.015879470854997635, 0.009139426983892918, 0.04222261905670166, -0.02749003656208515, -0.021418603137135506, -0.04172930121421814, 0.030594417825341225, -0.0008809891878627241, 0.04836107790470123, 0.0005101392744109035, 0.018051445484161377, -0.05563350394368172, -0.0064965602941811085, -0.0276000015437603, -0.05401885509490967, -0.0009335058275610209, -0.022866085171699524, -0.0417933315038681, 0.04677344113588333, 0.014310968108475208, 0.009597805328667164, 0.004822940099984407, -0.031164156273007393, -0.015065695159137249, 0.02017821930348873, 0.03902292996644974, 0.03211157023906708, 0.024961113929748535, -0.008757059462368488, 0.031672410666942596, -0.009113620035350323, -0.08989772945642471, -0.06072816625237465, -0.040016014128923416, 0.04229868948459625, 0.02448013797402382, 0.026229843497276306, 0.0334741473197937, -0.0035072339233011007, 0.0831722617149353, -0.003214122960343957, -0.07791502773761749, -0.05998845770955086, -0.018998894840478897, -0.008545001968741417, 0.00018389345495961607, 0.03339027613401413, -0.017277901992201805, 0.02574215456843376, 0.0072678192518651485, -0.0016869523096829653, 0.04161443933844566, 0.013228011317551136, 0.04287337139248848, -0.051169272512197495, -0.06347767263650894, 0.010189919732511044, 0.004094026517122984, 0.0077976989559829235, 0.031515657901763916, 0.005110068246722221, -0.05031643807888031, -0.004257432650774717, -0.013124336488544941, -0.007735637482255697, 0.010765056125819683, -0.010001793503761292, 0.027660736814141273, -0.02822514995932579, -0.08566835522651672, -0.056110598146915436, -0.03618612885475159, 0.028737660497426987, 0.005950502585619688, -0.007643400225788355, 0.020541606470942497, -0.02414313703775406, -0.05931194871664047, 0.011612260714173317, 0.004719759337604046, 0.007366786245256662, 0.024294668808579445, -0.03885956481099129, 0.035768285393714905, -0.001978950807824731, 0.010673916898667812, 0.02921929582953453, -0.0013451396953314543, 0.026802344247698784, -0.001012492342852056, -0.0018987094517797232, 0.05331604927778244, -0.010321098379790783, 0.044709496200084686, -0.008534367196261883, 0.06637293845415115, -0.029725823551416397, 0.01377299427986145, 0.017318865284323692, -0.022725241258740425, 0.04872886463999748, -0.007448716554790735, 0.04171372205018997, -0.010914590209722519, 0.006107677705585957, 0.034264110028743744, 0.0053168474696576595, 0.022212166339159012, -0.02303411439061165, 0.009110350161790848, -0.030149364843964577, 0.04020325094461441, 0.016810618340969086, -0.07300258427858353, -0.011624595150351524, 0.09244988113641739, 0.030526332557201385, 0.04245077818632126, 0.011941063217818737, -0.005376928020268679, 0.01983746327459812, -0.026054497808218002, 0.04914584010839462, -0.06617918610572815, -0.024090507999062538, 0.020559733733534813, 0.005724387243390083, -0.0037313979119062424, -0.03956729918718338, 0.06344283372163773, 0.009671996347606182, 0.01654219627380371, -0.05113012716174126, 0.032732829451560974, 0.05539286136627197, -0.054340213537216187, -0.029925690963864326, -0.028292516246438026, -0.07633386552333832, 0.0727248340845108, 0.0029458452481776476, -0.04383999854326248, 0.01875721476972103, 0.01381061039865017, 0.013458114117383957, -0.014219576492905617, 0.05882355570793152, 0.03316968306899071, -0.014679279178380966, 0.02388213574886322, -0.0006509749800898135, -0.055220626294612885, -0.04027961194515228, 0.019666476175189018, -0.028653495013713837, -0.02372138574719429, 0.05157482996582985, 0.037462349981069565, -0.025264834985136986, 0.012228431180119514, 0.024526886641979218, 0.04998210072517395, 0.03184744343161583, -0.04480847343802452, -0.012470776215195656, 0.04856981709599495, 0.03900253027677536, 0.04498356953263283, -0.04403669759631157, -0.06973131000995636, -0.0246539618819952, -0.03207780048251152, 0.07510977983474731, -0.006047684233635664, -0.04274239391088486, 0.040737226605415344, -0.010719506070017815, -0.004268137738108635, 0.014551252126693726, 0.0017528152093291283, 0.0048096985556185246, -0.02088499255478382, -0.0311223603785038, -0.024794943630695343, -0.026069849729537964, 0.0036185448989272118, 0.01635209284722805, 0.002170975785702467, 0.009828854352235794, -0.031013157218694687, 0.025708824396133423, -0.06579217314720154, 0.00026348259416408837, 0.040934477001428604, 0.001146454131230712, -0.017549825832247734, 0.01732892543077469, 0.006907041184604168, -0.005854742135852575, 0.007402676157653332, 0.04661194980144501, -0.05291138216853142, -0.007360005285590887, -0.039868079125881195, -0.025106849148869514, 0.028985269367694855, -0.022325076162815094, -0.04068916290998459, -0.058738917112350464, -0.05600425973534584, 0.03678615763783455, 0.008655039593577385, -0.03867319971323013, -0.04077254608273506, -0.019213160499930382, -0.02249067649245262, -0.06763500720262527, 0.06456509232521057, 0.022146133705973625, -0.0034956687595695257, 0.06218370422720909, -0.02841651253402233, -0.015104805119335651, 0.0003347317688167095, -0.022611668333411217, -0.019965847954154015, -0.012180688790977001, 0.007905700244009495, -0.04444495588541031, -0.013324262574315071, 0.0012278440408408642, 0.037500351667404175, -0.09907454997301102, -0.04061204940080643, -0.05806906521320343, -0.05274471640586853, 0.026347871869802475, 0.09241526573896408, -0.004800637252628803, 0.02666427008807659, 0.001469808747060597, 0.05627092346549034, 0.010843606665730476, -0.037418607622385025, -0.023037880659103394, -0.01932685822248459, -0.004290938843041658, 0.07906865328550339, -0.007088450249284506, -0.004991511348634958, 0.01135438121855259, -0.010702315717935562, -0.014615548774600029, 0.027905408293008804, -0.05349048599600792, -0.03219874948263168, 0.005197340622544289, 0.00851122010499239, -0.07131386548280716, 0.02835119515657425, 0.019040951505303383, -0.027420660480856895, -0.013837968930602074, -0.002947902074083686, 0.03361562639474869, 0.015860164538025856, -0.042549192905426025, 0.008171993307769299, -0.0163866076618433, 0.023239899426698685, -0.08420761674642563, -0.03340163454413414, -0.003984055481851101, 0.030017243698239326, 0.023839041590690613, -0.07234209775924683, -0.037533748894929886, -0.004084454383701086, 0.015066985040903091, -0.02259008400142193, 0.04085909575223923, -0.027297068387269974, -0.04283659905195236, 0.03809300810098648, -0.021153509616851807, -0.019238002598285675, 0.02002820186316967, -0.004513717256486416, -0.03166178986430168, 0.017277376726269722, 0.042383790016174316, -0.03635740280151367, -0.026150675490498543, 0.014629852958023548, -0.010531213134527206, -0.013524683192372322, -0.020336482673883438, 0.02192419208586216, 0.026277923956513405, -0.022181864827871323, -0.006921853870153427, 0.01011646632105112, -0.009550485759973526, 0.023904701694846153, 0.05171528086066246, -0.01317211426794529, 0.06490591168403625, 0.020429065451025963, 0.07945021986961365, -0.057445451617240906, -0.026515619829297066, -0.0374683178961277, -0.04572371020913124, -0.02741689234972, -0.047369327396154404, -0.017369220033288002, 0.019522774964571, -0.010967577807605267, -0.015023212879896164, -0.0501241497695446, 0.031142691150307655, -0.021389147266745567, -0.018406523391604424, 0.01024223119020462, 0.027073673903942108, -0.04579437896609306, 0.00030268117552623153, 0.00583631731569767, -0.015864158049225807, -0.0013704042648896575, -0.03668859228491783, 0.023205433040857315, -0.0327455960214138, -0.004296996630728245, -0.0006874857936054468, 0.017240464687347412, -0.03060918301343918, 0.06743583083152771, -0.007207073271274567, -0.021994179114699364, 0.04037575423717499, -0.030399778857827187, 0.002407849533483386, -0.01799212396144867, -0.005518111865967512, -0.03721264749765396, -0.005208322778344154, -0.062022414058446884, 0.03798867017030716, 0.024475833401083946, -0.015950588509440422, -0.023620519787073135, -0.020411284640431404, -0.030283328145742416, -0.008519303984940052, 0.06837110221385956, 0.017871391028165817, -0.01608065515756607, -0.050683677196502686, 0.004691520240157843, 0.030833877623081207, 0.025202110409736633, 0.008660814724862576, 0.0339958555996418, 0.04206741228699684, -0.007191671058535576, 0.08281359076499939, 0.0004444129590410739, 0.051236990839242935, -0.04694720730185509, -0.015596777200698853, -0.05974398925900459, -0.023866357281804085, 0.0723651871085167, 0.0116059435531497, -0.043901246041059494, 0.06785939633846283, 0.0012653250014409423, 0.004751644097268581, -0.056917157024145126, 0.021104462444782257, -0.01505249459296465, 0.019068511202931404, -0.06939856708049774, 0.03933347761631012, 0.03993969038128853, 0.012343797832727432, 0.011659183539450169, -0.022400833666324615, -0.011374288238584995, 0.00427540298551321, 0.05520593002438545, 0.05122184008359909, -0.00404775096103549, -0.05409546196460724, -0.0982443317770958, 0.027272319421172142, -0.01769944094121456, -0.0657573863863945, -0.016668904572725296, 0.01741345226764679, -0.024545464664697647, 0.008968566544353962, 0.05304478481411934, -0.03791576623916626, -0.023297414183616638, 0.01358947902917862, -0.04600885882973671, -0.0037940628826618195, -0.016584012657403946, 0.0014551884960383177, 0.051028311252593994, 0.059041932225227356, -0.019935958087444305, -0.0009027663618326187, 0.03945229575037956, 0.015065401792526245, 0.007304192986339331, 0.03133342042565346, -0.00029978074599057436, 0.04662791267037392, -0.023779960349202156, -0.005879047326743603, 0.045613501220941544, 0.020020999014377594, 0.0015099737793207169, -0.012310709804296494, -0.0005141021101735532, 0.0202571339905262, -0.07995302230119705, 0.06206243485212326, -0.0636407658457756, 0.04465726763010025, 0.02000378631055355, 0.04418912157416344, 0.02214161865413189, -0.032390762120485306, -0.041080329567193985, 0.007649392820894718, 0.06880345195531845, -0.00827893614768982, 0.04566285014152527, 0.006472389213740826, -0.07665473967790604, -0.0173165425658226, 0.037284281104803085, 0.0008110805647447705, 0.007972843013703823, 0.0682004913687706, 0.0729379951953888, 0.009035409428179264, -0.021064192056655884, -0.005342235788702965, 0.05680742487311363, -0.00927818939089775, 0.016233982518315315, 0.0241814237087965, -0.013148680329322815, -0.012407829985022545, -0.03764195367693901, -0.07312683761119843, 0.00591506902128458, 0.006332017481327057, 0.024146124720573425, 0.02080758474767208, 0.006895780097693205, 0.0457179993391037, -0.04291015863418579, 0.05077175423502922, -0.030035026371479034, 0.052323177456855774, 0.01865398697555065, -0.05023186653852463, 0.036309875547885895, 0.00014987470058258623, 0.0380810871720314, 0.02060125768184662, 0.05600690096616745, -0.032388947904109955, -0.08732996881008148, -0.006653588265180588, -0.02397945709526539, -0.011904757469892502, -0.04895776882767677, -0.027238747105002403, -0.04988786578178406, 0.039857786148786545, 0.014203617349267006, 0.055376969277858734, 0.01794138364493847, -0.061303671449422836, 0.04847598075866699, 0.010329590179026127, 0.039163097739219666, 0.060628168284893036, 0.04590834304690361, -0.008763434365391731, -0.043793220072984695, 0.07403051108121872, -0.03309933468699455, -0.045555632561445236, -0.03780841454863548, 0.07801700383424759 ]
<p>As I understand it, when we say that the $SU(2)_{L} \times U(1)_{Y}$ is broken via the Higgs mechanism, this is because the symmetry acts on the Higgs mass in a way that would change it's value. If we want to pick a particular model we need to pick a fixed value of the Higgs mass, and this is only possible if we say $SU(2)_{L} \times U(1)_{Y}$ is broken to $U(1)_{em}$. The Lagrangian is always invariant to $SU(2)_{L} \times U(1)_{Y}$ (even if the Higgs mass changes under $SU(2)_{L} \times U(1)_{Y}$ the Lagrangian is such that it remains invariant). The symmetry breaking is just neccesary in choosing a theory with one particular value of the Higgs vev. </p> <p>Real life does appear to have a fixed Higgs mass so we require that $SU(2)_{L} \times U(1)_{Y}$ breaks to $U(1)_{em}$. But then aren't we saying that observable physics is described by $SU(3)_{C} \times U(1)_{em}$, why does the weak interaction still work in our universe that contains a fixed Higgs mass?</p>
g4215
[ 0.03247611224651337, 0.01706041768193245, -0.011238514445722103, -0.005353775341063738, 0.009566244669258595, 0.03666628897190094, 0.029906433075666428, 0.0554853193461895, -0.043641120195388794, -0.008797635324299335, -0.009970207698643208, -0.03278086706995964, -0.012754501774907112, 0.03701061010360718, -0.023048019036650658, 0.027063913643360138, 0.07400226593017578, -0.028165414929389954, 0.015405151061713696, 0.023623991757631302, -0.03856587037444115, -0.013597766868770123, -0.028126725926995277, -0.035670217126607895, 0.00997925829142332, -0.021509964019060135, 0.09594445675611496, -0.0013917554169893265, -0.01565714180469513, 0.015413985587656498, 0.06774800270795822, -0.022083263844251633, 0.04102547839283943, -0.10255013406276703, -0.021022897213697433, -0.09377830475568771, 0.07991460710763931, 0.023715795949101448, 0.061117950826883316, 0.007688914891332388, -0.004401677753776312, 0.03699518367648125, 0.0579870343208313, -0.004337221849709749, -0.0182398222386837, -0.0056300354190170765, 0.02349180355668068, -0.012069846503436565, 0.011548802256584167, -0.042124874889850616, 0.025812342762947083, 0.031564220786094666, 0.024440299719572067, 0.0037025921046733856, 0.014518644660711288, 0.0016366938361898065, -0.004490039311349392, 0.069809190928936, 0.01792471669614315, -0.005856017582118511, -0.009450281970202923, 0.02741621620953083, 0.028004087507724762, 0.022070663049817085, 0.05656863749027252, -0.008326681330800056, -0.060417208820581436, -0.006149621680378914, -0.01452688779681921, -0.002497453475371003, -0.0312337689101696, -0.03100893832743168, -0.05008706450462341, -0.04049166291952133, -0.014957770705223083, 0.01288371067494154, 0.0036684980150312185, -0.02635905146598816, -0.0687810555100441, -0.03835027664899826, -0.04794676601886749, -0.026757024228572845, 0.007967508397996426, -0.029668308794498444, 0.08418931812047958, -0.08019973337650299, -0.025829507037997246, 0.028835421428084373, -0.020686844363808632, -0.016490545123815536, 0.0023260461166501045, -0.021770063787698746, 0.03146199509501457, 0.008852273225784302, -0.02291734702885151, -0.0334324836730957, 0.00902919564396143, 0.038713473826646805, -0.06273577362298965, 0.013932549394667149, -0.03025483526289463, -0.02045147493481636, -0.005811783019453287, 0.0022559575736522675, 0.033823639154434204, 0.03236842527985573, 0.08244261145591736, -0.008846822194755077, 0.01134952437132597, -0.02461506985127926, -0.011055908165872097, 0.020390255376696587, 0.023329731076955795, -0.034049034118652344, -0.03046610578894615, -0.02746295928955078, 0.04056229442358017, 0.014817511662840843, 0.022503137588500977, 0.012673883698880672, -0.018072668462991714, 0.003237206256017089, -0.04216200113296509, 0.04283370077610016, -0.002749833045527339, -0.012270515784621239, -0.02459362894296646, 0.006801181938499212, 0.003206803696230054, -0.01180899515748024, 0.0021759960800409317, 0.022073449566960335, -0.024460740387439728, 0.019121386110782623, 0.00206229230388999, 0.0877651572227478, 0.10117091983556747, -0.014114136807620525, 0.04614418372511864, -0.01830257475376129, -0.04008428379893303, -0.014351357705891132, -0.016687938943505287, -0.013107191771268845, 0.006449068430811167, 0.03324761241674423, -0.01621311716735363, 0.006256298627704382, 0.0004386908549349755, 0.018430350348353386, -0.0240597166121006, 0.09584388136863708, 0.01365798618644476, 0.06190801039338112, -0.043041981756687164, -0.0018329400336369872, 0.02208341844379902, 0.04040168598294258, 0.036015529185533524, -0.015093320049345493, 0.05399847775697708, -0.03037605993449688, -0.00019004495698027313, -0.00808656495064497, -0.0564136728644371, 0.03725258260965347, 0.0038530598394572735, -0.018051860854029655, 0.001064401469193399, 0.01579681970179081, -0.08561024069786072, 0.02309161238372326, -0.024283623322844505, 0.07430368661880493, -0.02154485322535038, 0.054988157004117966, -0.0020033284090459347, -0.01888173259794712, -0.019129106774926186, -0.0038593753706663847, -0.029508819803595543, -0.0881463810801506, -0.006787471938878298, -0.038293857127428055, -0.04539397358894348, 0.04693733900785446, 0.020464498549699783, -0.01755487360060215, 0.07058053463697433, 0.031592387706041336, -0.06618013232946396, 0.005444531328976154, -0.009063650853931904, 0.03330841287970543, 0.00746448477730155, 0.011451426893472672, 0.03427055478096008, 0.0026368347462266684, -0.06301569193601608, -0.032457202672958374, 0.030794739723205566, 0.017453519627451897, 0.013994542881846428, -0.030941108241677284, -0.029867971315979958, -0.04355694353580475, 0.004456641618162394, -0.001965302275493741, -0.002670471090823412, 0.019272590056061745, 0.022370677441358566, 0.008398105390369892, 0.025106851011514664, -0.0330822579562664, -0.007253921125084162, -0.024041373282670975, -0.0036938113626092672, 0.04180063307285309, -0.02652006223797798, -0.024128727614879608, -0.002319833729416132, 0.015469258651137352, 0.0740722194314003, 0.014649571850895882, -0.017432183027267456, -0.014225835911929607, -0.07910207659006119, -0.008051922544836998, 0.017455168068408966, -0.0065460228361189365, -0.011631308123469353, 0.038232430815696716, -0.004148285835981369, 0.006504332646727562, -0.001097820233553648, 0.041670769453048706, -0.012915260158479214, -0.04893393814563751, 0.03261829540133476, -0.0025713229551911354, 0.08001527190208435, -0.024234315380454063, -0.06357090920209885, -0.006014510057866573, 0.08516396582126617, -0.016749227419495583, 0.07667694240808487, -0.018490124493837357, -0.040995799005031586, 0.02326558530330658, -0.015678606927394867, 0.027405928820371628, -0.047225795686244965, -0.09429735690355301, -0.02028069458901882, -0.0635576918721199, 0.05354469642043114, 0.05026339739561081, -0.05138479545712471, -0.008647335693240166, 0.040511179715394974, -0.019418267533183098, 0.03894453123211861, 0.017397787421941757, -0.039144206792116165, -0.00936307292431593, 0.0029423607047647238, -0.056643951684236526, -0.03498867526650429, 0.0003849449276458472, -0.03777644783258438, -0.045314133167266846, 0.041655514389276505, 0.03592517971992493, 0.02000376209616661, -0.03508903831243515, -0.04230938479304314, -0.03730980306863785, 0.013585910201072693, -0.07772855460643768, -0.036973707377910614, 0.009104653261601925, -0.042956672608852386, -0.010177952237427235, 0.05800844728946686, -0.04477914422750473, -0.09288685023784637, -0.06835391372442245, -0.013843833468854427, 0.020931653678417206, 0.014953036792576313, -0.009448491036891937, 0.00012441784201655537, -0.013398164883255959, 0.007373232394456863, 0.0448584221303463, -0.05343426391482353, -0.006663918495178223, -0.11765974014997482, -0.025475338101387024, 0.012309628538787365, 0.04242539033293724, 0.0210166797041893, 0.007450612261891365, -0.05595099553465843, 0.008423235267400742, 0.00013763798051513731, -0.0030439095571637154, -0.011369280517101288, -0.061419107019901276, 0.004047537222504616, 0.06798400729894638, 0.011452760547399521, -0.030887795612215996, -0.013745294883847237, -0.0003828933695331216, -0.03878451883792877, 0.024482361972332, -0.05286680907011032, -0.07830554991960526, -0.04178151115775108, -0.00824629794806242, 0.013737822882831097, -0.049767278134822845, -0.04244888946413994, 0.0017066261498257518, -0.02049860544502735, -0.0316786989569664, -0.022353604435920715, -0.025137629359960556, 0.0239641722291708, -0.016536954790353775, 0.007789580151438713, -0.003374281572178006, 0.0032391787972301245, 0.006260122172534466, -0.02333999052643776, -0.047554370015859604, 0.05870356038212776, -0.004855497274547815, -0.051244061440229416, 0.003646992379799485, -0.024142475798726082, 0.059201549738645554, 0.02682800590991974, 0.017922667786478996, -0.035940006375312805, -0.018983274698257446, 0.04084998741745949, -0.0072093200869858265, 0.0659092515707016, 0.061365123838186264, -0.04116656631231308, -0.00649782782420516, -0.01688382402062416, -0.003813638584688306, -0.01389175746589899, 0.044270191341638565, 0.020090389996767044, -0.027811797335743904, 0.03766810894012451, 0.018800778314471245, -0.023532720282673836, 0.021154209971427917, -0.01921166107058525, 0.08082829415798187, -0.0008152563823387027, -0.008981535211205482, 0.03629913926124573, 0.019355066120624542, 0.021543174982070923, -0.0560385063290596, 0.020840436220169067, -0.008906666189432144, 0.01328942459076643, 0.007504696492105722, 0.05705191195011139, -0.003123637055978179, 0.029467705637216568, -0.020925143733620644, 0.016863757744431496, -0.0019272577483206987, 0.008264231495559216, 0.0029008756391704082, 0.041036948561668396, 0.040919460356235504, -0.04074642434716225, 0.04432741552591324, -0.06294655799865723, 0.010579552501440048, 0.008849913254380226, 0.022210441529750824, -0.022323602810502052, 0.03711822256445885, 0.060295410454273224, 0.006287551950663328, 0.01640489511191845, -0.0356089286506176, 0.0213480107486248, -0.03330463171005249, -0.004800870083272457, 0.013434546999633312, -0.006019700318574905, -0.03676891699433327, -0.003124764421954751, 0.029451441019773483, 0.05817096307873726, 0.037597544491291046, 0.015552093274891376, 0.006762147881090641, -0.03292663395404816, -0.006708772853016853, 0.005075438413769007, -0.08169158548116684, 0.02149069868028164, -0.029425695538520813, -0.028211340308189392, -0.017527123913168907, 0.04922661930322647, -0.052900269627571106, 0.04017370566725731, 0.008526691235601902, -0.007600299082696438, -0.04959042742848396, -0.06154058501124382, 0.08416306972503662, 0.05570008233189583, 0.03638337925076485, -0.03563970699906349, -0.06853432953357697, 0.009253116324543953, -0.02029765583574772, -0.029181115329265594, -0.02083391137421131, -0.022173969075083733, -0.0024524733889847994, -0.0038003704976290464, -0.0027366068679839373, -0.07537554204463959, 0.0527186319231987, 0.10727779567241669, -0.02307005412876606, 0.003944226540625095, 0.02487281709909439, -0.012514736503362656, 0.019510675221681595, -0.031151428818702698, -0.03203009441494942, 0.015069064684212208, -0.024681933224201202, -0.03479522466659546, 0.005110363941639662, 0.019607016816735268, 0.002937472891062498, 0.029369821771979332, -0.026508770883083344, 0.0014819717034697533, 0.027655545622110367, 0.05083348602056503, 0.01866518333554268, -0.024354899302124977, -0.09346940368413925, 0.05106285586953163, -0.010952997021377087, 0.01849299669265747, -0.05637945607304573, -0.07780791074037552, -0.00701039656996727, -0.04164435341954231, -0.021193411201238632, 0.01726754941046238, 0.020176740363240242, 0.020388834178447723, 0.031927742063999176, 0.03503652289509773, -0.005257878452539444, -0.035396598279476166, -0.048314742743968964, -0.003558171447366476, -0.014497022144496441, 0.017528260126709938, -0.008684918284416199, 0.022530274465680122, 0.012937880121171474, -0.01563866436481476, -0.014095591381192207, -0.06698369234800339, -0.005561502650380135, -0.03345135599374771, -0.03352207690477371, 0.014341377653181553, 0.032249871641397476, 0.10991065204143524, -0.033102016896009445, 0.0010145461419597268, 0.0395934097468853, -0.00018881993310060352, -0.01284837443381548, -0.04943028837442398, -0.020681247115135193, -0.05871744826436043, 0.009011972695589066, 0.03985178843140602, -0.007998731918632984, -0.02340257167816162, 0.0473528653383255, 0.04822919890284538, -0.003991120960563421, 0.0008256550645455718, -0.02024184726178646, 0.040573690086603165, -0.027428504079580307, -0.005248721223324537, 0.00038926457636989653, 0.007687616162002087, 0.021185943856835365, 0.033860042691230774, 0.05831388011574745, -0.004773798864334822, -0.019632961601018906, -0.01908094622194767, 0.014027077704668045, 0.02376345731317997, -0.027540132403373718, 0.05509353056550026, -0.047885145992040634, -0.06664422899484634, -0.04577650502324104, 0.03334621340036392, 0.030752113088965416, 0.05900086462497711, 0.006503141950815916, 0.01463386882096529, -0.0005660320748575032, 0.035112880170345306, -0.017514897510409355, 0.008240616880357265, -0.040034253150224686, -0.027274485677480698, 0.012248210608959198, 0.01776847429573536, -0.06953201442956924, 0.05502859130501747, -0.019302578642964363, 0.016062036156654358, -0.0045539806596934795, -0.030390871688723564, -0.007797009311616421, 0.007053129840642214, -0.01780037209391594, -0.05677178129553795, 0.010237805545330048, -0.012790336273610592, 0.02158028446137905, -0.0029107138980180025, 0.008771371096372604, 0.004917134065181017, 0.00977115985006094, -0.03252090886235237, -0.010152587667107582, 0.018046582117676735, 0.01752128265798092, 0.011831500567495823, 0.005409609526395798, 0.0629139095544815, -0.035769861191511154, 0.003340682480484247, 0.004967889748513699, 0.06163932383060455, 0.029223065823316574, -0.004664524458348751, 0.06268058717250824, -0.016666999086737633, -0.0394827164709568, 0.027012625709176064, 0.038199082016944885, -0.05150744318962097, 0.01914174295961857, -0.019783684983849525, -0.0332525409758091, 0.010592249222099781, -0.03654549643397331, 0.046778906136751175, -0.03811008483171463, 0.024278679862618446, -0.0030828143935650587, -0.017945365980267525, -0.0013502073707059026, 0.03722785785794258, 0.046597156673669815, -0.0007490422576665878, -0.020413151010870934, -0.07335039228200912, 0.05694268271327019, -0.005560878664255142, 0.023199014365673065, -0.015030087903141975, -0.04421290010213852, -0.052849795669317245, -0.02137138321995735, 0.06171197071671486, 0.05728388950228691, -0.0005250669200904667, -0.04611191153526306, -0.0022222462575882673, 0.04577558860182762, -0.04450580105185509, 0.04422935098409653, 0.06339435279369354, 0.03176203742623329, -0.03184739872813225, 0.011101757176220417, -0.029671689495444298, 0.014597528614103794, -0.028536155819892883, -0.024476464837789536, -0.027721218764781952, 0.01019652932882309, -0.05368295684456825, -0.01713048852980137, -0.007371956016868353, 0.04298122227191925, 0.062149230390787125, -0.04705903306603432, 0.024242611601948738, 0.014027444645762444, -0.0057708490639925, -0.008116606622934341, 0.03383580222725868, 0.03226947411894798, 0.010642847046256065, -0.020540019497275352, 0.020618434995412827, 0.03226945921778679, -0.01765734888613224, 0.026535019278526306, -0.021783916279673576, -0.006760812364518642, -0.002752235159277916, -0.010481692850589752, 0.0068384758196771145, 0.07929259538650513, 0.050818998366594315, -0.004022620618343353, -0.029847649857401848, 0.031620949506759644, 0.05236424133181572, 0.012839457020163536, -0.08698861300945282, -0.023224826902151108, 0.006372240837663412, 0.018250858411192894, -0.04418953135609627, -0.013435150496661663, -0.02007925882935524, 0.01513117179274559, -0.06668586283922195, 0.012195353396236897, 0.05558229237794876, -0.013010209426283836, -0.06626909971237183, 0.011484782211482525, 0.029003625735640526, 0.0022657811641693115, 0.014069187454879284, -0.020960044115781784, -0.04118071123957634, -0.05448285490274429, 0.07006267458200455, -0.0031197492498904467, -0.023056181147694588, -0.07784648984670639, -0.030410651117563248, -0.015156088396906853, 0.03962237015366554, -0.0519787035882473, 0.007051597349345684, 0.028585147112607956, -0.00602356530725956, 0.016839079558849335, 0.028936482965946198, 0.06163184344768524, -0.019156143069267273, 0.0437936969101429, -0.034067634493112564, 0.045526206493377686, -0.026456179097294807, -0.0009757769294083118, -0.013270438648760319, 0.06800951808691025, 0.07895727455615997, 0.02853609062731266, 0.01762133650481701, -0.012900792062282562, -0.05246800184249878, -0.0181107297539711, 0.01944252848625183, 0.060182031244039536, 0.02374047227203846, 0.02079666405916214, -0.0031460970640182495, -0.046398550271987915, 0.012526758946478367, -0.04027937725186348, 0.09130629152059555, -0.013675747439265251, -0.039461322128772736, -0.02723178081214428, 0.002094011753797531, 0.03232280910015106, -0.06310337036848068, 0.07553619146347046, 0.04477078840136528, -0.01524473074823618, 0.06234203651547432, -0.02487746812403202, -0.018486997112631798, 0.016285579651594162, 0.0861649364233017, 0.012777993455529213, -0.036735422909259796, -0.015352845191955566, -0.010535065084695816, -0.01904257945716381, -0.01794881746172905, -0.02399107813835144, 0.07248078286647797, -0.01273271068930626, 0.009855326265096664, 0.06978610157966614, -0.03965909779071808, 0.0339374877512455, 0.013851633295416832, -0.015395134687423706, -0.02718961611390114, 0.031388867646455765, -0.0075573185458779335, -0.04308249056339264, -0.025609513744711876, 0.008435278199613094, -0.043332554399967194, -0.04750833660364151, 0.05047398805618286, 0.02036190964281559, 0.010674825869500637, -0.0051252529956400394, -0.009341212920844555, -0.028628315776586533, 0.06224091351032257, -0.0040870350785553455, 0.021843306720256805, 0.019229743629693985, -0.038959112018346786, 0.049817752093076706, 0.013013696298003197, -0.03558929264545441, 0.0027814526110887527, -0.04575495794415474, -0.002805695403367281, -0.0026161503046751022, 0.03132455796003342, -0.02274109609425068, 0.03847421333193779, -0.00874341744929552, -0.027623631060123444, -0.012895140796899796, 0.04862811788916588, 0.04714928939938545 ]
<p>If you happen to have the Third Edition of Classical Electrodynamics by John David Jackson, turn to section 11.8, as that's where I'm getting all this from. If not, you should still be able to follow along.</p> <p>In said section, Jackson gives us this equation that relates any physical vector <strong>G</strong> in a rotating vs. non-rotating reference frame:</p> <p>$\left(\frac{d\mathbf{G}}{dt}\right)_{nonrot} = \left(\frac{d\mathbf{G}}{dt}\right)_{rest frame} + \boldsymbol{\omega}_T \times \mathbf{G}$</p> <p>where</p> <p>$\boldsymbol{\omega}_T = \frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma+1}\frac{\mathbf{a}\times\mathbf{v}}{c^2}$</p> <p>"where <strong>a</strong> is the acceleration in the laboratory frame," according to the textbook. Also, gamma is defined using <strong>v</strong>, the velocity of the particle as measured in the lab frame.</p> <p>Ok. So I decided to check this by setting <strong>G</strong> = <strong>x</strong>, the position vector, for a particle that is undergoing circular motion in the laboratory frame. So we have</p> <p>$\left(\frac{d\mathbf{x}}{dt}\right)_{nonrot} = \mathbf{v}$</p> <p>and</p> <p>$\left(\frac{d\mathbf{x}}{dt}\right)_{rest frame} = 0$ because the particle doesn't have any velocity in its own frame (right?).</p> <p>So far so good (I think). Now, this implies that $\boldsymbol{\omega}_T \times \mathbf{x} = \mathbf{v}$. So if we can verify this using the definition of $\boldsymbol{\omega}_T$, we're golden. However, if you use the fact that $|a| = \frac{v^2}{|x|}$ for circular motion as well as the fact that <strong>a</strong> is perpendicular to <strong>v</strong>, and that <strong>a</strong> is (anti)parallel to <strong>x</strong>, and carefully apply the right hand rule, you'll find, after the algebraic dust settles, that</p> <p>$\boldsymbol{\omega}_T \times \mathbf{G} = (1-\gamma)\mathbf{v}$</p> <p>So this is definitely a contradiction. Because it implies that $\mathbf{v} = (1-\gamma)\mathbf{v}$. Can anyone tell me where this went horribly horribly wrong? I worked on this with my professor for two hours yesterday and we couldn't figure it out.</p>
g4216
[ 0.07542210072278976, -0.003456421196460724, -0.01753600686788559, -0.06487312912940979, 0.09867078065872192, 0.017375098541378975, 0.10319140553474426, -0.024758435785770416, -0.0454711839556694, 0.008745279163122177, 0.002890185918658972, 0.05600249394774437, -0.030328093096613884, 0.007458094507455826, -0.004121990874409676, 0.004381169099360704, 0.08165948837995529, 0.044606518000364304, 0.022732986137270927, -0.0027451629284769297, -0.010983847081661224, 0.038464926183223724, 0.01102240476757288, -0.046167176216840744, 0.01800689660012722, -0.01633015088737011, -0.007443696726113558, -0.028846699744462967, -0.04895012453198433, 0.0003066434001084417, 0.048220619559288025, -0.017688095569610596, 0.022454744204878807, 0.001220321049913764, -0.01193345058709383, -0.0075832633301615715, 0.039782196283340454, 0.04307069629430771, 0.028451984748244286, -0.017122434452176094, 0.011289818212389946, -0.006861307192593813, 0.03198209032416344, 0.011948665603995323, 0.006065516732633114, 0.004602765664458275, -0.02150852605700493, 0.03805258497595787, -0.03371400013566017, -0.01109409611672163, -0.045011281967163086, 0.06173032894730568, 0.07303600758314133, -0.007017943542450666, -0.03765431419014931, 0.04076123982667923, 0.02955717034637928, -0.0022062158677726984, 0.00316422525793314, 0.04186142235994339, 0.0292045995593071, -0.0377839095890522, 0.021170873194932938, -0.027724191546440125, 0.024682817980647087, 0.018083512783050537, -0.0026465526316314936, -0.007970388978719711, -0.04608658328652382, -0.0019331545336171985, 0.008419784717261791, -0.07216281443834305, 0.03588908165693283, 0.004262366332113743, -0.01327592320740223, -0.038188301026821136, 0.008710628375411034, -0.031623758375644684, -0.011847344227135181, -0.01235241536051035, -0.0041613224893808365, 0.05405795946717262, 0.019341036677360535, 0.006764065008610487, 0.02451477013528347, -0.02673138491809368, -0.03033020719885826, 0.03911064937710762, -0.001541636069305241, -0.007896658964455128, 0.012311441823840141, -0.055324163287878036, 0.044610414654016495, -0.013276968151330948, -0.004006045870482922, -0.027991777285933495, -0.0577174536883831, 0.09341857582330704, 0.012474693357944489, -0.009601060301065445, -0.015943096950650215, 0.013168871402740479, -0.04680565372109413, 0.010573347099125385, -0.02256818674504757, 0.007481839507818222, 0.0651884526014328, 0.0319238156080246, -0.04402678832411766, -0.06770402193069458, -0.0547948032617569, -0.006251391489058733, -0.047402191907167435, -0.052836012095212936, -0.032091107219457626, -0.010701330378651619, 0.039221666753292084, -0.026749201118946075, 0.01899375393986702, 0.0511341467499733, -0.00930817611515522, 0.008482031524181366, 0.008136161603033543, 0.07681425660848618, -0.04781382903456688, 0.014590338803827763, 0.008665166795253754, 0.012431204319000244, 0.023859839886426926, -0.008635064586997032, 0.02677810564637184, -0.024000972509384155, 0.015210491605103016, 0.03948798030614853, 0.006391992326825857, 0.0002718672913033515, 0.02124040573835373, -0.02397177927196026, -0.03968345746397972, -0.003740044077858329, 0.010831906460225582, -0.025988155975937843, 0.024340275675058365, -0.020812464877963066, -0.006544561590999365, 0.060574594885110855, 0.016325347125530243, -0.055175501853227615, 0.04289969429373741, 0.018433840945363045, 0.0007091441657394171, 0.10782145708799362, -0.02996229939162731, -0.032897986471652985, 0.049906615167856216, 0.010717581026256084, 0.07679080218076706, 0.0334768071770668, 0.027124812826514244, 0.034384287893772125, 0.07444306463003159, -0.015026702545583248, 0.006562978960573673, -0.021344786509871483, -0.03919953480362892, -0.009215200319886208, -0.00010550546721788123, -0.0025298260152339935, 0.018705524504184723, -0.03954156115651131, -0.07154617458581924, -0.031776558607816696, 0.07106266915798187, -0.033845651894807816, -0.051214464008808136, 0.09492356330156326, -0.02955232933163643, -0.07155613601207733, 0.007229779381304979, -0.011346738785505295, -0.010046315379440784, -0.002680316334590316, 0.026001593098044395, -0.02943352423608303, -0.026827001944184303, -0.009406841360032558, -0.06513906270265579, 0.04310566186904907, -0.05252430588006973, -0.0018525422783568501, -0.02261764369904995, 0.019300010055303574, -0.023470373824238777, 0.04844649136066437, -0.041272226721048355, 0.02260398678481579, -0.043222006410360336, -0.07989975810050964, -0.049666374921798706, 0.03151369094848633, -0.01194937527179718, 0.042546216398477554, 0.06628423184156418, 0.012495915405452251, 0.013678723946213722, -0.006324601359665394, -0.029176142066717148, -0.006683237850666046, 0.02994351089000702, 0.009494258090853691, 0.0015214182203635573, 0.038005854934453964, -0.03903370723128319, 0.0463724322617054, 0.012974605895578861, -0.08125855028629303, 0.018609171733260155, -0.00865963939577341, -0.05586344376206398, 0.02611631155014038, -0.03232354298233986, -0.06465008854866028, 0.01929417811334133, -0.07418379932641983, 0.017803365364670753, -0.01198901329189539, -0.024056924507021904, -0.03178129717707634, -0.041711315512657166, 0.015053793787956238, -0.06109737232327461, 0.026668593287467957, -0.07493269443511963, -0.007537156343460083, 0.0705677941441536, 0.0056054783053696156, -0.043598201125860214, -0.0003223199164494872, 0.08065367490053177, 0.014884577132761478, -0.024963529780507088, 0.010631437413394451, -0.058093439787626266, -0.02022365853190422, 0.021546393632888794, 0.020759712904691696, 0.10506157577037811, -0.009614662267267704, 0.026605932042002678, -0.020267494022846222, 0.024228252470493317, 0.011501926928758621, 0.014420351944863796, 0.00028342820587567985, -0.01738635078072548, -0.003594946349039674, -0.059134021401405334, 0.017864150926470757, -0.05131424963474274, -0.017857225611805916, -0.023619510233402252, -0.003919615875929594, -0.02608676254749298, 0.00729750981554389, -0.03768092393875122, 0.019538171589374542, -0.021580930799245834, -0.007252500392496586, -0.03420116379857063, -0.004879576154053211, 0.01162946131080389, 0.0324275903403759, 0.04200727865099907, 0.02017015591263771, -0.01696838065981865, 0.001938555622473359, -0.01902768760919571, 0.006058377679437399, 0.02204815484583378, -0.014631010591983795, 0.015534340403974056, 0.0027917458210140467, -0.008723164908587933, 0.013930212706327438, 0.015741903334856033, -0.04907454922795296, 0.014392643235623837, 0.056118763983249664, -0.044776711612939835, -0.025276925414800644, -0.06700809299945831, 0.049436550587415695, 0.039069321006536484, -0.02946840226650238, -0.014199987053871155, 0.09768780320882797, 0.02927066572010517, -0.023252613842487335, 0.041973214596509933, -0.024354808032512665, 0.04962501674890518, 0.0727926716208458, -0.042889147996902466, 0.035084161907434464, 0.05174070596694946, 0.02721899189054966, -0.07105672359466553, -0.055154331028461456, -0.020619571208953857, 0.030386188998818398, -0.010785169899463654, -0.01253517996519804, 0.03366031125187874, -0.01738741807639599, -0.035306259989738464, -0.027811869978904724, -0.01848328486084938, -0.025302840396761894, 0.05259083956480026, 0.0761747807264328, -0.037896160036325455, -0.038691774010658264, -0.010319638065993786, -0.013522903434932232, 0.03716461360454559, -0.005026400554925203, -0.03383224830031395, 0.017625467851758003, -0.02827007696032524, -0.036659106612205505, 0.010395053774118423, 0.02204155921936035, 0.01727607101202011, -0.00517537584528327, -0.012512700632214546, -0.019477523863315582, 0.010260388255119324, 0.019836129620671272, 0.02167506515979767, -0.027695929631590843, 0.014931406825780869, -0.002678497927263379, -0.02064598724246025, -0.04618910327553749, 0.0032132957130670547, 0.01715463399887085, 0.0031154004391282797, 0.011583882384002209, 0.009137005545198917, 0.02064371109008789, 0.03807841241359711, -0.0448765903711319, 0.0021677000913769007, -0.015953196212649345, -0.005113985855132341, 0.019036155194044113, 0.06972663849592209, 0.060748759657144547, 0.05395945906639099, -0.014628587290644646, 0.010679706931114197, -0.013944689184427261, -0.003315744223073125, -0.01246313564479351, -0.014607896097004414, 0.060226380825042725, 0.004827943630516529, 0.06474883109331131, 0.005739099811762571, -0.046364180743694305, -0.0038829089608043432, -0.049473028630018234, 0.008066759444773197, -0.03225276246666908, 0.00839388370513916, -0.06952319294214249, -0.01892012543976307, 0.037183571606874466, -0.02258809469640255, 0.06556552648544312, 0.016056157648563385, -0.010846092365682125, 0.03505682572722435, 0.011682604439556599, -0.003939401358366013, 0.035093680024147034, -0.005541007965803146, 0.029084060341119766, -0.020579108968377113, -0.007316551171243191, 0.010438395664095879, 0.03981653228402138, -0.027878258377313614, -0.010177364572882652, 0.024603385478258133, -0.06011420860886574, 0.024519436061382294, 0.0012725170236080885, -0.03839349001646042, 0.002821048256009817, 0.0035315605346113443, 0.03496900945901871, -0.02825535461306572, -0.012814400717616081, -0.06911668181419373, 0.04851214587688446, 0.009803933091461658, -0.04029844328761101, 0.010778514668345451, -0.027148079127073288, -0.04491403326392174, -0.020950131118297577, -0.007312131579965353, -0.09656909108161926, 0.04707673192024231, 0.02181066758930683, 0.0313272699713707, 0.02558804117143154, 0.017630869522690773, -0.0420992411673069, 0.06520649045705795, 0.054156430065631866, 0.03408055007457733, -0.044631391763687134, 0.015500601381063461, 0.08535555750131607, 0.026554232463240623, 0.09013260900974274, -0.016471607610583305, -0.017445240169763565, 0.020585687831044197, 0.00254177232272923, 0.0021993082482367754, 0.020651964470744133, -0.03887456655502319, 0.030544692650437355, -0.05078497901558876, 0.06730830669403076, 0.05196832865476608, 0.039581507444381714, 0.09009144455194473, -0.025885561481118202, 0.04523365572094917, -0.03807836025953293, 0.019860632717609406, 0.046616289764642715, -0.058263543993234634, -0.006252344232052565, 0.010148409754037857, -0.013129137456417084, -0.0013027164386585355, 0.04223199188709259, -0.005335934925824404, 0.028668168932199478, 0.01076582632958889, -0.02125704102218151, -0.009987209923565388, 0.05055280029773712, -0.0174578707665205, 0.016790756955742836, -0.07450471818447113, -0.005901297088712454, -0.006141153629869223, 0.013280640356242657, 0.04721636325120926, 0.03088456392288208, -0.023669175803661346, 0.008558548055589199, -0.06417480111122131, -0.02031724341213703, -0.01476044487208128, -0.007271570153534412, -0.05196651816368103, -0.04402793571352959, -0.03936946392059326, -0.00687633128836751, 0.01082879863679409, 0.008143589831888676, -0.03750957176089287, -0.0655907690525055, -0.011728079058229923, -0.004651926923543215, 0.030700860545039177, -0.004755329806357622, 0.056041568517684937, 0.0015425685560330749, -0.02619246020913124, -0.008022379130125046, -0.012040206231176853, 0.005880292039364576, 0.018516728654503822, 0.006675740238279104, -0.04194960743188858, -0.030639123171567917, -0.021429650485515594, 0.012388964183628559, -0.01101753767579794, -0.06484590470790863, -0.032955463975667953, 0.009456073865294456, -0.05633401870727539, 0.020443186163902283, 0.022879909723997116, -0.014124810695648193, -0.0018760678358376026, 0.026959817856550217, 0.02109522558748722, 0.0068100313656032085, -0.057151079177856445, 0.049425143748521805, 0.00576401362195611, 0.020136570557951927, 0.048247843980789185, 0.03518496826291084, 0.008834827691316605, -0.02195938676595688, 0.01090585719794035, -0.03503509610891342, 0.02104872465133667, -0.10404745489358902, 0.04515821859240532, 0.05972958356142044, -0.01781637594103813, -0.07071875780820847, -0.03109102137386799, 0.04530661925673485, -0.02073732204735279, -0.02898622304201126, -0.004296362865716219, 0.0654878243803978, -0.043614085763692856, -0.03255591168999672, 0.01907266117632389, 0.020942505449056625, -0.01505562849342823, -0.06813571602106094, 0.020780950784683228, -0.020499562844634056, 0.0013868456007912755, -0.038231730461120605, -0.05461745336651802, 0.0129153523594141, 0.038697853684425354, 0.006491454783827066, -0.05832128971815109, 0.02761715278029442, -0.011850946582853794, -0.024998502805829048, 0.04373263567686081, -0.039636459201574326, 0.011599971912801266, 0.029141036793589592, -0.00987462792545557, -0.014369973912835121, 0.014098321087658405, 0.006960667669773102, -0.0069144065491855145, -0.058679334819316864, -0.021547779440879822, -0.02428191527724266, 0.012432122603058815, -0.02272857539355755, 0.03686268627643585, 0.04195283725857735, 0.00018857720715459436, -0.029966779053211212, -0.007484158501029015, -0.003481360152363777, -0.016571493819355965, -0.007255761418491602, -0.06054583564400673, 0.04345538839697838, 0.0020153920631855726, 0.045180268585681915, 0.03989708796143532, 0.08670375496149063, -0.06451637297868729, -0.030882906168699265, -0.05706867203116417, -0.01661042869091034, 0.01649007387459278, 0.020009085536003113, 0.06368817389011383, -0.005817629862576723, -0.01690519042313099, -0.03632180392742157, -0.043758198618888855, 0.026980826631188393, 0.016951799392700195, -0.008384308777749538, 0.0013446379452943802, -0.02167445793747902, -0.06154827028512955, -0.0012010608334094286, -0.0713820829987526, -0.02121252752840519, 0.020669616758823395, 0.006324428599327803, 0.007689798716455698, -0.01207363698631525, 0.019615577533841133, 0.03579535707831383, 0.031398333609104156, -0.02844959869980812, 0.03648417443037033, -0.01031456794589758, -0.04345152899622917, -0.0022297846153378487, 0.009600205346941948, 0.010131523944437504, 0.025314930826425552, 0.04864869639277458, 0.02925722859799862, 0.04375973716378212, -0.03903923183679581, -0.03560083732008934, 0.01666507124900818, 0.0099800331518054, 0.018525775521993637, -0.0167783722281456, -0.01229093037545681, 0.02724679931998253, 0.008368253707885742, -0.02644394524395466, 0.06816162914037704, 0.05147738754749298, -0.02743149921298027, 0.03348636254668236, 0.05408940464258194, 0.014604715630412102, 0.06293576210737228, -0.012389535084366798, -0.027556542307138443, 0.007261563092470169, 0.025047674775123596, -0.020167546346783638, -0.07383519411087036, 0.04247243329882622, 0.0073553393594920635, -0.009021885693073273, -0.010044381953775883, 0.05980375036597252, 0.015392756089568138, -0.08358674496412277, -0.07998505234718323, -0.034610383212566376, 0.022909656167030334, 0.025273878127336502, -0.0592271089553833, 0.007113545201718807, 0.018606938421726227, -0.011204121634364128, -0.017223799601197243, 0.022818725556135178, -0.01260881032794714, -0.016112886369228363, 0.06136531010270119, -0.009772267192602158, 0.08309274911880493, -0.049465905874967575, 0.002139324089512229, -0.023535234853625298, 0.043226152658462524, 0.04427414387464523, -0.02772502414882183, 0.013881301507353783, -0.06969354301691055, -0.021509291604161263, 0.038018494844436646, 0.004466853104531765, 0.027686435729265213, 0.015267708338797092, -0.02572672627866268, 0.012597961351275444, -0.0070507824420928955, 0.03074643574655056, 0.01826881617307663, 0.03923865780234337, -0.03986956551671028, -0.04251677915453911, -0.020541338250041008, 0.01821698620915413, -0.023055311292409897, 0.0472211018204689, -0.029544368386268616, 0.001813271432183683, -0.006374660413712263, -0.027206428349018097, -0.003909236751496792, 0.04676340892910957, -0.016563357785344124, 0.017486773431301117, 0.04390896111726761, 0.013629279099404812, 0.03324546664953232, 0.017509115859866142, 0.013396553695201874, 0.03742962330579758, 0.049512024968862534, 0.008938603103160858, 0.005195717327296734, -0.03964943066239357, -0.03487549349665642, 0.03752912953495979, -0.010084261186420918, 0.03561733290553093, -0.031155427917838097, -0.030450401827692986, -0.034986838698387146, -0.05409398674964905, 0.04476604610681534, -0.015338490717113018, 0.005114683881402016, 0.012756189331412315, 0.0817546471953392, -0.02003381960093975, -0.015488692559301853, 0.019665619358420372, 0.07099803537130356, -0.023123878985643387, -0.024987082928419113, -0.009683292359113693, -0.06524074077606201, -0.035681284964084625, -0.02113225869834423, -0.05199269577860832, -0.010924112051725388, -0.0006467138300649822, 0.035186510533094406, -0.0019796777050942183, -0.056596141308546066, 0.012452824972569942, -0.01397629827260971, 0.024285491555929184, -0.050417494028806686, -0.016060445457696915, 0.0017063174163922668, -0.03939817100763321, 0.0643320381641388, 0.004992293659597635, -0.006171043962240219, -0.05495927110314369, -0.04728413745760918, -0.011548132635653019, -0.05777221918106079, -0.03790486231446266, -0.015889864414930344, 0.04337645322084427, -0.02680584415793419, -0.04091599956154823, -0.01910410448908806, 0.028817258775234222, -0.015414390712976456, 0.023073501884937286, 0.06110086292028427, -0.04199496656656265, 0.043110694736242294, -0.027030188590288162, 0.05318942293524742, 0.052402086555957794, -0.024951821193099022, -0.05829663202166557, 0.0574411004781723, -0.060126837342977524, 0.045403119176626205, -0.08714604377746582, -0.008495645597577095, 0.0173376202583313 ]
<p>Let's say I have a free jet of air leaving a pipe into the atmosphere. I know that the static gauge pressure at the pipe exit is equal to the atmospheric. But what about the static gauge pressure 10 meters away if the air is still traveling as a free jet? Is it still atmospheric?</p>
g4217
[ 0.036182813346385956, -0.020784912630915642, 0.0010362397879362106, -0.018647411838173866, -0.02822199836373329, 0.07754165679216385, 0.004844979383051395, -0.02676747925579548, -0.07902240008115768, 0.03767586499452591, -0.03396866098046303, -0.0041130827739834785, -0.018117204308509827, -0.01704428531229496, 0.05645639821887016, 0.023173624649643898, 0.08059483021497726, -0.056784454733133316, 0.019032873213291168, -0.02503880299627781, 0.014705170877277851, -0.06801638752222061, 0.009237546473741531, -0.09481976181268692, -0.039832256734371185, -0.04758386313915253, 0.02479233406484127, -0.05554172769188881, -0.024806901812553406, -0.03460623696446419, 0.018338728696107864, 0.05875387042760849, 0.05381988361477852, -0.0037906744983047247, -0.017711037769913673, -0.01487277913838625, 0.02673395350575447, 0.02025480568408966, 0.04927998036146164, -0.04532381519675255, 0.047019995748996735, -0.026337923482060432, -0.07229630649089813, 0.02137618139386177, 0.013093681074678898, 0.03598009794950485, -0.0074347215704619884, -0.010103553533554077, -0.034047264605760574, -0.029473498463630676, -0.02118588052690029, 0.03096763603389263, -0.041250791400671005, 0.009595343843102455, -0.06050397455692291, 0.046334072947502136, 0.01342071034014225, -0.041807081550359726, 0.00407094182446599, 0.032878801226615906, -0.04207184538245201, 0.055847298353910446, 0.0003388430050108582, -0.015881754457950592, 0.03747287392616272, -0.006864476483315229, -0.03805992379784584, -0.006071176845580339, -0.0414457768201828, 0.049308378249406815, 0.0417499914765358, -0.04904695227742195, -0.022782089188694954, 0.0688745379447937, -0.03439566493034363, 0.05183436721563339, -0.04390210658311844, -0.0276420209556818, 0.04921603947877884, 0.006072067189961672, -0.02721708081662655, -0.019473847001791, 0.009112522937357426, -0.04833953082561493, 0.016521921381354332, -0.0517607107758522, 0.008324503898620605, -0.031851109117269516, -0.10513018071651459, -0.040927790105342865, -0.03483525291085243, -0.09860662370920181, 0.05262614041566849, 0.03314661607146263, 0.023043854162096977, 0.01989915780723095, -0.0010598772205412388, 0.04430834576487541, 0.017827007919549942, -0.013998305425047874, -0.06147417426109314, -0.05869429185986519, -0.00014881753304507583, 0.0558503083884716, 0.026253653690218925, -0.03866108879446983, 0.06263906508684158, 0.03387025371193886, -0.005931142717599869, -0.051570825278759, 0.03548211604356766, -0.00046121678315103054, -0.08816307038068771, 0.028124572709202766, -0.027578404173254967, -0.04677489772439003, 0.024508334696292877, -0.01207598764449358, 0.013204958289861679, 0.021336961537599564, 0.05840079486370087, 0.01999162882566452, 0.060502395033836365, -0.005940125323832035, 0.03887661173939705, -0.011490054428577423, -0.046912457793951035, -0.00234413193538785, 0.000737276510335505, -0.031083565205335617, -0.0003296275972388685, 0.01984378881752491, -0.027772031724452972, 0.04468930885195732, -0.002690137131139636, -0.024740666151046753, -0.026977119967341423, 0.003258033189922571, 0.010836181230843067, 0.04617941007018089, 0.050086427479982376, -0.014051911421120167, 0.01861521042883396, -0.015243159607052803, -0.020437758415937424, 0.001522572012618184, 0.0378020741045475, -0.017990639433264732, 0.05700564384460449, -0.05750936642289162, 0.029505379498004913, 0.025848396122455597, 0.006341326516121626, 0.03209909796714783, -0.04389176145195961, -0.033327117562294006, -0.00015497836284339428, 0.016904715448617935, 0.05381865054368973, -0.0470988005399704, 0.04201367869973183, -0.05054914206266403, 0.10934421420097351, -0.0022248702589422464, -0.0575212799012661, -0.00943941343575716, -0.02119004726409912, -0.01947972923517227, 0.04064086452126503, 0.0011548082111403346, -0.06873419135808945, 0.04402970150113106, 0.03686909005045891, 0.009220689535140991, 0.015153116546571255, -0.012545042671263218, 0.022949019446969032, 0.024912642315030098, 0.017709646373987198, -0.0031561716459691525, 0.05399142578244209, 0.007248278241604567, 0.021405337378382683, -0.05699107050895691, -0.04732871428132057, 0.020353097468614578, -0.020368045195937157, -0.01535444613546133, -0.010222104378044605, -0.0235927551984787, 0.06972672790288925, -0.020901205018162727, 0.0012298478977754712, 0.05432620272040367, -0.05991692095994949, -0.02959631383419037, 0.02054295875132084, -0.016301678493618965, -0.043057557195425034, 0.02709071710705757, 0.022484958171844482, 0.08830005675554276, 0.025960294529795647, -0.05043316259980202, 0.024974847212433815, -0.022321302443742752, 0.044542454183101654, 0.013434916734695435, -0.003297616494819522, -0.0006954927812330425, -0.004412995185703039, 0.03302383050322533, 0.0314260870218277, 0.03970816358923912, 0.017367882654070854, 0.012115830555558205, -0.014864522032439709, -0.00432484969496727, -0.04390944540500641, 0.027378635480999947, 0.0099203921854496, -0.012759817764163017, 0.006809220649302006, -0.02786504477262497, -0.014257553964853287, -0.029797988012433052, -0.021058065816760063, -0.0025005911011248827, 0.01029856689274311, 0.028681157156825066, 0.019802510738372803, -0.011121894232928753, -0.010623641312122345, -0.000822529080323875, 0.04372512176632881, 0.019897622987627983, 0.06346222013235092, 0.03986312448978424, -0.029203150421380997, -0.043902527540922165, 0.028553711250424385, -0.01934673823416233, -0.04808714985847473, 0.054922714829444885, 0.03771790862083435, 0.012694465927779675, -0.037483781576156616, 0.04075589403510094, -0.02533559687435627, 0.05541226640343666, -0.023776469752192497, 0.044142529368400574, -0.02155454456806183, 0.10346336662769318, 0.0035965796560049057, -0.03783215209841728, 0.02078009955585003, -0.007007460575550795, -0.09041563421487808, -0.024196114391088486, -0.05008222535252571, -0.00007595462375320494, -0.017033807933330536, -0.02800646983087063, -0.009955656714737415, 0.028369391337037086, 0.032120250165462494, 0.06739911437034607, 0.03282926604151726, -0.001950723584741354, 0.04793206602334976, 0.05192277207970619, -0.01028589066118002, 0.04747244343161583, 0.01631947048008442, 0.002423721132799983, 0.0042009917087852955, 0.027885040268301964, -0.019603239372372627, -0.028883863240480423, 0.014804011210799217, 0.006191711872816086, -0.0684751644730568, 0.005706368945538998, 0.03512317314743996, -0.08092831075191498, 0.04038393124938011, 0.010671260766685009, -0.02166563831269741, 0.03160810470581055, 0.04388992115855217, 0.015614221803843975, 0.039500702172517776, 0.08608128875494003, -0.0016443179920315742, -0.014443892985582352, 0.017931906506419182, -0.02556576579809189, -0.00006314733764156699, -0.05243108049035072, -0.0005715804290957749, -0.07285530120134354, -0.03383297473192215, 0.039741504937410355, -0.0053985584527254105, 0.03718763217329979, -0.06178945675492287, -0.008044199086725712, -0.013611912727355957, -0.033952269703149796, 0.028980549424886703, 0.06584660708904266, 0.03697814792394638, 0.01491501647979021, -0.00122686882968992, 0.0035083729308098555, 0.014495312236249447, -0.00910654291510582, -0.004198957234621048, 0.07123642414808273, -0.047153908759355545, -0.03982013091444969, 0.010974316857755184, 0.054255831986665726, -0.004064945038408041, -0.01893279142677784, 0.013532068580389023, -0.016080442816019058, -0.03866700828075409, -0.008759194985032082, 0.02252434939146042, 0.0645691305398941, -0.011887271888554096, -0.04095614328980446, -0.021500524133443832, -0.01716349460184574, -0.028258806094527245, 0.04278063774108887, 0.02279556170105934, 0.022936588153243065, 0.03743449226021767, -0.03200357034802437, -0.0569966658949852, -0.013027518056333065, -0.029864780604839325, 0.005292457062751055, 0.01575434021651745, -0.038963787257671356, 0.008349285461008549, 0.0037268311716616154, 0.03077642433345318, -0.009993122890591621, -0.00973134022206068, -0.07917933911085129, -0.027273153886198997, -0.014489328488707542, 0.01622038148343563, 0.02973286062479019, -0.014182659797370434, -0.03256285935640335, 0.05252703279256821, -0.011815114878118038, 0.006401488091796637, 0.04130089282989502, -0.045918095856904984, -0.07896420359611511, -0.004164195153862238, 0.011675499379634857, 0.06306672096252441, -0.03893669322133064, -0.009107785299420357, 0.03167992830276489, -0.05752536654472351, 0.06941381096839905, -0.030489232391119003, -0.03011091612279415, 0.04175037145614624, 0.022720813751220703, 0.012654559686779976, 0.07528132945299149, 0.02285725250840187, 0.013080962002277374, -0.04261218011379242, 0.01984468661248684, -0.018829306587576866, 0.031106004491448402, -0.04821566119790077, 0.06013689935207367, 0.037283871322870255, -0.029529735445976257, -0.014060343615710735, -0.05421796441078186, -0.016188105568289757, -0.013571209274232388, 0.02057337574660778, -0.0009887897176668048, -0.01642790623009205, 0.025634994730353355, 0.04882737994194031, -0.022443518042564392, 0.08538158237934113, 0.024162380024790764, 0.011670935899019241, 0.04352004826068878, 0.03745071589946747, 0.004235946107655764, 0.01720753125846386, 0.001191621064208448, -0.0053289905190467834, 0.025288932025432587, 0.01899825409054756, -0.021831009536981583, -0.0571897029876709, -0.05120042711496353, -0.02375597134232521, -0.03140169754624367, -0.009009982459247112, -0.011332284659147263, 0.037505052983760834, -0.012339495122432709, -0.010923339985311031, 0.02869034931063652, 0.04801927134394646, 0.015014909207820892, -0.013586285524070263, 0.11714080721139908, 0.0027533587999641895, -0.016699522733688354, -0.03838622197508812, -0.04736214876174927, 0.00973362848162651, -0.043352846056222916, -0.005681550595909357, -0.029266107827425003, -0.040776968002319336, 0.07632636278867722, -0.040172066539525986, -0.06483133137226105, -0.03565891832113266, -0.010923655703663826, 0.029483148828148842, 0.0274337250739336, 0.0520390085875988, -0.007638731971383095, 0.012553106062114239, -0.0023291499819606543, 0.045192901045084, -0.019468339160084724, 0.014065933413803577, -0.01196359470486641, -0.04735014960169792, 0.006785407662391663, -0.04313785955309868, -0.012516731396317482, -0.06936100870370865, 0.0049166907556355, -0.027037790045142174, -0.019352270290255547, 0.005814142990857363, 0.002953334478661418, -0.04860121011734009, -0.002062656218186021, 0.0383109413087368, 0.03358875960111618, 0.04263988509774208, -0.02706911414861679, -0.05358083173632622, -0.023556791245937347, -0.03022846207022667, -0.0016292245127260685, 0.0017003684770315886, 0.020883910357952118, -0.032053589820861816, 0.040934931486845016, 0.011972909793257713, 0.05410376191139221, -0.00437146658077836, -0.002939217956736684, 0.056461188942193985, -0.04353517293930054, 0.04675564542412758, 0.033568061888217926, 0.015140056610107422, 0.041985806077718735, 0.01043463870882988, -0.053701769560575485, -0.048689909279346466, 0.012833722867071629, -0.008427365683019161, -0.04933108761906624, 0.05239834263920784, 0.046583618968725204, -0.0007140669040381908, 0.002241584938019514, -0.022963128983974457, 0.02205251157283783, -0.01365338172763586, -0.04401632398366928, -0.014065937139093876, 0.010140355676412582, -0.06993384659290314, -0.0007051677093841136, 0.03378910571336746, 0.005340846721082926, -0.04047302156686783, 0.056533075869083405, 0.04600822553038597, -0.031281959265470505, 0.011137174442410469, 0.09846512973308563, -0.03175090625882149, -0.045338716357946396, -0.01657799445092678, 0.04221246764063835, 0.06764237582683563, -0.03638961538672447, -0.019638732075691223, -0.02703300304710865, -0.0525476336479187, 0.009178689680993557, 0.06720809638500214, 0.005676425527781248, 0.03419964015483856, 0.05191490799188614, -0.021767986938357353, 0.0024340117815881968, -0.02525307610630989, -0.005492686294019222, -0.007608064915984869, 0.05129586160182953, -0.02955891191959381, -0.03976888954639435, 0.08573799580335617, -0.04439177364110947, 0.025924554094672203, 0.02198883146047592, -0.00400231359526515, -0.029358696192502975, 0.052252668887376785, -0.004471305292099714, 0.010708966292440891, -0.029491199180483818, 0.0007050284766592085, 0.03206266462802887, 0.011961998417973518, 0.03109651431441307, -0.003938038367778063, 0.03822048753499985, 0.010688312351703644, -0.03968964144587517, -0.016275065019726753, 0.07842230796813965, -0.08798347413539886, 0.02597365714609623, 0.042208295315504074, -0.026055868715047836, 0.049049217253923416, 0.0053716483525931835, 0.0027019288390874863, -0.04041343182325363, 0.022234555333852768, -0.0030070908833295107, -0.0006494410336017609, -0.014575938694179058, 0.03878110274672508, -0.022830180823802948, -0.017743093892931938, -0.028444916009902954, 0.019929494708776474, -0.0014180458383634686, 0.0022647096775472164, 0.02444623038172722, -0.03625980764627457, -0.03242579847574234, -0.032469432801008224, 0.041519928723573685, 0.0014896774664521217, 0.009702321141958237, 0.0018254052847623825, 0.0019217673689126968, -0.010616518557071686, 0.04653341695666313, 0.10778989642858505, -0.07799305766820908, -0.00005968506229692139, 0.04374539479613304, 0.00696273660287261, 0.009676620364189148, 0.01761043630540371, 0.07339778542518616, 0.005751054268330336, -0.044705454260110855, 0.011642631143331528, 0.024380216374993324, -0.03490482643246651, -0.0421108715236187, 0.022731786593794823, -0.019668569788336754, 0.02667100355029106, 0.05064158886671066, 0.034515380859375, 0.0953686386346817, 0.04172974452376366, -0.08310867100954056, 0.02133389748632908, 0.054959774017333984, -0.002068204339593649, 0.006322837434709072, -0.009589500725269318, -0.030183522030711174, -0.04882155731320381, -0.019774511456489563, 0.027932235971093178, -0.006687398534268141, 0.047762975096702576, 0.006478398572653532, 0.006069246679544449, -0.045514337718486786, -0.026811392977833748, -0.000997917726635933, 0.019551917910575867, 0.03267904743552208, 0.022791702300310135, -0.051156140863895416, 0.0040018437430262566, 0.037337083369493484, 0.011204314418137074, -0.005230962764471769, 0.016683997586369514, 0.01096697524189949, -0.021594330668449402, 0.012337385676801205, -0.041574686765670776, 0.001493097166530788, -0.01932573691010475, -0.011211024597287178, -0.017554085701704025, 0.02428046055138111, 0.027962271124124527, 0.03505475074052811, 0.017344610765576363, -0.012564127333462238, 0.008486607111990452, -0.014714195393025875, -0.027138996869325638, -0.009965324774384499, -0.0036074896343052387, -0.046501126140356064, -0.029043622314929962, 0.019907809793949127, -0.09954056888818741, -0.022683853283524513, -0.005174280609935522, 0.07069901376962662, -0.03355930745601654, 0.014065081253647804, -0.028217537328600883, 0.03813943639397621, -0.014269373379647732, -0.022716902196407318, -0.014985661022365093, -0.016732100397348404, -0.030897794291377068, -0.002558557316660881, 0.06013977527618408, 0.02748064324259758, -0.0018005759920924902, -0.05719706788659096, 0.0025808331556618214, -0.02481270208954811, -0.03542158752679825, -0.04848106577992439, -0.01444260124117136, 0.01197849866002798, -0.008044463582336903, 0.02462960034608841, -0.05324969068169594, 0.002440227195620537, -0.02161278761923313, -0.0032199581619352102, -0.016925638541579247, 0.04733064025640488, 0.031974077224731445, 0.019201558083295822, -0.04449837654829025, -0.004051340743899345, -0.047109682112932205, 0.0016990900039672852, 0.018347643315792084, -0.06335044652223587, 0.036275118589401245, 0.014924009330570698, 0.04827537387609482, -0.07728257775306702, 0.02379346452653408, -0.007689189165830612, 0.05161432549357414, -0.047700848430395126, 0.02073068544268608, -0.033759016543626785, -0.010176978074014187, -0.014092257246375084, -0.05155361443758011, -0.008103222586214542, 0.026750650256872177, -0.013787738978862762, -0.0018541160970926285, -0.0014843675307929516, -0.06633850932121277, 0.016720125451683998, 0.016804207116365433, 0.036321934312582016, 0.053421009331941605, 0.00807477068156004, -0.007358152884989977, -0.03361134976148605, -0.03880899026989937, -0.02017514407634735, 0.00829352531582117, -0.009365338832139969, -0.02735506370663643, -0.039809778332710266, -0.006052081473171711, -0.029383137822151184, -0.0839831605553627, 0.08806909620761871, -0.000715888396371156, -0.0129474438726902, 0.013487709686160088, -0.06680730730295181, -0.025998065248131752, 0.007349156308919191, 0.002084787003695965, 0.03969181701540947, -0.010236200876533985, 0.0007714980165474117, 0.017527513206005096, -0.017174888402223587, -0.011877222917973995, 0.007330406457185745, 0.024982541799545288, 0.000530384888406843, -0.003840601770207286, -0.00962888728827238, 0.023359252139925957, -0.06832215189933777, 0.03136675804853439, 0.016662370413541794, -0.01457394752651453, 0.011432505212724209, 0.04048485681414604, -0.046696871519088745, 0.026715798303484917, 0.0027437680400907993, 0.02483018860220909, -0.07299183309078217, -0.00248066452331841, -0.004632887896150351, -0.016097541898489, -0.018161477521061897, -0.01880641095340252, 0.022010676562786102, -0.002385227708145976, -0.03853458911180496, -0.03801097348332405, -0.030370421707630157, 0.016520826146006584, -0.003742551663890481 ]
<p>Why is gravity such a weak force? </p> <p>It becomes strong for particles only at the Planck scale, around $10^{19}$ $\text{GeV}$, much above the electroweak scale ($100$ $\text{GeV}$, the energy scale dominating physics at low energies). </p> <p>Why are these scales so different from each other? What prevents quantities at the electroweak scale, such as the Higgs boson mass, from getting quantum corrections on the order of the Planck scale? </p> <p>Is the solution super symmetry, extra dimensions, or just anthropic fine-tuning?</p> <p>Can we relate few problems of quantum mechanics with gravity ?</p> <p>Despite the fact that there is no experimental evidence that conflicts with the predictions of general relativity, physicists have found compelling reasons to suspect that general relativity may be only a good approximation to a more fundamental theory of gravity. The central issue is reconciling general relativity with the demands of quantum mechanics. Well tested by experiment, quantum mechanics is the theory that describes the microscopic behavior of particles. In the quantum world, particles are also waves, the results of measurements are probabilistic in nature, and an uncertainty principle forbids knowing certain pairs of measurable quantities, such as position and momentum, to arbitrary precision. The Standard Model is the unified picture of the strong, weak, and electromagnetic forces within the framework of quantum mechanics. Nonetheless, theoretical physicists have found it to be extremely difficult to construct a theory of quantum gravity that incorporates both general relativity and quantum mechanics.</p> <p>At the atomic scale, gravity is some $40$ orders of magnitude weaker than the other forces in nature. In both general relativity and Newtonian gravity, the strength of gravity grows at shorter and shorter distances, while quantum effects prevent the other forces from similarly increasing in strength. At a distance of approximately $10^{-35}$ $\text{m}$, called the Planck length, gravity becomes as strong as the other forces. At the Planck length, gravity is so strong and spacetime is so highly distorted that our common notions of space and time lose meaning. Quantum fluctuations at this length scale produce energies so large that microscopic black holes would pop into and out of existence. A theory of quantum gravity is needed to provide a description of nature at the Planck length. Yet, attempts by researchers to construct such a theory, analogous to the Standard Model of particle physics, have lead to serious inconsistencies.</p>
g4218
[ 0.04079651087522507, 0.07175127416849136, -0.012022541835904121, -0.022844549268484116, 0.04016273468732834, 0.08321873843669891, -0.02226722426712513, -0.006293423008173704, -0.07459432631731033, -0.050144925713539124, 0.054153893142938614, -0.054446667432785034, -0.03703281655907631, 0.04217810928821564, -0.02965063974261284, 0.0400223471224308, 0.057942453771829605, 0.002551496494561434, 0.0491502583026886, 0.015785593539476395, 0.027604032307863235, -0.035079773515462875, -0.015519419685006142, -0.05287089943885803, -0.03134596720337868, -0.014711824245750904, 0.036613281816244125, -0.02822471223771572, -0.041364748030900955, 0.025837335735559464, -0.008368291892111301, 0.027507351711392403, 0.055793337523937225, -0.04065824672579765, 0.03360997140407562, -0.035784680396318436, 0.03973177820444107, 0.04254838824272156, 0.013166658580303192, -0.014974134042859077, -0.003133205696940422, -0.05844772234559059, 0.014617659151554108, -0.025507720187306404, 0.027050651609897614, 0.00315099093131721, 0.014439134858548641, -0.010664405301213264, 0.04472867399454117, -0.04125193506479263, -0.0007909946725703776, 0.05603904277086258, 0.04581034556031227, 0.001994100399315357, 0.04525921493768692, 0.017172398045659065, 0.013096035458147526, 0.04494044929742813, 0.004807695746421814, -0.009306998923420906, 0.027301523834466934, 0.023292075842618942, 0.0123033057898283, 0.03779244050383568, 0.01719149574637413, 0.007590313907712698, -0.04020547494292259, -0.031435590237379074, -0.005437011830508709, -0.005463430657982826, -0.03310500085353851, -0.10963858664035797, -0.047110576182603836, 0.023419611155986786, -0.026177149266004562, 0.0004225651209708303, -0.013722850009799004, 0.07266589254140854, -0.02885742299258709, -0.027005720883607864, 0.005166659597307444, -0.015872472897171974, -0.032495565712451935, 0.0056177605874836445, 0.02543046697974205, -0.07714015245437622, -0.058296166360378265, 0.034159500151872635, 0.026705043390393257, 0.07494879513978958, -0.0071157910861074924, 0.0026091248728334904, 0.04761337861418724, 0.030553199350833893, -0.016425589099526405, -0.035126764327287674, 0.04442096874117851, 0.06098586693406105, -0.016924846917390823, 0.018933264538645744, -0.024983230978250504, 0.029971977695822716, -0.0441741943359375, 0.007497249636799097, 0.002938380930572748, -0.008077099919319153, 0.028842542320489883, 0.0893908366560936, 0.042113710194826126, 0.00297192158177495, -0.04389163479208946, 0.006471684668213129, -0.00473741814494133, -0.07145719230175018, -0.010387202724814415, -0.03847426176071167, 0.03073839657008648, -0.0143270967528224, 0.017854858189821243, -0.020800281316041946, 0.011313154362142086, -0.008474772796034813, 0.047846145927906036, 0.013477892614901066, -0.08852337300777435, -0.054901909083127975, -0.00854265782982111, 0.023646963760256767, -0.004697457421571016, -0.06243499368429184, 0.051922354847192764, 0.021862192079424858, -0.05688713118433952, 0.024730660021305084, -0.01842377334833145, 0.02555924467742443, 0.0003555347502697259, 0.0519854836165905, -0.010376009158790112, 0.025793541222810745, -0.09679470211267471, -0.038651883602142334, 0.039582617580890656, 0.03473962843418121, -0.005328644532710314, 0.035588618367910385, -0.01602124609053135, 0.04951385408639908, 0.006388227920979261, -0.03232337534427643, -0.0010100383078679442, 0.07561598718166351, -0.009469348005950451, -0.04015380144119263, -0.01565520651638508, 0.031660471111536026, 0.04239173233509064, 0.04855998978018761, -0.01298176497220993, -0.006108521018177271, 0.0408221073448658, 0.026559514924883842, -0.007507179398089647, 0.034200821071863174, -0.014847328886389732, 0.07207593321800232, 0.0008986162720248103, -0.03717194125056267, 0.010536781512200832, 0.012052923440933228, -0.10055111348628998, -0.009947925806045532, 0.017585843801498413, 0.00238900282420218, -0.03637830913066864, 0.0432661697268486, 0.01220537256449461, -0.030361857265233994, -0.02699042111635208, -0.044650398194789886, 0.015943363308906555, -0.044295862317085266, 0.021943334490060806, -0.002120280172675848, -0.04225531592965126, 0.02858778089284897, 0.04002276062965393, 0.011871236376464367, 0.05482782796025276, 0.004776578396558762, -0.04920155927538872, 0.0011455562198534608, -0.011184947565197945, 0.03393029421567917, 0.01581723988056183, 0.03401438891887665, 0.0076119969598948956, -0.0704846903681755, -0.05344561114907265, -0.018187731504440308, -0.06578043103218079, 0.05349168926477432, 0.001667967066168785, 0.003413222264498472, 0.04693492874503136, 0.009936060756444931, -0.04371197149157524, 0.019217168912291527, 0.025310678407549858, 0.01306822244077921, 0.03952665627002716, 0.0009927507489919662, 0.0063215033151209354, 0.01945934258401394, -0.027819927781820297, -0.0012448843335732818, 0.0015923625323921442, 0.018497927114367485, -0.020992083474993706, 0.046965863555669785, -0.023268243297934532, -0.020509153604507446, 0.020471299067139626, -0.0028178782667964697, -0.03744456171989441, -0.02463030070066452, -0.0762096717953682, -0.04509992152452469, -0.015080071054399014, 0.031112218275666237, -0.010460016317665577, 0.045710813254117966, 0.0011406635167077184, 0.0437169224023819, -0.011175152845680714, 0.025995658710598946, 0.03095136024057865, -0.032491832971572876, 0.011495601385831833, 0.01584714464843273, 0.004388545174151659, -0.015248343348503113, -0.026204338297247887, -0.04391416534781456, 0.02483990043401718, -0.008763276040554047, 0.01082014013081789, -0.02709973230957985, -0.033106300979852676, -0.004485820420086384, 0.03043515235185623, -0.016964776441454887, -0.011463988572359085, -0.01981866918504238, -0.0008228295482695103, -0.006793132517486811, 0.059364598244428635, 0.047049250453710556, -0.07714208960533142, -0.035441551357507706, -0.0067986976355314255, 0.03095141425728798, -0.013221336528658867, 0.06009041517972946, -0.01581938937306404, -0.02333550713956356, -0.057653456926345825, 0.07011648267507553, -0.04562654346227646, -0.013453027233481407, 0.0017232790123671293, -0.002110030734911561, -0.008259518072009087, -0.016985343769192696, 0.01670186221599579, -0.005961074028164148, -0.02396560087800026, -0.016717663034796715, 0.08506672829389572, 0.02421482466161251, -0.08501958101987839, 0.009838041849434376, -0.057709697633981705, -0.04430364444851875, 0.07494406402111053, -0.0361442044377327, -0.021754847839474678, -0.05946839973330498, 0.005143837537616491, 0.010351463221013546, -0.01609492488205433, 0.07748115062713623, 0.036468397825956345, 0.02249136194586754, -0.018702849745750427, 0.010214881040155888, -0.025523357093334198, -0.012611002661287785, -0.09829124063253403, -0.043611884117126465, -0.00031258052331395447, -0.002196342684328556, 0.024303313344717026, 0.0579729862511158, -0.0068468861281871796, -0.0028063009958714247, 0.03293606638908386, 0.005933628883212805, -0.042962446808815, 0.01855706237256527, -0.016224542632699013, 0.08035431057214737, 0.03787093237042427, 0.019757328554987907, -0.05747894197702408, -0.03617439791560173, -0.01657831482589245, 0.04384976997971535, -0.03475433588027954, -0.08207244426012039, 0.04705352708697319, -0.04472944140434265, -0.019982343539595604, -0.051571182906627655, 0.0222502239048481, 0.03253655508160591, -0.026122353971004486, -0.030681010335683823, -0.023357948288321495, 0.05993879213929176, 0.008732777088880539, 0.004019537940621376, 0.012932250276207924, 0.06652797013521194, -0.01786275953054428, -0.005678374785929918, 0.03558431938290596, -0.06180032342672348, 0.048150740563869476, -0.006796431262046099, -0.007709831465035677, 0.0039381771348416805, -0.07917928695678711, 0.032694198191165924, -0.008839822374284267, 0.06356356292963028, 0.005094288382679224, -0.02931906469166279, 0.011349675245583057, 0.0025158117059618235, -0.04545742645859718, 0.01557498425245285, 0.06383976340293884, -0.022805286571383476, -0.002513542305678129, -0.022324834018945694, 0.03241579607129097, 0.008709331974387169, 0.028950076550245285, -0.017874576151371002, 0.028831148520112038, 0.015381639823317528, 0.011005106382071972, 0.03259561210870743, -0.05736454203724861, 0.014114237390458584, 0.02739071659743786, -0.032715972512960434, 0.03341735526919365, -0.04198427498340607, 0.025149788707494736, -0.006941058672964573, 0.026020195335149765, -0.014532078988850117, 0.03209637850522995, -0.045594051480293274, 0.09337390959262848, -0.009148254059255123, 0.005946693010628223, -0.027365898713469505, 0.04394366592168808, 0.061618685722351074, -0.03999600186944008, -0.009851273149251938, 0.031978849321603775, -0.043620090931653976, -0.09708800911903381, -0.05037257820367813, 0.010161326266825199, 0.012047452852129936, -0.10197486728429794, -0.0481763556599617, -0.044191453605890274, 0.026125043630599976, -0.002425062470138073, -0.015925636515021324, 0.06021652743220329, 0.017938975244760513, 0.026182785630226135, -0.027507413178682327, -0.016154948621988297, -0.0009155425359494984, -0.013832288794219494, 0.00962209701538086, -0.021319029852747917, -0.0036330840084701777, 0.025692975148558617, -0.0008379119681194425, -0.06367623805999756, -0.0035376623272895813, 0.0674828439950943, 0.06125975400209427, 0.027564290910959244, -0.09156514704227448, -0.013983405195176601, -0.046933501958847046, 0.0019659821409732103, -0.009702553041279316, 0.05883259326219559, -0.0014350820565596223, 0.0468708798289299, 0.07015020400285721, 0.03141843527555466, -0.00575344730168581, -0.03051592782139778, 0.08862202614545822, -0.021046683192253113, 0.06515855342149734, -0.013069924898445606, 0.008027072995901108, 0.01960654743015766, 0.03146545588970184, -0.03486588969826698, -0.003627500729635358, -0.02047843299806118, 0.0522506982088089, -0.0026517051737755537, -0.012761542573571205, -0.002202579053118825, 0.061372652649879456, 0.07899478822946548, 0.06531238555908203, 0.02810564823448658, 0.001665616757236421, 0.0472932904958725, 0.03622063249349594, -0.05169648304581642, -0.002670877380296588, -0.06663786619901657, 0.017668694257736206, -0.0050484295934438705, -0.018481718376278877, 0.005060630850493908, -0.026447026059031487, -0.013335507363080978, 0.03879544138908386, -0.025447268038988113, 0.043380334973335266, 0.026515595614910126, 0.0006237418274395168, -0.06357292085886002, -0.009116231463849545, -0.005637886933982372, 0.04654534161090851, 0.012789752334356308, -0.029493849724531174, -0.07294146716594696, -0.008785401470959187, -0.039376188069581985, -0.02832038514316082, 0.011187851428985596, -0.017058031633496284, 0.010811220854520798, -0.00434846943244338, 0.02716284990310669, 0.04543505609035492, -0.010260461829602718, -0.006636866368353367, -0.008740529417991638, -0.04975096881389618, -0.016567138954997063, -0.02462390810251236, 0.028232671320438385, 0.04325858876109123, -0.02068583108484745, -0.014731034636497498, -0.013984354212880135, 0.02267523482441902, -0.0249661635607481, -0.045931197702884674, -0.004122023470699787, 0.02407504804432392, 0.0496034249663353, 0.014581723138689995, -0.005695662926882505, 0.027587993070483208, -0.02827010490000248, -0.01527902577072382, 0.05033326521515846, -0.005852437578141689, 0.016906261444091797, 0.007801059167832136, -0.031454458832740784, -0.01601945422589779, 0.02031680941581726, 0.029061334207654, 0.0034129538107663393, 0.016339436173439026, -0.0008778526680544019, 0.03702263534069061, -0.06903323531150818, -0.0002505765005480498, -0.0007195190410129726, 0.004381824284791946, 0.012089427560567856, -0.04284434765577316, 0.047713954001665115, 0.029320158064365387, -0.038969673216342926, 0.0014444405678659678, 0.02204037271440029, -0.01607150211930275, 0.03200111538171768, -0.042280908674001694, 0.036778926849365234, 0.05355332791805267, -0.053616393357515335, -0.008999168872833252, 0.03905903920531273, -0.0010611590696498752, 0.04824211448431015, 0.007631113287061453, 0.040834687650203705, -0.02217024937272072, 0.027753174304962158, 0.047593336552381516, 0.060147933661937714, 0.014850602485239506, 0.006453257519751787, -0.03226849436759949, 0.01597745157778263, 0.010897805914282799, -0.020311107859015465, 0.0404583178460598, 0.029228299856185913, 0.0027038012631237507, -0.045540619641542435, 0.001933869905769825, 0.05864756554365158, -0.028633255511522293, -0.02277977392077446, 0.015289686620235443, -0.010352040641009808, 0.01685318537056446, -0.05423089489340782, 0.0006762557895854115, 0.015772975981235504, -0.055229030549526215, -0.02700040675699711, -0.0381445474922657, 0.03304101899266243, 0.00045007996959611773, -0.019830266013741493, -0.02159848064184189, 0.014173248782753944, -0.023375649005174637, -0.01980920322239399, -0.04415958374738693, 0.017660042271018028, 0.006536421366035938, -0.002164497273042798, 0.0837578997015953, -0.005268331151455641, 0.016864504665136337, -0.004522449802607298, -0.021548448130488396, -0.002039849990978837, -0.0245489664375782, -0.03934400528669357, -0.03941715508699417, -0.011602778919041157, 0.007379795890301466, -0.01930871233344078, -0.03563646972179413, -0.06630302220582962, -0.01044397708028555, -0.0347544401884079, 0.005883888807147741, 0.05549262464046478, -0.009463883005082607, 0.011569329537451267, -0.023653218522667885, -0.003348201746121049, -0.05287576839327812, -0.06097519025206566, -0.01956971362233162, 0.042995017021894455, -0.07614286243915558, -0.024237006902694702, -0.015881860628724098, 0.03622651472687721, 0.0371071957051754, -0.021092530339956284, 0.036505382508039474, 0.05811828374862671, 0.03453816473484039, -0.08910174667835236, 0.03381878510117531, 0.032068751752376556, 0.03086029924452305, 0.05548933893442154, 0.06308557838201523, -0.028640219941735268, -0.014932418242096901, -0.04665985703468323, -0.04250498116016388, 0.015069529414176941, -0.0059034391306340694, -0.054820358753204346, -0.027391070500016212, -0.01866217702627182, 0.014286930672824383, 0.02924000844359398, -0.033664535731077194, 0.047527458518743515, 0.027386674657464027, -0.0016406633658334613, 0.07436813414096832, 0.05281788855791092, 0.0007253478979691863, -0.0003330835606902838, 0.014343365095555782, 0.027973784133791924, 0.06676183640956879, -0.06345818936824799, 0.03037695214152336, -0.039913956075906754, -0.02340514585375786, -0.01374414935708046, 0.00922530796378851, -0.008138010278344154, -0.03780753165483475, 0.030563795939087868, -0.009068791754543781, -0.038685474544763565, 0.0026700166054069996, 0.07394278049468994, 0.06388868391513824, -0.020614484325051308, -0.00028122137882746756, -0.009935869835317135, -0.04030284658074379, -0.03564031422138214, -0.012139206752181053, -0.007320362608879805, 0.028065476566553116, -0.04612962529063225, 0.006752894259989262, 0.06776734441518784, -0.0671284943819046, 0.0015193171566352248, 0.019608313217759132, 0.04743622615933418, -0.01254136860370636, -0.043156836181879044, 0.08703639358282089, -0.00394156388938427, -0.08076799660921097, -0.053216639906167984, -0.015520825050771236, 0.05003863200545311, -0.08355404436588287, -0.021508021280169487, -0.020536767318844795, 0.015174775384366512, 0.00027174578281119466, -0.059543177485466, 0.02598048746585846, 0.0192304365336895, -0.029268791899085045, 0.005606556311249733, 0.029252760112285614, -0.01872454769909382, 0.00724394666031003, -0.007992456667125225, 0.022291481494903564, 0.019135335460305214, 0.016970552504062653, -0.02521822229027748, -0.006665632128715515, 0.005938820540904999, -0.02111653797328472, -0.05337926745414734, 0.035678282380104065, 0.014526240527629852, -0.018222440034151077, -0.00005715409861295484, -0.008976617828011513, 0.05355946347117424, -0.026804381981492043, 0.012307032011449337, -0.06921017915010452, -0.007420144509524107, -0.04493308067321777, 0.004956951830536127, 0.04277621582150459, 0.021930500864982605, -0.00955819059163332, -0.0628705769777298, -0.0524878054857254, -0.02506224252283573, 0.01477994117885828, 0.03921933099627495, 0.0035264031030237675, 0.015505884774029255, 0.02394765056669712, 0.020797865465283394, -0.01297182496637106, -0.028267644345760345, -0.045565467327833176, 0.046567585319280624, -0.054929979145526886, 0.020411057397723198, -0.06434926390647888, -0.04118679463863373, -0.0005000362289138138, 0.017772991210222244, -0.035710714757442474, -0.0030300470534712076, -0.004477581940591335, -0.05736011266708374, -0.00025772509980015457, -0.01531290728598833, -0.026184599846601486, -0.02536952868103981, 0.04686043784022331, 0.0028976588509976864, 0.025052350014448166, -0.052752409130334854, 0.0028528592083603144, -0.015206512063741684, -0.04708734527230263, -0.03227340057492256, 0.04195611923933029, -0.0022814334370195866, -0.042849428951740265, -0.027706963941454887, -0.010270187631249428, 0.02948504127562046, 0.040604930371046066, -0.017984770238399506, 0.025119014084339142, -0.011278681457042694, 0.0682666078209877, 0.003504733555018902, -0.04195133224129677, 0.0036408845335245132, 0.040832456201314926, 0.0019979928620159626, -0.03981010988354683, 0.011856415309011936, 0.01614162139594555, 0.03700099512934685, -0.0026686026249080896, -0.03735499829053879, 0.010659630410373211, 0.013533761724829674, 0.019832788035273552 ]
<blockquote> <p><strong>Possible Duplicate:</strong><br> <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/10670/what-nonlinear-deformations-will-a-fast-rotating-planet-exhibit">What nonlinear deformations will a fast rotating planet exhibit?</a> </p> </blockquote> <p>This is really a basic physics question that I wanted to check myself on because I'm not entirely sure of the correct answer. I asked a puzzler question on the last episode of <a href="http://podcast.sjrdesign.net/shownotes_008.php" rel="nofollow">my podcast about hollow Earth claims</a>. I asked people to imagine a sphere with a solid shell that was filled with a compressible material, and this was spun very rapidly. (1) Would a hollow form, and (2) what shape would that hollow take on if it did form?</p> <p>My thinking is that, yes, a hollow would form, but it would not be spherical as the hollow Earthers claim. It would be a biaxial ellipsoid with the short axis oriented along the poles and the long axes to the equator. This is because the centrifugal forces at the equator due to the spin would be <strong>much</strong> greater than at the poles, so there would be no "outward force" at the poles.</p> <p>Is this correct? If so, is that a good explanation for a lay audience? If not correct, then what is the solution (it's been a long time since I took classical mechanics)? Thanks!</p>
g129
[ 0.06044594943523407, 0.01916125789284706, 0.01728023961186409, 0.01205984503030777, 0.04914335161447525, 0.03484576940536499, 0.025570623576641083, -0.0314730629324913, -0.0087570920586586, -0.05713701248168945, 0.0009012266527861357, 0.005732337944209576, 0.0286822821944952, -0.03366473317146301, 0.003609593492001295, -0.006302043795585632, 0.04465794563293457, -0.011485601775348186, 0.03877689689397812, 0.0220320001244545, -0.02102634683251381, -0.005037751514464617, 0.01522030495107174, -0.024103565141558647, -0.044509612023830414, 0.06398773193359375, 0.011100412346422672, -0.0020802889484912157, 0.005550858564674854, -0.014061315916478634, 0.05761629343032837, 0.027949318289756775, 0.01986214518547058, -0.0367879681289196, -0.03006822243332863, 0.010765337385237217, 0.051595866680145264, 0.03687204048037529, 0.007234996184706688, 0.025039227679371834, -0.005028912797570229, -0.04541878402233124, 0.023499755188822746, 0.03021768480539322, 0.0028956399764865637, -0.003993134945631027, 0.0020062497351318598, 0.009477724321186543, -0.025247052311897278, -0.001993600744754076, -0.03738521412014961, -0.006550731603056192, 0.05959128588438034, -0.06732219457626343, 0.028353748843073845, 0.055925771594047546, 0.03890906274318695, 0.0009133610874414444, 0.01953309401869774, -0.01786273531615734, -0.07332228869199753, -0.01311424095183611, -0.0036464217118918896, -0.022498534992337227, 0.010584695264697075, 0.007942459546029568, -0.009852960705757141, 0.029251636937260628, 0.0349564291536808, -0.030910911038517952, 0.0140135008841753, -0.02925913780927658, -0.02959958091378212, -0.04118058830499649, -0.047169048339128494, 0.07413322478532791, 0.02818470634520054, -0.007027299143373966, 0.04425688087940216, -0.0012429201742634177, -0.02000666782259941, 0.014610306359827518, -0.007119313348084688, 0.0032112840563058853, 0.03094393014907837, -0.03567016124725342, 0.0028536419849842787, -0.019899694249033928, 0.03405934199690819, 0.020362192764878273, 0.025761106982827187, -0.02520928904414177, -0.008131921291351318, 0.031332068145275116, 0.0031489047687500715, -0.03727910667657852, -0.026208603754639626, 0.06533291190862656, -0.05314179137349129, 0.03906507417559624, -0.008679857477545738, -0.024535229429602623, -0.011596845462918282, -0.032929953187704086, -0.005629152990877628, -0.014607846736907959, -0.0032629319466650486, 0.010881115682423115, 0.001338648609817028, -0.05698014050722122, 0.014356938190758228, -0.022450493648648262, 0.014785182662308216, 0.017151063308119774, -0.033517733216285706, -0.04943445697426796, 0.03868400678038597, -0.036563701927661896, 0.09042470902204514, 0.12270708382129669, 0.02020799182355404, -0.003874720772728324, 0.014780551195144653, 0.07965628057718277, -0.009709577076137066, -0.0022467474918812513, -0.0047901286743581295, -0.009558606892824173, 0.01491480227559805, -0.04966818168759346, 0.0031715405639261007, 0.04086728021502495, 0.004940314218401909, 0.023867860436439514, 0.012236841022968292, 0.0030024952720850706, -0.07328030467033386, -0.029599707573652267, 0.0323181077837944, 0.0023965423461049795, 0.03681841120123863, -0.00311515131033957, 0.06330697238445282, -0.0038521469105035067, 0.02857379987835884, -0.0258027333766222, 0.045832689851522446, -0.027341313660144806, 0.11111219227313995, 0.05795818939805031, -0.051164813339710236, 0.061483316123485565, 0.04288225620985031, -0.0292673222720623, 0.020132966339588165, 0.06569275259971619, 0.05287661403417587, 0.0017239408334717155, 0.023209543898701668, 0.016191037371754646, 0.053126104176044464, -0.025015730410814285, -0.021556101739406586, 0.04792990908026695, -0.030301377177238464, 0.048768896609544754, -0.03204689919948578, -0.0452740378677845, -0.0006185923120938241, 0.012950999662280083, -0.07303131371736526, -0.020956309512257576, 0.04198254272341728, 0.11068133264780045, -0.02668965794146061, -0.013487721793353558, 0.0314578041434288, -0.053493522107601166, 0.02353784441947937, 0.03059161826968193, -0.014420789666473866, -0.025229264050722122, -0.012145720422267914, 0.03103840909898281, 0.006908650044351816, -0.03174462914466858, 0.07366258651018143, -0.005271079018712044, -0.03362680971622467, 0.010932083241641521, 0.010272136889398098, -0.07381384074687958, -0.017174851149320602, 0.01737145334482193, -0.02417926676571369, -0.024901919066905975, 0.043351802974939346, -0.026605306193232536, -0.03488617017865181, -0.004832581151276827, 0.037788454443216324, 0.02515922114253044, 0.06741420179605484, 0.005084018222987652, 0.015687568113207817, -0.0037519624456763268, 0.03365660831332207, -0.016098348423838615, 0.005932328291237354, 0.02125542238354683, 0.0704667791724205, 0.02217916212975979, -0.04089762270450592, 0.03569337725639343, -0.009839882142841816, 0.05063252151012421, -0.0056359306909143925, 0.05529388412833214, -0.048594046384096146, -0.020320652052760124, 0.03870449960231781, -0.041856907308101654, -0.010406266897916794, -0.037521086633205414, 0.023992065340280533, -0.05124838650226593, -0.02120211534202099, -0.00022569911379832774, 0.005278137046843767, 0.004242462106049061, -0.001250821747817099, -0.05464262142777443, 0.056047625839710236, -0.013052771799266338, 0.037532221525907516, 0.04903165623545647, -0.0358576737344265, -0.042205896228551865, -0.0226503424346447, -0.012580439448356628, 0.0003004737081937492, -0.050884876400232315, 0.0077227880246937275, -0.051783401519060135, 0.008871103636920452, -0.012576262466609478, 0.04089762270450592, -0.037730079144239426, 0.037444107234478, 0.04913027957081795, 0.04920236021280289, -0.04628932476043701, -0.05432169511914253, -0.03194912150502205, 0.03795323893427849, 0.010394511744379997, -0.026299193501472473, 0.08328095078468323, -0.0743592157959938, -0.09589185565710068, -0.007890285924077034, -0.05180947110056877, -0.02085464634001255, 0.026816437020897865, -0.07513338327407837, -0.051206089556217194, -0.05694013088941574, -0.062070559710264206, -0.002579726278781891, 0.015493713319301605, -0.06708664447069168, 0.058071065694093704, -0.019312970340251923, 0.06444457918405533, -0.024988597258925438, -0.022075824439525604, -0.05318218469619751, 0.025638781487941742, -0.026440205052495003, 0.03437146916985512, 0.005427330266684294, 0.02924373559653759, -0.020983900874853134, 0.007182854227721691, 0.004151848144829273, -0.03211532533168793, -0.041094161570072174, 0.02828567661345005, -0.05081981420516968, 0.026830660179257393, -0.03430039435625076, 0.039070602506399155, 0.04589840769767761, -0.000818191037978977, -0.013366579078137875, 0.08857934176921844, 0.061803460121154785, -0.038454484194517136, 0.002981283003464341, 0.0051887850277125835, 0.03183480352163315, -0.0011719887843355536, 0.015733487904071808, 0.06813482940196991, -0.011727985925972462, 0.015106934122741222, -0.03478193283081055, -0.048847828060388565, -0.04502889886498451, 0.012344596907496452, -0.04057317227125168, 0.037318844348192215, -0.00807169172912836, 0.041772693395614624, -0.05600030720233917, -0.02165304683148861, -0.05311783030629158, -0.0017468520672991872, 0.08946926146745682, -0.0018608442042022943, -0.09031607955694199, -0.048327937722206116, -0.003848401131108403, -0.01259935274720192, 0.004066847264766693, 0.002281986875459552, -0.034330788999795914, -0.03203608840703964, -0.011768306605517864, -0.05336006358265877, 0.0034765703603625298, -0.027708720415830612, -0.04782828688621521, -0.00784456729888916, -0.033296674489974976, 0.026522420346736908, 0.010136028751730919, -0.0012913498794659972, 0.01450342871248722, 0.04799586907029152, 0.003091412130743265, -0.02403804287314415, -0.04031161218881607, -0.07699073106050491, -0.001605506637133658, -0.008327681571245193, 0.0048219505697488785, -0.08600898087024689, -0.017957674339413643, 0.01785188913345337, 0.04275936260819435, -0.01568053849041462, 0.0050590261816978455, -0.04411940276622772, 0.06363747268915176, 0.008995979093015194, 0.05404788628220558, -0.021671894937753677, 0.04089614003896713, -0.024725819006562233, 0.014524664729833603, -0.04050653800368309, 0.03352478891611099, -0.025864101946353912, -0.03260952606797218, 0.01079593412578106, 0.03431455418467522, -0.03605516254901886, -0.01792353391647339, 0.023133965209126472, 0.017379986122250557, 0.0036862301640212536, -0.020393384620547295, 0.015107533894479275, 0.05003434419631958, -0.025298548862338066, 0.007379460614174604, -0.00145058985799551, -0.021615847945213318, -0.028531942516565323, 0.024210471659898758, -0.003547824453562498, 0.017556745558977127, 0.027578987181186676, -0.04026911407709122, 0.06526412069797516, 0.004736620932817459, -0.03869921714067459, -0.00682758679613471, -0.007343820761889219, -0.015253660269081593, -0.01800803281366825, -0.014535341411828995, -0.033019933849573135, -0.015077470801770687, -0.006597451865673065, -0.0023058298975229263, -0.056582026183605194, 0.001471846248023212, 0.01021503284573555, -0.023148411884903908, -0.0034420036245137453, -0.043761301785707474, -0.04683704674243927, -0.004282527603209019, -0.030140284448862076, -0.03399494290351868, -0.06364770978689194, -0.04418018460273743, -0.08317124843597412, 0.023969704285264015, 0.03690091520547867, -0.04554062336683273, -0.03624478355050087, 0.06361325830221176, -0.008465753868222237, 0.018762405961751938, 0.014353632926940918, -0.05565540865063667, -0.025355150923132896, -0.027480781078338623, 0.012839214876294136, 0.015494005754590034, 0.026911556720733643, 0.0026943536940962076, 0.006289522163569927, 0.028540410101413727, -0.015546782873570919, -0.05010812729597092, -0.025619853287935257, -0.007534501608461142, -0.0047181835398077965, 0.06063469871878624, 0.0038703647442162037, -0.02349499799311161, -0.005311052780598402, -0.02155635878443718, 0.01698150672018528, 0.018971363082528114, 0.00542254326865077, -0.040131669491529465, -0.006023019552230835, 0.08212867379188538, -0.04118615761399269, -0.04771927744150162, 0.05465874820947647, -0.059455446898937225, 0.02031770534813404, 0.024893810972571373, -0.01746593415737152, -0.026201317086815834, -0.04257362708449364, 0.035158269107341766, 0.009433740749955177, -0.020127298310399055, -0.01046860683709383, -0.01773136854171753, 0.025085819885134697, 0.023297898471355438, 0.014148031361401081, -0.01741967909038067, -0.01700696349143982, 0.010585911571979523, 0.014267473481595516, 0.01615774631500244, 0.011889861896634102, -0.017120562493801117, 0.004400149919092655, -0.00610122038051486, -0.031384535133838654, -0.04095670208334923, -0.014892307110130787, 0.009555745869874954, 0.01595241203904152, -0.020262738689780235, 0.09392821043729782, 0.04106394201517105, -0.07825972139835358, 0.024676868692040443, -0.03350767120718956, -0.023923760280013084, -0.025915754958987236, 0.033849965780973434, 0.003568702843040228, 0.00635976018384099, 0.02529164031147957, -0.03946489468216896, -0.027295013889670372, -0.0317559577524662, 0.04543198645114899, -0.01774078607559204, 0.019230669364333153, -0.044891443103551865, -0.0034550786949694157, -0.010436764918267727, -0.002334622200578451, 0.05332523211836815, -0.08677609264850616, -0.0731237381696701, 0.07085192948579788, -0.06749235838651657, 0.03900781273841858, -0.02085115760564804, 0.02758895419538021, 0.007756669539958239, 0.07501373440027237, 0.02545422501862049, -0.00238489406183362, 0.05986594408750534, 0.011776403523981571, -0.026936274021863937, -0.00048822950338944793, -0.02209974266588688, -0.01011689379811287, 0.04710875079035759, -0.015470949932932854, -0.02454962208867073, 0.02322332002222538, 0.006089775823056698, 0.04243467003107071, 0.031256429851055145, -0.004841601010411978, 0.015454426407814026, -0.026003874838352203, 0.01953062228858471, 0.009162608534097672, -0.03957206383347511, 0.026937788352370262, 0.010873268358409405, 0.0977780818939209, -0.009648541919887066, -0.02941160462796688, 0.063022680580616, -0.02934836596250534, 0.010207628831267357, 0.016918383538722992, 0.025274766609072685, 0.02810872346162796, 0.07810931652784348, -0.04666029289364815, -0.03380167856812477, 0.0005184544716030359, 0.019451657310128212, 0.014882409945130348, -0.04711572825908661, 0.000779172230977565, 0.06037623807787895, -0.006110077258199453, 0.08179806917905807, 0.03351134434342384, -0.06506248563528061, 0.030852727591991425, -0.07499655336141586, -0.01864900253713131, -0.031039433553814888, 0.04253567010164261, -0.01169680804014206, -0.016044866293668747, -0.0008387528941966593, -0.09131986647844315, -0.030092857778072357, -0.017882198095321655, 0.02029644511640072, 0.03988229110836983, -0.03888743743300438, -0.0004190059844404459, -0.013055388815701008, -0.019602136686444283, 0.11944735050201416, 0.02581954561173916, 0.0014973472571000457, 0.0017522209091112018, 0.05573747307062149, 0.04246319457888603, 0.06344539672136307, 0.009475533850491047, -0.014481804333627224, 0.019452128559350967, -0.011889852583408356, 0.02133207954466343, 0.012921616435050964, -0.016733016818761826, 0.0666743665933609, 0.03977112099528313, 0.05798851326107979, 0.06885223835706711, -0.02232036553323269, 0.023752275854349136, -0.03712248057126999, -0.049417462199926376, 0.025676637887954712, 0.016350865364074707, -0.023738021031022072, -0.01641833782196045, -0.01559816300868988, 0.038546886295080185, -0.01595156267285347, 0.030768493190407753, -0.02797003462910652, -0.03151755407452583, -0.03138565644621849, -0.005831119604408741, 0.05423419922590256, 0.026680249720811844, 0.010803449898958206, -0.040518730878829956, 0.0006966842920519412, 0.03466330096125603, 0.008473232388496399, -0.013372138142585754, -0.011836504563689232, 0.002159692347049713, 0.0518963448703289, -0.025273257866501808, -0.029528597369790077, -0.05708092078566551, -0.026396265253424644, -0.017463913187384605, 0.04462604969739914, -0.033438004553318024, 0.005427094642072916, 0.04625076428055763, -0.022658975794911385, -0.09398695081472397, -0.05663501098752022, 0.03421947732567787, -0.03082076460123062, 0.009715711697936058, -0.003429118311032653, 0.025956572964787483, 0.016967058181762695, 0.016363583505153656, -0.02483181841671467, 0.023863645270466805, 0.023235589265823364, 0.033540643751621246, -0.041902948170900345, 0.04395198076963425, 0.06492797285318375, 0.019353367388248444, 0.03549770638346672, 0.0025353943929076195, 0.020115727558732033, 0.023016229271888733, -0.0906984880566597, 0.0056388769298791885, 0.00639629689976573, -0.002503414871171117, 0.00207078130915761, -0.00753483921289444, -0.009453874081373215, -0.06420402973890305, -0.019969388842582703, -0.005740332417190075, 0.020856760442256927, -0.01610582321882248, 0.014351291581988335, 0.01414073258638382, 0.023508958518505096, -0.02178831398487091, -0.03759395331144333, -0.013631803914904594, 0.0016435915604233742, -0.04163782671093941, -0.040023308247327805, 0.005511885974556208, -0.029959026724100113, -0.007906898856163025, -0.04054863378405571, 0.03281569480895996, 0.02889217808842659, 0.0038498740177601576, -0.03781421110033989, -0.010487077757716179, 0.025160061195492744, 0.0039222752675414085, -0.01219263393431902, -0.0636192113161087, 0.04762677848339081, 0.0019281209679320455, 0.020044555887579918, 0.05205943435430527, 0.010553804226219654, 0.04158414527773857, -0.0647624284029007, -0.0010204649297520518, -0.021749932318925858, 0.05759744346141815, -0.02157687395811081, -0.013465146534144878, 0.03546828776597977, 0.07889316976070404, -0.05265286937355995, 0.034399718046188354, -0.04876245558261871, -0.012939391657710075, 0.032235000282526016, 0.01599171943962574, -0.010016265325248241, -0.0559612438082695, -0.012181172147393227, 0.030927427113056183, -0.07602138817310333, 0.02307426929473877, 0.07652585208415985, 0.02322367951273918, 0.02209318056702614, 0.003865382168442011, -0.04310709610581398, 0.01602499559521675, 0.06884048134088516, -0.016090650111436844, 0.02455116994678974, -0.047667745500802994, 0.038908958435058594, 0.00044440687634050846, 0.013605115935206413, -0.00275550689548254, 0.026904456317424774, -0.015530992299318314, -0.08346273750066757, 0.051932211965322495, -0.016797354444861412, -0.026961494237184525, -0.01850195974111557, -0.038828156888484955, -0.005076708737760782, -0.005479880608618259, -0.03157508745789528, 0.0008535920060239732, -0.005644566845148802, -0.0003704671107698232, -0.006043925881385803, 0.0512474961578846, 0.0038513399194926023, -0.03259573131799698, -0.048186223953962326, -0.024921979755163193, -0.03182946890592575, -0.029826264828443527, -0.009955612011253834, -0.023229386657476425, 0.025940822437405586, -0.030391724780201912, 0.013360962271690369, 0.017973560839891434, -0.01674884371459484, 0.10091520100831985, 0.043921757489442825, 0.00010300445137545466, -0.028004730120301247, -0.025177590548992157, 0.018854279071092606, -0.005541159771382809, -0.017283650115132332, -0.04670868441462517, -0.02367350645363331, -0.0023251401726156473, -0.01368153840303421, -0.04226911440491676, 0.006617014296352863, -0.016378948464989662, 0.05465651676058769, -0.008151596412062645, 0.023562056943774223, -0.027696406468749046, -0.0016720768762752414, 0.05100807920098305 ]
<p>I am studying scattering theory right now in my QM class, and I'm attempting the Griffiths problem 11.4 as an exercise (it's not for homework). The problem is: Consider the case of low-energy scattering from a spherical delta-function shell: $V(r) = \alpha \delta(r-a)$. Calculate the scattering amplitude $f(\theta)$, the differential cross-section, and the total cross-section. </p> <p>He outlines the following method in the section: in the exterior region where $V(r) = 0$, you get an expression for the wavefunction in terms of some complicated Hankel function expression $$ \psi(r,\theta) = A \sum i^l (2l+1)[j_l(kr) + ika_lh_l^{(1)}(kr) ] P_l(cos \theta). $$ You then match boundary conditions with the explicit solution to the wavefunction inside the region where $V(r) \neq 0$. </p> <p>I'm confused how to carry this out. It seems that the solution of the wavefunction inside the region $r&lt;a$ is your typical plane wave $f(r) = \sin(kr)/r$. Then I'm thinking that you should match $f(a) = \psi(a)$ and $\psi&#39;(a)-f&#39;(a) = - \frac{2m\alpha}{\hbar}^2 f(a)$. However, this doesn't appear to give me the right answer.. </p> <p>So is this the correct approach (if not, how do you go about these kinds of problems)? </p>
g4219
[ 0.0428466722369194, -0.03917388990521431, -0.00012116776633774862, -0.029801184311509132, 0.019533248618245125, -0.0008742801728658378, 0.025837304070591927, -0.03772445023059845, -0.05607292056083679, -0.041686590760946274, 0.02286137454211712, -0.010141436010599136, 0.05984831228852272, -0.0031569856218993664, 0.018525701016187668, -0.0345299206674099, 0.01413155347108841, 0.008421785198152065, -0.011993804015219212, -0.0029781933408230543, -0.03363291546702385, 0.025793753564357758, 0.018259268254041672, -0.04438569396734238, 0.04883258044719696, -0.0009726629359647632, -0.02990635856986046, 0.044529471546411514, -0.031815022230148315, -0.00458012567833066, -0.0053577483631670475, 0.01785667985677719, 0.0411636047065258, -0.05612365901470184, -0.049784936010837555, 0.05963311716914177, 0.008226389065384865, 0.02319929376244545, -0.02694697678089142, -0.01859598234295845, 0.0009597356547601521, -0.06877817958593369, 0.030312631279230118, 0.026243913918733597, 0.037729404866695404, 0.013526956550776958, -0.012064963579177856, -0.0056840889155864716, -0.03293241560459137, -0.006071904208511114, -0.018216820433735847, -0.0013575966004282236, 0.06295111030340195, -0.04479505494236946, -0.01070014014840126, 0.0389833077788353, 0.048627253621816635, -0.005793242249637842, 0.009385763667523861, 0.01982813887298107, 0.012958901934325695, 0.03227441757917404, -0.009714663028717041, -0.03805997967720032, 0.053630609065294266, -0.056429196149110794, -0.02793845161795616, 0.00518970238044858, -0.050183627754449844, -0.041579388082027435, 0.039572663605213165, -0.05649373307824135, -0.00456371670588851, -0.017831265926361084, -0.03077419474720955, -0.017895670607686043, -0.00855708122253418, 0.021110760048031807, 0.06655173748731613, 0.009772781282663345, -0.04029490798711777, -0.027949105948209763, 0.027739351615309715, -0.0038823739159852266, -0.008369741030037403, 0.02445235475897789, 0.010868702083826065, -0.03271009027957916, 0.010710729286074638, 0.015067278407514095, 0.01279656682163477, -0.023492304608225822, 0.03886594623327255, -0.01418786309659481, -0.013516618870198727, 0.017895903438329697, -0.007905814796686172, 0.051421333104372025, -0.025707729160785675, -0.029273303225636482, 0.038363464176654816, 0.01645590364933014, -0.005378947127610445, 0.03288528695702553, -0.03373723849654198, 0.01854957453906536, 0.040172405540943146, 0.0068876673467457294, 0.0042884754948318005, -0.007054230198264122, -0.008541861549019814, -0.00003080941314692609, 0.0005349196726456285, -0.05139031261205673, -0.020962540060281754, -0.02456807717680931, 0.02132674679160118, 0.0023357186000794172, 0.03652673959732056, 0.07828640937805176, 0.02469814568758011, 0.026656467467546463, 0.06624115258455276, 0.01518119778484106, 0.032317761331796646, -0.01940368302166462, -0.03040514886379242, -0.007005911786109209, 0.0864301472902298, -0.02693956159055233, -0.002139004413038492, 0.008113518357276917, 0.012508968822658062, 0.0041604419238865376, 0.06100877746939659, -0.033420491963624954, 0.025268051773309708, -0.01441866997629404, -0.0035373808350414038, -0.013382977806031704, 0.007910682819783688, -0.04134966805577278, -0.011243411339819431, 0.02709200233221054, 0.002382015809416771, 0.020672837272286415, -0.00289572193287313, -0.06458783894777298, -0.014060823246836662, -0.04620351269841194, 0.011344950646162033, 0.07438143342733383, 0.043389156460762024, 0.00881308875977993, 0.030190763995051384, 0.0005543443257920444, 0.024270694702863693, -0.03401070833206177, 0.03271501883864403, -0.026282742619514465, 0.03855007886886597, 0.02682432532310486, 0.01986405998468399, 0.0005590259679593146, -0.03525419533252716, 0.029228145256638527, -0.03388052433729172, 0.022529227659106255, -0.023211084306240082, -0.07869141548871994, 0.021426046267151833, -0.014604590833187103, 0.044703662395477295, 0.01973508857190609, -0.0042949640192091465, 0.08148255199193954, -0.020768217742443085, -0.011899999342858791, -0.029819972813129425, 0.008118899539113045, 0.024350333958864212, -0.015489382669329643, 0.00986339058727026, -0.020762387663125992, 0.04531096667051315, -0.012235025875270367, 0.029459036886692047, -0.013298668898642063, -0.039050690829753876, 0.026793107390403748, 0.030293548479676247, 0.01214466243982315, -0.004929966758936644, -0.008895544335246086, 0.01131897047162056, 0.09047283232212067, 0.061271753162145615, -0.08380866795778275, -0.04930642619729042, 0.052099719643592834, 0.033712346106767654, 0.0997556522488594, 0.09056679159402847, 0.032407548278570175, 0.04380165785551071, 0.020448310300707817, 0.008763271383941174, -0.02109582908451557, 0.003063748124986887, -0.00009842596045928076, -0.013742748647928238, -0.05683862790465355, 0.02055036835372448, 0.006403295788913965, -0.003521375125274062, 0.008649230934679508, 0.031707365065813065, 0.00210228911601007, -0.009417255409061909, 0.021508196368813515, -0.06747252494096756, 0.037728678435087204, -0.010124566964805126, -0.04407044127583504, 0.03731945529580116, 0.033442173153162, 0.0320618636906147, 0.02688758447766304, -0.04635969176888466, -0.001062978757545352, -0.037344370037317276, -0.010085212998092175, -0.019825678318738937, -0.05220387503504753, -0.011871281079947948, -0.011633781716227531, -0.0026413409505039454, 0.008507703430950642, 0.006942617706954479, 0.037451282143592834, -0.024873023852705956, -0.0037163556553423405, -0.018738489598035812, 0.0218429546803236, 0.008548260666429996, 0.038534488528966904, 0.020310621708631516, 0.01579972170293331, -0.013736200518906116, -0.0091561209410429, 0.03048153966665268, 0.00268752034753561, -0.004371529445052147, 0.007940907962620258, -0.03626753389835358, -0.050227195024490356, -0.07765834033489227, 0.020334431901574135, 0.054414406418800354, -0.00658796401694417, 0.009479016065597534, 0.022708039730787277, 0.03121601603925228, 0.031138647347688675, -0.04820649325847626, -0.00811106339097023, -0.0012097347062081099, 0.06522613018751144, 0.001868994440883398, -0.010083481669425964, -0.01949315518140793, 0.08221297711133957, 0.02724441885948181, 0.022315561771392822, -0.010905024595558643, -0.055974081158638, -0.032349053770303726, -0.02345891110599041, 0.03480139002203941, -0.01729445718228817, 0.0021669198758900166, -0.03799851983785629, 0.01805640012025833, 0.017650963738560677, 0.019265566021203995, -0.07555746287107468, 0.07809479534626007, 0.06473706662654877, 0.027769654989242554, -0.016842052340507507, 0.02273310162127018, 0.025671882554888725, -0.01754900813102722, 0.011260278522968292, -0.005319150164723396, 0.02876502089202404, 0.05301203578710556, -0.033121488988399506, 0.023855028674006462, 0.024463318288326263, -0.02098129317164421, -0.010138936340808868, -0.051599401980638504, -0.00353789865039289, 0.04199431836605072, -0.03400561213493347, -0.038989387452602386, -0.02774069830775261, -0.019797641783952713, 0.04649309813976288, -0.002096079057082534, -0.007135372143238783, 0.004657034762203693, -0.011564861051738262, -0.0012624175287783146, 0.009159249253571033, -0.018851470202207565, -0.03295900300145149, 0.009851072914898396, 0.027497103437781334, -0.01115597877651453, -0.016642091795802116, 0.02105785720050335, 0.02071705274283886, -0.049997806549072266, 0.03705233335494995, -0.07401655614376068, -0.01345808431506157, -0.021670902147889137, -0.04778638482093811, -0.0016998191131278872, 0.004545954056084156, 0.027391968294978142, -0.03111114725470543, 0.0274482611566782, -0.04841529205441475, -0.05370906740427017, 0.02981891669332981, 0.048079442232847214, 0.044011440128088, 0.029420388862490654, -0.06130417063832283, 0.011727191507816315, 0.015087886713445187, 0.021014440804719925, -0.008181087672710419, -0.01749524474143982, 0.07898185402154922, -0.012966499663889408, 0.003242160426452756, -0.036283206194639206, 0.017423221841454506, 0.00023155671078711748, 0.024052264168858528, -0.008004947565495968, 0.003637316869571805, 0.003676954424008727, 0.016216708347201347, 0.027938542887568474, -0.010455459356307983, 0.039292916655540466, 0.000716312148142606, 0.006015671417117119, -0.050845760852098465, 0.01373505499213934, -0.03273361921310425, 0.05770549550652504, 0.03435885161161423, -0.02516469731926918, -0.03176788613200188, 0.013854469172656536, 0.001997151179239154, 0.012986889109015465, 0.008555727079510689, 0.010175182484090328, -0.05982432886958122, -0.055415939539670944, -0.004689852241426706, -0.014493195340037346, 0.04440831393003464, -0.05586560070514679, 0.010032203048467636, -0.048465777188539505, 0.048140086233615875, 0.04029352217912674, 0.028152041137218475, -0.05361819639801979, 0.003764904337003827, 0.013593263924121857, -0.017678413540124893, 0.056276336312294006, -0.07486500591039658, -0.051916223019361496, 0.027962591499090195, -0.007240100763738155, -0.02906588837504387, 0.013063054531812668, -0.01760626956820488, -0.08290991187095642, 0.023526020348072052, -0.029342472553253174, 0.0014193124370649457, 0.014442740008234978, -0.02018888108432293, -0.02513933554291725, -0.03088909201323986, -0.0030484222806990147, -0.04884513095021248, -0.025856681168079376, 0.019276658073067665, 0.030336732044816017, -0.028308263048529625, -0.009805158711969852, -0.062034618109464645, 0.0011899792589247227, -0.06092866510152817, 0.041773341596126556, 0.009004378691315651, -0.02810140885412693, 0.00031339796259999275, -0.06110037863254547, -0.010811164043843746, -0.005841908045113087, -0.00847832951694727, 0.04283779859542847, -0.011834319680929184, 0.05156354978680611, 0.042988844215869904, 0.01579832285642624, -0.06802235543727875, -0.03718603774905205, 0.010251450352370739, -0.002969450317323208, 0.06514015048742294, -0.08885442465543747, 0.03342118114233017, -0.08890549838542938, -0.016122108325362206, -0.005269985646009445, -0.015634743496775627, 0.05426589399576187, 0.02106890082359314, -0.04864354059100151, 0.01201795507222414, -0.005666643381118774, 0.029769238084554672, -0.04557022079825401, -0.09447421878576279, 0.03937572240829468, -0.03853161633014679, -0.03371623158454895, -0.03303493931889534, 0.020541232079267502, -0.0442255400121212, -0.007429611403495073, 0.01774079166352749, 0.00975890550762415, 0.033346351236104965, -0.014809830114245415, 0.00042766996193677187, -0.020158272236585617, 0.00750425411388278, -0.011923953890800476, -0.0240493081510067, 0.059456560760736465, -0.0021967035718262196, -0.011859297752380371, 0.01767369918525219, -0.023790569975972176, -0.03594973310828209, 0.011195068247616291, 0.004624014254659414, 0.07089566439390182, -0.06870639324188232, -0.038182005286216736, 0.024492297321558, -0.032433271408081055, -0.009833330288529396, -0.03239677473902702, -0.003833743976429105, 0.012045862153172493, -0.015802396461367607, 0.0011713181156665087, 0.03462225943803787, -0.04361087456345558, 0.03042007051408291, 0.03340613469481468, -0.041175633668899536, 0.013705558143556118, 0.030927788466215134, 0.03393663465976715, -0.015759866684675217, -0.05841992050409317, -0.005254614166915417, 0.03018016181886196, -0.034876756370067596, 0.0684008076786995, -0.06515764445066452, -0.0076128034852445126, 0.040280792862176895, -0.05568188056349754, 0.017452429980039597, -0.02090979926288128, 0.040471699088811874, -0.004248322453349829, 0.05941053852438927, 0.05587608739733696, 0.016428155824542046, 0.06645357608795166, 0.018470127135515213, 0.00804385170340538, -0.024177905172109604, 0.030071942135691643, -0.0005965633899904788, -0.03358027711510658, -0.04370696097612381, -0.03581232205033302, 0.053236037492752075, -0.10868483036756516, 0.021354638040065765, 0.07033136487007141, 0.02340671233832836, -0.07815685123205185, -0.012880192138254642, 0.008010976016521454, 0.0038037269841879606, -0.00900843646377325, -0.061523839831352234, -0.07669297605752945, 0.02856310084462166, -0.019127752631902695, -0.013426563702523708, -0.05820821225643158, 0.037796273827552795, 0.03226979076862335, -0.0350932851433754, -0.03211487457156181, -0.0009783273562788963, 0.03461696580052376, -0.026128336787223816, -0.008116207085549831, 0.0016079393681138754, 0.06268537789583206, -0.0003735734208021313, -0.096338652074337, -0.03182581439614296, 0.03170579671859741, 0.0016584331169724464, -0.028972001746296883, 0.03057999163866043, -0.06188127025961876, -0.05429058521986008, -0.060595665127038956, 0.010222110897302628, 0.03709728270769119, -0.013577100820839405, 0.009753050282597542, -0.07112517952919006, -0.029699549078941345, 0.02985270321369171, 0.01698598451912403, -0.053230587393045425, -0.017108770087361336, 0.005728879477828741, -0.0037665923591703176, -0.01482407283037901, -0.03687426447868347, -0.01243630051612854, 0.03881773725152016, -0.04526872932910919, -0.07637115567922592, -0.030111460015177727, 0.030953019857406616, -0.027122078463435173, 0.01464774925261736, 0.013026813976466656, -0.03131331875920296, -0.008853106759488583, -0.027914106845855713, 0.058635830879211426, -0.010038232430815697, 0.007654682267457247, 0.032972875982522964, -0.06684901565313339, -0.015304154716432095, 0.044168416410684586, 0.0024298226926475763, -0.08540396392345428, 0.0529157854616642, -0.02196311205625534, -0.033541593700647354, -0.0146511634811759, 0.005588544066995382, 0.048712193965911865, 0.049382757395505905, -0.0021975452546030283, 0.029151471331715584, 0.06526131182909012, -0.052323196083307266, -0.019418610259890556, 0.0436493381857872, -0.041784562170505524, 0.06702065467834473, -0.01547462958842516, 0.04721624031662941, 0.02927267551422119, -0.010390069335699081, -0.014897603541612625, -0.0003028831852134317, 0.05994638055562973, 0.03471224755048752, 0.04248395189642906, 0.052332084625959396, 0.027332404628396034, 0.007470550015568733, -0.06635434925556183, -0.04025733098387718, 0.023956870660185814, 0.04278988391160965, 0.014014657586812973, 0.0940215215086937, 0.010498948395252228, -0.03811144083738327, -0.04743940755724907, 0.06883593648672104, 0.007098004221916199, -0.043295443058013916, -0.022034592926502228, 0.022605031728744507, -0.0004861315537709743, 0.03421083465218544, -0.009932262822985649, -0.05714353173971176, 0.0022878306917846203, -0.08880284428596497, 0.014483352191746235, 0.04224640503525734, 0.025989824905991554, -0.028888359665870667, 0.048116475343704224, -0.014950747601687908, 0.05325298756361008, 0.06141810119152069, -0.038769807666540146, -0.0840357095003128, -0.026355676352977753, 0.042724769562482834, -0.013650988228619099, -0.1359875500202179, 0.08274703472852707, 0.08186252415180206, 0.003638364840298891, -0.013216380961239338, 0.009838911704719067, -0.01793150044977665, 0.014460224658250809, 0.027368072420358658, 0.007089152000844479, -0.014592386782169342, 0.01667586714029312, 0.0003811764472629875, -0.032780904322862625, -0.049534499645233154, -0.004740965086966753, 0.05219496786594391, 0.07653039693832397, 0.019760385155677795, -0.01730058528482914, 0.02111305668950081, -0.022444885224103928, 0.0073857721872627735, -0.016399020329117775, -0.0649912878870964, 0.006050001364201307, 0.03428368270397186, 0.015272301621735096, 0.05475176125764847, 0.025280820205807686, -0.029492033645510674, 0.002350475639104843, 0.04462743550539017, -0.020368484780192375, -0.026776930317282677, 0.04710596427321434, 0.015103364363312721, 0.0032465639524161816, 0.012135864235460758, -0.010767537169158459, 0.07221999019384384, 0.03214806318283081, -0.0020077659282833338, 0.03975886479020119, -0.021351534873247147, -0.026346752420067787, -0.044952087104320526, 0.024062132462859154, 0.03813460096716881, 0.016046645119786263, 0.00167413882445544, -0.005519063211977482, 0.011638478375971317, -0.005044379737228155, 0.044043637812137604, 0.0064070625230669975, -0.02681792341172695, -0.020797856152057648, -0.016209401190280914, -0.05322369933128357, 0.02238604985177517, 0.02520674839615822, 0.09097766876220703, 0.008650735020637512, 0.03267614170908928, 0.022886406630277634, 0.035104900598526, 0.03090292401611805, -0.030588295310735703, 0.011757752858102322, 0.024828119203448296, -0.035384565591812134, -0.023973600938916206, -0.018338043242692947, -0.01922605372965336, -0.019203919917345047, 0.043790727853775024, -0.034983426332473755, -0.06783232092857361, -0.009804308414459229, 0.005428744480013847, -0.011973941698670387, -0.05617654696106911, -0.014246249571442604, -0.04907946661114693, -0.003501224098727107, -0.004420667886734009, -0.0408749021589756, -0.019862113520503044, -0.11035321652889252, 0.03775174543261528, 0.025005003437399864, 0.035649772733449936, -0.02388203702867031, -0.006520995404571295, -0.018441686406731606, -0.011899520643055439, 0.006052943412214518, -0.021252617239952087, 0.023891795426607132, 0.09652884304523468, 0.04265739023685455, 0.01618100516498089, 0.010142030194401741, -0.0024261819198727608, 0.046525854617357254, -0.025136666372418404, -0.08551407605409622, 0.014761853031814098, 0.004615137819200754, -0.007279522251337767, 0.026409249752759933, 0.019264420494437218, -0.03174947202205658, 0.017953701317310333, 0.060492802411317825, 0.019027816131711006, -0.0767461359500885, -0.022082477807998657, -0.02065274864435196 ]
<p>Why galaxies move away from each other in general on the astronomical scale? Which answer is correct of the following?</p> <p>It is because of the big bang theory, everything is just moving away from everything else on the astronomical scale, because of the explosion that happened in the past, just by inertia.</p> <p>It is because space is being created all the time between galaxies, that is why they look receding from each other. Like drawing dots on a rubber sheet, then start stretching that rubber sheet. Dots are not moving, just more and more space is created between them.</p> <p>Which answer is the right one? and if the 2nd answer is the right one, is it only space that is being created or spacetime?</p>
g4220
[ 0.05153809115290642, 0.0033832851331681013, 0.01159754116088152, -0.03598548471927643, 0.048746053129434586, 0.06654182821512222, -0.0015400286065414548, -0.020635154098272324, -0.003305009100586176, -0.053779713809490204, 0.034783776849508286, 0.006504203658550978, 0.01628299616277218, 0.029562879353761673, 0.029697643592953682, 0.004271968733519316, 0.0035144800785928965, -0.0020219970028847456, -0.04557535797357559, 0.03357856720685959, -0.060472335666418076, -0.012261316180229187, 0.005755324847996235, -0.039718147367239, -0.026786617934703827, -0.010409058071672916, 0.019754955545067787, -0.011036652140319347, 0.011259292252361774, -0.006060205399990082, 0.03482194244861603, 0.0637676790356636, 0.0020970592740923166, -0.049493417143821716, 0.01968073658645153, -0.009413233958184719, -0.0003512229595798999, 0.019672203809022903, 0.005930029321461916, 0.0024184389039874077, -0.030104586854577065, -0.019174931570887566, 0.01395356934517622, -0.009699484333395958, 0.03635241463780403, 0.00756162079051137, -0.037740543484687805, 0.03982649743556976, 0.04911809787154198, -0.006623045541346073, -0.015998151153326035, 0.028751738369464874, 0.01026628352701664, -0.045853085815906525, -0.02109636180102825, 0.030625075101852417, 0.03496680036187172, -0.0450592115521431, 0.08931378275156021, -0.018054736778140068, -0.08263640850782394, 0.004534340929239988, 0.0401422493159771, -0.009707137010991573, 0.04585445299744606, -0.030285870656371117, -0.022796040400862694, 0.005556065589189529, 0.02927302196621895, -0.036371488124132156, 0.01597021520137787, -0.03387325629591942, -0.04155203700065613, -0.0056567927822470665, -0.10440409928560257, 0.0475996769964695, 0.020811112597584724, -0.043782442808151245, -0.020940037444233894, 0.011769630014896393, -0.03551753982901573, -0.027891546487808228, -0.013856055215001106, 0.019578468054533005, 0.06991276144981384, 0.016100522130727768, -0.0052717868238687515, -0.023444712162017822, -0.026088953018188477, 0.02162308804690838, 0.0004530231817625463, 0.004060492385178804, 0.054962143301963806, 0.00866790022701025, -0.010541503317654133, -0.02694181352853775, -0.04833389073610306, 0.09698798507452011, -0.031781308352947235, -0.013165661133825779, -0.05727791786193848, -0.037247657775878906, 0.025643205270171165, 0.017292605713009834, -0.006756200455129147, -0.04165124148130417, 0.022416140884160995, 0.01726708747446537, 0.02477974444627762, 0.010943731293082237, -0.042085036635398865, -0.04368363320827484, 0.030862651765346527, -0.008008806966245174, 0.007683886680752039, -0.0024328494910150766, 0.024937300011515617, 0.0004130162997171283, 0.06034158915281296, 0.026821834966540337, -0.013647950254380703, -0.020653806626796722, -0.013182982802391052, -0.0160287506878376, -0.019844943657517433, -0.03762449324131012, 0.028409259393811226, -0.0005696925218217075, 0.01780422404408455, 0.031663428992033005, 0.009360499680042267, 0.03992515057325363, -0.03741114214062691, 0.021576549857854843, 0.027963154017925262, -0.03513365983963013, -0.009063424542546272, -0.02336498722434044, -0.005250770598649979, -0.009431901387870312, 0.059421390295028687, -0.010213423520326614, 0.03495670109987259, -0.06033005937933922, -0.05505670607089996, 0.08537626266479492, 0.018108008429408073, 0.02293570525944233, 0.021331707015633583, -0.010232375003397465, -0.012603568844497204, 0.05291355773806572, -0.019874311983585358, -0.039305731654167175, 0.0028626101557165384, 0.006467435508966446, 0.02722158282995224, 0.04122031107544899, -0.0294125247746706, 0.0006990752299316227, 0.01619904115796089, -0.04084298759698868, -0.002433854155242443, -0.003787148045375943, 0.012109091505408287, 0.06693349778652191, -0.040416210889816284, -0.04346875846385956, -0.00010323927563149482, -0.0009137556771747768, -0.07167884707450867, -0.04283203184604645, -0.004156074952334166, 0.026643432676792145, 0.04012826085090637, 0.05629585683345795, 0.041346222162246704, -0.006426970474421978, -0.033569447696208954, -0.006119946017861366, 0.005541993770748377, -0.02139180898666382, 0.015027130953967571, 0.012222841382026672, 0.03727320581674576, -0.06433809548616409, -0.03340405970811844, -0.025161081925034523, -0.0383693091571331, 0.010474133305251598, 0.050163015723228455, -0.01698763482272625, -0.006584038957953453, 0.01148820761591196, 0.0071080029010772705, 0.006968152243643999, 0.03848816081881523, 0.02282189205288887, -0.0643676146864891, 0.03479614853858948, -0.033205389976501465, 0.028983205556869507, 0.002394109731540084, -0.0039190491661429405, 0.031743843108415604, -0.02767166495323181, -0.07974379509687424, -0.00864834152162075, 0.042462531477212906, -0.029189584776759148, -0.02547079510986805, 0.014147662557661533, -0.03271549567580223, -0.01941519044339657, -0.056361354887485504, -0.009793813340365887, 0.012050551362335682, -0.010800175368785858, -0.01868695579469204, 0.04939315840601921, 0.009960993193089962, -0.0007300337310880423, -0.012400626204907894, -0.057530175894498825, 0.03790193051099777, -0.0260913223028183, -0.03096991777420044, -0.024335695430636406, -0.0077917021699249744, 0.015420299954712391, -0.0427347794175148, -0.012141932733356953, 0.020266173407435417, -0.03399673104286194, 0.014861414209008217, 0.014254867099225521, 0.006665919441729784, 0.006549461279064417, -0.0027958303689956665, 0.03913497552275658, 0.057163432240486145, -0.029716171324253082, -0.021432437002658844, -0.047741491347551346, 0.052921537309885025, -0.07198824733495712, 0.07515609264373779, -0.03640328347682953, -0.028821313753724098, 0.023948324844241142, 0.04269976168870926, -0.015998177230358124, -0.032098188996315, -0.06859433650970459, 0.005075254011899233, -0.033837318420410156, 0.06446395814418793, 0.06707903742790222, -0.07495857775211334, -0.041980475187301636, -0.012916871346533298, -0.024901170283555984, 0.009273762814700603, -0.04141990840435028, -0.06610464304685593, -0.016433196142315865, -0.020315032452344894, 0.023513872176408768, -0.008901131339371204, -0.016851993277668953, 0.0035524661652743816, 0.03701401501893997, 0.020915351808071136, 0.060967568308115005, 0.00462113693356514, 0.05393367260694504, 0.05443842336535454, -0.01931159570813179, 0.0017586775356903672, 0.04561056196689606, -0.007316058035939932, 0.004668783862143755, -0.07881168276071548, -0.0318819135427475, 0.04351668059825897, -0.02254621312022209, -0.0016914092702791095, -0.01518906932324171, 0.013260303065180779, 0.017569435760378838, 0.0012896572006866336, 0.024240069091320038, 0.03406032919883728, 0.05295725166797638, 0.03472386300563812, 0.08782459795475006, -0.013134175911545753, -0.032258789986371994, -0.03690749406814575, -0.058068178594112396, 0.027796784415841103, -0.03565967455506325, 0.047177042812108994, -0.017582546919584274, 0.050990018993616104, 0.10888940840959549, 0.014226138591766357, -0.0002724549558479339, -0.06320758908987045, -0.06610587239265442, 0.023392485454678535, 0.04067203402519226, 0.03921119496226311, 0.04636673629283905, 0.028369683772325516, 0.04416904225945473, 0.0015035318210721016, -0.02257406711578369, 0.05771638825535774, 0.02775253914296627, -0.0015534419799223542, 0.034956470131874084, -0.003933418542146683, -0.0547017902135849, 0.02819729782640934, -0.0016390926903113723, -0.04891306534409523, -0.08148305118083954, -0.049659766256809235, -0.01671530306339264, -0.07354800403118134, 0.0031589248683303595, -0.012507852166891098, -0.002247011521831155, -0.0680815726518631, -0.01437363214790821, -0.011713379994034767, 0.0018052947707474232, 0.035661570727825165, 0.049316633492708206, 0.013466496020555496, -0.0006691043963655829, -0.07719004899263382, 0.022914038971066475, 0.005206018686294556, 0.0765131488442421, 0.03148358315229416, 0.004526227246969938, 0.012648780830204487, -0.03481491655111313, 0.03649654611945152, -0.02881067432463169, 0.06290965527296066, -0.05511615052819252, -0.022821558639407158, -0.018283281475305557, -0.00716253649443388, -0.00200993032194674, 0.046191610395908356, 0.002658459823578596, 0.014161201193928719, 0.0038125207647681236, -0.029439734295010567, 0.04932635277509689, -0.017234791070222855, -0.012000189162790775, -0.03211173042654991, -0.02272661402821541, -0.01630273647606373, -0.00519573176279664, 0.028930937871336937, 0.05065714567899704, -0.07340458035469055, 0.020989106968045235, 0.11303433030843735, -0.0018086101626977324, 0.04489654302597046, 0.04731491208076477, -0.021519167348742485, -0.012950762175023556, 0.017679259181022644, 0.03312017023563385, -0.018754372373223305, 0.024556074291467667, 0.03358657658100128, -0.0032561204861849546, -0.04087475314736366, -0.026134058833122253, -0.024521058425307274, -0.0744553729891777, 0.04724793881177902, -0.04753149300813675, -0.004180250223726034, -0.06210046261548996, 0.011951584368944168, -0.0425734668970108, 0.022389646619558334, 0.02586098201572895, 0.06643315404653549, -0.017086144536733627, 0.014822344295680523, 0.020905595272779465, -0.03337292745709419, -0.01838577166199684, 0.021694594994187355, -0.01000496931374073, 0.038726016879081726, -0.06507609784603119, -0.035753216594457626, -0.031797997653484344, -0.0010428177192807198, 0.0007870260742492974, -0.0035887875128537416, -0.04053165018558502, 0.04595043137669563, -0.04252340644598007, 0.006475213915109634, -0.005200063344091177, 0.01794738695025444, 0.02727692387998104, -0.009864946827292442, 0.05680647864937782, 0.0254500899463892, 0.00033283536322414875, 0.0012466773623600602, 0.12548045814037323, -0.04445667564868927, 0.009844806045293808, 0.01698322780430317, 0.025091003626585007, 0.039064448326826096, 0.05718705803155899, 0.02717091515660286, 0.045575425028800964, -0.08167195320129395, 0.06082171946763992, -0.0001048308695317246, 0.11593861132860184, 0.026691287755966187, -0.047152936458587646, 0.041102826595306396, 0.007763544097542763, 0.019920047372579575, 0.07516247779130936, 0.035999786108732224, 0.07951632887125015, -0.06921962648630142, -0.03370967134833336, -0.07745904475450516, -0.021853512153029442, 0.003215107135474682, 0.028123488649725914, -0.04138631001114845, 0.02948732301592827, 0.0019457871094346046, -0.02355830743908882, -0.00642408337444067, 0.016588857397437096, 0.047626692801713943, 0.09071149677038193, -0.03724891319870949, 0.0559595450758934, 0.015641184523701668, 0.03305867686867714, 0.08395204693078995, -0.006097814999520779, -0.02094894088804722, -0.045392051339149475, -0.0011584211606532335, 0.04842973127961159, 0.005517792887985706, -0.006632351316511631, 0.006765095517039299, -0.0032859293278306723, -0.03201412782073021, 0.057123810052871704, -0.001336395274847746, 0.019958462566137314, 0.017320528626441956, -0.05188632756471634, -0.05901762470602989, -0.033951807767152786, 0.09253483265638351, -0.0224609412252903, -0.0003863382153213024, 0.035350263118743896, -0.016663799062371254, 0.01380249671638012, 0.03977254778146744, -0.04114333167672157, 0.018036246299743652, -0.058738823980093, 0.045307911932468414, -0.02119779773056507, -0.023922797292470932, -0.025571271777153015, -0.0223745908588171, -0.03649372234940529, -0.03481002524495125, -0.033802807331085205, 0.013222042471170425, 0.03401710093021393, -0.02060818299651146, -0.036921966820955276, -0.03062129206955433, -0.008549430407583714, -0.006963460240513086, -0.045767754316329956, 0.018632419407367706, 0.019117938354611397, -0.018832797184586525, 0.04868526756763458, 0.009089667350053787, 0.018626093864440918, 0.017564035952091217, -0.06090933829545975, 0.025592034682631493, 0.003535616211593151, 0.03448087349534035, 0.010208851657807827, -0.03596971556544304, 0.009878819808363914, 0.025218913331627846, 0.007427745033055544, 0.1197034940123558, 0.032739538699388504, 0.0025822496972978115, 0.015371636487543583, 0.03869863227009773, -0.023061631247401237, -0.013804313726723194, 0.005299502983689308, 0.02964736334979534, -0.00525394594296813, -0.01739921234548092, 0.02618098072707653, -0.02964286506175995, 0.018591294065117836, 0.038540929555892944, -0.0402078852057457, 0.029884343966841698, 0.0041495198383927345, -0.005834646988660097, 0.009687304496765137, -0.006496551912277937, 0.030621634796261787, -0.04534560814499855, -0.033284254372119904, 0.036284446716308594, -0.0249427892267704, -0.01505916379392147, 0.0611647292971611, 0.04284609481692314, -0.01220706943422556, -0.06801494210958481, 0.04326373338699341, 0.007265384308993816, -0.027682021260261536, -0.019085364416241646, -0.07186045497655869, 0.019593371078372, -0.01799565926194191, 0.002147217746824026, -0.006309507880359888, 0.004482937045395374, -0.06476186215877533, 0.02377510629594326, -0.03369513526558876, 0.09079629927873611, 0.03372369706630707, -0.0025830722879618406, -0.000682818004861474, 0.024707993492484093, 0.04043726995587349, 0.004720347002148628, -0.0008878984954208136, -0.01565161533653736, -0.029285866767168045, -0.0519980788230896, 0.057841502130031586, 0.02977263554930687, -0.0020548850297927856, 0.003431672230362892, -0.08744215965270996, -0.06074810400605202, 0.021566681563854218, 0.04051486775279045, -0.053891729563474655, 0.048978496342897415, -0.03509595990180969, -0.011306039057672024, -0.011171597987413406, 0.01197152677923441, 0.0027304061222821474, -0.02411210909485817, -0.005364569835364819, -0.01023188978433609, 0.0020501466933637857, -0.020768942311406136, -0.015286077745258808, -0.026028355583548546, -0.0004782601026818156, 0.03720440715551376, -0.0008425921550951898, 0.01278647966682911, 0.02172734960913658, -0.03952260687947273, 0.010559125803411007, 0.038193099200725555, -0.017839135602116585, -0.00894668698310852, 0.04361364245414734, 0.07260973751544952, 0.04193342104554176, 0.02555219642817974, 0.020344270393252373, 0.02944987826049328, -0.002804052783176303, 0.02819080837070942, -0.023632561787962914, 0.050025735050439835, -0.04638028144836426, 0.0008973387884907424, 0.03407588228583336, 0.03304414078593254, 0.05384720861911774, -0.07131572812795639, -0.020971499383449554, -0.038951240479946136, 0.026156635954976082, 0.000026865738618653268, 0.022577593103051186, 0.008428292348980904, 0.046640899032354355, -0.037129562348127365, 0.00396697036921978, -0.03502724692225456, 0.003125174902379513, -0.0010985316475853324, -0.04019232466816902, 0.00897858664393425, -0.014537453651428223, 0.030929801985621452, 0.01248055137693882, -0.031241342425346375, 0.027859007939696312, 0.01602339930832386, -0.06390970200300217, -0.032931242138147354, -0.013963786885142326, -0.05424419790506363, -0.03629424050450325, -0.017972702160477638, 0.015458513982594013, -0.04134172201156616, -0.013017012737691402, -0.031812675297260284, -0.0457644909620285, -0.021147187799215317, -0.048934802412986755, -0.07916717231273651, -0.04817723482847214, -0.04260203242301941, -0.019067442044615746, 0.029380155727267265, 0.05771118402481079, 0.00874219462275505, -0.013139155693352222, -0.009603812359273434, -0.01225192192941904, -0.00848939549177885, 0.0005547697655856609, -0.033983852714300156, -0.003425325732678175, -0.021392732858657837, -0.02017384208738804, 0.002347165485844016, -0.03078651800751686, 0.06211936101317406, -0.014581302180886269, -0.0020440921653062105, 0.042948536574840546, -0.005932230036705732, 0.021521685644984245, -0.024367596954107285, 0.07198666036128998, -0.009983916766941547, -0.0011731961276382208, -0.10499762743711472, -0.03448964282870293, 0.009911510162055492, -0.012604490853846073, -0.0650101974606514, -0.028104525059461594, 0.04020820930600166, 0.03057253547012806, 0.04300997033715248, 0.0294943917542696, -0.003790944814682007, -0.040781375020742416, 0.023939382284879684, -0.028930310159921646, 0.01056394912302494, 0.004593176301568747, 0.03539133816957474, 0.01152537576854229, 0.03198523074388504, 0.04331202432513237, -0.04353923350572586, -0.024375131353735924, 0.039153747260570526, 0.007143679074943066, -0.01194409467279911, -0.05916630104184151, -0.041747599840164185, -0.050139330327510834, 0.03137994930148125, -0.037702955305576324, -0.017413713037967682, -0.014307236298918724, -0.007043144665658474, -0.03788743540644646, 0.003862064564600587, -0.04606637358665466, -0.009694774635136127, 0.022896068170666695, 0.04410022124648094, -0.05687965825200081, 0.030386850237846375, -0.024460578337311745, -0.032963141798973083, 0.029401620849967003, -0.035310521721839905, 0.01584658771753311, -0.007144894916564226, 0.027695996686816216, -0.01603996381163597, -0.08346149325370789, 0.0038573676720261574, -0.016081055626273155, 0.034584276378154755, -0.03226569667458534, -0.005693318787962198, -0.008501897566020489, -0.033871665596961975, -0.06095347926020622, 0.025513825938105583, 0.03951961174607277, 0.03591615706682205, -0.00714898481965065, 0.03037438541650772, 0.011312986724078655, -0.03204122185707092, 0.03604208678007126, 0.05342397838830948, -0.018154596909880638, 0.033222075551748276, -0.022300461307168007, -0.023792892694473267, -0.01748950034379959, -0.025601467117667198, 0.00856825988739729, 0.012060638517141342, 0.009907035157084465, 0.01850988157093525, -0.06754304468631744, -0.0396772176027298, 0.013694031164050102 ]
<p>In Steven Weinberg's Lecture on Quantum Mechanics (p. 342), he writes:</p> <blockquote> <p>The correlation between the spins of the two particles can be expressed as the average value of the product of the $\hat{a}$ component of the spin of particle 1 and the $\hat{b}$ component of the spin of particle 2:</p> <p>$\langle (\textbf{s1} \cdot \hat{a}) (\textbf{s2} \cdot \hat{b}) \rangle = -\frac{\hbar^2}{4} \int{d\lambda\ \rho(\lambda) S(\hat{a}, \lambda) S(\hat{b}, \lambda)}$</p> <p>where $\hat{a}$ and $\hat{b}$ are any two unit vectors.</p> <p>In quantum mechanics, we have:</p> <p>$\langle (\textbf{s1} \cdot \hat{a}) (\textbf{s2} \cdot \hat{b}) \rangle = -\frac{\hbar^2}{4} \hat{a} \cdot \hat{b}$</p> <p>There is no obstacle to constructing a function $S$ and a probability density $\rho$ for which are equal for any single pair of directions $\hat{a}$ and $\hat{b}$.</p> </blockquote> <p>Can someone explain to me precisely how this is done and what $S(\hat{a}, \lambda)$ and $\rho(\lambda)$, along with the hidden variables $\lambda$ would be?</p> <p>My guess is that since we want something that is rotationally invariant since it depends only on the dot product, we want some $S$ and hidden variables $\lambda$ that act nicely under rotations.</p> <p>On the other hand, since the first equation is a local hidden variable theory, I thought this was not possible by Bell's inequalities...</p>
g4221
[ 0.0016066327225416899, -0.031547896564006805, -0.030127260833978653, -0.044756412506103516, 0.0350087471306324, 0.0028191779274493456, 0.0617259182035923, 0.031641095876693726, -0.017841409891843796, -0.01666252873837948, -0.032472509890794754, 0.05272038280963898, 0.012163632549345493, -0.046089135110378265, 0.01774590089917183, 0.017679432407021523, 0.007205893751233816, 0.013879470527172089, -0.0198046937584877, -0.022978389635682106, -0.019441640004515648, -0.00885961763560772, -0.011536653153598309, -0.019027475267648697, 0.008739907294511795, -0.03943090885877609, -0.020014706999063492, -0.031992826610803604, -0.04478932544589043, 0.016292747110128403, 0.016769932582974434, 0.012914693914353848, 0.03683803603053093, -0.08307132124900818, 0.014199655503034592, -0.023533020168542862, 0.08713880181312561, -0.004488500766456127, -0.02387985773384571, 0.04090265929698944, -0.03320159390568733, 0.032623399049043655, -0.010074191726744175, -0.046711266040802, 0.036424748599529266, 0.05742594599723816, 0.004316028673201799, 0.015720440074801445, -0.014319139532744884, -0.01936633139848709, -0.011109588667750359, 0.037627674639225006, 0.07276938855648041, -0.0313875675201416, 0.01618799939751625, 0.10289628058671951, 0.04832366853952408, 0.00507412850856781, 0.07089658826589584, 0.06088537350296974, -0.00010868175741052255, -0.039913006126880646, -0.006991581991314888, -0.0010197607334703207, 0.07022791355848312, -0.042019881308078766, -0.02964966744184494, 0.004282818641513586, -0.021431120112538338, -0.0046976543962955475, -0.0019517206819728017, -0.04090026393532753, 0.045962054282426834, -0.01599452644586563, -0.05772631987929344, -0.005286259576678276, 0.011414138600230217, -0.03153989464044571, -0.0034396820701658726, 0.04070086404681206, -0.06857254356145859, 0.010211368091404438, 0.028408978134393692, 0.007109731901437044, 0.048059143126010895, 0.012241634540259838, 0.04358404502272606, -0.012201298028230667, -0.012349290773272514, 0.029316116124391556, 0.032919742166996, -0.016530226916074753, 0.03923199698328972, 0.0694301575422287, 0.023321043699979782, -0.025435326620936394, -0.0557406060397625, 0.014986486174166203, -0.01833432726562023, -0.00497574545443058, -0.01625720225274563, 0.053338173776865005, 0.04314442723989487, 0.016749881207942963, 0.0003939976741094142, -0.06664853543043137, 0.05444905906915665, 0.054015520960092545, -0.041630566120147705, -0.017730405554175377, -0.060934342443943024, -0.020665904507040977, -0.02458089217543602, -0.04598664119839668, -0.07037585228681564, -0.019443688914179802, 0.09747107326984406, -0.05303299054503441, 0.00811756681650877, 0.03840980306267738, 0.013433504849672318, 0.04701061174273491, -0.014147093519568443, 0.13735201954841614, 0.028034482151269913, 0.0312177911400795, -0.000818703614640981, 0.01706552878022194, 0.05579089745879173, -0.02402849681675434, 0.06115669012069702, -0.05353600159287453, 0.03265630826354027, 0.04228748381137848, -0.010399742983281612, 0.04597027972340584, 0.01930473931133747, 0.05137276276946068, 0.009929390624165535, 0.008528896607458591, -0.010642702691257, -0.023079587146639824, 0.0005015851347707212, 0.00020224660693202168, -0.045693956315517426, -0.005877285730093718, 0.023374401032924652, -0.07813797146081924, 0.002091724192723632, -0.02039019949734211, 0.043985892087221146, 0.04600931331515312, -0.0156097412109375, -0.002126963110640645, 0.028978927060961723, -0.02085953578352928, 0.02435556799173355, -0.026179349049925804, 0.013201834633946419, 0.05137289687991142, 0.0653117224574089, -0.03702973946928978, 0.011025852523744106, -0.014821355231106281, -0.05330059304833412, 0.025339091196656227, 0.016075894236564636, -0.040627483278512955, -0.018871575593948364, -0.04606299102306366, -0.010442012920975685, -0.03118668496608734, -0.06703616678714752, 0.0281204991042614, 0.045102618634700775, 0.055345527827739716, -0.08676518499851227, -0.0022863768972456455, -0.005945184733718634, 0.05958636850118637, 0.021812506020069122, 0.01588180847465992, 0.05843439698219299, 0.021287640556693077, -0.015119839459657669, 0.02542002685368061, 0.0034321798011660576, 0.01290968619287014, -0.04349128529429436, -0.027276158332824707, -0.02990344539284706, -0.01100979745388031, -0.008809306658804417, 0.034765344113111496, 0.02037711627781391, 0.005584334954619408, 0.04733312129974365, -0.03657255321741104, 0.01646638661623001, 0.05023246258497238, -0.04084175080060959, 0.023035869002342224, 0.05295354127883911, 0.013659256510436535, 0.026076236739754677, -0.007344265002757311, -0.009373381733894348, -0.001515141106210649, 0.033593449741601944, -0.03484942018985748, 0.010064545087516308, -0.05559078976511955, -0.059301964938640594, 0.013976684771478176, -0.016911432147026062, -0.09440121799707413, 0.0037814981769770384, 0.019472790881991386, -0.00014667936193291098, -0.0003823472070507705, 0.032869040966033936, -0.023732148110866547, 0.015092859975993633, 0.010588126257061958, -0.03457922860980034, 0.03488937392830849, -0.01369488425552845, -0.006680332124233246, -0.011944054625928402, 0.05933201685547829, -0.0164097398519516, -0.047232504934072495, -0.03235502541065216, 0.009475131519138813, 0.022442221641540527, 0.04090658202767372, -0.004240002483129501, 0.034003179520368576, 0.017940975725650787, 0.014509724453091621, 0.023031149059534073, 0.02942964807152748, -0.024659376591444016, 0.022379105910658836, 0.051753103733062744, 0.0042559914290905, 0.0538623109459877, -0.012054667808115482, -0.004285149741917849, 0.07211070507764816, -0.03386492654681206, -0.015309860929846764, -0.01909005641937256, -0.060750968754291534, 0.014776989817619324, -0.01011604443192482, 0.021789448335766792, 0.03891843929886818, -0.0447092168033123, -0.05379651114344597, -0.023965520784258842, 0.018689194694161415, -0.010227428749203682, 0.006249653175473213, 0.01673022098839283, -0.019807063043117523, 0.008028407581150532, -0.019551949575543404, 0.011173701845109463, -0.008756374940276146, -0.017949605360627174, 0.07087089866399765, -0.030469514429569244, 0.04632166773080826, -0.023562116548419, -0.020660851150751114, 0.030275238677859306, -0.012128484435379505, -0.028991185128688812, -0.006934549659490585, -0.03271389380097389, 0.04024338349699974, -0.03418827801942825, 0.0034297944512218237, 0.010309280827641487, -0.016610387712717056, 0.015156786888837814, -0.0069750575348734856, 0.05671560391783714, 0.014818785712122917, -0.006018888670951128, 0.07059185206890106, -0.0013886765809729695, -0.00834101252257824, 0.043012745678424835, 0.01674581691622734, 0.004256374668329954, -0.04220745712518692, -0.03156280145049095, 0.027330415323376656, -0.0024759690277278423, -0.020259441807866096, 0.0009892263915389776, -0.018410665914416313, 0.04319516941905022, -0.04797489941120148, -0.02967182546854019, 0.010000238195061684, -0.012032543309032917, 0.029069678857922554, -0.0668204203248024, 0.05881672725081444, 0.023611148819327354, -0.06787791103124619, -0.0008153109229169786, -0.019798438996076584, -0.029339030385017395, 0.07700075209140778, 0.020212359726428986, -0.0622207336127758, -0.04448741301894188, -0.041180409491062164, 0.010599903762340546, -0.03201796114444733, 0.043599434196949005, -0.04064455255866051, -0.07282346487045288, 0.07160241156816483, -0.06178952753543854, -0.062430549412965775, 0.014124692417681217, -0.0026328163221478462, 0.00908958725631237, 0.010622434318065643, -0.08594594150781631, 0.01984514482319355, -0.02287398837506771, 0.03085232526063919, -0.02247377298772335, -0.017179151996970177, 0.0022474059369415045, -0.02863875776529312, -0.03495250642299652, 0.025857191532850266, -0.02795744128525257, 0.021399930119514465, -0.021104274317622185, -0.005472017452120781, 0.06232588738203049, 0.03314955532550812, -0.02716994844377041, 0.006972949951887131, 0.04819750785827637, 0.02766142413020134, 0.03472207486629486, 0.05891580879688263, 0.04166928306221962, -0.04390706494450569, 0.04461083561182022, -0.019496861845254898, 0.013958518393337727, -0.01904219388961792, 0.04441797733306885, -0.01824599876999855, 0.00307824625633657, -0.014082018285989761, -0.0018171530682593584, 0.05533213913440704, 0.005050900857895613, -0.00667343195527792, 0.01530557032674551, 0.020228268578648567, -0.0038241620641201735, -0.01233589742332697, 0.003332407446578145, -0.058480072766542435, -0.009144933894276619, -0.016844702884554863, -0.045591089874506, -0.004836622159928083, -0.021470557898283005, 0.03527605161070824, 0.027243372052907944, 0.05976849049329758, 0.011750519275665283, 0.006106903776526451, -0.032047465443611145, -0.00806525070220232, 0.059565622359514236, -0.027616605162620544, 0.011771438643336296, 0.0033339462243020535, 0.0002297429455211386, 0.04771260917186737, 0.03054075501859188, -0.00469203619286418, 0.04721880331635475, -0.032768119126558304, -0.0043219393119215965, 0.02383902110159397, -0.08348110318183899, -0.03355425223708153, -0.017655614763498306, -0.03614743798971176, -0.014024375937879086, -0.012476020492613316, 0.00962273683398962, -0.015699736773967743, 0.029098710045218468, -0.00760545814409852, -0.008670426905155182, 0.04606791213154793, 0.05332189425826073, 0.00917389802634716, 0.007743976078927517, -0.025684578344225883, 0.01975390501320362, -0.054012030363082886, -0.01700449548661709, -0.04608512669801712, -0.04163595288991928, 0.030109377577900887, 0.03823823481798172, 0.009117632173001766, 0.038449499756097794, 0.0009178243344649673, 0.0263576228171587, -0.012367869727313519, -0.015571623109281063, -0.04702746123075485, 0.06794359534978867, 0.013821948319673538, 0.01756318099796772, 0.024435175582766533, -0.044576000422239304, -0.015013609081506729, -0.046913761645555496, -0.004714831244200468, -0.006105699576437473, 0.011962590739130974, -0.011900398880243301, -0.02355658821761608, 0.03585011884570122, 0.01448014471679926, -0.009840627200901508, 0.06782325357198715, -0.02345971390604973, -0.03086213394999504, -0.008422985672950745, 0.009265627712011337, -0.014960992150008678, 0.026451369747519493, 0.004948020447045565, -0.05203954875469208, 0.021560898050665855, -0.022488757967948914, -0.051818348467350006, 0.045039836317300797, 0.08017565310001373, -0.01599566824734211, -0.056081682443618774, -0.02610708586871624, -0.033213336020708084, -0.046605613082647324, 0.012027572840452194, -0.02416178584098816, -0.07170218974351883, 0.00965967122465372, -0.05196835473179817, -0.03136386349797249, 0.0037415807601064444, -0.00029713500407524407, 0.025314677506685257, -0.001948665827512741, 0.03330032527446747, 0.03157291188836098, -0.007238398771733046, -0.005958652123808861, -0.026856444776058197, -0.06771876662969589, -0.06429267674684525, 0.040151916444301605, -0.021099913865327835, 0.03652648255228996, 0.01534342672675848, 0.00041390405385755, -0.02316656894981861, -0.06132035329937935, -0.004254429135471582, -0.017633134499192238, 0.021010220050811768, 0.013600893318653107, 0.019748831167817116, 0.015785405412316322, 0.008393979631364346, -0.04174380749464035, -0.027272986248135567, -0.08989693224430084, 0.0055806576274335384, -0.009340944699943066, -0.061819855123758316, 0.009399734437465668, 0.028122376650571823, 0.06060612201690674, -0.006848658435046673, 0.044342368841171265, 0.046183422207832336, 0.016554631292819977, 0.0000023398959001497133, 0.0254350658506155, -0.0346783772110939, -0.006357270292937756, 0.05473216250538826, 0.029956400394439697, -0.037967558950185776, 0.03092499077320099, -0.0010723331943154335, 0.06801514327526093, -0.0509394034743309, -0.06755725294351578, 0.00482911104336381, 0.01835266500711441, -0.03060932457447052, 0.005299318116158247, 0.056867893785238266, -0.011758251115679741, -0.04470062628388405, -0.020689303055405617, -0.004995465278625488, 0.022807827219367027, -0.016570482403039932, 0.008136811666190624, 0.027308089658617973, -0.018135128542780876, -0.009538231417536736, -0.0404464490711689, -0.003313917899504304, -0.019502729177474976, 0.002084915293380618, 0.06864070147275925, 0.005635874345898628, -0.04613686352968216, -0.026363441720604897, 0.05883268639445305, -0.03437140956521034, 0.0008695937576703727, -0.021748580038547516, -0.02320331707596779, 0.020168151706457138, 0.025185808539390564, -0.03415423631668091, -0.00997161865234375, -0.04427570104598999, -0.02150116115808487, 0.011819032952189445, -0.009808041155338287, -0.03133271262049675, -0.02402513101696968, -0.005036810413002968, 0.049140576273202896, 0.06933196634054184, -0.007415270898491144, 0.047233954071998596, 0.019930126145482063, -0.07795930653810501, -0.009156559593975544, 0.006343964487314224, 0.009341472759842873, 0.03518079221248627, 0.028754040598869324, -0.03664310649037361, -0.02985174022614956, -0.0529073104262352, 0.054160136729478836, 0.017862197011709213, 0.037092532962560654, -0.025573981925845146, -0.06537233293056488, -0.03583491966128349, -0.004299127962440252, -0.015035444870591164, 0.038780730217695236, -0.04540250822901726, -0.011001826263964176, -0.012238145805895329, 0.042199116200208664, -0.04012707993388176, -0.002244951669126749, -0.004340458195656538, 0.029992949217557907, -0.045204635709524155, -0.006817762739956379, -0.04285479336977005, 0.002130077453330159, -0.012348278425633907, -0.030898677185177803, 0.013309366069734097, -0.03338008373975754, -0.025608735159039497, -0.07602626085281372, 0.01712447963654995, -0.005697853863239288, 0.07384704798460007, 0.008999270386993885, 0.002584507456049323, 0.03192661702632904, -0.05866505578160286, -0.010717809200286865, -0.04140903055667877, 0.004732093773782253, -0.042121436446905136, 0.017333395779132843, 0.017610009759664536, 0.04288151115179062, 0.02754308097064495, -0.0055947150103747845, 0.01884499378502369, 0.07235347479581833, -0.0700020045042038, -0.010109269991517067, 0.06656330078840256, 0.0252144243568182, -0.03391493484377861, -0.049907051026821136, 0.07307764142751694, 0.03046061098575592, -0.026554124429821968, -0.03252939507365227, 0.03443395718932152, 0.010735472664237022, 0.04461352154612541, -0.02441142499446869, -0.009335438720881939, 0.02625419571995735, -0.02192716859281063, 0.03409241512417793, -0.031588029116392136, 0.06347934901714325, 0.027520326897501945, 0.07602418959140778, 0.0027590764220803976, 0.06248050183057785, 0.013252264820039272, 0.004223615862429142, -0.00030695920577272773, -0.0213717520236969, 0.08054444938898087, -0.031809259206056595, -0.09680324792861938, 0.01911872997879982, 0.055601537227630615, 0.013696693815290928, -0.010815233923494816, -0.048067569732666016, 0.02020241506397724, -0.026841912418603897, 0.06693064421415329, 0.03055936098098755, 0.018707016482949257, -0.02187187224626541, -0.05900855362415314, -0.06503989547491074, -0.03484303504228592, -0.04962393268942833, -0.030015787109732628, 0.01780480518937111, 0.019670236855745316, 0.02094264142215252, -0.000008256377441284712, -0.04836507886648178, 0.011296573095023632, -0.028253953903913498, -0.06601172685623169, 0.06112045422196388, 0.015254572965204716, -0.011812339536845684, 0.02337753400206566, 0.04991200566291809, -0.027512092143297195, -0.05874728411436081, -0.01142080221325159, 0.020564941689372063, -0.044277723878622055, 0.05016524717211723, -0.01591908000409603, 0.01159367710351944, -0.02084927447140217, -0.03539762645959854, 0.0244224201887846, 0.046093109995126724, -0.041800662875175476, 0.002637293888255954, 0.01428739633411169, -0.015541070140898228, -0.037528980523347855, 0.023589007556438446, 0.022086692973971367, 0.016064312309026718, -0.0640019103884697, 0.05689123272895813, -0.0139456233009696, -0.0021261340007185936, -0.002824164694175124, -0.027811499312520027, 0.039927463978528976, -0.03281588852405548, 0.03524543344974518, -0.03156560659408569, -0.025897931307554245, -0.015203871764242649, -0.0024658211041241884, 0.021011535078287125, -0.04435264691710472, -0.019314154982566833, 0.03754761815071106, 0.0128776915371418, -0.054055459797382355, 0.07774289697408676, 0.033740825951099396, -0.017161067575216293, -0.026348203420639038, 0.005788397043943405, 0.022467080503702164, -0.055467814207077026, -0.01697107031941414, -0.07853592932224274, 0.04674214497208595, -0.013012783601880074, 0.049471665173769, 0.00614725099876523, -0.02736384980380535, -0.018402209505438805, -0.06310704350471497, 0.06939096003770828, -0.005593962501734495, -0.011952485889196396, 0.003057057736441493, 0.024613698944449425, -0.021418219432234764, 0.025736868381500244, -0.05378428474068642, -0.08800973743200302, 0.04079551249742508, -0.04149322956800461, -0.03878546506166458, 0.0403141975402832, -0.02896917052567005, 0.04963061958551407, 0.010030522011220455, -0.03480451554059982, 0.0006638334016315639, 0.054613154381513596, -0.07521785795688629, 0.056024882942438126, 0.05880555883049965, -0.052414026111364365, -0.01530105248093605, 0.048232220113277435, 0.005574874579906464, 0.018170654773712158, 0.016018256545066833, 0.012965772300958633, -0.044284574687480927, 0.04524651914834976, -0.006361451931297779, -0.0335531160235405, -0.012435083277523518, 0.07634375244379044 ]
