question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>In PADMANABHAN, Gravitation (Foundations and Frontiers), Cambridge, p $304$, exercice $7.6$, an example of the Schwarzschild metric in a different coordinate system is given : </p> <p>$$\mbox{d}s^2= -c^2\mbox{d}T^2 + \dfrac{4}{9}\left(\frac{9GM}{2(R-cT)}\right)^ {\large \frac{2}{3}} \mbox{d} R^2+\left(\frac{9GM}{2}(R-cT)^2\right)^ {\large \frac{2}{3}} \mbox{d}\Omega^2 \tag{7.52}$$</p> <p>The second part of the exercise is : </p> <blockquote> <p>"Consider observers located at fixed spatial coordinates. Show that they are on a free fall trajectory starting with zero velocity at infinite distances and that $T$ represents their proper time. This provides a simple interpretation of this coordinate system"</p> </blockquote> <p>I am afraid I don't really know how precisely to see this...</p>
g3999
[ 0.04028525948524475, 0.048312488943338394, -0.01888098567724228, 0.011968018487095833, 0.031776491552591324, 0.03252594918012619, 0.08416223526000977, 0.005709724500775337, -0.06926433742046356, -0.026536831632256508, -0.034829095005989075, 0.0067702098749578, 0.05395893380045891, -0.005467792507261038, -0.015557137317955494, -0.010096641257405281, 0.06656146794557571, -0.041990362107753754, 0.01515553705394268, -0.03570374846458435, 0.04413488879799843, -0.004673115909099579, -0.009512721560895443, -0.015399080701172352, 0.000509019591845572, -0.010675355792045593, 0.051750410348176956, 0.004097962751984596, -0.08647892624139786, 0.00029391926364041865, 0.011523757129907608, 0.04524976387619972, -0.0036377401556819677, 0.0038798523601144552, -0.0008904634742066264, 0.04234840348362923, 0.042656369507312775, -0.012841299176216125, -0.03884715586900711, -0.015616870485246181, 0.007808068301528692, -0.025019902735948563, -0.02868376486003399, -0.0037946247030049562, 0.010958687402307987, -0.013689853250980377, 0.000635669392067939, -0.029927510768175125, -0.003799291094765067, 0.021243005990982056, -0.030153080821037292, 0.10181227326393127, -0.006542142014950514, -0.031248202547430992, -0.06939197331666946, 0.04946361482143402, 0.010472875088453293, -0.0546654649078846, 0.005789844319224358, 0.02445165440440178, 0.02258402109146118, -0.02985609695315361, 0.0315762534737587, -0.0725933089852333, 0.05138259381055832, 0.016052942723035812, -0.04486847668886185, -0.03403201699256897, -0.023746419697999954, -0.03625689446926117, -0.005714023485779762, -0.035455863922834396, -0.035549480468034744, 0.05833708867430687, -0.08598414063453674, 0.03606535866856575, -0.01225798949599266, -0.015530023723840714, 0.024191003292798996, 0.01697404682636261, -0.05191424489021301, 0.011580800637602806, 0.010219557210803032, -0.020704396069049835, 0.08499949425458908, 0.03146693482995033, 0.030057547613978386, 0.044054970145225525, -0.07010425627231598, 0.05911385267972946, -0.002708939602598548, 0.00023408060951624066, 0.011728731915354729, 0.03366127237677574, 0.009631704539060593, -0.013337982818484306, -0.03767944127321243, 0.08770216256380081, -0.0031353964004665613, 0.014382919296622276, -0.07901105284690857, 0.06504365801811218, 0.003415517508983612, -0.02108324132859707, 0.015011497773230076, -0.055807992815971375, -0.004971714690327644, 0.04753772169351578, -0.02018912509083748, -0.06813076138496399, 0.021822327747941017, -0.04856431856751442, -0.02181900478899479, -0.013799340464174747, -0.0029590274207293987, -0.03306782990694046, 0.06516005098819733, -0.02374834381043911, -0.033352140337228775, 0.08535636961460114, 0.022306295111775398, 0.0032642590813338757, -0.009501034393906593, 0.02175106666982174, -0.010272949002683163, 0.002936902455985546, -0.014433556236326694, -0.0510832704603672, 0.027651377022266388, 0.015278014354407787, -0.013714936561882496, 0.014364711008965969, 0.017035266384482384, -0.01762768067419529, -0.05496601760387421, 0.05421510711312294, -0.014568340964615345, 0.022571761161088943, -0.020058562979102135, 0.01705368608236313, -0.032025400549173355, -0.08249332010746002, -0.040652353316545486, -0.026293430477380753, 0.03654424846172333, -0.010633890517055988, 0.024763410910964012, 0.015667231753468513, 0.054857827723026276, -0.02239895984530449, -0.016779981553554535, 0.07795541733503342, -0.004637227859348059, -0.0036436780355870724, -0.029666613787412643, -0.012107589282095432, -0.029835861176252365, -0.024252181872725487, -0.028613848611712456, 0.01244268100708723, 0.06378854811191559, 0.002864895621314645, 0.02298995666205883, 0.01425103098154068, -0.05181794613599777, 0.05455036461353302, -0.008711538277566433, -0.07194570451974869, 0.01451181061565876, -0.07152985036373138, -0.09072770178318024, -0.0077752647921442986, -0.008592762053012848, -0.034908123314380646, -0.03343529626727104, -0.017721429467201233, -0.02867039293050766, -0.0027811836916953325, 0.0245819129049778, 0.023598182946443558, 0.01349637471139431, -0.005174458026885986, 0.029137082397937775, -0.04057316109538078, 0.02559848502278328, 0.0017203987808898091, 0.05631774291396141, 0.0266154445707798, -0.005973933730274439, 0.005093198269605637, 0.007454736158251762, -0.026544813066720963, 0.022717997431755066, 0.08842115104198456, -0.044617000967264175, 0.03632130101323128, -0.008738472126424313, 0.008244357071816921, -0.038301147520542145, 0.062034972012043, -0.0022603031247854233, 0.02076135016977787, 0.0012201626086607575, 0.04196006432175636, 0.02617059461772442, -0.007766938768327236, 0.005337551236152649, 0.01985088922083378, -0.013390174135565758, -0.020862648263573647, 0.008185594342648983, -0.022094441577792168, 0.0024111964739859104, 0.024276994168758392, -0.06667903810739517, 0.0010381432948634028, -0.019015341997146606, 0.012696207500994205, -0.002549164928495884, 0.047827381640672684, -0.009383564814925194, -0.02733977511525154, 0.02155413292348385, -0.06844891607761383, 0.009508965536952019, 0.00543973920866847, -0.058648157864809036, -0.0034453014377504587, 0.04517747834324837, 0.01645618863403797, -0.03279882296919823, -0.00281161698512733, -0.01167961023747921, 0.007879928685724735, 0.07224979996681213, 0.009662658907473087, -0.004620295017957687, -0.010423016734421253, 0.04561121389269829, 0.027786001563072205, 0.043976642191410065, -0.004433006513863802, -0.052896976470947266, -0.04117245972156525, 0.08505618572235107, 0.019332416355609894, 0.06771973520517349, 0.03426755964756012, -0.04423114284873009, -0.005145240109413862, 0.008354664780199528, -0.012719632126390934, 0.0019048084504902363, -0.00013192025653552264, 0.0010881267953664064, 0.02842647023499012, -0.03669268637895584, 0.013372987508773804, -0.04960237443447113, -0.07866529375314713, 0.02753223106265068, -0.02329356223344803, -0.005466077476739883, 0.08667764067649841, -0.033035747706890106, 0.025969650596380234, -0.02572641894221306, 0.037343934178352356, -0.008756974712014198, -0.0025910523254424334, 0.005794245284050703, -0.0013127558631822467, 0.031064758077263832, 0.07950761914253235, -0.06364881247282028, 0.008970358408987522, -0.01630145125091076, -0.005182834342122078, 0.006230855826288462, 0.035169895738363266, -0.02392331324517727, 0.017213981598615646, -0.03481306880712509, 0.029007136821746826, 0.06048902869224548, -0.06561604887247086, 0.046910375356674194, 0.06453446298837662, 0.013221499510109425, -0.06556172668933868, 0.008094311691820621, 0.0666760727763176, 0.02422579936683178, 0.07068582624197006, -0.0473955012857914, 0.06890954077243805, 0.007257794961333275, -0.0315391980111599, 0.0008669192320667207, 0.008819451555609703, -0.0035869816783815622, -0.05240267142653465, 0.01925053633749485, 0.027452915906906128, 0.007341512478888035, -0.005413657054305077, 0.0055744582787156105, -0.02692890353500843, -0.04356720298528671, -0.031910546123981476, 0.033224400132894516, 0.025044335052371025, -0.0016858265735208988, -0.046898696571588516, -0.00727551756426692, 0.003062209812924266, -0.032937999814748764, -0.038413699716329575, -0.01575491577386856, 0.034255366772413254, -0.03167223185300827, -0.05706831440329552, -0.013958200812339783, 0.012938836589455605, 0.05234659090638161, 0.03888712823390961, -0.04928802698850632, -0.007226042915135622, -0.048075322061777115, -0.004908802453428507, -0.03090861067175865, 0.03627506643533707, 0.021601269021630287, -0.031908947974443436, -0.02858092449605465, -0.03434717282652855, 0.022651441395282745, 0.04318160191178322, 0.07237943261861801, -0.016216885298490524, -0.007886756211519241, 0.011721804738044739, -0.04349461570382118, 0.03294823318719864, 0.026750078424811363, -0.02824147418141365, 0.037605877965688705, 0.03385081887245178, 0.011727279983460903, -0.07278795540332794, 0.013032216578722, 0.00616582203656435, 0.03753408044576645, 0.0005134932580403984, -0.030402151867747307, 0.09058612585067749, 0.03722021356225014, 0.001936041284352541, -0.0061162253841757774, -0.009453777223825455, 0.024403337389230728, -0.016313783824443817, -0.05379757657647133, 0.05755690857768059, -0.00025777542032301426, -0.052742764353752136, -0.016150405630469322, 0.0020145121961832047, -0.01883784681558609, -0.050570130348205566, 0.061152275651693344, -0.018615933135151863, 0.011685439385473728, -0.014076916500926018, 0.047558508813381195, -0.07059448212385178, -0.01373213343322277, -0.015635516494512558, -0.03842698037624359, 0.010795553214848042, 0.038712989538908005, 0.003259187564253807, 0.025426695123314857, -0.039843007922172546, 0.04126308113336563, 0.0026997688692063093, -0.013199916109442711, -0.004948031157255173, 0.0028411983512341976, 0.01176808588206768, 0.027538007125258446, -0.044045478105545044, 0.04896007850766182, -0.017415624111890793, 0.016929805278778076, 0.028130972757935524, 0.01802911050617695, 0.011273612268269062, -0.05627062916755676, 0.026524392887949944, -0.022695327177643776, 0.02371523529291153, 0.010299086570739746, -0.021213948726654053, -0.01964070089161396, 0.0070911855436861515, 0.05202411115169525, 0.003795600263401866, 0.04782383516430855, 0.02233581617474556, 0.004944911692291498, -0.011201317422091961, 0.026599621400237083, -0.05321960151195526, 0.040556084364652634, -0.0036950737703591585, 0.014106989838182926, -0.005540266167372465, 0.016480127349495888, -0.001802585320547223, 0.02501630410552025, 0.017948884516954422, 0.02346836030483246, -0.0808146595954895, 0.01288448553532362, 0.04069017991423607, 0.02583584003150463, 0.040289506316185, -0.03794531896710396, -0.005147106479853392, -0.01866794191300869, 0.014148873277008533, 0.030822426080703735, 0.05061710253357887, -0.06067600101232529, 0.038529787212610245, 0.05702369660139084, 0.033576879650354385, -0.006789956241846085, 0.07461277395486832, -0.022705350071191788, 0.002776278415694833, -0.007968021556735039, -0.0362374372780323, 0.00039124966133385897, 0.0643591657280922, -0.02140703983604908, -0.08098530769348145, 0.051546480506658554, -0.0413726344704628, -0.0012598999310284853, 0.038986749947071075, 0.040125470608472824, 0.02445000223815441, 0.011813834309577942, -0.03227265924215317, -0.040454983711242676, 0.019791599363088608, -0.018178265541791916, -0.003408225253224373, -0.01994798518717289, -0.02630208060145378, -0.01419356931000948, 0.009641468524932861, -0.027656281366944313, 0.009560503996908665, -0.07569312304258347, -0.02321060374379158, -0.04026247188448906, -0.04805716872215271, -0.043927885591983795, 0.02873270958662033, 0.01809987798333168, -0.04219270497560501, 0.014817670919001102, 0.039875343441963196, 0.008683537133038044, -0.0002527087926864624, 0.08860457688570023, -0.04463639482855797, -0.0077440254390239716, -0.016078587621450424, 0.024044202640652657, -0.054489266127347946, -0.01128693949431181, -0.014429358765482903, -0.04598143696784973, -0.028174737468361855, -0.0019319116836413741, -0.03484240174293518, 0.04415237158536911, -0.05669747292995453, -0.019754920154809952, 0.020575324073433876, 0.0027961370069533587, 0.04192926362156868, 0.02329203113913536, -0.023610180243849754, 0.019187256693840027, -0.012051790952682495, -0.061171598732471466, -0.015073397196829319, 0.03628959134221077, 0.02152148261666298, -0.018403632566332817, 0.054913751780986786, 0.05441254749894142, 0.021072885021567345, 0.0003662178642116487, 0.03704763948917389, -0.029824772849678993, 0.0240823682397604, 0.026512566953897476, 0.05939682945609093, -0.040801435708999634, -0.060386933386325836, 0.0033824092242866755, 0.014583658427000046, -0.052617840468883514, -0.03012298420071602, -0.030775485560297966, -0.0031190975569188595, 0.05318819358944893, -0.021083086729049683, 0.04528633505105972, 0.005346841178834438, 0.001072343555279076, -0.01162034086883068, -0.002913725795224309, 0.0007490906864404678, 0.03130565211176872, -0.08444978296756744, -0.006555556319653988, -0.02027694322168827, 0.04676240310072899, -0.02415945939719677, -0.011343318037688732, -0.01310815755277872, 0.007352612912654877, -0.05875944718718529, -0.02503536455333233, -0.02234058454632759, 0.02124989591538906, 0.0034312093630433083, -0.042683590203523636, 0.020966000854969025, -0.040076613426208496, 0.03278261795639992, 0.01443255040794611, -0.05068295821547508, -0.07180070132017136, 0.02715141512453556, -0.0030678394250571728, 0.014999252744019032, 0.0246999841183424, 0.05381385236978531, -0.022103585302829742, 0.00652581499889493, -0.08346094191074371, -0.04854597896337509, 0.01197445672005415, 0.014581841416656971, -0.014528133906424046, 0.040981724858284, -0.02969207614660263, -0.02904459275305271, -0.04616296663880348, -0.00013685082376468927, 0.086006760597229, 0.012342410162091255, -0.005146697163581848, 0.01082972064614296, -0.02035493403673172, 0.0032352274283766747, -0.005905115511268377, -0.002865984570235014, -0.03659028932452202, -0.03179289773106575, 0.013038395904004574, 0.005262013990432024, -0.015507006086409092, 0.031072398647665977, 0.030192945152521133, -0.04386255890130997, -0.045166678726673126, 0.05211856588721275, -0.053158827126026154, -0.011493232101202011, 0.022021116688847542, 0.017262736335396767, -0.020832974463701248, -0.012082383967936039, -0.019789868965744972, -0.027710072696208954, -0.029420403763651848, -0.028593573719263077, 0.022670265287160873, -0.014836078509688377, -0.09164582937955856, -0.0035914224572479725, -0.012514473870396614, 0.03168404847383499, 0.05941137298941612, -0.0035876217298209667, 0.01841079629957676, 0.022898614406585693, -0.03356190398335457, -0.041048724204301834, 0.05800061300396919, 0.01624266989529133, -0.021888088434934616, 0.07752344757318497, -0.0011830455623567104, 0.10529502481222153, 0.013854516670107841, -0.04797029495239258, 0.06382723152637482, 0.0030748925637453794, -0.05271739140152931, -0.03338347002863884, 0.12095493823289871, -0.02904517389833927, -0.013501839712262154, -0.04853742569684982, 0.003915578126907349, 0.01176980510354042, -0.02061762660741806, 0.04175092652440071, -0.008227027952671051, -0.003473013173788786, 0.016706662252545357, 0.00768175907433033, -0.04051373898983002, -0.01187268365174532, -0.021984560415148735, 0.07672563940286636, -0.006778729148209095, 0.07366412878036499, 0.07018221169710159, 0.08783551305532455, -0.011168264783918858, -0.012273354455828667, 0.0021082472521811724, -0.048074930906295776, -0.04650112986564636, -0.007498340681195259, 0.008565928786993027, 0.012210885994136333, -0.04009274020791054, 0.0008545164600946009, 0.034566763788461685, -0.0280330628156662, -0.005680077709257603, 0.045972790569067, -0.016465606167912483, -0.03104313462972641, -0.00004553738472168334, 0.007076331414282322, 0.0048460946418344975, -0.05681547150015831, -0.027757879346609116, -0.03546223044395447, -0.0501057431101799, 0.022567899897694588, -0.035861752927303314, 0.0405195951461792, -0.019269436597824097, -0.007877806201577187, -0.01605549454689026, 0.032663557678461075, 0.01462106965482235, 0.043096959590911865, -0.009362959302961826, 0.0036717418115586042, -0.015696337446570396, 0.037751179188489914, 0.04588371887803078, 0.052846476435661316, -0.043313972651958466, -0.021004419773817062, 0.016419971361756325, 0.07335984706878662, -0.023752741515636444, 0.006059193983674049, -0.025103379040956497, 0.0065346527844667435, 0.040657784789800644, 0.03345058858394623, -0.034426670521497726, -0.019642489030957222, 0.00732799619436264, 0.11713171750307083, -0.04468793794512749, -0.04760273918509483, 0.024367330595850945, -0.029634328559041023, 0.04944712668657303, 0.050331901758909225, 0.02526891604065895, 0.009888916276395321, -0.007804693188518286, -0.010626654140651226, -0.04780523106455803, 0.08319992572069168, -0.016947772353887558, 0.006364554166793823, -0.0432913601398468, -0.034203074872493744, -0.01154983788728714, 0.03810306265950203, -0.00015865136811044067, 0.02573898434638977, 0.0024392702616751194, -0.020190393552184105, 0.0017578444676473737, -0.002663560677319765, -0.043130602687597275, 0.028366360813379288, -0.04488265514373779, -0.0569215789437294, 0.008860072121024132, -0.01858353428542614, -0.015387491323053837, -0.07134639471769333, -0.030132396146655083, 0.0037827666383236647, -0.023557797074317932, -0.02097385749220848, 0.010706726461648941, -0.019194530323147774, -0.041809238493442535, -0.019585762172937393, -0.03105364367365837, 0.03305390104651451, -0.0076715974137187, 0.0017213390674442053, -0.06464701145887375, -0.037358853965997696, -0.019851835444569588, -0.003857075236737728, -0.038605742156505585, 0.018147174268960953, -0.016418874263763428, 0.007278999779373407, 0.013542868196964264, -0.02146034501492977, 0.040718842297792435, 0.027498910203576088, 0.04988737776875496, -0.05636020749807358, 0.05230209231376648, 0.0677855834364891, 0.05686885118484497, -0.001576441340148449, 0.017233727499842644, -0.02918054163455963, -0.035491153597831726, -0.02060743421316147, 0.05593455582857132, -0.009368828497827053, -0.00971952360123396, -0.030864005908370018, -0.02066199854016304, 0.03042169101536274, -0.04368229955434799, -0.029693232849240303, -0.0061355819925665855, 0.04515204206109047 ]
<p>From my limited classical interpretation of the universe, i've always found it convenient to think of energy as what happens when an object isnt in its equilibrium position in the universe, and thus has some combination of the 4 fundamental forces acting on it to cause it to move to an equilibrium state.</p> <p>So in terms of the subatomic world, when people say for example that an electron can be at different energy levels, does that mean that either the electron or its internal components are farther from an equilibrium position and thus more energy will be used when the forces act on the electron? Or does my interpretation of energy fall apart at this level?</p> <p>My apologies if my lack of knowledge has caused me to pose the question in an ill formed manner.</p> <p>I was just really wondering if the concept of energy works along the same principles at the subatomic level</p>
g4000
[ 0.0027783482801169157, 0.029950562864542007, 0.0170927494764328, 0.00432612793520093, 0.010302540846168995, -0.006450708489865065, -0.02325068973004818, 0.042797405272722244, -0.08046896755695343, -0.006112508475780487, -0.005808051209896803, -0.03252940997481346, -0.053334303200244904, -0.05298944190144539, -0.017699427902698517, -0.022947324439883232, 0.05510426312685013, -0.02342676743865013, 0.0006900906446389854, 0.03601690009236336, -0.04870889335870743, 0.008912850171327591, -0.02561310864984989, 0.005905394442379475, -0.03365400433540344, 0.045498572289943695, -0.022245492786169052, 0.00029170361813157797, -0.05048908293247223, -0.03251750394701958, -0.025114282965660095, -0.00028114268206991255, 0.08849206566810608, -0.06899718940258026, -0.06545644253492355, -0.03741098567843437, 0.058590468019247055, 0.05835550278425217, 0.06006261333823204, -0.052998848259449005, -0.03210936114192009, -0.007101927883923054, -0.01303894817829132, -0.041339751332998276, 0.006021786015480757, -0.011355138383805752, -0.02683498151600361, -0.024153145030140877, 0.03184393420815468, -0.025466280058026314, 0.016092706471681595, 0.05124051868915558, -0.0005019247764721513, 0.076165109872818, 0.10623125731945038, 0.014273608103394508, 0.02930883690714836, -0.0023555236402899027, 0.06696119904518127, 0.03864891082048416, 0.03816019743680954, 0.05239907652139664, 0.04404091089963913, -0.0038193955551832914, 0.07957369834184647, 0.04558354243636131, -0.054574981331825256, 0.007512903772294521, -0.03065403364598751, -0.05406273901462555, 0.019427381455898285, -0.03416847810149193, -0.0681886076927185, -0.043195661157369614, -0.014398789033293724, -0.012390951626002789, 0.03050151653587818, -0.009616469033062458, 0.013766966760158539, 0.02145451307296753, 0.025220060721039772, -0.0035642054863274097, 0.06010662391781807, 0.04502974450588226, 0.08079592883586884, 0.005914181005209684, 0.003960908390581608, 0.04144672676920891, -0.0011626922059804201, -0.011418799869716167, 0.02396850660443306, 0.017059458419680595, 0.06521879881620407, -0.02744845300912857, -0.08710076659917831, 0.014666675589978695, -0.005884879268705845, 0.06591155380010605, -0.03286989405751228, -0.015307661145925522, -0.05713687464594841, -0.0057281083427369595, 0.022250862792134285, 0.004162381403148174, -0.023296961560845375, -0.024169934913516045, 0.012204447761178017, -0.04566043242812157, -0.012819679453969002, -0.008421110920608044, 0.009598019532859325, -0.037993110716342926, -0.02552228607237339, -0.011463450267910957, -0.058503955602645874, 0.019682299345731735, 0.05524754524230957, -0.012808454222977161, -0.015483296476304531, 0.02181990072131157, 0.009524890221655369, 0.07306206971406937, -0.002563351532444358, 0.023063555359840393, -0.02074751816689968, -0.02830151468515396, 0.0015052866656333208, -0.019948158413171768, -0.011650092899799347, -0.04907282069325447, 0.0283768642693758, -0.03234027698636055, -0.03538145124912262, -0.03346940129995346, -0.014590175822377205, 0.03199060633778572, -0.015124584548175335, -0.025221630930900574, 0.01180459838360548, 0.010458101518452168, 0.05351196601986885, 0.02091689594089985, -0.007759223226457834, -0.07063772529363632, -0.01986599713563919, -0.00593885313719511, -0.022382816299796104, 0.031238747760653496, 0.032791055738925934, 0.02295302040874958, 0.01609094627201557, 0.056481070816516876, 0.018034331500530243, -0.05450207740068436, 0.023816365748643875, -0.008313586935400963, -0.01997455209493637, 0.02001126855611801, -0.0184928085654974, 0.003623998025432229, 0.026616450399160385, -0.02034306339919567, 0.05392148345708847, 0.005156861152499914, -0.01340038888156414, 0.04332087188959122, 0.038491833955049515, -0.037401363253593445, 0.044427018612623215, -0.023610809817910194, -0.05555187538266182, -0.02594287134706974, -0.032854143530130386, 0.007711311802268028, 0.0034576922189444304, 0.060006532818078995, 0.03402428328990936, -0.028575384989380836, 0.025373635813593864, 0.009194155223667622, -0.03383403271436691, 0.0096593601629138, -0.025222172960639, -0.022114139050245285, 0.013300388120114803, 0.03752773255109787, -0.027189355343580246, 0.023442506790161133, 0.018995879217982292, 0.014061033725738525, 0.020366810262203217, 0.015674522146582603, 0.006511332467198372, -0.004389363806694746, -0.020273271948099136, -0.00933118350803852, -0.058152809739112854, -0.05324526131153107, -0.06144433468580246, -0.0749124214053154, 0.025588830932974815, -0.016099391505122185, -0.0003989326942246407, 0.007105085067451, 0.06266346573829651, 0.05916043743491173, -0.00733419694006443, 0.009341003373265266, 0.04895162954926491, -0.02952968142926693, 0.023703815415501595, 0.004628788214176893, 0.009468980133533478, 0.01905839517712593, -0.010454732924699783, -0.005714849103242159, 0.00420075748115778, 0.007116254419088364, 0.02471831627190113, 0.047035980969667435, -0.05046337470412254, 0.024309860542416573, 0.020978210493922234, 0.0304420106112957, 0.014001097530126572, -0.009416856802999973, -0.06160682812333107, -0.018436845391988754, -0.039425600320100784, 0.021307481452822685, -0.04458273574709892, 0.03849983587861061, 0.03103279136121273, -0.021633073687553406, 0.052650272846221924, 0.020177369937300682, -0.03068433329463005, -0.04550819471478462, 0.007233690936118364, 0.01085901353508234, 0.02052292414009571, -0.04568854346871376, -0.013768431730568409, 0.000878877704963088, 0.07881616055965424, -0.033518191426992416, 0.07001673430204391, -0.014865630306303501, 0.00944173987954855, 0.038171034306287766, 0.036393195390701294, -0.015500410459935665, -0.04791856184601784, 0.04560094326734543, -0.05531766265630722, -0.026083549484610558, -0.04584052413702011, 0.05463993176817894, -0.043477799743413925, -0.009792492724955082, 0.02973322756588459, 0.020790841430425644, 0.004387099761515856, 0.03803320601582527, -0.014232832007110119, -0.04593934118747711, 0.042236559092998505, 0.023999763652682304, -0.02125074341893196, 0.013636440970003605, -0.03135905787348747, 0.07170497626066208, -0.05918155983090401, -0.019668014720082283, -0.009177008643746376, -0.01981339603662491, 0.0022316372487694025, -0.027150865644216537, 0.018979839980602264, -0.025949686765670776, -0.03233354538679123, -0.00481804646551609, -0.02158985286951065, 0.01467587985098362, 0.05132049694657326, -0.03314065560698509, -0.0398106686770916, -0.022425109520554543, -0.061007820069789886, -0.006078506354242563, -0.024352964013814926, -0.021407173946499825, 0.028777306899428368, -0.014132783748209476, 0.03943268582224846, 0.004862185567617416, 0.051743872463703156, -0.047780342400074005, -0.08212244510650635, 0.06704556196928024, -0.05885940045118332, -0.05371067300438881, -0.056818004697561264, -0.03646961599588394, -0.018351130187511444, 0.056659430265426636, -0.026133369654417038, -0.03748343512415886, -0.04129587113857269, -0.030752358958125114, -0.03590141609311104, 0.05756625533103943, -0.0163753442466259, 0.015135723166167736, -0.04401375353336334, -0.004728633910417557, -0.0072871665470302105, 0.018376503139734268, -0.014592330902814865, -0.04251079261302948, -0.035025663673877716, 0.012542884796857834, 0.0009890350047498941, -0.010946061462163925, -0.02543032355606556, 0.06014476716518402, 0.0007974686450324953, -0.015220170840620995, -0.00588963832706213, 0.004758116789162159, 0.028414681553840637, -0.016080914065241814, -0.015816496685147285, 0.062259264290332794, -0.034281279891729355, -0.01796102337539196, -0.02935023047029972, -0.033827394247055054, 0.014438214711844921, 0.0377325713634491, 0.01206368301063776, 0.02742326632142067, 0.0535704605281353, -0.0031183473765850067, 0.013299930840730667, 0.03701212629675865, -0.083504818379879, 0.009526572190225124, -0.08041930943727493, -0.004662607796490192, 0.016308356076478958, 0.0016721870051696897, 0.019976574927568436, 0.01783887669444084, 0.0017166943289339542, -0.052645403891801834, 0.020414629951119423, 0.0008059541578404605, -0.035074472427368164, 0.04043034464120865, 0.029268257319927216, -0.03251698613166809, 0.05719877406954765, -0.02703823707997799, -0.03025820106267929, -0.016923876479268074, -0.03590722382068634, 0.005524786189198494, 0.027509702369570732, -0.01720406301319599, -0.0028847679495811462, -0.01825002022087574, -0.008209853433072567, 0.04087115079164505, 0.012634051963686943, -0.05041668936610222, 0.08400196582078934, -0.06566614657640457, -0.02289942279458046, -0.03758467361330986, 0.0639844760298729, 0.009165164083242416, -0.004654472693800926, 0.04313257336616516, 0.022468430921435356, 0.04694373905658722, -0.03538444638252258, 0.0014563852455466986, 0.021344369277358055, 0.008227298967540264, -0.011524164117872715, -0.05927129462361336, -0.01059600617736578, 0.037763841450214386, 0.021652674302458763, 0.012417360208928585, 0.010557069443166256, 0.007747812196612358, 0.051510151475667953, 0.02926276996731758, 0.016132760792970657, -0.009145286865532398, -0.04679425433278084, 0.01304175890982151, 0.0226930920034647, 0.047318506985902786, 0.04075761139392853, -0.043884627521038055, -0.043821413069963455, -0.059831589460372925, 0.06939003616571426, 0.00482654944062233, -0.0031073663849383593, -0.03398202732205391, -0.05566725879907608, -0.006214532535523176, -0.013901523314416409, -0.03472983092069626, 0.015084497630596161, 0.038017988204956055, 0.023568985983729362, 0.04507904127240181, -0.005671445280313492, -0.006107744760811329, -0.04398207738995552, 0.07070554792881012, 0.03584907203912735, 0.01223564799875021, -0.03643663227558136, -0.008329108357429504, 0.020192036405205727, 0.013179920613765717, 0.0042452034540474415, -0.03226645290851593, -0.06866755336523056, 0.007418576627969742, -0.015415179543197155, -0.01516973040997982, -0.028767293319106102, 0.03279581665992737, 0.07928375154733658, 0.05744495615363121, -0.01239368412643671, 0.02558797039091587, 0.004515233915299177, 0.07255171984434128, -0.08673609793186188, -0.0037790106143802404, -0.03529099002480507, -0.07171369343996048, -0.053613416850566864, 0.03157292306423187, -0.008725139312446117, -0.022982629016041756, -0.010539771057665348, -0.0903717577457428, -0.005266329273581505, -0.008260978385806084, 0.0008018995285965502, -0.03244839236140251, -0.07943320274353027, -0.0008932115160860121, -0.015315881930291653, 0.013438723050057888, 0.019514892250299454, 0.015207030810415745, -0.0777837261557579, 0.030633380636572838, -0.06584449857473373, 0.02429312653839588, 0.059339575469493866, -0.029956921935081482, 0.019787076860666275, -0.011691685765981674, 0.03619442507624626, -0.004618142731487751, -0.01524431724101305, -0.014579102396965027, 0.003348952392116189, 0.011238262057304382, -0.043300166726112366, 0.022707048803567886, 0.011818105354905128, 0.022439902648329735, -0.05628218501806259, 0.006346249487251043, -0.04606335982680321, 0.0012531508691608906, 0.03650975227355957, 0.0036999601870775223, 0.013293768279254436, 0.020584046840667725, 0.02649688720703125, -0.016791626811027527, -0.02018103562295437, 0.04115287587046623, 0.032998234033584595, -0.062771737575531, 0.009532279334962368, 0.023241963237524033, -0.011116684414446354, -0.0007759407162666321, -0.03173451870679855, 0.03852604329586029, 0.015392465516924858, 0.018996499478816986, 0.10672654956579208, -0.05987484008073807, -0.013771280646324158, -0.007745584938675165, 0.02062523365020752, 0.010369634255766869, -0.01737167499959469, 0.04853341728448868, -0.002916658064350486, -0.0266135074198246, 0.013086256571114063, 0.048058222979307175, -0.000009113768101087771, -0.010481356643140316, 0.014284906908869743, 0.0029538567177951336, 0.06392610818147659, -0.03824571520090103, 0.00884805154055357, 0.06308828294277191, 0.01951734535396099, 0.03867005184292793, 0.007688988000154495, 0.06024768203496933, 0.007336710579693317, 0.03174435347318649, 0.059639301151037216, 0.02922791615128517, -0.016283398494124413, -0.016579782590270042, -0.07434463500976562, 0.02466067112982273, 0.0372910350561142, 0.03337701037526131, 0.04652946814894676, -0.08514311164617538, -0.0028081138152629137, 0.026186544448137283, -0.0006262729875743389, -0.0008080175030045211, -0.09893135726451874, -0.005749927368015051, 0.024773433804512024, -0.004848924465477467, -0.004352713469415903, 0.06973359733819962, -0.054157570004463196, -0.008147264830768108, -0.0027428751345723867, 0.04802149534225464, 0.001184911816380918, -0.010737056843936443, -0.032497555017471313, -0.012292250990867615, 0.003123061265796423, 0.06123613193631172, 0.04870816692709923, 0.03195492550730705, 0.06283985823392868, -0.029233915731310844, -0.00316754006780684, -0.05698050186038017, 0.03964565694332123, 0.02405431866645813, 0.047894563525915146, 0.036833275109529495, -0.017833556979894638, -0.01277211308479309, -0.004727628082036972, -0.017197174951434135, -0.024517105892300606, -0.019458191469311714, -0.03990228474140167, 0.0289582759141922, -0.015447794459760189, -0.04284002259373665, -0.029223263263702393, 0.05015673488378525, -0.014907033182680607, 0.09064976125955582, -0.014752342365682125, 0.027872804552316666, 0.000600673200096935, -0.04968414455652237, 0.04471563920378685, -0.006437224335968494, 0.03419665992259979, 0.047164760529994965, -0.011430615559220314, 0.003601166419684887, 0.009157044813036919, -0.03915911912918091, -0.009325822815299034, 0.05382050573825836, 0.00598294660449028, -0.001767507754266262, 0.03707467019557953, -0.05912606418132782, 0.06731786578893661, 0.03732827678322792, -0.022598188370466232, 0.03775043413043022, -0.019407479092478752, 0.007997412234544754, -0.017235664650797844, 0.014183576218783855, 0.03956104442477226, -0.009881590493023396, 0.011940641328692436, -0.013796104118227959, -0.05071353167295456, 0.04279021546244621, 0.028898188844323158, 0.0011931322515010834, 0.00716980779543519, -0.009458920918405056, 0.027394721284508705, -0.02284984104335308, 0.022289158776402473, 0.06559091806411743, -0.06541124731302261, 0.06273495405912399, 0.09289824962615967, -0.0027249916456639767, -0.010950596071779728, -0.03980161249637604, 0.0649493932723999, 0.09983354806900024, -0.018171578645706177, -0.006038975901901722, -0.014541163109242916, 0.03215061500668526, -0.026758112013339996, 0.04274309054017067, -0.019829507917165756, -0.00017678692529443651, 0.06949051469564438, 0.024121856316924095, -0.007508779410272837, 0.019956452772021294, 0.031097745522856712, 0.058775465935468674, -0.039512284100055695, -0.029198911041021347, -0.030637111514806747, -0.015977101400494576, -0.0481962151825428, 0.0294620580971241, -0.0442594476044178, 0.03348434343934059, -0.07629998028278351, -0.01662762649357319, 0.05060605704784393, -0.0484599843621254, -0.018988458439707756, -0.00781386811286211, -0.010237232781946659, 0.015906233340501785, -0.05359727144241333, 0.0709262564778328, 0.01308848150074482, -0.02060702256858349, -0.08759071677923203, -0.030419522896409035, -0.020953478291630745, -0.08442221581935883, -0.06864798814058304, 0.018654033541679382, -0.040805354714393616, -0.00305341393686831, -0.03941771388053894, -0.002420182339847088, -0.0013482444919645786, 0.0015981773613020778, 0.00903487391769886, 0.05318513885140419, 0.010134010575711727, 0.03694527596235275, -0.02665887586772442, 0.015607297420501709, -0.048478782176971436, -0.059484004974365234, -0.034894492477178574, -0.018073687329888344, 0.008805222809314728, 0.02706725522875786, 0.047430846840143204, -0.04776713252067566, -0.05552653968334198, 0.012580563314259052, 0.0407906137406826, 0.06108153611421585, -0.0023185829631984234, -0.012426253408193588, 0.0006743621779605746, -0.023164408281445503, 0.030668331310153008, -0.03393152356147766, 0.023405831307172775, 0.006219702772796154, -0.04165179654955864, 0.03224196285009384, -0.05183190852403641, -0.00748504837974906, 0.018921641632914543, 0.017759984359145164, 0.07427047938108444, 0.06357041746377945, 0.002229810692369938, 0.009552092291414738, -0.011811546050012112, 0.021788228303194046, -0.03313954919576645, 0.07326442003250122, 0.013022856786847115, -0.033100713044404984, -0.017436761409044266, -0.012356968596577644, -0.01452203281223774, 0.00925499014556408, 0.009271927177906036, -0.033843640238046646, 0.012653120793402195, -0.048554155975580215, -0.00036819023080170155, -0.010563596151769161, 0.005089989397674799, -0.0000941833495744504, 0.01929648220539093, 0.02161179482936859, 0.02518618106842041, -0.054179318249225616, -0.0012545556528493762, -0.01947229728102684, 0.004700650926679373, -0.06357314437627792, 0.011351748369634151, 0.02197086252272129, -0.012460550293326378, -0.023617615923285484, -0.017107168212532997, -0.01898038573563099, 0.03833040967583656, 0.006313808262348175, -0.041557639837265015, -0.00866488367319107, -0.03456958010792732, -0.011621225625276566, 0.029237806797027588, -0.07449794560670853, 0.014568736776709557, -0.008653908036649227, -0.042162977159023285, 0.016211891546845436, 0.010040441527962685, 0.011191779747605324, 0.016530238091945648, -0.06236498802900314, -0.019061436876654625, -0.02426394820213318, -0.005567207001149654, 0.00230477936565876 ]
<p>In the gravity well-like 2d surfaces that are used in documentaries to illustrate the fact Earth orbits the Sun, I don't seem to find any kind of geodesic that will at least resemble an ellipse... What am I doing wrong? Is spacetime curved entirely different from what the animators show us? Any mathematical argument is apreciated but not neccesary... :)</p>
g4001
[ 0.02834676019847393, 0.05499282479286194, 0.008398976176977158, 0.008942663669586182, -0.010329115204513073, 0.07355077564716339, 0.021582605317234993, -0.05032973363995552, -0.015812845900654793, -0.05718304589390755, 0.048499103635549545, 0.0045226141810417175, 0.10979912430047989, 0.0391409732401371, -0.02384405955672264, -0.010454712435603142, 0.011284100823104382, -0.03303203731775284, 0.040084391832351685, 0.014933764934539795, 0.034922465682029724, -0.0067000798881053925, 0.05522036552429199, 0.008328251540660858, -0.06566818058490753, 0.0008455376955680549, -0.0012082665925845504, -0.0003455453843344003, -0.03629697859287262, 0.022890213876962662, 0.016773445531725883, 0.0070357732474803925, 0.012010038830339909, -0.041797272861003876, -0.012968885712325573, -0.023175552487373352, -0.013499966822564602, -0.006436964031308889, 0.03983594849705696, -0.004789634607732296, 0.005390321370214224, -0.014045275747776031, 0.008454043418169022, 0.07202034443616867, 0.02897263877093792, -0.025082740932703018, -0.004865607712417841, 0.042619578540325165, 0.056310396641492844, -0.04020664468407631, -0.010945037938654423, 0.04852059483528137, 0.059355590492486954, -0.06343719363212585, 0.01665777899324894, 0.010559968650341034, 0.03000776097178459, -0.0013178976951166987, 0.07041998952627182, 0.014819693751633167, -0.012595338746905327, 0.017164738848805428, 0.008460775017738342, 0.0064172944985330105, 0.05628018453717232, 0.02647407166659832, -0.02380882203578949, 0.013051282614469528, -0.013390341773629189, 0.03954800218343735, 0.04971669241786003, -0.01972774602472782, 0.03218687325716019, -0.0014568849001079798, -0.022213231772184372, 0.05625784397125244, 0.015930496156215668, 0.03975933790206909, 0.002984334947541356, -0.008966673165559769, 0.025413494557142258, 0.026258373633027077, -0.07321979105472565, -0.014252269640564919, 0.07810525596141815, -0.012427994050085545, 0.011069982312619686, 0.031266409903764725, -0.013507706113159657, -0.0003012488887179643, -0.019748860970139503, -0.04245681315660477, 0.0400044322013855, 0.03757735714316368, -0.03208490461111069, -0.06630286574363708, -0.01638125441968441, 0.05906682088971138, -0.01403140090405941, 0.021424854174256325, -0.01837315782904625, -0.01290986593812704, 0.017902081832289696, 0.018169935792684555, 0.027071168646216393, 0.016108261421322823, -0.03959367424249649, -0.0011484556598588824, 0.06103246659040451, -0.07706663012504578, 0.028658807277679443, 0.023202061653137207, -0.005960121750831604, -0.017216457054018974, -0.024531513452529907, -0.024823596701025963, 0.02986872009932995, -0.012356803752481937, 0.048596300184726715, 0.057240117341279984, 0.04480796307325363, 0.028834214434027672, 0.02111726626753807, 0.030762629583477974, 0.022151002660393715, 0.014115570113062859, -0.021224696189165115, -0.03800065815448761, 0.027230631560087204, 0.002497617620974779, 0.010592817328870296, 0.03722833842039108, -0.011761265806853771, -0.005503037478774786, -0.004141299054026604, 0.02166290394961834, -0.055645495653152466, -0.035965386778116226, -0.060899171978235245, 0.01211730670183897, 0.015922212973237038, -0.00032043427927419543, 0.026861723512411118, -0.04674737900495529, -0.03738037496805191, -0.047394707798957825, -0.00838968064635992, -0.010816356167197227, 0.023771433159708977, -0.03185117244720459, -0.04362082481384277, 0.07725610584020615, 0.05607207864522934, -0.041344135999679565, -0.006197011098265648, 0.00005453861740534194, 0.004909951705485582, -0.027774058282375336, 0.03136667236685753, 0.05066317692399025, 0.06473094969987869, 0.024915728718042374, 0.02480936236679554, -0.023936396464705467, -0.004186335019767284, -0.02235330641269684, 0.0018567030783742666, -0.014156601391732693, 0.03343428298830986, 0.02198541909456253, -0.026852000504732132, -0.03027000091969967, 0.01100896392017603, 0.04510363191366196, -0.06654145568609238, 0.030434194952249527, 0.029266906902194023, -0.022820735350251198, 0.008188669569790363, 0.02720273658633232, -0.0042556282132864, -0.005163407884538174, -0.01920892670750618, -0.005232815630733967, 0.03315228968858719, -0.023368623107671738, -0.01683058589696884, -0.007787994109094143, -0.036320678889751434, -0.03453028202056885, 0.03305189311504364, -0.02337249554693699, -0.0243732538074255, 0.00026952545158565044, 0.04706401750445366, 0.031879495829343796, 0.09188743680715561, -0.03793665021657944, -0.009457682259380817, 0.056409358978271484, 0.017008036375045776, 0.03396191447973251, 0.026448145508766174, 0.018843792378902435, -0.07722736895084381, -0.014243397861719131, -0.02140715904533863, -0.007766111753880978, -0.028270801529288292, 0.009411623701453209, 0.023090526461601257, 0.004175218753516674, -0.0010133410105481744, -0.02618381753563881, 0.004022296983748674, 0.04105563089251518, -0.03085262142121792, -0.06146126613020897, -0.03920076787471771, -0.0004287150804884732, 0.010033032856881618, 0.0023176800459623337, 0.02365434169769287, -0.05225808173418045, 0.10842816531658173, 0.00124005984980613, -0.0025600704830139875, -0.014065022580325603, 0.05547040328383446, -0.0029829975683242083, -0.0268537774682045, -0.05905958637595177, 0.03841745853424072, 0.018618304282426834, 0.016781959682703018, -0.027444321662187576, 0.008679570630192757, 0.02191082388162613, 0.006150231231004, -0.009296044707298279, 0.03213958069682121, -0.024671420454978943, -0.043275199830532074, 0.0051331291906535625, 0.09670624881982803, -0.020678984001278877, 0.048974476754665375, 0.007454161997884512, -0.010119747370481491, 0.06755568832159042, 0.04465942084789276, -0.06746650487184525, -0.09401416033506393, 0.06604331731796265, 0.05017685890197754, -0.016999315470457077, -0.05051513761281967, 0.01300011295825243, -0.03878439590334892, -0.030842160806059837, -0.05297315865755081, -0.01947186514735222, -0.0062921675853431225, 0.010122825391590595, -0.0604228600859642, -0.05086599290370941, -0.01771598309278488, -0.02233324944972992, 0.02595091611146927, 0.022567039355635643, -0.04382918030023575, 0.05697426572442055, -0.026192594319581985, 0.025927359238266945, -0.07773632556200027, -0.0094760125502944, -0.0030215175356715918, 0.007634412497282028, -0.03932975232601166, -0.038313452154397964, 0.02742157131433487, 0.005580469500273466, -0.005050335545092821, 0.042856164276599884, 0.05649086833000183, -0.017743932083249092, -0.019673164933919907, 0.04530471935868263, -0.024767717346549034, 0.01379577349871397, -0.0230338703840971, -0.0051032318733632565, -0.01053876243531704, 0.007324041798710823, -0.0492977574467659, -0.02265201136469841, -0.027280107140541077, 0.04724935069680214, -0.016834108158946037, 0.03185924142599106, -0.03253292292356491, 0.013994673267006874, 0.03000112995505333, 0.07231661677360535, -0.06712006032466888, -0.006620142143219709, -0.002353571355342865, -0.09804143756628036, 0.0017065179999917746, -0.03156960383057594, -0.0021283775568008423, -0.006771504413336515, -0.0052401116117835045, 0.023965775966644287, 0.055955350399017334, -0.025007890537381172, -0.025532472878694534, 0.008257322013378143, 0.05841672793030739, 0.07773060351610184, -0.03881604224443436, 0.004781306255608797, -0.04256446659564972, 0.040063027292490005, -0.03824034705758095, 0.05720497667789459, 0.001959239598363638, -0.021631721407175064, -0.03705636411905289, -0.015531599521636963, 0.03176452964544296, 0.008929048664867878, 0.017332838848233223, 0.02372412383556366, 0.026202235370874405, -0.00469303410500288, -0.06733907014131546, -0.024995485320687294, 0.06799174100160599, -0.03682473674416542, -0.07190627604722977, 0.03891044482588768, -0.0454501174390316, -0.030410239472985268, 0.008584653958678246, -0.04846862331032753, -0.0028872406110167503, 0.02209530770778656, -0.0232281181961298, -0.04157806560397148, 0.03082936443388462, -0.005231522489339113, 0.015052299946546555, -0.022788282483816147, 0.03333665058016777, 0.013719683513045311, 0.035769570618867874, -0.0023488840088248253, -0.011735012754797935, -0.01600675843656063, -0.014942127279937267, 0.0015751738101243973, -0.04224565625190735, -0.04063207283616066, 0.01930127665400505, -0.023089945316314697, -0.013281194493174553, 0.03645063564181328, -0.04806126654148102, -0.013735651969909668, 0.05150485038757324, 0.025676744058728218, 0.0021075212862342596, 0.014025989919900894, -0.016513314098119736, -0.020289262756705284, -0.0243931133300066, 0.015590162947773933, -0.031556516885757446, -0.03019741363823414, 0.05431593582034111, 0.0291130430996418, 0.031929757446050644, 0.005111007485538721, -0.00747187715023756, 0.006174047943204641, 0.02927287481725216, -0.0655229240655899, 0.0022185631096363068, -0.03435423597693443, 0.02819051593542099, -0.02762802504003048, 0.024227377027273178, -0.03970813751220703, 0.020161742344498634, -0.014048938639461994, 0.04559092968702316, 0.033709149807691574, -0.012480600737035275, 0.0068884300999343395, 0.03462390601634979, 0.04860830307006836, -0.011220516636967659, 0.017270486801862717, -0.010397259145975113, -0.05175696685910225, 0.01723542809486389, -0.008393152616918087, -0.018823010846972466, 0.00020586038590408862, 0.04856094345450401, 0.025576151907444, 0.0468127578496933, -0.0438806489109993, 0.051132433116436005, 0.030143525451421738, -0.07402664422988892, 0.04213685542345047, -0.0004320835287217051, -0.0024311246816068888, -0.01229291595518589, 0.11024857312440872, -0.022447966039180756, -0.014277401380240917, -0.0005700328038074076, 0.08215072751045227, 0.016365114599466324, -0.0483841635286808, -0.0384286567568779, -0.026658963412046432, 0.029303131625056267, -0.010499997064471245, 0.00986512377858162, 0.023608069866895676, -0.030248094350099564, 0.03435082361102104, -0.0035406299866735935, 0.05020453780889511, 0.006605101283639669, 0.01781705766916275, 0.020831404253840446, -0.007563480641692877, 0.022613506764173508, -0.058360688388347626, -0.03774147853255272, 0.044992510229349136, -0.061663057655096054, -0.02596394158899784, -0.047753382474184036, 0.02307460829615593, -0.012718566693365574, 0.0024657552130520344, 0.024204151704907417, 0.040616367012262344, -0.03621947392821312, 0.034764181822538376, -0.03965015336871147, 0.03730258718132973, -0.047510694712400436, 0.01644923910498619, -0.03715513274073601, -0.03448592126369476, -0.015552317723631859, 0.03855770826339722, -0.015110233798623085, -0.034382179379463196, -0.11046187579631805, -0.021977903321385384, -0.006624691188335419, 0.00374233047477901, -0.05312095209956169, 0.06328915804624557, 0.008349407464265823, 0.0024211753625422716, -0.05618181824684143, 0.026119541376829147, -0.033525463193655014, -0.02055470459163189, 0.004437583964318037, -0.05606796592473984, -0.06701704114675522, 0.023714445531368256, 0.005566770676523447, 0.03000548481941223, 0.0179317407310009, 0.03397659584879875, -0.01128682866692543, 0.04307105392217636, 0.000015341671314672567, 0.03803892061114311, 0.03138700872659683, -0.0360078439116478, 0.008465959690511227, -0.07990643382072449, -0.030181439593434334, 0.000549105869140476, 0.017559446394443512, -0.034581009298563004, 0.035495907068252563, 0.016563376411795616, -0.06206146255135536, 0.05476834625005722, -0.029101045802235603, -0.024765823036432266, 0.06033119931817055, 0.05077129229903221, 0.0668875202536583, -0.016590947285294533, -0.033495545387268066, 0.05596457049250603, -0.026405496522784233, -0.04571983590722084, -0.03890838846564293, -0.03306509181857109, 0.08197617530822754, -0.0664747878909111, -0.024530082941055298, 0.031042352318763733, -0.019774608314037323, 0.028759527951478958, 0.06254690885543823, -0.001494729658588767, -0.006474436726421118, -0.030467012897133827, 0.06691455096006393, 0.0013474546140059829, -0.03849861025810242, -0.022319454699754715, 0.034532126039266586, 0.025782689452171326, 0.0165447648614645, -0.049288637936115265, -0.038970090448856354, -0.06689067929983139, 0.0011928626336157322, -0.04554992914199829, 0.06084758788347244, 0.007173377554863691, 0.09832265228033066, -0.047551266849040985, -0.052231695502996445, -0.015041396021842957, -0.022488171234726906, 0.07008901238441467, -0.01909741386771202, -0.01938481628894806, 0.018355725333094597, 0.018261784687638283, 0.06987355649471283, -0.02763936296105385, -0.028505442664027214, 0.027025116607546806, 0.014933690428733826, 0.02944713830947876, -0.06910112500190735, 0.044517431408166885, -0.015220914036035538, 0.0027444122824817896, -0.004298445302993059, -0.05274393409490585, 0.0027311877347528934, 0.029291270300745964, 0.006897367537021637, -0.010563031770288944, -0.057053036987781525, -0.027279788628220558, 0.019443601369857788, 0.012319713830947876, 0.0646037831902504, 0.021653611212968826, -0.015482247807085514, -0.07193681597709656, -0.002964012324810028, 0.023485803976655006, -0.04925786331295967, -0.07976772636175156, -0.01606411300599575, 0.012497375719249249, -0.04141923412680626, -0.0013862387277185917, 0.0011978762922808528, 0.017323436215519905, 0.06102230027318001, -0.022081268951296806, 0.0012503761099651456, 0.016084663569927216, -0.017277248203754425, 0.03452201932668686, -0.03533896058797836, -0.04822291433811188, -0.03632016107439995, 0.004653127398341894, -0.00943837035447359, 0.01697026751935482, 0.0029910109005868435, -0.0013287063920870423, -0.013708707876503468, 0.06921705603599548, -0.016043992713093758, -0.05203336849808693, -0.007178239058703184, 0.008040525019168854, 0.04379748925566673, -0.033784110099077225, 0.03186891973018646, 0.017967132851481438, -0.03381001204252243, 0.023512890562415123, 0.010358142666518688, -0.06254206597805023, -0.00430671451613307, 0.07917022705078125, -0.01732577010989189, 0.02159816212952137, -0.02922239527106285, -0.007054855581372976, 0.017870629206299782, -0.048111751675605774, 0.02630757726728916, -0.055923547595739365, 0.042733196169137955, 0.05273839086294174, 0.014468098059296608, -0.04120102524757385, 0.0057905614376068115, 0.007643014192581177, -0.06844086199998856, 0.012528127059340477, -0.006917527411133051, -0.014080269262194633, -0.03404231742024422, -0.00539620965719223, -0.018494736403226852, 0.05362558364868164, 0.0006412464426830411, 0.017903892323374748, -0.02995983324944973, 0.04735862836241722, 0.02363588660955429, 0.03754274919629097, -0.020434394478797913, 0.00827481597661972, 0.0005582297453656793, 0.012687047943472862, -0.05992720648646355, 0.017030814662575722, -0.056003667414188385, 0.01074009109288454, -0.03876665234565735, 0.017017055302858353, 0.02996732108294964, -0.0392722450196743, 0.02893492765724659, -0.015105397440493107, -0.018267154693603516, 0.028492840006947517, -0.06704917550086975, -0.020765431225299835, 0.010336074978113174, -0.08007960766553879, -0.030746623873710632, -0.020303620025515556, -0.034612756222486496, -0.014925728552043438, -0.06626202166080475, 0.012118530459702015, -0.05886778607964516, 0.04137832298874855, -0.05282297730445862, 0.0394841767847538, 0.026832090690732002, 0.02732233889400959, 0.0030759654473513365, 0.037675123661756516, -0.006649393122643232, -0.0259106382727623, -0.0027807247824966908, 0.012149776332080364, -0.019200656563043594, -0.006847782991826534, 0.026660460978746414, 0.0877620205283165, 0.08812510967254639, -0.0045511298812925816, -0.04751995950937271, 0.0013091637520119548, 0.013767003081738949, -0.02611352503299713, -0.07921434938907623, 0.024629829451441765, 0.023611174896359444, 0.078244648873806, -0.03795517608523369, 0.016716841608285904, 0.011038672178983688, 0.0038060115184634924, -0.0233465489000082, 0.005982877686619759, -0.023093197494745255, -0.07520991563796997, 0.0013768732314929366, 0.019992036744952202, -0.025412028655409813, 0.041421204805374146, 0.03115575760602951, -0.01334734819829464, 0.011313953436911106, -0.009300152771174908, -0.02554081752896309, -0.011601114645600319, 0.015369120985269547, 0.029792949557304382, -0.013789325952529907, 0.011715877801179886, 0.05688348039984703, 0.008918184787034988, -0.028494173660874367, 0.0077805789187550545, 0.0246479120105505, -0.04400410130620003, -0.02663632668554783, -0.03334526717662811, -0.006910804659128189, -0.007503478787839413, 0.02032366581261158, 0.013257874175906181, 0.03437826409935951, -0.06803037971258163, 0.005075536668300629, -0.0036791921593248844, 0.004798248875886202, 0.0832497850060463, 0.037447188049554825, 0.02075941488146782, -0.06136767193675041, -0.03209744393825531, -0.024495849385857582, -0.08798062056303024, -0.038472749292850494, -0.027423543855547905, -0.02184096910059452, -0.01269639190286398, 0.03789656609296799, -0.08893265575170517, 0.04394630715250969, -0.004896116908639669, 0.008422575891017914, 0.04762878268957138, -0.001725516514852643, -0.02498333901166916, -0.005877353250980377, -0.002357267076149583, 0.024096783250570297, -0.015388472937047482, 0.01808501034975052, -0.02822737768292427, 0.025323161855340004, -0.07072700560092926, 0.05905839055776596, -0.011555533856153488, 0.011184245347976685, -0.017029954120516777, -0.0008404558175243437, -0.015084899961948395, -0.03733693063259125, -0.023505253717303276, -0.022407157346606255, 0.048200882971286774 ]
<p>For generators of the Lorentz group we have the following algebra: $$ [\hat {R}_{i}, \hat {R}_{j} ] = -\varepsilon_{ijk}\hat {R}_{k}, \quad [\hat {R}_{i}, \hat {L}_{j} ] = -\varepsilon_{ijk}\hat {L}_{k}, \quad [\hat {L}_{i}, \hat {L}_{j} ] = \varepsilon_{ijk}\hat {R}_{k}. $$ For the splitting of algebra, we can introduce operators $$ \hat {J}_{k} = \hat {R}_{k} + i\hat {L}_{k}, \quad \hat {K}_{k} = \hat {R}_{k} - i\hat {L}_{k}. $$ So $$ [\hat {J}_{i}, \hat {J}_{j} ] = -\varepsilon_{ijk}\hat {J}_{k}, \quad [\hat {K}_{i}, \hat {K}_{j} ] = -\varepsilon_{ijk}\hat {K}_{k}, \quad [\hat {J}_{i}, \hat {K}_{j}] = 0. $$ So, each irreducible representation of Lie algebra is characterized by $(j_{1}, j_{2})$, where $j_{1}$ is max eigenvalue of $\hat {J}_{3}$ and $j_{2}$ is max eigenvalue of $\hat {K}_{3}$.</p> <p>Then I can classify objects that transform through the matrices of the irreducible representations, $$ \Psi_{\mu \nu}' = S^{j_{2}}_{\mu \alpha }S^{j_{2}}_{\nu \beta}\Psi_{\alpha \beta}, $$ where $S^{j_{i}}_{\gamma \delta}: (2j_{i} + 1)\times (2j_{i} + 1)$.</p> <p>For $(0, 0)$ I have scalar field, for $\left(\frac{1}{2}, 0\right); \left(0; \frac{1}{2}\right)$ I have spinor, for $(1, 0); (0, 1)$ I have 3-vectors $\mathbf a, \mathbf b -&gt; \mathbf a + i\mathbf b$ creating antisymmetrical tensor etc. </p> <p>Also, for scalar $j_{1} + j_{2} = 0$, for spinor - $\frac{1}{2}$, for tensor - $1$. So, the question: is sum $j_{1} + j_{2}$ experimentally observed? Is it connected with a spin?</p>
g4002
[ -0.05804336816072464, -0.037590231746435165, -0.026190415024757385, -0.03055422753095627, 0.005875843111425638, -0.03756328299641609, 0.05143342539668083, 0.03332262858748436, 0.029512805864214897, 0.01610191911458969, -0.0830894336104393, 0.05670860782265663, 0.021383240818977356, -0.0013478915207087994, -0.02069501206278801, -0.007278867065906525, 0.06488143652677536, 0.029125863686203957, -0.019853970035910606, -0.09823784232139587, -0.0485590398311615, 0.06876350939273834, -0.019587818533182144, -0.02569533884525299, 0.073405921459198, -0.004414058290421963, 0.047178104519844055, -0.050620339810848236, -0.015525326132774353, -0.018733998760581017, 0.05081189051270485, 0.02649800479412079, -0.025102080777287483, -0.09835412353277206, 0.011519474908709526, -0.05737069249153137, 0.06460437923669815, 0.029099399223923683, -0.006065929774194956, -0.017686832696199417, 0.010493326932191849, 0.0010565037373453379, -0.016498373821377754, -0.0021968481596559286, -0.048291776329278946, -0.015077060088515282, 0.007743720430880785, 0.00729716569185257, 0.0034426383208483458, 0.0471469946205616, 0.020731335505843163, -0.0016880364855751395, 0.06218928471207619, -0.01958017610013485, 0.01823176071047783, -0.00045529287308454514, -0.046555884182453156, -0.020211156457662582, 0.007654193323105574, 0.022018902003765106, -0.03905373439192772, -0.0149775305762887, -0.018248483538627625, 0.008230328559875488, 0.045958202332258224, -0.01025540754199028, -0.022794686257839203, 0.02034658007323742, -0.03388874977827072, 0.013226057402789593, -0.001287042978219688, 0.012180840596556664, 0.10468277335166931, 0.00839871633797884, 0.009855006821453571, -0.00027622285415418446, 0.04839058965444565, 0.05271044373512268, 0.011049316264688969, 0.04025664180517197, 0.059203073382377625, -0.04044177383184433, -0.01918898895382881, -0.01871911622583866, 0.01590636931359768, 0.026225415989756584, -0.01922670751810074, 0.0065452177077531815, 0.017686353996396065, 0.03768843039870262, 0.07231244444847107, -0.04166460782289505, 0.025298060849308968, 0.02183297649025917, -0.020954953506588936, 0.011698885820806026, 0.009389186277985573, 0.004923645872622728, -0.078931525349617, -0.02749546989798546, -0.029399439692497253, 0.05216842144727707, 0.0579037182033062, -0.023200837895274162, 0.008706063032150269, 0.0503983236849308, 0.04269278049468994, -0.0668693259358406, 0.0008934736833907664, 0.03315992280840874, -0.03702092170715332, -0.012388703413307667, 0.01174232829362154, -0.01789703033864498, -0.06714152544736862, -0.02404235489666462, 0.0008595364051871002, -0.026036091148853302, -0.02301786094903946, 0.07272940874099731, 0.023665402084589005, -0.011696232482790947, -0.003992792684584856, 0.05610731989145279, -0.006614494603127241, 0.018281549215316772, 0.018062571063637733, -0.02074408531188965, 0.03581421449780464, -0.07376574724912643, -0.03550989553332329, -0.014014523476362228, 0.00445042597129941, 0.045960038900375366, -0.011115378700196743, 0.03436584025621414, -0.01400145422667265, 0.02178712747991085, 0.000645301362965256, -0.019522104412317276, -0.009472224861383438, -0.013451664708554745, -0.02792261354625225, -0.006756634917110205, -0.0068021370097994804, -0.03897909075021744, 0.05346950143575668, -0.08073482662439346, -0.0029315887950360775, 0.039556555449962616, -0.014322054572403431, 0.021659420803189278, -0.007826974615454674, 0.010412498377263546, 0.02024407498538494, -0.02898375876247883, -0.015983616933226585, -0.003507334040477872, 0.056959882378578186, -0.0064699770882725716, 0.033905696123838425, -0.03654302656650543, 0.02086123451590538, -0.009006546810269356, -0.06435061246156693, -0.009901998564600945, 0.025051308795809746, -0.008925179950892925, 0.01411144994199276, -0.010070753283798695, -0.007223024964332581, 0.02041417732834816, 0.013193102553486824, -0.003360325936228037, 0.027666479349136353, 0.03612488880753517, -0.02988697774708271, -0.005031156819313765, -0.011979402974247932, 0.02244529314339161, -0.05781852453947067, -0.014503924176096916, 0.007070630323141813, -0.03094572015106678, 0.0331677682697773, 0.01384727843105793, -0.028997011482715607, 0.046052709221839905, -0.02415900118649006, -0.009837601333856583, 0.0030390953179448843, 0.10047238320112228, 0.01813257485628128, 0.004099416546523571, -0.04107779636979103, 0.020122084766626358, 0.020846525207161903, -0.05970602110028267, -0.0658058151602745, 0.02660123072564602, 0.030720163136720657, 0.05900118499994278, 0.0008589945500716567, -0.014859484508633614, -0.060508161783218384, -0.030998438596725464, -0.002512620994821191, 0.02942066639661789, -0.007016648538410664, -0.0019412353867664933, 0.024264724925160408, -0.059931352734565735, 0.05878618732094765, 0.023441093042492867, -0.07136375457048416, -0.041208621114492416, 0.04778153449296951, -0.03620780631899834, -0.007342149503529072, 0.04829534515738487, 0.04562366008758545, -0.030250726267695427, 0.08635107427835464, 0.007173540536314249, -0.03649016097187996, 0.009640238247811794, 0.006297199986875057, -0.029445229098200798, 0.027553727850317955, 0.011197838932275772, -0.05359400808811188, 0.022522222250699997, -0.001016530324704945, -0.03969805687665939, 0.0123604666441679, -0.03306439518928528, -0.0044090645387768745, 0.013502965681254864, 0.002206681529060006, -0.052474260330200195, 0.0638430267572403, 0.006535186432301998, -0.053574077785015106, -0.01979161612689495, 0.03814442455768585, 0.024773981422185898, 0.01371074840426445, 0.007627300452440977, -0.023348316550254822, 0.0350998155772686, -0.01263509877026081, -0.02845936454832554, 0.0053003630600869656, 0.010691637173295021, 0.008118157275021076, -0.01848536729812622, 0.04444897547364235, 0.008141777478158474, -0.0269183162599802, 0.024750061333179474, -0.00962996855378151, 0.026737211272120476, 0.012835264205932617, 0.026746727526187897, -0.0836930125951767, 0.013586736284196377, -0.002843952039256692, -0.0065600196830928326, -0.024506492540240288, -0.02090190351009369, -0.11300971359014511, 0.052229732275009155, 0.02567708119750023, 0.0554695688188076, -0.0764942616224289, 0.032076407223939896, -0.04631120339035988, 0.010731498710811138, -0.02931199036538601, -0.043713126331567764, -0.012269655242562294, 0.035581689327955246, 0.007194321136921644, 0.02875646948814392, -0.02893420122563839, -0.03797013312578201, -0.03954000398516655, 0.00889723189175129, 0.010283360257744789, 0.07488144189119339, -0.028425060212612152, -0.00015742886171210557, 0.028525881469249725, -0.024365216493606567, -0.03846254199743271, -0.005134142469614744, -0.011022106744349003, -0.059091635048389435, -0.009364528581500053, 0.06926791369915009, 0.03351312130689621, -0.06606922298669815, 0.045531127601861954, -0.043417491018772125, 0.01528966799378395, -0.030919935554265976, -0.06292641907930374, -0.011965052224695683, -0.002463376149535179, -0.02323221229016781, -0.08122515678405762, 0.022413812577724457, 0.012808012776076794, -0.025847025215625763, 0.012989582493901253, 0.004058272577822208, 0.010463046841323376, -0.016508029773831367, 0.012184982188045979, -0.058356598019599915, -0.00003967625161749311, 0.004503651987761259, 0.02703924849629402, 0.02450568974018097, 0.0194737259298563, -0.014186535961925983, -0.050452493131160736, 0.002159809460863471, -0.022467367351055145, -0.032926540821790695, -0.034396544098854065, -0.025613369420170784, 0.02758098766207695, 0.07299387454986572, -0.04701990261673927, -0.004001317545771599, -0.0692203938961029, 0.024363048374652863, -0.031661007553339005, -0.07911399006843567, -0.012131905183196068, -0.02799166552722454, -0.0250631645321846, -0.009769298136234283, -0.020842233672738075, 0.03746137022972107, -0.05954677239060402, 0.012063062749803066, 0.009656350128352642, 0.016626182943582535, -0.030376404523849487, 0.03468113765120506, 0.038448113948106766, -0.03349587693810463, -0.002882840111851692, -0.01329138595610857, 0.06389923393726349, 0.028948402032256126, -0.009595638141036034, -0.010686415247619152, -0.004625920671969652, 0.030366336926817894, 0.0365857258439064, -0.038379039615392685, -0.0810738056898117, 0.02830236405134201, 0.012593011371791363, -0.026097584515810013, -0.01466620247811079, 0.05748547613620758, 0.01877165026962757, -0.015597298741340637, -0.012895886786282063, 0.033856283873319626, -0.05041182041168213, -0.006864815950393677, 0.013095050118863583, -0.026082847267389297, -0.02585865743458271, 0.01013406366109848, -0.009231625124812126, 0.034422822296619415, 0.06592405587434769, 0.039951715618371964, 0.010237263515591621, 0.046194661408662796, 0.07051772624254227, 0.02017262764275074, -0.004935206845402718, -0.010889544151723385, 0.04037405923008919, 0.018183555454015732, 0.005705320276319981, 0.00225115311332047, -0.011463039554655552, -0.023172743618488312, -0.005263608414679766, -0.011569893918931484, -0.047334372997283936, 0.03276577591896057, -0.056587688624858856, -0.00005212927135289647, 0.008875473402440548, -0.036467377096414566, -0.00481224013492465, -0.019661959260702133, 0.02211676724255085, -0.01913507655262947, 0.02345895953476429, 0.019437186419963837, -0.049415223300457, 0.049195777624845505, 0.03226296976208687, -0.07263686507940292, 0.06660445779561996, -0.004537871107459068, -0.01755998283624649, -0.007947167381644249, 0.006706249434500933, -0.048077572137117386, 0.0313749685883522, 0.02548118866980076, 0.049763090908527374, 0.015547757036983967, 0.017540166154503822, -0.0037623688112944365, 0.08290719240903854, -0.0004859413602389395, -0.07224491983652115, -0.015649696812033653, 0.01939525082707405, -0.021797779947519302, 0.0169421024620533, 0.003005736041814089, -0.07538469135761261, -0.023072216659784317, -0.07240390032529831, 0.07669074833393097, 0.017528995871543884, 0.03303644061088562, 0.055073875933885574, 0.03289421275258064, 0.042298574000597, -0.0034778702538460493, 0.031114444136619568, -0.003614066168665886, 0.01879344880580902, -0.009293080307543278, 0.03664589300751686, -0.0012941102031618357, -0.027702469378709793, 0.010362722910940647, 0.02892226353287697, -0.010561686009168625, 0.05004207789897919, 0.012927702628076077, 0.006426135543733835, 0.011235194280743599, 0.004433947615325451, 0.03204329311847687, 0.037275511771440506, -0.02938072942197323, -0.04303839057683945, 0.010609579272568226, -0.001087200827896595, -0.029598820954561234, -0.07450433820486069, -0.000004918107606499689, -0.023955291137099266, -0.02220156416296959, 0.039594341069459915, -0.0074012926779687405, 0.009083922952413559, -0.003777818288654089, 0.004169789608567953, 0.03834937512874603, -0.06766583770513535, -0.0059537687338888645, -0.08026402443647385, 0.01961231604218483, 0.01296386681497097, -0.00561240129172802, -0.005190498661249876, -0.020531129091978073, 0.025317702442407608, 0.07773749530315399, -0.0007690702914260328, -0.01324931625276804, 0.004446081817150116, -0.015751756727695465, -0.019828500226140022, 0.010018575936555862, -0.00682027405127883, -0.03611977770924568, 0.002351089846342802, 0.0248706117272377, 0.008246708661317825, -0.08349133282899857, 0.006942024454474449, 0.0816400796175003, -0.004979363176971674, 0.03971696272492409, 0.051684364676475525, 0.003400450339540839, -0.023164132609963417, -0.01397595927119255, 0.05125798285007477, 0.015744173899292946, -0.006842979695647955, 0.09139865636825562, 0.013792352750897408, 0.029414670541882515, 0.05138068646192551, -0.013539419509470463, -0.0016242519486695528, -0.022495564073324203, 0.001852725283242762, 0.055822309106588364, -0.010061404667794704, -0.03661243990063667, -0.041533052921295166, -0.04362814128398895, 0.02445884607732296, -0.038028743118047714, 0.023643897846341133, 0.07362831383943558, -0.029672257602214813, -0.024229247123003006, 0.0013885019579902291, 0.0035683554597198963, 0.018112989142537117, 0.002226858399808407, 0.0365627184510231, -0.02492826245725155, 0.08039313554763794, -0.09295050799846649, 0.03895161300897598, -0.031767550855875015, -0.006378720514476299, 0.028845427557826042, 0.004977433010935783, -0.09077032655477524, 0.020581737160682678, 0.03559811785817146, 0.0045103817246854305, -0.015433968044817448, -0.020952241495251656, -0.0022018603049218655, 0.045871492475271225, 0.016832292079925537, -0.02193971537053585, -0.019230583682656288, 0.033998437225818634, 0.03365777060389519, 0.025874007493257523, -0.025953136384487152, -0.05688827484846115, -0.0038098676595836878, -0.012446639128029346, 0.028500810265541077, -0.008262032642960548, 0.03402227163314819, -0.028745826333761215, 0.007850464433431625, 0.0049672513268888, -0.007086270023137331, 0.03619641810655594, -0.07443288713693619, 0.03170134872198105, 0.02548154629766941, -0.0026015613693743944, 0.03453803434967995, 0.059590477496385574, 0.01777324639260769, 0.04004311189055443, 0.009318417869508266, 0.034946516156196594, -0.040385887026786804, 0.0024875570088624954, -0.003044125624001026, 0.034031473100185394, -0.033674996346235275, -0.0035291635431349277, -0.003243205603212118, -0.0159857589751482, 0.026940273120999336, -0.0509028285741806, 0.025059670209884644, -0.014628399163484573, -0.03215169906616211, -0.02932043932378292, 0.019736265763640404, -0.042592622339725494, -0.0345882773399353, -0.0009002059232443571, 0.01597560942173004, 0.02352748066186905, 0.020854519680142403, -0.007804260589182377, 0.020403007045388222, 0.04694727435708046, -0.014188679866492748, 0.016955668106675148, 0.03519759699702263, -0.021949904039502144, 0.053917210549116135, -0.1085629016160965, 0.005373518913984299, -0.0016393050318583846, 0.03773945942521095, 0.005226346664130688, -0.02151687815785408, -0.06503468751907349, 0.03349737450480461, -0.012270160019397736, -0.005927093792706728, 0.0157063789665699, 0.012438702397048473, -0.025310155004262924, -0.007056709844619036, 0.024633705615997314, 0.022673306986689568, -0.017912445589900017, -0.04117191210389137, 0.02901139110326767, 0.08838607370853424, 0.04503776133060455, -0.014823571778833866, -0.03212703391909599, 0.03485218062996864, 0.04121967405080795, 0.012362245470285416, -0.026890074834227562, 0.0003573076974134892, 0.027130309492349625, -0.029008835554122925, -0.03431588411331177, 0.06377630680799484, 0.05967346951365471, 0.10493402928113937, -0.0038921874947845936, 0.03313056007027626, -0.03697298839688301, 0.045103225857019424, 0.03195451200008392, 0.027922602370381355, 0.011315656825900078, 0.020730607211589813, -0.09612967073917389, 0.013108253479003906, 0.03936735913157463, 0.029829299077391624, -0.0014914443017914891, -0.047772157937288284, -0.10103292763233185, -0.040758971124887466, 0.039666853845119476, 0.0407833494246006, 0.020280996337532997, -0.04703480005264282, -0.049682486802339554, 0.0027165566571056843, -0.0271990317851305, -0.053817786276340485, -0.03282869979739189, 0.011488907039165497, -0.011059860698878765, 0.04508165642619133, -0.013614920899271965, -0.039091918617486954, -0.07476703822612762, -0.061143435537815094, 0.002831050893291831, -0.01086590625345707, -0.0478067584335804, -0.013975187204778194, 0.018447590991854668, 0.01739935390651226, -0.01302336249500513, -0.02991514280438423, -0.060085590928792953, 0.05737090855836868, -0.04135960340499878, 0.043578557670116425, -0.036862507462501526, 0.008032946847379208, -0.010579070076346397, -0.021641189232468605, 0.013622726313769817, 0.00038875231985002756, 0.0031431361567229033, 0.043054595589637756, 0.04744841903448105, 0.028733693063259125, -0.05190800130367279, -0.036612287163734436, -0.026479501277208328, 0.04091479629278183, 0.011483117938041687, 0.043853387236595154, -0.01338530145585537, 0.006011342164129019, -0.007038416340947151, 0.007678937632590532, 0.03365890309214592, -0.008769058622419834, 0.012944279238581657, 0.006921388208866119, -0.01168316975235939, -0.03391304612159729, -0.07571802288293839, 0.022133847698569298, -0.06155388057231903, 0.004983707796782255, 0.031905677169561386, 0.05796419829130173, -0.024456756189465523, 0.021625392138957977, 0.023253198713064194, 0.005160269793123007, 0.06342189759016037, 0.021154101938009262, -0.02467975579202175, -0.01648900844156742, -0.02223154902458191, -0.0361078716814518, 0.062488432973623276, 0.006586379837244749, 0.016920486465096474, 0.016651364043354988, -0.02151252143085003, 0.024761708453297615, -0.12109300494194031, 0.04401438683271408, -0.047531239688396454, 0.017955951392650604, -0.015802912414073944, -0.037189457565546036, 0.025885416194796562, 0.018015246838331223, -0.03572067245841026, -0.04542079567909241, -0.0018305963603779674, 0.0328381210565567, -0.04194425418972969, -0.004366359673440456, -0.04690350592136383, -0.029323281720280647, -0.0002466563892085105, -0.016011500731110573, -0.045856546610593796, 0.024638468399643898, 0.027577731758356094, 0.07497542351484299, 0.02996421977877617, 0.008433962240815163, 0.01689021848142147, -0.006581406574696302, 0.0493837334215641, -0.003951537422835827, -0.04463357850909233, -0.027194302529096603, -0.04094075411558151, 0.0391530804336071, -0.0178245697170496, -0.07615304738283157, -0.0027189727406948805, 0.07525503635406494 ]
<p>It just occurred to me that almost all images I've seen of the (in)famous mushroom cloud show a vertical column rising perpendicular to the ground and a horizontal planar ring parallel to the ground. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/yqTdB.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Not that I'm an expert (that's why this question) but I have rarely seen anything go in the 45 degree angle. Or for that matter anything other than the 'special' 0 degree horizontal plane and 90 degree vertical column. Shouldn't there be radial vectors at all angles between 0 and 90 degrees giving rise to a hemispherical explosion envelope? Why is it a vertical cylinder? </p> <p>PS: I understand the top expands eventually on cooling and lowered air pressure giving the mushroom look but my questions is for the previous stage - the vertical column.</p>
g4003
[ 0.02871151827275753, 0.0342390201985836, 0.01557961106300354, 0.043371234089136124, 0.045866794884204865, 0.015622694976627827, 0.051872123032808304, 0.021195879206061363, -0.046780992299318314, -0.01979447901248932, -0.034155890345573425, 0.04546758905053139, 0.06523515284061432, -0.017560558393597603, 0.06063856557011604, -0.048820994794368744, -0.03795264661312103, -0.06483037024736404, -0.010989879257977009, 0.0019000004976987839, -0.018081268295645714, -0.020740041509270668, -0.01786520890891552, 0.0530720017850399, -0.017109734937548637, -0.01552433893084526, -0.023088011890649796, 0.006405800115317106, -0.011563180945813656, 0.03450029715895653, -0.00777290016412735, 0.03792813792824745, -0.007458899170160294, 0.013157150708138943, -0.004155505448579788, -0.03683054819703102, -0.010133124887943268, 0.012775617651641369, 0.010972573421895504, -0.0000903367908904329, -0.02888479083776474, -0.0327979251742363, 0.011804817244410515, 0.018758531659841537, -0.022999301552772522, 0.026549886912107468, -0.030486319214105606, 0.01988070085644722, -0.04316195473074913, 0.019974423572421074, -0.02023310773074627, -0.04209360107779503, 0.01752156764268875, 0.009341170080006123, 0.007752172648906708, 0.042868271470069885, 0.026883255690336227, -0.014140799641609192, 0.003136092098429799, 0.06016881763935089, -0.03756329044699669, 0.049746572971343994, 0.04481657221913338, 0.01091931201517582, 0.04005303606390953, -0.03454018756747246, -0.0899791568517685, 0.03809770569205284, -0.009833055548369884, 0.04255389794707298, 0.037849850952625275, -0.05369306355714798, 0.003383355215191841, -0.0095527870580554, -0.05919544771313667, 0.017806142568588257, 0.010034440085291862, -0.06738720089197159, 0.01840203069150448, -0.009646477177739143, 0.017315050587058067, 0.042489055544137955, 0.007076648063957691, -0.06921350955963135, 0.056670062243938446, 0.05760776624083519, 0.03301363065838814, -0.05496674031019211, -0.009475916624069214, 0.0022342612501233816, 0.002228535246104002, 0.007793389726430178, 0.034971561282873154, 0.007661082781851292, 0.0012828727485612035, -0.07518575340509415, -0.04486001282930374, 0.0701834186911583, -0.012545811012387276, 0.004176782444119453, -0.001272070687264204, -0.01921706832945347, 0.03476528078317642, 0.005534397903829813, -0.03497588261961937, 0.031715571880340576, -0.03407328203320503, -0.009603695012629032, 0.017584960907697678, -0.06101194769144058, -0.05404167249798775, -0.05583903193473816, -0.04903498664498329, 0.02921988256275654, -0.004243483766913414, -0.03397378697991371, 0.06052063778042793, 0.025339866057038307, 0.03483014926314354, 0.039521053433418274, 0.039126500487327576, 0.012896450236439705, -0.006017834413796663, 0.03431195020675659, -0.039823148399591446, -0.008097950369119644, 0.07564486563205719, -0.025839949026703835, -0.013875236734747887, -0.05662485584616661, -0.0037986361421644688, -0.008503605611622334, 0.0027197995223104954, 0.0315876379609108, 0.09693194925785065, -0.012000671587884426, -0.053601741790771484, -0.004870201461017132, -0.0021229563280940056, -0.023333240300416946, 0.0065399655140936375, 0.0004808642843272537, 0.056846197694540024, -0.016383714973926544, 0.037604883313179016, -0.017281780019402504, 0.04216201603412628, 0.05925695225596428, 0.03497275710105896, 0.012730560265481472, -0.07852235436439514, 0.0373186357319355, 0.004293995443731546, -0.05857796221971512, -0.02860112674534321, 0.04206923395395279, 0.02883215993642807, 0.0009754637139849365, 0.023470602929592133, 0.039475951343774796, 0.012067700736224651, 0.03092745877802372, 0.010106116533279419, -0.01470471452921629, -0.0809553861618042, 0.016622746363282204, 0.017500346526503563, 0.007888494059443474, 0.03134303167462349, -0.05232514441013336, -0.04436076804995537, -0.029485318809747696, -0.02871459163725376, 0.02395249530673027, -0.017436157912015915, 0.03416749835014343, 0.07059299200773239, -0.009459361433982849, 0.03446055203676224, -0.03519168496131897, -0.047782786190509796, -0.04620230570435524, -0.019099410623311996, -0.027424439787864685, 0.05687912926077843, -0.040128134191036224, 0.024120787158608437, 0.07116595655679703, -0.05329935625195503, 0.014095071703195572, 0.033071260899305344, -0.011460533365607262, -0.04325016587972641, 0.05230327695608139, 0.0459536612033844, -0.07021358609199524, 0.015982497483491898, 0.03350028023123741, -0.0712374597787857, 0.07411177456378937, -0.02211863175034523, 0.015622377395629883, 0.053197696805000305, 0.0513625293970108, -0.014421844854950905, 0.08122582733631134, -0.009253001771867275, 0.02533561922609806, 0.08074021339416504, 0.020049219951033592, -0.06920771300792694, -0.02872047759592533, 0.028948135673999786, 0.012383311055600643, 0.018631216138601303, 0.03607458621263504, 0.03953444957733154, -0.012250588275492191, -0.021341463550925255, -0.030974775552749634, 0.004476516507565975, -0.04903798550367355, 0.013665292412042618, -0.039636433124542236, 0.03759923204779625, -0.0229922067373991, -0.042633481323719025, 0.028002271428704262, 0.030810849741101265, 0.003419233951717615, -0.05606812983751297, 0.0151389604434371, 0.014870686456561089, -0.07280202955007553, -0.043596018105745316, 0.026369858533143997, 0.0412711538374424, -0.037523552775382996, 0.012446828186511993, -0.03446953743696213, -0.03140190988779068, -0.039982520043849945, -0.024396492168307304, 0.03537897393107414, 0.029507620260119438, -0.005664338823407888, 0.034804392606019974, -0.027509961277246475, -0.05319457873702049, 0.0028967224061489105, 0.018461989238858223, -0.03496423363685608, -0.04691203311085701, 0.03734841197729111, -0.033904463052749634, 0.0014939666725695133, -0.07903207093477249, -0.01654735580086708, -0.049051593989133835, -0.06779105961322784, -0.062257684767246246, -0.033648062497377396, 0.009258868172764778, 0.012229949235916138, -0.11876638233661652, 0.040309175848960876, -0.08321863412857056, -0.023808825761079788, -0.028543366119265556, -0.01505176443606615, -0.053247351199388504, 0.06002671644091606, 0.003245495492592454, 0.04710838198661804, -0.08363447338342667, 0.0337190106511116, -0.008147835731506348, 0.07439401000738144, -0.030593477189540863, -0.0032004753593355417, -0.013481146655976772, 0.03730602189898491, -0.002725079422816634, 0.008479169569909573, 0.03816984221339226, -0.010966403409838676, -0.01357970666140318, 0.017867274582386017, -0.050685666501522064, -0.006153631955385208, -0.05388578400015831, 0.032757874578237534, -0.025833474472165108, -0.0025648826267570257, 0.008707193657755852, -0.012872863560914993, 0.07526114583015442, -0.04593506455421448, -0.054556794464588165, 0.03195785731077194, -0.03541499376296997, -0.030776582658290863, 0.0256691612303257, -0.0029255934059619904, -0.007476845756173134, 0.0401909202337265, 0.012336188927292824, -0.044265009462833405, -0.043298982083797455, 0.0008986548637039959, -0.04110575094819069, 0.007175214122980833, -0.05366482958197594, 0.029816441237926483, -0.022692732512950897, -0.034221574664115906, -0.011462817899882793, 0.05148492008447647, 0.005952517036348581, 0.094327911734581, -0.06531774252653122, -0.03454406559467316, -0.00032480890513397753, 0.003418685169890523, -0.021595830097794533, -0.023942263796925545, -0.03502308949828148, 0.011019266210496426, 0.0382404550909996, -0.03448357805609703, 0.007702572271227837, 0.01651824824512005, 0.0383293442428112, -0.003951304592192173, 0.0038481701631098986, 0.0257148128002882, -0.07117403298616409, -0.024766316637396812, 0.005497082602232695, -0.0338449664413929, -0.005877988412976265, 0.015338544733822346, -0.007574627175927162, -0.03003505989909172, 0.010637694969773293, -0.0004311039228923619, 0.009438080713152885, -0.0150671461597085, 0.00912387389689684, -0.010117837227880955, 0.04542938992381096, -0.02012042887508869, 0.03830930218100548, -0.020081615075469017, -0.00014580594142898917, 0.021870329976081848, 0.053477391600608826, 0.024142466485500336, 0.003402498783543706, 0.04368800297379494, -0.030676601454615593, -0.009489491581916809, 0.006642123218625784, 0.04270442575216293, -0.0036662952043116093, 0.02615559846162796, -0.029394757002592087, 0.05729985237121582, 0.012894298881292343, 0.006523037329316139, -0.032628364861011505, 0.04433756321668625, -0.016337307170033455, -0.026694107800722122, 0.05166177451610565, 0.029169172048568726, -0.010745342820882797, -0.0036976682022213936, -0.021766778081655502, 0.029347922652959824, -0.003524970728904009, -0.07845465838909149, 0.00743471272289753, -0.012807665392756462, -0.047524187713861465, 0.031705379486083984, -0.05724501609802246, -0.0036737071350216866, -0.005519448779523373, -0.04942737892270088, -0.010846206918358803, -0.0034949732944369316, -0.04646702855825424, -0.024136116728186607, -0.030666038393974304, 0.029101692140102386, 0.046268805861473083, 0.007002982310950756, -0.02333376742899418, 0.04678843542933464, 0.04961356893181801, -0.038338080048561096, 0.04569447040557861, -0.0272089634090662, -0.008664154447615147, 0.023793702945113182, 0.00713206734508276, 0.017758727073669434, 0.025316234678030014, -0.010993435978889465, 0.12191928923130035, 0.08316963165998459, -0.04436304792761803, -0.030556010082364082, 0.12286090105772018, -0.03966506943106651, 0.04472995176911354, 0.039351966232061386, 0.020884595811367035, 0.0016994824400171638, -0.004152711480855942, 0.04091886058449745, -0.02663325145840645, 0.012467543594539165, 0.009463971480727196, 0.035435184836387634, 0.016227612271904945, -0.04483513906598091, -0.0597386360168457, 0.009008519351482391, -0.012331451289355755, -0.004524268675595522, 0.05516804754734039, -0.0018233144655823708, -0.023677505552768707, 0.021611709147691727, -0.017447499558329582, 0.013685787096619606, 0.029090488329529762, 0.04010200500488281, 0.0584060437977314, -0.012134910561144352, 0.010280399583280087, -0.030920717865228653, -0.010182364843785763, 0.044530414044857025, 0.007652805652469397, 0.022768547758460045, -0.04052849858999252, -0.0037339094560593367, -0.033584825694561005, 0.052457090467214584, 0.03158373758196831, -0.006708516739308834, -0.011093232780694962, -0.0953211709856987, -0.008398560807108879, 0.0030540097504854202, 0.03394144028425217, -0.01154538244009018, -0.04274061322212219, -0.03141392394900322, -0.04291228950023651, -0.002887887414544821, 0.0039147245697677135, 0.006133273243904114, -0.03539566323161125, -0.013620862737298012, 0.016918588429689407, 0.034941382706165314, -0.030732043087482452, -0.017637109383940697, 0.04013620316982269, 0.043874066323041916, -0.03857789933681488, 0.014784608967602253, 0.05155898258090019, -0.038674257695674896, 0.06705118715763092, -0.0644640251994133, 0.0035353978164494038, 0.0014874564949423075, 0.024383990094065666, 0.006792614236474037, 0.009736146777868271, -0.0029571671038866043, 0.00814744085073471, -0.01531090959906578, 0.04390620440244675, -0.006839449983090162, 0.004508881364017725, 0.013139239512383938, -0.10702415555715561, -0.01879976876080036, 0.04885484278202057, -0.06331004202365875, 0.07051490247249603, -0.020949464291334152, -0.017996057868003845, -0.023837832733988762, -0.055398937314748764, -0.007502331864088774, -0.005803219508379698, 0.03673410415649414, 0.005010064225643873, 0.045617371797561646, 0.06442619115114212, -0.008231417275965214, 0.05370630323886871, 0.042288705706596375, 0.023683417588472366, -0.07027758657932281, 0.030553890392184258, 0.00873061828315258, -0.03516898304224014, -0.0548764243721962, 0.026913538575172424, 0.04666398465633392, 0.015508422628045082, 0.0027647404931485653, -0.011623498052358627, -0.02168973907828331, -0.019627107307314873, -0.0007566720014438033, 0.005776870995759964, -0.0021895472891628742, -0.06797346472740173, -0.002522032940760255, 0.012920745648443699, 0.055605120956897736, -0.06409706920385361, -0.04080382362008095, -0.00561811588704586, 0.020321179181337357, -0.02148449793457985, -0.006309401709586382, 0.017454663291573524, 0.014903535135090351, 0.10364846885204315, -0.03712845221161842, -0.027360234409570694, -0.07286986708641052, -0.01471421867609024, 0.06615838408470154, -0.028492968529462814, -0.013936979696154594, 0.025127427652478218, 0.043797556310892105, 0.028447825461626053, 0.026338398456573486, -0.04710029438138008, 0.0581207275390625, -0.011503043584525585, 0.03983538970351219, -0.008798515424132347, -0.02935674972832203, -0.015036786906421185, -0.018185794353485107, 0.04608714208006859, -0.036713555455207825, 0.0616610012948513, -0.021113580092787743, 0.0021509421057999134, 0.03093409352004528, -0.03692075237631798, 0.0035374274011701345, -0.058745965361595154, 0.013711517676711082, 0.05986559018492699, 0.012407663278281689, -0.012539361603558064, -0.051932211965322495, 0.01825324445962906, 0.032315414398908615, 0.06980938464403152, 0.010816526599228382, -0.013567635789513588, 0.060279954224824905, 0.022791670635342598, 0.03469891473650932, 0.03195371851325035, 0.007443796377629042, 0.08134762197732925, -0.03734138235449791, 0.01256378274410963, -0.03502397984266281, -0.08240971714258194, 0.01597774587571621, 0.015759598463773727, -0.008074563927948475, -0.05650486797094345, 0.0247382540255785, -0.035553134977817535, 0.010291464626789093, -0.02007954567670822, -0.02091776207089424, -0.0462493821978569, 0.06124721094965935, 0.0014474119525402784, -0.05353204905986786, 0.043920718133449554, 0.024585185572504997, -0.020702484995126724, 0.03336316719651222, 0.009981376118957996, -0.038481973111629486, -0.0032969487365335226, 0.04150596261024475, -0.008729678578674793, 0.0020791369024664164, 0.06652111560106277, 0.046303655952215195, 0.0248907208442688, -0.021205954253673553, -0.0006447808118537068, -0.05543342977762222, -0.007081084884703159, 0.018855301663279533, 0.010656096041202545, -0.01735524833202362, -0.030047785490751266, 0.02252153679728508, -0.008753937669098377, -0.04251696914434433, 0.018891172483563423, 0.013414881192147732, -0.011770240031182766, 0.033952221274375916, -0.014657970517873764, 0.018204079940915108, 0.0030035418458282948, 0.0539093054831028, -0.025767548009753227, -0.008151284419000149, 0.03623342514038086, -0.007241737563163042, 0.03336909040808678, -0.04075159877538681, 0.03232455626130104, 0.021524276584386826, 0.020235687494277954, -0.013339484110474586, -0.03875438868999481, -0.02480255253612995, 0.0032144817523658276, 0.01388416439294815, 0.010039168410003185, -0.050377316772937775, 0.0030627953819930553, 0.01479812990874052, 0.022855492308735847, 0.008993876166641712, -0.056808363646268845, 0.008593479171395302, -0.04309564828872681, 0.004115059040486813, 0.04788052663207054, -0.0422833189368248, 0.020880060270428658, -0.031847644597291946, -0.011427945457398891, 0.030598986893892288, 0.025559330359101295, -0.0337819866836071, -0.0418228879570961, -0.040287118405103683, 0.05836661905050278, -0.016882728785276413, 0.007672468665987253, -0.0034924570936709642, 0.015079864300787449, 0.013747354038059711, -0.040413402020931244, -0.03133675828576088, -0.04499446600675583, -0.002726860111579299, -0.018727904185652733, 0.015227152965962887, -0.01579902321100235, -0.0014334898442029953, -0.030096009373664856, 0.018556244671344757, 0.027034753933548927, -0.03975403308868408, -0.014499111101031303, -0.0045907506719231606, -0.015337735414505005, -0.03433806449174881, -0.027595380321145058, -0.00552383391186595, -0.00044372864067554474, 0.04728793725371361, 0.005096249282360077, -0.006825574673712254, 0.013041195459663868, 0.03137195110321045, -0.009207850322127342, -0.021321086212992668, -0.04987610876560211, -0.025296425446867943, 0.024625929072499275, -0.014662093482911587, 0.04161376133561134, 0.0005933491047471762, 0.0765906497836113, 0.006726638879626989, -0.0071581630036234856, 0.07696294039487839, -0.027939243242144585, -0.0014168188208714128, 0.0064070094376802444, 0.03514094278216362, 0.06070861965417862, 0.0002288881951244548, -0.013882017694413662, 0.025058988481760025, -0.03809744119644165, -0.005951322615146637, -0.03618562966585159, -0.05403419956564903, -0.08585427701473236, -0.005492359399795532, -0.044556088745594025, -0.08770284801721573, 0.02720922790467739, 0.014246714301407337, -0.011327777057886124, 0.002820871537551284, 0.029708677902817726, -0.016282983124256134, 0.02317930944263935, 0.05875644087791443, -0.030853427946567535, 0.057672735303640366, 0.013180828653275967, 0.008312664926052094, 0.010959737934172153, -0.020219534635543823, 0.021812502294778824, -0.03784792125225067, 0.005122621543705463, -0.008345301263034344, -0.03808676078915596, -0.021703246980905533, -0.03275443613529205, -0.000552330631762743, -0.013349528424441814, 0.01997411623597145, 0.006535546388477087, -0.01998763345181942, 0.034056179225444794, -0.005594691727310419, -0.0027258843183517456, 0.015008574351668358, -0.024300940334796906, 0.005842641927301884, 0.006764428690075874, 0.02319316379725933, 0.011371400207281113, -0.03982996195554733, -0.003908463288098574, -0.021611995995044708, 0.07219530642032623, -0.04069972410798073, 0.012201913632452488, 0.05352642759680748, -0.07660441845655441, 0.014255046844482422 ]
<p>Can anyone explain to me the meaning of this picture? I Know that the argument is Quantum Physics and that cat is the Schrödinger's cat, but I don't know how to interpret the bra–ket notation and also the two numerical coefficients...</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/Of40B.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g4004
[ -0.011227939277887344, 0.021177371963858604, 0.015098429284989834, -0.026915548369288445, 0.07130978256464005, 0.036864880472421646, 0.00950387492775917, 0.0552591010928154, 0.001086015603505075, 0.003320869291201234, 0.0047754934057593346, 0.04612725228071213, 0.05246180668473244, 0.021079299971461296, 0.012260268442332745, -0.003360588336363435, 0.027629289776086807, 0.02193021960556507, -0.007415002677589655, 0.03064502589404583, -0.03001544438302517, 0.0416952446103096, -0.05539991706609726, -0.05096921697258949, 0.0015450729988515377, -0.012236853130161762, -0.024491185322403908, -0.00034758573747240007, -0.04360479488968849, 0.026167094707489014, 0.019442856311798096, -0.016491012647747993, 0.07995054125785828, -0.022587237879633904, -0.07606085389852524, -0.023746196180582047, 0.07998654991388321, 0.028330635279417038, 0.007017858326435089, -0.00035956475767306983, -0.030713438987731934, -0.014841940253973007, -0.00007133560575312003, -0.037084225565195084, -0.07262413948774338, -0.0047615207731723785, 0.017188720405101776, -0.001612096675671637, -0.07162286341190338, 0.007340109441429377, -0.044995661824941635, -0.008477485738694668, 0.01946171186864376, 0.028316201642155647, 0.028915410861372948, 0.05307096615433693, 0.037449583411216736, 0.027103986591100693, 0.06498321145772934, 0.08946188539266586, 0.03257390111684799, 0.02380579523742199, -0.015573788434267044, 0.03796681389212608, 0.07372079789638519, 0.010941234417259693, -0.01626122184097767, 0.005346309393644333, -0.015169852413237095, -0.0163732822984457, 0.021880658343434334, -0.11960633844137192, 0.009940287098288536, 0.015877244994044304, -0.006170451641082764, 0.018374217674136162, -0.0016471216222271323, 0.007531117647886276, -0.011853223666548729, 0.060871709138154984, -0.032537076622247696, -0.0445772148668766, -0.00021341130195651203, 0.0019240889232605696, 0.04686228930950165, -0.01423458382487297, -0.005783324129879475, 0.008601457811892033, 0.015542512759566307, 0.039013300091028214, -0.03758404403924942, -0.04217606037855148, 0.048810407519340515, -0.02506892941892147, 0.001272498513571918, -0.07009817659854889, 0.008050372824072838, 0.005466101225465536, -0.01618419960141182, -0.004438274540007114, -0.09619628638029099, 0.03275074437260628, 0.02492709457874298, -0.000531408644746989, 0.04252555966377258, 0.01298084668815136, -0.03664533793926239, -0.01825696788728237, -0.030464010313153267, -0.06740528345108032, -0.06603380292654037, -0.056601058691740036, -0.04153604060411453, -0.005012841895222664, -0.03006032668054104, -0.027789438143372536, 0.04086475074291229, -0.028709352016448975, 0.005492217838764191, 0.012343693524599075, 0.04862131178379059, 0.01122377160936594, 0.06172722950577736, 0.019115256145596504, -0.030006960034370422, 0.026634905487298965, -0.0022439761087298393, -0.04833254963159561, 0.02041509561240673, 0.00466030091047287, 0.01555128488689661, 0.02115330472588539, 0.04080832749605179, 0.027037974447011948, 0.041215669363737106, 0.07299504429101944, -0.008351007476449013, -0.055820442736148834, 0.03887717425823212, 0.005151909776031971, 0.021386457607150078, -0.014341994188725948, 0.016160376369953156, -0.03687538579106331, -0.013028867542743683, -0.015943529084324837, 0.008136258460581303, 0.00021959624427836388, 0.02202846109867096, 0.039232004433870316, 0.0015618327306583524, 0.027753986418247223, -0.05687250196933746, -0.009522151201963425, 0.03214043378829956, -0.039637621492147446, 0.045995987951755524, 0.03743024542927742, -0.040462784469127655, 0.003928088117390871, 0.014952966012060642, -0.008202925324440002, -0.002008897950872779, -0.018747400492429733, -0.0604652501642704, 0.0362713485956192, 0.01262606494128704, -0.08353064209222794, -0.01175528671592474, 0.007320587523281574, -0.032388947904109955, 0.03720070794224739, -0.0456395298242569, 0.028471285477280617, 0.03569778800010681, 0.07850735634565353, 0.022468363866209984, -0.010920662432909012, 0.027500556781888008, 0.03594588860869408, -0.009013622999191284, 0.011138593778014183, 0.04578208923339844, -0.028389522805809975, -0.03782344236969948, -0.031046029180288315, 0.0048319450579583645, 0.08190992474555969, 0.006747941020876169, -0.027759764343500137, -0.0320650190114975, -0.011016735807061195, -0.009343858808279037, 0.056157566606998444, 0.006024916656315327, -0.02228175289928913, -0.005468746647238731, 0.016913380473852158, -0.009327799081802368, -0.008912931196391582, -0.00009613059955881909, 0.04384931921958923, -0.0054954951629042625, 0.030610287562012672, 0.019804468378424644, 0.0419294536113739, -0.05706150084733963, 0.04130231961607933, 0.020148953422904015, -0.052502602338790894, -0.006728753913193941, 0.014185700565576553, 0.01764710061252117, 0.04700087383389473, -0.034798212349414825, -0.02982300892472267, 0.017363857477903366, -0.08352261781692505, -0.04148298129439354, 0.019152721390128136, 0.0052350047044456005, -0.08152858912944794, 0.011864147149026394, -0.03909226879477501, 0.017386117950081825, -0.00443623261526227, -0.0389658659696579, -0.025188647210597992, -0.024415159597992897, 0.00848825741559267, -0.048985496163368225, 0.013568323105573654, -0.00041507286368869245, -0.02169862948358059, 0.062274571508169174, 0.08251560479402542, 0.03444589301943779, -0.0002947214525192976, 0.011412689462304115, 0.03179614618420601, 0.011936001479625702, -0.003232369665056467, -0.0400378592312336, 0.021924085915088654, 0.06450130045413971, 0.04788164049386978, 0.011945933103561401, -0.060327738523483276, -0.059474460780620575, 0.002724486868828535, 0.017638618126511574, -0.04966764524579048, -0.010623120702803135, -0.007132551167160273, 0.0158790685236454, -0.06232062354683876, 0.001792319817468524, 0.027940278872847557, -0.05232805758714676, -0.016515569761395454, -0.020498836413025856, -0.06828437000513077, -0.0672663226723671, 0.010746060870587826, -0.03010466881096363, -0.03107369691133499, -0.021684100851416588, 0.03590661287307739, 0.04694735258817673, -0.04030288755893707, -0.012180554680526257, 0.044982604682445526, -0.012888931669294834, -0.03854461386799812, -0.037840116769075394, -0.03815644979476929, 0.04061761125922203, -0.03564208373427391, 0.013307456858456135, -0.07009357959032059, 0.011928755789995193, 0.01656980812549591, -0.04841487482190132, 0.061357155442237854, 0.0355372279882431, -0.023803630843758583, -0.015314502641558647, 0.04801170527935028, 0.002500233007594943, 0.031519565731287, 0.04070170223712921, -0.004076361656188965, 0.0014462550170719624, -0.0012978732120245695, -0.030513616278767586, -0.014671580865979195, 0.054280102252960205, 0.023252764716744423, 0.04267030581831932, 0.09723542630672455, -0.00516077596694231, 0.018923325464129448, -0.007954995147883892, 0.0063563743606209755, 0.052436526864767075, 0.02359602227807045, -0.03181711211800575, 0.0010514308232814074, -0.028235726058483124, -0.061595432460308075, -0.0007978444918990135, -0.01982119306921959, 0.027709441259503365, 0.007561438251286745, -0.021213149651885033, -0.04228796064853668, -0.042274463921785355, 0.029168138280510902, 0.027149612084031105, 0.023196198046207428, -0.006225765682756901, -0.05479320138692856, 0.007042389363050461, 0.020590059459209442, 0.02278498001396656, -0.02148795686662197, -0.07639335095882416, -0.04379100725054741, 0.04332069680094719, -0.048775892704725266, -0.0048178937286138535, 0.0021263191010802984, 0.023298751562833786, -0.007785818539559841, -0.07265259325504303, -0.02315475046634674, -0.02252446487545967, 0.03164317458868027, 0.008002707734704018, -0.017838656902313232, 0.0036985985934734344, -0.01274720299988985, 0.014790225774049759, 0.029170962050557137, 0.09579171985387802, -0.03707750886678696, -0.016915854066610336, 0.0034406043123453856, 0.05350882187485695, -0.07811017334461212, -0.01794488914310932, 0.022790104150772095, 0.046745747327804565, 0.04094425216317177, -0.0715845450758934, 0.02921316772699356, -0.023393940180540085, -0.02552429586648941, -0.03211936354637146, -0.022389985620975494, -0.005355502013117075, 0.0031877413857728243, 0.0628022700548172, 0.07760811597108841, -0.0393885113298893, -0.02476373314857483, -0.03355993703007698, 0.04700431227684021, -0.005739465355873108, -0.03273146599531174, -0.04926152154803276, -0.037773653864860535, -0.020655980333685875, -0.011861992068588734, 0.05125805735588074, 0.005481097847223282, -0.011018007062375546, -0.02745688706636429, -0.014021891169250011, 0.035118378698825836, 0.031908243894577026, 0.058025285601615906, 0.037561967968940735, 0.0231611505150795, 0.04635193943977356, -0.003998500760644674, -0.01109952200204134, 0.0051368363201618195, 0.029758330434560776, 0.006310627795755863, 0.028702573850750923, 0.02350761368870735, -0.09490302205085754, -0.02856055088341236, 0.01919742301106453, 0.0036262727808207273, 0.030242489650845528, 0.012075032107532024, -0.06203202158212662, 0.03307792916893959, -0.060749705880880356, 0.00994633138179779, 0.026807868853211403, 0.010689360089600086, -0.023401085287332535, -0.0016312459483742714, 0.04824351146817207, -0.015445051714777946, 0.0758214220404625, -0.007199143059551716, -0.040268782526254654, 0.02228347584605217, -0.03271966055035591, -0.05361533164978027, 0.05851588398218155, 0.04249141737818718, 0.0329861082136631, -0.03463334962725639, 0.04259029030799866, 0.01879054680466652, 0.013700209558010101, 0.019757986068725586, 0.013376391492784023, -0.04184950888156891, -0.016122905537486076, -0.030658604577183723, -0.009851797483861446, 0.0958157554268837, -0.04068772494792938, -0.00048794501344673336, 0.029472019523382187, -0.004966702777892351, 0.01178957149386406, 0.03909360617399216, -0.045591454952955246, 0.03556346148252487, -0.07315623015165329, -0.009776032529771328, -0.02705620415508747, 0.02721126563847065, 0.08323489874601364, -0.017155377194285393, 0.007399547845125198, -0.03037291392683983, -0.008510780520737171, 0.011227822862565517, -0.014845646917819977, -0.026245180517435074, -0.05012326315045357, -0.00719229131937027, -0.06225128471851349, 0.018065975978970528, -0.013562805019319057, -0.0027789624873548746, 0.03090718388557434, -0.040480904281139374, -0.04777754843235016, -0.03448651358485222, 0.008566622622311115, 0.034487269818782806, -0.09526872634887695, 0.07096924632787704, -0.05234745889902115, -0.021652761846780777, 0.06799028813838959, 0.045275699347257614, -0.0186223816126585, 0.00004657141471398063, 0.013893172144889832, 0.020949361845850945, 0.04869946837425232, -0.04115624725818634, 0.02703111805021763, -0.05483735725283623, 0.08230751007795334, -0.03875643387436867, 0.008331162855029106, -0.0137518011033535, -0.013214116916060448, -0.019670911133289337, 0.023902500048279762, 0.01593370921909809, 0.037173349410295486, 0.010916550643742085, -0.011324210092425346, 0.0577285960316658, 0.004282088950276375, 0.03030400350689888, -0.01906755566596985, 0.009185021743178368, 0.0011581529397517443, 0.03445567190647125, -0.0034817957784980536, -0.04325203597545624, 0.040107183158397675, 0.03312059864401817, 0.03658220171928406, -0.003841422265395522, 0.06072935089468956, 0.023281462490558624, -0.002369515597820282, 0.023805756121873856, 0.030055014416575432, 0.022558296099305153, -0.013755095191299915, 0.03893230855464935, 0.04719296470284462, -0.025238169357180595, 0.06208072230219841, 0.0018579671159386635, -0.029792994260787964, -0.06663590669631958, 0.02029670774936676, 0.003148870775476098, 0.03167358413338661, -0.036156658083200455, -0.0034618228673934937, -0.03247589245438576, 0.03447073698043823, -0.005522817838937044, 0.06665252894163132, 0.02549123764038086, 0.012016660533845425, -0.07722041010856628, 0.051987066864967346, -0.020383289083838463, 0.024659886956214905, -0.00229903357103467, 0.04434969276189804, 0.012505375780165195, 0.013780246488749981, 0.033831533044576645, -0.008365126326680183, 0.010783135890960693, -0.008419494144618511, -0.023799501359462738, 0.0007420684560202062, -0.023265967145562172, 0.04728991538286209, 0.015281365253031254, 0.00471885409206152, 0.054593801498413086, -0.011986438184976578, 0.03817760944366455, 0.004809413105249405, 0.02662300132215023, -0.0098361661657691, -0.012328199110925198, 0.006306965369731188, -0.029072975739836693, 0.018844587728381157, 0.008634842000901699, -0.011866513639688492, -0.0002494606887921691, 0.030472485348582268, -0.011041352525353432, -0.02460041642189026, -0.030860746279358864, -0.026582293212413788, 0.03772962465882301, 0.01832304522395134, 0.0745379850268364, 0.05690080672502518, 0.042723312973976135, 0.006538985297083855, 0.01022647600620985, -0.055508147925138474, 0.0334639772772789, 0.02580321580171585, -0.013500037603080273, -0.08025367558002472, 0.05851638317108154, -0.034708041697740555, 0.02610136568546295, 0.0009885546751320362, 0.015317450277507305, 0.028249409049749374, 0.0037604609970003366, 0.007817630656063557, -0.04627830162644386, 0.018668411299586296, 0.014076568186283112, -0.010428711771965027, -0.08537653833627701, -0.02707848884165287, 0.019631652161478996, -0.03868526220321655, -0.03021358512341976, -0.0007020113407634199, 0.043756529688835144, -0.012742782011628151, 0.017509179189801216, -0.00543808052316308, 0.03516053035855293, -0.005763923283666372, -0.03763892874121666, -0.0020747233647853136, 0.004235549829900265, -0.030658598989248276, 0.0327506959438324, -0.03588566184043884, -0.01838274858891964, -0.029192078858613968, 0.004182891920208931, -0.033843934535980225, -0.01952189765870571, 0.015230247750878334, -0.013202345930039883, -0.07645760476589203, 0.024007970467209816, -0.05162322521209717, 0.0367903895676136, -0.012153475545346737, 0.050458114594221115, 0.024666141718626022, -0.07037574797868729, 0.05058988183736801, 0.024766551330685616, -0.05090542137622833, 0.02547830156981945, 0.03534596413373947, -0.027559034526348114, -0.022035369649529457, 0.052374616265296936, 0.02947918511927128, 0.04241492599248886, -0.002926354529336095, 0.07310310006141663, 0.012321223504841328, 0.005195494741201401, -0.041691120713949203, 0.008580760098993778, 0.08634885400533676, 0.05650835484266281, 0.04097280651330948, 0.011345825158059597, -0.0598173514008522, -0.011545340530574322, 0.030160462483763695, 0.008479446172714233, -0.0069487267173826694, -0.03346486762166023, 0.028220215812325478, -0.06456200033426285, -0.04918994382023811, -0.02026592567563057, 0.010028588585555553, -0.07013088464736938, -0.06768354028463364, -0.03476500138640404, -0.003931697458028793, 0.015552492812275887, -0.04637187719345093, 0.03449402377009392, -0.00990901980549097, -0.057012639939785004, -0.0013592500472441316, 0.01398877240717411, 0.02495732344686985, -0.06092988699674606, -0.03530178964138031, -0.03537846356630325, -0.02717195264995098, -0.02181270718574524, -0.004105588421225548, 0.0016317422268912196, 0.021846529096364975, -0.03643075376749039, 0.015820471569895744, -0.035078711807727814, -0.03484682738780975, -0.04882475733757019, 0.014619143679738045, 0.015328929759562016, -0.03679351881146431, -0.008837014436721802, -0.011664333753287792, 0.03830735757946968, -0.02730816975235939, 0.00024291095905937254, 0.034411657601594925, 0.0580318383872509, 0.01247568428516388, 0.05208126828074455, -0.007952983491122723, -0.03547412529587746, 0.029227595776319504, -0.04603470116853714, -0.0016286271857097745, 0.00854616891592741, -0.000016992036762530915, -0.05023636296391487, 0.028326090425252914, -0.018783509731292725, -0.011707866564393044, 0.011826504953205585, 0.007649033796042204, -0.032602183520793915, 0.0491330511868, 0.025416189804673195, 0.011244697496294975, -0.0170258991420269, -0.02556452341377735, 0.022200841456651688, 0.027067959308624268, 0.019189389422535896, 0.0072984094731509686, -0.0011000935919582844, -0.04543810337781906, -0.024702539667487144, 0.011690381914377213, -0.0724186897277832, 0.012068959884345531, 0.03845770284533501, 0.05452873557806015, 0.0072303530760109425, -0.011385648511350155, 0.05415359511971474, -0.045304056257009506, 0.007577505428344011, 0.00398337421938777, -0.00713387643918395, 0.025422468781471252, -0.06103894114494324, -0.04773375764489174, -0.049622997641563416, 0.0005742667708545923, -0.00018624782387632877, -0.037199366837739944, 0.007937460206449032, -0.03168414160609245, 0.0383320190012455, -0.06525936722755432, -0.029780346900224686, -0.04642472788691521, 0.04735012352466583, -0.02572205290198326, -0.002821678062900901, 0.03463546186685562, -0.017425285652279854, -0.02869282104074955, -0.03111749142408371, -0.0028969687409698963, -0.025249304249882698, -0.09605272859334946, -0.047980695962905884, -0.07222075015306473, -0.0014084427384659648, 0.10374388098716736, -0.03192093223333359, 0.005672618746757507, 0.007501459214836359, 0.0016992632299661636, 0.03197130560874939, 0.05212189257144928, -0.03983404487371445, -0.02405901812016964, 0.06126231700181961, 0.0375654362142086, 0.001547039020806551, 0.008353655226528645, -0.0671633705496788, -0.01263806689530611, 0.018738599494099617, -0.018447786569595337, -0.0033130354713648558, -0.06307309865951538, 0.006594243459403515 ]
<p>I was watching a show on discovery and according to it, in a nebula the dust and gases slowly come together and as the gravity increases and the pressure rises in the core the gases fuse together and a star is born and the rest of the left over dust and gases come together and form planets and moons.</p> <p>So my question is that isn't all of the dust and gases used in the formation of the star? Why is some of it left and used to form planets, or why it is not sucked by the newly born star due to it's gravity. Why does the left over turn into planets and not other stars?</p>
g4005
[ -0.0020323891658335924, -0.034223124384880066, 0.011415894143283367, -0.029823312535881996, 0.021295873448252678, 0.05201070383191109, -0.04277745634317398, 0.00878550112247467, -0.02133183553814888, -0.06552436202764511, 0.013185413554310799, 0.018413901329040527, 0.06406112015247345, -0.0006794317159801722, 0.020473957061767578, 0.020980529487133026, 0.03675656393170357, -0.018626391887664795, 0.00043739558896049857, 0.03907935321331024, -0.01951947622001171, -0.01228507049381733, 0.023392658680677414, 0.017728881910443306, -0.061752960085868835, -0.03726467117667198, 0.029816659167408943, -0.016810575500130653, 0.01237516663968563, -0.00605133967474103, 0.0435926727950573, 0.07947058230638504, 0.0520685538649559, -0.059707753360271454, 0.060301296412944794, -0.03480781614780426, 0.010494955815374851, -0.040892452001571655, 0.007032669615000486, -0.03706992790102959, -0.003797834040597081, 0.011571143753826618, 0.02414844185113907, 0.021034467965364456, -0.007022500969469547, -0.012347972020506859, -0.010477803647518158, -0.03512489050626755, 0.009625024162232876, -0.02919389307498932, -0.02917652018368244, 0.012712149880826473, -0.03309347480535507, -0.006746809929609299, 0.006016795057803392, 0.010689510963857174, 0.05831940472126007, -0.04781100153923035, 0.04318796470761299, -0.029513796791434288, -0.05040639638900757, 0.003166717244312167, -0.011286014690995216, 0.0523892305791378, 0.01246268954128027, -0.034963276237249374, -0.010381428524851799, 0.04855239391326904, 0.069117970764637, 0.05228441581130028, 0.013397050090134144, 0.026796488091349602, 0.03307487815618515, -0.01848057471215725, -0.02528037317097187, 0.029763437807559967, -0.018926693126559258, 0.022268611937761307, -0.057323992252349854, 0.06531669944524765, 0.06117168068885803, -0.009157302789390087, -0.02734716236591339, 0.029103130102157593, 0.07959909737110138, 0.01567261293530464, -0.060546670109033585, -0.047671668231487274, -0.03302464634180069, 0.05289100855588913, 0.01453327015042305, 0.017361868172883987, -0.023093029856681824, -0.014971102587878704, 0.022274678573012352, 0.015701783820986748, -0.01986016146838665, 0.055234115570783615, -0.032560959458351135, -0.0037213058676570654, 0.018246524035930634, -0.034742239862680435, 0.08312603086233139, -0.02871028520166874, 0.062191229313611984, 0.0024355389177799225, -0.01670445315539837, 0.010588633827865124, 0.007138192653656006, -0.029428770765662193, -0.008025171235203743, 0.01083636749535799, 0.06801106780767441, 0.012022246606647968, -0.04617764428257942, 0.018657581880688667, 0.04721473902463913, 0.029336409643292427, 0.029109736904501915, 0.044171251356601715, -0.029704371467232704, 0.03609028086066246, 0.003055729204788804, -0.04987616464495659, -0.029325831681489944, -0.024099892005324364, 0.03992784395813942, -0.00496643828228116, 0.028785839676856995, -0.0029936532955616713, 0.031152013689279556, -0.001414538943208754, -0.033286768943071365, -0.002986539388075471, 0.021645553410053253, -0.023250259459018707, -0.04805468022823334, 0.023930052295327187, -0.014889130368828773, 0.02201838232576847, 0.046611882746219635, 0.0406421534717083, 0.03276609629392624, 0.003216039389371872, -0.036327820271253586, 0.04209265857934952, 0.01286104042083025, 0.026570286601781845, -0.021646462380886078, 0.008475170470774174, 0.0031711540650576353, 0.045155398547649384, 0.013324499130249023, -0.06974031031131744, 0.01884397864341736, 0.013311797752976418, 0.023870965465903282, 0.031096646562218666, 0.011496957391500473, -0.04053656384348869, 0.07627246528863907, -0.05611454322934151, 0.004667689558118582, -0.03888145834207535, -0.05276954546570778, 0.04551369696855545, -0.05466926470398903, -0.10232546925544739, 0.004913683515042067, 0.00612233579158783, 0.015786081552505493, -0.007424586918205023, -0.00030362867983058095, 0.05417986586689949, 0.02526145987212658, 0.05451414734125137, 0.09977157413959503, -0.017707563936710358, -0.019893549382686615, -0.008366486988961697, 0.037299927324056625, -0.05125867947936058, -0.022176673635840416, -0.0048111374489963055, 0.036637600511312485, -0.023870011791586876, -0.012798539362847805, -0.046765703707933426, -0.05007471516728401, -0.0020541721023619175, 0.017178865149617195, 0.02538922056555748, -0.001009076600894332, 0.059851933270692825, 0.06228019297122955, 0.00014881842071190476, -0.022249585017561913, 0.010143371298909187, -0.0915478840470314, 0.028412053361535072, -0.0304997731000185, 0.031438492238521576, 0.01057338621467352, -0.009459693916141987, 0.024683330208063126, 0.010737362317740917, -0.022516805678606033, 0.04720683395862579, 0.036158058792352676, 0.009218838065862656, -0.029224853962659836, 0.017173198983073235, 0.052082642912864685, -0.019820785149931908, -0.07886505872011185, 0.0088244853541255, -0.009658388793468475, 0.004413096699863672, 0.024485958740115166, -0.02605487033724785, -0.03187398985028267, -0.08055347949266434, 0.034271739423274994, -0.009290097281336784, -0.007964450865983963, 0.004512017127126455, 0.008215293288230896, 0.012782596983015537, 0.008428371511399746, 0.006449689622968435, 0.006326774600893259, -0.048600003123283386, -0.021734066307544708, 0.0005059902905486524, 0.005447354167699814, -0.012979134917259216, -0.02469123899936676, -0.036760080605745316, 0.0066394503228366375, -0.02525138668715954, -0.024170218035578728, -0.05065733939409256, 0.011589975096285343, 0.004176474642008543, 0.04563412442803383, -0.0253122691065073, 0.013547507114708424, -0.05552244931459427, -0.06646845489740372, 0.005730625707656145, -0.03311748057603836, 0.007034898269921541, 0.015190672129392624, -0.002312479307875037, -0.00025804457254707813, -0.03999488800764084, -0.008290134370326996, 0.03724512457847595, -0.0659232884645462, -0.07568658143281937, -0.012394636869430542, 0.0012942665489390492, -0.05888037383556366, 0.0013427797239273787, -0.05891695246100426, 0.03497566282749176, 0.0004306758055463433, -0.036838628351688385, 0.04364446923136711, 0.0037160562351346016, -0.05792143940925598, -0.02783234603703022, -0.009148193523287773, 0.020152658224105835, -0.03984643518924713, -0.00014871772145852447, -0.0028972942382097244, 0.04141732677817345, 0.004898630082607269, -0.0031149464193731546, 0.04292363300919533, 0.004270406439900398, -0.06465992331504822, -0.021857356652617455, 0.015015333890914917, -0.028596216812729836, -0.030951915308833122, -0.02281315252184868, -0.010437211953103542, 0.01011384092271328, 0.03237391635775566, -0.0008960564737208188, 0.02622075378894806, 0.043559297919273376, 0.023031599819660187, 0.04410991072654724, -0.009898735210299492, 0.04236851632595062, -0.08803469687700272, -0.0013822653563693166, 0.0013252319768071175, -0.020253486931324005, 0.04003105312585831, 0.044589098542928696, 0.028647802770137787, 0.021946489810943604, -0.01887444779276848, 0.0010420551989227533, -0.07206756621599197, -0.08731434494256973, 0.051432982087135315, 0.05036289989948273, -0.055934496223926544, 0.025315243750810623, -0.001185271656140685, -0.05740019306540489, 0.033335573971271515, -0.012084880843758583, 0.03198247775435448, 0.014590323902666569, -0.024913180619478226, 0.004642858635634184, -0.00711182551458478, -0.03779597580432892, -0.029171336442232132, -0.025673625990748405, -0.014269525185227394, -0.026193032041192055, 0.002934623509645462, -0.010720670223236084, -0.008365998044610023, -0.020398274064064026, -0.04162495583295822, 0.019850393757224083, -0.04834163188934326, 0.03629400581121445, -0.03041476383805275, -0.0006020008004270494, 0.039832647889852524, 0.029197387397289276, -0.023202328011393547, 0.020668359473347664, -0.05105866119265556, 0.01138715073466301, -0.028478045016527176, 0.0018532677786424756, 0.061234474182128906, -0.013310570269823074, -0.04595614969730377, 0.004337348975241184, 0.023889979347586632, -0.019646257162094116, 0.03868887200951576, -0.00135990628041327, -0.07656467705965042, 0.028517641127109528, 0.002652799477800727, 0.016450628638267517, 0.0293613038957119, 0.0018692814046517015, 0.03028453141450882, -0.03136683627963066, -0.003922306001186371, 0.046112269163131714, -0.000015518629879807122, -0.008103840984404087, 0.011246736161410809, -0.09295660257339478, 0.04450462758541107, 0.04397169128060341, -0.0035525884013623, 0.003004282945767045, -0.030279342085123062, -0.010139469057321548, 0.023699643090367317, -0.039825789630413055, 0.06754273921251297, 0.009188941679894924, 0.014059588313102722, -0.003603425808250904, 0.0523144006729126, 0.008167240768671036, -0.015157455578446388, 0.01465519331395626, 0.06553694605827332, 0.02669745869934559, -0.010983032174408436, 0.038690824061632156, 0.014762423932552338, -0.045722734183073044, -0.006743478588759899, -0.07999525219202042, 0.009289920330047607, -0.03029792010784149, -0.022879531607031822, -0.03653480112552643, 0.05237497761845589, 0.0025454615242779255, 0.05017039179801941, -0.000050008784455712885, -0.006673374678939581, 0.04474400728940964, -0.0056971036829054356, -0.07543332874774933, 0.07190874218940735, 0.0038136900402605534, 0.012749659828841686, -0.07767900079488754, -0.01439595129340887, -0.019239015877246857, 0.05240127816796303, 0.01919342204928398, -0.012199723161756992, 0.036281898617744446, 0.05202881246805191, -0.04520129784941673, 0.00350457732565701, 0.04413502290844917, -0.01516836229711771, -0.039212945848703384, -0.0167632307857275, 0.04963592067360878, -0.01734585501253605, 0.02191079407930374, 0.061040010303258896, 0.09937145560979843, 0.027882279828190804, -0.012814540416002274, -0.003833834547549486, -0.019108833745121956, 0.03608639910817146, 0.036177001893520355, 0.03500714153051376, -0.012407943606376648, -0.10894268751144409, 0.05617853254079819, -0.053802743554115295, 0.046158187091350555, -0.013265450485050678, 0.0422714464366436, 0.08265543729066849, 0.04111054539680481, 0.00563510088250041, 0.0011396082118153572, 0.009243595413863659, -0.003361190902069211, -0.007609386462718248, -0.036312252283096313, -0.030670760199427605, -0.006090570706874132, 0.03438365086913109, -0.021830430254340172, -0.01543654128909111, -0.04245506599545479, 0.005028096958994865, 0.026255374774336815, -0.030365880578756332, -0.004322846885770559, -0.008876065723598003, 0.03228312358260155, 0.004051034804433584, -0.0027634466532617807, 0.07088331133127213, 0.0673418715596199, 0.014336660504341125, -0.030766261741518974, -0.07172146439552307, -0.014928949065506458, 0.020073141902685165, 0.004211876541376114, 0.002845283132046461, 0.007736778352409601, -0.010250415652990341, 0.08077018707990646, -0.0068816435523331165, -0.012747411616146564, 0.01420782320201397, -0.03231943026185036, 0.06276795268058777, -0.06312974542379379, -0.0021838932298123837, 0.019660474732518196, 0.028594939038157463, 0.06149158254265785, -0.018054578453302383, 0.004486320540308952, -0.010525115765631199, -0.054267022758722305, 0.0001296075788559392, -0.04429279640316963, -0.0038963055703788996, 0.02149876393377781, 0.07056646794080734, -0.024322224780917168, 0.0031621085945516825, -0.01637149043381214, -0.028119970113039017, -0.11830257624387741, -0.038093920797109604, -0.019787589088082314, -0.004302140790969133, -0.02129354327917099, -0.07411298900842667, 0.018794165924191475, 0.012464242056012154, -0.013618084602057934, -0.007201999891549349, -0.015705570578575134, 0.03538947552442551, 0.015361693687736988, 0.05000157281756401, -0.0050105745904147625, -0.0019312429940328002, 0.06125493720173836, -0.0052795675583183765, -0.019569942727684975, -0.011406130157411098, 0.0019023811910301447, 0.039162591099739075, -0.0077763027511537075, -0.027517586946487427, 0.00011102996359113604, 0.02555948495864868, 0.01622067391872406, 0.06114194542169571, 0.04832437261939049, -0.011958162300288677, 0.0633421242237091, 0.04827556014060974, 0.026588231325149536, -0.009125380776822567, -0.04683869332075119, 0.07096182554960251, 0.08567924052476883, -0.03283897042274475, 0.05831126496195793, -0.0076720453798770905, 0.053142547607421875, 0.0893879383802414, -0.001713409903459251, -0.0020121210254728794, -0.02674170397222042, -0.03643825650215149, 0.03351695463061333, -0.0034587832633405924, 0.06075498089194298, -0.027628818526864052, 0.041798416525125504, 0.00707875145599246, 0.012579310685396194, -0.0016045550582930446, 0.02659185416996479, -0.019674455747008324, -0.04174012690782547, -0.07480412721633911, 0.009531541727483273, 0.009907923638820648, -0.017365820705890656, -0.009519449435174465, -0.037708234041929245, 0.016092557460069656, -0.0050631677731871605, 0.010072128847241402, 0.05683474615216255, -0.013191457837820053, -0.02342153526842594, 0.001136171631515026, -0.014649837277829647, 0.06311969459056854, -0.019489537924528122, 0.022158056497573853, 0.012123692780733109, 0.01648753695189953, -0.015141543000936508, 0.017330393195152283, -0.030948447063565254, -0.003300481243059039, -0.0005980501300655305, 0.004625272937119007, -0.036720748990774155, 0.12265148758888245, -0.061797115951776505, -0.01929504983127117, -0.06222611293196678, -0.0034926594235002995, -0.013267752714455128, 0.015460597351193428, -0.028016818687319756, -0.02367888018488884, 0.001847330597229302, -0.030948184430599213, -0.06687432527542114, 0.011525810696184635, 0.017701467499136925, -0.026801330968737602, -0.01893962174654007, -0.0486266054213047, -0.0706794261932373, -0.004106807056814432, -0.09869734197854996, -0.028708752244710922, 0.03678523376584053, -0.0018366327276453376, 0.007951071485877037, -0.005630553234368563, -0.030711421743035316, -0.045226603746414185, 0.0009539172169752419, 0.01826486736536026, 0.04008945822715759, -0.022406719624996185, 0.0016499138437211514, -0.05675164610147476, -0.012551737949252129, -0.009655257686972618, -0.04257039725780487, -0.004534690175205469, 0.029284480959177017, 0.009143823757767677, 0.010330401360988617, -0.027833832427859306, -0.007854272611439228, 0.05053584277629852, -0.04846911504864693, 0.024699952453374863, 0.06423301994800568, 0.0013995079789310694, 0.044797033071517944, 0.03159823268651962, 0.06999467313289642, -0.013043821789324284, 0.04038599878549576, -0.06522741913795471, -0.01197393424808979, 0.012196247465908527, -0.004144594073295593, -0.02584071084856987, 0.011648083105683327, 0.04653792455792427, 0.012754734605550766, -0.014123590663075447, -0.07124968618154526, 0.027324488386511803, 0.037736959755420685, 0.026738755404949188, 0.020994175225496292, 0.01810602843761444, -0.027181683108210564, -0.07134389877319336, -0.03985891491174698, -0.06760420650243759, -0.014306002296507359, -0.018210968002676964, -0.01841299794614315, -0.058976493775844574, 0.013364947400987148, 0.00006468753417721018, -0.0002666219952516258, -0.024389073252677917, -0.061484791338443756, -0.03676027059555054, -0.03510439023375511, -0.0153975123539567, 0.03272721543908119, 0.014804061502218246, 0.07132978737354279, 0.0966157391667366, -0.0025677625089883804, -0.011363359168171883, -0.015535480342805386, -0.044625621289014816, -0.047146447002887726, -0.03487786278128624, 0.034934256225824356, 0.009635048918426037, 0.007291558664292097, 0.02106362022459507, -0.02732573263347149, 0.03648659214377403, -0.036886390298604965, -0.005228247959166765, 0.02862045355141163, -0.0010228280443698168, 0.006592999212443829, -0.063247449696064, 0.009301790967583656, 0.001689782366156578, 0.03257212042808533, -0.011564452201128006, -0.03938620164990425, 0.02196411043405533, 0.05127812549471855, 0.025136295706033707, -0.025610754266381264, -0.0436139777302742, -0.03189745917916298, 0.07122351229190826, -0.011154777370393276, 0.02299661375582218, -0.039344269782304764, 0.013204915449023247, -0.018621571362018585, -0.05581558495759964, -0.09361874312162399, 0.03543322533369064, -0.0101627791300416, 0.006734995171427727, 0.06080561876296997, -0.07143818587064743, -0.024975121021270752, 0.02570374868810177, -0.0058066993951797485, 0.036750227212905884, -0.007220356725156307, 0.009409678168594837, -0.016697784885764122, 0.013330316171050072, 0.009407184086740017, -0.002085660817101598, 0.015155728906393051, -0.010619163513183594, -0.015084643848240376, 0.007755356375128031, -0.03232033550739288, -0.024080688133835793, 0.015577725134789944, -0.007502611260861158, -0.012710263952612877, 0.016697976738214493, -0.013075990602374077, -0.06384629756212234, 0.047592680901288986, 0.031126758083701134, -0.03346489742398262, -0.031955212354660034, -0.021273106336593628, 0.016086529940366745, -0.10052596777677536, -0.02340254746377468, -0.02214411459863186, -0.03576111048460007, -0.04738271236419678, 0.06982260942459106, -0.042329512536525726, -0.024356290698051453, -0.024276526644825935, -0.003462023101747036, 0.04865441471338272, 0.04837728291749954, 0.020275631919503212, 0.012375619262456894, 0.046144429594278336, 0.029352277517318726, 0.052632056176662445, 0.020551005378365517, 0.008071031421422958, -0.02034332975745201, 0.04594194144010544, -0.03497225418686867, -0.05059327185153961, -0.0102182412520051, 0.022038105875253677, -0.017692798748612404, -0.012414331547915936, -0.016384005546569824, -0.01829230785369873, 0.03272538259625435, 0.0297052301466465 ]
<p>We all know (or maybe know) that to move, we need to spend energy. If you want to drive a car, you gotta spend gasoline.</p> <p>We also know that energy can't be created (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_law_of_thermodynamics" rel="nofollow">first law of thermodynamics</a>, and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perpetual_motion" rel="nofollow">perpetual motion</a>).</p> <p>Also, we know that in energy transformation, in real-world almost some part of it is converted into heat produced because of the friction between motion bodies. (for example, part of the gasoline of the car in burned to overcome car's friction with air, and thus would be converted into heat, and won't serve any movement at all).</p> <p>Now a question has obsessed my mind. <strong>How electrons circulate around nucleus for ever</strong>? Where does electron get its energy from? </p>
g202
[ 0.009707709774374962, 0.03750953823328018, -0.0015316494973376393, 0.032555051147937775, 0.06457376480102539, -0.050015758723020554, -0.01718507707118988, 0.10524612665176392, -0.045232754200696945, -0.01580708473920822, -0.009462053887546062, -0.0029862532392144203, 0.007837952114641666, -0.03834553807973862, 0.008174842223525047, -0.028570232912898064, 0.01789994165301323, 0.018126538023352623, 0.013073406182229519, 0.09299159049987793, -0.004963499493896961, -0.009857811965048313, 0.02101552113890648, -0.012646186165511608, 0.01020376943051815, -0.037027277052402496, 0.017993254587054253, -0.029794998466968536, -0.0032348190434277058, -0.043249789625406265, 0.06562042981386185, -0.029711343348026276, 0.015149105340242386, -0.05477394908666611, -0.04434899985790253, -0.02775905281305313, 0.023231005296111107, 0.0019654412753880024, 0.06046724319458008, -0.003457519691437483, -0.018808232620358467, -0.02920648641884327, 0.0012918241554871202, 0.0002766332763712853, 0.004409369081258774, 0.008245190605521202, 0.033751409500837326, -0.030200347304344177, -0.030506333336234093, 0.04373850300908089, -0.021585291251540184, 0.04328432306647301, 0.015281673520803452, 0.07524815201759338, 0.05823966860771179, 0.006038567516952753, 0.021692587062716484, 0.004383598454296589, 0.04497553035616875, 0.008777235634624958, 0.018801581114530563, -0.017128849402070045, 0.014166236855089664, 0.017147185280919075, 0.05180962383747101, -0.04306216165423393, -0.02796340547502041, 0.07390519976615906, 0.030980175361037254, 0.01856810413300991, 0.04193177446722984, -0.020312044769525528, -0.03470704331994057, 0.0007122194510884583, 0.033904582262039185, 0.004296833649277687, 0.028584586456418037, -0.04002919793128967, 0.04002320021390915, 0.0010649182368069887, -0.006557405460625887, 0.0010061865905299783, 0.051550544798374176, -0.03411940857768059, 0.07050445675849915, 0.0262326467782259, -0.016328342258930206, 0.008223766461014748, 0.03839728981256485, -0.028966689482331276, 0.029552949592471123, 0.01680873893201351, 0.10997641086578369, 0.00680313166230917, -0.007325727958232164, -0.09469584375619888, -0.01982162520289421, 0.05259614810347557, -0.03223910182714462, -0.03636004030704498, -0.01859642192721367, -0.04949707165360451, 0.009061655960977077, -0.026792308315634727, 0.042220406234264374, -0.009090670384466648, -0.052801575511693954, -0.032393548637628555, 0.01744423434138298, -0.01843782514333725, -0.03031844273209572, -0.01633503846824169, 0.0006718857912346721, -0.008038794621825218, -0.0016710857162252069, 0.037307243794202805, 0.02271067164838314, 0.019165797159075737, 0.02057904377579689, 0.05764295905828476, -0.021566316485404968, 0.06424224376678467, -0.02431001141667366, 0.020065071061253548, -0.044497884809970856, 0.01750269904732704, 0.0020468176808208227, -0.03296137601137161, 0.0026623886078596115, 0.029865611344575882, -0.023268744349479675, 0.023759692907333374, -0.017255596816539764, -0.0023178160190582275, 0.05648224800825119, 0.05220510810613632, -0.052442990243434906, 0.033060137182474136, -0.03584965690970421, 0.015697991475462914, 0.061193760484457016, -0.02001091279089451, -0.0067076124250888824, -0.00425220001488924, -0.01761256903409958, -0.014585747383534908, -0.07336054742336273, -0.008335036225616932, 0.034326065331697464, 0.016210757195949554, -0.012500753626227379, 0.05354880541563034, 0.009763077832758427, -0.058775193989276886, 0.0710706114768982, -0.07477539032697678, 0.050659190863370895, -0.03388064354658127, -0.01611272804439068, -0.01769576407968998, 0.044581882655620575, -0.0600251741707325, 0.04277681186795235, -0.03319751098752022, -0.02605654112994671, -0.038641948252916336, -0.021681061014533043, -0.025411682203412056, 0.06419546902179718, 0.010742172598838806, -0.06647762656211853, -0.045186273753643036, -0.05114027112722397, 0.05191553011536598, -0.019009366631507874, 0.017171377316117287, 0.04170398786664009, 0.002453362103551626, 0.039625104516744614, -0.04870230704545975, 0.007416184991598129, 0.004716166295111179, 0.09278164803981781, 0.01195361465215683, 0.03610770404338837, 0.025437187403440475, -0.06748034805059433, 0.03500601649284363, -0.04377199336886406, -0.011622613295912743, -0.028802160173654556, -0.04443355277180672, 0.02876564860343933, -0.018508683890104294, -0.0037472553085535765, -0.010898943059146404, -0.026332126930356026, -0.04246855899691582, -0.039582427591085434, -0.07223259657621384, 0.009937267750501633, 0.009158894419670105, 0.015072665177285671, 0.02104911580681801, 0.05120690539479256, 0.03897930309176445, -0.012897628359496593, -0.03578696772456169, 0.01763877645134926, 0.01684185303747654, 0.06665454804897308, 0.0054048639722168446, -0.043225083500146866, -0.00469310162588954, -0.022099394351243973, -0.056698400527238846, -0.028262726962566376, -0.05284345522522926, 0.010888537392020226, -0.009605527855455875, 0.02155669406056404, -0.042541638016700745, 0.004382809158414602, 0.005937708541750908, -0.0036511593498289585, -0.002439896110445261, -0.04085661470890045, -0.059496406465768814, -0.03743830695748329, 0.04659438133239746, -0.05063355714082718, 0.02642364613711834, 0.0076067447662353516, -0.028813209384679794, 0.024418026208877563, 0.026425953954458237, -0.041847966611385345, 0.0351128987967968, 0.020198330283164978, 0.0101411622017622, 0.0282401442527771, -0.014193582348525524, 0.006570643745362759, -0.03280365467071533, 0.015284341759979725, -0.05317818745970726, 0.058538518846035004, 0.0017120884731411934, -0.013336891308426857, -0.031481076031923294, 0.01784709095954895, -0.016461364924907684, -0.08258961886167526, -0.010054891929030418, -0.0044714598916471004, -0.016188034787774086, -0.005785427521914244, 0.03830821067094803, -0.01993226259946823, -0.02969834953546524, 0.018434850499033928, -0.028110887855291367, -0.020319165661931038, 0.016008270904421806, -0.06615345180034637, -0.01821991056203842, -0.04401464760303497, -0.04849523678421974, -0.01938701793551445, -0.022730935364961624, -0.05880044400691986, 0.0539514385163784, 0.014101161621510983, -0.014477928169071674, 0.005651045124977827, -0.06050420179963112, 0.046580199152231216, -0.015233522281050682, -0.007147463969886303, -0.043161433190107346, 0.009412524290382862, 0.01996808871626854, -0.02087603509426117, 0.005729382857680321, 0.011765860952436924, -0.043928809463977814, 0.00014614530664402992, 0.01993604749441147, -0.005899629555642605, -0.05046255514025688, -0.021604174748063087, -0.02869335375726223, 0.03012344427406788, -0.002323717577382922, -0.0369766503572464, 0.06629525125026703, 0.06839456409215927, -0.012217681854963303, -0.047034330666065216, -0.008552671410143375, -0.023009255528450012, -0.028311943635344505, 0.013652478344738483, 0.031547266989946365, -0.00249732518568635, 0.05223634093999863, -0.017915446311235428, -0.058393385261297226, -0.027475839480757713, 0.014515779912471771, 0.0437459759414196, 0.0015054810792207718, -0.03466063365340233, 0.024028608575463295, -0.05551500990986824, -0.004338422790169716, -0.07250238955020905, -0.0007730071083642542, 0.0981503501534462, 0.012992075644433498, -0.031455542892217636, -0.04441498965024948, 0.04312284290790558, -0.06319200247526169, 0.06123333424329758, 0.026425307616591454, -0.03049461916089058, -0.020700452849268913, 0.026350928470492363, -0.04849805682897568, -0.027712350711226463, 0.036483533680438995, -0.042124390602111816, -0.045026496052742004, -0.023287687450647354, -0.032301682978868484, -0.026433119550347328, 0.050654564052820206, 0.02350539341568947, 0.025800397619605064, -0.021322790533304214, 0.014796734787523746, -0.038616813719272614, 0.030141813680529594, 0.04446980357170105, 0.06091144680976868, -0.0308835506439209, -0.004276770632714033, -0.02451002411544323, -0.032545559108257294, 0.021108301356434822, -0.006663707084953785, -0.04256625100970268, 0.003564633661881089, -0.05567510798573494, 0.03322070464491844, -0.015866002067923546, 0.025493569672107697, 0.00433669239282608, -0.00016609510930720717, -0.050975047051906586, -0.014940914697945118, 0.07834159582853317, 0.030809711664915085, 0.004286192823201418, 0.010465666651725769, -0.052506934851408005, -0.04287484288215637, 0.05674441158771515, -0.027708981186151505, -0.040540240705013275, -0.06221401318907738, -0.016782153397798538, 0.0022268437314778566, 0.017287733033299446, -0.0063493759371340275, 0.06373394280672073, 0.05447838455438614, -0.08382071554660797, 0.008649447932839394, -0.007720505818724632, 0.011391130276024342, 0.02678239718079567, -0.004760558716952801, 0.0234450064599514, 0.023182054981589317, -0.0667022243142128, 0.012101920321583748, 0.009718552231788635, 0.011635199189186096, 0.018570970743894577, -0.007505491375923157, 0.0490383543074131, -0.015607715584337711, 0.004547628108412027, -0.06434087455272675, 0.05004170164465904, -0.05271952226758003, 0.02382746897637844, 0.028987418860197067, 0.01714685559272766, 0.023874137550592422, -0.024960678070783615, -0.05627231299877167, 0.010302303358912468, 0.021648701280355453, 0.06195089966058731, -0.06502561271190643, -0.0005496062221936882, -0.05576963350176811, -0.008712317794561386, 0.044827304780483246, 0.03271909058094025, -0.02394087240099907, 0.016320398077368736, -0.0019170613959431648, -0.06480268388986588, -0.04056636616587639, 0.03226817399263382, 0.0018074607942253351, -0.03485233336687088, 0.03153179958462715, 0.04828759655356407, 0.027128424495458603, -0.002623789943754673, 0.07798198610544205, 0.020539293065667152, 0.001854912145063281, -0.02862512320280075, -0.04811283200979233, 0.018406100571155548, -0.015165853314101696, 0.017459869384765625, 0.018297085538506508, -0.08597684651613235, 0.0210903100669384, -0.022826828062534332, 0.04707664996385574, 0.03815096989274025, 0.054902251809835434, 0.05930202826857567, 0.00913329143077135, 0.04645257070660591, 0.05278123542666435, -0.041207510977983475, 0.043273720890283585, -0.008735833689570427, -0.011668388731777668, -0.008095715194940567, -0.026686420664191246, -0.023118756711483, 0.022059248760342598, -0.020866384729743004, 0.032212261110544205, 0.014832309447228909, 0.004866609815508127, -0.07805325090885162, 0.0014789506094530225, 0.061352577060461044, 0.016531165689229965, -0.05643330514431, -0.0501432903110981, 0.02770906500518322, 0.06983420252799988, -0.02070300094783306, 0.003659976413473487, 0.0019268575124442577, -0.004250385798513889, 0.017856746912002563, -0.01171290036290884, 0.02633320726454258, 0.03179023414850235, -0.003638538299128413, 0.01702396757900715, 0.03339051827788353, -0.03118022531270981, 0.06237180531024933, -0.0506301075220108, 0.0010238460963591933, -0.04232631251215935, -0.0051613193936645985, 0.00513179786503315, 0.030620798468589783, 0.031144391745328903, 0.011456090956926346, 0.021042488515377045, -0.06525558233261108, 0.03900577500462532, 0.022776750847697258, -0.023306597024202347, -0.028803028166294098, 0.05661747604608536, 0.02231414057314396, -0.06878302246332169, 0.0005876352079212666, 0.014483175240457058, 0.008391779847443104, 0.004059394355863333, -0.03340531513094902, -0.009525860659778118, -0.07757211476564407, -0.010819793678820133, -0.04313323646783829, -0.004713434725999832, 0.08984889835119247, -0.010200613178312778, 0.06567228585481644, -0.008054748177528381, -0.05826978012919426, -0.0008576246909797192, 0.011877580545842648, 0.00241862959228456, -0.05836516618728638, 0.011624922975897789, 0.030006155371665955, -0.009348114021122456, -0.030749527737498283, -0.01046996470540762, 0.034886475652456284, 0.005285638850182295, 0.0021773665212094784, -0.004267568700015545, 0.06732024997472763, -0.03752748668193817, 0.039506398141384125, 0.004427678417414427, -0.0515570193529129, -0.06985591351985931, 0.04904633387923241, 0.06679454445838928, 0.04547836259007454, -0.028187328949570656, -0.014265638776123524, 0.06419835984706879, -0.04714544117450714, 0.03973455727100372, 0.014422358945012093, 0.004456386435776949, 0.031548868864774704, -0.031257566064596176, 0.05568405240774155, -0.07913704216480255, 0.009187635034322739, 0.044361408799886703, -0.0020589306950569153, 0.009702449664473534, -0.018543032929301262, 0.020820574834942818, -0.003222818486392498, -0.002161905402317643, -0.015439390204846859, 0.0679585412144661, 0.002739877672865987, -0.04150988161563873, 0.029589734971523285, 0.007307884749025106, 0.016705907881259918, -0.048275090754032135, -0.03194303438067436, 0.014256313443183899, 0.029881644994020462, 0.07940776646137238, 0.05013970658183098, 0.045126594603061676, 0.06422758102416992, -0.006436460185796022, -0.0019881550688296556, -0.005719619803130627, -0.0024510398507118225, 0.13621698319911957, 0.03826805576682091, -0.004164449870586395, 0.02462414838373661, -0.011298997327685356, 0.05816119164228439, -0.012131689116358757, -0.04418323189020157, -0.019685981795191765, -0.0542103610932827, 0.012570001184940338, 0.052601706236600876, -0.02588224969804287, -0.010111984796822071, 0.00411619059741497, -0.021472133696079254, 0.033931903541088104, -0.030771709978580475, -0.0017952547641471028, 0.05777161568403244, -0.021232424303889275, -0.012832299806177616, -0.019570384174585342, -0.021885523572564125, 0.03505830466747284, 0.008269707672297955, -0.019022082909941673, 0.0017245827475562692, -0.07600334286689758, -0.011946850456297398, 0.050924621522426605, -0.04731367528438568, 0.008703330531716347, -0.02619369886815548, -0.0093994140625, 0.010727129876613617, -0.009823303669691086, 0.010799456387758255, 0.022977307438850403, 0.00007980027294252068, 0.009422176517546177, -0.04947727918624878, 0.024509543552994728, 0.02746059186756611, -0.05802623927593231, -0.03562512621283531, 0.03127126395702362, -0.04172923043370247, 0.07698319107294083, 0.013294906355440617, -0.04897313192486763, -0.03463183343410492, 0.006111857946962118, 0.036307819187641144, -0.017939206212759018, 0.06129008159041405, -0.014162363484501839, -0.05557231232523918, 0.06829995661973953, 0.07517749071121216, -0.02551487274467945, 0.025929804891347885, 0.0010242859134450555, 0.0017299290047958493, 0.05253428593277931, 0.01212768442928791, -0.009439132176339626, -0.057571712881326675, -0.00417459849268198, 0.05368613824248314, 0.05354662612080574, -0.03507179394364357, -0.008216341957449913, -0.00375295989215374, 0.033835846930742264, -0.053046103566884995, 0.009375578723847866, 0.013160530477762222, -0.012427976354956627, -0.026650892570614815, -0.033999718725681305, 0.017284471541643143, -0.07874566316604614, -0.038783445954322815, -0.0015324203995987773, -0.03763386234641075, 0.007366633042693138, -0.005145067814737558, -0.0411849170923233, -0.0018405539449304342, -0.06430966407060623, 0.015501239337027073, -0.045685503631830215, 0.02438093163073063, 0.040122345089912415, 0.020229842513799667, -0.004513975698500872, 0.015679672360420227, -0.046746306121349335, 0.041979990899562836, -0.03559265658259392, -0.0013133236207067966, -0.012199087999761105, -0.01493739802390337, -0.015754813328385353, -0.02511153370141983, 0.0038442343939095736, 0.025248246267437935, 0.025283461436629295, 0.021638723090291023, -0.038948945701122284, 0.002702284138649702, 0.009068206883966923, -0.012784917838871479, -0.014907865785062313, 0.0004616306978277862, -0.05423969402909279, -0.06513277441263199, 0.01893404871225357, -0.051992349326610565, -0.008888098411262035, -0.02248558960855007, -0.0012360960245132446, -0.021239710971713066, -0.012290073558688164, 0.006382353138178587, 0.028355954214930534, 0.03977324441075325, -0.0036520264111459255, 0.005211404524743557, 0.0318484753370285, 0.008785756304860115, -0.029768984764814377, 0.03022131882607937, 0.010925010778009892, -0.028476707637310028, 0.01728685013949871, 0.013380535878241062, 0.009353218600153923, -0.06359761953353882, 0.04555785283446312, 0.02226170338690281, -0.03229402378201485, 0.009085006080567837, 0.03163513168692589, 0.01722250133752823, 0.019599033519625664, 0.04066130518913269, 0.041722655296325684, 0.047653838992118835, 0.043752510100603104, 0.00908803939819336, -0.0014579258859157562, -0.029732249677181244, -0.033218856900930405, 0.012433595955371857, -0.0077058784663677216, 0.022693661972880363, -0.06341832131147385, 0.030605481937527657, -0.04928202927112579, -0.07501162588596344, 0.047064408659935, 0.040483105927705765, -0.04386834800243378, -0.0486162044107914, -0.03667863458395004, 0.030252916738390923, -0.0812465101480484, 0.030493849888443947, -0.018008364364504814, 0.004485927056521177, -0.03627403825521469, 0.024713696911931038, -0.016944698989391327, -0.02921033278107643, -0.05327112227678299, -0.025652658194303513, 0.05771518126130104, 0.026179036125540733, -0.017234519124031067, 0.022823747247457504, -0.0016571658197790384, -0.034503985196352005, 0.0054549528285861015, 0.045948971062898636, -0.0029833170119673014, -0.00977378524839878, 0.005940485745668411, 0.0048297736793756485, 0.053146589547395706, -0.01778511516749859, 0.009750478900969028, 0.05767102912068367, -0.015579032711684704, 0.007805620785802603, -0.03880062699317932, 0.013433207757771015, -0.011993817053735256 ]
<p>I noticed an unusually fast moving cloud this morning.</p> <p>My questions:</p> <ul> <li><p>What is the average velocity of a cloud on Earth?</p></li> <li><p>What is the greatest ever recorded cloud velocity?</p></li> <li><p>What factors affect the velocity of a cloud? (e.g. do they experience inertia?)</p></li> </ul>
g4006
[ 0.03937140852212906, 0.04110197350382805, -0.008286243304610252, -0.012932893820106983, 0.0687885731458664, -0.022319283336400986, -0.017751585692167282, 0.0034179664216935635, -0.0450863316655159, -0.036039043217897415, -0.001964004011824727, -0.0033552974928170443, 0.0327739343047142, 0.058389462530612946, 0.03773275762796402, -0.041808608919382095, 0.07738432288169861, -0.05660194531083107, 0.019404275342822075, 0.017463218420743942, 0.00925802905112505, -0.026250822469592094, 0.00836658664047718, 0.01274789683520794, 0.045738335698843, 0.013618367724120617, -0.012385454028844833, -0.006269501987844706, -0.05477312579751015, 0.011242142878472805, 0.02746628224849701, -0.037716664373874664, -0.022763194516301155, -0.09188741445541382, 0.01966826431453228, 0.03615069016814232, 0.01770675554871559, -0.04282882437109947, -0.013912087306380272, 0.05151483789086342, 0.04811808839440346, -0.03202488645911217, 0.04955148324370384, 0.010864365845918655, 0.009795437566936016, 0.03480393812060356, -0.000362940423656255, -0.009170187637209892, 0.0513942651450634, -0.035663504153490067, -0.054166797548532486, 0.01647910848259926, 0.036227788776159286, -0.007080726325511932, -0.06551167368888855, 0.018860889598727226, -0.004053939133882523, -0.019273880869150162, -0.01971547119319439, 0.0011350861750543118, 0.010300709865987301, -0.07554461061954498, 0.008820591494441032, -0.08598437160253525, -0.0035530682653188705, -0.038605738431215286, -0.01923176646232605, 0.03163839131593704, 0.02839878387749195, 0.018928077071905136, 0.021205885335803032, -0.028518695384263992, -0.021609000861644745, -0.042542386800050735, -0.06925712525844574, 0.016257373616099358, -0.0033855850342661142, -0.034710027277469635, 0.04726719856262207, 0.005282147321850061, 0.017257196828722954, 0.00042470870539546013, 0.03182150423526764, -0.013999862596392632, -0.00904799997806549, 0.014023148454725742, -0.007152355741709471, -0.007648182567209005, 0.0249855425208807, -0.038861945271492004, 0.028858335688710213, -0.05549035593867302, 0.021137390285730362, -0.02716408483684063, 0.00999550148844719, -0.006965655367821455, -0.029913706704974174, 0.040828704833984375, -0.005482433829456568, 0.04135570302605629, -0.05379137024283409, -0.02966388314962387, 0.04053118824958801, 0.0391133651137352, 0.024341939017176628, -0.001451567281037569, -0.0020466342102736235, -0.022133512422442436, -0.021075699478387833, -0.04391574487090111, 0.038639940321445465, -0.0996805876493454, 0.019139405339956284, -0.04377802088856697, 0.006432562600821257, -0.044121626764535904, -0.01583518460392952, 0.04659109190106392, 0.030460840091109276, 0.013965041376650333, -0.0058849649503827095, 0.05452593043446541, 0.019019294530153275, 0.004538381472229958, 0.02436688356101513, -0.00929504819214344, 0.05283118411898613, -0.06168266385793686, -0.004402820952236652, 0.01570620760321617, 0.01702909730374813, -0.005533155985176563, -0.009161210618913174, 0.01931099221110344, -0.06870468705892563, 0.00209913682192564, -0.030995162203907967, 0.039620887488126755, -0.0051622549071908, -0.004444546531885862, 0.04033355787396431, 0.002177505288273096, 0.049973178654909134, 0.025195226073265076, -0.009615138173103333, 0.004608220420777798, -0.0008439650409854949, 0.017977526411414146, 0.007180818356573582, -0.04669317230582237, -0.018403910100460052, 0.04856213927268982, -0.03261009603738785, 0.006279950030148029, -0.04002883657813072, 0.03533554449677467, 0.0049568042159080505, 0.06410198658704758, -0.05617335066199303, 0.02319217659533024, 0.029002727940678596, 0.020605752244591713, 0.0259238351136446, 0.014844054356217384, -0.0016420854954048991, 0.017957434058189392, 0.01673019491136074, 0.06780989468097687, 0.06639590859413147, 0.003694576444104314, -0.029950518161058426, -0.021490497514605522, 0.0015754436608403921, 0.02486441656947136, -0.004078616388142109, -0.02793152816593647, 0.09676291793584824, -0.015544156543910503, 0.016188757494091988, -0.04283040016889572, -0.026546107605099678, -0.06171785667538643, -0.03467649966478348, -0.060399267822504044, -0.020464017987251282, -0.04022828862071037, -0.015727344900369644, -0.031138839200139046, -0.10987348109483719, 0.024609841406345367, -0.017450397834181786, -0.05524113029241562, 0.03840036317706108, -0.01421532966196537, -0.01512628048658371, -0.05348175764083862, 0.06837143003940582, 0.019501911476254463, -0.017550237476825714, -0.022812863811850548, -0.030760692432522774, 0.021208984777331352, 0.015344616957008839, -0.010021714493632317, 0.031422216445207596, 0.02690206840634346, -0.04709600284695625, 0.03574622794985771, 0.026957839727401733, 0.02107657492160797, 0.042280636727809906, -0.002701425924897194, -0.027634194120764732, 0.020854979753494263, -0.00005937058449489996, 0.0571771115064621, 0.0066938153468072414, -0.024259481579065323, 0.016812121495604515, 0.02139424905180931, -0.0164226982742548, 0.008242395706474781, 0.047603342682123184, 0.006618021056056023, 0.049742553383111954, -0.028271149843931198, -0.029118327423930168, 0.003243339015170932, 0.06422597169876099, 0.05768689885735512, -0.007379667833447456, 0.03933770954608917, 0.0048641967587172985, -0.024835651740431786, -0.044786419719457626, 0.03908061608672142, -0.008671441115438938, -0.046081043779850006, 0.05929112061858177, 0.0000932320108404383, 0.023119546473026276, 0.0012799494434148073, -0.007732227444648743, -0.0520767904818058, 0.0156037462875247, -0.041564829647541046, -0.033544234931468964, -0.0022394293919205666, 0.01815522089600563, 0.014860035851597786, 0.0391320139169693, -0.07608412206172943, -0.03327491506934166, -0.052691396325826645, 0.011498997919261456, -0.04420735687017441, -0.03623906150460243, 0.09920788556337357, -0.06164801865816116, -0.023080885410308838, -0.012260094285011292, 0.023378798738121986, -0.0018337132642045617, -0.015110515058040619, -0.017827842384576797, 0.025074467062950134, -0.012101560831069946, 0.002029211027547717, -0.004618917591869831, -0.022601602599024773, 0.018021397292613983, -0.007660744711756706, 0.021567687392234802, 0.028452808037400246, -0.018002821132540703, 0.02026519551873207, -0.04549798369407654, -0.009601960889995098, -0.042883314192295074, -0.0431896336376667, -0.017697414383292198, -0.03606656566262245, -0.026081683114171028, -0.01770537905395031, 0.013245160691440105, -0.02114337868988514, 0.001436161925084889, 0.07100526988506317, 0.014578858390450478, -0.057503100484609604, 0.00735451327636838, 0.0019118593772873282, 0.005218177102506161, 0.031770650297403336, -0.01603241264820099, 0.015193016268312931, 0.013345454819500446, -0.030940745025873184, -0.04115799814462662, -0.054960861802101135, 0.03444458916783333, -0.04647497832775116, 0.04439779743552208, -0.021215058863162994, -0.025479299947619438, 0.024942830204963684, 0.012469982728362083, 0.024958312511444092, -0.014197423122823238, 0.002397723961621523, 0.025640906766057014, 0.04234695807099342, -0.01608140394091606, 0.006866267416626215, -0.0066349138505756855, 0.022763578221201897, 0.06343082338571548, -0.003987714648246765, 0.02366766147315502, 0.015041871927678585, -0.03208921104669571, -0.0391562357544899, -0.004771422129124403, 0.01840011402964592, 0.014573528431355953, 0.02826026827096939, -0.004745506215840578, -0.015236142091453075, -0.023905808106064796, -0.059305641800165176, -0.04625594615936279, 0.020772259682416916, -0.00005448209049063735, -0.02539006620645523, -0.04750160872936249, 0.010668695904314518, 0.03975718095898628, 0.016990436241030693, 0.0802224650979042, -0.017653020098805428, 0.002737109549343586, -0.012906203977763653, -0.0673462525010109, -0.06843838840723038, 0.013750302605330944, 0.0107030738145113, 0.01819464936852455, -0.02777845785021782, -0.014258735813200474, 0.020903099328279495, 0.09520842880010605, -0.04364302009344101, -0.003372086677700281, -0.056374385952949524, 0.03421121835708618, 0.03725481033325195, 0.04784702509641647, 0.036342691630125046, -0.03352681174874306, -0.030072854831814766, -0.06444497406482697, 0.018556227907538414, 0.030623814091086388, 0.044134724885225296, -0.026369556784629822, -0.015606102533638477, -0.0021819956600666046, 0.019379576668143272, -0.02978689596056938, 0.054145652800798416, -0.023552648723125458, 0.01988106220960617, -0.008882235735654831, -0.027411527931690216, -0.0016889231046661735, 0.011142661795020103, 0.0014391345903277397, -0.007024944294244051, 0.009365277364850044, 0.03207585960626602, 0.0315697081387043, -0.026068147271871567, 0.061240583658218384, -0.04741549491882324, 0.007269015535712242, -0.020163580775260925, -0.02299112267792225, 0.009474271908402443, -0.012935185804963112, -0.0797208771109581, 0.03449427708983421, -0.023900648579001427, 0.00629343930631876, -0.0373450368642807, -0.012937705963850021, -0.019133221358060837, 0.020283343270421028, 0.052696771919727325, -0.02655104547739029, 0.006314112804830074, 0.01576801761984825, 0.02343326434493065, -0.007755863480269909, 0.015065050683915615, 0.010997738689184189, 0.04122013598680496, -0.0021685112733393908, -0.0024919421412050724, 0.017869863659143448, 0.002843899419531226, 0.012637178413569927, 0.059888336807489395, -0.059656597673892975, -0.0036019503604620695, 0.01840611733496189, 0.03114898130297661, 0.0033260202035307884, 0.0085644805803895, -0.00809421855956316, -0.02827700786292553, -0.01922864094376564, 0.013975649140775204, 0.0015309262089431286, -0.028346585109829903, 0.02218267321586609, -0.015100155025720596, 0.08936388790607452, 0.002261603716760874, -0.04343368113040924, 0.03154519200325012, 0.0932513102889061, -0.04539833962917328, 0.03442024439573288, 0.06869078427553177, 0.000956949545070529, 0.04967612400650978, 0.07501237839460373, 0.001645379001274705, 0.004375752527266741, -0.004357938189059496, 0.015828125178813934, -0.005023022647947073, 0.07607278227806091, 0.043994300067424774, -0.041172631084918976, 0.08468490839004517, -0.050579700618982315, -0.015745144337415695, -0.04577530547976494, 0.015910660848021507, 0.04757627472281456, 0.027881106361746788, -0.06364313513040543, 0.04644506424665451, -0.009082553908228874, -0.01965920254588127, -0.011700180359184742, 0.014853045344352722, 0.008173942565917969, 0.03768249601125717, -0.049929145723581314, -0.0026964806020259857, 0.06956198811531067, 0.038683488965034485, -0.05265370011329651, -0.027745412662625313, 0.0063857161439955235, -0.030538536608219147, -0.029951995238661766, -0.019103650003671646, -0.05429922044277191, 0.006756167858839035, 0.005646809004247189, 0.10354699194431305, -0.0012374987127259374, -0.006488637998700142, -0.018405143171548843, -0.007088045589625835, 0.015779588371515274, -0.054457906633615494, 0.031692612916231155, 0.027398182079195976, 0.032640695571899414, -0.04355722665786743, 0.05376739427447319, -0.08423199504613876, -0.007773578632622957, -0.02005685120820999, -0.04431496188044548, -0.014318927191197872, -0.059237606823444366, -0.03292955830693245, -0.02682635560631752, -0.0494023822247982, 0.0352700911462307, -0.015080484561622143, 0.042172033339738846, -0.017968568950891495, 0.0036178866866976023, 0.0018192232819274068, -0.0400492399930954, -0.004172553773969412, 0.0036749031860381365, -0.008206653408706188, 0.01321098580956459, 0.047004956752061844, 0.03184259682893753, -0.026450570672750473, 0.01963898353278637, 0.018919410184025764, -0.07261382043361664, 0.05681638792157173, 0.03727785497903824, 0.0001238660333910957, -0.009679609909653664, -0.037758249789476395, 0.03225135803222656, 0.008375667035579681, 0.018166495487093925, 0.02146359533071518, -0.017736701294779778, -0.07529324293136597, 0.024789242073893547, 0.06299249827861786, 0.001277698902413249, -0.05631685256958008, -0.013481958769261837, 0.0011251693358644843, 0.044555969536304474, 0.01853308454155922, -0.018683508038520813, -0.025164686143398285, 0.00721965916454792, -0.10493580251932144, 0.007253655232489109, -0.006835103500634432, 0.04231013357639313, -0.009686416015028954, 0.023889390751719475, 0.008936161175370216, -0.0693831816315651, -0.06489575654268265, -0.03158888220787048, -0.0007849826943129301, -0.029231440275907516, 0.0007817689329385757, 0.05455624684691429, 0.02509617991745472, 0.061263542622327805, 0.0157556664198637, -0.05461473762989044, -0.007618993055075407, 0.04137006774544716, -0.013432053849101067, -0.010776402428746223, 0.017909910529851913, -0.05792791396379471, 0.0391215905547142, 0.0038231827784329653, 0.001984806265681982, 0.043135322630405426, -0.007221778854727745, 0.06266244500875473, -0.023598989471793175, -0.02379191853106022, -0.04311883822083473, -0.023593399673700333, -0.06848319619894028, 0.060064103454351425, 0.06113366410136223, -0.029861921444535255, 0.03881329670548439, 0.022353878244757652, -0.0185797568410635, 0.08555706590414047, 0.010836642235517502, 0.017186801880598068, 0.06558316946029663, -0.0665142610669136, -0.051825910806655884, 0.0488131120800972, -0.003220170270651579, 0.013786442577838898, -0.06430832296609879, -0.0006215323810465634, -0.03785710036754608, 0.029573148116469383, 0.03100946918129921, 0.034078605473041534, -0.043540675193071365, 0.004657620098441839, 0.04264684021472931, 0.0017284582136198878, -0.06875969469547272, -0.04773232713341713, -0.05090254545211792, -0.037473294883966446, -0.025526894256472588, -0.0313902273774147, -0.04485905542969704, -0.005467195995151997, -0.008704211562871933, 0.012368416413664818, -0.0011201289016753435, 0.011601313017308712, -0.0003236335178371519, 0.0205348152667284, 0.03691629320383072, -0.012712198309600353, 0.029115650802850723, -0.03182545676827431, 0.008540107868611813, 0.022449567914009094, 0.0385122075676918, -0.10397378355264664, -0.02747097983956337, -0.017175063490867615, -0.01679251343011856, 0.045774102210998535, -0.02037559077143669, 0.035131532698869705, 0.007891732268035412, -0.005037290509790182, -0.016623564064502716, -0.038715660572052, 0.0343855582177639, -0.06729917973279953, 0.01894858479499817, -0.0029538569506257772, 0.01804909110069275, 0.057416632771492004, 0.007225674577057362, 0.010171538218855858, -0.006994753610342741, 0.019064774736762047, 0.0032624946907162666, -0.013713818974792957, 0.04476654902100563, 0.021279942244291306, 0.007171077188104391, 0.06871848553419113, 0.00014178438868839294, -0.08793777227401733, -0.02850531041622162, -0.034756336361169815, 0.019608095288276672, 0.014095836319029331, -0.06757192313671112, -0.015469040721654892, -0.04637175053358078, -0.06568028032779694, -0.051731180399656296, 0.018241282552480698, 0.07245982438325882, -0.01903349533677101, 0.003324001794680953, 0.02030158042907715, 0.008430616930127144, -0.005066522862762213, -0.045656684786081314, -0.019087135791778564, 0.025587210431694984, -0.004696636460721493, -0.019344845786690712, 0.03393103927373886, 0.016788208857178688, -0.021455157548189163, -0.0562729686498642, -0.03679165616631508, 0.008118953555822372, 0.010556479915976524, 0.013138487935066223, -0.010658672079443932, -0.026958564296364784, 0.02080412581562996, 0.048065926879644394, -0.06718803197145462, 0.028802668675780296, 0.02800792083144188, 0.015670286491513252, -0.015957601368427277, 0.05354069918394089, -0.005783085711300373, -0.0037801836151629686, -0.01623520441353321, 0.0248781219124794, -0.04877780005335808, 0.021234426647424698, 0.029789244756102562, -0.06673180311918259, -0.027966029942035675, 0.03291232883930206, -0.003046767320483923, -0.04642462730407715, -0.02850659191608429, -0.015490138903260231, -0.013836166821420193, -0.03083796612918377, 0.029746973887085915, -0.020232558250427246, -0.010904009453952312, -0.02844216860830784, -0.025834552943706512, 0.02009887993335724, 0.04425683245062828, 0.01711193658411503, 0.025851264595985413, 0.042986974120140076, -0.07375437021255493, 0.038458243012428284, 0.01506823394447565, -0.01554951537400484, 0.040135353803634644, -0.055328987538814545, 0.057476386427879333, -0.028012990951538086, 0.01220390759408474, 0.016402924433350563, -0.037299033254384995, 0.04203760251402855, 0.02375071868300438, 0.02875334396958351, 0.015535205602645874, -0.0017621159786358476, -0.004832294769585133, -0.027671370655298233, -0.024884067475795746, 0.005024872720241547, 0.04634770378470421, 0.018427826464176178, 0.021135574206709862, 0.022906772792339325, -0.02587215229868889, -0.02379544824361801, -0.08383212238550186, 0.0307982936501503, 0.052107058465480804, -0.038409169763326645, -0.019420109689235687, 0.06941482424736023, -0.04248598590493202, -0.00044214428635314107, -0.04952391982078552, -0.02657563053071499, 0.012694388628005981, -0.028598571196198463, 0.0332043319940567, 0.014454920776188374, -0.03484483063220978, -0.01769089698791504, 0.09079199284315109, 0.12041700631380081, -0.061618346720933914, 0.07826800644397736, -0.04523855075240135, 0.042488787323236465, 0.03392746299505234, 0.03828931227326393, 0.030472218990325928, -0.06555355340242386, -0.009708951227366924, -0.04770270362496376, 0.07785588502883911, 0.01790018193423748, 0.03172767907381058, -0.0245138481259346, -0.0026116061490029097, 0.042696863412857056 ]
<p>Let $H= \frac{p^2}{2m}$, then I am supposed to calculate $[x,e^{-iHt}]$.</p> <p>My idea was to use $[x,p^n]=i \hbar n p^{n-1}$ and so I ended up by using the series for the exponential function with $-\frac{t \hbar}{m} e^{-iHt}$.</p> <p>Could anybody tell me, whether this result is correct? </p>
g4007
[ -0.02477906458079815, 0.005555737763643265, -0.005164772737771273, -0.026616740971803665, 0.025790229439735413, 0.013714652508497238, 0.037100814282894135, 0.008887939155101776, -0.07665295898914337, 0.03452347591519356, -0.03279316797852516, 0.051504187285900116, 0.034760233014822006, 0.051272280514240265, -0.031364358961582184, 0.01569170504808426, 0.06417042762041092, 0.03292001783847809, -0.06559060513973236, -0.0022299913689494133, -0.04357102885842323, -0.041845571249723434, -0.012050047516822815, 0.010008329525589943, 0.1021563708782196, -0.014299733564257622, 0.0297174584120512, 0.042608559131622314, -0.06037629395723343, 0.013529385440051556, 0.014020119793713093, 0.04539964720606804, 0.05030281841754913, -0.026242373511195183, -0.02732125297188759, 0.04630610719323158, 0.02869928628206253, 0.075533427298069, 0.060256242752075195, -0.05205124616622925, -0.01885506510734558, -0.009668495506048203, 0.01986085996031761, 0.03839808329939842, -0.0003562444762792438, -0.03191201016306877, -0.03456921502947807, 0.0578143373131752, 0.023769574239850044, -0.0024337051436305046, 0.05325433984398842, 0.022438427433371544, 0.036195386201143265, 0.004164877347648144, -0.03717198222875595, -0.021165885031223297, -0.002650453941896558, -0.053598616272211075, 0.03267959505319595, 0.027665892615914345, 0.010243161581456661, -0.023930935189127922, -0.02719864621758461, -0.01819724217057228, 0.023860659450292587, 0.004356490448117256, 0.031772878021001816, 0.013238813728094101, 0.05809847265481949, 0.039590075612068176, -0.019319413229823112, -0.06224062293767929, 0.03308076784014702, 0.0257741529494524, -0.04553020000457764, -0.017315557226538658, 0.034475177526474, 0.0032188321929425, 0.032232556492090225, -0.0002905703440774232, 0.043847668915987015, -0.034887753427028656, 0.05103491246700287, 0.013839569874107838, -0.020412815734744072, -0.02411133050918579, 0.007964372634887695, -0.014350762590765953, -0.03788187354803085, -0.01603313535451889, -0.02533186413347721, -0.03234720230102539, -0.021931597962975502, 0.008174560964107513, -0.00833298359066248, -0.037567514926195145, -0.03366326540708542, -0.012737998738884926, -0.000643191859126091, -0.01812293939292431, 0.02172306552529335, 0.004014606587588787, 0.017370497807860374, 0.02162153087556362, -0.004604565445333719, 0.05173933878540993, 0.03690356761217117, -0.0007973849424161017, 0.03817453607916832, -0.028710009530186653, -0.02113642916083336, -0.0005052175256423652, -0.05180395022034645, -0.06620246917009354, -0.027093712240457535, 0.05026397109031677, 0.004057008307427168, -0.03210051357746124, -0.017370503395795822, 0.047951944172382355, 0.027470663189888, -0.030963102355599403, 0.016993533819913864, 0.007157605141401291, -0.033544160425662994, 0.010888775810599327, -0.0669354498386383, 0.03147127479314804, 0.06311555206775665, -0.004193943925201893, -0.0011503096902742982, 0.012750501744449139, 0.05250253528356552, -0.008478664793074131, 0.05061357095837593, 0.012984879314899445, -0.018671713769435883, -0.0036300532519817352, -0.002678300952538848, 0.02098040282726288, -0.0521104633808136, -0.04112949222326279, -0.020297782495617867, -0.012028125114738941, -0.05224505439400673, 0.06410405039787292, -0.003198572900146246, -0.05368738994002342, 0.01846962608397007, -0.02338246814906597, -0.030132660642266273, 0.07237425446510315, 0.009100782684981823, 0.045112643390893936, 0.024188706651329994, 0.029045231640338898, 0.033423446118831635, 0.004934362135827541, -0.007812228053808212, 0.015574486926198006, -0.032943740487098694, 0.019914044067263603, 0.051111944019794464, 0.016194624826312065, -0.027391819283366203, 0.0351167768239975, -0.03733278065919876, -0.03143530711531639, 0.00008219636947615072, -0.05415312945842743, -0.006195466965436935, 0.045529428869485855, 0.02332153543829918, -0.009908588603138924, -0.009338533505797386, 0.0030977523420006037, 0.041254110634326935, 0.0024007882457226515, -0.015070637688040733, 0.03055226057767868, 0.03517216071486473, -0.013477468863129616, -0.006385629530996084, 0.019142786040902138, 0.0036197551526129246, -0.04264450818300247, 0.020018700510263443, -0.012364272959530354, -0.06671932339668274, -0.002645611995831132, -0.010148967616260052, 0.08658426254987717, -0.024420762434601784, 0.03738946467638016, 0.015000524930655956, 0.07780896872282028, 0.01968555338680744, -0.060987915843725204, -0.01825535297393799, 0.05418795347213745, 0.0114857517182827, 0.06870492547750473, 0.061205849051475525, -0.04426976293325424, -0.02056020498275757, -0.011982228606939316, -0.005240464583039284, -0.06343290954828262, 0.003677050117403269, -0.002575781662017107, -0.0411035381257534, -0.046213433146476746, -0.03330356255173683, 0.0021404726430773735, -0.026860436424613, -0.0329500176012516, -0.019652148708701134, 0.024838730692863464, -0.0703299343585968, -0.0005437007057480514, -0.019358910620212555, 0.050274014472961426, 0.004514743108302355, 0.008668427355587482, -0.014319321140646935, 0.004455653019249439, 0.037204448133707047, 0.027750814333558083, -0.02514517866075039, -0.027317779138684273, -0.054105211049318314, -0.004831936210393906, -0.026310395449399948, -0.0417480394244194, -0.004061955958604813, -0.016308045014739037, -0.02721440978348255, 0.01979336142539978, 0.023626068606972694, 0.04301764443516731, 0.005988302640616894, -0.01218531932681799, -0.02157364785671234, -0.015906020998954773, 0.05652538686990738, -0.00003893366738338955, 0.027903487905859947, 0.015435882844030857, -0.005265228450298309, -0.0026303930208086967, -0.002295717829838395, -0.00004567414725897834, -0.037260957062244415, 0.034216463565826416, -0.007213765289634466, -0.02600497379899025, -0.05043696612119675, -0.03080247901380062, 0.016188887879252434, 0.047613222151994705, -0.024704480543732643, -0.0459371954202652, 0.00042606150964275, -0.03149011731147766, -0.09290444105863571, -0.03237700089812279, -0.0358675979077816, -0.016040939837694168, 0.04742661491036415, 0.0020370176061987877, -0.0032415371388196945, 0.019773175939917564, 0.0060348594561219215, 0.06866656243801117, -0.045629970729351044, -0.09472457319498062, 0.03242107853293419, -0.016854554414749146, 0.027446705847978592, -0.015328023582696915, -0.024302560836076736, 0.012325878255069256, 0.0010326600167900324, 0.051123086363077164, 0.031330205500125885, -0.0073786089196801186, 0.022841889411211014, 0.08893677592277527, -0.0070925019681453705, 0.02977571450173855, 0.012985221110284328, -0.04135465621948242, -0.04312289133667946, -0.027309738099575043, 0.027464332059025764, 0.03031928278505802, 0.019291697070002556, -0.056751709431409836, 0.010843024589121342, 0.023624571040272713, 0.02483206056058407, -0.042231496423482895, 0.005093616899102926, -0.058234307914972305, 0.027576908469200134, -0.05874403938651085, 0.006530187092721462, -0.036264099180698395, 0.04019545391201973, -0.008726708590984344, -0.008920509368181229, 0.03356446325778961, 0.04087161272764206, -0.027960576117038727, -0.023304324597120285, 0.02762950025498867, 0.09059133380651474, -0.03207133337855339, 0.02640756592154503, 0.016066767275333405, -0.030850842595100403, -0.06516526639461517, -0.026592480018734932, -0.015553737990558147, -0.04972592741250992, 0.010953599587082863, -0.024392347782850266, -0.028678610920906067, -0.05742921307682991, -0.011764655821025372, 0.010352971963584423, 0.0002894182689487934, 0.022110769525170326, -0.012934725731611252, 0.015515211038291454, -0.020749829709529877, 0.04782229661941528, 0.028305647894740105, 0.0025776729453355074, 0.01685478165745735, -0.04650901257991791, 0.002045056549832225, 0.021137848496437073, 0.002440223703160882, -0.02513621374964714, -0.09320034086704254, -0.0742659941315651, 0.061490777879953384, 0.024643704295158386, -0.01813453435897827, -0.028153875842690468, -0.0019083669176325202, 0.015937259420752525, 0.024261746555566788, 0.03889961168169975, -0.027171989902853966, 0.018211519345641136, 0.02112751081585884, 0.03549831360578537, -0.003060563001781702, 0.020714538171887398, -0.05793814733624458, 0.0033692384604364634, 0.07211927324533463, -0.04561145231127739, -0.07072152197360992, 0.020099829882383347, 0.11399081349372864, -0.012602872215211391, 0.006705884821712971, 0.010577155277132988, -0.008003788068890572, 0.091975137591362, 0.00867933314293623, -0.04349805787205696, -0.023995960131287575, 0.01048523560166359, 0.013187522068619728, 0.009227636270225048, 0.07648149877786636, 0.008225868456065655, -0.006358403712511063, -0.030052851885557175, 0.045024968683719635, 0.039417367428541183, -0.012791808694601059, 0.010410916060209274, 0.011235477402806282, 0.07864858210086823, -0.03386466205120087, 0.008030922152101994, -0.006478185299783945, 0.009834065102040768, 0.010869870893657207, 0.01240196917206049, -0.059285134077072144, 0.015253868885338306, -0.003676207037642598, -0.08890136331319809, 0.04994480684399605, 0.004730637185275555, -0.04919314384460449, 0.04194384068250656, -0.012395022436976433, -0.05287661775946617, 0.037252169102430344, 0.03274250775575638, -0.04115314036607742, 0.06297601759433746, -0.022702880203723907, -0.05904868617653847, -0.00411341292783618, 0.03985718637704849, -0.036158572882413864, -0.019459789618849754, -0.019237523898482323, 0.057226017117500305, -0.023312591016292572, 0.02849728614091873, 0.01638871431350708, 0.009287571534514427, -0.04252977296710014, 0.0030498739797621965, -0.05199280381202698, -0.047815028578042984, 0.05864197388291359, 0.09372779726982117, 0.008382472209632397, -0.022479914128780365, 0.023309972137212753, -0.026914017274975777, 0.03015340119600296, -0.012077054008841515, 0.009796489030122757, -0.029390016570687294, 0.02316884882748127, 0.009241200052201748, 0.0004143581900279969, -0.04206359013915062, 0.019125094637274742, 0.05415601283311844, -0.015124854631721973, -0.03872506320476532, -0.002076962264254689, 0.047524210065603256, 0.004939228296279907, 0.005035123322159052, -0.07047796249389648, 0.033828724175691605, 0.05046466737985611, -0.010292141698300838, -0.018592966720461845, 0.06321331858634949, 0.04132678732275963, 0.04296037554740906, -0.02229594811797142, -0.004608894232660532, -0.0018466133624315262, 0.05972585082054138, 0.04060713201761246, -0.016836637631058693, -0.020749559625983238, 0.012276330031454563, 0.0316450335085392, 0.09043439477682114, 0.018091579899191856, -0.08259867876768112, 0.010376698337495327, 0.013397104106843472, 0.020579004660248756, -0.002032185671851039, 0.033938053995370865, 0.01796271651983261, -0.05746466666460037, 0.019965529441833496, 0.0061997463926672935, -0.045405156910419464, 0.02347463369369507, -0.07158397883176804, -0.02614017389714718, 0.013282367959618568, -0.0673539862036705, 0.0005980905843898654, -0.024115227162837982, 0.010260308161377907, -0.03217252716422081, -0.03779191896319389, -0.017340345308184624, 0.0007105317199602723, -0.02030233107507229, 0.025768611580133438, 0.02264530584216118, 0.014559776522219181, -0.01450631208717823, -0.013701135292649269, -0.041933320462703705, 0.05595383420586586, -0.019614918157458305, 0.06836343556642532, 0.02416061982512474, -0.01933514140546322, 0.007675344590097666, -0.0986514687538147, -0.027995143085718155, 0.031278546899557114, 0.01900939643383026, 0.08049353957176208, -0.042164288461208344, -0.04482446238398552, 0.034381695091724396, 0.029378676787018776, -0.021823009476065636, 0.008240807801485062, 0.03444310277700424, 0.023887068033218384, 0.04375133290886879, -0.038122616708278656, -0.012551157735288143, -0.057520411908626556, -0.027702437713742256, 0.08816860616207123, 0.027764495462179184, 0.07454461604356766, -0.03859773278236389, -0.0036804673727601767, -0.02153504267334938, -0.0458269901573658, -0.08736880868673325, -0.0363437719643116, 0.030044319108128548, -0.017362894490361214, -0.043864063918590546, -0.012405981309711933, -0.005604267120361328, -0.0031380525324493647, -0.008900010026991367, -0.033563680946826935, 0.015006080269813538, 0.0444231741130352, 0.0025446570944041014, -0.013121259398758411, 0.0056720031425356865, 0.011703449301421642, 0.036025092005729675, -0.019800709560513496, 0.032677311450242996, -0.005926067940890789, 0.004762185737490654, 0.05839231610298157, 0.02647917903959751, -0.027808386832475662, 0.02220313437283039, -0.036245837807655334, -0.09878069907426834, -0.019676724448800087, 0.06893013417720795, 0.07008597999811172, -0.033696457743644714, 0.043873295187950134, 0.01215609535574913, -0.005532294511795044, -0.03140779212117195, -0.05282243713736534, 0.023663204163312912, -0.04067520797252655, -0.017229758203029633, 0.05686030164361, 0.043014045804739, -0.04105454310774803, 0.03991853445768356, 0.008659430779516697, 0.02695300057530403, 0.03541892394423485, 0.011367235332727432, 0.090703584253788, 0.050794534385204315, 0.03190062195062637, -0.0367419496178627, 0.03883102163672447, -0.06235930696129799, -0.04974546283483505, 0.04087219759821892, 0.019864927977323532, 0.055262356996536255, -0.03728717938065529, -0.01747887022793293, 0.0075856470502913, -0.018532857298851013, 0.05820528045296669, 0.008318492211401463, -0.0479472279548645, -0.0072371866554021835, -0.015557716600596905, -0.0088053522631526, 0.028076644986867905, 0.024965250864624977, 0.01711321249604225, 0.0037137854378670454, -0.03716038540005684, -0.026618225499987602, 0.04998379945755005, 0.000982506200671196, 0.014414401724934578, -0.05032666400074959, 0.010848341509699821, -0.021603714674711227, 0.029036594554781914, 0.039061762392520905, -0.016215262934565544, 0.028863316401839256, -0.0240730419754982, 0.036155104637145996, 0.019314616918563843, 0.0003630038700066507, -0.019109250977635384, -0.05116523057222366, 0.050684601068496704, 0.02980613335967064, 0.0058999937027692795, 0.006296976935118437, 0.037503186613321304, -0.03086046874523163, -0.045944809913635254, -0.01623108983039856, 0.02637791819870472, 0.03953181579709053, 0.014554956927895546, -0.005086617078632116, 0.02567487768828869, -0.051454536616802216, 0.027836229652166367, -0.0006343508721329272, -0.0372769758105278, 0.009262055158615112, -0.012063788250088692, -0.000529370503500104, -0.024047978222370148, 0.05464476719498634, -0.06347587704658508, 0.042774930596351624, -0.05699607729911804, 0.044126320630311966, 0.00511453952640295, 0.018893959000706673, -0.0824575424194336, 0.016714490950107574, 0.035700324922800064, 0.014829833060503006, -0.10166683048009872, 0.011135831475257874, 0.055679239332675934, 0.049923334270715714, -0.00919647142291069, -0.006157237105071545, -0.021578926593065262, -0.02784663252532482, 0.022678682580590248, 0.004897909238934517, -0.003334237029775977, 0.003360495902597904, -0.004983832128345966, -0.009090148843824863, 0.001423482084646821, -0.007535945158451796, 0.00937903206795454, 0.02176673710346222, 0.003851610701531172, -0.032880548387765884, 0.0024349510204046965, -0.04790233448147774, -0.005063749849796295, 0.029781043529510498, -0.04522695392370224, -0.01855112612247467, 0.024860741570591927, 0.029811179265379906, -0.025287706404924393, 0.016969935968518257, -0.08794142305850983, 0.000059679900004994124, -0.023450449109077454, 0.006116657983511686, 0.0036696474999189377, -0.05557500198483467, -0.016482414677739143, 0.029484491795301437, -0.07073676586151123, -0.057018838822841644, -0.0028822505846619606, -0.00202822033315897, -0.004776120651513338, -0.028986625373363495, 0.048919763416051865, -0.03364555165171623, -0.005900814663618803, -0.017651818692684174, 0.015370158478617668, -0.021415872499346733, -0.050067368894815445, 0.025223245844244957, 0.049425505101680756, -0.027095356956124306, 0.018911786377429962, -0.030107000842690468, -0.024952000007033348, -0.005012575536966324, 0.0006735006463713944, -0.014235485345125198, 0.002720113843679428, -0.06700758635997772, 0.06671307235956192, 0.03413137048482895, -0.030635720118880272, -0.0076533048413693905, 0.00001737278580549173, -0.030980173498392105, -0.00796465203166008, -0.0035369566176086664, -0.006300066597759724, -0.04662051424384117, -0.05657882243394852, 0.007778641767799854, 0.03454308211803436, 0.008055625483393669, -0.06006838008761406, 0.028510907664895058, -0.03156903758645058, -0.05000332370400429, -0.023645760491490364, 0.026534397155046463, -0.06862598657608032, -0.04452582821249962, -0.013607698492705822, 0.037095170468091965, -0.022414714097976685, -0.03914358466863632, 0.01808820106089115, -0.01202067919075489, 0.022433962672948837, 0.01609773375093937, -0.04349479451775551, -0.014080138877034187, 0.01015134435147047, -0.01319647766649723, 0.05212453752756119, -0.04893862456083298, -0.0030726687982678413, -0.016964087262749672, 0.06252448260784149, 0.026821954175829887, -0.004197318106889725, 0.037052642554044724, -0.04191780462861061, 0.033903103321790695, 0.048776160925626755, -0.05930711701512337, 0.007686074357479811, 0.03581128269433975, 0.031613752245903015, 0.034265659749507904, -0.017268801108002663, -0.028139637783169746, -0.07453751564025879, 0.007584821432828903, 0.005227354820817709, -0.07333612442016602, 0.05751386657357216, 0.037914928048849106 ]
<p>Let's consider a single-particle(boson or fermion) with $n$ states $\phi_1,\cdots,\phi_n$(normalized orthogonal basis of the single-particle Hilbert space), and let $h$ be the single-particle Hamiltonian. As we all know, the second quantization Hamiltonian $H=\sum\left \langle \phi_i \mid h \phi_j \right \rangle c_i^\dagger c_j$ of $h$ should <em>not</em> depend on the single-particle basis we choose(where $c_i,c_i^\dagger$ are the bosonic or fermionic operators.), and this can be easily proved as follows:</p> <p>Choose a new basis, say $(\widetilde{\phi}_1,\cdots,\widetilde{\phi}_n)=(\phi_1,\cdots,\phi_n)U$, where $U$ is a $n\times n$ unitary matrix. Further, from the math viewpoint, an inner product can has two alternative definitions, say $\left \langle \lambda_1\psi_1\mid \lambda_2 \psi_2 \right \rangle=\lambda_1^*\lambda_2 \left \langle \psi_1\mid \psi_2 \right \rangle(1)$ or $\lambda_1\lambda_2^* \left \langle \psi_1\mid \psi_2 \right \rangle(2)$.</p> <p>Now, if we think $(\widetilde{c}_1^\dagger,\cdots,\widetilde{c}_n^\dagger)=(c_1^\dagger,\cdots,c_n^\dagger)U$ combined with the definition (1) for inner product, then it's easy to show that $\sum\left \langle \widetilde{\phi}_i \mid h \widetilde{\phi}_j \right \rangle \widetilde{c}_i^\dagger \widetilde{c}_j=\sum\left\langle \phi_i \mid h \phi_j \right \rangle c_i^\dagger c_j$; On the other hand, if we think $(\widetilde{c}_1,\cdots,\widetilde{c}_n)=(c_1,\cdots,c_n)U$ combined with the definition (2) for inner product, one can also show that $\sum\left \langle \widetilde{\phi}_i \mid h \widetilde{\phi}_j \right \rangle \widetilde{c}_i^\dagger \widetilde{c}_j=\sum\left\langle \phi_i \mid h \phi_j \right \rangle c_i^\dagger c_j$. </p> <p>Which <strong>combination</strong> of transformation for operators and definition for inner product is more reasonable? I myself prefer to the former one. </p>
g4008
[ -0.004778760951012373, 0.008384467102587223, 0.0028031656984239817, -0.022602636367082596, 0.057858388870954514, -0.04971781373023987, 0.014488788321614265, 0.038062743842601776, 0.02153375744819641, 0.006794462446123362, -0.06371676176786423, 0.04593908041715622, -0.06366797536611557, 0.007192880846560001, -0.018147261813282967, 0.018388796597719193, 0.028496764600276947, 0.04611238092184067, 0.006643709260970354, -0.02139505185186863, -0.08655831962823868, 0.0446598082780838, -0.026609722524881363, -0.01355353556573391, 0.011420291848480701, -0.09018353372812271, 0.010236037895083427, 0.020639656111598015, -0.026887008920311928, 0.023464947938919067, 0.06190505251288414, 0.001540729426778853, 0.02322719618678093, 0.006449680309742689, 0.011049910448491573, 0.00041657869587652385, 0.08376076817512512, 0.04182915762066841, 0.05159804970026016, -0.03313789144158363, -0.005571563728153706, -0.014661435037851334, 0.03890175744891167, -0.0564986951649189, -0.013263799250125885, 0.010287373326718807, 0.021337680518627167, 0.004088903311640024, -0.0224413201212883, -0.014641380868852139, 0.0008614667458459735, 0.022310398519039154, 0.03135361522436142, -0.009682316333055496, 0.03929665684700012, 0.04960513487458229, -0.04891163483262062, -0.005024909973144531, 0.009690465405583382, 0.058566492050886154, -0.032092634588479996, -0.0012367849703878164, -0.04273313656449318, -0.025545503944158554, 0.025334643200039864, 0.04186515137553215, 0.02082635648548603, 0.06201868876814842, -0.0028110952116549015, -0.005501899868249893, 0.010375934652984142, -0.0861220583319664, 0.0737534835934639, 0.012449952773749828, -0.00553493807092309, -0.043572403490543365, -0.017852121964097023, 0.02683725580573082, 0.020780816674232483, 0.022854816168546677, -0.05108601599931717, -0.04735805466771126, -0.025210974738001823, -0.016850681975483894, 0.00974139105528593, 0.013075505383312702, 0.01291776541620493, 0.03409644216299057, 0.03387898579239845, 0.049029964953660965, -0.023186538368463516, 0.033931393176317215, 0.05164983496069908, 0.07165702432394028, -0.021973205730319023, -0.04131493717432022, -0.01806768961250782, 0.032125383615493774, -0.0002210270904470235, -0.004876674618571997, -0.022640274837613106, -0.00536034582182765, 0.008535929024219513, -0.04498813673853874, 0.005394135136157274, 0.021685127168893814, 0.05122780054807663, -0.03921551629900932, -0.022394821047782898, -0.013217083178460598, -0.06093720719218254, 0.013048925437033176, 0.03221748024225235, -0.04255954176187515, -0.04340314492583275, -0.008985796943306923, 0.015419385395944118, 0.006601070053875446, -0.028848521411418915, 0.055590637028217316, -0.015101595781743526, -0.0359000526368618, 0.07118673622608185, 0.0077976626344025135, 0.025758983567357063, -0.014577003195881844, -0.008661481551826, 0.02701951190829277, 0.018194027245044708, -0.022743506357073784, -0.015172658488154411, -0.03667805343866348, -0.004548260476440191, 0.048950549215078354, 0.0024967058561742306, 0.0060690222308039665, -0.005190275609493256, 0.024532118812203407, -0.006011508405208588, -0.005223086569458246, 0.007142720744013786, -0.030132301151752472, -0.01525944471359253, -0.01396669540554285, -0.02623799256980419, 0.010187608189880848, 0.054742418229579926, -0.039263706654310226, -0.021403733640909195, 0.0774681568145752, -0.020281724631786346, 0.011106541380286217, -0.012957997620105743, 0.031368620693683624, 0.007841241545975208, 0.009317412972450256, 0.08493849635124207, 0.04516102001070976, -0.0017581356223672628, 0.012675418518483639, -0.011214647442102432, 0.020585283637046814, 0.008583013899624348, -0.0010862975614145398, 0.004110938869416714, -0.031596921384334564, 0.04274219274520874, -0.059155065566301346, 0.017462100833654404, -0.05190594121813774, 0.030434902757406235, -0.013307220302522182, -0.00979660078883171, 0.00887362938374281, 0.04756660386919975, -0.0009232870652340353, -0.04053419828414917, 0.017622366547584534, -0.016305429860949516, 0.06507028639316559, -0.04909667372703552, 0.048619721084833145, 0.028846418485045433, 0.013930924236774445, -0.0020821229554712772, -0.001368983881548047, -0.0029973227065056562, 0.02633776143193245, 0.01030784472823143, 0.055656157433986664, -0.058138903230428696, 0.024590060114860535, 0.03728264570236206, -0.01442120410501957, -0.03900575265288353, 0.018155066296458244, 0.06740058958530426, -0.0371093824505806, -0.03677389398217201, -0.023882349953055382, -0.10085558146238327, -0.0005439577507786453, 0.027474340051412582, -0.02408580482006073, -0.02818877622485161, 0.01780405268073082, 0.00610567769035697, 0.037225671112537384, 0.004959150217473507, -0.051940932869911194, 0.030089033767580986, -0.02381974831223488, -0.0414043553173542, 0.01610632985830307, -0.01807257905602455, -0.040004655718803406, -0.030682124197483063, 0.009826290421187878, -0.04914601519703865, 0.03963566571474075, -0.01455416064709425, -0.030039437115192413, 0.023138122633099556, -0.027017569169402122, -0.009980231523513794, 0.035325538367033005, -0.011813468299806118, -0.02885379269719124, 0.018393268808722496, 0.018507979810237885, -0.028195161372423172, 0.030780334025621414, -0.04041903465986252, -0.06629515439271927, 0.030403122305870056, 0.01094039250165224, 0.005365054588764906, 0.011571294628083706, 0.04502662643790245, 0.05050717294216156, 0.01333093922585249, -0.06887141615152359, -0.02326204814016819, -0.060412757098674774, 0.0030614205170422792, 0.006370928138494492, -0.023441515862941742, 0.014014744199812412, -0.02759706787765026, -0.05375247821211815, -0.09533104300498962, -0.009447998367249966, -0.03854085132479668, -0.0357726588845253, -0.014400456100702286, -0.0068410481326282024, 0.033422138541936874, -0.030858419835567474, -0.01485161017626524, 0.022722436115145683, 0.011770336888730526, 0.0015713425818830729, -0.05450836941599846, 0.0891503095626831, -0.01261056773364544, 0.010250722989439964, -0.016135195270180702, -0.010706004686653614, 0.05266125500202179, 0.03185397759079933, -0.05087529122829437, 0.044984132051467896, -0.01740899309515953, 0.0013877792516723275, -0.004022878594696522, -0.04917093738913536, -0.0629904642701149, 0.029969099909067154, -0.0066006784327328205, 0.012167206965386868, -0.015221703797578812, 0.03814239427447319, -0.028357308357954025, 0.045221034437417984, 0.006710930727422237, -0.07758424431085587, -0.042908065021038055, 0.02000158466398716, -0.013239541091024876, 0.03423125296831131, 0.032013535499572754, 0.04258681833744049, 0.04874107614159584, 0.0055420235730707645, 0.018951615318655968, -0.02008740045130253, -0.007656604517251253, -0.019032549113035202, 0.034146204590797424, 0.062306925654411316, 0.05451195314526558, -0.015518907457590103, 0.0013964228564873338, -0.01859523355960846, 0.0721053034067154, -0.03275357931852341, -0.037325795739889145, -0.043921373784542084, -0.06098974868655205, -0.0013939975760877132, 0.023439111188054085, 0.05621051788330078, 0.0087278438732028, -0.03699523210525513, -0.014652591198682785, -0.038754429668188095, -0.02229214459657669, -0.0425906628370285, 0.02976369857788086, -0.059125564992427826, -0.029166387394070625, -0.022942664101719856, 0.019876183941960335, -0.01856931298971176, 0.0366252139210701, 0.025476790964603424, -0.0861053541302681, 0.01115726213902235, -0.025654103606939316, -0.09171807020902634, -0.03156657889485359, 0.014106925576925278, 0.05572037026286125, 0.057626012712717056, -0.07766147702932358, -0.042383238673210144, 0.024529658257961273, -0.03153347596526146, 0.02454143948853016, -0.00703305983915925, 0.0168002936989069, -0.04945112392306328, -0.011863133870065212, -0.00023975899966899306, -0.03807671740651131, -0.02969970926642418, 0.000845947302877903, 0.03275744244456291, 0.006218302994966507, 0.0018483658786863089, -0.014359944500029087, 0.0019799494184553623, 0.040549833327531815, 0.05035318806767464, 0.002901917090639472, -0.0070098391734063625, 0.04187743738293648, 0.07414540648460388, 0.01715756021440029, -0.008066128939390182, 0.011093642562627792, -0.010234487242996693, -0.015522043220698833, -0.009237508289515972, -0.053839728236198425, -0.025403469800949097, 0.022027447819709778, -0.03236471861600876, -0.020117247477173805, -0.026457512751221657, 0.024461692199110985, 0.07118949294090271, 0.01120403315871954, -0.05454213172197342, -0.02507452480494976, -0.016198744997382164, 0.02705198898911476, -0.02989690564572811, 0.024889251217246056, -0.046683698892593384, 0.002608792157843709, 0.0010442206403240561, 0.005634189583361149, 0.026058480143547058, 0.012860100716352463, 0.04571017622947693, 0.012433398514986038, 0.0007882376667112112, 0.02337171882390976, 0.01884867437183857, -0.013881013728678226, -0.04552580043673515, 0.004115583375096321, 0.0008467846782878041, 0.05265386402606964, 0.0030062878504395485, 0.007698538713157177, -0.05060494318604469, -0.10866198688745499, 0.04034830257296562, -0.06546784192323685, -0.07411065697669983, 0.03934657201170921, -0.08298111706972122, -0.07621800899505615, -0.0038176707457751036, 0.04333759844303131, -0.0031903882045298815, -0.02053861692547798, -0.06188351660966873, 0.0004928678972646594, 0.025744615122675896, 0.046356432139873505, 0.009797449223697186, -0.013181070797145367, -0.012150313705205917, -0.01088454108685255, -0.029805144295096397, -0.02830084227025509, 0.017435221001505852, 0.03248041495680809, 0.01880568638443947, 0.002923906547948718, 0.01785586215555668, -0.006415440700948238, -0.06173871457576752, 0.03636404126882553, 0.07311376184225082, 0.006780436262488365, 0.006438984535634518, 0.02506333217024803, -0.0015106648206710815, 0.030977491289377213, 0.010658159852027893, -0.08373641222715378, 0.00548926368355751, -0.012464076280593872, 0.028445007279515266, 0.0027527380734682083, 0.026428526267409325, 0.02229888364672661, 0.013065285980701447, -0.019352244213223457, -0.04240766540169716, 0.042881179600954056, -0.04790269583463669, -0.02729850821197033, -0.029323261231184006, 0.008816300891339779, -0.012148183770477772, 0.0034802821464836597, 0.04770590364933014, 0.004252886865288019, -0.009675387293100357, 0.029519788920879364, 0.0028953496366739273, -0.013632640242576599, 0.00713694142177701, 0.017568781971931458, 0.02196255512535572, 0.0033432987984269857, 0.01650291681289673, 0.0038813615683466196, -0.010629252530634403, 0.001730459975078702, 0.001912356005050242, -0.08579984307289124, 0.07088956981897354, -0.05081408470869064, -0.020672980695962906, 0.026634251698851585, 0.03981347754597664, 0.028497397899627686, -0.05050819367170334, 0.049380842596292496, 0.037228699773550034, -0.029479973018169403, -0.06143363565206528, -0.04601414129137993, -0.015597392804920673, -0.029105888679623604, -0.030484521761536598, -0.016060372814536095, 0.03769394010305405, 0.004548311699181795, 0.0242890827357769, 0.014979323372244835, -0.05468488484621048, -0.05635448917746544, -0.005888247396796942, -0.02307637594640255, 0.014570550993084908, 0.020784612745046616, 0.016507286578416824, -0.01944056898355484, 0.030922524631023407, -0.022053003311157227, -0.06322269886732101, 0.012411621399223804, 0.0018566343933343887, -0.025365561246871948, -0.0007849607500247657, -0.0024116449058055878, 0.051785483956336975, 0.008037950843572617, -0.09046029299497604, 0.057248055934906006, 0.006053735502064228, 0.02894558757543564, 0.021859515458345413, 0.05508878082036972, 0.01082079578191042, 0.011732636950910091, -0.010054565034806728, -0.007690675090998411, 0.05467814952135086, 0.0821056142449379, 0.07577291876077652, -0.020104985684156418, -0.06495536118745804, 0.0396605022251606, 0.031721290200948715, 0.007276082411408424, -0.010463094338774681, 0.06053592264652252, 0.058476030826568604, -0.028208835050463676, -0.059596914798021317, 0.0019797931890934706, 0.028792744502425194, 0.03452618047595024, 0.06912746280431747, 0.04241495952010155, 0.02887660078704357, -0.012929223477840424, -0.0715748742222786, -0.03534616529941559, 0.014107432216405869, -0.038227926939725876, -0.0047506308183074, -0.01700105331838131, -0.03404612839221954, 0.018152112141251564, 0.01814684271812439, -0.009011146612465382, 0.025492681190371513, -0.015333025716245174, 0.006347972434014082, -0.008539347909390926, 0.014903190545737743, -0.010924292728304863, -0.05840371176600456, -0.061267927289009094, -0.07257843017578125, 0.054787613451480865, 0.015665337443351746, 0.06069108098745346, -0.022392448037862778, -0.0019648743327707052, 0.012500175274908543, -0.01911335065960884, -0.03599263355135918, -0.0026644498575478792, 0.012479842640459538, 0.0402703732252121, 0.000958132790401578, 0.01816866174340248, -0.02341311424970627, -0.001764424261637032, 0.0428677462041378, 0.015071097761392593, 0.0461442731320858, 0.04048212245106697, 0.02172878384590149, 0.07109075784683228, 0.07295019179582596, 0.013287834823131561, -0.02806546725332737, -0.023261314257979393, 0.02438264898955822, -0.005576553754508495, -0.008448692038655281, 0.00199393043294549, -0.024969248101115227, -0.011906513012945652, 0.05452713370323181, -0.029263241216540337, -0.03900676593184471, 0.07234163582324982, 0.03833698108792305, -0.013391120359301567, 0.00003693158578244038, -0.0007787360227666795, -0.04559922218322754, 0.01131049357354641, 0.07916142791509628, -0.022482678294181824, -0.013395821675658226, -0.0426996611058712, -0.017613306641578674, 0.04477180168032646, -0.020735448226332664, 0.018545107915997505, 0.02622586116194725, -0.01515282690525055, 0.046368345618247986, -0.04836176335811615, -0.02271137572824955, -0.02475161664187908, 0.00991299469023943, 0.030607320368289948, -0.054331548511981964, -0.004563393071293831, 0.0430266335606575, -0.03734618052840233, -0.049517229199409485, -0.018968842923641205, 0.061579227447509766, 0.00468955934047699, 0.022277789190411568, 0.0302939061075449, -0.04111369326710701, -0.017734695225954056, -0.06389201432466507, -0.015628913417458534, 0.11027274280786514, 0.013251018710434437, -0.030533121898770332, 0.01032949984073639, 0.010691392235457897, 0.008304673247039318, 0.03738365322351456, 0.1115318015217781, -0.014160805381834507, -0.0492733009159565, -0.00992411095649004, -0.026376862078905106, 0.029098080471158028, -0.05032820254564285, 0.04541204869747162, -0.04032742977142334, 0.010276220738887787, 0.03677244111895561, -0.01469248253852129, -0.11034447699785233, 0.030567171052098274, 0.05407236889004707, 0.03363972529768944, -0.04530267044901848, -0.0036063427105545998, 0.015240720473229885, 0.04335852339863777, 0.011840404942631721, -0.021946845576167107, 0.003554866649210453, -0.03202465549111366, 0.06024248152971268, 0.02902175299823284, 0.04642524570226669, -0.04293645918369293, -0.023745236918330193, -0.015567517839372158, -0.061713386327028275, -0.02041107974946499, 0.008129151538014412, 0.023046398535370827, -0.03281673789024353, 0.03747859597206116, -0.006824249867349863, -0.05595264583826065, -0.03029157780110836, -0.01682078279554844, -0.05226850509643555, 0.007872172631323338, 0.023718250915408134, 0.04212350398302078, -0.0014051366597414017, 0.060000743716955185, -0.002459682757034898, -0.027672065421938896, -0.028448134660720825, 0.001871275482699275, -0.051059722900390625, -0.007465032394975424, -0.05038012936711311, -0.010474679060280323, -0.02047288417816162, 0.014155824668705463, -0.023565957322716713, -0.030877599492669106, 0.0072164093144237995, 0.013096165843307972, -0.031493838876485825, 0.0028743722941726446, -0.06286611407995224, 0.05632622539997101, 0.07658622413873672, 0.03850037604570389, 0.04914702847599983, 0.04412009194493294, 0.04216218739748001, -0.014486389234662056, -0.06122826784849167, -0.0001326615602010861, 0.022901203483343124, -0.0065358709543943405, 0.009605154395103455, -0.00010934936290141195, 0.031529467552900314, -0.007929009385406971, 0.04050060361623764, -0.012467875145375729, -0.03164985403418541, 0.07187100499868393, 0.0028445615898817778, -0.0481906421482563, -0.006109417416155338, 0.04355384781956673, 0.004172795917838812, 0.025786221027374268, 0.06449001282453537, -0.021879421547055244, -0.03697977960109711, -0.024326259270310402, 0.012263396754860878, -0.07272952049970627, 0.0032978684175759554, 0.022897735238075256, -0.019576916471123695, 0.03819821774959564, -0.024111997336149216, -0.06747615337371826, -0.05189558491110802, 0.03440117463469505, -0.016392139717936516, 0.010364354588091373, -0.06889878213405609, -0.006699236109852791, 0.001194506767205894, -0.028270652517676353, 0.010082435794174671, -0.06818576902151108, 0.00776376249268651, 0.028829358518123627, -0.03390137106180191, 0.011938953772187233, -0.012051130644977093, -0.017350440844893456, 0.023564482107758522, -0.052340056747198105, -0.012708703055977821, 0.03811945393681526, -0.029368869960308075, 0.05397210642695427, 0.051821038126945496, -0.0008389335125684738, -0.014494998380541801, 0.06185504421591759, 0.05904555320739746, 0.05237150937318802, 0.023623891174793243, -0.0018288081046193838, -0.03264107555150986, -0.06736072152853012, 0.00543840741738677, -0.011400549672544003, 0.0062220171093940735, 0.055510956794023514 ]
<p>Previously, on <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/86509/33806">Save us from swallowing baby universes, please!</a>, I pointed out the dangers associated with false vacuum decay.</p> <p>I wish to be more specific here. Suppose the Standard Model remains a good description of our universe even at higher energies. <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/31291/33806">The observed value of the Higgs mass predicts that our current phase is metastable.</a> If our phase decays in a bubble, its interior will have a different much higher value for the Higgs field. </p> <p>What happens to matter as it encounters the expanding bubble wall? Coleman-de Luccia assumed the exterior is initially in the vacuum state. They did not take the presence of matter into account. A changing value for the Higgs field is unlikely to affect the electromagnetic field much. But we expect the electromagnetic coupling strength to change inside the bubble due to a different running of the coupling constants under the renormalization group in the new phase. How much will this affect photons, and what is its frequency dependence? The leptonic and quark masses due to the Yukawa Higgs coupling will jump up dramatically in the new phase. Will this lead to a partial reflection and a partial transmission of leptons as the bubble passes through? What about confined bound states of quarks in hadrons? How will hadrons be affected? Leptons and quarks also happen to be dressed states, and the dressing will differ between the two phases. Might this cause a particle shower if these particles are transmitted? The masses of the W and Z bosons will also jump up. What will happen to them? Will neutrinos be unaffected? What if neutrino oscillations are also taken into account?</p> <p>This leads us to the ultimate question. Suppose we have some lump of matter, like a cyborg, which is a complicated bound state of leptons, hadrons and photons. What will happen to this cyborg as the bubble expands and hits it?</p>
g4009