<p>In equation of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbs_free_energy#Graphical_interpretation" rel="nofollow">Gibbs free energy</a> change $(\Delta G) = (\Delta H)-T(\Delta S)$, is $T$ the system's or surrounding's temperature? </p> <p>Edit:Oh sorry I am not clear earlier now I get clear question.I know we have to calculate gibbs free energy of system but criterion for spontaneity of ΔStotal should be greater than zero.When we relate it to gibbs free energy to show that gibbs free energy change should be always negative we keep both system and surrounding temperature same with pressure also constant.Then how process can occur?Wikipedia says that it is chemical potential that undergo changes there but what about gibbs free energy change.</p> <p>I think I made too hurry to ask question when I am studying but I am running out of time so I ask here.</p> <p><strong>NEW EDIT TO QUESTION</strong> :I found that above equation can only be applied to open systems but the quoted statement at top of <strong><em>Free energy of reactions</em></strong> section taken from <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibbs_free_energy/" rel="nofollow">Wikipedia Article</a></p> <blockquote> <p>To derive the Gibbs free energy equation for an <strong><em>isolated system</em></strong>, let Stot be the total entropy of the isolated system, that is, a system that cannot exchange heat or mass with its surroundings. According to the second law of thermodynamics:</p> </blockquote> <p>the word isolated system means that the formula $\Delta G=\Delta H-T\Delta S$ is derived for isolated system.But I think exactly in opposite way that it is true for open systems.Read Above question before this New EDIT to understand my question.Please Help me.</p>
g4222
[ 0.003966596908867359, -0.012428315356373787, 0.007819234393537045, -0.008788525126874447, -0.042748428881168365, -0.0037136366590857506, -0.005812568590044975, 0.07290243357419968, -0.020285313948988914, 0.018501346930861473, -0.02909337356686592, 0.04404624551534653, 0.06483706831932068, -0.029942264780402184, -0.011030875146389008, 0.015438184142112732, 0.08337344229221344, -0.009829413145780563, -0.02012893557548523, 0.04448847845196724, -0.06000301614403725, -0.027100734412670135, -0.041318897157907486, -0.05093054845929146, -0.0028784924652427435, -0.06259622424840927, 0.027317596599459648, 0.02675442397594452, -0.02178497426211834, -0.001610816572792828, -0.020059285685420036, 0.03932822495698929, 0.0830005630850792, -0.041099097579717636, -0.029526501893997192, 0.020425155758857727, 0.08319877088069916, 0.02770495042204857, 0.015965700149536133, -0.028967663645744324, 0.023807302117347717, -0.0029591594357043505, -0.02878403663635254, -0.030074801295995712, -0.01475574728101492, -0.007649868261069059, 0.021014314144849777, -0.0009829067857936025, -0.050526756793260574, 0.020954450592398643, 0.019111715257167816, 0.06942660361528397, 0.016075022518634796, -0.03798641264438629, -0.03255874663591385, 0.02818681113421917, 0.03964981809258461, 0.008407975547015667, 0.024793561547994614, 0.04545684531331062, -0.035331595689058304, -0.002105978550389409, 0.028692573308944702, 0.0029274076223373413, 0.01895950920879841, 0.0012117961887270212, 0.0035902198869735003, -0.01785973086953163, 0.004479910247027874, 0.026690049096941948, 0.0303298719227314, -0.0003222171508241445, -0.05220774933695793, -0.016071287915110588, 0.034884583204984665, -0.022228162735700607, 0.012238690629601479, -0.07235967367887497, 0.0075118886306881905, -0.01798930950462818, -0.009322135709226131, -0.0015257175546139479, 0.027224402874708176, -0.01824306696653366, 0.07518811523914337, -0.03623445704579353, 0.022111991420388222, -0.008675805293023586, -0.004203439690172672, 0.041521139442920685, 0.01880161464214325, -0.00846914667636156, 0.0792001411318779, -0.00394571665674448, -0.00034616683842614293, 0.06357675790786743, 0.031493961811065674, 0.023288819938898087, 0.04035276547074318, -0.054464422166347504, -0.008268261328339577, -0.028867974877357483, 0.00937308743596077, -0.027050942182540894, -0.007410896942019463, -0.028078975155949593, -0.014288392849266529, 0.010428444482386112, -0.017240991815924644, 0.01238988060504198, 0.047553256154060364, 0.004702202044427395, -0.08892415463924408, -0.05316182225942612, 0.023521792143583298, -0.031679172068834305, 0.0878107026219368, -0.01430742908269167, 0.014722668565809727, -0.0022291617933660746, -0.023812362924218178, 0.06924265623092651, 0.004298858344554901, 0.006296797655522823, -0.02142675220966339, 0.015974469482898712, -0.036682650446891785, -0.03868085891008377, 0.030291341245174408, -0.03731826692819595, 0.025971122086048126, 0.03282816335558891, -0.01415819488465786, 0.006907717790454626, 0.023516828194260597, 0.017073165625333786, 0.030205274000763893, 0.03225655108690262, 0.016561882570385933, -0.054749030619859695, -0.010098017752170563, 0.020232709124684334, -0.006644015200436115, -0.003389421384781599, 0.01883920282125473, -0.017089636996388435, 0.00389545108191669, 0.024517899379134178, 0.04129709303379059, -0.00933164358139038, 0.026324274018406868, 0.03388998284935951, -0.024628710001707077, -0.03487841784954071, -0.012403009459376335, -0.03892865031957626, 0.018470020964741707, 0.00806618481874466, 0.0008806016412563622, -0.0076400479301810265, -0.004810878075659275, -0.03044968470931053, 0.05751725658774376, -0.025400863960385323, -0.07232464849948883, 0.0014950921759009361, -0.023419229313731194, -0.029358159750699997, -0.008861145935952663, -0.04497535526752472, -0.062102947384119034, 0.02801218442618847, -0.0195783618837595, 0.040366336703300476, -0.013512469828128815, -0.004365898668766022, 0.042969271540641785, 0.013632639311254025, 0.025450339540839195, -0.02774558961391449, -0.007625235710293055, 0.009184753522276878, 0.07729744166135788, -0.06001298874616623, -0.0033531973604112864, 0.10436728596687317, 0.007035468239337206, 0.04744703322649002, -0.01895804889500141, 0.021905990317463875, -0.011041255667805672, 0.021650126203894615, -0.009837629273533821, 0.026380928233265877, -0.001892749802209437, -0.007974927313625813, -0.026904001832008362, -0.06307163834571838, -0.01631949469447136, 0.00705668656155467, -0.07975910604000092, 0.08223505318164825, -0.03263856843113899, 0.0072513362392783165, 0.009953444823622704, 0.03725342079997063, -0.00868226122111082, 0.01872289553284645, 0.017039718106389046, -0.018229708075523376, -0.003998888656497002, 0.05320810154080391, -0.03997243195772171, -0.0017057987861335278, 0.0750957801938057, -0.030010530725121498, -0.028237231075763702, 0.020124532282352448, 0.0009507232462055981, -0.02132602222263813, 0.014584981836378574, 0.030295556411147118, -0.00683545833453536, 0.04389141872525215, -0.00855549331754446, -0.028117245063185692, -0.05147594213485718, -0.02839338406920433, -0.023209869861602783, 0.055031005293130875, 0.010237283073365688, -0.015350030735135078, -0.0038157424423843622, -0.008352012373507023, 0.01849425956606865, 0.03557043522596359, 0.014019977301359177, 0.007884500548243523, 0.03835137188434601, 0.008522901684045792, 0.003439168678596616, -0.023796988651156425, -0.07169119268655777, 0.05193810537457466, 0.023287463933229446, -0.05182357132434845, 0.026134371757507324, 0.008677322417497635, 0.010745227336883545, 0.006401970516890287, -0.018675707280635834, 0.03015376254916191, -0.003111977595835924, -0.0011372016742825508, -0.04597865045070648, 0.017233949154615402, -0.029046352952718735, -0.023609859868884087, -0.04500037059187889, -0.058987680822610855, 0.027746785432100296, -0.029382970184087753, 0.015441406518220901, 0.06013406813144684, -0.03358432278037071, -0.0017530348850414157, -0.029692597687244415, -0.0664692297577858, 0.007377812638878822, 0.0009205005480907857, -0.01652926206588745, 0.08657722920179367, 0.035429392009973526, 0.05507243424654007, -0.010713466443121433, 0.0014442350948229432, 0.00018919710419140756, -0.009151388891041279, -0.008701147511601448, -0.0039365170523524284, -0.00809981394559145, 0.007090209983289242, -0.017628012225031853, 0.07591976970434189, 0.02350739762187004, -0.054435525089502335, 0.04419754445552826, -0.02564905397593975, -0.021906951442360878, -0.04441818594932556, 0.04504299536347389, 0.05582158640027046, -0.00858904980123043, 0.01274020690470934, -0.0545157790184021, 0.009371601045131683, 0.01765061728656292, -0.08265046030282974, 0.030285656452178955, 0.0563175193965435, 0.00044815035653300583, -0.013293907977640629, -0.015508006326854229, 0.065590038895607, 0.06942560523748398, 0.04237871617078781, -0.06776658445596695, -0.03312087804079056, -0.009397841989994049, 0.018970798701047897, -0.02410244569182396, 0.002071141032502055, 0.021985791623592377, 0.008912893943488598, -0.03705038130283356, 0.08089787513017654, -0.029174204915761948, -0.021825794130563736, 0.02916720323264599, -0.01642066426575184, -0.02187184803187847, -0.032391257584095, -0.005090619437396526, 0.01925402134656906, -0.002764598000794649, -0.018799634650349617, -0.01988229900598526, -0.016988864168524742, -0.025429433211684227, -0.033192072063684464, 0.05315588414669037, -0.0024041305296123028, 0.008795482106506824, -0.04868505522608757, -0.03374283388257027, -0.0006738257361575961, 0.013061262667179108, -0.03515287861227989, 0.06881347298622131, -0.024028273299336433, -0.01840122602880001, -0.029919356107711792, -0.058150652796030045, 0.0775461196899414, -0.04206813499331474, 0.0065706875175237656, 0.018770607188344002, -0.014918644912540913, 0.013802063651382923, -0.03034128062427044, 0.04235814884305, -0.005916880909353495, -0.004900871776044369, 0.03721562772989273, -0.014284659177064896, -0.00660539697855711, -0.04805823415517807, 0.026992127299308777, -0.025250520557165146, 0.007685108110308647, -0.03872166946530342, -0.08013434708118439, 0.013188113458454609, -0.01655483990907669, -0.007806768640875816, 0.007168504875153303, 0.019990067929029465, -0.02602333389222622, -0.03017868660390377, -0.08913295716047287, 0.00011706552322721109, -0.052384115755558014, 0.011270466260612011, -0.015711255371570587, 0.05822351574897766, 0.007924745790660381, 0.022879546508193016, 0.02946307137608528, -0.03255428746342659, 0.0005887521547265351, 0.05045434460043907, -0.042081527411937714, -0.020470181480050087, 0.04403308406472206, 0.037711188197135925, 0.028255660086870193, -0.00615665502846241, 0.034522730857133865, -0.05741133540868759, -0.020614052191376686, 0.01673334650695324, 0.012218932621181011, 0.0380697138607502, 0.044409263879060745, -0.007991062477231026, 0.030661357566714287, 0.03630749136209488, 0.0018926063785329461, -0.030786694958806038, 0.025378774851560593, 0.022183090448379517, -0.07578667998313904, 0.009985224343836308, -0.0473368875682354, -0.032300643622875214, -0.05388154089450836, 0.02488541416823864, 0.0011760691413655877, -0.01970824785530567, -0.012613155879080296, 0.017284348607063293, -0.044954169541597366, 0.027401896193623543, -0.0035328867379575968, 0.0010052415309473872, -0.04476966708898544, 0.06401066482067108, -0.04534495994448662, 0.012472236528992653, 0.00462358957156539, 0.011859336867928505, -0.035270385444164276, -0.014523039571940899, 0.04412459209561348, -0.00074099499033764, 0.04693686217069626, 0.054184768348932266, 0.004522992298007011, -0.022732887417078018, -0.056049373000860214, -0.007724007125943899, 0.04328520596027374, -0.013980579562485218, -0.016551192849874496, -0.05239259824156761, 0.07675207406282425, -0.013303663581609726, 0.0075544193387031555, -0.04505537077784538, 0.0031365102622658014, 0.01646827720105648, 0.03884366154670715, 0.017768846824765205, -0.03821833059191704, -0.019974058493971825, 0.023689711466431618, 0.04299122467637062, -0.026727179065346718, 0.007718002889305353, -0.09476486593484879, -0.05434761941432953, 0.05459749326109886, -0.024343635886907578, 0.004483876284211874, 0.0005434858030639589, -0.027920732274651527, -0.06571376323699951, -0.0507633350789547, -0.021364694461226463, 0.037304941564798355, -0.027803970500826836, -0.10249725729227066, 0.03124295547604561, 0.058907847851514816, 0.031228825449943542, 0.028759976848959923, -0.06623672693967819, 0.026762159541249275, -0.013579768128693104, 0.012685411609709263, 0.01577049307525158, 0.03382788971066475, 0.011423328891396523, -0.0019070288399234414, -0.0066122133284807205, -0.01013980433344841, -0.036915626376867294, -0.04367521405220032, 0.04740521311759949, 0.005627648904919624, 0.03669340908527374, 0.026255058124661446, 0.015829669311642647, 0.05745057389140129, 0.013628224842250347, 0.009165655821561813, -0.03264634311199188, 0.012367560528218746, 0.011007670313119888, -0.04463688284158707, -0.0018995503196492791, 0.049095530062913895, 0.02445806749165058, 0.03233221545815468, 0.007907019928097725, -0.03534073755145073, -0.012805318459868431, -0.023739919066429138, -0.02276666834950447, 0.0089516406878829, -0.04454142600297928, -0.0030506111215800047, -0.01789919100701809, 0.0577598512172699, 0.033002790063619614, 0.04032095894217491, 0.02182517759501934, -0.022563951089978218, -0.005381138529628515, 0.04724675044417381, -0.0013207129668444395, 0.022726282477378845, 0.013289087451994419, 0.012056555598974228, 0.0005783165688626468, -0.05588969588279724, -0.06641355901956558, -0.05106622725725174, -0.0768655464053154, -0.027992263436317444, 0.059267349541187286, -0.021428009495139122, 0.02681746520102024, -0.021485257893800735, -0.026959514245390892, 0.018233364447951317, -0.09616410732269287, -0.0006875249091535807, 0.014249286614358425, 0.03465114161372185, -0.054807599633932114, 0.030139364302158356, -0.022960109636187553, 0.011871835216879845, 0.02369142882525921, -0.02688809670507908, -0.04541521146893501, 0.06190749630331993, -0.016210218891501427, -0.005231196992099285, 0.05024990439414978, -0.09332587569952011, -0.0046846638433635235, 0.01597312092781067, -0.04863704368472099, -0.030624108389019966, -0.044555116444826126, -0.07405072450637817, -0.009599603712558746, 0.001757030258886516, -0.05575747415423393, 0.009180370718240738, 0.014140153303742409, -0.03471449762582779, 0.014739775098860264, 0.03768756985664368, 0.04185248911380768, 0.008953988552093506, 0.01096291746944189, -0.012139683589339256, 0.0382719561457634, 0.015266086906194687, -0.034444477409124374, 0.04817735403776169, 0.0330728255212307, -0.07986598461866379, -0.016190793365240097, 0.007358873728662729, 0.008535519242286682, 0.09900247305631638, 0.04858992248773575, 0.0120356110855937, 0.015807731077075005, -0.03368155658245087, -0.000627616886049509, -0.022846268489956856, -0.08195105940103531, -0.017456592991948128, -0.06511186063289642, -0.010750874876976013, -0.06463582068681717, 0.0006109216483309865, 0.03095095232129097, -0.06422729045152664, -0.017755400389432907, 0.0470273420214653, -0.004870048724114895, -0.0044648004695773125, 0.03744141012430191, 0.04537437483668327, 0.01645718142390251, -0.06019588187336922, -0.0465281680226326, 0.056638203561306, 0.022781511768698692, -0.0003468398645054549, -0.055589452385902405, -0.024309586733579636, -0.0058525302447378635, 0.02152729406952858, -0.04285461828112602, -0.02116178162395954, 0.014404842630028725, -0.10485824197530746, -0.03309864550828934, 0.0021013233345001936, 0.02649175561964512, 0.05035627260804176, 0.008437891490757465, 0.010629309341311455, -0.06025135517120361, -0.005445368122309446, 0.05301476642489433, -0.026783384382724762, 0.034077826887369156, -0.02828296087682247, -0.01072798389941454, 0.06166885420680046, -0.028371350839734077, 0.03912511467933655, -0.016486188396811485, -0.03508811816573143, 0.043953754007816315, 0.002835216000676155, 0.04926447570323944, 0.08053768426179886, -0.03238934651017189, 0.031206900253891945, 0.026078034192323685, 0.018346332013607025, 0.008526315912604332, 0.011517079547047615, -0.07870495319366455, 0.03349246829748154, -0.03288017213344574, -0.0253318939357996, -0.056536514312028885, 0.009870192967355251, 0.09776433557271957, 0.002010095864534378, -0.030501989647746086, 0.013365430757403374, 0.009249255061149597, 0.012155682779848576, -0.024672221392393112, 0.025105074048042297, 0.07946381717920303, -0.03858013451099396, -0.01784200221300125, 0.04834597557783127, -0.018863899633288383, -0.06721455603837967, -0.050451282411813736, -0.0014014164917171001, 0.0021011449862271547, 0.046131495386362076, -0.022492844611406326, 0.009174060076475143, -0.014218639582395554, -0.011894969269633293, -0.01673620194196701, -0.032279808074235916, 0.02401098422706127, 0.07116246223449707, 0.012245085090398788, 0.09504515677690506, 0.09903910756111145, -0.04355449974536896, 0.01335782092064619, -0.003327969927340746, -0.0017230429220944643, -0.0032064137049019337, -0.014839524403214455, -0.019857753068208694, -0.015146085061132908, 0.010386302135884762, 0.03660951554775238, 0.03369935601949692, 0.030868781730532646, 0.02925589680671692, 0.011188400909304619, -0.010981547646224499, 0.01550750806927681, -0.016961630433797836, 0.01032913476228714, 0.01440409105271101, -0.025739815086126328, 0.04872048273682594, 0.03656540438532829, 0.0006315693608485162, -0.030796322971582413, 0.05954807996749878, -0.012585878372192383, -0.003113980870693922, -0.05204803869128227, -0.00044235758832655847, 0.07212512195110321, 0.029789309948682785, 0.021922456100583076, -0.10694924741983414, -0.027451805770397186, -0.03935692831873894, -0.03875211253762245, 0.006077916827052832, 0.0436115488409996, 0.018371127545833588, -0.0022186648566275835, -0.050548724830150604, -0.03773083537817001, 0.027343763038516045, 0.028355993330478668, -0.04608682915568352, 0.03400794044137001, -0.042923033237457275, 0.03823313117027283, 0.01974758878350258, 0.004780714865773916, -0.0008731804555281997, 0.016024893149733543, -0.014094242826104164, 0.0202983096241951, -0.04429332911968231, -0.02966577559709549, -0.0692794993519783, -0.03784608095884323, -0.0013547573471441865, 0.013060330413281918, -0.03028353676199913, 0.0298631452023983, -0.013425855897367, -0.015765391290187836, -0.004821769893169403, 0.024947071447968483, -0.040955863893032074, -0.023504182696342468, 0.0067778839729726315, 0.05581369623541832, -0.021957233548164368, 0.025203799828886986, 0.046205297112464905, 0.020662982016801834, -0.006270692218095064, 0.04802507534623146, -0.04555075243115425, 0.024716299027204514, -0.01788158155977726, 0.0063008773140609264, 0.057255227118730545, 0.0815790668129921, -0.007071395870298147, 0.0018025279277935624, -0.0178372822701931, -0.03296883404254913, -0.014120776206254959, 0.0537518709897995, -0.0881480947136879, -0.05408882722258568, -0.01279678475111723, 0.0016711227362975478, 0.04453755170106888, -0.004255990032106638, 0.04707145318388939, -0.03217446804046631, 0.009594934061169624, -0.0020006143022328615, -0.04155094921588898, -0.002647264627739787, 0.04821713641285896 ]
<p>I am a graduate student in pure mathematics, during my study on <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ricci_flow" rel="nofollow">Ricci Flow</a> I faced some functional known as <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_functional" rel="nofollow">energy functional</a>. For example Einstein-Hilbert functional is called an energy functional, also in Perelman's works $\mathcal{F}(g,f)=\int_M(R+|\nabla f|^2)e^{-f}d\mu$ is introduced as an energy functuional, where $M$ is a closed manifold, $g$ is Riemannian metric, $R$ is Ricci scalar, and $f$ is any function that in the physics literature is called <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dilaton" rel="nofollow">dilaton</a>. </p> <p>I do not know why these functionals are attributed to the energy concept and why does $f$ show dilaton concept? </p> <p>Can anyone help me?</p>
g4223
[ 0.060332849621772766, 0.01895352452993393, -0.013021646067500114, 0.022420408204197884, 0.002351540606468916, -0.0060141864232718945, 0.0565171092748642, 0.031755562871694565, -0.03523988276720047, -0.03161187097430229, -0.05206863954663277, -0.005664286203682423, 0.07229766249656677, 0.002558644162490964, -0.013206356205046177, -0.045290134847164154, 0.06940094381570816, 0.019458146765828133, -0.0024435832165181637, 0.011688660830259323, -0.030026840046048164, 0.014947081916034222, 0.0025291992351412773, -0.007590480614453554, 0.03519405052065849, 0.011867729015648365, 0.05253385752439499, -0.05183896794915199, -0.03381676599383354, -0.0032063438557088375, 0.05067853257060051, 0.006001836154609919, 0.052996546030044556, -0.006532158236950636, 0.007614203728735447, 0.030023308470845222, 0.045706041157245636, 0.007580399513244629, 0.015558572486042976, 0.006081418599933386, -0.02713334560394287, 0.015794478356838226, 0.03024131804704666, 0.012666786089539528, 0.024998819455504417, 0.017238248139619827, -0.004493374843150377, 0.056897010654211044, 0.0045835282653570175, -0.016609488055109978, 0.04168311133980751, 0.05411963537335396, 0.03138837218284607, -0.014283435419201851, 0.07160130888223648, -0.0019487106474116445, 0.0038065670523792505, 0.045878004282712936, -0.032550860196352005, 0.039503153413534164, -0.017051266506314278, 0.0068418229930102825, -0.02673407830297947, -0.005430690012872219, 0.05081000551581383, -0.04429231584072113, -0.006259245797991753, -0.06487169116735458, 0.047831106930971146, 0.03525625914335251, 0.019768230617046356, 0.0450526662170887, 0.013485584408044815, -0.012931525707244873, -0.006376021075993776, -0.06199634075164795, 0.008755083195865154, 0.01974032260477543, -0.012445049360394478, -0.031096018850803375, 0.04111064225435257, -0.02274855226278305, 0.03329665958881378, 0.007595553528517485, 0.09571301192045212, 0.03480180352926254, 0.021852638572454453, 0.028895165771245956, 0.008926205337047577, 0.03447921574115753, 0.020785674452781677, -0.015105210244655609, 0.05043390765786171, 0.02962290681898594, -0.047796156257390976, 0.005195959471166134, -0.05089034512639046, -0.004350536968559027, 0.017760084941983223, -0.004867209121584892, 0.03241567686200142, -0.027121812105178833, 0.07770701497793198, 0.03123043105006218, 0.07346579432487488, 0.026572031900286674, -0.02525225467979908, 0.011078430339694023, -0.037885669618844986, -0.01143998745828867, -0.014647617936134338, 0.031795091927051544, -0.023446807637810707, -0.01853049546480179, -0.012094410136342049, -0.030015984550118446, 0.049279216676950455, -0.04482702910900116, -0.03533361107110977, 0.05110776051878929, -0.030613966286182404, 0.03311430662870407, 0.039225947111845016, 0.029622485861182213, -0.028600076213479042, 0.02812041901051998, 0.0480111725628376, -0.03715762123465538, 0.02258487232029438, -0.032295238226652145, 0.05709734559059143, 0.0020915139466524124, 0.001990735298022628, -0.027477223426103592, 0.039054494351148605, 0.0034085900988429785, -0.02232343517243862, -0.01237885095179081, 0.007238483987748623, 0.03628086298704147, 0.04535477235913277, -0.07719498872756958, -0.022926002740859985, -0.016669629141688347, -0.048691052943468094, -0.008285892195999622, -0.04131154343485832, -0.04953628405928612, 0.03355484455823898, -0.03855245187878609, -0.010424715466797352, 0.08087727427482605, -0.026074564084410667, -0.058017533272504807, 0.07322416454553604, 0.003912008833140135, 0.004435150884091854, -0.023000992834568024, -0.044544368982315063, 0.0136580690741539, 0.012842398136854172, 0.06000959128141403, 0.08990475535392761, -0.0046099149622023106, -0.06040375307202339, 0.06061340123414993, 0.03949890285730362, -0.056853268295526505, 0.009919561445713043, -0.05041930079460144, -0.057677991688251495, -0.016538573428988457, -0.01926930993795395, 0.033039774745702744, 0.020464541390538216, 0.017421158030629158, -0.004664986860007048, 0.005085994489490986, 0.002037032973021269, -0.0075241997838020325, -0.06782262027263641, -0.02153860405087471, 0.038529492914676666, 0.011602620594203472, -0.015229777432978153, 0.047994885593652725, 0.02327868528664112, -0.003526117652654648, -0.08702090382575989, 0.0338115468621254, 0.010199997574090958, 0.01414159219712019, 0.004556720145046711, -0.0032904762774705887, 0.025880929082632065, 0.04823058471083641, -0.013318553566932678, -0.04672640562057495, -0.04247022047638893, 0.015470893122255802, 0.005886445753276348, 0.0055890935473144054, -0.00680406391620636, -0.03872651979327202, 0.0023975109215825796, 0.004674388095736504, -0.021464824676513672, 0.029903987422585487, 0.03195217251777649, 0.004360300954431295, 0.020745009183883667, -0.07148189842700958, 0.009874630719423294, 0.03627847507596016, 0.02983185648918152, -0.006324016954749823, -0.040065426379442215, -0.01599135249853134, -0.033184658735990524, 0.05497334897518158, -0.05327747389674187, -0.04465555399656296, 0.07488594949245453, 0.044164568185806274, -0.025822075083851814, -0.0030148765072226524, -0.032794445753097534, -0.06861785799264908, -0.01976020820438862, -0.0012270972365513444, -0.09035464376211166, 0.024350078776478767, 0.07734815776348114, 0.02756592072546482, 0.03795913979411125, -0.030290549620985985, 0.00644794013351202, -0.037421803921461105, 0.052569352090358734, -0.0029794666916131973, -0.037234555929899216, -0.026851821690797806, -0.022578265517950058, -0.008507718332111835, 0.04201469570398331, -0.009983048774302006, -0.010662666521966457, -0.007696735206991434, 0.0014867399586364627, 0.007561726029962301, -0.0076765320263803005, -0.057967569679021835, -0.030895855277776718, 0.043750911951065063, 0.037444762885570526, -0.01417792122811079, -0.004385255742818117, 0.028342295438051224, -0.054563406854867935, -0.0430675633251667, 0.002739151706919074, -0.011558536440134048, 0.002684357576072216, 0.07719986140727997, -0.02011912874877453, 0.003531483467668295, -0.012371380813419819, 0.002801947295665741, -0.03819894418120384, 0.013299448415637016, 0.025569293648004532, 0.09286560863256454, 0.055091410875320435, 0.001572239096276462, -0.016044890508055687, -0.020057857036590576, 0.01604609750211239, -0.03801915422081947, 0.054114338010549545, -0.0009200587519444525, -0.029662512242794037, -0.05799266695976257, -0.04245692119002342, -0.03269743546843529, 0.0003889897488988936, -0.04617457091808319, -0.054897621273994446, 0.039577778428792953, 0.000463046133518219, -0.031308382749557495, -0.021428106352686882, 0.04791729897260666, -0.006415785755962133, 0.00810807105153799, -0.021820690482854843, -0.04505873844027519, -0.017207728698849678, -0.028718730434775352, -0.07863499969244003, 0.053288742899894714, -0.04060298576951027, -0.001836039824411273, -0.02866186574101448, 0.016725456342101097, -0.053562987595796585, -0.003790440736338496, -0.04688914120197296, -0.06916819512844086, -0.030639223754405975, 0.00442866887897253, -0.004160675220191479, 0.003932831808924675, -0.0028634192422032356, 0.01858036406338215, -0.008270411752164364, 0.06946094334125519, 0.001400634297169745, -0.0022187482099980116, 0.02984875813126564, -0.009890499524772167, -0.04217476397752762, -0.028538648039102554, 0.023864982649683952, 0.017496099695563316, 0.042670223861932755, 0.01479878555983305, -0.03820404037833214, -0.00993251521140337, -0.018566954880952835, -0.06449507176876068, 0.002696168376132846, -0.029486404731869698, -0.020843135192990303, 0.048729706555604935, -0.019246280193328857, 0.007069442421197891, -0.1004505604505539, 0.044432882219552994, 0.0549914687871933, -0.01690402254462242, -0.031766850501298904, 0.025109058246016502, -0.02087041735649109, 0.0022014889400452375, -0.007666127756237984, 0.05535794794559479, -0.021814418956637383, 0.007616741582751274, -0.004174028988927603, -0.019465625286102295, 0.014238744042813778, -0.08001792430877686, 0.027977896854281425, -0.04116874188184738, 0.02164231240749359, -0.06423108279705048, 0.022643063217401505, -0.00613652216270566, 0.018109014257788658, 0.011646307073533535, 0.0051939161494374275, 0.032182347029447556, 0.0024901656433939934, 0.008166308514773846, -0.04259805381298065, -0.012608171440660954, 0.021447356790304184, -0.0329357273876667, -0.07903826981782913, -0.020604435354471207, 0.07475826889276505, -0.0035760386381298304, 0.02480321377515793, 0.024021660909056664, -0.005682751536369324, -0.024228665977716446, -0.015560710802674294, -0.006342599168419838, -0.0588013119995594, 0.010289371013641357, 0.028081756085157394, -0.037581369280815125, 0.03443992882966995, 0.09154591709375381, 0.007331989239901304, -0.020811032503843307, -0.016404984518885612, 0.007197570987045765, 0.020950693637132645, -0.006968474481254816, -0.021525397896766663, -0.009499559178948402, 0.01169228833168745, -0.008353832177817822, 0.04026160389184952, -0.022379981353878975, 0.010844959877431393, -0.022726215422153473, -0.05474749580025673, 0.10453926026821136, 0.00030360734672285616, 0.01797838881611824, 0.01416210737079382, -0.02130902372300625, 0.002601384883746505, -0.01533432211726904, 0.0037737677339464426, -0.0001917257031891495, 0.009758658707141876, -0.028401564806699753, 0.027025636285543442, -0.019872291013598442, 0.04119972139596939, -0.05207831785082817, 0.012556434608995914, -0.010264975018799305, -0.03117777593433857, -0.08949488401412964, -0.012604004703462124, 0.023376476019620895, -0.029248205944895744, 0.00924106314778328, 0.00966325867921114, 0.03266812115907669, -0.020892050117254257, 0.12977318465709686, 0.08355607837438583, 0.04198525846004486, -0.02981543354690075, -0.03993385285139084, -0.002073287032544613, 0.023566726595163345, -0.00714636268094182, -0.008909129537642002, -0.0396759919822216, 0.028292303904891014, -0.07016885280609131, 0.0174590852111578, 0.0007250587223097682, 0.044545795768499374, 0.03229246661067009, 0.04453931376338005, 0.0005185201880522072, -0.029432103037834167, -0.021873556077480316, 0.032666660845279694, -0.10190596431493759, -0.03673762455582619, -0.053003065288066864, -0.01100071333348751, 0.031844258308410645, 0.022949934005737305, -0.01591048762202263, 0.049867626279592514, 0.02483493834733963, -0.01150562521070242, -0.06094198301434517, -0.06498973071575165, 0.05292344465851784, 0.029943374916911125, -0.06734544783830643, -0.03829103708267212, 0.015096697025001049, -0.003695703810080886, 0.016044972464442253, -0.044289857149124146, 0.03861866891384125, 0.006202881224453449, 0.007255741860717535, -0.050201673060655594, 0.03475939482450485, -0.022412866353988647, -0.013394279405474663, -0.006089385598897934, 0.02524435892701149, 0.03782501816749573, 0.02910647913813591, 0.0008658513543196023, 0.0393800213932991, -0.007430488243699074, -0.014432619325816631, 0.04402356594800949, -0.020841224119067192, 0.02311032824218273, -0.049871690571308136, -0.030187025666236877, -0.049728330224752426, -0.007982232607901096, 0.010301122441887856, -0.008901776745915413, 0.03559727966785431, -0.0029859391506761312, 0.001317517482675612, -0.005359405651688576, 0.03192862123250961, -0.028229989111423492, 0.04091881215572357, -0.014285603538155556, 0.011806645430624485, -0.019827431067824364, -0.024202540516853333, -0.016426539048552513, -0.033432215452194214, -0.04312199354171753, 0.0593840591609478, 0.0333547368645668, 0.07112633436918259, 0.016727998852729797, 0.018740830942988396, 0.045623864978551865, -0.0026612263172864914, -0.042060282081365585, 0.008122816681861877, 0.017456190660595894, 0.050222981721162796, 0.027085045352578163, 0.0009670117869973183, -0.03165308013558388, -0.010607883334159851, -0.004870337434113026, 0.027167731896042824, -0.0048863631673157215, 0.03575495630502701, -0.001756409415975213, 0.06717217713594437, -0.008480310440063477, -0.0021177157759666443, -0.0074420166201889515, -0.002127002691850066, 0.07256639748811722, -0.03952324762940407, 0.008203924633562565, 0.04745263606309891, 0.052203159779310226, -0.03706254065036774, 0.008071193471550941, 0.01203431561589241, 0.021376866847276688, -0.0029466035775840282, 0.025370948016643524, -0.006781270261853933, 0.014105170033872128, 0.01670222170650959, 0.049683377146720886, -0.033228710293769836, 0.0344541110098362, -0.00292596104554832, -0.043552104383707047, 0.04517421871423721, -0.0812339335680008, -0.016458645462989807, -0.040984705090522766, 0.029644502326846123, -0.0617377869784832, 0.04052324965596199, 0.001975330524146557, 0.02059801295399666, -0.04151604697108269, -0.06606117635965347, 0.009645652025938034, 0.011798917315900326, -0.03646102547645569, 0.008104107342660427, 0.05273282155394554, 0.035773612558841705, -0.04155954346060753, 0.00848558358848095, -0.02164561301469803, -0.003526793560013175, -0.019653331488370895, -0.015606582164764404, 0.010357766412198544, 0.06564904004335403, -0.032114531844854355, 0.049235839396715164, 0.023254049941897392, -0.023046687245368958, -0.023174723610281944, -0.029089421033859253, -0.037893038243055344, 0.06455174088478088, -0.050450753420591354, 0.02578350529074669, -0.009142661467194557, -0.022109294310212135, 0.0017677302239462733, 0.005370767321437597, -0.07303829491138458, 0.01451183296740055, -0.014807815663516521, 0.0077973282895982265, -0.00754964305087924, -0.017874546349048615, -0.0026339557953178883, -0.044158484786748886, 0.012268261052668095, -0.0271394494920969, 0.0026077188085764647, -0.005906017031520605, 0.021338097751140594, 0.012085383757948875, 0.02439960651099682, 0.049497075378894806, -0.05107416957616806, 0.0007758570136502385, 0.03833790868520737, -0.022252392023801804, -0.020803090184926987, -0.04545266181230545, 0.032845865935087204, -0.053893592208623886, 0.04561718925833702, 0.007575334049761295, 0.019946245476603508, -0.034875575453042984, -0.040472809225320816, 0.005231079179793596, 0.0032330031972378492, 0.03231486678123474, -0.015336613170802593, 0.05790693312883377, 0.035662610083818436, 0.09177486598491669, -0.04411733150482178, 0.03483787551522255, 0.04659351333975792, -0.0688319280743599, 0.06999410688877106, -0.01912258192896843, -0.037880975753068924, -0.0007235188968479633, 0.05573663488030434, -0.05521387979388237, 0.06264623254537582, -0.03899301216006279, -0.004267229698598385, -0.0551644004881382, 0.01301867701113224, 0.0642363652586937, -0.028205281123518944, -0.07289387285709381, 0.06776461750268936, -0.013104941695928574, -0.04032522812485695, -0.014402774162590504, -0.021352196112275124, -0.010559569112956524, -0.0011397720081731677, -0.101776622235775, 0.01893872581422329, -0.056928850710392, -0.00041080426308326423, -0.025633089244365692, 0.018560931086540222, -0.06969175487756729, 0.044768206775188446, -0.0301765576004982, -0.03546914830803871, 0.0614347942173481, -0.08331827074289322, 0.006295037921518087, 0.04672590270638466, -0.010398567654192448, -0.0040771979838609695, -0.03651822358369827, 0.026135707274079323, 0.0633140355348587, -0.038873784244060516, 0.017606118693947792, 0.010637539438903332, -0.01940375193953514, 0.0015751163009554148, -0.08145447820425034, 0.016632763668894768, -0.06916320323944092, -0.03348651900887489, 0.007008669897913933, 0.001768826856277883, 0.013815034180879593, 0.013299047946929932, -0.02187037467956543, 0.07062113285064697, 0.025931743904948235, -0.011894765309989452, -0.06292836368083954, 0.02523168735206127, -0.0016631195321679115, -0.021765587851405144, -0.018144523724913597, 0.017160343006253242, -0.003131846198812127, 0.042823247611522675, 0.05195391923189163, -0.011001656763255596, -0.03588767722249031, 0.031325630843639374, 0.06602886319160461, -0.008592130616307259, 0.01044714916497469, -0.02158149518072605, -0.010562506504356861, -0.0387231707572937, -0.0026301038451492786, 0.0023283669725060463, 0.009130904451012611, 0.012255885638296604, -0.001394470687955618, 0.030014801770448685, -0.03253762796521187, 0.002852866193279624, 0.02704143151640892, -0.05540236085653305, -0.01953928917646408, 0.01630931720137596, -0.026089198887348175, 0.010750330053269863, -0.026735402643680573, 0.026828253641724586, 0.03833748400211334, -0.08520148694515228, 0.00037639838410541415, -0.046725016087293625, 0.0088177639991045, -0.05871488153934479, -0.07239358127117157, -0.016812901943922043, -0.03159116208553314, -0.05442216619849205, -0.017376359552145004, -0.010457340627908707, -0.05567224696278572, 0.001300714211538434, 0.031372278928756714, -0.0034039542078971863, -0.03909793496131897, 0.019890818744897842, 0.025383466854691505, -0.0326010026037693, 0.06857702881097794, 0.02570195123553276, -0.020116057246923447, -0.048734940588474274, 0.02251472696661949, -0.008996852673590183, 0.03513960912823677, -0.08409790694713593, 0.029059210792183876, 0.030438458546996117, 0.016949394717812538, -0.0262271910905838, 0.013263935223221779, 0.05081622675061226, 0.0035966953728348017, 0.015155433677136898, 0.03170441836118698, -0.009416919201612473, 0.020999396219849586, 0.06608565151691437, 0.03832121565937996, -0.002089724177494645, 0.01317540742456913, 0.01796036586165428, -0.019187284633517265, -0.018825190141797066, -0.027992401272058487, -0.03922921046614647, 0.0116164805367589, 0.01982380449771881 ]
<p>The Source of Water is Pond where the water level do change randomly. A pipeline of 200mm pipe diameter run for around 2500 m. The Height difference between the level of the inlet pipe and the level of the exit pipe is around 9m. In other word: Water need to run by gravity for 2500 m. Difference in height is 9m. </p> <p>My question: How I could calculate the water volume/flow received at the exit pipe as function of the height of the water above the inlet pipe. </p> <p>Ex: If the water in the Pond is covering the inlet pipe by say 10 cm, what is the expected flow at the exit pipe. </p>
g4224
[ 0.02345871552824974, 0.01486996654421091, 0.00726266810670495, -0.005693321116268635, -0.07457219064235687, 0.013994835317134857, 0.07883196324110031, -0.011472233571112156, -0.08348636329174042, -0.00864586140960455, -0.06144731864333153, 0.10503454506397247, 0.08932621777057648, 0.008060239255428314, 0.01850687898695469, -0.008633085526525974, -0.005442386958748102, -0.009389806538820267, 0.011340056546032429, 0.005259246565401554, -0.09804662317037582, 0.0022288502659648657, -0.0144502529874444, -0.01746729388833046, -0.027095450088381767, -0.05436553433537483, 0.03972708433866501, 0.013512790203094482, -0.037201493978500366, 0.026029808446764946, -0.05347006395459175, 0.05608940124511719, 0.04821454733610153, -0.05088232457637787, -0.06585931777954102, 0.04987524449825287, 0.008084817789494991, 0.004937591031193733, 0.02162148430943489, -0.02052563987672329, 0.06275559961795807, 0.014742789790034294, -0.034720636904239655, 0.0460527166724205, -0.03130624443292618, 0.03879965841770172, 0.007569843903183937, 0.008431189693510532, -0.04113246127963066, -0.028142744675278664, 0.021241236478090286, 0.05420014262199402, -0.0374046228826046, 0.01984310708940029, -0.05641050636768341, 0.07612696290016174, 0.016270846128463745, -0.06617466360330582, 0.007823949679732323, 0.0003212254086975008, 0.008456711657345295, -0.001918616471812129, -0.011141758412122726, -0.005407010205090046, 0.05162981152534485, 0.003251957008615136, 0.02155122347176075, -0.04105643555521965, -0.015687115490436554, 0.03676256164908409, 0.044143714010715485, -0.05015838146209717, 0.03698470816016197, -0.037152282893657684, -0.013375259935855865, -0.005264074541628361, -0.006838783156126738, -0.02098311111330986, -0.009452104568481445, 0.014021962881088257, 0.02306307666003704, -0.003071804065257311, -0.008260982111096382, 0.0192402433604002, 0.03159439563751221, 0.023949824273586273, -0.015459475107491016, -0.0009806376183405519, -0.032637130469083786, 0.04789912328124046, -0.05052506551146507, 0.017837295308709145, 0.0571887269616127, -0.0012610394041985273, 0.008349536918103695, -0.03766320273280144, -0.05388018488883972, 0.016065899282693863, 0.023740697652101517, 0.002202181378379464, 0.03193279728293419, -0.002546216594055295, 0.03623988851904869, 0.0213091392070055, 0.02910827286541462, 0.02175365574657917, 0.02263648435473442, 0.04304468259215355, -0.04614671692252159, -0.01536870189011097, -0.003022294258698821, -0.030707962810993195, -0.05149837210774422, 0.0013409779639914632, 0.014361405745148659, -0.020791105926036835, 0.034185487776994705, 0.042131371796131134, 0.0039054309017956257, 0.03716745227575302, -0.05665508657693863, -0.02985401451587677, -0.008627789095044136, 0.020065447315573692, 0.028756244108080864, -0.016336016356945038, -0.028529850766062737, -0.00037077468005008996, 0.032678984105587006, 0.047016967087984085, 0.03672412782907486, -0.04076278582215309, -0.026667751371860504, 0.03485919162631035, 0.08725502341985703, 0.020020494237542152, -0.038371261209249496, -0.006622992921620607, 0.026195919141173363, -0.0104177575558424, 0.05749211087822914, 0.0049455133266747, -0.0008410143200308084, -0.02117413841187954, -0.058713532984256744, 0.010005124844610691, 0.023957762867212296, -0.0664607509970665, -0.04080568626523018, -0.0577668622136116, 0.02556476555764675, 0.061977919191122055, 0.04239201545715332, -0.021059440448880196, 0.01107147615402937, -0.022573372349143028, -0.05546475946903229, 0.06658098101615906, 0.008377062156796455, 0.00448787584900856, -0.002839101944118738, -0.05181223526597023, 0.028138913214206696, 0.03965340182185173, -0.09760787338018417, 0.03787681460380554, 0.006672617048025131, -0.0422353632748127, -0.029386384412646294, -0.039360783994197845, 0.00673341890797019, 0.010358237661421299, 0.0006854152888990939, -0.009433815255761147, -0.036954861134290695, -0.014943881891667843, 0.01506768073886633, -0.023320665583014488, -0.020529041066765785, 0.038674887269735336, 0.04693923518061638, -0.00799468345940113, 0.05758237838745117, -0.03447269648313522, 0.012553009204566479, 0.008589446544647217, 0.019905827939510345, -0.023818321526050568, -0.05760755017399788, -0.017122026532888412, -0.044626858085393906, -0.009017229080200195, 0.04332112520933151, -0.006815871689468622, -0.02792656421661377, 0.023842917755246162, 0.0030053991358727217, -0.04075539484620094, -0.03080374002456665, 0.017683735117316246, 0.019581854343414307, 0.023266682401299477, 0.007147388532757759, 0.02860839292407036, -0.012629035860300064, 0.03569486364722252, 0.003483090316876769, 0.0402289554476738, -0.06803053617477417, -0.005362025462090969, 0.008711686357855797, -0.033724989742040634, 0.006488655228167772, 0.04608265310525894, -0.0434960313141346, 0.06462343782186508, 0.0028905891813337803, -0.008661655709147453, -0.03335284814238548, 0.04027645289897919, 0.03835747018456459, -0.046625055372714996, -0.002164846984669566, 0.047517094761133194, -0.025405365973711014, 0.023072611540555954, -0.005187401082366705, -0.005596781615167856, -0.02418874017894268, -0.013652770780026913, -0.00608901958912611, 0.0049588605761528015, 0.0015394497895613313, -0.015143697150051594, 0.028958983719348907, 0.010895923711359501, 0.006603941321372986, 0.02760235406458378, 0.027030589058995247, -0.0790584534406662, 0.010140766389667988, 0.01910587213933468, -0.03692319989204407, -0.008670723997056484, -0.02987651154398918, 0.02289639599621296, 0.043046608567237854, -0.029574871063232422, -0.005614402703940868, 0.05398932471871376, -0.07292017340660095, -0.0050859879702329636, 0.013133030384778976, 0.042780932039022446, 0.007437372114509344, -0.030024196952581406, 0.0017921925755217671, -0.01869022846221924, -0.028725232928991318, -0.02430541068315506, -0.03729159012436867, -0.015231013298034668, 0.08501452952623367, 0.05378511920571327, -0.0362040176987648, 0.022412048652768135, -0.007611822336912155, 0.028536589816212654, 0.05463351681828499, 0.002801239490509033, -0.0113143902271986, 0.005044946447014809, 0.034572191536426544, 0.05526449531316757, 0.01690792292356491, -0.03845110535621643, -0.015650274232029915, 0.03253692016005516, 0.006632380653172731, 0.015279632993042469, -0.014770496636629105, -0.0660889744758606, -0.06000019982457161, 0.04944879189133644, 0.07518911361694336, -0.08337096124887466, 0.0528680682182312, 0.01954706199467182, -0.0012894045794382691, 0.015506072901189327, 0.009700741618871689, -0.018254080787301064, -0.023539772257208824, 0.03462979570031166, 0.03637947887182236, -0.005488193593919277, -0.008066706359386444, 0.05434863269329071, -0.013196866028010845, -0.04791766777634621, -0.06933243572711945, -0.0479857437312603, 0.01589355431497097, -0.02650236152112484, -0.08894567936658859, 0.012523612007498741, 0.006872873287647963, 0.04592718183994293, -0.004911079537123442, 0.021183902397751808, -0.004465210717171431, -0.01839955896139145, 0.004533047787845135, -0.05854480713605881, 0.03601614385843277, -0.004375495482236147, -0.004251176957041025, -0.034745942801237106, -0.017264803871512413, 0.027889970690011978, -0.06787670403718948, -0.04948196932673454, 0.009883880615234375, 0.01849278062582016, -0.08481773734092712, -0.010005490854382515, -0.02772102877497673, 0.016052108258008957, -0.04132653772830963, -0.02665180154144764, 0.030880950391292572, 0.036910105496644974, -0.07946478575468063, 0.024662086740136147, 0.03776002675294876, -0.017165839672088623, 0.04308019578456879, 0.04711062088608742, 0.04017442837357521, 0.007072997745126486, 0.0033182967454195023, -0.017926055938005447, -0.02449868805706501, -0.06406264007091522, 0.017882078886032104, -0.030577896162867546, 0.006289713084697723, 0.005279084667563438, -0.0029864932876080275, 0.03273073583841324, 0.07434971630573273, -0.020100941881537437, 0.029284074902534485, -0.011542958207428455, 0.008929740637540817, 0.019123274832963943, 0.04465639591217041, 0.019808948040008545, -0.023470096290111542, 0.016061438247561455, 0.021437490358948708, -0.08345844596624374, 0.009250256232917309, 0.06338127702474594, -0.04101764038205147, -0.07666099816560745, 0.00898524560034275, 0.032388027757406235, -0.09534110873937607, -0.021207960322499275, 0.030228549614548683, -0.003053543856367469, -0.009110422804951668, 0.003146289149299264, -0.03144106641411781, -0.04298683628439903, 0.02337806485593319, -0.009800894185900688, -0.030638830736279488, 0.03179529681801796, 0.05958933010697365, 0.04486611485481262, -0.03074871003627777, -0.002407034393399954, -0.027150342240929604, -0.029335442930459976, -0.06594271212816238, 0.02018047869205475, 0.11362285166978836, -0.01778801903128624, 0.025151889771223068, -0.023091409355401993, 0.02071697637438774, 0.004812861792743206, 0.036324016749858856, 0.041784387081861496, 0.012829052284359932, 0.007187810726463795, -0.05366073548793793, -0.012142191641032696, -0.015730969607830048, -0.03678254038095474, -0.03850381821393967, 0.06590677052736282, 0.009599730372428894, 0.01561808679252863, 0.08360042423009872, -0.0033883326686918736, -0.01718088798224926, 0.01892632432281971, 0.044417914003133774, -0.045112282037734985, 0.004356428515166044, -0.025016890838742256, -0.0021706644911319017, -0.011713472194969654, 0.03431408479809761, -0.039094459265470505, -0.010140269063413143, 0.05414547398686409, 0.004878636449575424, -0.014304528944194317, -0.015011223964393139, -0.021279482170939445, -0.024817639961838722, 0.04320279881358147, -0.03867405280470848, -0.0036493821535259485, -0.023143785074353218, -0.028470728546380997, 0.03638162836432457, 0.03072243742644787, -0.016518818214535713, -0.0003938199661206454, 0.018322743475437164, 0.08019144833087921, 0.021289389580488205, 0.019488634541630745, -0.025323359295725822, -0.04628246650099754, 0.034930408000946045, 0.0035068129654973745, -0.022067898884415627, -0.012727152556180954, 0.0072282422333955765, 0.012379810214042664, 0.009765652939677238, -0.04728419706225395, 0.03868478536605835, -0.04361443221569061, -0.04560598358511925, 0.0007331714150495827, -0.004237433895468712, -0.0539063923060894, -0.06378155946731567, 0.011277909390628338, -0.05339603126049042, 0.021767806261777878, -0.055416252464056015, -0.016883542761206627, -0.024442587047815323, -0.019894996657967567, -0.056005094200372696, 0.0010416465811431408, -0.004347088746726513, -0.05688560754060745, -0.045065753161907196, -0.0018620447954162955, 0.008868982084095478, 0.039100173860788345, -0.0057863760739564896, 0.01998022384941578, 0.03792259097099304, -0.012930864468216896, -0.003555168164893985, 0.0648488774895668, -0.020604729652404785, 0.019422682002186775, 0.07760296761989594, -0.04033764824271202, -0.005933910608291626, 0.0013174546184018254, -0.00984559953212738, 0.05132947862148285, 0.019597794860601425, -0.03724411875009537, 0.0085854921489954, -0.0061198933981359005, 0.03684410825371742, -0.03716132417321205, -0.028842290863394737, 0.011098518036305904, 0.03511284664273262, 0.06267055124044418, 0.0062559680081903934, -0.08240744471549988, -0.00524234538897872, 0.00912274420261383, 0.018857082352042198, 0.013601738028228283, -0.02981759048998356, -0.02410653606057167, -0.055514220148324966, -0.013726470060646534, 0.025784634053707123, 0.08705288171768188, -0.032748281955718994, 0.06032775714993477, -0.016750486567616463, 0.02146192640066147, 0.09868386387825012, -0.023336801677942276, -0.004525825846940279, -0.014759059064090252, 0.00604148069396615, -0.02888881228864193, -0.026888132095336914, 0.032486699521541595, 0.015992574393749237, 0.0631725937128067, 0.06107545644044876, -0.0122705502435565, 0.056507255882024765, 0.01885729283094406, -0.020069744437932968, -0.017252760007977486, -0.032620709389448166, 0.02267061360180378, -0.011209357529878616, -0.042983341962099075, -0.025875331833958626, -0.007241963408887386, -0.03625607490539551, -0.04299738630652428, -0.02859535627067089, 0.019015802070498466, 0.008449294604361057, 0.003426783252507448, 0.05209684744477272, 0.01645767129957676, -0.01550383772701025, 0.03188719600439072, 0.04498811811208725, 0.018279490992426872, 0.0036129443906247616, -0.002324180444702506, -0.02862158976495266, 0.03655633702874184, 0.01698681339621544, -0.02905665710568428, 0.010659812949597836, 0.06807103753089905, 0.031115874648094177, 0.04885178431868553, 0.001942007103934884, -0.023117393255233765, 0.002921425737440586, -0.0013320583384484053, -0.03416866809129715, -0.018403207883238792, 0.020061075687408447, -0.05988555774092674, 0.014421607367694378, 0.012574908323585987, 0.01426314003765583, -0.01184327807277441, -0.023822983726859093, -0.0017950079636648297, -0.01108612772077322, 0.016645364463329315, -0.01180299837142229, -0.04771067202091217, 0.0038585555739700794, -0.03412938117980957, 0.019157476723194122, 0.06888794898986816, -0.01516327727586031, -0.0014683783520013094, 0.010420724749565125, 0.028613382950425148, 0.022440018132328987, 0.030095526948571205, -0.0027084581088274717, -0.03317725658416748, -0.03347855806350708, 0.040312062948942184, -0.014270720072090626, -0.009725535288453102, -0.0004740878939628601, 0.02727079950273037, 0.02810170315206051, -0.04487300664186478, -0.00444207014515996, -0.005681902635842562, 0.06778214871883392, -0.05274318531155586, 0.03500257804989815, 0.004623576533049345, 0.0038962785620242357, 0.0131087526679039, 0.0014288683887571096, 0.02045704983174801, 0.032266248017549515, -0.07915221154689789, 0.009304090403020382, -0.03408612310886383, 0.03893447667360306, -0.006689013913273811, -0.03639749810099602, -0.05334267392754555, 0.03019190952181816, 0.059984441846609116, 0.03738074749708176, 0.0654103085398674, -0.06059049814939499, -0.005105552263557911, -0.02334507368505001, -0.01528568472713232, 0.02297521010041237, 0.03155932202935219, 0.05033373460173607, 0.02060910314321518, 0.048277758061885834, -0.06748402863740921, 0.031481169164180756, 0.039749473333358765, -0.014579052105545998, -0.017546271905303, 0.025240710005164146, 0.0004498699272517115, 0.03564576432108879, 0.03888952359557152, -0.048868328332901, -0.007554389536380768, -0.03166462481021881, -0.00033770824666135013, 0.03267046809196472, 0.012745185755193233, 0.05131973698735237, 0.1308075487613678, 0.07407931238412857, 0.03451941907405853, 0.015158943831920624, 0.02962677925825119, -0.014695960097014904, 0.03322000429034233, 0.023905182257294655, -0.003674854524433613, -0.03427417203783989, 0.00013962072262074798, 0.014992932789027691, -0.040120575577020645, -0.009140797890722752, 0.0532219372689724, -0.028600255027413368, 0.050403546541929245, -0.009651816450059414, 0.00030963009339757264, -0.012917594984173775, -0.044417668133974075, -0.022475576028227806, 0.0021139904856681824, -0.02057233452796936, 0.0017258238513022661, 0.02670963481068611, 0.01797565445303917, 0.01247659232467413, -0.0068590459413826466, -0.006768189836293459, -0.022969640791416168, -0.018268845975399017, -0.04017268866300583, -0.06394623965024948, 0.03037840500473976, -0.060079995542764664, -0.014532702974975109, -0.030877357348799706, 0.04886586219072342, -0.06972060352563858, 0.0007789017399773002, -0.01967383176088333, 0.030845481902360916, -0.0035640487913042307, 0.011182795278728008, -0.041447389870882034, -0.027951521798968315, -0.059107810258865356, -0.028917305171489716, 0.06282395124435425, 0.022763026878237724, -0.00929951760917902, 0.027927445247769356, 0.05203575640916824, -0.055857133120298386, -0.023815704509615898, 0.08996249735355377, -0.04688108339905739, -0.022205080837011337, 0.04868530109524727, -0.02588770166039467, 0.030606210231781006, 0.022284995764493942, -0.036147575825452805, -0.028394261375069618, -0.015535901300609112, -0.0135734174400568, -0.02309012971818447, 0.08512187749147415, -0.03496910631656647, -0.02484511397778988, 0.01547404658049345, 0.017682045698165894, -0.03647967800498009, 0.0004048831469845027, -0.0978483259677887, 0.034619372338056564, -0.05074816197156906, -0.04285078123211861, -0.01757330819964409, -0.0422096773982048, -0.05031543970108032, 0.01266644336283207, 0.020154330879449844, -0.04619881138205528, -0.052181560546159744, -0.007977236993610859, -0.01131355855613947, -0.003652425017207861, -0.04788055270910263, -0.0004396972362883389, -0.014433622360229492, -0.016778023913502693, 0.003399583511054516, 0.04186598211526871, 0.010341749526560307, 0.0024253902956843376, 0.021094443276524544, -0.013987433165311813, -0.022321252152323723, 0.005245385225862265, 0.02094138413667679, 0.03136153891682625, 0.010132282972335815, -0.03840106725692749, 0.00534559553489089, -0.05152863636612892, 0.05841457471251488, 0.006698225624859333, -0.029443582519888878, -0.06350575387477875, 0.07240650802850723, 0.007544366177171469, 0.019088761880993843, 0.026576323434710503, 0.0431479848921299, -0.08315622806549072, -0.0017403208184987307, 0.029844041913747787, -0.13078628480434418, -0.027766138315200806, -0.03268502280116081, 0.019488638266921043, 0.008617221377789974, -0.030494878068566322, 0.01434077974408865, -0.009706984274089336, -0.03080364130437374, -0.01635575108230114 ]
<p>Lets say I enter a closed room with the walls and everything in it (including me and my eyes) at thermal equilibrium. Its a very hot room, but my super-eyes still work at 5000 degrees Kelvin.</p> <p>I have two propositions which are in conflict.</p> <p>The first is that I should be effectively blind when I am in the room. For me to see anything at all, the pigments in my retina would have to absorb some of the thermal radiation and convert it into electrical impulses for my brain. (The same applies for anything which detects radiation). But we can't extract energy from the heat without a cooler object, and there is none, so we can't use the energy in the black-body radiation for vision. There is no available free heat energy; everything is at thermal equilibrium. What is happening is that the pigments in my retina are generating black body radiation at the same rate as they are absorbing black body radiation from the object being looked at, so no net chemical change can occur and hence no vision.</p> <p>However, I also know that objects have different emissivity, which means some objects in the room will be brighter than others. If I am looking at an object of lower emissivity than the pigments in my eyes, my eyes should radiate more power out than they absorb from the object, and vice versa for an object of higher emissivity. This means that if I look at different things, the pigments in my eyes will react differently to different objects, meaning vision is possible. But this contradicts the first proposition.</p> <p>Can somebody explain this "paradox" ?</p>
g4225
[ 0.03475342318415642, 0.005451184697449207, 0.015020526945590973, 0.026937363669276237, 0.011645769700407982, 0.0034769538324326277, 0.022879626601934433, 0.08086660504341125, 0.011939273215830326, -0.004357566591352224, 0.020533550530672073, 0.04986841231584549, 0.005326447542756796, 0.01669992506504059, -0.01459546759724617, 0.013217098079621792, 0.0390128493309021, -0.04376421496272087, 0.02114560268819332, -0.0015560939209535718, -0.012329245917499065, -0.022854134440422058, -0.004687929060310125, -0.030732378363609314, 0.005148388911038637, -0.00040761695709079504, 0.02476891689002514, -0.013207957148551941, -0.034382112324237823, -0.034456245601177216, -0.00032086536521092057, -0.05460647866129875, 0.019327711313962936, -0.02532733976840973, -0.0020417007617652416, 0.014644102193415165, 0.08150915056467056, 0.04531591385602951, -0.014004699885845184, 0.060513582080602646, 0.005121448542922735, -0.028123892843723297, 0.043472904711961746, -0.047609709203243256, 0.008501873351633549, 0.03676476702094078, 0.01887134090065956, -0.0009003587765619159, -0.024319790303707123, -0.04882759973406792, 0.03486845642328262, 0.024766795337200165, -0.005772907752543688, 0.04249560832977295, 0.05369137227535248, -0.010284517891705036, -0.017471682280302048, -0.010805382393300533, 0.0037329287733882666, 0.02312682941555977, 0.0006728881853632629, -0.003276827512308955, 0.0073959906585514545, 0.01954592578113079, 0.046539273113012314, 0.018022118136286736, -0.029767503961920738, 0.010904332622885704, 0.008239790797233582, 0.004557596519589424, -0.023597396910190582, -0.03857577219605446, -0.03878416866064072, -0.017410442233085632, -0.009734738618135452, -0.03949135169386864, 0.006681571714580059, 0.006613992154598236, 0.00733512919396162, 0.050277743488550186, -0.06868652254343033, -0.0011483299313113093, 0.051687344908714294, 0.0394221693277359, 0.08548066765069962, 0.020730426535010338, 0.03757937625050545, -0.07211561501026154, 0.021983688697218895, 0.01042279601097107, 0.09626621752977371, 0.03897799178957939, 0.09016304463148117, 0.04864639416337013, 0.01481400802731514, 0.06141624227166176, 0.04649966210126877, 0.05986412987112999, -0.041587840765714645, -0.00468726921826601, -0.02567274123430252, -0.04637296497821808, -0.014420656487345695, 0.007330349646508694, 0.0012132334522902966, -0.0015950624365359545, -0.02388390712440014, 0.0032472810707986355, -0.09915079176425934, 0.01328469067811966, -0.07421083748340607, -0.08500368148088455, -0.03936365991830826, -0.03948153555393219, -0.048820674419403076, -0.05042845755815506, 0.06816922128200531, 0.0012452801456674933, -0.006795450113713741, 0.05256761983036995, -0.025035714730620384, 0.09217314422130585, -0.04301438480615616, 0.051765747368335724, -0.035440076142549515, -0.0248842965811491, -0.027732793241739273, -0.041178394109010696, 0.030324246734380722, 0.004777418449521065, 0.03736405447125435, 0.013901207596063614, -0.012838313356041908, 0.06605596840381622, 0.03236093372106552, -0.004308259580284357, 0.06187291815876961, -0.02162722870707512, 0.01789981871843338, -0.038772329688072205, 0.024008728563785553, 0.01957346312701702, -0.00620831036940217, -0.022119401022791862, -0.06001930683851242, -0.029024403542280197, -0.021801289170980453, 0.001741477637551725, 0.07733821123838425, 0.0007392437546513975, -0.010053343139588833, 0.07666732370853424, -0.04509693756699562, -0.01391248032450676, -0.023412983864545822, -0.056011080741882324, -0.0013083219528198242, 0.0012283030664548278, -0.028600355610251427, -0.052234940230846405, 0.04179376736283302, 0.0059448848478496075, -0.002053877804428339, -0.024485629051923752, -0.0823943018913269, -0.019569633528590202, 0.00858057290315628, -0.03413889557123184, 0.014382438734173775, -0.051927901804447174, -0.0885150283575058, 0.059953685849905014, -0.049546871334314346, 0.03860405832529068, -0.0033717164769768715, 0.002197759924456477, 0.07089227437973022, -0.006010882090777159, -0.045033618807792664, -0.024084547534585, -0.062446046620607376, 0.009903306141495705, 0.032280098646879196, -0.06461342424154282, 0.01527145691215992, -0.007056067232042551, 0.004129108972847462, 0.04168812185525894, -0.0719720721244812, 0.057506341487169266, -0.033103592693805695, -0.04254773259162903, -0.03482966870069504, -0.01313008088618517, 0.012351881712675095, -0.0019432884873822331, -0.024279866367578506, 0.0189609806984663, -0.012798037379980087, 0.025012986734509468, 0.003591003827750683, -0.013403716497123241, -0.02358383871614933, -0.010404020547866821, -0.013668952509760857, 0.05589815601706505, -0.03608499839901924, 0.030176617205142975, 0.024128170683979988, -0.030410688370466232, 0.01450720801949501, -0.02177141234278679, 0.00469598826020956, -0.0006841587019152939, 0.007660161703824997, 0.014282810501754284, 0.015207760967314243, 0.027069687843322754, 0.033653635531663895, -0.043246351182460785, 0.017582491040229797, 0.0007821852923370898, 0.02455924078822136, -0.013129767961800098, -0.053817156702280045, 0.016697341576218605, -0.11085893958806992, -0.075411856174469, 0.05198071524500847, 0.052551571279764175, -0.056128934025764465, 0.03496881201863289, 0.060765959322452545, 0.0034846202470362186, -0.0069035133346915245, 0.045708611607551575, 0.030046992003917694, 0.019555142149329185, 0.011535453610122204, -0.014654606580734253, 0.03246002644300461, -0.0020114353392273188, -0.05975382775068283, -0.024163562804460526, 0.03719938546419144, 0.023488642647862434, -0.02867979183793068, -0.019645873457193375, 0.02414214052259922, 0.04844643548130989, -0.004634439945220947, 0.02548026852309704, -0.012381204403936863, -0.06956767290830612, 0.010913054458796978, 0.012720096856355667, -0.05612730607390404, 0.032164257019758224, -0.06865138560533524, -0.006655951030552387, 0.017258739098906517, -0.0455036498606205, -0.007751243654638529, 0.012690317817032337, 0.0036216601729393005, 0.03152120113372803, -0.003538279328495264, 0.0013770656660199165, 0.034366026520729065, -0.00613537710160017, -0.020100779831409454, 0.06519229710102081, 0.004022673238068819, 0.05176078900694847, 0.007558532524853945, 0.0400882214307785, -0.05376957729458809, -0.010309102013707161, 0.09528140723705292, -0.019804075360298157, -0.006784664001315832, 0.004167947918176651, -0.06722056865692139, -0.02842424064874649, 0.040450405329465866, -0.011588647961616516, -0.009793202392756939, 0.0008292050333693624, -0.015580450184643269, -0.035844385623931885, -0.07058349996805191, 0.06114571914076805, 0.007281086873263121, 0.05630655586719513, -0.0899016410112381, 0.004526852164417505, 0.05355890467762947, -0.009421889670193195, -0.028199102729558945, 0.06373501569032669, 0.025035729631781578, 0.017628325149416924, -0.0037514613941311836, 0.03663424775004387, 0.029089637100696564, 0.018039634451270103, -0.07500860840082169, -0.05248115584254265, 0.0701088160276413, -0.011935471557080746, -0.022954896092414856, 0.007769164629280567, -0.016723044216632843, -0.0007787523791193962, 0.047546446323394775, -0.041903749108314514, 0.0042950729839503765, 0.024004381150007248, 0.08978792279958725, -0.021274367347359657, 0.01047105249017477, 0.04600348323583603, -0.0019662107806652784, -0.0013440772891044617, 0.04746139794588089, -0.01231054775416851, -0.05260501429438591, -0.05585979297757149, -0.016696147620677948, -0.011940245516598225, 0.022178389132022858, 0.05111826956272125, 0.039886027574539185, 0.05850386619567871, -0.019922558218240738, -0.008283217437565327, 0.012878624722361565, -0.025570325553417206, -0.006058771628886461, 0.013841187581419945, 0.007307559717446566, -0.018071899190545082, -0.005902623757719994, 0.01034399401396513, 0.04238161817193031, 0.006510040257126093, -0.020085323601961136, 0.005502116400748491, -0.04787081480026245, 0.0061867497861385345, 0.02993934601545334, 0.015630122274160385, 0.04014575108885765, -0.038723867386579514, -0.05418603867292404, 0.021519839763641357, -0.03573126345872879, 0.035099588334560394, 0.022754177451133728, 0.017217805609107018, -0.023656832054257393, -0.03566262125968933, 0.021518457680940628, -0.09557029604911804, -0.022704266011714935, -0.001408622250892222, 0.06598807126283646, 0.003420171793550253, 0.009465809911489487, -0.009869844652712345, -0.018685990944504738, -0.03671250864863396, -0.05982478708028793, 0.017386483028531075, 0.04742254689335823, -0.027722984552383423, 0.018680481240153313, -0.012176388874650002, -0.05463014170527458, 0.008262721821665764, 0.0038858307525515556, 0.0412931926548481, -0.001564529025927186, 0.0001119766166084446, 0.06658711284399033, 0.018480852246284485, 0.027028042823076248, -0.012553822249174118, 0.0020184374880045652, -0.02745239809155464, -0.0022353874519467354, 0.009807589463889599, 0.00031168287387117743, 0.019019339233636856, 0.00861729122698307, -0.021095382049679756, 0.018756870180368423, -0.009854176081717014, 0.0412854328751564, -0.000600573664996773, 0.03858751431107521, 0.05038604512810707, 0.05782429128885269, -0.024050338193774223, -0.0058859363198280334, 0.02015163190662861, 0.0036662158090621233, 0.04006072133779526, -0.05646764859557152, -0.015045294538140297, 0.0024977962020784616, 0.04002675786614418, 0.01981004700064659, -0.035803306847810745, -0.015257380902767181, 0.038015179336071014, 0.021542243659496307, -0.017354816198349, 0.038317661732435226, 0.028805788606405258, -0.010259398259222507, -0.019378390163183212, -0.01235345657914877, -0.02697846293449402, 0.011660625226795673, 0.022788407281041145, 0.018786735832691193, 0.04410332068800926, -0.0352415032684803, -0.022374352440238, 0.018367720767855644, -0.01974598690867424, -0.009887713007628918, -0.042773038148880005, -0.004702336620539427, 0.027200600132346153, -0.10495027154684067, 0.010628832504153252, 0.024790756404399872, 0.05253567174077034, 0.043030716478824615, 0.030319608747959137, 0.010089371353387833, -0.08635734021663666, 0.030766665935516357, 0.02178501896560192, -0.02597815729677677, -0.022822732105851173, -0.07320511341094971, -0.0537564717233181, 0.0124595258384943, 0.03397988900542259, -0.0515039823949337, -0.002041826257482171, -0.024191612377762794, -0.017726102843880653, -0.027115007862448692, 0.05565020069479942, 0.059274524450302124, 0.004767070524394512, -0.029081149026751518, -0.014476782642304897, 0.00650616642087698, -0.012257230468094349, 0.00786422286182642, 0.03881876543164253, -0.041735053062438965, -0.002721777418628335, -0.026167994365096092, -0.011854652315378189, -0.02918563410639763, 0.012788288295269012, 0.0019222642295062542, 0.027372444048523903, 0.011378713883459568, -0.010638413019478321, -0.01802678592503071, 0.008785860612988472, -0.021419385448098183, 0.04552093520760536, -0.06982176750898361, 0.004829395562410355, 0.011587759479880333, 0.03342456743121147, 0.011282560415565968, -0.01487993448972702, -0.039847031235694885, 0.04162820428609848, 0.00025531803839839995, -0.05204402282834053, -0.014443752355873585, 0.03852081671357155, -0.04917757585644722, 0.024125542491674423, 0.025908080860972404, 0.04487859457731247, 0.032807521522045135, 0.027884939685463905, -0.03465462103486061, 0.048333361744880676, -0.07550651580095291, -0.004250870086252689, -0.0037110799457877874, -0.0032768300734460354, 0.0010144481202587485, 0.03264839947223663, -0.003314694855362177, -0.0502145029604435, 0.027204513549804688, 0.054712530225515366, -0.020291103050112724, -0.026641687378287315, -0.01245113369077444, 0.03853802755475044, -0.018727868795394897, -0.05827105790376663, -0.048208966851234436, -0.014845297671854496, -0.022600287571549416, -0.012886831536889076, 0.03772883117198944, -0.044521357864141464, 0.02841172367334366, 0.000495085259899497, -0.014190650545060635, 0.014047742821276188, -0.04736778512597084, 0.04802868142724037, 0.05882222205400467, 0.014673796482384205, 0.026717066764831543, 0.08961685746908188, 0.0070593589916825294, 0.025728778913617134, -0.0058107939548790455, -0.014623026363551617, -0.019042421132326126, 0.00610466068610549, 0.012600847519934177, 0.017381029203534126, 0.041908033192157745, -0.005466452334076166, 0.03135872632265091, 0.05845892056822777, 0.004339674022048712, 0.007191938813775778, -0.1069740355014801, -0.021881887689232826, -0.043405551463365555, 0.014443046413362026, 0.0055760834366083145, 0.062313806265592575, -0.004254778381437063, 0.01734892651438713, 0.04577323794364929, 0.0021226154640316963, 0.012297752313315868, -0.003719218308106065, 0.02396349236369133, -0.030729981139302254, 0.09282849729061127, 0.05730825662612915, 0.017046790570020676, -0.030811449512839317, 0.009185617789626122, -0.018753131851553917, -0.017775237560272217, -0.005580088123679161, -0.052710700780153275, 0.0670866072177887, 0.030117057263851166, 0.02452784590423107, 0.00818372331559658, -0.030929695814847946, -0.028583331033587456, 0.029815703630447388, 0.00562208192422986, -0.03142039477825165, -0.04095633327960968, -0.02065025269985199, 0.01177325937896967, 0.005870088003575802, -0.02555096708238125, -0.017281267791986465, -0.04788379743695259, 0.026318175718188286, -0.010539294220507145, 0.035094670951366425, 0.02573017217218876, 0.012217933312058449, -0.024303685873746872, -0.05866871774196625, 0.014405877329409122, -0.011699056252837181, -0.007853036746382713, -0.010502285324037075, -0.06983266025781631, -0.026901183649897575, -0.08905074745416641, 0.015984155237674713, -0.040536798536777496, -0.03901253268122673, 0.0012903152965009212, -0.05755666643381119, 0.0013215324142947793, -0.03594905510544777, -0.05017448589205742, -0.0029237084090709686, -0.003955405205488205, 0.0015123537741601467, -0.001492610783316195, 0.017239032313227654, 0.00858263298869133, 0.027087004855275154, 0.032183513045310974, -0.02810942381620407, -0.02454310469329357, 0.01083737425506115, -0.0033036654349416494, -0.017325006425380707, -0.029976701363921165, -0.04807456582784653, -0.016142792999744415, -0.08479597419500351, 0.06483647972345352, 0.0026954365894198418, -0.0826815664768219, 0.05695195123553276, 0.09913063794374466, 0.04311360418796539, -0.01533159613609314, -0.03361974656581879, -0.03276146948337555, 0.09229808300733566, -0.0015758139779791236, -0.02794530615210533, -0.01768956147134304, -0.006353432312607765, -0.004430350847542286, -0.010718246921896935, 0.022906847298145294, 0.011536573991179466, -0.01415404211729765, 0.015869460999965668, 0.010127155110239983, 0.06102398410439491, 0.05618404597043991, -0.008860803209245205, -0.0804787203669548, -0.012972027994692326, -0.008044631220400333, -0.04689444974064827, -0.06109238788485527, -0.046196963638067245, -0.02650877647101879, -0.009644066914916039, -0.03382514789700508, -0.016080472618341446, 0.025264648720622063, -0.05933408811688423, 0.004320455249398947, -0.047297295182943344, -0.07633712142705917, 0.02229149639606476, 0.03243878856301308, -0.009129598736763, 0.04885947331786156, -0.011006001383066177, 0.05271975323557854, -0.04549315199255943, 0.040427882224321365, -0.03538089618086815, -0.03977011889219284, -0.046933822333812714, -0.0049284459091722965, -0.023711949586868286, 0.02535664290189743, 0.06622809171676636, -0.011573979631066322, 0.019767852500081062, 0.05696495994925499, -0.0003107262891717255, 0.014450861141085625, 0.008212964050471783, 0.009873026050627232, -0.0325910747051239, -0.013110032305121422, -0.013421875424683094, 0.06082811951637268, -0.011908646672964096, -0.04337326064705849, -0.014808966778218746, 0.022538157179951668, 0.019070744514465332, 0.03627076372504234, -0.008229929022490978, 0.04374987632036209, 0.03931460902094841, 0.05910339951515198, -0.01612577587366104, -0.047479722648859024, -0.004478877875953913, 0.012946967966854572, 0.0016768996138125658, -0.008746795356273651, 0.03532698377966881, 0.005708920769393444, 0.0034347570035606623, -0.027487868443131447, 0.024266812950372696, 0.06234164163470268, 0.03498823195695877, 0.042678166180849075, 0.04586730897426605, -0.04594762250781059, -0.0024074087850749493, -0.10185706615447998, 0.012622452341020107, 0.004569974262267351, -0.0036283035296946764, 0.0018864631420001388, -0.021604318171739578, -0.030148079618811607, -0.03498397767543793, 0.010622171685099602, -0.05434843525290489, 0.01952010951936245, -0.050739698112010956, 0.015421082265675068, -0.006433982867747545, 0.004108537919819355, 0.013956268317997456, -0.015032653696835041, -0.058623865246772766, 0.010539992712438107, 0.041804201900959015, 0.015532830730080605, -0.020607803016901016, 0.02136632800102234, 0.010912398807704449, -0.038031626492738724, -0.02936108224093914, -0.026287447661161423, -0.0049222540110349655, -0.01751735992729664, -0.024079279974102974, -0.04184672236442566, 0.027095377445220947, 0.052478041499853134, 0.02250850573182106, -0.06237464025616646, -0.010995590128004551, -0.05626392364501953, 0.004404931794852018, 0.08036135882139206, -0.027586400508880615, 0.019645119085907936, -0.011650032363831997, 0.02081162855029106, 0.05106709524989128, -0.05115007981657982, -0.010563148185610771, -0.03482639417052269, -0.014916232787072659, 0.022114912047982216, -0.01508904155343771, 0.032103486359119415, -0.015864748507738113 ]
<p>Lets say we have a tunelling problem in the picture, where $W_p$ is a finite potential step: </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/aFgQ4.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>If particle is comming from the left a general solutions to the Schrödinger equations for sepparate intervals I, II and II are: </p> <p>\begin{align} \text{I:}&amp; &amp; \psi_1 &amp;= \overbrace{A e^{i\mathcal L x}}^{\psi_{in}} + \overbrace{Be^{-i \mathcal L x}}^{\psi_{re}}&amp; \mathcal L &amp;= \sqrt{\tfrac{2mW}{\hbar^2}}\\ \text{II:}&amp; &amp; \psi_2 &amp;= C e^{\mathcal K x} + De^{-\mathcal K x}&amp; \mathcal K &amp;= \sqrt{-\tfrac{2m(W-W_p)}{\hbar^2}}\\ \text{III:}&amp; &amp; \psi_3 &amp;= \underbrace{E e^{i \mathcal L x}}_{\psi_{tr}}&amp; &amp;\\ \end{align}</p> <p>Where $\psi_{in}$ is an incomming wave, $\psi_{re}$ is a reflected wave and $\psi_{tr}$ is transmitted wave. I used the boundary conditions and got a system of 4 equations: </p> <p>\begin{align} {\tiny\text{boundary}}&amp;{\tiny\text{conditions at x=0:}} &amp; {\tiny\text{boundary conditions}}&amp;{\tiny\text{at x=d:}}\\ A + B &amp;= C + D &amp; Ce^{\mathcal K d} + De^{-\mathcal K d} &amp;= E e^{i \mathcal L d}\\ i \mathcal L A - i \mathcal L B &amp;= \mathcal KC - \mathcal K D &amp; \mathcal K C e^{\mathcal K d} - \mathcal K D e^{-\mathcal K d}&amp;= i \mathcal L E e^{i \mathcal L d} \end{align}</p> <p>So now i decided to calculate coefficient of transmission $T$: </p> <p>\begin{align} T &amp;= \dfrac{|j_{tr}|}{|j_{in}|} \!=\! \Bigg|\dfrac{\dfrac{\hbar }{2mi}\! \left( \dfrac{d\overline{\psi}_{tr}}{dx}\, \psi_{tr} - \dfrac{d \psi_{tr}}{dx}\, \overline{\psi}_{tr} \right)}{\dfrac{\hbar}{2mi} \!\left( \dfrac{d\overline{\psi}_{in}}{dx}\, \psi_{in} - \dfrac{d\psi_{in}}{dx}\, \overline{\psi}_{in} \right) }\Bigg| \!=\! \Bigg|\dfrac{\frac{d}{dx}\big(\overbrace{Ee^{-i\mathcal L x}}^{\text{konjug.}}\big) Ee^{i\mathcal L x} - \frac{d}{dx} \left( Ee^{i\mathcal L x}\right)\! \overbrace{Ee^{-i\mathcal L x}}^{\text{konjug.}}}{ \frac{d}{dx}\big(\underbrace{Ae^{-i\mathcal L x}}_{\text{konjug.}}\big) Ae^{i\mathcal L x} - \frac{d}{dx} \left( Ae^{i\mathcal L x}\right)\! \underbrace{Ae^{-i\mathcal L x}}_{\text{konjug.}}}\Bigg|\! = \nonumber\\ &amp;=\Bigg|\dfrac{-i\mathcal L Ee^{-i\mathcal L x} E e^{i \mathcal L x} - i\mathcal L E e^{i \mathcal L x} Ee^{-i \mathcal L x}}{-i \mathcal L A e^{-i\mathcal L x} Ae^{i \mathcal L x} - i \mathcal L A e^{i \mathcal L x}Ae^{-i \mathcal L x} }\Bigg|=\Bigg|\dfrac{-i\mathcal L E^2 - i\mathcal L E^2}{-i \mathcal L A^2 - i \mathcal L A^2}\Bigg|=\Bigg|\dfrac{-2 i \mathcal L E^2}{-2i\mathcal L A^2}\Bigg| = \frac{|E|^2}{|A|^2} \end{align}</p> <p>It accured to me that if out of 4 system equations i can get amplitude ratio $E/A$, i can calculate $T$ quite easy. Could anyone show me how do i get this ratio?</p>
g4226
[ -0.038507141172885895, -0.031040050089359283, -0.009479282423853874, -0.05753583461046219, 0.04982265084981918, -0.026064429432153702, 0.07224863022565842, -0.007121521979570389, 0.023413633927702904, 0.021346524357795715, -0.008071450516581535, 0.046451225876808167, 0.006331463810056448, 0.0324823372066021, -0.038831375539302826, 0.0009108554222621024, 0.10457400977611542, -0.009150795638561249, -0.024072514846920967, -0.03239030763506889, -0.009458569809794426, 0.03186245262622833, -0.035116251558065414, -0.04746963456273079, -0.0012180195190012455, -0.03400509059429169, -0.02988961897790432, -0.02879311330616474, -0.06263373047113419, 0.036546491086483, -0.012685541063547134, 0.0235119815915823, 0.022229449823498726, -0.029428664594888687, -0.022344959899783134, 0.02619290165603161, 0.032399192452430725, -0.009989168494939804, -0.015779638662934303, 0.0077697536908090115, 0.037256594747304916, -0.03546738624572754, -0.010574380867183208, -0.0017550531774759293, 0.05932816118001938, -0.06106135621666908, -0.007516914047300816, 0.03924860805273056, -0.045875344425439835, -0.008594789542257786, -0.04489510506391525, 0.05818215757608414, 0.014610659331083298, -0.019209470599889755, -0.044192343950271606, 0.05343262851238251, -0.01577361486852169, -0.0406147800385952, 0.037845026701688766, 0.04439485818147659, 0.003511786926537752, -0.05660339072346687, -0.007899665273725986, 0.008148441091179848, 0.06414353102445602, -0.0360620953142643, -0.025324009358882904, -0.01694302447140217, -0.023227864876389503, -0.021982625126838684, 0.0305058341473341, -0.05717168003320694, 0.02160041034221649, -0.03709587827324867, -0.03592368960380554, -0.013183982111513615, 0.007372351363301277, 0.03966791555285454, -0.006580859888345003, 0.015310343354940414, -0.03960585594177246, -0.030025271698832512, -0.007445703260600567, -0.021932268515229225, 0.0085907569155097, 0.05479702353477478, 0.0367099903523922, 0.012746416963636875, -0.002315318677574396, -0.01906431093811989, -0.024529485031962395, -0.03663073852658272, -0.016862640157341957, -0.018240654841065407, 0.07030701637268066, -0.0032905919943004847, -0.04962101951241493, 0.002755890367552638, 0.04571753367781639, -0.018480801954865456, -0.015437105670571327, 0.03610806539654732, -0.005859324708580971, -0.0019309340277686715, -0.0034200295340269804, -0.0035889626014977694, 0.04097071290016174, -0.021799404174089432, -0.0225991103798151, 0.006973195355385542, -0.007022408302873373, -0.05733759328722954, -0.029293356463313103, -0.027257999405264854, -0.0008205408230423927, -0.03343263268470764, -0.030810996890068054, 0.03295556455850601, -0.011468920856714249, 0.03773006796836853, 0.04726964235305786, -0.021157963201403618, 0.02597014605998993, 0.032316043972969055, -0.00992448627948761, 0.009117865934967995, 0.051271963864564896, -0.012627017684280872, 0.0715060904622078, 0.02803150936961174, 0.021154025569558144, -0.021795447915792465, 0.004239212721586227, -0.003251460148021579, -0.005048458464443684, 0.0384029857814312, 0.012941401451826096, -0.024391042068600655, 0.009626658633351326, 0.024326331913471222, -0.024474186822772026, -0.0378284677863121, 0.008137659169733524, -0.04664001241326332, -0.11349371820688248, 0.023190276697278023, -0.018725693225860596, -0.10419980436563492, 0.04569653794169426, -0.037374097853899, 0.02632845751941204, 0.05167291685938835, -0.006717754062265158, 0.042383234947919846, 0.028657887130975723, 0.0009802121203392744, 0.014145506545901299, -0.07954881340265274, -0.0029552262276411057, 0.004128782078623772, -0.01662798412144184, -0.02732658013701439, -0.009543492458760738, -0.01416461169719696, -0.015776444226503372, 0.053631652146577835, -0.023867934942245483, -0.014132466167211533, -0.030272869393229485, -0.06242138147354126, -0.03780495375394821, 0.022594688460230827, 0.057969894260168076, 0.01877490058541298, 0.0507793128490448, 0.1264835000038147, 0.004097325261682272, -0.029546113684773445, 0.02364514395594597, 0.01982213370501995, -0.009857446886599064, 0.008743050508201122, 0.02804245427250862, 0.0011243836488574743, -0.020346658304333687, -0.03517919406294823, -0.018669279292225838, -0.020737413316965103, 0.017577921971678734, -0.013007721863687038, 0.01662859320640564, 0.045918069779872894, 0.0005812367890030146, -0.006923187058418989, -0.025573357939720154, -0.029784437268972397, 0.03578369691967964, -0.04593166708946228, 0.022163547575473785, -0.027730165049433708, 0.02920476906001568, 0.04072468355298042, 0.07872077077627182, -0.03532746434211731, 0.08179794996976852, -0.020784540101885796, 0.0007916783797554672, 0.02423716150224209, -0.008164558559656143, -0.008270575664937496, -0.025855867192149162, -0.02946515381336212, -0.01565368101000786, -0.004368402063846588, -0.06601689010858536, -0.09883417189121246, 0.028672801330685616, 0.014072501100599766, -0.038230523467063904, 0.0382404699921608, 0.003525154897943139, -0.0005243175546638668, 0.037094950675964355, -0.030917087569832802, -0.025877341628074646, 0.016183823347091675, -0.0017362125217914581, 0.030159300193190575, -0.044563982635736465, 0.05623403564095497, -0.0336710587143898, 0.0055275470949709415, 0.00900858175009489, -0.00539758987724781, 0.009598941542208195, 0.07414107024669647, -0.03504296764731407, -0.00950680673122406, 0.001700467080809176, -0.05072162300348282, 0.031317632645368576, -0.017288092523813248, -0.018458211794495583, -0.01709233969449997, 0.0279740858823061, 0.037609588354825974, 0.02816835418343544, 0.010989869013428688, -0.01941940188407898, -0.028309514746069908, -0.02772088721394539, -0.018146591261029243, -0.007711437065154314, 0.014521436765789986, -0.02927318587899208, -0.025940624997019768, -0.027713477611541748, 0.04641086235642433, 0.03773178532719612, -0.04287176579236984, -0.0064408862963318825, 0.013814953155815601, 0.036005884408950806, 0.0038282163441181183, -0.053729914128780365, 0.000004993103630113183, -0.024331778287887573, 0.03436040133237839, -0.0073744431138038635, 0.01639828458428383, 0.02349700778722763, 0.044679366052150726, -0.04235611483454704, 0.04432332515716553, -0.03230425342917442, 0.008900300599634647, 0.016995077952742577, -0.05357740819454193, 0.04311272129416466, 0.006274241488426924, -0.0038446488324552774, -0.02118329145014286, 0.02841080352663994, 0.026679789647459984, 0.03956655412912369, -0.10429812222719193, 0.03877340629696846, 0.049238573759794235, -0.007702747359871864, 0.0454135425388813, -0.03138459473848343, -0.024917298927903175, 0.02668483927845955, 0.09300878643989563, -0.01693357713520527, 0.026951704174280167, 0.06202266737818718, -0.020633772015571594, 0.00037783675361424685, 0.0364699549973011, -0.02144506946206093, 0.05716851353645325, -0.029236409813165665, 0.007902476005256176, 0.05228448659181595, 0.03411445394158363, -0.008771178312599659, 0.002107603708282113, 0.035227347165346146, 0.027794180437922478, 0.03085007332265377, 0.017413264140486717, 0.01553801354020834, -0.05101389065384865, -0.0023229599464684725, 0.035020459443330765, 0.008368570357561111, -0.006878501735627651, 0.016888054087758064, 0.027113251388072968, -0.025746876373887062, -0.03666165471076965, 0.025794653221964836, -0.005437963642179966, -0.011174892075359821, -0.04086712747812271, -0.0969538763165474, 0.019550634548068047, -0.057970061898231506, 0.04146138206124306, 0.025467047467827797, 0.04625064507126808, 0.04366965964436531, 0.0029513309709727764, 0.01666932925581932, -0.040436938405036926, -0.04875688999891281, 0.022081585600972176, 0.011063436046242714, -0.01030681375414133, -0.040290165692567825, -0.06866177171468735, -0.03581126034259796, 0.036280542612075806, 0.022673817351460457, -0.02640237845480442, 0.02947990596294403, 0.03984953835606575, 0.003530861111357808, -0.05138290300965309, -0.03471795469522476, -0.014092993922531605, 0.014677407220005989, -0.025745514780282974, 0.006835844833403826, 0.01707974448800087, 0.05539892613887787, 0.05492418259382248, 0.044852979481220245, -0.007560553029179573, -0.008083213120698929, -0.055897556245326996, 0.017321493476629257, 0.0232206080108881, 0.04846735671162605, -0.06283579766750336, 0.009718531742691994, 0.04211004450917244, -0.007985326461493969, -0.03775111958384514, 0.005624484270811081, 0.011054838076233864, -0.014838553965091705, 0.07521151751279831, -0.0035846661776304245, -0.10285582393407822, -0.04468629136681557, 0.007201838307082653, -0.03011571243405342, -0.001454665558412671, -0.0437590666115284, -0.0018927361816167831, -0.0018190500559285283, 0.0059101334773004055, 0.045991942286491394, -0.04034479334950447, 0.03915432468056679, -0.022880500182509422, 0.005901041906327009, 0.030613740906119347, 0.040133263915777206, -0.014791826717555523, -0.020034221932291985, 0.02471586875617504, -0.0021891461219638586, 0.009777133353054523, 0.015576230362057686, 0.025680840015411377, -0.08152070641517639, 0.023075684905052185, -0.028719462454319, -0.0003956334840040654, -0.010582326911389828, -0.014300460927188396, -0.00993332639336586, -0.03233923390507698, 0.027966268360614777, 0.010510030202567577, -0.00623062951490283, -0.02710890956223011, -0.04630564898252487, 0.0024165636859834194, -0.026430707424879074, 0.028723224997520447, -0.03412516787648201, -0.015115315094590187, 0.002777405548840761, -0.009739025495946407, 0.05310644209384918, 0.020662058144807816, -0.006235826760530472, 0.04755168780684471, 0.004954922944307327, -0.017447572201490402, 0.02860812470316887, -0.008574492298066616, -0.023656409233808517, 0.02189914882183075, -0.03517762944102287, -0.008463972248136997, -0.04708365350961685, 0.01457083411514759, -0.014932539314031601, 0.024696432054042816, -0.020292943343520164, 0.03847295045852661, -0.06252741068601608, 0.005273152608424425, 0.0062328362837433815, -0.03571975976228714, 0.02330925688147545, -0.0102741289883852, -0.006117129232734442, -0.010594841092824936, 0.002841557376086712, 0.09862096607685089, -0.040964074432849884, -0.058331601321697235, 0.008837754838168621, 0.007695173379033804, -0.018961893394589424, 0.02496212348341942, 0.04888905957341194, 0.004206192214041948, 0.005908718332648277, -0.06847967952489853, 0.020244363695383072, 0.060060761868953705, -0.011949288658797741, 0.005625537130981684, 0.0010804029880091548, 0.011577406898140907, -0.01848304085433483, -0.03506775200366974, 0.07376188784837723, -0.004357699304819107, 0.0009544695494696498, 0.006686762440949678, -0.04389320686459541, -0.08032248914241791, 0.05412691459059715, -0.018749507144093513, 0.0596037320792675, 0.0002281440538354218, 0.017329281195998192, -0.015705525875091553, -0.06687740236520767, 0.043859366327524185, -0.02903234027326107, -0.000974364927969873, 0.04998910799622536, -0.05758414417505264, -0.024555129930377007, 0.03632768988609314, -0.003640285227447748, 0.03517448902130127, -0.052016500383615494, 0.016219275072216988, -0.05659414827823639, 0.017883531749248505, 0.04242515563964844, 0.032318875193595886, -0.02684888057410717, -0.003932430408895016, -0.03042583353817463, -0.053893402218818665, 0.02957627922296524, -0.03804881125688553, 0.011146944016218185, 0.044204600155353546, -0.05775248631834984, -0.0003508100635372102, -0.035593971610069275, 0.04472090303897858, -0.023625573143363, 0.043518755584955215, 0.09539403766393661, -0.014926808886229992, 0.04527786374092102, 0.0940680205821991, 0.0015357841039076447, -0.02760513499379158, 0.04056388512253761, 0.004883063491433859, 0.02368776872754097, -0.008772156201303005, -0.040514152497053146, 0.0537060908973217, -0.03383810445666313, -0.02056325599551201, 0.07771910727024078, 0.03120364621281624, -0.02993849106132984, 0.012224658392369747, 0.04166468605399132, -0.0032219074200838804, -0.05029651150107384, -0.01610732078552246, -0.01507954578846693, -0.03087431564927101, 0.00883915089070797, 0.00793085154145956, -0.03031015768647194, 0.01604158617556095, 0.11282523721456528, -0.05012257397174835, 0.026794036850333214, -0.05376845598220825, -0.02671820856630802, -0.008168322965502739, -0.004747862461954355, 0.012221843004226685, 0.03882237523794174, 0.03526823967695236, 0.030023915693163872, 0.009120342321693897, -0.05361531674861908, -0.0007701385184191167, -0.004770346917212009, 0.0395549014210701, -0.01853213459253311, 0.007148503791540861, -0.036996323615312576, 0.020851021632552147, -0.021052440628409386, -0.006047028582543135, 0.009305953979492188, -0.025319436565041542, -0.01564163900911808, 0.05901668220758438, 0.047453027218580246, -0.04178096726536751, 0.0033998042345046997, 0.014694809913635254, -0.02774766832590103, -0.023892337456345558, -0.015192562714219093, 0.03420743718743324, 0.009108250960707664, 0.05258597061038017, -0.060620538890361786, -0.030649619176983833, -0.024500006809830666, 0.014257654547691345, 0.018342381343245506, 0.04283861815929413, -0.052437134087085724, -0.045732300728559494, 0.014224658720195293, 0.03185878321528435, -0.07101136445999146, -0.000015873452866799198, 0.02733522094786167, -0.0074342540465295315, -0.02297048456966877, 0.0008216476999223232, -0.044150929898023605, -0.06617125123739243, 0.06333552300930023, -0.03933253884315491, -0.10726921260356903, -0.031010819599032402, 0.006953537929803133, -0.028977077454328537, 0.03162188455462456, -0.09459094703197479, 0.041608646512031555, 0.033048760145902634, 0.0005988060147501528, 0.060701336711645126, 0.022658972069621086, -0.08081993460655212, -0.0317520871758461, 0.045598652213811874, -0.0811692401766777, -0.011895939707756042, 0.016136936843395233, -0.03633096069097519, -0.04427526146173477, 0.052556827664375305, -0.03754371404647827, 0.016310004517436028, 0.07039722800254822, 0.010632640682160854, -0.005482990760356188, -0.031020382419228554, 0.07602957636117935, 0.08016740530729294, 0.04113113507628441, -0.0035652476362884045, 0.07747030258178711, 0.0030281199142336845, 0.02900618128478527, 0.000408468913519755, 0.03772757202386856, 0.012688596732914448, 0.024988239631056786, -0.043581344187259674, 0.01089328434318304, -0.038814809173345566, 0.08179649710655212, -0.01871492713689804, -0.00042597163701429963, 0.03735171630978584, -0.00575108639895916, 0.07285197079181671, 0.007242318242788315, 0.0242110937833786, 0.020398415625095367, 0.05770433694124222, 0.0011814450845122337, 0.0722682923078537, 0.0005312974099069834, -0.040293071419000626, -0.0317387580871582, -0.004283350892364979, 0.039280567318201065, -0.004474812187254429, -0.10341805964708328, 0.032637130469083786, 0.04163325950503349, 0.0037049399688839912, -0.021398069337010384, 0.013674968853592873, -0.0456673763692379, 0.011948565021157265, 0.015479590743780136, -0.007784885820001364, 0.05357227474451065, -0.03411062806844711, 0.024196546524763107, -0.059285569936037064, 0.00738541828468442, -0.005703907925635576, 0.033776115626096725, 0.01570342294871807, 0.018152011558413506, -0.02271658182144165, -0.013805296272039413, -0.06337407231330872, 0.010208429768681526, -0.01877383328974247, -0.012189808301627636, 0.05140392854809761, -0.0005693458369933069, -0.0072556110098958015, 0.08657816797494888, 0.05169292911887169, -0.027508122846484184, 0.015061220154166222, 0.042070478200912476, -0.018965112045407295, -0.017458723857998848, 0.03988803178071976, -0.02253960259258747, 0.046580951660871506, -0.006299820262938738, -0.019116315990686417, -0.00746184540912509, 0.022401444613933563, -0.049642857164144516, 0.030347812920808792, -0.005074348766356707, -0.026548882946372032, -0.0048289611004292965, 0.01743791066110134, -0.026134397834539413, 0.013681476935744286, 0.018019897863268852, -0.01573079451918602, 0.020687680691480637, -0.023070545867085457, -0.01820622943341732, 0.022144081071019173, 0.025365374982357025, -0.011030425317585468, -0.031728245317935944, -0.09177803248167038, 0.030396537855267525, -0.006239389535039663, -0.012587136588990688, -0.0015211852733045816, -0.004786214325577021, 0.04067699611186981, 0.017006900161504745, 0.013599296100437641, -0.05287880077958107, 0.09252213686704636, 0.02437375672161579, -0.02410634234547615, -0.008465916849672794, -0.013574290089309216, -0.02353520318865776, -0.04154858738183975, 0.004049038514494896, -0.046107761561870575, 0.019704576581716537, -0.031149841845035553, -0.05640057474374771, -0.06223728135228157, -0.015379992313683033, 0.03276937082409859, -0.03488965332508087, -0.005417513195425272, -0.04408309608697891, 0.0010165368439629674, -0.02334580570459366, 0.027311865240335464, 0.024446498602628708, 0.028744937852025032, -0.01655520498752594, -0.05675716698169708, 0.02808743715286255, -0.0643073245882988, 0.05323910340666771, -0.012694157660007477, -0.03863024711608887, 0.021268026903271675, 0.0009531448013149202, 0.026930544525384903, -0.012100580148398876, -0.028888069093227386, -0.04702882096171379, 0.021436812356114388, 0.06118765473365784, -0.05660209432244301, 0.036970820277929306, 0.04269115999341011, -0.01842416636645794, -0.02124292217195034, -0.040734853595495224, -0.019673442468047142, -0.005156776402145624, 0.008184438571333885, 0.0023242849856615067, -0.033951785415410995, 0.0073612951673567295, 0.02286866307258606 ]
<p><a href="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJJuq_pcyIQ" rel="nofollow">http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UJJuq_pcyIQ</a></p> <p>What exactly is going on in the video example? I understand the phenomena occurs because of magnetism but I am trying to figure out the mechanics behind this sculpture. There obviously is a magnet underneath but what is it doing? Is it moving? Is it getting some type of charge? Any insight is great!</p>
g4227
[ 0.01950271613895893, 0.0778241828083992, -0.019242627546191216, -0.024012019857764244, 0.05875968560576439, 0.058724645525217056, 0.036442436277866364, -0.011982381343841553, 0.0038312182296067476, 0.002076484961435199, -0.03623559698462486, 0.026239851489663124, 0.017738446593284607, -0.0051633394323289394, -0.01615670882165432, -0.0031350823119282722, 0.03411124274134636, -0.007306045852601528, 0.028355596587061882, 0.017670145258307457, -0.0026813761796802282, 0.04183558374643326, 0.0012649636482819915, -0.007406258024275303, -0.013610602356493473, 0.033524516969919205, 0.010563361458480358, 0.030657481402158737, 0.02707240916788578, -0.032290857285261154, 0.021878788247704506, -0.024451445788145065, 0.008123964071273804, -0.0116973165422678, -0.056120872497558594, -0.03036382794380188, 0.03699560835957527, 0.0008171417284756899, -0.05773425102233887, 0.05278599634766579, -0.034811001271009445, -0.06805237382650375, 0.012930771335959435, -0.017492396757006645, -0.01727527379989624, -0.004767263308167458, -0.04822313413023949, -0.07353733479976654, -0.044932350516319275, 0.03341967612504959, -0.058000557124614716, -0.01112386491149664, 0.050532229244709015, 0.019604140892624855, 0.040045447647571564, -0.0484212227165699, 0.06950969249010086, 0.0013865998480468988, 0.07016131281852722, 0.006687559653073549, 0.0085567282512784, 0.06244836747646332, 0.025152131915092468, 0.05459930747747421, 0.011028583161532879, -0.01300764735788107, -0.046054400503635406, 0.026345811784267426, 0.03536798059940338, 0.014404072426259518, -0.024638185277581215, 0.00558013841509819, -0.03841264918446541, -0.052546288818120956, -0.048204246908426285, 0.03324928134679794, 0.05382772162556648, -0.005637649912387133, 0.026537572965025902, -0.013524518348276615, -0.013028119690716267, 0.01430397480726242, -0.01578274741768837, 0.011470470577478409, 0.07760009914636612, 0.03146929293870926, -0.04950205236673355, 0.02360716462135315, -0.04978082701563835, -0.008747308515012264, 0.05835133418440819, -0.015425875782966614, 0.045407410711050034, -0.0478077195584774, -0.03514554351568222, -0.06954299658536911, -0.011364532634615898, 0.03844587132334709, -0.029660169035196304, 0.013041707687079906, -0.022552872076630592, -0.031077872961759567, -0.041639067232608795, 0.02470562234520912, 0.02492145076394081, 0.06129831448197365, 0.0029387695249170065, 0.052399978041648865, -0.05505382642149925, 0.03729672357439995, 0.005113175604492426, -0.02941427007317543, -0.025864051654934883, -0.001282839453779161, 0.00652950769290328, -0.010733351111412048, 0.04786735400557518, 0.06462831050157547, 0.039795611053705215, -0.016000136733055115, 0.02124510332942009, 0.028837088495492935, -0.043876297771930695, 0.03216017782688141, -0.05860992893576622, -0.01585307903587818, 0.048231832683086395, -0.004465059377253056, -0.03086506761610508, 0.024314239621162415, 0.02471131458878517, 0.009867513552308083, 0.003977875225245953, -0.03269048035144806, 0.011671405285596848, 0.037685852497816086, 0.0009580105543136597, -0.0027736048214137554, -0.011911463923752308, -0.0026496187783777714, 0.007108649238944054, -0.04607626795768738, 0.020754944533109665, -0.025525065138936043, -0.01925090327858925, 0.009358846582472324, 0.02114175632596016, 0.031089484691619873, 0.0652453675866127, -0.037099480628967285, -0.025639034807682037, 0.09061820805072784, 0.037933349609375, -0.06478016078472137, 0.06930473446846008, -0.035583727061748505, 0.05153791978955269, 0.004204530734568834, 0.03160380944609642, 0.04734742268919945, 0.043867528438568115, -0.04140844941139221, 0.008415436372160912, -0.0037449211813509464, -0.07014979422092438, 0.0009061942691914737, 0.023092735558748245, 0.004312785342335701, 0.005475227255374193, 0.012576380744576454, -0.04282180592417717, -0.05037728697061539, -0.0676666647195816, 0.10953787714242935, 0.002296810271218419, 0.03639589622616768, 0.04777035117149353, -0.04969755560159683, 0.06578948348760605, -0.015407172031700611, -0.027691582217812538, -0.017327452078461647, -0.010895044542849064, -0.0386287160217762, 0.0034872815012931824, 0.0010325206676498055, 0.009832211770117283, 0.08215561509132385, -0.0651681125164032, -0.004402319435030222, -0.06865894049406052, -0.04900175705552101, -0.014698871411383152, 0.060360558331012726, 0.006845044903457165, -0.034784410148859024, -0.011792722158133984, 0.0069955079816281796, -0.027884768322110176, -0.03658458963036537, 0.03743504360318184, -0.011095268651843071, 0.00996780302375555, 0.026535363867878914, -0.0025562054943293333, 0.01071630697697401, -0.049182284623384476, 0.03966852277517319, 0.010455709882080555, 0.028404029086232185, 0.020569922402501106, 0.055029090493917465, 0.02421274036169052, -0.0008779547060839832, -0.061764925718307495, 0.0342477485537529, -0.002272147685289383, -0.03515157848596573, -0.028003448620438576, 0.025831934064626694, 0.0016335779801011086, -0.012680604122579098, 0.008061332628130913, -0.011922627687454224, -0.03596564382314682, -0.026767786592245102, -0.023007508367300034, -0.037843529134988785, 0.027214596047997475, 0.04156025871634483, -0.03374652937054634, -0.00007389552047243342, 0.0026699635200202465, 0.027083907276391983, 0.035846393555402756, 0.03413677215576172, -0.028768260031938553, -0.0000338163627020549, -0.05441052094101906, -0.06049993261694908, -0.020101742818951607, -0.019386470317840576, -0.03800947964191437, -0.07959138602018356, 0.016409577801823616, -0.001290579792112112, 0.037445634603500366, 0.026309028267860413, 0.0010109251597896218, 0.011931425891816616, 0.10340894013643265, -0.09628555923700333, 0.009137030690908432, -0.03394680842757225, 0.010819918476045132, -0.04100478067994118, -0.07098651677370071, 0.038019102066755295, -0.021241480484604836, -0.09494714438915253, 0.011131803505122662, -0.09519722312688828, 0.043674275279045105, 0.04011782258749008, -0.05889953672885895, -0.05576774850487709, -0.005432761739939451, 0.014989566057920456, 0.022901540622115135, -0.01114983856678009, -0.012726927176117897, 0.05346846207976341, -0.03755641728639603, -0.01900556869804859, -0.05910928174853325, 0.012771829031407833, 0.03595251962542534, 0.019961189478635788, 0.026171140372753143, -0.024818653240799904, 0.02935889922082424, 0.022074317559599876, -0.041832566261291504, 0.011154813691973686, 0.0033536541741341352, 0.014971341006457806, -0.0184837207198143, -0.00006136585579952225, -0.06018146127462387, -0.009227927774190903, -0.04367131367325783, -0.04905587062239647, 0.04101090133190155, -0.014082839712500572, -0.014653188176453114, 0.0016858148155733943, 0.0001316964189754799, 0.0014787225518375635, -0.02409909851849079, 0.04690805822610855, 0.03128161281347275, -0.02873939834535122, 0.0086572440341115, -0.013099292293190956, -0.006559022702276707, 0.0697115808725357, 0.054158806800842285, -0.039198197424411774, 0.025404391810297966, -0.0242935623973608, 0.0011405636323615909, 0.016058163717389107, 0.03429773077368736, 0.02500445581972599, 0.016142236068844795, 0.0023936794605106115, -0.06517432630062103, 0.010960161685943604, 0.017346486449241638, 0.00723467068746686, -0.039717428386211395, 0.0010214699432253838, 0.01865074783563614, 0.026406457647681236, 0.057384513318538666, 0.021210387349128723, 0.005428091157227755, 0.001664087874814868, -0.026897039264440536, -0.0018677846528589725, 0.0481145866215229, -0.007920097559690475, -0.07024114578962326, -0.07584130018949509, 0.0035972793120890856, 0.018531646579504013, -0.009441439993679523, 0.042040787637233734, 0.01099457312375307, -0.017748329788446426, -0.016924072057008743, -0.007427861448377371, -0.02528725378215313, -0.008300073444843292, 0.036713723093271255, 0.021638663485646248, -0.026468636468052864, -0.02362298220396042, 0.030936511233448982, -0.011394426226615906, 0.025031937286257744, 0.05996611341834068, 0.0026428638957440853, -0.01515130139887333, -0.019740518182516098, -0.015770891681313515, 0.015632644295692444, 0.0034145403187721968, -0.08767320960760117, 0.0004220041155349463, 0.029663877561688423, -0.011026628315448761, 0.017579110339283943, -0.035690221935510635, -0.0022950717248022556, 0.019014744088053703, -0.009495855309069157, 0.023735828697681427, 0.024129118770360947, -0.014992638491094112, 0.03184731304645538, -0.012849473394453526, -0.054838500916957855, -0.002936512464657426, 0.0015569987008348107, 0.006313657388091087, -0.004797377623617649, -0.005392779130488634, 0.030087919905781746, 0.0002956341195385903, 0.03459431976079941, 0.02138165384531021, 0.010776719078421593, -0.02799391560256481, 0.01638217270374298, 0.05753284692764282, -0.04189944267272949, 0.050342679023742676, 0.00565251475200057, -0.0899943932890892, -0.0038948841392993927, 0.04759940505027771, -0.013590431772172451, 0.010389654897153378, 0.020881526172161102, -0.034953828901052475, 0.003987201489508152, -0.03534698486328125, 0.03559161722660065, -0.06405002623796463, 0.05128883570432663, 0.045443594455718994, -0.05230332538485527, 0.027674956247210503, 0.015970218926668167, 0.032472118735313416, 0.02850547805428505, -0.049616072326898575, 0.04984697327017784, -0.008994456380605698, 0.004908953793346882, 0.060363393276929855, -0.028274085372686386, -0.08071096241474152, 0.03528527915477753, 0.02480093203485012, -0.03327663615345955, 0.05582490190863609, -0.029491247609257698, -0.014893393963575363, 0.056549377739429474, 0.08960894495248795, 0.024874724447727203, 0.01464070100337267, -0.03470143303275108, 0.025521578267216682, 0.035870134830474854, 0.039617352187633514, -0.044297218322753906, -0.07648201286792755, -0.026744987815618515, 0.06828629970550537, -0.009607760235667229, -0.020572029054164886, -0.04026874154806137, 0.07092329114675522, -0.044162817299366, -0.014921552501618862, 0.026018895208835602, 0.05745786800980568, 0.059005625545978546, 0.020020566880702972, 0.023117706179618835, -0.005729250144213438, -0.007152657490223646, -0.0030463668517768383, -0.021832358092069626, -0.018845006823539734, 0.035525500774383545, -0.07699880748987198, -0.048869114369153976, 0.023236973211169243, -0.040313173085451126, -0.05465393885970116, 0.06541575491428375, 0.00681312894448638, 0.031683359295129776, -0.024098819121718407, -0.03134485334157944, 0.00887973327189684, -0.036418333649635315, 0.0007603750564157963, -0.026815487071871758, 0.008298036642372608, 0.007526673376560211, -0.024063145741820335, 0.009015969932079315, -0.07678655534982681, 0.033820122480392456, -0.0036928849294781685, 0.011129448190331459, -0.0041987281292676926, 0.016536131501197815, -0.0010486328974366188, 0.046814776957035065, -0.017445502802729607, 0.017223600298166275, 0.010767142288386822, 0.062089819461107254, -0.04818686097860336, -0.0023342997301369905, 0.06872379034757614, 0.03755275905132294, -0.052342191338539124, -0.03788469359278679, -0.03470413759350777, -0.07768433541059494, 0.049159348011016846, -0.0019554931204766035, -0.02078694850206375, -0.0091679897159338, -0.018028194084763527, 0.0006361018167808652, -0.029396837577223778, -0.005979100242257118, -0.0013406665530055761, 0.01905428059399128, 0.05232040956616402, 0.002844808390364051, -0.009345097467303276, 0.025713903829455376, -0.03778805211186409, -0.010354588739573956, 0.013032272458076477, 0.018163731321692467, 0.02995152585208416, 0.03304342180490494, -0.0053296685218811035, 0.036236125975847244, 0.04865853860974312, -0.05437528342008591, 0.01703505404293537, 0.0038263946771621704, -0.018610894680023193, 0.015380297787487507, 0.0050325035117566586, -0.007381977513432503, -0.010280696675181389, -0.0046508884988725185, 0.03445613384246826, -0.0016793499235063791, -0.021314896643161774, 0.016332507133483887, -0.10350887477397919, 0.01857583411037922, -0.0008611335651949048, 0.0030443109571933746, -0.009490943513810635, 0.01582702063024044, 0.052968669682741165, -0.03273530304431915, -0.06136300414800644, 0.06035085394978523, 0.0234073419123888, -0.007816208526492119, -0.021249983459711075, 0.05440853163599968, -0.047043971717357635, 0.018823394551873207, 0.028328143060207367, 0.04326457902789116, -0.060037191957235336, 0.02653614990413189, 0.06257105618715286, -0.013600486330688, -0.0054492708295583725, 0.041641294956207275, -0.01763417385518551, 0.061294764280319214, -0.002011651638895273, -0.01290928479284048, 0.04402979090809822, 0.013884478248655796, 0.06490401178598404, 0.027439845725893974, 0.002775460248813033, -0.08058812469244003, -0.05635695904493332, 0.004814027808606625, -0.05552012845873833, 0.08770159631967545, 0.007919836789369583, 0.006073551718145609, -0.029905566945672035, 0.0471196211874485, -0.019202763214707375, -0.002834930783137679, -0.014921720139682293, 0.05733494088053703, 0.06121770665049553, 0.0035250470973551273, -0.017991216853260994, -0.03865080326795578, -0.004085151012986898, -0.00032015301985666156, 0.04623749107122421, -0.04217368736863136, -0.006734174210578203, -0.09257849305868149, -0.0049072145484387875, 0.06498017907142639, 0.01575918309390545, 0.06880073249340057, 0.017739312723279, -0.012120665982365608, 0.06261618435382843, -0.08369779586791992, 0.005114690866321325, 0.007728649768978357, -0.06242348626255989, -0.04058114066720009, 0.022422954440116882, -0.027162233367562294, -0.03068011999130249, -0.03491406887769699, -0.03812742605805397, -0.012760014273226261, 0.03986964002251625, 0.004727240186184645, -0.010739482007920742, -0.03582172840833664, -0.008062145672738552, -0.012994290329515934, -0.02236487716436386, 0.03131932392716408, -0.015523438341915607, 0.00963203888386488, 0.014847788959741592, -0.029730187729001045, 0.01912098191678524, -0.014118867926299572, 0.07854510843753815, -0.05585862323641777, -0.008361157961189747, -0.01157253049314022, -0.0037840690929442644, -0.011328138411045074, -0.007976587861776352, 0.02291971631348133, -0.017584368586540222, -0.04101797938346863, -0.036717113107442856, 0.0222274512052536, -0.04871301352977753, 0.012277687899768353, -0.019645465537905693, -0.046179551631212234, 0.01628001220524311, -0.0032179669942706823, -0.011815047822892666, -0.05714918673038483, 0.02422238327562809, 0.03106868453323841, 0.02195741981267929, 0.008282141759991646, 0.012494944036006927, 0.04421088844537735, -0.002471259329468012, 0.07495128363370895, 0.02913903258740902, 0.026885639876127243, -0.032832611352205276, -0.0327129140496254, 0.007390259765088558, -0.012905758805572987, 0.020828908309340477, -0.018013350665569305, -0.011208007112145424, -0.024233875796198845, -0.021911006420850754, -0.03525374084711075, -0.04529275745153427, 0.007041817530989647, -0.007179168984293938, -0.05153445154428482, 0.04304423928260803, -0.013303086161613464, -0.030057961121201515, 0.04899338260293007, -0.06069439277052879, -0.06217066943645477, 0.03333752602338791, -0.02961568534374237, -0.007566685322672129, 0.010040270164608955, 0.00970753189176321, -0.02827947586774826, -0.007976948283612728, 0.0032945009879767895, 0.001749697607010603, -0.021152811124920845, -0.02789781056344509, 0.03875429183244705, 0.019002003595232964, -0.024085400626063347, 0.006614895537495613, 0.013292263261973858, 0.052345938980579376, -0.0003301716933492571, -0.0030621213372796774, 0.024554645642638206, 0.05114324763417244, 0.006722554098814726, -0.023354198783636093, 0.0030210153199732304, -0.00506354495882988, -0.05382104963064194, 0.032945044338703156, -0.06701578944921494, 0.0014381224755197763, 0.056913528591394424, 0.028638076037168503, 0.011994168162345886, 0.03461877629160881, 0.0009354705107398331, 0.029787959530949593, 0.011716118082404137, 0.005857355426996946, 0.0026864521205425262, 0.0011932926718145609, -0.040295008569955826, 0.00025572293088771403, -0.006642078515142202, 0.02330862544476986, 0.023807937279343605, -0.02243145741522312, -0.022584093734622, 0.007051015738397837, -0.016891250386834145, 0.026747334748506546, 0.005084550939500332, 0.008187985979020596, 0.022264139726758003, -0.0750153511762619, 0.015521726571023464, 0.10315266251564026, -0.02068425342440605, 0.04319770261645317, -0.01791824959218502, 0.04141728952527046, -0.06915359199047089, 0.06685765087604523, -0.01701895147562027, -0.08790234476327896, -0.04839710891246796, -0.029358992353081703, 0.021423177793622017, 0.000042499974370002747, -0.01645299606025219, 0.026303455233573914, -0.014671459794044495, 0.004796928260475397, -0.03533461317420006, -0.0372094064950943, -0.04934195429086685, -0.015102913603186607, 0.029814673587679863, -0.04583872854709625, 0.05628135800361633, -0.053662147372961044, 0.018914073705673218, -0.0021054537501186132, -0.04138152673840523, -0.004931848030537367, -0.035994913429021835, 0.0451677069067955, -0.031885262578725815, 0.05419560521841049, 0.0049103256314992905, -0.04561377316713333, 0.053134385496377945, -0.02420981414616108, -0.0014574084198102355, -0.048263903707265854, -0.023844704031944275, -0.05289814621210098, -0.046193819493055344, 0.07429486513137817, 0.04802185297012329, -0.0030963686294853687, 0.010177750140428543, -0.013824614696204662, -0.06770248711109161, -0.02356261946260929, -0.0008969319169409573, -0.011953064240515232, -0.027878403663635254, -0.007667681202292442 ]
<p>Lets say we have a particle of mass $m_1$ which has a kinetic energy $W_{k1}$. This particle collides with another same particle. How can i calculate mass $m_2$ and the speed $v_2$ of the particle which is formed out of the colliding two particles? </p> <p>I know that relativistic preservation of energy $W$ and momentum $p$ must hold and i know these equations: </p> <p>\begin{align} W^2 &amp;= p^2c^2 + {W_0}^2\\ W &amp;= W_k + W_0\\ W &amp;= mc^2 \gamma(v)\\ p &amp;= mv\gamma(v)\\ \end{align}</p> <hr> <p>My attempt was something like this: </p> <p>\begin{align} p_2 &amp;= p_1\\ p_2 c&amp;= p_1 c\\ {p_2}^2 c^2&amp;= {p_1}^2 c^2\\ {W_1}^2-{W_{01}}^2 &amp;= {W_2}^2-{W_{02}}^2 \longleftarrow \smash{\substack{\text{Doesnt it hold that $W_1 = W_2$?}\\ \text{Can i cross them out to get}\\\text{the line below?}}}\\ {W_{01}}^2 &amp;= {W_{02}}^2\\ \left(2m_1c^2\right)^2 &amp;= \left(m_2 c^2\right)^2\\ 4{m_1}^2c^4 &amp;= {m_2}^2 c^4\\ m_2 &amp;= 2m_1 \end{align}</p> <p>Is this even correct? My professor said it is not... Why?</p>
g4228
[ 0.08035972714424133, -0.05943339690566063, 0.007453046273440123, 0.015848776325583458, 0.07071637362241745, 0.023283883929252625, 0.0008128167246468365, 0.00947296991944313, -0.07351361960172653, 0.03154812008142471, 0.033720411360263824, 0.052469462156295776, 0.0014182666782289743, -0.0001952891325345263, -0.024577682837843895, -0.009695898741483688, 0.117629773914814, -0.01131243072450161, 0.005586795508861542, 0.05807659775018692, -0.057812150567770004, -0.01848483644425869, -0.004641305655241013, -0.0010769236832857132, -0.004938420373946428, -0.030582746490836143, 0.017237402498722076, -0.03872362896800041, -0.039326634258031845, -0.005812837276607752, 0.031221069395542145, -0.0010046863462775946, 0.038948312401771545, -0.0570499561727047, -0.029380405321717262, -0.024540236219763756, 0.06179329752922058, -0.08848929405212402, -0.02382787875831127, 0.025092262774705887, 0.026005806401371956, 0.0006756354123353958, 0.04379909113049507, -0.0049408976919949055, 0.06777404248714447, 0.0012641128851100802, -0.026017483323812485, -0.03604470193386078, -0.026120878756046295, -0.010126267559826374, -0.04984814673662186, 0.07522135972976685, -0.003841065801680088, -0.009876284748315811, -0.03679945692420006, 0.009955734945833683, 0.07688303291797638, -0.0200851708650589, 0.09508237987756729, 0.0257879588752985, 0.0325797013938427, -0.056618910282850266, 0.04343955218791962, -0.0035651649814099073, 0.03725406900048256, -0.0767996683716774, -0.04567902162671089, 0.012505455873906612, 0.026127701625227928, 0.008962971158325672, -0.025096893310546875, -0.0006154664442874491, 0.025580627843737602, -0.023133741691708565, 0.0330021046102047, -0.03525736182928085, 0.02844659984111786, -0.030870512127876282, 0.014670759439468384, 0.010078933089971542, -0.03852859511971474, 0.05594225972890854, 0.027124635875225067, -0.030521081760525703, 0.009506762959063053, -0.035565149039030075, 0.01895691268146038, 0.03014977276325226, -0.0842050090432167, -0.01385401375591755, 0.03544287011027336, -0.029624441638588905, 0.03846893459558487, 0.019568143412470818, 0.019236838445067406, -0.022603614255785942, -0.0719042494893074, 0.04463188722729683, -0.00819311197847128, -0.002979714423418045, 0.030704328790307045, -0.018953314051032066, 0.0011646621860563755, 0.02513669617474079, 0.05580797791481018, -0.047097355127334595, 0.0033488040789961815, 0.04635261744260788, -0.0169337447732687, -0.014138396829366684, 0.027940265834331512, -0.08611492812633514, 0.05614931508898735, -0.0152328135445714, -0.06371419876813889, -0.06490548700094223, 0.043296102434396744, 0.011375467292964458, 0.012094231322407722, 0.037867866456508636, 0.048924025148153305, -0.006865243427455425, -0.022581372410058975, 0.04040466248989105, 0.029582446441054344, -0.03948621824383736, -0.019118189811706543, -0.004314846359193325, 0.029339754953980446, -0.009451278485357761, -0.009115474298596382, -0.0175111535936594, 0.08439119905233383, 0.04719828441739082, -0.05018416419625282, -0.019781367853283882, 0.057471536099910736, 0.03899858146905899, -0.03178080916404724, -0.028551481664180756, 0.011508812196552753, 0.03054507076740265, 0.027090657502412796, -0.03275870531797409, -0.10801555961370468, 0.054772235453128815, -0.00969396810978651, -0.051373664289712906, 0.021722549572587013, 0.03330736607313156, -0.005139096640050411, 0.040138132870197296, -0.01786959543824196, 0.018208639696240425, 0.0406813770532608, -0.008623349480330944, 0.012778965756297112, -0.0017613330855965614, -0.0008859913796186447, 0.023601073771715164, 0.09568864852190018, -0.051127370446920395, 0.01802709326148033, -0.02031620219349861, -0.011528224684298038, 0.0003828591725323349, 0.03917533904314041, -0.051430992782115936, -0.03902508318424225, -0.061576079577207565, -0.05455753952264786, -0.056168995797634125, -0.0007312081870622933, 0.06296925246715546, -0.0016442016931250691, 0.006450317334383726, -0.03417108207941055, -0.006043553818017244, -0.015176982618868351, -0.00733939278870821, 0.0018097878200933337, -0.029863787814974785, 0.05374753475189209, 0.004095146898180246, 0.008651552721858025, -0.020540107041597366, -0.027180910110473633, 0.09739251434803009, -0.0623350590467453, 0.017121553421020508, -0.015577235259115696, 0.0057066660374403, -0.025894049555063248, 0.01723577082157135, 0.020166974514722824, 0.05398555472493172, 0.050114937126636505, -0.030309194698929787, -0.032829463481903076, 0.03447887673974037, -0.027806168422102928, 0.07512902468442917, -0.01102052815258503, 0.012263061478734016, 0.04682515189051628, -0.007546597626060247, 0.0348229855298996, 0.0024790933821350336, 0.010515687987208366, 0.011258705519139767, 0.056383371353149414, 0.0015750281745567918, -0.03622535243630409, -0.02909310907125473, -0.021278470754623413, -0.01864355243742466, 0.0026484618429094553, 0.0068435342982411385, -0.04870104789733887, -0.03660181537270546, -0.07495205849409103, -0.006468901876360178, 0.04021583870053291, -0.04606427252292633, -0.02002318948507309, -0.008588025346398354, -0.07912435382604599, -0.009412018582224846, 0.0010453435825183988, 0.03609644994139671, -0.00481465645134449, 0.06891009211540222, -0.04904868081212044, 0.0010430198162794113, 0.03784496337175369, 0.05768986791372299, -0.023994365707039833, 0.0187344029545784, 0.01331945601850748, 0.022485703229904175, 0.031954724341630936, -0.06183875724673271, 0.0027220253832638264, -0.016389425843954086, 0.015575534664094448, -0.0446256659924984, 0.07247911393642426, 0.019626516848802567, 0.01410235371440649, 0.01692168600857258, 0.010543877258896828, -0.022497860714793205, -0.04892357811331749, -0.03005494736135006, 0.018253380432724953, -0.03723395615816116, -0.023877110332250595, 0.08125610649585724, -0.08403215557336807, -0.04349120706319809, 0.017667554318904877, 0.017331043258309364, -0.03453006595373154, 0.04602701589465141, 0.00323879043571651, -0.04827478155493736, -0.008890724740922451, 0.048536594957113266, 0.033141329884529114, 0.01630447618663311, -0.01619994267821312, -0.0029075436759740114, -0.02442663162946701, 0.010584204457700253, -0.02704888954758644, -0.0639318898320198, 0.020954784005880356, -0.07999098300933838, 0.040642667561769485, 0.016065357252955437, -0.020735375583171844, 0.03861071914434433, -0.03265351429581642, -0.00972958467900753, 0.026291027665138245, -0.11733418703079224, -0.023549841716885567, 0.025911875069141388, 0.0022240872494876385, 0.032238852232694626, -0.008942610584199429, 0.04630996659398079, 0.016296567395329475, 0.02162613347172737, 0.06233961135149002, 0.025931870564818382, 0.01882699877023697, -0.01443708036094904, -0.029164180159568787, -0.02323879674077034, 0.029461368918418884, 0.0023143505677580833, -0.040251195430755615, 0.013277011923491955, 0.03541024029254913, 0.032387953251600266, -0.06428621709346771, -0.012909677810966969, 0.07562122493982315, -0.031967706978321075, 0.006277114152908325, 0.08386717736721039, 0.0016088810516521335, 0.021612100303173065, -0.026287177577614784, -0.017153004184365273, 0.014001956209540367, -0.02306726574897766, -0.023237096145749092, 0.0360640287399292, -0.016133146360516548, -0.024915620684623718, 0.05257681384682655, 0.006876735016703606, 0.0014528704341500998, 0.0071434821002185345, -0.057823680341243744, 0.01216710451990366, -0.032777089625597, -0.0024786987341940403, 0.009296352043747902, 0.023919615894556046, -0.006874821614474058, -0.006962781772017479, 0.04118841513991356, -0.03185238689184189, 0.020190071314573288, -0.016828713938593864, 0.025393106043338776, 0.020989548414945602, 0.018860802054405212, 0.023607011884450912, -0.02960515022277832, 0.02724533900618553, -0.016160814091563225, -0.010336736217141151, 0.053627390414476395, -0.01653851754963398, 0.017904192209243774, -0.06825366616249084, 0.023687859997153282, 0.006385320797562599, -0.017001060768961906, -0.03709975630044937, -0.03949499875307083, 0.025479450821876526, -0.02878458797931671, 0.04412059113383293, 0.012982194311916828, 0.00988028384745121, -0.008050015196204185, -0.04104975610971451, 0.004767175763845444, -0.003237291006371379, -0.035195667296648026, -0.02352498285472393, -0.06134803965687752, 0.001676841638982296, 0.031488142907619476, -0.0203576497733593, -0.031669147312641144, -0.0282579492777586, -0.020516056567430496, 0.04572117701172829, -0.05493226647377014, -0.025435902178287506, 0.03853990137577057, 0.014860373921692371, -0.018942883238196373, -0.013832857832312584, 0.03119249828159809, -0.047940172255039215, -0.06549494713544846, 0.03510203957557678, -0.005443125497549772, 0.016659433022141457, -0.037588540464639664, -0.004367674235254526, 0.030436867848038673, -0.013264584355056286, 0.005330484360456467, -0.03167407587170601, -0.05792084336280823, -0.021348532289266586, 0.01215660385787487, -0.004033215343952179, 0.03246660530567169, -0.030275683850049973, -0.00962177012115717, 0.0012692970922216773, -0.05914577096700668, 0.0589129664003849, -0.021001914516091347, -0.07463102042675018, 0.004219417925924063, 0.0023690620437264442, 0.02805945836007595, 0.000643696344923228, 0.04228364676237106, -0.0002127882034983486, 0.0077438331209123135, -0.0010896504390984774, 0.03860199451446533, -0.030301498249173164, -0.0200460497289896, -0.015480803325772285, -0.03593812510371208, -0.013508266769349575, 0.012590344063937664, -0.008595401421189308, -0.017848636955022812, 0.0192366074770689, 0.0141430189833045, -0.044101063162088394, 0.017710590735077858, 0.037551745772361755, 0.05446339398622513, -0.018025778234004974, -0.004438408184796572, 0.016987785696983337, 0.08682256191968918, 0.02584362030029297, -0.0021050218492746353, -0.01183505542576313, -0.0411241240799427, 0.019925545901060104, 0.007901575416326523, 0.011312871240079403, 0.015507407486438751, 0.06369055807590485, 0.030537908896803856, -0.018941879272460938, 0.013761183246970177, -0.014951815828680992, 0.023464305326342583, 0.061948262155056, -0.04209792613983154, -0.02954479120671749, -0.030438728630542755, -0.04846121370792389, 0.021158913150429726, -0.0049517154693603516, 0.019587909802794456, -0.02046295441687107, 0.007469257805496454, -0.01740473322570324, -0.04535267502069473, 0.030738651752471924, 0.02751241996884346, 0.01727362908422947, -0.05164320394396782, 0.019363611936569214, 0.12167499214410782, -0.04445615038275719, 0.024954264983534813, -0.023455386981368065, -0.03499449044466019, 0.0023139093536883593, -0.06558409333229065, -0.02217804826796055, 0.012374693527817726, -0.023865660652518272, -0.03412412106990814, -0.03194410726428032, 0.004128221422433853, -0.008452796377241611, -0.09448512643575668, -0.002458064118400216, 0.050224386155605316, -0.01142390538007021, 0.007193549070507288, -0.00290593015961349, -0.005452193785458803, 0.009589534252882004, 0.026805367320775986, 0.026307709515094757, -0.06286773830652237, 0.04792330041527748, 0.025136485695838928, -0.005660082213580608, 0.010972217656672001, 0.03572222590446472, -0.008256695233285427, -0.011051779612898827, 0.05739317461848259, 0.018690504133701324, -0.010095874778926373, -0.021371114999055862, 0.023922188207507133, 0.01339348591864109, -0.039243120700120926, -0.007359913084656, -0.019549841061234474, 0.025615645572543144, 0.01179827656596899, 0.06698183715343475, 0.05877405405044556, 0.03130287677049637, -0.022141234949231148, 0.018218716606497765, 0.013919566757977009, 0.007084371987730265, 0.061922721564769745, -0.005827935878187418, 0.03016866371035576, 0.028116358444094658, 0.07720436900854111, 0.0019616414792835712, -0.010294785723090172, -0.06057635694742203, 0.04881257936358452, 0.006803398486226797, 0.005324497353285551, 0.04961809515953064, -0.01918020099401474, -0.008109720423817635, -0.054555509239435196, -0.03606807813048363, -0.00628405436873436, 0.034542638808488846, 0.022015463560819626, -0.08650261908769608, 0.010264182463288307, 0.016929959878325462, -0.05419657751917839, -0.0602283738553524, -0.035163044929504395, -0.012570775113999844, -0.0026653294917196035, -0.010127637535333633, -0.00979788787662983, -0.007310169283300638, 0.015791254118084908, 0.07775918394327164, 0.03632077947258949, 0.026309549808502197, -0.031333573162555695, -0.024407830089330673, -0.015978163108229637, -0.02918219566345215, -0.007810719311237335, 0.006303027272224426, 0.010149767622351646, -0.03759119287133217, 0.025967556983232498, -0.02353820763528347, 0.017602935433387756, -0.01486709900200367, -0.020513517782092094, -0.029700756072998047, 0.00577137153595686, 0.0017157786060124636, 0.016887709498405457, 0.003217195626348257, -0.001843610662035644, -0.023745940998196602, -0.014970283955335617, -0.00792772602289915, 0.056996606290340424, -0.021346235647797585, 0.010860372334718704, 0.03218008577823639, -0.04205179587006569, -0.017684845253825188, 0.03871815279126167, 0.023063387721776962, -0.001783129759132862, 0.027988651767373085, -0.00565652921795845, -0.057346098124980927, 0.05542821064591408, 0.0033381031826138496, -0.01635160483419895, -0.08400031924247742, -0.016507938504219055, 0.04776463657617569, -0.0010884373914450407, -0.027397722005844116, 0.02317284606397152, 0.017667915672063828, 0.02695091813802719, 0.019619669765233994, -0.015968527644872665, -0.04014253243803978, -0.047432150691747665, -0.029080452397465706, -0.05095900967717171, -0.016667932271957397, -0.006923676934093237, 0.07294663041830063, 0.019721994176506996, 0.024440577253699303, 0.01799946092069149, -0.011285090819001198, -0.0038192213978618383, 0.04074633866548538, -0.10050556063652039, 0.012948908843100071, -0.0055899424478411674, -0.0041385190561413765, -0.08826176077127457, 0.0332537442445755, -0.008805857971310616, 0.001171871437691152, -0.03621838614344597, 0.005141132511198521, -0.0016802492318674922, 0.04285162687301636, -0.025125661864876747, -0.024746302515268326, 0.05276919901371002, 0.0025510371197015047, 0.016497723758220673, -0.022694181650877, 0.007143984083086252, 0.031622514128685, -0.031414348632097244, 0.054765213280916214, 0.05481932684779167, 0.003740070154890418, -0.00014078061212785542, -0.04639636352658272, -0.0010001558111980557, 0.0270195584744215, 0.028432948514819145, 0.06295235455036163, 0.006817089393734932, 0.01200433261692524, -0.01278492622077465, 0.03599773347377777, 0.030571287497878075, 0.01788717322051525, 0.05112702026963234, 0.018807344138622284, -0.06352188438177109, -0.009945621713995934, 0.048233941197395325, -0.035926759243011475, -0.06892922520637512, -0.03800053894519806, -0.07510366290807724, 0.009994158521294594, 0.001221788115799427, 0.019149502739310265, -0.010152596980333328, 0.02167941816151142, -0.04397568106651306, -0.010610964149236679, 0.05971658602356911, 0.0026836367323994637, 0.019908536225557327, -0.04312499612569809, 0.02215447463095188, -0.04828351363539696, -0.0025579887442290783, 0.035707440227270126, -0.017633898183703423, -0.02711985819041729, 0.019583305343985558, -0.028102103620767593, -0.03517862781882286, -0.06378965824842453, -0.05759093910455704, 0.0075928526930511, -0.018940044566988945, -0.0015470541547983885, 0.00618371507152915, 0.022817444056272507, -0.022108830511569977, -0.011419475078582764, 0.011895440518856049, 0.018976885825395584, -0.021719811484217644, 0.03743908554315567, 0.023344388231635094, 0.05521786957979202, -0.008421041071414948, 0.017665036022663116, 0.008384748362004757, 0.03390205278992653, -0.0123821459710598, 0.03474574163556099, 0.04282332956790924, -0.02726486138999462, -0.005621291231364012, -0.014375987462699413, 0.006143477279692888, 0.05570032447576523, -0.004826090764254332, 0.01419906411319971, 0.04497288912534714, -0.025327319279313087, 0.04019326716661453, 0.014794083312153816, -0.017482491210103035, 0.02659689076244831, -0.016636552289128304, -0.06902394443750381, -0.024729857221245766, 0.015259544365108013, 0.02495316043496132, 0.004402381367981434, 0.02559199184179306, -0.03506338596343994, 0.05348662659525871, -0.06707820296287537, -0.024586260318756104, 0.03851143270730972, 0.06208621710538864, -0.016764946281909943, -0.005949539598077536, -0.015561231411993504, -0.035810720175504684, -0.10697025805711746, 0.03237120062112808, -0.05617254972457886, 0.002812799299135804, 0.03523056209087372, -0.044292815029621124, 0.0410027913749218, -0.014013232663273811, 0.021497132256627083, -0.05937286838889122, 0.018117453902959824, 0.029973162338137627, -0.012190012261271477, -0.0012109685922041535, -0.021243588998913765, -0.04326845705509186, 0.005451084580272436, -0.028390366584062576, -0.06623652577400208, -0.00041433164733462036, 0.005424517672508955, -0.040314026176929474, -0.04027516767382622, 0.034874383360147476, 0.050981469452381134, 0.07438326627016068, -0.01098613440990448, 0.06621792167425156, 0.007668721955269575, -0.03808683529496193, 0.07940516620874405, 0.06299865990877151, -0.10005396604537964, 0.03457910940051079, -0.0018956847488880157, -0.04070558026432991, -0.002148723928257823, -0.013016149401664734, -0.02739124931395054, -0.014800957404077053, -0.008859585039317608, 0.049145475029945374, -0.01452343538403511, -0.022645484656095505, -0.005379307083785534 ]
<p>In 2009, Rowan University released a paper claiming to replicate Blacklight Power's results on energy generation using hydrino states of the hydrogen atom. <a href="http://www.blacklightpower.com/pdf/BLPIndependentReport.pdf" rel="nofollow">The paper</a> appears to describe the procedure in every detail as far as my untrained eye can tell.</p> <p>Has anyone else attempted to replicate these results and did they succeed?</p>
g60
[ 0.010936659760773182, 0.005038148257881403, 0.014144043438136578, -0.006861526984721422, 0.015611929818987846, -0.058683834969997406, -0.029506923630833626, 0.07861601561307907, -0.04529176652431488, -0.0005652133841067553, 0.06575975567102432, -0.016425814479589462, 0.025342155247926712, -0.04015961289405823, 0.011430174112319946, 0.010072401724755764, 0.05581297725439072, 0.020452262833714485, -0.013506456278264523, -0.008442753925919533, -0.026983143761754036, 0.017223872244358063, -0.0551924854516983, -0.027401776984333992, -0.006528057157993317, -0.015532631427049637, -0.036982230842113495, -0.05394037812948227, -0.06257311254739761, -0.05501969903707504, 0.012153161689639091, -0.007418926805257797, 0.05032068490982056, -0.019882384687662125, -0.04215580224990845, 0.0626920610666275, 0.003777609206736088, 0.019047921523451805, -0.0046504344791173935, 0.019651472568511963, 0.015378827229142189, 0.0005830225418321788, -0.04160723835229874, -0.019573863595724106, 0.004473112989217043, -0.008315746672451496, 0.05084080249071121, -0.0073322816751897335, -0.03470097482204437, 0.00833360105752945, 0.03353632241487503, 0.046647991985082626, 0.10174053907394409, -0.012464025989174843, 0.04312635958194733, 0.012940777465701103, -0.04212380200624466, -0.03827226907014847, 0.025902677327394485, 0.03099016286432743, -0.03494546189904213, 0.03453349322080612, 0.020491620525717735, -0.003382529830560088, 0.06251774728298187, -0.012593649327754974, -0.01827869564294815, -0.012300902977585793, -0.04807474836707115, 0.01372339017689228, 0.02222035638988018, -0.011857599951326847, -0.021912751719355583, 0.00334076932631433, 0.03932483494281769, 0.008395767770707607, 0.028677554801106453, -0.003493562340736389, -0.005125370342284441, 0.03740749880671501, -0.036143552511930466, -0.06990250200033188, 0.00827876664698124, 0.059337176382541656, 0.07943254709243774, 0.02793235145509243, -0.012055928818881512, 0.05606263503432274, 0.03966377303004265, -0.00011257251026108861, 0.022983862087130547, 0.015026192180812359, 0.05285422131419182, -0.056914713233709335, -0.01953785866498947, -0.004342804662883282, -0.009986979886889458, 0.028741048648953438, 0.03903340548276901, 0.04758578911423683, -0.05563109740614891, 0.018977414816617966, 0.020863063633441925, -0.011639955453574657, 0.0392695814371109, -0.02907668426632881, -0.0006476142443716526, -0.03576589748263359, 0.01594388298690319, 0.029777565971016884, -0.04939349368214607, -0.015417739748954773, 0.009708487428724766, -0.004580838140100241, -0.03544997796416283, -0.03879264369606972, 0.023687105625867844, 0.0010185675928369164, -0.02276611141860485, 0.0083010820671916, -0.013800472021102905, 0.009464023634791374, -0.00578380236402154, 0.0298452191054821, -0.014605180360376835, -0.03649269789457321, -0.11004576832056046, -0.05771535262465477, -0.016014525666832924, -0.024517608806490898, 0.0012792203342542052, -0.05030328407883644, -0.048524368554353714, 0.06605520099401474, 0.011519127525389194, 0.02913220226764679, 0.04596507549285889, -0.021067222580313683, 0.015804516151547432, -0.008370257914066315, 0.005753704346716404, -0.032673560082912445, -0.0018337875371798873, -0.009632550179958344, 0.04623037204146385, 0.032517898827791214, -0.041915640234947205, -0.03397181257605553, -0.004360675811767578, 0.06722664088010788, -0.021013179793953896, 0.03148988261818886, 0.0397426038980484, -0.011147365905344486, -0.025648240000009537, 0.020124943926930428, -0.013646974228322506, 0.009654466062784195, -0.029082873836159706, 0.07008481025695801, 0.04309549555182457, -0.007579544093459845, 0.02100704237818718, -0.06413432210683823, 0.05098767951130867, -0.029890045523643494, 0.053430087864398956, -0.02587273344397545, 0.031606920063495636, -0.007136255502700806, -0.005524291191250086, -0.0017543433932587504, -0.04504067078232765, 0.03225066512823105, -0.026383578777313232, 0.01488276943564415, 0.05594909191131592, -0.024660926312208176, 0.03451290726661682, 0.014923794195055962, 0.009026657789945602, -0.02170254848897457, 0.03030715137720108, -0.004285464063286781, 0.043980009853839874, 0.022305773571133614, 0.024250226095318794, -0.0008375528850592673, 0.0014255702262744308, -0.03753504157066345, -0.0525907427072525, 0.038137856870889664, 0.042331501841545105, 0.006124081090092659, 0.017334522679448128, 0.013541204854846, 0.016253799200057983, -0.04810801148414612, 0.04302776977419853, 0.034637853503227234, -0.04148859530687332, 0.004981616046279669, -0.00803595595061779, -0.012987896800041199, 0.06956570595502853, 0.03624064847826958, 0.015419566072523594, -0.03713153675198555, 0.060867007821798325, -0.010510820895433426, -0.058012913912534714, 0.08970874547958374, -0.0021720121148973703, -0.0026853398885577917, 0.004878380801528692, -0.013666109181940556, -0.037233833223581314, -0.0010088605340570211, -0.003131937002763152, -0.01240490097552538, -0.07945419102907181, 0.016626013442873955, 0.019899161532521248, 0.06349341571331024, -0.00044436455937102437, 0.04223036766052246, -0.040295735001564026, -0.06969037652015686, -0.015785956755280495, -0.024017171934247017, 0.0033828408923000097, 0.01638546586036682, 0.019147386774420738, -0.04426625743508339, 0.008504104800522327, 0.05567897856235504, 0.001945594558492303, -0.017687156796455383, 0.02705994062125683, 0.0007368198712356389, -0.001736983540467918, -0.029103774577379227, -0.07965429127216339, 0.016544127836823463, 0.019531643018126488, -0.019259218126535416, 0.040479984134435654, -0.045396797358989716, -0.014114188961684704, 0.020624950528144836, 0.033328983932733536, 0.009656439535319805, -0.022750385105609894, 0.020735645666718483, -0.005220735911279917, -0.03849628567695618, 0.0010064298985525966, 0.031241057440638542, -0.023339392617344856, 0.027353715151548386, 0.028173858299851418, 0.007061725948005915, 0.05111592635512352, 0.022306164726614952, -0.024459781125187874, -0.03877005726099014, -0.03414004296064377, -0.1279212087392807, 0.006675551179796457, 0.019419565796852112, -0.005681602284312248, 0.0064672185108065605, 0.021881410852074623, -0.0013156443601474166, -0.037469953298568726, -0.003199224593117833, -0.0138049041852355, -0.01526876911520958, 0.04511861503124237, -0.027716059237718582, -0.032363228499889374, -0.08560726791620255, -0.046354372054338455, 0.016227172687649727, -0.03777654096484184, -0.012627200223505497, -0.06725876778364182, -0.018205439671874046, -0.04182371497154236, 0.04265378415584564, -0.01988247036933899, -0.012225895188748837, 0.01676730439066887, 0.0172885749489069, -0.03834916278719902, 0.00010682208085199818, 0.033708613365888596, -0.03567739576101303, -0.05510702729225159, 0.03772979974746704, -0.01654881238937378, -0.010348152369260788, -0.019479969516396523, 0.06451385468244553, -0.028806572780013084, 0.038145534694194794, -0.05122045427560806, -0.0021185295190662146, -0.002203030278906226, 0.04746716842055321, -0.003010156098753214, -0.04947676137089729, -0.04470691457390785, 0.06442099064588547, 0.01664275862276554, -0.04385412111878395, 0.03919433057308197, 0.01649138331413269, 0.04204653576016426, 0.013819094747304916, 0.03961864486336708, 0.001115784514695406, 0.037021588534116745, 0.010290179401636124, 0.05313602834939957, 0.062292225658893585, -0.005286404397338629, 0.021560026332736015, -0.07164982706308365, -0.044245462864637375, -0.014645466580986977, 0.010781251825392246, 0.032836124300956726, 0.016180695965886116, -0.008527059108018875, -0.044070176780223846, -0.06510992348194122, -0.01245476957410574, 0.02685464918613434, 0.010095836594700813, -0.0049884021282196045, -0.026257338002324104, -0.022557243704795837, 0.013966838829219341, 0.008843299932777882, -0.003665112890303135, -0.06141567602753639, -0.00024384651624131948, -0.0207557063549757, 0.04886111244559288, 0.04228793829679489, 0.020267928019165993, -0.010785447433590889, -0.0033206776715815067, 0.046343494206666946, 0.0021176745649427176, 0.005196717102080584, 0.017810139805078506, 0.05039674788713455, 0.0371142216026783, -0.058630313724279404, -0.013833674602210522, 0.08198070526123047, -0.03443867713212967, -0.030427632853388786, 0.03172207996249199, -0.00047106511192396283, 0.03032531961798668, -0.006838782224804163, -0.02756623923778534, -0.02464032731950283, -0.02120104804635048, 0.057188570499420166, -0.04880586266517639, -0.02080441080033779, -0.028273049741983414, 0.012279864400625229, -0.018906868994235992, -0.012525489553809166, 0.05601664260029793, -0.03322363272309303, 0.05718938633799553, 0.020226232707500458, 0.040799181908369064, -0.027021538466215134, -0.002201548544690013, -0.05586200952529907, 0.01701730117201805, 0.05288197845220566, -0.005859768949449062, -0.07751684635877609, -0.0115989800542593, -0.0558527335524559, -0.04766440391540527, -0.021098719909787178, 0.004331560339778662, 0.012131222523748875, -0.040611397475004196, 0.005141906440258026, 0.04368053749203682, -0.010605881921947002, -0.05620819702744484, 0.042507514357566833, 0.0451875776052475, -0.01908203214406967, 0.02225831337273121, 0.026534294709563255, -0.0027763117104768753, 0.035606034100055695, -0.007222607731819153, 0.03906160593032837, 0.05161344259977341, 0.015826163813471794, -0.03609049692749977, 0.02481589838862419, -0.07530710101127625, 0.027403051033616066, -0.0005115404492244124, -0.020266296342015266, 0.01182933896780014, 0.007588383741676807, -0.002474634675309062, -0.019606148824095726, 0.05132994428277016, 0.027673251926898956, -0.00813965778797865, -0.00722730066627264, -0.022836042568087578, 0.02393626980483532, -0.0010214619105681777, 0.07803360372781754, -0.04439352825284004, 0.022014396265149117, -0.006096388213336468, -0.01739506982266903, 0.0017500980757176876, -0.04155943915247917, 0.022085726261138916, 0.005801180377602577, 0.05638724938035011, 0.09852711856365204, 0.03671734035015106, -0.0002441692922729999, 0.035228293389081955, -0.02043679915368557, 0.04405015707015991, 0.0018392358906567097, -0.002401380566880107, -0.004943412262946367, -0.015014912001788616, 0.021978888660669327, -0.06865327060222626, 0.0251382514834404, 0.012534292414784431, -0.0043450226075947285, -0.02010253444314003, -0.07091829925775528, 0.06730978935956955, 0.03905245289206505, 0.05602162703871727, -0.017090052366256714, -0.024674657732248306, 0.05012305825948715, -0.019772900268435478, 0.017286386340856552, 0.0063981604762375355, -0.061806727200746536, 0.017969928681850433, -0.020032284781336784, -0.05414484441280365, -0.0036171094980090857, -0.02471182867884636, 0.02158759906888008, -0.03762957081198692, 0.018932247534394264, -0.09907524287700653, -0.01894252561032772, -0.006152970250695944, 0.015815353021025658, 0.017109081149101257, -0.04236176237463951, 0.017224490642547607, 0.012446350418031216, 0.02147064171731472, 0.005609386134892702, 0.033858515322208405, -0.07029031962156296, 0.03410659357905388, -0.03420964628458023, -0.08448753505945206, -0.02094302512705326, 0.0657428726553917, 0.023088790476322174, -0.034762147814035416, 0.004815530963242054, 0.0012826044112443924, 0.03832259774208069, -0.022407086566090584, -0.047259874641895294, 0.040059179067611694, -0.08664874732494354, 0.03757883608341217, 0.014122946187853813, -0.02486017905175686, 0.04620165377855301, 0.012622997164726257, 0.03797772154211998, 0.05457882583141327, 0.03142625838518143, -0.01915934681892395, -0.0010525097604840994, 0.034031614661216736, -0.02854614518582821, 0.08491221070289612, 0.05547253042459488, 0.017912045121192932, -0.031686849892139435, 0.09688764810562134, -0.040077731013298035, -0.06467016786336899, 0.05745803937315941, -0.040447939187288284, 0.04301278293132782, -0.028697874397039413, 0.03465884178876877, 0.03749332204461098, -0.05142020806670189, -0.028021395206451416, 0.011725607328116894, 0.03900110721588135, -0.00008602502202847973, 0.012448325753211975, 0.05253710225224495, -0.008553894236683846, -0.023693092167377472, -0.013427776284515858, -0.018032915890216827, -0.006879844237118959, 0.01593538001179695, 0.01593116670846939, 0.02957831509411335, -0.03187565505504608, 0.023096183314919472, 0.003001520177349448, -0.0025710752233862877, -0.03349296376109123, -0.016215959563851357, -0.047511469572782516, -0.01086308341473341, -0.04387266933917999, -0.0226662028580904, 0.013376512564718723, -0.01402991358190775, 0.03822522610425949, 0.018763616681098938, -0.014150958508253098, 0.017106136307120323, -0.089834064245224, -0.007595607545226812, 0.03482784703373909, 0.015143693424761295, 0.04422701150178909, 0.07580656558275223, 0.025688989087939262, 0.07732628285884857, -0.0011949647450819612, 0.016528965905308723, -0.03649451583623886, -0.02363649196922779, 0.007255847565829754, 0.011578491888940334, 0.008429417386651039, 0.038175951689481735, -0.029814116656780243, -0.02121121808886528, -0.002824821276590228, 0.038626234978437424, -0.02523737959563732, -0.04322490841150284, -0.04451169818639755, 0.008655311539769173, -0.01604652591049671, 0.05111570656299591, -0.004595034755766392, 0.011537551879882812, -0.03272610902786255, -0.007108922582119703, 0.09397516399621964, 0.005518382880836725, -0.03390352427959442, -0.01691162772476673, -0.023737721145153046, -0.017046453431248665, -0.03663891926407814, -0.04081859067082405, -0.0003958923916798085, 0.018221376463770866, 0.003925990778952837, -0.030878107994794846, -0.017486248165369034, -0.036083728075027466, 0.014583772048354149, -0.026341184973716736, -0.07235588878393173, 0.014233920723199844, 0.030900970101356506, -0.07244955748319626, 0.011413750238716602, -0.009756045415997505, -0.010341783054172993, -0.06425008922815323, -0.008659744635224342, -0.07490356266498566, -0.061887793242931366, -0.016232332214713097, -0.04869381710886955, 0.04501291736960411, 0.019154515117406845, 0.04864710941910744, 0.02757957950234413, -0.017106734216213226, 0.03431481122970581, 0.05143555626273155, -0.07093740254640579, 0.05998764559626579, 0.05921036750078201, -0.042409345507621765, 0.028807537630200386, 0.03240268677473068, 0.04688461124897003, 0.01049810741096735, 0.010588057339191437, 0.008547949604690075, 0.07340878248214722, 0.005841046571731567, 0.012370987795293331, 0.027918610721826553, 0.04519005864858627, 0.011581622064113617, -0.022834740579128265, -0.013690209947526455, -0.011791260913014412, 0.043543435633182526, -0.026020502671599388, -0.07312607020139694, 0.004785287193953991, 0.015656396746635437, 0.02266058884561062, -0.034694474190473557, -0.0003507868095766753, 0.02565382607281208, -0.0810747891664505, -0.017884282395243645, -0.03758063539862633, -0.006351857911795378, 0.030078904703259468, -0.043723542243242264, -0.013564543798565865, 0.0025788110215216875, -0.05597975105047226, -0.008474866859614849, 0.0012046085903421044, 0.035637713968753815, -0.02173200435936451, 0.02894054912030697, 0.01032156590372324, -0.0403471402823925, 0.013219683431088924, 0.060481127351522446, -0.00998630654066801, 0.017035990953445435, -0.023457052186131477, -0.03466594219207764, 0.006868629716336727, -0.0579400397837162, -0.04772325977683067, 0.029094958677887917, 0.07490724325180054, 0.02002769522368908, 0.013903588987886906, 0.012846279889345169, -0.00017117260722443461, -0.03939013555645943, 0.02525324746966362, 0.013048498891294003, -0.025556497275829315, -0.12952576577663422, 0.0002554064558353275, 0.011928004212677479, 0.002171129919588566, -0.034113138914108276, -0.05300498381257057, -0.04285665228962898, 0.008042125962674618, 0.0164466742426157, 0.010263719595968723, 0.024127613753080368, 0.018720926716923714, 0.023871129378676414, -0.02218543365597725, -0.02124546281993389, -0.006093150936067104, 0.026221947744488716, -0.020962879061698914, 0.02838023565709591, -0.004790719598531723, -0.02559596113860607, -0.019318221136927605, 0.009912875480949879, -0.03891932964324951, -0.010521437972784042, 0.02768382988870144, -0.03801942989230156, -0.0347110815346241, 0.03592874854803085, -0.031791359186172485, -0.02256588451564312, -0.006043076049536467, 0.047874271869659424, 0.05043712630867958, 0.05241037905216217, 0.04013200104236603, 0.04790159687399864, 0.03185778483748436, 0.036542922258377075, -0.030708380043506622, -0.03654196858406067, 0.015789056196808815, -0.034623920917510986, 0.011098306626081467, 0.027216721326112747, -0.04615435376763344, 0.012944982387125492, -0.021435370668768883, -0.03753523528575897, -0.03917417675256729, -0.012290965765714645, 0.0035699871368706226, 0.007320054806768894, 0.013057395815849304, -0.028293194249272346, -0.06832865625619888, 0.033508818596601486, -0.08252030611038208, 0.01701979711651802, -0.025646943598985672, -0.050649549812078476, 0.04101710394024849, 0.07285665720701218, 0.02127041667699814, -0.02817818894982338, 0.01808830164372921, -0.05458032339811325, -0.026268690824508667, 0.11160341650247574, -0.05498340725898743, 0.004921918269246817, 0.05696667358279228, -0.00905418861657381, 0.0645209401845932, -0.016237949952483177, -0.012902027927339077, -0.0330163836479187, -0.044350020587444305, -0.03316231444478035, -0.020966248586773872, 0.021912794560194016, 0.020624274387955666 ]
<p>So when you're looking at B-H curves for ferromagnetic substances, you often see these magnetic hysteresis curves, which occur, I gather, largely because of domain formation which has some reversible and some irreversible components:</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/DNjCd.png" alt="A magnetic hysteresis curve."></p> <p>I've been reading through many papers, web sites and <a href="http://rads.stackoverflow.com/amzn/click/0120932709">this book (Hysteresis in Magnetism)</a>, but I haven't seen any equations for how to generate these curves. I recognize that there may be no easy way to express the entire curve in a single equation, but clearly people are generating these plots, and I think they're doing it from some equations, presumably based on some characteristic parameters like the saturation remanance, the coercive force, etc. Is there anyone out there who can help me with this?</p> <p>Personally, my first choice would be an equation that actually describes the system given some set of material conditions (subject to some constraints is fine, too) but if that's quite complicated and for the most part, people just stitch together two <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sigmoid_function">sigmoid functions</a> until it looks about right, then I'm fine with that answer as well, so long as there's some justification for why this is done in there somewhere.<sup>1</sup></p> <p><sup>1</sup><sub>Full disclosure: I am in thesis deadline mode and I'm currently probably a 5 on the <a href="http://www.stanford.edu/~dement/sss.html">Stanford Sleepiness Scale</a>, so I apologize if some of the words in this post don't make sense - I'll try and edit it if people find that I haven't adequately conveyed my question.</sub></p>
g4229
[ 0.004570614546537399, 0.018849045038223267, -0.02500816434621811, -0.013514646328985691, 0.03306175395846367, 0.0033228560350835323, 0.021082444116473198, 0.016187913715839386, -0.024862229824066162, 0.019593482837080956, -0.005095745902508497, 0.037399064749479294, 0.050372328609228134, 0.009700090624392033, -0.0006444962345995009, -0.01862398348748684, -0.030743207782506943, 0.04449798911809921, 0.008534066379070282, 0.009080000221729279, 0.03520028665661812, 0.032642774283885956, 0.0189367588609457, -0.04922765493392944, -0.03377998620271683, 0.04287102073431015, -0.0021119306329637766, 0.00873319711536169, -0.015052136033773422, 0.000336389581207186, -0.0027722236700356007, 0.024415073916316032, 0.0412510447204113, 0.007164699025452137, -0.032660048454999924, 0.005828773602843285, -0.07247654348611832, 0.008599876426160336, -0.02288411371409893, 0.023455942049622536, -0.02492356300354004, -0.03006078116595745, 0.03642557933926582, -0.01752578280866146, 0.009366708807647228, 0.01192074827849865, 0.007264214567840099, 0.007577975280582905, -0.06664431095123291, -0.0015820518601685762, 0.01665521413087845, 0.013735820539295673, 0.07889257371425629, -0.05889606475830078, -0.025437593460083008, -0.02082286961376667, 0.037964560091495514, -0.01396714337170124, 0.0400097481906414, 0.030224580317735672, -0.03980623185634613, 0.0044410694390535355, -0.027426589280366898, 0.025855422019958496, 0.058957938104867935, 0.002447779756039381, -0.07018624246120453, -0.034463584423065186, 0.022188596427440643, -0.00913420133292675, -0.022674275562167168, 0.02908121608197689, 0.011543787084519863, -0.005286748521029949, -0.0633610263466835, 0.0099115539342165, -0.016039492562413216, -0.007826006971299648, 0.026031216606497765, 0.03261129558086395, -0.006192993838340044, 0.024218160659074783, 0.007934654131531715, 0.020551718771457672, 0.06983738392591476, 0.024940721690654755, 0.02477310225367546, -0.023745600134134293, -0.0008900900138542056, -0.0016923436196520925, 0.01938687264919281, 0.015868712216615677, -0.009453085251152515, -0.01642869971692562, 0.0012513394467532635, -0.04965684935450554, 0.0258730947971344, 0.024407757446169853, -0.0814334824681282, -0.0072547742165625095, -0.04187246039509773, -0.0379129983484745, -0.035948529839515686, -0.021280795335769653, -0.026207396760582924, -0.013874847441911697, -0.016809772700071335, 0.03287157416343689, -0.00005706855881726369, 0.022694269195199013, 0.014372815378010273, 0.05520791932940483, -0.049636878073215485, 0.0648515522480011, -0.025132915005087852, -0.08419618755578995, -0.009033078327775002, -0.0017693225527182221, -0.023075833916664124, 0.05012993514537811, 0.0021073666866868734, -0.08215536922216415, -0.016215603798627853, 0.060082901269197464, -0.024280183017253876, 0.02544584684073925, -0.03843849524855614, -0.0006149309920147061, -0.006847774609923363, -0.005824470892548561, 0.05434350669384003, 0.026280518621206284, -0.016072768718004227, -0.03238145262002945, -0.032754234969615936, 0.010466318577528, 0.017788289114832878, 0.03572336584329605, -0.02867058664560318, -0.02888500690460205, 0.018908191472291946, -0.06720758974552155, -0.015467398799955845, -0.035926759243011475, -0.029862836003303528, 0.006955401506274939, -0.025935612618923187, -0.0027617095038294792, 0.0023532737977802753, 0.03655365854501724, -0.03555994853377342, 0.04689444229006767, 0.0010512551525607705, -0.03373695909976959, 0.004518252797424793, -0.030911775305867195, 0.04689791053533554, -0.008312744088470936, -0.03167641535401344, 0.0003348754544276744, 0.09631332010030746, -0.09033782035112381, 0.053628381341695786, -0.01696467027068138, 0.029486825689673424, 0.013977350667119026, 0.011692991480231285, -0.0008058257517404854, -0.042126912623643875, -0.0311722569167614, -0.06484561413526535, 0.013016333803534508, 0.018964525312185287, 0.0873468816280365, 0.024334289133548737, 0.02214173413813114, 0.10275304317474365, -0.01860152557492256, 0.06903044134378433, 0.020253298804163933, 0.025404416024684906, 0.05089953914284706, 0.013732905499637127, -0.005898843519389629, -0.008291812613606453, -0.03284050151705742, -0.015564720146358013, 0.009645084850490093, -0.0808761790394783, 0.0033315459731966257, 0.017635049298405647, -0.0015803041169419885, -0.022581076249480247, 0.049720052629709244, -0.00038708714419044554, -0.024567024782299995, 0.03107019141316414, 0.0014563516015186906, 0.025297552347183228, 0.02972237952053547, -0.001234429539181292, 0.01760890521109104, 0.048744264990091324, -0.002088334411382675, -0.004884692374616861, 0.007509137503802776, -0.013654656708240509, 0.038735371083021164, -0.03141772374510765, -0.026196669787168503, 0.03154749050736427, 0.013076668605208397, 0.010306327603757381, -0.039218589663505554, -0.006344479043036699, -0.012681153602898121, -0.007357929367572069, -0.024942168965935707, -0.006788009312003851, -0.033898238092660904, 0.012850873172283173, 0.013223226182162762, -0.02028368040919304, 0.036473266780376434, -0.012852484360337257, -0.030932236462831497, 0.02927699312567711, -0.023858267813920975, 0.023654602468013763, -0.07150440663099289, 0.028931938111782074, -0.06140930950641632, -0.002001460874453187, -0.053197186440229416, 0.024225713685154915, 0.04223193600773811, -0.026778357103466988, -0.020669307559728622, -0.00506554776802659, -0.01087923627346754, 0.00865848083049059, 0.03614979237318039, 0.07816430181264877, -0.00786281656473875, -0.0012732852483168244, -0.0683678612112999, 0.06126732379198074, 0.016178248450160027, 0.01293946523219347, 0.022327106446027756, 0.03777673840522766, -0.06706128269433975, 0.002799925860017538, -0.0006723018013872206, 0.0054739853367209435, -0.033157337456941605, -0.0021893191151320934, 0.013895567506551743, -0.05661458149552345, -0.039370808750391006, -0.011202773079276085, -0.041191183030605316, 0.0378773957490921, 0.054920751601457596, -0.07886286824941635, -0.09364359825849533, -0.005859886761754751, -0.14476671814918518, 0.013669801875948906, -0.006272245664149523, -0.0451362170279026, 0.019923320040106773, 0.03231560066342354, 0.03209206089377403, 0.0027468048501759768, -0.03500878065824509, 0.015950139611959457, 0.02715962938964367, 0.017177261412143707, 0.004880417603999376, 0.021373672410845757, -0.03219360485672951, -0.001970387762412429, -0.0064112101681530476, 0.018249694257974625, 0.00174606591463089, 0.011848454363644123, 0.0220958199352026, -0.020541291683912277, 0.04224231839179993, -0.03592272475361824, -0.026775529608130455, 0.01593063957989216, 0.013892333954572678, -0.0648767501115799, -0.0011745530646294355, 0.0031933626160025597, -0.029402391985058784, -0.015824366360902786, 0.030570855364203453, 0.008676192723214626, 0.026251623407006264, -0.0010692321229726076, 0.007392778526991606, -0.052650146186351776, -0.027429746463894844, 0.005679674446582794, -0.06278203427791595, -0.008350992575287819, 0.04319643974304199, -0.04445815086364746, -0.012485927902162075, 0.03057224117219448, 0.00848347693681717, 0.05885358154773712, 0.04171476885676384, 0.05491247773170471, -0.01780918799340725, 0.049842145293951035, -0.0035794659052044153, -0.02020561881363392, -0.02910381183028221, 0.03174284100532532, -0.0029858953785151243, 0.015506316907703876, -0.026897350326180458, 0.044637177139520645, -0.047214485704898834, -0.05661739781498909, -0.002951475791633129, 0.06467040628194809, -0.0026685590855777264, 0.02475317195057869, 0.014924385584890842, -0.07343785464763641, -0.0337010957300663, -0.06944582611322403, -0.01663384959101677, -0.005393247585743666, -0.011874634772539139, -0.062136199325323105, -0.036726851016283035, -0.05131378024816513, -0.007297625299543142, -0.041438594460487366, 0.05788164585828781, -0.007193642668426037, -0.03083072230219841, 0.009817853569984436, -0.07713446021080017, -0.04700661078095436, -0.009802015498280525, 0.06199396774172783, -0.038825858384370804, 0.0161257553845644, 0.038866862654685974, 0.010179003700613976, -0.05256558582186699, 0.03294873610138893, 0.01894219219684601, -0.025891700759530067, -0.025825466960668564, -0.06422732770442963, 0.018096324056386948, -0.014255678281188011, 0.016004951670765877, 0.03420725464820862, 0.09257763624191284, -0.017579849809408188, -0.025688959285616875, 0.021763483062386513, 0.018244009464979172, 0.0360330231487751, -0.042036186903715134, 0.04185795783996582, -0.0439884215593338, -0.04434240981936455, -0.007217573467642069, -0.034906502813100815, 0.03356287255883217, -0.03219879791140556, 0.020839020609855652, 0.06100865453481674, 0.012990348041057587, 0.0032288008369505405, 0.03200086951255798, -0.018570255488157272, 0.009932304732501507, 0.014610802754759789, -0.006673143710941076, 0.0006091704708524048, -0.032329101115465164, 0.002566340146586299, 0.003891200991347432, 0.06342874467372894, -0.05197349935770035, -0.033480867743492126, 0.02723967656493187, 0.015911078080534935, 0.0000968023159657605, 0.020396269857883453, 0.02514037862420082, -0.005193036049604416, 0.08080510050058365, 0.0260652806609869, -0.012692306190729141, -0.03505343943834305, -0.05797697603702545, 0.025396397337317467, -0.04597781226038933, 0.02414781041443348, -0.027745911851525307, 0.015957124531269073, -0.006159569136798382, 0.03194985166192055, 0.007093168329447508, -0.005918423645198345, 0.00013657656381838024, -0.004946569912135601, -0.03854497894644737, -0.03344970941543579, 0.008907170966267586, 0.016742056235671043, -0.033744607120752335, -0.001496002310886979, 0.032378241419792175, 0.0339009054005146, 0.0006422831793315709, 0.025118406862020493, -0.020983494818210602, 0.02802230417728424, 0.03447944298386574, 0.04749424383044243, -0.0002549440832808614, -0.04544127732515335, -0.008566551841795444, -0.03654734045267105, 0.03530433773994446, -0.030346330255270004, -0.013408748432993889, -0.02854122966527939, 0.009427657350897789, 0.023938046768307686, -0.013110669329762459, -0.07823050022125244, -0.010692214593291283, -0.05253540351986885, -0.011211383156478405, -0.06536608934402466, -0.053206540644168854, -0.037818484008312225, 0.007090369239449501, -0.02973301336169243, -0.010724439285695553, 0.0025074228178709745, 0.007701823953539133, 0.035476572811603546, 0.025223297998309135, 0.03693560138344765, -0.0009462847374379635, 0.006011579651385546, -0.054441049695014954, -0.012089075520634651, 0.03231042996048927, -0.008227664977312088, 0.013051971793174744, -0.0385325625538826, -0.0036649976391345263, 0.0419335700571537, 0.027314333245158195, 0.030487991869449615, 0.02050391212105751, 0.03669605404138565, -0.011577954515814781, 0.09510279446840286, 0.0222482867538929, -0.023106452077627182, -0.04131954908370972, -0.08426998555660248, -0.015561812557280064, -0.04869850352406502, 0.04517793282866478, 0.05620969459414482, 0.0025574578903615475, -0.022594328969717026, 0.01236923411488533, -0.0070895180106163025, 0.02585628256201744, -0.010710202157497406, -0.011734593659639359, -0.0330423004925251, 0.009876647032797337, -0.010358035564422607, -0.062151916325092316, 0.016117438673973083, -0.10734862834215164, 0.034916650503873825, -0.0037417111452668905, -0.07408025860786438, -0.017307423055171967, -0.05068245157599449, 0.022338105365633965, 0.006025418173521757, -0.0067639728076756, 0.023301588371396065, 0.051614608615636826, 0.026697080582380295, -0.01561669260263443, 0.05760380998253822, 0.015568435192108154, 0.009967119432985783, -0.0016339087160304189, 0.03033546172082424, 0.04020382836461067, 0.04333174601197243, 0.042739346623420715, -0.04512208327651024, 0.04464958608150482, 0.006207659840583801, -0.05055840685963631, 0.025718720629811287, 0.008818193338811398, 0.07954460382461548, -0.03549817577004433, 0.056759510189294815, 0.06274969130754471, -0.0722363293170929, -0.037008725106716156, 0.04343613609671593, 0.02165636606514454, -0.024986615404486656, -0.024784384295344353, -0.007290874142199755, -0.0201632771641016, 0.015372933819890022, -0.04524308070540428, 0.06492781639099121, -0.004420051816850901, 0.013771794736385345, 0.009799569845199585, -0.04167892411351204, 0.024359598755836487, 0.031346242874860764, -0.007383400108665228, 0.015668805688619614, -0.0461101159453392, 0.05102364346385002, -0.005267914850264788, -0.0012369768228381872, 0.026370488107204437, -0.0674271360039711, -0.002161564538255334, 0.042838744819164276, -0.015804851427674294, -0.05983436852693558, 0.04683292284607887, 0.02382711134850979, -0.039831094443798065, -0.012124326080083847, 0.0036202396731823683, 0.04935670271515846, -0.003768669907003641, 0.004692239221185446, 0.0694904625415802, -0.051006291061639786, -0.02416176348924637, -0.02890334464609623, 0.016762642189860344, 0.07831567525863647, 0.041407596319913864, 0.008902550674974918, -0.006583021022379398, 0.012041759677231312, 0.03127531707286835, -0.011529384180903435, -0.01214296743273735, 0.00037444697227329016, -0.08586354553699493, 0.0059449682012200356, 0.052679307758808136, -0.004405877087265253, 0.04124140366911888, 0.011541311629116535, 0.005474282428622246, -0.042772408574819565, 0.036614663898944855, -0.009397249668836594, -0.01390141248703003, -0.013276748359203339, -0.049376603215932846, 0.017427358776330948, 0.02386045828461647, -0.004581307526677847, -0.04836726188659668, 0.04080184921622276, -0.008247106336057186, -0.021336277946829796, 0.009652507491409779, 0.007526487112045288, -0.046797849237918854, -0.011836019344627857, 0.03611547127366066, -0.003761841682717204, -0.03926210477948189, 0.04331903159618378, -0.038417063653469086, -0.01837216690182686, 0.041049107909202576, 0.03092755377292633, -0.032440271228551865, -0.016185833141207695, 0.01415855810046196, -0.06362224370241165, 0.01225468423217535, 0.052190151065588, -0.056939467787742615, 0.01407769788056612, 0.09283972531557083, 0.025596460327506065, -0.0029871363658457994, -0.042046330869197845, 0.007701809052377939, 0.056621238589286804, -0.042190007865428925, 0.033735983073711395, 0.03009261004626751, 0.01750630885362625, 0.012302659451961517, -0.04404458403587341, 0.0004930617869831622, -0.0169038325548172, -0.0094080725684762, -0.020252225920557976, 0.056601762771606445, 0.020926890894770622, 0.07427556067705154, -0.0004396105359774083, 0.04402097687125206, 0.03456873819231987, 0.0770537331700325, -0.008892212994396687, -0.014584437943994999, -0.008471356704831123, 0.06867007166147232, -0.04056544601917267, -0.0722767561674118, -0.0157315693795681, -0.006054953206330538, -0.03249974548816681, 0.034468669444322586, -0.0013454626314342022, -0.03777903690934181, -0.02043755166232586, 0.03683679923415184, 0.018549352884292603, 0.0027695652097463608, -0.007622620090842247, -0.006413477007299662, 0.01585203967988491, 0.004366251640021801, -0.06580944359302521, 0.04921744391322136, -0.021870171651244164, -0.03138337656855583, 0.052823059260845184, 0.07176537811756134, 0.06823782622814178, 0.00197559199295938, 0.06581742316484451, -0.01658487692475319, -0.011116991750895977, -0.02133874036371708, 0.03614819422364235, 0.03766807168722153, -0.017035705968737602, -0.0005451934412121773, 0.025044381618499756, 0.0046157375909388065, 0.04516554996371269, -0.016355499625205994, -0.03836645931005478, -0.0021828156895935535, 0.031363289803266525, -0.07086138427257538, 0.020397504791617393, 0.014523823745548725, -0.05488329008221626, 0.05570857971906662, 0.03160402178764343, 0.03117361292243004, -0.07129496335983276, 0.0476553812623024, -0.0031553995795547962, 0.025707468390464783, -0.0821959599852562, 0.004027394577860832, -0.03145603463053703, 0.0060381232760846615, 0.06262751668691635, -0.03969854861497879, 0.07329168915748596, -0.037252720445394516, 0.014433118514716625, 0.0005583188030868769, 0.01970769837498665, 0.009696937166154385, -0.07429167628288269, -0.03243275731801987, -0.001722116838209331, -0.006310202647000551, -0.01233072578907013, 0.029750710353255272, -0.028357038274407387, -0.03628692403435707, -0.0025689289905130863, 0.04170941188931465, -0.030161429196596146, -0.02727057784795761, -0.00019200652604922652, -0.015179308131337166, -0.028947705402970314, -0.00429474888369441, 0.0449441596865654, -0.062120240181684494, 0.054794762283563614, -0.026341158896684647, -0.009381094947457314, 0.030328748747706413, -0.03756307065486908, 0.024885578081011772, 0.009870377369225025, -0.04755974933505058, 0.01639530062675476, 0.01940615475177765, -0.016254471614956856, -0.05480203777551651, -0.02044053003191948, -0.05036144703626633, -0.007301280274987221, -0.02125580608844757, 0.02395150065422058, -0.07581716775894165, -0.044998593628406525, -0.06087152659893036, 0.04256508871912956, 0.07197363674640656, -0.04669002443552017, 0.09048604965209961, 0.06918390840291977, -0.01073408592492342, 0.029702864587306976, 0.01463724859058857, -0.012657367624342442, -0.010684520937502384, 0.02455749176442623, -0.03499055281281471, 0.015508737415075302, 0.09521827101707458, 0.019628342241048813, 0.0422079861164093, -0.005597237031906843, -0.022753369063138962, -0.05644268915057182, 0.07514756172895432, -0.07888038456439972, 0.015174724161624908, -0.008081427775323391, 0.0359073281288147 ]
<p>I want to calculate the work done by friction if the length $L$ of uniform rope on the table slides off. There is friction between the cord and the table with coefficient of kinetic friction $\mu_k$.</p> <p>$$ W = \int F \cdot d \vec{s}$$ I think it would be: $$ W_{fr} = \frac M L g \int_{0}^{L} dx$$</p> <p>But the solutions (which could be mistaken) say: $$ dW_{fr} = \mu_k \frac M L g \, x \, dx$$ which is then integrated.</p> <p>Should there be an $x$ in the integral? I don't think there should be because you are summing up over an infinitesimal displacement $dx$ and the force of friction is not proportional to the displacement at any instant (I think).</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/lKzuO.png" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g4230
[ 0.0465543270111084, 0.011017867363989353, -0.01909528486430645, -0.0533825159072876, 0.03031839057803154, -0.032864995300769806, 0.038130033761262894, 0.0008862672257237136, -0.07786162942647934, -0.0029820369090884924, -0.06345438957214355, -0.020415673032402992, 0.002128095366060734, -0.008697777055203915, 0.032846540212631226, 0.015629829838871956, 0.04529310390353203, -0.010825530625879765, 0.0020306946244090796, 0.05159614607691765, -0.04801241308450699, 0.03703902289271355, -0.00441189156845212, -0.006314173340797424, 0.04252394288778305, -0.03302299976348877, 0.06293799728155136, 0.0008910362375900149, -0.0030409337487071753, -0.006644825451076031, -0.03171894699335098, 0.024179311469197273, -0.012191812507808208, -0.043215494602918625, -0.06547481566667557, -0.03727792948484421, 0.05990295484662056, -0.02360806055366993, 0.019586820155382156, -0.02984665334224701, 0.017170293256640434, -0.03353274613618851, 0.02880805730819702, 0.05399325489997864, -0.015360821969807148, -0.029182910919189453, -0.015475134365260601, 0.048956308513879776, -0.011229771189391613, 0.05285078287124634, 0.0031143128871917725, 0.059347014874219894, -0.02248806320130825, -0.01678897812962532, -0.05207020789384842, 0.05479559674859047, 0.06055142730474472, -0.027599332854151726, -0.013274033553898335, 0.05686875432729721, 0.004487449768930674, -0.07438427954912186, -0.003750202478840947, -0.0707644671201706, 0.01135055348277092, -0.07135967910289764, 0.009500160813331604, 0.03122958540916443, -0.005314188543707132, 0.036178164184093475, -0.014315343461930752, 0.007048456929624081, 0.08671381324529648, 0.008283669129014015, -0.03722202777862549, -0.008412444032728672, 0.030375400558114052, 0.02517252042889595, -0.014405950903892517, 0.010782605968415737, -0.07885156571865082, 0.06097954511642456, -0.002909794682636857, 0.016894161701202393, 0.004118874669075012, -0.028364229947328568, 0.054761406034231186, 0.017236875370144844, -0.04397257789969444, 0.010373716242611408, 0.022298792377114296, -0.023010434582829475, 0.05746575817465782, 0.022217225283384323, 0.006079073064029217, -0.04370013251900673, -0.02829587273299694, 0.04092063382267952, -0.019319435581564903, -0.021940555423498154, -0.013474575243890285, -0.007697963155806065, -0.010792681947350502, 0.01889081299304962, 0.026043381541967392, -0.04784763976931572, -0.013602709397673607, 0.009402114897966385, -0.010003367438912392, -0.040609899908304214, -0.007522791624069214, 0.016157642006874084, -0.056738510727882385, -0.07183227688074112, 0.056294843554496765, -0.08262388408184052, 0.0130347004160285, 0.011473438702523708, -0.022434640675783157, 0.05024554952979088, -0.012240293435752392, -0.03227585181593895, 0.02914699725806713, 0.061421096324920654, 0.025730891153216362, -0.008267302066087723, 0.02410845458507538, 0.028302183374762535, 0.047943804413080215, -0.017469190061092377, -0.012822740711271763, 0.027754539623856544, 0.03032447211444378, 0.03140612319111824, 0.006913037039339542, 0.043447669595479965, -0.047346871346235275, 0.056776661425828934, -0.035826195031404495, 0.05670259892940521, 0.00410433067008853, -0.026424920186400414, -0.016254847869277, 0.004000868182629347, -0.08209887892007828, 0.02020873688161373, -0.034616343677043915, -0.04055140167474747, 0.06085273250937462, -0.06293092668056488, 0.035882484167814255, 0.033268459141254425, -0.0011522623244673014, -0.009507639333605766, 0.08266261965036392, 0.020772866904735565, 0.041275154799222946, -0.015534481965005398, 0.05179687589406967, -0.009288700297474861, -0.01156105287373066, -0.017474176362156868, 0.033661775290966034, 0.008450445719063282, -0.06174478679895401, 0.06979953497648239, 0.00017086976731661707, -0.0017703387420624495, 0.008752252906560898, -0.015963304787874222, 0.012324376031756401, 0.0013729995116591454, 0.04645655304193497, 0.01097006443887949, 0.009273966774344444, 0.03816062957048416, 0.048723526298999786, 0.021240143105387688, 0.011598685756325722, 0.04868421331048012, 0.029707638546824455, 0.001703531132079661, 0.030756516382098198, -0.05290764942765236, 0.03633403778076172, -0.00363544886931777, -0.01970023103058338, 0.010390650480985641, -0.03712838888168335, -0.011878333054482937, -0.00009117941954173148, 0.03695712238550186, 0.032479386776685715, 0.029940355569124222, -0.08097152411937714, -0.005690891295671463, -0.0019314183155074716, -0.08105012029409409, 0.03558938577771187, -0.006848126649856567, 0.029861653223633766, 0.061948012560606, 0.06126450374722481, -0.002158885123208165, -0.029296642169356346, 0.012111545540392399, -0.020194729790091515, 0.023072727024555206, 0.03215008229017258, -0.039973702281713486, 0.04751532897353172, -0.04036935418844223, -0.053693462163209915, 0.06331290304660797, -0.052982740104198456, -0.09013888984918594, 0.013720216229557991, -0.004011537414044142, -0.03293512016534805, -0.008389173075556755, -0.030283214524388313, -0.001635349472053349, 0.023397142067551613, 0.03588166460394859, -0.04229898005723953, -0.04450257495045662, -0.040989216417074203, -0.01883728988468647, -0.00017959914111997932, 0.033291906118392944, -0.046529702842235565, -0.0288096833974123, -0.06210055947303772, -0.03585859388113022, 0.030384408310055733, 0.043927568942308426, 0.028716498985886574, -0.007588935550302267, 0.024431956931948662, 0.045889586210250854, 0.06385865062475204, -0.07607313245534897, -0.008601690642535686, -0.05736223980784416, 0.009741763584315777, 0.06026029586791992, 0.032045554369688034, 0.029704689979553223, -0.004517091903835535, 0.004461823031306267, -0.014716115780174732, 0.009475437924265862, -0.05007278546690941, 0.03752177953720093, -0.005496003199368715, 0.03318815678358078, -0.00011591491784201935, -0.0006716507486999035, 0.019149450585246086, -0.016499921679496765, -0.05084216594696045, 0.016549818217754364, -0.01036744099110365, 0.03412478044629097, -0.09681493043899536, 0.04542940482497215, -0.07433426380157471, -0.007166079245507717, 0.03517131134867668, 0.04307322949171066, 0.03673068434000015, -0.00792719516903162, -0.041522085666656494, 0.02863231487572193, 0.03189397603273392, -0.059377484023571014, 0.028419842943549156, 0.0047468384727835655, -0.006045614369213581, 0.021012265235185623, 0.04545639827847481, -0.04323595017194748, -0.025412239134311676, 0.04475095123052597, 0.002672788919880986, -0.039558663964271545, 0.015405995771288872, 0.03269578143954277, -0.04336569458246231, 0.009824477136135101, -0.007135571911931038, 0.045087553560733795, 0.03945446386933327, -0.01970551908016205, 0.024726208299398422, 0.07739517092704773, 0.03636101260781288, -0.07466500997543335, -0.029577668756246567, 0.018881671130657196, -0.024904973804950714, -0.00970641802996397, -0.028910545632243156, 0.03582773357629776, 0.04296377673745155, -0.014984162524342537, -0.01014777459204197, -0.047835823148489, 0.043959248811006546, -0.011310500092804432, 0.03681085258722305, 0.03779757022857666, 0.014476103708148003, -0.057045742869377136, -0.025399494916200638, 0.009589635767042637, 0.07513255625963211, 0.017501866444945335, -0.0005121026188135147, 0.028889834880828857, -0.008074076846241951, -0.1012861356139183, 0.01699480414390564, 0.009537498466670513, -0.016741963103413582, -0.00982806459069252, -0.07879523187875748, 0.0058602686040103436, -0.021296586841344833, -0.009644851088523865, -0.008411876857280731, 0.026507416740059853, -0.00006313250196399167, -0.04520109295845032, -0.050044190138578415, -0.04936438426375389, -0.01095151249319315, -0.005819777492433786, -0.03842128813266754, 0.0320860780775547, -0.07158810645341873, -0.027818933129310608, 0.011182707734405994, 0.0018638556357473135, -0.00996432639658451, -0.002812339225783944, 0.011623998172581196, 0.09190557152032852, 0.0061170728877186775, -0.00155072461348027, 0.07888054102659225, -0.029840689152479172, -0.025923097506165504, -0.01239762268960476, -0.015958884730935097, 0.03759804740548134, 0.025361893698573112, 0.08595442771911621, -0.08155329525470734, 0.011922746896743774, 0.08540032804012299, -0.029169825837016106, -0.018253425136208534, -0.021420195698738098, 0.0067139905877411366, 0.013063565827906132, 0.023818597197532654, 0.09342467784881592, -0.03476867452263832, 0.03172575682401657, -0.07277428358793259, 0.006464467383921146, -0.0044204494915902615, -0.06795430183410645, 0.0415850467979908, -0.0387377105653286, 0.034359708428382874, 0.03625066205859184, 0.02029070071876049, 0.06999430805444717, 0.06301982700824738, 0.02131430245935917, -0.07246235013008118, 0.02445194497704506, 0.05498446524143219, 0.06291303783655167, -0.015263842418789864, -0.014428297989070415, 0.05994299799203873, -0.01902824267745018, 0.07450072467327118, 0.005572728347033262, 0.020254740491509438, 0.000578658131416887, -0.008894561789929867, -0.02085198648273945, 0.007666010409593582, 0.03305415064096451, -0.022865118458867073, -0.04655870795249939, -0.0027395382057875395, -0.032283637672662735, 0.021220197901129723, 0.037322595715522766, -0.0029637059196829796, 0.03686404600739479, 0.025662224739789963, -0.024951521307229996, 0.06396255642175674, 0.01574154756963253, -0.015898803249001503, -0.06722930073738098, -0.015332851558923721, 0.0032774421852082014, -0.03278990834951401, -0.014402729459106922, -0.02332977205514908, -0.01166720874607563, 0.002777182264253497, -0.029955999925732613, 0.00795087218284607, 0.06040910631418228, -0.001990139251574874, 0.006158404052257538, -0.02906479500234127, 0.006765431724488735, 0.043702978640794754, 0.0572054348886013, 0.026559138670563698, -0.052672017365694046, -0.03193236142396927, 0.023153938353061676, -0.04954300448298454, -0.012686911970376968, -0.07264182716608047, 0.055719297379255295, 0.014495393261313438, 0.014003592543303967, 0.00031118758488446474, 0.086229607462883, -0.05497140437364578, 0.05457139015197754, -0.022654825821518898, 0.024152465164661407, -0.030923642218112946, 0.058986879885196686, -0.0118840541690588, -0.04541938006877899, -0.03975435718894005, -0.048571839928627014, -0.014222070574760437, 0.0038752343971282244, -0.06184200569987297, -0.0007917709299363196, 0.012611404992640018, 0.03177233412861824, 0.03024306334555149, 0.0051007517613470554, -0.03009234555065632, -0.03204676881432533, 0.005576639901846647, 0.03143365681171417, -0.06432601809501648, -0.015864579007029533, -0.04630158841609955, 0.005472531542181969, -0.007794766686856747, 0.06967149674892426, -0.05871037766337395, 0.0456150658428669, 0.031205929815769196, -0.037054430693387985, 0.015182730741798878, 0.025286806747317314, 0.0013047234388068318, -0.013428792357444763, 0.010556894354522228, 0.06827328354120255, 0.03655637055635452, -0.021271636709570885, -0.033301323652267456, 0.005351830739527941, -0.0017401020741090178, -0.05618562921881676, 0.050070371478796005, -0.03575463965535164, -0.03368055447936058, -0.02075698785483837, 0.023366034030914307, -0.008180057629942894, 0.0569184273481369, 0.01102979201823473, -0.004402772057801485, -0.013015354983508587, -0.039810724556446075, 0.018319526687264442, 0.006335743702948093, -0.020608142018318176, 0.08439991623163223, 0.02597476728260517, -0.04877547174692154, 0.022678107023239136, 0.01541096530854702, -0.019936054944992065, -0.0010207118466496468, 0.050609491765499115, 0.06749589741230011, 0.020978396758437157, 0.005421467125415802, 0.06034360080957413, 0.02021324448287487, 0.053994882851839066, 0.04279022663831711, -0.004833357874304056, -0.02760370448231697, -0.00314768822863698, 0.01671624556183815, -0.04723682627081871, -0.009711959399282932, -0.018996553495526314, 0.0484115332365036, 0.04219365864992142, -0.01895776018500328, -0.008094950579106808, -0.018590260297060013, -0.012434286996722221, -0.05175917595624924, -0.017923520877957344, -0.05484751984477043, -0.004446050617843866, -0.0022589219734072685, -0.021618163213133812, -0.006587355863302946, 0.02307015098631382, -0.0021935671102255583, -0.021220969036221504, 0.02092665620148182, -0.032063696533441544, -0.007224085740745068, -0.046509336680173874, -0.04341104254126549, -0.03235043212771416, 0.022011922672390938, 0.036338865756988525, -0.04456738010048866, -0.02541818469762802, -0.012865066528320312, -0.03249048441648483, 0.01663007214665413, -0.07948579639196396, 0.009211933240294456, 0.03962118551135063, -0.03621422499418259, 0.005301365163177252, -0.03049357794225216, -0.02130032889544964, 0.01807720772922039, 0.02195129171013832, 0.0014771909918636084, 0.021049026399850845, 0.05651729926466942, -0.03746115788817406, -0.031589340418577194, 0.012998303398489952, 0.039821356534957886, -0.031412240117788315, 0.03186952695250511, 0.048005033284425735, 0.0354946106672287, 0.04179457575082779, -0.030146067962050438, 0.0035223073791712523, -0.052515558898448944, 0.029513241723179817, 0.029534488916397095, 0.02554463967680931, -0.030131008476018906, -0.081044040620327, -0.006043727975338697, -0.035933852195739746, -0.009601449593901634, 0.0010439888574182987, -0.014973227865993977, -0.07132034003734589, -0.027883784845471382, -0.024761997163295746, -0.0300759170204401, -0.036645788699388504, 0.049599748104810715, 0.012150977738201618, -0.030585359781980515, 0.09431722015142441, -0.01744978502392769, 0.04413827508687973, 0.016980981454253197, -0.017336424440145493, -0.013819225132465363, 0.005034536123275757, 0.022287800908088684, 0.03336038440465927, 0.016298837959766388, 0.019907811656594276, 0.07045936584472656, -0.04218341037631035, -0.012443020939826965, -0.02060147374868393, -0.00744343688711524, 0.008628714829683304, -0.008889409713447094, 0.006140347570180893, 0.041571956127882004, 0.024646686390042305, -0.02502230741083622, 0.022729845717549324, 0.011002459563314915, -0.02482317015528679, 0.010664221830666065, 0.0015818227548152208, 0.010049729607999325, -0.038969360291957855, 0.021277733147144318, -0.024531321600079536, -0.011176896281540394, -0.017697123810648918, 0.010674534365534782, 0.019525961950421333, -0.0995124876499176, 0.002578139305114746, 0.0303463377058506, -0.026012519374489784, 0.03687325119972229, -0.005586318671703339, -0.048743344843387604, -0.0028197395149618387, -0.04435821622610092, 0.09191739559173584, -0.06128070503473282, -0.049215156584978104, -0.003785033244639635, 0.07268506288528442, -0.014557205140590668, -0.018270788714289665, 0.0663103237748146, 0.013848192989826202, 0.0037559987977147102, -0.00864340364933014, 0.0178673192858696, -0.042842984199523926, -0.039972130209207535, 0.015221459791064262, 0.01977936550974846, 0.00007047528197290376, -0.03079521842300892, 0.029851362109184265, 0.010815798304975033, -0.030052518472075462, -0.023354407399892807, 0.02429605834186077, -0.004314023535698652, 0.03028017468750477, 0.0004384751955512911, -0.037547219544649124, -0.006433483678847551, -0.03499407693743706, 0.004310300573706627, 0.039281610399484634, 0.07077828794717789, -0.022172624245285988, -0.04556065425276756, -0.011859267950057983, 0.01768728531897068, 0.0013210171600803733, 0.01832377351820469, 0.02114802971482277, 0.0411878265440464, 0.06118506193161011, 0.012796583585441113, -0.032452989369630814, -0.037036679685115814, 0.028837935999035835, 0.019254984334111214, 0.0036622670013457537, 0.00209059938788414, -0.028954584151506424, -0.023822244256734848, -0.03688511997461319, 0.019741080701351166, -0.03468084707856178, -0.015373476780951023, 0.012695502489805222, 0.0032948567532002926, 0.07547181844711304, 0.009485095739364624, -0.05232938751578331, 0.051187094300985336, -0.015664031729102135, -0.00842888280749321, 0.007083819713443518, 0.029639199376106262, 0.017363252118229866, 0.06228630989789963, -0.01624363847076893, 0.0018834630027413368, -0.033713970333337784, -0.06992551684379578, 0.004218625836074352, 0.01889200136065483, -0.007325262296944857, -0.02827920764684677, -0.036125585436820984, -0.019275721162557602, 0.04289263114333153, -0.04193394258618355, -0.0028337156400084496, -0.02122948132455349, -0.019861821085214615, -0.05192127823829651, -0.0380651094019413, 0.029245318844914436, -0.04171823337674141, -0.02041863463819027, 0.019058693200349808, -0.05476289987564087, -0.06079818308353424, -0.0008503604913130403, -0.03979341313242912, -0.03249547630548477, -0.014905416406691074, -0.03056158311665058, 0.026025911793112755, 0.00008619714935775846, -0.026864327490329742, -0.014453723095357418, -0.017147080972790718, -0.02980533055961132, -0.03177911788225174, 0.013099616393446922, -0.03186583146452904, 0.005777742248028517, 0.022336876019835472, -0.017443792894482613, -0.04205557703971863, -0.060275059193372726, 0.022851891815662384, 0.01292649656534195, -0.0017825821414589882, -0.023310020565986633, 0.012739625759422779, 0.006389001850038767, -0.0069157094694674015, 0.0457124188542366, 0.011041813530027866, -0.03198806568980217, 0.004073289223015308, 0.03318411111831665, -0.024561649188399315, -0.022614026442170143, -0.02091786451637745, -0.008217249065637589, 0.025413377210497856, -0.006571392063051462, -0.0074979993514716625, -0.04269885644316673, 0.022243168205022812, 0.024661021307110786, -0.07498978078365326, 0.026096513494849205, 0.01617303490638733 ]
<p>For an experiment I will hopefully be soon conducting at Johns Hopkins I need two different lenses.</p> <p>The first needs to allow all wavelengths above 500 nm to pass (thus a high pass filter) and cut off everything else.<br> The second needs to allow all wavelengths below 370 nm to pass (thus a low pass filter) and cut off everything else.</p> <p>My knowledge of optics is middling. I know that good old glass cuts of UV light, but I was hoping for something more specific. Does anyone know of the theory necessary to "tune" materials to make such filters?</p> <p>Truth be told, I'm an experimentalist, so simply giving me a retail source that has such lenses would get me to where I need to go! But learning the theory would be nice as well.</p> <p>Thanks, Sam</p>
g4231
[ -0.013421379029750824, -0.05285293236374855, 0.008875350467860699, 0.04869786277413368, 0.030309848487377167, -0.01600090228021145, -0.019174203276634216, 0.018713658675551414, 0.04470350593328476, -0.009845969267189503, 0.05082476884126663, 0.043344076722860336, 0.02381031960248947, -0.013843218795955181, -0.0027420618571341038, 0.030412981286644936, -0.006663622800260782, 0.0560624822974205, 0.01008476223796606, 0.026804989203810692, -0.040838733315467834, 0.008450817316770554, 0.006607174873352051, -0.05175800621509552, -0.04761384800076485, -0.010522326454520226, -0.05223315209150314, 0.026054026558995247, -0.044671233743429184, 0.06311856955289841, 0.009893957525491714, -0.07642094790935516, 0.02640952542424202, -0.04166097939014435, 0.032137680798769, 0.03155533969402313, 0.03322407975792885, -0.0028597586788237095, -0.036603718996047974, 0.024857953190803528, -0.036064859479665756, 0.031196314841508865, -0.025947021320462227, -0.04102884232997894, 0.042311929166316986, -0.00672351848334074, -0.02872689813375473, -0.030852990224957466, -0.0067562321200966835, -0.05811421573162079, 0.0017698797164484859, 0.024487599730491638, 0.008959045633673668, 0.010059653781354427, -0.04271411895751953, -0.007555338554084301, -0.024896075949072838, 0.04262169077992439, 0.06434967368841171, -0.02221238985657692, -0.0036441260017454624, -0.03263938054442406, -0.04468921944499016, 0.02128361165523529, -0.03946872055530548, 0.0336742177605629, 0.019158830866217613, -0.09456741064786911, 0.023320941254496574, 0.06085958331823349, -0.039331693202257156, 0.037150025367736816, -0.06034868210554123, -0.025293827056884766, 0.03710586205124855, 0.007577760145068169, -0.016919365152716637, 0.051598113030195236, -0.014570229686796665, 0.005219963379204273, -0.006035583093762398, 0.019666660577058792, -0.06557983160018921, 0.07208497077226639, 0.022891094908118248, -0.02147088386118412, 0.019282402470707893, 0.005508701782673597, 0.007835491560399532, -0.04010152816772461, -0.00720447301864624, 0.020413897931575775, 0.04860398918390274, -0.026021618396043777, 0.07541447132825851, 0.10568783432245255, -0.02385234832763672, 0.04820540174841881, -0.0164254829287529, 0.004088048357516527, 0.01897646300494671, -0.011167062446475029, 0.08122991770505905, 0.008635979145765305, -0.05851508304476738, -0.027446551248431206, 0.06558442860841751, -0.013556667603552341, -0.009902612306177616, 0.02093544416129589, -0.09892117977142334, -0.001394133549183607, -0.06700890511274338, -0.0030602291226387024, -0.027366381138563156, -0.042821746319532394, 0.0024172686971724033, 0.022711358964443207, 0.022519567981362343, 0.04032903164625168, 0.029376531019806862, 0.03274358808994293, 0.025504611432552338, 0.03479233384132385, -0.005517125595360994, 0.017850082367658615, 0.0028152968734502792, 0.018921738490462303, 0.02492467686533928, -0.00689990958198905, 0.044149190187454224, -0.07952012866735458, 0.013049924746155739, 0.011860707774758339, -0.0066104973666369915, -0.025778764858841896, 0.028292760252952576, -0.025804441422224045, 0.026704706251621246, -0.019654622301459312, 0.03476204350590706, -0.012954872101545334, 0.022917339578270912, -0.0019921218045055866, -0.03399909660220146, 0.012852064333856106, -0.06870148330926895, 0.013983987271785736, 0.03870401158928871, -0.021360084414482117, 0.06375816464424133, 0.01191735453903675, 0.053725190460681915, 0.042778365314006805, -0.043911926448345184, -0.007246396504342556, -0.022717377170920372, -0.06540068238973618, 0.013992118649184704, -0.032621677964925766, -0.006178450305014849, -0.00338243180885911, -0.025878727436065674, -0.0027351826429367065, -0.06536152958869934, -0.01931489259004593, -0.030311763286590576, -0.033056605607271194, -0.01109321042895317, -0.047885116189718246, -0.03527556732296944, 0.018513532355427742, 0.03628985211253166, 0.03793128952383995, 0.005325136706233025, 0.05512913689017296, 0.11228454113006592, -0.028464993461966515, -0.014645972289144993, 0.06973432004451752, -0.04759512469172478, -0.015904627740383148, -0.025117570534348488, -0.043090324848890305, 0.002737731672823429, -0.010664313100278378, 0.0002841309178620577, -0.059068772941827774, -0.015060951933264732, 0.022396773099899292, -0.0014033678453415632, -0.014204805716872215, 0.015692779794335365, -0.0543164499104023, -0.024691961705684662, -0.02002672106027603, 0.007528242189437151, 0.005596770904958248, -0.01130825188010931, 0.05079301446676254, -0.026614932343363762, 0.009887352585792542, -0.02171105146408081, 0.023002637550234795, 0.041402820497751236, 0.005245552398264408, 0.0388241671025753, 0.00002941596721939277, -0.00405679177492857, -0.009250996634364128, -0.08614516258239746, -0.0008638714789412916, 0.043093491345644, -0.043976470828056335, 0.004374970681965351, 0.0028202279936522245, 0.0012222093064337969, -0.006695365533232689, -0.010752896778285503, 0.0085514597594738, 0.0418320894241333, 0.030521707609295845, 0.04108840227127075, 0.021359575912356377, 0.006322621833533049, -0.010791999287903309, 0.017697066068649292, 0.04010838642716408, 0.04755342751741409, -0.04662959650158882, -0.020710475742816925, 0.010765544138848782, -0.0010995437623932958, -0.041638102382421494, -0.014369135722517967, 0.04295140877366066, 0.0007168674492277205, -0.050261933356523514, 0.015284165740013123, 0.00740771135315299, -0.005755663383752108, 0.005723999347537756, -0.015733547508716583, -0.018192298710346222, -0.0031946205999702215, -0.07959173619747162, -0.01392719428986311, 0.033339325338602066, -0.012339875102043152, 0.005960970651358366, -0.0015655697789043188, 0.009534072130918503, -0.02652130462229252, -0.010433387011289597, -0.07076849788427353, -0.058155909180641174, 0.00015935194096527994, 0.050782233476638794, -0.05877567082643509, -0.002845900831744075, -0.014938239939510822, -0.046441566199064255, 0.024330390617251396, 0.011132389307022095, -0.06520191580057144, -0.01852949522435665, -0.08953621983528137, -0.015598861500620842, 0.0383504182100296, 0.03442307934165001, -0.010461924597620964, 0.013461824506521225, 0.035331644117832184, -0.006524760276079178, 0.00005809398498968221, 0.014234205707907677, -0.025682048872113228, -0.0030231850687414408, -0.007606349419802427, 0.04738934710621834, 0.003200155682861805, 0.023057959973812103, -0.02999235689640045, 0.03430555388331413, 0.04101080447435379, -0.02959316037595272, 0.04182766377925873, -0.007327784784138203, 0.016811100766062737, 0.04560389369726181, -0.07783254981040955, 0.04606851562857628, 0.01785942167043686, 0.03216611593961716, -0.02372092567384243, 0.00000818279295344837, 0.028573831543326378, -0.023964209482073784, -0.056973110884428024, 0.04820459336042404, -0.039604008197784424, -0.0011272422270849347, 0.0019371125381439924, 0.02268584817647934, 0.0038011069409549236, -0.03025876358151436, -0.021295176818966866, -0.025450080633163452, 0.011185678653419018, 0.025483334437012672, -0.0007495105965062976, -0.04352901130914688, 0.031982291489839554, -0.00148483132943511, 0.04110490530729294, 0.006319093983620405, -0.00038328280788846314, -0.05166025832295418, -0.022289326414465904, -0.019796712324023247, 0.054254982620477676, 0.039477791637182236, 0.03041345812380314, -0.02194269560277462, 0.004945873748511076, 0.009256288409233093, 0.023594560101628304, -0.05508444830775261, -0.034069161862134933, 0.046496327966451645, 0.047502800822257996, 0.04076598584651947, -0.07019683718681335, 0.03880712389945984, 0.004600109998136759, -0.022700350731611252, -0.03228871524333954, 0.01796618103981018, 0.05906970798969269, -0.01665215939283371, 0.02543419972062111, 0.023940183222293854, -0.0452117845416069, 0.001085291849449277, 0.036825235933065414, -0.005942194256931543, 0.022495949640870094, -0.00840578880161047, -0.016017979010939598, -0.03151674196124077, 0.030416080728173256, -0.006126605439931154, 0.009395290166139603, -0.009745116345584393, -0.02844691462814808, 0.07321099936962128, 0.03605491667985916, 0.06479410082101822, 0.10760942846536636, -0.013861036859452724, -0.009333842433989048, -0.005567613057792187, 0.030368158593773842, -0.04755271226167679, -0.003979019820690155, 0.010364251211285591, 0.02008545771241188, -0.01612784154713154, -0.008368446491658688, 0.047612763941287994, 0.02968325838446617, 0.015362618491053581, -0.04405659809708595, -0.0016900040209293365, -0.10762082040309906, 0.029882963746786118, 0.08289835602045059, 0.06101786345243454, -0.09434161335229874, 0.04384731501340866, 0.02997633069753647, 0.08154371380805969, 0.054677337408065796, 0.047887369990348816, 0.010332181118428707, -0.03216220811009407, -0.028196390718221664, -0.04853314161300659, 0.0004342686152085662, -0.01358514092862606, -0.03854905441403389, -0.027136655524373055, -0.04940292611718178, -0.049504272639751434, -0.04775587469339371, -0.08158133178949356, 0.011230644769966602, -0.07472462952136993, -0.009350371547043324, -0.009071864187717438, 0.041681427508592606, 0.05164145305752754, -0.017502104863524437, -0.038177333772182465, -0.061080824583768845, 0.015207546763122082, -0.017356757074594498, 0.016278717666864395, -0.022648677229881287, 0.030473044142127037, -0.024623440578579903, -0.03908436372876167, 0.04476168379187584, -0.07242411375045776, 0.04508112370967865, 0.007531085982918739, -0.005331671331077814, -0.016809217631816864, 0.06603964418172836, 0.016924120485782623, -0.031476955860853195, 0.058171313256025314, -0.03310289978981018, -0.027334608137607574, 0.041674479842185974, 0.03564009815454483, -0.0027984960470348597, -0.03535952791571617, 0.054640863090753555, -0.01574200950562954, 0.03745529055595398, -0.04081139340996742, -0.009329667314887047, 0.01966099627315998, 0.024800674989819527, -0.00510775251314044, -0.07665656507015228, -0.003934208303689957, -0.002770225750282407, 0.06289875507354736, -0.02030818723142147, 0.0057957288809120655, -0.012287462130188942, -0.04778911545872688, 0.05698687210679054, 0.01067282073199749, 0.00872114673256874, 0.05609240010380745, -0.026181884109973907, 0.018269093707203865, -0.022874705493450165, -0.03571799769997597, -0.046495504677295685, -0.030681859701871872, -0.038012344390153885, 0.007149614859372377, -0.01076314877718687, 0.033730003982782364, 0.07049553096294403, -0.024897731840610504, 0.01141984760761261, 0.021830230951309204, -0.008795135654509068, -0.010882705450057983, 0.05831237882375717, 0.03266110271215439, -0.012144163250923157, -0.048213835805654526, -0.00863880105316639, -0.01126709021627903, 0.004974012728780508, 0.00046478150761686265, 0.06014471873641014, 0.09133346378803253, 0.002550463890656829, -0.053432922810316086, -0.03624308109283447, -0.04843972250819206, -0.007140590343624353, 0.038830384612083435, -0.05693522095680237, 0.03709811717271805, 0.04418715089559555, 0.032267455011606216, 0.033586226403713226, -0.011367762461304665, -0.018608730286359787, 0.05354531481862068, -0.0175944697111845, -0.015254199504852295, -0.025204991921782494, 0.0009697395144030452, 0.004832260310649872, 0.033103954046964645, -0.03439480438828468, 0.031173087656497955, 0.048904094845056534, -0.0007131207385100424, -0.013270328752696514, 0.01927216723561287, -0.0018980825552716851, -0.022368257865309715, -0.010639938525855541, -0.040163084864616394, -0.003740383544936776, -0.011948804371058941, 0.054822370409965515, 0.022455882281064987, 0.03150221332907677, 0.03253532573580742, 0.0028680937830358744, -0.0018800253747031093, 0.034345533698797226, 0.02422511577606201, 0.02767021209001541, -0.0067534055560827255, -0.026368310675024986, 0.050525203347206116, -0.0224757082760334, -0.00723696406930685, -0.028144434094429016, -0.039159610867500305, -0.01068636029958725, 0.05861001834273338, 0.05678370222449303, 0.05408891662955284, -0.01676253043115139, 0.016695303842425346, 0.02407880499958992, -0.05332450568675995, -0.030745021998882294, 0.019967705011367798, 0.00878142286092043, -0.027094032615423203, 0.025703415274620056, -0.006783998105674982, 0.005637434311211109, 0.03666594624519348, -0.07677870988845825, 0.0026712026447057724, -0.040144745260477066, 0.05567986145615578, 0.08112134784460068, 0.02773861028254032, -0.008656992577016354, -0.016625719144940376, 0.04491495341062546, 0.01249182689934969, 0.04957032948732376, 0.017270052805542946, -0.019093243405222893, 0.0023458695504814386, 0.0036597102880477905, -0.019087690860033035, 0.015474707819521427, 0.015056927688419819, -0.021306369453668594, 0.011003272607922554, 0.05686961114406586, -0.002455464331433177, 0.05284402519464493, -0.012775150127708912, -0.010060062631964684, -0.023218123242259026, -0.025114063173532486, -0.07460276782512665, 0.005660889204591513, -0.01450017187744379, -0.0001724291651044041, -0.014283311553299427, -0.06424102932214737, -0.03514935076236725, -0.034146662801504135, -0.04411929100751877, -0.022701183333992958, 0.05356663092970848, -0.02848088927567005, -0.0762181207537651, -0.004849418997764587, -0.001806272310204804, 0.012858366593718529, 0.050336793065071106, -0.05699894577264786, -0.008687221445143223, -0.08954527974128723, 0.027729542925953865, -0.007907033897936344, -0.041500937193632126, 0.017512274906039238, -0.03632217273116112, -0.02803547866642475, -0.019601179286837578, -0.049479953944683075, 0.004590047989040613, 0.00628474447876215, 0.004250412341207266, 0.014519349671900272, 0.004801089875400066, -0.028047895058989525, 0.06794331222772598, 0.01930098421871662, -0.07193120568990707, 0.0025395452976226807, -0.03934839740395546, 0.028321359306573868, 0.061780743300914764, -0.005432244390249252, -0.0061771865002810955, 0.032266877591609955, 0.01962638832628727, -0.024108512327075005, 0.01369041483849287, 0.006824033334851265, -0.012605729512870312, -0.07615754753351212, 0.03296656161546707, -0.0401260070502758, 0.012036879546940327, -0.055615246295928955, -0.004151133354753256, 0.0013833893463015556, -0.06214509159326553, -0.06293168663978577, 0.00995475985109806, -0.006266093347221613, 0.02454441413283348, 0.06371119618415833, -0.04777442663908005, 0.02150014229118824, 0.02414991334080696, 0.016356918960809708, -0.03844026103615761, 0.08024809509515762, -0.015246540307998657, 0.00253534154035151, 0.04461821913719177, -0.05398227646946907, 0.018738649785518646, 0.024321304634213448, 0.015438373200595379, 0.03944510221481323, 0.0006379817496053874, 0.005819458514451981, 0.07722412794828415, 0.016285087913274765, 0.024182412773370743, -0.003553553018718958, -0.006306434981524944, -0.050066832453012466, -0.004240979440510273, -0.008277799002826214, 0.0005475265788845718, -0.005447197239845991, 0.01262951735407114, 0.0076716067269444466, 0.0679430216550827, -0.005363240838050842, 0.047352101653814316, 0.03899024426937103, -0.021679464727640152, 0.04938603192567825, -0.001282078679651022, 0.019259953871369362, -0.00314985029399395, -0.033697303384542465, 0.02859671227633953, 0.0024313805624842644, -0.004733910318464041, -0.04108922928571701, 0.004163307137787342, -0.016870973631739616, -0.004177037160843611, 0.003418115433305502, -0.014868708327412605, -0.012870250269770622, -0.03283859044313431, -0.07573714107275009, 0.08140666037797928, -0.00543691823258996, -0.008534467779099941, 0.009761419147253036, 0.03920525312423706, 0.031124355271458626, -0.08176211267709732, -0.03990541398525238, -0.02070659212768078, -0.05278816446661949, -0.025275304913520813, 0.08833962678909302, 0.021304205060005188, -0.042184438556432724, 0.036456286907196045, 0.021198388189077377, -0.03952093422412872, -0.02611185796558857, 0.020064380019903183, -0.0003968837554566562, -0.003390298457816243, 0.0075078862719237804, 0.018076838925480843, -0.00425001559779048, -0.017737770453095436, -0.005616150330752134, -0.04577208682894707, -0.016892684623599052, 0.0423768050968647, -0.01970621384680271, -0.05711360275745392, 0.052002787590026855, -0.011891218833625317, 0.01793995499610901, 0.014069559052586555, 0.012224189937114716, 0.05545920133590698, 0.01506405882537365, -0.01807333156466484, -0.04792119562625885, -0.02628001570701599, -0.027601109817624092, 0.049934688955545425, -0.015408642590045929, 0.005898440722376108, 0.052375342696905136, -0.06652768701314926, -0.018804257735610008, -0.033766746520996094, 0.007479793392121792, -0.0024945037439465523, -0.054428547620773315, -0.006216524634510279, 0.006580838933587074, -0.03367406129837036, -0.06895865499973297, -0.03115190379321575, -0.012812000699341297, 0.039599549025297165, -0.0340423658490181, -0.014692326076328754, 0.02670297585427761, 0.034581832587718964, 0.06207584962248802, -0.010518628172576427, -0.07352783530950546, -0.06495615839958191, -0.0003069984959438443, -0.042738206684589386, -0.012479128316044807, -0.023325752466917038, 0.004735256545245647, 0.005719324573874474, -0.04106608405709267, 0.049228522926568985, 0.011396398767828941, 0.04233690723776817, -0.002854567253962159, -0.06641121208667755, 0.03884293511509895, -0.02972160466015339, 0.008511033840477467, 0.008500867523252964, 0.01073671504855156, -0.011624135076999664, 0.04374868795275688, 0.09885694831609726, 0.01944558322429657, 0.002383045619353652, 0.029713556170463562, -0.05529871955513954 ]
<p>You build a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dyson_sphere">Dyson sphere</a> around a star to capture all its energy. The outer surface of the Dyson sphere still radiates heat at much higher temperature than the cold space background, so you're easy to detect.</p> <p>But you'd like to stay hidden. So you cool the outer surface of the Dyson sphere to near cold space background. Of course you still need to radiate your excess heat somewhere, so you plan to radiate it off in directed beams, away from the directions of the nearby solar systems, to stay hidden from your neighbors at least.</p> <p><strong>Questions</strong>:</p> <ol> <li>Is such directed radiation of excess heat allowed by known laws of physics?</li> <li>Would the energy of the star be sufficient for running the cooling system?</li> </ol>
g4232
[ -0.012393352575600147, 0.02964744344353676, 0.01158730499446392, -0.006792120635509491, -0.038763053715229034, 0.0037491675466299057, -0.025339379906654358, 0.01598932221531868, 0.006249442230910063, -0.04185229539871216, -0.0009193358127959073, 0.11741098016500473, 0.019341496750712395, -0.013194721192121506, 0.008530909195542336, 0.016774829477071762, 0.050744008272886276, -0.04677137732505798, 0.013557927682995796, 0.0830005556344986, -0.0454968623816967, -0.051871176809072495, 0.027399985119700432, -0.02036040648818016, -0.03612241521477699, -0.05457009747624397, 0.021076131612062454, 0.015639545395970345, -0.04643469303846359, -0.041769396513700485, 0.0007491945871151984, -0.001800927217118442, 0.07092680037021637, -0.008315165527164936, -0.008567852899432182, -0.011332154273986816, 0.0318274199962616, 0.0176453348249197, -0.06282895803451538, -0.03646949678659439, -0.026646023616194725, 0.005141983740031719, -0.005976535379886627, -0.0026962331030517817, 0.01965850405395031, 0.024220295250415802, -0.00007279066630871966, 0.006600789725780487, -0.023267358541488647, -0.007892766036093235, -0.02061634324491024, -0.028364289551973343, 0.006948452442884445, -0.025357604026794434, -0.01830912008881569, -0.027654346078634262, -0.05598777160048485, -0.06663314998149872, 0.08811171352863312, -0.014856018126010895, 0.023792413994669914, 0.042636431753635406, -0.058258384466171265, -0.032148659229278564, -0.014865221455693245, -0.03221506625413895, -0.045655008405447006, -0.04794686287641525, -0.02301604300737381, 0.0014006884302943945, 0.033430084586143494, -0.03835117816925049, -0.03232675790786743, -0.09208281338214874, 0.0034991034772247076, 0.01636854000389576, -0.011931058019399643, -0.02362590655684471, -0.003005749313160777, 0.05225575342774391, -0.04433377459645271, -0.04743003845214844, -0.0009594238363206387, -0.035291578620672226, 0.11061439663171768, 0.006684143096208572, -0.006300996523350477, -0.03848147764801979, -0.01073515135794878, 0.00694629130885005, 0.02018836699426174, 0.0772789791226387, 0.06477521359920502, -0.010668309405446053, 0.024582477286458015, 0.022595221176743507, -0.02385818026959896, -0.020431704819202423, -0.014146184548735619, -0.021184047684073448, -0.008778855204582214, 0.003426161827519536, 0.03995630517601967, 0.010229790583252907, 0.039785776287317276, -0.01552475057542324, -0.0033333878964185715, 0.012680552899837494, -0.011351949535310268, 0.010505693964660168, -0.032823074609041214, -0.09343472868204117, 0.014294816181063652, -0.03948589786887169, -0.02160225622355938, -0.0015227049589157104, 0.07019592821598053, -0.032066162675619125, -0.006576088257133961, 0.04995846375823021, 0.05844076722860336, 0.050142962485551834, -0.015596872195601463, 0.005473170429468155, -0.004525128286331892, 0.024674806743860245, -0.00860307551920414, -0.04151967167854309, 0.058814484626054764, -0.00690822908654809, 0.032301243394613266, 0.003094273153692484, -0.07276332378387451, 0.023698868229985237, -0.017618080601096153, 0.03750060498714447, -0.024691982194781303, 0.02585207112133503, -0.029030514881014824, -0.04042481631040573, 0.036267682909965515, 0.007578372489660978, 0.019745616242289543, -0.013156680390238762, -0.04930339753627777, 0.011826748959720135, -0.027020486071705818, -0.026975765824317932, 0.04687366634607315, 0.028245551511645317, -0.008041711524128914, 0.045840222388505936, 0.022441817447543144, -0.05135639011859894, 0.07606806606054306, 0.021287351846694946, 0.017740212380886078, -0.0027882622089236975, 0.03604146093130112, -0.021399380639195442, 0.011810634285211563, 0.047429464757442474, 0.04320476949214935, -0.04103219881653786, -0.0302694421261549, -0.014390547759830952, -0.020055707544088364, -0.04709408059716225, 0.002228546654805541, 0.013858570717275143, -0.05359062924981117, 0.008856773376464844, -0.0037884435150772333, -0.0066667660139501095, -0.015572783537209034, 0.041462961584329605, 0.05642804875969887, -0.025366228073835373, -0.01489280816167593, 0.01537842582911253, 0.008748737163841724, -0.0029209950007498264, 0.035300083458423615, 0.036665067076683044, 0.01823239214718342, 0.013033472001552582, 0.025467028841376305, -0.0666489452123642, 0.007955401204526424, 0.04976228252053261, -0.0038500840310007334, -0.022470606490969658, 0.019806556403636932, 0.09322869777679443, 0.011927729472517967, -0.04962656646966934, 0.02582794986665249, -0.024913949891924858, -0.05270480737090111, 0.07870732247829437, 0.03412863239645958, 0.012339537963271141, -0.002764762146398425, -0.007519301492720842, 0.032494883984327316, 0.016296716406941414, -0.0011549047194421291, 0.0024026574101299047, 0.05235782265663147, -0.03330650180578232, 0.046626947820186615, 0.0004841306072194129, 0.027216874063014984, -0.005406626034528017, 0.010525397956371307, 0.008953835815191269, -0.03150619566440582, 0.024490494281053543, -0.018828606233000755, 0.02718067355453968, -0.021345041692256927, 0.03065362572669983, 0.03334081545472145, -0.0113269267603755, -0.02636725641787052, 0.037166185677051544, -0.1392810195684433, -0.013400842435657978, -0.0038371579721570015, 0.09842417389154434, -0.030873049050569534, -0.03188105672597885, 0.06389590352773666, -0.0492679625749588, 0.06261110305786133, -0.010832419618964195, -0.06259556114673615, 0.045445021241903305, 0.0032601249404251575, 0.012307667173445225, -0.03990725800395012, -0.008208745159208775, -0.04722622409462929, -0.019525673240423203, 0.0047861747443675995, -0.00828523002564907, 0.013182053342461586, 0.0018764841370284557, -0.01899360865354538, -0.023150572553277016, 0.02981410175561905, 0.03152582049369812, -0.012730640359222889, -0.0361027754843235, -0.009025897830724716, 0.02311449497938156, -0.10648060590028763, 0.03207399323582649, -0.06280065327882767, -0.08433390408754349, -0.011861471459269524, -0.043734099715948105, 0.009771780110895634, -0.020860744640231133, -0.005168309900909662, 0.016074953600764275, -0.020129460841417313, -0.05579541251063347, 0.04696369916200638, 0.021813973784446716, 0.022050311788916588, 0.08209290355443954, 0.04647013917565346, 0.05955904722213745, -0.007966926321387291, 0.09377601742744446, -0.003014503512531519, 0.009494907222688198, 0.05009586364030838, 0.012300577014684677, 0.03261132910847664, 0.020598238334059715, -0.06373794376850128, 0.03213982284069061, 0.0006368946633301675, -0.0775982216000557, -0.0007438323809765279, 0.00009699033398646861, 0.018897337839007378, -0.08006362617015839, -0.0005395874031819403, -0.029412871226668358, 0.03159723058342934, 0.012446888722479343, -0.007578463293612003, -0.0005668059457093477, 0.021773533895611763, 0.0339742936193943, 0.013488931581377983, 0.06471941620111465, 0.022006645798683167, -0.05481000617146492, -0.013571348041296005, -0.015388041734695435, 0.03457757085561752, 0.02826264128088951, -0.10955345630645752, -0.004179778974503279, 0.043519359081983566, 0.01739880070090294, 0.06838183850049973, 0.013282153755426407, 0.03948390856385231, 0.056060321629047394, 0.018859801813960075, -0.015290752984583378, -0.03240739554166794, -0.06421435624361038, 0.008637783117592335, 0.033416908234357834, 0.042969342321157455, 0.10335475951433182, -0.015073982998728752, -0.03627974912524223, 0.025416677817702293, 0.025929491966962814, 0.014050072059035301, -0.01524902693927288, 0.006847379729151726, -0.02181711234152317, -0.0030683926306664944, -0.023287275806069374, -0.0035686215851455927, 0.01757086254656315, -0.0534823015332222, 0.04409245401620865, -0.05409443378448486, 0.022859470918774605, 0.03774216026067734, 0.023390430957078934, 0.009952745400369167, -0.04572562500834465, -0.019806059077382088, -0.005788824055343866, -0.0061631277203559875, 0.03594835102558136, 0.0007399695459753275, -0.03442908823490143, -0.005034775007516146, 0.024710221216082573, 0.04470529779791832, -0.017615005373954773, -0.027833852916955948, -0.007267836015671492, -0.03956584259867668, -0.0024493103846907616, 0.00587228499352932, 0.029937585815787315, 0.027043040841817856, -0.02995433658361435, -0.004163471050560474, 0.008646736852824688, 0.0032293631229549646, -0.07760486751794815, 0.04299665987491608, 0.031043289229273796, 0.038849253207445145, -0.02653597667813301, -0.01695891283452511, 0.029436537995934486, -0.020174644887447357, -0.025325126945972443, -0.08285258710384369, 0.0024092046078294516, 0.04569750651717186, -0.012671896256506443, 0.04819784685969353, 0.033445220440626144, -0.042127374559640884, 0.008500393480062485, -0.053947869688272476, 0.0420154444873333, -0.0023165051825344563, 0.03691228851675987, 0.010000396519899368, 0.026915572583675385, 0.01588834635913372, -0.010633980855345726, 0.012816772796213627, -0.0015826545422896743, -0.003641064977273345, -0.03397094085812569, 0.05451127141714096, 0.05198676139116287, -0.0031326257158070803, -0.00040241109672933817, 0.043668631464242935, 0.013014629483222961, 0.009379245340824127, -0.030445028096437454, 0.044254183769226074, 0.026065180078148842, 0.04726212099194527, -0.0631004050374031, -0.009385669603943825, -0.05251602455973625, -0.006228032521903515, -0.01897609978914261, -0.025660621002316475, -0.0031420125160366297, 0.030325284227728844, -0.03766421228647232, 0.01245785504579544, -0.04272812232375145, 0.04308784753084183, -0.010889855213463306, -0.02228160761296749, -0.02909177914261818, -0.01677398942410946, -0.016274048015475273, -0.04836878180503845, -0.030254317447543144, -0.004717395640909672, 0.032694317400455475, -0.018186181783676147, 0.0693606585264206, 0.04163279011845589, -0.06611666083335876, -0.06366949528455734, 0.010727772489190102, 0.07308544963598251, 0.015230672433972359, -0.05385369807481766, 0.026676369830965996, -0.03417884185910225, 0.012704016640782356, -0.05016851797699928, 0.027300754562020302, -0.017890894785523415, 0.03845841437578201, 0.009352845139801502, -0.045356813818216324, 0.052415285259485245, -0.02248666249215603, -0.01810893416404724, 0.08978622406721115, 0.028387518599629402, -0.050629258155822754, -0.014946376904845238, -0.02543305978178978, -0.011296617798507214, -0.009365681558847427, -0.05689147114753723, 0.050690945237874985, -0.016253255307674408, -0.02276044338941574, -0.054797809571027756, 0.026267405599355698, -0.008532470092177391, 0.03424694761633873, -0.022215355187654495, -0.05386551097035408, 0.04635186493396759, -0.016078241169452667, 0.01635563187301159, 0.008908559568226337, -0.02011466957628727, -0.03446710854768753, 0.0028229383751749992, 0.03237030655145645, -0.001290900050662458, 0.07528432458639145, 0.050084102898836136, 0.055480536073446274, -0.061231523752212524, -0.04851234704256058, -0.006370867602527142, -0.02311309240758419, -0.011397519148886204, 0.02157861739397049, -0.02618812769651413, 0.03961767628788948, 0.038585733622312546, 0.054962463676929474, 0.007488940376788378, 0.022765271365642548, -0.07247819751501083, -0.009970509447157383, 0.00014883354015182704, 0.014137488789856434, -0.04717127978801727, 0.0053219273686409, -0.009614970535039902, 0.019228121265769005, -0.00033353714388795197, 0.014519506134092808, -0.04710306227207184, -0.07126396894454956, -0.01621897704899311, 0.04103318974375725, 0.050666820257902145, 0.010645084083080292, -0.006072809919714928, 0.015440370887517929, -0.023144681006669998, 0.01650257036089897, 0.05036887526512146, -0.013102193363010883, 0.0014832749729976058, -0.03990975022315979, -0.049725789576768875, 0.05633685737848282, 0.009930917993187904, -0.03031347505748272, 0.02989499643445015, -0.08692912012338638, -0.05846837908029556, 0.03276142105460167, -0.004786612465977669, -0.005501716863363981, -0.025898395106196404, -0.020916728302836418, 0.004353066440671682, -0.023756548762321472, 0.012690851464867592, 0.010885236784815788, -0.048461444675922394, 0.016547253355383873, -0.006027988623827696, -0.006914564408361912, 0.018308168277144432, -0.016967350617051125, -0.06261814385652542, 0.05523373931646347, 0.0015332357725128531, 0.007457376923412085, -0.01592748612165451, 0.06010819971561432, 0.007212725467979908, 0.006075542885810137, 0.0066714053973555565, -0.036281734704971313, 0.06329884380102158, 0.026794278994202614, -0.026136105880141258, -0.004733574576675892, -0.03975515812635422, -0.007602175232023001, 0.05127483978867531, -0.04248248040676117, -0.03165228292346001, -0.004378303419798613, 0.026561018079519272, -0.00234031630679965, 0.02448028326034546, -0.017655527219176292, -0.038045886904001236, 0.031138841062784195, 0.028390275314450264, 0.009080025367438793, -0.05738462507724762, -0.04061390832066536, 0.03936130553483963, 0.0035222815349698067, 0.00793503224849701, -0.0001549992011860013, -0.027034441009163857, -0.04126106947660446, 0.0585167333483696, 0.020427731797099113, 0.013934418559074402, -0.04307065159082413, 0.010070388205349445, 0.01807595230638981, 0.06056996434926987, -0.006004486698657274, -0.013714578934013844, 0.05106654763221741, 0.0036461108829826117, 0.010759830474853516, 0.0014317079912871122, -0.007266854867339134, 0.016290811821818352, -0.03990766778588295, 0.04417400434613228, 0.03621748834848404, -0.01973448321223259, 0.060534197837114334, -0.0002300723863299936, -0.10649828612804413, -0.0012657964834943414, -0.08720775693655014, -0.005001466255635023, 0.02336004190146923, -0.04599085822701454, -0.02045658603310585, -0.029563775286078453, 0.047012802213430405, -0.005789638496935368, -0.006409222725778818, 0.03372979536652565, -0.09403425455093384, 0.003933619242161512, -0.029391570016741753, 0.014413509517908096, 0.013232095167040825, 0.0061261835508048534, -0.008177543058991432, 0.004466979764401913, 0.0371101014316082, -0.004498324356973171, -0.016443734988570213, 0.027765056118369102, -0.03762878105044365, -0.007413832470774651, -0.041720855981111526, -0.0013665227452293038, 0.010644967667758465, 0.03859075903892517, -0.005948674865067005, 0.02788422629237175, -0.03232520818710327, -0.007680668029934168, -0.025162087753415108, -0.025568241253495216, 0.01166365947574377, -0.021253811195492744, 0.026948638260364532, 0.03795071318745613, 0.04964378848671913, 0.03991544991731644, 0.018559809774160385, -0.01652635633945465, -0.023256240412592888, 0.016798852011561394, 0.010641091503202915, 0.03083035536110401, 0.04487568140029907, -0.005066375248134136, 0.02615473046898842, -0.05984564125537872, 0.033913303166627884, -0.008961698040366173, 0.05108635500073433, 0.016316372901201248, 0.004260671325027943, 0.019661011174321175, 0.005822984501719475, 0.0001911259605549276, -0.020239785313606262, -0.010449639521539211, -0.05885256454348564, -0.0456199012696743, -0.040962446480989456, 0.014746995642781258, -0.006652385927736759, -0.020939290523529053, 0.03962353616952896, -0.030889807268977165, -0.09809644520282745, 0.05216535925865173, -0.03375275060534477, -0.0060694245621562, 0.016553742811083794, 0.051381856203079224, 0.049090947955846786, 0.04501236230134964, -0.0051485588774085045, -0.02922508306801319, -0.002972847782075405, -0.0016371144447475672, 0.031397074460983276, -0.03264491632580757, -0.02104935236275196, -0.005189796444028616, -0.031463511288166046, 0.015798822045326233, 0.00007776146230753511, 0.025861695408821106, 0.008622388355433941, 0.0019238493405282497, -0.007885266095399857, -0.03047722950577736, -0.006073538679629564, -0.07284823060035706, 0.00821299385279417, -0.03353922814130783, -0.0260213203728199, 0.05104437097907066, -0.0036230147816240788, -0.08035114407539368, 0.04506201669573784, 0.01642863266170025, 0.0363883301615715, -0.015676990151405334, 0.055959247052669525, 0.06328810751438141, 0.013556904159486294, -0.012509718537330627, -0.03215784952044487, -0.02838759496808052, 0.04589434713125229, 0.03824514150619507, -0.008123052306473255, 0.022509247064590454, 0.046719200909137726, 0.04202193394303322, -0.013754759915173054, 0.005164012778550386, 0.030363446101546288, 0.013435160741209984, 0.054945655167102814, 0.0056401933543384075, 0.006090616807341576, -0.016192929819226265, 0.009967120364308357, -0.06717895716428757, 0.06173025071620941, 0.04339788109064102, -0.02706025540828705, -0.03501537814736366, 0.007217151112854481, -0.00017072894843295217, -0.007611133623868227, 0.02158033289015293, -0.0924270823597908, -0.01533162035048008, -0.011350157670676708, 0.04575933516025543, 0.007918030954897404, 0.029299113899469376, 0.04191303253173828, -0.02493542991578579, -0.061999376863241196, -0.020768746733665466, -0.04821411892771721, -0.0017366872634738684, -0.06054748222231865, -0.008259886875748634, 0.040737804025411606, 0.020579375326633453, -0.04804501682519913, 0.0411815382540226, -0.10067050904035568, -0.017211169004440308, -0.026878628879785538, -0.03678183630108833, -0.00004915053796139546, 0.07350688427686691, 0.02229967527091503, 0.018720978870987892, 0.01692282035946846, -0.019069291651248932, -0.0011838034261018038, 0.05039968341588974, 0.02063228189945221, -0.0037780513521283865, -0.03354286774992943, -0.0286985095590353, 0.003376609180122614, -0.009633717127144337, 0.006561076268553734, -0.0073652928695082664, -0.01833789423108101, 0.034176766872406006, -0.06096673384308815, -0.0019698133692145348, -0.005824187770485878 ]
<p>An ideal spring is attached to a wall, and the other end is attached to a mass $m$. The spring is initially compressed a distance $x$. After it is released, the mass collides with another mass $2m$ at a distance $x/2$ to the right of the spring equilibrium. The collision is inelastic and they slide together. How far will they slide before coming to a momentary stop?</p> <p><strong>My work</strong></p> <p>Since the collision is inelastic then mechanical energy is not conserved. And since the two-mass system has an external force, momentum is not conserved. So one has to use only mechanical principles to solve this.</p> <p>We can compute the velocity of the mass at the moment of impact using simple harmonic motion, $r(t) = -x\cos\left( t\sqrt{k/m}\right)$ so that $x/2 = -x\cos \left(t^{*}\sqrt{k/m}\right)$. With this I could do an awkward solution for time and maybe continue from there.</p> <p>At this point, though, I'm not perfectly clear on how to move forward. Do I just assume that momentum is conserved for a very, very short time period during the collision and use that to find the velocity of the combined mass system, then put that into another simple harmonic motion problem?</p>
g4233
[ 0.10449334979057312, -0.004901318345218897, 0.013609824702143669, 0.05903295427560806, 0.019909925758838654, -0.021504709497094154, 0.011256461963057518, 0.013462386094033718, -0.08987685292959213, 0.002927361289039254, -0.030996287241578102, -0.038798075169324875, -0.016624152660369873, -0.024074271321296692, -0.011741614900529385, 0.0074331434443593025, 0.10725843161344528, 0.02071927674114704, 0.021005306392908096, 0.0812511295080185, -0.055356454104185104, 0.01400353666394949, 0.0013564350083470345, -0.03090604394674301, 0.00672810897231102, 0.04412452504038811, 0.04277243837714195, 0.03188258409500122, -0.03707248717546463, -0.0235743448138237, -0.01568867452442646, -0.02729598619043827, 0.008329296484589577, -0.029995258897542953, -0.05698461830615997, 0.043228697031736374, 0.0511285737156868, -0.08962078392505646, -0.02053152024745941, -0.011614400893449783, 0.06203899160027504, -0.07481900602579117, 0.036100614815950394, 0.02949894778430462, 0.026208767667412758, -0.008086267858743668, -0.001950872247107327, -0.03321186453104019, -0.00859864242374897, 0.02098800800740719, 0.0322430282831192, 0.06039686128497124, -0.003016125177964568, -0.0271168015897274, 0.003471808275207877, 0.014327493496239185, 0.061541758477687836, -0.043435242027044296, 0.032332152128219604, -0.03543386608362198, -0.012541758827865124, -0.02476629987359047, 0.0028887151274830103, -0.01647336408495903, 0.057485178112983704, -0.011303585022687912, -0.015497841872274876, -0.0214066319167614, 0.07975630462169647, 0.007975212298333645, -0.05569794401526451, 0.02573711983859539, 0.028365783393383026, -0.04439401254057884, -0.02904459834098816, -0.02152714505791664, 0.017846081405878067, -0.010225703939795494, 0.0017261258326470852, -0.029271479696035385, -0.0577067956328392, 0.028359493240714073, 0.049528513103723526, -0.06089632585644722, -0.0012265716213732958, 0.0069597214460372925, -0.012637863866984844, 0.028143303468823433, -0.044729553163051605, -0.018343333154916763, 0.01946256496012211, -0.05962610989809036, -0.006047824863344431, -0.0026500700041651726, -0.009813998825848103, 0.0033107262570410967, -0.03976064547896385, 0.05235093832015991, 0.065908282995224, -0.008529609069228172, -0.03428671881556511, -0.03048042021691799, -0.03274950012564659, -0.016877589747309685, 0.015857815742492676, -0.014119613915681839, 0.0496102049946785, 0.032732073217630386, -0.035397619009017944, 0.0039151739329099655, 0.010558261536061764, -0.06908421963453293, 0.011762664653360844, -0.05100683122873306, -0.01135979499667883, -0.07343024015426636, 0.02254563942551613, 0.00916582066565752, 0.0021037040278315544, 0.05767932906746864, -0.02360020950436592, 0.0029887512791901827, 0.0542605035007, 0.022945459932088852, 0.004931182600557804, -0.03859325498342514, 0.010495944879949093, 0.016002824530005455, 0.026666617020964622, -0.0044447919353842735, -0.05349963158369064, 0.0008882138645276427, 0.06257831305265427, 0.030001411214470863, 0.0075164614245295525, 0.06485264003276825, 0.04712269455194473, 0.03499419242143631, -0.026213403791189194, 0.051513444632291794, 0.02133426070213318, -0.005856154952198267, -0.035883765667676926, -0.0010463736252859235, -0.04572443664073944, 0.0629088506102562, -0.00844504963606596, -0.05250412970781326, -0.009626743383705616, -0.0011006038403138518, -0.013595035299658775, 0.07080695778131485, -0.05359402671456337, 0.0019772311206907034, 0.0637696385383606, -0.004628261551260948, 0.038444213569164276, 0.021044140681624413, -0.03820594400167465, 0.003780709346756339, 0.03856184333562851, -0.032321617007255554, 0.029132820665836334, -0.028418898582458496, -0.024194318801164627, 0.023028938099741936, -0.0314958393573761, -0.07284563779830933, 0.008604466915130615, -0.03880893066525459, -0.07623990625143051, -0.05515497550368309, 0.00840692687779665, 0.08442512154579163, -0.017097271978855133, -0.058907121419906616, 0.03289729356765747, -0.059707771986722946, -0.005592838395386934, -0.03563491627573967, 0.009469185024499893, -0.014325722120702267, 0.045058395713567734, 0.013796786777675152, 0.012137185782194138, 0.03132189065217972, 0.06651940196752548, 0.112682044506073, -0.04026768356561661, 0.017114678397774696, -0.016116300597786903, -0.012518811039626598, 0.012475896626710892, 0.004963553510606289, -0.0528428815305233, 0.019827721640467644, 0.07176433503627777, -0.002561385277658701, -0.045250970870256424, -0.0016697983955964446, 0.0051475632935762405, 0.05250108242034912, 0.054725609719753265, 0.043627914041280746, -0.024006078019738197, 0.03070514276623726, -0.010497605428099632, -0.007220992352813482, -0.02109343931078911, -0.010622192174196243, 0.008617240004241467, -0.014659405685961246, -0.012850145809352398, 0.006413955241441727, -0.0000861956286826171, -0.013223008252680302, -0.009256749413907528, -0.026689304038882256, -0.016646835952997208, 0.04170186445116997, -0.008176103234291077, -0.00394469453021884, 0.04515135660767555, -0.05834512785077095, -0.03961629793047905, -0.0271194688975811, -0.04162057116627693, 0.008876828476786613, 0.015883052721619606, -0.017416413873434067, 0.005824946332722902, 0.10755006223917007, 0.008785372599959373, 0.03175925463438034, 0.008138071745634079, 0.04758092761039734, -0.022352309897542, 0.0100835170596838, 0.005897664465010166, 0.032070402055978775, 0.06319276243448257, -0.026691852137446404, 0.02905048429965973, -0.06098691001534462, -0.0076812501065433025, 0.01938161626458168, 0.05363242328166962, 0.0393393374979496, 0.04361899197101593, 0.038044970482587814, 0.012836924754083157, -0.013251636177301407, 0.007809897419065237, -0.011930214241147041, 0.02838446944952011, -0.0235747043043375, -0.017912134528160095, 0.025296805426478386, 0.004548400174826384, -0.046140335500240326, 0.0065766675397753716, -0.04956745356321335, 0.01736770197749138, 0.024209439754486084, -0.08377097547054291, -0.026086529716849327, -0.018381081521511078, -0.002873427467420697, 0.02848055027425289, -0.004703802987933159, -0.02530798316001892, 0.04111015051603317, 0.005908068735152483, 0.07170845568180084, 0.007346766069531441, -0.023679722100496292, -0.010847778990864754, -0.051765382289886475, -0.01336376741528511, 0.015087121166288853, 0.023151518777012825, 0.024437369778752327, -0.0020244077313691378, -0.0455983467400074, 0.03436427190899849, -0.095652736723423, -0.03174498677253723, 0.05326838046312332, 0.0029995364602655172, 0.0021757646463811398, -0.026727085933089256, 0.012748632580041885, 0.05827631056308746, 0.01281512901186943, 0.000554264523088932, 0.10700918734073639, 0.027970314025878906, -0.04351324215531349, -0.017252588644623756, -0.011186881922185421, 0.022829674184322357, -0.06571882218122482, 0.01374563854187727, 0.02322366274893284, -0.01223819050937891, 0.04379432275891304, 0.005886549595743418, -0.024881556630134583, 0.033423494547605515, 0.004341375548392534, 0.029851095750927925, 0.016861233860254288, 0.05484284833073616, -0.025782538577914238, -0.09815388917922974, -0.005434473976492882, 0.0409182608127594, -0.057800695300102234, -0.04981932044029236, 0.0028121895156800747, -0.004565116483718157, -0.0639433041214943, 0.04964902624487877, -0.039522405713796616, -0.017747195437550545, 0.05735611170530319, -0.05205652117729187, -0.002649762434884906, -0.04040638729929924, -0.05807904899120331, -0.03341386094689369, 0.040946509689092636, 0.00781677383929491, -0.028636720031499863, -0.0067114862613379955, -0.05727021396160126, 0.013487845659255981, -0.008563444949686527, 0.09180149435997009, 0.04445856809616089, -0.011373751796782017, -0.029124680906534195, 0.0018171933479607105, 0.002838512184098363, 0.007576989475637674, 0.001851698849350214, 0.004400625359266996, -0.00873366929590702, -0.014305813238024712, -0.041705723851919174, 0.018199525773525238, -0.03271537274122238, -0.007600802928209305, -0.044727589935064316, -0.014817237854003906, 0.08320099115371704, 0.0006683986284770072, 0.044127825647592545, -0.07448797672986984, -0.007455562241375446, 0.012372421100735664, -0.04029948264360428, -0.023718733340501785, 0.02172105200588703, 0.004888209514319897, -0.031113142147660255, -0.05542650446295738, 0.02099226601421833, 0.01973007433116436, -0.0003429372445680201, 0.0014546854654327035, -0.027218447998166084, 0.016679879277944565, -0.0019793990068137646, 0.030320366844534874, -0.08949108421802521, 0.024015886709094048, 0.03558900207281113, -0.03214077278971672, 0.018607117235660553, 0.05384191870689392, 0.0003379960253369063, -0.03264737129211426, -0.01186252012848854, -0.0018002273282036185, 0.03495661914348602, 0.003159505082294345, 0.013890717178583145, 0.020931070670485497, -0.001947631360962987, 0.019877590239048004, -0.07147424668073654, -0.03418079763650894, 0.015627732500433922, 0.014430959708988667, 0.009290197864174843, 0.016434339806437492, -0.025411535054445267, -0.04289793223142624, -0.038487646728754044, -0.05404970794916153, 0.038399409502744675, -0.04255427420139313, 0.00886202696710825, -0.029846427962183952, 0.0615934282541275, 0.030070092529058456, -0.0395391471683979, 0.05298266559839249, 0.003968074917793274, 0.04997337982058525, -0.042697012424468994, -0.024001361802220345, 0.0036911480128765106, -0.008278083056211472, -0.04478058964014053, -0.0036979918368160725, -0.01157444342970848, 0.013976897113025188, 0.007786078378558159, -0.011847204528748989, 0.049487076699733734, -0.0009201614884659648, -0.014903124421834946, -0.025445859879255295, 0.02881855145096779, 0.05293501541018486, -0.04443519562482834, -0.0015534231206402183, -0.06183108687400818, 0.05575969070196152, -0.0054357475601136684, 0.0019512017024680972, -0.006179417483508587, -0.04668643698096275, 0.06578999757766724, -0.007852687500417233, 0.010287681594491005, -0.0030487566255033016, 0.08799343556165695, -0.021077413111925125, 0.016451362520456314, 0.021125521510839462, -0.013230661861598492, 0.013559415005147457, 0.03152264282107353, -0.01154913567006588, -0.04498036950826645, 0.028849614784121513, -0.056082796305418015, -0.005477574188262224, -0.0384664349257946, 0.006056356709450483, -0.016966577619314194, -0.028938569128513336, 0.032166238874197006, -0.07018230855464935, 0.030263304710388184, -0.0265598613768816, 0.010814430192112923, 0.0233871228992939, -0.028179733082652092, 0.00955373514443636, -0.029932038858532906, -0.0006515667773783207, -0.028767863288521767, -0.012361148372292519, -0.01567753404378891, -0.008539206348359585, -0.011905920691788197, -0.004018360283225775, 0.0015138433082029223, -0.03448426350951195, 0.02334689162671566, 0.03540387749671936, 0.029830699786543846, -0.0030543357133865356, 0.037859510630369186, 0.09149355441331863, -0.0022017876617610455, 0.00779653899371624, -0.011060844175517559, -0.026817526668310165, 0.007054019253700972, 0.02453661523759365, -0.022587299346923828, -0.040524922311306, 0.0025892953854054213, 0.02408151887357235, 0.01581011898815632, 0.011700560338795185, 0.02018757350742817, -0.02757459506392479, 0.03400317206978798, 0.021516947075724602, 0.06457176804542542, -0.004466388840228319, -0.014148187823593616, -0.054969243705272675, -0.020532889291644096, -0.052603673189878464, -0.016232842579483986, -0.029476149007678032, 0.023021679371595383, 0.004426272120326757, 0.04112282022833824, 0.009311161935329437, 0.03508830815553665, 0.003405326744541526, 0.04698476567864418, 0.0038620822597295046, 0.04914744198322296, 0.010379803366959095, 0.0295586958527565, -0.005625951569527388, -0.0013991586165502667, 0.04640468209981918, 0.004071510396897793, -0.033322062343358994, -0.07626118510961533, 0.0856032520532608, 0.00809007789939642, 0.00038151253829710186, 0.002909179776906967, 0.025165319442749023, 0.0030785021372139454, -0.004812024533748627, -0.009277031756937504, -0.05753663182258606, 0.055763497948646545, 0.0011037344811484218, -0.11113309860229492, -0.0019834607373923063, 0.0013234269572421908, -0.012949857860803604, -0.02844962477684021, -0.01638120785355568, -0.032893046736717224, -0.05103861913084984, -0.006010561715811491, -0.07718993723392487, -0.020202869549393654, 0.04255836829543114, 0.07848810404539108, -0.025704992935061455, 0.002784430282190442, -0.01142741646617651, -0.04822155088186264, 0.01859007030725479, 0.010792909190058708, -0.04572565108537674, 0.03801964223384857, -0.01127514336258173, 0.026870593428611755, 0.0062034884467720985, 0.015297895297408104, 0.03370596468448639, -0.04596205800771713, 0.014810550957918167, 0.027023904025554657, 0.05244483798742294, -0.021960537880659103, -0.027241522446274757, 0.02696893736720085, 0.03679932653903961, 0.008610282093286514, -0.015629082918167114, -0.01316739059984684, 0.05577212944626808, -0.010452689602971077, 0.010047443211078644, 0.006301169749349356, 0.0073679909110069275, 0.023730603978037834, 0.014960071071982384, 0.05830857902765274, -0.06039971113204956, -0.017500774934887886, -0.01958838850259781, -0.032077331095933914, 0.007497910410165787, -0.007216195110231638, 0.06017663702368736, -0.03755353018641472, -0.02613426186144352, 0.010300183668732643, -0.0452868677675724, -0.05939759686589241, 0.08691821992397308, 0.005681751761585474, 0.006985609419643879, 0.00907205417752266, -0.0064416686072945595, 0.02188916876912117, -0.009245001710951328, -0.017668187618255615, 0.018484877422451973, 0.020719971507787704, -0.05763792246580124, 0.08360214531421661, 0.022018836811184883, 0.0025994807947427034, 0.10998363047838211, -0.04347426816821098, -0.01598012074828148, 0.017945846542716026, -0.03016829490661621, -0.004784793592989445, -0.008123558945953846, 0.0013179094530642033, -0.07518192380666733, 0.006654130760580301, 0.0025692263152450323, 0.03686396777629852, 0.006176578346639872, 0.014028333127498627, -0.012683894485235214, 0.028125030919909477, -0.02919100783765316, -0.043885767459869385, 0.030823685228824615, 0.0021698300261050463, 0.021271588280797005, -0.04405609518289566, 0.004044797271490097, -0.030630938708782196, -0.07430816441774368, 0.032965656369924545, 0.051825009286403656, 0.018943367525935173, 0.018150096759200096, -0.006114610470831394, -0.004311804194003344, 0.03421331197023392, -0.01733785681426525, 0.06356924772262573, -0.0017103985883295536, 0.04574822634458542, 0.02679397352039814, 0.029439087957143784, 0.0462191179394722, 0.0226628165692091, -0.021635476499795914, 0.07564146816730499, -0.05878118425607681, 0.008001391775906086, 0.06178749352693558, -0.03317447751760483, -0.06512056291103363, -0.006995381787419319, -0.03758011758327484, -0.021390942856669426, -0.024325000122189522, -0.018760090693831444, -0.014689687639474869, -0.010363160632550716, 0.010214687325060368, -0.03422260284423828, 0.055480100214481354, 0.0016483322251588106, -0.02280493453145027, -0.03200934827327728, 0.00929263699799776, -0.04871702194213867, 0.025986801832914352, 0.04978606849908829, 0.0012331657344475389, -0.030517028644680977, 0.021880287677049637, -0.04837200790643692, 0.009221158921718597, 0.0014289617538452148, -0.026349928230047226, 0.021893801167607307, -0.0005482410197146237, 0.003798536490648985, 0.04172488674521446, -0.014835147187113762, 0.014370318502187729, -0.018793225288391113, -0.023160597309470177, -0.024950288236141205, -0.05643939971923828, 0.00032301241299137473, 0.03676394000649452, 0.03562357276678085, -0.01712694950401783, 0.05069399252533913, -0.025783579796552658, 0.01118642557412386, -0.018934758380055428, 0.05690906569361687, -0.020497584715485573, -0.009625166654586792, -0.003023129189386964, -0.014436480589210987, 0.01554703339934349, 0.02359793148934841, 0.015383034013211727, 0.016968026757240295, 0.002479637274518609, 0.020912624895572662, 0.04332193359732628, 0.045057736337184906, -0.023090144619345665, 0.022127047181129456, -0.059995368123054504, -0.06172260269522667, 0.008616961538791656, 0.059643905609846115, 0.053149037063121796, 0.054368678480386734, -0.004608833231031895, 0.012293480336666107, 0.030495580285787582, 0.016625873744487762, -0.002867277478799224, 0.017174402251839638, 0.0450386181473732, -0.0042035747319459915, -0.015134517103433609, -0.04883446916937828, 0.005541697144508362, -0.11179102212190628, -0.037082310765981674, -0.014058321714401245, 0.004458401817828417, 0.0032774086575955153, -0.007503673434257507, -0.02356823906302452, -0.05261624604463577, -0.07535286992788315, 0.008007870055735111, 0.03449980542063713, -0.00916437990963459, -0.002285416005179286, -0.017355551943182945, -0.0196902547031641, -0.0630413293838501, 0.02481842413544655, -0.045824937522411346, -0.1150474101305008, -0.017606012523174286, -0.029085690155625343, 0.03066316246986389, -0.0009777455125004053, 0.01921946555376053, 0.05119861289858818, 0.044170577079057693, -0.02808726765215397, 0.06708137691020966, -0.015364778228104115, -0.009019708260893822, 0.02865779772400856, -0.013171403668820858, -0.04257100820541382, -0.028164513409137726, -0.014757578261196613, -0.03551026061177254, 0.018160758540034294, -0.049780476838350296, -0.012432670220732689, -0.02085636928677559, -0.03476570174098015, 0.061893098056316376, -0.008591597899794579, -0.0064856382086873055, -0.02015731856226921 ]
<p>Suppose I have an atom at rest which is at energy level $E_i$. Would it be possible to raise it to the next higher level $E_{i+1}$ by shooting a photon of energy $E_{i+1}-E_i$ at it?</p> <p>I ask because the photon will impart some momentum to the atom, so the atom will end up with some kinetic energy after the absorption, and clearly this kinetic energy must come out of the photon's energy budget. So if the energy levels $E_i$ and $E_{i+1}$ do not already account for this kinetic energy [and I don't see how they could], I would need to use a photon of energy slightly higher than $E_{i+1}-E_i$. </p> <p>Conversely, if the atom is at rest at energy level $E_{i+1}$, and it emits a photon to fall back to energy level $E_i$, I assume that the emitted photon will have energy slightly lower than $E_{i+1}-E_i$, to account for the kinetic energy of the atom after the emission. Is that correct?</p> <p>I was led to this question while thinking about the energy balance in laser cooling.</p>
g130
[ 0.013709881342947483, -0.0022627057041972876, 0.008827985264360905, 0.03994840383529663, -0.004994762130081654, 0.01742677576839924, 0.013927577994763851, 0.045987557619810104, -0.03260587900876999, 0.04394591972231865, -0.010569138452410698, 0.040421850979328156, 0.011397300288081169, -0.04364882409572601, -0.01530187577009201, 0.03021099790930748, 0.14467491209506989, -0.01626690663397312, 0.05215401202440262, 0.08519347012042999, -0.07607366889715195, 0.01990584097802639, -0.008136043325066566, -0.06369224190711975, -0.01683850586414337, 0.035620689392089844, 0.003787675406783819, 0.02640531398355961, -0.07652317732572556, -0.0018866370664909482, -0.012232760898768902, -0.014976192265748978, 0.04618775099515915, 0.03702324256300926, 0.0031214996706694365, 0.010135339573025703, 0.07263548672199249, 0.03579676151275635, 0.01668546348810196, -0.00815147440880537, 0.003434699261561036, -0.011776210740208626, 0.04170377925038338, 0.019921986386179924, 0.015016278252005577, -0.0028685778379440308, 0.0026534658391028643, 0.010850101709365845, 0.008720585145056248, -0.025142408907413483, 0.01660625822842121, 0.026648059487342834, -0.05576604604721069, 0.02829708717763424, 0.022781813517212868, 0.02740103006362915, -0.05099392309784889, -0.03820383548736572, 0.013669691979885101, 0.019700154662132263, 0.04522733762860298, -0.021926159039139748, 0.026622718200087547, -0.040713150054216385, 0.029117150232195854, -0.027666449546813965, -0.043397367000579834, 0.007726668380200863, -0.04531838372349739, -0.03214763477444649, -0.02271798998117447, 0.005625254940241575, -0.06573620438575745, -0.024156397208571434, 0.013034994713962078, -0.02960265800356865, 0.017340146005153656, -0.031694862991571426, -0.005482449196279049, 0.01692357286810875, -0.044869497418403625, 0.03342055529356003, 0.058491870760917664, -0.04178031533956528, -0.007683369796723127, 0.05462364852428436, -0.03959518298506737, 0.029011469334363937, -0.012202008627355099, 0.07475190609693527, 0.04263335466384888, 0.029218057170510292, 0.10944578051567078, -0.024635137990117073, 0.039110761135816574, -0.022551674395799637, 0.0037468615919351578, 0.05514813959598541, -0.019705386832356453, -0.017505275085568428, -0.027688603848218918, -0.02577071078121662, 0.0070163793861866, -0.0021212201099842787, -0.04327160492539406, 0.019095290452241898, 0.007505075540393591, -0.05906379967927933, -0.02427520789206028, 0.017871994525194168, 0.00966721773147583, -0.0907040685415268, -0.061317577958106995, -0.018073780462145805, -0.0776498094201088, 0.011776627041399479, 0.04926760867238045, 0.0024641123600304127, 0.003292505396530032, 0.044368065893650055, 0.018747778609395027, 0.03546951711177826, -0.0006764166755601764, 0.012619948014616966, 0.047868262976408005, 0.006481774616986513, -0.026941150426864624, -0.019924232736229897, -0.011516936123371124, 0.0023930405732244253, 0.0028638849034905434, 0.010438423603773117, -0.003745107911527157, 0.003968107048422098, -0.0021735273767262697, 0.01168700959533453, -0.0029868539422750473, 0.03361890837550163, 0.010763261467218399, -0.030559763312339783, 0.04700576514005661, -0.0306878499686718, 0.02308986708521843, -0.04683082923293114, -0.030349526554346085, 0.060039814561605453, -0.02829154022037983, 0.03613624721765518, 0.03198343142867088, 0.05137660726904869, 0.003404883434996009, -0.00944377388805151, 0.04612532630562782, -0.09323666989803314, 0.051290299743413925, -0.03724275529384613, -0.003894603345543146, -0.012728954665362835, -0.022416947409510612, 0.02267545275390148, 0.039311397820711136, -0.007073123008012772, 0.039970703423023224, -0.010402070358395576, -0.008422980085015297, 0.010567910969257355, -0.006753640249371529, -0.026773672550916672, -0.05095160752534866, -0.04649002104997635, -0.005123676732182503, -0.022689606994390488, 0.015178884379565716, -0.053688425570726395, -0.03051440231502056, 0.03760155662894249, 0.05279725044965744, -0.049555741250514984, -0.03016778826713562, -0.037038128823041916, -0.009886935353279114, 0.01486288197338581, 0.029851596802473068, -0.015224583446979523, 0.02578100748360157, -0.04491501674056053, -0.019645560532808304, -0.009592843241989613, -0.020949874073266983, -0.013389958068728447, 0.0006353069329634309, 0.006340695079416037, 0.010983048006892204, -0.008685626089572906, -0.03525539115071297, -0.04453307017683983, -0.01337800920009613, -0.08339904248714447, -0.033676523715257645, 0.06804871559143066, -0.02093547396361828, 0.015212317928671837, -0.04793247953057289, -0.05651644244790077, 0.036219943314790726, -0.0036878783721476793, -0.012882567942142487, 0.001601578900590539, -0.004934925585985184, -0.028168411925435066, 0.005252758506685495, 0.002279636450111866, 0.008643902838230133, 0.016779769212007523, 0.012387892231345177, 0.05019471049308777, -0.002789344172924757, -0.015744341537356377, -0.019045032560825348, -0.04632983356714249, -0.07246176153421402, -0.0005913134082220495, 0.0020185948815196753, -0.014814376831054688, -0.020709475502371788, -0.023807266727089882, -0.06419691443443298, 0.01992703042924404, -0.03538674861192703, 0.05260532721877098, -0.0838390588760376, 0.08423899859189987, -0.03428969904780388, -0.026868658140301704, 0.07763296365737915, 0.04499378800392151, -0.01769649051129818, -0.006976771634072065, 0.03660649433732033, -0.014283640310168266, -0.020122220739722252, -0.05999729409813881, -0.02133929170668125, -0.009833420626819134, -0.02164842002093792, -0.02573392540216446, -0.021169481799006462, -0.003047358710318804, -0.07269232720136642, -0.029224496334791183, 0.041409239172935486, -0.07981129735708237, -0.017967596650123596, -0.023613283410668373, -0.030729442834854126, -0.056080836802721024, -0.02770732343196869, 0.047939613461494446, -0.05334216728806496, -0.016259897500276566, 0.032994166016578674, -0.06015623360872269, -0.03535649925470352, 0.007551493123173714, 0.013937212526798248, 0.02461753971874714, -0.008778377436101437, -0.03606892004609108, 0.01597721502184868, 0.0019829259254038334, -0.004715383518487215, 0.07829210162162781, 0.008062132634222507, 0.05271521583199501, -0.01049330085515976, -0.0273373331874609, 0.014356757514178753, -0.02036542259156704, 0.02628336288034916, -0.04240155592560768, -0.0207977257668972, -0.007876310497522354, -0.08066128939390182, -0.0019482496427372098, 0.011816205456852913, -0.08204431086778641, -0.011062616482377052, 0.004924948792904615, 0.007772787474095821, -0.03307501599192619, -0.029644565656781197, 0.007509398739784956, 0.02040790766477585, 0.05047395080327988, -0.0011068800231441855, 0.015644675120711327, 0.03941399231553078, -0.0370321199297905, -0.04004238545894623, 0.09757933020591736, 0.00866627972573042, -0.07291200757026672, -0.01936349831521511, -0.032307740300893784, 0.02332242764532566, 0.029976552352309227, -0.037883177399635315, -0.017677705734968185, -0.018896382302045822, 0.015055411495268345, -0.033520642668008804, 0.062152791768312454, -0.02654891461133957, 0.04820313677191734, -0.04032931476831436, -0.034362468868494034, -0.02307783253490925, -0.03913978114724159, -0.0013576059136539698, -0.0008986114407889545, 0.021994607523083687, 0.022673068568110466, 0.0029541929252445698, 0.036240048706531525, 0.026987280696630478, 0.002721506869420409, -0.013908560387790203, -0.021013056859374046, -0.0394100621342659, 0.022575754672288895, 0.04459095746278763, 0.0005581978475674987, -0.0218022633343935, 0.049564044922590256, 0.05109052360057831, 0.01566675677895546, 0.00304747698828578, 0.010274272412061691, 0.051795486360788345, 0.024048641324043274, -0.01475303340703249, 0.04731282219290733, 0.013465018942952156, -0.015853092074394226, 0.008979911915957928, 0.018998034298419952, -0.05444375425577164, -0.016046782955527306, -0.0271370280534029, -0.04448043927550316, 0.05005519092082977, 0.012439175508916378, -0.03606223315000534, 0.004829471465200186, -0.046055715531110764, 0.012120424769818783, 0.030336659401655197, 0.05137292295694351, 0.006780312862247229, 0.015055662952363491, 0.015037615783512592, 0.018645578995347023, 0.08178465068340302, -0.05566828325390816, -0.05146051570773125, -0.00776950316503644, -0.05001353099942207, -0.020412370562553406, 0.030643267557024956, 0.0293179452419281, 0.011136948131024837, -0.019245214760303497, -0.028272632509469986, -0.010091949254274368, -0.025082817301154137, -0.014413641765713692, 0.1114468201994896, 0.001092484686523676, -0.05304345116019249, -0.010689398273825645, -0.031060263514518738, -0.02015788108110428, -0.007857345044612885, 0.011249511502683163, 0.02391406148672104, 0.03688037395477295, -0.043440282344818115, 0.006601413711905479, 0.008500591851770878, 0.004152271896600723, -0.018411340191960335, -0.07349546253681183, -0.055112991482019424, 0.043953604996204376, 0.0031013726256787777, 0.019863564521074295, 0.012365260161459446, -0.06828898936510086, 0.01120789721608162, 0.04604359716176987, 0.03900972008705139, 0.03439183533191681, 0.028006218373775482, -0.0014796726172789931, 0.00877051055431366, -0.021847989410161972, 0.03893064334988594, 0.014873062260448933, -0.03413597494363785, -0.01527494378387928, -0.000040644416003488004, -0.04461454227566719, -0.012468714267015457, -0.03464549407362938, -0.01772957481443882, -0.0051994784735143185, -0.0037895774003118277, 0.00855385884642601, 0.01559376809746027, 0.027762429788708687, -0.004010982811450958, -0.023375144228339195, 0.03825085237622261, 0.005456698127090931, 0.022752150893211365, 0.10591687262058258, 0.06964743882417679, -0.003992965444922447, -0.006038207095116377, -0.043087270110845566, 0.0013246778398752213, 0.007792260032147169, 0.032007668167352676, -0.006600325461477041, 0.004003313835710287, 0.03347255289554596, 0.026867659762501717, 0.029444394633173943, 0.01737917587161064, 0.008314390666782856, 0.08315674215555191, -0.009169332683086395, -0.0036323692183941603, 0.01266952883452177, 0.009029277600347996, 0.04640898108482361, -0.051155608147382736, -0.05037117004394531, -0.0068910750560462475, -0.018873464316129684, 0.0004689418710768223, -0.0006715112249366939, -0.020433343946933746, 0.019438035786151886, -0.02473762445151806, -0.03829414024949074, -0.06160978600382805, 0.038540054112672806, 0.002200438641011715, 0.06711377203464508, 0.002606746042147279, 0.012093591503798962, 0.0631570965051651, -0.06175532191991806, 0.029402896761894226, -0.0174874197691679, 0.0012866173638030887, 0.03808045759797096, -0.04286307096481323, 0.016431303694844246, 0.054513126611709595, 0.014709977433085442, 0.0007137239445000887, 0.03890678659081459, 0.0012906681513413787, -0.07206892222166061, 0.007212978787720203, -0.013850617222487926, 0.018712492659687996, -0.00956004112958908, 0.010458219796419144, 0.004245883785188198, -0.036255985498428345, 0.02962135523557663, -0.0287015363574028, -0.03877468779683113, -0.05168985575437546, 0.011165307834744453, 0.03542034327983856, -0.004993812646716833, 0.003461388638243079, 0.037775807082653046, -0.008467914536595345, 0.03365921601653099, -0.009797030128538609, 0.052163708955049515, 0.016863802447915077, -0.013434789143502712, 0.026450056582689285, 0.052428971976041794, -0.05178150162100792, 0.016902906820178032, -0.013778949156403542, -0.04160963371396065, 0.015639180317521095, -0.05268406122922897, 0.008759057149291039, 0.027382414788007736, -0.03999893739819527, -0.01353788748383522, -0.0418439619243145, -0.006226808298379183, -0.02199792116880417, 0.039686355739831924, 0.02738676778972149, -0.034988485276699066, 0.036644745618104935, 0.025440355762839317, -0.011506699956953526, 0.007437527179718018, 0.029687663540244102, 0.012699936516582966, 0.027857137843966484, -0.013583946973085403, -0.00861156266182661, 0.039617665112018585, -0.04778441786766052, 0.01745321974158287, -0.03471621125936508, 0.04157775267958641, 0.03929196670651436, 0.02195729687809944, -0.009003880433738232, 0.0105351647362113, 0.038094986230134964, 0.04313543438911438, -0.0620122030377388, 0.025493832305073738, -0.06119394302368164, 0.07246354222297668, 0.028775356709957123, -0.015214160084724426, 0.04704982787370682, 0.05975352227687836, 0.02086270973086357, -0.04033645614981651, -0.0398668497800827, 0.03859331086277962, 0.028619034215807915, -0.08319102972745895, 0.04165276512503624, 0.009826809167861938, 0.017794007435441017, -0.036459021270275116, -0.018259556964039803, -0.013416765257716179, 0.012140773236751556, 0.028100550174713135, 0.02077549509704113, -0.05475950986146927, -0.006714047398418188, 0.026671918109059334, 0.06657767295837402, 0.057600054889917374, 0.027436180040240288, 0.005516564939171076, -0.036771539598703384, -0.04936588183045387, 0.05326028913259506, -0.01006639190018177, 0.031124519184231758, 0.012006746605038643, -0.04926292225718498, 0.009114844724535942, 0.02526661939918995, 0.019102688878774643, -0.038912683725357056, 0.015185601077973843, -0.029923081398010254, -0.004222068935632706, -0.025080174207687378, 0.01227639988064766, -0.008361250162124634, -0.005565731320530176, -0.009124690666794777, -0.020293373614549637, -0.08616361767053604, 0.012799862772226334, 0.033902134746313095, 0.00020864566613454372, -0.051054809242486954, -0.04749011993408203, -0.018160955980420113, 0.03340310603380203, -0.022509796544909477, 0.0038920387160032988, -0.009228594601154327, -0.04289824515581131, -0.03394094482064247, 0.07185343652963638, 0.06673652678728104, -0.05032207816839218, 0.023259898647665977, -0.0264313705265522, -0.03753429651260376, 0.06660836935043335, -0.01144945714622736, 0.05501062050461769, -0.00438464293256402, 0.023605532944202423, -0.010832402855157852, -0.018543828278779984, 0.050510987639427185, -0.00930683221668005, -0.04192976653575897, -0.04380962625145912, 0.01764034293591976, 0.020122632384300232, -0.018491890281438828, -0.00996566191315651, 0.00669604679569602, -0.06463802605867386, 0.03759605810046196, -0.03016752190887928, 0.04290201514959335, 0.030067332088947296, -0.01207579206675291, 0.07551807910203934, 0.04943365231156349, 0.06730718165636063, -0.016843123361468315, 0.029567493125796318, -0.0366341732442379, 0.06450530141592026, 0.017273185774683952, 0.039724938571453094, -0.014053312130272388, 0.01734147034585476, -0.0006204905221238732, 0.03280739113688469, -0.021046731621026993, 0.012691948562860489, 0.04486909881234169, 0.03645671531558037, -0.03329117223620415, 0.02789359726011753, 0.007895714603364468, 0.024997960776090622, -0.054163191467523575, 0.04686857387423515, -0.03243296220898628, -0.016461975872516632, -0.08543550968170166, 0.00739400926977396, -0.026271071285009384, 0.01569214276969433, -0.05336018279194832, 0.009470973163843155, 0.010044574737548828, -0.051987748593091965, 0.055458955466747284, -0.04304806888103485, 0.036644916981458664, -0.001531486283056438, -0.026095621287822723, 0.037097275257110596, 0.018588194623589516, -0.0249085184186697, -0.019492080435156822, -0.027166176587343216, -0.0014170585200190544, -0.10467352718114853, -0.0457661896944046, -0.02104618214070797, -0.01935715042054653, 0.05733517184853554, -0.021997831761837006, 0.06986955553293228, -0.017305070534348488, -0.02924215979874134, -0.05165676400065422, 0.02163466066122055, 0.024912863969802856, -0.05803902819752693, -0.03920362889766693, 0.10884319245815277, 0.02027381770312786, -0.0014323872746899724, 0.026774683967232704, -0.03018670156598091, -0.03786259517073631, 0.027159612625837326, 0.03695454075932503, 0.05754366144537926, -0.04625566303730011, 0.001213237177580595, 0.018884355202317238, -0.01708579622209072, -0.02425139583647251, -0.04137565195560455, 0.0034105267841368914, -0.01700710505247116, 0.04377647116780281, -0.0032198079861700535, -0.011022449471056461, 0.029497798532247543, 0.008128726854920387, -0.03311322256922722, 0.006272565107792616, -0.046021848917007446, -0.010252300649881363, -0.012868656776845455, 0.03150855749845505, 0.1110694408416748, -0.000060608992498600855, -0.05581273138523102, 0.014651617966592312, -0.0009492280660197139, -0.005609338637441397, 0.025009946897625923, -0.013619709759950638, -0.01633472554385662, -0.02203252539038658, -0.022008998319506645, 0.0323551781475544, 0.011697322130203247, 0.008508407510817051, -0.02750098891556263, -0.0027668543625622988, 0.000827703857794404, 0.02044490911066532, 0.0015552775003015995, -0.028917580842971802, -0.04567017778754234, 0.07899802923202515, -0.015594602562487125, -0.026014909148216248, -0.03633668273687363, 0.037699196487665176, 0.03055470623075962, -0.004601018503308296, -0.07514596730470657, 0.03978070989251137, 0.02947506681084633, 0.0023266468197107315, -0.07372808456420898, 0.0024445699527859688, 0.022550910711288452, 0.08409421145915985, -0.010284890420734882, -0.02023112215101719, 0.008298935368657112, -0.045757051557302475, 0.053873803466558456, 0.09420442581176758, -0.022199293598532677, 0.011789347976446152, -0.002973568858578801, -0.06443913280963898, -0.015736505389213562, -0.02607276849448681, -0.015813153237104416, -0.025943376123905182, -0.08397094905376434, 0.028526462614536285, -0.03350042924284935, 0.02428998053073883, -0.02834128774702549 ]
<p>The <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bekenstein_bound">Bekenstein bound</a> sets the maximum amount of information that can be contained in a region of space/energy, and is usually referred to in the same way as computer storage density:</p> <blockquote> <p>For example, a single hydrogen atom, if it were to code as much information as permitted by the Bekenstein Bound, would code about 4×10<sup>6</sup> bits of information, since the hydrogen atom is about one Ångström in radius, and has a mass of about 1.67×10<sup>−27</sup> kilograms. (<a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/astro-ph/0111520.pdf">source</a>)</p> </blockquote> <p>&nbsp;</p> <blockquote> <p>Nature permits a surprising amount of information to be encoded before the Bekenstein bound is reached. For example, a hydrogen atom can encode about 1 Mb of information — most of a floppy disk. (<a href="http://books.google.com/books?id=Kp6g79LuKWEC&amp;lpg=PA54&amp;ots=axR1DK3S8l&amp;dq=Bekenstein%20bound%20hydrogen%20atom&amp;pg=PA54#v=onepage&amp;q=Bekenstein%20bound%20hydrogen%20atom&amp;f=false">source</a>)</p> </blockquote> <p>&nbsp;</p> <blockquote> <p>The "Bekenstein bound" leaves room for a million bits in a hydrogen atom (<a href="http://books.google.com/books?id=fduW6KHhWtQC&amp;lpg=PA166&amp;ots=SvrByr246k&amp;dq=Bekenstein%20bound%20hydrogen%20atom&amp;pg=PA166#v=onepage&amp;q=Bekenstein%20bound%20hydrogen%20atom&amp;f=false">source</a>)</p> </blockquote> <p>But what does this really mean? How could <em>any</em> information be stored in a hydrogen atom?</p>
g4234
[ 0.03238378465175629, 0.08767668902873993, -0.011625469662249088, -0.01489349640905857, 0.004678057506680489, 0.03726322948932648, -0.039745621383190155, 0.013425490818917751, -0.09073362499475479, -0.026248175650835037, 0.012240258045494556, -0.009185525588691235, 0.02437591552734375, -0.048323869705200195, 0.04556223750114441, 0.005916064139455557, -0.001552992849610746, -0.020766960456967354, 0.03773386403918266, 0.03554132208228111, -0.03844740614295006, 0.05625522881746292, -0.026224393397569656, -0.03687005490064621, -0.08851413428783417, 0.022190889343619347, 0.051684096455574036, -0.043982408940792084, -0.06800975650548935, -0.006299806758761406, -0.017141612246632576, -0.049820832908153534, -0.009801761247217655, -0.028936656191945076, -0.053468283265829086, -0.08074492961168289, -0.017258450388908386, -0.014783219434320927, 0.0361548513174057, -0.003868037136271596, 0.017740949988365173, -0.05894250422716141, -0.012212434783577919, -0.03056345507502556, -0.021800469607114792, 0.06029779836535454, 0.015233510173857212, -0.028255881741642952, 0.032346077263355255, -0.046254962682724, -0.036089733242988586, 0.046390704810619354, 0.008647684007883072, 0.03564024716615677, 0.02663367986679077, -0.0004085124528501183, -0.007912248373031616, -0.0021683676168322563, 0.07786190509796143, -0.02876346930861473, 0.02166081964969635, 0.009089088998734951, -0.031864941120147705, -0.017255989834666252, 0.05062225088477135, 0.013775142841041088, -0.0907650962471962, 0.023145586252212524, 0.013987806625664234, -0.03557123616337776, 0.04815303161740303, 0.009528759866952896, -0.03253820538520813, -0.054614387452602386, -0.0031644515693187714, 0.021853404119610786, 0.019094286486506462, 0.04393012076616287, 0.03201109915971756, 0.08007464557886124, -0.03837397322058678, -0.07794591784477234, -0.036607928574085236, -0.03387264907360077, 0.059946898370981216, 0.009341323748230934, -0.03018326684832573, -0.03859065845608711, 0.0010811294196173549, 0.0855904072523117, -0.018468592315912247, -0.007498414721339941, 0.04991587623953819, -0.022113705053925514, 0.040467098355293274, 0.07152294367551804, 0.004376369062811136, 0.025541318580508232, -0.007827089168131351, -0.012058199383318424, 0.01494511403143406, 0.0052023581229150295, 0.021882986649870872, 0.008773858658969402, -0.030137235298752785, 0.02532518096268177, 0.0020380159839987755, -0.03915390372276306, -0.007803381886333227, -0.009335748851299286, 0.020226171240210533, -0.019278135150671005, -0.030179224908351898, 0.02420078031718731, -0.061788734048604965, 0.022984996438026428, 0.0661187544465065, 0.017859814688563347, -0.049302347004413605, -0.010696401819586754, -0.05238362401723862, 0.01919657364487648, 0.029193779453635216, 0.050683073699474335, -0.019086536020040512, 0.001848523155786097, 0.019360296428203583, 0.012703988701105118, 0.010651357471942902, -0.033342599868774414, 0.01442315336316824, 0.013895348645746708, -0.03598138689994812, 0.02507147565484047, -0.026614679023623466, -0.028825659304857254, -0.04575342312455177, 0.04115170240402222, 0.032058946788311005, -0.02019006572663784, -0.03696350008249283, 0.004629888106137514, -0.021704809740185738, -0.05958690494298935, -0.010313642211258411, -0.05207894742488861, -0.022484032437205315, 0.028392145410180092, -0.050644855946302414, -0.013317028991878033, -0.015789087861776352, 0.000879329105373472, 0.0007042275392450392, -0.03662041947245598, 0.03574342653155327, -0.005505915265530348, 0.0973988026380539, 0.05338014289736748, -0.006566524505615234, 0.10445040464401245, 0.05857483297586441, 0.06177101284265518, -0.005051393993198872, 0.03631513938307762, -0.050837960094213486, 0.016919057816267014, 0.044335611164569855, -0.04880920797586441, -0.023991622030735016, -0.05539122596383095, -0.00559699023142457, 0.012943879701197147, -0.041870471090078354, 0.028083311393857002, -0.07701712101697922, 0.03367331996560097, 0.06870485097169876, -0.06383716315031052, 0.04896813631057739, 0.04456532746553421, -0.02095608413219452, 0.031397975981235504, 0.039259932935237885, -0.027425792068243027, -0.02256246656179428, -0.01006491482257843, -0.0025973208248615265, -0.04477112740278244, -0.04396195337176323, -0.009158843196928501, -0.04817632585763931, 0.024455364793539047, 0.043993789702653885, -0.0028610171284526587, 0.00634580897167325, -0.030458658933639526, 0.006018651183694601, -0.04872111603617668, -0.006084136199206114, 0.00561903789639473, 0.0009961804607883096, 0.0008073599310591817, -0.0046338955871760845, 0.018636735156178474, 0.06810637563467026, 0.006997926160693169, 0.03384636342525482, 0.03364768251776695, 0.04603421688079834, 0.008089975453913212, 0.04772108420729637, -0.020730486139655113, 0.029962580651044846, 0.08217942714691162, 0.0912918820977211, -0.05029115080833435, -0.023595614358782768, -0.013053692877292633, -0.031245728954672813, -0.002817201428115368, 0.03464138135313988, -0.023289678618311882, 0.05288108065724373, -0.010023066774010658, -0.004796098917722702, 0.021502787247300148, 0.04335067793726921, -0.030744485557079315, -0.04327864572405815, 0.04241330176591873, -0.06648295372724533, 0.02432623691856861, -0.007147680036723614, 0.03209727630019188, -0.04559418559074402, 0.09243441373109818, -0.0212016049772501, 0.002590467222034931, 0.010123910382390022, -0.008238944225013256, -0.0006877703126519918, 0.0003667987766675651, -0.050150200724601746, 0.024413401260972023, -0.013607515953481197, -0.039638012647628784, 0.03681403025984764, -0.03383681923151016, -0.011966228485107422, 0.04039103537797928, -0.005520225968211889, -0.033038463443517685, 0.009744860231876373, 0.028853051364421844, 0.012131167575716972, -0.017141705378890038, -0.046402428299188614, -0.005489052273333073, -0.03152436763048172, -0.006565184332430363, 0.01996183767914772, -0.012544953264296055, 0.07179819047451019, -0.032819442451000214, -0.004223508294671774, -0.01802142709493637, -0.08749466389417648, 0.007907716557383537, 0.03777984529733658, 0.0383424386382103, -0.009281742386519909, 0.054053593426942825, 0.030437622219324112, 0.015281064435839653, -0.028021272271871567, 0.00024618589668534696, -0.018891816958785057, -0.009660130366683006, 0.05388736352324486, -0.048509471118450165, -0.04515459015965462, 0.043320104479789734, -0.0829835832118988, -0.014219471253454685, -0.010928834788501263, -0.003116981592029333, -0.030758654698729515, 0.03051108680665493, -0.018285058438777924, -0.033795714378356934, -0.007486564572900534, 0.03131131827831268, 0.014894058927893639, -0.003101445734500885, 0.001271441695280373, 0.027824679389595985, -0.015126769430935383, 0.005533271934837103, -0.029578829184174538, 0.03049459680914879, -0.040175311267375946, -0.012659077532589436, 0.02909131348133087, 0.04275445267558098, -0.030123841017484665, 0.005113780498504639, -0.06440889090299606, -0.029781263321638107, -0.026402559131383896, -0.015668543055653572, 0.004569637589156628, -0.016347503289580345, -0.01174335740506649, -0.023179227486252785, -0.03644395247101784, -0.04019654169678688, 0.008503025397658348, -0.02274836227297783, 0.012838061898946762, -0.029321957379579544, 0.018166521564126015, 0.010771652683615685, 0.015949895605444908, 0.004567461088299751, 0.02870495617389679, 0.013796813786029816, -0.09286472946405411, -0.051122479140758514, -0.03150482475757599, -0.019493654370307922, -0.0023597413673996925, -0.030700204893946648, 0.00804954208433628, 0.0007565501146018505, -0.07726253569126129, -0.08660616725683212, -0.02293701097369194, 0.020379267632961273, -0.027651101350784302, -0.04466630518436432, -0.0009338904055766761, -0.06455706059932709, -0.003564117942005396, 0.0135962450876832, 0.03637475520372391, 0.043807853013277054, -0.02830401621758938, -0.005178192164748907, -0.0005006068386137486, 0.02487778849899769, 0.01080769021064043, 0.01813093014061451, 0.01864207349717617, -0.004748818464577198, -0.002580249449238181, 0.0789158046245575, -0.017077861353754997, -0.027377985417842865, 0.01566348597407341, 0.0012726300628855824, 0.02219177968800068, -0.04227078706026077, 0.0442483127117157, -0.023329731076955795, -0.02509044110774994, 0.0000900227387319319, -0.034095704555511475, -0.008706441149115562, 0.022149330005049706, -0.0010678087128326297, 0.004623077809810638, -0.06432756036520004, 0.07581672072410583, 0.011554601602256298, 0.07470306754112244, -0.08940307796001434, -0.003856241935864091, 0.027602268382906914, 0.026123367249965668, 0.06492383778095245, 0.017423488199710846, 0.0047136456705629826, 0.04682347550988197, -0.07104302197694778, -0.0026319450698792934, -0.05821065977215767, 0.01493452675640583, 0.010756273753941059, 0.002940137404948473, -0.006092357449233532, -0.0007760823355056345, -0.05947485193610191, 0.019718274474143982, 0.02711636573076248, 0.012036019004881382, -0.01758989319205284, -0.017008518800139427, 0.041316188871860504, 0.008830100297927856, 0.05569755285978317, 0.0017741058254614472, 0.025338348001241684, -0.0409359447658062, -0.016891121864318848, 0.03160335123538971, 0.020645972341299057, -0.015256686136126518, -0.011751562356948853, -0.01703205332159996, -0.033006321638822556, 0.065791055560112, -0.0004887563409283757, -0.04718261584639549, -0.027424953877925873, 0.0106726735830307, 0.0023877741768956184, -0.016237135976552963, -0.040191568434238434, -0.016553454101085663, 0.005228754598647356, -0.031139526516199112, 0.04705958440899849, -0.02912512980401516, -0.008331893011927605, 0.03604738414287567, 0.08101407438516617, 0.026361573487520218, -0.0067230043932795525, 0.030412979423999786, 0.012714317999780178, 0.03726952522993088, 0.01403532549738884, 0.00017417245544493198, 0.05436326563358307, -0.011062068864703178, 0.04078996554017067, -0.07202407717704773, 0.018526768311858177, 0.028252912685275078, 0.010522774420678616, 0.03865457698702812, 0.00009486686030868441, 0.027023904025554657, 0.03250754624605179, -0.0413469634950161, 0.0003919768496416509, 0.01795804128050804, 0.03763490170240402, 0.0012441445142030716, 0.008702137507498264, -0.041272446513175964, -0.061002906411886215, 0.003731603967025876, -0.06164080649614334, 0.023118073120713234, -0.010911593213677406, -0.056535106152296066, 0.018466230481863022, 0.03409665450453758, 0.04806637763977051, -0.015188203193247318, -0.002684547333046794, -0.006413451861590147, 0.048890069127082825, 0.007012093439698219, -0.04270436614751816, -0.001907089026644826, -0.022760747000575066, -0.051612671464681625, 0.04368339478969574, 0.029432496055960655, 0.014883498661220074, 0.004168084356933832, 0.030095206573605537, 0.055515412241220474, 0.06429748237133026, -0.03327547013759613, -0.025888483971357346, -0.008424561470746994, -0.03164435923099518, -0.018309172242879868, 0.04031701013445854, -0.0015156470471993089, 0.10300952941179276, 0.040972087532281876, 0.066954106092453, -0.016303066164255142, 0.03616325184702873, -0.009389450773596764, 0.0117587735876441, 0.03008831851184368, 0.051356371492147446, 0.039867103099823, 0.017781777307391167, -0.054536327719688416, -0.08546140789985657, -0.0438779853284359, -0.06357717514038086, -0.0501658171415329, -0.006305196788161993, -0.016072336584329605, 0.020099401473999023, 0.03166550397872925, -0.03350468724966049, 0.025310780853033066, 0.016870882362127304, 0.022822948172688484, 0.06368657201528549, -0.003135168692097068, 0.007014754228293896, -0.023463226854801178, 0.0011150042992085218, -0.02600879594683647, 0.04067274555563927, 0.06617599725723267, -0.02330891229212284, -0.03827498108148575, 0.07681755721569061, -0.05143940821290016, -0.048489172011613846, -0.02040024660527706, 0.004096995107829571, 0.07121462374925613, -0.050688110291957855, -0.022555971518158913, -0.026020724326372147, -0.021982647478580475, -0.07280357927083969, 0.012990642338991165, 0.073427714407444, 0.04402206838130951, 0.03010820783674717, 0.006256197113543749, -0.037168484181165695, 0.018404023721814156, 0.011266970075666904, -0.027101323008537292, -0.002751564374193549, 0.024926908314228058, 0.02821279503405094, 0.02627805806696415, 0.01647050864994526, -0.03826126456260681, 0.04489482566714287, -0.009149699471890926, -0.0430586151778698, -0.04253726825118065, -0.0019319140119478106, 0.02880169451236725, -0.02870778925716877, 0.018123582005500793, -0.005003680940717459, -0.029100392013788223, -0.04983307793736458, 0.04192338511347771, 0.007578346878290176, 0.06138308718800545, 0.02175447903573513, 0.01079851109534502, 0.03372730687260628, -0.025452908128499985, 0.041790712624788284, 0.01125249918550253, 0.036989010870456696, 0.02127448096871376, 0.00961234886199236, 0.038003306835889816, -0.09192439168691635, 0.0076979342848062515, 0.016911232843995094, 0.021763620898127556, 0.025713056325912476, 0.048378147184848785, 0.00232135783880949, 0.017489343881607056, 0.01842152141034603, -0.022490333765745163, -0.010314935818314552, -0.03130727633833885, -0.06881529837846756, -0.044917598366737366, -0.02628961019217968, -0.0013156795175746083, -0.020477749407291412, 0.05153902992606163, 0.018098682165145874, -0.050135206431150436, -0.004664408043026924, 0.019030621275305748, -0.06936585158109665, -0.0027298873756080866, 0.012908278033137321, 0.02382509969174862, -0.03940248489379883, -0.01968739926815033, -0.003994402009993792, -0.002915977733209729, -0.016710437834262848, -0.042873699218034744, -0.01567545346915722, 0.007819191552698612, 0.04483991116285324, 0.07959850877523422, 0.021846480667591095, 0.04001777246594429, 0.03585365042090416, -0.005078853573650122, 0.022785523906350136, -0.012800960801541805, -0.0001349813537672162, -0.014508342370390892, -0.014823450706899166, -0.0005714613362215459, -0.05014888197183609, -0.019034050405025482, -0.008560440503060818, 0.018040042370557785, -0.03915022313594818, 0.03166897967457771, 0.009249953553080559, 0.019597794860601425, -0.0035857930779457092, 0.010805266909301281, -0.03897148370742798, 0.007426389493048191, 0.024540698155760765, 0.006311229895800352, 0.04648124426603317, 0.012321879155933857, 0.031101789325475693, 0.04620172083377838, 0.02555312030017376, -0.0005323751829564571, 0.13198108971118927, -0.04785146191716194, -0.006948290858417749, -0.06511062383651733, 0.02094878815114498, 0.02392462268471718, 0.05189809203147888, -0.008019874803721905, -0.07609377801418304, -0.007730543147772551, 0.004912883043289185, -0.05939966440200806, 0.00282167736440897, 0.0192877110093832, 0.0169819425791502, -0.017841802909970284, -0.03653871268033981, 0.005052210763096809, 0.043466806411743164, -0.025885066017508507, 0.03169509023427963, -0.06337697058916092, 0.03564620763063431, -0.06124219670891762, -0.009439327754080296, 0.003380137262865901, -0.06373552232980728, -0.04155108332633972, 0.01001053024083376, 0.054906610399484634, 0.0019735631067305803, 0.030906371772289276, 0.012038827873766422, 0.00013709570339415222, -0.014716067351400852, 0.00469708489254117, -0.05130881816148758, 0.008384454064071178, -0.017590010538697243, 0.011400246992707253, -0.013399805873632431, -0.0167065542191267, 0.03767496347427368, 0.010336589068174362, -0.033217012882232666, 0.017109617590904236, -0.003283408936113119, -0.033869028091430664, 0.016392294317483902, -0.011313984170556068, 0.01850653626024723, 0.001822850201278925, -0.0012078552972525358, -0.11764466762542725, 0.0367639884352684, 0.06090531498193741, -0.007134835701435804, 0.013244610279798508, -0.049462586641311646, -0.010236156173050404, -0.0052397181279957294, -0.03153644874691963, 0.04641538858413696, 0.022261394187808037, 0.04982772096991539, 0.028999367728829384, -0.04089607298374176, -0.022918013855814934, -0.0028449492529034615, 0.06869784742593765, 0.0348496213555336, 0.07663802802562714, 0.032599762082099915, -0.003807956585660577, 0.032597362995147705, -0.0034534414298832417, -0.04362284019589424, -0.024833567440509796, -0.05835016816854477, -0.025184547528624535, -0.03215509653091431, 0.04568948224186897, 0.03570385277271271, 0.01274802628904581, -0.004098917823284864, -0.011118419468402863, -0.03600771725177765, -0.00804418046027422, 0.05140208080410957, -0.027506155893206596, 0.021140584722161293, -0.031872548162937164, -0.011730056256055832, 0.01844635047018528, -0.00591015862300992, 0.03908541426062584, 0.015558775514364243, -0.06127379834651947, -0.07399886846542358, 0.007083345670253038, 0.0066440110094845295, -0.04966855049133301, 0.022036148235201836, -0.028604570776224136, -0.026663996279239655, -0.013015157543122768, 0.017001302912831306, 0.00020105281146243215, -0.021559391170740128, -0.002248943317681551, -0.0333273708820343, 0.005322019103914499, -0.06208861246705055, -0.05358291044831276, 0.038755323737859726, 0.03230433911085129, -0.030770324170589447, -0.016131188720464706, -0.05044829472899437, 0.02066514641046524, 0.04258354380726814, -0.016200685873627663, 0.0032074335031211376, 0.05482989549636841, -0.010289049707353115, 0.03500596433877945, 0.0222952738404274, 0.031310856342315674, -0.005843617953360081, 0.017720038071274757, -0.013871313072741032, 0.037367384880781174, -0.035415757447481155, 0.040248796343803406, 0.006075375713407993 ]
<p>For an outside observer the time seems to stop at the event horizon. My intuition suggests, that if it stops there, then it must go backwards inside. Is this the case?</p> <p>This question is a followup for the comment I made for this question: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/23118/are-we-inside-a-black-hole">Are we inside a black hole?</a></p> <blockquote> <p>Food for thought: if time stops at the event horizon (for an outside observer), for inside, my intuition suggests, time should go backwards. So for matter, that's already inside when the black hole forms, it won't fall towards a singularity but would fall outwards towards the event horizon due to this time reversal. So inside there would be an outward gravitational force. It would be fascinating if it turns out that all this cosmological redshift, and expansion we observe, is just the effect of an enormous event horizon outside pulling the stuff outwards.</p> </blockquote> <p>So from outside: we see nothing fall in, and see nothing come out.</p> <p>And from inside: we see nothing fall out, and see nothing come in.</p> <p>Hopefully the answers make this clear, and I learn a bit more about the GR. :)</p>
g4235
[ -0.0019831201061606407, 0.022596823051571846, 0.04208048805594444, -0.02363462746143341, 0.019717944785952568, 0.03787607699632645, 0.019661856815218925, 0.055049799382686615, -0.09796083718538284, -0.0348154678940773, 0.028373684734106064, 0.0010332318488508463, -0.0027007278986275196, 0.0087793730199337, 0.026554344221949577, -0.014703084714710712, 0.013652638532221317, -0.03866155818104744, -0.020485997200012207, -0.003958944231271744, 0.012902013957500458, -0.00010298538109054789, -0.005043052136898041, -0.014489223249256611, -0.019965339452028275, 0.011763076297938824, 0.04540277272462845, -0.01072566770017147, -0.006622350309044123, -0.02133701555430889, 0.03605383634567261, 0.010380197316408157, -0.03325841948390007, -0.04258926212787628, 0.014116466045379639, 0.003734186291694641, 0.01656305231153965, 0.04437832534313202, 0.010152652859687805, 0.019278021529316902, 0.023084120824933052, -0.008934914134442806, -0.003382850205525756, -0.04696262627840042, 0.022065242752432823, 0.01198780070990324, 0.00896852184087038, 0.012525397352874279, 0.083231121301651, -0.036232106387615204, -0.06331595033407211, 0.023112615570425987, 0.020519178360700607, 0.05768957361578941, -0.009174230508506298, 0.0025613170582801104, 0.024950047954916954, -0.021172545850276947, 0.04493246600031853, 0.0027896868996322155, -0.0210457481443882, -0.046341024339199066, 0.01749604567885399, 0.00941910408437252, 0.005410234909504652, -0.006659030448645353, -0.07515773922204971, -0.008064032532274723, -0.021097959950566292, -0.023020075634121895, 0.030405910685658455, 0.001314322929829359, -0.014120534062385559, -0.0030212474521249533, 0.04174083098769188, 0.06836311519145966, 0.005039885640144348, 0.030150657519698143, 0.017340656369924545, -0.023097343742847443, -0.06418614834547043, -0.02932327799499035, -0.0057562063448131084, 0.016883160918951035, 0.09629543125629425, 0.06205855309963226, 0.02332312799990177, 0.010595139116048813, 0.004932397045195103, 0.044650450348854065, 0.04242314025759697, -0.02014295756816864, 0.04113048315048218, -0.0271063894033432, -0.013637580908834934, 0.018722964450716972, -0.008029494434595108, 0.06604425609111786, 0.01849033497273922, 0.05960099771618843, -0.05914987623691559, -0.014924728311598301, -0.0005280252662487328, -0.03939263895153999, 0.0375395268201828, -0.06992771476507187, -0.02925187349319458, 0.0004605088324751705, -0.04449945315718651, -0.020303407683968544, -0.021631406620144844, -0.0874268114566803, -0.027567798271775246, -0.004006965551525354, -0.04206760972738266, 0.015842029824852943, 0.06917507946491241, 0.024913029745221138, 0.037080444395542145, 0.08528012782335281, -0.028574153780937195, 0.02927562966942787, -0.004702193662524223, 0.012127542868256569, -0.008459944278001785, 0.005537887569516897, -0.01353535708039999, -0.03994904085993767, -0.0007384243654087186, -0.0047586942091584206, -0.002402203856036067, 0.06290918588638306, 0.022463452070951462, 0.07381508499383926, 0.01982029154896736, 0.003142624394968152, 0.016505815088748932, -0.02769620530307293, 0.034573424607515335, 0.00016208320448640734, 0.010160894133150578, -0.01240704394876957, 0.015900136902928352, 0.012060090899467468, 0.0057380106300115585, 0.0249226875603199, -0.011484464630484581, -0.009540688246488571, 0.01886609010398388, 0.053808167576789856, 0.007067194674164057, 0.09882941842079163, -0.03932928666472435, 0.0274332445114851, -0.021312488242983818, -0.011329439468681812, 0.02646517939865589, 0.034363508224487305, 0.03686114028096199, 0.0531507283449173, 0.08066567778587341, -0.025776641443371773, -0.00565063813701272, 0.0843111053109169, -0.025185778737068176, -0.017165981233119965, -0.011429326608777046, -0.016043249517679214, 0.0061954655684530735, -0.0534500814974308, -0.04155665636062622, 0.030454687774181366, -0.03177204355597496, 0.052540332078933716, 0.010578639805316925, 0.008453963324427605, 0.02072177454829216, 0.07613395154476166, -0.027073638513684273, -0.002346653491258621, -0.03698451444506645, -0.034634023904800415, -0.022050701081752777, -0.03931712731719017, 0.01655273139476776, -0.016606474295258522, 0.0595502071082592, 0.06180284917354584, -0.00647195428609848, 0.0068953987210989, 0.007758207619190216, -0.04840487241744995, 0.04780689254403114, 0.023059740662574768, 0.014414806850254536, -0.022282980382442474, -0.0005213702679611742, -0.048194728791713715, 0.032774120569229126, -0.00120205944404006, -0.0030506057664752007, -0.01489852461963892, 0.04644910618662834, 0.031266581267118454, 0.04100419953465462, 0.013547204434871674, 0.024485815316438675, -0.006080633495002985, -0.0047571007162332535, -0.03988989070057869, 0.0257857758551836, 0.012450085021555424, 0.012568125501275063, 0.012972177937626839, 0.0036538317799568176, 0.05927041918039322, -0.008755677379667759, 0.04992751032114029, -0.0006448294734582305, 0.0512668713927269, -0.04146545007824898, -0.019199024885892868, -0.022235533222556114, -0.07776700705289841, -0.017451267689466476, 0.040935564786195755, -0.0707617998123169, -0.041708219796419144, 0.018017102032899857, -0.02734135463833809, -0.10396437346935272, 0.04573005810379982, -0.010142652317881584, -0.02043183520436287, 0.08263490349054337, -0.003833015449345112, 0.010118349455296993, -0.018423985689878464, 0.037339210510253906, 0.003415732877328992, -0.021237673237919807, -0.05173192918300629, -0.09359532594680786, -0.015047464519739151, 0.010544423013925552, -0.035230476409196854, 0.029853535816073418, -0.007437823340296745, 0.009912148118019104, 0.012406528927385807, 0.08476033061742783, -0.001965092960745096, -0.03336481377482414, -0.015109541825950146, -0.04618750885128975, -0.005281347315758467, -0.004504174459725618, 0.04056587815284729, -0.10884501039981842, -0.04730953276157379, 0.004154975060373545, -0.01591626927256584, 0.026334695518016815, 0.008508161641657352, -0.05791941657662392, -0.026399128139019012, -0.07321018725633621, 0.016858670860528946, -0.005068045575171709, 0.04553364962339401, 0.031122343614697456, 0.025182588025927544, 0.04750461131334305, 0.013349772430956364, 0.0014793650479987264, 0.0031962392386049032, -0.035713087767362595, 0.0028857900761067867, 0.11970449239015579, 0.0029540027026087046, -0.036033838987350464, 0.02784411795437336, -0.0802805945277214, 0.004486395046114922, -0.039771776646375656, -0.058590006083250046, 0.002038935199379921, -0.026218218728899956, 0.006390634458512068, -0.009568153880536556, -0.0157480388879776, 0.04099823534488678, -0.0019363636383786798, 0.06593788415193558, 0.028297286480665207, 0.01510735135525465, -0.006629067473113537, -0.047065362334251404, -0.029055533930659294, -0.019103439524769783, -0.030520174652338028, -0.07390423864126205, -0.010050613433122635, -0.018049176782369614, 0.011791505850851536, 0.022599440068006516, 0.0036829335149377584, -0.028728200122714043, 0.011260218918323517, -0.07980453968048096, 0.005892174784094095, -0.0033401285763829947, -0.026131071150302887, 0.004790672566741705, 0.021817266941070557, -0.0026115383952856064, -0.016142504289746284, 0.021430647000670433, -0.034390341490507126, -0.03824613615870476, -0.022686485201120377, 0.05891980975866318, -0.04912850260734558, 0.029025372117757797, 0.017672806978225708, 0.010465248487889767, 0.016497695818543434, -0.022403789684176445, -0.05224601924419403, -0.007808228023350239, -0.03177260980010033, -0.007791812997311354, 0.012458700686693192, -0.003699361113831401, 0.003558433149009943, -0.0016929738922044635, -0.005034224130213261, 0.01719963736832142, 0.025883782655000687, 0.017060386016964912, 0.036057475954294205, -0.06313774734735489, 0.037929970771074295, 0.03244509920477867, 0.04390786960721016, -0.007310814224183559, -0.06367412209510803, -0.01492822915315628, -0.015715593472123146, -0.014734240248799324, 0.034775856882333755, -0.019238673150539398, 0.0505085252225399, -0.04228348657488823, -0.0007483885856345296, -0.039121318608522415, 0.02440398931503296, 0.04179741442203522, 0.01974424347281456, -0.036000169813632965, 0.0445968434214592, -0.04350445419549942, 0.03913627564907074, -0.04406818374991417, 0.006598425563424826, -0.04705904796719551, 0.001033943728543818, -0.009948374703526497, 0.030054939910769463, 0.005813240073621273, -0.0027257869951426983, 0.053502585738897324, -0.015277080237865448, 0.0109052499756217, 0.062417492270469666, -0.07231207937002182, 0.01226896420121193, 0.05654766783118248, 0.04816082492470741, -0.008060496300458908, 0.05196640267968178, -0.016496850177645683, -0.036564745008945465, -0.010723412036895752, 0.052029356360435486, 0.07459831237792969, -0.02771618962287903, -0.061556242406368256, -0.04780550301074982, -0.06132083013653755, -0.027110937982797623, 0.00542411906644702, 0.05438245087862015, -0.09296476095914841, 0.0043903193436563015, 0.03268447890877724, -0.0026727737858891487, -0.03522329404950142, -0.00020643637981265783, -0.05942443013191223, 0.025919612497091293, -0.030719226226210594, 0.012291899882256985, 0.04167626425623894, 0.04699096828699112, 0.031139032915234566, 0.03818304091691971, -0.044307686388492584, -0.03395536169409752, -0.02159898169338703, -0.0018923121970146894, 0.018512291833758354, -0.043637149035930634, -0.03250900283455849, 0.055381327867507935, -0.05448668450117111, 0.061910513788461685, 0.016348402947187424, 0.030558805912733078, -0.018375277519226074, 0.11414600163698196, 0.019227297976613045, -0.03491921350359917, 0.03305933251976967, -0.011993126012384892, -0.012343816459178925, -0.035245731472969055, 0.07455891370773315, -0.05771040916442871, 0.02062455378472805, -0.05176080763339996, -0.005954897962510586, -0.014113262295722961, 0.03038620576262474, -0.049397002905607224, 0.059932127594947815, -0.03175726532936096, 0.016356592997908592, -0.0012261033989489079, -0.00851621013134718, 0.028541330248117447, -0.05241178348660469, -0.023514728993177414, -0.029669007286429405, 0.017894580960273743, 0.019093573093414307, 0.005951490253210068, 0.03210039809346199, 0.048979707062244415, -0.026594068855047226, -0.054910607635974884, 0.004286751616746187, -0.018460910767316818, -0.04417156055569649, -0.008896286599338055, 0.03312689810991287, -0.02719609998166561, 0.014549084939062595, -0.05196494981646538, -0.006264884024858475, -0.025373438373208046, -0.038274042308330536, -0.008557149209082127, 0.041508324444293976, -0.0018285228870809078, 0.012001249007880688, -0.003661047900095582, -0.05040453001856804, -0.0029864804819226265, 0.015009467490017414, -0.06557749956846237, 0.057879142463207245, -0.03116278164088726, -0.0133454455062747, -0.01267192792147398, 0.07981840521097183, -0.03086039051413536, -0.04756731167435646, 0.0625702515244484, -0.05504786968231201, -0.03112729638814926, -0.02814832702279091, 0.08801676332950592, -0.01613582856953144, -0.04129969701170921, 0.024637805297970772, -0.015682004392147064, -0.012753539718687534, 0.002340951468795538, -0.014965361915528774, 0.008890286087989807, -0.031089603900909424, -0.0015738330548629165, -0.04105294495820999, -0.05429007485508919, 0.000149606290506199, 0.010385926812887192, -0.02226502262055874, -0.006527920253574848, -0.029695892706513405, -0.09688280522823334, -0.009306356310844421, -0.01656276546418667, 0.01618136093020439, -0.01068186853080988, 0.03231815993785858, 0.0019550395663827658, -0.03625771775841713, 0.012362678535282612, 0.08309143781661987, -0.00788816250860691, -0.00012945827620569617, -0.0538368746638298, 0.03716075420379639, 0.07799512892961502, -0.06490551680326462, 0.0019496009917929769, -0.01565954089164734, 0.01251055859029293, -0.012541706673800945, -0.03100518323481083, -0.001078146044164896, 0.022507179528474808, -0.020121872425079346, 0.016507767140865326, 0.030874893069267273, -0.008849306032061577, -0.018321095034480095, 0.005248813424259424, -0.00963191594928503, 0.01047931332141161, 0.02416643127799034, 0.03858629986643791, -0.0007719247369095683, 0.029301103204488754, 0.05371006205677986, -0.008809331804513931, -0.012962708249688148, 0.04462667182087898, -0.045969221740961075, 0.0000588344810239505, 0.007678793743252754, -0.052172254770994186, 0.010538993403315544, -0.026094654574990273, 0.024639403447508812, -0.08421046286821365, 0.02506309561431408, 0.0011422325624153018, -0.012254778295755386, -0.0037846870254725218, 0.016570689156651497, -0.05654975399374962, 0.031253982335329056, -0.04398350790143013, 0.0017555304802954197, 0.021967854350805283, -0.023541761562228203, -0.050457172095775604, -0.1025843694806099, 0.0033382365945726633, 0.0028121003415435553, -0.05951739847660065, 0.0018237220356240869, 0.018518859520554543, 0.017052719369530678, 0.041296154260635376, -0.0029953340999782085, 0.010912955738604069, -0.005214246921241283, 0.036044761538505554, -0.011136500164866447, -0.0013402150943875313, 0.010168470442295074, -0.033415064215660095, 0.009038755670189857, 0.020679736509919167, 0.0027741193771362305, -0.03416536748409271, -0.0021967110224068165, 0.028525415807962418, -0.03436896577477455, 0.06775104999542236, -0.10431146621704102, 0.02962297759950161, -0.023551052436232567, -0.029444849118590355, 0.03414932265877724, 0.026907140389084816, 0.008885690942406654, 0.02954135090112686, 0.0284557081758976, 0.04510005936026573, -0.03393610939383507, -0.06103365868330002, -0.012032469734549522, -0.03266206011176109, -0.03990212082862854, -0.02287118323147297, -0.005528404377400875, -0.06382850557565689, 0.021772675216197968, 0.024630406871438026, -0.051637470722198486, 0.03935005143284798, -0.015615345910191536, -0.023176884278655052, 0.017910528928041458, 0.06562726199626923, -0.0112993735820055, 0.03557434305548668, -0.007142087444663048, 0.017766112461686134, 0.040988244116306305, 0.04311836138367653, 0.05221854895353317, -0.009083795361220837, -0.025821465998888016, 0.0005057233502157032, 0.0013031961861997843, 0.036445725709199905, -0.004858438391238451, -0.0242984127253294, -0.019912824034690857, -0.02848827838897705, 0.05123751237988472, -0.0413006916642189, 0.022656291723251343, 0.01200118288397789, 0.05324319005012512, -0.016508033499121666, 0.04302698373794556, -0.02588818408548832, 0.02590920217335224, 0.013293086551129818, 0.028165612369775772, 0.036987967789173126, 0.01697753742337227, -0.013079672120511532, -0.05201287940144539, 0.040142934769392014, -0.03821898251771927, 0.03387051448225975, 0.027920084074139595, -0.049775004386901855, 0.0482611246407032, 0.06072530895471573, 0.009937195107340813, -0.08014298975467682, -0.013954811729490757, 0.056291017681360245, -0.03910612314939499, -0.03151308745145798, -0.036899931728839874, -0.02429640293121338, 0.009005706757307053, 0.009328564628958702, 0.037038397043943405, 0.06466859579086304, -0.037121254950761795, 0.028663059696555138, 0.010368133895099163, -0.06716012954711914, 0.07771404087543488, -0.0072629558853805065, 0.040906261652708054, 0.01191656943410635, -0.053821735084056854, -0.020581696182489395, -0.016494499519467354, -0.0013257414102554321, -0.04079637676477432, -0.04746143892407417, -0.048056118190288544, -0.043442051857709885, -0.02859501726925373, -0.051564957946538925, 0.04581032320857048, -0.003245274070650339, 0.07394666969776154, 0.04116429388523102, 0.034604512155056, 0.005091659724712372, 0.03849514573812485, -0.03569324314594269, 0.03736305981874466, -0.03435567766427994, -0.004288556985557079, -0.05143674835562706, 0.01942359283566475, -0.042223431169986725, 0.0832442119717598, -0.05915750190615654, -0.0744590237736702, -0.010916449129581451, -0.004120845813304186, -0.006443102844059467, 0.04926734417676926, -0.05015584081411362, -0.026322437450289726, 0.010184653103351593, 0.035276707261800766, 0.04832393676042557, -0.013435330241918564, 0.010377240367233753, -0.012456108815968037, -0.055031150579452515, -0.0037875326815992594, -0.015026970766484737, 0.026563752442598343, 0.04475647583603859, 0.017792025581002235, -0.031339555978775024, -0.022841664031147957, 0.03445413336157799, -0.037333112210035324, -0.0017706212820485234, -0.010434218682348728, 0.044965870678424835, -0.08642547577619553, -0.009971430525183678, 0.030504465103149414, -0.04486671835184097, 0.0032569703180342913, -0.06225321814417839, 0.028019119054079056, 0.04996136948466301, -0.030249079689383507, -0.008762474171817303, -0.026155302301049232, -0.021548377349972725, 0.04276289418339729, -0.014269819483160973, 0.007268551737070084, -0.012953920289874077, 0.007350774481892586, 0.042388856410980225, -0.00840086955577135, -0.03399696201086044, -0.020321810618042946, 0.023856665939092636, -0.003435522085055709, 0.004358446225523949, -0.016489366069436073, 0.03455091640353203, -0.007080479059368372, 0.016503117978572845, 0.02397243306040764, 0.03784153237938881, -0.016078289598226547, 0.02300691045820713, -0.016352927312254906, 0.012859591282904148, -0.006259604822844267, 0.008586754091084003, -0.024204803630709648, -0.04682645946741104, 0.03698456287384033, -0.0025132072623819113, 0.039730094373226166, -0.00923688244074583, 0.004926270339637995, -0.029307415708899498, -0.0034374690148979425, 0.0060838558711111546, -0.011814863421022892, 0.05529848113656044, 0.020005999132990837 ]
<p>Some sources say that when a photon hits the PV cell, it breaks apart electron-hole pairs. Other sources say that photons <em>create</em> electron-hole pairs. Can anyone explain which one is right? I've read several explanations of what goes on in the solar cell, but they don't seem very clear. To me, who has little prior knowledge, a few aspects of the many different explanations seem to contradict each other. I don't know if it's because some of the explanations said things a certain way for simplicity's sake, but this part seems too significant to ignore.</p> <p>For example, <a href="http://www.solarenergyexperts.co.uk/buyersguides/photovoltaic-glass-how-does-it-work/" rel="nofollow">http://www.solarenergyexperts.co.uk/buyersguides/photovoltaic-glass-how-does-it-work/</a>: "When photons (light particles) from the sun hit the cell, the energy breaks up the paired particles. The freed electrons go into the n-type layer, while the holes go down into the p-type layer."</p> <p>science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/energy/solar-cell3.htm : "When light, in the form of photons, hits our solar cell, its energy breaks apart electron-hole pairs."</p> <p>solarjourneyusa.com/bandgaps.php has a hole section called "<em>Generation</em> of electron-hole pairs"</p> <p>This one basically seems to be talking about the same thing, but doesn't really mention electron-hole pairs, and the explanation seems more confusing to me, but anyway, <a href="http://www2.pv.unsw.edu.au/nsite-files/pdfs/UNSW_Understanding_the_p-n_Junction.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://www2.pv.unsw.edu.au/nsite-files/pdfs/UNSW_Understanding_the_p-n_Junction.pdf</a>: "...broken bonds created by the light act as holes ... and these holes are also free to move throughout the material. Electrons and holes created in this way are physically near each other: for every electron excited by the light there is a corresponding hole generated. These electrons and holes can remain excited only for a short period of time. In a process called recombination, excited electrons stray too close to holes and the two fall back into bonded positions." This one seems to be saying that photons break apart the bonds between the electron and its atom, which creates a free electron and a hole, i.e. another one saying that an electron-hole pair is created.</p> <p>solarcellcentral.com/junction_page.html : "When photons hit the solar cell, free electrons attempt to unite with holes in the p-type layer." </p> <p>www.solarenergy.net/Articles/how-photovoltaic-cells-work.aspx : "When enough photons are absorbed by the negative layer of the photovoltaic cell, electrons are freed from the negative semiconductor material."</p> <p>So what actually happens when light hits a solar cell?</p>
g4236
[ 0.009662560187280178, 0.024022549390792847, -0.01939878612756729, 0.029734192416071892, 0.06078063324093819, -0.01113695465028286, 0.04232320189476013, 0.0010188762098550797, 0.022446343675255775, -0.003563839243724942, 0.03931019827723503, 0.011580842547118664, 0.008595765568315983, -0.020108871161937714, -0.013715436682105064, -0.04213946312665939, 0.06929904222488403, -0.008309170603752136, -0.018826639279723167, 0.07453864067792892, -0.05703499913215637, -0.02290201187133789, -0.0014577489346265793, -0.04240084066987038, -0.04043010622262955, -0.008281839080154896, 0.027990346774458885, -0.0035782926715910435, 0.00945304799824953, -0.02269512414932251, 0.025760864838957787, -0.0069729327224195, 0.07640526443719864, -0.06402728706598282, -0.02943393588066101, -0.018621452152729034, 0.05141068994998932, -0.020891083404421806, -0.005345968529582024, -0.021117370575666428, 0.047515515238046646, -0.04458468407392502, -0.0023971768096089363, 0.009548063389956951, 0.04104059189558029, -0.06537722051143646, -0.03049645759165287, 0.007177405524998903, 0.016191795468330383, 0.00423028040677309, 0.01480952836573124, 0.04286150634288788, 0.05324840918183327, -0.008278020657598972, 0.05024724081158638, -0.005788145586848259, 0.04500066488981247, -0.003291529603302479, 0.08080743253231049, 0.037710484117269516, -0.018082041293382645, 0.031128613278269768, 0.018793679773807526, 0.017319323495030403, 0.04895445331931114, -0.01431731041520834, -0.0005686387303285301, -0.0031367260962724686, -0.021334681659936905, -0.006540801841765642, -0.0156851839274168, -0.020980888977646828, -0.04849552363157272, -0.026845062151551247, 0.03752066567540169, -0.03266535699367523, -0.014163147658109665, 0.012760053388774395, 0.05273626744747162, 0.01161116361618042, 0.05628896877169609, -0.030343150720000267, 0.032739732414484024, -0.07292812317609787, 0.046009182929992676, -0.02307884767651558, -0.01575256697833538, -0.028995372354984283, -0.044874466955661774, -0.00941949337720871, 0.0685766413807869, -0.03805544972419739, 0.042564790695905685, 0.0021602106280624866, -0.09125810861587524, 0.0494784452021122, -0.024307455867528915, 0.015981048345565796, -0.02131660096347332, -0.024792220443487167, -0.017532063648104668, -0.03214848414063454, 0.038272030651569366, -0.032836221158504486, -0.021180380135774612, 0.04543076828122139, 0.011863188818097115, -0.0008839761139824986, -0.013519897125661373, 0.021345021203160286, -0.04881768673658371, 0.02424663119018078, -0.028494657948613167, -0.017789099365472794, -0.011702115647494793, 0.01349435094743967, 0.06040513888001442, -0.014608084224164486, 0.04187391325831413, 0.09047181159257889, 0.03197656571865082, 0.09902217984199524, -0.03448288142681122, 0.024450818076729774, -0.017391953617334366, 0.0052199293859303, 0.05445735901594162, -0.010424861684441566, 0.006063899490982294, 0.03722343221306801, 0.050882935523986816, -0.02679368481040001, -0.015049736946821213, 0.03155618906021118, 0.047470878809690475, 0.03327171504497528, 0.031482063233852386, -0.018449800089001656, 0.05015885829925537, 0.003678911365568638, -0.025406837463378906, 0.02153424732387066, -0.05121688172221184, -0.07625128328800201, 0.011445485055446625, -0.012396334670484066, -0.03740868344902992, -0.015578588470816612, 0.01695292443037033, 0.03367241099476814, 0.044948697090148926, 0.0017315333243459463, -0.04671521112322807, -0.05059907212853432, -0.017211133614182472, 0.027465755119919777, 0.05416180193424225, -0.03189881518483162, 0.025883255526423454, 0.06350624561309814, 0.08376707881689072, -0.03893856704235077, 0.011293853633105755, -0.004238484892994165, -0.05472596734762192, -0.048607248812913895, 0.03056064061820507, -0.07303303480148315, -0.013054409995675087, -0.027323564514517784, -0.02299746870994568, -0.008370374329388142, -0.0037297005765140057, 0.027197910472750664, -0.02169676683843136, 0.0631684884428978, 0.050469592213630676, -0.05490410327911377, 0.016926316544413567, 0.02564057894051075, 0.01667441986501217, -0.05448659881949425, -0.00042800200753845274, -0.0017364106606692076, 0.04156423732638359, -0.02703874558210373, 0.00028572921291925013, -0.02763591893017292, 0.025281906127929688, 0.0232853963971138, -0.056657906621694565, -0.010780440643429756, -0.020466212183237076, 0.008136376738548279, -0.0637594535946846, 0.008412964642047882, -0.02046496793627739, -0.05372418835759163, -0.014781112782657146, -0.016295168548822403, -0.036885570734739304, -0.007557809818536043, -0.018505200743675232, 0.039024703204631805, 0.014845564030110836, 0.0521358922123909, -0.06048719212412834, -0.049038175493478775, -0.015215316787362099, 0.047664202749729156, 0.03445376083254814, -0.015270857140421867, 0.003782278625294566, 0.016614826396107674, -0.017785249277949333, -0.05682162940502167, -0.04923604056239128, -0.004449541214853525, -0.03557886928319931, -0.05494522303342819, 0.014856580644845963, -0.013707068748772144, 0.011132718063890934, -0.08464393019676208, 0.0028703322168439627, 0.058076828718185425, 0.014692873694002628, -0.007258817087858915, 0.006416816730052233, 0.003544579027220607, -0.05803583189845085, 0.02386089600622654, -0.044797010719776154, -0.036255523562431335, -0.03409120440483093, -0.012617373839020729, -0.02934841625392437, 0.02852746658027172, -0.04622158780694008, -0.0641629621386528, 0.04078487306833267, -0.04790864512324333, -0.06176277622580528, 0.004228412173688412, -0.00005248621528153308, -0.05599026754498482, 0.06520184874534607, -0.04375612363219261, -0.003994068130850792, 0.014300506561994553, 0.11146818101406097, -0.03486514091491699, -0.00042623415356501937, 0.02638387121260166, -0.03155546262860298, -0.09385952353477478, 0.041930295526981354, 0.03229748085141182, -0.027621017768979073, 0.025149991735816002, -0.006298714783042669, 0.016587693244218826, -0.05476585403084755, -0.006708656903356314, -0.019298946484923363, 0.005104992538690567, 0.04191150888800621, -0.03229551389813423, 0.017225133255124092, -0.05027848482131958, -0.056569185107946396, 0.08319453150033951, 0.05509568005800247, -0.06352072209119797, 0.07637487351894379, -0.04437809810042381, -0.00906594842672348, -0.011293549090623856, 0.023364562541246414, -0.07862397283315659, 0.005033099092543125, -0.01383532490581274, -0.06297703832387924, -0.039633627980947495, 0.06782373785972595, -0.01912112347781658, -0.04713103175163269, -0.010059872642159462, 0.02146206609904766, -0.004219275899231434, 0.006072650663554668, -0.09046196937561035, 0.02348247915506363, -0.03443622216582298, 0.003352833678945899, 0.0021618588361889124, 0.03349626809358597, -0.029198985546827316, -0.07401085644960403, -0.01997557282447815, 0.00614481046795845, 0.00929476972669363, -0.03314286842942238, 0.012164094485342503, 0.01174840610474348, 0.07690814882516861, -0.006660797633230686, -0.0015125548234209418, -0.06721612066030502, -0.004378856625407934, -0.016687730327248573, -0.020964177325367928, 0.009695497341454029, 0.03137620538473129, -0.012404333800077438, 0.08288963884115219, -0.014280893839895725, 0.012909196317195892, 0.020853154361248016, 0.01374894194304943, -0.06630924344062805, 0.04293346032500267, 0.03126385807991028, 0.011592458002269268, 0.0051990714855492115, 0.04015728086233139, 0.0160510316491127, -0.07927275449037552, -0.0033476250246167183, 0.007867257110774517, 0.04178113117814064, 0.0027929351199418306, -0.033447492867708206, -0.010594885796308517, -0.01584356091916561, -0.00007253650255734101, -0.01026232074946165, 0.04475630074739456, 0.05489563196897507, -0.04887321963906288, 0.0403544083237648, 0.008200623095035553, -0.020062299445271492, -0.011189636774361134, 0.02362607605755329, -0.032472286373376846, 0.0025118121411651373, 0.00581005122512579, 0.02460796758532524, -0.020430728793144226, 0.06925807148218155, -0.014911075122654438, -0.01285787858068943, -0.002825146308168769, -0.06482699513435364, -0.0004079801728948951, -0.022417819127440453, -0.016246337443590164, -0.001825112383812666, 0.028562253341078758, 0.03257928788661957, -0.03088109940290451, 0.05110568553209305, -0.026112249121069908, -0.042077258229255676, -0.0006056930287741125, -0.023687362670898438, -0.0001928474084706977, -0.011229531839489937, -0.052574437111616135, -0.03487830609083176, 0.007350662723183632, -0.0311390683054924, 0.02882189117372036, -0.014588829129934311, -0.010367671959102154, 0.03422171622514725, 0.00873658712953329, 0.0233443696051836, 0.013760372065007687, -0.018761975690722466, -0.060204315930604935, 0.05162493884563446, 0.027641955763101578, 0.1259315311908722, -0.001068148878403008, 0.03516455367207527, 0.02925277128815651, -0.0760219544172287, -0.03322368115186691, 0.06756702065467834, 0.028781378641724586, -0.05471843108534813, 0.006109000649303198, 0.03357943147420883, 0.023832052946090698, 0.004793099593371153, 0.03740352392196655, -0.021851593628525734, -0.0080189798027277, 0.058449383825063705, 0.03523058816790581, -0.029216062277555466, -0.033708781003952026, 0.05067910626530647, 0.015111671760678291, 0.0013557259226217866, -0.03180807828903198, -0.0036585256457328796, -0.01165019255131483, 0.0173807255923748, 0.03367002308368683, 0.032509300857782364, -0.04287644475698471, 0.026387955993413925, 0.0043744477443397045, 0.003714685095474124, 0.05057623237371445, 0.051517728716135025, 0.030396459624171257, -0.03747936338186264, 0.015552638098597527, 0.03756708279252052, -0.034101422876119614, 0.011745245195925236, 0.10848893225193024, 0.03570062667131424, -0.03836197406053543, 0.0649510845541954, -0.014987416565418243, 0.03309082239866257, 0.00045284611405804753, -0.04055154323577881, -0.03417243808507919, -0.00993437971919775, 0.027272123843431473, -0.0468975231051445, -0.0021608122624456882, 0.026829589158296585, 0.033356137573719025, 0.10400078445672989, -0.015300554223358631, 0.051411163061857224, -0.006798934657126665, 0.05754322186112404, -0.004033360164612532, 0.029104415327310562, -0.025346120819449425, 0.011043266393244267, -0.03610081598162651, 0.00842319056391716, 0.009530165232717991, 0.014243057928979397, -0.03788015618920326, 0.006113978568464518, 0.0329376757144928, -0.012583213858306408, -0.042657721787691116, -0.029537100344896317, 0.0449405238032341, -0.04095496982336044, -0.010905861854553223, 0.04049874469637871, 0.021011611446738243, 0.021177174523472786, -0.03529540076851845, -0.005495143122971058, -0.023903651162981987, -0.04305899888277054, -0.005997346714138985, -0.008909688331186771, 0.027145637199282646, 0.016465185210108757, 0.0021780498791486025, 0.009088228456676006, -0.025462841615080833, -0.027438312768936157, 0.004199756775051355, -0.04469892755150795, -0.0026034305337816477, 0.0409688875079155, 0.01247345469892025, 0.043697159737348557, -0.005064752418547869, 0.007888377644121647, 0.025177793577313423, -0.024829048663377762, 0.007884757593274117, 0.015088435262441635, -0.006487276870757341, 0.0184969250112772, -0.05702916532754898, -0.030092189088463783, -0.050714194774627686, -0.06824832409620285, 0.00796535238623619, -0.006963930558413267, 0.08456367999315262, 0.0143942441791296, 0.009444593451917171, -0.0012724095722660422, 0.02477712742984295, -0.01600028946995735, -0.04133512079715729, 0.03879835084080696, -0.00617245864123106, 0.030702926218509674, -0.0014155494282022119, 0.057439953088760376, -0.025965716689825058, -0.04230160266160965, -0.04615452513098717, 0.020618241280317307, 0.021261300891637802, 0.013610112480819225, -0.01661064475774765, -0.027550185099244118, 0.009245302528142929, 0.04668011888861656, -0.008080230094492435, 0.0056691961362957954, 0.006033977493643761, 0.006163882091641426, -0.0072800214402377605, 0.06649769097566605, -0.04639658331871033, -0.09744425117969513, 0.04654334858059883, 0.098174549639225, 0.0020893330220133066, 0.02363639324903488, 0.006879490800201893, 0.05237371847033501, -0.02395973727107048, -0.026315169408917427, -0.06282325834035873, -0.004360896535217762, -0.012262444943189621, 0.048456814140081406, -0.019491951912641525, -0.01866302452981472, -0.04275408759713173, 0.012385412119328976, 0.0512528121471405, -0.011924106627702713, -0.03212211653590202, 0.004631726071238518, -0.0034709502942860126, 0.018529875203967094, 0.06784628331661224, -0.031586430966854095, -0.019908247515559196, 0.027920661494135857, 0.020868513733148575, 0.011797448620200157, 0.016324441879987717, 0.02452705428004265, -0.02292546257376671, -0.0135162603110075, -0.05246281996369362, 0.042195919901132584, 0.04878703132271767, -0.025235475972294807, -0.009283713065087795, 0.030572988092899323, 0.008530539460480213, -0.027453213930130005, -0.06768284738063812, -0.04201037809252739, 0.009297819808125496, 0.04212622717022896, -0.01147809624671936, -0.004096397198736668, -0.02073316089808941, -0.010221557691693306, 0.025577526539564133, 0.03512108325958252, 0.04216405376791954, -0.06761052459478378, -0.05116622895002365, 0.039873261004686356, -0.007014283444732428, -0.0026582195423543453, -0.015204674564301968, -0.008690190501511097, 0.05965185910463333, 0.01873335987329483, -0.020323893055319786, 0.02391514927148819, -0.01377114187926054, -0.007099851034581661, 0.01063797902315855, 0.031110655516386032, 0.027722781524062157, -0.03549431264400482, -0.01534193567931652, 0.05568723380565643, -0.034198690205812454, 0.015276721678674221, 0.039417024701833725, -0.0053311921656131744, 0.06723526120185852, 0.04458223655819893, -0.016123805195093155, -0.019999535754323006, 0.019563494250178337, 0.0013910331763327122, 0.026730548590421677, -0.018563438206911087, 0.005644825752824545, -0.08438853919506073, 0.010089163668453693, -0.01613190583884716, 0.035124581307172775, -0.012887051329016685, -0.022862490266561508, -0.039789583534002304, 0.013581013306975365, 0.03419208526611328, -0.008622664958238602, -0.0199276115745306, -0.07156915217638016, 0.003005199832841754, -0.036523498594760895, 0.046239081770181656, 0.11175382137298584, -0.0015517773572355509, 0.011330374516546726, 0.04259345307946205, -0.05671825632452965, -0.002703974023461342, -0.06581627577543259, -0.034393638372421265, 0.030966363847255707, -0.02738378942012787, 0.027005234733223915, -0.02271297387778759, 0.014121963642537594, -0.008093509823083878, -0.044209256768226624, -0.0022872535046190023, 0.009734860621392727, 0.027856701985001564, 0.053985875099897385, 0.03121868148446083, -0.013092183507978916, -0.02644546516239643, -0.050086457282304764, -0.059702467173337936, -0.025029541924595833, -0.023384077474474907, -0.043076999485492706, -0.008461291901767254, 0.007128837052732706, 0.00918501801788807, 0.07691676169633865, -0.05324443802237511, 0.013884796760976315, -0.03574115410447121, -0.0369766540825367, 0.007819660939276218, -0.010929047130048275, -0.00578432297334075, 0.059452325105667114, 0.006473800167441368, -0.019289910793304443, 0.021299641579389572, -0.07220546901226044, -0.04780276492238045, 0.0028069347608834505, 0.003212090814486146, -0.02804628759622574, -0.025246625766158104, -0.0036913761869072914, -0.07476644963026047, 0.014569401741027832, -0.013495068997144699, 0.08971796929836273, -0.08276201039552689, -0.053716789931058884, 0.01912749744951725, 0.010795713402330875, 0.044271402060985565, -0.06280291080474854, -0.009521851316094398, -0.013786747120320797, -0.041255708783864975, 0.02268621325492859, -0.026264335960149765, 0.004279106389731169, 0.043985527008771896, 0.015904663130640984, -0.013565299101173878, -0.0050362478941679, -0.00041450263233855367, -0.007484086789190769, 0.06491413712501526, 0.009403112344443798, -0.030465958639979362, 0.04352252185344696, -0.013650485314428806, -0.032522980123758316, -0.0047861794009804726, -0.014619274064898491, 0.02278262935578823, 0.01686602644622326, 0.020156510174274445, -0.023208055645227432, 0.010133758187294006, -0.014303351752460003, 0.05031054839491844, -0.05021871253848076, -0.022912371903657913, -0.03967542201280594, -0.015944041311740875, -0.04627714306116104, -0.015626659616827965, 0.0602274090051651, 0.008385931141674519, 0.056274496018886566, 0.004474536515772343, 0.004421168472617865, -0.024716340005397797, 0.008651115000247955, 0.009847491979598999, 0.030856844037771225, 0.05961685627698898, 0.0356157012283802, -0.00922151654958725, -0.0055572655983269215, -0.02559678815305233, -0.02255115658044815, 0.01779860071837902, 0.008846437558531761, 0.022407904267311096, -0.005459377076476812, -0.01207820326089859, -0.006283957976847887, 0.059891413897275925, -0.004357662983238697, -0.00455360347405076, -0.07588173449039459, -0.03589789196848869, -0.008414584212005138, 0.013853142037987709, -0.03971557691693306, 0.029778188094496727, 0.029513448476791382, 0.006586168892681599, 0.027936134487390518, 0.010056428611278534, -0.0006520405295304954, -0.008599787019193172, 0.03619025647640228, 0.08390717208385468, -0.03501799702644348, -0.04414653405547142, 0.001085759256966412, 0.019481930881738663, -0.021917369216680527, -0.006308140233159065, -0.006952556315809488, -0.020899014547467232, -0.0322875902056694, 0.013404070399701595, -0.01916799694299698, -0.0037910931278020144, -0.026741869747638702 ]
<p><strong>Question:</strong></p> <blockquote> <p>consider a long, straight wire of cross-sectional area $A$ carrying a current $i$. Let there be $n$ free electrons per unit volume. An observer places himself on a trolley moving in the direction opposite to the current with a speed $v = \frac{i}{nAe}$ and separated from the wire by a distance $r$. The magnetic field seen by the observer is very nearly</p> </blockquote> <p><strong>My Answer:</strong></p> <blockquote> <p>Zero. Because current is $neAv$ where $v$ is drift velocity of electrons. Relative velocity between him and electrons is zero. So, no flow of charge through any cross-section according to him. So no current. So no magnetic field.</p> </blockquote> <p><strong>Actual answer:</strong></p> <blockquote> <p>$\frac{\mu\ i}{2\cdot\pi\cdot r}$ where $\mu$ is the permeabilty of free space.</p> </blockquote>
g4237