[ 0.0004200062248855829, 0.04995063319802284, 0.012764118611812592, 0.01854568161070347, 0.008878195658326149, 0.08535301685333252, -0.02465585060417652, 0.021892400458455086, 0.021792110055685043, -0.0577547512948513, -0.07675613462924957, -0.0003230055153835565, 0.014516733586788177, 0.04713914915919304, 0.005802500993013382, 0.0019673435017466545, 0.02429344691336155, -0.046474162489175797, -0.021048879250884056, -0.011125665158033371, 0.002943923696875572, -0.027044430375099182, -0.047853194177150726, -0.04368678107857704, -0.09133630990982056, 0.010859672911465168, 0.08003603667020798, 0.021024443209171295, 0.005397320259362459, -0.003633031388744712, 0.06493610888719559, -0.012716967612504959, -0.02403840608894825, -0.048491448163986206, 0.010949883610010147, -0.09317395836114883, 0.023602791130542755, 0.013969387859106064, -0.052525561302900314, -0.006427830550819635, 0.01766834408044815, 0.0036648274399340153, 0.029224611818790436, -0.003577875206246972, 0.01950818859040737, 0.04512852430343628, -0.031392522156238556, -0.0413665771484375, 0.018203938379883766, -0.011261556297540665, 0.011665391735732555, 0.014103157445788383, -0.01773793064057827, 0.016930678859353065, 0.08000870794057846, 0.017710575833916664, 0.012554413639008999, -0.02049494907259941, 0.07668095827102661, -0.03499740734696388, 0.015903932973742485, -0.007730213925242424, 0.00474542984738946, -0.008294443599879742, 0.052171990275382996, -0.01038534939289093, -0.05835090950131416, 0.01156962476670742, -0.004986523184925318, 0.000861401844304055, 0.03427192196249962, 0.01554558239877224, -0.05308733507990837, -0.02449466660618782, -0.014934848062694073, 0.047093816101551056, -0.03207379952073097, -0.0355045311152935, -0.029631899669766426, -0.00638375012204051, -0.0797281414270401, 0.027277005836367607, -0.004337397404015064, 0.0483144149184227, 0.0187794528901577, -0.04463217034935951, -0.03775511309504509, -0.046054087579250336, -0.006393614690750837, -0.0324893593788147, 0.03276199474930763, -0.029895517975091934, 0.029895802959799767, -0.038315098732709885, 0.027150269597768784, -0.012016629800200462, 0.01542587485164404, 0.04438888654112816, 0.02974885143339634, -0.03606083616614342, 0.008918838575482368, -0.0346921868622303, 0.0007744343020021915, -0.026790067553520203, -0.08429740369319916, -0.01742042601108551, 0.07464610040187836, -0.0008823415264487267, -0.008163782767951488, 0.03311152383685112, -0.01641802303493023, -0.0454002320766449, -0.05507605895400047, -0.06423373520374298, -0.0423998162150383, 0.02311248704791069, 0.03823300823569298, 0.007345117162913084, 0.0339997261762619, 0.044472791254520416, 0.044336263090372086, 0.05129105597734451, -0.0046242401003837585, -0.043485525995492935, -0.02187933772802353, -0.037057098001241684, 0.031933266669511795, -0.006691123358905315, 0.014013739302754402, 0.009278220124542713, 0.023388409987092018, 0.005402821581810713, -0.058428917080163956, 0.04919295012950897, 0.02606557495892048, 0.011603208258748055, 0.08889305591583252, 0.02357598952949047, 0.03758716955780983, -0.09755957871675491, 0.016200430691242218, -0.011090571992099285, 0.017886875197291374, 0.06630225479602814, -0.0025086617097258568, -0.005942141637206078, 0.0526762418448925, 0.008458402007818222, -0.030362296849489212, 0.0060610221698880196, 0.034625981003046036, 0.05630064755678177, -0.016266128048300743, 0.0032292562536895275, 0.038896046578884125, 0.030129553750157356, 0.031710702925920486, 0.006393256597220898, 0.030587919056415558, -0.01030312106013298, 0.023548459634184837, -0.05699070170521736, 0.013622150756418705, -0.003373477142304182, -0.03903883323073387, 0.053952768445014954, -0.0031520703341811895, -0.031005345284938812, 0.002263122471049428, -0.035982415080070496, -0.04680940881371498, -0.002151231514289975, -0.018435003235936165, 0.08632764220237732, 0.025048641487956047, 0.029453447088599205, -0.015082336962223053, -0.013435534201562405, -0.01722429133951664, -0.007744973991066217, 0.022816186770796776, -0.061660975217819214, -0.008337484672665596, 0.004008948337286711, 0.007492289412766695, 0.03466937318444252, -0.028974192216992378, 0.031166093423962593, 0.0005536602693609893, -0.011492377147078514, -0.03365539759397507, -0.002229326870292425, -0.018065564334392548, 0.01323600485920906, 0.005154444836080074, -0.013149847276508808, 0.02997777797281742, -0.009832033887505531, -0.03259103745222092, -0.03124193474650383, -0.020937584340572357, 0.0524439662694931, -0.009294524788856506, -0.01676142029464245, 0.01776512712240219, 0.001162951230071485, 0.010173793882131577, 0.023638086393475533, 0.025319894775748253, -0.045885518193244934, 0.03352808207273483, -0.016734087839722633, 0.0015542745823040605, 0.008796527981758118, -0.007845798507332802, 0.0767044648528099, 0.013400780037045479, 0.020357687026262283, 0.04835020378232002, 0.04048142582178116, -0.012634063139557838, 0.009797962382435799, 0.046471092849969864, -0.02852768264710903, 0.028792312368750572, -0.013246688060462475, -0.014290330931544304, -0.0523139052093029, 0.015898941084742546, 0.0073026069439947605, -0.005174477118998766, 0.015676224604249, -0.029454197734594345, -0.0170740969479084, -0.023335538804531097, 0.057272668927907944, 0.01014976017177105, 0.038746029138565063, 0.03874821588397026, 0.017488280311226845, 0.06697995960712433, -0.0022216946817934513, -0.047018833458423615, -0.04652096703648567, 0.0453849732875824, -0.034507591277360916, 0.07183370739221573, -0.011713079176843166, -0.008874652907252312, 0.02569684199988842, 0.016834726557135582, 0.025294043123722076, 0.008746210485696793, -0.014724211767315865, -0.023347076028585434, -0.007741244044154882, 0.02488677017390728, 0.033084120601415634, -0.06722693145275116, -0.014519997872412205, 0.06325306743383408, -0.004036457743495703, -0.03862308710813522, 0.014833171851933002, -0.050720736384391785, 0.06470530480146408, 0.020930472761392593, 0.031829237937927246, -0.01264844462275505, -0.041807033121585846, 0.02364264987409115, 0.02998495288193226, -0.0361122190952301, 0.011449627578258514, 0.055646996945142746, -0.05325712263584137, 0.020644305273890495, -0.02747289091348648, 0.0680239126086235, -0.06239970400929451, -0.10324928909540176, -0.03374833986163139, -0.036848284304142, -0.025920502841472626, 0.04085931554436684, -0.07072131335735321, -0.034115493297576904, -0.0032574760261923075, -0.042539261281490326, 0.04053739830851555, 0.02436985820531845, -0.00026540798717178404, 0.026994455605745316, 0.07798983156681061, 0.014997558668255806, 0.08523385971784592, 0.0017523630522191525, 0.0455925352871418, -0.027558565139770508, -0.01704414188861847, -0.03608494997024536, 0.004978271666914225, -0.03591180220246315, -0.022159989923238754, -0.00015138166781980544, -0.0031787832267582417, -0.016357483342289925, -0.004693973809480667, 0.0389498695731163, -0.05659550055861473, -0.062415655702352524, 0.0916559174656868, -0.0003052567190025002, -0.052800726145505905, -0.03155670315027237, -0.0034699570387601852, 0.035954587161540985, 0.0377604216337204, -0.01628427952528, -0.015904106199741364, 0.019514204934239388, 0.029277117922902107, 0.06327181309461594, -0.014838668517768383, -0.03170707821846008, 0.008611153811216354, -0.027581803500652313, 0.027895314618945122, -0.053317591547966, 0.024806782603263855, 0.014033502899110317, -0.007772114593535662, -0.0038501995149999857, -0.01765720546245575, -0.022835910320281982, 0.030722424387931824, -0.0021944863256067038, 0.016079619526863098, 0.03625877946615219, 0.008188135921955109, 0.01067010685801506, -0.07100178301334381, -0.022426092997193336, 0.034376125782728195, 0.017121221870183945, 0.01863250695168972, 0.023370761424303055, -0.05183064565062523, 0.04241011291742325, -0.007836571894586086, 0.07470524311065674, 0.015124165453016758, 0.010449579916894436, -0.0312594398856163, -0.0023466015700250864, 0.014323977753520012, 0.016725748777389526, 0.002276988234370947, 0.04204120114445686, -0.02455058880150318, -0.013040315359830856, -0.07329550385475159, 0.05998331308364868, 0.03569968417286873, -0.04742545261979103, -0.001514976960606873, 0.017985288053750992, 0.018468065187335014, 0.0007786549394950271, -0.003924002405256033, 0.017480460926890373, -0.01896529085934162, -0.052097272127866745, 0.06132860854268074, -0.023936934769153595, 0.022983457893133163, 0.07891114056110382, -0.07291574031114578, 0.005174068734049797, 0.021872716024518013, 0.015451084822416306, 0.005365231540054083, 0.019749468192458153, -0.07182177901268005, -0.006160884164273739, -0.0008868385339155793, -0.03857873007655144, -0.02004593051970005, -0.038843847811222076, -0.029030000790953636, -0.0030915099196135998, 0.05021176487207413, 0.0007059650379233062, 0.027092749252915382, 0.07420990616083145, -0.053958501666784286, 0.02921147458255291, -0.012661147862672806, -0.026459790766239166, -0.05226951465010643, 0.013072317466139793, -0.020377447828650475, 0.05511303246021271, 0.017870616167783737, 0.03336768224835396, -0.036115262657403946, 0.04157288745045662, -0.05384073406457901, -0.013413275592029095, -0.058825429528951645, 0.04854724556207657, 0.010757677257061005, -0.044206149876117706, -0.06319928169250488, 0.04653041809797287, -0.07737614214420319, 0.06533046811819077, 0.009119296446442604, 0.040685877203941345, -0.03397190198302269, -0.04821386560797691, -0.01576150394976139, -0.05059013515710831, 0.020541395992040634, -0.014448011294007301, 0.018663819879293442, 0.02040492370724678, -0.023300280794501305, -0.06245533004403114, -0.02960306406021118, 0.04102637618780136, 0.031008725985884666, -0.041627056896686554, 0.027625443413853645, -0.02137094922363758, 0.0478837750852108, -0.07172897458076477, -0.006649923510849476, -0.0075643640011549, 0.05237128585577011, 0.09777311980724335, -0.013425828889012337, -0.0037801594007760286, -0.003469236195087433, -0.02002166025340557, 0.056954339146614075, -0.04949703440070152, 0.030896374955773354, 0.04905293136835098, 0.008017566986382008, -0.003902709810063243, 0.06223166361451149, 0.04133123904466629, -0.0158512182533741, 0.035437777638435364, -0.03773169964551926, 0.04754200577735901, 0.020950594916939735, 0.0055528488010168076, 0.0004232394276186824, -0.039929356426000595, 0.0671067014336586, 0.04530726373195648, 0.0012679712381213903, 0.0038692946545779705, -0.04794804006814957, -0.04599708318710327, -0.045328788459300995, 0.007255941163748503, 0.016354110091924667, -0.039314884692430496, 0.0059570008888840675, 0.038489896804094315, -0.01867787539958954, 0.02089436911046505, 0.03761483356356621, -0.08135735243558884, -0.01838587410748005, -0.005173596553504467, -0.033568594604730606, 0.0606280192732811, -0.024197589606046677, 0.001790279638953507, -0.005340280011296272, -0.035248175263404846, 0.022865185514092445, -0.08025265485048294, 0.030896732583642006, -0.051017992198467255, 0.019504915922880173, -0.004318711813539267, 0.06526022404432297, 0.043784432113170624, 0.042486611753702164, 0.014901801943778992, 0.026645682752132416, 0.003521332051604986, 0.01542843971401453, -0.02314785309135914, 0.014011898078024387, -0.024439873173832893, -0.009167115204036236, 0.0524345338344574, 0.01497773639857769, -0.043220970779657364, 0.07563159614801407, -0.029011398553848267, 0.007818713784217834, 0.011838497593998909, -0.05419301986694336, -0.04576226323843002, 0.01672172360122204, -0.0058074165135622025, 0.009024132043123245, -0.004885631147772074, -0.05604827404022217, -0.02244051732122898, 0.011003069579601288, -0.024732306599617004, -0.03281576558947563, -0.04033870995044708, 0.054444245994091034, 0.02519918978214264, 0.04652637988328934, 0.05195821821689606, 0.025766631588339806, 0.03175658732652664, 0.004450561478734016, -0.0019299250561743975, -0.027843482792377472, 0.04847504943609238, 0.014702477492392063, 0.015845291316509247, 0.017745288088917732, 0.0405375137925148, -0.009915081784129143, -0.0053841168992221355, -0.018243568018078804, 0.0408613458275795, 0.07186414301395416, -0.030837981030344963, 0.0018255059840157628, 0.003856322495266795, 0.05100337788462639, 0.018883971497416496, 0.009385536424815655, -0.04741736501455307, 0.059505537152290344, -0.0015442527364939451, 0.014066935516893864, -0.03633567690849304, -0.02444985695183277, 0.0013791316887363791, 0.0574483722448349, -0.006426318548619747, -0.004774563014507294, 0.06804417073726654, 0.00037091539707034826, -0.01684378646314144, -0.036485206335783005, -0.017826303839683533, 0.0045472560450434685, 0.01220884919166565, 0.022654060274362564, 0.009029830805957317, -0.027335776016116142, 0.025802910327911377, -0.06581524759531021, 0.03774845227599144, -0.016111616045236588, 0.035289160907268524, -0.0013828892260789871, -0.041672952473163605, -0.05389576032757759, -0.013823527842760086, -0.00030035266536287963, -0.05239691957831383, -0.020858682692050934, -0.01875261217355728, 0.030854901298880577, -0.012221748009324074, -0.045097772032022476, 0.042847104370594025, 0.029049105942249298, 0.013223209418356419, -0.012701856903731823, -0.014384745620191097, -0.011030487716197968, 0.07606716454029083, -0.015028795227408409, -0.005371374543756247, -0.02106797881424427, -0.012450214475393295, -0.011141999624669552, -0.009069648571312428, 0.05319995433092117, -0.04578101634979248, -0.08433409780263901, -0.025990527123212814, -0.006738534662872553, 0.022982969880104065, 0.03274274989962578, -0.026812301948666573, -0.024175653234124184, 0.009179165586829185, -0.04396254941821098, 0.00858913455158472, 0.05643557757139206, 0.033583737909793854, 0.034944381564855576, 0.012616625055670738, -0.016647636890411377, 0.026010029017925262, -0.052410613745450974, 0.008491196669638157, -0.053315624594688416, 0.10686612129211426, 0.018920181319117546, -0.02751447819173336, 0.03485763072967529, -0.03591710329055786, -0.009462929330766201, 0.03651053085923195, -0.0503806434571743, 0.002231846796348691, -0.028033295646309853, 0.011005237698554993, 0.0025413939729332924, 0.006695971824228764, 0.037198107689619064, 0.05432869866490364, -0.013517026789486408, 0.02218562923371792, 0.004596147686243057, -0.007566644810140133, 0.04080483317375183, -0.0523831732571125, 0.003471961012110114, -0.03523974120616913, -0.044763099402189255, 0.05395496264100075, -0.004980188794434071, 0.019417567178606987, -0.008319413289427757, -0.05197558179497719, 0.06655290722846985, 0.06269558519124985, -0.009665653109550476, -0.00006975117867114022, 0.02059909701347351, -0.004797300789505243, -0.027827665209770203, -0.04858404025435448, -0.027214672416448593, -0.046162575483322144, 0.012738817371428013, -0.04271681234240532, 0.012286292389035225, 0.010912842117249966, -0.04018852859735489, -0.02288219705224037, -0.01350931916385889, 0.03402659296989441, 0.021421140059828758, 0.02954902872443199, -0.02263345569372177, 0.05766507238149643, -0.045145634561777115, 0.013321593403816223, -0.002192917512729764, 0.0003288955776952207, -0.07051607221364975, -0.04489327594637871, -0.029410894960165024, 0.04833434522151947, -0.04234006628394127, -0.03951601684093475, -0.012709197588264942, 0.0251931045204401, 0.007020737510174513, 0.005857360083609819, 0.00860508717596531, 0.008571379818022251, 0.0014079310931265354, -0.039818618446588516, 0.04084625467658043, -0.019482510164380074, 0.025860795751214027, -0.07865612208843231, 0.01459861733019352, 0.048017796128988266, -0.02394929900765419, -0.01567900739610195, 0.011440538801252842, -0.03549162670969963, 0.006354336626827717, -0.027653764933347702, 0.037868041545152664, -0.03402184695005417, -0.009250887669622898, -0.043377526104450226, 0.005608099978417158, -0.04176127910614014, -0.05963463708758354, 0.03983509540557861, -0.000427649007178843, 0.023025615140795708, -0.046712640672922134, -0.0160022284835577, 0.015801580622792244, 0.026933638378977776, 0.02641425095498562, 0.042098794132471085, 0.015200271271169186, -0.0013633748749271035, -0.06985358148813248, -0.028263255953788757, 0.009002404287457466, 0.0823817253112793, 0.00874382071197033, -0.03231415897607803, -0.03286886587738991, -0.023038756102323532, 0.010695059783756733, 0.013284758664667606, -0.06332182884216309, 0.015098811127245426, 0.0697922483086586, -0.049315087497234344, -0.04725820571184158, -0.0608106330037117, 0.0014034018386155367, -0.011040178127586842, -0.05079945549368858, -0.044326841831207275, 0.06772580742835999, 0.030322277918457985, 0.0026364182122051716, 0.0066960882395505905, -0.057774439454078674, -0.019100932404398918, -0.03350714594125748, 0.018465593457221985, -0.014597547240555286, 0.03068864904344082, -0.00909325759857893, -0.029176322743296623, -0.01858493685722351, 0.007346594240516424, -0.02834518440067768, 0.0262299757450819, -0.08190297335386276, -0.04738539457321167, 0.04912085086107254, -0.015713943168520927, -0.06454827636480331, -0.048483412712812424, -0.043670956045389175, -0.01689564250409603, -0.03023083508014679, 0.01795242726802826, 0.030983123928308487, -0.010047631338238716, -0.011124364100396633, 0.0064736464992165565, -0.05363117903470993, 0.05319192260503769, 0.047960132360458374 ]
<p>How do you derive the solution to Poisson's equation with a point charge source? Without using Coulomb's law or the electric field! To be more explicit, we have a point charge at $(0,0)$ of charge $q$ and we want to solve Poisson's equation to find the potential. </p>
g4010
[ 0.05096915736794472, 0.011271271854639053, -0.008545850403606892, -0.040389012545347214, 0.0914614126086235, -0.0462167002260685, -0.061903730034828186, 0.03162182494997978, 0.0044585419818758965, 0.013483203016221523, -0.03863771632313728, -0.004805516451597214, -0.014962754212319851, -0.022305862978100777, -0.025917794555425644, -0.01026856154203415, 0.04324151948094368, 0.013113959692418575, -0.004769286140799522, 0.000267689028987661, 0.0018728869035840034, -0.029136845842003822, 0.05623644217848778, -0.030939070507884026, -0.04744141921401024, 0.0014886256540194154, -0.0548718124628067, 0.020973043516278267, -0.023876851424574852, -0.056278400123119354, -0.06771373003721237, 0.0033158876467496157, -0.04133874550461769, -0.0009935317793861032, -0.039464838802814484, -0.006744869984686375, 0.03694971278309822, -0.023700617253780365, -0.007682673167437315, -0.036715976893901825, -0.0024316953495144844, -0.0063871401362121105, 0.07171711325645447, 0.05173607915639877, -0.02087082900106907, -0.018354913219809532, -0.00197805417701602, 0.06869329512119293, -0.0627112090587616, 0.019129592925310135, -0.01488805003464222, 0.028849784284830093, -0.004284455440938473, -0.03823469579219818, 0.014944225549697876, 0.03356136754155159, 0.012094518169760704, -0.06611774861812592, 0.02971668355166912, 0.03324165567755699, 0.02348124235868454, 0.017364880070090294, 0.008751475252211094, 0.02065354585647583, 0.02202550880610943, -0.027025915682315826, -0.062067754566669464, 0.0019769470673054457, -0.027984648942947388, 0.038658104836940765, 0.01347776036709547, -0.03519133850932121, -0.05322377011179924, -0.06653720885515213, -0.03223166614770889, 0.008768320083618164, 0.014103188179433346, -0.0028762451838701963, 0.03435096889734268, -0.044100452214479446, 0.051202014088630676, -0.028013989329338074, 0.06481023132801056, -0.022977862507104874, 0.025456978008151054, -0.02013671211898327, 0.01999123953282833, 0.01414666511118412, 0.015192573890089989, 0.007915168069303036, -0.06129637360572815, 0.07130444794893265, 0.039586979895830154, -0.07670373469591141, -0.01917882449924946, -0.010983336716890335, 0.050254642963409424, 0.023460987955331802, -0.0030773209873586893, -0.005294854752719402, -0.05732094869017601, -0.029710974544286728, 0.02479882538318634, 0.03322799876332283, 0.0346011258661747, 0.021183298900723457, -0.041552603244781494, 0.04365534707903862, -0.01062195934355259, -0.010694458149373531, -0.006073326338082552, -0.04120470583438873, -0.049011893570423126, -0.02501354180276394, -0.0712662935256958, 0.015054365620017052, 0.026161791756749153, -0.01383939292281866, 0.010419623926281929, 0.0750126764178276, -0.08554991334676743, 0.008017354644834995, 0.019151272252202034, 0.0748128890991211, 0.005041333846747875, -0.007586750201880932, 0.008763054385781288, 0.019444674253463745, 0.05701521784067154, 0.023783639073371887, 0.00041847507236525416, -0.0019417270086705685, -0.011574724689126015, -0.007646857760846615, 0.0020473652984946966, 0.07687033712863922, -0.001223966246470809, -0.01701528951525688, 0.06904041022062302, 0.015849169343709946, -0.003854204900562763, -0.030614754185080528, -0.03635512292385101, -0.0005454064230434597, 0.003482656553387642, -0.020226947963237762, 0.018100526183843613, -0.03697047010064125, 0.0005370675935409963, 0.09301092475652695, -0.018985215574502945, 0.002975134178996086, -0.00669316528365016, 0.02347896620631218, 0.025328541174530983, 0.04051196947693825, 0.048868730664253235, -0.030675683170557022, -0.00815623253583908, 0.0011213525431230664, 0.007740148343145847, 0.0326322540640831, 0.006382533814758062, 0.030443329364061356, 0.023259807378053665, -0.046970900148153305, 0.032552748918533325, -0.042235590517520905, -0.07287498563528061, -0.02507709711790085, 0.014836365357041359, -0.0003382933500688523, 0.023326359689235687, -0.0068261390551924706, 0.049345359206199646, -0.007929183542728424, -0.019452998414635658, 0.01751825399696827, 0.05042462423443794, -0.002926809713244438, 0.011769704520702362, 0.010076764971017838, 0.05841214582324028, -0.03303186595439911, 0.01898299716413021, 0.021406469866633415, -0.025846542790532112, 0.09007177501916885, 0.0316116027534008, -0.005823461338877678, -0.021816382184624672, 0.00683582155033946, -0.07238174974918365, 0.023879945278167725, -0.04760434851050377, 0.037771135568618774, 0.02040235698223114, -0.05663399025797844, 0.04840288683772087, -0.028624942526221275, -0.022353792563080788, -0.0050570908933877945, -0.009462959133088589, 0.04612813889980316, 0.0708501860499382, -0.04089074581861496, -0.05441521853208542, -0.0816207155585289, -0.0023957230150699615, -0.03215878829360008, -0.04820779711008072, -0.042974743992090225, -0.010601706802845001, 0.07869602739810944, -0.046403516083955765, -0.04949371889233589, -0.028812551870942116, -0.02725067548453808, -0.05813736841082573, 0.044578127562999725, -0.1041293740272522, -0.023460976779460907, 0.02756410650908947, 0.04599538818001747, 0.013423915021121502, 0.06299203634262085, 0.06049319729208946, -0.012789985164999962, -0.042240746319293976, 0.015256478451192379, -0.021937686949968338, 0.029295295476913452, -0.009543471969664097, -0.02684319019317627, 0.018621167168021202, -0.05418869107961655, -0.07111555337905884, -0.0391400083899498, -0.03505229949951172, -0.01716448925435543, -0.0672168955206871, -0.0441068597137928, -0.014988219365477562, 0.05259411409497261, 0.009993431158363819, -0.007619915530085564, 0.05959261208772659, -0.0024235197342932224, 0.03927202522754669, -0.033701129257678986, 0.0554884597659111, -0.009497154504060745, 0.030947109684348106, -0.0013123310636729002, 0.002658203477039933, -0.011731842532753944, 0.006837441120296717, -0.021661506965756416, -0.04744230955839157, -0.07286495715379715, -0.017215510830283165, 0.03579600527882576, -0.034872960299253464, 0.024337850511074066, -0.005188378505408764, 0.04053212329745293, -0.03483616188168526, 0.007748751901090145, 0.04013858363032341, -0.031363461166620255, -0.009743791073560715, 0.05215327814221382, 0.013731674291193485, -0.031153487041592598, -0.002058600541204214, -0.04672252759337425, 0.03756137937307358, 0.02173839695751667, 0.07155142724514008, -0.017349544912576675, 0.0068048639222979546, -0.0003242765960749239, -0.02080404944717884, 0.04855935648083687, 0.008211065083742142, -0.026643872261047363, 0.029873378574848175, 0.01132278610020876, 0.022466134279966354, -0.0571950264275074, -0.004305121023207903, 0.010232226923108101, 0.0003483739565126598, -0.049839574843645096, 0.017197314649820328, 0.03466448560357094, -0.018433712422847748, -0.0365498922765255, -0.01076381653547287, 0.006028577219694853, 0.053646840155124664, -0.03257150202989578, 0.002972780726850033, -0.009057649411261082, 0.0685417577624321, 0.03755221143364906, 0.009657464921474457, -0.006647437810897827, 0.021392859518527985, 0.0018465218599885702, 0.025446416810154915, 0.029269421473145485, 0.008123057894408703, 0.044210392981767654, 0.014883291907608509, 0.018617598339915276, -0.012461535632610321, -0.0371500626206398, -0.005935767199844122, -0.08098107576370239, -0.008145216852426529, -0.03376751393079758, 0.025321630761027336, -0.039182644337415695, 0.05162075161933899, 0.04672000929713249, -0.0073278117924928665, 0.05932451784610748, -0.014338900335133076, -0.03202183544635773, -0.024003392085433006, -0.022457031533122063, 0.08684131503105164, -0.01562162023037672, 0.01918352022767067, -0.06173928081989288, 0.00973595678806305, 0.025090983137488365, 0.02694694697856903, -0.06514597684144974, 0.017295541241765022, -0.036907728761434555, -0.08992336690425873, -0.045159388333559036, -0.09020525217056274, -0.04662125185132027, 0.02557385340332985, 0.00031294330256059766, 0.0292107705026865, -0.036229319870471954, 0.015496743842959404, 0.007014057599008083, -0.03161752596497536, 0.05325710028409958, -0.013728552497923374, -0.020858217030763626, -0.039943721145391464, 0.019982721656560898, -0.05158678814768791, 0.052351489663124084, 0.022441674023866653, -0.04954609274864197, 0.04723167419433594, -0.008651616983115673, 0.0671176090836525, -0.05074992775917053, -0.006550452206283808, -0.0066602579317986965, -0.01996382512152195, -0.0396001860499382, 0.00024747606948949397, -0.013253790326416492, 0.03460652381181717, -0.06464183330535889, -0.004993502516299486, -0.01896975375711918, -0.0362342931330204, 0.0034931241534650326, -0.014699053019285202, -0.031915925443172455, -0.036730993539094925, 0.009208137169480324, 0.005730913486331701, 0.024480516090989113, 0.009282696060836315, 0.019641607999801636, -0.05739400535821915, -0.00649289321154356, 0.04642217233777046, -0.02677106484770775, 0.050316326320171356, -0.033660247921943665, 0.03347276896238327, 0.008242695592343807, -0.004311265889555216, -0.016408268362283707, -0.02737118862569332, -0.0549539215862751, -0.021744320169091225, 0.043062180280685425, 0.05274726077914238, -0.01690201461315155, 0.0553034283220768, 0.009959470480680466, 0.025376547127962112, 0.020090455189347267, 0.070100337266922, -0.03416890650987625, 0.027955686673521996, -0.024909576401114464, -0.039576753973960876, -0.026465047150850296, 0.012446635402739048, 0.03358348831534386, -0.018711689859628677, -0.037516143172979355, 0.030977685004472733, 0.037851206958293915, 0.04625651240348816, 0.020488761365413666, 0.0017207171767950058, -0.04364028200507164, 0.02050216682255268, -0.014544535428285599, -0.025215646252036095, 0.0002869128074962646, 0.04868151620030403, 0.007474198471754789, -0.0065987249836325645, 0.04005567729473114, 0.004423144739121199, 0.0576021745800972, 0.0013938817428424954, 0.024768931791186333, -0.05837424099445343, 0.03553109988570213, -0.014654564671218395, 0.01802752912044525, 0.0001841392513597384, -0.0507948137819767, 0.044349174946546555, 0.005160417407751083, 0.032870568335056305, 0.009254537522792816, -0.0256143007427454, 0.023406527936458588, -0.013968373648822308, 0.0031632562167942524, 0.027554558590054512, 0.009489959105849266, 0.00452268635854125, -0.011225936003029346, -0.021695183590054512, -0.03792639449238777, -0.022771434858441353, 0.018876241520047188, 0.0016038048779591918, -0.030394792556762695, -0.015306095592677593, 0.051980238407850266, -0.005343475379049778, -0.053316328674554825, 0.018550483509898186, -0.03535418584942818, 0.06244427338242531, -0.033308666199445724, -0.06212104484438896, -0.046256761997938156, 0.008653054013848305, -0.004349233582615852, -0.04089157655835152, 0.03086150996387005, 0.04173838347196579, -0.017222950235009193, 0.02155967801809311, -0.016580743715167046, 0.006321351509541273, -0.009821783751249313, -0.051816150546073914, -0.03085765428841114, 0.023253321647644043, -0.000567182432860136, -0.011739824898540974, -0.036621276289224625, 0.0009021377773024142, 0.02358074299991131, -0.01150964479893446, 0.04045262560248375, -0.028043625876307487, -0.04511352255940437, 0.006990185473114252, 0.03218328207731247, 0.03338828682899475, 0.05306848883628845, 0.0022191829048097134, 0.016336530447006226, 0.012282448820769787, 0.03976985812187195, 0.013773093931376934, 0.06967279314994812, 0.00043539938633330166, -0.05018632858991623, -0.028560837730765343, 0.04540063813328743, -0.01811741665005684, 0.043154988437891006, 0.054738957434892654, 0.02254188247025013, 0.043041814118623734, 0.00671429093927145, 0.04237440600991249, 0.01683679036796093, 0.024809380993247032, -0.018539687618613243, 0.03403753042221069, 0.01944500394165516, -0.09118253737688065, -0.012486540712416172, -0.035211231559515, 0.06164339557290077, 0.03675712272524834, 0.013316348195075989, -0.027016431093215942, 0.018315352499485016, 0.03418885916471481, -0.029679108411073685, -0.044001102447509766, -0.02572680078446865, -0.012205137871205807, -0.02477101981639862, -0.009384561330080032, -0.000694991322234273, 0.006150620058178902, -0.012034394778311253, 0.0008753141737543046, -0.029976559802889824, -0.04477914050221443, -0.03731337562203407, 0.007500461768358946, 0.030248165130615234, -0.02183498814702034, -0.009258003905415535, 0.050561778247356415, -0.029673822224140167, 0.01209352072328329, -0.011165391653776169, -0.03562919422984123, 0.024314964190125465, 0.00644594244658947, -0.07255803793668747, -0.021186452358961105, 0.06011797860264778, 0.003014460438862443, -0.0034342689905315638, -0.02852211520075798, 0.005583483725786209, -0.026344498619437218, 0.03841258957982063, -0.07291273772716522, -0.01069535780698061, 0.02729828655719757, -0.04907473549246788, 0.0063606067560613155, 0.07833325862884521, 0.023099437355995178, 0.000749343482311815, 0.011057182215154171, -0.01251471508294344, 0.023215757682919502, -0.008975110948085785, -0.018897125497460365, 0.003430362790822983, -0.042333878576755524, -0.048137784004211426, 0.007962357252836227, -0.0012876444961875677, -0.009951681829988956, -0.023118458688259125, -0.047943394631147385, 0.05879734084010124, -0.028118107467889786, 0.07887788861989975, 0.045538999140262604, 0.01976175419986248, -0.035147882997989655, 0.05167972296476364, 0.023684144020080566, -0.030073119327425957, 0.07149195671081543, 0.036394573748111725, 0.08018888533115387, 0.020744143053889275, -0.012281583622097969, -0.020678851753473282, -0.03179185837507248, -0.012201795354485512, 0.02384178340435028, -0.02527534030377865, -0.047612737864255905, 0.039111144840717316, 0.004811998922377825, 0.02524496428668499, -0.041649360209703445, 0.016182538121938705, 0.07654445618391037, -0.057690322399139404, 0.007064062170684338, -0.004662626888602972, 0.005220232997089624, -0.040329985320568085, -0.016143616288900375, 0.023661643266677856, -0.007018181961029768, -0.04781777411699295, 0.06555420905351639, 0.06969868391752243, 0.0020564752630889416, 0.023340485990047455, -0.04153573140501976, -0.004775723442435265, 0.030988261103630066, -0.013620654121041298, -0.012654639780521393, 0.018589364364743233, 0.07283581048250198, 0.021521013230085373, 0.005007467232644558, 0.01873072236776352, 0.0769091472029686, -0.02619837038218975, -0.011626433581113815, 0.007100732531398535, -0.0337064154446125, 0.046691082417964935, -0.06411261856555939, 0.00898318737745285, 0.10901127010583878, 0.01588299870491028, 0.08489605039358139, 0.04061075299978256, -0.051552023738622665, 0.027564270421862602, 0.04325161129236221, -0.004928602371364832, -0.08053294569253922, -0.050445202738046646, -0.015787750482559204, 0.0640193447470665, -0.0635162815451622, 0.00011495828221086413, 0.03383197635412216, -0.016802465543150902, 0.026914291083812714, 0.006270008161664009, -0.01735442690551281, 0.047496385872364044, 0.021008651703596115, 0.020959263667464256, 0.006224129814654589, -0.02694697678089142, -0.042011141777038574, 0.022968625649809837, -0.02980961464345455, -0.012225301004946232, -0.003201040904968977, -0.006987989414483309, 0.009610334411263466, -0.0732496902346611, -0.00782995019108057, 0.0074620721861720085, -0.004901356995105743, -0.025996185839176178, -0.022880328819155693, 0.020336393266916275, 0.009644405916333199, -0.015237679705023766, -0.00866694375872612, 0.0912650004029274, 0.006082986947149038, -0.027180617675185204, 0.007338228169828653, -0.011706778779625893, -0.06749921292066574, -0.05317064747214317, 0.012936270795762539, 0.005722713656723499, -0.017762182280421257, 0.03470107913017273, 0.017742183059453964, 0.06337228417396545, -0.011019017547369003, -0.03710366412997246, 0.012932421639561653, -0.02826128527522087, 0.0035656073596328497, 0.009004075080156326, 0.03427542373538017, -0.01657886430621147, 0.04276331886649132, -0.009203032590448856, 0.019161362200975418, -0.0789673924446106, 0.044818244874477386, -0.023109398782253265, -0.04776546731591225, -0.06085079535841942, 0.004735215101391077, -0.01572391204535961, -0.02560996077954769, 0.018482215702533722, -0.006552833132445812, -0.032870274037122726, -0.030150901526212692, 0.029769133776426315, 0.06464570760726929, 0.0033372780308127403, -0.02862182818353176, 0.07517367601394653, 0.022318577393889427, 0.000021257312255329452, -0.06171676144003868, 0.004063874948769808, -0.00783948041498661, -0.008919390849769115, 0.04538765177130699, 0.034405749291181564, -0.02351565659046173, 0.024707883596420288, -0.03883952274918556, -0.03194192424416542, 0.002509693382307887, -0.010277711786329746, 0.015844546258449554, 0.005750671960413456, 0.015441573224961758, -0.049986470490694046, -0.004743276629596949, -0.030025800690054893, -0.009099074639379978, -0.05996827036142349, 0.05073646456003189, -0.006157321855425835, -0.0018929943908005953, -0.06763540208339691, 0.05217479169368744, -0.043974846601486206, -0.020472275093197823, 0.023794088512659073, 0.09858688712120056, -0.0014656923012807965, 0.033434752374887466, -0.01113009825348854, -0.043363578617572784, 0.03167739883065224, 0.014559915289282799, -0.07950519770383835, 0.011295036412775517, 0.014260532334446907, -0.0021470815408974886, 0.02388603799045086, 0.02685326524078846, -0.03324411064386368, 0.050606146454811096, 0.07375746965408325, 0.006697715260088444, -0.046089813113212585, 0.006662874016910791, 0.004864821210503578 ]
<p>I'm familiar with gravitational lensing but still I'm wondering if there is experiments (conducted here on Earth) which show that light bends due to gravity. For example mirrors setup to hold the light or something like that.</p> <p>My question is inspired by this <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/121514/slowing-of-time-under-gravity">bounty question</a>.</p>
g4011
[ 0.030830975621938705, 0.05546681582927704, 0.013004080392420292, -0.01459985226392746, 0.04646207392215729, 0.03906811773777008, -0.0025524639058858156, -0.021675730124115944, -0.014052823185920715, -0.020607290789484978, 0.07931458950042725, 0.010428821668028831, 0.02913425676524639, 0.05284691974520683, -0.030832184478640556, 0.007883280515670776, 0.08282183110713959, -0.023173678666353226, 0.02297324687242508, 0.03163629025220871, 0.02323027141392231, -0.00677365530282259, -0.03481274098157883, -0.011376988142728806, -0.061427947133779526, 0.047004375606775284, 0.00767415901646018, -0.0003653296735137701, 0.004239196423441172, -0.016371464356780052, -0.029384324327111244, -0.09639772772789001, 0.012357504107058048, -0.05509418621659279, -0.018173081800341606, -0.06078910082578659, 0.03252346068620682, 0.007988879457116127, 0.048130497336387634, 0.020243100821971893, -0.02181817777454853, -0.001923061441630125, -0.01980278454720974, 0.0232357457280159, 0.0756138414144516, 0.02932131476700306, 0.018623540177941322, 0.02420511282980442, 0.02772435173392296, -0.04020273685455322, -0.02528904564678669, 0.03125870227813721, 0.008703961968421936, -0.016162317246198654, 0.03993683680891991, -0.02543911151587963, -0.01880919560790062, 0.003265095641836524, 0.11052238941192627, -0.00284947850741446, 0.0018345409771427512, -0.0005875617498531938, 0.052204787731170654, 0.03278001770377159, 0.011478123255074024, -0.008403276093304157, -0.03292367234826088, -0.04366897791624069, 0.0959283709526062, -0.0015684665413573384, 0.010126126930117607, 0.03412888944149017, -0.03786701336503029, -0.0446133017539978, -0.005218645092099905, 0.003144125686958432, 0.016324616968631744, 0.04907285049557686, -0.030292125418782234, 0.00398649275302887, -0.0016729985363781452, -0.006972061935812235, -0.06647328287363052, 0.03681517764925957, 0.03021470457315445, 0.0021129311062395573, 0.02447686716914177, 0.00514405220746994, -0.011449265293776989, 0.02136124297976494, 0.04454820230603218, -0.02989407442510128, 0.03526080399751663, 0.016667090356349945, -0.03806127980351448, 0.040103886276483536, 0.024074194952845573, 0.07446258515119553, -0.04421627148985863, 0.01703805662691593, -0.05897446349263191, 0.002333638956770301, -0.030817674472928047, 0.055542171001434326, 0.022014547139406204, -0.032617297023534775, 0.0002253519487567246, 0.01929406449198723, -0.0028143483214080334, -0.04524577036499977, -0.03575529530644417, -0.03400706872344017, -0.006667756475508213, -0.02520979754626751, -0.04738789424300194, -0.06465771794319153, 0.041844241321086884, 0.04898855835199356, 0.008793632499873638, 0.041244398802518845, 0.026808172464370728, 0.03522169217467308, -0.034620411694049835, 0.047423627227544785, -0.020297354087233543, 0.03858296945691109, 0.039896368980407715, -0.010492532514035702, 0.009595988318324089, 0.016086198389530182, -0.0010701108258217573, 0.010662712156772614, -0.011772808618843555, -0.017536845058202744, -0.0016676060622557998, 0.02901030331850052, 0.001136504695750773, -0.06447794288396835, -0.016212008893489838, -0.0032197933178395033, 0.02033066377043724, -0.06440892815589905, 0.057657305151224136, 0.0028717925306409597, -0.01612675189971924, 0.021036554127931595, -0.009748748503625393, 0.058239489793777466, 0.06074845418334007, 0.033697161823511124, -0.03727341070771217, 0.07189682871103287, 0.021452639251947403, -0.09506282210350037, 0.03392453491687775, 0.01625187322497368, 0.0001392200792906806, -0.06177997961640358, 0.018638944253325462, 0.04794427752494812, 0.04896591976284981, -0.017975740134716034, -0.03813235089182854, 0.0028804116882383823, -0.09140564501285553, 0.022804591804742813, -0.011990481056272984, 0.024760564789175987, 0.008221260271966457, -0.06648535281419754, -0.10458660870790482, -0.024072861298918724, 0.045074447989463806, 0.06310005486011505, 0.03107479400932789, 0.05644237995147705, 0.011039713397622108, -0.000920560909435153, 0.002488218480721116, 0.01743737980723381, 0.018182668834924698, -0.07038239389657974, -0.06457532197237015, -0.06177433952689171, 0.023826096206903458, -0.011640142649412155, -0.006583685986697674, -0.06313888728618622, -0.021982356905937195, -0.019735263660550117, -0.009036581963300705, -0.037626978009939194, 0.016454774886369705, -0.013129974715411663, 0.01525814738124609, -0.09109940379858017, 0.04672076925635338, -0.03597971796989441, -0.01610087789595127, 0.03592154383659363, -0.05800115317106247, 0.007896311581134796, 0.02518399991095066, -0.0031867539510130882, 0.011562437750399113, 0.012955640442669392, -0.024182766675949097, -0.04522775113582611, 0.031867776066064835, -0.008462189696729183, 0.06955812126398087, 0.013630453497171402, 0.0815487802028656, -0.05256543681025505, -0.05495501682162285, 0.07503930479288101, -0.01512062456458807, 0.04667182266712189, 0.0371834933757782, 0.020777827128767967, -0.028064627200365067, 0.04924304410815239, -0.018643276765942574, -0.01148370560258627, 0.047621630132198334, -0.052725650370121, -0.022189730778336525, 0.017615558579564095, 0.06303643435239792, -0.018133843317627907, -0.07148720324039459, 0.032501060515642166, -0.028236566111445427, -0.018829477950930595, 0.05630293861031532, 0.03599737584590912, -0.035637449473142624, 0.016145028173923492, 0.015952490270137787, -0.0007015491719357669, -0.0017008270369842649, -0.03414304926991463, -0.024488499388098717, -0.05991582199931145, 0.01591460406780243, -0.0031822763849049807, 0.03147679194808006, 0.02001793123781681, 0.010150302201509476, -0.031305015087127686, 0.03127684444189072, 0.0161305982619524, 0.0040883454494178295, 0.012060216628015041, -0.039498522877693176, -0.0029906025156378746, -0.04700690135359764, 0.07001403719186783, -0.06490723043680191, -0.003291019704192877, 0.0006063461769372225, -0.011924544349312782, 0.015526937320828438, -0.043491166085004807, -0.023419959470629692, -0.05183259770274162, 0.00834424514323473, -0.05287545174360275, 0.03854041174054146, 0.08388501405715942, -0.0379653200507164, 0.03266282007098198, 0.0011581153376027942, 0.015051553957164288, 0.013790967874228954, 0.020445290952920914, -0.04464520514011383, -0.03674481064081192, -0.004542050417512655, -0.04693307355046272, -0.020096350461244583, -0.03810689225792885, -0.060698188841342926, 0.005841095000505447, 0.009130366146564484, -0.024423543363809586, -0.056158289313316345, 0.009047796949744225, -0.00957692414522171, 0.03661385178565979, -0.03607800975441933, -0.0021564208436757326, 0.05890804901719093, -0.011765674687922001, -0.00908701866865158, 0.04014544188976288, 0.0424983873963356, 0.012493950314819813, -0.01540091261267662, -0.000025430254027014598, 0.0020393854938447475, -0.03200605884194374, 0.018646346405148506, 0.04865074157714844, 0.011938300915062428, 0.010469261556863785, -0.022194217890501022, -0.0374758318066597, 0.05429359897971153, -0.01824094168841839, -0.011814604513347149, 0.005028242245316505, -0.015370058827102184, 0.08895692229270935, -0.045528292655944824, -0.0772474929690361, -0.04183083772659302, 0.007952467538416386, -0.008028361946344376, -0.05297739803791046, 0.032441336661577225, -0.02015428990125656, -0.04614250361919403, -0.020370524376630783, 0.009249960072338581, 0.018195491284132004, 0.002332870149984956, -0.031002681702375412, 0.0074070957489311695, 0.033782877027988434, 0.046414583921432495, -0.05177582427859306, -0.03874429687857628, -0.03591621667146683, 0.018301358446478844, 0.03172021731734276, -0.030974188819527626, 0.02271421067416668, 0.06785055994987488, 0.032370805740356445, -0.014036531560122967, 0.006184337195008993, -0.05799827724695206, 0.010188953019678593, 0.025732209905982018, -0.014609355479478836, -0.02549046277999878, -0.02992440201342106, -0.001563283265568316, -0.015894567593932152, 0.03991473838686943, 0.0026350561529397964, -0.010887203738093376, -0.07703796774148941, 0.011342925950884819, -0.0008441112004220486, -0.0025908644311130047, 0.020298827439546585, 0.01455837395042181, -0.05146997049450874, 0.03163202852010727, 0.015107979997992516, 0.004573628772050142, -0.023906564339995384, -0.0036985669285058975, 0.0126391826197505, 0.0140639403834939, 0.0023910158779472113, 0.014892724342644215, 0.010410919785499573, 0.0033989385701715946, 0.026069380342960358, -0.023998158052563667, 0.04200516268610954, 0.023280607536435127, -0.013327258639037609, 0.05035712942481041, 0.013095781207084656, 0.0022712009958922863, 0.02051595039665699, 0.04667249694466591, 0.043520841747522354, 0.03537524864077568, 0.01397791225463152, -0.019323628395795822, -0.01958487555384636, -0.04230809211730957, -0.060878634452819824, 0.026129478588700294, -0.01733553409576416, 0.013228604570031166, -0.029168445616960526, -0.01607166975736618, -0.027396002784371376, -0.015501431189477444, 0.00914689339697361, 0.025810344144701958, 0.0013837084406986833, 0.017540624365210533, -0.07248297333717346, 0.0567316971719265, 0.05878353491425514, 0.021483086049556732, 0.036303382366895676, -0.019256457686424255, -0.04054304212331772, 0.033896319568157196, 0.009559597820043564, -0.055976323783397675, 0.017864519730210304, 0.015248356387019157, -0.032521702349185944, -0.04991982877254486, -0.06772314012050629, 0.0605354942381382, -0.0026192120276391506, 0.015683455392718315, -0.0032989131286740303, 0.06420774012804031, -0.028984434902668, 0.007984740659594536, 0.07647812366485596, -0.018877428025007248, -0.010588165372610092, -0.03127571940422058, 0.04391107335686684, 0.0018052883679047227, -0.008817058987915516, 0.011343827471137047, -0.0065879980102181435, 0.03475797176361084, 0.01996331475675106, -0.02535047009587288, -0.045726727694272995, -0.009331492707133293, 0.040832724422216415, 0.009338193573057652, 0.0007607024745084345, -0.0012294573243707418, 0.022381506860256195, 0.04127306118607521, -0.0006465130718424916, 0.040369223803281784, -0.02847164124250412, -0.0328855887055397, 0.06777556985616684, -0.03270735219120979, -0.017189597710967064, 0.021573815494775772, -0.020247744396328926, -0.04553244262933731, 0.003824410494416952, -0.02584400586783886, 0.009892341680824757, -0.026755915954709053, -0.03983912616968155, 0.008710725232958794, 0.031859755516052246, -0.005147077608853579, 0.02480608969926834, 0.0005049490719102323, -0.019791902974247932, 0.058093663305044174, -0.005693123210221529, -0.004614400211721659, -0.02916567027568817, -0.03209126368165016, -0.05779910832643509, -0.0167166106402874, -0.0026625003665685654, -0.0800517126917839, 0.023071274161338806, 0.006051318719983101, 0.050620611757040024, 0.00662362203001976, -0.021588891744613647, -0.05744212493300438, 0.00043993230792693794, 0.013642116449773312, -0.034645240753889084, -0.02100660838186741, 0.03601266071200371, 0.00328638544306159, -0.06656558066606522, -0.008313242346048355, 0.01570875756442547, -0.06451559066772461, 0.05039261281490326, 0.023048067465424538, -0.06924421340227127, -0.0006661093211732805, -0.0725700706243515, -0.034972064197063446, -0.06552066653966904, -0.020730677992105484, 0.0019673455972224474, -0.023279665037989616, 0.019314298406243324, 0.024091115221381187, -0.0030077628325670958, 0.022906087338924408, 0.009658670984208584, 0.020879870280623436, -0.04411977902054787, 0.01883690245449543, 0.04819563403725624, -0.02588389813899994, -0.01343473419547081, -0.018112068995833397, 0.07146403938531876, -0.027764560654759407, 0.0189549308270216, -0.00555392075330019, 0.034231968224048615, 0.050272006541490555, -0.04392700642347336, -0.01532315369695425, 0.06093557924032211, 0.011409853585064411, -0.04992213100194931, -0.036512624472379684, -0.032408758997917175, 0.012398481369018555, 0.04922400787472725, 0.09110426902770996, 0.02191372774541378, -0.024192262440919876, 0.026184329763054848, 0.024917086586356163, -0.04788069427013397, 0.04704374074935913, -0.011728770099580288, 0.07445138692855835, -0.003510497510433197, 0.025376424193382263, -0.014097200706601143, 0.03182316944003105, 0.02980809472501278, 0.010798487812280655, -0.004600202199071646, -0.05390215292572975, -0.026552559807896614, 0.048347074538469315, 0.037393681704998016, 0.01949251815676689, -0.028027217835187912, -0.012453360483050346, 0.010529412887990475, 0.05993122234940529, -0.024837547913193703, -0.004237930290400982, 0.026735318824648857, -0.016517480835318565, 0.03190670534968376, -0.027269400656223297, 0.021873414516448975, -0.04912634193897247, -0.10696607083082199, -0.000389600929338485, -0.019589144736528397, 0.05082738399505615, 0.03923175483942032, 0.02177886851131916, -0.05020272359251976, -0.000058591653214534745, -0.04455197975039482, -0.006887448485940695, -0.009688927792012691, 0.07371260225772858, 0.021392658352851868, -0.006836819928139448, -0.02697927877306938, -0.04854920133948326, 0.008050589822232723, -0.02104421705007553, -0.011409219354391098, -0.04863102734088898, -0.015170251950621605, -0.06956801563501358, -0.025081494823098183, 0.02465221844613552, -0.026151075959205627, 0.03629818558692932, -0.05312855541706085, -0.0494694747030735, 0.039660658687353134, -0.01723935641348362, 0.032170750200748444, 0.051843784749507904, -0.05203947052359581, -0.07643258571624756, -0.014274626038968563, -0.023289738222956657, -0.018529389053583145, -0.024532491341233253, 0.004610651172697544, -0.01458789687603712, 0.05896386131644249, -0.0330502912402153, 0.009762371890246868, -0.029704604297876358, 0.03517501801252365, 0.043660808354616165, 0.009087050333619118, 0.03347979858517647, -0.026196174323558807, -0.02309398166835308, 0.03813065215945244, 0.12707147002220154, 0.036330051720142365, 0.019818689674139023, 0.0240757055580616, 0.022988736629486084, 0.014831247739493847, -0.05000322684645653, -0.017390089109539986, 0.011163879185914993, -0.0408184751868248, -0.01005737204104662, -0.020693572238087654, 0.01760537549853325, -0.0841362327337265, -0.0038101535756140947, -0.00046777710667811334, -0.024230048060417175, 0.03567197173833847, -0.026944084092974663, -0.034530844539403915, 0.012744979932904243, 0.013991760089993477, -0.017041897401213646, -0.0031342594884335995, -0.015180070884525776, -0.017718585208058357, 0.05129936337471008, 0.023563550785183907, -0.005067774560302496, 0.025985561311244965, 0.0421605110168457, 0.04409767687320709, 0.042194344103336334, -0.0236778873950243, 0.014111903496086597, 0.011410374194383621, -0.05029556527733803, 0.055696405470371246, -0.033778462558984756, -0.016999559476971626, -0.018597804009914398, -0.0661812573671341, 0.008907304145395756, -0.0448308102786541, -0.019037635996937752, -0.0067532784305512905, -0.0236648079007864, 0.03895770013332367, -0.028187690302729607, 0.029659243300557137, -0.00712025910615921, -0.0779448002576828, 0.006279430817812681, 0.02007313445210457, 0.004318676423281431, 0.02829907275736332, 0.025758495554327965, -0.007703804410994053, -0.032592594623565674, -0.057948432862758636, -0.002778727561235428, 0.056840844452381134, 0.019729135558009148, 0.00012216840696055442, 0.03515016287565231, 0.019526595249772072, 0.0394352562725544, 0.01319508720189333, -0.03452564403414726, 0.027970459312200546, -0.006578940432518721, 0.033638808876276016, 0.006744478363543749, 0.08006442338228226, 0.02430451102554798, 0.026400446891784668, -0.05871588736772537, 0.035860560834407806, -0.007082813419401646, 0.02310330606997013, -0.025484221056103706, -0.06535360962152481, 0.0046910750679671764, 0.08977948129177094, -0.05061887204647064, -0.023387594148516655, -0.014184335246682167, -0.03069416992366314, -0.00408528046682477, 0.013477827422320843, -0.007313874084502459, -0.026036059483885765, -0.06455353647470474, -0.02347431518137455, 0.01363991480320692, -0.04980903118848801, 0.04727273806929588, -0.010665783658623695, -0.07952561974525452, -0.03034820221364498, -0.01134684681892395, 0.031747326254844666, 0.038121748715639114, 0.02519502490758896, 0.008225210011005402, 0.017633814364671707, 0.0679197832942009, -0.02139180153608322, -0.018274877220392227, 0.015451083891093731, 0.008463677950203419, 0.02345493994653225, -0.05197371169924736, -0.03188508376479149, 0.025690028443932533, -0.06122209131717682, -0.019699547439813614, -0.0039051452185958624, 0.021466964855790138, -0.07447909563779831, -0.017689935863018036, -0.008521199226379395, 0.03370645269751549, 0.02573028765618801, -0.015445544384419918, -0.05099042132496834, -0.0048407576978206635, 0.042864955961704254, -0.003777566133067012, -0.07118301838636398, -0.033041879534721375, 0.019664069637656212, 0.008974168449640274, -0.01665022410452366, -0.03932736814022064, -0.03542136400938034, 0.07464843988418579, 0.020956413820385933, 0.024150118231773376, 0.04269496724009514, 0.03770293667912483, -0.016422603279352188, 0.04902459308505058, 0.05089215934276581, -0.004585863556712866, 0.03602905943989754, 0.004692124202847481, 0.00992617942392826, -0.05604902654886246, -0.010949689894914627, -0.007921731099486351, -0.016315240412950516, -0.043108049780130386, -0.017731616273522377, 0.0415017306804657, -0.010639053769409657, 0.019570374861359596, -0.04918517917394638, 0.02369045466184616, 0.002946450375020504 ]
<p>Is it true that a Mach-Zehnder interferometer with two polarizing beam splitters (PBS) is nothing but a bit flip for the polarisation degree of freedom?</p> <p>Say the PBSs reflect vertical polarized light and transmit horizontal polarized light. If we send in a state like $|+\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt 2}(|H\rangle+|V\rangle)$ the horizontal part gets reflected only once (by the mirror in the interferometer) but the vertical part gets reflected three times (first PBS, mirror, second PBS). At the end we have a relative Phase of $i^2=-1$ between $|H\rangle$ and $|V\rangle$ which means that we end up with the state $|-\rangle = \frac{1}{\sqrt 2}(|H\rangle-|V\rangle)$.</p> <p>Thus it is a bit flip of the polarisation. Right?</p>
g4012
[ -0.027568019926548004, -0.011974869295954704, -0.00788498017936945, -0.010285469703376293, 0.03511291742324829, 0.007771999575197697, 0.007515478413552046, 0.05000251531600952, 0.028815515339374542, 0.0012659152271226048, -0.018964556977152824, 0.03933453932404518, -0.0673493966460228, -0.0434698686003685, 0.0439181812107563, -0.007177046965807676, 0.03484245762228966, 0.04062856733798981, 0.009078639559447765, 0.02674747444689274, -0.04867986962199211, -0.006466057617217302, -0.0575750470161438, -0.0495525598526001, 0.003047260222956538, -0.00017896648205351084, 0.04213076829910278, -0.06714930385351181, -0.0193330105394125, 0.04485291242599487, -0.004997758660465479, -0.014866610988974571, 0.041035957634449005, 0.026380717754364014, -0.05907332897186279, -0.00045946723548695445, -0.008067510090768337, -0.02879238873720169, 0.0033418587408959866, 0.00532939238473773, 0.008344326168298721, 0.01847825013101101, -0.018014943227171898, 0.024700239300727844, 0.054062772542238235, -0.044912442564964294, 0.02731824852526188, 0.016429243609309196, -0.016795143485069275, -0.0409756563603878, 0.013068707659840584, -0.013377146795392036, 0.09469334036111832, 0.03654547780752182, 0.004650973714888096, 0.022536708042025566, -0.05954641476273537, -0.017722826451063156, 0.024700244888663292, 0.03127814456820488, -0.00585034117102623, -0.059991154819726944, 0.009724356234073639, 0.03878721222281456, -0.015443655662238598, -0.026550516486167908, -0.026731107383966446, -0.05520825833082199, 0.010721193626523018, -0.03137463703751564, -0.02759583666920662, -0.004839346278458834, 0.043000876903533936, -0.03221949189901352, -0.0024570482783019543, 0.019990554079413414, 0.004927974659949541, -0.047623541206121445, 0.03969654068350792, 0.01127410214394331, -0.003388388315215707, -0.06562890857458115, -0.06156289577484131, 0.0300452820956707, 0.05179457366466522, -0.018893375992774963, 0.020343312993645668, 0.009108525700867176, -0.09243055433034897, 0.014416545629501343, 0.019016239792108536, -0.06475060433149338, -0.0150598818436265, 0.06434140354394913, -0.046170540153980255, -0.0310017429292202, 0.014320599846541882, 0.02532775327563286, 0.017201818525791168, 0.005702419206500053, -0.05307203531265259, 0.03348047658801079, -0.03748588636517525, -0.009488505311310291, 0.034794650971889496, -0.013592412695288658, 0.04476543143391609, -0.025999201461672783, -0.09299029409885406, -0.02621440216898918, -0.05682677403092384, -0.031704146414995193, 0.0012920901644974947, -0.016597170382738113, -0.06314367800951004, -0.007815182209014893, 0.03581557050347328, -0.018231498077511787, 0.007642101030796766, -0.017350681126117706, 0.0385928712785244, -0.004257827997207642, -0.008702078834176064, 0.09417750686407089, -0.03271707892417908, 0.03336194530129433, -0.001411218661814928, 0.03117341734468937, 0.052104417234659195, 0.009141125716269016, -0.012224560603499413, 0.03575780615210533, 0.02078927867114544, 0.014334476552903652, 0.04768634960055351, -0.015117321163415909, 0.04356556385755539, -0.014154864475131035, 0.0034412716049700975, 0.0033009767066687346, -0.0023421344812959433, -0.006638357415795326, -0.010384452529251575, -0.07195441424846649, 0.001438888255506754, -0.02941083163022995, -0.019168635830283165, -0.010438024997711182, 0.033902835100889206, 0.000498757406603545, -0.00997347291558981, 0.02906045876443386, -0.023375671356916428, -0.03395586460828781, -0.047523025423288345, -0.005208222195506096, 0.07007645070552826, -0.03199733793735504, 0.03850850462913513, 0.06980665773153305, 0.019049422815442085, -0.0222986601293087, -0.05320701375603676, 0.022018486633896828, -0.07886412739753723, 0.024217523634433746, -0.026855161413550377, -0.031758617609739304, 0.06422700732946396, -0.06561616063117981, -0.014934659004211426, 0.019501756876707077, 0.03580969199538231, 0.020077642053365707, 0.017083073034882545, 0.01359656360000372, -0.024579713121056557, 0.01897459663450718, 0.03838278353214264, 0.06144169718027115, -0.06905365735292435, 0.029636116698384285, -0.05130964145064354, 0.017942864447832108, 0.0523143894970417, -0.04197124019265175, 0.013403098098933697, -0.03641245886683464, -0.06013159826397896, -0.00821906328201294, 0.009501826949417591, 0.049341484904289246, -0.03560023754835129, -0.03664596751332283, -0.0018488422501832247, -0.04295969009399414, 0.014745892025530338, 0.005512676667422056, 0.04380334913730621, 0.062162403017282486, 0.011773044243454933, 0.04189804196357727, 0.030297359451651573, 0.018722200766205788, -0.023480884730815887, -0.013541996479034424, 0.005390899255871773, -0.039575427770614624, -0.05842847377061844, -0.027493368834257126, 0.02770007774233818, 0.0059279813431203365, -0.026572834700345993, -0.04434487968683243, -0.05958186089992523, 0.05574748292565346, 0.018168985843658447, 0.02790590561926365, -0.038487616926431656, 0.03729782626032829, 0.01829090155661106, 0.010153912007808685, 0.08584151417016983, -0.04718650504946709, -0.03370928019285202, -0.007529975846409798, -0.015632491558790207, -0.03897661343216896, -0.03607643023133278, 0.047277115285396576, -0.0374322384595871, -0.034686584025621414, -0.0061723943799734116, -0.01957007311284542, 0.026906175538897514, 0.043778132647275925, 0.012938056141138077, 0.015881452709436417, 0.03195272386074066, 0.021442774683237076, 0.011087223887443542, -0.010619474574923515, -0.06021317094564438, 0.03278202936053276, -0.00042280592606402934, 0.017064658924937248, 0.029825301840901375, 0.042996544390916824, -0.030574534088373184, -0.012940492480993271, 0.03900816664099693, -0.05636470392346382, 0.029552115127444267, 0.02723025716841221, -0.06090228632092476, -0.011549034155905247, -0.011576916091144085, 0.03999599069356918, -0.01695377007126808, -0.005047398153692484, -0.0011922320118173957, -0.008125309832394123, 0.015039131045341492, 0.0035885677207261324, -0.04958520084619522, -0.022848904132843018, 0.05207093432545662, -0.012228735722601414, 0.03312799334526062, 0.037499457597732544, 0.001059234724380076, 0.1384989321231842, 0.008254855871200562, 0.02488848939538002, -0.03092369996011257, 0.040378324687480927, 0.006747406907379627, -0.035992782562971115, -0.01589437574148178, -0.006864032242447138, -0.0642707347869873, 0.01586027257144451, -0.010803957469761372, 0.0340912789106369, 0.01645282655954361, -0.04328679293394089, -0.020705727860331535, 0.0676613599061966, -0.02593187987804413, 0.08702263236045837, -0.0671987384557724, -0.021009162068367004, 0.08936714380979538, -0.048686910420656204, -0.009838603436946869, 0.015417583286762238, 0.056972917169332504, -0.06254982203245163, -0.028009872883558273, 0.06810310482978821, -0.03036169335246086, 0.01830117218196392, -0.003694638144224882, 0.0018831639317795634, 0.024843866005539894, -0.007071930915117264, -0.031230418011546135, -0.017291206866502762, -0.036364056169986725, -0.025447683408856392, -2.8631831128222984e-7, 0.00961383804678917, 0.019439538940787315, -0.013868843205273151, -0.02017241157591343, -0.03383694961667061, -0.058778923004865646, -0.029651714488863945, -0.032660264521837234, 0.0764867514371872, -0.0536426343023777, 0.006338751874864101, -0.0023800069466233253, -0.005069779232144356, 0.032223936170339584, 0.02494516409933567, -0.057461146265268326, -0.014114436693489552, -0.020760538056492805, 0.0033652952406555414, -0.016797440126538277, 0.017525412142276764, -0.01906714215874672, -0.011427978985011578, -0.012614244595170021, -0.037664808332920074, -0.002241083886474371, 0.09375888854265213, 0.038097742944955826, -0.009039707481861115, 0.009180193766951561, -0.0194886215031147, -0.049230631440877914, 0.001970138633623719, 0.014042086899280548, 0.02697734907269478, -0.04430314153432846, 0.021843042224645615, -0.005615420639514923, 0.005331858526915312, 0.02756817825138569, 0.011745976284146309, 0.028660597279667854, 0.00428676325827837, 0.02178417332470417, 0.06595298647880554, 0.018454229459166527, 0.05815767124295235, -0.005397979635745287, -0.044883843511343, -0.0002530887140892446, 0.014985614456236362, -0.009774581529200077, -0.05340050533413887, -0.03435935825109482, -0.024995816871523857, -0.0384124219417572, 0.002460071351379156, -0.01615493930876255, -0.04941294714808464, -0.040491241961717606, -0.07551340013742447, -0.01058922428637743, 0.013997506350278854, -0.01438424177467823, -0.009309981018304825, -0.002221436472609639, -0.10137133300304413, 0.003802681341767311, 0.024183282628655434, -0.007613119203597307, -0.003739423817023635, 0.06749315559864044, 0.05168873071670532, 0.01998267136514187, 0.047112055122852325, -0.002285613911226392, 0.024932000786066055, 0.00969560258090496, 0.011235705576837063, 0.03225615993142128, 0.011628617532551289, 0.00819325353950262, 0.013662061654031277, -0.000042940864659613, 0.033342935144901276, 0.04328280687332153, -0.020518293604254723, -0.07671567797660828, 0.018050167709589005, 0.01770608127117157, 0.00795348733663559, -0.015081328339874744, -0.05104126036167145, -0.03151702880859375, -0.008993001654744148, -0.008017201907932758, -0.0009661954245530069, -0.042712245136499405, 0.0275870393961668, -0.0087738037109375, 0.038292646408081055, 0.0017885674024000764, -0.07206659764051437, 0.04623754322528839, 0.058943383395671844, 0.022486383095383644, 0.01099797897040844, 0.09673308581113815, -0.0023038473445922136, -0.00669728172942996, 0.02738315612077713, 0.0006968329544179142, 0.0023282766342163086, -0.0025046346709132195, 0.06993939727544785, 0.005637250375002623, -0.027510689571499825, 0.0305271428078413, -0.013385012745857239, 0.05265655741095543, -0.0477280393242836, 0.03170294314622879, -0.019501816481351852, -0.006884770467877388, -0.012234598398208618, -0.05939369648694992, -0.026549719274044037, -0.021870989352464676, 0.005547179374843836, 0.03433644026517868, -0.09559794515371323, -0.05357939377427101, -0.010336147621273994, 0.013375005684792995, -0.025927087292075157, -0.04112749546766281, -0.060636408627033234, 0.07353147119283676, 0.00985211506485939, -0.05944562703371048, 0.005267233122140169, -0.034150488674640656, -0.06727775931358337, -0.003091544611379504, 0.013194819912314415, -0.04956752061843872, -0.014310921542346478, 0.02431037276983261, 0.012953231111168861, -0.03282413259148598, -0.0013375435955822468, 0.004857422783970833, -0.006549193989485502, 0.011940651573240757, 0.03239607810974121, -0.057486481964588165, 0.018573809415102005, -0.043851688504219055, -0.02202419564127922, -0.030440235510468483, 0.028879264369606972, 0.007959219627082348, 0.04330051690340042, -0.0196777805685997, 0.009701441042125225, 0.0033874381333589554, -0.06076432392001152, -0.008862900547683239, -0.035008613020181656, 0.0070876386016607285, -0.023242246359586716, 0.060259927064180374, -0.03758447617292404, -0.029814036563038826, -0.00038834422593936324, -0.010909726843237877, -0.014121790416538715, -0.03938465937972069, -0.12536188960075378, 0.03457455337047577, 0.04307778179645538, -0.020855968818068504, -0.03873320296406746, -0.004647193942219019, -0.003889266634359956, -0.01174546591937542, 0.009607833810150623, 0.007434952072799206, 0.08576962351799011, -0.005949425045400858, 0.026880623772740364, 0.023422449827194214, 0.06158347800374031, 0.01899094320833683, 0.019603556022047997, 0.006370360963046551, -0.0054812952876091, -0.06466223299503326, 0.03585917502641678, -0.01781965047121048, -0.049392323940992355, 0.023132003843784332, 0.049052223563194275, 0.0043949238024652, -0.05569661036133766, 0.0009282498504035175, 0.04725002869963646, -0.030188385397195816, -0.0510854572057724, 0.03093111887574196, -0.019728804007172585, -0.004566842690110207, 0.05327253043651581, -0.015050731599330902, -0.016482127830386162, -0.03463149815797806, 0.033125054091215134, -0.016847116872668266, 0.02878500148653984, 0.025325259193778038, 0.005359724164009094, 0.002158503280952573, 0.01373137254267931, 0.06706809252500534, -0.06444703042507172, 0.0025985799729824066, -0.013417717069387436, -0.029933832585811615, 0.018183158710598946, -0.0006212570006027818, 0.019058864563703537, 0.03045813925564289, 0.07150270789861679, -0.045876916497945786, 0.019008247181773186, -0.0014674300327897072, -0.04122983664274216, 0.02715429849922657, 0.0002862105320673436, 0.01158568263053894, 0.01496883761137724, -0.013876333832740784, -0.008351980708539486, 0.03516547754406929, 0.062412139028310776, -0.0455457866191864, -0.03116101771593094, 0.055189117789268494, -0.004907587077468634, 0.06896335631608963, 0.015466216951608658, 0.019088637083768845, 0.003641312476247549, -0.03246091306209564, -0.020630717277526855, -0.028892923146486282, 0.05671066418290138, -0.04155930131673813, 0.009119627065956593, -0.037465739995241165, 0.015652893111109734, -0.08951644599437714, 0.03725216165184975, 0.022037481889128685, 0.03129277750849724, -0.07703310996294022, -0.06049930304288864, 0.028537321835756302, 0.016184499487280846, 0.012492104433476925, -0.00736837787553668, 0.025683246552944183, 0.01594834215939045, -0.049662914127111435, -0.0009148471872322261, -0.06838816404342651, 0.01347892265766859, 0.013926585204899311, -0.009697476401925087, -0.06980717182159424, -0.02062576822936535, -0.008673449978232384, -0.010738959535956383, 0.014653780497610569, -0.017958225682377815, 0.01079830713570118, 0.038359384983778, -0.030984792858362198, 0.003042608965188265, 0.04023057594895363, 0.06187880039215088, 0.04113440588116646, 0.008503665216267109, 0.00041676865657791495, 0.0681513100862503, -0.007217481266707182, 0.01581035740673542, 0.02091595157980919, 0.006973681040108204, 0.05255969986319542, -0.04519199952483177, -0.06605090200901031, 0.020337898284196854, 0.01131778210401535, -0.0011445794953033328, -0.0040288022719323635, -0.03375546261668205, 0.007656976114958525, 0.029516620561480522, 0.0343930758535862, -0.014457661658525467, -0.032039742916822433, -0.03259807825088501, 0.0048462641425430775, 0.08550519496202469, 0.011634069494903088, 0.011510537937283516, 0.06634531170129776, 0.09643585979938507, 0.010171610862016678, 0.023176999762654305, -0.018894122913479805, -0.048754047602415085, 0.06412523239850998, -0.010230294428765774, -0.05215456336736679, 0.05282416567206383, 0.010550501756370068, 0.03941142186522484, -0.002192300045862794, 0.022824037820100784, 0.019923143088817596, 0.028972448781132698, -0.004338167607784271, 0.05113926902413368, -0.03707621991634369, 0.031937915831804276, -0.01432777103036642, 0.009346229955554008, -0.03794276714324951, 0.0014396863989531994, -0.04041889309883118, -0.001206632237881422, 0.0007972788880579174, 0.009652825072407722, 0.07929057627916336, 0.044416140764951706, 0.007986178621649742, 0.029351264238357544, -0.0447782464325428, -0.053385328501462936, -0.02653822861611843, 0.01229342631995678, -0.004828004632145166, 0.0005973007646389306, -0.03102153353393078, -0.03742453455924988, -0.0014603078598156571, -0.054665159434080124, -0.024890387430787086, -0.05190049111843109, -0.021512331441044807, 0.04531973972916603, 0.03725258633494377, -0.03285357728600502, -0.008557228371500969, -0.010687108151614666, -0.018711179494857788, 0.03851943463087082, -0.000309103139443323, 0.037922900170087814, -0.018713073804974556, 0.01766536943614483, 0.018842142075300217, 0.020070966333150864, -0.037648651748895645, 0.011797122657299042, 0.018678927794098854, 0.002108475659042597, 0.014555555768311024, -0.0037600190844386816, 0.07145604491233826, 0.031143294647336006, -0.04150422289967537, 0.037311699241399765, 0.03617289662361145, 0.09139353036880493, -0.015374671667814255, 0.0034342461731284857, 0.00495477020740509, 0.021075643599033356, 0.023818982765078545, 0.06166738644242287, 0.006564977578818798, -0.0005199190927669406, 0.015402473509311676, 0.001037859357893467, 0.046885453164577484, 0.0069979894906282425, 0.009780395776033401, 0.008845227770507336, 0.023877037689089775, 0.054007768630981445, 0.03728529438376427, -0.06672489643096924, -0.103701651096344, 0.01864783465862274, 0.014273802749812603, -0.02681572735309601, 0.0030130441300570965, 0.02605511248111725, -0.005693970248103142, 0.0013528239214792848, -0.1026398092508316, 0.02961951494216919, -0.002556283725425601, -0.021899670362472534, 0.044294487684965134, -0.020519724115729332, 0.036297574639320374, -0.00577034056186676, -0.04389754310250282, 0.04865054413676262, 0.01946355029940605, 0.022006921470165253, -0.003574283793568611, 0.030259914696216583, 0.003541753627359867, 0.06692852824926376, 0.05823485180735588, -0.01830846443772316, -0.030857916921377182, -0.0658399760723114, -0.03815475478768349, 0.010319204069674015, -0.010692279785871506, 0.027473365887999535, -0.006023187655955553, -0.014014637097716331, -0.013716395944356918, 0.0022414519917219877, 0.0047377971932291985, 0.0177959892898798, 0.07106375694274902, -0.013795381411910057, -0.036581967025995255, -0.015175909735262394, 0.0033842434640973806, 0.010150793939828873, -0.02675301767885685, -0.04488995671272278, -0.01985100470483303, -0.04569168761372566, -0.05639134347438812, -0.01996963657438755, -0.036755725741386414, 0.04690518230199814 ]
<p>Would it be possible for a neutron to lose a positron and become an antiproton? Or would would it need to be the decay of a antineutron to antiproton instead? </p>
g4013
[ 0.024161743000149727, -0.01574893295764923, 0.043233249336481094, -0.02253575623035431, 0.03258797898888588, 0.010209379717707634, -0.050887130200862885, -0.01173922885209322, -0.013869382441043854, -0.06728868186473846, -0.0173555426299572, 0.014568818733096123, -0.01718185842037201, -0.026438480243086815, 0.013213756494224072, -0.018545299768447876, 0.023108161985874176, -0.0070824832655489445, 0.017348550260066986, -0.015538136474788189, 0.01475962158292532, -0.030203256756067276, -0.015440761111676693, -0.014830403961241245, -0.05675049498677254, 0.0061442372389137745, -0.0469246543943882, -0.02316625602543354, -0.03397393971681595, -0.011460556648671627, -0.013526370748877525, -0.05611496791243553, -0.018263818696141243, -0.020889433100819588, 0.033236004412174225, -0.0737895593047142, 0.026405857875943184, 0.07998164743185043, 0.0006970310350880027, 0.02631840854883194, 0.019168870523571968, -0.014659118838608265, 0.054319530725479126, -0.013383973389863968, 0.03605908155441284, -0.009907888248562813, -0.017399365082383156, 0.027411501854658127, -0.019156228750944138, -0.06814195960760117, 0.017146172001957893, -0.013769418001174927, -0.021484335884451866, 0.011804596520960331, -0.02822139486670494, 0.016902530565857887, 0.010877030901610851, -0.0781196728348732, 0.06468650698661804, 0.04015698283910751, -0.046579182147979736, 0.006576474756002426, -0.008765793405473232, 0.017048070207238197, 0.04035596176981926, -0.04537901654839516, -0.029915470629930496, -0.010844090022146702, -0.0000015360695897470578, 0.07123502343893051, 0.028566112741827965, 0.05284975841641426, -0.01700243540108204, 0.002832779660820961, 0.07857781648635864, -0.0310219693928957, 0.0037224902771413326, -0.09271818399429321, 0.04671040177345276, 0.007634103298187256, 0.005874146241694689, -0.002302011242136359, 0.025244098156690598, 0.03611975163221359, 0.055216941982507706, -0.011993891559541225, 0.0031909991521388292, 0.0016124678077176213, -0.04757263511419296, 0.004549664910882711, -0.0065193441696465015, -0.020955311134457588, -0.023066703230142593, -0.03686238080263138, 0.023548001423478127, -0.04868968576192856, 0.0020824274979531765, 0.026079276576638222, -0.08090810477733612, 0.018445592373609543, 0.043771665543317795, -0.06782565265893936, -0.003730700584128499, 0.001292296452447772, 0.03906821832060814, -0.05127286911010742, 0.05931463837623596, -0.020697128027677536, 0.05179350823163986, 0.04747660458087921, 0.02253684215247631, 0.007836059667170048, -0.049082498997449875, -0.05507749319076538, 0.016377106308937073, 0.0074647716246545315, 0.031088929623365402, -0.0015862692380324006, -0.02478954568505287, 0.060552556067705154, 0.03778817504644394, 0.06538213044404984, -0.013831262476742268, 0.06408712267875671, -0.015950635075569153, 0.017240798100829124, -0.03198846057057381, 0.049612462520599365, 0.022409720346331596, 0.07418986409902573, 0.0048883091658353806, 0.008207911625504494, -0.03916449099779129, 0.08554816246032715, -0.037009987980127335, 0.05558681860566139, 0.03248782828450203, -0.012775857001543045, -0.01417218241840601, -0.07482092082500458, 0.030294252559542656, 0.0028421736788004637, -0.013326088897883892, 0.0037220329977571964, -0.01660747267305851, 0.024836573749780655, 0.007051973603665829, 0.046916984021663666, -0.05329540744423866, 0.07317918539047241, 0.06382393091917038, -0.02046498842537403, 0.03882027789950371, -0.026935476809740067, 0.01641128771007061, -0.050022535026073456, 0.0330563448369503, 0.03245542570948601, -0.015207515098154545, -0.018637247383594513, 0.028912020847201347, 0.04048506170511246, -0.022024482488632202, -0.013001465238630772, -0.03284483775496483, -0.006762200966477394, -0.023280221968889236, 0.03132261708378792, -0.07370364665985107, 0.018364153802394867, 0.009310009889304638, 0.028585942462086678, 0.020008161664009094, 0.052121441811323166, 0.004656756296753883, -0.003689957084134221, -0.07639403641223907, 0.04309700429439545, -0.02144726738333702, -0.010546994395554066, -0.028980938717722893, 0.04540427401661873, 0.02941766008734703, -0.001973712118342519, 0.016131574288010597, 0.02276649884879589, -0.02267799898982048, 0.0244140662252903, 0.014001949690282345, 0.011074074544012547, 0.008244612254202366, 0.015363937243819237, 0.021798765286803246, 0.03358732536435127, 0.04230785369873047, -0.018076611682772636, -0.009838201105594635, -0.08651619404554367, 0.05684564262628555, 0.03363332897424698, -0.061288509517908096, -0.04057193174958229, -0.04464288800954819, -0.010740252211689949, 0.03663348779082298, -0.09359553456306458, 0.0005871774046681821, 0.008673656731843948, 0.026804476976394653, -0.038229938596487045, 0.05160544812679291, 0.03796253353357315, -0.00608427170664072, 0.008471418172121048, -0.07781277596950531, 0.04230065271258354, -0.025385139510035515, 0.04452791064977646, -0.03301076963543892, 0.030570948496460915, -0.052784767001867294, -0.02996130846440792, 0.01811831258237362, 0.00578536419197917, -0.03803470730781555, 0.03986334428191185, -0.0231056809425354, -0.00979616492986679, -0.026832405477762222, 0.0389954149723053, -0.04347022995352745, 0.005260728299617767, -0.03289719298481941, -0.026968535035848618, 0.03701914846897125, -0.00469660060480237, -0.011989578604698181, 0.031453490257263184, -0.022027380764484406, -0.003466175403445959, -0.027939988300204277, 0.008683585561811924, -0.06388795375823975, 0.024003097787499428, 0.03119826689362526, -0.08513926714658737, 0.006101551465690136, -0.007279872428625822, -0.023477694019675255, 0.013591372407972813, 0.03154302388429642, -0.026943719014525414, -0.04314775764942169, 0.005982000380754471, 0.017765739932656288, 0.010968904942274094, 0.0054665617644786835, -0.008691852912306786, -0.01644655503332615, -0.03416452184319496, -0.025478476658463478, -0.030301395803689957, -0.020256347954273224, 0.0047709038481116295, 0.02639845199882984, -0.01671721041202545, -0.020282410085201263, 0.001799503923393786, 0.007938436232507229, 0.06362749636173248, 0.017725689336657524, 0.03337420895695686, -0.03285624459385872, 0.03046768344938755, -0.010906246490776539, 0.00996406003832817, 0.014156675897538662, -0.019346436485648155, 0.0336049385368824, -0.0304858535528183, -0.06639578938484192, 0.07777528464794159, -0.01742667891085148, -0.023363934829831123, -0.0119736697524786, -0.005039846058934927, 0.06425563246011734, -0.05357186123728752, -0.03621091693639755, 0.011509289965033531, -0.03162788227200508, -0.021717431023716927, 0.025099867954850197, -0.028082748875021935, 0.02234066091477871, 0.0159755889326334, 0.04886738955974579, -0.02489757165312767, -0.038258444517850876, -0.012285691685974598, 0.030811984091997147, -0.0009759771055541933, -0.008195828646421432, -0.038933273404836655, 0.04150309041142464, -0.010050905868411064, -0.1386423259973526, 0.058596331626176834, 0.01986815221607685, -0.044036637991666794, -0.05967437103390694, 0.09080737084150314, 0.005877526011317968, 0.039931077510118484, 0.022218376398086548, 0.031204715371131897, 0.018082641065120697, 0.038911689072847366, 0.09190446138381958, -0.048898641020059586, -0.016602622345089912, -0.0029974430799484253, -0.006772284395992756, 0.02608278952538967, 0.05867204815149307, 0.006075546145439148, -0.043057605624198914, -0.011726252734661102, -0.03840554505586624, -0.01514364406466484, 0.041692815721035004, -0.029330769553780556, 0.0049959151074290276, 0.025507109239697456, -0.06504721194505692, 0.0518585667014122, 0.07594799995422363, 0.02272680774331093, 0.0016258555697277188, 0.05806148797273636, 0.06893162429332733, -0.07435169816017151, -0.012536533176898956, 0.04020896926522255, 0.04367642477154732, -0.008945572189986706, 0.04166007414460182, -0.07045190781354904, 0.05973983183503151, -0.008758323267102242, 0.029273582622408867, -0.019827447831630707, 0.04088297486305237, 0.03807510808110237, -0.022194769233465195, -0.05517420917749405, 0.036971233785152435, -0.00696569262072444, 0.002108159242197871, 0.031760323792696, 0.012239890173077583, -0.05461498722434044, 0.07625055313110352, -0.01013232208788395, -0.04910863935947418, 0.051459286361932755, -0.054948367178440094, 0.033032648265361786, 0.018235309049487114, 0.023258941248059273, 0.008082601241767406, 0.0145816495642066, -0.04022602736949921, -0.026516254991292953, -0.016712259501218796, 0.02257172390818596, -0.000880507635883987, 0.0168828833848238, -0.050662022083997726, 0.02142421156167984, -0.008167126215994358, -0.05980631709098816, 0.03531951457262039, -0.020159095525741577, -0.014334353618323803, -0.02768501080572605, 0.003950821701437235, -0.023052873089909554, -0.027689974755048752, 0.03485412523150444, -0.0019880265463143587, 0.014578516595065594, 0.01008126325905323, 0.0057542291469872, 0.031201908364892006, 0.016162341460585594, -0.05059293285012245, -0.0730525404214859, -0.0441322848200798, -0.0015848266193643212, -0.08206199109554291, 0.06050829216837883, 0.027363814413547516, -0.07187283039093018, 0.06801549345254898, -0.020880453288555145, -0.014269824139773846, 0.00014590646605938673, -0.018116673454642296, 0.009943246841430664, -0.030710874125361443, 0.010947933420538902, 0.02421063371002674, -0.0024274010211229324, -0.01149152684956789, -0.004840862937271595, -0.00871502049267292, 0.04888350889086723, -0.024515461176633835, 0.003702352289110422, -0.00903539452701807, 0.052155740559101105, 0.028811857104301453, 0.07934296876192093, -0.002633369527757168, 0.05298442021012306, -0.010125309228897095, 0.00665018055588007, -0.0451103150844574, -0.019740870222449303, 0.007733131758868694, 0.03410768508911133, 0.0637505054473877, 0.03110395185649395, 0.006319228559732437, 0.03929516300559044, -0.029459750279784203, -0.04190588742494583, 0.024622002616524696, -0.011959034949541092, 0.001716983038932085, 0.035614579916000366, 0.025432538241147995, -0.04899568855762482, -0.01949978992342949, 0.001144231529906392, -0.0024653461296111345, -0.019741971045732498, 0.007804200518876314, -0.05192795395851135, -0.0033036505337804556, 0.012728214263916016, -0.029238851740956306, -0.003774483921006322, -0.021885287016630173, 0.006952682975679636, 0.014924917370080948, -0.029019586741924286, -0.006212787237018347, 0.06719692796468735, -0.001649998826906085, -0.054729487746953964, -0.0010962911183014512, 0.00260997680015862, 0.05040386691689491, -0.03172385320067406, -0.015731973573565483, 0.03224384784698486, -0.037034112960100174, -0.027577323839068413, -0.053207967430353165, 0.03097669780254364, -0.014167191460728645, 0.039403609931468964, -0.004254243336617947, -0.04219770431518555, 0.01050630398094654, -0.02127963863313198, 0.04527236893773079, 0.0033810383174568415, -0.0270561333745718, 0.02551659196615219, -0.011535808444023132, -0.017559686675667763, -0.046111732721328735, 0.0198859553784132, -0.040620364248752594, 0.022780684754252434, 0.030401388183236122, -0.02770913578569889, -0.00017770371050573885, -0.012870019301772118, 0.06460718810558319, 0.03688300400972366, 0.03016822226345539, -0.0016411560354754329, -0.07918684184551239, -0.03641951084136963, 0.04679019749164581, 0.05620869994163513, -0.004303632769733667, -0.01284350547939539, -0.025478430092334747, -0.0522422157227993, -0.025535861030220985, 0.009800420142710209, 0.06345099955797195, 0.0006884085014462471, -0.024266811087727547, -0.012159498408436775, -0.04221930354833603, 0.014186862856149673, -0.03673779219388962, 0.0008738047326914966, 0.03652681037783623, 0.01460079662501812, -0.06971009075641632, 0.028609994798898697, 0.011733105406165123, -0.015717990696430206, 0.0028662472032010555, 0.08477073162794113, 0.03656206279993057, -0.03463791683316231, -0.017163900658488274, -0.00694870064035058, -0.061253622174263, 0.04914527386426926, -0.012628731317818165, -0.08823733776807785, 0.050369199365377426, 0.00862219650298357, -0.03532372787594795, 0.011154888197779655, -0.03619867190718651, -0.025978120043873787, -0.04282969608902931, -0.017383135855197906, 0.01457365695387125, -0.01676749438047409, -0.04902534931898117, -0.0037625806871801615, 0.015159707516431808, 0.05608924478292465, 0.02512582391500473, 0.005880068987607956, -0.04542093724012375, 0.01713370904326439, -0.00031588581623509526, -0.051307111978530884, 0.01608261466026306, 0.057207055389881134, -0.032386697828769684, -0.016309361904859543, -0.014741230756044388, 0.009254179894924164, 0.05429207161068916, 0.003480734536424279, 0.06093709543347359, -0.06102854758501053, -0.03752203285694122, -0.0317053496837616, -0.0525154210627079, 0.06048146262764931, 0.010759145021438599, 0.010647700168192387, 0.0041900030337274075, -0.0080382339656353, -0.004646393936127424, -0.01610616035759449, 0.04238182678818703, 0.010708725079894066, -0.037789057940244675, 0.0005145760951563716, 0.005848849657922983, 0.024528352543711662, 0.018643207848072052, -0.01987377740442753, 0.005493826698511839, -0.028438957408070564, 0.004140065051615238, 0.02142062410712242, -0.021878546103835106, 0.010790771804749966, 0.004804342053830624, 0.005212518852204084, -0.028916461393237114, 0.058695241808891296, 0.012881273403763771, 0.03680146858096123, -0.02231789194047451, 0.021948574110865593, -0.03669139742851257, -0.0040465774945914745, -0.017921477556228638, 0.01680580899119377, -0.04136386141180992, -0.03861595690250397, -0.062166716903448105, 0.027429580688476562, 0.0000943792620091699, 0.017422251403331757, 0.009978828020393848, 0.019855758175253868, 0.004298368934541941, 0.04518665745854378, 0.081845723092556, 0.061422403901815414, 0.0355670191347599, -0.058471497148275375, -0.03421873226761818, 0.014422187581658363, 0.03507262468338013, -0.004931585863232613, -0.005318194627761841, -0.03388098627328873, 0.03858337551355362, -0.011609356850385666, -0.021995365619659424, -0.030695611611008644, 0.030414186418056488, -0.029144369065761566, -0.019112396985292435, -0.0067923120222985744, -0.0011504953727126122, 0.004775608889758587, -0.009398386813700199, 0.07387039810419083, 0.020439695566892624, 0.0414922833442688, -0.0028385515324771404, -0.0015841276617720723, 0.03961043432354927, -0.015579448081552982, -0.010768672451376915, 0.041219066828489304, -0.022321384400129318, -0.02040283754467964, 0.012105373665690422, -0.011474297381937504, 0.03185843303799629, -0.0005992369260638952, 0.02365410514175892, -0.013583291321992874, -0.04975348711013794, 0.13126172125339508, 0.003771357238292694, -0.07393630594015121, -0.02346789464354515, 0.04681931063532829, 0.012874786742031574, -0.013914443552494049, -0.044706180691719055, 0.024520093575119972, -0.032528381794691086, 0.04522237181663513, -0.03929534927010536, 0.05311679095029831, 0.02727469615638256, -0.027124082669615746, -0.004426972940564156, -0.039419420063495636, 0.06605886667966843, -0.012186848558485508, 0.04331884905695915, -0.06934801489114761, 0.05609671771526337, -0.03314581513404846, -0.012429946102201939, 0.05349500849843025, -0.04463166370987892, 0.0051123593002557755, -0.03892870619893074, 0.01800817809998989, 0.03473570570349693, -0.021568285301327705, -0.0033581568859517574, 0.03707749769091606, 0.038569748401641846, -0.00420008972287178, -0.01846233569085598, 0.010576551780104637, -0.0008782658842392266, 0.0008562480797991157, 0.033983081579208374, 0.11142437160015106, -0.029451698064804077, 0.028862982988357544, 0.01154501922428608, 0.05133108049631119, -0.015085249207913876, -0.023572292178869247, 0.07144301384687424, -0.033481087535619736, -0.03565538302063942, -0.025848831981420517, -0.04810300096869469, -0.007600503508001566, 0.01566782221198082, -0.06023070588707924, -0.008263381198048592, 0.051109425723552704, 0.014584019780158997, -0.04130665212869644, -0.05645546689629555, -0.009497414343059063, -0.03762011229991913, -0.045607808977365494, -0.03559694439172745, -0.009797084145247936, 0.06748497486114502, 0.08430003374814987, 0.013071482069790363, -0.014398716390132904, 0.007590102031826973, 0.0011891264002770185, 0.0006368752801790833, -0.08827094733715057, 0.016114622354507446, 0.007346946746110916, -0.06545673310756683, 0.010866861790418625, -0.04392770305275917, -0.004464095924049616, -0.019714567810297012, -0.026939501985907555, 0.022981436923146248, -0.015576323494315147, -0.015033258125185966, 0.057624172419309616, -0.02573317289352417, 0.01907266303896904, -0.04449974372982979, -0.04678300768136978, 0.04106597229838371, -0.04193852096796036, -0.01615447923541069, 0.005508166737854481, -0.029148630797863007, 0.0013479952467605472, 0.004858263768255711, -0.054405227303504944, 0.015575297176837921, -0.008667207323014736, 0.009137741290032864, -0.05221710354089737, -0.0037604006938636303, 0.05629806965589523, -0.016485579311847687, -0.04413093626499176, -0.016488945111632347, 0.010140475817024708, 0.00814529974013567, 0.06393562257289886, 0.0534580834209919, 0.02404910884797573, -0.02676207944750786, 0.00587391946464777, -0.040034230798482895, -0.03420625999569893, 0.008780468255281448, 0.04026973620057106, -0.0026730899699032307, -0.019643202424049377, -0.026220843195915222, -0.03959490358829498, -0.022075453773140907, 0.014964502304792404 ]
<p>What factors determine whether or not wind resistance will have an important effect on the trajectory of a projectile? </p>
g4014
[ 0.04872604086995125, 0.012513569556176662, 0.029985617846250534, 0.029364105314016342, 0.04076273366808891, 0.06382717192173004, 0.03189128637313843, -0.02451484091579914, -0.015486297197639942, -0.028232848271727562, -0.025271087884902954, 0.007442439906299114, 0.011266851797699928, 0.035706132650375366, -0.020712057128548622, 0.016595015302300453, 0.08667280524969101, -0.002596701728180051, 0.01420257892459631, 0.03589949384331703, -0.03729755058884621, -0.07563204318284988, -0.021396080031991005, 0.026390040293335915, -0.004130210727453232, -0.012130456045269966, 0.005185180343687534, -0.018323784694075584, -0.09968174248933792, 0.04181615263223648, -0.0008841507951729, 0.032488949596881866, -0.03209897503256798, -0.039379797875881195, -0.06223133206367493, -0.042514264583587646, -0.0386202335357666, -0.023654218763113022, -0.0016420487081632018, 0.010896209627389908, -0.014719038270413876, -0.028533030301332474, -0.021411243826150894, 0.06714867055416107, 0.029225217178463936, 0.04081005975604057, 0.022832902148365974, -0.012830698862671852, -0.05752839148044586, -0.018817778676748276, -0.05460385978221893, -0.05955331772565842, -0.04739036038517952, -0.024603333324193954, -0.0468602292239666, 0.017470333725214005, 0.032222215086221695, 0.021166149526834488, -0.02225545607507229, 0.012559939175844193, 0.032137077301740646, 0.019277499988675117, -0.08206164091825485, -0.03935873880982399, 0.012306204997003078, -0.05061032250523567, -0.046862371265888214, 0.023698436096310616, 0.03512585908174515, -0.026498112827539444, 0.07733038067817688, -0.008056707680225372, -0.05860228091478348, -0.04318857938051224, 0.01767527498304844, -0.014563186094164848, -0.028252679854631424, 0.008292126469314098, -0.04640799015760422, -0.021751707419753075, -0.02118314802646637, 0.057715728878974915, 0.026214515790343285, -0.01749013178050518, 0.0217909999191761, 0.0006801494746468961, 0.03800021857023239, 0.039794936776161194, -0.026080064475536346, -0.014422320760786533, 0.005964670330286026, -0.010221753269433975, 0.04805365204811096, -0.007546793203800917, 0.017267759889364243, 0.02812112495303154, -0.055474553257226944, 0.08020449429750443, 0.022173691540956497, 0.04013240709900856, -0.02630423754453659, -0.0007054550223983824, -0.037580739706754684, 0.0251159630715847, 0.030247032642364502, -0.022241996601223946, 0.12901413440704346, 0.014420947059988976, 0.02606193907558918, -0.016929473727941513, -0.0075196437537670135, -0.019619693979620934, -0.06806744635105133, 0.018733343109488487, -0.007914404384791851, -0.014559358358383179, 0.06321907788515091, -0.04164588451385498, 0.04129449650645256, 0.06804206222295761, -0.007375153247267008, -0.005260385572910309, -0.0323459729552269, 0.020706644281744957, -0.02729041874408722, -0.03438321501016617, 0.01602434366941452, -0.02510991320014, -0.02806752733886242, -0.01675638183951378, 0.04666801542043686, -0.03787108138203621, 0.015929603949189186, 0.005265067331492901, 0.004925202578306198, 0.0064224861562252045, 0.02146342769265175, 0.06016020104289055, -0.019857265055179596, -0.00041967362631112337, 0.04466419667005539, 0.006288638338446617, 0.057190991938114166, 0.0018833843059837818, -0.048338547348976135, 0.06246504560112953, -0.027961980551481247, 0.002706308616325259, -0.016338052228093147, -0.00982651486992836, 0.0155947832390666, 0.013076117262244225, -0.026614578440785408, 0.004575295373797417, -0.021087002009153366, -0.04519158974289894, -0.02077467553317547, -0.02122632786631584, -0.0011180273722857237, 0.010227487422525883, 0.021351316943764687, -0.0006085428176447749, -0.021125705912709236, 0.018357276916503906, -0.026315908879041672, -0.019661573693156242, -0.058596573770046234, 0.05185754597187042, -0.025296086445450783, -0.028954477980732918, -0.017621053382754326, -0.00033388211159035563, 0.0599190779030323, 0.04041522368788719, -0.003077205503359437, 0.02742922678589821, 0.026312561705708504, -0.006040689069777727, 0.007306849583983421, -0.027247656136751175, 0.04404055327177048, 0.061335623264312744, -0.04822874069213867, -0.034016288816928864, -0.026547856628894806, -0.03559280186891556, 0.04688829928636551, 0.026520542800426483, -0.051858995109796524, -0.02442987635731697, 0.039637286216020584, -0.020294189453125, -0.043183017522096634, -0.027967914938926697, -0.011496126651763916, -0.006790587678551674, -0.01535478513687849, 0.0028587591368705034, -0.06426849961280823, -0.02063523791730404, -0.05269981175661087, 0.05898258835077286, 0.022637464106082916, -0.0144775016233325, -0.01503429189324379, 0.030615873634815216, 0.005358497146517038, 0.03631207346916199, 0.007813222706317902, -0.010555058717727661, 0.026862723752856255, 0.012915262952446938, 0.023003092035651207, 0.05241967365145683, 0.04490166902542114, 0.05104822665452957, 0.010402713902294636, 0.07425504177808762, -0.01633988693356514, 0.04542927071452141, -0.019739115610718727, 0.04051441699266434, -0.01842731609940529, 0.010942799970507622, -0.07342197746038437, 0.014994407072663307, -0.007203849498182535, 0.002171152038499713, 0.031308289617300034, 0.02211431786417961, 0.013332534581422806, -0.022231215611100197, -0.03642294183373451, 0.005944267380982637, 0.05701050907373428, -0.025394722819328308, 0.07823118567466736, -0.030073251575231552, 0.05256044864654541, -0.009535908699035645, 0.004272965714335442, -0.04834441840648651, 0.02122565731406212, -0.004293536767363548, 0.07836940139532089, -0.05667903646826744, -0.02087724767625332, -0.017814720049500465, -0.04523277282714844, 0.0035515588242560625, -0.020832519978284836, 0.03234907612204552, -0.024532539770007133, 0.029578058049082756, -0.06501384824514389, -0.015279818326234818, -0.027576586231589317, -0.025802066549658775, -0.05087410286068916, 0.007494037039577961, -0.017446938902139664, -0.061108656227588654, -0.044233161956071854, -0.047865357249975204, -0.03600906953215599, 0.04913472384214401, -0.02649518847465515, 0.06846704334020615, -0.02291179820895195, 0.0043714395724236965, 0.03548487648367882, 0.05182680860161781, -0.008866663090884686, 0.03601693734526634, -0.006926050875335932, -0.006260607857257128, 0.014784584753215313, 0.008086686953902245, -0.014497993513941765, 0.013920463621616364, 0.037106405943632126, -0.04415654018521309, -0.04411311447620392, 0.04512852430343628, 0.06763230264186859, -0.00508095370605588, -0.011733180843293667, 0.07935541868209839, -0.038243528455495834, -0.0387943796813488, -0.013044657185673714, 0.033317238092422485, 0.011730949394404888, -0.028092464432120323, 0.0360993891954422, 0.00722117256373167, 0.056313320994377136, -0.005864866077899933, 0.06510545313358307, 0.015641523525118828, -0.011298582889139652, 0.04400607943534851, -0.03795868158340454, -0.037559837102890015, -0.02806759625673294, 0.05593474581837654, 0.01565813273191452, -0.03755094110965729, 0.019712258130311966, -0.016186492517590523, -0.03709328919649124, 0.05708352476358414, 0.00009448151104152203, 0.02451282925903797, -0.058080222457647324, -0.026951875537633896, -0.008819769136607647, 0.06603991985321045, 0.0049378168769180775, 0.040535084903240204, -0.006317639257758856, -0.02227574959397316, 0.043727971613407135, 0.0086813447996974, -0.0006832280196249485, 0.032853320240974426, 0.034939441829919815, 0.024506447836756706, 0.05888565257191658, -0.014206528663635254, -0.016140166670084, 0.06526890397071838, 0.01368555799126625, -0.008805355057120323, -0.026858747005462646, 0.04689649119973183, 0.07372961938381195, -0.01634095050394535, -0.039828043431043625, -0.008166985586285591, 0.04102780297398567, -0.05193142965435982, -0.0590115524828434, 0.03145776689052582, -0.023636946454644203, -0.018378164619207382, 0.03936399519443512, -0.013049212284386158, 0.018542740494012833, -0.05983125418424606, 0.03512517362833023, -0.042738836258649826, -0.06413490325212479, 0.024192988872528076, -0.003981281537562609, -0.0013036972377449274, 0.04654761776328087, 0.04039030522108078, -0.01344070304185152, 0.03701755777001381, -0.023675212636590004, -0.008915792219340801, -0.027315473183989525, 0.01616581343114376, -0.001975373597815633, 0.033264320343732834, -0.051007673144340515, -0.03596542775630951, -0.049497563391923904, 0.011713559739291668, -0.023045670241117477, -0.011492017656564713, -0.06164625287055969, 0.038131918758153915, 0.012721494771540165, 0.06856679171323776, 0.053507592529058456, 0.0018830844201147556, -0.04641919955611229, -0.006773312110453844, 0.04642025753855705, 0.03147820755839348, -0.0058546168729662895, 0.025472113862633705, -0.010963378474116325, 0.006446025799959898, -0.03297444060444832, -0.018943695351481438, 0.05061962082982063, -0.0651792585849762, -0.01399671658873558, -0.02475293166935444, -0.01203914638608694, -0.016554629430174828, 0.11139149963855743, -0.02484092116355896, -0.01830131746828556, 0.040071602910757065, -0.0012818307150155306, 0.012437567114830017, 0.0805378332734108, 0.011732201091945171, -0.003919224254786968, -0.004212523344904184, 0.0155952088534832, 0.00985441729426384, 0.0012518453877419233, -0.010609612800180912, -0.0666620060801506, -0.03205130249261856, 0.023098386824131012, 0.007059043273329735, -0.0527743361890316, -0.04531515762209892, -0.04256982356309891, -0.03295403718948364, -0.06853389739990234, 0.05670904368162155, -0.04256574437022209, -0.044419415295124054, 0.029055505990982056, 0.02918100915849209, 0.00399773707613349, -0.02557959593832493, 0.025028351694345474, -0.021807530894875526, 0.0374608151614666, -0.023612504824995995, 0.024792736396193504, 0.03082307055592537, 0.0380457378923893, 0.042097773402929306, -0.012985387817025185, 0.01248425804078579, 0.007494801189750433, 0.020510725677013397, 0.013309803791344166, 0.009254365228116512, 0.058881811797618866, 0.02738216333091259, -0.015878405421972275, 0.04790237918496132, -0.03539447486400604, -0.011136415414512157, -0.04958079755306244, 0.07705645263195038, -0.025758054107427597, 0.05441233143210411, 0.004415787290781736, 0.007503594271838665, -0.023470617830753326, -0.0368998683989048, -0.01768580824136734, -0.028521042317152023, -0.0437937006354332, 0.025633158162236214, -0.029678594321012497, -0.005172833800315857, -0.006703253369778395, 0.013331957161426544, -0.05970930680632591, 0.0010116553166881204, 0.0121269216760993, 0.0013884122017771006, -0.041014499962329865, -0.006932687480002642, 0.04986517131328583, -0.0071813263930380344, -0.06257085502147675, -0.03405950590968132, -0.004209562670439482, -0.0009561236947774887, 0.02618246152997017, 0.036009546369314194, -0.07211963832378387, -0.023628655821084976, 0.011187798343598843, -0.047539081424474716, 0.08088619261980057, -0.012530009262263775, 0.030530376359820366, -0.01352339331060648, 0.0029373024590313435, -0.0328642800450325, 0.005417452193796635, 0.000776285829488188, -0.007623170968145132, 0.016761615872383118, 0.027163734659552574, -0.03916928544640541, 0.025420740246772766, 0.02006329596042633, -0.05564451962709427, -0.0016074215527623892, -0.014333927072584629, 0.011943730525672436, 0.019168440252542496, 0.009983091615140438, 0.07972750812768936, -0.011424877680838108, -0.051156703382730484, -0.046169281005859375, 0.06000775098800659, 0.05054280906915665, -0.041515104472637177, 0.0048552220687270164, 0.049925293773412704, -0.07184738665819168, -0.03803402557969093, 0.005659222137182951, -0.020993977785110474, 0.012789910659193993, -0.00019806271302513778, -0.05957653746008873, -0.00007457524770870805, 0.0013181868707761168, 0.02938314527273178, 0.03019832633435726, 0.031213700771331787, 0.002947636879980564, 0.04529999569058418, -0.03192181512713432, -0.009295512922108173, 0.015070543624460697, -0.014150260016322136, 0.011872663162648678, -0.06270569562911987, -0.03704455867409706, -0.053613487631082535, 0.028661008924245834, 0.004390778485685587, -0.0068581984378397465, 0.022314684465527534, 0.019554954022169113, 0.01419088989496231, -0.062776580452919, 0.041909173130989075, 0.006570689845830202, 0.023114975541830063, -0.03167819604277611, -0.07398074865341187, 0.015169459395110607, 0.024998990818858147, -0.009790359996259212, -0.02389717288315296, 0.024358341470360756, -0.0128558911383152, 0.015169968828558922, 0.0007139600347727537, -0.09120974689722061, -0.020216936245560646, 0.044309087097644806, -0.002576724160462618, -0.06793852895498276, -0.04397779703140259, 0.020686356350779533, -0.003481476102024317, 0.008187992498278618, 0.01770726777613163, -0.06590919941663742, 0.001740155043080449, 0.075849749147892, 0.0065514943562448025, 0.0560927651822567, 0.020785687491297722, -0.07468655705451965, 0.0009628867846913636, -0.024262133985757828, 0.046830177307128906, 0.009390560910105705, -0.06411983072757721, 0.006285994313657284, -0.021347081288695335, 0.03861072659492493, 0.0010307824704796076, -0.04089110717177391, -0.06938253343105316, -0.046555276960134506, -0.015811631456017494, -0.0032122067641466856, 0.020435523241758347, 0.028017111122608185, 0.04895923286676407, -0.036912959069013596, -0.012234640307724476, 0.0217402633279562, 0.00376899354159832, 0.00866029690951109, 0.03370680287480354, 0.0011009086156263947, -0.05863271281123161, -0.0023483990225940943, 0.05051400512456894, -0.001666565891355276, -0.07085215300321579, -0.008491812273859978, 0.006210914812982082, -0.014627696946263313, -0.02452528104186058, -0.0075295064598321915, 0.022649653255939484, -0.0013123903190717101, 0.0575239397585392, 0.002340585459023714, 0.027772512286901474, 0.007474023383110762, 0.03940049931406975, 0.02629670314490795, 0.06211225315928459, -0.007987605407834053, 0.01434297114610672, 0.037590790539979935, 0.06513591855764389, 0.04549185186624527, -0.08237274736166, 0.04531406611204147, -0.025535261258482933, -0.009433863684535027, -0.03403487801551819, 0.020730923861265182, 0.05726202204823494, -0.02055330201983452, -0.027594195678830147, -0.021157190203666687, -0.05557180196046829, 0.006594961043447256, -0.0456247441470623, 0.01877794787287712, -0.006327382288873196, -0.006155789829790592, 0.056769028306007385, 0.0026854833122342825, 0.03945159912109375, 0.0039057759568095207, 0.010202313773334026, 0.0197061225771904, -0.0010128860594704747, 0.05721760541200638, -0.01791323721408844, 0.018915526568889618, 0.01319507323205471, 0.034156739711761475, -0.029536249116063118, 0.026354357600212097, -0.06902264803647995, 0.01555718295276165, 0.02887098677456379, -0.054359376430511475, 0.01984856091439724, -0.02781769447028637, -0.03218292444944382, -0.019965043291449547, 0.01024333480745554, 0.0034541557542979717, 0.017248623073101044, 0.027291210368275642, -0.02191666141152382, 0.01566210202872753, 0.00880368147045374, 0.006526927463710308, -0.024068918079137802, -0.022432565689086914, -0.007694564294070005, 0.00044283605529926717, -0.031953297555446625, 0.009032882750034332, -0.017865119501948357, 0.014653629623353481, -0.014452317729592323, 0.036036934703588486, 0.01240516733378172, 0.000884711800608784, 0.00543817738071084, 0.059438493102788925, 0.03200880438089371, -0.04656190425157547, -0.06242547929286957, -0.03910462185740471, 0.0028828298673033714, 0.03959083929657936, 0.04260129854083061, 0.012122806161642075, 0.024024730548262596, -0.0008701385813765228, 0.004507635720074177, 0.04186414182186127, -0.05121511593461037, 0.013265980407595634, 0.011365266516804695, -0.0892421305179596, -0.056267149746418, 0.052179623395204544, 0.07027977705001831, -0.022970393300056458, -0.01843339577317238, -0.03326604887843132, 0.05169951915740967, 0.0069137802347540855, 0.004421894438564777, 0.0191725492477417, 0.026989277452230453, 0.031107183545827866, 0.044731736183166504, -0.004587225615978241, 0.030368128791451454, 0.014593912288546562, -0.05551237240433693, 0.05740532651543617, -0.05064099654555321, -0.0038083463441580534, -0.03231096267700195, -0.0039016299415379763, 0.026068435981869698, 0.05283056199550629, -0.032252002507448196, -0.06553776562213898, 0.01122326124459505, -0.040684476494789124, -0.039571963250637054, 0.029798945412039757, 0.02534690499305725, 0.03631551191210747, 0.007311010267585516, -0.030710946768522263, 0.045312292873859406, -0.11767155677080154, -0.03267335891723633, -0.025023072957992554, 0.047003116458654404, -0.05194682627916336, 0.015383034013211727, -0.07219405472278595, 0.004834989085793495, 0.023750530555844307, -0.08254271745681763, 0.004950761795043945, -0.010082049295306206, -0.007605311460793018, -0.03153053671121597, 0.03624485060572624, -0.02596387453377247, 0.05533623322844505, -0.03423026204109192, -0.014126928523182869, -0.06374821811914444, -0.02620824985206127, 0.07455954700708389, 0.03712635487318039, -0.03133738413453102, 0.030544506385922432, 0.08744934946298599, 0.021036416292190552, -0.07221981883049011, 0.026572899892926216, -0.01360412035137415, -0.027515877038240433, -0.07131658494472504, 0.005164807662367821, 0.0390973836183548, 0.015111424960196018, -0.01552056148648262, -0.02379535511136055, 0.01494188979268074, 0.01540815457701683, 0.02417493611574173, -0.024371851235628128, -0.018648384138941765, 0.004959671758115292 ]
<p>I'm trying to understand precession for a gyroscope or top.</p> <p>I do understand why precession occurs using the vectors for the weight force and torque and angular momentum. But what I don't understand is why precession only occurs at high angular speeds. Looking at the different vectors, there should still be a resulting change in the top's angular momentum.</p> <p>I've tried to find an answer in my favorite physics textbook, but it only says that at lower angular speeds, the situation becomes much more complex. Which is not very helpful.</p> <p>Can anyone explain the basic idea why precession only occurs at high angular velocities. I don't need this for an exam or anything, so I don't require a detailed mathematical explanation. I just want to get the basic idea.</p>
g4015
[ 0.03941848501563072, 0.009274442680180073, 0.0007742394227534533, -0.014875946566462517, 0.06165288761258125, 0.00019665506260935217, 0.1079244315624237, 0.03468494862318039, -0.03883570432662964, -0.03518984839320183, -0.01412508636713028, -0.014960450120270252, 0.02930375188589096, -0.01850559003651142, 0.02908896468579769, 0.0018446518806740642, 0.017657868564128876, -0.010142325423657894, 0.08302796632051468, 0.013480058871209621, 0.012618358246982098, 0.01591707207262516, -0.02493825927376747, -0.05659877881407738, -0.0700228214263916, 0.009644024074077606, -0.028832392767071724, -0.02106224000453949, -0.03401940315961838, 0.0507800467312336, 0.0035201467107981443, -0.03565429896116257, 0.01587294042110443, -0.04892663657665253, 0.010143251158297062, -0.05192337930202484, 0.06501217186450958, 0.002670362824574113, -0.015310566872358322, -0.00867646187543869, 0.03219255059957504, -0.027230337262153625, -0.008442995138466358, -0.06564923375844955, 0.016961274668574333, 0.04913509637117386, -0.0037998235784471035, 0.001640942762605846, -0.0407048799097538, -0.010618248023092747, -0.027049217373132706, 0.04802274331450462, -0.012357786297798157, -0.010075504891574383, 0.0075317141599953175, 0.020960738882422447, 0.034568626433610916, 0.008321050554513931, 0.03542395681142807, 0.038995642215013504, 0.03302854672074318, -0.00048811823944561183, -0.011610155925154686, 0.02163139544427395, 0.0017331776907667518, -0.006005513481795788, -0.009945469908416271, -0.010085495188832283, 0.0613347664475441, -0.03494143486022949, 0.0004263747832737863, -0.019656190648674965, -0.036447782069444656, -0.059905942529439926, -0.013506341725587845, -0.036422453820705414, 0.03608086332678795, -0.04986113682389259, 0.009710479527711868, -0.012922598980367184, -0.04600650444626808, -0.0008128506015054882, -0.009692718274891376, 0.01800408400595188, 0.0434417799115181, -0.00844279583543539, 0.01572815515100956, 0.051499102264642715, 0.02725282683968544, 0.017068956047296524, 0.07810892909765244, 0.0031527504324913025, 0.05545162782073021, -0.0051430827006697655, -0.0796118900179863, -0.055353742092847824, -0.060998279601335526, 0.05563503876328468, 0.025167977437376976, -0.004883127752691507, -0.0029391052667051554, 0.003622648771852255, 0.014907905831933022, -0.026488732546567917, 0.021086737513542175, -0.024464668706059456, 0.020204752683639526, 0.02181113325059414, -0.021761203184723854, -0.02376280538737774, -0.006915987003594637, 0.008147863671183586, -0.03773346543312073, -0.012168940156698227, -0.048805031925439835, -0.042455874383449554, 0.10103551298379898, -0.0069336798042058945, -0.0028638860676437616, -0.018006088212132454, 0.0035397550091147423, 0.017036577686667442, -0.05239561200141907, 0.06555108726024628, -0.06698047369718552, 0.008259741589426994, 0.03220151737332344, 0.003610349725931883, 0.05628623440861702, 0.03009139560163021, 0.04677555710077286, 0.021269051358103752, 0.0176059752702713, 0.05966386944055557, 0.029704276472330093, 0.0045899031683802605, 0.01734914630651474, 0.010730477049946785, 0.03940119594335556, -0.0036655166186392307, 0.04809553176164627, -0.039814043790102005, 0.027839483693242073, -0.029634634032845497, 0.011348316445946693, -0.02661777473986149, 0.005413712467998266, 0.01580449566245079, 0.05212603136897087, -0.0154188247397542, 0.042517103254795074, 0.057783178985118866, -0.011858120560646057, -0.0462014265358448, 0.021699579432606697, 0.0006593532161787152, 0.015048377215862274, -0.02628215216100216, 0.06989984959363937, 0.04713865742087364, 0.06496154516935349, 0.011740561574697495, 0.029897622764110565, -0.003132350742816925, -0.05120155215263367, 0.027444345876574516, -0.05163109302520752, -0.009440040215849876, -0.02841229736804962, -0.04636145383119583, -0.0642942264676094, -0.05329843983054161, 0.029390571638941765, 0.08384119719266891, 0.044370487332344055, -0.016206877306103706, 0.036590706557035446, -0.05330165848135948, -0.019316529855132103, 0.013344239443540573, -0.07462119311094284, -0.033662788569927216, 0.05673464760184288, 0.01613306626677513, -0.006554516032338142, 0.05365421995520592, -0.04273466765880585, 0.051977552473545074, -0.11880689859390259, 0.0428260862827301, -0.04180830344557762, -0.030669691041111946, -0.00197730865329504, 0.012908543460071087, 0.02386745996773243, -0.038414064794778824, 0.048615552484989166, -0.04245436191558838, -0.07952874898910522, 0.0838450938463211, -0.009411390870809555, -0.028629405423998833, -0.003394852625206113, 0.050900984555482864, -0.02678203023970127, 0.0396837554872036, -0.043929506093263626, 0.017260784283280373, 0.0134812006726861, 0.01416913140565157, 0.010349960997700691, 0.0519866980612278, -0.0426066592335701, 0.03214899078011513, 0.0006623538210988045, 0.02852131612598896, -0.009166683070361614, 0.051815882325172424, -0.013212498277425766, 0.009178617037832737, -0.018577588722109795, -0.06627806276082993, -0.02562672086060047, 0.0187067948281765, -0.09010937809944153, 0.013013300485908985, -0.010881803929805756, -0.03923752158880234, -0.0003410395875107497, 0.005707209929823875, 0.0038823517970740795, 0.03323649987578392, -0.01408479642122984, -0.023215973749756813, 0.026119889691472054, 0.04872974753379822, 0.02856307663023472, 0.022359181195497513, 0.01177160069346428, 0.0016829438973218203, -0.01442757435142994, 0.009328910149633884, 0.012423381209373474, -0.05199268460273743, 0.024794038385152817, -0.07500988990068436, 0.04620242863893509, -0.01049108523875475, 0.023030420765280724, 0.021859101951122284, 0.02922273986041546, -0.06928578019142151, -0.011159506626427174, -0.024882858619093895, 0.0076454319059848785, 0.023296402767300606, 0.007331507280468941, 0.07025870680809021, -0.10424765199422836, -0.09520827978849411, -0.01659850962460041, 0.04799118638038635, 0.02200642228126526, 0.012533512897789478, -0.059393011033535004, 0.010613715276122093, -0.005069117993116379, 0.023528816178441048, -0.01447245478630066, -0.013406164012849331, -0.05368945375084877, 0.06175757199525833, -0.01078811939805746, 0.011108949780464172, -0.02893037721514702, -0.060992281883955, -0.0268786009401083, -0.016078567132353783, -0.01644383743405342, 0.03209645301103592, -0.06284114718437195, -0.003453322220593691, -0.012144905515015125, -0.028470657765865326, 0.06656736880540848, -0.004098253790289164, 0.013579512014985085, 0.037765685468912125, -0.05087394639849663, -0.017789464443922043, -0.03760646656155586, 0.009977101348340511, 0.023527882993221283, -0.07583784312009811, 0.042096834629774094, 0.025939712300896645, 0.04462184011936188, -0.010718335397541523, -0.054751068353652954, 0.0027533252723515034, -0.0033847750164568424, 0.033407554030418396, 0.04901333525776863, 0.022748569026589394, 0.023114129900932312, 0.009998263791203499, -0.004167725332081318, -0.018701065331697464, -0.051900748163461685, 0.03528939560055733, -0.03455629572272301, 0.03724798187613487, -0.006647312548011541, 0.0327729769051075, -0.06758587062358856, 0.0031625893898308277, -0.008294270373880863, 0.015051965601742268, -0.048900071531534195, 0.018361661583185196, -0.07926571369171143, -0.055988412350416183, -0.040768977254629135, -0.005045899655669928, 0.029817087575793266, 0.08302490413188934, -0.0074959672056138515, 0.008925029076635838, 0.034236568957567215, -0.052146341651678085, 0.05660839006304741, 0.036136701703071594, 0.006272817496210337, 0.044543057680130005, -0.04110822454094887, -0.009637851268053055, -0.005715268664062023, -0.00332569214515388, 0.025811051949858665, 0.034114543348550797, 0.024950075894594193, 0.005517883226275444, -0.03806859999895096, -0.013993981294333935, -0.029725322499871254, 0.03157775104045868, 0.04525528848171234, -0.011325251311063766, 0.012719699181616306, 0.003080114023759961, 0.047622378915548325, 0.007424785289913416, 0.01818348467350006, 0.0014256968861445785, -0.03203316777944565, 0.05247433856129646, -0.012204361148178577, -0.01725008152425289, 0.0094160046428442, -0.005882729310542345, 0.024346696212887764, 0.0005114926607348025, -0.026786448433995247, 0.03735245019197464, 0.00412259204313159, 0.017234086990356445, -0.002639937447384, 0.04288623481988907, -0.03382178023457527, 0.03673596307635307, 0.04993830993771553, -0.006490827538073063, -0.021217091009020805, -0.02726764604449272, 0.00619547488167882, -0.003932022489607334, 0.07999949157238007, 0.027897998690605164, 0.0720662772655487, -0.023306332528591156, 0.09774986654520035, 0.03016919642686844, -0.011829603463411331, -0.0312516912817955, -0.02212054282426834, -0.00791383907198906, -0.05331611633300781, 0.021802952513098717, -0.02920985221862793, -0.03911234065890312, 0.012588998302817345, -0.04118010029196739, 0.04135560616850853, 0.011371507309377193, 0.013628465123474598, -0.03234754502773285, 0.018163351342082024, 0.00818645115941763, -0.001069861464202404, 0.01759897731244564, -0.021008413285017014, 0.07945218682289124, -0.03627500310540199, -0.005830463021993637, 0.024142146110534668, 0.05421071499586105, -0.008489067666232586, -0.0018047544872388244, -0.019197965040802956, 0.011907688342034817, 0.04583410918712616, 0.04850437119603157, -0.0036634195130318403, -0.03694744408130646, -0.0009120317408815026, 0.04153280705213547, -0.009407514706254005, 0.03949996083974838, -0.02046087011694908, 0.021951956674456596, -0.012134222313761711, 0.0427955724298954, 0.04531684145331383, -0.022045373916625977, -0.0275193452835083, 0.022387119010090828, 0.018101917579770088, -0.0026146788150072098, 0.04185890033841133, 0.02907215617597103, 0.014066558331251144, -0.00590461865067482, -0.016037391498684883, -0.03574772924184799, -0.007415240630507469, 0.025781868025660515, 0.03912738338112831, 0.03013751097023487, -0.017958639189600945, -0.04218801483511925, 0.013270611874759197, 0.06425219029188156, 0.005599359981715679, -0.059315167367458344, -0.03671111911535263, 0.005151784047484398, -0.06990648061037064, 0.008549224585294724, -0.002727742772549391, -0.056626517325639725, -0.021281521767377853, 0.008996637538075447, -0.011405392549932003, -0.04272657632827759, -0.025759560987353325, -0.029825381934642792, -0.0054924702271819115, 0.027143215760588646, 0.0175273809581995, -0.01171725895255804, -0.04970056936144829, 0.060698799788951874, -0.03517189621925354, -0.028229910880327225, 0.010244875214993954, 0.03628941997885704, -0.005426456220448017, -0.010948553681373596, 0.018358608707785606, -0.04877208173274994, 0.005860096774995327, -0.04304772615432739, -0.022541115060448647, 0.04624103382229805, 0.0016402986366301775, 0.06211208552122116, 0.009089157916605473, -0.010116671212017536, 0.02284739725291729, 0.010225928388535976, 0.0020837667398154736, 0.01416565477848053, 0.030902821570634842, -0.0382637158036232, -0.03158019855618477, -0.08260182291269302, -0.012298338115215302, -0.07594837248325348, 0.027813473716378212, -0.044397518038749695, -0.0027724069077521563, 0.058047667145729065, -0.006948818918317556, -0.043981071561574936, 0.03500249609351158, 0.04241883009672165, 0.026643922552466393, -0.04043491557240486, -0.05435832589864731, -0.0395464189350605, -0.059642646461725235, -0.03381700813770294, -0.006682136561721563, -0.0228726789355278, 0.0436975471675396, 0.04836595430970192, 0.04558662325143814, 0.040955230593681335, 0.026478441432118416, 0.05569438636302948, -0.05023634433746338, 0.03860614821314812, -0.008775468915700912, 0.02299726940691471, -0.03210930898785591, -0.03761817514896393, 0.03178049996495247, -0.03196202591061592, 0.02535693161189556, 0.0021310127340257168, 0.0026001445949077606, -0.038560573011636734, 0.01732642762362957, -0.05020367354154587, -0.014120439998805523, 0.02986285835504532, -0.04583979398012161, -0.032481599599123, 0.03597985580563545, 0.020761147141456604, 0.005080598406493664, -0.03404507786035538, 0.04435882717370987, 0.009822550229728222, 0.015144173055887222, -0.035632964223623276, 0.048092447221279144, -0.06398211419582367, 0.04497530311346054, 0.0013096473412588239, -0.0314740315079689, -0.0005171934026293457, -0.0024096297565847635, 0.03119870461523533, -0.03086855821311474, -0.0038906079716980457, -0.011763145215809345, 0.002117064781486988, 0.05299198254942894, 0.004069884307682514, -0.053580813109874725, 0.044117577373981476, 0.026683291420340538, -0.059377629309892654, -0.0756978690624237, 0.04430018365383148, -0.017882799729704857, -0.028406886383891106, -0.000630894850473851, -0.04960256442427635, 0.05825721472501755, 0.008557835593819618, 0.0902009829878807, 0.011611961759626865, 0.025146793574094772, -0.07072611153125763, -0.02307693287730217, 0.011753721162676811, 0.03455205261707306, 0.08706654608249664, -0.0398898608982563, -0.016753530129790306, -0.09093646705150604, 0.01806114800274372, 0.07904888689517975, 0.06281120330095291, -0.016996955499053, -0.0085669606924057, -0.07112368196249008, -0.03820421174168587, 0.025607625022530556, 0.018120314925909042, 0.01567911170423031, -0.023786697536706924, -0.023362793028354645, -0.04685892537236214, -0.05165718495845795, 0.016438646242022514, 0.03073633275926113, -0.029351240023970604, 0.004048305097967386, 0.039438288658857346, -0.04458223283290863, -0.020105162635445595, -0.039345163851976395, 0.004349060822278261, 0.0032630576752126217, 0.041051894426345825, -0.010779837146401405, 0.014415722340345383, 0.07813429832458496, -0.03142346814274788, 0.03793184459209442, 0.04395651817321777, -0.010585829615592957, 0.030171571299433708, -0.003849641652777791, 0.003853058209642768, 0.02372417226433754, 0.05594190955162048, 0.009432369843125343, 0.010963491164147854, -0.03298664838075638, -0.025383641943335533, -0.04789980873465538, 0.01716899871826172, 0.017451277002692223, 0.03650641813874245, -0.006184600759297609, -0.0222342386841774, 0.0213699359446764, -0.0008175328839570284, 0.04313758388161659, 0.03800687938928604, -0.010923173278570175, -0.03115507774055004, 0.007246428169310093, 0.08668412268161774, 0.05175043269991875, 0.03175254911184311, -0.0073034074157476425, -0.02851416915655136, -0.0299716517329216, 0.007817047648131847, -0.0019048303365707397, 0.028852613642811775, -0.04533742740750313, 0.03954751044511795, 0.006981660611927509, 0.057315003126859665, 0.04815896973013878, -0.01577751152217388, -0.03516555204987526, 0.007092809304594994, 0.019761087372899055, -0.010822419077157974, -0.03178827837109566, -0.008051673881709576, -0.0030335632618516684, 0.013746416196227074, -0.004644137341529131, -0.026516301557421684, 0.015815677121281624, -0.0030970685184001923, 0.005888442508876324, -0.005616100039333105, 0.03588198497891426, 0.015292461961507797, 0.0131378173828125, 0.02289067953824997, -0.02488546445965767, 0.016470562666654587, -0.028101645410060883, 0.04375774413347244, -0.07515399158000946, 0.019223008304834366, 0.018712013959884644, -0.05882251635193825, 0.007947440259158611, -0.0009783869609236717, -0.046940479427576065, -0.015013198368251324, -0.024443920701742172, -0.03762491047382355, -0.020773369818925858, -0.03173258900642395, -0.07357287406921387, -0.05205534026026726, -0.0322895385324955, -0.0027384725399315357, -0.0310160331428051, 0.059210404753685, -0.0008764780941419303, 0.07220625877380371, -0.045499756932258606, 0.023552697151899338, -0.02256711944937706, -0.008324851281940937, -0.029399173334240913, -0.051051851361989975, -0.04093312472105026, 0.03519502282142639, 0.0169853325933218, -0.0008577057742513716, -0.002311242977157235, -0.017425647005438805, 0.015521322377026081, 0.01901227794587612, -0.04966874420642853, -0.0062825558707118034, -0.0049737500958144665, -0.04112029820680618, -0.008807577192783356, 0.05892961472272873, 0.03476785868406296, 0.0356280691921711, 0.0035677067935466766, 0.005601207725703716, -0.04082537442445755, 0.011211737990379333, -0.047276295721530914, 0.021814655512571335, 0.06377986073493958, -0.036402665078639984, -0.014835342764854431, -0.01732983998954296, -0.021830540150403976, -0.002091526286676526, -0.04233061149716377, -0.010599936358630657, -0.04430992901325226, -0.029149478301405907, 0.018186084926128387, -0.023685960099101067, -0.0761587992310524, -0.0772080346941948, -0.04296767711639404, -0.008577433414757252, 0.034252796322107315, 0.013475566171109676, 0.032485876232385635, 0.003794643562287092, -0.01646866649389267, 0.0007925998070277274, -0.00316723738797009, 0.06381256878376007, 0.01615401916205883, -0.03879241272807121, -0.021284710615873337, 0.015862032771110535, 0.03536219522356987, -0.06344515085220337, 0.01145224366337061, -0.003870398737490177, -0.02473706379532814, 0.014082217589020729, 0.03733843192458153, -0.019738487899303436, -0.01402909867465496, -0.018517648801207542, -0.022036390379071236, 0.035166721791028976, -0.018604442477226257, 0.005403866525739431, -0.054071929305791855, 0.04113718867301941, -0.002392667345702648, 0.04195031151175499, -0.038574110716581345, -0.06002696976065636, -0.024300329387187958, 0.003063679439947009, 0.010687307454645634, -0.020068705081939697, 0.005099388770759106, -0.0681368038058281, -0.10210868716239929, -0.0010968282585963607 ]
<p>In scattering theory, P wave means $l=1$, where $l$ is the azimuthal quantum number. However, what does P wave mean when referring to particle states? For example, in <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/9208254" rel="nofollow">this paper</a> (arXiv link), the authors are talking about <em>P-wave charmonia states</em>. What does that mean?</p> <p>More specifically, I understand that in some sort of potential model, solved using Schroedinger equation for example, there will be states that may be labeled by $n$=something, $l=1$. But here, the article says P-''wave'' charmonia! What is this wave?</p>
g4016
[ -0.03263495862483978, 0.05634191259741783, -0.01800919696688652, -0.001562947523780167, 0.05649004876613617, 0.019639423117041588, -0.01026689913123846, 0.040260810405015945, 0.08523397147655487, -0.025640208274126053, -0.05304490029811859, 0.015739595517516136, 0.040558941662311554, -0.005362480878829956, -0.0010166546562686563, -0.07006528973579407, 0.05644841864705086, 0.02600685879588127, 0.015428532846271992, -0.012267323210835457, -0.013555432669818401, 0.008909632451832294, -0.05445553734898567, -0.04601452499628067, -0.0009742421098053455, 0.03200441226363182, -0.03721393644809723, -0.035569049417972565, 0.03113248199224472, -0.04085183143615723, 0.02847900055348873, -0.04518294334411621, 0.00791190192103386, -0.03533964604139328, -0.021160919219255447, 0.029827691614627838, 0.03621729463338852, -0.037356115877628326, 0.015642009675502777, 0.008790730498731136, -0.008306321687996387, -0.00414024293422699, -0.020292388275265694, -0.007682102732360363, 0.0037136273458600044, 0.021102767437696457, -0.0082909120246768, 0.03596392273902893, -0.020907191559672356, 0.006863676477223635, 0.012475037947297096, -0.017439458519220352, 0.11308655887842178, 0.006746504455804825, 0.03400125354528427, -0.006853747181594372, 0.023460013791918755, -0.03492925688624382, 0.0730651393532753, 0.03670499846339226, 0.06273102015256882, 0.055173978209495544, -0.0037315746303647757, 0.0018587644444778562, 0.05168991535902023, 0.01671319268643856, -0.052200790494680405, -0.033562734723091125, -0.03971334546804428, 0.03243009001016617, 0.02240527980029583, -0.07269862294197083, -0.04040154442191124, -0.06398894637823105, -0.03588046878576279, 0.03627798333764076, -0.022607773542404175, -0.01579917035996914, 0.03372654318809509, 0.0046140155754983425, 0.0656139999628067, -0.009363610297441483, -0.002526136813685298, -0.03265869617462158, 0.04229830205440521, 0.01439584605395794, -0.0316200815141201, -0.028556860983371735, -0.03705132380127907, -0.0007412679260596633, 0.011546691879630089, -0.026924120262265205, 0.050090890377759933, -0.013208558782935143, -0.03969960659742355, 0.0029254902619868517, -0.027665553614497185, 0.01286192424595356, -0.038202881813049316, 0.011205893941223621, -0.05402024835348129, 0.02497686631977558, 0.002883824286982417, -0.05368391051888466, 0.04881621524691582, 0.04624544829130173, -0.031166555359959602, -0.02338741347193718, -0.013953553512692451, -0.050447262823581696, -0.04614361748099327, 0.005380608607083559, 0.02000490389764309, -0.006919488776475191, -0.10556768625974655, -0.06678241491317749, 0.04188577085733414, 0.010776279494166374, 0.028298886492848396, 0.05641629546880722, 0.04734203219413757, 0.021006276831030846, 0.02159273810684681, 0.09059233218431473, 0.021153677254915237, 0.0002030860196100548, -0.022281307727098465, -0.050409164279699326, 0.007637904491275549, 0.012234244495630264, 0.03349943086504936, 0.01286445651203394, -0.03467508405447006, 0.029859978705644608, -0.045411545783281326, 0.023278484120965004, -0.01149313896894455, -0.009579436853528023, 0.015326743945479393, -0.03966164216399193, 0.008675927296280861, 0.007856360636651516, 0.06071372702717781, 0.010087631642818451, 0.00817656610161066, -0.0291272085160017, 0.013025023974478245, -0.06382015347480774, 0.007754893973469734, -0.018282204866409302, 0.03593667596578598, 0.03375343978404999, 0.021641355007886887, -0.07328242808580399, 0.03443733975291252, 0.0035843858495354652, 0.036133598536252975, -0.005329101346433163, -0.06275435537099838, 0.017558932304382324, 0.06337418407201767, 0.04832315817475319, -0.04200289770960808, 0.018595339730381966, -0.04549785703420639, -0.0059641627594828606, 0.039945088326931, -0.04856967180967331, -0.06173863261938095, -0.035389307886362076, 0.035897091031074524, 0.022504746913909912, -0.005916434805840254, 0.025729315355420113, -0.036564260721206665, 0.0445757694542408, -0.014233073219656944, 0.016479332000017166, 0.013421723619103432, -0.025260303169488907, -0.012716337107121944, -0.006103829946368933, -0.02407766878604889, 0.029958296567201614, 0.009590637870132923, -0.0038931516464799643, -0.03291924670338631, -0.01067580096423626, 0.006574629805982113, -0.03535767272114754, -0.01939455047249794, 0.014812297187745571, 0.03923521935939789, 0.05681503191590309, 0.008888128213584423, 0.018168361857533455, 0.0030977854039520025, -0.05211186781525612, -0.052680328488349915, -0.028757037594914436, -0.01096276380121708, -0.0212088655680418, 0.01727784052491188, 0.011437921784818172, 0.04132001847028732, 0.0002333328011445701, -0.0073426272720098495, 0.027456331998109818, -0.022100379690527916, 0.010416227392852306, -0.020808639004826546, -0.06823495030403137, 0.0037322454154491425, 0.06155901774764061, -0.004128153435885906, -0.03317538648843765, 0.0018393064383417368, 0.032904066145420074, -0.01689206436276436, -0.0022762019652873278, -0.018499312922358513, -0.021783169358968735, 0.09391900151968002, 0.025859296321868896, 0.04005157947540283, 0.10334168374538422, -0.0025911820121109486, 0.03586774319410324, 0.018335392698645592, 0.035028308629989624, -0.04063275083899498, 0.011376219801604748, -0.04402538761496544, 0.0039988732896745205, 0.01541264820843935, 0.008461437188088894, -0.003061957424506545, 0.018419109284877777, 0.0021286120172590017, -0.014164384454488754, -0.04598299786448479, -0.04098695144057274, -0.024048004299402237, 0.025019526481628418, 0.007223926484584808, 0.03113148733973503, 0.025173967704176903, 0.01440868154168129, -0.07466917484998703, -0.03526484966278076, 0.04192277416586876, -0.03552505746483803, -0.026074066758155823, 0.04532554745674133, 0.04377936199307442, -0.03889302909374237, -0.02487807534635067, 0.03157050162553787, -0.030258728191256523, -0.005717332940548658, -0.000787711760494858, 0.014202448539435863, -0.002998966723680496, -0.020195646211504936, 0.024263588711619377, -0.031999580562114716, 0.010082215070724487, 0.042218029499053955, -0.027357274666428566, -0.07047446817159653, -0.01615758426487446, 0.09426478296518326, 0.0068323248997330666, -0.026990443468093872, 0.014576946385204792, -0.08802609145641327, -0.024578047916293144, -0.03654101490974426, 0.007557541131973267, -0.01977006532251835, -0.04607786610722542, 0.03659273684024811, -0.031639061868190765, 0.0196217093616724, 0.04575956240296364, -0.093898244202137, 0.07518944144248962, 0.008788765408098698, 0.01727730967104435, 0.0033447970636188984, 0.06030207499861717, 0.011415094137191772, -0.0028416141867637634, -0.04866442829370499, -0.0007317943382076919, 0.031538352370262146, 0.014803181402385235, -0.03341842070221901, 0.055158909410238266, 0.03806058689951897, 0.002357591176405549, -0.021274711936712265, -0.022503191605210304, -0.003776234108954668, 0.05952748656272888, 0.06292612105607986, -0.08077175915241241, -0.012273034080862999, -0.043486203998327255, 0.04769957810640335, -0.03742239624261856, 0.08471551537513733, -0.020050745457410812, 0.01527781505137682, -0.011716343462467194, 0.060700900852680206, -0.08159072697162628, -0.004287827759981155, -0.048500724136829376, -0.015906473621726036, -0.02108008973300457, -0.036314528435468674, 0.02163008041679859, -0.032491229474544525, 0.01956011727452278, -0.031479667872190475, -0.048958633095026016, 0.020032409578561783, -0.04498423635959625, -0.06304872035980225, -0.009075643494725227, -0.017451591789722443, -0.03390349820256233, -0.011021225713193417, 0.04574524983763695, -0.05759084224700928, -0.0005550714558921754, 0.01426759921014309, 0.08593662828207016, 0.024984221905469894, 0.04663806036114693, -0.011997055262327194, 0.00023418590717483312, 0.020152343437075615, 0.0620637871325016, 0.006926081608980894, -0.013743411749601364, -0.009979489259421825, -0.023945456370711327, -0.004748133011162281, 0.00747260544449091, 0.055940963327884674, 0.007046005222946405, -0.034309349954128265, -0.019298745319247246, 0.016433777287602425, 0.005009890533983707, -0.008429727517068386, 0.016626788303256035, 0.06282855570316315, 0.029969966039061546, -0.02622556872665882, -0.014456531032919884, -0.016964444890618324, 0.0014304184587672353, 0.006036015227437019, -0.009268046356737614, -0.06181863322854042, 0.026364468038082123, -0.07081642001867294, -0.040323592722415924, -0.01887623406946659, 0.04892461746931076, 0.022555632516741753, -0.05099322646856308, 0.019031794741749763, -0.04942663758993149, -0.013092945329844952, -0.027300285175442696, -0.007778793573379517, -0.017778243869543076, 0.010490722954273224, 0.03121946193277836, 0.039816513657569885, 0.007231151685118675, 0.04468241333961487, -0.014847463928163052, 0.009543929249048233, 0.008608163334429264, 0.0057650282979011536, 0.06181129813194275, -0.06368754059076309, -0.022236276417970657, 0.018012244254350662, 0.0693170502781868, 0.011178742162883282, 0.0010065826354548335, -0.06729830801486969, -0.008903468027710915, 0.08380867540836334, 0.011068769730627537, 0.0011106581659987569, 0.0244978629052639, -0.04418914392590523, 0.02868841215968132, -0.002518904162570834, 0.037742581218481064, -0.03874588757753372, -0.052313655614852905, -0.011377758346498013, -0.03777109459042549, 0.08664893358945847, -0.008504228666424751, -0.04643979296088219, -0.021337419748306274, 0.05036243423819542, -0.031864527612924576, -0.0670936331152916, -0.011248689144849777, 0.06741157919168472, 0.024710852652788162, 0.06779225170612335, 0.011712758801877499, 0.008939909748733044, -0.05720439925789833, 0.02560560032725334, 0.015564902685582638, 0.019454549998044968, -0.04971698299050331, -0.04526175186038017, 0.020563388243317604, 0.07752355188131332, 0.007258275523781776, 0.010293432511389256, -0.07532111555337906, 0.003398347645998001, -0.04510087892413139, 0.023585490882396698, 0.05307513475418091, -0.014037394896149635, 0.06210936978459358, 0.01478295587003231, -0.007628965191543102, 0.0318891815841198, 0.000625959481112659, -0.00000486493672724464, -0.031524691730737686, -0.03036329708993435, -0.01609645038843155, -0.03933743014931679, -0.08641701191663742, 0.02229061722755432, -0.011942563578486443, -0.0844917967915535, 0.03070424124598503, -0.015363733284175396, 0.011324179358780384, 0.03724357858300209, -0.015022660605609417, 0.03346081078052521, -0.047197360545396805, 0.0011342618381604552, 0.023781824856996536, 0.00616588955745101, 0.048389893025159836, -0.005982080474495888, -0.0327504500746727, -0.0017301123589277267, -0.06607323884963989, 0.011728719808161259, -0.009485634043812752, -0.06196602061390877, 0.005661190487444401, -0.027521241456270218, 0.00022626935970038176, 0.023989425972104073, 0.0038977591320872307, 0.02066141553223133, -0.03043110854923725, -0.02847982570528984, 0.007848202250897884, -0.02310989983379841, -0.01946510560810566, -0.04163980111479759, -0.018940502777695656, 0.036552608013153076, -0.02067410573363304, 0.030444588512182236, -0.02568700909614563, 0.012449191883206367, 0.0031863704789429903, -0.05115160718560219, -0.022300314158201218, -0.00898447260260582, 0.01244702935218811, -0.03495808318257332, 0.02946852520108223, -0.043436042964458466, 0.013728439807891846, 0.043724168092012405, -0.02520778775215149, -0.04409445822238922, 0.07211964577436447, -0.02416474185883999, -0.05661885812878609, 0.018408585339784622, 0.04079718142747879, -0.022262031212449074, 0.011651353910565376, -0.06122154742479324, 0.04933687672019005, -0.013814154081046581, -0.03950614482164383, -0.030035480856895447, 0.010683632455766201, -0.03947017714381218, -0.04673010855913162, 0.04943236708641052, -0.0407356433570385, 0.05972451716661453, -0.015660462900996208, 0.04560127854347229, 0.00924649741500616, -0.05273345485329628, -0.007208269089460373, 0.0051247659139335155, -0.010282128117978573, -0.025568120181560516, 0.06558854132890701, 0.031642261892557144, 0.0030979213770478964, 0.055227261036634445, 0.05250776931643486, 0.05230909585952759, 0.03151686117053032, -0.03682301938533783, -0.014380627311766148, 0.012550628744065762, 0.05230199918150902, 0.05628019943833351, -0.05233907327055931, -0.029901133850216866, 0.00842192955315113, 0.07076628506183624, 0.010210450738668442, 0.011346215382218361, 0.00011449814337538555, 0.00568469800055027, -0.019512487575411797, 0.0038713652174919844, -0.017468806356191635, -0.008708782494068146, 0.005997130647301674, -0.06600181013345718, 0.05253620818257332, 0.01414788980036974, 0.0027927677147090435, -0.021217385306954384, -0.03550945594906807, -0.02681310474872589, 0.004736125934869051, 0.017804717645049095, 0.010797151364386082, -0.01768995262682438, -0.01183860283344984, 0.03400873765349388, -0.030677640810608864, 0.00011184936010977253, -0.0012214359594509006, 0.015892954543232918, -0.027262788265943527, -0.014680393040180206, -0.01927938684821129, -0.0051969727501273155, -0.021416625007987022, -0.003220981452614069, 0.03159867972135544, -0.07505272328853607, -0.057725101709365845, 0.012818431481719017, -0.012275654822587967, 0.003955019172281027, -0.0020306408405303955, 0.009861721657216549, 0.003410517470911145, 0.06913336366415024, -0.023686248809099197, -0.07077077031135559, 0.05615941807627678, 0.03916969522833824, -0.04046841338276863, -0.028477229177951813, -0.02559038996696472, 0.029456982389092445, -0.03854498267173767, 0.03838492929935455, 0.021162526682019234, 0.05836107209324837, -0.030573779717087746, -0.0002437936345813796, 0.04780081659555435, -0.007195173297077417, -0.006141421850770712, 0.031355928629636765, 0.041385795921087265, 0.0573207251727581, -0.0214997511357069, -0.03173571452498436, -0.027398113161325455, 0.019887655973434448, 0.009231683798134327, 0.030428020283579826, -0.007210966665297747, -0.051038697361946106, 0.016909409314393997, -0.047707341611385345, -0.026914848014712334, -0.00048301470815204084, -0.03988496959209442, -0.01012082863599062, 0.021575098857283592, -0.021507948637008667, -0.0033930425997823477, 0.05817136913537979, 0.05622340738773346, 0.07125542312860489, -0.004810648504644632, -0.0179764237254858, 0.01704273372888565, -0.011222300119698048, 0.00017806512187235057, -0.03169719874858856, 0.02719004638493061, 0.04765738919377327, -0.015686597675085068, -0.009779969230294228, -0.02535771206021309, -0.02835663966834545, 0.057259075343608856, 0.040052782744169235, -0.02039456181228161, 0.02965119667351246, 0.05382610112428665, -0.04435613751411438, -0.07890036702156067, 0.010738277807831764, 0.00046650582225993276, -0.00015981118485797197, -0.03875870630145073, -0.03759918734431267, -0.007343895733356476, -0.005554998759180307, -0.05328011512756348, -0.02182457596063614, 0.011492928490042686, -0.009485864080488682, 0.030254855751991272, 0.03737133741378784, -0.062476251274347305, -0.04836355894804001, 0.01796196587383747, -0.04768434166908264, -0.019849000498652458, 0.04593835026025772, 0.005330413114279509, 0.02744128368794918, -0.018436796963214874, -0.03908378258347511, 0.0186568982899189, -0.03730388730764389, -0.01940876990556717, -0.05323154851794243, -0.036954429000616074, -0.021861640736460686, -0.03865748643875122, 0.0761389210820198, -0.0022176846396178007, 0.026953205466270447, -0.020663097500801086, -0.06975585222244263, 0.037116456776857376, 0.04035007581114769, 0.0014663204783573747, 0.003653373569250107, -0.010121614672243595, 0.021750669926404953, 0.0003991747507825494, 0.028423821553587914, -0.015884840860962868, -0.009529449976980686, 0.05112463980913162, -0.03797490522265434, 0.015871500596404076, -0.05245327949523926, 0.001844183774664998, 0.01669744774699211, 0.04644622653722763, 0.07938909530639648, -0.013208177872002125, -0.008124470710754395, -0.0021145069040358067, -0.0403069332242012, -0.004311835393309593, 0.04446788504719734, 0.031525734812021255, -0.0672108456492424, -0.0004130741290282458, 0.0025030572433024645, 0.0012939556036144495, -0.010351784527301788, -0.07216349244117737, -0.014340866357088089, 0.031595632433891296, 0.025444870814681053, 0.012758448719978333, 0.08132446557283401, 0.044484686106443405, 0.029945222660899162, -0.029379406943917274, 0.041235923767089844, 0.00876929983496666, 0.05441226437687874, 0.021692387759685516, -0.00041143293492496014, 0.03652383014559746, -0.026110710576176643, 0.01640416495501995, 0.04156289994716644, 0.028963429853320122, -0.006485734134912491, -0.05528629943728447, 0.03836526721715927, -0.06511260569095612, 0.07960527390241623, 0.0005292671266943216, 0.04005846008658409, 0.0067708780989050865, -0.012299471534788609, 0.049860142171382904, -0.012273040600121021, 0.052435312420129776, -0.00006118722376413643, 0.046064529567956924, -0.0362110435962677, -0.018467310816049576, -0.02673974633216858, -0.002832928439602256, 0.013420265167951584, 0.05448009818792343, 0.0021944765467196703, -0.025176841765642166, 0.02565639466047287, 0.01747027412056923, 0.04713119566440582, -0.005386998411267996, -0.005766391288489103, 0.053238533437252045, -0.034396879374980927, 0.03139535337686539, -0.06765660643577576, 0.02367418259382248, -0.012012780643999577, 0.021522628143429756, 0.027072124183177948, -0.02803819626569748, -0.08448127657175064, -0.03034125454723835, -0.02318839728832245 ]
<p>Following Kepler's publication of his <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kepler%27s_laws_of_planetary_motion#Third_law">3rd law of planetary motion</a><sup>1</sup>, </p> <p>$$p^2 / r^3 = 1$$</p> <p>in 1619, it would have been possible to use telescopic observations to arrive at an estimate of the orbital radii the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moons_of_Jupiter#Discovery">Jovian moons observed</a> by Galileo 1610, expressed in Earth orbital radii.<sup>2</sup> Along with the observed periods of the moons, these radii could have been used in a Jovian version Kepler's formula to discover that (at least for Io, Europa, and Callisto<sup>3</sup>)</p> <p>$$p^2 / r^3 \approx 1.053 \times 10^3$$</p> <p>or as close as telescopic technology of the day would allow.</p> <p>Did anyone at the time take this, or a similar approach, to arrive at the conclusion that there is an attribute the Sun and Jupiter in which they differ by a factor of approximately a thousand? That attribute, of course, turns out to be mass.</p> <p>Did Kepler, Galileo, or any of their contemporaries perform this calculation in the early 1600s? If not, why?</p> <hr> <p><sup>1. For $p$ in Earth years and $r$ in Earth orbital radii (today's AU).<br/> 2. Applying trigonometry to the observed angular extent of the moons' orbits and the distance to Jupiter.<br/> 3. Ganymede produces a slightly different value.</sup></p>
g4017
[ -0.03319195285439491, 0.010499315336346626, -0.001184075023047626, 0.008235663175582886, -0.007248076144605875, 0.047211602330207825, 0.02686668001115322, -0.019094975665211678, 0.02679314650595188, 0.02839227020740509, 0.02614934742450714, 0.0020616459660232067, 0.05019063130021095, -0.04553122818470001, 0.007109000347554684, -0.01706361025571823, 0.08759983628988266, 0.00006057368955225684, 0.06070622429251671, 0.046017203480005264, 0.019098946824669838, -0.021877070888876915, -0.059129394590854645, -0.0039576273411512375, -0.007335206959396601, -0.027213452383875847, -0.007650280836969614, -0.01311304047703743, -0.05999968945980072, 0.011264575645327568, 0.0008846131386235356, -0.02966264821588993, 0.01690272055566311, -0.03879394754767418, 0.040584664791822433, 0.015044125728309155, -0.0011970122577622533, -0.004599773790687323, -0.04481549561023712, 0.003432963276281953, -0.05419546738266945, -0.0413568839430809, 0.008192313835024834, 0.08720522373914719, 0.010960407555103302, -0.008409231901168823, -0.04819086566567421, -0.04719820246100426, 0.041518304497003555, -0.03258165344595909, -0.015567309223115444, 0.09531891345977783, 0.030119648203253746, -0.01379577349871397, 0.018160687759518623, 0.07445354759693146, -0.007143715396523476, -0.04231923073530197, 0.008192101493477821, 0.0030119020957499743, 0.019091492518782616, -0.02954365313053131, -0.009009159170091152, 0.004587422125041485, 0.05679091066122055, 0.029621737077832222, 0.006664494518190622, 0.07567528635263443, -0.002778746886178851, 0.004622714128345251, 0.02773921936750412, 0.008267982862889767, -0.0009682720410637558, -0.05406384915113449, -0.06817920506000519, -0.00893278419971466, 0.012372561730444431, -0.024791400879621506, 0.001668624929152429, 0.04184352979063988, 0.011869053356349468, -0.015016269870102406, -0.003958669025450945, 0.0013218593085184693, 0.00027772021712735295, -0.03551775589585304, 0.0008447399013675749, 0.0452030785381794, -0.010952593758702278, 0.08174760639667511, -0.004225393291562796, 0.061466023325920105, 0.025624340400099754, 0.012923710979521275, -0.011421366594731808, -0.027024827897548676, 0.020670529454946518, 0.056625064462423325, -0.04659576341509819, 0.03591589629650116, 0.018741436302661896, 0.029177486896514893, 0.022119078785181046, 0.023292796686291695, 0.04728895053267479, -0.0008070397307164967, 0.09418818354606628, -0.024176456034183502, 0.024562213569879532, -0.005592461209744215, -0.054511141031980515, -0.032944176346063614, 0.060981087386608124, -0.040182579308748245, 0.0027543234173208475, -0.019373947754502296, -0.031939875334501266, -0.023285340517759323, 0.031644921749830246, 0.05027056485414505, -0.026761740446090698, -0.029694724828004837, -0.0061850049532949924, 0.11663287878036499, -0.001905137556605041, -0.003358324756845832, 0.019645292311906815, -0.00888241920620203, 0.03438505530357361, -0.05734493210911751, -0.07636061310768127, 0.05685809254646301, -0.003790027927607298, 0.008391852490603924, -0.019593417644500732, 0.04407058656215668, -0.04065911844372749, -0.0005286156665533781, -0.053343091160058975, 0.023865342140197754, 0.016270067542791367, -0.0030818330124020576, 0.03936585783958435, -0.019931087270379066, -0.0076450505293905735, 0.03518039733171463, -0.052251145243644714, -0.021945619955658913, 0.03791012614965439, 0.0608576200902462, 0.01181382592767477, 0.01305710431188345, 0.07512986660003662, -0.025774477049708366, -0.03237038850784302, -0.03457485884428024, -0.057518817484378815, 0.03177101910114288, -0.06665295362472534, 0.03745409846305847, 0.021710943430662155, -0.007902238517999649, -0.020022127777338028, 0.05195792019367218, -0.0852898359298706, 0.02997596189379692, 0.02145257405936718, -0.057838186621665955, -0.0038830453995615244, -0.050155431032180786, -0.06161485239863396, -0.009248144924640656, -0.014047587290406227, -0.014388605952262878, -0.06864084303379059, 0.03263320401310921, 0.03003530204296112, -0.05444755405187607, 0.002133062807843089, 0.018412930890917778, 0.021656960248947144, -0.015272310003638268, -0.03243216872215271, 0.002033696509897709, -0.05570962652564049, -0.027584537863731384, 0.039059363305568695, -0.05826825648546219, -0.03184717521071434, 0.013254471123218536, -0.0470535084605217, 0.005644390359520912, 0.013985568657517433, -0.015074917115271091, -0.011579707264900208, -0.009464342147111893, 0.01129433885216713, -0.005831151735037565, -0.06057842820882797, 0.09151679277420044, -0.008238270878791809, 0.022544322535395622, -0.0032634909730404615, 0.00818390678614378, -0.04366695508360863, -0.003635464934632182, 0.06874531507492065, -0.010486387647688389, 0.02771933563053608, 0.008441130630671978, -0.05569453909993172, 0.03925217315554619, -0.01867956854403019, 0.04885423183441162, -0.06373968720436096, 0.008922618813812733, -0.015444413758814335, 0.005404862575232983, 0.05151228606700897, -0.02542540244758129, -0.034406568855047226, 0.011716360226273537, 0.0931495651602745, -0.006803506053984165, 0.03205109015107155, -0.015712400898337364, -0.041292767971754074, 0.040422987192869186, 0.041189566254615784, 0.014387582428753376, 0.008141531608998775, -0.022937368601560593, -0.0508669875562191, 0.03629201278090477, 0.006798983551561832, 0.055853471159935, 0.0001273719681194052, -0.0907353013753891, 0.01978089101612568, 0.019086482003331184, 0.04392048344016075, -0.013791744597256184, -0.03281677886843681, -0.00814991444349289, 0.02168634533882141, -0.053759217262268066, -0.013779959641397, -0.007813322357833385, -0.03693778067827225, 0.05833768472075462, -0.01427270844578743, 0.020643560215830803, -0.03893151879310608, -0.0035215553361922503, -0.02913709357380867, 0.02114918828010559, -0.011774715967476368, 0.018558643758296967, -0.08377615362405777, 0.04559381678700447, -0.02307823672890663, -0.03926078975200653, 0.08206881582736969, 0.013000013306736946, 0.006367820315063, -0.05553185194730759, -0.053585849702358246, 0.0003653040621429682, 0.014216792769730091, -0.03182376176118851, 0.04028420150279999, 0.02757306955754757, 0.030569083988666534, -0.009709801524877548, -0.06919539719820023, 0.01669895462691784, -0.013240905478596687, -0.004780873190611601, -0.050645552575588226, 0.01887991838157177, -0.048679713159799576, 0.019535211846232414, -0.08285054564476013, 0.007402992807328701, 0.025741253048181534, -0.005073883570730686, 0.00429039029404521, 0.02265741489827633, 0.024921411648392677, 0.030283508822321892, 0.01643129251897335, 0.02913837693631649, 0.0376364067196846, -0.021667083725333214, -0.00137533328961581, 0.03375089541077614, 0.0220608189702034, 0.014246898703277111, 0.033992331475019455, -0.0121020982041955, 0.011240496300160885, -0.030354050919413567, -0.009054409340023994, 0.04058649018406868, 0.04296467825770378, -0.026573460549116135, -0.03869618475437164, -0.011469069868326187, -0.0024092812091112137, -0.0442383773624897, 0.012403134256601334, 0.035754017531871796, -0.022009557113051414, 0.010138054378330708, 0.007446004077792168, -0.0499204657971859, -0.0377216637134552, 0.013790714554488659, 0.013345003128051758, 0.04791564121842384, 0.00884715560823679, -0.008479258976876736, -0.016155030578374863, -0.09909895062446594, 0.031223606318235397, 0.08246693015098572, -0.07684022188186646, 0.009068027138710022, 0.041752755641937256, 0.011432958766818047, -0.09714342653751373, -0.00399620458483696, -0.012830858118832111, 0.013004251755774021, -0.042673565447330475, 0.024998482316732407, 0.03455161303281784, 0.046577662229537964, 0.07681179791688919, -0.02263094112277031, 0.012152357026934624, 0.009484666399657726, -0.0749918520450592, -0.024706566706299782, 0.03629770874977112, -0.012988009490072727, 0.017803246155381203, 0.022670665755867958, -0.0008072044001892209, -0.02481464110314846, 0.017366601154208183, -0.00787333957850933, -0.03067256323993206, 0.012117480859160423, -0.01416027545928955, 0.06083735078573227, -0.0380689762532711, 0.04177059978246689, 0.011424589902162552, -0.02392926998436451, 0.029719900339841843, 0.04240508750081062, -0.02160465344786644, 0.0006758408271707594, 0.04506726562976837, 0.017830953001976013, 0.040657252073287964, 0.019478214904665947, 0.020586509257555008, 0.022097093984484673, -0.04234275966882706, -0.014602337963879108, 0.034634388983249664, 0.029152236878871918, 0.03926229849457741, -0.05444719269871712, 0.01098615862429142, -0.012152817100286484, -0.019204389303922653, 0.04119409993290901, 0.021456098183989525, 0.04203175753355026, 0.020241843536496162, 0.06621500849723816, 0.005184555891901255, -0.06827189773321152, -0.006837557069957256, -0.04932388290762901, 0.06462977826595306, -0.061436187475919724, -0.04497620463371277, -0.054364223033189774, -0.010430492460727692, -0.055875107645988464, 0.02624846249818802, -0.046189114451408386, 0.0448266863822937, -0.0547611266374588, 0.028526075184345245, -0.0014727077214047313, 0.002978731645271182, 0.007607635110616684, 0.04419200122356415, 0.0288676954805851, -0.03020837903022766, 0.0006163708167150617, 0.06613793969154358, 0.016544893383979797, 0.036509111523628235, 0.056277796626091, -0.02811683900654316, 0.009730557911098003, 0.015556796453893185, -0.07033132761716843, -0.029768509790301323, 0.033872947096824646, 0.015768513083457947, -0.012461746111512184, 0.01781146228313446, 0.018207497894763947, -0.02614692971110344, 0.06288143992424011, -0.03000621311366558, -0.04483175650238991, -0.0028471038676798344, 0.04666722193360329, 0.028938094154000282, -0.08964458853006363, 0.009218364022672176, 0.002398790093138814, 0.04172954335808754, 0.021067539229989052, 0.008468612097203732, -0.021908478811383247, -0.0064710029400885105, -0.001817899290472269, 0.022055184468626976, 0.04854940250515938, 0.017225028946995735, -0.00034248505835421383, -0.003329598344862461, 0.042125403881073, 0.019810236990451813, 0.001568364561535418, 0.005203223787248135, 0.004272612743079662, -0.016832098364830017, 0.014438915997743607, 0.014285588636994362, 0.00515487976372242, 0.012787003070116043, -0.049380622804164886, 0.003207053756341338, 0.04189542680978775, -0.07199941575527191, 0.017595430836081505, -0.0646626278758049, 0.007549640256911516, -0.009352749213576317, 0.01688392460346222, -0.0231882743537426, 0.006049819756299257, -0.009240793064236641, 0.058129891753196716, 0.01856374181807041, -0.017345238476991653, -0.045012298971414566, 0.0059244972653687, -0.017095932736992836, -0.023316603153944016, 0.008635501377284527, 0.012263026088476181, -0.011958449147641659, 0.022673917934298515, -0.0016773140523582697, -0.0462687648832798, 0.011238942854106426, -0.005488284397870302, 0.016771560534834862, 0.013762522488832474, -0.00647734897211194, 0.0036365871783345938, 0.02348652482032776, 0.036250073462724686, -0.0216290932148695, 0.03672599419951439, -0.06419157981872559, -0.05865633487701416, -0.015343680046498775, -0.013876277953386307, 0.001257544383406639, -0.013755680993199348, 0.0044771842658519745, -0.03540016710758209, -0.007487342692911625, 0.03708730265498161, 0.0071023209020495415, -0.0699801817536354, -0.08289658278226852, 0.018997715786099434, -0.0310051366686821, 0.07109679281711578, 0.00040272530168294907, 0.03302910178899765, 0.028398875147104263, 0.023383483290672302, -0.036806318908929825, -0.04908248409628868, 0.05695034936070442, 0.039553623646497726, 0.014093964360654354, 0.03860154375433922, -0.01888703927397728, 0.013396778143942356, 0.015585716813802719, -0.02452198974788189, 0.03970710188150406, 0.0466226302087307, 0.02988852933049202, -0.056908831000328064, 0.038204457610845566, -0.020827779546380043, 0.06669017672538757, 0.01874607428908348, 0.04621419310569763, 0.02783816307783127, 0.005628244951367378, -0.03920718654990196, -0.017023038119077682, -0.050099071115255356, -0.07233843207359314, -0.0434066541492939, 0.05190832167863846, -0.00612255884334445, -0.039910268038511276, -0.014436169527471066, -0.028383424505591393, 0.04718619957566261, 0.05719965696334839, -0.0943148210644722, -0.011949393898248672, 0.019202927127480507, 0.028652461245656013, 0.05115288496017456, 0.02263655886054039, 0.010677020996809006, -0.04960957169532776, -0.0002652237890288234, 0.06029156222939491, -0.015583927743136883, 0.03663352131843567, 0.013688048347830772, -0.043187275528907776, -0.02897547371685505, 0.000018356960936216637, 0.01264252606779337, -0.005777293350547552, -0.006192844361066818, -0.05539238080382347, -0.025115253403782845, 0.010022499598562717, -0.035435739904642105, 0.009446653537452221, 0.016070453450083733, -0.06535817682743073, -0.011755912564694881, 0.04640384390950203, -0.02576414868235588, -0.010531493462622166, 0.04918481409549713, 0.05088984966278076, -0.06847324222326279, 0.003457560669630766, 0.038944143801927567, 0.05426207557320595, 0.01701870560646057, -0.02276349999010563, -0.03306761011481285, -0.03158736974000931, -0.02602693811058998, 0.04632510989904404, -0.0056293862871825695, -0.011867749504745007, 0.03857201710343361, -0.0608392134308815, -0.003209018846973777, -0.01629122905433178, 0.052847396582365036, -0.015403629280626774, -0.05797868221998215, 0.008636290207505226, -0.01644546166062355, -0.041461363434791565, -0.026051629334688187, -0.03370912745594978, -0.015623184852302074, -0.0029258124995976686, 0.015122119337320328, 0.00014600007853005081, 0.061725083738565445, 0.015040694735944271, -0.02679363079369068, 0.07485152035951614, -0.02473004348576069, 0.03317512199282646, -0.058983586728572845, -0.06388908624649048, 0.00854742992669344, 0.014019718393683434, -0.022882109507918358, 0.02287416160106659, 0.03430655971169472, 0.00965801626443863, 0.025867989286780357, -0.011205488815903664, 0.020566999912261963, 0.019377078860998154, -0.0006119023892097175, -0.06587258726358414, -0.03214101120829582, 0.006124085746705532, -0.000057701712648849934, 0.01035497896373272, -0.07882273942232132, 0.010850710794329643, 0.021221324801445007, -0.00983683206140995, -0.00013233645586296916, -0.03312104940414429, 0.022941837087273598, 0.030559860169887543, -0.04328460246324539, -0.036989446729421616, 0.05421232804656029, 0.036718353629112244, -0.010599623434245586, 0.016611434519290924, 0.0007963608950376511, -0.013783222064375877, -0.005595147144049406, -0.03549469634890556, -0.09094354510307312, -0.013821403495967388, 0.014667833223938942, -0.015106510370969772, -0.014622018672525883, -0.001869172789156437, 0.031031392514705658, -0.05021597817540169, 0.02362249791622162, -0.020483674481511116, -0.05257628858089447, 0.037810828536748886, 0.00540396710857749, 0.017854072153568268, -0.010571839287877083, -0.005399561952799559, 0.02196470834314823, 0.029864374548196793, -0.05408210679888725, 0.008920750580728054, 0.019062524661421776, 0.03183183819055557, -0.03174440562725067, -0.027809152379631996, -0.02482537552714348, -0.0520419143140316, -0.031036067754030228, -0.07727973163127899, -0.04136449843645096, 0.04087137058377266, 0.0025137828197330236, -0.014120460487902164, 0.022993063554167747, -0.04266698285937309, 0.03864666819572449, 0.010997248813509941, -0.06021925434470177, -0.009704544208943844, -0.003696225583553314, 0.009456057101488113, 0.045755255967378616, -0.028558002784848213, 0.054236702620983124, -0.029401008039712906, 0.01968766748905182, -0.04677579924464226, -0.03170588240027428, 0.009866958484053612, 0.011677331291139126, -0.008045881055295467, 0.02981880120933056, 0.02415105327963829, 0.023377899080514908, -0.006395830772817135, -0.017441051080822945, 0.050975047051906586, 0.047021061182022095, 0.022804617881774902, 0.03277815133333206, 0.03377468138933182, -0.046731267124414444, 0.03485828638076782, -0.04489127919077873, 0.024795478209853172, 0.02442220412194729, -0.0356401726603508, 0.022210832685232162, -0.026020104065537453, 0.0021105969790369272, 0.0028734763618558645, -0.010686146095395088, -0.02707645669579506, 0.022258104756474495, 0.04572977498173714, 0.020646417513489723, 0.028902314603328705, 0.019965240731835365, -0.06394761055707932, -0.032249197363853455, -0.04425406455993652, -0.07284244149923325, 0.02126535214483738, -0.10966430604457855, -0.040035754442214966, 0.016456926241517067, 0.01186960469931364, -0.038331538438797, 0.05506246164441109, -0.053418390452861786, 0.05377813056111336, 0.07386685162782669, 0.001058204099535942, -0.004872805904597044, -0.024411331862211227, 0.022825654596090317, 0.009039854630827904, -0.05387422814965248, -0.07070691883563995, 0.07649338245391846, -0.018029548227787018, 0.011364240199327469, 0.03685927763581276, -0.015521490946412086, -0.017535710707306862, 0.009921619668602943, -0.06821222603321075, 0.011022680439054966, -0.0017802998190745711, -0.033808544278144836, -0.04575234651565552, 0.018249664455652237, -0.02390441671013832, 0.026309896260499954, 0.019630277529358864, 0.017763953655958176, -0.021869203075766563, -0.02201823890209198, 0.012095802463591099, -0.017987849190831184, -0.006317976396530867, 0.00462378840893507, 0.007531468290835619, -0.005792555864900351, 0.02923361398279667, -0.07105787843465805, 0.005649457219988108, 0.07638552784919739 ]
<p>I don't know how to solve question like this: </p> <p>A transverse wave is propagated in a string stretched along the x-axis. The equation of the wave, in SI units, is given by:y = 0.006 cos π(46t - 12x). The frequency of the wave, in SI units, is closest to ...</p> <p>Will appreciate your help!</p>
g4018
[ 0.0446251779794693, 0.05776206776499748, 0.01845845766365528, -0.04152500256896019, 0.003355042077600956, -0.05105116590857506, 0.023999730125069618, -0.001731951953843236, 0.00858819019049406, 0.013371549546718597, -0.014803876169025898, 0.05822426825761795, -0.04239058494567871, -0.0344860777258873, 0.03859125077724457, 0.012626285664737225, 0.04709707573056221, 0.02244327962398529, 0.012632299214601517, 0.02932155877351761, -0.011728067882359028, -0.011534483171999454, 0.011677984148263931, -0.03448912128806114, 0.02525808848440647, -0.00736286910250783, 0.006053548771888018, 0.008453034795820713, -0.013857122510671616, -0.043307121843099594, 0.08059455454349518, 0.060540735721588135, 0.08833833783864975, -0.012634215876460075, -0.010661812499165535, -0.0160601194947958, -0.015607637353241444, -0.01379394344985485, 0.0342220738530159, 0.036878589540719986, -0.01381698902696371, -0.015658294782042503, -0.003988499753177166, -0.016038723289966583, 0.061822861433029175, -0.088126040995121, 0.001534331706352532, 0.0439671091735363, 0.020267553627490997, -0.05685213580727577, -0.061829693615436554, 0.0056555685587227345, 0.02351357974112034, -0.016248423606157303, -0.04937183856964111, 0.01979704014956951, -0.017606867477297783, -0.03078398108482361, 0.02345142513513565, 0.06995026767253876, 0.004213809967041016, 0.02296770177781582, 0.04805239662528038, -0.061698026955127716, 0.00551128014922142, -0.045070238411426544, -0.0208741445094347, 0.026369009166955948, 0.01846439763903618, 0.005842297337949276, 0.006424497812986374, -0.06600302457809448, 0.035054560750722885, -0.04002883657813072, -0.0738363265991211, -0.018977239727973938, 0.001239547273144126, -0.0006949293310754001, -0.07122157514095306, -0.00368723482824862, -0.042764514684677124, 0.002329054055735469, 0.02807464823126793, -0.001292539294809103, -0.010637704282999039, -0.041277773678302765, 0.0336931049823761, 0.05050007253885269, -0.048986051231622696, 0.032509565353393555, -0.011176840402185917, 0.0375312976539135, 0.03380875289440155, 0.002213010098785162, 0.04447951912879944, -0.04550834000110626, -0.07530370354652405, 0.0674716979265213, 0.056983232498168945, 0.005578090902417898, 0.02550693415105343, 0.01345807034522295, -0.01835937239229679, -0.018958741798996925, -0.023231614381074905, -0.005844978615641594, 0.003580293618142605, 0.012663926929235458, -0.00910323765128851, 0.03903358429670334, -0.0022849522065371275, -0.04583512991666794, 0.027558693662285805, -0.03395967558026314, -0.023765966296195984, 0.02108083665370941, 0.02294819802045822, 0.02016124501824379, 0.04804248735308647, 0.0250693429261446, -0.06670263409614563, -0.0660652443766594, 0.02246350236237049, 0.04279323294758797, -0.012771871872246265, -0.003986875526607037, -0.02586325630545616, 0.007255391217768192, 0.03786589950323105, 0.031463880091905594, -0.028635414317250252, 0.011559517122805119, 0.028080161660909653, 0.02833307906985283, 0.009510650299489498, 0.005119518842548132, -0.004298179876059294, -0.025141028687357903, 0.007695633452385664, 0.027329767122864723, -0.025527343153953552, -0.04836332052946091, 0.04278784617781639, -0.0014446453424170613, -0.03988293930888176, 0.028170570731163025, -0.03660831227898598, -0.10506072640419006, 0.029605399817228317, -0.07069219648838043, -0.03908661752939224, 0.11034731566905975, 0.016872284933924675, -0.008154498413205147, 0.008313697762787342, -0.039304137229919434, 0.06447039544582367, -0.01187190506607294, -0.07214357703924179, -0.018626093864440918, 0.025331828743219376, 0.02105528488755226, -0.040888186544179916, 0.06851519644260406, -0.029017627239227295, -0.02281472645699978, 0.002636803314089775, -0.03595574572682381, 0.018595056608319283, -0.03237995132803917, -0.03364662453532219, -0.04855526238679886, 0.01894165389239788, -0.029142456129193306, 0.014709013514220715, 0.07289211452007294, 0.048932187259197235, 0.015322711318731308, 0.0507018081843853, 0.040063098073005676, -0.03044174239039421, -0.027857210487127304, 0.004522024188190699, 0.059937577694654465, -0.009560907259583473, -0.01971217431128025, 0.017067089676856995, -0.035942431539297104, -0.08541872352361679, 0.025304000824689865, 0.03000236302614212, -0.0005069139297120273, -0.0030448404140770435, 0.0072389221750199795, -0.03701433166861534, 0.004551955498754978, 0.034562330693006516, -0.002100736368447542, 0.004579906351864338, 0.0223985705524683, 0.01586589217185974, 0.0699000433087349, 0.08769994974136353, -0.036539070308208466, 0.06954522430896759, -0.03235863149166107, -0.021679406985640526, -0.0640375167131424, 0.0012928306823596358, 0.017252475023269653, -0.011913600377738476, -0.050478849560022354, -0.008113687857985497, 0.061235424131155014, -0.030485661700367928, -0.014653236605226994, 0.04511313885450363, 0.03670164570212364, -0.03508192300796509, 0.05435963347554207, -0.025012411177158356, -0.02698579616844654, 0.027063868939876556, -0.00845891609787941, -0.008956310339272022, 0.008352376520633698, 0.0012585603399202228, 0.005820329766720533, -0.00782014150172472, -0.004332086071372032, -0.013422257266938686, 0.011993919499218464, 0.01755862683057785, 0.011552950367331505, 0.005168234463781118, -0.009269238449633121, -0.050719209015369415, 0.03282806649804115, 0.05241812393069267, -0.002063686028122902, -0.010974113829433918, 0.01209687627851963, 0.0006286563584581017, -0.027156135067343712, 0.02172604762017727, 0.005548516288399696, 0.020702091977000237, -0.010910223238170147, 0.0014087491435930133, -0.003339905058965087, 0.015631897374987602, -0.025120891630649567, -0.026223493739962578, 0.030863042920827866, 0.01683814823627472, -0.06259175390005112, -0.03967750445008278, 0.03868579864501953, -0.006505205295979977, -0.021735934540629387, -0.0097822779789567, 0.01916917786002159, 0.033855270594358444, -0.05223565176129341, -0.04382912442088127, -0.030078595504164696, -0.005707023199647665, -0.016534237191081047, 0.006076449062675238, -0.0372292660176754, -0.01600409299135208, 0.037325646728277206, -0.021505974233150482, 0.04269372299313545, 0.01978515274822712, -0.02443518489599228, 0.04929802566766739, -0.013991880230605602, -0.05791383981704712, 0.02298532798886299, 0.0390608124434948, 0.0029311026446521282, 0.06028713285923004, 0.02343686856329441, 0.045137595385313034, -0.06241041049361229, 0.002541610272601247, -0.02359013818204403, 0.02761301025748253, 0.05625375732779503, -0.031057877466082573, 0.07714914530515671, -0.006743568927049637, 0.08177970349788666, -0.00996529869735241, 0.06954771280288696, 0.0194771196693182, -0.0466303750872612, -0.04270566254854202, 0.002320237224921584, -0.045870766043663025, 0.006920186337083578, 0.0339336022734642, -0.020254958420991898, 0.046567000448703766, 0.00794113427400589, -0.00009383804717799649, -0.026076989248394966, 0.05551483482122421, 0.03142987936735153, 0.020665349438786507, -0.031186150386929512, 0.09003742784261703, -0.06083175539970398, -0.029128190129995346, 0.029922926798462868, -0.0022306134924292564, 0.005049034487456083, -0.026151716709136963, 0.05319740250706673, 0.02168661542236805, -0.0104359807446599, 0.08231042325496674, 0.018428564071655273, -0.05795997008681297, 0.004055161029100418, -0.020369045436382294, 0.07686708867549896, -0.07088647037744522, -0.051893364638090134, -0.09004303812980652, -0.05683725327253342, 0.03216481953859329, -0.05564049258828163, 0.04750059172511101, -0.03895142301917076, -0.021813608705997467, 0.02911866270005703, 0.031317681074142456, 0.06800773739814758, -0.0397266186773777, -0.021446799859404564, -0.07481187582015991, -0.035023223608732224, -0.004023413639515638, 0.014670231379568577, -0.02644539438188076, 0.027142880484461784, 0.027349460870027542, -0.005972919054329395, -0.02304169535636902, -0.050577521324157715, 0.005367489065974951, 0.010069401003420353, 0.012904257513582706, 0.09430938214063644, 0.038221944123506546, 0.006934487260878086, 0.030224332585930824, -0.030492283403873444, 0.054715968668460846, -0.05096399784088135, -0.036680519580841064, -0.016028137877583504, 0.015924610197544098, 0.004311358090490103, 0.09057226032018661, 0.028610095381736755, 0.0019091583089902997, -0.0009227136033587158, -0.00999712198972702, -0.02685515768826008, 0.06406355649232864, -0.01859179697930813, -0.028153305873274803, -0.037313349545001984, -0.06188986077904701, -0.06595724821090698, -0.03232664242386818, 0.056998442858457565, -0.04038053750991821, -0.03251604363322258, 0.01034531183540821, -0.033881038427352905, 0.008497603237628937, -0.025582347065210342, -0.01193312555551529, -0.0021865249145776033, 0.008431213907897472, 0.006612883880734444, 0.004036444239318371, -0.06665660440921783, -0.011281825602054596, -0.008612779900431633, -0.032847389578819275, -0.0745028480887413, 0.02186787687242031, 0.008910028263926506, -0.08205751329660416, -0.005642821546643972, 0.039578162133693695, 0.009764808230102062, 0.03761405870318413, 0.01269630715250969, -0.009155549108982086, 0.004011045675724745, 0.055519916117191315, -0.019819477573037148, -0.011388706043362617, 0.01654365286231041, -0.00837079156190157, 0.018217021599411964, -0.018767237663269043, -0.025433924049139023, 0.03726906329393387, 0.027644095942378044, 0.08620360493659973, 0.0033353103790432215, -0.010816381312906742, 0.03859368711709976, -0.0020027540158480406, 0.054295044392347336, 0.0009209943236783147, -0.021804392337799072, -0.03788886219263077, 0.012568456120789051, 0.04721716418862343, -0.015781685709953308, 0.00032558373641222715, 0.014050545170903206, -0.07115520536899567, -0.015953868627548218, 0.022431524470448494, 0.038479167968034744, -0.03069234825670719, 0.017041923478245735, -0.07282234728336334, -0.02441214583814144, 0.035449787974357605, 0.019223375245928764, 0.004204107448458672, -0.04569542407989502, -0.022729206830263138, -0.006364487111568451, -0.055540576577186584, 0.012876909226179123, 0.006644205655902624, -0.06981093436479568, -0.00496155908331275, -0.04555336758494377, -0.04255150631070137, 0.014206751249730587, 0.022583303973078728, -0.05696553364396095, 0.010129056870937347, -0.028947528451681137, -0.05435880273580551, 0.005237525794655085, 0.01834600605070591, 0.008304447866976261, -0.009451695717871189, 0.012838533148169518, -0.027627646923065186, 0.0034169615246355534, 0.06281404197216034, -0.021883990615606308, 0.002189591061323881, -0.016673315316438675, 0.01327558420598507, 0.04229447990655899, 0.05014149099588394, -0.010005406104028225, 0.029453689232468605, 0.02118365839123726, -0.022830577567219734, 0.055629707872867584, -0.0742904543876648, 0.047865744680166245, -0.04304423928260803, -0.04486415907740593, -0.03199628368020058, -0.05817198008298874, 0.002106608124449849, -0.021712396293878555, 0.021108677610754967, -0.010053449310362339, -0.03287537023425102, 0.051131099462509155, -0.0015956367133185267, -0.03780721500515938, -0.008322042413055897, -0.010150323621928692, -0.004000519402325153, -0.004377597011625767, 0.0018896207911893725, -0.054448630660772324, 0.06033211201429367, -0.0454275906085968, -0.011544868350028992, -0.02092697098851204, -0.0011126280296593904, 0.008576183579862118, -0.03944632038474083, 0.035294078290462494, -0.00001383578000968555, 0.03071470931172371, -0.014527540653944016, 0.03066033497452736, -0.029927024617791176, 0.026970839127898216, 0.07912171632051468, 0.04586510732769966, -0.012290713377296925, 0.01518830843269825, 0.009475118480622768, -0.026899760589003563, -0.010942756198346615, 0.02962142787873745, 0.000012850026905653067, 0.025283003225922585, -0.0006788031896576285, 0.026806440204381943, -0.010652309283614159, 0.00856925081461668, 0.02277502231299877, -0.033280808478593826, -0.055606525391340256, -0.010756458155810833, 0.00015897216508165002, -0.040236081928014755, 0.03526504710316658, -0.045396823436021805, -0.010916459374129772, -0.035659901797771454, 0.0579058937728405, -0.01727561093866825, 0.040367331355810165, -0.03578604385256767, -0.055656541138887405, -0.035217300057411194, -0.05515547841787338, -0.05991379916667938, 0.06433991342782974, -0.03426968306303024, -0.01658451184630394, -0.0022786688059568405, -0.018571242690086365, 0.05241414159536362, -0.014927294105291367, -0.0017852080054581165, -0.003968650475144386, 0.006376432254910469, 0.00975420605391264, 0.0021476896945387125, -0.030695872381329536, 0.012347509153187275, -0.026046300306916237, -0.055514171719551086, -0.03355490788817406, -0.00022271397756412625, 0.010539136826992035, -0.05289677157998085, -0.022949455305933952, 0.0312940813601017, 0.00753704784438014, -0.037375032901763916, 0.002632623305544257, 0.005270564928650856, 0.08711230009794235, -0.009894073009490967, -0.012473858892917633, 0.012599465437233448, -0.022785702720284462, 0.036848969757556915, 0.02075181156396866, 0.025381559506058693, 0.002271751407533884, -0.010516460053622723, -0.040416598320007324, 0.03792135789990425, -0.02930043265223503, 0.041122063994407654, 0.004971632268279791, 0.009970921091735363, -0.007974104955792427, 0.02645019069314003, -0.0140422023832798, -0.08193092793226242, 0.06131414696574211, -0.0012663488741964102, 0.005494922399520874, -0.017357664182782173, -0.04864811152219772, 0.07588469982147217, -0.006813403218984604, -0.01896899752318859, 0.007080319337546825, 0.06729000806808472, -0.0015085494378581643, 0.03393341600894928, 0.07549877464771271, 0.003973769955337048, 0.07901442050933838, 0.01907406374812126, 0.007999162189662457, -0.04956900700926781, 0.017611771821975708, -0.03518380969762802, -0.005550904665142298, 0.013224105350673199, 0.04107639193534851, 0.03060527704656124, -0.004128646105527878, 0.015677031129598618, -0.005774409975856543, 0.016099872067570686, 0.061126887798309326, 0.05531085655093193, -0.013276609592139721, 0.010836752131581306, 0.08366730064153671, 0.012342222966253757, -0.07028116285800934, 0.0037107719108462334, -0.021045392379164696, -0.03410416096448898, -0.020393626764416695, -0.010518726892769337, 0.05353159457445145, -0.025886625051498413, 0.014642477966845036, 0.012607147917151451, -0.03957980126142502, 0.0032093769405037165, -0.068513423204422, 0.03985743224620819, -0.06003609299659729, 0.031906865537166595, -0.014372142031788826, 0.0883948877453804, 0.020422015339136124, 0.019036222249269485, 0.03766181692481041, -0.037560999393463135, -0.017807401716709137, 0.010265672579407692, 0.054977335035800934, -0.02819165401160717, -0.03675291687250137, 0.005571748595684767, -0.013554575853049755, 0.02357637509703636, -0.043643347918987274, 0.053060390055179596, -0.01187077071517706, -0.002357621444389224, 0.02337426319718361, -0.05268171429634094, -0.009761172346770763, 0.014059154316782951, -0.040032967925071716, -0.054944898933172226, 0.023388566449284554, 0.003071007551625371, -0.019908860325813293, 0.11456099152565002, 0.020270906388759613, -0.018397381529211998, 0.021583249792456627, 0.02559642493724823, -0.035719018429517746, -0.02356729470193386, -0.03658974915742874, -0.029435215517878532, 0.016546467319130898, 0.026133965700864792, -0.046065546572208405, 0.014896513894200325, -0.020687485113739967, -0.020853932946920395, -0.011268691159784794, -0.04683252424001694, -0.022175995633006096, -0.00814418587833643, 0.026998989284038544, -0.005052690394222736, 0.02867453545331955, 0.01114612352102995, 0.004745888523757458, 0.0008687495137564838, 0.002231781603768468, 0.040302205830812454, 0.000674729177262634, 0.0006902238819748163, 0.047478243708610535, 0.006690360140055418, -0.01625899411737919, 0.0503440722823143, 0.03194058686494827, 0.007741856854408979, 0.004346642643213272, 0.0531119704246521, 0.005803380161523819, 0.05941363796591759, 0.016248904168605804, 0.004011398181319237, -0.05160088092088699, -0.07482709735631943, -0.04329738765954971, -0.07682657986879349, 0.019756093621253967, -0.024552423506975174, -0.018195740878582, -0.010370424017310143, 0.080604188144207, 0.01743217371404171, 0.004449022002518177, 0.0015654320595785975, -0.07121910154819489, -0.04499131441116333, -0.030303671956062317, -0.004945126362144947, 0.0316581055521965, -0.03498787060379982, 0.013835891149938107, -0.04635209962725639, -0.06539475917816162, 0.010311390273272991, -0.009810357354581356, -0.025247113779187202, 0.009028148837387562, 0.01834137551486492, 0.0009694326436147094, -0.0015198236797004938, 0.006817162502557039, 0.016322143375873566, 0.004446175415068865, -0.007744449656456709, 0.02137666568160057, 0.022761305794119835, 0.023216187953948975, 0.021902868524193764, -0.042827870696783066, -0.008392046205699444, 0.01313800923526287, 0.0644146278500557, 0.005817913915961981, -0.008360457606613636, 0.036865007132291794, -0.03931187093257904, 0.0019494054140523076, 0.010461878962814808, -0.0509338304400444, 0.09033310413360596, 0.008721280843019485, -0.08296938985586166, 0.02363542653620243, 0.0450875498354435, -0.025491375476121902, -0.05434994772076607, -0.0015396203380078077, 0.015864454209804535, -0.006058097817003727, 0.016420265659689903, -0.0013398951850831509, -0.042447932064533234, -0.04808848351240158, -0.019892530515789986 ]
<p>Here is one task below. How to solve equation $$ m\ddot {x} + ax = F(t), x(0) = \dot x (0) = 0 $$ in quadratures by using two methods?</p> <p>I tried to create a system of equations</p> <p>$$ \begin{matrix} \dot v = F(t) - w_{0}^{2}x \\ \dot x = v \\ \end{matrix}, $$</p> <p>but I don't know, what to do next without using some vector $\varepsilon = v + \alpha x$. So, i know only one way. Can you help me with the second way?</p>
g4019
[ 0.011856447905302048, -0.03568737208843231, -0.004576460923999548, -0.042240697890520096, 0.04255492612719536, -0.06496819108724594, -0.011244588531553745, -0.023788414895534515, -0.003910814877599478, -0.015412709675729275, -0.06191143020987511, 0.01560782641172409, 0.05939042940735817, -0.0016445652581751347, -0.007080428767949343, 0.03302673250436783, -0.0037536080926656723, -0.007909023202955723, -0.05442637950181961, 0.0013850072864443064, -0.01214404683560133, 0.028463710099458694, 0.06307846307754517, -0.009288962930440903, -0.003869730746373534, -0.017040623351931572, -0.06656885147094727, 0.10094871371984482, -0.07507553696632385, 0.027458300814032555, -0.011224408634006977, 0.04152617231011391, 0.05707826092839241, 0.0050500682555139065, 0.0018810579786077142, -0.015958746895194054, 0.029944241046905518, 0.03524581342935562, 0.013187260366976261, -0.11726159602403641, -0.053410258144140244, -0.0419660247862339, 0.000777124660089612, 0.009992623701691628, -0.00548972561955452, -0.06417954713106155, -0.022411668673157692, -0.03772442415356636, 0.0009232236188836396, 0.020163176581263542, 0.04422501474618912, -0.006666862405836582, 0.009801018983125687, -0.04199976101517677, -0.08399765193462372, 0.030418511480093002, 0.016942938789725304, -0.07543233036994934, 0.048220742493867874, 0.00808173418045044, -0.04441140964627266, -0.016564400866627693, 0.07532118260860443, -0.017948241904377937, 0.016120612621307373, -0.03283485770225525, 0.041173964738845825, -0.056477487087249756, -0.004292029421776533, -0.003994190599769354, 0.009312374517321587, -0.00893336720764637, 0.05300949886441231, -0.002023005625233054, 0.017689090222120285, 0.011338828131556511, 0.044753238558769226, 0.03405004367232323, 0.0076883649453520775, 0.01734785921871662, 0.027611462399363518, 0.007190024480223656, 0.01106145977973938, 0.06447433680295944, 0.013838077895343304, -0.022682491689920425, 0.01875479146838188, -0.004086144268512726, -0.03689656779170036, -0.01598222739994526, -0.0017926611471921206, 0.027740173041820526, 0.04649294167757034, 0.04739551618695259, -0.014828827232122421, -0.03727806732058525, -0.04060132056474686, 0.04869557172060013, 0.03825642168521881, -0.00993258785456419, -0.0033843109849840403, 0.04609832540154457, -0.005629758350551128, -0.03743970766663551, -0.020079772919416428, -0.008719151839613914, 0.029292142018675804, 0.011046389117836952, -0.020179420709609985, 0.022050760686397552, -0.10268551856279373, 0.008762527257204056, -0.04705287143588066, -0.014484056271612644, 0.005353739485144615, -0.037028584629297256, 0.013390542939305305, -0.05061980336904526, 0.019695675000548363, 0.006593964993953705, 0.024983439594507217, -0.048463571816682816, 0.04466680809855461, 0.023045774549245834, 0.05777614563703537, 0.01363864354789257, 0.008687435649335384, 0.03187716007232666, 0.08766165375709534, -0.020902346819639206, 0.020568223670125008, -0.034340307116508484, 0.033870190382003784, 0.04510710760951042, 0.029717251658439636, 0.024594517424702644, -0.03774021193385124, -0.0007077606860548258, 0.039900846779346466, -0.0179582629352808, -0.04909621924161911, -0.038020357489585876, -0.01353498175740242, -0.03957836329936981, 0.006347671616822481, -0.015521163120865822, 0.033532414585351944, -0.05266685038805008, 0.03193897381424904, -0.05461730435490608, -0.0011249618837609887, 0.10358675569295883, -0.024773718789219856, 0.01084528211504221, -0.023918166756629944, 0.029230372980237007, 0.032784659415483475, -0.015836192294955254, -0.03573423624038696, -0.057793933898210526, 0.04298501834273338, -0.012765653431415558, 0.01625838503241539, -0.023331930860877037, -0.012219925411045551, 0.04389268532395363, -0.0363273061811924, -0.03953128308057785, -0.0011335922172293067, -0.030970679596066475, -0.005824544932693243, 0.0038352261763066053, 0.042498696595430374, -0.015483238734304905, 0.015795085579156876, 0.03762824088335037, 0.033171553164720535, -0.027848288416862488, 0.045793645083904266, -0.028058381751179695, 0.0027656382881104946, 0.024833789095282555, -0.03655560314655304, 0.017816681414842606, 0.011127270758152008, 0.008877977728843689, 0.015332118608057499, 0.05820596218109131, -0.06164940446615219, 0.017673056572675705, 0.01385716162621975, 0.02012171596288681, 0.05257992818951607, 0.05991553142666817, -0.026610923931002617, 0.05127950757741928, 0.04131069779396057, 0.0116878105327487, 0.00017962981655728072, 0.02157711423933506, -0.01396989542990923, 0.047523196786642075, -0.005033739842474461, 0.016526639461517334, -0.0022468576207756996, 0.030091924592852592, -0.049542684108018875, -0.029115993529558182, 0.022643502801656723, 0.022856147959828377, -0.010979102924466133, 0.016949186101555824, -0.029554732143878937, 0.043096285313367844, -0.05998523533344269, -0.04843379929661751, 0.02349332720041275, -0.03512197732925415, -0.03335293009877205, -0.004138682037591934, -0.020607521757483482, 0.005215425975620747, -0.022936731576919556, 0.004487541038542986, -0.06270480901002884, 0.04652208462357521, -0.011527989991009235, -0.038693614304065704, -0.04733331874012947, -0.024450600147247314, -0.009206016547977924, -0.07785360515117645, -0.05341450497508049, -0.027156153693795204, 0.07919014990329742, 0.015347849577665329, 0.017725197598338127, 0.03780050948262215, 0.029404155910015106, 0.08833594620227814, 0.023556513711810112, 0.013175449334084988, 0.04550617188215256, -0.007921325042843819, 0.023317087441682816, 0.0021589582320302725, 0.02600494958460331, 0.05481720715761185, -0.00720952358096838, 0.008383117616176605, -0.051181428134441376, -0.03459465503692627, -0.007430113852024078, -0.020223131403326988, -0.06388583034276962, 0.009297803975641727, 0.04748611897230148, -0.014427817426621914, -0.005611587315797806, -0.011268775910139084, -0.03393121436238289, 0.0011060740798711777, -0.024645378813147545, 0.014852075837552547, -0.06856942176818848, -0.015767661854624748, -0.02783817984163761, -0.01593591459095478, 0.019836679100990295, 0.018899142742156982, -0.05349971354007721, 0.025691425427794456, 0.02928350865840912, -0.03217102587223053, -0.01137562282383442, -0.05581178516149521, -0.011513789184391499, -0.014369247481226921, 0.01476956158876419, 0.006522953510284424, -0.032994698733091354, -0.01643555983901024, 0.06694788485765457, 0.09709545224905014, 0.08280865103006363, -0.029899638146162033, 0.0511484332382679, 0.0185343399643898, -0.010021117515861988, -0.037611573934555054, -0.03242767974734306, 0.05284472554922104, 0.001687623094767332, -0.07219113409519196, -0.0710173174738884, -0.005421527661383152, 0.024311009794473648, -0.023348908871412277, 0.00696305837482214, 0.037760525941848755, -0.030339213088154793, 0.006900236010551453, 0.0000480160815641284, -0.007587569300085306, 0.01804819330573082, -0.0286926981061697, -0.046754203736782074, -0.0036738256458193064, 0.02638358622789383, 0.0007322845049202442, 0.05498076230287552, -0.005690656136721373, -0.0017775832675397396, -0.07865486294031143, 0.022389216348528862, -0.03892182931303978, -0.005365507677197456, -0.04323782026767731, 0.051115959882736206, 0.028607051819562912, -0.040467940270900726, -0.05248996615409851, 0.05567541345953941, 0.023626118898391724, -0.018283581361174583, 0.029653167352080345, 0.008465551771223545, 0.07036963105201721, -0.048883769661188126, 0.018742967396974564, 0.005529576446861029, 0.010049327276647091, -0.03269067779183388, 0.028522057458758354, 0.01830078475177288, -0.007908905856311321, -0.027363350614905357, -0.0010804177727550268, -0.002583811292424798, 0.01576787792146206, 0.014034119434654713, 0.00009112518455367535, -0.03298626095056534, -0.03804494068026543, 0.0058060684241354465, -0.017366543412208557, 0.018608294427394867, 0.003801116021350026, 0.030820870772004128, -0.011592831462621689, 0.006837148219347, 0.00998648814857006, 0.008970636874437332, 0.020548444241285324, 0.02053379826247692, 0.0166077371686697, 0.03271399810910225, 0.010109259746968746, 0.012951121665537357, -0.0666356161236763, 0.009968670085072517, -0.05022419989109039, -0.035842616111040115, -0.009466070681810379, 0.021922359243035316, -0.008890962228178978, 0.06275489181280136, -0.016445012763142586, -0.048897627741098404, -0.09141558408737183, 0.06892048567533493, 0.005151599179953337, 0.04950626939535141, -0.02232440933585167, -0.02751302532851696, -0.04968529939651489, -0.0002934240037575364, -0.08463413268327713, -0.003767006564885378, 0.012143706902861595, 0.006996938958764076, -0.009610066190361977, 0.027898358181118965, 0.015766069293022156, -0.0172747615724802, 0.03147660195827484, -0.005695628933608532, -0.018687911331653595, 0.024196697399020195, -0.0053916210308671, 0.06058439612388611, -0.009949861094355583, -0.03992883488535881, 0.0044684140011668205, -0.05230196937918663, 0.007937174290418625, -0.029157310724258423, 0.017046915367245674, -0.12300614267587662, -0.02411162108182907, 0.012732485309243202, -0.018051108345389366, 0.03099147416651249, -0.032336387783288956, -0.006959694903343916, -0.02029884047806263, -0.07989446073770523, -0.03919924050569534, 0.06486643850803375, 0.03693026304244995, 0.00933894980698824, -0.03643126040697098, 0.009706055745482445, 0.009063352830708027, 0.02084433287382126, -0.023188944905996323, 0.028765222057700157, 0.008085368201136589, -0.015544023364782333, -0.06192069128155708, -0.0015677527990192175, 0.012004358693957329, -0.026547325775027275, 0.019485000520944595, 0.04186724126338959, 0.029745325446128845, -0.026141641661524773, 0.00721006840467453, 0.013676957227289677, 0.047879550606012344, -0.004496784880757332, 0.008366436697542667, -0.020098401233553886, 0.015270959585905075, -0.016171153634786606, 0.0008974345400929451, -0.03203265368938446, -0.036632753908634186, 0.00560670206323266, 0.001145802205428481, 0.0014764528023079038, 0.05303463339805603, -0.037401482462882996, 0.0026111886836588383, -0.052747003734111786, 0.02747056633234024, 0.05217835307121277, -0.054970499128103256, -0.005456425715237856, 0.01189795508980751, 0.0012958399020135403, 0.06611954420804977, 0.021369123831391335, -0.014530502259731293, -0.021537022665143013, 0.0004918048507533967, -0.041318416595458984, 0.06690432131290436, 0.02950441651046276, 0.041719935834407806, 0.01062371302396059, -0.006018406245857477, -0.05273674800992012, 0.05360057204961777, 0.04844437539577484, 0.019358709454536438, -0.07073065638542175, 0.04779069870710373, -0.04251588135957718, -0.05593910440802574, 0.00170531973708421, -0.011034307070076466, 0.013305752538144588, -0.0065973917953670025, 0.016622407361865044, -0.03768569976091385, -0.10501517355442047, 0.019382253289222717, 0.0075426893308758736, 0.036901555955410004, 0.005879223812371492, -0.009248812682926655, 0.03701646625995636, 0.02626580186188221, 0.045120272785425186, 0.007638769689947367, 0.023372851312160492, -0.02192653901875019, 0.06286276876926422, -0.05034666880965233, -0.05997878685593605, 0.08513610064983368, 0.009126467630267143, -0.008335258811712265, -0.0010359585285186768, -0.02399245835840702, -0.009549640119075775, 0.0197086650878191, 0.016258545219898224, -0.010692316107451916, -0.013979541137814522, 0.006111839320510626, -0.06715326011180878, -0.025714771822094917, 0.06717468053102493, 0.0008218801231123507, 0.04903731122612953, -0.019465850666165352, 0.04638254642486572, 0.06783746927976608, 0.022488681599497795, -0.014967717230319977, 0.028579363599419594, 0.01663856767117977, -0.03883403539657593, 0.0022151584271341562, 0.003368396544829011, 0.0088833998888731, -0.02602902241051197, -0.02885359525680542, 0.04127419739961624, -0.051913004368543625, -0.016295993700623512, 0.019584430381655693, 0.07429993897676468, -0.005829073954373598, -0.04497220367193222, -0.07852619886398315, -0.02764909528195858, 0.008818124420940876, -0.016867900267243385, -0.03221505135297775, -0.03349357843399048, -0.02274514175951481, -0.007423049304634333, -0.08369149267673492, 0.007580408826470375, -0.06739243119955063, -0.001431580283679068, -0.006383134983479977, 0.024544544517993927, -0.019516197964549065, 0.048058222979307175, 0.01459741685539484, 0.011203543283045292, -0.06964230537414551, 0.03499387204647064, -0.0006833007209934294, -0.012906712479889393, -0.0093331104144454, -0.06863021850585938, -0.00424867682158947, -0.023804817348718643, -0.021443435922265053, -0.020388087257742882, 0.027213526889681816, -0.07372583448886871, -0.04639802873134613, -0.04265813156962395, 0.004459396470338106, 0.054918959736824036, -0.06060679256916046, -0.005687564145773649, -0.016370777040719986, -0.03575773164629936, 0.018182555213570595, 0.028736621141433716, 0.03352392464876175, 0.028129814192652702, 0.03709997609257698, 0.03503156825900078, -0.017597315832972527, -0.039490845054388046, 0.10618548095226288, 0.08730436116456985, 0.044643256813287735, -0.01036287471652031, 0.01982944644987583, 0.02119491808116436, 0.011222507804632187, -0.05019807443022728, 0.056680310517549515, -0.03424176573753357, -0.019626159220933914, 0.015126110054552555, 0.022606136277318, -0.042334798723459244, -0.053145889192819595, 0.03363696113228798, -0.010872901417315006, -0.016166482120752335, 0.022646162658929825, -0.04950578883290291, -0.022607650607824326, 0.011935894377529621, 0.026183271780610085, 0.019057590514421463, 0.048044897615909576, 0.01678093522787094, -0.017390627413988113, -0.0007989479345269501, 0.023446038365364075, 0.015890778973698616, 0.0002707515668589622, -0.03679049015045166, 0.036442603915929794, 0.021090064197778702, -0.0144662382081151, 0.018986007198691368, -0.010412970557808876, -0.011960391886532307, 0.06873650848865509, -0.03745642676949501, 0.0018763415282592177, 0.02867211401462555, 0.01463698036968708, -0.00905260257422924, 0.0479808934032917, 0.04470647871494293, -0.003209158545359969, 0.025530466809868813, -0.04141835495829582, -0.022676000371575356, 0.0014537846436724067, 0.024520955979824066, 0.04715866222977638, 0.01982630230486393, -0.006833932362496853, 0.04326285421848297, -0.020685583353042603, 0.0783134177327156, -0.06968287378549576, -0.0413387268781662, 0.004872314631938934, -0.01850847527384758, 0.06847435235977173, 0.0031977600883692503, 0.05809277296066284, -0.005954073742032051, 0.0818231850862503, -0.02961328998208046, 0.06346600502729416, -0.026752455160021782, -0.01597278006374836, 0.036601755768060684, 0.013444307260215282, -0.018281402066349983, -0.013355117291212082, -0.0817841961979866, 0.030576664954423904, 0.060122326016426086, 0.032346103340387344, 0.06178481504321098, 0.00949400756508112, 0.002849600277841091, -0.010668502189218998, 0.017016544938087463, 0.011893819086253643, -0.01643683761358261, 0.018258729949593544, -0.01845872960984707, -0.01651032827794552, 0.0000848276904434897, 0.05644611641764641, 0.006019099149852991, 0.05545438081026077, 0.04864411801099777, -0.014474304392933846, -0.028643781319260597, 0.01633099466562271, 0.03257419914007187, 0.0028674600180238485, -0.03887886926531792, 0.018428510054945946, 0.0071596200577914715, 0.05158264935016632, 0.022111205384135246, 0.0166395865380764, -0.023473287001252174, -0.0305807963013649, 0.03587478771805763, -0.0059973751194775105, -0.04262431338429451, -0.07165007293224335, 0.013170920312404633, 0.005324192810803652, 0.043068937957286835, 0.04157094284892082, 0.010666096583008766, -0.010815669782459736, -0.00667043961584568, 0.0404343381524086, 0.041479017585515976, -0.019407736137509346, -0.031390730291604996, 0.004255909938365221, -0.03792966157197952, 0.03377021849155426, 0.0019800325389951468, 0.02653644047677517, -0.022500189021229744, -0.013739299029111862, 0.02467234432697296, -0.005021234974265099, -0.07415429502725601, -0.013182374648749828, -0.003021394833922386, 0.00454028369858861, -0.006111791357398033, -0.012743416242301464, -0.00845882948487997, 0.02961280755698681, -0.06891501694917679, 0.022878305986523628, -0.027330143377184868, -0.06444662809371948, -0.027467912063002586, 0.08188466727733612, 0.0002483583230059594, -0.012788071297109127, -0.0034937059972435236, -0.02651124633848667, -0.008562500588595867, -0.0856718197464943, -0.03516620025038719, 0.020270060747861862, 0.012583140283823013, 0.00506599061191082, 0.002393839880824089, -0.005021051038056612, -0.012304841540753841, -0.07584302127361298, -0.03264325484633446, 0.043993789702653885, 0.043502405285835266, 0.006469065323472023, -0.01645088940858841, -0.04311190918087959, 0.003474486293271184, 0.014273416250944138, 0.004851257894188166, -0.05552377179265022, -0.06562834978103638, 0.049072377383708954, 0.0189684946089983, 0.0018265799153596163, 0.02807709388434887, 0.051946040242910385, 0.05715091526508331, 0.008148330263793468, 0.011301291175186634, -0.019964739680290222, -0.03770554065704346, 0.0015257099876180291, -0.00900898315012455, -0.01836101897060871, 0.0032968451268970966, 0.060620617121458054, 0.03157014399766922, -0.012217612937092781, -0.02793561853468418, 0.06393378973007202, -0.04594924673438072, 0.04599078372120857, 0.01773819886147976, -0.06661666929721832, -0.022288668900728226, -0.05717587471008301 ]
<p>So I was wondering, with all this Higgs talk going on, they just detected a particle with a mass of 125 GeV (CMS) or 126.5 GeV (ATLAS). But they still don't know what it is, since there is tons of data to go through.</p> <p>How do you determine spin of a particle from such experiments? Measuring the magnetic moments of a particle or?</p> <p>If they find out that it has spin 0, and the other decay channels are in agreement with this, then they can say: it's Higgs, right?</p> <p>So how do you do it? What do you need to analyse?</p>
g211
[ 0.02385619841516018, -0.01090143620967865, -0.013582642190158367, -0.04710983484983444, 0.09503396600484848, -0.025623630732297897, 0.026743194088339806, 0.07597345113754272, 0.00027177241281606257, -0.037547189742326736, -0.04888018220663071, 0.015086104162037373, 0.021823959425091743, -0.01337520219385624, 0.019258206710219383, -0.054231397807598114, -0.00861822534352541, -0.01652657240629196, 0.04662080109119415, 0.038060881197452545, 0.07699772715568542, -0.0020271569956094027, 0.020134953781962395, 0.0005855014896951616, -0.06422223150730133, -0.03329622745513916, -0.040423694998025894, 0.007546681445091963, 0.03353206068277359, 0.035225749015808105, -0.020599085837602615, -0.016501031816005707, 0.03301948681473732, -0.062121305614709854, 0.05998079106211662, -0.08065283298492432, 0.05578232184052467, 0.019725216552615166, -0.02805979549884796, -0.002406551269814372, 0.001231198781169951, -0.017614491283893585, 0.0319870263338089, 0.006848957855254412, 0.0213798638433218, 0.09131304919719696, -0.009621694684028625, 0.007973580621182919, 0.015681058168411255, 0.013485614210367203, -0.0397321879863739, 0.015717098489403725, 0.054184429347515106, 0.08545390516519547, 0.003916073590517044, 0.013113370165228844, -0.0238108541816473, 0.025849424302577972, 0.1286507397890091, -0.04239856079220772, 0.01674545928835869, -0.022323735058307648, -0.027267560362815857, 0.028871314600110054, 0.012977777048945427, -0.032418809831142426, -0.09950770437717438, 0.03236022964119911, -0.02537476271390915, 0.009249189868569374, 0.026317181065678596, -0.06069941818714142, 0.047410182654857635, -0.01363037433475256, -0.07636852562427521, -0.03327528387308121, 0.004490645602345467, -0.02245478704571724, -0.0029277466237545013, 0.03771676868200302, -0.005035357549786568, -0.023766474798321724, 0.05467672646045685, -0.006965592969208956, 0.01747545786201954, 0.0015951931709423661, -0.058709871023893356, 0.012035916559398174, 0.05188433825969696, -0.009529207833111286, 0.0469655804336071, -0.07338371872901917, 0.043513379991054535, 0.013907802291214466, 0.01627986878156662, 0.019170187413692474, 0.016978561878204346, -0.009346771985292435, -0.0014167557237669826, -0.008782802149653435, 0.00385130662471056, -0.004191348794847727, -0.06962217390537262, -0.06612793356180191, 0.010823829099535942, 0.017789378762245178, 0.002865350106731057, 0.04557078331708908, 0.08078709989786148, -0.0021060092840343714, -0.05310903117060661, 0.01145271584391594, -0.05024217441678047, -0.007758032530546188, -0.0628572404384613, -0.0503099262714386, 0.11767525970935822, 0.007311694789677858, -0.003188034053891897, 0.016939232125878334, 0.010218380019068718, 0.018516244366765022, -0.033750709146261215, 0.07449548691511154, 0.008198588155210018, -0.004493655636906624, 0.040110260248184204, -0.01033478882163763, 0.03580589219927788, 0.06007193401455879, -0.02526385337114334, -0.009826199151575565, 0.0065140677616000175, 0.0319523811340332, -0.021315734833478928, 0.07410963624715805, 0.004775677807629108, 0.03772352635860443, -0.02290952205657959, -0.019411295652389526, -0.01462430041283369, -0.020038429647684097, 0.021883545443415642, -0.03563344106078148, 0.04580623283982277, 0.030811944976449013, 0.03510167822241783, 0.008212666027247906, 0.019140364602208138, 0.08178139477968216, 0.02687547728419304, 0.05208704620599747, 0.06131470575928688, -0.014490848407149315, 0.024307625368237495, -0.057299330830574036, 0.02548379823565483, -0.050565775483846664, -0.020219439640641212, 0.05716846138238907, 0.03326563909649849, -0.07274243980646133, -0.024361174553632736, 0.0072205341421067715, -0.036360032856464386, -0.0014604623429477215, 0.026790350675582886, 0.011842704378068447, 0.023326685652136803, -0.07433825731277466, -0.04365824535489082, 0.029234185814857483, 0.007700991351157427, 0.015840230509638786, 0.04442296549677849, 0.042622052133083344, -0.013840668834745884, -0.0432853139936924, 0.045341599732637405, 0.07459495961666107, 0.04263840988278389, 0.019996482878923416, 0.061374686658382416, 0.010066631250083447, -0.028883280232548714, 0.008517361246049404, 0.002431199187412858, -0.02159598469734192, 0.07117747515439987, 0.0077357725240290165, -0.006076894234865904, -0.032119039446115494, -0.030757177621126175, -0.026304351165890694, 0.046123720705509186, 0.0067185452207922935, 0.002618290949612856, -0.07140357792377472, -0.025285566225647926, 0.020874321460723877, -0.019063668325543404, 0.031603846698999405, -0.01112968660891056, 0.061284322291612625, 0.030710691586136818, -0.0835757926106453, 0.009074668399989605, -0.009723800234496593, 0.05117873474955559, 0.00202464172616601, 0.06288150697946548, 0.01737704873085022, -0.03772170469164848, 0.007354050874710083, -0.061770081520080566, -0.007939170114696026, 0.012594047002494335, 0.028945473954081535, 0.04240763559937477, -0.01723344996571541, -0.03845563158392906, -0.0303812175989151, 0.02998623065650463, 0.0008477193769067526, -0.03410398215055466, 0.012372873723506927, -0.04098137468099594, 0.028347978368401527, 0.000021007670511608012, 0.005843775346875191, 0.02613038755953312, -0.015030567534267902, 0.03937443718314171, -0.0016363069880753756, 0.012181207537651062, -0.0122529286891222, -0.03857315704226494, -0.005579471588134766, -0.019403764978051186, 0.06923177093267441, 0.017001496627926826, 0.003081905422732234, -0.0625930055975914, -0.032814912497997284, 0.02347397431731224, 0.009237146005034447, 0.060528986155986786, 0.025374548509716988, -0.03891478478908539, 0.003500359132885933, 0.039699625223875046, 0.004862516187131405, 0.03897165507078171, -0.047348324209451675, 0.00930757261812687, -0.008805855177342892, 0.012354519218206406, 0.04147719591856003, -0.07777188718318939, -0.0335111990571022, 0.02078305184841156, 0.0028366553597152233, 0.017831729725003242, 0.036819085478782654, 0.019079525023698807, -0.06326702982187271, 0.0008028148440644145, -0.012197610922157764, -0.03584444150328636, -0.020400401204824448, -0.052093032747507095, 0.0031747331377118826, 0.024693554267287254, 0.011742907576262951, -0.03326808288693428, -0.06143861636519432, 0.025255342945456505, 0.050671570003032684, 0.04444984719157219, -0.0457242988049984, -0.022528821602463722, 0.02253989689052105, 0.0023907064460217953, 0.0055665019899606705, -0.006338243838399649, -0.02757032960653305, -0.03094780072569847, -0.09382668137550354, 0.0013485811650753021, -0.03254038095474243, 0.0025609591975808144, -0.0470072366297245, 0.04860896244645119, -0.03649873286485672, -0.0040794541127979755, 0.05296371504664421, 0.05289000645279884, 0.026822587475180626, -0.010256313718855381, 0.020764624699950218, 0.053170640021562576, 0.014853444881737232, -0.021662861108779907, -0.0417279489338398, 0.03911197930574417, 0.005148218013346195, -0.0358772911131382, -0.024512430652976036, -0.005200085695832968, -0.032759781926870346, -0.08266125619411469, 0.03841739520430565, 0.020671753212809563, -0.012145020999014378, 0.010482395999133587, 0.029532283544540405, -0.027209540829062462, 0.05631382018327713, 0.005358901806175709, -0.008603684604167938, -0.02040228806436062, -0.03427058458328247, 0.05197172984480858, 0.010179153643548489, 0.018589571118354797, -0.022182736545801163, 0.0019399153534322977, 0.010711388662457466, -0.06531386822462082, -0.017529280856251717, -0.012265892699360847, 0.014961190521717072, -0.03466297686100006, 0.018246140331029892, -0.006079724058508873, 0.020942358300089836, 0.04082532599568367, -0.00614881981164217, 0.015325767919421196, 0.042306046932935715, 0.025888117030262947, -0.012968498282134533, -0.05074354633688927, 0.03950062021613121, 0.02512974664568901, 0.017515448853373528, -0.0016706690657883883, -0.019646095111966133, 0.009641744196414948, -0.019606683403253555, -0.019564751535654068, 0.058201711624860764, -0.0060018799267709255, -0.023195059970021248, 0.008744217455387115, -0.004230940248817205, -0.03344494849443436, 0.018709847703576088, 0.02354089356958866, 0.004851966630667448, 0.016714494675397873, 0.00008454226917820051, 0.021762026473879814, -0.0296500101685524, 0.011270323768258095, -0.0002541769645176828, -0.002692461246624589, -0.009554061107337475, 0.03752169758081436, -0.04966549575328827, 0.027665147557854652, 0.004854176659137011, 0.01166510209441185, 0.03160818666219711, -0.03489156439900398, -0.0410894937813282, 0.0045950585044920444, -0.04851055145263672, 0.008713430725038052, -0.03300265595316887, -0.05085518956184387, 0.032785769551992416, 0.018365556374192238, -0.046300601214170456, -0.015247561037540436, -0.0016905629308894277, -0.03879343718290329, 0.021140702068805695, -0.029724691063165665, -0.02621747925877571, 0.04043610766530037, 0.034675613045692444, -0.010052637197077274, 0.016163785010576248, 0.0553821325302124, -0.043132930994033813, -0.008634911850094795, -0.031455375254154205, -0.03950444236397743, 0.04251917824149132, -0.04015200212597847, 0.05493202805519104, 0.03516876697540283, -0.015823064371943474, 0.03417440503835678, 0.04118121415376663, -0.02586992457509041, -0.03787646070122719, 0.05794282257556915, -0.00795324333012104, -0.02627122774720192, 0.003977606073021889, 0.009552594274282455, -0.006037010811269283, 0.010796516202390194, -0.03133934736251831, 0.0005790471332147717, -0.01866469718515873, -0.02705247886478901, -0.02483341470360756, -0.020299768075346947, -0.03801712021231651, -0.011854205280542374, -0.018777141347527504, -0.08465828746557236, 0.04002443328499794, 0.0023570223711431026, 0.06334561854600906, -0.07328543066978455, -0.031174346804618835, 0.039073023945093155, -0.0035808475222438574, 0.04241834208369255, -0.0007330090738832951, -0.00840551033616066, 0.0286005400121212, 0.003581858240067959, -0.04721313714981079, 0.02114776149392128, 0.024796530604362488, 0.013877402059733868, -0.025536466389894485, -0.004511179868131876, -0.01746348850429058, -0.06256747990846634, 0.04504353925585747, -0.06175857409834862, -0.003682395676150918, -0.015007616020739079, 0.004082759376615286, -0.0016484172083437443, 0.012103230692446232, -0.06622717529535294, -0.028178106993436813, 0.019182566553354263, 0.02373732626438141, 0.01542660128325224, 0.04531896486878395, -0.04259127378463745, -0.014958541840314865, -0.09177283942699432, -0.06416631489992142, 0.012903853319585323, 0.012311454862356186, -0.06752916425466537, 0.022549321874976158, -0.03198083117604256, -0.04953794553875923, 0.0034760867711156607, 0.0206141397356987, -0.04501081258058548, -0.04855514317750931, 0.0748598575592041, -0.04562706500291824, -0.03119337372481823, 0.0865376740694046, -0.049955688416957855, -0.0031865998171269894, -0.037736352533102036, -0.032932963222265244, -0.04793566092848778, 0.012288805097341537, -0.033683888614177704, -0.033995989710092545, -0.006225646939128637, -0.02407139539718628, -0.04763459414243698, -0.03461310267448425, 0.04313845559954643, -0.004469245672225952, -0.026029206812381744, 0.06821997463703156, 0.03220459073781967, -0.04411542788147926, 0.018500197678804398, -0.06267935782670975, -0.0100512420758605, -0.05843222141265869, -0.005136531312018633, 0.021222572773694992, 0.0037265776190906763, -0.021387239918112755, -0.008793016895651817, 0.04041053354740143, -0.03502870723605156, 0.04032866656780243, 0.055560152977705, -0.07090532034635544, 0.027882346883416176, -0.013047920539975166, -0.007384081371128559, 0.013843300752341747, 0.04139695689082146, 0.04473960027098656, 0.0313020795583725, 0.0007259047124534845, -0.0007047223043628037, 0.0775424912571907, 0.01119028776884079, 0.007097859401255846, -0.07532227039337158, 0.04474630579352379, 0.044509708881378174, -0.037759024649858475, 0.008622406050562859, -0.08189316838979721, -0.06796189397573471, 0.023173026740550995, 0.025110695511102676, 0.02850102260708809, 0.017621617764234543, 0.022586764767766, 0.01535867340862751, 0.03999064862728119, -0.017712967470288277, -0.05053839087486267, -0.014749379828572273, -0.04034176468849182, 0.012155985459685326, 0.0063019064255058765, -0.06423591822385788, -0.011349485255777836, 0.016906695440411568, 0.0011079414980486035, 0.002272573299705982, -0.009177611209452152, 0.04872031509876251, -0.010825324803590775, 0.023721538484096527, -0.0510684959590435, -0.06944736838340759, 0.0008767387480475008, 0.04816407337784767, 0.003413679776713252, -0.04104703292250633, 0.012910446152091026, -0.0015228850534185767, 0.03341169282793999, 0.020853811874985695, 0.04539657384157181, -0.022455628961324692, -0.05179766193032265, 0.02178882248699665, -0.04710283502936363, 0.006492163985967636, -0.016008907929062843, -0.011591842398047447, -0.010309322737157345, -0.002704149577766657, -0.005741696339100599, -0.04406570643186569, -0.025214822962880135, -0.060300424695014954, 0.007938302122056484, -0.0034155428875237703, 0.017341086640954018, 0.006122878286987543, 0.029708951711654663, 0.009712518192827702, -0.013019335456192493, 0.03152356296777725, 0.007222448475658894, 0.024388860911130905, 0.00033200730103999376, 0.016355805099010468, 0.03404708579182625, 0.024280324578285217, -0.025416458025574684, -0.0018684121314436197, 0.07541900873184204, -0.00781691912561655, 0.03059588372707367, -0.007325501646846533, -0.026524512097239494, -0.011337070725858212, 0.008967125788331032, 0.011863946914672852, -0.060179270803928375, -0.0032592767383903265, -0.02482629381120205, -0.0009299850789830089, -0.021020250394940376, -0.02254139631986618, 0.01687275804579258, 0.022461488842964172, 0.0008503590361215174, -0.014665995724499226, 0.0022802758030593395, -0.022218260914087296, -0.035146456211805344, -0.048330530524253845, -0.024777991697192192, -0.0023222349118441343, 0.03014274127781391, 0.033701371401548386, 0.007146462332457304, 0.04458644986152649, -0.016982560977339745, -0.014698350802063942, -0.043613821268081665, -0.005131950136274099, 0.021860403940081596, -0.0045627118088305, -0.09037358313798904, 0.04403619095683098, -0.00504256272688508, 0.0897577553987503, -0.0011857998324558139, 0.0163404680788517, -0.02176627516746521, 0.013011767528951168, 0.01639440469443798, 0.011243377812206745, -0.002484830329194665, -0.030844569206237793, 0.035671427845954895, -0.00940172839909792, -0.005437340121716261, 0.019874926656484604, 0.04970787093043327, 0.032202236354351044, -0.005827178247272968, -0.05044907331466675, -0.039466492831707, -0.054342880845069885, -0.020088402554392815, 0.0006296770297922194, 0.009358346462249756, -0.022983916103839874, -0.01368126180022955, -0.005576188210397959, -0.01163430791348219, 0.02723139338195324, -0.002424475736916065, 0.0115891695022583, 0.04609649255871773, 0.0700598880648613, 0.04626695066690445, 0.06348101794719696, -0.05505172163248062, -0.06891808658838272, -0.024385716766119003, -0.010754436254501343, -0.0054590459913015366, -0.049654845148324966, -0.021500790491700172, -0.026588542386889458, -0.023385614156723022, 0.060260456055402756, -0.04278044030070305, -0.029944725334644318, -0.04981352761387825, -0.06770114600658417, 0.04493294656276703, 0.0321522131562233, -0.05278525874018669, -0.005606621503829956, -0.018063034862279892, -0.05437063053250313, -0.03404383733868599, -0.05303825065493584, 0.053671542555093765, -0.009531649760901928, 0.03443198651075363, 0.005571442190557718, 0.012873291969299316, -0.09176397323608398, 0.010430221445858479, 0.005348502192646265, 0.01498380396515131, -0.02017195150256157, 0.04638761654496193, 0.07376335561275482, -0.05288469418883324, -0.03808581456542015, 0.0007582625257782638, 0.04960644617676735, 0.006638225633651018, -0.03400234133005142, -0.03474966809153557, -0.001362219569273293, 0.012635396793484688, 0.042314279824495316, 0.010980166494846344, 0.010766401886940002, -0.00464093079790473, -0.008133584633469582, 0.010827894322574139, -0.03433941677212715, 0.05924399197101593, -0.008791279047727585, 0.0055233086459338665, 0.029126694425940514, 0.03314044326543808, -0.004080528859049082, 0.013186785392463207, -0.030347321182489395, -0.008083163760602474, 0.0925845131278038, -0.01694279909133911, 0.01606687530875206, 0.027778809890151024, 0.01695382036268711, -0.011497322469949722, -0.015733566135168076, -0.06598387658596039, -0.008749962784349918, 0.10875736176967621, 0.05203580856323242, 0.015632858499884605, 0.0342203788459301, 0.07409463077783585, -0.015696611255407333, -0.01160364504903555, -0.05655774101614952, -0.025899158790707588, 0.059732597321271896, -0.04955996572971344, 0.00860226433724165, 0.0553741492331028, 0.002145926933735609, 0.0031893723644316196, 0.014817321673035622, -0.014995090663433075, -0.007567449007183313, -0.0012189502594992518, -0.00004746114063891582, 0.01747179962694645, 0.03897268697619438, 0.025915304198861122, -0.0008053712663240731, 0.024510031566023827, 0.012743562459945679, 0.04446481913328171, -0.06617182493209839, -0.055206652730703354, -0.004089600406587124, 0.029270684346556664, -0.011445234529674053, -0.004529131576418877, 0.03877587616443634, -0.025575842708349228, 0.02820625901222229, 0.07716935873031616, -0.030739741399884224, -0.02478797920048237, -0.029083995148539543, 0.024292461574077606 ]
<p>What's a physical meaning of, for example, complex part of the solution for coordinate change of the anharmonic oscillator? Why after substitute (for diff. equation solve) for real x we can earn $x = Re(z) + iIm(z)$? It's because of substitute?</p>
g4020
[ 0.03202344849705696, -0.009896671399474144, -0.014755664393305779, -0.025555115193128586, 0.03848252817988396, -0.03428743779659271, 0.05165668949484825, 0.03543902933597565, -0.0214872807264328, 0.039621949195861816, -0.07092894613742828, 0.025584427639842033, 0.0365733839571476, -0.026331262663006783, 0.02151704579591751, 0.00340858893468976, 0.0486832819879055, 0.052500758320093155, -0.0009957723086699843, -0.06078372895717621, -0.04688198119401932, 0.035336900502443314, 0.007414876949042082, -0.04295548424124718, 0.011067218147218227, -0.04092510789632797, 0.060373470187187195, -0.034618765115737915, -0.04493206739425659, 0.011606181971728802, -0.028155792504549026, -0.006865543778985739, 0.06571011245250702, -0.004589649848639965, -0.07091925293207169, 0.006648337468504906, 0.09853389859199524, 0.05924306437373161, 0.032635077834129333, 0.02547745406627655, 0.05201578512787819, 0.007181250024586916, 0.030184974893927574, -0.02872607298195362, -0.017534317448735237, -0.04150497540831566, -0.05140625312924385, -0.0029284527990967035, 0.005176724400371313, 0.009024779312312603, -0.025340083986520767, -0.012020849622786045, 0.0840563103556633, 0.028116419911384583, 0.014651513658463955, 0.03209032863378525, 0.016176434233784676, 0.008609994314610958, 0.003163635265082121, 0.053907666355371475, 0.026233552023768425, -0.004358924925327301, 0.04825584590435028, 0.015114466659724712, 0.07156813889741898, -0.03211352229118347, -0.0027547881472855806, 0.002006359165534377, -0.018625928089022636, -0.012027760036289692, -0.008225206285715103, -0.04443051666021347, 0.0034629276487976313, 0.020247530192136765, -0.030728692188858986, -0.04598107561469078, -0.031181374564766884, -0.02198655530810356, 0.0028692109044641256, -0.01297298539429903, -0.012132841162383556, -0.01257261261343956, 0.0843994989991188, 0.00991878192871809, 0.06495747715234756, 0.02748630940914154, 0.03001532517373562, 0.010469421744346619, 0.012096994556486607, 0.052347999066114426, -0.024492202326655388, -0.033255405724048615, 0.03140416368842125, -0.032031506299972534, -0.03191673383116722, -0.03688979893922806, -0.036723893135786057, 0.03866755962371826, 0.038293611258268356, 0.013745216652750969, 0.013335409574210644, -0.034354306757450104, 0.0010120653314515948, -0.000006542600203829352, -0.012902304530143738, -0.03979852795600891, 0.015463643707334995, -0.051407985389232635, 0.004317869897931814, 0.021905729547142982, -0.0011684688506647944, -0.0045841410756111145, -0.014745241031050682, -0.032079532742500305, 0.06694737821817398, -0.015432094223797321, -0.030765974894165993, -0.03143920376896858, -0.015000990591943264, 0.051498908549547195, -0.035311292856931686, -0.028897488489747047, 0.02701052650809288, 0.0444878451526165, -0.008901110850274563, 0.007894101552665234, 0.030709905549883842, -0.005087049677968025, 0.08957376331090927, -0.01284568477421999, 0.00613180547952652, 0.01370574813336134, -0.007810314651578665, -0.0005262256599962711, -0.021342916414141655, -0.0249116700142622, 0.03554905205965042, -0.0571802593767643, -0.029896551743149757, -0.011332259513437748, 0.051891129463911057, -0.05873757600784302, 0.01665325276553631, -0.03242526203393936, -0.01182117871940136, -0.005193234886974096, -0.0010273073567077518, -0.06720391660928726, 0.002427901141345501, -0.013437196612358093, -0.014954948797821999, 0.07040395587682724, 0.028484812006354332, 0.003457668237388134, -0.0018813791684806347, -0.027464192360639572, -0.02166195772588253, -0.011160057969391346, -0.007212241180241108, 0.03994797542691231, 0.02309945411980152, 0.00011533543874975294, -0.042627982795238495, 0.033344566822052, -0.019603891298174858, 0.02343306876718998, 0.014896959997713566, -0.03283613175153732, -0.0701533630490303, 0.00462175952270627, -0.03718920797109604, 0.016159702092409134, -0.012565618380904198, 0.04119827598333359, 0.10010487586259842, 0.05353471636772156, -0.0030267653055489063, 0.016103781759738922, 0.022392630577087402, 0.043357040733098984, 0.005628772545605898, -0.031533338129520416, 0.03615324944257736, -0.02417237125337124, 0.017346348613500595, 0.04978610575199127, -0.02435167506337166, 0.03032107464969158, -0.11532657593488693, 0.030965039506554604, 0.010925693437457085, -0.015371793881058693, 0.0034662759862840176, 0.03270583227276802, -0.012761646881699562, 0.04048480838537216, -0.05001280456781387, 0.032005127519369125, -0.06768268346786499, 0.08899743854999542, 0.014576036483049393, 0.08972901105880737, 0.0018500773003324866, -0.030321352183818817, 0.002526878146454692, 0.0014196360716596246, -0.0033170043025165796, -0.05941144376993179, -0.02785537578165531, 0.05704965069890022, 0.009026388637721539, -0.023444917052984238, 0.029292521998286247, 0.000014532423847413156, -0.016977569088339806, -0.036119718104600906, 0.02588111348450184, -0.04348905012011528, -0.00066705810604617, 0.058026887476444244, -0.046612728387117386, -0.07067269831895828, 0.03538487106561661, 0.013394021429121494, 0.01061997376382351, -0.004467836581170559, -0.0016853525303304195, -0.04665769264101982, 0.0008962775464169681, 0.015580400824546814, -0.012736781500279903, -0.005613413639366627, 0.01675867848098278, 0.02819952368736267, 0.017722517251968384, 0.007575205061584711, -0.034224819391965866, 0.03326010704040527, 0.05118372663855553, 0.038636162877082825, 0.049156248569488525, -0.04463529214262962, -0.05316063016653061, -0.01837855763733387, 0.012914961203932762, 0.03843655809760094, 0.04532955586910248, -0.0321904681622982, -0.051367271691560745, 0.029748205095529556, 0.061082109808921814, -0.02537325583398342, -0.03249496594071388, -0.0341646783053875, -0.047271449118852615, -0.04494960233569145, -0.010330569930374622, 0.01490775216370821, 0.03738930821418762, -0.038517799228429794, -0.043636977672576904, 0.004115686751902103, 0.02946394681930542, 0.048183001577854156, -0.03487629070878029, -0.024785762652754784, -0.00936854537576437, 0.036640334874391556, 0.031247315928339958, -0.03317110985517502, -0.011344884522259235, 0.018284996971488, 0.0028407236095517874, 0.03221386671066284, -0.041964832693338394, -0.019334767013788223, 0.007435058709233999, -0.05489945039153099, 0.06773733347654343, -0.030658764764666557, 0.03893093764781952, -0.008000903762876987, -0.04164016991853714, 0.05889267101883888, 0.005084020085632801, -0.014515052549540997, 0.0200408473610878, 0.01748020388185978, -0.02339188940823078, 0.01816452294588089, -0.03261399641633034, -0.01564873568713665, 0.02858765609562397, -0.011216321028769016, -0.05112169310450554, 0.0005061039119027555, 0.0214431993663311, -0.03209114819765091, 0.030271515250205994, 0.05801960825920105, 0.06798359006643295, 0.013078578747808933, -0.014300609938800335, 0.04598711058497429, 0.0012594590662047267, 0.040609486401081085, -0.03777448087930679, 0.05629822611808777, 0.03647492080926895, -0.020095275714993477, 0.031615376472473145, -0.02342170663177967, -0.003944993019104004, -0.03862470015883446, -0.03282325714826584, 0.05490214377641678, -0.07366269081830978, -0.08197280764579773, 0.0673031359910965, -0.04204598814249039, -0.030680786818265915, -0.04610499367117882, -0.0438474602997303, -0.035341545939445496, 0.007211938966065645, -0.008547165431082249, -0.0693219006061554, -0.005950458813458681, -0.030551539734005928, -0.04262616112828255, 0.014964807778596878, 0.0011079668765887618, -0.009500302374362946, -0.024370698258280754, 0.00213936110958457, -0.07537174969911575, -0.0037179067730903625, 0.014285564422607422, -0.004230627790093422, -0.04441351816058159, 0.03544115275144577, -0.010099399834871292, 0.01236558984965086, -0.030342813581228256, -0.0004032279539387673, 0.01063961535692215, 0.0174066461622715, 0.007485447451472282, 0.01175282895565033, -0.021008674055337906, -0.0020324289798736572, 0.022249195724725723, -0.008972769603133202, 0.014736372977495193, -0.015207341872155666, 0.025837717577815056, 0.0906008705496788, 0.0193029697984457, -0.03635542094707489, 0.027986416593194008, 0.04733622819185257, -0.07627291977405548, -0.05514191463589668, 0.03491142764687538, -0.0034154769964516163, 0.02478833869099617, 0.043382253497838974, 0.0117665845900774, -0.08322644233703613, -0.02822001464664936, -0.025593314319849014, 0.0006508316146209836, 0.03926660865545273, -0.007191993296146393, 0.0022289177868515253, -0.0271085686981678, -0.0586099848151207, 0.03160320967435837, 0.01958933100104332, -0.022364700213074684, 0.013011961244046688, -0.0027007455937564373, 0.0420568510890007, -0.023432420566678047, 0.07332899421453476, -0.00641702301800251, 0.009528890252113342, 0.015392230823636055, -0.05037597566843033, -0.03781343251466751, -0.009086866863071918, 0.013677968643605709, -0.014530261978507042, 0.028544709086418152, -0.0005887235747650266, -0.06990859657526016, -0.02587425895035267, -0.03600404039025307, -0.010447824373841286, 0.04827270284295082, -0.010077734477818012, -0.061050817370414734, -0.021071782335639, -0.006704735569655895, 0.05550521984696388, -0.010816266760230064, 0.06361556798219681, -0.047932859510183334, 0.057065993547439575, -0.02136327140033245, -0.05076851323246956, -0.03779472038149834, 0.018882593140006065, -0.040634363889694214, -0.0073247309774160385, -0.008700946345925331, 0.05670616030693054, 0.01915215700864792, 0.025967009365558624, -0.02531653456389904, 0.01974407210946083, 0.0639663115143776, 0.007687097880989313, 0.019983990117907524, 0.01345585472881794, 0.024646690115332603, 0.0452611967921257, -0.021267002448439598, 0.03054666891694069, -0.06136847287416458, -0.005556443706154823, -0.020556770265102386, 0.02122301608324051, 0.008622009307146072, -0.07116302847862244, 0.0036629384849220514, -0.10495965927839279, 0.016102610155940056, -0.07255633920431137, 0.016801506280899048, 0.011880867183208466, 0.03740191459655762, -0.01039904449135065, 0.005116461776196957, 0.022945145145058632, -0.010282672941684723, -0.01226422842592001, -0.06210377812385559, -0.017317762598395348, -0.0459294319152832, -0.0017410798463970423, 0.08472899347543716, 0.06931003928184509, -0.02180955559015274, 0.043612122535705566, 0.0025247849989682436, 0.028562739491462708, -0.03923684358596802, -0.018087707459926605, 0.036880385130643845, -0.03031187504529953, -0.06329353153705597, -0.08381935209035873, 0.022027980536222458, 0.0031535751186311245, 0.009058278053998947, -0.06489688158035278, -0.04748930409550667, -0.03964575380086899, 0.08626077324151993, 0.024293340742588043, -0.0006097731529735029, 0.020245574414730072, -0.036853305995464325, 0.07950787246227264, -0.042075250297784805, -0.0066829766146838665, -0.07128296047449112, 0.01567283645272255, -0.03857557475566864, -0.010515683330595493, 0.03254273533821106, 0.03223717585206032, 0.020093893632292747, -0.02392650581896305, 0.027361946180462837, -0.028765588998794556, -0.009997308254241943, -0.020063962787389755, -0.012182327918708324, 0.06154901534318924, -0.020133528858423233, 0.009594772011041641, -0.05634196847677231, 0.008274341933429241, 0.015766989439725876, -0.005382738076150417, -0.004042654298245907, 0.02645304799079895, -0.01165507361292839, -0.045628465712070465, 0.05894710496068001, 0.03059685416519642, 0.024617841467261314, 0.009617766365408897, 0.02275683730840683, 0.026952363550662994, -0.011785645969212055, 0.0031416004057973623, -0.011925185099244118, 0.044970884919166565, 0.007992434315383434, 0.004526523407548666, 0.014087057672441006, 0.017082814127206802, -0.01319971401244402, -0.04059803858399391, 0.017810232937335968, -0.02753392979502678, -0.008971243165433407, -0.0004594813217408955, -0.029003040865063667, 0.03709710016846657, -0.038414403796195984, 0.002008839277550578, 0.03526688739657402, -0.049225207418203354, 0.0013577559730038047, 0.023640522733330727, 0.017173128202557564, 0.0013539863284677267, 0.038268208503723145, -0.003085481468588114, -0.01111315656453371, -0.03356315940618515, 0.019574305042624474, -0.0437743104994297, -0.04867896810173988, 0.04790330305695534, -0.03163043037056923, 0.010996370576322079, 0.002304366324096918, 0.0428280346095562, 0.030435936525464058, -0.01487198006361723, 0.02254580892622471, -0.060271937400102615, 0.08399876207113266, 0.026681791990995407, -0.041139472275972366, -0.013400795869529247, -0.026156699284911156, 0.016893398016691208, 0.0210571326315403, 0.016806257888674736, -0.0031153929885476828, -0.012128861621022224, -0.023069757968187332, -0.02591724693775177, 0.029339753091335297, 0.0030806472059339285, 0.04868963733315468, -0.028459489345550537, 0.018944591283798218, 0.02228718250989914, -0.07211092114448547, 0.024916158989071846, 0.06999602913856506, 0.0636243149638176, -0.004242958966642618, -0.033247821033000946, -0.0305313803255558, -0.010560965165495872, 0.011697163805365562, -0.02378496155142784, 0.03283533453941345, -0.022929463535547256, -0.04003944247961044, -0.018924331292510033, 0.0326986201107502, -0.006616880185902119, -0.023085974156856537, 0.02907630428671837, -0.028305187821388245, -0.020255427807569504, -0.009280536323785782, -0.04381129890680313, -0.047346193343400955, 0.04900047555565834, 0.022301968187093735, 0.014811956323683262, -0.0037558923941105604, -0.05851438269019127, -0.03711764141917229, -0.009855353273451328, 0.020429717376828194, 0.011688890866935253, 0.08914240449666977, -0.005390943493694067, 0.04808608815073967, 0.0801776647567749, -0.0012822035932913423, -0.0000966476509347558, 0.03279508277773857, -0.004707123152911663, -0.046222083270549774, -0.011333446018397808, -0.039993368089199066, -0.0238911472260952, 0.011867450550198555, -0.018357329070568085, 0.032262615859508514, 0.012797369621694088, 0.028270695358514786, 0.02331501431763172, 0.037181463092565536, 0.04680271074175835, 0.039275143295526505, -0.008164267987012863, -0.03462405502796173, 0.03833257406949997, -0.05563656613230705, 0.035648658871650696, 0.018327606841921806, 0.03051343746483326, 0.02618955448269844, 0.04272922873497009, 0.010240591131150723, 0.04715632647275925, 0.009610561653971672, 0.022877132520079613, 0.05278865247964859, -0.07355064153671265, -0.007814358919858932, -0.05565952509641647, 0.014593769796192646, -0.008525975048542023, -0.03588050603866577, 0.053873855620622635, 0.053486570715904236, 0.00779432849958539, 0.06029198318719864, 0.031505048274993896, -0.020652705803513527, -0.08822215348482132, -0.01221471093595028, 0.05148692429065704, -0.024761369451880455, -0.05514167994260788, 0.021574465557932854, 0.04134737327694893, 0.0058578564785420895, -0.06433289498090744, -0.001557874958962202, -0.026256145909428596, -0.030752070248126984, -0.03410910442471504, 0.01774756796658039, -0.01468427013605833, -0.027414515614509583, -0.06756536662578583, -0.02417856641113758, 0.03386965021491051, 0.054309770464897156, -0.005865455139428377, 0.04534824937582016, -0.007103236857801676, -0.06418104469776154, 0.04947782680392265, 0.0039011172484606504, -0.04618166387081146, 0.00010508301784284413, 0.0035896182525902987, -0.006404086481779814, 0.03207525238394737, 0.03715067356824875, 0.035922497510910034, 0.015481332316994667, -0.08990417420864105, -0.011427134275436401, 0.04221690818667412, 0.032610081136226654, 0.015103543177247047, -0.002186801750212908, -0.0028066120576113462, 0.025232380256056786, -0.05542086064815521, 0.026175551116466522, 0.010797109454870224, 0.01629447191953659, 0.05162816494703293, 0.015613088384270668, -0.043252117931842804, 0.047002289444208145, -0.04606236517429352, -0.030047787353396416, 0.0065795318223536015, 0.05487610399723053, -0.014418493956327438, -0.010170702822506428, 0.034688130021095276, -0.08324641734361649, 0.015538601204752922, 0.0434265173971653, -0.044334523379802704, 0.001875613466836512, 0.01637086272239685, -0.04392571002244949, -0.021508462727069855, 0.018711062148213387, -0.04052430018782616, 0.004771368578076363, -0.011957108043134212, 0.005349256098270416, 0.015588736161589622, 0.02848558872938156, 0.005063063930720091, 0.0050273858942091465, -0.03859825059771538, -0.020621787756681442, -0.028529852628707886, 0.02687089517712593, -0.027369793504476547, -0.03052385337650776, -0.026388561353087425, -0.044197648763656616, 0.02034776844084263, -0.017628269270062447, -0.014101940207183361, -0.006447679828852415, -0.03727451711893082, 0.013830980286002159, -0.0016675734659656882, 0.06958306580781937, 0.05228106677532196, -0.04830583557486534, -0.04996515065431595, 0.018168693408370018, -0.0013913565780967474, -0.0063184411264956, 0.017171500250697136, -0.05176926404237747, -0.052241042256355286, 0.00975910946726799, -0.02937188185751438, 0.021026594564318657, -0.008201250806450844, 0.040977343916893005, 0.10156501084566116, -0.056807007640600204, -0.09678292274475098, 0.02258756197988987, -0.058352481573820114, 0.020474005490541458, 0.04726487025618553, -0.03750510513782501, -0.02868684194982052, -0.01955072209239006, 0.05893872678279877, -0.009692085906863213, 0.037708546966314316, 0.013652609661221504, -0.06312503665685654, 0.01615852490067482, -0.012316014617681503, -0.02950105257332325, -0.021076016128063202, 0.02273237332701683 ]
<p>As Wikipedia explains, one photon passing through a crystal sometimes down-converts to two photons. Wikipedia says total energy and momentum are conserved by just considering the three photon states; is Wikipedia wrong here?</p> <p>It seems a phonon (or something else) is needed too. If Wikipedia is right, can you provide 3 example (non-parallel) momenta vectors so that I can see my logic mistake?</p>
g4021
[ 0.026725297793745995, 0.02797323651611805, -0.005258928518742323, -0.0008788796258158982, 0.05417408049106598, -0.011259070597589016, 0.062009092420339584, 0.088204026222229, -0.006215945817530155, 0.02005479484796524, -0.001496335957199335, -0.015318733640015125, -0.08400203287601471, -0.02360956370830536, -0.04186201095581055, 0.011743159033358097, 0.0897875428199768, 0.01670181006193161, 0.015764722600579262, 0.05775659158825874, -0.10298538953065872, 0.0056661562994122505, -0.06773983687162399, -0.06241437792778015, -0.0356227308511734, 0.0437198244035244, -0.007757637184113264, -0.09278784692287445, -0.05139024928212166, -0.0020651957020163536, 0.028640082105994225, -0.046531178057193756, 0.002663486870005727, -0.044132769107818604, 0.021115243434906006, 0.0017858837964013219, 0.08862531185150146, 0.003882535733282566, 0.019275905564427376, 0.021576369181275368, 0.031371861696243286, -0.009397739544510841, -0.03310135751962662, -0.029800765216350555, -0.0006334949866868556, -0.02132447436451912, -0.019647536799311638, -0.044658828526735306, -0.020259255543351173, -0.02315596677362919, 0.04896409437060356, 0.045864805579185486, 0.07971643656492233, 0.033269185572862625, 0.04223007708787918, 0.021164005622267723, 0.015626732259988785, -0.026851773262023926, 0.09471745789051056, 0.012756160460412502, -0.010205929167568684, -0.04354718327522278, -0.011547813192009926, 0.049199510365724564, 0.07052791118621826, -0.005148346535861492, -0.055558186024427414, -0.010538008995354176, 0.0074525075033307076, 0.018817732110619545, 0.01854941062629223, 0.0030702720396220684, 0.014225314371287823, -0.024970218539237976, 0.029710279777646065, -0.009576668031513691, -0.04397737234830856, -0.056936901062726974, -0.01625194400548935, 0.016337789595127106, -0.025340018793940544, 0.03333262726664543, 0.08049666881561279, -0.01687832921743393, 0.07202520221471786, -0.005948442965745926, -0.02800937183201313, 0.03389517217874527, -0.03255786374211311, -0.06025419384241104, 0.014924773946404457, -0.02244085818529129, 0.06015444174408913, -0.01893071085214615, 0.0005969501216895878, -0.0015005278401076794, -0.035837508738040924, 0.08555475622415543, 0.028544971719384193, 0.032840993255376816, -0.03534283861517906, -0.016744714230298996, -0.012425466440618038, 0.002499850234016776, 0.04788753017783165, -0.010829320177435875, 0.028974175453186035, -0.006242025643587112, 0.00018762884428724647, 0.023935360834002495, -0.04474075138568878, 0.0021061766892671585, -0.03529809042811394, -0.007772755343466997, -0.0760951116681099, -0.05048571899533272, 0.087722547352314, -0.003913270775228739, 0.009210297837853432, 0.032193806022405624, 0.04858028143644333, 0.004218145273625851, 0.008113966323435307, 0.09775996208190918, -0.02296026051044464, 0.051765456795692444, -0.028789497911930084, -0.003935021348297596, -0.019612837582826614, 0.009337185882031918, -0.0278976671397686, 0.04580216854810715, -0.008036607876420021, -0.006504715420305729, 0.02193417400121689, 0.012643372640013695, 0.01561729982495308, 0.03787796571850777, 0.0052130939438939095, 0.03907764330506325, -0.011625287123024464, -0.03539120405912399, -0.04680972173810005, -0.0666051059961319, -0.021472955122590065, -0.01557568833231926, -0.013340159319341183, 0.002476924564689398, 0.0015668484847992659, -0.006495988927781582, 0.04007773473858833, 0.07739462703466415, 0.04692862927913666, 0.0059415618889033794, 0.014584332704544067, -0.029156671836972237, 0.07758516073226929, -0.03535226732492447, 0.0022346102632582188, 0.06319332867860794, 0.03162931278347969, 0.015433399938046932, -0.0213625468313694, -0.027567163109779358, -0.009511019103229046, -0.01805831491947174, 0.041655283421278, -0.10238125175237656, -0.04608916863799095, -0.005559961311519146, 0.009689903818070889, -0.04435581713914871, -0.03131328523159027, 0.04940279200673103, -0.005359695293009281, 0.06278979778289795, 0.02340443804860115, -0.009100217372179031, 0.02040453627705574, -0.004223969765007496, -0.007284949067980051, 0.007219116203486919, 0.011733448132872581, 0.004863878712058067, 0.03667651489377022, 0.04914132133126259, -0.049549899995326996, 0.056476760655641556, -0.05360991507768631, 0.011211027391254902, 0.013956569135189056, 0.024138282984495163, 0.012989025563001633, -0.012141703628003597, -0.01225394569337368, -0.004263234790414572, 0.014355617575347424, -0.03953618183732033, -0.04356991499662399, 0.025274991989135742, -0.037566568702459335, -0.005782516207545996, 0.014477205462753773, 0.011595448479056358, 0.04253574460744858, 0.036326248198747635, -0.019007567316293716, 0.051923856139183044, -0.019309408962726593, -0.013484162278473377, 0.029258986935019493, 0.00893231201916933, -0.0016968164127320051, 0.0054025715216994286, 0.015310230664908886, -0.02592436596751213, 0.02587919495999813, -0.0031662590336054564, -0.039832379668951035, 0.0035388271789997816, -0.08201441913843155, -0.009620758704841137, 0.07102421671152115, -0.020521461963653564, -0.030992574989795685, 0.012287700548768044, -0.022997314110398293, 0.014659706503152847, 0.023362649604678154, 0.026972617954015732, -0.02687351033091545, 0.02723628096282482, -0.02696939744055271, -0.052546177059412, 0.05988318473100662, 0.06791692972183228, -0.05231999233365059, 0.02573583647608757, -0.006533627863973379, -0.016887176781892776, 0.028241105377674103, -0.019270475953817368, -0.027196716517210007, -0.0044254157692193985, 0.0390796884894371, -0.020633704960346222, 0.00999804399907589, 0.011282579973340034, -0.013983098790049553, 0.014609921723604202, 0.08184207230806351, -0.03634214401245117, 0.017350345849990845, -0.004754485096782446, -0.02227393351495266, -0.0005989454803057015, 0.012026306241750717, 0.043083351105451584, -0.04450755566358566, 0.0034430683590471745, 0.04245670139789581, -0.07456272840499878, -0.007387753110378981, -0.04850329831242561, -0.038747381418943405, -0.021828074008226395, 0.013625409454107285, 0.01259638648480177, -0.010999893769621849, 0.0046014077961444855, -0.04523639380931854, 0.04295378923416138, 0.07939168065786362, -0.007179240230470896, 0.020767446607351303, -0.009760817512869835, 0.027382029220461845, -0.01782638393342495, -0.016864720731973648, -0.038826581090688705, -0.05287758260965347, 0.01314801350235939, -0.03900795802474022, -0.051455412060022354, 0.025259384885430336, -0.026526568457484245, -0.01555000152438879, -0.027376443147659302, 0.018038861453533173, 0.033371854573488235, -0.03421897068619728, 0.04561978578567505, 0.06788969784975052, 0.03252672776579857, -0.01519028004258871, -0.017474912106990814, 0.025051549077033997, -0.08295068889856339, -0.04208941012620926, 0.10623720288276672, 0.019544411450624466, -0.011697331443428993, 0.03444252163171768, 0.006171342916786671, 0.054158661514520645, 0.07600051909685135, -0.07283830642700195, -0.026416178792715073, 0.015601099468767643, 0.002850064542144537, 0.018564049154520035, 0.04786128178238869, 0.003456951817497611, 0.034443508833646774, -0.046614453196525574, -0.032799478620290756, -0.020886242389678955, 0.015394379384815693, -0.0027802102267742157, 0.04017683118581772, -0.03840213268995285, 0.04197022691369057, 0.03746280074119568, -0.018624579533934593, 0.013857933692634106, 0.03062385693192482, -0.09394178539514542, 0.022972559556365013, -0.03265281766653061, -0.015623688697814941, -0.020802916958928108, -0.05216732993721962, -0.04643792286515236, 0.012214119546115398, 0.006093970499932766, -0.022145148366689682, -0.012654240243136883, -0.006419493816792965, 0.05092532932758331, 0.008513359352946281, -0.03049599565565586, -0.02331695519387722, -0.02018936164677143, 0.040125757455825806, 0.03731623664498329, -0.030114971101284027, -0.03884269297122955, 0.025471949949860573, 0.0003249043948017061, -0.026257120072841644, 0.010443114675581455, -0.006237778812646866, -0.0205845907330513, -0.00007703619485255331, -0.06965995579957962, 0.038582805544137955, -0.006645334418863058, 0.059623025357723236, 0.0301685631275177, 0.010965685360133648, 0.028908520936965942, -0.0532146580517292, 0.05539436638355255, -0.03541148826479912, -0.04126724600791931, 0.06308858841657639, -0.06610920280218124, -0.0015805409057065845, 0.024728519842028618, 0.019882502034306526, 0.0007834658026695251, -0.07461506873369217, -0.07105240225791931, -0.006518241483718157, 0.005067829508334398, -0.031015845015645027, 0.028434382751584053, -0.039631638675928116, -0.07249480485916138, 0.06043123081326485, 0.0030127556528896093, -0.007185229100286961, 0.04800418019294739, 0.02837499789893627, 0.022491490468382835, 0.04831821843981743, -0.054514046758413315, 0.041012242436409, -0.04975200816988945, 0.043656203895807266, 0.023374615237116814, -0.009655962698161602, -0.04577077925205231, -0.02021739073097706, 0.032112233340740204, -0.05555638298392296, 0.05250759795308113, -0.05881045013666153, -0.005567708984017372, 0.07328309118747711, -0.031628191471099854, -0.0007483933004550636, -0.04422866925597191, -0.04292188957333565, 0.009214788675308228, 0.05304226279258728, 0.02896995097398758, -0.030668964609503746, -0.01707475073635578, 0.022621190175414085, -0.007120105903595686, -0.008291149511933327, 0.0324670746922493, -0.006030131597071886, 0.01718883588910103, -0.014033687300980091, -0.030966168269515038, -0.05470528453588486, 0.02759251743555069, 0.024984069168567657, 0.047525372356176376, 0.04246494546532631, 0.0039804838597774506, 0.016114437952637672, -0.006081020925194025, 0.12283316254615784, 0.07491417229175568, -0.018397748470306396, -0.06208089366555214, -0.011928274296224117, 0.08735806494951248, 0.026638342067599297, 0.034869495779275894, 0.009015342220664024, 0.0004930265131406486, 0.022925138473510742, -0.02576639875769615, 0.05904850363731384, 0.009392112493515015, 0.05802321061491966, 0.06455595791339874, -0.0006138047319836915, -0.01982269436120987, -0.004429875873029232, 0.009068778716027737, 0.023586135357618332, -0.05525162070989609, -0.05530343949794769, 0.017417848110198975, -0.06457892805337906, 0.0016480821650475264, 0.042776528745889664, -0.06077073886990547, -0.008598876185715199, 0.03751540556550026, 0.05459628626704216, 0.0019589303992688656, 0.019374512135982513, 0.027355223894119263, 0.05943430960178375, -0.05291895568370819, 0.011654391884803772, 0.01311443094164133, -0.0023214765824377537, 0.021898265928030014, -0.013214128091931343, -0.0464160330593586, 0.01472549606114626, -0.003718047868460417, -0.03814615309238434, 0.09669756144285202, -0.048692092299461365, -0.04643740504980087, 0.027248794212937355, 0.0055863820016384125, -0.05783538147807121, -0.022461937740445137, 0.01609131135046482, 0.020590856671333313, -0.019196942448616028, 0.003115392057225108, 0.04402325674891472, 0.028804512694478035, 0.029289383441209793, -0.00904178712517023, -0.003685247851535678, -0.06440899521112442, 0.009092556312680244, -0.01768958941102028, 0.015567662194371223, -0.03866131231188774, 0.0010722485603764653, -0.01765209436416626, 0.039899133145809174, 0.015791630372405052, 0.018424857407808304, 0.030213341116905212, -0.01338876597583294, -0.0032547416631132364, 0.0066261859610676765, -0.04358431324362755, -0.02080768533051014, -0.02045801281929016, -0.047081682831048965, 0.005543805193156004, -0.03015812113881111, 0.06548189371824265, 0.02322283387184143, -0.029164418578147888, 0.006616609171032906, 0.017638366669416428, -0.020570337772369385, -0.009884356521070004, -0.0010514284949749708, 0.01061964686959982, -0.043471809476614, 0.015997620299458504, -0.015939107164740562, 0.011651153676211834, -0.0407157801091671, -0.006783905904740095, 0.01402781717479229, 0.004913941025733948, -0.06647074967622757, -0.008721698075532913, -0.006105499342083931, -0.06684599816799164, -0.04196666553616524, 0.02041763812303543, -0.010776914656162262, -0.020733049139380455, -0.030518658459186554, -0.014761245809495449, 0.047554049640893936, 0.014478396624326706, -0.04184634983539581, 0.0005700294277630746, 0.02864193543791771, 0.007774997968226671, 0.008919977582991123, -0.05168328434228897, -0.02711569331586361, -0.0009173423750326037, 0.08538664132356644, -0.0013982357922941446, 0.012644201517105103, -0.002776037435978651, -0.03964608907699585, 0.0010097918566316366, -0.025554213672876358, -0.0021864683367311954, -0.031212082132697105, -0.01920471526682377, -0.05083030089735985, 0.0025763525627553463, 0.016304250806570053, 0.019341975450515747, -0.013785080052912235, 0.04000530019402504, 0.0015608933754265308, -0.01509230025112629, 0.048610344529151917, 0.03436126932501793, -0.005790171679109335, 0.002121026162058115, -0.04820747300982475, -0.029309198260307312, 0.00851256214082241, 0.027176329866051674, -0.034513235092163086, 0.03846921771764755, 0.02892383746802807, -0.03766384720802307, 0.03938686475157738, -0.02166556380689144, 0.028875621035695076, -0.040536414831876755, -0.062228281050920486, -0.0627436488866806, -0.03174860402941704, 0.0030235035810619593, -0.0036158484872430563, 0.04720931500196457, -0.0011908994056284428, -0.026344960555434227, -0.007981165312230587, -0.013781831599771976, -0.024317573755979538, 0.008665927685797215, 0.012600782327353954, 0.015451289713382721, -0.001239313860423863, -0.07553856074810028, -0.007653063628822565, 0.021512089297175407, 0.0031441471073776484, 0.010724213905632496, -0.04681398719549179, -0.04714684933423996, 0.0512303002178669, 0.031875696033239365, -0.03047286719083786, 0.0392945371568203, -0.05979909747838974, 0.011476555839180946, 0.10216441750526428, -0.010306861251592636, -0.01721736043691635, -0.00963680911809206, 0.014327993616461754, -0.02794012799859047, -0.0020785199012607336, 0.0075013781897723675, 0.0019074775045737624, -0.008023838512599468, -0.060473158955574036, 0.019984431564807892, 0.026031900197267532, -0.007418319582939148, 0.02985185943543911, 0.0020319947507232428, -0.044933855533599854, 0.018223553895950317, -0.019539879634976387, 0.012870969250798225, 0.039768703281879425, -0.06762824952602386, 0.04486240819096565, 0.05140658840537071, 0.0377105213701725, -0.0057076928205788136, -0.017111342400312424, -0.03513726964592934, 0.019555551931262016, 0.013140451163053513, 0.04230012744665146, -0.048033855855464935, -0.036888133734464645, 0.03279479593038559, -0.025291549041867256, 0.03381257504224777, 0.042747996747493744, 0.03324250876903534, 0.06750757992267609, 0.0026014414615929127, 0.07888752967119217, 0.000031086157832760364, -0.031074799597263336, -0.007133131381124258, -0.028730010613799095, -0.007695580832660198, 0.013544606044888496, -0.03620867431163788, 0.03275498375296593, -0.04642689973115921, 0.008197675459086895, 0.034056149423122406, 0.04182548075914383, 0.01662280037999153, -0.04877864941954613, 0.0036259605549275875, -0.0737437903881073, 0.02769479528069496, -0.015433584339916706, 0.00031468618544749916, 0.01478201150894165, 0.0033247030805796385, -0.07531916350126266, 0.04996129125356674, -0.01734781824052334, -0.01753338612616062, -0.009362240321934223, -0.052184853702783585, 0.011749586090445518, -0.024065624922513962, -0.025179753080010414, 0.019366713240742683, 0.006382310763001442, -0.053471021354198456, -0.03183072432875633, -0.013519089668989182, 0.02911728248000145, -0.00767461908981204, -0.05471018701791763, -0.0038494737818837166, 0.03860528767108917, -0.0024344767443835735, -0.011163532733917236, -0.00931453611701727, 0.042335961014032364, -0.010017548687756062, 0.020781973376870155, 0.05437111109495163, -0.04664996266365051, -0.01544023398309946, 0.06431443244218826, 0.060602232813835144, 0.0034905034117400646, -0.009160979650914669, 0.021894948557019234, -0.04597080498933792, -0.016368748620152473, 0.012832284905016422, 0.02179204858839512, 0.0062126885168254375, -0.004626428708434105, 0.0372886098921299, -0.06515421718358994, 0.041534360498189926, -0.004430235363543034, -0.013876531273126602, -0.024234389886260033, 0.011445957235991955, -0.005377552006393671, 0.037886641919612885, -0.029583640396595, -0.03787299990653992, -0.0015536631690338254, 0.01348393876105547, -0.0058609009720385075, -0.01595103181898594, -0.005676052067428827, -0.06670361012220383, 0.0112863564863801, 0.019892241805791855, -0.026971904560923576, 0.03032086230814457, 0.02345512993633747, -0.0152565473690629, -0.0027070757932960987, -0.04346988722681999, -0.01900961622595787, -0.0569966584444046, -0.019394325092434883, -0.03185384348034859, 0.03070298209786415, -0.0057577104307711124, -0.03198644518852234, 0.008785989135503769, 0.023380097001791, -0.017739947885274887, -0.042388711124658585, -0.031572841107845306, -0.06548198312520981, 0.035358697175979614, -0.02134975604712963, -0.003066102508455515, 0.016189949586987495, 0.0931754857301712, -0.03408227488398552, -0.016698146238923073, -0.0023837359622120857, 0.038107436150312424, 0.004275509621948004, 0.040457986295223236, -0.026851966977119446, 0.04744115471839905, 0.011379245668649673, -0.025317490100860596, -0.02674168534576893, -0.03943488746881485, 0.028933212161064148, -0.027225209400057793, -0.023015731945633888, -0.012148598209023476, -0.02769690565764904, -0.04639141261577606, -0.011323542334139347 ]
<p>My sister asked me this question and I keep thinking that water would conduct heat much faster than sand. Hence the energy transfer of heat across the lake does not allow it to heat up soon. Sand on the other hand is probably a bad conductor of heat and hence more heat energy is held up by each grain of sand. </p> <p>But then with water there is also convection which perhaps plays a role. </p> <p>I would like to see what the experts say. My thinking is quite informal. </p>
g4022
[ 0.08765815943479538, 0.02345062606036663, 0.027933139353990555, 0.019233666360378265, -0.002308142138645053, 0.033073049038648605, 0.021701674908399582, 0.01048970315605402, -0.03735784813761711, -0.03663227707147598, 0.02103927731513977, 0.021430959925055504, 0.03430895507335663, 0.061807893216609955, -0.016755864024162292, -0.011816957965493202, 0.023720337077975273, -0.03288101777434349, -0.007452665362507105, 0.0860835611820221, -0.038466621190309525, -0.02587045170366764, 0.012664794921875, 0.022398456931114197, -0.12516918778419495, -0.0374719575047493, -0.0182967372238636, -0.039317868649959564, 0.012736146338284016, -0.03136623278260231, 0.07423914968967438, 0.00020293338457122445, 0.017197679728269577, -0.08967433869838715, -0.052450671792030334, 0.0061835236847400665, -0.02444373071193695, -0.017734317108988762, 0.03720676153898239, -0.03661871328949928, -0.02456193044781685, -0.006724542006850243, -0.044061966240406036, 0.03915395215153694, 0.008058401755988598, -0.0597197525203228, -0.009327053092420101, 0.03303508087992668, -0.048240020871162415, 0.00010930464486591518, -0.033185817301273346, -0.04394840821623802, 0.05613408982753754, 0.07200835645198822, -0.021639905869960785, -0.027364064007997513, -0.05805227905511856, -0.008318102918565273, 0.026873605325818062, 0.02298486977815628, -0.0029441150836646557, 0.036079827696084976, -0.036817438900470734, -0.03713574633002281, 0.017558835446834564, 0.0322672501206398, -0.04468001425266266, 0.027867184951901436, 0.05061732977628708, 0.0018365405267104506, 0.02786538377404213, 0.021554214879870415, -0.039241015911102295, -0.05388380214571953, -0.01656046137213707, 0.002378495642915368, 0.03221135586500168, -0.040725283324718475, -0.0039566513150930405, -0.02781662531197071, 0.02049262449145317, 0.007420946378260851, 0.013329786248505116, -0.0183765459805727, 0.05794047191739082, 0.0041459547355771065, -0.013698779046535492, 0.017488159239292145, -0.006796492729336023, 0.02594563737511635, -0.02443726733326912, -0.005726942792534828, 0.09925037622451782, 0.0321040004491806, -0.021461665630340576, -0.034283824265003204, -0.005132322199642658, -0.013546607457101345, -0.04269270971417427, 0.024689598008990288, 0.002930158982053399, -0.04458608850836754, 0.06977596133947372, -0.002990816021338105, 0.014560865238308907, -0.004746108781546354, -0.05968071147799492, 0.02886621654033661, -0.01267101801931858, 0.04631461575627327, 0.06109544634819031, -0.004606544505804777, -0.053504578769207, -0.006864467170089483, -0.001348157529719174, 0.00983941275626421, 0.04520072042942047, 0.02169583924114704, 0.030187973752617836, 0.005641200114041567, -0.037068434059619904, 0.008682656101882458, -0.02230643667280674, 0.024515127763152122, -0.02112417295575142, 0.01894071325659752, 0.050417181104421616, -0.0047509861178696156, 0.0051948088221251965, 0.040542326867580414, -0.04448753967881203, 0.03711593523621559, -0.0027306720148772, 0.01600104570388794, -0.02361925318837166, -0.022703692317008972, -0.05684863403439522, -0.006143404636532068, -0.007842926308512688, -0.04206441342830658, 0.01956215873360634, -0.015456034801900387, -0.008108969777822495, -0.0007610969478264451, -0.02151397429406643, 0.05113639310002327, -0.026803407818078995, 0.08152006566524506, 0.005602239165455103, 0.04124167561531067, 0.013930186629295349, 0.021179838106036186, 0.002835221588611603, -0.01301212515681982, 0.08266203850507736, 0.03338439762592316, 0.052698638290166855, 0.00786551833152771, 0.07380132377147675, 0.002263291971758008, -0.0021961366292089224, 0.025540802627801895, 0.01233343593776226, 0.005128465127199888, -0.06723037362098694, -0.015056625008583069, 0.038056135177612305, -0.011368965730071068, -0.03725075349211693, 0.014820389449596405, -0.00962755549699068, 0.00679971557110548, -0.05018039047718048, 0.03959929198026657, 0.03752100467681885, 0.016276273876428604, 0.013786878436803818, 0.013433454558253288, -0.01779252290725708, -0.07828924059867859, -0.055714886635541916, 0.01597338169813156, -0.025240909308195114, -0.07075850665569305, 0.029153482988476753, -0.013636178337037563, -0.004661785438656807, -0.0766778290271759, -0.05563310533761978, -0.034659091383218765, -0.053144216537475586, -0.04554619640111923, -0.04994448646903038, 0.010718070901930332, 0.01744561642408371, 0.0171439778059721, 0.0018723801476880908, -0.01498864870518446, -0.05215729773044586, 0.013384169898927212, 0.020550213754177094, 0.02779044397175312, 0.029939129948616028, -0.026045259088277817, 0.02515939064323902, 0.05194462463259697, -0.03055405057966709, -0.0028267591260373592, 0.02689778245985508, -0.0637102872133255, 0.0007067722035571933, 0.03643709421157837, 0.001379457418806851, 0.0013755692634731531, -0.0010716296965256333, 0.047304242849349976, -0.04927181079983711, 0.010658240877091885, -0.028035929426550865, -0.017002616077661514, -0.02285228855907917, 0.01287492923438549, -0.02272830158472061, 0.0037207899149507284, -0.06218106672167778, 0.018482735380530357, 0.00541109312325716, -0.004892905708402395, -0.021867157891392708, 0.06891796737909317, -0.017304226756095886, -0.01673220284283161, 0.03426888585090637, -0.009869840927422047, 0.024267222732305527, 0.06695222854614258, -0.008648477494716644, 0.059591855853796005, 0.04802661016583443, -0.02000860869884491, -0.05200473591685295, 0.03694755584001541, -0.018929366022348404, 0.03175169229507446, 0.04530474916100502, -0.05701669305562973, -0.009333303198218346, -0.023890415206551552, 0.03493349254131317, -0.021277226507663727, 0.04809870570898056, 0.0007077729096636176, -0.015358771197497845, 0.0385308675467968, -0.020548997446894646, -0.041192661970853806, 0.021326404064893723, -0.0027736558113247156, -0.04831577092409134, -0.009167194366455078, 0.0185641311109066, -0.01949252374470234, 0.008884607814252377, -0.04976768419146538, -0.039738044142723083, -0.03709371015429497, -0.04294053465127945, 0.0168333500623703, -0.004434431437402964, -0.012432585470378399, -0.025875357910990715, -0.022263115271925926, 0.006813667248934507, -0.0040168557316064835, -0.0365808829665184, -0.04748604819178581, 0.008187235333025455, 0.014353630132973194, 0.05252357944846153, -0.11396234482526779, 0.05165400356054306, -0.050838932394981384, -0.020722100511193275, 0.049698710441589355, 0.049278631806373596, -0.0516832172870636, 0.0026408133562654257, 0.05856691300868988, 0.033995047211647034, -0.02242622710764408, -0.0045011513866484165, 0.041685108095407486, 0.06736993789672852, -0.017572801560163498, 0.05144136771559715, 0.001763486536219716, 0.029656460508704185, -0.03815784305334091, 0.010448744520545006, -0.01837596297264099, 0.05060296505689621, -0.002951963571831584, -0.01832435466349125, -0.009623954072594643, -0.0022152038291096687, 0.03618693724274635, -0.06102709472179413, 0.0005698190652765334, 0.022375335916876793, -0.07542627304792404, 0.04099573567509651, -0.042767561972141266, -0.06599020957946777, 0.026442328467965126, -0.06707379221916199, -0.014515018090605736, -0.08902108669281006, -0.02057039737701416, 0.04837212339043617, -0.002454656409099698, -0.04758856073021889, 0.04010311886668205, -0.007839848287403584, -0.0031045526266098022, -0.07523266971111298, 0.07431083172559738, 0.04326678812503815, -0.005470608361065388, -0.020628077909350395, 0.025927798822522163, -0.09135018289089203, 0.019514398649334908, -0.045983824878931046, 0.010173670947551727, -0.054978542029857635, -0.004990185145288706, -0.02370193973183632, 0.031718309968709946, -0.01708313636481762, 0.0365135483443737, 0.007934149354696274, 0.0660472884774208, -0.10178685188293457, -0.00442244578152895, 0.020710015669465065, 0.04645891860127449, 0.04006269946694374, -0.04704006016254425, -0.07106859236955643, 0.004600366577506065, 0.02504022978246212, -0.04692043736577034, 0.007905113510787487, -0.023732470348477364, -0.03412483632564545, 0.038330163806676865, -0.041057366877794266, 0.0650114119052887, 0.001357557252049446, 0.06128627434372902, 0.04434823989868164, 0.01968282274901867, 0.028239784762263298, -0.03905985504388809, -0.007434892933815718, 0.055475737899541855, -0.04658647999167442, -0.02299131266772747, -0.05561087653040886, 0.05278179422020912, 0.06621687114238739, 0.010938148014247417, 0.0004942821688018739, 0.05801602825522423, 0.08265457302331924, 0.05899321287870407, 0.0715663880109787, -0.017530808225274086, -0.0281850416213274, -0.015911605209112167, 0.032795242965221405, 0.0034654929768294096, 0.023318666964769363, 0.03316381946206093, -0.055561844259500504, 0.012570006772875786, -0.011579098179936409, 0.009478739462792873, -0.00560262193903327, -0.01733056828379631, 0.0012148418463766575, 0.02725188247859478, -0.0008436273201368749, -0.01998056471347809, -0.010939002968370914, -0.03530796617269516, 0.01930505409836769, 0.03043917566537857, 0.002208720427006483, -0.00114592129830271, -0.03500921279191971, 0.023817816749215126, -0.00027056143153458834, -0.009923361241817474, -0.04321343079209328, -0.006134128198027611, 0.01926828734576702, -0.030339403077960014, -0.06680529564619064, -0.05576436221599579, 0.00815609097480774, -0.009155485779047012, 0.010268179699778557, -0.015012803487479687, -0.027890782803297043, -0.029258806258440018, -0.025103667750954628, 0.0226376261562109, 0.00847320631146431, 0.052421823143959045, -0.01168754231184721, 0.025785179808735847, -0.0535069964826107, -0.011865762062370777, 0.018496261909604073, 0.03315114602446556, 0.03400743752717972, -0.0019389291992411017, -0.0011951487977057695, -0.0015605652006343007, 0.026857832446694374, 0.05767893046140671, -0.018146870657801628, -0.024478409439325333, -0.03643089532852173, 0.04225483536720276, 0.01062002032995224, 0.01884198933839798, 0.0047026206739246845, 0.03559957072138786, -0.011502251029014587, 0.03794286400079727, 0.02875891700387001, 0.02116359956562519, -0.00570012629032135, 0.02482302114367485, 0.01356059405952692, -0.02483062818646431, -0.020824266597628593, -0.10070351511240005, -0.053886789828538895, 0.04511382058262825, -0.03473668545484543, -0.02460690587759018, -0.07616925239562988, 0.00971424300223589, -0.036942239850759506, 0.031076615676283836, -0.02617041952908039, 0.07136169821023941, -0.021908564493060112, 0.030600078403949738, 0.02746010012924671, 0.030071403831243515, -0.005703787785023451, -0.05807268247008324, 0.049252305179834366, -0.03033686988055706, 0.003337199566885829, 0.04024820402264595, 0.07168377935886383, 0.08913715183734894, 0.02744721993803978, 0.05458611249923706, 0.04013286530971527, -0.017826788127422333, 0.008740188553929329, -0.025642814114689827, 0.023656681180000305, -0.03207124024629593, -0.0508916974067688, 0.07002851366996765, 0.030712667852640152, 0.01798749528825283, 0.02305075153708458, 0.030390527099370956, -0.056890036910772324, 0.03644523769617081, 0.006974533200263977, -0.01478559896349907, -0.008203350938856602, -0.005573438946157694, -0.050408706068992615, -0.01422179862856865, -0.0410105399787426, -0.0223650261759758, 0.004307278897613287, 0.014834443107247353, 0.013894142583012581, 0.024992236867547035, 0.03997427225112915, -0.05757346376776695, -0.0169635321944952, -0.0017145900055766106, 0.028873663395643234, 0.07770824432373047, 0.06251344829797745, 0.00017186060722451657, -0.023642726242542267, 0.006663099396973848, 0.005158505402505398, -0.0236667450517416, -0.10410179197788239, -0.058669283986091614, 0.04019470140337944, -0.008333590812981129, 0.028690995648503304, 0.0027496463153511286, 0.08749504387378693, -0.007985680364072323, 0.015026779845356941, -0.026101987808942795, -0.007201895117759705, -0.014722918160259724, -0.009279291145503521, -0.03896896541118622, -0.05499805137515068, 0.021209605038166046, 0.0024551795795559883, -0.00030983545002527535, 0.05225316062569618, 0.023214956745505333, -0.050652991980314255, 0.00043650175211951137, 0.00934034213423729, -0.01437027845531702, 0.009488754905760288, -0.004438078962266445, 0.0018680099165067077, 0.010185904800891876, -0.03373819962143898, -0.0177063699811697, 0.034096505492925644, 0.0776480957865715, 0.014334730803966522, -0.03997404873371124, -0.02975597232580185, -0.061488620936870575, 0.038576848804950714, -0.030084487050771713, 0.005476553924381733, 0.015466835349798203, 0.01635543256998062, -0.04462543874979019, 0.02873792126774788, -0.007848311215639114, 0.012868259102106094, -0.021822962909936905, 0.0031200717203319073, -0.051933713257312775, 0.011670091189444065, 0.05340341106057167, -0.017270924523472786, 0.038674790412187576, 0.023253077641129494, -0.05553417280316353, -0.022569257766008377, -0.06005077436566353, 0.07247380167245865, 0.0040940637700259686, 0.017540009692311287, -0.07238179445266724, 0.03379485756158829, -0.05295748636126518, 0.005698854103684425, 0.0025691771879792213, 0.0086880624294281, -0.008526736870408058, -0.0060822670347988605, -0.022903790697455406, 0.004434393718838692, -0.01508485060185194, -0.012261497788131237, -0.012659762986004353, 0.04520581662654877, -0.004847192205488682, 0.006625469774007797, 0.038379766047000885, 0.036937128752470016, -0.029640821740031242, -0.03108576312661171, -0.013979054056107998, 0.04148659482598305, -0.0035984471905976534, 0.013480570167303085, -0.026513105258345604, 0.007359723560512066, 0.01612258516252041, 0.004660638980567455, -0.014967863447964191, 0.027382051572203636, 0.0002315947349416092, 0.06652909517288208, -0.06704005599021912, 0.002228004625067115, -0.018172260373830795, 0.09042385220527649, 0.02582220546901226, 0.019276438280940056, -0.021060170605778694, 0.008051875047385693, 0.015053852461278439, 0.06086314097046852, 0.010601256974041462, -0.06870454549789429, -0.014673887751996517, -0.006639782804995775, -0.011193281039595604, -0.001892997301183641, -0.011365414597094059, 0.007659695576876402, 0.01154867559671402, 0.00068050401750952, -0.046097755432128906, 0.04005540534853935, 0.029176577925682068, -0.06675582379102707, 0.0673799067735672, 0.059716638177633286, -0.00012453006638679653, 0.053828734904527664, -0.0018131716642528772, 0.03695335611701012, 0.04035273566842079, 0.02040882222354412, -0.040746450424194336, -0.02964942529797554, -0.004607431124895811, -0.02582480013370514, 0.024655956774950027, 0.02331218123435974, -0.003381292102858424, 0.010372046381235123, 0.02610964886844158, -0.014005608856678009, 0.006137656979262829, 0.032098181545734406, -0.08928326517343521, -0.058344483375549316, -0.04455539211630821, -0.009837951511144638, -0.040290266275405884, -0.047357480973005295, 0.00476627005264163, 0.012807135470211506, -0.012504041194915771, -0.03018915466964245, 0.047477081418037415, -0.003404907649382949, 0.014329992234706879, 0.02949347347021103, 0.03328309580683708, 0.022432303056120872, 0.03384030610322952, 0.04326854646205902, 0.047881171107292175, 0.004715295508503914, -0.02463802881538868, 0.021591156721115112, 0.08021189272403717, 0.031922511756420135, -0.06968145817518234, 0.03813793882727623, -0.008773774839937687, -0.029797783121466637, -0.007678805384784937, -0.010576145723462105, 0.00692399637773633, 0.0006054490222595632, 0.011992361396551132, 0.05445301532745361, -0.054477058351039886, 0.013916512951254845, 0.016634084284305573, -0.017533505335450172, 0.03408123180270195, -0.017299331724643707, 0.030573932453989983, 0.005975893698632717, -0.021472418680787086, -0.04883725568652153, 0.014090594835579395, 0.012439035810530186, -0.021105974912643433, 0.014163829386234283, 0.022539129480719566, 0.04027331620454788, -0.002455746755003929, 0.06335489451885223, -0.001153907855041325, -0.030560165643692017, -0.018590284511446953, 0.044509366154670715, 0.02664671093225479, 0.012375378049910069, 0.02085465006530285, -0.011606341227889061, 0.03724066540598869, -0.0574486069381237, -0.05895675718784332, 0.012467780150473118, 0.017631888389587402, -0.04466654360294342, -0.018509406596422195, -0.014364294707775116, -0.01833111234009266, -0.0029768161475658417, -0.045562390238046646, -0.09867077320814133, -0.02187737450003624, -0.01069561392068863, -0.030612587928771973, -0.01662186160683632, -0.0535457506775856, -0.005240496713668108, 0.007670340593904257, 0.011879070661962032, -0.07255937904119492, 0.007590533699840307, 0.008306430652737617, -0.01618107780814171, 0.00790480151772499, -0.03246026858687401, -0.06240807846188545, -0.016085185110569, 0.02307882532477379, 0.011060148477554321, 0.014573291875422001, 0.0350680835545063, 0.0255441814661026, 0.008778052404522896, 0.08841776847839355, -0.006117015145719051, -0.028750553727149963, 0.016670752316713333, -0.051824599504470825, 0.0027654357254505157, -0.005392144899815321, 0.017720989882946014, -0.04756439849734306, 0.01316684391349554, -0.013802601024508476, -0.0813366249203682, -0.024573905393481255, 0.028575871139764786, 0.022074148058891296, -0.011911682784557343, 0.039478302001953125, 0.024043811485171318, -0.025529861450195312, -0.014454459771513939, -0.019138488918542862, 0.0074674333445727825, -0.028143538162112236, 0.01729581318795681, -0.04486905783414841, 0.00924123264849186, -0.0013822310138493776 ]
<p>Consider the following action with a fermionic field $\psi$ and a scalar field $\sigma$, </p> <p>$S = \int d^dx \{ -\bar{\psi}(\gamma^\mu \partial_\mu +\sigma )\psi + \Lambda^{d-4}[ \frac{(\partial_\mu \sigma )^2 + m^2\sigma^2 }{2g^2 } + \frac{\lambda \sigma^4 }{4!g^4 } ] \} - (N'-1)Trln(\gamma^\mu \partial_\mu + \sigma )$</p> <p>Assuming that this has a large-N saddle with uniform $\sigma$ one gets the large-N free energy density as, </p> <p>$E(\sigma) = \Lambda^{d-4}(\frac{m^2\sigma^2}{2g^2} + \frac{\lambda \sigma^4 }{4!g^4 } ) - \frac{N}{2}\int^\Lambda \frac{d^dq}{(2\pi)^d}ln [\frac{q^2 + \sigma^2 }{q^2 } ]$</p> <p>And the large-N saddle value of $\sigma$ is determined by the large-N gap equation, $E'(\sigma)=0$</p> <p>Now from here how do the following conclusions come? </p> <ul> <li>Firstly that a non-trivial solution to the gap equation exists only when, $\frac{m^2}{g^2} &lt; N\Lambda^{4-d}(\frac{1}{(2\pi)^d} \int^\Lambda \frac{d^dk }{ k^2 } ) $ </li> </ul> <p>How does this one come? </p> <ul> <li>Secondly from this apparently follows that the inverse $\sigma$ propagator in the massive phase is, </li> </ul> <p>$\Delta_\sigma^{-1}(p) = \Lambda^{d-4}(\frac{p^2}{g^2} + \frac{\lambda \sigma^2}{3g^4} ) + \frac{N(p^2+4\sigma^2) } {2(2\pi)^d}\int^\Lambda \frac{d^dq }{(q^2+\sigma^2)((p+q)^2 + \sigma^2)} $</p> <p>How does this equation come? </p> <ul> <li><p>Now from this one can show that $\Delta_\sigma \sim \frac{2}{N b(d) p^{d-2} }$</p> <p>From the above it follows that the canonical dimension of $\sigma$ is 1. How does one understand that the mass dimension of the field $\sigma$ does not depend on the space-time dimension? </p></li> <li><p>Now I don't understand this argument which says that now since $[\sigma] =1$, both the terms $(\partial_\mu \sigma)^2$ and $\sigma^4$ are of dimension $4$ and hence for $2\leq d \leq 4$ these terms vanish in the IR critical theory? For this argument to work was it necessary that the IR theory was critical? </p></li> </ul>
g4023
[ -0.007528975140303373, 0.010620378889143467, -0.019605480134487152, -0.043568700551986694, 0.02188947983086109, 0.044916361570358276, 0.03192761540412903, 0.017627257853746414, -0.06343286484479904, 0.04030754417181015, -0.008625458925962448, 0.007065264042466879, 0.0031771038193255663, 0.003618094138801098, 0.04958765581250191, 0.003988801501691341, 0.06109778583049774, -0.02360900491476059, -0.024888671934604645, -0.050979211926460266, -0.044100675731897354, -0.02022971399128437, 0.017613528296351433, -0.023281093686819077, -0.0006875530234538019, -0.030931061133742332, 0.06292450428009033, -0.03508300706744194, 0.05289625748991966, -0.06595798581838608, 0.09017550945281982, 0.005454936996102333, 0.054936956614255905, -0.07391410320997238, -0.05757604539394379, 0.0035945617128163576, 0.06351932138204575, 0.022946732118725777, 0.0021721229422837496, -0.02367880567908287, -0.008262939751148224, -0.06907792389392853, 0.036447059363126755, 0.040067680180072784, 0.014250450767576694, 0.006776906084269285, -0.053639765828847885, 0.017950979992747307, -0.007964442484080791, 0.004630199633538723, 0.01531500369310379, 0.07371092587709427, 0.01339068915694952, -0.0018449946073815227, -0.05798701196908951, 0.03316827490925789, -0.02842196635901928, -0.012968113645911217, 0.07227868586778641, 0.07907550781965256, 0.006549382582306862, -0.05744699016213417, 0.032560255378484726, 0.05337413027882576, 0.044200409203767776, -0.02770395576953888, -0.04280383884906769, -0.037622082978487015, -0.010158112272620201, -0.07485434412956238, -0.029624056071043015, -0.01004139706492424, 0.0053236400708556175, -0.03896354138851166, -0.027846412733197212, 0.07670673727989197, -0.004730568267405033, 0.008108180947601795, -0.04133883863687515, -0.010882743634283543, -0.016413787379860878, -0.012991993688046932, 0.008837249130010605, 0.013361874036490917, 0.052560072392225266, -0.05463857203722, -0.002606819150969386, -0.0029402258805930614, -0.05201184004545212, 0.018860066309571266, 0.0035732733085751534, -0.06043560430407524, -0.017185810953378677, 0.007995200343430042, 0.023183053359389305, 0.04252789542078972, -0.0002111379726557061, 0.060945358127355576, -0.06271256506443024, -0.021851729601621628, 0.00710678705945611, 0.038074515759944916, 0.07664943486452103, 0.0216816496104002, -0.030465655028820038, 0.02381882257759571, -0.012168613262474537, 0.01509606372565031, 0.02956673875451088, 0.07903459668159485, -0.04741628095507622, 0.05171022191643715, -0.016660457476973534, -0.02015206776559353, -0.03243890777230263, 0.007785387337207794, 0.0957963839173317, -0.020065288990736008, -0.025638317689299583, 0.035191409289836884, -0.004801868461072445, -0.0016986671835184097, 0.0428508035838604, 0.051140978932380676, -0.007199589628726244, -0.04544585198163986, -0.011669689789414406, 0.04837111756205559, 0.0005990148638375103, 0.016580956056714058, -0.0061562927439808846, -0.03438515588641167, 0.017475806176662445, 0.04862816259264946, 0.04414156824350357, -0.03187381476163864, -0.04888637736439705, -0.008734357543289661, 0.014678101055324078, -0.006943537853658199, -0.04374813288450241, 0.012204178608953953, -0.02148428000509739, -0.033430036157369614, -0.060412365943193436, -0.003611223539337516, 0.016814202070236206, -0.04903094843029976, -0.007701766677200794, -0.03616243600845337, 0.015255213715136051, 0.02819700352847576, -0.02079315297305584, 0.0024472076911479235, 0.005072405561804771, 0.04744337871670723, 0.009626204147934914, -0.020411642268300056, -0.01002675760537386, 0.002689492190256715, -0.022858034819364548, 0.010515010915696621, 0.039012737572193146, -0.00888032652437687, 0.02065301686525345, -0.01502640638500452, 0.07736635208129883, -0.07903099805116653, -0.007205435540527105, -0.06768593192100525, -0.029737483710050583, 0.027069007977843285, 0.04834631457924843, -0.0015565149951726198, 0.022459061816334724, 0.0637926459312439, -0.03370741382241249, -0.05843711271882057, 0.0007126479176804423, 0.04897700995206833, -0.03971774876117706, -0.037017822265625, 0.010328060947358608, -0.025415416806936264, 0.0027812840417027473, -0.013885343447327614, 0.061971504241228104, 0.019118905067443848, 0.018994439393281937, 0.01656227558851242, -0.029787851497530937, 0.026608793064951897, 0.013966968283057213, 0.08706506341695786, 0.027705585584044456, 0.03002764657139778, 0.03388537839055061, -0.09205657243728638, -0.033721961081027985, -0.014376100152730942, -0.04034791514277458, -0.012000315822660923, 0.04832383990287781, 0.007963371463119984, 0.05525190755724907, 0.024353070184588432, -0.03662464767694473, 0.015610144473612309, 0.022489996626973152, -0.0503893680870533, 0.02320869080722332, -0.08261347562074661, -0.0016342290909960866, 0.014867452904582024, -0.026484763249754906, -0.07721268385648727, -0.013664309866726398, -0.009271497838199139, 0.010802021250128746, 0.06698498874902725, -0.006896616891026497, -0.01834477297961712, 0.0680222287774086, -0.0035189150366932154, 0.009841232560575008, 0.04593520611524582, -0.033998217433691025, 0.021174386143684387, -0.015187189914286137, 0.03978332504630089, -0.08934847265481949, -0.004658047575503588, 0.0034790390636771917, 0.020348932594060898, -0.022194145247340202, 0.013931465335190296, 0.016400042921304703, -0.0377667061984539, 0.018391480669379234, 0.07029947638511658, 0.032131992280483246, -0.02378564514219761, -0.026066191494464874, 0.029600733891129494, 0.02372138947248459, 0.0402769036591053, 0.026455864310264587, 0.03333591669797897, -0.07404985278844833, 0.011206085793673992, 0.016895893961191177, 0.023761842399835587, -0.012633539736270905, 0.02824743092060089, -0.03541121259331703, -0.009149398654699326, 0.013757474720478058, 0.00629283394664526, -0.0308801531791687, 0.022116538137197495, 0.01684405840933323, -0.015454638749361038, 0.007807746063917875, 0.03531155362725258, -0.0497296079993248, -0.022217165678739548, 0.024215469136834145, 0.0504097118973732, 0.004392999690026045, 0.01152579765766859, 0.009702802635729313, 0.0475899800658226, -0.008486676029860973, 0.04506656154990196, 0.008871329016983509, -0.019091151654720306, -0.006911023054271936, -0.01969979703426361, 0.050637103617191315, -0.027001826092600822, -0.02069205790758133, 0.018945714458823204, -0.028117191046476364, 0.07366173714399338, 0.08714444190263748, -0.0526832640171051, 0.0269676111638546, 0.02689574845135212, 0.019615963101387024, 0.010506724007427692, 0.030868100002408028, 0.003948511555790901, -0.011350927874445915, 0.023681476712226868, -0.018857723101973534, -0.009707367978990078, -0.06934995204210281, -0.05685459077358246, 0.017267487943172455, -0.02402987703680992, -0.0022307231556624174, -0.027486756443977356, -0.02327672578394413, -0.006181952077895403, 0.051519036293029785, -0.032917458564043045, -0.06144041568040848, -0.05753040686249733, -0.08269816637039185, -0.044973429292440414, -0.0063042426481842995, 0.04454432800412178, 0.03691085800528526, -0.07041922211647034, -0.006093117408454418, 0.049660902470350266, -0.01624763384461403, 0.01817869022488594, 0.004357844591140747, -0.004726633429527283, -0.0294765867292881, -0.06654328107833862, -0.020116480067372322, -0.03449375927448273, -0.020975004881620407, -0.012325290590524673, -0.047779619693756104, -0.017728932201862335, -0.026523344218730927, 0.017069688066840172, -0.007527625188231468, 0.008791003376245499, 0.041190553456544876, -0.02531152404844761, -0.043136563152074814, 0.00017550427583046257, -0.04361969977617264, 0.0357653871178627, 0.06939071416854858, -0.008457458578050137, -0.07513633370399475, 0.021966075524687767, -0.011701764538884163, 0.029717760160565376, -0.0011148556368425488, 0.0030380834359675646, 0.00014179320714902133, -0.0022960039786994457, 0.0002561169385444373, -0.026966067031025887, -0.02071598544716835, -0.027602270245552063, -0.014465287327766418, 0.004751834087073803, -0.028045987710356712, 0.019740378484129906, 0.001265826402232051, 0.021516738459467888, 0.04388793185353279, -0.022233303636312485, 0.005383707582950592, -0.049127109348773956, 0.025448134168982506, 0.03261324018239975, -0.004112639930099249, -0.018120530992746353, -0.03466334939002991, -0.06706028431653976, -0.03971650451421738, -0.017322933301329613, 0.05390555039048195, -0.010701176710426807, 0.004616755060851574, 0.08742648363113403, 0.023400090634822845, -0.060397300869226456, -0.01675812341272831, -0.014584964141249657, -0.05359833687543869, 0.020157599821686745, 0.056959155946969986, 0.03888692706823349, -0.021961310878396034, -0.003929914906620979, 0.02098233811557293, 0.02593451738357544, -0.01905904710292816, -0.011987832374870777, -0.005696967244148254, -0.008987268432974815, 0.053828250616788864, -0.019380992278456688, -0.037252288311719894, 0.019594471901655197, 0.006433847825974226, 0.028752177953720093, -0.009261478669941425, 0.009050666354596615, -0.04995298385620117, -0.04083483666181564, -0.0008989291382022202, 0.059746913611888885, 0.03783157095313072, -0.035557571798563004, -0.015072673559188843, 0.004645819775760174, 0.012905709445476532, 0.008141238242387772, 0.039627257734537125, -0.012193994596600533, 0.015025937929749489, 0.006254411768168211, -0.025470411404967308, -0.07668589800596237, 0.0036446775775402784, -0.050656758248806, -0.000955609604716301, 0.026443298906087875, -0.005988053511828184, -0.01974836178123951, 0.07077508419752121, -0.010832705534994602, -0.02577446587383747, -0.0360000841319561, 0.05784374102950096, 0.06105697527527809, 0.051211997866630554, 0.04188045486807823, -0.045085884630680084, -0.010083229281008244, -0.015891006216406822, -0.0005057735252194107, -0.037775490432977676, 0.07130519300699234, -0.08700785040855408, 0.05397070199251175, -0.04938777536153793, 0.009092699736356735, -0.03450440242886543, 0.027357863262295723, 0.007036035414785147, 0.003887009806931019, 0.05094962194561958, -0.006145623978227377, 0.008295395411550999, 0.033864423632621765, -0.012441087514162064, -0.014258855022490025, -0.033675942569971085, -0.016482794657349586, 0.002158304676413536, -0.02698463387787342, 0.003468001028522849, -0.012994240038096905, 0.04194249212741852, -0.039653826504945755, -0.02014070376753807, 0.017522213980555534, 0.012166911736130714, -0.01590869389474392, -0.05300509184598923, 0.0009805888403207064, -0.017114920541644096, 0.044938549399375916, 0.07406056672334671, -0.04331226274371147, -0.060526199638843536, -0.03433665260672569, 0.0003663170209620148, 0.011899351142346859, 0.024660326540470123, 0.017479758709669113, 0.03208136931061745, -0.03540701046586037, -0.006526139099150896, 0.01267932914197445, -0.01108924113214016, 0.012211237102746964, 0.04230622202157974, -0.04986332356929779, 0.02785594016313553, -0.03873862698674202, 0.040109600871801376, 0.01315579004585743, -0.02034531533718109, 0.043740544468164444, -0.041057173162698746, -0.02507360279560089, -0.021505065262317657, -0.03802051767706871, -0.013021441176533699, 0.021607695147395134, -0.039232928305864334, 0.03733426705002785, -0.020332757383584976, 0.06029796600341797, 0.027424290776252747, 0.023302264511585236, -0.007295751944184303, 0.03378098085522652, -0.00043638600618578494, -0.013656547293066978, 0.02493715099990368, 0.040556397289037704, -0.03593243286013603, 0.0978882685303688, 0.1531858891248703, -0.009209683164954185, 0.04059462994337082, 0.04479767382144928, 0.04452814161777496, 0.012991839088499546, 0.04527252912521362, 0.0041708978824317455, -0.014354335144162178, -0.028668222948908806, 0.04195128753781319, -0.00909517239779234, 0.019577592611312866, -0.06208782270550728, 0.028520934283733368, 0.0027487236075103283, 0.047017041593790054, 0.03736789897084236, 0.03179629147052765, 0.015417411923408508, 0.008993060328066349, -0.07637831568717957, 0.046376850455999374, 0.004701550584286451, -0.0062063648365437984, -0.06279325485229492, -0.02924189902842045, -0.016867974773049355, -0.012518889270722866, -0.009352493099868298, -0.005824276711791754, -0.0033354538027197123, -0.031575776636600494, -0.08200755715370178, 0.008494241163134575, -0.043129172176122665, -0.021548008546233177, 0.03291212022304535, -0.013045902363955975, -0.02728918381035328, 0.006512632127851248, -0.036204803735017776, -0.003503437153995037, -0.004220303148031235, 0.0065535493195056915, -0.0287088043987751, -0.06872155517339706, -0.014099094085395336, -0.0014936308143660426, -0.02591066248714924, 0.050696611404418945, -0.03313761577010155, -0.05654790252447128, -0.012001249939203262, -0.007006308063864708, -0.013762922957539558, 0.02690686471760273, 0.0719323679804802, 0.03039243072271347, -0.003329843282699585, 0.005925632081925869, -0.08078110218048096, 0.0536407046020031, -0.026718849316239357, 0.0031761934515088797, 0.04530536010861397, 0.006894867867231369, -0.0027893129736185074, 0.055778246372938156, -0.01164054125547409, 0.022489456459879875, -0.006829789374023676, -0.03282677009701729, 0.03016231581568718, -0.005644522607326508, 0.023520560935139656, 0.0032043519895523787, -0.045854635536670685, -0.002998123876750469, 0.02535802312195301, -0.04948490113019943, -0.05024397745728493, 0.028516169637441635, 0.037058040499687195, -0.03261631727218628, 0.00081282650353387, -0.03434448689222336, -0.007052320521324873, -0.02279587835073471, -0.04751814901828766, -0.029073016718029976, -0.053011830896139145, -0.046231236308813095, 0.040162354707717896, -0.010865573771297932, 0.014475454576313496, 0.0122924093157053, -0.010433310642838478, -0.030786145478487015, 0.02937413938343525, 0.0028441217727959156, -0.007663425523787737, -0.05481020733714104, 0.060114409774541855, 0.011655427515506744, 0.006402380298823118, 0.02991090901196003, 0.0018952967366203666, 0.021791640669107437, -0.02514849230647087, 0.05946219712495804, 0.04587842896580696, -0.03410543128848076, 0.030178284272551537, -0.007382300682365894, 0.041324593126773834, 0.025006797164678574, -0.018748605623841286, 0.0021130465902388096, 0.02566184289753437, -0.04502095654606819, -0.021970761939883232, 0.01991855539381504, 0.010045810602605343, 0.027991726994514465, 0.00040051774703897536, 0.0023793941363692284, 0.03535141795873642, -0.003360362956300378, 0.0006085978238843381, -0.07640298455953598, 0.03945823386311531, -0.05707089975476265, 0.02404247783124447, 0.011886963620781898, -0.006587049458175898, 0.017164235934615135, -0.01945851743221283, -0.05357634648680687, 0.007823611609637737, 0.030432160943746567, 0.022514168173074722, -0.053978707641363144, -0.0443066768348217, 0.029523076489567757, 0.018167313188314438, -0.011925596743822098, -0.0334387831389904, -0.04308149218559265, 0.0028543046209961176, -0.025617433711886406, 0.04205058142542839, -0.0243719182908535, -0.022430218756198883, 0.017623739317059517, -0.018048029392957687, 0.03789641708135605, 0.009557600133121014, -0.019170962274074554, 0.05398634448647499, 0.01804903894662857, -0.02241227962076664, 0.09516458213329315, -0.019242217764258385, 0.015435497276484966, 0.01631203666329384, -0.07912693917751312, 0.030674923211336136, 0.0299308430403471, -0.001073969528079033, 0.004187168553471565, 0.026915239170193672, 0.022234365344047546, 0.0114528713747859, 0.023041972890496254, 0.03221872076392174, -0.043183378875255585, -0.056347139179706573, -0.05531257018446922, -0.025777556002140045, -0.001162156811915338, -0.05130481719970703, -0.05423985421657562, 0.06295870244503021, -0.012581733986735344, 0.0003038171853404492, 0.041383784264326096, 0.00835332553833723, -0.005909774452447891, 0.0013159341178834438, -0.049591291695833206, 0.04102105647325516, 0.0245460644364357, 0.0699179545044899, 0.07201629877090454, -0.01773231476545334, -0.06983532756567001, -0.0016714291414245963, 0.06479860842227936, 0.03356800600886345, 0.022052891552448273, 0.020706452429294586, -0.023247236385941505, 0.007735235150903463, 0.03952915593981743, 0.0333845280110836, -0.04585780203342438, 0.035969290882349014, 0.09627440571784973, -0.0002379871002631262, -0.02464318834245205, 0.01696014404296875, 0.035750098526477814, -0.05376265570521355, 0.024991899728775024, -0.03886975720524788, -0.06532441079616547, -0.05618656799197197, -0.021496925503015518, -0.02401263639330864, -0.033941302448511124, -0.0012482083402574062, 0.04958152770996094, 0.04278841242194176, -0.06524230539798737, -0.043415848165750504, -0.06484710425138474, 0.0022616528440266848, -0.041383128613233566, 0.020604580640792847, -0.00327520864084363, -0.0001870616979431361, 0.05235151946544647, -0.047352518886327744, -0.01864231750369072, -0.020671119913458824, 0.07895657420158386, 0.01028437353670597, -0.006418648641556501, -0.004990127868950367, -0.02980087511241436, 0.01523357443511486, 0.012760654091835022, -0.01098956260830164, -0.013895276933908463, -0.027713976800441742, -0.04308293014764786, 0.0436675138771534, 0.026615193113684654, -0.03160316124558449, -0.006316033657640219, 0.0267033651471138, 0.055579882115125656, -0.01675475761294365, -0.0031001786701381207, -0.04478657618165016, 0.00355417188256979, 0.01121990755200386, -0.008595330640673637, -0.026751695200800896, 0.02500777319073677, 0.00594964437186718 ]
<p>Suppose we have a quantum state $\rho$ and let's denote the photon number operator $\hat{n}=\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a}$ where $\hat{a}$ is the annihilation operator. Let mean photon number $\bar{n}=\operatorname{Tr}(\rho\hat{n})&lt;\infty$ obviously be finite. Can $\rho$ have infinite photon number <em>variance</em>, which we define as follows:</p> <p>$$\operatorname{Var}(\rho)=\operatorname{Tr}(\rho\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a}\hat{a})-\bar{n}^2$$</p> <p>I ask this because it came up in a quantum information theory research problem that I am working on. Mathematically, it's easy to define $\rho$ with infinite photon number variance: let $\rho=|\psi\rangle\langle\psi|$ where $|\psi\rangle=\sum_{n=0}^\infty a_n|n\rangle$ such that $|a_n|^2=(n+1)^{-3}/\zeta(3)$ with $\zeta(3)=\sum_{k=1}^\infty1/k^3$ being the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Riemann_zeta_function" rel="nofollow">Reimann zeta function</a>. That is, $|\psi\rangle$ is a superposition of number states which is prepared such that the photon number of the state is distributed according to the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeta_distribution" rel="nofollow">Zipf distribution</a>. </p> <p>However, I am wondering if such state (or one like it) can actually exist in nature. If yes, how would one construct it? If not, is there a concrete reason as to why? (ideally, I am looking for a mathematical proof, but would accept a generally accepted well-cited explanation.) </p> <p>I am confused because it seems to me that the requirement if one applies a measurement $\sum_{m=k}^\infty|m\rangle\langle m|$ with a large $k$ to a coherent state there is a chance of it returning a positive answer, however small, as coherent states are not "peak photon number" limited (if they were, that chance would be zero starting at some fixed $k$). Here the difference is the heavy tail on the photon number.</p> <p>This is my first question to this forum. I am not a physicist, I study information theory and have been looking at quantum information theory lately. I know a lot of math, but not necessarily how things work in the "universe we touch". I only have a rudimentary knowledge of quantum mechanics. Please forgive my ignorance and feel free to refer this question somewhere else if it's not suitable for this forum.</p>
g4024
[ -0.01166240032762289, 0.012840472161769867, -0.013956267386674881, 0.013814115896821022, -0.008719675242900848, -0.0032334856223315, 0.05882171168923378, 0.0706591010093689, 0.014239774085581303, -0.041978660970926285, -0.003805865766480565, -0.01678665168583393, -0.015023532323539257, 0.012055869214236736, -0.02007206529378891, -0.014009120874106884, 0.07505635172128677, 0.05250324681401253, 0.006142996251583099, -0.0042199124582111835, -0.09878136217594147, -0.004147504922002554, 0.023131094872951508, -0.021255724132061005, 0.03225485607981682, -0.046615589410066605, 0.03609175607562065, -0.028847143054008484, -0.038093604147434235, -0.053770601749420166, 0.009549695998430252, -0.035745371133089066, 0.009282509796321392, 0.02153116464614868, 0.010153764858841896, -0.02993977814912796, 0.032351333647966385, 0.017567096278071404, 0.03522958606481552, 0.07104664295911789, -0.09305377304553986, 0.03306763991713524, 0.04771046340465546, -0.03835730254650116, -0.013340387493371964, 0.08314795047044754, 0.06179672107100487, 0.08356500416994095, -0.015758974477648735, -0.06315629184246063, -0.006886878050863743, -0.011492128483951092, 0.021179689094424248, 0.028325194492936134, 0.07286978513002396, 0.004579047206789255, -0.052101776003837585, -0.03793356567621231, 0.021364785730838776, 0.028711823746562004, 0.03237023949623108, -0.022315269336104393, -0.0010867227101698518, -0.006098968908190727, 0.028718402609229088, 0.028112463653087616, -0.01742880791425705, 0.013715480454266071, -0.003553220769390464, 0.0027503722812980413, -0.011112933047115803, -0.06504001468420029, 0.004298936575651169, -0.0071566482074558735, 0.00615585595369339, 0.0482877753674984, -0.02158496156334877, -0.02087147906422615, -0.002391609363257885, 0.06604182720184326, -0.030463149771094322, -0.07480652630329132, 0.03489932417869568, 0.01040717400610447, 0.008032451383769512, 0.0012137001613155007, 0.038014236837625504, 0.026565467938780785, -0.0035580319818109274, 0.04397035762667656, 0.050815943628549576, 0.032863009721040726, 0.08366449177265167, 0.029500296339392662, -0.010467004030942917, -0.029291383922100067, -0.040530379861593246, 0.06844424456357956, -0.06915251910686493, -0.00748858880251646, -0.0007074470049701631, 0.02885909378528595, 0.03983334079384804, 0.0307624451816082, 0.02025439217686653, 0.008569459430873394, 0.008200399577617645, -0.057523343712091446, -0.012538615614175797, 0.012043561786413193, -0.06397702544927597, 0.0010079352650791407, -0.012042193673551083, -0.06098604574799538, -0.044569119811058044, 0.02275214157998562, 0.026248417794704437, 0.034651510417461395, -0.040100373327732086, 0.03502125293016434, 0.021511776372790337, 0.01635630987584591, -0.026428038254380226, 0.06843867152929306, -0.047282569110393524, 0.041258446872234344, 0.003233320079743862, 0.022182723507285118, -0.012490889057517052, 0.002352854935452342, 0.060698509216308594, 0.0038670639041811228, -0.011162582784891129, 0.01369637344032526, -0.040463242679834366, 0.023414568975567818, 0.023971233516931534, 0.045744266360998154, 0.03557545691728592, 0.02182294987142086, 0.00717137660831213, -0.041447244584560394, 0.038569800555706024, -0.03068411909043789, -0.022412128746509552, -0.008966650813817978, 0.006956032477319241, -0.03397170081734657, 0.012191317044198513, -0.011803241446614265, -0.006534802261739969, 0.020659364759922028, 0.0033816981595009565, -0.033227257430553436, -0.018574001267552376, -0.046833254396915436, 0.026923052966594696, 0.02260901778936386, -0.07173978537321091, 0.010743928141891956, 0.022831173613667488, 0.024179959669709206, 0.01619565859436989, -0.016035331413149834, -0.006408241577446461, 0.017710542306303978, 0.01611199602484703, -0.0305160041898489, -0.06906730681657791, -0.07206787168979645, 0.04833255335688591, 0.037473585456609726, 0.04379218444228172, -0.029657689854502678, -0.006751006934791803, -0.041327688843011856, 0.004534527659416199, 0.013751410879194736, -0.002647508168593049, -0.0007245019660331309, -0.04704125598073006, 0.0004706763429567218, 0.02067156881093979, -0.04772977530956268, 0.038275957107543945, -0.013701960444450378, -0.047968339174985886, -0.054384779185056686, 0.0055879573337733746, 0.013365814462304115, -0.03151089698076248, 0.048704251646995544, 0.04647522047162056, 0.01257620844990015, 0.003629759419709444, -0.0005810881266370416, 0.012060172855854034, -0.0839204415678978, -0.020269237458705902, 0.03247522562742233, -0.029082588851451874, 0.04331381991505623, -0.019252505153417587, -0.008901441469788551, -0.04469776526093483, -0.03215549886226654, -0.04243478178977966, -0.038306206464767456, -0.0382423996925354, 0.008451147936284542, 0.056563057005405426, -0.070363849401474, -0.01372817624360323, 0.031382136046886444, 0.05376802012324333, -0.026982564479112625, 0.03515646606683731, -0.006022291723638773, 0.01222188025712967, 0.011398402974009514, 0.005444547161459923, 0.006762534845620394, 0.07060461491346359, -0.02083405666053295, -0.0223484318703413, 0.04501490667462349, -0.03293078392744064, -0.033630017191171646, 0.006379870697855949, 0.020772382616996765, -0.03020535781979561, 0.0055964794009923935, -0.0006473850226029754, -0.02388106845319271, 0.0027639889158308506, 0.027516959235072136, 0.0369299091398716, 0.07229184359312057, -0.016844643279910088, 0.00768690649420023, -0.026995519176125526, -0.01792135275900364, -0.029907263815402985, 0.05556337535381317, -0.03427034616470337, -0.011978142894804478, -0.05324253812432289, -0.01044362224638462, -0.017499404028058052, 0.04685517027974129, -0.001519576646387577, -0.08322358131408691, 0.037438731640577316, 0.003608536208048463, 0.021217310801148415, -0.03309674561023712, 0.008837447501718998, 0.01026184018701315, 0.005159181542694569, -0.020777486264705658, -0.02404729463160038, 0.026091238483786583, -0.012491242960095406, -0.06048522889614105, -0.024041766300797462, 0.0246416125446558, -0.004739444237202406, 0.020606737583875656, -0.03215906023979187, 0.018076112493872643, 0.014700728468596935, 0.04073237627744675, 0.07656197249889374, 0.018098248168826103, -0.010166536085307598, 0.02698386274278164, -0.08273335546255112, -0.045663848519325256, 0.05954158678650856, -0.0437481589615345, -0.038183052092790604, -0.005020583979785442, -0.03308399021625519, 0.04509856179356575, 0.005744959227740765, -0.06198178976774216, 0.06737887114286423, 0.026111634448170662, -0.04018888622522354, 0.020387718454003334, 0.019559474661946297, 0.03119000233709812, 0.016786271706223488, -0.029556704685091972, -0.020798740908503532, -0.00045266051893122494, 0.018022114410996437, -0.0534495934844017, 0.03424445167183876, 0.046282995492219925, -0.004305666778236628, 0.0024618960451334715, 0.005293415393680334, -0.026446931064128876, 0.017863178625702858, 0.018060512840747833, -0.07091828435659409, 0.004433350637555122, 0.060020867735147476, 0.008690385147929192, 0.011315234005451202, 0.09076688438653946, -0.0045960433781147, -0.015636146068572998, 0.015382149256765842, -0.014030751772224903, -0.05783700942993164, 0.030160410329699516, 0.00005943408177699894, 0.031546417623758316, -0.014825654216110706, -0.002663124119862914, 0.024615835398435593, -0.01162113156169653, 0.09170293807983398, 0.032358430325984955, -0.09351979196071625, 0.06474000960588455, -0.008994853124022484, -0.027905886992812157, 0.03383439779281616, -0.011588928289711475, -0.01549475733190775, -0.007711544632911682, -0.03536878898739815, -0.006020372733473778, -0.0006744007114320993, 0.020647825673222542, 0.0748085007071495, -0.00929503608494997, -0.008321741595864296, -0.07583540678024292, -0.037470802664756775, 0.0004866823146585375, 0.01206875592470169, 0.0008621016168035567, -0.018891392275691032, 0.05719933286309242, 0.04023461043834686, 0.05085260793566704, 0.011274931952357292, 0.01790105178952217, 0.02032250538468361, -0.030084488913416862, 0.04275627061724663, 0.03337499126791954, -0.013229156844317913, 0.044871050864458084, 0.03075595572590828, -0.05287008732557297, 0.029257018119096756, -0.016879748553037643, -0.01654050312936306, -0.05789920315146446, 0.015282929874956608, 0.034126073122024536, 0.003546954831108451, -0.00680918525904417, 0.030786748975515366, -0.008011901751160622, -0.04232889786362648, -0.01444330159574747, -0.01633598655462265, -0.01198482047766447, -0.03546560928225517, -0.031247025355696678, -0.008510073646903038, 0.0006787829915992916, -0.019539356231689453, 0.005678847432136536, 0.013961218297481537, 0.017479408532381058, 0.00779916113242507, -0.011733576655387878, 0.013625098392367363, 0.04656548425555229, 0.025788241997361183, -0.04565080627799034, 0.010304289869964123, -0.029932823032140732, 0.0292858574539423, -0.06986834853887558, -0.016891224309802055, 0.016723770648241043, 0.04566331207752228, 0.01293788943439722, 0.02102651074528694, -0.062422845512628555, -0.024402370676398277, 0.03790881484746933, 0.0377667136490345, -0.03866933658719063, 0.04756801947951317, 0.026902936398983, -0.010701602324843407, -0.013047736138105392, 0.07424179464578629, -0.012344376184046268, -0.021870329976081848, -0.07643277943134308, -0.01959066465497017, 0.04608933627605438, -0.01320558600127697, -0.06478852778673172, 0.00794578529894352, 0.012938451021909714, -0.004242856986820698, -0.05929085612297058, -0.045283399522304535, 0.014803077094256878, -0.03679848462343216, 0.0313044898211956, 0.023667676374316216, -0.03349534422159195, -0.013078578747808933, -0.021075556054711342, 0.0013631231850013137, 0.010321799665689468, 0.024736689403653145, -0.01383789163082838, 0.09764184057712555, 0.015667395666241646, -0.009201141074299812, 0.06976479291915894, -0.032634563744068146, -0.014223570004105568, -0.01107805036008358, -0.042958904057741165, -0.009531310759484768, 0.038791950792074203, -0.01249670423567295, 0.0057481201365590096, -0.02073988877236843, 0.009492402896285057, -0.01717626117169857, 0.01563543640077114, -0.018321849405765533, -0.03265707567334175, -0.04024478793144226, 0.006627318914979696, 0.001130984048359096, -0.013750392012298107, -0.053095102310180664, -0.09522300213575363, 0.027158057317137718, -0.004597585182636976, -0.028323285281658173, -0.008046304807066917, 0.011035741306841373, -0.03366931900382042, -0.052034180611371994, 0.008852401748299599, -0.017860323190689087, 0.008828551508486271, 0.02237795479595661, 0.02244901843369007, -0.07859879732131958, 0.07436168193817139, -0.08273564279079437, -0.00991345290094614, -0.006198192480951548, 0.009364414028823376, 0.06152115762233734, 0.008945412002503872, -0.05501307547092438, -0.01438953448086977, -0.03469107300043106, -0.014245164580643177, -0.03402993083000183, -0.0022996915504336357, -0.012000215239822865, 0.021475164219737053, -0.022615741938352585, -0.020090894773602486, 0.02877076342701912, 0.009456233121454716, -0.049271803349256516, -0.03892764821648598, -0.0030742839444428682, -0.07176049053668976, -0.001509018475189805, -0.02172577939927578, 0.021584153175354004, -0.015143332071602345, 0.04239334538578987, -0.03496826812624931, 0.0038308543153107166, -0.06039905175566673, -0.011065772734582424, 0.0020708045922219753, -0.041273005306720734, -0.006920028943568468, -0.02207799442112446, 0.007082929834723473, 0.004477804061025381, -0.046526581048965454, 0.050779007375240326, -0.001341290189884603, 0.04078342765569687, 0.014167224988341331, -0.0426582507789135, -0.07404203712940216, 0.028059862554073334, -0.02803502418100834, 0.009451611898839474, -0.01790379174053669, -0.03901077061891556, 0.0392063669860363, 0.023511946201324463, -0.022697515785694122, -0.031079363077878952, 0.026706676930189133, 0.04473626986145973, -0.01650320552289486, 0.015044515952467918, 0.007526792585849762, -0.06798367947340012, -0.04026436060667038, -0.044326189905405045, -0.04706890136003494, 0.042213182896375656, 0.06553666293621063, 0.03398001194000244, -0.022506270557641983, 0.02237776294350624, -0.04419349879026413, 0.015267047099769115, 0.018776994198560715, -0.0012625246308743954, 0.009952129796147346, 0.05479160323739052, 0.0008478148374706507, 0.00023389968555420637, 0.06790384650230408, 0.010405789129436016, -0.023486599326133728, -0.03353727236390114, -0.011065781116485596, -0.03139106556773186, -0.0007102435920387506, 0.020984835922718048, 0.019423309713602066, 0.005375652574002743, -0.058890748769044876, 0.0036595033016055822, 0.031195735558867455, 0.0357113853096962, -0.0052404263988137245, -0.012211835943162441, 0.00867196824401617, 0.0387100949883461, -0.006018789019435644, 0.03617434203624725, 0.052429601550102234, -0.00492272200062871, -0.038168031722307205, -0.017790857702493668, -0.021084578707814217, 0.0042903912253677845, 0.10478254407644272, 0.01294941920787096, 0.05172369256615639, -0.055003196001052856, -0.005130452569574118, 0.03136838972568512, -0.020398903638124466, -0.02855469472706318, -0.04274649918079376, -0.030009279027581215, -0.02278902381658554, -0.001267090905457735, 0.0249412152916193, 0.05450516566634178, -0.042215801775455475, 0.03614412248134613, 0.044889308512210846, -0.02728387527167797, -0.003276186529546976, 0.02887275628745556, 0.023577935993671417, 0.0006790334009565413, 0.012974530458450317, -0.025880634784698486, -0.017694221809506416, -0.04544578120112419, 0.007840457372367382, 0.032649651169776917, -0.030520865693688393, -0.020490214228630066, -0.0220551285892725, 0.03896881639957428, 0.0029880132060498, 0.04354220628738403, 0.0024351286701858044, -0.0037784662563353777, 0.04007504880428314, -0.06214224174618721, -0.0048966738395392895, 0.001220828271470964, 0.0013881507329642773, 0.0066862949170172215, -0.022141754627227783, -0.021103043109178543, -0.002311442978680134, -0.03418073058128357, -0.027167465537786484, -0.016757303848862648, 0.038929883390665054, -0.04032798111438751, 0.05957964435219765, 0.0887473076581955, 0.0059536234475672245, 0.0021644695661962032, -0.04501839354634285, 0.05398120358586311, 0.058338068425655365, 0.01991155557334423, 0.020781319588422775, 0.014110215939581394, 0.017494553700089455, 0.023793691769242287, -0.006380652543157339, 0.011960065923631191, 0.07044196128845215, -0.002451852196827531, 0.03825991228222847, -0.06064910814166069, 0.030871400609612465, 0.019187767058610916, 0.0065337917767465115, 0.008121207356452942, 0.023363547399640083, 0.08993716537952423, 0.00420853216201067, 0.024201607331633568, 0.05257442593574524, 0.010834244079887867, 0.02240351215004921, -0.061850033700466156, 0.02497134730219841, 0.0038241674192249775, 0.03587321192026138, -0.0033777838107198477, 0.011930756270885468, 0.035488057881593704, 0.005872391629964113, -0.01932661049067974, -0.01600549928843975, -0.0354374460875988, -0.07547137141227722, 0.0048313019797205925, -0.013569237664341927, -0.016152221709489822, -0.0031378513667732477, -0.05641268566250801, 0.021476373076438904, 0.026157043874263763, -0.04937346279621124, 0.011621993966400623, -0.05385400727391243, 0.06816528737545013, -0.007147423457354307, -0.08255396783351898, -0.05201432481408119, 0.026759058237075806, 0.03845677897334099, 0.01636529713869095, 0.05183197930455208, -0.0457291454076767, 0.006334398873150349, -0.00039234469295479357, 0.0009383648284710944, -0.01268468052148819, -0.025947466492652893, 0.0004660191189032048, 0.02312583103775978, -0.009554632939398289, -0.0037330451887100935, 0.03220740333199501, -0.018799299374222755, 0.018677765503525734, -0.07725612074136734, 0.010863227769732475, -0.005662820767611265, 0.03404861316084862, 0.006981442682445049, 0.021424880251288414, 0.028945552185177803, 0.005536941811442375, 0.03310813382267952, 0.038244567811489105, -0.028896084055304527, -0.012622738257050514, -0.058354273438453674, 0.021167436614632607, 0.0475655198097229, 0.014703811146318913, -0.017115334048867226, 0.019428927451372147, -0.030176380649209023, 0.022396892309188843, -0.021619627252221107, -0.03468651697039604, -0.0007007091189734638, -0.004310527350753546, 0.01804445870220661, -0.00731356255710125, -0.0019473048159852624, -0.0025225942954421043, -0.052605945616960526, -0.03885398432612419, 0.009359261952340603, -0.0035949416924268007, 0.006734094116836786, -0.02670922875404358, -0.043662071228027344, -0.006588223855942488, 0.02699047140777111, -0.044304002076387405, -0.021649735048413277, 0.010192930698394775, -0.05988664925098419, -0.09254177659749985, 0.006502170581370592, -0.03933730721473694, -0.02413516864180565, -0.004621757194399834, 0.07637137174606323, 0.05523989349603653, -0.030505914241075516, -0.04128970205783844, -0.07366422563791275, 0.06915795803070068, -0.0036810070741921663, 0.047256533056497574, 0.002729950472712517, -0.00297685363329947, -0.02546231634914875, -0.02889556810259819, -0.003554494120180607, -0.06029532477259636, 0.040713902562856674, 0.019164372235536575, 0.12310975790023804, 0.1519915908575058, 0.010306103155016899, 0.11310042440891266, -0.012256859801709652, 0.01746561750769615, 0.03131730109453201, 0.024334797635674477, -0.05569147691130638, -0.05931406468153, -0.022100653499364853, -0.031958382576704025, -0.07225155830383301, 0.01006023958325386, -0.041141483932733536 ]
<p>Assuming there is an incident beam(i.e. $p$ or $\alpha$) and a target. How can I be sure if a rutherford backscattering will take place?</p> <p>I know that for high $Z$ it more likely to happen as well as for higher beam energies. Is there a boundary/formula/criterion to tell me that at that beam, for that energy, for this $Z$ target I will have rutherford backscattering.</p> <p>To rephrase it, for a certain beam(i.e. $p$) and a certain target(i.e. $SbF_3$) at what energies I am going to have Rutherford Backscattering?</p>
g4025
[ 0.03841733559966087, 0.026471193879842758, 0.013984179124236107, 0.01440494041889906, 0.04696173593401909, -0.03147004172205925, 0.023330040276050568, 0.025929704308509827, -0.0020627418998628855, -0.04490119591355324, -0.0043813991360366344, 0.06947360932826996, -0.038167573511600494, -0.045998260378837585, -0.013258279301226139, -0.01804148033261299, 0.06748354434967041, -0.005103640258312225, 0.026654504239559174, 0.05877313390374184, -0.0670967772603035, 0.024721160531044006, -0.002991338726133108, -0.09419739991426468, 0.055281274020671844, 0.006539156194776297, -0.03845899552106857, -0.009528571739792824, -0.024700704962015152, -0.04924933984875679, -0.013849516399204731, -0.00973826739937067, -0.012672096490859985, -0.018058830872178078, -0.027481717988848686, -0.040749188512563705, 0.028078807517886162, 0.05633493885397911, 0.038354478776454926, -0.00730497669428587, -0.019576001912355423, -0.011625527404248714, -0.040335118770599365, -0.035841237753629684, -0.01368635892868042, 0.004936518147587776, -0.004380774684250355, -0.07019542157649994, 0.006560486275702715, 0.04100850969552994, -0.0406879186630249, 0.06540365517139435, -0.004539865534752607, -0.0713987872004509, -0.004034980200231075, 0.03793780878186226, -0.02018280327320099, -0.025902805849909782, 0.016529057174921036, 0.024714110419154167, 0.052534569054841995, 0.0329509899020195, 0.016125036403536797, -0.07219428569078445, 0.03798012062907219, 0.0024024099111557007, -0.04399389773607254, 0.01215465646237135, -0.04271344095468521, -0.02959788590669632, 0.07723979651927948, -0.03595343604683876, -0.05440983921289444, 0.013376624323427677, -0.01390149723738432, -0.03443824499845505, -0.040208492428064346, 0.056715227663517, -0.032232217490673065, 0.03654240444302559, -0.0170974712818861, -0.051242053508758545, -0.0048293969593942165, -0.004994579125195742, -0.027197208255529404, 0.052656203508377075, 0.04569832608103752, -0.014648647978901863, -0.003604067722335458, -0.019643427804112434, 0.033436067402362823, 0.02459736168384552, 0.031235400587320328, 0.02161364257335663, -0.02233026921749115, 0.005039273761212826, 0.017371339723467827, 0.016102800145745277, -0.009819868952035904, 0.013675539754331112, -0.039704855531454086, -0.00851929746568203, -0.019115455448627472, 0.022220643237233162, -0.04663017764687538, -0.1177249401807785, 0.017774710431694984, -0.07787299901247025, -0.03142308071255684, 0.028860053047537804, -0.04537757486104965, -0.033283550292253494, -0.058262430131435394, 0.010228060185909271, -0.07176180183887482, -0.03294346109032631, 0.03781748563051224, 0.0048051560297608376, 0.029953408986330032, 0.04726153984665871, -0.0009611684363335371, 0.0031781888101249933, -0.04409397393465042, 0.01596059836447239, -0.03137608617544174, 0.019811449572443962, -0.05159140005707741, -0.025861831381917, 0.01391238160431385, 0.019311118870973587, -0.009363744407892227, -0.05722027271986008, -0.002507289871573448, 0.0319073423743248, 0.0509193018078804, -0.010738817043602467, 0.048368021845817566, 0.025947507470846176, 0.0019075676100328565, -0.02475108951330185, 0.05580446124076843, -0.00461275689303875, -0.006204420235008001, -0.0580143965780735, -0.036713093519210815, 0.020961133763194084, 0.008323315531015396, -0.013571851886808872, 0.008832801133394241, 0.006334045436233282, 0.008657696656882763, 0.04598599299788475, -0.009878321550786495, -0.050453782081604004, 0.008504727855324745, -0.00460485415533185, -0.032510530203580856, -0.008223139680922031, 0.012160840444266796, 0.02566264569759369, 0.048528630286455154, 0.011428780853748322, -0.013979632407426834, -0.01684054546058178, -0.011125233955681324, 0.0074551887810230255, 0.016998184844851494, -0.03524395450949669, 0.043183811008930206, 0.005850742105394602, 0.01126091368496418, 0.0185014009475708, 0.041412658989429474, -0.026587091386318207, 0.03472629562020302, 0.07621604949235916, -0.017597654834389687, 0.022971589118242264, 0.06501966714859009, 0.04609411209821701, -0.012363064102828503, -0.02235533483326435, 0.05562926083803177, 0.028916632756590843, -0.0029327399097383022, -0.03092927671968937, -0.04592602327466011, 0.0018770210444927216, -0.02617012709379196, 0.06154729798436165, -0.010910220444202423, -0.019788777455687523, 0.0482185035943985, -0.07881505787372589, 0.006813636515289545, -0.0226628128439188, 0.015020612627267838, -0.019822251051664352, 0.006847698241472244, 0.004716627299785614, -0.0008000818779692054, 0.058971475809812546, 0.02605396881699562, 0.0827270895242691, 0.027765704318881035, 0.07102140784263611, -0.007208290509879589, 0.012863622978329659, -0.03278040885925293, -0.01629740372300148, -0.047262102365493774, -0.027909256517887115, 0.006888213567435741, 0.05432639271020889, 0.04758865386247635, 0.038606174290180206, 0.012785319238901138, 0.09661396592855453, 0.02432357519865036, 0.007557000499218702, -0.12301888316869736, 0.005094548687338829, 0.02754683792591095, -0.005928546190261841, -0.030797947198152542, 0.07995288074016571, 0.027309812605381012, -0.00888478010892868, 0.06727027893066406, 0.03716200217604637, 0.017936712130904198, -0.001378657529130578, -0.010901106521487236, -0.06275162845849991, -0.008094285614788532, -0.008863268420100212, 0.03089594841003418, -0.04065856710076332, 0.0020795559976249933, 0.01480137836188078, 0.03302539885044098, 0.014661669731140137, 0.004665583837777376, 0.031831614673137665, 0.026089714840054512, -0.09761493653059006, 0.021930351853370667, 0.019044876098632812, -0.026208335533738136, 0.010815365239977837, 0.031843401491642, 0.017241982743144035, 0.061568520963191986, 0.003147171577438712, -0.0433402843773365, -0.027046622708439827, -0.014049951918423176, 0.01990175060927868, -0.030168015509843826, -0.04014507681131363, -0.003286270657554269, 0.007513099815696478, 0.06161945313215256, -0.041063662618398666, -0.05080943927168846, -0.06277123838663101, -0.05437133461236954, 0.007080999668687582, -0.0343228355050087, 0.02255253680050373, -0.0005340867210179567, 0.03449587896466255, 0.050441402941942215, 0.05063421651721001, 0.007387186400592327, -0.0035171855706721544, -0.01680389605462551, -0.014656567946076393, 0.012663754634559155, -0.0031202975660562515, -0.07020404189825058, -0.006057294551283121, 0.030009057372808456, 0.030014604330062866, 0.0008718387107364833, 0.031241199001669884, 0.07965743541717529, -0.009251809678971767, -0.04719727858901024, 0.03129905089735985, -0.07791748642921448, 0.0015944447368383408, 0.02209891378879547, -0.019235434010624886, 0.036490585654973984, 0.0012198169715702534, 0.07052610069513321, -0.02997731603682041, 0.026874301955103874, 0.0640796348452568, -0.04971461370587349, -0.01794222742319107, -0.04624917358160019, -0.03551332652568817, 0.03585134446620941, 0.011494379490613937, -0.025545792654156685, -0.0017206266056746244, 0.002791596343740821, -0.03231438621878624, -0.022413428872823715, 0.038651272654533386, 0.0611121840775013, 0.01270376332104206, 0.014091306366026402, -0.05778013914823532, 0.03151194378733635, -0.020308244973421097, 0.006599519867449999, -0.016740843653678894, -0.06347780674695969, 0.005094846710562706, 0.013644745573401451, -0.00587044982239604, 0.012325464747846127, 0.02087586373090744, -0.05744444951415062, 0.028321556746959686, -0.022134220227599144, 0.03824472427368164, 0.047768644988536835, 0.050109341740608215, -0.01385097298771143, 0.021623017266392708, 0.004521985072642565, -0.06544915586709976, 0.008403938263654709, 0.04316941648721695, 0.03149551525712013, 0.07221092283725739, 0.11919303238391876, -0.00624498724937439, 0.03443890064954758, 0.008146965876221657, 0.012469843029975891, 0.01933159865438938, -0.01043052040040493, 0.022751666605472565, 0.07615633308887482, -0.043578919023275375, 0.02008582092821598, 0.01670251600444317, -0.0152449831366539, 0.06734804064035416, 0.01687825471162796, 0.01980060711503029, -0.024022899568080902, 0.02800489403307438, 0.007491628639400005, -0.03267015144228935, 0.00467225955799222, -0.0625666156411171, 0.006782705429941416, -0.05304952338337898, 0.0006931303651072085, -0.05062074214220047, -0.044320449233055115, 0.030834274366497993, 0.002379742916673422, -0.04248877987265587, 0.041289668530225754, -0.009168473072350025, 0.08036341518163681, 0.05204620212316513, 0.007117893546819687, -0.022174501791596413, 0.041851043701171875, -0.016775669530034065, 0.04388125613331795, 0.0021489388309419155, 0.0457940436899662, 0.0656055137515068, -0.00428488664329052, 0.017772087827324867, -0.05174802988767624, 0.02118336595594883, -0.005140457767993212, -0.0322832427918911, 0.005320534575730562, -0.024348098784685135, 0.006002969108521938, -0.056466784328222275, -0.020792808383703232, 0.02777920477092266, 0.07542764395475388, 0.0010570797603577375, 0.0025668982416391373, 0.002062593586742878, 0.0298937875777483, 0.025169869884848595, -0.029781080782413483, -0.013229360803961754, -0.006181812379509211, -0.08649719506502151, 0.008505456149578094, -0.0055877394042909145, 0.021903512999415398, 0.022790029644966125, -0.023483088240027428, 0.010152898728847504, 0.015126179903745651, -0.0063228304497897625, 0.0020429487340152264, -0.04624882712960243, -0.017500540241599083, -0.03703612461686134, 0.02442585863173008, 0.02602395974099636, -0.02585182711482048, 0.03555375337600708, 0.04523135721683502, -0.004864207934588194, 0.04691790044307709, -0.04924800246953964, 0.011376341804862022, 0.01439883653074503, 0.022717179730534554, -0.040789756923913956, 0.021986329928040504, -0.007876438088715076, 0.0035216689575463533, 0.015705060213804245, -0.01828489825129509, 0.010178758762776852, -0.014839583076536655, 0.04654502496123314, -0.008809500373899937, -0.0333588644862175, -0.0225420743227005, 0.06268563866615295, 0.036631908267736435, -0.002169758779928088, -0.030859656631946564, -0.017850076779723167, 0.013166210614144802, 0.046418916434049606, -0.043334998190402985, -0.0324762798845768, 0.01809171587228775, -0.04404732212424278, -0.05840396508574486, -0.03679988533258438, -0.022926846519112587, -0.042969491332769394, -0.01172711607068777, -0.011027832515537739, -0.044434867799282074, 0.03445562347769737, -0.006516794674098492, 0.05318744108080864, -0.06629935652017593, -0.02951616607606411, 0.04383749142289162, -0.06073658913373947, 0.022467242553830147, 0.01266031339764595, -0.009286265820264816, -0.054204680025577545, -0.018025867640972137, -0.016371510922908783, -0.008701149374246597, -0.00788728054612875, 0.04826757311820984, 0.01786031760275364, -0.053543511778116226, -0.03622264415025711, -0.022285467013716698, -0.038577742874622345, -0.030591465532779694, 0.02907288633286953, -0.015949752181768417, -0.030396360903978348, -0.029347864910960197, -0.02444414421916008, -0.034383948892354965, -0.02573198638856411, -0.028031039983034134, -0.03789644315838814, 0.008253701962530613, 0.044553548097610474, 0.012448141351342201, 0.0280151404440403, -0.010415914468467236, -0.00027116353157907724, -0.007239889819175005, -0.08830615133047104, -0.02585900016129017, -0.020719125866889954, -0.0009367023012600839, 0.03624700382351875, -0.00886426493525505, 0.01107830461114645, -0.05256354808807373, 0.022400910034775734, -0.03331513702869415, 0.1041816845536232, 0.0731048434972763, -0.0543292760848999, -0.014465037733316422, 0.019790053367614746, -0.010375807993113995, -0.010145330801606178, 0.003145292866975069, 0.0019978308118879795, -0.052592575550079346, -0.027706844732165337, 0.03226229548454285, 0.13439393043518066, -0.13301745057106018, -0.015882335603237152, -0.0047151027247309685, -0.02959958277642727, 0.014028515666723251, -0.005605051293969154, 0.00009598227188689634, -0.028164386749267578, -0.011385812424123287, 0.008115856908261776, 0.018396150320768356, 0.001196555676870048, 0.0026607937179505825, 0.007526146713644266, -0.02158389613032341, -0.030421560630202293, 0.09746231883764267, -0.01919650286436081, -0.0245345551520586, 0.010668635368347168, -0.07304169982671738, -0.010118548758327961, 0.004758710972964764, -0.004249737598001957, 0.04621829837560654, 0.031143462285399437, -0.01081855222582817, -0.004123835824429989, -0.06917785853147507, 0.046661533415317535, -0.008032776415348053, -0.09017860889434814, 0.03220745921134949, -0.0027399801183491945, -0.051805511116981506, 0.009292966686189175, 0.013367822393774986, 0.0030571636743843555, 0.02151707001030445, -0.0048499987460672855, 0.039032865315675735, -0.015141294337809086, -0.00833036471158266, 0.015288759022951126, -0.019737444818019867, -0.02041047252714634, 0.03416105732321739, 0.008598669432103634, -0.00978331919759512, -0.008483517915010452, 0.04650144651532173, -0.005669810343533754, -0.00934545136988163, -0.005562886130064726, -0.017734874039888382, 0.013682477176189423, 0.052090127021074295, 0.028633326292037964, -0.047190189361572266, -0.014111047610640526, -0.007652711123228073, 0.023591697216033936, -0.003431454300880432, 0.03889627009630203, 0.0515688918530941, -0.013669322244822979, 0.06203074753284454, 0.01829622872173786, 0.0012701040832325816, 0.031132597476243973, 0.056209463626146317, -0.025742249563336372, -0.002680361969396472, -0.06368963420391083, 0.022546010091900826, -0.004813529085367918, -0.06329015642404556, -0.008468792773783207, 0.04049165919423103, 0.037822332233190536, -0.03178107738494873, 0.019940383732318878, 0.03286103904247284, 0.03754572197794914, 0.03329136595129967, 0.004836047068238258, 0.017304755747318268, 0.08839134871959686, 0.048743803054094315, 0.023308755829930305, -0.04114876687526703, 0.008409976959228516, 0.011815795674920082, 0.004439580254256725, 0.005990292876958847, 0.06064318120479584, 0.0031296364031732082, -0.040453001856803894, 0.00020550633780658245, 0.009995522908866405, 0.03476475179195404, 0.0509922169148922, 0.07524120807647705, -0.022486789152026176, -0.03662906587123871, 0.005150031764060259, -0.003459263127297163, -0.010152931325137615, -0.01762535236775875, 0.056624703109264374, 0.016715271398425102, 0.00190956168808043, 0.041702933609485626, 0.024276353418827057, -0.06716862320899963, 0.045247599482536316, -0.011284169740974903, 0.00242917169816792, 0.026265405118465424, 0.029773106798529625, -0.019831888377666473, 0.018595485016703606, -0.059436216950416565, 0.04063425958156586, 0.01480319444090128, -0.009524192661046982, -0.06989353895187378, -0.006122409366071224, -0.023207059130072594, -0.015997355803847313, -0.05983353778719902, -0.00636740867048502, 0.003942067734897137, -0.010993937961757183, -0.02426104061305523, -0.08255434036254883, 0.00788149144500494, 0.022316453978419304, -0.009444277733564377, 0.034245725721120834, 0.013301124796271324, -0.01354042999446392, 0.034350086003541946, -0.06613581627607346, -0.0118250148370862, -0.06429989635944366, 0.0062316968105733395, 0.011391473934054375, -0.004414086230099201, 0.01401551254093647, -0.006256599444895983, -0.02502424642443657, -0.012463840655982494, -0.09224837273359299, -0.03894304484128952, 0.027243610471487045, -0.0335497222840786, 0.02796536311507225, 0.035686392337083817, 0.028346344828605652, 0.03009028546512127, 0.012642007321119308, 0.05997880920767784, 0.014081167057156563, -0.05122219771146774, 0.005966905504465103, -0.0036800906527787447, 0.04891812801361084, 0.010157743468880653, 0.023046907037496567, -0.026184119284152985, -0.026182103902101517, -0.011451038531959057, 0.013748805038630962, 0.06057089567184448, -0.053714390844106674, -0.033965080976486206, 0.0037578237242996693, -0.017233535647392273, 0.01986953243613243, -0.019541839137673378, -0.0643521100282669, -0.023818375542759895, 0.049069859087467194, 0.04906193166971207, -0.0074312142096459866, -0.02930491603910923, 0.008268998004496098, -0.015795771032571793, -0.022174932062625885, -0.007395534310489893, -0.039632558822631836, 0.019733015447854996, 0.04782147333025932, 0.051393523812294006, 0.03310323879122734, 0.0008779339259490371, 0.02167515829205513, -0.0461994968354702, 0.02891741693019867, 0.03168163821101189, -0.036004871129989624, 0.03659411147236824, 0.037574268877506256, -0.07929040491580963, -0.03303966671228409, 0.014365693554282188, -0.04040033370256424, -0.028852691873908043, -0.016463803127408028, 0.0183369442820549, -0.005918615497648716, 0.010903502814471722, -0.028230581432580948, -0.04434740170836449, -0.022561218589544296, 0.02209305576980114, -0.0429471991956234, -0.0006271891761571169, -0.055579639971256256, -0.009596955962479115, 0.020005792379379272, 0.0544792078435421, -0.036628443747758865, -0.000838391890283674, -0.02535347267985344, -0.016217639669775963, 0.02184663712978363, 0.008019829168915749, -0.02910492569208145, 0.042699042707681656, 0.00986065436154604, 0.01640644483268261, -0.03513408079743385, 0.0123409079387784, 0.037072569131851196, 0.023916687816381454, -0.050443001091480255, 0.01786625012755394, 0.03102273680269718, -0.0013039631303399801, -0.02088172547519207, -0.008732639253139496, -0.028502311557531357, -0.035514071583747864, 0.0344400629401207, -0.04096487909555435, -0.037773966789245605, -0.06644392758607864, -0.03365689143538475 ]
<p>I'm trying to develop an inertial navigation system.</p> <p>I can access data from an accelerometer sensor (acceleration on three axes) and gyroscope sensor (angular velocity on three axes).</p> <p>First of all, I integrate my angular velocity data with respect of time, and get angles on all three axes at every moment ($x \to \phi, y \to \theta, z \to \psi$).</p> <p>Then I feed the angles to this rotation matrix</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/USq1f.png" alt="Rotation matrix"></p> <p>and I use it to rotate my acceleration vector at that time, thus taking all my acceleration values on the same reference frame.</p> <p>Finally, I integrate acceleration to get space travelled, using the simple formula $$s(t) = \frac12 a(t) t^2 + v(t - 1)t + s(t - 1)$$</p> <p>My method seems to work fine with fake data, but performs really bad when I plug in the real data, the output is almost meaningless.</p> <p>Am I doing something wrong with the math or I have to search the problem in my implementation?</p>
g4026
[ 0.04747200384736061, 0.016076695173978806, -0.009422368369996548, -0.006584930699318647, 0.016904424875974655, -0.02813022956252098, 0.06574520468711853, -0.008205692283809185, -0.02685130573809147, 0.00555005669593811, -0.0002908508467953652, -0.012134035117924213, 0.057808324694633484, 0.020581601187586784, -0.0031529543921351433, 0.0027043605223298073, 0.02671736851334572, -0.0067708310671150684, -0.004053143318742514, 0.04223446175456047, 0.05320998281240463, 0.016847994178533554, -0.009197093546390533, -0.023297788575291634, 0.02608064003288746, -0.049879997968673706, 0.01876135542988777, -0.01268692221492529, -0.07811889052391052, 0.01454318966716528, 0.03166007995605469, -0.011127741076052189, -0.024028675630688667, -0.01224867906421423, 0.009049028158187866, -0.038762081414461136, -0.013813139870762825, 0.03524021804332733, 0.0009841505670920014, -0.05720899999141693, 0.00010855826258193702, -0.06678930670022964, 0.04126458242535591, 0.03977644443511963, -0.00407034857198596, 0.03391442820429802, 0.018154099583625793, 0.0004363770713098347, -0.020106757059693336, -0.015007873997092247, -0.05807451903820038, 0.04489726945757866, -0.03157583251595497, 0.02689271606504917, 0.023519638925790787, 0.04908636957406998, -0.005552726797759533, -0.004906431306153536, 0.01930304244160652, 0.0033141491003334522, -0.03384638950228691, -0.05681852996349335, 0.0035252170637249947, -0.017101949080824852, 0.07641232013702393, 0.03265240415930748, -0.010159117169678211, 0.03513442352414131, -0.05142560228705406, 0.011161577887833118, 0.019987918436527252, 0.000015266321497620083, 0.06050176918506622, -0.04614151269197464, -0.07653821259737015, 0.013224436901509762, 0.04032254219055176, -0.0387871190905571, -0.022101350128650665, 0.08339790999889374, -0.054647501558065414, 0.013304403983056545, -0.016567006707191467, -0.013140900060534477, 0.009879566729068756, 0.023375848308205605, 0.0037935238797217607, 0.019839121028780937, 0.012599443085491657, -0.04872574657201767, -0.002086354186758399, 0.0024593689013272524, 0.07650452107191086, 0.041652482002973557, -0.012981384992599487, -0.017906716093420982, -0.0808490738272667, 0.038551125675439835, 0.02685595490038395, 0.014555305242538452, -0.003858197946101427, 0.024474848061800003, 0.011763731017708778, -0.0576639324426651, 0.025334302335977554, -0.06677930802106857, 0.08164165914058685, 0.017563404515385628, -0.017920102924108505, -0.027414388954639435, -0.01056644320487976, -0.049958422780036926, -0.004802017472684383, -0.047341279685497284, 0.007138450164347887, -0.022780057042837143, 0.03538765013217926, -0.011630787514150143, -0.0010882940841838717, -0.03191938251256943, -0.0171222947537899, 0.007913151755928993, -0.012890124693512917, 0.06633022427558899, -0.010409386828541756, -0.025487342849373817, -0.0028349629137665033, 0.0021063541062176228, 0.04312892258167267, -0.031023863703012466, -0.040428221225738525, -0.03812040761113167, -0.022140134125947952, 0.01224728673696518, -0.011116256937384605, -0.010193046182394028, 0.002135145477950573, -0.032410766929388046, -0.006077941972762346, 0.060259539633989334, -0.019020797684788704, -0.07412321120500565, -0.0002048386086244136, -0.03262501582503319, -0.014845173805952072, 0.011732316575944424, -0.04114001244306564, -0.025319866836071014, 0.08244521170854568, -0.023816097527742386, 0.00818311981856823, 0.10421033203601837, -0.002297176979482174, 0.016634777188301086, 0.05063607543706894, -0.017314143478870392, 0.03737134113907814, -0.07750217616558075, 0.030761629343032837, 0.012791385874152184, 0.0805366039276123, -0.018069438636302948, 0.10189129412174225, -0.0015254875179380178, -0.030399193987250328, 0.031610336154699326, -0.0676494762301445, -0.0404323935508728, 0.02510441653430462, -0.043817128986120224, -0.015002500265836716, 0.031099770218133926, 0.04360295459628105, -0.05592034012079239, -0.0576685406267643, 0.006884072907269001, 0.007586644031107426, -0.02759486995637417, -0.010864479467272758, 0.002399357035756111, 0.010455325245857239, 0.03906610980629921, 0.014194365590810776, -0.03611928969621658, -0.002061301376670599, 0.001255507580935955, -0.0377037487924099, -0.005904132965952158, -0.09348250925540924, -0.006755554582923651, 0.005894066300243139, 0.004796015098690987, 0.017751796171069145, 0.011407874524593353, -0.010768882930278778, 0.019941512495279312, 0.040378011763095856, -0.060713909566402435, -0.0495486855506897, 0.08147885650396347, 0.008087494410574436, 0.0415218286216259, 0.03092729113996029, 0.029810892418026924, 0.03861444070935249, -0.0647563561797142, -0.0031364955939352512, -0.023402085527777672, 0.004175284411758184, 0.04034586623311043, 0.011266113258898258, 0.07587547600269318, -0.04716220498085022, 0.06550164520740509, 0.016041286289691925, -0.03011894039809704, 0.05453525111079216, -0.033877573907375336, 0.018814880400896072, -0.0007505752728320658, -0.01342795230448246, -0.04819274693727493, 0.03569870814681053, -0.029356643557548523, -0.03687218576669693, -0.016694271937012672, -0.024829819798469543, -0.03191741183400154, 0.015154390595853329, -0.02034028433263302, 0.009224331937730312, -0.003487975336611271, 0.015661990270018578, -0.0015371395274996758, 0.08199124783277512, 0.023075370118021965, -0.01557364035397768, 0.02671593241393566, 0.043624263256788254, 0.03465677425265312, -0.009727300144731998, 0.0032352148555219173, -0.010748747736215591, -0.053840361535549164, 0.07057158648967743, -0.019384928047657013, 0.07392561435699463, -0.016774136573076248, 0.03781379014253616, 0.008797548711299896, -0.06172296777367592, 0.05740183964371681, -0.048318516463041306, -0.00268215942196548, -0.03199292719364166, 0.07160540670156479, 0.005103006958961487, -0.012960930354893208, -0.0012654609745368361, 0.0622066967189312, -0.04561647027730942, -0.004863278474658728, 0.004733117762953043, 0.043403442949056625, -0.026557547971606255, 0.006982248742133379, 0.013034914620220661, 0.014087498188018799, 0.03284074738621712, 0.0012632963480427861, -0.06032276153564453, 0.02359752543270588, 0.0677017942070961, 0.034359607845544815, 0.032335616648197174, 0.011727001518011093, -0.0013243950670585036, -0.011078175157308578, -0.021912382915616035, -0.006571883801370859, -0.0779479593038559, -0.06923478096723557, 0.0033445926383137703, 0.05236857756972313, 0.024293167516589165, -0.047369975596666336, 0.02652168832719326, 0.02262609638273716, -0.03427554666996002, -0.013862441293895245, -0.03647258132696152, -0.00544275576248765, -0.010199322365224361, 0.0009703434188850224, -0.012122277170419693, 0.04102400690317154, 0.004794935695827007, -0.021515732631087303, 0.06267630308866501, 0.006018095184117556, 0.017279721796512604, 0.036060821264982224, 0.04783405363559723, -0.009312796406447887, -0.04251252859830856, -0.030814388766884804, 0.02660885639488697, -0.02550242468714714, -0.018069172278046608, 0.03610583767294884, -0.012181935831904411, -0.04205518215894699, 0.002492527710273862, -0.05315489321947098, -0.006160352379083633, -0.03922678902745247, -0.012099641375243664, -0.02298770099878311, -0.01686961017549038, -0.007427011150866747, -0.040663957595825195, -0.09089036285877228, -0.0392729714512825, -0.013389475643634796, 0.013049923814833164, 0.01846947893500328, 0.006336568854749203, 0.008151763118803501, -0.003649170743301511, -0.0458555743098259, 0.00240144575946033, 0.04167664796113968, -0.034742336720228195, 0.035334162414073944, -0.017263256013393402, -0.0413874126970768, -0.04363736882805824, 0.03207309916615486, -0.019665656611323357, -0.004516621585935354, -0.09880521148443222, -0.023477351292967796, 0.017147190868854523, -0.04171403497457504, 0.026789991185069084, -0.008308998309075832, -0.0010350901866331697, 0.025508679449558258, 0.03051692247390747, -0.032530203461647034, 0.03342469409108162, -0.0066296011209487915, -0.0022995215840637684, -0.0206394474953413, -0.04614335671067238, 0.03251466527581215, 0.007459969259798527, 0.03188037499785423, -0.0031638522632420063, 0.022524988278746605, 0.03678963705897331, 0.004618632607161999, -0.0151698412373662, 0.02687765099108219, 0.01334268506616354, 0.014316494576632977, -0.008845414966344833, 0.09506803750991821, 0.03099309839308262, 0.00026694239932112396, 0.0424407422542572, -0.03380560129880905, 0.05190974473953247, -0.09188389778137207, -0.0028763862792402506, -0.05517596751451492, -0.015994487330317497, 0.008716593496501446, -0.025606434792280197, 0.04874453693628311, 0.07574130594730377, 0.03063536435365677, -0.0050806705839931965, -0.015387974679470062, 0.059592343866825104, 0.0045391470193862915, 0.026597408577799797, 0.012989438138902187, 0.005557426251471043, -0.00681658461689949, 0.007239869330078363, -0.027095062658190727, 0.010245166718959808, 0.01264370046555996, 0.04796447232365608, -0.09740357100963593, -0.036513131111860275, 0.0003712170582730323, -0.03381681814789772, -0.016123831272125244, -0.0598488412797451, 0.014337853528559208, 0.047091733664274216, 0.007316477131098509, -0.0422917902469635, 0.0006016881670802832, 0.005653843283653259, 0.03547856584191322, 0.012036027386784554, 0.0400218591094017, -0.02972051128745079, 0.012099821120500565, 0.02561931498348713, -0.04693374037742615, 0.0372934453189373, 0.02818620577454567, 0.05982914939522743, -0.0287411380559206, -0.05660909786820412, -0.022907862439751625, -0.033362481743097305, 0.11262130737304688, 0.001880971947684884, -0.04218759015202522, -0.019293958321213722, 0.05481550097465515, 0.01158746238797903, -0.011148401536047459, 0.0377969816327095, 0.03402971103787422, 0.047041747719049454, -0.005531165283173323, -0.0006472746026702225, 0.02098418027162552, -0.03302463889122009, 0.0621032789349556, 0.018081318587064743, 0.06309548020362854, 0.020161690190434456, 0.026110902428627014, 0.007859839126467705, 0.007514416240155697, 0.021445050835609436, -0.04194662347435951, -0.0035979917738586664, 0.04484550282359123, -0.005437653046101332, -0.03689533844590187, 0.043429382145404816, 0.008304259739816189, 0.008102642372250557, -0.05854929983615875, 0.04534788802266121, 0.009007214568555355, 0.0060979644767940044, 0.04244433715939522, -0.009057284332811832, 0.04653388634324074, -0.017684847116470337, 0.0074643585830926895, -0.028202924877405167, 0.045946914702653885, -0.1046467125415802, -0.043803103268146515, -0.000736858113668859, -0.019559314474463463, -0.04260780289769173, -0.0010731457732617855, 0.05357818678021431, -0.04855423793196678, 0.03148140013217926, -0.012746158987283707, -0.037949755787849426, 0.022493384778499603, 0.03627811744809151, 0.03962273895740509, 0.008499950170516968, 0.05822562426328659, -0.025830773636698723, -0.020421039313077927, -0.019455203786492348, 0.031920913606882095, 0.028892774134874344, 0.0462644062936306, 0.043333686888217926, 0.006941931787878275, -0.031412698328495026, -0.034884028136730194, 0.05722489207983017, -0.01753060892224312, 0.06012007221579552, 0.029989395290613174, 0.02120073139667511, -0.07287426292896271, 0.030197732150554657, 0.04001764953136444, -0.0245578084141016, -0.047849979251623154, -0.07435600459575653, -0.029027627781033516, -0.06446205824613571, -0.003013905370607972, -0.06841918081045151, -0.05769836902618408, 0.03588481619954109, 0.003569216700270772, 0.051546305418014526, 0.046551503241062164, -0.03420308604836464, 0.033505041152238846, 0.04545051231980324, 0.011428861878812313, 0.03649890050292015, -0.025280063971877098, -0.024082142859697342, -0.022804854437708855, 0.03936336189508438, 0.014692842029035091, 0.005274687893688679, -0.03984545171260834, 0.0293460451066494, 0.02490183897316456, -0.017569223418831825, -0.04600018262863159, 0.0069743250496685505, 0.04528540372848511, 0.008307233452796936, -0.05040409788489342, 0.005507424473762512, 0.0025498310569673777, -0.03694722056388855, -0.012113175354897976, -0.00692271301522851, -0.030039140954613686, 0.025079231709241867, -0.010192863643169403, 0.003024469595402479, -0.06457484513521194, 0.08424082398414612, -0.04149111360311508, -0.053510770201683044, -0.004270828794687986, -0.01119192037731409, 0.04987522214651108, -0.04563894867897034, 0.003783551976084709, 0.004179022740572691, -0.003731822595000267, 0.0758647471666336, -0.007876131683588028, -0.027722664177417755, 0.008431396447122097, 0.006916681304574013, -0.06862533837556839, 0.010580098256468773, 0.001930907485075295, -0.06307804584503174, 0.03838576748967171, -0.05280962213873863, 0.027399243786931038, 0.020825674757361412, -0.0049802702851593494, 0.054604820907115936, -0.00950688123703003, 0.00689424155279994, 0.016988810151815414, 0.04166984558105469, 0.053113825619220734, -0.021312443539500237, -0.011378678493201733, -0.02776375785470009, -0.02448214963078499, -0.03947627544403076, 0.01626516319811344, 0.046119675040245056, 0.013786494731903076, 0.0006309236632660031, -0.0002715211594477296, -0.019567081704735756, 0.027220189571380615, 0.006455595139414072, -0.045063383877277374, 0.024719998240470886, 0.0175455454736948, 0.010198003612458706, -0.02642122656106949, -0.07082965224981308, -0.043990813195705414, -0.0028196305502206087, -0.08913140743970871, -0.061169784516096115, 0.04668693616986275, -0.02346186153590679, -0.020650990307331085, -0.05730712413787842, -0.0642126277089119, 0.0072157299146056175, 0.018164288252592087, 0.013232310302555561, -0.027632644400000572, 0.01602536253631115, -0.008269163779914379, 0.05517948791384697, -0.02890857867896557, -0.03281132131814957, -0.07250466197729111, -0.006004501134157181, 0.0008960241102613509, 0.034896399825811386, 0.00333013036288321, -0.023698225617408752, 0.02380484528839588, -0.044244248420000076, 0.10813485085964203, 0.006525586824864149, 0.025830978527665138, 0.025867894291877747, -0.011636193841695786, 0.007742647547274828, 0.008351041935384274, 0.04508279636502266, 0.015986017882823944, 0.016207383945584297, 0.02737119421362877, 0.04807152599096298, -0.0017711222171783447, 0.009295131079852581, 0.006147779058665037, 0.0018491122173145413, -0.015499187633395195, 0.014133390039205551, 0.003389685181900859, -0.026980910450220108, 0.0030264919623732567, 0.03586885705590248, 0.04459870234131813, 0.01923574134707451, 0.044625334441661835, 0.01030364353209734, 0.06574155390262604, -0.0037463807966560125, 0.027040734887123108, -0.05205116048455238, -0.00019885018991772085, -0.023248057812452316, -0.040703099220991135, -0.013524959795176983, 0.013508475385606289, -0.03952920809388161, 0.06053802743554115, 0.09277408570051193, -0.03439650312066078, 0.033439356833696365, -0.002299588406458497, -0.019661538302898407, -0.01209811121225357, 0.002703206380829215, 0.025506410747766495, 0.029663171619176865, -0.04522943124175072, 0.004133528098464012, -0.04189436510205269, -0.027504492551088333, 0.00953954178839922, 0.014042134396731853, -0.00861644372344017, -0.040292542427778244, 0.022384585812687874, 0.05240854620933533, -0.025171572342514992, -0.0016175074269995093, 0.006675692740827799, 0.008264373056590557, 0.014968997798860073, 0.0054405187256634235, 0.003951513674110174, 0.032119233161211014, -0.037059586495161057, -0.08166946470737457, -0.015102149918675423, -0.004769496154040098, 0.03978542238473892, 0.005538464058190584, 0.0680602490901947, 0.005609180778264999, -0.01734825037419796, 0.002193581545725465, -0.07362480461597443, -0.0888919085264206, -0.03864593058824539, 0.00963143352419138, 0.020902249962091446, 0.00020186898473184556, 0.02349451556801796, -0.008534027263522148, -0.006268590223044157, 0.021775344386696815, 0.041821401566267014, -0.036605555564165115, 0.01687774620950222, -0.0022417681757360697, -0.012826171703636646, 0.03041113168001175, 0.028668787330389023, 0.01882893219590187, 0.03052365779876709, 0.010733299888670444, 0.015100383199751377, 0.0006657954072579741, 0.04597098007798195, -0.01519753411412239, 0.03373673930764198, -0.02904500626027584, -0.018559949472546577, -0.02982804924249649, -0.02266419120132923, 0.0004380911123007536, 0.017840495333075523, -0.029094021767377853, -0.04190967231988907, -0.08423956483602524, -0.033279161900281906, 0.030061088502407074, -0.02949131652712822, 0.007697624154388905, -0.046828411519527435, -0.021676337346434593, -0.02661433257162571, 0.010161465965211391, -0.04264216870069504, -0.04883235692977905, -0.010202925652265549, -0.011136606335639954, 0.040854182094335556, -0.02418142557144165, 0.005346997175365686, 0.032489337027072906, -0.08398237824440002, -0.010717380791902542, 0.0704788789153099, -0.019564665853977203, -0.0239662267267704, -0.023472724482417107, -0.015190931037068367, 0.03112560510635376, 0.0014458608347922564, -0.01384003832936287, 0.013060369528830051, 0.04393294081091881, -0.01756877824664116, 0.007692560087889433, 0.0001148088849731721, -0.10872668772935867, -0.030943723395466805, -0.002922650193795562, 0.016108250245451927, 0.03628804534673691, -0.01700364612042904, 0.030789462849497795, 0.0060880836099386215, 0.009800602681934834, -0.025771133601665497, -0.06623893976211548, 0.00808987021446228, -0.00047096857451833785, -0.08537155389785767, -0.034094203263521194, 0.05225801467895508 ]
<p>Consider a liquid solid interface $z =\zeta(x,t)$ moving at constant speed $v$, for a two dimensional problem. Due to solidification interface is changing it position. For simplicity heat conductivities, heat capacity of liquid and solid are assumed to be the same. Heat conduction equation in the liquid and solid region is \begin{eqnarray} C\frac{\partial T}{\partial t} &amp;=&amp; k\nabla^2 T \nonumber \\ \end{eqnarray} Here, $k$, $C$ are heat conductivity and heat capacity.</p> <p>Heat balance equation at interface is \begin{eqnarray} Lv &amp;=&amp; k(\nabla T_s - \nabla T_l)\cdot \hat n \nonumber \\ \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>$L$ latent heat of solidification. $\hat n$ is unit normal to the interface and $v_n$ is velocity of interface in the normal direction. $T_l$ and $T_s$ are temperatures in the liquid and solid domains.</p> <p>Boundary conditions are: \begin{eqnarray} T &amp;=&amp; T_{\infty} \hspace{1cm}z \to \infty \\ T &amp;=&amp; T_m \hspace{1cm} z = \zeta(x,t) \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>I need to find Green's function for this problem. Green's function for heat diffusion of point source is</p> <p>\begin{eqnarray} G = \frac{1}{{4\pi D(t-t_1)}}\exp\left(-\frac{(x-x_1)^2 +(z-z_1)^2}{4\pi D (t-t_1)}\right) \end{eqnarray} Where $D= k/C$</p> <p>Then I proceeded as follows:</p> <p>Since all the heat generated is at the interface $\zeta(x,t)$, \begin{eqnarray} T - T_{\infty} = \int^{t}_{0}dt_1 \int^{}_{}dx_1\frac{1}{{4\pi D(t-t_1)}}\exp\left(-\frac{(x-x_1)^2 +(z-z_1)^2}{4\pi D (t-t_1)}\right) \zeta(x,t) \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>Research <a href="http://journals.aps.org/rmp/abstract/10.1103/RevModPhys.52.1" rel="nofollow">paper</a> gives following equation, \begin{eqnarray} \frac{T-T_\infty}{L/C} &amp;=&amp; \int^t_0 dt_1 \int^{\infty}_{-\infty}dx_1 G[x-x_1, z-\zeta(x_1,t_1)+ v(t-t_1), t-t_1] \left( v + \frac{\partial \zeta}{\partial t}\right) \end{eqnarray}</p> <p>where,\begin{equation} G(x,t) = \frac{1}{{4\pi D(t)}}\exp\left(-\frac{(x)^2 +(z+vt)^2}{4\pi D (t)}\right) \end{equation}</p> <p>which is clearly different from what I assume. How can I arrive at this equation?</p>
g4027
[ 0.029401889070868492, -0.01653941348195076, -0.0013700281269848347, 0.029367495328187943, 0.06093302741646767, -0.021647892892360687, 0.0740545243024826, 0.053169362246990204, -0.06599795073270798, -0.013076706789433956, -0.04111992567777634, 0.013403074815869331, 0.02317548356950283, 0.02419205941259861, 0.003035056171938777, 0.006206525955349207, 0.04121080040931702, -0.04824027419090271, -0.03275180235505104, 0.09271834790706635, 0.01075153797864914, 0.02330828830599785, 0.019562574103474617, -0.017568331211805344, 0.0011239395244047046, -0.08119378983974457, -0.048350535333156586, -0.015096364542841911, -0.008993836119771004, -0.009663480333983898, -0.03564376384019852, 0.0028477434534579515, 0.009882817976176739, -0.005324637517333031, -0.029384365305304527, 0.04188591241836548, 0.04109565541148186, -0.05014524608850479, 0.03572474792599678, -0.046048011630773544, -0.0007456798921339214, -0.0036502566654235125, 0.03522943705320358, 0.017796669155359268, 0.07148072868585587, 0.018255099654197693, -0.02727128379046917, -0.008872597478330135, -0.017532870173454285, 0.060443177819252014, 0.022700674831867218, 0.10624539852142334, 0.01522009540349245, -0.027562905102968216, -0.04860362783074379, 0.038847409188747406, 0.001941501279361546, 0.019703026860952377, 0.03133188188076019, 0.030643001198768616, 0.03118184395134449, 0.014910670928657055, -0.04218157008290291, -0.06159910187125206, 0.026798846200108528, -0.007567043881863356, 0.014094673097133636, 0.01353626698255539, 0.0022400894667953253, -0.010191073641180992, 0.04705391451716423, -0.015167256817221642, 0.04432547837495804, -0.013000788167119026, -0.07024208456277847, 0.0007591082830913365, 0.04651670157909393, -0.048218853771686554, 0.012681723572313786, -0.029802953824400902, -0.07494635879993439, 0.0009847186738625169, -0.03301740810275078, 0.03436373174190521, -0.011742635630071163, 0.0494295135140419, -0.012090543285012245, 0.015694985166192055, -0.021338270977139473, 0.006917098071426153, -0.023137373849749565, 0.058585114777088165, 0.018538953736424446, -0.022308168932795525, 0.05821984261274338, -0.004817174281924963, 0.0052969735115766525, 0.023146606981754303, -0.03848028555512428, -0.04253320023417473, 0.04389064013957977, -0.0003495355194900185, 0.061768949031829834, 0.03298452869057655, -0.02730957232415676, 0.0006254686741158366, 0.011523392982780933, 0.0013587453868240118, -0.03186836466193199, 0.013930539600551128, 0.07830203324556351, -0.03920729458332062, 0.023574892431497574, -0.017818298190832138, 0.05570152774453163, 0.022708207368850708, 0.04350496456027031, 0.023506704717874527, -0.03411359339952469, -0.01992851123213768, -0.006606504321098328, -0.03542764112353325, -0.007431270554661751, 0.03952684625983238, 0.027190061286091805, 0.016272448003292084, 0.03723158687353134, -0.0167438555508852, 0.03265904262661934, 0.029177121818065643, 0.012046176008880138, 0.03217409551143646, 0.0787656232714653, 0.017426079139113426, -0.026054732501506805, 0.0385945625603199, -0.005307740066200495, 0.020823977887630463, 0.0006726969731971622, 0.017678193747997284, 0.025445392355322838, -0.0636860728263855, -0.00181554164737463, -0.010642769746482372, -0.028797484934329987, 0.050892457365989685, -0.004863398149609566, -0.06866440176963806, 0.03596004098653793, -0.02710798569023609, 0.006548784673213959, 0.08011247217655182, 0.00688083516433835, 0.06481993198394775, -0.00712727103382349, -0.0007830093381926417, 0.033065348863601685, -0.02817324548959732, 0.035363566130399704, -0.04381280392408371, 0.027721794322133064, -0.06286682933568954, 0.016723651438951492, 0.012324688956141472, 0.02487272210419178, 0.016487672924995422, 0.0034534672740846872, -0.0306654404848814, -0.0015751391183584929, -0.019404219463467598, -0.044508196413517, 0.04547800496220589, 0.003168961266055703, 0.05059409886598587, 0.03685822710394859, -0.014883897267282009, -0.04384641349315643, 0.007242775056511164, -0.013844050467014313, -0.027003558352589607, -0.037862759083509445, -0.026612086221575737, 0.04036130756139755, -0.018485859036445618, 0.00547107495367527, -0.024724459275603294, 0.05696791410446167, -0.04437648504972458, -0.02505601942539215, 0.019940754398703575, -0.010202745907008648, 0.002668732311576605, -0.05454811453819275, 0.025131044909358025, 0.010133404284715652, 0.014176560565829277, 0.06405102461576462, -0.0879787877202034, -0.04912092536687851, -0.06350114196538925, -0.0005004897830076516, 0.05089268088340759, 0.011728992685675621, -0.004717790521681309, -0.005027433857321739, 0.020338496193289757, -0.001082659000530839, 0.018010107800364494, -0.05382274463772774, 0.020255008712410927, -0.028078438714146614, -0.0408322848379612, -0.05162445828318596, 0.026219483464956284, 0.012374038808047771, -0.05109028518199921, -0.013981570489704609, 0.01038681622594595, 0.00657404912635684, -0.06380417197942734, -0.016647659242153168, 0.034369368106126785, -0.03776680305600166, -0.019973767921328545, -0.0673179104924202, -0.041890617460012436, 0.06428983062505722, 0.009026340208947659, -0.03697435185313225, 0.05986044183373451, -0.0065783667378127575, -0.0008817595662549138, 0.05384254828095436, -0.0344729870557785, 0.02065226621925831, -0.015649015083909035, -0.08529779314994812, 0.021180175244808197, -0.013593411073088646, -0.020499233156442642, -0.022161463275551796, -0.040455933660268784, -0.05846620723605156, 0.004444994032382965, 0.024097945541143417, 0.005151441320776939, 0.04742538928985596, 0.008392145857214928, 0.042716000229120255, 0.01098145917057991, 0.08467783033847809, 0.02076811157166958, -0.029623795300722122, -0.01592666655778885, 0.0038215932436287403, -0.08728236705064774, -0.03024795465171337, -0.012614068575203419, -0.019038300961256027, -0.11432774364948273, -0.029484601691365242, -0.033266231417655945, 0.06314242631196976, 0.026332173496484756, -0.04278358444571495, -0.022450517863035202, -0.05941601097583771, -0.012039384804666042, 0.006436972413212061, -0.01581989787518978, 0.016697902232408524, -0.050187092274427414, 0.019639387726783752, 0.03195040673017502, -0.0026543946005403996, -0.038752831518650055, 0.02368738502264023, -0.04888804629445076, 0.0514361746609211, 0.02668154053390026, 0.0187221672385931, 0.0012495628325268626, 0.014270591549575329, 0.01093162689357996, -0.010537608526647091, -0.07123640179634094, 0.025695882737636566, 0.03389080613851547, -0.0009592571295797825, 0.0002282571658724919, 0.009928837418556213, -0.03277535364031792, -0.02401113323867321, 0.021679595112800598, 0.06737791746854782, -0.02118457853794098, -0.007885378785431385, -0.042635928839445114, 0.03600039333105087, -0.04609815403819084, 0.025923825800418854, -0.015398724004626274, 0.00011656692367978394, 0.009639887139201164, -0.02281961590051651, -0.016457920894026756, -0.02396905981004238, -0.03246508538722992, 0.013039148412644863, -0.025524836033582687, 0.06556091457605362, 0.03301020339131355, -0.017434202134609222, -0.0018203709041699767, -0.0026884451508522034, 0.029461801052093506, 0.016605641692876816, -0.02849835902452469, 0.03618406131863594, -0.030862413346767426, 0.014261663891375065, -0.015325461514294147, 0.05123504251241684, 0.004711614456027746, 0.0285412035882473, 0.0476672537624836, 0.01738465018570423, 0.003276931121945381, -0.09127942472696304, 0.035961076617240906, 0.014501657336950302, 0.03420379012823105, -0.03070438653230667, -0.03195284307003021, -0.04161445423960686, -0.05127060413360596, 0.026226738467812538, 0.05045069754123688, 0.07838703691959381, 0.023798741400241852, -0.03179570287466049, 0.0061668879352509975, -0.03147253394126892, 0.009803182445466518, -0.009659686125814915, -0.06707154214382172, 0.02267024852335453, 0.09348860383033752, -0.017288994044065475, 0.0295659601688385, 0.0439593642950058, -0.02970964089035988, 0.006062634754925966, 0.008266030810773373, -0.027161195874214172, 0.015432952903211117, 0.034774765372276306, 0.0070187728852033615, -0.03842555731534958, -0.007590411696583033, 0.015671057626605034, -0.05314115434885025, 0.03791948780417442, 0.003523115999996662, 0.0364275723695755, -0.015603607520461082, 0.03354357182979584, -0.04977206513285637, -0.07064369320869446, -0.005771665368229151, 0.01209329441189766, -0.0049587939865887165, 0.024708369746804237, 0.01702680066227913, -0.014115854166448116, 0.014855196699500084, 0.006578220520168543, 0.037974994629621506, -0.08723251521587372, 0.03468367084860802, 0.004133714362978935, -0.003512354800477624, 0.020402565598487854, 0.03760470449924469, -0.001991269877180457, 0.013279971666634083, -0.0053428104147315025, -0.017978837713599205, 0.020113620907068253, -0.03406285122036934, 0.022246846929192543, -0.03364451229572296, 0.018023161217570305, -0.014281108044087887, -0.030821967869997025, -0.046804241836071014, 0.016054874286055565, 0.021113425493240356, -0.01730499044060707, -0.026279160752892494, -0.03132569044828415, -0.033071693032979965, 0.02265210635960102, -0.011161889880895615, -0.060142986476421356, -0.042637892067432404, 0.021307094022631645, 0.0011796406470239162, 0.01406111940741539, -0.1038488894701004, 0.004333436954766512, -0.005017627030611038, 0.010782213881611824, 0.04128007963299751, 0.01056764181703329, -0.04036839306354523, -0.003266917774453759, -0.031753793358802795, -0.003907256294041872, -0.010893412865698338, -0.018466448411345482, -0.03695070371031761, 0.023475635796785355, -0.017836211249232292, 0.07451920211315155, -0.0008531818748451769, 0.048158641904592514, -0.019947152584791183, 0.003130831988528371, -0.05545832961797714, -0.03937491029500961, 0.015131930820643902, -0.03658148646354675, 0.05952155590057373, -0.034484848380088806, 0.06074127182364464, 0.004375563934445381, 0.017487749457359314, -0.020010964944958687, 0.012321805581450462, 0.0015169456601142883, 0.026940248906612396, -0.022701699286699295, 0.05859394371509552, 0.004084977321326733, 0.02678668312728405, -0.04940195009112358, -0.04071762040257454, -0.00008538323891116306, -0.07491758465766907, -0.0058993566781282425, 0.014445720240473747, 0.009073705412447453, 0.026184728369116783, -0.01694314368069172, -0.006823851726949215, -0.025708777830004692, -0.006961211562156677, 0.00197071535512805, 0.0259978249669075, -0.048195499926805496, 0.021859029307961464, -0.05016123130917549, -0.05570026859641075, 0.022970229387283325, -0.009090432897210121, -0.02487640641629696, 0.04092441871762276, 0.03958725184202194, 0.018872208893299103, 0.01863492839038372, 0.020041506737470627, 0.049145739525556564, 0.02636571228504181, 0.011647953651845455, 0.01661347970366478, 0.01621248573064804, 0.023812225088477135, 0.010658851824700832, -0.04269562289118767, 0.012915773317217827, 0.013364802114665508, 0.01928134821355343, 0.043223313987255096, 0.04047059267759323, -0.023943040519952774, -0.024662133306264877, -0.008749992586672306, 0.04384317621588707, 0.046420980244874954, 0.031803861260414124, -0.06676778942346573, -0.02379634603857994, -0.0024428737815469503, -0.06355832517147064, -0.007405214011669159, 0.04305744916200638, 0.003165873698890209, 0.004896915052086115, 0.018783772364258766, -0.06739576905965805, -0.015679143369197845, 0.009573711082339287, -0.006190338637679815, 0.041045185178518295, 0.03644191473722458, 0.037481095641851425, 0.02189386636018753, 0.008990178816020489, 0.03238006681203842, 0.02864071913063526, 0.012093894183635712, -0.00615374930202961, -0.08259738981723785, -0.002386627485975623, 0.0008498688112013042, 0.05080965533852577, -0.01840401440858841, 0.056876033544540405, -0.017512593418359756, 0.020903797820210457, 0.027468837797641754, -0.05207492411136627, -0.01569373346865177, -0.05196090415120125, -0.011380528099834919, -0.05300910398364067, 0.03149881586432457, -0.011903910897672176, -0.031518373638391495, 0.007164825685322285, 0.025364583358168602, -0.025042686611413956, -0.014743962325155735, -0.0789279118180275, 0.02230803668498993, -0.062160346657037735, -0.023574987426400185, -0.03631380945444107, -0.001606276840902865, -0.023827141150832176, -0.018347803503274918, 0.0336514450609684, 0.059114474803209305, 0.06222360581159592, 0.037335023283958435, -0.06503742188215256, -0.020070862025022507, -0.009793887846171856, 0.0014834884786978364, 0.08400211483240128, -0.028901034966111183, -0.037836890667676926, 0.02552897110581398, 0.029952777549624443, 0.010596743784844875, 0.02595050074160099, -0.016362491995096207, 0.007294004783034325, -0.04206152632832527, -0.03415578603744507, -0.02923838421702385, -0.02710532210767269, 0.056496474891901016, 0.021638568490743637, -0.06469633430242538, -0.04503847286105156, 0.02018876001238823, 0.01631794683635235, -0.021022144705057144, -0.01873398944735527, 0.00991452019661665, 0.008974662981927395, 0.0033604076597839594, 0.024323321878910065, 0.052401699125766754, -0.05987041816115379, 0.012456518597900867, -0.01959262043237686, 0.04534365236759186, -0.06315243244171143, 0.03409970551729202, 0.01729419454932213, 0.011313767172396183, -0.009353683330118656, 0.017359884455800056, -0.008456707932054996, -0.10224377363920212, -0.021296463906764984, -0.013864187523722649, -0.008448162116110325, 0.010744255967438221, -0.02606021612882614, -0.0033636922016739845, 0.002314319834113121, -0.026637881994247437, -0.012889382429420948, -0.006047085393220186, -0.036056965589523315, 0.09794903546571732, -0.017662741243839264, -0.0435154102742672, -0.03327609971165657, -0.025636741891503334, -0.03636210784316063, -0.028672074899077415, 0.006138165015727282, 0.057196326553821564, 0.0011608507484197617, -0.06388844549655914, 0.005333101376891136, 0.010992743074893951, 0.04338384047150612, 0.029762178659439087, -0.017097264528274536, -0.041581928730010986, -0.003448783652856946, 0.033565059304237366, 0.02601499669253826, -0.009068342857062817, 0.016032932326197624, 0.00948925781995058, 0.04113560542464256, -0.038252413272857666, 0.05333300307393074, -0.0007857371238060296, -0.06016120687127113, -0.0011092328932136297, 0.0035955843050032854, 0.017260851338505745, 0.10866845399141312, -0.004485445562750101, -0.02224676124751568, 0.006698650307953358, -0.006701495964080095, 0.006778594572097063, 0.006819433532655239, -0.003204213222488761, 0.08659903705120087, 0.050957050174474716, 0.03468926623463631, -0.005332674365490675, 0.018124490976333618, -0.013252507895231247, -0.03207040950655937, -0.019709620624780655, -0.026350155472755432, 0.0143149858340621, -0.14301258325576782, 0.018721843138337135, 0.04486282542347908, 0.030484534800052643, -0.016451837494969368, -0.023469876497983932, 0.030089987441897392, 0.07300857454538345, 0.03179009631276131, 0.01295999065041542, -0.05615287646651268, 0.02829701080918312, -0.006462083663791418, -0.013583026826381683, 0.05420712009072304, 0.007320258300751448, 0.007348467130213976, 0.10979252308607101, 0.03992895409464836, -0.007383263669908047, 0.01645771600306034, -0.044373806565999985, -0.06059287488460541, -0.07392439991235733, -0.04397937282919884, 0.03250141069293022, -0.009480071254074574, 0.04638248309493065, 0.08064281195402145, 0.08088547736406326, -0.025582198053598404, -0.014351118355989456, 0.039254769682884216, -0.030933497473597527, -0.008876432664692402, -0.04299219325184822, 0.011571193113923073, -0.019563058391213417, 0.01260681264102459, -0.0206302423030138, 0.031107444316148758, 0.06003322824835777, -0.04463961720466614, 0.008718234486877918, -0.05368609353899956, 0.03903292492032051, -0.04995334520936012, -0.009915118105709553, -0.013743891380727291, 0.04907875508069992, 0.052116941660642624, 0.015283329412341118, -0.02657274901866913, -0.027453826740384102, 0.006109561305493116, 0.022841423749923706, -0.0471770353615284, 0.01503409817814827, -0.019476696848869324, -0.02110711857676506, -0.007890206761658192, -0.00008131610229611397, 0.005242755636572838, -0.003487531328573823, -0.016127025708556175, -0.001075964537449181, 0.014807585626840591, 0.011178415268659592, 0.010997624136507511, -0.0330512560904026, 0.0435076504945755, -0.037367209792137146, -0.02477264404296875, -0.05602124705910683, -0.07776582986116409, -0.04380455240607262, -0.02521793730556965, -0.03464910760521889, -0.005740191787481308, -0.056666284799575806, 0.0084237614646554, 0.04067760705947876, -0.036183323711156845, 0.025207223370671272, -0.014470811001956463, -0.027049966156482697, -0.05269155278801918, -0.00656902464106679, 0.014037253335118294, -0.006462936755269766, 0.07522828876972198, -0.027784844860434532, -0.05716181546449661, -0.03093969263136387, 0.06259883940219879, -0.010404524393379688, 0.025217045098543167, -0.0008454335038550198, -0.016602590680122375, 0.05779503285884857, 0.07520333677530289, -0.012746049091219902, 0.05548751726746559, -0.020605262368917465, -0.020912423729896545, -0.02946331538259983, -0.030009862035512924, -0.006902478169649839, 0.019614582881331444, -0.015156756155192852, -0.015935955569148064, -0.02233043499290943, -0.08990219235420227, -0.05423969402909279, 0.01790473982691765, 0.02765195444226265, -0.01616888865828514, 0.024849290028214455, 0.03299596905708313, 0.016035940498113632 ]
<p>Nuclei spontaneously decay according to a certain decay rate. There are however different kinds of decay, alpha, beta, gamma... What causes then the nuclei, when they decay, to do so in one way of another? Is there a different decay rate for each kind of decay? </p>
g4028
[ 0.045727673918008804, 0.0340418666601181, 0.014529779553413391, 0.007539689540863037, 0.11773519963026047, -0.01138167455792427, -0.004185735713690519, 0.03637080267071724, -0.0035794698633253574, -0.0705588087439537, -0.021588940173387527, 0.03290054574608803, -0.009445559233427048, 0.09001660346984863, 0.03236939758062363, -0.04617050662636757, 0.03453749045729637, -0.019830647855997086, 0.05986568704247475, 0.029523564502596855, -0.007410900201648474, 0.02670315094292164, -0.03530862182378769, 0.00553407846018672, 0.027181867510080338, -0.015314406715333462, -0.01066900696605444, -0.017088573426008224, 0.019459903240203857, -0.0344451405107975, 0.010485759936273098, 0.0181049183011055, 0.04409792274236679, -0.02822304517030716, 0.042109180241823196, -0.01579299010336399, 0.052730854600667953, -0.02358970418572426, 0.06098034232854843, 0.04637250676751137, -0.024159561842679977, -0.03430435433983803, 0.07418470829725266, 0.006469458807259798, -0.005749581381678581, -0.0008889207965694368, -0.028584418818354607, 0.0194893516600132, -0.031165173277258873, -0.0028343794401735067, 0.01133308932185173, -0.02535482496023178, -0.0006554729770869017, -0.012380932457745075, -0.020532792434096336, -0.08420821279287338, -0.017652306705713272, -0.02373306080698967, 0.05042647197842598, 0.030740326270461082, -0.011005495674908161, -0.010122417472302914, 0.07299808412790298, -0.010424059815704823, 0.08885513246059418, -0.03876544162631035, -0.013246296904981136, 0.033784057945013046, 0.026576733216643333, 0.026006167754530907, -0.005317848641425371, 0.0036865544971078634, -0.07045305520296097, -0.05361011624336243, 0.010569758713245392, 0.0028272506315261126, 0.008088167756795883, -0.058851730078458786, -0.007372457534074783, 0.06610769033432007, -0.004073628690093756, -0.07544923573732376, -0.022423187270760536, 0.05721183866262436, 0.020203977823257446, 0.019511308521032333, -0.01442635152488947, -0.022359799593687057, -0.03507476672530174, 0.013621173799037933, 0.007920820266008377, -0.10009031742811203, -0.006170128937810659, 0.04189798980951309, -0.09860821068286896, -0.02977769449353218, -0.017362534999847412, 0.062162041664123535, -0.00948230642825365, 0.039968907833099365, 0.004766533616930246, -0.0008794572204351425, 0.009289187379181385, -0.042691487818956375, -0.017428433522582054, 0.011903775855898857, 0.009921196848154068, 0.011922019533813, 0.009037747047841549, 0.04111545905470848, 0.023907484486699104, -0.01883001998066902, -0.0034738508984446526, 0.002825680887326598, 0.04577937349677086, 0.029033908620476723, 0.03738437220454216, -0.03777161240577698, 0.061544742435216904, 0.04421047866344452, 0.03432483971118927, 0.009635617025196552, -0.032110195606946945, 0.00008544643060304224, -0.07051645219326019, 0.04677095264196396, 0.02789583057165146, 0.010169259272515774, 0.015057703480124474, 0.08878608047962189, 0.07488532364368439, 0.005772930104285479, -0.06403115391731262, 0.05919695273041725, -0.001377333072014153, 0.04220210015773773, 0.013182079419493675, 0.013492395170032978, -0.032444193959236145, -0.0739433541893959, 0.030389806255698204, -0.0372500866651535, 0.0335606224834919, 0.004803916439414024, -0.030656075105071068, 0.011738860048353672, 0.0429280661046505, 0.05342356860637665, -0.03930756822228432, 0.017400627955794334, -0.021813103929162025, -0.02749347686767578, -0.021506402641534805, -0.03845413401722908, 0.005976434797048569, 0.019375041127204895, -0.005005315411835909, 0.08636413514614105, -0.06472807377576828, 0.044138312339782715, 0.04949812963604927, -0.003480548970401287, -0.06735091656446457, -0.013339372351765633, -0.05608100816607475, 0.04109155386686325, 0.0076020946726202965, -0.057920023798942566, -0.04161640256643295, -0.05457211285829544, 0.016999416053295135, 0.010784735903143883, -0.025618983432650566, 0.055186979472637177, 0.03723834455013275, 0.028691958636045456, 0.0028109783306717873, -0.019202060997486115, 0.034459780901670456, -0.01364960242062807, -0.017474330961704254, 0.046985577791929245, -0.000759309041313827, -0.038342732936143875, 0.06345182657241821, -0.011571811512112617, -0.011866663582623005, 0.010933050885796547, -0.013034245930612087, 0.03901331126689911, 0.014201558195054531, -0.04657719284296036, 0.023337284103035927, -0.0011048928136005998, -0.010026217438280582, 0.018619447946548462, -0.010370650328695774, -0.034367382526397705, 0.016395676881074905, -0.0286208838224411, -0.021443858742713928, -0.05132468417286873, -0.00017986241437029094, 0.015816597267985344, 0.04081089422106743, -0.04854586720466614, -0.045057591050863266, 0.050151895731687546, 0.0667734369635582, -0.01643321104347706, 0.039853353053331375, -0.004966143053025007, -0.019273867830634117, -0.018271438777446747, -0.029581734910607338, -0.016961252316832542, 0.03326434642076492, 0.012370957992970943, -0.004315078258514404, -0.004586982075124979, -0.029687989503145218, -0.007128667086362839, -0.015327067114412785, -0.03468048945069313, 0.018041297793388367, 0.04481726139783859, -0.016863752156496048, -0.007038183510303497, 0.03816558048129082, 0.01699289306998253, -0.06530722975730896, -0.02711227536201477, -0.03194953128695488, -0.06022113189101219, -0.022476298734545708, -0.003563366364687681, 0.033706583082675934, -0.0016139273066073656, 0.0018398365937173367, -0.03298351541161537, -0.05345887318253517, -0.019166242331266403, -0.024488363415002823, -0.006789819803088903, -0.008228329010307789, -0.09382922202348709, -0.013034234754741192, -0.04594369977712631, -0.01925566978752613, 0.007268404588103294, 0.004843758884817362, -0.04926767945289612, -0.055454984307289124, 0.019005874171853065, -0.06352711468935013, -0.03854496404528618, -0.012173782102763653, 0.060170359909534454, -0.04116588085889816, 0.02285965345799923, -0.035576045513153076, -0.027775917202234268, -0.04342164471745491, -0.017737500369548798, -0.03728068247437477, -0.027685677632689476, 0.011714018881320953, 0.01863906718790531, -0.003072540508583188, 0.031898368149995804, -0.04159173369407654, 0.03256138786673546, 0.07368160039186478, 0.029275791719555855, -0.02665260247886181, 0.05420326814055443, 0.024655023589730263, -0.02290698140859604, -0.027242464944720268, -0.03608817607164383, 0.026173986494541168, 0.06202293932437897, -0.026766566559672356, -0.007484524045139551, 0.0680675283074379, -0.047602418810129166, 0.025372261181473732, -0.04642043262720108, -0.0012400264386087656, 0.011117375455796719, -0.004525246098637581, -0.004128893371671438, 0.04032023251056671, -0.032953277230262756, 0.07897898554801941, 0.0675639808177948, 0.012709323316812515, -0.05642860010266304, -0.029665466398000717, 0.02073572762310505, 0.056094955652952194, -0.02602650411427021, -0.018008891493082047, -0.03140579164028168, 0.02579193189740181, 0.020098309963941574, -0.016786566004157066, 0.014992134645581245, -0.00831516832113266, 0.03341114521026611, -0.05005675554275513, 0.03890479728579521, -0.051622699946165085, 0.003450128948315978, 0.008196614682674408, -0.01979099027812481, -0.03217797353863716, 0.0094440383836627, 0.026669591665267944, 0.005748714320361614, -0.07471100240945816, -0.04629823938012123, 0.00888998992741108, -0.020742012187838554, 0.027541901916265488, 0.008172465488314629, 0.006527738180011511, -0.03965716063976288, -0.025559140369296074, -0.042461805045604706, 0.0320199653506279, -0.014520875178277493, -0.051518674939870834, -0.01794677972793579, -0.043955203145742416, 0.05196094140410423, -0.02205098792910576, 0.018395140767097473, 0.00729736965149641, 0.008203585632145405, 0.05718746408820152, 0.009990669786930084, -0.0836191326379776, -0.013943958096206188, 0.056389953941106796, 0.018796727061271667, 0.055956244468688965, -0.0011164549505338073, 0.012228117324411869, 0.02562672831118107, 0.051858872175216675, -0.0499199740588665, -0.009621194563806057, 0.02615363895893097, 0.00555471982806921, 0.05141345039010048, -0.032217081636190414, 0.009166432544589043, 0.0004714125534519553, -0.02148684673011303, -0.009998608380556107, -0.033865511417388916, 0.07912226021289825, 0.030910970643162727, -0.06765302270650864, 0.04716486483812332, 0.011828484944999218, 0.02290535159409046, 0.0191561970859766, -0.01355520449578762, 0.014624086208641529, 0.07272644340991974, -0.0010775205446407199, -0.08117447793483734, 0.032333847135305405, 0.057794276624917984, 0.002054633339866996, -0.012530959211289883, -0.09517643600702286, 0.014972946606576443, -0.017171813175082207, -0.08245552331209183, 0.0333169624209404, 0.01607820950448513, 0.04072371870279312, -0.0026540677063167095, -0.0007283505983650684, -0.008475367911159992, -0.03706543892621994, -0.0624297596514225, 0.03987271711230278, -0.017503734678030014, -0.009116466157138348, -0.03912845253944397, 0.02439669519662857, -0.015429763123393059, 0.013319469057023525, 0.005721325054764748, 0.03270288184285164, 0.014026065357029438, -0.05190566927194595, 0.0325382724404335, -0.040629491209983826, -0.04001103341579437, 0.08772557973861694, 0.059281133115291595, -0.05524652078747749, -0.07032378017902374, 0.024928264319896698, -0.0074941786006093025, -0.03548145294189453, 0.03612897917628288, 0.032066479325294495, 0.026922015473246574, 0.017726868391036987, -0.010237778536975384, 0.04270310699939728, 0.058226000517606735, 0.0013685758458450437, 0.012073785066604614, -0.04406673461198807, -0.027639497071504593, -0.006930021569132805, -0.005307147279381752, 0.016896864399313927, -0.026509717106819153, 0.026010964065790176, 0.0374428853392601, -0.009119633585214615, -0.02242891490459442, 0.06165563687682152, -0.006294067483395338, 0.04333716630935669, 0.01292081642895937, -0.0597362145781517, -0.009254499338567257, -0.03261483460664749, 0.04945864900946617, 0.031226450577378273, 0.03106536902487278, 0.05253266543149948, -0.012675287202000618, 0.04095519706606865, 0.009824300184845924, 0.05877752974629402, 0.04162043333053589, -0.048344120383262634, -0.022451912984251976, 0.0073793488554656506, -0.011241434141993523, -0.00576042803004384, 0.049984246492385864, -0.053545739501714706, -0.044509388506412506, -0.007752370089292526, -0.03416156396269798, -0.024300457909703255, 0.047339100390672684, -0.012671461328864098, 0.044119227677583694, -0.017980260774493217, -0.04147202521562576, 0.0410107783973217, -0.043469350785017014, -0.03845357522368431, 0.01789846085011959, 0.02527794800698757, -0.029350584372878075, -0.039703406393527985, -0.006980919279158115, -0.03792250528931618, -0.022702684625983238, -0.02210022509098053, -0.0051434640772640705, 0.016458582133054733, -0.02970750816166401, 0.027143817394971848, 0.02753174863755703, -0.046244364231824875, -0.03038756549358368, -0.014550573192536831, -0.03292461857199669, -0.013404824770987034, -0.0034940638579428196, -0.004519423004239798, -0.0170141588896513, 0.012247034348547459, -0.0027907288167625666, 0.06119460240006447, -0.03433409705758095, 0.032301656901836395, -0.006098814308643341, 0.025600798428058624, -0.010327954776585102, 0.003263683756813407, -0.08482995629310608, -0.004607858136296272, 0.05471191182732582, 0.06909237056970596, -0.007710665930062532, -0.0719304010272026, -0.021390236914157867, -0.010072335600852966, 0.013568111695349216, 0.02487374283373356, 0.05258011445403099, 0.06568292528390884, -0.013676900416612625, -0.013007951900362968, -0.011798670515418053, 0.0004681324353441596, -0.03173515945672989, 0.00737124914303422, -0.003503363346680999, -0.006945187691599131, 0.0025364297907799482, -0.0063346815295517445, -0.0022768506314605474, 0.05846588313579559, -0.017772704362869263, -0.023817796260118484, -0.008976778015494347, 0.0006587271927855909, 0.012422471307218075, 0.0734621062874794, -0.006015806458890438, -0.05484628304839134, 0.003414592007175088, 0.09109046310186386, -0.04693575203418732, 0.01738273911178112, -0.04884752258658409, 0.004045421257615089, -0.01756402663886547, -0.027124205604195595, -0.08103089034557343, -0.03267102316021919, -0.03741886094212532, -0.018972009420394897, -0.0007964192191138864, 0.016361435875296593, 0.038792066276073456, 0.016002995893359184, 0.037169892340898514, -0.012529905885457993, -0.04678206518292427, -0.0012826955644413829, -0.0004251462232787162, -0.027749933302402496, 0.023499060422182083, -0.04674040153622627, -0.004325812216848135, -0.001383208204060793, -0.015447762794792652, 0.03484532982110977, 0.030374785885214806, 0.006560012698173523, 0.000888840586412698, 0.0018437999533489347, -0.024667561054229736, -0.03681131824851036, 0.013519933447241783, 0.04809902608394623, 0.06204871088266373, 0.011857532896101475, -0.10008908063173294, -0.008846736513078213, -0.08400101959705353, -0.0012923975009471178, 0.0689547061920166, 0.041700657457113266, 0.0023877352941781282, -0.015053492039442062, 0.0472169890999794, 0.007433048449456692, 0.008155817165970802, 0.007950172759592533, -0.012572710402309895, 0.0014478564262390137, 0.02262675017118454, 0.009171916171908379, 0.013879387639462948, 0.014076527208089828, -0.03986026346683502, -0.038977742195129395, 0.09364357590675354, 0.013422977179288864, -0.014174559153616428, 0.02686016447842121, -0.08378743380308151, -0.022206144407391548, -0.015697970986366272, -0.003781044390052557, -0.04352879524230957, -0.04544016718864441, 0.02135845273733139, -0.017934301868081093, -0.021085958927869797, -0.021643351763486862, -0.014396559447050095, -0.011770072393119335, 0.006851937156170607, 0.04393237456679344, -0.058401983231306076, -0.0006414214731194079, 0.039776816964149475, 0.011560702696442604, -0.007429872639477253, 0.022419022396206856, -0.0021856569219380617, 0.0027998716104775667, -0.0007754914695397019, -0.00719714630395174, -0.05529336258769035, -0.06912609934806824, -0.06761519610881805, -0.0029798655305057764, 0.0009675616165623069, -0.029234232380986214, 0.044721316546201706, 0.04545193165540695, -0.03643586114048958, 0.03434101119637489, -0.010238292627036572, 0.05329698324203491, 0.008106956258416176, -0.017957592383027077, -0.011161679401993752, -0.0002269040560349822, -0.008421598002314568, -0.025923142209649086, 0.011343006044626236, -0.012409755028784275, -0.010176119394600391, -0.015652531757950783, 0.043274085968732834, -0.0708799734711647, -0.00761864148080349, 0.0196218304336071, -0.009321562014520168, 0.06807208806276321, 0.033385034650564194, 0.006329089403152466, -0.01767766661942005, -0.03495870530605316, 0.0440598726272583, 0.030845239758491516, -0.010484050959348679, -0.021075373515486717, -0.020079480484128, -0.004485571291297674, -0.0016491193091496825, -0.03865952789783478, 0.040924351662397385, 0.0017068745801225305, 0.02269095741212368, 0.03825712949037552, 0.021627962589263916, 0.0198906809091568, -0.04864286631345749, -0.03880464285612106, 0.021534975618124008, 0.0008267450612038374, 0.025480689480900764, 0.06052623316645622, 0.025211241096258163, 0.00491498876363039, 0.004662702791392803, -0.028846681118011475, -0.0065328036434948444, -0.012778349220752716, -0.022365814074873924, -0.012981885112822056, -0.00821116752922535, -0.001989132259041071, 0.01200473215430975, 0.06649546325206757, 0.011499608866870403, 0.06601616740226746, -0.04013749212026596, 0.0004175690410193056, 0.00448397733271122, 0.010765151120722294, -0.04667683690786362, -0.0013748191995546222, 0.11194650828838348, -0.0008708066889084876, 0.018425961956381798, -0.031235475093126297, -0.02045818231999874, -0.036204494535923004, 0.03368557244539261, 0.03292839601635933, -0.021299608051776886, -0.07358092814683914, -0.006114112678915262, -0.04785160347819328, 0.009885905310511589, -0.055896710604429245, 0.03645239770412445, -0.028370575979351997, 0.006143216509371996, 0.09178845584392548, 0.023731717839837074, 0.00911017507314682, -0.025047598406672478, -0.03209509700536728, 0.0334872268140316, -0.05541766434907913, -0.0339386872947216, 0.008802343159914017, 0.0017099081305786967, 0.052651260048151016, -0.012324588373303413, -0.051295917481184006, -0.020576942712068558, -0.019532134756445885, -0.01826212741434574, -0.03203690052032471, -0.002998997690156102, -0.010843238793313503, -0.012425662018358707, -0.0723964124917984, -0.02517431229352951, 0.02044987864792347, 0.0004637495439965278, 0.026358619332313538, -0.003085711505264044, 0.04556720331311226, 0.029330328106880188, -0.01667986437678337, 0.01172440592199564, -0.006818253081291914, 0.035880252718925476, 0.0348728708922863, 0.0033136652782559395, 0.05786561965942383, -0.06828511506319046, -0.0026365118101239204, -0.006946871057152748, 0.0571734756231308, 0.0114414868876338, -0.0014134240336716175, 0.035760629922151566, 0.022935781627893448, -0.04611041024327278, -0.009575518779456615, 0.04747477173805237, 0.012666025198996067, -0.057864684611558914, 0.019395217299461365, 0.031024377793073654, 0.03335472568869591, 0.08801593631505966, -0.03538478910923004, -0.02745610475540161, 0.01708081364631653, 0.08168037980794907, 0.023979980498552322, 0.003765174187719822, -0.04517394304275513, -0.0023040808737277985, -0.017109712585806847, -0.008647853508591652, -0.019848136231303215, -0.04522063583135605, -0.004882499109953642, 0.007596730720251799 ]
<blockquote> <p>Is there any reason the universe has matter not being able to exceed the speed of light, or why there is a speed limit in the first place?</p> </blockquote> <p>I know why it can't, meaning the basic physics of it. I am just wondering if the reason why the universe is like this is or the benefit of it known.</p> <p>I know this might be too philosophical, but I am just wondering.</p>
g122
[ 0.026224324479699135, 0.08826940506696701, 0.05911853909492493, 0.01178714632987976, 0.04120565950870514, -0.002258115913718939, 0.007993455976247787, -0.020463956519961357, -0.022107422351837158, -0.02820439264178276, 0.07414215803146362, -0.020620856434106827, 0.0014887993456795812, 0.06740058213472366, -0.011569444090127945, 0.024834124371409416, 0.02668360061943531, -0.04448407143354416, 0.05530925840139389, -0.0019570747390389442, -0.024765653535723686, -0.014739046804606915, 0.0023128599859774113, -0.054898519068956375, -0.034728530794382095, 0.007588599808514118, 0.02726159617304802, -0.09755969792604446, -0.04287511855363846, 0.0050470540300011635, 0.02661067433655262, -0.06118736416101456, -0.014607978984713554, -0.04969749599695206, 0.03990301862359047, 0.004912559408694506, 0.023282714188098907, -0.030522247776389122, 0.027255455031991005, -0.012882227078080177, 0.038397662341594696, 0.00008561467257095501, -0.02847019024193287, -0.008909623138606548, 0.012780621647834778, 0.022091588005423546, -0.024839146062731743, 0.04791302606463432, 0.003962518181651831, -0.03727087751030922, -0.034337472170591354, -0.01681503839790821, 0.026492588222026825, 0.012728464789688587, 0.030656566843390465, -0.04078696668148041, 0.011938049457967281, 0.0034022764302790165, 0.0385742112994194, 0.013706473633646965, -0.040837422013282776, -0.017896924167871475, 0.05985868722200394, -0.014703190885484219, 0.04142726585268974, -0.01523373182862997, -0.016983363777399063, -0.04287288337945938, 0.04622539132833481, 0.06057320907711983, 0.03296324610710144, -0.022953622043132782, -0.050504621118307114, -0.07845877856016159, -0.010838801972568035, 0.026239929720759392, 0.0481717474758625, 0.06168091297149658, 0.036970581859350204, 0.0377657487988472, 0.014987378381192684, -0.03015906549990177, -0.03810437023639679, -0.0040212953463196754, -0.013096529059112072, -0.0028595873154699802, -0.014554896391928196, -0.01397984940558672, -0.01630423218011856, 0.025358224287629128, 0.004627412650734186, -0.0005153169040568173, 0.04264898598194122, -0.012919743545353413, 0.03308814391493797, -0.006513324566185474, -0.020586511120200157, 0.03839346766471863, 0.012824954465031624, 0.06657836586236954, -0.010291142389178276, 0.003393762279301882, 0.08307584375143051, -0.00011631743109319359, 0.02338993176817894, -0.05094480887055397, -0.016316739842295647, -0.0055091287940740585, -0.013644755817949772, -0.05544186756014824, 0.00811675377190113, -0.08724428713321686, -0.029002992436289787, -0.0004663116706069559, -0.06868886947631836, -0.02404654026031494, 0.0821344330906868, 0.011852467432618141, -0.026746345683932304, 0.0530116893351078, -0.033779338002204895, 0.03320963308215141, -0.018626714125275612, -0.04014260321855545, -0.060119565576314926, 0.008588790893554688, 0.04285057261586189, -0.004988771863281727, -0.002605919959023595, -0.04517833888530731, 0.005219445563852787, 0.026222147047519684, -0.008339637890458107, 0.037874478846788406, -0.019647980108857155, -0.019268963485956192, 0.04874147102236748, -0.007875803858041763, 0.02054511569440365, -0.031003281474113464, -0.0009007178596220911, 0.0022448059171438217, 0.02399257943034172, 0.0043441373854875565, -0.034471191465854645, -0.008299559354782104, 0.002295759739354253, 0.043811701238155365, -0.0329270139336586, -0.0024440244305878878, 0.020310789346694946, 0.0412132702767849, -0.010746876709163189, -0.04721337556838989, -0.012607178650796413, 0.0160591471940279, 0.11506875604391098, -0.009784928523004055, -0.02065001055598259, 0.044886838644742966, 0.046599820256233215, 0.055493686348199844, -0.06684014946222305, -0.007671887055039406, -0.09619487076997757, 0.023853540420532227, -0.00898759812116623, 0.0013750490033999085, -0.02824430540204048, -0.029363209381699562, -0.060256537050008774, -0.026712127029895782, 0.009466034360229969, 0.09417716413736343, 0.029723385348916054, -0.015772894024848938, 0.0366794653236866, -0.002775212749838829, -0.06147554889321327, 0.04069703444838524, -0.045172110199928284, -0.07184357941150665, 0.00728585384786129, 0.015387702733278275, -0.003727156901732087, 0.02250504121184349, -0.007565581705421209, 0.021236738190054893, -0.04750803858041763, 0.011140594258904457, 0.0016715172678232193, -0.050616052001714706, -0.012746325694024563, 0.035065118223428726, 0.004166568163782358, -0.017895815894007683, 0.024394527077674866, 0.0066195279359817505, -0.025504324585199356, -0.009077738039195538, -0.023483870550990105, 0.03149477392435074, -0.012253470718860626, -0.03384848311543465, 0.034025199711322784, -0.012885406613349915, -0.05908995866775513, 0.059200409799814224, 0.03149006888270378, -0.005284673534333706, 0.06783756613731384, -0.012514812871813774, -0.0004984868573956192, 0.03932037204504013, 0.006767409387975931, -0.0414930135011673, -0.02737305499613285, 0.03732147440314293, 0.016974324360489845, 0.031180959194898605, -0.044352591037750244, -0.014498956501483917, -0.020484384149312973, -0.053223006427288055, -0.05473111569881439, -0.01805267296731472, -0.048304229974746704, -0.02895243465900421, 0.010009219869971275, 0.09065309911966324, -0.04757384583353996, -0.025095297023653984, 0.004734512884169817, -0.016850493848323822, 0.008428110741078854, -0.006704897154122591, 0.016301052644848824, -0.011431960389018059, -0.031753674149513245, 0.027473652735352516, 0.01395441684871912, -0.032570552080869675, -0.02447408437728882, 0.029672103002667427, 0.014585595577955246, -0.1255607157945633, 0.014882480725646019, -0.11348558962345123, -0.008516072295606136, 0.022558247670531273, 0.05534086748957634, -0.002477389993146062, -0.01896105334162712, -0.012374553829431534, 0.01384039781987667, -0.03135531023144722, 0.01686517894268036, 0.08735273778438568, -0.07726705074310303, -0.06585653871297836, 0.02887168526649475, 0.040066804736852646, 0.03211251273751259, 0.0027799790259450674, -0.036070819944143295, 0.013212674297392368, -0.07023891806602478, 0.03943531587719917, -0.0034888137597590685, 0.04541482403874397, -0.02375958301126957, -0.01777990162372589, 0.005199936684221029, -0.01945735514163971, -0.016410592943429947, 0.030846109613776207, -0.007234164979308844, -0.05218464881181717, 0.06052982434630394, 0.008837037719786167, -0.01992500014603138, 0.01099094282835722, -0.041381414979696274, -0.027248715981841087, 0.015406916849315166, -0.04725305363535881, -0.04651132971048355, 0.001735441735945642, 0.010255414061248302, -0.014992306008934975, -0.04573524743318558, 0.08132808655500412, 0.006987337954342365, 0.013547992333769798, 0.03858313709497452, 0.08551684767007828, -0.018911151215434074, -0.005222842562943697, -0.06993473321199417, 0.0019344422034919262, -0.015489249490201473, -0.010529368184506893, 0.025645097717642784, 0.0245556328445673, -0.021003561094403267, 0.02780173532664776, 0.013323869556188583, 0.03971520811319351, 0.018608758226037025, 0.003883955767378211, 0.0742390975356102, 0.05878329649567604, 0.015503354370594025, 0.04195520281791687, -0.02885913848876953, 0.03226805478334427, 0.004187350627034903, 0.008439652621746063, 0.03133408725261688, -0.020695578306913376, 0.035325635224580765, 0.056432485580444336, -0.04241069033741951, 0.023083046078681946, 0.0009118361631408334, 0.01916494034230709, -0.012804282829165459, -0.027882158756256104, 0.010054590180516243, -0.007735928054898977, -0.0027365735732018948, -0.025106381624937057, 0.012247602455317974, 0.045859817415475845, -0.08601253479719162, -0.017522623762488365, 0.01838436722755432, 0.027806537225842476, 0.06185728684067726, -0.017237532883882523, -0.013150378130376339, 0.018409503623843193, -0.05370768904685974, 0.042872924357652664, -0.022576576098799706, 0.04796289652585983, -0.023211997002363205, -0.006192265078425407, -0.012888842262327671, 0.024225492030382156, 0.043522048741579056, 0.037174683064222336, -0.01326410099864006, -0.038130227476358414, 0.012719409540295601, 0.052595365792512894, 0.009504605084657669, 0.059586916118860245, 0.019274022430181503, -0.06359516084194183, 0.01828867197036743, 0.02497665397822857, 0.05320549011230469, -0.0023601180873811245, 0.00839595403522253, 0.06660449504852295, 0.018626105040311813, 0.033349063247442245, -0.04563864320516586, 0.0255893487483263, 0.04266025498509407, -0.022730140015482903, -0.03952277824282646, 0.05526776239275932, 0.03210831433534622, -0.017275841906666756, 0.03783423826098442, -0.019170017912983894, -0.005902352277189493, 0.0022405569907277822, 0.039035387337207794, 0.02961120754480362, 0.03034377284348011, -0.005791536532342434, -0.018626155331730843, -0.022753514349460602, -0.05366872251033783, -0.04497901350259781, -0.0026935443747788668, -0.09543637931346893, 0.029502201825380325, -0.061352916061878204, -0.04271296411752701, -0.002530657686293125, -0.04059526324272156, 0.02074948325753212, 0.01541147567331791, -0.00969782005995512, 0.030119141563773155, -0.0027392946649342775, 0.0036782941315323114, -0.015290405601263046, -0.06042690575122833, -0.016188569366931915, 0.0020831450819969177, -0.01706630177795887, 0.04347244277596474, -0.013622114434838295, 0.026722488924860954, -0.017100661993026733, -0.018021607771515846, 0.004719440825283527, -0.047490186989307404, 0.004969106521457434, 0.021305996924638748, -0.010246101766824722, 0.03383840620517731, -0.04504358023405075, 0.043132200837135315, -0.010153325274586678, 0.00551215372979641, -0.02952020801603794, -0.023625385016202927, 0.001815676805563271, 0.04141907021403313, 0.04854680225253105, -0.005358041264116764, -0.03842503949999809, 0.018662670627236366, 0.06635966151952744, -0.02536052092909813, 0.0007313582464121282, -0.02087734080851078, 0.05380875989794731, -0.011604025959968567, 0.02581596001982689, -0.005869312211871147, 0.04941478371620178, -0.03057275153696537, 0.05412314832210541, 0.06697090715169907, -0.04648973420262337, 0.027481015771627426, 0.04728974401950836, 0.008078227750957012, 0.031589630991220474, -0.03422347083687782, -0.0048232972621917725, -0.04520575702190399, -0.013453327119350433, -0.024253234267234802, -0.03307231515645981, -0.02367894910275936, -0.032629359513521194, -0.049232613295316696, -0.038598135113716125, -0.03987439349293709, 0.043719977140426636, 0.048200372606515884, 0.06338666379451752, -0.02533092349767685, 0.010017373599112034, 0.06627484411001205, 0.015994327142834663, 0.01495995931327343, 0.02594558335840702, -0.01567111536860466, -0.03930026665329933, -0.046863000839948654, 0.020188266411423683, -0.031086957082152367, -0.020873546600341797, -0.0046097515150904655, 0.06960289180278778, -0.019796347245573997, -0.002856616862118244, -0.03979151323437691, -0.011263159103691578, -0.0680486410856247, 0.0010077793849632144, -0.016302915289998055, 0.01273361686617136, 0.0016767728375270963, -0.01101417001336813, -0.004811544436961412, 0.022610872983932495, -0.07085688412189484, 0.04540698975324631, -0.05915212631225586, -0.028017934411764145, -0.014027340337634087, 0.047027893364429474, -0.006930790841579437, -0.02308768406510353, -0.0425979308784008, 0.029745247215032578, 0.06980033218860626, 0.01660561002790928, -0.030399568378925323, -0.02142339013516903, -0.01077216025441885, 0.0008881677058525383, 0.021600840613245964, -0.009581057354807854, -0.009223263710737228, 0.024449117481708527, -0.02169177494943142, 0.036667026579380035, -0.03156272694468498, 0.019309693947434425, 0.024070093408226967, -0.023783935233950615, 0.03737664222717285, 0.04149748012423515, 0.0815756693482399, -0.05251102149486542, 0.03098931722342968, -0.05499406158924103, 0.035338349640369415, -0.04461246728897095, -0.04230104014277458, -0.00699977669864893, 0.06113685294985771, -0.013268198817968369, 0.01964705064892769, -0.005317750386893749, -0.04360971227288246, -0.029493700712919235, 0.008002865128219128, 0.030304383486509323, 0.05705178156495094, 0.01639672927558422, 0.05480100214481354, -0.07596385478973389, -0.04592198133468628, 0.014381258748471737, -0.020566215738654137, -0.004266852047294378, -0.04056381434202194, -0.001808921224437654, 0.00533263199031353, -0.031581755727529526, -0.025048300623893738, 0.03583505004644394, 0.08592844754457474, 0.016159992665052414, -0.03143053129315376, 0.003959993831813335, 0.024380937218666077, -0.03935369849205017, -0.018225202336907387, -0.014153039082884789, -0.014358403161168098, 0.021504264324903488, -0.007805070374161005, 0.07642138004302979, 0.0032082393299788237, 0.011819963343441486, -0.023724311962723732, -0.0676773190498352, -0.017733870074152946, 0.021960536018013954, -0.0024974101688712835, -0.004267541691660881, 0.029596269130706787, -0.05319381132721901, 0.015764843672513962, -0.03584253415465355, 0.005009871907532215, 0.0041261278092861176, -0.020619196817278862, 0.07192143052816391, 0.014608463272452354, 0.024282610043883324, 0.004436524119228125, -0.016513768583536148, 0.018888210877776146, -0.0028927663806825876, -0.042242322117090225, -0.05448538064956665, -0.03426826000213623, -0.007676394190639257, 0.022484714165329933, -0.06519360095262527, 0.055989403277635574, -0.013750207610428333, 0.0022360337898135185, 0.04701700061559677, 0.018651360645890236, -0.04634862020611763, -0.007344132289290428, 0.01901177130639553, 0.0023161538410931826, -0.05051398277282715, 0.005176431033760309, -0.038211993873119354, -0.014514015056192875, -0.035957805812358856, -0.04838895797729492, -0.00960279256105423, 0.008303326554596424, -0.029378419741988182, 0.04129591956734657, 0.008003064431250095, 0.05238725617527962, 0.03639482334256172, -0.058675993233919144, -0.011727562174201012, 0.045233145356178284, 0.036559682339429855, 0.04173995181918144, -0.006305593065917492, -0.0037448557559400797, 0.041497647762298584, -0.08249233663082123, -0.01824481226503849, 0.021701166406273842, -0.06158409267663956, -0.047732386738061905, 0.021002301946282387, 0.06922699511051178, 0.010118643753230572, 0.017986759543418884, -0.04148222133517265, -0.03781390190124512, 0.025942053645849228, -0.020075028762221336, 0.06835360825061798, 0.055748846381902695, 0.02941126562654972, 0.04256571829319, -0.0006847763434052467, -0.02701493538916111, 0.02871307171881199, -0.03719469904899597, 0.013908901251852512, -0.018629832193255424, -0.006124799605458975, 0.04885006695985794, 0.004445985425263643, 0.02431829646229744, -0.02371135540306568, 0.002024004003033042, 0.00381982559338212, -0.007921606302261353, -0.00692398427054286, 0.045745600014925, 0.010309119708836079, 0.0024300734512507915, -0.06616026908159256, -0.02300535887479782, 0.016554348170757294, -0.009957175701856613, -0.008307226933538914, -0.0045007760636508465, -0.025026632472872734, -0.021131141111254692, 0.021657651290297508, -0.008975532837212086, -0.08224307000637054, -0.03061849996447563, 0.0366496741771698, -0.005998286418616772, -0.00865101721137762, 0.006222063209861517, 0.048770904541015625, -0.0037976359017193317, -0.037368886172771454, 0.008743529208004475, -0.05614464357495308, -0.005029262509196997, -0.026264706626534462, -0.04589713737368584, 0.008261495269834995, 0.050525519996881485, -0.01322198286652565, -0.015439087525010109, 0.04571155458688736, 0.059608519077301025, -0.04750951752066612, 0.008215054869651794, 0.03474850580096245, -0.0352260060608387, 0.027256246656179428, -0.022183965891599655, 0.04805559292435646, 0.015111821703612804, -0.0026326084043830633, 0.02974163182079792, -0.02653220295906067, 0.008520428091287613, -0.0030978007707744837, 0.0007520598592236638, -0.044899336993694305, -0.00017498050874564797, 0.016384627670049667, -0.037699561566114426, 0.026881566271185875, -0.02218680828809738, -0.01959419809281826, -0.09184105694293976, -0.042038820683956146, -0.05393702909350395, -0.006773867178708315, -0.009528483264148235, 0.0013365112245082855, 0.02317277528345585, 0.03610960766673088, -0.03772816061973572, -0.013094630092382431, -0.007574272342026234, 0.03300772234797478, -0.0785764828324318, -0.02869781106710434, 0.01678728684782982, 0.009767632000148296, 0.02040637657046318, -0.00884570088237524, 0.019694523885846138, -0.00753557775169611, 0.016630517318844795, -0.007512466516345739, -0.027565021067857742, -0.06724535673856735, -0.03587542474269867, 0.01474835630506277, 0.027570560574531555, -0.044803787022829056, -0.10292496532201767, -0.0005075635272078216, 0.0600336529314518, 0.02337072603404522, 0.009402461349964142, -0.04296931251883507, -0.1028367355465889, 0.05005454272031784, 0.018611008301377296, 0.029408492147922516, -0.024704869836568832, 0.04882356524467468, -0.030623944476246834, 0.020451534539461136, -0.05052667483687401, 0.01948142610490322, 0.030935775488615036, -0.029376160353422165, -0.03392971307039261, 0.00507549149915576, 0.0627792552113533, 0.044150471687316895, 0.028744574636220932, 0.07620560377836227, 0.00916897039860487, 0.035877060145139694, 0.05505248159170151, -0.00950586050748825, 0.008423786610364914, -0.024787915870547295, -0.010574803687632084, 0.008261340670287609, 0.04121222719550133, -0.008504603058099747, 0.08351172506809235, 0.009274269454181194, 0.03825240954756737, -0.023398596793413162, -0.004657047800719738, -0.05513733997941017 ]
<p>Given an electromagnetic wave in resonance mode in a vacuum cavity inside a perfect conductor, on the boundary, the parallel component of $E$ field vanishes, and the perpendicular of component of $B$ field vanishes. How does one derive, through solving Maxwell equation boundary value problem, say by the way of stress-energy tensor or other by products of the Maxwell equation, $\frac{\partial \int_{\text{cavity}}\mathbf S dV}{\partial t} = 0$ or $\frac{\partial \int_{\text{cavity}} \mathbf&lt;S&gt;dV}{\partial t} = 0$ where $\mathbf S=E\times B$ is the Poynting vector, the integral is over the space of the cavity, $&lt;\cdot&gt;$ denotes time average? In other words, how does one show the total momentum of the field inside the cavity vanishes from Maxwell equation computation?</p>
g4029
[ 0.03515935689210892, -0.0025425285566598177, -0.020269092172384262, -0.006176290567964315, 0.0712486132979393, 0.025925448164343834, 0.08372678607702255, 0.030464934185147285, -0.04478007182478905, 0.04221807047724724, -0.0332208015024662, 0.010418581776320934, -0.031025297939777374, 0.0005382500239647925, 0.0006753882626071572, -0.03381788358092308, 0.06423500180244446, -0.028785444796085358, 0.009896552190184593, -0.04228721931576729, -0.04123760014772415, 0.03498780354857445, 0.021426409482955933, -0.027533436194062233, 0.041922684758901596, 0.02731204219162464, 0.0017544231377542019, 0.011555518954992294, -0.0011060036486014724, -0.050210900604724884, -0.011323375627398491, 0.03802056983113289, 0.0488647036254406, 0.006669566500931978, -0.0373687669634819, -0.029510920867323875, 0.025362182408571243, 0.11534586548805237, 0.0004947345587424934, 0.02026318572461605, 0.05924704670906067, -0.07811428606510162, -0.006085818167775869, 0.001673976075835526, 0.0019542891532182693, -0.026795318350195885, -0.057478707283735275, 0.02917112223803997, -0.01843765750527382, 0.01275488268584013, 0.021962108090519905, -0.024411188438534737, 0.062422480434179306, -0.08418729156255722, -0.04932858422398567, 0.043628908693790436, 0.018713071942329407, -0.09336280822753906, 0.048563722521066666, 0.020727984607219696, 0.0006409828783944249, -0.04728678613901138, -0.019022909924387932, 0.059349507093429565, 0.03306504711508751, 0.02142970822751522, -0.04632873460650444, -0.01712295040488243, -0.03195749223232269, -0.03509869799017906, 0.02005876414477825, 0.022712714970111847, 0.011185096576809883, -0.005798622965812683, -0.021889684721827507, 0.008046775124967098, 0.011922447010874748, -0.01657984033226967, 0.02517472207546234, -0.0176162701100111, -0.0009436169639229774, -0.015890708193182945, 0.0276557058095932, -0.01884477771818638, 0.007851846516132355, -0.019677605479955673, 0.0022776371333748102, 0.02495826967060566, -0.01904962584376335, 0.04308465123176575, 0.009100658819079399, 0.019243409857153893, 0.04957492649555206, 0.015598712489008904, 0.052679210901260376, -0.006520604249089956, 0.0025114710442721844, 0.04130623862147331, -0.01754273660480976, -0.04360762983560562, 0.047127220779657364, -0.009680017828941345, -0.07545370608568192, -0.05590813606977463, -0.004203340969979763, 0.00807267613708973, -0.0342407152056694, 0.0024587451480329037, -0.015238361433148384, 0.03345973789691925, -0.034097135066986084, -0.02852296456694603, -0.09131862223148346, -0.04722070321440697, -0.01910071261227131, -0.07033928483724594, 0.02047613076865673, -0.03934827819466591, 0.013642783276736736, 0.05876933038234711, -0.015138883143663406, 0.008915775455534458, -0.004532926715910435, 0.0222101341933012, 0.007540499791502953, 0.05462465062737465, -0.06051100417971611, 0.014924880117177963, 0.0337812602519989, 0.03796180337667465, -0.034601423889398575, 0.012538245879113674, 0.024821486324071884, 0.014932693913578987, 0.005190891679376364, -0.004943788051605225, -0.003167356364428997, 0.03463875874876976, -0.006247181911021471, -0.035552576184272766, -0.03584873303771019, 0.006428302265703678, -0.05621422082185745, -0.02656250074505806, -0.02511296607553959, -0.021257741376757622, -0.0026024181861430407, -0.05025501176714897, -0.013948056846857071, 0.020165832713246346, 0.07370884716510773, 0.08674728125333786, 0.026804141700267792, 0.02086135558784008, -0.004157840274274349, 0.0036424268037080765, 0.031420495361089706, -0.05519993603229523, 0.032385244965553284, 0.018542278558015823, 0.07313196361064911, 0.01580820418894291, -0.0031936580780893564, 0.01453922688961029, -0.01525580883026123, -0.024205787107348442, 0.0009853006340563297, -0.06526301801204681, -0.03027281165122986, -0.052301209419965744, -0.02612289786338806, -0.025557445362210274, 0.02345682680606842, 0.013512512668967247, -0.01767374761402607, 0.08236105740070343, 0.0009406763128936291, 0.02158811129629612, 0.024410776793956757, 0.04650474712252617, 0.03712758421897888, 0.00570094957947731, 0.10366953909397125, -0.031193360686302185, 0.039900511503219604, 0.005303717218339443, -0.038081586360931396, 0.0541500598192215, -0.06873569637537003, -0.001055810833349824, 0.001812811940908432, 0.051985565572977066, -0.0001299919094890356, 0.05170222371816635, -0.018435189500451088, 0.007725908420979977, 0.00036489905323833227, -0.038817811757326126, 0.026078326627612114, 0.004937332589179277, -0.04937215521931648, 0.04304928705096245, 0.08863336592912674, 0.01399912964552641, 0.022644419223070145, -0.039056308567523956, 0.00760717922821641, -0.012237939052283764, 0.020950941368937492, -0.012850453145802021, 0.013434008695185184, -0.02075827680528164, -0.020115423947572708, 0.07765137404203415, -0.027968555688858032, -0.016789842396974564, -0.004578444175422192, 0.018241893500089645, -0.03094002977013588, -0.027842048555612564, -0.09586489945650101, -0.03991897404193878, -0.05106375738978386, -0.030335716903209686, -0.030364932492375374, 0.004452888388186693, 0.002219893503934145, 0.0479271374642849, -0.05282735824584961, 0.04102155938744545, -0.09502892941236496, 0.0038029784336686134, -0.029164161533117294, -0.038710933178663254, 0.04752324894070625, 0.022359691560268402, -0.016800399869680405, 0.008601272478699684, -0.009129070676863194, 0.026383981108665466, 0.002235951367765665, 0.010818997398018837, -0.06053618714213371, 0.01382752787321806, -0.013334936462342739, -0.012817028909921646, 0.06147250160574913, -0.03526761382818222, 0.023923292756080627, -0.00481911888346076, -0.005371884908527136, -0.032291751354932785, 0.004661950748413801, -0.03157074749469757, -0.046338073909282684, 0.007524924818426371, 0.011370912194252014, 0.015873603522777557, 0.011142046190798283, 0.014719969592988491, -0.012610742822289467, -0.005317316856235266, 0.033675696700811386, 0.051520418375730515, -0.07337731122970581, -0.012213082052767277, -0.024833114817738533, -0.022669095546007156, 0.04698895663022995, 0.005167824681848288, -0.05902687460184097, 0.08136117458343506, -0.0017083791317418218, -0.018514784052968025, 0.04137103632092476, -0.05461268872022629, 0.03405355289578438, -0.01975598745048046, 0.02625867910683155, 0.009885786101222038, -0.05485416576266289, 0.03062412329018116, -0.04223748296499252, 0.022174151614308357, -0.030534839257597923, -0.06518857181072235, 0.028535539284348488, -0.009245560504496098, 0.008636689744889736, 0.04794367775321007, -0.05560415983200073, -0.019046733155846596, -0.0056587401777505875, 0.011025318875908852, 0.011352024041116238, 0.07269173115491867, 0.06192745640873909, -0.05951088294386864, 0.014815634116530418, -0.03141451254487038, -0.004288464784622192, -0.01897340640425682, -0.029270635917782784, -0.05522223934531212, 0.04489125683903694, 0.0028765921015292406, -0.01503005437552929, 0.0005379064241424203, 0.015034256502985954, 0.023368248715996742, -0.0147313317283988, 0.009265640750527382, 0.05431871861219406, -0.040410369634628296, -0.021940672770142555, 0.04757433384656906, -0.01365652959793806, -0.08087325096130371, -0.02612796612083912, 0.0054074060171842575, -0.010456143878400326, -0.012464798055589199, 0.055877722799777985, -0.05671831592917442, 0.032330889254808426, -0.031229788437485695, -0.038139116019010544, 0.01793973706662655, -0.04084481671452522, -0.0048431637696921825, -0.04526699706912041, 0.001707218587398529, 0.003126400290057063, -0.009139398112893105, 0.03565366193652153, -0.03539738059043884, -0.03897921368479729, 0.07108298689126968, -0.0034891432151198387, -0.033717505633831024, 0.01242738962173462, -0.06923946738243103, 0.005100460723042488, 0.032711807638406754, -0.01597382314503193, -0.01236754097044468, 0.00008950248593464494, 0.00315293506719172, 0.08805503696203232, -0.024075409397482872, -0.010244468227028847, 0.01689455471932888, 0.008515212684869766, 0.02117816172540188, -0.06167536601424217, 0.05974532663822174, 0.08060601353645325, 0.0213530994951725, -0.013960607349872589, 0.004928523674607277, -0.00047390011604875326, -0.05011715739965439, 0.020135315135121346, -0.034832730889320374, -0.01719319075345993, -0.03521697595715523, 0.02812923677265644, 0.07521873712539673, -0.043438028544187546, -0.09162203222513199, -0.01894320733845234, -0.002869183896109462, 0.0051217274740338326, -0.02831922098994255, -0.011267212219536304, -0.07774863392114639, -0.047795042395591736, -0.012141173705458641, 0.022399840876460075, 0.024831989780068398, -0.008973009884357452, 0.01616279035806656, 0.0013202641857787967, -0.041299790143966675, 0.02622789330780506, 0.006560212932527065, -0.02232981286942959, 0.017734121531248093, 0.0461585633456707, 0.01833612285554409, 0.006537240464240313, 0.023029128089547157, -0.0036366977728903294, 0.03134524077177048, -0.027710197493433952, -0.02155553363263607, -0.010217868722975254, 0.018902845680713654, -0.041256558150053024, 0.0036792720202356577, 0.019340306520462036, 0.0338621623814106, 0.0245163906365633, 0.044030219316482544, 0.012553653679788113, 0.05589967593550682, -0.0009163144277408719, -0.012457256205379963, -0.016091695055365562, -0.0029654253739863634, -0.06550707668066025, -0.057891033589839935, 0.015067054890096188, -0.00462518772110343, 0.056370772421360016, 0.002429648069664836, 0.05453917384147644, 0.014119843021035194, 0.045401863753795624, -0.00611804099753499, 0.047874391078948975, -0.0005568786873482168, -0.023518484085798264, 0.0006254406762309372, 0.014510177075862885, 0.001319198403507471, 0.03341510519385338, -0.021419648081064224, -0.013024692423641682, -0.01699759252369404, 0.03371865674853325, 0.010287582874298096, -0.03680821880698204, 0.05227172002196312, -0.07463071495294571, 0.06307127326726913, -0.03717900067567825, 0.026070650666952133, 0.012039034627377987, 0.051691144704818726, 0.05663030967116356, -0.06317045539617538, 0.006605790928006172, -0.05891413241624832, -0.07577943801879883, 0.05819234997034073, 0.0031371547374874353, -0.10060931742191315, -0.011883665807545185, -0.02687748335301876, -0.06637806445360184, 0.03750054910778999, 0.004725994076579809, -0.07240414619445801, 0.008930863812565804, -0.025088518857955933, -0.018345413729548454, 0.06569463014602661, 0.06073160097002983, 0.0008940103580243886, -0.022761477157473564, -0.022710930556058884, 0.002426482504233718, 0.033445682376623154, 0.07349133491516113, -0.07916389405727386, 0.012400058098137379, 0.05286839231848717, -0.033969126641750336, 0.02423802763223648, 0.07596476376056671, 0.03303396329283714, 0.026092885062098503, -0.03796029090881348, 0.00918492116034031, -0.016594069078564644, -0.033421631902456284, 0.003726762253791094, -0.039902716875076294, -0.027789752930402756, 0.014321435242891312, 0.006358052603900433, -0.001575987203978002, -0.010163073427975178, -0.04190373793244362, 0.006279335357248783, -0.02628730796277523, -0.020566590130329132, -0.025763407349586487, -0.010890355333685875, -0.02847222425043583, 0.05629308894276619, -0.004751330707222223, -0.04514438286423683, 0.006570957601070404, -0.0002692866255529225, 0.024264749139547348, -0.0137232206761837, -0.025940807536244392, 0.01302723865956068, -0.00454224506393075, -0.05998755618929863, -0.009374784305691719, -0.007397366221994162, -0.029502511024475098, 0.07557874917984009, 0.005098534282296896, 0.027907555922865868, -0.025182772427797318, -0.0010564972180873156, 0.04543162137269974, 0.020201634615659714, 0.043791621923446655, 0.035605836659669876, 0.02118026278913021, -0.03190206363797188, 0.00972286518663168, 0.02392454817891121, -0.07501301169395447, 0.04767771437764168, 0.0633821189403534, -0.016500812023878098, 0.03240837901830673, -0.02500363066792488, 0.022912904620170593, -0.024402886629104614, -0.015827849507331848, -0.009859245270490646, -0.04119623824954033, -0.012072227895259857, -0.0021310090087354183, 0.03788936883211136, -0.022388825193047523, -0.0240941159427166, -0.0063412548042833805, -0.07659931480884552, 0.031280532479286194, -0.031928762793540955, -0.003598951967433095, 0.007225625216960907, -0.039895519614219666, -0.061699483543634415, 0.002170087303966284, 0.021981235593557358, -0.01956331543624401, 0.0010870725382119417, 0.01582692749798298, -0.010425591841340065, 0.031043866649270058, -0.020788615569472313, -0.022318556904792786, 0.008873526006937027, -0.020944232121109962, 0.03303498029708862, -0.00024039085838012397, -0.009212466888129711, 0.03201194480061531, 0.049246110022068024, -0.07791122794151306, 0.02054799161851406, 0.05266348272562027, -0.013162040151655674, -0.019090035930275917, -0.049662720412015915, -0.046605851501226425, -0.017179319635033607, -0.026989443227648735, 0.003019630676135421, 0.034741900861263275, -0.04306420311331749, 0.020520972087979317, -0.022273261100053787, -0.003074206179007888, -0.028377516195178032, 0.03609282895922661, 0.06376238167285919, -0.011712581850588322, -0.06258608400821686, -0.015551828779280186, 0.027817122638225555, 0.01659560389816761, -0.022313838824629784, 0.08521291613578796, -0.032702092081308365, 0.006228594575077295, 0.022293558344244957, -0.03794119507074356, -0.05354958400130272, 0.07373683154582977, 0.030259044840931892, -0.003494689939543605, 0.011824505403637886, 0.012122132815420628, -0.010517151094973087, -0.011267663910984993, -0.0075673628598451614, -0.0029878991190344095, 0.02079666219651699, 0.0008756268653087318, 0.07235515117645264, 0.03610536456108093, 0.008398636244237423, -0.05080227181315422, 0.042594727128744125, 0.017723817378282547, -0.011323231272399426, -0.03895372524857521, -0.062462568283081055, -0.07862913608551025, 0.005502548534423113, 0.07137837260961533, 0.04224361851811409, 0.008701026439666748, 0.002933709416538477, 0.02537825144827366, -0.009031369350850582, 0.03051859326660633, 0.06594669818878174, -0.010498467832803726, 0.014494682662189007, 0.02500659041106701, -0.014947068877518177, 0.020827090367674828, 0.028355538845062256, 0.0666918158531189, 0.00956807192414999, -0.05720781162381172, -0.010920470580458641, 0.0379895456135273, -0.01991450972855091, 0.025622157379984856, -0.0037224628031253815, -0.04559984803199768, 0.009287371300160885, 0.006482385098934174, 0.05813520774245262, 0.002594485180452466, -0.004131998401135206, 0.004743719939142466, -0.034671735018491745, 0.018325546756386757, 0.03912496194243431, 0.09326151013374329, 0.01334731001406908, -0.04879578948020935, -0.009176642633974552, -0.0007193285855464637, -0.03372662141919136, -0.03550945222377777, 0.003431421471759677, 0.03276348486542702, 0.004542254842817783, 0.012525058351457119, 0.01672002486884594, -0.023579366505146027, 0.0147761981934309, 0.021840769797563553, -0.023229019716382027, -0.034624211490154266, -0.02561560831964016, 0.013733272440731525, -0.054575804620981216, 0.027638554573059082, -0.009812569245696068, 0.03939368203282356, 0.010943900793790817, -0.004231251776218414, -0.062492191791534424, 0.04562480002641678, -0.00820261612534523, 0.030424922704696655, -0.0031784523744136095, -0.03560151904821396, 0.03955022618174553, -0.013804549351334572, 0.042758069932460785, -0.03626265004277229, 0.07043666392564774, -0.03415307775139809, 0.007447815965861082, -0.05635929852724075, 0.017574278637766838, -0.06766592711210251, -0.02201785333454609, 0.033718500286340714, 0.03986884281039238, 0.03172765299677849, 0.015531366690993309, -0.001324155949987471, 0.013978585600852966, -0.04190536588430405, -0.00437238160520792, 0.0253601111471653, -0.011646024882793427, -0.0017242783214896917, -0.012004884891211987, 0.06261336803436279, 0.03658374771475792, 0.03741244971752167, -0.004773490596562624, 0.014266462996602058, -0.019097235053777695, 0.02620144747197628, 0.02097100019454956, -0.035310834646224976, -0.0013791306409984827, -0.028914207592606544, -0.051409654319286346, 0.013193263672292233, 0.02214854769408703, 0.04183259978890419, 0.048782557249069214, 0.025713635608553886, -0.055497489869594574, 0.012648181058466434, 0.010964673012495041, -0.09067977964878082, 0.07140104472637177, 0.0049657924100756645, -0.004959728103131056, -0.04787661135196686, 0.010632803663611412, 0.01195856649428606, -0.03368430957198143, 0.0003500463499221951, 0.017819656059145927, -0.023330669850111008, 0.033930081874132156, 0.032505881041288376, -0.025133147835731506, 0.03698122501373291, 0.0025294460356235504, -0.0321691520512104, 0.015005468390882015, 0.014391993172466755, 0.01153027918189764, 0.008688422851264477, 0.009352599270641804, 0.020723039284348488, 0.027121324092149734, 0.02387586236000061, -0.12367827445268631, -0.007842824794352055, -0.029177172109484673, 0.01651665009558201, 0.00940875243395567, -0.07884915918111801, 0.009377892129123211, 0.02697492204606533, -0.004455615300685167, -0.0013712897198274732, 0.0011959479888901114, -0.04845309630036354, 0.07947918772697449, 0.026757217943668365, -0.07105498760938644, 0.025890428572893143, -0.04813263937830925, -0.019878385588526726, 0.010184039361774921, 0.0037343252915889025, 0.018657218664884567, 0.01983017474412918, -0.03682365268468857, -0.02508534863591194, -0.02761596255004406, 0.00589867914095521, 0.010069304145872593 ]