[ 0.04682096838951111, 0.07591331005096436, -0.0013427793746814132, -0.015124429948627949, 0.029390182346105576, 0.053483426570892334, 0.09145252406597137, 0.004359639249742031, -0.038259465247392654, 0.0025062214117497206, -0.0321236178278923, 0.036378420889377594, -0.02812047488987446, 0.0017048562876880169, 0.000015351015463238582, 0.02680191956460476, 0.09850195050239563, -0.03549390286207199, 0.03513847663998604, -0.0009347310988232493, -0.0026503591798245907, -0.00689207436516881, 0.0379088893532753, -0.03169196844100952, 0.05109066516160965, -0.06616152822971344, 0.006890824530273676, -0.02208157256245613, -0.036713700741529465, -0.005287614651024342, 0.034081704914569855, -0.014546447433531284, 0.03783141076564789, -0.06512055546045303, -0.07583253085613251, -0.0297867339104414, -0.011765819042921066, 0.046800777316093445, 0.053788214921951294, 0.008119968697428703, 0.03725733608007431, -0.0015621472848579288, 0.015714088454842567, -0.023456348106265068, 0.025740046054124832, 0.013481583446264267, -0.028410563245415688, -0.016425153240561485, -0.026364987716078758, -0.027927234768867493, -0.07302623987197876, 0.03530711308121681, 0.03626701608300209, -0.006648504175245762, -0.04555906355381012, 0.007847892120480537, 0.023910371586680412, -0.02827375940978527, -0.025471778586506844, 0.06368011236190796, 0.022029662504792213, 0.03723771497607231, 0.028327733278274536, -0.03558069467544556, -0.002530233236029744, 0.023108839988708496, -0.0627298578619957, 0.031529396772384644, 0.012207288295030594, 0.02027306891977787, 0.0241866335272789, -0.06448012590408325, -0.03519398346543312, -0.020308835431933403, -0.0017624881584197283, 0.015419532544910908, 0.005101086106151342, 0.0001645812881179154, 0.10528481006622314, -0.04668457806110382, -0.1174117848277092, -0.04663165658712387, -0.030900029465556145, 0.0557091124355793, 0.033678628504276276, -0.007397003471851349, 0.029499415308237076, 0.011685030534863472, 0.0030758848879486322, 0.03712178394198418, 0.03474399074912071, -0.029264483600854874, 0.08925594389438629, 0.0021151641849428415, 0.01877128891646862, -0.019772401079535484, -0.042940594255924225, 0.027877021580934525, -0.041098639369010925, -0.025284651666879654, -0.03888367861509323, -0.021794363856315613, -0.02956661581993103, 0.007964178919792175, -0.019361454993486404, 0.005431653466075659, 0.032752733677625656, 0.02188248001039028, 0.006481765303760767, -0.004635924007743597, 0.02789042703807354, -0.05771537497639656, -0.040336206555366516, 0.016650915145874023, -0.00701450789347291, 0.008454551920294762, 0.053472451865673065, -0.02410842850804329, 0.0053476071916520596, 0.02049241214990616, -0.0001519140787422657, 0.04002420976758003, 0.07249681651592255, 0.06335943192243576, -0.007921416312456131, 0.008343623951077461, 0.0017941613914445043, 0.02992972731590271, 0.02765863947570324, 0.01261375192552805, -0.03754626587033272, -0.019542457535862923, 0.007771178614348173, 0.02389797382056713, -0.028697287663817406, -0.028753409162163734, -0.001378378365188837, 0.018077434971928596, -0.009761425666511059, 0.02929866313934326, 0.029710955917835236, -0.06071077287197113, 0.01263417862355709, -0.028168007731437683, -0.018032260239124298, -0.06308580189943314, -0.013008126989006996, -0.03349047526717186, 0.10190816968679428, -0.036882590502500534, 0.006316338665783405, 0.07454701513051987, -0.028866183012723923, -0.006698815152049065, -0.00348518043756485, -0.050731152296066284, 0.08568429946899414, -0.043321579694747925, 0.08507469296455383, -0.05517623946070671, 0.008741967380046844, 0.0044883545488119125, 0.014127891510725021, -0.009441408328711987, -0.04607689008116722, -0.03438170999288559, 0.07601270079612732, -0.044237252324819565, 0.06390999257564545, -0.04252972453832626, -0.056164734065532684, -0.05695251747965813, 0.0625843033194542, 0.07936551421880722, -0.026596996933221817, -0.03507286682724953, 0.0029616025276482105, 0.008683387190103531, 0.016164928674697876, 0.014299529604613781, 0.014414187520742416, 0.034143466502428055, 0.04982464388012886, 0.0015714290784671903, -0.010659514926373959, 0.00914475042372942, -0.06919390708208084, 0.01099204458296299, -0.046127479523420334, -0.02566649578511715, -0.011175142601132393, 0.011533894576132298, -0.015397611074149609, 0.028120853006839752, -0.04250256344676018, -0.0009033624664880335, 0.025221947580575943, -0.04778078570961952, -0.008769964799284935, -0.03291863203048706, 0.0157457422465086, 0.039952125400304794, 0.06883865594863892, 0.015936536714434624, 0.015034165233373642, -0.014494247734546661, -0.013431793078780174, -0.043652862310409546, 0.06666591018438339, 0.02041197009384632, 0.08011852204799652, 0.040688563138246536, -0.023425156250596046, 0.028447825461626053, -0.0288845207542181, -0.07190718501806259, -0.03150582313537598, -0.016143109649419785, -0.05974946171045303, 0.014827161096036434, 0.021464718505740166, -0.025824572890996933, 0.03337693586945534, -0.03474770858883858, -0.025735242292284966, -0.025245551019906998, 0.04809096083045006, -0.061513833701610565, -0.028383849188685417, 0.03709665313363075, -0.07464911788702011, 0.01852431520819664, -0.031283535063266754, -0.0054292501881718636, 0.03150975704193115, 0.03556748107075691, -0.004850903060287237, 0.031448669731616974, 0.0050484915263950825, -0.010373791679739952, -0.014073660597205162, 0.0068537089973688126, -0.022058755159378052, -0.03606559708714485, 0.015847118571400642, -0.0003473896940704435, 0.042771127074956894, 0.02310238592326641, 0.04014567658305168, -0.022391853854060173, 0.007026467472314835, -0.027728624641895294, 0.008611955679953098, 0.056649092584848404, -0.0047150603495538235, 0.00953078456223011, -0.0244853924959898, 0.05700201541185379, -0.023901985958218575, -0.04868120700120926, 0.014810604974627495, -0.002369896275922656, 0.054520685225725174, 0.010535945184528828, -0.05627547577023506, -0.00036880001425743103, -0.03382878378033638, 0.016837818548083305, 0.059004198759794235, -0.026815315708518028, -0.011382093653082848, 0.05279669910669327, -0.03532128036022186, 0.03469718247652054, 0.01728421077132225, -0.01817445270717144, 0.013729491271078587, -0.0009052141103893518, -0.02062899060547352, 0.0025370116345584393, 0.012388821691274643, 0.03375814110040665, 0.01322948932647705, 0.010670744813978672, 0.01837260276079178, -0.030005643144249916, 0.02851303480565548, -0.028523487970232964, 0.022189317271113396, 0.025550829246640205, -0.054377231746912, -0.01885828748345375, 0.08643028140068054, -0.005902210716158152, -0.0145077770575881, 0.06032295152544975, 0.07062368839979172, -0.05142564699053764, -0.01408554706722498, -0.01697406731545925, 0.014746423810720444, -0.00966633204370737, -0.016197767108678818, 0.031312257051467896, 0.040520112961530685, -0.007458771113306284, -0.006935337092727423, -0.07895977795124054, -0.006755843758583069, -0.004628339782357216, -0.0024040283169597387, 0.043276816606521606, 0.0057878922671079636, -0.053266096860170364, -0.035809226334095, -0.017280487343668938, -0.024186963215470314, -0.00894306693226099, 0.03856652230024338, 0.006035475060343742, 0.033735089004039764, -0.014497448690235615, 0.0009134774445556104, 0.038146886974573135, 0.006757664494216442, -0.0313730426132679, 0.0006280425586737692, 0.025338348001241684, -0.022972118109464645, -0.035540804266929626, -0.012037604115903378, 0.044297847896814346, 0.011642646975815296, -0.03216126188635826, -0.011213978752493858, -0.017724689096212387, 0.049556437879800797, 0.06029117479920387, 0.03229687735438347, 0.014769959263503551, -0.030074039474129677, -0.05162033066153526, -0.0829826071858406, -0.05468820780515671, -0.0077424724586308, 0.03136054798960686, -0.021717220544815063, 0.023235606029629707, 0.03919324278831482, 0.00463017588481307, 0.08202750980854034, 0.01158678438514471, -0.015400061383843422, -0.04520057514309883, -0.014728648588061333, -0.015924053266644478, 0.017758069559931755, -0.02821626141667366, -0.03874054178595543, -0.018779292702674866, 0.022032931447029114, -0.016945617273449898, 0.00498224189504981, -0.021577507257461548, -0.016169561073184013, -0.006813535001128912, 0.015337873250246048, 0.07114136964082718, 0.006403210572898388, -0.08220026642084122, -0.040639303624629974, -0.11021681874990463, -0.01411402877420187, 0.05651013180613518, 0.02992706559598446, -0.04307779297232628, -0.004492605570703745, 0.0018697569612413645, -0.047129806131124496, 0.03734375536441803, 0.041525255888700485, -0.007086767349392176, -0.06064711883664131, -0.0015828815521672368, 0.01034968625754118, -0.031740300357341766, -0.0014367366675287485, 0.02878417633473873, -0.06303000450134277, -0.030338726937770844, 0.025970596820116043, 0.029747655615210533, -0.01543803233653307, 0.04818505793809891, -0.026341451331973076, -0.023078445345163345, 0.0186622217297554, -0.0021881761495023966, 0.021223250776529312, -0.015350595116615295, 0.06762208789587021, 0.00951505545526743, -0.001465609180741012, 0.02897179313004017, 0.025566626340150833, 0.016582274809479713, 0.021823424845933914, -0.02470073290169239, 0.003966519609093666, 0.018788134679198265, -0.03321139141917229, -0.016959520056843758, -0.06446453183889389, -0.0475044846534729, 0.03418063744902611, 0.001087403972633183, -0.0014620794681832194, 0.025118958204984665, -0.0008385403198190033, -0.05848616734147072, 0.014444872736930847, 0.025798430666327477, 0.02269669994711876, -0.0492042675614357, -0.027015648782253265, 0.05820757895708084, 0.02986324205994606, -0.0056161414831876755, 0.006734881550073624, -0.0459468811750412, -0.029829954728484154, 0.04430177062749863, -0.03591753914952278, 0.040555208921432495, -0.05130540952086449, 0.0696881040930748, -0.029136305674910545, 0.00680703017860651, 0.015619158744812012, 0.10807527601718903, 0.031103091314435005, -0.03874999284744263, 0.05595313385128975, 0.00808061845600605, -0.04760327935218811, 0.00874004140496254, -0.01524853240698576, -0.036139339208602905, 0.018323924392461777, -0.041274283081293106, 0.02446073852479458, -0.006206226069480181, -0.05036613345146179, 0.026352334767580032, 0.005605489946901798, -0.03104405477643013, -0.015580076724290848, -0.03846944496035576, 0.01863441802561283, 0.008657775819301605, -0.02651563473045826, 0.039792999625205994, -0.004390972666442394, 0.06734716892242432, 0.0060270484536886215, -0.017702661454677582, -0.008901959285140038, -0.06338250637054443, -0.058243170380592346, 0.0004902237560600042, -0.00008979325502878055, 0.05763411894440651, 0.010110095143318176, -0.012820053845643997, -0.054443079978227615, 0.056319355964660645, 0.02791675366461277, -0.008947660215198994, -0.039276495575904846, -0.008910102769732475, -0.029561391100287437, -0.022107386961579323, -0.0007249001646414399, 0.02010752633213997, 0.037228167057037354, 0.014186698943376541, -0.06552977114915848, 0.08780123293399811, -0.012510792352259159, -0.09747422486543655, -0.032536830753088, 0.06100703775882721, -0.02146029658615589, -0.00253439717926085, -0.03746580332517624, -0.005137554835528135, 0.05236966907978058, 0.021553991362452507, -0.04304618760943413, -0.011756893247365952, -0.05259496346116066, -0.03650987893342972, 0.0265866219997406, 0.030120117589831352, -0.03472741320729256, 0.0468057356774807, -0.011401331052184105, -0.029695909470319748, -0.01662353426218033, 0.0065701184794306755, -0.02351880818605423, 0.032094985246658325, 0.042771801352500916, -0.031836386770009995, 0.04997079819440842, -0.01313494611531496, -0.025999536737799644, -0.0038630967028439045, -0.027357803657650948, 0.010462588630616665, 0.04897265508770943, -0.016576694324612617, 0.0370035395026207, 0.021252090111374855, -0.006123949773609638, -0.05422290787100792, -0.04963363707065582, -0.03447277098894119, 0.04327477142214775, 0.0393877848982811, 0.054129112511873245, 0.0004749610961880535, -0.018253177404403687, -0.06845172494649887, -0.0030733600724488497, -0.011974581517279148, 0.011793738231062889, -0.05005599558353424, -0.023203689604997635, -0.027920156717300415, 0.006676922552287579, -0.0000868761126184836, 0.026677291840314865, 0.08869472146034241, -0.05208481848239899, -0.001410488155670464, -0.018487436696887016, -0.03599102795124054, 0.015281112864613533, -0.014832871966063976, -0.025366302579641342, 0.02184242382645607, -0.039329931139945984, -0.012843530625104904, 0.05213708057999611, 0.020684529095888138, 0.01857728883624077, 0.014120275154709816, -0.06448030471801758, -0.037601325660943985, 0.07665283232927322, -0.020094241946935654, 0.020130297169089317, 0.025065934285521507, 0.018457239493727684, -0.03970929607748985, -0.021336587145924568, 0.03395192697644234, 0.02817402221262455, 0.048570673912763596, -0.04486328363418579, -0.03621580824255943, -0.004296767525374889, 0.0022446855437010527, 0.04668774455785751, 0.020063171163201332, -0.03243834152817726, -0.006812375504523516, -0.06731338053941727, 0.030146105214953423, -0.01636039838194847, 0.024918267503380775, -0.005886807106435299, -0.059278421103954315, -0.001309139421209693, 0.05284632369875908, 0.0036883598659187555, -0.035287193953990936, 0.033043742179870605, 0.011067518964409828, -0.04009132832288742, 0.0053595309145748615, 0.006354927085340023, -0.051570627838373184, -0.015107874758541584, -0.0423460379242897, -0.021191058680415154, -0.03425626829266548, -0.05587878078222275, 0.10118206590414047, -0.00038132976624183357, 0.02226623333990574, 0.030506711453199387, 0.034777916967868805, 0.06506441533565521, 0.0441773384809494, 0.014865615405142307, 0.020351599901914597, -0.057903267443180084, -0.004249730613082647, 0.03645053505897522, 0.019007021561264992, 0.045836593955755234, 0.01936555840075016, -0.004824688192456961, 0.02580762654542923, 0.0004138716321904212, -0.02199995145201683, 0.020453250035643578, 0.03849826008081436, -0.010263773612678051, -0.021712785586714745, -0.07704244554042816, -0.02662677876651287, 0.019324148073792458, 0.04823164641857147, -0.003251949092373252, -0.014610908925533295, 0.05736688897013664, -0.01100227888673544, 0.032487187534570694, 0.026015261188149452, -0.03301672264933586, -0.011985794641077518, -0.005800692364573479, -0.008968129754066467, 0.021885404363274574, -0.013376009650528431, 0.052699726074934006, 0.04587286338210106, -0.029827315360307693, 0.028147820383310318, 0.000600393395870924, -0.014595148153603077, -0.04425793141126633, -0.057128310203552246, 0.00813690759241581, 0.0654282197356224, 0.02092619426548481, -0.00972283910959959, 0.023806123062968254, -0.00483680097386241, 0.018162958323955536, -0.011669796891510487, -0.020947109907865524, -0.020395124331116676, 0.02177639864385128, 0.0209030844271183, 0.010318512097001076, -0.028119217604398727, -0.025604305788874626, -0.027335477992892265, 0.0013228205498307943, -0.010851502418518066, 0.035465989261865616, 0.013289863243699074, -0.06160993501543999, 0.017397871240973473, -0.04783789813518524, -0.05194651335477829, 0.004595836624503136, -0.033332981169223785, -0.007488937582820654, -0.014819750562310219, 0.031893424689769745, -0.012807248160243034, -0.048219166696071625, 0.028553159907460213, 0.026271726936101913, -0.029035018756985664, -0.020036859437823296, 0.006010816898196936, -0.03456994518637657, -0.013414209708571434, 0.004384016152471304, -0.03376671299338341, -0.02662861905992031, -0.008542885072529316, 0.013973523862659931, -0.03656632825732231, 0.03998694196343422, 0.023530498147010803, 0.06935372203588486, -0.019511202350258827, -0.00397155387327075, 0.03426368534564972, 0.013706807047128677, 0.029818257316946983, 0.08508425205945969, -0.022439122200012207, 0.04565102607011795, 0.021954266354441643, -0.026525121182203293, 0.06461981683969498, -0.005152801983058453, 0.007498432416468859, -0.0002567741903476417, -0.028200022876262665, -0.07980022579431534, 0.025284506380558014, 0.059680379927158356, 0.07061551511287689, -0.030173201113939285, -0.03304978460073471, 0.01936451345682144, -0.03561466187238693, -0.03265029564499855, 0.025409460067749023, 0.04427417367696762, -0.009477204643189907, -0.007350790314376354, -0.014514267444610596, -0.004797544330358505, -0.005253931973129511, -0.04733126610517502, -0.01203688234090805, -0.011121023446321487, 0.014908954501152039, -0.012615536339581013, 0.0014879661612212658, 0.04123937338590622, -0.040320903062820435, -0.055387943983078, 0.005792759824544191, -0.06975949555635452, -0.017071420326828957, 0.040413785725831985, -0.016144752502441406, 0.03240435570478439, 0.018718555569648743, 0.01051529124379158, -0.008114690892398357, -0.04234599322080612, -0.003732512705028057, -0.021143291145563126, 0.018637079745531082, -0.03419465199112892, 0.03954048827290535, 0.010155115276575089, -0.04767477884888649, 0.05215846747159958, 0.014271175488829613, -0.043609388172626495, -0.016901306807994843, 0.05004991963505745, -0.034779954701662064, 0.03893901780247688, -0.03260299935936928, 0.01246404554694891, 0.07608882337808609, -0.03630710765719414, -0.049078408628702164, 0.011989183723926544, 0.033437106758356094, 0.025224905461072922, -0.07714425027370453, -0.041116394102573395, 0.009504633955657482 ]
<p>I'm doing an experiment where I bring a probe very close to a well full of fluid and then very slowly lower it to obtain some force deformation values. The material behaves very much like a fluid and when I bring the probe close to the fluid, it sort of jumps up and grabs the probe and forms like a "column?" that actually pulls on the probe rather than pushing on it. </p> <p>Anyway, I'm trying to coat the probe with an oil or something that will prevent this, but I don't know how to look into it because I don't know what its called or how its described in the literature. Any ideas on what this phenomena is called?</p>
g4238
[ 0.034352242946624756, -0.025877628475427628, 0.017040951177477837, -0.08355322480201721, 0.02051282301545143, 0.03427651897072792, 0.009623807854950428, -0.03947857767343521, 0.02354329638183117, -0.020178943872451782, 0.06425021588802338, -0.0232296884059906, 0.017149800434708595, -0.001211992115713656, 0.010458551347255707, 0.0069973100908100605, 0.058510974049568176, -0.029027273878455162, 0.038920801132917404, -0.009045768529176712, -0.0334637314081192, 0.07277334481477737, 0.021581031382083893, -0.010502292774617672, -0.022677550092339516, -0.03205679729580879, 0.01409746240824461, 0.018106399103999138, 0.05447864532470703, -0.021472055464982986, -0.01295800693333149, -0.0013045815285295248, -0.007591784466058016, 0.007915186695754528, -0.016753576695919037, -0.06451095640659332, 0.0002529877529013902, -0.03649882227182388, -0.015073471702635288, 0.0030881441198289394, -0.006599655840545893, -0.001985972747206688, 0.05461131036281586, 0.00355167081579566, 0.00909526739269495, -0.00032159924739971757, -0.0011195165570825338, -0.03376079350709915, -0.014088243246078491, -0.02293926477432251, 0.0014463530387729406, -0.01023171842098236, -0.053106799721717834, -0.013459432870149612, 0.04810088127851486, -0.023052850738167763, 0.008473535068333149, 0.034930575639009476, 0.09983285516500473, 0.00023254172992892563, 0.011394026689231396, 0.023681597784161568, 0.0018870853818953037, -0.0027038229163736105, 0.0005506896995939314, -0.019958123564720154, -0.023391298949718475, -0.01539696380496025, 0.029361385852098465, 0.061037637293338776, -0.018179038539528847, 0.06928817182779312, 0.008108149282634258, -0.03002038411796093, -0.03562919422984123, 0.013509955257177353, -0.023257549852132797, 0.004761030897498131, 0.01681700348854065, -0.04457365348935127, -0.014386098831892014, 0.05112990736961365, -0.04248020052909851, 0.006804380565881729, 0.0739014744758606, 0.0336093008518219, -0.04388390854001045, 0.023202095180749893, 0.008428732864558697, -0.013026226311922073, 0.025863543152809143, -0.049235761165618896, 0.013584292493760586, -0.014207454398274422, -0.017007702961564064, -0.01146716345101595, -0.015261122956871986, 0.007355784066021442, -0.035818979144096375, 0.0008788060513325036, 0.007457104977220297, 0.0003642089432105422, -0.0008286290103569627, -0.004151829984039068, -0.06092663109302521, -0.0023403337690979242, -0.03845885396003723, 0.01697651296854019, 0.049670394510030746, -0.05721835792064667, 0.021705972030758858, 0.023293623700737953, -0.015633033588528633, -0.0378422737121582, 0.021800577640533447, -0.05436775088310242, -0.020151007920503616, 0.08144291490316391, -0.023720379918813705, 0.018402474001049995, 0.051608212292194366, 0.010684438981115818, 0.013473852537572384, 0.04642864316701889, -0.023895837366580963, -0.018577752634882927, 0.04165409505367279, 0.027419529855251312, -0.005962830036878586, -0.007804008200764656, 0.033584509044885635, 0.014074834994971752, -0.002615043194964528, -0.06245845556259155, -0.023300383239984512, -0.036619849503040314, -0.02134566195309162, 0.007449066266417503, 0.01724492385983467, -0.008635847829282284, 0.039463210850954056, -0.005770849995315075, -0.00548787834122777, 0.05419062077999115, 0.07204342633485794, -0.03471076861023903, -0.009698583744466305, 0.019892927259206772, 0.08710694313049316, -0.06669581681489944, 0.04282623901963234, 0.05069832503795624, -0.013099638745188713, -0.0643242597579956, 0.058754775673151016, 0.020661387592554092, 0.10350298136472702, -0.004668405745178461, 0.03718118369579315, 0.020418791100382805, 0.051373422145843506, -0.039856862276792526, 0.04752860963344574, -0.01160150021314621, -0.047865625470876694, 0.017581451684236526, -0.0007253846852108836, 0.03419232368469238, 0.02530866116285324, 0.024698816239833832, -0.037636708468198776, -0.037126243114471436, 0.004764049779623747, 0.04554753378033638, -0.011245894245803356, -0.01710553467273712, 0.0698585957288742, -0.05105837062001228, 0.03590918704867363, -0.012792093679308891, 0.012180798687040806, -0.07673574239015579, -0.0026083362754434347, -0.011061829514801502, 0.004413381218910217, -0.0031279209069907665, 0.01886356621980667, 0.0006838049739599228, -0.049744825810194016, -0.020874857902526855, -0.01059059426188469, -0.09793020039796829, -0.013567103073000908, -0.011608131229877472, -0.03439221903681755, -0.07175298035144806, 0.038617949932813644, -0.07951148599386215, -0.038214899599552155, -0.019574297592043877, -0.0026909171137958765, 0.008878406137228012, 0.007807565852999687, 0.02909078076481819, -0.00732732517644763, -0.021698705852031708, -0.010006158612668514, 0.01728440821170807, -0.01758912205696106, 0.02941439300775528, 0.0643189325928688, 0.004951614420861006, 0.00011557638208614662, -0.012201675213873386, -0.015635373070836067, -0.009006737731397152, 0.018793916329741478, 0.048229120671749115, -0.0028310457710176706, 0.013865343295037746, -0.027349309995770454, 0.017807569354772568, -0.0024718130007386208, 0.01933131366968155, 0.02224242128431797, 0.006002918817102909, 0.029930058866739273, 0.024405628442764282, -0.01914515346288681, -0.04311949759721756, -0.029246458783745766, -0.037900786846876144, 0.030866310000419617, -0.03759745880961418, 0.059583209455013275, -0.0008039346430450678, -0.015318994410336018, 0.03764810040593147, -0.02947092242538929, -0.029825955629348755, -0.028591148555278778, -0.058669522404670715, -0.03545829653739929, -0.04094526916742325, 0.005879153963178396, -0.023996079340577126, 0.009948697872459888, 0.0581841804087162, 0.09367453306913376, -0.05859307944774628, 0.034844398498535156, -0.010849324986338615, -0.013015682809054852, 0.0664505884051323, 0.01332752127200365, 0.07867254316806793, -0.03563569113612175, 0.09142734110355377, -0.014051360078155994, -0.04696163535118103, -0.032342471182346344, -0.009813238866627216, 0.04432682693004608, -0.0008953728247433901, -0.058118123561143875, 0.03306398540735245, -0.059417665004730225, -0.003173608798533678, 0.013023079372942448, 0.07794898003339767, -0.02040465921163559, 0.01705865003168583, 0.04692418500781059, 0.00568808801472187, 0.025987518951296806, -0.006906332913786173, -0.001031229505315423, -0.05938462167978287, 0.04746817797422409, -0.04215233400464058, -0.0010086296824738383, -0.0020108590833842754, 0.01235998049378395, -0.0008359776111319661, 0.0016596773639321327, -0.003873242298141122, -0.000006498457878478803, -0.041447605937719345, -0.03282015025615692, -0.008743547834455967, 0.003201419487595558, -0.010960161685943604, 0.003044137265533209, 0.0025320290587842464, 0.027273541316390038, 0.03530558571219444, 0.03948088362812996, 0.025071468204259872, -0.027262147516012192, 0.06112760677933693, -0.02227044105529785, -0.031009871512651443, 0.010461872443556786, 0.04221297428011894, 0.023912323638796806, -0.021488480269908905, 0.012035330757498741, -0.05351509526371956, -0.05705370381474495, 0.010016671381890774, -0.05426832661032677, -0.007249784655869007, -0.026529723778367043, 0.0457395575940609, -0.02677297033369541, 0.006676409859210253, 0.03131688013672829, 0.007657989859580994, -0.013414532877504826, 0.009122658520936966, 0.014036068692803383, -0.05373983457684517, 0.021581165492534637, 0.07281267642974854, 0.029886238276958466, -0.005317294970154762, -0.02815798856317997, -0.02181403897702694, -0.04373951628804207, -0.03834383562207222, 0.06761434674263, -0.003961511887609959, -0.019223935902118683, -0.09127188473939896, -0.01773468777537346, -0.04595058038830757, -0.06911274790763855, 0.05447082594037056, 0.06767150014638901, -0.0270796287804842, 0.0006586630479432642, -0.001443045912310481, -0.015524931252002716, -0.02156679518520832, -0.07452286779880524, 0.03194067254662514, 0.036511387676000595, -0.0008566205506213009, -0.003646788652986288, -0.0280564296990633, 0.047304656356573105, 0.002589043229818344, 0.036968328058719635, -0.06759176403284073, 0.06437643617391586, -0.004640987142920494, 0.05010334774851799, -0.035900138318538666, -0.005280838347971439, -0.03992244228720665, 0.02235480025410652, -0.023805851116776466, -0.02569134160876274, 0.008988083340227604, -0.017593244090676308, -0.05825720727443695, 0.007833003997802734, 0.10443736612796783, -0.021772120147943497, -0.0037984519731253386, -0.008060554042458534, -0.003942796494811773, -0.035244569182395935, 0.05869832634925842, 0.010005843825638294, -0.027077041566371918, -0.016279829666018486, 0.01672366075217724, 0.016404205933213234, -0.01634819619357586, 0.0258285291492939, 0.011455358937382698, -0.018306205049157143, 0.05319157987833023, -0.009005863219499588, 0.021479832008481026, 0.004206972196698189, -0.0017558623803779483, 0.047441236674785614, -0.04853720963001251, -0.004021816421300173, -0.01781412772834301, -0.007758610881865025, -0.049407605081796646, -0.003475569887086749, 0.004759401082992554, 0.03679333254694939, -0.01018822006881237, -0.005566601175814867, -0.06361892074346542, 0.052683405578136444, -0.0030270025599747896, -0.033721040934324265, 0.0007550904992967844, 0.0056600989773869514, -0.031056903302669525, 0.06440892815589905, -0.018987810239195824, -0.01966271363198757, -0.030364608392119408, 0.011427611112594604, -0.04519195482134819, -0.057408079504966736, -0.007837900891900063, 0.012155712582170963, -0.03157941251993179, 0.03656480833888054, 0.07132185995578766, -0.022080842405557632, -0.013491357676684856, -0.015581868588924408, 0.07629331201314926, -0.021667465567588806, 0.02195972204208374, -0.019293352961540222, -0.029973041266202927, 0.00816058088093996, 0.05774383619427681, -0.006945759057998657, -0.04896315559744835, -0.013039053417742252, -0.03560337796807289, -0.0021653324365615845, -0.011028540320694447, 0.015741607174277306, 0.07399214059114456, -0.045047130435705185, -0.046583253890275955, 0.013277282007038593, 0.07507049292325974, -0.04098121449351311, 0.011183591559529305, -0.011445246636867523, -0.017146296799182892, 0.012563895434141159, 0.09229879081249237, -0.006079851184040308, 0.05742719769477844, -0.05515165627002716, 0.027269674465060234, -0.0895993560552597, -0.0026399740017950535, -0.02416040003299713, -0.04132888838648796, -0.01306979451328516, 0.009899376891553402, 0.025784485042095184, -0.017707061022520065, -0.016373243182897568, -0.01916288211941719, 0.006665777415037155, 0.011000319384038448, -0.005925596226006746, 0.02152772806584835, 0.03838285803794861, -0.009829736314713955, -0.037400227040052414, -0.019405560567975044, 0.027159681543707848, 0.000182906529516913, -0.05894544720649719, 0.00591666903346777, 0.03078051470220089, 0.043240971863269806, 0.02052346058189869, 0.0020870992448180914, 0.020403167232871056, 0.06487546116113663, 0.05681105703115463, -0.1001233384013176, 0.022629430517554283, 0.08642274886369705, 0.032143764197826385, -0.04806050658226013, -0.006960695143789053, -0.010669891722500324, -0.036061130464076996, 0.09219848364591599, -0.006557821296155453, 0.010075956583023071, 0.0548245906829834, 0.025482645258307457, 0.01787763088941574, 0.010872812010347843, -0.053315624594688416, 0.02243085578083992, 0.055464837700128555, 0.017861731350421906, -0.0355454683303833, -0.012031943537294865, -0.01101551204919815, -0.01712295040488243, -0.0397617369890213, 0.023218659684062004, -0.015643497928977013, 0.0014307934325188398, 0.02616311050951481, -0.02472629025578499, 0.05853744223713875, 0.06270399689674377, -0.03870313614606857, 0.021395592018961906, 0.03503793105483055, -0.021513115614652634, 0.0020751345437020063, 0.008137531578540802, 0.03368222713470459, -0.03576438128948212, -0.011734179221093655, -0.021335629746317863, -0.00001787075962056406, -0.03668978437781334, -0.017873911187052727, 0.07278691232204437, -0.03672333061695099, 0.009130594320595264, -0.05203903093934059, 0.05306736379861832, 0.01672358065843582, 0.002876646351069212, 0.03162261098623276, -0.0031215171329677105, 0.0649978443980217, -0.04223676770925522, -0.04192304611206055, 0.035207998007535934, 0.04319041594862938, 0.0018666294636204839, 0.04070521146059036, -0.046513572335243225, 0.035640597343444824, -0.01112157292664051, 0.044014863669872284, 0.02225378528237343, -0.008441693149507046, 0.0159603264182806, 0.04387512803077698, 0.03062048740684986, 0.10146977752447128, -0.017845720052719116, 0.011028221808373928, 0.03170667961239815, -0.04276809096336365, 0.051684387028217316, -0.008758990094065666, -0.054913394153118134, 0.002142906654626131, -0.07640595734119415, -0.019548770040273666, -0.01802693121135235, -0.01111264992505312, 0.00469998549669981, -0.024518724530935287, 0.006837641820311546, 0.021060150116682053, -0.04195992276072502, -0.028085416182875633, 0.053815681487321854, 0.021960288286209106, 0.050357576459646225, -0.03471287712454796, 0.022753356024622917, 0.034891728311777115, -0.043891772627830505, -0.005395501386374235, -0.023467810824513435, -0.04245859757065773, 0.06450919061899185, 0.0044746845960617065, -0.002975710667669773, 0.01715087890625, 0.013478411361575127, 0.043519798666238785, -0.025341695174574852, 0.0203264020383358, 0.007396876346319914, -0.0252609234303236, 0.008851354010403156, 0.043086692690849304, -0.019732089713215828, -0.01216915249824524, 0.044464945793151855, -0.06747785210609436, 0.014123312197625637, 0.01515658013522625, -0.028496837243437767, -0.06169499456882477, -0.0011735720327124, 0.03278838470578194, 0.002178469207137823, -0.033971454948186874, -0.027304839342832565, 0.05019721761345863, -0.04772553592920303, -0.033427391201257706, -0.002435625297948718, 0.03254445269703865, -0.00665760412812233, 0.030908335000276566, -0.026592539623379707, -0.023791151121258736, 0.01498126145452261, 0.009955385699868202, -0.03611494600772858, -0.029508154839277267, -0.02705398201942444, 0.012987244874238968, -0.0047601209953427315, 0.05741247162222862, -0.03959578648209572, -0.04112592339515686, 0.0032906965352594852, 0.03713383898139, -0.06655341386795044, -0.010685217566788197, -0.01328956801444292, -0.03597657382488251, -0.04074743390083313, -0.010251942090690136, -0.008935320191085339, -0.032332222908735275, -0.011640149168670177, -0.005744382739067078, -0.0560055635869503, -0.0509575679898262, 0.012425118125975132, -0.030570056289434433, 0.02735159359872341, 0.09754344820976257, 0.012017667293548584, 0.00920903030782938, -0.029029229655861855, 0.039958175271749496, 0.023171178996562958, -0.00627262843772769, 0.04122353345155716, -0.07755186408758163, 0.01587897725403309, -0.042036864906549454, 0.0461629256606102, -0.008404352702200413, -0.06464049965143204, -0.041972458362579346, 0.03746163845062256, 0.0076535711996257305, 0.03823917731642723, 0.0589287094771862, -0.03312596306204796, 0.006075975485146046, -0.03320971131324768, -0.0330536812543869, -0.05926525220274925, -0.04466613009572029, -0.0012082522734999657, -0.07263848930597305, 0.09549645334482193, -0.04889173433184624, -0.04333245009183884, 0.019210215657949448, 0.0227594543248415, 0.037938717752695084, -0.04050368070602417, 0.010253083892166615, -0.030085250735282898, 0.06785669922828674, -0.039212413132190704, 0.005303783342242241, 0.03322044014930725, -0.005842253100126982, -0.006390369031578302, -0.023400086909532547, 0.0218252781778574, 0.10337207466363907, -0.07338674366474152, -0.06192182004451752, -0.05298752337694168, 0.002736578928306699, 0.04183417186141014, 0.0020773038268089294, -0.02975667268037796, 0.055731821805238724, 0.061244189739227295, -0.018597165122628212, -0.025178736075758934, 0.003376018488779664, -0.03877586871385574, -0.022858629003167152, -0.03746794909238815, -0.04069938138127327, 0.04779670387506485, 0.018789231777191162, 0.007996582426130772, 0.010276996530592442, -0.019907981157302856, 0.01200568862259388, 0.02572770044207573, -0.014530462212860584, -0.007822171784937382, -0.009215866215527058, -0.0025733117945492268, 0.0007593693444505334, 0.05263078212738037, 0.009823395870625973, -0.0027649716939777136, 0.05700841173529625, 0.008480601012706757, -0.00019907974638044834, 0.004022074397653341, -0.04252633452415466, -0.06690587103366852, -0.0575982965528965, 0.027294309809803963, 0.02055417187511921, -0.019270099699497223, 0.007158253807574511, -0.018349524587392807, -0.010756192728877068, 0.018876710906624794, -0.05423089489340782, 0.00840204767882824, -0.01643085479736328, -0.05392071232199669, 0.00951648224145174, -0.01031055860221386, -0.02949916571378708, -0.013420904986560345, 0.014283113181591034, 0.022853387519717216, -0.01035994105041027, -0.005239030811935663, 0.048835087567567825, -0.06017792597413063, -0.03237265348434448, 0.020460061728954315, 0.05727685987949371, -0.008919971063733101, 0.01258932426571846, 0.08235613256692886, 0.027125976979732513, -0.03566509112715721, 0.012849993072450161, 0.0010080172214657068, 0.03818235173821449, 0.0008058708044700325, -0.03627431392669678, -0.06733908504247665, -0.09543924033641815, 0.01669847033917904, 0.0176869984716177, -0.06178838387131691, -0.039391353726387024, -0.005640208721160889, 0.00705861346796155, 0.027797071263194084, -0.005739251151680946, -0.0010150516172870994, 0.0010377323487773538, 0.009328625164926052 ]
<p>The last decades there has been a lot of research going on in the the area of three dimensional gravity. The motivation, I understand, is threefold:</p> <ol> <li><p>Whereas gravity is not perturbatively renormalizable in four spacetime dimensions, in three dimensions it is. To make it even more interesting it has black hole solutions and it is exactly solvable. This opens the way to to study quantum black holes. This make three dimensional gravity a very interesting system on itself.</p></li> <li><p>Through the AdS/CFT correspondence there is a connection between conformal field theories (CFT) in two dimensions and gravity in three dimensions. CFT's are important in condensed matter physics and one can use 3D gravity to learn more about them.</p></li> <li><p>Gravity in three dimensions is simpler to deal with then gravity in four dimensions. Therefor it can be used as a toy model for gravity in four dimensions. </p></li> </ol> <p>I am wondering what are the most important insights that 3d gravity brought in these respects? In particular I am interested in point three: did 3d gravity provide any new view on 4d gravity so far?</p>
g4239
[ 0.041279006749391556, 0.05247585475444794, 0.013543626293540001, -0.0176340751349926, 0.005085556302219629, 0.10792210698127747, 0.017559897154569626, -0.0073268841952085495, -0.05456829443573952, -0.029561500996351242, 0.03624500334262848, -0.03538298234343529, 0.04607091844081879, -0.01990918070077896, -0.02111000195145607, 0.03628888726234436, 0.03329513221979141, -0.006358350161463022, 0.01570790447294712, -0.045822277665138245, 0.08757545799016953, 0.004092330578714609, 0.03359411284327507, -0.06022581458091736, -0.08707470446825027, -0.008937269449234009, 0.022796180099248886, -0.027868885546922684, -0.007574936840683222, 0.02886785939335823, 0.056108515709638596, 0.0118594104424119, 0.022834882140159607, -0.03480369597673416, -0.03361992910504341, -0.03016076050698757, 0.05859312415122986, 0.0927499309182167, -0.06359827518463135, -0.022068917751312256, -0.048973213881254196, -0.0011269006645306945, -0.05435699597001076, 0.023887133225798607, -0.016747158020734787, -0.025826778262853622, -0.03797082602977753, -0.0019460839685052633, 0.045577045530080795, -0.030657852068543434, -0.0019571795128285885, 0.05548693984746933, 0.044638343155384064, -0.0061692302115261555, 0.028004320338368416, 0.010694198310375214, 0.004127385560423136, 0.014884482137858868, 0.03400629758834839, -0.0111460592597723, -0.06606630980968475, 0.04157143086194992, 0.039697542786598206, 0.0025572713930159807, 0.035582590848207474, -0.03520753234624863, -0.053461842238903046, 0.006277984473854303, 0.004616566933691502, -0.00940435379743576, 0.086720772087574, -0.01666576974093914, 0.03328787907958031, -0.01924942620098591, -0.039010848850011826, 0.03197504207491875, -0.009856012649834156, -0.027211802080273628, -0.07928789407014847, -0.03285736218094826, -0.015181510709226131, -0.04362686723470688, -0.04029655456542969, -0.02444365993142128, 0.10661647468805313, 0.012840677052736282, -0.0004765621852129698, 0.018941273912787437, 0.018212245777249336, 0.011459188535809517, -0.022233521565794945, 0.017719855532050133, 0.02757861837744713, 0.02515810914337635, -0.046511709690093994, 0.0006303345435298979, 0.040629904717206955, 0.010608265176415443, 0.011586343869566917, 0.04456664249300957, -0.04363114759325981, 0.035229459404945374, 0.05754666402935982, 0.04677773267030716, 0.010502273216843605, 0.03372473269701004, 0.07300564646720886, 0.06770574301481247, 0.03987085074186325, 0.00926146563142538, -0.054986126720905304, 0.01368042454123497, 0.007961583323776722, 0.01597360149025917, -0.0254169013351202, 0.02021205984055996, 0.0028455404099076986, -0.03975449502468109, 0.0298759788274765, 0.032030072063207626, 0.035207077860832214, 0.027637474238872528, 0.06635063141584396, 0.019717687740921974, 0.02239948697388172, -0.0014414760516956449, -0.02532319352030754, 0.02177530527114868, 0.01977897249162197, -0.00966991949826479, 0.019066715613007545, 0.003875759895890951, -0.018373144790530205, -0.021084249019622803, 0.04864995554089546, 0.020034128800034523, -0.03604581952095032, -0.01489268522709608, 0.008746073581278324, 0.040080055594444275, -0.04322819039225578, -0.08318950235843658, -0.03208212926983833, 0.03657687455415726, 0.020507648587226868, -0.0384678952395916, 0.025136016309261322, 0.02397936023771763, -0.029151756316423416, -0.0026746902149170637, 0.010808882303535938, 0.10859021544456482, 0.04864567518234253, -0.08304019272327423, -0.02109154686331749, 0.007457125466316938, -0.04799145087599754, -0.02575131319463253, -0.0000507213371747639, -0.04392720386385918, -0.007890406996011734, 0.004609501454979181, -0.012612171471118927, 0.016965121030807495, -0.017910338938236237, 0.023639658465981483, 0.08044713735580444, -0.07642930001020432, 0.01035693846642971, 0.008924947120249271, -0.07402846962213516, 0.01848582737147808, 0.005309719126671553, 0.0028296553064137697, -0.0228604506701231, -0.008502560667693615, -0.03891487419605255, -0.03631361573934555, -0.005177723243832588, -0.0480465404689312, -0.0029615743551403284, -0.05540194362401962, -0.04977700859308243, 0.028388669714331627, -0.046925611793994904, 0.05497672036290169, 0.04236792400479317, -0.011881963349878788, 0.01206165924668312, 0.0322657972574234, -0.07250750064849854, 0.05733462795615196, 0.0014160479186102748, 0.025620223954319954, -0.03453812748193741, 0.0002825968840625137, 0.06372418254613876, 0.014531110413372517, -0.008282605558633804, -0.02092112973332405, -0.010213438421487808, -0.010107525624334812, 0.043418675661087036, 0.03186572715640068, 0.0037899597082287073, 0.010777164250612259, -0.03208258002996445, 0.017314165830612183, 0.017938798293471336, 0.016834355890750885, -0.011830081231892109, 0.026480987668037415, 0.0831933468580246, -0.011340812779963017, 0.042311131954193115, 0.07567543536424637, -0.00037201750092208385, 0.033229563385248184, -0.029186664149165154, 0.05167112499475479, -0.03150379657745361, -0.0077161360532045364, -0.003918961156159639, -0.028260601684451103, -0.020535413175821304, -0.028843678534030914, -0.034723374992609024, 0.005317626986652613, 0.012731735594570637, 0.02568828873336315, -0.07024208456277847, -0.0077588967978954315, -0.002783286850899458, 0.041766732931137085, 0.04591137543320656, 0.02966918610036373, -0.02445427142083645, -0.0900261253118515, 0.02652690000832081, 0.0400591678917408, 0.06347081810235977, 0.06071307510137558, -0.007719329558312893, -0.0533931627869606, 0.081724613904953, -0.015544652938842773, 0.0021968912333250046, -0.01026859600096941, -0.04315147176384926, -0.003686056239530444, -0.00010964983084704727, 0.04507717862725258, -0.05006339028477669, -0.02175493910908699, -0.015516020357608795, 0.022431958466768265, 0.0387251079082489, 0.026074275374412537, -0.044389817863702774, -0.0494949109852314, 0.04082478582859039, -0.007906251586973667, -0.0012238358613103628, 0.04763909801840782, -0.036251697689294815, -0.013449440710246563, 0.0052610221318900585, 0.0010712924413383007, -0.022602887824177742, -0.00248444895260036, -0.05136756971478462, -0.0037862351164221764, 0.004916810430586338, -0.04996464028954506, -0.04727879911661148, -0.0019490487175062299, -0.012083842419087887, 0.0018593863351270556, -0.025170162320137024, -0.034272078424692154, 0.0025317424442619085, -0.039328187704086304, -0.049185723066329956, -0.01193930022418499, 0.030143456533551216, 0.010164259932935238, -0.00836778525263071, -0.04024546965956688, -0.016362454742193222, 0.013444298878312111, 0.03696277737617493, 0.016514834016561508, -0.032835446298122406, -0.010400661267340183, -0.0030057032126933336, -0.04423285648226738, -0.04686584696173668, -0.004251288250088692, -0.007964374497532845, -0.0018951630918309093, 0.007712674792855978, 0.0291074737906456, 0.009590641595423222, -0.0036349003203213215, 0.028131816536188126, -0.032997433096170425, -0.016589052975177765, 0.015540442429482937, 0.00851286668330431, -0.0191496554762125, -0.05921698734164238, -0.026658421382308006, 0.018161365762352943, 0.015921561047434807, -0.06468094140291214, -0.05762931704521179, 0.0018280328949913383, 0.04733598977327347, 0.010681710205972195, -0.03728444129228592, 0.025488583371043205, 0.0038418907206505537, -0.054507967084646225, -0.06240059435367584, 0.046294551342725754, 0.0830405056476593, 0.013692873530089855, -0.004716970957815647, -0.012353789992630482, 0.033952925354242325, -0.03295135498046875, -0.031093981117010117, -0.006229714024811983, 0.026808660477399826, -0.043841950595378876, 0.005927161779254675, -0.05693492665886879, 0.01364782266318798, 0.07269659638404846, -0.08073462545871735, 0.03807806223630905, -0.024260669946670532, -0.028306186199188232, -0.02975575067102909, 0.030064178630709648, 0.004440430086106062, 0.007681575138121843, 0.01831810735166073, 0.024826079607009888, -0.030137136578559875, 0.008552271872758865, 0.012588433921337128, 0.028522789478302002, -0.0008283142815344036, 0.041955702006816864, 0.01549840159714222, -0.014610862359404564, 0.06172029301524162, -0.046714551746845245, -0.0025396221317350864, -0.05919705703854561, -0.026538116857409477, 0.007345318794250488, 0.04335910454392433, -0.01707632467150688, -0.025247061625123024, 0.03571544587612152, -0.047216325998306274, -0.007215200923383236, 0.010280448012053967, 0.03648578003048897, -0.0277955774217844, 0.002282205503433943, -0.008663066662847996, 0.0728992223739624, -0.030267348513007164, -0.009911797940731049, -0.00995701178908348, -0.04254297539591789, -0.01730346865952015, 0.013656798750162125, -0.000255068443948403, 0.03268185630440712, 0.010618758387863636, -0.032977961003780365, -0.020991941913962364, -0.018770921975374222, -0.029179513454437256, -0.07533156126737595, -0.02025037631392479, -0.030453266575932503, 0.022895988076925278, -0.029170099645853043, 0.002327256603166461, -0.02507088892161846, -0.0043232678435742855, 0.010470044799149036, -0.002913760719820857, 0.028795046731829643, -0.04067780822515488, -0.03375401347875595, -0.007683224510401487, -0.017365600913763046, 0.04927155748009682, -0.06500495970249176, -0.01883196085691452, 0.03991255164146423, 0.007208604831248522, 0.038868024945259094, 0.00044117501238361, -0.025786662474274635, 0.006125475279986858, 6.695231604680885e-7, -0.050048619508743286, 0.023024199530482292, -0.0844634622335434, -0.023087162524461746, -0.0023990082554519176, 0.034464988857507706, 0.02139955386519432, 0.09328775852918625, 0.007650751154869795, 0.01210173312574625, 0.013509456999599934, 0.04923784360289574, 0.02329387702047825, 0.0406385213136673, -0.015402836725115776, -0.0888013243675232, 0.058251723647117615, 0.05775707587599754, -0.013993827626109123, -0.029772663488984108, 0.0251564159989357, -0.01717201992869377, -0.006315684411674738, -0.05102032050490379, 0.015462977811694145, -0.06487564742565155, -0.0018154927529394627, 0.051295097917318344, 0.04692736640572548, -0.019250042736530304, -0.024310177192091942, 0.016808588057756424, 0.010990015231072903, -0.031641993671655655, 0.016242679208517075, -0.006396191194653511, 0.03690732270479202, 0.01477163564413786, -0.01836862787604332, -0.010762961581349373, 0.003791209077462554, -0.03549627587199211, 0.012495109811425209, -0.011387147009372711, -0.0040942649357020855, 0.022292299196124077, 0.010029633529484272, -0.06645231693983078, 0.003086487064138055, -0.03642899543046951, -0.004283982329070568, -0.0045936391688883305, -0.0436607301235199, -0.03326416015625, -0.021625488996505737, -0.0479661226272583, -0.03750202804803848, 0.02719375677406788, -0.00012443767627701163, -0.009018385782837868, 0.006543860305100679, -0.032501596957445145, 0.03176213055849075, 0.029632942751049995, -0.014612962491810322, 0.025534613057971, -0.06207680702209473, 0.06751395761966705, -0.07461772114038467, 0.07122275233268738, 0.043669722974300385, -0.01936270110309124, -0.01467170100659132, -0.07576901465654373, 0.00578022887930274, -0.08252836018800735, -0.015077645890414715, 0.005949714221060276, -0.026931343600153923, -0.021911496296525, 0.004182963166385889, -0.10837595164775848, 0.02310933731496334, -0.010376768186688423, -0.010861549526453018, -0.014197339303791523, -0.03316006064414978, -0.026280734688043594, 0.008317177183926105, 0.06599865108728409, -0.02061288431286812, -0.013136463239789009, 0.041085295379161835, 0.04947000741958618, -0.09239044785499573, 0.006614575162529945, 0.014559663832187653, -0.0833992138504982, -0.0511014349758625, -0.05586880072951317, 0.024780750274658203, 0.04327112063765526, -0.0004158600640948862, 0.018822604790329933, 0.011019225232303143, 0.053199321031570435, 0.02971862442791462, -0.0335228331387043, -0.03552691265940666, 0.0019189071608707309, -0.02168365940451622, 0.09349340945482254, -0.010166199877858162, -0.003727374132722616, 0.04098360240459442, 0.04546193778514862, -0.021797718480229378, 0.013104204088449478, 0.009392434731125832, 0.05042436718940735, 0.009240704588592052, -0.02720510959625244, -0.0006577108870260417, 0.046746451407670975, 0.07040263712406158, 0.10060542821884155, -0.010931883938610554, -0.06667877733707428, 0.00969591923058033, -0.0841645896434784, 0.071492038667202, -0.024623466655611992, -0.0339369960129261, -0.008287898264825344, -0.018278010189533234, 0.03676416724920273, -0.04719044640660286, -0.013875169679522514, -0.028010737150907516, -0.018925290554761887, 0.026104899123311043, 0.01025320217013359, -0.019332174211740494, -0.048367828130722046, -0.013572581112384796, -0.04735259711742401, -0.05966773256659508, -0.030005859211087227, 0.012054048478603363, 0.018912408500909805, -0.0347524993121624, -0.0495297908782959, -0.011605081148445606, -0.04606372490525246, -0.02889784798026085, 0.01022803969681263, -0.007522535976022482, -0.04989894479513168, -0.0015343830455094576, 0.0073693664744496346, 0.07128877192735672, -0.009321973659098148, -0.030092090368270874, 0.05418279394507408, 0.005581353325396776, -0.050641320645809174, -0.02963997796177864, 0.023719632998108864, 0.018908947706222534, 0.06728427857160568, -0.06656774133443832, -0.015407642349600792, 0.04565159231424332, 0.010084766894578934, -0.020719274878501892, -0.018833132460713387, -0.07046686857938766, 0.004715902730822563, 0.01716485247015953, 0.011405149474740028, 0.00164713931735605, 0.005925158970057964, -0.02059902809560299, 0.035580698400735855, 0.027844050899147987, -0.044885143637657166, -0.025556866079568863, 0.0008278831955976784, 0.06367705017328262, -0.018545685335993767, 0.026745948940515518, -0.031150583177804947, 0.04638039693236351, -0.026816830039024353, -0.07260064780712128, 0.05265729874372482, 0.038969773799180984, 0.027909383177757263, 0.01761120930314064, -0.04724489897489548, 0.07104413956403732, 0.01648680306971073, 0.012016233056783676, 0.04207728058099747, -0.029042188078165054, 0.036633219569921494, -0.0077388412319123745, 0.04988785460591316, -0.02276281639933586, 0.032511044293642044, -0.019462252035737038, 0.023316144943237305, 0.033071137964725494, -0.03864680230617523, -0.004924330860376358, -0.011103781871497631, 0.04680126905441284, -0.01833675429224968, -0.02496027573943138, 0.011390365660190582, 0.09145703911781311, 0.016132693737745285, -0.016792776063084602, -0.018678564578294754, -0.02463337779045105, -0.0031521967612206936, 0.005532956216484308, -0.046838030219078064, -0.048023153096437454, 0.03482912853360176, 0.0075298091396689415, -0.03229483962059021, 0.0331253707408905, -0.0013439820613712072, 0.0435410737991333, -0.027613205835223198, 0.04091854766011238, -0.009180624037981033, -0.027143847197294235, 0.02840471640229225, -0.007082010619342327, -0.024893956258893013, 0.012055465951561928, -0.032084036618471146, 0.05805592983961105, 0.02312455326318741, -0.03714791312813759, -0.0433693565428257, -0.0022826322820037603, -0.03367195650935173, 0.015270181000232697, -0.008002446964383125, 0.027376864105463028, 0.003707463387399912, -0.013545135967433453, 0.023210719227790833, 0.009935427457094193, 0.00919125135987997, -0.012903088703751564, -0.016519492492079735, 0.028705600649118423, -0.0453946478664875, 0.014879230409860611, -0.0015164167853072286, 0.03867732733488083, 0.02354731410741806, 0.036228954792022705, -0.047881316393613815, 0.07862187922000885, -0.007313578389585018, 0.02577604539692402, -0.04388072341680527, -0.005218892358243465, 0.026997189968824387, 0.030766168609261513, -0.08214053511619568, 0.023562628775835037, 0.01610414870083332, 0.021581172943115234, -0.007864424958825111, -0.012485843151807785, -0.0350123830139637, 0.017501769587397575, 0.016020024195313454, 0.009514630772173405, 0.05130968242883682, 0.08031526952981949, -0.020021691918373108, -0.04450298473238945, -0.003961645998060703, -0.06892336159944534, 0.0235655065625906, -0.03393201157450676, 0.014664498157799244, -0.03203686326742172, -0.027263402938842773, 0.05411682650446892, -0.012985456734895706, 0.014018133282661438, 0.041943296790122986, 0.003730322467163205, 0.022419998422265053, 0.0327627994120121, -0.01961516961455345, 0.011424615047872066, -0.016755051910877228, -0.035258516669273376, 0.013920131139457226, -0.008467024192214012, -0.03907661885023117, -0.03555867075920105, -0.028002003207802773, 0.033942900598049164, -0.021462833508849144, -0.02757672592997551, 0.023662155494093895, 0.02019602246582508, -0.015886425971984863, 0.0011663958430290222, -0.03608184680342674, 0.03175780549645424, -0.0070466548204422, 0.09649176150560379, 0.04829547554254532, -0.006695170421153307, 0.009267929010093212, -0.010338547639548779, -0.007927334867417812, 0.06176787242293358, 0.008398380130529404, -0.0403219573199749, 0.006261247675865889, -0.041083820164203644, -0.014049944467842579, 0.027646701782941818, 0.00035767152439802885, -0.004502494819462299, -0.002048531314358115, 0.05532318726181984, 0.018431134521961212, 0.008796132169663906, 0.01638275757431984, 0.009923304431140423, 0.005088170059025288, -0.010117663070559502, 0.019396990537643433, -0.023524651303887367, 0.01214428711682558, 0.04776184633374214, 0.06929898262023926, 0.014324333518743515, 0.0012198607437312603, -0.02730579487979412, 0.023596633225679398, 0.05163523182272911 ]
<p>I'm trying to get motivated in learning the Atiyah-Singer index theorem. In most places I read about it, e.g. wikipedia, it is mentioned that the theorem is important in theoretical physics. So my question is, what are some examples of these applications?</p>
g4240
[ 0.01643991284072399, 0.03528941422700882, 0.009426314383745193, -0.0020185403991490602, 0.020750120282173157, -0.050276052206754684, -0.03025004453957081, 0.0022393660619854927, -0.014916417188942432, 0.031664058566093445, -0.03952080383896828, 0.021975422278046608, 0.06636188179254532, 0.011367701925337315, -0.023526092991232872, -0.026824627071619034, 0.026185788214206696, 0.05468795821070671, 0.03192989155650139, 0.01304133515805006, -0.0015258914791047573, 0.001736892038024962, -0.006405996158719063, -0.032113902270793915, 0.012853302992880344, 0.0021943554747849703, 0.05959552526473999, -0.025660838931798935, -0.03820764273405075, 0.019992129877209663, -0.006740375887602568, -0.037113551050424576, 0.049904145300388336, -0.055933743715286255, -0.0035229618661105633, -0.04898993670940399, 0.03386540338397026, -0.024140823632478714, 0.07112861424684525, -0.002006737282499671, 0.011986392550170422, -0.0103466110303998, 0.006352186668664217, 0.045502301305532455, -0.002110727597028017, 0.021854383870959282, -0.03302464634180069, -0.005841181613504887, -0.008450000546872616, -0.0014737066812813282, 0.037251658737659454, 0.03845802694559097, 0.058266531676054, 0.04823867976665497, 0.04233232140541077, -0.05777750909328461, -0.011415145359933376, -0.015163322910666466, 0.09595987945795059, -0.014355185441672802, -0.011012068949639797, 0.04602382332086563, -0.0071865106001496315, 0.004878115374594927, 0.03689464181661606, 0.009077021852135658, 0.03323153406381607, 0.00361598446033895, -0.00277994223870337, 0.044239915907382965, 0.07801446318626404, 0.008571650832891464, 0.10338421165943146, 0.017211144790053368, -0.07665275782346725, -0.004475447814911604, -0.021445374935865402, -0.033969223499298096, -0.03524190932512283, 0.04222256690263748, -0.058346621692180634, -0.027226734906435013, 0.032098762691020966, -0.03849909454584122, 0.03422795236110687, -0.024371793493628502, 0.004617161583155394, 0.06917083263397217, -0.020369045436382294, -0.025481313467025757, 0.04967838153243065, 0.025173407047986984, -0.028104271739721298, -0.0504484549164772, 0.004051046445965767, 0.06234661862254143, -0.0036792028695344925, 0.009342831559479237, -0.037370841950178146, 0.048376910388469696, -0.03410226106643677, 0.05704471468925476, 0.07064653933048248, 0.011537139303982258, 0.008504563011229038, -0.0024053289089351892, 0.06397455930709839, -0.03988281637430191, 0.024643205106258392, 0.04713702201843262, 0.0018939381698146462, 0.005556968040764332, -0.037266723811626434, 0.00023282130132429302, -0.05095386505126953, 0.027356212958693504, 0.03687305748462677, -0.040323201566934586, -0.030012527480721474, 0.03532141447067261, 0.03136761859059334, 0.04855066165328026, 0.027576325461268425, -0.032754186540842056, -0.0008528659236617386, 0.025469791144132614, -0.010731714777648449, 0.0019982035737484694, -0.05125866457819939, -0.033430926501750946, 0.036009281873703, -0.062002647668123245, -0.026624934747815132, -0.012918809428811073, 0.012063262984156609, 0.05181172862648964, -0.020451214164495468, -0.01109349075704813, 0.008568010292947292, -0.029969511553645134, 0.04385994374752045, 0.0015389759792014956, -0.08917751908302307, 0.020721787586808205, 0.018925385549664497, 0.011608383618295193, -0.006391088478267193, 0.009538226760923862, -0.06867072731256485, 0.03686802461743355, -0.05465294420719147, 0.0818166583776474, 0.014359746128320694, -0.01444518007338047, 0.037099339067935944, 0.003973659593611956, 0.01207900233566761, -0.0450269989669323, 0.041366249322891235, -0.018345292657613754, 0.017189841717481613, -0.007396013010293245, -0.0009958267910405993, 0.03376925736665726, 0.013595632277429104, -0.010283193551003933, 0.051007337868213654, -0.04380703717470169, 0.005051896441727877, 0.013104202225804329, -0.03518987074494362, 0.02660105936229229, 0.04889669641852379, 0.0744435116648674, 0.03689608722925186, 0.01423864159733057, -0.01869397982954979, 0.001968368887901306, 0.02797514945268631, 0.022716274484992027, 0.020397355780005455, -0.08592813462018967, -0.0028403664473444223, -0.008058827370405197, -0.03256290405988693, -0.030134713277220726, 0.013552776537835598, -0.009427066892385483, -0.12605322897434235, 0.029352648183703423, -0.02215113490819931, 0.07575193047523499, -0.022126326337456703, 0.04622465744614601, -0.05535893887281418, -0.09135842323303223, 0.020697902888059616, -0.008493677712976933, -0.03428024426102638, -0.047250110656023026, -0.015782712027430534, -0.020599283277988434, 0.06900830566883087, 0.012205972336232662, -0.039723120629787445, 0.07204607129096985, -0.022397072985768318, -0.06695844978094101, -0.009348121471703053, 0.018438192084431648, 0.039124198257923126, -0.016539499163627625, 0.07329956442117691, 0.05494534224271774, 0.014249105006456375, 0.04943442717194557, -0.038733478635549545, -0.026450052857398987, 0.04274877905845642, -0.021092038601636887, -0.015253237448632717, -0.06479442864656448, -0.019511543214321136, 0.03377531096339226, -0.03311104327440262, 0.01420474424958229, 0.010568841360509396, 0.021914957091212273, 0.015868613496422768, -0.03938272222876549, -0.06503922492265701, -0.0033489845227450132, 0.024427758529782295, 0.00919585395604372, 0.05065445974469185, -0.007212348282337189, -0.0005454507772810757, -0.013151634484529495, 0.06557989120483398, 0.07035703957080841, -0.01726466231048107, -0.02643623761832714, 0.019611487165093422, -0.002295651938766241, -0.016819622367620468, -0.031518056988716125, 0.01719089411199093, -0.1000974178314209, 0.009272417053580284, 0.02342282421886921, -0.0025937571190297604, -0.030971314758062363, -0.0035551374312490225, 0.012110439129173756, 0.013275119476020336, -0.028337402269244194, 0.027728065848350525, -0.023388812318444252, 0.0350310318171978, -0.029860181733965874, 0.02610614337027073, -0.038575489073991776, 0.0008667227812111378, -0.04884818196296692, -0.06369166821241379, -0.04169444367289543, -0.04166755825281143, -0.030244439840316772, -0.022193968296051025, -0.014221415854990482, -0.0030461447313427925, -0.0005656525027006865, -0.014518912881612778, -0.002749909181147814, 0.031341467052698135, 0.01368476077914238, 0.0537046380341053, -0.03854125365614891, 0.01567520759999752, -0.003728354349732399, 0.014518341049551964, -0.05005190148949623, -0.0598139613866806, 0.023638499900698662, 0.02593754045665264, -0.05754011124372482, -0.016953477635979652, -0.009485696442425251, -0.032132066786289215, -0.006212357897311449, 0.011516720056533813, -0.013889381662011147, 0.04209005460143089, 0.033991653472185135, -0.019801028072834015, -0.019726507365703583, 0.028510676696896553, -0.017283810302615166, -0.016488052904605865, -0.0212260689586401, 0.027966106310486794, -0.02236711047589779, 0.05259110778570175, -0.0662529245018959, 0.014520418830215931, 0.000983365229330957, -0.03520054742693901, -0.02911999821662903, 0.0011140818241983652, 0.012544584460556507, -0.018412452191114426, -0.007305690553039312, 0.026736753061413765, 0.04512038826942444, -0.019053755328059196, -0.022308411076664925, 0.04604184255003929, 0.03292251378297806, 0.06213962659239769, -0.05729372054338455, 0.04321588575839996, -0.0047997417859733105, 0.025923900306224823, -0.02906407229602337, 0.013420067727565765, 0.001347390585578978, -0.013263587839901447, -0.029666341841220856, 0.05171491205692291, -0.045865222811698914, 0.04194411635398865, -0.00533634377643466, -0.0036212140694260597, -0.05123204365372658, -0.09406065940856934, -0.07400370389223099, -0.014278282411396503, 0.006650380324572325, 0.002537438180297613, 0.025041798129677773, 0.02637309394776821, -0.041578516364097595, -0.022583801299333572, -0.017665725201368332, -0.006314502097666264, -0.021601932123303413, 0.07140012830495834, 0.046843405812978745, 0.06189112737774849, -0.046864356845617294, -0.010522691532969475, -0.03581380099058151, 0.019632428884506226, -0.029687564820051193, -0.05256957560777664, 0.004446430131793022, 0.06157288700342178, 0.0016550729051232338, 0.012386694550514221, 0.025407923385500908, -0.0007774396217428148, 0.047146718949079514, 0.032290395349264145, 0.061578407883644104, -0.009174929931759834, 0.0023264745250344276, -0.02786524035036564, 0.01732320711016655, -0.061219461262226105, -0.021480897441506386, 0.014198711141943932, -0.027525901794433594, -0.011649541556835175, -0.037759482860565186, -0.030032403767108917, -0.006756246089935303, -0.04460269212722778, 0.02518526092171669, 0.006859378423541784, 0.0608549565076828, 0.012646527960896492, 0.05987180396914482, 0.04043620452284813, 0.016485294327139854, 0.03467417508363724, -0.07989184558391571, -0.03373159095644951, 0.019561810418963432, 0.01534044835716486, 0.007049140054732561, 0.031186524778604507, -0.011671999469399452, -0.00858385767787695, 0.014167637564241886, 0.021926434710621834, -0.04802846163511276, -0.012698831968009472, -0.013054555281996727, 0.04946912080049515, 0.037381019443273544, -0.016803856939077377, -0.06276702880859375, -0.032738227397203445, 0.008455564267933369, 0.04202388599514961, -0.007133031263947487, 0.05266822129487991, 0.0008138599805533886, -0.039837684482336044, -0.037046708166599274, -0.03058077022433281, 0.0009872574592009187, -0.02314305119216442, -0.027478814125061035, 0.023715896531939507, 0.018269047141075134, -0.01899583823978901, -0.05861597880721092, -0.019139489158988, 0.0041354866698384285, 0.0005203694454394281, 0.049302637577056885, 0.01342824287712574, -0.05146349221467972, -0.000007995653504622169, 0.085520438849926, 0.04268953204154968, 0.027940798550844193, 0.06417626887559891, -0.013790304772555828, 0.040036484599113464, -0.017179742455482483, 0.009044962003827095, -0.002242856426164508, 0.004965603351593018, 0.03137777000665665, -0.005652094725519419, 0.01583019644021988, -0.06967400014400482, 0.0020969060715287924, 0.07726249098777771, 0.019614912569522858, -0.046449434012174606, 0.010122020728886127, -0.04686002805829048, -0.008889326825737953, -0.06776808947324753, 0.039543792605400085, -0.05395473912358284, -0.036645084619522095, -0.04520247131586075, 0.0066715930588543415, -0.0011770715937018394, -0.060151584446430206, -0.020981576293706894, -0.04809216782450676, -0.009892472065985203, 0.028410043567419052, 0.09159478545188904, 0.02571859210729599, -0.015818992629647255, 0.0020772486459463835, -0.03366662189364433, 0.000962035555858165, 0.028067080304026604, 0.009087089449167252, -0.04364462569355965, 0.015678755939006805, -0.002821835922077298, -0.04412943124771118, -0.03569679334759712, 0.00247958698309958, 0.011628666892647743, 0.004585313145071268, 0.003925153519958258, 0.013276933692395687, -0.05718187615275383, 0.034045059233903885, -0.01140211708843708, -0.07324086874723434, -0.037330176681280136, 0.004976506344974041, 0.026119351387023926, 0.006390775553882122, -0.0485880970954895, -0.06538193672895432, -0.06325452774763107, 0.017472688108682632, -0.03440375253558159, -0.0487290658056736, 0.028869403526186943, -0.00863350834697485, 0.050556786358356476, 0.013634168542921543, -0.024235224351286888, -0.07268565148115158, 0.006372959353029728, -0.029689986258745193, -0.06684346497058868, -0.03188244625926018, 0.012242252938449383, 0.0018870641943067312, -0.023951537907123566, 0.015513465739786625, 0.002427118131890893, 0.017563998699188232, 0.0011375343892723322, -0.02691664919257164, -0.0034643951803445816, 0.012903088703751564, 0.030025331303477287, 0.05360644683241844, 0.022113554179668427, -0.0466056726872921, 0.074552021920681, 0.02392624132335186, 0.01990802399814129, -0.006465202197432518, -0.01609824039041996, -0.03683338686823845, 0.03458240628242493, -0.021675284951925278, 0.0363796092569828, -0.010825623758137226, 0.07309214770793915, -0.02003544569015503, -0.010600447654724121, 0.048483166843652725, -0.04903377592563629, -0.0462091825902462, 0.02724170871078968, -0.037917036563158035, -0.03024677000939846, -0.020698245614767075, -0.0027483042795211077, 0.012065958231687546, -0.015461936593055725, 0.042002808302640915, -0.0037289177998900414, 0.03410116210579872, -0.050195783376693726, -0.02307778410613537, 0.009728588163852692, -0.02403094992041588, 0.00036282953806221485, -0.009677708148956299, 0.006365607026964426, -0.007790041156113148, 0.0666690394282341, -0.003252403810620308, -0.0316602997481823, 0.018382500857114792, -0.034755975008010864, -0.03349429368972778, -0.05570801720023155, -0.02821376733481884, -0.008425946347415447, -0.00530271464958787, 0.027435338124632835, 0.0025879431050270796, 0.029948705807328224, 0.03421778976917267, -0.003503394080325961, -0.010837115347385406, 0.0010135119082406163, 0.0001869377156253904, 0.006004003807902336, 0.04312272369861603, 0.043323323130607605, 0.022032249718904495, -0.033543605357408524, -0.02455521933734417, 0.03115231543779373, 0.012875732034444809, -0.0030684678349643946, 0.032756637781858444, -0.016911542043089867, -0.041151825338602066, 0.020775139331817627, -0.048027608543634415, 0.02296452969312668, -0.008579377084970474, 0.056658096611499786, -0.08123554289340973, -0.004315973725169897, 0.008744340389966965, -0.02354084700345993, -0.04408732056617737, 0.01747721992433071, -0.03547219932079315, -0.0572831891477108, -0.0003161620406899601, -0.05075966566801071, -0.018678907305002213, -0.005245233420282602, -0.0235882680863142, 0.028704345226287842, 0.016698701307177544, -0.044654522091150284, 0.001757920952513814, -0.02245345339179039, -0.02686607651412487, 0.07484621554613113, -0.0017770652193576097, -0.03696943819522858, 0.07006858289241791, 0.03143114224076271, -0.01702975481748581, 0.018438193947076797, 0.016551712527871132, -0.04260415956377983, 0.05489809811115265, -0.018778789788484573, 0.04539713263511658, 0.03246957063674927, -0.01628687046468258, 0.02848966419696808, 0.00883515179157257, 0.005136093124747276, -0.05870344862341881, 0.016096917912364006, -0.06233929097652435, 0.03529643267393112, -0.040608957409858704, -0.015815548598766327, -0.007006039377301931, -0.005741785280406475, 0.0759129673242569, -0.009695760905742645, 0.035086676478385925, 0.012312273494899273, -0.007390742190182209, 0.05933951213955879, -0.02870941162109375, -0.0135548310354352, 0.029635990038514137, -0.016539210453629494, 0.018462909385561943, 0.07738234102725983, 0.03498101234436035, -0.05565411597490311, 0.041728533804416656, 0.008107815869152546, -0.005748397670686245, 0.019073912873864174, 0.00368630257435143, 0.013070158660411835, 0.016676491126418114, -0.08393974602222443, -0.015962205827236176, 0.010610336437821388, -0.038466185331344604, -0.06389012932777405, 0.023876551538705826, -0.039055708795785904, 0.002233363687992096, -0.018104277551174164, -0.04101254418492317, 0.05289847403764725, -0.003947421442717314, 0.001372127328068018, 0.05180950462818146, 0.06033717468380928, 0.0008962387219071388, -0.027358783408999443, 0.047533392906188965, 0.04496496170759201, -0.0900292843580246, -0.012720244005322456, 0.041050512343645096, 0.011483835987746716, -0.03681501746177673, -0.06973966956138611, -0.011929951608181, 0.0018185288645327091, -0.04032965004444122, -0.04455484077334404, 0.042978741228580475, -0.03949141129851341, -0.04662381112575531, -0.003621168900281191, 0.053670771420001984, 0.039837952703237534, -0.045305706560611725, 0.010937764309346676, 0.0392601378262043, -0.048004042357206345, 0.030115511268377304, 0.017468931153416634, -0.04135121405124664, -0.011306583881378174, -0.04935930669307709, -0.0065478370524942875, -0.06118664890527725, 0.04668041691184044, 0.0029817502945661545, 0.012166168540716171, 0.012510371394455433, -0.0003731880569830537, 0.05510486662387848, -0.00643571000546217, 0.0005796876503154635, 0.02192147821187973, -0.04044103994965553, 0.084217369556427, -0.020443415269255638, 0.022711459547281265, -0.025400668382644653, -0.026952868327498436, -0.040893055498600006, -0.01650175452232361, 0.0072898040525615215, 0.03467577323317528, 0.019950537011027336, 0.04829401150345802, -0.042971596121788025, -0.05764634162187576, 0.004202529788017273, -0.02482752501964569, 0.0778946802020073, 0.04390306770801544, -0.011514842510223389, 0.06288015097379684, -0.0012022876180708408, -0.05149870738387108, 0.0013408539816737175, -0.02439650148153305, 0.04013604298233986, -0.02183331549167633, 0.02191329374909401, -0.0414913110435009, -0.014539510011672974, -0.027471641078591347, 0.04852799326181412, -0.034529637545347214, 0.00808069109916687, 0.08283261209726334, -0.021171394735574722, 0.03015965409576893, 0.014155182987451553, -0.03588381037116051, -0.01895199716091156, 0.03778362274169922, -0.06532484292984009, 0.05506359040737152, -0.026150546967983246, -0.008475042879581451, 0.006509601138532162, 0.028714079409837723, 0.006360333412885666, -0.03103206865489483, 0.065960593521595, 0.039976272732019424, 0.071372851729393, -0.009676314890384674, 0.02316623367369175, -0.00028651620959863067, 0.002041431376710534, 0.0498918816447258, 0.026644598692655563, 0.03508077934384346, 0.024016324430704117, -0.02791452407836914, -0.008233754895627499, -0.038677509874105453, -0.05275972560048103, 0.019292397424578667, -0.020933030173182487 ]
<p>Why is the critical point for the phase diagram of pure water degrees of freedom equal to 0? Maybe, you know what is the mathematical explanation for the fact that the number of degrees of freedom at the critical point is 0? What else is affected by the lack of degrees of freedom in addition to the Gibbs phase rule? </p>
g4241
[ 0.0459502749145031, 0.026337018236517906, 0.02612914890050888, 0.029487591236829758, 0.0591481551527977, 0.013413899578154087, 0.014989446848630905, 0.03612764924764633, 0.027905143797397614, -0.03913131728768349, 0.007397236302495003, -0.015922673046588898, 0.03537866845726967, -0.010687649250030518, -0.0253565963357687, -0.009722993709146976, -0.014021387323737144, 0.03967691585421562, -0.003505529835820198, 0.013346242718398571, -0.037641674280166626, -0.0612441785633564, -0.0029648432973772287, -0.004448331892490387, -0.02792949788272381, 0.028394240885972977, 0.03499869629740715, -0.040860552340745926, -0.04422002285718918, 0.03760697692632675, 0.011993981897830963, 0.055539146065711975, -0.0047210268676280975, -0.024660838767886162, -0.043461766093969345, -0.07702310383319855, 0.03175268694758415, 0.04319678992033005, -0.009767446666955948, -0.006889393087476492, 0.033642254769802094, 0.05864576995372772, -0.0595804862678051, 0.007331762928515673, -0.008317273110151291, 0.023393750190734863, -0.021302981302142143, -0.003067011246457696, -0.06051278114318848, -0.02371424436569214, 0.0313609316945076, 0.046593546867370605, 0.06643427163362503, -0.04809108003973961, -0.010409945622086525, 0.03891168162226677, -0.02998274564743042, 0.0312969870865345, 0.019803466275334358, 0.011472980491816998, 0.0061904448084533215, 0.008662981912493706, 0.023680711165070534, 0.016360467299818993, 0.03966686874628067, -0.06325644254684448, -0.03867528587579727, -0.04569486156105995, 0.0012978978920727968, 0.04228333756327629, -0.015857070684432983, -0.07460275292396545, -0.040949851274490356, 0.026059871539473534, -0.05725117400288582, -0.02635345794260502, -0.038136858493089676, -0.04988308250904083, 0.031492047011852264, -0.09795866161584854, -0.03019467182457447, 0.024073760956525803, 0.03388672694563866, 0.003000569297000766, 0.04781297221779823, -0.006514775101095438, 0.05322347208857536, -0.03263692557811737, -0.0066568730399012566, 0.03340835124254227, -0.01682993955910206, 0.00361868878826499, -0.0036116004921495914, 0.018693357706069946, 0.04467061161994934, -0.003486693138256669, 0.03177092969417572, 0.045715562999248505, 0.03135855123400688, 0.0002912927884608507, -0.015239544212818146, 0.013056638650596142, 0.02891911193728447, -0.04493463784456253, -0.00005330935528036207, -0.009623831138014793, 0.04943421110510826, 0.011075788177549839, 0.0010903917718678713, -0.0116634676232934, -0.015085982158780098, -0.0002075832599075511, -0.035806864500045776, 0.03410009294748306, -0.015091235749423504, 0.01356549933552742, 0.09596841037273407, -0.059533726423978806, 0.04047136753797531, 0.009047304280102253, -0.019567498937249184, 0.018396131694316864, 0.03863156586885452, 0.06055609881877899, -0.02035471983253956, 0.009896734729409218, 0.056238189339637756, 0.006631121970713139, 0.014568896032869816, 0.01338598970323801, -0.0400257371366024, 0.05382278934121132, -0.05121086537837982, -0.0006015773979015648, 0.025787631049752235, -0.016507945954799652, -0.0013570648152381182, 0.022826936095952988, 0.001471117022447288, -0.005431722849607468, -0.01966913230717182, 0.01562089379876852, -0.026662373915314674, 0.021697258576750755, 0.010443486273288727, -0.06273160129785538, 0.006201742682605982, 0.021646752953529358, -0.006880682893097401, 0.004125528037548065, 0.006872997153550386, -0.0021200028713792562, 0.026473332196474075, -0.022155076265335083, -0.018558192998170853, -0.019971027970314026, 0.048365067690610886, -0.038652870804071426, 0.016354944556951523, -0.06908030062913895, -0.02940080128610134, 0.002397907664999366, 0.04731132090091705, 0.053370118141174316, -0.09457171708345413, -0.03936232626438141, -0.014819598756730556, 0.0012126696528866887, 0.029653513804078102, -0.04116019234061241, -0.06739918887615204, -0.013847526162862778, -0.02651391364634037, 0.07233648747205734, 0.014118915423750877, 0.02223532646894455, 0.004870457109063864, 0.014667291194200516, 0.023078497499227524, 0.003976636566221714, -0.017978914082050323, -0.007655518129467964, 0.03779037669301033, -0.020382098853588104, -0.056347575038671494, 0.03566348925232887, 0.03289089351892471, 0.01978125050663948, -0.05295213311910629, -0.01615552417933941, 0.013092982582747936, 0.01734309084713459, -0.09573184698820114, 0.0054317740723490715, 0.05507544428110123, -0.015027613379061222, -0.014327913522720337, -0.017436152324080467, -0.04733557999134064, 0.003745084162801504, -0.02760661207139492, 0.0009085783967748284, -0.028747878968715668, 0.04383459687232971, -0.030730081722140312, -0.007561628241091967, -0.04744722694158554, 0.08139458298683167, 0.016710538417100906, 0.0205707810819149, -0.0001025391902658157, -0.0010963812237605453, -0.03400309756398201, 0.023497093468904495, -0.05440870299935341, 0.028599809855222702, 0.03236465901136398, -0.019303811714053154, 0.00887126661837101, 0.03064383566379547, 0.004081064369529486, 0.08528704196214676, 0.007503606844693422, 0.0542428158223629, -0.009007494896650314, -0.004225300624966621, -0.050572581589221954, -0.044970348477363586, -0.00013192456390243024, 0.011657178401947021, -0.02416123077273369, -0.028623264282941818, 0.019453492015600204, 0.02271978370845318, -0.026545092463493347, -0.007649475242942572, -0.004305459558963776, 0.0001216372475028038, -0.012694970704615116, 0.048131052404642105, -0.006972258444875479, 0.014033102430403233, -0.040905967354774475, 0.04067770019173622, -0.033727481961250305, -0.013336650095880032, 0.012154466472566128, -0.027470875531435013, -0.03197265416383743, 0.03920462727546692, 0.036344122141599655, 0.03600729629397392, 0.0021886881440877914, 0.03931119292974472, -0.025570783764123917, 0.06638851761817932, 0.01973138004541397, 0.056130703538656235, -0.08045313507318497, -0.023447047919034958, -0.0013472895370796323, -0.019282763823866844, 0.013413275592029095, -0.00828826054930687, -0.045713696628808975, 0.034907445311546326, 0.0034223950933665037, 0.03270979970693588, 0.002377672353759408, -0.017922846600413322, 0.004728556610643864, 0.0806242898106575, -0.05158313363790512, 0.06629737466573715, -0.04048028215765953, -0.05703210458159447, 0.04640395566821098, -0.0018132501281797886, 0.011436419561505318, 0.00944959931075573, -0.06446023285388947, -0.0064561860635876656, -0.036188047379255295, 0.050703007727861404, 0.01747586950659752, -0.031007610261440277, 0.018238885328173637, 0.03933015838265419, -0.03039073385298252, -0.022567013278603554, 0.04959694668650627, 0.024562733247876167, -0.025749992579221725, 0.02963360771536827, 0.013895147480070591, -0.018337570130825043, 0.0758448988199234, -0.04988131672143936, -0.014925715513527393, 0.06817465275526047, 0.023847147822380066, 0.059818070381879807, 0.0008011539466679096, 0.03684094175696373, -0.046628519892692566, 0.04890255630016327, 0.0010303822346031666, -0.05023324862122536, -0.0648098886013031, -0.05543861165642738, -0.04846647009253502, 0.01878000609576702, -0.017649872228503227, -0.0017594286473467946, -0.030422452837228775, 0.0925663486123085, -0.04666311293840408, 0.044140808284282684, 0.0322372168302536, -0.03402932360768318, -0.03830950707197189, -0.018847733736038208, -0.0006625920068472624, 0.004910952411592007, 0.04267575964331627, 0.020724257454276085, -0.053113650530576706, -0.016466427594423294, -0.061690736562013626, -0.027649037539958954, 0.005002717487514019, -0.01640842668712139, 0.05561870336532593, 0.021329494193196297, -0.05154898017644882, 0.003471400821581483, -0.016312014311552048, -0.00010377902071923018, 0.034592486917972565, 0.0033501770813018084, 0.00020293319539632648, 0.02433428354561329, -0.045316487550735474, 0.02346300147473812, 0.010028417222201824, 0.004415081348270178, -0.01057811826467514, -0.02673601545393467, -0.01093111652880907, 0.006792963016778231, 0.015339814126491547, -0.026577388867735863, -0.03319847583770752, -0.055647239089012146, 0.030937492847442627, 0.030396582558751106, -0.026819484308362007, 0.02045978605747223, -0.024808021262288094, 0.018696686252951622, 0.03290993720293045, -0.037799786776304245, 0.028807181864976883, 0.010949863120913506, 0.00828271172940731, 0.04037927836179733, -0.01781269907951355, 0.05731745436787605, -0.02272864244878292, -0.04516753926873207, -0.017999600619077682, -0.07867998629808426, 0.007642517331987619, 0.010179922915995121, 0.04944830760359764, 0.01615908183157444, 0.01332820113748312, -0.02824905700981617, -0.08282437920570374, 0.07377219200134277, 0.05089950934052467, -0.033706385642290115, -0.0751471221446991, -0.006202386692166328, 0.008773019537329674, -0.06598921865224838, -0.033414650708436966, -0.024983292445540428, -0.039139360189437866, -0.049171946942806244, 0.05469838157296181, -0.053513091057538986, 0.02856295183300972, 0.040736861526966095, 0.055174969136714935, 0.05671992525458336, 0.007617855444550514, 0.03805521875619888, -0.05016076937317848, 0.028130650520324707, 0.0002852021134458482, -0.013137818314135075, -0.022958319634199142, -0.046465709805488586, 0.028527868911623955, -0.031940311193466187, 0.020307235419750214, -0.013989049941301346, -0.00851454772055149, -0.02551359124481678, 0.009612983092665672, 0.0010143304243683815, 0.0004987527499906719, -0.035849183797836304, -0.0028104085940867662, 0.008071202784776688, 0.02712332457304001, -0.03759543225169182, 0.05369827151298523, 0.01554964855313301, -0.004300878383219242, -0.03454253077507019, -0.035751983523368835, -0.053541745990514755, 0.0018376065418124199, -0.011431166902184486, 0.041017353534698486, -0.004884038586169481, -0.02852904051542282, -0.030342359095811844, -0.01015944592654705, 0.0302408579736948, 0.013978919014334679, -0.0187690332531929, -0.001425043330527842, 0.04762893170118332, -0.011166575364768505, 0.07249000668525696, -0.056000757962465286, 0.03156064823269844, 0.02345864474773407, -0.00005755474921897985, 0.03802040219306946, 0.015795547515153885, -0.009784012101590633, 0.008021960034966469, 0.05499579384922981, -0.0645880401134491, -0.027021346613764763, -0.04581952840089798, -0.029880788177251816, 0.02776104025542736, -0.009224273264408112, 0.0018368394812569022, -0.016689397394657135, -0.021380949765443802, -0.09124889224767685, 0.05962805077433586, -0.031033148989081383, 0.038985103368759155, 0.005604780279099941, -0.047928910702466965, 0.010479748249053955, 0.020515305921435356, 0.05712401121854782, 0.007919537834823132, 0.035454925149679184, -0.03283361718058586, -0.05199960991740227, 0.022146789357066154, 0.03910589963197708, 0.006612579803913832, 0.0654275044798851, 0.0641675516963005, 0.025102490559220314, -0.040062326937913895, 0.030521269887685776, -0.04153876379132271, 0.040293190628290176, -0.03277150169014931, 0.014836090616881847, -0.017798949033021927, 0.04537326470017433, -0.014707516878843307, 0.012166431173682213, -0.014526473358273506, -0.04897395893931389, -0.005346828140318394, -0.004075107630342245, -0.05623796209692955, 0.03277333825826645, 0.012889129109680653, 0.009342155419290066, 0.033288635313510895, 0.011136697605252266, -0.03434758633375168, 0.004924860782921314, 0.0233631432056427, 0.004309145733714104, 0.02111588604748249, -0.06702981889247894, 0.01610400527715683, 0.007446577772498131, 0.0159121286123991, -0.034265317022800446, 0.05491592735052109, 0.004994281101971865, -0.037928447127342224, 0.00730829406529665, -0.0024495229590684175, 0.05663660913705826, -0.03651256114244461, 0.005993432365357876, 0.007645489647984505, 0.049914564937353134, -0.01736154407262802, -0.04806990921497345, -0.1033320426940918, -0.052934810519218445, 0.02050970122218132, 0.07152725756168365, 0.029253965243697166, -0.026510290801525116, -0.036788590252399445, -0.05589064583182335, -0.010052875615656376, -0.0951296016573906, -0.005665332544595003, 0.03152913600206375, 0.0406576469540596, -0.026401987299323082, 0.004573083017021418, 0.06361446529626846, 0.0018510487861931324, -0.005249867215752602, -0.026473818346858025, -0.03785070776939392, -0.0028030863031744957, 0.08548754453659058, 0.004857383668422699, 0.0024044804740697145, 0.06132863461971283, 0.014198481105268002, 0.06536445766687393, 0.028830764815211296, 0.015192289836704731, -0.002003039000555873, -0.02555677480995655, -0.020914366468787193, -0.0076004196889698505, -0.05409838631749153, 0.05191095545887947, -0.015800826251506805, 0.009954757057130337, -0.03860294446349144, 0.010159206576645374, 0.015964314341545105, -0.03559006378054619, -0.034880995750427246, -0.035238705575466156, 0.00010711392678786069, 0.01937122270464897, -0.005129104480147362, 0.057311322540044785, -0.0019107635598629713, -0.04996248334646225, -0.02277662605047226, 0.039532169699668884, 0.010103290900588036, 0.0832972303032875, -0.002036142162978649, 0.009502389468252659, -0.010960561223328114, 0.0016299033304676414, 0.011254701763391495, 0.022660791873931885, -0.03396012261509895, 0.0011840941151604056, -0.00023222179152071476, -0.0014876702334731817, -0.04944374039769173, 0.054845526814460754, -0.007598504889756441, -0.03133015334606171, 0.010184758342802525, 0.004359498620033264, -0.022029880434274673, -0.02761702425777912, 0.023329846560955048, 0.05523179471492767, 0.0021862643770873547, 0.01856444962322712, -0.03765110671520233, -0.011392473243176937, 0.07816693186759949, -0.0025274190120399, 0.006449459120631218, -0.020800689235329628, -0.05088040605187416, 0.03578290715813637, -0.006539446767419577, -0.019982000812888145, 0.028537018224596977, 0.047121502459049225, -0.055027902126312256, -0.01911717839539051, 0.0321020670235157, -0.023494182154536247, 0.016093414276838303, 0.04536354914307594, 0.010500127449631691, 0.042436834424734116, 0.05223373696208, -0.05615480616688728, -0.018758976832032204, -0.03291283920407295, -0.018606973811984062, 0.023443035781383514, -0.04964548721909523, 0.016227709129452705, 0.010992254130542278, -0.05415282025933266, -0.023310573771595955, -0.024891847744584084, 0.06264375895261765, 0.007453682832419872, -0.01614200510084629, 0.052961692214012146, -0.0026038323994725943, -0.021935960277915, -0.020181553438305855, 0.0005927438614889979, -0.040906473994255066, 0.01238641794770956, -0.025873946025967598, 0.014812151901423931, -0.08200322836637497, -0.018286073580384254, 0.06894749402999878, 0.012446390464901924, 0.021698128432035446, 0.003073897212743759, 0.024904722347855568, 0.02424599416553974, -0.03829669579863548, 0.06720106303691864, 0.04847769811749458, -0.07153715938329697, -0.06280560791492462, 0.025695793330669403, 0.02122475393116474, -0.036202322691679, -0.03053627908229828, -0.025799617171287537, -0.015173283405601978, 0.04009672999382019, 0.028171971440315247, 0.02921825461089611, 0.012811966240406036, -0.0031694239005446434, -0.044927723705768585, 0.0964151993393898, 0.03099505789577961, 0.03897101804614067, -0.018551276996731758, 0.07339107990264893, 0.05810699611902237, -0.03182489797472954, 0.05890026316046715, -0.033808205276727676, -0.020056065171957016, 0.017838910222053528, -0.027957215905189514, 0.022644469514489174, 0.0541723370552063, -0.005340697709470987, -0.004757808055728674, -0.053744763135910034, 0.049184124916791916, 0.06073036789894104, 0.04657931998372078, 0.01704108901321888, -0.007700806017965078, -0.09251619130373001, 0.0007493547163903713, -0.004171438980847597, 0.00907484907656908, 0.01582508161664009, 0.06500987708568573, -0.03669019788503647, -0.010120883584022522, 0.0048270937986671925, -0.003698623739182949, -0.017822828143835068, 0.009126014076173306, -0.013593889772891998, 0.009186788462102413, 0.035909928381443024, 0.04324804246425629, -0.03046451136469841, 0.04955422133207321, -0.1231517493724823, -0.05603303015232086, 0.051064006984233856, 0.03713701665401459, 0.015787025913596153, 0.04368230327963829, 0.0011206531198695302, -0.012563046999275684, -0.03487062826752663, -0.022807780653238297, -0.002205447992309928, 0.00800406839698553, -0.038192108273506165, -0.019794145599007607, -0.011449418030679226, -0.0371895506978035, 0.016755137592554092, 0.003879424650222063, -0.06340013444423676, -0.03465108200907707, -0.06162480264902115, -0.021042335778474808, -0.0715605691075325, -0.003847869113087654, -0.002187319565564394, -0.0021965501364320517, -0.01844850182533264, -0.005349133163690567, -0.00042148580541834235, -0.02772764302790165, -0.05250392109155655, -0.02236912027001381, 0.07295997440814972, -0.030497629195451736, 0.007248463574796915, -0.002872382989153266, -0.015203665941953659, -0.023620476946234703, -0.008624380454421043, 0.010671229101717472, 0.039520543068647385, -0.0012665280373767018, -0.05231032893061638, 0.01903104968369007, -0.054683152586221695, -0.033760979771614075, 0.08536624163389206, 0.06556972116231918, 0.002278449246659875, -0.065155990421772, -0.052843380719423294, 0.01658799685537815, -0.011047635227441788, 0.020372290164232254, -0.039793118834495544, -0.03847385570406914, 0.005995362997055054, 0.004034548532217741, -0.023882053792476654, -0.017120910808444023, -0.0009428490302525461, 0.04523071274161339, 0.06946481764316559, -0.012788008898496628, -0.02983013540506363, -0.0026608442422002554, 0.014428464695811272 ]
<p>Consider two objects presented in the figure below. Objects have equal masses and are separated by a distance of 60 light seconds. </p> <p>Assume that we move left object by 3 light seconds to the left in 30 seconds. This requires energy input, lets say it's equal to X. Change in potential energy is also equal to X.</p> <p>Now, the right object does not 'know' yet that the left object was moved. Left object was moved 30 seconds ago and this information requires 60 seconds to reach the right object. </p> <p>We have 2 options:</p> <p><strong>A:</strong> We can move the right object by 3 light seconds to the right with the speed of 0.1c now. </p> <p><strong>B:</strong> We can move it with the same speed and by the same distance later - let's say after 60 seconds.</p> <p>Clearly case A requires the same energy input as when moving left object = X. This is because right object still 'thinks' that the left mass in the same place.</p> <p>In the case B the right object 'knows' that the left mass was move so we will need less energy to move it. Energy needed &lt; X.</p> <p>The end state in A and B is the same. Why it is possible to achieve it with 2 different energy inputs? If we choose method A the increase in potential energy is smaller than energy input X. Where is the missing energy?</p> <p>Maybe the 'speed of gravity' is infinite?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/dgCfA.png" alt="2 objects"></p>
g4242
[ 0.05500432103872299, 0.0403008908033371, 0.00008605090988567099, 0.03160693868994713, 0.05353507027029991, 0.02191336825489998, 0.04073219746351242, 0.01925789751112461, -0.10744059085845947, -0.009234699420630932, 0.012237503193318844, -0.024808766320347786, 0.008510490879416466, -0.013569590635597706, -0.02230447344481945, -0.009699760936200619, 0.10823625326156616, -0.06794198602437973, 0.019011741504073143, 0.04236944392323494, 0.008717441000044346, 0.014264032244682312, 0.019940078258514404, -0.04297076165676117, -0.05014823377132416, -0.013696136884391308, 0.022493110969662666, -0.04188389331102371, -0.04910518601536751, 0.01954701915383339, 0.022352175787091255, -0.029028665274381638, 0.06689990311861038, -0.054248347878456116, -0.04253567382693291, -0.04032820090651512, 0.08107893168926239, -0.03454771265387535, -0.010843684896826744, 0.009630554355680943, 0.016660651192069054, -0.011234299279749393, -0.002913270378485322, -0.006162833422422409, 0.0539785772562027, -0.010039065964519978, 0.03137590363621712, -0.0035503115504980087, 0.023468343541026115, -0.06435619294643402, -0.016000116243958473, 0.051330991089344025, 0.016983287408947945, 0.011965912766754627, 0.01783411018550396, 0.0440913625061512, 0.0010932870209217072, -0.0330570787191391, 0.03943600133061409, -0.000036351262679090723, 0.016735129058361053, -0.034868352115154266, 0.07108359783887863, 0.003577600000426173, 0.016965173184871674, 0.02222955785691738, -0.05129624530673027, -0.015427947044372559, 0.016191724687814713, -0.010515606962144375, -0.010226920247077942, -0.014869820326566696, -0.04215829074382782, -0.06626299768686295, 0.009123863652348518, -0.0296548530459404, 0.04108016565442085, -0.048594146966934204, -0.007469601929187775, 0.026033813133835793, -0.05372101441025734, -0.027623755857348442, 0.033953744918107986, 0.004299684427678585, 0.0049209510907530785, 0.01951708272099495, 0.006269290577620268, 0.037906765937805176, -0.007473329547792673, 0.02211405523121357, -0.02122163213789463, -0.03047182224690914, 0.1090293824672699, 0.06257417052984238, -0.009385211393237114, -0.015294271521270275, -0.035567399114370346, 0.09341764450073242, -0.010890865698456764, 0.0032722994219511747, -0.004889670293778181, -0.03297530487179756, -0.006146733649075031, 0.0061198268085718155, 0.015477297827601433, -0.02901383489370346, -0.014543396420776844, -0.0017595402896404266, -0.043356120586395264, -0.030215119943022728, -0.0014291675761342049, -0.042741019278764725, 0.017350003123283386, -0.03584567829966545, -0.03559841960668564, -0.06753523647785187, 0.06935181468725204, -0.01616082526743412, -0.02329210937023163, -0.012765456922352314, -0.05413402244448662, 0.003311761887744069, -0.012919856235384941, 0.016978079453110695, -0.009761723689734936, -0.01791292428970337, 0.004772505722939968, -0.010604048147797585, 0.05558958277106285, -0.02356957085430622, -0.02661380171775818, -0.014018050394952297, 0.0247705839574337, 0.04756558686494827, -0.018129682168364525, -0.005234455224126577, 0.039659131318330765, 0.043904464691877365, 0.0006734891212545335, 0.023652657866477966, -0.015726428478956223, -0.0206715390086174, 0.013065679930150509, -0.05160701647400856, -0.05583401024341583, 0.067123644053936, -0.012706570327281952, -0.004997471813112497, 0.018313273787498474, 0.003061015158891678, 0.03125488758087158, 0.08254405856132507, -0.0001585769496159628, 0.008594533428549767, 0.04876679182052612, -0.007069665007293224, 0.053276047110557556, 0.002697722287848592, -0.00009626241080695763, -0.013095071539282799, 0.10605983436107635, 0.017315207049250603, 0.02313539944589138, -0.0299205482006073, -0.03975653648376465, 0.07442565262317657, 0.07212677597999573, -0.0673532709479332, 0.0002726171223912388, -0.062058739364147186, -0.08545511215925217, -0.03854846954345703, 0.025251546874642372, 0.051999159157276154, 0.03477570414543152, 0.041361406445503235, 0.07909714430570602, -0.09182220697402954, -0.02675633318722248, 0.025123190134763718, -0.0339520126581192, -0.008192382752895355, -0.002839374588802457, -0.04004571586847305, 0.013819007202982903, -0.027081189677119255, -0.026693260297179222, 0.041000500321388245, -0.05863829702138901, -0.01889074221253395, -0.047581084072589874, -0.021258801221847534, -0.05030294507741928, 0.04360756278038025, -0.051435280591249466, 0.019486522302031517, 0.05480741336941719, -0.03143039718270302, -0.06777624785900116, 0.03922563046216965, -0.005644323769956827, 0.01354400347918272, 0.07689221203327179, -0.01733311079442501, 0.046448543667793274, 0.004857172723859549, 0.044797804206609726, 0.028979402035474777, 0.025082191452383995, -0.020236559212207794, 0.03342011570930481, 0.017416536808013916, -0.03338339179754257, 0.012709666043519974, 0.010720125399529934, -0.01168892253190279, 0.003522463608533144, 0.006066854577511549, 0.02146027237176895, -0.03150707110762596, -0.024911759421229362, -0.018210582435131073, 0.09540557861328125, -0.035919707268476486, -0.06347846984863281, -0.028228066861629486, -0.06072474643588066, -0.012538736686110497, -0.051867078989744186, 0.05787542089819908, -0.026359332725405693, 0.04446563869714737, 0.0166142750531435, -0.0011190100340172648, 0.04285347834229469, -0.006504444405436516, 0.015303079970180988, 0.027468813583254814, 0.002989749191328883, 0.015984266996383667, 0.051080211997032166, -0.05254504457116127, 0.007064510136842728, 0.01389522384852171, 0.011720111593604088, -0.008985341526567936, 0.051285985857248306, -0.02293180488049984, 0.006939307786524296, 0.06176372617483139, -0.01152111403644085, -0.04263865575194359, -0.08355478942394257, 0.004886441398411989, 0.00959449727088213, -0.042391981929540634, -0.015148021280765533, 0.029684673994779587, -0.05968276038765907, -0.04299171268939972, -0.02063208818435669, 0.007328180130571127, 0.05650101229548454, 0.03765787184238434, -0.043260347098112106, 0.026591479778289795, -0.04423189163208008, -0.024861406534910202, -0.024193285033106804, -0.03770388662815094, -0.08651942014694214, 0.04089812561869621, -0.014246052131056786, 0.02969357743859291, -0.000286281225271523, 0.014621878042817116, 0.012456745840609074, -0.029674112796783447, 0.06373747438192368, 0.03778679668903351, -0.021682443097233772, -0.03356305509805679, -0.07126286625862122, 0.027745334431529045, 0.02237285114824772, -0.040048748254776, -0.008109666407108307, 0.03977304697036743, -0.044652167707681656, -0.008676947094500065, -0.017026998102664948, 0.08792676031589508, 0.08033668994903564, -0.019351776689291, -0.019044451415538788, 0.02735433354973793, 0.006690220441669226, -0.03763571381568909, -0.04384111985564232, -0.03843698278069496, 0.025022229179739952, 0.030187327414751053, -0.007454418111592531, 0.02963658981025219, 0.03922836482524872, -0.00856926292181015, -0.038851577788591385, -0.030973361805081367, -0.001704954425804317, -0.03380468115210533, 0.05046293884515762, 0.04469870403409004, -0.02246294915676117, 0.01928192377090454, -0.013834334909915924, -0.020791953429579735, -0.045182377099990845, 0.018140321597456932, -0.03482601046562195, -0.0336616151034832, 0.013085324317216873, 0.014989035204052925, -0.007300932426005602, -0.021966220811009407, 0.013118774630129337, 0.03797702491283417, -0.07721666991710663, -0.019215798005461693, -0.04320846498012543, 0.014188379980623722, 0.03468635678291321, 0.045535944402217865, -0.059235475957393646, -0.0010220021940767765, -0.049845293164253235, -0.03236033767461777, 0.025981273502111435, 0.011194526217877865, 0.08328403532505035, 0.0472380556166172, -0.020243721082806587, 0.031064718961715698, -0.062296412885189056, 0.06393245607614517, 0.015361119993031025, 0.029737213626503944, -0.009748720563948154, 0.005635490640997887, -0.043923523277044296, 0.0017973221838474274, 0.030109595507383347, 0.00050120719242841, -0.012570884078741074, -0.022627603262662888, -0.019043829292058945, -0.0110966507345438, -0.02010183595120907, 0.02546844445168972, 0.005832477007061243, -0.00038162266719155014, -0.0020333752036094666, -0.0040235924534499645, 0.030781041830778122, 0.04827307537198067, -0.01845620386302471, 0.012954815290868282, -0.053341493010520935, 0.002524697221815586, 0.017534444108605385, -0.022491252049803734, 0.020633123815059662, -0.026858417317271233, -0.030954888090491295, -0.026211246848106384, 0.04962188005447388, -0.04887812212109566, 0.06567757576704025, -0.018923841416835785, -0.0323927104473114, 0.03212273493409157, 0.07496858388185501, -0.0009744359413161874, 0.015592225827276707, -0.01525986846536398, 0.03903995081782341, 0.018560118973255157, -0.03270786628127098, -0.027220727875828743, 0.00841210875660181, -0.002056049183011055, 0.011015577241778374, -0.03190810978412628, -0.018079841509461403, 0.04030918702483177, -0.016158342361450195, 0.03689230978488922, 0.011990689672529697, -0.029828336089849472, 0.021402468904852867, 0.04518134519457817, -0.06135832890868187, 0.0359053909778595, -0.07644187659025192, -0.03772618621587753, -0.05419953167438507, 0.005291024222970009, 0.0559515580534935, -0.029307058081030846, 0.02108721062541008, -0.024577967822551727, 0.008733847178518772, -0.027322804555296898, 0.01958155818283558, -0.051415763795375824, -0.03658333793282509, -0.04539867118000984, 0.018016407266259193, -0.009153538383543491, 0.03293577581644058, 0.037052106112241745, 0.050554946064949036, 0.07786300033330917, -0.014799623750150204, -0.04252456873655319, -0.0036278103943914175, 0.08216738700866699, 0.023616651073098183, -0.017376327887177467, -0.024895962327718735, -0.06579984724521637, 0.02480318956077099, 0.04806334525346756, 0.03573138266801834, -0.0014592830557376146, -0.048808787018060684, 0.04834960773587227, -0.0002240977919427678, 0.03361551836133003, 0.055508192628622055, 0.04921910911798477, 0.04793432354927063, 0.050847530364990234, 0.0006243510288186371, -0.027917761355638504, 0.03500262275338173, 0.05023392662405968, 0.0018591685220599174, -0.04185902327299118, 0.013216247782111168, -0.020228656008839607, -0.04039282724261284, 0.03371255099773407, 0.006120596081018448, -0.01832057721912861, 0.0091951759532094, 0.00018963144975714386, -0.038406334817409515, 0.03720699995756149, -0.02421700209379196, 0.02001308649778366, -0.020438890904188156, 0.018756909295916557, 0.01869135908782482, -0.00839762669056654, -0.017267772927880287, -0.010563219897449017, -0.02907406911253929, -0.005176785867661238, -0.04439202696084976, -0.0013802730245515704, 0.023817598819732666, -0.010138966143131256, 0.0012817548122256994, 0.081618532538414, -0.030136093497276306, -0.0021190897095948458, 0.010874660685658455, -0.038043063133955, 0.055493567138910294, -0.03284778073430061, -0.06848324090242386, 0.000635363336186856, 0.05486040934920311, 0.027023058384656906, 0.013788539916276932, -0.0018856590613722801, -0.08960185199975967, 0.03342045098543167, 0.03306496515870094, -0.018948260694742203, 0.06746076792478561, 0.01910218596458435, -0.010734232142567635, -0.03995843231678009, -0.023308932781219482, 0.02674270235002041, 0.007456114050000906, 0.025065504014492035, -0.04329691082239151, -0.005837178323417902, -0.06105440482497215, 0.014972527511417866, 0.00907119084149599, -0.03427482023835182, 0.0064109209924936295, 0.0162341371178627, 0.057535283267498016, -0.0059197028167545795, 0.016423000022768974, 0.01589290052652359, -0.053582195192575455, 0.01065544318407774, 0.0030562712345272303, 0.036222219467163086, 0.019845644012093544, -0.009150589816272259, 0.047090381383895874, -0.01950628124177456, 0.008892464451491833, -0.06499787420034409, 0.05582726001739502, 0.003712612437084317, 0.029961517080664635, -0.018030434846878052, 0.041076626628637314, 0.012617903761565685, -0.07143031805753708, 0.014028883539140224, -0.017229991033673286, 0.06488754600286484, 0.053428687155246735, 0.007015417795628309, -0.0336129292845726, -0.003893985180184245, -0.028922297060489655, 0.007847829721868038, 0.01830851472914219, 0.0025287147145718336, 0.0102134570479393, -0.04824535921216011, -0.02279587648808956, -0.06160705164074898, -0.006642152555286884, 0.061350055038928986, -0.012936299666762352, -0.012297441251575947, -0.013858468271791935, -0.07945144176483154, -0.0077268281020224094, -0.04656791314482689, -0.005517273675650358, 0.029570220038294792, 0.004877086263149977, 0.017872262746095657, 0.016352087259292603, 0.028085272759199142, -0.012400091625750065, -0.02624424360692501, 0.013003533706068993, -0.020370963960886, 0.029211778193712234, 0.005526543129235506, 0.03651482239365578, -0.002151164226233959, 0.04287542775273323, -0.05644504725933075, 0.008657796308398247, 0.007412574253976345, -0.018448950722813606, 0.02883974276483059, -0.010573898442089558, 0.0072161550633609295, -0.001106790965422988, -0.007988971658051014, 0.04320535436272621, 0.016183825209736824, -0.01544116996228695, -0.009292549453675747, -0.027839500457048416, -0.03208744898438454, -0.03705763816833496, 0.009311172179877758, -0.016656534746289253, -0.010106603614985943, 0.002775413915514946, 0.02884153462946415, -0.05627329647541046, -0.021216554567217827, 0.07615615427494049, -0.04492051526904106, -0.044062498956918716, -0.051546018570661545, -0.015372367575764656, -0.10419727861881256, -0.05984557792544365, -0.004650596063584089, -0.07122558355331421, -0.007876653224229813, -0.04535719007253647, 0.07974424213171005, -0.003545014886185527, -0.00712595647200942, 0.058579642325639725, 0.026544298976659775, -0.05431289225816727, 0.038470786064863205, -0.05516147240996361, -0.024845564737915993, 0.029979310929775238, -0.00510310847312212, -0.04797130078077316, -0.02131093665957451, 0.009363999590277672, 0.011626680381596088, -0.030130257830023766, -0.0056920042261481285, -0.02243935875594616, 0.023103483021259308, 0.006202398799359798, -0.017734073102474213, 0.0177554152905941, -0.005917477421462536, 0.0631784126162529, -0.057590387761592865, 0.07817107439041138, -0.008001303300261497, -0.0801980271935463, 0.03257209062576294, 0.05933531001210213, 0.03640499338507652, 0.027143392711877823, 0.006988447159528732, -0.03079070895910263, 0.07609334588050842, -0.005262551363557577, 0.03034091554582119, -0.020854642614722252, 0.05875513330101967, -0.016994444653391838, 0.017759831622242928, 0.007373284548521042, 0.025790000334382057, 0.0036956784315407276, 0.050002265721559525, -0.011863472871482372, 0.0031735410448163748, 0.02601018361747265, 0.01505999080836773, -0.031444668769836426, -0.034192364662885666, -0.02312825433909893, -0.014285769313573837, -0.020028892904520035, 0.005077265202999115, -0.025336166843771935, -0.0018165337387472391, -0.02210056781768799, -0.020830685272812843, 0.032390277832746506, -0.06636218726634979, -0.035538747906684875, -0.03727317973971367, -0.053466007113456726, 0.037378281354904175, -0.004878436215221882, 0.04991310089826584, 0.014208671636879444, -0.046522535383701324, -0.014989836141467094, -0.023138124495744705, -0.0001775192649802193, 0.02204611711204052, -0.04501982778310776, 0.0035220447462052107, -0.024552397429943085, 0.035295840352773666, 0.04696100950241089, 0.01800539158284664, 0.012189595960080624, -0.023731833323836327, 0.004609446972608566, -0.017851125448942184, -0.016132814809679985, 0.013379596173763275, 0.014869906939566135, 0.04110238701105118, -0.03650239109992981, 0.018871720880270004, -0.01253795251250267, -0.02825009822845459, 0.022382624447345734, 0.05644560977816582, 0.017184942960739136, 0.06793516129255295, -0.05311297997832298, 0.008744394406676292, -0.031419672071933746, 0.03767288848757744, 0.08351113647222519, 0.004263706039637327, -0.011121680028736591, -0.0215801689773798, 0.01885652169585228, 0.030537281185388565, -0.030725207179784775, -0.03654642775654793, -0.024350324645638466, -0.013759682886302471, -0.013967873528599739, 0.007877526804804802, 0.0038891532458364964, 0.026885028928518295, -0.007584018167108297, 0.024121087044477463, -0.020512351766228676, 0.011933990754187107, -0.014957296662032604, 0.0371587797999382, 0.014584766700863838, 0.021153144538402557, -0.0031022175680845976, -0.008739580400288105, -0.07468618452548981, -0.07943054288625717, -0.021672416478395462, 0.022195693105459213, 0.011610438115894794, 0.008871708996593952, -0.03163854777812958, -0.009259629994630814, 0.015781836584210396, 0.004953581839799881, -0.038685478270053864, -0.027259856462478638, -0.03731051832437515, 0.02236630581319332, -0.008608505129814148, -0.006704009138047695, -0.019082942977547646, 0.014051132835447788, -0.023375162854790688, -0.05634508281946182, 0.03146862983703613, 0.015259754844009876, 0.03141745179891586, -0.05542352795600891, -0.029065178707242012, 0.050595518201589584, 0.06895458698272705, -0.00994162168353796, -0.030525727197527885, -0.021413929760456085, -0.08945611119270325, 0.04481557011604309, 0.03764062747359276, 0.03947056457400322, 0.0327782928943634, -0.007532163057476282, -0.047421570867300034, 0.002290308242663741, -0.025011401623487473, 0.017939141020178795, 0.011195988394320011, -0.02605835348367691, 0.022518189623951912, 0.004437141120433807, -0.00741500873118639, 0.03279929608106613 ]
<p>There have been a few <a href="http://www.crunchgear.com/2010/12/10/navys-mach-7-railgun-fires-a-round-at-33000-megajoules/">articles about the Navy's new Mach 7 33 Megajoule railgun.</a> As a physics teacher, I have a couple of questions about this, and was hoping for some help. </p> <ol> <li><p>Is the kinetic energy of the projectile 33 MJ, or is that the energy that was delivered from the capacitor bank that was used to fire the projectile, so that some of it would have been lost in resistive heating, etc. </p></li> <li><p>The photos of the projectile show a cloud of hot gas behind the projectile? What is this? superheated air? Plasma from the electrical breakdown inside the railgun? What causes this? </p></li> </ol>
g4243
[ 0.08682093024253845, 0.03113969787955284, 0.006696976255625486, -0.004559489898383617, 0.04286235570907593, 0.03033738024532795, 0.033314213156700134, 0.0004883004003204405, -0.07642710953950882, -0.045629315078258514, -0.04107290133833885, 0.005935480818152428, 0.07052318751811981, 0.02850073203444481, 0.05290135368704796, -0.07270964235067368, 0.06153871864080429, -0.041783880442380905, 0.03313134238123894, 0.049250926822423935, -0.02572009153664112, -0.015917830169200897, -0.008484752848744392, -0.029422856867313385, 0.00047456438187509775, 0.012600544840097427, 0.03444528207182884, -0.029041793197393417, -0.0304863378405571, -0.06079430133104324, 0.02208266779780388, -0.034192975610494614, 0.0032022905070334673, -0.026597116142511368, -0.05335058271884918, -0.016946658492088318, -0.01249660924077034, 0.024694152176380157, 0.017543505877256393, 0.0005475837970152497, 0.010340220294892788, -0.06374894082546234, 0.018482662737369537, -0.005811920389533043, 0.017592985183000565, 0.06600046902894974, -0.028853915631771088, 0.0038717789575457573, -0.05023231729865074, -0.035437971353530884, -0.0214715376496315, -0.012283425778150558, 0.036310724914073944, -0.00811221543699503, 0.011317680589854717, -0.005822045728564262, -0.04721942916512489, 0.010873560793697834, 0.023416878655552864, -0.012220279313623905, 0.031803157180547714, -0.017415989190340042, -0.050004538148641586, 0.004796959925442934, 0.0009691740269772708, -0.053640011698007584, -0.058892883360385895, -0.006879984401166439, 0.04969681426882744, 0.03797656670212746, 0.004279487766325474, -0.04577409848570824, -0.008806182071566582, -0.031021591275930405, 0.04595854878425598, -0.040085699409246445, 0.0055005233734846115, 0.008338908664882183, -0.04673836752772331, 0.02002028562128544, 0.006699990015476942, 0.05204187333583832, -0.011341908015310764, -0.07856075465679169, 0.041417673230171204, -0.0011259783059358597, -0.037105951458215714, 0.021873679012060165, -0.03788909688591957, -0.010947625152766705, -0.030312150716781616, 0.06462162733078003, 0.03451794013381004, 0.009714525192975998, 0.019286692142486572, 0.03707335889339447, -0.061176806688308716, 0.049411628395318985, -0.009823579341173172, 0.043777499347925186, -0.007727618794888258, -0.036408428102731705, -0.0020270245149731636, -0.010729379020631313, 0.03400919586420059, 0.005582120269536972, 0.023980814963579178, 0.02213350124657154, 0.0067956699058413506, -0.032652098685503006, -0.00683303689584136, -0.0640614926815033, -0.050986841320991516, 0.0029439039062708616, 0.009399044327437878, -0.018736105412244797, 0.006480049341917038, -0.02146228589117527, -0.018377698957920074, 0.06870072335004807, 0.03329527750611305, 0.057419758290052414, -0.04419976472854614, -0.024391790851950645, -0.01316138356924057, -0.05136632174253464, 0.05500524118542671, -0.005121333058923483, -0.018872860819101334, -0.019648442044854164, -0.010957518592476845, -0.02144489623606205, 0.027191808447241783, -0.02514922432601452, 0.01013980619609356, -0.0385524220764637, 0.004727900959551334, 0.03019191138446331, -0.024983664974570274, -0.038282863795757294, 0.10036290436983109, -0.016602734103798866, 0.03978410363197327, 0.025570649653673172, -0.02601701393723488, 0.067322738468647, -0.03628755360841751, 0.02964155748486519, 0.0314573273062706, 0.042767737060785294, 0.054700229316949844, -0.02741229720413685, -0.00043733222992159426, -0.056091804057359695, 0.024053091183304787, -0.016863998025655746, 0.034617312252521515, -0.05068185180425644, 0.03358210250735283, 0.005129427649080753, -0.007684222422540188, -0.008632860146462917, 0.059718918055295944, 0.04451123625040054, 0.022471019998192787, 0.01821170747280121, 0.01975349709391594, 0.022092707455158234, 0.06634707003831863, 0.013096658512949944, 0.036063302308321, -0.04336398467421532, -0.0331844761967659, 0.02858174592256546, -0.02452090010046959, 0.013171952217817307, 0.08942113816738129, -0.055575720965862274, -0.015369840897619724, -0.039393577724695206, -0.012956214137375355, 0.002476409310474992, 0.028747910633683205, -0.06913615018129349, 0.016785411164164543, -0.004577930551022291, -0.007203244138509035, 0.021773550659418106, 0.011882313527166843, 0.015922077000141144, -0.12148196250200272, -0.01007627323269844, 0.014096942730247974, 0.03691621497273445, 0.01527122501283884, -0.036008335649967194, -0.0047006323002278805, 0.00005258465898805298, -0.027743389829993248, -0.007553799543529749, -0.04209141433238983, 0.05203407630324364, 0.014802595600485802, 0.0222859438508749, 0.040321771055459976, -0.013972173444926739, -0.01816544122993946, 0.018629252910614014, -0.015800414606928825, -0.014307403936982155, 0.03868936002254486, 0.02430201694369316, 0.057203177362680435, -0.05191302299499512, -0.0062745544128119946, 0.05781935900449753, 0.06376064568758011, 0.03085673786699772, 0.00842456053942442, -0.0009743115515448153, -0.013364257290959358, -0.021438490599393845, 0.004392964765429497, -0.03945231810212135, -0.013533844612538815, 0.004781728610396385, -0.05174217000603676, -0.10341997444629669, -0.00005481106200022623, 0.0058643631637096405, -0.01748211868107319, 0.0626373216509819, -0.002827106276527047, -0.041337139904499054, -0.0010934373131021857, 0.009764794260263443, 0.053605563938617706, -0.029309004545211792, 0.032600753009319305, 0.010480964556336403, -0.004180447664111853, 0.029826676473021507, -0.009429465979337692, -0.03050576150417328, 0.00481717474758625, -0.06396389752626419, -0.032140206545591354, 0.03696049377322197, -0.004775394685566425, -0.006477133836597204, 0.019407473504543304, -0.05932140722870827, -0.03299855813384056, -0.000587823917157948, 0.045150287449359894, -0.020051967352628708, 0.003292420646175742, 0.005446450784802437, -0.046309806406497955, -0.06826885789632797, 0.019172385334968567, 0.016419460996985435, -0.046233177185058594, 0.01877755858004093, -0.04831203073263168, 0.007937317714095116, -0.022185390815138817, -0.01953103207051754, 0.012991533614695072, -0.047651760280132294, -0.03844926133751869, 0.043542440980672836, 0.008957210928201675, 0.020390238612890244, 0.02486804686486721, -0.020375775173306465, -0.005177500657737255, -0.025543073192238808, 0.024619704112410545, -0.05377986282110214, -0.028000259771943092, -0.013229161500930786, -0.011960270814597607, -0.028452441096305847, 0.0033569596707820892, -0.07612491399049759, -0.015180633403360844, 0.020414691418409348, 0.015132593922317028, -0.025156164541840553, -0.05030560493469238, -0.01659836806356907, 0.040913134813308716, -0.009954041801393032, -0.0614684596657753, 0.014418157748878002, 0.06912112236022949, -0.011177957989275455, 0.016102051362395287, -0.03713337704539299, 0.012913674116134644, -0.0292377769947052, -0.05072660371661186, -0.005246572196483612, -0.02832135371863842, 0.04871922358870506, -0.031524889171123505, -0.021965958178043365, 0.011080212891101837, 0.002025074325501919, 0.0318397656083107, 0.026782503351569176, 0.01456347294151783, 0.003489519003778696, -0.005223909392952919, -0.014419558458030224, -0.04740382358431816, 0.03550209850072861, -0.006549153942614794, 0.07823918759822845, -0.06681077927350998, -0.02883676066994667, 0.02990998513996601, 0.011919669806957245, -0.008270105347037315, 0.012297961860895157, 0.05890124663710594, -0.029252635315060616, 0.031062398105859756, 0.028791947290301323, -0.019611133262515068, 0.03537870571017265, 0.019840167835354805, 0.010227387771010399, -0.01340701524168253, 0.012844906188547611, -0.003657600609585643, 0.09527435898780823, 0.044005341827869415, 0.010036682710051537, 0.08302251249551773, 0.025093063712120056, -0.014782681129872799, -0.05437975376844406, 0.0640900507569313, 0.020708899945020676, 0.037894487380981445, -0.015001201070845127, -0.010452370159327984, -0.013799049891531467, 0.09457031637430191, -0.010387727059423923, 0.012000027112662792, 0.042213551700115204, -0.05777981877326965, 0.0116296811029315, -0.02658107690513134, 0.03302557393908501, -0.004672322887927294, 0.04622500389814377, -0.03809008374810219, -0.01604844070971012, 0.031209012493491173, 0.009455539286136627, 0.0139817139133811, -0.018817592412233353, -0.09491138160228729, 0.00619201734662056, 0.028059063479304314, -0.05625401437282562, -0.04825425148010254, -0.04019312933087349, -0.07852960377931595, 0.016743801534175873, 0.01230658683925867, 0.002087164204567671, -0.0162621159106493, -0.010757887735962868, -0.049565959721803665, 0.004046537913382053, 0.045027587562799454, -0.004899263381958008, 0.013674445450305939, 0.03252223879098892, 0.06644900888204575, 0.010331910103559494, -0.03394436463713646, 0.027120312675833702, -0.01830345205962658, -0.06989628076553345, -0.006987296510487795, -0.02341475710272789, -0.042851634323596954, 0.037709496915340424, -0.007056793663650751, -0.004510849714279175, 0.0014741693157702684, 0.00013845103967469186, 0.005088488571345806, -0.014796962961554527, -0.01490075420588255, 0.06905631721019745, -0.014426068402826786, -0.02037256769835949, -0.008212076500058174, 0.024895060807466507, 0.05909214913845062, -0.04373890534043312, 0.012838825583457947, -0.04327424243092537, 0.012860390357673168, -0.009961315430700779, -0.03447435423731804, -0.01318324450403452, -0.03450801223516464, -0.04978659376502037, 0.027238819748163223, 0.07426831871271133, -0.057747360318899155, -0.03702607750892639, 0.031950365751981735, -0.03732939064502716, 0.01775171048939228, 0.017461825162172318, -0.003201504237949848, 0.0015953810652717948, 0.047675665467977524, -0.00546417897567153, 0.061946649104356766, 0.01732545904815197, 0.09627753496170044, -0.05347064882516861, -0.06468700617551804, 0.019420770928263664, -0.034661371260881424, 0.049085475504398346, 0.005896291229873896, 0.023336686193943024, 0.01708592101931572, 0.10639435797929764, 0.06663168966770172, -0.0050403159111738205, 0.021734090521931648, -0.017973171547055244, 0.07924555987119675, 0.00047447727411054075, -0.04527152702212334, 0.027317967265844345, -0.022296875715255737, 0.02500692941248417, 0.005524520296603441, -0.01962360367178917, -0.041122954338788986, 0.044047798961400986, 0.007888765074312687, 0.012493455782532692, -0.025705963373184204, 0.01996602490544319, 0.020782051607966423, 0.02038266509771347, -0.0703333392739296, -0.021629219874739647, 0.0441257618367672, 0.03144339099526405, -0.03077656589448452, -0.009489686228334904, 0.03739400953054428, -0.03379116207361221, 0.00656410725787282, -0.014406817965209484, 0.008414948359131813, -0.015273155644536018, -0.02389826811850071, -0.003107198281213641, -0.02881551906466484, -0.04462800920009613, 0.009783556684851646, -0.018948839977383614, 0.007634674198925495, -0.05887040123343468, 0.020937325432896614, 0.0590134896337986, -0.05545272305607796, 0.015094948001205921, 0.004758457653224468, 0.006808072328567505, -0.02369784750044346, -0.017365219071507454, 0.0111084608361125, -0.049480587244033813, 0.026313036680221558, 0.04852466657757759, -0.020894013345241547, 0.0064826905727386475, 0.015363354235887527, -0.00420211860910058, 0.04207613691687584, 0.01940707117319107, -0.019040456041693687, 0.009945787489414215, -0.023587346076965332, -0.03568565472960472, -0.04504120349884033, 0.04858461767435074, -0.031041055917739868, -0.01718928851187229, -0.02487913891673088, 0.02088337577879429, -0.013850797899067402, 0.05036820098757744, -0.0396706648170948, 0.027646172791719437, -0.00833946280181408, -0.007314876187592745, 0.04325789213180542, -0.05340654030442238, 0.018240980803966522, 0.027466392144560814, 0.04370066896080971, 0.006696627475321293, 0.011575324460864067, -0.084843210875988, 0.03469565510749817, 0.017450878396630287, -0.034453973174095154, 0.005314239300787449, 0.020845122635364532, -0.03252379223704338, 0.027746541425585747, 0.030697939917445183, -0.039761628955602646, 0.007836369797587395, 0.028676502406597137, 0.03534905984997749, -0.06713370978832245, 0.07336850464344025, 0.03345247730612755, -0.06999697536230087, 0.018857832998037338, 0.06241786479949951, 0.01610495150089264, -0.027464086189866066, 0.004406101070344448, -0.04544152691960335, -0.0062009855173528194, -0.0398312583565712, 0.004893803503364325, -0.003919693641364574, 0.01914350502192974, -0.03428022935986519, -0.029282240197062492, 0.027740299701690674, 0.06764868646860123, -0.09337639808654785, 0.0405375175178051, 0.044735901057720184, 0.04380492493510246, -0.010155647993087769, 0.0006391628994606435, -0.053711939603090286, 0.0023632741067558527, 0.07765141129493713, 0.037092652171850204, 0.03005504608154297, 0.0503857359290123, 0.0075606973841786385, -0.05788734182715416, -0.055690135806798935, 0.05897580459713936, -0.0226980559527874, 0.06230875849723816, 0.026781965047121048, -0.015778467059135437, 0.0006322907283902168, 0.03924474120140076, 0.05460626259446144, 0.012571840547025204, 0.004125012084841728, -0.052539482712745667, 0.024202721193432808, 0.03658230975270271, -0.02773955650627613, 0.0035326636862009764, -0.022724872455000877, -0.026104899123311043, 0.0013689500046893954, -0.00390309514477849, 0.04352123662829399, 0.0013098252238705754, 0.008897943422198296, -0.0003794658405240625, -0.001434273668564856, 0.03604695200920105, -0.04895002767443657, 0.004084512125700712, 0.02292441576719284, -0.012169459834694862, 0.032525110989809036, 0.008005497977137566, -0.00765501381829381, 0.015184012241661549, 0.007258246187120676, -0.045972514897584915, -0.013566435314714909, -0.009440438821911812, 0.00008877734944690019, 0.01539576891809702, -0.03859071061015129, -0.048525478690862656, 0.02857811376452446, -0.017609642818570137, -0.013306377455592155, -0.0400983989238739, 0.016763227060437202, -0.06015937775373459, 0.02428584359586239, -0.013658738695085049, -0.006735644303262234, -0.023207316175103188, 0.023238925263285637, 0.05275661498308182, -0.015507995150983334, 0.02855749987065792, -0.016041936352849007, 0.006421149242669344, -0.00013173578190617263, 0.009158747270703316, -0.003541151061654091, 0.05182817578315735, -0.03382038697600365, 0.02120506390929222, 0.008472028188407421, 0.009134285151958466, 0.07424842566251755, 0.024908015504479408, 0.021833060309290886, 0.03803010657429695, 0.021115897223353386, 0.05615338683128357, 0.01992822252213955, 0.007344703655689955, -0.026452284306287766, -0.0000883004249772057, 0.03273891657590866, -0.06598811596632004, -0.021059315651655197, 0.07097908854484558, -0.02745647542178631, -0.059126123785972595, -0.03968963772058487, -0.12346038967370987, -0.050392795354127884, 0.018572187051177025, 0.02982485294342041, -0.036132510751485825, 0.01670265942811966, 0.015255354344844818, -0.01950475201010704, 0.05023486167192459, -0.0861826241016388, 0.01592051237821579, 0.029152540490031242, 0.02779465541243553, -0.03921080753207207, 0.0001693862141110003, 0.093305803835392, 0.020849047228693962, -0.023352796211838722, 0.038032907992601395, 0.014718923717737198, -0.020950110629200935, -0.044493578374385834, -0.01439861673861742, -0.003983212169259787, -0.0181580800563097, -0.014137627556920052, -0.009267081506550312, -0.005398705136030912, -0.019905706867575645, -0.011152085848152637, -0.011953801847994328, 0.056392718106508255, -0.013080614618957043, 0.0009726561256684363, -0.01333332434296608, -0.017576202750205994, -0.09195947647094727, 0.03611888736486435, 0.03022836707532406, -0.01224895566701889, 0.020922046154737473, 0.008910023607313633, 0.08149833232164383, 0.01476347353309393, 0.04060486704111099, -0.006714734714478254, 0.004868741147220135, -0.007003026083111763, 0.048086099326610565, -0.052262477576732635, 0.0012020122958347201, 0.03034224733710289, -0.00877889059484005, -0.011327737011015415, 0.004682520870119333, 0.04387877508997917, 0.0033049152698367834, 0.015437006019055843, -0.05514753609895706, -0.006607217248529196, -0.022712256759405136, -0.029966112226247787, 0.048095256090164185, 0.002146991668269038, 0.004842255264520645, -0.015590470284223557, 0.006135024130344391, -0.0350891649723053, 0.026051471009850502, -0.025246405974030495, -0.0351831391453743, 0.057407498359680176, -0.001937731634825468, -0.03430934250354767, -0.006697369273751974, -0.048302583396434784, -0.06101582199335098, 0.04826734960079193, -0.001117499778047204, -0.024549825116991997, -0.0028080821502953768, 0.0018438969273120165, -0.01741722784936428, 0.024593442678451538, 0.012236052192747593, -0.045627765357494354, 0.030728930607438087, -0.0009109870879910886, 0.060846466571092606, 0.015312986448407173, 0.05218124017119408, -0.04367021098732948, -0.012518987990915775, -0.047602131962776184, 0.014758840203285217, -0.030664537101984024, -0.018592985346913338, 0.06166569143533707, -0.01652599684894085, 0.007039603311568499, 0.09069428592920303, -0.027003075927495956, -0.07252077013254166, 0.019739516079425812, -0.01761433482170105, -0.07771851122379303, 0.023416979238390923, 0.03616072237491608, -0.006197015289217234, -0.031678520143032074, -0.006929860450327396, -0.027101054787635803, 0.02258753404021263, -0.09589191526174545, 0.04589056968688965, -0.05832580476999283, -0.01436062715947628, -0.06528925150632858 ]
<p>One of the most disturbing aspects of General Relativity is the 'Marble versus Wood' duality of the theory: Matter creates curvature, and curvature doesn't create curvature (at least not directly)</p> <p>The holographic principle suggests a reason for this division: matter fields and gravity are paired to structures that exist in different dimensions: so 4D gravity (if taken over a finite region $\Omega$ of spacetime) should be paired with some (abstract or actual) 3D (2 spatial+1 time?) boundary $\partial \Omega$ where a QFT of some sort exists, but the curvature in this 4D spacetime is dictated by 4D distributed matter fields, which themselves might be related to some 5D gravity (possibly actual, but maybe unobservable) that has the 4D spacetime as part of its boundary. </p> <p>Arguably one could extend this idea to lower and higher dimensional mappings. Besides the pragmatic but inherently hard question about what could be gained by such insight, I'm asking if</p> <blockquote> <p>Has anyone tried to formulate physical theory in terms of a hierarchy of such mappings?</p> </blockquote> <p>It seems that such formulation would have to deal somehow with the fact that the boundary operator is nilpotent ($\partial \partial \Omega = 0$) when defining the hierarchy</p> <p>So, if the set $HM(D)$ gives all the possible meaningful holographic mappings between compact manifolds of dimension $D$ and their boundaries, then one can imagine that a full description of physics could be achieved by experimentally finding the elements $hm_0, hm_1...hm_X$ with $hm_i \in HM(i)$ and $X$ some maximum dimension above which all different mappings become completely unobservable at 4D</p>
g4244
[ 0.07699211686849594, 0.005686680320650339, -0.0035073943436145782, -0.016485171392560005, 0.013269606977701187, 0.04285023733973503, 0.03871503844857216, -0.009530335664749146, -0.008879163302481174, -0.01981346867978573, 0.0031322864815592766, -0.06300663203001022, 0.03991767391562462, -0.02690870687365532, -0.07382313162088394, 0.03470703586935997, 0.02981892041862011, 0.0320163257420063, -0.0035493974573910236, 0.025679774582386017, 0.018478402867913246, 0.009075942449271679, 0.02237522602081299, -0.06299753487110138, -0.0980052724480629, 0.006933662574738264, 0.01043170876801014, -0.05314919352531433, -0.04147099331021309, -0.0036949145141988993, -0.01571258343756199, 0.016050318256020546, -0.01054189819842577, -0.03876115009188652, -0.048548657447099686, -0.000946694693993777, 0.04914768785238266, 0.08354685455560684, -0.0036987196654081345, 0.008658981882035732, -0.014200471341609955, -0.022451126947999, -0.003343506483361125, -0.022475939244031906, -0.04326900839805603, 0.04498855024576187, 0.006343152839690447, 0.029579639434814453, 0.028345398604869843, -0.004844392649829388, -0.006988943554461002, 0.04299124702811241, 0.0030029257759451866, 0.02173217572271824, -0.006882294546812773, 0.06131826713681221, 0.038193438202142715, 0.03702577203512192, 0.05458170175552368, -0.046723540872335434, -0.05558333545923233, 0.053272806107997894, 0.00022990557772573084, 0.07755452394485474, 0.08232173323631287, 0.017577815800905228, -0.06643252819776535, -0.07609858363866806, 0.028836378827691078, -0.0037353839725255966, 0.02086355723440647, -0.03657977283000946, 0.04625982046127319, 0.02394183911383152, -0.00785652082413435, 0.07744643837213516, 0.01054762676358223, -0.01707679033279419, -0.030162561684846878, -0.03666447103023529, -0.019911043345928192, 0.004202008247375488, 0.05986736714839935, 0.016426030546426773, 0.06408009678125381, -0.0030745663680136204, 0.034777045249938965, 0.009064610116183758, -0.013259044848382473, 0.050250787287950516, -0.055208366364240646, 0.000780842499807477, 0.03660000488162041, 0.00937314610928297, 0.02439061366021633, -0.046214763075113297, 0.016486966982483864, -0.00973425805568695, -0.05943915247917175, -0.007642403710633516, -0.03201635554432869, 0.03355120122432709, 0.07370898872613907, 0.033492885529994965, 0.019087644293904305, -0.029510831460356712, 0.027199776843190193, -0.01899459771811962, 0.027764614671468735, 0.0034649334847927094, -0.007030831184238195, 0.017036937177181244, -0.0626489669084549, 0.023027481511235237, -0.015418591909110546, -0.04809660091996193, 0.007258275523781776, -0.027503948658704758, -0.06706549227237701, 0.07656115293502808, -0.023034604266285896, 0.02842012792825699, 0.039109669625759125, 0.008141590282320976, -0.02264021523296833, 0.0544443316757679, 0.0160183385014534, -0.022286687046289444, 0.016672750934958458, -0.04502252861857414, 0.026924962177872658, 0.03447386249899864, 0.03938687592744827, -0.006641715299338102, 0.009701342321932316, 0.04175063222646713, 0.013570871204137802, -0.02641935460269451, 0.023234093561768532, -0.01959998905658722, -0.07434844225645065, -0.05313635244965553, -0.040728066116571426, -0.04241970553994179, 0.014854906126856804, 0.0749744400382042, 0.04917631670832634, -0.011385214515030384, 0.01425881590694189, 0.015029173344373703, 0.02310175448656082, 0.07948500663042068, -0.002282443456351757, -0.0106183011084795, 0.054820507764816284, 0.05552345886826515, 0.01906881108880043, -0.0027094001416116953, 0.007194400765001774, -0.05949512496590614, -0.03217872977256775, 0.02906098961830139, -0.019614843651652336, -0.031954988837242126, -0.017068449407815933, 0.007647218648344278, 0.010416712611913681, -0.010232833214104176, 0.035751257091760635, -0.07025317847728729, -0.07361986488103867, 0.04088592156767845, 0.016695577651262283, 0.05089579522609711, 0.006014460697770119, 0.028163865208625793, -0.04547432065010071, -0.018830357119441032, -0.031969811767339706, 0.04214216023683548, 0.021653776988387108, -0.08506889641284943, 0.040239445865154266, 0.006232307758182287, 0.026943769305944443, 0.013093000277876854, -0.0015469110803678632, -0.002531263045966625, -0.0060525876469910145, 0.034507110714912415, -0.032586026936769485, -0.007085131481289864, 0.01355730090290308, 0.002489099744707346, 0.0505005307495594, 0.034640830010175705, 0.045514315366744995, -0.018990015611052513, 0.04285569489002228, 0.03998490050435066, 0.02493383176624775, 0.05984873324632645, 0.024900559335947037, -0.016287757083773613, 0.04757349565625191, 0.03077147714793682, -0.0396202877163887, 0.00769211258739233, 0.007840273901820183, -0.00527970353141427, -0.035177480429410934, -0.06463654339313507, 0.02447632886469364, 0.003319868817925453, -0.0023840044159442186, 0.003654788015410304, 0.019850241020321846, 0.017213452607393265, -0.00908372551202774, 0.03254234418272972, -0.01373881846666336, 0.011484161950647831, 0.0024266333784908056, 0.019338274374604225, -0.027757691219449043, -0.010386303067207336, -0.028733763843774796, -0.006031121592968702, -0.04360949620604515, -0.03777158632874489, -0.034171946346759796, -0.023534638807177544, 0.034849122166633606, -0.047853030264377594, 0.017311472445726395, 0.02513928711414337, -0.006272387225180864, -0.06877146661281586, 0.02220115065574646, 0.004725656937807798, 0.04546205699443817, -0.028684396296739578, -0.017999233677983284, 0.003060057060793042, 0.06677310913801193, -0.023516567423939705, 0.041851870715618134, 0.009145725518465042, -0.01757993921637535, 0.0435628816485405, 0.024185998365283012, -0.022669844329357147, -0.04744354262948036, -0.03768114373087883, 0.04558007791638374, -0.014396751299500465, 0.039843134582042694, 0.005180069245398045, -0.07665494084358215, -0.05197176709771156, 0.015834035351872444, -0.023325210437178612, -0.022961871698498726, 0.023938562721014023, -0.0796477198600769, -0.02200942672789097, -0.005405172239989042, -0.001330029801465571, -0.06156136840581894, 0.07529491931200027, -0.008954038843512535, 0.03858836367726326, 0.01858990266919136, -0.00493967067450285, -0.07132362574338913, 0.04076707735657692, -0.029635632410645485, -0.015294981189072132, -0.005795992445200682, -0.008837633766233921, 0.03225097432732582, -0.006571574602276087, -0.048246607184410095, -0.05236539989709854, -0.005802668631076813, -0.003565021324902773, -0.03572370484471321, -0.030550487339496613, -0.016212288290262222, 0.01952701061964035, -0.004452322609722614, -0.01739872433245182, 0.009659872390329838, 0.006051973905414343, -0.038436852395534515, 0.008709036745131016, -0.03995492309331894, -0.013903084211051464, -0.06906742602586746, -0.003543091705068946, -0.07828293740749359, -0.00383583502843976, 0.0667947381734848, 0.03335082530975342, -0.042703427374362946, -0.025396306067705154, -0.023998569697141647, -0.04672008007764816, -0.0176997110247612, -0.002634101314470172, 0.029222818091511726, 0.034479446709156036, -0.014104194939136505, -0.021363558247685432, -0.0010197998490184546, -0.027618374675512314, -0.003389002289623022, 0.011587061919271946, -0.005384719464927912, -0.04076216742396355, -0.00884689949452877, -0.014685765840113163, -0.06924532353878021, -0.008701156824827194, -0.00854893121868372, 0.04439409449696541, -0.0405433215200901, -0.02450467273592949, -0.03474954143166542, 0.048825062811374664, 0.036035019904375076, -0.04208971932530403, 0.06353919953107834, 0.05857012793421745, -0.029923470690846443, -0.008348441682755947, -0.10342677682638168, -0.01590859517455101, 0.08585522323846817, -0.018421689048409462, 0.003416340798139572, 0.004106552805751562, -0.05651170015335083, 0.024383531883358955, 0.013536419719457626, 0.010199048556387424, 0.03591879457235336, 0.04752740636467934, -0.008984212763607502, -0.0464116707444191, -0.0327887199819088, 0.008275090716779232, 0.028725935146212578, 0.02911929041147232, 0.08680694550275803, 0.03899526968598366, 0.03878313675522804, 0.06177163124084473, 0.04241255670785904, -0.006055003497749567, 0.013156809844076633, 0.009958354756236076, -0.040825773030519485, -0.008869326673448086, 0.024187345057725906, -0.005637018475681543, 0.023721620440483093, -0.005644642747938633, -0.08515430986881256, 0.011082980781793594, 0.11038827151060104, -0.06711413711309433, -0.04155541956424713, 0.055491600185632706, 0.034942012280225754, -0.023671358823776245, -0.01211409829556942, -0.03632001951336861, 0.02253592573106289, -0.023510858416557312, -0.03391608968377113, 0.05039864778518677, 0.0728520080447197, 0.02184022031724453, -0.0010264194570481777, -0.021635115146636963, -0.07404575496912003, -0.06247745081782341, 0.04387577995657921, 0.005399331450462341, -0.06840680539608002, -0.008510429412126541, -0.053294382989406586, -0.009487698785960674, 0.031732380390167236, 0.022007877007126808, -0.015159652568399906, 0.034530531615018845, -0.007614433765411377, -0.02324206940829754, 0.006227969657629728, -0.02725936844944954, -0.006681252736598253, 0.0015696596819907427, -0.0290832556784153, -0.059149596840143204, -0.007566936779767275, 0.01767314225435257, 0.010271354578435421, -0.02051306702196598, 0.003139704931527376, -0.04602537304162979, -0.004381491802632809, -0.028792640194296837, 0.06482242792844772, -0.030777303501963615, 0.015562442131340504, 0.002568514784798026, 0.003336658701300621, 0.0368255190551281, 0.015731845051050186, 0.06430674344301224, -0.026508407667279243, 0.021818479523062706, 0.06147203966975212, 0.02933838963508606, -0.021467840299010277, -0.021913502365350723, -0.052604369819164276, -0.00010443945211591199, 0.03491263464093208, -0.013116268441081047, -0.016862060874700546, 0.017595365643501282, -0.034577544778585434, 0.014808602631092072, -0.05483511835336685, -0.037802260369062424, 0.00789547711610794, -0.01833614520728588, 0.03642026707530022, -0.013818948529660702, -0.0035217704717069864, 0.026260603219270706, 0.037942785769701004, 0.01590357907116413, -0.03966768831014633, -0.013651013374328613, -0.0485994853079319, -0.03252791240811348, 0.023697929456830025, -0.02754279226064682, -0.04654833301901817, 0.017741460353136063, 0.00012143448111601174, -0.008130937814712524, -0.029485851526260376, -0.01563441753387451, -0.001125531503930688, -0.014398499391973019, -0.06089296191930771, 0.02875453419983387, 0.021278804168105125, -0.00782764982432127, 0.0009691534214653075, -0.03317456692457199, -0.12104273587465286, -0.0014276374131441116, -0.019769299775362015, 0.025811398401856422, 0.014287490397691727, -0.003892303444445133, 0.0030506709590554237, -0.01454114355146885, -0.013181141577661037, 0.020220758393406868, -0.011637160554528236, 0.016181813552975655, -0.04002711921930313, -0.09448520839214325, 0.021842408925294876, -0.004341128282248974, 0.03093835711479187, 0.02880406193435192, -0.019782191142439842, 0.014977963641285896, -0.03876342251896858, -0.0038967025466263294, -0.005713122431188822, 0.00953920092433691, -0.01786748133599758, 0.018540285527706146, -0.013825313188135624, 0.021462291479110718, -0.020680859684944153, -0.06185818463563919, 0.004990783054381609, -0.012930994853377342, -0.07390840351581573, -0.058335866779088974, -0.008535061031579971, 0.03527509421110153, 0.02307388372719288, -0.041771017014980316, 0.0008820005459710956, 0.029324114322662354, 0.09573645889759064, -0.003511725226417184, 0.020238328725099564, -0.0012978578452020884, -0.009703103452920914, -0.00033575278939679265, -0.035817019641399384, 0.06621801853179932, 0.03268228843808174, -0.03620224446058273, -0.030540326610207558, 0.03313237056136131, 0.021942798048257828, -0.02284502051770687, -0.003873406909406185, -0.00656821159645915, 0.01844620704650879, 0.01962074264883995, 0.08149676769971848, 0.04193764552474022, 0.007581949699670076, 0.014958777464926243, -0.009100744500756264, 0.0616731122136116, 0.0487314835190773, 0.004997692536562681, 0.03531084209680557, 0.03152528777718544, 0.021851643919944763, -0.05102940648794174, 0.0515575110912323, 0.052863262593746185, 0.08054030686616898, 0.04134334623813629, -0.05067736655473709, 0.00943090207874775, -0.01161534246057272, 0.04107796028256416, -0.002254517050459981, -0.008983958512544632, -0.039242252707481384, 0.01975376531481743, 0.07589787244796753, -0.030312703922390938, -0.016277294605970383, -0.060410141944885254, 0.01938800886273384, 0.05239835008978844, -0.049835290759801865, -0.019811702892184258, -0.010073928162455559, -0.07082495093345642, -0.014428968541324139, 0.0014450461603701115, 0.0410042330622673, 0.04393157735466957, -0.004268948454409838, -0.012373220175504684, -0.03765817731618881, -0.012242380529642105, -0.004851863719522953, -0.018049880862236023, 0.06767862290143967, -0.031988874077796936, -0.033050213009119034, -0.0114895636215806, 0.017135867848992348, 0.09445684403181076, -0.0002816363994497806, -0.015962233766913414, -0.034943319857120514, -0.017517104744911194, -0.04452451318502426, 0.02558143436908722, -0.009139585308730602, 0.04422089084982872, 0.058597173541784286, -0.014835773035883904, -0.03286582976579666, 0.003717444371432066, -0.02489681914448738, -0.013783838599920273, -0.014288828708231449, 0.006124819163233042, 0.019514834508299828, 0.03306436538696289, -0.018964525312185287, 0.05155733600258827, 0.04602266848087311, 0.018237724900245667, 0.05637560039758682, 0.018458902835845947, -0.03020191378891468, -0.014728128910064697, 0.029497751966118813, 0.001991847064346075, -0.008628173731267452, -0.01865497976541519, 0.021954886615276337, 0.08117111027240753, -0.05402807891368866, -0.025486595928668976, 0.010198401287198067, 0.011096389964222908, 0.05135185271501541, 0.03441814333200455, -0.04959679767489433, 0.042968329042196274, -0.025244148448109627, -0.010416939854621887, 0.024567438289523125, -0.03548474982380867, -0.010270040482282639, 0.014110760763287544, 0.0391320139169693, 0.05667722970247269, 0.013237438164651394, -0.025292610749602318, 0.031656619161367416, -0.006981466431170702, 0.009464845061302185, -0.0241024661809206, -0.018915243446826935, 0.023204941302537918, -0.0046417731791734695, -0.04490039870142937, 0.043013475835323334, 0.03884337842464447, -0.00833702739328146, -0.0048269247636199, -0.031112730503082275, -0.019420919939875603, 0.0005993171944282949, 0.026481393724679947, 0.04321441799402237, -0.06974633783102036, 0.023988785222172737, 0.0050439415499567986, -0.0050185685977339745, -0.053118493407964706, -0.012638195417821407, 0.005696836858987808, -0.058433517813682556, 0.01068955473601818, 0.02448321506381035, 0.05303667485713959, -0.021159598603844643, -0.015878159552812576, -0.09973137825727463, 0.00935934018343687, -0.02157336100935936, -0.0010904375230893493, -0.01586393639445305, -0.013548039831221104, 0.009003628976643085, -0.010381004773080349, -0.00023312310804612935, -0.008416454307734966, -0.06783054769039154, -0.011351033113896847, 0.010287958197295666, 0.057481907308101654, -0.008689499460160732, 0.011981729418039322, 0.044112011790275574, -0.02164650335907936, 0.0026907373685389757, 0.04130705073475838, -0.03304295986890793, -0.056623343378305435, 0.016212044283747673, 0.06210556998848915, -0.0034412634558975697, 0.007533299271017313, -0.012628346681594849, 0.08879289031028748, 0.0476643368601799, 0.024696866050362587, -0.02218989096581936, -0.022583458572626114, 0.05113359913229942, 0.020992698147892952, -0.015893280506134033, 0.037629857659339905, -0.008092846721410751, -0.007231030613183975, -0.007059799041599035, -0.008680948987603188, -0.01654505543410778, 0.024172673001885414, 0.029977314174175262, 0.021186264231801033, -0.02752039022743702, 0.007428369950503111, -0.06348180025815964, -0.017291538417339325, -0.00993513222783804, -0.027396831661462784, 0.010663818567991257, -0.028929533436894417, 0.007865197025239468, -0.002125207567587495, -0.017156075686216354, 0.041855864226818085, -0.0008654308621771634, 0.1392260193824768, 0.005569780711084604, -0.03568315505981445, 0.02511502429842949, -0.05949918553233147, -0.024946659803390503, -0.0784212201833725, 0.011637983843684196, -0.04575077444314957, -0.0011698149610310793, 0.006701418664306402, -0.043102845549583435, -0.07821007817983627, 0.023836549371480942, 0.020679567009210587, 0.03632513806223869, -0.05727403610944748, -0.014788311906158924, 0.02562943659722805, -0.011314709670841694, 0.03338988497853279, 0.013088228181004524, 0.013547824695706367, -0.042760640382766724, 0.009450291283428669, 0.0032775457948446274, -0.016915492713451385, 0.03316846117377281, -0.02284010872244835, -0.03909534960985184, -0.028783299028873444, 0.006294697988778353, -0.07001025229692459, 0.012744786217808723, -0.04723019152879715, -0.030252525582909584, 0.003066153032705188, 0.03691231831908226, -0.028490127995610237, -0.03530203923583031, 0.016171770170331, 0.04504614695906639, -0.027086392045021057, 0.03357661888003349, -0.07587938010692596, 0.026820944622159004, 0.009702702984213829, 0.015773434191942215, -0.006052596028894186, 0.009670187719166279, -0.06350330263376236, 0.039053548127412796, 0.013378500938415527, -0.05921027064323425, 0.021622121334075928, 0.017719632014632225, 0.026350537315011024 ]
<p>A wire placed in a magnetic field and has current flowing, it will experience the Lorentz force, work is done by the electric field and energy is conserved. Being converted from the power source to KE, and the wire moves.</p> <p>How can we apply Poynting's theorem to state that this system's energy will always be conserved?</p> <p>To fully observe the conservation of energy from the power source is equal to the work done by the wire when it gains KE.</p>
g4245
[ 0.03620419278740883, 0.01730814203619957, -0.001612190157175064, -0.015963727608323097, -0.004243062809109688, -0.005736490245908499, 0.001083704293705523, 0.022522788494825363, -0.051092226058244705, 0.004966035485267639, -0.031683314591646194, -0.015558778308331966, -0.07980144768953323, 0.01088878232985735, 0.001273631234653294, 0.027099475264549255, 0.06515853106975555, -0.013746246695518494, 0.06957760453224182, 0.04872111231088638, 0.01572149060666561, 0.013404917903244495, 0.007631104905158281, -0.022203514352440834, 0.005619273521006107, -0.012794858776032925, 0.010384582914412022, -0.028122562915086746, -0.04756203666329384, -0.08335728198289871, 0.023708755150437355, 0.03006180189549923, 0.044459957629442215, -0.04001940041780472, -0.033924516290426254, 0.002455026376992464, 0.04358908534049988, 0.0458109974861145, 0.02561923861503601, -0.00930004008114338, 0.005481168627738953, 0.054337017238140106, 0.019080957397818565, 0.026944421231746674, -0.02618292160332203, -0.053785502910614014, -0.054424505680799484, -0.04254977032542229, -0.03761996701359749, 0.023147273808717728, -0.007741841021925211, 0.023180294781923294, 0.008576580323278904, 0.02107648178935051, 0.01909499615430832, -0.026072530075907707, 0.02410898730158806, -0.04230419173836708, -0.004809250123798847, 0.00021450474741868675, 0.009580100886523724, 0.004139604512602091, 0.003038151655346155, 0.031125472858548164, 0.031999584287405014, -0.04650595039129257, -0.04421071335673332, 0.011839821003377438, -0.00015071945381350815, 0.02215092070400715, 0.012965768575668335, -0.009933636523783207, 0.01839735358953476, -0.009116319939494133, 0.04628891870379448, 0.023341910913586617, -0.00933773536235094, -0.00053577491780743, 0.02443874627351761, -0.012405382469296455, -0.07573357224464417, 0.004079130012542009, -0.007337797898799181, 0.022020725533366203, 0.09591032564640045, 0.04158468544483185, -0.005616416689008474, -0.028551531955599785, 0.007574550807476044, 0.06649777293205261, 0.024474428966641426, 0.0054942225106060505, 0.08773026615381241, -0.01764863356947899, 0.021326404064893723, 0.015173623338341713, 0.020310400053858757, 0.04682041332125664, -0.027762586250901222, -0.018954869359731674, -0.04081160947680473, -0.059343066066503525, -0.07474028319120407, 0.013409141451120377, 0.054086167365312576, 0.05937758833169937, -0.013151939958333969, -0.006377645768225193, -0.025964289903640747, 0.023778844624757767, 0.01804511435329914, -0.06906548887491226, -0.072060227394104, 0.029914170503616333, -0.015151571482419968, -0.031421687453985214, 0.03979841619729996, 0.027341792359948158, -0.018010597676038742, 0.06262213736772537, -0.0035816861782222986, 0.0012505464255809784, -0.01101025938987732, 0.05191544070839882, -0.008187804371118546, 0.050901368260383606, -0.017476117238402367, 0.01990671269595623, 0.01603267714381218, 0.0014228890649974346, 0.027265973389148712, -0.01333516277372837, 0.022966336458921432, -0.012969140894711018, 0.044972795993089676, 0.02037774957716465, 0.005105959717184305, 0.02102743834257126, 0.04751268029212952, 0.002806305419653654, -0.017501067370176315, -0.08617676794528961, -0.007105703931301832, -0.03838932886719704, -0.008896428160369396, 0.0020651305094361305, 0.02873639203608036, -0.009789835661649704, 0.03757582604885101, 0.03804842755198479, 0.0065545677207410336, 0.12461791187524796, 0.000697476090863347, -0.045714136213064194, 0.0719577893614769, -0.04389553144574165, 0.03776150569319725, -0.06886667013168335, 0.00635962188243866, 0.004198966082185507, 0.03832726925611496, -0.030120663344860077, 0.06701277196407318, -0.02730550430715084, -0.02392844669520855, -0.020252464339137077, 0.0007240674458444118, -0.06110049784183502, 0.013873066753149033, -0.03129860758781433, -0.07188591361045837, -0.04026948660612106, 0.0357477106153965, 0.04397917911410332, -0.010073752142488956, 0.06038879603147507, 0.0007639362011104822, -0.008892657235264778, -0.010053083300590515, -0.04579003527760506, -0.02894878201186657, -0.02716291882097721, 0.07706809788942337, -0.014458760619163513, -0.052719879895448685, 0.05547335371375084, -0.04361579939723015, 0.01172325573861599, -0.07722444832324982, -0.0022518860641866922, -0.017153847962617874, 0.02547173574566841, -0.027005018666386604, 0.02678871341049671, -0.03781202435493469, -0.0007048920379020274, -0.011566516011953354, -0.022088466212153435, -0.02685800939798355, 0.007913172245025635, 0.010690289549529552, 0.022123025730252266, 0.02355211041867733, -0.007643728982657194, 0.014959666877985, -0.004227576311677694, -0.014640740118920803, 0.0136847710236907, 0.050319261848926544, -0.057517148554325104, 0.030924955382943153, -0.003295946167781949, -0.01728697679936886, 0.023788338527083397, 0.008105706423521042, -0.024476733058691025, -0.033319294452667236, -0.0010514546884223819, -0.04739880561828613, -0.0008787063998170197, -0.049899954348802567, -0.014410967007279396, 0.09423170983791351, 0.028058873489499092, -0.07708335667848587, -0.009382513351738453, -0.0346158929169178, -0.04499529302120209, -0.01769849844276905, 0.02320866659283638, -0.04745791479945183, 0.03449142351746559, 0.001718002837151289, 0.02281835488975048, 0.06262992322444916, 0.05094084516167641, -0.012361973524093628, 0.0005039147799834609, 0.013667070306837559, 0.008092707954347134, -0.018076149746775627, 0.015400940552353859, -0.014159619808197021, -0.005519053898751736, 0.019499871879816055, 0.0012309971498325467, 0.04706941545009613, 0.01215730793774128, 0.0037704966962337494, 0.009618818759918213, 0.07389731705188751, -0.05011608824133873, 0.014819922856986523, 0.036643046885728836, 0.05406179279088974, -0.032228823751211166, -0.047072168439626694, 0.01590763032436371, -0.07120466232299805, -0.05185966566205025, 0.03751370310783386, -0.010472968220710754, 0.04135395586490631, 0.043953098356723785, 0.00479695713147521, 0.013890116475522518, -0.009045287035405636, -0.031173720955848694, -0.004038417711853981, -0.01812550239264965, -0.04685381427407265, 0.07422264665365219, -0.03710872679948807, 0.03331300616264343, -0.015109248459339142, -0.040619514882564545, 0.04295943304896355, -0.00501416577026248, -0.003832165151834488, -0.001376276952214539, -0.04328667372465134, -0.011685521341860294, -0.038637675344944, 0.03908944129943848, -0.021830465644598007, -0.0113396430388093, -0.017549853771924973, -0.049038104712963104, 0.017977692186832428, -0.021440517157316208, -0.08264476805925369, 0.005776701960712671, 0.03925413638353348, -0.061993714421987534, -0.042766913771629333, -0.0019877415616065264, 0.00013962159573566169, -0.04042670875787735, -0.02277752012014389, 0.05587491765618324, 0.011153033934533596, -0.03283388540148735, -0.007576613686978817, 0.030704522505402565, 0.04661718010902405, 0.05870278179645538, -0.052790567278862, -0.047395143657922745, 0.02168797329068184, 0.002593359211459756, -0.030678654089570045, 0.012203127145767212, 0.027795335277915, -0.06010083854198456, -0.008887718431651592, -0.008064829744398594, 0.008455280214548111, -0.03744785487651825, 0.06376808881759644, -0.021709011867642403, 0.03222382813692093, 0.01728840544819832, 0.0202180165797472, -0.028996825218200684, 0.014593799598515034, 0.01954515278339386, -0.039440952241420746, 0.03053537756204605, -0.024195760488510132, 0.039963364601135254, -0.0055277226492762566, 0.009637976065278053, 0.017273031175136566, -0.03433031588792801, -0.011395154520869255, -0.024271951988339424, -0.034153591841459274, -0.002195140114054084, -0.03875495493412018, 0.032353486865758896, -0.030383847653865814, -0.04545232653617859, -0.08238140493631363, -0.007392590865492821, 0.004007443320006132, 0.0231460053473711, -0.013006459921598434, -0.039508920162916183, 0.08640601485967636, -0.047881487756967545, 0.0773109570145607, -0.0075928820297122, -0.006579353008419275, -0.005857114680111408, -0.01884542405605316, 0.004319765139371157, -0.03121877834200859, 0.005944870878010988, -0.05295732244849205, 0.01616622693836689, 0.012103709392249584, 0.005151924677193165, 0.07552437484264374, 0.01768660917878151, -0.021499235183000565, 0.04965004697442055, 0.0024252538569271564, 0.02879224717617035, 0.009001510217785835, -0.009818176738917828, -0.030575741082429886, -0.00008421438542427495, -0.01874934881925583, -0.007257940713316202, 0.03440433368086815, -0.018591001629829407, 0.031242134049534798, 0.011204884387552738, -0.02371504157781601, 0.029675211757421494, 0.0195173267275095, 0.04752583056688309, -0.07791593670845032, 0.048155851662158966, 0.041770484298467636, 0.04662543907761574, 0.004678437020629644, 0.04996584728360176, 0.03603552281856537, 0.022475576028227806, 0.03255992382764816, -0.015763381496071815, 0.031303152441978455, -0.005325346253812313, 0.004662469495087862, -0.018289893865585327, 0.032393015921115875, -0.02149324305355549, -0.00008484897261951119, -0.009810419753193855, -0.023015812039375305, 0.06062912195920944, -0.03654161095619202, -0.007379516959190369, 0.007098611444234848, -0.021934010088443756, 0.06502922624349594, -0.013945164158940315, 0.026437150314450264, 0.027100322768092155, 0.013191086240112782, -0.016151653602719307, 0.009939666837453842, -0.036544524133205414, 0.04058824107050896, -0.015522480942308903, 0.00786252785474062, -0.01568485051393509, 0.044375814497470856, -0.04476432129740715, 0.03497518599033356, 0.0740150511264801, 0.04211074113845825, -0.04581661894917488, -0.057211440056562424, 0.05263476446270943, 0.06409923732280731, 0.015510511584579945, -0.010860372334718704, -0.046986330300569534, 0.0431230328977108, 0.01705196499824524, 0.009252776391804218, -0.026423752307891846, -0.1059517040848732, 0.03374626860022545, -0.013569600880146027, -0.0060591306537389755, -0.030484944581985474, 0.05463358387351036, 0.09036341309547424, -0.01545077282935381, -0.008519021794199944, -0.023542774841189384, -0.028565673157572746, 0.05473226308822632, -0.02481755241751671, -0.05253195762634277, 0.03218653425574303, -0.05291802063584328, -0.0184777919203043, -0.034127674996852875, -0.02131880447268486, 0.008040902204811573, 0.014198456890881062, -0.007462893147021532, -0.03007061406970024, -0.0902940034866333, 0.06892622262239456, 0.04238447546958923, -0.05156733840703964, -0.003991617821156979, -0.0018405652372166514, 0.045737411826848984, -0.01364402286708355, 0.04484979063272476, -0.045171357691287994, -0.005045705940574408, -0.09501688927412033, 0.04655250534415245, 0.05123542994260788, 0.03399167209863663, 0.022594960406422615, 0.005509953014552593, 0.01153356023132801, -0.016833433881402016, -0.0033165980130434036, -0.018555108457803726, 0.06551740318536758, -0.03715416043996811, -0.022566594183444977, -0.02094297856092453, -0.02392164058983326, 0.00885096937417984, -0.007630134467035532, 0.02770456112921238, -0.010168897919356823, 0.01252051256597042, -0.024855202063918114, -0.041426822543144226, 0.0011231633834540844, 0.06252289563417435, 0.09441360086202621, -0.024154603481292725, -0.005976270884275436, 0.016496548429131508, -0.007169809658080339, -0.04781385511159897, -0.027384284883737564, -0.00218059029430151, -0.047593068331480026, -0.023182271048426628, -0.07086963206529617, -0.012730365619063377, -0.01144846435636282, 0.0800601914525032, 0.025462310761213303, 0.013232128694653511, -0.049141597002744675, 0.01123439148068428, -0.05176777392625809, 0.028425052762031555, 0.025633223354816437, 0.03280050680041313, 0.07463092356920242, 0.0006166736711747944, -0.03936513513326645, -0.013733726926147938, -0.05935991182923317, 0.012752898037433624, 0.06366798281669617, 0.06952490657567978, 0.010966918431222439, -0.03258654847741127, 0.016618812456727028, 0.06751173734664917, -0.056812550872564316, 0.010785054415464401, 0.014744880609214306, -0.006647791713476181, 0.03464147448539734, 0.0008773909066803753, -0.019435610622167587, 0.024664033204317093, 0.01451331190764904, 0.0018542659236118197, -0.010129957459867, -0.036525335162878036, 0.02164141647517681, 0.012965820729732513, -0.007007409352809191, -0.040156371891498566, 0.05907808989286423, 0.03032449632883072, -0.010104936547577381, 0.01399285439401865, -0.004935172852128744, -0.02034422755241394, 0.0175547506660223, -0.05924062058329582, -0.05296818166971207, 0.03745214268565178, -0.013303264044225216, 0.007858235388994217, 0.008395511656999588, 0.006445952691137791, 0.02403639443218708, -0.0513581745326519, -0.0240852739661932, -0.009749912656843662, 0.007251847069710493, 0.020825643092393875, -0.0012436932884156704, 0.02376401238143444, 0.05640590563416481, -0.05689316987991333, -0.015655798837542534, 0.030440624803304672, 0.0347549207508564, 0.05545873939990997, -0.04740164056420326, 0.006097288802266121, -0.029097015038132668, 0.033591218292713165, 0.006099157966673374, -0.022147411480545998, -0.053187038749456406, -0.059425290673971176, -0.04432889446616173, 0.006479485891759396, 0.016001775860786438, 0.013454949483275414, 0.000523207476362586, -0.04673361778259277, 0.012857399880886078, 0.002958103781566024, -0.014997346326708794, 0.06994813680648804, 0.05548401549458504, 0.06396162509918213, 0.02755320444703102, 0.010682311840355396, 0.004531757440418005, 0.021218175068497658, -0.01988787017762661, 0.024601127952337265, -0.046071607619524, -0.007326669525355101, -0.04364681616425514, 0.10423523187637329, -0.0552779845893383, -0.0460386723279953, 0.00839302409440279, -0.08453809469938278, 0.03045877255499363, 0.012039615772664547, -0.00971202552318573, 0.03784487023949623, -0.011557955294847488, -0.00012365987640805542, 0.02899816818535328, -0.02397308312356472, 0.01719863899052143, -0.003558808472007513, -0.005638372618705034, 0.030234813690185547, 0.023448729887604713, -0.04132022336125374, -0.013091668486595154, 0.03696386143565178, 0.015143399126827717, -0.02876570075750351, 0.0005429881275631487, -0.014393460005521774, 0.08181237429380417, 0.03066798858344555, -0.07516741752624512, 0.031943242996931076, 0.023878464475274086, 0.034431036561727524, -0.060523055493831635, 0.05702389404177666, -0.042563360184431076, 0.04309665411710739, 0.0011653703404590487, 0.005056019406765699, 0.04380542039871216, -0.04811225086450577, 0.08126021921634674, 0.02808084525167942, -0.04599347710609436, 0.07749591022729874, 0.05557987838983536, 0.0145575487986207, -0.09523165225982666, -0.02633686363697052, -0.02627691999077797, 0.0032083236146718264, -0.03983556851744652, -0.007848363369703293, -0.008284198120236397, -0.031173190101981163, 0.013650967739522457, 0.012027614749968052, -0.04248902201652527, 0.03276294097304344, -0.028895879164338112, -0.03127792850136757, 0.0005775215686298907, -0.05041546747088432, 0.02049585059285164, -0.06443635374307632, 0.03039581887423992, -0.04258885607123375, 0.028411248698830605, -0.027368303388357162, -0.008137947879731655, -0.028432361781597137, -0.012597044929862022, 0.017250817269086838, -0.05598324164748192, -0.08719754219055176, -0.00990336388349533, 0.027753224596381187, 0.00156074995175004, -0.05008424445986748, 0.006657884921878576, 0.009222755208611488, 0.001330427941866219, -0.002473765518516302, -0.07262493669986725, 0.020768677815794945, -0.05235328525304794, -0.03900706768035889, 0.031803619116544724, 0.0009726553107611835, -0.05093326419591904, 0.014826583676040173, 0.01610114984214306, -0.007290148641914129, -0.015743888914585114, 0.015358428470790386, 0.0752577930688858, -0.013865037821233273, -0.0464191660284996, 0.014404344372451305, 0.049616653472185135, -0.00126832933165133, 0.007758449763059616, 0.0023324808571487665, 0.020637907087802887, -0.017041247338056564, -0.007293769624084234, 0.06097867712378502, -0.03772663325071335, -0.01668674126267433, -0.029406722635030746, -0.04509957507252693, -0.054404377937316895, 0.04309897869825363, -0.02477799542248249, 0.03116060048341751, -0.009608120657503605, 0.018080759793519974, 0.025767410174012184, -0.00914690550416708, -0.02707412838935852, -0.0081576993688941, 0.032540298998355865, 0.013140477240085602, -0.005051363725215197, 0.005740119609981775, -0.015185888856649399, -0.0498989000916481, 0.01724066771566868, -0.016278132796287537, -0.006296023726463318, -0.025960326194763184, -0.05567687749862671, -0.03196660429239273, -0.030682576820254326, -0.019711120054125786, 0.004161338321864605, -0.05404488369822502, -0.037103328853845596, -0.0049955169670283794, -0.02266574092209339, -0.02997000701725483, -0.02945546992123127, 0.030537107959389687, 0.024633444845676422, -0.009030704386532307, 0.008276710286736488, -0.038722872734069824, 0.013002716936171055, 0.031551700085401535, -0.02757927030324936, 0.044419825077056885, 0.03246442601084709, -0.04962224140763283, 0.026345811784267426, 0.0413125678896904, -0.03141270950436592, 0.025874344632029533, 0.05565377697348595, -0.01449340395629406, 0.016726987436413765, -0.02342631295323372, 0.0005443439004011452, 0.08968231081962585, -0.03656382858753204, -0.015419716015458107, -0.009673526510596275, -0.01553999911993742, -0.01324446126818657, -0.0638856366276741, 0.01265792828053236, 0.04883381351828575 ]
<p>I found the following explanation for <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chirality_%28physics%29">chirality</a> for spin 1/2 particles <a href="http://www.quantumdiaries.org/2011/06/19/helicity-chirality-mass-and-the-higgs/">here</a></p> <blockquote> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/mUD0C.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What happens when you rotate a left- vs right-chiral fermion 360 degree about its direction of motion. Both particles pick up a -1, but the left-chiral fermion goes one way around the complex plane, while the right-chiral fermion goes the other way. The circle on the right represents the complex phase of the particle's quantum state; as we rotate a particle, the value of the phase moves along the circle. Rotating the particle 360 degrees only brings you halfway around the circle in a direction that depends on the chirality of the fermion.</p> </blockquote> <p>My question is: Isn't the way the phase of the wavefunction changes related to the direction of rotation of the particle, which is an external parameter depending on how you rotate it? Is there a better explanation for chirality?</p>
g4246
[ -0.018603147938847542, -0.0538591630756855, 0.0018119275337085128, -0.037899140268564224, 0.11688593775033951, -0.007820756174623966, 0.06379195302724838, 0.049121566116809845, -0.009508205577731133, -0.009790596552193165, -0.03134218230843544, -0.012794958427548409, 0.029347002506256104, 0.0034887241199612617, 0.052253253757953644, -0.03435012698173523, -0.028808316215872765, 0.029336681589484215, 0.03334600478410721, 0.028330206871032715, -0.023325374349951744, -0.002630843548104167, -0.008938931860029697, -0.005117472261190414, -0.018960025161504745, -0.015495427884161472, 0.006407891865819693, -0.019868263974785805, 0.0021971873939037323, 0.04760000854730606, 0.03778364136815071, -0.008655351586639881, 0.008230487816035748, -0.034236226230859756, 0.03096216730773449, -0.04460659995675087, 0.020391089841723442, -0.037126217037439346, 0.013716277666389942, 0.008736781775951385, 0.06319823861122131, 0.0021864124573767185, -0.02837461046874523, -0.024873798713088036, 0.05865040421485901, 0.016442183405160904, -0.03730424493551254, 0.06531577557325363, -0.04219886660575867, -0.0019530762219801545, -0.051711343228816986, -0.009702885523438454, 0.007808380294591188, 0.06762146204710007, 0.050379134714603424, 0.030926011502742767, 0.021780626848340034, 0.030635148286819458, 0.07327620685100555, 0.05555795505642891, -0.0010948819108307362, 0.014522803016006947, -0.025005603209137917, 0.014922397211194038, 0.023041728883981705, -0.06013188883662224, -0.0021780526731163263, 0.008431375958025455, -0.02773231267929077, -0.020083440467715263, -0.01832694001495838, -0.0594240203499794, -0.005391837563365698, -0.04269028827548027, 0.004980832803994417, -0.00373704987578094, 0.002854101825505495, -0.05793165788054466, 0.02721145749092102, -0.025124497711658478, -0.05693995952606201, -0.059367287904024124, -0.02345401421189308, 0.01545871514827013, 0.06627313792705536, 0.014781047590076923, 0.032512422651052475, 0.004512655548751354, -0.017497647553682327, -0.003150975564494729, 0.022281572222709656, -0.09537410736083984, 0.025986462831497192, 0.016828741878271103, -0.06567160040140152, -0.014804564416408539, -0.010259432718157768, 0.05297369509935379, 0.006289119832217693, -0.0006207323749549687, 0.0014098393730819225, -0.012418655678629875, 0.0424022413790226, -0.050174813717603683, -0.0018022527219727635, 0.024741701781749725, 0.024577995762228966, 0.046443305909633636, -0.05161942541599274, 0.012615890242159367, -0.02820567414164543, -0.04011504352092743, -0.008323931135237217, -0.04843219369649887, -0.008368823677301407, -0.0019362482707947493, 0.10492322593927383, 0.004747152794152498, 0.06541208922863007, 0.02759491465985775, 0.02500801905989647, 0.02635817788541317, -0.004229692742228508, 0.06509102880954742, 0.037276461720466614, 0.04781405255198479, -0.0046035065315663815, -0.037680402398109436, 0.03198261931538582, 0.03283967822790146, 0.017695888876914978, 0.011775045655667782, -0.003553569782525301, 0.007960283197462559, -0.0004441527999006212, -0.00019021728076040745, 0.028137361630797386, 0.020543593913316727, -0.008860099129378796, -0.023283837363123894, 0.02233414351940155, -0.038889866322278976, 0.06022343784570694, -0.06207440420985222, 0.005035830661654472, 0.016870032995939255, -0.01023886539041996, -0.05093494802713394, 0.011926074512302876, 0.01366665493696928, 0.0508933924138546, 0.022261446341872215, 0.008418599143624306, 0.019374147057533264, 0.02676371857523918, -0.005680324509739876, 0.026298709213733673, 0.03302960470318794, -0.006909731775522232, 0.01489862147718668, 0.08077866584062576, -0.040110062807798386, -0.049008745700120926, -0.0020658965222537518, -0.04112961143255234, 0.04312413930892944, -0.04780174046754837, -0.026716385036706924, -0.0675274133682251, -0.016431722790002823, -0.05050252750515938, -0.0017084141727536917, -0.051498979330062866, 0.022597908973693848, 0.05626475438475609, 0.07857592403888702, -0.04476398974657059, 0.005047009326517582, 0.03073512390255928, 0.039330217987298965, 0.009295432828366756, 0.005029759369790554, 0.005707574542611837, 0.007364470977336168, -0.038643427193164825, -0.03939611464738846, 0.02465207874774933, 0.02685781754553318, -0.04498707503080368, -0.02394123375415802, 0.05025279149413109, -0.03589969873428345, -0.04594745859503746, 0.007505958434194326, -0.03661761060357094, -0.016742857173085213, -0.011711769737303257, 0.004208706319332123, -0.07370992004871368, 0.02957308292388916, -0.006618288811296225, -0.010227803140878677, 0.09174065291881561, 0.0022388126235455275, 0.012895092368125916, -0.028903044760227203, -0.02910982444882393, 0.06239248439669609, 0.08229916542768478, -0.02299044467508793, 0.048310864716768265, 0.05764223262667656, -0.042222168296575546, 0.05852293595671654, -0.013231676071882248, 0.02119276113808155, -0.005742345005273819, 0.020037008449435234, 0.008486011996865273, -0.0056103975512087345, 0.027562936767935753, -0.04152845963835716, 0.03446613624691963, 0.008763082325458527, 0.019619127735495567, 0.016309209167957306, -0.037206728011369705, -0.026726579293608665, -0.013870329596102238, 0.08309680223464966, -0.04696761071681976, 0.011449993588030338, 0.01982872374355793, 0.009512337855994701, 0.043407853692770004, 0.0008077219245024025, -0.0037307702004909515, 0.050828274339437485, 0.006476169917732477, -0.020822230726480484, -0.002942372113466263, -0.012876180000603199, -0.05061599612236023, -0.018969951197504997, 0.009105906821787357, 0.024318285286426544, 0.04631534591317177, 0.0017211452359333634, -0.012702583335340023, 0.009147738106548786, 0.05168529972434044, -0.004477087873965502, -0.048850879073143005, -0.021323097869753838, -0.007521331310272217, -0.04923442751169205, -0.0193499606102705, 0.04829894378781319, -0.06852628290653229, -0.06147480756044388, 0.025828644633293152, 0.01448682602494955, 0.039458680897951126, 0.006584079470485449, -0.014814328402280807, 0.07165706902742386, 0.02410721406340599, 0.054543472826480865, -0.01757904514670372, -0.02999395690858364, -0.06503546983003616, 0.08722446113824844, 0.0028173259925097227, 0.07634014636278152, -0.0861738920211792, -0.09501352906227112, -0.014000335708260536, 0.0517784021794796, 0.009033499285578728, -0.0003074207343161106, -0.009438250213861465, 0.018876509740948677, -0.04395158216357231, 0.04097880423069, 0.053723812103271484, -0.0005323056830093265, -0.026146717369556427, 0.023178759962320328, -0.04885239526629448, 0.017926666885614395, -0.044802166521549225, 0.02142915315926075, 0.019733333960175514, -0.028295092284679413, 0.054386597126722336, -0.02188711427152157, 0.059937600046396255, -0.015843946486711502, 0.011498278938233852, 0.07851482182741165, 0.03082880564033985, 0.00971475150436163, -0.029827957972884178, 0.012686430476605892, 0.013520960696041584, 0.020205585286021233, -0.007589143235236406, -0.0531451441347599, -0.06847439706325531, 0.011801209300756454, -0.03506651893258095, 0.004259674809873104, -0.03604839742183685, -0.010270271450281143, 0.0264019425958395, 0.00032430310966446996, -0.04764454439282417, 0.05130472406744957, 0.030649054795503616, 0.01780097372829914, -0.07343484461307526, 0.006078498903661966, -0.0720190703868866, 0.00969590526074171, 0.026374079287052155, 0.023821363225579262, -0.06552504003047943, 0.030034895986318588, -0.027029460296034813, -0.09436296671628952, 0.034074049443006516, 0.02794184908270836, -0.0041310740634799, -0.00436819065362215, -0.01613267883658409, 0.034004420042037964, -0.03560006245970726, -0.039260461926460266, 0.0064322431571781635, -0.023397384211421013, 0.004696889780461788, 0.015486311167478561, 0.02079722471535206, 0.029506731778383255, 0.020151009783148766, 0.0032368344254791737, -0.017475061118602753, -0.027227915823459625, 0.0010785169433802366, 0.06790625303983688, -0.00852645467966795, 0.027880217880010605, -0.035096269100904465, 0.008243273943662643, 0.005449599586427212, -0.04879400506615639, -0.009900866076350212, 0.019399194046854973, 0.00375887518748641, 0.029581768438220024, -0.0005310498527251184, -0.04442759230732918, 0.034402698278427124, -0.0028425604104995728, 0.019896117970347404, 0.026991931721568108, -0.033315762877464294, 0.0008138584671542048, -0.0038869520649313927, 0.0030977088026702404, -0.04865340143442154, -0.032824862748384476, 0.030814293771982193, -0.031189585104584694, 0.01233986672013998, -0.025254061445593834, 0.019115908071398735, -0.027710024267435074, -0.06743887811899185, -0.010657883249223232, -0.01365963090211153, 0.012980975210666656, 0.008917777799069881, 0.021469248458743095, 0.007865176536142826, 0.055460888892412186, -0.05436595529317856, -0.007728311233222485, -0.042173031717538834, -0.0017355354502797127, 0.04783271998167038, -0.02711590565741062, 0.0278596431016922, 0.02245992049574852, 0.0773385763168335, -0.0018938395660370588, -0.011565417051315308, -0.027624264359474182, -0.04111890494823456, -0.006369247101247311, 0.0010646908776834607, -0.03697124123573303, -0.0094205467030406, -0.04453606531023979, -0.0008071741322055459, -0.0013076377799734473, -0.012334039434790611, -0.018880119547247887, -0.011465635150671005, -0.04609227925539017, 0.025431107729673386, 0.06864655017852783, 0.025069650262594223, -0.026363661512732506, 0.04314883425831795, -0.0022333094384521246, -0.0015976965660229325, 0.0019555536564439535, -0.006126038730144501, 0.005552911665290594, 0.0029134214855730534, 0.02372020110487938, 0.01859545335173607, 0.025684328749775887, 0.022734515368938446, 0.03584054484963417, 0.06463025510311127, 0.014081285335123539, -0.06843502819538116, -0.042507320642471313, 0.027297314256429672, 0.037137020379304886, 0.015484951436519623, -0.037388935685157776, -0.016976110637187958, 0.0030966794583946466, -0.06702520698308945, 0.025449248030781746, 0.04978368803858757, -0.015216999687254429, 0.024624431505799294, 0.023850848898291588, -0.0347600094974041, -0.023117898032069206, -0.01844559982419014, -0.007754647638648748, 0.0016112645389512181, -0.008898034691810608, 0.01645270362496376, -0.035516366362571716, -0.050055231899023056, 0.02940213680267334, -0.022857187315821648, -0.014036967419087887, 0.004555650055408478, -0.02579416334629059, -0.012367158196866512, 0.003752306569367647, -0.04519614949822426, -0.044205013662576675, -0.1315009444952011, -0.04896458983421326, 0.00993906520307064, -0.022104792296886444, -0.011703836731612682, 0.03382541611790657, 0.00279701454564929, -0.03736568242311478, -0.027238989248871803, 0.04576883092522621, 0.004618594888597727, 0.0024978818837553263, 0.012872298248112202, -0.0066239009611308575, 0.011327818967401981, -0.00009823431173572317, -0.002243796829134226, -0.0476449579000473, -0.021620143204927444, -0.07831655442714691, -0.04453529417514801, -0.023299595341086388, 0.06431169807910919, 0.037409309297800064, 0.004698007367551327, -0.041551683098077774, 0.05221109464764595, -0.016607046127319336, 0.00558545021340251, -0.006951453629881144, 0.037912413477897644, -0.007594230119138956, 0.0010648246388882399, -0.08845356106758118, 0.03879496827721596, -0.021889578551054, 0.0005070855258964002, -0.02184244617819786, -0.004106738604605198, -0.017835229635238647, -0.003047240199521184, 0.02184455282986164, 0.016127141192555428, 0.04326412454247475, -0.04036828875541687, 0.05941031500697136, 0.04455576092004776, -0.044154636561870575, -0.02776692621409893, -0.013062865473330021, -0.008249960839748383, -0.04903034493327141, 0.0011737443273887038, -0.013781005516648293, -0.008668525144457817, -0.0065080830827355385, -0.02546961046755314, 0.007067983504384756, -0.002322814194485545, 0.005267555359750986, -0.049884043633937836, 0.0486002117395401, -0.002455543028190732, -0.05379761382937431, -0.0009416088578291237, -0.03952663764357567, -0.08009207993745804, -0.008510850369930267, 0.027531437575817108, 0.023430364206433296, -0.007784722838550806, 0.014730245806276798, 0.10172036290168762, 0.08411610126495361, -0.016888156533241272, -0.0156549122184515, -0.02519148774445057, 0.005587626248598099, 0.0743330791592598, 0.04106544330716133, 0.015302542597055435, -0.010611201636493206, -0.00033076395629905164, 0.05944240838289261, -0.02494034171104431, 0.0006012443918734789, -0.016449015587568283, -0.0322398766875267, 0.0013477288885042071, -0.0058484687469899654, -0.04668359085917473, 0.07698861509561539, 0.006629683542996645, -0.04419803246855736, 0.013711567968130112, 0.020388413220643997, -0.047510288655757904, -0.018974466249346733, -0.0217181034386158, -0.06409669667482376, 0.02768862619996071, -0.043243616819381714, 0.07397443056106567, 0.03741934522986412, 0.031013434752821922, -0.010871314443647861, 0.01731029525399208, -0.0359000638127327, 0.019827459007501602, 0.07525908201932907, -0.02531088888645172, -0.03588442504405975, -0.036944057792425156, -0.012678436934947968, 0.009439412504434586, 0.051976390182971954, -0.04127086326479912, -0.04582781344652176, -0.047946322709321976, 0.001179701997898519, 0.014976149424910545, 0.027269847691059113, 0.02403745800256729, 0.0046845003962516785, -0.008635478094220161, 0.035773247480392456, 0.0002464609278831631, 0.02539379708468914, 0.045991990715265274, 0.04429606348276138, -0.09340588003396988, 0.0319734662771225, -0.035743944346904755, 0.00018896428809966892, -0.009307469241321087, 0.029291421175003052, -0.017965205013751984, -0.007679260801523924, -0.017828792333602905, -0.057787589728832245, 0.1005760207772255, -0.013302946463227272, 0.0424426831305027, -0.01891050487756729, 0.0080129848793149, -0.021585019305348396, 0.0009118302259594202, 0.017756778746843338, 0.0014206664636731148, -0.01141810230910778, -0.006612150464206934, 0.0030138869769871235, -0.011420861817896366, 0.023318691179156303, -0.004033165518194437, -0.020953264087438583, -0.012188836932182312, 0.03207371011376381, -0.028009412810206413, -0.015269946306943893, 0.009280950762331486, 0.05221550539135933, -0.00961085595190525, -0.02874354086816311, 0.02947668358683586, 0.020721085369586945, -0.05399482324719429, 0.03922348842024803, 0.05547730252146721, 0.04994089901447296, 0.08509775996208191, -0.005510938819497824, -0.00523384939879179, 0.05924114212393761, 0.03506315127015114, -0.05049372836947441, -0.0701962485909462, -0.010796398855745792, 0.012953730300068855, 0.06525389105081558, 0.03505600988864899, 0.03356378898024559, 0.022814301773905754, -0.020105576142668724, -0.09121090173721313, -0.01642199046909809, -0.010421819053590298, -0.014865389093756676, -0.023260165005922318, 0.005827674176543951, 0.02645452506840229, -0.05250656604766846, -0.045432426035404205, 0.03030439093708992, 0.02354746311903, -0.04363902658224106, 0.02658308669924736, 0.025646338239312172, 0.032331980764865875, -0.07167419046163559, -0.0730147659778595, -0.024636413902044296, -0.013104265555739403, 0.0365082323551178, -0.02506720833480358, 0.0047739832662045956, 0.006061037071049213, 0.05541650205850601, 0.051228731870651245, -0.03365639969706535, -0.029039185494184494, 0.015187769196927547, -0.057957518845796585, -0.010037862695753574, 0.011613385751843452, -0.02275528758764267, -0.03773925080895424, -0.049267932772636414, 0.00632050633430481, 0.03996169939637184, 0.012796103022992611, -0.021649491041898727, 0.029473988339304924, -0.00026461773086339235, -0.02929418347775936, -0.02260177582502365, -0.024303149431943893, -0.007317548152059317, -0.027805307880043983, -0.02396443672478199, 0.018949657678604126, 0.03126087039709091, -0.02243391051888466, -0.003945902921259403, -0.07039710879325867, 0.0354483388364315, 0.0814943015575409, 0.041387658566236496, -0.003520029131323099, 0.041726548224687576, 0.019174467772245407, -0.06441926956176758, 0.026766637340188026, -0.018994702026247978, 0.10056363046169281, -0.03326476365327835, 0.0014435375342145562, -0.02341877855360508, -0.03294531628489494, 0.04939863830804825, 0.03667794167995453, -0.017215076833963394, 0.011398292146623135, 0.015029914677143097, -0.037397708743810654, 0.0262688510119915, 0.008869410492479801, 0.07643448561429977, 0.04568368196487427, -0.006589703261852264, -0.04483218863606453, -0.0010267896577715874, -0.031203648075461388, 0.001427916926331818, -0.059053391218185425, -0.019876699894666672, -0.001786950509995222, 0.00699032424017787, 0.03296167403459549, 0.02570735663175583, 0.030484195798635483, 0.0809926837682724, -0.056188005954027176, 0.009780537337064743, -0.028407897800207138, 0.048701733350753784, -0.06008538231253624, 0.007252545561641455, -0.00017946261505130678, -0.016919415444135666, 0.05363693833351135, -0.0018569184467196465, 0.043003957718610764, -0.08516149967908859, -0.04611684009432793, -0.041970688849687576, 0.0032140391413122416, 0.004995784722268581, 0.022801890969276428, -0.016716286540031433, -0.03560872748494148, 0.0003384813608136028, -0.046785496175289154, 0.005553672090172768, -0.004866155330091715, -0.011405139230191708, -0.04984341561794281, -0.021073374897241592, 0.023613983765244484, -0.01345555204898119, 0.007482121232897043, -0.02172570675611496, 0.011907006613910198, -0.015765460208058357, -0.015454096719622612, -0.014484420418739319, -0.04564303159713745, 0.040437281131744385 ]
<p>I was reading <a href="http://www.lightreading.in/document.asp?doc_id=226833&amp;site=lrindia&amp;" rel="nofollow">this article</a>. There is a statement "It is a well-known fact that the telecom towers mounted with antennas in the lower frequency bands can cover far greater areas than those using the 1800 frequency bands." Is this accurate/wrong/a simplified version. One point which made me think that it is wrong is the fact that Satellite TV uses high frequency bands for communication</p>
g4247
[ 0.0002457699447404593, 0.03802942484617233, 0.004409437067806721, -0.020294765010476112, 0.0071778311394155025, -0.015705568715929985, -0.031689200550317764, 0.010283896699547768, 0.06618635356426239, -0.03789953887462616, 0.022098306566476822, 0.051731377840042114, 0.04845661669969559, 0.012596851214766502, -0.045091260224580765, 0.007028365973383188, 0.02896425686776638, 0.03374708443880081, 0.027122637256979942, 0.11131095141172409, -0.04262751713395119, -0.0007721174624748528, -0.015110203996300697, -0.07140465080738068, -0.08048569411039352, 0.04193698987364769, 0.03788496181368828, 0.02220223657786846, -0.05178325995802879, -0.0038415840826928616, 0.01936417818069458, -0.00663214735686779, 0.008511881344020367, -0.03396013379096985, -0.06891065835952759, -0.055140238255262375, -0.010059051215648651, -0.03353501483798027, -0.0012214576127007604, 0.003580196527764201, 0.008796130307018757, -0.029216255992650986, -0.03590097650885582, -0.005146725568920374, -0.009560455568134785, -0.05692543089389801, -0.007852581329643726, 0.010239161550998688, 0.0062103113159537315, -0.04582938179373741, -0.044733427464962006, -0.03524421155452728, 0.03677196800708771, 0.011002558283507824, 0.024164682254195213, -0.02711847983300686, -0.03460969775915146, -0.028980905190110207, 0.04347788915038109, 0.013112989254295826, 0.023499848321080208, 0.04291767254471779, -0.005708807148039341, -0.01787504367530346, 0.0023872549645602703, 0.014011031948029995, -0.0326019749045372, -0.03406749293208122, -0.011212198063731194, 0.011267236433923244, 0.021870052441954613, -0.03682144731283188, -0.05304050073027611, -0.02324260026216507, -0.031744495034217834, -0.02213706076145172, -0.004010636359453201, 0.007742799818515778, -0.004468573722988367, 0.09189232438802719, 0.010103601031005383, -0.024543631821870804, -0.04948463663458824, 0.032233089208602905, 0.008689817041158676, 0.0499810092151165, -0.004180302377790213, -0.00816713459789753, 0.03151367977261543, 0.04158145934343338, 0.04579659178853035, -0.004115079063922167, 0.04359157755970955, 0.02403866872191429, -0.006424649152904749, -0.018735239282250404, 0.0004904691013507545, -0.00472358288243413, 0.03917136788368225, -0.03265116736292839, -0.013477806933224201, 0.061639342457056046, 0.005655820481479168, 0.03280132636427879, -0.0684647485613823, 0.031092418357729912, 0.026184961199760437, -0.03392849862575531, -0.06468715518712997, 0.03607335686683655, 0.016797620803117752, -0.008013950660824776, 0.005154164507985115, -0.03845595195889473, -0.06293787807226181, 0.002672863192856312, 0.07832903414964676, -0.002901228843256831, 0.00024391051556449383, -0.011159004643559456, 0.011246050707995892, -0.03329998254776001, 0.046945858746767044, 0.05966800078749657, -0.024276334792375565, -0.05219147726893425, 0.01260262168943882, 0.027462095022201538, 0.046730175614356995, -0.049979645758867264, -0.07135561108589172, -0.03597865626215935, 0.029317021369934082, 0.016393940895795822, 0.08087711781263351, -0.0031833238899707794, 0.05516422912478447, -0.07017169892787933, 0.020143726840615273, -0.0014469926245510578, 0.005767236929386854, 0.014296555891633034, 0.06522266566753387, -0.1021147072315216, 0.025112787261605263, 0.03641108050942421, -0.007950481958687305, -0.01960821822285652, -0.006355456076562405, -0.007828809320926666, -0.001964560244232416, 0.0179047379642725, 0.05393499881029129, -0.014298699796199799, -0.03965391591191292, 0.008071349933743477, 0.015591759234666824, 0.06344542652368546, 0.032344721257686615, 0.01324288547039032, -0.02188698574900627, 0.03291307017207146, 0.008487757295370102, 0.0004395458090584725, -0.02361222729086876, -0.001460578409023583, -0.04214483126997948, 0.026212723925709724, -0.049293361604213715, -0.010427017696201801, -0.011874567717313766, 0.0331021249294281, 0.02006182074546814, 0.035734545439481735, 0.018337033689022064, 0.009880582801997662, 0.11318738013505936, -0.048907309770584106, 0.0624048113822937, 0.03483399376273155, -0.010036214254796505, 0.03510957583785057, -0.05750752612948418, -0.015537906438112259, 0.006230917293578386, -0.014598874375224113, -0.014355283230543137, -0.07605279982089996, -0.031033916398882866, 0.03211021050810814, -0.08328129351139069, 0.043122246861457825, -0.0006107166409492493, 0.00960825476795435, -0.07604652643203735, 0.0140563128516078, 0.011691651307046413, 0.049848709255456924, 0.015233892016112804, -0.025709955021739006, 0.036302562803030014, 0.0046610780991613865, 0.038212649524211884, 0.002002519788220525, 0.012602495960891247, 0.0024751550517976284, -0.054555974900722504, -0.011927868239581585, 0.05814163759350777, -0.03209591656923294, -0.06737181544303894, -0.03880619257688522, -0.009777506813406944, 0.03242962434887886, 0.04825301468372345, -0.0045584868639707565, -0.08303019404411316, 0.02034129574894905, 0.008582797832787037, -0.018140092492103577, -0.05320916697382927, -0.006362801883369684, 0.03316011279821396, -0.038150619715452194, 0.008893188089132309, -0.01039110217243433, -0.00983912032097578, -0.03145349770784378, -0.013191014528274536, -0.0038703656755387783, 0.06087817624211311, -0.015658844262361526, -0.007512429729104042, -0.007805475499480963, -0.01975286193192005, -0.020266897976398468, 0.042063143104314804, 0.037565477192401886, 0.062037792056798935, 0.021580176427960396, 0.027277562767267227, -0.004678553435951471, -0.014508416876196861, -0.019517352804541588, -0.009671336971223354, -0.02520931512117386, 0.0217385645955801, -0.07187481224536896, -0.032097525894641876, 0.018577173352241516, 0.03034479357302189, 0.010502466931939125, 0.05572013184428215, -0.002298783976584673, 0.009034795686602592, -0.025827212259173393, -0.011962827295064926, -0.015004025772213936, -0.025148896500468254, 0.03725901618599892, -0.02487538568675518, -0.019762979820370674, 0.033860478550195694, -0.05228012427687645, 0.00962397363036871, 0.007385971024632454, -0.01604962721467018, -0.01512773148715496, 0.055941298604011536, -0.04248917102813721, 0.031901776790618896, 0.04271610826253891, 0.00680843461304903, -0.002626100555062294, -0.023588411509990692, -0.07658261060714722, -0.024966144934296608, -0.012927141040563583, -0.005437758285552263, -0.005117224063724279, 0.015380588360130787, -0.05016058310866356, 0.023505644872784615, -0.00217260979115963, 0.04189256206154823, -0.024330412968993187, -0.010760785080492496, -0.013500940054655075, -0.05935046076774597, 0.0013528517447412014, 0.01900942251086235, -0.027213959023356438, 0.027521930634975433, -0.01667642593383789, -0.03518808260560036, 0.020248204469680786, 0.04851405695080757, -0.06619055569171906, -0.03736672177910805, 0.023772137239575386, 0.004973797593265772, 0.007356247864663601, 0.02420324645936489, 0.005002132151275873, 0.006561520043760538, 0.010175032541155815, 0.009607387706637383, -0.05995748192071915, 0.03216087818145752, -0.08859438449144363, -0.01954156532883644, 0.049223463982343674, -0.044985331594944, -0.031001221388578415, -0.009103121235966682, 0.051774390041828156, 0.021013718098402023, 0.04146180301904678, 0.01672104187309742, 0.04025543853640556, 0.011714696884155273, -0.014049828983843327, -0.0073224641382694244, -0.02504199929535389, -0.026002760976552963, 0.05047977715730667, 0.01317058876156807, 0.02497105859220028, -0.00230226619169116, 0.0120715806260705, -0.007181767374277115, -0.027192778885364532, -0.011287500150501728, -0.02514815703034401, -0.04802190884947777, 0.016531938686966896, 0.00896704476326704, 0.06250274181365967, 0.0005339363706298172, -0.03107183612883091, 0.005330229643732309, -0.030706465244293213, -0.059351157397031784, -0.050741687417030334, -0.0009862749138846993, 0.08483803272247314, -0.059024784713983536, 0.006931801792234182, -0.040337421000003815, -0.04424626752734184, 0.01667081005871296, 0.0018933090614154935, -0.004088641609996557, -0.03089188225567341, -0.022696100175380707, 0.046882402151823044, 0.019462982192635536, 0.0311202984303236, 0.021245740354061127, 0.017592577263712883, 0.059353843331336975, 0.02834891714155674, 0.06017042696475983, -0.019580503925681114, -0.030058061704039574, 0.01658986136317253, -0.04413427412509918, 0.07883921265602112, -0.03463616967201233, 0.017081739380955696, 0.005776779260486364, -0.03466298058629036, -0.022769493982195854, -0.009387200698256493, 0.10867961496114731, 0.06914982199668884, 0.027933111414313316, -0.01244889385998249, 0.04830031096935272, 0.028587939217686653, 0.023891357704997063, 0.023707963526248932, -0.05244875326752663, -0.020396113395690918, 0.03688938543200493, -0.05498329922556877, 0.026754185557365417, 0.022555191069841385, -0.016009291633963585, 0.0012575414730235934, 0.007508254610002041, -0.03960977867245674, 0.021503515541553497, 0.02759247086942196, -0.004670730791985989, -0.041639700531959534, -0.0020741024054586887, 0.00016380203305743635, 0.06145640090107918, 0.04144560173153877, 0.017464982345700264, 0.015259047038853168, -0.03249362111091614, -0.02237011305987835, -0.04124792665243149, 0.0336700901389122, -0.01115933433175087, -0.019655590876936913, -0.06475094705820084, -0.057046666741371155, -0.05795612186193466, 0.04031376913189888, 0.03468676283955574, -0.03508942574262619, 0.029401810839772224, 0.10976093262434006, -0.015108735300600529, -0.053243234753608704, 0.05157706141471863, 0.05964174494147301, -0.04081103950738907, 0.06366757303476334, -0.019394032657146454, -0.07648885250091553, 0.02895154245197773, 0.03824201226234436, -0.007009102497249842, -0.0595875047147274, 0.010132675059139729, 0.02059268392622471, 0.013625532388687134, -0.0188312865793705, -0.02727684937417507, -0.011560515500605106, 0.014941087923943996, 0.02729066088795662, 0.022958578541874886, -0.024641605094075203, 0.06589124351739883, 0.030565762892365456, -0.006801221985369921, -0.056091032922267914, -0.03908248990774155, -0.017564410343766212, 0.02003643475472927, 0.018666664138436317, -0.04916669800877571, 0.030188066884875298, -0.021777158603072166, 0.03242579847574234, 0.002909706439822912, 0.03790729492902756, -0.00235718279145658, -0.03333451971411705, -0.007453171536326408, -0.04433509707450867, -0.01650548167526722, -0.01176331378519535, 0.03900448605418205, -0.012567726895213127, -0.00005246846558293328, -0.013019421137869358, -0.012800006195902824, 0.03920431435108185, 0.06253089010715485, 0.03142784535884857, -0.03452782705426216, -0.01855943351984024, -0.058815330266952515, -0.047088682651519775, 0.013888991437852383, -0.02660812810063362, 0.030347973108291626, 0.0147216422483325, 0.015788352116942406, -0.018964054062962532, -0.024150250479578972, -0.0034638186916708946, 0.02807863987982273, 0.004917683079838753, -0.02930171601474285, -0.008676317520439625, -0.026393860578536987, 0.019182099029421806, 0.01030701119452715, 0.03701521456241608, -0.000891814474016428, -0.011116299778223038, 0.04806862026453018, -0.11293957382440567, 0.022090032696723938, -0.06921126693487167, -0.048742860555648804, 0.000709146203007549, -0.06396736949682236, -0.06692837923765182, 0.012116510421037674, -0.035366665571928024, -0.0018333925399929285, 0.0025119842030107975, 0.02714706026017666, 0.0084371417760849, 0.0028076935559511185, -0.03697334975004196, -0.022730883210897446, 0.05154997110366821, 0.02302055060863495, -0.015365809202194214, 0.011405077762901783, -0.024955475702881813, 0.03999103605747223, 0.018187707290053368, -0.03035232424736023, -0.031061995774507523, 0.04165015369653702, -0.10282871872186661, -0.07874533534049988, 0.030208472162485123, -0.047821272164583206, -0.004722415003925562, 0.02250026911497116, -0.02126837894320488, 0.01993817463517189, 0.0015345592983067036, 0.0012449247296899557, -0.036866165697574615, -0.009405200369656086, -0.011048638261854649, 0.012316642329096794, 0.021472571417689323, 0.0414387546479702, 0.10621937364339828, -0.04234743490815163, 0.013566127978265285, 0.022288847714662552, 0.048511117696762085, 0.008598631247878075, -0.015800271183252335, 0.0033190054818987846, 0.008517617359757423, 0.027255909517407417, 0.014785712584853172, 0.06146567314863205, 0.06231632083654404, 0.036386024206876755, -0.03695182502269745, -0.004575224593281746, 0.022204339504241943, 0.020163996145129204, 0.04007211700081825, 0.0032983580604195595, 0.006696679163724184, -0.036800697445869446, 0.020142830908298492, -0.0044863843359053135, 0.014788838103413582, 0.061816614121198654, 0.033318061381578445, 0.04552462697029114, -0.010023195296525955, -0.007984396070241928, 0.020650388672947884, -0.04561006277799606, -0.012615363113582134, 0.05468643456697464, -0.003947960212826729, -0.010227251797914505, 0.019695725291967392, 0.016415661200881004, 0.00951822753995657, -0.03517225757241249, -0.0022989416029304266, 0.0008591937948949635, 0.04576171934604645, -0.005475431680679321, 0.04662061110138893, -0.018495850265026093, 0.009346522390842438, -0.0014783471124246716, -0.05651870742440224, -0.04887876287102699, -0.04374130442738533, 0.010449390858411789, -0.01293704193085432, 0.011486581526696682, 0.021443163976073265, -0.004326577298343182, 0.009154722094535828, -0.004059778060764074, -0.02822788991034031, 0.0031032010447233915, -0.002734509762376547, 0.011119576171040535, 0.06694809347391129, -0.016615474596619606, -0.07488801330327988, -0.006471582222729921, 0.0928032174706459, -0.02612897753715515, -0.004392825532704592, 0.0714019238948822, -0.01193262543529272, 0.07883679866790771, -0.012948974967002869, 0.014331233687698841, 0.017342329025268555, 0.061944931745529175, -0.033990588039159775, -0.004955100826919079, -0.017600808292627335, 0.027736375108361244, 0.04464788734912872, 0.04970037192106247, -0.006508945021778345, -0.030984872952103615, -0.05197366699576378, -0.055561613291502, 0.03112579509615898, -0.015058556571602821, -0.0016967878909781575, 0.059347860515117645, -0.025822043418884277, -0.09751514345407486, -0.025051672011613846, -0.02462494745850563, 0.06470552831888199, 0.06171143427491188, -0.008895667269825935, 0.06001051887869835, -0.01814027689397335, -0.0069142053835093975, -0.050857365131378174, -0.030306247994303703, -0.06275396049022675, -0.07326440513134003, 0.014232573099434376, 0.005331861320883036, -0.03449827432632446, -0.03658609464764595, 0.01059584692120552, -0.04377536103129387, 0.03180515021085739, 0.035244252532720566, 0.012041790410876274, -0.003972025588154793, 0.013075399212539196, -0.007540834601968527, -0.022486496716737747, -0.014991877600550652, 0.00020089859026484191, 0.01674426533281803, -0.027645744383335114, 0.004143403843045235, -0.05725341662764549, 0.007873483002185822, -0.04714995622634888, 0.0509733110666275, 0.009610156528651714, 0.005013874266296625, -0.0006565218791365623, -0.01779079996049404, 0.036507755517959595, -0.010579527355730534, 0.1100052073597908, -0.010243776254355907, 0.00024761594249866903, 0.009917264804244041, -0.09184753149747849, -0.022925518453121185, -0.018441053107380867, -0.003287165891379118, -0.023818165063858032, 0.00007664463191758841, -0.026730554178357124, -0.028971893712878227, 0.007973766885697842, -0.08334818482398987, -0.05219724401831627, -0.045823924243450165, 0.0407465398311615, 0.055827971547842026, -0.0363687202334404, 0.008808992803096771, 0.009589187800884247, 0.05140220746397972, 0.009891364723443985, -0.023192519322037697, -0.012852699495851994, 0.02246592752635479, -0.055916912853717804, -0.022916190326213837, 0.015330885536968708, 0.01761801354587078, -0.012972536496818066, 0.02635616436600685, 0.00979091040790081, -0.022452466189861298, -0.012359535321593285, -0.013694869354367256, 0.009831909090280533, -0.002445982303470373, 0.02000262215733528, 0.010410595685243607, -0.022569799795746803, 0.06951531767845154, 0.04357590153813362, 0.04388505220413208, 0.03544793650507927, -0.03204052522778511, -0.026367411017417908, 0.05144372209906578, 0.004532362334430218, 0.06358650326728821, 0.021280938759446144, 0.0019039985490962863, 0.04470948502421379, -0.015269294381141663, -0.05654080584645271, -0.03142738714814186, -0.03416091948747635, 0.01287369430065155, -0.0433906614780426, 0.0506281778216362, -0.051483869552612305, -0.03292855620384216, 0.05238686501979828, 0.019106607884168625, -0.023464331403374672, 0.021120334044098854, 0.014278423972427845, 0.009846181608736515, -0.02495526149868965, -0.030933743342757225, -0.04651039466261864, 0.029031233862042427, -0.025914479047060013, -0.024972185492515564, 0.03528087958693504, -0.044459011405706406, 0.039250507950782776, -0.015329200774431229, 0.06587255746126175, -0.052267372608184814, 0.040966134518384933, 0.005461128894239664, 0.0045172846876084805, -0.013437222689390182, -0.032947421073913574, 0.04976397380232811, -0.002494825515896082, -0.016779672354459763, 0.03163038566708565, -0.02400415949523449, 0.06087256222963333, -0.00424277363345027, 0.018977556377649307, 0.03544498607516289, 0.003257283940911293, 0.03486137092113495, -0.008612608537077904, -0.024227524176239967, -0.007655223831534386, 0.0475461408495903, -0.04972101002931595, -0.028701219707727432, -0.07404116541147232, -0.015690647065639496, 0.03375823795795441 ]
<p>I've recently been reading (at a basic level) about the double slit experiment and how the mere act of observing can cause the "wave function to collapse", as they say. I find this mind-blowingly fascinating, and it naturally sparks some questions.</p> <p>In particular, consider the following scenario: I perform the double slit experiment and detect which slit was traversed, sending the data to some computer. This would cause the wave function to collapse, as I understand. Now, imagine that I delete the data as it is being read by the computer. If I am not mistaken, the wave function would not collapse in this case, since there would be no way for me to determine which slit was traversed. <em>Now,</em> imagine that I am under the <em>belief</em> that the data is being deleted when in reality it is being saved to some disk. What would happen in this case? Assuming I never come to know about the existence of the saved data, would the wave function collapse?</p>
g4248
[ 0.021296299993991852, -0.004439969081431627, 0.02382521890103817, -0.0535251721739769, 0.018837817013263702, 0.013316498138010502, 0.04249325022101402, 0.04810922592878342, -0.038769301027059555, -0.05495158210396767, -0.015971677377820015, 0.016721393913030624, 0.04821838065981865, 0.018550455570220947, -0.009145762771368027, -0.00354329077526927, 0.008736451156437397, 0.006351144518703222, 0.02978578209877014, 0.011970304884016514, -0.007091299165040255, 0.004063805099576712, 0.00858427956700325, 0.009094879031181335, -0.06201241910457611, -0.013240955770015717, 0.006965189706534147, 0.011468816548585892, -0.05228443816304207, 0.046436384320259094, 0.012400267645716667, 0.011158338747918606, -0.006829295307397842, -0.05347231402993202, -0.04882407560944557, 0.00824459083378315, -0.015956049785017967, 0.023978659883141518, -0.03272390365600586, 0.044577013701200485, -0.05976139008998871, -0.019478067755699158, 0.009015399031341076, -0.03723840042948723, 0.040717776864767075, 0.023757286369800568, 0.004327699076384306, -0.04793388396501541, 0.08948779851198196, -0.057644348591566086, 0.05841801315546036, 0.0006879609427414834, 0.0430121086537838, 0.055022623389959335, 0.05205240473151207, 0.05685589462518692, 0.02762405388057232, -0.001296498579904437, 0.0917554423213005, -0.029311323538422585, 0.005804590880870819, -0.0008025924907997251, 0.02242591790854931, -0.01993771642446518, 0.032690469175577164, 0.025980785489082336, -0.07246558368206024, 0.06366939842700958, 0.010873477905988693, -0.03731297701597214, 0.04941913112998009, 0.029895897954702377, -0.025617951527237892, -0.02982974424958229, 0.03885622322559357, 0.06545629352331161, 0.012914790771901608, -0.02575143612921238, -0.04134939983487129, 0.014608507044613361, -0.018076438456773758, 0.0013959917705506086, -0.005257723852992058, 0.05582524091005325, 0.005783026572316885, 0.00967826135456562, -0.016313795000314713, -0.017231304198503494, 0.022997239604592323, 0.014047772623598576, -0.013210455887019634, -0.06488469988107681, 0.09382811188697815, 0.00010584179108263925, 0.022252297028899193, 0.005850388668477535, -0.026170991361141205, 0.07293521612882614, 0.006247204728424549, 0.054942820221185684, 0.006382956635206938, -0.09084231406450272, 0.009616737253963947, 0.04060719534754753, -0.023987773805856705, -0.0032416055910289288, 0.008549741469323635, 0.02620375156402588, 0.0038089039735496044, -0.003235182259231806, 0.02552548423409462, -0.017598118633031845, -0.03179079666733742, -0.00947467889636755, -0.007099969778209925, -0.013907480984926224, 0.0032370027620345354, -0.016113970428705215, -0.02729417383670807, 0.011765535920858383, 0.057791098952293396, 0.008875451050698757, 0.004768583923578262, -0.028281472623348236, 0.023975849151611328, 0.00667931092903018, -0.02012856863439083, 0.06718407571315765, 0.03589235246181488, 0.013835811987519264, -0.005556921940296888, 0.05737200751900673, -0.041933346539735794, 0.0738987922668457, 0.045899130403995514, -0.010458468459546566, 0.023828594014048576, -0.010415884666144848, 0.0014259276213124394, -0.019894834607839584, -0.026881439611315727, -0.037239667028188705, -0.0029098461382091045, -0.011546994559466839, 0.02351108193397522, -0.012763290666043758, 0.04645106568932533, 0.016974642872810364, 0.0008430943125858903, -0.013333899900317192, -0.04568609222769737, 0.018581993877887726, -0.08149375021457672, -0.07679370045661926, 0.03958342596888542, -0.01473940908908844, 0.04498670622706413, -0.048707928508520126, -0.003161592874675989, 0.005408605560660362, 0.08223247528076172, 0.012384864501655102, 0.0016987735871225595, 0.07435198128223419, -0.046054352074861526, 0.005620917305350304, 0.035783443599939346, -0.059522777795791626, 0.05740225315093994, -0.04733825847506523, -0.05716972425580025, -0.00749904103577137, 0.02435111440718174, 0.0630054771900177, -0.015945475548505783, 0.08196021616458893, -0.007363556418567896, 0.02513994462788105, 0.04988737404346466, -0.01385471411049366, -0.02665834315121174, 0.04700690880417824, -0.010803909972310066, -0.04988757520914078, 0.08632815629243851, -0.06278520077466965, 0.0012497284915298223, 0.057091861963272095, -0.08588966727256775, -0.00791813526302576, -0.04034970700740814, -0.05964738503098488, -0.003935981076210737, 0.026016488671302795, 0.008520018309354782, -0.029967693611979485, 0.050680454820394516, 0.007867207750678062, -0.030046820640563965, 0.02198849245905876, -0.028587158769369125, 0.05399957299232483, 0.04084688052535057, -0.03199038282036781, -0.04690466448664665, 0.02555004321038723, -0.0307660810649395, -0.002309268107637763, -0.03526407852768898, -0.035721320658922195, 0.024004368111491203, 0.02656417153775692, -0.013229535892605782, -0.033619221299886703, 0.02062273770570755, 0.010600389912724495, 0.011388869024813175, 0.0050071608275175095, -0.05181041732430458, -0.04092177748680115, -0.03672165796160698, 0.007741007022559643, 0.056267473846673965, -0.02219480276107788, 0.01070129033178091, 0.003130177268758416, -0.09587158262729645, -0.041629765182733536, -0.023757625371217728, -0.024782394990324974, -0.055858880281448364, 0.010263473726809025, 0.04086872190237045, -0.028256285935640335, 0.014930053614079952, 0.09659865498542786, -0.04665767401456833, 0.026924939826130867, 0.059287261217832565, -0.037168387323617935, 0.0025026840157806873, 0.05774820223450661, -0.07150378823280334, -0.006996092852205038, 0.07120147347450256, -0.05272870883345604, 0.007089342921972275, 0.04763700067996979, 0.05642683058977127, -0.0015839257976040244, 0.021879637613892555, -0.0018500399310141802, -0.03301660344004631, 0.053186606615781784, 0.006536476314067841, -0.01608273573219776, 0.0001741029554978013, 0.0036151399835944176, -0.03941590338945389, -0.02288912609219551, 0.009595898911356926, 0.07569249719381332, -0.012480673380196095, -0.012367921881377697, -0.0002813967876136303, -0.08246903866529465, 0.026394307613372803, 0.03624496981501579, -0.008556324988603592, 0.00001907150544866454, 0.027665652334690094, 0.03331505507230759, 0.019951727241277695, 0.05071447044610977, 0.08333757519721985, 0.03639873117208481, -0.013757330365478992, -0.03904762119054794, 0.014249459840357304, -0.07592340558767319, -0.0634857788681984, 0.01940990798175335, -0.06099036708474159, 0.008706565946340561, 0.027675872668623924, -0.07292580604553223, 0.008008458651602268, 0.015608160756528378, 0.01741567626595497, 0.04853877052664757, -0.06011169031262398, -0.0009928960353136063, -0.021361924707889557, 0.011050238274037838, -0.02466912940144539, -0.018765319138765335, -0.012679874897003174, -0.02581486664712429, 0.00008269475802080706, -0.024784395471215248, -0.06290702521800995, -0.03842616453766823, -0.01880614086985588, -0.012418320402503014, -0.016521252691745758, 0.029120510444045067, -0.04075254499912262, -0.006344645284116268, -0.08515146374702454, -0.05448118969798088, -0.0205271914601326, 0.07510683685541153, 0.0028393592219799757, -0.03135596588253975, -0.057270992547273636, 0.040421511977910995, -0.005040568765252829, 0.0019213866908103228, 0.0013059322955086827, 0.020381852984428406, -0.020330077037215233, 0.02484220452606678, -0.030791237950325012, -0.009317530319094658, 0.0627116709947586, 0.0132284639403224, 0.023761482909321785, 0.0009153148275800049, -0.02385563589632511, 0.0011975850211456418, -0.009035627357661724, -0.04417320340871811, -0.017955245450139046, -0.018878718838095665, 0.010040514171123505, -0.014905961230397224, -0.02474149689078331, 0.03137047588825226, 0.014322405681014061, 0.056265804916620255, 0.07385271042585373, -0.039202746003866196, -0.02165752463042736, -0.04006173089146614, 0.04477066546678543, 0.03784335404634476, -0.00940794963389635, -0.019734378904104233, 0.05988074839115143, -0.026086270809173584, 0.055767640471458435, -0.04207700863480568, 0.005448733456432819, -0.06542401760816574, -0.003423891728743911, -0.008242456242442131, -0.010231493972241879, 0.00467330077663064, 0.01810411736369133, -0.00031294304062612355, -0.014595165848731995, -0.07272401452064514, 0.02947687916457653, -0.04542547091841698, -0.06029549613595009, -0.021315766498446465, 0.024805638939142227, 0.01190963201224804, -0.005526077933609486, -0.040197327733039856, -0.015386227518320084, -0.006735281553119421, -0.0319613553583622, -0.000573518278542906, -0.02797369845211506, -0.037811607122421265, 0.0028794410172849894, 0.03533383831381798, -0.007164358161389828, 0.05876710265874863, 0.01393940206617117, 0.010809026658535004, 0.06776324659585953, -0.025088798254728317, 0.024909574538469315, -0.05397147312760353, -0.03570357337594032, -0.015317159704864025, 0.010468813590705395, 0.008379770442843437, 0.02147289365530014, -0.016598550602793694, -0.023006143048405647, -0.0074237557128071785, 0.018843814730644226, -0.017321595922112465, -0.03496934100985527, -0.02937687188386917, -0.007704350631684065, -0.015057383105158806, 0.0034494083374738693, 0.010578555054962635, 0.01852261833846569, 0.007332001347094774, -0.020968979224562645, 0.01580643467605114, 0.020303213968873024, -0.0629216879606247, -0.027108099311590195, -0.008997132070362568, 0.015817791223526, -0.007142939139157534, -0.02275037206709385, -0.07545404136180878, 0.025290580466389656, 0.043034300208091736, 0.07731327414512634, 0.020756829530000687, -0.0017780752386897802, 0.01682005636394024, -0.00591315608471632, 0.0028157623019069433, -0.012620240449905396, 0.033349763602018356, -0.07934251427650452, 0.006610398646444082, 0.02753613144159317, -0.03378098085522652, -0.03728568181395531, -0.062082309275865555, 0.04419787973165512, 0.04161178320646286, 0.00533145060762763, 0.06330268830060959, -0.04397273063659668, 0.015908431261777878, 0.013784602284431458, 0.003030519001185894, -0.04524903744459152, 0.0781688392162323, 0.02552514709532261, -0.04792827367782593, -0.03371657058596611, 0.008595108054578304, -0.03572581708431244, 0.04823848605155945, -0.004458162467926741, -0.03332873433828354, -0.0021686749532818794, -0.0019995206966996193, -0.04529959335923195, 0.036709014326334, -0.009219135157763958, -0.02358221262693405, 0.07039929181337357, -0.03963353857398033, -0.05676133558154106, -0.008660017512738705, 0.03041052259504795, 0.028487809002399445, -0.03095429018139839, -0.008171116933226585, -0.03649651259183884, 0.05636928230524063, 0.03494475409388542, -0.028928518295288086, 0.004583357833325863, -0.08637094497680664, -0.028788737952709198, -0.006679590791463852, -0.013939241878688335, 0.02801266498863697, -0.007352421525865793, -0.031605370342731476, 0.017738573253154755, 0.021517449989914894, -0.10569531470537186, 0.019754068925976753, 0.014527817256748676, -0.013880616053938866, 0.016804922372102737, 0.0004619722021743655, 0.05501575767993927, -0.03767166659235954, 0.0017986394232138991, -0.008915976621210575, -0.03365790843963623, 0.00403177784755826, 0.029775815084576607, -0.05426544323563576, 0.01839054375886917, -0.05554906651377678, 0.060819149017333984, 0.028742579743266106, 0.02123810350894928, -0.04397337883710861, 0.0254917461425066, 0.002764498582109809, -0.028506126254796982, -0.02182236686348915, 0.010168856009840965, -0.04366558417677879, 0.00906518753618002, 0.003519546240568161, -0.022593075409531593, -0.009559186175465584, -0.013926928862929344, -0.005226803943514824, -0.010856756940484047, 0.009997069835662842, -0.01639942266047001, 0.0285891555249691, -0.0555366687476635, 0.0061814552173018456, 0.05023251101374626, -0.055065032094717026, -0.03169763833284378, 0.0025719681289047003, -0.006832884158939123, -0.044312238693237305, -0.04354376345872879, 0.06878650933504105, 0.03935613855719566, 0.022579265758395195, 0.048789989203214645, -0.017335131764411926, -0.03856099769473076, 0.002331978175789118, -0.01158046629279852, -0.014527296647429466, 0.03372539207339287, 0.04022486135363579, -0.002694007707759738, 0.04724184796214104, -0.012760830111801624, -0.019117511808872223, 0.010777363553643227, -0.013374405913054943, 0.035849958658218384, 0.04843907803297043, 0.01969475857913494, 0.04541053995490074, 0.0367717407643795, 0.05809880420565605, -0.012206939980387688, -0.03215856850147247, 0.014450221322476864, 0.024499116465449333, 0.016233470290899277, -0.043992798775434494, -0.01764822192490101, -0.02691422402858734, -0.041286323219537735, 0.007682210765779018, -0.019788583740592003, -0.019856860861182213, -0.008705893531441689, -0.0512654073536396, 0.003180130384862423, -0.06459973007440567, -0.005327660124748945, 0.03617233410477638, 0.009226210415363312, 0.058429405093193054, 0.035295240581035614, 0.03952323645353317, 0.04067477956414223, -0.024940237402915955, 0.038829512894153595, 0.018618926405906677, -0.0420047864317894, 0.0020670213270932436, -0.013576950877904892, 0.003795282682403922, -0.004630388226360083, 0.03560350462794304, 0.04573399946093559, -0.01982259750366211, -0.023199383169412613, -0.07688671350479126, 0.023856475949287415, -0.022367101162672043, 0.05359539017081261, 0.005364375654608011, -0.07706647366285324, 0.039717867970466614, -0.044023267924785614, -0.06187615543603897, 0.04177577421069145, 0.027913838624954224, -0.02698887698352337, -0.005071326624602079, 0.04304713010787964, 0.014383690431714058, 0.035604480654001236, -0.005124659277498722, -0.0017647731583565474, -0.04069041088223457, -0.00422639399766922, 0.028765659779310226, -0.006699721794575453, -0.03217895328998566, 0.0862949937582016, -0.023599999025464058, -0.008813687600195408, -0.029795311391353607, 0.013516072183847427, 0.024482576176524162, -0.01803881861269474, -0.027410494163632393, -0.014553453773260117, 0.017108680680394173, 0.00003507611472741701, -0.01517011970281601, -0.0073297712951898575, -0.07614829391241074, 0.02946513146162033, -0.02863466553390026, -0.0350002683699131, 0.04914087429642677, 0.02535046823322773, -0.058690328150987625, 0.02194000966846943, 0.011377178132534027, -0.02161308191716671, 0.00003781623672693968, 0.028071410953998566, -0.03543489798903465, 0.12072323262691498, 0.037987928837537766, -0.030473720282316208, 0.023814424872398376, -0.004053949844092131, 0.01551245991140604, -0.03759529069066048, 0.05666455999016762, -0.02540965937077999, 0.021286239847540855, -0.0018144957721233368, -0.027983533218503, 0.07896853983402252, 0.01916232332587242, 0.05915661156177521, -0.06730838119983673, -0.06651591509580612, 0.06944061070680618, 0.04220174625515938, -0.021722426638007164, -0.04319259524345398, -0.03322810307145119, -0.0442628487944603, -0.007305809762328863, 0.01534756738692522, -0.009745355695486069, 0.04768082872033119, 0.05416170507669449, 0.004252757411450148, 0.014190834946930408, -0.021464835852384567, -0.03342162445187569, -0.00029707461362704635, -0.04476671665906906, -0.028281208127737045, -0.03870013728737831, -0.0073934998363256454, 0.0275409035384655, 0.006165188271552324, -0.0864998996257782, 0.0018891263753175735, -0.02837250381708145, -0.015463198535144329, -0.019817912951111794, -0.04365154355764389, -0.03721744194626808, 0.015100426971912384, -0.023055685684084892, 0.03934469446539879, -0.041427742689847946, -0.017120737582445145, 0.020793620496988297, -0.058305367827415466, 0.03379802033305168, 0.04390775039792061, -0.051986850798130035, -0.06861692667007446, 0.07082602381706238, -0.003079479793086648, 0.037161000072956085, -0.021009406074881554, 0.013254167512059212, -0.01193641684949398, -0.018659669905900955, 0.03151465952396393, -0.05125991627573967, -0.025353189557790756, -0.002046448877081275, 0.04679812863469124, -0.008100130595266819, 0.025674404576420784, 0.033130813390016556, -0.002560323802754283, 0.017923204228281975, -0.024125616997480392, 0.024878818541765213, 0.03115537017583847, 0.06112969294190407, 0.014845436438918114, -0.050137318670749664, -0.011436842381954193, 0.03262822702527046, 0.027210436761379242, 0.030297067016363144, 0.00032308182562701404, -0.025034824386239052, 0.015446859411895275, -0.018622150644659996, -0.03853454813361168, 0.0011326395906507969, 0.039980147033929825, 0.01351074781268835, 0.027113042771816254, 0.0015627346001565456, -0.021553725004196167, 0.020554762333631516, 0.020762894302606583, 0.01492469385266304, -0.021870801225304604, -0.003804986597970128, 0.0023883439134806395, 0.024640796706080437, 0.015627754852175713, 0.0036192319821566343, -0.02388380654156208, -0.038291238248348236, 0.01949181780219078, 0.02076728269457817, -0.013758929446339607, 0.04907437413930893, -0.052442070096731186, -0.0073944577015936375, 0.027716251090168953, 0.004255612846463919, -0.017809469252824783, -0.07373424619436264, 0.0051946816965937614, -0.024859348312020302, -0.010966303758323193, -0.01388459000736475, 0.04865875095129013, -0.021868547424674034, 0.03762077912688255, -0.0378023162484169, 0.008018662221729755, 0.10246320813894272, 0.000042184659832855687, -0.01638873852789402, -0.04024249315261841, -0.01854640059173107, 0.0009476509876549244, -0.008465403690934181, 0.003952345345169306, 0.034130897372961044, -0.025617273524403572, 0.005046547390520573, -0.058038316667079926, -0.02054089494049549, 0.04531428962945938, 0.05741073563694954 ]
<p>Is photon interaction , electrostatic interaction outside the nucleus and gravitational interaction is all due to electromagnetic waves ? and CAN be identified as with the de Broglie waves ?</p> <p>I thought of a theory in which is assuming that photon interaction , electrostatic interaction outside the nucleus and gravitational interaction is all due to electromagnetic waves and can be identified as with the de Broglie waves in order to explain how the force of gravitation act between particles . So can this assumption stand a chance of being theoretically and experimentally correct . Please add your comments regarding this in your answer and please explain why or why not .</p>
g4249
[ 0.05056634545326233, 0.02044997550547123, 0.009422623552381992, -0.005178275052458048, 0.063234843313694, 0.019687607884407043, 0.011794495396316051, -0.0034887895453721285, -0.021830469369888306, -0.057762306183576584, 0.04544098675251007, 0.0019732352811843157, 0.013874916359782219, 0.032246094197034836, 0.008452873677015305, 0.006261872593313456, 0.07665938884019852, -0.046959180384874344, 0.015580324456095695, 0.016419667750597, -0.022099994122982025, 0.03371863812208176, -0.0225240346044302, -0.07527421414852142, -0.03330335021018982, 0.02715972810983658, 0.08899014443159103, -0.051520947366952896, 0.010602137073874474, -0.060423847287893295, 0.0045375097543001175, -0.035877130925655365, 0.04515557736158371, -0.01183228101581335, -0.03304927051067352, -0.05761697515845299, -0.0007102470262907445, 0.046698953956365585, 0.0052650743164122105, 0.019756078720092773, 0.02347467839717865, -0.0060788593254983425, -0.006726840510964394, 0.009128239937126637, 0.022993013262748718, 0.02594684809446335, -0.03376580774784088, 0.007801349740475416, 0.0010323883034288883, -0.012245525605976582, -0.04628440737724304, 0.011980373412370682, 0.008604425005614758, 0.008642813190817833, 0.0675770491361618, 0.015232447534799576, 0.09046854078769684, 0.016447944566607475, 0.0996696799993515, -0.009441902860999107, -0.01291793305426836, 0.04171402379870415, 0.0017198262503370643, 0.005066859535872936, 0.03834197670221329, -0.02579328417778015, -0.0446813628077507, -0.012541025876998901, 0.03288950026035309, -0.039151303470134735, 0.01564546674489975, -0.022977586835622787, -0.023972028866410255, 0.026266371831297874, 0.07265467941761017, 0.017751609906554222, 0.013504480943083763, 0.009913958609104156, -0.023029839619994164, 0.0027804584242403507, -0.0177516657859087, -0.06752746552228928, 0.01898677460849285, -0.010247494094073772, 0.12636110186576843, -0.03069998510181904, -0.01132249552756548, -0.00968748889863491, 0.00586720323190093, 0.019806472584605217, 0.011378313414752483, -0.060854408890008926, 0.018860090523958206, 0.02057318575680256, 0.002592770615592599, 0.005518483463674784, 0.016135400161147118, 0.09370793402194977, 0.029012221843004227, -0.041954413056373596, -0.016843121498823166, -0.046915702521800995, -0.020118117332458496, -0.006127641536295414, 0.026266932487487793, 0.004135297145694494, -0.01819312758743763, 0.03442353010177612, -0.021303784102201462, -0.00987126026302576, -0.06483568996191025, 0.013563979417085648, -0.0228907261043787, -0.04635273292660713, -0.0019641797989606857, -0.04000239446759224, 0.03839480131864548, -0.04152717813849449, -0.01345519907772541, 0.08856910467147827, -0.031295258551836014, 0.036839745938777924, -0.06640098243951797, 0.02716718427836895, -0.04280639439821243, -0.03960667923092842, -0.011331765912473202, 0.020325753837823868, 0.05007514730095863, -0.0314679890871048, 0.016357066109776497, 0.011568301357328892, -0.014253362081944942, 0.007380421739071608, 0.00903678685426712, -0.012813788838684559, 0.043623488396406174, -0.005811567883938551, -0.014939136803150177, -0.013983330689370632, -0.023176154121756554, -0.006004935596138239, 0.009678512811660767, -0.004503312986344099, -0.023197628557682037, 0.036581769585609436, -0.009337039664387703, 0.031222855672240257, -0.02019096165895462, 0.0366801843047142, 0.01139361783862114, 0.07235908508300781, 0.04989853873848915, -0.043174903839826584, 0.01727907359600067, -0.01294114999473095, -0.027179669588804245, -0.030669372528791428, -0.0496860146522522, 0.07969310879707336, 0.06114299222826958, -0.02217162773013115, 0.02676345221698284, 0.0184615645557642, -0.004543932620435953, -0.011869779787957668, -0.004790496081113815, -0.07438772916793823, -0.008719004690647125, -0.03796566277742386, -0.07079692929983139, -0.014814081601798534, -0.0024004268925637007, 0.05636177211999893, -0.0034439244773238897, 0.043088383972644806, -0.020982403308153152, -0.04482782259583473, 0.01074778102338314, -0.021182147786021233, -0.04224894940853119, -0.01562432385981083, 0.01559260580688715, 0.0016318293055519462, -0.06195054203271866, 0.011841736733913422, 0.01924315094947815, 0.032048165798187256, -0.03286607190966606, -0.010982228443026543, -0.0832117348909378, -0.0038510006852447987, -0.028382454067468643, 0.017561309039592743, 0.017850840464234352, -0.004401469137519598, -0.027033621445298195, -0.023154353722929955, 0.0050917258486151695, 0.03308616951107979, -0.09480143338441849, 0.04533097892999649, 0.05300325155258179, -0.009850075468420982, 0.0615588016808033, -0.0010570852318778634, 0.00019544367387425154, -0.012185771949589252, 0.060356590896844864, -0.005276527255773544, 0.0034468681551516056, 0.02096995711326599, 0.016944080591201782, 0.0009520676685497165, -0.023832345381379128, -0.0426584929227829, -0.018266228958964348, 0.02307201363146305, -0.022463638335466385, 0.04209534823894501, -0.05368676781654358, 0.00833125039935112, -0.00047908586566336453, 0.028484582901000977, -0.0736401304602623, -0.039392292499542236, -0.03902279585599899, 0.03745574876666069, -0.039775799959897995, 0.02442377246916294, -0.015188637189567089, 0.042650770395994186, 0.03959396854043007, -0.006221593823283911, 0.04520592838525772, 0.05820755660533905, -0.0076006618328392506, -0.06216954067349434, -0.019387245178222656, 0.018159380182623863, 0.018256064504384995, -0.02278275042772293, -0.008688430301845074, -0.013111419975757599, 0.014185190200805664, -0.048606015741825104, 0.02604108862578869, 0.0017805284587666392, -0.009565587155520916, -0.02119825780391693, 0.055052950978279114, 0.007906117476522923, -0.028087221086025238, -0.030871111899614334, -0.006013932637870312, -0.0037336640525609255, -0.038241948932409286, 0.03889256343245506, -0.06291130185127258, -0.02925119362771511, -0.018395133316516876, -0.03532261773943901, -0.00009882226004265249, 0.042178213596343994, -0.07868092507123947, -0.005413935985416174, -0.04007572680711746, 0.012430690228939056, -0.04740627110004425, -0.012352928519248962, -0.0069345999509096146, 0.04554285854101181, 0.019919076934456825, -0.015149439685046673, 0.009119849652051926, -0.04184364527463913, -0.004045356530696154, -0.018384549766778946, 0.012315423227846622, -0.005500285420566797, -0.0022026319056749344, 0.03561912849545479, -0.0515495203435421, -0.02823580987751484, 0.05823800712823868, -0.07321284711360931, -0.024532511830329895, -0.0013909706613048911, 0.03265617415308952, -0.04249544069170952, 0.03773842379450798, 0.007797153200954199, 0.012979529798030853, 0.015626950189471245, -0.039631228893995285, 0.0669175237417221, 0.007812113966792822, -0.03151141479611397, -0.05216804891824722, 0.030144326388835907, 0.012654578313231468, -0.04282497242093086, 0.00022898116731084883, 0.01654788665473461, -0.007220282219350338, 0.008417264558374882, -0.04102965071797371, 0.000551304779946804, -0.007416302338242531, -0.016055820509791374, -0.01774970255792141, 0.06633442640304565, 0.031674742698669434, 0.03663845360279083, -0.01604372262954712, -0.038369182497262955, 0.008266528137028217, -0.017315994948148727, -0.02062864974141121, 0.006574256345629692, -0.026499120518565178, -0.00987954530864954, 0.021533135324716568, -0.06798417866230011, 0.03928837552666664, 0.06386808305978775, -0.032883089035749435, 0.030095122754573822, -0.07848384976387024, -0.01851196587085724, -0.012740730307996273, -0.03628569468855858, 0.021460019052028656, -0.023266365751624107, -0.0417848564684391, 0.014083489775657654, 0.013303152285516262, 0.01336885429918766, 0.04493728280067444, 0.019170070067048073, 0.014443482272326946, -0.039076320827007294, -0.044101499021053314, -0.0012307791039347649, -0.02732108347117901, 0.02735714241862297, -0.007061365060508251, -0.04777270555496216, 0.014883101917803288, 0.00943009089678526, 0.0013393863337114453, -0.017546923831105232, 0.027296746149659157, 0.0003899482835549861, -0.01382236648350954, -0.011428939178586006, 0.03480994328856468, 0.06365992873907089, 0.008727180771529675, 0.00036332750460132957, -0.000680138124153018, 0.040664926171302795, 0.016003279015421867, -0.014101603999733925, -0.019627904519438744, -0.026141107082366943, -0.0431133471429348, -0.008517633192241192, -0.0014189291978254914, 0.009723184630274773, 0.01618579402565956, 0.019072044640779495, -0.015381088480353355, -0.007570498622953892, 0.07092545181512833, -0.040867213159799576, 0.08564560860395432, -0.021148882806301117, -0.0033053881488740444, 0.033777303993701935, -0.033234987407922745, 0.05300468951463699, 0.02219538949429989, 0.08047032356262207, 0.13628225028514862, 0.017334967851638794, -0.03450022637844086, 0.04405862092971802, -0.011288587003946304, 0.012731492519378662, -0.033421240746974945, -0.008334234356880188, -0.030850747600197792, 0.026286212727427483, 0.014160441234707832, -0.002719935728237033, -0.0008792518638074398, -0.05129656568169594, 0.05527011305093765, 0.003883510362356901, 0.04495854675769806, -0.006499568000435829, -0.014919212087988853, -0.009017139673233032, 0.015801269561052322, 0.02499745413661003, 0.00020672233949881047, -0.012747394852340221, -0.02053225226700306, 0.002403799444437027, 0.006794868037104607, -0.03059517592191696, 0.020387696102261543, -0.01395478006452322, 0.03982818126678467, 0.027616284787654877, -0.007294910494238138, -0.02251366339623928, 0.006717422977089882, 0.0011975638335570693, 0.038822025060653687, 0.05222748592495918, 0.0076841977424919605, -0.0018097157590091228, -0.03468670696020126, 0.08947157114744186, 0.07209648936986923, 0.023123055696487427, 0.012679916806519032, -0.026590920984745026, -0.040113095194101334, 0.05036713927984238, -0.019385473802685738, -0.029882783070206642, -0.0792173370718956, 0.022345339879393578, -0.041458409279584885, 0.05426189303398132, 0.057229168713092804, 0.021581901237368584, 0.11332178115844727, 0.01668631099164486, -0.0060641770251095295, -0.006057812832295895, 0.05654671788215637, 0.08095800876617432, 0.014469627290964127, -0.03699374571442604, -0.04484369233250618, -0.02242046408355236, -0.002403818303719163, -0.007322379387915134, -0.044823210686445236, -0.024355491623282433, -0.014805964194238186, 0.03542688488960266, 0.022221127524971962, -0.007714343722909689, -0.019057974219322205, 0.0007630908512510359, -0.021335115656256676, 0.011393649503588676, 0.06212618201971054, 0.037495724856853485, 0.08013627678155899, -0.056344084441661835, -0.04147966206073761, -0.024954942986369133, -0.061047039926052094, -0.018460383638739586, -0.00434860959649086, 0.03946628049015999, 0.06514657288789749, -0.02618662267923355, -0.008163101971149445, -0.020826173946261406, -0.0583316944539547, -0.023553848266601562, 0.022422488778829575, -0.029357582330703735, -0.0010263208532705903, 0.02038164809346199, 0.020920291543006897, 0.0007739167776890099, -0.0767909586429596, 0.0032427364494651556, 0.005443624686449766, 0.06404464691877365, -0.08352521061897278, -0.04266084358096123, 0.03367442265152931, -0.09076160192489624, 0.007567067630589008, -0.05108244717121124, -0.0027706455439329147, 0.02273174375295639, -0.003963744733482599, -0.022192243486642838, 0.01701384223997593, -0.04510516673326492, 0.0002693892165552825, -0.01750456728041172, -0.02915186434984207, -0.005148577969521284, -0.05249134823679924, 0.00505084590986371, 0.04137352481484413, -0.0013095234753564, -0.051048967987298965, 0.0441615916788578, -0.021293101832270622, -0.0027766923885792494, -0.026691116392612457, 0.04325828328728676, -0.012839922681450844, -0.001813779934309423, -0.027062999084591866, 0.020861944183707237, 0.04574158415198326, -0.0003779038379434496, 0.022612854838371277, -0.015089214779436588, -0.019905468448996544, -0.05242601037025452, 0.06529628485441208, -0.047341350466012955, 0.018338629975914955, 0.030063124373555183, 0.027311330661177635, 0.03469850495457649, 0.02525164745748043, 0.011944649741053581, 0.024281766265630722, 0.05363497883081436, 0.0063253287225961685, -0.07887539267539978, -0.013091915287077427, -0.0024301134981215, 0.04827968776226044, 0.009584104642271996, 0.025700930505990982, -0.012312594801187515, 0.04972360283136368, 0.05614791437983513, 0.00767957279458642, 0.05222231522202492, -0.012340054847300053, -0.0006498292787000537, -0.016879117116332054, -0.05629603564739227, -0.049425575882196426, 0.041988395154476166, 0.008892751298844814, 0.021880364045500755, -0.037683624774217606, 0.04507860913872719, 0.015322507359087467, -0.03876333683729172, 0.014118929393589497, -0.01582181639969349, 0.03337739408016205, 0.03503050282597542, -0.019019540399312973, 0.023771116510033607, 0.007930361665785313, 0.023347707465291023, 0.030759409070014954, -0.07030929625034332, 0.010442581959068775, 0.021547134965658188, -0.005949188955128193, 0.006419770419597626, -0.055444031953811646, 0.007334842812269926, 0.028611473739147186, -0.037190016359090805, 0.019353806972503662, -0.00016476857126690447, -0.055016420781612396, 0.005698188208043575, 0.09505537152290344, 0.009024822153151035, 0.03028992936015129, -0.07352148741483688, -0.030849037691950798, -0.006758462637662888, -0.03403058648109436, 0.03748563304543495, 0.03597325086593628, -0.0230487659573555, 0.009109151549637318, -0.04176284745335579, -0.028817495331168175, -0.02793753892183304, -0.0343526229262352, -0.05196331813931465, 0.033033713698387146, -0.02158619649708271, 0.009225568734109402, 0.07235193252563477, 0.03817617520689964, -0.07187046110630035, 0.020864328369498253, 0.054234523326158524, -0.00464932806789875, 0.010602060705423355, -0.0496746301651001, -0.01829378493130207, -0.014284458011388779, 0.023507948964834213, -0.02877984382212162, -0.010431340895593166, -0.03464047610759735, -0.033951468765735626, -0.019342007115483284, -0.08048532903194427, -0.04549798741936684, 0.010049057193100452, -0.01811521127820015, -0.006949051283299923, -0.02272469736635685, -0.0274354275316, -0.029883773997426033, -0.06914865225553513, 0.06236092746257782, 0.025879742577672005, -0.03776842728257179, 0.01733577996492386, 0.014547429047524929, 0.04051653668284416, -0.004197616595774889, 0.0002543757436797023, 0.011549320071935654, -0.0015171581180766225, -0.04090460017323494, 0.0542062483727932, 0.012584823183715343, -0.08024420589208603, 0.06581169366836548, -0.03370659425854683, -0.023350104689598083, 0.04716431349515915, 0.08114657551050186, 0.03312278166413307, -0.06830702722072601, -0.03144846856594086, 0.0459296740591526, -0.039452336728572845, -0.08937624841928482, 0.03446357697248459, -0.0661841481924057, -0.04370143637061119, 0.016037115827202797, 0.023681646212935448, -0.002528973389416933, 0.011573543772101402, -0.04528602212667465, 0.010606442578136921, -0.016970966011285782, -0.03320695459842682, -0.08852660655975342, 0.022630302235484123, -0.017149358987808228, 0.021078940480947495, 0.015062275342643261, -0.00760157685726881, -0.01619533821940422, -0.04491342976689339, -0.02649012580513954, -0.007897925563156605, -0.02350173518061638, -0.08065468072891235, -0.015707142651081085, -0.0040268441662192345, -0.042310118675231934, 0.005821084138005972, -0.018722787499427795, -0.003317736554890871, -0.021490193903446198, 0.012485760264098644, 0.02462555095553398, 0.034497763961553574, -0.021766318008303642, 0.09234100580215454, -0.06315004080533981, 0.07481615990400314, 0.054349541664123535, 0.0030587322544306517, -0.054028674960136414, 0.03348299115896225, -0.023122288286685944, -0.017804434522986412, 0.01835891790688038, -0.015518777072429657, 0.000628710666205734, -0.02905390039086342, 0.0035407727118581533, 0.08425813913345337, 0.0318126380443573, -0.028992926701903343, -0.01555710844695568, 0.033266495913267136, -0.0304414015263319, -0.050540585070848465, 0.008056797087192535, 0.026847923174500465, -0.004094152245670557, 0.008366545662283897, -0.018775325268507004, 0.05103135481476784, 0.04320758581161499, 0.024514300748705864, 0.034518081694841385, 0.028505032882094383, -0.009099111892282963, 0.05488664656877518, -0.010462806560099125, 0.0389690138399601, 0.019867664203047752, 0.011952883563935757, 0.012843258678913116, 0.004776549059897661, -0.07027269899845123, -0.04032690078020096, -0.038798701018095016, 0.0012771034380421042, -0.008415451273322105, -0.0373193584382534, 0.038702256977558136, 0.00882700178772211, -0.06050242483615875, 0.001756519777700305, -0.02756022848188877, -0.015981193631887436, -0.0021969082299619913, 0.03325451910495758, 0.00991884432733059, -0.037510618567466736, -0.02923605963587761, 0.010349366813898087, 0.026551926508545876, -0.05496922507882118, -0.010389837436378002, -0.005322575569152832, 0.007857577875256538, -0.015955574810504913, 0.005185917019844055, -0.008941463194787502, 0.05493912845849991, 0.02817479521036148, 0.020026974380016327, 0.06710320711135864, 0.0005084851873107255, 0.06221221387386322, 0.04834028333425522, -0.07231906801462173, -0.004723817575722933, 0.029528072103857994, 0.02490060403943062, 0.007354086264967918, 0.0011499013053253293, 0.011128515005111694, 0.014588265679776669, -0.03923331946134567, -0.005217905156314373, 0.013887770473957062, -0.003425234230235219, 0.04464605823159218 ]
<p>Let $\mathbf{E}(r,t),\mathbf{B}(r,t)$ be two vector fields (in $\mathbb{R}^3$), s.t. they satisfy fot $t=0$ the equations:</p> <ol> <li><p>$\nabla \cdot \mathbf{B}(r,0)=0.$ </p></li> <li><p>$\nabla \cdot \mathbf{E}(r,0)=\frac{\rho(r,0)}{\epsilon_0}.$</p></li> </ol> <p>The question now is:</p> <p>What properties have $\mathbf{E}$ and $\mathbf{B}$ got in order to satisfy equation 1 and 2 for all $t&gt;0$?</p> <p>I think $\mathbf{B}$ must be independent of $t$, i.e. $\mathbf{B}(r,t)=\mathbf{B}(r,0)$ for all $t&gt;0$. But what about $\mathbf{E}$?</p> <p>Doesn't the answer depend on the function $\rho(r,t)$?</p>
g4250
[ 0.026720408350229263, -0.013471824117004871, -0.038087595254182816, 0.057687800377607346, 0.07885076850652695, -0.0242389477789402, 0.036531124264001846, 0.007199897896498442, -0.04253707081079483, 0.018521597608923912, -0.0967135801911354, 0.035350266844034195, -0.0021596048027276993, -0.03391672670841217, -0.006439398042857647, 0.027132201939821243, 0.013704987242817879, -0.02397632971405983, -0.01650441810488701, 0.03228678181767464, -0.04075518622994423, 0.02413257211446762, 0.05231058970093727, 0.015157661400735378, 0.09138667583465576, -0.03891142085194588, 0.05137502774596214, 0.007112130057066679, -0.07125570625066757, -0.0673968493938446, -0.006316665560007095, 0.08308185636997223, 0.06816764175891876, -0.03840936720371246, 0.0030140781309455633, 0.004213537555187941, 0.03939837962388992, -0.009296267293393612, 0.043411124497652054, -0.032449763268232346, 0.011067070066928864, 0.024414287880063057, 0.006928973365575075, 0.050929367542266846, -0.018233805894851685, 0.000011566802641027607, -0.02248411253094673, 0.03174329921603203, 0.0027305169496685266, -0.05640459060668945, 0.014601270668208599, -0.017907047644257545, 0.04839792475104332, -0.06151171773672104, -0.08042793720960617, 0.026604866608977318, -0.000773379229940474, -0.05535472556948662, 0.018811918795108795, -0.0012942206813022494, -0.020618325099349022, -0.039144568145275116, -0.031028680503368378, 0.042688652873039246, -0.01998867839574814, -0.012236044742166996, 0.004219760186970234, -0.026951344683766365, -0.033886026591062546, 0.019433490931987762, 0.003371061757206917, -0.007492821663618088, -0.015748655423521996, -0.05675576254725456, -0.0662405788898468, -0.02476198971271515, 0.016673481091856956, 0.025427984073758125, 0.019406825304031372, 0.022597750648856163, 0.017957596108317375, 0.0417095422744751, 0.0032139134127646685, 0.03708921745419502, -0.002835954772308469, -0.00856377650052309, 0.05014078691601753, -0.0008235585992224514, 0.012707901187241077, 0.04597485065460205, -0.027485860511660576, -0.022072963416576385, -0.006398273631930351, 0.01798553578555584, -0.0145528269931674, -0.004626740235835314, 0.005723377224057913, 0.006368375848978758, -0.004878039937466383, -0.015054379589855671, 0.017576243728399277, -0.008889000862836838, 0.03273208439350128, -0.003434103447943926, 0.05426729470491409, -0.012682429514825344, 0.07452906668186188, 0.042117081582546234, -0.03191269189119339, -0.020787164568901062, -0.04203975945711136, 0.02224918268620968, -0.08922507613897324, -0.017461087554693222, -0.03131929785013199, -0.019706208258867264, 0.03487246856093407, -0.03475768491625786, -0.018461834639310837, 0.019417118281126022, 0.007502339780330658, -0.036006588488817215, 0.06943953037261963, 0.072578065097332, -0.04442618042230606, 0.07862862199544907, 0.02538001537322998, 0.05739833042025566, 0.06864144653081894, -0.04479190334677696, 0.012242334894835949, -0.028841769322752953, 0.02511478401720524, -0.006341332104057074, 0.022322893142700195, 0.041443049907684326, -0.05855027958750725, 0.04456713795661926, -0.022476181387901306, -0.02516685053706169, 0.013178694061934948, -0.019408132880926132, -0.02923189289867878, -0.0061029428616166115, -0.05390407145023346, 0.0032923517283052206, 0.06059067323803902, -0.0871017575263977, 0.01863900013267994, 0.028407324105501175, -0.04614867642521858, 0.02236710675060749, -0.019838634878396988, 0.014698737300932407, 0.03004082664847374, 0.03199661523103714, 0.025731639936566353, -0.06883779168128967, -0.016782129183411598, -0.03542126342654228, 0.051299866288900375, 0.007047977298498154, 0.05860317125916481, 0.028117451816797256, -0.03525626286864281, 0.008114544674754143, -0.006071177776902914, -0.07046566903591156, -0.00704101100564003, -0.023817095905542374, -0.03912601247429848, 0.0783141702413559, 0.03061079978942871, 0.0065686702728271484, 0.047463223338127136, 0.0515659898519516, -0.039537277072668076, -0.022186079993844032, 0.009239627979695797, -0.011445296928286552, -0.052710987627506256, -0.01185094378888607, 0.02105829492211342, 0.01539523620158434, 0.0050211334601044655, -0.04409043490886688, 0.03375062346458435, 0.01325015164911747, -0.10887924581766129, 0.008300340734422207, -0.021554041653871536, 0.0673421174287796, 0.007622332777827978, -0.03416246175765991, 0.0010758357821032405, 0.05525851622223854, -0.061154671013355255, -0.06040976941585541, 0.021433932706713676, 0.011674652807414532, -0.006110191810876131, 0.04015813767910004, 0.01362750306725502, 0.03943784162402153, -0.05911118537187576, 0.0055402428843081, 0.006379153113812208, 0.02707814984023571, 0.03368167579174042, -0.0017441584495827556, -0.01594531163573265, -0.07711850851774216, 0.013417006470263004, 0.04888581857085228, -0.013380936346948147, -0.0477425679564476, 0.04164149612188339, -0.0033107157796621323, -0.05416109412908554, -0.02886326238512993, -0.029169082641601562, -0.02754073776304722, 0.0547482892870903, 0.012072010897099972, -0.06981915980577469, 0.010296558029949665, -0.02161257714033127, 0.04707585275173187, 0.01888113096356392, -0.015459398739039898, -0.016316888853907585, -0.03546195104718208, 0.02764379046857357, -0.022952578961849213, 0.014950514771044254, -0.018433580175042152, 0.03268281742930412, -0.014425343833863735, 0.03178250417113304, 0.07496479898691177, 0.027226191014051437, 0.016301309689879417, 0.012375378049910069, 0.016347898170351982, 0.02768990583717823, -0.0016903559444472194, 0.0597694106400013, -0.013741175644099712, 0.014338049106299877, 0.04517596960067749, -0.03162481635808945, -0.006248129066079855, 0.0278474111109972, 0.08028250187635422, -0.068020299077034, -0.00554264010861516, 0.048161569982767105, -0.01564261130988598, -0.04003237932920456, -0.009074937552213669, -0.004902415443211794, 0.026293152943253517, 0.028550997376441956, 0.05328963324427605, -0.08769988268613815, 0.013383879326283932, -0.023252809420228004, 0.015532849356532097, 0.01900435984134674, -0.02665923908352852, -0.034261737018823624, 0.04546266049146652, -0.01239303220063448, 0.05575770139694214, 0.012603183276951313, -0.04140947759151459, -0.013874420896172523, -0.004281433764845133, 0.018508311361074448, -0.002084951614961028, -0.022899489849805832, -0.02836446277797222, -0.01889885775744915, 0.053158238530159, 0.003686683252453804, 0.005643591284751892, -0.01542628649622202, 0.015072846785187721, -0.034963227808475494, 0.0427938774228096, -0.06154376268386841, 0.0785331204533577, 0.07960420101881027, -0.014269793406128883, -0.02510472759604454, 0.006111192051321268, -0.029621802270412445, -0.07027888298034668, -0.029434053227305412, 0.008082223124802113, -0.007176640443503857, 0.04398904740810394, -0.041027337312698364, -0.03767940402030945, -0.02358146943151951, -0.04437299817800522, -0.05067690834403038, -0.06338069587945938, 0.05089489743113518, 0.03604256361722946, -0.017052609473466873, -0.006904359441250563, 0.0007638228707946837, -0.05366148427128792, 0.026958724483847618, 0.037073299288749695, 0.022186288610100746, -0.02031167596578598, 0.023793064057826996, 0.015854081138968468, -0.022395646199584007, -0.0780157744884491, 0.03435889631509781, -0.03515559807419777, 0.0046684942208230495, 0.00660559581592679, -0.0016575992340222, 0.0008425013511441648, -0.0052522942423820496, -0.002223141025751829, -0.01289854384958744, 0.03152415156364441, 0.03802751749753952, -0.03337091580033302, 0.018214453011751175, 0.02574020065367222, 0.01212355587631464, 0.04863652214407921, 0.0329713448882103, -0.04646247997879982, 0.003257234115153551, -0.005009881220757961, -0.06273933500051498, 0.02000422775745392, -0.06815596669912338, 0.007980912923812866, 0.02077934518456459, -0.015375648625195026, 0.07848813384771347, -0.006596961058676243, -0.01560330018401146, -0.018668046221137047, 0.03345789760351181, -0.030657732859253883, 0.002807572018355131, -0.021312657743692398, 0.046442970633506775, 0.01270704623311758, -0.0067632803693413734, -0.0037136718165129423, 0.023274991661310196, -0.030464816838502884, -0.010631415992975235, -0.0042961640283465385, -0.016616862267255783, -0.02526398003101349, 0.0073903584852814674, 0.02325356751680374, -0.030277587473392487, -0.0027184991631656885, 0.03717578575015068, -0.008405260741710663, 0.0194558072835207, 0.0517691969871521, 0.05178455635905266, -0.05394203960895538, 0.02609923668205738, 0.003050609026104212, -0.07883886247873306, 0.02809235081076622, 0.056488391011953354, 0.04316633567214012, 0.0006963522755540907, 0.05886624753475189, -0.013701987452805042, -0.04360910877585411, -0.007734767626971006, -0.001338195987045765, 0.03844057768583298, 0.022994117811322212, 0.020733019337058067, 0.03158337250351906, -0.024196993559598923, 0.00669736135751009, 0.03473931550979614, -0.020451359450817108, 0.04862091690301895, -0.0265340656042099, -0.040627580136060715, -0.01599067449569702, 0.04050320014357567, -0.01929664984345436, 0.05312912166118622, -0.01512350607663393, -0.03611570969223976, -0.012944853864610195, -0.0062265959568321705, 0.0011553652584552765, 0.036425307393074036, -0.011833281256258488, -0.03851429745554924, -0.07928606867790222, -0.021240685135126114, -0.005605723243206739, -0.003601404372602701, 0.04143078625202179, 0.0312114879488945, -0.027236662805080414, 0.026255503296852112, -0.050390295684337616, 0.01827028952538967, -0.04793235659599304, 0.04148673266172409, -0.059813983738422394, 0.051346272230148315, 0.08014831691980362, 0.02398364059627056, -0.050801098346710205, -0.03475992754101753, 0.021409275010228157, 0.004712600260972977, 0.01896362565457821, -0.049383752048015594, 0.04854147508740425, -0.02987719140946865, 0.032596785575151443, -0.04556702822446823, 0.06803718209266663, -0.04319802671670914, 0.0003880984440911561, 0.01546429842710495, -0.03165047615766525, 0.0020106572192162275, -0.07140111923217773, -0.017255142331123352, 0.024319497868418694, -0.050186656415462494, -0.03029363602399826, -0.008825070224702358, 0.00462754862383008, 0.009628213942050934, 0.05064354091882706, 0.01792830042541027, -0.018203292042016983, -0.029688868671655655, -0.00796207319945097, 0.004035003017634153, 0.018331322818994522, 0.0539245530962944, -0.028298724442720413, -0.007982428185641766, -0.03262334689497948, 0.0339537188410759, 0.0007744989125058055, 0.053816840052604675, -0.03782162442803383, -0.026274003088474274, 0.0248428825289011, -0.04749542102217674, 0.017152655869722366, 0.01913355104625225, -0.013261178508400917, 0.052437685430049896, 0.03914148733019829, -0.04907840117812157, -0.06509219110012054, -0.036454103887081146, 0.01701308786869049, -0.045624881982803345, -0.04545741155743599, 0.003413795493543148, -0.02986915409564972, 0.021770257502794266, 0.057517871260643005, 0.03138092905282974, -0.03383742272853851, 0.008674892596900463, -0.012917021289467812, 0.039483293890953064, -0.02972756326198578, -0.04063963145017624, 0.07553336024284363, 0.019398236647248268, 0.0553576797246933, -0.04963654652237892, -0.0661010816693306, 0.00356636056676507, 0.02689601667225361, 0.02374514937400818, 0.028713148087263107, -0.02332618460059166, -0.015101260505616665, -0.029712721705436707, 0.010843133553862572, 0.027046894654631615, 0.01718699373304844, 0.04126359149813652, -0.03874063491821289, 0.004564693663269281, -0.03654467314481735, -0.014487456530332565, -0.026599949225783348, 0.0018081507878378034, 0.02649593912065029, -0.036363385617733, -0.019045397639274597, -0.04716923087835312, -0.009640632197260857, -0.029074652120471, -0.023273270577192307, 0.05913364142179489, -0.053371213376522064, 0.043576814234256744, -0.03670353814959526, 0.05166852846741676, 0.02833513543009758, -0.06878653168678284, -0.06298653036355972, 0.0030175817664712667, 0.05154705047607422, -0.06675104796886444, 0.005725777242332697, 0.0071984087117016315, -0.05001198500394821, 0.05067269131541252, -0.028842857107520103, 0.0022415691055357456, -0.02498578652739525, -0.0008353996090590954, -0.0054189227521419525, 0.041045598685741425, 0.023563511669635773, 0.009194357320666313, 0.026533028110861778, -0.0836077556014061, -0.029263567179441452, 0.013004795648157597, 0.0028733082581311464, 0.02401399239897728, -0.06096780672669411, -0.053741734474897385, -0.0180771816521883, -0.002116600750014186, 0.00005568045162362978, -0.030040116980671883, 0.01870555616915226, 0.002674416173249483, 0.016873972490429878, -0.0544087179005146, -0.050941310822963715, 0.02803458645939827, -0.0519997663795948, -0.013045030646026134, -0.008932836353778839, -0.020168257877230644, -0.02924325317144394, 0.05593450367450714, 0.048452235758304596, -0.005462277214974165, 0.01030980795621872, -0.020211612805724144, -0.031228885054588318, 0.022367410361766815, -0.01721917651593685, 0.038056615740060806, 0.03756650909781456, -0.021663956344127655, -0.017224445939064026, 0.017186962068080902, -0.013331360183656216, 0.01574501395225525, 0.023490507155656815, 0.017342278733849525, -0.07704797387123108, -0.017081188037991524, 0.04699195176362991, -0.01355831976979971, -0.05628657713532448, 0.0857451930642128, -0.004131046123802662, -0.020102832466363907, -0.02533665858209133, -0.019337188452482224, -0.020945392549037933, 0.03449442237615585, 0.019249286502599716, -0.029014864936470985, 0.03434554487466812, 0.033922161906957626, -0.004718402400612831, 0.00015564558270853013, 0.041338227689266205, 0.08712901920080185, -0.0293438583612442, 0.01412168052047491, 0.03329747915267944, -0.03457644581794739, -0.039389319717884064, -0.035763390362262726, -0.026054907590150833, -0.0135576743632555, 0.023586835712194443, -0.012517021037638187, -0.015521508641541004, -0.027447747066617012, 0.0014821935910731554, -0.017902657389640808, 0.041055742651224136, -0.027460608631372452, -0.02489819936454296, -0.01543360110372305, -0.10002058744430542, -0.0137648219242692, -0.0076478649862110615, -0.0035970909520983696, 0.0005118685658089817, 0.012498016469180584, 0.045585550367832184, 0.022833840921521187, -0.01836678571999073, 0.0685921162366867, 0.03150416538119316, -0.06282875686883926, 0.008314132690429688, -0.005638251081109047, 0.008113205432891846, -0.05314329266548157, 0.029040828347206116, -0.03465244174003601, -0.010230405256152153, -0.01814243197441101, 0.107137531042099, 0.03456217050552368, 0.04465963691473007, 0.00808663573116064, 0.010483771562576294, 0.024688933044672012, -0.006556424777954817, -0.05968242138624191, -0.013026083819568157, 0.08852381259202957, 0.04154176265001297, 0.012044540606439114, -0.027754560112953186, -0.0006958081503398716, -0.08982884883880615, -0.0031242507975548506, -0.022804586216807365, -0.03631994500756264, 0.007831568829715252, 0.017736513167619705, 0.008194171823561192, -0.023137491196393967, 0.013109139166772366, -0.0052206204272806644, 0.001069233869202435, 0.05526239797472954, -0.022371960803866386, 0.02749057300388813, -0.005618207156658173, 0.028559671714901924, -0.008068397641181946, 0.018592949956655502, 0.04169376939535141, -0.04827180504798889, 0.02052447758615017, -0.02047538571059704, 0.03593550994992256, -0.0033459237311035395, -0.026724757626652718, 0.018206020817160606, 0.00852882768958807, 0.002744367578998208, -0.0436408631503582, -0.05229257047176361, 0.05256270617246628, -0.007940289564430714, -0.010680563747882843, 0.030581703409552574, -0.008781539276242256, -0.037122778594493866, 0.044988617300987244, 0.06801589578390121, 0.01773550920188427, 0.00035351276164874434, -0.006840904243290424, -0.04302637651562691, 0.019670946523547173, 0.016231510788202286, -0.014424356631934643, 0.007099589798599482, -0.04902180656790733, 0.016825765371322632, -0.032842881977558136, 0.016406234353780746, -0.01254408061504364, 0.003694497048854828, -0.02028706483542919, -0.03829927742481232, 0.022459009662270546, -0.020218150690197945, -0.007411186583340168, 0.03996366634964943, -0.0024368022568523884, 0.027779456228017807, -0.005157057195901871, -0.07498868554830551, 0.04070567712187767, 0.009005139581859112, 0.018894493579864502, -0.023947497829794884, -0.028987543657422066, -0.008344140835106373, -0.05203574150800705, 0.007403112482279539, 0.020501838997006416, -0.06236756592988968, -0.035706646740436554, 0.024825524538755417, -0.004490517545491457, -0.05724911391735077, -0.04480008780956268, -0.002162344055250287, 0.0856470838189125, -0.026150481775403023, 0.09964922070503235, 0.041390467435121536, -0.028100501745939255, -0.02873881347477436, 0.024072300642728806, 0.0009476580307818949, -0.014054246246814728, -0.022340670228004456, 0.045256927609443665, -0.005835436284542084, -0.009195062331855297, 0.027214130386710167, 0.014902764931321144, 0.011306190863251686, 0.0024160179309546947, -0.027657464146614075, -0.00029451315640471876, -0.04364599660038948, 0.03335617855191231, 0.07885211706161499, -0.010885905474424362, -0.00690458482131362, 0.020841913297772408, 0.09068417549133301, 0.05444265529513359, -0.006930214818567038, 0.03392047435045242, -0.031264081597328186, 0.019472097977995872, -0.007638111244887114, -0.03756226226687431, -0.0017270122189074755, 0.05466879531741142 ]
<p>Conventional wires become very lossy at high frequencies. </p> <p><strong>Is this because of the skin effect?</strong></p> <p>Plasmon based computer chips, since plasmons can support much higher frequencies (~100 THz range). </p> <p>Aren't free electron oscillations in a metal plasmons. What is the difference and why can they support such high optical frequencies?</p>
g4251
[ 0.08827318251132965, 0.037483904510736465, -0.004921525251120329, 0.02033056691288948, 0.03663218393921852, 0.044690102338790894, 0.0007431583944708109, -0.030240507796406746, 0.025604495778679848, -0.021519528701901436, 0.04117462784051895, 0.0591670498251915, -0.01874994859099388, 0.04309994727373123, -0.03041781298816204, 0.03003048524260521, -0.020795496180653572, 0.026808546856045723, 0.05746996030211449, 0.05139893665909767, -0.059880152344703674, -0.06309060752391815, -0.046940550208091736, 0.0017810787539929152, -0.040999144315719604, 0.0018294398905709386, -0.0029660500586032867, -0.03909743204712868, 0.0024753022007644176, -0.019010381773114204, 0.021535517647862434, -0.04810435324907303, 0.09385912865400314, 0.001792790601029992, -0.02523198164999485, -0.000508827855810523, 0.007076164707541466, -0.00821639969944954, -0.0031560861971229315, 0.041442062705755234, -0.003744126297533512, -0.030181489884853363, 0.017373142763972282, 0.020844655111432076, -0.023143719881772995, -0.05042008310556412, -0.06315618008375168, -0.062298305332660675, -0.002236597705632448, -0.11412398517131805, -0.007961916737258434, -0.04017980769276619, 0.021603800356388092, 0.00017502994160167873, 0.031983595341444016, -0.04903390631079674, -0.011156538501381874, 0.03037077747285366, 0.03923323005437851, 0.010998077690601349, 0.027355685830116272, 0.0766368880867958, -0.02346952073276043, 0.0436728298664093, -0.018635880202054977, -0.020216038450598717, 0.028925130143761635, 0.022299494594335556, 0.009637110866606236, -0.0030294235330075026, 0.014524278230965137, -0.08173669874668121, -0.05405756086111069, -0.04168038070201874, 0.05737169086933136, -0.01883203536272049, -0.05411308631300926, 0.011723688803613186, 0.02918151021003723, -0.00518116494640708, -0.0663222223520279, 0.02981867827475071, -0.08136885613203049, 0.053138673305511475, -0.022509224712848663, -0.014594550244510174, -0.04157298430800438, -0.017287788912653923, 0.02317584492266178, 0.07044344395399094, 0.04537951573729515, -0.003540982957929373, 0.05674466863274574, -0.03798637539148331, -0.01671379618346691, -0.0244467630982399, 0.03440400958061218, 0.019747581332921982, 0.012998200953006744, -0.0463336706161499, 0.009617057628929615, -0.021775217726826668, 0.030478056520223618, 0.022439299151301384, -0.032435111701488495, -0.018993141129612923, 0.028645269572734833, 0.006515883840620518, -0.03665640205144882, 0.04140312597155571, 0.03561399132013321, -0.036775141954422, -0.040038254112005234, 0.017489148303866386, 0.015568227507174015, 0.03882172703742981, -0.018202506005764008, -0.02811635285615921, 0.0063090878538787365, 0.03948155418038368, 0.05367397889494896, -0.06634318083524704, 0.024695513769984245, 0.0003747279697563499, 0.024759948253631592, 0.02777155116200447, 0.06660250574350357, 0.013342699967324734, 0.03345291316509247, -0.025263698771595955, 0.02156679891049862, 0.04865804687142372, -0.08379818499088287, 0.008709130808711052, 0.04120098799467087, -0.007101581431925297, 0.008889191783964634, -0.04388585314154625, 0.06040892377495766, -0.0037755027879029512, 0.01905987039208412, -0.06157377362251282, 0.026092898100614548, -0.06553134322166443, -0.059030838310718536, 0.040421850979328156, 0.0026306381914764643, 0.004519670270383358, 0.046428702771663666, -0.01748747006058693, 0.004556344822049141, 0.05458555370569229, 0.018962088972330093, -0.07871448993682861, -0.016550229862332344, -0.009559143334627151, 0.0136859817430377, -0.011316669173538685, -0.020911306142807007, 0.00910242274403572, 0.03181484714150429, 0.00002582531851658132, -0.003811015747487545, 0.03609149903059006, 0.011733912862837315, -0.02309943176805973, -0.022693101316690445, -0.04469602182507515, 0.0018435845850035548, -0.02718782052397728, 0.0023508479353040457, 0.01615339331328869, -0.04193258285522461, 0.09678132832050323, 0.01155543327331543, 0.006074624601751566, 0.025056961923837662, 0.009868793189525604, 0.06370559334754944, -0.024220136925578117, -0.03853248432278633, -0.03641918674111366, -0.04281850531697273, 0.004088393412530422, 0.02415185049176216, 0.034967090934515, 0.038125764578580856, 0.015323009341955185, -0.05486948788166046, 0.07928647845983505, -0.08589360117912292, 0.010625234805047512, -0.02277267910540104, -0.016048850491642952, -0.00008853658073348925, -0.01370785292237997, -0.026421191170811653, -0.009606672450900078, -0.055393949151039124, 0.018403368070721626, 0.008925343863666058, 0.009059982374310493, -0.014146976172924042, -0.027153795585036278, 0.03758075088262558, -0.01129370741546154, -0.06805074959993362, -0.01947806030511856, 0.015897177159786224, -0.06479421257972717, 0.018897201865911484, 0.0933823511004448, -0.0009449947974644601, 0.011278744786977768, 0.02407209761440754, -0.0015595738077536225, 0.008151843212544918, -0.008554168976843357, 0.017663659527897835, 0.024493390694260597, 0.04536658525466919, -0.027591919526457787, 0.0428774394094944, -0.007483206689357758, -0.07151903212070465, -0.010010828264057636, -0.013864066451787949, -0.00640259962528944, 0.012054407969117165, -0.004773419350385666, 0.0001544933911645785, -0.011172485537827015, -0.032854873687028885, -0.020799770951271057, -0.02951575070619583, 0.010009665973484516, 0.028162388131022453, 0.022869903594255447, -0.009057994931936264, -0.010635598562657833, 0.02264559082686901, -0.03170144930481911, -0.040410760790109634, -0.0036277282051742077, -0.07111503183841705, -0.054252419620752335, -0.015053960494697094, -0.009435437619686127, -0.011760853230953217, 0.011593279428780079, 0.08636907488107681, 0.01262899860739708, 0.0010920597705990076, 0.008144017308950424, -0.003534052986651659, -0.005432918667793274, 0.004462437704205513, 0.06732607632875443, 0.002476921770721674, -0.00449395040050149, -0.0015926037449389696, 0.024715440347790718, -0.07266486436128616, -0.02491842769086361, 0.0063009606674313545, 0.033056240528821945, 0.030141808092594147, 0.03871305286884308, -0.06445781141519547, 0.014502113685011864, -0.01220912765711546, 0.04157039150595665, -0.044387638568878174, 0.004056672565639019, 0.04538882151246071, -0.022808512672781944, 0.017338283360004425, 0.03286024555563927, 0.037879496812820435, -0.02396327443420887, -0.01882435381412506, 0.03744034469127655, -0.03738914057612419, -0.030785301700234413, -0.026195576414465904, -0.048125896602869034, 0.07369808852672577, -0.012362382374703884, 0.01271834410727024, 0.008163969963788986, -0.044844936579465866, 0.0215472225099802, 0.024608848616480827, -0.024191120639443398, -0.025558266788721085, -0.019860727712512016, 0.07574832439422607, -0.0032533302437514067, -0.07242689281702042, 0.04494550824165344, 0.0028418079018592834, 0.024856487289071083, 0.019979076460003853, 0.04642874002456665, 0.028062855824828148, 0.05108138918876648, -0.04100413993000984, -0.021809764206409454, 0.03025570884346962, -0.05294273421168327, 0.09597481042146683, 0.03617961332201958, 0.05422002822160721, -0.022181624546647072, -0.05262227728962898, -0.00024227946414612234, -0.003211952978745103, 0.009889447130262852, -0.005017272662371397, 0.013536188751459122, -0.04664761200547218, -0.03712744265794754, -0.04348564147949219, -0.03229931369423866, 0.01148748304694891, -0.08762875199317932, -0.021275755017995834, 0.008556553162634373, -0.05679647997021675, 0.003685965668410063, -0.006212957203388214, -0.012274201028048992, -0.04698644205927849, -0.025950297713279724, -0.03036457672715187, -0.048346854746341705, 0.02122131735086441, 0.049953777343034744, 0.0024863556027412415, 0.008332774043083191, -0.023863647133111954, 0.028138818219304085, -0.062160853296518326, -0.051793698221445084, -0.007405173499137163, 0.05711248144507408, 0.0008281850605271757, 0.0010437617311254144, -0.012874494306743145, -0.037876442074775696, 0.021028991788625717, 0.07912911474704742, 0.008785318583250046, -0.02310118079185486, -0.06335928291082382, -0.01300838589668274, -0.007104034069925547, 0.045824598520994186, 0.029084358364343643, -0.02512357197701931, 0.02340715005993843, -0.05771558731794357, 0.05429454892873764, -0.05126987025141716, -0.028609657660126686, 0.007345307152718306, 0.03536155819892883, 0.11674323678016663, -0.012929526157677174, -0.02608058787882328, -0.029133977368474007, 0.027342546731233597, -0.011375385336577892, -0.0012048418866470456, 0.01805945672094822, 0.028125427663326263, -0.018062062561511993, -0.02300557866692543, 0.004850767087191343, 0.04081285744905472, 0.004886569920927286, -0.04690013453364372, 0.00868831854313612, -0.020765742287039757, 0.04781448841094971, -0.08161484450101852, 0.0009773543570190668, -0.011586650274693966, -0.07041344791650772, -0.014776279218494892, -0.03550315648317337, -0.03402548283338547, 0.0037812520749866962, 0.023640399798750877, 0.004568962845951319, -0.09592718631029129, 0.024177011102437973, -0.006494126282632351, 0.06815695762634277, -0.000025501349227852188, 0.013137424364686012, 0.030882546678185463, -0.0168315302580595, -0.021083025261759758, 0.06135069951415062, -0.025589533150196075, 0.01510754507035017, -0.041446421295404434, -0.04809171333909035, 0.025413144379854202, -0.021832847967743874, 0.007299388758838177, 0.05139508843421936, -0.06436214596033096, -0.0031847632490098476, 0.0376100018620491, 0.034801602363586426, -0.0059796529822051525, 0.013626983389258385, -0.012034832499921322, -0.01803271844983101, 0.0017265176866203547, 0.023098841309547424, 0.04245707020163536, 0.001763422624208033, 0.05793013796210289, -0.050120435655117035, -0.01687130331993103, 0.017488425597548485, -0.010533593595027924, 0.0034985067322850227, -0.008417492732405663, -0.01619352027773857, -0.04207265377044678, -0.010469135828316212, 0.040077585726976395, -0.002467305399477482, -0.01089307852089405, 0.027975592762231827, 0.05131557956337929, 0.027482232078909874, -0.02438272163271904, -0.006586302071809769, -0.00813546683639288, 0.026332445442676544, 0.04256051406264305, -0.06877362728118896, 0.03321955353021622, -0.05450911074876785, 0.0021912355441600084, -0.02058028057217598, 0.0017715985886752605, -0.014970225282013416, -0.018365034833550453, -0.05055776610970497, -0.030099723488092422, -0.008976026438176632, -0.014577389694750309, 0.05647912621498108, -0.022446591407060623, -0.10460317879915237, 0.010398835875093937, -0.06567590683698654, 0.012303147464990616, 0.028817398473620415, 0.05716288834810257, -0.013279089704155922, -0.04610960930585861, -0.037022534757852554, 0.0018912918167188764, 0.010596022009849548, -0.04217340424656868, 0.01998089998960495, 0.051548462361097336, -0.011025279760360718, 0.025272971019148827, -0.020198505371809006, -0.07447125762701035, 0.005406510084867477, -0.03878102824091911, 0.002471811370924115, 0.00370140396989882, 0.04972381517291069, -0.039355192333459854, -0.08385813236236572, -0.005283300764858723, -0.016993004828691483, 0.08105334639549255, 0.012245851568877697, -0.03180757164955139, -0.0004963657120242715, -0.06956670433282852, -0.028970474377274513, 0.04693824425339699, -0.015189056284725666, 0.004860128741711378, 0.05320782959461212, 0.005694850347936153, -0.020507842302322388, 0.03533874452114105, -0.012197684496641159, -0.0463252030313015, -0.0231136716902256, -0.028523769229650497, 0.005372649058699608, 0.024133974686264992, 0.032762665301561356, -0.038078080862760544, 0.059827160090208054, -0.014676503837108612, -0.002960112178698182, 0.014635044150054455, 0.0664801374077797, 0.017348317429423332, -0.021696098148822784, 0.019901439547538757, 0.029037557542324066, -0.0062769940122962, -0.04378531500697136, 0.02937145344913006, -0.011567017063498497, -0.028349105268716812, 0.05362064391374588, 0.04683418571949005, -0.008366459980607033, 0.05764942616224289, -0.01642685942351818, 0.016623808071017265, 0.04366374388337135, -0.07180655002593994, 0.05153052136301994, 0.0569298192858696, 0.01925693266093731, 0.014107231982052326, 0.057357579469680786, -0.00018189649563282728, 0.0228724405169487, 0.012416290119290352, -0.06047386676073074, 0.03752797842025757, 0.018147561699151993, -0.014345460571348667, 0.012102276086807251, 0.07595731317996979, -0.02710949443280697, 0.0029651648364961147, 0.06485680490732193, 0.019983956590294838, -0.014229170978069305, -0.008292238228023052, 0.04219798743724823, -0.011854009702801704, 0.011413918808102608, 0.030161596834659576, 0.02714991755783558, -0.02330091781914234, -0.003621587995439768, -0.027271341532468796, 0.044745687395334244, 0.005902149714529514, 0.05678941681981087, 0.05523544177412987, 0.01790366880595684, 0.0003499762387946248, 0.04985814169049263, -0.021802673116326332, -0.014356241561472416, 0.04899071529507637, 0.001337509136646986, 0.08089952915906906, -0.005357355810701847, 0.023053906857967377, -0.028461067005991936, 0.032082799822092056, -0.00005889742897124961, 0.03153734654188156, -0.012099234387278557, 0.004800648894160986, -0.00805308111011982, -0.018799947574734688, -0.041624151170253754, -0.002807900309562683, -0.03725137934088707, 0.03511505573987961, -0.020678864791989326, -0.07250610738992691, 0.05009235814213753, 0.07095999270677567, 0.06944526731967926, -0.03144589439034462, -0.016341958194971085, 0.024180015549063683, 0.033739227801561356, 0.016570482403039932, -0.01663648709654808, -0.024190256372094154, -0.059799112379550934, 0.019223958253860474, 0.0018234706949442625, 0.031527791172266006, 0.07337485998868942, -0.019638685509562492, 0.029374822974205017, 0.032017916440963745, 0.06572514772415161, -0.005601466633379459, 0.05624829977750778, 0.017374154180288315, 0.00330749130807817, 0.06909352540969849, -0.0147646963596344, 0.020322881639003754, -0.009349053725600243, -0.017938556149601936, -0.008726891130208969, -0.014720248058438301, 0.00849808007478714, -0.024798624217510223, -0.033494509756565094, 0.057476483285427094, -0.020410774275660515, -0.02613416314125061, -0.05059010535478592, -0.00008893354242900386, -0.008662404492497444, 0.01127907820045948, -0.023956770077347755, 0.05907173454761505, 0.015936916694045067, -0.029503613710403442, -0.02111675962805748, 0.0724928081035614, -0.013194135390222073, 0.05570508912205696, 0.001809990033507347, 0.037690162658691406, -0.027022426947951317, -0.0681689977645874, 0.008638790808618069, -0.029370537027716637, -0.00185488595161587, 0.02393024042248726, 0.036042775958776474, 0.03200154006481171, 0.02133428305387497, 0.059552449733018875, 0.014074613340198994, 0.029342005029320717, -0.0017450167797505856, -0.017437726259231567, 0.00997228268533945, -0.017119789496064186, -0.0011059868847951293, 0.043435174971818924, 0.052984677255153656, -0.013312235474586487, -0.03030366264283657, 0.02956213429570198, 0.04730883613228798, -0.034116003662347794, -0.03444192185997963, -0.01008354127407074, -0.007216183003038168, 0.047071050852537155, 0.04814468324184418, -0.0005097228568047285, 0.019598163664340973, -0.022624634206295013, -0.049198467284440994, 0.029388219118118286, 0.0022386193741112947, -0.0041943565011024475, -0.0012245079269632697, -0.05850619077682495, -0.004980830475687981, -0.03471792861819267, -0.08344021439552307, -0.0534437820315361, -0.059137698262929916, -0.025432398542761803, -0.010325361043214798, -0.0022883673664182425, 0.02088405378162861, -0.012280266731977463, 0.02798411250114441, 0.013021747581660748, -0.05704959109425545, 0.043474651873111725, 0.02214924991130829, 0.02028597891330719, -0.01642649620771408, -0.021383142098784447, -0.02473706193268299, -0.010454889386892319, 0.030649740248918533, -0.0037191465962678194, -0.020735478028655052, 0.014054511673748493, 0.038370244204998016, 0.011990469880402088, -0.035760413855314255, -0.035274654626846313, 0.0034185615368187428, 0.03397460654377937, 0.04235950857400894, 0.02045164257287979, -0.005687483586370945, -0.029962187632918358, -0.015439401380717754, -0.021349379792809486, 0.026700563728809357, 0.01519515085965395, 0.021655375137925148, 0.05884665995836258, 0.020398616790771484, -0.027678262442350388, -0.005712554790079594, -0.005477288272231817, -0.0519140250980854, -0.011829798109829426, 0.05613436922430992, -0.06746125221252441, 0.003219983074814081, -0.024198487401008606, 0.011281142942607403, -0.01986948773264885, 0.016474174335598946, 0.008995571173727512, -0.012760519050061703, -0.0017978902906179428, 0.004780714865773916, -0.01722613535821438, -0.03719581663608551, -0.06478019803762436, -0.03018866665661335, -0.019986379891633987, 0.006006202194839716, 0.07467059791088104, -0.04449797421693802, 0.045489147305488586, 0.07058818638324738, 0.007486433256417513, -0.09506959468126297, 0.010448611341416836, -0.0333215706050396, 0.004304584581404924, -0.048271868377923965, -0.00981141161173582, 0.005842441692948341, -0.017746519297361374, -0.03931977227330208, -0.027986139059066772, -0.05802703648805618, 0.022841239348053932, -0.0059208436869084835, -0.027138561010360718, 0.03204449638724327, -0.02633700706064701, -0.010820511728525162, -0.005220254883170128, -0.05321972072124481, 0.03518380597233772, -0.012399103492498398, 0.020722292363643646, -0.016463743522763252, -0.0405319407582283, -0.05691344663500786, -0.009629745036363602 ]
<p>Two equal masses of mass M are glued to a massless hoop of radius R is free to rotate about its center in a vertical plane. The angle between the masses is 2$\theta$. Find the frequency of oscillations.</p> <p>My attempt at a solution is ($\phi$ is the displaced angle): $$x_{m1}=-R\sin (\theta -\phi)$$ $$y_{m1}=-R\cos(\theta-\phi)$$ $$x_{m2}=R\sin(\theta+\phi)$$ $$y_{m2}=-R\cos(\theta +\phi)$$</p> <p>I got my lagrangian and then found the Euler Lagrange equations in terms of $\phi$. I found that $$\ddot {\phi}=\frac{-g\cos(\theta)}{R}\sin\phi$$ So for small angles, $\sin(\phi)\approx\phi$ which means $\omega^2=\frac{g\cos(\theta)}{R}$</p> <p>Can anyone let me know if this makes sense. I think I did it correctly, but I am not completely sure. Thanks!</p> <p>EDIT:: Lagrangian: $$L=T-U=mR^2\dot{\phi}^2+2mg\cos(\theta)\cos(\phi)$$</p>
g4252
[ 0.06624922901391983, -0.020867621526122093, 0.0051216846331954, -0.04896732419729233, 0.026718785986304283, -0.005618110299110413, 0.08824731409549713, 0.01653408072888851, -0.03498483821749687, 0.04312470182776451, -0.015535272657871246, 0.07194878160953522, -0.017386747524142265, -0.007570302579551935, 0.02433464489877224, 0.026621032506227493, 0.028687121346592903, 0.04435880482196808, -0.03841719031333923, 0.01731043867766857, -0.012355941347777843, -0.03350389376282692, -0.022306270897388458, 0.02470618672668934, 0.07722997665405273, -0.03533802554011345, 0.04841092601418495, 0.025136673822999, -0.05301177129149437, 0.026489349082112312, -0.019983777776360512, 0.003960644360631704, 0.0714605525135994, -0.09844282269477844, 0.003164798952639103, 0.006166671868413687, -0.010857995599508286, -0.04956324025988579, 0.049021363258361816, -0.02517167292535305, -0.0009783897548913956, -0.03829224780201912, 0.04205881059169769, 0.016924133524298668, 0.046788863837718964, -0.008709927089512348, -0.008176666684448719, -0.010121981613337994, -0.00620241928845644, -0.01518100593239069, -0.006463706959038973, 0.028867989778518677, 0.047320690006017685, -0.0901598185300827, -0.08592792600393295, 0.039302289485931396, 0.06520597636699677, -0.02813991717994213, 0.024777932092547417, 0.0974157378077507, 0.05409848690032959, -0.06909899413585663, 0.0013327921042218804, -0.005150311626493931, 0.050359662622213364, -0.0251043438911438, 0.009189508855342865, 0.019115163013339043, 0.02958085760474205, -0.027240177616477013, -0.009469342418015003, -0.05318713188171387, 0.04159118980169296, -0.054976798593997955, -0.0645599290728569, 0.0011701994808390737, 0.045322779566049576, -0.003074884647503495, -0.02245461754500866, -0.04859848693013191, -0.06775837391614914, -0.00665289768949151, 0.02477182261645794, 0.04463152959942818, 0.06262141466140747, -0.04091649875044823, 0.0033874649088829756, 0.03612709417939186, -0.014116238802671432, 0.03574094921350479, 0.06941211223602295, -0.021118368953466415, 0.031010717153549194, 0.0073608397506177425, 0.022939661517739296, 0.004804802592843771, -0.02899176813662052, 0.06263580918312073, -0.03504926338791847, 0.014245276339352131, 0.001742818858474493, -0.048219308257102966, 0.005493827164173126, 0.003692111698910594, 0.011397670954465866, 0.002832593396306038, 0.05088748037815094, 0.008354876190423965, 0.021109983325004578, 0.020202165469527245, -0.0017038356745615602, -0.019678033888339996, -0.011983925476670265, -0.04587637260556221, -0.03481399640440941, -0.053887490183115005, 0.04567286744713783, -0.0009369296603836119, 0.018985528498888016, 0.05423787236213684, 0.021699046716094017, -0.04427497088909149, -0.02249826304614544, 0.12175785005092621, 0.035244379192590714, 0.0027974150143563747, -0.00732504902407527, -0.04163021221756935, 0.04721592739224434, -0.009703324176371098, -0.07298386842012405, -0.012975377030670643, 0.04515165463089943, 0.030878549441695213, -0.008563128300011158, 0.05487958714365959, -0.04160696640610695, -0.01015532948076725, 0.0014737227465957403, -0.015727361664175987, -0.007774106226861477, -0.00008383447129745036, 0.036559101194143295, -0.03050164319574833, -0.08654782921075821, 0.06830849498510361, -0.013326304964721203, -0.05441082641482353, 0.014883961528539658, 0.06040081009268761, -0.002494682790711522, 0.03546728938817978, -0.030903687700629234, 0.012549816630780697, 0.0027767030987888575, -0.038402657955884933, -0.0304451622068882, -0.002128377091139555, -0.005305412225425243, 0.01673239655792713, -0.0012754198396578431, -0.045308440923690796, 0.07589256018400192, 0.016600459814071655, -0.023785436525940895, 0.060737527906894684, -0.032033830881118774, -0.03265923634171486, -0.01539459265768528, -0.0378706231713295, -0.05484774336218834, -0.03332243114709854, -0.0020093382336199284, 0.05342382565140724, -0.0333731509745121, 0.07155896723270416, 0.0022717989049851894, -0.044868454337120056, 0.03628214821219444, 0.09095741808414459, 0.019308464601635933, -0.030249733477830887, 0.002821039641276002, -0.008767999708652496, -0.006940803956240416, -0.029482565820217133, 0.07823894172906876, 0.028250280767679214, 0.003615008667111397, 0.01577296480536461, 0.0018755862256512046, 0.024973509833216667, -0.0659698024392128, 0.0037987197283655405, 0.012243097648024559, 0.07126232981681824, 0.02813996933400631, -0.027908457443118095, -0.003205087035894394, 0.0641893818974495, -0.007973883301019669, -0.022516312077641487, 0.07039491087198257, -0.03274478763341904, -0.00828047189861536, -0.010826360434293747, 0.05953816697001457, -0.03663918003439903, 0.008428486064076424, 0.04567296430468559, -0.030305897817015648, -0.014865592122077942, -0.026987208053469658, 0.02517208456993103, -0.02069193311035633, -0.02044997550547123, 0.04304872453212738, 0.02468251809477806, -0.021737372502684593, -0.00829386431723833, -0.010862036608159542, 0.009354406036436558, 0.048918724060058594, -0.031554002314805984, 0.06288046389818192, -0.04195336997509003, -0.03395676985383034, -0.024036545306444168, -0.026575611904263496, -0.00776399252936244, -0.01437024399638176, 0.0006952812545932829, 0.04817011579871178, 0.008891087025403976, -0.005871864035725594, -0.0026606209576129913, -0.00946448277682066, 0.02794346772134304, 0.03781194984912872, 0.027349472045898438, 0.0713343396782875, 0.007133130915462971, -0.034904785454273224, -0.05560438334941864, 0.03784077614545822, 0.0014088914031162858, 0.028521407395601273, 0.019914137199521065, 0.037648770958185196, 0.008281080983579159, -0.005441170185804367, 0.0011703899363055825, -0.06072314456105232, -0.02122822031378746, -0.0153838861733675, 0.0033489640336483717, -0.00010739126446424052, -0.02314906381070614, -0.012040140107274055, -0.002309279516339302, -0.04208988696336746, -0.052577320486307144, -0.04436158388853073, 0.01501754205673933, -0.04168228060007095, -0.005540117621421814, -0.03151153400540352, -0.009463341906666756, 0.06044774875044823, -0.03289497271180153, -0.018595632165670395, 0.035571616142988205, 0.01951906457543373, 0.08765774220228195, 0.0238814577460289, -0.029775915667414665, 0.020824210718274117, -0.027621185407042503, -0.031027257442474365, 0.012872536666691303, 0.04563793167471886, -0.004302805755287409, -0.02924487739801407, 0.014626240357756615, -0.014304724521934986, -0.0019108057022094727, -0.09778010845184326, 0.042319223284721375, 0.026327697560191154, 0.05362528935074806, 0.005003626924008131, 0.05804222449660301, 0.06284812092781067, -0.020713642239570618, -0.02177467942237854, 0.09300497174263, 0.028499320149421692, 0.006036730483174324, -0.00047619573888368905, 0.04236451908946037, 0.008556692861020565, 0.035362984985113144, 0.015333459712564945, -0.004297228530049324, -0.03986714035272598, -0.014866525307297707, 0.04390629380941391, -0.027142807841300964, 0.01858668029308319, -0.015888256952166557, 0.0208301804959774, -0.0032738603185862303, 0.05355974659323692, -0.026081230491399765, -0.06130153685808182, 0.025632541626691818, 0.02378058061003685, -0.05006144195795059, -0.008377262391149998, 0.039242133498191833, -0.1111280545592308, -0.01234692707657814, 0.03019210323691368, 0.03268563002347946, -0.0020664939656853676, -0.010795500129461288, -0.01597985439002514, 0.018577586859464645, -0.028207706287503242, -0.04154215008020401, -0.0076796067878603935, -0.022218121215701103, 0.016895199194550514, -0.0665307343006134, 0.0045995814725756645, -0.039383888244628906, 0.01771056093275547, -0.009260822087526321, 0.028587982058525085, 0.03347514942288399, -0.10729660838842392, 0.020078714936971664, -0.05801880732178688, -0.0031510733533650637, 0.0028034853748977184, -0.054806917905807495, -0.07212062180042267, -0.0008551669307053089, 0.047802817076444626, -0.030381346121430397, 0.002921606646850705, -0.009589914232492447, -0.008117565885186195, 0.013479790650308132, 0.025053169578313828, 0.018856927752494812, 0.039535995572805405, 0.000410925509640947, -0.019026970490813255, 0.0004177578666713089, -0.01081719622015953, -0.03253737464547157, -0.033977754414081573, 0.028981098905205727, 0.0034807128831744194, -0.026898151263594627, -0.03761202469468117, 0.054201263934373856, -0.023326732218265533, -0.0012885539326816797, -0.03611655905842781, -0.053297776728868484, 0.02708972804248333, -0.005542268976569176, -0.014031674712896347, -0.04399777203798294, -0.013529356569051743, -0.04643838852643967, -0.04699695110321045, 0.04689844697713852, -0.015801960602402687, -0.07163646072149277, -0.004135878756642342, 0.005936142057180405, 0.030470222234725952, 0.03796352073550224, 0.01087829191237688, 0.06047448515892029, 0.005451321601867676, -0.015785550698637962, 0.012736455537378788, -0.018871162086725235, 0.025150993838906288, -0.0034132760483771563, 0.03490987420082092, -0.057239264249801636, 0.009937799535691738, 0.018821299076080322, -0.05731802061200142, -0.00779188284650445, 0.026866905391216278, 0.010278209112584591, -0.006960744969546795, -0.026439936831593513, -0.026318758726119995, 0.05830742046236992, 0.022139228880405426, 0.015206866897642612, 0.02269182913005352, 0.0076990085653960705, -0.005542338360100985, -0.03314786031842232, 0.042048271745443344, -0.027497895061969757, 0.05708877742290497, 0.046005502343177795, 0.015484361909329891, -0.004699987359344959, -0.031329523772001266, 0.005739734508097172, -0.06760413199663162, 0.059058792889118195, 0.00654058251529932, -0.009900329634547234, 0.01750193163752556, 0.022352300584316254, 0.0224877018481493, 0.03802390769124031, -0.002360738581046462, -0.04099920019507408, -0.014761535450816154, -0.04275856912136078, 0.0015097629511728883, -0.03458850085735321, -0.0330241434276104, 0.010117020457983017, -0.057023316621780396, -0.025394728407263756, -0.021088002249598503, 0.05752536654472351, 0.03635125979781151, -0.006971769500523806, -0.014256756752729416, -0.015843961387872696, 0.013744428753852844, 0.011681593023240566, 0.06555691361427307, -0.02410600334405899, 0.03700249642133713, -0.038423459976911545, 0.02799043245613575, -0.0328565277159214, 0.05195211246609688, 0.025213491171598434, 0.0098643833771348, -0.015000485815107822, -0.019815227016806602, 0.003518692683428526, -0.021974345669150352, 0.004255840089172125, 0.008859863504767418, -0.043703291565179825, 0.019482329487800598, -0.06264156103134155, 0.08561424165964127, 0.0184713676571846, -0.05517242103815079, -0.015282636508345604, -0.023319203406572342, -0.051869846880435944, 0.006307320203632116, 0.020309975370764732, 0.0009726101998239756, -0.0011073800269514322, -0.029134465381503105, -0.0025684162974357605, -0.022480014711618423, -0.015515631064772606, 0.020929254591464996, -0.042152054607868195, -0.02809104695916176, -0.004286651965230703, -0.0041693877428770065, -0.00890433881431818, -0.015891078859567642, -0.026535142213106155, 0.023101596161723137, -0.011278722435235977, 0.03079584427177906, -0.03954029455780983, 0.016126278787851334, -0.0032896006014198065, -0.043696433305740356, 0.028178155422210693, 0.02163063734769821, 0.024410458281636238, 0.0008221041061915457, -0.014955444261431694, -0.0017257750732824206, 0.024312660098075867, 0.0005862658726982772, 0.03221811726689339, 0.02190358377993107, 0.04511558264493942, -0.011646567843854427, -0.008833919651806355, 0.005605352111160755, 0.007869494147598743, -0.005484039895236492, 0.058736901730298996, -0.04210365563631058, -0.014737199991941452, 0.03292407840490341, 0.03937176242470741, -0.02157505601644516, -0.05559192970395088, 0.036024488508701324, 0.03331616520881653, 0.01843295805156231, 0.013769793324172497, 0.025792932137846947, -0.00007836151053197682, 0.013213093392550945, -0.03652852401137352, -0.007808956783264875, -0.0005402536480687559, -0.021147742867469788, 0.0361936092376709, -0.04676820710301399, -0.013278131373226643, -0.04270900413393974, -0.05479399859905243, 0.01734565943479538, -0.015870070084929466, 0.04948892071843147, -0.049440570175647736, -0.034959252923727036, -0.04698668047785759, -0.00844449270516634, -0.06506999582052231, -0.02018517255783081, -0.05882317200303078, 0.040929026901721954, 0.0037888057995587587, -0.04117878898978233, 0.06526650488376617, -0.014943527989089489, -0.0310460664331913, 0.0022196650970727205, 0.02404896728694439, -0.07294124364852905, 0.03570333495736122, 0.014768842607736588, 0.027509599924087524, -0.03729185834527016, 0.013231191784143448, -0.02040581777691841, -0.009680020622909069, -0.00915133859962225, 0.041453856974840164, 0.02834010310471058, -0.025172041729092598, 0.03447384759783745, 0.06214771047234535, 0.016382282599806786, 0.01045332383364439, 0.05265074223279953, -0.002283143810927868, 0.013111147098243237, -0.00039373437175527215, -0.06979964673519135, 0.013171801343560219, -0.028302952647209167, 0.052277956157922745, 0.07202830165624619, 0.07356081902980804, -0.048116281628608704, -0.08582745492458344, -0.015656249597668648, 0.01389359775930643, 0.001838610740378499, 0.02791888453066349, -0.011467797681689262, -0.022837551310658455, 0.008412995375692844, 0.00606292812153697, -0.003790491260588169, -0.0499308779835701, 0.021276289597153664, -0.02957736887037754, 0.031762782484292984, 0.01248178631067276, -0.10225486755371094, 0.047070298343896866, -0.03348128870129585, 0.011266538873314857, 0.03063691407442093, 0.009017624892294407, -0.0161068644374609, 0.0031548538245260715, 0.09205956757068634, 0.04242325946688652, 0.06818345934152603, 0.0071176569908857346, 0.01730201579630375, -0.03342127054929733, -0.05735049024224281, 0.02777285687625408, -0.042586151510477066, 0.007673004176467657, -0.011118157766759396, 0.023879194632172585, 0.05171281099319458, -0.006902968976646662, -0.03265984356403351, -0.017842872068285942, 0.019291242584586143, 0.04095281660556793, -0.04090157523751259, -0.045630525797605515, 0.02059517800807953, 0.016072623431682587, -0.05671510845422745, -0.03344030678272247, -0.003247710643336177, -0.028069861233234406, 0.0028819688595831394, -0.030280474573373795, -0.006240440532565117, -0.02153705060482025, 0.07537811994552612, -0.01114598847925663, -0.019849669188261032, -0.03147783875465393, 0.02859726920723915, 0.11029279232025146, -0.03187045827507973, 0.05123577639460564, 0.030678048729896545, 0.027876194566488266, 0.017713993787765503, 0.06380514055490494, 0.01458678487688303, -0.005298077128827572, -0.002741179196164012, 0.019375817850232124, 0.03127794712781906, 0.023447677493095398, -0.0474531464278698, -0.030677711591124535, 0.005086800549179316, -0.03187119588255882, -0.031034665182232857, 0.02861674875020981, -0.04948558658361435, -0.01772037334740162, 0.002619515871629119, 0.02346610277891159, 0.03819402679800987, -0.019722843542695045, -0.09057687968015671, -0.010524095967411995, 0.03240104019641876, -0.002344065345823765, 0.00799505040049553, 0.02151492051780224, 0.006464899517595768, 0.010965841822326183, 0.013274842873215675, -0.011113280430436134, 0.011999541893601418, -0.02971506118774414, -0.05904878303408623, -0.012518547475337982, -0.036582957953214645, 0.010370966047048569, 0.024784140288829803, 0.02656235545873642, -0.05119917541742325, 0.025357315316796303, 0.010824405588209629, -0.06138184294104576, -0.014303169213235378, 0.047894857823848724, -0.013213071040809155, -0.007337428629398346, -0.0031046406365931034, -0.011619361117482185, -0.004767374135553837, 0.05632832273840904, -0.005547514650970697, 0.056269917637109756, 0.0018885066965594888, 0.026776563376188278, -0.01133771426975727, -0.03451351076364517, -0.003764581633731723, 0.025693612173199654, 0.00611908221617341, 0.019923031330108643, -0.0027926606126129627, -0.022664466872811317, 0.004225574899464846, 0.012170631438493729, -0.003938071895390749, 0.04883785918354988, -0.0263681523501873, -0.020809011533856392, -0.0017755160806700587, 0.003554962109774351, 0.06461837887763977, 0.016542738303542137, -0.019948124885559082, -0.019275249913334846, 0.06703463196754456, 0.007325002923607826, -0.06059234216809273, 0.06700063496828079, -0.03548740968108177, -0.0510326623916626, -0.10247596353292465, -0.03674846142530441, -0.01390310563147068, -0.12804625928401947, -0.0061929007060825825, -0.03063749335706234, -0.0168228130787611, 0.015006206929683685, -0.027384605258703232, -0.034765321761369705, -0.003448926145210862, -0.012892230413854122, -0.004926025867462158, 0.012012491934001446, -0.019199661910533905, -0.013691120781004429, -0.024699730798602104, -0.024783475324511528, -0.004704218823462725, 0.04453612491488457, -0.005355898756533861, -0.04681424796581268, -0.029757998883724213, -0.008403241634368896, 0.008883865550160408, 0.06625381112098694, -0.0171763114631176, -0.017409879714250565, 0.040341611951589584, -0.03984709084033966, 0.010649786330759525, 0.060841456055641174, -0.04402148723602295, 0.026739824563264847, 0.04765849933028221, -0.06246263533830643, 0.014236615970730782, -0.030010253190994263, 0.02791343815624714, -0.015895318239927292, -0.03799207881093025, -0.004217857029289007, -0.02955431304872036, -0.0012977687874808908, 0.031458206474781036, -0.07717559486627579, 0.030349697917699814, 0.03689413145184517 ]
<p>Everybody has been taught at one point, "oh the universe expands, but that doesn't mean that everything is expanding uniformly, since that means we can't detect the expansion, but only that huge galaxies are moving away from each other".</p> <p>But I'm rather confused. Can't the expanding universe simply be thought as a coordinate axis that expands? The definition of "1" on the coordinate axis constantly expands? After all, spacetime itself is expanding, and not only "average distance of galaxies".</p> <p>So our Planck length would expand, light wavelengths expand, we expand, etc. But clearly this isn't happening. Of course, the handwavy explanation is "electromagnetism/gravity overcomes expansion at small scales", but the electromagnetic and gravity forces are defined in terms of constants relative to our "coordinate intervals", so if spacetime itself is expanding "under the feet" of gravity, shouldn't gravity not be able to do anything about it?</p> <p>We would also be unable to measure the expansion of spacetime since all of our measurement benchmarks and tools are also expanding.</p> <p>Clearly, this isn't happening. What is the <em>precise</em> reason?</p>
g56
[ 0.03907543793320656, 0.0491972416639328, 0.012157021090388298, -0.006930097937583923, -0.0016977390041574836, 0.04630019888281822, 0.00752200186252594, -0.002154733520001173, -0.018397310748696327, -0.059049949049949646, 0.06433609873056412, -0.02130836620926857, -0.004789603408426046, 0.03571927547454834, 0.013647926039993763, -0.00577848544344306, -0.005537701770663261, -0.03419989347457886, 0.029047084972262383, 0.007838201709091663, 0.006584578659385443, -0.005488271825015545, 0.03450746834278107, -0.03569437935948372, -0.07950198650360107, -0.009406100027263165, 0.03946685418486595, -0.0377303846180439, 0.0005682012997567654, -0.020613782107830048, 0.020909948274493217, 0.02941068448126316, 0.02723018266260624, 0.01568411849439144, 0.036418817937374115, 0.009909222833812237, -0.01902468502521515, -0.024112066254019737, 0.04131513088941574, -0.009787926450371742, -0.05151674151420593, 0.023120541125535965, 0.028039749711751938, -0.0035625346936285496, 0.027911538258194923, -0.013897486962378025, -0.060716912150382996, -0.005264716222882271, 0.08200477808713913, -0.06797335296869278, -0.053526684641838074, -0.020160358399152756, 0.031217258423566818, 0.09457391500473022, 0.06549935042858124, 0.0517718605697155, 0.012621055357158184, 0.016163522377610207, 0.06795018166303635, 0.01289286371320486, -0.003550227964296937, -0.003276909701526165, 0.06095196679234505, 0.03525238856673241, -0.008884996175765991, 0.023053009063005447, -0.06317862123250961, -0.05845331773161888, 0.0025004560593515635, 0.004631739109754562, -0.0014807248953729868, -0.11458174139261246, -0.03464560955762863, -0.04159124940633774, -0.06606823951005936, 0.05731187015771866, 0.04207471013069153, -0.004517185036092997, 0.009749388322234154, -0.04070277884602547, -0.023300252854824066, 0.01502524595707655, -0.006963429506868124, 0.0515243224799633, 0.031999778002500534, -0.027031827718019485, -0.03795387223362923, 0.00993264839053154, 0.005368105601519346, 0.04350484162569046, 0.01444218773394823, 0.005937950685620308, 0.08380310237407684, 0.025137463584542274, -0.02275584451854229, -0.077595554292202, 0.021529052406549454, 0.0605894960463047, -0.020736755803227425, -0.004644279833883047, -0.03544919192790985, 0.03298480808734894, -0.024349471554160118, -0.005137370899319649, 0.0318286269903183, -0.0035454565659165382, -0.03640088438987732, 0.03571955859661102, 0.04318367317318916, -0.05225878581404686, -0.01630222611129284, -0.0017762918723747134, -0.03302725777029991, -0.03924468532204628, -0.053658969700336456, -0.011801088228821754, 0.039342522621154785, 0.0827348381280899, 0.04021280258893967, 0.02183367870748043, 0.003616082016378641, 0.022090476006269455, 0.017269490286707878, 0.026342002674937248, -0.03258521854877472, -0.030504461377859116, 0.006663380190730095, 0.008628456853330135, -0.03381820023059845, -0.0480128712952137, 0.038447506725788116, 0.03207171708345413, -0.040165483951568604, 0.0457744263112545, 0.03583356365561485, -0.01814202405512333, 0.005114054307341576, -0.025907162576913834, -0.014757622964680195, 0.053543638437986374, -0.043857552111148834, -0.03548472002148628, 0.037962935864925385, -0.059719379991292953, 0.0015663162339478731, 0.0185957383364439, 0.0032614634837955236, 0.0010808904189616442, 0.03406492993235588, -0.007335257716476917, -0.008655550889670849, 0.13781146705150604, -0.02164221927523613, -0.07288247346878052, -0.031917113810777664, 0.02933482453227043, 0.02649805136024952, -0.009781068190932274, -0.017080841585993767, 0.04739527776837349, 0.040529053658246994, -0.009403918869793415, -0.030155763030052185, 0.008968723937869072, -0.009252036921679974, 0.06768275797367096, -0.03358880802989006, -0.059168972074985504, -0.021545976400375366, -0.023429952561855316, -0.06487427651882172, -0.03499238193035126, 0.00329161761328578, 0.03824247419834137, -0.041611697524785995, 0.09708110988140106, 0.04814169928431511, 0.012337857857346535, -0.04737077280879021, 0.011985559947788715, -0.04476477578282356, -0.04711972177028656, 0.00700213061645627, -0.04687018692493439, -0.06857055425643921, -0.014099244959652424, -0.01646031066775322, 0.0005010151653550565, 0.008206464350223541, -0.015241330489516258, 0.0275168027728796, -0.01812933012843132, 0.018930334597826004, 0.05913326516747475, 0.010210965760052204, -0.004269360564649105, -0.004615120589733124, -0.009739241562783718, -0.04491666331887245, -0.005675234366208315, -0.04779123142361641, 0.044754017144441605, 0.02326318994164467, 0.028245551511645317, 0.04566369950771332, -0.025222020223736763, -0.06691965460777283, -0.007164714392274618, 0.06648577749729156, 0.004543686285614967, 0.04127221554517746, -0.05546236038208008, 0.03850989043712616, 0.021261420100927353, 0.0053860582411289215, -0.01976979523897171, -0.026746299117803574, 0.005367347504943609, -0.0059180245734751225, 0.030789373442530632, 0.0033922118600457907, 0.015021978877484798, -0.00030649174004793167, -0.03295906260609627, -0.01189754530787468, -0.04671105369925499, -0.042882755398750305, -0.057073596864938736, 0.011945275589823723, 0.0006846135365776718, -0.07362701743841171, 0.009946700185537338, 0.009383396245539188, 0.01026841625571251, -0.016966966912150383, 0.028990929946303368, -0.019405879080295563, 0.017000004649162292, -0.031007707118988037, 0.031030986458063126, 0.0205730851739645, -0.05250665545463562, 0.04410873353481293, -0.009381153620779514, 0.05451725423336029, -0.1048298105597496, 0.045968394726514816, -0.05808059498667717, -0.05395655333995819, -0.0011561933206394315, 0.03951151669025421, -0.019370630383491516, -0.012515795417129993, -0.014010030776262283, -0.01842460036277771, -0.025907328352332115, -0.0038196153473109007, 0.07691679894924164, -0.09971264749765396, -0.058569375425577164, -0.032043568789958954, -0.022766895592212677, 0.06161969155073166, 0.048134129494428635, -0.007608070038259029, -0.0299791619181633, -0.04526131600141525, 0.03976356238126755, -0.02015226148068905, -0.044288720935583115, -0.05251573398709297, 0.007358690723776817, -0.0335412360727787, -0.0019686950836330652, -0.0422903448343277, 0.03232007846236229, 0.045063719153404236, 0.0003474239492788911, 0.06635351479053497, 0.0001761501480359584, -0.05189010873436928, -0.0036912099458277225, -0.05159459635615349, -0.013013537041842937, 0.029175983741879463, -0.053811103105545044, 0.003348559606820345, -0.05935369059443474, -0.029080264270305634, -0.028406789526343346, 0.033433519303798676, 0.03173113241791725, -0.004255190491676331, -0.007746558170765638, -0.03158554062247276, 0.014186068437993526, -0.03703610971570015, -0.028511356562376022, -0.00720442458987236, 0.02722468413412571, -0.0023716066498309374, -0.009258510544896126, 0.0679161325097084, -0.03453624248504639, 0.010733334347605705, 0.0541485957801342, 0.013501639477908611, -0.03877416253089905, -0.004234424326568842, 0.006310069467872381, 0.0036651063710451126, 0.04517480358481407, 0.0014738219324499369, 0.043606948107481, -0.017330249771475792, 0.011870501562952995, 0.036034516990184784, -0.0001891642459668219, 0.020530102774500847, 0.019116748124361038, 0.032014816999435425, -0.031219065189361572, -0.06914473325014114, -0.034157223999500275, 0.032863158732652664, -0.022454166784882545, -0.010947511531412601, -0.008183833211660385, -0.06261423975229263, 0.027615970000624657, 0.003243211191147566, -0.03432244434952736, 0.028720742091536522, 0.018658775836229324, -0.033316317945718765, -0.02130497433245182, -0.00863997545093298, -0.017021559178829193, 0.05032366141676903, -0.008480178192257881, -0.04330013692378998, 0.002375116338953376, -0.05672366917133331, 0.013203262351453304, -0.0024544664192944765, 0.055747125297784805, -0.004278175532817841, -0.03168792650103569, 0.03385067731142044, -0.014769450761377811, 0.05192586034536362, 0.03433406352996826, 0.022947682067751884, -0.019437598064541817, -0.014470205642282963, 0.002136415569111705, 0.0048484159633517265, 0.015309031121432781, -0.01400279626250267, -0.028975749388337135, 0.0516195185482502, 0.02810010500252247, -0.013101021759212017, 0.007633175700902939, -0.010887788608670235, 0.004403107799589634, 0.06915948539972305, 0.052528731524944305, -0.013801777735352516, 0.015112056396901608, 0.04121839627623558, -0.004020932596176863, -0.01947512850165367, 0.012845738790929317, 0.06023925542831421, -0.023193370550870895, 0.03186623752117157, -0.0041797952726483345, 0.03478606790304184, 0.01082831621170044, 0.05592266842722893, 0.02819124050438404, -0.0013807843206450343, 0.0013315086252987385, -0.015918470919132233, -0.002013198798522353, -0.07498981803655624, -0.01950131170451641, 0.0031625947449356318, -0.029453029856085777, 0.06528525799512863, -0.04710265249013901, 0.020249249413609505, 0.009453737176954746, 0.014369606971740723, -0.09162266552448273, 0.0012647724943235517, -0.021952198818325996, 0.04268968850374222, -0.001237794291228056, 0.062033530324697495, 0.026620974764227867, -0.015015150420367718, 0.020345401018857956, -0.03795986250042915, 0.008936366066336632, 0.062422264367341995, 0.004622729495167732, 0.0196426622569561, -0.031152069568634033, 0.03920460864901543, 0.06260012090206146, -0.0015155912842601538, -0.07425796240568161, 0.07879932969808578, 0.00532888900488615, 0.018345247954130173, -0.0862448439002037, 0.009728049859404564, 0.006674541626125574, -0.003024762263521552, 0.042552798986434937, 0.012243724428117275, -0.0054894802160561085, -0.04027924686670303, 0.07219531387090683, -0.018409011885523796, -0.004667228553444147, 0.01645130105316639, -0.03406340628862381, 0.006147349718958139, 0.019943971186876297, 0.046000588685274124, 0.04780038073658943, -0.03277520835399628, 0.011366410180926323, 0.005243382416665554, 0.13282737135887146, -0.024542460218071938, 0.03126300498843193, 0.0787869468331337, 0.018329691141843796, -0.007617607247084379, 0.049780845642089844, 0.004194832406938076, 0.016562335193157196, -0.04840517416596413, -0.013492852449417114, -0.014440931379795074, 0.013848992995917797, -0.06569549441337585, 0.03391054645180702, 0.06347109377384186, -0.0017782055074349046, -0.00431008730083704, -0.02904052659869194, -0.019115421921014786, 0.0067540789023041725, 0.05840245261788368, 0.05509533733129501, -0.06410816311836243, 0.04645412415266037, -0.005566454492509365, 0.06310614943504333, 0.00933938380330801, 0.027957914397120476, -0.05316043272614479, -0.06001131981611252, -0.0334327407181263, 0.06904314458370209, -0.007235316094011068, 0.001205650856718421, 0.008671280927956104, 0.009615492075681686, 0.01623169705271721, 0.06339678168296814, 0.0018236080650240183, -0.01052231714129448, -0.052829086780548096, -0.06367214769124985, -0.03895063325762749, -0.050855495035648346, 0.05373591184616089, 0.01519740279763937, -0.009920503944158554, 0.06376447528600693, 0.025744333863258362, 0.0352601632475853, 0.0029719762969762087, -0.0069605205208063126, 0.023265451192855835, -0.040655817836523056, 0.022545672953128815, 0.0003107586526311934, -0.021082252264022827, -0.014018150046467781, -0.024612829089164734, -0.02854505553841591, 0.011840691789984703, -0.06146051734685898, -0.0076251220889389515, 0.036329735070466995, -0.05697324499487877, -0.004413201939314604, -0.013368763029575348, 0.009074840694665909, 0.00225277291610837, -0.01369897834956646, -0.026392068713903427, 0.03516977280378342, -0.0034258156083524227, 0.025547105818986893, -0.000531890953425318, -0.008287681266665459, 0.0608355849981308, -0.06828951090574265, 0.010748016647994518, -0.02528049796819687, -0.015560264699161053, -0.020541807636618614, -0.008725658059120178, 0.026680052280426025, 0.06017524003982544, -0.05857078731060028, 0.07545994967222214, 0.030939405784010887, -0.004767055157572031, -0.006343274377286434, 0.013669594191014767, 0.028020890429615974, 0.035809293389320374, 0.025266727432608604, 0.007308105006814003, -0.04623212665319443, 0.008141770027577877, 0.042726822197437286, 0.03081553615629673, -0.027546485885977745, 0.04327630251646042, -0.029137086123228073, -0.009805398061871529, 0.01955012045800686, -0.06296341121196747, 0.03197862580418587, -0.011260447092354298, 0.020358886569738388, -0.012447289191186428, 0.031229469925165176, 0.0692364051938057, -0.043058089911937714, -0.025814054533839226, 0.011613736860454082, -0.033317528665065765, -0.025020355358719826, -0.06636063754558563, 0.051936350762844086, 0.014461626298725605, -0.012739267200231552, -0.05037261173129082, -0.06864739954471588, 0.009886695072054863, -0.02757953852415085, -0.010852910578250885, -0.04134649783372879, -0.011028043925762177, -0.04390903562307358, -0.003819486126303673, -0.049248769879341125, 0.04267098382115364, 0.06289885193109512, -0.04825413227081299, 0.020666155964136124, 0.029649676755070686, -0.01189632061868906, 0.029993947595357895, 0.03875498101115227, -0.001361920265480876, 0.015949014574289322, -0.03264385089278221, -0.0027093898970633745, 0.014306838624179363, -0.027577390894293785, 0.014058890752494335, -0.038714662194252014, -0.01933838427066803, 0.0077652959153056145, -0.04552963376045227, 0.028308730572462082, 0.060198549181222916, -0.02520977519452572, 0.019225288182497025, 0.009444731287658215, 0.018797732889652252, -0.0402594730257988, -0.048433318734169006, -0.08146975189447403, -0.01893145963549614, 0.001856513787060976, -0.0075490656308829784, 0.013780560344457626, 0.02294454351067543, 0.025654835626482964, 0.04651232063770294, -0.007983239367604256, 0.0033990037627518177, -0.02430502325296402, -0.049683213233947754, -0.001468584523536265, 0.06408853828907013, -0.004793010652065277, -0.00033898139372467995, 0.04149695485830307, 0.008516501635313034, 0.040783125907182693, 0.025520386174321175, -0.07820238173007965, 0.04000004008412361, -0.021301191300153732, 0.014590776525437832, 0.0034821643494069576, 0.011857517063617706, -0.025412101298570633, 0.02718493342399597, 0.04083780199289322, 0.013833504170179367, -0.007240008562803268, -0.002963036298751831, -0.032494720071554184, 0.021705416962504387, -0.043160855770111084, -0.006111327558755875, 0.05088895931839943, -0.03981110826134682, 0.04180334880948067, 0.0050301929004490376, 0.03301813453435898, -0.02690035291016102, -0.030619977042078972, -0.00002445514837745577, 0.012723122723400593, 0.00631809514015913, -0.02378402091562748, 0.05959980562329292, -0.005936340428888798, -0.056995928287506104, 0.016982218250632286, -0.036852315068244934, 0.002725019119679928, -0.047680873423814774, 0.057257525622844696, -0.020362714305520058, -0.05187473073601723, -0.05506667122244835, 0.03604953736066818, -0.01313236728310585, -0.009960070252418518, -0.020462213084101677, -0.06262779235839844, -0.06056448817253113, -0.03377418965101242, -0.020760532468557358, -0.005270771682262421, -0.014841282740235329, 0.023563392460346222, -0.053644243627786636, 0.020127683877944946, 0.022513380274176598, 0.007328582927584648, 0.058614347130060196, -0.025997472926974297, 0.007112761493772268, 0.01749238558113575, 0.02407333441078663, 0.03398339822888374, 0.04448312520980835, -0.022403573617339134, -0.08020131289958954, -0.017052164301276207, 0.040085166692733765, -0.008450450375676155, -0.020655862987041473, 0.02658608742058277, 0.02201564982533455, 0.051217563450336456, -0.021811354905366898, 0.02014498971402645, -0.030617274343967438, -0.016157593578100204, -0.004644987639039755, -0.016801176592707634, 0.02466551586985588, -0.011610589921474457, -0.06047780439257622, 0.03667883574962616, 0.011746315285563469, 0.03965167701244354, 0.02794293686747551, 0.039839968085289, -0.03357626870274544, -0.03631372004747391, -0.02850331738591194, -0.07676958292722702, -0.03541291132569313, 0.01745128445327282, 0.03819902613759041, 0.027932997792959213, 0.020412549376487732, 0.04441772401332855, -0.0048844581469893456, -0.04112405329942703, -0.0062546455301344395, 0.011289582587778568, -0.006294562481343746, -0.02321581169962883, -0.0459328331053257, 0.017800945788621902, 0.03558318689465523, -0.04701162502169609, 0.013651290908455849, -0.08645425736904144, -0.015794241800904274, -0.011525548063218594, 0.007255614269524813, -0.05450749397277832, -0.00557295884937048, 0.01239288505166769, 0.01788352243602276, -0.030743854120373726, 0.0037681974936276674, -0.026830874383449554, -0.02403831295669079, -0.021414242684841156, -0.01906462572515011, -0.001845056307502091, -0.02065250650048256, 0.04406066983938217, 0.006589300464838743, -0.004196568392217159, -0.055765267461538315, 0.004337011836469173, -0.02333795465528965, -0.03695930913090706, -0.033212363719940186, 0.008271603845059872, 0.008081409148871899, -0.029125940054655075, -0.018586747348308563, 0.05338235944509506, 0.04636659473180771, 0.02562655508518219, -0.04552615061402321, 0.03900777921080589, -0.004822771530598402, 0.057299308478832245, 0.051873303949832916, -0.019406622275710106, -0.015609720721840858, -0.018120987340807915, -0.008219976909458637, -0.007397775538265705, 0.018273934721946716, 0.030424656346440315, 0.026495007798075676, -0.025638137012720108, -0.015481571666896343, -0.04129144176840782, -0.04331154376268387, 0.05537229776382446 ]
<p>This is related to this question:<a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/88826/does-the-weight-of-an-hourglass-change-when-sands-are-falling-inside">Does the weight of an hourglass change when sands are falling inside?</a></p> <p>At Brigham Young University, there is a display consisting of a sealed off liter bottle with a sunken sealed off hourglass. When one turns over the bottle, the hourglass floats as the sands flow down. Eventually, the hourglass reaches some transition, and precipitately changes from floating to sinking.</p> <p>It has a sign next to it saying that it's for a fishing lure,and that you should not reveal the answer if you get it.</p> <p>What causes it to change from floating to sinking so quickly? </p>
g4253
[ 0.039382848888635635, 0.03389931470155716, -0.01713719591498375, -0.06740203499794006, 0.08706596493721008, 0.05018163099884987, 0.05392811447381973, -0.018711550161242485, -0.032012633979320526, -0.037343114614486694, 0.01190650649368763, 0.03458802029490471, 0.06736094504594803, 0.016645167022943497, 0.011396501213312149, 0.0005160111468285322, 0.06841520220041275, -0.031475141644477844, 0.008954303339123726, -0.02156888134777546, -0.007030312903225422, 0.03528091311454773, -0.02172013372182846, 0.02999427355825901, -0.06646828353404999, -0.002234920160844922, 0.005327596329152584, 0.019449222832918167, 0.028331222012639046, 0.03541775792837143, -0.0388055220246315, 0.019276419654488564, 0.0004961328231729567, -0.02805754914879799, 0.008629118092358112, -0.08482139557600021, 0.02101094275712967, -0.04313944652676582, 0.017228074371814728, -0.002219989662989974, -0.027128450572490692, 0.02356482483446598, 0.03823547437787056, 0.004167851526290178, -0.03551742061972618, -0.006265696603804827, 0.01150720939040184, 0.007663090247660875, -0.041164714843034744, -0.042314182966947556, 0.006439755205065012, -0.010874787345528603, 0.001604260760359466, 0.07812447100877762, 0.017626959830522537, -0.00004804262789548375, -0.0321376658976078, -0.001480642007663846, 0.04834387078881264, 0.05508144199848175, 0.009395834989845753, -0.0221352968364954, 0.01800129935145378, 0.007557898759841919, 0.01474481076002121, 0.010198033414781094, 0.043796032667160034, -0.006751690525561571, 0.03704999387264252, 0.01127512939274311, 0.03667950630187988, -0.004737722687423229, 0.006462647579610348, -0.0533340685069561, -0.06615312397480011, 0.06069464236497879, 0.03217299282550812, -0.008367045782506466, -0.039931342005729675, -0.03904586285352707, -0.005940570030361414, 0.08268062770366669, -0.012752508744597435, -0.023727277293801308, 0.02356746979057789, 0.06995122134685516, -0.022062551230192184, 0.06301270425319672, 0.02065279521048069, -0.008343388326466084, 0.02942265011370182, -0.06019787862896919, 0.04854677617549896, -0.026886601001024246, -0.033986154943704605, -0.04628896713256836, 0.012851733714342117, 0.015837350860238075, -0.02694046124815941, 0.05295473709702492, -0.02128387801349163, -0.03058677911758423, 0.01921355538070202, 0.02740808017551899, -0.015138113871216774, 0.025628702715039253, 0.022987183183431625, 0.04792032390832901, -0.04280159994959831, -0.004781933967024088, -0.02413550764322281, -0.04534789174795151, -0.045250751078128815, -0.017483431845903397, 0.00942564383149147, -0.017507143318653107, 0.05850078538060188, 0.020768923684954643, 0.009129059500992298, -0.04340984299778938, -0.01895071193575859, -0.02696375735104084, 0.015926605090498924, 0.03856588900089264, -0.023372352123260498, -0.0033222842030227184, 0.03836655616760254, 0.02478519082069397, -0.015288527123630047, 0.021639512851834297, -0.03671010211110115, 0.06000394746661186, -0.02983359433710575, 0.023314502090215683, 0.009489509277045727, 0.009068557061254978, -0.0266584400087595, -0.00013276972458697855, 0.019085120409727097, 0.024633822962641716, 0.0032869302667677402, -0.016762610524892807, 0.013215932995080948, 0.02253972925245762, -0.006976618431508541, -0.004294291604310274, 0.03178330138325691, 0.03196055069565773, 0.04038659483194351, 0.0064096045680344105, -0.01985965296626091, 0.050103809684515, 0.029892969876527786, -0.011021328158676624, 0.0633382648229599, 0.00461913924664259, 0.03719558194279671, -0.016364939510822296, 0.01017551589757204, 0.013839363120496273, 0.0645216777920723, -0.02010924182832241, -0.023930348455905914, 0.07511058449745178, -0.10776402056217194, -0.0031965309754014015, 0.07375427335500717, 0.017152247950434685, -0.03859378397464752, -0.0171749796718359, -0.036896560341119766, -0.020057257264852524, 0.034281469881534576, 0.10238806158304214, 0.0385986864566803, 0.014263495802879333, 0.06603660434484482, 0.008314278908073902, 0.02794799767434597, 0.014368751086294651, 0.0018740729428827763, -0.028143547475337982, 0.0031269281171262264, 0.00773219158872962, 0.043735235929489136, -0.027039533481001854, 0.023100385442376137, 0.018080774694681168, -0.051103103905916214, -0.03251063451170921, -0.06287771463394165, -0.03450726717710495, -0.04724331200122833, -0.029466867446899414, 0.011433964595198631, -0.04083935543894768, 0.028971217572689056, -0.06846337765455246, -0.036288149654865265, 0.020619582384824753, 0.014445492997765541, 0.0121986772865057, 0.02010907605290413, -0.001572921290062368, 0.0013662128476426005, 0.03117060288786888, -0.01734989881515503, -0.03978613018989563, 0.009538154117763042, 0.014260315336287022, 0.07072769850492477, 0.046294812113046646, 0.013122009113430977, -0.009182487614452839, 0.02512131817638874, 0.04718737304210663, -0.006974315736442804, 0.07248122245073318, 0.05312906950712204, 0.006809932179749012, 0.007701985538005829, 0.01460826862603426, -0.004844326991587877, -0.003364379284903407, 0.00794640276581049, -0.0012541867326945066, -0.020254680886864662, -0.06040342524647713, -0.009066926315426826, -0.004140586592257023, 0.03653253987431526, -0.03777647390961647, -0.010404758155345917, 0.034755077213048935, 0.016265152022242546, 0.013138006441295147, 0.0007807432557456195, 0.00437578558921814, 0.05612291768193245, -0.025847269222140312, -0.01761869341135025, -0.02891773357987404, -0.06737355887889862, -0.00858621671795845, -0.01944446936249733, -0.03030756115913391, 0.00936572253704071, 0.004400087054818869, -0.014156419783830643, 0.051592905074357986, 0.05888877809047699, 0.010533765889704227, 0.022008610889315605, 0.030562881380319595, 0.021886689588427544, 0.016914749518036842, -0.07896894961595535, -0.008847618475556374, -0.030658576637506485, 0.006366857327520847, -0.0007565345731563866, -0.04788866266608238, -0.007490982301533222, -0.018907448276877403, -0.07060939073562622, -0.07402396947145462, -0.03070257604122162, 0.009848696179687977, 0.04069894552230835, 0.024197706952691078, -0.03344115614891052, -0.02533631958067417, 0.08132565766572952, 0.08579529821872711, -0.03617671877145767, 0.006450985092669725, -0.0475112609565258, 0.011388742364943027, 0.014044307172298431, -0.05438901484012604, -0.024467602372169495, -0.00728277862071991, -0.12205485254526138, 0.07652144134044647, -0.011258860118687153, -0.03395616635680199, 0.007070227991789579, 0.04458379000425339, -0.06172093003988266, 0.036529041826725006, -0.041663121432065964, 0.04581127688288689, 0.05546390265226364, 0.004629597999155521, 0.0169365331530571, 0.03791525587439537, -0.0072102975100278854, -0.0018288932042196393, -0.0304514542222023, 0.007579841651022434, 0.06314590573310852, 0.01261342503130436, 0.007541164290159941, 0.013051186688244343, 0.05306299030780792, 0.10233128070831299, -0.014221384190022945, -0.0007117359200492501, -0.04309029132127762, -0.0030329956207424402, -0.03453153371810913, -0.014185714535415173, -0.020639026537537575, 0.023446599021553993, -0.07104021310806274, 0.024523653090000153, -0.017221590504050255, 0.02063985913991928, -0.015483513474464417, -0.05743515118956566, -0.043838586658239365, 0.0683017447590828, -0.020892301574349403, -0.02805202640593052, -0.007027209270745516, -0.017639504745602608, -0.000019504852389218286, 0.014652842655777931, -0.0020050255116075277, -0.003268478438258171, 0.02572588250041008, -0.012024598196148872, -0.034409988671541214, -0.07179006934165955, -0.0214841291308403, 0.06674539297819138, 0.04030054807662964, 0.06472843885421753, -0.03485970199108124, 0.012870662845671177, -0.00848004687577486, -0.05559259653091431, 0.028604112565517426, -0.021436868235468864, -0.00025869064847938716, -0.009890684857964516, 0.07773123681545258, -0.02573174238204956, 0.004460371099412441, -0.01082624401897192, 0.02795816771686077, -0.001586314756423235, -0.036196500062942505, -0.018724825233221054, 0.02012755163013935, 0.016024451702833176, -0.006503729615360498, -0.00030977773712947965, -0.03619449585676193, 0.010069661773741245, -0.0034362091682851315, -0.055970508605241776, 0.0002490757324267179, 0.02858739346265793, 0.020668786019086838, 0.012520181015133858, -0.020626012235879898, 0.000029481316232704557, -0.03670937195420265, 0.02528814598917961, 0.03749145567417145, 0.04321697726845741, -0.05316435918211937, -0.03299938887357712, 0.0062548210844397545, -0.03272023797035217, 0.001160014420747757, 0.005922989454120398, 0.013270911760628223, -0.03849514201283455, 0.05481670796871185, 0.015456554479897022, -0.00425411481410265, -0.0065945046953856945, -0.00532650388777256, 0.053228508681058884, -0.02746315859258175, -0.06124060973525047, 0.02673470601439476, -0.04437847435474396, -0.03242470324039459, 0.008575471118092537, 0.021630365401506424, 0.010643151588737965, -0.013898668810725212, 0.02447596564888954, -0.013704284094274044, -0.032500337809324265, 0.01335730031132698, -0.02947421371936798, -0.04198823124170303, 0.05304558947682381, -0.0638190358877182, 0.031905654817819595, -0.004154457710683346, 0.09423389285802841, 0.028882062062621117, -0.08352877199649811, -0.0368492417037487, -0.04862586036324501, 0.051564402878284454, 0.034099943935871124, -0.04004015773534775, -0.0340670682489872, -0.03937657177448273, 0.08038127422332764, -0.01045417133718729, 0.04015118256211281, 0.01976892165839672, 0.003093522507697344, -0.029667461290955544, 0.05895386263728142, -0.028178919106721878, -0.005166647024452686, -0.04053625464439392, -0.03591950237751007, 0.01048736646771431, 0.03211443871259689, 0.025373034179210663, -0.05532241240143776, 0.0014759942423552275, 0.031316179782152176, 0.02629096806049347, 0.008437743410468102, -0.017468668520450592, 0.06406369060277939, 0.009791914373636246, -0.015653232112526894, -0.01932327263057232, -0.0013225823640823364, 0.03499915450811386, 0.017260942608118057, -0.022516600787639618, -0.01116256695240736, 0.006705997511744499, 0.02060309611260891, -0.01769252121448517, 0.0540696457028389, 0.05881841108202934, -0.03322518244385719, -0.06532396376132965, 0.021017927676439285, 0.028110239654779434, -0.06457719951868057, -0.006047691218554974, -0.030954577028751373, -0.013331571593880653, 0.03286544233560562, -0.03265386447310448, 0.019759023562073708, 0.010946406982839108, 0.00009290475281886756, -0.03434880077838898, 0.013067435473203659, 0.004963398445397615, -0.00020333100110292435, 0.03185716271400452, -0.04335122928023338, 0.03773023188114166, -0.01417580433189869, -0.020797908306121826, 0.015296044759452343, 0.015115311369299889, 0.01656709425151348, -0.018841562792658806, 0.03599679842591286, 0.016811441630125046, -0.011702962219715118, 0.09677562862634659, -0.05812572315335274, -0.040871039032936096, 0.03276137635111809, -0.028636028990149498, 0.024583572521805763, -0.055090028792619705, 0.005735582206398249, -0.041038211435079575, 0.0015767336590215564, 0.02419552020728588, 0.005162786226719618, -0.013499965891242027, -0.056345634162425995, 0.001664773910306394, -0.03213243931531906, -0.020819758996367455, -0.035684552043676376, 0.024179156869649887, -0.013960176147520542, -0.011588512919843197, -0.03199378401041031, -0.07334183901548386, -0.03639725223183632, 0.010553930886089802, -0.004770110826939344, 0.027776511386036873, 0.02597351185977459, 0.001596952904947102, 0.010998792015016079, 0.03834279254078865, 0.05494857206940651, 0.027893610298633575, -0.004162970930337906, -0.0028816084377467632, -0.03858612850308418, 0.05353659391403198, -0.030079711228609085, -0.03728891909122467, -0.007940023206174374, 0.035093314945697784, 0.05087023600935936, -0.06565169245004654, 0.005575704853981733, -0.004555207211524248, 0.02506330981850624, -0.057577792555093765, 0.004914904944598675, -0.044424787163734436, -0.06492365896701813, -0.025335831567645073, -0.013476668857038021, 0.020625226199626923, 0.012176111340522766, 0.02106819488108158, 0.006034182384610176, -0.013333252631127834, -0.04090146720409393, 0.05787666141986847, 0.013907087035477161, 0.03953849896788597, 0.02741849236190319, -0.048194896429777145, 0.022521579638123512, -0.01598009094595909, 0.07095442712306976, 0.05766501650214195, -0.02384389005601406, 0.0011134729720652103, -0.009984038770198822, 0.03986254334449768, 0.011940048076212406, -0.0009656108450144529, 0.07912369072437286, -0.01718965359032154, 0.043876126408576965, -0.024030808359384537, 0.015040533617138863, -0.043126579374074936, 0.005731318611651659, -0.06647153198719025, 0.008565901778638363, -0.017088228836655617, 0.01138327270746231, 0.007155959494411945, -0.005257501266896725, 0.06281882524490356, -0.0896802768111229, -0.005707636009901762, 0.021459538489580154, 0.07089120149612427, 0.029941895976662636, -0.017193112522363663, -0.034421637654304504, 0.0020290485117584467, -0.08506689220666885, -0.024227922782301903, -0.0029742137994617224, -0.03871200978755951, -0.02628006599843502, -0.0019994580652564764, -0.04487746208906174, 0.02823568694293499, -0.025892224162817, 0.03228135034441948, -0.03329842537641525, 0.003911220468580723, -0.0046699512749910355, -0.04520002007484436, -0.04885900020599365, 0.03797850385308266, -0.009584622457623482, -0.03323930501937866, 0.0029502413235604763, -0.029299389570951462, -0.012795264832675457, -0.029642891138792038, -0.011103793047368526, -0.03610208258032799, -0.0037256532814353704, 0.0028522482607513666, -0.04779764637351036, -0.018968895077705383, 0.023598024621605873, 0.08044406026601791, -0.040010906755924225, 0.012736140750348568, 0.03272509574890137, 0.05307606980204582, 0.011386878788471222, -0.013405743055045605, -0.060505855828523636, -0.005561348982155323, 0.017457077279686928, 0.021428031846880913, 0.011644738726317883, -0.06688319146633148, -0.026525357738137245, 0.0397438108921051, 0.004196706227958202, -0.05887523666024208, -0.021051568910479546, -0.021599439904093742, -0.05600566416978836, 0.07775956392288208, -0.0299768578261137, 0.020354920998215675, 0.07148708403110504, -0.06063154339790344, -0.016379429027438164, -0.008493104949593544, -0.03259953483939171, 0.022068465128540993, -0.06989974528551102, 0.031034985557198524, -0.013430983759462833, 0.027801087126135826, 0.04525792971253395, 0.01716037280857563, 0.05401330068707466, 0.007684566546231508, 0.043221913278102875, 0.009217881597578526, 0.02424398995935917, 0.013477377593517303, 0.02446608804166317, -0.0061654322780668736, -0.005211690906435251, 0.04760339483618736, -0.04054240137338638, -0.04061517491936684, 0.011817831546068192, 0.01187673956155777, -0.013677136041224003, -0.02270440012216568, 0.0375128909945488, 0.06576277315616608, 0.05649492144584656, -0.03544945269823074, -0.000500961032230407, -0.01636817865073681, -0.049868542701005936, -0.01828906498849392, 0.032790377736091614, -0.0038751123938709497, 0.015823079273104668, -0.04831523820757866, 0.05509874224662781, -0.010600210167467594, -0.10809449106454849, 0.012536951340734959, 0.07792866975069046, -0.027709539979696274, -0.027137231081724167, -0.04265319183468819, -0.04595771059393883, 0.021481597796082497, 0.038906604051589966, -0.03849955275654793, 0.0077537475153803825, 0.02741714008152485, -0.01667346991598606, 0.02782161720097065, 0.01114579662680626, -0.01616276055574417, -0.05334194749593735, -0.026110796257853508, 0.003175414865836501, -0.06763448566198349, 0.06216932088136673, 0.015037036500871181, 0.024403944611549377, 0.024330919608473778, 0.0333540178835392, -0.041585296392440796, 0.04446013644337654, -0.007143592461943626, -0.036507852375507355, 0.04980352520942688, -0.05562496930360794, 0.01588364876806736, 0.023565268144011497, -0.024381760507822037, -0.04366918280720711, -0.0456397570669651, 0.02344493195414543, 0.03238362818956375, -0.039207424968481064, 0.004583410453051329, 0.04052841663360596, -0.05261603742837906, -0.018103962764143944, 0.02834136411547661, -0.036223433911800385, 0.026506870985031128, -0.10960385203361511, 0.004845621529966593, 0.011033348739147186, 0.03710288554430008, -0.014041324146091938, -0.09126227349042892, -0.004503261763602495, -0.01046996470540762, -0.005214987322688103, 0.029075030237436295, -0.050908882170915604, -0.07906654477119446, -0.0750889778137207, 0.057079512625932693, -0.027963479980826378, -0.06575330346822739, -0.0027667521499097347, -0.0403992123901844, 0.018763262778520584, -0.006019080523401499, -0.04171326756477356, -0.017375292256474495, -0.003581490833312273, 0.044055476784706116, 0.02968483977019787, -0.00489347567781806, -0.029233235865831375, 0.014332828111946583, 0.02590860053896904, 0.011918244883418083, 0.0004645519657060504, 0.05158553272485733, -0.032583191990852356, -0.016170121729373932, 0.038617946207523346, 0.03194056451320648, -0.053806059062480927, -0.017712365835905075, 0.020512497052550316, 0.031618569046258926, 0.009378061629831791, -0.011172524653375149, 0.0027916969265788794, -0.042660560458898544, 0.024069931358098984, 0.01038492750376463, -0.06199626997113228, -0.003325221361592412, -0.0019400466699153185, -0.036582354456186295, -0.007394695654511452, 0.006801154464483261, -0.027281638234853745, 0.011698076501488686, 0.036415524780750275 ]