<p>I am an undergrad intern at a national lab currently working with a basic proton NMR device. The device consists of two big coils which provide the static magnetic field, and a smaller coil, which sends both the "excitation" signal and receives the NMR signal. A week or so ago, my supervisor asked me to calculate the magnitude of the magnetic field of the inner coil. </p> <p>Since I knew the maxiumum voltage of my signal, I chose to use Faraday's law of induction for a tightly wound coil of wire: $\mathcal{E}=-N\frac{d\phi_B}{dt}$. Knowing that the excited net magnetization vector $\vec{M}$ has a torque exerted on it (thanks to the static field), I reasoned that the magnetic flux through the smaller coil would be: $\phi_{B}=BA\cos\omega t$. Taking the derivative of this, I reasoned that the maximum voltage would be equivalent to the maximum of $-N\frac{d\phi_B}{dt}$:</p> <p>$V_{max}=NBA\omega$.</p> <p>I figured that from this equation; knowing the area, precession frequency, and number of coils; I would be able to find $B$ pretty easily. </p> <p>But we measured B another way, using $\theta=\gamma B_1t_p$, and got a result that was half the size of the "Faraday way". At first, even my supervisor was confused, but then he quickly remembered that we forgot to remember that we were working in a "rotating frame". </p> <p>For this reason, our supervisor said that the correct relation between max voltage and max flux was really $\frac{V_{max}}{2}=NBA\omega$.</p> <p>Well, this baffled me. It still baffles me. He tried to explain to me that we can think of our signal as two arrows which oscillate in opposite directions in a circle, each arrow having a magnitude half the size of the actual thing. I know I'm using vague language right now, but that's because I don't get it. Why do I cut my max voltage in half. Even if we did use this rotating frame, wouldn't the max voltage be when the arrows are in phase, and add up together. </p> <p>If you guys could help me out, that would be awesome. Let me know if you need any clarification on the setup of the experiment; I'll be happy to elaborate.</p>
g4030
[ -0.00808666367083788, -0.014553789980709553, 0.006976838689297438, -0.013752174563705921, 0.05139269307255745, -0.04091835021972656, 0.08149464428424835, 0.029240522533655167, -0.037401407957077026, -0.028896057978272438, -0.039739955216646194, 0.02307744324207306, 0.011890283785760403, 0.007716751657426357, 0.062016453593969345, -0.03685547783970833, 0.01044338196516037, -0.004203634336590767, 0.034254975616931915, -0.017119478434324265, -0.00929624680429697, 0.029318053275346756, -0.009254081174731255, -0.005304089281708002, 0.028447238728404045, -0.0013687980826944113, 0.021888872608542442, 0.03910322114825249, -0.044909823685884476, 0.006534670013934374, 0.032675329595804214, 0.020376775413751602, 0.06531692296266556, -0.030030792579054832, -0.05379416421055794, 0.01612680032849312, 0.004093694034963846, 0.05455534905195236, -0.010976681485772133, 0.0030518523417413235, 0.004016465041786432, -0.049192190170288086, 0.05680587515234947, -0.017364853993058205, 0.007633554749190807, 0.02716970071196556, -0.0028973205480724573, -0.018953580409288406, -0.01243313867598772, 0.007620752789080143, -0.07005422562360764, -0.026520848274230957, 0.05312983691692352, 0.014991695992648602, 0.008505028672516346, 0.024517768993973732, -0.01787828840315342, -0.03619213029742241, 0.08460230380296707, 0.066413514316082, 0.027446730062365532, -0.006365619134157896, -0.04104306921362877, 0.020427126437425613, 0.001833129208534956, 0.014732958748936653, -0.009748365730047226, -0.026782140135765076, -0.022038666531443596, 0.05959927290678024, -0.043242596089839935, -0.11273885518312454, 0.006464945152401924, -0.039622921496629715, 0.013063352555036545, 0.00728377653285861, 0.021442584693431854, -0.02896372228860855, 0.051836851984262466, 0.0026675995904952288, 0.013941028155386448, 0.003132857847958803, -0.04004533216357231, 0.04728895053267479, 0.06653857976198196, 0.044560957700014114, 0.020276011899113655, 0.06496072560548782, 0.007403608877211809, 0.0669434517621994, 0.051813576370477676, -0.03203624114394188, 0.06543437391519547, -0.03175397217273712, 0.0243544802069664, -0.034021731466054916, 0.019095804542303085, 0.063526451587677, -0.01905699446797371, 0.01751784048974514, -0.009850703179836273, 0.02825315296649933, 0.007766524329781532, -0.01529395580291748, -0.047948818653821945, 0.06174575909972191, 0.06684435158967972, -0.030460476875305176, -0.01102317776530981, -0.017452392727136612, -0.06503462046384811, -0.04473330080509186, -0.03928326815366745, -0.03555664047598839, -0.023193558678030968, 0.011603865772485733, 0.038198232650756836, -0.012095446698367596, 0.004451410844922066, 0.023029865697026253, 0.027133973315358162, -0.0017242245376110077, 0.014095652848482132, 0.1029234305024147, -0.015304366126656532, 0.043241217732429504, -0.03643763065338135, 0.05210646241903305, 0.04903704673051834, -0.04651082307100296, -0.019564226269721985, -0.054383791983127594, 0.011606277897953987, 0.028748556971549988, 0.013597131706774235, 0.023629726842045784, -0.037662044167518616, 0.0009690910228528082, 0.03618223965167999, -0.005382866598665714, -0.006790062412619591, -0.08786087483167648, -0.0035027656704187393, -0.032838210463523865, -0.023436732590198517, 0.0756830945611, -0.02545010671019554, -0.043209441006183624, 0.05057705193758011, 0.008196949027478695, 0.036243367940187454, 0.04918539151549339, -0.06725790351629257, -0.008253451436758041, 0.014820879325270653, 0.001807555090636015, 0.03309644013643265, -0.04980896785855293, 0.008338461630046368, -0.014975156635046005, 0.033365461975336075, -0.032525353133678436, 0.02366415411233902, -0.011508948169648647, -0.03328772634267807, 0.007352091837674379, 0.0562443882226944, -0.0169677734375, -0.007945070043206215, -0.04683365300297737, -0.08453746140003204, -0.03851113095879555, 0.047450389713048935, 0.0008179275318980217, -0.011589271947741508, 0.08687343448400497, 0.02464742213487625, -0.017701808363199234, 0.049204371869564056, 0.08696077018976212, -0.012819508090615273, 0.03883056715130806, 0.01929648034274578, -0.037454333156347275, -0.060648515820503235, 0.04691511392593384, -0.01735079661011696, 0.04900847375392914, -0.03769584745168686, -0.01246930193156004, 0.0049215927720069885, -0.021883994340896606, -0.04170071706175804, 0.04902129992842674, -0.06320665031671524, 0.01648496463894844, 0.0038349884562194347, -0.04448917135596275, -0.031242171302437782, -0.009454154409468174, -0.031720589846372604, -0.02503257989883423, 0.005311134271323681, -0.0022365308832377195, 0.0005358782364055514, -0.018016336485743523, 0.027331851422786713, 0.010637040250003338, 0.06169327720999718, 0.029366200789809227, 0.015074617229402065, 0.0024011835921555758, -0.06910643726587296, 0.04065004363656044, 0.02441105805337429, -0.050127021968364716, 0.033167093992233276, -0.0015429911436513066, -0.03360616788268089, 0.029246361926198006, 0.04031621664762497, 0.0014134175144135952, 0.08840598911046982, -0.010811980813741684, -0.05865395814180374, 0.017856882885098457, 0.027804667130112648, -0.024258170276880264, -0.04177394136786461, 0.003806161694228649, -0.029587307944893837, 0.011694916523993015, 0.005504756700247526, 0.014837365597486496, 0.0020373198203742504, 0.031238384544849396, 0.0033096291590481997, -0.017298957332968712, -0.029661303386092186, -0.02787979319691658, 0.04328234866261482, 0.03440716862678528, -0.023468762636184692, 0.0015710358275100589, -0.046710968017578125, -0.015235829167068005, 0.024244608357548714, 0.0118724899366498, -0.011697481386363506, 0.050092268735170364, 0.04193446412682533, 0.00923242699354887, 0.025566382333636284, 0.016911424696445465, -0.014836420305073261, 0.025576725602149963, -0.04894284904003143, 0.03414874151349068, -0.07692242413759232, -0.03337619826197624, -0.013289784081280231, -0.027252623811364174, 0.01238743495196104, 0.031177237629890442, -0.04553331434726715, -0.03449500724673271, -0.021749312058091164, 0.032541852444410324, 0.03087279386818409, -0.027639079838991165, -0.022119566798210144, 0.06676577776670456, -0.029529206454753876, -0.012518635019659996, -0.0014268943341448903, 0.008977090008556843, 0.048214081674814224, 0.013405952602624893, 0.03451773524284363, -0.009921151213347912, -0.07939102500677109, 0.02250736765563488, -0.07201170176267624, 0.005606350023299456, 0.035423628985881805, -0.01542243454605341, -0.03854517266154289, 0.0289474967867136, -0.02721654437482357, 0.062444671988487244, -0.0887041836977005, 0.004987298045307398, -0.027311991900205612, -0.04024368152022362, -0.0007226358284242451, 0.013802279718220234, 0.05383509770035744, 0.03266502544283867, 0.015043703839182854, 0.042288314551115036, 0.0349210686981678, 0.01528665330260992, 0.008351664990186691, -0.06697666645050049, -0.032160740345716476, -0.022508814930915833, -0.029441889375448227, -0.0937838926911354, -0.03527006506919861, 0.06016027554869652, -0.08720701932907104, -0.024153796955943108, 0.047000106424093246, -0.06628762930631638, -0.03522595390677452, 0.008208530955016613, 0.007300774101167917, 0.040140267461538315, 0.030256830155849457, -0.003460617270320654, -0.016596028581261635, -0.029029542580246925, 0.007378589361906052, 0.015763642266392708, 0.03814682364463806, -0.006069687195122242, -0.014490542933344841, 0.023910410702228546, -0.0724562555551529, -0.08904235064983368, 0.03112442046403885, 0.018803833052515984, 0.019940676167607307, 0.019600316882133484, -0.02125694416463375, -0.032575126737356186, -0.05092514306306839, 0.08326775580644608, -0.002228780882433057, 0.01359834149479866, -0.042609840631484985, -0.03621622920036316, -0.05376638472080231, -0.06858348846435547, 0.0010266246972605586, 0.043160367757081985, -0.08472900092601776, 0.009940257295966148, -0.02545824646949768, 0.008464316837489605, 0.028321901336312294, -0.025226453319191933, -0.028272975236177444, -0.006980970036238432, 0.006798074580729008, 0.021586008369922638, 0.049654096364974976, 0.005032166372984648, -0.02862921915948391, 0.0074528418481349945, -0.005737322382628918, -0.0364617258310318, -0.01089592557400465, -0.0027475086972117424, -0.02339365892112255, 0.03750396519899368, 0.008130043745040894, 0.06471572071313858, -0.02259192056953907, -0.021193096414208412, -0.10534241795539856, -0.069244883954525, -0.021886711940169334, -0.014573230408132076, -0.04043758660554886, -0.019002621993422508, -0.004739824682474136, -0.01740855537354946, -0.01966027170419693, 0.07180754095315933, 0.012180693447589874, 0.03769506514072418, -0.049307867884635925, -0.015482515096664429, 0.0015833501238375902, 0.014244037680327892, 0.031127063557505608, 0.024774502962827682, -0.02250412106513977, 0.004245196934789419, -0.00833740271627903, -0.01813575252890587, -0.009160236455500126, 0.033062729984521866, -0.04728022590279579, -0.02915528044104576, -0.031769149005413055, 0.05784577503800392, -0.015858497470617294, -0.008421405218541622, 0.0020899137016385794, -0.026691827923059464, -0.021556289866566658, -0.031100725755095482, -0.0066645583137869835, 0.014226933009922504, 0.03876377269625664, 0.008550777100026608, 0.03972327336668968, -0.03985736891627312, -0.01865844428539276, 0.0372505821287632, -0.05180111154913902, -0.09197980165481567, 0.04261454939842224, 0.030409451574087143, 0.0076591758988797665, -0.013376139104366302, -0.003505983855575323, -0.016591230407357216, 0.01801723800599575, 0.012975539080798626, 0.019624127075076103, -0.01245168223977089, -0.02107580378651619, 0.03553519397974014, -0.02592112310230732, 0.030041266232728958, 0.04782751202583313, -0.02931063063442707, -0.006533896084874868, 0.007927565835416317, -0.04576536640524864, 0.015104678459465504, -0.044522713869810104, 0.06486856937408447, -0.059855736792087555, 0.0428580641746521, 0.01884870044887066, 0.027400029823184013, 0.07288503646850586, -0.028313172981142998, 0.01487396378070116, 0.010336266830563545, 0.01348201185464859, 0.012224901467561722, -0.04548979550600052, -0.0065835765562951565, -0.062131598591804504, -0.020672067999839783, 0.014678330160677433, 0.026307104155421257, -0.03064790926873684, 0.018766162917017937, 0.059652816504240036, -0.01807474158704281, -0.034054871648550034, 0.0014200282748788595, 0.011573283933103085, 0.0018837886163964868, -0.08131948858499527, -0.007524540647864342, -0.04396895691752434, 0.0031244084239006042, 0.07971881330013275, 0.03814522922039032, 0.0093540009111166, -0.06932268291711807, -0.03338160365819931, 0.016501381993293762, 0.017936596646904945, -0.008081040345132351, 0.0049623954109847546, -0.031824514269828796, 0.019017212092876434, 0.02409985288977623, 0.025536946952342987, 0.004762993194162846, -0.03942446783185005, -0.062212854623794556, -0.09369999170303345, -0.009021081030368805, 0.04465872049331665, 0.04473978281021118, 0.020545994862914085, -0.023823024705052376, -0.04558173567056656, -0.02081247977912426, 0.03356703370809555, -0.05715103819966316, 0.0006236261688172817, 0.049285419285297394, 0.021775703877210617, 0.006960572209209204, 0.01716565527021885, -0.026973906904459, -0.012751918286085129, -0.06170448288321495, -0.0359802320599556, -0.05367342010140419, -0.08465910702943802, -0.010678395628929138, -0.030084745958447456, 0.012743866071105003, -0.02481420524418354, 0.03218108043074608, -0.03639831021428108, -0.0138889504596591, -0.012629332952201366, 0.05113482102751732, 0.00616020942106843, 0.0038779801689088345, 0.05174975097179413, 0.0003806736203841865, 0.05773830786347389, -0.04401497542858124, 0.0019983819220215082, 0.0028033575508743525, 0.008025425486266613, -0.01330815814435482, 0.05421882122755051, -0.017323916777968407, 0.06495481729507446, -0.0454510897397995, -0.01102529838681221, 0.038117971271276474, -0.033644795417785645, -0.010981838218867779, 0.0013762504095211625, 0.01592354103922844, -0.01741773821413517, 0.05826365202665329, 0.00803972128778696, 0.028179604560136795, -0.0014549829065799713, -0.012549960054457188, 0.032445792108774185, -0.021613340824842453, 0.013697817921638489, -0.013510595075786114, 0.016537290066480637, -0.030896376818418503, -0.010966059751808643, -0.005319743882864714, -0.051498956978321075, -0.003998727072030306, 0.02874438650906086, -0.035938698798418045, 0.04905558377504349, 0.048209626227617264, -0.037438880652189255, 0.007979978807270527, 0.010397017002105713, -0.029778940603137016, 0.027335578575730324, 0.061295270919799805, 0.0027121189050376415, 0.008547337725758553, 0.00863755214959383, 0.012422377243638039, 0.01598626933991909, 0.010090031661093235, -0.009641383774578571, 0.04767095670104027, 0.03323395922780037, -0.015299600549042225, -0.00032029830617830157, 0.00845254585146904, 0.04313531517982483, 0.02822940982878208, 0.014676530845463276, -0.004779384937137365, -0.027584731578826904, 0.037421487271785736, 0.0481986366212368, 0.0660676658153534, -0.0006398149416781962, -0.026723215356469154, -0.027086054906249046, -0.01796022802591324, 0.008676732890307903, 0.008014452643692493, 0.03477019816637039, -0.028414195403456688, 0.036433473229408264, 0.04204772785305977, -0.005453279707580805, 0.03154997527599335, 0.017214393243193626, -0.03857029229402542, -0.029067886993288994, 0.03494652360677719, 0.013711599633097649, -0.004490640014410019, -0.018572278320789337, -0.016235437244176865, -0.018975986167788506, -0.061597809195518494, -0.006502614822238684, 0.017806898802518845, 0.02629448100924492, 0.009684136137366295, 0.046041686087846756, -0.005911937914788723, 0.047922637313604355, 0.03309842571616173, -0.03632808104157448, -0.01850913278758526, -0.04086150601506233, 0.02562127448618412, 0.001799712423235178, -0.005061157513409853, -0.01999094896018505, 0.025034289807081223, 0.008879078552126884, 0.02003943920135498, 0.0371810644865036, 0.0025312858633697033, 0.026576271280646324, 0.024587612599134445, -0.018667621538043022, 0.011925078928470612, 0.00758271524682641, 0.021102190017700195, 0.02930527552962303, 0.031775955110788345, 0.0019079598132520914, -0.0361151248216629, 0.023142321035265923, -0.005163486581295729, 0.02045714668929577, 0.0013389091473072767, -0.0024239495396614075, 0.028408315032720566, 0.044686101377010345, 0.005795767065137625, 0.02367902360856533, 0.031206728890538216, 0.004059020429849625, 0.04067407548427582, -0.023755310103297234, 0.0415814146399498, -0.01987415924668312, 0.02461126260459423, 0.020703602582216263, -0.04476230591535568, 0.012881189584732056, 0.0345730185508728, -0.05003271624445915, 0.010461666621267796, 0.017318570986390114, 0.011518399231135845, -0.023191822692751884, 0.04100680351257324, -0.021230222657322884, 0.00552809564396739, 0.007465421687811613, 0.02066134475171566, 0.059594422578811646, -0.03139922022819519, -0.00937744788825512, 0.010571932420134544, 0.005104045383632183, -0.022646740078926086, 0.0420965775847435, 0.006073314230889082, -0.021344901993870735, 0.002087557455524802, -0.003969273995608091, -0.049180787056684494, -0.018382282927632332, -0.03883305564522743, -0.007199538871645927, 0.014256536960601807, 0.03805702179670334, -0.030708709731698036, -0.01409087236970663, -0.013722687028348446, 0.0028443080373108387, 0.0042960066348314285, -0.0628158450126648, -0.05420118570327759, 0.006456506904214621, -0.04315228760242462, -0.05609617754817009, 0.0006696279160678387, -0.09742811322212219, 0.007789434399455786, 0.03176544979214668, 0.03100675530731678, 0.010141996666789055, 0.002628443529829383, 0.07167556136846542, 0.019203871488571167, -0.021533716470003128, 0.04942502826452255, 0.0035876294132322073, 0.05901751294732094, 0.0712684765458107, -0.016075467690825462, 0.07636868208646774, -0.024473194032907486, -0.03411271423101425, 0.01325767207890749, 0.049315668642520905, 0.07987338304519653, 0.018068790435791016, -0.00775737501680851, -0.04229048639535904, -0.03028174489736557, -0.008753315545618534, 0.033368200063705444, 0.013510932214558125, 0.035496488213539124, 0.01746191829442978, 0.02418982982635498, -0.04834321513772011, 0.002965469378978014, 0.05024389922618866, -0.013144684955477715, -0.08942218869924545, 0.04069061204791069, -0.01618470437824726, -0.0313388854265213, -0.09020166099071503, -0.05592828616499901, -0.053673673421144485, 0.011928867548704147, -0.03776254877448082, -0.01087155006825924, 0.002060821047052741, -0.07618667930364609, -0.04943782836198807, -0.015557847917079926, -0.06748093664646149, -0.04089455306529999, -0.01998230814933777, 0.0020865353289991617, 0.03498983010649681, 0.0031657018698751926, 0.023421090096235275, -0.04530303552746773, -0.050635192543268204, -0.09031474590301514, -0.03539258986711502, 0.037093210965394974, -0.05807613953948021, 0.043966349214315414, 0.03492208570241928, -0.05719200521707535, -0.0335116870701313, 0.0052693369798362255, -0.029063990339636803, 0.028276003897190094, 0.11097630858421326, -0.02359732612967491, -0.02814854122698307, 0.019634440541267395, 0.030908778309822083, 0.016011422500014305, -0.037699077278375626, -0.03366607427597046, 0.02546641044318676, 0.036528944969177246, 0.07662101089954376, -0.021131671965122223, -0.014539924450218678, -0.007742471992969513 ]
<blockquote> <p>A closed calorimeter of negligible water equivalent contains 1kg ice at 0 degree Celsius. 1kg of steam at 100 degrees Celsius is pumped into it. Find the resultant temperature of the mixture. </p> </blockquote> <p>I did the standard approach. Heat absorbed by ice = Heat lost by steam. I took the change in temperature as $\Delta\theta_{i}$ and $\Delta\theta_{s}$. I will use sub $s$ for steam and sub $i$ for ice.</p> <p>$$Q_\text{ice} = Q_\text{steam}$$</p> <p>$$m_is_f + m_is_w\Delta\theta_i = m_ss_v + m_ss_w\Delta\theta_s$$</p> <p>Where $s_f$ is specific heat of fusion of water, $s_w$ is specific heat of water and $s_v$ is specific heat of vaporization of water. </p> <p>Since $\Delta\theta_s = 100 - \Delta\theta_i$,</p> <p>$$m_is_f + m_is_w\Delta\theta_i = m_ss_v + m_ss_w(100 - \Delta\theta_i)$$</p> <p>$$m_is_f + m_is_w\Delta\theta_i = m_ss_v + 100m_ss_w - m_ss_w\Delta\theta_i$$</p> <p>$$\Delta\theta_i(m_is_w + m_ss_w) = m_ss_v + 100m_ss_w - m_is_f$$ and thus \begin{align}\Delta\theta_i&amp;=\frac{m_ss_v + 100m_ss_w - m_is_f}{m_is_w + m_ss_w}\\&amp;= \frac{1000g\times2230\,\mathrm{\frac{J}{g}} + 100\,\mathrm{K}\times1000\,\mathrm{g}\times4.18\,\mathrm{\frac{J}{gK}} - 1000g\times334\,\mathrm{\frac{J}{g}}}{1000\,\mathrm{g}\times4.18\,\mathrm{\frac{J}{gK}} + 1000\,\mathrm{g}\times4.18\,\mathrm{\frac{J}{gK}}}\\&amp;= 276.79\,\mathrm{K}\end{align}</p> <p>Which makes no sense. I know I am making some naive error. But I have gone through this problem at least ten times but to no avail. </p>
g4031
[ 0.0424075722694397, -0.016138656064867973, -0.0035243784077465534, 0.008423269726336002, -0.04815966635942459, -0.01151568815112114, 0.023439250886440277, 0.06084659323096275, -0.05120177939534187, 0.026868240907788277, -0.018053758889436722, 0.08186913281679153, 0.03364910930395126, 0.044089291244745255, -0.0185728520154953, 0.006221999879926443, 0.07709383219480515, 0.031205983832478523, 0.013126424513757229, 0.046840205788612366, -0.017469657585024834, -0.056214019656181335, 0.03406848385930061, -0.05864712968468666, -0.049320392310619354, -0.06918910145759583, 0.033231221139431, 0.0070312232710421085, -0.021403172984719276, -0.02307809330523014, -0.005418065004050732, 0.04882240667939186, 0.001456537051126361, -0.026715852320194244, -0.055297449231147766, -0.006509940139949322, -0.0013353120302781463, 0.03415141627192497, 0.0275450199842453, -0.09736938029527664, 0.028328586369752884, 0.024421272799372673, 0.05648602172732353, 0.03874042630195618, 0.0010784007608890533, 0.03895747661590576, -0.027060696855187416, -0.015696683898568153, -0.020972512662410736, 0.018415728583931923, 0.04368448629975319, 0.05622514337301254, 0.07095640152692795, -0.04444139450788498, -0.025865977630019188, 0.07274404168128967, -0.013827156275510788, -0.044384341686964035, 0.00608788663521409, 0.03885240852832794, 0.05554037541151047, -0.05865837633609772, -0.005841976962983608, -0.0368691124022007, 0.054225411266088486, -0.023496778681874275, -0.030733542516827583, -0.0022794953547418118, 0.03567172586917877, 0.058613911271095276, 0.006505267694592476, -0.017323577776551247, 0.028527265414595604, 0.02285200171172619, -0.043908774852752686, -0.0758652463555336, -0.020489193499088287, -0.020952748134732246, 0.04031745344400406, -0.026871128007769585, -0.011772088706493378, 0.03070780076086521, 0.03167612478137016, -0.0006614472949877381, 0.024737589061260223, -0.01358750183135271, -0.03366276994347572, 0.03955003619194031, -0.02165009081363678, -0.0073510645888745785, -0.07652705162763596, 0.02393665723502636, 0.07750540226697922, -0.0005924644065089524, 0.041050396859645844, 0.04216545447707176, 0.03455760329961777, -0.011949206702411175, 0.004217976704239845, 0.02902836911380291, 0.03224221244454384, -0.00846585538238287, -0.023938404396176338, -0.03303563967347145, -0.008440753445029259, -0.024521905928850174, 0.009303794242441654, -0.010785981081426144, -0.05296211317181587, 0.034058235585689545, 0.0009234612225554883, -0.026136884465813637, -0.08306803554296494, -0.05885409191250801, -0.0027423384599387646, -0.004060181323438883, -0.033598918467760086, 0.04072311520576477, -0.041952431201934814, 0.003914371132850647, -0.029176658019423485, 0.02766038104891777, 0.004192863591015339, 0.08022111654281616, -0.012006103061139584, -0.030443627387285233, 0.020477844402194023, -0.019643204286694527, 0.058824241161346436, -0.012396907433867455, -0.02881678380072117, 0.014572398737072945, -0.006632198579609394, -0.03192882612347603, 0.02978767640888691, -0.016594136133790016, 0.019489314407110214, 0.04581126943230629, -0.0033693057484924793, 0.022225242108106613, -0.03666606917977333, 0.022636324167251587, -0.025050325319170952, -0.016442574560642242, -0.009689069353044033, 0.014578387141227722, -0.044041600078344345, -0.03871849179267883, -0.03879544883966446, -0.023502595722675323, -0.00021193514112383127, 0.06098313629627228, 0.03728950768709183, 0.018078500404953957, 0.02639097161591053, -0.05671895667910576, 0.014123638160526752, 0.007696892134845257, 0.05756736919283867, -0.039358142763376236, -0.027964359149336815, -0.02685372158885002, 0.0253919567912817, 0.003514466341584921, -0.03102891333401203, 0.01379311177879572, 0.006769951898604631, -0.037543971091508865, 0.02320687286555767, -0.06093595176935196, -0.06726370751857758, 0.0406656488776207, -0.009456631727516651, 0.015413309447467327, -0.008985040709376335, 0.002560490509495139, 0.05191890150308609, 0.010009926743805408, -0.02306530252099037, 0.017984742298722267, 0.06719477474689484, 0.06808143854141235, 0.06949719041585922, -0.06985419243574142, -0.02676226943731308, 0.030931387096643448, 0.006931852549314499, 0.016682442277669907, -0.05921417102217674, -0.002864895388484001, 0.008943119086325169, -0.0039626252837479115, 0.07067953050136566, 0.042942970991134644, 0.05106455087661743, 0.05512562766671181, 0.000814353465102613, -0.020763350650668144, -0.07526706159114838, 0.017861630767583847, -0.03171514719724655, 0.04810251668095589, -0.00530958641320467, -0.01317798625677824, -0.01916681043803692, -0.014367133378982544, 0.05266520380973816, 0.00625830190256238, 0.020397072657942772, -0.004363030660897493, -0.08810450881719589, -0.00548927579075098, -0.06454823166131973, -0.011031760834157467, -0.04007139056921005, -0.002569532487541437, 0.018108388409018517, -0.016569899395108223, -0.0614931657910347, -0.023050345480442047, 0.0217418372631073, 0.04146410897374153, 0.02334067039191723, -0.0025350148789584637, -0.06272197514772415, -0.01636606641113758, -0.01784670725464821, -0.014887881465256214, -0.01686524786055088, 0.021804561838507652, -0.04458161070942879, 0.008633744902908802, 0.03050665184855461, -0.050950292497873306, 0.03118855133652687, 0.037233736366033554, -0.039494361728429794, 0.022658316418528557, 0.030106808990240097, 0.029562396928668022, -0.012076340615749359, -0.0075965337455272675, -0.039462100714445114, -0.014481167308986187, 0.04708400368690491, 0.025149425491690636, 0.029235567897558212, -0.01162638794630766, 0.05399991571903229, -0.016470003873109818, -0.07391399890184402, 0.08711550384759903, -0.0022068284451961517, 0.02003222517669201, 0.011157911270856857, -0.002338411984965205, -0.04000313952565193, -0.027952643111348152, 0.01181629579514265, 0.05775098502635956, -0.0064435782842338085, -0.03302184119820595, -0.038947708904743195, 0.017432838678359985, -0.014998037368059158, -0.017642812803387642, -0.06092460826039314, -0.0501716323196888, 0.04747853800654411, 0.028670907020568848, 0.03532494232058525, -0.01526803057640791, 0.050417400896549225, 0.08584584295749664, -0.007511197589337826, -0.01801283471286297, 0.011443649418652058, -0.004651770461350679, 0.05318325757980347, -0.025895768776535988, 0.005901744123548269, -0.027700919657945633, 0.001114219194278121, 0.0041685644537210464, -0.027054086327552795, -0.07547619193792343, 0.0033814008347690105, 0.017534317448735237, 0.03423311561346054, -0.005336093250662088, 0.005121125373989344, 0.009667481295764446, -0.040201835334300995, 0.04200758785009384, 0.03823870047926903, 0.013948865234851837, 0.04083660617470741, 0.013402878306806087, 0.008538798429071903, -0.03442889824509621, 0.03164751082658768, -0.02176726795732975, -0.026047278195619583, 0.004089787602424622, -0.014527705498039722, 0.000986135215498507, -0.02682473696768284, -0.06743977963924408, 0.02663659118115902, 0.007555341813713312, 0.02261940762400627, -0.052471358329057693, 0.0006755428621545434, -0.06343433260917664, -0.012791657820343971, -0.017170824110507965, -0.012933915480971336, -0.05160529166460037, 0.011462274007499218, 0.01968028023838997, -0.011280849575996399, -0.032506879419088364, 0.009493505582213402, 0.011937287636101246, 0.000534858729224652, 0.013644474558532238, -0.022699352353811264, -0.029504351317882538, -0.038730040192604065, -0.0026601282879710197, -0.046507127583026886, 0.0017721031326800585, -0.03338708356022835, -0.030745580792427063, -0.03127613291144371, -0.05143876373767853, -0.01509894896298647, 0.015062684193253517, 0.014211071655154228, 0.019525842741131783, -0.043112318962812424, -0.03452328220009804, 0.05539717525243759, 0.03593197092413902, 0.015572795644402504, -0.009499850682914257, -0.047226566821336746, 0.04736417904496193, 0.0008200174779631197, -0.023628804832696915, 0.04377664998173714, 0.0027860719710588455, 0.0037730736657977104, -0.030420074239373207, -0.02755860611796379, 0.06549809873104095, 0.04922904074192047, 0.02126089483499527, -0.009487328119575977, 0.05038266256451607, 0.0435589998960495, -0.008263475261628628, -0.014479977078735828, 0.025032568722963333, -0.03812069818377495, 0.00567651679739356, 0.0029343932401388884, 0.016671400517225266, -0.04163282364606857, 0.034670405089855194, -0.003468720242381096, -0.02864990197122097, -0.03536710515618324, -0.012707510031759739, 0.03077847510576248, -0.041278086602687836, -0.01386202871799469, 0.016996057704091072, -0.03884567320346832, 0.048570577055215836, 0.011508581228554249, -0.0458577536046505, -0.012865261174738407, 0.00887730997055769, 0.037571270018815994, -0.01814214512705803, 0.03015602007508278, 0.050566304475069046, 0.04732782766222954, -0.04990618675947189, 0.00640154117718339, -0.02107476443052292, 0.01797471009194851, 0.08377573639154434, -0.03139221668243408, 0.003018731251358986, 0.0348518081009388, 0.007758633699268103, -0.0481390506029129, -0.04413732886314392, 0.005276945419609547, -0.06566263735294342, 0.05587273836135864, -0.04736883193254471, -0.023934053257107735, -0.02579631842672825, 0.020054172724485397, -0.031134577468037605, 0.008210571482777596, -0.012558121234178543, -0.0009806441375985742, 0.019362321123480797, -0.004423761740326881, 0.009094784036278725, 0.03587636724114418, -0.055698610842227936, 0.05453121289610863, -0.01526562962681055, 0.022881826385855675, -0.03872156888246536, -0.05356073006987572, -0.024086499586701393, -0.058622390031814575, -0.05202275142073631, 0.03254026547074318, 0.04217379167675972, 0.0031988495029509068, 0.019797630608081818, 0.011355475522577763, -0.07333815842866898, 0.03349052369594574, -0.02556397020816803, -0.030025195330381393, 0.03656581789255142, 0.0024866231251507998, 0.057568978518247604, -0.023209266364574432, -0.03328938037157059, -0.0010950462892651558, 0.10230536013841629, -0.012794685550034046, 0.03675074502825737, 0.0016098342603072524, 0.040759529918432236, 0.006055994890630245, 0.017749860882759094, 0.037357576191425323, -0.03187518194317818, 0.019005974754691124, -0.06244849041104317, 0.014546754769980907, 0.03491344302892685, -0.011490820907056332, 0.01414824090898037, -0.024645160883665085, 0.009229087270796299, -0.011699048802256584, 0.08205562084913254, -0.04058263823390007, 0.03300401568412781, -0.012436172924935818, -0.02085559256374836, -0.02159869484603405, -0.01370946317911148, 0.030529296025633812, -0.0023629742208868265, -0.015688348561525345, -0.009310451336205006, -0.023898685351014137, -0.0317615382373333, 0.06139898672699928, 0.08035959303379059, 0.0210367850959301, -0.03614538162946701, 0.03565114736557007, 0.06064346805214882, 0.0016253694193437696, -0.03966663405299187, 0.0588177889585495, 0.009645004756748676, 0.011814354918897152, 0.020352791994810104, 0.009519382379949093, 0.0673460140824318, 0.02852126769721508, 0.014477148652076721, -0.029700057581067085, 0.038691990077495575, 0.06845187395811081, -0.07002993673086166, 0.02106240577995777, 0.025447165593504906, 0.03849181532859802, -0.014808782376348972, -0.0017452574102208018, -0.022517701610922813, -0.008396593853831291, -0.030192041769623756, 0.02388392575085163, 0.0658959150314331, -0.044119443744421005, 0.021941736340522766, -0.022879693657159805, 0.030438149347901344, 0.026462402194738388, -0.008678381331264973, -0.025618357583880424, 0.07128193974494934, -0.032066136598587036, 0.03492731600999832, 0.0013973456807434559, -0.01370180957019329, 0.037355780601501465, 0.015842463821172714, 0.06634195148944855, -0.027177125215530396, -0.005725105293095112, -0.05350479111075401, -0.010908766649663448, -0.11134285479784012, 0.029768874868750572, -0.012409163638949394, -0.05033564567565918, 0.07153116166591644, -0.03841943293809891, -0.005588790867477655, -0.10791848599910736, -0.03942260146141052, -0.004892709199339151, -0.03745605796575546, 0.024705475196242332, -0.009522916749119759, 0.003212783019989729, 0.01787528581917286, 0.026357091963291168, -0.021122323349118233, -0.023004358634352684, -0.035186465829610825, 0.02901211753487587, 0.05540182441473007, -0.002516354899853468, 0.031457092612981796, -0.002955051837489009, 0.06092889979481697, -0.02888217754662037, 0.029925160109996796, 0.0029498066287487745, 0.0096852146089077, -0.004320333246141672, 0.031628113240003586, -0.034369055181741714, 0.017087573185563087, 0.05371543765068054, -0.07156788557767868, 0.08700317144393921, -0.028608180582523346, 0.023468798026442528, -0.024809580296278, -0.025286167860031128, 0.002114503411576152, -0.00719921849668026, 0.0040611582808196545, -0.014000709168612957, 0.041426315903663635, 0.028497176244854927, -0.07654941827058792, -0.04909563437104225, -0.018458303064107895, -0.015766574069857597, -0.00903236772865057, 0.0009168492397293448, 0.03278711065649986, 0.009315041825175285, -0.05089582875370979, 0.06216665729880333, -0.018824907019734383, -0.05554770305752754, 0.006370373070240021, 0.008165962994098663, -0.009259908460080624, -0.025686049833893776, 0.003403756767511368, -0.032002005726099014, 0.05010046064853668, 0.052875783294439316, 0.00441768579185009, -0.06192335858941078, 0.012888689525425434, -0.026892580091953278, 0.042652569711208344, 0.014452293515205383, 0.01648029126226902, -0.011913103051483631, -0.020736316218972206, 0.04714173078536987, -0.005146728362888098, 0.010951174423098564, 0.038252681493759155, -0.022439122200012207, -0.017176713794469833, 0.005347502883523703, 0.007711583282798529, 0.05319332331418991, -0.009279202669858932, -0.04577221721410751, -0.0025224974378943443, 0.012626699171960354, 0.018564458936452866, -0.04336388781666756, -0.007129122037440538, -0.029289720579981804, 0.0576699860394001, 0.043370604515075684, -0.007991190999746323, -0.043729983270168304, -0.05374738946557045, -0.000585641770157963, 0.025989623740315437, -0.005316860042512417, -0.0066843959502875805, 0.017574284225702286, -0.00112065183930099, 0.014882195740938187, -0.058047398924827576, 0.029040563851594925, 0.04956521838903427, -0.026791736483573914, 0.009565158747136593, 0.006933850701898336, -0.02509503997862339, 0.02448490634560585, -0.04094575345516205, -0.024495935067534447, -0.020595457404851913, 0.004219244699925184, 0.06342732906341553, 0.011264670640230179, 0.044861603528261185, 0.035659823566675186, 0.0970003753900528, -0.04721754416823387, 0.011139917187392712, 0.0030023064464330673, 0.02708260342478752, -0.06371619552373886, 0.04035002738237381, -0.024466058239340782, -0.05698724091053009, -0.05566674843430519, 0.013350888155400753, -0.014603640884160995, 0.010803798213601112, -0.00016570757725276053, 0.021894635632634163, -0.04647192358970642, 0.03704157844185829, 0.0220066849142313, -0.0241906326264143, 0.058148473501205444, 0.019320223480463028, -0.030641499906778336, -0.06571447104215622, 0.004551820922642946, 0.0511835478246212, 0.0082264868542552, 0.058903589844703674, -0.012424497865140438, -0.01881757751107216, 0.08102107048034668, -0.09952058643102646, -0.024806378409266472, 0.014372719451785088, -0.015379597432911396, -0.022771354764699936, 0.023859312757849693, 0.0054853856563568115, 0.07945562154054642, 0.0012757617514580488, -0.0024760738015174866, -0.035086870193481445, -0.006881699897348881, -0.01593625359237194, 0.023689551278948784, -0.0068069687113165855, -0.01574678346514702, 0.010203497484326363, -0.0014939663233235478, 0.0017442286480218172, 0.08957113325595856, 0.06109246984124184, -0.02719184197485447, 0.04914594441652298, 0.053450021892786026, 0.00574814947322011, 0.022172238677740097, 0.03831866756081581, 0.027657901868224144, 0.03508712351322174, 0.0090863648802042, -0.0067732189781963825, 0.029226861894130707, 0.007566327694803476, -0.007302183657884598, -0.005978420376777649, -0.02050159126520157, 0.036526091396808624, -0.007519191596657038, 0.0012899354333058, 0.022854048758745193, 0.0019474991131573915, -0.0053499252535402775, 0.0351874940097332, 0.03334566950798035, -0.0338326133787632, 0.043269649147987366, -0.03540676459670067, -0.08408872783184052, -0.0271487757563591, -0.0036130736116319895, -0.053415775299072266, -0.041893504559993744, -0.03693985939025879, -0.029333682730793953, -0.0345010869204998, 0.014026560820639133, -0.033576395362615585, 0.00021960405865684152, -0.05178138613700867, -0.007999341934919357, 0.00877380184829235, -0.044724177569150925, -0.012025661766529083, -0.03123614564538002, -0.02375796064734459, -0.024534713476896286, -0.0415513776242733, -0.02895568683743477, -0.027596337720751762, 0.025761649012565613, 0.07994887977838516, -0.04224430397152901, -0.007634651381522417, 0.00013849248352926224, -0.056241780519485474, 0.03260513022542, -0.03812749311327934, -0.04042196646332741, 0.01974421739578247, -0.01451166719198227, -0.06381597369909286, 0.04979871213436127, 0.025609686970710754, -0.05792805552482605, -0.08106469362974167, 0.04168153181672096, -0.014134041965007782, -0.02563565783202648, 0.027235083281993866, -0.018743248656392097, 0.01953781396150589, -0.05807360261678696, -0.08455678820610046, -0.033170778304338455, 0.04096584394574165, 0.010427146218717098, 0.003707904601469636, -0.00024266447871923447, 0.011254439130425453 ]
<p>This question is concerned with a thermodynamic paradox for radiating bodies and radiation in a cavity of a specific shape.</p> <p>Consider two nested shells that are axisymmetric ellipsoids with the same two foci, A and B, as shown in the figure (line AB is the axis of symmetry). Cut the system along the vertical plane of symmetry and remove the right side of the outer shell, and remove the left half of the inner shell. Then connect the two halves with vertical surface, as shown in the figure, to make it a continuous enclosure. The result is a figure of rotation shown by the thick black line in the figure.</p> <p>Next, make the inner surface of it a perfect mirror. The property of such a cavity is that each ray emitted from point B comes to point A; but not each ray emitted from point A comes to point B - some rays emitted from A (shown in blue) come back to A.</p> <p>Now, put two small black bodies (say, two spheres of some small radius) at points A and B. Thermodynamic equilibrium requires that eventually the temperatures of the two spheres equilibrate. However, according to the geometric properties of this cavity, all energy emitted from B comes to A but only a fraction of energy emitted from A comes to B; so the equality of temperatures is not consistent with balance of emitted and absorbed power. How to resolve this paradox?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/igGAT.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p>
g4032
[ 0.043828822672367096, 0.01751691661775112, 0.012610082514584064, 0.022907083854079247, 0.042818039655685425, -0.010505729354918003, 0.012702533043920994, 0.015952961519360542, 0.013042251579463482, 0.017824634909629822, -0.00951194204390049, 0.07386209070682526, 0.029140617698431015, -0.010404887609183788, 0.003526594489812851, 0.034816622734069824, 0.03655405342578888, -0.034955840557813644, 0.03594190254807472, 0.06333981454372406, -0.013158897869288921, 0.0008272371487691998, -0.03904103487730026, -0.01253880001604557, 0.015467730350792408, 0.01596492901444435, 0.02742222510278225, 0.023507388308644295, -0.058522779494524, -0.03183233365416527, 0.00815537292510271, 0.003657445078715682, 0.04685818403959274, -0.01139591634273529, -0.0172286294400692, -0.005420625675469637, 0.05405335873365402, 0.0329684279859066, -0.012743433006107807, 0.0444117933511734, 0.07071343064308167, -0.0016841640463098884, 0.03777811676263809, 0.0037588158156722784, 0.014232996851205826, -0.05265048146247864, 0.01128790620714426, 0.025287700816988945, -0.004458105191588402, 0.001523728366009891, 0.005726783536374569, -0.00969239417463541, 0.032685089856386185, -0.08086762577295303, -0.023481398820877075, 0.028280992060899734, -0.004484651144593954, -0.01921536587178707, -0.01338087860494852, 0.02226589433848858, -0.040276478976011276, 0.007922965101897717, -0.07097085565328598, 0.03522980958223343, 0.02730482816696167, 0.016669346019625664, -0.04127703979611397, 0.015607349574565887, -0.010529824532568455, -0.017338166013360023, 0.005367123521864414, 0.011775495484471321, 0.010385621339082718, -0.0751085877418518, -0.050862472504377365, -0.021620973944664, 0.021946435794234276, 0.05197640880942345, -0.05179803445935249, -0.0009151936392299831, -0.030144210904836655, 0.012145595625042915, 0.044136203825473785, -0.00726582296192646, 0.05115985870361328, 0.04666833579540253, 0.013781802728772163, -0.009750112891197205, -0.02430885285139084, 0.0049085188657045364, 0.03225182369351387, 0.03999198600649834, 0.07577864825725555, 0.011465865187346935, 0.05718296766281128, 0.014523521065711975, 0.03858160227537155, 0.026597436517477036, -0.06474342942237854, 0.019031478092074394, 0.04994549602270126, -0.009840630926191807, -0.021733256056904793, 0.025820285081863403, 0.0025825395714491606, 0.005087829194962978, 0.01009372342377901, 0.03774702176451683, -0.07606015354394913, 0.027955088764429092, -0.02642076276242733, -0.12507931888103485, -0.029270971193909645, -0.04907669126987457, 0.005831344053149223, -0.0736408457159996, 0.07718539983034134, -0.07465659826993942, 0.028772924095392227, 0.0733375996351242, 0.012165894731879234, 0.03084072656929493, -0.06146980822086334, 0.03531370311975479, 0.011064965277910233, -0.030899880453944206, -0.023162150755524635, 0.02311541698873043, 0.04185150936245918, 0.018974043428897858, -0.013396363705396652, 0.020463332533836365, -0.005302004516124725, 0.06548412889242172, 0.041561536490917206, 0.04927128180861473, 0.02137552574276924, 0.004458823706954718, 0.022737063467502594, -0.052302952855825424, -0.0417480506002903, 0.003477083519101143, 0.026224374771118164, 0.005086992401629686, -0.03189576044678688, 0.014776140451431274, -0.0013614158378913999, 0.003394140163436532, 0.024130066856741905, 0.022408341988921165, -0.01147198025137186, 0.07849229127168655, 0.0022311212960630655, -0.012872278690338135, -0.02568187192082405, -0.02072880230844021, 0.01598970964550972, 0.027771223336458206, -0.016175223514437675, -0.029457639902830124, 0.03236391022801399, 0.039281368255615234, 0.010084476321935654, -0.00037826900370419025, -0.07458410412073135, -0.00248737633228302, -0.010299690067768097, -0.06966641545295715, -0.010787858627736568, -0.05071759596467018, -0.06309130787849426, 0.003602266078814864, -0.013173222541809082, 0.056085411459207535, 0.002750828629359603, 0.04435475543141365, 0.003425952745601535, -0.038690779358148575, -0.02310594543814659, -0.018812110647559166, -0.0667237788438797, 0.041187189519405365, 0.07629615813493729, -0.037365663796663284, -0.021030448377132416, -0.0545189343392849, 0.03312237933278084, 0.01541831623762846, -0.061876583844423294, -0.0028150463476777077, -0.03228315711021423, 0.014941954985260963, -0.03196444362401962, 0.005529828369617462, 0.03253207728266716, -0.012672952376306057, 0.08513609319925308, -0.0033503605518490076, -0.03373245894908905, 0.02804047428071499, 0.012285332195460796, 0.019522670656442642, 0.04713878780603409, -0.01058234553784132, 0.006815366446971893, 0.01703086495399475, -0.03287774324417114, -0.02636808156967163, -0.01945875585079193, 0.0025259593967348337, -0.011052733287215233, 0.024934152141213417, -0.03467971831560135, -0.012897618114948273, 0.03146303817629814, 0.049558576196432114, -0.006017548497766256, -0.004204822238534689, 0.013191795907914639, -0.04646649956703186, -0.016353419050574303, 0.03528490662574768, -0.017163045704364777, -0.05634503439068794, 0.004749984014779329, 0.01740189827978611, -0.06399523466825485, 0.02031347155570984, 0.012299496680498123, 0.04117412492632866, -0.07258447259664536, -0.0048548197373747826, 0.0632183626294136, -0.019831912592053413, 0.024685297161340714, -0.012868418358266354, -0.010491671040654182, 0.05978900566697121, -0.03644230589270592, 0.038023367524147034, 0.03248954564332962, 0.0031619968358427286, -0.10491518676280975, 0.008930345065891743, 0.0252058207988739, 0.028915682807564735, -0.007535689044743776, 0.004659285303205252, 0.028591662645339966, 0.03076877072453499, 0.019334733486175537, -0.044883184134960175, -0.010919212363660336, -0.038666754961013794, -0.014332246035337448, 0.00906311720609665, -0.04249846935272217, 0.0481627881526947, -0.010730188339948654, -0.029213368892669678, -0.0029253046959638596, -0.04122498258948326, 0.03053722344338894, -0.01925041154026985, -0.04222690686583519, -0.02720017172396183, 0.015721019357442856, -0.056433141231536865, 0.019695496186614037, 0.0405183769762516, -0.006326085422188044, 0.06373476982116699, 0.06746641546487808, 0.050395600497722626, -0.01625155285000801, 0.005673043895512819, -0.006767898332327604, -0.047096770256757736, 0.04955051839351654, -0.008917747996747494, -0.0030911543872207403, -0.0074236406944692135, -0.08690601587295532, 0.02754691056907177, 0.04493322595953941, -0.045172058045864105, -0.05913805589079857, 0.035909175872802734, -0.009592692367732525, 0.029517004266381264, -0.02132399193942547, -0.014041837304830551, 0.005864693317562342, 0.034022923558950424, -0.023672640323638916, 0.038318756967782974, -0.0032686844933778048, -0.04217785224318504, 0.02052174136042595, 0.01430987287312746, -0.0286844614893198, 0.006346145179122686, -0.005985806696116924, -0.03381510078907013, 0.006010189186781645, 0.013824797235429287, -0.027099717408418655, -0.06285275518894196, 0.04949982091784477, 0.05470636114478111, -0.025854509323835373, -0.012771448120474815, 0.011278856545686722, 0.016871636733412743, -0.013624691404402256, 0.017443377524614334, -0.08538974821567535, 0.006809827405959368, 0.046119000762701035, -0.021420123055577278, -0.033304497599601746, 0.04209115728735924, 0.014239379204809666, -0.03709062933921814, 0.03298553451895714, 0.011352241970598698, -0.030337834730744362, -0.011259746737778187, 0.006960899103432894, -0.00927102379500866, -0.02950018271803856, 0.012847409583628178, 0.004721168894320726, 0.032504595816135406, 0.013536041602492332, 0.012757695280015469, -0.0066930195316672325, -0.020363042131066322, -0.0001518557546660304, 0.03703603520989418, 0.012789946980774403, -0.03251749277114868, -0.018944835290312767, -0.005485763307660818, 0.03711313754320145, 0.0008081297273747623, -0.01020743791013956, -0.00903378613293171, -0.010501595214009285, 0.0026381067000329494, 0.012557667680084705, -0.001723177614621818, 0.038444288074970245, 0.01576189696788788, -0.00519267562776804, 0.023078901693224907, 0.00745035195723176, 0.02292197197675705, 0.02244417369365692, 0.031231623142957687, -0.012414013966917992, -0.053544145077466965, 0.05472467467188835, -0.024153703823685646, 0.009859416633844376, -0.01900636777281761, -0.003960480447858572, 0.032116860151290894, -0.01445247046649456, -0.013861519284546375, -0.042182520031929016, -0.006978232879191637, -0.052282534539699554, -0.011283943429589272, 0.07671525329351425, -0.036149974912405014, 0.002827803371474147, -0.015128358267247677, -0.061375174671411514, -0.033626701682806015, 0.014962260611355305, 0.028606930747628212, -0.0348205640912056, -0.005990769248455763, -0.011982209049165249, 0.05324602127075195, 0.005691260565072298, -0.029508531093597412, 0.016245223581790924, -0.04328249767422676, 0.07111667841672897, -0.009106420911848545, -0.0212019681930542, -0.005376987624913454, 0.021802345290780067, -0.0032826184760779142, -0.006421724334359169, -0.0513322539627552, -0.023456096649169922, -0.0034962287172675133, 0.03567812219262123, 0.0017759150359779596, 0.03566610440611839, -0.017695657908916473, -0.005172200500965118, -0.02033219486474991, 0.0016009093960747123, -0.01947915554046631, -0.03359270468354225, -0.026794616132974625, 0.027366135269403458, 0.0006443531601689756, 0.06409228593111038, -0.009937012568116188, 0.026797747239470482, 0.017413830384612083, -0.0027701975777745247, -0.001037934678606689, 0.037570010870695114, 0.01329007651656866, -0.05259598791599274, 0.02335272915661335, -0.0010558515787124634, -0.0051788934506475925, 0.038268934935331345, 0.0023352487478405237, 0.026521675288677216, -0.0025684235151857138, 0.00403087493032217, -0.016821203753352165, 0.015309227630496025, 0.0037551422137767076, 0.00014042246039025486, -0.010090487077832222, -0.053181104362010956, 0.005319577641785145, -0.07193440943956375, 0.03893103078007698, -0.0223387461155653, 0.042715296149253845, 0.0348631925880909, -0.053080663084983826, -0.020244328305125237, -0.046354666352272034, -0.0010821039322763681, 0.0523020476102829, -0.05986109375953674, -0.0816209688782692, -0.03167162463068962, -0.044009629637002945, 0.0048010079190135, -0.031049232929944992, -0.0012737053912132978, -0.02045411802828312, -0.05852743983268738, -0.019414717331528664, -0.06769097596406937, 0.1011296883225441, 0.07159984111785889, -0.027739208191633224, -0.04617667943239212, -0.015338882803916931, 0.06352420896291733, -0.022573459893465042, 0.01571386680006981, -0.05875270441174507, 0.03187325969338417, -0.014376848936080933, -0.014274563640356064, -0.021190259605646133, -0.0114007368683815, 0.07330509275197983, 0.0020978786051273346, 0.058992043137550354, -0.06659513711929321, -0.0018427742179483175, 0.010470699518918991, -0.01702728308737278, -0.006620017811655998, 0.0003801965794991702, -0.01569458283483982, -0.008661954663693905, 0.03065839223563671, 0.05040035396814346, -0.0272628553211689, -0.02840781956911087, -0.013238887302577496, -0.006047684233635664, 0.011833996511995792, 0.04554624855518341, -0.024375202134251595, 0.001159132574684918, -0.000031496139854425564, 0.03279787302017212, 0.04808015003800392, 0.005710608791559935, 0.011010157875716686, -0.05446972697973251, -0.01860363781452179, 0.0914153903722763, -0.04145022854208946, -0.012589853256940842, -0.019677216187119484, 0.04335557296872139, 0.009029530920088291, 0.021740078926086426, -0.002559623448178172, 0.046769168227910995, 0.023551980033516884, -0.006453791633248329, 0.059668730944395065, -0.07368224114179611, 0.04611945524811745, -0.016090504825115204, -0.005235863849520683, -0.05861818417906761, -0.05240437015891075, 0.018447956070303917, 0.0037543203216046095, 0.0039583477191627026, 0.049027230590581894, 0.052721962332725525, -0.02414579875767231, -0.038830194622278214, 0.03361991420388222, 0.021401483565568924, -0.0339287593960762, 0.00065666000591591, 0.03327232599258423, 0.04732367396354675, 0.0036151704844087362, 0.04315527528524399, -0.046656399965286255, 0.03385087475180626, -0.025765132158994675, -0.03351181000471115, -0.028600914403796196, 0.013257886283099651, 0.024603525176644325, 0.0007270064088515937, 0.00566847762092948, -0.042527079582214355, 0.0670536607503891, 0.04797443374991417, -0.01847514696419239, 0.005194598343223333, -0.06127817928791046, -0.03915092721581459, 0.043116722255945206, 0.06627646833658218, -0.006898730527609587, 0.013944038189947605, 0.010185264982283115, -0.003561886725947261, 0.015842149034142494, 0.01137748546898365, -0.009097308851778507, 0.02594846859574318, 0.004319553263485432, -0.07280733436346054, 0.016931768506765366, 0.015628911554813385, 0.04162931069731712, 0.014478171244263649, -0.03350076824426651, -0.04640289023518562, -0.03649492934346199, -0.010386639274656773, 0.007963496260344982, 0.029983224347233772, 0.03738905489444733, 0.024022454395890236, 0.028429429978132248, 0.010972228832542896, -0.00028680902323685586, 0.042780764400959015, -0.053205378353595734, -0.013255592435598373, -0.04731857031583786, 0.044195011258125305, -0.026988638564944267, 0.012919389642775059, -0.00824275054037571, -0.012839882634580135, -0.05864860489964485, 0.07938288897275925, 0.014898023568093777, 0.013575376011431217, 0.005524997133761644, -0.050120897591114044, -0.03690122067928314, -0.10439124703407288, -0.02663031592965126, 0.03416084870696068, 0.02373943105340004, 0.00867639109492302, -0.04166089743375778, 0.030088912695646286, -0.07299060374498367, 0.014905020594596863, -0.010822748765349388, -0.05256984755396843, 0.0167465228587389, -0.04414894059300423, 0.036947011947631836, -0.016699619591236115, -0.05538630113005638, -0.009471037425100803, -0.004533426836133003, 0.0008832735475152731, 0.03333338722586632, 0.0074877371080219746, -0.02615003101527691, 0.015587182715535164, 0.0027608845848590136, 0.012096663005650043, 0.01927768439054489, 0.022773008793592453, -0.03963666781783104, -0.010477865114808083, -0.03021777793765068, -0.03895166516304016, -0.026476262137293816, -0.10742645710706711, 0.056521233171224594, -0.008576548658311367, -0.09937597066164017, 0.014290589839220047, 0.04691949114203453, 0.0500689372420311, -0.03682347387075424, -0.03103112056851387, -0.014438001438975334, -0.007223146501928568, -0.009432598948478699, -0.0013214772334322333, -0.028045810759067535, 0.04074506089091301, 0.02237454615533352, 0.020586494356393814, -0.001565941027365625, 0.04556058719754219, 0.04358383268117905, 0.06604629009962082, -0.06170755997300148, 0.06092007830739021, 0.008750256150960922, -0.03021007589995861, -0.0887860655784607, 0.03608190640807152, -0.0017923763953149319, -0.04066162556409836, -0.09879764914512634, -0.03476012870669365, -0.02350008673965931, -0.040612444281578064, -0.03185804560780525, 0.00503600062802434, 0.02880379930138588, -0.035977475345134735, 0.016877006739377975, 0.01756032183766365, 0.014862957410514355, -0.014197045937180519, 0.027706457301974297, -0.02799849770963192, 0.02804863452911377, 0.011468828655779362, -0.017559625208377838, -0.03477058932185173, 0.00021898536942899227, 0.01753840036690235, -0.057707399129867554, 0.04634161293506622, -0.012055709026753902, -0.022843187674880028, 0.052639253437519073, 0.026349762454628944, 0.030906036496162415, -0.005405856762081385, 0.0413375161588192, -0.013475384563207626, -0.036158908158540726, 0.014439661987125874, 0.0037338242400437593, 0.005375553388148546, -0.04288381338119507, -0.011895425617694855, 0.015770860016345978, 0.03686889261007309, -0.03267832472920418, 0.02310691587626934, 0.009655473753809929, 0.016824427992105484, -0.024023959413170815, -0.03688671812415123, 0.05732027441263199, 0.07499029487371445, 0.030409300699830055, -0.08991038054227829, 0.008510776795446873, 0.021618377417325974, 0.01676442101597786, 0.00026414653984829783, 0.01367876771837473, 0.013397766277194023, -0.012262603268027306, 0.045290056616067886, -0.014010653831064701, 0.014016710221767426, -0.005517351906746626, 0.013049138709902763, 0.07350543141365051, 0.03299511596560478, -0.010989472270011902, -0.037479571998119354, -0.0922735184431076, 0.08256356418132782, 0.07818979024887085, -0.01720135286450386, -0.022547150030732155, -0.03508361801505089, -0.02802630513906479, -0.08343812078237534, 0.00315195438452065, -0.054990459233522415, 0.0006757796509191394, -0.07556676119565964, 0.054963335394859314, 0.021532217040657997, 0.04869868606328964, 0.02813146449625492, -0.014399680308997631, 0.017050093039870262, 0.041654422879219055, 0.011782418936491013, -0.01670028828084469, -0.056986965239048004, 0.0012814514338970184, -0.006980391684919596, -0.012510321103036404, -0.04448004439473152, 0.04820158705115318, -0.07696613669395447, -0.047019410878419876, 0.019355356693267822, -0.08074826002120972, 0.07205656915903091, 0.029459618031978607, 0.015543720684945583, -0.03976527601480484, -0.0072223469614982605, -0.06691570580005646, 0.034854333847761154, 0.06232733651995659, -0.06534633785486221, 0.035372354090213776, -0.061906084418296814, -0.06988523155450821, 0.02307140827178955, -0.018625322729349136, 0.007198450155556202, 0.024262484163045883, -0.02863316424190998, -0.01639219932258129, 0.03698118403553963, 0.054293371737003326, 0.04661865904927254 ]
<p>We all know that when we say A it sounds different than when we say B. I was wondering what exactly can be the difference between saying A and B in terms of physics. I first thought that it may due to difference in the combination of frequencies. Then I realized I can say any alphabet in many different tones. </p> <p>So what exactly in terms of physics is the difference between saying A and B ?</p>
g4033
[ 0.043385833501815796, 0.02128148451447487, 0.030678464099764824, -0.053347036242485046, 0.06605426222085953, 0.010402142070233822, -0.010670245625078678, 0.03283468261361122, 0.012165190652012825, 0.0032662469893693924, 0.04108976572751999, 0.015409938991069794, -0.043458543717861176, 0.05135950818657875, 0.008159019984304905, -0.02680078148841858, -0.009001664817333221, -0.06192556768655777, 0.05365385115146637, 0.007932147942483425, 0.03679032251238823, 0.04346030205488205, -0.021989790722727776, -0.024669911712408066, -0.02805347926914692, -0.05895226076245308, -0.010226880200207233, -0.0627744197845459, -0.03706297650933266, -0.07153815776109695, -0.016258714720606804, -0.021767375990748405, 0.040571656078100204, 0.029292577877640724, -0.036934830248355865, -0.0421375147998333, 0.0014647835632786155, 0.007600791286677122, 0.011934181675314903, 0.032513998448848724, 0.021901829168200493, 0.03383911773562431, -0.013956751674413681, -0.024985937401652336, 0.047857336699962616, 0.005692342296242714, -0.022107595577836037, -0.011804413050413132, -0.02332933247089386, 0.02598237618803978, 0.008740413002669811, -0.01628047414124012, 0.028565237298607826, 0.05242181941866875, 0.051373470574617386, -0.01514215487986803, 0.0616588220000267, 0.036423783749341965, 0.05533194541931152, 0.032513439655303955, -0.01646733283996582, 0.06919213384389877, -0.013580210506916046, 0.027903996407985687, 0.03908153250813484, -0.027642827481031418, -0.01099790632724762, -0.03217490389943123, 0.011053458787500858, 0.00898076593875885, 0.030121127143502235, -0.08979243785142899, 0.00014143352746032178, -0.00938650593161583, -0.058497726917266846, -0.012161771766841412, -0.02204779163002968, -0.03293333202600479, 0.013599391095340252, 0.10551656782627106, 0.0002531181671656668, 0.001324018812738359, 0.09272556006908417, 0.043481990694999695, 0.015011869370937347, 0.013877038843929768, -0.01899629831314087, 0.013589487411081791, -0.011154785752296448, 0.03946202993392944, 0.026175078004598618, -0.0774913802742958, 0.046649567782878876, 0.08828803896903992, -0.037323884665966034, -0.029542339965701103, -0.0660281851887703, 0.0646369457244873, -0.008895695209503174, 0.056812990456819534, -0.000378149765310809, 0.033752311021089554, 0.0732426643371582, -0.014957660809159279, 0.01528626773506403, -0.03440298140048981, -0.00745991850271821, -0.02581494301557541, -0.0748353973031044, 0.01455677393823862, -0.013205249793827534, -0.0012936884304508567, 0.022135259583592415, -0.06302917003631592, -0.0830443799495697, -0.012724315747618675, -0.02601018361747265, -0.0389292873442173, -0.023182513192296028, 0.005722247064113617, 0.030871711671352386, -0.01811515912413597, -0.023939305916428566, 0.0008585024625062943, -0.03397200256586075, -0.009171840734779835, 0.002696856390684843, -0.039450641721487045, 0.03616064414381981, -0.02350025810301304, 0.03549620136618614, 0.030214907601475716, 0.024092383682727814, -0.0036704670637845993, 0.003784037195146084, 0.00248729158192873, 0.056579090654850006, -0.0018360801041126251, 0.05851224437355995, -0.04049380123615265, 0.02608378604054451, -0.004291813354939222, 0.03569366782903671, -0.054358165711164474, -0.03800615668296814, -0.0216081403195858, -0.03800063952803612, -0.017438219860196114, 0.007974307984113693, 0.06871013343334198, -0.011011648923158646, 0.042150579392910004, 0.050521474331617355, -0.015585087239742279, -0.00047696949332021177, 0.03084373287856579, 0.03225002437829971, 0.09953044354915619, -0.014183582738041878, 0.02149781584739685, 0.06709303706884384, -0.009326247498393059, -0.0003462602326180786, 0.032705679535865784, -0.06178439408540726, 0.005369374994188547, -0.030161410570144653, -0.062269359827041626, 0.011621585115790367, -0.004683014005422592, -0.04434794560074806, 0.02492467686533928, 0.002790963975712657, 0.06442383676767349, 0.03472878783941269, 0.08855325728654861, 0.010715358890593052, -0.017868313938379288, -0.0034206307027488947, -0.0012743518454954028, 0.0064465319737792015, 0.011589129455387592, -0.0033081548754125834, -0.021560199558734894, -0.018654337152838707, 0.04125329852104187, -0.01678616553544998, -0.026230795308947563, -0.059063076972961426, 0.026084551587700844, -0.07638213038444519, -0.06931551545858383, -0.03925617039203644, -0.04245823249220848, -0.019009126350283623, -0.04830597713589668, -0.03416449949145317, 0.046534158289432526, -0.00712565379217267, 0.04225987195968628, 0.03869502991437912, 0.02045215293765068, 0.03719543293118477, -0.03374941647052765, 0.017942238599061966, 0.030428986996412277, -0.07429990917444229, 0.03172999247908592, -0.007020748220384121, -0.0078824982047081, 0.025619884952902794, 0.020434357225894928, 0.04479561746120453, -0.009984024800360203, 0.05604430288076401, 0.01600717194378376, 0.041522618383169174, -0.053343433886766434, -0.017143504694104195, 0.001805513515137136, 0.010703359730541706, -0.0522422194480896, -0.006373223848640919, 0.007672411389648914, -0.016486994922161102, -0.00011601903679547831, -0.04215322434902191, -0.0005736970924772322, 0.004910631570965052, 0.01853371411561966, 0.007464373018592596, -0.038428548723459244, 0.01622840389609337, -0.04954613000154495, -0.006708956323564053, 0.054603103548288345, 0.056214429438114166, -0.05758417770266533, -0.017894575372338295, 0.00927269272506237, -0.01818392053246498, -0.013171735219657421, -0.007927238009870052, 0.0694691464304924, -0.029788481071591377, -0.024984512478113174, 0.02144337259232998, -0.01244276575744152, -0.00600570859387517, 0.006155769340693951, 0.00776472594588995, -0.03148173540830612, -0.046329740434885025, -0.04024290293455124, 0.018369821831583977, 0.009924152866005898, 0.0012881987495347857, 0.01695946976542473, -0.03344806283712387, -0.06271874159574509, 0.02100500464439392, -0.05075022950768471, 0.009117994457483292, 0.012461631558835506, -0.01194055937230587, 0.023333270102739334, -0.024635745212435722, -0.0036411064211279154, -0.021472947672009468, 0.010334567166864872, -0.025935225188732147, 0.03037758730351925, 0.010301976464688778, -0.05692039057612419, -0.047998495399951935, 0.00801136251538992, -0.00002886794027290307, -0.02754940651357174, 0.04683749005198479, -0.06348426640033722, -0.041528720408678055, 0.040814876556396484, -0.025557275861501694, -0.004512494895607233, 0.023525672033429146, 0.023950105533003807, 0.029261430725455284, -0.04647256061434746, -0.05440051108598709, 0.015182705596089363, -0.030048685148358345, 0.023681554943323135, 0.03257013112306595, -0.03811633959412575, -0.021241268143057823, 0.08167216181755066, 0.043121337890625, -0.03497854620218277, -0.016069134697318077, -0.03202808275818825, 0.041637059301137924, 0.016573641449213028, 0.0024125995114445686, 0.03684614226222038, 0.0011554394150152802, 0.06967058777809143, -0.030982809141278267, -0.01737513206899166, 0.01175622083246708, -0.011042593978345394, -0.03387053310871124, 0.02327224425971508, 0.05795157328248024, -0.009640059433877468, -0.0060117109678685665, -0.012694204226136208, 0.0379156768321991, 0.023672670125961304, 0.03447829931974411, 0.017605187371373177, -0.027634581550955772, -0.018904970958828926, 0.03018207848072052, 0.006232237443327904, -0.011236456222832203, -0.007688232231885195, 0.004769010003656149, 0.019385453313589096, -0.04619985818862915, -0.05831940844655037, -0.09796185791492462, 0.001512364950031042, -0.06459254771471024, -0.008582143113017082, 0.00019139787764288485, 0.05473389849066734, 0.028076542541384697, -0.05484743043780327, 0.00469124736264348, 0.025303682312369347, 0.12610895931720734, -0.03236040845513344, -0.006328764371573925, 0.0425071157515049, -0.0035463920794427395, 0.07284940779209137, -0.0033658375032246113, -0.012525085359811783, -0.019259238615632057, -0.01231971476227045, 0.03545403480529785, -0.0177450068295002, 0.01797257363796234, 0.006582270376384258, 0.019171258434653282, 0.005936756264418364, 0.033267684280872345, -0.016356825828552246, -0.02951325662434101, -0.007420371752232313, -0.01257884968072176, -0.013011408038437366, 0.04759381338953972, 0.02416609786450863, -0.017241381108760834, 0.0040002139285206795, 0.00015509972581639886, 0.04218360409140587, -0.005911750718951225, -0.010479903779923916, -0.0081408666446805, -0.024438658729195595, -0.00972374901175499, -0.005702791269868612, 0.009779004380106926, -0.075216144323349, -0.01224600151181221, -0.03126459941267967, 0.005424406845122576, -0.0027102974709123373, -0.007386107463389635, 0.056765858083963394, 0.05747101828455925, -0.010031672194600105, 0.011112214997410774, -0.0990251675248146, 0.02020961046218872, 0.014221208170056343, 0.002660693833604455, -0.05760696902871132, 0.007514814380556345, 0.0010789562948048115, -0.048842258751392365, 0.0035453501623123884, -0.006931015755981207, 0.007905331440269947, -0.022437188774347305, 0.017948897555470467, 0.005312682595103979, 0.07861163467168808, -0.04893635958433151, -0.0077919126488268375, 0.023284971714019775, -0.018177200108766556, 0.015022574923932552, -0.043188001960515976, 0.07780709117650986, -0.021215423941612244, -0.04061879217624664, -0.02654736489057541, -0.030010996386408806, -0.014921316877007484, 0.0007715370738878846, -0.02674129046499729, -0.03686504065990448, 0.06488294154405594, 0.019320014864206314, 0.0016500611091032624, 0.06863904744386673, 0.046048812568187714, 0.02182483673095703, 0.06787983328104019, -0.008811399340629578, -0.029503341764211655, -0.0014110213378444314, 0.025947924703359604, 0.015383640304207802, 0.05309242382645607, 0.014885817654430866, 0.04640519991517067, 0.027345875278115273, -0.02099827118217945, -0.02176656760275364, 0.040593694895505905, -0.0435987189412117, 0.025117257609963417, -0.01584690250456333, -0.0042747319675982, 0.08118315041065216, -0.014709943905472755, 0.06152360886335373, -0.027131563052535057, -0.0267551988363266, -0.016955208033323288, 0.03807131201028824, 0.005477791652083397, 0.025516759604215622, -0.04278968274593353, -0.033334724605083466, 0.013050345703959465, -0.05327540263533592, 0.0364525280892849, -0.0192334596067667, -0.0554395467042923, -0.004487229976803064, 0.029804270714521408, 0.0022790217772126198, -0.002054299460723996, 0.01744171604514122, -0.02369117923080921, 0.004858053755015135, -0.0013102804077789187, 0.026166660711169243, -0.0023876770865172148, -0.018413005396723747, 0.002069836249575019, 0.005648372694849968, -0.04277826473116875, -0.06886932253837585, -0.0018246305407956243, 0.021810384467244148, -0.03153052181005478, -0.019318073987960815, 0.053407587110996246, 0.058215998113155365, -0.017863070592284203, -0.02165592461824417, -0.019017966464161873, -0.05117142200469971, -0.04563719406723976, -0.015849119052290916, -0.02206149883568287, -0.002526514697819948, 0.017595063894987106, -0.039930764585733414, -0.006287852302193642, -0.028780341148376465, -0.008116735145449638, -0.016398712992668152, -0.01892778091132641, 0.05329032614827156, 0.0686122477054596, 0.04266244173049927, -0.004409107379615307, -0.06769794970750809, -0.04735107719898224, -0.026201054453849792, 0.0004095484036952257, -0.022509686648845673, 0.025791849941015244, -0.05046570673584938, 0.016111399978399277, 0.03539310395717621, -0.02467324398458004, 0.014024179428815842, 0.04628193750977516, 0.047784145921468735, 0.03936596214771271, -0.01376517303287983, 0.06046276167035103, -0.007881750352680683, -0.02974243275821209, -0.0074036139994859695, 0.04417765885591507, 0.042245764285326004, 0.02689366042613983, 0.047252632677555084, 0.0027950077783316374, 0.01577608287334442, -0.027388114482164383, -0.014568052254617214, -0.04277268424630165, 0.04527140408754349, -0.0016879210015758872, 0.01152312383055687, -0.011657152324914932, -0.02707059495151043, -0.04375532269477844, 0.011154302395880222, -0.0032186543103307486, 0.0016566907288506627, 0.05423922836780548, 0.032835088670253754, -0.025479046627879143, -0.027783526107668877, -0.06586962938308716, -0.0014691523974761367, -0.028244102373719215, -0.014197339303791523, 0.05321439355611801, -0.06404920667409897, 0.023000242188572884, -0.030336275696754456, 0.1142214834690094, 0.012325083836913109, -0.030676988884806633, 0.003958019893616438, -0.015957532450556755, -0.017262130975723267, 0.015247206203639507, -0.06659594923257828, -0.00474914675578475, -0.05422360450029373, 0.009945293888449669, 0.01931694522500038, 0.04362286999821663, -0.0794701874256134, 0.022825317457318306, 0.03114154189825058, 0.01738099753856659, -0.015658633783459663, 0.019310954958200455, 0.009434436447918415, -0.06630458682775497, -0.006270526442676783, -0.04632096737623215, -0.01843971386551857, -0.03969603031873703, 0.024158887565135956, 0.04307479038834572, 0.025850150734186172, -0.020597634837031364, -0.06522757560014725, 0.04357399046421051, 0.016293715685606003, 0.03156908228993416, -0.04026401787996292, -0.05505654588341713, -0.0067355516366660595, 0.009192298166453838, -0.05600898340344429, -0.015491517260670662, -0.019695095717906952, 0.029403451830148697, -0.07088778167963028, 0.02799672819674015, -0.006613956764340401, 0.044658537954092026, 0.02567432075738907, 0.030031640082597733, 0.003966121003031731, -0.046097636222839355, -0.05619027093052864, 0.002818278269842267, -0.04050204157829285, -0.028996605426073074, -0.03141338750720024, -0.005333803594112396, 0.017466841265559196, 0.026589524000883102, 0.04526213929057121, -0.006770450156182051, 0.05438407510519028, -0.012777666561305523, -0.03508642688393593, 0.08500629663467407, -0.04869376868009567, 0.0008765518432483077, 0.01829099841415882, -0.02549835853278637, -0.0075695449486374855, 0.02922314777970314, 0.04441136121749878, 0.02236991375684738, 0.009012931026518345, -0.01016342081129551, -0.011352852918207645, -0.009071051143109798, 0.02038075588643551, 0.003538195276632905, 0.013474992476403713, 0.009344377554953098, -0.029920421540737152, -0.07115178555250168, 0.07513723522424698, 0.03681245818734169, -0.013342561200261116, 0.04489000141620636, 0.00927900243550539, -0.054701145738363266, -0.022878900170326233, -0.027981018647551537, 0.013214859180152416, 0.07757338136434555, -0.004075389821082354, 0.028114333748817444, -0.03673644736409187, 0.013623839244246483, -0.02445968985557556, 0.036533307284116745, 0.013378853909671307, 0.002634986536577344, 0.05953687056899071, 0.08192362636327744, -0.015559461899101734, 0.0022942163050174713, -0.03478402644395828, -0.04952165484428406, -0.06562701612710953, -0.006031592842191458, -0.032538872212171555, -0.004828725941479206, -0.05051647871732712, 0.024554366245865822, -0.001958173932507634, 0.034835267812013626, 0.039618249982595444, 0.03485424444079399, 0.024791782721877098, -0.04946053400635719, -0.01726689748466015, -0.03241604566574097, -0.007697926368564367, 0.023323820903897285, 0.037542570382356644, 0.054233696311712265, 0.008854940533638, -0.08842889964580536, 0.002904267981648445, 0.04174945503473282, -0.007469194009900093, -0.01856398582458496, -0.010480199009180069, -0.01588134653866291, 0.02044280804693699, -0.0032570911571383476, -0.011968984268605709, -0.05061279609799385, -0.042943477630615234, -0.04018289968371391, 0.03708764538168907, -0.015492559410631657, 0.010202469304203987, 0.004033021628856659, -0.023496748879551888, 0.017889568582177162, -0.035595960915088654, 0.08619681745767593, 0.05276770144701004, -0.03850333020091057, 0.03478378802537918, -0.04463522881269455, -0.015628421679139137, -0.05100465565919876, -0.0016630139434710145, -0.024891799315810204, 0.05295133963227272, 0.053469616919755936, -0.02085776813328266, -0.02751765586435795, 0.056341152638196945, -0.00816652923822403, 0.02350117638707161, -0.025559721514582634, -0.010103615932166576, 0.0073785665445029736, 0.05069331079721451, 0.042297229170799255, -0.03660215809941292, -0.06378167867660522, 0.008714159019291401, -0.01885467767715454, 0.07090646028518677, 0.047229520976543427, -0.005994504317641258, -0.003824313636869192, -0.03522422909736633, 0.003408918622881174, -0.025238385424017906, -0.02553849294781685, 0.002473947126418352, -0.01355232484638691, -0.01879437081515789, -0.07919582724571228, -0.010280190967023373, 0.00487926509231329, 0.061583638191223145, -0.025606032460927963, -0.048220884054899216, -0.0029224155005067587, 0.010640498250722885, 0.018545305356383324, 0.01564447022974491, 0.01484119612723589, -0.004879215732216835, 0.0016435562865808606, 0.044137142598629, 0.009433467872440815, -0.04112530127167702, -0.05734371393918991, 0.005690869875252247, 0.026874123141169548, 0.009242023341357708, 0.009518146514892578, 0.004195352550595999, 0.008242418058216572, -0.04856986179947853, 0.09377168864011765, 0.04924224317073822, -0.05853024497628212, -0.05674371123313904, 0.020032521337270737, -0.02742459811270237, 0.08414997160434723, -0.010688805021345615, 0.029128510504961014, -0.0012854182859882712, 0.0036963503807783127, 0.03953135386109352, -0.048172686249017715, -0.02087109535932541, 0.08520486950874329, 0.015039944089949131, -0.03710707649588585, -0.03854922950267792, -0.033787764608860016, -0.02933036908507347, -0.050155285745859146 ]
<p>Is it correct that the number of lines originating from vertices on Feynman diagrams is equal to the order of phi in interaction lagrangian for scalar field?</p>
g4034
[ 0.045487672090530396, 0.013559306971728802, -0.0026173272635787725, -0.04372703656554222, 0.06998362392187119, -0.006215611007064581, 0.02195366472005844, -0.0008963362197391689, -0.00750151788815856, -0.016545936465263367, -0.004533018916845322, 0.050054579973220825, -0.010655094869434834, 0.024947727099061012, -0.02402324415743351, 0.018758166581392288, 0.03315087407827377, 0.005177483428269625, -0.021685082465410233, 0.013740664348006248, -0.08189759403467178, -0.0005087762838229537, -0.013011080212891102, -0.004468343686312437, 0.03936683386564255, -0.044346921145915985, 0.023930666968226433, -0.019397985190153122, -0.04178915545344353, -0.044323038309812546, 0.0012520531890913844, 0.041485365480184555, 0.01999804936349392, -0.06011410802602768, -0.07456440478563309, -0.0050214435905218124, 0.021214298903942108, 0.003442967077717185, 0.03569774702191353, -0.0032120735850185156, -0.012448673136532307, -0.02524818852543831, 0.045234616845846176, 0.00149344012606889, -0.04265916347503662, 0.0018317491048946977, -0.03364924341440201, 0.04345553368330002, -0.017506945878267288, 0.009293213486671448, 0.01076318696141243, 0.03915135934948921, 0.024781247600913048, -0.03439134359359741, -0.025739550590515137, 0.12579572200775146, 0.015084720216691494, -0.01575840637087822, 0.029673175886273384, 0.09209152311086655, 0.016677547246217728, -0.011025888845324516, 0.017809204757213593, 0.0056338831782341, 0.04239965230226517, 0.04040038213133812, -0.021780870854854584, -0.01984861120581627, 0.00618135929107666, 0.0033516138792037964, -0.05141180008649826, -0.10736941546201706, 0.02077925018966198, -0.004018423613160849, 0.026630863547325134, 0.05774390697479248, -0.017995987087488174, -0.053982045501470566, 0.038435690104961395, -0.006238721311092377, -0.05979786068201065, -0.03507716953754425, -0.023548010736703873, 0.05144037678837776, 0.14468687772750854, -0.009629391133785248, 0.03267011046409607, -0.0542277954518795, -0.03907819464802742, 0.037847600877285004, 0.018913425505161285, 0.023376815021038055, 0.0077517395839095116, 0.012350684963166714, -0.038006268441677094, -0.01581553742289543, 0.019767409190535545, -0.024449748918414116, -0.008222621865570545, -0.06809335947036743, -0.05057503283023834, -0.010577251203358173, -0.00018515769625082612, -0.04477699473500252, -0.017352016642689705, 0.017303816974163055, -0.005094755440950394, -0.016239004209637642, 0.043658092617988586, -0.0027904848102480173, -0.03429631143808365, 0.011897284537553787, -0.022079411894083023, 0.010257731191813946, -0.026506178081035614, 0.005366925615817308, 0.05130723863840103, -0.030282197520136833, -0.025077659636735916, 0.06890635192394257, 0.03845996782183647, -0.0250010434538126, 0.036056481301784515, 0.042529575526714325, 0.03870364651083946, -0.023077944293618202, -0.030511561781167984, -0.002440871438011527, 0.01819995790719986, 0.008059845305979252, -0.026457713916897774, -0.032343581318855286, 0.012267224490642548, 0.028719130903482437, -0.014875753782689571, 0.01691531389951706, 0.014447217807173729, 0.006274685729295015, 0.03178495168685913, -0.035558681935071945, -0.017539605498313904, -0.02248828299343586, -0.00704935472458601, -0.13537535071372986, -0.011231259442865849, 0.0051040430553257465, 0.0293556060642004, -0.026810303330421448, 0.007154399063438177, -0.009393843822181225, 0.02024129219353199, 0.024322958663105965, -0.026693550869822502, 0.028603723272681236, -0.05927838385105133, -0.013887458480894566, -0.0010281699942424893, -0.005924632307142019, -0.0007368677179329097, -0.04478707164525986, 0.02992212027311325, -0.028570624068379402, 0.07344194501638412, -0.0030771433375775814, 0.00236072251573205, -0.005182536784559488, 0.015910374000668526, -0.054061226546764374, -0.008617853745818138, -0.036979012191295624, -0.016843903809785843, 0.026275133714079857, 0.024953598156571388, 0.015426931902766228, -0.018461421132087708, 0.06486200541257858, -0.05995648726820946, 0.0021240082569420338, 0.0670357346534729, 0.03673144429922104, -0.0042213392443954945, -0.04242756590247154, 0.0166852418333292, -0.00034730511833913624, -0.010104639455676079, 0.009881400503218174, -0.017966914921998978, 0.07088305801153183, -0.02360932156443596, -0.0037892148829996586, 0.003952563274651766, 0.044230520725250244, -0.0609947070479393, 0.030066633597016335, 0.05509018525481224, 0.012754123657941818, 0.018923982977867126, -0.042170554399490356, -0.00882926769554615, -0.0727778971195221, -0.001324987388215959, 0.018755655735731125, 0.003937028348445892, 0.0020728837698698044, -0.05628342926502228, 0.047907523810863495, -0.011572470888495445, -0.015368000604212284, 0.05295785889029503, -0.004423940554261208, 0.02183484099805355, -0.005542634520679712, 0.0067030456848442554, 0.05205734074115753, -0.022678684443235397, -0.052603889256715775, 0.039024412631988525, 0.021877629682421684, 0.04542647674679756, 0.03532905876636505, -0.004631339572370052, 0.04135695472359657, 0.02393139712512493, -0.023180922493338585, 0.006618302781134844, 0.00393366115167737, 0.033136993646621704, -0.009573178365826607, -0.06656830757856369, -0.01980922557413578, -0.08459414541721344, -0.03170927241444588, -0.04169193655252457, -0.04413221403956413, 0.019521327689290047, -0.030560528859496117, -0.020153792575001717, -0.01817444898188114, -0.00029826286481693387, 0.025242457166314125, 0.04562116414308548, -0.015450950711965561, 0.008007210679352283, -0.001643056864850223, 0.05109427124261856, 0.03771192952990532, 0.029993603006005287, 0.012203849852085114, -0.08505147695541382, 0.05496687814593315, 0.01807757467031479, 0.005905192345380783, -0.029530877247452736, 0.050805069506168365, -0.017918661236763, -0.019991649314761162, 0.03993644937872887, 0.022375259548425674, 0.014532855711877346, -0.03229789063334465, -0.031354501843452454, -0.009647831320762634, -0.03462930768728256, 0.018078967928886414, -0.040526218712329865, -0.023677382618188858, 0.0031119685154408216, -0.016000865027308464, -0.0030697498004883528, -0.048096708953380585, -0.049396052956581116, 0.06931169331073761, 0.021998045966029167, 0.027222443372011185, 0.026426449418067932, -0.015283124521374702, 0.007520283106714487, 0.001722815097309649, 0.02925644814968109, -0.023602284491062164, 0.014113940298557281, -0.0641377866268158, -0.016651682555675507, 0.035498958081007004, 0.0634976327419281, -0.029481295496225357, -0.03020535409450531, -0.04728894308209419, -0.04320213198661804, 0.07678896188735962, 0.018063945695757866, -0.014468200504779816, 0.014421443454921246, -0.03610454499721527, -0.03058744966983795, 0.02686157077550888, 0.01660275273025036, -0.034455135464668274, 0.016815422102808952, 0.03993711993098259, -0.017467739060521126, 0.01890132576227188, -0.0031810856889933348, 0.0058613927103579044, -0.0003132869314868003, -0.009238403290510178, -0.011319703422486782, -0.029762547463178635, -0.015949171036481857, -0.06122179701924324, -0.01932075060904026, -0.013221673667430878, -0.025131631642580032, 0.024286769330501556, 0.0014936989173293114, 0.020501788705587387, 0.05353478714823723, 0.046842604875564575, 0.01988750696182251, 0.01399480551481247, -0.04513431340456009, 0.02245674841105938, 0.019051259383559227, -0.01650194451212883, -0.008287179283797741, 0.015226146206259727, 0.005370135884732008, -0.0008259964524768293, 0.004973754286766052, -0.009489621967077255, 0.009348435327410698, -0.058044400066137314, 0.030797256156802177, 0.0022264206781983376, -0.029034025967121124, -0.030011937022209167, -0.08340959250926971, -0.05458860471844673, -0.007209007162600756, 0.045604974031448364, -0.0853673592209816, -0.014500564895570278, -0.06915000826120377, 0.010106566362082958, 0.04011049121618271, -0.040990978479385376, -0.04187900945544243, -0.006018894724547863, -0.012862109579145908, -0.012844635173678398, 0.0033519838470965624, 0.011858716607093811, -0.0418614037334919, 0.023796211928129196, 0.01315941009670496, -0.05247359350323677, -0.03138815239071846, 0.03677254170179367, -0.005590624641627073, 0.0320267416536808, 0.05957603082060814, 0.024324677884578705, -0.019336789846420288, -0.005208621732890606, -0.027195563539862633, 0.004275811370462179, -0.07833655178546906, 0.08456975221633911, 0.07432466745376587, -0.0357515774667263, 0.011750035919249058, -0.048179350793361664, 0.0009572234703227878, 0.024886419996619225, 0.024276459589600563, 0.015626927837729454, 0.0016896147280931473, -0.0064740427769720554, -0.01493134442716837, 0.04069885239005089, -0.04814126342535019, -0.006710025481879711, -0.03885294497013092, -0.017239881679415703, 0.040194809436798096, 0.024338798597455025, 0.005482871551066637, -0.004447521176189184, -0.05325135588645935, -0.028927098959684372, -0.0017473956104367971, -0.003976978827267885, -0.00894683226943016, 0.014710239134728909, -0.012258847244083881, -0.018592605367302895, 0.021423259750008583, 0.09875424951314926, -0.0014526937156915665, 0.05288754403591156, 0.03577367961406708, -0.0037589913699775934, -0.018648415803909302, -0.018769893795251846, 0.03360016644001007, -0.01771949790418148, 0.02806694246828556, 0.04015142470598221, 0.0550188273191452, -0.05601460859179497, -0.0036635976284742355, -0.012176291085779667, 0.03165478631854057, -0.04637368023395538, 0.06389326602220535, -0.007501582615077496, -0.050224460661411285, -0.04844782501459122, -0.03529839217662811, -0.029788540676236153, 0.03409431129693985, -0.002913733711466193, 0.038967158645391464, 0.026790650561451912, 0.01670091226696968, 0.03716255724430084, -0.01595045067369938, 0.02735697291791439, -0.06446624547243118, -0.007629989646375179, -0.020335180684924126, -0.0019131769658997655, -0.021031638607382774, -0.02479279600083828, -0.08772873133420944, 0.008837354369461536, -0.03911580890417099, 0.06593907624483109, -0.00309873279184103, 0.0704847052693367, 0.0013142020907253027, 0.014807136729359627, 0.005518130026757717, -0.027854356914758682, 0.03497787192463875, -0.025922255590558052, -0.04899885505437851, -0.051046792417764664, -0.02226695418357849, 0.001188609516248107, -0.029144981876015663, -0.03411629796028137, 0.0020211541559547186, -0.004074022639542818, 0.07201129198074341, -0.0328805036842823, -0.01380934938788414, 0.04233839362859726, -0.010597064159810543, 0.02053697407245636, -0.012776787392795086, 0.008345930837094784, -0.04891452565789223, -0.004531898535788059, 0.05953451246023178, 0.0008931816555559635, -0.07477527111768723, 0.03896315023303032, -0.04825897514820099, -0.009993231855332851, 0.04846718907356262, -0.0185148473829031, 0.07012554258108139, -0.024600466713309288, -0.011915873736143112, -0.013412811793386936, -0.028093857690691948, 0.031494248658418655, -0.04961710795760155, -0.053787387907505035, -0.02741239033639431, -0.01607339456677437, -0.01420990563929081, -0.006806580349802971, -0.007993259467184544, 0.031014459207654, 0.005125740077346563, -0.007900955155491829, -0.0038258174899965525, -0.03915148228406906, 0.016756093129515648, -0.0003155003651045263, -0.00679174205288291, 0.05947760120034218, -0.009588053449988365, -0.042907629162073135, -0.010363361798226833, -0.0669798031449318, 0.040680550038814545, 0.033909887075424194, -0.009290894493460655, 0.02715257555246353, -0.03088761866092682, -0.04775070399045944, -0.08704409748315811, 0.0609164796769619, 0.05068621784448624, -0.01155635342001915, -0.019380396232008934, 0.005439207423478365, -0.02498285286128521, -0.006383098196238279, 0.06115835905075073, 0.053461648523807526, -0.06862064450979233, -0.006279414985328913, 0.011810936965048313, -0.02517383173108101, -0.017917940393090248, 0.04732296243309975, 0.1061716377735138, 0.010848312638700008, 0.0007098644273355603, -0.06572618335485458, -0.018407510593533516, 0.03402869403362274, -0.023880332708358765, -0.019928665831685066, 0.045508865267038345, 0.000853763660416007, -0.006205200217664242, 0.060370251536369324, -0.05108020827174187, 0.0528249554336071, 0.018407883122563362, -0.07523889094591141, 0.010303184390068054, 0.021451544016599655, 0.08475526422262192, 0.027606312185525894, -0.01029543112963438, -0.018725818023085594, -0.021175680682063103, 0.009919354692101479, 0.057215649634599686, 0.05885389447212219, -0.010525810532271862, -0.024920346215367317, 0.008285361342132092, -0.02029476873576641, -0.021404385566711426, 0.012694383040070534, 0.01100307609885931, 0.03083423152565956, -0.04052147641777992, 0.050529807806015015, 0.04627043381333351, -0.005901028867810965, 0.02064359001815319, 0.04844018071889877, 0.018293257802724838, 0.018365586176514626, 0.00032467267010360956, -0.006903024856001139, -0.036308858543634415, 0.046800680458545685, -0.028561115264892578, 0.027099980041384697, -0.026061786338686943, -0.037386342883110046, 0.060827482491731644, -0.022403599694371223, -0.01907099410891533, 0.09862788021564484, 0.11168824881315231, 0.04463515430688858, 0.03211868554353714, -0.022681916132569313, -0.02083556540310383, -0.0027116609271615744, -0.03143398463726044, 0.019112661480903625, 0.0036748815327882767, -0.07291604578495026, 0.029555240646004677, 0.030068345367908478, -0.0019496219465509057, -0.03748151659965515, 0.0005527840694412589, 0.038157396018505096, 0.03782123327255249, -0.010000322945415974, -0.0006610537529923022, 0.02521071583032608, 0.03957074135541916, 0.00976543314754963, 0.022249959409236908, 0.010517668910324574, -0.00022614489716943353, 0.053376782685518265, 0.05965133011341095, 0.0017837748164311051, 0.009936287999153137, -0.03357461094856262, -0.019696209579706192, 0.00003769624527194537, -0.04951528459787369, 0.06042344495654106, -0.054752666503190994, -0.016697773709893227, 0.04933648556470871, 0.018665630370378494, -0.04120475798845291, 0.005306216888129711, 0.04796088859438896, -0.01919197477400303, 0.013912513852119446, 0.07843655347824097, -0.06942799687385559, 0.008866027928888798, -0.007593723479658365, 0.004264489281922579, -0.08647453039884567, -0.04198839142918587, -0.010352008044719696, 0.0658477172255516, -0.02155795320868492, -0.005795622710138559, -0.00648538488894701, 0.0024720432702451944, 0.04596684128046036, -0.011526078917086124, -0.010385267436504364, 0.025490853935480118, 0.06832005828619003, 0.044404663145542145, -0.01566237211227417, -0.030324898660182953, 0.023341352120041847, 0.053228896111249924, -0.013915970921516418, 0.026461193338036537, 0.078155517578125, -0.029598940163850784, 0.005978676490485668, -0.00102736905682832, -0.02278534322977066, 0.02882975898683071, -0.08162431418895721, 0.014975596219301224, 0.015503857284784317, 0.0147989047691226, -0.06543949246406555, 0.0027319712098687887, 0.004818269982933998, -0.024249013513326645, -0.025429747998714447, 0.033620115369558334, -0.0040886239148676395, -0.003189985640347004, -0.03788930922746658, -0.013994157314300537, -0.01166403479874134, -0.013573113828897476, -0.014028787612915039, 0.007413914427161217, -0.03760192543268204, -0.01768927089869976, -0.0051649766974151134, 0.0035327316727489233, -0.047413039952516556, -0.08608482033014297, -0.07890245318412781, 0.020391177386045456, -0.026667866855859756, -0.006870914716273546, 0.0414511039853096, -0.0023921041283756495, -0.012107876129448414, 0.04609837010502815, 0.013499269261956215, 0.0221865251660347, 0.01527440082281828, -0.03010980226099491, -0.027534132823348045, -0.005281157325953245, -0.020977428182959557, -0.006255351006984711, -0.014901543036103249, 0.017400573939085007, 0.02958734706044197, -0.01669677533209324, -0.06784434616565704, -0.055304188281297684, 0.018574131652712822, -0.01618940941989422, -0.00240970472805202, 0.033933062106370926, 0.012546448968350887, 0.0646946057677269, 0.05411894991993904, 0.014057937078177929, -0.04213172569870949, -0.008554146625101566, 0.020089643076062202, 0.036247000098228455, 0.015501467511057854, 0.03315604105591774, 0.0014629191718995571, -0.028973164036870003, -0.017253141850233078, 0.03764950856566429, 0.02562626078724861, 0.09015744179487228, 0.046582888811826706, 0.04601329565048218, -0.024197297170758247, -0.009371028281748295, 0.05918564647436142, -0.03451920300722122, 0.009829194284975529, 0.024177586659789085, -0.04736371710896492, -0.047460149973630905, -0.009550527669489384, -0.032057058066129684, 0.03157902881503105, 0.052456099539995193, 0.0022114450111985207, 0.03515135869383812, -0.010189531370997429, -0.05705876275897026, -0.02728411555290222, 0.05195731669664383, -0.03965350240468979, -0.03708980605006218, -0.007059610448777676, -0.05229287967085838, 0.06325919181108475, -0.06906484812498093, 0.01952536776661873, -0.004725548904389143, 0.024919146671891212, -0.03164690360426903, -0.016009431332349777, -0.02742769569158554, -0.04054340347647667, -0.053608499467372894, 0.05049976333975792, 0.03782929107546806, 0.024558158591389656, -0.0006964818458072841, 0.047926656901836395, 0.007946021854877472, -0.0023478695657104254, -0.03687490150332451, -0.02214028313755989, -0.014539885334670544, 0.006229562219232321, 0.02093757875263691, -0.010235263034701347, -0.03113464079797268, 0.05025261268019676, 0.05360160395503044, -0.04495944827795029, -0.0032720232848078012, -0.0009123863419517875, -0.01911168359220028 ]
<p>Apparently to create wormholes you need negative energy/matter. Say you had negative matter/energy, how would it be applied towards making a wormhole?</p>
g4035
[ -0.004668345674872398, 0.024234261363744736, 0.004809848964214325, -0.020502639934420586, 0.027924614027142525, 0.022556830197572708, -0.04261336848139763, 0.020707713440060616, -0.04482802003622055, -0.02095918543636799, 0.05437124893069267, -0.004076600540429354, 0.04199115186929703, 0.04895991086959839, -0.06839772313833237, -0.006667699199169874, 0.03634215518832207, 0.029172556474804878, 0.013492722995579243, 0.028205905109643936, -0.01155042927712202, -0.06880582123994827, -0.005643428768962622, -0.04903705045580864, -0.026465902104973793, -0.0576094388961792, -0.014230726286768913, 0.0015206817770376801, -0.013190897181630135, 0.0008230424718931317, 0.058544058352708817, -0.05096117779612541, -0.038643158972263336, -0.003941491711884737, -0.06436203420162201, -0.006449105218052864, -0.004372108727693558, 0.033986158668994904, -0.0026478020008653402, 0.026876380667090416, -0.02821393869817257, -0.03302302956581116, -0.050780560821294785, -0.030173523351550102, -0.034723564982414246, 0.06386670470237732, 0.05907115340232849, -0.023262370377779007, 0.021517371758818626, -0.03654420003294945, 0.007136537227779627, 0.04263633117079735, 0.017345016822218895, -0.04314862936735153, 0.03312523663043976, 0.020051758736371994, 0.028475511819124222, -0.03755544498562813, 0.06000431999564171, -0.008437475189566612, -0.0010120179504156113, 0.019561221823096275, 0.019803613424301147, 0.06604917347431183, 0.08402533829212189, 0.04974442720413208, -0.020112570375204086, 0.004611913114786148, -0.004884279798716307, 0.03489796444773674, 0.04025133699178696, -0.02236400730907917, -0.04877523332834244, -0.045633312314748764, 0.007460694294422865, 0.03650621324777603, 0.052953172475099564, 0.04125019162893295, -0.025808971375226974, 0.011064349673688412, -0.01055999007076025, -0.046267736703157425, 0.01687549613416195, -0.03194413334131241, 0.12182461470365524, 0.03448192775249481, -0.022569779306650162, -0.033932216465473175, 0.03153544291853905, 0.023421771824359894, 0.01813647337257862, 0.013185516931116581, 0.04979882761836052, 0.01910785585641861, 0.018086453899741173, 0.032821472734212875, -0.01485142670571804, 0.03144402429461479, -0.0491524338722229, -0.013415173627436161, 0.016922395676374435, -0.001200992614030838, 0.05519779026508331, -0.06197318807244301, -0.030115116387605667, 0.027189740911126137, -0.00804385170340538, 0.003685291623696685, 0.09741821885108948, -0.007367380429059267, -0.0352189876139164, -0.04013044014573097, -0.026619765907526016, 0.03087710775434971, 0.022709311917424202, -0.02262864261865616, 0.039922699332237244, -0.03212149441242218, 0.00785904098302126, 0.10537353157997131, -0.007442363537847996, 0.06818229705095291, -0.024574462324380875, 0.0254802443087101, -0.018363935872912407, 0.0006441655568778515, 0.014995984733104706, -0.08878207206726074, 0.00896546896547079, 0.007814660668373108, 0.08098245412111282, 0.0005761071806773543, -0.025010403245687485, -0.024119390174746513, 0.03497941419482231, 0.02185901813209057, -0.01047794334590435, -0.043930426239967346, 0.013034469448029995, 0.011550321243703365, -0.001109306002035737, -0.04389442130923271, 0.033874500542879105, 0.04133623465895653, 0.012569788843393326, -0.026730874553322792, -0.04047044366598129, 0.01730358600616455, -0.04290983825922012, 0.030952950939536095, 0.005003665573894978, 0.0495402030646801, 0.04196310415863991, -0.037180736660957336, 0.09237581491470337, 0.01622297242283821, 0.07272187620401382, 0.01788443513214588, 0.024227632209658623, 0.008623464033007622, 0.07207229733467102, -0.004760341718792915, 0.05629543587565422, 0.030185729265213013, -0.026168374344706535, -0.007154150400310755, 0.037606578320264816, -0.04351181536912918, 0.024426430463790894, 0.046836454421281815, -0.025175264105200768, -0.03118281625211239, 0.02185707539319992, -0.012931706383824348, 0.02577870897948742, 0.0627531036734581, 0.008847854100167751, -0.036815106868743896, 0.0277214664965868, -0.012412814423441887, 0.0040316153317689896, -0.02581440843641758, -0.01355529110878706, 0.00008152888040058315, 0.032660555094480515, 0.004892457742244005, 0.0040938155725598335, 0.018918121233582497, -0.06656602770090103, 0.0068869865499436855, 0.0031688837334513664, -0.021797049790620804, 0.020783681422472, 0.038275934755802155, 0.016720715910196304, -0.004350799601525068, 0.027767889201641083, -0.03783530369400978, 0.030255723744630814, 0.048166703432798386, 0.02504231408238411, 0.09068978577852249, 0.02175319753587246, 0.014109788462519646, 0.026626119390130043, 0.016995033249258995, -0.04653996229171753, -0.011616600677371025, 0.051914945244789124, -0.010622268542647362, 0.08588902652263641, -0.003458083141595125, 0.0004510300059337169, -0.030751392245292664, -0.05712177976965904, -0.025969771668314934, -0.05504046007990837, -0.041474491357803345, -0.019662076607346535, -0.05461807921528816, -0.026860566809773445, -0.019034968689084053, 0.015883343294262886, -0.02737700566649437, 0.009910310618579388, 0.07438401877880096, -0.03603563457727432, -0.01145602110773325, -0.013805095106363297, -0.023707251995801926, -0.02015582285821438, 0.003979036118835211, -0.017061421647667885, -0.06198488920927048, 0.017845040187239647, 0.02745121158659458, 0.0077920532785356045, 0.018781807273626328, -0.023000555112957954, -0.014543047174811363, 0.02232213318347931, -0.0277190450578928, 0.008847126737236977, 0.017302559688687325, 0.00037396998959593475, -0.05084817111492157, 0.03987210616469383, -0.006933432072401047, -0.06030665710568428, -0.03499696031212807, 0.05242239311337471, -0.009515338577330112, -0.04089762270450592, 0.03165869787335396, 0.004681285470724106, -0.052601467818021774, -0.016658522188663483, 0.08014707267284393, -0.06287708878517151, -0.028702186420559883, 0.07131506502628326, 0.004178356379270554, 0.003746026661247015, 0.04230653494596481, 0.0004594305937644094, -0.03181872516870499, -0.018910961225628853, -0.011194229125976562, 0.018953807651996613, 0.01686646044254303, -0.021637339144945145, -0.010996896773576736, -0.02776462770998478, -0.035954393446445465, 0.015624910593032837, -0.03755652531981468, 0.0054804254323244095, 0.039120689034461975, 0.020146986469626427, -0.0028465758077800274, -0.018778452649712563, -0.002235664753243327, -0.007309737149626017, -0.02339155785739422, -0.03405972942709923, -0.04156332463026047, 0.018695496022701263, -0.03859466314315796, -0.023789700120687485, 0.03335755318403244, 0.030790183693170547, -0.03304625302553177, -0.0224881861358881, -0.010513204149901867, 0.044775623828172684, 0.02223381958901882, 0.045822903513908386, -0.06389019638299942, -0.04501038044691086, -0.009054304100573063, -0.005152702797204256, -0.009634670801460743, 0.030476834625005722, -0.01033457089215517, -0.031239446252584457, -0.003857850097119808, -0.010250700637698174, 0.008061070926487446, -0.012338689528405666, 0.016558920964598656, -0.08216582983732224, 0.016496768221259117, 0.051091715693473816, 0.031089451164007187, 0.010067785158753395, 0.023946328088641167, -0.017195481806993484, 0.0008498439565300941, -0.009372652508318424, -0.032157618552446365, -0.00975025724619627, 0.011815454810857773, 0.022328928112983704, -0.01410657074302435, 0.019753044471144676, 0.075774185359478, 0.013755288906395435, -0.04136356711387634, -0.001207952038384974, 0.00197606161236763, 0.03362538665533066, -0.024576855823397636, -0.01727396994829178, 0.08190226554870605, -0.04651331156492233, 0.0156804658472538, -0.02405674196779728, -0.03350237011909485, -0.006014331243932247, 0.06946293264627457, -0.0005969764315523207, -0.03034469112753868, -0.04360356554389, 0.024707332253456116, -0.021793238818645477, 0.06107523664832115, -0.052327901124954224, 0.051357850432395935, 0.029939409345388412, -0.02619362808763981, -0.006930610630661249, -0.005092898849397898, 0.04468720033764839, 0.004347663372755051, 0.0034738152753561735, -0.01912412978708744, 0.0036670914851129055, 0.03146804869174957, 0.01451251283288002, 0.0712670162320137, -0.02218819223344326, -0.04040088132023811, -0.04120422154664993, -0.005073233507573605, -0.004082942381501198, 0.03258386254310608, -0.00796842947602272, -0.01547110266983509, -0.01817808486521244, 0.028394656255841255, 0.030580297112464905, -0.006221963558346033, -0.02550957165658474, -0.0029002444352954626, 0.041988957673311234, -0.043266404420137405, 0.01781509816646576, 0.023357588797807693, -0.027584722265601158, -0.014684673398733139, 0.013152633793652058, 0.008397622033953667, 0.03867138922214508, 0.01121572032570839, -0.019043928012251854, -0.010026064701378345, -0.039175719022750854, -0.016530083492398262, -0.01771814003586769, -0.018003245815634727, -0.035382550209760666, -0.046865176409482956, 0.0037341543938964605, -0.04184660688042641, 0.009937004186213017, 0.005982876755297184, -0.0056467861868441105, -0.016830962151288986, 0.025150230154395103, 0.06636291742324829, 0.0027417754754424095, 0.03723094239830971, 0.052388131618499756, 0.03116888739168644, 0.030670924112200737, -0.04956474527716637, 0.0564846433699131, -0.011608620174229145, 0.009864676743745804, -0.013046884909272194, 0.02770286612212658, -0.045831065624952316, -0.04262346029281616, -0.024799473583698273, -0.048290979117155075, -0.07038412988185883, 0.0320778489112854, -0.03717305138707161, 0.02227766066789627, 0.07568530738353729, 0.014257055707275867, 0.03953443095088005, -0.010803604498505592, -0.0021914057433605194, -0.02684931270778179, 0.0801120325922966, 0.0031702308915555477, -0.005473238416016102, -0.040284235030412674, 0.001408622250892222, 0.0036081706639379263, 0.001712247496470809, -0.018556861206889153, -0.010114343836903572, -0.02399718388915062, 0.03810853883624077, 0.0009467159979976714, 0.0039708856493234634, 0.00738027598708868, -0.002138378331437707, 0.04858338460326195, -0.005411346442997456, 0.018649686127901077, -0.06280545145273209, -0.019171804189682007, 0.06369730085134506, -0.03585469722747803, -0.050215646624565125, -0.02439696528017521, 0.023813307285308838, 0.009699605405330658, 0.005665860138833523, 0.013159453868865967, -0.009767317213118076, -0.02735123038291931, 0.0629606768488884, -0.07173234224319458, 0.07858681678771973, -0.02660166658461094, 0.02934505045413971, -0.06854285299777985, 0.061342380940914154, 0.043925873935222626, 0.028616877272725105, 0.015063650906085968, 0.023969285190105438, -0.027378596365451813, -0.0002590981312096119, 0.021800165995955467, 0.022482993081212044, -0.044097933918237686, -0.02672729082405567, -0.01772347465157509, 0.07065651565790176, -0.018792351707816124, -0.01705169677734375, 0.001112308818846941, -0.038598157465457916, -0.07035776227712631, -0.015755921602249146, -0.016047215089201927, -0.014254406094551086, 0.07173314690589905, -0.02669321559369564, -0.007561651058495045, 0.020140789449214935, -0.04127928614616394, 0.07572375237941742, 0.0319865457713604, -0.009727858006954193, -0.04941343516111374, 0.06942568719387054, 0.04936312511563301, -0.002121874364092946, -0.05064547806978226, 0.025109129026532173, -0.04819200560450554, -0.02419532835483551, -0.09238462895154953, 0.06350095570087433, -0.0500701479613781, -0.025498105213046074, -0.014457655139267445, -0.06820468604564667, 0.0141134737059474, -0.009178639389574528, 0.04867611080408096, 0.017105339094996452, 0.0122284647077322, -0.021772567182779312, -0.05445089563727379, 0.01295444555580616, -0.00314148492179811, 0.0025717176031321287, 0.0299206655472517, -0.06040671840310097, -0.0074029299430549145, -0.0109007703140378, -0.032490864396095276, 0.0010617567459121346, -0.012483709491789341, -0.032913174480199814, 0.02665124461054802, -0.007003516424447298, 0.02646595984697342, 0.05385318398475647, -0.0631704330444336, -0.014708025380969048, 0.024728890508413315, -0.03762708231806755, 0.013396183960139751, -0.028980916365981102, 0.030321577563881874, 0.03214288130402565, 0.021248813718557358, -0.03373957797884941, 0.04859354719519615, 0.10298378765583038, 0.07581739872694016, -0.021207988262176514, -0.01383809931576252, -0.0647716373205185, 0.03472433611750603, 0.03474722430109978, 0.04285423457622528, -0.042481642216444016, -0.0050018830224871635, 0.027043422684073448, -0.012471269816160202, -0.09000851958990097, -0.0767039880156517, -0.0007377999136224389, 0.02463231422007084, 0.012283537536859512, -0.03740283474326134, -0.012597223743796349, -0.016076799482107162, -0.07465262711048126, -0.019354868680238724, -0.04517078772187233, -0.005367644131183624, -0.017783181741833687, 0.0009781302651390433, 0.014277532696723938, 0.003195695113390684, -0.014953522011637688, 0.01918104663491249, 0.011503872461616993, 0.023641379550099373, 0.008085333742201328, -0.027612149715423584, 0.03143260255455971, -0.04521028697490692, -0.030199607834219933, 0.01852112077176571, -0.012772736139595509, 0.021457232534885406, -0.028251493349671364, -0.04988313093781471, 0.018272560089826584, 0.0549469031393528, -0.005161745008081198, 0.06063605844974518, -0.044198423624038696, -0.03593657165765762, 0.006035837810486555, 0.024757588282227516, 0.0075102634727954865, 0.011016128584742546, -0.0365423820912838, -0.012851365841925144, 0.04003297910094261, -0.04202219098806381, -0.0540539026260376, -0.000050102302338927984, 0.003918277099728584, -0.006320962216705084, -0.062039896845817566, -0.013939767144620419, -0.05143726244568825, -0.058544453233480453, -0.027750013396143913, -0.0007953871390782297, 0.04473738744854927, 0.005792723502963781, -0.007006559055298567, -0.0036454491782933474, 0.028680678457021713, -0.0008466081926599145, 0.019214265048503876, -0.011638902127742767, 0.03658623248338699, -0.06343352794647217, -0.02359895408153534, 0.007192415185272694, 0.08523041754961014, -0.017832299694418907, -0.03247959539294243, 0.09426432847976685, 0.016200687736272812, -0.02258926071226597, -0.05102330073714256, -0.0030375279020518064, -0.06681860983371735, 0.03417113795876503, 0.04248622804880142, -0.05770660936832428, 0.05068432539701462, -0.038321055471897125, 0.0016802948666736484, -0.022887401282787323, 0.006465001031756401, -0.00553132314234972, 0.023547645658254623, -0.028994789347052574, -0.0003740982501767576, 0.028395771980285645, 0.02321203425526619, 0.02546539157629013, 0.030666351318359375, 0.07378605008125305, -0.07466728240251541, -0.05471425876021385, 0.020778238773345947, -0.007357483729720116, 0.06795212626457214, 0.01675102673470974, 0.004252979531884193, -0.04565296322107315, -0.03694505989551544, -0.0069589694030582905, -0.05400564894080162, -0.04927289858460426, -0.016084546223282814, 0.012318712659180164, -0.02657661773264408, -0.027505934238433838, 0.05119209364056587, -0.046225350350141525, -0.045284204185009, 0.03631942719221115, -0.03153909742832184, -0.010622839443385601, 0.03458153083920479, 0.003827866166830063, 0.038833051919937134, -0.015616144053637981, 0.04968670755624771, 0.029610630124807358, 0.015124136582016945, 0.005153494421392679, 0.012317386455833912, -0.031696464866399765, -0.003807858331128955, -0.0899372324347496, -0.0955328568816185, 0.0334489569067955, 0.008809734135866165, -0.050702840089797974, -0.02738194912672043, 0.00794615875929594, 0.02390439435839653, 0.017510196194052696, -0.03581840544939041, -0.08729611337184906, -0.030856914818286896, -0.028054531663656235, 0.015521385706961155, -0.027643350884318352, -0.02980686165392399, -0.0038660874124616385, 0.028642335906624794, -0.012677142396569252, -0.029798012226819992, -0.041736483573913574, 0.022231923416256905, 0.0659916028380394, 0.07813005894422531, -0.015060911886394024, -0.027226615697145462, -0.009567482396960258, -0.052671078592538834, -0.03504009172320366, 0.012980514205992222, -0.010590502992272377, 0.014110150747001171, 0.013585804961621761, 0.0017437058268114924, -0.08109112083911896, 0.01737508550286293, 0.03578514978289604, -0.0054343827068805695, -0.009718514047563076, 0.03542419150471687, 0.0070912279188632965, 0.0003636297187767923, -0.007793720345944166, 0.012851913459599018, 0.020926836878061295, 0.0245266892015934, 0.021508239209651947, 0.009048674255609512, -0.04847375303506851, 0.010436421260237694, 0.03453843668103218, 0.031101377680897713, -0.04584639519453049, -0.026578037068247795, 0.021188095211982727, 0.014823270961642265, -0.06365171819925308, 0.03498590737581253, 0.015701599419116974, 0.048568159341812134, -0.054720811545848846, -0.03174135461449623, 0.044036731123924255, -0.04171841964125633, 0.0012591966660693288, 0.03801471367478371, 0.010564959608018398, -0.022162750363349915, -0.026790466159582138, -0.050663333386182785, 0.014973361976444721, -0.020900890231132507, -0.0350315161049366, 0.11348823457956314, 0.03546954318881035, -0.029744522646069527, 0.005373422056436539, 0.020764850080013275, 0.004983924329280853, -0.015787901356816292, 0.0753890797495842, -0.041335899382829666, 0.0026863280218094587, -0.023444650694727898, -0.020704122260212898, 0.027931690216064453, 0.025377580896019936, 0.014877554029226303, 0.030830994248390198, 0.016135454177856445, 0.010102714411914349, -0.05137960985302925, 0.06032876297831535, -0.010269000194966793 ]
<p>I have a pot of vigorously boiling water on a gas stove. There's some steam, but not alot. When I turn off the gas, the boiling immediately subsides, and a huge waft of steam comes out. This is followed by a steady output of steam that's greater than the amount of steam it was producing while it was actually boiling. </p> <p>Why is there more steam after boiling than during boiling? Also, what's with the burst of steam when it stops boiling?</p>
g4036
[ 0.03451283276081085, 0.007913139648735523, 0.0076966057531535625, 0.02584206871688366, -0.049814026802778244, 0.0009238884085789323, 0.025086333975195885, 0.085471510887146, -0.03237821161746979, -0.044356685131788254, -0.03713919594883919, 0.03087407536804676, 0.06558507680892944, 0.079773910343647, 0.05645749717950821, -0.03155829757452011, -0.030414052307605743, -0.014715651981532574, -0.034664202481508255, 0.023671137169003487, -0.028095796704292297, -0.05513254925608635, 0.04819616302847862, -0.03424232453107834, -0.019237583503127098, -0.017589593306183815, -0.0019729360938072205, 0.018010422587394714, 0.0932074561715126, -0.019726501777768135, -0.03484078124165535, 0.04980117827653885, -0.022613272070884705, -0.018967436626553535, -0.06138302758336067, -0.026498308405280113, -0.0019955337047576904, -0.031718648970127106, 0.01540842093527317, -0.06313702464103699, 0.05489489436149597, -0.006382487714290619, 0.00236350460909307, 0.025439629331231117, -0.059065498411655426, -0.01238936185836792, -0.0404500737786293, 0.06147976592183113, -0.021934542804956436, -0.017046885564923286, 0.0005624797777272761, -0.038710400462150574, -0.026644092053174973, -0.016348814591765404, 0.05955229699611664, 0.0023183266166597605, -0.02593931183218956, 0.024905305355787277, 0.027991296723484993, 0.025324448943138123, 0.006337047088891268, 0.0017163257580250502, 0.0032081627286970615, 0.007318153046071529, 0.06000073254108429, -0.017348654568195343, -0.06592109799385071, -0.013186674565076828, 0.06327507644891739, 0.06503254920244217, 0.008340451866388321, -0.037442367523908615, 0.01965351030230522, -0.010266224853694439, -0.028010355308651924, -0.03995490074157715, 0.01418383326381445, -0.00289522809907794, -0.04948630928993225, -0.006535590160638094, 0.012581931427121162, -0.03856174275279045, -0.012125380337238312, 0.010049661621451378, -0.05304770916700363, 0.006904435344040394, -0.025490008294582367, -0.019146807491779327, -0.030862955376505852, -0.0022193756885826588, 0.028827786445617676, -0.009362182579934597, 0.122488833963871, 0.020417621359229088, -0.08107168227434158, 0.03603944554924965, -0.008282785303890705, 0.0053284731693565845, -0.013281725347042084, 0.044161345809698105, 0.04762687534093857, -0.04920107498764992, 0.03371116891503334, -0.03833913803100586, -0.012869059108197689, -0.033974505960941315, -0.044554393738508224, -0.017944367602467537, -0.02669270895421505, -0.01431075669825077, -0.003596722846850753, 0.011996161192655563, -0.02764178067445755, -0.0035915328189730644, -0.01588601991534233, -0.0012879522982984781, 0.002770816208794713, 0.060517482459545135, -0.011370406486093998, 0.008180738426744938, 0.01642097346484661, -0.036364827305078506, -0.028052322566509247, -0.038521382957696915, 0.014529136940836906, -0.0390145368874073, 0.06422976404428482, 0.016951601952314377, 0.04743238165974617, 0.12098574638366699, 0.057583168148994446, 0.009571165777742863, -0.04862423241138458, 0.03703300654888153, 0.07599463313817978, 0.06311243027448654, -0.0072083924897015095, 0.03888050466775894, 0.03162297606468201, 0.013583308085799217, 0.016478881239891052, 0.011380953714251518, 0.007796771824359894, -0.056317973881959915, -0.01689242385327816, 0.02636747993528843, 0.049277376383543015, 0.009647505357861519, 0.0004136215429753065, -0.005174687132239342, 0.012553604319691658, -0.000011851219824166037, 0.05199473351240158, 0.025747856125235558, 0.06892862170934677, -0.019182490184903145, 0.04472436383366585, -0.01186121441423893, 0.04819526895880699, 0.013509832322597504, -0.01114443875849247, -0.03546934202313423, 0.004740396048873663, 0.03871915489435196, -0.06984151899814606, 0.010278196074068546, -0.026629626750946045, -0.0404670313000679, -0.019276248291134834, -0.02272663451731205, -0.04414154216647148, 0.012875362299382687, -0.009517350234091282, 0.0002391667221672833, 0.07413574308156967, 0.0061501492746174335, 0.13005685806274414, 0.014263586141169071, 0.002602744847536087, -0.01923145353794098, -0.045057766139507294, -0.029543127864599228, -0.0503535196185112, -0.03255344182252884, 0.03590637817978859, 0.026576656848192215, -0.006045283284038305, -0.02013685181736946, -0.06363658607006073, 0.007990901358425617, 0.019850650802254677, -0.013771322555840015, 0.025914903730154037, 0.02241271547973156, -0.03358280658721924, -0.01534971036016941, -0.05124950408935547, -0.005218365229666233, -0.03985043987631798, -0.029514629393815994, -0.025980645790696144, -0.023784687742590904, 0.008736629970371723, -0.002213819185271859, -0.05086446925997734, -0.013102149590849876, -0.029382670298218727, 0.05413252115249634, 0.024042712524533272, -0.039250463247299194, -0.029595263302326202, 0.030314728617668152, 0.04545947536826134, -0.03201793506741524, -0.07747667282819748, -0.005723884329199791, 0.003391294041648507, 0.02144276537001133, -0.019712598994374275, 0.007212981581687927, 0.0663544088602066, -0.005930765066295862, -0.018207306042313576, -0.006862164940685034, 0.016230762004852295, 0.014500162564218044, 0.01302045676857233, -0.0008088323520496488, -0.03975259140133858, 0.06472920626401901, -0.04519658163189888, 0.04131622612476349, 0.04377913847565651, -0.053988512605428696, 0.016984272748231888, -0.009548546746373177, 0.05329376459121704, 0.03125613555312157, -0.0018180001061409712, -0.010749706998467445, -0.023100683465600014, -0.018166478723287582, -0.014311147853732109, -0.0066819339990615845, 0.04069967567920685, 0.006869669537991285, -0.028505869209766388, -0.05107073858380318, -0.006674492731690407, -0.0427231565117836, -0.012323522008955479, 0.024889953434467316, -0.010848650708794594, 0.04024512320756912, -0.055233243852853775, -0.09211288392543793, -0.06711215525865555, 0.05972631275653839, -0.09473363310098648, 0.00209744437597692, 0.004028015304356813, 0.018387123942375183, 0.017923545092344284, -0.01419877726584673, 0.04388975352048874, 0.0021802547853440046, 0.023463275283575058, -0.034378550946712494, 0.02737705409526825, -0.00819625984877348, 0.016359739005565643, 0.008997656404972076, -0.0372113436460495, 0.0023333868011832237, -0.009324712678790092, 0.03300695866346359, -0.012296264059841633, 0.029439328238368034, 0.039553452283144, -0.01569395698606968, 0.0005397563218139112, -0.012599271722137928, 0.02090936340391636, -0.024032076820731163, -0.04045125097036362, -0.07356669753789902, 0.05521196126937866, 0.031734198331832886, -0.007189588155597448, -0.004372640512883663, 0.03762869909405708, -0.042696770280599594, -0.01937837526202202, 0.05337503179907799, 0.007945161312818527, 0.02000720426440239, 0.026409275829792023, -0.016456423327326775, -0.017032453790307045, -0.038788631558418274, -0.009258566424250603, -0.03448804095387459, -0.031453002244234085, -0.005371450912207365, 0.006380094680935144, -0.011015539057552814, 0.0004522967792581767, -0.03609456494450569, -0.03323102369904518, -0.03935445472598076, -0.012386730872094631, -0.026633495464920998, -0.05406147241592407, 0.0313972532749176, 0.005202853586524725, 0.008347704075276852, -0.017197156324982643, 0.03177797421813011, 0.025546221062541008, 0.0014638721477240324, -0.082603819668293, -0.007028304506093264, -0.020623475313186646, -0.015168626792728901, 0.03205695003271103, 0.008201779797673225, -0.03861873224377632, -0.031804196536540985, -0.008101947605609894, -0.06086686626076698, -0.003198325401172042, -0.033895935863256454, -0.05309183895587921, -0.040884263813495636, -0.03272688016295433, 0.03568670526146889, -0.028231097385287285, 0.027452299371361732, -0.0010872628772631288, 0.04512327164411545, 0.013094009831547737, 0.04445858672261238, -0.04728950932621956, -0.00925520807504654, 0.013864465057849884, 0.034578319638967514, -0.012034374289214611, -0.030761180445551872, 0.010923516005277634, 0.014936813153326511, 0.019582686945796013, 0.020044542849063873, 0.04755626991391182, -0.044337205588817596, -0.033637937158346176, -0.008277923800051212, 0.006766833830624819, -0.004681787453591824, -0.03305721655488014, -0.02766549214720726, -0.04579826071858406, -0.0761231854557991, -0.03858962655067444, 0.021264566108584404, -0.04366666078567505, -0.01539620477706194, 0.05181080475449562, 0.0753176361322403, -0.016817303374409676, 0.021005742251873016, 0.01117047481238842, -0.030626237392425537, -0.04606948792934418, 0.004811540711671114, 0.03750740736722946, 0.021736139431595802, 0.04395626112818718, 0.04345788061618805, 0.02515491470694542, -0.021681854501366615, 0.05260763689875603, 0.005137873813509941, -0.025783412158489227, 0.01528978906571865, 0.01345039252191782, -0.042681023478507996, 0.020821494981646538, 0.036368921399116516, 0.04049674794077873, -0.10657297074794769, 0.027723392471671104, -0.03883136063814163, 0.01444352325052023, 0.023595063015818596, 0.006217752117663622, 0.020120643079280853, 0.0019974843598902225, 0.01837940141558647, 0.03789295256137848, 0.009381204843521118, 0.013545751571655273, -0.01836393028497696, -0.0329032763838768, 0.034654971212148666, -0.00885764230042696, -0.017905961722135544, 0.0785275548696518, 0.045716557651758194, 0.022163130342960358, -0.003150530392304063, -0.0050916471518576145, 0.029472144320607185, -0.08247293531894684, 0.00035330807440914214, -0.03585295006632805, -0.062304310500621796, 0.04068922623991966, 0.03381076082587242, 0.003774872748181224, -0.04616881534457207, 0.006671565119177103, -0.006682946812361479, 0.04048485681414604, 0.034714553505182266, 0.04221036285161972, 0.004842804744839668, 0.014490868896245956, -0.046440668404102325, 0.017777128145098686, -0.0064269076101481915, 0.010261020623147488, 0.03244404122233391, -0.046463701874017715, 0.036523185670375824, -0.017091598361730576, 0.04173143953084946, -0.037231579422950745, -0.0013493181904777884, -0.024171113967895508, 0.03968403860926628, 0.06697171181440353, 0.014599626883864403, -0.015939639881253242, 0.05487470701336861, 0.08101198822259903, -0.05420474335551262, -0.011895685456693172, -0.008951852098107338, -0.05002082884311676, -0.03442396968603134, -0.025339752435684204, 0.03595457971096039, -0.0001299151626881212, -0.038745202124118805, -0.02185571752488613, -0.011736986227333546, -0.04720386490225792, 0.01549740880727768, -0.06171884760260582, -0.003660316579043865, 0.021730171516537666, 0.034671030938625336, -0.03824710100889206, 0.02513273060321808, -0.009401141665875912, -0.0372946672141552, -0.03170192614197731, -0.0405365489423275, -0.01888096146285534, -0.004259020555764437, 0.024248352274298668, 0.014165523461997509, 0.06859461218118668, 0.045715026557445526, 0.0365305133163929, 0.06619405001401901, 0.010460274294018745, -0.009053920395672321, 0.010888548567891121, 0.014768263325095177, -0.0024598920717835426, -0.03109688125550747, 0.020725620910525322, 0.04380849376320839, -0.000008876608262653463, 0.031649552285671234, 0.050824396312236786, 0.005318180657923222, 0.049172040075063705, -0.04429496079683304, 0.00788788590580225, 0.002418704330921173, -0.003854295937344432, 0.007786185014992952, 0.011897350661456585, -0.059658233076334, 0.04346891865134239, -0.0012683129170909524, -0.004395503085106611, 0.020771224051713943, -0.058267511427402496, 0.018262820318341255, -0.05338350310921669, 0.03396018221974373, -0.05997833237051964, 0.053096041083335876, -0.026632035151124, -0.03161581978201866, 0.01978539116680622, 0.031668856739997864, 0.001144440146163106, 0.006443609483540058, -0.03527691587805748, -0.0015136636793613434, 0.07175619155168533, -0.02635575272142887, 0.012422686442732811, -0.09107670933008194, -0.017362309619784355, 0.05150100216269493, 0.0018703155219554901, -0.06391647458076477, -0.03515047952532768, 0.034042663872241974, 0.04317760095000267, -0.007032840047031641, -0.025257395580410957, -0.02398017980158329, 0.05627759173512459, 0.03078923560678959, 0.048764463514089584, 0.039741430431604385, 0.0592518076300621, 0.03422509506344795, 0.023745907470583916, 0.08367586880922318, 0.004225311800837517, -0.016297675669193268, -0.001795831136405468, -0.015041494742035866, -0.03139807656407356, 0.016168013215065002, -0.015003329142928123, 0.06119256839156151, 0.05506832152605057, -0.047009918838739395, -0.019436806440353394, -0.036459315568208694, 0.05759837478399277, 0.025495344772934914, -0.03338932618498802, 0.05788775160908699, -0.0019109029090031981, -0.03620343655347824, -0.025563832372426987, 0.0397644080221653, 0.023781312629580498, 0.01592710241675377, 0.022293103858828545, -0.03640249744057655, -0.006070693489164114, 0.000990719418041408, 0.037891507148742676, -0.04070589691400528, 0.013228188268840313, -0.005661392118781805, -0.06339049339294434, 0.004209471866488457, 0.011401019990444183, 0.03824373707175255, 0.017228052020072937, 0.04630649834871292, 0.06154899671673775, -0.023556556552648544, -0.05141831561923027, 0.025926966220140457, -0.04694751650094986, 0.044270385056734085, -0.01850741170346737, -0.025394704192876816, -0.02759544551372528, 0.003289750311523676, 0.01255382876843214, 0.030188167467713356, -0.02706427499651909, -0.04447106644511223, 0.003152227960526943, 0.0737142562866211, 0.01869160123169422, 0.056340042501688004, -0.01546517014503479, 0.014372107572853565, 0.004474423825740814, 0.01926620677113533, 0.07660505920648575, -0.022475775331258774, -0.029633020982146263, 0.030319644138216972, -0.032178401947021484, -0.057733647525310516, 0.04794200137257576, 0.034438375383615494, 0.07464562356472015, 0.003432013327255845, -0.050497326999902725, 0.030379220843315125, 0.06820347160100937, -0.035284239798784256, -0.07049904763698578, 0.01806662790477276, 0.020516350865364075, 0.01593574695289135, 0.041202887892723083, -0.0209204088896513, -0.029661813750863075, -0.006743912119418383, -0.06177464872598648, 0.02597583457827568, 0.010625886730849743, -0.01319168135523796, 0.0525871179997921, -0.007112336345016956, 0.046274345368146896, -0.05550558492541313, 0.04008607938885689, -0.007475639693439007, -0.019664324820041656, -0.0012446492910385132, 0.0500723235309124, 0.0024139946326613426, 0.012507522478699684, -0.0017107580788433552, -0.05169692263007164, -0.005537232384085655, -0.030248193070292473, -0.049738314002752304, -0.04959918558597565, 0.020155882462859154, 0.02442770265042782, 0.05962342768907547, -0.03597584366798401, 0.00950262974947691, 0.02287529967725277, 0.0017704869387671351, 0.03393638879060745, -0.029729297384619713, -0.007033410482108593, -0.056889113038778305, -0.08661449700593948, -0.04114142432808876, -0.022907566279172897, -0.027156967669725418, -0.0026506399735808372, -0.04042700678110123, -0.04094206541776657, -0.005223516374826431, -0.0008157050469890237, 0.02576911449432373, -0.009653717279434204, -0.022888541221618652, 0.011683044955134392, 0.009692475199699402, -0.0010121462401002645, 0.08794908970594406, 0.004313901998102665, 0.0629814863204956, 0.001564076985232532, -0.0313064269721508, 0.039669446647167206, -0.027217404916882515, -0.0074876886792480946, -0.0032894760370254517, -0.04865795746445656, -0.020607110112905502, 0.02297964133322239, 0.008484051562845707, -0.016316039487719536, -0.015142634510993958, 0.020394550636410713, -0.013244247995316982, -0.08105351030826569, -0.008822593837976456, 0.021681945770978928, -0.021108848974108696, -0.03256227448582649, -0.03547847643494606, -0.010516983456909657, 0.029457230120897293, 0.0015219214837998152, 0.02372840791940689, 0.014493800699710846, -0.044213637709617615, 0.03440634533762932, 0.007260364480316639, -0.004952683113515377, 0.016698667779564857, 0.009651937521994114, -0.058122437447309494, 0.014837432652711868, 0.012267239391803741, 0.05675389617681503, -0.008788947947323322, -0.0049740346148610115, -0.06212903931736946, 0.016477251425385475, -0.004987640306353569, 0.04057053104043007, 0.03491361066699028, -0.028471045196056366, -0.05751560255885124, -0.008679443039000034, -0.014076453633606434, 0.010492328554391861, -0.06515587121248245, -0.007864425890147686, -0.016724221408367157, -0.09248670190572739, -0.051746662706136703, 0.03020179457962513, -0.020160183310508728, -0.051536403596401215, -0.03757888451218605, 0.004883649293333292, 0.03824291005730629, -0.01732679270207882, 0.016942227259278297, 0.02280721254646778, -0.04649847745895386, -0.02550400048494339, 0.09123830497264862, 0.019895218312740326, 0.03983120620250702, 0.04247298836708069, -0.027591176331043243, -0.006187051068991423, 0.011292291805148125, 0.07230454683303833, 0.04428195208311081, 0.04892309755086899, -0.02684781514108181, 0.05063609778881073, 0.03935893252491951, 0.06352948397397995, -0.024368904531002045, 0.05174032971262932, -0.04147569090127945, 0.01758294552564621, 0.03581218048930168, 0.04189905524253845, -0.047030799090862274, 0.028453242033720016, -0.026966096833348274, 0.011625885032117367, -0.041354950517416, 0.010509501211345196, 0.002265705494210124, -0.02695206180214882, 0.03886175528168678, -0.0024464831221848726, -0.012521160766482353, -0.01736801117658615, 0.025125212967395782, -0.02831166237592697, 0.020637139678001404, -0.03050992079079151, -0.02824542485177517, -0.04343550652265549, -0.06664171814918518 ]
<p>I recently have read about interception of wireless information, however this mentions that people can intercept the information, and then somehow the recipient also gets the information. Regardless of this context, what happens to the actual photon if it is absorbed by one antenna how can another person receive the same signal? Is it that when the photon is absorbed exciting the electron, the electron will then leap back to the lower energy state causing it to emit another photon? so the antenna acts as a receiver &amp; transmitter? to be honest I'm confused overall in how antennas work.</p>
g4037
[ -0.004409892950206995, -0.025202719494700432, -0.00829712301492691, 0.033236317336559296, 0.020840751007199287, 0.017002219334244728, 0.025339774787425995, 0.04346735030412674, 0.01664622314274311, -0.010379892773926258, -0.013889740221202374, 0.05422007665038109, 0.01653994247317314, -0.0583203062415123, 0.02256336621940136, -0.026466060429811478, 0.029826682060956955, 0.014385522343218327, 0.005020069424062967, 0.0436801016330719, -0.02334371954202652, 0.06455925107002258, -0.03309891000390053, -0.053943295031785965, -0.07606397569179535, -0.07424766570329666, 0.04598105698823929, -0.008173535577952862, -0.02964162267744541, -0.04656364396214485, -0.08686322718858719, -0.08330124616622925, -0.01774933561682701, -0.03955540433526039, -0.05307714641094208, -0.01772439293563366, -0.031189829111099243, -0.06350640207529068, -0.04641873762011528, 0.024866199120879173, -0.005232206080108881, -0.007797260768711567, -0.012277056463062763, -0.01214748714119196, 0.030396806076169014, -0.0054758512414991856, 0.03722440451383591, -0.020457802340388298, 0.05579172447323799, -0.02226707898080349, -0.03386322781443596, -0.03593737632036209, -0.02151307463645935, 0.06667289137840271, 0.07603034377098083, -0.01967824622988701, 0.0007923797238618135, -0.061158791184425354, 0.10603322833776474, -0.039719969034194946, -0.00317067070864141, 0.03504110127687454, -0.014647777192294598, -0.02198830619454384, 0.0565233938395977, 0.002163907513022423, -0.03611963614821434, 0.017198098823428154, -0.04811069369316101, -0.00559891015291214, 0.04562745988368988, -0.017418067902326584, -0.05837150290608406, -0.043390583246946335, 0.06624580919742584, 0.0036938562989234924, 0.0378924123942852, -0.018729690462350845, 0.03270238637924194, 0.04935476556420326, -0.01559954509139061, -0.025846483185887337, -0.00893140397965908, 0.017126359045505524, 0.028399471193552017, 0.023722488433122635, -0.021833406761288643, -0.008436164818704128, -0.06976031512022018, -0.042750466614961624, 0.06283263862133026, -0.031087001785635948, 0.061289358884096146, 0.03420311212539673, -0.04779382422566414, -0.004794089123606682, -0.026871470734477043, -0.023905321955680847, -0.01641678810119629, -0.031914789229631424, -0.011711189523339272, 0.0005185415502637625, -0.003184049390256405, 0.03129614517092705, 0.018935266882181168, 0.003592289052903652, 0.007232381030917168, -0.017035214230418205, -0.006556402426213026, 0.05775706097483635, -0.02223627269268036, -0.07875266671180725, 0.00447378633543849, 0.008994833566248417, 0.0025724335573613644, -0.009061346761882305, 0.05907580628991127, 0.003460210282355547, -0.027091240510344505, 0.02819162607192993, 0.0634860247373581, 0.031126946210861206, -0.027154168114066124, 0.049682796001434326, 0.019753502681851387, 0.01623803935945034, 0.02592642419040203, 0.03586868569254875, 0.003451067954301834, -0.003940406255424023, 0.006593110505491495, 0.03149748593568802, -0.009487783536314964, 0.011727994307875633, 0.026200763881206512, -0.03374543413519859, 0.011870792135596275, 0.03204112872481346, 0.036277610808610916, -0.04136055335402489, 0.0069340611808001995, -0.03273302689194679, 0.002515841508284211, -0.06317935883998871, -0.0016965653048828244, -0.01123600173741579, -0.005542966537177563, -0.0010055572493001819, -0.01657995395362377, 0.02466118149459362, 0.02414148859679699, 0.04351310431957245, 0.054165564477443695, -0.05520887300372124, 0.04733904078602791, -0.036027371883392334, 0.06908899545669556, -0.016008608043193817, 0.000534490158315748, 0.045609600841999054, 0.06472915410995483, 0.013462267816066742, -0.0013264563167467713, 0.034873053431510925, -0.03775562718510628, 0.012335064820945263, -0.007964997552335262, -0.05244648829102516, 0.0391777902841568, -0.05629687383770943, 0.031914155930280685, 0.026202594861388206, -0.06288173794746399, 0.005715847015380859, -0.04501200094819069, 0.039108291268348694, 0.005028760526329279, -0.01335905771702528, -0.01511845737695694, 0.02951323427259922, -0.06992528587579727, -0.010863767005503178, 0.02534468099474907, -0.013235785998404026, 0.03484946861863136, -0.05007755011320114, -0.015973949804902077, -0.0026249971706420183, -0.016331499442458153, -0.010121936909854412, -0.06621051579713821, -0.018312927335500717, 0.010894396342337132, 0.0019016030710190535, -0.03496096283197403, 0.012467688880860806, 0.009321757592260838, -0.01776382140815258, 0.02916565164923668, 0.0119957709684968, -0.020573463290929794, 0.019221479073166847, 0.013842297717928886, 0.04001899063587189, 0.04650931432843208, 0.015118828043341637, 0.026883477345108986, -0.014932540245354176, 0.01831365004181862, -0.037779707461595535, 0.03851313143968582, -0.04262256994843483, 0.03954806551337242, 0.015627095475792885, -0.0038098818622529507, 0.01853729784488678, -0.028658989816904068, 0.0065419054590165615, 0.03244344890117645, -0.07900223881006241, 0.043907057493925095, -0.06509020924568176, 0.014083302579820156, -0.046428926289081573, -0.0665440484881401, 0.02098558098077774, -0.07530128955841064, -0.04632646590471268, -0.026438381522893906, 0.04294288158416748, -0.011689443141222, 0.007563106250017881, -0.02348840981721878, -0.040784675627946854, 0.011644909158349037, 0.04107694700360298, -0.02682146243751049, 0.03365446254611015, 0.013634219765663147, -0.09689684212207794, -0.023722432553768158, 0.009288283064961433, 0.004993107635527849, 0.02653859369456768, -0.017962221056222916, 0.006807695142924786, 0.022605162113904953, -0.02553466334939003, -0.036350637674331665, -0.032778702676296234, 0.003142296802252531, 0.00013335703988559544, 0.0054357037879526615, 0.045980799943208694, -0.04939303547143936, -0.09705252945423126, -0.028826452791690826, -0.01233131717890501, -0.08168059587478638, -0.02230525016784668, -0.020124677568674088, -0.007043180055916309, -0.0011286530643701553, -0.01773831807076931, 0.017123879864811897, -0.02173660881817341, 0.06509760767221451, 0.059785716235637665, 0.03863794729113579, -0.032745011150836945, -0.05673542618751526, 0.048388198018074036, 0.018593082204461098, 0.0067393723875284195, -0.009634324349462986, -0.006113994866609573, 0.03028090111911297, -0.05428602173924446, 0.04847859591245651, -0.05631805956363678, -0.028265709057450294, 0.014641745015978813, 0.019711479544639587, -0.01058485172688961, 0.016288049519062042, -0.08711683750152588, -0.0006789152976125479, -0.01779608614742756, -0.017211632803082466, -0.039565641433000565, -0.03872835636138916, -0.03850572928786278, 0.06787990033626556, 0.020452555269002914, -0.06647379696369171, 0.028676345944404602, 0.04384663328528404, 0.03407656028866768, -0.024070171639323235, -0.0006778491660952568, -0.03661075234413147, 0.007649893872439861, 0.005308000836521387, -0.07727822661399841, 0.011555716395378113, 0.015607180073857307, -0.03126758709549904, 0.007711018901318312, -0.009379329159855843, -0.03417964652180672, -0.04423275962471962, 0.03331442549824715, -0.026567252352833748, -0.013176258653402328, -0.021740959957242012, -0.017759257927536964, -0.05711283162236214, 0.06555537134408951, 0.0004065576067660004, 0.031183689832687378, 0.010773119516670704, 0.005098436493426561, 0.003478885628283024, -0.04635903611779213, 0.01473290752619505, 0.03292613476514816, 0.001856406801380217, 0.00029478297801688313, 0.030489947646856308, -0.03405177220702171, 0.008046203292906284, -0.031146256253123283, -0.028552774339914322, 0.005347660277038813, 0.03669697418808937, -0.018578525632619858, -0.030119942501187325, 0.055866893380880356, -0.005737744737416506, -0.014223281294107437, 0.020048948004841805, -0.0363653227686882, -0.01176987774670124, -0.0007347723585553467, 0.03984546288847923, 0.011329828761518002, 0.005644014570862055, -0.021831732243299484, 0.0013484627706930041, -0.05599687993526459, 0.03180653974413872, 0.02571016177535057, -0.02220710925757885, -0.03915093466639519, -0.06333027780056, 0.007578953169286251, -0.030274057760834694, 0.013020374812185764, -0.003786168061196804, 0.020328497514128685, 0.016171304509043694, -0.0391228049993515, 0.07884770631790161, 0.02548639103770256, -0.027666840702295303, 0.022378088906407356, -0.014088950119912624, 0.009790836833417416, 0.0060684774070978165, 0.005258148070424795, -0.019606461748480797, -0.02213708497583866, 0.004101418890058994, -0.0005169177311472595, -0.034345973283052444, -0.019601760432124138, 0.015249245800077915, 0.015730148181319237, 0.005644309800118208, 0.025510963052511215, -0.05248117074370384, 0.05918719992041588, 0.007916000671684742, -0.003524346509948373, 0.060739267617464066, 0.0156551580876112, 0.02519414573907852, 0.03139236941933632, -0.013473734259605408, -0.012663536705076694, 0.06665018200874329, -0.05677596479654312, -0.01996752992272377, 0.03930127993226051, 0.05589274317026138, -0.06305425614118576, -0.04118231683969498, -0.04542820528149605, 0.04705905541777611, 0.02565951459109783, 0.04559037461876869, 0.06843093037605286, 0.0021223353687673807, -0.0457799918949604, 0.017280548810958862, 0.03359876200556755, 0.02058940939605236, -0.024644428864121437, 0.009994719177484512, -0.019451647996902466, -0.028032032772898674, 0.036655597388744354, -0.02395367994904518, -0.032677121460437775, -0.00011197053390787914, 0.06403474509716034, 0.03805983439087868, -0.02920021302998066, -0.01162740122526884, 0.005763164721429348, -0.015556016005575657, -0.0007210036274045706, -0.00478223105892539, 0.02204207144677639, -0.04508115351200104, 0.07208199054002762, 0.0582541897892952, 0.028075603768229485, -0.020103957504034042, -0.0261483546346426, 0.10452830046415329, 0.024248577654361725, -0.007248776499181986, 0.005327974911779165, -0.03549162670969963, -0.01293248776346445, 0.009346089325845242, 0.008782240562140942, 0.048093896359205246, 0.07016370445489883, 0.09111512452363968, -0.040220633149147034, 0.006026035640388727, 0.010350493714213371, 0.03861436992883682, 0.013530006632208824, 0.029369501397013664, 0.01728331856429577, 0.03075465001165867, 0.0379120334982872, -0.01261573750525713, -0.002252589212730527, -0.033765263855457306, -0.08596550673246384, 0.009276202879846096, 0.05243575945496559, 0.005769865587353706, -0.05854867398738861, 0.09623831510543823, -0.003100709058344364, 0.011335927061736584, -0.016742179170250893, -0.003183938330039382, -0.027704810723662376, -0.027662402018904686, 0.029076488688588142, -0.03546326979994774, 0.015969624742865562, -0.050786182284355164, 0.0284897293895483, -0.016857275739312172, 0.03257869929075241, -0.010974864475429058, 0.01720464415848255, 0.043663136661052704, -0.00854897778481245, -0.0376100167632103, -0.012672020122408867, -0.02452906221151352, 0.02973676659166813, 0.02001805230975151, -0.0008637409191578627, 0.014051648788154125, 0.015705805271863937, -0.004483897238969803, -0.013482512906193733, 0.025349309667944908, 0.043647974729537964, -0.018962668254971504, -0.07295602560043335, -0.01401400938630104, 0.014629267156124115, 0.0031684786081314087, -0.024048153311014175, -0.033485762774944305, -0.001191785209812224, -0.016878526657819748, 0.030232474207878113, -0.019422631710767746, -0.0032621994614601135, 0.015942733734846115, -0.02586434595286846, -0.06866016238927841, 0.006039031781256199, -0.01644810102880001, 0.012754993513226509, 0.029167143628001213, -0.036320414394140244, -0.0103366170078516, 0.006796901114284992, -0.0423368439078331, -0.047577861696481705, -0.04465658590197563, -0.039507512003183365, 0.03098260425031185, -0.011168389581143856, -0.06609157472848892, 0.00751309422776103, 0.00493241660296917, -0.027304889634251595, -0.04362354427576065, 0.07584879547357559, -0.03692173212766647, 0.01842654123902321, 0.03722267970442772, -0.05341339856386185, -0.10855105519294739, 0.023257574066519737, 0.0010689477203413844, 0.01934516802430153, 0.05478208139538765, 0.07808370888233185, -0.0035494198091328144, 0.033993080258369446, 0.03798871487379074, -0.0383794866502285, 0.03380764275789261, -0.04137048125267029, 0.04700459912419319, 0.014803680591285229, 0.029662951827049255, 0.009599575772881508, 0.06537557393312454, 0.07931015640497208, 0.00524499686434865, -0.01324142049998045, -0.006120154168456793, 0.01864687167108059, -0.004167649894952774, 0.05876264348626137, -0.006160684861242771, -0.00962120946496725, 0.0738479346036911, -0.004199463874101639, 0.01797880232334137, 0.014421401545405388, 0.017056604847311974, 0.044672537595033646, 0.05915277823805809, -0.050212886184453964, 0.034443099051713943, 0.07379505038261414, 0.0048709772527217865, -0.0001597355294506997, 0.044201791286468506, 0.0011576908873394132, 0.0035212046932429075, -0.01282995380461216, -0.006319907959550619, 0.025520235300064087, 0.058634202927351, -0.002383008599281311, -0.02275697886943817, 0.010702242143452168, -0.07435280829668045, 0.02496989630162716, 0.018641812726855278, -0.0581563301384449, -0.02360186167061329, -0.009455838240683079, 0.05614597350358963, -0.013169419951736927, 0.00810609757900238, -0.018609464168548584, 0.0202749352902174, 0.051869045943021774, -0.050795018672943115, -0.010284427553415298, 0.0921974703669548, -0.02965541183948517, -0.027271628379821777, -0.00454730587080121, 0.03490378335118294, 0.0014806210529059172, -0.0920015498995781, -0.040677282959222794, 0.006791332270950079, 0.0021897372789680958, 0.011923838406801224, 0.05350613221526146, 0.0229788925498724, -0.03652649372816086, 0.03219902142882347, -0.011911413632333279, 0.026316680014133453, 0.03416300565004349, -0.010656108148396015, -0.06516388803720474, 0.0491793118417263, -0.035779919475317, -0.013020336627960205, -0.03820986673235893, 0.024559322744607925, -0.04446551576256752, 0.013270571827888489, -0.035717595368623734, -0.04422829672694206, -0.020896364003419876, -0.02562106028199196, 0.013326304964721203, -0.008134189061820507, -0.07064651697874069, -0.000291090807877481, 0.021621599793434143, -0.032386649399995804, 0.03778810426592827, 0.06351850181818008, 0.04051625356078148, 0.021681692451238632, 0.05251266807317734, 0.0236872099339962, 0.06759064644575119, 0.05753178894519806, 0.004453621804714203, 0.030958525836467743, 0.02691427245736122, 0.0012265437981113791, -0.007175220176577568, -0.02648746781051159, 0.03761410340666771, 0.04463967680931091, 0.06566303223371506, 0.006846372038125992, 0.01029113493859768, -0.036642368882894516, 0.04477136954665184, -0.008079905062913895, -0.0015168477548286319, -0.018367834389209747, 0.011432158760726452, -0.04490074887871742, -0.019623901695013046, -0.0058116549625992775, 0.014767750166356564, 0.033644162118434906, -0.01962231658399105, -0.0035922967363148928, 0.03285563364624977, 0.01697959192097187, -0.0436980165541172, -0.050470538437366486, -0.045365381985902786, 0.0012324576964601874, 0.05575299635529518, 0.032219428569078445, -0.05596868693828583, 0.03433832898736, -0.07740574330091476, -0.026799757033586502, -0.010223978199064732, -0.005958928726613522, -0.0886220633983612, 0.013715221546590328, -0.015204787254333496, 0.02672882191836834, -0.03895758464932442, -0.004111753776669502, 0.03583357855677605, -0.07375788688659668, -0.0010979010257869959, 0.02713523805141449, 0.017349842935800552, 0.05333031341433525, 0.0005277065210975707, -0.01194429025053978, 0.02580377086997032, -0.030171385034918785, 0.04125317558646202, -0.007038157433271408, -0.029677845537662506, -0.03363814949989319, -0.028095325455069542, 0.023739824071526527, 0.020381150767207146, -0.06041346490383148, 0.014024648815393448, -0.006357585079967976, 0.04761235788464546, -0.06633596867322922, 0.03525388985872269, -0.00023776991292834282, -0.0009305342100560665, 0.044659242033958435, -0.03181948512792587, 0.08831813931465149, 0.0059072705917060375, -0.041882503777742386, -0.029392309486865997, -0.015367593616247177, 0.024286221712827682, -0.009589269757270813, -0.018394583836197853, 0.010901973582804203, 0.003172490978613496, -0.03650582954287529, 0.012956383638083935, -0.01753830909729004, 0.07775919884443283, 0.040233999490737915, -0.0016700738342478871, 0.015104081481695175, 0.03314706310629845, 0.00014601302973460406, -0.043703239411115646, -0.016533931717276573, -0.0014358951011672616, 0.0214442927390337, 0.012922598980367184, 0.010715854354202747, 0.012098544277250767, 0.010508439503610134, 0.05458378791809082, -0.01899593323469162, -0.0911458432674408, 0.039704013615846634, 0.03873001039028168, 0.051312465220689774, -0.019015809521079063, -0.0010505550308153033, -0.025334753096103668, 0.0048376102931797504, 0.02082163840532303, -0.04769391939043999, -0.03169967606663704, -0.03464805334806442, -0.015832727774977684, -0.024211758747696877, -0.02184440568089485, 0.05488923564553261, -0.04155303165316582, -0.029891835525631905, 0.008927866816520691, -0.049173105508089066, 0.07283878326416016, 0.06664999574422836, -0.02611289918422699, -0.03456180915236473, -0.013324424624443054, 0.025832338258624077, -0.0024408348836004734, 0.01560699101537466, 0.014657124876976013, -0.019347624853253365, -0.021005531772971153, -0.06995484232902527, -0.010128375142812729, -0.013822884298861027, 0.07103263586759567 ]
<p>Can anybody suggest me a good algorithm for the time evolution of the reduced density matrix using Linbald equation. My Hamiltonian is time dependent. I am aware about Qotoolbox and Qutip. I have checked both things but I don't have any clues about the algorithms they are using. I have to find the entanglement dynamics in a bipartite system under dissipation and forcing.</p>
g4038
[ 0.035407841205596924, -0.006310218013823032, 0.024542400613427162, -0.051834240555763245, 0.023284083232283592, -0.03911678120493889, 0.03442154452204704, -0.002108750632032752, -0.01231067068874836, 0.06494200974702835, -0.01813667081296444, 0.00030361601966433227, 0.029542239382863045, 0.027334900572896004, 0.043872058391571045, 0.061063915491104126, 0.0035420283675193787, 0.046688150614500046, -0.014344452880322933, -0.03786507621407509, -0.017746014520525932, 0.051301442086696625, 0.004187445621937513, 0.011367726139724255, 0.04394698888063431, -0.07851759344339371, 0.02873591147363186, 0.013549773953855038, -0.033706046640872955, 0.004878812935203314, -0.038252320140600204, 0.005613386631011963, 0.0044037699699401855, -0.04009629040956497, 0.030001768842339516, 0.013040954247117043, 0.04686247557401657, -0.07312556356191635, -0.014973362907767296, 0.031220508739352226, -0.02685096114873886, -0.048544470220804214, -0.01124606467783451, 0.005576921161264181, 0.01728600449860096, -0.03776085376739502, -0.006186967249959707, 0.009832631796598434, -0.01940886490046978, 0.02495933510363102, 0.025184839963912964, -0.016436167061328888, 0.050300776958465576, -0.04209156334400177, -0.02357390709221363, 0.076671302318573, -0.05044679716229439, -0.006873368751257658, -0.01502685621380806, 0.00010628195741446689, 0.01757487840950489, -0.0661742240190506, -0.0009292361210100353, -0.03138294816017151, 0.02047869935631752, -0.028461579233407974, -0.017857510596513748, -0.0017549205804243684, -0.009993602521717548, 0.021895015612244606, -0.020689144730567932, 0.01236316841095686, -0.04884439706802368, 0.04484343156218529, 0.06331896781921387, 0.004559074994176626, 0.02056523598730564, -0.033064816147089005, 0.021105321124196053, -0.014134828001260757, -0.0853370726108551, 0.02969210036098957, 0.03411661088466644, -0.05146590247750282, 0.03415157273411751, 0.008652566000819206, 0.0013454296858981252, 0.01892707496881485, -0.009234779514372349, -0.05740173161029816, -0.02245466411113739, -0.010302070528268814, 0.06849320977926254, -0.03849044442176819, -0.0596177838742733, 0.008574668318033218, 0.02032291702926159, 0.02612152509391308, 0.040292803198099136, 0.0016794996336102486, -0.01751488447189331, 0.0261056050658226, 0.009754703380167484, -0.04347395896911621, -0.0072624655440449715, -0.032732877880334854, -0.05336575210094452, -0.044013433158397675, -0.04109790176153183, 0.06239921599626541, -0.0005060794646851718, -0.026710327714681625, -0.05196833610534668, 0.021918848156929016, 0.004505746532231569, -0.06133776530623436, 0.0434437096118927, -0.06633930653333664, -0.04017919301986694, 0.009330091066658497, -0.049055274575948715, -0.027945488691329956, 0.05436377227306366, -0.017463918775320053, 0.005756567697972059, -0.007711601909250021, 0.00946302805095911, 0.02982725203037262, 0.000751461077015847, -0.0003498947771731764, 0.01616685464978218, 0.039271265268325806, 0.03067513182759285, 0.05139995366334915, 0.0021172072738409042, 0.03890804201364517, -0.023885510861873627, 0.04290899261832237, 0.013628598302602768, 0.04166907072067261, 0.00589355593547225, -0.02557515725493431, -0.002951418748125434, -0.011470334604382515, -0.0070371427573263645, 0.00039420236134901643, 0.024420710280537605, -0.03329179808497429, 0.0066069974564015865, 0.049402378499507904, 0.021328022703528404, 0.009268050082027912, 0.03260955959558487, -0.032198552042245865, 0.007833648473024368, 0.05657586455345154, 0.051505863666534424, -0.024127274751663208, -0.01656179502606392, -0.025453677400946617, -0.02573324739933014, -0.005818731617182493, 0.02451319806277752, 0.005199779756367207, -0.011935519985854626, 0.06395362317562103, -0.01417812705039978, -0.042297881096601486, 0.02987927384674549, -0.0511426143348217, -0.03809988871216774, -0.0037500597536563873, -0.05868111550807953, 0.036905474960803986, 0.0070816646330058575, 0.021372130140662193, -0.03928718343377113, -0.010626706294715405, 0.001150217722170055, 0.021739285439252853, 0.02771865576505661, 0.001316086738370359, 0.03551250323653221, 0.02390066534280777, 0.03680434450507164, 0.01896154321730137, -0.012612945400178432, 0.005860231351107359, -0.0538298673927784, -0.03872453048825264, 0.03031473234295845, -0.0077126529067754745, -0.00328914076089859, -0.04850195348262787, 0.040388986468315125, 0.0550166480243206, 0.07878334820270538, -0.03604299575090408, -0.010689021088182926, -0.03319530934095383, -0.04605831205844879, 0.012004202231764793, 0.0665038600564003, 0.03805752471089363, -0.010024224407970905, -0.019095227122306824, -0.018426163122057915, 0.01709931157529354, 0.031193239614367485, -0.012550142593681812, 0.004017013590782881, -0.0020688476506620646, -0.044224418699741364, 0.016033876687288284, 0.01029217429459095, 0.05532621219754219, -0.005253281444311142, 0.03844665363430977, -0.0025637904182076454, 0.031603891402482986, -0.015110298991203308, 0.018216373398900032, -0.008245198987424374, 0.011237355880439281, 0.022341212257742882, -0.019409460946917534, 0.00418072659522295, -0.01891995593905449, 0.02487981878221035, 0.014234986156225204, -0.027066051959991455, 0.02750958502292633, -0.0439690537750721, -0.023768350481987, 0.02354024350643158, 0.06726426631212234, -0.044240985065698624, 0.008085041306912899, 0.047174934297800064, 0.021028153598308563, -0.008248979225754738, 0.06349093466997147, -0.019673872739076614, 0.009574415162205696, 0.0011041263351216912, -0.08735931664705276, -0.0045232707634568214, -0.04808030650019646, 0.030662622302770615, -0.0059127467684447765, 0.04150420427322388, -0.02786283940076828, -0.023888587951660156, -0.05564771220088005, -0.008754823356866837, -0.02474035695195198, 0.046689920127391815, 0.040863148868083954, 0.036125633865594864, -0.0827612355351448, 0.00009113188571063802, 0.07877995073795319, -0.026146305724978447, -0.00959576852619648, 0.023439615964889526, 0.030856819823384285, -0.0034987586550414562, -0.06723622232675552, 0.002027942566201091, 0.002189459279179573, 0.0005009954329580069, 0.024630514904856682, -0.043543338775634766, -0.01663871482014656, -0.014305293560028076, 0.04327932745218277, -0.02388859912753105, 0.005442604888230562, -0.03127950802445412, 0.021242916584014893, 0.04101340100169182, -0.03258511796593666, -0.011284139938652515, 0.08558325469493866, 0.017696648836135864, -0.054145555943250656, 0.019358811900019646, 0.01428220421075821, 0.041263241320848465, 0.02952304482460022, -0.02064276486635208, 0.04708366096019745, -0.06344860047101974, 0.02312646061182022, -0.045845430344343185, -0.016253698617219925, -0.018353870138525963, -0.12627315521240234, -0.0020912731997668743, 0.0538809671998024, -0.041601262986660004, -0.03561117500066757, 0.020190399140119553, 0.018117433413863182, 0.05803724378347397, -0.009884998202323914, -0.05846046656370163, 0.010311152786016464, -0.031408973038196564, -0.03511854261159897, 0.014808857813477516, -0.0014312450075522065, 0.03050864301621914, -0.03030133992433548, 0.025372985750436783, -0.06080903485417366, 0.0009053883841261268, -0.027229273691773415, 0.0321493037045002, -0.044811636209487915, 0.00403145095333457, -0.058196548372507095, -0.0033994188997894526, -0.02141423150897026, 0.0409531444311142, -0.025435956194996834, -0.006038352381438017, 0.012832789681851864, -0.030978109687566757, -0.019805528223514557, 0.03405304625630379, -0.050703465938568115, 0.0833188146352768, 0.038751307874917984, -0.028816962614655495, -0.08740685135126114, -0.1123102679848671, -0.021182890981435776, -0.032728467136621475, 0.02379564568400383, -0.05433419719338417, -0.06658512353897095, -0.05879778787493706, 0.011886171996593475, -0.04114948585629463, -0.03038712404668331, -0.040032364428043365, -0.033000778406858444, 0.010867569595575333, 0.012423194944858551, 0.014867153018712997, -0.0421515516936779, 0.053836721926927567, -0.01562849059700966, 0.004596564453095198, -0.01919393800199032, -0.0007667607278563082, -0.005894423462450504, 0.0374671034514904, 0.011446242220699787, -0.043412137776613235, -0.037892747670412064, 0.023365085944533348, 0.04782634228467941, 0.00587307196110487, -0.03162802755832672, 0.0031283125281333923, 0.041900359094142914, 0.018514852970838547, 0.019655834883451462, -0.004082683008164167, 0.052195679396390915, 0.01635003462433815, -0.014761405996978283, 0.009178051725029945, -0.004607848357409239, -0.01981348730623722, -0.008328464813530445, 0.028306936845183372, 0.039323292672634125, 0.014307951554656029, -0.045243386179208755, 0.028071578592061996, 0.0012696824269369245, -0.006212067790329456, 0.034873608499765396, 0.022674180567264557, -0.017000844702124596, -0.018466776236891747, -0.03093837760388851, 0.01820646971464157, -0.07343819737434387, -0.01870627887547016, -0.022027401253581047, 0.007195424288511276, 0.05097111314535141, 0.018079370260238647, 0.008172102272510529, -0.024922790005803108, -0.006399171426892281, -0.056236423552036285, -0.03378216177225113, 0.0034899883903563023, 0.04243866726756096, 0.020409878343343735, -0.03260421007871628, -0.023235948756337166, -0.013561666943132877, 0.042336124926805496, -0.00522263627499342, -0.01714422181248665, -0.033702295273542404, 0.001346941920928657, 0.018203753978013992, -0.04932696744799614, -0.028067119419574738, 0.08974052965641022, -0.0033829070162028074, -0.03504973649978638, 0.021731896325945854, 0.03598887100815773, 0.06832350790500641, -0.03681959584355354, -0.04440003260970116, -0.06913813948631287, 0.018823064863681793, 0.07452943176031113, -0.025824816897511482, -0.013755708001554012, -0.026161152869462967, 0.0423702634871006, -0.06607164442539215, -0.05412128567695618, 0.028893940150737762, -0.03872319310903549, 0.016741136088967323, 0.02392951399087906, 0.0159930307418108, -0.022428881376981735, -0.02363421581685543, 0.028518183156847954, -0.042451635003089905, 0.018079714849591255, 0.02404162473976612, -0.003567679785192013, 0.052696593105793, 0.02149987407028675, -0.03424562141299248, -0.047473933547735214, -0.025409240275621414, 0.05631360784173012, 0.07351899147033691, 0.02858983911573887, -0.011466916650533676, 0.007949762046337128, -0.011046790517866611, 0.021347271278500557, -0.0006383483414538205, 0.026978883892297745, 0.10939652472734451, -0.027482807636260986, 0.030832430347800255, -0.11570002883672714, -0.020625295117497444, -0.004833099897950888, -0.028646187856793404, -0.015616494230926037, 0.026878628879785538, 0.04023712873458862, -0.01813155971467495, 0.048910465091466904, -0.02365334890782833, 0.03376500681042671, -0.04070917144417763, -0.038872454315423965, -0.005757002625614405, -0.020619450137019157, -0.011434484273195267, 0.10460732132196426, -0.008079220540821552, 0.04106839373707771, 0.0118443937972188, -0.006382256280630827, -0.01656080223619938, 0.04257462918758392, 0.0007241199491545558, 0.05028526857495308, -0.004006110597401857, 0.03461112082004547, -0.08418029546737671, 0.03301774337887764, -0.03489503636956215, 0.016012465581297874, 0.04239460080862045, 0.02096623182296753, -0.023774640634655952, 0.023400897160172462, -0.00995889212936163, -0.022450193762779236, -0.0005985849420540035, -0.04615605250000954, 0.017512060701847076, -0.03159165009856224, -0.0005032616900280118, -0.00016935104213189334, -0.012176799587905407, 0.027786068618297577, 0.00048032571794465184, -0.02932228147983551, 0.06095585972070694, -0.02404576912522316, 0.06491686403751373, 0.06479266285896301, 0.050441473722457886, -0.029046680778265, -0.011108117178082466, -0.04925408959388733, -0.0012055524857714772, -0.01903017796576023, -0.07320896536111832, -0.006088166497647762, 0.005196146201342344, 0.022411786019802094, -0.02576378360390663, 0.04772353917360306, 0.04330545663833618, -0.055076632648706436, 0.010368216782808304, -0.0613248236477375, -0.01063992828130722, -0.010122704319655895, -0.01935476064682007, 0.030782420188188553, -0.050762880593538284, -0.030883094295859337, -0.016275057569146156, -0.004255060572177172, 0.016157343983650208, -0.014554213732481003, 0.040489841252565384, 0.03901074454188347, -0.10116404294967651, 0.001076665474101901, 0.026283027604222298, 0.0029698743019253016, -0.03128639981150627, -0.03531811386346817, -0.008714733645319939, -0.012963872402906418, -0.02275974489748478, -0.05978403985500336, -0.032126303762197495, -0.020208097994327545, 0.04627254232764244, -0.01193301286548376, -0.0010501809883862734, -0.03990037739276886, -0.03164725750684738, -0.02017967961728573, 0.13417398929595947, -0.01419182401150465, 0.0002848424483090639, 0.009675998240709305, -0.009455508552491665, -0.012230388820171356, -0.08241330832242966, 0.011980126611888409, 0.04989128187298775, 0.0447075255215168, 0.0449957512319088, 0.022928506135940552, 0.017327504232525826, 0.005683142691850662, 0.04450472444295883, 0.06504645943641663, 0.03128092363476753, -0.013042217120528221, -0.10038534551858902, -0.07789039611816406, 0.0045832437463104725, -0.08937787264585495, 0.03943201154470444, -0.01957051269710064, -0.01767837442457676, -0.03895893320441246, 0.01846577413380146, -0.005749546457082033, -0.039161644876003265, 0.041858166456222534, 0.0028300208505243063, 0.005272394511848688, 0.07125653326511383, -0.03354218974709511, -0.04032052308320999, -0.010542180389165878, 0.03994138538837433, -0.007322954945266247, 0.024164652451872826, 0.014996703714132309, -0.009762249886989594, 0.004348845686763525, -0.019065599888563156, -0.018464265391230583, -0.028520584106445312, -0.05642368644475937, 0.01779806613922119, -0.01026692520827055, -0.03477200120687485, 0.030502693727612495, 0.011927228420972824, 0.006290903780609369, 0.0074256667867302895, -0.027963533997535706, -0.013587637804448605, 0.04153396934270859, -0.030156686902046204, -0.023177454248070717, 0.05546911060810089, -0.021936483681201935, 0.06126074492931366, -0.01668376848101616, 0.015462840907275677, 0.006169851869344711, -0.018353721126914024, 0.0038008815608918667, 0.093119315803051, 0.01120974775403738, -0.05039707571268082, 0.02826496958732605, 0.008497055619955063, 0.060337748378515244, -0.04913664236664772, -0.030757227912545204, 0.03894826024770737, -0.028940849006175995, -0.035041313618421555, -0.05524946004152298, 0.08767181634902954, 0.024625735357403755, 0.022864481434226036, 0.0309415515512228, 0.0077687413431704044, 0.01985779218375683, -0.014706650748848915, -0.0069280099123716354, 0.025784706696867943, 0.00023163743026088923, -0.014711595140397549, -0.02384019084274769, -0.0030373362824320793, 0.059999000281095505, 0.054240159690380096, -0.044717397540807724, 0.04170669615268707, -0.03302530199289322, -0.0076947640627622604, 0.01723311096429825, 0.0058887917548418045, 0.0527740940451622, 0.019640199840068817, -0.014190965332090855, -0.01777086965739727, 0.0009997970191761851, 0.014697696082293987, 0.009993170388042927, 0.03443343564867973, 0.01954178884625435, -0.023369109258055687, 0.05398902669548988, -0.011647239327430725, -0.0758681669831276, -0.0649503841996193, -0.009887450374662876, 0.0009136090520769358, -0.04854969307780266, -0.012614846229553223, -0.008620050735771656, 0.027588745579123497, -0.028436003252863884, 0.014789348468184471, 0.015596656128764153, 0.027185587212443352, -0.0523667074739933, -0.02440614067018032, 0.050170887261629105, 0.045421455055475235, 0.026711665093898773, -0.03074011392891407, -0.0032165399752557278, 0.009543957188725471, 0.003961753565818071, 0.05557635426521301, -0.053993020206689835, -0.0063824220560491085, 0.023693779483437538, 0.022047903388738632, 0.053164828568696976, -0.03549148142337799, 0.054520584642887115, 0.07671801000833511, -0.01586586982011795, -0.016426337882876396, 0.03528939560055733, -0.004112446215003729, -0.05506861209869385, -0.029414772987365723, -0.05095522105693817, -0.03907965496182442, 0.01483024563640356, 0.0351894348859787, -0.00034787843469530344, -0.026489142328500748, 0.0038631076458841562, -0.025853564962744713, 0.05881156027317047, 0.008678942918777466, -0.024422332644462585, 0.06650451570749283, -0.016933249309659004, 0.008519439026713371, 0.005866380874067545, 0.015943700447678566, -0.001714977901428938, -0.026302654296159744, 0.047508761286735535, -0.054568786174058914, -0.003918085712939501, -0.003007445950061083, -0.031875934451818466, -0.027587493881583214, 0.038128454238176346, -0.05901843309402466, -0.011949120089411736, 0.02422189526259899, 0.12500227987766266, 0.03573800250887871, -0.010770266875624657, 0.05488289147615433, 0.02874799072742462, 0.04407725855708122, -0.0027067167684435844, -0.06971662491559982, -0.01971771940588951, -0.010574565269052982, 0.07766781002283096, -0.021112604066729546, -0.021078377962112427, -0.015500228852033615, 0.038588616997003555, 0.0063896626234054565, -0.010594303719699383, -0.02470492571592331, -0.009945301339030266, 0.033705051988363266, -0.003282575635239482, -0.03089015558362007, 0.0284320916980505, -0.0136810801923275, 0.0076674786396324635, -0.014369579963386059, 0.016717592254281044, -0.0010323110036551952, 0.021005036309361458, -0.002344095380976796, -0.009410928934812546, -0.04438270255923271, 0.011861632578074932, 0.02055865339934826 ]
<p>In the Metropolis algorithm, the change in the energy given by the hamiltonian is compared for flipping a spin. This is not the free energy, but for systems above absolute zero you are trying to minimize the free energy, not the energy. So how is free energy built into this kind of simulation? How is entropy?</p>
g4039
[ 0.00884969998151064, 0.0016789325745776296, -0.017655495554208755, -0.04791310802102089, -0.045622579753398895, -0.016278279945254326, 0.010345792397856712, 0.08255049586296082, -0.021632226184010506, 0.030686987563967705, -0.024546639993786812, 0.02323843166232109, 0.09898857027292252, -0.057644981890916824, -0.00739149609580636, 0.05259124934673309, -0.015131928957998753, 0.029752105474472046, 0.020949004217982292, 0.04218669608235359, -0.024941295385360718, -0.06946214288473129, -0.02551943063735962, -0.02058168314397335, -0.04646506533026695, -0.04940149560570717, -0.030962646007537842, -0.02443980984389782, -0.032862719148397446, 0.018589304760098457, -0.04993605986237526, 0.021113572642207146, 0.0835740715265274, -0.037764377892017365, -0.05208578333258629, 0.0207167137414217, 0.07384232431650162, 0.028342975303530693, 0.003225495805963874, -0.02620222605764866, 0.00873410701751709, -0.017485691234469414, -0.02702789008617401, 0.03350767865777016, 0.000510894285980612, 0.018998976796865463, 0.03324579820036888, 0.016741307452321053, -0.02629115805029869, 0.0011318974429741502, 0.002347351284697652, 0.03005867637693882, 0.05012862756848335, 0.03213509917259216, -0.015267666429281235, -0.006398679688572884, -0.019930819049477577, 0.009337875060737133, 0.07951199263334274, 0.0423947237432003, 0.023109110072255135, -0.031928762793540955, 0.007533547002822161, 0.03556215390563011, 0.01444492768496275, 0.023346781730651855, -0.01595349796116352, -0.0010752619709819555, 0.0041906568221747875, -0.0014145829482004046, -0.01489613763988018, -0.009628398343920708, -0.031749170273542404, 0.020442958921194077, 0.06706973165273666, 0.02445732057094574, 0.03718501329421997, -0.042953331023454666, 0.020548103377223015, -0.019471535459160805, -0.03414268419146538, -0.012503329664468765, 0.032740380614995956, -0.05229245498776436, 0.01630619540810585, -0.008278041146695614, -0.016175908967852592, 0.0015399076510220766, -0.014415174722671509, 0.04017497971653938, 0.007789102382957935, 0.020204050466418266, 0.08352689445018768, -0.018178405240178108, -0.050426289439201355, 0.043884746730327606, -0.06854100525379181, 0.012454643845558167, 0.029562151059508324, -0.02152298577129841, -0.0717032179236412, 0.016364941373467445, 0.036369115114212036, -0.04174736514687538, -0.008073871023952961, -0.02837044559419155, 0.0026476127095520496, -0.0019185986602678895, 0.03208766132593155, 0.0011161604197695851, 0.03205133229494095, 0.002519621979445219, -0.021791784092783928, 0.005291937384754419, -0.07347600162029266, -0.008543472737073898, 0.13388581573963165, -0.015283890068531036, 0.018506035208702087, 0.02096521481871605, -0.0401494987308979, 0.04082266241312027, 0.003640304785221815, 0.023795560002326965, -0.0032145718578249216, 0.05974481627345085, 0.014165472239255905, -0.01636492647230625, 0.0006544627831317484, -0.016908567398786545, 0.02547306939959526, -0.0512663833796978, -0.012396780773997307, 0.008253056555986404, 0.01727544143795967, 0.03280378505587578, -0.038517460227012634, -0.04046403244137764, 0.01682250015437603, 0.0006145384977571666, -0.03776659443974495, -0.05784907937049866, -0.038685668259859085, -0.06039388105273247, 0.0012358834501355886, -0.025633933022618294, 0.01112302578985691, -0.031281180679798126, 0.016385091468691826, -0.006204970646649599, 0.057229094207286835, 0.08564795553684235, 0.042204950004816055, -0.054618485271930695, 0.01391303539276123, -0.010827137157320976, 0.056905098259449005, -0.0037985118106007576, 0.021147454157471657, 0.012928389012813568, 0.03502095863223076, -0.07203609496355057, 0.08223405480384827, -0.004304429050534964, -0.03079257346689701, 0.03479823097586632, 0.07203011959791183, -0.019523752853274345, 0.005334191489964724, -0.013614905066788197, -0.013523176312446594, -0.04823681339621544, -0.01912994123995304, 0.07977582514286041, 0.028789570555090904, 0.023251112550497055, -0.04163294658064842, 0.042310044169425964, 0.025574946776032448, 0.03172822296619415, 0.030663955956697464, 0.04195749759674072, 0.03423197194933891, -0.011695966124534607, 0.04904962331056595, 0.010552666150033474, 0.004828149452805519, 0.03275482729077339, 0.007475994993001223, -0.03670519217848778, -0.0212952122092247, 0.059399813413619995, -0.0238562673330307, -0.019999226555228233, 0.01799803227186203, 0.0586329847574234, 0.00763477198779583, -0.03272494673728943, -0.017344428226351738, 0.005159794352948666, 0.04358527064323425, 0.007453052327036858, -0.009118974208831787, 0.027537601068615913, -0.010488230735063553, 0.025877900421619415, 0.03429410606622696, -0.01262200903147459, 0.02675974741578102, -0.03647351637482643, -0.005596462171524763, 0.02551405131816864, -0.0033093385864049196, 0.003582350444048643, 0.030613839626312256, 0.06375702470541, -0.03062419220805168, 0.014236824586987495, 0.028689639642834663, 0.008889632299542427, 0.03835099935531616, -0.0334600992500782, 0.04978463426232338, 0.002775816014036536, 0.01895860955119133, -0.00803292915225029, -0.05024656653404236, 0.020251061767339706, -0.04039405286312103, 0.023651864379644394, -0.016525859013199806, 0.021780671551823616, -0.009759243577718735, 0.00248774909414351, 0.010145636275410652, 0.06178451329469681, -0.015700407326221466, 0.07473663985729218, 0.01157290581613779, -0.0052083455957472324, 0.0021139595191925764, 0.009627037681639194, -0.06178857386112213, 0.0043110596016049385, 0.029460540041327477, -0.05205061286687851, 0.03771171718835831, 0.04345228150486946, -0.04482021927833557, -0.04170040413737297, -0.005735624581575394, 0.02628522738814354, 0.006182836834341288, -0.022218631580471992, -0.024185314774513245, -0.02516717091202736, -0.00819457322359085, 0.012712833471596241, -0.03653527423739433, 0.03474753722548485, 0.039429258555173874, 0.00662693427875638, 0.038229770958423615, 0.024119170382618904, -0.009572031907737255, 0.019249718636274338, -0.006864815019071102, -0.06814123690128326, -0.042494092136621475, 0.02092932164669037, -0.0008127373293973505, 0.07970786839723587, -0.039953626692295074, 0.018877588212490082, -0.028789913281798363, -0.03526963293552399, 0.07278337329626083, 0.01265047863125801, 0.02756245993077755, -0.03736896812915802, -0.06095169112086296, -0.011342779733240604, -0.04344255477190018, 0.01192900724709034, 0.04593992605805397, -0.04896298795938492, 0.022406112402677536, 0.012963921763002872, 0.002838479820638895, -0.06116040050983429, 0.009203528054058552, 0.04506698623299599, 0.008315193466842175, -0.016176480799913406, -0.07537440210580826, 0.02739604003727436, 0.061495691537857056, -0.06365492194890976, -0.01574849896132946, 0.08765991777181625, -0.008419403806328773, 0.005367315374314785, 0.010246658697724342, 0.056732673197984695, 0.04594583064317703, 0.05313670262694359, -0.038555972278118134, -0.03157583251595497, -0.0379936583340168, -0.009128083474934101, -0.04084053263068199, 0.012751681730151176, 0.013626650907099247, 0.016264840960502625, -0.04252835363149643, 0.02442994900047779, 0.006679154932498932, -0.030728168785572052, -0.00040892348624765873, -0.05754614248871803, -0.01285838708281517, -0.012272442691028118, 0.0325547531247139, 0.007592784706503153, 0.001034604269079864, 0.017212960869073868, -0.043421514332294464, -0.055462952703237534, -0.07256054878234863, -0.008619720116257668, 0.03210758790373802, 0.015256368555128574, -0.012659423984587193, 0.015873955562710762, -0.14145633578300476, -0.0630623996257782, -0.04058027267456055, -0.01851111464202404, 0.027627715840935707, -0.01100086234509945, -0.02265258878469467, -0.00445063691586256, -0.056200962513685226, -0.04109737649559975, -0.05373987928032875, 0.03685346990823746, -0.038175370544195175, -0.05445312336087227, 0.004196842201054096, -0.07809306681156158, 0.023167572915554047, -0.0003861912409774959, 0.0023635495454072952, -0.017657307907938957, -0.008868282660841942, -0.026551442220807076, -0.007799395825713873, -0.011521940119564533, 0.03187336400151253, 0.033787962049245834, 0.008814073167741299, -0.04888961464166641, 0.027820240706205368, -0.026597121730446815, -0.020193537697196007, 0.005677434150129557, -0.046287912875413895, -0.002850861055776477, 0.007830295711755753, -0.060497961938381195, -0.025629552081227303, -0.035810213536024094, -0.00798783265054226, -0.01001353282481432, 0.002716176211833954, 0.020556407049298286, 0.021743424236774445, 0.020259788259863853, -0.0034844009205698967, 0.007264611776918173, 0.012685507535934448, -0.04730275645852089, -0.022846827283501625, -0.0172975342720747, -0.015615977346897125, 0.05144273489713669, -0.060738008469343185, 0.0032848890405148268, -0.04729801043868065, -0.026527680456638336, 0.013193578459322453, 0.014283551834523678, 0.00704915588721633, 0.01573116146028042, 0.03622778132557869, -0.0006493881810456514, 0.026815103366971016, -0.04221150279045105, -0.009447186253964901, 0.059735868126153946, -0.006998656317591667, 0.012075570411980152, -0.029948236420750618, -0.024544866755604744, 0.07096513360738754, -0.046215400099754333, -0.020500507205724716, 0.0033484469167888165, -0.03618696704506874, 0.016004221513867378, 0.0006705936975777149, 0.032528363168239594, 0.02622259594500065, -0.04955228790640831, -0.04816363379359245, -0.005691979080438614, -0.002040806459262967, -0.027986058965325356, -0.014296149834990501, 0.0020172675140202045, -0.014270796440541744, -0.0201638825237751, -0.003950338810682297, 0.025956902652978897, -0.03551134467124939, 0.029154539108276367, 0.07510791718959808, -0.03594610467553139, -0.03730273246765137, -0.0679820105433464, 0.041212983429431915, 0.02583238109946251, -0.002948763780295849, -0.005775731522589922, -0.07199592888355255, 0.021488094702363014, -0.035489149391651154, 0.0211931224912405, -0.0220597255975008, 0.03271397203207016, 0.08283064514398575, -0.014131009578704834, 0.02060050144791603, 0.008961513638496399, -0.032421428710222244, 0.023992210626602173, -0.0036796224303543568, -0.014667767100036144, -0.05354352295398712, -0.04307183995842934, 0.006073647644370794, 0.0038731226231902838, 0.000713445944711566, 0.013062943704426289, 0.011242260225117207, -0.024697789922356606, -0.08988193422555923, -0.005249145440757275, 0.0652218610048294, 0.011915438808500767, -0.031083697453141212, -0.00967833586037159, -0.07843069732189178, -0.00807261187583208, -0.03943878412246704, 0.006909274496138096, -0.028993232175707817, 0.028757702559232712, -0.04392299801111221, 0.0011400310322642326, 0.0748174712061882, -0.05112750828266144, -0.03542156144976616, 0.023404812440276146, 0.022185662761330605, 0.015092272311449051, 0.018406864255666733, -0.05472411587834358, 0.06145380437374115, 0.015757882967591286, -0.021981965750455856, 0.03187449276447296, -0.03504686430096626, 0.011474871076643467, -0.025240493938326836, 0.017583485692739487, -0.0068866414949297905, -0.019355235621333122, 0.01930449716746807, -0.059163957834243774, 0.018509406596422195, 0.08531590551137924, 0.0025710740592330694, -0.0439363494515419, 0.039418939501047134, -0.010194950737059116, 0.02853316441178322, 0.015448590740561485, -0.02222810685634613, -0.05142313987016678, -0.01734432950615883, 0.0134615832939744, -0.03143826127052307, 0.03751322254538536, -0.00866345502436161, 0.013741420581936836, 0.06047884747385979, 0.010776115581393242, -0.006833590101450682, 0.10473649203777313, -0.05312367156147957, -0.02164301835000515, 0.017105834558606148, 0.027093011885881424, 0.03555452451109886, -0.06425158679485321, -0.003396084997802973, -0.06396961212158203, -0.04351812228560448, -0.07419005781412125, 0.03450934216380119, 0.02793969213962555, 0.010025338269770145, -0.019419757649302483, -0.006900454871356487, 0.04072142764925957, -0.02847432903945446, -0.006964909844100475, -0.018214542418718338, 0.029816806316375732, -0.030273281037807465, -0.008600214496254921, -0.02113048918545246, 0.03662683442234993, -0.06851101666688919, 0.005790113005787134, -0.03747091069817543, 0.02165854163467884, 0.002396863652393222, 0.05384891852736473, 0.057032112032175064, -0.08971913903951645, 0.022325102239847183, 0.05320960283279419, -0.04976022243499756, -0.02258278802037239, -0.03393125906586647, 0.0013912711292505264, -0.015078425407409668, -0.07210099697113037, -0.05678406357765198, 0.011157904751598835, 0.011990748345851898, 0.0024859190452843904, 0.01155365351587534, -0.006800377741456032, -0.015038304962217808, -0.043312638998031616, 0.020149072632193565, 0.08139216154813766, 0.03784201666712761, -0.008437358774244785, 0.0384819433093071, -0.010452658869326115, 0.05333961546421051, 0.0010383144253864884, -0.02398017980158329, 0.019013991579413414, 0.018115732818841934, 0.01352057047188282, -0.03739830106496811, -0.010738418437540531, 0.006018373183906078, 0.001563361962325871, 0.0057555995881557465, -0.010049303062260151, -0.03657026216387749, -0.07195799797773361, -0.037590786814689636, -0.06252642720937729, -0.029912447556853294, -0.05102510377764702, 0.016028549522161484, -0.02731003798544407, 0.04015648365020752, 0.012762674130499363, -0.006188226398080587, -0.002048963215202093, 0.04662715271115303, 0.05228112265467644, -0.037315115332603455, 0.0018410751363262534, -0.007512906566262245, -0.03267722949385643, 0.03610239177942276, 0.014027850702404976, -0.04999348893761635, -0.07509193569421768, -0.036035362631082535, -0.01494754757732153, 0.009277990087866783, 0.0005514134536497295, 0.0035381256602704525, -0.06397673487663269, 0.0016777346609160304, 0.07984550297260284, 0.014430255629122257, 0.010663320310413837, -0.03685993328690529, 0.026697885245084763, -0.033163975924253464, -0.022785400971770287, 0.03383391350507736, 0.0034393914975225925, 0.011438464745879173, -0.014665716327726841, 0.0030793792102485895, -0.0029486701823771, 0.019976524636149406, 0.0037188634742051363, 0.01080886647105217, -0.01906857267022133, 0.03235292807221413, -0.04826050251722336, 0.0372643806040287, 0.07890211045742035, 0.014991107396781445, 0.06658545136451721, 0.0705062597990036, 0.005663192830979824, 0.017646148800849915, 0.04626373201608658, -0.07873048633337021, 0.07688038051128387, -0.004413296468555927, 0.0015487733762711287, -0.09852642565965652, 0.0396868959069252, 0.050025034695863724, 0.06495022773742676, 0.02211141027510166, 0.007817678153514862, 0.011781602166593075, 0.00494394451379776, 0.009751235134899616, 0.014038288034498692, -0.01910037361085415, 0.028603779152035713, -0.017742637544870377, 0.02384813316166401, -0.010075856000185013, -0.020995838567614555, -0.03689908608794212, -0.006226650904864073, -0.046491846442222595, 0.04567938670516014, -0.023398635908961296, 0.006970287766307592, 0.050170253962278366, -0.008928821422159672, 0.010625218972563744, -0.024557137861847878, -0.007310573011636734, -0.0000935135394684039, 0.03575626388192177, 0.08182014524936676, 0.030671672895550728, 0.02947198785841465, 0.06418600678443909, -0.04293060675263405, -0.04851585999131203, -0.02347322180867195, -0.12221870571374893, 0.04592251777648926, 0.0066490937024354935, -0.041826579719781876, -0.01396674569696188, 0.06392119079828262, 0.006725086830556393, -0.036369144916534424, 0.021940508857369423, 0.038709744811058044, 0.001533301081508398, 0.008088788017630577, -0.003786617424339056, 0.060715202242136, -0.06150040030479431, 0.060743991285562515, -0.02344769425690174, 0.009443845599889755, 0.018887793645262718, 0.05072496458888054, 0.04071306437253952, 0.008568940684199333, -0.02511981502175331, 0.049039941281080246, 0.010046865791082382, 0.01520891860127449, 0.054946523159742355, -0.03739594295620918, 0.06240588799118996, -0.0417267344892025, 0.013562476262450218, 0.05509406700730324, -0.02047702670097351, 0.00498159509152174, 0.024893078953027725, -0.021369701251387596, 0.006331025622785091, -0.03117600455880165, 0.036554720252752304, 0.003921630326658487, 0.023840805515646935, -0.013901060447096825, 0.011140534654259682, -0.008890828117728233, -0.023847337812185287, -0.019111180678009987, 0.01901302859187126, 0.003611296648159623, 0.027093106880784035, 0.0044278111308813095, -0.04374530911445618, 0.01359645277261734, 0.007595800328999758, 0.003529622917994857, 0.006574486382305622, 0.02908310852944851, -0.03655355051159859, 0.029613424092531204, -0.02480281889438629, -0.03850778192281723, 0.0066344463266432285, -0.010567843914031982, -0.029141541570425034, -0.019694097340106964, -0.01601709984242916, -0.007229862734675407, 0.016697276383638382, -0.0019601827953010798, -0.03480927646160126, -0.032455675303936005, 0.07946886867284775, -0.07762308418750763, -0.02390216663479805, -0.0014145385939627886, -0.0321958065032959, 0.03422629088163376, 0.0510452501475811, -0.03847061097621918, -0.009999196976423264, 0.008263111114501953, -0.025207549333572388, 0.011717920191586018, 0.03892117738723755, 0.02296668291091919, 0.009854137897491455, -0.058547791093587875, 0.01697346195578575, 0.023460058495402336, 0.00041703321039676666, -0.030020685866475105, -0.009545795619487762, 0.0107848159968853, 0.010709552094340324, -0.05979521572589874, 0.019631467759609222, 0.07774733752012253 ]
<p>I've got a homework question. </p> <blockquote> <p>Consider a 2 dimensional space with metric $$ ds^{2} = \frac{dr^{2}}{1 -\frac{2}{r} } + r^{2}d\theta^{2} .$$ </p> <p>I need to show that this is the induced metric (not sure if im translating this correctly) from $\Bbb R ^{3}$ and I need to find the parametrization of the surface. </p> </blockquote> <p>I really don't know how to start with the parametrization. Any help getting me started would be greatly appreciated. </p> <p>Edit: since the question got put on hold I will try to clarify my question. I need some intuition behind this metric, specifically the $g_{rr}$ coefficient. I tried different things involving trig functions of $\theta$ and $r$ to be the usual polar transformation, but I'm stuck. I'm pretty sure that is I can manage to get the parametrization right I can prove that the given metric is the induced metric from $\Bbb R ^{3}$. Hope this clarifies the question.</p>
g4040
[ 0.009099606424570084, 0.02555072493851185, -0.010861923918128014, -0.04579981788992882, 0.01733805425465107, 0.03910849243402481, 0.07014746218919754, 0.016728656366467476, -0.06065040081739426, -0.055099476128816605, -0.03580198064446449, 0.04261426255106926, 0.031982481479644775, -0.05655719339847565, 0.0254367683082819, -0.002786105265840888, -0.008635387755930424, -0.03220563754439354, -0.029820190742611885, -0.025491822510957718, -0.022797148674726486, -0.052949726581573486, 0.05854673683643341, -0.04255659505724907, 0.04006807133555412, -0.056362856179475784, 0.07304506003856659, 0.0017454201588407159, 0.011071794666349888, -0.014498153701424599, -0.043224770575761795, 0.03964368999004364, 0.011151975020766258, -0.007549250032752752, -0.028431573882699013, 0.02687351405620575, 0.041405368596315384, 0.03745431452989578, 0.03997528553009033, 0.00013645777653437108, 0.025102248415350914, -0.012991636991500854, 0.03083743155002594, 0.03302834928035736, 0.021527212113142014, -0.04707839712500572, 0.02972465194761753, 0.00039278852636925876, 0.016454022377729416, 0.009220877662301064, -0.03623513877391815, 0.04768727347254753, 0.0364743210375309, -0.05493489280343056, -0.08235309273004532, 0.057171352207660675, 0.02733076736330986, -0.03586380556225777, -0.005080732982605696, -0.01525723934173584, -0.0687447339296341, -0.0048427339643239975, -0.012369559146463871, -0.016522588208317757, 0.020589465275406837, -0.010797938331961632, 0.0009479457512497902, 0.0009961898904293776, -0.005095023661851883, -0.014825807884335518, 0.03799571096897125, -0.03370467945933342, 0.06937923282384872, 0.018416937440633774, -0.05072164162993431, 0.01345053967088461, 0.016462648287415504, 0.008791519328951836, -0.02734336070716381, -0.00436842767521739, 0.04126518592238426, -0.0034476295113563538, -0.005514656193554401, -0.04557886719703674, 0.07821866124868393, 0.020505471155047417, 0.02491218037903309, 0.02034309320151806, -0.014694226905703545, -0.018366998061537743, -0.025047436356544495, -0.013707157224416733, -0.0018279660725966096, 0.03494295850396156, 0.017836827784776688, -0.01190024521201849, -0.011609543114900589, 0.017176015302538872, -0.05277391895651817, 0.002264463808387518, -0.01769341714680195, 0.005498311948031187, 0.0223765317350626, 0.017650537192821503, 0.03818546608090401, -0.019920598715543747, 0.07727588713169098, 0.030626989901065826, 0.028867265209555626, -0.07006865739822388, -0.06943558901548386, -0.0048463051207363605, -0.02820279821753502, -0.05211032181978226, 0.037789300084114075, -0.05331268161535263, 0.0618269219994545, -0.035867806524038315, -0.007987406104803085, 0.05994921550154686, 0.026109661906957626, 0.00690258527174592, -0.008665107190608978, 0.02273361198604107, -0.024388903751969337, 0.02589491568505764, -0.027060123160481453, 0.033595021814107895, 0.09620065987110138, 0.03626858815550804, 0.03043046034872532, 0.02760632149875164, 0.0014726418303325772, 0.001614665612578392, 0.002088927198201418, 0.03283310309052467, 0.0201936736702919, -0.009920588694512844, 0.006725465878844261, 0.024342313408851624, -0.04922182112932205, 0.013699625618755817, 0.011772995814681053, 0.015715621411800385, -0.05917155370116234, 0.04117954522371292, 0.024830741807818413, -0.03352443873882294, -0.007641935721039772, 0.029094254598021507, 0.04879390448331833, 0.10767021775245667, 0.002456089248880744, -0.019400352612137794, 0.04880142956972122, -0.025862375274300575, 0.010341291315853596, -0.025499893352389336, 0.04032311588525772, -0.0029228380881249905, 0.052914950996637344, -0.020462574437260628, 0.016984451562166214, 0.019449383020401, -0.024047477170825005, -0.001954997656866908, 0.03561176732182503, -0.03716748580336571, -0.011055134236812592, -0.09458676725625992, -0.02406943030655384, 0.05436073616147041, -0.0032146242447197437, 0.025386422872543335, -0.001074493397027254, 0.027908697724342346, -0.08058451116085052, 0.029102018103003502, 0.019251875579357147, 0.050111837685108185, -0.015983082354068756, -0.0029709332156926394, 0.00639238441362977, -0.04113427549600601, -0.010259732604026794, -0.06650601327419281, 0.06603730469942093, 0.008365950547158718, -0.03663681820034981, 0.04068984091281891, -0.022031059488654137, 0.0508006326854229, 0.05098120868206024, -0.011370835825800896, 0.04680014029145241, 0.04253017529845238, 0.07925652712583542, -0.05374603718519211, 0.056044336408376694, 0.04261208698153496, -0.019263150170445442, 0.00026115935179404914, 0.021717078983783722, 0.007419210392981768, -0.032338228076696396, -0.035017453134059906, 0.028400590643286705, -0.05113133788108826, -0.013000196777284145, 0.014816894195973873, -0.017942514270544052, -0.021042507141828537, -0.003350274870172143, -0.04907872900366783, -0.04037818685173988, 0.017918338999152184, -0.0385793074965477, 0.033000119030475616, -0.04282369837164879, 0.013208406046032906, -0.01698276586830616, -0.010379589162766933, 0.03223172575235367, -0.008914973586797714, -0.01738889142870903, 0.02700105682015419, 0.0009158838074654341, 0.001378632732667029, -0.013894183561205864, 0.014582433737814426, -0.011619496159255505, -0.05174533277750015, 0.037522587925195694, -0.024814605712890625, 0.015895608812570572, 0.07671033591032028, -0.05442626029253006, -0.04317675158381462, 0.03456982597708702, -0.02580895833671093, 0.013737456873059273, 0.0038208740297704935, -0.03798700124025345, -0.006968921050429344, 0.03619213402271271, -0.02359631285071373, 0.04132924973964691, 0.054626185446977615, 0.06112780049443245, -0.025594308972358704, 0.009780045598745346, 0.013710028491914272, -0.016789443790912628, -0.04695744812488556, 0.023516807705163956, -0.016986200585961342, -0.0554368793964386, 0.0010079138446599245, -0.019659798592329025, -0.06423638015985489, -0.025352315977215767, -0.08101367950439453, -0.004205802921205759, 0.055707503110170364, -0.10524508357048035, -0.01004839688539505, -0.05687275156378746, -0.02770906314253807, 0.018704010173678398, 0.009167655371129513, 0.0026284665800631046, 0.011484058573842049, 0.0327674001455307, 0.015606299042701721, -0.04350258782505989, -0.04698649048805237, 0.02027124911546707, -0.025044016540050507, -0.04774623364210129, 0.020899387076497078, -0.021874262019991875, -0.04137236997485161, -0.0629340186715126, 0.018653441220521927, -0.009009050205349922, -0.0233059860765934, -0.014538080431520939, 0.05252697691321373, -0.023373043164610863, 0.020904967561364174, -0.03271542489528656, -0.00970656517893076, 0.01379902008920908, 0.01366382371634245, 0.011776736937463284, 0.009950012899935246, -0.033495910465717316, 0.013982032425701618, -0.01893375813961029, 0.00709772203117609, -0.01351387333124876, -0.02335534244775772, 0.00639398954808712, -0.09414876997470856, -0.02830568142235279, -0.038250699639320374, 0.009080728515982628, -0.0800565630197525, -0.00785837136209011, 0.022918134927749634, -0.008266824297606945, -0.04960891976952553, -0.02502870187163353, 0.004242679104208946, 0.002723659621551633, -0.024942493066191673, -0.05974580720067024, -0.04123367369174957, -0.005569398403167725, 0.021974559873342514, -0.014280222356319427, -0.06520198285579681, -0.018317291513085365, 0.019116146489977837, 0.04946548864245415, 0.003895698580890894, -0.08138920366764069, 0.043816111981868744, 0.0012171488488093019, -0.025507500395178795, 0.017541587352752686, -0.00424368167296052, -0.017576895654201508, -0.03252716735005379, -0.022478360682725906, -0.02944168820977211, -0.03843144699931145, 0.0784747451543808, 0.028336048126220703, -0.0048255957663059235, -0.0455501452088356, -0.02116316184401512, -0.014907985925674438, -0.04009139910340309, -0.0007796845748089254, -0.019033605232834816, 0.0074278824031353, 0.016858207061886787, 0.011477630585432053, -0.021851256489753723, -0.006294360384345055, -0.01788989268243313, 0.02147367224097252, -0.024713560938835144, 0.0043654488399624825, 0.07494531571865082, -0.007358581759035587, 0.034099116921424866, 0.02193407714366913, -0.06671585887670517, 0.01699385978281498, -0.04764024540781975, -0.05021078884601593, 0.014930748380720615, -0.0022785612381994724, -0.04737382009625435, 0.0324564166367054, 0.026181865483522415, -0.019331596791744232, 0.056830137968063354, 0.03801868483424187, -0.01709250919520855, 0.016599232330918312, 0.10322924703359604, 0.025353610515594482, -0.018861986696720123, -0.045921724289655685, 0.021609557792544365, 0.006627779919654131, 0.024103328585624695, -0.03168869391083717, 0.017572607845067978, 0.05537301301956177, -0.003152483142912388, 0.004046943504363298, -0.008704871870577335, -0.029556917026638985, 0.02019593119621277, 0.06281454861164093, -0.0811910331249237, -0.0884636715054512, -0.0000032625171115796547, -0.02019614540040493, 0.01031277421861887, -0.00671683344990015, -0.08708448708057404, 0.023104650899767876, 0.02397238276898861, 0.0010443637147545815, 0.0263188686221838, -0.021280106157064438, -0.01365060918033123, 0.007317237090319395, 0.015416000969707966, -0.05940541252493858, -0.06992830336093903, 0.08417884260416031, 0.006750533357262611, 0.008651004172861576, 0.006209196988493204, -0.03578902781009674, 0.017102576792240143, -0.003139459528028965, -0.08247292041778564, 0.06280037015676498, 0.05055542290210724, 0.03252960741519928, 0.01993698999285698, 0.005070853978395462, 0.006993127521127462, -0.0760960504412651, -0.004105300176888704, 0.03048473224043846, -0.05716713145375252, 0.034864284098148346, 0.029044242575764656, 0.10939900577068329, -0.0650424063205719, -0.017698990181088448, 0.025952734053134918, 0.002779346192255616, 0.019419683143496513, -0.0860581248998642, 0.022562658414244652, -0.03719589486718178, -0.02726380154490471, -0.08118876814842224, 0.004746153485029936, -0.020816467702388763, -0.023354539647698402, 0.030196448788046837, -0.04605570435523987, 0.033905088901519775, -0.046860046684741974, -0.0045096734538674355, -0.009984936565160751, -0.019594870507717133, -0.018694771453738213, 0.025554047897458076, 0.04412546381354332, 0.0319317951798439, -0.009349385276436806, 0.036108680069446564, -0.010615470819175243, -0.025184478610754013, 0.050969723612070084, -0.013889923691749573, 0.037209756672382355, -0.0006127297529019415, 0.00222711730748415, -0.0010476082097738981, -0.02567862719297409, -0.010159625671803951, -0.00048164770123548806, 0.026891816407442093, -0.04416671767830849, -0.05874938145279884, 0.06550346314907074, 0.010941613465547562, -0.05098186433315277, -0.010998345911502838, 0.02401675656437874, -0.025404270738363266, -0.017668722197413445, -0.005160011351108551, 0.07235611975193024, -0.007320864591747522, -0.007294477894902229, 0.034158721566200256, -0.031239811331033707, 0.0058748433366417885, -0.0036908595357090235, 0.01756506972014904, 0.007832665927708149, -0.026058567687869072, 0.018544180318713188, -0.03170671686530113, -0.008888168260455132, -0.04262511059641838, 0.01663043536245823, -0.039076175540685654, 0.08234698325395584, 0.027488458901643753, 0.014003830030560493, -0.0588870570063591, 0.021197613328695297, -0.028404852375388145, -0.01839483715593815, 0.008336764760315418, 0.017697762697935104, -0.04451512172818184, 0.04099379852414131, 0.05708038806915283, 0.009910613298416138, -0.008790645748376846, -0.005220350809395313, 0.044130757451057434, -0.02135549485683441, 0.057249125093221664, 0.02891812101006508, -0.04367392882704735, -0.0066636698320508, 0.009495604783296585, 0.012920326553285122, 0.029523085802793503, 0.014345336705446243, 0.01193592231720686, 0.05489623546600342, 0.032230544835329056, 0.025595156475901604, 0.021637367084622383, -0.06939923763275146, 0.006277511361986399, -0.02908947318792343, 0.02867881953716278, 0.017921961843967438, -0.03147033601999283, -0.023941107094287872, 0.03872772678732872, -0.030098484829068184, 0.03757854178547859, -0.004042905755341053, -0.05188785865902901, 0.02034054510295391, 0.04814643785357475, -0.04992092773318291, 0.023850614205002785, 0.01981496252119541, 0.0223039910197258, -0.026201404631137848, -0.012680930085480213, -0.02888803370296955, 0.07005035877227783, -0.028564630076289177, 0.015674784779548645, 0.011331179179251194, 0.009051118977367878, 0.006240152753889561, -0.003929020371288061, 0.04135081171989441, -0.012230130843818188, -0.014200355857610703, 0.03470996767282486, -0.007439938839524984, 0.017724251374602318, 0.0428687259554863, -0.02300206944346428, -0.06104453280568123, -0.017552345991134644, -0.04115082696080208, 0.017469218000769615, -0.03465178981423378, 0.008402662351727486, 0.012956627644598484, 0.02110677771270275, -0.04236924648284912, -0.003538440680131316, 0.0546116977930069, 0.07161672413349152, -0.01886541023850441, 0.020232727751135826, 0.01823105849325657, -0.00007782258035149425, 0.08686334639787674, 0.055719051510095596, 0.03804447501897812, -0.007125147618353367, -0.019947612658143044, 0.019675690680742264, 0.0828714519739151, 0.0362740159034729, 0.0022509172558784485, 0.030192160978913307, -0.02710474655032158, 0.008733710274100304, 0.026700956746935844, -0.034007515758275986, -0.021205589175224304, 0.01149383932352066, -0.018220188096165657, -0.04245780408382416, 0.022945215925574303, -0.03386116772890091, -0.027570627629756927, 0.046310458332300186, -0.020086118951439857, 0.002011140575632453, 0.011659027077257633, -0.015998046845197678, -0.01704023964703083, -0.05009512975811958, 0.005478988867253065, 0.054660264402627945, -0.006336596328765154, 0.03864764794707298, -0.04792063683271408, -0.004902628716081381, -0.06958242505788803, -0.004512600600719452, 0.004200899042189121, -0.0005885084974579513, 0.02696504257619381, -0.0656059980392456, 0.05689842998981476, 0.008570977486670017, -0.03591078519821167, -0.005640067160129547, 0.003924883436411619, -0.006440908648073673, 0.014746018685400486, 0.07211431860923767, 0.000943876919336617, 0.01674351654946804, -0.04230897128582001, 0.030684534460306168, 0.02892223931849003, 0.000319154147291556, 0.011977558955550194, 0.022457383573055267, 0.0751921758055687, -0.01178930327296257, -0.05702749267220497, -0.04199819639325142, -0.0006674635224044323, -0.0018467450281605124, 0.003739862237125635, -0.0015070628141984344, 0.05896336957812309, 0.057267703115940094, 0.08612605184316635, 0.0018064939649775624, -0.013006085529923439, -0.07457658648490906, -0.0681847482919693, -0.04204462096095085, 0.0056076315231621265, 0.018530232831835747, -0.005250782705843449, -0.06317150592803955, 0.05658159404993057, 0.04693998023867607, 0.05379059165716171, 0.0075903222896158695, 0.005928137339651585, -0.03825109079480171, -0.0159282386302948, -0.011479060165584087, 0.02544471062719822, -0.03491818904876709, -0.014465214684605598, -0.0880383625626564, -0.036201730370521545, -0.003476017853245139, -0.033352166414260864, -0.020682837814092636, 0.0529867485165596, -0.023894434794783592, 0.015844102948904037, 0.04569818452000618, -0.05198853090405464, -0.040466953068971634, -0.0685945674777031, 0.04672340303659439, 0.032459989190101624, -0.029348598793148994, 0.011381424963474274, 0.08280137181282043, 0.019298607483506203, 0.043793655931949615, -0.007404776755720377, 0.01580505445599556, 0.021489828824996948, -0.037767983973026276, 0.0034858561120927334, -0.011867965571582317, 0.02738730050623417, -0.010260852985084057, -0.008597162552177906, -0.0048478213138878345, 0.007111744023859501, -0.0016880591865628958, 0.03125569596886635, -0.02985464036464691, 0.062080591917037964, 0.009677092544734478, -0.05597597360610962, 0.013875104486942291, 0.06780292093753815, -0.01051709521561861, -0.03198884427547455, 0.024798400700092316, -0.012643217109143734, -0.059127263724803925, -0.02520459145307541, -0.0002798247442115098, 0.029841354116797447, -0.03924226760864258, -0.03197861462831497, 0.011622386984527111, -0.022311687469482422, 0.008072310127317905, -0.007082344498485327, 0.029593845829367638, -0.04876096919178963, 0.012898043729364872, 0.01555023156106472, -0.03751601278781891, 0.07473070919513702, 0.007244364824146032, -0.04651814326643944, -0.03368866816163063, 0.025616543367505074, -0.010752154514193535, -0.06489324569702148, -0.026207081973552704, -0.03937789425253868, -0.009070063009858131, -0.05092274770140648, 0.027414584532380104, 0.030021492391824722, -0.022522807121276855, 0.04355510696768761, 0.00724433409050107, -0.002262475434690714, -0.029706675559282303, 0.04558899998664856, 0.040377892553806305, -0.020261744037270546, 0.03335127979516983, 0.023156164214015007, 0.0012984339846298099, 0.012680217623710632, 0.03718281909823418, -0.034654706716537476, 0.01568247564136982, -0.02004161663353443, -0.009164231829345226, 0.03491171449422836, 0.06254716217517853, -0.032536763697862625, 0.030661653727293015, 0.020075922831892967, 0.020323496311903, -0.050650909543037415, 0.030246984213590622, -0.07797162979841232, -0.017524247989058495, 0.013556119985878468, 0.04438117891550064, -0.02299373596906662, 0.027047716081142426, -0.011940855532884598, -0.050792545080184937, 0.04053635150194168, -0.031151987612247467, 0.004295466002076864, -0.035942453891038895, 0.07429417222738266 ]
<p>So, there are all kinds of 'standard' explanations that people just 'know' about how things work which are wrong. The sort of explanations a dad may give to their son when he asks the infamous "why" word to explain how the world works. Not all of these answers are entirely true. </p> <p>I thought, for the sake of helping us all be a little better informed, we could think up some of the most commonly misunderstood phenomenon and give a better or more accurate explanation to them. Think of it as something like Wikipedia list of common misconceptions, but specifically targeted to physical explanations and more of a focus on explaining the <em>true</em> reasons. I'll even include a bounty for the best answer</p> <p>For example, the #1 misconception that comes to me is "how airplanes fly", which even Google itself will simplify to Bernoulli's principle, while the real answer is...actually a bit too complicated for me to explain well lol.</p> <p>To make this sporting here are some 'rules' for the sort of answers I'm looking for</p> <p>1) erroneous explanation should be about something common place, in other words if your couldn't see someone under the age of 13 asking about a phenomenon it's probably too complicated 2) corrected explanations given should be simple enough that an intelligent laymen would have a chance of understanding it. I'm looking for answers that could actually be used to correct a misconception when it occurred.</p> <p>I'll generally select whatever answer has the highest vote count as the winner. However, I reserve the write to pick something else as the winner if I feel that the top voted answer does not fit the two categories, or that it only won because it was posted early and had more time to get up voted.</p>
g4041