<p>The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle" rel="nofollow">uncertainty principle</a> states that,</p> <p>$$\sigma _{{x}}\sigma _{{p}}\geq {\frac {\hbar }{2}}.$$</p> <p>It is mentioned from many sources that the probability distribution of the particle position and momentum would follow a Gaussian distribution.</p> <p>Why is it a Gaussian distribution? is this the distribution that minimizes uncertainty? Is this distribution definitely the case for the uncertainty principle or can it be different under different conditions? Has this been proven?</p> <p>What are the formulas for position and momentum probability distributions of a free particle? How is this derived from the wave function? What would be the formulas of the probability distributions for the position and momentum for a system of 2 identical bosons separated by a distance $R$?</p>
g4254
[ 0.029867948964238167, 0.013886691071093082, -0.017623959109187126, -0.009521758183836937, 0.028594383969902992, 0.03584350273013115, 0.010959831066429615, 0.01294333953410387, -0.029890337958931923, -0.0018592861015349627, -0.01865256391465664, -0.021865811198949814, -0.05203249305486679, -0.06887535750865936, 0.013943593017756939, 0.02582358382642269, 0.06137065216898918, 0.028670109808444977, 0.016323698684573174, 0.04621872305870056, -0.010369984433054924, -0.020635485649108887, -0.0025793875101953745, -0.020696621388196945, -0.004607237875461578, -0.0052688028663396835, -0.05971191078424454, -0.04597436264157295, -0.0067582204937934875, -0.0006462808232754469, 0.009865056723356247, 0.023862658068537712, 0.09924443066120148, -0.030233096331357956, 0.04316123202443123, -0.020847951993346214, 0.056162040680646896, -0.03350485861301422, 0.011268704198300838, -0.021667253226041794, -0.026970980688929558, -0.02453056536614895, 0.01323174312710762, -0.037283699959516525, -0.028366511687636375, 0.06186966225504875, -0.04246191680431366, 0.003250246401876211, -0.0024938276037573814, -0.02653200551867485, 0.004176442977041006, 0.06054176017642021, 0.010279963724315166, 0.032970938831567764, 0.028834139928221703, 0.07460948824882507, 0.07380099594593048, 0.023703431710600853, -0.02331431955099106, 0.014238203875720501, -0.014443332329392433, 0.03735129162669182, -0.0806993618607521, 0.016992324963212013, -0.01745511218905449, -0.049559131264686584, -0.05070323869585991, 0.014198516495525837, 0.010369614697992802, -0.006254982203245163, 0.03972497209906578, -0.027465561404824257, -0.05538070201873779, -0.03958763927221298, -0.05081227421760559, -0.03651050105690956, -0.023534834384918213, 0.041574627161026, -0.02563948556780815, 0.026198677718639374, -0.0263359472155571, -0.024713590741157532, 0.038136158138513565, -0.026112306863069534, 0.014979110099375248, -0.023748472332954407, 0.038757726550102234, 0.016321029514074326, 0.031178640201687813, -0.03374550864100456, 0.006104408297687769, -0.0517694316804409, 0.03510343283414841, 0.0019275086233392358, -0.01623745635151863, 0.017978211864829063, -0.059400979429483414, 0.0333624966442585, 0.014009841717779636, -0.038536034524440765, -0.016046276316046715, 0.05242343246936798, 0.015614926815032959, -0.016235820949077606, -0.002946436870843172, -0.037715088576078415, 0.017346108332276344, 0.035435546189546585, 0.015391213819384575, -0.0067242044024169445, -0.042375195771455765, 0.03644251078367233, 0.007261508144438267, -0.031005237251520157, -0.009812277741730213, -0.02364402264356613, 0.0670122429728508, -0.021499916911125183, 0.048369523137807846, 0.02438177727162838, 0.03688620403409004, 0.03241608291864395, 0.02265341393649578, 0.05939745530486107, -0.07109908759593964, -0.005518002435564995, -0.030622264370322227, -0.004929039161652327, -0.0007453049765899777, 0.007644238881766796, 0.03577331826090813, -0.03439412638545036, -0.03313681110739708, 0.03981756791472435, -0.05265349894762039, 0.01551254652440548, -0.01971798576414585, 0.024056263267993927, 0.025542065501213074, 0.01786023937165737, 0.03525238111615181, 0.004346481524407864, 0.04440879449248314, -0.05135718360543251, -0.004957673139870167, -0.015459046699106693, -0.029181960970163345, -0.05469352751970291, -0.017190320417284966, -0.001340087503194809, -0.0035654944367706776, 0.03735283389687538, -0.010587044060230255, 0.038591742515563965, 0.022076595574617386, 0.005168964620679617, 0.012976953759789467, 0.026911607012152672, -0.019404064863920212, -0.0281929112970829, 0.04298687353730202, -0.0038110017776489258, 0.06608184427022934, 0.00925489328801632, -0.04145936667919159, -0.003213172312825918, 0.02246774546802044, -0.05924868583679199, 0.01892610639333725, -0.04588262736797333, 0.0014988637994974852, -0.024741949513554573, -0.04089037701487541, 0.026421425864100456, 0.045396752655506134, 0.02203492820262909, -0.04044121503829956, -0.022912180051207542, 0.004345475696027279, 0.08425036817789078, -0.046462636440992355, 0.05501002445816994, 0.017486605793237686, -0.02685638889670372, -0.08467543870210648, 0.06097546964883804, 0.023016702383756638, -0.027618316933512688, 0.002396865515038371, 0.03006657399237156, -0.014648432843387127, -0.04676910862326622, -0.04641542583703995, 0.0047163767740130424, -0.009123538620769978, 0.07649477571249008, 0.025736182928085327, -0.019579976797103882, -0.008350434713065624, 0.06692580878734589, 0.0012937806313857436, 0.052918605506420135, 0.011257246136665344, -0.005937244743108749, 0.06586983799934387, -0.015538006089627743, 0.044574398547410965, -0.04006900638341904, -0.027149993926286697, -0.031520646065473557, -0.015513919293880463, -0.06192562356591225, -0.023894580081105232, 0.06545694917440414, 0.04079490527510643, -0.06856490671634674, -0.01410498097538948, 0.02390836551785469, 0.01413604337722063, -0.028568172827363014, -0.04974910616874695, -0.0031800861470401287, 0.031004449352622032, 0.008349232375621796, 0.010254797525703907, 0.08557550609111786, -0.06054455414414406, -0.030034568160772324, -0.04234784469008446, 0.07481933385133743, -0.05353918671607971, -0.04526080563664436, -0.03053281642496586, 0.03324680030345917, 0.06514180451631546, 0.05272552743554115, 0.010491332039237022, -0.010832500644028187, 0.03988000750541687, 0.0925183892250061, 0.008164572529494762, -0.021699002012610435, 0.003900530282407999, 0.01851620525121689, 0.005090558901429176, -0.05710368975996971, 0.02743171900510788, -0.00006421942816814408, -0.03102264553308487, -0.026070011779665947, -0.02159297466278076, 0.027634987607598305, -0.0355401411652565, -0.04489686340093613, 0.008828223682940006, 0.01406320184469223, 0.02781493030488491, -0.00022656990040559322, -0.08201423287391663, -0.034206002950668335, 0.03723754361271858, -0.06875240802764893, 0.0015103538753464818, 0.008824198506772518, -0.031178364530205727, 0.06576642394065857, -0.013129541650414467, 0.07590117305517197, 0.03263036161661148, -0.005939486902207136, 0.06286419928073883, 0.061659280210733414, -0.02019965648651123, 0.03197937086224556, -0.013935629278421402, -0.009087401442229748, 0.026634162291884422, -0.050941869616508484, 0.0036962812300771475, 0.033980876207351685, -0.028796838596463203, 0.0030085735488682985, -0.08664724975824356, -0.014470101334154606, 0.019636502489447594, 0.017691507935523987, 0.03229059651494026, 0.03382398560643196, 0.004638192243874073, -0.013503403402864933, 0.057806346565485, 0.005024266429245472, 0.06480205059051514, 0.030036676675081253, -0.0004149082815274596, 0.05416366457939148, 0.002399939112365246, -0.03935246914625168, -0.08530968427658081, 0.004025487694889307, -0.01948031596839428, -0.0037265149876475334, -0.04496069252490997, 0.023543348535895348, 0.028708916157484055, 0.02350594848394394, -0.03737908601760864, -0.01689859665930271, -0.0428578183054924, 0.009160144254565239, -0.018463609740138054, 0.07337981462478638, 0.004694415256381035, 0.030809789896011353, -0.003795948810875416, 0.002015461213886738, -0.05720766261219978, 0.011090565472841263, 0.009386193938553333, -0.007040629629045725, -0.049541592597961426, -0.027300680056214333, -0.01851671002805233, -0.025285011157393456, 0.1002492904663086, 0.034863945096731186, -0.056143634021282196, 0.030070502310991287, -0.05804179981350899, -0.029350638389587402, 0.013145213015377522, 0.02575005404651165, 0.010445155203342438, -0.06380510330200195, -0.006151774898171425, -0.06911146640777588, 0.09457648545503616, -0.021635273471474648, 0.02750767581164837, 0.00431307777762413, 0.04309682920575142, 0.005250043701380491, -0.044935308396816254, 0.03435051813721657, -0.04001064971089363, -0.01706930249929428, 0.05740095674991608, -0.01527290791273117, 0.04321270063519478, -0.02901693992316723, -0.01862785778939724, 0.004473451059311628, 0.021702265366911888, 0.019939767196774483, -0.027832500636577606, 0.056179605424404144, -0.004977360367774963, -0.036251701414585114, 0.04048741236329079, -0.0050703128799796104, 0.018916090950369835, -0.05334140732884407, 0.025074496865272522, 0.03237520530819893, 0.0034233806654810905, -0.05552615597844124, 0.0015044391620904207, 0.05317733436822891, 0.022642243653535843, -0.02211897075176239, -0.022062022238969803, 0.0012332431506365538, 0.014076492749154568, 0.02459191530942917, 0.041895393282175064, -0.012582981027662754, 0.05474761128425598, -0.01623261719942093, -0.03473112732172012, -0.020324381068348885, 0.02416379377245903, 0.04273489862680435, 0.009688123129308224, -0.008355621248483658, 0.011485320515930653, -0.0085822194814682, -0.0726822093129158, 0.033355552703142166, 0.025431960821151733, -0.051694974303245544, -0.02685588039457798, -0.0286262147128582, -0.014685754664242268, 0.004349897149950266, 0.016092026606202126, 0.05125615373253822, -0.011031240224838257, 0.02478828653693199, 0.004664937499910593, 0.005289160180836916, -0.005573871545493603, -0.02284134365618229, -0.023995282128453255, 0.00699088117107749, 0.02880183607339859, 0.05073397234082222, 0.005295454058796167, -0.02765798568725586, -0.013813252560794353, 0.01005695853382349, 0.01163457240909338, -0.0034623409155756235, 0.03894698992371559, -0.018212080001831055, 0.05032069608569145, -0.006526927929371595, -0.007476605009287596, -0.022371580824255943, -0.020540112629532814, 0.05138605833053589, 0.018155412748456, -0.0036879924591630697, 0.08793071657419205, -0.0415460504591465, -0.061106204986572266, 0.002708552172407508, 0.07487735152244568, 0.029020698741078377, 0.0051233465783298016, -0.009929224848747253, -0.005436515901237726, 0.009491403587162495, 0.01499736588448286, -0.01376043725758791, -0.024054426699876785, 0.010572056286036968, -0.00367546733468771, -0.040427207946777344, 0.010873151011765003, 0.041479531675577164, 0.004973299335688353, -0.0115219010040164, 0.036198459565639496, -0.008612025529146194, 0.023208243772387505, 0.0494253970682621, 0.008068500086665154, -0.001102435402572155, 0.022492829710245132, -0.001953180180862546, -0.010949143208563328, 0.008215353824198246, -0.0481439083814621, -0.024883698672056198, 0.045813821256160736, -0.00332906236872077, -0.06518550962209702, 0.04020078852772713, 0.05095755681395531, -0.013504979200661182, -0.046403903514146805, 0.02002711594104767, 0.02653723955154419, -0.022753190249204636, 0.010107832960784435, 0.04017813876271248, -0.1108611673116684, -0.0019102165242657065, -0.021066809073090553, -0.0006828685873188078, -0.022399047389626503, 0.013561001047492027, 0.04886220023036003, 0.017689742147922516, 0.046493884176015854, -0.021819595247507095, 0.01010148599743843, -0.02177472412586212, 0.035184912383556366, -0.04637875407934189, -0.06998215615749359, -0.002480411436408758, 0.010768570937216282, -0.016200747340917587, 0.003706984221935272, -0.03516721725463867, -0.02901913970708847, -0.009411306120455265, 0.0002507993776816875, -0.012917335145175457, 0.01364411972463131, 0.012107943184673786, 0.01764298975467682, -0.045795463025569916, 0.02844943292438984, -0.032430991530418396, -0.0005027683801017702, -0.004590028431266546, -0.01573055051267147, 0.0018757369834929705, -0.03928537666797638, -0.02384941652417183, -0.010970879346132278, 0.023592716082930565, 0.012731733731925488, 0.0723043754696846, 0.07985100150108337, -0.041031211614608765, -0.01816977933049202, -0.009369699284434319, 0.03164351359009743, -0.011591068468987942, -0.038183268159627914, -0.04508182778954506, -0.02766389399766922, -0.034768231213092804, -0.007772762328386307, 0.00562448101118207, -0.01812322437763214, 0.02491312101483345, 0.04639596492052078, 0.0011410729493945837, 0.051998358219861984, -0.016665825620293617, -0.037447791546583176, -0.04308631271123886, -0.0394958071410656, -0.036655180156230927, -0.007968437857925892, 0.0318576842546463, -0.025553308427333832, 0.018258756026625633, 0.06432337313890457, -0.03328974172472954, -0.025916900485754013, -0.047336284071207047, -0.02500603348016739, -0.02080029807984829, 0.014714610762894154, -0.015645384788513184, -0.015665575861930847, -0.030846836045384407, 0.005896876100450754, 0.055098649114370346, -0.09777797758579254, 0.00770827429369092, -0.022444263100624084, 0.014187151566147804, 0.033362992107868195, -0.06764320284128189, -0.004822574555873871, 0.030130289494991302, -0.02264324575662613, -0.01955156959593296, -0.030478516593575478, 0.023371169343590736, 0.0011247053043916821, 0.026225926354527473, -0.0018063404131680727, 0.018070165067911148, -0.0018416800303384662, -0.04317256063222885, -0.02224719524383545, -0.003823746694251895, 0.0851697102189064, 0.0038758316077291965, -0.020524147897958755, 0.016596920788288116, -0.011140056885778904, 0.1099877655506134, -0.015050218440592289, 0.0655425637960434, -0.00996809359639883, 0.04850813001394272, 0.028694774955511093, -0.031689781695604324, 0.0007801049505360425, -0.030071772634983063, -0.0563165582716465, -0.044169116765260696, -0.024471843615174294, 0.0697798803448677, 0.006613662466406822, -0.025723114609718323, -0.06813834607601166, 0.042321763932704926, 0.020111648365855217, -0.042824674397706985, 0.05437258630990982, 0.04445688799023628, 0.01842580735683441, -0.018570391461253166, -0.005486354231834412, 0.004626335110515356, -0.07074201852083206, -0.047175705432891846, 0.04434759169816971, -0.04757160320878029, -0.020170139148831367, -0.00758572481572628, -0.015503241680562496, 0.002399564953520894, -0.0014828555285930634, -0.006868054624646902, 0.01831713505089283, 0.02355792187154293, 0.0027924063615500927, 0.0171549953520298, -0.012820030562579632, 0.006599803455173969, -0.004714416339993477, 0.009481223300099373, -0.0036917130928486586, -0.009661976248025894, 0.027958350256085396, 0.003241015365347266, -0.03259710967540741, 0.02973240241408348, -0.07759486138820648, 0.026570376008749008, 0.06810518354177475, 0.0022282181307673454, -0.01808367483317852, 0.04567461088299751, 0.07117193192243576, 0.03022214025259018, -0.006652551703155041, -0.011929890140891075, 0.03265611454844475, 0.004049967043101788, -0.002104530343785882, -0.012922864407300949, 0.1036389023065567, 0.07742395251989365, -0.07638561725616455, 0.0013570986920967698, -0.03654402121901512, 0.026972005143761635, -0.01403152197599411, 0.019723111763596535, -0.002798281377181411, -0.04348557069897652, 0.04971299320459366, -0.012534283101558685, -0.041285883635282516, 0.0006550404359586537, 0.037327516824007034, 0.013138346374034882, -0.045438747853040695, 0.026308001950383186, -0.08830484002828598, -0.02272167056798935, -0.009772677905857563, -0.03540368378162384, 0.010707281529903412, 0.0525079071521759, -0.005577475298196077, -0.022781213745474815, -0.01236227061599493, -0.041541267186403275, -0.041185010224580765, -0.0006428012275137007, -0.002532712649554014, -0.03644034266471863, 0.0016349273500964046, 0.06808459758758545, 0.004383152350783348, -0.03161928802728653, -0.0842057317495346, -0.015661129727959633, -0.0013412872795015574, -0.03195922449231148, -0.030967576429247856, -0.010078860446810722, 0.007511972449719906, 0.026724204421043396, -0.02171299047768116, 0.01322020124644041, -0.0477735660970211, 0.007862834259867668, 0.013523322530090809, 0.04052545502781868, -0.03814273700118065, -0.010373109951615334, -0.010733364149928093, 0.014375983737409115, -0.028926562517881393, 0.017885813489556313, -0.03194097429513931, -0.09228716790676117, -0.03186964988708496, -0.023592742159962654, 0.03899950534105301, -0.0910235345363617, 0.00631914846599102, 0.034358587116003036, 0.022679515182971954, -0.005714734084904194, 0.020117592066526413, -0.011329704895615578, -0.0021535337436944246, -0.006123417057096958, -0.02042374201118946, -0.007520315237343311, 0.03229636326432228, -0.06482072919607162, 0.008514379151165485, 0.06259109079837799, -0.044359683990478516, -0.10072047263383865, 0.06385210156440735, -0.028386736288666725, 0.021806174889206886, -0.032838888466358185, 0.0006020324071869254, -0.03903140127658844, -0.025346772745251656, 0.04192552715539932, -0.0481867641210556, 0.009985375218093395, 0.0748722031712532, -0.04084015265107155, -0.058477871119976044, 0.020401891320943832, 0.0038447463884949684, 0.0010498433839529753, -0.03771398589015007, -0.005194577854126692, 0.04154851287603378, 0.029717005789279938, -0.06025012210011482, 0.009176964871585369, -0.05456642806529999, 0.012496539391577244, -0.028284426778554916, -0.012527941726148129, 0.02355255000293255, 0.051049914211034775, 0.016851026564836502, -0.005171265918761492, 0.05766640603542328, -0.0028317777905613184, 0.056661881506443024, -0.0061346678994596004, -0.05483822152018547, -0.027569781988859177, 0.006023025140166283, 0.04570072144269943, 0.0363786444067955, 0.0009966056095436215, -0.02304867096245289, 0.047617606818675995, -0.04088189825415611, 0.07077650725841522, 0.06147220358252525, -0.059513550251722336, 0.0025051895063370466, 0.0839923769235611, 0.001192332012578845, -0.008951613679528236, 0.028647830709815025, -0.031172335147857666, -0.01599285751581192, 0.03263484686613083, -0.05469588562846184, 0.000563261506613344, 0.006212379317730665, 0.030543647706508636 ]
<p>I read somewhere that the tidal forces between the earth and the moon causes the equality between the 2 periods of the moon and that every planet-satellite system will evolve to this condition (like pluto-charon of you consider pluto a planet). Can somebody give me some references (books, articles) discussing this idea and why doesn't this happen in a star-planet system?</p>
g4255
[ 0.019947726279497147, 0.045022811740636826, 0.011539889499545097, 0.009540419094264507, 0.035918425768613815, 0.048601988703012466, -0.028710801154375076, -0.01119840145111084, 0.023279944434762, -0.034656181931495667, 0.008495191112160683, 0.03198537975549698, 0.031663376837968826, 0.013146146200597286, 0.03710007295012474, 0.0062822639010846615, 0.004200752824544907, -0.02937491238117218, 0.014680491760373116, 0.08132409304380417, -0.012518356554210186, 0.037959035485982895, -0.01415727287530899, 0.00005105723539600149, 0.0022789810318499804, 0.020109469071030617, 0.04362906143069267, -0.018840134143829346, 0.011631705798208714, -0.00800266396254301, 0.06551758944988251, 0.012290590442717075, 0.03230451047420502, -0.03186460956931114, -0.015660999342799187, -0.01383509486913681, -0.013797570951282978, -0.004720014985650778, -0.048881106078624725, 0.024253027513623238, 0.0386817529797554, -0.019629251211881638, -0.011099815368652344, 0.06078434735536575, -0.012926114723086357, -0.06372781097888947, -0.044327471405267715, -0.014956632629036903, -0.048041004687547684, -0.05293586105108261, 0.02769288420677185, 0.01178446039557457, 0.02648346871137619, -0.019395262002944946, -0.013884363695979118, 0.034237224608659744, 0.05238723382353783, -0.03594258055090904, 0.023918883875012398, 0.018052220344543457, 0.01673952117562294, -0.018996018916368484, 0.033764008432626724, 0.04185021296143532, 0.041849952191114426, 0.0017653258983045816, 0.03542015329003334, 0.05224120244383812, 0.00709879444912076, -0.008639048784971237, -0.008362926542758942, 0.015177056193351746, -0.03302605077624321, -0.008932230994105339, -0.01652483642101288, 0.028654204681515694, -0.009196805767714977, 0.012902678921818733, 0.0008138822740875185, 0.01658507250249386, 0.03383709490299225, 0.052417851984500885, 0.013344223611056805, 0.031361162662506104, 0.07103481143712997, -0.04230574518442154, 0.028003597632050514, -0.01222623884677887, -0.022471830248832703, 0.014944180846214294, 0.013018263503909111, -0.04739787057042122, 0.0022497300524264574, 0.023938622325658798, -0.0629398375749588, -0.02166573517024517, 0.033812664449214935, 0.060320984572172165, -0.010224701836705208, -0.019408773630857468, -0.0737389326095581, -0.011047749780118465, 0.000982376979663968, 0.011626391671597958, 0.033447179943323135, 0.013233229517936707, 0.039952732622623444, 0.018855703994631767, 0.029455330222845078, -0.05084788799285889, -0.03245256468653679, -0.011140361428260803, -0.012095061130821705, 0.02243395708501339, 0.008638602681457996, -0.044255807995796204, 0.07658322155475616, 0.0017074748175218701, 0.06568865478038788, 0.05555107444524765, -0.02025064080953598, 0.019242918118834496, -0.03528112173080444, 0.02611737884581089, -0.0679415911436081, -0.0252362247556448, 0.08437987416982651, 0.0023174744565039873, 0.022483360022306442, -0.01749241165816784, 0.008027723990380764, 0.015138687565922737, -0.028616057708859444, -0.023570775985717773, 0.018082477152347565, 0.010178021155297756, -0.030864285305142403, -0.04560570791363716, -0.025362104177474976, -0.045151565223932266, -0.040618520230054855, -0.04663681983947754, -0.01638410985469818, -0.009779639542102814, -0.08203292638063431, 0.022723760455846786, -0.02543138526380062, -0.020007740706205368, 0.02983524464070797, 0.06407429277896881, 0.03575200214982033, 0.08705965429544449, 0.040677472949028015, -0.06507501006126404, 0.0003131569246761501, 0.03772508725523949, 0.003041486721485853, -0.013223784975707531, -0.04597926512360573, 0.008277468383312225, 0.018776630982756615, 0.016937952488660812, -0.005780340172350407, -0.02556357905268669, -0.08153285831212997, 0.03946816921234131, -0.024812979623675346, -0.05140448361635208, -0.03028733655810356, -0.007165783084928989, -0.01434541679918766, -0.007697785273194313, -0.0011225456837564707, 0.101042240858078, 0.035982437431812286, 0.05114845931529999, 0.016049910336732864, -0.02876502089202404, 0.008926227688789368, 0.019083360210061073, -0.014560512267053127, -0.05032077059149742, -0.06440258026123047, 0.027021287009119987, 0.0014065882423892617, -0.06387436389923096, 0.0012437275145202875, 0.012886619195342064, -0.057068027555942535, 0.04268569499254227, 0.002833037404343486, -0.002593692159280181, 0.012035789899528027, 0.006445161998271942, 0.031640470027923584, -0.007433129008859396, -0.0032635359093546867, -0.011430561542510986, -0.0919121578335762, 0.003953171893954277, -0.049323100596666336, 0.030407674610614777, 0.04424988105893135, -0.04389112442731857, 0.006860536988824606, 0.026838254183530807, 0.02782207727432251, 0.012434621341526508, 0.07437191158533096, -0.03359673172235489, -0.010882004164159298, -0.025542881339788437, -0.0385655015707016, -0.011416960507631302, -0.09421037137508392, -0.010307823307812214, -0.04719864949584007, -0.024812469258904457, 0.03798810392618179, -0.043425142765045166, -0.000815681996755302, -0.008914324454963207, 0.01392865926027298, 0.030632957816123962, -0.04509784281253815, 0.02372707426548004, -0.03789214789867401, 0.052248019725084305, 0.04186192527413368, 0.008642361499369144, -0.004803705029189587, -0.013831204734742641, 0.011444379575550556, -0.003764704568311572, -0.0076163834892213345, 0.06933663040399551, -0.0027591465041041374, -0.02293381653726101, -0.0015729311853647232, 0.01363665983080864, -0.06894926726818085, -0.016080306842923164, -0.017682718113064766, 0.03700995445251465, 0.08440814912319183, -0.06662635505199432, 0.03352639824151993, -0.013512486591935158, -0.04811478406190872, 0.029120298102498055, 0.03386760130524635, -0.037802331149578094, -0.05542504042387009, -0.015229721553623676, -0.0010256748646497726, -0.04992096871137619, 0.0035538424272090197, 0.0714971050620079, -0.06351768970489502, 0.02742246724665165, 0.024223193526268005, -0.010483089834451675, 0.01754183880984783, 0.03169632330536842, -0.03942671790719032, -0.020036861300468445, 0.01838211715221405, -0.04507005959749222, -0.034621331840753555, 0.007274880539625883, 0.06599064916372299, 0.07514436542987823, 0.013826710171997547, 0.08776254206895828, -0.07586447894573212, 0.05673408880829811, -0.031709641218185425, -0.008363055065274239, -0.0520155131816864, 0.011931875720620155, 0.010848365724086761, -0.015532540157437325, 0.020485688000917435, 0.01632809452712536, 0.034419819712638855, -0.010838407091796398, 0.006008869968354702, 0.049865905195474625, -0.024619638919830322, 0.007631239946931601, 0.0037979548797011375, 0.008115959353744984, 0.02902521938085556, 0.03975082188844681, -0.009628999046981335, 0.0397087000310421, 0.015666509047150612, -0.021355247125029564, -0.08021873980760574, 0.013595116324722767, 0.04472184181213379, -0.03659474477171898, 0.032448604702949524, 0.023759879171848297, -0.0213160403072834, 0.01410292461514473, -0.02140454575419426, -0.017434610053896904, -0.013908145017921925, -0.029759734869003296, -0.02152887172996998, 0.051477763801813126, -0.05856277793645859, 0.03949495404958725, -0.03010433167219162, 0.045159634202718735, 0.027677979320287704, 0.011885483749210835, -0.03144596517086029, -0.014239962212741375, 0.019931456074118614, -0.03481623902916908, 0.02529851347208023, -0.004616165533661842, -0.038620758801698685, 0.009711618535220623, -0.06463982164859772, -0.050323959439992905, -0.03472178801894188, 0.005369317252188921, 0.0156251210719347, 0.026071147993206978, 0.02217174880206585, 0.014833258464932442, -0.05192787945270538, 0.05738260969519615, 0.022707754746079445, 0.03374142944812775, -0.006174689624458551, 0.07782788574695587, 0.011244057677686214, 0.0003316605289001018, -0.045725904405117035, -0.007821043953299522, -0.005935101769864559, 0.060255493968725204, 0.038258422166109085, -0.028011072427034378, 0.017173191532492638, -0.0016421996988356113, 0.04317445680499077, 0.004226537887006998, 0.047182679176330566, 0.005470874719321728, -0.006457164417952299, 0.020353516563773155, 0.02203511632978916, 0.0036749374121427536, 0.03391987830400467, -0.01699839159846306, 0.04059813916683197, 0.00166972482111305, 0.0009127369266934693, 0.07750709354877472, 0.009842638857662678, 0.016608556732535362, 0.020344361662864685, 0.03640512004494667, -0.012748214416205883, -0.027122437953948975, 0.05434390902519226, -0.003089478937909007, 0.004537554457783699, -0.0335739329457283, 0.07180707156658173, -0.07626888900995255, 0.036562711000442505, 0.00034585644607432187, 0.01831684820353985, 0.00005773505472461693, 0.08562002331018448, -0.03119531273841858, -0.03626565262675285, 0.07844424992799759, 0.037921179085969925, 0.003747540060430765, -0.04493652656674385, 0.013675648719072342, 0.03376010060310364, -0.085109181702137, 0.015198188833892345, -0.02496744692325592, -0.0070037441328167915, -0.04540163278579712, 0.06707555800676346, 0.014593351632356644, 0.01929597742855549, -0.03526606783270836, 0.002082930179312825, -0.01879710517823696, -0.02211897075176239, -0.027330929413437843, -0.04234299808740616, -0.011449943296611309, -0.0559857115149498, -0.026935677975416183, -0.010855769738554955, -0.0352744422852993, -0.006598696578294039, 0.024356784299016, 0.06564272195100784, 0.05805796757340431, 0.03236144781112671, -0.04066503793001175, -0.0019413585541769862, 0.016065066680312157, -0.01473415270447731, 0.010205419734120369, 0.0901518240571022, 0.005285598803311586, -0.023724710568785667, 0.07267991453409195, -0.04620441421866417, -0.024587808176875114, 0.014099572785198689, 0.061479803174734116, 0.05669859051704407, -0.015471781603991985, -0.03282604739069939, 0.02139577642083168, -0.025871872901916504, 0.04283581301569939, 0.03323114663362503, -0.043792881071567535, -0.02390783652663231, 0.03591689094901085, -0.02371402457356453, 0.013487325049936771, -0.0653647854924202, 0.021344633772969246, 0.04130302742123604, -0.017655516043305397, 0.02446719817817211, -0.02163710817694664, -0.01717202737927437, 0.09503630548715591, 0.03841704502701759, -0.06906925141811371, 0.04630067199468613, -0.0554213747382164, -0.01129759568721056, -0.020784728229045868, 0.004632329102605581, 0.021116798743605614, -0.018180133774876595, -0.027882451191544533, -0.025998776778578758, 0.025291139259934425, 0.00040040441672317684, 0.025790555402636528, -0.003510088659822941, -0.030823655426502228, 0.016610808670520782, 0.04738887771964073, 0.014886202290654182, 0.012177331373095512, -0.055520519614219666, 0.04100055992603302, -0.03168141096830368, -0.014060922898352146, -0.0017654576804488897, 0.012820196337997913, -0.008752279914915562, 0.046641163527965546, 0.0018958153668791056, -0.030609775334596634, -0.026180511340498924, -0.08066245913505554, 0.04224209114909172, -0.06926923990249634, 0.0016842612531036139, -0.015329232439398766, 0.04893799126148224, 0.04182317107915878, -0.04879329353570938, 0.014999408274888992, -0.06869173794984818, -0.016585862264037132, 0.011653812602162361, -0.014418737962841988, -0.052699457854032516, -0.01290935929864645, 0.03159931302070618, -0.04125944525003433, 0.018660368397831917, 0.002106236293911934, -0.022187694907188416, -0.06858053058385849, 0.0002291737328050658, 0.0016057603061199188, -0.007931225001811981, -0.015236904844641685, 0.0018159011378884315, 0.07064474374055862, 0.024161776527762413, 0.04598424211144447, -0.0018142019398510456, -0.00669080950319767, 0.00533219613134861, -0.008204708807170391, 0.02410115674138069, 0.048959407955408096, -0.005869210232049227, 0.05613836273550987, -0.0347687192261219, -0.016316838562488556, 0.005474386736750603, -0.02301008626818657, 0.006081738043576479, -0.07823927700519562, 0.005672101397067308, -0.03832721710205078, 0.0310406144708395, 0.04754405468702316, 0.031447045505046844, 0.009280944243073463, -0.004871386103332043, -0.022883618250489235, -0.013820232823491096, 0.027944864705204964, 0.0018100340384989977, -0.04252133518457413, -0.009415464475750923, 0.014596454799175262, 0.002023783279582858, -0.04680810123682022, 0.026264186948537827, 0.079737089574337, 0.06638564169406891, -0.05094360187649727, 0.024773042649030685, -0.033485524356365204, 0.027644915506243706, -0.040142275393009186, -0.06330462545156479, 0.0008679584716446698, -0.08295769989490509, 0.023838629946112633, 0.021081862971186638, -0.028941959142684937, -0.06703194975852966, 0.016278237104415894, 0.014713753946125507, -0.036639608442783356, -0.02202685736119747, 0.04104585945606232, 0.010656531900167465, 0.0053998613730072975, -0.022056011483073235, -0.0306558720767498, 0.03605405241250992, 0.01884979009628296, 0.02321612648665905, 0.021955834701657295, -0.028846662491559982, 0.0032684628386050463, 0.011130744591355324, -0.00597063172608614, 0.07427261769771576, 0.06280870735645294, 0.03286188840866089, -0.003499275539070368, -0.02134578488767147, -0.046928856521844864, -0.002064499771222472, -0.06076046824455261, -0.0461442694067955, -0.022880451753735542, -0.02400905452668667, 0.009059403091669083, 0.04529917240142822, -0.06591293215751648, -0.027222013100981712, 0.027129441499710083, -0.08102858066558838, 0.01255420409142971, -0.02280563674867153, -0.05321933329105377, 0.029236096888780594, -0.06056293472647667, -0.03740503266453743, -0.04535200074315071, 0.0038111996836960316, 0.043975312262773514, 0.009688252583146095, 0.030727900564670563, -0.05243552476167679, -0.008096277713775635, 0.006238692440092564, -0.03524865582585335, -0.009239745326340199, -0.002211992396041751, 0.08743641525506973, -0.024000709876418114, 0.0032021936494857073, -0.0015622099163010716, -0.04567760229110718, 0.005630563944578171, 0.04054511711001396, 0.06057937443256378, 0.011338555254042149, 0.01699165254831314, -0.01925867795944214, 0.02064388059079647, -0.021730007603764534, -0.04656486213207245, -0.007606016006320715, 0.012543745338916779, -0.06385631859302521, 0.0008261860348284245, 0.06246090307831764, 0.01454981416463852, 0.039747145026922226, -0.07310871034860611, 0.044137973338365555, 0.03769689053297043, -0.005183923523873091, 0.021579191088676453, 0.009224900975823402, -0.03350827097892761, 0.006404432002454996, -0.06314781308174133, 0.006189185660332441, 0.009637042880058289, 0.009539846330881119, -0.017593879252672195, -0.06510896980762482, -0.0287496205419302, 0.028403082862496376, 0.002661878475919366, -0.011488012038171291, 0.01947493851184845, 0.008430707268416882, 0.0010881350608542562, 0.0368538498878479, 0.03174349293112755, 0.012510808184742928, -0.04525824263691902, -0.06678037345409393, -0.00029886289848946035, -0.013978298753499985, -0.08895191550254822, -0.01662963628768921, 0.025268234312534332, 0.02639123424887657, 0.051308490335941315, 0.01589551940560341, -0.037550028413534164, 0.024501467123627663, -0.021218474954366684, -0.0032116419170051813, 0.01484532468020916, 0.004411207512021065, 0.05523308366537094, 0.008622173219919205, 0.008115074597299099, 0.05925704538822174, -0.04438656195998192, -0.0021856522653251886, -0.009313734248280525, -0.01845819130539894, -0.003454207442700863, -0.03720920905470848, -0.007940549403429031, -0.009636891074478626, -0.008971787057816982, -0.03668677806854248, -0.031579967588186264, 0.030950864776968956, -0.006830853410065174, -0.016733281314373016, 0.010006650350987911, -0.0024155767168849707, -0.019085822626948357, 0.005593909416347742, 0.02038811333477497, -0.017846399918198586, -0.005652745254337788, 0.00005702266935259104, -0.01955418474972248, -0.0060440003871917725, 0.052647531032562256, 0.001598156988620758, -0.025995705276727676, -0.0249803364276886, -0.023673750460147858, 0.02847192995250225, 0.02639228291809559, 0.007038844749331474, -0.03148193657398224, 0.030077693983912468, 0.004441161174327135, -0.05789375305175781, -0.0077404482290148735, 0.07443732023239136, 0.022748587653040886, -0.03227170184254646, 0.052966419607400894, -0.05536266043782234, -0.042381301522254944, 0.032182276248931885, 0.006447684019804001, -0.04197831451892853, -0.002999204909428954, -0.04217837378382683, -0.01830805465579033, 0.013453586027026176, -0.0029547165613621473, -0.06325282901525497, 0.025140199810266495, -0.024894647300243378, -0.04190787300467491, 0.0678982213139534, -0.12082193791866302, -0.06602777540683746, -0.040321726351976395, 0.023714175447821617, -0.03889380395412445, 0.041765592992305756, -0.04200984910130501, 0.01505426038056612, 0.007240098901093006, 0.01679774932563305, -0.04965268820524216, -0.026245523244142532, 0.024478726089000702, 0.01742846705019474, -0.05465901643037796, -0.0818716287612915, -0.005727589130401611, -0.06972518563270569, -0.03730356693267822, 0.07022444158792496, -0.01744901016354561, 0.04521588608622551, -0.029546882957220078, 0.004325744230300188, 0.07249903678894043, 0.04655098915100098, -0.04362882301211357, -0.017933189868927002, 0.022383304312825203, -0.02549743466079235, -0.011476568877696991, 0.03937805816531181, -0.049043208360672, -0.027604911476373672, -0.001886399695649743, -0.02146633341908455, -0.0006351322517730296, -0.003155801445245743, 0.030803071334958076, 0.014467965811491013, -0.04383740946650505, -0.004797269590198994, 0.018499083817005157, 0.016070041805505753, 0.06000600755214691 ]
<p>The global conformal group in 2D is $SL(2,\mathbb{C})$. It consists of the fractional linear transforms that map the Riemann sphere into itself bijectively and is finite dimensional. </p> <p>However, when studying $CFT_2$ people always use the full Virasoro algebra, not just the $L_{0,\pm1}$ which actually exponentiate to invertible transformations. I would like to know why people consider the other $L_n$'s to be symmetries of the theory. </p> <p>I am aware that Ward identities are local statements, and that I can consider a coordinate patch where the additional conformal transformations are bijective in order to derive relations between correlation functions in this patch. I am also familiar with the representations of the Virasoro algebra and how constraining the symmetry is.</p> <p>However, we are doing quantum mechanics, and a symmetry of the theory should take me from one physical state to another. In addition, the symmetry should have an inverse which undoes this transformation. This means that the physical Hilbert space should organize itself into representations of the symmetries of the theory. However, the local conformal transformations cannot have inverses, and so they do not form a group as far as I know. So why is it assumed that the states of a $CFT_2$ should organize themselves into representations of the Virasoro algebra? (I am aware $L_{n \leq -2}|0\rangle\neq 0$, $\langle 0|L_{n\geq 2} \neq 0$ so all but the $L_{0,\pm 1}$ are "spontaneously broken" on the in/out vacuum, but this is not relevant since the states of the theory are still assumed to assemble into Verma modules since it is assumed that the Virasoro was a symmetry of the theory which is just violated by the vacuum).</p> <p>My question basically boils down to: How can I have symmetries of a theory which are not invertible? I'd appreciate any comment's that clear up my confusion.</p>
g4256
[ 0.03391852602362633, -0.04196567088365555, -0.005046914331614971, -0.005903088022023439, 0.032133568078279495, 0.02562759816646576, 0.0555056594312191, 0.05325629934668541, -0.031239887699484825, -0.03823710232973099, -0.014430791139602661, 0.023686213418841362, -0.004103442188352346, 0.021577829495072365, -0.016969090327620506, -0.0012720871018245816, 0.03226073086261749, -0.0043233586475253105, 0.06489189714193344, -0.03199020028114319, -0.024313680827617645, -0.005988662131130695, 0.00008218151197070256, 0.017516985535621643, 0.03708556666970253, 0.0576876737177372, 0.07121748477220535, -0.005166192539036274, 0.033729344606399536, -0.026628315448760986, 0.07596340030431747, 0.04979800805449486, 0.03713255375623703, -0.10793357342481613, -0.04223989322781563, 0.014347017742693424, 0.04488547891378403, 0.012951374053955078, 0.025716060772538185, 0.04052799195051193, -0.02873988449573517, 0.0016086730174720287, -0.0022669502068310976, -0.023211341351270676, -0.0821048691868782, -0.00013451819540932775, 0.011008664965629578, 0.01741335541009903, -0.06484448164701462, -0.04104351997375488, 0.043490730226039886, 0.012886976823210716, 0.020003847777843475, -0.018023153766989708, -0.027788927778601646, 0.028128359466791153, 0.01059187576174736, 0.061068858951330185, 0.06826195120811462, 0.005569348577409983, -0.05996132642030716, -0.015977706760168076, 0.022080978378653526, 0.02122739516198635, 0.06908357888460159, -0.06800337135791779, -0.08050262182950974, -0.03566015511751175, -0.05155043676495552, 0.00828185211867094, 0.0016221744008362293, -0.027776984497904778, 0.05511734262108803, 0.015132058411836624, -0.010994586162269115, 0.0256525706499815, 0.008440282195806503, -0.01616857759654522, -0.003681525122374296, -0.028768397867679596, -0.014384572394192219, -0.013947183266282082, -0.02199382521212101, 0.010251980274915695, 0.07923385500907898, 0.002678210847079754, -0.003146690083667636, -0.0044501665979623795, -0.01824171282351017, 0.006305523216724396, -0.017516542226076126, -0.015961870551109314, 0.0901782363653183, 0.019688360393047333, -0.03916873037815094, 0.009787533432245255, 0.01100627426058054, -0.007728660944849253, -0.06138232350349426, -0.004283245652914047, -0.0338471457362175, 0.01802177168428898, 0.0052110375836491585, 0.0427732951939106, 0.013877893798053265, 0.01740371063351631, 0.05599632114171982, 0.00815513450652361, 0.03562360256910324, 0.0031656178180128336, -0.06482648849487305, 0.05318645387887955, -0.032168466597795486, 0.05145120620727539, -0.06706782430410385, -0.015879398211836815, 0.018882740288972855, -0.023489272221922874, 0.051945146173238754, -0.013243678957223892, 0.08700226247310638, -0.013179432600736618, 0.05457397922873497, 0.02339257299900055, 0.04620210826396942, -0.003050078870728612, -0.03594202920794487, 0.02308841049671173, 0.05242343246936798, -0.07705717533826828, 0.03211287781596184, 0.016754398122429848, -0.01389559917151928, 0.0312824621796608, 0.02257447876036167, -0.036459457129240036, -0.005646131467074156, 0.030619649216532707, 0.02911187894642353, -0.05378418043255806, -0.07429070770740509, 0.012882637791335583, 0.0029284281190484762, -0.015023556537926197, 0.0343581959605217, -0.058548454195261, 0.029542792588472366, -0.02075233869254589, 0.021862110123038292, -0.008361225947737694, -0.01595437526702881, 0.03719920292496681, 0.04741368815302849, -0.0425313301384449, -0.013699336908757687, 0.010309125296771526, 0.07771030068397522, -0.011608169414103031, 0.012002494186162949, 0.00776022020727396, 0.023623129352927208, 0.027953891083598137, -0.018471702933311462, 0.03361549228429794, -0.06824289262294769, 0.009819063358008862, 0.04021894931793213, 0.00939082633703947, 0.006312166340649128, -0.04294528439640999, -0.008207487873733044, 0.041682977229356766, -0.008920073509216309, 0.04990922659635544, 0.042083896696567535, 0.07605545222759247, -0.07490567117929459, -0.004176613874733448, 0.03581857308745384, 0.01348603144288063, -0.0747208446264267, -0.016520285978913307, -0.030449021607637405, -0.008589024655520916, -0.03553404659032822, 0.009565221145749092, -0.018393194302916527, 0.006094152573496103, -0.03756152465939522, 0.011091872118413448, 0.08990714699029922, 0.06469820439815521, -0.02406783401966095, 0.00773861026391387, -0.04359561577439308, 0.01187451183795929, 0.025586778298020363, -0.02996879816055298, -0.025314588099718094, -0.007306615822017193, 0.03213490918278694, -0.010837431997060776, 0.00875458586961031, -0.006707821972668171, 0.013914864510297775, 0.00846912618726492, -0.05136388912796974, -0.05479469895362854, -0.057034529745578766, 0.001348910853266716, 0.03414853662252426, -0.034997403621673584, 0.004359344951808453, -0.020158089697360992, 0.03278562054038048, -0.0052424161694943905, -0.04144739359617233, -0.0044220490381121635, -0.014282013289630413, -0.0021274485625326633, 0.012889508157968521, 0.006463422905653715, 0.04088602215051651, -0.008733369410037994, -0.027550507336854935, 0.03660634532570839, -0.057468608021736145, -0.020787948742508888, -0.03333147242665291, -0.01950712688267231, -0.06220751628279686, -0.014696029014885426, -0.02360885962843895, -0.02617221511900425, -0.028528105467557907, 0.026604196056723595, -0.04680566489696503, 0.05150908976793289, 0.07104812562465668, 0.012760736048221588, 0.005145358387380838, 0.02842411957681179, -0.041098520159721375, 0.031142698600888252, 0.017278650775551796, -0.010649154894053936, -0.010150131769478321, 0.039293188601732254, 0.008802138268947601, 0.05473506078124046, -0.036008816212415695, -0.02770538255572319, -0.1157512441277504, -0.013957425020635128, -0.03319958597421646, -0.05527971312403679, 0.023353049531579018, 0.023179916664958, -0.03556074947118759, -0.019012736156582832, 0.02591678313910961, -0.03852837532758713, -0.016087397933006287, 0.03693051636219025, -0.09468233585357666, -0.005733951460570097, 0.04510682821273804, 0.043315231800079346, 0.0006519139278680086, 0.004722672514617443, -0.00046067600487731397, 0.054893117398023605, -0.012239993549883366, 0.011619064025580883, -0.03805668279528618, -0.062394097447395325, 0.007713915314525366, -0.027760345488786697, -0.046521950513124466, 0.023953132331371307, -0.027671748772263527, -0.03602112457156181, -0.04231979325413704, -0.030088933184742928, 0.004527197685092688, -0.06681112945079803, -0.008587841875851154, -0.013139920309185982, 0.014957567676901817, 0.07287705689668655, 0.037620317190885544, -0.0064410255290567875, -0.021642712876200676, 0.04160361364483833, 0.014501811005175114, -0.04439105466008186, 0.0039564273320138454, 0.0024655195884406567, -0.02435467578470707, 0.03663763776421547, 0.008932361379265785, -0.01107269711792469, 0.03633744269609451, -0.0009646079852245748, 0.012076147831976414, -0.038469452410936356, -0.013416384346783161, -0.025330815464258194, -0.003235616721212864, -0.04084429889917374, -0.04261241480708122, -0.010468280874192715, 0.04966738075017929, -0.034061964601278305, 0.009924793615937233, 0.0063294111751019955, -0.04708699509501457, 0.056567661464214325, -0.04024693742394447, -0.026942681521177292, -0.07159553468227386, 0.05785626918077469, 0.04029414802789688, 0.014971115626394749, 0.04205187037587166, -0.009156476706266403, -0.036268994212150574, -0.02095363289117813, -0.018396995961666107, -0.07140032947063446, -0.007118546403944492, -0.031403664499521255, 0.006687138695269823, -0.03312521427869797, -0.005618544295430183, -0.038780298084020615, -0.1277153342962265, -0.03234415873885155, -0.002203980926424265, -0.05970073491334915, -0.04429854080080986, -0.011905570514500141, -0.01893959753215313, 0.04162275046110153, 0.053160618990659714, -0.022419458255171776, -0.03614038974046707, -0.007108830846846104, -0.06547748297452927, 0.030399374663829803, -0.023490533232688904, 0.0045333132147789, 0.0111860865727067, -0.007503763772547245, 0.021702274680137634, 0.05191083997488022, 0.03386872634291649, 0.04150020703673363, -0.02619384415447712, 0.017703289166092873, 0.01809265837073326, -0.01323724165558815, 0.02107115276157856, 0.02813946083188057, 0.011081854812800884, 0.01426517590880394, -0.006508896127343178, -0.06053267419338226, -0.007975506596267223, 0.04070279002189636, -0.0033157828729599714, -0.0413738377392292, -0.039514344185590744, -0.0016749945934861898, 0.020639220252633095, -0.0496768057346344, -0.021865470334887505, 0.027662595734000206, -0.09571386128664017, -0.02396474778652191, 0.02425314299762249, -0.010139092803001404, 0.043455783277750015, -0.029177678748965263, 0.0031916783191263676, 0.01830657571554184, -0.0453614816069603, 0.042208895087242126, -0.037718676030635834, -0.007031665649265051, 0.015581675805151463, -0.02026442624628544, -0.006977950222790241, -0.02123253606259823, 0.01881522499024868, 0.0012779866810888052, 0.03514973074197769, 0.055097293108701706, 0.008707752451300621, -0.012783617712557316, 0.01997358165681362, 0.030785204842686653, 0.03834689408540726, -0.03145361319184303, 0.004067626316100359, -0.008291289210319519, -0.018573740497231483, -0.030929524451494217, 0.02314792200922966, -0.010006364434957504, -0.034482065588235855, 0.03966808691620827, 0.028626078739762306, -0.07689663022756577, 0.0072312490083277225, 0.040780551731586456, -0.0030546432826668024, -0.05543268099427223, 0.013090546242892742, -0.024750635027885437, 0.009710156358778477, 0.003574472852051258, 0.03814167156815529, 0.0165119506418705, 0.06727942824363708, 0.04132027551531792, 0.07525933533906937, 0.00791146606206894, -0.022955596446990967, -0.020618734881281853, 0.010506074875593185, 0.015121403150260448, 0.0540686696767807, 0.0033359441440552473, -0.06006503850221634, -0.017451249063014984, -0.015262516215443611, 0.07592818140983582, -0.062075287103652954, 0.027292525395751, 0.07429774850606918, -0.005701387766748667, -0.07139304280281067, -0.014760304242372513, -0.01807137206196785, -0.016966097056865692, -0.03954794257879257, -0.0039506834000349045, 0.007850898429751396, 0.014113239012658596, -0.02530049718916416, 0.028778139501810074, 0.049848780035972595, -0.015791254118084908, -0.004288938362151384, 0.020480379462242126, -0.0026232858654111624, -0.006563497707247734, 0.004912043455988169, -0.033864885568618774, -0.01667831465601921, -0.04881397262215614, -0.009600397199392319, 0.00010513882443774492, 0.04551684111356735, 0.05305156484246254, -0.040372516959905624, -0.00993190798908472, -0.05958942696452141, -0.08292599022388458, 0.05101566016674042, 0.027372917160391808, -0.05919435992836952, -0.07634191960096359, 0.014115866273641586, 0.04678112640976906, -0.0015365256695076823, -0.04553576558828354, -0.011577666737139225, -0.025842508301138878, 0.00006802513235015795, 0.0547536164522171, 0.028749555349349976, 0.00765307666733861, 0.0171913281083107, -0.004066552966833115, 0.05195583403110504, 0.018097834661602974, 0.010895900428295135, -0.01439155638217926, -0.0035955822095274925, 0.04316966235637665, -0.034354694187641144, -0.0030447891913354397, 0.03203616291284561, 0.04054757207632065, -0.016177617013454437, -0.04919781908392906, -0.03009294904768467, -0.017594125121831894, -0.00658956915140152, 0.09232456237077713, 0.02158965915441513, 0.05171611160039902, 0.009079690091311932, 0.049676649272441864, 0.11454316973686218, 0.015657447278499603, -0.006624186411499977, 0.019101591780781746, 0.04009292647242546, -0.03329858183860779, -0.0222903024405241, 0.03547018766403198, 0.060863398015499115, -0.025028375908732414, 0.008801355957984924, -0.03300303965806961, -0.005511499010026455, -0.00991944968700409, -0.07969241589307785, -0.00043972546700388193, -0.0031927914824336767, -0.052058398723602295, 0.004226596560329199, 0.04098198562860489, -0.08993104845285416, -0.042454998940229416, 0.02179533988237381, 0.04002079367637634, 0.03745754808187485, -0.01151735894382, 0.055314697325229645, 0.012224714271724224, 0.029218386858701706, -0.030489051714539528, 0.026193544268608093, 0.02056444250047207, 0.056171104311943054, 0.013372046872973442, -0.00984245166182518, -0.06975410878658295, -0.016245072707533836, 0.014278317801654339, 0.010756897740066051, 0.017187416553497314, 0.024355752393603325, -0.0557410791516304, -0.008634394966065884, 0.03463684394955635, -0.0372040830552578, 0.04908394441008568, -0.041770581156015396, 0.016124974936246872, 0.05175255984067917, 0.005608549807220697, -0.07147962599992752, -0.01481054536998272, -0.007207730319350958, 0.0122142368927598, 0.007196539547294378, -0.0042007178999483585, 0.012667239643633366, -0.04213566705584526, -0.00021844352886546403, -0.03190844506025314, -0.014696945436298847, 0.03768259659409523, 0.10080821812152863, 0.03590966388583183, -0.025513067841529846, 0.04184345528483391, 0.05277685821056366, 0.003993488382548094, 0.012127182446420193, -0.01689608208835125, 0.007254315074533224, -0.01663380302488804, -0.009547713212668896, -0.0044815074652433395, -0.010870309546589851, -0.03571772947907448, 0.008961634710431099, -0.08423186093568802, -0.05240602046251297, 0.03424615412950516, -0.0022468569222837687, -0.06063012406229973, 0.019113877788186073, -0.0011449598241597414, -0.03923999145627022, 0.03574451804161072, 0.027006885036826134, 0.03697113320231438, 0.030553698539733887, 0.01745937392115593, -0.03912012279033661, 0.012951568700373173, 0.01842464506626129, -0.016912057995796204, 0.03580193966627121, 0.017808489501476288, 0.05091927945613861, 0.06921006739139557, -0.03128385171294212, 0.06221601739525795, -0.06769780814647675, 0.020307136699557304, 0.03510863333940506, 0.04099640995264053, 0.01189934741705656, 0.018112627789378166, -0.014462248422205448, 0.042751818895339966, 0.0017282378394156694, -0.006866688374429941, -0.058745644986629486, -0.040091339498758316, -0.027831342071294785, 0.013566198758780956, 0.03459689021110535, -0.0016058081528171897, -0.01955188438296318, 0.01855652406811714, -0.012782896868884563, 0.04824329912662506, 0.011917397379875183, 0.002024308545514941, 0.06969435513019562, 0.07616167515516281, -0.059327222406864166, -0.026029398664832115, 0.028200073167681694, 0.021819952875375748, 0.04438913241028786, -0.0069375247694551945, -0.04909510537981987, 0.011229453608393669, 0.013807243667542934, -0.03484165668487549, -0.058068882673978806, 0.004211024381220341, -0.011582143604755402, 0.005595195572823286, -0.030375301837921143, 0.023204801604151726, 0.010715367272496223, 0.024046141654253006, -0.055261071771383286, 0.04253261536359787, 0.01592867262661457, 0.024582207202911377, -0.04848247766494751, 0.008940080180764198, -0.058145783841609955, -0.057332683354616165, 0.023826006799936295, 0.06703599542379379, -0.00015609562979079783, -0.03647590056061745, -0.013453425839543343, -0.012626647017896175, 0.008383436128497124, -0.020890457555651665, -0.014554825611412525, 0.03434045612812042, -0.014221031218767166, -0.041404202580451965, 0.02306157536804676, -0.0327765978872776, -0.013197294436395168, -0.00895253848284483, 0.0022964307572692633, 0.0006260646623559296, 0.008143418468534946, -0.024125898256897926, 0.02230665273964405, 0.043968841433525085, 0.031160198152065277, 0.0007839207537472248, 0.011669181287288666, 0.050738509744405746, -0.0050384956412017345, -0.015772763639688492, -0.02988441474735737, 0.01736629195511341, 0.04510536417365074, -0.005794688127934933, -0.016162345185875893, 0.018524767830967903, 0.05443698540329933, 0.006916960701346397, -0.007916712202131748, -0.00036851863842457533, -0.03831321373581886, 0.03167020156979561, -0.010314900428056717, -0.03101389855146408, 0.00501236692070961, -0.005102499853819609, 0.04955558478832245, -0.019409416243433952, -0.030146120116114616, -0.028330422937870026, 0.034615449607372284, -0.04242948442697525, -0.016594775021076202, -0.045895323157310486, 0.0033913475926965475, -0.039979271590709686, -0.0643756166100502, 0.03223813697695732, 0.03575580567121506, 0.014717134647071362, 0.07671621441841125, -0.008452887646853924, -0.056200962513685226, 0.008880323730409145, 0.03363030031323433, 0.009712920524179935, 0.013848607428371906, 0.011938802897930145, -0.037622932344675064, -0.020171217620372772, -0.029620693996548653, -0.01750202290713787, 0.051814332604408264, -0.01228879950940609, -0.011888446286320686, 0.056751418858766556, -0.034443482756614685, 0.006052233278751373, -0.027150895446538925, 0.014292996376752853, -0.04052727669477463, 0.026403244584798813, -0.008854024112224579, -0.11796163022518158, 0.03164718300104141, -0.02443104423582554, 0.0056824213825166225, -0.009155705571174622, 0.015302504412829876, -0.04834992438554764, -0.043038949370384216, -0.025335248559713364, -0.027847744524478912, 0.019472016021609306, 0.014378107152879238, 0.004370880778878927, 0.051647040992975235, 0.06752322614192963, -0.004671464208513498, 0.03326163440942764, 0.0521995909512043, -0.01416865549981594, 0.0027959898579865694, -0.030540820211172104, 0.03624633699655533, 0.012355666607618332, -0.01828228123486042, 0.015155822038650513, 0.03077550418674946, 0.029347462579607964, -0.0308527834713459, -0.03852243348956108, -0.0360642708837986, 0.045792944729328156 ]
<p>I understand that a general interpretation of the $1/r^2$ interactions is that virtual particles are exchanged, and to conserve their flux through spheres of different radii, one must assume the inverse-square law. This fundamentally relies on the 3D nature of space.</p> <p>General relativity does not suppose that zero-mass particles exchanged. What is the interpretation, in GR, of the $1/r^2$ law for gravity? Is it come sort of flux that is conserved as well? Is it a postulate?</p> <p>Note that I am not really interested in a complete derivation (I don't know GR enough). A physical interpretation would be better.</p> <p>Related question: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/89/24774">Is Newton&#39;s Law of Gravity consistent with General Relativity?</a></p>
g4257
[ 0.03121342882514, -0.027466321364045143, -0.023319866508245468, 0.01712385006248951, 0.012545849196612835, 0.10633350908756256, 0.04546148329973221, -0.025474414229393005, -0.015680966898798943, 0.00407966086640954, 0.017634529620409012, 0.01644262857735157, 0.025103358551859856, -0.03027345798909664, -0.060895662754774094, 0.022467616945505142, 0.08263757079839706, -0.02434445172548294, -0.001092584803700447, 0.03490934893488884, -0.029861928895115852, -0.08836160600185394, -0.00225519435480237, -0.022319497540593147, -0.005957936868071556, -0.008626523427665234, 0.038530975580215454, 0.012239334173500538, -0.07649790495634079, 0.0014242002507671714, 0.03637413680553436, -0.018399948254227638, 0.025769833475351334, -0.05662311986088753, -0.037709251046180725, -0.014034776948392391, 0.021566929295659065, 0.011723192408680916, 0.01654600165784359, 0.0031608312856405973, 0.04577933996915817, -0.0187015850096941, 0.04034725949168205, 0.013882395811378956, 0.017783457413315773, 0.015258180908858776, -0.031511373817920685, -0.0025536115281283855, -0.016161169856786728, -0.028302816674113274, 0.001728742616251111, 0.07123631983995438, -0.01710781268775463, 0.05190605670213699, -0.0235973559319973, -0.013929308392107487, 0.039416588842868805, -0.000804554729256779, 0.01469297893345356, 0.02801721729338169, 0.02676982991397381, -0.005823366343975067, -0.002868860261514783, 0.043706636875867844, 0.030002400279045105, 0.0059234462678432465, -0.08308568596839905, -0.006934221368283033, 0.021349696442484856, -0.02331397496163845, 0.040503911674022675, -0.0021077352575957775, 0.00576382502913475, -0.014068414457142353, -0.007178090047091246, -0.004865797236561775, 0.0255291648209095, 0.05037969350814819, 0.023235900327563286, -0.018728794530034065, -0.07452188432216644, -0.05328135937452316, 0.008345997892320156, 0.010149660520255566, 0.11529365181922913, 0.0037859699223190546, 0.01562105119228363, -0.044241130352020264, -0.0050936173647642136, 0.05335965380072594, 0.010936081409454346, -0.0058747087605297565, 0.07773391902446747, -0.015967637300491333, -0.019503146409988403, 0.01717466302216053, -0.004533042665570974, 0.06011905521154404, -0.051886726170778275, -0.01954503357410431, -0.015802007168531418, -0.02494240552186966, 0.029814844951033592, 0.008369549177587032, 0.04622187465429306, 0.01593971438705921, 0.014676138758659363, 0.1020977720618248, 0.01835869811475277, -0.030118504539132118, -0.046097710728645325, 0.00023234676336869597, 0.011109339073300362, -0.01757001131772995, 0.013653993606567383, -0.04696336388587952, 0.05578729137778282, -0.044624414294958115, 0.03401941433548927, 0.081048384308815, 0.037031855434179306, 0.07287845760583878, -0.027851257473230362, 0.094179168343544, -0.044409189373254776, -0.04934201017022133, 0.019708877429366112, -0.025317881256341934, 0.02400100603699684, 0.02329520881175995, -0.007772918790578842, -0.031947121024131775, -0.016926541924476624, -0.015506412833929062, -0.05874556303024292, 0.011643212288618088, 0.018609479069709778, -0.0025980190839618444, -0.019626565277576447, -0.07426478713750839, -0.038964852690696716, -0.02534254640340805, -0.003796237986534834, -0.01396250631660223, -0.0037668768782168627, 0.02125716023147106, 0.005612188950181007, -0.024015087634325027, -0.009254928678274155, 0.03897557780146599, 0.030602218583226204, 0.11379484087228775, 0.03113500401377678, -0.002038598293438554, -0.0037350268103182316, -0.029600700363516808, -0.05566312372684479, -0.050269220024347305, -0.010652070865035057, 0.017560359090566635, 0.07869118452072144, -0.024739038199186325, -0.006507804151624441, 0.002807062119245529, -0.06658360362052917, 0.03757185861468315, -0.0000964230130193755, -0.10304583609104156, 0.02441723458468914, -0.08963827788829803, -0.04546869918704033, 0.03534002974629402, 0.0029731423128396273, 0.05854659900069237, -0.06721483170986176, -0.028866959735751152, -0.04024535045027733, -0.01318785548210144, -0.003687653224915266, -0.026735758408904076, -0.029621530324220657, -0.04326213151216507, 0.01282934844493866, 0.00845505204051733, 0.004912203643471003, -0.013790161348879337, 0.019093886017799377, 0.009434428997337818, -0.032613787800073624, -0.007699229754507542, -0.0162295363843441, 0.00014347719843499362, -0.02896248735487461, 0.045260194689035416, 0.008552420884370804, 0.02358986623585224, 0.005641946103423834, -0.030837608501315117, -0.031563468277454376, 0.10354398190975189, -0.0011801233049482107, 0.00918823853135109, 0.0605570450425148, 0.04290274903178215, 0.03446217626333237, -0.04594522714614868, 0.013163214549422264, -0.015622260980308056, 0.0407383069396019, -0.0033324738033115864, 0.033819012343883514, -0.06704943627119064, 0.07000650465488434, -0.05654757842421532, -0.039741430431604385, -0.01915866695344448, -0.002753639593720436, 0.045705072581768036, -0.00031638468499295413, -0.02722606249153614, -0.017342718318104744, 0.0017070386093109846, 0.04657572880387306, 0.038549602031707764, -0.002983354963362217, -0.01751638762652874, -0.04867003485560417, 0.011651946231722832, -0.004546449985355139, 0.07018333673477173, -0.04973376914858818, 0.03728404641151428, -0.04327112436294556, -0.028451459482312202, 0.02917439304292202, 0.059169840067625046, -0.03618801012635231, -0.0005318166804499924, 0.030247973278164864, 0.01055420283228159, 0.003537246957421303, 0.01341207418590784, -0.02434653602540493, 0.0009922173339873552, 0.05625543370842934, 0.012063568457961082, 0.006857030559331179, 0.0008962753927335143, 0.010952107608318329, -0.04252994805574417, 0.024182235822081566, 0.03770479932427406, -0.0497547872364521, -0.0065592750906944275, 0.019000617787241936, 0.0038197266403585672, -0.010394725017249584, 0.0025146116968244314, -0.0654786080121994, -0.07929850369691849, 0.016312068328261375, -0.056772783398628235, -0.026794152334332466, 0.06573966145515442, -0.026936296373605728, -0.0249310452491045, 0.006657978054136038, 0.0625729039311409, 0.006793386768549681, 0.013739979825913906, -0.007423448842018843, 0.0025746552273631096, -0.056135937571525574, 0.04149818792939186, -0.029361238703131676, 0.010836259461939335, 0.0272743571549654, -0.04928649961948395, 0.022106237709522247, 0.002293758327141404, 0.01011026930063963, 0.01590375415980816, 0.004080284386873245, -0.029666757211089134, 0.04432329162955284, -0.07566691190004349, -0.016122713685035706, 0.017888527363538742, -0.037249140441417694, 0.01080462709069252, 0.029175017029047012, 0.025987714529037476, 0.012129968963563442, 0.00803425069898367, -0.033322662115097046, 0.05515630170702934, 0.005192933604121208, 0.009237180463969707, -0.01183765847235918, 0.08019957691431046, -0.0048489682376384735, -0.040386930108070374, -0.005037812516093254, -0.0020137333776801825, -0.05108862370252609, -0.013838664628565311, -0.052163999527692795, -0.06697776168584824, 0.001520010526292026, -0.01213464979082346, 0.0010462201898917556, 0.059273552149534225, -0.020271947607398033, -0.03464612364768982, -0.02717830426990986, -0.03225412592291832, -0.02894037403166294, 0.00735322805121541, -0.04585381597280502, 0.021688271313905716, -0.03931485861539841, -0.03973257541656494, 0.07268624752759933, -0.05491260439157486, -0.013211271725594997, 0.0688071921467781, -0.074615977704525, -0.04963929206132889, 0.018080392852425575, 0.0036403287667781115, -0.00829770602285862, 0.007634644862264395, 0.001077307970263064, 0.00045362781384028494, -0.03159252926707268, -0.04514952003955841, -0.026866598054766655, -0.050025470554828644, 0.03743411600589752, -0.014845131896436214, -0.025652790442109108, 0.01381911151111126, 0.007168385200202465, 0.009615992195904255, 0.05002643167972565, 0.03397096320986748, -0.0043374462984502316, 0.026170087978243828, -0.005391839426010847, -0.020165594294667244, 0.015749506652355194, -0.026049906387925148, 0.0729447603225708, -0.017230957746505737, -0.030061054974794388, 0.028245488181710243, 0.01508395466953516, 0.073678158223629, -0.04211057722568512, -0.028633970767259598, 0.029529528692364693, -0.02044411562383175, -0.013348997570574284, 0.07393421977758408, 0.024063942953944206, -0.022304179146885872, -0.010813315398991108, -0.07322356849908829, 0.0012429693015292287, 0.028641920536756516, -0.008549765683710575, -0.02247997187077999, 0.002929779700934887, 0.10209378600120544, 0.062284186482429504, -0.03024231642484665, 0.06152290478348732, 0.018628466874361038, -0.006942118052393198, 0.0086359279230237, 0.05344320461153984, 0.0518774688243866, -0.01079070009291172, 0.00194909842684865, 0.030420562252402306, -0.018032249063253403, -0.06708309799432755, -0.00833637174218893, -0.036181189119815826, -0.02931518666446209, -0.033535297960042953, -0.005244041793048382, 0.0244681928306818, -0.023955736309289932, 0.033573001623153687, 0.016957558691501617, 0.0005998065462335944, 0.009445822797715664, 0.03358275815844536, 0.0003947880759369582, 0.000340036116540432, 0.061078738421201706, 0.012072088196873665, -0.05495116114616394, 0.03265296667814255, 0.0005002874531783164, 0.019727086648344994, -0.06609373539686203, -0.015875352546572685, 0.028249042108654976, -0.010311078280210495, 0.05497611314058304, 0.0199722982943058, -0.019690321758389473, 0.02220282144844532, 0.03352421522140503, -0.05000022053718567, -0.021803999319672585, 0.04142843931913376, -0.01523608062416315, 0.05068495497107506, 0.05593525990843773, 0.009037693962454796, -0.01697118952870369, 0.024503938853740692, 0.0540020652115345, 0.04947013407945633, -0.012861436232924461, -0.03699427843093872, 0.00003262559403083287, 0.021345550194382668, -0.011491174809634686, -0.03286577761173248, -0.0059284428134560585, -0.09994110465049744, 0.0030560074374079704, -0.027159396559000015, 0.041719336062669754, 0.014419586397707462, 0.032294221222400665, 0.0793328508734703, 0.0031720856204628944, -0.016474053263664246, -0.031449094414711, 0.013568553142249584, -0.0019616596400737762, -0.0225386843085289, -0.0016918968176469207, 0.023534400388598442, -0.004095785785466433, -0.002374400617554784, -0.005946184508502483, 0.00021955835109110922, -0.05520682781934738, 0.011671943590044975, 0.04136225953698158, -0.021282268688082695, 0.025647515431046486, 0.02891121432185173, -0.03856644779443741, -0.05616886541247368, 0.03373204171657562, 0.05994848534464836, 0.04910200461745262, 0.01073777861893177, -0.030455665662884712, -0.08874088525772095, 0.014532501809298992, -0.024400757625699043, -0.035554446280002594, -0.051145948469638824, -0.006018053740262985, -0.022290866822004318, -0.013553757220506668, 0.03139744699001312, 0.010304335504770279, 0.014960567466914654, -0.013269403949379921, 0.05309602618217468, -0.03045235387980938, -0.01660715788602829, -0.011180172674357891, 0.05262059345841408, 0.007667615078389645, 0.011974024586379528, 0.026035159826278687, 0.014527503401041031, 0.007608629297465086, -0.0065698809921741486, -0.0027548610232770443, -0.018994882702827454, -0.03594072908163071, -0.016350310295820236, -0.015390285290777683, 0.002147486200556159, -0.01709388568997383, 0.018011273816227913, -0.06564969569444656, -0.01861293986439705, -0.02930760197341442, -0.0530889630317688, -0.017053265124559402, 0.03745759278535843, 0.018009541556239128, -0.06353483349084854, 0.050944648683071136, -0.013851090334355831, 0.0010711740469560027, -0.07047227770090103, 0.006743947044014931, -0.011478777043521404, -0.051699478179216385, 0.022034090012311935, 0.001328010344877839, 0.04036641865968704, 0.018246561288833618, -0.006956214085221291, 0.04333110526204109, 0.025344548746943474, 0.025296106934547424, -0.00792744942009449, -0.005077276844531298, 0.007482720073312521, -0.0028355144895613194, -0.008296220563352108, 0.022388599812984467, -0.018269222229719162, 0.030682826414704323, 0.06695040315389633, 0.05480048432946205, -0.017078500241041183, -0.0357966385781765, -0.0036069247871637344, 0.0357159748673439, -0.0338478609919548, -0.056099265813827515, -0.010931368917226791, 0.010515457950532436, 0.07543270289897919, -0.019374951720237732, -0.05087454244494438, 0.06403008848428726, -0.04554405063390732, 0.03849417716264725, -0.06186053156852722, 0.034576911479234695, -0.021948395296931267, -0.016689615324139595, 0.05826665833592415, -0.024256637319922447, 0.0028235893696546555, -0.02875446155667305, -0.02922072261571884, 0.025137245655059814, 0.03656052425503731, -0.0010755344992503524, 0.0015423926524817944, -0.01834285818040371, 0.037464939057826996, -0.01075178012251854, -0.011887419037520885, 0.05630974844098091, 0.03849956393241882, -0.007138432003557682, -0.008897065185010433, -0.02577550709247589, 0.021532662212848663, -0.043920647352933884, 0.04876751825213432, 0.03067133203148842, -0.05031433328986168, 0.023070046678185463, 0.021033553406596184, -0.023641521111130714, 0.017913589254021645, -0.03784773498773575, -0.02052561566233635, -0.05368858203291893, -0.025708256289362907, 0.013249804265797138, 0.0922352597117424, -0.01521487720310688, 0.049425091594457626, -0.07373682409524918, -0.06317000091075897, 0.041697438806295395, -0.0015005589229986072, 0.004394908901304007, 0.02507900632917881, 0.009729652665555477, 0.048627376556396484, -0.026343591511249542, -0.033125244081020355, -0.027254754677414894, -0.013238486833870411, -0.06435579061508179, 0.008536559529602528, -0.01185484230518341, -0.016527675092220306, -0.00800625141710043, -0.018353402614593506, 0.022886091843247414, -0.020165959373116493, -0.004698777571320534, 0.04443827643990517, -0.0800994411110878, -0.06775020807981491, -0.03671616315841675, -0.04334495961666107, 0.04623819887638092, -0.018950078636407852, 0.042047739028930664, -0.016690533608198166, 0.007345485966652632, 0.04427148401737213, -0.07546555250883102, -0.04187444970011711, 0.015105903148651123, -0.011295800097286701, -0.0782046914100647, -0.0281211007386446, 0.002643078565597534, -0.010023524053394794, -0.03060845285654068, 0.027270782738924026, -0.02205020934343338, 0.016303759068250656, 0.03673958778381348, 0.05933760851621628, 0.02394610270857811, -0.01669144630432129, 0.054861944168806076, -0.022039128467440605, 0.008977150544524193, 0.018726693466305733, -0.009482732973992825, -0.013565189205110073, -0.029468784108757973, 0.02006208710372448, 0.011852349154651165, -0.03273303806781769, -0.00006919634324731305, 0.047392092645168304, 0.020488351583480835, -0.027451304718852043, -0.04339385777711868, 0.03185464069247246, 0.020916054025292397, -0.0290349330753088, 0.05151338502764702, -0.05664946883916855, -0.017243891954421997, 0.019545912742614746, -0.04111766815185547, -0.010239267721772194, -0.009873737581074238, -0.05216974765062332, 0.019635876640677452, 0.01750420406460762, -0.10835564136505127, -0.028953872621059418, -0.024461058899760246, 0.015377290546894073, 0.04997304454445839, -0.005053375847637653, 0.006775540299713612, 0.02594686485826969, -0.03871545568108559, 0.014014587737619877, -0.02273935079574585, 0.027074597775936127, -0.05982425808906555, 0.019222071394324303, 0.011794139631092548, 0.00022754987003281713, -0.04035849869251251, -0.03206350654363632, 0.02206992544233799, 0.015858333557844162, 0.02603222243487835, 0.057064030319452286, 0.022684933617711067, 0.04056013375520706, 0.06119119003415108, -0.026113271713256836, 0.020037807524204254, 0.03902743011713028, 0.010373263619840145, -0.06389248371124268, 0.06151999905705452, -0.020984509959816933, 0.0005868367734365165, -0.002370536793023348, 0.024054819718003273, 0.0012628448894247413, -0.031555768102407455, 0.03874461352825165, 0.0355987511575222, 0.0008870556484907866, 0.023576192557811737, 0.0005055760848335922, -0.02252337522804737, -0.028680656105279922, 0.005972215440124273, 0.028011884540319443, 0.00527068180963397, 0.02365233562886715, -0.047379378229379654, -0.02888531982898712, -0.016057008877396584, 0.022729285061359406, -0.033002354204654694, 0.03669723495841026, -0.0015714984619989991, 0.026987358927726746, 0.010114199481904507, -0.010024553164839745, 0.003753404598683119, 0.025344472378492355, -0.0653565302491188, -0.012900876812636852, 0.01285616960376501, -0.047139331698417664, -0.06331905722618103, -0.06946158409118652, -0.018893247470259666, -0.010294395498931408, -0.00139060546644032, -0.003419472835958004, 0.04522784799337387, 0.003992384299635887, 0.017551131546497345, -0.031717680394649506, 0.015053457580506802, 0.011269799433648586, 0.09597759693861008, 0.002610114635899663, -0.01164295431226492, -0.0037291531916707754, 0.03816346824169159, 0.02395571582019329, -0.035207752138376236, 0.014354608952999115, -0.03462300822138786, -0.05042645335197449, 0.0006619948544539511, -0.005851030815392733, 0.048761021345853806, -0.0016807174542918801, -0.050182927399873734, -0.0019421273609623313, 0.028670471161603928, 0.03640618547797203, 0.0030618770979344845, 0.056765392422676086, -0.11636274307966232, -0.00430441927164793, 0.0010792796965688467, -0.02998872846364975, -0.004791140090674162, 0.03148059919476509, -0.041002221405506134, 0.0005649889935739338, 0.030069351196289062, 0.020642070099711418, -0.002753904554992914, -0.011639251373708248, 0.08606664091348648 ]
<p>This in the context of the AdS/CFT correspondence. I am reading <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep--th/9905111.pdf" rel="nofollow">this</a> review on AdS/CFT Aharony et. al. (The MAGOO review) The abstract can be found <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-th/9905111" rel="nofollow">here</a></p> <p>Equation (2.50) of the above paper lists the $R$-symmetry groups of extended supersymmetries in $AdS_{p+2}$. He uses the following notation for the group: </p> <blockquote> <p>$AdS_5: SU(2,2 | {\cal N}/2),~{\cal N}=2,4,6,8$</p> </blockquote> <p>Can anyone explain this notation to me?</p>
g4258
[ -0.03062567301094532, 0.04120595380663872, -0.030382856726646423, 0.01225566677749157, -0.012707406654953957, 0.014128172770142555, 0.04002077877521515, 0.02173379249870777, -0.011481561698019505, -0.012725585140287876, -0.026991449296474457, 0.04831177368760109, 0.04625127464532852, 0.0047616055235266685, 0.005095367785543203, 0.026510082185268402, 0.04828546941280365, 0.018668867647647858, -0.00998158659785986, -0.007671191822737455, -0.012381166219711304, -0.03796219080686569, 0.012215807102620602, -0.058445002883672714, 0.05145115777850151, 0.012963379733264446, 0.05234985798597336, -0.0756758451461792, -0.05768407881259918, -0.020840588957071304, 0.03798475116491318, 0.07262972742319107, 0.02177799679338932, -0.006451804656535387, -0.03388277441263199, -0.09410058706998825, 0.08726866543292999, 0.013944768346846104, 0.016528164967894554, 0.022508688271045685, -0.01656223274767399, 0.045172978192567825, -0.0012144256616011262, -0.010923915542662144, -0.06702076643705368, -0.03619447723031044, -0.02871205098927021, 0.03484022989869118, -0.020110612735152245, -0.0741749256849289, 0.04380417987704277, 0.03433988615870476, 0.025221385061740875, -0.015049203298985958, 0.03557462990283966, 0.024931631982326508, -0.0013321774313226342, -0.0022221121471375227, -0.01615920290350914, 0.06751736253499985, -0.009914382360875607, 0.045503582805395126, -0.014505679719150066, 0.03340689837932587, 0.07066117227077484, 0.026171009987592697, 0.0058562117628753185, -0.002979954471811652, -0.02260817401111126, -0.028972283005714417, 0.00776499742642045, -0.007532024290412664, 0.03246057406067848, 0.011756385676562786, -0.020605603232979774, 0.05271174758672714, 0.013987770304083824, 0.0004966274136677384, -0.0035775587894022465, -0.03139028325676918, -0.007294138427823782, -0.029281344264745712, 0.011300702579319477, 0.009656758978962898, -0.00433599716052413, -0.03456960991024971, -0.03879856318235397, 0.0340900681912899, -0.008073839358985424, -0.010140964761376381, 0.017783695831894875, -0.034380439668893814, -0.011191842146217823, -0.019120458513498306, 0.011317459866404533, 0.04216291010379791, 0.029307376593351364, -0.016554536297917366, -0.11115612089633942, 0.011486988514661789, -0.03809256851673126, -0.0075424653477966785, 0.06347313523292542, 0.01024828851222992, 0.041984207928180695, 0.005024729296565056, 0.03545377776026726, -0.02220752462744713, -0.023572759702801704, -0.0003231078735552728, -0.06317905336618423, 0.048243969678878784, -0.03438763692975044, 0.003449881449341774, -0.0856873020529747, 0.03258140757679939, 0.05365612730383873, -0.009077857248485088, 0.007521221414208412, -0.04419897869229317, 0.04491196572780609, 0.031295064836740494, -0.006877625826746225, 0.039418283849954605, -0.02833293192088604, -0.03830518573522568, 0.033060796558856964, -0.0006649742717854679, 0.06352323293685913, -0.05322800576686859, -0.01676068641245365, -0.010500829666852951, -0.00962644349783659, 0.0046106609515845776, -0.02203661948442459, 0.004613734781742096, 0.050191160291433334, -0.03437064588069916, -0.01499231904745102, -0.031041104346513748, -0.07971354573965073, 0.025290323421359062, 0.011886581778526306, -0.008221408352255821, -0.0165269635617733, -0.0371292382478714, 0.007988190278410912, -0.04415254667401314, -0.014141779392957687, -0.027574438601732254, 0.010215959511697292, 0.01608007587492466, -0.01335995364934206, 0.005357393063604832, -0.03404095768928528, -0.024428419768810272, 0.019681140780448914, -0.028521524742245674, 0.0014988940674811602, 0.054376691579818726, 0.034723490476608276, 0.03164776414632797, -0.012700030580163002, 0.03510706126689911, -0.12552480399608612, 0.02423999458551407, 0.003807053668424487, -0.011316665448248386, -0.016610918566584587, -0.016826380044221878, -0.06240745261311531, 0.014937342144548893, 0.056567735970020294, 0.04643804207444191, 0.042370736598968506, 0.07773485779762268, 0.039345599710941315, 0.05973794311285019, 0.033896028995513916, 0.021226486191153526, -0.07591111212968826, -0.008987235836684704, 0.0017856450285762548, 0.044312916696071625, -0.020724976435303688, 0.04900136590003967, -0.019061801955103874, -0.014901976101100445, -0.0385013073682785, 0.00532855000346899, 0.014399774372577667, 0.03952258452773094, -0.001897133537568152, 0.05481966957449913, -0.05621659755706787, 0.06289561837911606, -0.0020131284836679697, -0.02697371318936348, -0.030843401327729225, -0.00034300456172786653, 0.0470355860888958, 0.025600556284189224, 0.00008202268509194255, -0.023558685556054115, 0.06900375336408615, 0.023544512689113617, -0.07364286482334137, -0.0769561380147934, 0.002513714600354433, 0.0288652703166008, 0.008104832842946053, 0.005479786079376936, -0.01895977556705475, -0.023838596418499947, -0.011475860141217709, -0.03393293917179108, -0.0189902912825346, -0.011754629202187061, -0.02719092182815075, 0.0704054906964302, -0.014964132569730282, -0.009736951440572739, 0.024079855531454086, 0.060308247804641724, -0.041460152715444565, 0.038590457290410995, -0.02206503041088581, 0.03601871058344841, 0.041302792727947235, -0.02484838292002678, -0.023966947570443153, 0.004771240521222353, 0.005841539707034826, -0.02167326956987381, -0.03982832655310631, -0.019863534718751907, 0.01357272919267416, 0.0746893659234047, 0.061135485768318176, 0.02228056639432907, -0.03963971883058548, 0.04204018414020538, -0.059662993997335434, 0.09210947155952454, 0.01565278135240078, 0.04364519566297531, 0.05480007454752922, 0.007336486130952835, -0.03496062010526657, 0.03347164765000343, 0.009738556109368801, 0.010388820432126522, 0.005833572708070278, -0.026278890669345856, 0.03952017426490784, -0.03214462473988533, 0.020719828084111214, 0.013326738029718399, -0.04401030391454697, 0.04235004261136055, -0.0022332295775413513, -0.006977703422307968, 0.046281684190034866, -0.024490542709827423, -0.02928321808576584, -0.035922806710004807, 0.008286654017865658, -0.02218618616461754, 0.02944374643266201, -0.02268054336309433, -0.02036675252020359, 0.07594000548124313, -0.0006721279351040721, -0.05758260190486908, -0.05056523159146309, -0.019528796896338463, -0.003433008212596178, -0.03599383309483528, 0.03369000181555748, -0.022473318502306938, 0.031185660511255264, -0.014623572118580341, 0.04422631114721298, 0.009893449954688549, 0.015517405234277248, -0.005257553420960903, -0.012367472983896732, 0.026917140930891037, 0.00003065600685658865, 0.005389141384512186, 0.0217321515083313, -0.04156947508454323, -0.029565218836069107, 0.01703280210494995, 0.020498566329479218, 0.023444723337888718, -0.005524256732314825, -0.028785860165953636, -0.04281727224588394, 0.06345823407173157, 0.010957895778119564, 0.001205849926918745, 0.01025186013430357, -0.0079072006046772, 0.01235504075884819, -0.000615751720033586, -0.026324592530727386, -0.043998248875141144, 0.025666844099760056, -0.027831245213747025, -0.025582067668437958, 0.02407740242779255, 0.011815615929663181, -0.0016295042587444186, -0.02456597425043583, 0.08227410912513733, -0.04034227877855301, -0.027356214821338654, 0.017286568880081177, -0.06122947111725807, -0.036964960396289825, -0.017475394532084465, 0.040967367589473724, 0.05899597704410553, 0.028992321342229843, -0.0077053760178387165, -0.035181086510419846, -0.03862082213163376, 0.004729337524622679, -0.014678998850286007, -0.00567811680957675, -0.062442898750305176, 0.031780291348695755, -0.06107150390744209, -0.07145417481660843, 0.018351130187511444, -0.016075564548373222, 0.03474612534046173, -0.004789379425346851, -0.010460040532052517, 0.01859082281589508, 0.0011426660930737853, 0.014586018398404121, 0.011950764805078506, 0.029828526079654694, -0.004229430574923754, -0.012893646955490112, 0.0006368605536408722, 0.013070656917989254, -0.02439703606069088, -0.04979037493467331, 0.08624947816133499, 0.05575006827712059, -0.030129430815577507, -0.041433487087488174, 0.04529118165373802, 0.05636579170823097, 0.025415737181901932, -0.005175179336220026, 0.004536713007837534, 0.022492872551083565, 0.007756362669169903, -0.001160592189989984, 0.059547245502471924, 0.030240068212151527, 0.03846241533756256, 0.0023552326019853354, -0.0639931932091713, -0.0438448041677475, -0.01240910030901432, 0.0858723446726799, -0.07086041569709778, 0.011152612045407295, -0.02969023957848549, 0.035668209195137024, -0.04669352248311043, -0.010984865948557854, -0.052049871534109116, -0.029922351241111755, -0.02240128628909588, 0.02810661308467388, -0.032752297818660736, 0.04399964213371277, -0.0011354415910318494, 0.019212311133742332, 0.0010065202368423343, -0.01614639163017273, 0.025720946490764618, -0.06603933125734329, -0.032760705798864365, -0.0012642130022868514, 0.04171860218048096, 0.011769762262701988, -0.028118761256337166, 0.02485184744000435, 0.0024522445164620876, 0.04007721319794655, 0.013185406103730202, -0.027451802045106888, 0.049567051231861115, -0.024072643369436264, 0.03232989087700844, 0.02467561513185501, -0.003250101348385215, -0.03443313017487526, -0.015435329638421535, 0.015096182934939861, -0.023658771067857742, 0.047878142446279526, 0.004027619492262602, -0.04433882236480713, 0.020436415448784828, 0.017855973914265633, -0.0148114999756217, 0.04416486993432045, 0.032795924693346024, 0.0042818342335522175, -0.05740094929933548, -0.008239570073783398, 0.008875792846083641, -0.011533793993294239, 0.00493679428473115, 0.024475395679473877, 0.008483491837978363, -0.004220000468194485, -0.0013979130890220404, -0.006677128840237856, 0.019296156242489815, 0.023447735235095024, -0.014472896233201027, 0.002219507237896323, -0.0010492113651707768, -0.014940005727112293, 0.03153836354613304, -0.07757484167814255, -0.0038464684039354324, -0.03816288709640503, -0.002869892166927457, -0.022646596655249596, 0.0672927051782608, 0.06160847842693329, -0.002595775993540883, 0.0006862349691800773, -0.01866324059665203, -0.008348079398274422, -0.053981926292181015, 0.026247259229421616, -0.014613588340580463, 0.04779043048620224, 0.038916464895009995, -0.05057946592569351, 0.0058487835340201855, 0.10804340243339539, -0.012477071955800056, -0.0380464568734169, -0.035463232547044754, 0.028536804020404816, -0.012502714991569519, 0.06347913295030594, 0.001137619954533875, -0.10055427998304367, -0.008176768198609352, -0.0047577121295034885, -0.0339236743748188, 0.06713906675577164, 0.08309146761894226, 0.03639626130461693, -0.04435109347105026, -0.009113582782447338, -0.03404995799064636, 0.011705143377184868, -0.0095783406868577, -0.002764458069577813, -0.01955369859933853, 0.012512448243796825, 0.058245014399290085, -0.02894875593483448, -0.053438473492860794, 0.009662010706961155, 0.06836511194705963, -0.003282466670498252, 0.044361915439367294, 0.01927989162504673, -0.04633193090558052, 0.00299152173101902, -0.007359370123594999, 0.031048087403178215, 0.007645811419934034, -0.05093657225370407, -0.015112276189029217, -0.04219823330640793, -0.032570961862802505, -0.02757122926414013, -0.029553569853305817, -0.03285437077283859, 0.10307851433753967, 0.0682339072227478, -0.03922956809401512, 0.009007901884615421, -0.03086858056485653, 0.03892125189304352, 0.08290650695562363, 0.049757279455661774, 0.04645727574825287, 0.03795149549841881, 0.06186310946941376, 0.05246373638510704, 0.003309287130832672, 0.0333528146147728, -0.030424198135733604, 0.00518390815705061, -0.030063962563872337, 0.02369212545454502, 0.0383748784661293, 0.026444008573889732, 0.0237739197909832, -0.028460264205932617, 0.03311166912317276, -0.04328983277082443, -0.04490474611520767, -0.02088489942252636, -0.011323723010718822, -0.0038459475617855787, -0.0738581046462059, 0.0250522643327713, 0.002375649055466056, -0.04985618591308594, -0.024982308968901634, 0.07782499492168427, 0.029626619070768356, 0.011020916514098644, -0.05173613131046295, 0.0732489675283432, 0.02201458252966404, 0.06245695427060127, -0.08976387977600098, 0.004778637550771236, -0.10217874497175217, 0.028885148465633392, -0.00011818642087746412, -0.011722700670361519, -0.038879502564668655, -0.02759157121181488, 0.06572654098272324, 0.027728738263249397, -0.004206609912216663, -0.016269752755761147, -0.029216613620519638, -0.02573860064148903, 0.025741122663021088, 0.03433538228273392, 0.005472095217555761, 0.02148718386888504, 0.0054186261259019375, 0.028378432616591454, -0.0022830390371382236, 0.006901587825268507, -0.013664007186889648, 0.023803798481822014, -0.05227523669600487, -0.0003120572364423424, -0.00966066773980856, -0.022018147632479668, -0.002058660378679633, -0.01699282042682171, -0.01700334995985031, 0.05192723125219345, -0.038021206855773926, 0.02396530844271183, 0.010395204648375511, -0.056069955229759216, 0.07378503680229187, 0.02382035180926323, -0.009641352109611034, -0.029335910454392433, 0.04132112115621567, 0.02168041467666626, -0.02808511070907116, 0.009240696206688881, 0.02285556122660637, -0.06724489480257034, -0.05098206177353859, -0.03641833737492561, -0.016846226528286934, -0.024583956226706505, 0.005006974563002586, -0.04867323860526085, -0.03577997535467148, 0.06251717358827591, -0.0796407088637352, -0.028197187930345535, 0.008891167119145393, -0.027581673115491867, 0.07217756658792496, -0.04202920198440552, 0.011897694319486618, 0.012827851809561253, 0.04316363483667374, 0.02446848154067993, 0.008444066159427166, 0.051364146173000336, 0.05810672417283058, 0.03911091759800911, 0.00525281485170126, 0.04950772598385811, 0.013328537344932556, -0.011497508734464645, -0.013455091044306755, 0.004610903095453978, 0.047944389283657074, 0.004727878607809544, 0.004700932186096907, -0.013145530596375465, 0.06294159591197968, -0.020164888352155685, -0.021465228870511055, 0.0028467692900449038, 0.005073701962828636, -0.03334230184555054, 0.005174011457711458, 0.019228119403123856, -0.010774292051792145, -0.044533222913742065, -0.016492512077093124, 0.02810734324157238, 0.07316922396421432, 0.010507396422326565, -0.0023747782688587904, 0.008003337308764458, -0.0015077561838552356, -0.0000613859374425374, -0.007986821234226227, 0.04629727825522423, -0.022002635523676872, -0.025529704988002777, -0.002226494252681732, -0.08231475204229355, 0.003942951560020447, 0.04043776914477348, 0.04625263065099716, -0.04067416489124298, 0.0258597694337368, 0.021857788786292076, -0.0338752344250679, -0.009248834103345871, -0.033891815692186356, -0.021890811622142792, 0.03654192388057709, -0.020368754863739014, 0.006378832273185253, 0.01624039188027382, -0.07269027829170227, -0.04394863173365593, 0.027843857184052467, -0.03866216912865639, -0.01568397879600525, -0.01794772408902645, 0.0048674969002604485, -0.0027001542039215565, -0.03409425541758537, -0.04476488381624222, 0.0284584891051054, -0.002186486264690757, 0.0016899866750463843, -0.037817616015672684, 0.004103129729628563, -0.0017969364998862147, 0.03273765370249748, 0.051903825253248215, -0.06289331614971161, -0.022556284442543983, 0.006175705697387457, 0.02438347227871418, -0.03683636337518692, 0.022277547046542168, -0.03415082395076752, 0.004958742298185825, 0.0032412870787084103, -0.02428276836872101, -0.012000284157693386, -0.0201944001019001, -0.03378516063094139, -0.024286748841404915, -0.012132140807807446, -0.05143672972917557, 0.05940135940909386, 0.016519516706466675, 0.0369388721883297, 0.010574238374829292, 0.03516564145684242, -0.004069966729730368, -0.004337477032095194, 0.009520217776298523, 0.018393956124782562, -0.036360494792461395, -0.003060858929529786, -0.03338735178112984, 0.02272891066968441, -0.026317300274968147, 0.008652808144688606, 0.06732449680566788, -0.03426232933998108, -0.058703355491161346, 0.04468740150332451, 0.029126934707164764, 0.010944369249045849, 0.010979928076267242, -0.023034386336803436, -0.020268714055418968, -0.05490585044026375, -0.02851969376206398, 0.01688765361905098, 0.009813153184950352, 0.020038491114974022, 0.0459260568022728, 0.02636285312473774, -0.007748379837721586, -0.02727203443646431, -0.002804021118208766, 0.00736197829246521, -0.026923973113298416, -0.02919280342757702, 0.005079227965325117, -0.05781977251172066, -0.1066216379404068, -0.06365642696619034, 0.0017590937204658985, 0.010813801549375057, 0.006510477513074875, 0.019800381734967232, -0.04146802797913551, 0.012345552444458008, -0.05307919904589653, 0.002030345145612955, -0.03077203780412674, 0.017909418791532516, -0.05256042629480362, -0.08215674012899399, 0.07580967992544174, 0.02823619544506073, 0.005497495178133249, -0.03820328041911125, 0.01069142296910286, -0.003488286165520549, -0.04474128037691116, -0.008566438220441341, -0.04402250424027443, -0.043089017271995544, 0.012785677798092365, -0.04178549349308014, 0.08052481710910797, 0.07565087825059891, -0.01964026503264904, 0.014581008814275265, 0.04521024599671364, -0.04546979442238808, 0.05675659701228142, -0.03585616499185562, 0.0062141441740095615, -0.006291333120316267, -0.0047136940993368626, -0.018273932859301567, -0.008746425621211529, -0.01616147719323635, 0.02034659869968891, -0.03099086880683899, -0.07661693543195724, -0.004053768701851368 ]
<p>Is it possible to quick freeze half of an unopened bottle of water or soda by putting half of the bottle in a subfreezing solution liquid nitrogen or other solution without freezing the whole bottle?</p>
g4259
[ 0.026727529242634773, -0.0019728101324290037, 0.027321387082338333, 0.05059189349412918, 0.031556904315948486, -0.004616230260580778, -0.017932120710611343, -0.006631611380726099, -0.027299709618091583, -0.015536499209702015, -0.025313641875982285, -0.001080917427316308, -0.02252965047955513, -0.013420918956398964, -0.010179026052355766, 0.07715573906898499, 0.003221371443942189, -0.037916604429483414, -0.021402884274721146, 0.05638894811272621, 0.009240531362593174, -0.0019282305147498846, 0.03633850812911987, -0.012941727414727211, -0.10139983147382736, 0.025975817814469337, 0.004609764087945223, 0.03760671243071556, -0.08761896938085556, 0.050069790333509445, -0.06927742809057236, 0.019659599289298058, -0.012400896288454533, 0.0036520827561616898, -0.055711980909109116, -0.053569693118333817, 0.043580133467912674, 0.034934576600790024, 0.009110085666179657, -0.027513306587934494, -0.01993393898010254, 0.04982350394129753, 0.03213002160191536, -0.05232398957014084, 0.030271578580141068, 0.03266380727291107, 0.0016747049521654844, -0.009997589513659477, -0.05830991268157959, -0.0551532506942749, 0.002287266543135047, 0.005143741611391306, -0.04128468409180641, 0.008984396234154701, -0.05616128072142601, 0.02816695161163807, 0.021703381091356277, 0.019634312018752098, 0.034261513501405716, 0.02858535759150982, 0.004856991581618786, 0.0022371273953467607, 0.06769205629825592, 0.042185042053461075, -0.04195508360862732, 0.011853596195578575, -0.03224226087331772, -0.00889083556830883, 0.09623092412948608, 0.030744411051273346, -0.040923140943050385, 0.018893824890255928, -0.011597871780395508, -0.018838997930288315, -0.005447269883006811, 0.016974927857518196, -0.059854183346033096, 0.05394727736711502, 0.038600705564022064, -0.023778608068823814, 0.017377257347106934, 0.02069445326924324, -0.05764792487025261, 0.009610521607100964, -0.01515110768377781, -0.0014225048944354057, -0.07367799431085587, 0.01318349502980709, -0.03388158604502678, 0.003959413152188063, -0.017871608957648277, -0.04235386848449707, -0.01937195099890232, 0.007896773517131805, 0.08959369361400604, 0.01724870316684246, 0.0403631255030632, 0.008978066965937614, 0.004922869149595499, -0.0034213135950267315, -0.032194834202528, -0.06814435869455338, 0.010427771136164665, -0.02419637329876423, -0.028846807777881622, -0.00045792432501912117, 0.03141860291361809, -0.017130713909864426, -0.033040422946214676, 0.0437360554933548, -0.019210776314139366, -0.04378689080476761, -0.012691684998571873, 0.02981293760240078, -0.00338504696264863, 0.058634620159864426, 0.05222537741065025, 0.000027653120923787355, 0.06653197109699249, 0.01691313274204731, 0.016537312418222427, 0.07460609078407288, 0.03571975231170654, 0.01309969276189804, 0.010617764666676521, -0.009173652157187462, -0.0010496748145669699, -0.003276197938248515, 0.03508686646819115, -0.018767694011330605, -0.04963212460279465, 0.0034649153240025043, -0.03254397213459015, -0.06415513902902603, -0.043647587299346924, 0.022317366674542427, -0.05077238380908966, -0.01849658042192459, 0.026874762028455734, -0.04003174975514412, 0.025120506063103676, 0.011647957377135754, -0.006292922887951136, 0.10024578124284744, -0.014153541065752506, 0.0062737055122852325, -0.0644146278500557, 0.02219383791089058, -0.010943897068500519, 0.01712765358388424, -0.057676658034324646, 0.014821373857557774, 0.026667261496186256, 0.02532065659761429, -0.004722260404378176, 0.03037990815937519, 0.052259206771850586, -0.02475273236632347, 0.06488528102636337, 0.03157762065529823, 0.002839843276888132, 0.01070700865238905, 0.035926464945077896, 0.012719527818262577, -0.03624699264764786, 0.011366013437509537, -0.012108835391700268, -0.014635138213634491, -0.016340790316462517, -0.02279309183359146, -0.0793011337518692, 0.009947188198566437, 0.03629206866025925, 0.07217217236757278, 0.0854257121682167, -0.004688371438533068, 0.03615543991327286, 0.03192510828375816, -0.004456263966858387, 0.01277229655534029, 0.019860245287418365, 0.03924468904733658, -0.05408009886741638, 0.0024575109127908945, 0.04234909638762474, 0.030761197209358215, 0.030057359486818314, 0.037789613008499146, 0.028546273708343506, -0.01210653968155384, 0.04069537669420242, 0.03708608075976372, -0.057246118783950806, 0.0010254873195663095, -0.0018841802375391126, -0.012208760716021061, 0.009605584666132927, -0.016263453289866447, -0.014306271448731422, 0.0192412156611681, 0.01196946669369936, -0.047899726778268814, -0.001061891089193523, 0.014153607189655304, -0.01392758172005415, 0.00556977791711688, -0.006945324596017599, -0.00860250648111105, 0.0816444605588913, 0.047064363956451416, 0.0043473499827086926, 0.0232401005923748, 0.010625860653817654, -0.019062727689743042, -0.02265631966292858, -0.010394626297056675, -0.023066401481628418, 0.004277556203305721, -0.0033790443558245897, 0.00047293727402575314, -0.00004373405681690201, 0.09435161203145981, 0.003296224633231759, -0.02656397596001625, -0.01618879847228527, 0.024701490998268127, -0.025950273498892784, 0.015232490375638008, -0.05811161547899246, 0.019832750782370567, -0.008951641619205475, -0.007326219696551561, -0.038739047944545746, -0.0014656299026682973, -0.014240147545933723, 0.06689665466547012, -0.028047138825058937, 0.014375677332282066, 0.02734268829226494, -0.007860093377530575, -0.042556725442409515, -0.0076277414336800575, -0.05472758039832115, 0.07917999476194382, 0.048050832003355026, -0.032973527908325195, -0.005691492930054665, -0.03917809948325157, 0.040194153785705566, 0.033700890839099884, -0.008447105064988136, -0.012459327466785908, -0.03581811487674713, -0.0324009470641613, 0.008868495933711529, 0.04646230861544609, -0.016983335837721825, 0.013804280199110508, -0.0018019480630755424, -0.019771883264183998, -0.0264828372746706, 0.0008822763338685036, -0.011668414808809757, -0.029303360730409622, -0.00339727895334363, -0.025408554822206497, -0.032856535166502, 0.025230253115296364, 0.07191949337720871, 0.07933103293180466, -0.052658889442682266, -0.02864936925470829, -0.01649065688252449, 0.008749673143029213, -0.06072592735290527, 0.004981495905667543, 0.008103933185338974, -0.0008291244739666581, 0.005374342668801546, 0.006746935658156872, -0.0077413818798959255, -0.017342139035463333, -0.03437567502260208, 0.0673493891954422, -0.007756153587251902, 0.015884090214967728, -0.05797310918569565, 0.034369342029094696, -0.009901256300508976, -0.00018354102212470025, -0.019454507157206535, -0.013867136090993881, 0.08366318047046661, -0.00020351700368337333, 0.018099287524819374, 0.019484393298625946, 0.0009228780982084572, 0.046231165528297424, 0.01810883916914463, 0.024175867438316345, -0.005871663801372051, 0.004376369994133711, -0.031381718814373016, 0.07698892802000046, 0.0034925302024930716, -0.010936714708805084, -0.017051804810762405, 0.003948768600821495, -0.02222631871700287, 0.005896361544728279, -0.0663164034485817, 0.05230094492435455, -0.0412348136305809, 0.032613545656204224, -0.015903301537036896, -0.030011797323822975, -0.026259172707796097, 0.012444642372429371, 0.046423885971307755, -0.07362785935401917, 0.023781921714544296, -0.009501354768872261, 0.010231301188468933, 0.06980902701616287, 0.045126866549253464, 0.0015502105234190822, 0.021622244268655777, 0.014871958643198013, -0.04356510192155838, 0.011262462474405766, 0.010140565223991871, 0.015267740935087204, 0.035972803831100464, -0.04696153476834297, 0.000889497110620141, -0.002424759091809392, -0.027419909834861755, -0.05142335221171379, -0.0009911182569339871, -0.01166127622127533, -0.0021451523061841726, -0.05194566771388054, -0.008019271306693554, -0.00903116911649704, -0.014980725012719631, 0.013658491894602776, 0.0008824137039482594, -0.03907233849167824, 0.02108612470328808, 0.0014851002488285303, 0.04037411883473396, 0.008465901017189026, -0.05801096931099892, 0.042813144624233246, 0.006219907663762569, 0.05733006075024605, 0.03584248200058937, 0.010262063704431057, 0.006845265626907349, 0.011152554303407669, 0.006440747529268265, -0.03180936351418495, 0.04561430215835571, 0.06166369840502739, 0.019569916650652885, 0.020759131759405136, 0.06957262009382248, -0.026994485408067703, -0.06583191454410553, -0.005804999265819788, -0.021875489503145218, 0.00956395547837019, 0.016926873475313187, -0.06406379491090775, -0.03128909319639206, -0.015423662960529327, 0.01694449968636036, -0.0022279967088252306, -0.04683190956711769, 0.03506266698241234, 0.031887952238321304, -0.018910929560661316, 0.023095153272151947, -0.002177954651415348, -0.005448739975690842, -0.043262820690870285, -0.030439499765634537, -0.0293436199426651, -0.03070724382996559, 0.020479535683989525, 0.010007229633629322, -0.011717583984136581, 0.014584078453481197, 0.05630325898528099, -0.01988704316318035, 0.0411762073636055, 0.01529681496322155, -0.03935123607516289, 0.0121865039691329, -0.0114775775000453, -0.05420726165175438, -0.029568621888756752, -0.058604661375284195, -0.06312522292137146, -0.018422147259116173, 0.024681802839040756, 0.000449773040600121, 0.0005148994969204068, 0.007545091211795807, -0.026012815535068512, 0.0554075762629509, -0.0371018722653389, -0.014406871050596237, 0.06905071437358856, -0.015060382895171642, -0.029815413057804108, -0.013203907757997513, 0.03290296345949173, 0.011694825254380703, -0.0064781480468809605, -0.012850209139287472, -0.04007885605096817, -0.11740725487470627, -0.007065521087497473, -0.07180532068014145, -0.014843995682895184, -0.0071153161115944386, -0.0034955674782395363, 0.027765296399593353, -0.0023721056059002876, 0.008492882363498211, 0.02394791878759861, -0.011319209821522236, -0.012753203511238098, 0.08405829966068268, -0.0025875784922391176, -0.046471934765577316, -0.021035391837358475, 0.012243624776601791, 0.017500920221209526, -0.007429291494190693, 0.007193988189101219, -0.0037564518861472607, 0.050870057195425034, -0.03745727613568306, 0.026961755007505417, 0.025557130575180054, 0.01556670293211937, 0.003150316420942545, -0.03374233469367027, -0.017893556505441666, 0.03602088987827301, -0.03587121516466141, -0.00011869105219375342, 0.0021955661941319704, 0.020171714946627617, -0.004220105241984129, 0.008429788053035736, 0.0025624395348131657, 0.04332948476076126, -0.005635910667479038, 0.0013028394896537066, 0.018706630915403366, -0.0003164717636536807, 0.04337652400135994, 0.004656167235225439, 0.02146458998322487, -0.08010590076446533, -0.002416373696178198, 0.06085041165351868, 0.008997535333037376, 0.05692388489842415, -0.0014600807335227728, -0.0028273528441786766, 0.007863873615860939, -0.0340115912258625, 0.006036055274307728, -0.015436268411576748, 0.046120185405015945, 0.02517119236290455, -0.019673148170113564, 0.012639341875910759, -0.045877330005168915, -0.023196948692202568, 0.009889696724712849, -0.002862352877855301, -0.026062598451972008, 0.06759022176265717, 0.002953343326225877, -0.07014119625091553, 0.030838431790471077, 0.05200343206524849, 0.014196852222084999, 0.006949036382138729, -0.029433082789182663, -0.01443276647478342, -0.042461492121219635, -0.06937211006879807, 0.04393213614821434, -0.0028253858909010887, 0.01384721975773573, -0.017645610496401787, 0.03601020947098732, 0.007986960001289845, 0.07826341688632965, 0.02166379801928997, -0.07224171608686447, 0.04213886708021164, -0.017551235854625702, -0.013607709668576717, 0.007222763728350401, -0.016216741874814034, -0.016228433698415756, 0.1068471372127533, 0.06075195223093033, -0.021364131942391396, -0.013596806675195694, -0.007466146256774664, -0.0015381135744974017, -0.026180190965533257, -0.015078941360116005, -0.01653928868472576, -0.04412911832332611, 0.05664699152112007, -0.04700250178575516, -0.023263724520802498, -0.0681862011551857, -0.0065587665885686874, -0.047133687883615494, 0.0007274176459759474, 0.04826759174466133, -0.007144297007471323, 0.04803091287612915, -0.017032194882631302, -0.0019790881779044867, -0.08456477522850037, -0.0436033196747303, 0.008211882784962654, 0.03707105666399002, 0.051799140870571136, 0.005093052517622709, 0.026775451377034187, -0.00508436793461442, 0.041692398488521576, -0.010199273936450481, 0.006562759634107351, 0.017004963010549545, -0.013737047091126442, 0.01399814710021019, -0.012477092444896698, -0.02925567887723446, 0.030712425708770752, -0.08506126701831818, 0.015082336030900478, 0.02119545079767704, 0.015430510975420475, -0.052154362201690674, -0.04252796620130539, 0.05100788176059723, 0.009218444116413593, -0.01846904307603836, -0.0012362924171611667, 0.06549261510372162, 0.04945774003863335, -0.05932842940092087, -0.051998887211084366, -0.0050594923086464405, 0.02801649458706379, 0.03367951512336731, -0.06913258880376816, -0.06578264385461807, 0.05754049867391586, -0.06094611436128616, -0.012134002521634102, 0.011806624941527843, -0.038759294897317886, 0.059897635132074356, 0.02765359729528427, 0.03504828363656998, -0.016208983957767487, -0.12414874136447906, 0.014247258193790913, -0.04885703697800636, 0.011010713875293732, -0.0013150167651474476, -0.021554166451096535, -0.023366864770650864, 0.0513794869184494, 0.00651609105989337, -0.009570077061653137, -0.016795963048934937, -0.041295889765024185, -0.06077999621629715, -0.05991523340344429, -0.005493393167853355, 0.012523838318884373, 0.06097441539168358, -0.03085750713944435, -0.04624275118112564, 0.050564926117658615, 0.005534400697797537, 0.0831720381975174, 0.03126753121614456, -0.018340501934289932, -0.0874854326248169, 0.06618641316890717, 0.011051000095903873, 0.03851395845413208, 0.025190535932779312, 0.018236614763736725, -0.043686795979738235, -0.00494756456464529, 0.045209694653749466, -0.05156245827674866, -0.02439918927848339, -0.0277333352714777, 0.01557235885411501, 0.005071544554084539, -0.01092211902141571, -0.011946123093366623, -0.051303524523973465, -0.021704399958252907, 0.0029529589228332043, -0.015641000121831894, 0.030118495225906372, -0.0037512534763664007, -0.012973660603165627, 0.013152220286428928, 0.0060881213285028934, -0.05326634645462036, 0.06818854063749313, -0.013835160061717033, 0.013770957477390766, -0.007501709740608931, -0.002585955196991563, 0.011875158175826073, -0.05084310099482536, 0.002899054903537035, 0.041033778339624405, 0.031641360372304916, -0.004058156628161669, -0.01346499752253294, 0.012741884216666222, 0.07318820059299469, -0.03941952809691429, 0.009929252788424492, 0.005349422339349985, 0.007772072218358517, -0.04377094656229019, 0.024311747401952744, -0.023422207683324814, -0.04452534765005112, -0.027889370918273926, 0.011494560167193413, -0.016022030264139175, 0.08788838237524033, -0.0028524724766612053, 0.028660576790571213, -0.03074197843670845, -0.04126109182834625, -0.01964137703180313, 0.05652270466089249, 0.041780393570661545, -0.06566186994314194, 0.00864730030298233, 0.046274539083242416, -0.024157395586371422, -0.010569502599537373, 0.02861947752535343, -0.02223285101354122, -0.027085866779088974, -0.0463516041636467, -0.014555870555341244, -0.012510213069617748, 0.029039369896054268, 0.04441504552960396, 0.027275213971734047, 0.0037995195016264915, 0.09495264291763306, 0.022186987102031708, 0.0016154528129845858, 0.0040160357020795345, -0.05736915394663811, 0.01849384419620037, -0.017151031643152237, -0.025884345173835754, 0.01868501864373684, 0.06542080640792847, 0.08337090909481049, -0.022295137867331505, -0.035060398280620575, -0.008114015683531761, 0.03823457658290863, 0.0018807811429724097, -0.04975753277540207, -0.029619894921779633, -0.021378740668296814, -0.01082390546798706, -0.011331883259117603, 0.028911929577589035, 0.016067134216427803, 0.04275033250451088, 0.005231953226029873, 0.02965562418103218, -0.04553015157580376, -0.038615014404058456, 0.03714007884263992, 0.015922175720334053, -0.03948044404387474, -0.04246780276298523, 0.003432814497500658, 0.03523766249418259, -0.007714732550084591, -0.00915421824902296, 0.02476140670478344, -0.08907460421323776, 0.008303067646920681, 0.01147307176142931, 0.013994905166327953, -0.04685251787304878, -0.05755741894245148, -0.00266563193872571, 0.05317489802837372, -0.03577352315187454, -0.07285146415233612, 0.011014099232852459, -0.009549272246658802, 0.04170651361346245, -0.026866594329476357, -0.03617461770772934, 0.02291451208293438, -0.004673914983868599, 0.028870755806565285, -0.015598002821207047, -0.001672208309173584, -0.031614355742931366, -0.059636496007442474, -0.07485158741474152, 0.034016504883766174, 0.04799351468682289, 0.00587822962552309, 0.03929800167679787, -0.009384461678564548, -0.060722868889570236, 0.05068299546837807, -0.0026098641101270914, -0.024404624477028847, 0.03199394419789314, 0.034341853111982346, -0.06422922015190125, -0.10164742916822433, -0.06893212348222733, 0.04951449856162071, -0.03145663067698479, 0.034531399607658386, -0.028748661279678345, -0.0331447497010231, -0.012493736110627651, -0.05892715975642204, -0.0021999282762408257, -0.04196944087743759, 0.008386894129216671, 0.028735941275954247, 0.029498375952243805, 0.06887087225914001, 0.06442271173000336, 0.041678208857774734, -0.04199400544166565 ]
<p>A hollow cylinder, with no top or bottom, of radius $R$ and length $L$ is uniformly charged with density $\sigma&gt;0$. I have to find the point on space where a point charge $q&gt;0$ has to be drawn from $\infty$ with speed $v\rightarrow0$ so that the work done is maximum, so I have to find the point with maximum potential. What I did was find the electric field, using Gauss's law, and then set $V(\infty)=0$:</p> <p>$0&lt;\rho &lt; R: E=0 \\R&lt;\rho &lt; \infty: E=\frac{\sigma R}\rho$</p> <p>so $V(\rho)=-\int\limits_\infty^\rho{E.dl}$ .</p> <p>For $R&lt;\rho&lt;\infty$ I get $V(\rho)=\sigma R \ln(\infty/\rho) $, so here I don't know what to do. Maybe I shouldn't have used Gauss's law, and calculate $E$ the 'classic' way, integrating over the cylinder, but the integral looks so complicated. This problem was given on an exam and trust me, if the integral is actually that complicated, I wasn't supposed to do it that way. So, what should I do?</p>
g4260
[ 0.04418693482875824, -0.021142341196537018, -0.0048012156039476395, 0.005061405710875988, 0.02793903276324272, 0.003233807161450386, -0.010150319896638393, -0.007506049238145351, -0.06029786169528961, 0.046584051102399826, -0.05176826938986778, 0.004506072960793972, -0.02250000275671482, -0.011763539165258408, 0.010981029830873013, -0.008899478241801262, 0.0313834473490715, 0.0012395080411806703, -0.02118026278913021, -0.008538051508367062, 0.00800877995789051, 0.008786403574049473, 0.04376114532351494, 0.00975864753127098, 0.0033075890969485044, -0.004461708478629589, 0.03164151310920715, 0.032140642404556274, -0.02983688749372959, -0.05896211415529251, 0.012679577805101871, 0.03175097331404686, 0.01626349426805973, 0.008305206894874573, -0.021715234965085983, -0.03059394285082817, 0.04198336973786354, 0.03135174885392189, -0.006440081167966127, -0.04110507667064667, -0.013040429912507534, -0.061816323548555374, 0.08948633819818497, 0.004132005851715803, 0.014709805138409138, 0.004292021505534649, -0.0014865970006212592, 0.07065754383802414, 0.0018446834292262793, -0.03383185714483261, -0.027082713320851326, 0.0028130582068115473, -0.019438570365309715, -0.08581162244081497, 0.00398535979911685, 0.002536444691941142, -0.04124517738819122, -0.033652279525995255, 0.01828387752175331, 0.04054494947195053, -0.017944687977433205, -0.04759365692734718, -0.04984338954091072, 0.019829271361231804, -0.016817808151245117, -0.009558020159602165, 0.017909998074173927, -0.02381405606865883, -0.03322061151266098, 0.01661313883960247, 0.011150257661938667, -0.07649433612823486, 0.0049643442034721375, -0.09340835362672806, -0.06871359795331955, -0.005338364280760288, 0.057273171842098236, 0.016950879245996475, 0.010763595812022686, -0.04370622709393501, -0.040832728147506714, 0.00025545957032591105, 0.03336998447775841, -0.0009307345026172698, 0.060991477221250534, -0.03345319256186485, 0.04412608966231346, 0.015407186932861805, -0.021257512271404266, 0.002164415782317519, -0.024990491569042206, 0.02526281401515007, 0.03249214217066765, 0.007612156681716442, 0.022334668785333633, -0.023651493713259697, 0.02117658592760563, 0.06809291988611221, -0.010485020466148853, -0.022985124960541725, -0.023697739467024803, -0.04201472923159599, 0.0341675691306591, 0.006256294436752796, -0.03459498658776283, 0.0012686994159594178, 0.004081167280673981, -0.003737943945452571, -0.009916716255247593, -0.036354485899209976, -0.0065782214514911175, -0.07040594518184662, -0.030049370601773262, -0.07982949912548065, 0.000134979301947169, -0.006658697035163641, 0.03458181396126747, -0.004899157676845789, -0.012322532944381237, 0.03335147723555565, 0.00010341268352931365, 0.030440786853432655, 0.04430997744202614, 0.020161205902695656, -0.014704681001603603, 0.04796771705150604, -0.03669288754463196, 0.01408928632736206, -0.00408012792468071, -0.009186690673232079, 0.01428512204438448, 0.00042560702422633767, 0.032892871648073196, 0.0026705984491854906, -0.031625378876924515, 0.060448236763477325, -0.07062635570764542, -0.025713780894875526, 0.018716096878051758, -0.028301309794187546, -0.001548992469906807, -0.03417523205280304, -0.021875718608498573, 0.01287282444536686, -0.03392999619245529, 0.032020024955272675, -0.02960941195487976, -0.06801681220531464, -0.013944275677204132, -0.0018530481029301882, -0.013424716889858246, 0.027151843532919884, -0.0045380559749901295, 0.008670316077768803, 0.02238420583307743, 0.042540788650512695, 0.06603898108005524, 0.018156537786126137, 0.03446811065077782, -0.03560611233115196, 0.0013387140352278948, 0.05550356209278107, -0.0016376310959458351, 0.020047644153237343, -0.009954392910003662, 0.03513443470001221, -0.03595912829041481, -0.017023250460624695, 0.010215029120445251, -0.05592057853937149, -0.014786724001169205, 0.015833282843232155, 0.04474799707531929, 0.01009235717356205, 0.0011197172570973635, -0.0180366113781929, -0.010645690374076366, -0.029163330793380737, 0.021661704406142235, 0.055340155959129333, -0.0302859079092741, -0.0869823470711708, 0.052384473383426666, -0.014370179735124111, -0.023394793272018433, 0.01083244290202856, -0.02572149969637394, 0.0035659540444612503, -0.0246988944709301, -0.014333226718008518, 0.0017190543003380299, 0.05682681128382683, 0.011656451039016247, 0.06083083525300026, -0.01323813945055008, 0.04703221470117569, 0.08638888597488403, -0.06204959750175476, -0.004412699956446886, -0.0435347855091095, -0.039472147822380066, 0.03733605518937111, 0.05067679286003113, 0.05763233080506325, 0.02378573641180992, -0.026405639946460724, 0.021877611055970192, -0.012658439576625824, -0.00012676866026595235, 0.06822654604911804, -0.0064313956536352634, -0.006198109593242407, -0.03770081326365471, 0.06360796838998795, 0.0109780952334404, -0.05014662444591522, -0.06313453614711761, 0.03560798987746239, -0.04315418750047684, -0.009693204425275326, -0.03447260335087776, 0.0014373272424563766, 0.043211888521909714, 0.0028380234725773335, -0.01560668833553791, -0.007028781808912754, 0.05536482483148575, 0.020975161343812943, 0.019321274012327194, -0.009086068719625473, -0.0006054635159671307, 0.024293798953294754, -0.011493111960589886, -0.041537556797266006, 0.016799001023173332, 0.03499218821525574, -0.05459482967853546, -0.03890404850244522, -0.011248031631112099, 0.03999444842338562, -0.014709544368088245, -0.034523095935583115, 0.032465264201164246, -0.026522785425186157, -0.011108722537755966, -0.015053730458021164, -0.016228465363383293, 0.016705987975001335, -0.07256501168012619, 0.04385581240057945, -0.007242344785481691, 0.07306553423404694, 0.007814786396920681, 0.004436954390257597, 0.019443005323410034, 0.04738527536392212, -0.02580968476831913, -0.027793295681476593, -0.015150867402553558, -0.07643910497426987, -0.027832623571157455, -0.006663687992841005, -0.020852867513895035, 0.01830476149916649, -0.07293088734149933, 0.05202218145132065, -0.06148206442594528, -0.03177978843450546, 0.01580492965877056, -0.005950817372649908, -0.03907192125916481, 0.11894245445728302, -0.01715434342622757, -0.0019070119597017765, 0.0461648628115654, 0.007097965106368065, 0.018142657354474068, -0.0003126490337308496, 0.07803452759981155, 0.008881548419594765, -0.0022515447344630957, -0.06861689686775208, -0.0010501097422093153, 0.035714611411094666, -0.0062239100225269794, -0.05944522097706795, 0.030240297317504883, 0.06219809129834175, 0.032127223908901215, -0.02286476641893387, -0.015306682325899601, 0.030436499044299126, 0.02798542007803917, -0.00021592428674921393, 0.04794073477387428, 0.06640869379043579, 0.02635560743510723, -0.03627939149737358, 0.007259716279804707, -0.012826114892959595, -0.009961283765733242, -0.034208208322525024, 0.018558526411652565, 0.005459408741444349, 0.04200040176510811, -0.03047213889658451, 0.01800275221467018, -0.06767144054174423, 0.0024074972607195377, 0.008891054429113865, 0.054881881922483444, -0.019341154024004936, 0.05683767423033714, -0.07632561028003693, -0.010580727830529213, -0.002806008793413639, -0.008251145482063293, -0.0674542561173439, -0.006439204793423414, 0.017466474324464798, 0.0028894527349621058, -0.022198859602212906, 0.007567130029201508, -0.02038581483066082, 0.05051388964056969, 0.03761715814471245, -0.05239838734269142, -0.03866549953818321, -0.04084719717502594, 0.030704176053404808, -0.014214390888810158, 0.06806071847677231, 0.038254864513874054, 0.01494838297367096, -0.010343894362449646, -0.07136557251214981, 0.028261447325348854, 0.038691140711307526, 0.05575670674443245, -0.06890665739774704, -0.09563389420509338, -0.0095222108066082, 0.0042580412700772285, -0.02832690253853798, 0.03412051871418953, -0.04407591372728348, 0.020681483671069145, 0.08018755912780762, 0.033717624843120575, 0.025076957419514656, 0.01206224039196968, -0.04806913807988167, -0.025864776223897934, -0.009882052429020405, -0.0005595766706392169, -0.0066747767850756645, 0.043621912598609924, 0.036214299499988556, -0.05299636721611023, -0.05454137921333313, 0.023926664143800735, -0.008031307719647884, -0.023986022919416428, -0.013323524966835976, 0.038223475217819214, -0.0491316020488739, 0.010413997806608677, 0.057717278599739075, -0.019965242594480515, 0.005729599390178919, 0.03166022524237633, -0.031887639313936234, 0.056744564324617386, 0.02030159719288349, 0.0009172614081762731, -0.05414106696844101, 0.0074897450394928455, -0.005378038622438908, 0.005167121533304453, 0.049624186009168625, 0.0372527576982975, 0.011283655650913715, 0.005074602086097002, -0.051273755729198456, -0.00007152102625695989, 0.028862521052360535, -0.03455054387450218, -0.039767440408468246, 0.048268355429172516, -0.009662075899541378, -0.02898963913321495, 0.008718988858163357, -0.022928394377231598, 0.021624404937028885, -0.07004523277282715, -0.010494834743440151, 0.03028874658048153, 0.010675329715013504, -0.0686752051115036, 0.0027558295987546444, 0.0017785029485821724, 0.00384422205388546, 0.024580927565693855, 0.00951369944959879, -0.0018813456408679485, -0.02111857198178768, 0.029588045552372932, -0.01763756200671196, 0.048523370176553726, -0.033207930624485016, 0.0037618251517415047, -0.02796844393014908, -0.013045636005699635, -0.014720139093697071, 0.02012195810675621, 0.006200362462550402, 0.005688019562512636, -0.0005132395890541375, -0.07182168960571289, -0.006256724242120981, -0.02389172650873661, -0.016234664246439934, 0.04022764042019844, -0.03520360216498375, 0.009317571297287941, -0.03966917842626572, 0.08931205421686172, 0.056078795343637466, 0.02055649645626545, 0.005719477776437998, -0.037724725902080536, 0.013079579919576645, -0.061195164918899536, 0.018856259062886238, -0.01064460352063179, 0.054829396307468414, -0.025101235136389732, 0.012331810779869556, -0.06575902551412582, 0.06530694663524628, 0.020981723442673683, -0.0258390661329031, 0.034168802201747894, -0.00826101191341877, 0.0033405208960175514, 0.005000348202884197, -0.0304301455616951, -0.0543242022395134, -0.024099769070744514, -0.040064625442028046, -0.034823380410671234, -0.048388343304395676, 0.028047706931829453, 0.023156307637691498, 0.03488119691610336, -0.01842665858566761, -0.06947188824415207, 0.038602862507104874, 0.012678919360041618, -0.0105827571824193, -0.048631925135850906, 0.020761296153068542, -0.05267716571688652, 0.004046550951898098, 0.04840652272105217, -0.037563059478998184, -0.0365864634513855, -0.008569247089326382, -0.013070645742118359, -0.006987454369664192, 0.015924347564578056, 0.03629769757390022, 0.10775686055421829, -0.03616633266210556, -0.01092800684273243, 0.0022918470203876495, 0.023138388991355896, 0.02587030455470085, -0.04987899214029312, -0.019912322983145714, -0.07938675582408905, -0.025037966668605804, 0.005156622733920813, 0.016899747774004936, 0.003624080214649439, 0.055758342146873474, -0.040206510573625565, -0.0174929890781641, -0.004933584481477737, 0.014933974482119083, -0.0043178447522223, 0.07879503816366196, -0.013102024793624878, -0.0025348879862576723, 0.061092909425497055, 0.025358179584145546, 0.07515808194875717, -0.0017311150440946221, -0.05948528274893761, 0.027453426271677017, -0.052183058112859726, 0.024990588426589966, -0.04902463033795357, -0.0059898532927036285, -0.042075466364622116, 0.030274828895926476, 0.0033171656541526318, 0.058541614562273026, -0.007898990996181965, 0.036577366292476654, 0.03050750494003296, 0.049197178333997726, 0.07755906134843826, -0.02580893784761429, 0.00007693954830756411, 0.00031340165878646076, -0.04146156832575798, -0.0023274736013263464, -0.026570040732622147, -0.029111243784427643, 0.11392594128847122, 0.008626035414636135, 0.03212754800915718, -0.03925442323088646, -0.006951954215764999, 0.006291390396654606, -0.027488065883517265, -0.0876770094037056, -0.004713117145001888, 0.0011550954077392817, -0.039673108607530594, -0.03568467125296593, -0.02768498845398426, -0.045730460435152054, -0.017660200595855713, -0.01230668369680643, -0.04722616448998451, -0.0002995999820996076, 0.015967348590493202, -0.03025939129292965, 0.02199900709092617, 0.00009305636922363192, -0.008425137959420681, 0.03177976608276367, -0.07786061614751816, -0.0014694109559059143, -0.07423073798418045, 0.0077458834275603294, 0.07821206003427505, 0.007596937008202076, -0.009207597002387047, 0.022053958848118782, -0.0263803843408823, 0.009409813210368156, 0.019618837162852287, -0.010700023733079433, 0.008984815329313278, 0.029184753075242043, -0.05570099130272865, 0.03769127279520035, 0.04840322583913803, -0.04834869131445885, 0.012702954933047295, 0.029447440057992935, -0.0032707874197512865, -0.03522920981049538, 0.00866678636521101, -0.02571711875498295, 0.01831255480647087, 0.007258561439812183, 0.04050227254629135, -0.024363964796066284, 0.037397176027297974, -0.015989063307642937, 0.08275623619556427, 0.012103152461349964, -0.04714392125606537, 0.05378871411085129, 0.01276310719549656, 0.010197172872722149, -0.07756555825471878, 0.018373023718595505, 0.06029478833079338, -0.023592857643961906, 0.0041131870821118355, 0.02352973259985447, -0.004387777764350176, -0.07962561398744583, 0.08697021007537842, -0.06407259404659271, 0.012277960777282715, 0.02633179910480976, 0.030868183821439743, 0.015895521268248558, -0.03690022975206375, -0.009829608723521233, 0.004864146932959557, -0.04964851215481758, -0.015450181439518929, 0.038503702729940414, 0.010304160416126251, 0.034039903432130814, -0.01774781011044979, 0.020733505487442017, 0.07080397009849548, -0.027431705966591835, -0.030421925708651543, -0.02475903369486332, -0.04779171571135521, -0.026941247284412384, 0.008412274532020092, 0.005195569712668657, -0.018726438283920288, 0.02339068055152893, -0.009227254427969456, 0.04423626884818077, 0.03823615983128548, 0.011460565030574799, 0.003356481436640024, -0.0016889225225895643, 0.05878685787320137, 0.05449283495545387, -0.0034779824782162905, 0.02707599103450775, -0.012077298946678638, 0.03244275227189064, -0.03326985985040665, -0.022816652432084084, 0.04665656015276909, -0.021423492580652237, 0.06982773542404175, 0.02667452208697796, -0.046782273799180984, 0.062471527606248856, 0.011012561619281769, -0.005486831534653902, 0.03949245065450668, 0.014046343974769115, 0.032550062984228134, 0.06330553442239761, -0.023493986576795578, 0.041336461901664734, -0.002754390239715576, 0.010945458896458149, -0.020015709102153778, -0.07989545166492462, 0.026923568919301033, -0.0007397656445391476, -0.03815913200378418, 0.057784657925367355, 0.03472317010164261, 0.050728537142276764, -0.006354588083922863, -0.04246058315038681, -0.03373768925666809, 0.00852039735764265, 0.05537695810198784, 0.05255808308720589, -0.02351890690624714, -0.05379525572061539, 0.020861409604549408, 0.03867202252149582, 0.00552681740373373, -0.027004200965166092, 0.015742851421236992, 0.008210300467908382, -0.04860986769199371, -0.06247244402766228, -0.02102203667163849, -0.057590682059526443, -0.006938653998076916, 0.010229597799479961, -0.03637479618191719, 0.008271482773125172, 0.061853792518377304, 0.019800683483481407, 0.014109806157648563, 0.07837283611297607, -0.06255871802568436, 0.009539888240396976, 0.0007145129493437707, 0.03307005390524864, -0.06091734394431114, 0.05294166877865791, -0.003762174630537629, 0.008474517613649368, -0.033807627856731415, 0.0079619400203228, -0.03937981277704239, 0.02571033500134945, -0.003775557968765497, 0.02195647545158863, 0.04308433085680008, -0.0179110299795866, 0.0356663316488266, 0.027638649567961693, 0.0005462617846205831, 0.02445812337100506, 0.0565531887114048, -0.02461658976972103, 0.0007506568799726665, -0.009926027618348598, 0.028668755665421486, -0.012610995210707188, -0.014861749485135078, -0.008371642790734768, 0.0068877157755196095, 0.007249471265822649, -0.006551139522343874, 0.030230402946472168, 0.048365138471126556, 0.010441609658300877, 0.005365012679249048, -0.013305189087986946, 0.07949505746364594, 0.031781528145074844, -0.0492279976606369, 0.013838913291692734, 0.009145128540694714, -0.021591151133179665, -0.030282458290457726, 0.03822408244013786, -0.019076084718108177, -0.05078718066215515, -0.04241931065917015, -0.03412139043211937, -0.06391632556915283, -0.019304491579532623, 0.005101663060486317, -0.027561450377106667, -0.014107685536146164, -0.027581918984651566, -0.03657285124063492, 0.05109364911913872, -0.058651939034461975, -0.04896237701177597, -0.03316762298345566, 0.015263501554727554, 0.01991901732981205, 0.0016987259732559323, -0.02513202838599682, -0.0251995287835598, -0.02806663140654564, -0.010395323857665062, 0.031082158908247948, -0.03465183079242706, -0.03629384562373161, 0.018563788384199142, 0.09899628907442093, 0.04308074340224266, -0.0046815224923193455, 0.015682078897953033, -0.012682323344051838, -0.011236277408897877, -0.002712446730583906, -0.05969714745879173, 0.08367352932691574, 0.008039861917495728, 0.03131772205233574, 0.010956630110740662, 0.013810297474265099, -0.05448979139328003, -0.020182352513074875, 0.032898981124162674, 0.05246824771165848, -0.06045559421181679, -0.0010105696273967624, -0.018656397238373756 ]
<p>This is about the same paper as this thread: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/11645/some-questions-about-chapter-i-1-by-minahan-of-the-review-of-ads-cft-integrab">Some questions about chapter I.1 (by Minahan) of the &quot;Review of AdS/CFT Integrability&quot;</a> but it was never answered. </p> <p>I have some different questions about it and I'll separate them into a couple posts if need be. I'd also be grateful if anyone can recommend other introductions or reviews for understanding N=4 generally and the Minahan review <a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/1012.3983v2" rel="nofollow">http://arxiv.org/pdf/1012.3983v2</a> in particular. Some of the algebra/group theory was particularly hard for me to follow (highest-weight reps, Cartan subalgebras...).</p> <p>Some questions I'm particularly intrigued/troubled by are:</p> <ol> <li><p>After (3.1) he says an operator $O(x)$ having dimension $\Delta$ means that when $x\rightarrow \lambda x$, then "$O(x)$ scales as $O(x) \rightarrow \lambda^{-\Delta} O(\lambda x) $." Should this be $O(x) \rightarrow \lambda^{-\Delta} O(x) $? If we say that $O(x)$ is some polynomial of degree $n$ in $x$, then after the rescaling $O(x)$ will be a polynomial of degree $n$ in $\lambda x$. So we'd have $O(x) \rightarrow O(\lambda x) \sim \lambda^n O(x)$. Then if we identify $-\Delta = n$ we have $O(x) \rightarrow O(\lambda x) \sim \lambda^{-\Delta} O(x)$. Am I missing something?</p></li> <li><p>How does he get eq. (3.2)? It apparently follows from $D$ being the generator of scalings, by which he says he means that $O(x) \rightarrow \lambda^{-iD} O(x) \lambda^{iD}$. I'm confused by this, too, as I expect to see the generator exponentiated by $e$, not $\lambda$. I'd expect something like $e^{-i\lambda D} O(X) e^{i\lambda D}$, with $D$ as the generator and $\lambda$ as the parameter. </p></li> <li><p>Later, in eq. (3.9), he introduces the $R_{IJ}$ as the $SO(6)$ R-symmetry generators, as well as some matrices $\sigma^{IJ}$ that he only addresses later. Here $I, J = 1...6$. I don't understand the notation. Why are there two indices on these guys? And if it's an $SO(6) \sim SU(4)$ symmetry group, then there should only be 15 generators. So are some of these $R$ and $\sigma$ redundant? Because naively it would appear that we have $6\times 6=36$ of each. I suspect that I'm missing something about how to understand these indices. </p></li> <li><p>Kind of the same thing as 3. In (3.14) he gives some of those $\sigma^{IJ}$ and states that they are the generators in the fundamental $SU(4)$ representation. Why? Where did these come from?</p></li> </ol> <p>I'll stop for now and post any other questions I have in another thread so as not to go overboard.</p>
g4261
[ -0.018885789439082146, 0.041233744472265244, 0.00007928283594083041, -0.010064758360385895, 0.012024715542793274, 0.003400186076760292, 0.045151930302381516, -0.014243395067751408, -0.06300690025091171, 0.005653020925819874, -0.08678850531578064, 0.0001265878527192399, 0.04504839703440666, 0.02328536845743656, -0.007534398697316647, 0.02503122389316559, 0.010176336392760277, 0.04179500788450241, 0.012605610303580761, -0.029969925060868263, -0.021739616990089417, 0.014001073315739632, 0.018285255879163742, -0.06843256950378418, 0.046467967331409454, 0.02937096171081066, 0.026390446349978447, -0.027185942977666855, -0.053472571074962616, -0.09203459322452545, 0.06172327697277069, 0.03558151423931122, 0.02539920248091221, -0.02968185395002365, -0.06207004562020302, 0.013357036747038364, 0.06825514882802963, 0.04004242643713951, 0.014089884236454964, 0.016005361452698708, -0.024232538416981697, -0.009367250837385654, -0.001312502077780664, -0.025442026555538177, -0.07272643595933914, 0.021738111972808838, -0.047247838228940964, 0.01570465788245201, 0.03636827692389488, -0.013831709511578083, 0.04257388040423393, 0.028950991109013557, 0.05097990110516548, -0.03379634767770767, 0.006615177728235722, 0.0714893639087677, 0.012987497262656689, 0.020649492740631104, 0.03553636372089386, 0.07395235449075699, -0.01802775263786316, -0.00350342714227736, -0.034384533762931824, 0.031885601580142975, 0.06873058527708054, -0.0624515637755394, 0.0512210987508297, -0.03231344372034073, -0.048213984817266464, -0.04293942451477051, -0.0003426425682846457, 0.005556139629334211, 0.0591190941631794, 0.06912313401699066, -0.031089231371879578, -0.001982060493901372, 0.04414662346243858, -0.005234218668192625, 0.034920573234558105, -0.053174372762441635, -0.01872372068464756, -0.01233926322311163, 0.0319334976375103, 0.027149885892868042, -0.02095809206366539, -0.026601744815707207, -0.050858039408922195, -0.0020144309382885695, 0.03200887143611908, 0.009571515955030918, 0.024020781740546227, -0.042252812534570694, -0.024656666442751884, 0.04011554270982742, 0.004509240388870239, 0.04592278227210045, -0.029472362250089645, 0.01061649527400732, -0.0600929893553257, -0.06578684598207474, -0.02824525162577629, 0.02781066857278347, 0.0631062239408493, 0.028680047020316124, -0.025871921330690384, 0.04558528959751129, 0.06612493097782135, -0.0314718596637249, -0.016919653862714767, 0.010643203742802143, -0.0803278461098671, 0.002149139763787389, -0.04299880191683769, -0.024231789633631706, -0.09198453277349472, 0.054399821907281876, 0.0659150555729866, -0.011130060069262981, 0.0028756337705999613, 0.008399768732488155, 0.05120941251516342, 0.025304539129137993, 0.08900421112775803, -0.027204828336834908, -0.014925559982657433, 0.00820170808583498, 0.04556236416101456, 0.043278273195028305, -0.016961559653282166, -0.05413578450679779, 0.030780814588069916, -0.013697194866836071, -0.014648860320448875, -0.007181891705840826, 0.019484011456370354, 0.00889651384204626, -0.00017632023082114756, 0.010879752226173878, -0.05423252657055855, -0.037547871470451355, -0.034098777920007706, -0.005412681493908167, -0.025790132582187653, -0.004917951300740242, 0.026436172425746918, -0.024510780349373817, -0.006479756906628609, -0.02982051856815815, 0.0020980299450457096, -0.008296027779579163, 0.05854204297065735, 0.059012509882450104, -0.015504688024520874, -0.011600585654377937, 0.03556125611066818, 0.05163213610649109, 0.035702940076589584, -0.042378976941108704, -0.011337530799210072, -0.028395362198352814, 0.06197609007358551, -0.010391565039753914, 0.026441220194101334, 0.023206572979688644, -0.053103670477867126, -0.02831101045012474, 0.03193632513284683, -0.03894675523042679, 0.04213452711701393, -0.009770325385034084, -0.012412983924150467, 0.03301277756690979, 0.078777976334095, -0.013866104185581207, 0.045971449464559555, 0.07370401173830032, 0.02172207087278366, 0.009402896277606487, 0.0013789191143587232, -0.000512787199113518, -0.039319731295108795, -0.032559119164943695, -0.002451477339491248, 0.008086414076387882, 0.016122067347168922, -0.014823815785348415, -0.013433001935482025, -0.0033147225622087717, -0.004278069362044334, -0.0057968865148723125, -0.03826029226183891, 0.051591429859399796, -0.003879894968122244, 0.09414029866456985, -0.015541373752057552, -0.005155789200216532, 0.02833929844200611, -0.059422533959150314, -0.011398596689105034, -0.008317511528730392, 0.03318096324801445, 0.021319059655070305, -0.028800446540117264, 0.027584848925471306, 0.051767729222774506, 0.048781923949718475, -0.04641961306333542, -0.03677190840244293, -0.01668516919016838, -0.00014233836554922163, -0.005750933662056923, -0.057005625218153, 0.0039568571373820305, 0.0005610671360045671, 0.022138046100735664, -0.001204744097776711, -0.0008257532608695328, -0.034748077392578125, -0.037704914808273315, 0.05363066494464874, 0.03704739362001419, -0.04888973385095596, -0.03530888631939888, 0.048405203968286514, -0.051859766244888306, 0.014488110318779945, -0.08657658100128174, 0.004740334581583738, 0.030509809032082558, 0.013109752908349037, -0.06626375764608383, 0.046862415969371796, -0.017812922596931458, -0.01353188045322895, 0.002223607851192355, 0.01577777974307537, -0.016961023211479187, 0.0114136328920722, 0.05007723718881607, 0.003731026314198971, 0.03273956850171089, 0.03003537841141224, 0.004533438012003899, 0.0028666891157627106, 0.018430177122354507, 0.005365023389458656, 0.03530275076627731, 0.023425592109560966, -0.037597380578517914, 0.03767065703868866, -0.02641984261572361, -0.012238754890859127, 0.02424030564725399, 0.016921168193221092, 0.024931510910391808, -0.01587492600083351, 0.06208011135458946, 0.024916410446166992, 0.006672644522041082, 0.06650754809379578, 0.018303589895367622, -0.04580359160900116, -0.025896945968270302, -0.029214581474661827, -0.093599334359169, -0.0028860142920166254, -0.011046826839447021, -0.05337096005678177, 0.0005450787721201777, -0.044730618596076965, -0.014367295429110527, 0.059564534574747086, 0.027635646983981133, -0.02567937597632408, -0.012197901494801044, 0.01049740705639124, -0.038584981113672256, -0.02266860008239746, 0.001042185234837234, -0.012709353119134903, 0.007545149885118008, -0.018414746969938278, -0.04907195642590523, -0.024960162118077278, 0.03516576066613197, -0.008923863992094994, 0.010336140170693398, 0.0036449721083045006, -0.030519971624016762, 0.033005308359861374, -0.00542397191748023, -0.05732300132513046, 0.018215101212263107, 0.004792999941855669, 0.009472129866480827, -0.03442525863647461, -0.02895856276154518, -0.05249395966529846, -0.0029380284249782562, -0.0024325402919203043, 0.0009016222320497036, -0.012264743447303772, 0.02523649111390114, -0.04972320795059204, 0.06976103782653809, 0.0244681965559721, -0.04035765677690506, 0.026423674076795578, 0.0029104570858180523, 0.03893529996275902, -0.05445927754044533, -0.041781600564718246, -0.004850550554692745, -0.06866329908370972, -0.00405628839507699, 0.011536271311342716, 0.007462421432137489, -0.005813689436763525, -0.011460434645414352, -0.06182677298784256, -0.009538073092699051, -0.012468678876757622, 0.031673021614551544, 0.0045900470577180386, 0.004328146576881409, 0.03544733673334122, -0.006882789544761181, 0.01246136985719204, 0.01474950835108757, -0.03210226818919182, 0.038758594542741776, -0.03952017426490784, 0.05180592089891434, -0.003969110082834959, -0.04894439876079559, -0.03336323797702789, -0.05840872973203659, 0.03591618686914444, 0.06576572358608246, -0.04684169217944145, -0.01572815701365471, 0.0026051413733512163, 0.0025368414353579283, -0.038980886340141296, -0.008098958991467953, 0.005663746036589146, -0.034608252346515656, 0.012155408971011639, -0.04412262141704559, 0.014778602868318558, -0.011601271107792854, 0.03034922294318676, 0.00131443131249398, -0.0628143772482872, -0.006340146530419588, 0.06840119510889053, 0.03304259479045868, 0.029784055426716805, -0.039277415722608566, 0.013493920676410198, 0.022132018581032753, 0.017126495018601418, -0.0024666551034897566, 0.06136834993958473, -0.005496426019817591, -0.006093667354434729, 0.0023807953111827374, 0.03293916583061218, -0.04022827371954918, 0.04110262915492058, 0.07823652774095535, -0.015036419034004211, -0.020241407677531242, 0.0319780632853508, -0.05842997878789902, -0.029766544699668884, 0.0054763141088187695, 0.044154658913612366, 0.03603564202785492, -0.028642011806368828, -0.01975058764219284, -0.024508001282811165, 0.05368637293577194, -0.0013761423761025071, 0.03351074829697609, 0.05570903792977333, -0.03460244834423065, 0.012783846817910671, -0.037318456918001175, -0.06457144021987915, -0.0004883661167696118, -0.011601640842854977, -0.006959468126296997, -0.003930994775146246, 0.032142315059900284, 0.006397429388016462, 0.018094876781105995, 0.02704925276339054, 0.018716048449277878, 0.023757992312312126, 0.03211485594511032, 0.0002256878069601953, 0.0019077302422374487, 0.008801436983048916, -0.023864122107625008, 0.06777524203062057, 0.02934124693274498, -0.02548823691904545, 0.06214318424463272, -0.04675952345132828, -0.04974367842078209, 0.024026766419410706, 0.013547632843255997, -0.0834868997335434, 0.00469515286386013, 0.021022137254476547, 0.028688965365290642, -0.0222536101937294, -0.005257552023977041, -0.03485286980867386, 0.03172186762094498, -0.010133834555745125, -0.009754182770848274, -0.023889336735010147, 0.05132262781262398, 0.04088444262742996, 0.044301245361566544, -0.01531984657049179, 0.038546666502952576, 0.03484354540705681, 0.0326179675757885, 0.053286828100681305, -0.014214183203876019, 0.04246130585670471, -0.03426133841276169, 0.0031199310906231403, -0.025436166673898697, 0.036893654614686966, -0.01752915047109127, -0.015066809952259064, 0.017601389437913895, 0.027743183076381683, 0.0012136787408962846, -0.018529674038290977, 0.01904219388961792, -0.011555170640349388, 0.007266449276357889, -0.00044163415441289544, 0.0412885881960392, 0.05163786560297012, 0.007225103676319122, 0.010840230621397495, 0.04182436689734459, -0.06466192752122879, 0.03832327574491501, -0.05427059158682823, 0.0644604042172432, 0.02590978518128395, 0.04277179017663002, -0.016144001856446266, -0.05664608255028725, -0.004308286588639021, -0.02314453385770321, -0.036998700350522995, 0.04097776859998703, 0.01743459142744541, 0.010605818592011929, -0.014667796902358532, -0.05796057730913162, -0.01350280549377203, 0.07552947849035263, -0.034684959799051285, 0.0020107559394091368, -0.07337691634893417, 0.024029988795518875, 0.014363948255777359, 0.00677461177110672, -0.013409961014986038, -0.021080441772937775, 0.030908677726984024, 0.024088097736239433, -0.0019825987983494997, -0.029664641246199608, 0.013473814353346825, -0.03543033450841904, 0.013054941780865192, -0.035982947796583176, -0.05384978652000427, -0.05709782615303993, -0.001981884939596057, 0.022219708189368248, -0.017435720190405846, 0.009297632612287998, -0.04237114638090134, -0.05724181607365608, 0.12317883223295212, 0.02414046786725521, -0.011197247542440891, -0.0029689380899071693, -0.046286873519420624, 0.009316998533904552, 0.03846504166722298, 0.013073253445327282, 0.00783554743975401, 0.01573149301111698, 0.01509455218911171, 0.11241129040718079, -0.007335257716476917, -0.0030745083931833506, 0.02659650519490242, -0.02889341674745083, 0.03898884728550911, -0.015932435169816017, 0.03469855710864067, -0.014450257644057274, -0.023319434374570847, 0.01838243380188942, 0.014361994341015816, -0.049131765961647034, -0.060788948088884354, -0.015863995999097824, -0.05415351316332817, 0.014102582819759846, -0.025966091081500053, 0.030858326703310013, 0.034062933176755905, 0.0012605189112946391, -0.10157463699579239, 0.041816141456365585, 0.0003421416040509939, 0.003990017808973789, 0.001064022071659565, -0.001450969255529344, 0.00323290447704494, -0.013650381937623024, -0.028017887845635414, -0.022357068955898285, -0.05399414896965027, 0.05439361557364464, 0.01217893697321415, -0.00423792889341712, -0.015200742520391941, -0.008947070688009262, 0.048376962542533875, -0.0729188621044159, -0.024537913501262665, 0.019349949434399605, -0.024550700560212135, -0.00004173537308815867, 0.036497924476861954, -0.018097544088959694, -0.009847109206020832, -0.017186200246214867, 0.023438511416316032, -0.012315795756876469, 0.03142044320702553, 0.005678769201040268, 0.004138849209994078, -0.016186388209462166, -0.010498316958546638, 0.0601092167198658, 0.001931184669956565, -0.02660251408815384, -0.032533418387174606, 0.004067305941134691, 0.003851605113595724, 0.003026285208761692, -0.04494592919945717, 0.053933318704366684, 0.04545309767127037, -0.047089558094739914, 0.054036952555179596, 0.034270111471414566, 0.0019131922163069248, 0.007745015434920788, 0.019347667694091797, 0.006465103477239609, -0.053763728588819504, -0.012969935312867165, -0.01954234018921852, -0.04332997649908066, -0.026929788291454315, 0.050339214503765106, -0.05313847213983536, -0.039517585188150406, 0.00008122381404973567, -0.08100911229848862, -0.030804898589849472, 0.0452258437871933, -0.04940081760287285, -0.013817460276186466, 0.028655674308538437, 0.020806223154067993, 0.04015310853719711, -0.0308205708861351, 0.026411158964037895, 0.047464389353990555, 0.03921712934970856, 0.01491987332701683, -0.0066410088911652565, 0.01963035576045513, 0.029477950185537338, 0.05597425997257233, -0.004156764596700668, 0.0008084339206106961, 0.10196609050035477, -0.06432240456342697, -0.04769667237997055, 0.0329669788479805, 0.07019476592540741, -0.011714912950992584, 0.0372297503054142, -0.001496877521276474, 0.052664048969745636, 0.005577764939516783, -0.03102809190750122, -0.005779382307082415, -0.019849445670843124, -0.012481767684221268, 0.039109110832214355, 0.05411340668797493, 0.009902535937726498, 0.023986969143152237, 0.027471428737044334, -0.012534352019429207, 0.058700449764728546, 0.016277801245450974, -0.01973654329776764, -0.007737034931778908, 0.03016548417508602, 0.00284356321208179, -0.042596276849508286, 0.04770568758249283, 0.02829180657863617, -0.01952289789915085, -0.02533888816833496, -0.07250815629959106, 0.08365720510482788, 0.02661704830825329, 0.053590159863233566, -0.032607369124889374, 0.01091046817600727, -0.019387662410736084, 0.013563057407736778, 0.00016263217548839748, -0.049099698662757874, -0.0030947583727538586, -0.034550800919532776, -0.04388343542814255, 0.018878739327192307, 0.023074904456734657, -0.030542731285095215, -0.04660436883568764, -0.00853306520730257, -0.04244929552078247, -0.0462949238717556, 0.017000878229737282, 0.023778265342116356, 0.012423461303114891, -0.015192746184766293, -0.03853736072778702, 0.01844971813261509, 0.028785554692149162, -0.005848077591508627, -0.043376971036195755, 0.04984893277287483, -0.008078000508248806, 0.021650053560733795, 0.036667950451374054, -0.022887419909238815, -0.022541677579283714, -0.02415870502591133, 0.0003166938840877265, 0.021126946434378624, -0.003173071425408125, -0.013715623877942562, -0.01249638106673956, 0.045146048069000244, -0.013840587809681892, 0.02848995476961136, -0.029025539755821228, 0.03136155381798744, -0.00022005928622093052, -0.012993247248232365, -0.04037243872880936, -0.0009456657571718097, -0.057494115084409714, -0.04563681408762932, 0.020563917234539986, -0.02514546364545822, -0.02223312109708786, -0.01230017002671957, 0.037868648767471313, 0.020941399037837982, -0.0538661852478981, -0.0059445141814649105, -0.0007697282126173377, 0.015596547164022923, -0.038551900535821915, 0.039923783391714096, 0.07861185073852539, -0.08844462037086487, -0.019166525453329086, -0.06035448983311653, 0.05099428445100784, -0.03766881674528122, 0.020718511193990707, -0.007622803561389446, -0.0023067621514201164, -0.024509672075510025, -0.07829513400793076, 0.01741134561598301, -0.0778859481215477, 0.020053233951330185, 0.07099094241857529, -0.022607862949371338, -0.004460243973881006, -0.036930814385414124, -0.01895449310541153, 0.05268942192196846, 0.033465705811977386, -0.05801180377602577, 0.011107638478279114, -0.06829620897769928, -0.03928114101290703, -0.03927517682313919, -0.0003780830302275717, 0.00449930876493454, 0.017757341265678406, 0.06480344384908676, -0.09447736293077469, -0.019807850942015648, -0.05472618341445923, -0.01286974735558033, -0.044821176677942276, 0.04713999852538109, 0.01641848497092724, -0.04993255436420441, 0.027825461700558662, -0.026636121794581413, 0.03398117050528526, -0.013193441554903984, 0.0024920341093093157, 0.02778446301817894, -0.07647829502820969, -0.042670588940382004, -0.07724829763174057, -0.001977186417207122, -0.002073789481073618, -0.062003571540117264, 0.062174756079912186, 0.012745155952870846, -0.013620984740555286, 0.03381656855344772, 0.057783715426921844, -0.03783096745610237, 0.0030573063995689154, 0.053556106984615326, 0.0638684406876564, -0.01456093043088913, -0.009050155058503151, -0.042481351643800735, -0.012998872436583042, 0.03083239495754242, -0.007227905560284853, -0.04422731325030327, -0.040040574967861176, -0.0021644379012286663 ]
<p>Lets say we have a potential step with regions 1 with zero potential $W_p\!=\!0$ (this is a free particle) and region 2 with potential $W_p$. Wave functions in this case are: </p> <p>\begin{align} \psi_1&amp;=Ae^{i\mathcal L x} + B e^{-i\mathcal L x} &amp; \mathcal L &amp;\equiv \sqrt{\frac{2mW}{\hbar^2}}\\ \psi_2&amp;=De^{-\mathcal K x} &amp; \mathcal K &amp;\equiv \sqrt{\frac{2m(W_p-W)}{\hbar^2}} \end{align}</p> <p>Where $A$ is an amplitude of an incomming wave, $B$ is an amplitude of an reflected wave and $D$ is an amplitude of an transmitted wave. I have sucessfuly derived a relations between amplitudes in potential step: </p> <p>\begin{align} \frac{A}{D} &amp;= \frac{i\mathcal L-\mathcal K}{2i\mathcal L} &amp; \frac{A}{B}&amp;=-\frac{i \mathcal L - \mathcal K}{i \mathcal L + \mathcal K} \end{align}</p> <p>I know that if i want to calculate transmittivity coefficient $T$ or reflexifity coefficient $R$ i will have to use these two relations that i know from wave physics:</p> <p>\begin{align} T &amp;= \frac{j_{trans.}}{j_{incom.}} &amp; R &amp;= \frac{j_{trans.}}{j_{incom.}} \end{align}</p> <hr> <p><strong>Question 1:</strong> I know that $j = \frac{dm}{dt} = \frac{d}{dt}\rho V \propto \rho v \propto \rho k$ But what is a density $\rho$ equal to?</p> <p><strong>Question 2:</strong> I noticed that $\mathcal L$ and $\mathcal K$ are somehow (i dont know how) connected to the wavevector $k$ from the equation in 1st question but how? How can i make it obvious?</p>
g4262
[ -0.016236349940299988, -0.04900028184056282, -0.011204022914171219, -0.014708825387060642, 0.05853627994656563, -0.0023968673776835203, 0.033253252506256104, 0.02577182836830616, -0.02504112757742405, 0.023867139592766762, -0.09230323135852814, 0.06056957691907883, 0.06375396251678467, 0.05020056664943695, -0.009311804547905922, -0.0019391754176467657, 0.0709298625588417, 0.0050085606053471565, 0.051754556596279144, -0.020167261362075806, -0.0005886520957574248, -0.007742033340036869, -0.022967934608459473, -0.05378151312470436, -0.0010151127353310585, -0.039677415043115616, 0.019003573805093765, -0.032729823142290115, -0.06448055803775787, -0.03697073459625244, 0.021341444924473763, 0.0012852181680500507, 0.0760272741317749, -0.04257383197546005, -0.07492814213037491, 0.029630199074745178, 0.012828705832362175, 0.04792408645153046, -0.017418140545487404, 0.026994096115231514, 0.009457554668188095, -0.002896822988986969, 0.02975292317569256, -0.013948380947113037, 0.027628758922219276, -0.014978181570768356, -0.06669508665800095, 0.00030000266269780695, 0.01127726398408413, -0.05404869467020035, -0.007082444615662098, -0.0018840593984350562, 0.03353568911552429, 0.010345092974603176, -0.04348400607705116, 0.06870720535516739, -0.016809381544589996, -0.04203588515520096, 0.06326767802238464, 0.011317485012114048, 0.009885862469673157, -0.023356180638074875, 0.0073557086288928986, -0.024083469063043594, 0.05180805176496506, 0.005299284588545561, -0.021281767636537552, 0.02995466999709606, -0.034152403473854065, -0.0025872995611280203, 0.011056057177484035, -0.07177574187517166, -0.03408660367131233, -0.0784587562084198, -0.021253835409879684, -0.010861271061003208, 0.008773998357355595, -0.02111879363656044, 0.05454913154244423, -0.012920154258608818, -0.011881975457072258, -0.07132208347320557, 0.024773042649030685, 0.04748523235321045, 0.010897195897996426, 0.004269859753549099, 0.04250715300440788, 0.025471830740571022, 0.0443836972117424, 0.0006369239999912679, 0.006382843479514122, -0.0516502782702446, 0.051489103585481644, 0.03981509059667587, 0.060857776552438736, 0.00005383263487601653, -0.034136515110731125, 0.01512719877064228, 0.006882260553538799, -0.05612044408917427, -0.004391935653984547, 0.030134372413158417, -0.015583451837301254, 0.027798805385828018, -0.016287479549646378, 0.009379724971950054, 0.037545353174209595, 0.006556292530149221, -0.016279032453894615, 0.026143088936805725, -0.056317288428545, -0.019173070788383484, -0.041824132204055786, -0.03933453559875488, -0.01999582163989544, -0.07996219396591187, 0.006687521934509277, -0.023640597239136696, -0.06071993336081505, 0.043373651802539825, -0.009524239227175713, 0.016692662611603737, 0.04321952909231186, 0.054656874388456345, 0.0069130645133554935, 0.022539649158716202, 0.0069060055539011955, 0.003890502965077758, 0.01918753795325756, 0.049432698637247086, 0.06838822364807129, -0.02608606591820717, -0.043061770498752594, 0.041127875447273254, -0.01057715155184269, -0.01964912936091423, 0.01957831159234047, 0.011944483034312725, 0.018316809087991714, 0.02930961363017559, -0.005620826035737991, -0.023300107568502426, 0.0029980081599205732, -0.04463062435388565, -0.07629130780696869, -0.0017050824826583266, 0.02101781964302063, -0.06547337770462036, 0.08881929516792297, -0.018593622371554375, 0.011323019862174988, 0.02119317837059498, -0.017893925309181213, -0.010128338821232319, 0.06264875084161758, -0.03946680203080177, 0.035487763583660126, -0.04358843341469765, 0.01417333073914051, -0.005921324249356985, 0.03949678689241409, -0.0362100750207901, 0.009397286921739578, 0.03435254469513893, 0.029956867918372154, -0.05109115689992905, 0.05460153520107269, -0.06867033243179321, 0.03509174659848213, -0.008349534124135971, -0.02804662473499775, -0.008264538832008839, 0.020878860726952553, 0.023506319150328636, 0.00010984687833115458, 0.04584570229053497, -0.029610618948936462, -0.02641548402607441, 0.05555424466729164, 0.047810740768909454, -0.049529675394296646, 0.013770169578492641, 0.01933985948562622, 0.0058327666483819485, -0.011646321043372154, -0.021968401968479156, -0.018881822004914284, -0.01755061373114586, -0.036253806203603745, 0.004958838224411011, -0.03700864687561989, 0.03182213753461838, -0.02684553526341915, 0.005109874531626701, -0.030184729024767876, -0.00504743168130517, 0.02172262594103813, -0.04495862498879433, -0.03174949437379837, -0.020276015624403954, 0.028316838666796684, 0.011893878690898418, 0.06693796813488007, 0.008087854832410812, 0.08334668725728989, 0.05446341261267662, 0.025995733216404915, 0.007582826539874077, -0.016492757946252823, 0.031091416254639626, -0.02454531192779541, -0.050843141973018646, -0.03385167568922043, -0.011337940581142902, -0.04510655626654625, -0.04668897017836571, -0.02921404130756855, 0.018646299839019775, -0.023925622925162315, -0.0026995965745300055, -0.05327735096216202, 0.005173121578991413, 0.029971007257699966, -0.008086008951067924, -0.057620324194431305, 0.04571862891316414, -0.01409790851175785, 0.003875343594700098, 0.0059267752803862095, 0.022745376452803612, -0.06256882846355438, -0.004392719827592373, 0.011650370433926582, 0.003473617834970355, 0.029860708862543106, 0.07580363750457764, -0.04603338614106178, 0.016110390424728394, 0.016180304810404778, -0.01646413281559944, 0.012973855249583721, -0.052483297884464264, -0.018082594498991966, 0.01798062026500702, 0.04235358536243439, 0.041082851588726044, 0.038730595260858536, 0.06140194088220596, 0.00631349952891469, -0.0024240752682089806, -0.01872118189930916, 0.011583265848457813, -0.02462773397564888, 0.03832237794995308, -0.04184543713927269, 0.012426851317286491, 0.00741977896541357, 0.04663228616118431, -0.006237941328436136, -0.055767834186553955, 0.02513783797621727, 0.03155514597892761, -0.005275406874716282, 0.04130028560757637, -0.07890033721923828, 0.043807923793792725, -0.017716888338327408, 0.050737008452415466, -0.007214820943772793, -0.015485045500099659, 0.03483666852116585, 0.05390050634741783, 0.045175161212682724, 0.05500796064734459, -0.017346389591693878, 0.010344955138862133, 0.02046060375869274, -0.06077560782432556, 0.0016878389287739992, -0.023833760991692543, -0.0009063765755854547, 0.015058178454637527, -0.0031101072672754526, 0.02155180275440216, 0.03832608833909035, -0.038219958543777466, 0.06860866397619247, 0.08176324516534805, -0.014902741648256779, 0.03546888381242752, 0.028985392302274704, 0.0040270560421049595, -0.03349322825670242, 0.10807382315397263, -0.0806054025888443, 0.013725249096751213, 0.01789279095828533, -0.0895649716258049, 0.04483553394675255, -0.033873818814754486, 0.03386924788355827, 0.0315152183175087, -0.0077744172886013985, -0.015882547944784164, 0.019642604514956474, -0.003948553930968046, -0.018394794315099716, -0.06837815791368484, -0.014611789956688881, 0.044358182698488235, -0.03100472129881382, -0.00947890430688858, 0.006661340594291687, -0.01284029334783554, 0.00640899920836091, 0.006077643483877182, -0.04527405649423599, 0.018230736255645752, 0.01990903913974762, 0.017123229801654816, -0.04981866851449013, -0.052409373223781586, 0.030331945046782494, -0.019216973334550858, 0.0011871918104588985, -0.028661051765084267, -0.06285838037729263, -0.017591405659914017, -0.02439517341554165, -0.028570491820573807, 0.0017912653274834156, 0.0681983083486557, 0.04790547117590904, -0.000013846633009961806, -0.04451555386185646, -0.06512724608182907, -0.036034874618053436, -0.008072414435446262, -0.016564834862947464, -0.018319666385650635, -0.04735316336154938, -0.04655791074037552, -0.039533354341983795, -0.005721519235521555, -0.012806851416826248, 0.0020885858684778214, 0.01178000122308731, 0.034941352903842926, 0.010486189275979996, -0.028225598856806755, -0.02838560938835144, -0.004897300619632006, 0.03471410647034645, -0.03266625106334686, -0.007407997269183397, -0.0011388784041628242, 0.05804844945669174, 0.009545322507619858, 0.06168622151017189, -0.03950238227844238, 0.009316669777035713, -0.039920657873153687, 0.01579718105494976, 0.011277394369244576, 0.005738392472267151, -0.06121222302317619, 0.04054320976138115, 0.0471368245780468, -0.015190222300589085, 0.019709695130586624, 0.037539657205343246, -0.04684070125222206, -0.03664326295256615, 0.05888691917061806, 0.00223184609785676, -0.057270731776952744, -0.041194286197423935, -0.005002434831112623, -0.04062889143824577, 0.060216404497623444, 0.029493721202015877, -0.000668705499265343, 0.04914290830492973, 0.002152109984308481, 0.06598537415266037, -0.030889427289366722, -0.028099851682782173, -0.027750538662075996, 0.030000289902091026, -0.03628562390804291, 0.02844914235174656, -0.014204546809196472, -0.0263994038105011, -0.014733998104929924, 0.0032362935598939657, -0.016517868265509605, 0.02130231261253357, 0.023807281628251076, -0.09068255871534348, 0.03788042813539505, -0.06932646781206131, -0.010687883011996746, 0.009191525168716908, 0.016635283827781677, -0.009415755979716778, -0.004643268883228302, 0.022239871323108673, -0.05425621196627617, -0.027360696345567703, -0.06839140504598618, 0.010772272013127804, -0.017149263992905617, -0.023503245785832405, -0.07525383681058884, -0.0728951171040535, -0.026922764256596565, 0.025845039635896683, -0.049626000225543976, -0.01743434928357601, 0.012776842340826988, -0.0017634688410907984, 0.011038842611014843, 0.04270806536078453, -0.04049362987279892, 0.0305262990295887, 0.030284376814961433, 0.07191648334264755, 0.006220802199095488, 0.00994010828435421, -0.0010730051435530186, -0.0057038841769099236, 0.042444948107004166, 0.03785446286201477, -0.0007219762774184346, -0.047324132174253464, 0.025298427790403366, -0.05209781602025032, 0.03322001174092293, 0.03169731795787811, -0.01322638988494873, 0.011388182640075684, -0.008243229240179062, -0.03249039500951767, -0.04126395657658577, 0.0010390941752120852, 0.05097154155373573, -0.05234212428331375, -0.058294378221035004, 0.01625676266849041, -0.0331641286611557, -0.011763143353164196, 0.05372707545757294, 0.020033160224556923, -0.08743041753768921, 0.0002806374686770141, 0.02796238660812378, 0.01741153746843338, 0.03296908736228943, -0.020054515451192856, -0.07645026594400406, 0.010032515041530132, 0.015254972502589226, 0.053956467658281326, -0.04252735897898674, 0.027827110141515732, -0.045366257429122925, -0.023780718445777893, 0.06583774834871292, -0.07313238829374313, -0.013352736830711365, 0.030108407139778137, -0.03535885736346245, 0.045555371791124344, 0.033605869859457016, -0.01465803012251854, 0.029044093564152718, -0.02096407301723957, -0.006826341152191162, -0.029897456988692284, -0.040263596922159195, 0.0500982441008091, 0.01130138523876667, -0.014763341285288334, -0.015556472353637218, -0.01698906533420086, 0.01971718855202198, -0.04120578244328499, 0.007996264845132828, -0.04205366224050522, -0.03255362808704376, 0.014050512574613094, -0.0030780669767409563, -0.04300357401371002, 0.014724036678671837, -0.015081875957548618, -0.01158974226564169, 0.004973978269845247, -0.004735380876809359, 0.0061526005156338215, 0.08005814254283905, 0.03597792237997055, -0.008950098417699337, 0.01647840067744255, 0.05559968203306198, -0.030698727816343307, 0.04411513730883598, 0.10201731324195862, -0.012721487320959568, -0.0057839080691337585, 0.04260845109820366, -0.01591394655406475, 0.005871627014130354, 0.017470795661211014, -0.006229910999536514, 0.04827004671096802, 0.016468655318021774, -0.05897021293640137, 0.040624674409627914, -0.08572277426719666, 0.007012370508164167, 0.04963156208395958, 0.013066533952951431, 0.03181138262152672, 0.013777794316411018, 0.017039567232131958, -0.05742547661066055, -0.0420735701918602, -0.034692589193582535, 0.07075938582420349, 0.01261548325419426, -0.037377119064331055, 0.05816711485385895, -0.018642514944076538, 0.03899073600769043, 0.037877701222896576, -0.08820471167564392, 0.011582068167626858, -0.015477302484214306, -0.00849447026848793, 0.0007149877492338419, 0.006471754517406225, 0.029045263305306435, 0.003180604660883546, 0.01822882890701294, -0.011461758054792881, 0.024535730481147766, 0.0597228966653347, -0.04248993471264839, 0.017809156328439713, -0.0005464550922624767, -0.06822724640369415, 0.007620606571435928, -0.035903528332710266, -0.02939903736114502, 0.008975841104984283, -0.017938733100891113, 0.009700957685709, -0.06485460698604584, -0.03971431031823158, 0.007297067902982235, 0.06966693699359894, 0.002103058621287346, -0.031112274155020714, -0.0076072062365710735, -0.010852616280317307, -0.007643416058272123, 0.009832637384533882, 0.04280839487910271, 0.00945803988724947, 0.013278929516673088, -0.014805248938500881, -0.01749345101416111, 0.03708653524518013, -0.023297807201743126, 0.032519590109586716, 0.08508390188217163, -0.021831704303622246, -0.015583864413201809, -0.002876246115192771, 0.019133955240249634, -0.054213929921388626, 0.02832925133407116, -0.010910454206168652, -0.06505988538265228, -0.08774365484714508, 0.02991023100912571, -0.01896761916577816, -0.0902232974767685, 0.06551225483417511, 0.006308953743427992, -0.05601305514574051, -0.01618204452097416, -0.028409315273165703, -0.0455818846821785, 0.015210757032036781, -0.05088472366333008, 0.05235767737030983, -0.015097860246896744, 0.001702717854641378, 0.045007605105638504, 0.012909431010484695, -0.03779203072190285, 0.0017995601519942284, -0.0063030612654984, -0.057187024503946304, -0.0004570457385852933, 0.012935495004057884, -0.023507997393608093, -0.05951203405857086, 0.03728150576353073, -0.026352573186159134, 0.034540124237537384, 0.05172794312238693, -0.022264545783400536, 0.0469389446079731, -0.03887765854597092, -0.002659002086147666, 0.05490138754248619, -0.010304925963282585, -0.00448067020624876, 0.046600814908742905, 0.0018396007362753153, 0.0098115848377347, 0.005974400322884321, 0.02890385314822197, 0.05170832574367523, -0.028562676161527634, -0.03622518852353096, -0.01406205166131258, 0.021546723321080208, 0.06224844604730606, 0.01896723359823227, 0.012171107344329357, 0.03715620934963226, -0.0053132688626646996, 0.0625542402267456, -0.04526950418949127, 0.05564042180776596, -0.009768690913915634, 0.011571230366826057, 0.013599849306046963, 0.05317329987883568, -0.04584122821688652, -0.015015831217169762, -0.04729371517896652, -0.011317609809339046, 0.02621297724545002, -0.039183858782052994, -0.1214580088853836, 0.031944096088409424, 0.03579189255833626, 0.004377439618110657, 0.003907470963895321, 0.02946219965815544, -0.011844892986118793, 0.01760547049343586, 0.02318711206316948, 0.05905293673276901, 0.03243982046842575, -0.02777285687625408, 0.007204088382422924, -0.05345352739095688, 0.036811962723731995, -0.02181105501949787, -0.015748199075460434, 0.07140687108039856, 0.0073168654926121235, -0.027422018349170685, -0.048064544796943665, -0.03396622836589813, 0.015216954052448273, -0.0039582448080182076, -0.0455295704305172, -0.007331088185310364, -0.01844845712184906, 0.0030997965950518847, 0.03991783410310745, 0.010340584442019463, -0.032064225524663925, 0.02836557850241661, 0.004964080639183521, 0.012099053710699081, 0.01856740191578865, 0.022513533011078835, -0.02553217113018036, 0.057633157819509506, -0.003672803519293666, -0.04064543917775154, -0.015310927294194698, 0.012911561876535416, -0.022246627137064934, 0.04502137750387192, 0.044888488948345184, -0.031341250985860825, 0.014502561651170254, -0.02338981069624424, -0.016940684989094734, 0.0335867702960968, 0.005094821099191904, 0.0016444927314296365, 0.022401124238967896, -0.012329020537436008, -0.024252232164144516, 0.0037330398336052895, 0.08460775762796402, -0.010911610908806324, -0.005363764241337776, -0.04221460968255997, -0.004404289182275534, -0.010279010981321335, 0.03512672707438469, 0.013125242665410042, 0.05443188175559044, -0.010311529971659184, -0.014315139502286911, 0.03285592421889305, -0.050006203353405, 0.07960762828588486, 0.03115367703139782, -0.0062241763807833195, 0.03351612016558647, 0.00018116565479431301, -0.0006216666079126298, -0.07204096019268036, 0.01931232213973999, 0.0005785396788269281, -0.04854314774274826, -0.01844634674489498, -0.013097726739943027, 0.044033315032720566, -0.022656213492155075, 0.004284147638827562, -0.03478119894862175, 0.03391804173588753, 0.0042355917394161224, -0.026732131838798523, 0.02973760850727558, 0.04720960557460785, 0.0018184708897024393, 0.03065817803144455, -0.0021897158585488796, -0.05314574018120766, -0.011810495518147945, -0.012744254432618618, -0.014063005335628986, -0.03486074134707451, -0.005734821781516075, 0.06875286251306534, 0.06352820247411728, -0.0181000716984272, -0.007113836705684662, 0.0467572882771492, -0.04559337720274925, 0.034460533410310745, 0.027858056128025055, -0.05578300729393959, 0.005086211953312159, 0.012775405310094357, 0.04235519468784332, -0.020170871168375015, -0.012173370458185673, -0.010899856686592102, -0.041220806539058685, 0.010687876492738724, -0.02313406392931938, -0.01666790246963501, -0.03089863806962967, 0.028811922296881676 ]
<p>I would like to find the equation of motion for the scalar field $\phi$ by varying the following action in General Relativity. </p> <p>Special Relativity: $$ S = -\tfrac{1}{2}\int d^4\xi\, \eta^{ab} \partial_a \phi\partial_b\phi $$</p> <p>General Relativity: $$ S = -\tfrac{1}{2}\int d^4x \sqrt{g}\, g^{\mu\nu} \partial_{\mu} \phi\partial_\nu \phi $$</p> <p>I was able to get the correct equation using the covariant derivatives. Since they are constant with respect to the metric partial integration works and one obtains $ \Box\phi = 0$. But since for the scalar field the covariant and the partial derivates are the same I wanted to vary the action with the partial derivatives. </p> <p>Note: $\phi \rightarrow \phi + \delta\phi$ $$ \begin{align} \delta S &amp;= -\tfrac{1}{2}\int d^4x \sqrt{g}\, (g^{\mu\nu} \partial_{\mu} \delta\phi\partial_\nu\phi + g^{\mu\nu} \partial_{\mu} \phi\partial_{\nu} \delta\phi ) \\ % &amp;=-\int d^4x \sqrt{g}\, g^{\mu\nu} \partial_{\mu} \delta\phi\partial_\nu\delta\phi \\ % &amp;=\int d^4x \, \partial_\nu(\sqrt{g}\,g^{\mu\nu}\partial_\mu\phi)\delta\phi \end{align} $$ The third line one obtains after partial integration. But at this point I'm stuck. I know the following definition: $$ \Box\phi = \tfrac{1}{\sqrt{g}}\partial_\mu(\sqrt{g}g^{\mu\nu}\partial_\nu\phi) $$ But I'm not able to convert my obtained solution into this. Thanks for your help!</p>
g4263
[ 0.004921441897749901, 0.009527741000056267, -0.011707158759236336, 0.00199971254914999, 0.04725360497832298, -0.005675713066011667, 0.07544289529323578, -0.0013630627654492855, -0.01627206988632679, 0.001413610647432506, -0.004372179042547941, 0.01852673478424549, -0.022424524649977684, -0.02952759712934494, 0.007734613958746195, -0.008446665480732918, 0.05573946610093117, -0.05656921863555908, -0.04518050700426102, 0.015473896637558937, -0.00043668036232702434, 0.019695889204740524, 0.03989668935537338, -0.016871144995093346, 0.07329186052083969, -0.008516740053892136, 0.00920893158763647, 0.015918169170618057, -0.04327017441391945, -0.013714607805013657, -0.03967341408133507, 0.04175030067563057, 0.05523068830370903, -0.02435007505118847, 0.033036328852176666, 0.007658032234758139, 0.07816129177808762, 0.027298366650938988, 0.04333071783185005, -0.03049663081765175, 0.011030847206711769, -0.06076623871922493, 0.006977877113968134, 0.012669823132455349, 0.02826467901468277, -0.04261510446667671, -0.0013969421852380037, -0.02951185591518879, -0.011287225410342216, 0.005817821249365807, -0.0034990806598216295, 0.05374206602573395, -0.011233329772949219, -0.028469473123550415, -0.02920452319085598, 0.05790790542960167, 0.01183382049202919, 0.009974461048841476, -0.007878377102315426, 0.0149214006960392, -0.052905358374118805, -0.08123151957988739, 0.055109940469264984, -0.002592350821942091, 0.03830802068114281, 0.0050446707755327225, -0.005272952374070883, -0.09068787842988968, 0.01467212289571762, -0.03436894714832306, -0.005624369252473116, 0.007805346045643091, 0.05473865568637848, 0.038308221846818924, -0.027095019817352295, -0.008536512963473797, 0.005928043741732836, 0.0049090576358139515, -0.005883131641894579, -0.03493233770132065, 0.0032332069240510464, -0.026793157681822777, 0.06863971799612045, 0.07049345970153809, 0.03250511735677719, 0.028965089470148087, -0.0072633191011846066, -0.0002764796372503042, -0.047245096415281296, -0.0029793567955493927, -0.003009801497682929, 0.031213056296110153, 0.025945842266082764, 0.04768635705113411, 0.031180763617157936, -0.04545941576361656, 0.01553218811750412, 0.043096400797367096, 0.03567921742796898, -0.005748969502747059, -0.033240675926208496, 0.026426119729876518, 0.03317226842045784, 0.004835369065403938, -0.0847134217619896, -0.03896339610219002, 0.014400176703929901, 0.023713769391179085, 0.006715521682053804, -0.019879616796970367, -0.028450585901737213, -0.009024196304380894, 0.05675354227423668, -0.05726584047079086, 0.006988530047237873, -0.0232099536806345, -0.016016094014048576, -0.028643272817134857, -0.03413981571793556, -0.014475598931312561, -0.006310970988124609, -0.023528356105089188, 0.021268604323267937, 0.03217283636331558, -0.05153742432594299, -0.032076988369226456, -0.04593917727470398, 0.040257737040519714, 0.06581013649702072, -0.0038753990083932877, 0.006686922162771225, -0.022211169824004173, 0.05817369371652603, 0.047770969569683075, -0.03736479580402374, 0.018627936020493507, -0.005023968406021595, 0.03248610720038414, -0.005138339940458536, 0.0023742993362247944, 0.002782764146104455, -0.009078259579837322, 0.008911642245948315, 0.04049735516309738, -0.002635257551446557, 0.06962084770202637, 0.022112436592578888, -0.004143833182752132, 0.019722944125533104, -0.003542164107784629, 0.03084285743534565, 0.08386462181806564, -0.018919365480542183, 0.028284532949328423, 0.00741294352337718, -0.03150185942649841, 0.0007744001341052353, 0.011932027526199818, -0.033227574080228806, -0.04110153391957283, 0.08012259751558304, 0.020098574459552765, 0.013928843662142754, -0.011568908579647541, -0.01263072993606329, 0.06904511153697968, -0.02957320399582386, 0.003150133416056633, 0.0026298125740140676, -0.058767952024936676, -0.0003591526474338025, 0.00646199518814683, 0.013415517285466194, 0.03572565317153931, -0.006597092840820551, 0.03537748381495476, 0.03329984098672867, 0.014189080335199833, 0.0065880645997822285, 0.04793715849518776, 0.0013057587202638388, -0.015680566430091858, 0.015043962746858597, -0.06871885061264038, 0.005951297469437122, -0.025428690016269684, -0.0002031287585850805, -0.008379701524972916, -0.0390852726995945, 0.0014406992122530937, -0.03223639726638794, -0.022302215918898582, 0.00793435052037239, 0.044718459248542786, -0.04146172106266022, 0.05937657132744789, 0.02773933671414852, -0.08053463697433472, -0.026376347988843918, 0.016691904515028, -0.012425832450389862, 0.029553763568401337, 0.034401483833789825, -0.014762109145522118, 0.07530152797698975, -0.0452551506459713, 0.030143503099679947, -0.04919515550136566, 0.09236888587474823, 0.02015983872115612, 0.025708217173814774, -0.07141201943159103, -0.016224272549152374, -0.04958838224411011, -0.013560590334236622, -0.07338769733905792, 0.05908095836639404, 0.046581339091062546, -0.012866359204053879, 0.0262308232486248, -0.033805280923843384, 0.02422506734728813, 0.007768615148961544, 0.0005875083152204752, -0.04358775168657303, 0.058830808848142624, 0.01623920165002346, -0.0077971164137125015, 0.008886358700692654, 0.04901789873838425, -0.024147868156433105, 0.03282073140144348, 0.0010201241821050644, 0.048493560403585434, 0.07603480666875839, 0.028462860733270645, -0.06277449429035187, -0.047480612993240356, 0.01182069443166256, 0.0359332300722599, 0.015949103981256485, 0.03461664170026779, -0.004959922283887863, -0.017789220437407494, 0.018201414495706558, 0.024846304208040237, 0.07434508204460144, 0.022302716970443726, -0.020156312733888626, -0.011255936697125435, 0.004185772500932217, -0.03128241375088692, 0.025047019124031067, -0.04379545897245407, 0.02328227460384369, -0.00465369550511241, -0.006117736455053091, 0.04658614471554756, 0.03913707658648491, 0.009726050309836864, -0.01732335425913334, -0.07081679254770279, -0.010687436908483505, 0.10133110731840134, 0.030346324667334557, -0.027628276497125626, 0.024640632793307304, 0.017037292942404747, 0.028820408508181572, -0.0012356481747701764, -0.04456549882888794, 0.02443757653236389, -0.015981649979948997, 0.04731816053390503, -0.028132295235991478, -0.025866040959954262, -0.009835329838097095, -0.0046045612543821335, 0.006152986083179712, 0.019670898094773293, 0.0162966325879097, 0.01741606555879116, 0.014853411354124546, 0.002974868519231677, 0.07735710591077805, -0.026293938979506493, 0.004307227209210396, 0.00021297515195328742, -0.013730539008975029, 0.06996413320302963, 0.01654907874763012, -0.009418158791959286, -0.07257453352212906, -0.03282661363482475, 0.002880676183849573, 0.05098475515842438, -0.049946825951337814, -0.01658712327480316, 0.010386740788817406, 0.04710502550005913, 0.013267520815134048, -0.032182611525058746, -0.05608561635017395, 0.044483933597803116, -0.06680843979120255, -0.04198358580470085, 0.02437254600226879, -0.013337117619812489, -0.000191046652616933, 0.005246485583484173, 0.007120976224541664, 0.012452322989702225, 0.0484636165201664, -0.0388229675590992, -0.05127640441060066, -0.02582305297255516, 0.009935712441802025, -0.026967786252498627, -0.006128688808530569, -0.0010242104763165116, 0.02935110777616501, -0.06401935964822769, -0.0773686021566391, -0.0021730023436248302, 0.018029790371656418, 0.03435813635587692, 0.008342007175087929, 0.04140694439411163, -0.0457301028072834, -0.03902379050850868, -0.07186305522918701, 0.003440184285864234, -0.007055996917188168, 0.004782098811119795, 0.0026679066941142082, 0.005669086240231991, -0.07700923085212708, 0.006265223957598209, 0.07111332565546036, -0.028388507664203644, 0.015542677603662014, -0.02908524125814438, -0.10374460369348526, 0.06372816860675812, -0.040273841470479965, -0.016560863703489304, 0.07568420469760895, -0.013051437214016914, -0.0008534314692951739, 0.027500972151756287, -0.06029100716114044, -0.03551541268825531, 0.006145351566374302, 0.024504899978637695, -0.017794549465179443, 0.01910170540213585, 0.037084050476551056, 0.052965015172958374, 0.008262407034635544, -0.0009402856230735779, 0.030956989154219627, -0.07618533819913864, -0.06177458167076111, 0.07741205394268036, 0.02671739086508751, 0.012231498956680298, 0.04229014739394188, -0.06478162109851837, -0.07096891850233078, -0.016881877556443214, 0.09888072311878204, -0.0008780306670814753, 0.03480905294418335, -0.02111230604350567, -0.02686256356537342, -0.06819884479045868, -0.016579335555434227, -0.006261543370783329, -0.04774095490574837, -0.01871727779507637, 0.03481565788388252, 0.005159197375178337, 0.002401952864602208, 0.02497347630560398, -0.009634749963879585, -0.02189973182976246, 0.00039469724288210273, -0.03793737292289734, -0.011727101169526577, 0.03729670122265816, -0.02709195390343666, 0.013745108619332314, -0.01749168150126934, -0.0014990343479439616, -0.0460825189948082, 0.04259238764643669, 0.015163158997893333, 0.04687201604247093, -0.08083976060152054, 0.010901780799031258, -0.03482257202267647, -0.017094552516937256, 0.018878191709518433, -0.012088865041732788, -0.052396662533283234, -0.01343684270977974, -0.00012987676018383354, -0.023771407082676888, 0.03843526914715767, -0.0048064133152365685, -0.04440739378333092, -0.0030126713681966066, 0.03108784556388855, -0.02909279242157936, 0.052322424948215485, 0.06542102247476578, -0.00503850681707263, 0.03818550333380699, -0.0041700503788888454, -0.013872165232896805, 0.051545772701501846, 0.004070402123034, 0.04612855985760689, -0.013552908785641193, 0.05517324060201645, 0.036681998521089554, 0.05151437222957611, -0.003499590326100588, 0.0011715344153344631, 0.0039271400310099125, -0.027560442686080933, 0.015302025713026524, 0.0063597168773412704, 0.07117169350385666, -0.10534954071044922, 0.08712127804756165, -0.06871635466814041, -0.03819608315825462, 0.013570060953497887, 0.01899302750825882, 0.037543199956417084, 0.059251025319099426, 0.013399454765021801, -0.045396097004413605, -0.003010442480444908, 0.038176029920578, -0.032526895403862, -0.08185099810361862, 0.0285384189337492, -0.025060001760721207, -0.05053647980093956, 0.002597888931632042, 0.012802536599338055, 0.032682280987501144, 0.011370698921382427, -0.019855661317706108, -0.06611280888319016, 0.016967756673693657, 0.00888868048787117, 0.04287024214863777, -0.01131050568073988, -0.00562143512070179, 0.012897894717752934, -0.01715710014104843, 0.06071833148598671, -0.01063359435647726, -0.07749279588460922, 0.011892956681549549, -0.0005496788653545082, -0.008432050235569477, 0.01389622688293457, -0.0005337389302439988, -0.03106079064309597, 0.0002780634968075901, 0.02595081552863121, 0.011541580781340599, 0.01209440641105175, 0.032518383115530014, -0.0012586497468873858, -0.02559252269566059, 0.00202964898198843, -0.030837267637252808, 0.01862562634050846, 0.021648822352290154, -0.002346696564927697, 0.03615858033299446, 0.034787777811288834, -0.008090450428426266, 0.0151514308527112, -0.06179448962211609, -0.0013933023437857628, 0.010987917892634869, 0.03233640268445015, 0.012302588671445847, -0.015581919811666012, 0.023072898387908936, -0.009091073647141457, 0.020725402981042862, 0.014459452591836452, 0.015748687088489532, -0.06492700427770615, 0.03775554522871971, -0.027175087481737137, -0.008267471566796303, -0.02649642713367939, 0.018620768561959267, 0.04068443924188614, 0.03567631542682648, -0.04543602466583252, 0.0422278493642807, 0.00978322047740221, 0.005514950957149267, 0.03961217403411865, 0.03644439950585365, -0.05228743329644203, 0.007065105717629194, 0.028350848704576492, -0.009650948457419872, 0.0323839895427227, -0.04920962080359459, 0.035726893693208694, 0.026388494297862053, -0.03549257665872574, -0.026848120614886284, 0.07399845123291016, 0.03577490895986557, -0.04628005996346474, -0.05056880787014961, 0.03236182779073715, -0.015518403612077236, 0.01204902958124876, -0.020520614460110664, 0.017805859446525574, -0.016165724024176598, -0.004792305175215006, -0.010540789924561977, -0.044732850044965744, -0.016434097662568092, 0.0199702437967062, -0.009941200725734234, -0.08980409055948257, -0.00565311498939991, -0.005731589626520872, 0.0005064225406385958, -0.035700153559446335, 0.0028172426391392946, -0.020483100786805153, -0.008096380159258842, -0.016174448654055595, 0.032800037413835526, -0.009745180606842041, 0.018446847796440125, -0.03684521093964577, 0.022243682295084, -0.008889124728739262, 0.0017458648653700948, 0.004185215570032597, -0.03673121705651283, 0.016808005049824715, -0.015303140506148338, -0.006730020511895418, -0.02254934050142765, -0.031535807996988297, -0.0365779884159565, -0.014768942259252071, -0.04891914501786232, 0.032512545585632324, -0.02332446537911892, 0.07161389291286469, -0.053088605403900146, -0.04334556311368942, 0.015809347853064537, -0.03731377050280571, 0.021000249311327934, -0.010968458838760853, 0.020756177604198456, -0.007664608769118786, -0.03851212188601494, -0.05161064863204956, 0.04253728315234184, -0.04369194060564041, -0.014173999428749084, -0.0130609180778265, -0.12148324400186539, -0.07900237292051315, 0.061848174780607224, -0.02726282924413681, -0.0198348555713892, -0.0041253832168877125, 0.030550392344594002, 0.009159070439636707, 0.030123939737677574, -0.03921034559607506, -0.0006830788915976882, 0.014331279322504997, -0.05622159317135811, 0.023544644936919212, 0.04624238982796669, 0.0006656966870650649, 0.05764884129166603, -0.00967765599489212, 0.003363655647262931, 0.013833996839821339, -0.04476717486977577, 0.00571972643956542, 0.016236966475844383, -0.06904032826423645, 0.011015388183295727, 0.0072405687533319, -0.0011711691040545702, 0.04425472393631935, -0.014569477178156376, -0.04416585713624954, 0.042104411870241165, 0.0116545669734478, 0.0049658543430268764, 0.01952269673347473, 0.09228960424661636, 0.018124273046851158, -0.051148422062397, -0.0024124672636389732, 0.03099585883319378, 0.02354392781853676, -0.024565337225794792, 0.012454020790755749, -0.05276480317115784, -0.02667352557182312, -0.018621254712343216, -0.023717937991023064, -0.025004707276821136, 0.05655185505747795, -0.0025565640535205603, -0.05929012969136238, 0.029127227142453194, 0.022811422124505043, 0.05379661172628403, -0.042305923998355865, 0.06696603447198868, -0.021728642284870148, 0.052801597863435745, -0.035592954605817795, 0.012903363443911076, 0.008962280116975307, -0.03423819690942764, -0.07090593874454498, 0.029958520084619522, 0.007533092051744461, 0.0069383722729980946, -0.07699964195489883, 0.027254264801740646, 0.05035395920276642, 0.0021000802516937256, -0.035750217735767365, -0.05265098810195923, -0.05667373165488243, 0.04870164766907692, 0.008463638834655285, -0.024357445538043976, -0.006059364415705204, -0.04856569692492485, -0.018111316487193108, -0.054165542125701904, -0.042958229780197144, 0.05819477140903473, -0.034429147839546204, 0.06236688792705536, 0.02952701412141323, -0.03142654523253441, 0.03342291712760925, -0.045513398945331573, 0.006728873122483492, 0.029407232999801636, -0.004728671163320541, 0.029426230117678642, 0.019333822652697563, 0.02285851165652275, 0.00925892312079668, 0.030990824103355408, 0.05065276101231575, 0.014754009433090687, -0.05908932164311409, 0.04326320067048073, -0.006762502249330282, -0.04367111250758171, -0.08080640435218811, -0.02269257977604866, 0.012855744920670986, -0.02817228063941002, 0.016569415107369423, 0.038864865899086, -0.03226005285978317, 0.001943781040608883, -0.04513482749462128, 0.016688471660017967, -0.0011473718332126737, -0.00421278877183795, -0.022366566583514214, 0.048942726105451584, 0.022534379735589027, 0.045564547181129456, 0.03170793130993843, -0.04250999912619591, -0.04196023568511009, 0.011671353131532669, -0.056526072323322296, -0.030424298718571663, -0.05017733573913574, -0.005569226574152708, -0.0310833677649498, 0.008104718290269375, 0.014634312130510807, 0.06040693446993828, -0.008495044894516468, 0.012948966585099697, 0.016277622431516647, 0.030036233365535736, -0.029477402567863464, 0.007508197799324989, 0.010605398565530777, -0.042244937270879745, -0.011589186266064644, 0.015062837861478329, -0.05419932305812836, -0.08720672875642776, 0.02451406791806221, -0.01729734241962433, -0.059362947940826416, -0.05349140614271164, 0.06075681373476982, -0.04608156532049179, -0.021466784179210663, -0.047196198254823685, -0.046192314475774765, 0.02503943257033825, 0.01966061070561409, 0.0434977188706398, -0.0018126731738448143, -0.0624580979347229, 0.04486957564949989, -0.023739276453852654, 0.027161862701177597, -0.02308901585638523, 0.0049026235938072205, 0.01319932471960783, -0.001902610412798822, -0.002738249721005559, 0.03275303542613983, 0.021203169599175453, 0.04256739839911461, -0.03688063845038414, 0.008036542683839798, -0.014559953473508358, -0.02591804787516594, -0.008426784537732601, -0.032063014805316925, 0.0020932990591973066, -0.004281241912394762, 0.03624085336923599, -0.001287931459955871, 0.006549754645675421, -0.05818229541182518, -0.07518275827169418, -0.014505400322377682, 0.04156394302845001, -0.014479098841547966, -0.030257945880293846, 0.074376679956913, -0.01315066497772932 ]
<p>What would happen if you were to accelerate one end of a material, say a steel rod for instance, at faster per second than the speed of sound in that material? </p> <p>For example, if the speed of sound in steel is 6100m/s, what would happen if you pushed the end of that piece of steel at more than 6100m/s/s?</p> <p>This only occurred to me because I heard that the speed of sound is the speed an impulse travels through a material, and I was wondering if there could be some sort of limit to acceleration which would arise from this. </p> <p>I appologize in advance if I'm comparing apples with irrelevant oranges. Thanks!</p>
g4264
[ 0.10458347946405411, 0.06882420927286148, 0.02370106428861618, -0.0074349031783640385, 0.05225306376814842, -0.011768266558647156, 0.005103376694023609, 0.02169441059231758, -0.06344066560268402, 0.011175142601132393, -0.021139074116945267, 0.023463942110538483, -0.043528128415346146, -0.008603150025010109, 0.027368074283003807, -0.01752563938498497, 0.06785807013511658, -0.024269668385386467, 0.026475735008716583, 0.05587593466043472, -0.019547374919056892, -0.0014615872642025352, -0.009203137829899788, -0.0370502769947052, -0.027102721855044365, 0.041569262742996216, 0.0038022343069314957, -0.044366538524627686, -0.03386443480849266, 0.013837276957929134, -0.03303026780486107, -0.04753868654370308, 0.010025599040091038, -0.009059370495378971, -0.023298421874642372, -0.03184118866920471, 0.04956216737627983, -0.034507766366004944, 0.030011843889951706, 0.027315765619277954, -0.003291281871497631, -0.050596777349710464, -0.01185164600610733, -0.024379855021834373, 0.004746309481561184, 0.03161017596721649, -0.026815811172127724, -0.01106155663728714, 0.02994571067392826, -0.05478396266698837, -0.024062281474471092, 0.017140112817287445, 0.0051294248551130295, 0.005995354615151882, -0.03206107020378113, -0.001123675610870123, -0.003887300845235586, -0.03289638087153435, 0.07513119280338287, 0.0393291600048542, -0.04098711907863617, 0.00528357969596982, 0.005130500998347998, -0.029556693509221077, 0.06759195029735565, -0.015615151263773441, 0.013955419883131981, -0.02826712280511856, 0.05161431059241295, 0.02310394123196602, 0.0739244744181633, 0.004004960879683495, -0.05057428032159805, -0.06421228498220444, -0.051896512508392334, 0.0015780243556946516, 0.05201418697834015, 0.021185345947742462, -0.03249887377023697, 0.030407626181840897, -0.024223653599619865, -0.00724413339048624, 0.038146574050188065, -0.027522074058651924, -0.02989041432738304, -0.010635536164045334, 0.004865128081291914, 0.037252165377140045, -0.02958918921649456, -0.004236871842294931, -0.010867674835026264, -0.05077870562672615, 0.012265061028301716, 0.020041121169924736, -0.03854014724493027, -0.006827423814684153, -0.03048064187169075, 0.059232983738183975, 0.004235281143337488, 0.03648312762379646, -0.007661312818527222, -0.07798785716295242, 0.06793016195297241, -0.0441473051905632, -0.007697459310293198, -0.05106321722269058, 0.03941408172249794, -0.0543590746819973, -0.0388084352016449, -0.013328268192708492, 0.0337626077234745, -0.05317629501223564, -0.04283050820231438, -0.030177120119333267, -0.030685754492878914, -0.022948283702135086, 0.023296378552913666, 0.028126947581768036, -0.03406144678592682, 0.059937816113233566, 0.034776996821165085, -0.017412828281521797, -0.005255304742604494, 0.02228129841387272, -0.013486268930137157, 0.0052078221924602985, 0.03797643259167671, -0.008828051388263702, -0.017948037013411522, -0.028376463800668716, -0.03827902674674988, 0.010408256202936172, 0.05100017413496971, -0.013326352462172508, -0.009266179986298084, -0.009366407059133053, -0.023543694987893105, 0.03842555359005928, 0.020841969177126884, 0.013143125921487808, 0.009240611456334591, -0.052899572998285294, -0.036599431186914444, -0.020288264378905296, -0.04941999167203903, 0.026589855551719666, 0.006131085101515055, 0.034854475408792496, -0.0036659645847976208, 0.0178780946880579, 0.009788420982658863, 0.023092450574040413, 0.006723085418343544, -0.03750871494412422, 0.002621087245643139, 0.0398343987762928, 0.023393962532281876, 0.029960984364151955, 0.032460544258356094, 0.006325020920485258, 0.043202612549066544, 0.03467317298054695, 0.005342402029782534, 0.04537035897374153, -0.06386258453130722, 0.035308100283145905, 0.00924511905759573, 0.01299889013171196, 0.019679443910717964, 0.0028196016792207956, -0.04880776256322861, -0.012341617606580257, 0.022727733477950096, 0.07189255207777023, 0.026676667854189873, -0.01600310578942299, 0.0884411409497261, -0.038192689418792725, -0.06482359766960144, -0.03328704088926315, -0.04995150491595268, -0.03849053382873535, 0.005051134154200554, -0.061440542340278625, 0.011434704065322876, -0.009750230237841606, 0.03268473222851753, 0.01596835069358349, -0.07997620105743408, 0.08413349837064743, -0.03758640214800835, -0.06290186941623688, -0.026592962443828583, 0.01849714107811451, -0.07513562589883804, -0.04891427606344223, 0.021676233038306236, 0.010862724855542183, 0.001435526879504323, -0.03366941586136818, 0.04912874475121498, 0.062233321368694305, -0.0169907845556736, -0.01579860970377922, 0.027990009635686874, -0.017090579494833946, -0.04358144849538803, 0.00017940058023668826, 0.026532581076025963, 0.0019745812751352787, 0.03079039417207241, 0.051939934492111206, 0.02653692290186882, 0.08787783980369568, 0.01516982913017273, 0.008379590697586536, 0.025760559365153313, -0.0067020440474152565, 0.04521710425615311, -0.007965758442878723, 0.014838111586868763, -0.024294784292578697, 0.020268859341740608, -0.02248777449131012, -0.061157308518886566, -0.05275130271911621, -0.013314538635313511, -0.018838103860616684, -0.0030560577288269997, 0.04086729884147644, -0.03411577269434929, 0.039422690868377686, 0.0058028544299304485, -0.05640455707907677, 0.035006508231163025, 0.03904404863715172, 0.01942792348563671, -0.034849975258111954, -0.02964550256729126, -0.02990485168993473, 0.03343535587191582, -0.038253359496593475, -0.021902156993746758, -0.02671855501830578, -0.0421610102057457, -0.08240914344787598, 0.014820334501564503, -0.050839100033044815, 0.06013312190771103, 0.03337172046303749, -0.012192592956125736, 0.003780420171096921, -0.009107116609811783, 0.02854125387966633, 0.028113285079598427, -0.018016470596194267, -0.04574904963374138, 0.04094798490405083, -0.051619213074445724, -0.05183698609471321, -0.006350524257868528, 0.006891297642141581, 0.0067681497894227505, -0.005491517949849367, -0.07209772616624832, -0.0134207084774971, 0.024206731468439102, -0.04179883003234863, -0.010313347913324833, 0.07452216744422913, -0.08112248033285141, 0.005151086486876011, -0.037659019231796265, 0.01676688715815544, 0.02875060960650444, -0.0497010201215744, 0.01987668126821518, -0.057289112359285355, 0.04021502658724785, -0.00219916645437479, -0.05856425687670708, -0.03378855809569359, -0.043536629527807236, 0.025939157232642174, -0.04161335900425911, -0.04409857466816902, 0.0405510775744915, 0.0033737316261976957, 0.016220128163695335, 0.01764620468020439, -0.0695747584104538, 0.035943228751420975, 0.07396548241376877, 0.0011429593432694674, 0.06198500841856003, 0.07372363656759262, 0.006364654283970594, -0.02419833093881607, -0.015375345014035702, -0.0163497906178236, -0.008891422301530838, -0.056958284229040146, -0.04882727190852165, 0.036685120314359665, -0.012544197961688042, -0.0040128640830516815, -0.054813452064991, -0.014541564509272575, 0.0029131979681551456, -0.015302016399800777, 0.023975074291229248, 0.042706601321697235, 0.017582932487130165, 0.006660777609795332, -0.07653700560331345, -0.053970880806446075, 0.025443794205784798, 0.00708902208134532, 0.05706298351287842, 0.03618628904223442, -0.013047498650848866, -0.05449915677309036, 0.060525957494974136, -0.0033193514682352543, 0.015563023276627064, 0.027628492563962936, 0.03665218874812126, -0.015614905394613743, -0.07279656827449799, -0.007688719313591719, 0.021430354565382004, 0.0037337802350521088, -0.04372337460517883, -0.008256406523287296, -0.03487225994467735, -0.035330843180418015, 0.00811788160353899, 0.09299210458993912, 0.07594207674264908, 0.09018924087285995, 0.039460621774196625, 0.02923840656876564, -0.002512435195967555, 0.00380711373873055, 0.003997630439698696, 0.04180450364947319, 0.06720934063196182, 0.02678533084690571, 0.015921728685498238, 0.013430414721369743, 0.04075566679239273, -0.023603633046150208, 0.014935668557882309, -0.009301978163421154, -0.03188328444957733, 0.04475186765193939, 0.06481116265058517, 0.04140681400895119, 0.007627952378243208, -0.08674496412277222, -0.020456060767173767, -0.0033900723792612553, 0.02133946865797043, -0.044192973524332047, -0.01977057009935379, 0.005070832092314959, 0.028214404359459877, 0.02666735276579857, -0.008690512739121914, -0.025577282533049583, 0.04139258340001106, -0.028319595381617546, 0.016545649617910385, 0.007233740761876106, 0.017568396404385567, -0.028572894632816315, 0.006277653854340315, 0.03916609287261963, -0.00604343693703413, 0.010311339050531387, 0.08522305637598038, 0.06536588817834854, 0.027403660118579865, -0.018430523574352264, -0.031321242451667786, -0.03211472928524017, -0.030346954241394997, -0.04288650304079056, -0.03340539336204529, -0.04014428332448006, -0.000545622082427144, -0.08538614958524704, -0.031117133796215057, -0.0015624442603439093, -0.022494424134492874, -0.04458344355225563, -0.00270098471082747, -0.01105157844722271, -0.010215112008154392, 0.060745127499103546, -0.028790194541215897, 0.06151505187153816, -0.030831171199679375, 0.003528913715854287, 0.00008432297181570902, 0.03279019892215729, 0.0343628004193306, -0.01857548952102661, -0.019596131518483162, -0.009180759079754353, -0.028559742495417595, -0.029186030849814415, -0.051658015698194504, -0.011821527034044266, -0.0232816431671381, 0.014942790381610394, 0.05647791922092438, 0.012733385898172855, -0.00937468372285366, -0.004025406204164028, 0.015878958627581596, -0.004449589643627405, -0.007110857870429754, 0.005532568320631981, -0.00027129609952680767, 0.08124338835477829, 0.05325958505272865, -0.047250717878341675, 0.0258809681981802, -0.02928033471107483, -0.03245815634727478, -0.004276108928024769, 0.005973311606794596, 0.030144646763801575, 0.01679670438170433, 0.062469761818647385, -0.013369734399020672, 0.0722578763961792, 0.058874402195215225, 0.018582824617624283, 0.01193937286734581, 0.035920966416597366, 0.054741695523262024, 0.019280677661299706, 0.018881896510720253, 0.012190449982881546, -0.011954843997955322, -0.025061633437871933, -0.026943819597363472, -0.01822260208427906, -0.03100919909775257, 0.018186921253800392, -0.06481290608644485, -0.05562029406428337, -0.0019616074860095978, -0.008714384399354458, -0.01777690462768078, -0.016805987805128098, 0.013505060225725174, -0.00883497018367052, -0.027896109968423843, -0.03555026650428772, -0.03522045910358429, 0.007619813084602356, -0.018091490492224693, 0.003333828179165721, 0.02356700226664543, -0.04949508607387543, -0.05797215551137924, 0.046720489859580994, 0.012063469737768173, -0.02015775442123413, -0.03414393961429596, 0.0861940085887909, 0.07606224715709686, -0.018673989921808243, -0.054616332054138184, -0.0025432459078729153, -0.02592831663787365, -0.03783522918820381, -0.06301712244749069, 0.011983281932771206, 0.030512366443872452, -0.0690453052520752, -0.010023420676589012, -0.017889121547341347, -0.05557575821876526, 0.025845985859632492, -0.01713934727013111, -0.023861154913902283, 0.037653177976608276, 0.0008070285548456013, -0.07088926434516907, 0.005993999075144529, -0.03795880079269409, 0.04472007602453232, 0.06339053064584732, -0.004275540821254253, -0.08214594423770905, -0.026032133027911186, -0.07734722644090652, -0.029646581038832664, -0.010928940959274769, 0.009973807260394096, -0.0004071590374223888, 0.04432378336787224, 0.029250148683786392, -0.0024954460095614195, 0.024999605491757393, 0.05552297830581665, 0.050394050776958466, 0.10223269462585449, -0.010228144936263561, -0.013621688820421696, -0.016715243458747864, -0.027087654918432236, -0.006148402579128742, -0.025384720414876938, -0.003649844555184245, -0.02577824518084526, 0.05654183030128479, -0.03901122882962227, -0.03019881248474121, -0.00797348003834486, -0.026904864236712456, 0.015379486605525017, -0.012102415785193443, 0.005979324225336313, -0.007337546441704035, 0.03656885400414467, 0.07951930165290833, -0.04220734164118767, 0.007589723914861679, -0.037784941494464874, -0.03160443156957626, 0.03922217711806297, 0.042610492557287216, -0.048964615911245346, 0.016957370564341545, 0.01214137114584446, -0.03606299310922623, 0.0006409997004084289, 0.04177406430244446, 0.07855935394763947, -0.007135595194995403, 0.018568040803074837, -0.035191912204027176, -0.0019724974408745766, 0.02288997918367386, -0.046877212822437286, -0.007747159339487553, 0.031865574419498444, -0.002804378978908062, 0.01029269490391016, 0.017320426180958748, 0.06664716452360153, 0.007673302665352821, 0.016617311164736748, 0.034897446632385254, -0.06328537315130234, 0.03474024683237076, 0.008648550137877464, 0.06090033799409866, -0.005516642704606056, 0.016891295090317726, -0.048867423087358475, 0.03275882825255394, -0.011199746280908585, 0.05556141957640648, 0.037312984466552734, 0.03015691600739956, 0.013245192356407642, -0.0020581393036991358, 0.006878051441162825, -0.013864182867109776, -0.022351928055286407, -0.016645491123199463, -0.05888297036290169, -0.012121106497943401, -0.012586464174091816, -0.02685452438890934, 0.01803368330001831, -0.04080776497721672, 0.014862311072647572, 0.005413221661001444, -0.003953477833420038, -0.014969916082918644, -0.023106424137949944, 0.07258797436952591, -0.046206943690776825, -0.062158551067113876, -0.019251637160778046, -0.020956378430128098, 0.02562149427831173, -0.03432575240731239, -0.0009697852656245232, 0.001570053631439805, 0.009050124324858189, 0.022864922881126404, 0.06198668107390404, 0.05488128960132599, 0.008596961386501789, 0.09421318769454956, 0.007948939688503742, -0.03923213481903076, 0.005923097021877766, 0.019073905423283577, -0.01813068985939026, 0.011141892522573471, -0.004679454956203699, -0.0093265725299716, -0.034452930092811584, 0.04380546510219574, 0.04574960470199585, -0.006898708641529083, 0.036355555057525635, -0.005850453861057758, -0.11531047523021698, -0.006026973482221365, 0.010099546983838081, 0.02346225269138813, -0.04784123972058296, 0.021596333011984825, -0.044153306633234024, -0.010649827308952808, -0.02059366926550865, -0.023066604509949684, 0.036817003041505814, 0.028631016612052917, -0.038361214101314545, -0.009711126796901226, -0.01144761685281992, -0.0017685049679130316, 0.058894455432891846, 0.011786685325205326, 0.05051315203309059, 0.033381521701812744, 0.004894698038697243, 0.011768235825002193, 0.019680753350257874, 0.08362831175327301, -0.023406507447361946, -0.050514187663793564, 0.11427247524261475, -0.029301701113581657, 0.022802244871854782, 0.009540971368551254, -0.03459209203720093, -0.04225282371044159, -0.05731501057744026, -0.03455229848623276, -0.0062888083048164845, -0.06238935515284538, 0.010609772987663746, -0.023551499471068382, -0.0005140519351698458, 0.008546344935894012, 0.03958284854888916, 0.0650131106376648, -0.028725219890475273, -0.030001239851117134, 0.011043393984436989, 0.028489582240581512, -0.013843686319887638, -0.017661184072494507, 0.020907925441861153, 0.01567678526043892, -0.055961113423109055, -0.032201092690229416, -0.0024839050602167845, 0.042250972241163254, -0.015145417302846909, 0.015045512467622757, 0.0012299137888476253, 0.07297232002019882, 0.057000309228897095, -0.029894808307290077, -0.006336809601634741, -0.0022171696182340384, 0.004869120195508003, 0.034703146666288376, 0.01188597735017538, 0.014298568479716778, -0.02002476342022419, -0.017078282311558723, 0.001710683573037386, 0.018931597471237183, 0.07084301859140396, 0.022255441173911095, -0.0392906479537487, -0.004252126906067133, -0.0018187029054388404, 0.044787220656871796, 0.00905720703303814, 0.0021901046857237816, -0.004635258577764034, -0.01895381696522236, 0.05726948380470276, -0.06869848817586899, 0.04794538393616676, -0.027515465393662453, 0.01887793093919754, -0.002055665710940957, 0.021311750635504723, -0.011574794538319111, 0.025356823578476906, -0.020256366580724716, -0.018243981525301933, -0.020820168778300285, -0.034465011209249496, -0.00047292522503994405, 0.04446559026837349, -0.010135709308087826, -0.004769804421812296, 0.05104371905326843, -0.004325260873883963, -0.015298699960112572, -0.03334555774927139, 0.025013942271471024, 0.029968924820423126, -0.008134621195495129, 0.0314854271709919, -0.01605590246617794, -0.023556837812066078, -0.0072468239814043045, -0.0006146954256109893, 0.0022784227039664984, 0.006938553415238857, -0.021468129009008408, -0.01829351857304573, 0.04293027147650719, -0.013555044308304787, 0.025591161102056503, 0.029384704306721687, -0.06247564032673836, -0.017076170071959496, 0.07436532527208328, 0.004188903141766787, -0.018293144181370735, 0.02399178221821785, -0.004263822454959154, 0.0034456118009984493, -0.04924092814326286, 0.01722780242562294, -0.013426720164716244, -0.0022355015389621258, 0.0027247206307947636, 0.08337083458900452, 0.03449046239256859, -0.05376749113202095, -0.007192880380898714, -0.042353007942438126, -0.005762755870819092, 0.01974661834537983, 0.01711372844874859, 0.025811849161982536, -0.012022200971841812, 0.013264055363833904, -0.041919734328985214, -0.04855503886938095, -0.03956321254372597, 0.026947611942887306, -0.01093140710145235, -0.038011759519577026, 0.006106274202466011, -0.032141897827386856, -0.05523073300719261, -0.04265578091144562 ]
<p>I heard that this statement is correct. However, it seems odd to me. The number of possible microstates is still the same, so isn't the entropy constant?</p>
g4265
[ 0.024823110550642014, -0.002566954120993614, 0.011976909823715687, -0.012294882908463478, -0.012760726734995842, 0.013603628613054752, -0.008621780201792717, -0.009242605417966843, -0.014416934922337532, -0.052405841648578644, -0.05641210079193115, 0.017034005373716354, 0.02066858857870102, -0.038477860391139984, -0.03155038133263588, 0.020063137635588646, 0.051959916949272156, -0.022804103791713715, -0.0032615726813673973, 0.0687597393989563, -0.05745283141732216, -0.070024274289608, -0.017695046961307526, -0.07374513894319534, 0.04656612128019333, -0.005523653235286474, -0.015964528545737267, -0.017077060416340828, -0.026644939556717873, -0.033071208745241165, 0.10099710524082184, -0.021126823499798775, 0.023856185376644135, -0.06915170699357986, -0.047294728457927704, -0.03656456992030144, 0.018410932272672653, -0.0036051778588443995, 0.049524590373039246, -0.049454327672719955, 0.010082407854497433, 0.0162388626486063, -0.046411775052547455, 0.015682736411690712, -0.010438472963869572, 0.029209133237600327, 0.060663025826215744, 0.013128107413649559, 0.009939112700521946, -0.05389924719929695, 0.012480068951845169, 0.06375108659267426, 0.04715146869421005, 0.004398020450025797, 0.025435997173190117, 0.045488372445106506, 0.05810137093067169, -0.0264531709253788, 0.013343358412384987, 0.0577278770506382, 0.01868303306400776, -0.03176211938261986, -0.016776341944932938, 0.005945422220975161, 0.034867748618125916, 0.03057093359529972, -0.027644775807857513, -0.040040772408246994, -0.012956646271049976, 0.021579811349511147, -0.016034821048378944, -0.030347520485520363, -0.01978193409740925, -0.0069289663806557655, -0.0202937051653862, 0.037028782069683075, 0.02557484805583954, -0.005166775081306696, 0.019132116809487343, -0.00118838285561651, -0.05495390668511391, -0.05634927377104759, 0.05086290463805199, -0.00006508569640573114, 0.06266535073518753, -0.02406996488571167, 0.018888013437390327, -0.02727181278169155, 0.00039267088868655264, 0.06806299835443497, -0.04236907884478569, -0.007062352262437344, 0.019107447937130928, 0.029372286051511765, -0.014057355001568794, -0.06653948128223419, -0.021607203409075737, 0.036303866654634476, -0.02987794019281864, 0.01884130947291851, -0.02002488449215889, -0.004149650689214468, 0.04453540965914726, -0.02442755736410618, -0.02861006185412407, -0.02635693922638893, -0.04374821111559868, -0.046632613986730576, 0.00238479720428586, -0.02389320731163025, 0.03134499862790108, -0.007947045378386974, -0.026851383969187737, -0.0061059813015162945, -0.052497364580631256, 0.003268549218773842, 0.07444699853658676, -0.05281798914074898, -0.025825953111052513, 0.01958201266825199, 0.006102636456489563, -0.009433397091925144, -0.005855003837496042, 0.06982055306434631, -0.002767993835732341, 0.03851218894124031, 0.007991863414645195, 0.02250286564230919, 0.004734379705041647, -0.04379147291183472, 0.02514360472559929, 0.001538882264867425, -0.032388657331466675, 0.002214752836152911, 0.008026422932744026, 0.015006283298134804, -0.012104444205760956, -0.05863161385059357, -0.005355008877813816, 0.03160562366247177, -0.015390271320939064, 0.01573210209608078, -0.006306975614279509, -0.03287528455257416, -0.023381777107715607, -0.006607284303754568, -0.023264138028025627, -0.019921697676181793, 0.005170227028429508, 0.014136787503957748, 0.03090989775955677, 0.03831687569618225, 0.011283072642982006, 0.002347871195524931, -0.05589258670806885, 0.0018718017963692546, 0.07349268347024918, 0.022548161447048187, -0.0022273038048297167, 0.03731454536318779, 0.005437961779534817, -0.028910096734762192, 0.06759342551231384, -0.03407905623316765, -0.04054852947592735, 0.03739318624138832, 0.024083537980914116, -0.00352682638913393, -0.0009195898310281336, -0.041884928941726685, -0.01814959943294525, -0.011240503750741482, 0.023829549551010132, 0.04556257650256157, 0.04561736062169075, 0.021247901022434235, -0.03981313854455948, -0.015077884308993816, 0.04144314303994179, -0.016541514545679092, 0.029634328559041023, 0.06091520935297012, 0.05561017617583275, -0.04067792743444443, 0.01840156689286232, -0.01825152523815632, -0.02598431147634983, 0.041524820029735565, -0.04488731920719147, -0.022645218297839165, -0.015260918997228146, -0.00987146608531475, -0.0940307006239891, 0.027682045474648476, 0.07907617092132568, -0.03551524132490158, 0.029688652604818344, -0.06361677497625351, -0.038542263209819794, 0.004256086889654398, 0.06412866711616516, 0.025307705625891685, 0.02714843861758709, -0.0258561372756958, -0.006472303066402674, 0.04948902502655983, -0.009284446015954018, 0.027786578983068466, 0.024381272494792938, -0.005874688271433115, 0.030065184459090233, -0.0862089991569519, -0.02602427825331688, 0.047083571553230286, -0.020932521671056747, -0.05099138244986534, 0.0709221139550209, -0.014332232065498829, -0.0000809890843811445, 0.009302567690610886, -0.024663565680384636, 0.05810125172138214, 0.029223112389445305, -0.0032486673444509506, 0.018315255641937256, -0.006985309533774853, -0.06535699963569641, 0.009930229745805264, 0.023204563185572624, 0.0492512583732605, -0.00505213113501668, 0.009220493957400322, 0.008690791204571724, 0.0030848535243421793, -0.012532692402601242, 0.07654821872711182, 0.007971661165356636, 0.05884461849927902, -0.044213224202394485, -0.0010800412856042385, 0.07917545735836029, -0.08352619409561157, -0.011533449403941631, 0.059160202741622925, 0.031705163419246674, -0.014202620834112167, -0.04168976843357086, 0.02042982168495655, 0.03535253554582596, 0.020202377811074257, -0.02712971530854702, -0.0013714538654312491, 0.003717969637364149, 0.06585266441106796, -0.008723996579647064, -0.053558751940727234, -0.009681878611445427, -0.0050684502348303795, -0.05486670881509781, -0.018687451258301735, -0.012453689239919186, -0.011633269488811493, 0.05596667900681496, -0.04081234335899353, 0.03108133189380169, -0.07086364179849625, -0.04848014935851097, 0.011483525857329369, 0.0025219616945832968, 0.01730208657681942, 0.012212755158543587, 0.02602333016693592, -0.010920190252363682, 0.08772731572389603, 0.033527180552482605, 0.005432393401861191, 0.04061724990606308, -0.004445095546543598, -0.020274940878152847, -0.024495398625731468, -0.05750563368201256, 0.017272943630814552, -0.04054803401231766, 0.006252763327211142, 0.043587930500507355, -0.02864242158830166, 0.020643075928092003, -0.009342017583549023, -0.00986841693520546, 0.03551064431667328, 0.03903805837035179, 0.010729726403951645, 0.06109918653964996, 0.01674605906009674, -0.011828764341771603, 0.021303892135620117, 0.031174303963780403, -0.06032728776335716, -0.027165694162249565, 0.07064279913902283, 0.015225855633616447, -0.0025724354200065136, 0.012385147623717785, -0.019525250419974327, 0.00844571739435196, 0.01702902838587761, -0.05441826581954956, -0.03814622387290001, -0.011098145507276058, -0.008687343448400497, -0.04506998509168625, 0.07239467650651932, -0.05439099296927452, 0.02579721435904503, -0.061674974858760834, 0.03928440436720848, 0.035951364785432816, 0.03400390222668648, 0.037531714886426926, 0.012897059321403503, 0.039945561438798904, -0.013098466210067272, 0.01431063562631607, -0.0019391182577237487, 0.0047591752372682095, 0.016160141676664352, -0.08266904950141907, 0.0021712344605475664, -0.08502962440252304, 0.028980009257793427, 0.02870772033929825, -0.023451589047908783, 0.037170227617025375, -0.018439125269651413, -0.043284639716148376, -0.060675084590911865, -0.05858859419822693, -0.05260096490383148, 0.04428880661725998, 0.07362168282270432, -0.04209994897246361, 0.0391668938100338, -0.03766646236181259, 0.0034736760426312685, -0.03549390658736229, 0.03610946983098984, -0.026285570114850998, -0.005796621087938547, 0.03708367422223091, 0.022339312359690666, 0.029821503907442093, 0.012117920443415642, 0.019631333649158478, -0.001584836863912642, -0.006273078732192516, 0.0006614380981773138, -0.05605359375476837, -0.031222114339470863, 0.017042968422174454, 0.03280584514141083, 0.03241986781358719, -0.07924845814704895, 0.028851648792624474, -0.041638877242803574, 0.013891489244997501, 0.029310859739780426, -0.04162253811955452, 0.06852215528488159, 0.06092298403382301, 0.048133689910173416, -0.02206750586628914, -0.041837356984615326, 0.02001851052045822, 0.01787259243428707, 0.058945074677467346, 0.013142737559974194, 0.07389850169420242, 0.03764188662171364, -0.012774811126291752, -0.010550087317824364, 0.09949184954166412, -0.03961746394634247, -0.045510224997997284, -0.042725443840026855, -0.03707907721400261, 0.009627800434827805, -0.03109164722263813, 0.017454249784350395, -0.0203260388225317, -0.042914342135190964, -0.005827822722494602, 0.02583676390349865, -0.006657866295427084, -0.0197759997099638, 0.011632313020527363, 0.03603233024477959, 0.014559737406671047, -0.035373806953430176, 0.038450948894023895, 0.05343792214989662, 0.03745565563440323, -0.0162951722741127, -0.043812233954668045, -0.023488720878958702, 0.022007497027516365, -0.02290826477110386, 0.026538558304309845, 0.03936516493558884, 0.003790382295846939, -0.026461975648999214, -0.008369570598006248, 0.026688404381275177, 0.0298210047185421, -0.006450791843235493, -0.011221053078770638, 0.014744685962796211, -0.05233772471547127, -0.02880934625864029, 0.0028027924709022045, 0.040160778909921646, 0.005920098628848791, -0.001272937166504562, -0.027223587036132812, -0.011810051277279854, 0.02442215569317341, 0.023270219564437866, 0.04158124327659607, -0.01066652126610279, -0.06450223922729492, -0.0401218980550766, 0.02822011150419712, 0.0620664581656456, 0.01975279487669468, -0.010192068293690681, 0.0012552092084661126, 0.03219043090939522, -0.05984687805175781, -0.004073499236255884, -0.060252368450164795, 0.00942263100296259, -0.003998996689915657, 0.021275632083415985, 0.018572906032204628, 0.0250282920897007, -0.014356803148984909, 0.020462028682231903, 0.022558188065886497, -0.03390348330140114, -0.02385619841516018, -0.00719468342140317, -0.0054778470657765865, -0.029742266982793808, 0.018747862428426743, -0.041839007288217545, -0.02688765525817871, -0.02875535562634468, -0.029967015609145164, 0.03928964585065842, -0.04126732051372528, 0.04962123930454254, -0.04054999724030495, 0.0385572612285614, 0.030678389593958855, 0.03383863717317581, 0.06843597441911697, -0.0018010191852226853, -0.06513141840696335, 0.04360707104206085, -0.04583978280425072, -0.06057736650109291, 0.08936271071434021, -0.006717493291944265, -0.03240323066711426, 0.004849596414715052, 0.00656144181266427, -0.006145115941762924, 0.026872266083955765, -0.00014451022434514016, -0.0035098015796393156, 0.01930001564323902, -0.04358479008078575, -0.015531227923929691, 0.010950533673167229, 0.019699031487107277, 0.07969152182340622, 0.05730845779180527, -0.03638503700494766, -0.01487016025930643, -0.03496561199426651, -0.023738395422697067, 0.029103877022862434, 0.04007423669099808, 0.05844256281852722, 0.012984482571482658, -0.021961750462651253, -0.021071529015898705, -0.022938016802072525, -0.058527473360300064, -0.00942977424710989, 0.03517930954694748, -0.05690212547779083, -0.020111551508307457, -0.0037547822576016188, 0.004810485523194075, -0.05541061982512474, 0.01816469617187977, 0.012480148114264011, 0.004072807729244232, -0.006372830364853144, 0.029974283650517464, 0.008556424640119076, -0.005708818789571524, -0.00013175045023672283, 0.015166571363806725, 0.009115145541727543, -0.0056741442531347275, 0.04553736373782158, -0.03919651731848717, -0.016337843611836433, -0.06329208612442017, 0.03746550530195236, -0.0006645340472459793, 0.035822272300720215, -0.0058322749100625515, -0.02543727494776249, 0.014618237502872944, -0.05423201248049736, -0.016155986115336418, -0.028867067769169807, 0.035915080457925797, -0.0003172681899741292, 0.02765718288719654, 0.036245882511138916, 0.011610854417085648, 0.041613079607486725, 0.004900744184851646, -0.02663680911064148, 0.0268251970410347, 0.04064637050032616, 0.0071006715297698975, -0.013702141121029854, -0.05052037909626961, -0.01942470856010914, 0.02133452147245407, 0.016994880512356758, -0.017900336533784866, -0.05041268840432167, -0.024386091157794, -0.006437560543417931, -0.0981268510222435, 0.007221741136163473, 0.06878694891929626, -0.047474686056375504, 0.008581260219216347, -0.010980888269841671, 0.020703628659248352, 0.014893177896738052, 0.03772097826004028, -0.0040528117679059505, 0.02729399874806404, 0.0029683515895158052, 0.0442466102540493, 0.010880700312554836, -0.007822520099580288, 0.0013199409004300833, -0.10967937111854553, 0.04619049280881882, 0.008228194899857044, -0.02756650745868683, 0.035879384726285934, 0.02004927396774292, 0.016656259074807167, 0.005830500740557909, 0.0491158664226532, 0.020405447110533714, -0.008939704857766628, -0.058914318680763245, 0.0024023547302931547, -0.02497865818440914, -0.007939212955534458, -0.04133550077676773, -0.040400128811597824, -0.0074137127958238125, 0.02930326946079731, -0.017194725573062897, 0.046838898211717606, -0.04183989018201828, -0.0036041324492543936, -0.026160288602113724, 0.02740969881415367, -0.056021928787231445, -0.0024039673153311014, -0.06427152454853058, 0.035855114459991455, -0.02911817654967308, 0.0037020354066044092, -0.053289104253053665, -0.04137832298874855, -0.014574115164577961, -0.010047991760075092, -0.0032819060143083334, -0.016976790502667427, 0.03748111426830292, -0.05217297002673149, -0.054152145981788635, 0.03227030485868454, -0.036367837339639664, 0.04746280983090401, -0.04508829861879349, 0.041991349309682846, -0.03397725149989128, -0.0108645586296916, 0.010475135408341885, -0.02258114330470562, 0.02674134261906147, -0.05697007104754448, -0.05266961082816124, 0.0802159532904625, -0.0007303393795154989, 0.03565312549471855, -0.0068412479013204575, 0.010684356093406677, -0.027704311534762383, -0.09547681361436844, 0.044312797486782074, 0.10941530764102936, -0.025404665619134903, 0.016330676153302193, 0.030129706487059593, 0.050271712243556976, 0.005916137248277664, 0.03430979698896408, -0.0028003589250147343, 0.036153748631477356, -0.008575143292546272, -0.009100327268242836, -0.04819456487894058, 0.005123605951666832, 0.047278016805648804, -0.0062687997706234455, 0.037151675671339035, -0.004869166761636734, 0.0811491534113884, -0.008044209331274033, 0.02589084580540657, 0.008192376233637333, 0.018786054104566574, 0.015482218004763126, -0.028522050008177757, -0.0035580622497946024, 0.06307315081357956, -0.007345476653426886, -0.004891884047538042, -0.01397018413990736, -0.017385706305503845, 0.01731412298977375, 0.019298193976283073, 0.020648803561925888, 0.024280771613121033, -0.028564797714352608, -0.01573486253619194, 0.019877556711435318, -0.0013685686280950904, -0.005803326144814491, -0.0019161348463967443, 0.03558161109685898, 0.055147964507341385, -0.07392527163028717, 0.044084709137678146, -0.04447433724999428, -0.0035778414458036423, -0.03539939224720001, -0.02878396026790142, 0.014756698161363602, -0.02137206867337227, 0.001535887597128749, 0.01092915702611208, 0.020234305411577225, 0.0718071386218071, 0.04443211480975151, 0.0595029816031456, 0.013425922952592373, 0.031265344470739365, -0.000329217582475394, -0.034280989319086075, 0.07080428302288055, -0.09030448645353317, -0.029987100511789322, 0.05526183173060417, -0.008772510103881359, 0.03884781897068024, -0.02379113994538784, 0.008450486697256565, -0.021672870963811874, -0.036739520728588104, 0.020001454278826714, 0.028981905430555344, 0.0460432767868042, 0.0278619471937418, -0.09541922062635422, -0.008443888276815414, -0.003856377676129341, -0.011449258774518967, 0.02270926907658577, 0.024972423911094666, -0.016033951193094254, -0.0037747519090771675, 0.008748327381908894, -0.04456255957484245, -0.04818817228078842, -0.008520086295902729, 0.012589226476848125, 0.0087098004296422, -0.010965573601424694, -0.02369753271341324, 0.0076309614814817905, -0.07704712450504303, -0.04868614301085472, 0.04039612039923668, -0.040821101516485214, -0.04515952244400978, -0.04254517704248428, -0.03695131093263626, -0.015230934135615826, -0.03050951100885868, -0.07334072142839432, -0.032064225524663925, 0.0019196392968297005, 0.016706403344869614, 0.0032245039474219084, -0.03926694020628929, -0.009246166795492172, -0.0041689760982990265, -0.04199277609586716, -0.06634393334388733, 0.02474648505449295, 0.0669693872332573, 0.019174307584762573, 0.02061593346297741, -0.002268747193738818, -0.009720251895487309, 0.005296718329191208, 0.0846153050661087, 0.004620921798050404, 0.01732373982667923, -0.03733864799141884, -0.06697020679712296, -0.03707267716526985, 0.03711267560720444, -0.02341790497303009, -0.04540221020579338, -0.06770876049995422, 0.006655609235167503, -0.017749354243278503, 0.07388873398303986, -0.011346469633281231, 0.026279989629983902, 0.020325355231761932, 0.0006845468888059258, 0.0186881385743618, -0.048873160034418106, -0.043267522007226944, 0.024904416874051094, 0.024198193103075027, -0.002653151983395219, -0.0887097716331482, 0.008925573900341988, 0.040483977645635605 ]
<p>For a spin 1/2 particle you have two spin states, either up or down which are orthogonal. But what about a spin 1 particle which has 3 spin states, either up, down, not up/not down?</p>
g4266
[ -0.009157072752714157, -0.030332522466778755, 0.017439046874642372, -0.00860560405999422, 0.015584463253617287, 0.026718679815530777, 0.0035532189067453146, 0.025250999256968498, 0.048049312084913254, 0.019151683896780014, 0.009245466440916061, 0.000937928503844887, 0.009107064455747604, -0.07686969637870789, -0.03602057695388794, -0.002078036079183221, 0.04029269143939018, 0.010607057251036167, 0.029666012153029442, -0.00280209188349545, -0.021458281204104424, 0.014916776679456234, -0.036349110305309296, 0.0302689541131258, -0.016764022409915924, -0.03865129128098488, -0.016660163179039955, -0.06421396136283875, -0.07078045606613159, 0.0573076456785202, 0.015892349183559418, -0.015035879798233509, -0.03744669631123543, 0.02420664019882679, -0.00641239807009697, -0.02199515886604786, 0.073287233710289, 0.025701455771923065, 0.02896006777882576, 0.019086413085460663, 0.005485456436872482, -0.030047960579395294, 0.021663997322320938, -0.04741307348012924, 0.00693365465849638, 0.006065744906663895, 0.01807244122028351, 0.022670824080705643, -0.030455993488430977, -0.05444855988025665, -0.02610725536942482, 0.024776209145784378, 0.029744068160653114, 0.04121384024620056, 0.002211375394836068, 0.007085287477821112, -0.020808767527341843, -0.0026503584813326597, 0.07792751491069794, 0.0678284615278244, -0.0123728197067976, -0.06069398298859596, -0.014404919929802418, 0.013241155073046684, 0.02035667560994625, 0.029621759429574013, -0.019556330516934395, 0.006771543063223362, 0.005783640779554844, 0.004057606682181358, 0.025577634572982788, -0.03453924506902695, -0.0025408549699932337, -0.09857947379350662, -0.05565222352743149, 0.04834333062171936, -0.017253119498491287, -0.031845610588788986, 0.033985890448093414, 0.0562848336994648, -0.05929732695221901, -0.025936776772141457, 0.038022346794605255, -0.01691429689526558, 0.04464821144938469, 0.018693996593356133, 0.023751752451062202, 0.029077116400003433, -0.03555019944906235, 0.030834442004561424, -0.002288020448759198, -0.01373676024377346, 0.054293978959321976, 0.022482629865407944, -0.03650675714015961, -0.03636738285422325, -0.008406012319028378, 0.039326898753643036, -0.0005936657544225454, 0.000903863983694464, -0.009791504591703415, -0.014335381798446178, 0.010432043112814426, -0.07277262955904007, 0.020812684670090675, 0.009707889519631863, 0.09428157657384872, 0.010772132314741611, -0.03198201581835747, -0.07010708004236221, -0.05009631812572479, 0.0005842540413141251, 0.008548177778720856, -0.013519086875021458, -0.06901422142982483, -0.027704700827598572, 0.060269638895988464, -0.029151974245905876, 0.007451691664755344, 0.004442495293915272, 0.06932239979505539, 0.018646536394953728, 0.003395264269784093, 0.11257120966911316, -0.004292238038033247, 0.04311209172010422, -0.035261861979961395, -0.01254541240632534, 0.0027338815852999687, 0.014770244248211384, 0.0325811468064785, -0.01941717229783535, 0.03265710175037384, 0.005215625744313002, -0.04929931461811066, 0.017431974411010742, 0.04715874791145325, -0.014939287677407265, -0.029741719365119934, -0.01580186001956463, 0.0007980150985531509, -0.045083072036504745, -0.014657405205070972, -0.04106023535132408, 0.03987990692257881, -0.04109619930386543, 0.016487769782543182, -0.0328054241836071, -0.02042670175433159, 0.07494484633207321, 0.04178367927670479, 0.016271190717816353, 0.03409181907773018, -0.028821323066949844, 0.019299641251564026, -0.06525853276252747, 0.0674363449215889, 0.04257376864552498, 0.0360422357916832, 0.012643619440495968, 0.035982295870780945, -0.005177659448236227, -0.0563863180577755, 0.03997516259551048, -0.07350693643093109, 0.007090321741998196, 0.00035613219370134175, -0.0031266792211681604, -0.02174176089465618, -0.029039720073342323, 0.03040877729654312, 0.000022072779756854288, -0.005201547872275114, 0.015215782448649406, 0.045057110488414764, 0.0513523630797863, -0.010698337107896805, 0.009536897763609886, 0.03419574722647667, 0.016679588705301285, -0.0065517304465174675, 0.07266750931739807, -0.0016672187484800816, 0.056543976068496704, 0.026462672278285027, -0.02783845365047455, 0.0023786078672856092, 0.04299740120768547, -0.07190711796283722, -0.006604643072932959, 0.027367208153009415, 0.04517567157745361, 0.01074380986392498, -0.039309062063694, -0.020398778840899467, -0.043748509138822556, 0.011753272265195847, -0.0013471615966409445, 0.015117191709578037, 0.021827859804034233, 0.022290898486971855, -0.016319459304213524, 0.06390869617462158, -0.0019352034432813525, 0.02776426449418068, -0.03471170738339424, 0.022713040933012962, 0.04082269221544266, 0.09324255585670471, -0.016275625675916672, 0.004321055952459574, 0.017747217789292336, -0.008984155021607876, -0.020804189145565033, 0.026630697771906853, -0.036814842373132706, 0.05108217895030975, 0.030880479142069817, -0.0338011160492897, -0.0436481349170208, -0.01143409963697195, -0.027688978239893913, 0.0435020737349987, 0.025079427286982536, -0.025766003876924515, 0.043951693922281265, -0.04413650557398796, -0.01903562620282173, -0.018305465579032898, 0.038432031869888306, -0.03314393758773804, -0.0008929852047003806, 0.01618126593530178, -0.06890345364809036, 0.03426859527826309, 0.023815281689167023, -0.017225809395313263, 0.04597574844956398, 0.03054535761475563, -0.017042262479662895, -0.024298571050167084, 0.02166423201560974, 0.008231066167354584, 0.008860473521053791, 0.0104292593896389, -0.01183315459638834, -0.002758014714345336, 0.012655723839998245, -0.03441259264945984, -0.01220161747187376, 0.011703139171004295, -0.004806381184607744, -0.05074552446603775, -0.026168232783675194, 0.00416090153157711, -0.0013524249661713839, -0.04284798726439476, 0.032797712832689285, -0.043168049305677414, -0.08342986553907394, 0.017489081248641014, -0.025483611971139908, 0.027818920090794563, -0.022116996347904205, -0.00718526029959321, 0.026828566566109657, 0.011512039229273796, -0.050021350383758545, -0.04069378972053528, 0.05907333269715309, -0.025692764669656754, 0.02318824641406536, -0.008391662500798702, 0.0017700355965644121, -0.05221371725201607, -0.02472427673637867, -0.03160060942173004, 0.012972797267138958, -0.005502945277839899, -0.030536705628037453, -0.031656552106142044, 0.054847557097673416, -0.03233512490987778, -0.0033646111842244864, 0.035736437886953354, -0.0361735001206398, 0.0016103769885376096, 0.00016559231153223664, -0.07748819142580032, 0.06236710026860237, -0.03301786258816719, 0.06420796364545822, 0.07241097837686539, -0.05992988124489784, 0.04650875926017761, -0.013647163286805153, -0.03145124018192291, -0.038841843605041504, -0.030421866104006767, 0.11188841611146927, 0.025423564016819, -0.0006987917586229742, 0.0293364766985178, -0.04340111464262009, 0.058697979897260666, -0.010167445987462997, -0.05663570389151573, -0.0005389561410993338, -0.02055751532316208, 0.022953234612941742, -0.05728813260793686, 0.10835950076580048, -0.037994135171175, 0.015141988173127174, -0.03511713445186615, -0.04530438408255577, -0.05286245793104172, 0.02419796586036682, 0.05162913724780083, 0.02327514812350273, -0.06824325025081635, -0.028222179040312767, -0.037487007677555084, -0.007150312885642052, 0.02205115370452404, -0.0010317343985661864, -0.0677279531955719, -0.014534791000187397, -0.031132768839597702, -0.024823803454637527, 0.014609766192734241, -0.015112007968127728, 0.0005625486955977976, 0.022780900821089745, -0.005765818525105715, 0.047212906181812286, 0.0012927085626870394, -0.045099109411239624, 0.018578631803393364, 0.0473409928381443, -0.025309305638074875, 0.007147477474063635, -0.023565851151943207, -0.001099038403481245, 0.01143726333975792, 0.010101552121341228, -0.0364345982670784, 0.02574305795133114, -0.01830638386309147, 0.020271770656108856, -0.04022499546408653, 0.03548961132764816, -0.005098453722894192, 0.034204527735710144, 0.041593506932258606, -0.048277776688337326, 0.037250351160764694, 0.04615041986107826, -0.020152032375335693, 0.04882843792438507, -0.007921239361166954, -0.04756497964262962, -0.00039175304118543863, -0.00902723427861929, 0.004102273378521204, 0.02589144930243492, -0.019062036648392677, 0.016952548176050186, 0.02898828312754631, 0.008643182925879955, -0.031109347939491272, -0.04997720569372177, 0.014865058474242687, 0.007644429337233305, 0.002952529350295663, -0.007894343696534634, -0.026860205456614494, -0.06564678996801376, -0.06410963833332062, -0.01671540178358555, 0.0265482347458601, -0.00820462591946125, 0.03798157721757889, -0.0010838847374543548, -0.03428050875663757, 0.06665696948766708, -0.028125453740358353, 0.028722016140818596, -0.010860396549105644, 0.02980319783091545, 0.04900345951318741, -0.031957920640707016, -0.058217983692884445, 0.03048938885331154, 0.04345259442925453, 0.0432092659175396, 0.027196109294891357, -0.07438009977340698, -0.029514780268073082, 0.0407075434923172, -0.03207311034202576, -0.03819733113050461, -0.04048547148704529, -0.03805648908019066, -0.003148058196529746, 0.03568681702017784, 0.020889118313789368, -0.024763906374573708, -0.022719385102391243, -0.0237266942858696, 0.003623321885243058, 0.04394793510437012, 0.0062001775950193405, 0.026147034019231796, 0.011449361220002174, -0.018894722685217857, -0.031231924891471863, 0.01906519941985607, -0.04572499543428421, 0.05332113802433014, -0.01791919767856598, 0.05282289534807205, -0.0002023028355324641, 0.03354938328266144, -0.020398607477545738, -0.004287069663405418, -0.017891038209199905, -0.006256239954382181, -0.08987223356962204, 0.021004104986786842, 0.05034366250038147, 0.03609616681933403, 0.017278214916586876, -0.039664335548877716, -0.02272731065750122, -0.019272850826382637, -0.014243891462683678, -0.01469375193119049, 0.00674317916855216, -0.03741051256656647, -0.022224202752113342, -0.006373711861670017, -0.07612521201372147, -0.024642832577228546, -0.008610869757831097, 0.030399467796087265, -0.05104781314730644, -0.01881461963057518, 0.02277093008160591, -0.013266685418784618, 0.016805602237582207, 0.01548363734036684, -0.06389054656028748, -0.07287416607141495, -0.01810258813202381, -0.005655241198837757, -0.025971122086048126, 0.019564198330044746, -0.02797565422952175, 0.037890445441007614, -0.019610010087490082, 0.01160125806927681, 0.004865474998950958, -0.04145573079586029, -0.060943085700273514, -0.0026488688308745623, -0.06519853323698044, 0.031084835529327393, -0.038571882992982864, 0.03429673984646797, -0.0020486635621637106, -0.052125636488199234, 0.007559080142527819, 0.05118511617183685, -0.004166239872574806, 0.04288146272301674, 0.020206861197948456, -0.009055564180016518, -0.03458491712808609, -0.014153472147881985, -0.010484693571925163, -0.06302715092897415, 0.03666529431939125, -0.022829066962003708, -0.016212619841098785, -0.029061859473586082, -0.00025800932780839503, -0.0315295048058033, -0.005823437124490738, -0.025829404592514038, 0.014654581435024738, 0.07960488647222519, -0.01029782835394144, 0.017939558252692223, -0.014175673015415668, -0.03514527902007103, -0.06019609421491623, -0.02828490361571312, -0.052859093993902206, 0.01304259616881609, -0.08152273297309875, -0.02140747383236885, 0.031195325776934624, 0.025072498247027397, -0.051666710525751114, 0.0191525649279356, 0.10434531420469284, -0.03154505416750908, 0.019257262349128723, -0.045205216854810715, 0.0006678975187242031, -0.054275333881378174, 0.010048083029687405, -0.04990210384130478, -0.022751187905669212, -0.007123140152543783, 0.043178822845220566, 0.07386758923530579, 0.05135313794016838, 0.029666291549801826, -0.012074322439730167, -0.008675562217831612, 0.02489827387034893, -0.06260973960161209, -0.03207824006676674, 0.02451820857822895, -0.07797074317932129, 0.04873533174395561, 0.058166150003671646, 0.059453822672367096, 0.008324320428073406, 0.024726279079914093, -0.0053141494281589985, 0.012960812076926231, 0.0029356549493968487, -0.03484587371349335, -0.00834666844457388, 0.05140961334109306, 0.06606893241405487, -0.00020807278633583337, -0.04743170365691185, -0.05062651261687279, 0.0007338679279200733, 0.03660312294960022, -0.034205567091703415, -0.026686636731028557, -0.009743663482367992, -0.02586345747113228, -0.009767593815922737, -0.04830576479434967, 0.011831332929432392, 0.009821051731705666, -0.046527083963155746, -0.03247806429862976, 0.03095080330967903, 0.002713105408474803, 0.01982792094349861, -0.007268501445651054, 0.062210723757743835, 0.02085922099649906, -0.0332924947142601, -0.06754785776138306, 0.08699177950620651, -0.0038959686644375324, 0.017815737053751945, -0.020382191985845566, -0.06863129138946533, 0.02527722343802452, 0.008944079279899597, -0.004558085463941097, -0.01516321487724781, -0.0360562838613987, -0.017022546380758286, 0.05643290653824806, 0.01816484145820141, 0.02282392419874668, -0.0546313114464283, -0.010378600098192692, -0.03775268793106079, 0.019268782809376717, -0.008227868936955929, 0.021424993872642517, -0.008635549806058407, 0.048910390585660934, -0.01932482421398163, 0.06049984320998192, -0.020193500444293022, 0.02327592298388481, 0.05413084477186203, 0.03332578390836716, -0.013962522149085999, 0.026446564123034477, -0.06828894466161728, -0.018196480348706245, -0.012779023498296738, 0.001391878817230463, -0.016263848170638084, -0.025249674916267395, -0.03294060006737709, -0.01557178609073162, 0.024885891005396843, -0.04951086640357971, -0.02141786739230156, 0.03750566393136978, 0.010029712691903114, 0.0664033442735672, -0.05883064866065979, -0.0027463589794933796, 0.009589510038495064, -0.0009747122530825436, -0.014122248627245426, -0.05145490914583206, -0.011856197379529476, -0.010201615281403065, 0.02263234555721283, -0.0013311596121639013, 0.040420033037662506, 0.04251984506845474, 0.019712409004569054, 0.014516962692141533, -0.002561242086812854, -0.006350687704980373, 0.02744542993605137, -0.07046540826559067, 0.007915721274912357, 0.029041295871138573, 0.020537495613098145, -0.02821771427989006, 0.022898750379681587, -0.0038000044878572226, 0.0367547832429409, -0.020138388499617577, 0.030901947990059853, -0.0010785427875816822, 0.02417706698179245, -0.018490176647901535, -0.022158294916152954, -0.03356335312128067, -0.006032196804881096, 0.08854853361845016, 0.059670351445674896, 0.0571257658302784, 0.06112608313560486, -0.0022291154600679874, -0.03365740552544594, 0.06305418163537979, 0.004876001738011837, 0.02545575238764286, -0.03178006410598755, 0.006707781460136175, 0.02866046130657196, -0.021957622841000557, -0.033861346542835236, 0.009911433793604374, -0.017872057855129242, -0.018119800835847855, 0.06679464876651764, 0.011531057767570019, 0.049206942319869995, -0.03642646595835686, -0.04716179892420769, -0.07691299915313721, 0.0053933956660330296, -0.011808520182967186, -0.025080103427171707, -0.0026587173342704773, -0.014613861218094826, 0.0008877588552422822, 0.03730401396751404, -0.05075862631201744, -0.047947198152542114, -0.07584123313426971, -0.04185369238257408, 0.056185245513916016, -0.015126394107937813, -0.05767206475138664, 0.025634709745645523, 0.023523451760411263, 0.0012399046681821346, -0.050000421702861786, 0.019949719309806824, 0.006891455966979265, -0.014290828257799149, -0.006414967123419046, -0.045208293944597244, 0.023265067487955093, 0.02933536283671856, -0.023314518854022026, 0.04452284052968025, 0.04843269661068916, 0.03148717060685158, 0.062083788216114044, 0.059830062091350555, -0.02721351571381092, -0.05612659081816673, 0.03962736204266548, 0.0325755812227726, 0.01746494136750698, 0.011318814009428024, -0.026330135762691498, 0.016372574493288994, 0.0028111792635172606, 0.009245144203305244, 0.0007380496244877577, -0.015152333304286003, -0.045470308512449265, 0.01941751129925251, -0.0040049063973128796, -0.011130291037261486, -0.03917580470442772, 0.011455360800027847, 0.03027886338531971, 0.01664341241121292, 0.032740503549575806, 0.014287367463111877, -0.04512648284435272, -0.00534224696457386, 0.006359445862472057, 0.05131933093070984, 0.042369116097688675, -0.021289585158228874, 0.02785600535571575, -0.019557194784283638, 0.04196026548743248, -0.00784500315785408, -0.0748206153512001, 0.053662169724702835, 0.09456146508455276, 0.07830405235290527, 0.032362841069698334, 0.025201113894581795, 0.07137636840343475, -0.05721966549754143, 0.037569452077150345, -0.003359303344041109, 0.04341059550642967, -0.06373070925474167, -0.006026686634868383, 0.02277832292020321, 0.022019578143954277, -0.0035763888154178858, -0.04245967045426369, 0.0515989251434803, -0.06714814156293869, -0.019450409337878227, 0.02446754276752472, -0.011200977489352226, 0.03784605488181114, 0.04947368800640106, -0.0022536905016750097, -0.028592709451913834, -0.02061670646071434, 0.0005091845523566008, 0.04584120959043503, 0.08860033005475998, 0.042097244411706924, 0.025015974417328835, 0.02309904433786869, -0.013437296263873577, 0.018081314861774445, 0.022179124876856804, -0.025971584022045135, -0.010024827904999256, -0.016055315732955933, 0.0012484939070418477, -0.03267235681414604, -0.05905750393867493, 0.04089997708797455 ]
<p>Red colour bares 430-480THz and Violet bares 670-750THz according to Wikipedia.</p> <p>What frequencies are the colours between red and violet? Will they be higher than red? or lower than violet?</p> <p>What physically properties do opposite colours carry? Cyan is the opposite colour of red; yellow is the opposite colour of blue; green is the opposite colour of magenta. Can it be expressed mathematically?</p>
g4267
[ 0.04018641635775566, -0.03281547874212265, 0.0031378460116684437, -0.06600605696439743, 0.08271835744380951, 0.022165432572364807, 0.015059578232467175, -0.006575317122042179, -0.002018509665504098, 0.01413145661354065, -0.030095919966697693, 0.0019716238602995872, 0.007563173770904541, 0.05117567256093025, -0.030271584168076515, 0.03590817376971245, -0.03444959595799446, 0.05863955244421959, 0.024577295407652855, 0.027948690578341484, -0.06886978447437286, 0.03563389554619789, -0.05509957671165466, -0.045624472200870514, -0.06888733059167862, 0.01842445880174637, -0.03183651342988014, -0.020458001643419266, -0.00009079286246560514, -0.04176569730043411, 0.04502098262310028, -0.03105330467224121, 0.04102093726396561, 0.011311604641377926, 0.008715196512639523, 0.03798816725611687, -0.0081217922270298, 0.008982235565781593, -0.03366416320204735, 0.06540825963020325, 0.05835013836622238, 0.028352081775665283, -0.011268079280853271, -0.00615702522918582, 0.007254534400999546, 0.008997248485684395, -0.02566436305642128, 0.02758709527552128, -0.03823576495051384, 0.009920830838382244, -0.022483110427856445, 0.05267917364835739, -0.006646694149821997, 0.043954867869615555, 0.023763000965118408, -0.028576115146279335, 0.014844578690826893, -0.036164313554763794, 0.062473393976688385, 0.029895253479480743, 0.01694185845553875, 0.02942797914147377, -0.04793557524681091, 0.06762878596782684, 0.03834505379199982, -0.029055021703243256, -0.0069269174709916115, -0.04295885190367699, 0.016640806570649147, 0.005458272993564606, -0.0593169629573822, -0.048349469900131226, -0.017891203984618187, -0.019717847928404808, -0.02249244600534439, 0.010117556899785995, 0.07160572707653046, -0.005970629397779703, -0.0000747692902223207, 0.030287498608231544, -0.05415134131908417, -0.008128482848405838, 0.04173000529408455, 0.066288523375988, 0.07771547883749008, -0.0412021167576313, -0.0007746540941298008, -0.02210705541074276, -0.01779685728251934, 0.06663437187671661, 0.053368762135505676, -0.028669625520706177, 0.05179896578192711, -0.05807017907500267, 0.0006195495370775461, -0.019084976986050606, -0.07618953287601471, 0.04845493286848068, -0.01350479293614626, -0.013801953755319118, 0.001789748203009367, -0.03164593502879143, 0.042405158281326294, -0.05121982470154762, -0.0378260463476181, -0.017974914982914925, 0.0754491314291954, -0.014741456136107445, -0.0724136233329773, 0.025111118331551552, -0.03436872735619545, -0.017357632517814636, -0.03594105318188667, 0.011563649401068687, -0.052588481456041336, -0.056939996778964996, 0.02863910421729088, -0.00034567946568131447, 0.05276663228869438, 0.0587136335670948, 0.08055227994918823, 0.07929857820272446, 0.022441308945417404, -0.011151633225381374, 0.014943950809538364, -0.044690486043691635, 0.009407129138708115, -0.022571779787540436, -0.017022013664245605, 0.009616897441446781, 0.020220797508955002, 0.02170450985431671, 0.004908888600766659, -0.032391149550676346, 0.0612700916826725, 0.00037522547063417733, 0.07149844616651535, -0.011265475302934647, -0.0011822334490716457, -0.013128108344972134, 0.07501086592674255, -0.01811150088906288, 0.003255941206589341, -0.0551699697971344, -0.018261393532156944, -0.015607045032083988, 0.012998399324715137, -0.0087705347687006, -0.029274772852659225, 0.001576978829689324, 0.008656336925923824, 0.00119971192907542, 0.053298138082027435, -0.045160580426454544, -0.055591292679309845, -0.057151731103658676, 0.05485925078392029, 0.019241761416196823, -0.034047432243824005, 0.03670423477888107, 0.01851911097764969, -0.043281204998493195, 0.028152190148830414, 0.023126710206270218, 0.010510634630918503, -0.061461664736270905, 0.010090513154864311, -0.037110548466444016, -0.019372614100575447, 0.01960601843893528, -0.02922222763299942, 0.04136132448911667, -0.04544198513031006, 0.05175435170531273, 0.021021481603384018, 0.052327241748571396, 0.04774431139230728, -0.0030868463218212128, 0.01936756819486618, -0.018345726653933525, -0.020374121144413948, -0.021145019680261612, 0.011842550709843636, -0.014884279109537601, 0.011533660814166069, -0.036724433302879333, -0.004968680441379547, -0.024119017645716667, -0.04639045521616936, 0.07915971428155899, -0.032460130751132965, 0.008304145187139511, -0.014359396882355213, 0.007655635941773653, 0.021938273683190346, -0.09468164294958115, -0.0711311474442482, 0.08312549442052841, 0.018146073445677757, 0.06644577533006668, 0.004569619428366423, -0.023640891537070274, 0.025876397266983986, 0.01895005628466606, 0.00401377072557807, 0.03436454012989998, -0.01616501808166504, -0.025510122999548912, 0.058973658829927444, -0.012276710942387581, -0.016441460698843002, -0.015685999765992165, 0.042826149612665176, 0.08649327605962753, 0.08172831684350967, 0.018877198919653893, 0.0008069869945757091, -0.021134914830327034, 0.00015838818217162043, 0.010875983163714409, -0.0012916970299556851, -0.038486722856760025, 0.04326671361923218, 0.004016818478703499, -0.027247099205851555, 0.0013234481448307633, -0.05282771214842796, 0.053001247346401215, 0.02606203407049179, -0.017697622999548912, 0.008093002252280712, -0.005338661372661591, 0.012900848872959614, -0.02288350835442543, -0.03183687850832939, 0.06919678300619125, 0.019678747281432152, 0.019399581477046013, -0.01561096590012312, -0.022544624283909798, -0.013325377367436886, 0.004821873735636473, -0.00441362801939249, 0.07004901766777039, -0.06556808948516846, 0.015998555347323418, 0.020438633859157562, -0.02712804451584816, -0.038430195301771164, 0.051829732954502106, 0.019969448447227478, 0.014448455534875393, 0.0122947683557868, 0.027510441839694977, -0.023316847160458565, -0.007781865540891886, -0.02351972833275795, -0.022771041840314865, -0.04850558564066887, -0.04649648442864418, -0.01713992841541767, -0.008948083035647869, 0.008618617430329323, 0.012890193611383438, -0.06431419402360916, -0.017758678644895554, -0.036699749529361725, 0.0307200625538826, -0.03088432550430298, -0.004457335453480482, -0.05665558949112892, 0.009646767750382423, -0.03110741637647152, -0.04384887218475342, 0.013499404303729534, -0.003923478070646524, 0.028452644124627113, -0.09011059999465942, 0.012478973716497421, -0.00022871636610943824, 0.008923694491386414, 0.03063959628343582, -0.02038630098104477, -0.0013880158076062799, 0.00440372945740819, 0.0014589241473004222, 0.028488103300333023, 0.017124855890870094, -0.016918206587433815, 0.009050578810274601, -0.04215525463223457, 0.07771581411361694, 0.09091980755329132, 0.007699858862906694, -0.06161385029554367, 0.011511381715536118, 0.0482109934091568, -0.024727972224354744, -0.07398398965597153, 0.008660492487251759, 0.03159088268876076, 0.009827700443565845, 0.0015638871118426323, -0.00776019087061286, 0.04068373516201973, -0.01273653469979763, -0.05362216383218765, 0.020548207685351372, 0.007498207967728376, -0.013251153752207756, -0.02728911302983761, 0.0231388621032238, -0.01549682766199112, -0.010470985434949398, -0.0016565514961257577, 0.010405831970274448, -0.008325237780809402, -0.014645472168922424, 0.0020272391848266125, 0.02258535660803318, -0.028988810256123543, -0.04430733621120453, 0.017329437658190727, 0.0019856165163218975, 0.04321262612938881, -0.05054250359535217, -0.006019136868417263, -0.004908905364573002, -0.02342071756720543, 0.026088057085871696, 0.0514799989759922, 0.057372722774744034, -0.003355040680617094, 0.02542807348072529, -0.013612550683319569, 0.01774033159017563, 0.02438315376639366, -0.02338659204542637, -0.020843030884861946, 0.04460388422012329, 0.05515456572175026, 0.0026640703435987234, -0.025691788643598557, -0.049606602638959885, -0.0191657654941082, 0.03524113819003105, -0.04753594845533371, 0.018612680956721306, 0.005263186059892178, -0.04412531852722168, -0.013017240911722183, -0.03677209094166756, 0.08685364574193954, -0.01673869974911213, -0.0053385659120976925, 0.0038801790215075016, 0.02653166465461254, 0.04211985319852829, 0.011260459199547768, -0.011332455091178417, 0.013668484054505825, -0.018504131585359573, 0.014908884651958942, -0.08988898992538452, -0.009276184253394604, -0.04967843368649483, -0.02070089429616928, 0.06445057690143585, 0.007936119101941586, -0.03942219167947769, 0.01103284116834402, -0.0024770640302449465, -0.002448555314913392, 0.07045479863882065, -0.038552749902009964, -0.0035654313396662474, 0.0022003096528351307, -0.0292829517275095, -0.025723297148942947, 0.04413488134741783, 0.010594399645924568, 0.005517252255231142, 0.08360935002565384, -0.02756815031170845, 0.042860452085733414, -0.060519345104694366, -0.041796207427978516, -0.019764579832553864, -0.05409005656838417, -0.06023460254073143, -0.015758007764816284, -0.030269773676991463, -0.043393101543188095, 0.014934360980987549, 0.02262701280415058, -0.04408837482333183, 0.015882913023233414, -0.015406671911478043, 0.013716595247387886, 0.030177079141139984, -0.04636650159955025, 0.0006883901078253984, -0.02531343139708042, 0.0022645972203463316, -0.006617424543946981, 0.017026960849761963, 0.008811458013951778, -0.02745438739657402, -0.015526182018220425, 0.019758077338337898, -0.04123224690556526, -0.027060339227318764, 0.03384293243288994, -0.08945079892873764, 0.024626435711979866, 0.08108657598495483, 0.05027278512716293, -0.017086366191506386, 0.04381488263607025, 0.041403286159038544, 0.06903668493032455, 0.06095953658223152, 0.022232595831155777, -0.027943307533860207, 0.0038929181173443794, 0.0613410584628582, 0.058118607848882675, -0.008223293349146843, -0.01993492804467678, 0.0017832841258496046, 0.04396086186170578, -0.014441418461501598, -0.0156573299318552, -0.0025398924481123686, 0.005336560308933258, 0.03643609955906868, -0.0021952937822788954, 0.013700677081942558, 0.020057154819369316, -0.00530389416962862, -0.018460635095834732, -0.04773354530334473, -0.03128354623913765, -0.05293363332748413, -0.032852135598659515, 0.054735805839300156, -0.03360302373766899, -0.05217915400862694, -0.027313245460391045, -0.01512150838971138, 0.016417602077126503, 0.05318072438240051, -0.06108350679278374, 0.0372718870639801, -0.02589762955904007, 0.009489759802818298, -0.06639676541090012, -0.018929723650217056, 0.03454679250717163, -0.030646709725260735, -0.021625733003020287, -0.04934840276837349, -0.02023714780807495, -0.0538388267159462, 0.027840688824653625, 0.014664079993963242, -0.01718827895820141, 0.03911818936467171, -0.0336136631667614, 0.04443003982305527, -0.012642877176404, -0.011784475296735764, 0.04406445845961571, -0.005261753685772419, 0.025918666273355484, -0.03161356598138809, 0.026103220880031586, -0.0542265810072422, 0.03223205357789993, -0.03142732009291649, -0.03696739301085472, 0.000921394384931773, 0.00006986231892369688, 0.030710820108652115, -0.07891052216291428, 0.024221759289503098, -0.03426428511738777, 0.05737223103642464, -0.042807064950466156, -0.010245978832244873, 0.0228566937148571, -0.03500213846564293, -0.03802500292658806, 0.04019572213292122, -0.02542072907090187, -0.03124268539249897, 0.03227052465081215, 0.017659807577729225, -0.04254412278532982, -0.007648553233593702, 0.0010009288089349866, 0.0871729627251625, -0.007598896976560354, 0.02626817114651203, -0.018329359591007233, -0.04206455871462822, 0.03739498555660248, -0.03547702729701996, -0.03682661056518555, 0.011801921762526035, 0.0029315014835447073, -0.05786626785993576, 0.029566781595349312, 0.027829453349113464, -0.023101747035980225, -0.031073395162820816, -0.061506487429142, -0.040911320596933365, 0.045740868896245956, -0.00563235767185688, -0.04256827011704445, -0.013940037228167057, 0.018932880833745003, -0.02502003312110901, -0.05458958446979523, -0.008129123598337173, 0.003380629699677229, -0.010184720158576965, -0.0016363669419661164, -0.11190292984247208, 0.013721558265388012, 0.04005410522222519, 0.011850452050566673, -0.03319859504699707, -0.024578368291258812, -0.01779979281127453, -0.0038784502539783716, -0.03963480889797211, -0.07104067504405975, 0.0696723535656929, -0.000687266350723803, 0.02578255720436573, 0.03065546229481697, 0.049018971621990204, -0.04200524464249611, -0.025498241186141968, -0.05015895515680313, 0.06532152742147446, -0.0027965009212493896, 0.02471170574426651, 0.013463057577610016, 0.0055097430013120174, 0.025777827948331833, 0.04006536677479744, 0.02262928895652294, -0.02192067913711071, -0.033352095633745193, -0.03519263118505478, 0.025782475247979164, 0.008633897639811039, 0.028788985684514046, -0.004451841115951538, 0.020313872024416924, 0.0240426454693079, -0.04782687872648239, -0.046601343899965286, -0.00439969077706337, 0.004116068594157696, 0.07048290967941284, 0.03879912197589874, 0.026025887578725815, -0.020254846662282944, 0.025645509362220764, -0.0012353559723123908, 0.020423389971256256, 0.028792554512619972, -0.019237486645579338, -0.05872664600610733, -0.013998683542013168, -0.00652088038623333, 0.014930902048945427, 0.03912656754255295, -0.04966628551483154, 0.001864525955170393, -0.07131384313106537, 0.045344721525907516, 0.027065478265285492, -0.05499638244509697, 0.020891098305583, -0.0026261371094733477, -0.000013641366422234569, -0.010702366940677166, -0.011966162361204624, -0.04215028136968613, 0.01764722913503647, -0.02089814469218254, -0.0013295842800289392, 0.03565400466322899, -0.026305612176656723, 0.010516348294913769, 0.03668123111128807, -0.03775496408343315, 0.11042819172143936, 0.009041811339557171, 0.04885708913207054, 0.02411721460521221, 0.048743803054094315, 0.0075447275303304195, -0.03253648802638054, 0.010400776751339436, 0.01814301311969757, 0.04537888988852501, 0.018482545390725136, -0.006669045425951481, -0.02886892855167389, -0.04064909368753433, 0.028974510729312897, 0.01721945032477379, 0.0176465455442667, 0.021152637898921967, 0.01621929183602333, -0.042594414204359055, -0.053757160902023315, -0.040962930768728256, -0.00033124996116384864, 0.06096382811665535, 0.009425067342817783, 0.04595774784684181, 0.03185596317052841, -0.037864599376916885, 0.062332164496183395, -0.02816419117152691, 0.03669966012239456, 0.006752404849976301, 0.03488685190677643, -0.0200408436357975, -0.08168420195579529, -0.02453155815601349, 0.0271137747913599, -0.01910988613963127, 0.015433600172400475, 0.00006668033165624365, 0.000990435597486794, -0.0062031992711126804, 0.04999687895178795, 0.006719659548252821, 0.008389624767005444, -0.05711917579174042, 0.00839866790920496, 0.0030928694177418947, 0.01742427423596382, -0.008668438531458378, -0.04594308137893677, 0.00951976515352726, 0.011330503970384598, 0.027585141360759735, 0.03482344001531601, 0.027282999828457832, 0.015266671776771545, 0.018665147945284843, -0.03618665412068367, -0.03514035418629646, -0.03952774778008461, 0.009891711175441742, -0.01568877510726452, 0.013344724662601948, 0.049570292234420776, -0.07710540294647217, -0.03342696279287338, -0.01860569790005684, -0.024171462282538414, -0.03720379248261452, 0.0021401906851679087, -0.038076940923929214, 0.029383279383182526, -0.010511357337236404, -0.08751902729272842, 0.0021705671679228544, 0.040990184992551804, -0.020312728360295296, -0.029968254268169403, -0.012936325743794441, 0.04657960310578346, 0.006359881721436977, -0.002641625702381134, 0.06383705884218216, -0.03338319808244705, 0.01818801276385784, 0.023310517892241478, -0.04175912216305733, -0.027165208011865616, -0.011788813397288322, 0.009545075707137585, -0.051223620772361755, 0.016860568895936012, 0.014618515968322754, 0.005087397526949644, 0.0005204600747674704, 0.02757129818201065, 0.036458246409893036, 0.02268778160214424, -0.01870834454894066, 0.027892109006643295, -0.007159050088375807, 0.058728914707899094, 0.0013515787431970239, -0.006664890795946121, 0.008499111980199814, -0.0366598442196846, -0.037682656198740005, 0.040000468492507935, 0.03955501317977905, 0.060859985649585724, 0.05700958892703056, 0.04248897731304169, 0.017389971762895584, -0.06976290047168732, -0.04920034483075142, -0.05301667004823685, 0.027903201058506966, -0.01932051219046116, -0.014380319975316525, 0.05009860917925835, -0.06681887060403824, -0.057219117879867554, -0.01134802307933569, -0.014237224124372005, 0.042124129831790924, -0.00045743901864625514, 0.021941570565104485, -0.05968887358903885, 0.0190126895904541, 0.016836943104863167, 0.07786094397306442, -0.05364569276571274, 0.01057018619030714, 0.037241190671920776, 0.07677455991506577, -0.009808450937271118, 0.003541018348187208, 0.00922186579555273, 0.049949903041124344, -0.002702899044379592, -0.00003250690861023031, -0.014789765700697899, 0.00767620699480176, -0.03560909628868103, 0.02583436667919159, 0.050452739000320435, -0.06624722480773926, 0.013915801420807838, -0.007756618317216635, -0.014863547869026661, 0.040179312229156494, 0.07561883330345154, -0.027576763182878494, 0.025609394535422325, 0.023238450288772583, 0.040156759321689606, -0.05190841481089592, -0.04602936655282974, 0.016414310783147812, -0.01622093841433525, 0.003230263711884618, -0.014333631843328476, -0.003256009193137288, -0.07255006581544876, -0.012468992732465267 ]
<p>Basically, What is the difference <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamagnetism" rel="nofollow">diamagnetism</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Superconductivity" rel="nofollow">superconductivity</a>?</p> <p>As far as I understand, diamagnetism comes from the fact, that all electrons in a solid, when exerted by an external magnetic field, create so-called Eddy Currents which oppose the external magnetic field, right ?</p> <p>And in a superconductor, the supercurrents, are actually are "normal" current in the material, which opposes the magnetic field.</p> <p>But is that the whole story, or am I simplifying it too much ?</p>
g4268
[ 0.05423864349722862, 0.06207273527979851, -0.0032441820949316025, -0.03268202766776085, 0.025183483958244324, -0.0012178663164377213, 0.05234668776392937, 0.06715600192546844, -0.030478794127702713, -0.057944558560848236, -0.06319760531187057, -0.01855602115392685, -0.009876305237412453, 0.00782180018723011, -0.0002757605689112097, 0.03146319091320038, -0.04076777398586273, 0.026123270392417908, 0.05794752016663551, 0.0210677832365036, 0.027904244139790535, -0.0035926576238125563, 0.0691370740532875, -0.024801110848784447, -0.0029088729061186314, -0.00973531510680914, -0.04009164124727249, -0.06477389484643936, 0.006082450971007347, 0.008533326908946037, -0.020653661340475082, -0.02713661640882492, 0.09750425815582275, -0.02214045636355877, 0.024644291028380394, 0.00538133829832077, -0.007737698033452034, 0.03522064909338951, 0.007024763617664576, 0.011343174614012241, -0.06654301285743713, 0.059033945202827454, -0.007503965403884649, -0.05234258249402046, -0.014328072778880596, -0.04939104989171028, -0.07222216576337814, 0.00173441122751683, -0.03940736874938011, -0.008433825336396694, 0.02998819202184677, -0.021655654534697533, 0.017144538462162018, 0.02579858899116516, -0.0063002752140164375, -0.043265894055366516, 0.008612554520368576, -0.014218087308108807, 0.033784959465265274, -0.05076577886939049, -0.01885257288813591, 0.012335695326328278, -0.06031148135662079, 0.022015569731593132, 0.024471648037433624, 0.018792612478137016, -0.0010576439090073109, -0.0467478446662426, -0.008049129508435726, 0.013681010343134403, -0.02987956441938877, -0.06560686230659485, -0.04866345226764679, -0.06605421006679535, -0.026441462337970734, 0.012602001428604126, 0.04301599785685539, -0.06235703453421593, 0.07365712523460388, -0.0152755631133914, -0.00047563889529556036, -0.030445646494627, 0.003978540655225515, 0.101162388920784, 0.050111278891563416, 0.020679008215665817, -0.04091314598917961, 0.018194280564785004, 0.04126199707388878, 0.02010822482407093, 0.01017738413065672, 0.007166635245084763, -0.013348015956580639, 0.05381693318486214, -0.03297845274209976, 0.05146283656358719, 0.029733633622527122, 0.027114996686577797, 0.0053633591160178185, -0.0014070170000195503, -0.01113126054406166, -0.03194408491253853, 0.03068847954273224, 0.05547111853957176, 0.013293334282934666, -0.023151207715272903, 0.026696041226387024, 0.02172045409679413, -0.01374567300081253, 0.02198687754571438, -0.053942516446113586, 0.01676202565431595, -0.09169353544712067, 0.03646228089928627, 0.01289415080100298, -0.026030100882053375, -0.017957637086510658, -0.08380535989999771, -0.009768674150109291, 0.010219891555607319, -0.0073748016729950905, 0.046107519418001175, -0.04143454134464264, 0.08409319818019867, 0.001135007245466113, 0.003441466484218836, 0.005901514086872339, 0.015803396701812744, 0.005771226715296507, 0.002398134209215641, 0.034946009516716, -0.027612116187810898, 0.038141943514347076, -0.00859797652810812, 0.008905497379601002, 0.0378212034702301, 0.012011948972940445, 0.0036887305323034525, -0.02545083872973919, -0.037709567695856094, 0.00806175172328949, -0.04487006366252899, 0.003213702468201518, 0.015563529916107655, -0.020937182009220123, 0.0022398275323212147, -0.030035337433218956, 0.06284255534410477, 0.04512845352292061, 0.07270612567663193, 0.038223713636398315, 0.060162581503391266, 0.02441474236547947, -0.0077286516316235065, -0.020082388073205948, 0.026754075661301613, -0.011514829471707344, -0.00526166707277298, -0.012378194369375706, -0.0004356526187621057, 0.005661740433424711, -0.026905875653028488, 0.013225752860307693, -0.011140002869069576, -0.03549877554178238, -0.019561488181352615, -0.010301144793629646, 0.0401320643723011, -0.012389782816171646, -0.009949245490133762, 0.004738057963550091, 0.017069295048713684, -0.04963696748018265, 0.041199300438165665, 0.009017471224069595, 0.05172407627105713, 0.04115845263004303, -0.04634188115596771, 0.019354846328496933, -0.01847166381776333, -0.027627835050225258, 0.006342136766761541, 0.02329520881175995, -0.017790768295526505, 0.009657949209213257, 0.039506759494543076, 0.026653321459889412, 0.04531412944197655, -0.04291580244898796, 0.04920290410518646, -0.07476012408733368, -0.06436649709939957, -0.01185440830886364, 0.09361885488033295, -0.00166756147518754, -0.035390011966228485, -0.05414363369345665, 0.07027095556259155, -0.03389390558004379, -0.060265254229307175, 0.0352521613240242, -0.020767778158187866, 0.05262092128396034, -0.027950532734394073, -0.00108541757799685, -0.004561304580420256, -0.05154925212264061, -0.025265365839004517, 0.08424460887908936, -0.0015633809380233288, 0.013662572018802166, -0.006844733376055956, -0.012613525614142418, -0.03255394846200943, -0.044004689902067184, -0.012968524359166622, -0.0014104488072916865, -0.017121752724051476, -0.07868324965238571, -0.015134920366108418, -0.037648484110832214, -0.008222072385251522, 0.04636399820446968, -0.06458031386137009, -0.04606148973107338, -0.028417054563760757, -0.00718480721116066, -0.008740333840250969, 0.03159249946475029, -0.03543134033679962, -0.059532731771469116, -0.07989182323217392, 0.01643519476056099, -0.04315401613712311, 0.011808313429355621, 0.028944602236151695, 0.02610052563250065, -0.001373295788653195, -0.00732410280033946, -0.02150174044072628, 0.004810860846191645, -0.01788700744509697, -0.016796791926026344, -0.0017465275013819337, 0.008841076865792274, -0.08661731332540512, 0.08009553700685501, -0.012490740045905113, -0.028706148266792297, -0.05742191895842552, 0.004882564302533865, -0.01224098727107048, -0.0352901965379715, -0.026594974100589752, 0.012752126902341843, -0.056690867990255356, -0.01576581597328186, 0.019164003431797028, -0.04026070237159729, -0.0018479679711163044, -0.042205438017845154, -0.04606381058692932, 0.028905469924211502, 0.0004267592739779502, -0.06494534015655518, -0.02176043391227722, -0.01575426012277603, 0.04933977872133255, -0.04509717971086502, -0.027139311656355858, -0.007661651354283094, 0.051226262003183365, -0.020426902920007706, -0.0499228797852993, -0.028236063197255135, -0.027749158442020416, -0.014088703319430351, -0.0033138387370854616, 0.030037181451916695, -0.03736462816596031, 0.00497854920104146, -0.03348604589700699, -0.02606760710477829, -0.02501123771071434, 0.0033352694008499384, 0.022816170006990433, -0.03575810045003891, -0.05199902877211571, -0.023543689399957657, -0.01781514100730419, -0.016585450619459152, 0.01956081949174404, 0.04267764464020729, 0.024877125397324562, -0.008057367987930775, -0.0031659251544624567, 0.06384699046611786, 0.020654447376728058, -0.020886601880192757, 0.024426644667983055, -0.05281617119908333, 0.01401363406330347, -0.04460135102272034, 0.030546238645911217, 0.023064881563186646, 0.027085736393928528, -0.004662119783461094, -0.10235702991485596, -0.025664079934358597, -0.01859799213707447, -0.03163043037056923, 0.029899196699261665, -0.054490093141794205, 0.05157266929745674, 0.009441952221095562, -0.009782887995243073, 0.014937923289835453, 0.06565121561288834, 0.08765733987092972, -0.05733398348093033, -0.06989835202693939, -0.04598226025700569, -0.0016571168089285493, 0.006407467648386955, 0.02431138977408409, 0.04177796468138695, 0.011352680623531342, -0.008849896490573883, -0.08106404542922974, -0.0471208356320858, 0.0443953238427639, 0.026563310995697975, -0.06593423336744308, 0.001192946918308735, -0.09485309571027756, -0.0011951201595366001, -0.008597159758210182, 0.03944665566086769, 0.027644043788313866, 0.03267805650830269, 0.060210175812244415, -0.00562641303986311, -0.07693640142679214, -0.04103536158800125, 0.024023178964853287, 0.07533256709575653, -0.06789980828762054, 0.014363298192620277, 0.02894231304526329, 0.009188073687255383, 0.03420637547969818, 0.029502909630537033, 0.031705066561698914, 0.018879231065511703, -0.055716197937726974, -0.01637336052954197, 0.03988498076796532, 0.033118147403001785, -0.030052250251173973, 0.013529813848435879, 0.08940808475017548, 0.021909348666667938, 0.033027008175849915, -0.012978519313037395, -0.01206410676240921, -0.002451579086482525, 0.04396136477589607, -0.01164319645613432, -0.04556097462773323, -0.06262471526861191, 0.014581589959561825, -0.004457591101527214, -0.0022736643441021442, 0.008402020670473576, 0.06485636532306671, -0.04786228388547897, 0.030986346304416656, 0.050714075565338135, -0.0445750467479229, 0.013285521417856216, 0.047768257558345795, 0.05501805245876312, -0.005239491816610098, -0.04045957326889038, 0.00318515463732183, -0.02589450404047966, -0.028994055464863777, 0.04054948687553406, -0.03429921716451645, -0.04564628005027771, -0.05023811385035515, 0.013781681656837463, -0.023657571524381638, 0.0009985006181523204, -0.026395047083497047, 0.04586028307676315, -0.012350126169621944, -0.006278888322412968, 0.04920677840709686, -0.04141966253519058, 0.03294362500309944, 0.015940425917506218, -0.014066101983189583, 0.011720984242856503, 0.016547156497836113, 0.009752250276505947, 0.0373523086309433, -0.015789318829774857, 0.013754917308688164, -0.08045965433120728, -0.02138380892574787, 0.004373050760477781, -0.033723343163728714, -0.016517091542482376, 0.04552953317761421, -0.02645879052579403, -0.013094328343868256, 0.03574580326676369, 0.05322697013616562, -0.038914941251277924, -0.0156386811286211, -0.00961543619632721, 0.02385696955025196, 0.018466532230377197, 0.0038870435673743486, 0.06217818707227707, 0.04306476563215256, 0.02144087664783001, -0.0008925731526687741, 0.022655470296740532, 0.037155624479055405, 0.0450863279402256, 0.011328563094139099, 0.043399833142757416, -0.116794154047966, 0.013208679854869843, -0.02975720353424549, 0.06120031699538231, 0.04202209413051605, -0.03664408251643181, 0.05174091085791588, 0.030858557671308517, 0.037755612283945084, -0.0036056304816156626, 0.0419897586107254, 0.0029620579443871975, -0.06517976522445679, -0.0038117433432489634, -0.05923103168606758, -0.04667403921484947, -0.018408896401524544, 0.05461811646819115, 0.0008957945392467082, 0.011837242171168327, -0.04647153615951538, 0.026345932856202126, 0.012355237267911434, -0.054690875113010406, -0.0063496851362288, 0.0031163780950009823, -0.03224429860711098, -0.045781444758176804, -0.02226969040930271, -0.021089069545269012, -0.012037874199450016, -0.013014151714742184, 0.002778679598122835, -0.05064401030540466, -0.044617846608161926, -0.008626995608210564, 0.02082243748009205, 0.025515327230095863, 0.003997947089374065, 0.04880344867706299, 0.10054752230644226, -0.021607406437397003, 0.022959008812904358, 0.0002558969717938453, -0.03893337398767471, -0.022715669125318527, -0.021301647648215294, 0.05228239297866821, 0.08812917768955231, -0.007516070734709501, 0.04189583659172058, -0.022495731711387634, -0.01868419721722603, 0.04364701732993126, 0.05221585929393768, 0.0046717762015759945, -0.004898226819932461, -0.04144087806344032, -0.01980016939342022, -0.05961199104785919, -0.04491496831178665, -0.009321248158812523, 0.010795855894684792, 0.02047952078282833, -0.04828181490302086, -0.06468910723924637, -0.04366861656308174, 0.04800453409552574, 0.011628992855548859, 0.0007755847182124853, 0.047029148787260056, 0.031819846481084824, 0.057667508721351624, -0.02837282046675682, 0.01777963899075985, -0.027124609798192978, -0.05695727840065956, 0.002223413437604904, -0.012075496837496758, 0.007135932799428701, 0.03831446170806885, 0.07022690773010254, -0.027893178164958954, -0.023257866501808167, 0.04039108753204346, -0.02967030555009842, 0.006050406023859978, 0.021331578493118286, 0.026081103831529617, -0.07269324362277985, 0.009613118134438992, -0.03799595683813095, -0.01776203140616417, -0.01947646774351597, 0.0766213908791542, 0.03507962450385094, 0.02133144438266754, 0.02727627381682396, 0.06875094026327133, 0.01888424903154373, 0.003800345351919532, -0.012937074527144432, 0.012015770189464092, 0.023127585649490356, -0.01288850512355566, 0.062215544283390045, 0.020170437172055244, 0.023318970575928688, 0.0180082805454731, 0.07804947346448898, -0.03020915947854519, -0.007607490289956331, 0.02343975193798542, -0.027349596843123436, 0.024659624323248863, -0.0076676937751472, -0.03926100581884384, 0.04849765822291374, 0.037421561777591705, 0.02162925899028778, 0.026662787422537804, 0.0818156898021698, 0.012822572141885757, -0.018453577533364296, -0.049422040581703186, -0.05098969489336014, 0.03252987936139107, 0.04314517229795456, 0.017042865976691246, -0.019817959517240524, 0.049467287957668304, 0.06103334575891495, -0.03861754387617111, -0.029552338644862175, 0.01823333092033863, 0.018896739929914474, 0.016087951138615608, -0.044584114104509354, -0.00039811336318962276, 0.010904422029852867, -0.010567213408648968, 0.04576335474848747, -0.000329013098962605, -0.01486026868224144, -0.03022903949022293, 0.019100641831755638, 0.005394220817834139, -0.0015158681198954582, 0.03770400211215019, -0.025122670456767082, -0.008386269211769104, 0.03545669838786125, -0.04127762094140053, -0.03293002024292946, 0.05782337859272957, 0.005258750636130571, 0.014483842998743057, 0.021235262975096703, 0.001178771024569869, 0.002478447277098894, -0.006720781791955233, 0.002644370310008526, -0.017761755734682083, 0.007076052017509937, 0.036174118518829346, 0.013250090181827545, 0.03044155240058899, -0.0033855396322906017, 0.0289715938270092, -0.010591844096779823, 0.08628173917531967, -0.0017452731262892485, 0.02654351107776165, 0.04145083948969841, -0.029776133596897125, -0.04058750346302986, 0.001431607990525663, 0.043702807277441025, -0.04226841405034065, -0.013115694746375084, -0.033318206667900085, -0.04177151247859001, -0.08433443307876587, 0.029873976483941078, 0.011033061891794205, 0.005352136213332415, -0.03231850638985634, -0.06044045463204384, -0.03506716713309288, 0.059061869978904724, 0.017855746671557426, 0.046248458325862885, -0.0421278215944767, 0.04947347566485405, 0.020431848242878914, 0.045659389346838, 0.00846833735704422, -0.023573722690343857, -0.012329318560659885, 0.07003144919872284, 0.008536675944924355, 0.0007995395571924746, 0.048299748450517654, -0.011660040356218815, 0.030073458328843117, 0.022548016160726547, 0.019280897453427315, -0.02181396633386612, 0.05365776643157005, 0.011033432558178902, -0.04932964965701103, 0.0075227017514407635, 0.004515314940363169, 0.020083438605070114, -0.06906011700630188, -0.002225948264822364, 0.02221105992794037, -0.026406049728393555, -0.0045423563569784164, 0.03995554894208908, -0.032756656408309937, 0.02299177460372448, -0.01311272569000721, 0.028165724128484726, -0.01708834245800972, -0.05282678082585335, -0.021541016176342964, 0.015590088441967964, -0.013514016754925251, -0.049033425748348236, 0.04482724145054817, 0.035564541816711426, 0.004425095859915018, -0.024243846535682678, 0.018380627036094666, -0.018417097628116608, -0.0027579409070312977, -0.0332215242087841, 0.0034972424618899822, -0.01014146488159895, 0.014630318619310856, -0.04126537963747978, -0.0026106550358235836, -0.015945980325341225, -0.0015666299732401967, -0.06618436425924301, 0.01845349185168743, -0.00829255860298872, 0.06874288618564606, -0.05576081573963165, -0.026736866682767868, 0.01446505542844534, -0.021655917167663574, -0.030192352831363678, 0.023730715736746788, 0.0021457993425428867, 0.042578067630529404, -0.02285522036254406, -0.0013935742899775505, -0.007217200007289648, -0.020400358363986015, 0.023986902087926865, 0.02774771861732006, 0.03721984848380089, 0.0022893294226378202, 0.005504908040165901, 0.006079085171222687, 0.021170688793063164, 0.00899981427937746, 0.008768261410295963, 0.034764837473630905, 0.048722684383392334, 0.0012546604266390204, 0.0016555482288822532, -0.03894902393221855, -0.036985624581575394, 0.001175298704765737, 0.05974927172064781, 0.0633280947804451, 0.0363638699054718, 0.01171474065631628, 0.003830104833468795, 0.04442715644836426, -0.015778958797454834, -0.02569005824625492, -0.02403382584452629, -0.005893600173294544, 0.02237229235470295, -0.02655460499227047, -0.07184282690286636, -0.036752935498952866, 0.0207102969288826, -0.02338341623544693, 0.01993471197783947, 0.018577683717012405, -0.010734593495726585, -0.037054456770420074, 0.013407505117356777, 0.017279189079999924, -0.01533307135105133, -0.042263470590114594, -0.03895510733127594, 0.058859050273895264, 0.017722001299262047, -0.02106708101928234, -0.04494054242968559, 0.03476254269480705, 0.024853408336639404, -0.04059744253754616, 0.018514592200517654, -0.06142018362879753, 0.009121757000684738, -0.053460072726011276, 0.07282966375350952, -0.008141954429447651, -0.03295698016881943, 0.0026297597214579582, 0.021884702146053314, -0.050978951156139374, 0.012321578338742256, -0.004457908682525158, -0.024788573384284973, -0.019307266920804977, -0.005838547833263874, 0.06902981549501419, 0.008155577816069126, 0.013446686789393425, 0.019940707832574844, 0.0027545872144401073, -0.028611814603209496, -0.047231871634721756, 0.03121071308851242, -0.04394916817545891, 0.0016485650558024645 ]
<p>I recently studied that NASA has planned to tow and place it in the orbit of the moon. My doubt is when asteroid is placed in the orbit near moon.since the gravitational field of earth is very high.what will it revolve around the moon or the earth. Can anyone clarify my doubt ??</p>
g4269
[ 0.038833096623420715, 0.046956684440374374, 0.01691274717450142, 0.00809236615896225, 0.024675222113728523, 0.06180750951170921, -0.02767607383430004, -0.004685198422521353, -0.004850232042372227, -0.06387197971343994, 0.01564115844666958, 0.02895498462021351, 0.053965866565704346, -0.10210766643285751, 0.03788010776042938, -0.04122750461101532, 0.06257499009370804, 0.008410000242292881, -0.0248517207801342, 0.03530881553888321, -0.014416519552469254, -0.015820037573575974, -0.037725284695625305, 0.020672202110290527, -0.011774611659348011, 0.05043880641460419, 0.04656098037958145, 0.047295767813920975, 0.03688468039035797, -0.020836245268583298, 0.04200590401887894, -0.04238569363951683, 0.033080894500017166, -0.04472162574529648, -0.027026113122701645, 0.01742311380803585, -0.012443577870726585, -0.02048218809068203, -0.00242161238566041, -0.00429853331297636, -0.01639426127076149, -0.04054151847958565, -0.000900590792298317, -0.024182498455047607, 0.0008050529286265373, -0.015961235389113426, 0.03110687993466854, -0.06659124791622162, 0.03894812986254692, -0.004693557042628527, -0.0037757002282887697, 0.031703561544418335, -0.007585814688354731, -0.046598631888628006, -0.006242325063794851, 0.05422993004322052, 0.09197111427783966, -0.01604636386036873, -0.03240887075662613, -0.0010412030387669802, 0.03018008917570114, 0.010886858217418194, -0.019202403724193573, -0.025736819952726364, 0.004549506586045027, -0.012225110083818436, -0.0602090060710907, 0.05358994007110596, 0.03553537651896477, -0.032245222479104996, 0.03859276324510574, -0.012975246645510197, -0.00130635651294142, -0.03617563098669052, -0.08524645864963531, 0.006485541816800833, 0.038903556764125824, 0.037398748099803925, 0.0011989559279754758, 0.0029807547107338905, 0.04770471900701523, 0.0747133418917656, 0.026080653071403503, 0.01968701370060444, 0.04688175395131111, -0.00008399801299674436, -0.01838374324142933, 0.008986560627818108, -0.0036275573074817657, -0.013644286431372166, 0.013451939448714256, 0.020460521802306175, -0.003565838560461998, 0.03660508245229721, -0.019997889176011086, -0.052548959851264954, -0.0376138798892498, 0.03568316996097565, -0.028512533754110336, 0.029564853757619858, -0.06786448508501053, 0.007958058267831802, 0.019313443452119827, 0.018679911270737648, 0.0408722348511219, -0.00036439343239180744, -0.019741224125027657, 0.0419345498085022, 0.032392509281635284, -0.003603906836360693, 0.016853652894496918, 0.0012868271442130208, 0.06780071556568146, 0.01695393957197666, -0.0322803258895874, 0.07173614203929901, -0.009573993273079395, -0.016965368762612343, 0.04356788843870163, 0.01535497885197401, 0.07471297681331635, 0.02456185221672058, 0.01199139654636383, -0.03828916326165199, -0.013924582861363888, -0.030364787206053734, -0.008275938220322132, 0.0006637166370637715, -0.031232187524437904, -0.0027649621479213238, -0.0767621248960495, -0.008669139817357063, -0.007494586985558271, -0.0035571837797760963, -0.049696024507284164, -0.004492793697863817, -0.030403006821870804, -0.044091127812862396, -0.04147936776280403, 0.0016361933667212725, 0.012199093587696552, 0.008584482595324516, 0.05538182705640793, 0.018256762996315956, -0.07388019561767578, 0.03897570073604584, 0.04598187655210495, 0.01720282807946205, 0.010310678742825985, -0.025986751541495323, 0.019608113914728165, 0.03381955623626709, 0.016374699771404266, -0.09005839377641678, 0.030910644680261612, -0.021518046036362648, -0.007278614677488804, 0.04070447385311127, 0.002707101870328188, -0.06499635428190231, 0.02679743431508541, 0.03565250709652901, 0.03508824482560158, 0.01136829424649477, -0.05563952028751373, 0.011297882534563541, 0.026737652719020844, -0.06801166385412216, 0.015418601222336292, -0.04368137940764427, 0.03584473207592964, -0.07231543213129044, 0.06084395572543144, 0.07760761678218842, -0.005824272055178881, 0.0009606123203411698, 0.03279494494199753, 0.03151712194085121, 0.037462152540683746, 0.019468847662210464, 0.0648798868060112, -0.04924008622765541, 0.00267099030315876, 0.039294369518756866, -0.03246644511818886, -0.06269792467355728, -0.0516992025077343, -0.034599434584379196, -0.025371070951223373, 0.028390688821673393, 0.027552958577871323, 0.023924363777041435, 0.03306103125214577, 0.054587848484516144, 0.009547192603349686, -0.03204524517059326, 0.025800639763474464, -0.011509738862514496, -0.05790961906313896, 0.028210794553160667, 0.01313900575041771, -0.015171481296420097, -0.002353091724216938, -0.008285836316645145, -0.022102216258645058, 0.023097924888134003, 0.01659628562629223, 0.03373449295759201, -0.01139640063047409, 0.03237110748887062, 0.007816779427230358, 0.010765714570879936, 0.03464432433247566, -0.012644977308809757, -0.02481609582901001, 0.07306795567274094, -0.06915678828954697, 0.008565949276089668, 0.023516885936260223, -0.018089262768626213, -0.021371876820921898, -0.03451697155833244, 0.029132654890418053, -0.004509350284934044, 0.01831136643886566, 0.045840125530958176, -0.07683691382408142, 0.02480153553187847, 0.06714944541454315, -0.030083240941166878, -0.004878678359091282, -0.009094618260860443, -0.028554189950227737, -0.053311023861169815, 0.03994879126548767, -0.03512396290898323, -0.0040375771932303905, -0.014624729752540588, 0.035074856132268906, 0.045302554965019226, -0.007203470449894667, 0.0244727972894907, 0.04295051470398903, -0.06936994194984436, 0.04787404090166092, -0.06318441033363342, 0.02524801902472973, -0.002432636683806777, -0.013260425999760628, -0.02442735619843006, -0.003218165598809719, 0.00045389149454422295, -0.07089221477508545, 0.03818704932928085, 0.00006873481470393017, -0.028220804408192635, -0.07651710510253906, 0.03941982984542847, -0.025324756279587746, 0.015677519142627716, -0.03208334371447563, -0.05509167164564133, 0.04686053469777107, -0.005836746655404568, -0.039151810109615326, -0.009866489097476006, -0.03067934140563011, -0.019512396305799484, 0.037197984755039215, -0.04593167454004288, 0.01908150315284729, 0.04670276120305061, 0.09683161228895187, 0.0630062147974968, 0.018657764419913292, -0.027642972767353058, -0.031526610255241394, -0.03485781326889992, -0.029853802174329758, -0.007296102587133646, 0.036162350326776505, -0.009670943953096867, -0.023136798292398453, 0.009241720661520958, -0.013661971315741539, -0.01941952481865883, -0.014359734952449799, -0.03694521263241768, -0.03578412905335426, -0.004251102916896343, -0.05034494400024414, -0.04442349076271057, 0.01211610622704029, 0.042938340455293655, -0.0022815705742686987, 0.04173468053340912, 0.04332166165113449, 0.057776063680648804, -0.025874387472867966, -0.02042154036462307, 0.0010743517195805907, -0.04410185292363167, -0.005216577555984259, 0.028790147975087166, 0.041541095823049545, 0.047340404242277145, 0.017736991867423058, 0.0012595226289704442, -0.03860096260905266, 0.007208571769297123, -0.05840355157852173, 0.015254233963787556, -0.009520841762423515, -0.004824650473892689, -0.06800609081983566, -0.013034222647547722, -0.04484829679131508, 0.039493512362241745, 0.017556050792336464, 0.02701457217335701, 0.036800991743803024, -0.02950126864016056, -0.06097693368792534, 0.007279558107256889, -0.012786255218088627, 0.051233403384685516, 0.02813858352601528, -0.016698436811566353, 0.022922256961464882, 0.0005741300992667675, -0.03173932805657387, 0.05393010750412941, -0.062236376106739044, -0.03061549924314022, 0.04403441399335861, 0.07082970440387726, -0.002677557058632374, 0.02580169029533863, 0.0019592733588069677, 0.008170115761458874, 0.04116858169436455, 0.005437682848423719, 0.0002745081437751651, -0.009265205822885036, -0.027085518464446068, -0.006000780966132879, 0.025174928829073906, -0.03593116253614426, -0.01036817952990532, 0.013886600732803345, -0.029318494722247124, -0.0004661210114136338, -0.016400501132011414, -0.07348497956991196, -0.03249289467930794, 0.06503113359212875, -0.05943305417895317, 0.0072736055590212345, -0.024919725954532623, -0.013092071749269962, 0.0017784459050744772, 0.01816508360207081, -0.018290534615516663, 0.01727832295000553, 0.03420187905430794, -0.04304561764001846, -0.06005493551492691, -0.021906936541199684, -0.009340153075754642, 0.03886735439300537, -0.040911342948675156, -0.03265431523323059, 0.0227653831243515, 0.017449790611863136, 0.03794766217470169, -0.039677638560533524, 0.04993884265422821, 0.04470842331647873, -0.03023909591138363, -0.07058350741863251, 0.009277633391320705, 0.04043321684002876, -0.06030122563242912, 0.027353547513484955, 0.02243546023964882, 0.01685274951159954, -0.03296567127108574, 0.007639948278665543, 0.009301862679421902, -0.08462953567504883, -0.02638552524149418, -0.014872705563902855, 0.007895712740719318, -0.020238950848579407, -0.006606357172131538, -0.02587917633354664, 0.03785247728228569, 0.025787288323044777, 0.007897848263382912, -0.037199344485998154, 0.06821217387914658, 0.06795492768287659, 0.010210936889052391, -0.040378279983997345, -0.03530452772974968, 0.008458498865365982, 0.03601793572306633, -0.049294039607048035, -0.02062179706990719, -0.03740692138671875, 0.014721720479428768, 0.043654173612594604, -0.0005278730532154441, -0.04467848315834999, 0.030190957710146904, 0.017020951956510544, -0.03833957388997078, 0.09081536531448364, 0.00988854467868805, 0.02397160232067108, 0.0075696296989917755, 0.049079664051532745, 0.0385742112994194, -0.024676915258169174, -0.041874077171087265, 0.027075545862317085, 0.047385044395923615, -0.038946300745010376, 0.004942579660564661, 0.03270217776298523, 0.0037650526501238346, -0.0007716245600022376, -0.014072073623538017, 0.050392694771289825, -0.017505155876278877, 0.05770193040370941, 0.010089791379868984, -0.02041749097406864, -0.0009440006106160581, -0.030264077708125114, -0.046893518418073654, 0.019625995308160782, 0.012707574293017387, 0.03490180894732475, -0.0724388137459755, 0.055227696895599365, 0.07138843834400177, 0.010820629075169563, -0.008158356882631779, -0.049224916845560074, 0.00076944415923208, 0.011931413784623146, -0.04045260325074196, 0.03622898831963539, -0.017162665724754333, -0.019548531621694565, -0.0384979173541069, -0.005391419865190983, 0.01857958920300007, 0.03126165643334389, -0.014168873429298401, -0.0032363003119826317, 0.050967879593372345, 0.030598009005188942, 0.03218892216682434, -0.02757459133863449, 0.012526310048997402, -0.05107983201742172, -0.013955515809357166, -0.015140997245907784, -0.030045976862311363, -0.038423921912908554, 0.02637619525194168, 0.03466414660215378, 0.005510968156158924, 0.00868183746933937, -0.02182125113904476, -0.07024779170751572, 0.08485206216573715, -0.08554282784461975, -0.05262111499905586, -0.02880909852683544, -0.009067950770258904, -0.027690179646015167, -0.08903920650482178, 0.005126533098518848, 0.026630889624357224, -0.03576822206377983, 0.005887036677449942, 0.0020873532630503178, -0.03728581219911575, -0.024108147248625755, -0.005225218832492828, -0.059241585433483124, -0.022844670340418816, -0.008173679001629353, -0.055510226637125015, -0.01518735196441412, -0.003167692106217146, -0.015356164425611496, 0.06568866968154907, -0.03874710574746132, 0.008230786770582199, 0.05955503135919571, -0.0458965040743351, 0.04686996713280678, 0.05099765211343765, -0.007959675043821335, -0.0036623855121433735, -0.06553569436073303, 0.02607635222375393, 0.00007989424193510786, -0.053767092525959015, 0.0003660178917925805, -0.04606947302818298, -0.06883515417575836, 0.02225513942539692, 0.04937424138188362, -0.028511419892311096, 0.03016139566898346, -0.037859272211790085, 0.008943838067352772, 0.03376748785376549, 0.03718980774283409, 0.037661198526620865, -0.013899226672947407, 0.02842412330210209, 0.006174132227897644, 0.0030597669538110495, -0.0012086620554327965, -0.005657667759805918, -0.01212747860699892, 0.015763109549880028, -0.018542684614658356, 0.04062047600746155, -0.05408111587166786, 0.031836967915296555, -0.02017241157591343, 0.10665121674537659, -0.05117685720324516, 0.0052409241907298565, 0.00662092724815011, 0.002241758396849036, 0.028186829760670662, -0.04297034814953804, -0.028832929208874702, -0.10002408176660538, 0.05917055904865265, 0.01503501832485199, -0.016640936955809593, 0.02000417187809944, 0.0015763705596327782, -0.09075811505317688, -0.004420220386236906, -0.04882190749049187, 0.004291468299925327, -0.03900286182761192, 0.0024827688466757536, -0.012257362715899944, -0.04755309224128723, 0.004331232979893684, 0.034012455493211746, -0.028533916920423508, -0.026907719671726227, -0.0007287419866770506, -0.0026486562564969063, 0.04860357567667961, -0.023272311314940453, 0.0887177437543869, 0.030626429244875908, 0.008195318281650543, -0.023343877866864204, -0.025383155792951584, 0.014067540876567364, 0.05138996243476868, -0.03224853426218033, -0.008964556269347668, -0.00677506485953927, -0.02829047664999962, 0.021663689985871315, 0.0668998509645462, -0.02110372856259346, -0.002333615440875292, 0.050648149102926254, -0.03190590813755989, 0.05940195918083191, -0.007803209125995636, 0.008607805706560612, 0.03304809704422951, -0.033228617161512375, 0.00009666932601248845, 0.05025516077876091, 0.009908151812851429, 0.05101910978555679, -0.07035883516073227, 0.05345974490046501, -0.04761771112680435, -0.004502562806010246, 0.056909799575805664, -0.029764913022518158, -0.05326348543167114, 0.01124846562743187, 0.057739295065402985, 0.05722735449671745, 0.051194749772548676, 0.008257807232439518, 0.02151755802333355, 0.01471950113773346, 0.02706766501069069, -0.002056221244856715, 0.06108403205871582, -0.01787658780813217, -0.01947163976728916, 0.014496168121695518, -0.01428464986383915, 0.028643513098359108, 0.023518312722444534, 0.04357887804508209, -0.009955016896128654, -0.011551043018698692, 0.000011383627679606434, 0.029574597254395485, -0.038420114666223526, 0.0656389519572258, -0.03670351207256317, 0.04710106551647186, 0.009915321134030819, 0.010792420245707035, 0.047476477921009064, 0.010013515129685402, 0.012930565513670444, 0.009097792208194733, -0.011584097519516945, -0.012036464177072048, 0.03145228698849678, -0.02466915175318718, -0.07109931111335754, 0.05978068709373474, -0.026056386530399323, 0.01998641900718212, -0.024510741233825684, -0.027802905067801476, 0.004949770402163267, -0.00636832881718874, -0.034758806228637695, 0.042248375713825226, -0.015544723719358444, 0.02037828601896763, 0.0015484443865716457, -0.024115558713674545, -0.015173141844570637, -0.03462310880422592, 0.0028625859413295984, -0.0642610415816307, 0.017820129171013832, 0.024639591574668884, -0.03246566280722618, -0.0014663072070106864, 0.009339445270597935, -0.03289300948381424, 0.030525993555784225, 0.022020971402525902, -0.04612041637301445, 0.046729788184165955, -0.049937888979911804, -0.022526053711771965, 0.01716461032629013, -0.03237698972225189, -0.010100427083671093, 0.030914397910237312, -0.0032225886825472116, -0.0329015851020813, -0.00879334844648838, -0.015354540199041367, -0.014681617729365826, 0.004215520806610584, -0.01337924413383007, -0.024381421506404877, -0.033052463084459305, 0.029517075046896935, -0.04023740813136101, 0.055581044405698776, 0.025338079780340195, -0.018747592344880104, -0.04843948036432266, -0.028809675946831703, 0.01156720519065857, 0.021893249824643135, -0.01095001120120287, -0.024268535897135735, 0.009047005325555801, 0.07031190395355225, 0.020783446729183197, -0.1117074117064476, 0.027080968022346497, -0.013235296122729778, -0.021111924201250076, 0.015621035359799862, -0.011172054335474968, 0.024764252826571465, 0.004236253909766674, 0.045712798833847046, 0.02282216213643551, -0.07162025570869446, 0.020072387531399727, -0.0013096199836581945, -0.0006965153734199703, 0.03146424889564514, -0.09228130429983139, -0.020395806059241295, 0.005389773286879063, 0.01359483227133751, 0.06406808644533157, 0.0067030698992311954, -0.020475802943110466, 0.035854652523994446, 0.007284868974238634, 0.033055249601602554, -0.08409421145915985, 0.022390570491552353, -0.036153897643089294, 0.04240412637591362, 0.06263981759548187, -0.03469007462263107, -0.04513048753142357, -0.02488350309431553, 0.032781489193439484, 0.012032411061227322, 0.023093393072485924, -0.0631771981716156, 0.007185475435107946, 0.05433174595236778, 0.0008959432598203421, -0.07359445840120316, -0.015620901249349117, 0.01341917272657156, -0.03380761295557022, -0.05089842155575752, 0.033546872437000275, 0.04129559174180031, 0.020190846174955368, -0.045003440231084824, -0.01932196132838726, 0.005878139287233353, 0.005250817630439997, 0.03548956289887428, -0.02388767898082733, 0.014411721378564835, -0.017100298777222633, -0.07071889191865921, 0.0472320020198822, 0.040580444037914276, -0.016744282096624374, 0.0312529131770134, 0.02538982406258583, -0.008785427547991276, -0.05508192628622055, -0.03819921612739563, 0.03682618960738182, -0.04104043170809746, 0.02463660016655922, 0.020449494943022728, 0.019555652514100075, -0.007615240756422281, -0.02101646549999714, 0.015954598784446716, -0.008627130649983883, -0.003326136153191328 ]
<p>I am trying to prove the following equivalent form for long-range-order in superconductivity (Annett's book states something like this) : </p> <p>\begin{equation}\lim_{|R-R'|\to \infty}&lt;\psi^{\dagger}(R')\psi(R)&gt; = &lt;\psi^{\dagger}(R)\psi(R)&gt; \end{equation}</p> <p>where the brackets are evaluated on the BCS ground state : $|\psi_{BCS}&gt;= ∏_{k}(u_k^{*}+v_k^* P_k^{\dagger})|0&gt; $ ($|0&gt; $ being the zero-temperature Fermi sea), $P_k^{\dagger}=c_{k\uparrow}^{\dagger}c_{-k\downarrow}^{\dagger}$ when : </p> <p>$\psi^{\dagger}(R) = \int d^3r~\psi(r) \phi_{\uparrow}^{\dagger} (R+r/2)\phi_{\downarrow}^{\dagger}(R-r/2)$</p> <p>($\psi(r)$ being some wavefunction) and : </p> <p>$\phi_{\sigma}(r) = \sum_{k}e^{ikr} c_{k\sigma}$ ($c$ being the commun fermion annihilator, and the $P$s commuting like bosons for this particular state).(Sorry for the lengthy definitions)</p> <p>The gap function being defined as : $\Delta \propto \sum_k &lt;P_k&gt;$, we can see relatively easily that the right side of the first equation will be proportional to $|\Delta|^2$. But what I've found quite puzzling is what to do with the unhomogeneous terms (especially in the left term) where the $c$ and $c^{\dagger}$ do not form a pairing operator and the Fermi sea not being ideal to deal with them...</p> <p>Could somebody help me on this calculation ? Or am I taking the problem on the wrong side ?</p>
g4270
[ -0.0010365411872044206, 0.0011709806276485324, -0.006419321987777948, -0.04489811882376671, 0.05376986041665077, -0.020866094157099724, -0.02066950686275959, -0.010199976153671741, 0.009376036934554577, -0.0001419490436092019, -0.05675889179110527, 0.05175521597266197, -0.038507793098688126, 0.007608796935528517, 0.010513996705412865, 0.025589533150196075, 0.005583329126238823, 0.006435619667172432, -0.0005672464612871408, -0.05399791896343231, -0.03730512782931328, 0.021291427314281464, -0.0036676444578915834, -0.013954298570752144, 0.0048482995480299, -0.07067973911762238, 0.027120308950543404, -0.030240265652537346, -0.044701993465423584, 0.02109496481716633, 0.040724609047174454, 0.025969982147216797, 0.0357162281870842, 0.00748318200930953, -0.026362283155322075, 0.0027903623413294554, 0.05174795538187027, 0.035131439566612244, 0.02722073718905449, 0.00797113124281168, 0.009169839322566986, 0.02044445276260376, 0.024630215018987656, -0.04330023005604744, 0.025657042860984802, -0.012826432473957539, -0.04380589351058006, -0.007067331112921238, -0.04115649312734604, -0.03707524761557579, 0.009333275258541107, 0.021261148154735565, 0.0883110985159874, -0.026324713602662086, -0.039541441947221756, 0.021094145253300667, -0.02015729621052742, -0.024877041578292847, 0.005602150224149227, 0.010725943371653557, 0.029542991891503334, -0.05220254510641098, 0.02400023490190506, -0.03706442192196846, 0.0684434026479721, -0.01887246035039425, -0.00004998703661840409, 0.035101767629384995, -0.044044237583875656, -0.02020260877907276, -0.042467422783374786, -0.05201556906104088, 0.00041538444929756224, -0.005652670748531818, -0.08153782784938812, 0.02701062522828579, -0.04251575842499733, -0.027382710948586464, 0.052556511014699936, -0.001992381177842617, -0.05369065701961517, 0.011788785457611084, 0.010151656344532967, -0.012016905471682549, -0.03069641813635826, -0.043804269284009933, 0.037756044417619705, 0.005754172336310148, -0.01374547928571701, 0.049434758722782135, -0.02555100992321968, -0.030305825173854828, -0.0016706567257642746, -0.015256223268806934, 0.02161334455013275, 0.016815410926938057, 0.029155224561691284, 0.05653899163007736, 0.016010716557502747, -0.05837398022413254, -0.033030349761247635, 0.03723057731986046, 0.01436490286141634, 0.0441649854183197, -0.07343242317438126, 0.026516100391745567, 0.0476025752723217, 0.00618760846555233, -0.01762806996703148, 0.0070388964377343655, -0.05538221821188927, 0.024230511859059334, -0.016522180289030075, 0.009787697345018387, 0.024183133617043495, 0.02044438198208809, -0.023869819939136505, -0.009678555652499199, -0.03993172571063042, 0.038899049162864685, 0.043440986424684525, 0.03823716565966606, 0.008054565638303757, 0.06879474222660065, -0.023958314210176468, -0.03166807070374489, -0.049289900809526443, 0.08482903987169266, 0.04211759567260742, 0.0223708376288414, 0.027666596695780754, -0.010076184757053852, 0.013973266817629337, 0.05897321179509163, 0.017856474965810776, 0.02918817847967148, -0.007263644598424435, -0.009073774330317974, 0.001934877596795559, -0.03675299510359764, -0.08026720583438873, -0.04360326752066612, 0.01256486400961876, 0.0013853567652404308, -0.019051190465688705, -0.02682788297533989, -0.05630561709403992, -0.0585617870092392, -0.03552856668829918, 0.019938357174396515, -0.0011074392823502421, 0.017317529767751694, -0.03504856303334236, -0.0011307522654533386, -0.027310626581311226, 0.014008955098688602, 0.041857484728097916, -0.05200917273759842, 0.015509933233261108, -0.021360930055379868, -0.041544318199157715, 0.03695102408528328, 0.0067081693559885025, -0.030047481879591942, -0.024310221895575523, 0.027110803872346878, 0.0871795266866684, -0.026678165420889854, -0.03888177499175072, -0.022862881422042847, -0.06188308447599411, 0.028809739276766777, 0.014627217315137386, 0.017934322357177734, 0.016804398968815804, 0.041683875024318695, 0.004763585980981588, -0.022017281502485275, 0.014059249311685562, 0.011774669401347637, 0.007615214679390192, 0.005107571370899677, 0.016141213476657867, -0.00280378432944417, -0.0021746642887592316, 0.04298156872391701, 0.02952837385237217, 0.037146396934986115, -0.018235158175230026, 0.03214358165860176, -0.026336340233683586, 0.023701315745711327, -0.03406313806772232, 0.004060946870595217, -0.012428948655724525, 0.01775335520505905, -0.014379177242517471, -0.03797324374318123, -0.020716823637485504, -0.009557027369737625, -0.018103783950209618, 0.05142907425761223, 0.00921222846955061, -0.014810902066528797, -0.016199510544538498, -0.029782608151435852, -0.014553512446582317, 0.008224750868976116, 0.06426239758729935, -0.011722909286618233, 0.005490376614034176, -0.09276798367500305, -0.016733283177018166, 0.005322484765201807, -0.060472458600997925, -0.07912393659353256, 0.0070211803540587425, 0.0028567484114319086, -0.05497455969452858, 0.028038552030920982, 0.01794452778995037, -0.08230756223201752, 0.03249844163656235, 0.004530864302068949, -0.030547022819519043, 0.05540144443511963, -0.015538526698946953, -0.006698880810290575, 0.032459355890750885, 0.011864621192216873, -0.05919448658823967, 0.044536929577589035, -0.011379634961485863, -0.05011075735092163, -0.03169407695531845, 0.05194362252950668, 0.06514965742826462, 0.06041081249713898, 0.030717158690094948, 0.025816701352596283, -0.030735213309526443, -0.03031814843416214, -0.030096959322690964, 0.0825766921043396, 0.04541965574026108, 0.0168906282633543, 0.03771254047751427, 0.04542256519198418, -0.045271020382642746, 0.007594933733344078, -0.02595878206193447, -0.01634795591235161, -0.012137015350162983, 0.02472236379981041, 0.03196798637509346, -0.04697583243250847, -0.01988542638719082, -0.0005765910027548671, 0.0013884223299100995, -0.026734286919236183, -0.03339534252882004, -0.06743600964546204, -0.014580934308469296, 0.02021566964685917, -0.06552751362323761, 0.013366522267460823, -0.02191443182528019, -0.0411960631608963, 0.0317007377743721, 0.013659514486789703, 0.004129889886826277, 0.06262525171041489, 0.050060320645570755, 0.052831169217824936, -0.022355256602168083, -0.0667617917060852, -0.03511988744139671, 0.008576811291277409, 0.03534608334302902, 0.01686934567987919, 0.015898512676358223, -0.020940938964486122, 0.03952314704656601, 0.016810916364192963, -0.010571769438683987, -0.07104168832302094, 0.011404944583773613, 0.039650361984968185, 0.023741474375128746, 0.014725400134921074, 0.011211404576897621, -0.051078084856271744, 0.0207122340798378, 0.04308044910430908, -0.031213197857141495, -0.04674057289958, 0.04404198005795479, -0.027097128331661224, 0.01500545721501112, 0.040438126772642136, 0.027451928704977036, -0.014593315310776234, 0.030716340988874435, -0.018352344632148743, 0.03406478464603424, -0.023610038682818413, -0.01386706531047821, -0.03174542635679245, -0.009815152734518051, 0.0074065933004021645, 0.01806357130408287, 0.07023517042398453, -0.043619077652692795, -0.0941108763217926, 0.04137400537729263, -0.020255951210856438, 0.019093526527285576, 0.01222549844533205, 0.04651327803730965, -0.04792356118559837, -0.024096794426441193, -0.042867451906204224, 0.03304067626595497, -0.023149065673351288, 0.0008344844100065529, 0.011274565011262894, -0.051286254078149796, -0.007698008790612221, -0.06573732197284698, 0.04114999622106552, 0.0711720734834671, 0.014341604895889759, 0.08289872109889984, -0.030351389199495316, -0.10015767812728882, -0.04493037611246109, 0.019175395369529724, 0.04741045460104942, 0.013333613984286785, 0.050270721316337585, 0.028872502967715263, -0.0629311054944992, -0.03518941253423691, 0.06461302191019058, 0.028341589495539665, 0.02498794160783291, -0.010998696088790894, 0.07172097265720367, 0.012499739415943623, -0.00020781323837582022, -0.06140584871172905, -0.027802880853414536, 0.040822308510541916, 0.02198856696486473, -0.04674403369426727, 0.048320475965738297, 0.035934872925281525, 0.00006926965579623356, 0.04959592595696449, 0.022853180766105652, 0.050132155418395996, -0.0032784852664917707, 0.013597049750387669, -0.005569040309637785, -0.05321595072746277, -0.027565810829401016, 0.005431093275547028, 0.00528291892260313, 0.0008646093774586916, -0.034672386944293976, -0.02381020411849022, -0.035185836255550385, 0.031164122745394707, -0.026423471048474312, 0.02786923758685589, -0.04781278967857361, -0.017659582197666168, 0.023387307301163673, -0.02785259485244751, 0.04258550703525543, -0.006405595224350691, 0.021817611530423164, 0.04542606696486473, -0.03551170229911804, -0.00397083954885602, 0.03720907121896744, 0.034911081194877625, 0.003289616433903575, -0.03373017907142639, 0.02696373499929905, 0.029671048745512962, -0.015490509569644928, -0.026958776637911797, 0.06206687539815903, 0.012694044969975948, 0.012011898681521416, -0.0034837741404771805, -0.002097352873533964, -0.04516579583287239, -0.0023063570261001587, -0.046145014464855194, -0.04214156046509743, 0.018216010183095932, -0.04524604231119156, -0.044063959270715714, -0.048856545239686966, 0.03220062702894211, -0.013715749606490135, -0.0018907403573393822, -0.030900029465556145, 0.013504326343536377, 0.005644585471600294, 0.0009294712799601257, -0.05784580856561661, 0.011663949117064476, -0.06907571852207184, 0.0524645559489727, -0.04875394329428673, -0.0017776712775230408, 0.007216210477054119, 0.0060292924754321575, 0.02200954221189022, 0.010677855461835861, -0.015673454850912094, 0.01528580766171217, 0.06467946618795395, 0.0008652115939185023, 0.009597127325832844, 0.018571238964796066, 0.034134507179260254, 0.00434751994907856, 0.04180344194173813, -0.0033519838470965624, 0.07084741443395615, -0.03440498188138008, -0.03400138020515442, -0.05384817719459534, -0.022522319108247757, -0.010520231910049915, 0.1215672716498375, -0.060623347759246826, 0.024165306240320206, 0.019818847998976707, -0.01604064740240574, 0.014588939025998116, -0.006815215572714806, -0.052724700421094894, -0.046881403774023056, -0.0006475264672189951, -0.010606424883008003, 0.02126394957304001, 0.04324239864945412, -0.028235645964741707, -0.0025904506910592318, -0.0412115678191185, -0.03145818039774895, 0.01749347895383835, -0.046242643147706985, -0.00029681617161259055, -0.02657894790172577, -0.015931161120533943, 0.01148509792983532, -0.029896624386310577, -0.014312958344817162, 0.056900784373283386, 0.03956291824579239, 0.02391381934285164, -0.030672380700707436, -0.052323050796985626, 0.009475388564169407, 0.04801008477807045, 0.03030500002205372, 0.03685623034834862, -0.052530501037836075, 0.00325966184027493, 0.03714629262685776, -0.021704016253352165, 0.023698166012763977, -0.009385574609041214, 0.025106558576226234, -0.031441427767276764, -0.06551095843315125, -0.0005445957067422569, 0.0037360889837145805, -0.01203103456646204, -0.018270302563905716, -0.038972824811935425, -0.012980340979993343, 0.004257820080965757, -0.0458744540810585, 0.00264480197802186, 0.002540730405598879, 0.051146600395441055, -0.013389154337346554, 0.03404863923788071, -0.006011637393385172, 0.02740912139415741, 0.040851593017578125, -0.009414400905370712, 0.038807425647974014, -0.053288888186216354, -0.009240812622010708, -0.0021852082572877407, 0.0107903853058815, 0.01127819437533617, 0.08517616242170334, 0.09994520992040634, 0.0361645445227623, 0.04235107824206352, 0.0044445558451116085, -0.01137626264244318, 0.0197740588337183, 0.050356991589069366, -0.009229801595211029, -0.0216958187520504, 0.014850035309791565, -0.003605034900829196, 0.016259102150797844, -0.04930180311203003, -0.008661514148116112, 0.06305862963199615, 0.014759637415409088, 0.0073763118125498295, 0.00394122488796711, 0.010110408999025822, 0.04339107498526573, -0.0075006685219705105, -0.06009988486766815, 0.011745907366275787, -0.014693054370582104, -0.017937375232577324, 0.011466738767921925, -0.04595618695020676, -0.07591553032398224, 0.037727415561676025, -0.03949218988418579, -0.03838584944605827, 0.07103770971298218, -0.03982832655310631, -0.03586394712328911, 0.02497660182416439, -0.01900383271276951, -0.0201532244682312, 0.016234857961535454, -0.04182140529155731, -0.023777898401021957, -0.016939237713813782, -0.02430633455514908, -0.03062189742922783, -0.0019025699002668262, -0.05697687715291977, 0.0036758685018867254, -0.032143913209438324, -0.004319396335631609, 0.07004022598266602, -0.041000716388225555, 0.04166519269347191, -0.03311564028263092, -0.027172278612852097, 0.0026163654401898384, 0.042302291840314865, 0.029702411964535713, -0.010352556593716145, 0.032996129244565964, 0.04015976935625076, -0.025252381339669228, -0.051017407327890396, 0.01791203022003174, 0.031385231763124466, -0.0072649396024644375, -0.012489468790590763, -0.011872409842908382, -0.020496418699622154, -0.004689659923315048, 0.020120954141020775, 0.03140449523925781, -0.019080625846982002, -0.034050896763801575, 0.0407218374311924, 0.03612609580159187, -0.04739368334412575, 0.05699493736028671, 0.0028089992702007294, 0.03699493408203125, -0.036795757710933685, 0.10533896088600159, -0.024118294939398766, -0.05272083729505539, 0.04272424429655075, 0.03611655905842781, -0.05343066155910492, -0.007189689204096794, 0.0335746631026268, 0.026815537363290787, 0.018455691635608673, 0.0827581062912941, 0.011763295158743858, 0.0375390499830246, -0.05287495255470276, 0.008474436588585377, 0.03826480358839035, 0.0239810012280941, 0.024013884365558624, 0.032040368765592575, 0.014619055204093456, 0.03414506837725639, -0.017594793811440468, 0.010761138051748276, -0.04610881209373474, 0.04132914915680885, 0.03198106959462166, -0.015614718198776245, -0.02955370768904686, -0.017318977043032646, -0.02299477718770504, 0.019635353237390518, -0.015499914065003395, 0.04448831081390381, -0.06977880746126175, 0.049909964203834534, 0.03936154767870903, 0.027106517925858498, -0.05545907840132713, -0.008009583689272404, 0.026454990729689598, 0.06911686062812805, 0.011477898806333542, 0.014937985688447952, 0.026097852736711502, 0.001413431135006249, -0.02054925635457039, -0.018495844677090645, 0.012282752431929111, -0.013245681300759315, -0.009836890734732151, 0.034602969884872437, -0.030412808060646057, 0.029831718653440475, -0.05552220717072487, 0.0705188661813736, -0.06746113300323486, -0.01788545586168766, 0.040816958993673325, -0.06301958113908768, -0.07391967624425888, 0.02413330040872097, 0.0417669340968132, 0.012238573282957077, -0.0729546919465065, 0.019729482010006905, 0.04482688009738922, -0.017591385170817375, -0.014995049685239792, 0.006405510473996401, -0.018271753564476967, -0.0498802550137043, -0.01221721526235342, -0.00592876598238945, 0.02037716470658779, -0.007368116639554501, -0.0024896515533328056, -0.03199945390224457, 0.0019399693701416254, 0.0006121606566011906, 0.02931491658091545, 0.04849506542086601, -0.001904806587845087, -0.021071719005703926, 0.06489754468202591, -0.07263590395450592, -0.035463012754917145, -0.03527606651186943, -0.06815668195486069, -0.07972501963376999, -0.006721800193190575, 0.024786366149783134, 0.012570161372423172, 0.03285590931773186, -0.039484087377786636, -0.020447207614779472, 0.01503988727927208, -0.03246062248945236, -0.00407309690490365, -0.035004232078790665, -0.00967428833246231, 0.0656348243355751, -0.001749761519022286, -0.02334742248058319, 0.023255886510014534, 0.010570736601948738, 0.010534758679568768, 0.010049087926745415, 0.01012494694441557, -0.006824927870184183, 0.06130661442875862, 0.0013536164769902825, -0.035158783197402954, 0.0346997044980526, 0.046734172850847244, 0.031354665756225586, 0.07134959846735, 0.010532896965742111, -0.03721065819263458, -0.014798037707805634, 0.08887184411287308, 0.04412401095032692, -0.014385731890797615, 0.0038275904953479767, -0.022821899503469467, -0.0015957646537572145, 0.02811332792043686, 0.006718682590872049, 0.019200894981622696, -0.0011991482460871339, 0.054186493158340454, -0.001891490537673235, -0.028535503894090652, 0.025793639943003654, -0.01776331104338169, -0.048951853066682816, -0.007898028939962387, 0.03336590901017189, 0.06257359683513641, -0.023950302973389626, -0.004817062523216009, -0.022575512528419495, -0.06497456133365631, 0.044882550835609436, -0.015897275879979134, 0.008492982015013695, -0.034802015870809555, -0.05588435381650925, -0.09035147726535797, 0.06882447004318237, -0.018039658665657043, -0.011300632730126381, 0.01421368308365345, 0.028023196384310722, 0.06009286642074585, 0.008376496843993664, -0.0344633124768734, -0.05443551018834114, 0.010863047093153, -0.02467670664191246, 0.025837719440460205, 0.0012264088727533817, 0.0053546736016869545, -0.05839431658387184, 0.0076111191883683205, -0.03138384595513344, 0.005349092651158571, 0.03525042161345482, -0.04517476260662079, 0.0685366839170456, 0.07687593996524811, -0.038274720311164856, 0.06727799028158188, 0.0035790340043604374, 0.0672970786690712, 0.021444447338581085, -0.06174882873892784, -0.07849643379449844, -0.002738703740760684, 0.01437017135322094, 0.02327125146985054, -0.04985693469643593, -0.04139578342437744, 0.011225513182580471 ]
<p>I am trying to solve this problem:</p> <blockquote> <p><em>Consider a rocket moving relative to an inertial frame $\mathcal{F}$ , such that its worldline is given by $$x^{\mu}=c^2/g(\sinh(g\tau/c),\cosh(g\tau/c)-1,0,0).$$ What are the components of four acceleration relative to the instantaneous rest frame of the rocket, $\mathcal{F}'$?</em></p> </blockquote> <p>I (think I) understand how to do this using Lorentz transformation: $dt/d\tau=(1/c) \cdot dx^0/d\tau=\cosh(g\tau/c)$. This is equal to $\gamma$ and it is then straightforward to compute 3-velocity and then use the Lorentz matrix to get $$dx'^\mu(\tau)/d\tau=(c,0,0,0) \quad ; \quad d^2 x'^\mu(\tau)/d\tau^2=(0,g,0,0)$$ However, when I first saw this I immediately thought that by definition the 4-velocity in the instantaneous rest frame of the rocket would be (c,0,0,0) because in $\mathcal{F}'$ the 3-velocity is zero and $\gamma$ would be 1 and I was wondering if this is a valid reasoning. Even if it is, <strong>why is the following wrong</strong>?</p> <p>If $v'^\mu=dx'^\mu(\tau)/d\tau=(c,0,0,0)$, then $a'^\mu=dv'^\mu/d\tau=(0,0,0,0)$ since $c$ is a constant. But this contradicts the calculations given by the Lorentz transformation and I don't understand why and given this I have no idea of <strong>how to interpret 4-acceleration</strong>.</p>
g4271