[ 0.061398133635520935, 0.06749450415372849, 0.0055054109543561935, 0.0405852235853672, 0.03909502923488617, 0.007321691140532494, 0.018916260451078415, 0.009034770540893078, 0.03611242026090622, -0.010993074625730515, 0.03461216390132904, -0.04357462003827095, 0.01483143214136362, 0.036863941699266434, -0.017363667488098145, -0.007566626183688641, -0.010059813037514687, -0.042346835136413574, 0.05492397025227547, 0.05391426011919975, -0.01880907267332077, 0.013537096790969372, 0.042072195559740067, 0.019136514514684677, -0.11686298996210098, -0.04733366519212723, -0.08448687195777893, -0.01307339034974575, 0.011154955253005028, -0.06128523126244545, 0.01343241985887289, -0.05594535917043686, 0.007199379615485668, -0.06017439439892769, -0.027223868295550346, -0.013302828185260296, 0.008163456805050373, -0.013173268176615238, 0.03861311078071594, 0.02593761682510376, -0.016153521835803986, -0.0034585222601890564, -0.05304345488548279, 0.01508300844579935, 0.034994643181562424, -0.05542105436325073, -0.030379658564925194, -0.02350754849612713, 0.01584567129611969, -0.04296464845538139, -0.04029373452067375, -0.006158903241157532, 0.1250949651002884, 0.08344995975494385, -0.0009129085810855031, 0.020818570628762245, 0.06964240968227386, 0.033887866884469986, 0.05501362681388855, 0.017727408558130264, -0.014209096319973469, 0.025066019967198372, 0.017421728000044823, 0.002974869916215539, 0.004142594989389181, 0.0538773387670517, -0.0430346243083477, 0.052247434854507446, 0.06880570948123932, -0.024131005629897118, 0.06577084213495255, -0.051793575286865234, -0.028086256235837936, 0.027820507064461708, -0.003366694087162614, -0.02926141768693924, -0.06782004237174988, 0.0664987713098526, 0.050902899354696274, 0.02445305325090885, 0.02555190771818161, 0.01615302823483944, -0.025837725028395653, -0.03662621229887009, 0.06158173084259033, 0.025567812845110893, -0.002142585813999176, -0.038832008838653564, 0.05581009387969971, -0.038995642215013504, 0.01927454210817814, -0.0075529757887125015, 0.042074427008628845, 0.027697134763002396, -0.040458448231220245, 0.006920165847986937, -0.023140190169215202, -0.012096953578293324, 0.03675081208348274, 0.04977401718497276, -0.01157754473388195, -0.04129203408956528, -0.0599721297621727, 0.020332368090748787, -0.02750510536134243, 0.029943516477942467, 0.09207522869110107, -0.006505705416202545, -0.019827308133244514, 0.02304520085453987, -0.02131837233901024, -0.006750069558620453, -0.0064863646402955055, -0.020486008375883102, 0.026821954175829887, -0.045547254383563995, 0.04545360058546066, 0.0316653735935688, 0.031169936060905457, 0.09881523996591568, -0.038897257298231125, 0.05534248799085617, 0.010548746213316917, -0.012768721207976341, 0.024509305134415627, -0.016198663040995598, -0.013860007748007774, -0.018644332885742188, -0.013711999170482159, -0.03655998036265373, 0.02727876976132393, 0.027728069573640823, 0.004727817140519619, 0.02126564271748066, -0.019100172445178032, 0.03973771631717682, 0.030053840950131416, -0.014265012927353382, 0.044797662645578384, -0.008478418923914433, 0.06179654225707054, -0.03674549236893654, 0.02707577310502529, -0.01276826485991478, -0.012892888858914375, 0.005204944405704737, -0.039251312613487244, 0.03034653514623642, -0.016276627779006958, -0.0033521822188049555, 0.008319194428622723, 0.0877443328499794, 0.0232530627399683, -0.030278176069259644, 0.026070652529597282, -0.013094443827867508, -0.02209707535803318, 0.00529671274125576, 0.03740422800183296, 0.010757782496511936, 0.03838102146983147, 0.024930978193879128, -0.08764248341321945, 0.07286913692951202, -0.08276831358671188, 0.027638379484415054, 0.023447545245289803, -0.010834683664143085, -0.022275179624557495, 0.0007965093827806413, -0.07994193583726883, -0.04257582128047943, -0.003666155505925417, 0.028861481696367264, -0.0026956566143780947, 0.07218877971172333, 0.05316034331917763, -0.05477617308497429, -0.019082915037870407, -0.006741543300449848, 0.023085739463567734, -0.00002465662510076072, -0.0044437977485358715, 0.007917393930256367, -0.028537007048726082, 0.00292568514123559, -0.012951171956956387, -0.02370527945458889, -0.05499539524316788, 0.003815453965216875, -0.03745473176240921, -0.04425252974033356, -0.018214339390397072, 0.013637076131999493, -0.04925927147269249, -0.020145224407315254, -0.0339273139834404, 0.008203760720789433, -0.04989657178521156, 0.012938378378748894, 0.0027902298606932163, -0.014126639813184738, 0.045470695942640305, 0.005755824502557516, -0.02857789397239685, 0.009048319421708584, 0.02976932004094124, 0.03631707280874252, 0.04540442302823067, 0.0007010927656665444, 0.03812699392437935, -0.046627335250377655, -0.009668775834143162, -0.007879544980823994, -0.031551431864500046, 0.015770278871059418, -0.021886063739657402, -0.019557511433959007, -0.034463681280612946, -0.010198360309004784, -0.005555998533964157, 0.014011625200510025, -0.028033655136823654, 0.030160769820213318, 0.010415772907435894, 0.042661283165216446, -0.032466012984514236, -0.03233581408858299, 0.02069753408432007, 0.02777433767914772, -0.04326949641108513, -0.01515010092407465, 0.01763678342103958, -0.00809779204428196, 0.04101480171084404, -0.002053389558568597, -0.007108989171683788, -0.014381623826920986, 0.10676293820142746, -0.016084620729088783, 0.005960631649941206, 0.002477772533893585, -0.040627866983413696, -0.02363418973982334, -0.016718266531825066, -0.01340450905263424, -0.015906300395727158, -0.054372649639844894, 0.014248318038880825, 0.0183122381567955, -0.019509823992848396, 0.0672534629702568, 0.00683498615399003, -0.05554630234837532, -0.01639898680150509, -0.07834991812705994, 0.03272270783782005, 0.09249227494001389, -0.001627524383366108, 0.041249118745326996, -0.044102173298597336, 0.03580254316329956, -0.0013425193028524518, -0.00969200860708952, 0.002187685575336218, -0.030420823022723198, -0.030254468321800232, 0.04337170720100403, -0.04794111102819443, -0.04311949387192726, 0.04160385951399803, 0.0159099493175745, -0.028696633875370026, 0.005420174915343523, -0.017623411491513252, -0.03786498308181763, -0.04109959304332733, 0.030584467574954033, 0.029195621609687805, 0.008303445763885975, -0.021338293328881264, -0.011394882574677467, -0.025690574198961258, 0.025601984933018684, 0.08838751912117004, -0.009438900277018547, -0.08338279277086258, -0.06240634247660637, -0.0002869008167181164, 0.0024481010623276234, -0.005906962789595127, 0.010389100760221481, 0.020166639238595963, 0.05769748240709305, -0.019085094332695007, 0.052072975784540176, 0.0038865585811436176, -0.042971525341272354, -0.06478460133075714, -0.03512367978692055, 0.019651995971798897, 0.002019684761762619, -0.017107440158724785, 0.05038952827453613, -0.021416155621409416, 0.030692623928189278, 0.03389917314052582, -0.02194329723715782, 0.03787533938884735, -0.018290549516677856, -0.017363853752613068, 0.024461539462208748, -0.008835796266794205, -0.038880880922079086, -0.021393945440649986, 0.032851144671440125, -0.009175731800496578, 0.06642425060272217, 0.007494976744055748, -0.06675487756729126, 0.003978407941758633, -0.03676246851682663, -0.049883924424648285, 0.014971240423619747, -0.030680404976010323, 0.05711672827601433, -0.0729747861623764, 0.008607184514403343, -0.017850667238235474, -0.027077075093984604, -0.007851595990359783, 0.0028937191236764193, -0.024016672745347023, -0.02997734770178795, -0.04494158551096916, -0.038102488964796066, 0.005590660031884909, 0.05437564104795456, 0.005289814900606871, -0.040892597287893295, 0.030224403366446495, 0.029071347787976265, -0.02834203653037548, -0.0027830139733850956, 0.013841064646840096, 0.019004829227924347, -0.040722742676734924, -0.01213956717401743, -0.0024528498761355877, 0.02166111022233963, 0.08264372497797012, 0.01749727502465248, -0.03402644395828247, -0.0021561759058386087, -0.010836448520421982, 0.01965988427400589, -0.012222214601933956, -0.015683727338910103, 0.032969359308481216, -0.0011233381228521466, -0.0017862552776932716, 0.04027778282761574, -0.05552647262811661, 0.03203948587179184, -0.009337062947452068, 0.07499159872531891, 0.03398216888308525, 0.02454390376806259, -0.022789305076003075, -0.04962892085313797, -0.024752216413617134, 0.0455559566617012, 0.010843941010534763, 0.013506238348782063, -0.03509591519832611, 0.025998713448643684, 0.027139075100421906, 0.023736530914902687, -0.05371450260281563, -0.012668106704950333, 0.040126487612724304, 0.04683416709303856, -0.012866135686635971, 0.023016761988401413, 0.07733173668384552, 0.014502296224236488, -0.035375017672777176, -0.005333048291504383, 0.008592484518885612, 0.017763618379831314, 0.022279677912592888, 0.011602622456848621, -0.037928398698568344, 0.05932291969656944, 0.013527262955904007, -0.028003226965665817, -0.061088353395462036, -0.04919857159256935, -0.0035088076256215572, 0.0048537105321884155, 0.0562492236495018, -0.04440236836671829, 0.019561244174838066, -0.0012243238743394613, 0.024390151724219322, 0.02122250199317932, -0.005254276096820831, -0.024963269010186195, 0.03853375092148781, 0.027379745617508888, 0.020607806742191315, 0.05672748386859894, -0.024020399898290634, -0.03420572727918625, 0.04829644039273262, 0.03313519433140755, 0.02379271760582924, 0.036719877272844315, 0.003729803254827857, 0.0041705649346113205, 0.06043386831879616, 0.016022663563489914, -0.04889665171504021, -0.04232421889901161, 0.019474521279335022, 0.010238251648843288, 0.03916049376130104, 0.019584504887461662, 0.017310861498117447, 0.010249714367091656, 0.0059801735915243626, 0.03196331486105919, -0.033499956130981445, -0.015716342255473137, -0.006490303669124842, -0.03490426391363144, -0.031481239944696426, 0.02790440432727337, 0.002541237510740757, -0.013417894020676613, 0.03242998197674751, 0.025017106905579567, 0.023441148921847343, 0.009332996793091297, -0.023742523044347763, 0.053083714097738266, -0.022951383143663406, 0.0028498994652181864, -0.007553066127002239, 0.003723244881257415, -0.08892828226089478, 0.011297989636659622, 0.014229201711714268, -0.024737441912293434, -0.0027349230367690325, -0.01620398461818695, -0.008191296830773354, -0.007030606735497713, -0.03849129006266594, -0.03331198915839195, -0.05519481003284454, -0.06813250482082367, -0.012312705628573895, 0.013327513821423054, 0.020847167819738388, -0.0002968414919450879, -0.016711128875613213, -0.04860319197177887, -0.01569710485637188, -0.04748079180717468, -0.05216163396835327, -0.0016789027722552419, -0.01531548798084259, 0.03361635282635689, 0.016919413581490517, 0.05280134081840515, 0.00001803335180738941, 0.0045233252458274364, -0.04670508950948715, 0.04066046327352524, -0.02447277493774891, 0.017889807000756264, 0.01988060586154461, 0.05169019103050232, -0.047251056879758835, 0.019864238798618317, -0.02892484702169895, 0.04222998768091202, 0.010828874073922634, -0.0888354480266571, 0.019447345286607742, -0.0321727879345417, -0.004673712886869907, -0.09389805048704147, -0.06596001237630844, -0.04265069216489792, -0.037708722054958344, 0.01666712760925293, 0.017861349508166313, 0.01856542006134987, -0.08953845500946045, 0.05048810690641403, 0.024060094729065895, 0.007398607209324837, 0.047583527863025665, -0.03958656266331673, 0.03398716822266579, -0.01366300880908966, -0.0301488246768713, 0.03139203041791916, 0.02377260848879814, 0.014570368453860283, -0.04510899633169174, -0.037824515253305435, 0.0014992729993537068, 0.010767404921352863, 0.02052546665072441, 0.014274392277002335, 0.08922848105430603, 0.046447932720184326, 0.006381910759955645, -0.020760230720043182, 0.08082714676856995, 0.01758524589240551, -0.06120125204324722, -0.046539273113012314, -0.07658559083938599, 0.004902670159935951, 0.011889698915183544, 0.005046742036938667, -0.010221879929304123, 0.04393366351723671, 0.04769619181752205, -0.004243412520736456, -0.039363425225019455, 0.03248957544565201, 0.008159345015883446, -0.03505776822566986, 0.01933109387755394, 0.01479128748178482, 0.00582323269918561, 0.01300953421741724, 0.018885791301727295, 0.025935640558600426, -0.03752249851822853, -0.01857968606054783, -0.018445372581481934, 0.04778311401605606, 0.016601013019680977, -0.025575101375579834, 0.03210054710507393, 0.05431642383337021, 0.04371647909283638, -0.042244262993335724, -0.0344708077609539, 0.034891705960035324, -0.026909269392490387, -0.006329532712697983, 0.030758583918213844, -0.026018399745225906, -0.037625834345817566, 0.01778140664100647, -0.036821503192186356, -0.00003986837691627443, 0.012669531628489494, -0.01405273750424385, -0.02430105395615101, -0.04376090690493584, -0.024808889254927635, 0.03154417872428894, -0.002541059162467718, 0.03817106410861015, 0.04836176708340645, -0.007242708932608366, 0.0272462610155344, 0.010020576417446136, 0.029723025858402252, -0.00500700157135725, -0.03586834669113159, -0.04933987930417061, 0.012000491842627525, 0.03856978565454483, 0.0022881885524839163, -0.038945529609918594, -0.023785974830389023, 0.023659100756049156, -0.06934509426355362, 0.03134651109576225, -0.011152088642120361, -0.01517754141241312, 0.07633073627948761, -0.025010786950588226, 0.00925001036375761, -0.047933995723724365, -0.019554879516363144, -0.008571075275540352, 0.049624212086200714, -0.016243649646639824, -0.026496300473809242, -0.01340159960091114, -0.0708540752530098, 0.009371260181069374, 0.027398496866226196, 0.021456651389598846, 0.033782947808504105, 0.03341232240200043, -0.02333395928144455, 0.015687888488173485, 0.02643231488764286, -0.04712923988699913, -0.03481259196996689, -0.049124132841825485, -0.04615684226155281, 0.014581495895981789, -0.06565026193857193, -0.0345412902534008, -0.006613489240407944, -0.0072250510565936565, 0.03049505315721035, -0.015071631409227848, -0.029625890776515007, -0.08436399698257446, 0.05719539523124695, 0.02244574949145317, -0.0036857735831290483, 0.011747267097234726, -0.003952599596232176, -0.03144155442714691, 0.07383851706981659, 0.05717238783836365, 0.0006083025364205241, 0.0366135910153389, 0.05062760412693024, 0.024427788332104683, 0.010987551882863045, 0.016399508342146873, -0.0025741118006408215, 0.030898548662662506, -0.020788269117474556, 0.01814086176455021, 0.0013275995152071118, 0.03700738400220871, 0.041542600840330124, 0.033532045781612396, 0.008175664581358433, -0.05016862601041794, -0.003490402828902006, -0.03754864260554314, -0.033679258078336716, -0.042515020817518234, -0.0044772992841899395, -0.05611011013388634, -0.07651995122432709, 0.05855843797326088, 0.03210205212235451, 0.012020817026495934, 0.015019993297755718, 0.054032210260629654, 0.048761073499917984, -0.005721076391637325, 0.03822161629796028, 0.07044234126806259, 0.029749104753136635, 0.01770189218223095, -0.03859097883105278, 0.012827649712562561, -0.031798288226127625, -0.04716591536998749, -0.05215288698673248, -0.045102428644895554, 0.01696002669632435, 0.008334843441843987, 0.02217431552708149, -0.009693027473986149, 0.011400814168155193, -0.0008313203579746187, 0.029227137565612793, -0.028772665187716484, 0.008747318759560585, -0.026417914777994156, -0.0070519340224564075, 0.0655011534690857, -0.0286989938467741, -0.055311910808086395, -0.040635138750076294, -0.0111990449950099, -0.019084755331277847, 0.06313320249319077, -0.035734258592128754, -0.01590622588992119, 0.0014243259793147445, 0.02073303982615471, 0.02024935930967331, -0.02989823929965496, -0.03554367274045944, 0.02002277970314026, 0.04956905171275139, 0.0011862136889249086, 0.03739302605390549, -0.03229551762342453, 0.029834788292646408, -0.056926462799310684, -0.044129882007837296, -0.020141689106822014, -0.010895317420363426, -0.037213630974292755, -0.018095863983035088, 0.029522135853767395, -0.07980015128850937, 0.013969345949590206, 0.024718930944800377, 0.003884970908984542, 0.05259619280695915, 0.008732093498110771, 0.03687349334359169, -0.032356441020965576, 0.026572559028863907, 0.00020546989981085062, -0.03124612383544445, 0.03659844398498535, -0.025273015722632408, -0.004097592085599899, -0.04393415153026581, -0.09808996319770813, -0.021305479109287262, -0.007489606738090515, 0.010056405328214169, -0.06864196062088013, -0.007272310089319944, -0.016546623781323433, -0.036975547671318054, 0.006188804749399424, 0.06471867114305496, -0.012929288670420647, -0.0353301465511322, 0.05630345270037651, -0.08386895805597305, -0.03352060914039612, -0.06905872374773026, -0.014450744725763798, 0.01791519671678543, 0.004381436854600906, -0.01793690398335457, 0.01465926505625248, -0.023044481873512268, -0.08688034862279892, -0.015107912942767143, 0.03295369818806648, 0.017942966893315315, -0.029979826882481575, -0.003792654722929001, 0.04188309982419014, -0.04241466149687767, 0.028669197112321854, 0.034875914454460144, -0.01973656564950943, 0.011652858927845955, 0.07964426279067993, 0.03737058490514755, -0.04478882998228073, -0.03343384340405464, -0.005135390441864729, -0.027811283245682716, -0.0001846059167291969, -0.016448674723505974, 0.03799985349178314, -0.04169905558228493, 0.00037252710899338126 ]
<p>First of all I beg your forgiveness as I am not a physicist and the question I am going to ask may sound silly.</p> <p>I am aware that beyond a certain threshold in the hierarchy of building blocks of matter (electrons, atoms, etc.) the 'standard' laws of physics (e.g. <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_mechanics" rel="nofollow">Newtonian physics</a>) do not apply and we enter a totally different environment where the so called <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_mechanics" rel="nofollow">quantum mechanics</a> apply. </p> <ul> <li>Where is this threshold located in relation to types of particles? </li> <li>Are there any other similar thresholds in physics indicating completely new environments? If yes, what are they? (other than classical mechanics, quantum mechanics, ...maybe <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/String_theory" rel="nofollow">string theory</a>?).</li> </ul>
g4042
[ -0.0007146106217987835, 0.05981415510177612, -0.01894385553896427, -0.013100038282573223, 0.032745521515607834, 0.04220752418041229, 0.015962859615683556, 0.02960054762661457, 0.010557705536484718, 0.01869504153728485, -0.021084347739815712, 0.018044717609882355, -0.0031645516864955425, -0.0008117040270008147, -0.0003801157872658223, -0.04437575861811638, 0.06702791154384613, -0.005462860222905874, 0.08006369322538376, -0.019545236602425575, -0.06989669054746628, -0.017634740099310875, -0.011333506554365158, -0.055775560438632965, -0.05162227153778076, 0.01447826623916626, -0.03251763433218002, -0.0037069052923470736, -0.030073050409555435, 0.01883149892091751, -0.01515628956258297, -0.07314293831586838, 0.05781613290309906, -0.04629284515976906, 0.015782931819558144, -0.050030991435050964, 0.026911359280347824, 0.0026200783904641867, 0.033801235258579254, -0.0012897576671093702, 0.010425528511404991, -0.014878295361995697, -0.021206311881542206, -0.061581384390592575, -0.001985755516216159, 0.013087472878396511, -0.017319688573479652, -0.016108598560094833, -0.002589076291769743, -0.04787984862923622, 0.035891227424144745, -0.0011753347935155034, 0.003698103129863739, 0.027469294145703316, 0.05043875053524971, 0.01900305598974228, 0.017541442066431046, 0.015591930598020554, 0.0765322893857956, 0.004267694428563118, 0.020471131429076195, 0.033388059586286545, 0.019694071263074875, -0.01938626915216446, -0.00683492049574852, 0.060046516358852386, -0.028870509937405586, 0.0034225948620587587, -0.04093422368168831, -0.07446423172950745, 0.053496405482292175, -0.005723947659134865, -0.08012250065803528, -0.044286761432886124, -0.0313417986035347, 0.03716453164815903, 0.019293952733278275, 0.0300239659845829, 0.042712096124887466, 0.009586747735738754, -0.04681703820824623, 0.013310211710631847, 0.029985720291733742, -0.004203643649816513, 0.056844986975193024, 0.015879251062870026, -0.006780809257179499, 0.014463971368968487, -0.010346464812755585, 0.07479272037744522, 0.04449033364653587, -0.00786703173071146, 0.04622643440961838, -0.05482818931341171, -0.037134334444999695, -0.013006809167563915, 0.016271937638521194, 0.06328295171260834, -0.008047095499932766, -0.022299548611044884, -0.00012506487837526947, -0.03184853121638298, 0.0724877417087555, -0.03500203788280487, -0.04267146810889244, 0.03267226740717888, -0.017441803589463234, 0.002835681661963463, 0.0036280120257288218, -0.004889297299087048, -0.039363011717796326, 0.03930683434009552, -0.055616702884435654, -0.002097032032907009, -0.05019087716937065, -0.0003951570251956582, 0.05096708610653877, -0.0021338663063943386, -0.031222235411405563, 0.053907688707113266, 0.01720600202679634, 0.06652327626943588, 0.049069929867982864, 0.03987256437540054, -0.09115485101938248, -0.02189510501921177, 0.008179728873074055, -0.008453425019979477, 0.009438244625926018, -0.06024875119328499, 0.05011817440390587, -0.01112586259841919, -0.048233505338430405, 0.004235515836626291, -0.01348252221941948, 0.055868521332740784, 0.03938186168670654, -0.017275618389248848, -0.007102614734321833, -0.02924371138215065, 0.007276587653905153, -0.02035137265920639, 0.02983180247247219, -0.011658573523163795, -0.03150313347578049, -0.05524890497326851, 0.006060522980988026, 0.041580576449632645, -0.039857685565948486, 0.04840308800339699, 0.011437040753662586, 0.011073492467403412, 0.05184299871325493, -0.009261906147003174, -0.04976882413029671, -0.025507483631372452, -0.023884255439043045, 0.03476119786500931, -0.019517486914992332, -0.025118600577116013, 0.025790570303797722, -0.011455421335995197, -0.0021084649488329887, -0.025483403354883194, -0.05740958824753761, 0.01412506215274334, -0.04804034158587456, -0.029876813292503357, 0.04190008342266083, 0.004268559627234936, -0.04828302189707756, 0.002109822118654847, 0.002481671515852213, 0.04379979148507118, -0.001177610014565289, 0.08925383538007736, 0.04359648749232292, -0.039325155317783356, 0.013561430387198925, 0.010574311949312687, -0.013027009554207325, -0.048052120953798294, 0.060399968177080154, -0.0008011753670871258, -0.011588747613132, 0.02080114185810089, -0.007938439957797527, -0.010509761981666088, -0.007758270483464003, -0.023868290707468987, -0.05256980285048485, -0.0579659640789032, 0.012864465825259686, -0.02270548976957798, -0.0273506548255682, -0.03589737415313721, -0.0065365200862288475, -0.0530993826687336, -0.016773361712694168, -0.08040808141231537, 0.037750620394945145, 0.08119863271713257, -0.015754450112581253, -0.01809050142765045, 0.02242673560976982, 0.02447609417140484, 0.03636220470070839, 0.0336487703025341, 0.030732933431863785, -0.007512760814279318, -0.007357926573604345, -0.0025826673954725266, 0.02633710578083992, 0.035945825278759, -0.0003550004039425403, 0.0024278187192976475, -0.002393786096945405, 0.014144656248390675, 0.019155286252498627, 0.044558919966220856, 0.02105964720249176, 0.006123251747339964, -0.011389374732971191, 0.029724545776844025, 0.025425368919968605, -0.01903846487402916, -0.03882208839058876, 0.0014321451308205724, 0.016688911244273186, 0.06637855619192123, -0.0686282068490982, -0.030193518847227097, -0.04242052882909775, -0.06829607486724854, 0.023190464824438095, 0.049917105585336685, 0.022533554583787918, -0.07236821949481964, 0.03733159601688385, 0.011233464814722538, 0.02683241106569767, 0.0042732954025268555, -0.06773988902568817, 0.011672564782202244, -0.005712797865271568, -0.06807740032672882, -0.0246745552867651, -0.042232099920511246, -0.030848553404211998, 0.00450399424880743, 0.0022515275049954653, -0.042446035891771317, -0.0544234924018383, 0.010051332414150238, -0.023622307926416397, 0.055194929242134094, 0.02438203990459442, 0.03258071467280388, -0.07043319195508957, -0.039523813873529434, -0.014086245559155941, 0.008746149018406868, 0.04400712251663208, 0.01333176251500845, -0.013003084808588028, -0.0011952315689995885, -0.03266819193959236, 0.006413844879716635, 0.005506003275513649, 0.022122014313936234, -0.024207480251789093, 0.09077588468790054, -0.018460264429450035, -0.002246089279651642, 0.0437416173517704, -0.009328540414571762, 0.03468431532382965, 0.009923471137881279, 0.024897247552871704, -0.012960832566022873, -0.05362514778971672, -0.005360910668969154, -0.028860105201601982, -0.019982893019914627, 0.020679108798503876, -0.08531360328197479, 0.030214009806513786, -0.022154273465275764, -0.044431932270526886, 0.020407970994710922, -0.011538267135620117, 0.019951043650507927, 0.008393173106014729, 0.05381711572408676, -0.010121875442564487, 0.03911013901233673, 0.018415747210383415, -0.00952643621712923, -0.05248536169528961, 0.07757942378520966, -0.03845909237861633, -0.06662680208683014, 0.03280610963702202, 0.012294850312173367, 0.0394129753112793, -0.0007438356988132, -0.020286554470658302, -0.03971756622195244, -0.03846525028347969, 0.0016548355342820287, -0.0431620329618454, 0.06761541962623596, 0.04786292091012001, -0.010919670574367046, -0.028154605999588966, -0.029071945697069168, 0.004526116885244846, 0.058233633637428284, 0.01625981740653515, -0.04825626313686371, -0.038325000554323196, -0.03190711885690689, 0.048284269869327545, -0.02567066065967083, 0.0312492698431015, 0.0433151014149189, -0.0187376718968153, -0.014641022309660912, -0.026647156104445457, -0.023537611588835716, 0.08902713656425476, -0.012988710775971413, 0.007570683490484953, 0.0016484602820128202, -0.10881663858890533, -0.0639805942773819, -0.04558463394641876, 0.0010563002433627844, 0.08368657529354095, -0.03134806081652641, 0.011760846711695194, 0.029497461393475533, -0.0190290380269289, -0.0002234657440567389, -0.03102697618305683, 0.040449708700180054, -0.0028876366559416056, 0.01879867911338806, 0.0021045480389147997, -0.004626931622624397, 0.017559820786118507, 0.003277014708146453, -0.04115305095911026, -0.024234222248196602, -0.06648870557546616, 0.021137217059731483, 0.0354156494140625, 0.022396281361579895, 0.0005003336118534207, -0.012858761474490166, -0.030111033469438553, -0.03578805550932884, 0.055611155927181244, -0.010543815791606903, -0.0036784333642572165, 0.036736637353897095, -0.009427580051124096, -0.0345025509595871, 0.004213723819702864, -0.02218633145093918, 0.021186962723731995, -0.008040295913815498, -0.016729963943362236, 0.027999622747302055, 0.028306595981121063, 0.01623672991991043, 0.05887908861041069, 0.020526818931102753, -0.04035406559705734, -0.03164708986878395, -0.006152712274342775, -0.009941601194441319, 0.02613946609199047, -0.01565806195139885, 0.028880320489406586, 0.01803363859653473, -0.04810478538274765, -0.04160831868648529, -0.031666845083236694, 0.005999838933348656, -0.0160180926322937, 0.04897880554199219, 0.007725807838141918, 0.05603587254881859, 0.014555060304701328, 0.008248023688793182, 0.031762342900037766, 0.005256833042949438, 0.04912176355719566, 0.044934723526239395, 0.015950104221701622, 0.010200828313827515, 0.00799224991351366, 0.016268229112029076, 0.03615780547261238, -0.0022248306777328253, 0.011804474517703056, 0.026295926421880722, -0.05419197306036949, -0.043973494321107864, 0.03133078292012215, -0.058842405676841736, -0.02503015287220478, -0.02019454538822174, 0.010962856002151966, -0.004522856790572405, -0.01496235653758049, -0.03979518264532089, -0.01367637887597084, 0.022330859676003456, -0.035830795764923096, 0.012011077255010605, -0.0004195659712422639, -0.014343367889523506, 0.006196079310029745, 0.022360950708389282, 0.005842430517077446, 0.01903652772307396, -0.016737323254346848, -0.027833236381411552, 0.013268515467643738, 0.015580221079289913, -0.034883953630924225, -0.008985252119600773, -0.003651257138699293, 0.025461260229349136, -0.10202206671237946, -0.02065022476017475, 0.013685673475265503, -0.025480495765805244, 0.06830842047929764, -0.0011279647005721927, 0.004805188626050949, 0.014030180871486664, -0.017621997743844986, 0.08196056634187698, -0.01383515726774931, -0.01591479405760765, -0.015162864699959755, 0.0034748294856399298, -0.05154513195157051, 0.05279964208602905, -0.06678836047649384, -0.04716097563505173, -0.024771012365818024, -0.036086782813072205, -0.039280083030462265, 0.06341185420751572, -0.01257132925093174, 0.01140609197318554, -0.10285357385873795, 0.01470851432532072, -0.06411173194646835, 0.005975271109491587, -0.04268234223127365, -0.01814211532473564, -0.06876768916845322, 0.04937063902616501, -0.07055601477622986, -0.04031927138566971, 0.05046793445944786, -0.0048495568335056305, 0.0325033999979496, 0.06347489356994629, -0.008179042488336563, 0.028436174616217613, 0.03540237620472908, 0.02542620711028576, -0.03552026301622391, -0.05331812798976898, 0.002336418954655528, 0.0002309921255800873, 0.010186868719756603, 0.0572555810213089, -0.016532327979803085, 0.048649780452251434, -0.0487552285194397, 0.01657211408019066, -0.01124805212020874, -0.021878037601709366, 0.017340974882245064, 0.047308288514614105, -0.020946083590388298, 0.01294940710067749, -0.023439038544893265, 0.003882399760186672, 0.04127706587314606, -0.023448394611477852, 0.002627707552164793, 0.008163305930793285, -0.07485444843769073, -0.014943737536668777, 0.03963776305317879, -0.005884868558496237, -0.016838621348142624, 0.02556147240102291, 0.02306802198290825, -0.048462171107530594, 0.039882026612758636, -0.03144439682364464, -0.01364108081907034, -0.004420244134962559, -0.009587333537638187, 0.019866524264216423, 0.026426007971167564, 0.05327305942773819, 0.0012941560707986355, 0.05189836397767067, -0.062346410006284714, -0.07447468489408493, -0.0175029169768095, -0.04738749563694, 0.044047411531209946, 0.009709703736007214, -0.003934885375201702, 0.04425584897398949, -0.0376315601170063, -0.027278970927000046, 0.017499534413218498, 0.11664693802595139, 0.0009498466388322413, 0.0032604155130684376, -0.0016300193965435028, 0.01802605390548706, 0.043711427599191666, -0.04675789922475815, -0.03214273974299431, -0.0007984294788911939, -0.01105099730193615, 0.06916779279708862, -0.03079504892230034, -0.016536284238100052, 0.007619807962328196, 0.007606585044413805, 0.008795322850346565, -0.001054195687174797, -0.0012306105345487595, 0.027749892324209213, 0.07103826850652695, -0.06587189435958862, -0.027322901412844658, -0.004845223855227232, 0.005870518274605274, 0.015234502032399178, 0.02318825200200081, 0.05730896070599556, 0.013119276612997055, 0.02244214341044426, -0.020060749724507332, 0.026458019390702248, 0.03429045528173447, 0.011198741383850574, 0.050512440502643585, 0.017019692808389664, 0.008030164986848831, -0.051436685025691986, -0.019548071548342705, -0.03370743617415428, 0.07312347739934921, 0.05182093009352684, 0.033704742789268494, -0.011566095985472202, 0.04001753404736519, 0.022453196346759796, 0.016246382147073746, 0.03752688691020012, -0.07089085131883621, 0.009975261054933071, -0.02758415974676609, 0.03189057856798172, -0.003180368337780237, 0.042561985552310944, 0.0241952333599329, -0.0451422780752182, -0.041723135858774185, 0.07381176203489304, -0.008698495104908943, -0.028740908950567245, 0.015017765574157238, -0.005867965053766966, -0.0343674011528492, -0.037249550223350525, -0.01353359967470169, -0.00776236318051815, -0.03249127045273781, -0.016775313764810562, -0.004223093390464783, -0.06117692217230797, -0.000721353164408356, 0.06665638089179993, 0.006588554009795189, -0.042780570685863495, 0.010591631755232811, -0.030186861753463745, 0.08956120163202286, 0.0844142809510231, -0.05823063477873802, 0.013674300163984299, 0.008196416310966015, 0.05994464457035065, 0.016335001215338707, -0.03135274350643158, 0.02685442753136158, 0.02298644185066223, -0.013958144001662731, -0.06258127838373184, -0.004659838043153286, -0.0189359188079834, -0.05270213633775711, 0.025227030739188194, 0.03671766817569733, -0.019049985334277153, 0.03458096832036972, -0.0074144829995930195, 0.008418017067015171, 0.009441637434065342, -0.02857525646686554, 0.05915188044309616, 0.07576587796211243, -0.03420049697160721, 0.01450737752020359, -0.01422624010592699, -0.019011836498975754, 0.11970578879117966, -0.04068845883011818, -0.02880464307963848, -0.006182533223181963, -0.05575064197182655, 0.002602283377200365, -0.004460932686924934, 0.014813973568379879, -0.010893182829022408, 0.04707711189985275, -0.010572580620646477, 0.024466417729854584, -0.009733522310853004, 0.04399597644805908, -0.007197350729256868, -0.03822237625718117, -0.004269362892955542, 0.016403499990701675, -0.04401901736855507, -0.005478645674884319, -0.049689002335071564, -0.017521770671010017, 0.023747116327285767, -0.005604657810181379, 0.0034651029855012894, 0.024946944788098335, -0.07353575527667999, -0.02845323644578457, -0.0024502836167812347, -0.0014148990157991648, 0.010311347432434559, 0.019786957651376724, 0.04804634302854538, 0.02375917136669159, -0.07519935071468353, -0.026448272168636322, -0.0124618886038661, 0.043416205793619156, -0.05435984581708908, -0.054020680487155914, 0.016813579946756363, -0.013391928747296333, -0.024029038846492767, -0.02418219856917858, 0.061094608157873154, -0.01101886946707964, -0.02816588804125786, 0.057421762496232986, 0.017218496650457382, 0.020842719823122025, -0.04435981065034866, 0.004085095599293709, 0.05056937038898468, 0.006500333081930876, 0.013694057241082191, 0.051518529653549194, -0.014167983084917068, -0.024971380829811096, 0.027000680565834045, 0.03885672986507416, -0.07845912128686905, 0.034791797399520874, 0.00016632075130473822, 0.08045128732919693, 0.030823029577732086, 0.0616845078766346, -0.04792281985282898, -0.04433409869670868, -0.008739614859223366, -0.025825364515185356, -0.05249132588505745, 0.020685970783233643, 0.006936809979379177, -0.02665601670742035, -0.033331505954265594, -0.01662096008658409, 0.03505541384220123, -0.023531636223196983, 0.08088979125022888, 0.06628315895795822, 0.043186068534851074, 0.005887181498110294, -0.0015676115872338414, -0.0026470788288861513, 0.02504749782383442, 0.029545089229941368, 0.0053294082172214985, 0.028973132371902466, -0.006892753299325705, -0.021750232204794884, -0.02999173477292061, 0.023833271116018295, 0.005016545299440622, 0.03387279435992241, -0.010261966846883297, -0.013391843065619469, -0.03607260435819626, -0.009136311709880829, -0.0458555594086647, 0.024921342730522156, 0.028047708794474602, -0.12419094145298004, 0.04220939800143242, 0.05641864612698555, 0.008170072920620441, 0.0031882342882454395, -0.025465551763772964, 0.006309454329311848, -0.006937652360647917, -0.004273836500942707, 0.02302326075732708, -0.03147661313414574, -0.04384097084403038, -0.03605565428733826, 0.019044430926442146, -0.023329226300120354, -0.029948679730296135, -0.03796175494790077, 0.03799305111169815, 0.005434344056993723, 0.02553599700331688, 0.012585972435772419, -0.09940340369939804, -0.03262018412351608, 0.04082629084587097, 0.02869526483118534, 0.004030872602015734, 0.030090784654021263, -0.005824316293001175, 0.017967745661735535, -0.024708488956093788, 0.011392377316951752, -0.020018449053168297, 0.009239708073437214, -0.0007663336000405252 ]
<p>I have this problem: They give me, from a satellite that is in orbit in earth, a value for the period, and the closest height to earth surface, the ask me what the eccentricty of the orbit is. I have no idea how to do this. I've tried using Binet's equation, and the equation that comes for these movements ($p/r=1+e\cos(\theta-\theta_0)$) or the conservation of angular momentum to try to get some relations between quantities, but I can't get anything.</p> <p>For example, the angular momentum is conserved, so: $$l=mr^2\dot \phi$$ I can get from here: $$\int_0^T\frac{l}{mr^2}dt=2\pi$$ Being T the period, but I don't know $r(t)$ Or the other way: $$T\frac{l}{m}=\int_0^{2\pi}r(\phi)d\phi$$ Now I now the function $r(\phi)=\frac{p}{1+e\cos\phi}$, where $p=\frac{l^2}{\mu k}$, being $l$ the angular momentum and $k$ the constant of the gravity potential: $U=-k/r$. I don't know how to integrate that if it's possible or how to use the known value of the closest point. Some help?</p>
g4043
[ 0.010685521177947521, -0.03179198503494263, 0.007817910984158516, -0.03036327473819256, 0.0044107153080403805, 0.019260192289948463, 0.020941291004419327, -0.048308439552783966, -0.022093048319220543, 0.003420249791815877, 0.009231695905327797, 0.027195855975151062, 0.06268849223852158, -0.0179717019200325, 0.04729342833161354, -0.007529506925493479, 0.0869685634970665, 0.021425489336252213, 0.02352188155055046, 0.03579369932413101, 0.043989721685647964, -0.021663891151547432, -0.01062532514333725, 0.003019599476829171, 0.007413846906274557, -0.00175918557215482, 0.015070443041622639, 0.044249504804611206, -0.03635942563414574, 0.021485203877091408, -0.025117693468928337, -0.00347386347129941, 0.03206596150994301, -0.02980823628604412, -0.04687995836138725, 0.0011210654629394412, 0.009142352268099785, -0.011041034013032913, 0.003452487289905548, -0.020130805671215057, 0.012807151302695274, -0.0804368406534195, 0.01533496007323265, 0.05901111289858818, 0.023494210094213486, -0.019812889397144318, -0.03717000037431717, -0.01337655633687973, 0.012208870612084866, -0.03763856738805771, 0.022525876760482788, 0.08913248032331467, 0.012978458777070045, 0.005163562949746847, -0.03543151542544365, 0.045796461403369904, 0.03747902438044548, -0.07471130043268204, 0.03010803647339344, 0.01154920645058155, 0.010636987164616585, -0.06756949424743652, -0.018634676933288574, 0.020854869857430458, 0.054561033844947815, -0.037772614508867264, -0.01522679440677166, 0.02195308543741703, -0.030118800699710846, -0.01326559204608202, 0.01664513163268566, -0.0229362603276968, 0.00958420243114233, -0.026310812681913376, -0.060812223702669144, 0.018984060734510422, -0.0025447956286370754, -0.0043042548932135105, 0.04772217199206352, 0.0035567712038755417, -0.03586583584547043, 0.001317547750659287, 0.013480274938046932, -0.014948002062737942, 0.06586891412734985, -0.010885706171393394, 0.008235874585807323, 0.025419432669878006, -0.018370427191257477, 0.002775589469820261, 0.00730857253074646, -0.08460558950901031, 0.030295107513666153, -0.06261394917964935, 0.026073655113577843, 0.026698807254433632, -0.006332336459308863, 0.03338608145713806, -0.00714805256575346, -0.029212305322289467, 0.008020353503525257, 0.009295924566686153, -0.03788686543703079, 0.006028084550052881, 0.03940723463892937, 0.05089598894119263, 0.022858338430523872, 0.007518232800066471, 0.06363146007061005, -0.022094212472438812, 0.009658334776759148, -0.053515661507844925, 0.004055325407534838, -0.05013188719749451, -0.019236169755458832, -0.03284037485718727, 0.00853047240525484, -0.03259899839758873, 0.020533442497253418, 0.052975308150053024, -0.033689238131046295, 0.000005389118541643256, 0.01892426423728466, 0.08438672870397568, -0.008148480206727982, -0.015605665743350983, -0.009526414796710014, -0.011543739587068558, 0.026864951476454735, 0.04034256562590599, -0.057807568460702896, -0.03573554381728172, 0.04006854444742203, -0.04229685291647911, -0.017407452687621117, 0.01231556199491024, -0.0259800236672163, -0.013809071853756905, -0.0034010361414402723, -0.01457701250910759, -0.020427513867616653, -0.02998521365225315, 0.02577562816441059, -0.01203895453363657, -0.053566593676805496, 0.05985941365361214, -0.00500611262395978, -0.04759703949093819, 0.032669562846422195, 0.0035075803752988577, 0.028656739741563797, 0.07775764912366867, -0.020533300936222076, -0.010662796907126904, 0.059452444314956665, -0.04699982330203056, -0.01387624628841877, 0.055203281342983246, -0.009048111736774445, 0.013539250008761883, 0.05415884777903557, 0.025325454771518707, 0.008403398096561432, 0.024584196507930756, -0.040484774857759476, 0.02813936397433281, -0.006006699986755848, -0.04736130312085152, -0.03548185154795647, -0.07412414252758026, -0.03733871132135391, -0.02701869234442711, 0.049689214676618576, 0.06715063750743866, -0.047512236982584, 0.04565121605992317, -0.013786433264613152, -0.02787727117538452, 0.05627068132162094, 0.004617040045559406, 0.05417546257376671, -0.020672393962740898, 0.07059773802757263, 0.029001427814364433, -0.0352245457470417, 0.0008045584545470774, 0.07050322741270065, 0.026947110891342163, -0.023014482110738754, -0.008599787019193172, 0.034993331879377365, 0.01273867767304182, 0.014294024556875229, -0.012237099930644035, -0.03026273101568222, 0.0026435144245624542, 0.06993328779935837, -0.023600172251462936, -0.10658437758684158, 0.03777187317609787, -0.03115214593708515, 0.01892358995974064, 0.050320178270339966, 0.03734497353434563, -0.004318083170801401, -0.009809853509068489, 0.060056641697883606, 0.009192196652293205, 0.021312443539500237, 0.05686608701944351, -0.02944878116250038, -0.09696312248706818, -0.029772581532597542, 0.048352181911468506, -0.027098678052425385, 0.006086306646466255, 0.014250151813030243, 0.032047338783741, -0.02637646719813347, 0.04580012336373329, -0.0761987641453743, -0.017808759585022926, 0.011902146972715855, 0.03349781408905983, 0.004710508044809103, -0.0058805979788303375, 0.011009033769369125, 0.010934412479400635, 0.02479461021721363, 0.03288981691002846, -0.00022546194668393582, 0.03654558211565018, 0.0752757340669632, 0.01806000992655754, 0.043182991445064545, 0.013457568362355232, 0.019699450582265854, -0.0015756343491375446, 0.007291407790035009, 0.024832680821418762, 0.00023012231395114213, -0.003749445779249072, 0.0024100681766867638, -0.01319090835750103, 0.032225023955106735, 0.03993142768740654, 0.058967895805835724, 0.11131007969379425, 0.001470393966883421, 0.002110940171405673, -0.000057990571804111823, 0.05108090490102768, -0.04635613039135933, 0.03736075758934021, -0.008678007870912552, 0.014181074686348438, -0.06661387532949448, 0.024527687579393387, -0.059508152306079865, 0.01805906929075718, -0.029693761840462685, -0.10792595893144608, 0.035556990653276443, 0.018048781901597977, -0.012472513131797314, -0.005982351489365101, -0.0645633339881897, 0.014991894364356995, 0.013958523981273174, 0.014090930111706257, -0.024417757987976074, 0.06945477426052094, 0.0650375485420227, 0.13100948929786682, -0.06301568448543549, -0.03679213672876358, -0.015332209877669811, -0.03626322001218796, -0.02801593579351902, -0.026738351210951805, -0.01115795411169529, -0.007834401912987232, 0.01984754577279091, 0.07795265316963196, 0.02156749740242958, -0.003958170767873526, -0.0033413583878427744, 0.11523358523845673, -0.041706670075654984, -0.006397344172000885, -0.0026611792854964733, -0.004714924842119217, 0.029613325372338295, 0.07248489558696747, 0.012361925095319748, -0.0015292973257601261, 0.001521995640359819, -0.021901331841945648, -0.002624090760946274, 0.02428421936929226, 0.08721645176410675, -0.0017746511148288846, 0.00032101970282383263, 0.024187764152884483, 0.004130363930016756, -0.0009433440864086151, -0.044538214802742004, -0.04535035789012909, -0.007675691042095423, 0.015634112060070038, -0.05138656869530678, 0.010881457477807999, -0.034635115414857864, -0.009770565666258335, -0.028567994013428688, -0.002118950942531228, -0.014917218126356602, -0.03298836573958397, -0.006612581200897694, 0.049337953329086304, -0.01404324360191822, -0.08283603191375732, -0.032903991639614105, 0.007588787004351616, -0.02529594488441944, 0.04196297749876976, -0.06938255578279495, 0.05245424807071686, -0.07644015550613403, -0.03080436959862709, -0.014190752990543842, 0.015882952138781548, -0.017305942252278328, -0.02975611574947834, -0.013394529931247234, 0.048002079129219055, 0.0029674265533685684, 0.01684178225696087, 0.0584774985909462, 0.016242187470197678, -0.062076374888420105, 0.03500353544950485, -0.042524553835392, -0.03588223084807396, 0.013300365768373013, -0.016782796010375023, -0.012904444709420204, 0.015979453921318054, 0.0006644977838732302, -0.039852943271398544, -0.013935750350356102, 0.016956821084022522, 0.011055059731006622, -0.044745493680238724, 0.046929892152547836, 0.05083180591464043, -0.01815994828939438, 0.04382774978876114, 0.01795089989900589, 0.027249649167060852, 0.021866029128432274, -0.024156322702765465, 0.0029414098244160414, 0.04840240254998207, 0.007668314501643181, -0.05666785314679146, -0.015939239412546158, 0.04280064254999161, 0.004817056469619274, -0.002550553996115923, -0.006251761689782143, 0.010880419053137302, 0.040650125592947006, -0.02645447850227356, 0.03995953127741814, -0.06793751567602158, -0.019160451367497444, -0.05233854427933693, -0.046041958034038544, 0.0031446246430277824, -0.03284968435764313, 0.009604317136108875, -0.029177840799093246, 0.003369153942912817, 0.06336850672960281, 0.05255808308720589, -0.0034879453014582396, 0.0163275059312582, 0.0810026079416275, -0.04266216978430748, 0.05718539282679558, -0.07233449071645737, -0.027738606557250023, -0.02012045495212078, 0.022636696696281433, -0.009248640388250351, 0.01847790740430355, -0.00419606501236558, -0.04576646164059639, -0.004515259992331266, -0.02147388644516468, -0.004361164290457964, -0.015078513883054256, 0.007562654092907906, -0.04324227571487427, 0.040669217705726624, 0.018489954993128777, -0.021671663969755173, 0.019275564700365067, -0.007984785363078117, 0.00962057989090681, 0.000378867523977533, 0.03902857005596161, -0.027168983593583107, -0.0051535069942474365, -0.0003055107081308961, -0.01003960333764553, -0.03366300091147423, 0.024013573303818703, -0.014484673738479614, -0.020403647795319557, 0.09284698963165283, 0.004901831969618797, -0.03600243479013443, 0.040624987334012985, 0.016564663499593735, 0.07112852483987808, -0.016201423481106758, 0.019470416009426117, 0.008355028927326202, 0.017101502045989037, 0.020375946536660194, 0.04627512767910957, 0.06919987499713898, -0.08537363260984421, 0.025552254170179367, -0.026544535532593727, -0.010877423919737339, 0.032964076846838, 0.060305964201688766, -0.01658826693892479, 0.05656658858060837, -0.01096100639551878, -0.04288981109857559, 0.002136632101610303, 0.06129881367087364, 0.00042210097308270633, -0.02452486753463745, 0.017329348251223564, -0.00299936905503273, -0.00927889347076416, -0.057954467833042145, 0.005786515306681395, -0.011113828048110008, -0.026128524914383888, 0.02433365397155285, -0.01503139827400446, -0.00936597865074873, -0.017921745777130127, -0.020049473270773888, 0.0037411178927868605, -0.03240647539496422, 0.010645422153174877, -0.00022089698177296668, 0.06284882128238678, -0.0021738724317401648, -0.051347579807043076, 0.04189017042517662, -0.008741366676986217, -0.03944819048047066, 0.049319151788949966, -0.044036805629730225, 0.04859427362680435, 0.014260527677834034, -0.05602067708969116, 0.011677276343107224, -0.050941288471221924, -0.032681867480278015, 0.01778225786983967, -0.05179164186120033, -0.048018068075180054, 0.022149082273244858, -0.04137739539146423, 0.04757990688085556, -0.020846417173743248, 0.010819584131240845, -0.021498067304491997, -0.03854969143867493, 0.019594240933656693, -0.057676516473293304, -0.0552968755364418, 0.009859375655651093, 0.017605649307370186, -0.032779961824417114, 0.020060498267412186, 0.005511117167770863, -0.030175868421792984, 0.015335625037550926, 0.015734678134322166, 0.006403811275959015, 0.020199604332447052, 0.015190459787845612, -0.06895650178194046, 0.05178707093000412, 0.023341944441199303, 0.023679014295339584, 0.025644786655902863, 0.011720452457666397, -0.02793935500085354, -0.010661602951586246, -0.004621824715286493, 0.035695504397153854, -0.02063572034239769, -0.009046340361237526, -0.017096392810344696, -0.000675805495120585, 0.026390600949525833, 0.04403585568070412, -0.045113205909729004, 0.002228326164186001, 0.056344639509916306, -0.01348896324634552, 0.03129233047366142, 0.0006297625368461013, 0.06125307083129883, -0.036789122968912125, -0.0468655489385128, -0.030834659934043884, 0.023445557802915573, 0.022519906982779503, -0.018737711012363434, -0.06004474684596062, -0.06873824447393417, -0.025875551626086235, 0.0011168329510837793, -0.041564151644706726, -0.010868849232792854, 0.018025057390332222, 0.05405229702591896, -0.08075170964002609, -0.07201390713453293, 0.022030306980013847, 0.02216065675020218, 0.03234494477510452, -0.013774784281849861, 0.00744909280911088, -0.04732944443821907, -0.023919017985463142, 0.05464303493499756, 0.001651289756409824, -0.04837977513670921, 0.0271042101085186, -0.0439068041741848, -0.06423073261976242, -0.06237800791859627, -0.0049911076202988625, 0.017155494540929794, -0.018726762384176254, -0.02931346371769905, 0.02706940844655037, 0.008277609013020992, -0.02598162554204464, 0.02297958731651306, 0.023642580956220627, -0.009886672720313072, 0.030889272689819336, 0.0376267246901989, -0.01940278150141239, 0.03408628702163696, -0.043865323066711426, -0.03350072354078293, 0.004961979575455189, -0.010132180526852608, 0.04054165631532669, 0.038871150463819504, 0.006993211805820465, 0.010815839283168316, 0.027103111147880554, -0.031208230182528496, -0.03787099942564964, -0.01776880770921707, 0.01323266513645649, 0.06397087872028351, -0.02910904586315155, -0.04621543735265732, 0.07000584900379181, -0.043849099427461624, -0.06275784969329834, -0.025187799707055092, -0.020346157252788544, 0.0013696677051484585, 0.01635918766260147, -0.040573813021183014, 0.03733677789568901, -0.0017628559144213796, 0.03359699994325638, -0.013389232568442822, -0.035217273980379105, -0.012213664129376411, 0.04959314689040184, 0.030128471553325653, -0.018591590225696564, 0.07694508880376816, -0.010561848059296608, 0.03662462905049324, 0.0036077636759728193, -0.024131786078214645, -0.022518111392855644, -0.00008722036000108346, -0.03030104748904705, 0.0252690427005291, 0.05264653265476227, -0.013668349012732506, 0.014929592609405518, -0.0369490310549736, 0.002652485156431794, 0.004569714888930321, 0.06795680522918701, -0.051251474767923355, 0.00011609138164203614, 0.023200850933790207, 0.020265864208340645, -0.015727221965789795, -0.04643142223358154, 0.06773201376199722, 0.006253245286643505, -0.021562250331044197, -0.02306567132472992, -0.0382271409034729, 0.0198436938226223, 0.01900434121489525, 0.002891961019486189, -0.033034950494766235, -0.007025532424449921, 0.00632495665922761, 0.035054922103881836, -0.04961758106946945, 0.03715404123067856, 0.0003738157683983445, 0.021686699241399765, 0.03513544425368309, 0.011236701160669327, -0.00911835115402937, 0.028892679139971733, -0.0703107938170433, -0.0495833195745945, -0.009181929752230644, -0.04119803383946419, -0.04487990960478783, 0.031169330701231956, 0.05799252167344093, -0.023124732077121735, 0.001119657652452588, 0.018559953197836876, 0.02046690694987774, -0.03050880879163742, 0.008998863399028778, 0.014087153598666191, -0.00800488144159317, -0.02939353883266449, -0.007383824326097965, -0.038190241903066635, -0.0006172647699713707, -0.0050393519923090935, -0.032942142337560654, -0.012806497514247894, -0.041080400347709656, -0.01095573976635933, 0.0020409340504556894, -0.09181055426597595, -0.015342937782406807, -0.03257507085800171, -0.08876480162143707, 0.036456767469644547, -0.04850850999355316, 0.052660100162029266, 0.018676459789276123, -0.03543368726968765, -0.08649952709674835, 0.009143147617578506, -0.044761039316654205, -0.004254063591361046, 0.009541157633066177, 0.01160532608628273, -0.010029071941971779, 0.05597317963838577, -0.0015541899483650923, 0.03076271526515484, 0.020764023065567017, -0.0024485019966959953, -0.014224579557776451, 0.08221935480833054, 0.0010764419566839933, -0.03943631052970886, -0.015602858737111092, -0.047120947390794754, 0.0032411671709269285, 0.01850065030157566, -0.01882397010922432, 0.007174513302743435, 0.04878648370504379, -0.0033939070999622345, 0.06304547190666199, -0.01325817871838808, 0.029570791870355606, -0.003518927376717329, -0.021655995398759842, -0.009118105284869671, -0.05413006991147995, 0.037992581725120544, 0.05610201507806778, -0.0010457697790116072, -0.006198307499289513, -0.04427225887775421, 0.024222666397690773, 0.021061934530735016, 0.025115951895713806, 0.01165158860385418, -0.015695929527282715, -0.02099819853901863, -0.05646314099431038, -0.05174720287322998, 0.011085397563874722, -0.07573547214269638, -0.009673994965851307, 0.0011821581283584237, -0.09199994802474976, -0.036980628967285156, 0.030256295576691628, -0.05737262964248657, -0.0063674114644527435, 0.012638815678656101, -0.03563883900642395, -0.001239107921719551, 0.0426337867975235, -0.008717473596334457, -0.018345557153224945, -0.065851591527462, 0.022658707574009895, 0.026556601747870445, -0.052517034113407135, -0.05038800463080406, 0.03568970412015915, 0.023937784135341644, 0.014291947707533836, -0.014459596015512943, -0.032712940126657486, 0.05023094266653061, 0.057331424206495285, -0.008548001758754253, 0.00008342980436282232, 0.08090406656265259, -0.0018578114686533809, 0.02837471291422844, -0.02025494910776615, -0.04167558252811432, -0.03605953976511955, 0.00443662516772747, 0.01170736737549305, -0.0042456090450286865, -0.04293825104832649, 0.03058844804763794, -0.022793548181653023, 0.05459071323275566, 0.014819354750216007, -0.06571079045534134, -0.0018245885148644447, 0.03660442680120468 ]
<p>And what happens with the magnetic field of a star that goes supernova? The magnetic radiation is scattered through the cosmos? Each particle will go away with its own magnetic radiation?</p>
g4044
[ 0.010716049931943417, 0.06243029236793518, 0.012424550019204617, -0.014021973125636578, 0.0464063361287117, 0.00725862942636013, -0.06778804957866669, 0.02544482983648777, 0.047877416014671326, -0.061193451285362244, -0.05474795401096344, 0.0673917606472969, -0.00011422042007325217, -0.04738786071538925, 0.005630536004900932, -0.015275358222424984, 0.01168864592909813, -0.00427470775321126, 0.0385257825255394, 0.05056837573647499, 0.0070861754938960075, -0.021029585972428322, 0.00199713883921504, 0.008832796476781368, -0.09113810211420059, -0.02243124134838581, 0.017680834978818893, -0.02803102508187294, -0.0037434741389006376, -0.03994431346654892, 0.04549285024404526, 0.005545132793486118, 0.052434809505939484, -0.0333995446562767, 0.008020668290555477, -0.08061271160840988, -0.022164830937981606, 0.04461173713207245, 0.031762439757585526, -0.058037035167217255, 0.018987957388162613, -0.0127202607691288, 0.055535610765218735, -0.050207316875457764, -0.0009434744133614004, 0.016343161463737488, -0.023463472723960876, 0.011423954740166664, -0.04614952206611633, 0.026868555694818497, -0.04456937313079834, -0.02425793744623661, 0.027465514838695526, 0.09395100176334381, -0.0028697566594928503, -0.02776745893061161, 0.04950761795043945, -0.08623173087835312, 0.07379426062107086, -0.04030647128820419, -0.013597452081739902, -0.02611495740711689, -0.009398416616022587, 0.003138146596029401, -0.019135041162371635, -0.005158601328730583, -0.05325305089354515, 0.04424536973237991, 0.013112038373947144, 0.0028357140254229307, 0.04081563279032707, 0.0010765495244413614, -0.005464279558509588, -0.019233563914895058, -0.030514484271407127, 0.03133487328886986, 0.005359309259802103, 0.0019548055715858936, -0.05973941087722778, 0.09040442109107971, -0.007964406162500381, -0.01190757006406784, -0.04253770038485527, 0.020752854645252228, 0.033987920731306076, -0.011851194314658642, 0.03237352892756462, -0.023797841742634773, -0.037577107548713684, 0.0013506594114005566, -0.019709648564457893, 0.052328187972307205, 0.012626483105123043, -0.0569440983235836, 0.06056442856788635, -0.044352054595947266, 0.03688197582960129, -0.016535211354494095, -0.027500802651047707, -0.03896109387278557, -0.01934727653861046, 0.0010074718156829476, -0.0034279015380889177, -0.04488302394747734, 0.0649205893278122, -0.053140025585889816, 0.05641975626349449, 0.01692008040845394, 0.030230006203055382, 0.013793278485536575, -0.039269380271434784, -0.07630500197410583, 0.014782366342842579, 0.03648636117577553, -0.053519029170274734, -0.00789813231676817, 0.07563889771699905, -0.009910430759191513, 0.03411630168557167, 0.047030653804540634, 0.040825143456459045, 0.04556228592991829, -0.0524221770465374, 0.07386261224746704, -0.07015123963356018, -0.0008055405342020094, 0.00882529653608799, 0.008373021148145199, -0.008897636085748672, -0.018370695412158966, -0.009128477424383163, 0.0003594389127101749, 0.0000680688681313768, 0.03685247525572777, -0.025351041927933693, 0.0048330556601285934, 0.0017734912689775229, 0.03336610645055771, -0.010976552031934261, -0.02615896612405777, 0.05897955968976021, 0.01174509059637785, 0.06660351902246475, 0.008127795532345772, -0.03685155510902405, -0.005770811811089516, 0.04355553537607193, 0.0170911718159914, -0.021450750529766083, -0.004753401502966881, 0.0405752919614315, -0.004426034167408943, 0.021855397149920464, -0.0180266834795475, 0.026750104501843452, 0.005805130582302809, -0.012774530798196793, 0.0328986681997776, 0.001993785845115781, -0.021159665659070015, 0.03269345313310623, -0.03636493161320686, 0.0004593807097990066, 0.027401525527238846, -0.04706044867634773, -0.002428377978503704, 0.045238785445690155, -0.0168820321559906, -0.006396010052412748, 0.004191109910607338, -0.004722141660749912, 0.002320302650332451, -0.022546174004673958, 0.03615327179431915, 0.04596526548266411, -0.002982964739203453, 0.017569417133927345, 0.00309160677716136, -0.03213224932551384, 0.021866856142878532, 0.03689949959516525, -0.005652862135320902, 0.03515460342168808, -0.03378314524888992, 0.04924112930893898, -0.04324880987405777, -0.0919509083032608, 0.002242874586954713, -0.008111298084259033, 0.00857649464160204, 0.021008607000112534, -0.008581699803471565, 0.045243505388498306, 0.06168900802731514, 0.015747787430882454, -0.013219792395830154, -0.04346834868192673, 0.024703752249479294, -0.03573973476886749, -0.006766750942915678, 0.029532816261053085, 0.03946244344115257, 0.021403340622782707, 0.016815250739455223, 0.02217128872871399, -0.03016171045601368, -0.011852340772747993, 0.06618357449769974, -0.0021220853086560965, -0.025578465312719345, 0.032736703753471375, -0.01592996157705784, -0.053327009081840515, -0.02479131519794464, -0.06249014660716057, -0.02120094560086727, -0.00865133386105299, 0.018520306795835495, -0.0012193492148071527, 0.0730268731713295, -0.06483655422925949, -0.032577842473983765, 0.055479999631643295, -0.06261686980724335, -0.03366144001483917, 0.018612243235111237, -0.013973788358271122, -0.03487062826752663, 0.05038033798336983, -0.019383234903216362, -0.005633805878460407, -0.024796901270747185, 0.013014724478125572, -0.03960902616381645, -0.011919144541025162, -0.029865877702832222, 0.031145792454481125, -0.006311527453362942, 0.0020177629776299, -0.025632889941334724, -0.05919627100229263, 0.02766219526529312, 0.05330062657594681, -0.049502238631248474, 0.03770797699689865, -0.01524544507265091, 0.04947510361671448, 0.014689432457089424, -0.02804878167808056, -0.034629661589860916, 0.043129775673151016, -0.012655550613999367, 0.006075479555875063, 0.0359899140894413, -0.03104589506983757, 0.01111154817044735, -0.011314286850392818, 0.039728205651044846, -0.06282783299684525, -0.014763728715479374, 0.023513002321124077, -0.008424278348684311, -0.004478962626308203, 0.010377130471169949, 0.05829135328531265, 0.02228972315788269, 0.05252491310238838, 0.059648845344781876, 0.008730421774089336, 0.013555153273046017, -0.05204375460743904, 0.04566721245646477, 0.026302650570869446, 0.03630133345723152, -0.017119821161031723, 0.06218862161040306, 0.01907976344227791, 0.026879966259002686, 0.011352742090821266, -0.03615259379148483, 0.005929384846240282, 0.03118947148323059, -0.014431921765208244, -0.07937393337488174, -0.03162813559174538, -0.06665942072868347, -0.004482203628867865, -0.008368117734789848, 0.009656427428126335, -0.05978033319115639, 0.033936720341444016, -0.008347548544406891, 0.06640918552875519, 0.014626629650592804, 0.0012571888510137796, 0.05647793412208557, 0.04932442680001259, 0.07121885567903519, 0.0017190624494105577, 0.029129955917596817, 0.0832003802061081, -0.020748399198055267, -0.006668915972113609, -0.015755152329802513, -0.0036573545075953007, -0.000810961821116507, -0.041072748601436615, -0.01282338984310627, 0.004583572503179312, -0.007051405962556601, 0.008767605759203434, 0.04181577265262604, 0.05648012086749077, 0.05695303529500961, 0.038562383502721786, 0.016049789264798164, 0.040098775178194046, -0.017281388863921165, 0.06626816093921661, 0.05254051834344864, 0.002910563489422202, 0.00005107276592752896, 0.02989184483885765, -0.007244923152029514, 0.004378801677376032, -0.005764631554484367, 0.03186773136258125, 0.009902874007821083, -0.060717497020959854, -0.015677325427532196, -0.06391847133636475, 0.016038483008742332, -0.008840205147862434, -0.005348370410501957, -0.04446052759885788, 0.05704331770539284, -0.039353370666503906, 0.021204227581620216, 0.013212681747972965, 0.05393468588590622, 0.04903541877865791, -0.030189411714673042, -0.035621270537376404, 0.021529681980609894, 0.022547800093889236, 0.05888824909925461, 0.029180308803915977, -0.07001574337482452, 0.05105946585536003, 0.0008981024147942662, 0.0262635238468647, -0.043394215404987335, 0.059583790600299835, 0.016098810359835625, -0.06009328365325928, -0.010053691454231739, 0.019250791519880295, -0.0005814835894852877, 0.05498233065009117, -0.01910417340695858, 0.024408675730228424, -0.051053524017333984, 0.025868501514196396, 0.019529640674591064, 0.007306132931262255, 0.05702634155750275, 0.02014980837702751, -0.03232503682374954, 0.025543274357914925, 0.025224285200238228, -0.019245073199272156, -0.0429188497364521, -0.04014720022678375, -0.028440212830901146, -0.002951303031295538, -0.0030505226459354162, 0.006121533457189798, -0.005013937130570412, -0.05777420103549957, -0.014324242249131203, 0.014986039139330387, 0.041650984436273575, -0.00047198004904203117, -0.01058255322277546, 0.038624830543994904, 0.03805084154009819, 0.007384973112493753, -0.019396711140871048, -0.03506806120276451, -0.01786613278090954, 0.01450865063816309, -0.05521709844470024, 0.015730688348412514, -0.008118941448628902, 0.0280250683426857, -0.07340442389249802, 0.00027573402621783316, 0.011454804800450802, -0.01086902804672718, -0.021993141621351242, -0.015378662385046482, 0.03351602330803871, 0.030096519738435745, -0.04630813002586365, 0.05699468031525612, -0.022506065666675568, -0.03962360695004463, -0.035602547228336334, -0.024223338812589645, 0.024163486436009407, 0.017000799998641014, 0.018283221870660782, -0.06877105683088303, 0.0007917082984931767, 0.06575268507003784, -0.01927635818719864, 0.025233110412955284, -0.0017500505782663822, -0.05093468353152275, -0.04871131107211113, -0.012752861715853214, -0.021423129364848137, 0.040961652994155884, 0.0000582085303904023, -0.0374772734940052, 0.003991897217929363, 0.011438759043812752, 0.0009475673432461917, -0.02112499810755253, 0.04418586939573288, 0.04466737061738968, 0.047159552574157715, 0.0197035763412714, 0.03230683133006096, -0.04334799200296402, 0.056479331105947495, -0.06515862792730331, -0.02270543947815895, 0.017771322280168533, 0.0675373449921608, 0.05493434518575668, -0.005402944050729275, 0.046060800552368164, 0.009242169559001923, -0.0038943190593272448, 0.043491754680871964, 0.004788404796272516, -0.05217363312840462, -0.027469325810670853, -0.04265390336513519, 0.006576361134648323, -0.002739056246355176, -0.07903823256492615, -0.0008850721642374992, -0.024565936997532845, -0.059016890823841095, 0.008930660784244537, -0.0012032497907057405, 0.05060846358537674, 0.0084763765335083, -0.012589576654136181, 0.0659395381808281, 0.03192247822880745, 0.029759330675005913, 0.024521298706531525, 0.010818129405379295, -0.03275427967309952, -0.0745917335152626, -0.014528600499033928, 0.04346476495265961, -0.008943638764321804, -0.011492440477013588, 0.0053181881085038185, -0.04524289071559906, 0.0016715385718271136, -0.070429727435112, -0.0016539524076506495, -0.013727241195738316, 0.01229297835379839, -0.013003254309296608, -0.03657513111829758, 0.011951335705816746, 0.04634484648704529, 0.01936689019203186, -0.02306145615875721, 0.038747869431972504, -0.012861733324825764, 0.004647498019039631, 0.03180331364274025, -0.04020974785089493, -0.07639188319444656, -0.034688979387283325, 0.07027023285627365, -0.025635218247771263, 0.03988859802484512, -0.07180231809616089, -0.04894014075398445, -0.03153929114341736, -0.00918071623891592, -0.042690835893154144, -0.03879781812429428, -0.04687068983912468, -0.030272405594587326, 0.00452419463545084, -0.036605969071388245, 0.030850090086460114, 0.006014683749526739, -0.025991078466176987, 0.017416054382920265, 0.026114221662282944, 0.0007201845874078572, -0.005307380110025406, 0.03258000686764717, 0.06286243349313736, 0.01549629494547844, 0.009466642513871193, -0.045278679579496384, 0.005968894809484482, 0.041102997958660126, -0.02048921212553978, -0.07907239347696304, 0.025504950433969498, 0.0311737060546875, -0.02495425008237362, 0.04224765673279762, 0.02752804011106491, -0.0101314727216959, 0.003703648690134287, 0.07067051529884338, 0.01048115361481905, -0.023484693840146065, 0.0006110643153078854, -0.006070923060178757, 0.027374856173992157, 0.026009412482380867, -0.03159347176551819, -0.03496377170085907, -0.008222025819122791, 0.0037299017421901226, 0.06919753551483154, -0.04338005185127258, 0.0005187120987102389, 0.03123452141880989, -0.02835749089717865, 0.0042482237331569195, 0.03408946096897125, -0.029584553092718124, 0.061844728887081146, 0.04296113923192024, -0.04169699177145958, -0.061497241258621216, 0.03739071264863014, 0.007393851410597563, 0.034310437738895416, 0.006932264193892479, 0.02641845867037773, 0.02335052378475666, -0.022852027788758278, 0.04760090261697769, -0.026513801887631416, -0.061110809445381165, -0.06297414004802704, 0.03545379638671875, -0.06773469597101212, 0.008314740844070911, 0.0025142512749880552, -0.015823516994714737, -0.08348564803600311, 0.08024577796459198, 0.03180573880672455, 0.0025775565300136805, 0.03566224128007889, -0.027025731280446053, -0.014197294600307941, 0.008514633402228355, 0.01783798448741436, 0.022095954045653343, -0.022637957707047462, -0.006259626243263483, -0.010956275276839733, 0.06445807963609695, -0.013624988496303558, 0.04557723551988602, -0.0064976830035448074, -0.0011553959921002388, 0.023165088146924973, -0.015776872634887695, 0.023123599588871002, 0.04149022325873375, 0.020908772945404053, 0.021617403253912926, -0.06744947284460068, 0.029052844271063805, 0.045033037662506104, -0.08466867357492447, -0.0009060887969098985, -0.02979128807783127, -0.018516436219215393, -0.035733506083488464, -0.02353302575647831, -0.024242723360657692, 0.0008387506240978837, 0.03592782840132713, -0.01829240657389164, 0.03307615965604782, 0.009456989355385303, -0.08292379975318909, -0.01676827110350132, 0.017758581787347794, 0.018827015534043312, 0.026949163526296616, -0.030878126621246338, -0.0020073927007615566, 0.055679116398096085, 0.0004804362542927265, -0.002374893520027399, 0.007345807738602161, -0.017923718318343163, 0.010918846353888512, 0.04900631681084633, -0.04668897017836571, -0.08227531611919403, -0.006980768870562315, -0.026207048445940018, -0.04187176749110222, -0.03969140723347664, 0.005048010963946581, 0.005870659835636616, 0.016477184370160103, 0.057943880558013916, -0.003391113132238388, -0.00394332455471158, 0.0016403860645368695, 0.009433210827410221, 0.0122302807867527, -0.014268159866333008, 0.029829664155840874, -0.006769406609237194, 0.04959403723478317, 0.007761000189930201, 0.019808916375041008, 0.009997192770242691, -0.0319761224091053, -0.01737637259066105, -0.027719981968402863, 0.05018450692296028, -0.009318394586443901, -0.022948911413550377, -0.01625801995396614, -0.02531132474541664, -0.02065292000770569, -0.002988207619637251, 0.006724256090819836, -0.05118994042277336, -0.048496730625629425, -0.005849733017385006, 0.00517495721578598, 0.02617165632545948, -0.048894934356212616, -0.0737653523683548, -0.013641491532325745, -0.05551016330718994, -0.08714790642261505, -0.025603843852877617, 0.03887256607413292, 0.014917340129613876, 0.08808383345603943, -0.045313965529203415, 0.01927785761654377, -0.010180875658988953, -0.0372113473713398, 0.006920846179127693, -0.0637950524687767, -0.02340782806277275, -0.013510900549590588, -0.07570280134677887, -0.05279652401804924, -0.027960648760199547, 0.0636729821562767, -0.006605409551411867, 0.012771320529282093, 0.02690570056438446, 0.04903528094291687, -0.025652240961790085, 0.040854185819625854, 0.04416312649846077, -0.05161915719509125, 0.04058760404586792, 0.06615065783262253, 0.029110947623848915, -0.008827326819300652, -0.012709708884358406, 0.06849654018878937, -0.04516511783003807, 0.00843175407499075, -0.03860700875520706, -0.01319783367216587, 0.02527545392513275, 0.05278225988149643, -0.047525376081466675, -0.01712360978126526, 0.05366840958595276, 0.02635408192873001, -0.01816176436841488, 0.03195642679929733, 0.03234706073999405, 0.022653304040431976, 0.0011341031640768051, -0.04750864952802658, -0.040090300142765045, 0.046916183084249496, 0.024739162996411324, 0.03952406719326973, -0.007523548323661089, 0.009092709980905056, 0.02955198846757412, -0.02081121876835823, -0.009594484232366085, -0.0438830628991127, -0.01944720186293125, -0.05914737656712532, 0.046093810349702835, -0.014153840951621532, 0.03671933338046074, 0.04674907773733139, -0.010942056775093079, -0.06878598779439926, 0.02438523806631565, 0.025233112275600433, -0.050224967300891876, -0.011651309207081795, -0.013235686346888542, -0.0630967989563942, -0.024896852672100067, -0.04356055706739426, -0.027179058641195297, -0.03984757140278816, -0.06997234374284744, -0.01315831858664751, -0.02013237401843071, 0.05335475504398346, -0.06844242662191391, 0.0073222145438194275, -0.03895054757595062, -0.026738706976175308, -0.00399452168494463, -0.024414608255028725, 0.02196737378835678, 0.026188908144831657, -0.021005738526582718, 0.013343485072255135, 0.03718194365501404, -0.028270695358514786, 0.08877631276845932, 0.06207014620304108, -0.021400120109319687, -0.03165838494896889, -0.009992886334657669, -0.05166719853878021, -0.023992668837308884, 0.028088919818401337, -0.029603062197566032, -0.04228506237268448, -0.012222656048834324, 0.0013146840501576662, -0.03416981175541878, 0.018959295004606247, 0.014069470576941967 ]
<p>The assumptions are: </p> <ul> <li>Alice and Bob have perfectly synchronized clocks</li> <li>Alice and Bob have successfully exchanged a pair of entangled photons</li> </ul> <p>The idea is simply to have Alice and Bob perform the Quantum Eraser Experiment (doesn't need to be the delayed choice). </p> <p>Alice and Bob agree on a specific time when Bob's photon will be between the "path marker" (which is usually just after the slits) and the detector.</p> <p>If Alice acts using the eraser on her photon, the interference pattern will appear. If not it won't.</p> <p>Alice and Bob can be spatially separated...</p> <p>What am i misunderstanding? </p> <p>The only meaningful difference from this spatially separated quantum eraser experiment to one done on tabletop is that you won't be able to use a coincidence detector, but that is not impeditive to identifying the interference pattern, just will make errors more probable. Which we should be able to deal with a appropriate protocol...</p> <p>There is a experimental paper with a small amount of citations pointing out to the breaking of complementarity in a very similar setup: <a href="http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/05/23/1201271109" rel="nofollow">http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/05/23/1201271109</a></p>
g4045
[ 0.01788499765098095, 0.018274441361427307, 0.013123932294547558, -0.043010808527469635, 0.03712194040417671, 0.013169662095606327, 0.04661550372838974, 0.04532797634601593, 0.011333822272717953, 0.048854295164346695, 0.016750814393162727, 0.016693543642759323, -0.04401964694261551, -0.011818135157227516, -0.018789079040288925, 0.01023076567798853, 0.0707779973745346, -0.01633281074464321, 0.03539147973060608, 0.03614772483706474, -0.021268334239721298, 0.08089525252580643, -0.04631349444389343, -0.04890070855617523, -0.026347171515226364, -0.06162606552243233, -0.025329308584332466, -0.04453226178884506, -0.032532498240470886, -0.0037927229423075914, 0.057930540293455124, -0.05356515198945999, 0.02459835819900036, -0.07857654243707657, -0.02185835689306259, -0.031945642083883286, 0.014446168206632137, -0.036323562264442444, -0.07556474953889847, 0.05258702114224434, 0.02642454393208027, 0.02440549246966839, 0.020968422293663025, -0.050954725593328476, 0.017489930614829063, 0.03993453457951546, 0.06930878758430481, 0.022318297997117043, 0.08226928114891052, -0.04946666955947876, -0.030961306765675545, 0.003212970681488514, 0.0016655686777085066, 0.029996102675795555, 0.02605137974023819, 0.11555428057909012, 0.013382546603679657, -0.020993264392018318, 0.07351122051477432, -0.013870179653167725, 0.010001115500926971, -0.04504735767841339, 0.002475776243954897, 0.02848609909415245, 0.000665891042444855, 0.054515596479177475, -0.08502766489982605, 0.011150331236422062, -0.004387181252241135, -0.031066294759511948, 0.005723689682781696, -0.04094698652625084, -0.012848621234297752, 0.02019055373966694, 0.07028543204069138, 0.06302633881568909, 0.033307284116744995, -0.0715770572423935, 0.02321838028728962, 0.05696747824549675, -0.06870929151773453, -0.055937010794878006, -0.015010868199169636, 0.027498889714479446, 0.09656529873609543, 0.015701595693826675, -0.03985435143113136, -0.02063870057463646, -0.018037332221865654, 0.026612915098667145, 0.03227053955197334, -0.032082535326480865, 0.06547626107931137, 0.008775032125413418, -0.01048113964498043, -0.007386912126094103, -0.009255630895495415, 0.04186497628688812, -0.024301381781697273, 0.03741788491606712, -0.06777380406856537, 0.035569753497838974, 0.013604799285531044, 0.016197770833969116, -0.01603715308010578, -0.009211850352585316, 0.001536028110422194, -0.019250309094786644, -0.07114490866661072, -0.017051996663212776, 0.0013224221765995026, -0.04580268636345863, -0.08320928364992142, -0.009891645982861519, 0.038336921483278275, -0.024731522426009178, 0.06078082695603371, -0.031106287613511086, 0.007412584498524666, -0.030355963855981827, -0.0009910723892971873, 0.008124325424432755, -0.019203979521989822, 0.0068475473672151566, -0.018791232258081436, -0.021697422489523888, -0.014788920059800148, -0.0006005922914482653, 0.07208272069692612, 0.010842193849384785, 0.03969532623887062, 0.06202588230371475, -0.011717221699655056, 0.06278074532747269, 0.007202782202512026, -0.02954068034887314, 0.09075368940830231, -0.022401802241802216, 0.01686847396194935, -0.05257607623934746, -0.00197030371055007, 0.05140090361237526, 0.009562114253640175, -0.0287430752068758, 0.00017095435759983957, -0.010710063390433788, -0.02781742438673973, 0.026361355558037758, 0.012381857261061668, 0.07991870492696762, 0.05124196410179138, 0.0305015929043293, 0.010043878108263016, -0.04666635021567345, -0.02624833956360817, 0.02127346582710743, 0.060191452503204346, -0.017871789634227753, 0.0393739715218544, 0.02158481441438198, 0.08213115483522415, -0.008855164051055908, -0.019917096942663193, 0.020032834261655807, -0.027803152799606323, 0.019907960668206215, 0.05469067767262459, -0.03777072951197624, -0.005183825269341469, -0.0180802159011364, -0.03462088853120804, 0.018253035843372345, -0.035475704818964005, 0.00864997785538435, 0.002586162881925702, 0.12530802190303802, -0.02482568845152855, -0.027596374973654747, 0.0035136446822434664, 0.017270179465413094, 0.005215578246861696, 0.01414819248020649, -0.010527229867875576, -0.008998227305710316, -0.026579750701785088, -0.008649586699903011, -0.015344713814556599, 0.008929084055125713, -0.02967887558043003, -0.03176109865307808, 0.013760164380073547, -0.04127158597111702, -0.08143966645002365, 0.006018367130309343, -0.04860766604542732, 0.01011281181126833, 0.020744549110531807, -0.015494614839553833, 0.026064306497573853, 0.05285235494375229, -0.08339302986860275, 0.06189423426985741, -0.025951804593205452, 0.0229612085968256, -0.014051202684640884, -0.0035011081490665674, -0.002544027753174305, -0.04731891676783562, -0.04404442384839058, -0.007762547582387924, 0.027719419449567795, 0.05712513253092766, 0.007869944907724857, 0.028520479798316956, 0.007674028631299734, -0.017310597002506256, 0.01691613532602787, 0.023144911974668503, -0.03144031763076782, 0.025744132697582245, -0.006032673176378012, -0.02527959831058979, 0.0009221632499247789, -0.06655183434486389, -0.010884876362979412, -0.014697899110615253, -0.008464477024972439, -0.016175486147403717, -0.09618236124515533, 0.0283244289457798, -0.02764245495200157, -0.015762317925691605, -0.06985320895910263, -0.05516469106078148, 0.07102097570896149, 0.05631360784173012, 0.0016072456492111087, 0.04257198050618172, -0.023201409727334976, -0.01624707691371441, 0.02005988545715809, 0.011702505871653557, -0.09211469441652298, 0.05588793754577637, 0.0031039919704198837, -0.01195464562624693, 0.006694525480270386, -0.052132051438093185, -0.01759112812578678, 0.0054754409939050674, 0.008337290957570076, 0.010643651708960533, 0.0014654007973149419, 0.014389216899871826, 0.014848615974187851, -0.006510989740490913, 0.03708697855472565, -0.01823561266064644, -0.06667007505893707, -0.06702524423599243, 0.025769134983420372, -0.03207310661673546, 0.008713229559361935, 0.016660679131746292, 0.025036534294486046, -0.06903570890426636, 0.014753695577383041, 0.05312841385602951, 0.005953523330390453, 0.0009601705824024975, -0.04650866612792015, 0.014915104024112225, 0.029737714678049088, -0.010162386111915112, 0.012152423150837421, 0.053014129400253296, 0.011788212694227695, -0.02395733818411827, 0.050328098237514496, 0.06621942669153214, -0.01959325559437275, 0.04437816143035889, -0.10091723501682281, 0.00545306084677577, 0.050105903297662735, -0.06491049379110336, 0.0028958332259207964, 0.03407571092247963, 0.023003244772553444, 0.026982780545949936, -0.029288526624441147, 0.006830103695392609, 0.01917949877679348, 0.014516551978886127, -0.025159334763884544, 0.02881394326686859, -0.016655361279845238, 0.003715057158842683, 0.0014016958884894848, 0.035504598170518875, 0.03693900257349014, 0.008294627070426941, -0.0049570887349545956, 0.020969724282622337, 0.004948667250573635, -0.027941817417740822, -0.06017016991972923, 0.015390047803521156, -0.004815373104065657, -0.04381914809346199, -0.025226179510354996, 0.0006511459359899163, 0.014406784437596798, -0.014949248172342777, 0.037371281534433365, 0.014259058982133865, 0.013164704665541649, 0.04136520251631737, 0.03022700361907482, 0.03675050288438797, 0.007923801429569721, 0.07474049180746078, 0.012749233283102512, -0.008821696974337101, 0.012557797133922577, 0.01753866858780384, 0.02419036068022251, 0.004149314947426319, -0.05355869233608246, 0.01004884485155344, 0.013594039715826511, 0.028792228549718857, 0.05491713061928749, 0.00452770572155714, -0.014507560059428215, -0.05459471791982651, -0.05448511987924576, 0.00821456778794527, -0.04499006271362305, 0.030454756692051888, 0.012675197795033455, 0.027408558875322342, 0.04469199478626251, -0.00643237354233861, 0.006148561369627714, 0.028857126832008362, 0.042685266584157944, 0.001901951152831316, 0.0074042389169335365, -0.01848999597132206, 0.03443531319499016, 0.005351493135094643, -0.011883520521223545, -0.06661859154701233, -0.036899030208587646, -0.009233279153704643, 0.018689801916480064, 0.054296497255563736, 0.027971768751740456, -0.0147943627089262, 0.0704801082611084, 0.044650815427303314, 0.021488070487976074, -0.027655325829982758, -0.03709368780255318, 0.0514613576233387, -0.04140597581863403, 0.04237280786037445, 0.05123838037252426, -0.0013349717482924461, -0.06223786622285843, 0.04137634113430977, -0.029146168380975723, -0.03608793392777443, 0.037011828273534775, -0.010661110281944275, 0.07437731325626373, 0.015798458829522133, 0.012073774822056293, 0.024760369211435318, -0.04439855366945267, -0.0025616686325520277, 0.004057226236909628, -0.023091409355401993, 0.055439192801713943, 0.0359879732131958, -0.016184447333216667, -0.0033318151254206896, -0.04299450293183327, -0.03265052288770676, 0.03287936747074127, 0.02427590824663639, -0.059967055916786194, -0.03070196695625782, 0.0012501828605309129, 0.023046255111694336, 0.017053257673978806, -0.005677402019500732, 0.015117820352315903, -0.005552470684051514, -0.01416105218231678, -0.009658858180046082, -0.015145665034651756, 0.015678877010941505, -0.019972138106822968, -0.032976552844047546, -0.021515971049666405, -0.020517542958259583, -0.0058899219147861, 0.032655585557222366, -0.026400642469525337, 0.0052756136283278465, -0.05500251054763794, -0.040187668055295944, -0.01576071046292782, 0.008489195257425308, 0.035576678812503815, 0.025141891092061996, -0.007432159036397934, -0.01992950774729252, -0.041660528630018234, 0.09724277257919312, 0.03161289915442467, -0.014278382994234562, 0.014300272800028324, 0.03478333353996277, -0.02854664996266365, 0.018923871219158173, 0.026700004935264587, -0.08844587951898575, 0.038929667323827744, 0.043463777750730515, -0.018488677218556404, 0.008807027712464333, -0.04643338546156883, -0.03479189798235893, -0.03463742509484291, 0.07073788344860077, 0.05558750033378601, 0.05614949017763138, 0.04021404683589935, -0.030820371583104134, 0.022348495200276375, 0.013151364400982857, 0.017794806510210037, 0.07425809651613235, 0.002546734642237425, -0.0762716680765152, 0.0053861853666603565, -0.02069215476512909, 0.0093266936019063, 0.06089996173977852, -0.03384567052125931, 0.014029596000909805, -0.04519715532660484, 0.030984755605459213, -0.01897982880473137, 0.029821505770087242, 0.011873864568769932, 0.035021666437387466, -0.0034342657309025526, 0.005707195028662682, -0.0016941218636929989, 0.013848935253918171, -0.01727759651839733, 0.03237248212099075, -0.053832538425922394, -0.06376150250434875, -0.07634452730417252, -0.005901998840272427, -0.003868945874273777, -0.005271462257951498, 0.0008015071507543325, 0.05609709396958351, 0.03205743432044983, -0.03594391047954559, 0.002275113482028246, -0.0034209031146019697, 0.011942587792873383, -0.015509647317230701, -0.03267497196793556, -0.018861297518014908, 0.040185295045375824, -0.012441664934158325, 0.0015760321402922273, 0.045906927436590195, -0.03418218344449997, -0.009833605028688908, -0.0035404106602072716, 0.021257126703858376, 0.03775578737258911, -0.06161627918481827, 0.012587456032633781, -0.009499521926045418, 0.016099629923701286, -0.05602137744426727, -0.006051686592400074, 0.028471436351537704, -0.0026474071200937033, 0.010823328047990799, 0.005869897082448006, 0.05047105997800827, 0.009409799240529537, 0.0030791894532740116, -0.04701472073793411, 0.0037773840595036745, 0.03418437018990517, 0.016933226957917213, -0.041673146188259125, -0.05141007900238037, -0.05385331064462662, -0.004547592252492905, -0.04804983735084534, -0.07203800231218338, 0.012994950637221336, 0.04805238917469978, -0.017643682658672333, -0.052522074431180954, -0.013932437635958195, -0.03451405093073845, -0.015366115607321262, 0.10794120281934738, -0.04655812680721283, -0.03627621755003929, 0.01775205135345459, -0.028711142018437386, 0.0006664694519713521, -0.009358636103570461, -0.005109176971018314, -0.011950707994401455, 0.05670305714011192, 0.0654461532831192, 0.036483921110630035, 0.07839883118867874, -0.013532397337257862, -0.06344491243362427, 0.026535317301750183, 0.008508904837071896, 0.019265711307525635, -0.007262821309268475, -0.03254227340221405, -0.021667219698429108, 0.02454150840640068, 0.03347077593207359, -0.010945897549390793, -0.024506332352757454, -0.028363218531012535, -0.002190849045291543, 0.01890593022108078, -0.05997425690293312, -0.006633673328906298, -0.023293087258934975, 0.03443753346800804, 0.035218823701143265, 0.016038890928030014, -0.04356195032596588, -0.022522488608956337, -0.026292769238352776, 0.016829432919621468, 0.0069490233436226845, 0.021653851494193077, 0.015186282806098461, -0.002571841236203909, 0.0003068674122914672, 0.025344250723719597, -0.005903424229472876, -0.024015966802835464, 0.00626760208979249, 0.0191341582685709, 0.019937926903367043, 0.019484324380755424, 0.023424165323376656, -0.05894003063440323, 0.01720983162522316, -0.024681659415364265, 0.013841786421835423, -0.01845458522439003, -0.019787760451436043, -0.06670131534337997, -0.033754851669073105, 0.011053801514208317, 0.040042199194431305, -0.037688083946704865, -0.04629465565085411, 0.005869077984243631, 0.015469018369913101, -0.048888061195611954, 0.0007741021690890193, 0.030100688338279724, -0.042198020964860916, -0.06959947943687439, -0.005756058730185032, 0.02574407309293747, -0.03982168063521385, -0.03310313820838928, -0.01395718939602375, -0.017937278375029564, -0.00662393169477582, -0.042435888200998306, 0.03496566787362099, -0.05417148768901825, -0.053872644901275635, 0.012432867661118507, 0.0200907401740551, -0.019725728780031204, 0.03363402932882309, -0.024349400773644447, 0.01631498523056507, 0.028472760692238808, -0.019634699448943138, -0.061092834919691086, 0.02138345316052437, -0.004368660971522331, 0.022340720519423485, -0.02595379203557968, -0.052339330315589905, -0.0066906763240695, 0.013932894915342331, -0.04748355969786644, 0.038170989602804184, 0.0866045355796814, 0.0034529175609350204, -0.0002521520364098251, -0.0029898276552557945, -0.01587209850549698, 0.038631945848464966, 0.0039114016108214855, -0.006168499123305082, 0.06884118169546127, 0.040727388113737106, -0.005572005640715361, -0.033003006130456924, 0.020787468180060387, 0.014312079176306725, -0.01786237396299839, 0.04508262500166893, -0.07880930602550507, -0.0085375364869833, -0.011703027412295341, -0.009794089943170547, 0.03895564377307892, 0.05554042011499405, 0.08146138489246368, -0.0016555882757529616, -0.02435176819562912, 0.0822664275765419, 0.013591532595455647, 0.025729013606905937, -0.025784773752093315, 0.008288905955851078, -0.0017555628437548876, -0.007655383553355932, -0.04360910877585411, 0.006507739424705505, -0.004659739322960377, 0.019170431420207024, -0.003034810535609722, 0.043095171451568604, -0.00846563559025526, -0.07388793677091599, -0.034144748002290726, -0.09828706830739975, -0.07524456083774567, -0.025585778057575226, -0.004838236141949892, -0.04123404249548912, -0.007656818255782127, -0.030991893261671066, -0.014703446067869663, -0.03862903267145157, -0.008960505947470665, -0.06945353746414185, -0.03571391850709915, -0.006700183730572462, 0.05363369733095169, -0.031452301889657974, -0.010867705568671227, -0.00583660788834095, -0.05004007741808891, -0.011668018065392971, 0.029213832691311836, -0.009595477022230625, 0.019130151718854904, 0.018623005598783493, 0.02450205385684967, 0.05916760116815567, 0.0004957662313245237, 0.017453033477067947, -0.027849426493048668, -0.02838338166475296, -0.00014172180090099573, 0.009190390817821026, 0.006116341333836317, -0.007545854896306992, 0.03990231826901436, 0.028984172269701958, 0.05807975307106972, 0.025949163362383842, -0.00709611177444458, 0.045205529779195786, -0.019851025193929672, -0.02676529437303543, 0.02710885740816593, 0.0005401511443778872, 0.0414697602391243, 0.004673118237406015, -0.037382517009973526, -0.005829025059938431, 0.03074473701417446, -0.02420603297650814, -0.013292829506099224, 0.03276117891073227, -0.016397539526224136, 0.015225686132907867, -0.006056868005543947, -0.04743403568863869, -0.045556094497442245, -0.016690293326973915, 0.04419558867812157, 0.03498207777738571, 0.03403182327747345, 0.029998715966939926, -0.006708250381052494, 0.015588894486427307, -0.0227091945707798, -0.044537074863910675, 0.03581316024065018, 0.030688196420669556, 0.002730362117290497, -0.03805393725633621, 0.02322952076792717, -0.02817133441567421, -0.022821461781859398, -0.008708528243005276, 0.010406269691884518, 0.020398953929543495, -0.007085743360221386, 0.021219978109002113, -0.05221150070428848, -0.02248874306678772, -0.004113861359655857, -0.01660076528787613, -0.02355125918984413, -0.0869595855474472, -0.0310704056173563, -0.06423770636320114, -0.06161420792341232, -0.004300741944462061, -0.01409619115293026, -0.03720982000231743, -0.029726320877671242, -0.014585002325475216, -0.06628863513469696, 0.04350004717707634, 0.08788425475358963, -0.014110286720097065, 0.036815740168094635, -0.056631818413734436, 0.05222941190004349, -0.03405359387397766, -0.020454123616218567, -0.023903515189886093, -0.032453637570142746, 0.01915864273905754, -0.010296119377017021, 0.002049720846116543, 0.03907300904393196, 0.020370809361338615 ]
<p>my problem is that I can’t find a way to calculate the power required to drive the shaft and thus decide on a motor, I have tried several times using different methods and calculations but can’t seem to get a power requirement that would seem accurate, most recently I tried using a fluid equation of force on an immersed body travelling through a fluid using integration I got formula for torque, on each of the paddles rotating in the hopper of 1/8*Coeff drag*density*angular velocity^2*width of paddle*radius of paddle^4 and adding the inertia of the system, this gave me a power requirement of a 150 watts which seems ridiculous, I was wondering how i should go about calculating the power requirement. Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks ollie</p>
g4046
[ -0.041221436113119125, 0.0711715817451477, -0.014192720875144005, -0.002841826295480132, -0.02631870098412037, 0.03984465077519417, 0.040465425699949265, 0.027832865715026855, -0.05325407534837723, 0.014063002541661263, -0.02053527534008026, 0.004396029748022556, 0.010182330384850502, 0.023386478424072266, -0.012785333208739758, 0.04256264865398407, 0.01749729923903942, -0.02582179196178913, -0.008204897865653038, 0.03115049935877323, 0.0506129190325737, 0.03851885721087456, -0.06416846811771393, -0.014164255931973457, -0.02185007743537426, -0.03967510536313057, -0.015194381587207317, -0.04364961385726929, -0.0029108035378158092, -0.013416554778814316, -0.003697153879329562, 0.00022193360200617462, 0.007609669119119644, -0.06306979805231094, -0.08997168391942978, 0.000010720376849349122, 0.05285339429974556, 0.01002225186675787, -0.01542261429131031, 0.021463975310325623, -0.027007564902305603, -0.03354049101471901, -0.036443695425987244, 0.06040217727422714, -0.0042272466234862804, -0.01603451557457447, 0.057576343417167664, 0.0128511693328619, -0.0674857422709465, -0.035256173461675644, -0.006745236460119486, -0.049898069351911545, -0.026896830648183823, -0.018693435937166214, -0.05790988728404045, 0.03273094445466995, 0.020675579085946083, -0.010542898438870907, -0.043956439942121506, -0.03856394812464714, -0.030405502766370773, -0.06142239272594452, -0.003079690970480442, -0.03339274972677231, 0.04352836310863495, -0.05384327471256256, 0.039070889353752136, -0.05793684348464012, 0.004674618132412434, -0.01782812736928463, 0.016202198341488838, -0.05199646204710007, 0.007175506558269262, -0.02883094921708107, -0.013395048677921295, 0.0038633074145764112, 0.0195903480052948, 0.006523177493363619, 0.03176838532090187, 0.001338121946901083, 0.04565203934907913, 0.049544937908649445, 0.06784126907587051, -0.03429636359214783, 0.037282794713974, -0.016396306455135345, -0.04826488718390465, 0.02486184611916542, 0.044461797922849655, -0.009817918762564659, -0.04096611216664314, 0.058398403227329254, 0.07731255888938904, 0.00259211054071784, 0.04504505172371864, -0.06753738969564438, -0.030847879126667976, 0.022101720795035362, 0.03259781748056412, 0.05116455256938934, 0.0009969233069568872, 0.004685837309807539, -0.026756880804896355, -0.04589008912444115, 0.03665267303586006, -0.022211529314517975, 0.017682835459709167, 0.028530914336442947, -0.004440332297235727, -0.03862182796001434, -0.0007821702165529132, -0.01399829052388668, -0.000034907046938315034, -0.04989270865917206, 0.017998751252889633, -0.0707102045416832, 0.030582303181290627, 0.006464162841439247, -0.01045161485671997, 0.00685156462714076, -0.008914362639188766, 0.009118953719735146, -0.0629243329167366, 0.04341871663928032, 0.03168254345655441, 0.03345711901783943, -0.04576829820871353, -0.006618681363761425, 0.018762486055493355, 0.03173702955245972, 0.00477663753554225, 0.020961029455065727, 0.006467481609433889, -0.008307627402245998, -0.004814261104911566, 0.0466468371450901, -0.04015733301639557, -0.015876121819019318, 0.03172964230179787, -0.0046608587726950645, 0.049700938165187836, -0.00854586437344551, 0.018992390483617783, 0.02717476524412632, -0.0015389659674838185, 0.029478203505277634, -0.0021078409627079964, -0.061345625668764114, 0.03404741734266281, 0.061571069061756134, 0.07058408856391907, 0.042442671954631805, 0.010608271695673466, 0.005126037169247866, 0.12061767280101776, 0.0032408381812274456, 0.005426141899079084, 0.007295750081539154, -0.015583167783915997, -0.010550159029662609, 0.04702876880764961, -0.00011754816659959033, 0.07611547410488129, -0.0011569778434932232, -0.06655097007751465, 0.034581638872623444, -0.005846078507602215, -0.0025736778043210506, -0.01945904828608036, -0.06104481965303421, -0.056926559656858444, -0.031043710187077522, 0.03354479745030403, -0.031110642477869987, 0.019990913569927216, 0.004787045065313578, 0.07419341802597046, -0.011612423695623875, -0.00474658515304327, 0.0030871531926095486, 0.02555849589407444, 0.03483927249908447, 0.03388708457350731, 0.032452117651700974, -0.07369976490736008, 0.002940892707556486, 0.015029992908239365, -0.023878106847405434, 0.006547232158482075, -0.0007896432070992887, -0.043302398175001144, 0.03299877792596817, 0.03780846297740936, -0.013391347602009773, -0.014490506611764431, 0.05230202153325081, 0.09550584107637405, -0.022181371226906776, -0.06639805436134338, -0.044980067759752274, -0.0014610737562179565, 0.017733315005898476, -0.0018372372724115849, 0.010000825859606266, 0.015574152581393719, 0.008966260589659214, -0.009509623982012272, 0.045582499355077744, 0.03798921778798103, -0.018382146954536438, 0.0619555227458477, 0.025477202609181404, -0.01300750207155943, 0.02142552100121975, -0.05909361690282822, 0.02052466757595539, -0.007368772756308317, -0.04581503942608833, -0.04716290906071663, 0.001079138950444758, 0.009041791781783104, -0.007286321371793747, 0.0028258764650672674, 0.0769859254360199, -0.10303271561861038, 0.04055541008710861, -0.007572927046567202, -0.033790454268455505, 0.014515400864183903, 0.0436457023024559, -0.017827169969677925, -0.026907440274953842, 0.025279922410845757, -0.014636574313044548, 0.03410465270280838, 0.0011316207237541676, -0.027093857526779175, 0.01947823353111744, 0.021504053846001625, -0.0015469060745090246, -0.006105222273617983, 0.02645115926861763, 0.040951602160930634, -0.03544240817427635, -0.013007128611207008, 0.005463818553835154, 0.0649522989988327, -0.010464969091117382, -0.006515421438962221, 0.0009958504233509302, -0.014376659877598286, -0.02188696712255478, 0.03005984239280224, 0.010376863181591034, -0.013167072087526321, 0.022420665249228477, -0.021132320165634155, 0.005755412857979536, -0.0034538256004452705, -0.0014450158923864365, -0.009868824854493141, 0.01270381174981594, -0.03371984884142876, 0.031243298202753067, -0.06890156865119934, -0.015104230493307114, -0.03611808270215988, -0.07939057052135468, 0.06876745074987411, 0.02529970183968544, -0.04496719688177109, -0.0009618732146918774, -0.021015265956521034, -0.006239773705601692, 0.012926270253956318, -0.05644726753234863, -0.01958164945244789, 0.004157159477472305, 0.01975143514573574, 0.02527717687189579, 0.004848943091928959, -0.0541747622191906, -0.020037848502397537, 0.05437060818076134, -0.011589175090193748, -0.07958788424730301, 0.011106880381703377, 0.0035903560929000378, -0.022538775578141212, 0.019223995506763458, -0.026491988450288773, -0.0005836511263623834, -0.08211366832256317, -0.05237807333469391, 0.016326140612363815, 0.06530196964740753, 0.047676943242549896, -0.009197804145514965, 0.020946210250258446, -0.021389856934547424, 0.015729667618870735, -0.01639183796942234, 0.02734393998980522, -0.03269980102777481, 0.006034421268850565, 0.03867734223604202, -0.012011228129267693, 0.002578191226348281, -0.007637413218617439, 0.04223969578742981, -0.04664143919944763, 0.0316162109375, 0.009219823405146599, -0.029598373919725418, -0.04394949600100517, -0.00941365398466587, -0.023141970857977867, -0.03207918629050255, -0.041991643607616425, -0.012107683345675468, -0.0012823243159800768, -0.0555514357984066, 0.007862464524805546, 0.04207621514797211, 0.002749950857833028, 0.07190576940774918, -0.04764030501246452, 0.024356761947274208, -0.022218257188796997, -0.007853391580283642, 0.005245551001280546, 0.029882632195949554, -0.024309176951646805, 0.05424361675977707, -0.028148312121629715, -0.020659057423472404, 0.03408743068575859, -0.01769324764609337, -0.046067528426647186, 0.036231741309165955, 0.00012149900430813432, -0.05351454019546509, -0.03494260832667351, 0.013297183439135551, -0.04092882573604584, 0.016621826216578484, -0.08552303910255432, 0.023472800850868225, 0.004490375984460115, -0.010257488116621971, 0.07008194178342819, -0.053911980241537094, -0.003456825390458107, -0.025652090087532997, -0.004662633873522282, -0.02651132270693779, -0.006655776873230934, 0.017659185454249382, -0.030351411551237106, 0.04129625856876373, -0.01953018084168434, 0.02137729711830616, 0.011848071590065956, 0.045068804174661636, 0.029451685026288033, 0.0060356901958584785, -0.06869729608297348, -0.012826632708311081, -0.05841216444969177, 0.002777497284114361, 0.036221444606781006, -0.04368208348751068, -0.013928859494626522, -0.009204334579408169, -0.015681331977248192, -0.031309954822063446, 0.08205358684062958, -0.006007643416523933, -0.006184914615005255, 0.025249427184462547, 0.002613307209685445, 0.04739486053586006, -0.009537216275930405, 0.012345285154879093, -0.023456815630197525, 0.045753113925457, 0.0294958408921957, 0.03661465272307396, 0.049493782222270966, 0.001150001073256135, -0.008304211311042309, -0.06320332735776901, -0.07971418648958206, -0.033802300691604614, 0.04137104004621506, 0.02272247150540352, -0.008524703793227673, -0.02113625966012478, -0.013314657844603062, 0.009831245057284832, -0.015632521361112595, 0.002794320695102215, 0.03889305144548416, 0.07386898249387741, -0.01754852570593357, 0.015215202234685421, 0.06823590397834778, -0.021976804360747337, 0.015150919556617737, 0.043484944850206375, -0.021552471444010735, 0.03521033748984337, 0.05423327535390854, -0.07499793916940689, -0.09294404834508896, -0.025040755048394203, -0.002609532093629241, -0.04951160401105881, 0.045583195984363556, 0.05354812741279602, 0.054923661053180695, -0.01609034650027752, -0.04321609064936638, -0.048238642513751984, -0.08874591439962387, 0.015024116262793541, 0.015294796787202358, -0.01817905344069004, -0.026547249406576157, -0.022148681804537773, -0.001975170336663723, 0.04387696832418442, -0.02979971282184124, -0.027038738131523132, 0.02542530559003353, 0.012831046245992184, 0.03490128368139267, 0.011292279697954655, 0.06465034186840057, -0.010633005760610104, -0.0249320100992918, -0.00248846341855824, -0.004584659822285175, -0.00714691961184144, -0.020896295085549355, 0.06829100847244263, 0.001711235730908811, -0.036241162568330765, -0.034712668508291245, 0.0023821808863431215, 0.025290757417678833, 0.005318027921020985, -0.05853333696722984, -0.014659346081316471, -0.009573818184435368, 0.06771412491798401, -0.017629876732826233, -0.00014679897867608815, -0.021562982350587845, -0.02058347873389721, -0.020742611959576607, -0.005241873674094677, -0.004092197399586439, -0.023127876222133636, -0.04340922087430954, 0.026864629238843918, -0.029024822637438774, 0.03544049710035324, -0.010717022232711315, -0.054879795759916306, 0.0776071697473526, -0.01959340088069439, -0.005288025829941034, 0.05645454674959183, -0.03403225168585777, 0.039473600685596466, -0.03599284589290619, -0.034518346190452576, 0.08693996071815491, 0.04300529137253761, 0.008554202504456043, -0.009347560815513134, -0.0016090370481833816, 0.049693647772073746, -0.0074189938604831696, 0.0030301627703011036, -0.030847201123833656, 0.05443097651004791, 0.04938869923353195, -0.020351041108369827, -0.01644757017493248, 0.11515627056360245, -0.04528821259737015, -0.0034213371109217405, -0.037729814648628235, 0.06446045637130737, -0.018202507868409157, -0.005356789566576481, -0.025293691083788872, 0.08059132099151611, 0.030745387077331543, -0.009775795042514801, -0.058570876717567444, -0.0386480838060379, 0.004465713165700436, -0.01841934397816658, 0.05648032948374748, -0.015691248700022697, -0.014097742736339569, 0.041973453015089035, 0.03605583682656288, 0.01569834165275097, 0.058895085006952286, -0.002181538613513112, 0.021600237116217613, -0.0741768330335617, 0.0034562391228973866, 0.05158419534564018, 0.00874891597777605, 0.003868205938488245, 0.11716937273740768, 0.023164112120866776, 0.07099483162164688, -0.04146392270922661, -0.07581353187561035, 0.033618178218603134, -0.06803829222917557, 0.0037782443687319756, -0.004250604193657637, -0.03725304827094078, 0.012431778013706207, -0.007459684740751982, -0.006944617722183466, -0.011428180150687695, -0.03177838400006294, -0.06108386069536209, 0.06536918878555298, -0.028645573183894157, 0.0227119792252779, -0.01524343155324459, -0.0234085563570261, 0.026659386232495308, -0.01358867809176445, -0.00971195101737976, -0.010959465987980366, -0.0006051606615073979, -0.014305579476058483, -0.038837626576423645, 0.04295489192008972, -0.04163658246397972, -0.026582997292280197, 0.08278635889291763, 0.05293811112642288, 0.0053898547776043415, -0.019161555916070938, -0.019497809931635857, 0.0023549306206405163, -0.0017197474371641874, -0.013496121391654015, 0.0027398369275033474, 0.02672656811773777, 0.017941318452358246, -0.006588333752006292, -0.006928414572030306, -0.005485024768859148, 0.03771784156560898, 0.006116436794400215, 0.01517521683126688, -0.022867698222398758, 0.02962789498269558, 0.013543667271733284, -0.007975643500685692, -0.024331115186214447, -0.0033024910371750593, 0.07289440929889679, 0.0033629508689045906, -0.03898775205016136, -0.014449059963226318, -0.002018539933487773, 0.008832892403006554, 0.05247897654771805, 0.005951381754130125, -0.013008668087422848, -0.018748058006167412, 0.012795427814126015, 0.006179891061037779, -0.06923111528158188, 0.007361979689449072, 0.04554152116179466, -0.02858998253941536, 0.01086400356143713, 0.011360413394868374, 0.014505262486636639, -0.0601513609290123, 0.05136127769947052, -0.01856808550655842, -0.007119128480553627, 0.03804301470518112, 0.057612158358097076, -0.01102540735155344, 0.00715755857527256, 0.04739690572023392, -0.024194875732064247, 0.007498092483729124, -0.03246166557073593, -0.04467899352312088, -0.026459624990820885, -0.027227336540818214, -0.02786831371486187, -0.030392425134778023, -0.035297419875860214, -0.011754277162253857, 0.059927888214588165, -0.028059950098395348, 0.005579226650297642, 0.02231438271701336, 0.022439146414399147, 0.008053721860051155, 0.05914689972996712, 0.020550226792693138, 0.03656173497438431, -0.034860897809267044, 0.03899864852428436, -0.06847110390663147, 0.06811657547950745, -0.04742863029241562, -0.05375869199633598, 0.02550525777041912, 0.018360717222094536, -0.03951098769903183, 0.03701108321547508, -0.029945513233542442, -0.003520550671964884, 0.029597660526633263, 0.05454953387379646, 0.030000044032931328, 0.002433007350191474, 0.06998919695615768, 0.028206486254930496, 0.03768998384475708, -0.04134541004896164, 0.012204455211758614, -0.019745847210288048, 0.058943651616573334, -0.021890297532081604, 0.0038671090733259916, 0.012562242336571217, -0.0033092028461396694, 0.02688528411090374, -0.020194020122289658, -0.02727806754410267, -0.017788229510188103, 0.015859397128224373, -0.025506379082798958, -0.0421566367149353, 0.038628339767456055, -0.01895872689783573, -0.060935650020837784, 0.028028491884469986, -0.007917051203548908, 0.05988504737615585, -0.012700885534286499, -0.008860806003212929, -0.001269947737455368, -0.02063561975955963, -0.025733282789587975, -0.009824873879551888, 0.03841609135270119, 0.03059828281402588, 0.015213169157505035, -0.022076470777392387, -0.01051460113376379, -0.03951457142829895, -0.013679482974112034, -0.06902448832988739, -0.022443408146500587, 0.005850350949913263, -0.0044337064027786255, -0.03092307411134243, -0.013506539165973663, -0.02806491032242775, 0.016406502574682236, -0.04831884056329727, 0.07384172827005386, -0.009941444732248783, 0.0009033665992319584, 0.011374765075743198, -0.048727553337812424, 0.08190310746431351, 0.03786357864737511, -0.005452171433717012, 0.037204090505838394, 0.02522624470293522, -0.04475096985697746, -0.028879176825284958, -0.01621377281844616, -0.008181609213352203, 0.04108655825257301, 0.10400968790054321, 0.0320354700088501, 0.06233958154916763, -0.038790084421634674, 0.02924094721674919, 0.056828536093235016, -0.07349470257759094, 0.01210273802280426, -0.0077560460194945335, -0.016902588307857513, -0.0061325803399086, 0.027745842933654785, -0.03097793273627758, 0.0044287885539233685, -0.020379798486828804, -0.011950827203691006, -0.012438066303730011, 0.011751013807952404, -0.052976351231336594, 0.026542413979768753, -0.021480994299054146, -0.004013414960354567, 0.0041848886758089066, 0.011800612322986126, 0.04664215072989464, 0.013691021129488945, -0.028162790462374687, -0.09607283025979996, -0.031238950788974762, -0.028151988983154297, -0.04909812659025192, 0.014074007049202919, -0.05432434752583504, -0.04815256968140602, -0.042568087577819824, 0.01250491850078106, -0.06269656866788864, -0.02716745063662529, -0.06405413150787354, 0.03309289738535881, 0.011811773292720318, 0.06080179661512375, 0.053319528698921204, -0.020075330510735512, 0.00380705832503736, -0.028817636892199516, 0.014292587526142597, -0.03409457206726074, 0.00028377294074743986, 0.03417980298399925, 0.026437295600771904, 0.03295392170548439, 0.05164036899805069, 0.0030245166271924973, 0.009753014892339706, 0.014347010292112827, -0.03997209295630455, -0.075778529047966, -0.05627916380763054, -0.003322846256196499, -0.021807176992297173, -0.006918730679899454, -0.014297598041594028, 0.0660865306854248, 0.009895644150674343, 0.02123297192156315, -0.002889796392992139, -0.0025376509875059128, -0.03609823063015938, -0.011462777853012085 ]
<p>It is well-known that some exotic phases in condensed matter physics are described by <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_quantum_field_theory#Schwarz-type_TQFTs">Schwarz-type TQFT</a>s, such as Chern-Simons theory of quantum Hall states. My question is whether there are condensed matter systems that can realize <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Topological_quantum_field_theory#Witten-type_TQFTs">Witten-type TQFT</a>s?</p>
g4047
[ -0.00439533730968833, 0.07197611033916473, 0.026775827631354332, 0.004748424049466848, 0.0285180751234293, -0.03320351243019104, -0.045531291514635086, -0.02739321067929268, 0.027352426201105118, 0.013202851638197899, -0.02638104371726513, -0.025707989931106567, -0.007470843382179737, -0.037062231451272964, -0.044826604425907135, -0.004552697762846947, 0.018334876745939255, 0.05274159833788872, 0.01893831416964531, -0.0007100131479091942, -0.030825696885585785, 0.013022245839238167, -0.02606334537267685, -0.07763160765171051, -0.012994508258998394, 0.04268219321966171, -0.03278093785047531, 0.004769830033183098, 0.013950580731034279, -0.050150316208601, -0.004152202978730202, 0.0008876185165718198, 0.021123187616467476, -0.000308575778035447, 0.030820747837424278, 0.04084547236561775, 0.06662165373563766, -0.029121944680809975, 0.006696118041872978, -0.028305459767580032, 0.020624831318855286, 0.017277350649237633, -0.03009767271578312, -0.012954463250935078, -0.007767543662339449, 0.0529005229473114, -0.030557336285710335, 0.017603931948542595, -0.005665268283337355, 0.026329969987273216, 0.002378183649852872, 0.06648838520050049, 0.07645019888877869, 0.008801684714853764, 0.05462674796581268, -0.02662327140569687, 0.026459867134690285, -0.01685275137424469, 0.029415417462587357, 0.007438649423420429, -0.006825328338891268, 0.052294742316007614, 0.04073633626103401, 0.03266935795545578, 0.041614193469285965, 0.047926247119903564, 0.032992757856845856, -0.021687403321266174, -0.06044187769293785, -0.05323031544685364, -0.061562322080135345, -0.027582809329032898, -0.020730234682559967, 0.045427970588207245, 0.016847647726535797, 0.09115340560674667, 0.013186880387365818, -0.041271742433309555, 0.010001620277762413, 0.015118960291147232, -0.07535313814878464, -0.014322564005851746, 0.010114520788192749, -0.010326111689209938, 0.04892216622829437, -0.03365681320428848, 0.02169438637793064, 0.006643267348408699, 0.010024821385741234, -0.005129799246788025, -0.0041527883149683475, 0.014620454050600529, -0.03696694225072861, -0.021129978820681572, 0.014007559977471828, 0.012383412569761276, 0.04228958487510681, 0.03775222599506378, -0.06831882148981094, -0.006449043285101652, -0.020510219037532806, 0.031005103141069412, 0.036671798676252365, -0.03634011745452881, -0.05006764084100723, -0.018159126862883568, 0.00620384281501174, -0.05024459585547447, 0.02338479645550251, 0.07796370983123779, -0.019167913123965263, 0.029356220737099648, -0.03472989425063133, 0.013749776408076286, -0.026900308206677437, 0.05071347951889038, -0.02849024347960949, -0.02929176762700081, -0.08767709881067276, 0.04156671464443207, 0.029068684205412865, -0.0376758836209774, 0.023080265149474144, 0.007638279348611832, -0.027658332139253616, 0.014190864749252796, -0.009988045319914818, -0.01812024600803852, 0.022757001221179962, -0.029185479506850243, 0.054592303931713104, -0.021000215783715248, 0.026685047894716263, 0.012114318087697029, 0.014616730622947216, 0.02478194609284401, 0.008522321470081806, 0.01176011748611927, 0.013459177687764168, -0.01489910576492548, -0.0478094220161438, -0.05350267142057419, -0.08598070591688156, -0.016166914254426956, 0.009278254583477974, -0.006226773839443922, -0.008255546912550926, 0.00582214305177331, 0.039227649569511414, -0.028620624914765358, 0.03133048117160797, 0.010534198954701424, 0.010641681961715221, 0.014682324603199959, -0.003941512666642666, 0.010348119772970676, 0.01208539679646492, -0.05194101482629776, -0.018148424103856087, -0.03761039301753044, -0.0335991196334362, -0.01384881604462862, -0.063370481133461, -0.04340893775224686, 0.01763882115483284, -0.04342745989561081, -0.013279429636895657, -0.0012769104214385152, 0.011251957155764103, 0.004771903622895479, 0.015737259760499, 0.061341989785432816, -0.013413483276963234, 0.0882573127746582, 0.04537730664014816, -0.005962280556559563, -0.055276498198509216, 0.0007052093860693276, -0.0045158579014241695, -0.013405244797468185, -0.006720689125359058, -0.025735028088092804, -0.0615384504199028, 0.06670528650283813, 0.04687541350722313, 0.08199363201856613, 0.03844552859663963, 0.02766398899257183, 0.006595883052796125, 0.011714313179254532, -0.03471922501921654, -0.06347566843032837, 0.03193167597055435, -0.02916884608566761, 0.03173397108912468, -0.02146380953490734, 0.013526837341487408, 0.018681487068533897, -0.03268161788582802, -0.037498973309993744, -0.003969172481447458, 0.033653780817985535, 0.03743748366832733, -0.03836701810359955, 0.04506115987896919, 0.044878847897052765, -0.07702168077230453, -0.0384305864572525, 0.04931529238820076, -0.012072070501744747, 0.004316673614084721, 0.01770053803920746, 0.0003099045716226101, 0.010642209090292454, -0.03798134624958038, -0.0721484124660492, 0.008390815928578377, -0.017704084515571594, 0.026583656668663025, 0.03138086572289467, 0.022882545366883278, 0.03763604536652565, 0.06230468302965164, 0.07375811785459518, 0.0035347098018974066, -0.020676041021943092, -0.01815521903336048, 0.019514180719852448, -0.016817115247249603, -0.027880027890205383, -0.039908796548843384, 0.0019464282086119056, 0.003738895058631897, -0.01741856336593628, 0.05129687488079071, 0.034166369587183, -0.026815097779035568, 0.0012370848562568426, 0.04747758433222771, 0.05111603066325188, -0.0064623113721609116, 0.01572312042117119, -0.02661994844675064, -0.03410553187131882, -0.017139900475740433, -0.028706733137369156, 0.024919919669628143, -0.02627670019865036, -0.02625201642513275, -0.015690920874476433, 0.05733738839626312, -0.05228230729699135, -0.04156513512134552, -0.03173217549920082, -0.03772423416376114, 0.026208866387605667, 0.04852420464158058, 0.03316720947623253, 0.04133772850036621, -0.03543836995959282, 0.010961887426674366, 0.0009735235362313688, -0.02079332061111927, 0.004919452127069235, -0.023605436086654663, 0.02197459153831005, -0.027333984151482582, 0.015206068754196167, -0.04540859907865524, 0.001770972739905119, 0.00025439460296183825, 0.024562343955039978, 0.013125624507665634, 0.02115226536989212, -0.0070924521423876286, -0.0039728195406496525, 0.01122132409363985, -0.00438786530867219, -0.024727338925004005, 0.007045975420624018, -0.02098996751010418, -0.028032951056957245, 0.022037498652935028, 0.07377707213163376, 0.009402967058122158, -0.004708580672740936, -0.008640670217573643, -0.007790371309965849, 0.016668111085891724, 0.06538445502519608, -0.0048702191561460495, 0.039930831640958786, 0.0646025761961937, 0.00979042798280716, -0.01776532456278801, 0.030865231528878212, -0.00556214340031147, -0.024192767217755318, -0.03358520194888115, 0.0786864310503006, -0.006190537009388208, -0.025213366374373436, 0.05287260562181473, 0.05153898522257805, 0.035101618617773056, -0.030960550531744957, -0.011846328154206276, -0.0187141764909029, 0.0021530978847295046, -0.0729617103934288, -0.02820606343448162, 0.0629953145980835, -0.011919669806957245, 0.0050745392218232155, -0.021466102451086044, 0.022076627239584923, 0.009916144423186779, 0.021358326077461243, 0.06255637109279633, -0.03330305963754654, -0.010258355177938938, 0.029567988589406013, 0.04854566976428032, -0.02602711133658886, 0.02384153939783573, 0.05391349270939827, -0.06287802755832672, -0.039680495858192444, -0.011286797001957893, -0.09950663149356842, 0.08188589662313461, -0.010766040533781052, 0.009204455651342869, -0.006195165682584047, -0.049939852207899094, -0.017880568280816078, -0.02680235728621483, 0.040753550827503204, 0.027517247945070267, 0.016152190044522285, -0.04445217549800873, 0.020982755348086357, 0.01548824179917574, 0.06352285295724869, -0.003259889781475067, 0.01504703238606453, -0.017446089535951614, -0.020966950803995132, 0.028514860197901726, 0.02380210906267166, 0.02592461369931698, 0.027016017585992813, 0.034754469990730286, 0.015043441206216812, -0.06676512956619263, 0.02177407220005989, 0.09165886044502258, 0.039980221539735794, 0.06321384757757187, -0.037330981343984604, -0.009366828948259354, -0.030429258942604065, 0.04264342784881592, 0.0104520283639431, -0.02628004364669323, 0.007081144955009222, 0.04059535264968872, -0.010488580912351608, -0.04170842468738556, -0.02481982111930847, 0.006667556706815958, -0.051464177668094635, 0.03597596660256386, -0.018033841624855995, 0.041830748319625854, -0.029617268592119217, -0.04109756648540497, -0.03934738039970398, -0.07903511077165604, -0.028508799150586128, -0.02510744333267212, 0.009051927365362644, 0.012264231219887733, -0.005786861293017864, 0.015089424327015877, -0.010413999669253826, -0.09109346568584442, 0.009931715205311775, -0.04049020633101463, -0.004311298485845327, -0.05033521726727486, 0.01501481607556343, -0.041523177176713943, -0.00427191611379385, 0.005901499185711145, -0.031841717660427094, 0.0020886650308966637, -0.053649455308914185, 0.0054990448988974094, -0.017606096342206, 0.034104522317647934, -0.08402185142040253, 0.012683266773819923, -0.0606771819293499, 0.011207238771021366, -0.03648652881383896, 0.018528351560235023, -0.04796095937490463, 0.01676638051867485, -0.07635976374149323, 0.014702730812132359, -0.007971360348165035, 0.08834660053253174, 0.0010966950794681907, 0.03359425440430641, -0.03914085030555725, -0.022831253707408905, -0.08875527232885361, 0.030618585646152496, -0.017197508364915848, 0.04983683302998543, 0.006319778971374035, 0.030138911679387093, -0.02133491262793541, 0.0005051917396485806, 0.030851878225803375, -0.030891532078385353, 0.016461359336972237, -0.06471556425094604, -0.061794254928827286, -0.006021625827997923, -0.05174720287322998, 0.004835991654545069, 0.015417593531310558, -0.025590041652321815, -0.019691426306962967, -0.06603385508060455, -0.02579246461391449, -0.04309218376874924, 0.010079847648739815, -0.014624683186411858, -0.0033906681928783655, -0.037741322070360184, -0.02620791643857956, -0.011308026500046253, 0.046888791024684906, -0.048943355679512024, 0.015116105787456036, 0.011770389974117279, -0.011917141266167164, -0.05981037765741348, -0.04150797054171562, -0.03197665512561798, -0.010462295264005661, 0.007799492217600346, -0.05242009088397026, -0.00011704556527547538, 0.002869274001568556, -0.006197468377649784, 0.013005026616156101, -0.07234109938144684, -0.004571741446852684, 0.01604958437383175, 0.0034741528797894716, 0.0007756724371574819, 0.017977574840188026, -0.05482961982488632, 0.015568575821816921, 0.010275870561599731, -0.05299314856529236, 0.025952782481908798, -0.01296885684132576, 0.0145872188732028, 0.0742788314819336, 0.04014826938509941, -0.009558104909956455, -0.00611529778689146, -0.05561790242791176, 0.029576266184449196, -0.05541622266173363, 0.048838209360837936, -0.007332941982895136, 0.048366695642471313, -0.007403723429888487, -0.004169301129877567, 0.030399374663829803, -0.04898100346326828, 0.05411427095532417, -0.02064754255115986, -0.025175271555781364, 0.04164813086390495, -0.008410686627030373, -0.004907582420855761, 0.00738744530826807, 0.014768119901418686, 0.05192238464951515, 0.01810167357325554, -0.02119920775294304, -0.032873526215553284, 0.056991249322891235, 0.00403785053640604, -0.012381470762193203, 0.049270644783973694, 0.07379662990570068, 0.03550579398870468, 0.04121798276901245, -0.012028192169964314, -0.0452316589653492, -0.03746694326400757, -0.07651456445455551, -0.015263043344020844, 0.016047252342104912, -0.0038898102939128876, 0.01834501512348652, -0.0003092096303589642, 0.030225295573472977, -0.06359647214412689, 0.018077950924634933, -0.03976288065314293, -0.07856671512126923, -0.010552107356488705, 0.017449550330638885, 0.01791468821465969, 0.021209383383393288, -0.01918502151966095, 0.05426774546504021, -0.024513987824320793, -0.07739865034818649, 0.00716238422319293, 0.03871650993824005, 0.01337779313325882, -0.060424596071243286, 0.04281268268823624, 0.03613501042127609, 0.04964950308203697, 0.012718665413558483, 0.03979926556348801, 0.034865137189626694, -0.009771906770765781, 0.06016550213098526, -0.06335511058568954, 0.00580133032053709, 0.016011260449886322, 0.04396501183509827, 0.04729778319597244, -0.04195418208837509, -0.016126712784171104, 0.015468823723495007, 0.02562682330608368, -0.04194812476634979, -0.02828832156956196, -0.052950795739889145, -0.027065513655543327, -0.042750146239995956, 0.04907584935426712, 0.02989213913679123, -0.07315123826265335, -0.0332140251994133, -0.03317057713866234, 0.04535368084907532, 0.029312267899513245, 0.005374123342335224, -0.012348765507340431, -0.007853854447603226, -0.03997916728258133, 0.03642032667994499, 0.0002615904086269438, 0.02517118491232395, 0.057058267295360565, -0.002330958843231201, 0.03685649111866951, 0.0438004806637764, 0.010460483841598034, -0.04252469539642334, -0.042294785380363464, -0.022740934044122696, -0.008773929439485073, -0.07501987367868423, 0.008534150198101997, 0.003078566864132881, 0.02136843651533127, 0.010447071865200996, -0.0014824394602328539, -0.017300181090831757, 0.01887764036655426, 0.008723996579647064, -0.030655179172754288, 0.04973972961306572, 0.01806490868330002, 0.07285483926534653, -0.04094850644469261, 0.025715384632349014, -0.10652395337820053, 0.00002448453233228065, 0.04004745930433273, 0.10963079333305359, 0.009477009996771812, -0.009074370376765728, -0.07776513695716858, 0.03577187657356262, 0.027417583391070366, -0.029826674610376358, -0.009857012890279293, -0.04327604919672012, 0.025974594056606293, 0.08090317994356155, -0.005329939536750317, 0.045490916818380356, 0.024381883442401886, -0.055229514837265015, -0.030197734013199806, 0.001346795936115086, -0.03954409435391426, 0.014929678291082382, 0.056816451251506805, -0.045968443155288696, 0.046922631561756134, -0.005418975837528706, -0.026936156675219536, -0.015269778668880463, 0.04730109125375748, 0.0005309507250785828, 0.003334466367959976, -0.056250642985105515, -0.01565726287662983, 0.03681544214487076, 0.01739218272268772, 0.06523873656988144, 0.003797403071075678, -0.03865635395050049, 0.06171225383877754, 0.010935950092971325, 0.05990619957447052, -0.07195644825696945, 0.008090038783848286, 0.016849691048264503, 0.002131025306880474, -0.023900210857391357, -0.004018358886241913, -0.017395328730344772, 0.006816433276981115, 0.051105793565511703, 0.03628213331103325, -0.038057610392570496, 0.03521484136581421, -0.026261627674102783, 0.028652187436819077, -0.01929577812552452, -0.03758164122700691, 0.0019017597660422325, 0.04699256643652916, -0.026587599888443947, -0.049121662974357605, -0.04963168129324913, 0.044392772018909454, -0.04547460377216339, -0.0071584307588636875, -0.029369235038757324, -0.004609295167028904, -0.017254535108804703, -0.021875225007534027, -0.0013569483999162912, -0.0015864185988903046, 0.015062779188156128, -0.012775027193129063, 0.03137398138642311, -0.014824307523667812, -0.012842780910432339, 0.019289324060082436, -0.0161092821508646, -0.013576129451394081, 0.017038078978657722, -0.022649768739938736, -0.009138914756476879, -0.01013852283358574, -0.07145492732524872, -0.003265687031671405, 0.07163896411657333, 0.05606130138039589, -0.02961503341794014, 0.0034844649489969015, 0.0414091981947422, 0.05247720703482628, -0.015314830467104912, -0.014648379758000374, 0.014913637191057205, -0.037111613899469376, 0.04428631067276001, 0.022999610751867294, -0.013111896812915802, 0.0654008612036705, 0.03101157583296299, -0.01014637015759945, -0.028010116890072823, 0.024148307740688324, 0.008491449058055878, 0.018773576244711876, 0.019578080624341965, -0.05447884276509285, 0.059860896319150925, 0.005307579878717661, 0.07913105934858322, -0.011968646198511124, -0.03152712434530258, 0.08751841634511948, -0.048265241086483, 0.03171708807349205, -0.021207468584179878, -0.017153875902295113, 0.0025936837773770094, 0.02780797705054283, 0.016926178708672523, 0.04043686017394066, 0.04361506924033165, 0.04459456354379654, -0.02457108534872532, -0.05564533919095993, -0.03101763315498829, 0.05989883467555046, 0.005297667346894741, -0.05539238452911377, 0.020441049709916115, -0.06575256586074829, -0.0000026796426482178504, -0.01600981503725052, -0.0481402724981308, -0.011540326289832592, -0.00638196524232626, 0.010984438471496105, 0.003865640377625823, -0.03339492529630661, -0.007155328057706356, 0.022169725969433784, -0.02580205537378788, -0.02644382230937481, 0.0012866915203630924, -0.0015981830656528473, -0.032469235360622406, 0.07303101569414139, -0.019910836592316628, -0.028802407905459404, 0.0017114633228629827, 0.04711056500673294, -0.08828554302453995, 0.07070466876029968, 0.006914948578923941, -0.03453623130917549, -0.015595692209899426, 0.010303656570613384, 0.004617052152752876, 0.049153417348861694, -0.015536777675151825, 0.011440260335803032, 0.02552000619471073, -0.04137234017252922, -0.01690489985048771, -0.006428265478461981, 0.010583820752799511, -0.016879338771104813, 0.02184627391397953, -0.03884992003440857, 0.013815276324748993, -0.015234352089464664, 0.07976536452770233, -0.02534681186079979, 0.033898960798978806, -0.003525456413626671, 0.048771146684885025 ]
<p>Ryder in his QFT book writes in eqn (2.20):</p> <p>Probability density, $\rho = \frac{i\hbar}{2m}(\phi^*\frac{\partial \phi}{\partial t} - \phi \frac{\partial \phi^*}{\partial t})$</p> <p>Then in the next paragraph he writes: Since the Klein-Gordon equation is second order, $\phi$ and $\frac{\partial \phi}{\partial t}$ can be fixed arbitrarily a given time, so $\rho$ may take on negative values,..</p> <p>What does he mean by this line?</p>
g4048
[ 0.06924371421337128, -0.0022797537967562675, -0.023286430165171623, 0.006084149237722158, 0.08360393345355988, 0.039397697895765305, -0.00466977059841156, -0.011316959746181965, -0.05884832143783569, -0.007489037699997425, -0.009411775507032871, -0.009656992740929127, -0.0303179994225502, 0.04053427651524544, 0.021499115973711014, 0.010566823184490204, 0.04708653315901756, 0.02770916000008583, -0.029988804832100868, -0.007656868081539869, -0.08990473300218582, -0.006007487419992685, 0.010550029575824738, -0.04390546306967735, 0.07576509565114975, 0.01875421218574047, 0.047036007046699524, -0.021410387009382248, -0.040299419313669205, -0.0010402033803984523, -0.02008000575006008, 0.02633855864405632, -0.0007542205275967717, -0.09593133628368378, -0.04199051111936569, 0.009419268928468227, 0.04178021475672722, -0.003826479660347104, 0.06400278955698013, -0.050254885107278824, -0.014923079870641232, -0.011534590274095535, 0.02107522077858448, -0.04994339123368263, -0.004905481822788715, 0.03358522430062294, -0.01939993165433407, 0.08491344749927521, -0.04455713927745819, 0.00010743495658971369, 0.00769417267292738, 0.047548361122608185, 0.05654885992407799, -0.017717575654387474, -0.028766389936208725, 0.04932509735226631, 0.058169230818748474, -0.048261888325214386, 0.005650464911013842, 0.04403456300497055, -0.007360197603702545, -0.07288437336683273, 0.036506131291389465, 0.019422972574830055, 0.05734258517622948, 0.018821628764271736, 0.0002269432443426922, -0.03853914514183998, 0.024371003732085228, 0.044371336698532104, -0.0225165244191885, -0.030275829136371613, -0.018200913444161415, -0.011810043826699257, -0.01439850963652134, 0.06468145549297333, -0.01358113158494234, -0.0008677734876982868, 0.039059948176145554, -0.005524978041648865, -0.03814743086695671, 0.030559293925762177, -0.028645679354667664, 0.02961835451424122, 0.04200423136353493, -0.02616097964346409, 0.06351985037326813, -0.039559416472911835, 0.023369794711470604, 0.023432787507772446, -0.002062992425635457, 0.006156887859106064, 0.008402868174016476, 0.0019828288350254297, 0.025085225701332092, -0.01324545405805111, -0.028759481385350227, 0.026893986389040947, -0.06380487233400345, -0.02467799372971058, -0.039028193801641464, 0.026197046041488647, 0.023154951632022858, -0.03856007382273674, -0.04499950632452965, 0.014640138484537601, -0.007783480454236269, 0.03302805498242378, 0.012017035856842995, -0.0025079722981899977, 0.004739993251860142, 0.003091997466981411, -0.045944247394800186, -0.05854913219809532, -0.005470681004226208, 0.003492752555757761, 0.0007582734106108546, -0.02173658274114132, 0.01348176784813404, 0.07807749509811401, 0.012945577502250671, -0.026450898498296738, 0.015610110014677048, 0.06579218059778214, -0.08157028257846832, -0.03248501941561699, -0.05141504481434822, 0.06268325448036194, 0.03707323968410492, 0.03333025798201561, -0.007581168785691261, -0.0017024523112922907, 0.005196691025048494, 0.023055529221892357, -0.009215077385306358, 0.061149466782808304, -0.00020358212350402027, 0.006362746004015207, 0.00847315602004528, -0.01295588817447424, -0.019478004425764084, -0.017953090369701385, 0.02752261981368065, -0.015920434147119522, -0.003322943579405546, -0.0014446043642237782, 0.017245972529053688, -0.015934890136122704, -0.03811213746666908, -0.023874547332525253, -0.014066441915929317, 0.04701649397611618, -0.013630513101816177, 0.05184027552604675, 0.0460895374417305, 0.003519773483276367, 0.05781777575612068, -0.008239777758717537, -0.024326279759407043, -0.020522134378552437, 0.05751599371433258, 0.011194005608558655, 0.026466261595487595, -0.0032507956493645906, -0.03746085986495018, 0.03426573425531387, 0.03868091478943825, -0.08964372426271439, -0.0041179233230650425, -0.02378653548657894, 0.00869247317314148, 0.03203302249312401, 0.032615456730127335, -0.0132107213139534, -0.010870076715946198, 0.034417200833559036, -0.002984871855005622, -0.01831105351448059, 0.05274809151887894, 0.05728020891547203, -0.030488712713122368, -0.022170454263687134, 0.01791260950267315, -0.015432118438184261, -0.001713561825454235, 0.0001854088914114982, 0.025674549862742424, 0.02457793429493904, -0.026094060391187668, 0.008125727996230125, -0.004519307520240545, 0.023194555193185806, -0.052018266171216965, 0.02897140011191368, 0.05811624601483345, 0.0067322407849133015, -0.01813313737511635, -0.05846371501684189, -0.008660845458507538, 0.033492445945739746, 0.038614753633737564, -0.01007293164730072, 0.04028203338384628, 0.011413638480007648, 0.04960045590996742, -0.018410982564091682, 0.02943112701177597, -0.020768634974956512, 0.02703033573925495, 0.011268630623817444, 0.007014748640358448, -0.055749453604221344, -0.04417234659194946, 0.08469530940055847, 0.015140388160943985, -0.02833319455385208, 0.0007707450422458351, 0.03924550116062164, -0.00797633919864893, 0.0005777228507213295, -0.052985552698373795, 0.0019910510163754225, 0.07369707524776459, -0.03550197184085846, -0.0007076795445755124, 0.046707164496183395, 0.06275550276041031, -0.03372559696435928, -0.04839860647916794, 0.00013715040404349566, -0.0380534753203392, -0.025278236716985703, -0.066475048661232, 0.05211438611149788, 0.042912084609270096, 0.05003111809492111, -0.007115544285625219, -0.023979147896170616, 0.019009850919246674, 0.048942502588033676, -0.0009360686526633799, 0.0105223273858428, -0.034197621047496796, -0.010624971240758896, 0.028905246406793594, 0.017739195376634598, 0.06308690458536148, -0.010041720233857632, 0.010591927915811539, 0.05872996896505356, 0.05920805782079697, -0.06008940562605858, -0.01019388996064663, 0.03579556941986084, -0.000012933360267197713, -0.015987684950232506, -0.06112377718091011, 0.052485253661870956, -0.016835210844874382, -0.036955006420612335, 0.05230771005153656, 0.011320448480546474, 0.027738243341445923, -0.031045004725456238, -0.04877454414963722, -0.0115817254409194, -0.05372686684131622, 0.053420618176460266, 0.01230844296514988, 0.007598846219480038, 0.026239493861794472, 0.04401923343539238, 0.03291340544819832, 0.089748814702034, 0.0025468855164945126, -0.02877551130950451, 0.0018461321014910936, -0.03552820160984993, 0.042541295289993286, -0.008644862100481987, 0.016921665519475937, -0.03940128907561302, -0.013774584978818893, 0.04782601073384285, -0.023727448657155037, -0.04147748276591301, 0.01210105326026678, 0.011740053072571754, -0.014907371252775192, 0.08099088817834854, -0.0209804717451334, 0.015243283472955227, -0.0025185346603393555, -0.06618715822696686, 0.028995456174016, 0.06557203829288483, -0.01985081098973751, -0.09091833233833313, 0.03917708247900009, 0.015528247691690922, -0.03720172122120857, -0.016421427950263023, -0.05737340450286865, -0.015589505434036255, 0.036055807024240494, -0.0009581584017723799, -0.04847097396850586, -0.04134994372725487, -0.028600992634892464, -0.042942676693201065, 0.005906964186578989, 0.02518550306558609, -0.034448228776454926, -0.01853961870074272, 0.0020253658294677734, 0.04457524046301842, 0.007703129202127457, 0.026194948703050613, 0.012865942902863026, 0.004578434396535158, -0.0031045007053762674, -0.035224247723817825, -0.027332693338394165, -0.014732247218489647, 0.01371034700423479, 0.014800484292209148, -0.042780596762895584, 0.011315598152577877, -0.014439872466027737, -0.010657577775418758, 0.01132600661367178, -0.0660613477230072, 0.009046587161719799, -0.010133961215615273, -0.052177369594573975, -0.027963517233729362, -0.008477775380015373, 0.03213386982679367, -0.020463919267058372, 0.003058210713788867, -0.04773755744099617, -0.05663825571537018, -0.01783687435090542, 0.08130977302789688, -0.0009776703082025051, -0.06002338230609894, 0.004593806806951761, 0.03673616424202919, 0.05014371871948242, 0.03964986652135849, 0.0027695156168192625, -0.01772964559495449, 0.024373101070523262, -0.008244946599006653, 0.014331202022731304, 0.05136997252702713, 0.05036340281367302, 0.002997765550389886, 0.039301928132772446, -0.004975024610757828, -0.02525235153734684, -0.07247039675712585, 0.0022524946834892035, 0.04106597602367401, 0.020224550738930702, -0.021014370024204254, 0.009651200845837593, 0.05823538452386856, 0.00855911523103714, 0.03494410216808319, 0.010639720596373081, 0.007529747672379017, 0.0691472589969635, 0.028339596465229988, 0.012104060500860214, -0.04490610212087631, -0.025272570550441742, -0.020280886441469193, 0.03060789778828621, 0.08141008764505386, -0.0050349109806120396, 0.006595832761377096, -0.012347890064120293, 0.012053164653480053, -0.025590654462575912, 0.02358425036072731, -0.026362353935837746, -0.058282773941755295, 0.005897230934351683, -0.01998523809015751, -0.01784764789044857, -0.013685847632586956, -0.02156401239335537, 0.006957970093935728, 0.01868012361228466, -0.015441226772964, 0.02881142497062683, -0.023646438494324684, -0.05431516468524933, 0.0425964780151844, -0.021170513704419136, 0.00844046100974083, -0.018884271383285522, -0.0007644960423931479, -0.004433764610439539, 0.00811917893588543, -0.016403954476118088, -0.0024621293414384127, -0.017647480592131615, -0.06106516718864441, -0.016502993181347847, -0.060127850621938705, -0.020018458366394043, -0.05288448929786682, 0.008969751186668873, -0.039846789091825485, 0.02785521000623703, -0.017114685848355293, -0.006050001829862595, -0.0001986059796763584, 0.07815014570951462, -0.03858181834220886, -0.0012051926460117102, -0.04777194559574127, -0.005300623830407858, 0.004990525543689728, 0.06969619542360306, 0.019987056031823158, -0.007246547844260931, -0.05749748274683952, -0.0011901891557499766, 0.017142873257398605, 0.030100366100668907, 0.037539292126894, -0.030561428517103195, 0.025606626644730568, -0.0491478256881237, 0.00786652509123087, -0.091509148478508, 0.021117057651281357, -0.03375288471579552, -0.05196603387594223, 0.02284296229481697, -0.001540281460620463, 0.06759215891361237, 0.009753172285854816, -0.010694069787859917, -0.06180661544203758, 0.012002188712358475, -0.007725797593593597, -0.01842687651515007, -0.007682496681809425, 0.07641209661960602, -0.03350549936294556, 0.03421197086572647, -0.05461776629090309, -0.05780067294836044, 0.03151542320847511, 0.03716668859124184, 0.01944887451827526, -0.044596392661333084, 0.023711375892162323, 0.037940628826618195, -0.017838601022958755, 0.08366633951663971, 0.00361192156560719, -0.08941280841827393, 0.015983330085873604, -0.07483604550361633, -0.019107094034552574, -0.018331225961446762, 0.0038021779619157314, 0.025875559076666832, -0.03129389509558678, -0.005868745502084494, 0.020498011261224747, -0.02926212176680565, -0.003437879029661417, -0.04395640268921852, -0.020393794402480125, 0.00021470429783221334, 0.004570371937006712, 0.0045776874758303165, -0.0195529256016016, -0.03686382248997688, 0.04180935025215149, 0.00032775718136690557, 0.027422137558460236, 0.02125290036201477, -0.03935389593243599, 0.04748157784342766, 0.04980318620800972, 0.023630604147911072, 0.0688914880156517, -0.003704254049807787, 0.008667228743433952, 0.025457391515374184, -0.026498688384890556, -0.010480739176273346, 0.00780557282269001, -0.0036218983586877584, -0.017826523631811142, 0.03991803899407387, -0.039642754942178726, 0.007770678494125605, 0.08316672593355179, 0.01554237399250269, -0.023443525657057762, -0.031082378700375557, -0.011929582804441452, 0.01672264188528061, -0.03248607739806175, 0.02111409604549408, 0.025714965537190437, 0.016384780406951904, -0.020200638100504875, -0.030653711408376694, -0.045383308082818985, -0.04278107360005379, -0.036216214299201965, 0.048919133841991425, 0.07825109362602234, 0.030266376212239265, -0.04436573386192322, 0.00882114190608263, 0.014876064844429493, -0.06647436320781708, -0.05992216244339943, 0.028939230367541313, 0.022581441327929497, 0.021788880228996277, -0.021906308829784393, 0.03367472067475319, 0.028890259563922882, -0.01198448333889246, -0.0022181670647114515, -0.045401208102703094, 0.04042567312717438, 0.021528882905840874, 0.037489745765924454, 0.009973450563848019, -0.010105878114700317, 0.027708258479833603, 0.04479438439011574, -0.02360111102461815, 0.00547947408631444, -0.04459548369050026, -0.009914971888065338, 0.023401454091072083, -0.033702269196510315, -0.022923462092876434, -0.030736859887838364, -0.02240769751369953, -0.002999268937855959, -0.008827995508909225, 0.006395399104803801, 0.013598790392279625, -0.0017600060673430562, -0.03866732120513916, 0.02986697293817997, 0.006987088359892368, -0.0221512783318758, -0.006090862210839987, 0.06885753571987152, 0.0329984575510025, -0.006507225334644318, 0.025720808655023575, 0.009694777429103851, 0.00037437109858728945, -0.019498828798532486, -0.03569060564041138, 0.02586614154279232, 0.0005246787914074957, -0.013302721083164215, 0.032863058149814606, -0.01604124903678894, 0.01659824140369892, -0.11111286282539368, -0.04850076511502266, -0.02151329256594181, -0.03963851556181908, 0.01514660008251667, 0.0040300567634403706, -0.043018847703933716, -0.009258070960640907, 0.05862680822610855, 0.03397978097200394, -0.035101715475320816, 0.10324446856975555, 0.03948085755109787, -0.009018980897963047, -0.02903730235993862, -0.06712664663791656, -0.00853043980896473, -0.01585383713245392, 0.009955339133739471, -0.004545123782008886, -0.0174410417675972, -0.08867795765399933, 0.005740158725529909, -0.0021024129819124937, 0.06752848625183105, 0.06682547926902771, -0.043344683945178986, 0.03612286597490311, 0.00065431377151981, 0.024898111820220947, 0.026345254853367805, -0.019602131098508835, 0.05733234062790871, -0.023091427981853485, 0.013312846422195435, 0.014589644968509674, -0.025823907926678658, 0.08462047576904297, -0.040591493248939514, 0.038410086184740067, 0.02403615415096283, -0.01179788913577795, -0.01578294299542904, 0.047679603099823, -0.017245329916477203, -0.03545505180954933, -0.05639904737472534, 0.05868873745203018, 0.02049705572426319, 0.01626555062830448, -0.022465288639068604, 0.002849349519237876, 0.017458412796258926, 0.0533098429441452, -0.003944522235542536, -0.04618707299232483, 0.02580271102488041, -0.033017538487911224, -0.0009965065401047468, -0.08812568336725235, 0.06147424131631851, -0.01050895731896162, -0.017996646463871002, -0.0026420000940561295, 0.04684550315141678, 0.034880004823207855, -0.10968616604804993, -0.027185041457414627, 0.012323340401053429, 0.02201981656253338, -0.027031373232603073, -0.11499405652284622, 0.005221661180257797, 0.06669685989618301, 0.0036282551009207964, -0.004095093347132206, -0.010416751727461815, -0.00760394474491477, 0.0021509623620659113, -0.013812446035444736, 0.028576401993632317, 0.04217371717095375, -0.030616160482168198, -0.03908934444189072, 0.009108604863286018, -0.01491609774529934, 0.019292591139674187, -0.01785498671233654, -0.0617513470351696, -0.02345309406518936, -0.06640473753213882, 0.03352658823132515, -0.08404745161533356, 0.002930251881480217, -0.031648147851228714, -0.042825113981962204, -0.03412562608718872, -0.010662849992513657, -0.02165107987821102, 0.03194572031497955, 0.06722535938024521, 0.01756943017244339, 0.03625292703509331, -0.0025493933353573084, 0.03378169983625412, 0.025094447657465935, -0.06195129081606865, -0.023539463058114052, 0.03891364485025406, -0.025967007502913475, -0.06930476427078247, 0.04283176735043526, 0.01452045887708664, 0.03921829164028168, -0.031470637768507004, -0.016577810049057007, 0.0037980121560394764, 0.000951845315285027, -0.021926820278167725, 0.010248621925711632, 0.0775771290063858, 0.024221276864409447, 0.013675795868039131, 0.02719215489923954, -0.0049935090355575085, -0.02864089235663414, -0.004041609819978476, 0.03297647461295128, -0.006072490010410547, 0.07604994624853134, -0.0706544741988182, -0.03876114636659622, -0.0970969870686531, 0.02133466862142086, -0.021284736692905426, -0.008325297385454178, 0.026811467483639717, 0.02059587836265564, -0.004051296506077051, -0.02102457545697689, 0.012489263899624348, -0.01827935501933098, -0.07545124739408493, -0.018164493143558502, -0.03528369218111038, -0.019732246175408363, -0.031784914433956146, -0.02163352072238922, 0.023511603474617004, -0.03622226417064667, -0.007808674592524767, -0.000448424369096756, 0.06301109492778778, -0.09635379910469055, -0.03948156535625458, 0.0034782718867063522, 0.023901131004095078, 0.003061995841562748, 0.0025157397612929344, 0.01222813967615366, 0.018707996234297752, 0.025687124580144882, -0.009145569987595081, 0.003726025577634573, -0.023898260667920113, 0.021343732252717018, 0.022994956001639366, -0.005522937048226595, -0.04025757685303688, -0.04312507435679436, 0.004985393490642309, 0.06573209911584854, 0.00443823030218482, 0.007043902762234211, 0.004426876548677683, -0.008199450559914112, 0.026543589308857918, 0.019329532980918884, -0.0528707318007946, 0.030665064230561256, 0.03370406851172447, 0.022244427353143692, 0.026723630726337433, 0.03009439818561077, -0.0703183263540268, -0.06397762149572372, -0.0077561382204294205, 0.011717971414327621, -0.06054114177823067, 0.030396725982427597, 0.009335086680948734 ]
<p>I have a question about Eq. (4.3.3) in Polchinski's string theory book volume I, p. 131. It is said</p> <blockquote> <p>Replacing the $X^{\mu}$ with a general matter CFT, the BRST transformation of the matter fields is a conformal transformation with $v(z)=c(z)$, while $T^m$ replaces $T^X$ in the transformation of $b$. Noether's theorem gives the BRST current $$ j_B = c T^m + \frac{1}{2} : cT^g : + \frac{3}{2} \partial^2 c, $$ $$ = c T^m + : bc \partial c : + \frac{3}{2} \partial^2 c, \tag{4.3.3}$$</p> </blockquote> <p>My question is, what is the explicit expression of $T^m$?</p> <p>According to <a href="http://www.science.uva.nl/onderwijs/thesis/centraal/files/f1989820784.pdf" rel="nofollow">this thesis</a>, p 29, $$-\frac{1}{\alpha'}: c \partial X \cdot \partial X = :c T_X:$$</p> <p>Suppose this expression is correct, I cannot use it to vertify Eq. (4.3.11) $$T(z) j_B(0) \sim \frac{ c^m - 26}{2z^4} c(0) + \frac{1}{z^2} j_B(0) + \frac{1}{z} \partial j_B(0) \tag{4.3.11}$$</p> <p>if in (4.3.11), $T(z)= -\frac{1}{\alpha'} : \partial X^{\mu} \partial X_{\mu} : \tag{2.4.4}$ and I applied contraction Eq. (2.2.11).</p>
g4049
[ 0.026105543598532677, -0.048015523701906204, 0.000966094434261322, -0.0752284824848175, 0.021631155163049698, 0.01872727833688259, 0.048404354602098465, -0.013897043652832508, -0.02078232355415821, 0.015079952776432037, -0.08134891092777252, 0.04565531387925148, -0.009882360696792603, 0.026786834001541138, -0.017402803525328636, 0.03294271603226662, 0.05964590236544609, -0.015210744924843311, 0.05138257518410683, -0.04938681796193123, -0.008433077484369278, 0.015081174671649933, 0.021677259355783463, -0.024786973372101784, 0.009181328117847443, 0.006031912751495838, 0.03392669931054115, 0.024552181363105774, -0.019382404163479805, -0.039078280329704285, 0.02104010246694088, 0.06105061620473862, 0.07259856909513474, 0.03358918055891991, -0.025846952572464943, -0.006898520514369011, 0.10252177715301514, 0.07636181265115738, 0.0643918588757515, -0.0027360303793102503, 0.0031683987472206354, 0.021395599469542503, 0.018344053998589516, 0.008099828846752644, -0.024152847006917, -0.02096068486571312, -0.07467542588710785, -0.008953642100095749, -0.019424784928560257, 0.007774668745696545, 0.028247442096471786, 0.019911834970116615, 0.034492913633584976, -0.020337117835879326, -0.02618900127708912, 0.014242107048630714, 0.005963652860373259, -0.03702150657773018, 0.01797516830265522, 0.049985360354185104, -0.03693699836730957, -0.03630807250738144, -0.00596611388027668, -0.01907547377049923, 0.05100223049521446, -0.06467010080814362, -0.03019724227488041, 0.05191637575626373, 0.016839658841490746, 0.0036201898474246264, 0.033506911247968674, 0.025289196521043777, 0.05821935087442398, 0.0010650383774191141, -0.05163160338997841, -0.02094436250627041, -0.0097123421728611, -0.03846818581223488, 0.02965511381626129, -0.035050272941589355, -0.0313943475484848, -0.008135112933814526, -0.0005148190539330244, -0.0042737992480397224, 0.02682800404727459, -0.05661981552839279, -0.028189774602651596, 0.030062943696975708, 0.030446987599134445, 0.003254897426813841, -0.0524352490901947, 0.00874607264995575, -0.013242371380329132, -0.027804747223854065, 0.01645532064139843, -0.03063145838677883, 0.04523976892232895, -0.017758619040250778, -0.012055846862494946, -0.04883567616343498, -0.025977807119488716, 0.02868511714041233, -0.04010971635580063, 0.04178331419825554, -0.00830747652798891, -0.00596286216750741, 0.030039099976420403, -0.0003882802266161889, -0.036852654069662094, -0.035070084035396576, -0.05380139872431755, 0.00611501932144165, 0.013806667178869247, -0.016583560034632683, -0.05666833370923996, 0.02052091620862484, -0.06548797339200974, 0.024953346699476242, -0.06281875818967819, 0.017287814989686012, 0.02586417645215988, -0.03390509635210037, 0.058462534099817276, 0.053863923996686935, -0.010853540152311325, -0.043303489685058594, -0.024253590032458305, 0.08445997536182404, 0.08657560497522354, -0.024284763261675835, -0.03641009330749512, -0.02713852748274803, 0.08277980983257294, -0.008674271404743195, 0.030182145535945892, -0.028712453320622444, 0.02187693491578102, 0.011139485985040665, -0.010602653957903385, 0.019827192649245262, -0.004835445899516344, -0.05914812535047531, -0.02000652253627777, 0.03299369663000107, 0.0032914122566580772, 0.014754993841052055, -0.0316925123333931, -0.018408047035336494, 0.0329645611345768, -0.004618979059159756, 0.002855589846149087, 0.06135249510407448, 0.024354984983801842, -0.04224874824285507, -0.01948835887014866, 0.036792218685150146, 0.06321301311254501, -0.04234438017010689, -0.04043642804026604, 0.031422246247529984, 0.004222844261676073, -0.03751092404127121, -0.04115236550569534, 0.046889323741197586, -0.049801092594861984, -0.009183453395962715, 0.03417511284351349, 0.018394146114587784, 0.008750307373702526, -0.05915258079767227, -0.04703127592802048, 0.05247858539223671, 0.02617884986102581, 0.033531032502651215, 0.01466989517211914, 0.030715638771653175, -0.06332466006278992, -0.014495119452476501, 0.04699719324707985, -0.0012479507131502032, -0.0654863491654396, -0.02463628724217415, -0.014475883916020393, 0.015622762963175774, 0.018663670867681503, 0.005857527256011963, -0.02420138008892536, -0.010181383229792118, -0.04328758269548416, 0.05384988337755203, -0.06289379298686981, 0.04248496890068054, -0.0011077296221628785, 0.062216632068157196, 0.012491454370319843, 0.028838086873292923, 0.030950041487812996, -0.058723319321870804, 0.0036085990723222494, -0.03725511580705643, 0.03893706575036049, 0.02036408521234989, 0.052471984177827835, -0.045107949525117874, 0.06471331417560577, 0.020150715485215187, -0.06804893910884857, -0.01278227660804987, -0.006494623608887196, 0.014975836500525475, 0.01152282115072012, 0.010087866336107254, -0.013512814417481422, -0.01602129451930523, -0.05457542464137077, -0.03803858160972595, 0.01134475227445364, 0.0007648486644029617, -0.07069168984889984, 0.02442227303981781, -0.015226940624415874, -0.018149584531784058, 0.01677083596587181, -0.0021456873510032892, -0.04660305380821228, 0.02396433800458908, 0.03083086758852005, 0.012192968279123306, -0.020159298554062843, 0.0027324557304382324, -0.04410405457019806, -0.02568308636546135, -0.008183294907212257, 0.0026561988051980734, 0.019345343112945557, 0.0609392412006855, -0.007500683888792992, 0.022833511233329773, 0.08025674521923065, 0.06205957010388374, 0.056947335600852966, 0.027757711708545685, -0.058967169374227524, -0.03216344118118286, 0.051648106426000595, 0.0019761486910283566, 0.06673162430524826, 0.005255275871604681, 0.009568652138113976, -0.006428317632526159, -0.01376872044056654, -0.07698645442724228, -0.025249715894460678, 0.01981484517455101, -0.009322654455900192, 0.014828422106802464, -0.01554897055029869, 0.04079119861125946, -0.007558660581707954, -0.024449151009321213, -0.01093017403036356, -0.050827667117118835, -0.003976437728852034, 0.011369042098522186, -0.11451644450426102, -0.053127337247133255, -0.04374934732913971, -0.013932913541793823, -0.011935989372432232, 0.06397735327482224, -0.051171135157346725, -0.026991792023181915, 0.020419135689735413, 0.017284514382481575, -0.05415521189570427, -0.04271676763892174, -0.012566354125738144, -0.022008391097187996, -0.030784036964178085, -0.03196459263563156, -0.03447432443499565, 0.014869757927954197, 0.0017785903764888644, 0.034920163452625275, -0.034495700150728226, -0.051215119659900665, -0.020480984821915627, -0.013445856049656868, -0.03810596466064453, 0.008855394087731838, -0.003678475972265005, 0.027018385007977486, 0.05809784680604935, 0.0383048914372921, 0.017463933676481247, -0.0021689855493605137, 0.01702686958014965, -0.03794269636273384, 0.021343842148780823, 0.06416293978691101, -0.026992185041308403, -0.01765730045735836, -0.00231954432092607, 0.0430930070579052, -0.0008384492830373347, -0.016988608986139297, -0.044806379824876785, -0.0902654230594635, 0.027882659807801247, 0.013423102907836437, -0.046337150037288666, -0.03566589951515198, 0.05988605320453644, 0.0037922949995845556, -0.05224524438381195, 0.012298201210796833, -0.010288000106811523, 0.0017211856320500374, 0.05934002250432968, 0.02012714371085167, -0.011292333714663982, -0.001083372044377029, 0.04386010393500328, 0.0008691984112374485, 0.021459588780999184, -0.023857882246375084, -0.02261083573102951, 0.015933508053421974, -0.02583765611052513, -0.031010713428258896, -0.001092310412786901, 0.004021550063043833, 0.05686097964644432, -0.0500769317150116, -0.03550161421298981, -0.051209770143032074, 0.014027677476406097, 0.03914269804954529, 0.029500309377908707, -0.03701014816761017, -0.016499875113368034, -0.044596247375011444, -0.005038970150053501, 0.015434852801263332, -0.0021503388416022062, -0.016661277040839195, 0.008017108775675297, -0.000500841939356178, 0.050284501165151596, -0.03480440378189087, -0.01845061592757702, 0.032338086515665054, 0.026263879612088203, 0.015099911950528622, 0.03585256263613701, 0.014606005512177944, 0.025529619306325912, 0.051590483635663986, -0.00047570490278303623, -0.009741131216287613, 0.04348594695329666, -0.06186063587665558, -0.012547210790216923, 0.040250856429338455, 0.01489370409399271, -0.004718386568129063, 0.011913647875189781, 0.002217276953160763, -0.004446916747838259, 0.064841128885746, 0.024074729532003403, -0.03738774359226227, 0.013720768503844738, 0.030027814209461212, 0.0719819888472557, -0.06942156702280045, 0.0010068033589050174, 0.053319793194532394, -0.03755827993154526, 0.02249199151992798, 0.04414960369467735, -0.0009974321583285928, 0.005451963283121586, -0.021142922341823578, -0.012037905864417553, 0.005746283568441868, -0.017933981493115425, -0.006755581125617027, -0.013407476246356964, -0.020172154530882835, 0.009974165819585323, 0.0456184558570385, -0.0034557573962956667, -0.035356827080249786, -0.04957546293735504, 0.00022240352700464427, 0.04173056036233902, 0.024729201570153236, 0.0019020821200683713, -0.004151799250394106, -0.0032506058923900127, -0.008795630186796188, -0.015468304045498371, -0.035686660557985306, -0.03737068548798561, -0.028473710641264915, 0.007056036032736301, -0.01509249210357666, 0.033831145614385605, -0.046765074133872986, -0.05387142300605774, -0.01726415380835533, -0.04038313403725624, -0.03894595429301262, 0.052179329097270966, -0.023127254098653793, 0.03944505751132965, -0.026276933029294014, 0.01390981674194336, -0.053037259727716446, -0.00014800495409872383, -0.061279866844415665, -0.021972637623548508, -0.024626122787594795, 0.03731992840766907, 0.07810832560062408, 0.03615403175354004, 0.023546243086457253, 0.03765913471579552, 0.023162750527262688, -0.037418074905872345, 0.05927836149930954, -0.02119838446378708, 0.059915777295827866, -0.07548563182353973, 0.061193645000457764, -0.031663015484809875, 0.06411268562078476, 0.0033659699838608503, 0.05239338055253029, 0.03169672563672066, -0.060042332857847214, -0.02188105322420597, -0.042368724942207336, -0.011565301567316055, 0.022291887551546097, -0.06831657886505127, -0.04598965868353844, 0.028747690841555595, -0.007147490978240967, -0.029507029801607132, 0.06845049560070038, 0.009396538138389587, 0.0264857430011034, 0.002855771454051137, -0.015148117206990719, 0.02797701768577099, -0.009341727010905743, 0.03897176682949066, -0.006340517662465572, -0.048537127673625946, 0.046788088977336884, -0.016824936494231224, -0.0018268260173499584, 0.056685104966163635, 0.011212656274437904, -0.03128974139690399, 0.05549722909927368, 0.01738339103758335, -0.002325610024854541, -0.0031946480739861727, -0.009164340794086456, -0.022080013528466225, -0.03699440136551857, 0.029277857393026352, 0.03084503673017025, 0.017038308084011078, -0.02518143691122532, -0.019781796261668205, -0.042911551892757416, 0.0032956881914287806, -0.047848816961050034, 0.008913951925933361, -0.0222922470420599, -0.01946084201335907, 0.05395618453621864, -0.0229932963848114, 0.009902741760015488, 0.02242535538971424, -0.03125222399830818, 0.0277326051145792, 0.05236045643687248, 0.008986842818558216, -0.04386820271611214, -0.04326445981860161, 0.017720377072691917, 0.024741055443882942, -0.07040977478027344, -0.026266902685165405, 0.001056794309988618, -0.024178581312298775, 0.01704929955303669, -0.003996268380433321, 0.015115462243556976, -0.0353582501411438, 0.12091805785894394, 0.026070140302181244, 0.008147776126861572, -0.01846320368349552, -0.0004074646276421845, 0.018158523365855217, -0.02591637894511223, 0.008626990020275116, -0.02273615263402462, -0.02286341041326523, 0.014694010838866234, -0.04753456264734268, -0.04749298840761185, -0.007361828815191984, -0.0420551523566246, 0.07190755009651184, 0.023432951420545578, -0.010545861907303333, -0.010899832472205162, 0.042459886521101, 0.003957034554332495, -0.05134698376059532, -0.07319918274879456, -0.02546364814043045, 0.027683131396770477, -0.008903463371098042, -0.05374022573232651, 0.007565735373646021, 0.007982748560607433, 0.044398289173841476, 0.012249020859599113, -0.057368844747543335, -0.004103406332433224, 0.021770920604467392, -0.005128348246216774, -0.0006046905764378607, -0.01171649806201458, -0.021753555163741112, -0.0031315290834754705, -0.03259468078613281, 0.03638400137424469, -0.002975360257551074, 0.03072328306734562, 0.024272115901112556, -0.0730980709195137, -0.0007735874387435615, -0.033040307462215424, -0.04200144484639168, -0.03542274981737137, 0.04983629286289215, 0.05896357446908951, -0.032032039016485214, -0.030540578067302704, 0.0021248459815979004, -0.015994319692254066, 0.01621493510901928, -0.049302954226732254, -0.021937459707260132, -0.025696566328406334, 0.07995548099279404, -0.05838470160961151, -0.053281623870134354, 0.05163267254829407, 0.06238453835248947, 0.04565948620438576, -0.016924643889069557, 0.03676121309399605, 0.0008243874181061983, 0.008288703858852386, -0.04034487530589104, -0.008820990100502968, -0.00880686566233635, -0.04024922475218773, 0.0018875665264204144, 0.02648763544857502, 0.03413516655564308, -0.027037611231207848, 0.011501278728246689, -0.060467496514320374, -0.029769863933324814, -0.015095267444849014, -0.04531289264559746, -0.049778640270233154, 0.00035553405177779496, 0.05425315722823143, -0.005572208669036627, 0.06164342537522316, -0.012574956752359867, 0.09266018122434616, 0.025672679767012596, 0.04187257960438728, 0.0050462414510548115, 0.03756231442093849, 0.04358647018671036, 0.02309822477400303, 0.01914738491177559, 0.014712155796587467, 0.02471831440925598, -0.0036369108129292727, 0.04828872159123421, 0.028820201754570007, -0.031472574919462204, 0.011223112232983112, 0.00737893907353282, 0.027271129190921783, 0.03798442706465721, 0.013629129156470299, -0.02196698822081089, 0.02041625790297985, 0.07391498237848282, 0.011009246110916138, -0.04837056249380112, 0.02313828654587269, 0.008572028949856758, -0.022143691778182983, 0.07674497365951538, -0.00427657924592495, 0.03871333599090576, -0.027553778141736984, 0.0342978909611702, 0.037671297788619995, 0.010907694697380066, -0.021703585982322693, 0.0025854927953332663, 0.01369437389075756, -0.001695687067694962, -0.030725374817848206, -0.06956775486469269, -0.009138578549027443, 0.00578887015581131, 0.04684146121144295, -0.039137013256549835, 0.023421984165906906, -0.003977711778134108, 0.03634713590145111, -0.002629340160638094, 0.024448337033391, 0.043478112667798996, -0.03996807336807251, -0.08352391421794891, -0.018395476043224335, 0.035585951060056686, 0.005911261774599552, -0.12219688296318054, 0.04986748844385147, 0.04960402101278305, 0.06254322826862335, -0.03201417997479439, 0.031050169840455055, -0.02514513209462166, -0.061915844678878784, 0.012606102973222733, 0.008775496855378151, 0.022547705098986626, -0.04419061914086342, -0.05932851508259773, -0.05891084671020508, 0.029663851484656334, -0.012261542491614819, 0.04161592200398445, 0.04495901241898537, -0.0035735175479203463, -0.028085896745324135, 0.0342954583466053, -0.054857462644577026, -0.0009031357476487756, -0.011275901459157467, -0.07001573592424393, 0.004544769413769245, 0.010058561339974403, -0.011510447598993778, 0.019547291100025177, 0.07416021823883057, -0.006045230198651552, -0.017698515206575394, -0.01139690913259983, -0.015659278258681297, -0.012374145910143852, 0.025798963382840157, -0.06629186123609543, 0.035541437566280365, -0.010081890970468521, 0.05163335055112839, 0.019153891131281853, 0.058135986328125, 0.05030379816889763, -0.013624658808112144, 0.062370169907808304, -0.009268325753509998, 0.009802157990634441, -0.02307463437318802, -0.010262777097523212, 0.03409712761640549, 0.019912168383598328, -0.016861965879797935, 0.020815569907426834, -0.01487860269844532, -0.009058849886059761, 0.015025502070784569, 0.0031596727203577757, -0.03227003663778305, -0.026959596201777458, -0.0191662460565567, -0.03768360614776611, -0.012256723828613758, -0.04886738955974579, 0.017111556604504585, -0.0008270787657238543, 0.026199042797088623, 0.0738026425242424, -0.002162105171009898, 0.03153634071350098, 0.01738990657031536, -0.024100573733448982, 0.0015103680780157447, -0.013336499221622944, 0.01858505792915821, -0.11089818924665451, -0.004344867076724768, -0.05396445095539093, 0.016590433195233345, -0.04244183003902435, -0.0044459933415055275, 0.03208302706480026, 0.003867032937705517, -0.056444086134433746, -0.05154510959982872, -0.007919865660369396, 0.020096467807888985, 0.021717669442296028, 0.024233104661107063, 0.0409310981631279, -0.05353385582566261, 0.015395237132906914, 0.011362709105014801, -0.014361681416630745, -0.038431305438280106, -0.036298129707574844, 0.02881549298763275, -0.034230224788188934, 0.024505283683538437, -0.04951970651745796, 0.09741812944412231, -0.019783951342105865, -0.052049145102500916, 0.042724184691905975, 0.013920958153903484, 0.013208605349063873, 0.010654137469828129, 0.013417056761682034, 0.0053572566248476505, 0.05154597386717796, 0.011584211140871048, 0.03093082644045353, 0.030448483303189278, -0.023621203377842903, 0.01263443473726511, -0.010949062183499336, 0.07805269211530685, -0.04986601695418358, -0.032127074897289276, -0.007197643164545298, 0.04518476501107216 ]
<p>I'm quite familiar with SR, but I have very limited understanding in GR, singularities, and black holes. My friend, which is well-read and is interested in general physics, said that we can "jump" into another universe by entering a black hole.</p> <p><em>Suppose that we and our equipments can withstand the tidal forces near black holes. We jumped from our spaceship into a black hole. As we had passed the event horizon, we couldn't send any information to the outside anymore.</em></p> <ol> <li><p>Can this situation be interpreted as that we were in another universe separate from our previous universe?</p></li> <li><p>Is there corrections or anything else to be added to above statement?</p></li> </ol>
g4050
[ -0.0019688731990754604, -0.019560331478714943, 0.015155179426074028, -0.018433548510074615, -0.004484740551561117, 0.06772399693727493, 0.025083279237151146, -0.006570955738425255, -0.009378858841955662, 0.005087192635983229, 0.00047860664199106395, 0.010052608326077461, 0.04454537481069565, -0.03706468641757965, 0.02092619240283966, -0.04927200824022293, 0.0893590897321701, -0.09063297510147095, -0.023646237328648567, -0.028414417058229446, -0.022950375452637672, -0.030278852209448814, 0.017170162871479988, -0.025311565026640892, -0.02107170969247818, 0.000039598813600605354, 0.0338653102517128, 0.011591644957661629, -0.05450728163123131, -0.03184216469526291, 0.00023623295419383794, -0.03487985208630562, 0.040343571454286575, -0.06134112924337387, 0.00779312988743186, 0.005641792435199022, -0.03922114148736, 0.0009153017890639603, -0.0004065614193677902, -0.01773533597588539, 0.0010690785711631179, 0.004928990732878447, -0.03780008479952812, -0.062393900007009506, 0.04613911733031273, -0.020397361367940903, 0.019413180649280548, -0.04084351658821106, 0.09522821009159088, -0.05094185099005699, -0.007356088608503342, -0.005313752684742212, 0.002036196179687977, 0.033992063254117966, -0.001692597521468997, 0.008437673561275005, 0.08212205022573471, 0.0038352995179593563, 0.03765216842293739, 0.03246435895562172, -0.044053636491298676, -0.015389269217848778, 0.07203862816095352, -0.056011080741882324, 0.021631641313433647, 0.0186518132686615, -0.0922965332865715, 0.029498448595404625, -0.07584965974092484, 0.014404664747416973, 0.04255080968141556, -0.00974575150758028, -0.03129590302705765, -0.03532605990767479, -0.037512630224227905, 0.09681636840105057, -0.006073330994695425, -0.025775350630283356, -0.012257173657417297, -0.03404993563890457, -0.028051378205418587, -0.001320292241871357, 0.016723118722438812, 0.022010941058397293, 0.08804714679718018, 0.0185711607336998, -0.03848437964916229, 0.04672592878341675, -0.016040045768022537, 0.020159993320703506, 0.05372048541903496, -0.02005515992641449, 0.050762537866830826, 0.04179031401872635, 0.017078205943107605, 0.024956002831459045, -0.048669978976249695, 0.04307850822806358, 0.03952445834875107, 0.007877613417804241, -0.07302414625883102, 0.009970016777515411, 0.02055027335882187, -0.03313743695616722, 0.05291932821273804, 0.024164406582713127, -0.024512959644198418, 0.017477286979556084, -0.0251263827085495, -0.024115756154060364, 0.016917968168854713, -0.058868974447250366, -0.016760176047682762, 0.021041424944996834, -0.008297222666442394, -0.023226916790008545, 0.04532979428768158, -0.02655814029276371, -0.020316187292337418, 0.017015814781188965, -0.03130187466740608, 0.045484595000743866, -0.008511019870638847, 0.04274529218673706, 0.003149975324049592, -0.037555716931819916, -0.018259931355714798, -0.0015141126932576299, 0.07640811055898666, -0.013078220188617706, -0.013577258214354515, -0.019177021458745003, -0.00020073415362276137, 0.04107201471924782, -0.056518882513046265, 0.0009549031383357942, 0.06766949594020844, -0.037219442427158356, 0.02446206845343113, 0.0032622255384922028, 0.036293528974056244, -0.02035827375948429, -0.007531607523560524, 0.008931942284107208, 0.033743858337402344, -0.020309023559093475, -0.05501987785100937, 0.011365193873643875, -0.05613786354660988, 0.046031758189201355, 0.037888482213020325, 0.07838361710309982, -0.0500570610165596, 0.05080464482307434, -0.006110143847763538, 0.002145719015970826, -0.013827978633344173, 0.011761440895497799, 0.004508154466748238, -0.010928530246019363, 0.060452379286289215, -0.03495514765381813, 0.023851240053772926, 0.058006007224321365, -0.003765091998502612, 0.029958903789520264, 0.000042307630792493, -0.047523707151412964, 0.032222408801317215, 0.000437081849668175, 0.000519389403052628, 0.0017494424246251583, -0.005785253830254078, 0.028010768815875053, 0.034611716866493225, 0.06126507371664047, 0.047589123249053955, -0.04199110344052315, -0.0396718792617321, 0.031780000776052475, -0.014377592131495476, -0.016504652798175812, -0.026618592441082, -0.06464041024446487, 0.036947447806596756, -0.050945792347192764, -0.03969409316778183, 0.049172982573509216, 0.020339177921414375, -0.02328532375395298, -0.06717124581336975, -0.018621567636728287, 0.014651086181402206, 0.02667779102921486, -0.03744124993681908, -0.022540241479873657, 0.03295590728521347, -0.0014863304095342755, -0.022147485986351967, 0.042264845222234726, 0.04269041866064072, 0.05950665473937988, 0.0002116406540153548, -0.013412406668066978, 0.022115355357527733, -0.004055608529597521, -0.013089225627481937, 0.04074926674365997, 0.062046218663454056, -0.04817277193069458, 0.00498939398676157, -0.044779423624277115, 0.035907380282878876, -0.02068236656486988, -0.004012941382825375, -0.017567025497555733, -0.030979229137301445, 0.05439416319131851, 0.01229950226843357, -0.009528253227472305, -0.07256465405225754, -0.006449115928262472, 0.06631153076887131, -0.03477516770362854, -0.027051599696278572, 0.025478247553110123, -0.07252134382724762, -0.04222243279218674, 0.056151486933231354, 0.008427928201854229, -0.07869973033666611, 0.007542208302766085, 0.001056672423146665, -0.0345856212079525, 0.03051016479730606, 0.03178330883383751, -0.0017372750444337726, -0.010884576477110386, -0.026555346325039864, 0.025870688259601593, 0.060319721698760986, -0.03500670567154884, -0.05137060582637787, -0.010041831992566586, 0.03062346577644348, -0.005153710022568703, 0.030811818316578865, -0.01889892853796482, 0.0014722731430083513, -0.0016829436644911766, 0.02783600613474846, -0.05019986629486084, -0.02258952148258686, -0.002733272034674883, -0.03001468814909458, -0.05272817984223366, 0.0000022560313936992316, 0.04086738079786301, -0.10012800246477127, -0.014221901074051857, 0.028737841174006462, -0.014779693447053432, 0.048017002642154694, 0.08541388809680939, -0.03800491988658905, -0.008253579027950764, -0.0426802784204483, 0.007868562825024128, 0.014552125707268715, 0.002898784354329109, -0.0027876743115484715, -0.00025587898562662303, 0.013400358147919178, 0.007510181050747633, 0.0184283759444952, 0.006011554505676031, -0.03790698200464249, 0.015064489096403122, 0.04215336963534355, 0.0070800031535327435, -0.042238302528858185, -0.032333534210920334, -0.07894005626440048, -0.025040848180651665, -0.009005041792988777, -0.06287150084972382, 0.004881592467427254, 0.03362247347831726, 0.0017155103851109743, 0.009580256417393684, 0.0116572892293334, 0.007017549127340317, 0.032211121171712875, 0.05516789108514786, 0.035355325788259506, 0.060368917882442474, -0.009616300463676453, -0.006438876036554575, -0.026523010805249214, 0.0218852199614048, 0.0014017561916261911, -0.06788107007741928, -0.03522216156125069, -0.0006493276450783014, -0.06888414919376373, -0.0028536899480968714, -0.015468107536435127, 0.006214144639670849, 0.007395782973617315, -0.072627492249012, -0.06829458475112915, 0.04138166084885597, 0.00597412558272481, 0.0110132722184062, 0.012288878671824932, -0.013600343838334084, 0.019418764859437943, 0.03760585933923721, -0.011176369152963161, 0.04582711309194565, -0.0018330869497731328, -0.0009986772201955318, -0.008079266175627708, 0.0657113716006279, 0.04749888926744461, 0.03439464047551155, -0.03801613673567772, 0.01955404505133629, -0.05687826871871948, -0.03567073494195938, -0.024229226633906364, -0.01917630061507225, -0.02896265871822834, 0.01721319928765297, 0.006401498336344957, 0.0032191164791584015, -0.001353231375105679, 0.003502477193251252, 0.04960675910115242, -0.018805256113409996, 0.03134719282388687, -0.053599853068590164, 0.038915280252695084, 0.04682237654924393, 0.0029002761002629995, 0.058698710054159164, 0.010991177521646023, -0.008566276170313358, -0.011335490271449089, 0.004865686874836683, 0.02292485535144806, -0.010378006845712662, -0.001346634584479034, -0.014571869745850563, -0.03119911253452301, 0.01255502924323082, 0.008540676906704903, 0.020349550992250443, 0.0529431514441967, 0.004102598410099745, 0.00782418716698885, -0.06558293849229813, 0.02926260232925415, 0.004754218738526106, -0.01792302168905735, -0.005786317400634289, 0.005758508574217558, -0.01571381837129593, 0.0018997803563252091, -0.018096772953867912, 0.02792956866323948, -0.020805377513170242, -0.057817719876766205, -0.0026031932793557644, 0.03704594448208809, -0.10261521488428116, 0.06087935343384743, 0.03445896878838539, 0.02838919684290886, 0.03651540353894234, 0.0638338178396225, 0.01205257885158062, 0.0006067401845939457, 0.03214805945754051, 0.03133373335003853, 0.04158908501267433, -0.00838477909564972, -0.021557053551077843, -0.032360490411520004, -0.038778480142354965, 0.03369004651904106, -0.024509385228157043, -0.019122634083032608, -0.06354673951864243, 0.041701726615428925, -0.012927510775625706, -0.02951444312930107, -0.018578210845589638, 0.05534863471984863, 0.008095251396298409, 0.021727604791522026, 0.019206563010811806, 0.029033690690994263, -0.009836574085056782, -0.0047534857876598835, 0.014434651471674442, 0.05255565047264099, 0.008813700638711452, -0.006673896685242653, -0.018521558493375778, 0.05131965130567551, -0.001969884615391493, -0.04280860349535942, -0.013867393136024475, 0.014542440883815289, 0.014212229289114475, 0.05437416583299637, -0.026212112978100777, -0.033222418278455734, 0.02254216931760311, 0.029598267748951912, 0.015717431902885437, 0.06273118406534195, 0.018961923196911812, 0.008328326046466827, 0.026109613478183746, 0.04456368088722229, 0.018652530387043953, -0.0329289585351944, 0.003038412192836404, -0.031512606889009476, 0.022537507116794586, -0.03658078983426094, 0.03888632357120514, 0.00038625855813734233, 0.04408518224954605, -0.002902338979765773, 0.0033783367834985256, -0.01677885465323925, 0.0023077367804944515, 0.025101371109485626, -0.04770860821008682, -0.025070670992136, 0.012856956571340561, 0.07868428528308868, 0.04203855246305466, -0.005799006205052137, -0.0012306126300245523, -0.011713003739714622, 0.011519995518028736, -0.054905734956264496, -0.023126613348722458, 0.018240956589579582, -0.00979752466082573, -0.05642157420516014, 0.016406726092100143, 0.01802193559706211, 0.005490588955581188, -0.05474122241139412, 0.017137577757239342, -0.02920684590935707, -0.010461683385074139, 0.018970593810081482, 0.04069914296269417, 0.02649908885359764, -0.0220029354095459, -0.024288034066557884, -0.010950122959911823, -0.05809637904167175, 0.03491051867604256, -0.05450093001127243, 0.025943346321582794, -0.01120244525372982, -0.0061073447577655315, -0.03624523803591728, 0.005455529782921076, 0.040697816759347916, -0.04419960826635361, 0.02337728813290596, -0.03147486597299576, 0.003799963044002652, -0.04157273843884468, 0.04420328512787819, 0.027455627918243408, 0.010766517370939255, 0.05970945581793785, -0.04163239896297455, 0.026376798748970032, 0.02245369553565979, 0.044901687651872635, -0.03203844279050827, -0.018867503851652145, 0.004415806848555803, 0.016553057357668877, -0.04800235852599144, 0.03407490625977516, 0.0456804595887661, -0.039106614887714386, -0.05484309419989586, 0.007956785149872303, -0.028081923723220825, 0.008247432298958302, 0.04570759832859039, 0.025348342955112457, -0.027389856055378914, 0.048621609807014465, -0.029040496796369553, 0.013858548365533352, 0.00565799605101347, 0.028857506811618805, 0.009824149310588837, 0.0006952084368094802, -0.04400872811675072, -0.007518456317484379, 0.05873347446322441, -0.08395479619503021, 0.03718700632452965, -0.016301656141877174, 0.03082563728094101, -0.0569477453827858, -0.03035537339746952, -0.015863759443163872, 0.0033612214028835297, 0.02442801743745804, -0.015129167586565018, 0.01970909908413887, 0.0005509342299774289, 0.024685293436050415, -0.005929187405854464, 0.030063528567552567, 0.0797695443034172, 0.0472724474966526, 0.042444080114364624, 0.01191021129488945, 0.04741430655121803, -0.015584961511194706, -0.02174987643957138, -0.0070137265138328075, 0.008680760860443115, -0.054152585566043854, -0.08123685419559479, -0.010190250352025032, -0.030149701982736588, 0.011342153884470463, 0.0041525657288730145, 0.05091915652155876, -0.06634124368429184, 0.01533480267971754, 0.02447519265115261, -0.049073491245508194, -0.060917165130376816, 0.029861658811569214, -0.0368301160633564, 0.039532214403152466, -0.025359928607940674, 0.024884771555662155, 0.02834152989089489, 0.012220434844493866, -0.06646542251110077, -0.024340037256479263, 0.020179005339741707, -0.024647127836942673, 0.04009069502353668, -0.023726534098386765, 0.017363600432872772, -0.04224148020148277, 0.026490364223718643, -0.018926871940493584, 0.03429045155644417, -0.029117830097675323, -0.03668110445141792, 0.02772369235754013, 0.007733807433396578, 0.016670390963554382, -0.04500691592693329, -0.02892902120947838, 0.017001688480377197, 0.03307326138019562, 0.01952705718576908, -0.011153002269566059, -0.023291317746043205, -0.015090483240783215, 0.11203575134277344, -0.09715024381875992, -0.06936964392662048, 0.011522567830979824, -0.05420609936118126, -0.0012631171848624945, 0.032981209456920624, -0.022451017051935196, -0.015469319187104702, 0.028783991932868958, 0.07409900426864624, -0.02505730465054512, -0.08941835910081863, 0.008730746805667877, -0.0371471643447876, -0.02355971932411194, -0.019298572093248367, 0.06464017927646637, -0.03517039865255356, 0.041910041123628616, 0.08353567868471146, -0.0013239664258435369, 0.0043732053600251675, 0.009708433412015438, -0.06949052214622498, -0.028818298131227493, 0.05804307386279106, -0.03219353035092354, 0.0536247156560421, -0.032083816826343536, -0.028277108445763588, 0.06843063980340958, 0.006929874420166016, -0.004704109858721495, -0.061240389943122864, -0.026575449854135513, -0.012507818639278412, 0.006845555268228054, 0.06602729856967926, -0.02441149204969406, -0.005362061318010092, 0.011262785643339157, -0.02496865764260292, 0.035620152950286865, -0.06539680808782578, 0.04551951587200165, 0.0360349677503109, 0.06133520230650902, 0.009673161432147026, -0.023902418091893196, 0.0070810201577842236, -0.0005583148449659348, 0.022575676441192627, 0.06813357770442963, 0.033126283437013626, 0.010861539281904697, -0.02137458138167858, -0.04635046049952507, -0.010475116781890392, -0.0056065283715724945, 0.062082160264253616, 0.005008156411349773, 0.01932491548359394, 0.027041558176279068, 0.03544960543513298, 0.039422836154699326, -0.0513434000313282, 0.02360663376748562, 0.034340281039476395, -0.03891557455062866, -0.05043435096740723, 0.014860343188047409, -0.04498020559549332, -0.02687601000070572, -0.03928983211517334, 0.05413395166397095, -0.02470141462981701, -0.07961110770702362, 0.04985691234469414, -0.00021590552933048457, -0.050893574953079224, -0.04026011750102043, -0.0008597131236456335, 0.028570279479026794, 0.004095959942787886, -0.05271986126899719, -0.041878074407577515, -0.0003509464440867305, 0.008583126589655876, -0.026395291090011597, -0.06020846590399742, -0.030385904014110565, -0.051340002566576004, -0.03593125939369202, -0.0067863985896110535, 0.07370210438966751, 0.03887559846043587, 0.060424648225307465, 0.015178603120148182, -0.017183292657136917, -0.01565750129520893, 0.06119593605399132, -0.028055714443325996, 0.03647027909755707, 0.013863896951079369, -0.013141344301402569, 0.031814076006412506, -0.015054238960146904, -0.0371180921792984, 0.023608995601534843, -0.029705403372645378, 0.02777004987001419, 0.007062348071485758, -0.03292055428028107, 0.002547284122556448, 0.05783187597990036, 0.015582218766212463, -0.04874700307846069, -0.04409607872366905, 0.03377580642700195, -0.04445362463593483, -0.029018299654126167, -0.007526353932917118, -0.0019139888463541865, -0.053877729922533035, -0.025986377149820328, -0.019748834893107414, 0.023999003693461418, 0.007301435340195894, 0.023212866857647896, -0.012194621376693249, 0.027419915422797203, -0.0022862227633595467, -0.03682988882064819, 0.04733198508620262, 0.023090843111276627, 0.022267434746026993, -0.00313007109798491, 0.022410104051232338, 0.02119734324514866, 0.0033091912046074867, -0.0558384545147419, -0.03592187538743019, 0.044811349362134933, 0.011703428812325, 0.021470844745635986, -0.08681943267583847, -0.057026203721761703, 0.02169574424624443, -0.008972136303782463, -0.026924986392259598, -0.01962754875421524, 0.015128211118280888, 0.02921833097934723, 0.023703627288341522, 0.011672304011881351, -0.00906381942331791, -0.008003431372344494, 0.017660504207015038, -0.051437877118587494, 0.00545095931738615, -0.012074262835085392, -0.0029395492747426033, -0.10692348331212997, 0.011628997512161732, 0.02303990162909031, 0.0007366900681518018, 0.0004158556985203177, 0.03476087376475334, 0.015119977295398712, -0.019996101036667824, -0.001089450903236866, 0.023457616567611694, -0.0818929523229599, -0.10260945558547974, -0.024275097995996475, -0.07572254538536072, -0.006460521835833788, -0.04680439084768295, 0.03516779839992523, 0.004462347365915775, -0.020866120234131813, 0.03306585177779198, -0.021403782069683075, 0.029556630179286003, 0.05338692665100098 ]
<p>If, as I asked in <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/19631/question-about-the-perturbative-renormalization-group">this question</a>, a relevant operator in a renormalization group transformation can't be used in a perturbative expansion since it becomes large as the transformations are applied, does this mean that the operator can't be used in 'normal' perturbation theory? </p> <p>I.e. Is using the renormalization group a way to determine whether or not perturbation theory can be used at all? Or is it only relevant within renormalization groups since without it, the operator remains small?</p>
g4051
[ 0.002671988680958748, 0.055326785892248154, 0.0053923288360238075, -0.06618552654981613, -0.06648791581392288, -0.0153903653845191, -0.010598813183605671, 0.06765613704919815, 0.018111802637577057, -0.018292399123311043, -0.004081679042428732, 0.01902896910905838, -0.050058700144290924, 0.060064468532800674, -0.039876654744148254, -0.031171612441539764, 0.09117681533098221, 0.018486574292182922, 0.03425024077296257, 0.010846301913261414, -0.04908715561032295, -0.04172512888908386, 0.058245737105607986, -0.019671279937028885, 0.004855838604271412, -0.03396707773208618, 0.005512694362550974, 0.03738613799214363, -0.02066267840564251, -0.04777123034000397, 0.025620827451348305, 0.06579266488552094, 0.053143467754125595, -0.05733835697174072, -0.0015258912462741137, -0.0027290063444525003, 0.062114957720041275, 0.04385334625840187, 0.044830989092588425, -0.006214486435055733, -0.058724842965602875, 0.012037939392030239, 0.010674877092242241, 0.003973541781306267, -0.024068091064691544, 0.0267526526004076, 0.0457034595310688, 0.008591655641794205, -0.005583780352026224, 0.028190555050969124, -0.0303405299782753, 0.0282531026750803, 0.04555489122867584, 0.04945937544107437, 0.03746219724416733, 0.0349595732986927, 0.009445343166589737, -0.023816490545868874, 0.019436899572610855, 0.030855678021907806, 0.013191617093980312, 0.0008453268674202263, -0.0019178310176357627, -0.005970936268568039, -0.02963150106370449, -0.04192974418401718, 0.003826585365459323, -0.021542273461818695, -0.011865900829434395, -0.011323804967105389, -0.0043035950511693954, -0.06633807718753815, 0.008813613094389439, -0.03436710312962532, -0.032919470220804214, 0.03158978000283241, 0.03380865976214409, -0.08149370551109314, -0.0029134601354599, -0.02848430536687374, -0.03671986609697342, -0.06075326353311539, 0.04274929314851761, -0.022605877369642258, 0.01628061942756176, 0.030566619709134102, -0.009369714185595512, 0.08173046261072159, -0.030196087434887886, 0.1026107668876648, 0.011079409159719944, -0.041471026837825775, 0.04737355187535286, 0.01790590211749077, 0.0008710250840522349, 0.0385948084294796, -0.00897768884897232, 0.023556934669613838, 0.002197136403992772, 0.009527196176350117, -0.05388122797012329, 0.08365732431411743, -0.04457521438598633, 0.02471189945936203, -0.010279089212417603, 0.05074930191040039, 0.03255387768149376, -0.038672178983688354, 0.052705321460962296, -0.01314548496156931, -0.03514277562499046, -0.08146505057811737, 0.045080117881298065, -0.0060228449292480946, -0.023944666609168053, 0.00006901715823914856, 0.045691024512052536, -0.0071621849201619625, -0.0189578328281641, 0.06327660381793976, 0.017843468114733696, 0.032092317938804626, 0.002809362718835473, -0.0066373394802212715, -0.01042179111391306, 0.006278902292251587, -0.035537201911211014, 0.016552690416574478, 0.04562923684716225, -0.022734107449650764, 0.04445662721991539, -0.017465410754084587, 0.0035765699576586485, 0.029119566082954407, 0.03372042626142502, 0.017161982133984566, 0.016365470364689827, 0.012248625047504902, 0.02667657844722271, -0.01522272452712059, 0.02342330291867256, -0.00569063238799572, 0.008084123954176903, 0.03421704098582268, 0.04279298707842827, -0.002468264661729336, 0.04379124194383621, -0.025755073875188828, 0.0062194704078137875, 0.07843346148729324, 0.031072963029146194, 0.013528549112379551, 0.03736458718776703, -0.01672159507870674, 0.033130861818790436, 0.060710858553647995, 0.036444954574108124, 0.03595786169171333, 0.01423293724656105, 0.052774958312511444, -0.008270849473774433, -0.04390615597367287, -0.003834778442978859, 0.028570465743541718, 0.021428430452942848, -0.019031818956136703, 0.008132402785122395, -0.023618588224053383, -0.04187317192554474, -0.05066131427884102, 0.007127681281417608, 0.04721001535654068, 0.045623037964105606, 0.00791356060653925, 0.015735860913991928, 0.04829639568924904, -0.018208099529147148, -0.005909603089094162, -0.02489362470805645, 0.007928632199764252, -0.04356737062335014, -0.034508492797613144, 0.0005375546752475202, -0.0701398029923439, 0.008076190948486328, 0.015879325568675995, -0.07360251992940903, 0.042843256145715714, 0.03645073622465134, 0.01907178945839405, -0.033382974565029144, 0.045264456421136856, 0.06211680546402931, -0.006837716791778803, -0.06833917647600174, -0.028660468757152557, -0.032377228140830994, -0.06956446170806885, -0.036427270621061325, -0.031003469601273537, -0.0010006361408159137, 0.02345220185816288, 0.0002633115218486637, -0.021178945899009705, 0.04972502216696739, -0.010492820292711258, -0.10547079890966415, 0.041088275611400604, -0.005675587337464094, -0.03010939061641693, 0.045426081866025925, -0.022435100749135017, 0.0661628320813179, 0.018040701746940613, -0.05015671253204346, -0.007611112669110298, -0.008396334014832973, 0.009052274748682976, -0.016584381461143494, 0.10055074840784073, -0.010920103639364243, -0.0008492402266710997, 0.006861286237835884, 0.04893822595477104, 0.002763989381492138, 0.01433170773088932, 0.006733484100550413, 0.01236577145755291, -0.008271160535514355, 0.046572718769311905, -0.0816093236207962, -0.0023896009661257267, -0.04205993190407753, 0.011604287661612034, -0.03239399567246437, 0.0406150296330452, 0.030585680156946182, -0.03132078796625137, 0.024960722774267197, 0.06425140798091888, -0.037010420113801956, -0.039591286331415176, 0.037102073431015015, 0.00047725942567922175, -0.012510881759226322, -0.042497485876083374, 0.01213127188384533, -0.05429178103804588, -0.04118393734097481, 0.02655736915767193, -0.011905627325177193, -0.018095117062330246, -0.027200378477573395, 0.011180838569998741, -0.03446368873119354, 0.00426810747012496, 0.027128269895911217, 0.009057669900357723, 0.0003318841627333313, -0.011972572654485703, 0.023696113377809525, 0.01948963850736618, 0.0012011351063847542, 0.04519910365343094, -0.024843718856573105, -0.014441424049437046, -0.010640721768140793, 0.06630339473485947, -0.05046475678682327, 0.03683123365044594, 0.0011870915768668056, 0.03822869434952736, 0.019550448283553123, 0.015208114869892597, 0.008911842480301857, -0.048473622649908066, 0.017723731696605682, -0.02731422707438469, -0.0006612862343899906, -0.055211540311574936, 0.028795352205634117, -0.033280275762081146, -0.04276340827345848, 0.03647443652153015, -0.014851956628262997, -0.0697954073548317, 0.034293606877326965, -0.04140624403953552, -0.03433734178543091, 0.045017559081315994, -0.01360665075480938, 0.007472935598343611, 0.004408731125295162, 0.01216036919504404, -0.021289054304361343, -0.014445184729993343, 0.051170703023672104, -0.06564486026763916, 0.029060643166303635, 0.11144222319126129, 0.005775378551334143, -0.029852842912077904, -0.054345205426216125, 0.0011503242421895266, 0.05704015493392944, -0.02773081324994564, -0.08273116499185562, -0.021947292611002922, -0.01645253226161003, 0.02107873186469078, -0.02448834665119648, 0.047265131026506424, -0.02009693533182144, 0.023912502452731133, -0.03007916361093521, 0.009153822436928749, 0.010261142626404762, -0.03818115219473839, 0.02265598066151142, -0.042026013135910034, -0.02726312167942524, -0.034569140523672104, 0.0652061253786087, 0.019687848165631294, 0.007897572591900826, -0.032475609332323074, -0.020399468019604683, -0.022264389321208, 0.03686974197626114, -0.058631520718336105, 0.013512189500033855, -0.01297611091285944, 0.00592324323952198, -0.02069098688662052, -0.07629793137311935, 0.008944593369960785, 0.03769879415631294, -0.007527658715844154, 0.06746421754360199, -0.05944405868649483, 0.03162403777241707, -0.08210211247205734, -0.023120418190956116, 0.05633338913321495, 0.002565553179010749, -0.002283480716869235, -0.028771638870239258, 0.008555052801966667, -0.010121366009116173, -0.0733967125415802, 0.039561670273542404, 0.009358176961541176, -0.004712253343313932, -0.047393158078193665, -0.048558689653873444, 0.021154360845685005, 0.04731377214193344, 0.03808886185288429, -0.023126108571887016, -0.03053061105310917, -0.007129404693841934, -0.017208490520715714, -0.007900750264525414, 0.03685249015688896, 0.01667138747870922, 0.03597456216812134, -0.04562058672308922, 0.04195919632911682, -0.04385174810886383, -0.08062155544757843, 0.038287676870822906, 0.004359165206551552, -0.016842041164636612, 0.05356624722480774, -0.0046607316471636295, 0.020101070404052734, 0.027500854805111885, 0.017559101805090904, -0.017622483894228935, 0.023067332804203033, 0.020365646108984947, 0.0020033842884004116, -0.02144206129014492, 0.022611601278185844, 0.022973550483584404, -0.02197324112057686, -0.02250734344124794, 0.037622302770614624, 0.0008084802539087832, -0.00945714395493269, -0.02221660129725933, -0.024508923292160034, 0.014788247644901276, -0.017292000353336334, 0.01567562110722065, -0.004647991620004177, -0.04559111222624779, -0.049551475793123245, 0.08530586212873459, 0.06249373406171799, -0.018897244706749916, -0.03693709522485733, 0.020982423797249794, -0.009192139841616154, 0.029570424929261208, 0.004108733031898737, 0.07991918921470642, 0.054706595838069916, -0.007640483323484659, -0.0443747341632843, -0.045841529965400696, -0.014687171205878258, 0.01965496875345707, -0.0018488443456590176, 0.03041752614080906, -0.05391670763492584, -0.011236040852963924, -0.06810152530670166, -0.016194121912121773, -0.010098702274262905, -0.04652687907218933, -0.022931378334760666, 0.0010649766772985458, 0.007362731732428074, -0.02614814043045044, 0.05842044577002525, 0.018800020217895508, -0.013568324036896229, 0.04006706178188324, -0.05689417943358421, 0.00468531483784318, 0.042980391532182693, -0.00964914821088314, 0.02315211109817028, -0.07605428993701935, 0.010270346887409687, -0.05475441738963127, 0.08680301159620285, 0.012199731543660164, -0.06895921379327774, 0.05758378282189369, -0.048216313123703, -0.035632986575365067, -0.010679303668439388, -0.04442674666643143, -0.0064064147882163525, -0.021973757073283195, 0.05772935971617699, -0.018588600680232048, -0.00296808616258204, -0.029573531821370125, -0.004340808838605881, -0.0026076233480125666, 0.015120815485715866, -0.0433453731238842, -0.010601849295198917, 0.03409240394830704, -0.013737834058701992, 0.018168795853853226, -0.010621031746268272, -0.09035246074199677, 0.014719915576279163, -0.006167934276163578, 0.04210149124264717, 0.0013560540974140167, -0.014740451239049435, -0.012789228931069374, 0.0363081656396389, -0.015859011560678482, 0.009548784233629704, 0.036820702254772186, -0.01747445948421955, 0.013503468595445156, -0.056367963552474976, -0.03750597685575485, -0.024338873103260994, 0.06897828727960587, -0.029940519481897354, -0.005006934050470591, -0.017383219674229622, 0.02467583678662777, 0.0048740822821855545, 0.045272767543792725, 0.014582177624106407, 0.0506107397377491, -0.0004669885092880577, -0.014918231405317783, 0.04326801002025604, -0.00027038902044296265, -0.06659729033708572, -0.007339147385209799, 0.0107439449056983, 0.014051685109734535, 0.06274403631687164, 0.06381434202194214, 0.005406427197158337, 0.05154850706458092, 0.008872855454683304, -0.0063611362129449844, -0.03915642201900482, -0.021010631695389748, 0.025261005386710167, -0.0013174781342968345, 0.03002980351448059, -0.0416383258998394, -0.004953891504555941, 0.020332612097263336, 0.020116908475756645, 0.059261735528707504, 0.040139090269804, 0.02120768278837204, -0.005366412457078695, 0.036249496042728424, -0.06981183588504791, 0.0479055717587471, -0.03417801484465599, -0.00861672405153513, -0.03160746023058891, -0.041908130049705505, -0.05883590131998062, 0.03650360926985741, -0.016306789591908455, 0.022109732031822205, -0.05738028138875961, 0.022175753489136696, 0.02725709043443203, -0.0032360032200813293, -0.02138460800051689, -0.021046249195933342, 0.03934130072593689, 0.05251329764723778, -0.0172351635992527, -0.013452663086354733, 0.001387970638461411, 0.04617037624120712, -0.0011798572959378362, -0.03690187260508537, -0.031094931066036224, -0.022849123924970627, -0.04658295214176178, 0.005311580374836922, 0.024742070585489273, -0.04963794723153114, 0.034524284303188324, 0.0531468465924263, 0.05456645041704178, -0.01895696297287941, 0.05239725112915039, 0.014289340004324913, -0.019462276250123978, -0.026993736624717712, 0.0541389174759388, -0.03844943270087242, -0.04141644015908241, 0.010115416720509529, 0.017281033098697662, 0.011533956043422222, 0.005291251931339502, 0.012097250670194626, -0.027341211214661598, 0.020674997940659523, -0.03162762150168419, 0.05599459633231163, -0.0032278504222631454, -0.05026589706540108, -0.0776955634355545, 0.024244429543614388, 0.014924074523150921, -0.018541907891631126, 0.042877718806266785, -0.08242028206586838, 0.07322455942630768, 0.010757450014352798, 0.006970442831516266, 0.06877367198467255, -0.026693789288401604, -0.01516188494861126, 0.0029084323905408382, -0.011420296505093575, 0.004634007811546326, 0.01817825809121132, -0.0025387294590473175, 0.002703897887840867, -0.057584889233112335, -0.025626521557569504, -0.004320602864027023, -0.056304819881916046, -0.009910882450640202, 0.008593695238232613, 0.050036411732435226, -0.03286658227443695, 0.04202545806765556, -0.06043088436126709, 0.05589807406067848, -0.007969247177243233, -0.021447036415338516, -0.03507069870829582, -0.029006026685237885, -0.014024109579622746, 0.04224172979593277, 0.025153547525405884, 0.030473297461867332, 0.01477978378534317, 0.05062491074204445, 0.03463694825768471, -0.029081979766488075, 0.0013591296738013625, 0.010426106862723827, -0.033007074147462845, 0.01639651693403721, -0.029118003323674202, 0.011868774890899658, 0.056528761982917786, 0.00949320662766695, -0.03631468489766121, -0.004222531337291002, -0.028400138020515442, 0.01171999704092741, 0.009399177506566048, -0.007079759147018194, 0.0654386654496193, -0.034151263535022736, 0.022362664341926575, -0.021464016288518906, -0.044890910387039185, 0.013340716250240803, -0.010400080122053623, -0.035497620701789856, 0.06352676451206207, -0.010202765464782715, 0.01243177056312561, 0.020867343991994858, -0.02296641282737255, -0.03122701682150364, 0.029672397300601006, 0.07084940373897552, -0.06787653267383575, -0.009498520754277706, -0.056893039494752884, -0.008231227286159992, -0.07211222499608994, 0.017560459673404694, -0.0046683549880981445, -0.0010540876537561417, -0.05272002890706062, -0.029621245339512825, 0.06826522201299667, 0.024588093161582947, -0.039485108107328415, 0.006128278560936451, 0.04302534833550453, 0.02375679835677147, -0.03930271044373512, -0.018209872767329216, -0.019458787515759468, 0.012617247179150581, -0.0197033379226923, 0.07784223556518555, -0.04859479144215584, -0.04366844892501831, -0.017103444784879684, 0.009234885685145855, 0.029797986149787903, 0.06494981795549393, 0.004863174166530371, 0.005678432062268257, -0.0008070873445831239, 0.05180136114358902, 0.04013402387499809, -0.028725532814860344, -0.0038067700807005167, 0.003169755218550563, -0.02923610247671604, 0.006367417983710766, 0.06996696442365646, -0.03599471226334572, 0.004560239613056183, 0.050727590918540955, -0.019402114674448967, 0.0249037928879261, 0.023349354043602943, -0.017508046701550484, -0.011095401830971241, 0.00266684265807271, -0.008703840896487236, 0.008069194853305817, 0.005994904320687056, -0.02889021672308445, 0.015684863552451134, -0.003357622306793928, 0.02856224961578846, -0.03189872205257416, 0.017327729612588882, -0.004492678213864565, -0.011489980854094028, 0.0015701926313340664, 0.0029426130931824446, 0.019899403676390648, 0.004268045537173748, -0.0001490791910327971, 0.00007753170939395204, -0.025781914591789246, -0.06323952972888947, -0.05401682108640671, 0.07673432677984238, -0.009118896909058094, 0.056913938373327255, -0.0013795671984553337, -0.09041275829076767, -0.0041100806556642056, 0.0034690757747739553, -0.00896461121737957, 0.013469127006828785, 0.021168813109397888, -0.019017133861780167, 0.007965989410877228, -0.01008052658289671, -0.03944939747452736, 0.01935134269297123, 0.00939533207565546, 0.03459915518760681, -0.003967211581766605, -0.0004897238686680794, -0.0341641902923584, -0.062218040227890015, -0.0036451451014727354, -0.008332386612892151, 0.012179792858660221, -0.0533936470746994, -0.05876840651035309, -0.0509931854903698, 0.024979762732982635, -0.11125586926937103, -0.003022434189915657, -0.09767600893974304, 0.005449337884783745, -0.038694921880960464, -0.06722854822874069, 0.014172619208693504, -0.03478017821907997, -0.0015689184656366706, -0.011456691659986973, 0.0662866085767746, 0.027199827134609222, 0.01974199153482914, 0.003595869056880474, -0.038050293922424316, -0.017539609223604202, -0.010477465577423573, -0.06305081397294998, -0.051207054406404495, 0.004957770928740501, 0.02936573512852192, 0.04280698671936989, -0.041220761835575104, 0.02102956734597683, -0.03350258246064186, 0.021663373336195946, 0.02765093743801117, 0.049834027886390686, 0.050261978060007095, 0.04143192991614342, -0.009767173789441586, -0.038206905126571655, -0.0180327408015728, -0.049691468477249146, -0.032796915620565414, 0.0025282944552600384 ]
<p>I'm currently learning about the renormalization group (RG) in condensed matter physics and just want to clarify a couple of things:</p> <p>When doing the RG transformation, there's a flow to a fixed point. A coupling constant is a relevant operator (or relevant coupling, depending on which book you look at) if it gets larger as the transformation continues, and flows towards the fixed point. </p> <p>Have I understood that correctly?</p> <p>If doing perturbative renormalization, is it right that if you have a relevant operator it is not possible to use that operator in a perturbative expansion because it's large once the transformations are done (even if it was small to start with - before the RG transformations were done)?</p>
g4052