[ 0.03223738446831703, -0.0046553099527955055, 0.008454895578324795, -0.006489370483905077, 0.03708156943321228, -0.014612420462071896, 0.02144516073167324, 0.0205086637288332, -0.08385186642408371, -0.0023992250207811594, -0.017111362889409065, 0.027157146483659744, -0.01081124134361744, -0.009929646737873554, 0.05163063853979111, -0.02316151186823845, 0.10716494172811508, 0.014356482774019241, -0.0023551490157842636, -0.00526995025575161, -0.0039395177736878395, 0.01714000105857849, -0.015991199761629105, -0.05624224245548248, 0.06670235842466354, -0.016317425295710564, 0.022459592670202255, -0.0692589208483696, -0.05140966549515724, 0.019994186237454414, 0.06475385278463364, -0.013235878199338913, -0.044904936105012894, -0.05360931530594826, -0.02267439104616642, -0.01852651871740818, 0.08136022090911865, 0.028060438111424446, 0.008971833623945713, -0.03175578638911247, 0.014133618213236332, -0.023854626342654228, 0.030539728701114655, 0.034608203917741776, 0.0030391004402190447, 0.010908633470535278, -0.0035967871081084013, -0.000742318865377456, -0.01516476646065712, 0.01798046939074993, -0.05525600537657738, -0.003020067000761628, 0.03629852831363678, -0.05306003615260124, -0.007647765800356865, 0.04472571611404419, 0.006456231232732534, -0.028059842064976692, 0.006656609009951353, 0.08132488280534744, 0.013215024955570698, -0.12408814579248428, 0.047368623316287994, -0.05555151030421257, 0.08292961120605469, -0.0002773466403596103, -0.024541784077882767, 0.06290558725595474, 0.010260223411023617, 0.013972705230116844, 0.02251245081424713, -0.017690761014819145, -0.020321005955338478, 0.016939355060458183, -0.06346974521875381, 0.001603645971044898, -0.01647304557263851, -0.009623952209949493, -0.019104907289147377, -0.013997954316437244, -0.00489452900364995, 0.06848277151584625, 0.02912963181734085, -0.02418985590338707, 0.010100807063281536, 0.003195983823388815, 0.05462558940052986, 0.056163474917411804, 0.019843963906168938, -0.06009697914123535, 0.030036596581339836, -0.0006511716637760401, 0.027677416801452637, 0.02721977047622204, -0.026742354035377502, -0.019887948408722878, -0.0495477020740509, 0.0928930789232254, 0.028435014188289642, -0.022786172106862068, -0.0045707570388913155, -0.004082540515810251, -0.04719371721148491, -0.01565130427479744, 0.004228156991302967, -0.018441369757056236, 0.04324648901820183, -0.0004192995256744325, -0.007469143718481064, -0.05689680948853493, -0.04605521261692047, -0.061757322400808334, 0.056796494871377945, -0.03758304938673973, -0.05754050239920616, -0.05444681644439697, 0.014673365280032158, 0.020451074466109276, -0.0008724122308194637, 0.053228046745061874, 0.02311531826853752, 0.01824187859892845, -0.02000652812421322, 0.05393531545996666, 0.022625930607318878, -0.06019505858421326, -0.039255887269973755, 0.003426759969443083, 0.002145244274288416, -0.041751500219106674, -0.029422417283058167, 0.03811648115515709, 0.03238009288907051, 0.0017322908388450742, 0.00900302641093731, 0.003948833327740431, 0.05344249680638313, -0.023000987246632576, -0.029373187571763992, 0.06276223063468933, 0.0036840508691966534, -0.038270626217126846, -0.019513068720698357, 0.003927093464881182, -0.07462240010499954, 0.032961487770080566, 0.004786848556250334, -0.005728102754801512, 0.055007778108119965, -0.0008329546544700861, -0.014145425520837307, 0.10774750262498856, -0.05505399405956268, 0.025250839069485664, 0.07397178560495377, -0.015981437638401985, 0.024839410558342934, -0.026360850781202316, 0.00098667002748698, 0.07462318241596222, 0.08787821233272552, -0.02074170671403408, -0.01602523773908615, -0.005728879943490028, -0.07403635233640671, 0.017938673496246338, 0.01944848522543907, -0.035978056490421295, -0.017172953113913536, -0.06935849040746689, -0.06346245110034943, -0.0325343944132328, 0.023567134514451027, -0.04018038511276245, -0.08289758116006851, -0.006066414061933756, 0.03412184491753578, -0.05524066835641861, -0.0224466510117054, -0.012860524468123913, -0.03226717561483383, -0.027231931686401367, 0.02189057134091854, -0.013723108917474747, -0.014563150703907013, -0.03382839635014534, -0.010722915641963482, 0.010931702330708504, -0.06182244420051575, 0.021445129066705704, 0.017415795475244522, -0.0028447259683161974, -0.0032320369500666857, 0.01749042235314846, -0.02104148641228676, -0.02926972322165966, 0.004207652062177658, -0.010150699876248837, -0.042365383356809616, 0.04262341186404228, 0.02285442315042019, 0.06815386563539505, 0.05670887231826782, 0.043334562331438065, 0.02596736140549183, -0.007944990880787373, -0.03327673301100731, -0.013682031072676182, 0.018475912511348724, 0.02315661869943142, 0.07577981799840927, 0.0037330216728150845, -0.037844203412532806, 0.035616111010313034, -0.012041495181620121, -0.024197319522500038, 0.03410961106419563, 0.0019773044623434544, -0.010441974736750126, 0.04057233780622482, -0.029357610270380974, -0.029768848791718483, 0.007111246697604656, -0.029682286083698273, -0.07872472703456879, -0.046967629343271255, -0.021498680114746094, -0.016931911930441856, 0.05452520400285721, -0.006930455565452576, -0.03797399252653122, 0.008257037028670311, -0.06318337470293045, -0.0044871061109006405, 0.06936673820018768, 0.02612118422985077, -0.014881879091262817, 0.046525489538908005, 0.005538335070014, 0.035968758165836334, 0.0656965970993042, 0.0066452836617827415, -0.024445829913020134, -0.026701906695961952, 0.08294089883565903, -0.049213144928216934, 0.04649344086647034, -0.016645554453134537, -0.04483409598469734, -0.01531494501978159, -0.00876622088253498, -0.02135813981294632, -0.005272812210023403, -0.011121761985123158, -0.022097885608673096, -0.02587815746665001, -0.023072896525263786, 0.04793582856655121, -0.03535465523600578, 0.021309321746230125, -0.02781299315392971, -0.002070082351565361, -0.010568059049546719, 0.039120081812143326, -0.0683603435754776, 0.018835823982954025, -0.005099710542708635, 0.029100488871335983, -0.05611966550350189, -0.01948479190468788, -0.06603070348501205, 0.01570870354771614, 0.031783804297447205, 0.04853661358356476, -0.02277699112892151, -0.012657719664275646, -0.010837283916771412, -0.026774752885103226, -0.05935847386717796, 0.01030683796852827, 0.002145074075087905, -0.0007677488611079752, -0.021786091849207878, 0.008748897351324558, -0.0008414516923949122, -0.06068021059036255, -0.0035872648004442453, 0.050480104982852936, -0.006930727511644363, -0.0361848808825016, 0.015174798667430878, 0.015403538011014462, 0.002922536339610815, 0.008655046112835407, 0.01795255020260811, 0.02873729169368744, 0.019004758447408676, -0.03675730153918266, 0.01919880323112011, 0.005381626542657614, 0.033900342881679535, -0.037732139229774475, 0.02928711473941803, -0.014786211773753166, 0.0006007308838889003, -0.0008319408516399562, -0.05019436031579971, -0.014548742212355137, -0.05716400966048241, -0.00399420503526926, 0.011414974927902222, -0.0643838569521904, 0.0171507578343153, -0.00697722053155303, -0.03964421525597572, -0.008188174106180668, -0.01693682186305523, -0.028487421572208405, 0.042020395398139954, 0.02505684830248356, -0.041464805603027344, -0.09905355423688889, -0.02929539419710636, 0.0038608235772699118, 0.017584331333637238, 0.03828999027609825, -0.03276493772864342, 0.017426086589694023, -0.016677597537636757, -0.03225438669323921, -0.057729847729206085, 0.03606439754366875, 0.023610340431332588, 0.005810749251395464, 0.006576933432370424, -0.06757930666208267, -0.025488045066595078, 0.06961948424577713, -0.00301773427054286, -0.05302176997065544, -0.011738510802388191, -0.02395723946392536, -0.013465861789882183, 0.016231754794716835, 0.029087478294968605, 0.016568101942539215, 0.03824125975370407, 0.005831198301166296, -0.007723542395979166, 0.023364050313830376, 0.018561437726020813, 0.020157761871814728, 0.04058697447180748, -0.020323893055319786, -0.0197297353297472, 0.05654645711183548, 0.004731311928480864, 0.03263096511363983, -0.0068677207455039024, 0.017065247520804405, 0.006092204246670008, -0.02871958538889885, -0.060400739312171936, 0.047091513872146606, -0.046422142535448074, 0.02775069698691368, -0.021029053255915642, 0.033943694084882736, -0.02271892875432968, 0.008600751869380474, 0.03785458952188492, -0.05809398368000984, -0.02060517482459545, -0.043160662055015564, 0.0071323770098388195, -0.06817327439785004, 0.05700470134615898, 0.020690076053142548, -0.0322614349424839, 0.027148814871907234, 0.07787153869867325, 0.0007316129049286246, 0.05747964233160019, 0.009252798743546009, 0.048286985605955124, 0.02005794271826744, -0.027076218277215958, 0.018224898725748062, -0.02173067256808281, -0.04811529070138931, 0.045139819383621216, -0.0014283466152846813, -0.02486676722764969, -0.03675294667482376, 0.011512595228850842, -0.05980870872735977, 0.026851799339056015, -0.010966138914227486, -0.026041321456432343, 0.05177471041679382, -0.053495582193136215, 0.050325918942689896, -0.04284142702817917, -0.013312905095517635, -0.0350232757627964, 0.04829474538564682, -0.0028568815905600786, -0.026909565553069115, 0.02388245053589344, -0.003934287931770086, -0.017362749204039574, -0.003792132018133998, 0.038028113543987274, -0.0773884579539299, 0.050619322806596756, 0.004066599067300558, -0.015274349600076675, -0.018661584705114365, 0.010433845221996307, -0.006289597135037184, 0.05646859109401703, 0.02968316338956356, 0.03302309289574623, -0.034763582050800323, 0.047947026789188385, 0.026120178401470184, 0.07038290798664093, 0.05462224781513214, 0.058706268668174744, 0.025108028203248978, 0.05837724357843399, 0.014404498971998692, -0.005023493897169828, 0.06736749410629272, -0.04398421570658684, 0.011578857898712158, -0.0312950536608696, 0.08457077294588089, 0.008206102065742016, 0.05539443716406822, 0.039579279720783234, 0.014456694014370441, 0.04865163192152977, 0.021173549816012383, -0.04655648022890091, 0.07220625877380371, -0.040769726037979126, -0.002057043369859457, -0.012806421145796776, 0.026563391089439392, -0.07093819230794907, 0.01978444866836071, 0.010987010784447193, 0.03420520946383476, 0.02051200531423092, -0.013914241455495358, -0.02155601792037487, 0.00034975545713678, 0.015428098849952221, 0.03204474598169327, -0.024863434955477715, -0.003403829876333475, -0.032196637243032455, 0.03658727928996086, 0.03578980267047882, 0.02879459038376808, -0.06881922483444214, 0.0202176533639431, -0.027136949822306633, 0.01599292643368244, 0.04891793429851532, -0.03691762685775757, -0.026292569935321808, -0.007187193259596825, -0.02738342247903347, 0.0375855453312397, -0.006788121536374092, 0.030663684010505676, 0.032046884298324585, -0.053040143102407455, 0.001997330691665411, -0.02232595533132553, 0.01752021349966526, -0.03312656655907631, 0.048714663833379745, 0.03640104830265045, -0.02517928183078766, -0.04700649157166481, 0.008182684890925884, -0.02220917120575905, -0.011406205594539642, 0.00010679139813873917, -0.0312744602560997, -0.053699418902397156, -0.008313617669045925, 0.04283666983246803, 0.007921725511550903, -0.07752370089292526, -0.03305583447217941, -0.02098100818693638, -0.08531059324741364, -0.00998696405440569, 0.08446551114320755, -0.004665475804358721, -0.02140555903315544, 0.050821419805288315, 0.05752675235271454, 0.012547171674668789, -0.03754858672618866, 0.029468011111021042, 0.014390893280506134, 0.0777374878525734, 0.03062366507947445, -0.005317087285220623, -0.04742391034960747, -0.048345815390348434, 0.0727582797408104, -0.009312511421740055, 0.03342094644904137, -0.03982073441147804, 0.007645940408110619, 0.04159163683652878, 0.01184383686631918, -0.01675323396921158, 0.04778529703617096, 0.04117174074053764, 0.005097198765724897, -0.005762047134339809, -0.05073757842183113, 0.03452803194522858, -0.007218264043331146, -0.03385208919644356, -0.00008838271605782211, 0.003907301463186741, -0.020303862169384956, -0.0322393961250782, 0.0022065567318350077, -0.030943233519792557, 0.026203015819191933, -0.02393513359129429, -0.08067856729030609, -0.03253413736820221, 0.0009729815647006035, 0.06724298000335693, -0.08085601031780243, 0.030450018122792244, -0.023393288254737854, -0.02235172688961029, -0.008169948123395443, -0.005587907508015633, -0.0546160452067852, -0.025898350402712822, 0.0083340834826231, -0.041550882160663605, -0.00009530255192657933, 0.03464771807193756, 0.009839795529842377, 0.015990978106856346, -0.03295883908867836, 0.0059845163486897945, 0.01936410740017891, 0.0004029491974506527, 0.028020596131682396, 0.03619181364774704, -0.008725466206669807, 0.006736282259225845, 0.026890773326158524, 0.00230095605365932, 0.053738199174404144, -0.052018627524375916, 0.008357740007340908, 0.03991137072443962, 0.03407458961009979, 0.020389320328831673, -0.005813175346702337, -0.002111239591613412, -0.007931500673294067, 0.011596056632697582, -0.04940478503704071, 0.03631053864955902, 0.013674380257725716, 0.028551513329148293, 0.06864805519580841, -0.028153950348496437, -0.03921456262469292, -0.019128035753965378, -0.02316303178668022, -0.03763299062848091, 0.0159918200224638, -0.02028243988752365, -0.055768419057130814, 0.03210509568452835, -0.056884314864873886, -0.015021574683487415, -0.03405538573861122, -0.002892172895371914, -0.016449112445116043, -0.007914039306342602, 0.00009731842874316499, 0.006321627646684647, 0.07150538265705109, 0.009050940163433552, 0.05413873866200447, -0.03520853817462921, 0.023487964645028114, 0.024455169215798378, -0.057021692395210266, 0.01677529886364937, -0.017258817330002785, 0.017994863912463188, 0.07055313885211945, 0.040337733924388885, 0.01111263781785965, 0.054767679423093796, 0.02329886145889759, 0.0296675693243742, -0.06416232138872147, -0.0073960623703897, 0.009279503487050533, -0.05060668662190437, 0.04015464335680008, 0.0019879979081451893, -0.01304147019982338, 0.004648804664611816, 0.081785649061203, 0.06676272302865982, -0.0260225348174572, 0.017526857554912567, -0.008631248958408833, 0.0004713974485639483, 0.02763858065009117, -0.062115248292684555, -0.02349550649523735, 0.013514803722500801, 0.04980745539069176, 0.01880713552236557, -0.00914688315242529, 0.059816159307956696, 0.001355203683488071, 0.05476813763380051, -0.02936559170484543, -0.00042277295142412186, -0.049135010689496994, -0.008204521611332893, -0.044118478894233704, -0.03707302361726761, 0.04096406698226929, -0.052912529557943344, -0.07878133654594421, 0.006328722927719355, 0.0058302427642047405, 0.039197780191898346, 0.029993709176778793, 0.02224556729197502, -0.019347453489899635, -0.024357782676815987, -0.007066948339343071, 0.0019081643549725413, 0.051642101258039474, -0.026201115921139717, 0.0226909127086401, -0.07697711884975433, 0.006937399972230196, 0.03280813992023468, -0.0053789871744811535, 0.06097725033760071, -0.007086766418069601, -0.013282918371260166, 0.02905006892979145, -0.023527782410383224, 0.026589108631014824, 0.006591830402612686, -0.015500339679419994, 0.033438585698604584, -0.005559703800827265, 0.00667851697653532, 0.02177220582962036, -0.012642635963857174, -0.02019464038312435, -0.016441183164715767, -0.06370221078395844, 0.023433396592736244, -0.0012058215215802193, 0.04326869547367096, -0.05808243155479431, 0.029715150594711304, 0.030497947707772255, -0.018955597653985023, 0.01830783113837242, -0.058198411017656326, -0.030946994200348854, 0.07198965549468994, 0.030675474554300308, -0.013989530503749847, -0.03321614861488342, -0.013275357894599438, 0.001568676088936627, 0.009963884018361568, -0.03207997977733612, 0.07535117864608765, 0.006685817148536444, -0.02359086647629738, 0.02969961427152157, 0.026184789836406708, 0.061640217900276184, 0.0261295847594738, -0.003229054855182767, -0.046217452734708786, -0.0409068688750267, 0.03288612514734268, -0.024744069203734398, -0.009698946960270405, 0.0012648152187466621, -0.03148778900504112, 0.006588296964764595, -0.0015101935714483261, 0.039037350565195084, 0.028690649196505547, 0.031090399250388145, -0.006683282554149628, -0.04534829035401344, -0.012736628763377666, -0.015996119007468224, -0.038487814366817474, 0.005019397474825382, -0.028489932417869568, -0.039634544402360916, -0.02123144641518593, 0.01903664693236351, -0.03208201378583908, -0.04239707440137863, -0.03393947333097458, -0.019103189930319786, 0.06035013869404793, 0.010347829200327396, 0.0021534019615501165, -0.019287822768092155, -0.004895453806966543, -0.0018383718561381102, 0.07133502513170242, -0.0240985956043005, -0.008920665830373764, -0.053954001516103745, 0.02266152761876583, -0.04355546087026596, 0.018968774005770683, -0.0069849565625190735, 0.021660763770341873, 0.013350896537303925, -0.05468584969639778, 0.08256786316633224, 0.012877997010946274, -0.008373335935175419, 0.01861332170665264, -0.03220174461603165, -0.04679785296320915, -0.02480723336338997, -0.013255209662020206, 0.04415464773774147, -0.012807208113372326, -0.009569389745593071, -0.007785039488226175, 0.0059838490560650826, 0.0034676736686378717, 0.004522373899817467, -0.05241073668003082, -0.044120632112026215, 0.033333923667669296 ]
<p>Apologies in advance for the long question.</p> <p>My understanding is that in GR, massive observers move along timelike curves $x^\mu(\lambda)$, and if an observer moves from point $x^\mu(\lambda_a)$ to $x^\mu(\lambda_b)$, then his clock will measure that an amount of time $t_{ba}$ given by the curve's arc length; $$ t_{ba} = \int_{\lambda_a}^{\lambda_b}d\lambda \sqrt{-g_{\mu\nu}(x(\lambda))\dot x^\mu(\lambda)\dot x^\nu(\lambda)} $$ will have elapsed where $g_{\mu\nu}$ is a metric on spacetime with signature $(-,+,+,+)$. </p> <p><strong>Why is this so?</strong> </p> <hr> <p>Here is how I would attempt to justify this fact in special relativity with $g_{\mu\nu} = \eta_{\mu\nu}$. Consider an inertial observer $O$ in $\mathbb R^{3,1}$, and suppose that this observer sees a clock, which I'll call observer $O'$ moving around on a curve $x^\mu(\lambda)$. If $O'$ were also an inertial observer, then given any event with coordinates $x^\mu$ as measured by $O$, observer $O'$ would measure the coordinates of the event to be $x'^\mu = \Lambda^\mu_{\phantom\mu\nu} x^\nu + x_0^\mu$ for some Lorentz transformation $\Lambda$. If $O'$ is not inertial, then this is no longer true, and there is some more complicated family of transformations, say $T_\lambda$ between events as seen by both observers.</p> <p>I would argue, however, that if we were to partition the interval $[\lambda_a, \lambda_b]$ into a large number $N$ of intervals $I_1=[\lambda_a, \lambda_i], \dots, I_N=[\lambda_{N-1}, \lambda_b]$ with $\lambda_n = \lambda_a+n\epsilon_N$ and $\epsilon_N=(\lambda_b-\lambda_a)/N$, then on each interval $I_n$, $O'$ is approximately an inertial observer in the sense that $$ T_{\lambda_n} = P_n + \mathcal O(\epsilon_N), \qquad (\star) $$ for some Poincare transformation $P_n$. Then we would note that since $O'$ is stationary in his own reference frame, he measures his worldline to have the property $\dot x'^\mu(\lambda) = (\dot t(\lambda), \mathbf 0)$ so that $$ I_{ba}=\int_{\lambda_a}^{\lambda_b}d\lambda \,\sqrt{-\eta_{\mu\nu}\dot x'^\mu\dot x'^\mu} = \int_{\lambda_a}^{\lambda_b} d\lambda \, \sqrt{\dot t^2} = t(\lambda_b) - t(\lambda_a) = t_{ba} $$ On the other hand the integral on the left can be written as a Riemann sum using the partition above, and we can invoke ($\star$) above to get \begin{align} I_{ba} &amp;= \lim_{N\to\infty}\left[\sum_{n=1}^N \epsilon_N\sqrt{-\eta_{\mu\nu}\dot x'^\mu(\lambda_n)\dot x'^\nu(\lambda_n)}\right] \notag\\ &amp;= \lim_{N\to\infty}\left[\sum_{n=1}^N \epsilon_N\sqrt{-\eta_{\mu\nu}\dot x^\mu(\lambda_n)\dot x^\nu(\lambda_n)} + \mathcal{O}(\epsilon_N^2)\right] \notag\\ &amp;= \int_{\lambda_a}^{\lambda_b}d\lambda \,\sqrt{-\eta_{\mu\nu}\dot x^\mu\dot x^\mu} \end{align} Combining these two computations gives the desired result.</p> <p><strong>How do others feel about this argument?</strong></p> <p>I'm not completely comfortable with it because of the assumption $(\star)$ I made on $T_\lambda$.</p> <p>I imagine that in GR a similar argument could be made by invoking local flatness of the metric.</p>
g4272
[ -0.0027439838740974665, 0.0049865590408444405, -0.0016067844117060304, -0.03176845982670784, -0.007457395549863577, 0.031913504004478455, 0.052162352949380875, 0.011092293076217175, -0.027706176042556763, 0.02094213478267193, 0.004275577608495951, 0.012396019883453846, 0.017273498699069023, -0.03414765000343323, -0.005123693961650133, -0.0465979129076004, 0.09316319227218628, -0.00237179733812809, -0.01683332398533821, -0.009765367954969406, 0.0719163566827774, 0.04248088225722313, 0.015278403647243977, -0.04144442453980446, 0.03709353134036064, -0.0363793708384037, 0.07921779900789261, -0.01703234761953354, -0.028785808011889458, -0.004297768231481314, 0.05095309764146805, -0.0014589425409212708, -0.0051713380962610245, 0.005547085776925087, 0.02370988018810749, -0.004122831393033266, -0.008578331209719181, 0.0122281014919281, 0.0560498982667923, -0.003629676066339016, 0.012017396278679371, 0.010546712204813957, 0.07033030688762665, 0.005068041384220123, 0.0659637600183487, 0.0038641239516437054, -0.005157608538866043, 0.042622845619916916, 0.04020118713378906, -0.0371076874434948, -0.03484030067920685, 0.05322704091668129, -0.0006931176176294684, 0.006749299820512533, -0.017929362133145332, 0.12358709424734116, 0.021428359672427177, -0.02828012779355049, 0.00014189288776833564, 0.0427432581782341, -0.009799569845199585, -0.12026768922805786, 0.0014117916580289602, 0.022429699078202248, 0.02767479419708252, 0.0188490878790617, 0.00019071591668762267, -0.020143622532486916, 0.0004184552817605436, -0.016998298466205597, 0.024291133508086205, -0.002791434759274125, 0.022557439282536507, -0.01868518628180027, -0.03126490116119385, 0.0750766173005104, 0.013973072171211243, 0.02589072659611702, -0.03483126685023308, -0.0011669714003801346, -0.08158228546380997, -0.017787979915738106, 0.030368810519576073, 0.03994119539856911, 0.08092140406370163, -0.010903566144406796, 0.020134620368480682, -0.005693566054105759, 0.02183067612349987, 0.04406115785241127, 0.026072189211845398, -0.03836529329419136, 0.04604657366871834, 0.0035715424455702305, -0.03719788417220116, -0.050911884754896164, -0.031734734773635864, 0.03777807950973511, -0.030832745134830475, 0.030398249626159668, -0.037737227976322174, 0.010776486247777939, -0.012612950056791306, 0.027146749198436737, 0.041821856051683426, -0.04127432033419609, -0.07755663990974426, 0.010200482793152332, -0.01626213826239109, -0.04894666373729706, 0.018765753135085106, -0.031542208045721054, 0.02806699648499489, -0.014997147023677826, -0.05776137113571167, -0.00793466903269291, 0.01597079075872898, -0.004016959108412266, -0.01927880570292473, 0.06315566599369049, -0.01636596955358982, 0.012698025442659855, -0.017051955685019493, 0.07845082134008408, 0.01314997486770153, -0.04025958105921745, -0.001676445361226797, 0.03680161386728287, -0.00642457976937294, -0.0169893316924572, -0.0005851197056472301, 0.02364063449203968, 0.005454735364764929, 0.005294654984027147, -0.028122354298830032, 0.02050408348441124, 0.05940063297748566, -0.02706155925989151, -0.04977434501051903, 0.03510648012161255, 0.009897194802761078, 0.008296211250126362, 0.005480070132762194, -0.05455872789025307, -0.06779958307743073, 0.07385803759098053, -0.02575903758406639, -0.017905354499816895, 0.01826685294508934, -0.01657889038324356, -0.06244247034192085, 0.09166727215051651, -0.04546748101711273, 0.005983980838209391, 0.016034571453928947, 0.008566019125282764, -0.06430350244045258, -0.006583335809409618, -0.026845445856451988, 0.03991226106882095, 0.03873613849282265, -0.019207153469324112, -0.007084691897034645, -0.005706800613552332, -0.014685740694403648, 0.03306514397263527, -0.015778644010424614, -0.05949971824884415, -0.05232103541493416, -0.13096491992473602, -0.04390808567404747, 0.030232500284910202, 0.04451127350330353, 0.016247279942035675, -0.03172554820775986, 0.02235547825694084, -0.010738814249634743, -0.015525931492447853, -0.02317226305603981, -0.044839199632406235, -0.0368884801864624, -0.0115456972271204, 0.00964764691889286, -0.10585344582796097, -0.013316698372364044, -0.0800541341304779, 0.0020316883455961943, -0.0253074262291193, -0.03339018300175667, 0.030537337064743042, 0.03189440816640854, -0.03249794617295265, 0.023848868906497955, 0.0799524262547493, -0.03213943541049957, 0.024111168459057808, 0.05654740706086159, -0.015916017815470695, 0.014911835081875324, 0.006876478437334299, -0.013537002727389336, -0.017055459320545197, 0.035677675157785416, 0.008340688422322273, 0.03817904368042946, 0.018279636278748512, 0.016845598816871643, 0.036094579845666885, -0.03300813212990761, -0.009390465915203094, 0.028488246724009514, -0.0343124158680439, -0.01743524707853794, -0.044974640011787415, -0.061597853899002075, -0.014198877848684788, -0.00907589215785265, -0.0015243826201185584, 0.05305078253149986, 0.05880570411682129, 0.006724553182721138, -0.03245067223906517, 0.017379553988575935, -0.04258061200380325, 0.016656672582030296, -0.03273843973875046, -0.0591721311211586, 0.0005687632947228849, 0.03393915668129921, -0.002328073140233755, -0.03183760866522789, 0.060861073434352875, -0.029957663267850876, 0.01936660334467888, 0.07348915189504623, 0.006229650694876909, -0.0043034921400249004, 0.041795890778303146, 0.01819072663784027, 0.0030337634962052107, 0.09968794882297516, -0.03618761524558067, -0.017290905117988586, -0.04023514315485954, 0.020283769816160202, 0.011652139015495777, 0.008717584423720837, 0.02730640023946762, 0.00023177772527560592, 0.008777424693107605, -0.034743744879961014, 0.010043486021459103, 0.002584428060799837, -0.0024886091705411673, 0.012155499309301376, -0.006765448953956366, 0.0033014309592545033, 0.03308640047907829, -0.08127280324697495, -0.002599781146273017, 0.016351982951164246, -0.05650734156370163, -0.01866159401834011, -0.009055215865373611, 0.002997341798618436, -0.008356938138604164, -0.03141782060265541, 0.04721309617161751, -0.023998325690627098, -0.010110628791153431, -0.020222270861268044, 0.03711148723959923, 0.01316007785499096, 0.07024573534727097, -0.017116041854023933, 0.011881488375365734, 0.00339223793707788, -0.012230507098138332, 0.044191326946020126, -0.015435063280165195, -0.0057286606170237064, 0.023497432470321655, -0.09647736698389053, 0.01259657833725214, 0.031613465398550034, -0.060192372649908066, -0.005413257051259279, 0.019462047144770622, 0.028982365503907204, 0.012562325224280357, 0.04433649033308029, 0.018312226980924606, 0.05497795343399048, 0.018310559913516045, -0.030037162825465202, 0.03114180639386177, -0.03944393992424011, -0.03510281443595886, 0.030728086829185486, 0.010972593910992146, 0.005243029445409775, -0.0213070809841156, 0.009996362030506134, 0.04806160554289818, 0.03540044277906418, -0.012358314357697964, -0.02378706820309162, -0.07344936579465866, -0.020644698292016983, -0.019381621852517128, 0.055351920425891876, 0.01096819993108511, 0.022107144817709923, -0.024330832064151764, 0.007425953168421984, -0.028235850855708122, -0.04888829216361046, -0.002245354000478983, -0.06131938844919205, -0.010044340044260025, 0.02921639196574688, 0.007361978758126497, -0.052302297204732895, -0.02587033621966839, 0.014895956963300705, -0.015545375645160675, -0.006989559158682823, -0.006692554801702499, -0.07333044707775116, 0.001871555345132947, -0.05185079202055931, 0.027990663424134254, 0.025509964674711227, 0.038050781935453415, -0.01473461277782917, -0.005073145497590303, -0.0233880877494812, 0.027457745745778084, 0.043777383863925934, -0.05168246850371361, -0.053899336606264114, -0.009524160996079445, -0.043799884617328644, 0.012976780533790588, 0.038257524371147156, 0.023660767823457718, 0.03883686661720276, 0.01015355996787548, 0.03142758086323738, -0.02277989126741886, -0.0021637417376041412, -0.010413550771772861, -0.010787161998450756, -0.06530816107988358, 0.014768380671739578, 0.01597094163298607, 0.027747375890612602, 0.03491031751036644, 0.039147548377513885, -0.07856010645627975, 0.04330777749419212, 0.031456828117370605, -0.02718166820704937, -0.0047239395789802074, -0.009743986651301384, -0.03552912175655365, -0.05741371586918831, 0.02472039684653282, 0.0330246277153492, 0.011098883114755154, 0.04942331090569496, 0.04262451454997063, 0.025609031319618225, -0.024401893839240074, 0.05447886511683464, -0.07913890480995178, 0.035851556807756424, 0.04576331004500389, -0.02307461015880108, 0.0015724141849204898, 0.0386122465133667, 0.008309982717037201, -0.03757818043231964, -0.022532954812049866, 0.03690603747963905, 0.017850836738944054, 0.05282403156161308, -0.032063309103250504, -0.000935286283493042, -0.1050800308585167, 0.016320116817951202, -0.03597435727715492, -0.011173458769917488, -0.06917396932840347, 0.009744221344590187, -0.03843867406249046, 0.05520383641123772, 0.001940315356478095, 0.032110024243593216, -0.0039978111162781715, 0.0039191595278680325, 0.05533267557621002, 0.041584573686122894, 0.0034662920515984297, -0.04193611070513725, -0.057171739637851715, -0.022529050707817078, -0.03481605648994446, -0.007676985114812851, -0.050802044570446014, 0.002396761439740658, -0.008501626551151276, -0.005616459529846907, -0.06767572462558746, 0.04754698649048805, 0.04139256849884987, -0.02059067413210869, -0.028271891176700592, -0.015368840657174587, 0.0057961223646998405, 0.008220124058425426, 0.041584521532058716, 0.06483466178178787, -0.017661193385720253, 0.004646757617592812, 0.06343463063240051, 0.07278506457805634, 0.024043548852205276, -0.023576829582452774, -0.06381156295537949, 0.03086147829890251, 0.02390844002366066, 0.01850559189915657, 0.054766278713941574, -0.030346550047397614, 0.027721121907234192, 0.03977951034903526, 0.05863406881690025, -0.011217816732823849, -0.017433812841773033, -0.021143393591046333, -0.025944126769900322, -0.03611307591199875, 0.0013199234381318092, -0.0020434707403182983, 0.015474642626941204, -0.037570495158433914, -0.03418451547622681, -0.02148236520588398, 0.014772294089198112, -0.002992725232616067, 0.026133740320801735, 0.018787648528814316, 0.015923570841550827, 0.022070489823818207, -0.006805371027439833, 0.001861572964116931, 0.033610399812459946, -0.01030106283724308, -0.0380866602063179, -0.029756244271993637, -0.0369819812476635, 0.04423953592777252, 0.031494684517383575, 0.025941643863916397, -0.01931682415306568, -0.11129171401262283, -0.00040171045111492276, -0.0698489248752594, -0.02605166658759117, -0.010322186164557934, 0.004395705182105303, -0.034139830619096756, -0.030059009790420532, -0.04247066751122475, 0.011665983125567436, 0.0006032951059751213, -0.010286436416208744, 0.03604837507009506, -0.04003981128334999, -0.048760730773210526, 0.017985017970204353, -0.0030363542027771473, 0.0027586203068494797, -0.021637381985783577, 0.04160899668931961, -0.019055180251598358, -0.04168865457177162, 0.026898982003331184, 0.00502152880653739, 0.02415504865348339, -0.023712219670414925, 0.08555208891630173, 0.03160841763019562, 0.006572838872671127, 0.029859039932489395, 0.03492368757724762, -0.036740466952323914, 0.006369773764163256, -0.024236924946308136, -0.08431639522314072, 0.05071890354156494, 0.0034755307715386152, -0.02788645215332508, -0.02808365225791931, 0.049961190670728683, -0.0005296558374539018, 0.02420281060039997, -0.041068725287914276, 0.08793990314006805, 0.009190314449369907, 0.03576236218214035, -0.009133314713835716, 0.014198482036590576, -0.013878920115530491, -0.007490126881748438, 0.029689207673072815, -0.03467271849513054, -0.022620586678385735, -0.05717812478542328, 0.007799661252647638, 0.06568541377782822, 0.021396245807409286, 0.000886830035597086, 0.05070830509066582, -0.011199461296200752, -0.028215523809194565, -0.06722868233919144, -0.03424588218331337, 0.015964489430189133, 0.023755844682455063, -0.057280465960502625, -0.043129559606313705, 0.021915564313530922, 0.004922687076032162, 0.021732637658715248, 0.002947386587038636, 0.009367957711219788, 0.025792866945266724, -0.07763280719518661, -0.02937193401157856, -0.017083747312426567, -0.004159422125667334, 0.06421464681625366, -0.07030504941940308, -0.013412694446742535, -0.033804405480623245, -0.04214213788509369, 0.035825684666633606, -0.019285811111330986, -0.00863988883793354, 0.019946789368987083, -0.027692709118127823, -0.004990436602383852, -0.03823206573724747, 0.0527227409183979, 0.01659005880355835, -0.02713797800242901, -0.02555045858025551, -0.016716785728931427, -0.0011008913861587644, -0.0500827394425869, 0.04516284540295601, 0.03163602948188782, 0.018230246379971504, -0.028566209599375725, 0.010713720694184303, -0.026231877505779266, 0.05723702535033226, 0.04376285523176193, 0.01049931813031435, -0.01744695194065571, 0.020509319379925728, 0.004305384587496519, -0.05118889361619949, 0.01587332785129547, -0.025324666872620583, -0.015117129310965538, -0.03428534045815468, 0.03203001990914345, -0.02637157402932644, -0.03414439037442207, 0.06872104853391647, -0.05711091682314873, -0.0429336242377758, -0.025391725823283195, -0.01115360576659441, 0.03843310847878456, 0.0003355562803335488, 0.0026480816304683685, -0.03033985197544098, -0.026432456448674202, -0.04065487161278725, -0.03434039652347565, -0.06528987735509872, 0.0016966023249551654, 0.004099014215171337, -0.027819987386465073, -0.020572684705257416, -0.004955424927175045, -0.02544773928821087, 0.020213015377521515, 0.06762757152318954, -0.031178634613752365, 0.03591228649020195, 0.017674770206212997, -0.09388202428817749, 0.028333663940429688, 0.07142651081085205, -0.002400629920884967, 0.03669211268424988, 0.033465784043073654, 0.021830834448337555, 0.08178497850894928, 0.004842475987970829, -0.051360778510570526, -0.028013965114951134, 0.053413666784763336, -0.02311994880437851, 0.002332659438252449, 0.05472368001937866, 0.036879342049360275, 0.007451601326465607, 0.03515838459134102, 0.017529262229800224, 0.05798868089914322, -0.008025049231946468, -0.005233410280197859, -0.026401039212942123, 0.005493254866451025, -0.0032120358664542437, 0.018785731866955757, -0.08667507022619247, 0.021938171237707138, 0.027811245992779732, 0.04143780842423439, -0.002189728431403637, 0.04893307015299797, 0.027913542464375496, 0.037493448704481125, 0.008453905582427979, 0.026052134111523628, -0.005256692413240671, 0.004304840695112944, -0.07127076387405396, -0.026205463334918022, 0.026550810784101486, 0.02161228284239769, -0.04697125032544136, 0.0360059030354023, 0.02404703199863434, -0.01798805594444275, -0.015510876663029194, 0.02641529217362404, -0.03939773514866829, -0.06875121593475342, -0.03615303710103035, -0.045622773468494415, 0.058515969663858414, -0.05650496855378151, -0.028223875910043716, -0.004365172237157822, -0.06587037444114685, 0.020295869559049606, -0.009618685580790043, 0.03985072299838066, 0.003464069915935397, -0.06137668341398239, -0.01340674702078104, -0.05248960107564926, 0.03346641734242439, 0.024697307497262955, 0.028303729370236397, -0.03018510714173317, 0.019828075543045998, -0.014422367326915264, 0.02552148327231407, 0.00435240613296628, -0.020720168948173523, 0.012292727828025818, 0.006866132374852896, 0.01579190045595169, -0.0052103400230407715, 0.0482555516064167, -0.018069157376885414, 0.027874095365405083, 0.01309108268469572, -0.005676959175616503, -0.01434258371591568, -0.002901037922129035, -0.02537206932902336, 0.07341714948415756, -0.013043530285358429, 0.04737313091754913, 0.01154972705990076, 0.0010287197073921561, 0.006539487279951572, 0.012964731082320213, 0.020472202450037003, 0.023178409785032272, 0.03217976167798042, 0.01750253513455391, 0.007044126279652119, 0.016127625480294228, 0.05199391394853592, 0.07504576444625854, -0.012606047093868256, -0.062022361904382706, 0.04947817325592041, 0.05050589516758919, 0.004723499063402414, 0.005699917674064636, -0.01871664635837078, 0.0043298788368701935, 0.061282068490982056, -0.02369828335940838, -0.04144730046391487, -0.03258613497018814, 0.047958675771951675, -0.041149482131004333, -0.03322546184062958, -0.046103525906801224, -0.02491798624396324, -0.05883486196398735, 0.04788537323474884, 0.011326837353408337, 0.06495900452136993, -0.02615935169160366, 0.006853708531707525, -0.018104873597621918, 0.002451102714985609, -0.020128384232521057, -0.04482205584645271, 0.056687191128730774, -0.08191846311092377, -0.045366041362285614, -0.0019148223800584674, -0.0004261102876625955, -0.06271686404943466, 0.004293306730687618, 0.0314658023416996, -0.06353401392698288, 0.005268547218292952, -0.00553746847435832, -0.00646376796066761, -0.002624864922836423, 0.017083290964365005, 0.02254878170788288, -0.035953689366579056, -0.04177580401301384, -0.0007951512816362083, 0.04564493149518967, -0.046568021178245544, -0.020680829882621765, 0.0354362353682518, -0.014102951623499393, 0.06696329265832901, -0.016147548332810402, 0.03262864053249359, -0.0007128797005861998, -0.0052514998242259026, -0.0192415714263916, -0.025653501972556114, 0.00017798221961129457, -0.028870752081274986, 0.0186601635068655, 0.024938372895121574, 0.043008361011743546 ]
<p>An object with a density of $x$ inside a liquid with a density greater than $x$ would float. If we assume that both of these are positively charged and the object is in the middle of the liquid:</p> <ol> <li><p>Would the liquid touch the object?</p></li> <li><p>Would the object still float up because of buoyancy?</p></li> </ol>
g4273
[ 0.04759490489959717, 0.02511969581246376, 0.01232205517590046, -0.05776437371969223, 0.02370857447385788, 0.08639539778232574, -0.05506807193160057, -0.021748606115579605, -0.07137979567050934, -0.014492714777588844, -0.004179548472166061, 0.011430660262703896, -0.0020110514014959335, -0.055972643196582794, -0.02747250907123089, 0.009981062263250351, 0.08300428092479706, -0.03759567812085152, -0.027259452268481255, 0.0006607604445889592, -0.023440301418304443, 0.011729024350643158, -0.04643780738115311, -0.023936867713928223, -0.02397811785340309, -0.019764024764299393, 0.009697644971311092, 0.017914077267050743, -0.04131360724568367, -0.015225502662360668, -0.019829057157039642, 0.03109763003885746, -0.020941631868481636, -0.044859953224658966, -0.056581735610961914, -0.05224260315299034, 0.010000722482800484, 0.006289168726652861, -0.025058552622795105, -0.011771929450333118, 0.005262856371700764, 0.0341460220515728, 0.012318141758441925, -0.023176945745944977, -0.04257438704371452, -0.0033197447191923857, -0.0007831776747480035, 0.008065486326813698, 0.009125197306275368, -0.038093000650405884, -0.04659828543663025, 0.05039479583501816, -0.07553695887327194, 0.0022897818125784397, -0.0023360908962786198, 0.0720318853855133, 0.04076439142227173, -0.004611040931195021, -0.022596022114157677, 0.06380879878997803, 0.02234947681427002, 0.04640248045325279, -0.00818373542279005, -0.029347656294703484, 0.018364520743489265, -0.015916958451271057, -0.05549171194434166, -0.0053853667341172695, -0.013413646258413792, 0.010904229246079922, 0.0641784518957138, 0.01589147560298443, -0.03967101126909256, -0.0745217427611351, -0.08608516305685043, 0.03850560635328293, -0.0005880794487893581, 0.004232572857290506, 0.02319354936480522, -0.07890334725379944, -0.01803763397037983, -0.005207688082009554, 0.05466900393366814, -0.016554389148950577, 0.07437591254711151, 0.01278447825461626, -0.036040108650922775, -0.02350427396595478, -0.028381602838635445, -0.016583912074565887, 0.002438457915559411, -0.016504604369401932, 0.06862546503543854, 0.009604132734239101, 0.010003799572587013, -0.05716876685619354, 0.03950798138976097, -0.004515106324106455, -0.023255394771695137, -0.04731092229485512, -0.02282867766916752, -0.01117653213441372, 0.03198700770735741, 0.0051822541281580925, -0.020049989223480225, 0.021916165947914124, 0.04620646685361862, 0.02793004736304283, -0.006212333217263222, -0.006211127620190382, 0.03561759740114212, -0.02726663462817669, -0.01078411377966404, -0.010107050649821758, -0.014747921377420425, 0.017228612676262856, 0.09089958667755127, -0.0075708962976932526, -0.04189480096101761, -0.0013925197999924421, -0.01548764668405056, 0.04080710560083389, 0.08730083703994751, 0.05533537268638611, 0.033564794808626175, -0.011671827174723148, 0.039067354053258896, -0.0015197464963421226, -0.012218371033668518, 0.035725273191928864, 0.04146246239542961, 0.003578009782359004, -0.042452599853277206, -0.00881215836852789, 0.00895759928971529, -0.005494174547493458, 0.02618042565882206, -0.03024214506149292, 0.043676458299160004, -0.023853378370404243, 0.07777765393257141, -0.00917094200849533, -0.015357227064669132, 0.03101334534585476, 0.02700646221637726, -0.004417849704623222, -0.010909553617238998, 0.016973430290818214, 0.032080162316560745, 0.04742984473705292, 0.020399773493409157, 0.00038586099981330335, 0.06279628723859787, -0.02125699073076248, 0.01596536673605442, 0.024387819692492485, 0.0727984830737114, -0.030118491500616074, 0.04156132787466049, -0.013273162767291069, 0.05015430599451065, 0.039449360221624374, 0.04357466846704483, -0.014181102626025677, -0.020176846534013748, 0.0240121278911829, 0.0460810624063015, -0.03448910266160965, -0.04932989180088043, 0.004434513859450817, -0.02271275408565998, 0.01995287835597992, -0.04881411790847778, 0.05564887076616287, 0.08470248430967331, 0.007605931721627712, -0.05696845427155495, 0.001082989270798862, 0.08984081447124481, 0.01225558202713728, -0.047147974371910095, -0.012132755480706692, 0.008246563374996185, 0.05883008614182472, -0.007086224853992462, 0.012272235006093979, -0.0011103397700935602, 0.03833847865462303, -0.05299382284283638, 0.03489690646529198, -0.05086379498243332, 0.00845029391348362, -0.04407890886068344, 0.026857446879148483, -0.0042312247678637505, -0.0719512328505516, 0.07786628603935242, -0.006883316207677126, -0.04471783712506294, -0.024994248524308205, -0.04615788161754608, -0.03845900669693947, 0.03477779030799866, 0.004102046135812998, -0.018727311864495277, 0.02840735949575901, -0.013321839272975922, -0.037550099194049835, 0.04753858223557472, -0.02204449288547039, 0.006916208658367395, -0.04077288508415222, 0.02737843059003353, -0.00020366860553622246, -0.025686392560601234, 0.0013578874059021473, -0.04738077148795128, 0.0921100303530693, -0.024916891008615494, 0.02159818820655346, -0.05941203981637955, 0.024575427174568176, 0.02154351770877838, 0.013887069188058376, 0.008663439191877842, -0.015633979812264442, 0.0338258370757103, 0.01229326892644167, -0.005462734494358301, 0.00642388267442584, -0.014357081614434719, 0.0007770344382151961, 0.0035751445684581995, 0.006007758434861898, 0.033487822860479355, 0.09914200007915497, -0.032572418451309204, 0.04013681039214134, 0.002417957643046975, 0.012816613540053368, -0.037662114948034286, 0.020367875695228577, -0.0022734578233212233, 0.020789042115211487, 0.01535672415047884, -0.0054425508715212345, -0.03499897941946983, 0.035497505217790604, -0.00015361863188445568, 0.05232970789074898, 0.019111935049295425, 0.02401011995971203, 0.0195898599922657, 0.01478210836648941, 0.014378659427165985, 0.003709230339154601, -0.06774664670228958, 0.011384804733097553, -0.001367073506116867, -0.013970328494906425, 0.014423465356230736, -0.05541384592652321, -0.040623366832733154, -0.0717090368270874, -0.10025070607662201, 0.004390531685203314, -0.08352243900299072, -0.03201058506965637, 0.07303552329540253, 0.04322148114442825, -0.003294046502560377, 0.05742577835917473, 0.008051270619034767, 0.056883301585912704, 0.017470218241214752, 0.006176327355206013, -0.030594291165471077, -0.03657503426074982, 0.018724163994193077, -0.023137718439102173, 0.028224671259522438, 0.01969081535935402, -0.040689438581466675, 0.06812283396720886, 0.04832497984170914, -0.040650270879268646, -0.007533510681241751, 0.02537740021944046, 0.026142481714487076, 0.018114905804395676, 0.01994219794869423, 0.0208237636834383, 0.03875738009810448, -0.012731150723993778, 0.05412493646144867, 0.024048101156949997, 0.01713491603732109, 0.002421178389340639, -0.023232851177453995, 0.011069431900978088, 0.043953683227300644, -0.009921119548380375, 0.017561716958880424, 0.037689272314310074, 0.06637845933437347, 0.0202720258384943, -0.03138203173875809, -0.032036054879426956, -0.02065436914563179, -0.027112305164337158, -0.06573016941547394, 0.06664256751537323, -0.049390193074941635, -0.01617521420121193, -0.031262729316949844, -0.027549948543310165, 0.01869412139058113, 0.021349189803004265, -0.02271287702023983, -0.07571563124656677, -0.03985247761011124, 0.055839311331510544, 0.047122757881879807, -0.024514682590961456, -0.0034688522573560476, 0.030159778892993927, -0.026452668011188507, 0.03049086406826973, -0.014713367447257042, 0.02554354816675186, 0.02516472153365612, 0.0175012219697237, 0.030853761360049248, -0.0016410135431215167, 0.013759280554950237, -0.0055147865787148476, 0.04464763030409813, 0.004676590673625469, -0.0122068515047431, 0.06284332275390625, -0.018523942679166794, -0.06435680389404297, -0.019082453101873398, -0.05617279186844826, -0.032240960747003555, -0.034051015973091125, -0.03383376821875572, -0.01799928955733776, -0.0015194290317595005, -0.023016275838017464, 0.035514719784259796, -0.006153245456516743, 0.006093752104789019, -0.007838551886379719, -0.0021767388097941875, -0.014168210327625275, 0.0186212956905365, 0.022250855341553688, -0.017892299219965935, 0.03716406226158142, -0.003102544229477644, -0.018505847081542015, 0.05606472119688988, -0.027950547635555267, -0.013578327372670174, -0.025766421109437943, -0.03174632042646408, 0.024286750704050064, -0.014638205990195274, 0.006201899144798517, 0.003732086392119527, 0.008412319235503674, 0.0025952267460525036, -0.014641286805272102, 0.04842750355601311, -0.07842948287725449, 0.025047408416867256, -0.007848444394767284, -0.0364261269569397, -0.005541731137782335, 0.05034886300563812, -0.028636984527111053, -0.002206958131864667, -0.004693071357905865, -0.009165160357952118, 0.007949202321469784, -0.008950125426054, 0.015455618500709534, 0.016941340640187263, -0.07656612992286682, -0.015266421250998974, 0.01745717227458954, -0.005754151381552219, 0.03437182307243347, 0.013343662023544312, -0.02610495314002037, 0.015992911532521248, -0.010333691723644733, -0.0005624819896183908, -0.018131112679839134, 0.006261451169848442, 0.015333210118114948, -0.011548127047717571, -0.06379813700914383, -0.006692159920930862, -0.001928698387928307, 0.03601134568452835, -0.07164634764194489, -0.01821374148130417, -0.0702219158411026, 0.006498613860458136, 0.01596902497112751, -0.014420815743505955, 0.015286176465451717, -0.09609442204236984, 0.011840933933854103, 0.012530765496194363, 0.06316576898097992, -0.018133535981178284, 0.028456777334213257, 0.05383339151740074, 0.046188563108444214, -0.05688686668872833, -0.027596354484558105, -0.07972504943609238, 0.026813354343175888, 0.07785104215145111, 0.03533903509378433, 0.02007659338414669, -0.03853749483823776, -0.04908531531691551, 0.038100533187389374, 0.008127043955028057, 0.03851781040430069, -0.03325365483760834, 0.015009434893727303, -0.03197845444083214, 0.02548549696803093, -0.02876845747232437, 0.03381814807653427, -0.00899067148566246, -0.003956370055675507, -0.04437415674328804, 0.017511995509266853, 0.05370619148015976, 0.07074103504419327, 0.012854086235165596, -0.026209203526377678, 0.02011134661734104, -0.02712140791118145, -0.032951898872852325, -0.0006031577358953655, -0.007439024746417999, -0.020381124690175056, 0.00790295097976923, 0.018470074981451035, 0.056214794516563416, -0.015719791874289513, -0.09902950376272202, 0.004656688310205936, -0.018041511997580528, 0.007288801483809948, 0.04530543088912964, -0.017871228978037834, 0.05834782123565674, -0.12495016306638718, 0.024676784873008728, -0.05160277336835861, 0.014280268922448158, -0.013394302688539028, 0.023960743099451065, 0.03682264685630798, 0.10036962479352951, 0.07315938919782639, 0.02320772409439087, 0.02636723220348358, 0.00599261187016964, 0.014303126372396946, 0.02401473931968212, -0.09900958091020584, -0.004022542852908373, 0.02012435719370842, -0.06304590404033661, -0.007365826051682234, -0.02563055232167244, 0.013975260779261589, -0.018347779288887978, 0.04400654882192612, -0.04471205174922943, 0.017246391624212265, 0.007313520181924105, -0.051145877689123154, -0.020502343773841858, 0.04767816141247749, -0.05222548171877861, 0.016089024022221565, -0.07253631949424744, 0.016467897221446037, 0.005566560197621584, 0.022405754774808884, -0.021195147186517715, -0.036290913820266724, 0.010610421188175678, 0.0035468335263431072, -0.06837208569049835, 0.028581570833921432, 0.004955405369400978, -0.027732567861676216, 0.004215149208903313, 0.06900154054164886, -0.05484818294644356, 0.011820471845567226, -0.028500115498900414, 0.003865395439788699, -0.011974608525633812, -0.03080739639699459, -0.0259869322180748, 0.021559862419962883, 0.03236840292811394, 0.034782081842422485, 0.01565440371632576, -0.05732746794819832, 0.00030540095758624375, 0.036960866302251816, 0.005513932090252638, 0.018721645697951317, -0.000903105887118727, -0.03456494212150574, 0.03167342022061348, 0.056321434676647186, 0.05513599514961243, -0.0027950231451541185, 0.06535130739212036, -0.027992824092507362, -0.06533937901258469, -0.04988551139831543, -0.01467747613787651, 0.07374753057956696, 0.058465875685214996, 0.028924303129315376, 0.0228075310587883, -0.04053482785820961, 0.008161704055964947, 0.07910390198230743, 0.034442026168107986, 0.014025291427969933, -0.05994941294193268, 0.04195389151573181, 0.013277922756969929, -0.044697411358356476, 0.01156492531299591, 0.03142973780632019, -0.10317330807447433, 0.05585886165499687, -0.012094568461179733, -0.03275936469435692, -0.000673934118822217, -0.03782656788825989, 0.029211310669779778, -0.003205380169674754, 0.031251370906829834, -0.05160237103700638, -0.018317755311727524, 0.02465081959962845, 0.06473414599895477, -0.019838687032461166, -0.01733105070888996, -0.004129832144826651, 0.039692528545856476, 0.044047191739082336, -0.032974667847156525, -0.018326180055737495, 0.0018913198728114367, -0.036427050828933716, 0.1063021793961525, -0.01856856420636177, -0.01870056614279747, 0.06719162315130234, -0.02006412297487259, -0.009962457232177258, -0.002810501726344228, -0.0046949731186032295, -0.013595499098300934, -0.049012597650289536, 0.0058283135294914246, -0.05757799744606018, -0.02542409487068653, -0.010474048554897308, 0.01610056310892105, -0.05608462914824486, -0.05291127786040306, -0.028681671246886253, -0.02486989088356495, -0.06658009439706802, -0.006485860329121351, 0.0006237392080947757, -0.03288445249199867, -0.05108901858329773, -0.03370486944913864, 0.029516661539673805, 0.012320675887167454, 0.012004240415990353, -0.03464408591389656, 0.032897453755140305, -0.03072657249867916, 0.0029734959825873375, 0.037456560879945755, -0.0007535548647865653, -0.009257656522095203, 0.009267649613320827, -0.042943939566612244, 0.00025752646615728736, 0.002367790322750807, -0.019191477447748184, 0.00292786443606019, -0.01832115650177002, 0.06213841587305069, 0.029060687869787216, -0.004120337776839733, 0.039929404854774475, -0.0323714055120945, -0.04697057977318764, -0.027928423136472702, -0.05367103964090347, 0.02500465326011181, 0.00768533768132329, -0.03928051516413689, 0.00612060958519578, 0.02012365683913231, 0.04859807714819908, 0.01920599490404129, -0.0032528946176171303, 0.034409940242767334, 0.013105927035212517, 0.019080977886915207, 0.014285016804933548, -0.003031252883374691, 0.0035876897163689137, 0.007673538289964199, -0.012516969814896584, 0.034133683890104294, 0.0214503426104784, 0.02110876888036728, 0.022513970732688904, -0.024409055709838867, 0.009717949666082859, 0.06377045810222626, 0.01879590004682541, -0.06440737843513489, 0.005068228580057621, 0.01535284798592329, 0.020683225244283676, -0.029275797307491302, 0.02242008037865162, -0.05556828901171684, -0.040029339492321014, 0.013481836766004562, 0.058645784854888916, -0.01999577321112156, 0.0043197814375162125, -0.0014508345630019903, 0.005013955757021904, -0.025590408593416214, 0.01105162501335144, -0.0388900451362133, 0.018299898132681847, 0.02040667086839676, -0.02969552017748356, 0.022477420046925545, -0.021970437839627266, -0.015358610078692436, -0.02354368567466736, -0.06225045025348663, 0.017727864906191826, -0.00032949302112683654, 0.05068232864141464, -0.0033484743908047676, 0.005494505167007446, 0.009902788326144218, 0.051412660628557205, 0.004465571604669094, -0.0012247293489053845, -0.03564339876174927, -0.008411301299929619, -0.04558560997247696, -0.016106681898236275, 0.022800201550126076, 0.01028403639793396, 0.03849630057811737, -0.0324455201625824, 0.028011124581098557, 0.021414991468191147, 0.019904598593711853, -0.0042885467410087585, -0.06427271664142609, 0.02382410503923893, -0.019671805202960968, 0.032600585371255875, 0.053735487163066864, 0.04515362158417702, -0.0009014113456942141, -0.005586602259427309, -0.008508080616593361, -0.06431598216295242, -0.0318419486284256, -0.027331925928592682, -0.024671847000718117, -0.006747545674443245, -0.026547860354185104, -0.023554092273116112, 0.03643425554037094, 0.05329813063144684, 0.020798945799469948, -0.02547607384622097, 0.08110878616571426, -0.017263660207390785, -0.0017517205560579896, -0.01024510245770216, -0.07457945495843887, 0.01465750951319933, -0.0030814488418400288, 0.02680857665836811, -0.03092566877603531, -0.05870973318815231, -0.035415470600128174, -0.04872838780283928, -0.05614038556814194, 0.008378298953175545, -0.03217419236898422, -0.019078418612480164, -0.015894604846835136, -0.020112507045269012, -0.00793103314936161, -0.04335685446858406, 0.01327451504766941, 0.014163648709654808, 0.040842197835445404, 0.008026566356420517, 0.08799378573894501, -0.03163484111428261, -0.016650740057229996, -0.046908434480428696, 0.04051145166158676, 0.013033660128712654, 0.06688812375068665, -0.011297826655209064, -0.008184004575014114, 0.04012467712163925, 0.02151554450392723, 0.013577982783317566, -0.02089967578649521, -0.005501228850334883, -0.05429089814424515, 0.07197664678096771, 0.050714291632175446, 0.007409595884382725, -0.0458650216460228, 0.01165608037263155, -0.028291452676057816, -0.04120028018951416, -0.04113716632127762, 0.02152807079255581, 0.033016037195920944, -0.011250252835452557, -0.04351971298456192, -0.031970735639333725, -0.0034871832467615604, 0.039075467735528946 ]
<p>Usually what helps me understand a concept better in physics is to write a simulation of it. I've got to the point where I'm competent in the basics of special relativity, but, I can't figure out how to write a relativistic simulation! My normal approach in Newtonian mechanics is just to attach two objects together with a hookean spring force, maybe add a damping effect, and then just to use the calculated force to get acceleration, and numerically integrate over that.</p> <p>The first issue is length contraction. The issue isn't as easy as a contraction of $1/\gamma$. If I have two point events simultaneous in some reference frame, corresponding to locations of masses connected by a spring, I do know their spacelike separation, which is an invariant. However, even though the proper length is invariant, if I change reference frames, the events are no longer simultaneous, so I can't really get a consistent definition from this... I figured that I could apply the spring force instantaneously, "faster than light", and show how when I do that that leads to violation of causality, but I can't even define force consistently!</p> <p>I understand that if I use a wave equation or some sort of electromagnetic force, then I can have a force field that transforms correctly, but I really don't want to do this, because I'm not great at electromagnetism, and this is really just for me to better my understanding of special relativity. Plus it would be difficult computationally.</p> <p>I haven't been able to make any headway on assuming that the masses are connected by a chain of springs, whose velocities relative to each other are $&lt;&lt;c$, but I think the solution may lie there.</p>
g4274
[ 0.07790176570415497, -0.018363405019044876, -0.01109260506927967, -0.018638698384165764, 0.04507127404212952, -0.0171449463814497, 0.03208298608660698, 0.06610145419836044, -0.03216509893536568, -0.018513092771172523, 0.014492671005427837, -0.04228590056300163, 0.004221465904265642, -0.009604580700397491, 0.01995564065873623, 0.019647805020213127, 0.09308294206857681, -0.02178126759827137, 0.013938546180725098, 0.028264036402106285, 0.05844741687178612, 0.002843389520421624, 0.01532317977398634, -0.021280711516737938, -0.0005410368903540075, 0.04523925110697746, 0.028191449120640755, -0.02144736237823963, -0.05073678120970726, -0.02979324385523796, -0.019962569698691368, -0.03323264420032501, 0.014254636131227016, -0.028380703181028366, 0.005749917589128017, -0.006572524551302195, -0.004853836260735989, -0.0010424369247630239, 0.010077393613755703, -0.010675672441720963, 0.00796645786613226, -0.027739113196730614, 0.004179403651505709, -0.022740554064512253, 0.04806283116340637, -0.04454674944281578, 0.03515029698610306, -0.009354294277727604, 0.027692357078194618, -0.0168088898062706, -0.002792700193822384, 0.05429220199584961, 0.01070184726268053, -0.02963484823703766, 0.006337494123727083, 0.04601708799600601, 0.007635010872036219, 0.03156687319278717, 0.05470716953277588, 0.025666620582342148, 0.008201928809285164, 0.004061056766659021, 0.016271864995360374, 0.003749031340703368, 0.03682440146803856, 0.11890405416488647, -0.024858789518475533, 0.008018268272280693, -0.010618860833346844, -0.015461239032447338, -0.050609689205884933, -0.023586630821228027, 0.031073149293661118, -0.00928335078060627, -0.05244967341423035, -0.0036285356618463993, -0.02620197832584381, 0.011263486929237843, -0.01584838330745697, -0.0175289586186409, -0.010929051786661148, 0.01188758946955204, 0.04753778502345085, -0.02444477565586567, 0.06495735794305801, -0.001707103569060564, -0.02825157903134823, -0.004889108706265688, -0.0373588465154171, -0.024159297347068787, 0.060429781675338745, -0.01526565756648779, 0.05383702367544174, 0.04450622946023941, -0.024984953925013542, -0.04577155411243439, -0.03402280807495117, 0.08117562532424927, 0.05484805628657341, 0.0031242421828210354, -0.06325916200876236, 0.044357966631650925, -0.030260222032666206, -0.006682801991701126, -0.03884085267782211, -0.018345458433032036, -0.002128936816006899, 0.06590394675731659, 0.005109910387545824, -0.05249934643507004, -0.059334646910429, -0.05479435250163078, -0.019857848063111305, -0.036412809044122696, -0.057690151035785675, -0.07847686111927032, 0.03128159046173096, -0.019641872495412827, -0.010282984003424644, 0.01672404631972313, -0.06580322235822678, 0.01985778659582138, 0.02391323447227478, 0.073004812002182, -0.03331196680665016, -0.08231831341981888, 0.008904298767447472, 0.07621850073337555, 0.0241228137165308, -0.06168702244758606, 0.0044938866049051285, -0.06063724681735039, 0.021620459854602814, 0.025637244805693626, -0.03756432607769966, 0.00782577134668827, 0.01576194353401661, -0.03623092547059059, -0.03710540011525154, 0.007913863286376, 0.014451556839048862, -0.04948153346776962, -0.021457023918628693, -0.06219857558608055, -0.005300051998347044, 0.07120124250650406, -0.06373295187950134, -0.021548638120293617, 0.03408130258321762, -0.0005312416469678283, 0.015427963808178902, 0.09454096853733063, -0.06678712368011475, -0.033353596925735474, 0.05088603496551514, 0.03555179759860039, 0.04194483533501625, -0.045370448380708694, -0.03621452674269676, -0.010645318776369095, 0.05017979070544243, -0.0024413398932665586, -0.005654286593198776, -0.03794960677623749, -0.041211362928152084, 0.05656050145626068, -0.016712229698896408, -0.04834464564919472, -0.015391187742352486, -0.06587368249893188, -0.052080899477005005, -0.02457634173333645, -0.0014517520321533084, 0.0589156374335289, -0.00021424752776511014, -0.007110303733497858, 0.022321481257677078, -0.05170797184109688, -0.033978331834077835, -0.0003445585898589343, 0.021809836849570274, -0.014701995998620987, -0.004138987511396408, -0.0014674182748422027, -0.007269329857081175, 0.03378218784928322, 0.015064424835145473, 0.057714834809303284, -0.028030790388584137, -0.035383161157369614, -0.057379260659217834, -0.015514015220105648, 0.015070139430463314, 0.05071115866303444, -0.049649231135845184, 0.02013997733592987, 0.03326187655329704, -0.034213919192552567, -0.002052770694717765, 0.0431615486741066, -0.0010897709289565682, 0.0401998907327652, 0.022270796820521355, 0.0693628340959549, 0.02575027383863926, -0.0279855877161026, -0.03867705911397934, -0.00967754889279604, 0.0009695114567875862, 0.003691369667649269, 0.07461006939411163, -0.04931996017694473, 0.044516053050756454, -0.036435604095458984, -0.01475292444229126, -0.05324345454573631, -0.006109106354415417, -0.028419025242328644, -0.03649444505572319, 0.036732472479343414, -0.0372563861310482, -0.01891598105430603, 0.04748990759253502, -0.020519331097602844, -0.0882553681731224, -0.027378017082810402, -0.011268315836787224, 0.019473325461149216, 0.011265592649579048, -0.02631889283657074, -0.032250966876745224, 0.09819317609071732, -0.023024072870612144, -0.000912527902983129, 0.029630837962031364, 0.02912341058254242, -0.04521336033940315, -0.017859134823083878, -0.033355772495269775, -0.0485604964196682, 0.045003872364759445, -0.009339476004242897, 0.008834977634251118, -0.023164968937635422, 0.025736363604664803, -0.03653799369931221, 0.07957440614700317, 0.005013840738683939, -0.0072376541793346405, -0.024020090699195862, -0.054395902901887894, -0.025635110214352608, -0.0392255000770092, -0.01458006352186203, 0.040336817502975464, -0.006501451600342989, -0.01611391082406044, 0.03677907958626747, -0.06282564997673035, -0.024201972410082817, -0.007563986349850893, 0.0018062348244711757, 0.03740903362631798, 0.04443887621164322, -0.06661731749773026, -0.029552074149250984, 0.009806171990931034, -0.000959609285928309, 0.003948127385228872, -0.0057761226780712605, -0.03256795555353165, 0.0012067049974575639, 0.007399817928671837, -0.005780970212072134, 0.02714347653090954, -0.034826114773750305, -0.004932566545903683, -0.04121027886867523, 0.007182313594967127, 0.004410650115460157, -0.011534348130226135, -0.00039596212445758283, 0.0030153675470501184, 0.0056365118362009525, 0.037027791142463684, -0.09121903032064438, -0.012873622588813305, 0.008875224739313126, -0.02475237101316452, -0.03772227466106415, 0.005202410276979208, 0.07969112694263458, 0.010878445580601692, 0.0005514333606697619, 0.0013393928529694676, 0.025750789791345596, -0.03354823216795921, -0.05253130942583084, -0.02597617544233799, 0.021501054987311363, 0.014911002479493618, -0.0017750074621289968, 0.0680418461561203, 0.00969814695417881, -0.03793234005570412, 0.002178838709369302, -0.021938778460025787, -0.03141355887055397, 0.04916195943951607, -0.004235160071402788, 0.024265816435217857, 0.05097923427820206, 0.049960218369960785, -0.03158440813422203, -0.06765466928482056, -0.004389316309243441, 0.022950228303670883, -0.03484651446342468, -0.018790412694215775, -0.056688591837882996, 0.03738172724843025, -0.07222917675971985, 0.021580921486020088, -0.0034307143650949, -0.0032871870789676905, 0.0789811983704567, -0.01422739028930664, -0.006855311803519726, -0.07605043798685074, -0.01137109100818634, 0.020186772570014, -0.032742321491241455, 0.02160569466650486, 0.03423760086297989, -0.03265809640288353, -0.017947575077414513, -0.02730727382004261, 0.0020675824489444494, 0.0802152007818222, 0.023146821185946465, -0.0014831171138212085, -0.01507179718464613, -0.019247237592935562, 0.0021939771249890327, -0.0009603615035302937, 0.029701387509703636, 0.0711149275302887, 0.015578188933432102, 0.05580752715468407, -0.0490674152970314, 0.024286312982439995, -0.03580943122506142, 0.006139153148978949, -0.04580264538526535, 0.03389383479952812, -0.011296122334897518, 0.03445089980959892, -0.012178614735603333, -0.027871744707226753, 0.008386041969060898, 0.013515961356461048, 0.006934485863894224, -0.08877187967300415, 0.04132784903049469, -0.021716855466365814, -0.005539984442293644, -0.015368731692433357, 0.055727604776620865, 0.003973524551838636, -0.015518906526267529, 0.022123534232378006, -0.010857016779482365, 0.00521978922188282, -0.048037879168987274, -0.01144171692430973, -0.0748799741268158, 0.029696349054574966, -0.016239458695054054, 0.049044717103242874, -0.004777595866471529, 0.03047892637550831, 0.03703868389129639, -0.024453934282064438, 0.012292600236833096, 0.01819232478737831, 0.0302590224891901, 0.029817841947078705, -0.0006079449085518718, 0.02850496768951416, -0.02791428379714489, 0.010090421885251999, -0.07595665752887726, -0.05436364561319351, 0.0058241733349859715, 0.036147721111774445, -0.010664795525372028, 0.01968902163207531, -0.007239169906824827, -0.03559144213795662, -0.002168321516364813, -0.07852402329444885, 0.01872400753200054, 0.009288829751312733, 0.005833144765347242, -0.061048269271850586, 0.013979388400912285, 0.03455151617527008, 0.008247419260442257, -0.0022656258661299944, 0.027347100898623466, 0.04238301143050194, -0.024611473083496094, -0.00888195913285017, -0.06414365023374557, 0.03803732246160507, -0.017744021490216255, 0.009040958248078823, 0.03419548273086548, -0.0043443613685667515, 0.015202987007796764, -0.007962624542415142, 0.07123302668333054, 0.03707602620124817, -0.048503655940294266, 0.03476139158010483, 0.062872014939785, 0.025257283821702003, -0.00045330930151976645, 0.022158728912472725, -0.04477248340845108, 0.009883787482976913, 0.04950660467147827, 0.01752815954387188, -0.026854442432522774, -0.02882177010178566, 0.022144615650177002, 0.010617423802614212, 0.039238568395376205, 0.030147496610879898, 0.058126796036958694, 0.001054593245498836, 0.049684230238199234, 0.025499602779746056, -0.0031842305324971676, -0.0216218288987875, 0.032176673412323, -0.06415737420320511, -0.062061600387096405, -0.07056386023759842, 0.0013403594493865967, -0.024693656712770462, -0.0014311528066173196, -0.0034839510917663574, -0.018034348264336586, 0.026134582236409187, 0.052547991275787354, -0.06065691262483597, 0.052334096282720566, 0.010782240889966488, -0.056358370929956436, -0.004470583982765675, 0.0015040449798107147, -0.013386571779847145, -0.021975625306367874, -0.0054848711006343365, -0.020609712228178978, -0.06471684575080872, -0.019576050341129303, -0.007900427095592022, 0.020490141585469246, -0.02585975080728531, -0.06567852944135666, -0.038020841777324677, -0.013135157525539398, 0.06965157389640808, 0.013671763241291046, 0.007723475806415081, 0.015724828466773033, 0.02049398608505726, 0.0056759631261229515, -0.03690715879201889, -0.0013026102678850293, 0.01081594917923212, 0.009819460101425648, 0.0050345854833722115, 0.000645580468699336, 0.00021459943673107773, 0.04217324033379555, 0.04125797003507614, -0.0012036196421831846, 0.012365729548037052, -0.0014565158635377884, -0.020353661850094795, -0.023171721026301384, 0.0003938594600185752, 0.0325053408741951, 0.009893563576042652, 0.022359231486916542, -0.03591040521860123, -0.0373539999127388, -0.10145079344511032, 0.03680368885397911, 0.030099907889962196, 0.017902351915836334, -0.023339426144957542, 0.05376487597823143, 0.026890963315963745, 0.07272041589021683, -0.02925996482372284, 0.047299422323703766, 0.01639988087117672, 0.061506930738687515, 0.02472759410738945, -0.03296205773949623, 0.007757734041661024, 0.006948667578399181, 0.040229860693216324, 0.005314144771546125, -0.033488765358924866, -0.10157942771911621, 0.043237484991550446, -0.002741920528933406, 0.010324683971703053, -0.030451081693172455, 0.03743117302656174, -0.002047636080533266, -0.015723980963230133, -0.002969475230202079, -0.03090669959783554, -0.040416136384010315, -0.025706451386213303, -0.030590271577239037, 0.014556029811501503, -0.036403167992830276, -0.0095261475071311, -0.021693533286452293, 0.04477524012327194, -0.039681412279605865, -0.004323225002735853, -0.0016459840117022395, -0.05590175837278366, -0.03857242688536644, 0.024756263941526413, 0.05798051506280899, -0.053411487489938736, -0.0003813073562923819, -0.010318538174033165, 0.00984196923673153, 0.06115570291876793, -0.03679829463362694, -0.0005855901981703937, 0.00949003640562296, 0.004653597250580788, -0.008275656960904598, 0.01714974269270897, 0.0729963481426239, 0.01757984422147274, -0.05893303081393242, 0.018183374777436256, 0.053537387400865555, 0.04367033764719963, 0.011535636149346828, 0.03134987875819206, 0.04225931689143181, 0.007283252663910389, -0.02930060587823391, -0.008745995350182056, -0.04769229516386986, 0.035430703312158585, 0.026503078639507294, -0.02165578119456768, 0.008998861536383629, -0.04093872755765915, -0.00457450095564127, -0.03164853900671005, 0.047857824712991714, 0.02818487398326397, -0.004562167450785637, -0.019981779158115387, 0.006329572759568691, -0.038611192256212234, 0.03319147229194641, 0.06132938340306282, -0.0450136624276638, -0.04287852719426155, -0.013392806053161621, -0.03658737242221832, -0.015391633845865726, -0.02726714313030243, 0.004041822161525488, -0.009059752337634563, -0.024901291355490685, -0.014620351605117321, -0.04728608578443527, -0.016618356108665466, 0.01815064065158367, 0.0553937666118145, -0.019015375524759293, -0.015704208984971046, 0.09002642333507538, 0.007894818671047688, 0.04160555452108383, 0.06955786049365997, -0.07556577026844025, -0.0030310950241982937, 0.011306136846542358, -0.046945203095674515, -0.025705289095640182, 0.042268939316272736, -0.06497101485729218, -0.01667909324169159, 0.02615911141037941, -0.03095821663737297, 0.023375052958726883, 0.0162939615547657, 0.022043799981474876, 0.00894986093044281, 0.023698607459664345, 0.030664922669529915, -0.0177049208432436, 0.0470421276986599, -0.016520466655492783, 0.024828238412737846, -0.008734277449548244, 0.0017597305122762918, 0.04233080893754959, -0.048370927572250366, 0.0711427852511406, 0.025919616222381592, -0.013468991033732891, 0.029085872694849968, -0.02507363259792328, -0.04098546504974365, 0.06824750453233719, 0.034551240503787994, 0.10634485632181168, -0.010443863458931446, 0.025734776630997658, 0.03301592543721199, 0.05265764892101288, -0.0010163726983591914, 0.015535633079707623, -0.0070648822002112865, 0.04919808730483055, -0.022758033126592636, -0.0399872362613678, 0.06367701292037964, 0.007096792571246624, -0.04895079880952835, 0.00567625742405653, -0.013771389611065388, -0.018126806244254112, -0.02843482792377472, 0.030730249360203743, -0.042319584637880325, 0.03625974804162979, -0.02012677490711212, -0.00974494032561779, -0.020023975521326065, -0.028595075011253357, -0.04228121414780617, 0.01099436916410923, -0.006067355163395405, -0.055430907756090164, -0.00862217228859663, 0.05420079082250595, -0.00923668872565031, 0.010478065349161625, 0.02142326906323433, 0.03358159959316254, 0.013120478950440884, -0.024681802839040756, 0.011209990829229355, 0.054036952555179596, -0.0013740445720031857, -0.019743537530303, 0.03243398666381836, 0.04924461618065834, 0.01137540116906166, -0.01610923372209072, -0.01642512157559395, 0.07404270023107529, -0.029164159670472145, 0.03414112329483032, 0.01256320159882307, 0.03503977507352829, -0.01890605129301548, 0.06016536429524422, -0.03787842020392418, -0.016009435057640076, 0.00911632552742958, 0.03499928489327431, -0.06249101832509041, 0.03186433017253876, 0.023012526333332062, -0.0066030495800077915, 0.034721922129392624, 0.02770273946225643, 0.041435327380895615, -0.011370870284736156, -0.010906933806836605, -0.024393152445554733, 0.023530637845396996, 0.04094560071825981, 0.0015659742057323456, 0.023331480100750923, -0.08898144960403442, -0.02118629775941372, -0.009075546637177467, 0.030698318034410477, 0.008686937391757965, 0.04218507558107376, -0.03836885094642639, 0.032934609800577164, -0.031087063252925873, 0.015276758931577206, -0.02398310974240303, 0.0420188270509243, 0.05121271312236786, -0.04491449147462845, -0.045670285820961, 0.008492971770465374, -0.004454453941434622, -0.07794433832168579, 0.026244521141052246, -0.03801947087049484, 0.00728300167247653, -0.02470538020133972, -0.05446571484208107, -0.0020304727368056774, -0.02313239686191082, 0.0014042097609490156, -0.0243874192237854, 0.06682930886745453, -0.012804224155843258, 0.052242543548345566, -0.033257003873586655, -0.06580064445734024, -0.013133922591805458, 0.022802677005529404, -0.03433573618531227, -0.08172014355659485, -0.055864881724119186, -0.038892339915037155, 0.049967050552368164, -0.041290588676929474, 0.01788310706615448, 0.05610916018486023, 0.0607951283454895, 0.005036199931055307, -0.041703831404447556, 0.046971410512924194, -0.023894108831882477, -0.010330494493246078, 0.046230748295784, -0.03169308602809906, -0.016869407147169113, -0.013787523843348026, 0.04630666971206665, 0.018833834677934647, -0.01591428369283676, 0.011341391131281853, -0.05168742686510086, -0.01108633540570736, -0.009584878571331501, -0.04289434850215912, 0.044599831104278564, 0.05892738699913025 ]
<p>In one of his lecture,Prof. Susskind mentioned that the event horizon "bulges" forward to meet any incoming radiation or matter; and it is a property of Einstein field equations. I have not come across any such property, and if it exists, shouldn't it belong to the Schwarzchild metric rather? Please explain me that property in detail.</p>
g4275
[ 0.022134894505143166, 0.031007785350084305, 0.015291905030608177, -0.020770886912941933, -0.011465967632830143, 0.05480765923857689, 0.007722888141870499, 0.010972142219543457, -0.07045582681894302, -0.008237737230956554, 0.025632742792367935, -0.016152234748005867, 0.018222738057374954, 0.030206305906176567, 0.0009897530544549227, -0.04050913080573082, 0.03136212006211281, -0.027180328965187073, -0.026796413585543633, 0.0193658247590065, 0.042056892067193985, -0.02922983653843403, 0.05607214197516441, 0.03493728116154671, -0.024672845378518105, 0.05541781336069107, 0.06145991384983063, -0.014410468749701977, 0.003288112347945571, -0.05760175734758377, 0.057247087359428406, 0.078091099858284, 0.03187645971775055, -0.0233280211687088, 0.03476054221391678, -0.0010109668364748359, -0.04178682342171669, 0.01481370534747839, 0.04492834955453873, -0.007953239604830742, -0.024298736825585365, -0.0016010116087272763, 0.03512517735362053, -0.01601741649210453, 0.021740911528468132, 0.01677899993956089, -0.022913329303264618, 0.0042077223770320415, 0.03509945049881935, -0.04428242892026901, -0.050003957003355026, 0.008396067656576633, -0.0010666215093806386, -0.03830308839678764, -0.013241177424788475, -0.02296804077923298, 0.018938448280096054, 0.01334953960031271, 0.10196561366319656, 0.053101226687431335, 0.01622725836932659, -0.002969892928376794, 0.04460511356592178, -0.03338245674967766, 0.08308526873588562, 0.02062390372157097, -0.043304167687892914, -0.06592599302530289, 0.005332233849912882, 0.015781491994857788, 0.022441359236836433, 0.01776721514761448, -0.027850929647684097, -0.03200801834464073, 0.003155657323077321, 0.028683682903647423, 0.02452438324689865, 0.03766940161585808, -0.0037301259580999613, -0.03345143422484398, -0.08160524070262909, -0.03181883320212364, 0.025404291227459908, 0.03566322475671768, 0.15085384249687195, 0.022210512310266495, 0.01815740019083023, 0.016573363915085793, 0.02767355553805828, -0.016806766390800476, 0.003504484659060836, 0.01526839379221201, -0.02646266110241413, -0.04322120174765587, 0.07050851732492447, -0.03738907724618912, 0.0025669618044048548, 0.011358884163200855, -0.04097246751189232, 0.003771150717511773, -0.05146106705069542, 0.021337009966373444, 0.03331602364778519, 0.04115995764732361, -0.026309184730052948, -0.048010602593421936, -0.045071158558130264, -0.009141530841588974, 0.03568452224135399, -0.053647127002477646, -0.0006732943002134562, -0.031420208513736725, -0.032254211604595184, 0.019198721274733543, -0.06739325076341629, -0.02026345022022724, 0.033821385353803635, 0.021197305992245674, -0.01248446200042963, 0.05857196822762489, -0.019358865916728973, -0.014972520060837269, 0.017251260578632355, 0.012306097894906998, -0.031621869653463364, 0.036558814346790314, 0.007064738776534796, -0.011337674222886562, 0.011666336096823215, -0.01903517171740532, 0.03468809649348259, -0.0004259249253664166, 0.004166360944509506, -0.020698346197605133, -0.010754991322755814, 0.024079319089651108, -0.013416074216365814, 0.008038053289055824, 0.025834372267127037, 0.024110617116093636, -0.018281275406479836, -0.058265894651412964, 0.033511172980070114, -0.013452601619064808, 0.007208129856735468, 0.009182781912386417, -0.041834112256765366, 0.050453368574380875, 0.006315707229077816, -0.009608536027371883, -0.03735431283712387, 0.09612438827753067, -0.05327267199754715, -0.006983297411352396, -0.015599993988871574, 0.007786163594573736, 0.004672680050134659, -0.031381018459796906, -0.0016638266388326883, -0.014946740120649338, 0.019770704209804535, -0.0008181461016647518, 0.006833428982645273, -0.014331039041280746, 0.004871251992881298, 0.008979739621281624, 0.019037527963519096, -0.03449614718556404, -0.006523041985929012, -0.023446017876267433, -0.04765801504254341, 0.0053122928366065025, -0.026365334168076515, 0.028456425294280052, 0.005957257933914661, 0.016878023743629456, 0.018690677359700203, 0.01173107698559761, 0.03813761845231056, -0.01601138524711132, -0.08486680686473846, -0.027301425114274025, -0.01041742879897356, -0.022716067731380463, 0.04648552089929581, -0.051875460892915726, 0.01804884523153305, 0.019560091197490692, 0.029802924022078514, 0.024268077686429024, 0.009541592560708523, -0.02102186344563961, 0.006091308314353228, 0.05184714496135712, 0.05456351488828659, -0.010173717513680458, -0.0030864726286381483, 0.024735433980822563, -0.003405276918783784, 0.016024308279156685, -0.010545296594500542, 0.0504295751452446, -0.04361800476908684, -0.0052354587242007256, 0.02020513266324997, 0.05827312916517258, -0.01442169863730669, 0.04365542158484459, 0.013040094636380672, -0.027416372671723366, -0.022431207820773125, -0.06498309224843979, 0.014408971183001995, -0.03222649544477463, -0.010126658715307713, -0.017031405121088028, -0.013326501473784447, 0.01656711846590042, -0.000024681143258931115, 0.06670887023210526, -0.05260699987411499, 0.0022556425537914038, 0.010092406533658504, 0.014787597581744194, 0.003813564544543624, 0.02451835386455059, -0.0062675136141479015, 0.006210086401551962, 0.02112133987247944, -0.011988411657512188, -0.0938667580485344, 0.057296495884656906, 0.018798647448420525, -0.015119087882339954, 0.09779541194438934, -0.023603877052664757, 0.05698070302605629, 0.009114043787121773, 0.04400975629687309, -0.014362829737365246, -0.031148314476013184, 0.0054376013576984406, -0.05657265707850456, 0.016371704638004303, 0.06760773062705994, 0.030498579144477844, 0.037715595215559006, 0.034411877393722534, -0.006188182160258293, 0.0028033163398504257, 0.01546172983944416, -0.05445967987179756, -0.014973068609833717, 0.015872886404395103, -0.00809446070343256, 0.013469374738633633, -0.007193419616669416, 0.011862278915941715, -0.08734507113695145, -0.04099276661872864, -0.004925658460706472, -0.03418963775038719, 0.04704265296459198, -0.018647564575076103, -0.11120536923408508, 0.010524725541472435, -0.03862015902996063, 0.01361850369721651, -0.062171246856451035, 0.008243675343692303, -0.026475656777620316, 0.029994551092386246, 0.011444555595517159, 0.05426793172955513, -0.03334782272577286, 0.04358696565032005, 0.002339641097933054, 0.020953001454472542, 0.07648143917322159, -0.012823482975363731, -0.0722859725356102, -0.011947257444262505, -0.03902005776762962, -0.01162409782409668, -0.012503053061664104, -0.06003544107079506, -0.005550161469727755, 0.047640394419431686, 0.0356198288500309, -0.01541269849985838, 0.005412735976278782, 0.0384943000972271, 0.055766742676496506, 0.021537071093916893, 0.03534574806690216, 0.0434303916990757, -0.008517097681760788, -0.005508291069418192, 0.003589675296097994, 0.0068434737622737885, -0.00533684529364109, -0.06232958659529686, 0.028275106102228165, -0.05020737648010254, -0.012730914168059826, -0.001394439721480012, 0.0063967215828597546, -0.03316077962517738, -0.01734498143196106, -0.05481993034482002, -0.024492794647812843, 0.04192085191607475, -0.0004615705693140626, 0.013497462496161461, -0.008562691509723663, -0.01499700453132391, 0.05739479139447212, -0.01997147500514984, 0.008936806581914425, 0.00127069978043437, -0.0019075105665251613, 0.021811215206980705, -0.01397010963410139, 0.007887620478868484, 0.04480360820889473, -0.006779744755476713, -0.0244931448251009, 0.031460050493478775, -0.03112587332725525, 0.01568041555583477, 0.012020955793559551, -0.03913961350917816, 0.06319140642881393, 0.018155701458454132, 0.0025953445583581924, -0.017909418791532516, -0.007179799489676952, 0.06059148162603378, 0.049016520380973816, -0.008369222283363342, 0.01936311647295952, -0.028191328048706055, 0.012504181824624538, 0.02193492278456688, -0.05519848316907883, 0.012423979118466377, 0.017133891582489014, -0.04299382492899895, 0.039334338158369064, -0.002050817711278796, 0.006132073234766722, 0.03690572828054428, 0.0108489403501153, -0.03645532950758934, 0.07730279117822647, -0.03717252239584923, 0.044816117733716965, -0.002164181089028716, 0.05798817798495293, -0.03555998578667641, 0.0071845026686787605, -0.06906362622976303, -0.039474472403526306, 0.0058082593604922295, -0.02517051063477993, -0.09067773818969727, 0.014215678907930851, 0.06106638163328171, -0.010173361748456955, -0.013203607872128487, 0.01590133272111416, 0.022814642637968063, -0.012679900974035263, 0.07294225692749023, 0.022552402690052986, -0.08347319811582565, -0.012516997754573822, 0.010708944872021675, -0.05169828608632088, -0.04979056864976883, 0.04218180850148201, 0.012538203969597816, 0.03292325884103775, 0.01765003614127636, -0.05260263383388519, 0.018932117149233818, -0.0494353212416172, -0.03488020971417427, -0.020131494849920273, -0.012157785706222057, 0.00692230137065053, -0.027613194659352303, 0.00352701754309237, -0.06249639391899109, 0.015188474208116531, -0.01863694190979004, 0.00935855507850647, -0.001293782377615571, -0.0070929257199168205, 0.03385261818766594, 0.04062267392873764, 0.014884348027408123, 0.04108445346355438, 0.004759315401315689, -0.01013624481856823, 0.019624128937721252, 0.0426509790122509, -0.008234265260398388, -0.021455654874444008, 0.03758709505200386, 0.05424802377820015, -0.0036902085412293673, -0.04821767657995224, -0.027068762108683586, 0.05568145960569382, 0.013683262281119823, 0.03155868500471115, -0.015889111906290054, 0.05480363592505455, -0.032072462141513824, 0.006276257801800966, 0.004864916671067476, -0.012825141660869122, 0.0315970815718174, -0.0561756007373333, 0.05494369566440582, 0.030700666829943657, 0.011433849111199379, -0.07574062794446945, 0.029692092910408974, -0.020930882543325424, 0.014445359818637371, -0.01745736598968506, 0.04879559203982353, -0.06478307396173477, 0.049211546778678894, -0.055391326546669006, 0.0039319973438978195, -0.03659072890877724, 0.010558562353253365, 0.03862116113305092, -0.01654146797955036, 0.0038183405995368958, -0.040800947695970535, 0.05563631281256676, 0.08284293860197067, -0.004851413890719414, -0.03423060104250908, -0.06439827382564545, 0.013746204786002636, -0.006300936918705702, -0.004910002462565899, -0.005190395750105381, 0.015244610607624054, 0.028693130239844322, -0.004233359359204769, -0.052512187510728836, 0.04018167033791542, 0.03634725138545036, -0.031147237867116928, 0.048081181943416595, -0.043608658015728, 0.11065427958965302, 0.04564952105283737, 0.0307965949177742, -0.041730690747499466, -0.07931952178478241, -0.020024701952934265, -0.04259074479341507, 0.11298614740371704, -0.04206490516662598, 0.045020200312137604, -0.028464529663324356, 0.017648255452513695, -0.047111500054597855, 0.06918582320213318, -0.033103566616773605, -0.02025413140654564, -0.0645563080906868, -0.08079376816749573, -0.03985371068120003, 0.014572267420589924, -0.0023758478928357363, 0.018027177080512047, -0.07372945547103882, 0.04068379104137421, -0.035489123314619064, 0.03235289081931114, 0.01789417862892151, -0.04327511042356491, -0.012440738268196583, -0.021035419777035713, 0.0431467704474926, -0.0023391135036945343, -0.04983137920498848, 0.0006886683404445648, 0.027907514944672585, -0.040320541709661484, -0.006702251732349396, -0.03834160044789314, -0.05460184067487717, -0.03998498246073723, 0.010336522944271564, -0.010845420882105827, -0.04119837284088135, 0.0748327299952507, 0.05376216396689415, 0.011036315932869911, -0.028953958302736282, 0.03980681672692299, -0.0173611119389534, -0.009109548293054104, 0.02254432439804077, -0.011729956604540348, 0.005545042455196381, -0.06830718368291855, 0.02623670920729637, -0.030082188546657562, 0.03498595207929611, -0.037963733077049255, -0.01842489466071129, 0.029360728338360786, 0.04148118197917938, 0.043517909944057465, 0.02824692614376545, -0.0025223807897418737, -0.05010112375020981, 0.012900935485959053, 0.028994562104344368, 0.05259527638554573, -0.001429691561497748, -0.03573109209537506, 0.008838469162583351, 0.0147943627089262, 0.08404907584190369, 0.011143737472593784, 0.001126722781918943, 0.07094769924879074, 0.0021905689500272274, -0.03700421750545502, -0.007585042156279087, -0.05197863653302193, 0.019349856302142143, 0.0487377867102623, 0.01984267868101597, 0.042597733438014984, -0.04395556077361107, 0.07712340354919434, 0.030620520934462547, -0.05512361600995064, -0.026575634256005287, 0.00631213653832674, -0.02735716663300991, 0.01847790740430355, -0.035992175340652466, 0.013791803270578384, 0.013681753538548946, -0.039427757263183594, -0.06495670974254608, -0.04578963667154312, -0.00725170923396945, -0.011289477348327637, -0.030117634683847427, -0.02684384398162365, -0.019556734710931778, -0.04003148153424263, 0.051286958158016205, -0.04112118482589722, 0.061776623129844666, -0.007913717068731785, -0.008976995013654232, -0.010856128297746181, 0.01831253245472908, -0.036327946931123734, -0.025162266567349434, -0.046595703810453415, 0.027303844690322876, 0.002964939456433058, 0.0133420554921031, 0.015519186854362488, 0.012326551601290703, 0.04186603054404259, 0.10887045413255692, -0.0959700271487236, 0.008722362108528614, -0.019397469237446785, -0.07171480357646942, 0.05464370548725128, 0.044230151921510696, -0.020905474200844765, 0.020185692235827446, -0.035339560359716415, 0.004632116761058569, -0.058443907648324966, -0.08034929633140564, 0.008946702815592289, -0.028535248711705208, 0.014369443990290165, -0.08821263164281845, -0.06849217414855957, -0.032312024384737015, 0.018686452880501747, 0.04306613281369209, -0.03677699342370033, 0.053352031856775284, 0.003167212475091219, -0.008209990337491035, 0.04837962985038757, 0.03618329390883446, 0.003314804984256625, -0.05254734680056572, 0.0021822776179760695, -0.011190079152584076, 0.019060472026467323, -0.014361847192049026, 0.01952465809881687, 0.033601269125938416, 0.0047302632592618465, -0.0312562994658947, -0.07615430653095245, 0.06079619377851486, -0.00679977610707283, 0.02056005597114563, -0.013468076474964619, -0.0005688536330126226, -0.025357386097311974, -0.03796812519431114, 0.025226565077900887, -0.05078345537185669, 0.02891545370221138, -0.006280140019953251, 0.025368327274918556, -0.022214610129594803, 0.018176725134253502, 0.010035214945673943, 0.018157226964831352, -0.008983196690678596, 0.012826117686927319, 0.009370739571750164, 0.0005938537651672959, 0.03071628510951996, 0.0007119514630176127, 0.003394749714061618, -0.0026629737112671137, -0.06483086198568344, 0.021925149485468864, 0.009549657814204693, -0.0069527458399534225, -0.07365192472934723, -0.04603401571512222, 0.04485383629798889, 0.004328322596848011, -0.023696450516581535, 0.004056290723383427, -0.03943445160984993, -0.055071644484996796, -0.039254289120435715, -0.018350446596741676, 0.05583447217941284, -0.0685252919793129, -0.014799089170992374, -0.016893308609724045, -0.00009591277921572328, -0.01911911740899086, -0.03933399170637131, 0.004876682069152594, 0.04554488882422447, -0.00940756592899561, 0.0032640816643834114, 0.03585660830140114, 0.012629322707653046, 0.00010910732817137614, -0.06095989793539047, -0.04219730943441391, -0.03872641548514366, -0.01813095062971115, -0.049393292516469955, 0.08484470099210739, 0.0659889280796051, -0.026843367144465446, 0.013981488533318043, 0.07559533417224884, -0.03129951283335686, 0.011598875746130943, -0.04614812880754471, 0.06948381662368774, -0.014282578602433205, 0.009549351409077644, 0.03100295551121235, -0.018218494951725006, -0.002800154499709606, 0.03587070479989052, -0.0019275561207905412, -0.07135529816150665, 0.0208087507635355, -0.00933101586997509, -0.025315692648291588, 0.04355942830443382, -0.03197207301855087, -0.002435583621263504, -0.028236014768481255, -0.00426786532625556, -0.023543383926153183, 0.02115924283862114, 0.010861311107873917, 0.004312565084546804, -0.0038033705204725266, -0.017752349376678467, -0.040585845708847046, 0.06193118542432785, 0.014407056383788586, 0.019931508228182793, -0.00030503878952004015, -0.02833320014178753, -0.0319819413125515, -0.0057740421034395695, -0.026012901216745377, 0.013279717415571213, -0.0072730835527181625, -0.0740480124950409, 0.02136014960706234, -0.021893927827477455, -0.05498377978801727, 0.0040091536939144135, 0.045078396797180176, 0.006525516044348478, -0.023967666551470757, -0.04612839221954346, 0.009159525856375694, -0.04402921348810196, 0.021960364654660225, -0.005855553317815065, -0.005261177197098732, 0.005113211926072836, -0.04615721479058266, 0.025252966210246086, 0.04246560484170914, -0.04043322801589966, 0.011008117347955704, 0.011222578585147858, 0.04567450284957886, 0.0044609904289245605, 0.009011783637106419, -0.03690222278237343, -0.022839747369289398, -0.020270060747861862, 0.013367685489356518, 0.038758743554353714, 0.07858610153198242, -0.021990079432725906, -0.013046241365373135, 0.0570622943341732, -0.0027085987385362387, -0.003605029545724392, 0.025263778865337372, 0.00814520288258791, -0.0076115126721560955, -0.01146518811583519, 0.005437043495476246, -0.002047149930149317, -0.008216575719416142, -0.009998428635299206, 0.00719456048682332, -0.006868597120046616, -0.01097477599978447, 0.004276919178664684, 0.0064995805732905865, 0.033754486590623856 ]
<p>I notice a $2\pi$ term in the $\delta$-function when trying to construct an amplitude using the Feynman Rules. The $2\pi$ also appears as an integration measure to enforce normalisation in the phase space, what is the origin of this $2\pi$ term? Where does it come from? </p>
g4276
[ 0.0668216347694397, 0.012794341892004013, -0.007499820087105036, -0.0318782739341259, 0.05544949322938919, 0.0206493828445673, 0.030266890302300453, 0.06051192432641983, -0.0587167926132679, -0.04530901089310646, -0.08073414117097855, 0.04356934875249863, -0.015517455525696278, -0.0005626008496619761, 0.02986655943095684, -0.02738916501402855, -0.036847248673439026, 0.014404768124222755, 0.06554669141769409, -0.034018754959106445, -0.044783446937799454, -0.034351054579019547, 0.016936855390667915, -0.04725043475627899, 0.03846084326505661, -0.024010546505451202, 0.0070768664591014385, -0.006982830818742514, -0.04538990557193756, -0.071311816573143, 0.026069415733218193, 0.02652771770954132, 0.03236345946788788, -0.06147618964314461, -0.03044157661497593, 0.011388587765395641, 0.034085240215063095, 0.06411000341176987, 0.028173821046948433, 0.033174436539411545, -0.011700144968926907, -0.021925877779722214, -0.0031174232717603445, -0.02907656319439411, -0.007164337672293186, 0.0012666131369769573, 0.00017924657731782645, -0.0013843841152265668, -0.08445490151643753, -0.013831202872097492, -0.023532051593065262, -0.01639229618012905, 0.12011481821537018, -0.0018575850408524275, -0.0021165560465306044, -0.017092011868953705, 0.01721111126244068, -0.05707157030701637, 0.06764095276594162, 0.03168100491166115, -0.008178867399692535, -0.03624529764056206, 0.06071964651346207, 0.03579877316951752, 0.08802145719528198, -0.0686817467212677, 0.005317640025168657, -0.010289294645190239, -0.020945750176906586, 0.08659904450178146, 0.018233928829431534, -0.09972357749938965, 0.019104070961475372, -0.03254528343677521, -0.009845583699643612, -0.017355989664793015, 0.012062051333487034, -0.01790432259440422, 0.062051936984062195, -0.013567169196903706, -0.03096272237598896, -0.01837828755378723, -0.0002541743451729417, 0.04223041236400604, 0.07380715757608414, -0.0344170480966568, 0.021229801699519157, -0.015037846751511097, 0.004920072853565216, 0.049641311168670654, 0.03187117725610733, -0.01445083413273096, 0.00254120584577322, -0.03509718179702759, -0.04236968979239464, -0.02541087567806244, -0.0029962616972625256, 0.01614522747695446, -0.02217278629541397, -0.0028585337568074465, -0.029041875153779984, 0.07107946276664734, 0.02357524260878563, 0.02758035622537136, -0.020261473953723907, 0.10690458863973618, 0.013095155358314514, -0.007245712913572788, 0.036553382873535156, -0.010112414136528969, -0.05742073431611061, 0.018251169472932816, -0.042040299624204636, -0.05365336686372757, 0.009581645019352436, 0.017094405367970467, 0.03027508407831192, -0.05252038687467575, 0.014794082380831242, 0.046514105051755905, 0.043605025857686996, -0.05254095047712326, 0.06094232574105263, 0.004857007879763842, 0.00845527183264494, 0.03071620501577854, -0.04930226132273674, 0.05126901715993881, 0.06273940205574036, -0.00735287182033062, 0.03922894597053528, 0.030884074047207832, -0.032762594521045685, 0.02496163174510002, -0.01905856840312481, -0.033315058797597885, 0.016525069251656532, -0.061421267688274384, 0.012506936676800251, -0.01027524471282959, -0.056885913014411926, -0.01741531491279602, 0.01523987390100956, -0.05057081952691078, -0.019785625860095024, -0.03468417748808861, 0.05189012736082077, -0.05580257251858711, -0.0034052326809614897, 0.00295961438678205, -0.01227562129497528, 0.08301310241222382, -0.038088422268629074, -0.00982141587883234, 0.010077329352498055, -0.01121414452791214, 0.10685336589813232, 0.028564760461449623, 0.02719939313828945, -0.015048758126795292, 0.05852360278367996, -0.004132902715355158, -0.03033214993774891, -0.012840746901929379, -0.051579125225543976, -0.0038068662397563457, 0.022684738039970398, -0.02906719036400318, -0.02833973802626133, 0.021456506103277206, -0.0013611697359010577, -0.013126788660883904, -0.01341418456286192, 0.008988771587610245, 0.015843721106648445, 0.0753822848200798, -0.039520617574453354, -0.005359086208045483, 0.07265420258045197, 0.000623087864369154, -0.055255331099033356, -0.0009852525545284152, -0.012346696108579636, -0.049643803387880325, 0.02020758017897606, -0.022009318694472313, 0.030815524980425835, 0.01609344780445099, -0.04152095690369606, 0.02469160594046116, -0.039937667548656464, 0.006177969742566347, 0.021333754062652588, 0.005577177740633488, -0.0031378206331282854, -0.009015049785375595, -0.0013971528969705105, -0.05730073153972626, 0.006625885143876076, 0.03814789280295372, 0.007908894680440426, 0.016012515872716904, 0.04284283146262169, -0.07972945272922516, 0.03475088253617287, 0.026423323899507523, 0.00009971707913791761, 0.030097806826233864, 0.005850324872881174, 0.05459428206086159, -0.015808217227458954, 0.007276945281773806, 0.030760271474719048, 0.03510243445634842, 0.023994533345103264, -0.031036820262670517, 0.01711297035217285, 0.015332779847085476, 0.004264635033905506, 0.023478152230381966, 0.004694766830652952, -0.03623681887984276, 0.03925858438014984, -0.021735697984695435, 0.03900747001171112, 0.03347524628043175, -0.007339654956012964, 0.003828240791335702, -0.04425239562988281, 0.010618551634252071, -0.04151460900902748, -0.00569232227280736, -0.024490155279636383, 0.053936637938022614, 0.01580570638179779, 0.0038827762473374605, -0.016408249735832214, -0.005499131511896849, 0.015120120719075203, 0.03308241069316864, -0.05239766463637352, 0.013304676860570908, 0.018700823187828064, -0.013720587827265263, -0.0170931126922369, -0.01626737415790558, 0.02266119047999382, 0.07207896560430527, -0.06324733048677444, 0.017561720684170723, -0.030410146340727806, -0.041566673666238785, 0.012298052199184895, -0.025561193004250526, -0.019280297681689262, -0.030388785526156425, -0.026505202054977417, 0.0042559015564620495, 0.016260575503110886, -0.06246193125844002, 0.03337942808866501, 0.019463269039988518, 0.014544150792062283, 0.013428552076220512, 0.011674025095999241, -0.05676824226975441, 0.011424697935581207, 0.009544452652335167, 0.05015825107693672, 0.00557870976626873, -0.06333839148283005, 0.03819579258561134, -0.020816821604967117, 0.011938958428800106, 0.007192403078079224, -0.015107398852705956, 0.007266230881214142, -0.014151613228023052, 0.06417855620384216, 0.016679439693689346, -0.033622436225414276, -0.045412708073854446, -0.04365536943078041, 0.01810743287205696, -0.006533886771649122, -0.033842783421278, -0.02020021341741085, 0.045446448028087616, -0.039653316140174866, -0.011998491361737251, -0.012253133580088615, -0.011056211777031422, -0.018168484792113304, -0.007244011387228966, -0.013140874914824963, -0.021741610020399094, -0.008931024000048637, -0.03312266618013382, 0.0109139084815979, 0.047687068581581116, 0.009240367449820042, 0.006522280164062977, 0.0007708339835517108, -0.05564189702272415, -0.005823277402669191, -0.03637738525867462, -0.003961448557674885, -0.02457825466990471, -0.03265365958213806, 0.0032492722384631634, -0.009434431791305542, 0.029260966926813126, 0.004332296550273895, 0.040022145956754684, -0.03022070787847042, 0.026630824431777, 0.011354467831552029, 0.05291280150413513, 0.029472818598151207, 0.0010329119395464659, -0.06543156504631042, -0.05198260024189949, 0.0249039139598608, 0.041985396295785904, 0.06967049837112427, -0.038647472858428955, 0.007586730178445578, 0.008975434117019176, -0.005308825522661209, -0.05222684144973755, 0.05218872055411339, -0.03708178922533989, -0.004635718185454607, 0.01761416159570217, -0.04444088041782379, -0.05261959880590439, -0.0031070776749402285, 0.007259815465658903, -0.03383621573448181, 0.04248819500207901, -0.0020228130742907524, -0.022762933745980263, 0.026793254539370537, -0.018902920186519623, 0.04284317418932915, -0.0664970651268959, 0.020498547703027725, 0.06872356683015823, 0.02314828708767891, 0.010054760612547398, -0.006241321563720703, -0.00324942241422832, 0.05682335048913956, 0.011553928256034851, -0.012643435969948769, 0.011191287077963352, 0.02808205969631672, -0.03958848491311073, 0.012299137189984322, -0.06561397016048431, -0.003954007290303707, -0.0019985423423349857, -0.019411183893680573, -0.004094715230166912, 0.00966735277324915, -0.057901740074157715, -0.012861343100667, 0.09556231647729874, -0.014055673032999039, -0.010402631014585495, 0.026906348764896393, 0.03776327148079872, 0.04424479976296425, 0.018604453653097153, -0.0087146470323205, -0.07276002317667007, -0.04557688534259796, 0.024182133376598358, -0.05538596957921982, 0.043690528720617294, -0.045950137078762054, 0.03465566784143448, -0.019540322944521904, 0.024357682093977928, 0.03397628292441368, -0.03279430791735649, -0.03703613951802254, 0.02528563141822815, -0.017516646534204483, -0.050867918878793716, 0.012927859090268612, 0.036280155181884766, 0.026526153087615967, -0.013636520132422447, 0.00899503193795681, -0.006137738469988108, 0.01421015989035368, 0.00009362599666928872, -0.03392576426267624, 0.035889264196157455, -0.026138335466384888, -0.023056814447045326, 0.0889195054769516, 0.029654504731297493, -0.01530812680721283, 0.00835496187210083, 0.07034599781036377, 0.016711723059415817, 0.04137028381228447, -0.07365955412387848, 0.003942585550248623, 0.01586606353521347, 0.005024359095841646, -0.005886730272322893, 0.012559761293232441, 0.010369732975959778, 0.05143040791153908, -0.018427804112434387, -0.0037967951502650976, -0.005184996873140335, -0.0071735200472176075, 0.008496753871440887, 0.032268278300762177, -0.01710745505988598, 0.00999794527888298, 0.03212416544556618, 0.05586747080087662, -0.006770148407667875, 0.015771951526403427, -0.06011106073856354, -0.012979881837964058, 0.021209189668297768, -0.006809868384152651, -0.00003359960101079196, -0.06014568358659744, -0.027873564511537552, -0.032116521149873734, 0.018831143155694008, -0.048897624015808105, 0.02264390140771866, 0.06573507934808731, -0.050968997180461884, -0.01281677559018135, -0.025131959468126297, -0.0018388647586107254, 0.009572193957865238, 0.04244540259242058, -0.04676405340433121, 0.06068258360028267, 0.009971695952117443, -0.03281938284635544, 0.036672189831733704, 0.06915762275457382, -0.07749181240797043, 0.02764018625020981, -0.029896656051278114, -0.05625992640852928, 0.02186635695397854, 0.009074471890926361, -0.05528777465224266, -0.02613525278866291, -0.05550019443035126, -0.0685766339302063, 0.0074440366588532925, 0.05167962610721588, -0.04503380134701729, -0.06093231588602066, 0.032196301966905594, -0.02325442060828209, -0.0029098850209265947, 0.02791151963174343, -0.03747205063700676, 0.030521508306264877, -0.05447090417146683, -0.008073343895375729, 0.0296022966504097, 0.000052546685765264556, 0.04850099980831146, -0.0075960285030305386, -0.06187976524233818, 0.04462852701544762, 0.005390146281570196, -0.017188113182783127, 0.022871002554893494, -0.008051968179643154, -0.007734450977295637, 0.011226081289350986, -0.06195978820323944, 0.025945691391825676, -0.07975368946790695, 0.016152050346136093, 0.06271619349718094, 0.07106780260801315, 0.03764156624674797, -0.014954783022403717, -0.021137382835149765, -0.03409662842750549, -0.03127766400575638, 0.036271221935749054, -0.0026989367324858904, -0.0387817844748497, 0.046296898275613785, -0.0358935222029686, -0.018023954704403877, -0.011265176348388195, 0.047692861407995224, -0.0037193421740084887, 0.00031348568154498935, -0.02285814844071865, 0.019299853593111038, 0.05044988542795181, -0.0022307427134364843, 0.029568200930953026, -0.029031017795205116, 0.029968062415719032, -0.011921425350010395, 0.042655158787965775, 0.0005967496545054018, -0.04536115750670433, -0.04928397014737129, 0.08100833743810654, 0.00967297051101923, -0.02066637948155403, -0.05880267918109894, 0.013261115178465843, 0.03265705704689026, 0.004918665159493685, -0.0795227438211441, 0.042990922927856445, 0.03446910157799721, -0.013000543229281902, 0.018032345920801163, -0.006028568372130394, 0.012171417474746704, -0.007646558340638876, -0.03986619412899017, -0.009167738258838654, 0.05561511963605881, -0.04430580884218216, -0.009492674842476845, -0.0029441160149872303, -0.014457715675234795, -0.001977850217372179, 0.05650944635272026, -0.001826921128667891, 0.053688548505306244, 0.05986366420984268, -0.00838126428425312, 0.01615125872194767, -0.04450156167149544, 0.031055686995387077, -0.024079250171780586, -0.033240001648664474, -0.031108492985367775, -0.02809998393058777, 0.08856078237295151, -0.015450704842805862, 0.012082183733582497, -0.04237478971481323, -0.027992475777864456, 0.04470773786306381, -0.009683141484856606, 0.008016236126422882, 0.016017401590943336, -0.0022036712616682053, -0.06981294602155685, 0.01010367926210165, 0.047881945967674255, -0.012608466669917107, 0.015551908873021603, 0.02563363127410412, 0.0252993181347847, -0.024554936215281487, 0.047345563769340515, 0.02677326835691929, 0.05506542697548866, -0.027340179309248924, -0.038403961807489395, -0.03618608042597771, -0.018827693536877632, 0.024651406332850456, 0.07075880467891693, 0.06582006812095642, -0.04537094011902809, -0.039769574999809265, 0.08222348988056183, 0.01178134884685278, 0.010332105681300163, 0.021380877122282982, 0.035178687423467636, -0.022338496521115303, -0.016400247812271118, -0.04115092754364014, -0.02981090545654297, 0.011240382678806782, -0.005804278887808323, 0.048949576914310455, -0.06467218697071075, -0.006682245992124081, -0.04391404613852501, 0.052926842123270035, -0.06274940818548203, 0.011811350472271442, -0.01397630199790001, 0.04583161324262619, 0.0063651567324995995, 0.023834411054849625, -0.06481051445007324, -0.03570914268493652, -0.006670652888715267, -0.018851596862077713, 0.0034101398196071386, -0.020109867677092552, 0.03751019015908241, -0.026825478300452232, -0.04771023616194725, 0.010436207056045532, 0.041048333048820496, -0.03410590440034866, 0.0550035759806633, 0.07412225753068924, 0.02737671323120594, 0.009798715822398663, -0.03397912532091141, 0.028233999386429787, 0.00955258309841156, -0.018976688385009766, -0.020635316148400307, 0.0034501540940254927, 0.05798116698861122, -0.02167586050927639, -0.0049438574351370335, -0.003984357230365276, -0.013705496676266193, -0.07470961660146713, -0.033603474497795105, -0.00905830878764391, 0.005789557937532663, 0.03328941762447357, 0.04011690244078636, -0.028635691851377487, 0.051759880036115646, 0.022450799122452736, -0.06370712071657181, -0.035125598311424255, 0.008778785355389118, -0.026429949328303337, -0.022458411753177643, -0.06989412009716034, 0.01539490558207035, 0.013255436904728413, 0.018995698541402817, 0.011517614126205444, 0.011015842668712139, 0.0007926254183985293, -0.03544408082962036, 0.04889742285013199, -0.00017129011393990368, 0.006649395450949669, -0.055428918451070786, -0.03629300743341446, -0.01773093082010746, -0.012398164719343185, 0.04320511966943741, -0.009155213832855225, 0.036742132157087326, 0.01003948226571083, -0.005726073402911425, -0.018302494660019875, -0.08596692979335785, 0.005410559009760618, -0.04924428462982178, -0.042652323842048645, 0.011200524866580963, 0.010032068006694317, -0.016982415691018105, 0.04165990650653839, 0.026247000321745872, -0.05771660432219505, 0.02469467744231224, 0.06000598892569542, -0.040712352842092514, -0.019187631085515022, -0.060461077839136124, 0.00008872201578924432, -0.0028529022820293903, 0.018232444301247597, -0.05339094623923302, -0.011630360968410969, 0.028958521783351898, -0.029260531067848206, 0.008354169316589832, -0.022314580157399178, -0.04109122231602669, 0.032489582896232605, 0.011927105486392975, 0.05120554193854332, 0.050916071981191635, -0.021346934139728546, 0.010247184894979, 0.030455496162176132, -0.06461168825626373, -0.03995440527796745, 0.03521500155329704, 0.07426949590444565, 0.03363058716058731, 0.06508783996105194, -0.045410316437482834, -0.06016911566257477, -0.005492114927619696, 0.030133185908198357, 0.01521824300289154, -0.008134957402944565, 0.02311413735151291, 0.007948664017021656, 0.03512449190020561, -0.06287682056427002, 0.02576996013522148, 0.06497202068567276, -0.019942494109272957, 0.05453088879585266, 0.030337054282426834, -0.024158310145139694, -0.044437773525714874, 0.027485672384500504, -0.03174345940351486, 0.018247181549668312, -0.042371999472379684, 0.025087613612413406, 0.01727486215531826, -0.04781199246644974, 0.013352110050618649, -0.03434421122074127, 0.04945288226008415, -0.00717944884672761, -0.015001977793872356, -0.004542490001767874, 0.011145766824483871, 0.003072428982704878, -0.03815879672765732, 0.0006700221565552056, -0.016873985528945923, 0.03034168668091297, -0.03132655844092369, -0.025308266282081604, -0.05276944488286972, 0.01347479596734047, 0.0058447434566915035, -0.0015362313715741038, -0.0679704025387764, -0.003861259436234832, -0.006104206666350365, -0.041669633239507675, 0.089423768222332, 0.04202916845679283, -0.053672876209020615, 0.0037288698367774487, 0.028919043019413948, -0.03850382938981056, 0.027631744742393494, 0.019945871084928513, -0.022579362615942955, 0.026333320885896683, 0.019886566326022148, -0.06655313074588776, -0.04043031483888626, 0.0008344874950125813, 0.03246833384037018 ]
<p>I've heard two different descriptions of gravity, and I'm wondering how they work together.</p> <p>The first is Gravitons:</p> <blockquote> <p>"The three other known forces of nature are mediated by elementary particles: electromagnetism by the photon, the strong interaction by the gluons, and the weak interaction by the W and Z bosons. The hypothesis is that the gravitational interaction is likewise mediated by an – as yet undiscovered – elementary particle, dubbed the graviton. In the classical limit, the theory would reduce to general relativity and conform to Newton's law of gravitation in the weak-field limit." -- <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graviton" rel="nofollow">Source</a></p> </blockquote> <p>I'll admit I don't know much about them, but I assume that they would work similarly how photons do in EM.</p> <p>The second, which I understand more, is given by GR and is that space time is curves by mass-energy, sort of how putting a heavy object on a blanket curves it.</p> <p>So, how would these work together? Would the curves space time be analogous to a "graviton field", where the more massive/energetic objects produce a stronger field which other objects are attracted to, and excitations in the field produce gravitons?</p>
g131
[ 0.05752530321478844, 0.03840438276529312, -0.0043724835850298405, 0.010275434702634811, 0.07385106384754181, 0.04930161312222481, -0.014691636897623539, -0.01512263622134924, -0.0290591511875391, -0.04790185019373894, -0.00735969515517354, -0.04223339259624481, 0.06241900101304054, -0.028207343071699142, -0.013494603335857391, -0.0018095204140990973, 0.07111389935016632, 0.04760717228055, 0.056082699447870255, 0.018557989969849586, 0.049639347940683365, 0.014525306411087513, 0.008629647083580494, -0.0903901606798172, -0.05093247815966606, 0.001278547802940011, 0.050934482365846634, -0.032209914177656174, -0.045008692890405655, -0.04619373381137848, 0.02313009649515152, 0.009548007510602474, 0.011973264627158642, -0.014329538680613041, -0.044283755123615265, -0.07546214014291763, 0.01010096911340952, 0.035363949835300446, -0.016464928165078163, -0.004778250120580196, -0.025779690593481064, 0.008966449648141861, 0.03383326157927513, 0.0012938885483890772, -0.008053786121308804, -0.01853841543197632, -0.017856545746326447, -0.0021080216392874718, 0.02852751687169075, -0.02670195885002613, -0.0244281142950058, 0.06216294318437576, -0.004132382106035948, -0.009323159232735634, -0.003152134595438838, -0.008703459054231644, 0.03997795283794403, -0.02706187590956688, 0.05759172886610031, 0.027738725766539574, -0.008745318278670311, 0.015287416987121105, 0.029691573232412338, 0.002399627584964037, 0.09160321950912476, 0.013522811233997345, -0.03188107907772064, -0.028020406141877174, 0.026752164587378502, -0.013664072379469872, -0.006953676696866751, -0.05910355970263481, -0.036109503358602524, 0.0028554105665534735, 0.050314683467149734, 0.0274631530046463, 0.005702254828065634, -0.0012895348481833935, -0.006133618764579296, -0.029652107506990433, 0.03988347575068474, -0.02872973307967186, -0.014098751358687878, -0.014565333724021912, 0.0628192350268364, -0.058869585394859314, -0.0493386909365654, -0.03092215023934841, -0.002967699896544218, 0.005943682976067066, 0.041569583117961884, -0.0062384712509810925, 0.06150100752711296, -0.0021326576825231314, -0.04690178856253624, -0.015135375782847404, 0.01077947486191988, 0.09676477313041687, -0.04721212387084961, -0.04946327582001686, -0.02588643506169319, -0.014321895316243172, 0.01791800744831562, -0.04479772970080376, 0.028539638966321945, 0.003068480407819152, 0.05541223660111427, -0.00884335022419691, 0.04078984633088112, 0.015210485085844994, -0.04146156832575798, 0.02309834398329258, 0.015379030257463455, -0.05438562482595444, -0.04518013820052147, -0.07019637525081635, 0.004083297215402126, -0.028217598795890808, 0.013125622645020485, 0.05829012021422386, -0.027943700551986694, 0.02248690277338028, 0.00952487625181675, 0.049228131771087646, -0.03227659687399864, -0.024111168459057808, 0.014900797978043556, -0.004313122946768999, 0.005224949214607477, -0.011782927438616753, 0.0351153202354908, -0.006707844324409962, -0.019768428057432175, -0.001634402316994965, 0.013527733273804188, 0.0322033055126667, 0.03628337383270264, -0.002754524815827608, -0.04725288972258568, -0.03510765731334686, 0.0007217851816676557, -0.06521372497081757, -0.021024348214268684, -0.04415363445878029, -0.03469910845160484, 0.056447193026542664, -0.027923008427023888, -0.019870825111865997, -0.0010808067163452506, -0.012074270285665989, 0.013023673556745052, 0.057195767760276794, 0.05859193950891495, -0.03937331587076187, 0.03843771293759346, 0.007935170084238052, 0.01608285866677761, -0.03988850489258766, -0.019979948177933693, 0.004087749402970076, 0.0749683529138565, -0.022992435842752457, 0.07112947106361389, 0.02118702419102192, 0.007151694968342781, 0.04921466112136841, 0.05254114046692848, -0.051575906574726105, 0.056203797459602356, -0.021320661529898643, -0.0603535957634449, -0.04035903513431549, -0.02736726403236389, 0.0745248794555664, -0.040362387895584106, 0.010455275885760784, 0.009391563013195992, -0.07091367989778519, -0.02742324396967888, -0.013961792923510075, -0.014477886259555817, -0.003617374924942851, -0.005654091481119394, 0.015161238610744476, -0.020106235519051552, 0.0006609275587834418, -0.023005209863185883, -0.023851972073316574, -0.022038113325834274, 0.019896458834409714, -0.11349744349718094, -0.03696053475141525, 0.018277250230312347, 0.05411044508218765, -0.0009411012870259583, -0.019110914319753647, 0.015328753739595413, -0.03451519459486008, -0.014910227619111538, 0.020858142524957657, -0.03542367368936539, 0.030277175828814507, 0.02571878395974636, -0.012286683544516563, 0.03933078795671463, 0.01280201692134142, -0.011081595905125141, 0.05777853727340698, -0.003601555246859789, -0.021411076188087463, 0.05489504337310791, -0.02869521640241146, 0.03553662449121475, 0.014369215816259384, -0.0525670126080513, 0.01974364183843136, -0.07150495797395706, -0.01045350730419159, 0.026830198243260384, 0.03624172881245613, 0.02092032879590988, -0.030282579362392426, 0.060397643595933914, -0.04399293661117554, -0.021953891962766647, -0.06615642458200455, -0.0433601438999176, 0.032791342586278915, 0.04403511807322502, -0.016282275319099426, -0.04171779006719589, 0.02922949753701687, -0.03129934147000313, -0.01084102876484394, 0.02700047567486763, 0.02359657548367977, 0.00702727772295475, -0.010884842835366726, -0.01185292936861515, 0.03578590601682663, 0.00913460087031126, -0.016536252573132515, 0.05002013221383095, -0.04270331934094429, 0.029871895909309387, -0.04842216521501541, 0.029605643823742867, 0.020124847069382668, 0.007037449162453413, 0.040376611053943634, 0.03688196465373039, -0.005188994575291872, -0.05729212984442711, 0.056246113032102585, -0.008730237372219563, 0.007607521954923868, 0.00648933369666338, 0.04548133537173271, -0.13379856944084167, -0.06410881131887436, 0.013124561868607998, -0.020420262590050697, -0.0016990212025120854, 0.06705812364816666, -0.01729331538081169, -0.06709858775138855, 0.00166607485152781, -0.021366875618696213, -0.04089967906475067, -0.00623858068138361, -0.10541236400604248, 0.003096096683293581, -0.010463453829288483, -0.03546210005879402, -0.012159423902630806, -0.04413584992289543, 0.01651187613606453, -0.008369486778974533, 0.005018437746912241, -0.05245580896735191, 0.01555754616856575, -0.019416149705648422, -0.006088265683501959, -0.03140987828373909, 0.0557967834174633, -0.03063354641199112, 0.008651386015117168, 0.03130018711090088, -0.026911001652479172, -0.03769329935312271, 0.04934946447610855, 0.05282929912209511, 0.0622357614338398, 0.0080260606482625, -0.06983459740877151, -0.0012079693842679262, -0.0024209304247051477, 0.02963319793343544, -0.07068292051553726, 0.016758449375629425, 0.009584423154592514, -0.02674795314669609, 0.011482647620141506, 0.061504729092121124, -0.002866138005629182, -0.053249653428792953, -0.08599842339754105, -0.03748682886362076, -0.006309188436716795, -0.02476545237004757, -0.01630493812263012, 0.035854190587997437, 0.035875704139471054, 0.018490098416805267, 0.014825955033302307, -0.0023831783328205347, -0.028885817155241966, 0.005905608646571636, -0.016651397570967674, -0.03461894392967224, -0.03752347081899643, -0.008824373595416546, 0.014177948236465454, -0.06386006623506546, -0.03628069534897804, 0.04713539779186249, -0.01856144517660141, -0.031095638871192932, -0.06887056678533554, 0.000649119378067553, 0.021642282605171204, -0.015910666435956955, -0.057154614478349686, 0.042203254997730255, -0.039909906685352325, 0.06536193937063217, 0.006096580997109413, -0.028718378394842148, 0.030965371057391167, 0.018112679943442345, 0.006682125385850668, -0.0011972563806921244, -0.036518752574920654, 0.0010908489348366857, -0.024056024849414825, 0.05404026433825493, 0.003550700144842267, -0.00040717015508562326, -0.018192360177636147, -0.0194820798933506, -0.008387495763599873, -0.035778287798166275, 0.0342024527490139, -0.007808041758835316, -0.029712826013565063, -0.04147564247250557, -0.01454943884164095, 0.04230962321162224, 0.011331524699926376, -0.028543850407004356, 0.03324691951274872, 0.021349618211388588, -0.015586277469992638, 0.03053651563823223, -0.039542850106954575, -0.028345895931124687, 0.029484326019883156, -0.020264437422156334, 0.018142802640795708, 0.004930858034640551, 0.08816858381032944, -0.002438520547002554, 0.041106995195150375, 0.0007898150943219662, 0.06730563938617706, -0.08910953998565674, 0.05849028751254082, -0.028802698478102684, -0.004283551592379808, -0.00002897846388805192, 0.016560586169362068, 0.024479644373059273, 0.061195675283670425, 0.027505749836564064, 0.06430117040872574, 0.0067673055455088615, -0.014424136839807034, -0.020019572228193283, 0.028601735830307007, -0.03847881034016609, -0.03641266003251076, -0.04071926325559616, -0.03752361238002777, -0.012903613038361073, 0.022456973791122437, 0.0028556312900036573, 0.033434029668569565, 0.0028249460738152266, 0.020399998873472214, -0.014683247543871403, 0.014194495975971222, 0.09421136975288391, -0.00636454438790679, -0.037711888551712036, -0.02650858275592327, -0.04547078162431717, 0.0187192615121603, -0.054340001195669174, 0.005836151074618101, -0.039053332060575485, 0.024891521781682968, 0.020489975810050964, 0.0209941603243351, -0.05651919171214104, 0.007190010976046324, -0.044431887567043304, 0.003384106559678912, -0.0021532392129302025, 0.004525672644376755, 0.022119073197245598, 0.06300527602434158, 0.03292076662182808, 0.012031137943267822, -0.03706027567386627, -0.04304732009768486, 0.10164697468280792, -0.0028885267674922943, 0.010280465707182884, -0.026182977482676506, 0.007524080574512482, 0.042133878916502, 0.00880330242216587, 0.004137193784117699, -0.0058002714067697525, -0.03312717005610466, 0.03424233943223953, 0.0025257677771151066, 0.022838659584522247, 0.0383516326546669, 0.02495407499372959, 0.10692927241325378, -0.006390681955963373, -0.012662750668823719, -0.00008876421634340659, 0.06731738150119781, 0.07142326235771179, -0.044918593019247055, -0.0281713604927063, 0.007479395251721144, -0.020474405959248543, -0.0386161208152771, -0.025872163474559784, -0.04478931799530983, -0.04821459949016571, 0.010333104059100151, 0.034170713275671005, 0.06694773584604263, 0.032408200204372406, 0.012874258682131767, -0.03475208953022957, -0.052292633801698685, -0.0032572487834841013, 0.04818440228700638, 0.015752479434013367, 0.03150312229990959, -0.034883350133895874, -0.0626843124628067, -0.020964212715625763, -0.07516247034072876, -0.01690211519598961, -0.014549337327480316, 0.005299418233335018, 0.037931714206933975, 0.017437644302845, 0.03202977776527405, -0.044569648802280426, 0.0118278032168746, -0.03685244545340538, 0.009776206687092781, -0.048951830714941025, -0.021221496164798737, -0.009647375904023647, 0.0033647262025624514, -0.05084174498915672, -0.08481007814407349, -0.021167391911149025, -0.01106276921927929, 0.044957391917705536, -0.002284994116052985, 0.02510453201830387, -0.022441131994128227, -0.05628148838877678, -0.006808276288211346, -0.03057974763214588, 0.028400825336575508, 0.03539681062102318, -0.04347128048539162, 0.011001222766935825, -0.004343428183346987, 0.0021065787877887487, -0.012159018777310848, 0.0044941664673388, -0.043643396347761154, -0.004462636075913906, -0.04297566041350365, 0.05174349993467331, 0.06053819879889488, -0.016935525462031364, -0.02848241664469242, 0.08645550906658173, -0.045206692069768906, -0.018450448289513588, -0.05945718288421631, 0.06253977864980698, 0.03051084838807583, 0.028890667483210564, -0.03149505332112312, 0.00508245499804616, -0.021634425967931747, 0.0005712894489988685, 0.029757073149085045, 0.020068442448973656, 0.0034929912071675062, -0.037533070892095566, 0.040472015738487244, 0.0401899628341198, -0.05838039889931679, 0.045188773423433304, 0.11804066598415375, -0.0075936224311590195, 0.046439506113529205, 0.01326803769916296, 0.013627699576318264, 0.04115317761898041, 0.0372631810605526, -0.04091579094529152, 0.047026753425598145, 0.014486792497336864, 0.054807212203741074, -0.016612466424703598, -0.00856903288513422, 0.057031020522117615, 0.014367100782692432, 0.023708267137408257, 0.03708866238594055, -0.008671361021697521, 0.006311164703220129, -0.03559444844722748, 0.05005485191941261, -0.017910288646817207, -0.06675709038972855, 0.03987450152635574, 0.0399637371301651, 0.02627474069595337, -0.035796746611595154, 0.0008399304351769388, 0.027738068252801895, -0.05260726064443588, -0.011211828328669071, -0.025870611891150475, 0.015060245990753174, 0.04707277566194534, -0.004231777973473072, -0.008851840160787106, 0.023849083110690117, 0.011185779236257076, 0.021114952862262726, -0.03799410164356232, 0.014949219301342964, 0.055929459631443024, 0.02328353002667427, 0.01241993810981512, 0.010111537761986256, 0.024531304836273193, 0.010916097089648247, -0.02248287945985794, 0.0017045603599399328, -0.02771797403693199, -0.04552571102976799, 0.00023526015866082162, 0.04291512444615364, 0.004656519275158644, -0.012742466293275356, -0.07213568687438965, -0.06109321117401123, 0.03768572956323624, -0.021007763221859932, 0.008053845725953579, 0.0435846708714962, -0.027584804221987724, -0.0031553360167890787, -0.03548296540975571, -0.012753207236528397, -0.0023756353184580803, -0.06808080524206161, 0.021556518971920013, 0.01295773871243, 0.02420591562986374, -0.012823358178138733, 0.04850204288959503, -0.024606477469205856, 0.014188701286911964, 0.07292480766773224, 0.019016237929463387, 0.06096167117357254, 0.021812710911035538, -0.0929960161447525, -0.002026801463216543, 0.020195944234728813, 0.012794533744454384, 0.007456595078110695, 0.031181782484054565, 0.02427537553012371, -0.010605378076434135, 0.021529363468289375, -0.059102609753608704, -0.05908437445759773, -0.04402667284011841, -0.001012094202451408, 0.007960870862007141, -0.01806040108203888, -0.014705945737659931, 0.04485945776104927, -0.06671088933944702, 0.030457163229584694, 0.018942274153232574, -0.005517179146409035, 0.027144940569996834, -0.011080911383032799, -0.016517778858542442, -0.03405182436108589, -0.028225883841514587, 0.03204210847616196, 0.00811771396547556, -0.014100882224738598, 0.08521343767642975, -0.016618948429822922, 0.037241384387016296, -0.016349565237760544, 0.02649875357747078, 0.012928424403071404, 0.014808179810643196, 0.014445437118411064, 0.09050989151000977, -0.036048419773578644, 0.013747249729931355, -0.002670707181096077, 0.0018541916506364942, -0.003168183844536543, 0.024696791544556618, -0.0068894317373633385, -0.0677366778254509, 0.008851048536598682, 0.03249907121062279, -0.05407280847430229, 0.03782059997320175, -0.03388814255595207, -0.01687828078866005, 0.003598015056923032, -0.02720746025443077, -0.07227198034524918, 0.034032415598630905, -0.036355871707201004, 0.0354178287088871, -0.00229521538130939, 0.04992992803454399, 0.020242935046553612, -0.016288897022604942, -0.05140316113829613, 0.013739295303821564, -0.02869279496371746, -0.07308778166770935, -0.0341324619948864, 0.007049166597425938, -0.008595282211899757, -0.02694547548890114, -0.06156863272190094, 0.013130604289472103, 0.04348837584257126, 0.011714383028447628, 0.004239839501678944, 0.03547278791666031, 0.004034782759845257, 0.007935325615108013, 0.012725983746349812, 0.04465869069099426, -0.021972836926579475, 0.033625341951847076, -0.04287335276603699, 0.013083130121231079, -0.00932206679135561, -0.009032456204295158, 0.013751877471804619, 0.014450224116444588, 0.010542887263000011, -0.023239752277731895, -0.04872870817780495, 0.0450611375272274, 0.040672849863767624, -0.004074052907526493, 0.03566889837384224, -0.004268242046236992, -0.0034906230866909027, -0.040368203073740005, 0.008592990227043629, 0.015844576060771942, -0.02316584438085556, 0.008221549913287163, -0.013304393738508224, -0.0027402036357671022, -0.006390479393303394, 0.02320083975791931, 0.031740300357341766, 0.05078419670462608, 0.00878881849348545, 0.0355353057384491, -0.0034982962533831596, 0.016212306916713715, 0.043333858251571655, 0.02556784078478813, -0.04412129893898964, -0.0344521626830101, -0.025746308267116547, -0.028607090935111046, -0.007733195088803768, 0.0588168166577816, -0.007502994034439325, -0.04846729710698128, -0.006567361298948526, -0.0007069748244248331, -0.05767090618610382, -0.06535333395004272, -0.013498320244252682, -0.005903154145926237, -0.02591565065085888, 0.006598144304007292, -0.019440460950136185, 0.011755355633795261, -0.013777310959994793, -0.0010033356957137585, 0.0194257702678442, -0.08142314106225967, -0.02957678586244583, -0.005776182748377323, 0.01942509226500988, -0.0004980507656000555, -0.0041956366039812565, 0.036498527973890305, 0.026550957933068275, -0.009747511707246304, 0.018844299018383026, 0.0556318573653698, -0.006018959451466799, 0.02957279421389103, 0.07877925038337708, -0.06381507962942123, 0.0012035712134093046, 0.05335487052798271, 0.028916802257299423, 0.009021379984915257, -0.005542502738535404, 0.030664850026369095, -0.02040417119860649, -0.014820561744272709, -0.04519469290971756, 0.04107663407921791, -0.017115863040089607, 0.071357361972332 ]
<p>What sort of mode-locked laser systems allow for the production of single isolated pulse of light (as opposed to a train of more than one pulse), where the individual pulse duration is on order picoseconds ($\approx 10^{-12}$ seconds) to femtoseconds ($\approx 10^{-15}$ seconds)? Is there any reason I couldn't use a mode-locked Ti-sapphire laser to produce a single pulse of some desired / achievable duration in the femtosecond regime? Or is it generally challenging to drop the pulse repetition rate to a sufficiently small frequency to allow for shutters / etc. to filter out the rest of a pulse train?</p> <p>My guess is that if we can get the pulse repetition rate down to the MHz regime, we can start to think about diverting or blocking additional pulses using voltage or mechanically switchable filters? What do people actually use?</p> <p>I should also mention that I'm particularly interested in emission wavelengths in the range of something like $100 \space nm$ to $1.5 \space \mu m$ or so.</p> <p>...</p> <p>In terms of the different types of femtosecond lasers, there are fiber lasers, bulk lasers, dye lasers, semiconductor lasers, even free-electron lasers that one can use. Supposing I need something like a few hundred milliwatts to a watt of output power, and I'm interested in the visible to near-visible wavelength range, are there any families of femtosecond lasers particularly suited to the above task?</p>
g4277
[ -0.03936580568552017, 0.05311135947704315, 0.01687251776456833, 0.04732288047671318, 0.0004514997417572886, -0.04529276490211487, 0.032043226063251495, -0.021013649180531502, 0.00961314793676138, -0.04631178826093674, -0.013212695717811584, 0.013772676698863506, 0.04754023253917694, -0.0025508387479931116, -0.010571574792265892, 0.012491252273321152, 0.030308661982417107, 0.04214278236031532, -0.027329711243510246, 0.036004438996315, -0.01070480328053236, 0.03833533450961113, -0.047422487288713455, -0.024823244661092758, -0.02985103614628315, 0.043165769428014755, 0.07532806694507599, -0.05332060903310776, 0.006470356602221727, -0.022645115852355957, -0.026902122423052788, -0.0845266655087471, 0.0802478939294815, -0.015038711950182915, 0.014661144465208054, -0.033820509910583496, -0.006479308474808931, -0.04266573488712311, 0.04670971632003784, 0.04241793602705002, 0.03668408468365669, -0.06878591328859329, 0.0053366562351584435, -0.037307776510715485, 0.021003033965826035, 0.025824079290032387, 0.05845408886671066, -0.007320470176637173, -0.017547762021422386, 0.010153071954846382, 0.05267927795648575, -0.037279773503541946, 0.00223460397683084, 0.016282768920063972, -0.023351388052105904, -0.0199732668697834, -0.01595039665699005, 0.039129335433244705, 0.00015869899652898312, 0.024656731635332108, -0.06708695739507675, -0.04293838143348694, 0.05241549015045166, 0.012831353582441807, -0.011197288520634174, -0.014768373221158981, -0.05918844789266586, -0.03983919322490692, 0.02094159834086895, -0.024686550721526146, -0.04666782543063164, -0.05369319021701813, 0.0036516962572932243, -0.017492031678557396, 0.032195039093494415, -0.0006469131330959499, 0.005868546664714813, -0.02132699079811573, 0.0007342879544012249, -0.012251678854227066, 0.006959257181733847, -0.03333994373679161, -0.02697107382118702, 0.01276326086372137, 0.01599935255944729, -0.008929550647735596, -0.017455333843827248, 0.01789441518485546, -0.0083905179053545, 0.06107944995164871, 0.0013543963432312012, -0.014019273221492767, 0.03937573730945587, -0.011069423519074917, -0.008259930647909641, 0.048910025507211685, -0.015859220176935196, 0.004748845938593149, 0.06362129747867584, -0.005818337667733431, 0.02598462998867035, -0.02816571481525898, -0.004775064066052437, -0.05964665859937668, -0.033071473240852356, -0.04197192192077637, -0.0020939353853464127, 0.026865141466259956, 0.018834197893738747, 0.005096192937344313, 0.008991708979010582, 0.00657337112352252, -0.06150916591286659, -0.009457236155867577, -0.0514371357858181, 0.020535575225949287, 0.023359481245279312, 0.026438720524311066, 0.01184887532144785, 0.020518727600574493, 0.05205337330698967, 0.0034394769463688135, -0.01503544207662344, -0.02552766166627407, -0.04819295555353165, 0.025172395631670952, -0.0009356232476420701, 0.01672394387423992, 0.009136617183685303, -0.0057949526235461235, -0.053472936153411865, -0.016496744006872177, -0.026289166882634163, -0.003708662698045373, -0.026348885148763657, 0.004108102060854435, 0.009718562476336956, -0.02157757245004177, 0.040660906583070755, 0.005375909153372049, 0.01166183315217495, -0.012921002693474293, -0.011334856040775776, 0.0019048325484618545, -0.0029554488137364388, 0.07530269771814346, -0.09475944191217422, 0.03924359008669853, 0.048939578235149384, 0.06295650452375412, -0.005013134330511093, 0.05483586713671684, -0.025844410061836243, -0.013805652968585491, 0.006728847045451403, -0.022759627550840378, 0.04918571934103966, -0.01337981317192316, -0.034662697464227676, -0.0330447256565094, 0.06553606688976288, -0.04640944302082062, -0.03238169848918915, 0.008223965764045715, -0.0457337461411953, -0.02507038228213787, -0.007241508923470974, -0.03021097742021084, 0.014697755686938763, -0.02337605133652687, -0.0725906640291214, 0.01123241800814867, -0.04297968000173569, 0.06739716976881027, 0.06551530212163925, 0.0002804979158099741, 0.056562721729278564, -0.013621138408780098, -0.0480087548494339, -0.014612620696425438, 0.014611630700528622, 0.02590451017022133, -0.06512019783258438, -0.012660433538258076, 0.01945933699607849, -0.003644365817308426, 0.0026853904128074646, -0.026548948138952255, 0.029949456453323364, 0.09449591487646103, -0.015883656218647957, -0.002890605479478836, 0.025040075182914734, 0.05751125141978264, -0.025869978591799736, -0.0008217040449380875, 0.0000668087086523883, -0.05021817237138748, -0.045157626271247864, 0.026884399354457855, -0.07347195595502853, -0.009241500869393349, -0.010340739972889423, -0.025326544418931007, 0.0614115335047245, -0.044951289892196655, 0.0206170491874218, -0.007552954368293285, -0.008973176591098309, -0.014566181227564812, 0.07250159233808517, -0.02455168217420578, -0.03749655932188034, 0.02809637039899826, 0.020082520321011543, -0.008131159469485283, -0.027958054095506668, -0.024028589949011803, 0.00643780967220664, 0.015268885530531406, 0.03971167653799057, 0.017721932381391525, 0.040164608508348465, 0.016377007588744164, 0.023353250697255135, 0.009057282470166683, -0.029059594497084618, 0.044869642704725266, 0.041480354964733124, 0.0634765475988388, -0.03789208456873894, -0.006983029656112194, -0.038798585534095764, -0.08136581629514694, 0.024332644417881966, 0.05512728914618492, 0.013593182899057865, 0.013170426711440086, -0.03520464897155762, -0.045600999146699905, 0.018636127933859825, -0.029792504385113716, 0.019701827317476273, -0.022795315831899643, -0.034963544458150864, -0.03685206174850464, 0.0211078692227602, 0.030548010021448135, 0.008943910710513592, -0.04113101214170456, -0.04048922285437584, -0.04749884828925133, 0.028244055807590485, -0.011156035587191582, -0.06753473728895187, -0.058065686374902725, 0.09124762564897537, 0.09643061459064484, -0.04590439423918724, 0.05212242901325226, -0.012348377145826817, 0.022685127332806587, -0.0025800797156989574, -0.012811144813895226, 0.052163150161504745, -0.011521169915795326, 0.006638312246650457, 0.01328698918223381, 0.016795603558421135, 0.026199709624052048, -0.014936694875359535, 0.014926137402653694, -0.05995715782046318, -0.04779275134205818, 0.04735537990927696, 0.008489291183650494, 0.04635991156101227, -0.019192496314644814, 0.04506707191467285, -0.009889981709420681, 0.033568043261766434, -0.01744936779141426, -0.021643996238708496, 0.0062950546853244305, 0.05015069618821144, -0.07271317392587662, 0.0778423622250557, -0.00953302439302206, 0.007584478240460157, 0.02994440868496895, -0.02191867120563984, -0.00024024142476264387, 0.017073743045330048, 0.018954942002892494, -0.0661052018404007, -0.012798910960555077, -0.0030116939451545477, 0.016962211579084396, -0.018331998959183693, 0.002175825648009777, 0.07283398509025574, -0.025253726169466972, 0.04536396265029907, -0.003051952924579382, -0.02211606130003929, 0.012358455918729305, -0.0445190854370594, -0.008523277007043362, -0.014181101694703102, 0.01072448119521141, 0.05623282864689827, 0.038383692502975464, 0.01205572858452797, -0.000779825437348336, -0.035431597381830215, 0.012763758189976215, -0.012882048264145851, -0.020497383549809456, -0.013990853913128376, -0.02774963527917862, -0.003995971288532019, 0.011091853491961956, 0.011485756374895573, -0.06493495404720306, -0.016380520537495613, 0.011077587492763996, -0.005610740277916193, -0.006118833087384701, -0.05070740357041359, 0.007617402356117964, 0.0616874173283577, 0.002023103879764676, -0.007976929657161236, 0.0005397948552854359, -0.010972792282700539, -0.021590718999505043, -0.0554095059633255, 0.009872500784695148, 0.06076415628194809, -0.028054488822817802, 0.03816639259457588, 0.07619772851467133, -0.004994169808924198, -0.012354481965303421, 0.04952680319547653, 0.012741301208734512, -0.028306804597377777, -0.035752106457948685, 0.01637752540409565, 0.018510114401578903, -0.004075438715517521, -0.03854569047689438, 0.01829334907233715, -0.0015384005382657051, 0.044477712363004684, 0.07454826682806015, -0.002744673052802682, 0.04457935690879822, 0.04717016592621803, -0.0500701479613781, -0.02590171806514263, -0.02331799641251564, 0.022557124495506287, -0.061575498431921005, -0.021341031417250633, -0.017300400882959366, 0.03899483010172844, -0.03654631972312927, 0.020780477672815323, -0.044412221759557724, 0.027457505464553833, 0.02484346181154251, 0.019159633666276932, -0.041819017380476, -0.05707422271370888, 0.004737610463052988, 0.036634307354688644, 0.07627717405557632, -0.011116855777800083, -0.004290675278753042, -0.06756500899791718, -0.00651768920943141, 0.044268518686294556, -0.01214812695980072, -0.01742578111588955, 0.03980816528201103, 0.02124038152396679, 0.008713755756616592, -0.0360940620303154, -0.02287968434393406, 0.031566817313432693, -0.07679566740989685, -0.04034219682216644, -0.022549863904714584, -0.05164521187543869, -0.012242993339896202, -0.0030338389333337545, -0.05721014738082886, 0.027021940797567368, 0.05435360223054886, 0.03750722482800484, -0.027028148993849754, 0.0036856243386864662, 0.004844334442168474, 0.006187864579260349, -0.006504092365503311, -0.05088905617594719, 0.03666647896170616, -0.02612476795911789, 0.023716963827610016, -0.03928399831056595, -0.033338792622089386, 0.026298729702830315, 0.039069317281246185, 0.019708607345819473, 0.020370827987790108, 0.028504865244030952, -0.056207846850156784, 0.06492568552494049, -0.004641047213226557, 0.047592129558324814, -0.012502807192504406, -0.04719512537121773, 0.03334595635533333, -0.023104362189769745, 0.061078984290361404, -0.021132171154022217, -0.027078993618488312, -0.0013963108649477363, 0.016735579818487167, 0.06494233012199402, -0.0041603934951126575, 0.04403369501233101, -0.03324545919895172, 0.07217144966125488, -0.025681644678115845, -0.009799948893487453, 0.0027093396056443453, 0.013401915319263935, 0.05908455327153206, 0.022592918947339058, -0.030444003641605377, 0.040416765958070755, 0.013251758180558681, 0.007677802350372076, -0.002478726441040635, -0.06577891856431961, -0.006141628138720989, -0.05050978437066078, -0.004406558349728584, 0.014560740441083908, 0.0004113120085094124, -0.046493299305438995, -0.026159074157476425, 0.005910818465054035, -0.01180651132017374, -0.04576854407787323, -0.0006099931197240949, 0.10628658533096313, 0.03180168569087982, -0.02184501849114895, -0.010686741210520267, -0.021948985755443573, 0.007517686579376459, 0.05428091809153557, 0.0019958072807639837, 0.005327727645635605, 0.004180244170129299, -0.038998592644929886, -0.034466370940208435, 0.00012948541552759707, 0.011401896364986897, 0.06238323822617531, 0.07197758555412292, 0.026137858629226685, -0.0367153100669384, -0.0383937805891037, -0.055003199726343155, -0.007754884660243988, 0.002881450578570366, -0.012233833782374859, -0.031448397785425186, 0.016398513689637184, 0.08225833624601364, -0.008285190910100937, -0.03963015601038933, 0.003256317228078842, -0.012675924226641655, -0.022453004494309425, 0.0007553428877145052, -0.02277519553899765, 0.08437472581863403, 0.035014841705560684, -0.00755646824836731, 0.03255026042461395, -0.04459996894001961, 0.022779416292905807, 0.043799079954624176, 0.008591336198151112, -0.034651320427656174, -0.0027787021826952696, 0.03464367613196373, -0.018773837015032768, -0.020619789138436317, -0.0033453183714300394, -0.0024129399098455906, -0.027155227959156036, -0.014123615808784962, -0.00011017848737537861, 0.002674622694030404, 0.018093202263116837, -0.0005936086527071893, -0.07200027257204056, 0.0017891479656100273, 0.05328104645013809, -0.0645972490310669, 0.01584826596081257, -0.006322586443275213, 0.03591213747859001, -0.03990995138883591, -0.04648689180612564, 0.015005379915237427, 0.04320053383708, 0.08652392029762268, 0.08133310824632645, -0.00980512797832489, -0.04395207017660141, 0.05206393450498581, 0.012416044250130653, -0.06826944649219513, -0.009542210027575493, -0.030935754999518394, 0.011509026400744915, -0.009123199619352818, -0.008620740845799446, 0.06608706712722778, -0.023244677111506462, 0.03431856632232666, -0.062331750988960266, -0.00800897553563118, -0.06992398947477341, -0.03549593687057495, -0.008401407860219479, 0.012204986996948719, 0.003929313737899065, -0.05920134857296944, 0.05582687631249428, -0.014867454767227173, -0.046510960906744, 0.037424247711896896, 0.003383082337677479, -0.016744349151849747, -0.019306233152747154, -0.07795701175928116, -0.019772056490182877, 0.06169954314827919, -0.017109347507357597, 0.017047038301825523, -0.01776563748717308, -0.06803756207227707, 0.06095465272665024, 0.0941433236002922, -0.047881558537483215, -0.010229784063994884, -0.02507200464606285, -0.02759362757205963, 0.049616117030382156, -0.04669903963804245, -0.05035948008298874, 0.016046883538365364, -0.009406732395291328, -0.03491021320223808, -0.04289969429373741, 0.0009758435771800578, 0.02672896906733513, 0.007724838797003031, 0.04072197899222374, -0.050309114158153534, -0.013624275103211403, -0.002925226232036948, -0.08371513336896896, 0.017436368390917778, 0.02327582985162735, 0.00156728969886899, -0.003849328262731433, -0.015418202616274357, -0.02462177909910679, -0.03862195834517479, -0.021847380325198174, 0.03663035109639168, -0.01917940005660057, -0.0032058176584541798, -0.025540098547935486, 0.03528629615902901, 0.0031876149587333202, -0.006313036661595106, -0.02242019586265087, -0.0035526552237570286, -0.01793765462934971, 0.024642636999487877, 0.02637195773422718, 0.043898411095142365, 0.025382118299603462, -0.0333261713385582, -0.013758192770183086, 0.08520131558179855, 0.01400080882012844, 0.005403488874435425, 0.06456946581602097, 0.03198627382516861, -0.02451748587191105, 0.0005212891846895218, -0.0323011539876461, 0.02561803162097931, -0.056906845420598984, -0.015175022184848785, 0.0020983584690839052, -0.019671181216835976, -0.03389699384570122, 0.02467467449605465, 0.022820379585027695, -0.007639060262590647, 0.02225286141037941, -0.030190359801054, -0.04534041881561279, 0.0011950288899242878, 0.02094859629869461, -0.003905146149918437, 0.07922385632991791, 0.027132850140333176, 0.057672034949064255, -0.037088532000780106, 0.04264438524842262, 0.0016153131145983934, -0.038495223969221115, 0.0005046009318903089, -0.03235507383942604, 0.004675927106291056, -0.006847372278571129, -0.08090265095233917, -0.014823953621089458, 0.043244730681180954, -0.022451041266322136, 0.054348889738321304, 0.028545089066028595, 0.03642052039504051, 0.05040326714515686, -0.009462439455091953, 0.07060978561639786, 0.015910398215055466, -0.009762236848473549, -0.005955153610557318, -0.08041413873434067, 0.030302563682198524, -0.0011504798894748092, 0.044472236186265945, 0.016733447089791298, 0.019566187635064125, -0.007864458486437798, -0.015232137404382229, 0.01882634125649929, 0.06015365570783615, -0.031979069113731384, -0.028792712837457657, 0.04134594276547432, 0.06798525154590607, 0.014030957594513893, 0.004100862890481949, 0.027691202238202095, -0.015322400256991386, 0.02517402544617653, 0.020571136847138405, -0.02560586854815483, -0.012178738601505756, -0.016905317083001137, 0.007188247516751289, -0.05136232450604439, 0.0535394623875618, 0.044780343770980835, -0.008654787205159664, -0.14432398974895477, 0.03784528002142906, -0.021658815443515778, -0.04056885093450546, 0.01683075539767742, 0.06858055293560028, -0.052142489701509476, 0.05064993351697922, 0.020727261900901794, -0.08192253112792969, -0.029544157907366753, 0.021969454362988472, -0.039538897573947906, -0.05922045558691025, 0.028535407036542892, -0.043812014162540436, 0.03577851876616478, 0.012756259180605412, -0.0066336472518742085, 0.02630905993282795, -0.03187425807118416, 0.006377777084708214, 0.0068822260946035385, 0.027539316564798355, 0.04854000732302666, -0.02521054446697235, -0.05038323625922203, -0.008424913510680199, 0.02390063926577568, 0.043497730046510696, -0.025116894394159317, -0.01090981625020504, -0.002449970692396164, -0.004952600225806236, 0.020802542567253113, -0.050355199724435806, -0.0606720894575119, 0.004213145934045315, 0.003989811055362225, -0.009989067912101746, -0.01901491917669773, 0.015264859423041344, 0.043158989399671555, 0.00490995030850172, 0.020934559404850006, -0.011589533649384975, 0.045142825692892075, 0.001967460848391056, 0.046219438314437866, -0.018142813816666603, -0.013644316233694553, -0.0473904013633728, 0.03209299221634865, 0.018717555329203606, -0.03725287690758705, 0.030003393068909645, 0.04574020579457283, 0.015140006318688393, -0.0507051907479763, 0.0478668250143528, 0.08270607888698578, -0.017216283828020096, -0.054064732044935226, -0.004421725403517485, 0.04358534887433052, 0.06081334501504898, -0.020410548895597458, -0.0018686032854020596, -0.03514760360121727, -0.012806860730051994, 0.014190424233675003, 0.00620585260912776, -0.0493963360786438, 0.007893030531704426, 0.055638331919908524, -0.04427891969680786, -0.01814357563853264, -0.021750377491116524, 0.012872566469013691, -0.026357503607869148, 0.018082227557897568, 0.024715481325984, -0.07607007026672363, 0.020785225555300713, -0.00474585173651576, -0.021079886704683304, -0.006196291651576757, -0.07608499377965927 ]
<p>Malcolm Gladwell made a claim in a <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&amp;v=5L0GGfQblrc" rel="nofollow">recent talk</a> that a sling with a stone going at 30m/s has the same stopping power as a .45 calibre handgun.</p> <p>How would I verify whether or not this claim is true - even given some assumptions, like the stone has a weight of 1lb or 2 lbs or whatever.</p> <p>Not quite sure how to work this out.</p> <p>Assume that the bullet is a 185grain 0.45 calibre bullet.</p>
g4278
[ 0.09322939813137054, -0.038084447383880615, 0.019462041556835175, -0.0509205125272274, 0.01663377694785595, 0.04138180986046791, 0.025990815833210945, -0.06714361906051636, -0.021907897666096687, -0.02122650481760502, 0.003076499328017235, -0.007618617732077837, 0.008110875263810158, 0.005922280717641115, -0.00018135999562218785, -0.012686117552220821, 0.07779369503259659, -0.0773293524980545, 0.039036866277456284, 0.0723675861954689, -0.030875543132424355, -0.028713053092360497, -0.032341793179512024, -0.0458315834403038, -0.008452343754470348, -0.006772930268198252, 0.0017866473644971848, 0.006890546064823866, -0.055443037301301956, -0.023917168378829956, 0.025533344596624374, -0.021249528974294662, -0.03680591285228729, 0.00003705314520630054, -0.03802051022648811, 0.010681906715035439, 0.060364142060279846, 0.019816800951957703, -0.002373302122578025, 0.02858276292681694, 0.01243396196514368, -0.018580961972475052, 0.04123035818338394, 0.0027188712265342474, -0.012292217463254929, 0.011978285387158394, 0.03816662356257439, 0.10745828598737717, 0.02611096203327179, 0.025671904906630516, -0.11164728552103043, 0.034736596047878265, -0.022775063291192055, -0.029988693073391914, -0.039301224052906036, -0.01564442738890648, 0.025664987042546272, 0.009700906462967396, -0.0319373793900013, -0.037524428218603134, -0.03279384598135948, -0.045704979449510574, -0.05611778050661087, 0.0019428444793447852, 0.027162211015820503, -0.003214341588318348, -0.0059485966339707375, -0.018527943640947342, 0.03571172431111336, 0.03185908496379852, -0.02338254265487194, -0.08083641529083252, -0.04512181878089905, 0.010037005878984928, -0.016843512654304504, -0.027416830882430077, -0.01417481154203415, 0.056636493653059006, 0.004597806371748447, 0.04457924887537956, 0.014756644144654274, 0.02272237278521061, 0.018814176321029663, -0.09079436212778091, -0.027072297409176826, -0.015851344913244247, -0.04476248845458031, 0.001709348987787962, -0.0009116573492065072, 0.08882021903991699, -0.0019393429392948747, 0.04463503137230873, 0.07326026260852814, 0.05301831290125847, 0.014544427394866943, -0.008700132369995117, -0.02690330520272255, 0.046297963708639145, -0.04883579909801483, 0.03032010607421398, -0.006269231904298067, 0.017313465476036072, 0.010787050239741802, -0.0290405061095953, 0.031264252960681915, 0.04319598525762558, 0.04004966467618942, -0.012197155505418777, -0.0010152212344110012, 0.0023290328681468964, 0.0180978924036026, -0.030036447569727898, 0.014693859964609146, -0.061655543744564056, -0.016259808093309402, -0.023529265075922012, 0.02593376487493515, 0.003074662061408162, -0.009538643062114716, 0.009559505619108677, 0.038077522069215775, -0.012880681082606316, 0.033335115760564804, 0.05963141471147537, -0.0330282486975193, 0.016678832471370697, -0.043181221932172775, -0.020658288151025772, -0.032867200672626495, -0.005020301789045334, 0.004335456527769566, 0.0023281038738787174, 0.1407647728919983, -0.00013721919094678015, 0.04268543794751167, 0.04649592190980911, 0.036599621176719666, 0.01821178011596203, -0.0480354018509388, -0.05948236957192421, -0.0036232632119208574, 0.04384017363190651, 0.031768668442964554, 0.03258482739329338, -0.039791807532310486, 0.04587474837899208, -0.0609452947974205, -0.039586976170539856, 0.030884934589266777, 0.016894975677132607, 0.018816908821463585, 0.05518537014722824, 0.0015183464856818318, -0.027337172999978065, 0.019539043307304382, -0.029735732823610306, 0.03792742267251015, -0.004521994385868311, -0.004674225579947233, -0.006907150615006685, -0.027356356382369995, -0.045201320201158524, 0.0037901662290096283, 0.029426198452711105, -0.03706938773393631, 0.005208305083215237, 0.003923770040273666, 0.029307322576642036, -0.012003790587186813, -0.05111348256468773, -0.021158164367079735, 0.03976457193493843, 0.012881425209343433, -0.03324988856911659, 0.02534136176109314, -0.026386631652712822, 0.030611198395490646, -0.0439414344727993, -0.011088836006820202, -0.004863413516432047, -0.026545315980911255, -0.002787643577903509, 0.04534665867686272, -0.03928138688206673, 0.008255698718130589, 0.014062277972698212, 0.10706352442502975, -0.11249348521232605, 0.0025541007053107023, -0.017270376905798912, -0.04778187721967697, -0.06448249518871307, -0.013021977618336678, -0.03469093143939972, -0.048977892845869064, -0.0026759104803204536, 0.036524806171655655, 0.02288586087524891, 0.028064215555787086, -0.024500524625182152, 0.0021705301478505135, 0.04993234574794769, -0.038837652653455734, -0.012003081850707531, 0.01637515425682068, -0.023443404585123062, -0.00526924105361104, -0.019387179985642433, -0.051576633006334305, 0.0021010474301874638, 0.011795814149081707, 0.035635609179735184, -0.03727903962135315, 0.050688792020082474, 0.004083435051143169, 0.08345075696706772, 0.04584655910730362, 0.05245368182659149, -0.04082872346043587, -0.0026893680915236473, -0.03372649475932121, 0.03247492387890816, 0.011198566295206547, -0.029910940676927567, -0.03274182602763176, 0.004014316946268082, -0.04692491888999939, 0.03565026447176933, 0.02107570506632328, 0.028205420821905136, 0.0026007862761616707, -0.003719130763784051, -0.045257531106472015, -0.031228816136717796, 0.07068097591400146, 0.032911498099565506, 0.06871363520622253, 0.01918151043355465, 0.0379955880343914, 0.03157516568899155, 0.023302655667066574, 0.033372245728969574, -0.01520848460495472, 0.0011102070566266775, -0.01146171148866415, -0.053714022040367126, -0.0424770750105381, 0.011645895428955555, -0.005452779587358236, 0.007867442443966866, -0.021305279806256294, -0.06395407766103745, -0.024252669885754585, 0.028637217357754707, -0.03328230232000351, 0.010157093405723572, -0.036217305809259415, 0.007999823428690434, -0.044413842260837555, 0.007871418260037899, -0.0457858145236969, -0.03171299770474434, 0.04140565171837807, -0.02097470313310623, -0.07039857655763626, -0.015581836923956871, -0.020460333675146103, -0.027657242491841316, 0.013691439293324947, -0.04629839211702347, 0.017534010112285614, 0.025741634890437126, 0.045509908348321915, 0.06702779978513718, 0.043133221566677094, -0.03151703253388405, 0.012086840346455574, -0.03315193951129913, 0.012855634093284607, -0.06095002964138985, -0.017970042303204536, 0.01657877117395401, -0.022078171372413635, 0.024115482345223427, -0.015420711599290371, 0.006804988719522953, 0.016181055456399918, -0.017412908375263214, 0.007367901038378477, -0.01464904472231865, -0.00941239483654499, 0.059881292283535004, 0.03593962639570236, -0.0025976598262786865, -0.0021372311748564243, 0.05712097883224487, 0.04577498883008957, -0.009448157623410225, 0.04473491758108139, 0.000993889756500721, -0.05087430402636528, 0.01885521039366722, -0.054427579045295715, -0.009711647406220436, -0.013761842623353004, 0.007597918622195721, -0.01960824988782406, -0.04268770292401314, 0.014388477429747581, -0.022294437512755394, -0.015330018475651741, 0.012302299961447716, 0.06416676193475723, -0.033859435468912125, 0.0013112068409100175, -0.01229223795235157, -0.04957320913672447, -0.0027745261322706938, 0.0645364448428154, 0.045426275581121445, -0.031333308666944504, -0.046643465757369995, 0.029086660593748093, -0.003464612178504467, -0.0386265330016613, 0.04529847204685211, -0.020817376673221588, 0.0279949139803648, -0.07070292532444, -0.015520824119448662, 0.022374091669917107, 0.023218536749482155, -0.00668600108474493, -0.04388725012540817, 0.014777244068682194, -0.03892522677779198, 0.03197174519300461, 0.03565937653183937, 0.04250612109899521, 0.05823703855276108, -0.02785591594874859, 0.03719640523195267, 0.002429977059364319, 0.01615937426686287, -0.0066821095533668995, 0.0539328008890152, 0.032313015311956406, 0.053980834782123566, -0.012076489627361298, 0.0009460001601837575, 0.061864059418439865, -0.021170321851968765, 0.0027160285972058773, -0.02645820565521717, 0.001064437092281878, -0.007298144046217203, -0.05575013905763626, 0.036028265953063965, -0.019919656217098236, 0.010571976192295551, 0.015267042443156242, 0.0013239451218396425, 0.042576201260089874, -0.038024578243494034, 0.006597774103283882, 0.02731359750032425, -0.07447837293148041, 0.02021086774766445, -0.029642639681696892, -0.015078677795827389, -0.010863899253308773, -0.005378087516874075, -0.007284396328032017, -0.004375141113996506, 0.009886245243251324, 0.025019848719239235, 0.05159245431423187, 0.014452497474849224, -0.04245670884847641, -0.004141046665608883, 0.04486951604485512, 0.03353315591812134, 0.041740767657756805, -0.00013167037104722112, -0.02510564774274826, -0.04259892925620079, -0.06269022822380066, -0.004885071888566017, 0.03832470253109932, -0.07712389528751373, 0.05027274042367935, -0.08007746934890747, -0.059886254370212555, 0.0037489081732928753, 0.042163003236055374, 0.03366415947675705, 0.0059393527917563915, -0.1015181615948677, 0.05011039599776268, 0.05070173740386963, 0.009309101849794388, 0.0836159810423851, 0.025594467297196388, 0.005114329978823662, -0.03649785369634628, 0.0007450267439708114, 0.01769188791513443, 0.006594817154109478, 0.02466243878006935, -0.0062110028229653835, 0.004443989135324955, 0.017698418349027634, -0.029439300298690796, -0.04073674604296684, -0.04941932484507561, 0.013774018734693527, 0.027257295325398445, 0.030063413083553314, -0.06435220688581467, 0.01767829805612564, -0.029744422063231468, -0.008328682743012905, -0.008940710686147213, -0.02203679271042347, -0.02015693672001362, -0.019649112597107887, -0.007590079680085182, -0.01610446348786354, 0.04670701548457146, 0.0059452420100569725, 0.04960993677377701, -0.008264566771686077, 0.01800820603966713, 0.09627892076969147, 0.013253890909254551, 0.013076642528176308, -0.014207389205694199, 0.04219799488782883, 0.015091116540133953, 0.02985946461558342, -0.032371893525123596, -0.010800529271364212, -0.00008155719842761755, 0.038965895771980286, 0.005057390313595533, 0.02243638224899769, -0.04389001801609993, 0.05440659075975418, 0.04155833274126053, 0.02187511697411537, 0.03918639197945595, 0.02224956639111042, -0.03566034510731697, -0.015334858559072018, -0.012709014117717743, 0.035361651331186295, -0.03187241405248642, 0.010824678465723991, 0.029438715428113937, -0.01964491978287697, 0.006136524025350809, 0.02880833111703396, 0.05481277406215668, -0.008624009788036346, -0.0064550782553851604, -0.018408555537462234, -0.008946524932980537, 0.015118876472115517, 0.004065871238708496, -0.011931046843528748, -0.022494694218039513, -0.04792950674891472, 0.002171672647818923, -0.0015730117447674274, -0.02271151915192604, -0.05979936197400093, 0.0451655350625515, -0.030261393636465073, 0.030133796855807304, 0.048639342188835144, -0.03571854159235954, 0.013639540411531925, -0.06355726718902588, -0.07433430105447769, 0.03125733882188797, 0.04565124586224556, 0.010684316046535969, -0.0011352311121299863, -0.019172387197613716, 0.01454234216362238, 0.049277402460575104, -0.0021455169189721346, 0.009147165343165398, -0.04233724996447563, -0.01824944280087948, 0.004283839836716652, 0.06990370154380798, 0.07431989908218384, 0.004546047188341618, 0.009986196644604206, -0.04911811649799347, -0.004611974582076073, 0.03245644271373749, -0.018263157457113266, -0.0070183719508349895, 0.037769168615341187, 0.01369118969887495, 0.025115661323070526, -0.00010459406621521339, 0.05904734134674072, 0.03135712817311287, 0.004478184971958399, 0.026987841352820396, -0.05893491208553314, 0.064390167593956, -0.01310630701482296, 0.049478065222501755, 0.023135624825954437, 0.03043317049741745, -0.0006525092758238316, 0.02007613331079483, -0.05991038307547569, 0.0296441949903965, 0.010761690326035023, 0.015183321200311184, -0.02691485732793808, -0.040207039564847946, -0.06815163791179657, -0.03438162803649902, -0.037981852889060974, 0.059345539659261703, -0.052552480250597, 0.03867790848016739, -0.021788956597447395, -0.019697675481438637, -0.02020127885043621, 0.011851788498461246, -0.008323443122208118, -0.04776296392083168, -0.048577047884464264, -0.08209003508090973, -0.00122720783110708, 0.035754233598709106, 0.06122342869639397, -0.019908849149942398, -0.026967622339725494, -0.021462131291627884, -0.0494115948677063, 0.029433419927954674, -0.014407140202820301, 0.0008929804316721857, 0.027952900156378746, -0.006722722202539444, 0.011187816970050335, 0.018915316089987755, 0.001741402200423181, 0.029814908280968666, 0.014424704946577549, -0.009454452432692051, -0.03604976460337639, -0.009615435265004635, 0.003183656604960561, 0.024368243291974068, 0.019491378217935562, 0.02217840403318405, -0.03485151007771492, -0.024742303416132927, -0.09649882465600967, 0.024480778723955154, 0.013553231954574585, -0.005343954544514418, 0.034681107848882675, -0.03530999645590782, 0.014756940305233002, 0.030240997672080994, -0.021049777045845985, -0.0228008721023798, 0.0062833731062710285, 0.013092869892716408, 0.01244332641363144, 0.02089058607816696, 0.04748644679784775, 0.0332271084189415, 0.006129151210188866, -0.04053721949458122, -0.016694793477654457, -0.030778780579566956, 0.015577968209981918, -0.03228398784995079, -0.013236056081950665, 0.010687779635190964, 0.024060066789388657, -0.04455583915114403, -0.008645719848573208, -0.027009662240743637, -0.06283998489379883, 0.04145469889044762, 0.0076290275901556015, -0.0570841059088707, 0.030940791592001915, 0.0762169286608696, -0.02694050967693329, 0.04948505014181137, -0.062471795827150345, -0.0034503783099353313, 0.013333253562450409, 0.04957076907157898, -0.03655536100268364, -0.021345358341932297, -0.07406368106603622, 0.04521477222442627, 0.056675851345062256, 0.03510155901312828, 0.0362970344722271, -0.05520045757293701, 0.020328329876065254, -0.0845516100525856, -0.015368878841400146, -0.02046632580459118, 0.03916105628013611, -0.0031014468986541033, 0.02397540770471096, -0.02116876095533371, 0.04727872461080551, 0.02873985283076763, 0.016009388491511345, -0.004026398062705994, 0.06589595973491669, -0.018779098987579346, -0.0141267916187644, 0.004854049999266863, 0.024222401902079582, 0.016792280599474907, 0.011679819785058498, 0.013533017598092556, 0.06246962770819664, 0.024619823321700096, 0.006823192350566387, -0.013849304988980293, 0.02464151941239834, 0.027356239035725594, -0.015181504189968109, -0.008395764045417309, 0.025731975212693214, -0.06056578457355499, 0.02147497609257698, -0.008909250609576702, -0.020952200517058372, -0.024837104603648186, -0.051413606852293015, 0.011202299036085606, -0.02362731099128723, -0.01982240192592144, 0.002992002060636878, 0.01504757534712553, 0.03638193756341934, 0.0731879398226738, -0.017091840505599976, 0.013968768529593945, -0.05111004784703255, 0.004609119612723589, -0.009102914482355118, 0.04379181191325188, -0.06612589955329895, -0.0351010337471962, 0.04497537016868591, -0.07041173428297043, -0.057843904942274094, 0.01215364970266819, 0.019175352528691292, -0.011778036132454872, 0.00036778621142730117, 0.007929880172014236, 0.01729774847626686, 0.0709722638130188, -0.0008691258844919503, -0.023036548867821693, -0.017150314524769783, -0.011654884554445744, 0.03130057454109192, -0.031278692185878754, 0.019005045294761658, -0.009122276678681374, 0.04271846264600754, -0.04094146564602852, -0.024904562160372734, -0.02783496305346489, -0.009843709878623486, 0.05064447224140167, -0.015938015654683113, 0.006670637521892786, -0.024317780509591103, 0.04370269924402237, 0.06747625023126602, 0.03408627584576607, -0.06336880475282669, -0.002330436836928129, 0.05995099991559982, -0.037425123155117035, -0.021494626998901367, -0.0061072553507983685, -0.002352858195081353, 0.02496880479156971, 0.07012544572353363, -0.0168807040899992, -0.009983872063457966, -0.0015921088634058833, 0.025787942111492157, -0.058549027889966965, -0.04487571120262146, 0.0006775335059501231, -0.04293542355298996, -0.0015546145150437951, 0.0022035492584109306, 0.042225953191518784, 0.01144400704652071, -0.016744395717978477, 0.004432787653058767, 0.07567537575960159, -0.043006569147109985, -0.03525524213910103, 0.012688926421105862, 0.00478369789198041, -0.02471011132001877, -0.0011218517320230603, -0.08830861002206802, -0.014104867354035378, 0.0004669243935495615, -0.030336346477270126, 0.03040109947323799, 0.013637016527354717, -0.05759168788790703, 0.049541592597961426, -0.04920252040028572, -0.021606329828500748, 0.035598114132881165, 0.009237361140549183, -0.029430342838168144, -0.043239522725343704, 0.06210806220769882, -0.008029179647564888, 0.03227447345852852, -0.05100245401263237, -0.01927073858678341, -0.0029726645443588495, -0.019758768379688263, -0.057024359703063965, 0.07430332154035568, 0.02909020334482193, -0.0503830686211586, 0.05840452387928963, -0.019643450155854225, -0.00847026240080595, 0.04400929808616638, -0.058997467160224915, -0.03667730838060379, -0.07591208815574646, 0.0031261518597602844, 0.020621463656425476, -0.05269031599164009, 0.05562480911612511, -0.03263456001877785, -0.016306279227137566, -0.031653761863708496, -0.04033182933926582, -0.08536019176244736, -0.03258489444851875, 0.0041848947294056416 ]