[ -0.0012280648807063699, 0.027455387637019157, -0.018455950543284416, -0.03877924010157585, -0.005963884759694338, 0.0009377996902912855, -0.0011498444946482778, 0.05599924921989441, -0.01682210899889469, 0.0069558764807879925, -0.07116743177175522, 0.04676582291722298, -0.051025260239839554, 0.045341845601797104, -0.0035979219246655703, -0.04075540602207184, 0.07912831753492355, 0.009043683297932148, -0.0012241947697475553, -0.009430245496332645, -0.04691126197576523, -0.05919637158513069, 0.04180299490690231, -0.05483461916446686, -0.012377245351672173, -0.034727033227682114, 0.041367921978235245, 0.00340077793225646, -0.056425705552101135, -0.023029671981930733, 0.06199144199490547, 0.0431966558098793, 0.042210184037685394, -0.05239952728152275, 0.001944020390510559, -0.054792165756225586, 0.043973714113235474, 0.017098436132073402, 0.06457287073135376, -0.02677910402417183, -0.0005535132950171828, -0.01149765495210886, 0.023393329232931137, 0.03087512217462063, -0.023802591487765312, 0.0020484987180680037, 0.0028955701272934675, -0.02806926518678665, -0.003035889472812414, 0.05974501743912697, -0.039062634110450745, 0.07946547865867615, 0.021789945662021637, 0.02743767760694027, 0.027117034420371056, 0.06549031287431717, -0.005922181066125631, 0.034334342926740646, -0.051617078483104706, 0.023033030331134796, 0.031084323301911354, 0.01476217806339264, -0.01029754988849163, -0.03446036949753761, 0.026824411004781723, -0.029666239395737648, 0.009634340181946754, 0.020568110048770905, -0.0009524383931420743, 0.04217083379626274, -0.03214019909501076, -0.06589038670063019, 0.010987434536218643, -0.010095972567796707, 0.008103161118924618, -0.024568336084485054, 0.042762499302625656, -0.042474422603845596, 0.0007877457537688315, -0.051587220281362534, -0.046098850667476654, -0.04880082607269287, 0.08818097412586212, -0.06304415315389633, 0.03896048292517662, 0.035661306232213974, -0.015406430698931217, 0.04017132520675659, -0.040207039564847946, 0.07797034084796906, -0.013138728216290474, -0.058270424604415894, 0.013730211183428764, -0.0013445121003314853, 0.01020949985831976, 0.009280897676944733, -0.02450517751276493, 0.05758104845881462, -0.01814975216984749, 0.025338545441627502, -0.07614268362522125, 0.0670941174030304, -0.028504472225904465, 0.0643099993467331, -0.05199616402387619, 0.03680902719497681, 0.05363001301884651, 0.027263997122645378, 0.011206697672605515, -0.030505109578371048, -0.038712549954652786, -0.031829360872507095, 0.015238212421536446, -0.0015314955962821841, -0.042938895523548126, 0.04764412343502045, 0.024343622848391533, -0.00648646941408515, 0.002519457833841443, 0.07699394971132278, 0.01799912564456463, 0.02099933847784996, 0.022847138345241547, 0.02607172541320324, 0.011463703587651253, -0.01336442120373249, -0.023433944210410118, 0.04089559242129326, 0.05741637200117111, -0.007440247107297182, 0.04502258822321892, -0.08709864318370819, -0.019683094695210457, 0.04450715333223343, 0.0068648336455225945, 0.0037600442301481962, 0.0071401940658688545, 0.0233062282204628, 0.01187805738300085, 0.013768678531050682, -0.010955717414617538, -0.03534076362848282, -0.028408098965883255, -0.014805438928306103, 0.025168536230921745, 0.002873792080208659, -0.0075531527400016785, -0.03375958278775215, 0.02959764190018177, 0.02539428137242794, 0.046459682285785675, 0.06970018893480301, 0.011782713234424591, -0.0004791035607922822, 0.012561731971800327, 0.05264229699969292, 0.058720629662275314, -0.010354147292673588, 0.05105263739824295, -0.025343401357531548, 0.03278767317533493, -0.06093516945838928, -0.012164123356342316, 0.057314708828926086, -0.02724635787308216, 0.007839762605726719, 0.021369991824030876, -0.07612095028162003, -0.015478955581784248, -0.021322457119822502, -0.04682344198226929, 0.07916895300149918, 0.020722944289445877, 0.044897641986608505, 0.018372993916273117, 0.09190035611391068, 0.015253246761858463, -0.026138463988900185, -0.008868630044162273, 0.015989836305379868, -0.01804196462035179, -0.04363281652331352, 0.01156307477504015, -0.04221416637301445, 0.016064409166574478, 0.006613243371248245, -0.0635116696357727, 0.012220118194818497, 0.02136070281267166, -0.0012783006532117724, -0.025622855871915817, 0.020277798175811768, -0.00471162423491478, 0.016925986856222153, -0.04423290863633156, -0.04250248894095421, -0.04311816766858101, -0.0823187381029129, -0.05812010541558266, -0.03632816672325134, 0.014748073183000088, 0.013521641492843628, 0.006218861322849989, 0.002255784347653389, 0.04848431423306465, 0.04871015250682831, -0.07839906960725784, 0.031147383153438568, -0.04539996013045311, 0.023563707247376442, 0.050176266580820084, -0.00843815691769123, 0.06774450093507767, -0.030124373733997345, -0.023997081443667412, -0.015383603051304817, 0.013721234165132046, 0.0082172816619277, 0.003910757135599852, 0.10789709538221359, -0.024974780157208443, -0.016069520264863968, 0.046758558601140976, 0.07852359116077423, -0.031845103949308395, -0.01109758298844099, -0.004064053297042847, -0.003734731348231435, 0.004592875484377146, 0.008291102014482021, -0.07305929064750671, 0.057664524763822556, -0.06930774450302124, -0.02208833210170269, -0.010644332505762577, 0.03946172818541527, -0.011097616516053677, -0.02266988717019558, -0.006695210468024015, 0.030363881960511208, -0.004844279959797859, 0.0020714111160486937, -0.014812951907515526, -0.004210153594613075, 0.010739011690020561, -0.004169884603470564, 0.02448362298309803, 0.0061669256538152695, -0.03061487525701523, 0.030379580333828926, 0.0480613112449646, -0.045386023819446564, -0.03639473766088486, 0.027652138844132423, -0.0045083072036504745, 0.018764715641736984, 0.03943866863846779, 0.051328085362911224, -0.0032414335291832685, -0.0036348658613860607, 0.054359253495931625, 0.014079025946557522, -0.02117176167666912, 0.021814359351992607, -0.058692410588264465, 0.0574524849653244, 0.00047798187006264925, 0.033645421266555786, -0.010230658575892448, 0.03552632033824921, 0.020465172827243805, 0.027870899066329002, 0.03736177459359169, 0.006159087643027306, 0.028909869492053986, -0.030984466895461082, 0.016563620418310165, -0.021759910508990288, 0.0018644863739609718, -0.08423753082752228, 0.01837007701396942, -0.08274833858013153, -0.03559013083577156, 0.024970900267362595, -0.009105589240789413, -0.04705354943871498, 0.008891895413398743, -0.04270307347178459, -0.04872211441397667, 0.05279966816306114, 0.009757313877344131, 0.018021289259195328, 0.021050622686743736, 0.017509009689092636, -0.024391911923885345, -0.04359128326177597, 0.07296068221330643, -0.046889010816812515, 0.02820344641804695, 0.10357197374105453, 0.004260625224560499, -0.012406078167259693, -0.031248390674591064, 0.0117530208081007, 0.05180380120873451, 0.009200489148497581, -0.06114615127444267, -0.03542936593294144, -0.0534340962767601, 0.0017052614130079746, -0.011631586588919163, 0.01704595796763897, -0.03470408916473389, -0.027207668870687485, -0.0038864726666361094, -0.0021198680624365807, 0.0024106556084007025, -0.037247154861688614, 0.012379988096654415, -0.014551933854818344, -0.053413715213537216, -0.04086554795503616, 0.07032621651887894, -0.030280129984021187, 0.03795506805181503, -0.012169321067631245, -0.03903546929359436, -0.04715440049767494, 0.038388486951589584, -0.03369928523898125, 0.0394502654671669, -0.002271900651976466, -0.0025705480948090553, 0.004554085433483124, -0.06923024356365204, -0.036208853125572205, -0.022785793989896774, -0.014983037486672401, 0.04102219268679619, -0.05917330086231232, 0.011285850778222084, -0.05206236243247986, -0.007856166921555996, 0.05097994580864906, 0.023424427956342697, 0.0025636558420956135, -0.015025529079139233, -0.01097375899553299, 0.003171399934217334, -0.08466088771820068, 0.037736885249614716, 0.027322735637426376, -0.04184534773230553, -0.022730782628059387, -0.06484414637088776, -0.008138472214341164, 0.0038997195661067963, 0.037277162075042725, -0.03745024651288986, -0.03342311829328537, -0.04098274186253548, -0.025506572797894478, -0.05090216547250748, 0.03375065326690674, -0.011547744274139404, 0.024360738694667816, -0.018498096615076065, 0.0472215972840786, -0.010215410962700844, -0.04588005319237709, 0.05010489374399185, -0.037934333086013794, -0.0025437131989747286, 0.08750569820404053, -0.03255851939320564, -0.0007650761399418116, 0.025210194289684296, 0.007334206253290176, 0.0075490823946893215, 0.03488893806934357, -0.006872392725199461, -0.02348121628165245, -0.014084819704294205, 0.06257940083742142, -0.012208247557282448, -0.006965765729546547, 0.0025324940215796232, 0.027447517961263657, -0.042250506579875946, -0.028864318504929543, -0.0334872268140316, -0.006842629052698612, -0.0030902884900569916, 0.0031342452857643366, 0.04655454307794571, 0.005023161880671978, -0.041839759796857834, -0.03365906700491905, 0.0786081999540329, 0.056253157556056976, 0.014635310508310795, -0.028543582186102867, -0.04702122136950493, -0.010185261256992817, -0.009726244956254959, -0.0019491086713969707, 0.04011364281177521, 0.047443315386772156, -0.012087070383131504, -0.0242692269384861, -0.03558134287595749, 0.009118390269577503, 0.019355671480298042, -0.029300102964043617, 0.022864267230033875, -0.043931130319833755, -0.012030408717691898, -0.07835981994867325, 0.0016473635332658887, -0.024187766015529633, -0.04258992522954941, 0.007365832105278969, 0.06480130553245544, -0.013893097639083862, -0.011932045221328735, 0.05680141597986221, 0.05413864180445671, -0.018167011439800262, 0.02445938065648079, -0.05991550534963608, 0.03162568807601929, 0.02927146665751934, -0.02518864907324314, 0.014015959575772285, -0.07632586359977722, 0.031417906284332275, -0.01196196861565113, 0.0295720137655735, -0.06477781385183334, -0.032778192311525345, 0.054389264434576035, -0.04119438678026199, -0.011341441422700882, 0.0029809013940393925, 0.011649465188384056, 0.012938062660396099, -0.060130368918180466, 0.045202624052762985, -0.00908783357590437, 0.015581611543893814, -0.035515353083610535, 0.026611866429448128, 0.000823462731204927, 0.021671487018465996, -0.018788374960422516, -0.02031620778143406, 0.014070733450353146, -0.0016563130775466561, 0.0011073899222537875, -0.02029670774936676, -0.07370011508464813, 0.008302521891891956, 0.023839088156819344, 0.01785934902727604, -0.025322895497083664, -0.05021218955516815, -0.016332006081938744, -0.0030364845879375935, -0.04202703386545181, 0.02522900141775608, 0.01586826890707016, -0.009223365224897861, 0.024912232533097267, -0.004534722305834293, 0.03238484635949135, 0.004104881547391415, 0.06794912368059158, -0.03972189500927925, 0.0361296609044075, -0.044720713049173355, 0.023990970104932785, 0.04675184190273285, 0.024555150419473648, -0.0027538954745978117, 0.010202327743172646, -0.012235517613589764, -0.05747980624437332, -0.000556986138690263, 0.038198668509721756, -0.03952890262007713, 0.04197939112782478, 0.004903105087578297, 0.07616718858480453, 0.051141053438186646, 0.020880643278360367, 0.015344087034463882, 0.037054505199193954, 0.023117857053875923, -0.016873527318239212, -0.02321983315050602, -0.01882726512849331, 0.01753476820886135, -0.004672723356634378, 0.034950945526361465, -0.057613614946603775, -0.002871081233024597, 0.010071403346955776, 0.008754591457545757, 0.07338007539510727, 0.02719906158745289, 0.004652941599488258, -0.0077316369861364365, 0.023922154679894447, -0.047723785042762756, 0.03715759143233299, -0.0028858287259936333, -0.009682922624051571, -0.03427804633975029, -0.04542921483516693, -0.029652168974280357, -0.0024582052137702703, -0.01167659554630518, 0.010815114714205265, -0.003145199967548251, 0.009113692678511143, 0.025006912648677826, -0.0290528517216444, 0.018344836309552193, 0.030893737450242043, 0.042557843029499054, 0.059555716812610626, -0.011942476034164429, 0.02194926328957081, 0.04575091227889061, 0.013781730085611343, -0.0020421065855771303, -0.03748760744929314, -0.03261881694197655, 0.009813283570110798, -0.025517426431179047, -0.022308629006147385, 0.052929576486349106, -0.05209978669881821, 0.04269462823867798, -0.008549469523131847, 0.04291772097349167, 0.008121594786643982, 0.04539615660905838, -0.003044594544917345, -0.06560186296701431, -0.004273249767720699, -0.020791180431842804, 0.017837900668382645, -0.012091181240975857, 0.043173499405384064, -0.03102957084774971, -0.00878850370645523, -0.022657273337244987, 0.01064334437251091, 0.02242373116314411, 0.0029157232493162155, -0.0374549999833107, 0.025548245757818222, -0.01761453039944172, 0.02892129495739937, -0.06672129780054092, 0.05084249749779701, -0.01120706181973219, 0.012748892419040203, 0.0377800427377224, -0.05202283710241318, 0.030132105574011803, 0.04084111750125885, -0.008291390724480152, 0.026586376130580902, 0.00788034126162529, -0.027821343392133713, -0.002391316695138812, -0.031056014820933342, 0.003745266469195485, 0.03494374826550484, -0.00827814731746912, -0.007191427983343601, -0.05378904938697815, -0.04201605170965195, 0.04232972115278244, -0.062057338654994965, -0.013420306146144867, 0.010836462490260601, 0.06588975340127945, -0.002891869517043233, -0.02236435003578663, -0.03102358989417553, 0.05096517875790596, -0.030266202986240387, -0.010979468934237957, -0.015372009947896004, -0.06717821210622787, -0.025033578276634216, 0.030876148492097855, 0.025964630767703056, 0.07197029888629913, 0.03234313055872917, -0.01300808135420084, 0.004063224885612726, -0.04461897164583206, -0.006776231341063976, 0.005349046550691128, -0.016135236248373985, 0.03357221931219101, -0.013651802204549313, 0.00345069682225585, 0.0373680517077446, 0.008882005698978901, -0.01240095216780901, -0.0007504839450120926, -0.05677108094096184, 0.02267240732908249, 0.008584859780967236, -0.018742840737104416, 0.06186303496360779, 0.03881470486521721, 0.04773961752653122, -0.04630875214934349, -0.012662605382502079, 0.03759528324007988, 0.03847946599125862, 0.0008912539342418313, 0.029666582122445107, -0.03196452558040619, -0.007464694324880838, 0.0353514701128006, -0.054173894226551056, -0.012844268232584, 0.04759657382965088, 0.062498483806848526, -0.022399067878723145, -0.005068160593509674, -0.03349198028445244, 0.03261110931634903, -0.0035355626605451107, 0.010610646568238735, 0.01704552210867405, 0.013284035958349705, 0.018218709155917168, -0.028256583958864212, 0.060039862990379333, 0.04348161444067955, -0.05940724536776543, 0.02138885110616684, 0.029925579205155373, 0.016895098611712456, -0.050563231110572815, -0.02153775840997696, -0.06364135444164276, -0.001997038023546338, -0.03649121895432472, 0.07207494974136353, -0.04188130795955658, -0.02248590812087059, -0.0270139928907156, 0.0063292887061834335, 0.0023423894308507442, 0.04512681066989899, 0.008407389745116234, -0.0026406338438391685, -0.013903089798986912, 0.01924322545528412, 0.04989747330546379, -0.07238217443227768, -0.04025096446275711, 0.011644824407994747, -0.04212111234664917, 0.05209774896502495, 0.06018902361392975, -0.024489743635058403, -0.0005391717422753572, 0.06537474691867828, -0.014933706261217594, 0.011783415451645851, 0.04318418353796005, -0.0013622831320390105, 0.014438469894230366, -0.007782571483403444, -0.047577887773513794, 0.031831324100494385, -0.04486941918730736, -0.020292725414037704, 0.032829396426677704, -0.011327086947858334, 0.03284655883908272, -0.028505472466349602, 0.04120006784796715, 0.04739727824926376, -0.022200440987944603, 0.019272485747933388, 0.033541060984134674, 0.03671162575483322, -0.005793447140604258, 0.006359092891216278, 0.07005825638771057, -0.037369485944509506, -0.06510289758443832, -0.047236017882823944, 0.08179422467947006, -0.0007802809122949839, 0.05414576455950737, -0.009760291315615177, -0.023196987807750702, -0.013689584098756313, -0.013022063300013542, -0.05602993816137314, -0.006218430586159229, -0.013033043593168259, 0.0007330404478125274, 0.02573440596461296, -0.06552882492542267, -0.02146391198039055, 0.03866038843989372, 0.014505314640700817, -0.01830122247338295, -0.027312658727169037, -0.023249255493283272, -0.040974557399749756, -0.02382180280983448, -0.01391524262726307, -0.030273720622062683, -0.014619844034314156, -0.08192102611064911, -0.023659110069274902, -0.06031068414449692, 0.005994143895804882, -0.08815298229455948, -0.0015586292138323188, -0.06055591627955437, -0.010309369303286076, 0.0012975779827684164, -0.0567922443151474, 0.006100449711084366, -0.04776114225387573, 0.00309738889336586, -0.05902659520506859, 0.04839251935482025, 0.057828061282634735, 0.0237708892673254, -0.030653318390250206, -0.020008187741041183, 0.024253780022263527, -0.008784736506640911, -0.058075323700904846, -0.008899756707251072, 0.020976511761546135, 0.027316320687532425, 0.03114728443324566, -0.0482461154460907, -0.025429371744394302, -0.030618973076343536, 0.06830385327339172, 0.0056555853225290775, 0.033987171947956085, 0.02309303916990757, 0.033344101160764694, -0.024275751784443855, -0.04369146376848221, 0.00638276943936944, -0.011187336407601833, -0.07743718475103378, -0.027837269008159637 ]
<p>Since electromagnetic waves have both electric and magnetic field components, which oscillate in phase perpendicular to each other and perpendicular to the direction of energy propagation. How much is that electric charge? Can you possibly get a shock in some way?</p>
g485
[ 0.026411110535264015, 0.07284990698099136, -0.006974469870328903, 0.00008486546721542254, 0.08553843945264816, -0.0012654101010411978, -0.02580762840807438, 0.015523591078817844, 0.005766686517745256, 0.0097908740863204, 0.002216178458184004, 0.0009176810854114592, -0.011533566750586033, 0.0016846924554556608, 0.005681418813765049, -0.03148318827152252, 0.04372501000761986, -0.049141112715005875, -0.0070989192463457584, 0.03332768380641937, -0.0134887071326375, -0.021314676851034164, 0.024834292009472847, -0.021984165534377098, -0.013568821363151073, 0.020156580954790115, -0.0000950115718296729, -0.035264380276203156, -0.03322046995162964, -0.049262188374996185, -0.004259401001036167, -0.019181761890649796, 0.013308263383805752, -0.026209335774183273, -0.11934920400381088, -0.02046615071594715, -0.004642288666218519, 0.007299000862985849, -0.018342837691307068, 0.04529993236064911, 0.07709994167089462, -0.020207008346915245, 0.0319996140897274, -0.04045961797237396, 0.041935183107852936, -0.011385361663997173, -0.02967914380133152, 0.034152302891016006, -0.043832819908857346, 0.004822236020117998, -0.054324690252542496, -0.005199183709919453, 0.08581475913524628, 0.02008943445980549, 0.019166041165590286, 0.010604644194245338, 0.06203983351588249, -0.056380871683359146, 0.08553730696439743, 0.051674481481313705, -0.02359399013221264, 0.057362549006938934, 0.049316342920064926, 0.035156939178705215, -0.010600613430142403, -0.019609784707427025, -0.06605985760688782, -0.062077343463897705, 0.03938252851366997, -0.02562829852104187, 0.020818764343857765, -0.027920283377170563, -0.03313270956277847, -0.04040765017271042, 0.03779299557209015, 0.005167294293642044, -0.0358070433139801, 0.06337162852287292, 0.024676848202943802, 0.0026152702048420906, 0.07368744164705276, -0.035988595336675644, -0.024288205429911613, -0.032731298357248306, 0.042743831872940063, -0.05834091827273369, 0.01200600154697895, -0.0016377958236262202, -0.026124577969312668, -0.01684846729040146, -0.026957953348755836, -0.006216180976480246, 0.04150766506791115, 0.021041763946413994, 0.00827588327229023, -0.008788815699517727, -0.016401614993810654, 0.035148102790117264, 0.046745236963033676, -0.02044903114438057, -0.03922930359840393, -0.007333158981055021, -0.010505116544663906, -0.06766128540039062, 0.016981091350317, 0.00048227873048745096, -0.015923595055937767, 0.00980693381279707, -0.027362139895558357, -0.0438588485121727, -0.027803584933280945, -0.03552194684743881, -0.03746391087770462, -0.026103302836418152, -0.0823710635304451, -0.04471522942185402, 0.04112274572253227, -0.037273406982421875, 0.004084290470927954, 0.049856215715408325, 0.012160266749560833, -0.004953405819833279, -0.017732730135321617, 0.08795725554227829, 0.015789030119776726, 0.09215602278709412, -0.009739184752106667, 0.0034186746925115585, -0.0006600914639420807, 0.0013167047873139381, -0.008745292201638222, 0.018308818340301514, -0.048148833215236664, -0.03832384571433067, 0.02890053018927574, 0.039791714400053024, 0.009124066680669785, 0.01366372499614954, -0.05033619701862335, -0.03061789833009243, 0.038962554186582565, -0.03501452878117561, 0.015137450769543648, -0.029489343985915184, 0.006215252913534641, 0.019894201308488846, -0.020694894716143608, -0.03087233565747738, 0.03152325004339218, 0.003260125871747732, -0.001496406039223075, 0.007642407901585102, 0.02053055167198181, -0.02260298654437065, 0.07195716351270676, -0.009443588554859161, -0.005227632820606232, -0.04071385785937309, -0.0164200309664011, -0.0236875731498003, 0.05069933086633682, -0.0031757468823343515, 0.03982580453157425, 0.017083805054426193, 0.019034627825021744, -0.020260950550436974, 0.05334338918328285, 0.055227130651474, -0.010604029521346092, 0.03328762575984001, 0.01866205409169197, -0.0373675599694252, 0.08699610829353333, 0.0005833113100379705, 0.03945888951420784, 0.03623950108885765, -0.04178543761372566, -0.07459782809019089, 0.09394331276416779, -0.00005080503615317866, -0.054002534598112106, 0.0062029436230659485, 0.00339087238535285, -0.03229895979166031, 0.04744477570056915, 0.0060148886404931545, -0.031050633639097214, 0.05151264742016792, -0.021750671789050102, 0.01192553248256445, -0.03142799809575081, -0.003889836138114333, 0.0017982294084504247, 0.007146870251744986, 0.016240235418081284, -0.015675140544772148, -0.030028467997908592, 0.04067344218492508, -0.02656937949359417, 0.01199689693748951, -0.029682224616408348, 0.07298294454813004, 0.047277696430683136, 0.016137681901454926, 0.003392238635569811, 0.03554355725646019, -0.03102698177099228, -0.0368465930223465, 0.03126545622944832, -0.04698481783270836, 0.0468045175075531, -0.024799982085824013, 0.04331519454717636, 0.03906189650297165, -0.017186621204018593, 0.027644973248243332, 0.025470726191997528, -0.044325027614831924, -0.061562180519104004, 0.06320363283157349, 0.006662784144282341, 0.017338236793875694, 0.03012186475098133, -0.013187164440751076, -0.02150408923625946, -0.031915243715047836, -0.023043403401970863, 0.012790683656930923, -0.050860337913036346, -0.05480088293552399, -0.030401019379496574, 0.05557720363140106, -0.01565174013376236, -0.014197048731148243, 0.026981467381119728, 0.02086128666996956, -0.0038295213598757982, -0.03812418878078461, -0.020811527967453003, -0.02881545014679432, 0.05245877429842949, -0.008199750445783138, 0.044063132256269455, 0.006218388676643372, 0.008745466358959675, -0.026535701006650925, 0.049658406525850296, 0.06894513964653015, 0.012411612085998058, 0.002362949075177312, 0.01867309771478176, -0.030257539823651314, -0.013436167500913143, 0.04975238814949989, -0.020480800420045853, -0.02471502684056759, -0.0346909835934639, 0.014324055053293705, -0.04646981135010719, -0.010190865024924278, 0.01766953058540821, 0.03479783609509468, 0.03920406848192215, -0.0061731054447591305, -0.08675842732191086, 0.012656334787607193, -0.006490480154752731, 0.003117963904514909, -0.03592192381620407, -0.004120316356420517, -0.048396170139312744, 0.08337370306253433, -0.0052277203649282455, 0.03172808885574341, -0.004113990813493729, -0.015055600553750992, 0.053693633526563644, -0.030563058331608772, 0.04436725378036499, -0.09706097841262817, -0.03425772488117218, 0.017889685928821564, 0.012510398402810097, 0.02217266894876957, 0.024205775931477547, -0.004007063340395689, 0.0020049959421157837, -0.016004247590899467, -0.0379752591252327, 0.016044247895479202, -0.06598441302776337, -0.04017652943730354, 0.05344465747475624, 0.0016857788432389498, -0.05075856298208237, -0.038656555116176605, 0.03777600824832916, -0.05174626410007477, -0.020572207868099213, 0.016602806746959686, 0.07525746524333954, -0.047569844871759415, 0.018503813073039055, -0.002377367578446865, 0.03031664527952671, 0.006607700604945421, -0.038284458220005035, -0.029016265645623207, 0.04328625276684761, 0.020933957770466805, -0.02411835640668869, 0.07658843696117401, 0.03344094380736351, 0.027155663818120956, -0.07624655961990356, -0.01004809234291315, -0.017389938235282898, -0.04153609648346901, 0.020964089781045914, 0.0421486496925354, -0.010089259594678879, -0.05199895054101944, 0.033614180982112885, -0.023338977247476578, 0.0008650561212562025, 0.014324654825031757, -0.05861134082078934, -0.0026249925140291452, -0.01174190267920494, -0.04867633059620857, -0.003426305716857314, 0.005563235841691494, -0.015948163345456123, -0.030515624210238457, 0.047737665474414825, 0.026594040915369987, 0.02338855341076851, 0.043863631784915924, 0.002661579754203558, 0.07005299627780914, 0.03105880692601204, -0.021958252415060997, 0.004185911267995834, -0.04311288520693779, -0.015143546275794506, -0.011826780624687672, -0.011354261077940464, -0.044153306633234024, 0.03500339016318321, 0.020945781841874123, 0.023498592898249626, -0.02094779722392559, -0.00949019193649292, -0.010364490561187267, 0.010891498066484928, -0.011251403950154781, 0.04849933832883835, 0.023389670997858047, -0.012939097359776497, 0.029682716354727745, 0.016842611134052277, -0.05423026531934738, 0.019571393728256226, -0.06940198689699173, 0.007961327210068703, 0.023946914821863174, 0.005821692291647196, 0.04778043553233147, -0.02507529780268669, -0.0702078640460968, -0.047479141503572464, -0.03474470227956772, 0.027604596689343452, 0.008125748485326767, 0.01861281506717205, -0.06357579678297043, -0.0004695470561273396, -0.02615550346672535, -0.007143121678382158, 0.047292374074459076, -0.006182052660733461, -0.008679122664034367, 0.0036059734411537647, -0.005550567526370287, 0.013312876224517822, -0.01317578461021185, -0.0053533813916146755, -0.027709512040019035, 0.037537455558776855, 0.01289211492985487, 0.04753490909934044, -0.02595595456659794, -0.03315499797463417, 0.005902754608541727, 0.007584391627460718, -0.05805288255214691, -0.023396963253617287, -0.04530993476510048, -0.004855876322835684, 0.026540005579590797, 0.1246548444032669, 0.003933027386665344, -0.005229106172919273, -0.04778352379798889, 0.019289618358016014, 0.06780385226011276, 0.04857544228434563, 0.012943915091454983, -0.010394732467830181, -0.0403149276971817, 0.014000647701323032, -0.022095734253525734, -0.024846628308296204, -0.021398935467004776, -0.0041007790714502335, 0.0016841305186972022, 0.0633627399802208, 0.06411941349506378, 0.051084209233522415, 0.023182831704616547, 0.025584617629647255, 0.04314543679356575, -0.019645823165774345, 0.03195825591683388, -0.03555221110582352, 0.07293955236673355, 0.05295610800385475, -0.042099058628082275, -0.0648343414068222, -0.013269373215734959, 0.001159226754680276, 0.023641284555196762, 0.0037166746333241463, 0.031025975942611694, -0.03334041312336922, 0.02621745876967907, -0.06259343773126602, -0.006580890156328678, -0.008820628747344017, 0.014749150723218918, 0.019782809540629387, -0.008460733108222485, 0.019490640610456467, -0.013405554927885532, -0.001182290376164019, 0.05340900272130966, 0.023894954472780228, -0.07956087589263916, -0.024762073531746864, -0.04407813400030136, -0.037903860211372375, 0.023990552872419357, -0.04732218384742737, -0.040894199162721634, 0.06687407940626144, -0.014641661196947098, -0.013984329998493195, -0.004818612709641457, -0.0317249596118927, 0.019083300605416298, -0.0500163696706295, 0.027896763756871223, 0.04841892048716545, 0.057375501841306686, 0.04923418164253235, -0.07811089605093002, -0.014721321873366833, -0.03241701424121857, -0.028112804517149925, 0.03234165161848068, 0.008024298585951328, -0.0015990681713446975, 0.03155029937624931, -0.007945414632558823, 0.026224607601761818, -0.02055535279214382, -0.03819134086370468, -0.029256215319037437, -0.06645846366882324, 0.027041487395763397, 0.003924419172108173, -0.04221135750412941, 0.014456233941018581, -0.023897070437669754, -0.02360103651881218, 0.00029256840934976935, -0.03560924157500267, 0.0994441956281662, -0.013756238855421543, -0.11693421006202698, -0.04019143432378769, 0.026691623032093048, -0.07511981576681137, 0.008137978613376617, -0.010702280327677727, 0.026669560000300407, -0.001724869362078607, -0.0012344474671408534, -0.05650356411933899, -0.00856045726686716, -0.039730560034513474, -0.013346013613045216, 0.0013361350866034627, 0.011555555276572704, -0.029134100303053856, 0.004912013653665781, -0.030297381803393364, 0.003223701613023877, 0.0006999903707765043, -0.0007055182359181345, 0.012158598750829697, 0.008173579350113869, -0.0005118527333252132, 0.010310355573892593, 0.013958408497273922, 0.0021258608903735876, -0.03320302814245224, 0.037799034267663956, -0.017470164224505424, 0.031185513362288475, 0.04260575398802757, -0.05678694322705269, 0.05654071271419525, 0.03136943653225899, -0.0011863583931699395, -0.00954239722341299, -0.08905372023582458, -0.034537676721811295, 0.022666411474347115, 0.016092080622911453, 0.011439939960837364, 0.007047528401017189, -0.020766938105225563, -0.07121288031339645, 0.029051875695586205, -0.05000801011919975, 0.0869336798787117, -0.023574097082018852, 0.005913647823035717, 0.033406924456357956, -0.020185360684990883, -0.09002097696065903, 0.05417879298329353, 0.07844468206167221, 0.04532177373766899, 0.03387753665447235, -0.04416634887456894, 0.007911374792456627, 0.01808537356555462, -0.04634762555360794, -0.03345116600394249, 0.040547385811805725, -0.007436015643179417, -0.008914523757994175, 0.02515195496380329, 0.06501086801290512, 0.01689755544066429, -0.06009179726243019, -0.00909535214304924, 0.02962997555732727, 0.07185517996549606, -0.02231118641793728, 0.01956724002957344, 0.043799832463264465, -0.018117491155862808, 0.03574024513363838, 0.014542561024427414, -0.010138653218746185, 0.002240478992462158, -0.03212231397628784, 0.007685510441660881, -0.038107261061668396, -0.024296704679727554, 0.026579640805721283, 0.027284197509288788, -0.011346346698701382, 0.021992169320583344, 0.005364236421883106, -0.05094228312373161, 0.0313948318362236, -0.001864877063781023, 0.041679948568344116, 0.008455236442387104, 0.04541079327464104, 0.02903628535568714, -0.0016265895683318377, -0.06030682101845741, -0.005672742612659931, 0.018726889044046402, 0.0025818897411227226, -0.03410838171839714, -0.021134309470653534, -0.010388844646513462, -0.08727061003446579, -0.009075122885406017, -0.06398840248584747, 0.026923462748527527, -0.012576743960380554, 0.03156651556491852, 0.09984427690505981, 0.059472449123859406, 0.02872527949512005, -0.03530176728963852, 0.02916269563138485, 0.035316888242959976, -0.009916559793055058, -0.04647050425410271, -0.005341873504221439, -0.04794474318623543, 0.005696326959878206, -0.047844357788562775, -0.0417964905500412, -0.00608126912266016, -0.032533757388591766, 0.0015055981930345297, 0.016210248693823814, 0.03994978591799736, -0.03542480245232582, 0.016924036666750908, 0.01578936167061329, -0.013679897412657738, -0.03754529729485512, 0.0021474147215485573, 0.005905109457671642, 0.017353251576423645, 0.0006607190589420497, -0.03713624179363251, 0.016861766576766968, 0.02873958647251129, -0.020298581570386887, -0.002415125723928213, 0.037607818841934204, -0.01961502805352211, 0.05343130975961685, 0.03394827991724014, -0.003937279339879751, 0.05173347517848015, -0.05774424970149994, 0.020121052861213684, -0.02520045079290867, 0.035385701805353165, 0.05402417853474617, -0.0046221064403653145, 0.06739795207977295, -0.055407360196113586, 0.025696611031889915, 0.050886645913124084, -0.07065312564373016, 0.023534728214144707, -0.00598641112446785, -0.022955510765314102, -0.021659858524799347, 0.003208631882444024, 0.014626335352659225, -0.04762018099427223, -0.008262128569185734, 0.025657087564468384, 0.019085409119725227, 0.00018075374828185886, -0.0384681411087513, -0.001051508355885744, 0.019339710474014282, 0.011959894560277462, -0.027401890605688095, 0.031515397131443024, 0.0010970988078042865, 0.0015695869224146008, -0.08961334079504013, -0.00875481404364109, 0.01464942004531622, 0.028025634586811066, -0.029770340770483017, -0.005106508266180754, 0.017505357041954994, -0.05442243441939354, -0.011813660152256489, -0.012280060909688473, -0.018880115821957588, 0.015748918056488037, 0.0007982073584571481, 0.010781061835587025, 0.024444572627544403, 0.00267572863958776, 0.03028140775859356, 0.024880215525627136, -0.014305910095572472, -0.014628469944000244, 0.003313539084047079, 0.03830068185925484, 0.0019805110059678555, -0.013814400881528854, 0.034888677299022675, 0.051192156970500946, 0.012044823728501797, -0.005953444167971611, -0.014316912740468979, 0.021002905443310738, 0.049249470233917236, 0.02625460736453533, -0.008685753680765629, -0.04127291589975357, -0.00030010935734026134, 0.039857812225818634, 0.0012509835651144385, -0.0023326983209699392, 0.017987476661801338, 0.0576922670006752, -0.08546053618192673, -0.0497736856341362, -0.032330673187971115, 0.01835537701845169, 0.044535744935274124, -0.011619282886385918, 0.01357437763363123, 0.01630582846701145, 0.05362236499786377, 0.021791264414787292, 0.059309300035238266, 0.05885173752903938, 0.010241881012916565, -0.019171347841620445, -0.004160584416240454, -0.03494476154446602, -0.01502122450619936, 0.020768405869603157, 0.0004922259249724448, 0.023556498810648918, 0.005384502001106739, 0.0243306253105402, -0.05509030818939209, 0.04209587350487709, -0.026196977123618126, -0.013827149756252766, -0.009275916032493114, -0.008796908892691135, 0.034751370549201965, -0.003714523743838072, 0.013140999712049961, 0.0068771797232329845, -0.04281488060951233, 0.0707586258649826, -0.06478023529052734, -0.07403650879859924, -0.07011359184980392, 0.031066400930285454, -0.007200811989605427, -0.055152662098407745, 0.0433880090713501, 0.06303005665540695, -0.02609211765229702, 0.028009895235300064, -0.017543628811836243, -0.049473606050014496, 0.011458447203040123, 0.012873372063040733, -0.02885669656097889, -0.0543878935277462, -0.03101363033056259, -0.009008243680000305, 0.030747875571250916, 0.028418367728590965, 0.005657009780406952, 0.02719365991652012, -0.08252193033695221, -0.02995067648589611, -0.019891982898116112, 0.03021232597529888, -0.03907950967550278 ]
<p>I'm supposed to derive a relation for the range of wavelengths that's being transmitted by a spectrometer (bandpass) in terms of the dispersion, focal length and exit slit width.</p> <p>Given grating is $100mm$ wide, slit separation $d=5.6\times 10^{-7} m$, focal length $f=1\space m$, exit slit width $w=100\mu m$ and spectrometer working in first order regime.</p> <p>Then I'm supposed to find value of slit width that corresponds to a bandpass of theoretical resolving power of $\lambda \approx 500 nm$</p> <p><strong>Attempt</strong></p> <p>I found dispersion $\frac{d\theta}{d\lambda} = \frac{p}{d cos \theta} $ and resolving power $Np$.</p> <p>Thus The amount of wavelengths contained in the dispersion is simply $\delta \theta \times \frac{d\lambda}{d\theta} $</p> <p>But what is the angle of spread? Is it simply $\delta \theta = \frac{w}{f}$.</p> <p>If so, then I find the bandpass $\Delta \lambda = \frac{w}{f} \times \frac{d}{p} = 5.6 \times 10^{-11} $.</p> <p>Last part of the question doesn't make sense, as resolving power is only dependent on $N$.</p>
g4053
[ -0.00798901729285717, -0.04814374819397926, -0.01848333515226841, -0.01920643448829651, 0.05065499246120453, -0.06508424133062363, 0.004038277547806501, -0.01331903226673603, -0.0021436295937746763, -0.05276494845747948, 0.03827406093478203, 0.05321945622563362, -0.0012206489918753505, 0.026566607877612114, -0.005117267835885286, -0.04910579323768616, 0.0038635414093732834, 0.005011449102312326, 0.039906468242406845, 0.011279929429292679, 0.00929713249206543, -0.02154531329870224, -0.06049727275967598, -0.07851077616214752, -0.012430046685039997, -0.026916224509477615, 0.006856059189885855, -0.0124770263209939, -0.06884466856718063, -0.008043337613344193, 0.03493599221110344, 0.015710782259702682, 0.057496607303619385, 0.025993388146162033, -0.053270161151885986, 0.004796016961336136, -0.04578959941864014, 0.054548829793930054, 0.023005597293376923, -0.014592080377042294, 0.002705938881263137, -0.0246789138764143, 0.051863621920347214, -0.035928208380937576, -0.005651077721267939, -0.06139369308948517, -0.048581719398498535, 0.007566327694803476, 0.039993155747652054, -0.018599430099129677, 0.006503066513687372, 0.07110851258039474, 0.04419023171067238, -0.0048312293365597725, 0.013950519263744354, 0.04741058871150017, -0.020936984568834305, -0.028530718758702278, 0.0398891307413578, 0.021173249930143356, -0.001752863870933652, -0.028426630422472954, -0.03065749816596508, 0.03105764091014862, 0.02051597461104393, 0.011710920371115208, 0.006055210251361132, -0.004967875313013792, 0.002056849654763937, -0.04715008661150932, 0.0019423585617914796, -0.05993986874818802, 0.042226433753967285, -0.04439011216163635, -0.0288928784430027, -0.021218132227659225, 0.0013190369354560971, -0.026709623634815216, -0.028442056849598885, 0.010605501011013985, -0.017677655443549156, -0.05973450839519501, -0.03849359229207039, 0.051663484424352646, 0.016944080591201782, 0.031405478715896606, -0.0016594378976151347, -0.017185239121317863, 0.04317934811115265, 0.05030880868434906, 0.037543267011642456, 0.008648553863167763, 0.03894534707069397, 0.006141559220850468, 0.03319665789604187, 0.020108770579099655, -0.01978408917784691, 0.030151478946208954, 0.007335192058235407, -0.029391849413514137, 0.03461240977048874, -0.026685042306780815, 0.03811466321349144, 0.01477521937340498, 0.0037333532236516476, 0.01047115121036768, 0.015004855580627918, 0.008183171972632408, 0.027120964601635933, 0.03730738162994385, -0.060212187469005585, -0.020639335736632347, -0.07018911838531494, -0.05996173620223999, -0.04991144686937332, -0.011010067537426949, 0.006574817467480898, 0.04680481180548668, 0.02301405929028988, -0.00794591661542654, 0.015218249522149563, 0.019000930711627007, 0.033139318227767944, 0.04721298813819885, -0.02107318304479122, 0.008417323231697083, 0.02158266492187977, 0.04414762184023857, 0.06345292925834656, 0.03175269812345505, -0.009852120652794838, -0.03614979237318039, 0.011373011395335197, 0.07420323044061661, 0.02819966897368431, 0.010275604203343391, 0.03957776352763176, -0.01101696491241455, -0.057211004197597504, 0.036768704652786255, -0.019113432615995407, -0.009786347858607769, 0.017845744267106056, -0.05816465616226196, -0.03674713149666786, 0.03131093829870224, 0.019033381715416908, -0.06898007541894913, 0.07763438671827316, -0.03211916983127594, 0.009966566227376461, 0.10970626026391983, -0.03251093626022339, -0.042514264583587646, -0.030887525528669357, -0.026522187516093254, 0.007787263952195644, -0.054814890027046204, -0.007728436030447483, -0.03619156777858734, 0.029978889971971512, -0.028229817748069763, -0.005257149692624807, 0.029566628858447075, -0.032187897711992264, -0.05729680135846138, 0.035931386053562164, -0.07609599083662033, -0.005853426642715931, -0.05395819991827011, -0.051625438034534454, -0.010405286215245724, 0.01308757346123457, 0.0037630745209753513, 0.012779414653778076, 0.07247284054756165, 0.04873967915773392, 0.045302070677280426, -0.03352281078696251, 0.08128172159194946, -0.009626179002225399, -0.02553003840148449, -0.014868964441120625, -0.047717951238155365, -0.017505774274468422, -0.042098626494407654, 0.014965428039431572, -0.10722633451223373, 0.005210206378251314, 0.0332147553563118, -0.007765250746160746, -0.014662020839750767, 0.01868707686662674, 0.00578273693099618, -0.05114402249455452, -0.008265654556453228, 0.027377557009458542, -0.04055345430970192, -0.02553691528737545, 0.011969838291406631, -0.06964877992868423, 0.0498545877635479, 0.003538421355187893, 0.008094781078398228, 0.022970525547862053, -0.0028784205205738544, 0.0051300423219799995, 0.029412945732474327, -0.022835439071059227, 0.017843594774603844, -0.0592208206653595, -0.03914135694503784, -0.054321471601724625, 0.012596368789672852, -0.014101418666541576, 0.011059792712330818, -0.015091710723936558, 0.03357374668121338, 0.002843571826815605, 0.05761632323265076, -0.03655213117599487, 0.02801601216197014, -0.0026855238247662783, -0.00017405065591447055, -0.03189050778746605, 0.0065817455761134624, -0.02582031860947609, 0.02514345571398735, 0.020274804905056953, 0.021717313677072525, -0.058544326573610306, -0.0014441899256780744, -0.011224016547203064, -0.05141771212220192, 0.0013821361353620887, 0.020927704870700836, -0.05681105703115463, -0.0005734091973863542, -0.023546429350972176, -0.0017933486960828304, 0.0002996813564095646, -0.025690319016575813, -0.06287918239831924, 0.02307692915201187, -0.002247842727228999, 0.027071136981248856, 0.0427619144320488, 0.05300285294651985, -0.054302189499139786, -0.0063159530982375145, -0.021636739373207092, 0.01548889558762312, 0.04935510829091072, 0.051504794508218765, -0.03425315394997597, -0.026486128568649292, 0.0026715747080743313, 0.006659992970526218, -0.029812518507242203, -0.010973135940730572, -0.03129533305764198, -0.0026580211706459522, 0.05846211314201355, -0.038320522755384445, 0.014928958378732204, -0.0294019915163517, -0.027078932151198387, 0.013929753564298153, 0.007760598789900541, 0.0026348168030381203, 0.014418762177228928, -0.00972766149789095, 0.03848114237189293, 0.026790177449584007, 0.060676459223032, -0.035127125680446625, 0.037079449743032455, -0.05912112817168236, 0.034829165786504745, -0.017166059464216232, -0.018254639580845833, -0.011405255645513535, -0.021843882277607918, 0.012535793706774712, 0.025795888155698776, -0.06361718475818634, 0.062124207615852356, 0.06928207725286484, 0.005300926044583321, 0.009328456595540047, -0.0006460573058575392, -0.02680022083222866, -0.05304248258471489, 0.02464277110993862, -0.0387568324804306, -0.0016829944215714931, 0.07610764354467392, -0.004722962621599436, 0.06995302438735962, -0.037910982966423035, 0.017241770401597023, 0.02629964053630829, -0.029970595613121986, 0.0003665404801722616, 0.05231000483036041, 0.03205550089478493, -0.01643592119216919, -0.016173403710126877, -0.028162414208054543, 0.006398168858140707, 0.01742365024983883, -0.003088840516284108, 0.09117480367422104, -0.04194324463605881, -0.018503297120332718, 0.01037892047315836, 0.021785058081150055, -0.03787264972925186, -0.03633137419819832, 0.007648949045687914, 0.009187988936901093, -0.013866538181900978, 0.021262411028146744, -0.02500210516154766, -0.017905402928590775, -0.0018640827620401978, -0.07177162170410156, -0.02110135555267334, -0.052328310906887054, 0.03248395398259163, 0.013875283300876617, -0.029982443898916245, -0.004416049458086491, -0.04285801202058792, -0.024934248998761177, -0.0066125961020588875, -0.015694603323936462, 0.020539794117212296, 0.029032697901129723, -0.02575923502445221, -0.021144341677427292, -0.03120996244251728, -0.09500426054000854, 0.005748945754021406, 0.019236082211136818, 0.014253007248044014, -0.012332222424447536, 0.06388690322637558, -0.001790023292414844, -0.0009191454155370593, -0.05926618352532387, -0.03331664949655533, -0.012005135416984558, -0.020965345203876495, -0.01714450865983963, 0.03300165757536888, -0.027127886191010475, 0.019001789391040802, 0.029247958213090897, -0.02664017677307129, 0.011763271875679493, 0.0005484159337356687, 0.01261933520436287, -0.061500370502471924, -0.01968245953321457, -0.03141508996486664, 0.04377923160791397, 0.05268275365233421, -0.03238559886813164, -0.0032073145266622305, -0.014043619856238365, -0.06643625348806381, -0.02427954599261284, -0.0165952630341053, -0.02459198236465454, -0.023341631516814232, -0.02395194210112095, -0.014551771804690361, -0.000853454228490591, 0.07559137046337128, 0.0059467400424182415, -0.014784875325858593, 0.017781972885131836, 0.024146107956767082, 0.026321912184357643, -0.01817355304956436, -0.009568542242050171, -0.023003142327070236, 0.026306794956326485, -0.07229337096214294, -0.016297973692417145, -0.06547203660011292, -0.03540690243244171, -0.021104346960783005, -0.04423835501074791, -0.0716458112001419, 0.022648977115750313, 0.019805533811450005, -0.021752353757619858, 0.012671981938183308, 0.025110658258199692, 0.04645024240016937, 0.04123125597834587, 0.07002946734428406, -0.017269913107156754, 0.06994544714689255, 0.02802448160946369, -0.007780887186527252, -0.02387915551662445, 0.04126201197504997, -0.01850453019142151, -0.018026202917099, -0.03158627077937126, -0.034494273364543915, 0.004703070502728224, 0.022138068452477455, 0.028029026463627815, -0.032629452645778656, 0.030862338840961456, -0.0010588624281808734, -0.03120645321905613, 0.03486005589365959, 0.09595096111297607, 0.007155967876315117, -0.025761080905795097, -0.02120562270283699, 0.048824600875377655, -0.0025803563185036182, 0.028936028480529785, -0.009816179051995277, -0.03235863894224167, 0.020607640966773033, -0.006415368989109993, 0.026575377210974693, -0.05818227678537369, 0.05956077575683594, -0.02256815880537033, 0.011137840338051319, 0.014167174696922302, 0.018344199284911156, 0.027574429288506508, 0.024461425840854645, -0.00413872953504324, -0.007017234340310097, 0.018675416707992554, 0.0027701817452907562, -0.03705471754074097, -0.02647944912314415, 0.033910904079675674, -0.018640166148543358, -0.005449626129120588, -0.00707426480948925, -0.020577432587742805, -0.07692648470401764, -0.0033825573045760393, -0.07360882312059402, 0.00039339580689556897, 0.01642494834959507, 0.11124250292778015, 0.02055935561656952, 0.03777732327580452, 0.05041743442416191, -0.07790445536375046, 0.027840949594974518, 0.08315525949001312, 0.045468226075172424, -0.054839324206113815, 0.014252970926463604, -0.06848921626806259, -0.029661301523447037, -0.010629885829985142, 0.010485416278243065, 0.03190815448760986, -0.00627038674429059, 0.0014180701691657305, 0.013448174111545086, -0.014827283099293709, -0.019171588122844696, -0.01871703378856182, -0.01756647601723671, -0.014859494753181934, -0.044248517602682114, 0.061381664127111435, 0.02451724000275135, 0.02871786430478096, 0.008122463710606098, -0.004937043879181147, -0.03287260979413986, 0.01758425496518612, -0.07892121374607086, -0.018045686185359955, -0.017749181017279625, -0.02876875549554825, 0.04409756511449814, -0.0008060353575274348, -0.035808462649583817, 0.08274868130683899, 0.017090851441025734, 0.05680381506681442, -0.0035160232800990343, 0.06212356314063072, 0.03309054300189018, -0.0356672964990139, 0.03752826526761055, -0.009313360787928104, 0.07103404402732849, 0.0799836814403534, -0.0034936151932924986, 0.025832396000623703, 0.03582768514752388, 0.001984206959605217, 0.035721372812986374, -0.0019169352017343044, 0.019263848662376404, 0.06528840959072113, -0.048833075910806656, -0.06716801971197128, 0.03737368434667587, -0.03397231921553612, 0.003592408960685134, -0.0008091907948255539, 0.022200066596269608, 0.02601005882024765, 0.01743224449455738, 0.016580328345298767, -0.04166388511657715, -0.05999555438756943, -0.015059721656143665, 0.018752481788396835, -0.058884117752313614, 0.028152020648121834, 0.0745808407664299, -0.035748329013586044, -0.011034862138330936, 0.046188708394765854, -0.03745932877063751, -0.012541387230157852, 0.018802911043167114, -0.049462396651506424, -0.014185112901031971, -0.01002240926027298, 0.06132495775818825, 0.03304336592555046, 0.03174208849668503, 0.01775406487286091, -0.014914864674210548, 0.011361705139279366, -0.04095248505473137, 0.006095404736697674, 0.05724569782614708, -0.02232866734266281, 0.005167703609913588, -0.06022857502102852, -0.06486339122056961, -0.009554583579301834, 0.0375346876680851, 0.010578342713415623, -0.002574819838628173, -0.00524821225553751, -0.019698869436979294, 0.07828463613986969, 0.02279955893754959, -0.03681580722332001, 0.042998600751161575, -0.013025535270571709, -0.05361000820994377, 0.009974728338420391, 0.017225658521056175, 0.016208834946155548, 0.030337687581777573, -0.0623445026576519, 0.028873514384031296, 0.004986157175153494, -0.032803162932395935, 0.046621061861515045, 0.08921000361442566, 0.0410475917160511, -0.037249255925416946, -0.004913644399493933, -0.0317620225250721, -0.002232047962024808, 0.026007739827036858, 0.005346857011318207, 0.042525358498096466, -0.07606838643550873, -0.0015922273742035031, 0.0032524156849831343, -0.006956623867154121, 0.07216869294643402, 0.008464810438454151, 0.006811413913965225, -0.03202635794878006, 0.015414833091199398, -0.02503032051026821, -0.007875286974012852, -0.033219024538993835, 0.05894004926085472, -0.0026947185397148132, -0.0023817487526685, 0.03051954135298729, 0.0662754625082016, 0.012231895700097084, 0.014806747436523438, 0.03960371017456055, -0.00897815078496933, 0.012236949056386948, -0.03399408608675003, 0.005419776309281588, 0.004523251671344042, 0.0437144935131073, 0.04590465500950813, -0.006304488517343998, 0.13653109967708588, 0.02480974979698658, -0.001228980254381895, -0.05690533295273781, 0.009762647561728954, 0.03978365659713745, -0.02638906240463257, 0.02505248785018921, -0.0036279226187616587, -0.005416955798864365, -0.021364104002714157, 0.02279028296470642, -0.01138635165989399, 0.06039552763104439, 0.0034470048267394304, -0.04916752874851227, 0.024764537811279297, 0.0021209733095020056, 0.020168457180261612, -0.021604318171739578, 0.023137113079428673, 0.009394410997629166, -0.008893030695617199, 0.06194845214486122, -0.0920775905251503, 0.039777811616659164, -0.01704542525112629, 0.050593744963407516, 0.017771201208233833, -0.003850567853078246, 0.02445177175104618, -0.02934013493359089, -0.041363704949617386, 0.013774902559816837, -0.01803695596754551, 0.050625335425138474, 0.0014833364402875304, -0.0008207717328332365, 0.03237682953476906, -0.00812146719545126, -0.036368414759635925, 0.06736936420202255, -0.009537492878735065, 0.04111268371343613, 0.007291708141565323, -0.0027043898589909077, 0.005285248626023531, -0.018766986206173897, -0.011876330710947514, -0.059817858040332794, -0.024765003472566605, 0.0054244850762188435, -0.020580239593982697, 0.07445129752159119, 0.052521008998155594, -0.05794317647814751, -0.023282408714294434, -0.04207833111286163, -0.012279368005692959, -0.04678608104586601, 0.046886198222637177, -0.022790005430579185, -0.013121891766786575, 0.014358066953718662, -0.08485538512468338, -0.0010289829224348068, -0.025392115116119385, -0.022556856274604797, -0.035322368144989014, 0.014801952987909317, -0.018783189356327057, -0.016187837347388268, -0.037006448954343796, 0.019273536279797554, -0.055355604737997055, -0.03853908181190491, 0.03409189730882645, 0.03406168147921562, -0.04210237041115761, -0.004972674418240786, 0.03150133788585663, -0.04550275579094887, 0.013588720932602882, -0.0059821512550115585, 0.05100753530859947, 0.06759246438741684, 0.044764772057533264, 0.051076192408800125, 0.041950345039367676, -0.05483167991042137, -0.01607031561434269, 0.005605634767562151, 0.05440010130405426, 0.014843118377029896, -0.0026043541729450226, -0.014872348867356777, 0.046868566423654556, -0.060224682092666626, 0.04886443540453911, -0.03989880904555321, -0.006388833746314049, 0.03680357336997986, 0.00007336940325330943, 0.03088916838169098, -0.050053518265485764, 0.03226286917924881, -0.04224979504942894, -0.0042129941284656525, -0.0010700460989028215, -0.049336694180965424, 0.003661450697109103, -0.027944834902882576, -0.07379533350467682, -0.024520542472600937, 0.012383057735860348, -0.030857520177960396, 0.026622258126735687, 0.010569467209279537, -0.016025276854634285, -0.019313812255859375, -0.08054636418819427, -0.03403020277619362, -0.06331311911344528, 0.03473159670829773, 0.019631030037999153, -0.006114365067332983, -0.02596651017665863, 0.036155879497528076, 0.019824234768748283, 0.03301256150007248, 0.0025318823754787445, -0.01882387511432171, 0.010224134661257267, -0.023787979036569595, -0.020586799830198288, 0.00347593380138278, 0.04206061735749245, 0.017622843384742737, -0.07790317386388779, 0.030009862035512924, -0.011103340424597263, 0.0723135694861412, 0.059589169919490814, -0.0505271777510643, 0.03628045693039894, 0.016110174357891083, 0.015257010236382484, -0.026759611442685127, -0.027038512751460075, -0.00763156870380044, -0.03560379147529602, 0.05587650462985039, -0.015822986140847206, -0.006408222019672394, -0.04234226047992706, 0.02052166499197483 ]
<p>I've heard a couple of scary stories from experienced accellerator physiscists about something called neutron clouds. Apparently, if you have an experiment like a fixed-target experiment that produces a lot of neutrons with the correct energy, they don't just dissipate or get caught in surrounding matter. Instead, they hang around due to their large half-life (~15 minutes). The rumor goes that they actually form clouds, that wander around the facility, and that in the early days of some CERN experiment, people didn't think about the effect, and got a nasty (although not accute) dose when they entered the collision hall just after shutting down the beam.</p> <p>The description of the behavior of these clouds varies in different accounts. Sometimes they just pass through everything, but sometimes they're supposed to behave like a real gas, being held back by walls (but creeping through small openings).</p> <ul> <li>I can imagine this phenomenon is real, but how much of an issue is it in real experiments / nuclear facilities?</li> <li>Do the clouds really behave like a gas (I'd think the n-n cross section is not big enough to create pressure)? How do they behave wrt. walls? </li> <li>And in light of the recent nuclear waste transports in France and Germany: The waste emits a lot of gamma and neutron radiation, could it leave a temporary trail of low-energy neutron clouds behind?</li> </ul>
g4054
[ -0.039801936596632004, 0.05787896737456322, -0.005291115026921034, -0.04774782434105873, 0.03494967892765999, -0.03811938315629959, -0.0016711007338017225, 0.03352918475866318, -0.011883351020514965, -0.03673558682203293, 0.003148827701807022, 0.03124554455280304, 0.015271961688995361, -0.009962223470211029, -0.005857440643012524, -0.04305170476436615, 0.057139813899993896, -0.04398838058114052, -0.022473862394690514, 0.01851813867688179, -0.013551521115005016, 0.0007942644879221916, 0.014250143431127071, -0.05111239477992058, -0.0662362203001976, 0.028669441118836403, -0.004227065481245518, -0.025661062449216843, -0.05827915668487549, -0.021714460104703903, 0.059175342321395874, -0.07383651286363602, -0.010021773166954517, -0.056171443313360214, -0.03911357745528221, -0.042127467691898346, 0.024322330951690674, -0.042737383395433426, 0.02376089245080948, 0.0008795346948318183, 0.014668514020740986, -0.044955622404813766, 0.035503581166267395, -0.01023018453270197, -0.04905908182263374, 0.06919125467538834, -0.009777105413377285, 0.0261621605604887, 0.08415701985359192, -0.026459312066435814, -0.023675117641687393, 0.02738916501402855, -0.023711923509836197, 0.0828733816742897, 0.018454641103744507, 0.009008681401610374, -0.015688301995396614, -0.015568271279335022, 0.07337488234043121, 0.005396733526140451, 0.017237946391105652, 0.030908482149243355, -0.05327938124537468, -0.017309632152318954, 0.051637716591358185, -0.0409834086894989, -0.09675873070955276, 0.03416376933455467, 0.06880626827478409, 0.034587543457746506, 0.04157739505171776, 0.024097509682178497, -0.04298005998134613, -0.030337898060679436, 0.05887928977608681, 0.019954005256295204, -0.007776234298944473, 0.01919676922261715, 0.015889335423707962, 0.05716390907764435, -0.05240624397993088, -0.03597257286310196, -0.00002531094833102543, 0.02628585882484913, 0.03177464008331299, 0.08275871723890305, -0.024804241955280304, -0.005927552934736013, 0.034035488963127136, 0.00891729537397623, 0.02391204796731472, -0.03626382723450661, -0.013313592411577702, -0.013495245017111301, -0.023978592827916145, 0.01046203076839447, -0.012974057346582413, 0.032112590968608856, -0.0548112615942955, 0.03579937666654587, -0.02223222143948078, -0.015530302189290524, 0.005928227677941322, 0.01912848837673664, -0.008564610965549946, 0.032398927956819534, -0.01575767621397972, -0.033730629831552505, 0.05620717257261276, 0.005465666763484478, -0.011797025799751282, 0.0021162275224924088, 0.022132176905870438, -0.014477836899459362, 0.04027075693011284, -0.0019716517999768257, -0.009356850758194923, 0.07185695320367813, 0.02757355198264122, 0.08963584154844284, 0.03269945830106735, 0.09795863926410675, -0.016128579154610634, -0.05521966516971588, 0.02152162231504917, -0.031102607026696205, 0.014994495548307896, 0.019316378980875015, 0.0009459223947487772, 0.02910444512963295, 0.010959778912365437, 0.001968823606148362, -0.14109309017658234, 0.03431905806064606, 0.023013081401586533, 0.04545548930764198, 0.03367123007774353, -0.024109145626425743, -0.04439185932278633, -0.06919212639331818, 0.04924190416932106, 0.002164266537874937, -0.011487703770399094, -0.0075997235253453255, -0.01063995249569416, -0.0035853839945048094, 0.0007867710082791746, 0.055299535393714905, -0.05894462764263153, 0.0021082786843180656, -0.03521214798092842, 0.017469532787799835, -0.02365047112107277, -0.055851712822914124, -0.006107430439442396, 0.012554502114653587, 0.021299928426742554, -0.027663815766572952, -0.0541558638215065, 0.024477699771523476, 0.04281465709209442, 0.019229507073760033, 0.07933322340250015, -0.018822582438588142, -0.04889317974448204, 0.007106780540198088, 0.03379351645708084, 0.023434527218341827, 0.05095461755990982, 0.006251257844269276, -0.09523780643939972, 0.0005049442406743765, 0.005349889863282442, 0.0571526363492012, -0.035801444202661514, -0.019484981894493103, 0.0918327048420906, -0.009695028886198997, 0.028791334480047226, -0.04132451117038727, -0.039577189832925797, -0.03088265471160412, -0.05293101444840431, -0.06399539858102798, 0.00897865928709507, 0.027436936274170876, -0.019730571657419205, -0.04231470078229904, -0.0029137686360627413, -0.017140964046120644, 0.008844503201544285, -0.018625983968377113, 0.007638893555849791, 0.031631048768758774, 0.034008804708719254, -0.03052350878715515, -0.005089063197374344, -0.056587979197502136, 0.04232880100607872, 0.012873311527073383, -0.034460294991731644, 0.028340240940451622, -0.027043944224715233, 0.01655336655676365, 0.025713743641972542, 0.008144821040332317, -0.012169323861598969, 0.033793121576309204, 0.010383287444710732, 0.0027363167610019445, 0.07377628237009048, 0.0048951152712106705, 0.0025655829813331366, 0.016798237338662148, -0.011594664305448532, -0.017191778868436813, -0.0234542116522789, -0.007907777093350887, 0.0033470613416284323, 0.01529602985829115, 0.0009657837799750268, -0.0013767482014372945, 0.05456726253032684, -0.021144406870007515, 0.06759119778871536, 0.0025258769746869802, -0.054494667798280716, -0.0061820391565561295, 0.01662241667509079, -0.0004951822920702398, -0.021313415840268135, 0.03825844079256058, -0.0032331489492207766, -0.04478377103805542, 0.004980511497706175, -0.01697399653494358, 0.029016921296715736, -0.037960443645715714, 0.06289847195148468, -0.050293900072574615, -0.017193369567394257, 0.0009375931113027036, -0.09171435236930847, -0.03247246518731117, 0.022384239360690117, -0.07038646936416626, -0.009711897000670433, 0.012869403697550297, -0.0054456451907753944, -0.06214366480708122, 0.018217751756310463, -0.01253320649266243, -0.02147810347378254, -0.03372683748602867, 0.023524191230535507, -0.002763837343081832, -0.020037958398461342, -0.003630125429481268, -0.0064138504676520824, -0.05189301446080208, -0.026889467611908913, -0.033358920365571976, 0.04638640955090523, -0.016904078423976898, 0.00593401538208127, 0.0097708934918046, -0.03622834011912346, 0.02793736569583416, 0.02683214657008648, 0.002095916774123907, -0.012876708060503006, -0.004614939913153648, 0.03593258559703827, 0.06462247669696808, -0.004195698536932468, 0.04996791109442711, -0.032340142875909805, 0.045088525861501694, 0.043182894587516785, -0.03569898381829262, -0.03987943381071091, 0.020478779450058937, -0.04492777958512306, -0.036206312477588654, 0.04589676856994629, 0.004483562428504229, -0.010520544834434986, -0.03470878675580025, 0.03368458151817322, -0.04787668213248253, 0.029197420924901962, -0.06833408772945404, 0.02025653049349785, 0.006876304745674133, -0.03748146817088127, 0.0045793564058840275, -0.0038418553303927183, 0.01745031587779522, -0.028486166149377823, -0.026151491329073906, -0.004968608729541302, -0.010172928683459759, 0.01777881383895874, 0.005914422683417797, -0.019442636519670486, 0.013279186561703682, -0.04701513051986694, -0.02252456173300743, -0.022881455719470978, -0.06513994187116623, -0.0431971549987793, 0.02488798275589943, 0.007881839759647846, 0.0031748181208968163, 0.0463901050388813, 0.02433265559375286, 0.023172996938228607, 0.022806106135249138, 0.03239054977893829, -0.05050845444202423, 0.025905821472406387, 0.02295263111591339, 0.02934258058667183, 0.020698625594377518, 0.016642428934574127, 0.028120223432779312, 0.046061720699071884, -0.04869335889816284, 0.002629193477332592, -0.0717133954167366, 0.06002211570739746, -0.04645960032939911, 0.002422126242890954, -0.008601813577115536, -0.04084648936986923, -0.04220714420080185, -0.0013130313018336892, 0.032476022839546204, 0.02593301236629486, -0.018495602533221245, 0.004090482369065285, 0.01047026552259922, 0.010155143216252327, 0.027484603226184845, 0.03507214039564133, 0.0013788148062303662, -0.004606256727129221, -0.06417684257030487, -0.04641511291265488, -0.01606934517621994, 0.12535059452056885, -0.059276800602674484, -0.0027323721442371607, -0.002209931146353483, -0.02040635049343109, -0.045374780893325806, 0.06360027939081192, 0.00549479341134429, 0.04773493856191635, -0.029494328424334526, -0.06590074300765991, 0.00014160435239318758, 0.0369412899017334, 0.029011815786361694, -0.03702308610081673, -0.03263922408223152, 0.004578432068228722, 0.035872507840394974, 0.019393231719732285, 0.033127255737781525, -0.022646725177764893, 0.03469128534197807, 0.0006143908249214292, -0.00576142780482769, -0.014451572671532631, 0.02784336917102337, 0.0012276035267859697, 0.024174541234970093, -0.010742430575191975, 0.023838667199015617, -0.06447158753871918, -0.025575513020157814, 0.03585787117481232, -0.03406236320734024, 0.0038377437740564346, 0.006396048236638308, -0.018741808831691742, -0.026894593611359596, 0.0003902065218426287, -0.02403990551829338, -0.030451901257038116, -0.03145648166537285, -0.02048448473215103, 0.021541858091950417, 0.010658826678991318, 0.006479406729340553, -0.0005015337956137955, 0.0021479360293596983, 0.0065943170338869095, 0.013528785668313503, 0.009533356875181198, 0.049959082156419754, 0.009898688644170761, -0.03230646997690201, 0.049058713018894196, 0.0012783975107595325, -0.016146888956427574, -0.016084609553217888, -0.01073030661791563, -0.011578495614230633, 0.0361705981194973, 0.013869808055460453, -0.018243394792079926, -0.02363741584122181, 0.00641521904617548, -0.10216698795557022, 0.00885866954922676, 0.08561830967664719, -0.024634629487991333, 0.05430211126804352, -0.01123886089771986, 0.05640280619263649, 0.013875545002520084, 0.04279660806059837, -0.014617797918617725, 0.00594500545412302, 0.010565749369561672, 0.003970352001488209, -0.04312911629676819, -0.026390880346298218, 0.0585770420730114, -0.0016641992842778563, -0.00770915811881423, 0.000628100533504039, 0.002203458920121193, 0.04290592297911644, -0.08067412674427032, 0.01323393639177084, 0.011717936024069786, 0.08991814404726028, 0.09673425555229187, 0.02937127649784088, 0.07082922756671906, 0.051109541207551956, -0.010790335014462471, 0.03043055534362793, -0.05409388989210129, -0.025820164009928703, 0.010314610786736012, 0.01565779373049736, -0.048843469470739365, 0.006912242155522108, -0.029625609517097473, -0.03961535543203354, 0.025457080453634262, 0.007580442354083061, 0.003902856959030032, 0.023303057998418808, 0.007740660570561886, -0.017243867740035057, -0.02677484229207039, -0.01656782068312168, 0.034154828637838364, 0.002685347804799676, -0.051479022949934006, -0.037430353462696075, -0.024371057748794556, -0.07223376631736755, 0.004698919598013163, -0.02186865173280239, -0.02899092808365822, 0.04515831917524338, -0.00980289001017809, 0.010660767555236816, 0.03244904801249504, -0.05231691151857376, 0.03003370761871338, 0.026136867702007294, 0.01027910877019167, -0.019101914018392563, 0.03382677212357521, 0.03142969682812691, -0.003443226683884859, -0.009499766863882542, 0.036195870488882065, -0.01271326094865799, 0.007114051375538111, 0.000988840009085834, 0.062257856130599976, -0.016042962670326233, 0.025317296385765076, -0.03783201798796654, -0.015702255070209503, 0.017891548573970795, 0.026329834014177322, -0.05668332427740097, -0.004599261563271284, -0.02964850887656212, -0.005266841035336256, 0.012214036658406258, 0.027608349919319153, 0.021530117839574814, 0.0040535288862884045, -0.05961774289608002, -0.03807201236486435, 0.03905385360121727, 0.017154192551970482, -0.05215632542967796, 0.02970367856323719, -0.042052894830703735, -0.06760187447071075, 0.03984446078538895, -0.014078873209655285, 0.03867444396018982, 0.03062121383845806, -0.0005666922079399228, -0.0335528664290905, 0.013208318501710892, 0.02679184451699257, 0.008317753672599792, -0.024251045659184456, -0.006845898926258087, 0.04396523907780647, 0.04864061251282692, 0.0733334943652153, -0.02684709057211876, -0.04276974871754646, 0.021489456295967102, -0.011246203444898129, 0.020586097612977028, -0.014050625264644623, -0.04570150002837181, 0.0047017489559948444, -0.007443293929100037, -0.028612647205591202, -0.0033228807151317596, -0.020958872511982918, -0.0056968689896166325, 0.06701866537332535, 0.01769317500293255, -0.03120485134422779, -0.038282185792922974, 0.0044234320521354675, 0.0477752760052681, 0.022018171846866608, -0.025274643674492836, 0.02543378807604313, 0.03625084087252617, 0.04772799462080002, -0.032043810933828354, -0.044228795915842056, -0.011883601546287537, 0.023701136931777, 0.02886217087507248, 0.06523392349481583, -0.000404852646170184, -0.0018633638974279165, -0.012074883095920086, -0.013428854756057262, 0.012053076177835464, -0.01611080951988697, 0.027519211173057556, -0.023771611973643303, 0.03500186651945114, 0.0055639008060097694, -0.0061852228827774525, -0.05399716645479202, -0.029851673170924187, 0.03148096054792404, 0.03023453988134861, 0.042827196419239044, 0.028121305629611015, 0.03919561579823494, -0.033278707414865494, 0.04474937915802002, 0.026297803968191147, 0.05165116488933563, 0.027662836015224457, 0.0022111127618700266, -0.002693057293072343, 0.043926823884248734, -0.014231188222765923, 0.03396802023053169, -0.043938081711530685, 0.04336313158273697, -0.01584804616868496, 0.032788269221782684, 0.048912689089775085, 0.016268713399767876, -0.03688709810376167, -0.03941494971513748, -0.018193071708083153, -0.00029083056142553687, 0.02342008799314499, -0.07127189636230469, 0.007521745748817921, -0.025882303714752197, -0.009451677091419697, -0.09767721593379974, -0.020740369334816933, -0.010099992156028748, 0.06034202501177788, -0.03978149592876434, 0.02085992507636547, 0.002959390403702855, -0.0261116661131382, 0.014566320925951004, 0.04328470304608345, -0.026266366243362427, 0.02875618450343609, -0.03709087893366814, 0.04083246365189552, 0.01828080601990223, 0.012605121359229088, -0.05806431174278259, -0.06793227791786194, 0.024401679635047913, 0.004941181745380163, 0.007738727610558271, -0.05332757532596588, -0.0007750699296593666, 0.017305513843894005, -0.007490095216780901, -0.038984786719083786, 0.008494934067130089, -0.005999382119625807, -0.008973781950771809, 0.019044842571020126, 0.03445782512426376, 0.06257235258817673, 0.0010449279798194766, 0.022730300202965736, 0.029457414522767067, -0.04722997918725014, -0.058369576930999756, 0.03977762535214424, -0.059331201016902924, 0.02438366413116455, 0.060022421181201935, -0.03592634201049805, 0.0330129899084568, 0.0037902677431702614, -0.039354365319013596, -0.05663914233446121, -0.02808213420212269, 0.02519874833524227, 0.020189447328448296, -0.012692238204181194, -0.06637642532587051, 0.042471665889024734, -0.018008140847086906, -0.09408929198980331, -0.011654434725642204, -0.026847030967473984, -0.014967571012675762, 0.047171179205179214, -0.009016838856041431, 0.03475232422351837, 0.010954655706882477, -0.09025322645902634, -0.03311961144208908, -0.03852484002709389, -0.014537559822201729, 0.029492245987057686, -0.023863742128014565, -0.0668233260512352, 0.03382797911763191, -0.015110254287719727, 0.049524761736392975, -0.020615065470337868, 0.012996702454984188, -0.050936464220285416, -0.060079608112573624, 0.0005106441676616669, 0.02018325962126255, 0.009100288152694702, 0.008073369972407818, 0.05364758521318436, 0.044771548360586166, 0.02036544866859913, 0.011465033516287804, 0.045885588973760605, 0.02847149223089218, -0.04473466798663139, -0.036494944244623184, 0.047081317752599716, -0.05180990323424339, -0.016017859801650047, -0.024050453677773476, 0.01089879684150219, 0.03440415486693382, 0.03835415467619896, 0.08453939855098724, 0.002322900341823697, -0.045171190053224564, -0.018254315480589867, 0.030807586386799812, -0.014761731959879398, 0.005563478451222181, -0.03466791287064552, 0.0006179222837090492, 0.06365305930376053, 0.016085023060441017, -0.041689515113830566, 0.07166266441345215, 0.02227140963077545, 0.02371700294315815, 0.019809314981102943, -0.010677268728613853, 0.008648508228361607, -0.0011949364561587572, 0.05383840575814247, -0.008090893737971783, 0.030806424096226692, 0.0051576984114944935, -0.011601421050727367, -0.02228964865207672, -0.061610348522663116, 0.07355549931526184, 0.020531803369522095, -0.034995365887880325, -0.0038044380489736795, -0.05102214962244034, 0.04912996292114258, 0.09015347808599472, 0.011674504727125168, -0.041445083916187286, -0.01603970304131508, 0.0005558384000323713, 0.007917888462543488, -0.04125683382153511, -0.004518838599324226, 0.0008532587089575827, -0.002243125345557928, -0.002537534339353442, -0.03612392395734787, 0.0762639194726944, -0.06242373213171959, -0.03918909281492233, -0.05422027409076691, 0.052947115153074265, -0.037498876452445984, 0.0015900378348305821, -0.06379824131727219, -0.030719012022018433, -0.050774455070495605, 0.013126634061336517, -0.03240006044507027, -0.05499041825532913, -0.03250465169548988, 0.07624723762273788, 0.0035950264427810907, -0.021572180092334747, 0.0590885765850544, 0.055601816624403, -0.047765906900167465, -0.06525897979736328, 0.0279962457716465, 0.0023167692124843597, 0.023898601531982422, 0.0005775131285190582, -0.00665039150044322, 0.011246305890381336, 0.042476993054151535, -0.020813312381505966, -0.02272246591746807, 0.011823497712612152, -0.040954262018203735 ]
<p>In an experiment we were given non-homogenous dielectric substances described by functions of coordinate. How can capacitance be determined from this?</p>
g4055
[ -0.0256712194532156, 0.0031003819312900305, -0.0062886499799788, -0.02181418053805828, 0.027285119518637657, -0.04169589653611183, 0.0028754672966897488, -0.009818805381655693, -0.04038583114743233, -0.012835748493671417, -0.034469857811927795, 0.013538802042603493, 0.04145605489611626, -0.023939432576298714, -0.006726039573550224, -0.008699622005224228, 0.0763903483748436, 0.030102942138910294, 0.009301173500716686, 0.009193138219416142, 0.010709249414503574, 0.013662380166351795, 0.0273545254021883, -0.0007289237109944224, -0.02318408340215683, -0.05319873243570328, -0.0007038807962089777, -0.036776769906282425, -0.06828392297029495, -0.05913092568516731, 0.047108862549066544, -0.01234170887619257, 0.07288128137588501, 0.01232817117124796, -0.008645044639706612, 0.009453031234443188, 0.03258444741368294, 0.07255249470472336, 0.017212755978107452, 0.07581145316362381, -0.02396591380238533, 0.009120858274400234, -0.0073352959007024765, -0.00720414100214839, -0.015390951186418533, -0.019430940970778465, 0.0005681604379788041, -0.016910791397094727, -0.007193479686975479, -0.015130419284105301, -0.0016287931939586997, 0.03829183429479599, 0.035559624433517456, 0.028754502534866333, -0.011960810050368309, -0.02594364620745182, 0.002178408205509186, -0.012643247842788696, 0.08190695941448212, -8.965154734141834e-7, 0.00856192409992218, 0.02549648843705654, -0.022454317659139633, -0.005297840107232332, 0.047081708908081055, -0.06371157616376877, -0.02881406806409359, -0.03493880853056908, -0.031528934836387634, 0.043609123677015305, -0.020266007632017136, -0.04672706872224808, 0.021480469033122063, 0.010551230050623417, -0.02008257433772087, -0.01154818944633007, 0.035491347312927246, -0.0005933388019911945, 0.017452115193009377, -0.046186286956071854, 0.002665178384631872, 0.01501688826829195, 0.06814798712730408, 0.006498337257653475, -0.004611002281308174, -0.013748363591730595, -0.024559855461120605, -0.017448341473937035, -0.046616826206445694, 0.02245990000665188, 0.03206051513552666, -0.007116860710084438, 0.04603969305753708, 0.01691533625125885, 0.027502479031682014, 0.0049923378974199295, 0.009289204142987728, 0.026974065229296684, 0.024864519014954567, -0.02205738052725792, -0.023752868175506592, 0.07723912596702576, -0.0033864642027765512, 0.008522904478013515, 0.03867621347308159, 0.03938640281558037, 0.027559904381632805, 0.024553926661610603, -0.03085477650165558, -0.045225705951452255, 0.008228406310081482, 0.00906999409198761, -0.014643915928900242, 0.037704382091760635, 0.003850711276754737, -0.018263444304466248, 0.02983352728188038, -0.07575172185897827, 0.013243187218904495, 0.05530424416065216, 0.0016793347895145416, 0.014248429797589779, 0.041589412838220596, 0.06255481392145157, -0.0385299026966095, 0.059757642447948456, 0.038491055369377136, 0.0329110287129879, 0.023542232811450958, -0.07921306788921356, 0.03831808269023895, -0.046547915786504745, 0.003738032653927803, -0.0223581213504076, 0.00012261983647476882, 0.007218050304800272, 0.028879651799798012, -0.035313330590724945, 0.006362633313983679, 0.04636881500482559, 0.02061670832335949, -0.020212508738040924, -0.015462047420442104, 0.011836515739560127, -0.012190157547593117, -0.005659686867147684, 0.014491066336631775, -0.03582577407360077, 0.04706719517707825, 0.05712711438536644, 0.01622137241065502, 0.07579924166202545, 0.015954971313476562, -0.032660797238349915, 0.019551025703549385, -0.05147425830364227, 0.013263081200420856, -0.009865280240774155, 0.04239542409777641, -0.0005574634415097535, -0.01048042718321085, -0.03623685613274574, 0.015333116985857487, 0.031910449266433716, -0.015280140563845634, 0.00279557635076344, 0.010104040615260601, 0.05130485072731972, 0.049073848873376846, -0.028120048344135284, 0.005835625343024731, -0.016353832557797432, -0.043897923082113266, -0.013469778932631016, -0.006993485614657402, 0.050208114087581635, -0.03727512061595917, 0.06335839629173279, 0.06417723000049591, 0.010622409172356129, 0.021141640841960907, -0.009693301282823086, 0.027492547407746315, -0.05604789778590202, -0.0032941424287855625, 0.06986335664987564, -0.0029678912833333015, 0.04891088232398033, -0.0440177246928215, 0.03283980116248131, -0.07911952584981918, -0.01605481468141079, -0.040464285761117935, 0.023817267268896103, -0.013778883032500744, -0.04176301136612892, 0.030224233865737915, 0.015712207183241844, 0.006036749575287104, -0.020141951739788055, -0.030442319810390472, 0.04931360110640526, 0.04630503058433533, 0.05419621989130974, 0.008737309835851192, -0.08752566576004028, -0.0679907575249672, -0.022345632314682007, 0.03533783182501793, 0.018385350704193115, -0.014779791235923767, -0.0013552667805925012, -0.03470911085605621, 0.033466972410678864, -0.0347362719476223, -0.048733748495578766, -0.0254227165132761, -0.03829279541969299, -0.03744931519031525, -0.029119830578565598, -0.05354868248105049, -0.030008262023329735, 0.03913629427552223, 0.01808786951005459, -0.03818946331739426, -0.02451491169631481, 0.018527382984757423, 0.00697717210277915, -0.0692887231707573, -0.029761988669633865, -0.01282870676368475, -0.004197737667709589, 0.016213053837418556, 0.003436840372160077, -0.018301011994481087, 0.04662107303738594, -0.039804086089134216, -0.052425023168325424, 0.04541303217411041, 0.02517937310039997, -0.08685220777988434, -0.03621765598654747, 0.0357939749956131, 0.03493423014879227, -0.029853714630007744, -0.004341409541666508, 0.04352934658527374, 0.010235924273729324, 0.027194542810320854, 0.005625569261610508, -0.004861308261752129, -0.001590457744896412, -0.010891093872487545, 0.008726962842047215, -0.025718022137880325, -0.0030036666430532932, -0.00436377851292491, 0.02731858380138874, -0.014310598373413086, -0.03282320871949196, -0.027291495352983475, -0.07637172937393188, 0.038420505821704865, 0.0038908019196242094, -0.021800795570015907, -0.00232413480989635, -0.021490570157766342, 0.0003707928117364645, 0.014986639842391014, -0.003755654441192746, -0.04012122377753258, 0.03043524920940399, 0.03736818954348564, 0.022671716287732124, 0.020029693841934204, 0.004395381081849337, 0.07529608905315399, -0.009787563234567642, -0.028698107227683067, 0.03329534828662872, -0.04678347334265709, 0.019283249974250793, -0.019639702513813972, 0.022106261923909187, 0.02953971177339554, -0.04973367974162102, 0.038036685436964035, -0.011565171182155609, -0.035989757627248764, 0.007160107605159283, -0.03146437555551529, 0.017247051000595093, -0.017461251467466354, -0.007818426005542278, 0.027393924072384834, 0.026505008339881897, 0.04682677239179611, -0.06447029113769531, 0.022562898695468903, 0.07359803467988968, -0.04675069451332092, 0.01050418522208929, -0.025034911930561066, 0.01800842210650444, 0.020188387483358383, 0.06227234750986099, -0.014113886281847954, -0.025548312813043594, 0.0419287346303463, 0.02254955656826496, -0.026298774406313896, 0.030700406059622765, -0.012541022151708603, 0.006495038513094187, 0.00713645713403821, 0.0030261825304478407, 0.04873448237776756, 0.01863560825586319, -0.021213628351688385, -0.031766872853040695, 0.03280077502131462, -0.08327820152044296, 0.037633102387189865, -0.007009831722825766, 0.02868565544486046, 0.02543826401233673, -0.015336590819060802, -0.017853662371635437, -0.024850988760590553, -0.027603616937994957, 0.010920043103396893, 0.006495150271803141, -0.0018836273811757565, -0.024133341386914253, -0.008137268014252186, -0.05771513655781746, 0.012647246941924095, 0.03211424872279167, 0.05160236731171608, 0.013745380565524101, -0.03226357698440552, -0.03504044562578201, -0.005420344416052103, -0.06611305475234985, -0.06507407873868942, 0.0006940950988791883, -0.04658791422843933, 0.028424669057130814, -0.0009815595112740993, 0.009410164318978786, 0.009647863917052746, 0.010293138213455677, 0.02080332115292549, 0.020771682262420654, -0.03767317160964012, 0.04850347712635994, 0.060005832463502884, 0.029947154223918915, -0.021027090027928352, 0.003808742156252265, 0.022570285946130753, -0.032425858080387115, 0.057599976658821106, 0.0314333438873291, 0.02274354174733162, -0.0070690251886844635, 0.0716668888926506, 0.11546068638563156, -0.018077829852700233, -0.04856906458735466, -0.027908731251955032, -0.022940069437026978, 0.01414957083761692, 0.026597751304507256, 0.07929354161024094, -0.02146785520017147, -0.06400596350431442, -0.03100144863128662, -0.09577419608831406, 0.050493478775024414, -0.01585223712027073, 0.03577699512243271, 0.04504766687750816, 0.004304893780499697, 0.03771112859249115, -0.015090692788362503, 0.0029009822756052017, 0.06227266415953636, -0.018117545172572136, 0.016177808865904808, -0.006723165046423674, -0.05548964440822601, -0.05191558972001076, -0.00731842452660203, -0.08210503309965134, -0.09717504680156708, 0.033641695976257324, -0.040993280708789825, 0.034048568457365036, 0.019910868257284164, 0.023210274055600166, -0.04779408872127533, -0.0032192447688430548, 0.010110676288604736, 0.03767409920692444, 0.014741825871169567, 0.03768342733383179, -0.030972816050052643, 0.036399152129888535, 0.006429780274629593, -0.037614937871694565, -0.04085569828748703, 0.01703205332159996, -0.06267094612121582, -0.0010648459428921342, -0.03326208516955376, 0.06414646655321121, 0.0228399820625782, 0.00775926886126399, -0.027954941615462303, 0.020769011229276657, -0.01722552254796028, 0.0055330838076770306, -0.019821638241410255, 0.030781785026192665, -0.011572476476430893, 0.015983188524842262, -0.018341071903705597, -0.01773843914270401, 0.029173696413636208, -0.03386789932847023, 0.008422383107244968, -0.024157589301466942, 0.0487709641456604, -0.07817253470420837, -0.0019310262287035584, -0.027786899358034134, 0.04900296404957771, -0.01696205511689186, 0.08849265426397324, 0.0028241926338523626, -0.008238008245825768, 0.01550145260989666, -0.051663704216480255, 0.020175697281956673, 0.08060502260923386, -0.017228778451681137, -0.023732880130410194, -0.06602855026721954, -0.004499693866819143, -0.025246499106287956, 0.03406274691224098, -0.040783509612083435, 0.015212290920317173, 0.001807466265745461, -0.042753592133522034, -0.010330231860280037, -0.025479251518845558, -0.0032825456000864506, 0.04654639959335327, -0.0787101536989212, -0.04608316719532013, -0.042945221066474915, -0.01968863233923912, -0.044659268110990524, 0.014462152495980263, -0.018089059740304947, -0.034769363701343536, 0.006971461698412895, 0.040759049355983734, -0.011242260225117207, 0.03226005658507347, 0.051016438752412796, 0.05044915899634361, 0.02873755432665348, 0.010299689136445522, 0.0008788583218120039, 0.025062590837478638, -0.12373267859220505, -0.034828562289476395, -0.01695176400244236, 0.06509928405284882, -0.004504994489252567, -0.0035007342230528593, -0.014372768811881542, -0.005048329010605812, -0.0759783387184143, 0.016130417585372925, 0.012629695236682892, 0.011372641660273075, -0.01873357594013214, 0.006408577784895897, 0.017996978014707565, 0.045506156980991364, -0.04389534890651703, -0.04632182791829109, 0.005390483886003494, 0.0026543268468230963, -0.02402796782553196, 0.010351982899010181, -0.025245076045393944, 0.03104308433830738, 0.0005656433058902621, 0.03829996660351753, 0.013462970033288002, 0.053482238203287125, 0.0510588102042675, -0.01995917782187462, 0.018423335626721382, 0.028001338243484497, 0.01014393288642168, 0.03124946542084217, 0.043359484523534775, 0.04469886049628258, 0.015418587252497673, 0.04739990457892418, -0.02445295825600624, 0.027726436033844948, -0.025933966040611267, 0.015128613449633121, 0.08629892766475677, 0.010107278823852539, 0.008935440331697464, -0.04918457195162773, -0.04488066956400871, 0.029224928468465805, 0.03243314474821091, -0.024979805573821068, 0.005822382867336273, 0.09448947757482529, -0.0298796147108078, -0.0010115234181284904, -0.021366389468312263, -0.04986746981739998, -0.005513318348675966, 0.024670187383890152, -0.009783117100596428, -0.019290845841169357, 0.014743657782673836, 0.023870229721069336, -0.078190878033638, 0.002869520103558898, 0.04236874356865883, 0.033529557287693024, 0.016637930646538734, -0.018084829673171043, -0.010226848535239697, 0.06287433952093124, 0.022885674610733986, 0.04218124970793724, -0.03374108672142029, -0.02942151576280594, 0.03047512285411358, -0.024049703031778336, 0.05127560347318649, -0.002385871484875679, 0.023435838520526886, 0.007787373848259449, 0.018729310482740402, -0.02467174269258976, 0.052929770201444626, -0.01859341748058796, 0.013255547732114792, -0.029816467314958572, -0.005942667368799448, -0.0695820078253746, -0.008405851200222969, 0.01093363668769598, 0.06419000029563904, 0.0015038937563076615, -0.051103342324495316, -0.006878565065562725, -0.025678174570202827, -0.03771059960126877, -0.008194641210138798, -0.039152707904577255, 0.009373746812343597, 0.045670486986637115, 0.0747150257229805, 0.027626976370811462, -0.050288084894418716, -0.05821719765663147, -0.009769698604941368, -0.060604315251111984, -0.010991447605192661, 0.051838986575603485, 0.049043554812669754, -0.00047099898802116513, 0.006916014477610588, -0.01864236406981945, 0.01211376953870058, -0.03694692254066467, 0.04754673317074776, -0.016450580209493637, 0.04343658685684204, -0.07192245125770569, 0.08216770738363266, 0.01388630922883749, 0.05003562942147255, 0.05460848659276962, 0.010245406068861485, -0.022331062704324722, -0.011306642554700375, -0.013305217027664185, 0.027659349143505096, -0.028621390461921692, 0.0015174938598647714, 0.004269056487828493, -0.042374033480882645, -0.07615203410387039, -0.027680255472660065, 0.054263636469841, -0.04410683363676071, -0.013652140274643898, -0.012907678261399269, -0.010235554538667202, 0.054430726915597916, 0.005735921207815409, -0.017862217500805855, 0.012372590601444244, 0.04677249491214752, 0.0198544729501009, -0.04564269259572029, 0.034463703632354736, 0.03262036293745041, 0.04607062041759491, -0.02995113655924797, -0.00407651299610734, 0.01147830206900835, -0.020323943346738815, -0.054598014801740646, 0.026151496917009354, -0.007701967842876911, -0.013440221548080444, -0.007443990092724562, 0.029512032866477966, -0.029540937393903732, -0.03567451983690262, 0.0403914637863636, 0.024826914072036743, 0.005360343959182501, 0.02195769175887108, 0.06255803257226944, -0.01643131487071514, 0.0034397251438349485, 0.022158494219183922, 0.027281353250145912, -0.03589172661304474, -0.053296953439712524, 0.032024871557950974, 0.08968272060155869, -0.02807679958641529, -0.0001891724532470107, 0.09465914964675903, -0.021753713488578796, -0.06045040860772133, 0.07532931119203568, 0.006689583882689476, -0.012230451218783855, -0.009770674630999565, -0.055381957441568375, -0.02788776159286499, -0.013246547430753708, -0.01153451856225729, 0.002554672071710229, 0.0030359772499650717, -0.039044253528118134, -0.036798782646656036, -0.012559134513139725, -0.07421314716339111, -0.007945839315652847, -0.05078280717134476, -0.024554770439863205, 0.06444252282381058, -0.017362358048558235, -0.015376308932900429, 0.04285479709506035, 0.014830334112048149, -0.013903656043112278, -0.0033267538528889418, -0.002237815409898758, 0.04849155992269516, 0.0004641222476493567, -0.030995482578873634, -0.08461159467697144, -0.0076788789592683315, -0.03874192014336586, -0.07272826880216599, 0.03969709202647209, 0.06004003807902336, -0.06933261454105377, 0.044356632977724075, 0.03784245625138283, -0.032504674047231674, -0.0035459790378808975, -0.03264062479138374, -0.012385868467390537, -0.039635539054870605, -0.00022925925441086292, -0.048808615654706955, 0.050479453057050705, -0.03080672211945057, -0.08875615894794464, -0.03726496547460556, -0.061275966465473175, 0.0058255246840417385, -0.007456723600625992, -0.07125970721244812, -0.06275320798158646, -0.02887357957661152, -0.021527599543333054, 0.0756540298461914, 0.0007952019805088639, 0.03592856228351593, 0.0457526259124279, 0.06570535898208618, -0.060183413326740265, -0.008340439759194851, 0.01589117757976055, -0.026568852365016937, -0.04478849098086357, -0.03643859177827835, 0.0164199098944664, -0.04453607648611069, 0.005881292745471001, 0.012232767418026924, -0.04679394140839577, 0.017496461048722267, 0.04288225620985031, 0.017570801079273224, -0.027113039046525955, 0.0023432045709341764, 0.030431874096393585, 0.015866855159401894, -0.027567118406295776, -0.030980931594967842, 0.02123791165649891, 0.04290246218442917, 0.01610766164958477, 0.004105361644178629, -0.05439046397805214, 0.012187939137220383, -0.027721650898456573, 0.0026495112106204033, 0.03372843563556671, 0.011913560330867767, -0.051000501960515976, 0.0506058931350708, 0.06959450244903564, -0.022529801353812218, 0.025670602917671204, -0.042907148599624634, -0.022684017196297646, 0.022852811962366104, 0.009009681642055511, -0.05273595452308655, 0.005769049283117056, -0.002274231519550085, 0.06953933089971542, -0.04170042648911476, -0.045309726148843765, 0.002272675046697259, -0.013657285831868649, 0.015498058870434761, -0.02170763723552227, -0.015476038679480553, -0.010477178730070591, -0.002555638086050749 ]
<p>If we have a spherical capacitor with inner radius or r1 and outer radius of r2, with charges (+/-)q on them and there is a dielectric material (with constant e) in between them with. </p> <p>What kind of a potential would this create outside the entire capacitor? in the region with the dielectric? and inside the entire thing?</p>
g4056
[ 0.010561274364590645, 0.020229317247867584, 0.0004885268281213939, -0.002283625304698944, -0.034720104187726974, 0.0057317218743264675, -0.013974781148135662, -0.02294367551803589, -0.03233952820301056, 0.014060398563742638, -0.08654957264661789, 0.043602924793958664, 0.0259699746966362, 0.001670346362516284, 0.02792179211974144, -0.020997827872633934, 0.01712210103869438, -0.006445893086493015, -0.035093244165182114, 0.032855670899152756, -0.026688287034630775, -0.040009912103414536, 0.006602518260478973, 0.006264031864702702, -0.013068628497421741, 0.03009144961833954, 0.03231078013777733, 0.01791331358253956, -0.05110321566462517, -0.056363992393016815, 0.04935296252369881, 0.012298003770411015, -0.011292055249214172, -0.006702505983412266, -0.052120860666036606, 0.006836473476141691, 0.04245523363351822, 0.046355634927749634, -0.009381008334457874, 0.025700392201542854, -0.04122762754559517, -0.002614201046526432, 0.020620666444301605, 0.010387342423200607, 0.010840244591236115, -0.012369298376142979, 0.03618137910962105, 0.03141403570771217, -0.01024230569601059, -0.10017086565494537, -0.05386362597346306, -0.022940875962376595, 0.025846587494015694, -0.02319161780178547, 0.05496463552117348, -0.008583467453718185, -0.0013863781932741404, 0.014612848870456219, 0.015002899803221226, 0.006600007880479097, 0.012059365399181843, 0.041518326848745346, -0.08845780789852142, 0.005126164760440588, 0.04237433522939682, -0.014467057771980762, -0.013695930130779743, 0.00881524384021759, -0.02486659772694111, 0.0027057803235948086, 0.02890365570783615, -0.058984991163015366, -0.024144481867551804, -0.05743283033370972, -0.017060881480574608, 0.05081899091601372, 0.007135733962059021, 0.060658540576696396, 0.04374536871910095, -0.02365265041589737, -0.019357623532414436, -0.042168620973825455, 0.05303085222840309, -0.020677966997027397, 0.027727652341127396, 0.039241064339876175, 0.015545775182545185, 0.0011545937741175294, -0.08371174335479736, 0.057639993727207184, 0.003162860171869397, -0.04647725075483322, 0.039660703390836716, -0.04489694908261299, -0.009595098905265331, -0.021027561277151108, -0.010050452314317226, 0.027683161199092865, 0.021654736250638962, 0.007577261887490749, 0.010187833569943905, 0.022922774776816368, 0.024046756327152252, 0.05355096235871315, -0.0191129669547081, 0.03327910974621773, 0.08011490851640701, -0.04261333867907524, 0.0026524404529482126, 0.010260132141411304, -0.001340591232292354, 0.007493529934436083, 0.004865188617259264, -0.00167557573877275, -0.02423788607120514, 0.014128963463008404, 0.05043729022145271, -0.038715265691280365, 0.050668925046920776, 0.10668601095676422, 0.0052068522199988365, 0.020968670025467873, 0.013827861286699772, -0.008024483919143677, -0.024177130311727524, 0.08076842129230499, 0.054106760770082474, 0.016171131283044815, 0.032053932547569275, 0.004423828795552254, 0.04083716496825218, -0.028647899627685547, -0.02632327564060688, -0.025506824254989624, 0.00896497257053852, 0.04389246180653572, 0.012654859572649002, -0.03256091848015785, -0.04738454520702362, -0.011004587635397911, -0.014981902204453945, -0.02161865122616291, 0.017258169129490852, 0.009720546193420887, -0.017778750509023666, 0.017165550962090492, 0.04338274896144867, -0.006529863923788071, -0.03720657154917717, 0.01121163833886385, 0.04450488090515137, 0.03755468130111694, 0.006869244389235973, -0.02951100282371044, 0.0012641021749004722, -0.01174623891711235, 0.054469212889671326, 0.024822309613227844, 0.059903834015131, 0.00414935452863574, -0.013413968496024609, 0.022168029099702835, 0.008229784667491913, 0.037619248032569885, -0.021108919754624367, 0.020198969170451164, -0.01070378627628088, 0.03139706701040268, -0.007107381243258715, -0.04326614364981651, 0.04508154094219208, -0.047795988619327545, 0.013136832974851131, 0.0695323571562767, -0.006659835577011108, 0.02695460617542267, 0.03011656180024147, 0.05900999531149864, 0.03284713253378868, 0.01764473132789135, -0.028983667492866516, -0.029506025835871696, 0.00888063944876194, -0.016195880249142647, -0.02467282861471176, -0.004982973914593458, 0.10025355219841003, 0.08897514641284943, -0.011882863938808441, 0.030177390202879906, -0.05570542812347412, -0.02651020511984825, -0.034939173609018326, 0.05060277506709099, -0.0030790308956056833, -0.04238245636224747, 0.09678846597671509, -0.03545502573251724, -0.014276210218667984, -0.06907175481319427, -0.018662650138139725, 0.038725338876247406, 0.03923749923706055, 0.02947307750582695, 0.01623832806944847, -0.03924167901277542, 0.0031386453192681074, -0.009069585241377354, 0.059285327792167664, 0.04996514692902565, 0.0024573823902755976, 0.0006441743462346494, -0.008574138395488262, 0.004066165536642075, -0.00829353928565979, -0.01673523150384426, -0.04563402011990547, -0.011145230382680893, -0.04594001919031143, 0.03077382594347, -0.058538537472486496, 0.04054141044616699, -0.0244367066770792, -0.027969373390078545, -0.03377291187644005, 0.00810618419200182, -0.04482092708349228, 0.050724439322948456, -0.01734805852174759, -0.023496171459555626, -0.05682244151830673, -0.0038672368973493576, 0.03367573395371437, -0.027520019561052322, -0.05427144467830658, 0.07927976548671722, -0.019921978935599327, -0.04325795918703079, -0.031554922461509705, -0.059127647429704666, -0.008870490826666355, -0.02568667009472847, -0.050310030579566956, 0.012307479977607727, -0.03342094272375107, -0.0242295078933239, 0.061739157885313034, -0.0007822673651389778, -0.009282384067773819, 0.0036292856093496084, 0.04652523249387741, -0.0077793169766664505, -0.019121257588267326, 0.0011823084205389023, -0.033665355294942856, -0.0078055071644485, -0.018549922853708267, 0.04997185617685318, -0.007121020928025246, -0.06055501475930214, -0.0405571423470974, -0.038156621158123016, -0.00754503533244133, -0.004486990161240101, -0.0499357245862484, 0.026094142347574234, -0.05352034419775009, 0.0030029756017029285, 0.029009222984313965, 0.04951104521751404, -0.02155817113816738, 0.11080767214298248, 0.0358557291328907, 0.011651272885501385, 0.030768977478146553, -0.03442249819636345, -0.00067557004513219, -0.056485604494810104, 0.04619663953781128, -0.00688122259452939, 0.02738620527088642, 0.03747672960162163, -0.0521000437438488, 0.04009725898504257, -0.008547889068722725, -0.07567168772220612, 0.06249316781759262, 0.013136664405465126, 0.006954649928957224, -0.001457315287552774, -0.023775463923811913, -0.01559875626116991, 0.040976859629154205, -0.03308746591210365, 0.06371738016605377, 0.021617131307721138, 0.03968336060643196, -0.01613781601190567, 0.004848408978432417, 0.03873564675450325, -0.03165363892912865, -0.028371067717671394, -0.03140612319111824, -0.029631605371832848, -0.005012588109821081, 0.03138527646660805, 0.0016273747896775603, -0.0675831139087677, 0.06473544239997864, -0.0012189220869913697, -0.015285910107195377, 0.0666273906826973, -0.00827047973871231, 0.009154083207249641, 0.019905971363186836, 0.017262686043977737, 0.018674025312066078, -0.005118048749864101, -0.014941885136067867, -0.06618178635835648, 0.036797165870666504, -0.042369190603494644, 0.04622989892959595, 0.06710747629404068, 0.006209219805896282, 0.01319478452205658, -0.012342055328190327, -0.04583388566970825, -0.04529714211821556, -0.02704193815588951, -0.0161005686968565, -0.0036182564217597246, 0.002376967342570424, -0.04276331141591072, -0.01591354049742222, -0.03996680676937103, -0.01830228976905346, 0.04915716126561165, 0.07079903036355972, -0.003800586797297001, -0.0025146869011223316, -0.01281638815999031, -0.02614470385015011, -0.057288117706775665, 0.005522717256098986, 0.01628800481557846, -0.031119991093873978, -0.024515461176633835, 0.017564119771122932, 0.007870245724916458, 0.0162346288561821, -0.025870993733406067, 0.039532650262117386, -0.007839128375053406, 0.02081087976694107, 0.0059904130175709724, 0.03230208531022072, 0.05853578448295593, -0.019453398883342743, -0.02802722528576851, 0.026631014421582222, -0.09356419742107391, 0.04973163083195686, -0.04577692225575447, 0.009514362551271915, -0.05571674555540085, 0.03765719011425972, -0.002716190181672573, -0.012264682911336422, -0.06765840202569962, -0.01744295470416546, 0.0005334783345460892, -0.016863122582435608, 0.020438462495803833, 0.06711044907569885, -0.012063114903867245, -0.07078668475151062, 0.009532901458442211, -0.030018186196684837, -0.015037006698548794, 0.042085424065589905, -0.009096006862819195, 0.02151632122695446, -0.034871865063905716, 0.033395916223526, 0.03790793940424919, -0.00894211046397686, 0.010576022788882256, -0.03300219401717186, -0.05869147554039955, -0.040949732065200806, -0.03651874512434006, -0.02070639654994011, -0.009846432134509087, -0.034692950546741486, -0.021252918988466263, -0.02591261826455593, -0.08170072734355927, 0.02579052373766899, -0.002319344785064459, 0.024422988295555115, -0.03820754215121269, -0.00681330356746912, -0.03432559594511986, 0.02373635396361351, -0.03519735857844353, 0.054789360612630844, -0.015987787395715714, -0.016959285363554955, -0.011249963194131851, -0.004153883084654808, 0.003968000411987305, 0.008943556807935238, -0.057636626064777374, 0.02407906949520111, -0.03913821280002594, 0.0018156850710511208, 0.04719194769859314, 0.017748674377799034, -0.0014303873758763075, -0.02302630990743637, -0.02972513996064663, 0.013283374719321728, 0.04140954092144966, 0.041764527559280396, -0.06754211336374283, 0.03600703179836273, 0.023428549990057945, -0.011933731846511364, 0.0020109349861741066, -0.08069112151861191, 0.03633134067058563, -0.024166656658053398, 0.007027626037597656, -0.05091097205877304, 0.03872516751289368, -0.08498422801494598, 0.0009736216743476689, -0.000272174394922331, 0.007061365991830826, 0.03891510143876076, -0.03928370773792267, 0.02494668960571289, -0.047391120344400406, 0.022045234218239784, 0.059422750025987625, -0.007476900238543749, -0.008013613522052765, -0.011593034490942955, -0.04284103587269783, -0.057358331978321075, -0.029970841482281685, -0.061047814786434174, -0.017066217958927155, -0.026450615376234055, 0.011525186710059643, -0.014494192786514759, -0.03968951851129532, 0.022165535017848015, -0.002664043800905347, 0.00008687805529916659, -0.020012035965919495, -0.001955075655132532, -0.0009147854871116579, 0.011311442591249943, -0.007777164690196514, -0.04212000593543053, -0.00614710059016943, -0.02915242686867714, 0.008381987921893597, -0.0014314126456156373, 0.07415221631526947, 0.029484497383236885, 0.027081862092018127, 0.024978306144475937, 0.015444347634911537, -0.029427247121930122, -0.02296733483672142, -0.08486443758010864, -0.03792951628565788, 0.0017346256645396352, 0.03341636061668396, -0.0023002258967608213, -0.00974033959209919, -0.02190086990594864, 0.004977613687515259, -0.03781910985708237, 0.02454465627670288, -0.011551626957952976, 0.017528163269162178, 0.01622341014444828, -0.0029341198969632387, 0.008904865011572838, 0.02513621747493744, -0.015698948875069618, 0.04783184081315994, 0.04058864712715149, -0.04972698912024498, -0.0337989442050457, 0.009259997867047787, -0.005640419200062752, -0.013061195611953735, 0.020937498658895493, 0.07280749827623367, -0.01390378549695015, 0.007004349026829004, -0.009478201158344746, 0.006328330375254154, 0.07594819366931915, -0.027800247073173523, -0.03212856873869896, 0.037027910351753235, -0.01581290178000927, 0.03046368807554245, 0.04430510476231575, -0.008453505113720894, -0.10681480169296265, 0.013985298573970795, -0.035688869655132294, 0.04690173268318176, 0.04832909256219864, -0.03517073392868042, 0.0018208518158644438, -0.033999908715486526, 0.03723212331533432, 0.00309356558136642, -0.00038779861642979085, -0.044699348509311676, 0.04828556627035141, 0.06701989471912384, 0.03597819060087204, -0.01999032497406006, -0.03884127736091614, -0.005045115947723389, 0.044690944254398346, -0.008318343199789524, -0.0315554141998291, -0.005587417632341385, 0.06661955267190933, -0.014776051975786686, 0.014433745294809341, -0.0011591030051931739, -0.03730328753590584, 0.01592755876481533, -0.06703222543001175, -0.025495285168290138, -0.011430704966187477, 0.04169785603880882, 0.04820668697357178, 0.028849568217992783, 0.015499631874263287, -0.03537657856941223, -0.018172280862927437, 0.008074682205915451, 0.07770077139139175, -0.0308282058686018, 0.00788583979010582, -0.011229226365685463, 0.024885663762688637, -0.04119635000824928, 0.04088747128844261, -0.007848270237445831, -0.002132364781573415, 0.014589721336960793, -0.05073254555463791, -0.016459548845887184, 0.029782772064208984, 0.016553746536374092, 0.11488137394189835, 0.03811613470315933, 0.017804404720664024, -0.041749007999897, -0.001420124783180654, -0.05084988474845886, -0.009277721866965294, -0.0008449457818642259, 0.05345888435840607, 0.09498101472854614, 0.03191900998353958, 0.04484858363866806, -0.009137742221355438, -0.014260854572057724, 0.04010976478457451, -0.07141201198101044, 0.03219221532344818, 0.04824710637331009, 0.050553228706121445, -0.07481423020362854, 0.07314632833003998, -0.044484931975603104, -0.0521402582526207, -0.008642083033919334, -0.028899045661091805, -0.007693297229707241, 0.01710990071296692, 0.02005765587091446, 0.0376821868121624, -0.028619227930903435, -0.01064903475344181, 0.031463392078876495, 0.03822838142514229, -0.03798584267497063, -0.009949191473424435, -0.005028250627219677, -0.021963780745863914, -0.0421363040804863, -0.02486628293991089, -0.018517836928367615, -0.04080430045723915, 0.01979512721300125, -0.003684449940919876, 0.01409764215350151, -0.014635673724114895, -0.04000893607735634, -0.03250531852245331, 0.01192382536828518, 0.023722007870674133, 0.012134529650211334, -0.03270095959305763, -0.05502673611044884, 0.045679204165935516, 0.005542339291423559, -0.035794489085674286, -0.007005508057773113, 0.0020912245381623507, 0.04957899823784828, -0.007228515576571226, 0.0241656843572855, 0.016046006232500076, 0.0027869094628840685, 0.0036526499316096306, 0.07772446423768997, 0.0203416645526886, 0.028421007096767426, -0.0007104735122993588, 0.037810225039720535, 0.007840360514819622, -0.07558353245258331, -0.007822422310709953, -0.02481290139257908, 0.03165755048394203, 0.011936617083847523, 0.03301602229475975, 0.027353642508387566, -0.01122285332530737, 0.0016268226318061352, 0.08846466988325119, -0.0010014852741733193, -0.021678118035197258, 0.05917193368077278, 0.019047066569328308, -0.044916726648807526, -0.006185853388160467, 0.0022875696886330843, -0.04394475743174553, -0.032136235386133194, 0.04911588132381439, 0.04053415358066559, -0.03132810443639755, -0.04701772704720497, -0.042156681418418884, 0.0009423767332918942, -0.009681336581707, 0.011170764453709126, 0.027189143002033234, 0.03422165662050247, 0.009883774444460869, -0.037329353392124176, -0.029582200571894646, -0.0884346142411232, 0.009620914235711098, 0.017979633063077927, -0.025742772966623306, -0.015562268905341625, -0.0004077090125065297, 0.03418562933802605, 0.02979733794927597, 0.009672349318861961, -0.015750447288155556, -0.019333139061927795, 0.014651842415332794, 0.026958175003528595, -0.007705140858888626, -0.007267848122864962, -0.08097721636295319, -0.017910949885845184, -0.04516357555985451, -0.03257352486252785, 0.0713798999786377, 0.04442206397652626, 0.017491711303591728, 0.01410992257297039, 0.02222609706223011, -0.013019559904932976, -0.0022060321643948555, 0.029324818402528763, -0.009741699323058128, 0.0319506861269474, -0.01018404308706522, -0.03896024823188782, -0.006968135945498943, -0.043661024421453476, 0.021840712055563927, -0.04868960380554199, -0.016187751665711403, 0.026949884369969368, -0.05684233829379082, -0.02194821834564209, 0.0114245330914855, 0.028020579367876053, 0.04581271484494209, 0.06106923520565033, 0.06329463422298431, -0.0392167791724205, 0.020052827894687653, 0.02552824281156063, -0.040545497089624405, 0.052916619926691055, 0.030226316303014755, 0.0026488504372537136, -0.06454943120479584, -0.02453026734292507, 0.0007059247000142932, -0.02860868349671364, -0.04779795929789543, -0.05594968423247337, 0.0083419568836689, 0.013959444127976894, 0.05353616178035736, -0.02182532288134098, -0.009214791469275951, 0.003499446203932166, -0.013710370287299156, 0.012170929461717606, 0.002274526050314307, -0.08760897815227509, 0.046022895723581314, -0.010137151926755905, 0.03746430203318596, -0.07107751816511154, -0.02082665264606476, -0.07354483008384705, 0.039654169231653214, -0.05069480463862419, -0.008044769056141376, 0.036210376769304276, -0.07393790781497955, 0.044828835874795914, 0.09260807186365128, -0.053071338683366776, -0.029701191931962967, -0.0632375180721283, -0.016023162752389908, 0.009927297942340374, 0.019176553934812546, -0.07174476236104965, 0.010592537000775337, 0.04049035906791687, 0.03079664707183838, 0.012287081219255924, -0.01271114032715559, 0.011585434898734093, -0.0014871968887746334, 0.0472172312438488, 0.07953516393899918, 0.0013160869712010026, 0.03576373681426048, 0.032936323434114456 ]
<p>This question is based on the description of Longair in his book "Theoretical Concepts in Physics".</p> <p>He starts by giving some provisions:</p> <ul> <li>Conservative force field</li> <li>Fixed times $t_1$ and $t_2$</li> <li>Object moves from fixed point at $t_1$ to fixed point at $t_2$</li> </ul> <p>Then he defines:</p> <ul> <li>Lagrangian: $L = K-U$</li> <li>Action: $S = \int_{t_1}^{t_2}Ldt$</li> </ul> <p>He goes on to explain, that the principle of least action means, that an object moves on a path so that $S$ is minimized.</p> <p>Then he claims that this priciple is equal to Newton's 2nd law of motion, following through with a proof which is beyond my comprehension (which of course is my fault).</p> <p>After I calculated $S$ for a few examples, I am convinced, that this claim is correct only adding one additional provision (which Longair clearly does not state directly or indirectly):</p> <ul> <li>The object moves on a path fixed in space. (Just the speeds at the points is allowed to differ.)</li> </ul> <p>My argument for why this is necessary follows from a counterexample:</p> <ul> <li>Assume a central force field with constant force. Setup the object so that its trajectory is a circle. Take time $t_1$ and $t_2$ so that the object is at opposing ends of the circle, describing a half circle. Now change the force field, so that there is no force inside this circle. (This is still a conservative force field and the object moves still in the same circle.) Compare the $S$ of this half circle to the $S$ of the object moving with constant lower speed along the diameter of the circle. For both trajectories the $U$ is the same but the $K$ is lower for the shortcut along the diameter (lower speed). So the shortcut along the diameter has a lower action. Still, with the correct initial speed the object will move the half circle, fully in accordance to Newton's second law of motion. </li> </ul> <p>Since I cannot assume, that I found an error in Longair's standard book, can anyone please explain, what I got wrong.</p>
g4057
[ 0.07572382688522339, -0.02832919731736183, 0.005453570280224085, 0.007016561459749937, 0.05943357199430466, 0.007768478710204363, 0.07995934784412384, -0.016738852486014366, -0.03657112270593643, -0.04121736064553261, 0.00414924556389451, 0.005888300947844982, 0.009757575578987598, 0.009506039321422577, 0.011706137098371983, 0.0005262733320705593, 0.07965382933616638, -0.11185356974601746, 0.03563662990927696, 0.020468687638640404, -0.0027882009744644165, 0.027014335617423058, -0.004912145435810089, -0.021941332146525383, 0.005494659300893545, -0.020363233983516693, 0.07697794586420059, -0.013908391818404198, -0.10318267345428467, -0.004642750136554241, 0.07375524193048477, -0.016421955078840256, 0.03935009613633156, -0.08676956593990326, -0.002301124157384038, -0.0637507289648056, 0.06819168478250504, 0.026605594903230667, 0.026742419227957726, -0.0016873602289706469, 0.035750534385442734, -0.003945034928619862, 0.05357588082551956, -0.004313566721975803, 0.037092406302690506, -0.049353960901498795, -0.009339988231658936, -0.006576470099389553, -0.009306331165134907, 0.0049860416911542416, -0.05253613740205765, 0.01967044547200203, -0.03559574484825134, -0.04756799712777138, -0.04126724228262901, 0.08164795488119125, 0.0019482201896607876, 0.008157881908118725, -0.05085507035255432, -0.002263213275000453, -0.021737542003393173, -0.01752375438809395, 0.005826972424983978, 0.024737965315580368, 0.0070709604769945145, -0.018300510942935944, -0.026729213073849678, -0.04105452820658684, 0.008267965167760849, -0.029144179075956345, -0.02903139404952526, -0.08468271791934967, -0.02602117322385311, -0.061987973749637604, -0.06291305273771286, 0.01648617722094059, -0.017356568947434425, 0.021757345646619797, 0.035935401916503906, -0.028237534686923027, -0.058181360363960266, 0.006958669051527977, 0.011390632949769497, 0.01868685521185398, 0.058056801557540894, 0.0015277800848707557, -0.007101455703377724, -0.01922922395169735, 0.039430372416973114, 0.010269260965287685, 0.03329389914870262, -0.035537246614694595, 0.08037091791629791, 0.012410229071974754, -0.009259486570954323, -0.04887745529413223, 0.014512673020362854, 0.06616325676441193, -0.0162716805934906, -0.022779500111937523, -0.035048358142375946, -0.004687461536377668, -0.058424871414899826, 0.019819580018520355, -0.014869311824440956, 0.03334764763712883, 0.08142468333244324, 0.019463565200567245, -0.03564345836639404, -0.024512533098459244, 0.01746353879570961, -0.0378410741686821, -0.03043774515390396, -0.07895123958587646, 0.002713665133342147, -0.016820471733808517, 0.053141895681619644, 0.012209933251142502, 0.050611164420843124, 0.04032977670431137, 0.009353379718959332, -0.013724280521273613, -0.008174257352948189, 0.08054216206073761, -0.009779310785233974, -0.025572851300239563, -0.0639820247888565, 0.014676490798592567, 0.02838057093322277, 0.0037940701004117727, 0.019501598551869392, 0.04276030510663986, 0.03278428316116333, 0.0044854613952338696, -0.04660581424832344, 0.009056284092366695, -0.046035464853048325, -0.005255277268588543, -0.017704768106341362, -0.01882104016840458, -0.01809578575193882, -0.03756939619779587, 0.027362322434782982, -0.04934021458029747, -0.040387362241744995, 0.08449392765760422, -0.016776228323578835, 0.018037745729088783, 0.030003555119037628, -0.028869278728961945, -0.004616773687303066, 0.08442739397287369, -0.016085738316178322, 0.004811941180378199, -0.01643006131052971, -0.021538158878684044, 0.05243275314569473, 0.04873093217611313, 0.018581589683890343, -0.020538082346320152, 0.0363992340862751, 0.032787736505270004, 0.06845566630363464, 0.014073203317821026, -0.06772404164075851, 0.07166009396314621, -0.006977667100727558, -0.04366178810596466, 0.023100927472114563, -0.0400056391954422, -0.0710754320025444, -0.01925445720553398, 0.05743267014622688, 0.03257469832897186, 0.029112957417964935, 0.013116762973368168, 0.02392805926501751, -0.03739108890295029, -0.019869672134518623, -0.007479112595319748, -0.01059405505657196, -0.0286482535302639, -0.0007741787121631205, 0.011232249438762665, -0.01710541360080242, 0.044738732278347015, 0.01586151123046875, 0.0075194211676716805, -0.04579415172338486, 0.0030363791156560183, -0.059078849852085114, -0.02814132161438465, -0.04183980077505112, -0.022354604676365852, -0.024310430511832237, 0.027551760897040367, 0.04073699563741684, -0.07119275629520416, -0.08758142590522766, 0.008005787618458271, 0.06164167448878288, 0.014118770137429237, 0.020043235272169113, -0.0214756540954113, -0.012521349824965, 0.0003307472507003695, 0.029556864872574806, 0.0271784458309412, 0.050384800881147385, 0.013325012288987637, 0.059073034673929214, 0.032356660813093185, 0.008457696065306664, 0.025297028943896294, -0.003037536982446909, -0.03399789333343506, -0.001208219095133245, 0.03613927587866783, -0.04577246680855751, 0.008586607873439789, 0.03540517017245293, 0.021415235474705696, 0.07635165005922318, -0.04091232270002365, 0.025420628488063812, -0.007926861755549908, 0.003621297888457775, -0.05087379738688469, -0.010537217371165752, 0.07051924616098404, -0.03834407031536102, 0.015558170154690742, -0.034637026488780975, 0.04205585643649101, 0.07436041533946991, -0.01134103536605835, 0.027670610696077347, -0.008671924471855164, 0.07013511657714844, 0.011708345264196396, 0.03142658621072769, -0.011047977954149246, -0.020312661305069923, -0.006418691016733646, 0.054443180561065674, -0.03682618960738182, 0.022874968126416206, -0.00400886544957757, -0.005604027304798365, 0.06840574741363525, -0.003100446192547679, -0.033955514430999756, -0.01921400986611843, 0.0028195870108902454, 0.008348648436367512, 0.011084146797657013, -0.027889477089047432, -0.014243191108107567, -0.00020733456767629832, -0.0216855276376009, 0.02337307669222355, 0.046657051891088486, -0.002773122861981392, 0.03213256970047951, -0.09271237254142761, 0.02731364592909813, -0.048367392271757126, 0.030752209946513176, 0.025824574753642082, -0.03131880238652229, -0.03114491142332554, 0.04980653151869774, -0.008604731410741806, 0.04968234524130821, 0.026626117527484894, 0.00513040367513895, 0.01164336409419775, -0.03722768649458885, -0.03062407672405243, 0.04451911523938179, 0.03752649202942848, -0.007456507533788681, -0.051563337445259094, 0.04470349848270416, 0.04744439944624901, -0.02206297032535076, -0.0013784391339868307, 0.05216027423739433, -0.03468586876988411, 0.018941730260849, 0.029473628848791122, 0.05970520153641701, 0.04187226668000221, -0.002701335120946169, 0.01386825367808342, 0.041153449565172195, -0.016342561691999435, -0.03671162202954292, -0.004353209398686886, 0.000800491136033088, 0.003547820495441556, 0.0005309981061145663, -0.011497368104755878, 0.05339937284588814, -0.004206366371363401, -0.007303622551262379, 0.014593598432838917, -0.0863744392991066, -0.048425495624542236, -0.006908619310706854, 0.024254240095615387, 0.055407918989658356, -0.03590105101466179, -0.06277615576982498, -0.02244408056139946, -0.029371125623583794, -0.02016536518931389, 0.014616870321333408, 0.01795353926718235, 0.03164074942469597, -0.053943902254104614, -0.061132919043302536, -0.026871100068092346, -0.024005282670259476, 0.07052045315504074, 0.013162060640752316, -0.0412801094353199, 0.024077408015727997, -0.008668075315654278, -0.02605116181075573, 0.011710572056472301, 0.021546104922890663, -0.01740875653922558, 0.024337001144886017, -0.042209602892398834, -0.07487676292657852, 0.00475333072245121, -0.01756071299314499, 0.041230250149965286, 0.04010362550616264, 0.0035544168204069138, 0.0022073062136769295, -0.034062378108501434, 0.025279153138399124, 0.05688588321208954, 0.009114573709666729, -0.00360147375613451, 0.04055767133831978, 0.010650335811078548, -0.008015232160687447, 0.049122609198093414, -0.0787367895245552, -0.040857944637537, -0.003754424164071679, 0.024315569549798965, 0.07131437212228775, 0.027409469708800316, 0.024690808728337288, 0.014731069095432758, -0.004087380599230528, -0.031687814742326736, -0.008636102080345154, -0.011005603708326817, 0.08255190402269363, 0.029451923444867134, 0.025713128969073296, -0.025077572092413902, 0.05121340975165367, 0.008491245098412037, 0.01404272299259901, 0.013055521994829178, -0.05676194280385971, 0.025337710976600647, 0.016168415546417236, 0.05056438222527504, -0.008371151052415371, 0.06308452039957047, -0.01665845699608326, -0.024183817207813263, 0.02160433493554592, 0.09605053812265396, 0.08176713436841965, -0.034612178802490234, 0.043187886476516724, 0.021319463849067688, 0.028460783883929253, -0.036718398332595825, -0.008964423090219498, 0.03084186092019081, 0.01838885061442852, -0.04018175229430199, -0.05363171175122261, -0.028112215921282768, -0.015545591711997986, 0.03465155512094498, 0.050507284700870514, 0.019305242225527763, -0.009068161249160767, -0.02883126586675644, 0.01623167283833027, 0.009328742511570454, 0.054887570440769196, -0.03797590732574463, 0.008314038626849651, -0.03429175540804863, 0.014216780662536621, 0.03817237168550491, 0.019067909568548203, 0.017999621108174324, -0.016757043078541756, -0.010334845632314682, -0.04204907640814781, -0.036213070154190063, -0.07851368933916092, 0.012163907289505005, -0.03584309294819832, 0.012863493524491787, -0.009593620896339417, -0.03802831843495369, -0.03322529047727585, -0.009534004144370556, 0.05392454192042351, 0.0011590045178309083, -0.07223841547966003, -0.037493813782930374, 0.07469739019870758, 0.039562489837408066, 0.0389147624373436, -0.010577218607068062, -0.07472195476293564, -0.046052880585193634, 0.01090154331177473, 0.02816353738307953, 0.018319571390748024, -0.024459833279252052, 0.005438678897917271, 0.002623559208586812, 0.06658635288476944, 0.02689964696764946, -0.0005172237288206816, -0.026545941829681396, 0.05710989609360695, 0.013762643560767174, 0.015320660546422005, -0.03702655807137489, 0.009138509631156921, -0.030647575855255127, -0.03365112096071243, -0.013462969101965427, -0.04140830412507057, 0.019507089629769325, 0.056849364191293716, 0.027977190911769867, 0.0529467798769474, 0.008631452918052673, 0.0035178600810468197, -0.04355553165078163, 0.014346041716635227, -0.008103196509182453, -0.021407706663012505, -0.05141352489590645, -0.013171029277145863, -0.016829948872327805, -0.026590950787067413, 0.07587853819131851, 0.03306926041841507, -0.03395846486091614, -0.007957647554576397, -0.0626123920083046, 0.018655790016055107, 0.02590043470263481, 0.03780435398221016, -0.0254580769687891, 0.011076207272708416, -0.016145585104823112, -0.006362313404679298, 0.011388156563043594, 0.030881527811288834, 0.07370737195014954, 0.0065202959813177586, -0.003165857633575797, -0.05556454136967659, -0.0045332713052630424, -0.0269840769469738, 0.023967599496245384, 0.0003998097963631153, -0.029660077765583992, -0.03436781093478203, -0.010560822673141956, -0.06731417775154114, 0.04405605047941208, 0.04207717999815941, -0.00797030609101057, -0.02191423438489437, -0.06296474486589432, 0.06008661538362503, 0.047651540488004684, -0.019233763217926025, -0.04098736494779587, 0.043185826390981674, -0.09985443949699402, 0.01789841055870056, 0.02438790537416935, 0.04088806360960007, -0.040856294333934784, 0.009776643477380276, 0.04650859534740448, 0.03393648564815521, -0.04682573303580284, 0.005091553553938866, -0.005069035571068525, 0.08544858545064926, -0.00557519169524312, -0.004776063375174999, -0.059764742851257324, -0.022422662004828453, 0.03132081404328346, -0.01830165646970272, 0.0024806365836411715, -0.012392527423799038, 0.03461374342441559, 0.0005541046848520637, 0.0165280532091856, -0.015829171985387802, 0.04329332336783409, 0.04616883024573326, -0.016738727688789368, -0.021073978394269943, 0.02443881705403328, 0.05345575138926506, -0.023007705807685852, 0.0432744137942791, 0.023060260340571404, -0.004265001974999905, -0.04586673900485039, -0.01699264720082283, 0.0015197398606687784, -0.027448220178484917, 0.021169772371649742, -0.04649430885910988, -0.04789403825998306, -0.06431066244840622, 0.0012867047917097807, -0.013270902447402477, -0.026225650683045387, -0.017609121277928352, -0.02047341875731945, -0.015789704397320747, 0.035464514046907425, -0.03675903379917145, -0.02823840267956257, 0.035996004939079285, -0.0028497702442109585, 0.007943429052829742, 0.010815923102200031, -0.018871352076530457, -0.03659101948142052, -0.012859814800322056, 0.03199857845902443, -0.021746475249528885, 0.00929663423448801, 0.012188313528895378, 0.03128005191683769, 0.0006472194218076766, 0.08866695314645767, -0.03982619568705559, 0.0004658826510421932, 0.0040578595362603664, 0.05946734920144081, -0.0008803753880783916, -0.055346012115478516, 0.07133916765451431, -0.03166051581501961, -0.0074730259366333485, 0.07302531599998474, 0.004372900817543268, -0.006623163819313049, -0.04682934656739235, -0.06588388234376907, 0.01826447807252407, -0.03455502912402153, 0.003676694817841053, 0.022900287061929703, -0.02385849319398403, -0.058706291019916534, 0.007429224438965321, -0.01156947948038578, -0.082128144800663, 0.010091661475598812, 0.0058770556934177876, 0.01654711738228798, -0.01545311976224184, -0.03463505953550339, -0.02727045863866806, 0.00664220517501235, -0.05199882388114929, -0.004826545715332031, 0.011518437415361404, -0.026990387588739395, 0.038542166352272034, 0.010439069010317326, -0.006756508257240057, -0.022412102669477463, -0.04283616691827774, -0.027131982147693634, 0.03548578545451164, 0.007874269969761372, -0.019752750173211098, 0.025116950273513794, -0.012155321426689625, -0.027961349114775658, 0.02013627253472805, -0.0072265500202775, 0.055393412709236145, -0.0048554930835962296, 0.031342003494501114, -0.018324485048651695, 0.006276994477957487, -0.03480060398578644, -0.031065059825778008, 0.012501051649451256, 0.06023086607456207, -0.033108633011579514, -0.03223424404859543, -0.03536655753850937, 0.0278011467307806, -0.033846281468868256, 0.011277136392891407, -0.00553990388289094, 0.02220093086361885, 0.0009361929260194302, -0.005477219820022583, -0.011034960858523846, 0.027159536257386208, 0.008889290504157543, 0.021082505583763123, -0.03177058696746826, 0.04949125647544861, 0.002053861739113927, 0.0075296456925570965, -0.021631978452205658, 0.02240230143070221, 0.03896763175725937, 0.020265841856598854, -0.04778385907411575, -0.019499387592077255, -0.0070345597341656685, 0.05100895091891289, -0.06109346076846123, -0.003643900156021118, -0.011403697542846203, 0.04954821988940239, -0.017633380368351936, -0.022466979920864105, -0.03429490327835083, 0.009296306408941746, -0.024751367047429085, -0.05371939390897751, -0.00024215379380621016, -0.05499020963907242, -0.06242618337273598, -0.017172683030366898, -0.0018029018538072705, -0.03720254451036453, 0.024979617446660995, 0.030067244544625282, -0.04760180413722992, 0.030314240604639053, -0.03250892460346222, -0.049244847148656845, -0.04323388636112213, -0.020853646099567413, -0.048666760325431824, 0.07248358428478241, 0.010837404988706112, 0.08092320710420609, 0.038702744990587234, -0.024548271670937538, 0.02995210327208042, 0.015551210381090641, -0.0013599710073322058, 0.009484915062785149, -0.01262607704848051, -0.022953780367970467, -0.05689371004700661, 0.02584902197122574, -0.08010480552911758, -0.02872401848435402, -0.028258049860596657, -0.08074650913476944, 0.008924312889575958, 0.07329481095075607, 0.0052320812828838825, -0.03379330039024353, 0.005966888274997473, -0.01746405102312565, 0.007994791492819786, 0.017016494646668434, 0.009118468500673771, 0.03797179087996483, 0.005199849139899015, -0.015838226303458214, -0.058767590671777725, 0.054212216287851334, 0.037556931376457214, 0.03795541077852249, -0.028864413499832153, 0.04699476435780525, -0.07497335225343704, 0.02682081237435341, 0.02643728256225586, 0.008600302040576935, -0.03421325981616974, -0.007404879201203585, 0.009190338663756847, 0.003394880797713995, -0.01927724853157997, 0.053433869034051895, 0.03221587464213371, -0.011827939189970493, 0.03376232460141182, -0.005104373209178448, -0.028759976848959923, -0.049937933683395386, 0.002528590150177479, -0.048761866986751556, -0.02158399112522602, -0.017508700489997864, -0.034595638513565063, -0.007666461635380983, -0.005147913936525583, -0.0931244045495987, 0.002140394877642393, 0.0013456791639328003, -0.02960239350795746, 0.03120681270956993, -0.05044308677315712, -0.046175502240657806, 0.018918445333838463, 0.024360308423638344, -0.009882336482405663, -0.028951872140169144, 0.0014094513608142734, 0.033796362578868866, -0.010763290338218212, -0.039043232798576355, 0.004543443210422993, 0.023374663665890694, 0.012075199745595455, 0.025609729811549187, 0.02155785821378231, 0.025013087317347527, -0.04098378121852875, -0.04249667376279831, 0.013903617858886719, 0.003695935709401965, -0.0036202010232955217, -0.005914681125432253, 0.006649964489042759, 0.010919966734945774, -0.055315129458904266, -0.01160163152962923, 0.06368615478277206, 0.009246105328202248, -0.0010797349968925118, -0.036462221294641495, -0.012388485483825207, 0.014257694594562054 ]
<p>We use ceiling and table fans in home which are can be set to low or high speeds using regulators. I want to ask that does it uses or consumes same amount of electricity at different speeds? Here, "same amount of electricity" means exactly I want to know that, my electricity bill will be different for different speeds or will it be same. I know that, when it has less speed, less electricity flows through it, but my friend told me that, when it is at less speed, the remaining electricity get wasted at regulator, so total electricity consumed by fan + regulator is same, so same electricity bill will be generated regardless on which speed we use it. So is my fried correct or wrong?</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/KB3k8.jpg" alt="image of ceiling fan with regulator"> </p>
g4058
[ 0.029304130002856255, 0.048238009214401245, -0.00891859270632267, 0.05867697298526764, 0.07716435194015503, -0.08184871822595596, 0.051884185522794724, 0.0000813230944913812, -0.04564635083079338, 0.007615591865032911, -0.040357038378715515, 0.08900369703769684, -0.03325902670621872, 0.043472614139318466, 0.01878982037305832, 0.016561537981033325, -0.0004717029514722526, -0.027605144307017326, 0.047530174255371094, 0.05501937121152878, 0.014191658236086369, 0.010616686195135117, 0.0027954624965786934, -0.08181871473789215, -0.0019384759943932295, -0.0077758049592375755, -0.05524446442723274, -0.028864815831184387, -0.06926246732473373, -0.05402062460780144, 0.0019673616625368595, 0.08152374625205994, -0.010040325112640858, -0.01934065856039524, -0.06217381730675697, -0.017542487010359764, 0.059316642582416534, -0.03377481922507286, -0.02339158020913601, 0.02995547279715538, 0.04433586820960045, -0.0237369816750288, -0.020867515355348587, -0.039035212248563766, 0.012255747802555561, 0.03197551518678665, -0.0072372183203697205, 0.016358988359570503, -0.05008179694414139, -0.0069081406109035015, -0.022828474640846252, -0.007204873953014612, -0.02624274417757988, -0.028169162571430206, -0.00441619660705328, -0.0026258304715156555, -0.03979795053601265, -0.038642190396785736, -0.005569890607148409, 0.025603847578167915, -0.07391855120658875, -0.0003917358990292996, 0.028062254190444946, 0.030398225411772728, -0.017224770039319992, 0.050260502845048904, 0.06367332488298416, -0.015359706245362759, -0.0020142740104347467, 0.019472593441605568, 0.02196435071527958, -0.025953223928809166, 0.021126465871930122, -0.031135305762290955, -0.024928731843829155, 0.019605137407779694, 0.01731320656836033, -0.06757711619138718, 0.04638036713004112, 0.05791288986802101, -0.024114252999424934, -0.017279068008065224, 0.0019819403532892466, 0.07581070810556412, -0.017167087644338608, 0.06405900418758392, -0.003441358683630824, -0.04376470297574997, 0.01969764195382595, 0.026362642645835876, 0.019406728446483612, -0.02836030162870884, 0.03663860261440277, -0.01695089228451252, -0.015148637816309929, -0.005015349946916103, 0.010718539357185364, 0.016468441113829613, 0.04790649563074112, 0.00008578064444009215, -0.030418355017900467, 0.037032414227724075, 0.041361112147569656, 0.0067733279429376125, -0.03932990878820419, 0.04502526670694351, 0.0034554791636765003, -0.023425884544849396, -0.05731574445962906, 0.0037233931943774223, 0.026926765218377113, -0.06335972994565964, -0.023258263245224953, 0.01080306526273489, -0.00047622446436434984, -0.061814531683921814, 0.07407095283269882, 0.0450340174138546, -0.0553329661488533, -0.005173238459974527, 0.029343774542212486, 0.02808433026075363, 0.033035121858119965, -0.045852333307266235, -0.024557126685976982, -0.03952917829155922, 0.004690533969551325, 0.038037095218896866, 0.006443168967962265, 0.025177830830216408, 0.01829148828983307, 0.0007274392410181463, 0.006730078719556332, 0.060170531272888184, 0.028195349499583244, -0.000846398645080626, 0.0365721732378006, -0.04518035799264908, 0.002344804583117366, -0.009324328042566776, 0.030500225722789764, -0.00020348062389530241, 0.00030292614246718585, -0.07814200222492218, -0.035349756479263306, 0.0395297035574913, -0.002046397887170315, -0.0376894474029541, 0.0024456067476421595, 0.012481527402997017, 0.04433191940188408, 0.040638670325279236, -0.030845195055007935, -0.05728410929441452, 0.031152818351984024, -0.0046949442476034164, 0.0332624651491642, 0.01728457398712635, 0.006935487501323223, 0.06771760433912277, -0.007330959662795067, 0.008128349669277668, 0.04498353227972984, 0.03254806995391846, -0.04694950580596924, -0.04709461331367493, 0.04399707540869713, 0.00661618122830987, -0.0125498715788126, -0.025633016601204872, -0.011420891620218754, 0.007258233614265919, -0.002778416033834219, -0.019664321094751358, 0.05930532515048981, -0.03056875616312027, 0.03509478271007538, -0.024853570386767387, -0.030550729483366013, -0.009670085273683071, -0.05810980126261711, -0.003426371840760112, -0.004373527131974697, -0.061442214995622635, -0.01586105115711689, 0.04498628154397011, -0.039323922246694565, -0.04398297891020775, -0.012837283313274384, 0.01240562368184328, -0.01872202567756176, -0.05002492293715477, -0.03756475821137428, 0.032901447266340256, -0.03667660802602768, 0.036502376198768616, -0.006958681624382734, 0.00858407374471426, -0.06076718866825104, -0.031080955639481544, 0.023865286260843277, 0.005256542935967445, 0.08571026474237442, 0.012084946036338806, 0.04368671029806137, 0.05252378433942795, -0.044920533895492554, -0.07123026251792908, 0.05115573853254318, 0.02601456642150879, 0.015075424686074257, -0.0021282180678099394, -0.001247689942829311, 0.07656289637088776, -0.002074877033010125, -0.0003106246585957706, -0.026414118707180023, -0.026219015941023827, -0.014782572165131569, -0.043667104095220566, -0.028887547552585602, -0.02993255853652954, 0.02972126193344593, -0.06030683219432831, -0.08698159456253052, -0.05621451511979103, 0.008876563981175423, -0.03413239121437073, 0.03263908624649048, -0.0005561442230828106, 0.08500383049249649, -0.033220961689949036, 0.005977763328701258, -0.048675864934921265, -0.00805639661848545, -0.010481017641723156, -0.013378730043768883, 0.028381463140249252, 0.024180829524993896, -0.0599333718419075, -0.0240558460354805, -0.0338626429438591, 0.016439344733953476, 0.028641242533922195, -0.012088005430996418, -0.008790399879217148, 0.03677493706345558, -0.043731678277254105, 0.042883921414613724, 0.04154343530535698, 0.02000800333917141, 0.01156933419406414, -0.009243673644959927, 0.06458694487810135, -0.04519062861800194, -0.09934248775243759, -0.007735767867416143, -0.01381266675889492, -0.0028658313676714897, -0.022111723199486732, 0.03567801043391228, 0.01101241447031498, -0.01810460537672043, 0.01365642249584198, -0.012493383139371872, -0.05452669411897659, 0.024621350690722466, -0.014861439354717731, 0.04680456221103668, -0.018525753170251846, -0.0008787367260083556, 0.043681319802999496, -0.043258123099803925, -0.002348474459722638, -0.042243119329214096, -0.037607740610837936, 0.014971154741942883, -0.0475175566971302, 0.04799099639058113, -0.004555364605039358, 0.05062565580010414, 0.01783650740981102, -0.035127196460962296, -0.01071592140942812, 0.037836696952581406, -0.030971502885222435, -0.019259918481111526, -0.02965894713997841, -0.0775204598903656, 0.08276364952325821, -0.005046218167990446, -0.02102070301771164, 0.001564921229146421, -0.02129082940518856, 0.0132113266736269, 0.037139732390642166, -0.0006839288398623466, -0.012079408392310143, -0.05712620168924332, 0.023856591433286667, -0.01144821010529995, -0.002897927537560463, -0.06506462395191193, 0.10485346615314484, -0.027946919202804565, 0.060843437910079956, -0.08745525777339935, 0.007778390310704708, 0.024757875129580498, -0.033087581396102905, 0.019583992660045624, 0.02991991490125656, 0.028594672679901123, 0.0018170848488807678, -0.026561884209513664, -0.016818271949887276, 0.016370553523302078, -0.03020998276770115, 0.005198189523071051, 0.021867340430617332, 0.04752221703529358, -0.009790705516934395, 0.027698608115315437, 0.003687144024297595, -0.12797440588474274, 0.008458496071398258, -0.00170168187469244, 0.022328732535243034, 0.03519769012928009, -0.0026157591491937637, 0.03296086937189102, -0.0020882480312138796, -0.02986997738480568, 0.00643535703420639, 0.04891078919172287, -0.024865811690688133, 0.034865058958530426, 0.04177483916282654, 0.009794109500944614, 0.022514788433909416, 0.049338776618242264, 0.03903621807694435, -0.0000996674716589041, -0.03132135048508644, -0.03102629818022251, -0.038048043847084045, 0.0003209989226888865, 0.030715016648173332, -0.07465715706348419, -0.005724010523408651, 0.04692061245441437, -0.025805676355957985, -0.034567635506391525, -0.04573353752493858, 0.0033125942572951317, -0.03594585508108139, 0.002242540940642357, 0.05160176753997803, -0.04152399301528931, 0.03125491365790367, 0.005057389382272959, -0.009827124886214733, 0.025538524612784386, 0.028791464865207672, -0.08202583342790604, 0.02958489954471588, 0.002454329514876008, -0.015065664425492287, -0.07121124118566513, -0.003229486057534814, -0.007078593596816063, 0.030033789575099945, -0.04889766871929169, 0.01577790267765522, 0.04362950101494789, -0.02895943447947502, 0.06289809197187424, 0.05126792937517166, 0.028303517028689384, 0.0674176812171936, 0.02304278314113617, -0.0035528833977878094, -0.04524149000644684, 0.01451376173645258, 0.009044216014444828, -0.012151624076068401, 0.027140755206346512, -0.010669058188796043, 0.01323310099542141, -0.049678463488817215, -0.04165373370051384, -0.00956695806235075, -0.03826497122645378, 0.0040868669748306274, 0.048548415303230286, 0.016446074470877647, 0.028202949091792107, 0.0049787601456046104, 0.05881493538618088, 0.05611703544855118, -0.041311394423246384, -0.023174388334155083, -0.014392354525625706, 0.028376838192343712, 0.02888060174882412, -0.031835101544857025, 0.03828717768192291, -0.028904784470796585, 0.029767567291855812, -0.006217490416020155, -0.049244098365306854, 0.0007010960252955556, -0.018105560913681984, 0.018977858126163483, 0.0358770526945591, 0.03820471465587616, 0.005656411871314049, 0.004604806192219257, 0.05082310363650322, -0.005455806851387024, 0.007254443597048521, -0.006723042577505112, -0.02240089140832424, -0.04367722570896149, -0.002813454018905759, 0.005193538963794708, 0.07295338809490204, 0.027843447402119637, -0.06038149818778038, 0.004303340800106525, 0.025051767006516457, 0.012250345200300217, -0.00138690450694412, -0.007116074673831463, 0.005834203213453293, 0.018307363614439964, 0.05154663696885109, 0.04782770946621895, 0.02770392596721649, -0.013184329494833946, 0.050653424113988876, -0.010952390730381012, -0.0007805904024280608, 0.012311898171901703, -0.027504026889801025, 0.026481209322810173, -0.05870441719889641, -0.025969000533223152, -0.009735118597745895, -0.023448728024959564, -0.054522555321455, 0.039105191826820374, -0.03729325160384178, -0.028859930112957954, -0.04090781509876251, 0.0069931549951434135, 0.010848063044250011, -0.032539717853069305, 0.08030318468809128, -0.026692330837249756, -0.030565278604626656, 0.04669054597616196, 0.04360063374042511, 0.0025664737913757563, -0.022726142778992653, -0.00536964600905776, -0.03062612935900688, 0.03486363962292671, -0.053857579827308655, -0.0033365499693900347, 0.03462018817663193, -0.034850310534238815, -0.04187888279557228, 0.03134920820593834, 0.04638933762907982, 0.022194210439920425, 0.042465828359127045, 0.002313400385901332, -0.028606552630662918, -0.00947275385260582, -0.028412554413080215, -0.017105484381318092, 0.007385868113487959, -0.03427842631936073, 0.01311530638486147, -0.056716181337833405, -0.04540790989995003, 0.00802571140229702, 0.053884729743003845, -0.03921325504779816, -0.028981374576687813, 0.07506302744150162, -0.039677754044532776, -0.028461769223213196, -0.016268979758024216, 0.044060394167900085, 0.023892659693956375, -0.043429840356111526, -0.049052972346544266, -0.0042742653749883175, 0.05772309750318527, 0.042451098561286926, -0.034517623484134674, -0.03329234942793846, 0.03719267621636391, 0.08216977119445801, 0.013853970915079117, -0.011762614361941814, -0.0063717905431985855, 0.020034844055771828, -0.041218921542167664, 0.06498123705387115, 0.02624981477856636, 0.0625576600432396, 0.014077844098210335, -0.007286878302693367, 0.026479309424757957, 0.007975991815328598, -0.01470758393406868, -0.022794080898165703, 0.018437320366501808, -0.010866831988096237, 0.03553450107574463, 0.013403412885963917, -0.0319797545671463, 0.004873752593994141, -0.03262373432517052, 0.027561327442526817, 0.024738837033510208, -0.0043727681040763855, 0.003170599229633808, 0.019151637330651283, -0.058900997042655945, -0.019600652158260345, -0.036787159740924835, 0.038616642355918884, -0.03689832612872124, -0.022068295627832413, 0.05301103740930557, 0.0020231083035469055, 0.012278799898922443, -0.008521998301148415, 0.05264716222882271, 0.00036056595854461193, 0.0678330510854721, -0.028518540784716606, -0.009893467649817467, 0.02441004477441311, -0.03152112662792206, 0.06708833575248718, 0.019101670011878014, 0.031268853694200516, -0.001972953323274851, 0.02710885927081108, 0.007977614179253578, 0.03534264490008354, 0.06503128260374069, 0.007999303750693798, -0.010694106109440327, -0.027287231758236885, 0.028277253732085228, 0.04573768004775047, 0.03468732535839081, -0.03650025650858879, 0.05917080491781235, -0.0498557910323143, 0.00885687954723835, 0.016071178019046783, 0.017668647691607475, 0.027011489495635033, 0.051332324743270874, -0.059725403785705566, 0.024312732741236687, 0.002254127524793148, 0.025839390233159065, 0.020029813051223755, 0.0029009676072746515, -0.02588365599513054, -0.012719144113361835, -0.03328755870461464, 0.05976780503988266, -0.07528503984212875, -0.04616966098546982, -0.0437847301363945, 0.09473295509815216, 0.029269862920045853, -0.015701092779636383, 0.010483670979738235, 0.006528784520924091, 0.041482165455818176, -0.03971901908516884, -0.005297054536640644, 0.08277557045221329, 0.017100337892770767, 0.027577506378293037, 0.024977771565318108, -0.044384609907865524, -0.022978391498327255, -0.015884218737483025, 0.00017220106383319944, -0.03730153664946556, -0.01470666192471981, 0.019217297434806824, -0.054076556116342545, -0.03459688276052475, 0.03725966438651085, 0.01930740475654602, 0.0030063732992857695, -0.04270532354712486, -0.012089304625988007, -0.06770014017820358, 0.01714961789548397, 0.058407772332429886, -0.03164205327630043, -0.015612449496984482, -0.04005187377333641, -0.03255730867385864, -0.024021953344345093, -0.015043690800666809, 0.02060636319220066, 0.02800401858985424, -0.01641773246228695, -0.02345534786581993, -0.10447219759225845, 0.06612525880336761, 0.055294446647167206, 0.031757254153490067, 0.057022809982299805, 0.022161656990647316, 0.013717730529606342, -0.0521928034722805, 0.007454246282577515, -0.05082152411341667, -0.0005560017307288945, 0.03387618437409401, 0.03717238828539848, -0.0035788838285952806, -0.005153002683073282, 0.049513187259435654, 0.0619966946542263, 0.02170782908797264, 0.014398020692169666, -0.0408889465034008, 0.04410294443368912, -0.03344203159213066, -0.036359116435050964, 0.000299433566397056, -0.06643064320087433, -0.004743342287838459, 0.004149317741394043, -0.039106789976358414, 0.017541471868753433, -0.03991963714361191, 0.021566839888691902, -0.0008926291484385729, -0.011396711692214012, 0.0258279200643301, 0.004281444009393454, -0.04094140976667404, -0.004928980953991413, -0.010204264894127846, -0.04172239452600479, -0.00749905314296484, 0.07497386634349823, -0.017298195511102676, -0.044924814254045486, -0.008071225136518478, -0.006803857162594795, -0.02509382739663124, -0.05994224175810814, 0.0005507536116056144, -0.11048060655593872, -0.027540400624275208, 0.006263538263738155, -0.007140421774238348, 0.005320433527231216, -0.02297220751643181, 0.009550590999424458, 0.007935948669910431, -0.06115531921386719, 0.022672967985272408, 0.03489675745368004, 0.04605184495449066, -0.017564620822668076, 0.02619578316807747, -0.017119403928518295, -0.05103819817304611, -0.07706635445356369, 0.027988728135824203, -0.04156418889760971, -0.005782599560916424, -0.01352629717439413, 0.06284847855567932, 0.005132799036800861, -0.06520697474479675, 0.01681165024638176, 0.0032155534718185663, -0.0028090626001358032, -0.06424872577190399, 0.012927819974720478, 0.004693350289016962, 0.06690201163291931, 0.0247367974370718, -0.003167847404256463, -0.0007104044780135155, 0.01602909341454506, 0.01478088553994894, 0.016251107677817345, -0.06452420353889465, 0.03191778063774109, -0.05528046563267708, -0.021252932026982307, 0.02505909651517868, 0.050234485417604446, 0.029419202357530594, -0.007556566037237644, 0.02650340460240841, -0.045059602707624435, 0.001962879206985235, 0.003247631946578622, -0.007707411888986826, -0.004653237760066986, -0.028479142114520073, -0.061403870582580566, 0.003967347089201212, -0.003736341604962945, -0.017721613869071007, 0.023275161162018776, -0.008162414655089378, 0.047621771693229675, -0.0181778222322464, -0.0015862409491091967, 0.0010382110485807061, 0.011930261738598347, -0.019251225516200066, 0.014843087643384933, 0.02911727875471115, 0.030054111033678055, 0.024471117183566093, -0.024410158395767212, -0.012553040869534016, 0.012202098034322262, -0.02460480108857155, 0.04623723030090332, -0.0068923598155379295, 0.0031481983605772257, -0.04578583687543869, -0.05104788392782211, 0.06196241080760956, -0.04149569571018219, 0.05520667880773544, -0.047595009207725525, -0.040807850658893585, 0.04939257353544235, 0.01766361854970455, -0.02845674380660057, 0.021053073927760124, 0.01508349645882845, -0.06184752285480499, 0.0522710345685482, 0.01605566032230854, -0.05225538834929466, 0.010823152028024197, -0.03486194089055061, -0.006653024349361658, 0.005835114978253841, 0.03360044211149216, -0.013288941234350204 ]
<p>I am experimenting and playing around with some data, and I'm having trouble seeing how to generate invariant mass plots.</p> <p>The data I have has a bunch of events, and variables such as $P,P_T,\eta,\phi$ etc.. but no energy. There is a histogram which generates the invariant mass, but no macro provided for this. For example, I know there are tracks for electrons and protons (TPC), and I want to see if there are any pairs as a result of $\gamma\rightarrow e^+ e^-$. Conceptually I need to loop over all positive negative pairs, and plot the histogram. I should get a peak around zero for $\gamma$ pair production. The invariant mass formula is $$m_\gamma^2 = (E_{e^+}+E_{e^-})^2 - (\vec{p}_{e^+}+\vec{p}_{e^-})^2$$</p> <p>But there is no data for the energy, how do the high energy physicists do it? Do they guess some value for the energy and make plots with that guess?</p>
g4059
[ 0.011046145111322403, 0.0021134670823812485, -0.013798682019114494, -0.03724277392029762, -0.005449702963232994, 0.031105004251003265, 0.0019653255585581064, 0.04889114946126938, -0.08380579948425293, 0.00315694697201252, 0.006487611681222916, 0.017789633944630623, 0.00798601284623146, -0.007166673429310322, -0.020783452317118645, -0.027758890762925148, 0.07345914095640182, -0.0060040028765797615, 0.011292234994471073, 0.05908932909369469, 0.02908685803413391, -0.017674842849373817, -0.00951301958411932, -0.00932820700109005, 0.06672824174165726, -0.007780653424561024, 0.059900060296058655, -0.0035906571429222822, -0.00256350333802402, 0.01354614831507206, 0.013172391802072525, 0.014663868583738804, 0.0467703603208065, 0.020363545045256615, -0.0009836816461756825, -0.024141116067767143, -0.013275648467242718, 0.029243309050798416, 0.026866653934121132, 0.01970905438065529, -0.006501940079033375, -0.023130040615797043, 0.009873135946691036, 0.000608764763455838, -0.03298613056540489, 0.05415283516049385, 0.010772407986223698, -0.00023917922226246446, -0.04041248932480812, -0.014253399334847927, 0.01867441087961197, 0.028419986367225647, 0.07740859687328339, -0.0654873326420784, 0.011274597607553005, 0.05869877338409424, 0.017060916870832443, 0.004113820847123861, 0.08062343299388885, 0.004504490178078413, 0.021532192826271057, 0.0010661488631740212, 0.04565352573990822, -0.013114120811223984, 0.06792216747999191, 0.011563923209905624, -0.10933221131563187, 0.005357345100492239, -0.003811691189184785, -0.021658845245838165, -0.03647669777274132, 0.028013281524181366, -0.004654936492443085, 0.0331634059548378, -0.010637667961418629, -0.01862219348549843, -0.02130740135908127, 0.02590644732117653, -0.03213944286108017, -0.031971096992492676, 0.011157358065247536, 0.024183597415685654, -0.019215665757656097, 0.0012764292769134045, 0.056358080357313156, -0.044836025685071945, -0.0047471784055233, -0.01812330260872841, -0.032804541289806366, 0.004163882229477167, 0.040442246943712234, 0.027495982125401497, 0.03204985335469246, 0.029144713655114174, 0.011751996353268623, -0.004646454472094774, -0.05515071004629135, 0.07381096482276917, -0.023179199546575546, -0.009623530320823193, -0.007771152537316084, 0.05818060785531998, 0.04056774824857712, -0.036411844193935394, -0.02519313618540764, 0.0030954726971685886, -0.004188942722976208, -0.019314061850309372, 0.06191754713654518, -0.013632707297801971, -0.01727334037423134, 0.01488056592643261, -0.06399010866880417, 0.02287408709526062, -0.07348630577325821, -0.05681321397423744, 0.0784105584025383, -0.015645937994122505, -0.061001986265182495, 0.07862624526023865, 0.008316894993185997, -0.0040111662819981575, -0.03449379280209541, 0.041818879544734955, -0.048354484140872955, -0.009665538556873798, -0.03461746498942375, 0.0397232249379158, 0.04153703898191452, -0.001242379774339497, -0.009534485638141632, -0.09819217771291733, 0.005136036314070225, 0.04468745365738869, 0.007972769439220428, 0.00812370702624321, -0.004814292769879103, 0.061077434569597244, 0.018815405666828156, 0.01565142348408699, -0.03616122156381607, -0.01688995398581028, -0.05520331859588623, -0.01740029826760292, 0.008836347609758377, -0.014603674411773682, -0.03959256038069725, -0.051457878202199936, 0.03843109682202339, 0.03889772295951843, 0.009155246429145336, 0.04745597392320633, -0.04132881015539169, -0.028250113129615784, 0.04478419944643974, -0.016122136265039444, 0.009016801603138447, -0.020840611308813095, -0.022143099457025528, 0.024243583902716637, 0.0518205352127552, -0.032491981983184814, 0.08519355952739716, -0.055962130427360535, 0.024591514840722084, 0.0013619163073599339, 0.04492426663637161, -0.007548753637820482, -0.013574312441051006, -0.02127610519528389, -0.06116819381713867, -0.004303865600377321, 0.03448403626680374, -0.022271767258644104, -0.011075010523200035, 0.042303215712308884, -0.02482556365430355, 0.00037052936386317015, 0.0824885293841362, 0.04622868821024895, 0.0106417341157794, -0.016719575971364975, 0.056109264492988586, -0.003626602003350854, 0.02615814097225666, 0.005115577485412359, 0.0323067270219326, 0.015685860067605972, -0.012001639232039452, 0.03011390008032322, 0.005231671500951052, -0.01354206819087267, -0.03412678837776184, 0.013165673241019249, 0.007498597726225853, 0.004065089859068394, 0.018351444974541664, -0.03054562583565712, -0.006367481779307127, 0.028074542060494423, -0.0368066243827343, 0.0047177718952298164, -0.010540536604821682, -0.0050293756648898125, -0.06471280753612518, -0.026330148801207542, 0.026288500055670738, -0.034616176038980484, -0.029462024569511414, 0.007926502265036106, 0.0010853124549612403, -0.022477542981505394, 0.0051580374129116535, -0.005511726252734661, -0.03189310431480408, 0.017054947093129158, -0.015128688886761665, -0.07455956190824509, 0.01985659822821617, -0.021978404372930527, -0.004836004227399826, -0.02963234856724739, -0.03016769140958786, 0.05343034490942955, 0.00810816790908575, 0.031365927308797836, 0.032447006553411484, -0.014760125428438187, -0.032955460250377655, -0.008603096939623356, -0.021961813792586327, 0.06288118660449982, -0.015644216910004616, -0.042152490466833115, 0.024186259135603905, -0.005045399535447359, 0.009229157119989395, 0.02008524164557457, -0.0027959709987044334, 0.005267748609185219, 0.010550390928983688, -0.07953193783760071, -0.002839210908859968, -0.01539495587348938, 0.043999992311000824, -0.02944832108914852, 0.0635392814874649, 0.0071505047380924225, -0.0032583686988800764, 0.02335304580628872, 0.0019527270924299955, 0.0023665702901780605, 0.0005512934876605868, -0.0006149643450044096, 0.016897058114409447, -0.039041291922330856, -0.04207977280020714, 0.022702600806951523, -0.07066217809915543, 0.03380066901445389, -0.021447855979204178, -0.03514742851257324, 0.009380278177559376, 0.016626393422484398, -0.057205889374017715, -0.048927128314971924, 0.03942471370100975, -0.08640576153993607, -0.019604647532105446, -0.02047368884086609, -0.03952817618846893, 0.017415067180991173, 0.032700713723897934, 0.01795831508934498, -0.013120095245540142, -0.058618951588869095, 0.06515569239854813, 0.03401688486337662, 0.012945144437253475, -0.05852501094341278, 0.005960720591247082, 0.01994527317583561, -0.012651157565414906, 0.03652838245034218, 0.018358012661337852, -0.01943160966038704, -0.00013547271373681724, -0.0107795475050807, 0.023408744484186172, 0.008349226787686348, -0.011683713644742966, -0.06961993873119354, 0.0328126959502697, -0.013319025747478008, -0.0644751638174057, 0.005904838442802429, 0.03127874806523323, -0.02632894180715084, 0.023858020082116127, 0.008553877472877502, -0.004157781135290861, 0.03686821088194847, 0.0031633542384952307, -0.022312868386507034, 0.011424875818192959, -0.03114568628370762, -0.006310946308076382, -0.04728618636727333, -0.0515563040971756, 0.004745459649711847, 0.00474470155313611, 0.028882848098874092, 0.00669555040076375, -0.008029709570109844, 0.010645950213074684, 0.037781547755002975, -0.007101915776729584, -0.03618919104337692, -0.03642149642109871, -0.06347844004631042, -0.024275708943605423, -0.03415544703602791, 0.09736884385347366, -0.0054068900644779205, -0.04074091464281082, -0.022679315879940987, 0.0376417450606823, -0.0023697263095527887, -0.05141965299844742, -0.00689247902482748, 0.00003921997995348647, 0.027082335203886032, -0.006833669263869524, 0.051423944532871246, 0.012868749909102917, -0.024526508525013924, -0.032972827553749084, -0.040974538773298264, 0.05025365203619003, 0.014740712940692902, -0.08732769638299942, 0.0035432823933660984, -0.054963432252407074, -0.03866619989275932, -0.045552972704172134, 0.014709879644215107, 0.012133867479860783, -0.03646160662174225, 0.017164966091513634, -0.10927947610616684, 0.01651734486222267, -0.0044507719576358795, 0.020613141357898712, -0.007963691838085651, -0.021290559321641922, 0.0018722276436164975, 0.022295372560620308, -0.058591268956661224, 0.03503160923719406, 0.006989662069827318, -0.02838210202753544, -0.014249568805098534, -0.05464189499616623, -0.030847148969769478, -0.02298426441848278, 0.011884142644703388, -0.09134773164987564, 0.03617178276181221, 0.036211539059877396, -0.03279952332377434, 0.024115843698382378, -0.010153904557228088, 0.08440616726875305, -0.007994960993528366, -0.05058533325791359, -0.06425673514604568, -0.014468834735453129, 0.0044277748093008995, -0.026504186913371086, 0.028642451390624046, -0.004634416196495295, -0.06687037646770477, 0.05691076070070267, 0.04990258067846298, 0.009621561504900455, 0.014910819940268993, -0.0018929068464785814, 0.016394320875406265, 0.01828746870160103, -0.010734661482274532, 0.03404993936419487, -0.049978721886873245, -0.05713016167283058, 0.05872969329357147, 0.023309985175728798, -0.09711527079343796, 0.056775178760290146, 0.02454245463013649, -0.005634506233036518, 0.05254335328936577, 0.003387847449630499, 0.0010459467303007841, 0.0166789460927248, -0.03832630068063736, -0.0005363410455174744, -0.002420124365016818, -0.05487009510397911, -0.014976744540035725, 0.033045392483472824, -0.03799333795905113, 0.00809424463659525, -0.031868595629930496, 0.0687035620212555, -0.07757443189620972, 0.02683906815946102, 0.008999576792120934, -0.01314820908010006, -0.028756415471434593, 0.01608654111623764, 0.01596844382584095, -0.01975800096988678, 0.006230174098163843, 0.01479062158614397, -0.045000191777944565, -0.044071342796087265, 0.110448457300663, 0.02385491319000721, -0.041994959115982056, 0.03972300514578819, -0.0022567131090909243, 0.025646785274147987, 0.018516352400183678, 0.010084892623126507, 0.024284081533551216, -0.03209520876407623, -0.006319606676697731, -0.014646521769464016, -0.01119975559413433, 0.021070338785648346, 0.021755192428827286, 0.046678170561790466, -0.020161112770438194, -0.016602393239736557, -0.025270996615290642, -0.06894038617610931, 0.07145152240991592, 0.007575776893645525, -0.03903517127037048, -0.046797093003988266, 0.010802913457155228, 0.015935556963086128, -0.017863228917121887, -0.050364404916763306, -0.012574948370456696, 0.013350670225918293, -0.02790364995598793, -0.02343624085187912, 0.051574453711509705, 0.05683910846710205, 0.04702189937233925, -0.02541171759366989, -0.005679312162101269, 0.018178218975663185, 0.003829097840934992, 0.010829087346792221, -0.04796009883284569, -0.07256462424993515, -0.01411144994199276, 0.012491989880800247, 0.012137195095419884, -0.02876347117125988, 0.03980325534939766, 0.012224705889821053, -0.05159025266766548, 0.03568647801876068, -0.02562767080962658, -0.022474784404039383, -0.015856662765145302, -0.0050713373348116875, -0.020757945254445076, -0.014363507740199566, 0.057616449892520905, -0.001483420841395855, 0.025948652997612953, 0.04710281640291214, 0.02262643538415432, -0.021563146263360977, 0.037466492503881454, 0.048903875052928925, 0.02696816436946392, 0.002390659414231777, -0.018174005672335625, 0.06333944946527481, -0.03246932104229927, -0.009035826660692692, -0.07568397372961044, -0.048657432198524475, -0.0016943581867963076, -0.0005158954882062972, -0.02313639223575592, -0.015927113592624664, 0.017914025112986565, -0.042009346187114716, 0.029103485867381096, 0.030263619497418404, 0.00284447125159204, 0.03827289119362831, -0.012480979785323143, 0.047456830739974976, 0.028947610408067703, -0.03919144719839096, 0.024736283347010612, 0.05448164418339729, -0.010694100521504879, -0.008149703964591026, -0.003636786248534918, -0.02914150431752205, 0.038101352751255035, -0.06811507791280746, -0.06891749799251556, 0.05016207695007324, -0.003635113127529621, 0.05975355952978134, 0.017458582296967506, 0.1182020977139473, -0.02009737305343151, -0.053957175463438034, -0.036791183054447174, 0.03164120391011238, -0.010593855753540993, 0.02123127318918705, -0.06732174754142761, -0.027976838871836662, -0.016000861302018166, 0.030774075537919998, 0.025157300755381584, -0.0052123283967375755, 0.005315427668392658, 0.005943038035184145, 0.031061971560120583, -0.006470813881605864, -0.011379475705325603, 0.01175754051655531, 0.03923602029681206, -0.038111552596092224, -0.02303309738636017, -0.010388526134192944, -0.02693242020905018, 0.04107297956943512, -0.016138646751642227, -0.057006627321243286, -0.011638849973678589, 0.05095446854829788, -0.03154508396983147, -0.05065298080444336, 0.04236762225627899, 0.027364203706383705, -0.011709611862897873, -0.022112999111413956, 0.010563582181930542, 0.015910374000668526, 0.050414957106113434, 0.059914395213127136, 0.10005653649568558, 0.015277902595698833, 0.019643310457468033, 0.0005510671762749553, -0.010048847645521164, -0.05938314273953438, 0.005656261462718248, 0.022458679974079132, 0.03642544150352478, 0.027339071035385132, 0.0810953676700592, 0.024063443765044212, 0.05970768630504608, 0.02486099675297737, -0.012890453450381756, 0.0047084977850317955, 0.021075747907161713, -0.007420613430440426, 0.02836639992892742, 0.008405517786741257, -0.018748316913843155, 0.0038634634111076593, 0.0019452990964055061, 0.020307309925556183, -0.016390711069107056, 0.00109374662861228, 0.005898043047636747, -0.10030095279216766, 0.002221151255071163, -0.006057398859411478, -0.004558648448437452, -0.028416331857442856, 0.0014356834581121802, -0.05498640611767769, -0.027614064514636993, -0.005353795364499092, -0.011371767148375511, -0.026293734088540077, 0.0398670919239521, 0.046174366027116776, -0.02186412177979946, -0.04467453062534332, -0.05818495526909828, -0.0423775352537632, 0.035930175334215164, -0.04550847411155701, 0.0013673065695911646, -0.038091182708740234, 0.010717482306063175, -0.013297893106937408, 0.030989348888397217, 0.002165843266993761, -0.0030418450478464365, 0.018262356519699097, 0.05800909548997879, -0.06466386467218399, -0.02135862037539482, -0.0001305368059547618, 0.0024953584652394056, 0.033079035580158234, -0.04648532345890999, 0.05782046914100647, 0.054427362978458405, 0.01212160661816597, 0.020986946299672127, 0.03801281005144119, -0.021351201459765434, -0.03363057225942612, 0.05149533972144127, -0.016295569017529488, 0.03257834166288376, -0.035146769136190414, 0.017390474677085876, -0.043987274169921875, 0.13809968531131744, 0.07086847722530365, 0.036991607397794724, 0.0068127172999084, 0.02385343238711357, 0.029900195077061653, -0.03481973707675934, -0.08118875324726105, 0.014525291509926319, 0.024470558390021324, -0.00046453546383418143, -0.05177140608429909, -0.034973327070474625, -0.004318092484027147, -0.036732837557792664, -0.027082648128271103, -0.008724684827029705, -0.0054461099207401276, 0.06010168790817261, 0.008191113360226154, 0.03273165225982666, 0.04886401817202568, -0.0011376329930499196, -0.03164370357990265, -0.005001482553780079, 0.024440163746476173, -0.019974570721387863, 0.06744273006916046, 0.06265149265527725, -0.016017017886042595, -0.0271541066467762, 0.032808542251586914, -0.025321049615740776, 0.022704429924488068, -0.0555478073656559, -0.009886917658150196, 0.06394561380147934, 0.00932295247912407, -0.025953030213713646, -0.002006569877266884, 0.042030587792396545, -0.012527556158602238, 0.0013362333411350846, -0.06750429421663284, -0.021736694499850273, -0.03761281818151474, 0.006292093079537153, -0.0060077267698943615, 0.017164086923003197, -0.054743826389312744, 0.03218588978052139, -0.05872100591659546, 0.033350467681884766, -0.04658060148358345, -0.0016355550615116954, 0.028570400550961494, -0.03423309326171875, -0.035140108317136765, -0.008248311467468739, -0.008803271688520908, 0.0236747395247221, 0.030111180618405342, -0.0165385901927948, 0.04537206143140793, 0.0005166045157238841, 0.0015038310084491968, 0.012931493110954762, 0.03569602966308594, 0.0039051990024745464, 0.0196680910885334, -0.07599799335002899, -0.001115333870984614, 0.000850881333462894, 0.0051482366397976875, 0.03983558714389801, -0.05606286600232124, 0.027480890974402428, 0.013812617398798466, -0.013327721506357193, -0.07755447924137115, 0.005027176812291145, 0.034141767770051956, 0.03413039445877075, -0.06529532372951508, -0.004684812854975462, -0.004398328252136707, -0.02720850519835949, 0.0625457614660263, -0.01809590682387352, -0.0055598309263587, 0.036057647317647934, 0.015110548585653305, 0.034317053854465485, -0.015508233569562435, 0.025753116235136986, -0.030904218554496765, 0.05776171013712883, -0.0531684048473835, -0.042939573526382446, -0.005153013858944178, -0.0061224037781357765, -0.049837373197078705, 0.02749788388609886, 0.01154175866395235, -0.09090317040681839, -0.03789123520255089, -0.007072769105434418, 0.02628503181040287, 0.02028745785355568, 0.013273346237838268, 0.030312184244394302, 0.08332165330648422, -0.04904862865805626, 0.020675336942076683, -0.00889037549495697, -0.059421200305223465, 0.0589337982237339, 0.04695574566721916, -0.0262539591640234, 0.08971083164215088, -0.039112310856580734, 0.04874080419540405, 0.023421775549650192, 0.02105136588215828, 0.012225691229104996, -0.04151641204953194, -0.0020613998640328646, -0.01910359039902687, -0.012005929835140705, 0.044568054378032684, -0.010581549257040024 ]
<p>Suppose we are given two conducting, cocentric spheres of radius $a_1$ and $a_2$ respectively. The inner sphere with charge $q$, the outer sphere with charge $-q$.</p> <p>I can calculate the capacitance of this system by calculating the potential difference $U$ between the plates and then use the definition $C = q / U$. This is easy enough and indeed gives me the right result</p> <p>$$C = \dfrac{4\pi \epsilon_0}{a_1^{-1} - a_2^{-1}}$$</p> <p>But now I tried to caluclate $C$ by finding out the energy stored in the system in two different ways: First we have the expression $$W_{el} = \frac12 \frac {q^2}C$$ for the energy stored in any capacitor. Now I wanted to compare this to the energy stored in the electric field (since that's where the energy is, right?!) $$E(r) = \begin{cases}\frac1{4\pi \epsilon_0} \frac q{r^2} &amp; a_1 &lt; r &lt; a_2 \\ 0 &amp; \text{otherwise}\end{cases}$$ to derive the above formula for $C$ again. The energy density is $w_{el} = \frac {\epsilon_0} 2 E^2$, therefore the energy stored in the electric field is \begin{eqnarray*} W_{el} &amp;=&amp; \int w_{el} \;\mathrm{d}V \\ &amp;=&amp; 4\pi \int_{a_1}^{a_2} \frac{\epsilon_0}2 \left(\frac1{4\pi \epsilon_0} \frac q{r^2}\right)^2 r \; \mathrm dr \\ &amp;=&amp; \frac1{4\pi \epsilon_0}\frac{q^2}{2} \int_{a_1}^{a_2} \frac{\mathrm d r}{r^3} \\ &amp;=&amp; \frac1{4\pi \epsilon_0}\frac{q^2}{2} \frac14\left(\frac 1{a_1^4} - \frac1{a_2^4} \right) \end{eqnarray*}</p> <p>Comparing the two expressions gives </p> <p>$$C = \dfrac{16\pi \epsilon_0}{a_1^{-4} - a_2^{-4}}$$</p> <p>So my question is: Why is this wrong? Where is the energy in this capacitor stored, if not in the electric field (as it doesn't seem to be - unless I have made a mistake in deriving the result somewhere...)?</p> <p><strong>Edit:</strong> I also noticed, that the second result can be rewritten as</p> <p>$$C = \dfrac{4\pi \epsilon_0}{a_1^{-1} - a_2^{-1}}\frac 4{a_1^{-3} + a_1^{-2}a_2^{-1} + a_1^{-1}a_2^{-2} + a_2^{-3}}$$</p> <p>but I don't know whether this has any significance.</p> <p>Thanks for reading and any help will be greatly appreciated! :)</p>
g4060
[ 0.029353490099310875, 0.014764630235731602, -0.015253804624080658, -0.046828944236040115, 0.04651845991611481, 0.01367499865591526, 0.03389802575111389, -0.022409901022911072, -0.05632176622748375, 0.024392837658524513, -0.034117717295885086, 0.05401243269443512, 0.02341468818485737, -0.0020105226431041956, 0.007157301530241966, 0.028575610369443893, 0.08494188636541367, 0.00988064520061016, 0.0017685361672192812, -0.007832523435354233, -0.06706330925226212, -0.0538409948348999, 0.014365156181156635, -0.0021431432105600834, -0.004028613213449717, -0.02862253412604332, -0.010443056002259254, 0.023142332211136818, -0.05675569921731949, -0.06473879516124725, 0.02016410604119301, 0.020472994074225426, 0.07912670075893402, -0.049272798001766205, -0.03286304697394371, 0.02908954955637455, 0.08291833102703094, 0.053989607840776443, -0.016284924000501633, -0.013111413456499577, 0.006339608691632748, -0.026965731754899025, 0.06984715908765793, 0.042768023908138275, 0.025074977427721024, -0.055373627692461014, -0.025111328810453415, 0.005806765519082546, -0.039545297622680664, -0.04598912596702576, 0.010913664475083351, 0.0584549605846405, 0.05254911258816719, -0.004602959379553795, 0.015552358701825142, -0.0358157679438591, 0.02545754797756672, -0.015021491795778275, 0.05258213356137276, 0.04237492009997368, 0.06787542253732681, -0.004161348100751638, -0.00551192183047533, 0.016794323921203613, 0.02637013979256153, -0.05442088469862938, 0.010450785979628563, -0.00021287532581482083, -0.042748093605041504, -0.022629596292972565, -0.016819722950458527, -0.06861262023448944, 0.01910438761115074, -0.060851339250802994, 0.00015292585885617882, -0.03427395597100258, 0.045318130403757095, 0.006251136306673288, 0.0005219525774009526, -0.03805704042315483, -0.015967505052685738, -0.01122474204748869, 0.03681217506527901, -0.0062014758586883545, 0.013548682443797588, -0.01662750355899334, -0.012093343771994114, -0.007197672501206398, -0.034139495342969894, 0.01380089856684208, 0.007232778239995241, -0.008204024285078049, 0.050385694950819016, -0.012682885862886906, -0.009601175785064697, 0.020395252853631973, 0.008563878946006298, 0.022825229912996292, -0.039412323385477066, 0.02285141311585903, -0.005411663558334112, 0.01617521606385708, 0.015415351837873459, 0.03500723838806152, 0.017996979877352715, -0.002686718013137579, 0.0345955565571785, -0.01921069622039795, -0.012090262956917286, -0.032358113676309586, -0.029874049127101898, -0.009937436319887638, 0.013450471684336662, -0.013836659491062164, -0.021034827455878258, 0.0015001462306827307, 0.07030487060546875, -0.03546007350087166, 0.041141968220472336, 0.04492595046758652, -0.022199537605047226, -0.004569533746689558, 0.03549026697874069, 0.020068006590008736, 0.019925560802221298, 0.0145562794059515, 0.055879637598991394, 0.008152862079441547, 0.016690416261553764, -0.021308254450559616, 0.022327637299895287, -0.007163120433688164, 0.019623510539531708, 0.0004011123673990369, -0.00820990651845932, 0.006123862229287624, -0.01287924125790596, -0.003574991598725319, 0.003989511635154486, -0.013170476071536541, -0.013633908703923225, -0.02229003608226776, -0.006184845697134733, -0.00842598732560873, -0.054721783846616745, 0.01653001643717289, -0.016816793009638786, -0.07800967991352081, 0.03746233135461807, -0.005228311289101839, 0.052001263946294785, 0.07050658017396927, -0.03139350563287735, 0.010929015465080738, 0.024448059499263763, -0.0021932395175099373, 0.03735717386007309, 0.005572212859988213, 0.03667778521776199, 0.00609741173684597, 0.008910123258829117, 0.024892009794712067, 0.0427914522588253, 0.03524642810225487, -0.01988862454891205, 0.001678704866208136, 0.02734462544322014, -0.010353652760386467, -0.02081846073269844, -0.10267718881368637, 0.030370386317372322, -0.04549745097756386, 0.04222960025072098, 0.011132974177598953, -0.02006746456027031, 0.0718589723110199, 0.04219669848680496, -0.001150142983533442, 0.02791914902627468, 0.011324943043291569, -0.022226866334676743, 0.014082390815019608, 0.006781355477869511, -0.011323380284011364, -0.004161100368946791, -0.013252800330519676, 0.03802603483200073, 0.04394153133034706, -0.02601083368062973, 0.029329832643270493, -0.07729361206293106, 0.01065125036984682, -0.048904094845056534, 0.05494023114442825, 0.0036815605126321316, 0.03525283932685852, 0.051239363849163055, -0.04600556939840317, -0.0395219586789608, -0.010230718180537224, 0.02942228876054287, -0.006636912003159523, 0.02578841522336006, -0.008093072101473808, 0.06756290048360825, 0.018102144822478294, 0.009183361195027828, -0.05150541290640831, 0.055865805596113205, 0.006097658537328243, -0.025949614122509956, -0.0074980841018259525, -0.04780624434351921, 0.03910112380981445, 0.020622851327061653, -0.03422711044549942, -0.012503866106271744, -0.008233192376792431, -0.07144541293382645, 0.008398586884140968, -0.062084708362817764, -0.03913107141852379, 0.03775207698345184, -0.05497593805193901, -0.05525832623243332, 0.030120985582470894, -0.08308889716863632, 0.01678214967250824, -0.09304813295602798, 0.029511122032999992, -0.07398785650730133, 0.0008546432363800704, 0.021588092669844627, 0.010943152941763401, -0.009410165250301361, 0.03556250408291817, -0.06275275349617004, -0.06703705340623856, 0.050528768450021744, 0.023236924782395363, -0.02157280221581459, -0.054226845502853394, -0.0071141691878438, 0.008963216096162796, 0.04066365957260132, 0.013329503126442432, 0.048601359128952026, -0.004550611600279808, -0.018687855452299118, 0.007161056622862816, 0.032012566924095154, 0.045464105904102325, -0.02358636073768139, -0.005515456199645996, -0.005914315115660429, -0.008361419662833214, -0.008139370009303093, 0.012265084311366081, 0.0336819551885128, -0.04007398337125778, -0.02976764738559723, -0.032277509570121765, 0.007605332415550947, 0.02000078558921814, -0.014501405879855156, 0.028195897117257118, -0.0634450912475586, -0.006101921200752258, 0.07552029192447662, -0.038842134177684784, -0.023616578429937363, 0.11233818531036377, 0.030662741512060165, 0.05087627097964287, 0.044569581747055054, -0.03729749470949173, -0.003907636273652315, -0.004057764075696468, 0.03884194791316986, -0.006282538175582886, 0.007688702549785376, -0.0005257296143099666, -0.031083954498171806, 0.028994165360927582, -0.011754847131669521, -0.06039242073893547, 0.012482509016990662, -0.008407293818891048, -0.007850254885852337, -0.03878670185804367, -0.017062637954950333, 0.03088364005088806, 0.006250114180147648, -0.07401397079229355, 0.038898151367902756, 0.017925022169947624, 0.03511383384466171, -0.037443626672029495, 0.029097719117999077, 0.04415415972471237, -0.012426365166902542, 0.02066110260784626, -0.0747251808643341, 0.016613110899925232, 0.06861646473407745, 0.050938498228788376, -0.01718590036034584, -0.055769696831703186, 0.07669036090373993, 0.022457526996731758, -0.024516170844435692, 0.02005043253302574, 0.03224818408489227, -0.049263596534729004, -0.0041258614510297775, -0.00295666279271245, -0.01147263403981924, -0.02225729078054428, -0.00032834173180162907, -0.04436478018760681, -0.014547252096235752, 0.004121474921703339, 0.030274711549282074, 0.014781025238335133, -0.05843944847583771, 0.014613606035709381, -0.07587359845638275, -0.015965435653924942, 0.0012055503902956843, -0.02538249082863331, -0.028280319646000862, 0.023552987724542618, 0.02127188630402088, -0.051720019429922104, -0.04313041642308235, -0.05511699616909027, -0.05655783787369728, 0.03394802659749985, 0.013330246321856976, 0.014938714914023876, -0.07213026285171509, 0.022512145340442657, -0.009949999861419201, -0.06413337588310242, -0.042651452124118805, 0.013297595083713531, -0.026231946423649788, 0.04380396008491516, -0.005617672111839056, -0.01704377308487892, 0.023809663951396942, -0.019030572846531868, 0.0406075082719326, 0.04031963273882866, -0.052638351917266846, -0.005258950870484114, 0.007614322938024998, 0.018061848357319832, -0.0008506622398272157, 0.037278711795806885, 0.03915252909064293, -0.06866614520549774, 0.07770517468452454, -0.039284780621528625, -0.008745024912059307, 0.00836144294589758, -0.02577233873307705, 0.029788484796881676, -0.04635260999202728, -0.044496774673461914, -0.037411823868751526, 0.00114675413351506, -0.02526824362576008, 0.027859140187501907, 0.028788398951292038, -0.05475258454680443, -0.04875456914305687, 0.01141993049532175, -0.04742112010717392, 0.028880201280117035, 0.027964234352111816, -0.03344671428203583, 0.009085842408239841, 0.0008310407865792513, 0.01282179169356823, 0.01895621418952942, 0.05002940446138382, 0.05997822433710098, -0.04416069760918617, -0.004297940991818905, -0.011866698041558266, -0.021806873381137848, -0.031107496470212936, 0.020210810005664825, -0.024158362299203873, -0.03317227587103844, 0.00966010894626379, -0.02343982271850109, -0.0034438367001712322, 0.022133659571409225, -0.007715293671935797, -0.03944157809019089, 0.025111626833677292, -0.042627934366464615, 0.002850643126294017, -0.05097784474492073, 0.06936497241258621, -0.032990336418151855, 0.013633139431476593, 0.0024283735547214746, 0.027216637507081032, -0.034687213599681854, 0.05528834089636803, -0.08423595130443573, -0.03181109204888344, -0.039524562656879425, -0.02618512324988842, 0.02651357837021351, 0.058359622955322266, 0.0037540721241384745, 0.017714405432343483, -0.00007576003554277122, -0.013177015818655491, -0.03129510581493378, 0.058141522109508514, 0.006567738950252533, 0.018956122919917107, 0.007606941740959883, 0.021604023873806, 0.009227752685546875, 0.006176620721817017, 0.03767915442585945, 0.0190908070653677, 0.024024656042456627, -0.07074359804391861, 0.03843549266457558, -0.02606215886771679, 0.031705472618341446, -0.007909025996923447, 0.015212860889732838, 0.05920613929629326, 0.003316661808639765, 0.04505772516131401, -0.033844899386167526, 0.012115941382944584, 0.043552216142416, -0.02530650980770588, 0.013759052380919456, 0.02177922986447811, -0.050948742777109146, 0.022549057379364967, 0.012296018190681934, 0.047726720571517944, -0.0013728193007409573, -0.002187440637499094, -0.05256631225347519, 0.0467057004570961, -0.031096117570996284, -0.018345441669225693, 0.000980837270617485, -0.05429290607571602, 0.009075756184756756, -0.01427616085857153, -0.04880961775779724, 0.037793416529893875, 0.01784496381878853, -0.051750656217336655, -0.0626327246427536, -0.02049536257982254, -0.037439338862895966, 0.059273507446050644, 0.04245200380682945, 0.0390344001352787, -0.023743392899632454, 0.016266707330942154, 0.00993611291050911, -0.024538753554224968, -0.002051541581749916, -0.0528612919151783, -0.05539628118276596, -0.018511708825826645, 0.012621373869478703, -0.03350766748189926, 0.0565650500357151, -0.017970960587263107, 0.044069383293390274, -0.03974025696516037, -0.019449319690465927, -0.015089358203113079, 0.012223295867443085, -0.0011274864664301276, 0.03906548023223877, 0.020216306671500206, -0.01352143194526434, 0.023787589743733406, 0.03257392346858978, 0.01618872955441475, -0.035126667469739914, -0.033248841762542725, 0.014693914912641048, -0.008851573802530766, 0.037355147302150726, -0.04828944429755211, 0.03980293124914169, 0.04180270433425903, 0.028845779597759247, 0.016040818765759468, 0.04667339473962784, 0.06987772136926651, -0.001162045169621706, 0.007046618033200502, 0.018977589905261993, 0.057243648916482925, 0.03434734418988228, 0.04344967380166054, 0.03875616192817688, -0.014240197837352753, -0.003303307807072997, -0.04199376702308655, -0.02834630012512207, 0.035961661487817764, 0.03708191588521004, 0.034187354147434235, -0.012974631041288376, 0.004088511224836111, 0.052122339606285095, 0.028325682505965233, -0.07377919554710388, 0.03384775295853615, 0.010218547657132149, 0.015166490338742733, 0.00827434379607439, -0.04372219368815422, 0.026527157053351402, -0.01171907689422369, 0.0026593238580971956, -0.04842102900147438, -0.02270786091685295, 0.052069589495658875, -0.03019493632018566, -0.004260801710188389, -0.05092651769518852, -0.012136065401136875, 0.028286825865507126, -0.06795638054609299, 0.017701100558042526, -0.059345465153455734, -0.029247580096125603, 0.07075846940279007, 0.030420463532209396, 0.004968287423253059, -0.05477922782301903, -0.02460266463458538, -0.05140190199017525, 0.07297516614198685, 0.0013377751456573606, 0.007482558023184538, -0.02518213912844658, -0.014600754715502262, 0.008821818046271801, -0.004826758988201618, -0.03971302881836891, 0.018608763813972473, 0.018400337547063828, 0.005519285798072815, -0.011326939798891544, 0.024394115433096886, -0.0022164362017065287, 0.06001962348818779, -0.010472753085196018, -0.012080049142241478, 0.03637733310461044, 0.04116124287247658, -0.037772390991449356, 0.08574767410755157, 0.008675427176058292, -0.004891857039183378, 0.0669599324464798, -0.01663496345281601, -0.020908253267407417, -0.008816388435661793, -0.003924792632460594, -0.0012972996337339282, -0.019382506608963013, 0.03047550842165947, 0.0457971952855587, 0.03726663440465927, -0.05343541130423546, 0.07433843612670898, -0.05321153998374939, 0.015794917941093445, -0.017615608870983124, 0.05379204452037811, -0.05264361575245857, -0.005154694430530071, -0.014158597216010094, 0.025942470878362656, 0.009820463135838509, -0.0010892926948145032, 0.05769775062799454, 0.050081152468919754, -0.07309773564338684, -0.003728020703420043, -0.09042800962924957, 0.07185276597738266, -0.02900252677500248, -0.005124754272401333, 0.008212586864829063, -0.07801174372434616, 0.026371294632554054, -0.03630878031253815, 0.03629761189222336, -0.008120954036712646, -0.02882435731589794, -0.052084844559431076, 0.03531338647007942, 0.06363578140735626, 0.01634952798485756, -0.014008534140884876, -0.014583731070160866, 0.06522102653980255, 0.02914399653673172, -0.03290705382823944, -0.027699651196599007, 0.047408923506736755, 0.035386212170124054, -0.05870288237929344, 0.0035946292337030172, 0.015143423341214657, -0.035907525569200516, -0.020408995449543, 0.04694397747516632, 0.023793600499629974, 0.07395194470882416, 0.03433067724108696, -0.015200579538941383, -0.025893041864037514, -0.027183715254068375, 0.005197612568736076, -0.02794826216995716, -0.07116090506315231, 0.057654764503240585, 0.06731954216957092, 0.01996615342795849, -0.014743363484740257, -0.01003189291805029, 0.04388437792658806, -0.010641595348715782, -0.058122146874666214, 0.03332770988345146, 0.011195811443030834, -0.018468424677848816, -0.030970284715294838, 0.032241810113191605, -0.025218602269887924, -0.009264020249247551, -0.007172830868512392, 0.02450515702366829, 0.019950533285737038, 0.005526356399059296, -0.0021032397635281086, -0.0016641200054436922, -0.026158930733799934, 0.03437649831175804, 0.003973586019128561, 0.0182554479688406, -0.004339566454291344, -0.06587722152471542, 0.010781322605907917, -0.08004336059093475, 0.029913675040006638, 0.0018316404893994331, -0.08688753843307495, 0.006402463186532259, 0.009932964108884335, 0.0144936703145504, 0.07103239744901657, -0.007890207692980766, -0.025091132149100304, -0.026183610782027245, 0.00037515987060032785, -0.0490034818649292, -0.033776912838220596, 0.0018447770271450281, -0.062350448220968246, 0.03738853707909584, -0.0490761362016201, -0.05531840771436691, 0.005615522153675556, 0.062394484877586365, -0.016549954190850258, 0.0033292104490101337, -0.0033281033392995596, 0.0479394905269146, -0.047571320086717606, 0.0128835029900074, 0.03036981076002121, 0.018098516389727592, 0.01402828749269247, -0.010114084929227829, 0.07339659333229065, -0.04705143719911575, 0.012353137135505676, -0.0072192964144051075, -0.04914429411292076, 0.03243729844689369, -0.05100396275520325, 0.009872153401374817, -0.026419294998049736, 0.003049248130992055, 0.019303159788250923, 0.010727666318416595, 0.011010566726326942, -0.00043103090138174593, 0.04724651575088501, 0.0020175082609057426, -0.03907892107963562, 0.09066126495599747, 0.019940480589866638, 0.010781979188323021, -0.056339554488658905, -0.073513463139534, -0.004870690405368805, -0.060597293078899384, 0.006934843026101589, -0.0016334028914570808, 0.017888706177473068, -0.0010048492113128304, 0.03514668717980385, 0.0015497038839384913, -0.014488580636680126, 0.007201394531875849, 0.012246266007423401, -0.0198749378323555, -0.038609348237514496, -0.019904950633645058, 0.010442099533975124, 0.04345628246665001, 0.045337170362472534, -0.043220922350883484, -0.02589288540184498, -0.0378241129219532, 0.02007841318845749, -0.06011176109313965, -0.032567184418439865, 0.005761884152889252, -0.054255496710538864, 0.02826063148677349, 0.0863073319196701, -0.1085546463727951, 0.041920557618141174, -0.05581828951835632, -0.06273238360881805, 0.01575654372572899, -0.0029186250176280737, -0.034455616027116776, 0.05801410228013992, 0.02632678858935833, 0.03720072656869888, 0.0011349866399541497, -0.02249484322965145, -0.038749899715185165, -0.04463681951165199, -0.007917995564639568, 0.02985544688999653, -0.03642897307872772, 0.0010078693740069866, 0.00743894325569272 ]
<p>I am trying to do a crude particle identification, using a Bethe Bloch tenchnique. Here is a plot I made from the data that I have <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/SeyLv.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>From what I've read, the standard method to identify charged particles is by measuring the ionization for a given momentum, in what is known as the Bethe-Bloch Equation</p> <p>$$\langle \frac{dE}{dx}\rangle = \frac{P_1}{\beta^{P_4}}\left( P_2 - \beta^{P_4} - \log \left(P_3+\frac{1}{(\beta\gamma)^{P_5}}\right)\right)$$</p> <p>So I tried to fit it and found out the parameters that are used by the detector people (ALICE, in their documentation, they write that the parameters were found using some simulation program). So these parameters become given constants. Now the entire Bethe-Bloch curves are normalized to the values of the minimum ionizing particle. In the literature, this is referred to as MIP value. So I tried a one-parameter fit for the above curve, leaving ROOT to find out the value of the normalization constant. </p> <p>However, I get absurd results. </p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/u0tk6.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The three "fits" in the figure are supposed to be for pions, electrons and protons. However, they are not really accurate, as you can compare this to any of the standard plots released by CERN. </p> <p>For instance, this is a plot from STAR experiment, which obviously has much lower multiplicity.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/CYv56.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>What are the techniques used by practitioners to find this normalization constant. I am using the same platform but the fitting routine is clearly inadequate for such magnitude of data. </p> <p>PS: I do not have access to any online data or grid, etc. Most of the analysis code on the web seem to be based on somethings called ESDs and AODs and not for local standalone analysis (which is understandable but undfortunate for me)</p>
g4061
[ 0.07686695456504822, -0.0507027693092823, 0.007049619220197201, -0.06686617434024811, 0.049296390265226364, -0.02213980071246624, -0.011229406110942364, 0.050452329218387604, -0.044401511549949646, -0.002427698578685522, -0.023349452763795853, 0.030720718204975128, -0.0025170166045427322, -0.00044932265882380307, 0.012414668686687946, -0.05644696578383446, 0.05283592268824577, -0.0646541640162468, 0.06875398010015488, 0.0016779539873823524, 0.03884213790297508, 0.06564254313707352, 0.01676337979733944, -0.060295470058918, -0.014802571386098862, -0.007595838513225317, -0.021141914650797844, 0.0778791606426239, -0.012807880528271198, -0.0000923363259062171, -0.023704592138528824, 0.025906847789883614, 0.025263812392950058, -0.02889132872223854, -0.02522970922291279, -0.04339716583490372, 0.008837935514748096, 0.0047405315563082695, 0.04882761463522911, -0.018998337909579277, -0.04476473852992058, -0.06439369916915894, -0.0007361829630099237, 0.03583540767431259, -0.025177665054798126, -0.014757185243070126, -0.026069041341543198, -0.04634779319167137, 0.010633876547217369, -0.0233856663107872, -0.014060772024095058, 0.03346537426114082, 0.023574527353048325, -0.03089424967765808, -0.021627919748425484, 0.0589442178606987, -0.027821673080325127, -0.0006553197745233774, 0.03810867667198181, 0.061250001192092896, 0.06024004891514778, 0.03965693712234497, -0.01101831253618002, -0.007448699790984392, 0.028387343510985374, 0.015601765364408493, -0.05654767155647278, 0.023332780227065086, -0.0482020378112793, -0.017239907756447792, 0.015813739970326424, -0.057097263634204865, 0.005263358820229769, -0.05175366997718811, -0.07638172805309296, -0.02982509508728981, -0.031399764120578766, 0.0021085734479129314, -0.003271858673542738, 0.04182111471891403, -0.04531104490160942, -0.010679619386792183, 0.007310024928301573, 0.018739722669124603, 0.09321492910385132, -0.0429912768304348, -0.006135917734354734, -0.01734296791255474, -0.006041521206498146, -0.06754044443368912, 0.004740728996694088, -0.025222839787602425, -0.0010066853137686849, -0.03157096728682518, -0.0037420131266117096, 0.015464751981198788, -0.02338280715048313, 0.06689453125, -0.04482247307896614, -0.01080798078328371, 0.014007025398314, 0.015573814511299133, -0.03408145159482956, -0.011014426127076149, -0.0365755669772625, 0.0209511648863554, -0.010015172883868217, -0.014639335684478283, 0.07735157012939453, -0.04516221210360527, -0.0632801279425621, -0.04110424593091011, 0.005559621844440699, -0.07417204231023788, -0.06723400950431824, -0.03804972395300865, 0.05920739099383354, -0.05142640322446823, 0.0009072534739971161, 0.011516178958117962, -0.011842054314911366, -0.018323726952075958, -0.009099452756345272, 0.013217761181294918, -0.03846567124128342, -0.007732371333986521, -0.013400604017078876, -0.021316245198249817, 0.005533621180802584, -0.008330062963068485, -0.06408043950796127, -0.07590875029563904, -0.007540842518210411, 0.00063308299286291, 0.0064124250784516335, 0.03784318268299103, -0.012700332328677177, -0.012713986448943615, -0.026882454752922058, 0.03824455663561821, -0.041844725608825684, -0.000043664113036356866, 0.023455079644918442, -0.011418841779232025, -0.00884515792131424, 0.03305855393409729, -0.05361839383840561, 0.0068454863503575325, 0.04217531904578209, 0.07970117777585983, 0.015941467136144638, 0.06334715336561203, 0.07985542714595795, -0.003999990876764059, -0.018931109458208084, 0.01712106168270111, 0.047302886843681335, 0.012385373935103416, -0.026643073186278343, 0.03833239898085594, 0.017033863812685013, -0.06627567112445831, -0.0133596770465374, -0.011305597610771656, -0.0050549814477562904, 0.022218802943825722, 0.032182857394218445, 0.0018071848899126053, -0.001774261356331408, -0.05471357703208923, -0.04678290709853172, -0.030679883435368538, 0.066554494202137, -0.027639875188469887, -0.000014861182535241824, 0.03692501783370972, 0.0028888857923448086, -0.03743778541684151, 0.026484284549951553, 0.07041177898645401, 0.03635873645544052, 0.06422407180070877, 0.05410442873835564, -0.027623916044831276, -0.028510181233286858, -0.06850098073482513, 0.007281848229467869, 0.06427301466464996, 0.05277341231703758, -0.008678614161908627, 0.028571899980306625, 0.00706856045871973, -0.04345979914069176, 0.011746782809495926, -0.008392811752855778, -0.025432167574763298, -0.005365988239645958, -0.027984734624624252, -0.02200699783861637, -0.0153612419962883, -0.06269669532775879, 0.05164416879415512, 0.018838901072740555, -0.005505609791725874, 0.060128070414066315, -0.028616128489375114, 0.03002130053937435, -0.04980555921792984, 0.000682972720824182, 0.06275185942649841, -0.03775090351700783, -0.015362112782895565, -0.03506477549672127, 0.06427612155675888, -0.0041499389335513115, -0.03879166767001152, -0.016486408188939095, 0.06468525528907776, -0.02112703025341034, 0.022260213270783424, -0.073655866086483, -0.015945564955472946, -0.016026005148887634, -0.021755944937467575, 0.013314357958734035, -0.0039919111877679825, 0.0450127013027668, 0.04126143455505371, 0.03846834972500801, -0.021343829110264778, -0.01626499556005001, 0.04385799169540405, -0.021791594102978706, -0.027594076469540596, 0.02893981710076332, 0.013930516317486763, -0.044435590505599976, -0.018786851316690445, 0.016467081382870674, 0.029869714751839638, -0.046212662011384964, -0.02201300859451294, -0.059915948659181595, 0.024649115279316902, 0.07073714584112167, 0.04850953072309494, 0.0003747065784409642, -0.027560226619243622, -0.04191017523407936, 0.0006296938518062234, -0.03688495233654976, 0.03191065788269043, -0.04249914735555649, 0.04393143951892853, -0.01103917881846428, -0.035340748727321625, -0.022919446229934692, 0.027110356837511063, -0.015815671533346176, 0.0021942623425275087, -0.026539750397205353, -0.018619203940033913, 0.018043117597699165, 0.03163756802678108, -0.0345962829887867, -0.013875316828489304, 0.016268214210867882, 0.012881341390311718, 0.05583394691348076, -0.004534657578915358, 0.05441588535904884, -0.0025388195645064116, 0.03545751795172691, 0.06587554514408112, 0.07939431816339493, -0.026339774951338768, 0.057926520705223083, 0.054110679775476456, 0.0010588812874630094, -0.07633273303508759, -0.041986651718616486, 0.012826518155634403, -0.06883765012025833, 0.032268088310956955, 0.010108188726007938, 0.005223717540502548, 0.04762773588299751, -0.03653040900826454, -0.038806285709142685, 0.0563940703868866, -0.023180151358246803, -0.05733950063586235, -0.002312336815521121, 0.014603677205741405, -0.02294023148715496, 0.016100294888019562, 0.03889811784029007, -0.019676579162478447, 0.06411684304475784, 0.03567871078848839, 0.06504451483488083, 0.0030291990842670202, 0.0018566123908385634, -0.005295332986861467, -0.0254683680832386, -0.027623817324638367, -0.05967441573739052, -0.051116034388542175, -0.015292126685380936, 0.06567683815956116, -0.0059813810512423515, -0.03115147352218628, 0.02447614073753357, 0.010257074609398842, 0.002000137697905302, -0.025359872728586197, 0.011539232917129993, -0.012439301237463951, 0.009973824955523014, 0.010801587253808975, -0.011735113337635994, -0.008587340824306011, 0.042594388127326965, -0.001090595731511712, 0.05441392958164215, 0.01569322869181633, -0.017259493470191956, -0.010994571261107922, -0.02306833490729332, -0.024797353893518448, 0.048461999744176865, -0.03376467153429985, 0.0009496590937487781, 0.004420381039381027, -0.03352341428399086, -0.04389291629195213, -0.0011771159479394555, 0.07261840999126434, 0.03959852457046509, -0.03838447108864784, -0.0062287128530442715, 0.011584422551095486, -0.0805068090558052, -0.0018363286508247256, -0.030598657205700874, -0.054164256900548935, -0.01698141172528267, 0.024075143039226532, -0.004443115089088678, -0.02686762996017933, 0.009766691364347935, 0.06373558193445206, -0.03021843172609806, -0.0029052835889160633, 0.00668988935649395, -0.008820825256407261, 0.023944592103362083, 0.002184422919526696, 0.0067016552202403545, -0.005369833670556545, 0.03106287494301796, -0.022321615368127823, -0.03757975995540619, 0.04237210378050804, -0.009985405951738358, -0.03185964375734329, -0.037164606153964996, 0.08312126249074936, 0.07574253529310226, -0.03987586125731468, -0.040412791073322296, 0.02956133708357811, 0.05353071540594101, 0.03346249461174011, -0.03747258707880974, -0.0006687788991257548, -0.03387223556637764, 0.01309787854552269, -0.03141138330101967, 0.01048340369015932, -0.05100858584046364, -0.014766041189432144, -0.020363498479127884, 0.0010125519474968314, -0.006614774465560913, -0.04250527173280716, -0.018622733652591705, 0.02478683367371559, 0.006702299229800701, -0.04930216819047928, 0.042636312544345856, -0.08721756935119629, -0.04504695534706116, -0.06351302564144135, 0.03625360503792763, -0.04035026580095291, 0.015406779944896698, -0.005423389375209808, 0.001300810370594263, 0.05059272423386574, -0.008369707502424717, -0.02359776757657528, 0.03336496651172638, -0.032954033464193344, 0.0567757748067379, 0.029347309842705727, -0.008497728034853935, 0.015748076140880585, 0.007192088291049004, -0.07930910587310791, -0.000991089385934174, 0.017759623005986214, 0.0445353202521801, -0.025929708033800125, 0.020353570580482483, -0.0344630628824234, 0.011912566609680653, -0.05621909350156784, 0.05991602689027786, 0.0026295718271285295, 0.006047981325536966, 0.005519445054233074, -0.019508937373757362, -0.03469378873705864, 0.022104866802692413, 0.04073671996593475, 0.011076102964580059, 0.03441610187292099, 0.033593546599149704, 0.00006733593181706965, 0.016129164025187492, -0.0056128422729671, -0.013522897846996784, 0.03554963693022728, -0.03677835687994957, 0.01233749557286501, -0.029976457357406616, 0.024023588746786118, -0.00321290735155344, 0.02492341212928295, 0.029624151065945625, 0.005974689964205027, 0.031119979918003082, -0.007727982010692358, 0.0007034781156107783, 0.0424942672252655, -0.027885012328624725, -0.02173122763633728, -0.011375300586223602, -0.013319759629666805, 0.03985051438212395, 0.0045460062101483345, -0.010935214348137379, -0.051680903881788254, 0.004728041589260101, 0.041128937155008316, -0.005495304241776466, 0.04155174270272255, -0.0033230034168809652, 0.004161621443927288, -0.046377383172512054, 0.042684368789196014, -0.03665902093052864, -0.035853061825037, 0.015515811741352081, -0.010351525619626045, -0.06057346612215042, -0.005918196868151426, 0.02283463254570961, -0.05376032739877701, -0.021638907492160797, -0.0548587441444397, 0.08073082566261292, -0.06625266373157501, -0.009192039258778095, 0.004069156013429165, 0.0068261404521763325, 0.04053632542490959, -0.07349933683872223, 0.004488845355808735, -0.02608797326683998, 0.022941045463085175, -0.023021455854177475, 0.08264509588479996, -0.04817797243595123, 0.0166187547147274, -0.024014320224523544, 0.02963344007730484, 0.06662480533123016, 0.011692174710333347, 0.00023206537298392504, 0.02250686101615429, 0.036974333226680756, 0.0007403987692669034, 0.026090696454048157, -0.03402603417634964, -0.001127439085394144, 0.0045237354934215546, 0.0021915044635534286, 0.11620192229747772, 0.0006488013314083219, -0.024512557312846184, -0.010374925099313259, 0.015620050951838493, -0.014689808711409569, 0.06656835973262787, 0.03469954431056976, -0.02026604302227497, -0.010816308669745922, 0.04270467534661293, 0.040997788310050964, 0.013211543671786785, 0.08895637094974518, -0.08752789348363876, -0.053992919623851776, 0.013802699744701385, 0.0014293891144916415, 0.037993740290403366, 0.008965429849922657, -0.09857992082834244, 0.008896381594240665, 0.05061960965394974, 0.06391165405511856, -0.0019814162515103817, 0.05380267649888992, -0.06612397730350494, -0.0033595210406929255, -0.05223655328154564, 0.005438483320176601, -0.0036511749494820833, -0.03260750696063042, 0.018424293026328087, -0.023464292287826538, 0.004155547823756933, -0.012368704192340374, -0.0012947587529197335, -0.05065561830997467, 0.01612670160830021, 0.04160033166408539, -0.03639882802963257, -0.01281705778092146, -0.01683993451297283, 0.0161913875490427, -0.032438699156045914, -0.020327700302004814, 0.026013126596808434, 0.011749266646802425, 0.043727435171604156, 0.00534182321280241, -0.0432906411588192, -0.025122560560703278, -0.010266714729368687, 0.001256670686416328, -0.04949398338794708, -0.01076498068869114, 0.005813077557832003, 0.03833146393299103, -0.0029452259186655283, -0.04615061357617378, 0.021360211074352264, -0.010327770374715328, -0.03495296835899353, -0.008898080326616764, 0.03407842665910721, -0.019329765811562538, -0.003232507035136223, 0.04324905946850777, -0.03579309955239296, -0.0014345257077366114, 0.00223009055480361, -0.0562843419611454, -0.04223228991031647, 0.024302754551172256, 0.03760289400815964, 0.04247189685702324, 0.008879505097866058, -0.024767344817519188, 0.011058452539145947, -0.030502304434776306, 0.006681300234049559, 0.03188672289252281, 0.03484325110912323, 0.009069796651601791, -0.03978846222162247, 0.012031163088977337, 0.031008834019303322, -0.008335842750966549, -0.01864192821085453, -0.004622264765202999, -0.05323335528373718, 0.012516248039901257, 0.018805140629410744, 0.003651281353086233, -0.05843068286776543, -0.007697020657360554, -0.01625990867614746, 0.004604180809110403, -0.027256431058049202, 0.0010021374328061938, 0.0019243477145209908, 0.004694068804383278, -0.03780330345034599, -0.02370324358344078, 0.03927601873874664, 0.046370264142751694, -0.00638155359774828, -0.00773593969643116, -0.021545587107539177, -0.04434686899185181, 0.012618886306881905, -0.012657149694859982, 0.013862840831279755, -0.03753668814897537, 0.039464280009269714, 0.009557588957250118, -0.01941230148077011, 0.0342378206551075, 0.07004127651453018, -0.015754228457808495, 0.0027264992240816355, 0.02944212593138218, -0.004425095394253731, -0.08669424802064896, -0.00043051817920058966, 0.0829007551074028, 0.026069428771734238, 0.020739348605275154, -0.008582757785916328, 0.008319777436554432, -0.023047711700201035, -0.013307237066328526, 0.007089952006936073, 0.019327210262417793, 0.007003444712609053, -0.02163369581103325, 0.09839263558387756, 0.036240849643945694, 0.0164750088006258, -0.0009633055306039751, 0.06599701195955276, 0.03537812829017639, 0.01000905316323042, 0.020668894052505493, 0.0006625423557125032, -0.08072438836097717, -0.023541873320937157, 0.005022677127271891, 0.014671748504042625, -0.019583553075790405, 0.011214056983590126, 0.03471612185239792, 0.03861140459775925, 0.046490103006362915, 0.07709459960460663, 0.04179080203175545, -0.02019338682293892, 0.045154549181461334, 0.04268116503953934, 0.040034689009189606, -0.04188613221049309, -0.012801092118024826, -0.02890869788825512, 0.02986833266913891, -0.06718812137842178, 0.02293848618865013, -0.00889601744711399, -0.04924445226788521, -0.03436380624771118, 0.05110558122396469, -0.08389303833246231, 0.004846442956477404, 0.010776829905807972, -0.006585936062037945, 0.04796907678246498, 0.0336444228887558, 0.00001961516318260692, -0.005943154450505972, 0.043889712542295456, -0.048524778336286545, 0.02243664860725403, 0.012538829818367958, 0.007772564422339201, 0.038170650601387024, -0.007260224781930447, -0.019875645637512207, 0.0014544551959261298, -0.05969197675585747, 0.0014179865829646587, 0.031198441982269287, 0.03694150224328041, -0.006686755921691656, 0.000698871270287782, 0.07758476585149765, -0.061469193547964096, -0.03076319582760334, 0.03933887183666229, 0.01571061834692955, 0.000977017218247056, 0.07437528669834137, -0.013379680924117565, 0.0182462427765131, -0.03194909915328026, -0.02299548126757145, -0.06175125017762184, 0.010580344125628471, 0.04166726395487785, -0.0299367755651474, 0.014504422433674335, -0.005938807036727667, -0.00503881461918354, -0.0006777693051844835, 0.019379789009690285, -0.011320814490318298, -0.01106206513941288, -0.004669261630624533, -0.005243373103439808, 0.017901774495840073, 0.008429846726357937, 0.006796303670853376, -0.026002349331974983, -0.018991315737366676, -0.01605302095413208, -0.005903428420424461, 0.029247470200061798, 0.04354586452245712, -0.01996305026113987, -0.05466962978243828, 0.05095740035176277, -0.003882270772010088, 0.055566541850566864, -0.09319127351045609, 0.004158956464380026, -0.02068217284977436, -0.0010642523411661386, -0.07643119245767593, -0.027276156470179558, 0.021441202610731125, 0.001322633819654584, -0.039246466010808945, 0.07297731935977936, 0.012698944658041, -0.023120079189538956, -0.028222989290952682, 0.014339899644255638, -0.043570615351200104, 0.016239913180470467, -0.027693308889865875, 0.031347744166851044, 0.07829895615577698, -0.013466896489262581, 0.046950727701187134, -0.04878407344222069, -0.022731121629476547, 0.01819632761180401, 0.0023892559111118317, -0.010183055885136127, 0.014747477136552334, 0.08303815871477127, 0.027355166152119637, -0.0036869277246296406, -0.02379194274544716, -0.04017293453216553, -0.034961022436618805, 0.10672039538621902, -0.0038124879356473684, -0.04344036057591438, -0.03149876371026039, 0.062196996062994 ]
<p>I've been having trouble with my physics homework. The problem is: </p> <blockquote> <p><em>You may have measured the properties of a simple spring-mass system in the lab. Suppose you found ks = 0.9 N/m and m = 0.01 kg, and you observed an oscillation with an amplitude of 0.5 m. What is the approximate value of N, the "quantum number" for this oscillator? (That is, how many levels above the ground state is this oscillator?)</em></p> </blockquote>
g4062
[ 0.02588985301554203, 0.02482953481376171, 0.01524305809289217, -0.01101637352257967, -0.030964866280555725, 0.002314959652721882, 0.03526485338807106, 0.023334218189120293, -0.01770365983247757, 0.0002739360206760466, -0.04893643409013748, 0.03576800227165222, -0.00259462115354836, 0.06105216592550278, 0.028537753969430923, -0.025873588398098946, 0.10114089399576187, -0.00013525849499274045, 0.016466207802295685, -0.031383223831653595, 0.011156353168189526, -0.007808496709913015, -0.05512043833732605, -0.04566075652837753, 0.042184460908174515, 0.01866249553859234, -0.0362619012594223, 0.0017425469122827053, -0.09357113391160965, 0.009595058858394623, -0.063412144780159, 0.006797949317842722, 0.05420244112610817, -0.019670775160193443, -0.08887141197919846, 0.013955408707261086, 0.027419665828347206, 0.021296286955475807, -0.008498609066009521, -0.0043090833351016045, 0.03374982997775078, -0.06716801971197128, -0.021165307611227036, 0.015574018470942974, 0.016736937686800957, 0.05455863103270531, 0.028321396559476852, 0.007712559308856726, 0.0028961063362658024, -0.0170922689139843, -0.04459651559591293, 0.008744306862354279, 0.07237621396780014, 0.044833820313215256, 0.01211884431540966, 0.01657983288168907, -0.03512756898999214, -0.057599026709795, 0.09439762681722641, 0.0618654265999794, 0.05117630958557129, -0.013904513791203499, 0.0013246156740933657, -0.045592669397592545, 0.04032000154256821, 0.02980475127696991, -0.0415993332862854, 0.01696569100022316, -0.029905833303928375, -0.0041811056435108185, 0.019033467397093773, -0.03526018187403679, -0.046220168471336365, -0.007428331300616264, -0.009772229008376598, 0.0321677140891552, 0.011853941716253757, 0.029857145622372627, 0.06545352935791016, 0.006223205476999283, 0.03317460045218468, 0.020052045583724976, 0.016907569020986557, -0.03258246183395386, 0.06176690384745598, -0.008289341814815998, -0.05243366211652756, 0.008916929364204407, -0.017871404066681862, 0.040679123252630234, 0.007101481780409813, -0.011623737402260303, 0.044169384986162186, -0.04489792510867119, 0.03549102693796158, -0.043063580989837646, 0.027330588549375534, 0.0632370188832283, -0.011084958910942078, 0.034124068915843964, -0.02726302109658718, -0.032682616263628006, 0.0070165544748306274, 0.020839177072048187, -0.005089795682579279, 0.014330924488604069, -0.009775673970580101, -0.033007752150297165, -0.014978845603764057, -0.008116696961224079, -0.04542585834860802, -0.04089673236012459, -0.003729411168023944, -0.04177086800336838, -0.09306448698043823, -0.002101527526974678, 0.014755579642951488, 0.010983971878886223, -0.03631044924259186, 0.024635670706629753, -0.014113851822912693, 0.030431795865297318, 0.008908658288419247, 0.046838320791721344, 0.017938759177923203, -0.016594747081398964, -0.0006343927816487849, 0.0016502384096384048, 0.008463878184556961, 0.009315509349107742, -0.020118407905101776, -0.02965266816318035, -0.04973893612623215, 0.008950585499405861, -0.029994605109095573, 0.07157339155673981, 0.045240618288517, -0.006673797499388456, 0.011282536201179028, -0.0011097308015450835, 0.012014399282634258, 0.015467421151697636, -0.005359776318073273, -0.040302667766809464, -0.01389847882091999, 0.021376127377152443, 0.008607394993305206, -0.01889495924115181, 0.02698284573853016, 0.019475148990750313, 0.0049218893982470036, -0.01551680639386177, -0.0020249125082045794, -0.030347023159265518, 0.004264760296791792, -0.04239845275878906, 0.01832083985209465, 0.012766862288117409, -0.018317069858312607, 0.034183524549007416, 0.02672329545021057, -0.0016616544453427196, -0.028020763769745827, -0.005117149092257023, -0.06884050369262695, 0.010662122629582882, -0.020799122750759125, -0.017068548128008842, 0.00020931205654051155, -0.021194662898778915, -0.007893970236182213, -0.061275023967027664, 0.020670071244239807, -0.014809935353696346, -0.06639823317527771, 0.0645221397280693, 0.049179159104824066, -0.03188091516494751, 0.04512903839349747, 0.06659608334302902, 0.05628373101353645, -0.034332189708948135, 0.027241671457886696, 0.0025029433891177177, -0.016611436381936073, 0.0352804958820343, 0.04073423519730568, 0.003258761717006564, -0.014481604099273682, -0.02939719520509243, -0.009367898106575012, -0.023995840921998024, 0.015897247940301895, 0.03237345069646835, -0.0026908223517239094, -0.00295672076754272, 0.03110511600971222, 0.008762504905462265, -0.005157770123332739, 0.00018032253137789667, 0.021833190694451332, 0.037042200565338135, -0.00047435221495106816, 0.02433464676141739, 0.047916922718286514, 0.0016771556111052632, -0.02260747365653515, -0.0010552696185186505, -0.04423058032989502, -0.02968868426978588, -0.017006371170282364, -0.010870817117393017, -0.0063626025803387165, 0.07247088104486465, -0.027957076206803322, -0.0008847443968988955, 0.08304701000452042, 0.013215911574661732, 0.04045971855521202, 0.04884997010231018, 0.004209248349070549, 0.0012384932488203049, 0.05401186645030975, -0.008823145180940628, 0.0285330843180418, -0.014885684475302696, -0.05846575275063515, -0.0174759142100811, -0.030148057267069817, -0.014180503785610199, -0.053677067160606384, 0.03748007118701935, -0.040439631789922714, -0.006143398117274046, 0.026687772944569588, 0.046999722719192505, -0.033469006419181824, -0.025334930047392845, 0.02324606105685234, -0.01983872428536415, 0.025136522948741913, 0.016172295436263084, -0.030022375285625458, -0.03194711357355118, -0.008988128043711185, -0.009817265905439854, -0.03997717425227165, 0.03981052711606026, -0.006515714805573225, 0.019789723679423332, -0.008154867216944695, -0.019335614517331123, -0.004173108376562595, 0.04551148787140846, 0.017197495326399803, 0.02541329711675644, -0.06722214818000793, -0.011244301684200764, 0.011926009319722652, -0.05727440491318703, 0.012114346958696842, -0.11104349792003632, 0.037588272243738174, -0.0029217079281806946, -0.046346016228199005, -0.04588766396045685, -0.04146246612071991, 0.007033998146653175, 0.02992834709584713, -0.009828394278883934, -0.006079420447349548, 0.05617903918027878, -0.028860611841082573, 0.035552192479372025, -0.03857049345970154, -0.010144147090613842, 0.015782421454787254, -0.013655309565365314, 0.002693659160286188, -0.061106666922569275, -0.014650588855147362, 0.019319899380207062, -0.003286228748038411, 0.02733975276350975, 0.04804505407810211, -0.045256439596414566, 0.017570117488503456, -0.022026652470231056, 0.023775184527039528, -0.010644941590726376, -0.023562578484416008, 0.02973422408103943, 0.023404929786920547, 0.051781121641397476, -0.061744388192892075, 0.06276433169841766, 0.02789922058582306, -0.030120516195893288, 0.004367544781416655, 0.12022542953491211, 0.04925850033760071, -0.0183648020029068, -0.015394655056297779, -0.04897899180650711, -0.04789677634835243, 0.008249307982623577, 0.02924705669283867, 0.038349974900484085, 0.046222276985645294, 0.056308314204216, -0.02169196866452694, 0.04160134494304657, 0.040969379246234894, -0.015304747968912125, -0.05119471251964569, 0.04884985461831093, -0.011199112981557846, -0.027863452211022377, 0.029086677357554436, -0.07233394682407379, -0.033969540148973465, -0.0348544605076313, 0.07720070332288742, 0.0007502502994611859, 0.02759924903512001, 0.030003366991877556, -0.03870438411831856, 0.02844345010817051, -0.02234690636396408, -0.07940743863582611, 0.0064183566719293594, -0.029903750866651535, -0.011639348231256008, -0.018174368888139725, -0.009760876186192036, -0.07708065211772919, 0.022455019876360893, -0.024582991376519203, 0.013056918978691101, 0.026028459891676903, -0.02144598215818405, 0.0014533576322719455, 0.015454440377652645, -0.03505297377705574, 0.028570124879479408, -0.029809504747390747, -0.09769749641418457, 0.013467040844261646, -0.036451876163482666, 0.01131926104426384, 0.023256249725818634, 0.015092762187123299, -0.029255589470267296, -0.016677074134349823, 0.0008725696825422347, 0.0452081672847271, 0.025496721267700195, 0.040565744042396545, -0.01652209460735321, -0.043664783239364624, 0.02534385770559311, -0.01585463620722294, 0.057145483791828156, 0.016107087954878807, 0.009458780288696289, -0.004035900346934795, -0.04308858513832092, 0.09373130649328232, 0.001358868321403861, -0.021959958598017693, -0.045112188905477524, -0.04312658682465553, 0.06653332710266113, 0.0118514159694314, 0.04266422241926193, -0.0688694640994072, -0.021402902901172638, -0.03222543001174927, -0.0489182323217392, -0.0054625896736979485, 0.011352845467627048, -0.01568605564534664, 0.026348814368247986, -0.10104072093963623, 0.04261740297079086, 0.02252885326743126, -0.0005209938390180469, -0.014444679021835327, 0.04882761463522911, -0.0484125129878521, 0.014936642721295357, -0.05971362814307213, -0.1026240810751915, 0.060749854892492294, 0.010393527336418629, 0.045069701969623566, 0.05353614687919617, -0.0035721799358725548, -0.035734858363866806, 0.07895196974277496, 0.02850097231566906, 0.0038139638490974903, 0.008937327191233635, 0.010155674070119858, 0.0064630829729139805, 0.045225560665130615, 0.10272142291069031, -0.02360992506146431, 0.02266458235681057, 0.007345412392169237, 0.011103966273367405, -0.018774453550577164, -0.01976456493139267, -0.049203772097826004, -0.017256084829568863, 0.05219600349664688, 0.025631465017795563, -0.03736056014895439, -0.00007973259198479354, 0.0021573363337665796, -0.0325319804251194, 0.07193195074796677, -0.048176974058151245, -0.009190785698592663, -0.03987821936607361, 0.025012817233800888, 0.021700814366340637, -0.007949689403176308, 0.00002837736246874556, -0.008439576253294945, -0.015115232206881046, -0.010461019352078438, -0.004706716630607843, 0.03771733120083809, -0.05264510586857796, 0.025161612778902054, 0.012175268493592739, -0.006013438571244478, -0.005385470576584339, 0.012136179022490978, 0.03752097859978676, 0.010614677332341671, -0.037231024354696274, 0.04459604248404503, 0.014870152808725834, 0.008316803723573685, 0.015572113916277885, -0.015931321308016777, -0.03950435668230057, 0.002460031071677804, 0.004805147182196379, -0.004664033185690641, -0.04240494593977928, -0.02960626594722271, -0.027571195736527443, -0.03523079305887222, -0.0413297601044178, -0.0015132317785173655, 0.031156346201896667, 0.07223489880561829, 0.0006510877865366638, -0.035797059535980225, 0.01017556618899107, 0.00312953838147223, 0.019242804497480392, -0.031038492918014526, -0.04473956301808357, 0.030826136469841003, -0.04889500513672829, -0.03334170952439308, 0.039162777364254, -0.055082760751247406, 0.051807355135679245, 0.028917796909809113, 0.021323995664715767, 0.0075295185670256615, -0.02259022369980812, 0.002692741109058261, 0.03699396550655365, -0.01540856808423996, -0.028399784117937088, 0.01314519252628088, -0.007908951491117477, -0.0018031394574791193, -0.0054779052734375, 0.03458794578909874, -0.03383397310972214, -0.021892858669161797, 0.0407620444893837, -0.04158293083310127, 0.06756215542554855, 0.02643752656877041, -0.0024045626632869244, 0.013924147002398968, -0.013546189293265343, -0.04138265550136566, 0.006870380602777004, -0.003994624130427837, 0.047464385628700256, 0.029475197196006775, -0.03746940568089485, 0.022622816264629364, -0.01557998452335596, 0.06359178572893143, -0.05316728726029396, 0.0010887875687330961, -0.06798055768013, -0.019196541979908943, 0.014169101603329182, 0.041814833879470825, -0.025129353627562523, -0.05039737746119499, 0.014892678707838058, 0.015401308424770832, 0.03945603966712952, -0.022514279931783676, -0.04263533651828766, 0.029141247272491455, -0.05534614622592926, 0.03283880278468132, 0.053794015198946, -0.030435578897595406, 0.05890689417719841, -0.05188090354204178, 0.010743265971541405, -0.02119714953005314, -0.02920202724635601, -0.02233676053583622, -0.039429422467947006, 0.050753626972436905, 0.044621746987104416, 0.0074715325608849525, 0.0048737842589616776, -0.006944107357412577, 0.036692745983600616, 0.02680283598601818, -0.02981986477971077, -0.024340489879250526, -0.0165671706199646, 0.03258480876684189, 0.012052341364324093, -0.00006397234392352402, 0.04213107377290726, 0.010928374715149403, 0.042084723711013794, -0.011453730054199696, -0.0300496444106102, -0.0171065516769886, 0.031945668160915375, 0.015575350262224674, -0.03534155339002609, 0.02189856953918934, -0.03778731822967529, 0.027486706152558327, 0.03235142305493355, 0.03347248211503029, -0.018561938777565956, -0.0127119030803442, -0.022117746993899345, 0.06371767818927765, 0.04620211198925972, -0.002309163101017475, 0.05107688531279564, 0.04071832448244095, 0.055372633039951324, -0.03726988285779953, -0.050330422818660736, -0.017104677855968475, 0.02770194411277771, -0.009462620131671429, -0.03805657476186752, 0.0537557452917099, -0.01836274564266205, 0.0230562761425972, 0.005855543073266745, 0.06238614395260811, -0.028700916096568108, -0.05086812749505043, -0.040345922112464905, 0.05792231857776642, -0.08188595622777939, 0.03854072093963623, 0.060083407908678055, -0.028003128245472908, 0.0021907356567680836, 0.01092017162591219, -0.019267942756414413, 0.01808582805097103, -0.008265776559710503, 0.04108170047402382, -0.03819860890507698, -0.009928944520652294, -0.06148963049054146, 0.004024967551231384, 0.013881603255867958, -0.03275572881102562, 0.022017398849129677, -0.027539599686861038, -0.03764208033680916, 0.01666812226176262, 0.09492635726928711, -0.045384686440229416, 0.040963634848594666, -0.02676665596663952, 0.01919320784509182, 0.06240033358335495, -0.06402123719453812, 0.017248202115297318, -0.09824524074792862, 0.02437332086265087, 0.003197900950908661, 0.022160319611430168, -0.010653188452124596, 0.04694350063800812, 0.010587858967483044, -0.02592005394399166, 0.08405355364084244, 0.020946567878127098, -0.04131742939352989, -0.01815858855843544, 0.07244496047496796, -0.009424733929336071, 0.0021431385539472103, -0.020096715539693832, 0.015108906663954258, -0.0033375779166817665, 0.0221409909427166, -0.008711245842278004, 0.022945599630475044, -0.03409574180841446, -0.014984586276113987, -0.03858865052461624, 0.02929878793656826, -0.010946404188871384, -0.04761594906449318, 0.04721399396657944, 0.020438354462385178, 0.0034406688064336777, 0.011707089841365814, 0.051736291497945786, -0.05409063771367073, -0.024966930970549583, 0.029248369857668877, 0.0033385707065463066, -0.029522735625505447, -0.046268440783023834, 0.07151144742965698, 0.014417004771530628, -0.0550960972905159, 0.0026597967371344566, 0.00788037944585085, 0.008599190041422844, -0.015330193564295769, -0.008477451279759407, 0.005556127056479454, -0.006475531961768866, 0.05051824823021889, -0.01998165063560009, 0.07830995321273804, -0.03114372119307518, -0.0917893797159195, -0.0324857272207737, 0.022150225937366486, -0.009753222577273846, -0.012873820960521698, 0.07960720360279083, 0.01418860163539648, 0.022772841155529022, -0.004061047453433275, -0.04982413351535797, -0.0033064340241253376, -0.08242528140544891, -0.037437885999679565, 0.04465349018573761, -0.035469263792037964, 0.030790356919169426, -0.0023898829240351915, 0.04295246675610542, -0.026038171723484993, -0.028966693207621574, -0.004816699307411909, -0.03792300820350647, -0.05338926240801811, 0.03072403557598591, 0.011042127385735512, 0.03783589228987694, -0.0628201812505722, -0.0010683875298127532, 0.05027782917022705, 0.021693604066967964, 0.001876925234682858, 0.017927026376128197, 0.01149535272270441, -0.08528757095336914, -0.004339039791375399, -0.010195852257311344, -0.01215308252722025, -0.04838644340634346, 0.08005567640066147, -0.036730460822582245, 0.022917380556464195, 0.006755149457603693, -0.011616184376180172, 0.02242261916399002, -0.04604370519518852, 0.02588776685297489, 0.009471669793128967, -0.04710213840007782, -0.05900337174534798, -0.0045929872430861, -0.00039000489050522447, 0.015769444406032562, 0.03928878903388977, 0.038100216537714005, 0.034216973930597305, 0.07943389564752579, -0.059130098670721054, -0.007162683177739382, 0.013525988906621933, -0.0295429527759552, -0.03826563432812691, 0.04462292417883873, 0.005476179998368025, -0.003462765133008361, -0.041466765105724335, -0.054427631199359894, 0.011290603317320347, 0.010526541620492935, 0.00897385086864233, -0.029065582901239395, 0.0069989366456866264, -0.04371087625622749, -0.011429152451455593, 0.01653188467025757, -0.001820936449803412, -0.013761778362095356, 0.005217321682721376, 0.004535353742539883, -0.03189997375011444, 0.02782534807920456, -0.015950487926602364, -0.10229401290416718, -0.021154779940843582, 0.004922045860439539, 0.033886540681123734, -0.038682736456394196, -0.04500211030244827, 0.06262271106243134, 0.04133276268839836, -0.08500576764345169, -0.0005027824663557112, -0.010099229402840137, 0.038435209542512894, 0.06365776062011719, -0.008337960578501225, -0.05391630157828331, 0.027479177340865135, -0.021637819707393646, -0.02229565940797329, -0.007776495534926653, 0.001602050382643938, 0.02403620444238186, 0.021273480728268623, -0.0349092036485672, -0.051944226026535034, -0.04865788295865059, -0.011217234656214714, -0.051052723079919815 ]
<p>What is the advantage/purpose of using $\psi$ for wavefunctions and getting the probability with $|\psi|^2$ as opposed to just defining and using the probability function?</p>
g4063
[ 0.008872698992490768, -0.00462228013202548, 0.007783606648445129, -0.006011444143950939, 0.005825572181493044, -0.01379662286490202, 0.02303888276219368, 0.01414548885077238, -0.044139470905065536, -0.05743040144443512, 0.024037832394242287, -0.0004566364223137498, 0.011052045971155167, 0.01976710930466652, -0.012764165177941322, -0.03522064909338951, 0.058392804116010666, 0.030738525092601776, -0.007703934796154499, -0.009802190586924553, -0.010274386964738369, -0.06736763566732407, -0.018261272460222244, -0.04585709795355797, 0.050225138664245605, 0.005777551326900721, 0.02796969935297966, -0.029802504926919937, 0.023685256019234657, 0.04691263288259506, -0.005723907612264156, 0.051099494099617004, 0.0512673556804657, -0.06412473320960999, -0.020913125947117805, 0.015417413786053658, 0.08685784041881561, 0.0007765998016111553, 0.03021678701043129, -0.03674917295575142, 0.008173489943146706, 0.027399364858865738, 0.024555707350373268, -0.010497089475393295, -0.04614740610122681, -0.016542013734579086, -0.001453637145459652, 0.007900265976786613, -0.04398374632000923, -0.05755586549639702, 0.058276426047086716, -0.039054471999406815, 0.06937175244092941, 0.05333578586578369, 0.05543830990791321, 0.004118482582271099, 0.03856470063328743, 0.038371745496988297, 0.024504145607352257, 0.0216902457177639, 0.030238743871450424, 0.021359063684940338, 0.0450604148209095, -0.007612070068717003, 0.038522835820913315, 0.004314548801630735, -0.04617612063884735, -0.04321771487593651, 0.007392756175249815, 0.018342383205890656, -0.02261974662542343, -0.058288007974624634, -0.009645504876971245, 0.011727772653102875, -0.03890474885702133, -0.000026176705432590097, 0.014497854746878147, -0.027359288185834885, 0.02061566896736622, 0.0721120685338974, -0.011011157184839249, -0.09610208868980408, 0.02105487696826458, -0.020839491859078407, 0.03442000597715378, 0.005694830324500799, 0.010633010417222977, -0.03400908410549164, -0.0037726557347923517, -0.00014057978114578873, 0.024278875440359116, -0.010076196864247322, 0.029537515714764595, 0.013269664719700813, -0.027252476662397385, 0.0038896205369383097, -0.024968018755316734, 0.0032223938032984734, 0.04478815570473671, 0.05539487302303314, 0.03001064993441105, 0.01929301954805851, 0.06459216773509979, 0.07547996938228607, -0.022780686616897583, 0.0030933083035051823, -0.04211481288075447, 0.030316967517137527, -0.004216148983687162, 0.0077632032334804535, -0.016528675332665443, 0.0777563601732254, 0.029975425451993942, 0.009199447929859161, -0.07953013479709625, -0.035858649760484695, -0.010950209572911263, -0.043946221470832825, -0.060182929039001465, 0.07465411722660065, -0.032305940985679626, 0.005695893429219723, 0.054943133145570755, 0.03888513520359993, -0.026151912286877632, 0.019566630944609642, -0.01814926788210869, -0.002545032650232315, 0.023475972935557365, -0.06259895116090775, 0.061980318278074265, 0.01522591058164835, -0.0539185032248497, 0.018659640103578568, -0.012042452581226826, 0.0496879518032074, -0.02197534777224064, -0.006733571644872427, -0.007577977143228054, 0.03441430255770683, 0.018593601882457733, -0.03599055856466293, 0.01943904533982277, -0.04208117350935936, -0.04059156775474548, -0.03501705080270767, 0.003956829663366079, 0.01694764383137226, 0.00492587685585022, -0.02380172722041607, -0.051239077001810074, -0.0023834924213588238, -0.017616748809814453, -0.02180723287165165, 0.03151855990290642, -0.01689448393881321, 0.026547934859991074, 0.016645196825265884, -0.031572211533784866, 0.06418170779943466, 0.03461792692542076, 0.07087324559688568, 0.02233029156923294, -0.022832076996564865, -0.06185051053762436, 0.01902599446475506, 0.054349854588508606, -0.04397880658507347, -0.03884788230061531, -0.06954838335514069, 0.03354258835315704, 0.007135381456464529, 0.014787381514906883, 0.024089302867650986, 0.009942162781953812, 0.043601661920547485, -0.020424898713827133, 0.011789795011281967, -0.016637243330478668, 0.04778159409761429, -0.023860329762101173, -0.034754689782857895, -0.013887936249375343, -0.03531981632113457, -0.01923506148159504, 0.0227669607847929, 0.03597971424460411, 0.02480795979499817, -0.10458420217037201, 0.0763375386595726, -0.03279639407992363, -0.02438170090317726, -0.03902072831988335, 0.06821906566619873, -0.05949074774980545, 0.03648582845926285, -0.0016104290261864662, 0.02253587916493416, -0.07046391814947128, 0.08355659246444702, -0.020485980436205864, 0.0238859374076128, 0.02430344931781292, 0.00004602133412845433, 0.008187427185475826, 0.015183968469500542, 0.008034734055399895, 0.023062733933329582, 0.009596118703484535, -0.001018319744616747, 0.02395908161997795, -0.03275141492486, 0.017609020695090294, -0.00588995823636651, -0.005851814057677984, -0.007962710224092007, -0.014855354093015194, -0.00567030580714345, -0.013828249648213387, 0.006351991090923548, 0.020212940871715546, -0.023097248747944832, 0.046488747000694275, 0.0399366170167923, -0.005071434658020735, 0.0811939463019371, -0.04889613017439842, -0.019908718764781952, -0.013776705600321293, 0.03020472452044487, -0.08773075044155121, -0.045297589153051376, -0.017721086740493774, 0.07277290523052216, -0.01616477034986019, 0.03101208060979843, 0.00615390669554472, 0.02108352817595005, 0.04456553980708122, 0.016726691275835037, -0.009272255003452301, -0.030196338891983032, 0.015817509964108467, 0.03304382041096687, 0.019706878811120987, -0.01633072830736637, -0.046734631061553955, -0.005172131583094597, -0.03387977182865143, -0.01209476962685585, -0.0443224273622036, 0.0017267910297960043, -0.07830201834440231, 0.0040695322677493095, 0.006145866587758064, -0.06436195969581604, 0.011363510973751545, 0.0014855143381282687, -0.0533185750246048, -0.013518950901925564, 0.005056414287537336, 0.03444702550768852, 0.01936245895922184, 0.03554154187440872, 0.03783441334962845, 0.0033029818441718817, 0.01048927940428257, 0.04969649389386177, 0.03791861981153488, -0.03408106788992882, 0.041574571281671524, 0.05268681421875954, -0.0312002282589674, 0.04462416470050812, 0.018011625856161118, -0.023807616904377937, 0.03532255440950394, -0.01017962396144867, 0.014415286481380463, -0.06983870267868042, -0.024476805701851845, -0.018976029008626938, -0.005363895557820797, 0.044340360909700394, 0.03887617960572243, -0.07571834325790405, 0.042633239179849625, 0.03990248590707779, 0.005567865911871195, -0.018400687724351883, 0.08799436688423157, 0.06019579991698265, -0.04701137915253639, -0.019468387588858604, -0.005782345775514841, -0.02257371135056019, 0.014254746027290821, -0.055679816752672195, 0.009067941457033157, -0.018755393102765083, 0.0068909963592886925, 0.03807094693183899, 0.0023212742526084185, -0.014285573735833168, -0.005364928860217333, 0.02940264716744423, -0.023863861337304115, 0.024406082928180695, -0.014427736401557922, 0.005704076029360294, 0.047030966728925705, 0.058064691722393036, -0.0029671862721443176, 0.02486182376742363, -0.04730813577771187, -0.029888445511460304, 0.011147779412567616, -0.01939978450536728, -0.014426707290112972, 0.005493467207998037, -0.050578564405441284, -0.01611795648932457, 0.0025267431046813726, -0.014085795730352402, 0.01264095026999712, 0.05031896382570267, -0.029306255280971527, -0.011343788355588913, 0.05003659054636955, -0.006306434515863657, 0.041080720722675323, 0.036375969648361206, 0.0018487265333533287, 0.04117436334490776, -0.04881672188639641, -0.00948599074035883, -0.05012739077210426, 0.005164025817066431, -0.03250018134713173, -0.01452263630926609, 0.0041205184534192085, -0.02849947288632393, -0.03162892907857895, 0.028152838349342346, -0.014528554864227772, -0.030898798257112503, 0.012664484791457653, 0.033976104110479355, 0.031342390924692154, -0.043759942054748535, -0.053201500326395035, -0.031552985310554504, -0.0008825091645121574, 0.033285778015851974, 0.008292151615023613, -0.021029217168688774, 0.04309225454926491, -0.048212990164756775, 0.0077348267659544945, -0.008534501306712627, 0.01346855890005827, -0.036156054586172104, 0.0072067794390022755, 0.009507681243121624, -0.009067203849554062, -0.022516509518027306, 0.008917534723877907, 0.041192375123500824, -0.05114578455686569, -0.02913174033164978, 0.015657946467399597, 0.03280036151409149, 0.012020557187497616, -0.003670936916023493, -0.0107707679271698, -0.03941510245203972, -0.011790599673986435, -0.04474077746272087, -0.009822527877986431, -0.04936164990067482, 0.02008429355919361, -0.009878367185592651, 0.013369964435696602, 0.012339047156274319, 0.01019859965890646, -0.011002274230122566, -0.0649355873465538, 0.0018874116940423846, 0.03638024255633354, -0.02149162068963051, -0.026965130120515823, 0.013665594160556793, -0.04640282690525055, 0.040761448442935944, 0.026122746989130974, -0.006526715122163296, 0.02023882232606411, -0.029813824221491814, -0.015598642639815807, 0.07753029465675354, -0.04821203276515007, -0.039337847381830215, 0.029610024765133858, -0.0026616938412189484, 0.030646488070487976, -0.0021220098715275526, 0.059157077223062515, -0.044634222984313965, 0.022752150893211365, -0.057168591767549515, 0.015712173655629158, -0.019927432760596275, 0.05319085344672203, -0.05838007107377052, -0.031996261328458786, 0.004480340983718634, 0.022331414744257927, -0.06406605243682861, 0.008249321021139622, 0.03504549711942673, -0.004350231494754553, -0.026601580902934074, 0.02757016010582447, 0.021938160061836243, 0.011191876605153084, 0.0022193710319697857, 0.06965982168912888, 0.004977913107722998, 0.01833074539899826, -0.06682831794023514, 0.02672930434346199, 0.04021166265010834, 0.03581983596086502, -0.009911175817251205, -0.03883519023656845, -0.011078947223722935, -0.08652811497449875, -0.0075368331745266914, -0.010187816806137562, 0.02490350417792797, 0.05381486192345619, -0.010379143990576267, -0.041151490062475204, -0.015281559899449348, 0.018956780433654785, -0.06631074100732803, 0.00039376490167342126, -0.05831809714436531, -0.002521158428862691, 0.0072073438204824924, -0.05938770994544029, 0.017425736412405968, 0.01171339675784111, -0.051412638276815414, 0.051839642226696014, -0.020168421790003777, -0.043305229395627975, 0.014017644338309765, 0.02261773869395256, 0.01973598077893257, -0.05943066254258156, 0.01364194042980671, -0.011384974233806133, -0.030751457437872887, 0.012889368459582329, 0.07059628516435623, -0.1281416118144989, -0.03209700435400009, -0.04517620429396629, 0.034580014646053314, 0.015040638856589794, -0.05135355889797211, 0.03100041300058365, -0.015001744031906128, 0.0369703508913517, 0.022966792806982994, -0.0003675894404295832, -0.028524167835712433, 0.02712845243513584, -0.08188332617282867, -0.004330095835030079, 0.017679695039987564, 0.05096897855401039, 0.0031941388733685017, -0.01685686968266964, -0.011383574455976486, -0.022014759480953217, -0.04929729923605919, -0.025526326149702072, -0.04786650463938713, 0.03494320437312126, 0.03879714012145996, 0.06652111560106277, 0.0332290381193161, 0.025408105924725533, -0.03482650965452194, 0.0886983796954155, -0.02975679188966751, 0.003798961639404297, -0.0067017036490142345, -0.031256161630153656, 0.026080023497343063, -0.06109138950705528, 0.022245964035391808, -0.02678442932665348, 0.0066633690148591995, 0.10783248394727707, 0.027923835441470146, -0.002471689600497484, 0.0269499309360981, 0.0627182200551033, -0.05214455723762512, 0.011557314544916153, -0.04474033787846565, 0.06396909803152084, -0.009312566369771957, -0.002746986923739314, -0.0016549814026802778, -0.02734336629509926, 0.039581723511219025, 0.0755009576678276, 0.0363302044570446, 0.04157597944140434, -0.04748702794313431, 0.01592404767870903, 0.03957631066441536, -0.025652723386883736, -0.021194014698266983, -0.017118483781814575, 0.016263851895928383, -0.005828681401908398, -0.04318871721625328, 0.04786872863769531, 0.026444116607308388, -0.004149200394749641, 0.029125023633241653, -0.015125555917620659, -0.0015353437047451735, 0.009951465763151646, -0.02352007105946541, -0.03184136375784874, -0.009657506830990314, -0.035390593111515045, -0.013318200595676899, -0.01247593853622675, 0.015159936621785164, 0.04172013700008392, 0.0062876539304852486, -0.0030215149745345116, -0.032701846212148666, 0.003577783703804016, -0.04156092554330826, -0.02789422683417797, -0.09005268663167953, 0.016738979145884514, 0.09264072775840759, 0.018358295783400536, -0.03280188515782356, 0.0017952222842723131, 0.0012041589943692088, 0.004182395525276661, -0.0041097234934568405, 0.024829134345054626, -0.0158192478120327, 0.04143160581588745, -0.013785802759230137, -0.01717110350728035, 0.03402281552553177, -0.08280757069587708, 0.043983343988657, -0.017701590433716774, 0.02861209027469158, -0.006837154738605022, 0.029013078659772873, 0.037765830755233765, 0.009977664798498154, 0.03812788799405098, -0.011177077889442444, 0.030393552035093307, -0.06774639338254929, -0.018257776275277138, -0.022575316950678825, -0.01240385603159666, -0.08034230768680573, -0.043875958770513535, 0.03745153173804283, 0.080002561211586, -0.06984783709049225, 0.05622979253530502, 0.01997053064405918, -0.0017344795633107424, -0.01835951954126358, -0.023116938769817352, -0.008923071436583996, -0.0041232337243855, -0.011630190536379814, -0.030933676287531853, -0.0050203860737383366, 0.006521967705339193, -0.01722732186317444, 0.00958123616874218, 0.010096224024891853, -0.0025501237250864506, -0.021448103711009026, 0.02360173873603344, 0.003838954260572791, -0.030554156750440598, -0.0004673860967159271, -0.005079375114291906, 0.06727350503206253, -0.03174125403165817, 0.014778735116124153, -0.03522174060344696, -0.008328464813530445, 0.02092369832098484, -0.07680271565914154, 0.006401347927749157, 0.03537006303668022, -0.001326650264672935, 0.013903416693210602, 0.07481924444437027, 0.02616000734269619, -0.0014408593997359276, -0.04664168506860733, 0.045687753707170486, -0.0007749084034003317, 0.000430363230407238, -0.042423758655786514, 0.024934079498052597, -0.04303388670086861, -0.010043643414974213, 0.02930176444351673, 0.0009819025872275233, 0.04189327731728554, -0.11711942404508591, 0.01897139847278595, -0.03819522634148598, -0.007590006571263075, 0.06759310513734818, -0.006642937194555998, -0.045937519520521164, 0.010140329599380493, 0.0624452643096447, -0.03108050301671028, -0.06019527465105057, 0.020843813195824623, 0.056201014667749405, -0.003091961843892932, -0.09599883109331131, 0.0010715273674577475, -0.03147353604435921, 0.009914511814713478, -0.022988012060523033, -0.010549827478826046, -0.015776757150888443, 0.023396572098135948, 0.033023569732904434, 0.009955964982509613, 0.02287657931447029, -0.04028289020061493, 0.023812679573893547, -0.034872788935899734, -0.058152057230472565, 0.019627824425697327, 0.02047569863498211, 0.04523700848221779, -0.024261610582470894, -0.013767818920314312, 0.030747264623641968, -0.0166197307407856, 0.05412106215953827, 0.01576049253344536, -0.11344747990369797, -0.04000020772218704, -0.0014315942535176873, -0.017175767570734024, -0.006231861189007759, 0.013760390691459179, -0.027744688093662262, -0.005661378614604473, -0.020905030891299248, -0.01201047096401453, -0.030176689848303795, -0.02898232825100422, -0.04831630736589432, 0.028250213712453842, -0.021930892020463943, -0.025914961472153664, -0.06733318418264389, 0.05534171685576439, 0.02705639787018299, -0.025388889014720917, 0.01313561387360096, -0.023188255727291107, -0.02293304167687893, 0.027348149567842484, 0.04643342271447182, 0.016598647460341454, 0.02702450007200241, 0.08073238283395767, -0.0029446727130562067, -0.03790511563420296, -0.012518140487372875, 0.007346512749791145, 0.04593135416507721, -0.02227291651070118, 0.061190228909254074, -0.035251155495643616, 0.005141319707036018, -0.03889692947268486, 0.007274325005710125, -0.05459223687648773, -0.01815728470683098, 0.04254014417529106, -0.02293296344578266, -0.007652151398360729, -0.04144837707281113, 0.009993148036301136, 0.038938604295253754, -0.019814439117908478, 0.0728137418627739, -0.015938062220811844, -0.029033113270998, 0.0368855856359005, 0.007955306209623814, 0.018846016377210617, -0.06540048122406006, -0.015802333131432533, -0.04837051406502724, 0.03616727516055107, -0.04979311674833298, 0.03806399554014206, -0.021377306431531906, 0.019570456817746162, -0.014668108895421028, -0.028517138212919235, 0.019917452707886696, 0.027343515306711197, -0.0029402500949800014, 0.060260429978370667, 0.007562011945992708, 0.02015823870897293, -0.025586361065506935, 0.0018293806351721287, -0.03176487237215042, 0.012992735020816326, -0.010611742734909058, 0.0004997109645046294, 0.07160676270723343, 0.030041635036468506, -0.01573936641216278, 0.039943210780620575, -0.03224429488182068, 0.09274599701166153, -0.004674447234719992, -0.07559598237276077, 0.05675262212753296, 0.01630747690796852, 0.02146061137318611, -0.00685347244143486, 0.05980253592133522, -0.011527999304234982, 0.001568141276948154, -0.028529014438390732, -0.04630250483751297, -0.05200653895735741, 0.034842729568481445, 0.01660894975066185 ]
<p>I am trying to derive the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi%E2%80%93Dirac_statistics" rel="nofollow">Fermi-Dirac statistics</a> using density matrix formalism. I know that </p> <p>$$&lt;A&gt;= Tr \rho A.$$</p> <p>So I started from</p> <p>$$&lt;n(\epsilon_i)&gt;= Tr \rho n(\epsilon_i)=\frac {1}{Z} \sum e^{-\beta \epsilon_i n_i}n_i=\frac {1}{Z} e^{-\beta \epsilon_i}. $$</p> <p>In the last passage I used the pauli principle ($n_i=0,1$). Now to derive the correct Fermi-Dirac distribution I have to use for $Z=1 +e^{-\beta \epsilon_i}$. Why I have not to use the general form of </p> <p>$$Z=\prod_i (1 +e^{-\beta \epsilon_i})~?$$</p> <p>Can anybody give me a good explanation?</p>
g4064
[ 0.022774919867515564, 0.012228433042764664, -0.017894752323627472, -0.04178541526198387, 0.0782945454120636, -0.027890274301171303, 0.05142473801970482, 0.01858842372894287, -0.04347776249051094, -0.008702725172042847, -0.025582697242498398, -0.023040475323796272, 0.029298046603798866, 0.0670621320605278, 0.0384126752614975, 0.024637311697006226, 0.037013329565525055, 0.024116437882184982, 0.018117383122444153, -0.02170722745358944, -0.05196451023221016, -0.030896928161382675, 0.020880037918686867, -0.04566589370369911, 0.06851033121347427, -0.03902902081608772, -0.0399584099650383, 0.04360669106245041, -0.037845782935619354, -0.0271651279181242, 0.032542191445827484, 0.02076735906302929, 0.08699623495340347, -0.03464531898498535, 0.02665192261338234, -0.017553284764289856, 0.06607182323932648, 0.06987092643976212, 0.007209321949630976, 0.01630127616226673, -0.08535496890544891, 0.007500231731683016, 0.008890988305211067, -0.021372778341174126, 0.013151280581951141, 0.04443614184856415, -0.0931389108300209, 0.01811327412724495, -0.04074862226843834, 0.03960803151130676, 0.061240412294864655, 0.029798848554491997, -0.007516272831708193, 0.0038132648915052414, -0.0054917181842029095, -0.0005433667683973908, 0.061476849019527435, -0.046042706817388535, 0.07847820222377777, -0.012151922099292278, -0.0032815393060445786, -0.006005937233567238, -0.054346028715372086, 0.0008518751710653305, 0.04299071058630943, -0.0027488202322274446, 0.02302616648375988, 0.00888430792838335, 0.039966095238924026, 0.003360328497365117, -0.03885457292199135, -0.04324285313487053, 0.035584017634391785, -0.09190411865711212, -0.020016157999634743, -0.003233733819797635, 0.06139484792947769, 0.016836006194353104, 0.048904724419116974, -0.030594872310757637, -0.042303167283535004, -0.026746077463030815, 0.06314747035503387, -0.0007774695986881852, 0.025976188480854034, 0.018567660823464394, 0.03596771880984306, 0.02119024470448494, 0.03533768281340599, 0.01649267040193081, -0.016707396134734154, -0.031084256246685982, 0.00998745672404766, 0.043401673436164856, -0.0031173299066722393, -0.05414627492427826, -0.05177520588040352, 0.010501952841877937, -0.03915184736251831, -0.04562031850218773, 0.04816159978508949, -0.007275574374943972, 0.045369211584329605, 0.0046522775664925575, -0.03558777645230293, -0.0037789016496390104, -0.04023478552699089, 0.0019358070567250252, 0.017581822350621223, 0.010895791463553905, -0.04845840483903885, 0.02625204436480999, 0.03428109735250473, -0.06988906860351562, -0.008860940113663673, 0.025045432150363922, 0.03511057049036026, -0.044055353850126266, -0.009973817504942417, 0.017027948051691055, -0.01156413834542036, -0.0033745034597814083, 0.06911712884902954, 0.051669660955667496, -0.03941195830702782, -0.012628499418497086, -0.01712537370622158, 0.032700903713703156, 0.06538908928632736, -0.033625710755586624, 0.042645473033189774, 0.01641211286187172, 0.03378373757004738, -0.014197759330272675, -0.01048291102051735, 0.012716718949377537, -0.06939570605754852, 0.04445231333374977, 0.030278746038675308, 0.020318344235420227, -0.018658535555005074, -0.04923861846327782, 0.030382772907614708, -0.03868147358298302, -0.02168908901512623, -0.025998936966061592, -0.030970800668001175, -0.018212247639894485, 0.04467277228832245, 0.0352361798286438, -0.03272760286927223, 0.04698801785707474, -0.03849020227789879, 0.0077644577249884605, 0.0102998036891222, 0.06770014017820358, 0.009769430384039879, -0.03083202615380287, -0.016625147312879562, 0.03010043501853943, 0.028358837589621544, -0.02551925741136074, -0.058887310326099396, 0.009165572933852673, -0.01304664183408022, -0.027287188917398453, 0.0010473064612597227, -0.05648094043135643, 0.019014233723282814, -0.01572362519800663, -0.008411915972828865, 0.004810655489563942, -0.044664569199085236, -0.038242194801568985, -0.012589922174811363, 0.026927180588245392, -0.03983820974826813, 0.011879057623445988, 0.03603619337081909, 0.002634903648868203, -0.031959790736436844, -0.02082778885960579, 0.023723548278212547, -0.015424014069139957, 0.03800047188997269, -0.02716110274195671, 0.08273626863956451, 0.038132138550281525, -0.052837371826171875, 0.02190057560801506, -0.014520496129989624, -0.07027306407690048, -0.014164643362164497, 0.02499852515757084, 0.017469167709350586, -0.00010655889491317794, 0.043159302324056625, -0.09193061292171478, -0.03663981705904007, 0.0651569664478302, 0.035369936376810074, 0.02684619277715683, -0.0017010171432048082, -0.021431317552924156, 0.019135456532239914, -0.03161360323429108, -0.013476936146616936, -0.02532721497118473, 0.036869730800390244, 0.011768192052841187, -0.01406202930957079, -0.057541195303201675, 0.01678650453686714, 0.017438560724258423, -0.021520288661122322, -0.03691169619560242, 0.00446274084970355, 0.008599785156548023, -0.014276029542088509, 0.026982156559824944, -0.0898774266242981, -0.041496578603982925, 0.008747673593461514, 0.039552342146635056, 0.03474240377545357, 0.029661059379577637, 0.01913650706410408, -0.021754372864961624, -0.008034390397369862, 0.05021214112639427, -0.0717288926243782, -0.018177611753344536, -0.11825539171695709, 0.024646354839205742, 0.02817443758249283, 0.005874210502952337, 0.018696486949920654, -0.009411320090293884, -0.0017704355996102095, 0.018183410167694092, -0.0576389916241169, -0.03231631591916084, 0.0048236725851893425, -0.01902746967971325, 0.026616092771291733, -0.015560565516352654, 0.025601662695407867, -0.0239078588783741, -0.008817164227366447, -0.03908107429742813, -0.017917200922966003, 0.029116567224264145, -0.04103503376245499, -0.021839911118149757, 0.05440310016274452, -0.05347562953829765, -0.02164166048169136, 0.00900299847126007, 0.00788024254143238, 0.016118859872221947, 0.012209664098918438, -0.05358298122882843, -0.007178664207458496, -0.023857543244957924, -0.026372242718935013, 0.024440674111247063, 0.03985008969902992, 0.020610995590686798, 0.04130139574408531, 0.04412558302283287, 0.012099416926503181, 0.09101760387420654, 0.042857006192207336, 0.004176942631602287, -0.011518831364810467, -0.05561038851737976, -0.0085608484223485, -0.008093389682471752, 0.009493522346019745, -0.01290171779692173, -0.01820443384349346, -0.019872592762112617, 0.027861805632710457, -0.00780339865013957, 0.04887627437710762, -0.05082275718450546, 0.003781731706112623, -0.010759925469756126, -0.01178846973925829, -0.02418701909482479, -0.0012489986838772893, 0.03056550770998001, 0.012486585415899754, 0.0020207539200782776, 0.015351210720837116, -0.0319502055644989, 0.005577266216278076, -0.058638401329517365, -0.0053542423993349075, 0.05357570946216583, 0.005999703425914049, -0.029082464054226875, 0.0016976025654003024, -0.021393973380327225, 0.09356915205717087, 0.05466952547430992, -0.03159376233816147, -0.03844362497329712, -0.04060804471373558, -0.03663364425301552, 0.004224349744617939, 0.006524134427309036, 0.03523147478699684, -0.03692344203591347, -0.01719699054956436, -0.012884825468063354, 0.019499395042657852, -0.005699320696294308, 0.048530202358961105, -0.055137913674116135, -0.016068369150161743, -0.030360383912920952, 0.012225328013300896, 0.00823865458369255, 0.01796405389904976, 0.019668983295559883, -0.04552016407251358, 0.012481150217354298, 0.030063150450587273, -0.01156289130449295, 0.06188606843352318, -0.006257827393710613, 0.04989594221115112, -0.05147190019488335, -0.11950549483299255, -0.012362797744572163, -0.02304794080555439, 0.03409221023321152, -0.021544331684708595, -0.022589460015296936, -0.0714629516005516, -0.007225668989121914, -0.013446721248328686, 0.0248296856880188, 0.01328676100820303, -0.04815850779414177, 0.010535002686083317, 0.046234242618083954, -0.004067179746925831, 0.04887290298938751, -0.026453524827957153, -0.006501744966953993, 0.043239228427410126, 0.021314384415745735, -0.05275936424732208, 0.04649963229894638, -0.0016635446809232235, 0.031840693205595016, 0.08091039210557938, 0.023041721433401108, 0.034375131130218506, -0.033568765968084335, 0.021595453843474388, 0.011859679594635963, 0.0298510380089283, 0.016225697472691536, 0.004511051345616579, 0.03315781429409981, -0.011171089485287666, 0.008552409708499908, 0.00399369839578867, -0.010113256052136421, 0.07402848452329636, 0.04535006359219551, 0.03333243727684021, -0.0020296829752624035, 0.019549129530787468, 0.02996966987848282, -0.05161723494529724, 0.04654928669333458, 0.004905384965240955, -0.0011103673605248332, -0.011593161150813103, 0.032743629068136215, 0.02741956152021885, 0.01803489401936531, -0.056811101734638214, 0.012781971134245396, -0.014829983934760094, -0.03562014549970627, -0.01019658986479044, -0.024306103587150574, 0.0067356606014072895, -0.01830635592341423, -0.007900319993495941, 0.021738596260547638, 0.023315656930208206, -0.004018886014819145, -0.006014194339513779, 0.052701376378536224, -0.05896305665373802, 0.008727905340492725, 0.03914080560207367, -0.022927334532141685, 0.009803395718336105, 0.00048755781608633697, -0.04781688377261162, 0.009801140055060387, 0.048726651817560196, -0.008408919908106327, -0.021853551268577576, 0.00948313158005476, 0.051182571798563004, -0.02706211246550083, 0.04494267329573631, -0.01801193132996559, 0.04844965413212776, -0.0810748040676117, 0.004851926118135452, -0.00014591187937185168, -0.008899188600480556, -0.008652357384562492, 0.01018137764185667, -0.005308805499225855, -0.01094372570514679, 0.08568102866411209, 0.011791645549237728, 0.052614882588386536, -0.02576286531984806, -0.024241991341114044, -0.09189234673976898, 0.02226547710597515, -0.06483915448188782, -0.004705001134425402, -0.0764366090297699, 0.00962911918759346, -0.04363059252500534, 0.06834591925144196, -0.011456990614533424, -0.015967106446623802, 0.0030531093943864107, -0.01387663371860981, 0.03318782523274422, 0.014695432968437672, 0.030831214040517807, 0.032605089247226715, -0.02735287882387638, -0.04144378378987312, -0.044304829090833664, 0.034478574991226196, 0.0032912360038608313, 0.03720802068710327, -0.019033964723348618, 0.029634686186909676, 0.01642642356455326, 0.0033461719285696745, -0.00469534657895565, 0.028737645596265793, 0.05085305869579315, 0.015420068986713886, -0.058299172669649124, -0.00032991243642754853, -0.02153199166059494, -0.025431206449866295, 0.007280481513589621, -0.0037869741208851337, -0.018998095765709877, -0.0021111995447427034, 0.0062791407108306885, -0.0018038429552689195, -0.036048028618097305, -0.020106952637434006, 0.006900824140757322, -0.06530860811471939, 0.026676932349801064, 0.043888941407203674, -0.020176857709884644, -0.002811384154483676, -0.042334429919719696, -0.039767563343048096, -0.07364223897457123, -0.054100412875413895, 0.05356033146381378, 0.01656065694987774, 0.04290345683693886, 0.026748938485980034, 0.010153358802199364, -0.028647635132074356, 0.010938565246760845, -0.016201414167881012, 0.029245661571621895, 0.04081563651561737, -0.007124610245227814, 0.029341010376811028, 0.022848237305879593, -0.044855475425720215, 0.0519070066511631, -0.027008481323719025, 0.017869718372821808, -0.008648708462715149, -0.011727329343557358, -0.03597276285290718, -0.06390976160764694, -0.004720267839729786, 0.0006082420004531741, 0.040937330573797226, 0.10376928746700287, 0.02105070650577545, 0.0057757035829126835, -0.02355228364467621, 0.05375600978732109, -0.00506383553147316, 0.05205945670604706, -0.05292617529630661, -0.0617230162024498, -0.016254734247922897, 0.013305958360433578, -0.00814124010503292, -0.002187674632295966, -0.03452834486961365, 0.058835797011852264, -0.02014041878283024, 0.03311529755592346, -0.05672668293118477, -0.007102927193045616, -0.0621207095682621, -0.04259275272488594, -0.03608186915516853, 0.01716236025094986, -0.005361895076930523, -0.047740641981363297, -0.046999741345644, 0.00645545544102788, -0.0066011641174554825, -0.03395911678671837, -0.022379321977496147, 0.0024921295698732138, 0.02451854944229126, 0.019393816590309143, -0.005229326896369457, 0.028434135019779205, 0.019571853801608086, 0.0356539823114872, 0.04704033583402634, -0.06321096420288086, -0.01506571751087904, -0.018111377954483032, -0.00801935140043497, -0.0076652877032756805, -0.01679409295320511, 0.00048493954818695784, -0.004691450856626034, -0.031979065388441086, -0.003154285019263625, -0.009455284103751183, 0.03905494883656502, 0.04903719574213028, -0.01675664819777012, -0.02514849789440632, 0.016197701916098595, -0.036125022917985916, -0.040144309401512146, 0.05108140408992767, 0.028154999017715454, 0.00009656206384534016, -0.024515435099601746, -0.012478027492761612, -0.020917536690831184, -0.004788567312061787, 0.05545373260974884, 0.03969290107488632, 0.03589136525988579, -0.026365207508206367, 0.046505220234394073, 0.05043233558535576, -0.024898309260606766, -0.007152210455387831, -0.06694746762514114, 0.008579392917454243, -0.012824049219489098, 0.02705153077840805, 0.0301248487085104, 0.018237054347991943, 0.003784449538215995, -0.060689281672239304, 0.019918369129300117, -0.0030572928953915834, -0.028517482802271843, -0.026200732216238976, -0.0010119625367224216, -0.021353479474782944, -0.0013141263043507934, -0.013168809935450554, -0.02479168400168419, -0.06460516154766083, 0.018346702679991722, -0.05347495153546333, -0.04242689162492752, 0.013123443350195885, -0.048274945467710495, 0.011572104878723621, 0.02685151994228363, -0.042213648557662964, 0.015239743515849113, 0.06894545257091522, -0.022704049944877625, 0.017316389828920364, -0.018997138366103172, 0.013319302350282669, 0.04425347223877907, -0.00437536695972085, 0.020801549777388573, -0.03044428862631321, 0.035708650946617126, 0.026483358815312386, 0.00857692863792181, -0.014834094792604446, 0.011043805629014969, -0.02111075632274151, 0.05819924548268318, 0.018974794074892998, -0.042722154408693314, -0.02305871807038784, -0.042783450335264206, 0.05325385555624962, 0.04928402230143547, -0.025862544775009155, -0.005209924653172493, 0.0828092098236084, -0.018390800803899765, -0.015814557671546936, -0.016810018569231033, -0.05448714271187782, 0.049182161688804626, -0.043913375586271286, 0.03665831312537193, -0.02544412761926651, 0.02742346003651619, 0.07905146479606628, 0.02871229127049446, -0.046382173895835876, 0.03148205205798149, 0.04250800237059593, 0.000921780476346612, -0.0434914268553257, 0.03319652006030083, 0.017354100942611694, 0.08627878129482269, -0.10664889961481094, 0.003778634825721383, 0.07866166532039642, 0.01634061522781849, 0.005312959663569927, 0.038908932358026505, 0.02445734478533268, -0.007804383523762226, 0.007101097144186497, 0.012650544755160809, 0.05037117376923561, -0.0730719268321991, 0.012008404359221458, -0.03062525950372219, -0.0036792822647839785, -0.05135014280676842, 0.0190193559974432, 0.03149974346160889, -0.021701686084270477, 0.0018638208275660872, -0.004129460547119379, -0.04749099537730217, -0.0012309224111959338, -0.009439622052013874, -0.04105844348669052, -0.05034511908888817, 0.050368521362543106, 0.00836093258112669, 0.01263140607625246, -0.006119587458670139, -0.09109480679035187, 0.0019706839229911566, 0.008958833292126656, -0.021775148808956146, -0.017370712012052536, -0.07352806627750397, 0.0109825124964118, -0.00023597668041475117, -0.03289971128106117, -0.023173561319708824, 0.0014160770224407315, 0.05525905266404152, -0.0003300025418866426, -0.03843115642666817, 0.009193340316414833, -0.02621930092573166, -0.05677727982401848, 0.01821434497833252, 0.006830133032053709, 0.024068698287010193, -0.00047463583177886903, 0.06711544841527939, 0.044849757105112076, 0.009860885329544544, -0.04808371141552925, 0.006979859434068203, 0.05881381779909134, -0.037638887763023376, 0.015429018065333366, 0.015063338913023472, -0.04517942667007446, 0.015341158024966717, 0.02516423910856247, -0.055584777146577835, -0.02313649095594883, 0.08441136032342911, -0.018113428726792336, -0.011565032415091991, -0.035383980721235275, -0.004372684750705957, -0.028993111103773117, -0.032692693173885345, 0.028329964727163315, -0.024605095386505127, -0.007143899332731962, -0.0028005221392959356, -0.03200602903962135, -0.010552666150033474, -0.06420967727899551, 0.0427127406001091, 0.07824917137622833, 0.05384340509772301, -0.06688717007637024, 0.006001550704240799, -0.03856021538376808, 0.03394291177392006, -0.02517085149884224, 0.056086983531713486, 0.05530517175793648, -0.037495922297239304, 0.046589192003011703, 0.0108879329636693, 0.01520028430968523, 0.045893698930740356, 0.06443791836500168, 0.025429895147681236, -0.015236463397741318, -0.008217895403504372, -0.04366660118103027, 0.0040433090180158615, 0.04366353899240494, 0.04026626795530319, -0.05505124852061272, -0.013656063005328178, -0.04661136865615845, 0.029125312343239784, 0.026381827890872955, -0.06930253654718399, 0.07285212725400925, 0.015590008348226547, 0.03953903540968895, 0.008521993644535542, 0.0014636203413829207, -0.05115988105535507, -0.02583979070186615, 0.010955216363072395, -0.06015578657388687, -0.004980572033673525, -0.03905647620558739, -0.04458430036902428 ]
<p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/hbp7B.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>The mass is released at height $h$ above the spring, how far will the spring move? $E_i=mgh, E_f= kx^2/2+mgx$...why the second equation isn't $ E_f= kx^2/2-mgx$? Since it is below the "zero".</p>
g4065
[ 0.01934831403195858, 0.010401603765785694, 0.008328838273882866, 0.0694379135966301, -0.004527977202087641, 0.027634669095277786, 0.03731992468237877, 0.0360962338745594, -0.06414470076560974, -0.0384986475110054, -0.08761557936668396, 0.05476786568760872, 0.044995225965976715, -0.007699429057538509, 0.006233851425349712, -0.0036580050364136696, 0.09322581440210342, -0.00783759355545044, 0.01996809057891369, 0.036596912890672684, -0.03625881299376488, -0.016932127997279167, -0.02466377429664135, -0.026565145701169968, 0.06240949407219887, 0.03535233438014984, 0.059040702879428864, 0.012676546350121498, -0.07474593818187714, 0.012530244886875153, 0.0016972306184470654, 0.014662936329841614, 0.027986647561192513, -0.036047738045454025, -0.07054436206817627, -0.01835738867521286, 0.0399743914604187, 0.015736058354377747, -0.024078471586108208, -0.0472903698682785, 0.04488211125135422, -0.022694056853652, -0.0026127707678824663, -0.004707633052021265, 0.028526274487376213, 0.013164129108190536, 0.015661532059311867, 0.02144976146519184, -0.04578861594200134, 0.00205452018417418, -0.0023512705229222775, 0.03233512118458748, 0.01822945661842823, -0.013462893664836884, -0.01857692189514637, -0.003846463281661272, 0.007556595839560032, -0.028765669092535973, 0.08445683121681213, 0.01719193533062935, 0.011051766574382782, 0.0024661605712026358, -0.015046041458845139, -0.0260755717754364, 0.06243551895022392, 0.042679738253355026, -0.05341289937496185, 0.014955124817788601, 0.014433749951422215, 0.021204043179750443, -0.0058463807217776775, 0.04610789939761162, -0.014758969657123089, -0.026988456025719643, -0.034986063838005066, -0.012878062203526497, 0.03933155909180641, -0.01469899620860815, 0.02209859900176525, -0.04222121834754944, -0.04225971922278404, 0.03729967400431633, 0.0045507196336984634, -0.03440874442458153, 0.0450085811316967, 0.024244384840130806, 0.034171123057603836, 0.07821781933307648, -0.01541049312800169, 0.003694287734106183, 0.014325168915092945, 0.00443049892783165, 0.02274140529334545, -0.007407535798847675, -0.02061167173087597, -0.06806822121143341, -0.027721844613552094, 0.056944724172353745, 0.0504927858710289, -0.03361114114522934, -0.0253542922437191, -0.004521403927356005, 0.005794973112642765, 0.03320314735174179, -0.0064647020772099495, 0.034266892820596695, 0.0412026010453701, 0.04411493241786957, -0.020381737500429153, 0.03952579200267792, 0.006162707228213549, -0.009051384404301643, -0.05739232525229454, 0.0024106414057314396, -0.06076725944876671, -0.02740500681102276, 0.004785060416907072, -0.00415383605286479, 0.028223859146237373, -0.014119328930974007, 0.02314908057451248, 0.015859173610806465, 0.029446493834257126, 0.042890407145023346, -0.07669184356927872, -0.09649591147899628, -0.018631111830472946, 0.035368308424949646, -0.006947120651602745, -0.027039021253585815, -0.07704860717058182, -0.020445089787244797, 0.006521761883050203, 0.04357456788420677, 0.0037280472461134195, 0.06188732385635376, -0.00596797838807106, 0.02367454580962658, -0.04037797823548317, 0.018041623756289482, 0.0032435553148388863, -0.020539158955216408, 0.0006734638591296971, -0.04057317599654198, -0.0481717474758625, 0.019273970276117325, 0.047081220895051956, 0.012719464488327503, 0.026199892163276672, -0.00982760451734066, -0.023147685453295708, 0.015503836795687675, -0.014264375902712345, 0.027257803827524185, 0.024796470999717712, -0.03282139077782631, 0.05395719036459923, -0.00918726995587349, -0.011698839254677296, 0.021101564168930054, 0.021819598972797394, -0.033575259149074554, 0.024804100394248962, -0.04105542227625847, -0.060787711292505264, 0.002772463718429208, -0.03236088529229164, 0.010890549048781395, -0.022750524803996086, -0.04634373262524605, -0.0845264196395874, -0.0010676969541236758, 0.014702584594488144, 0.06626641005277634, -0.036277931183576584, -0.05284940451383591, 0.06596895307302475, -0.010588417761027813, 0.012833676300942898, 0.0059601785615086555, 0.009356385096907616, 0.002734332112595439, 0.03140835836529732, 0.007400625851005316, -0.013159158639609814, 0.008355053141713142, 0.034584205597639084, 0.056989990174770355, -0.0016558527713641524, -0.0315975546836853, 0.002811538754031062, -0.004617726895958185, 0.005635420326143503, 0.06063579022884369, -0.013485212810337543, 0.021633878350257874, -0.01511436142027378, -0.017293516546487808, -0.02097887545824051, 0.08295668661594391, 0.011293786577880383, 0.04941275343298912, 0.03404128924012184, -0.02279329113662243, 0.012334284372627735, 0.00715220021083951, 0.05101115256547928, -0.005482928827404976, -0.00611621281132102, -0.0371064618229866, -0.03266686946153641, -0.02223379537463188, -0.00019869752577506006, 0.0383361391723156, 0.050750769674777985, -0.01162264496088028, 0.016402609646320343, 0.012888972647488117, 0.0436430424451828, 0.06179642304778099, -0.03228418529033661, 0.0025604604743421078, 0.01887926459312439, -0.03716067597270012, -0.04959750920534134, -0.02786553092300892, -0.021953662857413292, -0.04611457139253616, -0.019418219104409218, -0.03128795698285103, 0.015340262092649937, 0.03533720597624779, -0.0031991100404411554, 0.024535685777664185, 0.00141861941665411, 0.04542132839560509, -0.026507504284381866, 0.028735507279634476, 0.019512861967086792, 0.031971920281648636, 0.002249218290671706, 0.011103806085884571, -0.013482394628226757, -0.0440182089805603, 0.01943078078329563, -0.016730457544326782, 0.07221734523773193, 0.0038617930840700865, 0.008646545000374317, 0.054446741938591, 0.029433932155370712, -0.03292565047740936, -0.0019358734134584665, 0.03527075797319412, -0.003191182157024741, 0.010341406799852848, -0.07410065829753876, -0.03417263552546501, -0.06769329309463501, -0.0691838189959526, -0.022164080291986465, -0.07335992902517319, 0.04230719804763794, -0.03528483211994171, -0.09208283573389053, -0.045206256210803986, -0.061419546604156494, 0.02093600668013096, 0.03699352964758873, -0.008989674970507622, 0.011832816526293755, 0.09195194393396378, -0.0037770788185298443, 0.1020270586013794, -0.0727037861943245, -0.04160188511013985, 0.018458032980561256, -0.022261474281549454, -0.007041809149086475, 0.013672140426933765, -0.014405841939151287, 0.01942376233637333, -0.010460183955729008, -0.005240674130618572, 0.004980922676622868, -0.024875709787011147, -0.03683315962553024, 0.04673216491937637, -0.07009345293045044, -0.010813465341925621, -0.03397690877318382, 0.0697612315416336, 0.0977150946855545, -0.01444630604237318, -0.007463384419679642, 0.0994022935628891, 0.012566830962896347, -0.026913823559880257, -0.012474101968109608, 0.0036452256608754396, -0.026687227189540863, -0.028048641979694366, 0.0004372905823402107, -0.02328040637075901, -0.057287540286779404, 0.0067629097029566765, 0.0551392026245594, -0.03460763767361641, 0.02507910318672657, 0.011250156909227371, 0.0087291169911623, 0.04627280682325363, 0.08419650793075562, -0.0042422739788889885, -0.10533375293016434, 0.003132696496322751, -0.020908862352371216, -0.02055216208100319, -0.019307676702737808, 0.006754093337804079, -0.0241402480751276, -0.052741412073373795, 0.022242700681090355, -0.01275577675551176, -0.007211796939373016, 0.02626609615981579, -0.00939128827303648, 0.03550785407423973, -0.02369733713567257, -0.007710856851190329, 0.04623638838529587, 0.04157966002821922, 0.017134981229901314, -0.03625018149614334, 0.03741730749607086, -0.02156398445367813, 0.015726203098893166, -0.0025242185220122337, 0.008283648639917374, -0.009443439543247223, -0.04306635633111, -0.016365883871912956, -0.02945627272129059, -0.002652061404660344, -0.01079496368765831, -0.001468201633542776, -0.010948495008051395, 0.0014168076450005174, -0.010958130471408367, -0.054390113800764084, -0.013801897875964642, -0.045002203434705734, -0.02399166114628315, 0.0018513660179451108, 0.009553681127727032, 0.025642838329076767, 0.00815517921000719, -0.021464891731739044, -0.05583902448415756, -0.002718837233260274, 0.00327977049164474, -0.05310925096273422, 0.01834876649081707, 0.08252260088920593, 0.013961508870124817, -0.026169516146183014, -0.03152091056108475, 0.0993850901722908, -0.031245864927768707, -0.021506914868950844, -0.03244274854660034, -0.0526595301926136, 0.05364726483821869, 0.009122423827648163, 0.030789928510785103, -0.015266318805515766, 0.04538298398256302, 0.00749039463698864, -0.027988646179437637, 0.015834884718060493, 0.012126809917390347, -0.03656502813100815, -0.023087671026587486, -0.016502737998962402, -0.04868266358971596, 0.012982973828911781, -0.0613732784986496, -0.023680763319134712, 0.0072694625705480576, -0.03605043888092041, -0.01579141803085804, 0.0005558154080063105, 0.019737200811505318, 0.05259719863533974, 0.03365812450647354, 0.030402114614844322, 0.008589718490839005, -0.0075809042900800705, -0.0271537434309721, -0.021436462178826332, -0.02540445327758789, 0.04113893583416939, -0.05334802716970444, -0.021246641874313354, -0.020932352170348167, 0.033879563212394714, 0.05127758905291557, 0.00004163565608905628, 0.046049050986766815, -0.03770475834608078, 0.07387939840555191, -0.04543808102607727, -0.0313100591301918, -0.00942471157759428, 0.07525209337472916, -0.0327221043407917, -0.028490303084254265, 0.021299470216035843, -0.03543002903461456, -0.008676900528371334, 0.03994887322187424, 0.05233113840222359, 0.022646665573120117, -0.02964617684483528, 0.024223456159234047, 0.061296191066503525, 0.021928448230028152, -0.053422339260578156, -0.02959444932639599, -0.07850684225559235, -0.02974058873951435, 0.012023836374282837, -0.006008360534906387, -0.0015690152067691088, -0.054576028138399124, 0.09333062171936035, 0.04444872587919235, 0.03425939753651619, -0.036614663898944855, 0.026448147371411324, 0.03174017369747162, 0.015173249877989292, -0.02468918450176716, 0.034585896879434586, -0.029577206820249557, -0.02180289477109909, -0.03017294593155384, -0.03532981500029564, -0.02029864862561226, -0.018524589017033577, -0.03550304099917412, -0.06924446672201157, 0.013753961771726608, 0.005958242807537317, 0.0003886136692017317, 0.0051939100958406925, -0.05781475082039833, 0.01964549906551838, 0.004368059802800417, 0.011906212195754051, -0.0017059334786608815, -0.046866416931152344, 0.023505819961428642, 0.04379112645983696, 0.05620535463094711, -0.08788983523845673, -0.024981368333101273, -0.0552467480301857, 0.0007648597820661962, 0.03659631311893463, -0.007131922524422407, 0.016124553978443146, 0.028227655217051506, -0.006897700019180775, 0.030444446951150894, 0.061800211668014526, 0.008628858253359795, 0.009470273740589619, 0.0639152079820633, -0.04913503676652908, -0.019230730831623077, 0.010863998904824257, -0.013068970292806625, 0.005396735388785601, -0.0030237273313105106, 0.04278187081217766, -0.03539571166038513, -0.005085709039121866, 0.02192656695842743, -0.04798533767461777, 0.08503797650337219, 0.009475788101553917, -0.01861768402159214, -0.018179647624492645, 0.03793330490589142, 0.007971742190420628, 0.016997745260596275, 0.02570877969264984, 0.027248550206422806, -0.01603168249130249, -0.05985649675130844, -0.005645078141242266, -0.0010562434326857328, 0.04720720276236534, -0.010997149161994457, 0.021672816947102547, 0.03308127075433731, -0.013851355761289597, 0.011447813361883163, 0.01743878237903118, 0.0390140637755394, -0.030936039984226227, 0.01732119917869568, 0.003264171537011862, 0.055229105055332184, -0.02744772471487522, -0.014222991652786732, 0.0015348632587119937, 0.01144228782504797, -0.008624998852610588, 0.0877251997590065, -0.020990915596485138, 0.05235929787158966, -0.05228827893733978, -0.005961433984339237, -0.0016233394853770733, -0.0177178792655468, -0.04151785001158714, -0.05305452272295952, 0.04525938630104065, -0.013299909420311451, -0.035764001309871674, 0.0460708923637867, -0.03468019887804985, -0.00033096058177761734, 0.01700037159025669, 0.011701973155140877, 0.007621979806572199, -0.00553945591673255, -0.022927768528461456, 0.008364785462617874, -0.03231316804885864, 0.02757488377392292, 0.09722905606031418, 0.008304470218718052, -0.008040298707783222, 0.014435164630413055, -0.04457038268446922, 0.06046615168452263, -0.01706967130303383, -0.042929161339998245, 0.10887844860553741, -0.023927485570311546, 0.06398842483758926, -0.007486468646675348, 0.0604790523648262, -0.013364515267312527, -0.04123701527714729, -0.02326207607984543, -0.014007028192281723, 0.03403553366661072, 0.039260100573301315, 0.016466647386550903, 0.025320278480648994, 0.04586876183748245, -0.06805790960788727, 0.01233320776373148, 0.012240146286785603, 0.08442579954862595, 0.03997381404042244, -0.06512533873319626, 0.013720902614295483, 0.018360882997512817, 0.06574052572250366, -0.010885198600590229, 0.019680777564644814, -0.04871804267168045, -0.033606722950935364, -0.006164845544844866, 0.010630815289914608, -0.01991758681833744, 0.040463756769895554, 0.02853679098188877, -0.01876089535653591, -0.005290043540298939, 0.003587441984564066, -0.0265035443007946, -0.016137657687067986, 0.05408348888158798, -0.00422026589512825, -0.03614256903529167, -0.036408431828022, -0.006419570650905371, 0.02338486723601818, -0.01808626763522625, -0.01794624887406826, -0.005565948318690062, 0.012243100441992283, -0.010063720867037773, 0.004109511151909828, 0.012379992753267288, 0.02130179852247238, 0.0890660509467125, -0.025323309004306793, 0.019771015271544456, 0.006696492433547974, -0.024067027494311333, 0.09201056510210037, -0.02600361779332161, -0.02811090089380741, -0.02713131159543991, 0.046778954565525055, 0.014105788432061672, -0.020618408918380737, 0.008892168290913105, -0.05437413603067398, 0.04023755341768265, 0.0766356959939003, -0.013827326707541943, -0.030904240906238556, -0.013408253900706768, 0.022646820172667503, 0.03053324669599533, -0.08576498925685883, -0.04797990247607231, -0.022960377857089043, -0.006127822678536177, 0.021056141704320908, -0.007849738001823425, 0.017340369522571564, 0.022751042619347572, 0.06216033920645714, -0.07355239987373352, 0.013599754311144352, -0.01925213821232319, 0.005839301273226738, -0.006631249096244574, 0.018833138048648834, 0.03919626399874687, 0.03736778721213341, 0.0029571671038866043, 0.043305233120918274, 0.01149893831461668, -0.005535735748708248, -0.045671913772821426, 0.004807206802070141, 0.02834462560713291, 0.0004261785070411861, -0.06910578906536102, -0.02181451953947544, -0.00912738498300314, -0.0659199133515358, -0.03213402256369591, -0.03304724395275116, 0.010475300252437592, -0.01923772506415844, -0.006669905036687851, -0.03043537028133869, 0.04637105390429497, 0.0024392674677073956, -0.08924255520105362, 0.012959909625351429, 0.06519205868244171, 0.018698513507843018, -0.006256436463445425, 0.020712213590741158, 0.01545552909374237, 0.01243976317346096, -0.0034492642153054476, -0.047488171607255936, 0.02705344744026661, -0.009256533347070217, -0.038506973534822464, -0.01867617666721344, -0.030261972919106483, 0.01336518581956625, -0.017122089862823486, -0.004755851812660694, -0.007303287740796804, 0.01176356989890337, 0.020618397742509842, 0.0010355828562751412, -0.01649394817650318, -0.04149739071726799, -0.02023029513657093, 0.008594508282840252, -0.051296595484018326, 0.017891351133584976, -0.00916738249361515, 0.014459476806223392, -0.025762304663658142, 0.006845502648502588, 0.011750145815312862, -0.06470824033021927, -0.027052827179431915, -0.006064282264560461, -0.03376704454421997, -0.014903361909091473, 0.03904889523983002, -0.017571965232491493, 0.022940488532185555, 0.014440055005252361, 0.008810837753117085, 0.028526054695248604, 0.02362976409494877, 0.0505102314054966, 0.019890321418642998, 0.03787579387426376, -0.041397541761398315, 0.007265603635460138, 0.029553331434726715, 0.05370275303721428, 0.024528320878744125, 0.04998167231678963, -0.012878592126071453, 0.037864070385694504, -0.01675058901309967, -0.040351271629333496, 0.01219706330448389, -0.0846395343542099, -0.026072032749652863, 0.042409107089042664, 0.017217276617884636, -0.09965232759714127, -0.057443004101514816, -0.03683244809508324, -0.015131842344999313, 0.0359899066388607, -0.017834126949310303, -0.021038787439465523, -0.07538195699453354, -0.054771408438682556, 0.0016080675413832068, 0.01746845245361328, -0.043498698621988297, -0.021336201578378677, -0.004142156336456537, -0.016149109229445457, 0.012361938133835793, 0.026318691670894623, -0.04039081931114197, -0.07970798760652542, 0.012311316095292568, -0.0036450207699090242, 0.0104470020160079, -0.007909039035439491, -0.02870374172925949, 0.08222266286611557, 0.03343256562948227, -0.04350157454609871, 0.027419280260801315, 0.017307592555880547, 0.004870516248047352, 0.05154207721352577, 0.00341212609782815, -0.10160225629806519, 0.022914303466677666, -0.003370830090716481, 0.013977105729281902, 0.010474096983671188, -0.04957113042473793, -0.03869285061955452, -0.0027867804747074842, 0.01557273231446743, -0.014252681285142899, -0.03449149802327156, 0.0022122827358543873, 0.0005385045078583062 ]
<p>In the first term the energies are given by the Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin (WKB) formula</p> <p>$$ \oint p dq = 2\pi \left( n+\frac{1}{2} \right) $$</p> <p>However, can this formula be improved to include further corrections? For example the wave function in the WKB approach can be evaluated to several orders of magnitude in $ \hbar $</p>
g4066
[ -0.019221875816583633, -0.021580493077635765, -0.0010891563724726439, 0.01773655414581299, 0.0012156461598351598, 0.0043847388587892056, -0.021505290642380714, 0.021624282002449036, -0.08920024335384369, 0.050897154957056046, 0.03986266255378723, 0.04880871623754501, -0.015826476737856865, 0.0727246031165123, -0.0041387369856238365, -0.008760607801377773, 0.042208388447761536, 0.050516046583652496, 0.011554691009223461, -0.02871784009039402, -0.08582174777984619, -0.012916460633277893, -0.04299800843000412, 0.0017963838763535023, 0.016539987176656723, 0.01187788788229227, -0.01282394677400589, 0.025311581790447235, -0.06927073746919632, 0.07345614582300186, -0.05818924680352211, 0.0037518080789595842, 0.019536873325705528, -0.02641700766980648, 0.012458493001759052, 0.0747058242559433, 0.05703260004520416, -0.00619793776422739, 0.06262882053852081, -0.03227602690458298, -0.04120444506406784, -0.021748900413513184, 0.04189058393239975, 0.0008815900073386729, 0.017030702903866768, -0.03643130883574486, -0.005615356378257275, -0.0023341334890574217, -0.005676378961652517, -0.01628696359694004, -0.04151786491274834, 0.06016930192708969, 0.08209413290023804, 0.006195963826030493, -0.03985805809497833, -0.010428997687995434, 0.000031434257834916934, 0.01576855033636093, 0.062322020530700684, 0.10373793542385101, 0.014045603573322296, -0.003705634269863367, -0.021798787638545036, -0.03223634511232376, 0.012014569714665413, 0.002081296406686306, -0.036338794976472855, 0.00880950503051281, -0.025209004059433937, -0.058421723544597626, 0.034154605120420456, 0.010167697444558144, -0.07101532071828842, -0.02661396935582161, 0.02932462841272354, 0.030103910714387894, 0.007756163831800222, -0.03881311044096947, -0.01067665871232748, 0.017094017937779427, -0.0016693812794983387, 0.020450059324502945, -0.026598811149597168, -0.05553033575415611, 0.017233628779649734, -0.0804031491279602, 0.005829234607517719, 0.07405005395412445, 0.017599446699023247, -0.021318640559911728, -0.0260431207716465, 0.008686638437211514, 0.0160878524184227, -0.0027790500316768885, 0.09084265679121017, 0.01674160175025463, -0.017404640093445778, -0.004966458771377802, -0.02092023380100727, -0.012272835709154606, 0.0367291122674942, -0.0015354919014498591, 0.005675594322383404, 0.0396064892411232, -0.029543258249759674, -0.01735920086503029, -0.014929662458598614, -0.0409836620092392, 0.01914585568010807, -0.03304540738463402, -0.019298730418086052, -0.06908917427062988, 0.005590669345110655, -0.0024321398232132196, -0.0798746794462204, -0.015746433287858963, 0.009640309028327465, -0.06539477407932281, -0.03928166627883911, 0.04555852338671684, 0.034952763468027115, -0.007693183608353138, 0.006137380376458168, 0.05198586359620094, 0.04733749479055405, -0.004628052469342947, -0.08215467631816864, -0.002423725323751569, 0.02185073494911194, -0.028450723737478256, -0.0017009848961606622, -0.013309428468346596, 0.07192123681306839, 0.022705039009451866, 0.028193172067403793, 0.001278155017644167, -0.002306495327502489, 0.09049560874700546, -0.020685838535428047, -0.016625119373202324, 0.016456669196486473, -0.05773143470287323, 0.02213764190673828, -0.007948043756186962, -0.023668745532631874, -0.01382984034717083, -0.06484430283308029, -0.016700981184840202, 0.05237333104014397, -0.03838265314698219, 0.01746024563908577, 0.022765938192605972, 0.05414814502000809, -0.0008702826453372836, -0.001052033039741218, 0.005775239784270525, 0.0224091075360775, -0.0043146866373717785, -0.018119102343916893, -0.0022768026683479548, -0.0034368662163615227, 0.005823101848363876, 0.03593996539711952, 0.022273486480116844, -0.013222526758909225, 0.050578128546476364, 0.017558589577674866, -0.06854989379644394, -0.06304445117712021, -0.015008825808763504, -0.024498429149389267, 0.020854322239756584, -0.05152865871787071, 0.018456706777215004, 0.011853145435452461, 0.08371691405773163, -0.01809721626341343, -0.01774759776890278, 0.0161126721650362, 0.07488095015287399, -0.05109819024801254, 0.016473062336444855, 0.030790966004133224, -0.0050648050382733345, 0.012729848735034466, -0.001743124215863645, -0.04783232882618904, 0.02166389301419258, -0.027765778824687004, -0.03820814937353134, -0.011248137801885605, 0.05914720892906189, 0.021092573180794716, 0.02494049444794655, -0.019321680068969727, 0.02702656202018261, 0.026614438742399216, -0.0757066011428833, -0.0950755700469017, 0.03282603994011879, -0.0294411052018404, 0.0478474460542202, 0.0585884153842926, -0.0026914910413324833, 0.06351085007190704, 0.02063792012631893, 0.050209131091833115, 0.037529975175857544, 0.026219267398118973, -0.05196685716509819, -0.025538165122270584, -0.012996859848499298, 0.005089645739644766, 0.04995322227478027, -0.006022915244102478, -0.01225806213915348, -0.060336675494909286, 0.025315580889582634, 0.0063539049588143826, 0.005287978332489729, -0.09179536253213882, 0.01643521338701248, 0.06259219348430634, 0.04266980662941933, -0.007969745434820652, 0.030756574124097824, -0.04840442165732384, -0.024663664400577545, -0.0020440085791051388, 0.010277049615979195, -0.06307260692119598, -0.019252661615610123, -0.012971695512533188, -0.006110051646828651, -0.024136502295732498, 0.013087645173072815, -0.01341016124933958, -0.03435828164219856, 0.03595023602247238, 0.05150921270251274, -0.03669702261686325, 0.005544725805521011, -0.007950612343847752, 0.03459814935922623, -0.005519428756088018, 0.022445017471909523, 0.022909104824066162, 0.015694400295615196, 0.0294199138879776, 0.012239769101142883, -0.018818804994225502, 0.05323775112628937, -0.011459656991064548, -0.008451414294540882, -0.02498502843081951, 0.05305350944399834, -0.04779323190450668, 0.0409550666809082, 0.0768708884716034, -0.06376136839389801, 0.01119893416762352, 0.002385364845395088, 0.012740095146000385, -0.03833959624171257, -0.04337579011917114, 0.03389811888337135, -0.014990570954978466, 0.01666678674519062, 0.04448103532195091, -0.023045791313052177, 0.02458178624510765, 0.057502035051584244, 0.021438436582684517, 0.04485844820737839, -0.009725358337163925, -0.022072380408644676, 0.05184340476989746, -0.016181213781237602, 0.0008570011705160141, -0.0017890931339934468, -0.04660262539982796, -0.0005260123289190233, -0.00856825988739729, 0.058411747217178345, -0.013968058861792088, -0.02492763102054596, 0.005860470701009035, -0.047410544008016586, -0.005301144905388355, 0.02940589375793934, -0.016968322917819023, 0.03255771845579147, -0.0006017253617756069, -0.026346391066908836, -0.01085713878273964, -0.001885232632048428, 0.03462105989456177, -0.081291064620018, 0.051353711634874344, 0.10269168019294739, 0.04098285734653473, -0.04496501013636589, -0.02572176605463028, -0.013698517344892025, 0.008355672471225262, -0.003972236532717943, 0.027937550097703934, -0.0055788662284612656, 0.03999039903283119, -0.0447123683989048, -0.01468953862786293, 0.06494003534317017, -0.0019387592328712344, -0.03276461362838745, -0.011226460337638855, -0.04275643453001976, -0.0072216191329061985, 0.027826230973005295, 0.016413317993283272, 0.0015554064884781837, 0.004543516784906387, -0.006989040412008762, 0.01477994304150343, -0.019396070390939713, 0.013179956004023552, 0.046774838119745255, -0.08788970112800598, -0.014990264549851418, -0.018513642251491547, 0.03317759186029434, 0.0253662820905447, 0.05586378648877144, 0.04698869213461876, -0.002430693246424198, -0.03566913679242134, -0.025773584842681885, 0.02625451609492302, 0.019764771685004234, 0.035518828779459, 0.03608723729848862, -0.06779950857162476, -0.04414497688412666, -0.05507124587893486, 0.04500402882695198, -0.01730804517865181, 0.023075198754668236, -0.004736793227493763, 0.005372966639697552, -0.02400125563144684, 0.04927380010485649, -0.011555729433894157, -0.0021493230015039444, 0.0037890819367021322, 0.03179716691374779, -0.00335515383630991, 0.01649743691086769, 0.040578220039606094, 0.0006205939571373165, -0.033458780497312546, 0.013193022459745407, -0.020353250205516815, -0.0268829558044672, 0.06809084117412567, 0.019522424787282944, -0.04041961580514908, -0.05708446353673935, 0.021071720868349075, 0.060452211648225784, -0.029877476394176483, -0.07350102812051773, -0.015047213062644005, -0.029005469754338264, 0.06079644337296486, -0.0322042778134346, -0.008017512038350105, -0.023075006902217865, -0.006032751873135567, -0.008208325132727623, -0.004732772707939148, 0.02134842984378338, 0.029601648449897766, -0.028764309361577034, -0.007021954283118248, 0.02031962014734745, -0.02996070683002472, 0.02098628133535385, -0.03292517364025116, -0.020864641293883324, 0.0024568242952227592, -0.012219871394336224, 0.016482658684253693, -0.04286865144968033, 0.006003791466355324, 0.035262711346149445, -0.03368748724460602, -0.027666879817843437, -0.016135921701788902, 0.03273070231080055, -0.05345645919442177, 0.06383682042360306, 0.011962171643972397, -0.03433232381939888, 0.00427770521491766, -0.03461404889822006, 0.018475625663995743, 0.0009605759405530989, 0.059909041970968246, 0.02224658988416195, -0.019327398389577866, 0.00955964531749487, 0.01638786494731903, -0.026145093142986298, 0.022846460342407227, -0.06791240721940994, 0.005298488773405552, -0.07518108189105988, 0.023935435339808464, -0.11769453436136246, 0.027598228305578232, 0.00789912324398756, 0.04255369305610657, -0.029523497447371483, -0.01734803430736065, -0.02175961621105671, 0.037210941314697266, 0.04682385176420212, 0.058782532811164856, -0.07678095996379852, 0.000317485595587641, -0.009987248107790947, 0.009103910997509956, 0.03601207211613655, -0.013132643885910511, 0.0309864804148674, -0.009515224024653435, -0.03371519222855568, 0.014728067442774773, -0.005151743069291115, 0.028795773163437843, 0.03041452169418335, 0.005522250663489103, 0.02301678992807865, -0.003794369287788868, -0.020210081711411476, 0.05764942243695259, 0.04841529205441475, -0.007999459281563759, -0.011248873546719551, 0.034565407782793045, -0.051949936896562576, -0.024609707295894623, -0.020138824358582497, 0.07991019636392593, -0.0035187711473554373, 0.0040439763106405735, -0.0736362412571907, 0.026999695226550102, 0.08034321665763855, 0.010317090898752213, 0.01538875512778759, -0.05889393389225006, 0.010784800164401531, -0.0404503270983696, -0.06475368142127991, 0.05003144219517708, 0.009691871702671051, -0.016328686848282814, 0.03069738671183586, -0.07736987620592117, -0.03906084969639778, 0.01873667724430561, 0.0018482451559975743, 0.0051012723706662655, -0.0570085234940052, -0.011830521747469902, -0.03114473633468151, -0.03127662464976311, -0.05537662282586098, 0.011627319268882275, -0.009225096553564072, -0.016033217310905457, -0.022157983854413033, -0.002984634367749095, 0.048584189265966415, -0.05974176898598671, -0.016110016033053398, -0.000488766934722662, -0.05237358808517456, -0.026391534134745598, 0.010163776576519012, 0.043800726532936096, 0.060380227863788605, 0.03390968218445778, -0.021914800629019737, 0.028590889647603035, 0.14391008019447327, 0.024995459243655205, -0.0644872859120369, 0.027385534718632698, 0.01953846774995327, -0.055895134806632996, -0.014458931051194668, -0.021129192784428596, -0.016229331493377686, -0.0016835849964991212, 0.046904195100069046, 0.04456019029021263, -0.007600766606628895, -0.018488023430109024, 0.005999739747494459, -0.004642737563699484, -0.043698929250240326, 0.047233548015356064, -0.02297392301261425, -0.006623824592679739, -0.00007627314334968105, -0.027403488755226135, 0.01626608334481716, -0.03845714032649994, -0.08226491510868073, 0.1072034165263176, -0.032641198486089706, 0.007190527860075235, 0.01823311112821102, 0.024197522550821304, 0.016211489215493202, -0.04228247329592705, -0.06567010283470154, 0.01652197539806366, -0.025598764419555664, -0.02762243151664734, -0.024051686748862267, -0.023446477949619293, 0.03758573904633522, 0.052758775651454926, -0.002273326274007559, -0.03775683045387268, 0.01577490009367466, -0.03219718113541603, -0.007873991504311562, 0.004815519321709871, 0.029586799442768097, 0.023612886667251587, 0.031400106847286224, 0.03743376210331917, 0.013764666393399239, 0.04107851907610893, 0.02947782166302204, 0.03473405912518501, -0.03655414283275604, -0.036269836127758026, -0.010420960374176502, -0.013395370915532112, -0.02394622564315796, 0.0012505770428106189, 0.002235402585938573, -0.003884337842464447, -0.029401276260614395, 0.02950882911682129, -0.020827796310186386, 0.023564616218209267, -0.013554699718952179, 0.003839681390672922, -0.004494822584092617, 0.02619384415447712, -0.041631221771240234, 0.004224603064358234, 0.02497873641550541, 0.01922774128615856, -0.048926059156656265, -0.02848845347762108, 0.01811494678258896, -0.025241585448384285, -0.0017137504182755947, 0.036401402205228806, 0.0006692811730317771, 0.05948656424880028, -0.017580926418304443, 0.015819450840353966, -0.03409567102789879, -0.11235279589891434, 0.01900489442050457, 0.013011537492275238, 0.01601020060479641, -0.0608023963868618, 0.015066380612552166, -0.04320923611521721, 0.043612752109766006, 0.0396292470395565, -0.0010629254393279552, -0.018375447019934654, -0.05111479386687279, 0.021716292947530746, 0.001316581154242158, -0.02405276522040367, -0.02047969400882721, 0.02639099396765232, 0.016395416110754013, -0.09826689958572388, 0.001766653498634696, 0.008761194534599781, -0.025118928402662277, -0.041995514184236526, 0.007708078715950251, 0.044433560222387314, 0.013748977333307266, -0.02918742597103119, -0.011722743511199951, -0.05031611770391464, 0.06647538393735886, -0.0034251802135258913, 0.01707823947072029, 0.0545048713684082, -0.023999812081456184, -0.015792900696396828, -0.028969591483473778, 0.057986244559288025, 0.05219486355781555, 0.04249032586812973, -0.027438053861260414, 0.04763977602124214, -0.04351338371634483, -0.014058401808142662, 0.013454950414597988, 0.033204395323991776, 0.01850203610956669, -0.0451229028403759, -0.01596861146390438, 0.018509751185774803, 0.04599062353372574, 0.017968675121665, 0.002840744098648429, 0.019605929031968117, 0.04441918060183525, -0.03151305392384529, -0.03128989413380623, -0.008989853784441948, -0.022946249693632126, -0.02123086154460907, 0.05625193566083908, -0.06804201751947403, -0.0013739438727498055, 0.06072727590799332, 0.0007794697885401547, -0.030083581805229187, -0.01999560371041298, 0.031121594831347466, 0.03435926139354706, -0.09542297571897507, 0.018946068361401558, 0.05972690507769585, -0.018651127815246582, 0.00960971973836422, 0.01192846242338419, -0.05606214702129364, -0.06720775365829468, -0.019425731152296066, 0.001957336440682411, 0.03810013458132744, -0.0041025313548743725, 0.009557073935866356, 0.0020507622975856066, 0.020309630781412125, 0.03262143209576607, 0.03293878957629204, 0.07423675805330276, 0.02571580745279789, 0.022506030276417732, 0.010909623466432095, -0.019968358799815178, 0.034116052091121674, -0.040739838033914566, -0.03131500631570816, -0.019160015508532524, -0.010460807010531425, 0.010008266195654869, 0.051390402019023895, 0.004423493519425392, -0.018910791724920273, -0.00859211478382349, -0.002349038142710924, -0.015227899886667728, 0.002502560382708907, -0.022598126903176308, 0.01734405755996704, 0.07804642617702484, 0.02108580619096756, -0.03545714542269707, -0.03219269961118698, 0.05958953872323036, 0.0028779811691492796, -0.017576463520526886, 0.045634444802999496, -0.027644628658890724, -0.02608887292444706, 0.025395257398486137, 0.00033088866621255875, 0.017654899507761, -0.012882212176918983, 0.015265611931681633, 0.028618719428777695, 0.03245859593153, -0.005210038274526596, -0.03729896992444992, -0.03393667936325073, 0.00030584685737267137, -0.04002858325839043, -0.05010182410478592, 0.010433015413582325, -0.058942072093486786, 0.04925605654716492, 0.009276085533201694, -0.04572845995426178, 0.007138402666896582, 0.06985832005739212, -0.02992282062768936, -0.013605649583041668, 0.053219061344861984, -0.01154786255210638, -0.00882917083799839, -0.023108744993805885, 0.0013863018248230219, -0.0480927899479866, -0.027780506759881973, 0.03439916670322418, -0.011330929584801197, -0.09420596063137054, -0.039818186312913895, -0.02116319164633751, 0.022648483514785767, -0.04214667156338692, 0.014855174347758293, -0.03053591027855873, -0.007544142194092274, 0.017770782113075256, -0.05995182693004608, -0.033264510333538055, 0.007774074096232653, 0.06308682262897491, 0.02063152752816677, 0.011776180937886238, -0.04521016404032707, 0.010496473871171474, -0.03439217805862427, -0.014043527655303478, 0.0014076660154387355, -0.026241781190037727, -0.016153281554579735, 0.04872670769691467, 0.0014572725631296635, -0.03234808146953583, 0.008804017677903175, -0.0337509885430336, 0.008555840700864792, 0.030876386910676956, -0.034270770847797394, 0.020608197897672653, -0.038312673568725586, 0.010856563225388527, 0.0116080641746521, 0.03146630525588989, 0.017498554661870003, -0.03954751044511795, 0.020274916663765907, 0.06490714102983475, -0.018448742106556892, -0.016455570235848427, -0.01009052898734808 ]
<p>There is a large metal container in form of a cube made of stainless steel. It is used for storing water in it for technical uses. The problem is that all joints at the bottom of the container have micro cavities and water leaks through them very slowly. I am thinking of a method to close these micro cavities from inside. And the most reasonable method I can think of is to make them cover by a layer of limescale, as any electrical teapot or heater does. The only problem is that this is a big container, and it isn't easy to heat that amount of water, or to boil it. </p> <p>So does anybody know any other way to cover the bottom or just micro cavities in the joints by limescale without heating during long time? Maybe some use of electrolysis?</p>
g4067
[ 0.010570170357823372, 0.035613495856523514, 0.024511728435754776, 0.005808294750750065, -0.06885303556919098, -0.013336187228560448, 0.012313930317759514, 0.021670082584023476, -0.056100696325302124, 0.0278709027916193, 0.06114814057946205, 0.029796725139021873, -0.009944905526936054, 0.06589218974113464, -0.007045334670692682, 0.009619777090847492, 0.02498483844101429, -0.008633731864392757, -0.02872476726770401, 0.04313551262021065, 0.01523551344871521, 0.003997670486569405, -0.039877813309431076, -0.0018037287518382072, -0.0035601709969341755, -0.02775338478386402, 0.004939674399793148, 0.05250982195138931, 0.03927084058523178, -0.02881799079477787, -0.05265580862760544, -0.06390802562236786, -0.04916297644376755, -0.014688669703900814, -0.017169419676065445, 0.01690026931464672, -0.03223536163568497, 0.025935079902410507, -0.03571729362010956, -0.007006262429058552, 0.013240337371826172, 0.04256487637758255, 0.049654521048069, 0.0012788573512807488, 0.02680705487728119, 0.032503642141819, -0.04300151392817497, -0.02999980002641678, 0.0269840806722641, -0.006001535337418318, 0.034958284348249435, -0.015737857669591904, 0.04512058570981026, -0.053826674818992615, 0.010322414338588715, -0.016364265233278275, -0.05213993042707443, 0.023769525811076164, 0.026942769065499306, -0.031721435487270355, 0.04298167675733566, 0.030123498290777206, -0.03726363182067871, 0.00682892045006156, 0.027303913608193398, 0.0328606441617012, -0.054130688309669495, 0.004890185780823231, 0.03754494711756706, 0.03785400092601776, -0.008127046748995781, 0.05936029180884361, -0.018014775589108467, -0.06393492221832275, -0.057084955275058746, 0.01487663108855486, -0.02223352901637554, 0.10155785083770752, 0.040187835693359375, 0.042643364518880844, -0.08622188866138458, -0.0024347021244466305, 0.018712565302848816, -0.05922456830739975, -0.005749330390244722, 0.004602000117301941, -0.04868471994996071, -0.01860441081225872, -0.015480654314160347, 0.02204113081097603, -0.06914298981428146, 0.016474155709147453, 0.07192434370517731, 0.05089721828699112, -0.011924593709409237, 0.02918337844312191, -0.02702869102358818, 0.011568139307200909, -0.021205848082900047, 0.049378663301467896, 0.08510512858629227, -0.07322749495506287, 0.04672871530056, 0.02250569500029087, -0.046275243163108826, -0.00775696849450469, -0.02102053351700306, 0.022603603079915047, 0.009556331671774387, 0.054185859858989716, 0.001552119618281722, -0.008680052123963833, -0.021330686286091805, -0.041823651641607285, 0.06446152180433273, 0.010384764522314072, 0.024312956258654594, 0.046150416135787964, -0.05577807128429413, 0.029005149379372597, 0.012029608711600304, 0.03869764134287834, -0.025107309222221375, 0.04851219058036804, 0.07418498396873474, 0.04488159716129303, 0.01523442380130291, 0.029353298246860504, -0.009803424589335918, 0.04072893038392067, -0.004351872019469738, 0.061090391129255295, 0.013689152896404266, 0.036015503108501434, 0.008707476779818535, 0.07612418383359909, -0.02762068621814251, -0.03169970214366913, -0.007530783303081989, -0.047705523669719696, -0.01301861833781004, 0.035419438034296036, 0.008517025038599968, 0.04594116657972336, 0.04319784417748451, -0.02085811085999012, -0.05424222722649574, -0.04394255951046944, -0.002986422972753644, 0.043884214013814926, -0.035774700343608856, -0.00861547514796257, 0.035849135369062424, -0.0030531976372003555, -0.01891406625509262, 0.015987172722816467, 0.03891487792134285, -0.062313906848430634, 0.06250707805156708, 0.03168017044663429, 0.006810561288148165, -0.006558902561664581, 0.02102839946746826, 0.00046461561578325927, -0.014493242837488651, 0.04987522214651108, 0.014577888883650303, -0.0505409836769104, -0.013564491644501686, -0.01671612076461315, 0.003976793028414249, 0.0007897168397903442, -0.03756865859031677, 0.10784198343753815, 0.011258658953011036, 0.030896490439772606, 0.013535006903111935, -0.0634419322013855, 0.001605970785021782, 0.021054817363619804, -0.0013851915718987584, -0.010520786046981812, 0.05907054245471954, -0.012283491902053356, -0.054440900683403015, 0.018213970586657524, -0.004360381979495287, 0.005620260257273912, -0.004844568204134703, -0.025675466284155846, 0.029697876423597336, 0.019622672349214554, -0.016583671793341637, 0.02775479294359684, 0.012204397469758987, -0.01333876233547926, 0.020593388006091118, -0.015310297720134258, 0.000033908025216078386, 0.004427840001881123, 0.033972933888435364, 0.008215108886361122, 0.02657189778983593, 0.08692535012960434, 0.017729945480823517, -0.028850939124822617, -0.06211576238274574, -0.027374152094125748, -0.030542219057679176, 0.05367622897028923, 0.0019367254571989179, 0.02431441657245159, -0.020215092226862907, -0.06495960056781769, -0.03204185143113136, -0.008624282665550709, 0.030552035197615623, 0.007122288458049297, -0.03910817578434944, 0.009436585009098053, -0.02925925701856613, -0.03540255129337311, -0.01827443577349186, -0.06595216691493988, 0.03345787897706032, 0.005999766755849123, 0.019455814734101295, 0.025939101353287697, 0.022587204352021217, 0.011730737052857876, -0.02143050916492939, -0.03846858814358711, 0.045799385756254196, -0.061487484723329544, -0.04496853053569794, 0.008143166080117226, -0.04738283529877663, 0.027847107499837875, -0.03580809012055397, 0.030368763953447342, 0.06553038209676743, -0.07330923527479172, -0.03940071165561676, -0.07747989147901535, 0.008717360906302929, -0.0154291782528162, -0.016753820702433586, -0.006493960507214069, 0.0567508302628994, 0.02981850691139698, 0.023427698761224747, 0.008125357329845428, -0.05518760904669762, 0.03527137264609337, -0.0003896881826221943, -0.046454377472400665, 0.04297676309943199, 0.007797590456902981, 0.00258667953312397, -0.09778271615505219, -0.010136410593986511, -0.03931596875190735, -0.0025108400732278824, -0.0014783380320295691, 0.03235805407166481, -0.01639498770236969, -0.11370141804218292, 0.014987931586802006, 0.029541287571191788, 0.09991656243801117, 0.0030696941539645195, -0.0050042374059557915, 0.01245738472789526, 0.03139697387814522, 0.025255247950553894, -0.036538392305374146, 0.02413909323513508, -0.021533837541937828, -0.007190161384642124, -0.060460057109594345, -0.02431645803153515, 0.007733370643109083, -0.0038744688499718904, 0.0061852154321968555, 0.026760470122098923, -0.021863548085093498, -0.0008480494725517929, 0.0014229418011382222, 0.025841182097792625, 0.029756413772702217, 0.04092993214726448, -0.016380082815885544, 0.02414056658744812, 0.027569644153118134, 0.014177225530147552, -0.0050003440119326115, -0.036487825214862823, 0.025266725569963455, 0.01112616341561079, -0.020313549786806107, -0.009657223708927631, -0.012005814351141453, 0.010929248295724392, -0.04178588464856148, -0.016739236190915108, 0.001874989946372807, -0.016930758953094482, 0.013229836709797382, -0.004229054786264896, -0.006053255405277014, -0.004842693451792002, 0.012055403552949429, -0.0012357647065073252, -0.01622975990176201, -0.05170625448226929, -0.024772511795163155, 0.019798703491687775, -0.013263371773064137, 0.06371809542179108, 0.01610567979514599, 0.0037913662381470203, 0.027349751442670822, 0.005765317939221859, -0.00780276907607913, -0.0074015348218381405, 0.04111248254776001, -0.017085928469896317, -0.013760026544332504, -0.06917893886566162, 0.03198310732841492, -0.030326267704367638, 0.049942780286073685, 0.008893468417227268, -0.02323509380221367, -0.03713437169790268, -0.02242659032344818, -0.028004160150885582, 0.0007841305341571569, 0.014347909949719906, 0.036455947905778885, -0.007022958714514971, -0.08799868822097778, -0.01197168417274952, -0.025105413049459457, 0.022623898461461067, -0.013927986845374107, 0.02595515549182892, 0.019896583631634712, 0.00008269871614174917, 0.0036772757302969694, 0.05649413540959358, 0.026054812595248222, 0.007452055346220732, 0.011813588440418243, -0.05005216971039772, 0.05189906805753708, 0.045062169432640076, -0.01820354536175728, 0.007358309347182512, 0.009332644753158092, -0.0443827360868454, -0.04689785838127136, 0.0418953001499176, 0.0201262217015028, -0.05811361223459244, 0.006055993027985096, 0.06871864944696426, 0.04138137772679329, -0.018564581871032715, 0.01757829450070858, 0.01788090541958809, 0.017595108598470688, -0.008329406380653381, 0.023656895384192467, 0.024320006370544434, -0.014394644647836685, 0.009782316163182259, 0.026928048580884933, 0.01430295780301094, -0.009479484520852566, -0.046412788331508636, 0.016043806448578835, 0.0264408178627491, -0.014709028415381908, -0.03520845249295235, 0.0026799095794558525, 0.062075093388557434, 0.04448039084672928, 0.003158085746690631, -0.04582680016756058, -0.014252007938921452, 0.05183672904968262, -0.017816348001360893, -0.00611279159784317, -0.061792757362127304, -0.006309195421636105, -0.010969264432787895, -0.05184129998087883, -0.01573723554611206, -0.04302556812763214, 0.0010554210748523474, -0.00398113951086998, 0.0030906281899660826, 0.02876494638621807, 0.010612535290420055, -0.01230443175882101, 0.031505998224020004, 0.002250097692012787, 0.04133693501353264, -0.02694844640791416, 0.012526045553386211, -0.006579504813998938, 0.011728091165423393, 0.04911569133400917, -0.012947716750204563, -0.08929179608821869, 0.018664205446839333, 0.05046030506491661, 0.024774372577667236, 0.02840866521000862, -0.05493791028857231, 0.01667393371462822, -0.0023856849875301123, 0.0048937066458165646, 0.03432314097881317, 0.009429804980754852, 0.0024055407848209143, -0.04391935467720032, -0.009831104427576065, 0.00781902577728033, 0.00590975396335125, 0.03200998157262802, -0.035984065383672714, -0.057480957359075546, 0.04754290729761124, -0.08285806328058243, -0.02447601780295372, -0.06336193531751633, -0.023307906463742256, 0.03519997373223305, -0.0011380321811884642, 0.02384824864566326, -0.01802309788763523, -0.030265100300312042, 0.011822397820651531, 0.004851348698139191, -0.04317735508084297, -0.037563029676675797, 0.016707828268408775, -0.025416435673832893, 0.038379967212677, 0.006211400497704744, 0.010475240647792816, 0.010682091116905212, -0.03273812681436539, 0.04478292912244797, 0.006572741083800793, 0.019879063591361046, -0.00941041111946106, 0.022286321967840195, -0.049146123230457306, 0.06828371435403824, -0.06129022315144539, 0.03379954770207405, 0.025193026289343834, -0.06980413943529129, 0.02810853347182274, -0.03549130633473396, 0.0377446748316288, 0.014435524120926857, 0.063261479139328, 0.08077254891395569, 0.024940168485045433, 0.028741760179400444, -0.004412244074046612, -0.006034058518707752, -0.009537027217447758, 0.054631900042295456, -0.002124413847923279, 0.07276102155447006, 0.013659263961017132, 0.037194084376096725, -0.026643797755241394, 0.02748957835137844, 0.06844920665025711, -0.03215000778436661, -0.011634506285190582, 0.03948082774877548, -0.03633251041173935, -0.015244849026203156, 0.0047178855165839195, 0.03054163046181202, 0.05944535508751869, 0.036600496619939804, 0.0005068517639301717, -0.008445416577160358, 0.03294330835342407, 0.0024446186143904924, 0.00030832691118121147, 0.035258419811725616, 0.018974578008055687, -0.08104288578033447, -0.0041482113301754, -0.01048179529607296, 0.03204881399869919, -0.02039138600230217, 0.007132757920771837, 0.030052585527300835, 0.027074065059423447, 0.07470371574163437, -0.019541224464774132, -0.03298772871494293, 0.009509732015430927, 0.009508542716503143, 0.06378334760665894, -0.06812992691993713, -0.009650487452745438, 0.04698151722550392, -0.035264141857624054, -0.020372042432427406, 0.008185329847037792, -0.03438558802008629, 0.011693394742906094, 0.008137008175253868, -0.027060572057962418, -0.030307583510875702, -0.039919663220644, 0.00012891367077827454, -0.0029482024256139994, 0.015996772795915604, 0.014748591929674149, -0.03623323515057564, 0.05906229838728905, -0.034778058528900146, -0.07127390801906586, 0.005968850571662188, 0.0044306181371212006, 0.01625148020684719, 0.010569943115115166, 0.05613166466355324, 0.06075245887041092, -0.029414288699626923, 0.05597051605582237, 0.004519353155046701, -0.04966919496655464, -0.012529561296105385, 0.028372233733534813, 0.01048382930457592, 0.03267631307244301, 0.021931292489171028, 0.01076729316264391, 0.07740318775177002, 0.016081808134913445, -0.010556943714618683, -0.0011656149290502071, -0.047291915863752365, 0.005474023055285215, -0.022468283772468567, 0.059526290744543076, 0.0067648328840732574, 0.0673438012599945, 0.021250534802675247, 0.026333224028348923, -0.015458336099982262, -0.015344831161201, -0.05556422844529152, -0.029219573363661766, -0.006314105354249477, 0.007084336597472429, -0.029921501874923706, -0.02361425943672657, -0.043741375207901, 0.028811542317271233, -0.042429279536008835, -0.03514597564935684, 0.09423592686653137, -0.018802082166075706, 0.08585960417985916, -0.002079649828374386, 0.022650526836514473, -0.04001758620142937, -0.008171944878995419, -0.12182722240686417, 0.0068030278198421, -0.04662417247891426, 0.021992182359099388, -0.04579641669988632, -0.03143036365509033, -0.03583691269159317, -0.06290199607610703, 0.01910402998328209, -0.000964989943895489, -0.018191909417510033, 0.07103610783815384, 0.006948296912014484, -0.0018339897505939007, 0.01557855773717165, 0.11135834455490112, 0.0018960771849378943, 0.05286794900894165, -0.01662522368133068, 0.014535556547343731, 0.009786956012248993, -0.053906671702861786, -0.0715111792087555, -0.004815364722162485, 0.01972496509552002, 0.00772811146453023, -0.01218307763338089, -0.0141630619764328, 0.00607924722135067, 0.040554288774728775, 0.048768337815999985, -0.018712805584073067, -0.02879159152507782, -0.07003121078014374, 0.006819505710154772, -0.014932844787836075, -0.00395239656791091, -0.031935375183820724, -0.012622198089957237, 0.00565051706507802, 0.022298971191048622, -0.004455127287656069, 0.013936788775026798, 0.015440527349710464, -0.04407280683517456, 0.01031574234366417, 0.02889980562031269, -0.04740998521447182, 0.0015506107592955232, -0.008173198439180851, -0.004164890386164188, -0.08989854902029037, -0.06812351197004318, 0.020589632913470268, 0.01914559304714203, -0.03660852462053299, 0.014839674346148968, -0.035614702850580215, 0.010553756728768349, -0.016021791845560074, 0.019065268337726593, 0.09356877952814102, -0.004417568910866976, 0.008556311950087547, 0.003321731695905328, 0.03812672197818756, -0.07047039270401001, -0.032744575291872025, 0.025779278948903084, -0.06025451049208641, -0.04566250741481781, -0.04399250075221062, -0.016653330996632576, 0.010203158482909203, 0.028465669602155685, -0.02035183645784855, -0.02942393347620964, 0.0278465636074543, -0.029536012560129166, -0.0012997454032301903, 0.03411698713898659, -0.06228465214371681, -0.016642646864056587, 0.041718490421772, -0.06549643725156784, -0.027136651799082756, -0.020923610776662827, -0.021382678300142288, -0.040457986295223236, -0.013093333691358566, -0.040383897721767426, -0.04066913202404976, -0.033843886107206345, -0.0031835814006626606, 0.055707234889268875, 0.042328570038080215, -0.011884783394634724, -0.021882271394133568, -0.033566076308488846, -0.02683284878730774, 0.01883723773062229, -0.03352218493819237, 0.032443296164274216, -0.04829412326216698, 0.019039738923311234, -0.0017115430673584342, 0.03808498755097389, 0.01413245964795351, 0.016604939475655556, -0.049452342092990875, 0.015040813945233822, 0.0025985068641602993, 0.014669522643089294, 0.0018744667759165168, 0.01448237057775259, -0.03516824543476105, -0.022351684048771858, -0.05295791104435921, -0.05614115670323372, 0.005273133981972933, 0.06517971307039261, -0.011239858344197273, 0.005161112640053034, 0.00909824762493372, -0.002041860017925501, 0.061368171125650406, -0.01830458641052246, 0.03465193137526512, 0.024624699726700783, 0.07156047970056534, 0.012848008424043655, -0.04190941900014877, 0.035922255367040634, 0.01386435516178608, -0.12656721472740173, -0.010883749462664127, 0.007832503877580166, -0.08555306494235992, -0.1408294141292572, 0.0003848350024782121, 0.023325540125370026, 0.011033388786017895, -0.003715676022693515, -0.04291906952857971, 0.00294835795648396, -0.02302810736000538, -0.0656859278678894, 0.004874363541603088, 0.026948021724820137, 0.006956243421882391, 0.03811261057853699, 0.03185863047838211, 0.019730105996131897, -0.06406685709953308, -0.014833283610641956, -0.00900716707110405, 0.02281210571527481, 0.014581803232431412, 0.023368166759610176, -0.050576262176036835, -0.027417387813329697, -0.015025603584945202, 0.05607946589589119, 0.039885491132736206, -0.05795682966709137, 0.009653509594500065, 0.03327735885977745, -0.017428893595933914, -0.029032018035650253, 0.0017340980703011155, -0.0476369671523571, -0.0228809155523777, -0.02343466691672802, -0.015702391043305397, 0.0007971340091899037, 0.014718469232320786, -0.025356920436024666, -0.058939024806022644, -0.012030881829559803, 0.02194739691913128, -0.0067291404120624065, 0.01777852512896061, 0.03780321404337883, -0.006139526143670082, 0.019719667732715607, -0.037887874990701675 ]
<p>I have a differential operator $L$,</p> <p>$\displaystyle L = i (t\frac{\partial}{\partial z} - z\frac{\partial}{\partial t})$</p> <p>I can trivially hit this operator to $x,y,z$ and $t$ as $L x$, $L t$, $L y$, $L z$.</p> <p>But I have a problem with <em>exponential of that operator</em>. I want to hit this operator to $x,y,z$ and $t$ as well.</p> <p>$\exp(i\eta L)\,\,x$</p> <p>($\eta$ is rapidity in this case)</p> <p>The first thing that comes to my mind is to use definition of exponential of an operator:</p> <p>$\displaystyle \exp(A) = I + A + \frac{A^2}{2!} + \frac{A^3}{3!} ...$ </p> <p>But, I don't know why, I don't want to use this infinite sum. There should be a smart way of doing this..</p> <p>Do you have any suggestions for me?</p>
g4068
[ 0.032068341970443726, 0.009049193933606148, -0.06052149832248688, 0.01909540221095085, 0.04286867752671242, -0.06307882070541382, 0.07741574943065643, -0.0006542450282722712, -0.010071702301502228, -0.0026027958374470472, 0.014175395481288433, 0.03758645057678223, 0.07373961806297302, 0.029633374884724617, -0.008162417449057102, 0.003307015635073185, 0.0657833069562912, 0.014762061648070812, 0.023051999509334564, -0.0031084606889635324, -0.011054717935621738, -0.009225538931787014, 0.01699662394821644, -0.034695815294981, 0.05553414672613144, -0.06070305407047272, 0.026282338425517082, 0.011844655498862267, -0.053917914628982544, -0.0006222821539267898, -0.02437031827867031, 0.05902624502778053, 0.021733729168772697, 0.023013032972812653, 0.016300033777952194, 0.000019250066543463618, 0.03151489421725273, 0.0663968175649643, 0.0403902642428875, -0.06486182659864426, 0.002658260054886341, -0.01614021323621273, 0.05783956125378609, 0.026417316868901253, -0.01294689066708088, -0.03306281939148903, -0.0439387746155262, 0.0194876529276371, 0.0031753883231431246, -0.030964916571974754, 0.021420221775770187, -0.00416985061019659, -0.029058901593089104, -0.06964050978422165, 0.0213847067207098, 0.018304932862520218, -0.039952319115400314, -0.016825230792164803, 0.0556386299431324, -0.026423446834087372, -0.021239297464489937, -0.052836108952760696, 0.045417722314596176, -0.05091824382543564, 0.036750007420778275, -0.006953774951398373, 0.0400058813393116, -0.01296696625649929, 0.04102976247668266, -0.028284385800361633, -0.01720980554819107, -0.04727382957935333, 0.014309396967291832, -0.024818619713187218, 0.00255068251863122, -0.004792484920471907, 0.025060128420591354, -0.03920479863882065, 0.057437196373939514, 0.017901282757520676, -0.009693003259599209, -0.06173686310648918, 0.04137038439512253, 0.04358978196978569, -0.07563567906618118, 0.014291892759501934, 0.014702104032039642, -0.026170292869210243, 0.013538066297769547, -0.052497051656246185, 0.010391473770141602, -0.020588552579283714, -0.017988508567214012, 0.0929640457034111, -0.025223782286047935, -0.01883707195520401, -0.023680413141846657, 0.06394489854574203, 0.0232937503606081, -0.020777083933353424, 0.02655732072889805, -0.010888844728469849, 0.019923226907849312, -0.03819446638226509, -0.035680510103702545, -0.007237316574901342, 0.032717034220695496, -0.03165031597018242, -0.025460608303546906, -0.02307315357029438, 0.03606268763542175, 0.011632731184363365, 0.016811495646834373, -0.08197834342718124, 0.03110925480723381, 0.056926995515823364, -0.01603112742304802, -0.018523292616009712, -0.10095463693141937, 0.024842869490385056, 0.053296737372875214, 0.010708661749958992, 0.05099909007549286, -0.009170420467853546, 0.0031907823868095875, 0.0010363484034314752, 0.020768268033862114, -0.01623893342912197, 0.04677216708660126, -0.016333939507603645, 0.015437795780599117, 0.04562761262059212, 0.03161989897489548, 0.032051775604486465, -0.024834314361214638, 0.04914774373173714, -0.011774207465350628, 0.0025520173367112875, 0.023522870615124702, 0.01993366703391075, -0.029979916289448738, -0.05692818760871887, -0.01361769251525402, -0.015287498012185097, -0.03190217539668083, 0.030206279829144478, -0.03548866882920265, -0.05324644595384598, 0.03841578587889671, -0.026663312688469887, -0.0026742289774119854, 0.0019441833719611168, -0.004820572212338448, 0.019689494743943214, 0.06903756409883499, 0.026228412985801697, 0.02492808736860752, 0.009845265187323093, -0.04560217633843422, -0.004125676117837429, -0.027439305558800697, 0.036486268043518066, -0.01673021726310253, -0.0020389731507748365, 0.025434419512748718, 0.008383974432945251, -0.01390077918767929, -0.033517319709062576, -0.009859073907136917, -0.036622192710638046, -0.017376698553562164, 0.05449598655104637, 0.028888674452900887, -0.047004759311676025, 0.031773924827575684, 0.007748400792479515, -0.006402399856597185, -0.003555223811417818, -0.0035778258461505175, -0.03970857337117195, -0.024701349437236786, -0.04823099449276924, -0.0013284559827297926, -0.01542721502482891, 0.021422546356916428, -0.0034091752022504807, -0.01380638312548399, 0.02544752135872841, -0.05933673307299614, 0.021914934739470482, 0.041392482817173004, 0.00981252919882536, 0.046728044748306274, 0.042047735303640366, -0.03721514344215393, -0.011306771077215672, 0.018010549247264862, -0.09960135072469711, -0.05499852076172829, -0.007297701667994261, 0.026921136304736137, 0.051705509424209595, 0.05290563404560089, 0.0325661301612854, -0.03854409232735634, -0.021981267258524895, -0.03416520357131958, -0.04987770691514015, 0.005187137518078089, 0.04069872573018074, -0.0021077923011034727, -0.06170510873198509, -0.007832540199160576, 0.03674459084868431, -0.049888838082551956, -0.04754548892378807, 0.01117607019841671, 0.008125062100589275, -0.01638687215745449, 0.004395135212689638, -0.03656456246972084, 0.05445792153477669, 0.016324304044246674, -0.03801892325282097, -0.0744481310248375, -0.017780961468815804, 0.01880537159740925, 0.012556592933833599, 0.024919157847762108, 0.002104036044329405, -0.04708768427371979, -0.006431032903492451, -0.005208417773246765, -0.05589350312948227, 0.03521193936467171, -0.04890943318605423, -0.00978128518909216, 0.02939976379275322, -0.025848006829619408, 0.005891695152968168, 0.011872558854520321, -0.011774135753512383, -0.006600148044526577, 0.025018945336341858, 0.008607346564531326, -0.027042755857110023, 0.005798199214041233, 0.05851412191987038, 0.0075960056856274605, 0.04164432734251022, -0.022378938272595406, 0.010274807922542095, -0.05121305212378502, 0.036245208233594894, 0.002496307250112295, -0.055694036185741425, 0.03888901323080063, 0.020653938874602318, 0.07275856286287308, 0.039790865033864975, -0.00698303896933794, 0.06025664880871773, 0.011095023714005947, 0.00924860779196024, -0.05125051364302635, 0.0006651745061390102, -0.019497914239764214, 0.003972514532506466, -0.01913134939968586, -0.0058080232702195644, -0.05034689977765083, -0.0027025637682527304, 0.008872966282069683, 0.011585522443056107, -0.017059091478586197, -0.04702797532081604, -0.005374277476221323, -0.060687970370054245, 0.02994818240404129, -0.03353649750351906, 0.039918843656778336, -0.008862758055329323, 0.01869960129261017, 0.05001136660575867, 0.0822238102555275, -0.040206123143434525, 0.06883962452411652, 0.08429974317550659, 0.01403407845646143, -0.03662871569395065, 0.007566098123788834, 0.030013522133231163, -0.0014991236384958029, -0.04266807436943054, -0.0079169487580657, -0.013590977527201176, 0.020669415593147278, -0.02001562900841236, 0.04465552046895027, 0.0045050764456391335, 0.026592325419187546, -0.03555857762694359, 0.01863151229918003, 0.003370741382241249, 0.05571959912776947, -0.06566978245973587, -0.02756522409617901, -0.0014448079746216536, 0.024937668815255165, 0.005379756446927786, 0.06835650652647018, -0.02373557724058628, -0.0032287274952977896, -0.01915959268808365, -0.018272072076797485, 0.016742432489991188, -0.0010846932418644428, -0.027458349242806435, 0.030402548611164093, 0.02494664303958416, 0.04791447892785072, -0.06959197670221329, 0.004268159624189138, 0.0547172948718071, -0.05837828665971756, 0.006111579015851021, 0.00944021251052618, -0.00905288103967905, -0.06853514164686203, 0.05144089460372925, 0.02325938269495964, 0.017676953226327896, -0.0029689506627619267, -0.03385560214519501, 0.022328970953822136, 0.0006134280120022595, 0.0009293472394347191, 0.05366847664117813, 0.012238581664860249, -0.02965933084487915, -0.008814667351543903, -0.027592146769165993, -0.043888092041015625, 0.01786385104060173, -0.003972464241087437, -0.06912123411893845, 0.03278461471199989, 0.05387158319354057, -0.014338419772684574, 0.018758341670036316, -0.028153929859399796, -0.011832794174551964, 0.006554897874593735, -0.012120026163756847, -0.006252034567296505, 0.03286118060350418, 0.038334619253873825, 0.05582930147647858, -0.04054713621735573, -0.016827013343572617, 0.0426030308008194, -0.028833650052547455, -0.011594517156481743, 0.055544231086969376, 0.026900770142674446, 0.012140731327235699, -0.00014989312330726534, 0.058882903307676315, -0.03855079784989357, 0.0440877228975296, 0.02848045527935028, -0.0056998999789357185, 0.0666627436876297, 0.06109439581632614, -0.02736617438495159, -0.059292443096637726, -0.006428721826523542, 0.013150830753147602, 0.03493430092930794, 0.023244090378284454, 0.04214715212583542, 0.0071386126801371574, -0.015741970390081406, 0.01120684389024973, 0.05043721944093704, -0.00096501549705863, 0.03119877725839615, -0.014543007127940655, 0.03770038112998009, -0.019072193652391434, -0.0013098290655761957, -0.02636040188372135, -0.00749715743586421, 0.03893721476197243, -0.03651242330670357, -0.0383789949119091, 0.04500652104616165, -0.041932471096515656, -0.07777637243270874, 0.029762310907244682, -0.06673116236925125, -0.06523354351520538, 0.07359881699085236, -0.029920125380158424, -0.05294068530201912, 0.0005635053385049105, 0.0453404001891613, 0.0022563929669559, 0.0715288519859314, -0.054996557533741, -0.01001625694334507, -0.047450825572013855, 0.033824075013399124, -0.0018559719901531935, -0.05730998143553734, 0.0025339017156511545, 0.0842985063791275, -0.04147343337535858, -0.019145257771015167, 0.02719186618924141, -0.004697531461715698, -0.013557384721934795, 0.024478411301970482, -0.08974411338567734, -0.00803821999579668, 0.07651486992835999, 0.06583326309919357, 0.014407533220946789, -0.01585310697555542, 0.03771209344267845, -0.06131264567375183, 0.05075393617153168, -0.048840511590242386, 0.08462972193956375, -0.013681335374712944, 0.012612663209438324, 0.03209220618009567, 0.028986072167754173, 0.004597910214215517, 0.05839162319898605, 0.013027898035943508, -0.024893976747989655, -0.07815390080213547, -0.00013941162615083158, 0.06244824081659317, 0.05678652599453926, 0.003192001720890403, -0.06622316688299179, 0.02223389968276024, 0.019306020811200142, -0.06788261979818344, 0.04679594561457634, 0.004204249940812588, 0.0010532113956287503, 0.023653216660022736, -0.03389740362763405, -0.033074963837862015, -0.014279771596193314, 0.00826982967555523, 0.023448849096894264, 0.008769473992288113, 0.01839941367506981, -0.012233520857989788, -0.010942072607576847, 0.06078104302287102, -0.009434458799660206, -0.07443612068891525, 0.05369851738214493, 0.004956562537699938, -0.034882284700870514, -0.01933252066373825, -0.028291260823607445, 0.0711367279291153, 0.046256642788648605, -0.037100356072187424, -0.004641841631382704, -0.017057335004210472, -0.0035332865081727505, -0.08508326858282089, 0.010248729959130287, -0.06463085114955902, -0.1119702085852623, -0.04800907522439957, -0.03424522280693054, -0.00559393223375082, 0.0018151386175304651, -0.021906327456235886, -0.017330365255475044, 0.04328935593366623, -0.021445777267217636, 0.06717760115861893, 0.01019336935132742, -0.019542623311281204, 0.024849751964211464, -0.09029445052146912, -0.004885844886302948, 0.07897993177175522, 0.047888968139886856, 0.021334122866392136, -0.042087651789188385, -0.006639862898737192, -0.012244758196175098, -0.0703127533197403, -0.0002112163492711261, 0.009418460540473461, -0.0021925533656030893, 0.076415054500103, 0.0029089327435940504, -0.0048041264526546, 0.039988238364458084, 0.013715110719203949, -0.02197178453207016, 0.03336448222398758, 0.016942696645855904, -0.022585438564419746, -0.020046845078468323, -0.06962020695209503, -0.006369159556925297, -0.06149716302752495, -0.0815771147608757, 0.06752435863018036, -0.02556229755282402, -0.03840618208050728, -0.01248127594590187, 0.023132314905524254, -0.028508368879556656, -0.06162242963910103, -0.02548052743077278, -0.020692773163318634, -0.009432060644030571, 0.030783861875534058, -0.00957324169576168, -0.005568295251578093, -0.06781534105539322, -0.03268015384674072, -0.03882034495472908, -0.010969010181725025, -0.01312637235969305, -0.012283253483474255, -0.030254967510700226, 0.05333686247467995, 0.028437601402401924, 0.013040892779827118, 0.02347048744559288, -0.00584019161760807, 0.012789590284228325, -0.004942147992551327, 0.037634219974279404, 0.025153111666440964, -0.017181647941470146, 0.008509170264005661, -0.015583436004817486, -0.03705869987607002, -0.035214632749557495, -0.023190099745988846, 0.03816014155745506, -0.0015463827876374125, 0.001958095235750079, -0.06502074003219604, -0.004883402027189732, -0.018031680956482887, -0.003534559393301606, 0.0008283263887278736, -0.03227418661117554, -0.01690342277288437, -0.06652867048978806, 0.03599338233470917, 0.06013449281454086, -0.0008068750612437725, 0.07053529471158981, 0.0421433188021183, 0.009264921769499779, 0.02962726540863514, 0.004508547950536013, 0.03942912071943283, 0.011413211934268475, 0.025786753743886948, 0.01445565652102232, 0.04077538847923279, -0.01297428086400032, -0.04831547290086746, -0.01505006942898035, -0.03797873482108116, -0.010638957843184471, -0.046062685549259186, 0.022208072245121002, -0.02180357836186886, -0.01339888945221901, 0.021502560004591942, -0.04222172498703003, -0.03277646005153656, -0.0054445588029921055, -0.049418430775403976, -0.024943441152572632, 0.0029163016006350517, 0.01572827436029911, -0.01538021769374609, 0.010184121318161488, 0.026783466339111328, 0.008270264603197575, 0.01630864292383194, -0.01207098551094532, 0.021120106801390648, -0.02024105004966259, -0.07458300143480301, 0.05936221778392792, -0.012776684947311878, -0.024593792855739594, 0.03356489911675453, -0.018091874197125435, -0.021678833290934563, -0.005104448646306992, -0.01138301007449627, 0.02612536959350109, -0.057357802987098694, 0.00474102608859539, 0.0005167204071767628, 0.01648816466331482, 0.04614737257361412, 0.006956940982490778, 0.048117563128471375, -0.020602473989129066, -0.015067881904542446, -0.01596153900027275, 0.023727789521217346, -0.003312192391604185, 0.03515719622373581, 0.00926622748374939, -0.014825777150690556, -0.06912054121494293, 0.0678662657737732, -0.0494222529232502, -0.08641500771045685, 0.04494497925043106, -0.04231369122862816, 0.039950840175151825, 0.015717141330242157, 0.024438392370939255, -0.022364294156432152, 0.008253424428403378, 0.01343069039285183, 0.06695905327796936, -0.02613202854990959, 0.033441510051488876, 0.010429250076413155, -0.027833066880702972, -0.004296225495636463, 0.039628345519304276, -0.052222926169633865, 0.021626902744174004, 0.07634811848402023, 0.02564837783575058, 0.018103785812854767, 0.03910907357931137, 0.01659216359257698, 0.007662177085876465, -0.004776529036462307, -0.04533979669213295, 0.021043911576271057, -0.01317515503615141, 0.012602780014276505, -0.003192670876160264, -0.001056480105035007, -0.0400647409260273, -0.04073651507496834, 0.018924206495285034, -0.006517976522445679, -0.04068588837981224, -0.02922257035970688, -0.02080458216369152, -0.012605398893356323, -0.04540558159351349, -0.03820417448878288, 0.007981983944773674, -0.003580107819288969, 0.060943763703107834, -0.022096652537584305, 0.04112441837787628, -0.05570506304502487, 0.027586378157138824, 0.021028704941272736, -0.008128110319375992, 0.028243757784366608, -0.04742119088768959, -0.033933911472558975, 0.061975955963134766, -0.0539110042154789, 0.01954672485589981, 0.05509510263800621, 0.0004314388206694275, 0.010750175453722477, 0.003268345957621932, 0.022605471312999725, -0.011852391995489597, -0.004815849009901285, -0.03136169910430908, -0.019062431529164314, 0.00861411914229393, -0.051430270075798035, 0.048140931874513626, 0.009042690508067608, 0.01344134658575058, 0.026760034263134003, -0.05362461507320404, -0.06903854757547379, -0.004025198519229889, 0.02176729217171669, 0.007144416682422161, 0.02511696331202984, 0.0014762718928977847, 0.005105572286993265, 0.02947266958653927, -0.00016711991338524967, -0.023803267627954483, -0.028067752718925476, -0.011684086173772812, 0.019336702302098274, 0.004141824785619974, 0.017174595966935158, -0.021748332306742668, -0.041291069239377975, 0.02555399388074875, 0.020222457125782967, -0.03653208911418915, -0.0185476653277874, 0.021485064178705215, -0.041302960366010666, -0.018372127786278725, 0.0007669934420846403, 0.04670010507106781, 0.002382214181125164, -0.021657515317201614, -0.019352588802576065, 0.0908983051776886, -0.04979793354868889, 0.053706154227256775, -0.03878350183367729, 0.023241087794303894, 0.04580547288060188, 0.017273571342229843, -0.021331364288926125, -0.07358541339635849, -0.028397396206855774, 0.04495283216238022, 0.09690912812948227, 0.0019228484015911818, 0.05425817519426346, 0.002074850257486105, 0.055777065455913544, 0.01449507474899292, -0.04425055533647537, 0.02804305963218212, -0.010813058353960514, 0.03284240886569023, -0.00816788338124752, 0.0027014778461307287, 0.06030993163585663, -0.008380955085158348, 0.01385301910340786, 0.017596721649169922, -0.062119338661432266, -0.04124369099736214, -0.030790014192461967, -0.0009625371312722564, -0.035344164818525314, -0.05036351829767227, -0.0035099987871944904, -0.011737816967070103 ]
<p>I'm trying to derive the equation for the cosmological fluid:</p> <p>$$\dot \rho + 3 \frac{\dot a}{a}(\rho +P)=0$$</p> <p>by starting from the conservation of the stress-energy tensor:</p> <p>$$\nabla^\mu T_{\mu \nu} = 0$$</p> <p>with the stress-energy for a perfect fluid in its own frame being:</p> <p>$$ T_{\mu \nu} = \text{diag} (\rho, a(t)^2 P,a(t)^2 P,a(t)^2 P) $$</p> <p>in a spatially flat FLRW metric:</p> <p>$$g_{\mu \nu} = \text{diag}(1,-a(t)^2,-a(t)^2,-a(t)^2)$$</p> <p>But I keep getting a bogus answer! Consider the equation you get from $ \nabla^\mu T_{\mu \nu} = 0$ when $\nu =0$:</p> <p>$$ \begin{align*} \nabla^\mu T_{\mu 0} &amp;= 0 \\ g^{\mu \alpha}\nabla_\alpha T_{\mu 0} &amp;= 0 \end{align*} $$</p> <p>$T$ is diagonal, so $\mu$ must be zero, but $g$ is diagonal as well, so if $\mu$ is zero, then so is $\alpha$. This gives:</p> <p>$$ \begin{align*} g^{0 0}\nabla_0 T_{0 0} &amp;= 0 \\ \nabla_0 \rho &amp;= 0 \\ \dot \rho &amp;= 0 \end{align*} $$</p> <p>Because $\rho$ is just a scalar, so the covariant derivative is the partial derivative. Except this answer is wrong.</p>
g4069
[ 0.045116279274225235, -0.04361370950937271, -0.019204849377274513, -0.0498150996863842, 0.04805019870400429, 0.025981348007917404, 0.05094034969806671, 0.022488048300147057, -0.057300496846437454, -0.030133962631225586, -0.0033914123196154833, 0.0038359512109309435, 0.014310849830508232, -0.03801775723695755, 0.02258036658167839, 0.024023661389946938, 0.017782341688871384, -0.028720317408442497, 0.03172237053513527, 0.03083401545882225, -0.06287495046854019, 0.003164090448990464, 0.077407605946064, -0.03324691951274872, 0.07799967378377914, -0.01509408000856638, 0.011475724168121815, -0.01741226390004158, -0.09590078145265579, -0.04380911588668823, 0.05534379556775093, 0.041528746485710144, 0.031931087374687195, -0.04941019043326378, -0.03167843073606491, 0.008304484188556671, 0.05533545836806297, 0.0465405248105526, 0.06312724947929382, -0.022673973813652992, -0.009846090339124203, 0.009226670488715172, 0.008922258391976357, 0.01736437901854515, 0.001179719460196793, -0.028457874432206154, -0.051552701741456985, -0.004182090051472187, -0.03639382869005203, 0.006902315188199282, 0.03091570734977722, 0.05796042084693909, 0.012426510453224182, -0.0592501200735569, -0.08558633178472519, 0.03286696970462799, 0.021287143230438232, -0.06789683550596237, 0.013791579753160477, 0.021139640361070633, -0.0012996074510738254, -0.0666389986872673, 0.018937624990940094, 0.011104005388915539, 0.04049552604556084, -0.07259660959243774, -0.024401331320405006, -0.01708393730223179, 0.07334959506988525, -0.003893478075042367, 0.08346904069185257, 0.004855823703110218, 0.07694607228040695, 0.01628207601606846, -0.008349912241101265, -0.028196359053254128, 0.013495193794369698, 0.008760367520153522, 0.013589366339147091, -0.053053200244903564, 0.008157267235219479, 0.00634511886164546, 0.0557677298784256, 0.05535343661904335, 0.008517290465533733, 0.01268409937620163, 0.0013212875928729773, 0.009944094344973564, -0.0002308882976649329, 0.05344529077410698, 0.008610490709543228, -0.0076954481191933155, 0.0023818949703127146, 0.02019013650715351, 0.06101531162858009, 0.009894347749650478, -0.023827427998185158, 0.05722760036587715, 0.03264611214399338, -0.040032755583524704, -0.017439518123865128, -0.012734092772006989, 0.037056244909763336, -0.0009067003848031163, 0.024325449019670486, -0.004034337121993303, -0.002302582608535886, 0.0464557446539402, 0.010488324798643589, -0.020331909880042076, -0.03356460854411125, 0.024106711149215698, -0.022827239707112312, -0.035780224949121475, -0.0002419301454210654, -0.011123238131403923, 0.01776066981256008, -0.04405125603079796, -0.004788404796272516, 0.027556762099266052, -0.004753840621560812, 0.006439528428018093, 0.0033381821122020483, 0.10668784379959106, -0.046230364590883255, -0.009373397566378117, -0.001934366999194026, -0.010374454781413078, 0.08996856212615967, -0.030623784288764, 0.026575226336717606, -0.010517505928874016, -0.000961651501711458, -0.036917831748723984, 0.02265874482691288, -0.00001212305505760014, -0.02731930837035179, 0.05235673487186432, -0.013203884474933147, 0.039413876831531525, -0.02615942247211933, -0.019724741578102112, -0.0130976727232337, 0.014478746801614761, -0.0015761960530653596, -0.047154903411865234, -0.007795195560902357, -0.04291792958974838, 0.07080619782209396, -0.0035569528117775917, 0.029179265722632408, 0.11423001438379288, -0.03331601619720459, -0.018277982249855995, 0.010444753803312778, 0.0019734466914087534, 0.01019027829170227, -0.05499161407351494, -0.029127614572644234, -0.01481009740382433, 0.08126885443925858, -0.022373521700501442, 0.0771922841668129, 0.03780083358287811, 0.016800733283162117, 0.017100322991609573, 0.003190769115462899, 0.0030868269968777895, 0.012121831066906452, -0.044162530452013016, -0.04402516037225723, 0.053853392601013184, 0.014002259820699692, -0.006413380615413189, -0.026629842817783356, 0.04980853572487831, -0.013117276132106781, 0.006289467681199312, 0.014681937173008919, 0.0080741997808218, 0.02893049456179142, -0.03847164660692215, 0.03792194649577141, -0.010863552801311016, 0.04107555374503136, -0.0294716227799654, -0.021326975896954536, 0.024956461042165756, -0.05853702127933502, 0.0404796302318573, 0.0036975417751818895, 0.044123440980911255, 0.0340120866894722, 0.00993244256824255, 0.010235458612442017, 0.041608721017837524, 0.005254561081528664, -0.06813369691371918, -0.03111603483557701, 0.055856846272945404, -0.006303609348833561, 0.004494856111705303, 0.03873484954237938, 0.02766129933297634, -0.015559237450361252, -0.016509350389242172, 0.01781816966831684, -0.03912743553519249, 0.00033782992977648973, -0.01725487969815731, -0.01618804782629013, -0.03069073148071766, -0.02187260054051876, -0.016054043546319008, 0.027833664789795876, -0.04784045368432999, 0.04571034014225006, 0.013051440939307213, -0.09156562387943268, 0.013042074628174305, -0.06913533061742783, 0.05003664270043373, 0.01007969118654728, -0.02251155860722065, -0.021974531933665276, 0.013916117139160633, -0.037957124412059784, -0.009914996102452278, -0.03393775597214699, -0.011351085267961025, -0.03407050669193268, -0.008560513146221638, 0.03182854503393173, 0.03733842819929123, 0.059898246079683304, 0.026676001027226448, -0.04335403069853783, 0.03800603374838829, -0.012481489218771458, 0.05449464172124863, -0.025903331115841866, 0.026056185364723206, -0.03752662613987923, 0.01754125952720642, 0.05175481364130974, 0.036567915230989456, 0.0621708519756794, -0.021987710148096085, 0.01581176370382309, -0.013949560932815075, 0.07077387720346451, -0.05095389485359192, 0.020769935101270676, -0.011891665868461132, 0.0014443844556808472, -0.009982213377952576, 0.003159357002004981, -0.024107618257403374, -0.04168608784675598, 0.004724838770925999, 0.034010596573352814, -0.03089895099401474, 0.00743910763412714, 0.010880568064749241, -0.02967405505478382, 0.006155979819595814, -0.0021274923346936703, 0.007703748997300863, 0.016795339062809944, 0.024638479575514793, 0.01798572763800621, 0.07242986559867859, 0.04863084852695465, 0.056746866554021835, -0.03849036991596222, -0.011346542276442051, -0.01984165795147419, -0.014565497636795044, -0.0016329647041857243, 0.02920377068221569, -0.006041715387254953, 0.040985312312841415, 0.00247711013071239, 0.033227503299713135, -0.002542093861848116, -0.05667511373758316, -0.0020239287987351418, 0.01575474441051483, 0.05987970158457756, -0.010067983530461788, 0.03676244243979454, 0.061610933393239975, -0.054929863661527634, -0.018790198490023613, 0.0005699029425159097, 0.032639432698488235, -0.01866072230041027, -0.019295012578368187, -0.028692472726106644, 0.02295677177608013, 0.016332026571035385, -0.0019359596772119403, -0.008559392765164375, -0.02246953919529915, -0.038275327533483505, 0.006334938108921051, -0.00620831735432148, -0.07801081240177155, 0.023772208020091057, -0.0048236544243991375, -0.03468272462487221, 0.01727239601314068, 0.0001874920417321846, -0.020718976855278015, -0.007343977224081755, -0.0003190292918588966, 0.02545579895377159, -0.0918920487165451, -0.021410590037703514, 0.023589517921209335, 0.003926623146981001, -0.03299185261130333, -0.05913592129945755, 0.04253224655985832, -0.0440375991165638, 0.03858364000916481, -0.044757530093193054, 0.00113883544690907, -0.02196946181356907, -0.006565757095813751, -0.006866839714348316, 0.002191209467127919, 0.018991362303495407, -0.018905289471149445, -0.008892230689525604, -0.05001382529735565, -0.08327824622392654, 0.051947467029094696, 0.07566314190626144, 0.0016025085933506489, -0.041745174676179886, -0.03268017619848251, -0.008213464170694351, -0.005777608137577772, -0.02990325726568699, 0.01753324642777443, 0.0012420122511684895, 0.0025171113666146994, 0.021201396360993385, 0.002332912525162101, 0.01728234626352787, -0.0029684905894100666, -0.025226587429642677, -0.05765213072299957, -0.010310978628695011, 0.002643394283950329, 0.04166794940829277, 0.038649722933769226, 0.04388872906565666, -0.0013402882032096386, 0.00021565350471064448, -0.04637965187430382, 0.018190907314419746, -0.002080632606521249, 0.019458450376987457, -0.021951310336589813, 0.02079170010983944, -0.027985980734229088, -0.07032205164432526, -0.00516170309856534, 0.03546440228819847, -0.024537891149520874, -0.008991853334009647, 0.020109862089157104, -0.0035288631916046143, -0.06387962400913239, -0.025301063433289528, -0.04922135919332504, -0.05751354247331619, 0.02765393629670143, 0.032211534678936005, -0.06906384229660034, 0.013921733014285564, 0.059167563915252686, -0.010220583528280258, 0.009508417919278145, -0.02186673879623413, 0.0019248848548159003, 0.03668080270290375, 0.026616880670189857, 0.008281728252768517, -0.016108684241771698, 0.018926341086626053, -0.0586322657763958, 0.009779931046068668, 0.01276813168078661, 0.05151054263114929, 0.04306178539991379, -0.06968259066343307, 0.020113777369260788, 0.002661023987457156, -0.049378927797079086, 0.023599855601787567, -0.017909033223986626, -0.011033614166080952, -0.01952425204217434, -0.025489823892712593, -0.06196996569633484, -0.014009515754878521, -0.03095153532922268, 0.035209495574235916, -0.029833132401108742, 0.01659821718931198, -0.035322368144989014, 0.07835627347230911, -0.059744324535131454, 0.009454227983951569, -0.016877921298146248, 0.031284160912036896, 0.013823321089148521, 0.04260687902569771, -0.014805258251726627, -0.0008959138067439198, 0.018799038603901863, 0.07753217220306396, 0.018684959039092064, 0.03318311274051666, 0.014518344774842262, -0.053487177938222885, -0.023452043533325195, 0.060040272772312164, 0.0003033477405551821, 0.0042036958038806915, 0.05371828004717827, -0.07797133922576904, 0.07501082122325897, -0.05157449096441269, -0.002124650403857231, -0.04002535715699196, 0.020124386996030807, 0.06589404493570328, 0.005150042939931154, 0.05367196351289749, -0.034029681235551834, 0.012635167688131332, 0.09000597149133682, 0.04807765781879425, -0.0701366737484932, 0.01860370859503746, -0.030858058482408524, -0.018415961414575577, 0.014324725605547428, 0.024492179974913597, -0.02556060068309307, 0.000473361142212525, -0.02498556673526764, -0.038224976509809494, 0.02842416614294052, 0.02514425478875637, 0.028033984825015068, -0.03820037469267845, 0.0082516148686409, 0.03428516536951065, -0.0027080471627414227, 0.052896276116371155, -0.014263716526329517, -0.018409866839647293, 0.04622746258974075, -0.03371025249361992, -0.0609421543776989, 0.003753444878384471, 0.0026611490175127983, -0.04975176602602005, -0.021664099767804146, -0.030289851129055023, 0.05755448713898659, -0.01864742301404476, -0.005186793860048056, -0.011755989864468575, -0.03486761823296547, 0.03760482370853424, 0.025861453264951706, 0.0214220080524683, 0.035244181752204895, 0.03787289932370186, 0.07043544203042984, -0.028544513508677483, -0.02836393006145954, 0.01904388889670372, 0.001357184024527669, -0.011636423878371716, 0.03152966871857643, 0.017033547163009644, -0.02957042306661606, 0.020270636305212975, 0.030681349337100983, -0.006880329456180334, -0.022670617327094078, -0.015955986455082893, -0.024561462923884392, -0.07417812198400497, -0.01988322101533413, -0.030799657106399536, -0.017797188833355904, 0.026866182684898376, 0.03901826962828636, 0.045424483716487885, -0.0068648504093289375, 0.009757674299180508, 0.07037422060966492, -0.004462718963623047, -0.03454555571079254, 0.04600576311349869, 0.04364462569355965, -0.002240281319245696, -0.05553703382611275, 0.03959321230649948, 0.009742039255797863, -0.048755113035440445, -0.034630291163921356, 0.014555719681084156, 0.0014025046257302165, 0.04476878046989441, 0.02778816409409046, 0.040908198803663254, 0.014150017872452736, -0.017576592043042183, -0.005617849063128233, -0.020928237587213516, 0.008680718950927258, -0.04646608605980873, -0.005325753707438707, -0.008314516395330429, -0.016981160268187523, 0.012624126859009266, -0.04908479377627373, -0.03254185616970062, 0.011374722234904766, 0.0628972053527832, -0.02341861091554165, 0.005458967760205269, -0.04434547573328018, -0.023434843868017197, -0.001038331538438797, -0.025171104818582535, 0.033618003129959106, -0.05315833538770676, -0.003378306282684207, -0.027728989720344543, -0.07595532387495041, -0.04803234711289406, 0.011969744227826595, -0.04931566119194031, 0.009532952681183815, 0.0350676029920578, -0.04405760392546654, 0.008736509829759598, -0.05418037995696068, -0.03825845569372177, -0.012188546359539032, -0.03423469141125679, 0.007163838017731905, -0.036510955542325974, 0.03693993017077446, -0.020881889387965202, -0.015655014663934708, -0.0007890654960647225, -0.03514440357685089, 0.0675884410738945, -0.04294866696000099, -0.005295215640217066, 0.033672794699668884, -0.019349876791238785, 0.0010983863612636924, 0.0758708044886589, -0.00481339730322361, -0.06760542839765549, 0.01597820781171322, -0.044799380004405975, 0.018317004665732384, -0.01092657819390297, -0.03541890159249306, 0.0675680935382843, -0.04794051870703697, 0.050849758088588715, 0.009886102750897408, -0.04496162757277489, -0.00385110336355865, 0.004367624409496784, 0.01917875185608864, 0.01194531749933958, 0.008495962247252464, -0.022556062787771225, -0.024783175438642502, 0.02896912954747677, -0.030882034450769424, -0.013238946907222271, -0.013310891576111317, -0.040120478719472885, 0.032540060579776764, -0.027048230171203613, 0.03156153857707977, 0.049465324729681015, -0.034674983471632004, 0.021435413509607315, -0.008273222483694553, -0.03384752199053764, 0.052216432988643646, 0.0008008248987607658, 0.03431317210197449, -0.03368924930691719, 0.0664152279496193, 0.009543873369693756, 0.0027372404001653194, 0.024928439408540726, -0.008381806313991547, -0.00595502182841301, 0.05404435098171234, 0.025959745049476624, -0.031505197286605835, 0.04704452306032181, 0.02727588079869747, 0.00580325024202466, -0.031154686585068703, 0.06564134359359741, -0.030789585784077644, -0.01476521696895361, 0.03091236762702465, -0.0006259412621147931, 0.016860859468579292, 0.03326806053519249, -0.012444181367754936, -0.08188743144273758, 0.09572545439004898, -0.010041864588856697, 0.059465985745191574, -0.0653214082121849, 0.002926540793851018, 0.04507585987448692, 0.01859389804303646, -0.04833761975169182, 0.0469873882830143, 0.016590040177106857, -0.01478060707449913, -0.05804036930203438, 0.06612255424261093, -0.01896902173757553, -0.014501712284982204, -0.057517651468515396, -0.039120905101299286, 0.03686223551630974, -0.05165310204029083, -0.026566408574581146, 0.018810143694281578, -0.08245208859443665, 0.0513005405664444, -0.048821259289979935, -0.010968604125082493, -0.020297707989811897, -0.03889544680714607, 0.048191484063863754, -0.04706641659140587, 0.0359308123588562, 0.037794265896081924, -0.006982551887631416, 0.04464670643210411, 0.027253324165940285, -0.07315719872713089, 0.06889443844556808, -0.005942321848124266, 0.05060311779379845, -0.010962202213704586, -0.09179424494504929, 0.03215397149324417, 0.010515584610402584, 0.023172086104750633, -0.01656363531947136, 0.015565237030386925, 0.018666785210371017, 0.0039443401619791985, -0.02452913671731949, 0.015037312172353268, -0.024227894842624664, -0.04162014275789261, -0.031795915216207504, 0.013111984357237816, 0.06050199270248413, -0.027355624362826347, 0.02653251402080059, 0.024185238406062126, 0.0008753568399697542, 0.05579245835542679, 0.020005017518997192, 0.008935301564633846, -0.043612584471702576, -0.022746382281184196, 0.016364138573408127, 0.03955800458788872, 0.01947855018079281, -0.00047575452481396496, -0.025214239954948425, -0.051332030445337296, -0.053255535662174225, 0.006024685222655535, -0.001068256446160376, -0.015037480741739273, -0.003654121421277523, -0.00804964080452919, -0.021862534806132317, 0.008027711883187294, 0.0644712895154953, -0.05717911943793297, -0.031766172498464584, 0.010391516610980034, 0.057041607797145844, -0.00808014441281557, -0.034282661974430084, 0.012541200965642929, -0.023488309234380722, -0.09464564919471741, -0.041511014103889465, 0.0052634249441325665, -0.028127513825893402, -0.0983794778585434, -0.009050307795405388, 0.06604770570993423, -0.025891147553920746, -0.046272583305835724, 0.016337363049387932, -0.028077030554413795, -0.0513409823179245, -0.02628588303923607, -0.01955481991171837, 0.013486611656844616, 0.05233210325241089, 0.021775471046566963, 0.028249476104974747, -0.05868130177259445, 0.03925325721502304, -0.019495327025651932, 0.007295115850865841, -0.046143900603055954, -0.010638464242219925, -0.05814535543322563, 0.04998665302991867, -0.014831868931651115, -0.005917721893638372, 0.020024161785840988, -0.0034293157514184713, -0.023922162130475044, 0.0380023792386055, 0.0408405140042305, 0.02407767064869404, 0.007353117689490318, 0.0007057942566461861, -0.07370433211326599, 0.02639501914381981, -0.053619127720594406, -0.02712438814342022, -0.005889913998544216, -0.005882068537175655, -0.055004775524139404, -0.00656855059787631, -0.01870626024901867, 0.04334508255124092, -0.046411335468292236, 0.038624107837677, 0.022991789504885674 ]
<p>I am working through Franz Schwabl's book on Statistical Mechanics, and he has a number of derivations of thermodynamic quantities that are different than those I have seen before. I am also having difficulty finding them repeated elsewhere.</p> <p>In particular, he has a method for calculating $\Omega(E)$, the number of states with a given energy $E$, of a series of $N$ independent Quantum Harmonic Oscillators ($\mathcal{H} = \sum_{j=1}^N\hbar\omega(n_j+\frac{1}{2})$) that I hadn't seen before. Proceeding from the result</p> <p>$$\Omega(E) = \mathrm{Tr}\,\delta(\mathcal{H}-E)=\sum_{n_1=0}^{\infty}\cdots\sum_{n_N=0}^{\infty}\delta\left(E - \hbar\omega\sum_{j=1}^N\left(n_j+\frac{1}{2}\right)\right),$$</p> <p>my strategy would be combinatoric: the delta-function turns the unrestricted sums over $n_j$ to a constraint on the total number of quanta. Calculating the number of ways you can partition $n=\sum_{j=1}^Nn_j$ quanta of energy among $N$ oscillators gives you $\Omega(E)$. This is the way we did it in undergraduate stat mech.</p> <p>Schwabl's approach proceeds differently: by taking the Fourier Transform of the delta function, one obtains</p> <p>$$\Omega(E) = \int \frac{dk}{2\pi}e^{ikE}\prod_{j=1}^N\left(e^{-ik\hbar\omega/2}\sum_{n_j=0}^{\infty}e^{-ik\hbar\omega n_j}\right)=\int\frac{dk}{2\pi}e^{ikE}\left(\frac{e^{-ik\hbar\omega/2}}{1-e^{-ik\hbar\omega}}\right)^N,$$</p> <p>where this last step involves <strong>summing a divergent geometric series,</strong> declaring $$\sum_{\ell=0}^{\infty}e^{-i\alpha\ell} = \frac{1}{1-e^{-i\alpha}}$$ and ignoring the fact that this series doesn't converge in a conventional sense. </p> <p>This simplifies to $$\Omega(E) = \int\frac{dk}{2\pi}e^{N(ik(E/N) - \log(2i\sin(k\hbar\omega/2)))}$$</p> <p>which is solved using the saddle-point approximation. The maximum of the argument of the exponential occurs at a value</p> <p>$$k_0 = \frac{1}{\hbar\omega i}\log\frac{\frac{E}{N}+\frac{\hbar\omega}{2}}{\frac{E}{N}-\frac{\hbar\omega}{2}}$$</p> <p>Which is clearly imaginary, <strong>despite the fact that in a Fourier Transform $k$ is supposed to be a real number!</strong></p> <p><em>In spite of all this</em>, if you evaluate the integral using the saddle point approximation at $k=k_0$, you get the same form for $\Omega(E)$ that one derives through the garden-variety combinatorial argument!</p> <p>My question(s) are</p> <blockquote> <p>Why does this work? Specifically:</p> <ul> <li><p>Why does it make sense to write the convergence of a divergent geometric series in the form given here (is this relying on some sense of convergence other than the typical one, and if so, what? And what does that imply about convergence in stat mech?), and </p></li> <li><p>Why can you use the saddle point approximation when the maximum value does not occur in the space over which you are integrating?</p></li> </ul> </blockquote> <p>Answers to this question might rely on appeals to other situations in which this math occurs and has been rationalized, physically if not mathematically. </p>
g4070
[ 0.02868787944316864, 0.03812591731548309, -0.009324723854660988, -0.03636500611901283, -0.001904500531964004, -0.00792508665472269, 0.010141808539628983, 0.004153008107095957, -0.033379796892404556, -0.016691887751221657, -0.05740310624241829, -0.022137701511383057, 0.10027739405632019, 0.06686963886022568, 0.006675451062619686, -0.05708571523427963, 0.03158978745341301, 0.023328231647610664, -0.014357433654367924, -0.020426610484719276, -0.08836487680673599, 0.005669830366969109, 0.012954353354871273, -0.06129442900419235, 0.012085980735719204, -0.039671704173088074, 0.02393236570060253, -0.00231381319463253, -0.012187644839286804, -0.02423844300210476, -0.010448260232806206, 0.01855885051190853, 0.04918354004621506, -0.003852629801258445, -0.042076945304870605, 0.024173973128199577, 0.09164227545261383, -0.00631778035312891, 0.05086801201105118, -0.038084305822849274, -0.007398763205856085, -0.05483003705739975, 0.02874814346432686, 0.04295159876346588, -0.010103605687618256, -0.021556347608566284, 0.005315183661878109, 0.002748707076534629, 0.0496334582567215, -0.0046357824467122555, 0.005467351991683245, 0.07386825233697891, 0.06667575985193253, -0.02597861923277378, 0.019037704914808273, -0.010903678834438324, -0.046619657427072525, -0.056347157806158066, 0.020985111594200134, 0.03989017754793167, -0.004334198776632547, -0.029375331476330757, 0.0019664678256958723, 0.027440490201115608, 0.08014757931232452, 0.017280464991927147, 0.012383158318698406, -0.006171954330056906, 0.00470738485455513, 0.002528969431295991, 0.04039584845304489, -0.05943084880709648, 0.025273945182561874, -0.05191998556256294, -0.035424910485744476, -0.026793766766786575, -0.00205419328995049, 0.008961698040366173, 0.015223001129925251, 0.016086798161268234, -0.0025147139094769955, -0.04111085832118988, -0.007629782892763615, -0.06319490075111389, 0.03781820461153984, -0.052022162824869156, 0.033209580928087234, -0.009151076897978783, -0.01827494241297245, 0.03538678213953972, 0.026112928986549377, 0.004461470525711775, 0.0065415408462285995, -0.016965271905064583, -0.05137808620929718, 0.011868930421769619, -0.025081975385546684, 0.03526166453957558, 0.04147786647081375, -0.01908211223781109, 0.015260187909007072, 0.04534431919455528, 0.011720996350049973, -0.037456609308719635, -0.03085155226290226, -0.0276383887976408, 0.014098472893238068, 0.006912645418196917, 0.0072034262120723724, -0.044483669102191925, -0.07571608573198318, -0.012166539207100868, -0.03242209926247597, -0.05616715922951698, -0.07842555642127991, -0.0018220635829493403, 0.03163217008113861, 0.005525539163500071, -0.022431012243032455, 0.052697766572237015, 0.002810773439705372, -0.0009607971296645701, 0.06145377457141876, 0.04647618904709816, -0.006035588216036558, 0.04986318573355675, 0.003996965009719133, -0.030654234811663628, 0.04496414214372635, -0.02715703845024109, -0.012893292121589184, 0.0067594340071082115, -0.03073410876095295, 0.04192548245191574, -0.03197702020406723, -0.012039006687700748, -0.02804914303123951, 0.0503883883357048, 0.022016581147909164, 0.001756958314217627, 0.005691396072506905, -0.06197655573487282, -0.014359251596033573, -0.07178846746683121, 0.012102882377803326, 0.04389287158846855, -0.01673159748315811, -0.11417712271213531, 0.009370197542011738, -0.03449583798646927, -0.005007583182305098, 0.038015082478523254, 0.012832592241466045, -0.020727727562189102, 0.010807536542415619, 0.028666429221630096, 0.06367611885070801, 0.032595206052064896, 0.006348768714815378, 0.035722069442272186, 0.022613834589719772, -0.037644874304533005, -0.02887384034693241, -0.021125946193933487, -0.0026450983714312315, 0.05982425808906555, -0.029516756534576416, -0.0777660608291626, -0.004851049277931452, -0.03628375008702278, -0.00997206848114729, 0.024771515280008316, -0.021697867661714554, -0.06885475665330887, 0.04398110881447792, 0.03496001288294792, 0.018546491861343384, -0.04024675861001015, -0.02328607253730297, 0.05598551407456398, 0.041409749537706375, -0.004565089009702206, 0.05075955018401146, -0.039895933121442795, 0.010725176893174648, 0.04109597206115723, 0.0071149724535644054, -0.017424194142222404, 0.01317562721669674, 0.008933129720389843, -0.0058940136805176735, 0.04377775639295578, 0.03603876009583473, 0.04120538756251335, -0.023716233670711517, 0.052105654031038284, 0.0514506921172142, -0.035806264728307724, -0.08531444519758224, -0.018713651224970818, 0.002418195828795433, 0.04866846278309822, 0.010526401922106743, 0.013576149940490723, -0.012333156540989876, 0.02197597548365593, 0.008048857562243938, 0.039064034819602966, -0.012501747347414494, 0.008888494223356247, -0.020641645416617393, -0.05331839993596077, -0.01696535386145115, 0.012410491704940796, -0.02642252668738365, -0.05006042867898941, 0.030202317982912064, -0.06991960108280182, 0.004757293965667486, 0.022712813690304756, 0.003826170926913619, -0.026228811591863632, 0.058337874710559845, 0.05874374881386757, 0.000595636258367449, 0.040356557816267014, -0.002704142825677991, -0.01988857612013817, -0.023228976875543594, 0.053241558372974396, -0.07264682650566101, -0.0005062953568994999, 0.01984548196196556, -0.03423851728439331, 0.015250101685523987, -0.003732487792149186, -0.002916642464697361, -0.02247302606701851, -0.0128939775750041, 0.026991819962859154, 0.09609773010015488, -0.05245233327150345, -0.038689833134412766, 0.0310011338442564, -0.00545078469440341, 0.03545577451586723, -0.03353251516819, -0.023327510803937912, -0.014328226447105408, -0.005800155457109213, -0.017248503863811493, 0.006935383193194866, 0.04539106413722038, 0.016117500141263008, -0.01507799793034792, 0.007879605516791344, 0.014636989682912827, -0.05911578610539436, -0.0158819742500782, -0.016855990514159203, -0.025516310706734657, -0.008857804350554943, 0.061112839728593826, -0.008753049187362194, -0.04013281315565109, -0.023977382108569145, 0.005538917146623135, -0.04476284980773926, 0.006643668282777071, -0.053799375891685486, -0.037553299218416214, 0.03744633123278618, 0.020018184557557106, 0.03278264030814171, 0.0003087355871684849, -0.029512429609894753, -0.00019678210082929581, -0.003497747238725424, 0.05412045121192932, -0.016716109588742256, -0.02068735472857952, -0.02678598091006279, -0.030292373150587082, 0.032648224383592606, 0.0492468997836113, -0.05644363537430763, 0.044202256947755814, -0.014694757759571075, 0.005303528625518084, 0.020477600395679474, 0.002325048204511404, 0.014519869349896908, -0.021186532452702522, 0.01466649491339922, -0.008589808829128742, 0.01947253756225109, -0.016634918749332428, -0.06511812657117844, 0.03147227317094803, 0.05649186670780182, 0.0419711098074913, -0.006214042194187641, -0.0134627940133214, -0.011702199466526508, 0.03166012465953827, 0.047683991491794586, -0.03461718186736107, -0.05880798399448395, 0.03128085657954216, 0.00675058551132679, 0.02550361678004265, 0.007445311173796654, 0.0362384095788002, -0.05780094489455223, -0.04345851019024849, -0.0038247129414230585, 0.010906344279646873, -0.03469311445951462, 0.024581732228398323, -0.05317079648375511, -0.03435012325644493, -0.07221655547618866, -0.006341096945106983, -0.02884664013981819, 0.040517233312129974, 0.013923348858952522, -0.04885478317737579, -0.035981811583042145, -0.03541223332285881, -0.012706110253930092, 0.02726775035262108, 0.033387191593647, 0.05830974876880646, 0.026787566021084785, -0.049381691962480545, -0.0817573294043541, -0.03719362989068031, -0.025431793183088303, 0.04645289480686188, -0.020195674151182175, -0.07620728015899658, -0.020283779129385948, 0.01036612968891859, -0.004448081366717815, 0.005080966744571924, -0.01897132769227028, -0.014888149686157703, 0.04015020281076431, -0.011799092404544353, 0.040658559650182724, 0.020709631964564323, -0.0117977075278759, 0.015428451821208, 0.043388575315475464, 0.014108477160334587, -0.012046616524457932, 0.03036661446094513, 0.006154187023639679, -0.0103751914575696, 0.02642170339822769, 0.03485166281461716, -0.020847827196121216, -0.0008856490021571517, 0.006908147130161524, -0.0012027377961203456, 0.012508129701018333, 0.023618189617991447, 0.05096979811787605, -0.006384431384503841, -0.006914462428539991, 0.003107120981439948, -0.06031171977519989, 0.037016961723566055, -0.015440348535776138, 0.00030838785460218787, -0.05483295023441315, 0.010414001531898975, 0.014130908995866776, -0.0493483766913414, 0.02699262835085392, 0.053343046456575394, -0.028702907264232635, 0.01444844901561737, -0.008639201521873474, 0.0339418388903141, -0.027849378064274788, -0.00039191023097373545, -0.009063598699867725, 0.03361264616250992, -0.04201173037290573, 0.08299198746681213, -0.021329544484615326, -0.00497442064806819, 0.009232715703547001, 0.023848028853535652, -0.03644692897796631, -0.009233356453478336, 0.006954706273972988, -0.03808862343430519, 0.1024397760629654, 0.023242363706231117, -0.08016554266214371, -0.027703629806637764, 0.0035274862311780453, -0.0411757193505764, -0.0017389028798788786, 0.026263223960995674, 0.0033375429920852184, 0.04805450513958931, -0.07342836260795593, 0.0047921170480549335, -0.02478107437491417, 0.03655857592821121, -0.024658167734742165, -0.02464517578482628, -0.0503767691552639, 0.0528901107609272, -0.027102671563625336, -0.02206825651228428, 0.01706586591899395, -0.04271790385246277, -0.007937573827803135, -0.04211633652448654, 0.023780925199389458, 0.026827218011021614, 0.01688716933131218, 0.005319087766110897, 0.019128670915961266, -0.04043475165963173, -0.037081267684698105, 0.04531759396195412, 0.02001672051846981, 0.010113388299942017, 0.017468154430389404, -0.04758184030652046, 0.06837234646081924, -0.004833191633224487, 0.0657859742641449, -0.04570864886045456, 0.020853746682405472, 0.02717779390513897, 0.02127644419670105, -0.006811469793319702, 0.003992118872702122, 0.06403690576553345, 0.05221238732337952, -0.033355120569467545, -0.0333566889166832, 0.047869086265563965, 0.00414995988830924, 0.024010665714740753, -0.00972029473632574, 0.07405917346477509, 0.014034264720976353, -0.01977679878473282, -0.019741469994187355, -0.02099478617310524, 0.06961013376712799, 0.01936757005751133, 0.0006489007500931621, -0.002624205080792308, -0.06331076472997665, -0.03596950322389603, -0.044734518975019455, 0.029584646224975586, 0.04788656532764435, -0.059728607535362244, 0.03832387179136276, -0.016214996576309204, -0.005859660916030407, 0.04655756801366806, 0.019577909260988235, 0.05834205821156502, -0.01538414042443037, 0.008308293297886848, -0.024014312773942947, 0.000994216650724411, -0.041148435324430466, -0.057493243366479874, -0.04311744123697281, 0.0030800625681877136, -0.00474426569417119, -0.00457923486828804, 0.09089861065149307, -0.04380964860320091, -0.012776670977473259, 0.029912540689110756, -0.09599795937538147, -0.009470416232943535, 0.019563233479857445, 0.013283556327223778, 0.01889840140938759, 0.041290074586868286, 0.03886163979768753, -0.005328639876097441, 0.02782425470650196, 0.07326537370681763, -0.006775897461920977, 0.003749664407223463, 0.005208966322243214, -0.09229877591133118, 0.04673074558377266, -0.06578627228736877, -0.021889351308345795, 0.04043798893690109, 0.008961676619946957, 0.07343016564846039, 0.018927495926618576, -0.021769635379314423, -0.0011474486673250794, 0.04621392488479614, 0.02132299169898033, -0.006231097970157862, -0.0057633668184280396, 0.02961578592658043, 0.0006341462722048163, -0.035844866186380386, -0.021983304992318153, -0.03262435272336006, -0.07729721814393997, 0.08989086747169495, -0.009575674310326576, 0.023142702877521515, -0.0015316533390432596, 0.04161340743303299, 0.02065335400402546, -0.05328232795000076, -0.07485299557447433, 0.01642155647277832, 0.01680470071732998, -0.004928699694573879, 0.031531922519207, 0.020588012412190437, 0.012657728046178818, -0.01099911518394947, 0.024894505739212036, -0.03814509138464928, 0.04006645083427429, 0.0023567061871290207, 0.02021976001560688, -0.00037232457543723285, -0.0035848389379680157, -0.025593681260943413, 0.07769427448511124, 0.010416367091238499, -0.009343428537249565, 0.001519909012131393, 0.014152854681015015, 0.005859474651515484, 0.041951436549425125, -0.02486163191497326, 0.006249021738767624, -0.04099597781896591, -0.042880479246377945, 0.0031444013584405184, 0.03279301896691322, 0.014092100784182549, -0.03336005657911301, -0.022141052410006523, 0.019703133031725883, 0.034319598227739334, 0.01282664854079485, -0.0061515821143984795, 0.016257738694548607, 0.02114616334438324, -0.0054016984067857265, 0.04434271156787872, -0.025103092193603516, -0.020238010212779045, 0.03646346181631088, 0.06214679777622223, -0.002546721836552024, 0.08159345388412476, 0.005867499392479658, 0.0677206739783287, 0.01102986466139555, -0.03112589381635189, -0.10409928858280182, -0.06232714653015137, -0.056702159345149994, -0.07168716192245483, -0.015607811510562897, 0.014918085187673569, -0.04290860891342163, -0.028409937396645546, 0.039307039231061935, -0.048734188079833984, 0.01941339671611786, -0.014538159593939781, 0.019997823983430862, 0.02683885395526886, -0.033776264637708664, -0.008872922509908676, 0.027833353728055954, 0.013898899778723717, -0.02096913568675518, 0.014536998234689236, 0.009611965157091618, -0.04052862897515297, -0.021546807140111923, 0.004809737205505371, -0.021700328215956688, 0.060084953904151917, -0.08443335443735123, -0.03322087600827217, -0.005339539144188166, -0.022091243416070938, -0.05440209060907364, -0.04776287451386452, 0.006673123221844435, -0.026149867102503777, 0.03779396787285805, 0.05327926576137543, 0.007325286976993084, 0.00910837110131979, 0.01338669378310442, 0.015211631543934345, 0.014675851911306381, -0.016006894409656525, 0.041711483150720596, 0.026980817317962646, 0.015586095862090588, 0.07334370166063309, -0.0007033891743049026, 0.0685398131608963, 0.013468032702803612, -0.04933806508779526, -0.00792625267058611, 0.07697750627994537, 0.027821965515613556, 0.04507697373628616, 0.07198503613471985, -0.0373496450483799, 0.05211997032165527, -0.03453494608402252, -0.007412217557430267, -0.04950697720050812, -0.0008313277503475547, 0.016243694350123405, 0.05239364877343178, -0.10644447058439255, 0.027573956176638603, -0.000160412018885836, -0.002936688717454672, -0.05322573706507683, 0.027767041698098183, -0.006692860275506973, -0.015067972242832184, -0.12645438313484192, -0.00966522004455328, 0.014027883298695087, 0.014625994488596916, -0.02673151344060898, -0.025966497138142586, -0.019016962498426437, 0.03170313686132431, 0.004842107184231281, 0.02464994601905346, 0.026614297181367874, -0.02116509899497032, -0.004064914304763079, 0.05188673734664917, 0.015559596940875053, -0.014058935455977917, -0.020374326035380363, 0.09454808384180069, 0.05666588619351387, -0.033415086567401886, -0.002996435621753335, -0.043655697256326675, 0.05243578180670738, -0.02435859479010105, -0.06545890122652054, 0.034278515726327896, 0.05894005298614502, -0.005837929900735617, 0.042460471391677856, 0.05245386064052582, -0.05039481073617935, -0.026049772277474403, 0.010029153898358345, -0.03946617990732193, -0.001960642170161009, -0.0640999972820282, -0.0011169480858370662, -0.014366578310728073, -0.029056059196591377, 0.0030087444465607405, 0.016848670318722725, 0.031845107674598694, 0.007298148237168789, 0.05356169119477272, 0.0015571105759590864, -0.011432519182562828, 0.011038431897759438, 0.05233359709382057, 0.03274300694465637, 0.018988613039255142, -0.012163941748440266, 0.03786667436361313, 0.04363241046667099, 0.0046903220936656, -0.006888167466968298, -0.0357431024312973, 0.010223479941487312, -0.009202767163515091, 0.000073941373557318, -0.04711683467030525, 0.025905178859829903, -0.01823446713387966, 0.021124720573425293, -0.04940419644117355, -0.02596179023385048, 0.0032529036980122328, 0.039157770574092865, 0.015706254169344902, 0.00361781963147223, 0.028964633122086525, 0.04430222138762474, -0.0007425518706440926, -0.02886873483657837, -0.012178660370409489, 0.011972873471677303, -0.0043589151464402676, -0.01086683664470911, -0.03451908379793167, 0.005419575609266758, -0.02557441033422947, 0.00037660833913832903, 0.03656155988574028, -0.061236534267663956, -0.004154515452682972, -0.022261248901486397, 0.038211021572351456, -0.0630747526884079, -0.043116189539432526, 0.0010983094107359648, -0.007700025569647551, 0.049382101744413376, -0.039765842258930206, -0.02532018907368183, -0.03652575984597206, 0.053903140127658844, -0.04422755911946297, 0.003486279398202896, -0.03413469344377518, -0.0693165585398674, -0.022612974047660828, 0.05553611367940903, -0.03257479518651962, -0.024180671200156212, -0.01866353489458561, 0.0048257457092404366, 0.049171414226293564, -0.002751557156443596, -0.05072851851582527, 0.049649957567453384, 0.027147263288497925, 0.054591912776231766, 0.018784955143928528, -0.001441875472664833, -0.01604684628546238, -0.014144638553261757, 0.015027408488094807, -0.00857700314372778, -0.0620226114988327, -0.021994687616825104, -0.017961304634809494 ]
<p>This is just a question about terminology that is used in the beginning of a chapter about phonons.</p> <p>In a simple cubic crystal, we can consider elastic oscillations in f.i. the [100] direction. In this direction there is one longitudinal and two transversal oscillation modes. Now my textbook tells that these two transversal oscillation modes can be degenerate. I wonder in which sense the word "degenerate" is used here and I hope that someone can clarify this.</p>
g4071
[ 0.03403538092970848, 0.04293140769004822, 0.007081667426973581, -0.036499302834272385, 0.0816919133067131, -0.01517188735306263, 0.03783441334962845, -0.004592117853462696, -0.0037802469450980425, -0.019501110538840294, -0.05171387270092964, -0.018863489851355553, -0.022935636341571808, -0.03384309262037277, 0.00938527099788189, -0.024659961462020874, 0.02772798016667366, -0.00012743887782562524, 0.00861824955791235, 0.021252159029245377, -0.034504059702157974, -0.010746617801487446, -0.04042156785726547, -0.046674586832523346, 0.03996989130973816, 0.05069560185074806, -0.03615337237715721, -0.07024560123682022, -0.034729670733213425, -0.01896461471915245, -0.014544020406901836, -0.0006970178219489753, 0.06755770742893219, -0.008206806145608425, 0.010766763240098953, 0.002240016357973218, 0.03574221953749657, -0.020048514008522034, 0.05600922182202339, 0.0012885978212580085, -0.015335260890424252, -0.040857791900634766, 0.008208545856177807, -0.06458467245101929, -0.015090408734977245, -0.02911020629107952, -0.06250988692045212, -0.03899677097797394, -0.05677834525704384, -0.01204126700758934, 0.0661030113697052, 0.0028197462670505047, 0.11686717718839645, -0.04581214487552643, 0.0036215700674802065, 0.005503145512193441, -0.03718121349811554, -0.01794629544019699, 0.10793445259332657, -0.014800479635596275, -0.0077627599239349365, -0.00881444476544857, 0.07304411381483078, 0.03377871215343475, 0.018931560218334198, -0.015658145770430565, -0.05353144183754921, 0.009397846646606922, 0.026945576071739197, -0.03536754101514816, 0.05250943452119827, -0.05610530450940132, -0.01408759318292141, 0.03421345725655556, -0.02797071821987629, 0.0056441957131028175, -0.013925808481872082, -0.04834577441215515, 0.009829478338360786, -0.039286985993385315, 0.008048287592828274, -0.012743807397782803, 0.02572914958000183, -0.03354325518012047, 0.08829260617494583, 0.04760472849011421, -0.005133782979100943, 0.037082187831401825, -0.030885109677910805, 0.005354433320462704, -0.043424032628536224, -0.0240778885781765, -0.0007505141547881067, -0.005013023503124714, -0.04024326428771019, -0.005756585858762264, -0.013399588875472546, 0.06653290241956711, -0.01686735451221466, 0.04676194116473198, -0.017576031386852264, -0.029569709673523903, 0.017949717119336128, 0.0073715257458388805, -0.014038468711078167, -0.02641894668340683, -0.02579353004693985, -0.053139906376600266, -0.03556036204099655, 0.0100029855966568, -0.03115103393793106, 0.045623164623975754, -0.00513428682461381, 0.031567659229040146, -0.012684044428169727, -0.02510981634259224, 0.055929023772478104, 0.07448040693998337, 0.007154571358114481, 0.03304433450102806, 0.026668205857276917, 0.0022168613504618406, -0.005041365511715412, 0.0660872608423233, 0.009230443276464939, 0.03943167254328728, -0.030478186905384064, -0.04851992055773735, 0.03228183090686798, 0.011692049913108349, -0.03825937956571579, 0.0569281242787838, 0.018381226807832718, -0.05611206963658333, 0.01789110153913498, 0.07219954580068588, 0.04832753911614418, 0.049922212958335876, 0.00027776273782365024, -0.0035591525956988335, 0.0019510113634169102, 0.0067751784808933735, 0.04443987458944321, -0.04226594418287277, -0.036735907196998596, -0.0003772287745960057, 0.02345985919237137, -0.032368868589401245, 0.024605944752693176, 0.023169677704572678, -0.05623606964945793, 0.013398369774222374, 0.052213557064533234, -0.031497564166784286, -0.06289496272802353, -0.0069181364960968494, -0.003597948234528303, -0.014160238206386566, 0.007196312770247459, 0.018154649063944817, 0.00812117662280798, 0.004795258864760399, -0.05789611116051674, -0.0033093413803726435, -0.038023680448532104, -0.008242940530180931, -0.02794174663722515, -0.007614722475409508, -0.0018036634428426623, 0.02735963836312294, -0.028824925422668457, -0.03452659398317337, 0.003933407366275787, 0.06841162592172623, 0.04800449684262276, 0.0501546636223793, 0.0433541014790535, -0.018099522218108177, 0.028558170422911644, 0.0009714100160636008, -0.039407093077898026, 0.007922603748738766, -0.03725847601890564, -0.02073211409151554, -0.009128856472671032, 0.03952006623148918, -0.0005500354454852641, 0.01082906685769558, -0.03954106941819191, 0.043770864605903625, 0.017106469720602036, -0.010776826180517673, -0.027197645977139473, 0.03492588549852371, -0.011824253015220165, -0.05037683621048927, 0.007650934625416994, 0.013822141103446484, -0.062388233840465546, 0.03691496700048447, 0.025000451132655144, -0.014529605396091938, 0.06223765388131142, 0.006214335560798645, 0.04139762371778488, 0.03992465138435364, -0.02351425215601921, -0.011060383170843124, 0.009284917265176773, -0.0035938811488449574, -0.017574289813637733, 0.04394913837313652, -0.013761494308710098, 0.030202258378267288, -0.012483492493629456, 0.015072674490511417, 0.048502396792173386, -0.015705356374382973, -0.024477941915392876, 0.0005054727080278099, -0.03463668003678322, 0.03704289719462395, 0.023219510912895203, 0.006932513788342476, -0.013016103766858578, -0.03806570544838905, -0.013269368559122086, 0.002300516702234745, -0.007431021425873041, -0.007996289059519768, -0.0385824590921402, -0.03379332274198532, 0.0010217740200459957, -0.06518962979316711, -0.01211601309478283, -0.030178315937519073, -0.05894291400909424, 0.047903191298246384, -0.04903237521648407, -0.053018029779195786, 0.04034211114048958, -0.04451184719800949, -0.027512691915035248, -0.04554269090294838, -0.011564734391868114, -0.04345746338367462, -0.0091722896322608, 0.0020486365538090467, 0.08413243293762207, 0.008507826365530491, 0.057311028242111206, -0.02557246945798397, -0.06570105254650116, 0.030655784532427788, -0.00966687686741352, 0.017602814361453056, -0.03070053830742836, 0.05014971271157265, -0.030323157086968422, 0.018066758289933205, 0.012065498158335686, -0.03655281290411949, 0.007453949190676212, -0.033617325127124786, -0.03967466205358505, -0.02449042908847332, 0.017898807302117348, 0.016045672819018364, -0.06749817728996277, -0.03287757188081741, 0.0011265883222222328, 0.09979572147130966, 0.02718701958656311, 0.06726714968681335, -0.04168412461876869, -0.034575656056404114, 0.01966223679482937, -0.03622398525476456, -0.043591562658548355, 0.03399911895394325, -0.003766815410926938, -0.004250911995768547, 0.0610046423971653, -0.0008368201088160276, 0.042249228805303574, -0.0035722230095416307, -0.021005786955356598, 0.008695721626281738, 0.05839285999536514, 0.03671983629465103, -0.03891986981034279, -0.012411569245159626, 0.009717592038214207, -0.0062799714505672455, -0.002862731460481882, 0.009815916419029236, 0.01684259995818138, -0.031113000586628914, -0.016468720510601997, 0.09663951396942139, -0.029539309442043304, 0.01631605066359043, 0.00218707462772727, 0.03862600028514862, 0.014213213697075844, 0.006876949220895767, 0.014020952396094799, 0.01147090271115303, 0.035363588482141495, 0.013194160535931587, 0.03381294012069702, 0.0373535118997097, 0.0722670778632164, 0.08680680394172668, -0.03082970343530178, 0.07450328022241592, -0.027793042361736298, -0.0324823260307312, 0.005205234047025442, 0.01378869079053402, -0.07622330635786057, 0.006168785970658064, 0.02489437907934189, 0.02677156776189804, -0.03250563517212868, 0.034491997212171555, -0.0052969022653996944, 0.05748656019568443, -0.10948552936315536, -0.005406226497143507, -0.026216860860586166, -0.04898684844374657, -0.06855188310146332, -0.053608909249305725, 0.017409728839993477, -0.015858959406614304, -0.043416980654001236, 0.025380166247487068, 0.059873178601264954, 0.046809323132038116, 0.017338542267680168, 0.012218907475471497, -0.009442965500056744, -0.011209877207875252, 0.012288450263440609, 0.008022647351026535, -0.09049557894468307, 0.016724884510040283, -0.05109375715255737, 0.0220489501953125, -0.026731552556157112, 0.008007573895156384, 0.008888956159353256, 0.012542643584311008, -0.045875925570726395, -0.013089781627058983, -0.016004815697669983, 0.05506312474608421, -0.04948533698916435, -0.00835160631686449, -0.000020784675143659115, -0.046243440359830856, 0.01641147769987583, 0.03816743567585945, -0.012544970028102398, 0.014385960064828396, -0.03143502026796341, 0.03380219638347626, -0.008247722871601582, 0.00142506358679384, -0.025601178407669067, -0.05323290824890137, -0.03453397750854492, 0.00767962820827961, 0.021085241809487343, -0.020595578476786613, 0.01867150329053402, 0.0029485453851521015, -0.0515797957777977, 0.06835629045963287, -0.012846218422055244, 0.011260047554969788, 0.08472718298435211, -0.005359926726669073, -0.014046799391508102, -0.0009056769195012748, 0.012896223925054073, -0.017264509573578835, -0.044248275458812714, 0.019142547622323036, -0.010123766958713531, 0.02546023204922676, -0.014339359477162361, 0.02401040308177471, -0.010916804894804955, -0.06228145956993103, 0.02067524380981922, 0.01306843664497137, 0.028204087167978287, 0.057695917785167694, 0.02600274793803692, -0.017434783279895782, -0.00738332187756896, -0.05855197459459305, 0.0035265726037323475, 0.06898049265146255, 0.016467837616801262, -0.021990392357110977, -0.03230908885598183, -0.016565311700105667, -0.0014105279697105289, -0.032834243029356, 0.030301248654723167, -0.019512001425027847, 0.045009274035692215, 0.03112717717885971, 0.03614858165383339, 0.015931032598018646, 0.05412595346570015, 0.0030553448013961315, 0.08332156389951706, 0.07311369478702545, -0.029763050377368927, 0.03545169532299042, 0.011166797950863838, 0.045210808515548706, 0.03408481180667877, -0.057380177080631256, -0.023386210203170776, -0.01228439062833786, -0.008987455628812313, -0.027779364958405495, 0.022665534168481827, 0.022793786600232124, -0.0037999956402927637, -0.002447662642225623, -0.0490255206823349, 0.035402487963438034, 0.0027556440327316523, 0.022959385067224503, 0.07564152777194977, -0.009197991341352463, -0.00552156288176775, -0.002995376940816641, 0.01629013568162918, -0.01141791045665741, 0.033157989382743835, -0.06624063849449158, 0.021482618525624275, -0.07819901406764984, 0.0058859470300376415, 0.08835625648498535, -0.05211474001407623, -0.02969212830066681, 0.030756648629903793, -0.058171115815639496, 0.010457675904035568, 0.013597949407994747, -0.020651089027523994, 0.006159401964396238, -0.006028907373547554, -0.023053182289004326, 0.0413367860019207, 0.013555796816945076, -0.015746532008051872, -0.002640968421474099, -0.005780715961009264, -0.034716833382844925, -0.04749308153986931, -0.023632356896996498, 0.03181876614689827, -0.030621197074651718, 0.009713437408208847, 0.08111808449029922, 0.023869836702942848, -0.035815272480249405, -0.022129012271761894, -0.021971063688397408, -0.025219153612852097, -0.04648236185312271, -0.011267310008406639, -0.03549908474087715, 0.039100080728530884, -0.016193337738513947, -0.05399477481842041, -0.011315317824482918, 0.004449962638318539, -0.03363003954291344, -0.03364000469446182, 0.01480507105588913, 0.028874726966023445, -0.03139345347881317, -0.02908334694802761, 0.037650734186172485, -0.0038826693780720234, -0.03918015584349632, 0.038866076618433, -0.010549282655119896, -0.021412014961242676, 0.0035945046693086624, -0.04684304818511009, 0.03281830623745918, 0.016590086743235588, -0.00998278334736824, -0.008314867503941059, 0.0056426627561450005, 0.07073752582073212, -0.039398882538080215, -0.04834706708788872, 0.005074753891676664, 0.003922019153833389, 0.004947416950017214, 0.02490842528641224, 0.09770078957080841, 0.004879727028310299, -0.03294053301215172, -0.04126281291246414, -0.030401460826396942, -0.058044347912073135, -0.027448847889900208, -0.0018990641692653298, 0.010812430642545223, -0.04430761560797691, -0.05816998705267906, -0.0018352665938436985, -0.022810935974121094, -0.0909632071852684, 0.01465105265378952, 0.009837123565375805, -0.026302209123969078, 0.019596334546804428, -0.01747129298746586, 0.0715823546051979, 0.06819453835487366, 0.020151525735855103, 0.015436163172125816, -0.0006359259714372456, -0.037074215710163116, -0.0615786649286747, 0.08306138217449188, -0.007497033104300499, -0.0345832034945488, 0.005669343750923872, 0.054523766040802, 0.01788843609392643, 0.028360718861222267, 0.013960771262645721, 0.03973136469721794, -0.044424980878829956, 0.0404728539288044, -0.0694703757762909, -0.020338742062449455, 0.030569130554795265, -0.01487382035702467, 0.00036097876727581024, 0.045079879462718964, -0.005319835152477026, -0.005677102133631706, -0.0028305009473115206, -0.02771974541246891, 0.03620992228388786, 0.04706414416432381, 0.028242945671081543, 0.0009604219812899828, 0.0045116739347577095, -0.01888773962855339, 0.0123751200735569, -0.009182985872030258, 0.05425739288330078, 0.009271004237234592, -0.029567541554570198, 0.0006205136305652559, 0.01331364270299673, -0.006771255750209093, 0.004710318520665169, 0.023996641859412193, -0.04893898218870163, -0.08738048374652863, 0.015458093956112862, 0.06816547363996506, -0.024903226643800735, 0.03616347536444664, -0.020557507872581482, 0.04261530190706253, -0.005283739883452654, 0.021858496591448784, 0.03667570278048515, -0.026781590655446053, -0.003231959417462349, -0.01456983108073473, 0.025219736620783806, -0.020809326320886612, -0.08875107765197754, -0.012334033846855164, 0.024666570127010345, 0.018876293674111366, -0.024736929684877396, 0.006325730588287115, -0.0010358820436522365, 0.032964449375867844, 0.06079806014895439, 0.04772159457206726, 0.048256270587444305, -0.0004836955340579152, 0.023653972893953323, 0.04308958724141121, 0.027503684163093567, 0.0723913162946701, -0.05531124398112297, 0.007487128023058176, -0.03456658497452736, -0.018043577671051025, 0.028429275378584862, -0.05185156315565109, 0.039939891546964645, -0.07019193470478058, -0.004312597215175629, -0.03265703469514847, 0.026871714740991592, -0.011264894157648087, 0.02119174599647522, -0.05106901377439499, 0.03672339394688606, -0.009782818146049976, -0.017931289970874786, 0.008725551888346672, -0.05557360500097275, 0.03137930482625961, 0.06308859586715698, -0.037689272314310074, 0.008959593251347542, -0.020040299743413925, -0.04088182374835014, -0.02792195789515972, -0.015756433829665184, 0.04785797372460365, -0.04996279627084732, -0.019985701888799667, 0.04364851862192154, -0.030004333704710007, -0.03509046137332916, 0.08760170638561249, 0.0837019681930542, 0.015197079628705978, 0.0075674219988286495, 0.06652840226888657, 0.023410744965076447, -0.08296792209148407, -0.02367645502090454, -0.019541794434189796, -0.01939057745039463, 0.0036976595874875784, -0.03227659687399864, 0.09347112476825714, -0.04851677268743515, 0.0508991964161396, 0.0767369419336319, 0.0010242518037557602, 0.016033481806516647, -0.022354379296302795, -0.0721520185470581, -0.020299766212701797, 0.01900327019393444, -0.028609631583094597, -0.005683246534317732, -0.017939209938049316, -0.008684080094099045, -0.03116682544350624, -0.06814185529947281, -0.0001300201256526634, 0.029439814388751984, -0.0250539630651474, 0.029211582615971565, -0.02184990607202053, -0.009952065534889698, 0.03879662975668907, -0.04748959839344025, 0.020449621602892876, 0.018952952697873116, -0.025485994294285774, 0.033163540065288544, -0.02067737840116024, 0.00756707601249218, -0.05876263976097107, -0.012926512397825718, 0.016818037256598473, 0.020281383767724037, -0.020730992779135704, 0.017892412841320038, -0.017203155905008316, -0.004720927681773901, 0.00784082617610693, 0.018288739025592804, -0.030796034261584282, -0.034325070679187775, 0.004877768456935883, -0.039571721106767654, 0.03506430611014366, -0.036570657044649124, 0.0009650694555602968, 0.0411120168864727, 0.004130372311919928, -0.03704148158431053, 0.06621011346578598, 0.012920569628477097, -0.02932799980044365, 0.04026155546307564, -0.017436476424336433, -0.017225254327058792, 0.06733977049589157, -0.010148059576749802, 0.036271944642066956, 0.05146932601928711, -0.02928893268108368, 0.01422237791121006, 0.019368913024663925, -0.045637764036655426, 0.005737534258514643, -0.02012375183403492, 0.01782030239701271, -0.002848763018846512, 0.006990028545260429, -0.009273923933506012, -0.06758809089660645, -0.021186761558055878, 0.028717096894979477, 0.015559227205812931, -0.021900437772274017, -0.014178144745528698, 0.012415789999067783, 0.018669238314032555, 0.008085057139396667, 0.04691898450255394, 0.044669028371572495, -0.04233550280332565, 0.027111923322081566, 0.028827298432588577, -0.00404510460793972, -0.05893382057547569, 0.0527641586959362, -0.003133554244413972, 0.03189107030630112, -0.04112030938267708, 0.0031592820305377245, -0.006094489246606827, 0.016501475125551224, -0.06915739178657532, 0.017762726172804832, 0.028341008350253105, -0.07000559568405151, -0.02194480039179325, -0.02022683247923851, 0.060389526188373566, -0.00543605163693428, 0.007265588268637657, -0.05537706986069679, -0.01713130623102188, 0.036250725388526917, 0.0005630976520478725, -0.04373916611075401, -0.030969372019171715, 0.06625846773386002, -0.014378510415554047, -0.02390887774527073, -0.01389799453318119, 0.030035441741347313, -0.049446988850831985, 0.04432003200054169 ]
<p>I'm currently a third year undergrad writing about Minimal Surfaces. In particular, trapped surfaces and black holes.</p> <p>What does the <a href="http://www.google.com/search?as_q=Positive+Mass+Theorem" rel="nofollow">Positive Mass Theorem</a> have to do with this? And does the theorem directly predict the existence of black holes?</p>
g256
[ 0.02859969064593315, 0.03139307349920273, 0.004314441233873367, -0.0015595440054312348, -0.0035736968275159597, 0.04531889408826828, 0.04482315480709076, -0.006833686027675867, -0.025302696973085403, -0.026774441823363304, 0.010497921146452427, -0.02401375025510788, 0.04290381073951721, -0.005278166849166155, -0.08411692827939987, 0.04315705969929695, 0.03177350014448166, 0.024044504389166832, 0.00823119468986988, -0.010694064199924469, 0.017368800938129425, -0.033275753259658813, 0.011365807615220547, -0.023860512301325798, -0.038101863116025925, 0.027769703418016434, 0.04014864191412926, 0.02063431590795517, -0.006310982163995504, -0.025799956172704697, 0.03344732150435448, 0.011409468948841095, 0.05161667242646217, -0.006409633904695511, -0.031943660229444504, -0.016035230830311775, 0.019834646955132484, 0.04912305623292923, -0.034947291016578674, -0.019320743158459663, 0.08256451040506363, -0.04956065118312836, -0.0004921990912407637, 0.008020448498427868, -0.015756679698824883, -0.021726815029978752, 0.0017050104215741158, -0.025476276874542236, 0.026856590062379837, 0.0031164928805083036, 0.05193021148443222, 0.02230844832956791, 0.05780009552836418, -0.010843263939023018, -0.03705422580242157, 0.010882996954023838, 0.04596501588821411, -0.027400510385632515, 0.0004670682246796787, -0.0029895652551203966, -0.04069848731160164, 0.014912453480064869, -0.011387460865080357, 0.014679758809506893, 0.06889772415161133, 0.009930841624736786, -0.04989016428589821, -0.03138430416584015, -0.015853388234972954, 0.05913454294204712, -0.006589336786419153, 0.04487437382340431, 0.02124957926571369, 0.018884481862187386, -0.020918285474181175, 0.081543929874897, -0.056484002619981766, -0.013935171067714691, -0.0368659608066082, -0.032181430608034134, -0.019143210723996162, 0.0055769579485058784, 0.01917743869125843, -0.020006394013762474, 0.05608263239264488, -0.0875857025384903, -0.021711835637688637, -0.02757629007101059, -0.008038214407861233, -0.021798457950353622, 0.035081520676612854, 0.008501064963638783, 0.04183386266231537, 0.002886857371777296, 0.00909489393234253, 0.03693278506398201, 0.06597694754600525, 0.0333755761384964, -0.06352975219488144, -0.004118076525628567, -0.05761326476931572, 0.032164089381694794, 0.002173059154301882, 0.0030937576666474342, 0.06409628689289093, 0.06657100468873978, -0.020623724907636642, -0.0006974120624363422, -0.013788346201181412, 0.056416332721710205, 0.009847046807408333, -0.019791623577475548, -0.0659223347902298, -0.006868630647659302, -0.06226551532745361, -0.014354697428643703, 0.060582809150218964, -0.017046313732862473, -0.004057248588651419, 0.0374259278178215, 0.005202847998589277, 0.031570401042699814, 0.016652259975671768, 0.019453121349215508, 0.020277220755815506, -0.02728663757443428, -0.05340876802802086, -0.018193773925304413, 0.05955669656395912, 0.03440147638320923, 0.027944954112172127, 0.007847282104194164, -0.05768388509750366, 0.04848772659897804, -0.04472958669066429, 0.0009776600636541843, -0.0026344952639192343, -0.0032824312802404165, 0.015674294903874397, 0.012264631688594818, -0.026611793786287308, -0.00011449532757978886, -0.04437984898686409, 0.028837451711297035, 0.05114288255572319, 0.005623635370284319, -0.031066814437508583, 0.00999006349593401, 0.005165136884897947, 0.04293779656291008, -0.0329262800514698, 0.1258149892091751, -0.04528993368148804, -0.009109706617891788, 0.0051752254366874695, -0.0012364163994789124, -0.02087482437491417, -0.0021479318384081125, -0.0015435582026839256, -0.05749425292015076, 0.10262030363082886, 0.02915048599243164, 0.021091802045702934, 0.013090264983475208, -0.02281840331852436, -0.03185466304421425, -0.018348416313529015, -0.04489654302597046, -0.030492357909679413, 0.010511654429137707, 0.003068148158490658, 0.03621687740087509, 0.02761296182870865, 0.04575503244996071, 0.003915563225746155, 0.0028945375233888626, -0.06379571557044983, 0.004039749503135681, 0.05226843059062958, -0.03433389961719513, 0.008793186396360397, -0.07135425508022308, 0.044097770005464554, 0.015170830301940441, 0.029854971915483475, 0.0021166056394577026, 0.00942559540271759, 0.02093544974923134, -0.029137030243873596, 0.051482655107975006, -0.03279139846563339, -0.003446039743721485, -0.018955789506435394, 0.05353875830769539, 0.08730264753103256, -0.0028377282433211803, 0.03562892600893974, -0.010579252615571022, -0.0009201103821396828, 0.02318599633872509, 0.01125197485089302, 0.0030531873926520348, -0.031381405889987946, -0.0533694252371788, -0.010553264059126377, -0.018161285668611526, -0.0010592853650450706, 0.0184488445520401, 0.023897835984826088, 0.03432855010032654, -0.032680850476026535, -0.0336620956659317, 0.0579398013651371, 0.013906127773225307, -0.0222366563975811, 0.04482094943523407, -0.05654270201921463, 0.04263244569301605, 0.02013271488249302, -0.05845802649855614, -0.02868429198861122, -0.01520236674696207, -0.03587590903043747, 0.03235321864485741, -0.003083343617618084, 0.03775970637798309, 0.0027052005752921104, -0.03726910054683685, -0.027396054938435555, 0.023524006828665733, -0.06791602820158005, -0.012335414066910744, 0.0013202311238273978, 0.0370401069521904, 0.041358061134815216, 0.07295997440814972, 0.001747413189150393, -0.019312120974063873, 0.018110334873199463, 0.04921289533376694, 0.023704303428530693, -0.04044622182846069, -0.10148235410451889, -0.024247899651527405, 0.013553092256188393, -0.03098696656525135, -0.012172804214060307, -0.006078785751014948, -0.009183292277157307, 0.05950891599059105, 0.015503830276429653, -0.05163174122571945, 0.027779312804341316, -0.029160480946302414, 0.019525201991200447, -0.0035645237658172846, -0.007781136315315962, 0.024280738085508347, -0.047447361052036285, -0.007407120428979397, 0.03338503837585449, -0.045609988272190094, -0.017123207449913025, -0.020120512694120407, -0.1190074160695076, -0.04595642536878586, -0.0757737085223198, -0.03514396399259567, -0.005520074162632227, 0.04106394946575165, -0.0014571950305253267, 0.03845198452472687, 0.046768154948949814, 0.03361682593822479, -0.010802928358316422, 0.013806569389998913, -0.009437702596187592, 0.04656807705760002, 0.014691953547298908, -0.006656621117144823, 0.011391700245440006, -0.014045992866158485, -0.08467140048742294, -0.03462201729416847, -0.04524829611182213, -0.01728527992963791, -0.015787897631525993, 0.003195157740265131, -0.0436413437128067, -0.0020106968004256487, -0.00921612698584795, -0.020591039210557938, 0.09146689623594284, 0.04782692715525627, -0.01579989120364189, 0.055445149540901184, 0.004467015154659748, -0.002995128743350506, -0.03136732801795006, 0.03127998486161232, -0.00029380660271272063, -0.004544404800981283, 0.012178288772702217, -0.04863833263516426, -0.02639431692659855, 0.01796983927488327, 0.00827227532863617, -0.06519974023103714, -0.02963242679834366, -0.07274539023637772, -0.012955457903444767, 0.02896047942340374, 0.030440358445048332, 0.022694328799843788, -0.00823712907731533, 0.07923781126737595, -0.0005443086847662926, 0.026426395401358604, -0.06581565737724304, -0.018121175467967987, -0.051412150263786316, 0.018155837431550026, 0.02700106054544449, -0.0393482968211174, 0.0714913010597229, 0.00273980968631804, 0.01681150309741497, -0.053483519703149796, -0.022296413779258728, 0.0315798819065094, 0.05139439180493355, 0.027873599901795387, 0.003310301573947072, -0.011401322670280933, 0.005253342445939779, -0.09110496193170547, -0.0040168724954128265, 0.006710111629217863, 0.045601073652505875, 0.02431909553706646, 0.023495366796851158, -0.03425385057926178, -0.03531675785779953, 0.020726555958390236, -0.00841766782104969, 0.005965909454971552, -0.028358153998851776, -0.02694186195731163, 0.0509510412812233, 0.02809061110019684, 0.007036028895527124, -0.026098504662513733, 0.028700169175863266, 0.030181968584656715, -0.0012085192138329148, 0.03430769219994545, 0.02775978483259678, -0.015165344811975956, 0.01943056844174862, 0.022135725244879723, -0.010198710486292839, 0.0008316246676258743, -0.012636120431125164, -0.012057849206030369, -0.0014745596563443542, 0.007515527307987213, 0.011242639273405075, -0.009414429776370525, -0.03873000293970108, -0.02321254275739193, -0.003588540479540825, 0.00840716902166605, 0.01670234091579914, 0.02113259583711624, 0.04125124216079712, -0.07229861617088318, -0.01644395850598812, 0.02253059856593609, 0.026637233793735504, -0.000523851893376559, 0.039681728929281235, -0.018162736669182777, 0.009293404407799244, -0.012429787777364254, -0.03683715686202049, 0.0007753573008812964, -0.08460874855518341, -0.02765430510044098, 0.015547135844826698, -0.08345156162977219, -0.06715872883796692, 0.0022993821185082197, -0.030111903324723244, -0.027242841199040413, 0.03822045773267746, -0.004271633457392454, 0.0045963772572577, -0.0020398572087287903, 0.03403117507696152, -0.005792753770947456, 0.06727112084627151, 0.06354081630706787, -0.0644841268658638, -0.003996643237769604, 0.034108810126781464, 0.025665011256933212, 0.009341890923678875, 0.045843854546546936, 0.03153664991259575, -0.018766703084111214, 0.04603539779782295, 0.0034565574023872614, -0.02476213127374649, -0.04292730987071991, 0.07014389336109161, 0.03431518375873566, -0.049718402326107025, -0.04892909899353981, -0.005649377591907978, 0.02631528116762638, 0.007673489395529032, 0.021105200052261353, -0.0015129497041925788, -0.026111703366041183, -0.007856018841266632, 0.05110172554850578, 0.020206378772854805, -0.013106387108564377, -0.008972348645329475, -0.000044064880057703704, 0.053340740501880646, -0.017736440524458885, 0.0038905448745936155, 0.021541284397244453, -0.06615263223648071, 0.025208730250597, -0.007685328833758831, 0.04587748274207115, 0.01434954535216093, -0.007448611315339804, 0.061684560030698776, 0.0172425527125597, -0.023771019652485847, -0.036260902881622314, -0.009437702596187592, 0.03904259204864502, 0.0010408019879832864, 0.006195560097694397, -0.04077333211898804, -0.053359076380729675, -0.02750401198863983, -0.02570507489144802, 0.017798960208892822, -0.04605942592024803, -0.01285515632480383, 0.019221214577555656, -0.05998901277780533, 0.06817847490310669, 0.0039411382749676704, 0.033855143934488297, 0.02438315935432911, -0.01535603404045105, 0.08778760582208633, 0.061385996639728546, 0.059696316719055176, -0.032799966633319855, -0.0014274402055889368, -0.01656133122742176, -0.031516749411821365, -0.030175527557730675, -0.041014593094587326, 0.0935419499874115, 0.012108433060348034, 0.013386677019298077, -0.021740185096859932, 0.028803864493966103, -0.0059026326052844524, -0.06012604013085365, 0.022160977125167847, -0.019709307700395584, 0.024579064920544624, 0.020290648564696312, 0.0643574669957161, -0.032696738839149475, 0.03704167902469635, 0.0442601777613163, -0.0030384224373847246, 0.05468624457716942, -0.039990995079278946, 0.01926971599459648, -0.003724542446434498, 0.01414386834949255, 0.012921555899083614, 0.018978407606482506, -0.06670371443033218, -0.06349999457597733, -0.049726784229278564, -0.03400234505534172, -0.03318272903561592, -0.0011312636779621243, -0.050071656703948975, -0.046169213950634, 0.06826435774564743, 0.04720771685242653, 0.047604843974113464, 0.04112951457500458, 0.01962914876639843, -0.0009693242027424276, 0.07058565318584442, 0.028309594839811325, -0.025172341614961624, 0.02422652393579483, -0.014368771575391293, 0.007862722501158714, 0.038229167461395264, -0.04835003241896629, -0.019900130107998848, 0.02042423002421856, -0.02370612695813179, 0.07965362071990967, 0.058651212602853775, -0.0396040678024292, -0.026713015511631966, 0.039652079343795776, 0.051044587045907974, 0.013818948529660702, -0.04813597351312637, -0.004621441010385752, 0.05652959644794464, -0.005689594894647598, 0.011159173212945461, -0.04984606057405472, 0.05900556221604347, -0.007281198166310787, 0.04920274764299393, -0.030904486775398254, 0.03401152417063713, 0.04879528284072876, 0.06833454966545105, -0.02978023700416088, -0.03567570820450783, -0.018535159528255463, 0.010720411315560341, 0.009379920549690723, 0.027213484048843384, 0.01958416774868965, -0.011989802122116089, -0.004353599157184362, 0.056077275425195694, -0.05481119081377983, -0.038372453302145004, 0.004514187108725309, -0.001664500217884779, 0.019343771040439606, -0.024438010528683662, 0.03285538777709007, 0.007951532490551472, -0.029208524152636528, -0.06359754502773285, -0.07497710734605789, 0.006620584521442652, -0.006814927328377962, -0.0018531611422076821, 0.036752693355083466, 0.02409088797867298, -0.03425893187522888, -0.006460235454142094, 0.01955590955913067, 0.029649784788489342, -0.04269104823470116, -0.06423839181661606, 0.008201366290450096, 0.021435609087347984, 0.0507134273648262, -0.061685170978307724, 0.02697620540857315, -0.03382489085197449, -0.0003185572277288884, -0.04254782572388649, -0.01531230565160513, 0.021151497960090637, -0.005266120657324791, 0.0510062649846077, -0.07455112040042877, 0.013664805330336094, -0.010100443847477436, -0.03643842786550522, 0.05488330498337746, 0.03791190683841705, -0.023894714191555977, -0.0029314567800611258, 0.045705992728471756, 0.05016916245222092, -0.012459266930818558, -0.030405109748244286, -0.015928011387586594, -0.03195171803236008, -0.05833657458424568, -0.04102647304534912, -0.06033503636717796, -0.0055330293253064156, 0.007640407886356115, 0.017956629395484924, 0.0032145169097930193, -0.009091127663850784, 0.03344469144940376, 0.03601926192641258, -0.08039633929729462, -0.057025473564863205, 0.04403321072459221, -0.07275648415088654, 0.08289962261915207, -0.03022528439760208, -0.025783810764551163, -0.00504680909216404, -0.008031316101551056, -0.05736282840371132, 0.010537507012486458, -0.002782562281936407, -0.07872842997312546, -0.004011675249785185, 0.02675550803542137, -0.0018368299352005124, -0.03469747677445412, 0.031029773876070976, 0.009420507587492466, 0.017145831137895584, 0.017809992656111717, 0.06780746579170227, 0.04028366506099701, -0.019251933321356773, 0.0010826311772689223, -0.0009198749903589487, 0.021553676575422287, 0.006985911633819342, 0.018763801082968712, -0.010286038741469383, 0.011728513985872269, 0.08538951724767685, -0.01855553686618805, -0.06482724100351334, -0.028910724446177483, -0.018795307725667953, 0.029801536351442337, -0.03238265588879585, -0.0017027908470481634, 0.004415665287524462, 0.05333006754517555, -0.07095633447170258, -0.054518550634384155, 0.030758028849959373, -0.05048884078860283, -0.03823704645037651, 0.010094252415001392, -0.02509668469429016, -0.04518073424696922, -0.048860497772693634, 0.0006411115755327046, 0.012258617207407951, -0.06191454827785492, -0.05278259888291359, 0.005892228800803423, 0.0011624901089817286, -0.026494262740015984, -0.001905155135318637, 0.038088053464889526, 0.041436802595853806, 0.019274987280368805, 0.008941193111240864, -0.009735469706356525, -0.00824179220944643, -0.04304293543100357, -0.02760196290910244, -0.015155015513300896, -0.05468061938881874, -0.025658076629042625, 0.0027401314582675695, 0.014569621533155441, 0.011216593906283379, 0.0487985834479332, 0.00531468540430069, -0.008974378928542137, -0.004626814741641283, 0.0015917441342025995, -0.004271265584975481, 0.03278729319572449, -0.06020708009600639, 0.03707893192768097, -0.0182074885815382, 0.0430012084543705, 0.007848805747926235, -0.04183945059776306, 0.018734503537416458, -0.02538599818944931, 0.012247585691511631, -0.07266584038734436, -0.024554340168833733, 0.06614294648170471, -0.004443024750798941, 0.003562558675184846, -0.020887427031993866, -0.019915765151381493, -0.03272799029946327, -0.016924433410167694, 0.030777625739574432, 0.037527211010456085, 0.01974237896502018, 0.03386496752500534, -0.025522654876112938, -0.01551266573369503, 0.04978756234049797, 0.002186512341722846, -0.015295417048037052, 0.008263276889920235, 0.02348371036350727, -0.06893676519393921, -0.03317192196846008, 0.01580977998673916, -0.01983659900724888, -0.03855067119002342, 0.0687020942568779, 0.025260645896196365, -0.030327653512358665, -0.0727652832865715, -0.04338505491614342, 0.011835047975182533, 0.019492628052830696, 0.033482152968645096, -0.05442342907190323, 0.002000716282054782, -0.027150874957442284, -0.007098751608282328, -0.015845241025090218, -0.005111531354486942, -0.037332236766815186, 0.024063287302851677, -0.004818195942789316, -0.02529102750122547, 0.005768743343651295, 0.01013838779181242, -0.0023743549827486277, -0.09419573843479156, 0.06110242381691933, -0.07871238142251968, 0.0033523538149893284, -0.018259787932038307, 0.004718570504337549, 0.00213776808232069, -0.015958251431584358, -0.005109141580760479, 0.030574839562177658, 0.003064667107537389, 0.01952996850013733, 0.00767620699480176, 0.005829708185046911, -0.08509376645088196, 0.023835236206650734, -0.0002800239308271557, 0.022130616009235382, 0.02865719236433506, -0.005353936459869146, 0.008034639060497284, -0.0030596796423196793, 0.022830914705991745, -0.05384925380349159, -0.03578903526067734, 0.06197204813361168, -0.05397705361247063 ]
<p>I have a throlabs half- and quarter-wave plate with rotation plate. There shown the angle scales and a line denotes the fast axis. But what does the angle mean? I do some research and someone said the angle reading tells the angle away from the transmission direction and other said that's the angle away from the fast axis. So here is the transmission direction same as the fast axis? </p> <p>If I know the incoming light is linear polarized but don't know the orientation. Is that possible to tell the orientation by using the half-wave plate?</p> <p>Also, I am studying the same optics element. When I read the material of the polarized beam splitter, I know that the incident beam will be split by the splitter with the two perpendicular outgoing beams. </p> <p>What really confusing is if the incident light is linear polarized, what can I tell about the outgoing beams after a splitter?</p> <p>Can I say they are bother linear polarized and what about the polarized orientation?</p> <p>The last question is pretty odd to me. In the text, it said we can use a quarter-wave plate to elliptical polarize a linear-polarized light. In some special case, the outgoing light could be circularly polarized. But how can I verify that? I tried the following: I let the linear-polarized light go through a half-wave plate so to control the orientation of the polarization, then let that light pass a quarter-wave plate. If I measure the power out of the quarter-wave plate, it is pretty constant. I think it doesn't tell if the beam is elliptical or circular because the power I measure is the average one, right? So I put a polarized beam splitter after the quarter-wave plate to observe the power of the split light. I think if the light is elliptical, the power should change with time, but again it is pretty constant. Doesn't matter how I rotate the quarter-wave or half-wave plate, the power is pretty constant. </p> <p>Is that anything wrong with this testing way?</p>
g4072
[ -0.012713955715298653, -0.010967792943120003, 0.011526108719408512, -0.0403284952044487, 0.04794713854789734, -0.061055466532707214, 0.07018734514713287, -0.023748723790049553, 0.005281134974211454, -0.002169088227674365, -0.00618806341663003, 0.029418449848890305, -0.036136165261268616, -0.04301799088716507, 0.07075441628694534, -0.0336151123046875, 0.05725556239485741, -0.033568769693374634, 0.09129917621612549, 0.04190274700522423, 0.0033976410049945116, 0.06991559267044067, -0.029601281508803368, -0.04860580340027809, 0.03936459496617317, 0.04717718064785004, -0.04308117553591728, -0.01024396251887083, -0.02543897181749344, -0.02895169146358967, 0.024743828922510147, -0.055817633867263794, 0.06862075626850128, -0.009079193696379662, -0.028757760301232338, 0.029314935207366943, 0.0021510303486138582, 0.021834596991539, 0.014959311112761497, 0.013548377901315689, -0.014768257737159729, -0.0426660031080246, -0.06711651384830475, -0.023328712210059166, 0.02812899276614189, -0.060596369206905365, -0.035351332277059555, -0.01184975914657116, -0.012937209568917751, -0.008040391840040684, -0.044994741678237915, -0.008724797517061234, 0.09144488722085953, -0.003652720246464014, -0.0009934898698702455, 0.061957865953445435, -0.009034830145537853, 0.04239320382475853, 0.0821671187877655, 0.033025000244379044, -0.015341607853770256, 0.007273877505213022, -0.00857795961201191, -0.020089073106646538, 0.030885368585586548, -0.0030487938784062862, 0.03899963200092316, -0.06349678337574005, -0.03496033698320389, 0.0523640513420105, -0.0030394631903618574, -0.0473719984292984, 0.00875638984143734, -0.030453424900770187, -0.03531225398182869, -0.018848197534680367, 0.039617639034986496, -0.02559310756623745, 0.0027774753980338573, 0.017648857086896896, -0.0037742597050964832, -0.040743086487054825, -0.017265964299440384, 0.005181799177080393, 0.03974888101220131, 0.041244447231292725, -0.01701025292277336, -0.013575215823948383, -0.07200856506824493, -0.01146016176789999, 0.04226714000105858, -0.05178413167595863, 0.02862393669784069, 0.036715663969516754, -0.03014928102493286, 0.012608694843947887, -0.005218108184635639, 0.020020224153995514, 0.019006840884685516, 0.03291947767138481, -0.032636262476444244, 0.022313907742500305, -0.026539873331785202, -0.01879396289587021, -0.0051058209501206875, 0.01419833954423666, -0.008710355497896671, 0.020920339971780777, -0.0043443432077765465, 0.012881431728601456, -0.07223840057849884, -0.06600961834192276, -0.09395518153905869, -0.06712502986192703, -0.027825040742754936, -0.07357127964496613, 0.08003995567560196, -0.005019311793148518, 0.04110885038971901, 0.015470463782548904, 0.04271668195724487, 0.0031603164970874786, -0.005673230160027742, 0.06038307771086693, 0.0025928046088665724, 0.00132464780472219, 0.018695635721087456, 0.019888736307621002, 0.043736085295677185, -0.010973749682307243, -0.021249152719974518, 0.007576269563287497, -0.01794392429292202, 0.03392140194773674, 0.011641229502856731, 0.024209650233387947, 0.029283111914992332, -0.023602522909641266, 0.04068030044436455, -0.031093943864107132, 0.014143835753202438, 0.0023981642443686724, -0.024532712996006012, -0.010323550552129745, 0.006935760844498873, 0.06690376251935959, 0.002864082343876362, -0.02437429688870907, 0.10745677351951599, 0.0724540501832962, 0.009432938881218433, 0.06876982748508453, -0.008864378556609154, 0.015137945301830769, -0.01099368091672659, -0.007357858587056398, -0.01017312053591013, -0.09638696163892746, 0.02697841078042984, 0.010173456743359566, 0.06355449557304382, 0.03881044313311577, -0.012054190039634705, -0.008734303526580334, 0.005754437297582626, -0.0007778331637382507, -0.017119547352194786, -0.029010534286499023, 0.06857407093048096, -0.012558582238852978, -0.029773902148008347, 0.0527803972363472, 0.06624190509319305, 0.006215221714228392, 0.016193918883800507, 0.08545292913913727, 0.0031598706264048815, 0.010460889898240566, 0.06192924827337265, 0.07182052731513977, -0.03976098448038101, 0.01400039903819561, 0.01629718951880932, 0.006500189658254385, -0.01787789911031723, -0.045598674565553665, 0.03658680245280266, -0.01870065927505493, 0.019361548125743866, 0.012900405563414097, 0.06996043771505356, -0.009045562706887722, -0.0824950560927391, 0.0296084675937891, -0.06485045701265335, -0.01191485021263361, 0.009824607521295547, 0.002262176014482975, -0.015389369800686836, 0.02064616046845913, 0.043047644197940826, 0.028295839205384254, 0.009958253242075443, 0.05933411419391632, 0.030828535556793213, -0.02301594614982605, 0.005941853858530521, 0.0006576947052963078, -0.011104785837233067, 0.026901816949248314, 0.03091803751885891, 0.008586850948631763, -0.006601362023502588, 0.011339590884745121, -0.07060737907886505, 0.025642093271017075, -0.022967806085944176, 0.073810875415802, -0.00016070315905380994, 0.04312603920698166, 0.04397978261113167, 0.00564898457378149, 0.0022308549378067255, -0.02670510672032833, -0.02756337635219097, 0.0013559589860960841, -0.04630960524082184, -0.018609192222356796, -0.035574913024902344, 0.07220032811164856, -0.019225411117076874, -0.01964067667722702, 0.06688104569911957, 0.019786208868026733, 0.04004878178238869, -0.07896718382835388, -0.043440815061330795, 0.008910447359085083, 0.016874605789780617, -0.029505807906389236, 0.041604120284318924, 0.02045959047973156, -0.004939841106534004, 0.019660109654068947, 0.035703204572200775, -0.01325020007789135, 0.025974860414862633, -0.010728269815444946, -0.003901420859619975, 0.057168763130903244, 0.032202135771512985, 0.01908431202173233, -0.025742892175912857, 0.03261146694421768, -0.057446956634521484, -0.0013821999309584498, -0.02533886954188347, 0.027278363704681396, -0.09953445196151733, 0.003697874490171671, 0.0019885969813913107, -0.03819001466035843, -0.0014764216030016541, 0.017003048211336136, -0.02464328519999981, -0.05229936167597771, 0.03413720056414604, 0.047394633293151855, 0.011537316255271435, -0.030784862115979195, -0.06548723578453064, 0.05872688069939613, 0.05052065849304199, 0.04745546355843544, -0.012227680534124374, -0.07043316215276718, -0.0034666084684431553, -0.06322606652975082, -0.043840885162353516, -0.0085175521671772, -0.027314286679029465, 0.010777603834867477, -0.060033492743968964, 0.04508033022284508, -0.03972316160798073, -0.00007124178227968514, 0.05428656190633774, 0.045249324291944504, -0.0578332357108593, 0.012389568611979485, -0.07550875842571259, -0.06407247483730316, 0.014908191747963428, -0.08537847548723221, -0.00021104785264469683, 0.007428426761180162, 0.08964406698942184, -0.058696020394563675, 0.012456873431801796, 0.009899968281388283, -0.018794339150190353, 0.007780381012707949, -0.006916246842592955, -0.0278941560536623, 0.013202445581555367, 0.02623865380883217, -0.025392873212695122, -0.05602504685521126, -0.010487417690455914, 0.09391647577285767, -0.020720453932881355, -0.006553725339472294, 0.01567164994776249, -0.015576465055346489, -0.012970893643796444, -0.008324273861944675, -0.053814847022295, -0.03826255723834038, -0.01219092682003975, 0.07543202489614487, -0.0362979881465435, 0.023291055113077164, -0.026798240840435028, 0.025387084111571312, -0.04584116488695145, -0.032119859009981155, 0.039196599274873734, 0.02114095725119114, -0.027956074103713036, -0.016163920983672142, 0.03408559411764145, 0.021127009764313698, -0.020519301295280457, 0.04496753215789795, 0.08277913182973862, -0.001677610445767641, -0.03070049174129963, 0.041731204837560654, 0.027431467548012733, -0.026086298748850822, 0.035025645047426224, -0.028717108070850372, -0.0266510471701622, -0.005530642811208963, 0.028529413044452667, -0.020177660509943962, 0.000600607949309051, -0.01639058068394661, -0.05916668847203255, 0.03275231271982193, 0.008821111172437668, 0.008911693468689919, 0.0075419992208480835, 0.0023468048311769962, -0.025787780061364174, 0.0005474021891131997, 0.00409708172082901, 0.026144174858927727, -0.018960798159241676, -0.04209887608885765, -0.024570832028985023, -0.0038682743906974792, 0.0055932542309165, -0.012126981280744076, 0.025466591119766235, 0.016593052074313164, -0.03030947968363762, 0.035516832023859024, -0.026835765689611435, -0.008007470518350601, -0.03642846643924713, -0.05764971673488617, -0.007325452286750078, -0.026754457503557205, -0.022186066955327988, -0.01576463133096695, 0.015078676864504814, -0.021829793229699135, -0.014192023314535618, 0.036188170313835144, -0.03011775016784668, 0.020814208313822746, -0.005233599804341793, 0.03855163976550102, 0.020199526101350784, 0.051898472011089325, 0.008951373398303986, 0.03372880443930626, 0.00764829246327281, 0.008784309029579163, 0.020765794441103935, -0.06119465455412865, -0.06279794871807098, -0.029198559001088142, -0.0034049057867377996, -0.033410586416721344, -0.011668290942907333, 0.0004020631604362279, -0.04952753707766533, -0.005716839339584112, -0.0037457526195794344, 0.030254129320383072, -0.0008630170486867428, -0.019473843276500702, -0.04851413145661354, 0.018646789714694023, -0.025925466790795326, 0.01203304436057806, 0.005892863497138023, -0.00012396569945849478, 0.008258524350821972, -0.029513617977499962, -0.01575082540512085, -0.07213939726352692, 0.01948840543627739, 0.021866412833333015, 0.03091423399746418, 0.006968951318413019, 0.052055004984140396, -0.01780114509165287, 0.009638628922402859, 0.030782366171479225, -0.04941968619823456, -0.04368944838643074, -0.02372661419212818, 0.0470551960170269, 0.0314653143286705, -0.06139570474624634, 0.0010259664850309491, -0.020511990413069725, 0.013873931020498276, -0.011411868035793304, 0.0012886534677818418, -0.048790253698825836, 0.015481625683605671, -0.021405955776572227, -0.04829344525933266, 0.055622536689043045, -0.000929185189306736, -0.003863445483148098, 0.014001701958477497, 0.03271277993917465, 0.0001410100667271763, -0.014294885098934174, 0.011073934845626354, 0.01853865385055542, -0.04541374742984772, -0.008537842892110348, 0.07692726701498032, -0.023128477856516838, 0.009173362515866756, 0.009386634454131126, -0.007773499935865402, -0.05297267436981201, 0.021270988509058952, -0.0007605211576446891, -0.0014568838523700833, 0.04425396770238876, 0.049396414309740067, 0.08376267552375793, -0.040708597749471664, -0.011606300249695778, 0.0012813439825549722, -0.014671100303530693, 0.025880025699734688, 0.009904545731842518, -0.026453273370862007, 0.007831583730876446, -0.05303644761443138, -0.011463372968137264, -0.046221427619457245, 0.001103039481677115, 0.006900470703840256, 0.0526571124792099, -0.06795194745063782, 0.02305452525615692, -0.03939437493681908, -0.019841721281409264, -0.0877656489610672, -0.025785578414797783, -0.02996649406850338, -0.044418975710868835, 0.03900158032774925, 0.040952593088150024, -0.014137353748083115, -0.03716403990983963, 0.02836444228887558, 0.023289820179343224, 0.019798368215560913, 0.018420841544866562, -0.02396320179104805, 0.0017740704352036119, -0.03238090127706528, -0.041151124984025955, -0.004478318616747856, 0.033468179404735565, 0.05043266341090202, -0.09136208891868591, 0.0318320170044899, 0.010975661687552929, -0.03268386796116829, 0.015904076397418976, 0.029373062774538994, 0.0050984774716198444, 0.001982667250558734, 0.05674104392528534, 0.0655413344502449, -0.039873041212558746, -0.006678394973278046, 0.06839894503355026, -0.024555450305342674, -0.012637888081371784, 0.017959024757146835, 0.0021290997974574566, -0.007537139113992453, -0.09003869444131851, -0.0005257554585114121, 0.046830810606479645, -0.05354522913694382, 0.018696194514632225, -0.07657071948051453, -0.027168503031134605, -0.021803973242640495, 0.006320080254226923, -0.00012543464254122227, -0.04685002192854881, -0.0068847113288939, 0.00022582408564630896, 0.004934938624501228, 0.04933716729283333, 0.021209845319390297, 0.08929706364870071, 0.030603986233472824, 0.04029153659939766, 0.019260207191109657, -0.04488971084356308, 0.0444347970187664, -0.04406512901186943, 0.012974358163774014, -0.024468548595905304, -0.03166656941175461, 0.006559640634804964, 0.022686796262860298, 0.05717385187745094, -0.018605230376124382, 0.031105414032936096, -0.04923410341143608, -0.040138788521289825, -0.01876179128885269, 0.027534453198313713, -0.026657065376639366, 0.05541433021426201, 0.0325162410736084, -0.050529446452856064, -0.01833398826420307, 0.014816027134656906, -0.0038116811774671078, -0.038009822368621826, -0.037544406950473785, -0.0305352583527565, 0.10458193719387054, -0.010292555205523968, 0.0002735954476520419, -0.04189161956310272, 0.03589988499879837, -0.005137409083545208, -0.03008950501680374, -0.027260614559054375, 0.005901978816837072, 0.006649402901530266, -0.017658084630966187, -0.015525930561125278, -0.030853528529405594, 0.005373156629502773, 0.06421405076980591, -0.005331483669579029, -0.02270621620118618, 0.032568302005529404, -0.005832408554852009, 0.06264397501945496, -0.015223934315145016, 0.03176729381084442, -0.006841849535703659, 0.02390851266682148, -0.0021915717516094446, -0.018858127295970917, -0.025606265291571617, -0.002417339477688074, 0.012303625233471394, -0.06410183757543564, -0.017151454463601112, 0.007218553684651852, -0.004343493841588497, -0.03937266394495964, -0.02384515292942524, -0.008366166613996029, 0.01741320826113224, 0.04883180558681488, 0.03028293512761593, 0.03625316172838211, -0.01819872111082077, 0.01401082519441843, -0.017444217577576637, -0.021119367331266403, 0.0031629486475139856, -0.026555463671684265, 0.02721504308283329, -0.051793139427900314, -0.002081099199131131, -0.0358177088201046, -0.0035478139761835337, 0.033528417348861694, 0.004772533662617207, 0.04267682880163193, -0.0071739270351827145, 0.03854675218462944, -0.043292250484228134, -0.023217232897877693, 0.003888850100338459, 0.04835081845521927, 0.052688006311655045, -0.02009933441877365, -0.03160307928919792, -0.013441532850265503, 0.042539820075035095, 0.07673074305057526, -0.009020390920341015, -0.007007039617747068, -0.018302185460925102, 0.02344505302608013, -0.007211338263005018, 0.02004319615662098, -0.0024728719145059586, 0.013046140782535076, 0.0661798045039177, -0.041021429002285004, -0.10395729541778564, 0.054562561213970184, 0.02653784491121769, 0.07179810106754303, 0.05697168409824371, 0.06277617067098618, -0.029107719659805298, 0.0046950774267315865, -0.018496083095669746, 0.0036648923996835947, -0.04885246604681015, 0.022863086313009262, -0.0025677925441414118, 0.0136710861697793, -0.061167217791080475, -0.03417837619781494, -0.01953691616654396, 0.058720335364341736, 0.03713017702102661, 0.025834277272224426, 0.033348310738801956, 0.05175144597887993, -0.041363202035427094, -0.020506512373685837, -0.03144441172480583, -0.03496602550148964, 0.026750706136226654, -0.047525689005851746, -0.050212983042001724, -0.012651685625314713, -0.005394188221544027, -0.010721646249294281, -0.02490953914821148, -0.012751178815960884, -0.04834143444895744, -0.037074316293001175, -0.018124984577298164, 0.023842828348279, 0.014628016389906406, 0.07062210887670517, -0.06190743297338486, -0.05880193039774895, 0.015074015595018864, -0.018354149535298347, -0.022681809961795807, 0.07473163306713104, -0.013258269988000393, 0.037015482783317566, -0.01582866907119751, -0.031084202229976654, -0.06102927401661873, -0.004001900553703308, -0.01606733910739422, -0.025965465232729912, -0.005080894101411104, 0.025072790682315826, 0.02077459916472435, 0.01669146865606308, -0.0036568818613886833, -0.009099082089960575, -0.008358987979590893, 0.06101902574300766, -0.01496008038520813, -0.016438821330666542, 0.0031972061842679977, 0.04173831269145012, 0.023054039105772972, 0.020202113315463066, 0.04136449471116066, -0.041328903287649155, 0.013903277926146984, -0.018360380083322525, 0.03667796030640602, 0.00918794795870781, 0.035360027104616165, 0.04363928735256195, 0.005610121879726648, -0.021535973995923996, -0.01948884129524231, 0.018565071746706963, -0.01153477281332016, 0.02578459307551384, -0.02068096399307251, -0.002593741286545992, -0.03337625786662102, 0.047722652554512024, -0.009613262489438057, -0.05493984371423721, 0.028951413929462433, 0.04526496306061745, -0.023526495322585106, 0.008432655595242977, 0.0024861374404281378, -0.00890101958066225, 0.0344054140150547, 0.05738580599427223, -0.07690618932247162, 0.005188295152038336, 0.017086798325181007, 0.085521399974823, 0.009741454385221004, -0.01867390051484108, 0.03243167698383331, 0.013930657878518105, 0.046720635145902634, -0.04903332144021988, 0.024539712816476822, -0.034444279968738556, -0.013112843036651611, -0.026327772065997124, -0.03036518394947052, 0.03438466042280197, -0.02893240563571453, 0.01579016074538231, -0.05891166999936104, 0.048590485006570816, -0.02079344354569912, -0.00799468718469143, 0.012613111175596714, -0.06187586113810539, 0.014186001382768154, -0.013720117509365082, 0.04474014788866043, -0.04366530105471611, -0.045555129647254944, 0.004929904825985432, 0.007067771162837744, -0.03677097707986832, -0.01113380491733551, -0.03147827461361885, -0.0725330114364624, -0.0031196395866572857 ]
<p>Suppose a warm body moving in an empty space with high speed. </p> <p>The body emits radiation based on its temperature. The protons emitted forwards of the body will have higher energy due to Doppler shift than those emitted backwards. Thus they will care greater momentum. The body should slowdown due to emitted radiation.</p> <p>Is there a mistake in this reasoning? Possibly the number of photons emitted forwards will be smaller?</p>
g4073
[ 0.04642285406589508, 0.019903894513845444, 0.014155569486320019, 0.02480645850300789, 0.030751053243875504, 0.06001341715455055, 0.024476584047079086, 0.08695927262306213, -0.051619045436382294, -0.03900078311562538, 0.020429104566574097, 0.04332200065255165, 0.025717608630657196, 0.04191764444112778, -0.02055876888334751, -0.01948145404458046, 0.1043909564614296, -0.010811282321810722, 0.00621627364307642, 0.055779118090867996, 0.012010389938950539, 0.06582491844892502, -0.03699146583676338, -0.03622424229979515, -0.04346010833978653, 0.03318861126899719, 0.012931328266859055, -0.015269212424755096, -0.029983242973685265, -0.05705083906650543, 0.051141586154699326, 0.006126385647803545, 0.002546836854889989, -0.0054389177821576595, -0.012101720087230206, -0.025437720119953156, 0.06549842655658722, 0.025810109451413155, -0.012295935302972794, 0.040523987263441086, 0.010681141167879105, -0.053404077887535095, 0.05402568355202675, -0.006423769518733025, 0.039722833782434464, 0.016190148890018463, 0.026391146704554558, 0.007781865540891886, -0.002067921217530966, -0.008299784734845161, -0.04575197398662567, -0.021856902167201042, -0.04854188859462738, 0.020971186459064484, 0.020397938787937164, -0.02595796249806881, -0.05138455331325531, -0.022709811106324196, 0.05497613921761513, 0.023641562089323997, -0.009877900592982769, 0.013999543152749538, -0.052416782826185226, -0.031732019037008286, 0.04734864830970764, -0.031592290848493576, -0.03617214411497116, -0.0362122543156147, 0.06412363797426224, -0.05147979035973549, 0.04077146574854851, -0.027773315086960793, -0.07305368781089783, -0.056926339864730835, 0.0018479861319065094, 0.0023476029746234417, -0.05603427067399025, -0.051498960703611374, -0.017802070826292038, 0.013186199590563774, -0.05736551061272621, -0.046756718307733536, 0.015504809096455574, 0.034087467938661575, 0.11735054850578308, -0.006553187035024166, -0.007953920401632786, 0.024907400831580162, -0.0021444528829306364, -0.023068569600582123, 0.03281372785568237, -0.019954483956098557, 0.09375301748514175, 0.014307665638625622, 0.01724166050553322, -0.0008506826125085354, -0.03218821808695793, 0.08606453239917755, -0.02519625425338745, -0.03881339356303215, -0.004234706982970238, -0.006433900445699692, -0.002322182757779956, -0.0020679254084825516, -0.01695096865296364, -0.06210888549685478, -0.01422889530658722, -0.008285093121230602, -0.04206457361578941, -0.036214035004377365, -0.00015466609329450876, -0.06585836410522461, -0.05428748205304146, -0.03240836411714554, -0.03527054190635681, -0.058553505688905716, 0.08990728110074997, -0.009556717239320278, 0.03293682262301445, 0.07299648970365524, 0.01612137258052826, -0.000191283761523664, -0.03150033950805664, 0.03451967239379883, -0.016034744679927826, -0.008224268443882465, -0.05377523973584175, 0.018216991797089577, 0.04546784609556198, 0.011606093496084213, -0.012092606164515018, 0.014984306879341602, -0.04701104015111923, 0.04961882159113884, 0.02132769115269184, 0.022203782573342323, 0.038841430097818375, 0.026177939027547836, 0.03698122128844261, -0.009909577667713165, 0.0728183388710022, 0.007229044567793608, 0.06511250138282776, -0.05769339203834534, -0.03456830978393555, 0.026054712012410164, -0.04959743469953537, -0.01712666265666485, 0.029139623045921326, 0.04037512466311455, 0.04991855472326279, 0.08506685495376587, 0.012996111065149307, 0.011013265699148178, 0.026816174387931824, 0.0016270059859380126, 0.04317066818475723, 0.040138501673936844, -0.046170011162757874, 0.007307307329028845, 0.027776364237070084, 0.027190495282411575, 0.02456151880323887, -0.024585306644439697, -0.026252249255776405, 0.006874771323055029, -0.03720848262310028, -0.049688998609781265, -0.06959692388772964, -0.004552952479571104, -0.002163388766348362, 0.009993827901780605, 0.0008515739464201033, 0.03967146947979927, -0.004483110271394253, 0.053799666464328766, 0.06653593480587006, -0.042573921382427216, -0.034231655299663544, 0.012541821226477623, -0.04300057142972946, -0.012185245752334595, 0.01459935586899519, -0.06376437842845917, 0.03887222707271576, -0.030084261670708656, -0.039467860013246536, 0.024959173053503036, -0.07383080571889877, -0.02144002541899681, -0.023625757545232773, -0.06704407185316086, -0.03740273416042328, 0.0006237988127395511, 0.008602753281593323, -0.03245456889271736, -0.016698211431503296, 0.0015935106202960014, -0.004821556154638529, 0.039542652666568756, -0.003871273947879672, 0.034931331872940063, 0.03493542969226837, -0.02585478499531746, 0.020435664802789688, 0.008312519639730453, -0.018213989213109016, 0.01306215114891529, 0.03299872204661369, -0.06679418683052063, 0.03764437884092331, -0.0019143089884892106, -0.029678702354431152, 0.020691610872745514, 0.04762738570570946, -0.02678520791232586, -0.05013156682252884, 0.011440056376159191, 0.024974636733531952, -0.009595922194421291, -0.04693005234003067, -0.016603773459792137, 0.00568805867806077, -0.02531808614730835, -0.068587526679039, 0.009116238914430141, -0.08839333057403564, -0.028135284781455994, 0.012371418066322803, 0.009207870811223984, -0.05789241939783096, 0.07214659452438354, -0.022966347634792328, -0.05065779387950897, 0.04560311883687973, -0.005221996922045946, 0.01570437103509903, 0.012676474638283253, 0.021784402430057526, 0.022571321576833725, -0.017719436436891556, -0.02287869155406952, -0.04054393991827965, -0.037118032574653625, 0.029064523056149483, -0.002510766265913844, 0.011950056999921799, -0.06579476594924927, -0.05770409479737282, 0.0013655141228809953, 0.011467527598142624, 0.039777785539627075, 0.0037901955656707287, -0.016841502860188484, -0.002026923233643174, 0.0025621901731938124, -0.06677327305078506, 0.03649403899908066, -0.05384456366300583, -0.041618235409259796, 0.016388816758990288, -0.09142621606588364, -0.034432027488946915, -0.043379928916692734, -0.027567021548748016, 0.04913392663002014, -0.029285667464137077, 0.011242006905376911, 0.003954639658331871, -0.021372923627495766, 0.039691995829343796, 0.04667050391435623, 0.027172787114977837, 0.04634183645248413, 0.014078585430979729, 0.03642226755619049, 0.03484957665205002, 0.0019264242146164179, 0.023860804736614227, -0.038358792662620544, -0.04441915825009346, 0.0010969671420753002, -0.08534504473209381, -0.05211023613810539, 0.029202569276094437, -0.06614192575216293, -0.007550501264631748, -0.03074738010764122, -0.012425500899553299, -0.022100618109107018, -0.022844577208161354, 0.019294850528240204, 0.05755426734685898, 0.040349964052438736, 0.026231655851006508, 0.07877178490161896, 0.08917967230081558, -0.05879436433315277, -0.025545649230480194, 0.05005265772342682, 0.06286508589982986, -0.020033789798617363, 0.000018714450561674312, -0.03484879806637764, 0.035802211612463, 0.018511777743697166, -0.08124256134033203, -0.07269696146249771, -0.027805229648947716, 0.0003603797231335193, 0.008166496641933918, 0.03912274166941643, -0.014358769170939922, 0.045649316161870956, 0.02306412346661091, -0.03257099539041519, -0.05893798545002937, -0.018465297296643257, 0.018205517902970314, 0.033057041466236115, -0.0038762702606618404, 0.003197443438693881, 0.003173826029524207, -0.00922556035220623, 0.0690990537405014, 0.004562798887491226, -0.02384979836642742, -0.009188934229314327, -0.018373830243945122, 0.027879254892468452, 0.025643005967140198, 0.010972698219120502, -0.011356999166309834, 0.01525978185236454, -0.04151194915175438, -0.031255971640348434, 0.018994033336639404, 0.04641276225447655, 0.015466469340026379, 0.01913306675851345, -0.02329993061721325, -0.04106271266937256, -0.02132561057806015, 0.022667171433568, 0.058863185346126556, 0.0335579551756382, 0.0015131571562960744, 0.022723061963915825, -0.030858462676405907, -0.03242666646838188, 0.03316190093755722, -0.01851198822259903, -0.008872694335877895, 0.0107562942430377, -0.05410702899098396, -0.016023635864257812, 0.0022979869972914457, 0.02563304267823696, 0.029923822730779648, 0.018886584788560867, -0.011985543183982372, -0.026521077379584312, 0.027380961924791336, 0.025539539754390717, -0.030146317556500435, 0.07108058035373688, -0.020914219319820404, 0.09505555778741837, -0.018609849736094475, -0.007330336607992649, -0.05605930835008621, -0.05957472324371338, -0.09146993607282639, 0.0018098311265930533, -0.005276807583868504, 0.024321239441633224, 0.04131767898797989, 0.0071465023793280125, -0.034405115991830826, 0.026959609240293503, 0.014982271008193493, 0.0024459667038172483, -0.0027866533491760492, 0.009781635366380215, 0.029627731069922447, 0.04543866217136383, 0.0030004195868968964, -0.0378514863550663, -0.0027216924354434013, -0.030457699671387672, 0.048614177852869034, -0.04354682192206383, 0.01814696565270424, -0.002627312671393156, 0.020136315375566483, -0.030021600425243378, 0.03213951736688614, -0.02397415041923523, 0.04340251162648201, 0.019370820373296738, -0.0056553795002400875, 0.00907393079251051, 0.02253551036119461, -0.013701967895030975, -0.02049654722213745, 0.04062899202108383, 0.024984510615468025, -0.016359731554985046, -0.05946125462651253, -0.009821364656090736, -0.05055109038949013, 0.01762332022190094, -0.024320129305124283, -0.053726859390735626, 0.024013716727495193, 0.020588835701346397, 0.02465759590268135, -0.002999235177412629, -0.0016903619980439544, 0.05135020613670349, 0.03352096304297447, 0.028996607288718224, 0.010375251062214375, -0.00003746496804524213, -0.013555306941270828, 0.06263069808483124, 0.07700765132904053, 0.01282805297523737, -0.04009652137756348, -0.01919468119740486, 0.009650046937167645, 0.029005588963627815, -0.005992457270622253, 0.01894281804561615, 0.0012853030348196626, 0.050763197243213654, 0.014374461956322193, 0.03746643662452698, -0.024336742237210274, 0.05948147922754288, 0.0007681802962906659, -0.029790055006742477, 0.026185421273112297, -0.023508770391345024, -0.027863992378115654, 0.09263619035482407, -0.006354303564876318, -0.07768498361110687, -0.04627110809087753, -0.02969552017748356, -0.029253380373120308, 0.033027756959199905, -0.04410800710320473, 0.025568466633558273, 0.04292086884379387, -0.017867228016257286, -0.020714519545435905, 0.004481627140194178, 0.004547217395156622, 0.009408015757799149, -0.03906272351741791, 0.04490415006875992, 0.08874976634979248, -0.03302786871790886, -0.022333458065986633, 0.01532781682908535, -0.031003616750240326, 0.011273592710494995, -0.029050365090370178, 0.021081803366541862, 0.003280013334006071, 0.023379430174827576, -0.04966864734888077, 0.01031058095395565, -0.010456927120685577, 0.004794233478605747, -0.007027137093245983, 0.0009601078927516937, -0.011209155432879925, 0.007398298475891352, -0.04467475414276123, -0.008575982414186, 0.04384502023458481, -0.018411630764603615, -0.029103875160217285, 0.03182324022054672, -0.07657501846551895, 0.03324597328901291, 0.056756969541311264, -0.06943713873624802, 0.0036507321055978537, 0.015999404713511467, -0.025093331933021545, -0.018318327143788338, 0.0029568925965577364, 0.030146688222885132, 0.041863713413476944, 0.025573955848813057, -0.011534152552485466, 0.02023102529346943, -0.06417334079742432, -0.033265743404626846, -0.02528597228229046, -0.018550056964159012, 0.029318783432245255, 0.02547486498951912, 0.07298652827739716, -0.026201920583844185, 0.011049012653529644, 0.004964208696037531, -0.033015552908182144, 0.06102532520890236, 0.04157315567135811, -0.03166345879435539, 0.006626586429774761, -0.035785652697086334, -0.037249233573675156, -0.028964057564735413, 0.03145706653594971, -0.027695002034306526, 0.049148935824632645, -0.004054258111864328, 0.05478657782077789, -0.01960855722427368, 0.020185837522149086, 0.01512835267931223, -0.018299207091331482, 0.007944116368889809, -0.049105942249298096, -0.005575339309871197, 0.09474121034145355, 0.03196243941783905, 0.026372408494353294, 0.03142338991165161, -0.02621975913643837, 0.02123325876891613, 0.02233162149786949, 0.04782985895872116, 0.0007565515115857124, -0.03240245580673218, -0.010245547629892826, -0.04175172001123428, 0.024432195350527763, 0.05742061138153076, -0.01681426726281643, 0.011765474453568459, -0.046602990478277206, -0.02264810912311077, 0.020318619906902313, -0.07355665415525436, -0.028494514524936676, 0.03338399529457092, -0.0056245638988912106, -0.011659076437354088, -0.0027674266602844, -0.004128165077418089, 0.019394664093852043, 0.027822690084576607, 0.053770314902067184, -0.023599842563271523, -0.012752871960401535, -0.013900783844292164, 0.05358336493372917, 0.001739595434628427, 0.03885318338871002, -0.03562130779027939, 0.0028505600057542324, -0.035869237035512924, 0.043739356100559235, 0.014151843264698982, 0.012106893584132195, 0.043344855308532715, 0.00139082211535424, 0.010491403751075268, -0.0012293875915929675, 0.04716457054018974, 0.023921962827444077, -0.028057841584086418, -0.04344553127884865, 0.004431010223925114, 0.01229404378682375, 0.03441630303859711, 0.004237547982484102, -0.03981144353747368, 0.005001202691346407, 0.01673881709575653, -0.04227159544825554, 0.04632609337568283, 0.05984572321176529, 0.019002070650458336, 0.00003330458639538847, -0.022606218233704567, -0.01921229250729084, -0.03544400632381439, -0.09444784373044968, 0.013161945156753063, -0.045571278780698776, -0.054211750626564026, -0.1094951406121254, 0.022524850443005562, 0.019125545397400856, -0.015265711583197117, 0.029911871999502182, -0.03770575672388077, 0.00923001579940319, 0.0030709095299243927, -0.0162193663418293, 0.06314996629953384, 0.018337581306695938, 0.04746103286743164, -0.04210078716278076, -0.0392935685813427, 0.01566261239349842, -0.01401329506188631, 0.007593044079840183, -0.027883155271410942, 0.031854063272476196, 0.02972760796546936, -0.014037026092410088, 0.01785200461745262, 0.008489187806844711, -0.004313441459089518, 0.024954527616500854, -0.015444849617779255, 0.04737534001469612, 0.017396626994013786, -0.05079719051718712, 0.028378797695040703, 0.011723627336323261, 0.028712764382362366, 0.012341083027422428, -0.015447784215211868, -0.08051477372646332, 0.0447063073515892, -0.0035282473545521498, -0.01191282831132412, -0.006685161031782627, 0.02179183065891266, -0.016069840639829636, 0.022324219346046448, 0.011590566486120224, 0.05285157263278961, -0.01284871157258749, -0.007632002234458923, -0.030795572325587273, 0.07387588173151016, 0.03328430652618408, 0.059873905032873154, -0.023173293098807335, -0.029666388407349586, -0.06059043109416962, -0.016202418133616447, -0.02146010287106037, 0.04371001943945885, 0.012879339046776295, -0.028006048873066902, -0.008047922514379025, 0.03235732764005661, 0.05022913217544556, -0.0765138640999794, 0.017931018024683, -0.0660383403301239, -0.010203893296420574, 0.06115029379725456, 0.03335711732506752, 0.017270199954509735, 0.02620728872716427, -0.007421377580612898, -0.0014932058984413743, 0.011410395614802837, 0.007217080798000097, -0.01489785686135292, -0.07178331166505814, -0.04444368928670883, -0.006357258651405573, 0.03494678810238838, -0.02968546748161316, -0.013751022517681122, -0.014702965505421162, 0.04163103923201561, 0.010563777759671211, 0.0005818416248075664, -0.013754239305853844, -0.001778398989699781, 0.01488958764821291, 0.04546143114566803, -0.04881107807159424, -0.05683169886469841, 0.040322355926036835, -0.006663793697953224, -0.03824847191572189, 0.010174601338803768, 0.005858148448169231, -0.030353456735610962, -0.03182336688041687, 0.042627908289432526, 0.014821204356849194, 0.04589620232582092, 0.027307771146297455, -0.009903891012072563, -0.0006864818278700113, 0.02940470352768898, 0.07131560891866684, 0.04021459072828293, -0.004483244847506285, 0.026187574490904808, 0.014251871965825558, -0.01973048411309719, -0.016059279441833496, -0.05869714543223381, 0.035749707370996475, 0.0006958486046642065, 0.02256535366177559, 0.030637765303254128, 0.020933719351887703, 0.00497551029548049, -0.05776906758546829, -0.0027169573586434126, 0.026325689628720284, -0.03525420278310776, -0.030425934121012688, -0.003190537914633751, -0.07105505466461182, -0.020075201988220215, -0.023253435268998146, -0.037461552768945694, -0.006059905048459768, -0.02687321975827217, 0.012914294376969337, -0.03173931688070297, 0.0073076169937849045, 0.0008639192674309015, -0.033263131976127625, -0.05370299890637398, -0.034502290189266205, -0.03238657861948013, 0.02105996385216713, -0.00647797342389822, -0.005123510491102934, 0.00045716104796156287, -0.028998490422964096, -0.024799564853310585, 0.030644331127405167, -0.04672371223568916, -0.009087244048714638, -0.052670594304800034, 0.008883798494935036, 0.021491486579179764, 0.07453056424856186, 0.01703568734228611, -0.005852284841239452, 0.000930587702896446, -0.05770081654191017, 0.06138573959469795, 0.041616883128881454, 0.04695853218436241, 0.05112938955426216, -0.003524722997099161, -0.055368706583976746, -0.03133394569158554, -0.04071027413010597, -0.031959857791662216, 0.0064604030922055244, -0.05718938261270523, -0.011880156584084034, -0.045201145112514496, 0.01282692514359951, -0.0004426786326803267 ]
<p>If one looks into a mirror, he can see a certain field of view.</p> <p>If he places a convex lens that magnifies (or a concave lens that does the opposite) in front of the mirror, but so that he can still see the entire mirror, will it affect the field of view shown in the mirror?</p>
g4074
[ -0.011700816452503204, 0.0225085336714983, 0.04284974932670593, -0.001993619604036212, 0.023959847167134285, -0.024820417165756226, -0.016745610162615776, 0.02132531628012657, 0.02981887198984623, -0.02550116926431656, -0.0058797430247068405, 0.02590051107108593, 0.05603814870119095, -0.0025479383766651154, -0.012057207524776459, 0.05385348200798035, 0.019140925258398056, 0.014054265804588795, -0.05056900531053543, -0.018473908305168152, -0.03934250771999359, 0.028691692277789116, -0.05119633674621582, 0.032888978719711304, -0.053859956562519073, 0.01658964529633522, 0.020957419648766518, 0.018915146589279175, -0.02144434116780758, -0.00030311261070892215, -0.026032695546746254, 0.02280847728252411, -0.01878444105386734, -0.050517868250608444, -0.016443762928247452, -0.0005379505455493927, 0.03200719505548477, 0.08945665508508682, 0.024846557527780533, -0.015768446028232574, -0.006158136297017336, 0.04139038175344467, 0.006229780614376068, -0.018770603463053703, 0.022136272862553596, -0.0033740547951310873, 0.021314376965165138, -0.0003675382467918098, -0.005047687795013189, -0.04191535338759422, -0.0115174800157547, 0.004800753202289343, -0.030898233875632286, -0.01433389913290739, 0.002502642571926117, 0.0017005025874823332, -0.04165621101856232, -0.010828142054378986, 0.0434296578168869, -0.011684891767799854, 0.027835218235850334, -0.035633716732263565, -0.035570237785577774, 0.052469853311777115, -0.020445477217435837, 0.0573156401515007, -0.06636081635951996, 0.004846172872930765, 0.01046888530254364, -0.023741340264678, -0.015614910051226616, 0.01031151507049799, -0.012988408096134663, -0.04770905151963234, -0.046351317316293716, 0.02686254121363163, 0.07909011840820312, -0.013575983233749866, -0.014602027833461761, 0.016143888235092163, -0.05639368295669556, 0.02781781367957592, 0.006734615191817284, 0.030955158174037933, 0.06154549866914749, 0.012802798300981522, 0.04912158101797104, 0.0352654866874218, 0.003447475377470255, 0.004565265960991383, 0.024206453934311867, 0.02451420947909355, -0.00013815359852742404, 0.08398782461881638, -0.008273506537079811, -0.016945306211709976, -0.0002571030636318028, 0.007590760942548513, -0.033965904265642166, 0.04968737065792084, -0.020920056849718094, 0.022334568202495575, 0.059305161237716675, 0.0040392521768808365, -0.02568257600069046, 0.0012636561878025532, 0.06767652928829193, -0.0049255662597715855, 0.008883966132998466, -0.03393874317407608, -0.060338765382766724, -0.08654579520225525, -0.049907416105270386, 0.012062267400324345, -0.08635573834180832, -0.02768089435994625, 0.07673484086990356, 0.0149765033274889, -0.008307230658829212, 0.0011818746570497751, 0.03300759196281433, 0.08128543198108673, 0.016104379668831825, 0.02299395203590393, -0.056713175028562546, 0.006468331441283226, 0.00986544881016016, 0.03089636005461216, 0.08046873658895493, -0.0264140572398901, 0.020425068214535713, -0.0018230440327897668, 0.029880104586482048, 0.010110808536410332, -0.030543051660060883, 0.05568268150091171, -0.0173067357391119, -0.0488911010324955, -0.01828177087008953, 0.04081959277391434, 0.003095590276643634, 0.049885693937540054, 0.017137082293629646, 0.01580013893544674, 0.005618482828140259, -0.0579722598195076, 0.002334624296054244, 0.02896220237016678, 0.06114114820957184, 0.05101072043180466, -0.02259933389723301, -0.029232094064354897, 0.025169212371110916, 0.007883802056312561, -0.004634607117623091, -0.031129250302910805, -0.07206901162862778, 0.010885430499911308, 0.02515132538974285, -0.03675393760204315, 0.01539745181798935, -0.014244033955037594, 0.015123269520699978, -0.0229648407548666, -0.07050298899412155, -0.015039769932627678, -0.05671534687280655, -0.04280660301446915, 0.007277174387127161, -0.04776698350906372, -0.015069789253175259, 0.024570714682340622, 0.036204852163791656, -0.007838482968509197, 0.010811903513967991, 0.018920110538601875, 0.01620950549840927, -0.01583879627287388, 0.027045508846640587, 0.07320854067802429, -0.0906599760055542, 0.01789194904267788, -0.048446666449308395, -0.051253993064165115, -0.01131739653646946, -0.009614480659365654, 0.011012725532054901, -0.010173510760068893, -0.10469663143157959, 0.0312273520976305, 0.039816245436668396, -0.008407860063016415, 0.0037047520745545626, 0.05809367820620537, 0.010956104844808578, 0.0016013345448300242, 0.025214755907654762, -0.03882506117224693, -0.029444847255945206, 0.004855304956436157, -0.048659272491931915, 0.029753427952528, 0.035904351621866226, 0.04878528043627739, -0.010836412198841572, -0.036350101232528687, 0.005599946714937687, 0.028764633461833, 0.0033087763004004955, -0.05466983839869499, 0.01624118909239769, 0.012305313721299171, 0.02905023843050003, -0.06859016418457031, -0.03246832266449928, 0.050851546227931976, -0.005365356802940369, 0.018110912293195724, -0.025419624522328377, 0.05191701650619507, -0.0005164265749044716, 0.039134856313467026, 0.0069577558897435665, 0.00975631084293127, -0.014558997936546803, -0.021194852888584137, -0.03999840095639229, -0.03504864498972893, -0.02128538489341736, 0.04167986661195755, -0.0473414771258831, -0.027948299422860146, 0.019965121522545815, 0.003879297524690628, 0.03476408123970032, -0.003477839520201087, -0.017202340066432953, 0.07016739994287491, 0.02854727953672409, 0.034885939210653305, -0.014781196601688862, 0.010569007135927677, -0.07359005510807037, -0.023082053288817406, -0.02095712162554264, -0.06176626682281494, -0.00477958470582962, 0.010961041785776615, 0.013179909437894821, -0.006851499434560537, -0.017060579732060432, 0.067262664437294, -0.006735796574503183, 0.014657655730843544, 0.0040395199321210384, 0.028319912031292915, 0.0034944002982228994, 0.019314024597406387, 0.016659092158079147, 0.05107301473617554, -0.040367934852838516, -0.0422927662730217, -0.04971449449658394, -0.05495529994368553, 0.0008659503073431551, 0.025037987157702446, -0.007721582427620888, 0.050890568643808365, 0.02577882818877697, 0.05238213390111923, -0.007864718325436115, 0.1643345206975937, -0.03239629790186882, 0.020798334851861, 0.009443210437893867, 0.01850794441998005, -0.0428607314825058, -0.08181805908679962, 0.012234143912792206, -0.07750425487756729, -0.06947622448205948, 0.07535513490438461, -0.008266033604741096, 0.04558646306395531, 0.010735523886978626, 0.042517006397247314, 0.008605271577835083, -0.07119017839431763, 0.02384592965245247, -0.02679220214486122, -0.043486468493938446, 0.05895334109663963, 0.01517428644001484, -0.004432328045368195, 0.04240832105278969, 0.020255008712410927, 0.06283173710107803, -0.021286044269800186, 0.08725154399871826, 0.015196532942354679, -0.03634363040328026, -0.04913533106446266, -0.03568853437900543, 0.04658158868551254, 0.03163910657167435, -0.018759258091449738, -0.027557646855711937, -0.09845419973134995, 0.04717438295483589, 0.002424380276352167, -0.061475373804569244, -0.007434597704559565, -0.019359387457370758, -0.008449812419712543, -0.031023381277918816, 0.014847672544419765, -0.024614514783024788, -0.02961345762014389, -0.029843250289559364, 0.012047178111970425, 0.0035496503114700317, 0.045399922877550125, 0.012342764064669609, 0.01116244774311781, 0.07064623385667801, 0.055664341896772385, 0.028264233842492104, -0.0081377774477005, 0.02613714523613453, -0.0046617379412055016, 0.01666857674717903, -0.02988581918179989, -0.03620775416493416, -0.0276847705245018, 0.00226309010758996, 0.059351980686187744, -0.03366926684975624, 0.014719286002218723, 0.03227872774004936, 0.005526854190975428, 0.07266978174448013, -0.004523795563727617, -0.01927303709089756, -0.06548202037811279, 0.05848408862948418, 0.025501180440187454, -0.03673598915338516, -0.029863962903618813, 0.025713419541716576, 0.029988646507263184, 0.03149518743157387, 0.007435209583491087, 0.00022448849631473422, -0.025145333260297775, -0.011207996867597103, 0.05004861578345299, 0.043861862272024155, 0.017466655001044273, 0.01830526813864708, -0.03912882134318352, 0.011839517392218113, -0.0270394254475832, -0.019373688846826553, -0.04597872123122215, -0.0105371018871665, 0.016185535117983818, 0.018514247611165047, -0.009164263494312763, -0.039428483694791794, 0.04226107522845268, -0.00922320131212473, -0.06727099418640137, -0.02711651474237442, 0.057529523968696594, -0.0020261213649064302, 0.034213319420814514, 0.027304718270897865, -0.021469397470355034, -0.06590916216373444, -0.023904263973236084, 0.02310563437640667, 0.009932086803019047, 0.009651415050029755, -0.0015280147781595588, -0.034117598086595535, -0.0320306196808815, 0.03186329826712608, -0.026713775470852852, 0.06428921967744827, 0.006086898036301136, -0.0031234079506248236, 0.015536480583250523, -0.010927334427833557, -0.00009267583664041013, 0.01343656424432993, 0.0461307018995285, -0.018830323591828346, -0.03104044869542122, 0.007827993482351303, -0.022320924326777458, 0.06848259270191193, 0.10202421993017197, 0.07121430337429047, 0.027004817500710487, -0.05794622004032135, -0.046002939343452454, 0.04347299784421921, 0.0246706735342741, -0.06524381041526794, -0.01259318832308054, -0.03870800882577896, -0.033158447593450546, -0.04815966263413429, -0.035425521433353424, 0.06819886714220047, 0.06776660680770874, 0.01033823098987341, 0.01621175929903984, 0.021719584241509438, -0.02755585126578808, -0.012711999006569386, 0.024267684668302536, -0.022204527631402016, 0.021092521026730537, 0.029011309146881104, 0.023155376315116882, 0.06928285211324692, -0.030991293489933014, -0.07156410813331604, -0.050258684903383255, -0.005389468744397163, 0.041214633733034134, 0.024797124788165092, 0.02161330357193947, -0.0018309197621420026, 0.004269421100616455, -0.011088692583143711, -0.008115079253911972, 0.01965818740427494, -0.01144727785140276, -0.05222874507308006, 0.011041694320738316, 0.029494650661945343, -0.051381513476371765, -0.045253295451402664, -0.01576155796647072, -0.04702349379658699, -0.039416879415512085, -0.009148703888058662, 0.003995680715888739, -0.052689239382743835, 0.0025231761392205954, -0.017702247947454453, -0.017673131078481674, -0.024973366409540176, -0.06726893037557602, -0.039376866072416306, -0.039950426667928696, 0.005875756032764912, -0.014127925969660282, 0.004967619199305773, 0.046928152441978455, 0.033975061029195786, 0.07539902627468109, 0.013977911323308945, -0.021859856322407722, 0.004744538106024265, -0.02448570914566517, -0.011785992421209812, 0.008130569942295551, 0.01640872098505497, 0.02144395187497139, 0.05018184706568718, 0.06015731766819954, -0.011371172033250332, -0.006318592466413975, -0.006614462472498417, -0.012419169768691063, 0.012692289426922798, 0.0035371300764381886, -0.013157937675714493, -0.01873048022389412, 0.07733186334371567, -0.02060874179005623, -0.046642765402793884, 0.02063783071935177, -0.03077629581093788, 0.017016617581248283, 0.0025230080354958773, -0.03714798018336296, -0.017748024314641953, 0.03355829790234566, 0.011365730315446854, -0.030826162546873093, -0.035391777753829956, 0.03458297997713089, 0.035013023763895035, -0.008562766946852207, 0.016705073416233063, 0.0367647260427475, 0.008572711609303951, 0.019897375255823135, 0.05282500758767128, -0.017879216000437737, -0.06745798885822296, -0.008700360544025898, -0.01210766937583685, -0.003623790806159377, 0.025628769770264626, 0.04019765928387642, -0.013874256983399391, 0.010886820033192635, 0.019545622169971466, 0.00019478339527267963, 0.031757108867168427, -0.07273952662944794, -0.08953817188739777, 0.030709005892276764, -0.00039659583126194775, -0.0346217006444931, 0.03062504157423973, -0.0023588768672198057, 0.007036541122943163, -0.008560286834836006, -0.014119715429842472, 0.045632023364305496, -0.038216110318899155, 0.02490905672311783, -0.004214040469378233, -0.0014729781541973352, 0.017417171970009804, 0.04125617817044258, 0.07075808942317963, -0.016765590757131577, 0.010908263735473156, -0.0390806719660759, -0.015391339547932148, 0.007561111357063055, 0.03327641636133194, 0.029611345380544662, -0.01609930396080017, 0.0069701895117759705, 0.06326594203710556, 0.10208385437726974, -0.023830687627196312, -0.017032193019986153, -0.030998947098851204, 0.004093421157449484, 0.0253915898501873, -0.00047443134826608, -0.004184094723314047, 0.02199145220220089, -0.0630265474319458, 0.00018875362002290785, -0.020802300423383713, 0.08054577559232712, -0.015800567343831062, -0.001723341760225594, 0.04556885361671448, -0.054847121238708496, 0.048918772488832474, -0.004014458041638136, -0.00259215384721756, -0.04386940225958824, -0.07088040560483932, -0.013134495355188847, 0.0330897718667984, 0.051062386482954025, 0.03023739531636238, -0.0018003728473559022, -0.021409055218100548, -0.03587578237056732, -0.013287430629134178, -0.057341068983078, 0.05582809075713158, 0.06082611158490181, -0.01823740266263485, -0.0403519906103611, -0.007557292468845844, 0.013802740722894669, 0.021873988211154938, -0.04776790365576744, -0.029010938480496407, -0.047796569764614105, -0.0046060108579695225, 0.03648407384753227, -0.04504663869738579, 0.026758452877402306, 0.02972729317843914, -0.04760417714715004, -0.030560992658138275, -0.021580951288342476, 0.014037801884114742, -0.0008004227420315146, 0.00887119397521019, -0.04305511713027954, -0.06717366725206375, 0.0668153241276741, -0.08027098327875137, 0.0743059515953064, 0.023291707038879395, -0.00592168141156435, 0.051455479115247726, -0.014482120051980019, 0.0006556333391927183, 0.012235095724463463, 0.007623571902513504, 0.0019891089759767056, 0.10366488248109818, 0.011726399883627892, 0.025894315913319588, -0.005315628834068775, 0.03713614493608475, 0.0389329195022583, -0.020883304998278618, 0.0009565319051034749, -0.007505684159696102, -0.049588486552238464, -0.028787927702069283, -0.03167196735739708, -0.013016943819820881, -0.045760124921798706, 0.022507894784212112, 0.010672325268387794, -0.015121719799935818, 0.01935274340212345, -0.0395941361784935, -0.017902592197060585, 0.06084814667701721, 0.026975486427545547, 0.0023809438571333885, -0.021835939958691597, -0.02013021521270275, -0.018630456179380417, 0.011305023916065693, -0.009301068261265755, -0.06575161963701248, 0.020172027871012688, -0.03592788800597191, 0.016540685668587685, 0.01687130145728588, 0.019532913342118263, -0.005137001629918814, -0.02084745652973652, -0.017322208732366562, 0.02526603452861309, 0.028228217735886574, -0.026392478495836258, -0.06417033821344376, 0.03634853661060333, 0.01068622712045908, 0.02939886786043644, -0.023509716615080833, 0.019652120769023895, -0.01521495170891285, 0.08754581212997437, -0.03213918209075928, 0.02371157519519329, -0.01864451915025711, -0.005676376633346081, -0.01718711294233799, 0.0027510160580277443, -0.06903746724128723, -0.018070107325911522, -0.02635946311056614, -0.029487231746315956, -0.014834726229310036, -0.02055210992693901, -0.010267851874232292, 0.030001092702150345, 0.01140449196100235, -0.047742169350385666, -0.0430709533393383, 0.030021747574210167, 0.0221390463411808, -0.06735348701477051, -0.052956901490688324, 0.019075213000178337, -0.017833173274993896, 0.06386751681566238, 0.022573048248887062, 0.04616587981581688, 0.043707214295864105, -0.04430001974105835, -0.001736944424919784, -0.03109525889158249, 0.019913550466299057, -0.006665112916380167, -0.009571612812578678, -0.11865321546792984, 0.012512397952377796, -0.053283486515283585, 0.01345863938331604, 0.023670140653848648, -0.02739305980503559, 0.0020920296665281057, 0.056095514446496964, 0.05085082724690437, -0.0006314190686680377, 0.01893021911382675, 0.022305384278297424, 0.02479877881705761, 0.022715607658028603, -0.015759335830807686, 0.022842515259981155, 0.008443575352430344, 0.003971801605075598, 0.022199220955371857, 0.005555323325097561, 0.00758169312030077, 0.005649775266647339, 0.01459194254130125, 0.012941994704306126, 0.04777058586478233, 0.00729494821280241, -0.047338638454675674, -0.01566271483898163, -0.0033205875661224127, -0.01354036945849657, -0.01516691129654646, -0.047785986214876175, 0.02474193088710308, -0.0017643185565248132, -0.10149629414081573, -0.06703775376081467, -0.009127597324550152, 0.010490049608051777, -0.026829512789845467, -0.009545275941491127, -0.007961653172969818, -0.021576661616563797, 0.008188708685338497, -0.05049645155668259, -0.056026507169008255, -0.006819074507802725, 0.005963142029941082, -0.042959727346897125, -0.08591434359550476, -0.010867256671190262, -0.009775293059647083, -0.002969338558614254, -0.064090296626091, 0.05295839533209801, -0.04663436487317085, -0.0200958289206028, 0.07356680929660797, -0.007158713880926371, -0.009963758289813995, -0.0022382040042430162, -0.0073893191292881966, -0.02351360023021698, -0.006711251102387905, 0.03104247711598873, 0.06332418322563171, 0.006420595105737448, -0.003525851760059595, -0.009445423260331154, -0.05240827798843384, 0.033224429935216904, -0.03688608482480049, -0.0030918153934180737, 0.003530653426423669, 0.006128156092017889, -0.006452459841966629, 0.0048250858671963215, -0.02271961234509945, -0.0003486248024273664, 0.009446755051612854 ]
<p>The Problem:</p> <blockquote> <p><em>An 8-m-long beam, weighing 14,700 N, is hinged to a wall and supported by a light rope that is attached 2.0 m from the free end of the beam. If the beam is supported at an angle of 30.0° above the horizontal, (a) find the tension in the rope and (b) the reaction force of the wall on the beam.</em></p> </blockquote> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/jhAhT.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> <hr> <p>My question: I have found part (a), the tension in the rope appears to be 13203.5 N. To solve part b can I move away from torques as use Newton's second law to sum the forces in the $x$ to find the normal force since the beam is not accelerating? Otherwise, how can I solve part (b)?</p>
g4075
[ 0.07304222136735916, 0.03621387854218483, 0.0019370929803699255, -0.013601627200841904, 0.008429953828454018, -0.0535367988049984, 0.020956017076969147, -0.006504664663225412, -0.02407706156373024, 0.0287303663790226, -0.03975842148065567, -0.006826331838965416, -0.049639295786619186, -0.02413766086101532, 0.05411086976528168, 0.049414318054914474, 0.09704667329788208, -0.022696835920214653, 0.05090834200382233, -0.0009993278654292226, -0.005530488211661577, 0.04942464828491211, -0.021022522822022438, -0.061369072645902634, 0.030716367065906525, 0.024394230917096138, -0.009075433947145939, 0.022482918575406075, -0.05532774329185486, 0.020244808867573738, -0.022738099098205566, -0.027278665453195572, 0.0367213599383831, -0.08468349277973175, 0.007907187566161156, 0.025405218824744225, 0.05799141898751259, -0.004428178537636995, 0.005638353060930967, -0.00015578657621517777, -0.051978569477796555, -0.014097883366048336, -0.03854913264513016, 0.013517433777451515, 0.013625076040625572, -0.051885150372982025, 0.02034887485206127, -0.0016051307320594788, 0.016983801499009132, -0.023350385949015617, -0.00971650704741478, 0.054177168756723404, -0.013146457262337208, -0.05268232151865959, -0.004504208452999592, 0.0400119312107563, 0.034010130912065506, -0.011221257969737053, 0.035293079912662506, 0.045252129435539246, -0.017478130757808685, -0.031839821487665176, 0.03539203479886055, 0.009272129274904728, 0.011938751675188541, -0.05603297799825668, -0.03056620992720127, -0.03226502984762192, 0.01279222872108221, -0.0011292151175439358, -0.026608720421791077, -0.053525201976299286, 0.005887526553124189, -0.05079026147723198, -0.07481102645397186, -0.055207427591085434, -0.004067914094775915, 0.0062714675441384315, -0.040102966129779816, -0.005362241063266993, -0.02456434816122055, 0.03287944197654724, 0.0017959644319489598, 0.03272366151213646, -0.025735793635249138, -0.012883448041975498, -0.02185039222240448, 0.02597683109343052, -0.03411100432276726, -0.002951014321297407, 0.05903176963329315, 0.009625455364584923, 0.05997861549258232, 0.014786130748689175, 0.002413305686786771, -0.04485981538891792, -0.017901983112096786, 0.032959021627902985, 0.03161615505814552, -0.0254198107868433, -0.045310113579034805, -0.06901899725198746, -0.033397477120161057, 0.005607382860034704, -0.0029474308248609304, -0.0386866070330143, 0.02548229694366455, 0.01087966002523899, -0.04630785435438156, 0.027882767841219902, -0.013992369174957275, -0.07503082603216171, -0.014680895023047924, -0.09239103645086288, -0.02994362823665142, -0.06247187405824661, 0.06594537198543549, -0.023225467652082443, 0.018285926431417465, 0.015669051557779312, -0.014406709931790829, 0.0097783412784338, -0.016238251700997353, 0.04240944981575012, -0.011180112138390541, -0.0347626730799675, -0.005273906048387289, 0.02247815765440464, 0.02450004778802395, -0.06157348304986954, 0.00033519993303343654, -0.022382330149412155, 0.022236282005906105, 0.031488899141550064, 0.021987490355968475, 0.06934236735105515, -0.0661836490035057, -0.019310161471366882, 0.031097054481506348, -0.0033846234437078238, 0.008999254554510117, -0.035013534128665924, 0.026851149275898933, 0.019669918343424797, -0.0183627400547266, 0.04358025640249252, -0.025829242542386055, 0.02376166172325611, 0.05266083776950836, 0.015454948879778385, -0.02536354586482048, 0.05543471872806549, -0.037584614008665085, -0.012766271829605103, 0.03461846709251404, -0.01768888160586357, 0.05233525112271309, -0.009353597648441792, -0.015320424921810627, -0.010739967226982117, 0.0033777232747524977, -0.01666213758289814, -0.026854315772652626, -0.0570819266140461, -0.012917020358145237, 0.05149780586361885, -0.05090119317173958, -0.0094705605879426, 0.030982650816440582, -0.04474145919084549, -0.03098677657544613, -0.048559755086898804, 0.03442733362317085, 0.011528605595231056, 0.027087828144431114, 0.019542189314961433, 0.02621203102171421, -0.030380593612790108, 0.01319164503365755, 0.006918889936059713, -0.0017329462571069598, -0.04513101279735565, 0.05754595622420311, 0.01986389420926571, -0.02507653459906578, 0.03595505282282829, 0.062311094254255295, 0.035656966269016266, -0.0069702379405498505, 0.004554306622594595, -0.027921972796320915, 0.019378095865249634, -0.02412533201277256, 0.021756967529654503, -0.0796334445476532, -0.01205436047166586, 0.0226327795535326, -0.06294914335012436, 0.015648022294044495, 0.02520737797021866, 0.021887721493840218, 0.009235371835529804, -0.01263545360416174, 0.024813318625092506, -0.0033920544665306807, -0.03870639204978943, 0.024447621777653694, 0.006945302244275808, 0.05358809605240822, -0.009990044869482517, -0.010618765838444233, -0.009346121922135353, -0.06478109955787659, 0.027327565476298332, -0.006747032515704632, -0.04989541694521904, 0.010189258493483067, 0.03262639418244362, -0.014444194734096527, 0.013996228575706482, -0.01906200312077999, 0.03088897094130516, 0.008373240940272808, -0.021060967817902565, -0.023623399436473846, -0.001204542233608663, -0.001905673649162054, -0.015883000567555428, -0.02274363860487938, -0.023397112265229225, -0.028210941702127457, -0.020725281909108162, -0.01963907666504383, -0.017410101369023323, 0.08733910322189331, 0.04120945930480957, 0.03596915677189827, 0.06968377530574799, 0.034368909895420074, 0.030869942158460617, 0.05043293908238411, 0.03418705612421036, -0.0021419322583824396, -0.06323074549436569, 0.01417023316025734, -0.009487469680607319, 0.024592190980911255, 0.016801754012703896, 0.03527392819523811, 0.027108393609523773, 0.0457596480846405, -0.016044801101088524, -0.011468273587524891, 0.01657998375594616, 0.04052020236849785, 0.01867198757827282, -0.01222935225814581, -0.017894405871629715, -0.00883916113525629, -0.06671854108572006, -0.045615922659635544, -0.005070723593235016, 0.006514274515211582, 0.023590048775076866, -0.11146128177642822, 0.007969427853822708, -0.04005544260144234, -0.03127577528357506, 0.0227540023624897, 0.029125234112143517, -0.01565185934305191, 0.006520204711705446, -0.05451134592294693, 0.0315406396985054, 0.011049837805330753, -0.06920139491558075, 0.01828690804541111, -0.017453834414482117, -0.029172630980610847, 0.02728564664721489, 0.02959398180246353, 0.03125227987766266, -0.018026849254965782, 0.07609230279922485, 0.03871915861964226, -0.007371146697551012, -0.009512107819318771, -0.017132507637143135, 0.019339151680469513, 0.03318677097558975, -0.0333862341940403, 0.044955916702747345, 0.040044017136096954, -0.025623321533203125, 0.00009980391769204289, 0.047055408358573914, -0.017890503630042076, -0.008565613999962807, -0.0063787829130887985, 0.013573389500379562, -0.07107920199632645, -0.04749331623315811, -0.055355824530124664, 0.00602862611413002, 0.0053616054356098175, -0.014485515654087067, -0.05915115028619766, -0.05401163548231125, 0.032357096672058105, 0.059404224157333374, -0.026869814842939377, 0.035919271409511566, 0.04645974561572075, -0.061681780964136124, -0.018070504069328308, -0.0047233072109520435, 0.07838083803653717, -0.010485869832336903, 0.01881742663681507, -0.02617715485394001, -0.05050210654735565, -0.0801575630903244, 0.009870204143226147, 0.027177250012755394, 0.006407240871340036, 0.04405822604894638, -0.04832424595952034, 0.032506223767995834, -0.025606492534279823, -0.022492604330182076, 0.008929042145609856, 0.006440659519284964, 0.018763331696391106, -0.04164654389023781, -0.019430989399552345, -0.032652564346790314, 0.036766353994607925, 0.005583843216300011, 0.03752802312374115, 0.016209816560149193, -0.01756637915968895, 0.009212077595293522, -0.04848168045282364, -0.014036854729056358, -0.02234257385134697, -0.019388481974601746, -0.03712666034698486, 0.024537475779652596, 0.014400963671505451, 0.010768435895442963, 0.05872184783220291, -0.016978848725557327, -0.0013192101614549756, 0.025736527517437935, 0.03732418268918991, 0.047061432152986526, 0.0063601597212255, -0.03528275713324547, -0.021878113970160484, -0.03430166468024254, -0.006107628811150789, -0.0004752460808958858, 0.01844308339059353, 0.022358901798725128, -0.03215811401605606, -0.02934621460735798, 0.013782798312604427, 0.05733739957213402, -0.015510632656514645, -0.04827932268381119, 0.045243192464113235, -0.08259762823581696, 0.02684323862195015, -0.02649182640016079, -0.005738015286624432, -0.013767508789896965, 0.03472033888101578, -0.06326939910650253, 0.037311453372240067, 0.05799137055873871, 0.04545408487319946, 0.0546029657125473, -0.0622466504573822, 0.029843425378203392, 0.03400256484746933, 0.04672102630138397, -0.017322232946753502, -0.005093676038086414, 0.07307855784893036, 0.02002529427409172, 0.014288154430687428, -0.028176086023449898, -0.033943530172109604, 0.02348356880247593, 0.015166642144322395, -0.041659533977508545, 0.04073208570480347, 0.024875586852431297, -0.09434622526168823, -0.04842764139175415, 0.029854893684387207, 0.03203156962990761, 0.005097795743495226, 0.011533388867974281, -0.02983403392136097, 0.030544854700565338, 0.04089243710041046, -0.002752442844212055, 0.03040706180036068, 0.03890360891819, 0.00655564246699214, -0.005460138898342848, 0.00212211930193007, -0.053480736911296844, 0.022218290716409683, -0.07204164564609528, 0.016443803906440735, 0.026442792266607285, -0.047160033136606216, -0.04188641905784607, 0.010082854889333248, 0.05451231822371483, 0.015227504074573517, 0.000728127546608448, -0.04083115980029106, 0.02259461209177971, 0.02660156786441803, 0.02421153150498867, 0.04956677183508873, -0.0528564378619194, -0.05167827382683754, 0.0062900688499212265, -0.049243200570344925, -0.02707625925540924, -0.01702422834932804, 0.045210473239421844, 0.04104474186897278, -0.02427615039050579, 0.042816706001758575, 0.06346961110830307, -0.0328463576734066, 0.0639558732509613, -0.012707614339888096, 0.012385163456201553, -0.014675009995698929, 0.0574813149869442, -0.025362906977534294, -0.044060587882995605, -0.017254138365387917, -0.006746619939804077, 0.018532903864979744, -0.04673870652914047, 0.009039666503667831, -0.003281048499047756, 0.03602812439203262, 0.03790343552827835, -0.020321253687143326, -0.0017738776514306664, 0.04540214687585831, 0.0077381376177072525, -0.004050032235682011, -0.04798797890543938, -0.022279230877757072, -0.004883623216301203, 0.04058650881052017, 0.025841355323791504, -0.03484440594911575, 0.031362589448690414, -0.02078252099454403, -0.01965055800974369, 0.0011261407053098083, -0.014128800481557846, 0.019231513142585754, -0.02281159535050392, -0.03730124235153198, 0.009308584965765476, -0.01641346886754036, 0.03137705475091934, 0.02866426669061184, 0.004731279797852039, -0.03502536192536354, 0.04285675287246704, -0.035208526998758316, -0.01916700229048729, 0.07577692717313766, -0.07585618644952774, 0.04212583974003792, 0.03968505561351776, 0.05538417026400566, -0.0006067606154829264, -0.047956548631191254, 0.05513157323002815, -0.07029188424348831, -0.052527591586112976, -0.006897152401506901, 0.05924191325902939, -0.012456989847123623, -0.028901545330882072, -0.014254198409616947, 0.058830682188272476, -0.06349294632673264, 0.02852475456893444, -0.023214444518089294, 0.037720803171396255, -0.05871814489364624, 0.03763621300458908, -0.033297400921583176, 0.04326535016298294, -0.0016749195056036115, 0.09625106304883957, 0.019578302279114723, 0.023035410791635513, 0.02610878087580204, -0.011490008793771267, -0.002326885936781764, -0.03399031609296799, 0.06389561295509338, 0.017477937042713165, -0.04912855476140976, -0.012433258816599846, 0.06693856418132782, 0.0035249849315732718, 0.0676530972123146, -0.02482534386217594, -0.004192674066871405, 0.009377710521221161, -0.016182545572519302, 0.006299002096056938, -0.06577999144792557, 0.03879009932279587, -0.009381301701068878, -0.01827862672507763, 0.018684448674321175, -0.02692965790629387, -0.02501584403216839, -0.008881550282239914, 0.0029638586565852165, -0.011105339974164963, -0.019234362989664078, -0.05200883373618126, 0.0399622768163681, -0.05857070907950401, 0.058687493205070496, -0.0026991141494363546, -0.003057780209928751, 0.02878461964428425, -0.06773635745048523, -0.046883173286914825, 0.07286446541547775, 0.010934317484498024, -0.01938648149371147, 0.03262897953391075, -0.06766874343156815, 0.028035033494234085, -0.030858388170599937, 0.020172614604234695, 0.03360455855727196, 0.0006362819112837315, 0.002915057586506009, 0.02516968734562397, 0.09268137067556381, -0.00906678382307291, 0.047608766704797745, 0.01580651104450226, 0.009672047570347786, -0.022652430459856987, -0.018224695697426796, 0.023447854444384575, 0.021340394392609596, 0.041512370109558105, 0.031108634546399117, 0.03640725091099739, -0.004262880422174931, 0.07061561942100525, 0.07703253626823425, 0.03779997676610947, -0.05891595408320427, -0.024356836453080177, -0.07616128027439117, 0.04098758101463318, -0.051570113748311996, 0.014224160462617874, 0.003686843905597925, -0.060164064168930054, -0.010463367216289043, -0.030086200684309006, 0.012084681540727615, -0.03178948163986206, 0.06391418725252151, -0.013627889566123486, -0.04466049745678902, 0.01483249943703413, -0.05202266201376915, 0.00328686716966331, -0.011557514779269695, -0.039921894669532776, 0.024887464940547943, 0.030935341492295265, 0.034709151834249496, 0.07697726041078568, 0.061285022646188736, -0.008388465270400047, 0.03416791185736656, -0.013098149560391903, 0.03797178342938423, 0.0029172059148550034, 0.008817516267299652, 0.02838188223540783, -0.017558572813868523, -0.008109043352305889, 0.03888611122965813, 0.03532514348626137, 0.009861858561635017, -0.0017804533708840609, 0.012551890686154366, -0.024857163429260254, 0.030822549015283585, 0.03025074675679207, -0.03657062351703644, -0.042904265224933624, 0.012986809015274048, -0.02297479845583439, 0.005180136766284704, -0.000950015033595264, -0.004867957439273596, -0.010443526320159435, -0.07496817409992218, -0.020199358463287354, 0.03873923420906067, -0.012494639493525028, 0.056547217071056366, -0.0534125454723835, -0.0532505139708519, -0.013835671357810497, -0.01415395550429821, 0.03157489746809006, -0.015090708620846272, 0.05663939565420151, 0.003958033863455057, 0.033734411001205444, -0.030743394047021866, 0.04350419342517853, -0.05161423981189728, -0.016399485990405083, -0.033985041081905365, -0.039859361946582794, 0.013673528097569942, -0.04931950196623802, -0.05251089856028557, 0.03145294263958931, 0.006331200245767832, -0.010872171260416508, -0.01672213338315487, 0.008999797515571117, -0.072552889585495, 0.009520330466330051, -0.012081692926585674, -0.026589443907141685, -0.0009785419097170234, 0.010895414277911186, -0.040063321590423584, 0.016606193035840988, 0.05383826419711113, -0.005467062816023827, -0.025235649198293686, 0.03972071409225464, -0.012416006065905094, 0.018447060137987137, -0.0011051339097321033, -0.00011543822620296851, -0.0005310438573360443, -0.07010374963283539, -0.019823724403977394, 0.026206014677882195, 0.006954277399927378, 0.07980316877365112, 0.0439821258187294, -0.004866587929427624, 0.0032100556418299675, -0.04101364687085152, -0.01169154979288578, 0.03179656341671944, -0.07563351839780807, -0.003912738524377346, 0.0008650426752865314, 0.038607217371463776, 0.017718762159347534, 0.016516394913196564, 0.006023293361067772, 0.017144229263067245, -0.01627933979034424, 0.11652965843677521, -0.007873226888477802, -0.06582656502723694, 0.011605538427829742, 0.0039241863414645195, -0.02097300812602043, 0.013315504416823387, 0.022425726056098938, -0.011208734475076199, -0.043500326573848724, 0.02439504861831665, -0.061352070420980453, 0.02273218147456646, -0.055763594806194305, -0.0011979031842201948, 0.005444697570055723, -0.05922532454133034, -0.019526761025190353, 0.00558321550488472, 0.027826908975839615, 0.06441476941108704, -0.05244175344705582, 0.014429012313485146, 0.03515509143471718, 0.022821102291345596, 0.012679021805524826, 0.0502946637570858, 0.06311071664094925, -0.006591692101210356, -0.04891514778137207, 0.027646999806165695, -0.04531291127204895, -0.041727952659130096, -0.05934498459100723, -0.05986921116709709, -0.008581537753343582, 0.030858395621180534, -0.07137904316186905, 0.048344552516937256, 0.008263240568339825, -0.04021669179201126, -0.020377950742840767, -0.051319949328899384, 0.020849118009209633, 0.0036877142265439034, 0.004416584502905607, -0.029002679511904716, 0.02911256067454815, 0.0618017204105854, 0.015377656556665897, 0.0040317983366549015, -0.0098854536190629, -0.0199048463255167, 0.05566318705677986, -0.01434645988047123, -0.04210240766406059, 0.05577422305941582, -0.00506306067109108, 0.01636343076825142, -0.023214150220155716, -0.008042577654123306, -0.001475630677305162, -0.032359614968299866, 0.008938007988035679, -0.04718635603785515, -0.06422677636146545, 0.010775599628686905, 0.039007533341646194, -0.02863898314535618, 0.006755405105650425, 0.04053816571831703, -0.07002589851617813, -0.02494998648762703, 0.06768541038036346, -0.03958642855286598, -0.050045568495988846, 0.02314547263085842 ]
<p>In David J. Griffiths's <em>Introduction to Electrodynamics,</em> the author gave the following problem in an exercise.</p> <blockquote> <p><em>Sketch the vector function</em> $$ \vec{v} ~=~ \frac{\hat{r}}{r^2}, $$ <em>and compute its divergence, where</em> $$\hat{r}~:=~ \frac{\vec{r}}{r} , \qquad r~:=~|\vec{r}|.$$ <em>The answer may surprise you. Can you explain it?</em></p> </blockquote> <p>I found the divergence of this function as $$ \frac{1}{x^2+y^2+z^2} $$ Please tell me what is the surprising thing here.</p>
g4076
[ 0.06224533170461655, -0.002641358645632863, -0.0021368926391005516, -0.03235568478703499, 0.058039769530296326, -0.005912983790040016, 0.08845504373311996, -0.007765304762870073, -0.026768680661916733, -0.051012132316827774, -0.08093120902776718, 0.030109863728284836, 0.025535285472869873, 0.01824462227523327, 0.01582598313689232, 0.0005930046318098903, 0.01626141183078289, 0.01877749152481556, -0.010695469565689564, -0.031176509335637093, -0.04538458213210106, 0.0033035168889909983, 0.05432615801692009, -0.020796578377485275, 0.05993311107158661, -0.031619664281606674, 0.08290661871433258, 0.014298337511718273, -0.0506364144384861, 0.05087800696492195, 0.04101723060011864, 0.061770256608724594, 0.03442947566509247, -0.02312276139855385, 0.015280968509614468, 0.04555812478065491, 0.06974580883979797, 0.012682020664215088, 0.0567263662815094, -0.012276101857423782, -0.02062179148197174, 0.028922976925969124, 0.015265077352523804, 0.00932274293154478, 0.0051658921875059605, -0.0565962940454483, -0.03050864115357399, -0.009448512457311153, -0.04905256628990173, -0.003370481776073575, 0.045056361705064774, 0.05120616778731346, 0.0861666202545166, -0.012941214255988598, 0.0226459763944149, 0.007834848947823048, 0.015622328966856003, 0.0002449750027153641, 0.08253548294305801, -0.0013316161930561066, -0.020282166078686714, -0.017859136685729027, 0.013350535184144974, -0.0361461415886879, 0.020403197035193443, -0.07564243674278259, -0.016254765912890434, -0.048397745937108994, 0.005578678101301193, 0.037463460117578506, 0.018755940720438957, -0.10352969169616699, 0.0025686658918857574, 0.005206070840358734, -0.023608842864632607, -0.020140647888183594, 0.06986764818429947, -0.02213433012366295, 0.012382698245346546, -0.003025030717253685, -0.025717567652463913, -0.027886413037776947, -0.059684984385967255, 0.06751197576522827, 0.07931612432003021, -0.04406260326504707, -0.022836994379758835, 0.011465556919574738, -0.030055632814764977, 0.024857621639966965, -0.0042208218947052956, 0.006984726060181856, 0.005236057098954916, 0.011835355311632156, -0.006810285151004791, -0.0472368486225605, -0.0327070988714695, -0.0008294130675494671, 0.011797420680522919, -0.012317688204348087, 0.057128485292196274, 0.017815979197621346, -0.0120084835216403, 0.012325165793299675, -0.0016468705143779516, 0.0007059420458972454, 0.04954171180725098, -0.010893372818827629, 0.0146105345338583, -0.07130460441112518, -0.019370462745428085, -0.03220945596694946, -0.052265383303165436, -0.053563442081213, -0.043084532022476196, 0.04743747040629387, 0.06454255431890488, -0.06562807410955429, -0.0633719339966774, 0.049157243221998215, -0.03663081303238869, -0.0028222177643328905, 0.010648823343217373, 0.024823077023029327, 0.011127598583698273, 0.031962744891643524, 0.03817858174443245, -0.014650530181825161, -0.008497820235788822, -0.006100391037762165, 0.022737491875886917, 0.04438447207212448, 0.016564829275012016, 0.006062138359993696, 0.024264859035611153, -0.0315912589430809, 0.0018425923772156239, -0.025231577455997467, 0.026233261451125145, 0.037969790399074554, 0.030123399570584297, -0.06556172668933868, -0.0009521115571260452, -0.060153014957904816, -0.04544181376695633, -0.027954885736107826, -0.024590522050857544, -0.044154372066259384, -0.01664862222969532, -0.04175032302737236, -0.000982734956778586, 0.046181365847587585, 0.01567891426384449, -0.03575970232486725, 0.06443250179290771, 0.04198453575372696, 0.07645264267921448, 0.014095474034547806, 0.0006721149547956884, 0.031232867389917374, 0.03667886182665825, 0.02147544175386429, 0.02172817476093769, 0.045248568058013916, -0.040868815034627914, 0.005347006488591433, 0.04284130036830902, -0.09997855871915817, 0.0037377472035586834, -0.04809108376502991, -0.02852906845510006, -0.010607501491904259, 0.009973033331334591, 0.0354497916996479, -0.014097968116402626, 0.042502276599407196, -0.029114117845892906, -0.014539184980094433, -0.034299079328775406, 0.048869211226701736, 0.022601569071412086, -0.040254395455121994, 0.0049804216250777245, -0.01773226074874401, -0.04450313001871109, -0.006833110935986042, -0.016578027978539467, 0.005369802471250296, -0.06171613559126854, -0.03476392850279808, -0.020993275567889214, -0.006863435264676809, -0.046187497675418854, 0.05785618722438812, -0.019264960661530495, 0.025389138609170914, 0.0180410947650671, -0.03831934928894043, -0.009853612631559372, 0.10952767729759216, 0.040485721081495285, 0.07057894021272659, 0.01926114410161972, 0.05608189478516579, -0.011005457490682602, 0.000036330609873402864, -0.07180207967758179, -0.051452916115522385, 0.040141697973012924, 0.027676953002810478, 0.07759730517864227, -0.057149313390254974, 0.020066943019628525, -0.007110913749784231, -0.011065016500651836, -0.050470020622015, 0.02609274350106716, 0.02368534542620182, -0.023699864745140076, 0.04071143642067909, 0.019485605880618095, -0.007386892102658749, 0.03993823006749153, 0.008418397046625614, -0.02267029695212841, 0.06233793497085571, -0.04632902890443802, -0.03115745261311531, -0.043802157044410706, -0.025400947779417038, -0.04405995458364487, -0.026747427880764008, 0.03900093212723732, -0.01482950896024704, 0.03430701419711113, 0.017392726615071297, -0.036176931113004684, 0.004804656375199556, 0.06349755078554153, -0.036679912358522415, 0.030002044513821602, -0.062317509204149246, 0.020801348611712456, 0.014296215027570724, 0.014065755531191826, 0.012989476323127747, 0.03723859414458275, 0.022516118362545967, 0.008990570902824402, -0.018027029931545258, 0.0481887049973011, 0.0037141479551792145, -0.05957718566060066, 0.08639821410179138, -0.018320415169000626, -0.05077800527215004, -0.05029807984828949, 0.018010826781392097, 0.006836966145783663, -0.06376568228006363, -0.09568280726671219, 0.0025660621467977762, 0.05257011204957962, 0.0386207289993763, -0.052680835127830505, 0.060835741460323334, -0.00495644798502326, 0.06125159189105034, 0.047797463834285736, -0.043809857219457626, -0.027463320642709732, 0.01327928900718689, 0.030804555863142014, 0.0184825137257576, -0.08723587542772293, -0.05812699720263481, -0.004144979175180197, -0.04192420840263367, 0.010392899625003338, -0.03016321174800396, -0.03418102487921715, 0.015225018374621868, -0.005593531299382448, 0.06072148680686951, 0.06204366683959961, -0.03923087567090988, 0.009555705823004246, 0.03433176875114441, -0.023857561871409416, -0.0533648245036602, -0.0770779550075531, 0.007542433682829142, 0.02073740027844906, -0.03739693760871887, 0.029217243194580078, 0.05548696219921112, -0.005664753261953592, -0.04099534451961517, -0.06469358503818512, -0.01771998219192028, 0.0723428800702095, 0.00208979076705873, -0.020398853346705437, -0.003516939701512456, 0.013795822858810425, -0.02952725812792778, -0.01153553370386362, -0.011939162388443947, 0.020823292434215546, -0.0005288685788400471, -0.019333168864250183, -0.013815871439874172, 0.03181066736578941, -0.0016325098695233464, -0.030203690752387047, 0.007359826471656561, 0.012917271815240383, 0.0007239189581014216, 0.060157664120197296, 0.013182171620428562, -0.04184180498123169, -0.03265197202563286, 0.04828481748700142, 0.012359274551272392, 0.026065874844789505, 0.005045413970947266, -0.02144891396164894, 0.01947895996272564, -0.005066512618213892, 0.010830016806721687, -0.021316519007086754, -0.00031955254962667823, -0.00552226509898901, 0.0037501021288335323, -0.04343827813863754, -0.055692221969366074, -0.01978161372244358, 0.06868654489517212, 0.004662724211812019, -0.015225233510136604, -0.021181799471378326, -0.03782502934336662, 0.03504805266857147, -0.03395194932818413, 0.0027197562158107758, 0.0199307631701231, -0.006413534749299288, 0.02851426787674427, 0.073374904692173, 0.015384353697299957, -0.012982604093849659, -0.019653303548693657, 0.038076166063547134, -0.006596467923372984, -0.003367699682712555, -0.014771847985684872, -0.0020069899037480354, -0.010753775015473366, -0.02281610481441021, 0.006173999980092049, 0.07735923677682877, -0.00871163047850132, 0.001506171771325171, -0.06279098987579346, 0.018738506361842155, 0.019371500238776207, 0.03557242453098297, 0.043881241232156754, -0.037364035844802856, -0.031260840594768524, 0.00781550444662571, -0.003043461823835969, 0.0017838828498497605, 0.10070648789405823, 0.00808725692331791, -0.031013023108243942, 0.02881384827196598, 0.02992645837366581, 0.00016613166371826082, -0.00020359037443995476, 0.04881827533245087, 0.012158003635704517, 0.033660683780908585, -0.010408097878098488, -0.02781897969543934, 0.02137107402086258, -0.01411946676671505, -0.021122761070728302, 0.009235519915819168, -0.0475347638130188, 0.0483698695898056, 0.0010594056220725179, -0.026348453015089035, 0.0474286787211895, -0.05106848105788231, -0.05557522550225258, 0.021496420726180077, 0.041300807148218155, -0.057910747826099396, 0.07325612753629684, -0.01748993992805481, -0.04137178137898445, -0.016860928386449814, -0.0033012274652719498, -0.028561623767018318, -0.03541681170463562, 0.0491628460586071, -0.05038284882903099, 0.04827527701854706, -0.019046444445848465, 0.03476400300860405, 0.006399641744792461, 0.00255256867967546, -0.0746878832578659, 0.035900093615055084, 0.0075768763199448586, 0.05474652349948883, 0.037384215742349625, 0.02155647985637188, -0.04006040468811989, -0.047563426196575165, 0.011568933725357056, 0.015410492196679115, 0.004849045537412167, 0.019225025549530983, 0.050372567027807236, 0.046745456755161285, 0.018495073541998863, 0.028202680870890617, -0.003620374947786331, 0.03132595494389534, 0.006628735922276974, -0.052670445293188095, 0.05029682815074921, -0.0630793422460556, 0.03432217240333557, 0.020299626514315605, 0.005256819538772106, -0.052684757858514786, 0.11032470315694809, 0.06472939252853394, -0.10115925967693329, -0.008552050217986107, -0.013254349119961262, 0.05424436926841736, 0.012174037285149097, -0.006213019136339426, -0.025672385469079018, 0.02931981347501278, 0.06189282611012459, -0.016131872311234474, 0.02009124495089054, 0.010942487977445126, 0.007890669628977776, 0.004331641830503941, -0.0671921893954277, -0.024319963529706, -0.02417004480957985, 0.05288452282547951, 0.008971690200269222, -0.0018273728201165795, -0.0013210434699431062, -0.015291710384190083, -0.008205113932490349, 0.05869784578680992, -0.007180239539593458, -0.004815608728677034, 0.02985144779086113, -0.023019669577479362, 0.01769852638244629, -0.018471919000148773, 0.00686718849465251, 0.026136182248592377, 0.011642183177173138, -0.035516563802957535, 0.001855444977991283, 0.015481802634894848, 0.005421164911240339, 0.007650105748325586, -0.007759659085422754, -0.029428755864501, -0.027306634932756424, -0.01332807820290327, 0.013774445280432701, -0.019182654097676277, -0.023616313934326172, -0.022721560671925545, -0.07087024301290512, -0.09143062680959702, 0.014228285290300846, 0.010745557956397533, 0.018402449786663055, -0.021688146516680717, -0.02235874906182289, 0.007369147147983313, -0.042408399283885956, 0.04602489247918129, -0.027797486633062363, 0.02263156697154045, -0.017193203791975975, -0.0933929830789566, 0.008727826178073883, -0.03684099391102791, -0.03311507776379585, 0.02996055968105793, 0.03235752880573273, 0.05650927126407623, -0.002768286969512701, 0.0036064423620700836, 0.05172491818666458, -0.028672106564044952, -0.02314070053398609, 0.027790617197752, -0.011787979863584042, 0.038533687591552734, -0.06374230235815048, -0.07519616186618805, -0.025531219318509102, -0.006787662860006094, -0.06133255362510681, 0.05329981446266174, -0.031957466155290604, 0.0017450839513912797, -0.023238858208060265, 0.008570115081965923, 0.005028740502893925, -0.09813672304153442, -0.04638123884797096, -0.0517461895942688, 0.0626859962940216, -0.019599126651883125, -0.011138813570141792, -0.015619568526744843, -0.016219401732087135, 0.01664626970887184, 0.016313586384058, -0.046484582126140594, -0.0440426841378212, -0.031004799529910088, -0.027488328516483307, 0.0356704406440258, 0.01466383133083582, 0.04287116974592209, 0.021487325429916382, -0.01597314141690731, -0.004538840614259243, -0.02552284114062786, 0.04935524985194206, 0.07669131457805634, -0.07181219756603241, 0.012586528435349464, 0.014199451543390751, -0.05024943873286247, -0.023694530129432678, -0.0271987896412611, -0.022157160565257072, -0.013905688188970089, 0.0014484962448477745, -0.044598937034606934, 0.0026259005535393953, 0.013052931055426598, -0.03223748505115509, -0.01972227729856968, -0.0506436750292778, -0.021797340363264084, -0.02542869746685028, 0.027638576924800873, 0.07328150421380997, 0.008559134788811207, 0.005393379833549261, 0.001767294597811997, 0.000964969745837152, 0.04750589653849602, 0.05570951849222183, 0.05628414824604988, 0.0429348349571228, 0.0004708167689386755, -0.0677059069275856, -0.009259806014597416, -0.05932406708598137, 0.0031680273823440075, -0.005181735847145319, 0.040641073137521744, -0.03296669200062752, -0.010182011872529984, 0.05663591995835304, -0.01985367015004158, -0.03733694180846214, -0.014978040009737015, 0.028811760246753693, -0.026379374787211418, 0.05821583420038223, -0.016383079811930656, 0.004064924083650112, 0.013494821265339851, -0.035188399255275726, 0.021941330283880234, 0.028055114671587944, -0.008957739919424057, -0.016107676550745964, 0.015685154125094414, 0.03392363712191582, 0.03167448937892914, 0.0016379166627302766, -0.010952246375381947, 0.00898955948650837, -0.018596280366182327, 0.0013699011178687215, -0.029851097613573074, 0.015790821984410286, 0.009855901822447777, 0.006061383988708258, 0.017557479441165924, 0.00012417729885783046, -0.007569995243102312, 0.02344568818807602, 0.013082034885883331, 0.03322417661547661, -0.013582780957221985, 0.0072387405671179295, 0.041920267045497894, -0.006263368763029575, -0.03841044753789902, -0.0680142268538475, -0.006554652936756611, 0.014950305223464966, -0.015295521356165409, -0.002062701154500246, 0.043956778943538666, -0.02479921281337738, 0.025054635480046272, 0.007022052071988583, -0.009284050203859806, 0.002766852267086506, -0.026455428451299667, 0.021409334614872932, 0.015004419721662998, 0.039897605776786804, 0.03006969764828682, 0.026391638442873955, -0.04472307115793228, 0.03016342595219612, 0.06271827220916748, -0.05591150000691414, 0.008497083559632301, 0.0019272287609055638, 0.009491418488323689, 0.020981058478355408, -0.06589100509881973, 0.029191648587584496, 0.0276976116001606, 0.07561477273702621, -0.0029814084991812706, -0.047402381896972656, 0.039605725556612015, -0.013962090946733952, -0.016301140189170837, 0.031161164864897728, 0.020610403269529343, -0.06598043441772461, -0.04735187068581581, 0.021812498569488525, 0.011451124213635921, 0.017554009333252907, -0.0005821950035169721, 0.02613518387079239, -0.016813602298498154, -0.05079903453588486, -0.009921517223119736, -0.07442530989646912, -0.010579480789601803, -0.023384535685181618, -0.011461998336017132, -0.006932578515261412, -0.0006422779406420887, 0.011975319124758244, -0.011464741080999374, 0.04220183566212654, -0.034055083990097046, 0.0011530269403010607, -0.011974033899605274, 0.015437108464539051, -0.027090124785900116, -0.019794240593910217, -0.017893990501761436, 0.023372216150164604, -0.028926793485879898, -0.07470797002315521, -0.0018489616923034191, -0.05125065892934799, -0.020149067044258118, 0.0063145579770207405, 0.00508037069812417, 0.00795905664563179, 0.05156167224049568, -0.009908468462526798, 0.011838961392641068, 0.04423760995268822, -0.008953792974352837, 0.040555864572525024, 0.013099350035190582, -0.0009694494656287134, 0.019485341385006905, -0.009493578225374222, -0.020871955901384354, 0.02773931995034218, 0.03649777173995972, -0.040412262082099915, -0.04541882127523422, -0.032839834690093994, 0.025057246908545494, -0.01861671917140484, -0.00952170230448246, -0.026527749374508858, 0.014959338121116161, 0.020058726891875267, -0.027812734246253967, 0.035022418946027756, 0.027927784249186516, -0.041748132556676865, 0.011923550628125668, 0.013923867605626583, 0.03052188642323017, -0.04983064532279968, -0.04601128026843071, -0.03760068491101265, -0.02158321440219879, -0.00022468531096819788, -0.02431315928697586, 0.00378941441886127, -0.010420720092952251, 0.007416254375129938, -0.02761474996805191, 0.02969953790307045, -0.006776324938982725, -0.014565177261829376, 0.060488276183605194, 0.02625148743391037, 0.06328225880861282, -0.005067691672593355, -0.021005339920520782, 0.008477333001792431, -0.0241082850843668, 0.0023752707056701183, 0.0013408426893875003, -0.029276376590132713, -0.0299830362200737, 0.02715245634317398, -0.011466410011053085, -0.012179269455373287, -0.03760616481304169, 0.033624060451984406, -0.053679607808589935, 0.03978317603468895, 0.09213554859161377, 0.006676816381514072, 0.04766883701086044, 0.05291081219911575, 0.030940543860197067, -0.012698015198111534, -0.02641412988305092, -0.07897740602493286, -0.019210558384656906, 0.030939698219299316, 0.02575005032122135, -0.05369289591908455, -0.03391214460134506, 0.04803687706589699 ]
<p>I read that </p> <blockquote> <p><em>Halo nuclei could be seen as special Efimov states, depending on the subtle definitions.</em> (The last sentence in the second to last paragraph of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efimov_state" rel="nofollow">this</a> Wikipedia article.) </p> </blockquote> <p>This does not seem trivial to me in the least. Can someone shed some light on this for me? </p>
g4077
[ 0.01656170003116131, 0.104008249938488, 0.02819894813001156, -0.045038990676403046, 0.05031534284353256, 0.0019369797082617879, -0.00942937470972538, 0.011490387842059135, 0.05480707809329033, -0.05207093432545662, -0.025258181616663933, 0.005597956478595734, 0.06327646225690842, -0.0007521128281950951, -0.01564818061888218, -0.004542926326394081, 0.0250448789447546, 0.006090421695262194, 0.05390608310699463, 0.06696369498968124, -0.04583803564310074, 0.007236885838210583, -0.060299716889858246, -0.025653792545199394, 0.027983535081148148, 0.04846036061644554, 0.04943573847413063, -0.05839156731963158, -0.05005255714058876, -0.01628735102713108, 0.057209331542253494, -0.0032309293746948242, -0.018168577924370766, -0.04029854014515877, 0.005579451564699411, 0.007911710068583488, 0.029845276847481728, 0.01596726104617119, 0.018028242513537407, 0.02727661281824112, -0.012835976667702198, -0.0015051880618557334, -0.006491752341389656, -0.028335366398096085, -0.07798419147729874, -0.0002397020871285349, 0.05360060930252075, -0.007294161710888147, -0.009650873020291328, -0.06460855156183243, 0.00550515903159976, 0.013804147951304913, 0.06207931041717529, 0.005297598894685507, 0.05522851273417473, -0.043964311480522156, 0.011265295557677746, 0.021301845088601112, 0.07709275186061859, -0.011929306201636791, 0.027207501232624054, 0.0003890447551384568, 0.022481223568320274, -0.03569381684064865, 0.03783160820603371, 0.005097089800983667, -0.012772317044436932, 0.0023771740961819887, 0.013636373914778233, 0.032759372144937515, -0.0035946995485574007, -0.007530645001679659, -0.06369813531637192, -0.03240976110100746, 0.03177957609295845, 0.02560260519385338, 0.026911165565252304, 0.00515853613615036, 0.04869744926691055, 0.0014606979675590992, 0.009824750944972038, -0.007545813452452421, 0.03494470193982124, 0.02007342502474785, 0.0946236178278923, 0.09843055158853531, -0.09390275925397873, 0.006850994657725096, 0.04550713300704956, -0.03216114640235901, -0.01579243876039982, -0.030139697715640068, 0.03477735444903374, 0.002366393804550171, -0.005865265149623156, 0.0011133115040138364, -0.023172710090875626, 0.0015277786878868937, -0.03945579752326012, 0.031830962747335434, -0.014880144968628883, 0.0027100183069705963, -0.029465224593877792, -0.06572777032852173, -0.015785006806254387, 0.017427818849682808, -0.0016272070351988077, -0.01480912510305643, 0.021016020327806473, -0.049689363688230515, -0.04399506375193596, 0.006865456234663725, -0.05094429478049278, 0.012720471248030663, -0.08592435717582703, 0.05612812936306, 0.046474892646074295, -0.029890064150094986, -0.025612089782953262, 0.004707575775682926, 0.04029381647706032, -0.004432412795722485, 0.002595692640170455, 0.06604022532701492, -0.022060062736272812, -0.021063383668661118, 0.033504992723464966, -0.03029676154255867, 0.02870803140103817, -0.0262642502784729, 0.004046074114739895, 0.010878168046474457, 0.025428535416722298, 0.029739784076809883, 0.015005071647465229, 0.01604214310646057, -0.02856985479593277, -0.008777857758104801, -0.0076767439022660255, -0.0401972159743309, -0.010481373406946659, 0.016875935718417168, 0.0214568879455328, -0.012475856579840183, 0.06077323108911514, -0.07271283119916916, -0.009444374591112137, 0.06035809591412544, 0.012676289305090904, -0.015616574324667454, -0.005196736194193363, 0.02466566115617752, -0.021535521373152733, -0.06534112244844437, 0.002563328016549349, 0.0059632789343595505, 0.025335703045129776, 0.053552839905023575, -0.09479012340307236, 0.06707576662302017, -0.00021469328203238547, 0.05775359272956848, -0.016218995675444603, 0.00641136197373271, -0.025081301108002663, -0.031399648636579514, -0.006323989015072584, -0.038219038397073746, -0.006795966997742653, -0.0020247655920684338, 0.027069009840488434, 0.03766698017716408, -0.08177348971366882, 0.06413274258375168, 0.034511465579271317, -0.009578638710081577, 0.006678677164018154, -0.05225829407572746, 0.08426430821418762, 0.015841124579310417, -0.02041456289589405, 0.015047222375869751, -0.02044564113020897, 0.02351493015885353, 0.016247307881712914, 0.028651602566242218, -0.03130001202225685, 0.015590177848935127, -0.039415620267391205, 0.02142006903886795, -0.07812774181365967, 0.03821615129709244, 0.03914352133870125, 0.023553699254989624, -0.016112178564071655, -0.006555850617587566, -0.026211678981781006, -0.060388192534446716, -0.058961376547813416, -0.008734047412872314, 0.017457755282521248, -0.002222620416432619, 0.009705103002488613, 0.054085757583379745, 0.03474058210849762, -0.004109487868845463, -0.016837334260344505, 0.019716812297701836, 0.03758072108030319, 0.03107575513422489, -0.0023599197156727314, -0.014926241710782051, -0.02726205810904503, -0.006881509907543659, 0.024158582091331482, -0.006267128977924585, 0.030543899163603783, 0.0251237154006958, -0.015941614285111427, -0.009891205467283726, -0.06255663931369781, -0.04636946693062782, -0.005729444790631533, 0.0019290121272206306, 0.05222911387681961, 0.01746627874672413, -0.011239280924201012, -0.013974800705909729, 0.013462834060192108, -0.01714915782213211, -0.05352899804711342, -0.022596625611186028, 0.0029040921945124865, -0.051505040377378464, 0.013984095305204391, 0.007548786699771881, 0.029051821678876877, 0.01735943742096424, -0.016109872609376907, 0.001688636839389801, 0.001200303784571588, -0.018495315685868263, -0.039607446640729904, 0.0058245062828063965, 0.0022871324326843023, -0.07473242282867432, 0.03959585353732109, -0.03736137971282005, -0.023208914324641228, 0.030954591929912567, -0.03397335857152939, -0.031343623995780945, -0.05521976575255394, 0.029347872361540794, 0.04565282166004181, -0.08006387203931808, -0.014860098250210285, 0.014701029285788536, 0.011046811006963253, 0.0789385512471199, 0.008548329584300518, -0.0316477045416832, 0.026945125311613083, -0.0025596823543310165, -0.004848734475672245, 0.009711586870253086, -0.016985466703772545, -0.010698438622057438, -0.027988051995635033, -0.03843161091208458, -0.014137977734208107, -0.00906884204596281, -0.027413474395871162, 0.01127713918685913, -0.06328675150871277, 0.05402950942516327, -0.013264759443700314, -0.0021216010209172964, 0.0019739896524697542, -0.04024672508239746, -0.08569429069757462, 0.0810920000076294, -0.04512644559144974, 0.01711435429751873, 0.041234340518713, -0.07080447673797607, -0.055604737251996994, 0.030493732541799545, -0.02992890030145645, -0.013603735715150833, 0.021175913512706757, -0.03015059605240822, -0.03144367039203644, -0.013374991714954376, 0.020359238609671593, 0.005126107484102249, -0.05486850440502167, 0.00735140684992075, -0.01755405031144619, 0.09164657443761826, 0.00451553612947464, -0.022443898022174835, 0.001961223315447569, 0.010978818871080875, -0.010997684672474861, 0.026517577469348907, -0.012005130760371685, 0.00652732141315937, -0.030590137466788292, -0.021263709291815758, -0.027176402509212494, 0.0636519268155098, -0.02708783932030201, 0.03990092873573303, 0.0013537666527554393, 0.03545905649662018, -0.002078407444059849, 0.04416866600513458, 0.014278987422585487, -0.007418936118483543, -0.03674051910638809, -0.000737264403142035, 0.004534803796559572, -0.042126089334487915, 0.04877343401312828, 0.017778722569346428, 0.007597317453473806, -0.039168279618024826, -0.01893461123108864, -0.017346210777759552, 0.031813111156225204, -0.02877708151936531, -0.005035859066992998, -0.01693781092762947, -0.05463577061891556, -0.02807364985346794, -0.07346188277006149, 0.06894386559724808, 0.0675542801618576, -0.0719730481505394, 0.025215446949005127, -0.030832402408123016, -0.022350119426846504, 0.024897320196032524, 0.030822191387414932, 0.04241460934281349, 0.03339989855885506, -0.01331871934235096, -0.012904515489935875, 0.006108724046498537, -0.01930808275938034, 0.056384459137916565, 0.033606961369514465, -0.033767666667699814, 0.0205589160323143, -0.0005061846459284425, 0.05628021061420441, 0.003769424743950367, 0.06007339060306549, 0.04170619323849678, 0.00709561537951231, -0.009886042214930058, 0.05741145834326744, -0.03903372585773468, -0.007300942204892635, 0.01655627228319645, -0.012361224740743637, 0.029081402346491814, 0.012979689985513687, -0.04577924311161041, -0.013632949441671371, 0.00830282736569643, 0.014040736481547356, -0.012424023821949959, 0.012746958993375301, -0.002776471897959709, 0.010555357672274113, 0.022925877943634987, -0.09521224349737167, 0.02442821115255356, 0.02388007566332817, 0.01901315338909626, 0.02211543545126915, -0.03231493756175041, 0.04038562998175621, -0.04413360357284546, 0.02139640599489212, 0.029542962089180946, 0.022400187328457832, -0.050202690064907074, -0.011495192535221577, -0.006606266368180513, -0.05294656381011009, -0.0402698889374733, 0.05660700798034668, 0.058167144656181335, 0.021686650812625885, -0.006856072694063187, 0.008549592457711697, 0.10047437995672226, 0.008349645882844925, -0.015401524491608143, -0.009416431188583374, -0.016406280919909477, 0.01844562403857708, 0.0190834179520607, -0.0061779264360666275, -0.023989731445908546, -0.005515706725418568, -0.05999131500720978, 0.02046123705804348, 0.08858766406774521, 0.036006033420562744, 0.027375245466828346, 0.06588359922170639, 0.00938987173140049, -0.0041465540416538715, 0.01781371235847473, -0.01815064251422882, 0.025281138718128204, -0.06367164850234985, 0.003802548861131072, -0.05710305646061897, 0.05800601467490196, 0.03738604485988617, 0.05910392105579376, -0.02110864408314228, 0.04786904528737068, -0.005366177763789892, 0.023050177842378616, 0.012157010845839977, -0.0042908890172839165, -0.011874817311763763, -0.0013738744892179966, -0.06285601109266281, 0.012757659889757633, -0.0947568267583847, 0.03186182677745819, 0.014560870826244354, 0.014062629081308842, 0.03917442634701729, -0.002402897458523512, -0.07524595409631729, 0.041934363543987274, 0.04368850588798523, 0.03023415245115757, 0.0069158682599663734, 0.029338257387280464, 0.01465590763837099, -0.00922660157084465, -0.052178751677274704, -0.03600958362221718, 0.004563468508422375, -0.06423142552375793, -0.0046235364861786366, -0.007468965370208025, -0.0044526634737849236, 0.049551744014024734, 0.016262758523225784, 0.04594438523054123, -0.028497355058789253, 0.006306767929345369, 0.004659522324800491, 0.004693697206676006, 0.030335383489727974, 0.011488201096653938, -0.05037997290492058, -0.01637984625995159, -0.004275455605238676, 0.015223422087728977, -0.04189148172736168, -0.04332466796040535, 0.036691997200250626, 0.025069795548915863, 0.04375363141298294, -0.01111986767500639, 0.031280290335416794, -0.01519780233502388, 0.005840816535055637, -0.010733365081250668, -0.07190241664648056, 0.012896496802568436, -0.009414448402822018, -0.0036596429999917746, 0.06109495460987091, 0.03482896834611893, -0.012238755822181702, 0.0012239094357937574, -0.0069478536024689674, 0.051584213972091675, 0.035663798451423645, 0.00813822727650404, -0.00003776317316805944, 0.021119557321071625, 0.022760624065995216, -0.05188114568591118, -0.01245082262903452, -0.060771554708480835, 0.0105252955108881, -0.0031442889012396336, -0.033972278237342834, 0.014673887751996517, 0.006220028270035982, 0.04175756126642227, 0.006318707950413227, 0.05735374614596367, 0.07557623088359833, 0.04059857502579689, 0.03952346369624138, -0.08311468362808228, -0.015119625255465508, -0.03658953309059143, -0.06738103926181793, -0.0007201338303275406, -0.037959981709718704, -0.057102978229522705, -0.07409711182117462, 0.03713422268629074, -0.018757589161396027, 0.0017579321283847094, -0.070536769926548, -0.028686944395303726, 0.015408223494887352, -0.029996532946825027, -0.039598625153303146, -0.05452713370323181, 0.014854304492473602, -0.02594926953315735, 0.03631821647286415, 0.07504972070455551, 0.014001736417412758, 0.027720369398593903, 0.02648208849132061, 0.034069500863552094, 0.044820383191108704, -0.06272086501121521, 0.0005223813932389021, 0.008105272427201271, 0.04104025661945343, 0.02147804945707321, 0.0010063175577670336, -0.03674662485718727, -0.017117397859692574, 0.14466454088687897, 0.000652005837764591, -0.00005955849701422267, 0.027209067717194557, 0.017249835655093193, 0.027056297287344933, -0.021054988726973534, -0.028881289064884186, 0.020455902442336082, -0.007543952204287052, -0.021722599864006042, 0.04661061242222786, 0.043211840093135834, 0.01913866028189659, 0.06852412223815918, 0.025474674999713898, -0.03446004539728165, -0.04694047197699547, 0.03136541321873665, 0.0024625256191939116, 0.052161805331707, 0.007338979281485081, -0.03992254659533501, -0.06872649490833282, -0.018368350341916084, 0.010834407992661, 0.014484483748674393, 0.03337728977203369, 0.001994999824091792, -0.051126737147569656, -0.012993058189749718, -0.01966669037938118, -0.043713342398405075, -0.013996402733027935, 0.052775923162698746, 0.02285068668425083, 0.008441668003797531, -0.041562940925359726, -0.005020799580961466, 0.07503233104944229, -0.02013253979384899, 0.014797189272940159, 0.018941054120659828, -0.02843293361365795, 0.04814576730132103, -0.0650043860077858, 0.02148604765534401, -0.01614944264292717, 0.002546042436733842, -0.006852987688034773, 0.01378920953720808, -0.012397374026477337, 0.029276316985487938, -0.022509923204779625, 0.028827307745814323, -0.01819155365228653, -0.01569342613220215, 0.055850010365247726, -0.01464519090950489, -0.055787425488233566, -0.01148002129048109, -0.0024803460109978914, 0.08719327300786972, -0.05190125107765198, 0.07616042345762253, -0.03227178007364273, -0.004651362542062998, -0.01950412429869175, -0.014777010306715965, -0.00958091951906681, -0.0782230868935585, -0.04042603820562363, -0.0460263267159462, -0.04490424692630768, -0.03638572618365288, -0.0656813383102417, -0.0011460379464551806, 0.023046519607305527, -0.022527510300278664, 0.02293919026851654, 0.02042057365179062, 0.04063402861356735, 0.08138920366764069, -0.023621825501322746, -0.04738590121269226, 0.01870916411280632, -0.00430285232141614, -0.025184499099850655, -0.054134417325258255, 0.020207488909363747, -0.02578710950911045, -0.012430453673005104, -0.04054439812898636, -0.05378906801342964, -0.027197180315852165, 0.052837811410427094, -0.0026212160009890795, 0.03274477645754814, 0.008349584415555, 0.061533600091934204, 0.0001857654715422541, -0.07559780776500702, 0.053397491574287415, 0.0014011247549206018, 0.03921772167086601, -0.016837920993566513, 0.010130937211215496, 0.007474285550415516, -0.012122089974582195, -0.06453019380569458, 0.021520594134926796, -0.024612588807940483, 0.02357993647456169, 0.049927741289138794, -0.03399258479475975, 0.006430519744753838, -0.006400130223482847, -0.06586660444736481, 0.012280651368200779, -0.015543225221335888, 0.01678851805627346, -0.0012841459829360247, 0.006141056306660175, 0.07216431200504303, -0.012703162617981434, -0.009920609183609486, -0.051166314631700516, -0.004565070383250713, -0.05363041162490845, -0.033752650022506714, -0.02356484904885292, 0.027538591995835304, -0.0558604821562767, 0.017735440284013748, 0.00573136517778039, 0.009805827401578426, -0.04299132525920868, -0.035032909363508224, 0.09073009341955185, 0.01793522760272026, -0.01261281967163086, -0.05356767028570175, 0.05628282204270363, -0.03910015895962715, -0.0038482006639242172, -0.02561608888208866, -0.002969393040984869, 0.024544524028897285, 0.08653654903173447, 0.005280218552798033, 0.003881216049194336, -0.026472242549061775, 0.012606309726834297, 0.016830286011099815, 0.024687908589839935, -0.04072728753089905, -0.03401194512844086, -0.06014666706323624, 0.02175230346620083, -0.033719614148139954, -0.010427958332002163, -0.013715730980038643, -0.018183881416916847, -0.03918782249093056, 0.0314222015440464, -0.043525803834199905, 0.004932538140565157, -0.0000698042640578933, 0.00693410262465477, -0.02316134236752987, 0.04404335096478462, -0.04790439084172249, -0.010322877205908298, 0.008424597792327404, 0.016439661383628845, -0.002435162663459778, 0.058152079582214355, -0.052827488631010056, -0.0024868056643754244, -0.04387269169092178, 0.02335890755057335, 0.0004218367685098201, -0.01485428586602211, 0.03390894830226898, 0.05342801287770271, 0.04616554081439972, -0.018317269161343575, 0.002436720533296466, 0.006616240832954645, 0.002510684309527278, -0.04641946777701378, 0.000797718355897814, -0.0027701144572347403, 0.016422566026449203, -0.058469727635383606, -0.041775308549404144, 0.0053310273215174675, 0.025464367121458054, 0.002024292480200529, 0.00018291495507583022, -0.05964331328868866, 0.03166790306568146, -0.018070343881845474, -0.03446516767144203, -0.008351203985512257, 0.04513700678944588, 0.018854286521673203, 0.0013198725646361709, 0.00309263844974339, -0.07343356311321259, 0.06319183111190796, 0.0405740812420845, -0.003993534948676825, -0.010931839235126972, 0.0049515035934746265, -0.0023075551725924015, 0.031102918088436127, -0.021482231095433235, 0.0020583306904882193, -0.009892233647406101, -0.029247229918837547, -0.0169259961694479, -0.044881295412778854, 0.01246857549995184, -0.0026369078550487757 ]
<p>This question is more about trying to feel the waters in our current abilities to compute (or roughly estimate) the refraction index of vacuum, specifically when high numbers of electromagnetic quanta of a given frequency $\omega$ occupy a spherical symmetric incoming wavefront modes $$\frac{e^{i k r}}{r^2}$$</p> <p>I'm interested in intensities above the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schwinger_limit" rel="nofollow">Schwinger limit</a>. Do exist analytical or lattice QED estimates?</p> <p><strong>Why this is interesting?</strong></p> <p>Usually i try to make my questions as self-contained as possible, but i believe it might be interesting to others why i'm interested in nonlinear vacuum refraction indices, so here it goes:</p> <p>Let's review what classical theory says about our ability to create micro black holes with electromagnetic radiation. Our sun produces about $10^{26}$ watts of power, so in principle in the future we could harness all that power. The question trying to be answered here is: is the energy output from Sol enough for a sufficiently technically advanced humanity to create micro black holes?</p> <p>Let's suppose we focus a spherically symmetric beam of light in a single focal point with the purpose of condense enough energy to create a black hole, well, the Schwarzchild radius of a given flow of energy is</p> <p>$$ R = \frac{ G E }{c^4}$$</p> <p>substituing constants,</p> <p>$$ R = 10^{-45} E $$</p> <p>Now, since this energy propagates electromagnetically as radiation, it needs to stay long enough inside the critical radius so that the black hole forms. If the (radial) refractive index inside a small enough region is $n$, then the light will stay inside the radius a time $T$</p> <p>$$ R = \frac{cT}{n}$$</p> <p>equating both terms we are left with an expression for the power that needs to be delivered in a spherical region in order to create a black hole</p> <p>$$ \frac{cT}{n} = 10^{-45} E $$</p> <p>$$ \frac{10^{53}}{n} = \frac{E}{T} = P $$ </p> <p>So, assuming a refractive index of vacuum of 1, it means that we require $10^{53}$ watts focused in a spherical region in order to create a black hole. This is $10^{27}$ more power than what would be available for a humanity that managed to create a Dyson shell around our sun!</p> <p>But if the refractive index could be managed to be above $10^{30}$ before reaching the focus region, then that future humanity would have a chance to create such micro black holes</p> <p>Even a less generous increase of the refractive index could be useful, if they could store the energy of the sun for a few years and then zapping it into an extremely brief $10^{-20}$ wide pulse, in a similar fashion as to how the National Ignition Facility achieves 500 TeraWatt pulses (by chirp-pulse compression)</p>
g4078
[ -0.03366488218307495, 0.023627450689673424, -0.0016361300367861986, -0.003754913806915283, -0.009311209432780743, 0.019471704959869385, 0.004661217797547579, -0.024598857387900352, -0.008979301899671555, 0.0016147221904248, 0.03439817950129509, 0.08355827629566193, 0.016114836558699608, 0.043269649147987366, -0.01130420807749033, 0.014773265458643436, 0.03627791628241539, -0.01408461295068264, 0.0005066209705546498, -0.014438320882618427, 0.007013455964624882, -0.01934363879263401, -0.04026683419942856, -0.059483855962753296, -0.02473442070186138, 0.05374343693256378, 0.07367341220378876, 0.010072711855173111, -0.05362857133150101, -0.04034898057579994, 0.0152306342497468, -0.019019125029444695, 0.018788360059261322, -0.005875216331332922, 0.01788339950144291, -0.010742146521806717, 0.01054055243730545, -0.007036710157990456, 0.01593714766204357, 0.006170825567096472, -0.008988967165350914, -0.05281911417841911, -0.03895501047372818, 0.041300758719444275, -0.029155166819691658, 0.006845258176326752, 0.027450798079371452, 0.007458336651325226, 0.05802019312977791, -0.025742266327142715, 0.007468958850950003, 0.0017660984303802252, 0.08758989721536636, -0.010997620411217213, 0.02009301446378231, 0.04123513028025627, -0.06551124155521393, -0.017275871708989143, 0.049634773284196854, 0.043107517063617706, -0.025361986830830574, 0.019303372129797935, 0.0349012091755867, 0.0014751380076631904, 0.06374521553516388, 0.012646895833313465, -0.05889522656798363, -0.011279232800006866, -0.040338385850191116, -0.04017253592610359, -0.020608054473996162, -0.046659667044878006, -0.0680966004729271, 0.06423810869455338, -0.0401013121008873, 0.06216230243444443, -0.033426523208618164, 0.019255420193076134, -0.013994424603879452, 0.0027422632556408644, -0.0072339377366006374, -0.0734715387225151, -0.0341900996863842, -0.03779671713709831, 0.05371354892849922, -0.04173434153199196, 0.010556443594396114, -0.031303949654102325, 0.0252041295170784, 0.01518934965133667, 0.06055288761854172, 0.008172045461833477, 0.010543249547481537, 0.021529218181967735, 0.07914474606513977, 0.04335687309503555, -0.001149828196503222, -0.0017955388175323606, -0.04119511693716049, 0.01167510449886322, -0.04402155056595802, 0.02109169401228428, 0.02091209962964058, -0.031048709526658058, 0.025953814387321472, -0.0010537540074437857, -0.004137483425438404, -0.03075282648205757, 0.01719512976706028, 0.0202056635171175, -0.019656158983707428, -0.058159079402685165, -0.028373705223202705, -0.01842472143471241, -0.11612540483474731, -0.04469311982393265, 0.03813284635543823, -0.04269684478640556, -0.014540106989443302, 0.09699277579784393, -0.004572710487991571, -0.008182569406926632, 0.06988872587680817, 0.005033572670072317, 0.0335591621696949, 0.03991037979722023, -0.035899803042411804, 0.016424044966697693, 0.04080257564783096, 0.012093656696379185, -0.03241909667849541, -0.041608694940805435, -0.03268936276435852, 0.01980394497513771, 0.014098651707172394, 0.0396868959069252, 0.009699086658656597, 0.00569671718403697, -0.0038877399638295174, 0.0030788667500019073, 0.0007419841713272035, 0.004281116649508476, -0.003548147389665246, -0.0026418184861540794, -0.02156241238117218, 0.0024441757705062628, -0.013967733830213547, -0.01354927383363247, 0.019918736070394516, 0.01826770231127739, -0.02095118537545204, 0.10704366862773895, 0.00467193778604269, 0.005045279860496521, -0.016054145991802216, 0.039112601429224014, 0.03286277875304222, -0.04161994904279709, -0.03588737174868584, -0.04500763490796089, 0.08497803658246994, -0.010348187759518623, 0.016548695042729378, 0.04752449691295624, -0.030989758670330048, -0.033576853573322296, -0.0028103780932724476, -0.05956774204969406, 0.0320388600230217, -0.08012285828590393, -0.032017577439546585, 0.0020741939079016447, 0.033656008541584015, 0.015853548422455788, -0.04349333420395851, 0.08923615515232086, 0.053903162479400635, -0.0049720583483576775, -0.037659648805856705, 0.09372039884328842, -0.0170256607234478, -0.06540696322917938, 0.019879313185811043, -0.02143322303891182, -0.0008991950890049338, -0.051810938864946365, 0.01390836387872696, 0.00012261312804184854, 0.03753029555082321, -0.05088278651237488, -0.021075965836644173, 0.026253309100866318, -0.007659445516765118, 0.06327784806489944, 0.0025666048750281334, 0.038101326674222946, 0.016946788877248764, -0.04158942401409149, -0.028700022026896477, 0.04017198458313942, 0.010973382741212845, 0.0420834943652153, 0.06577661633491516, 0.0398833230137825, 0.05737362429499626, 0.03602813929319382, -0.004000804852694273, 0.008012698963284492, 0.05768398195505142, 0.011568227782845497, 0.03781522810459137, -0.01328012254089117, 0.004412359558045864, 0.006928136572241783, -0.021581478416919708, 0.025538453832268715, 0.001325153512880206, 0.002628694288432598, 0.025322407484054565, -0.019950777292251587, -0.05496934428811073, 0.012391499243676662, 0.025122081860899925, 0.020014887675642967, -0.04517710953950882, 0.011265239678323269, -0.05906439945101738, -0.014980881474912167, 0.02455955371260643, 0.02685394324362278, -0.05409500375390053, 0.04900708049535751, 0.0016924310475587845, -0.030852777883410454, -0.014258313924074173, 0.06223036348819733, -0.0336255319416523, -0.047620028257369995, -0.017579464241862297, -0.011270042508840561, 0.0690353736281395, -0.008245253935456276, -0.05160064250230789, -0.01030951738357544, -0.040721409022808075, -0.02539101429283619, 0.003546371590346098, 0.0009935719426721334, 0.004025723785161972, 0.019923770800232887, 0.02727331966161728, -0.02264401502907276, 0.0031557364854961634, -0.00031581419170834124, -0.06085558608174324, -0.0012545065255835652, 0.020768817514181137, 0.11770664900541306, -0.08121146261692047, -0.07239940762519836, -0.012579704634845257, 0.00345692434348166, -0.007503023371100426, -0.0006237343768589199, -0.010538680478930473, 0.02531498670578003, -0.06117008998990059, 0.030414704233407974, 0.02515416219830513, 0.028882170096039772, 0.0011329842964187264, 0.045399509370326996, 0.049343157559633255, -0.00674446253105998, 0.032684650272130966, -0.023652520030736923, -0.014971365220844746, 0.020523061975836754, 0.08389873802661896, -0.03693766891956329, -0.07863888889551163, -0.06413579732179642, -0.0551643930375576, -0.0080943638458848, -0.04858173429965973, -0.05259442701935768, 0.013170365244150162, 0.04062969982624054, 0.010211129672825336, -0.01615014486014843, -0.009485071524977684, 0.022283248603343964, 0.016899650916457176, 0.02105305716395378, -0.039937857538461685, 0.031420279294252396, 0.03739022836089134, -0.011715259402990341, 0.005326414480805397, 0.03697396069765091, 0.03201201185584068, -0.05743512138724327, -0.02692636474967003, -0.04056365042924881, -0.012511419132351875, 0.0033351636957377195, -0.027464227750897408, -0.03693907707929611, 0.024218421429395676, -0.01084670890122652, 0.032686781138181686, 0.030235430225729942, 0.021588606759905815, 0.03495383635163307, -0.03370688483119011, 0.021519456058740616, 0.007908394560217857, -0.012760719284415245, 0.000991371925920248, -0.03101111575961113, 0.03231831640005112, -0.011754258535802364, 0.0001915808388730511, -0.03808767721056938, 0.007494996301829815, 0.00897166132926941, -0.018231747671961784, -0.016245616599917412, -0.04003654047846794, -0.0020394506864249706, 0.008714147843420506, -0.03434968367218971, 0.0001917870540637523, 0.04509275034070015, -0.0398351214826107, -0.0061345635913312435, -0.07419499009847641, -0.0007877438329160213, 0.05903596803545952, 0.03857973590493202, -0.01813173107802868, -0.030731700360774994, -0.021104665473103523, -0.013482099398970604, -0.00707221357151866, 0.023856228217482567, -0.02415849268436432, -0.02080237865447998, -0.03221001848578453, -0.010964549146592617, 0.04595232382416725, -0.03644564747810364, 0.001907726633362472, -0.003680908353999257, -0.016529329121112823, 0.048977117985486984, 0.048590682446956635, 0.04528845474123955, 0.0770694687962532, -0.05600268021225929, -0.013909153640270233, -0.01621994376182556, 0.03149330988526344, -0.048494305461645126, -0.0009732189355418086, -0.009748909622430801, 0.005839494522660971, 0.0185681264847517, -0.06412301957607269, 0.014811353757977486, -0.001319465576671064, -0.011401261202991009, 0.009250652976334095, 0.03191016614437103, -0.04123460873961449, -0.04384668171405792, 0.021398112177848816, -0.0014105797745287418, 0.007153855636715889, 0.04508424922823906, -0.028726227581501007, 0.024764420464634895, 0.026150908321142197, -0.028972584754228592, -0.07708366215229034, -0.014969664625823498, -0.027654055505990982, -0.05700547993183136, 0.011243801563978195, -0.08378582447767258, -0.02134915255010128, -0.060486726462841034, -0.024042978882789612, -0.01387114729732275, -0.027072830125689507, -0.025967206805944443, 0.025691736489534378, -0.03345324099063873, 0.005935688968747854, 0.046517979353666306, 0.06763486564159393, 0.013175874948501587, 0.06264325231313705, 0.007197417318820953, 0.011307361535727978, -0.017003072425723076, 0.030999496579170227, 0.02624567784368992, -0.03816242143511772, -0.04621197655797005, 0.045584745705127716, -0.004820842761546373, 0.024944646283984184, -0.10189071297645569, 0.06375270336866379, 0.02517717145383358, -0.014124375768005848, -0.07390940189361572, 0.02846643514931202, 0.024783805012702942, 0.017171569168567657, -0.03666726127266884, 0.01427484955638647, 0.006525514181703329, -0.005711171310395002, 0.01748577691614628, 0.01997295394539833, -0.04886343702673912, -0.022802306339144707, -0.010136940516531467, 0.05345284566283226, 0.04754454642534256, -0.043159909546375275, -0.004781506955623627, 0.03997983783483505, 0.026351695880293846, -0.04818876460194588, 0.015096619725227356, 0.009792525321245193, 0.06538937240839005, 0.06621276587247849, -0.03836794197559357, 0.030176401138305664, 0.009317884221673012, 0.00561554916203022, 0.05732028931379318, -0.03805084899067879, -0.01766233704984188, -0.046429943293333054, 0.06814734637737274, 0.006459107156842947, -0.040024496614933014, 0.018248096108436584, -0.05934878811240196, -0.058678481727838516, -0.02805287577211857, -0.09855590015649796, 0.025827236473560333, 0.0705978199839592, 0.029610732570290565, -0.04222327470779419, 0.05779225006699562, 0.0026177631225436926, 0.013111701235175133, 0.062171775847673416, -0.01538146287202835, -0.03907562792301178, -0.02380453795194626, -0.05092400684952736, -0.013610447756946087, 0.014300288632512093, 0.015055599622428417, 0.03289476037025452, -0.035422611981630325, -0.022900888696312904, -0.0030089733190834522, -0.028720427304506302, -0.066134013235569, -0.04282783716917038, -0.020646141842007637, -0.030766645446419716, 0.01840405911207199, 0.03478420898318291, 0.03525112569332123, -0.0003518987214192748, 0.027673397213220596, -0.05705418437719345, 0.03868842124938965, -0.05946223810315132, -0.005829250905662775, -0.009322783909738064, 0.024115970358252525, 0.013874921016395092, -0.04367825761437416, -0.03659496083855629, 0.016756730154156685, 0.05002865195274353, -0.0591224767267704, 0.022040080279111862, 0.03367769345641136, -0.003982190974056721, -0.009103812277317047, -0.04994984716176987, -0.039427295327186584, -0.012834166176617146, -0.0016974456375464797, 0.06597468256950378, -0.021413305774331093, 0.09048650413751602, 0.05656146630644798, -0.010949605144560337, -0.00431901914998889, 0.007314251270145178, -0.00416288897395134, 0.057818688452243805, -0.03815740346908569, -0.009430051781237125, 0.022236062213778496, -0.03295387700200081, -0.03361186385154724, 0.06601016968488693, -0.010718054138123989, 0.055596426129341125, 0.04157008230686188, 0.016745038330554962, 0.00004203881326247938, -0.05527854338288307, -0.022200729697942734, 0.034416306763887405, 0.006848598830401897, 0.03894122317433357, 0.009366706945002079, 0.016452541574835777, -0.018144870176911354, 0.07013480365276337, 0.01761096715927124, 0.04844925180077553, -0.00408167252317071, 0.03561953082680702, -0.016160892322659492, -0.04006902500987053, 0.023002495989203453, 0.016002845019102097, 0.03871573135256767, 0.007926743477582932, 0.010055004619061947, -0.015176312997937202, 0.010245946235954762, -0.012299696914851665, -0.0038447449915111065, -0.033690743148326874, 0.0028580166399478912, 0.018812013790011406, 0.010439123027026653, -0.03255583718419075, 0.022863829508423805, -0.007081465795636177, -0.04961276426911354, -0.04738412797451019, -0.032775696367025375, 0.04740717262029648, 0.01358459796756506, 0.014661790803074837, 0.004179764073342085, -0.006749180145561695, -0.04620303586125374, 0.01793700084090233, -0.04852322116494179, 0.02639288455247879, 0.008436247706413269, -0.05657727271318436, 0.003629663959145546, -0.0013231183402240276, 0.0122208958491683, 0.060112833976745605, -0.020858775824308395, 0.027417592704296112, 0.0292570311576128, 0.005897935945540667, -0.007926072925329208, 0.030185405164957047, 0.014146221801638603, 0.08136848360300064, -0.02469252608716488, 0.013213313184678555, 0.02129032090306282, -0.014749695546925068, 0.08542974293231964, -0.010576833039522171, -0.039252374321222305, -0.01648523099720478, 0.02510685846209526, 0.023796439170837402, -0.04935324192047119, -0.013955634087324142, -0.01693582907319069, 0.012372050434350967, -0.043632056564092636, -0.022629903629422188, 0.019430944696068764, 0.013587634079158306, 0.019896328449249268, -0.005775041412562132, 0.002190685598179698, -0.030084218829870224, -0.041025467216968536, -0.040230970829725266, 0.004058557096868753, 0.06860742717981339, 0.04595452547073364, -0.02004936710000038, -0.033474888652563095, -0.023356404155492783, -0.019180744886398315, -0.01589823141694069, -0.05861665681004524, -0.004069483373314142, 0.0001748034992488101, 0.004881985951215029, -0.04779304563999176, 0.02512384206056595, -0.03135006129741669, -0.007050975225865841, -0.07580399513244629, -0.006417570635676384, 0.022806061431765556, -0.02489321492612362, -0.02042200230062008, 0.03332725912332535, 0.04935038462281227, 0.08658825606107712, -0.004933031741529703, -0.0005249058012850583, 0.05114629864692688, 0.01725265197455883, 0.0428849421441555, -0.05885627120733261, 0.01469489373266697, -0.05651243403553963, -0.017131678760051727, 0.0020716863218694925, -0.002253928454592824, 0.0015178185421973467, 0.011424205265939236, -0.010006213560700417, 0.011205491609871387, 0.035565197467803955, 0.05116445943713188, -0.03702016547322273, 0.004251907113939524, 0.025321781635284424, -0.10135198384523392, -0.061591874808073044, -0.02902499958872795, -0.05426411330699921, 0.0317440927028656, -0.06402544677257538, 0.012849859893321991, 0.006593846250325441, -0.038593780249357224, 0.05271170660853386, 0.015214618295431137, 0.021047063171863556, -0.02603684552013874, -0.007365410681813955, 0.04960213229060173, 0.01231573335826397, -0.054718319326639175, 0.009680749848484993, -0.011841447092592716, 0.06584392488002777, -0.01430539507418871, -0.021611137315630913, -0.05315963923931122, -0.07280216366052628, -0.016277501359581947, -0.03369671851396561, 0.057565610855817795, 0.031551480293273926, 0.029112301766872406, -0.00041798443999141455, -0.027760127559304237, 0.009206152521073818, -0.009431264363229275, -0.028109127655625343, 0.015826217830181122, -0.08248759806156158, 0.019995512440800667, 0.06647023558616638, 0.019731968641281128, -0.020174173638224602, -0.0064912899397313595, 0.004573265556246042, 0.009059245698153973, 0.005534217227250338, 0.009090897627174854, 0.03493380546569824, 0.007603209000080824, 0.054156918078660965, -0.002215366344898939, -0.012622155249118805, 0.004578924272209406, 0.03519595414400101, -0.012254162691533566, -0.007990438491106033, 0.024720339104533195, -0.01389189064502716, -0.030164211988449097, 0.003100265981629491, 0.05644180253148079, 0.05789110064506531, 0.017895301803946495, -0.025937551632523537, 0.04802799969911575, 0.02522178180515766, 0.014631789177656174, -0.08168930560350418, 0.031463783234357834, 0.033204324543476105, -0.022164104506373405, -0.05194946750998497, -0.017648845911026, 0.014975269325077534, -0.04128260537981987, 0.003874856745824218, -0.07076019048690796, 0.02728998102247715, -0.030586184933781624, 0.00251449435018003, -0.00852825678884983, 0.004002541769295931, -0.049165528267621994, -0.06557878106832504, -0.01051983330398798, -0.01654641143977642, -0.007904678583145142, 0.008263498544692993, -0.0002483029675204307, -0.00488739600405097, 0.03755979239940643, 0.024545984342694283, -0.030969807878136635, -0.002406432991847396, -0.06511955708265305, 0.02626674994826317, 0.031366340816020966, -0.07469746470451355, 0.004832211881875992, 0.06177984178066254, -0.015729835256934166, -0.019440418109297752, 0.0033479828853160143, 0.019474981352686882, 0.02129220962524414, 0.07376128435134888, -0.05990699678659439, -0.003516189521178603, 0.002714764326810837, -0.01966850645840168, -0.021813564002513885, 0.031620439141988754, 0.008749633096158504, 0.05207213759422302, -0.013769655488431454, 0.013272859156131744, -0.034240033477544785, 0.052596330642700195, -0.021621255204081535 ]
<p>What is Curie-Weiss temperature? What is the difference between Curie-Weiss temperature and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curie_temperature" rel="nofollow">Curie temperature</a>?</p>
g4079
[ 0.05087454244494438, 0.03461291640996933, -0.023655006662011147, 0.016635358333587646, 0.030484791845083237, -0.015141544863581657, 0.05570276081562042, -0.004511169623583555, -0.04026248678565025, 0.022069105878472328, -0.026984384283423424, 0.030368108302354813, -0.0032779446337372065, -0.0006663179374299943, -0.027142895385622978, -0.006972538772970438, 0.03580891713500023, 0.03703806549310684, 0.026738569140434265, 0.033706244081258774, 0.026447942480444908, -0.014429776929318905, -0.017639167606830597, 0.001245570252649486, -0.030460484325885773, -0.03243941441178322, -0.08246952295303345, -0.011225592344999313, -0.055449649691581726, -0.006255399901419878, 0.004037829115986824, 0.019505929201841354, 0.07120389491319656, 0.023593205958604813, 0.08026786893606186, -0.01199252251535654, -0.0027344399131834507, -0.022060615941882133, 0.01451922208070755, 0.03082728013396263, -0.007692377083003521, 0.05064264312386513, 0.05835188925266266, -0.017238639295101166, -0.017558107152581215, 0.02754269540309906, -0.028577741235494614, -0.01892143487930298, -0.010212437249720097, 0.0518147274851799, 0.016753248870372772, 0.06870509684085846, -0.04092841222882271, 0.031565528362989426, 0.03730015829205513, -0.044212665408849716, 0.020017364993691444, -0.03193490207195282, 0.07091378420591354, 0.001900342758744955, -0.01977989636361599, 0.011501931585371494, -0.06603934615850449, -0.0006253976607695222, 0.009255421347916126, -0.010481749661266804, 0.03752904012799263, 0.0038600307889282703, -0.01638736203312874, -0.040787722915410995, -0.08498045802116394, 0.012260609306395054, -0.07069989293813705, 0.0036878464743494987, -0.017888907343149185, 0.015092955902218819, 0.010117081925272942, -0.05901939421892166, 0.026199227198958397, 0.00580936623737216, 0.001896678120829165, 0.03813624754548073, 0.023090455681085587, 0.017735715955495834, 0.0037567969411611557, -0.021729007363319397, -0.038288407027721405, 0.026657043024897575, 0.030660662800073624, 0.000045530570787377656, 0.03720834106206894, 0.060699887573719025, 0.023388657718896866, 0.02169341780245304, 0.017021333798766136, 0.049990806728601456, 0.03156131133437157, -0.0012876905966550112, 0.03232601284980774, 0.003823310835286975, -0.013028516434133053, 0.006668339483439922, 0.04881386458873749, -0.05699766054749489, 0.02543790452182293, 0.006129662040621042, -0.006720228586345911, -0.026701336726546288, -0.10489758849143982, 0.07339303940534592, -0.041215769946575165, -0.003234783886000514, -0.07095333188772202, -0.013068180531263351, 0.031852222979068756, 0.030295919626951218, -0.015671536326408386, -0.018797190859913826, 0.01780821941792965, 0.03007819503545761, -0.010702509433031082, 0.01686050184071064, 0.0533253438770771, 0.09794746339321136, -0.06708352267742157, 0.0020466982387006283, 0.032081007957458496, -0.024464763700962067, -0.07274572551250458, -0.035130687057971954, -0.028490306809544563, 0.006225131452083588, -0.0011489544995129108, -0.009080735966563225, 0.002904742956161499, -0.01955651119351387, 0.026648137718439102, 0.028546137735247612, -0.0039469050243496895, 0.04610496386885643, -0.012670506723225117, -0.013148925267159939, -0.006613760255277157, -0.027262333780527115, -0.03855295851826668, -0.04053759574890137, 0.004228102043271065, -0.016988219693303108, 0.049962133169174194, 0.030761398375034332, -0.014692317694425583, 0.044690344482660294, 0.020618896931409836, 0.007928901351988316, -0.059510812163352966, -0.031833216547966, 0.016500607132911682, 0.03807184472680092, 0.003138399450108409, 0.005121598951518536, -0.006416965741664171, -0.019387152045965195, 0.02955620177090168, 0.02021552063524723, -0.05982797220349312, 0.0012431446230039, 0.02075451798737049, 0.00791469868272543, -0.028583556413650513, -0.11143945157527924, -0.054232217371463776, 0.005191890522837639, 0.012016081251204014, -0.002227095188573003, -0.009049947373569012, 0.012262286618351936, -0.05194979906082153, 0.06877444684505463, 0.044594187289476395, -0.001906470744870603, -0.012888400815427303, 0.006772022694349289, 0.018434589728713036, -0.030154205858707428, -0.02202712930738926, 0.018265174701809883, 0.002813330153003335, -0.08299867063760757, -0.03799246624112129, 0.04459509253501892, -0.06265885382890701, -0.13815639913082123, -0.030036596581339836, -0.002604146022349596, 0.034160204231739044, 0.0033275247551500797, -0.05098297446966171, -0.009218421764671803, -0.036184798926115036, 0.01677028462290764, -0.038562532514333725, -0.0035817702300846577, 0.011767786927521229, 0.0064375135116279125, -0.011425845324993134, -0.007611758541315794, -0.032932348549366, -0.05574355646967888, -0.005189506337046623, -0.017044899985194206, -0.009054820984601974, -0.037634436041116714, 0.06104408577084541, 0.03539058566093445, -0.02641436830163002, 0.0560409314930439, -0.004553057253360748, -0.004112293478101492, -0.03637193143367767, 0.045072849839925766, -0.023569941520690918, -0.00644201785326004, 0.06503263115882874, -0.03544647619128227, 0.05047045648097992, -0.016117336228489876, 0.030870584771037102, -0.006770187057554722, 0.03183608129620552, 0.019746989011764526, -0.044078513979911804, -0.12626168131828308, -0.07870817929506302, 0.014646405354142189, 0.023690763860940933, 0.044485680758953094, 0.036027442663908005, 0.0061507453210651875, -0.0037438361905515194, 0.12807965278625488, -0.03040183149278164, -0.005897533148527145, -0.004541039001196623, 0.04318913444876671, 0.0014226509956642985, -0.029132680967450142, 0.0056441957131028175, -0.05809662491083145, 0.006903584580868483, -0.015141559764742851, -0.030731216073036194, -0.02805253118276596, 0.015028528869152069, 0.03199703246355057, -0.008877974934875965, 0.016688548028469086, -0.07747505605220795, -0.027211550623178482, -0.02877007983624935, 0.025147367268800735, 0.03650158643722534, -0.021843641996383667, -0.031305402517318726, -0.019489789381623268, -0.010239816270768642, -0.027054563164711, -0.07187388837337494, 0.024439221248030663, -0.08033514767885208, -0.0076002455316483974, 0.014700804837048054, 0.0345732681453228, -0.027638616040349007, -0.03252545744180679, -0.04895796626806259, 0.014789160341024399, 0.047489870339632034, -0.012180756777524948, 0.0018564749043434858, -0.048046667128801346, 0.014544103294610977, -0.023878034204244614, -0.03869207948446274, -0.012624546885490417, -0.0006342582637444139, -0.01979975402355194, -0.05077387019991875, 0.07515644282102585, -0.06161822751164436, -0.030123859643936157, 0.02062356472015381, 0.06178697571158409, 0.029437655583024025, -0.01102594193071127, 0.018985329195857048, -0.02046148292720318, 0.04784981906414032, -0.003896892536431551, -0.01749725639820099, 0.04036780446767807, 0.0035101543180644512, -0.0518537275493145, 0.002718136878684163, 0.004864059388637543, 0.057334545999765396, -0.011567608453333378, 0.015615606680512428, -0.022271255031228065, 0.01647375524044037, 0.00043554368312470615, -0.026019377633929253, -0.022574538365006447, 0.0432453379034996, 0.029057741165161133, 0.028084132820367813, -0.04319952428340912, -0.0321115218102932, 0.013115335255861282, 0.09804058820009232, -0.031087836250662804, -0.014830272644758224, -0.008326449431478977, 0.025232139974832535, -0.029219508171081543, -0.030779382213950157, 0.027433421462774277, 0.040222857147455215, 0.023199230432510376, 0.023831821978092194, -0.043042898178100586, -0.01301631797105074, 0.011235619895160198, -0.03968673571944237, -0.06983501464128494, -0.0012496704002842307, -0.026906386017799377, 0.03584279865026474, 0.012332857586443424, 0.020298566669225693, 0.018776854500174522, 0.03431457281112671, -0.005139243323355913, -0.0004257287073414773, 0.04447125643491745, 0.0011233518598601222, -0.017683813348412514, -0.03238322213292122, 0.07245828956365585, -0.027216969057917595, 0.0012043341994285583, 0.08759235590696335, 0.01638508215546608, 0.05689059942960739, -0.04620581120252609, -0.0011263196356594563, -0.02278216741979122, 0.0011764593655243516, 0.016720300540328026, -0.010439771227538586, 0.004129098728299141, 0.055331919342279434, 0.006755511276423931, -0.020917223766446114, 0.004005224443972111, 0.012590129859745502, 0.01928546652197838, -0.009928712621331215, -0.0023554852232337, 0.008591457270085812, -0.0461525060236454, -0.03571128845214844, -0.04039587080478668, 0.0068261343985795975, 0.020705508068203926, 0.08971194177865982, -0.010529227554798126, 0.003308582352474332, -0.006875411607325077, -0.012288753874599934, -0.008630639873445034, 0.013682200573384762, -0.0008867047727108002, 0.01650226302444935, -0.03846671059727669, 0.006423362530767918, -0.029515424743294716, -0.05308685824275017, -0.021682824939489365, -0.036189496517181396, -0.06722630560398102, 0.012743525207042694, 0.036617521196603775, -0.0006755677750334144, -0.013415642082691193, 0.013928146101534367, 0.023574821650981903, -0.005243759602308273, 0.021082457154989243, -0.04362976923584938, -0.020312270149588585, -0.023233551532030106, -0.03102071024477482, 0.015520672313869, 0.038676489144563675, -0.007929198443889618, -0.02330351434648037, 0.022387878969311714, -0.014636235311627388, -0.0005071013583801687, 0.019602900370955467, -0.018867716193199158, 0.04101208969950676, 0.00280428072437644, -0.04153386875987053, 0.05845503881573677, -0.020927434787154198, 0.011777687817811966, -0.040418725460767746, 0.023784823715686798, 0.0243395883589983, -0.02315615676343441, -0.0008166408515535295, -0.03279394283890724, -0.03802475705742836, -0.013465605676174164, 0.02513435296714306, 0.020910348743200302, 0.04698283225297928, 0.0002038448437815532, -0.03194339573383331, 0.013664198108017445, 0.007577380631119013, -0.05497068911790848, 0.035381533205509186, 0.006600375287234783, 0.0165269635617733, 0.005780316889286041, 0.01692928746342659, 0.03479267284274101, 0.05603726580739021, 0.013317174278199673, 0.03272738680243492, -0.025211794301867485, 0.01826617866754532, -0.028437957167625427, 0.016186540946364403, 0.025667240843176842, -0.006930915638804436, -0.019878970459103584, -0.007096400484442711, 0.006290351506322622, 0.01887592487037182, -0.056304268538951874, -0.00938852597028017, -0.014262635260820389, -0.01945994608104229, 0.0040398258715868, 0.02227434329688549, -0.016158252954483032, 0.047142449766397476, -0.060939300805330276, -0.028817689046263695, -0.009443462826311588, -0.0017033555777743459, 0.010575800202786922, -0.028948619961738586, -0.019801082089543343, -0.04861457273364067, -0.047398556023836136, 0.01561802439391613, -0.011695430614054203, 0.05086495727300644, 0.02342943474650383, 0.041515979915857315, 0.024775562807917595, 0.00011955644004046917, 0.05865189805626869, -0.027732033282518387, -0.002968413522467017, -0.0074610635638237, -0.006143284495919943, 0.040663108229637146, 0.07404664158821106, 0.038131412118673325, 0.03332231193780899, -0.012500734999775887, -0.018510766327381134, 0.03576916083693504, 0.04349807649850845, 0.037053193897008896, 0.022518260404467583, 0.021035974845290184, 0.031069446355104446, -0.013962086290121078, -0.040245406329631805, -0.01868467591702938, 0.0021258790511637926, -0.02298024669289589, 0.01717979833483696, -0.03064461424946785, 0.0030609280802309513, -0.017866341397166252, 0.010820608586072922, 0.027279727160930634, 0.048776283860206604, 0.025296475738286972, 0.07649499177932739, -0.01780998893082142, 0.03215622156858444, -0.03916655108332634, -0.010562136769294739, 0.0033656770829111338, 0.005657471250742674, -0.018396634608507156, 0.010540439747273922, 0.09787368774414062, 0.029789766296744347, 0.03819189593195915, 0.02991846762597561, -0.07535380870103836, -0.010461303405463696, -0.010948371142148972, 0.06275834143161774, 0.01787734031677246, -0.03311578929424286, -0.040236398577690125, 0.05370856821537018, -0.04962657392024994, 0.03292291983962059, 0.01205629762262106, 0.007717942353338003, -0.042487870901823044, 0.08257577568292618, 0.05842799320816994, 0.06997566670179367, -0.04198329523205757, 0.003689746605232358, -0.02211857959628105, 0.0012557078152894974, 0.0183834508061409, -0.0462556928396225, 0.02651621587574482, -0.019815756008028984, 0.005890109576284885, -0.006033324636518955, -0.004710619803518057, -0.016606707125902176, 0.00608389126136899, -0.020969947800040245, 0.023744618520140648, -0.029961293563246727, -0.07403012365102768, 0.048869539052248, -0.08033393323421478, 0.034424953162670135, 0.033657193183898926, 0.015367290936410427, -0.019912108778953552, -0.0492594912648201, 0.015187937766313553, 0.020843293517827988, -0.01681174524128437, 0.04533587396144867, 0.025427022948861122, 0.0033394843339920044, -0.04199319705367088, -0.08952857553958893, -0.009947185404598713, 0.06564304977655411, -0.042973749339580536, -0.0245661623775959, -0.0194654893130064, -0.05770134925842285, -0.08138322830200195, -0.0032150933984667063, 0.0025543714873492718, -0.04951692000031471, 0.004034180194139481, -0.015142365358769894, 0.04348200932145119, -0.033505767583847046, -0.01672440953552723, 0.04730026051402092, 0.0401773527264595, 0.001437495113350451, -0.016048923134803772, -0.019982116296887398, 0.016649411991238594, 0.004305487032979727, 0.04475100338459015, -0.003546440275385976, -0.02215750329196453, -0.036501444876194, 0.027557164430618286, -0.07194742560386658, -0.029669567942619324, -0.0685197040438652, 0.09100715816020966, -0.01382228173315525, -0.02832048572599888, 0.038374897092580795, 0.008523517288267612, 0.07724626362323761, 0.02825779840350151, 0.07992354035377502, 0.060022130608558655, 0.0015522465109825134, 0.010397791862487793, 0.02097301557660103, -0.013051812537014484, -0.02038785256445408, 0.07725534588098526, -0.0355815514922142, -0.05532410368323326, -0.00806852150708437, -0.031993016600608826, -0.04962601512670517, 0.0322711206972599, -0.0352785550057888, 0.04907621070742607, 0.02900676243007183, -0.08530262857675552, -0.04268530383706093, 0.014645879156887531, 0.04722031205892563, 0.04851642996072769, -0.055519942194223404, 0.07652097940444946, 0.009766937233507633, -0.031730975955724716, 0.0031921262852847576, -0.06453907489776611, 0.006636248901486397, 0.029728692024946213, 0.016243111342191696, 0.024057907983660698, -0.07525260746479034, -0.013411139138042927, 0.030155902728438377, 0.04636187106370926, 0.011987189762294292, -0.03707250952720642, 0.07398981600999832, 0.005897887051105499, -0.03347093239426613, -0.004068058915436268, -0.060860924422740936, -0.015535037033259869, -0.011229266412556171, 0.035830773413181305, -0.02576092816889286, -0.044830191880464554, -0.06269511580467224, 0.034933436661958694, -0.0020697747822850943, 0.0079115005210042, -0.009736581705510616, -0.018855633214116096, 0.019504480063915253, -0.007329611573368311, -0.058451179414987564, -0.005503028631210327, 0.034694403409957886, 0.012766076251864433, 0.0013409052044153214, 0.0684596374630928, -0.020649218931794167, -0.053226716816425323, 0.012882407754659653, -0.007788160350173712, -0.015683583915233612, 0.02354137785732746, 0.041370272636413574, -0.025958498939871788, -0.03643913194537163, -0.0019170462619513273, 0.040483854711055756, 0.03244726359844208, -0.02950393036007881, 0.0025430896785110235, -0.008375545963644981, -0.03793163225054741, 0.053532637655735016, -0.03433234244585037, -0.03162028640508652, 0.024627206847071648, -0.028994595631957054, 0.015974190086126328, 0.0730118528008461, 0.013852707110345364, 0.015688050538301468, 0.054438307881355286, -0.031548574566841125, -0.029596833512187004, -0.01444618683308363, -0.0012280081864446402, 0.019939685240387917, 0.0009543035412207246, 0.0173394363373518, 0.0064793541096150875, 0.0383237786591053, 0.023615378886461258, 0.03966415300965309, -0.00033615806023590267, 0.030742397531867027, 0.048715706914663315, 0.0007135444320738316, -0.013883059844374657, -0.009109936654567719, -0.01622234284877777, 0.01738021709024906, 0.03466235101222992, 0.04189217835664749, -0.006771057844161987, 0.0454481765627861, -0.002248352160677314, 0.031052354723215103, -0.06837164610624313, -0.05827433243393898, -0.0397934727370739, -0.00461633550003171, -0.0654536560177803, -0.06043248996138573, 0.007195588666945696, -0.03311878815293312, 0.043178655207157135, 0.010857581160962582, 0.02772936224937439, 0.0033122508320957422, -0.04436060041189194, -0.0625586286187172, 0.00521249882876873, -0.003951039165258408, 0.03476325049996376, -0.044455334544181824, 0.024372899904847145, 0.01714913360774517, 0.024903351441025734, 0.027677807956933975, 0.020858123898506165, 0.04158295318484306, 0.06363571435213089, 0.009394528344273567, -0.033848948776721954, -0.07154114544391632, 0.0072323898784816265, 0.021943766623735428, 0.08267153799533844, 0.03040679357945919, -0.06729183346033096, -0.00939323753118515, 0.005276535637676716, -0.0026623925659805536, 0.000520981615409255, 0.08694856613874435, -0.05177493020892143, -0.031267449259757996, -0.005549541208893061, 0.02469797618687153, -0.012167640961706638, -0.03462820127606392, -0.028186960145831108, 0.03405355289578438, -0.023029059171676636, -0.05111338570713997, 0.00851599220186472, -0.017036383971571922, -0.0494665652513504 ]
<p>This is homework and I need some guidance. The question I struggle with is:</p> <p>Place a particle with $m=2$ , $q=3$ in a constant electric field $\vec{E}=(5,0,0)$ Choose $\vec{r}(0)=(0,0,0)$ and $\vec{v}(0)=(0,0,0)$ and time steps $dt=1*10^{-4}$</p> <p>I've nummerically found a solution using Euler-Cromer method in python and I set the acceleration vector $a=\frac{q\vec{E}}{m}$ Furthermore i must plot the motion in x direction with t, with this solution and in the same plot I must plot the analytic solution of x and t. The problem is what analytic solution. </p> <p><code></p> <p>from pylab import *</p> <p>from mpl_toolkits.mplot3d import Axes3D</p> <p>from mpl_toolkits import *</p> <p>q = 3.0</p> <p>m = 2.0</p> <p>dt = 1e-4</p> <p>t0 = 0</p> <p>t1 = 1 </p> <p>E = array([5.0, 0.0, 0.0])</p> <p>t = linspace(t0, t1,(t1-t0)/dt)</p> <p>n=len(t)</p> <p>r = zeros((n,3))</p> <p>v = zeros((n,3))</p> <p>r[0] = array([0.0, 0.0, 0.0]) </p> <p>v[0] = array([0.0, 0.0, 0.0])</p> <p>a=q*E/m</p> <p>for i in range(len(t)-1):</p> <pre><code>v[i+1] = v[i] + a*dt r[i+1] = r[i] + v[i+1]*dt </code></pre> <p>figure("Exercize 1a og b", figsize=(12,10))</p> <p>plot(t, r[:,0], label="$x_{direction}$")</p> <p>title("Exercize 1a og b")</p> <p>xlabel("time")</p> <p>ylabel("position")</p> <p>legend()</p> <p>E=array([1.0,2.0,-5.0])</p> <p>a=q*E/m</p> <p>for i in range(len(t)-1):</p> <pre><code>v[i+1] = v[i] + a*dt r[i+1] = r[i] + v[i+1]*dt </code></pre> <p>figure("Exercize 1c",figsize=(12,10))</p> <p>plot(t, r[:,0], label="$x_{direction}$")</p> <p>plot(t, r[:,1], label="$y_{direction}$")</p> <p>plot(t, r[:,2], label="$z_{direction}$")</p> <p>title("Exercize 1c")</p> <p>xlabel("time")</p> <p>ylabel("position")</p> <p>legend()</p> <p>show() </code></p> <p>Both velocity ad position can be solved analytic. (And is what the motion is.)</p>
g4080
[ 0.06392902135848999, 0.0224200040102005, 0.004047805909067392, -0.032886311411857605, 0.07276494801044464, -0.03268752619624138, 0.05666236951947212, -0.024302490055561066, -0.06947576254606247, 0.04713139683008194, -0.017716187983751297, 0.039604153484106064, 0.02038581296801567, 0.04446577653288841, -0.02928379736840725, -0.028995009139180183, 0.06003827229142189, -0.033561091870069504, -0.00854522455483675, -0.012292901054024696, 0.020583076402544975, 0.021639356389641762, 0.010337036103010178, -0.02187247946858406, 0.06654036790132523, -0.060820549726486206, 0.04534004628658295, -0.012523132376372814, -0.04832186922430992, -0.013679380528628826, 0.019699689000844955, 0.04322730004787445, 0.016592741012573242, -0.029023898765444756, -0.03254684805870056, -0.06172935664653778, 0.0372837595641613, 0.028748769313097, -0.010438615456223488, 0.002559040207415819, -0.016681229695677757, -0.02410261519253254, 0.09653452783823013, 0.038908615708351135, 0.04053623974323273, -0.048242878168821335, -0.015303287655115128, 0.00012958738079760224, -0.06657242029905319, 0.042017608880996704, -0.022801171988248825, 0.06331434100866318, 0.019687911495566368, -0.0790882483124733, -0.001639782334677875, 0.05404765531420708, -0.023823313415050507, -0.014497127383947372, 0.032579898834228516, 0.033633992075920105, 0.028829190880060196, -0.046003542840480804, 0.036717090755701065, -0.078209288418293, 0.050621822476387024, -0.024757562205195427, -0.07057349383831024, 0.020019426941871643, -0.04816295951604843, -0.039546214044094086, -0.017671192064881325, -0.06213079020380974, 0.0415201410651207, -0.04413491114974022, -0.0632186084985733, -0.038166724145412445, -0.014259355142712593, -0.030825216323137283, 0.005576726980507374, 0.019813140854239464, -0.07170995324850082, 0.04717796668410301, -0.004094933159649372, -0.0005137916887179017, -0.0024507755879312754, -0.038839250802993774, 0.02641293779015541, -0.005302278324961662, -0.026371022686362267, -0.096043661236763, -0.04541042819619179, 0.043732985854148865, 0.010363197885453701, 0.04375694319605827, 0.0003993157297372818, -0.04068256914615631, -0.02862725220620632, 0.07026469707489014, -0.014773217961192131, -0.01789940893650055, -0.008380766026675701, 0.03036414459347725, 0.03261231258511543, 0.016185425221920013, -0.006552509497851133, -0.038775406777858734, 0.0649787113070488, 0.008442719466984272, -0.009545285254716873, -0.00036429669125936925, 0.004843615926802158, -0.07318764179944992, -0.0662468746304512, -0.0716877430677414, -0.028778690844774246, 0.022875720635056496, 0.049690116196870804, -0.01221531629562378, -0.00422811321914196, 0.03775250166654587, 0.03705250099301338, 0.0065688746981322765, 0.04778966307640076, 0.03868846595287323, 0.026242483407258987, 0.02207481861114502, -0.020698754116892815, -0.00955553725361824, 0.006094064097851515, -0.02916383557021618, 0.01859741285443306, -0.02260482870042324, 0.0574282705783844, 0.047687143087387085, -0.05579738691449165, 0.02329244650900364, -0.06477312743663788, 0.008454018272459507, 0.04455684497952461, 0.05143202468752861, -0.010099108330905437, -0.0554458312690258, -0.02482178993523121, -0.009778929874300957, -0.08917616307735443, 0.046000316739082336, -0.006957509554922581, -0.028697215020656586, 0.042360469698905945, 0.014871606603264809, 0.02623794600367546, 0.061811547726392746, -0.04032423719763756, 0.013276336714625359, 0.04407810792326927, 0.022555038332939148, 0.027873210608959198, 0.028237011283636093, 0.022136377170681953, -0.017579685896635056, 0.011568520218133926, 0.01906503364443779, 0.003103620372712612, 0.016565222293138504, -0.05358278751373291, 0.059976641088724136, 0.028010277077555656, -0.03827516362071037, -0.007700825575739145, -0.08699369430541992, -0.019630957394838333, -0.009154667146503925, 0.047620877623558044, 0.016180148348212242, -0.02224174700677395, 0.021593736484646797, -0.03757888823747635, -0.03371686488389969, 0.012577145360410213, -0.000995196052826941, 0.006899546831846237, -0.002965155290439725, -0.005788841750472784, 0.01864502765238285, -0.03035827912390232, 0.002458496019244194, -0.0037100480403751135, 0.017796214669942856, -0.06332945823669434, -0.028365783393383026, 0.014502447098493576, -0.03368097543716431, -0.022149791941046715, 0.023627499118447304, -0.05112549290060997, 0.02230082079768181, 0.018717339262366295, -0.08087951689958572, -0.02903985045850277, -0.024145200848579407, 0.01850263960659504, 0.05801600590348244, 0.043310146778821945, 0.03648267686367035, 0.014130107127130032, -0.03952215239405632, 0.008701243437826633, -0.028018072247505188, 0.010089298710227013, 0.05372641235589981, 0.021048422902822495, 0.027587005868554115, -0.007405776064842939, 0.04127540439367294, -0.004621076863259077, -0.08569568395614624, 0.03353050351142883, -0.013427319936454296, -0.035529252141714096, 0.019901780411601067, -0.01650514267385006, -0.04925629496574402, -0.0008094259537756443, -0.0019064799416810274, -0.019473111256957054, -0.0233389250934124, 0.027676675468683243, -0.008696145378053188, -0.003093607956543565, 0.03716333955526352, -0.08540720492601395, 0.007840911857783794, 0.007933064363896847, -0.010941453278064728, 0.0696195438504219, -0.02542109228670597, -0.0755089819431305, 0.008618616499006748, 0.014279341325163841, 0.02502146176993847, -0.012079011648893356, 0.04940865933895111, 0.026365799829363823, -0.050958938896656036, 0.050710637122392654, -0.020894279703497887, 0.07400519400835037, 0.022696293890476227, 0.007345158141106367, 0.020687445998191833, 0.017398294061422348, 0.019559524953365326, -0.0032792016863822937, 0.0064107864163815975, 0.011747282929718494, -0.02923576906323433, -0.006051705684512854, 0.009753415361046791, 0.052594009786844254, -0.029858773574233055, -0.06707089394330978, 0.04480066895484924, -0.030407149344682693, -0.006854962557554245, -0.03033801168203354, 0.02246747352182865, -0.03489549085497856, -0.0027752199675887823, 0.03010937012732029, -0.019586877897381783, -0.05331161990761757, -0.026269864290952682, 0.006323677022010088, 0.025542166084051132, -0.007873417809605598, -0.006815701723098755, 0.10399185866117477, -0.017840314656496048, 0.006236038636416197, 0.0009033732931129634, 0.036069273948669434, -0.05006711184978485, -0.018018778413534164, 0.01872447319328785, 0.03972526639699936, -0.009882127866148949, 0.008003325201570988, 0.05203506723046303, -0.007063609082251787, -0.016276860609650612, -0.019476771354675293, -0.004386995919048786, 0.05167233198881149, -0.07072840631008148, -0.05297059565782547, 0.06169099733233452, -0.009371161460876465, -0.00770817045122385, 0.05842176452279091, -0.01723121851682663, -0.0022457486484199762, 0.008900091983377934, 0.00718671502545476, 0.017311787232756615, 0.03755700960755348, -0.04335807263851166, 0.005708856508135796, -0.06560257822275162, 0.020684069022536278, 0.023274941369891167, 0.02781364694237709, 0.008118921890854836, -0.015924502164125443, -0.03936246037483215, -0.016850726678967476, 0.003963956143707037, -0.05857793614268303, -0.012521300464868546, 0.07452700287103653, -0.0036831621546298265, -0.02920709177851677, -0.026781994849443436, 0.03589479625225067, 0.007747481111437082, 0.012257681228220463, 0.055700987577438354, 0.03305082023143768, 0.05004381015896797, -0.04088001698255539, -0.025553610175848007, -0.020911583676934242, 0.030675053596496582, 0.04888628050684929, -0.03228360414505005, 0.023303290829062462, -0.0889553427696228, -0.014186783693730831, 0.05435764417052269, -0.011057197116315365, -0.010008621960878372, -0.044765520840883255, -0.05834675580263138, -0.028017442673444748, -0.033478572964668274, 0.008261440321803093, -0.03353263810276985, 0.0013178890803828835, 0.04904880002140999, 0.02052704431116581, -0.011039999313652515, 0.01686888560652733, -0.005705941002815962, -0.022231653332710266, -0.014191512949764729, -0.003877247916534543, -0.034856006503105164, 0.01782374456524849, -0.02181107923388481, 0.007996632717549801, -0.021123405545949936, 0.0018003529403358698, -0.025044478476047516, -0.06224731728434563, 0.036675602197647095, 0.05150000378489494, 0.005588947329670191, -0.04178828373551369, 0.054960962384939194, -0.0141672994941473, 0.020142843946814537, 0.002862026682123542, -0.01503397710621357, 0.01667584292590618, 0.031011683866381645, -0.07101307064294815, -0.01893891766667366, -0.030283082276582718, 0.013468575663864613, -0.06609620153903961, 0.02935085818171501, -0.025408800691366196, 0.025243686512112617, -0.010624933987855911, 0.042839743196964264, 0.032656293362379074, 0.04429648444056511, -0.024198273196816444, 0.028840310871601105, -0.0010574531042948365, -0.0007759616128169, 0.030690873041749, -0.03142867982387543, -0.010293475352227688, 0.015278308652341366, 0.012488683685660362, -0.04205798730254173, 0.06831177324056625, 0.0005360826035030186, -0.08245395123958588, -0.022435767576098442, 0.004424469545483589, -0.05442070588469505, -0.0003826504689641297, 0.03404780104756355, -0.04824142903089523, -0.042753688991069794, 0.004014471545815468, -0.027652682736516, 0.036490362137556076, -0.00931091234087944, -0.007317450363188982, -0.017584338784217834, -0.012125109322369099, -0.031219664961099625, 0.020445939153432846, 0.026093363761901855, 0.022829925641417503, 0.0704764798283577, -0.03760324418544769, 0.022094476968050003, 0.0390254408121109, 0.039344679564237595, 0.0063611953519284725, -0.11736787110567093, 0.02044306881725788, 0.041743963956832886, -0.0057061221450567245, -0.015678808093070984, 0.006926397327333689, 0.012633646838366985, -0.031192732974886894, 0.018146341666579247, -0.03579322621226311, 0.004492300096899271, -0.03741386905312538, 0.03416822850704193, 0.004110161680728197, -0.010341428220272064, 0.05686767026782036, 0.05378648638725281, 0.031349439173936844, -0.03883768245577812, -0.009867748245596886, -0.02966584637761116, -0.05844466760754585, 0.08218560367822647, -0.024664681404829025, -0.03219886124134064, -0.004442933015525341, -0.01925080455839634, 0.020553193986415863, 0.0481487400829792, 0.0018731890013441443, 0.007382614072412252, -0.022613702341914177, 0.016495509073138237, -0.0002061319537460804, -0.04669996351003647, 0.02057528868317604, 0.00826324988156557, -0.00411492632701993, -0.010394817218184471, -0.0483163483440876, -0.04208552837371826, 0.08508799970149994, 0.002476886147633195, -0.04586552083492279, -0.006859061773866415, -0.007049554027616978, -0.03993166238069534, 0.030522126704454422, 0.04231415316462517, 0.02014395035803318, -0.03269128128886223, -0.0035761757753789425, 0.011743833310902119, -0.0007116819615475833, 0.055694349110126495, 0.01044755894690752, -0.03901928663253784, -0.023783491924405098, -0.02628217823803425, 0.001562519115395844, 0.03267362713813782, 0.02274511195719242, -0.06309905648231506, -0.048722002655267715, 0.007417581509798765, 0.04473857581615448, 0.0025286199524998665, 0.0246295016258955, 0.031145308166742325, 0.02244693972170353, -0.02531319670379162, -0.03759514167904854, -0.0596933551132679, -0.02657156065106392, -0.011160305701196194, 0.014923199079930782, 0.024804040789604187, 0.011564656160771847, -0.016747118905186653, -0.08293107897043228, -0.0021754612680524588, -0.05374142527580261, 0.010942310094833374, 0.020305458456277847, 0.04679924249649048, 0.007618975359946489, 0.027085276320576668, 0.016590671613812447, 0.012144754640758038, 0.07200814038515091, -0.006217421963810921, -0.024584606289863586, -0.027456846088171005, 0.005932577420026064, -0.03600572049617767, -0.01605076715350151, -0.044166721403598785, 0.0713295191526413, 0.04452158510684967, -0.00014566605386789888, -0.02207135781645775, 0.06460977345705032, -0.009972414001822472, 0.0027608685195446014, -0.022341229021549225, -0.023614466190338135, 0.03294503316283226, 0.00000894781987881288, -0.013347350060939789, -0.01295185275375843, -0.003086780896410346, -0.018565800040960312, -0.02211325243115425, 0.00792209804058075, -0.06719435006380081, 0.007258125580847263, -0.07748217135667801, -0.012650717049837112, -0.012063849717378616, 0.005273568909615278, 0.00274075660854578, -0.02380557358264923, -0.003763294080272317, 0.007622092962265015, 0.0007430111872963607, 0.07643863558769226, -0.043283022940158844, 0.018614767119288445, 0.0114281065762043, -0.012196955271065235, -0.04106972739100456, -0.011583813466131687, 0.018577726557850838, -0.010347800329327583, -0.013047141022980213, -0.04445035383105278, -0.02278875559568405, 0.004319498315453529, -0.058629363775253296, 0.03186864033341408, 0.011394822970032692, 0.024207232519984245, 0.02548656053841114, 0.018153799697756767, 0.02896837145090103, 0.05221136659383774, 0.0035943801049143076, -0.011974185705184937, -0.006673868279904127, -0.01681949570775032, 0.055971451103687286, 0.05104215070605278, 0.05218014121055603, -0.02786925621330738, -0.01552467979490757, -0.10585421323776245, 0.07669982314109802, 0.028504647314548492, 0.01184927485883236, 0.019162794575095177, 0.010354441590607166, 0.008809499442577362, 0.011410029605031013, -0.02436596341431141, -0.04378264397382736, 0.0069369119592010975, -0.03247126564383507, -0.06246546655893326, 0.0009388192556798458, -0.025278344750404358, 0.010084838606417179, 0.018647819757461548, 0.03948231413960457, 0.0025340698193758726, -0.04669276624917984, 0.0006069905357435346, 0.05080796405673027, 0.00836256518959999, 0.01246927585452795, 0.0031677577644586563, 0.012766465544700623, -0.010115904733538628, -0.010661579668521881, -0.04805217683315277, -0.019923953339457512, 0.0011190464720129967, -0.06574182957410812, -0.009919312782585621, 0.044845592230558395, 0.004616390448063612, 0.06812053173780441, 0.025212537497282028, 0.03741583228111267, 0.027719952166080475, 0.05150096118450165, 0.01910248026251793, -0.005136914551258087, 0.022443119436502457, 0.01645573042333126, -0.027603864669799805, -0.006233287509530783, 0.009002945385873318, -0.018982529640197754, -0.02877199463546276, -0.04385959729552269, 0.07603984326124191, -0.014248008839786053, 0.033545058220624924, -0.01485483255237341, -0.03413454443216324, 0.02391045354306698, -0.016205331310629845, 0.032602205872535706, -0.005087409168481827, 0.08829361945390701, 0.02108166180551052, 0.09245403856039047, -0.02323983423411846, 0.09507919102907181, 0.012072563171386719, -0.03761988505721092, -0.03440428525209427, -0.02728818915784359, 0.013175761327147484, 0.020560160279273987, -0.07527640461921692, -0.0025140736252069473, 0.031006086617708206, -0.02011198364198208, -0.002866729162633419, 0.020971136167645454, 0.02466510236263275, -0.02067801170051098, 0.02403085306286812, 0.041502635926008224, -0.010613416321575642, -0.002523737959563732, -0.023596499115228653, -0.04314661771059036, 0.02204810082912445, 0.031996406614780426, 0.006428936030715704, 0.05093613266944885, -0.0536516048014164, -0.003002703422680497, 0.029709836468100548, -0.034454911947250366, -0.0015277056954801083, -0.008685359731316566, -0.025225719437003136, 0.023390116170048714, 0.03423083573579788, 0.02816838026046753, 0.05873468145728111, 0.04530936852097511, -0.01973157934844494, 0.0037746550515294075, -0.006718069780617952, -0.028940385207533836, -0.03169327229261398, -0.04149872064590454, 0.014399855397641659, -0.03642265126109123, -0.04504922777414322, -0.015402202494442463, -0.0012372995261102915, -0.011413696222007275, 0.025545679032802582, 0.05127723887562752, -0.01691013015806675, -0.040056388825178146, 0.03492269665002823, 0.01850174553692341, -0.05276690796017647, 0.013441569171845913, 0.060029320418834686, 0.012746098451316357, 0.04911132901906967, 0.007705643307417631, 0.018754640594124794, 0.04931776970624924, -0.04172924906015396, -0.023339061066508293, -0.005064987111836672, -0.01894974336028099, 0.0015155092114582658, 0.020421288907527924, -0.03131566569209099, 0.03215479478240013, -0.0006950409733690321, 0.004140427801758051, 0.019698238000273705, 0.05790504068136215, -0.027994783595204353, 0.06049621105194092, 0.05723583325743675, 0.01897062361240387, -0.06387298554182053, 0.025795821100473404, -0.039682187139987946, 0.01848149299621582, 0.06766287237405777, -0.05183899775147438, -0.06759750097990036, 0.013258950784802437, 0.01893341727554798, -0.017873167991638184, 0.019902260974049568, -0.00036463720607571304, -0.0515124648809433, 0.07268637418746948, -0.020649656653404236, -0.01647121086716652, -0.052378926426172256, -0.02596951648592949, -0.02969674952328205, 0.018565641716122627, -0.037973783910274506, -0.059628430753946304, -0.03931310027837753, 0.02295256406068802, 0.020571930333971977, -0.004944919142872095, 0.004518927074968815, 0.03557721897959709, 0.027850374579429626, -0.03526779264211655, 0.0028007952496409416, -0.0060568456538021564, -0.1286374032497406, -0.010947429575026035, 0.06562652438879013, -0.020284542813897133, 0.042842838913202286, 0.043897438794374466, 0.08550162613391876, -0.007861913181841373, -0.025326719507575035, -0.059998586773872375, -0.031203359365463257, 0.0037033562548458576, 0.04530332237482071, 0.006936468183994293, 0.012321271933615208, -0.010971766896545887 ]
<p>I understand the nature of light can be complex and has extensive theories/experimental data. We hear light can be both a wave and particle, so why can't it be both, a wave of particles?</p>
g4081
[ 0.011445261538028717, 0.04022257402539253, 0.008257555775344372, 0.020054379478096962, 0.0765344500541687, 0.0013165349373593926, 0.008835854940116405, 0.04325668886303902, 0.013219437561929226, -0.08488982915878296, 0.06570287048816681, 0.010582450777292252, 0.051074083894491196, 0.020066283643245697, -0.07055598497390747, -0.02926565520465374, 0.018394680693745613, 0.006305459886789322, 0.08739130944013596, 0.035519856959581375, -0.0010702530853450298, 0.019532620906829834, 0.049878064543008804, -0.03250519558787346, -0.09305869787931442, 0.017220113426446915, 0.006203269120305777, -0.06191529706120491, 0.03300664573907852, -0.004632089287042618, 0.05936581641435623, -0.02013278193771839, 0.01965399645268917, 0.00986035168170929, 0.02804383635520935, -0.08282656222581863, -0.014968284405767918, -0.024325698614120483, 0.02062123455107212, 0.04537491500377655, 0.007193520199507475, 0.02044774405658245, 0.012308933772146702, -0.019277792423963547, 0.027005434036254883, 0.014024744741618633, 0.03372965753078461, 0.03217604383826256, -0.02639925479888916, -0.042247701436281204, -0.01682194322347641, -0.006937573663890362, 0.021366316825151443, 0.07556263357400894, 0.0923878625035286, 0.004532324615865946, 0.011966762132942677, 0.025825513526797295, 0.09803670644760132, 0.04744935408234596, -0.008757910691201687, 0.011644797399640083, 0.02393912896513939, 0.08012811094522476, -0.010478443466126919, -0.06422332674264908, -0.011861180886626244, -0.06549464911222458, 0.04925335943698883, -0.012327567674219608, 0.04551093652844429, -0.06840650737285614, 0.005403389222919941, -0.009211122989654541, 0.06967738270759583, -0.008828883059322834, -0.05618773028254509, 0.050019651651382446, -0.017810922116041183, -0.031147031113505363, -0.0030607793014496565, -0.013259000144898891, -0.019478200003504753, 0.026396801695227623, 0.04377269744873047, -0.054236363619565964, -0.011528420262038708, -0.0886358842253685, 0.0015829328913241625, -0.03641195967793465, 0.02571074292063713, 0.00772885512560606, 0.11008650809526443, 0.04406711086630821, -0.015337929129600525, -0.0434994101524353, -0.03261448070406914, 0.05614163354039192, -0.007161970250308514, 0.038678672164678574, -0.022690776735544205, -0.007545757573097944, 0.0027284868992865086, 0.054274458438158035, 0.028438620269298553, -0.028030402958393097, -0.018594292923808098, 0.012569130398333073, -0.004870585631579161, -0.007824132218956947, -0.050519268959760666, -0.007839284837245941, 0.011688479222357273, -0.012258469127118587, -0.03756919130682945, -0.01973097026348114, 0.04683472588658333, 0.028503362089395523, -0.0007001394405961037, 0.046510834246873856, 0.04987768083810806, -0.003070240607485175, 0.023512061685323715, 0.03538505733013153, -0.030189212411642075, -0.01866348274052143, 0.04597122594714165, 0.02182607166469097, 0.020629869773983955, -0.00735910190269351, 0.04579688236117363, 0.009172779507935047, -0.03661280497908592, 0.03091132454574108, -0.0013486689422279596, -0.01689223013818264, 0.01614360697567463, -0.014839224517345428, -0.022580530494451523, 0.006584355607628822, 0.009085269644856453, 0.016878489404916763, 0.006275433115661144, 0.009051521308720112, -0.028064103797078133, 0.028898674994707108, -0.02072770893573761, -0.014378263615071774, -0.028891362249851227, 0.046492163091897964, 0.03399251773953438, 0.051815230399370193, 0.054225463420152664, 0.0074851480312645435, 0.04134112969040871, -0.030632611364126205, 0.07349569350481033, 0.0032489330042153597, -0.0744621679186821, 0.049534086138010025, 0.03332997485995293, 0.026081476360559464, -0.049160435795784, -0.0041889226995408535, -0.008160483092069626, -0.0018271149601787329, -0.04718463867902756, -0.0275390837341547, -0.02376810647547245, -0.06061529740691185, -0.025398720055818558, 0.010358468629419804, -0.02597835287451744, 0.082174152135849, 0.09189657121896744, 0.06025812402367592, -0.027478180825710297, 0.010967124253511429, -0.002565292874351144, 0.014290830120444298, -0.0784556046128273, -0.038493867963552475, -0.04779987037181854, -0.022029457613825798, -0.011416289955377579, -0.026521144434809685, 0.009343666955828667, 0.005142973270267248, -0.018712135031819344, 0.017530696466565132, 0.011191319674253464, -0.05934925377368927, 0.01667366735637188, 0.028267325833439827, 0.04594583809375763, 0.00029747633379884064, -0.011533795855939388, 0.009071686305105686, -0.031233621761202812, 0.042279623448848724, -0.026683328673243523, 0.036884605884552, 0.028028691187500954, -0.014928296208381653, 0.021169884130358696, 0.01920413039624691, -0.03886543959379196, -0.0008277480374090374, -0.015312490984797478, -0.011379655450582504, -0.003823712933808565, -0.013904204592108727, -0.004478458780795336, 0.03928462788462639, -0.016787895932793617, -0.06172700598835945, -0.0361875519156456, 0.01761694625020027, -0.014606687240302563, -0.0020245155319571495, -0.07320017367601395, -0.008844609372317791, 0.04232866317033768, -0.01296935323625803, -0.070097915828228, 0.07564353197813034, -0.049631282687187195, 0.019934136420488358, -0.017715364694595337, 0.04214094579219818, -0.08246465772390366, 0.01312533114105463, 0.02398836426436901, 0.028694836422801018, 0.04412367194890976, 0.0358564667403698, -0.039987992495298386, -0.03777649253606796, 0.04298199713230133, -0.035374581813812256, -0.041300218552351, -0.0015840568812564015, 0.048721082508563995, -0.039499763399362564, 0.004845380317419767, -0.04820062592625618, 0.003670176723971963, -0.025747202336788177, -0.013227074407041073, 0.0002653685805853456, 0.040495678782463074, -0.0411960631608963, -0.03719116374850273, -0.0042554521933197975, -0.030248286202549934, -0.028027791529893875, 0.012789414264261723, 0.05745528265833855, -0.03838321939110756, -0.019753217697143555, 0.029822712764143944, 0.014939059503376484, -0.017935071140527725, -0.014663398265838623, -0.003663803916424513, -0.017353259027004242, 0.017743289470672607, 0.04345263913273811, -0.013336285017430782, -0.02176644280552864, -0.03632744774222374, 0.02324514277279377, 0.02491125278174877, -0.04114565998315811, -0.016657190397381783, 0.012589946389198303, -0.039741843938827515, -0.04030797630548477, 0.04195259511470795, -0.03258703276515007, 0.02327125146985054, 0.03988117724657059, -0.043491702526807785, 0.0037247342988848686, 0.02890176698565483, -0.09221268445253372, -0.023907534778118134, 0.025165069848299026, 0.00870305672287941, 0.02449812740087509, -0.005583031568676233, 0.03707223758101463, 0.0064260163344442844, -0.02372443489730358, -0.021198803558945656, 0.01411413960158825, 0.0004972078604623675, -0.045017775148153305, -0.05219031125307083, 0.010738474316895008, -0.008844326250255108, 0.011917085386812687, 0.06181243062019348, -0.0024265418760478497, 0.013616155833005905, 0.031048644334077835, -0.06271909922361374, -0.0019565806724131107, 0.006551696453243494, 0.022114649415016174, 0.018245454877614975, 0.06469888985157013, -0.0506913959980011, 0.05564691126346588, -0.0072883013635873795, -0.023459242656826973, -0.05074081942439079, 0.03515435755252838, -0.014926795847713947, -0.038645025342702866, -0.05579802021384239, -0.001268728286959231, 0.012109480798244476, 0.018374579027295113, 0.016518961638212204, -0.0023090855684131384, -0.05191485211253166, 0.00587585661560297, -0.03178281709551811, -0.027577780187129974, 0.028843015432357788, -0.0397733598947525, -0.007491081953048706, -0.003107659984380007, 0.006647157482802868, -0.02109956182539463, 0.004589082673192024, -0.027465159073472023, 0.04261217638850212, -0.004787140060216188, -0.019046315923333168, 0.02182086743414402, -0.06106654182076454, 0.03575241565704346, -0.01501109916716814, 0.043247852474451065, -0.037482183426618576, -0.05784734711050987, 0.028826896101236343, -0.031020183116197586, 0.006724841892719269, 0.03121722862124443, 0.009274433366954327, -0.01541445404291153, -0.054464686661958694, 0.0023390299174934626, 0.05480306223034859, 0.04761238768696785, 0.03349956497550011, -0.03612403944134712, -0.00458363676443696, -0.013978192582726479, 0.04122921824455261, -0.030807198956608772, 0.009643987752497196, 0.005874771624803543, 0.023886190727353096, 0.01346597820520401, 0.0012233165325596929, 0.010272017680108547, 0.011596749536693096, -0.044224295765161514, -0.033254384994506836, 0.030471187084913254, 0.04187919944524765, -0.046864353120326996, 0.021988214924931526, 0.024142706766724586, 0.013599232770502567, 0.000082116384874098, 0.05281601846218109, 0.04499092325568199, 0.028090357780456543, 0.024932460859417915, -0.02071375399827957, 0.03611725941300392, -0.014898581430315971, 0.03581443428993225, -0.0033793540205806494, 0.009383972734212875, -0.005692178849130869, -0.027172861620783806, -0.06667366623878479, -0.021316129714250565, 0.02935054898262024, 0.025649020448327065, -0.011902965605258942, -0.05644242465496063, -0.017492540180683136, 0.02227574773132801, -0.003830601228401065, 0.03765842318534851, 0.03519975766539574, -0.06159138306975365, 0.0030934009701013565, 0.01951630227267742, 0.020578376948833466, -0.01992053911089897, 0.000051410468586254865, 0.009638425894081593, 0.041493337601423264, 0.007212300784885883, 0.028766702860593796, 0.00894751027226448, -0.036568958312273026, -0.005773948971182108, -0.02162679098546505, -0.055305711925029755, 0.05295620113611221, 0.04664381593465805, 0.02235456183552742, 0.05372397601604462, -0.007183078210800886, -0.021876025944948196, -0.015272666700184345, 0.05296069383621216, 0.006007663905620575, -0.007935602217912674, -0.0700693354010582, -0.030941367149353027, 0.006235147826373577, 0.026520367711782455, -0.021281545981764793, -0.04441031068563461, 0.002692143665626645, 0.006672607269138098, -0.03117945045232773, 0.04704214259982109, 0.037127312272787094, 0.010471981018781662, 0.05740168318152428, -0.00017230874800588936, 0.04620308801531792, -0.018392199650406837, 0.06528882682323456, 0.0332842618227005, 0.002197205787524581, -0.010286878794431686, -0.04697168245911598, -0.03440985828638077, -0.0035360560286790133, -0.006659143138676882, -0.07563881576061249, -0.040362048894166946, -0.0504533052444458, 0.03822070360183716, -0.00765202846378088, 0.023803818970918655, -0.03359409421682358, 0.024373605847358704, -0.07714643329381943, 0.0002664166095200926, 0.06428490579128265, 0.009817172773182392, 0.0524851493537426, 0.008311588317155838, -0.05589848756790161, -0.014103728346526623, -0.08024474233388901, 0.0024542887695133686, -0.023665478453040123, 0.0161922387778759, 0.03431621193885803, -0.007138434331864119, 0.02514590136706829, -0.059548210352659225, -0.03985672816634178, -0.0378245934844017, -0.028711672872304916, -0.06552929431200027, 0.0013112269807606936, -0.0137109300121665, 0.00013509501877706498, 0.024660110473632812, -0.038639746606349945, 0.03156954422593117, -0.07134304195642471, 0.10892683267593384, -0.0720636323094368, -0.03187553584575653, 0.02042604237794876, -0.0572211928665638, -0.00014360093337018043, -0.030007999390363693, 0.018677229061722755, -0.015310938470065594, -0.014477822929620743, -0.02948094718158245, -0.02788238413631916, -0.02405887469649315, -0.020372992381453514, -0.06983676552772522, -0.005719877779483795, -0.042540013790130615, -0.019435951486229897, 0.03847499191761017, 0.03779613971710205, -0.022332696244120598, -0.03371642157435417, 0.00872756727039814, 0.07729499042034149, -0.0798635482788086, -0.04560588672757149, 0.05290123075246811, 0.042623456567525864, 0.04966257885098457, -0.011084469966590405, 0.02991417609155178, 0.05123089253902435, 0.01416722871363163, -0.03665009140968323, -0.00657648965716362, 0.010993610136210918, 0.010277139022946358, 0.010861443355679512, -0.006714156828820705, -0.05491824448108673, -0.03230079263448715, 0.04045199602842331, 0.02267015166580677, 0.04574568197131157, 0.02546956203877926, 0.04084055870771408, 0.026805242523550987, -0.02612314186990261, -0.03372008726000786, 0.010467306710779667, -0.028603676706552505, 0.0032213928643614054, 0.04136382415890694, 0.0006318382220342755, -0.028899678960442543, -0.019056910648941994, 0.06441491842269897, 0.06468745321035385, 0.014256990514695644, 0.040439147502183914, 0.006018302869051695, 0.03946865350008011, -0.003814768511801958, -0.010456616058945656, -0.01977241411805153, -0.022638671100139618, -0.020047994330525398, 0.003235776210203767, 0.06882134824991226, 0.020040152594447136, -0.05201047658920288, -0.04703756794333458, -0.029540134593844414, -0.010967220179736614, -0.000619898026343435, -0.04174342751502991, -0.03436750918626785, 0.012949660420417786, 0.013428088277578354, -0.011239660903811455, -0.01155776996165514, -0.013365322723984718, 0.02901669405400753, -0.015461528673768044, 0.04599745571613312, 0.007262929808348417, 0.00680548558011651, 0.04706086963415146, -0.01632951758801937, 0.03223163262009621, -0.017552584409713745, -0.030219562351703644, -0.043683554977178574, 0.057005539536476135, 0.01608550362288952, -0.007002171128988266, -0.021670226007699966, -0.03906610980629921, -0.003054367145523429, -0.013763712719082832, -0.023301081731915474, 0.056137748062610626, 0.04166846722364426, -0.02880355902016163, -0.03485594317317009, -0.03769809380173683, -0.016498645767569542, -0.02372146025300026, -0.059381116181612015, 0.05477825179696083, -0.010531802661716938, -0.01835210621356964, 0.03157549723982811, 0.0015643585938960314, 0.009667503647506237, 0.00287860375829041, 0.08869904279708862, 0.058724284172058105, 0.0388961024582386, -0.04010922089219093, -0.020383689552545547, 0.03176112100481987, 0.03346579894423485, -0.057007379829883575, -0.02688063681125641, -0.048364344984292984, -0.02507890947163105, -0.03257575258612633, -0.07336019724607468, -0.0660335123538971, 0.030816299840807915, -0.017796238884329796, -0.007129616104066372, -0.0020320531912148, -0.02495328150689602, -0.037539057433605194, 0.0036643233615905046, -0.0008600730798207223, 0.003307886188849807, -0.02865893580019474, 0.0873241201043129, 0.07947437465190887, 0.030759800225496292, 0.05232396349310875, -0.014340117573738098, 0.04099981486797333, 0.039743080735206604, -0.02075602300465107, -0.02641213871538639, -0.02785097062587738, -0.022939858958125114, 0.009122704155743122, -0.014820833690464497, -0.0035547101870179176, 0.06939554214477539, 0.03419001027941704, 0.04390708729624748, -0.07150441408157349, -0.0058179330080747604, 0.0571252815425396, -0.09411389380693436, -0.0292221587151289, -0.018577229231595993, -0.020629221573472023, -0.021636707708239555, -0.0365481898188591, -0.02308294177055359, 0.0456293560564518, 0.005290391854941845, -0.02144620381295681, 0.009667405858635902, -0.056081078946590424, -0.06926170736551285, -0.06111987307667732, 0.010028287768363953, 0.03280522674322128, 0.012207435443997383, -0.019529087468981743, 0.0006724583217874169, -0.01767519675195217, -0.05007343739271164, -0.03669946268200874, -0.04795018211007118, -0.02404320240020752, -0.030528275296092033, -0.02179393172264099, -0.010234611108899117, -0.003213433315977454, -0.01329327467828989, -0.058896422386169434, 0.05520864948630333, 0.04946012794971466, 0.033164605498313904, 0.03709026053547859, 0.0389268584549427, -0.011282088235020638, 0.06696389615535736, 0.04964473098516464, 0.02699870616197586, -0.013154511339962482, -0.009867898188531399, 0.038509491831064224, 0.003508205758407712, -0.03177143633365631, -0.014698286540806293, -0.005672906059771776, -0.07421012222766876, -0.01710331253707409, 0.013700542040169239, 0.061310719698667526, 0.003921451512724161, 0.07377175986766815, 0.01307616475969553, -0.02867378666996956, -0.029873749241232872, -0.02178659662604332, -0.036905571818351746, 0.011851128190755844, -0.01305994763970375, 0.02198132500052452, 0.008136440999805927, -0.007979216985404491, -0.01773315668106079, -0.025291956961154938, 0.06705952435731888, -0.016882138326764107, 0.019986944273114204, 0.012879070825874805, 0.01918276585638523, 0.01016953680664301, 0.035821717232465744, -0.02353782206773758, -0.013205376453697681, 0.02406395599246025, -0.00707277562469244, -0.038065217435359955, -0.020764844492077827, 0.030827073380351067, -0.01647387444972992, 0.051154639571905136, -0.04858492314815521, -0.005861986894160509, 0.04376924782991409, -0.01003152597695589, 0.02553747408092022, -0.027172895148396492, -0.030574053525924683, -0.03677056357264519, 0.017667802050709724, -0.031551945954561234, 0.03163301572203636, -0.021830040961503983, 0.0020264543127268553, 0.051246363669633865, -0.016204718500375748, -0.007250505033880472, -0.039321769028902054, -0.03197880834341049, -0.0635935366153717, -0.0252049770206213, 0.026197349652647972, 0.05776304006576538, -0.014536496251821518, -0.040484145283699036, 0.0565963052213192, -0.01581444963812828, 0.06515596807003021, 0.10561876744031906, -0.07635685801506042, -0.0017170701175928116, 0.044065382331609726, 0.013299553655087948, -0.0206811111420393, 0.009887398220598698, 0.029174109920859337, 0.008053204976022243, -0.01845531351864338, -0.019119124859571457, 0.011089775711297989, -0.019657032564282417, 0.0011971285566687584 ]
<p>It is well known that the speed of light $c$ can be interpreted as the speed limit for information propagation. Similarly, the Planck's constant $h$ is interpreted as the minimum quantum package of action/entropy. Is there a similar interpretation for the Newton's constant $G$?</p>
g4082
[ -0.002330759773030877, -0.0045995102263987064, 0.0033920370042324066, -0.0036927491892129183, 0.03567083179950714, -0.01954960823059082, 0.019240250810980797, 0.019834905862808228, -0.05260048061609268, 0.010501006618142128, 0.06001685932278633, 0.01752842403948307, -0.03880311921238899, 0.00866245198994875, 0.004325575660914183, -0.008549902588129044, 0.03303650766611099, -0.04104598984122276, 0.035275910049676895, 0.009128316305577755, -0.009649630635976791, 0.007128479424864054, 0.005181022919714451, -0.043164245784282684, 0.013388052582740784, 0.014005107805132866, 0.04043717309832573, -0.06653512269258499, -0.06250765174627304, 0.026235738769173622, 0.03522162884473801, -0.06489500403404236, 0.04415161907672882, -0.07743111997842789, -0.011301376856863499, -0.015038466081023216, 0.015607831068336964, 0.006883969064801931, 0.05239284411072731, -0.00903941411525011, 0.01977764628827572, -0.030347811058163643, -0.034015972167253494, -0.005358548369258642, 0.02786344103515148, 0.012220154516398907, 0.041300974786281586, 0.027257399633526802, 0.027247577905654907, -0.045185625553131104, -0.031818658113479614, 0.048462510108947754, 0.023895934224128723, -0.022883465513586998, 0.05408386513590813, 0.05139898508787155, -0.0003528944216668606, -0.03107793815433979, 0.029076239094138145, 0.07656501978635788, 0.07479291409254074, -0.01621452532708645, 0.01696225441992283, -0.023035865277051926, 0.0775996595621109, 0.02233293280005455, 0.02130863070487976, -0.07568955421447754, -0.03788868710398674, 0.020198382437229156, -0.007323817815631628, -0.03841173276305199, -0.06589146703481674, -0.0162174254655838, 0.021814197301864624, -0.01046083401888609, 0.03815501555800438, 0.006071904208511114, 0.00810297206044197, -0.0014660534216091037, -0.03255316987633705, -0.006155036389827728, 0.009946256875991821, -0.07551988214254379, 0.01112543884664774, -0.028548065572977066, 0.019102154299616814, -0.0186289194971323, -0.019101625308394432, 0.04342281073331833, -0.02280910685658455, -0.04452887177467346, 0.02375652641057968, -0.02090793289244175, 0.019655020907521248, 0.03376685082912445, -0.023044263944029808, 0.04996557533740997, -0.01606145314872265, 0.04867454990744591, -0.048262692987918854, -0.015382172539830208, 0.02230718545615673, -0.018292304128408432, -0.015004861168563366, -0.01620575413107872, -0.023518456146121025, -0.016544252634048462, -0.013894862495362759, -0.026320213451981544, -0.005622813943773508, -0.013883739709854126, -0.015168290585279465, -0.04434262588620186, -0.07093653082847595, -0.09861811250448227, 0.061028629541397095, -0.010680604726076126, -0.025190096348524094, -0.004983251914381981, -0.02126944251358509, 0.023373199626803398, -0.007870444096624851, 0.04501572251319885, -0.004121608566492796, 0.024151058867573738, 0.009912079200148582, -0.002788922283798456, 0.029593011364340782, -0.04733801260590553, 0.04742833599448204, 0.006175593938678503, -0.04022834450006485, 0.06731744110584259, -0.03911220282316208, 0.001451074960641563, -0.019391866400837898, 0.013631493784487247, -0.026593483984470367, 0.008519349619746208, -0.027258971706032753, -0.07320978492498398, 0.017254076898097992, -0.04011336714029312, -0.017419498413801193, 0.007113202475011349, 0.017831772565841675, 0.018222017213702202, 0.012094072066247463, -0.006757558323442936, -0.027251584455370903, 0.07661422342061996, 0.03174746036529541, -0.02524249441921711, -0.03248229995369911, -0.0280446857213974, 0.06573271006345749, 0.017935164272785187, -0.018634051084518433, 0.0594923235476017, 0.0334046371281147, 0.0041022091172635555, 0.010775256901979446, 0.015058973804116249, -0.05658045411109924, 0.028988081961870193, -0.01023698877543211, 0.018739866092801094, 0.052512042224407196, -0.1290755569934845, -0.017076237127184868, -0.018558738753199577, -0.008081099949777126, 0.012755375355482101, -0.025793645530939102, -0.0060961078852415085, 0.039776306599378586, -0.026380645111203194, -0.0435023196041584, 0.01776762492954731, -0.04023100808262825, -0.015566479414701462, 0.04411992058157921, -0.03948703035712242, -0.022570712491869926, 0.017167601734399796, 0.01323460228741169, -0.04741836339235306, -0.06135723367333412, -0.005151018034666777, -0.03365527093410492, -0.01995106227695942, -0.020100174471735954, 0.02906644530594349, -0.024079250171780586, 0.013183552771806717, 0.009303810074925423, -0.04921021685004234, -0.015273178927600384, 0.011941367760300636, 0.02723575010895729, 0.045290738344192505, 0.01889733038842678, -0.0015211835270747542, 0.006816209759563208, 0.0033758897334337234, 0.026481295004487038, 0.050355203449726105, 0.031865861266851425, 0.001088692806661129, 0.06998603045940399, -0.0643317922949791, 0.010526861064136028, 0.06860914826393127, 0.029904916882514954, -0.0689995288848877, 0.02575276419520378, 0.02740858867764473, 0.01852671429514885, -0.010012776590883732, -0.017283271998167038, 0.029948057606816292, 0.014889279380440712, -0.03443191200494766, -0.01755373179912567, 0.026301631703972816, -0.07844424992799759, -0.02883514016866684, 0.0175364688038826, 0.04595686495304108, -0.02859387919306755, 0.016099963337183, -0.059772878885269165, 0.019065087661147118, -0.002982731442898512, 0.037635065615177155, -0.015628499910235405, -0.04123082011938095, 0.016301561146974564, 0.035713743418455124, 0.037584301084280014, 0.024852510541677475, -0.07143339514732361, 0.036237284541130066, 0.004069553688168526, 0.019132552668452263, -0.04344725236296654, -0.06010579317808151, -0.02540143020451069, 0.008474337868392467, 0.008743842132389545, -0.017105620354413986, 0.0356883741915226, -0.024375397711992264, 0.02793508768081665, -0.010445408523082733, -0.02940812148153782, -0.020420905202627182, -0.11312343925237656, -0.04507680609822273, 0.022317539900541306, 0.02650207094848156, -0.029619935899972916, -0.006604406982660294, -0.0038944703992456198, -0.04231191426515579, 0.015350516885519028, 0.04250861704349518, -0.02216494083404541, 0.037278808653354645, -0.04191694036126137, 0.0653877779841423, -0.017967920750379562, -0.01319656241685152, -0.009421054273843765, -0.015917740762233734, 0.030729055404663086, -0.08322349190711975, -0.02732047811150551, -0.05021023750305176, -0.058106597512960434, -0.02023370936512947, -0.02964209020137787, 0.007625256199389696, -0.0008219885639846325, -0.11300280690193176, 0.00555396918207407, 0.04641078785061836, 0.02649111859500408, 0.038947705179452896, 0.016484355553984642, 0.06618199497461319, 0.016467954963445663, 0.04964708909392357, -0.018457811325788498, 0.057768236845731735, 0.057169318199157715, -0.009082325734198093, 0.00874192826449871, 0.010949852876365185, 0.002390875481069088, -0.02900935523211956, -0.05567379668354988, 0.03040909580886364, -0.04792661592364311, -0.06350433826446533, -0.029638566076755524, -0.03721974790096283, -0.021075254306197166, 0.03328339755535126, 0.032876599580049515, 0.03247988969087601, 0.026199040934443474, 0.006340671796351671, -0.09033109992742538, -0.017274899408221245, -0.0454755537211895, -0.013828691095113754, -0.0037891939282417297, -0.01736419089138508, 0.035233788192272186, -0.050747599452733994, -0.0061603426001966, -0.03359973803162575, 0.0405689962208271, 0.025312276557087898, -0.03939826786518097, -0.03944576531648636, -0.029939977452158928, -0.034071777015924454, 0.036488328129053116, -0.03601367399096489, -0.0011595432879403234, 0.059227354824543, -0.024791860952973366, -0.08020565658807755, 0.0017351434798911214, 0.020421894267201424, 0.039787933230400085, 0.013785960152745247, 0.007186207454651594, 0.04220268875360489, -0.06263250857591629, 0.08172935247421265, 0.018952440470457077, -0.010517027229070663, -0.02314607985317707, 0.016611408442258835, -0.00356160756200552, -0.005980540532618761, 0.006089786998927593, -0.012517072260379791, -0.005973030347377062, -0.029203571379184723, -0.034070760011672974, 0.02855810709297657, -0.03056897222995758, 0.019565414637327194, 0.03744003549218178, -0.05527501553297043, 0.011159035377204418, -0.0432891808450222, 0.01570872589945793, 0.034695230424404144, 0.004782442003488541, -0.035095274448394775, -0.0023235955741256475, 0.06836114823818207, 0.041578441858291626, 0.0166260227560997, 0.015314863063395023, -0.024466177448630333, 0.0628238320350647, 0.04226790741086006, 0.02132353000342846, -0.042511261999607086, 0.017017168924212456, -0.022934282198548317, -0.011786788702011108, 0.03809736669063568, 0.012247671373188496, 0.029645472764968872, 0.03583156690001488, 0.03744461014866829, 0.046145979315042496, -0.02123846672475338, -0.021773800253868103, -0.02932767942547798, 0.0355568528175354, -0.048005733639001846, -0.024507848545908928, -0.04473691061139107, -0.0066698393784463406, 0.014314115047454834, -0.034634072333574295, -0.012390391901135445, 0.01831544004380703, 0.021382508799433708, 0.00011462676047813147, 0.026283571496605873, 0.051797859370708466, -0.02602568455040455, -0.03893880173563957, 0.014862505719065666, 0.03154509887099266, -0.02702869288623333, -0.007325621321797371, -0.0093586016446352, 0.044059500098228455, -0.016364678740501404, -0.011888645589351654, -0.01849847100675106, -0.003577468218281865, 0.003079683054238558, 0.010626778937876225, 0.06998953223228455, 0.0021839074324816465, -0.06560205668210983, 0.016704412177205086, 0.028381498530507088, -0.010991886258125305, 0.04247931018471718, 0.05126407369971275, 0.008621834218502045, -0.025748921558260918, 0.020145341753959656, 0.0806126743555069, 0.03015422821044922, -0.04111817851662636, -0.05147822946310043, 0.031429093331098557, -0.005144594702869654, 0.0013853481505066156, 0.035935115069150925, -0.010527617298066616, 0.07131847739219666, 0.03838429972529411, -0.027926595881581306, -0.015285966917872429, 0.024587463587522507, 0.0901048332452774, 0.020164240151643753, 0.0362800657749176, 0.026830481365323067, -0.03192285820841789, 0.05967451632022858, -0.021245336160063744, -0.029354125261306763, -0.024892963469028473, -0.036790817975997925, -0.01343648973852396, 0.008766797371208668, 0.01211337000131607, -0.04822155088186264, 0.013747563585639, -0.0031545916572213173, -0.09758641570806503, 0.03881865367293358, 0.048113785684108734, 0.004905465990304947, -0.03390974551439285, 0.03870907425880432, -0.010465191677212715, 0.002173712244257331, 0.04782679304480553, 0.01564573496580124, -0.12031548470258713, 0.07153177261352539, -0.044406045228242874, 0.013297701254487038, 0.004944262094795704, 0.035292915999889374, 0.0740487352013588, 0.027165398001670837, -0.03002503514289856, -0.02146444097161293, 0.012620605528354645, 0.0056077162735164165, -0.06615588814020157, 0.030181461945176125, -0.010127599351108074, 0.024689028039574623, 0.0516003854572773, 0.04131028801202774, 0.010767268016934395, 0.015707865357398987, -0.011907015927135944, 0.03928342089056969, -0.024863235652446747, -0.05347742140293121, 0.028314394876360893, 0.020987438037991524, 0.026796748861670494, 0.020950650796294212, -0.0617796815931797, 0.03313935175538063, 0.06105431541800499, 0.023275338113307953, -0.004351276904344559, -0.0003377483517397195, -0.053598932921886444, 0.045782141387462616, -0.013178722001612186, 0.027861086651682854, -0.029039230197668076, 0.022183571010828018, 0.042740341275930405, 0.0034945907536894083, -0.0480106920003891, 0.07166293263435364, 0.03400678560137749, 0.02587086893618107, -0.024806980043649673, 0.005076717585325241, 0.002929674694314599, -0.04873691871762276, -0.0014139547711238265, 0.031356293708086014, -0.001316491630859673, -0.030102143064141273, 0.02194035053253174, -0.0031204333063215017, 0.00023025780683383346, -0.0031575793400406837, 0.04418555274605751, 0.0028598085045814514, -0.08993673324584961, 0.0028079033363610506, 0.050406090915203094, 0.041198939085006714, 0.05780062824487686, 0.0463278628885746, 0.015372233465313911, -0.03467664122581482, 0.015534944832324982, -0.004908211994916201, 0.028504502028226852, 0.002654697746038437, -0.0013606217689812183, -0.040118440985679626, -0.06098157539963722, -0.04083861783146858, -0.03602886199951172, 0.05901884287595749, -0.011276356875896454, 0.04539850726723671, -0.04648076370358467, -0.013930865563452244, -0.03641216456890106, -0.03214411810040474, 0.045929353684186935, 0.007826285436749458, 0.008226561360061169, -0.02848150208592415, 0.031196430325508118, 0.06081238389015198, 0.007665826939046383, 0.007023131009191275, 0.011088807135820389, 0.007097652647644281, 0.02407754398882389, 0.03211380913853645, 0.04515983536839485, 0.03298031538724899, 0.047814298421144485, -0.060700491070747375, 0.030157223343849182, -0.03355000913143158, -0.01175903994590044, 0.06191069632768631, -0.03177356719970703, 0.05105191469192505, 0.014899997040629387, 0.047084275633096695, 0.008226136676967144, -0.04485755041241646, 0.02355962060391903, -0.06498725712299347, -0.108172707259655, 0.009802686981856823, -0.03914478421211243, -0.011103303171694279, -0.0015261085936799645, -0.0003532980044838041, -0.03051217459142208, -0.0038041023071855307, -0.03664778172969818, 0.0510026291012764, 0.045660752803087234, -0.020939813926815987, -0.003785931970924139, 0.015287294052541256, -0.025262000039219856, -0.00019933922158088535, -0.003222638973966241, -0.038376469165086746, 0.009690793231129646, -0.09429503232240677, -0.034396156668663025, -0.0007128809811547399, -0.0024390369653701782, 0.011558519676327705, 0.031530462205410004, -0.039422959089279175, 0.0474153533577919, 0.031805042177438736, -0.045544784516096115, -0.004137514159083366, -0.005002812948077917, 0.011212784796953201, 0.0005115338135510683, -0.0011077204253524542, 0.019207337871193886, 0.037009406834840775, 0.022755902260541916, 0.00688763614743948, -0.0005329103441908956, -0.033774882555007935, -0.020895836874842644, 0.011380604468286037, 0.03235246613621712, 0.033790819346904755, -0.01015553344041109, -0.004805983044207096, 0.011841810308396816, 0.054124973714351654, 0.021164001896977425, 0.012479664757847786, -0.012319790199398994, 0.053837850689888, 0.05580415576696396, 0.01793580874800682, -0.027624348178505898, 0.05559564009308815, 0.07181563973426819, -0.020408447831869125, -0.02054266259074211, 0.02908765710890293, -0.0025045983493328094, 0.007107412442564964, 0.08408291637897491, -0.07351458817720413, 0.04075608402490616, 0.005839107558131218, -0.0011224073823541403, 0.03367346525192261, 0.03572209179401398, 0.03172723203897476, 0.022642832249403, -0.04234670102596283, 0.015719542279839516, -0.00858371052891016, -0.03691772371530533, 0.05232279375195503, -0.0316510908305645, -0.008343830704689026, -0.03666511923074722, 0.0068199653178453445, -0.03650122135877609, -0.053331173956394196, -0.042217694222927094, -0.05499275028705597, 0.02637692727148533, -0.044615134596824646, 0.010951106436550617, 0.03263324126601219, 0.008294950239360332, -0.03300214186310768, -0.02997284010052681, -0.07776682823896408, 0.0022192213218659163, -0.045022252947092056, 0.02449534833431244, 0.024527505040168762, 0.010447612032294273, 0.0053026191890239716, -0.023540005087852478, 0.007108444347977638, -0.0505283959209919, -0.009555264376103878, 0.01749049313366413, -0.028383608907461166, 0.0631866455078125, -0.04953612759709358, -0.04091997817158699, -0.013318076729774475, -0.020346855744719505, -0.03696400299668312, 0.02046162821352482, -0.027605697512626648, 0.00021194948931224644, -0.056128136813640594, -0.006033466197550297, -0.03367859497666359, -0.026989320293068886, 0.011476480402052402, -0.022417522966861725, 0.05791327729821205, -0.0005040164105594158, -0.026655128225684166, -0.04080734774470329, -0.06826101243495941, -0.006382798310369253, 0.005001123528927565, -0.010321972891688347, 0.037952058017253876, -0.007047200575470924, -0.00820605643093586, 0.0013103918172419071, -0.012665306217968464, -0.02566869929432869, -0.011170759797096252, -0.01287265308201313, -0.012813752517104149, 0.0452602244913578, 0.05060955882072449, 0.000656561111100018, 0.016386250033974648, 0.024884173646569252, -0.03999416530132294, -0.0008044319692999125, -0.011120935901999474, -0.07656151801347733, -0.0006832492654211819, -0.007456702180206776, -0.009185283444821835, -0.03224670886993408, -0.025193408131599426, -0.046558674424886703, 0.0333213247358799, 0.0393914058804512, -0.02249201200902462, -0.016728082671761513, -0.0630476325750351, -0.06779878586530685, 0.10066356509923935, -0.01689639501273632, 0.04778608679771423, -0.021364567801356316, 0.04820086434483528, -0.02536052092909813, -0.04685330390930176, 0.001357663539238274, 0.07309132069349289, -0.004778795409947634, -0.024613741785287857, -0.05895722284913063, 0.034399788826704025, 0.058020755648612976, -0.0486198291182518, -0.014897914603352547, 0.049338579177856445, 0.0031959975603967905, 0.015011299401521683, -0.0012583445059135556, -0.0457567498087883, 0.027845576405525208, 0.00925692543387413, 0.03496691957116127, -0.00048477514064870775, -0.03523891046643257, -0.07881351560354233, 0.0472429096698761, 0.051420845091342926, 0.009379500523209572, 0.007341417483985424, 0.0014437366044148803, 0.009417803026735783 ]
<p>I'm reading <a href="http://www.tcm.phy.cam.ac.uk/~bds10/aqp/handout_operator.pdf" rel="nofollow">this tutorial</a> by Ben Simons entitled <em>Operator methods in quantum mechanics</em> in connection with his course in advanced QM, and I'm a bit puzzled by an identity in page 25, a bit above relation (3.3):</p> <p>With the momentum operator $\textbf{p}=-i\nabla$ and the vector $\textbf{a}$ we have</p> <p>$e^{-i\textbf{a}\cdot\textbf{p}}=e^{\ \textbf{a}\cdot\nabla}=\displaystyle\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{n!}a_{i_1}\cdots a_{i_n}\nabla_{i_1}\cdots\nabla_{i_n}\ ,$</p> <p>where repeated indices are summed over. What confuses me here is that (in 3D) $\textbf{a}$ and $\nabla$ have 3 components while this expression seems to refer to component $i_n$ where $n\rightarrow\infty$, and I don't recognize the usual expansion of the exponential.</p> <p>What am I missing here?</p>
g4083
[ 0.010045439004898071, -0.01319662295281887, -0.022967662662267685, -0.02367555908858776, 0.049147915095090866, 0.009949659928679466, 0.04348619654774666, 0.000587057787925005, 0.0073700654320418835, 0.048834457993507385, -0.06191318854689598, -0.011941625736653805, 0.005382182076573372, -0.0014062178088352084, -0.027591124176979065, -0.03651341423392296, 0.036620792001485825, 0.037787411361932755, 0.010049361735582352, -0.03739281743764877, -0.06643379479646683, 0.02599940076470375, -0.03965608775615692, -0.05590498074889183, 0.07678920030593872, -0.038909297436475754, -0.0012765154242515564, -0.026894135400652885, -0.029115555807948112, -0.036119814962148666, 0.034600622951984406, 0.04935960844159126, 0.02314833179116249, -0.017123781144618988, -0.037223976105451584, 0.0024915016256272793, 0.08369569480419159, 0.055529430508613586, 0.02835925668478012, 0.023396391421556473, -0.015979891642928123, -0.056174758821725845, 0.049066212028265, 0.035914260894060135, -0.02478206902742386, -0.003833618713542819, -0.028174446895718575, 0.024888109415769577, 0.02575824223458767, -0.07141232490539551, -0.017063533887267113, -0.005616799462586641, 0.060557544231414795, 0.008161731995642185, 0.007135454099625349, 0.07986847311258316, 0.005521582439541817, -0.02584538422524929, 0.029666705057024956, 0.0754208043217659, -0.01486683078110218, -0.02355942875146866, 0.04178084060549736, 0.01986072212457657, 0.09245648980140686, -0.054130591452121735, 0.020410437136888504, -0.021800551563501358, -0.03901886194944382, -0.05128949508070946, 0.04281141236424446, -0.06816685199737549, 0.0019186781719326973, 0.010554000735282898, 0.016878386959433556, -0.012988891452550888, -0.0022901787888258696, -0.0008028922602534294, 0.0118910763412714, 0.024307062849402428, -0.0070768967270851135, -0.02400236763060093, 0.07749951630830765, 0.043179724365472794, -0.011822185479104519, 0.01654673181474209, 0.024397017434239388, 0.04049225151538849, -0.07309753447771072, -0.08059555292129517, 0.004270546138286591, -0.017507661134004593, -0.006684151478111744, 0.08703304082155228, 0.002702675759792328, -0.048180148005485535, -0.038080472499132156, 0.021763352677226067, -0.011962718330323696, 0.014571969397366047, 0.008709096349775791, 0.046775929629802704, 0.037458937615156174, -0.04716027155518532, -0.0077234734781086445, -0.015259467996656895, 0.0222652405500412, -0.02332940138876438, -0.06647109985351562, -0.02463286556303501, -0.08188725262880325, -0.02005172334611416, -0.010658975690603256, -0.09806066751480103, -0.07727073132991791, -0.009630879387259483, -0.006346002221107483, -0.030491884797811508, -0.0018859677948057652, 0.013806040398776531, 0.007920392788946629, 0.00041535674245096743, 0.01583395153284073, 0.035617612302303314, -0.008410008624196053, -0.01349805761128664, 0.033828169107437134, 0.02262127958238125, 0.04135791212320328, -0.020117029547691345, -0.003676854306831956, -0.017944183200597763, 0.02461552619934082, 0.026374774053692818, 0.056612346321344376, 0.005193876102566719, -0.05803863704204559, 0.022626586258411407, 0.004742358345538378, 0.03902808576822281, -0.057405199855566025, 0.014293260872364044, -0.0024315500631928444, -0.0270350631326437, 0.0231787096709013, -0.01331384852528572, 0.013346421532332897, -0.08890920877456665, 0.060595784336328506, -0.01896977238357067, 0.030439509078860283, 0.07336683571338654, -0.020779099315404892, 0.002636207966133952, 0.012197814881801605, 0.015038242563605309, 0.004053251817822456, -0.07371003925800323, -0.012855663895606995, 0.0061026145704090595, 0.04999382048845291, -0.02078414335846901, 0.011086784303188324, -0.01602727733552456, -0.028876956552267075, -0.015734132379293442, 0.03764980658888817, -0.10425882786512375, 0.0018534334376454353, 0.001638112822547555, 0.009721127338707447, 0.012216893956065178, 0.001325345365330577, -0.015307923778891563, 0.0061081815510988235, 0.032614659518003464, -0.03752683103084564, 0.01036914810538292, 0.005193078424781561, 0.03286581113934517, -0.0303499735891819, 0.05059617757797241, 0.008611580356955528, -0.01741734892129898, 0.010558470152318478, 0.0046790908090770245, 0.006954055279493332, 0.05336500331759453, -0.0235392265021801, -0.04720645025372505, 0.011234837584197521, 0.06996959447860718, 0.010723462328314781, 0.08347506821155548, -0.03797965124249458, 0.0322878472507, 0.005260946694761515, -0.03461829572916031, -0.013445833697915077, -0.00853640679270029, -0.0050169676542282104, 0.026015058159828186, 0.03540020436048508, 0.0257736723870039, 0.023030539974570274, 0.011679881252348423, -0.026874728500843048, -0.005204047076404095, -0.024673618376255035, 0.0288686640560627, 0.021312620490789413, -0.012297182343900204, -0.03331389278173447, 0.04970450699329376, -0.011860459111630917, -0.023512179031968117, 0.018909553065896034, -0.013469734229147434, -0.0011033480986952782, 0.003374959109351039, -0.03190184384584427, -0.05038084462285042, -0.007553995121270418, -0.04733907803893089, -0.07333599030971527, 0.0198634322732687, 0.028514651581645012, 0.004537185654044151, 0.0014939882094040513, 0.009888090193271637, -0.08550528436899185, 0.012949278578162193, -0.02058168314397335, -0.020397039130330086, 0.04972779378294945, 0.007405071519315243, -0.009079521521925926, 0.03671938180923462, 0.0016586409183219075, 0.08377795666456223, 0.04254576563835144, 0.04400065168738365, -0.03702019900083542, -0.019547805190086365, 0.04271962121129036, 0.02585933357477188, 0.06868542730808258, -0.011559579521417618, -0.003453828627243638, 0.02622128836810589, -0.07483696937561035, -0.041187696158885956, 0.02074747532606125, 0.020896753296256065, -0.027046572417020798, -0.02173388935625553, 0.06085002049803734, -0.002145293401554227, 0.018066931515932083, 0.005668634548783302, -0.0009510571835562587, 0.003457397921010852, -0.02161702699959278, 0.028806930407881737, -0.05593600496649742, 0.0019990322180092335, -0.051188405603170395, 0.0015601973282173276, -0.013028583489358425, 0.005411839112639427, -0.028922883793711662, 0.018199121579527855, -0.04597635939717293, 0.0629303827881813, 0.005128964316099882, -0.029287006705999374, 0.0024893584195524454, -0.054089076817035675, 0.01926366239786148, -0.03442899510264397, -0.04086422547698021, 0.0009608135442249477, -0.014412371441721916, 0.009008334949612617, 0.02589394897222519, -0.006460172589868307, 0.011724990792572498, 0.03751477226614952, -0.011247513815760612, -0.0030417675152420998, 0.05071372911334038, 0.010449320077896118, -0.0005463503184728324, -0.01766126975417137, 0.004277355503290892, 0.013346743769943714, 0.04345285892486572, -0.06054306775331497, 0.013991731218993664, 0.05467582494020462, 0.006466250866651535, 0.010071586817502975, 0.014725171029567719, -0.07118629664182663, 0.07832618057727814, 0.03359377011656761, -0.01635947823524475, 0.028649209067225456, 0.004966936074197292, 0.046386025846004486, 0.0036697706673294306, -0.005047196056693792, -0.0025606504641473293, 0.015419608913362026, -0.007320661097764969, 0.036437176167964935, -0.06438734382390976, -0.03706613928079605, 0.01786212809383869, -0.04889792576432228, -0.08216852694749832, -0.06039033457636833, 0.01660642772912979, 0.0003913044056389481, 0.017685292288661003, 0.0096115218475461, -0.05009124055504799, 0.060705676674842834, 0.03723388537764549, -0.03830517828464508, -0.03014175407588482, -0.038295309990644455, 0.07445866614580154, 0.0016995122423395514, -0.04107009619474411, -0.029649533331394196, -0.04569290205836296, 0.05387997254729271, 0.036975182592868805, -0.07673046737909317, 0.015920955687761307, -0.022816870361566544, -0.005839252378791571, -0.008662013337016106, 0.0011930344626307487, -0.01683211885392666, 0.017519108951091766, 0.09129633009433746, 0.0029471968300640583, -0.003577672177925706, -0.042297132313251495, 0.03444228321313858, 0.04487623646855354, -0.021709352731704712, -0.008991530165076256, -0.00463453633710742, 0.018808837980031967, 0.026853911578655243, -0.012280522845685482, -0.04314183071255684, -0.010002321563661098, -0.006782808806747198, 0.04132624715566635, 0.06483553349971771, -0.013166407123208046, -0.014995701611042023, -0.002300126478075981, 0.061228372156620026, -0.016080176457762718, -0.029522664844989777, 0.0002256624575238675, -0.05133228749036789, -0.020269259810447693, -0.0005934181390330195, -0.04066447168588638, -0.06850012391805649, -0.017841797322034836, 0.01155073195695877, -0.013527583330869675, 0.02642444148659706, 0.02072976902127266, 0.026281265541911125, 0.023998137563467026, 0.01797773502767086, 0.01580829918384552, 0.020157936960458755, -0.029020391404628754, -0.02586032636463642, 0.036237165331840515, -0.06836914271116257, 0.04509434103965759, 0.022763995453715324, -0.014005483128130436, 0.02715650387108326, 0.04817827045917511, -0.07172340899705887, 0.012912691570818424, -0.0514310784637928, -0.0006925960769876838, 0.06808733940124512, 0.010903655551373959, -0.04006277024745941, 0.013958311639726162, 0.048202209174633026, -0.008654538542032242, 0.05128702148795128, 0.05265410616993904, -0.03707084059715271, 0.015284067951142788, -0.07735857367515564, -0.04081890359520912, 0.02375875972211361, 0.05978166311979294, -0.043383292853832245, -0.022808073088526726, 0.0016483853105455637, 0.01683088205754757, -0.05092277750372887, -0.03133826702833176, 0.009615705348551273, 0.026926519349217415, -0.00572242634370923, -0.0013004603097215295, -0.029381785541772842, 0.057627659291028976, 0.002887965412810445, 0.017605548724532127, 0.003188030095770955, -0.023893944919109344, 0.013408320024609566, -0.01612001657485962, 0.09920421242713928, 0.002374794567003846, 0.06417221575975418, -0.05069606006145477, 0.016903106123209, -0.04827604442834854, 0.06566506624221802, 0.020501278340816498, 0.04245218262076378, 0.06581593304872513, 0.014531375840306282, 0.005455531645566225, -0.03778450936079025, 0.035299625247716904, 0.03156837448477745, -0.029457008466124535, -0.0285322368144989, -0.0017087191808968782, 0.052214864641427994, -0.0238255076110363, 0.03587828576564789, 0.016330646350979805, -0.05570099502801895, 0.025001633912324905, -0.0006452511297538877, -0.0056290230713784695, 0.010072539560496807, 0.004192268010228872, -0.00830672588199377, -0.06011509522795677, -0.006736717652529478, -0.05475326254963875, -0.01791326515376568, 0.04780852794647217, -0.011942457407712936, -0.06199813634157181, 0.05698513239622116, -0.030369969084858894, -0.06457770615816116, 0.06591679900884628, -0.020500149577856064, 0.049308739602565765, -0.023444104939699173, 0.02975904755294323, 0.03340567275881767, 0.027118008583784103, -0.0023143503349274397, -0.07818096876144409, -0.019999045878648758, 0.0018507911590859294, -0.012138815596699715, -0.02640100196003914, 0.01989721693098545, 0.004191471263766289, -0.026238927617669106, -0.007829719223082066, -0.05496178939938545, 0.02032899670302868, 0.0034786926116794348, 0.030526405200362206, 0.026549259200692177, -0.01823163405060768, -0.004409403074532747, -0.04334811493754387, 0.02096845582127571, 0.09246782958507538, -0.0220931526273489, 0.04435515031218529, 0.008788730017840862, -0.06961874663829803, -0.013846899382770061, -0.040382131934165955, 0.044028881937265396, 0.030896387994289398, -0.014099668711423874, 0.0664246454834938, -0.010106099769473076, 0.03822842612862587, -0.037271056324243546, 0.004140898585319519, -0.019992820918560028, 0.008897444233298302, 0.005790697876363993, -0.005628409329801798, 0.03787924721837044, -0.037189558148384094, -0.024280626326799393, -0.05453109368681908, -0.02477606199681759, 0.012376922182738781, 0.0008358248742297292, 0.015939293429255486, -0.03514629229903221, 0.04998797923326492, 0.011208574287593365, -0.0012478770222514868, -0.05133884772658348, 0.016225365921854973, 0.02779664285480976, 0.012358777225017548, 0.050605110824108124, 0.014743955805897713, -0.0618470199406147, -0.006291287485510111, -0.004781875293701887, 0.0034819745924323797, 0.02732008323073387, 0.0431099608540535, -0.006804877892136574, 0.008500617928802967, -0.0300690196454525, -0.03771882504224777, 0.09579657018184662, -0.028385883197188377, -0.015518583357334137, 0.02048162743449211, -0.081637442111969, 0.04978150501847267, -0.025704946368932724, 0.017887355759739876, -0.04168977960944176, -0.04008172079920769, -0.026693452149629593, 0.03889651969075203, -0.026416078209877014, -0.02671140432357788, 0.05741136893630028, -0.04889775812625885, 0.010058602318167686, 0.02749031037092209, -0.003471879754215479, 0.01818946562707424, -0.006501156836748123, -0.057252056896686554, -0.020720744505524635, -0.002592526376247406, 0.03482174128293991, -0.04817677289247513, 0.020174045115709305, 0.013646751642227173, -0.014149310998618603, 0.006553361192345619, 0.01816924661397934, 0.03800123184919357, 0.07880617678165436, -0.014675073325634003, -0.051605481654405594, -0.022007392719388008, -0.008640729822218418, -0.006734945345669985, 0.006725803017616272, 0.027493244037032127, 0.003258614568039775, -0.010755952447652817, 0.04350278154015541, -0.0702863335609436, -0.019347960129380226, 0.03804574906826019, -0.020170925185084343, -0.040929801762104034, 0.007796729914844036, -0.039158452302217484, -0.027724625542759895, -0.02198202908039093, 0.02827385440468788, 0.03422395512461662, 0.02166891098022461, 0.05059594288468361, -0.0013812410179525614, 0.005194598808884621, -0.005536556243896484, 0.040962498635053635, -0.01843988336622715, -0.004701435100287199, 0.0669855996966362, -0.0021342423278838396, -0.01602032780647278, -0.021457353606820107, 0.009122746996581554, 0.006897105369716883, 0.008311632089316845, -0.009575474075973034, 0.04933420941233635, 0.021410848945379257, -0.015772847458720207, -0.0024674730375409126, 0.05849967151880264, 0.0011155741522088647, 0.03143817186355591, 0.05286093056201935, -0.013611126691102982, -0.021027248352766037, 0.0001333273103227839, 0.01660951040685177, 0.007922282442450523, -0.0065069678239524364, -0.016572652384638786, -0.024385977536439896, 0.006041788030415773, 0.02011847496032715, -0.04862133041024208, -0.034979771822690964, 0.01096037682145834, -0.00133683648891747, 0.031438153237104416, -0.036549925804138184, 0.03486645594239235, -0.012674064375460148, 0.06150301918387413, -0.05034714564681053, 0.05007467046380043, 0.018506284803152084, -0.01583974063396454, -0.019722700119018555, -0.003545732470229268, 0.0036945154424756765, -0.03479065001010895, -0.10586587339639664, 0.01306406781077385, 0.07964278757572174, 0.013180678710341454, -0.009419421665370464, 0.03127783164381981, -0.022918736562132835, -0.06059371307492256, 0.075048066675663, 0.022730737924575806, 0.05490919202566147, -0.019410740584135056, -0.028487559407949448, 0.007914217188954353, -0.026144394651055336, -0.015487118624150753, -0.02373453974723816, 0.07329880446195602, 0.04294398054480553, -0.05531121417880058, 0.039684247225522995, -0.02551351673901081, -0.027888508513569832, 0.01244611106812954, -0.010043928399682045, -0.000042556130210869014, 0.012933517806231976, 0.0462699718773365, 0.005920078605413437, 0.03572467714548111, -0.07273762673139572, 0.03906722366809845, -0.0008982473518699408, 0.05928918346762657, -0.009827885776758194, -0.039385464042425156, -0.04462209343910217, 0.018231840804219246, -0.018690476194024086, -0.01008826494216919, -0.021341508254408836, 0.02319134958088398, 0.019059456884860992, 0.02020663395524025, 0.05101471766829491, -0.027390077710151672, 0.016549967229366302, -0.009597595781087875, -0.01854485087096691, 0.016810018569231033, -0.03430887311697006, 0.0683232918381691, -0.008837434463202953, -0.051558222621679306, 0.004055507481098175, -0.06546982377767563, 0.016749363392591476, -0.02995208278298378, -0.0171703789383173, 0.0004938505007885396, 0.011988796293735504, -0.01371302641928196, -0.02722856216132641, -0.06186182051897049, 0.0057959058322012424, -0.0011474255006760359, 0.010119995102286339, 0.00931039359420538, -0.0009206507820636034, 0.02337985299527645, -0.044185977429151535, -0.0030430734623223543, -0.007671709638088942, 0.0266463290899992, -0.03593991696834564, -0.0005358151975087821, -0.04467011243104935, -0.05827236920595169, -0.025295309722423553, 0.057919908314943314, 0.04914022982120514, 0.04793693870306015, -0.06877525895833969, -0.03347979113459587, -0.035520028322935104, 0.05081360787153244, -0.06607426702976227, 0.016200648620724678, 0.0972285121679306, -0.04067041724920273, 0.011698142625391483, 0.01083568949252367, -0.006612822413444519, -0.05812511965632439, 0.026353923603892326, -0.0004219977417960763, 0.02249731309711933, -0.07110089808702469, -0.06280194222927094, -0.024770282208919525, 0.013912299647927284, -0.020651035010814667, -0.010660016909241676, 0.02022295445203781, -0.0023546351585537195, 0.019585542380809784, 0.03444121405482292, -0.0067763617262244225, -0.00895462092012167, 0.07442803680896759, 0.019057579338550568, 0.02984689362347126, -0.06360764056444168, -0.02142464928328991, -0.03476472571492195, -0.029449613764882088, -0.024063799530267715, -0.09182646125555038, -0.04177314415574074, 0.03879449889063835 ]
<p>I am in a serious doubt about it.</p> <p>Consider a battery of emf E and we connect it to an inductor. Initially the switch is open, now we close the switch. My question is: What mechanism happens just after closing the switch?</p> <p>When we close the switch, the electric field produced in the conductor by the battery causes the electron to flow in the inductor. As the electrons flow inside the inductor, the flux changes and an emf is induced, my question is that how is this induced emf Ldi/dt is equal to the external emf e, not simply by saying Kirchoff voltage law but by the mechanism happening that it should be E only?</p>
g4084
[ 0.04264432564377785, 0.025608649477362633, -0.013166292570531368, 0.01764068938791752, 0.03402707725763321, 0.046821340918540955, 0.05611332505941391, 0.041457440704107285, -0.023262901231646538, -0.04801478236913681, -0.10087895393371582, 0.04433029145002365, 0.05734114721417427, 0.010083271190524101, 0.059531088918447495, 0.006882192566990852, 0.07552817463874817, -0.023931946605443954, 0.03239757567644119, 0.03291355445981026, -0.040284447371959686, 0.04766213893890381, 0.0003561877820175141, 0.0010003162315115333, -0.0060192896053195, -0.012692756950855255, 0.0649375393986702, -0.012939230538904667, 0.00770729873329401, -0.03447094187140465, 0.0011672694236040115, 0.029142795130610466, 0.09451306611299515, -0.03851620480418205, -0.05186091735959053, -0.012074897065758705, -0.0022765821777284145, 0.03617674857378006, -0.016292771324515343, 0.06135411188006401, 0.015212845988571644, 0.048205334693193436, 0.030259808525443077, -0.014134552329778671, 0.009398384019732475, -0.02095028944313526, -0.044366735965013504, 0.008442262187600136, -0.04500551149249077, -0.06102176383137703, -0.03736930713057518, 0.01231860276311636, 0.005274446681141853, 0.04072678089141846, 0.043023109436035156, -0.0036331810988485813, 0.007236056495457888, 0.007428167387843132, -0.013236316852271557, -0.01443805918097496, -0.004065498244017363, 0.02683396078646183, -0.000410211127018556, -0.017426801845431328, 0.009753938764333725, -0.014197107404470444, 0.0037300758995115757, -0.008209437131881714, 0.05042576044797897, 0.019316216930747032, -0.03431550785899162, -0.05206144601106644, -0.038874465972185135, -0.000927884946577251, 0.0615900494158268, 0.04134707897901535, 0.06330646574497223, -0.014491609297692776, 0.047254856675863266, 0.0040864888578653336, -0.09346242249011993, -0.015067013911902905, 0.049686748534440994, 0.014115427620708942, 0.05839395150542259, 0.029649315401911736, -0.00007507058762712404, 0.010017209686338902, -0.023952985182404518, -0.03444992005825043, 0.021453168243169785, -0.0343330018222332, 0.02840641513466835, -0.05863603204488754, -0.06013419106602669, 0.008508757688105106, 0.01182364672422409, 0.044938214123249054, 0.03257651627063751, -0.0408208891749382, -0.026561332866549492, -0.033100761473178864, -0.015307252295315266, -0.02583771012723446, -0.00009412615327164531, 0.04651281237602234, -0.01117242593318224, -0.0106786098331213, -0.04901854321360588, 0.029830092564225197, -0.06311097741127014, -0.06415021419525146, -0.011600215919315815, 0.01999611034989357, 0.006257214117795229, 0.020651746541261673, 0.01112079806625843, -0.016296295449137688, -0.014119146391749382, -0.01795993372797966, -0.018672313541173935, 0.0131272803992033, 0.013562347739934921, -0.029843272641301155, 0.008870210498571396, 0.004383021965622902, -0.019311344251036644, 0.024359233677387238, 0.02205084078013897, 0.015466592274606228, -0.023461155593395233, 0.01477914396673441, -0.007550809998065233, 0.00411495566368103, 0.06238742172718048, 0.04783615097403526, 0.01516010146588087, -0.04556712135672569, -0.00438978336751461, -0.016371168196201324, -0.021565336734056473, -0.05294821038842201, -0.03977029770612717, -0.003920666873455048, -0.03373948857188225, 0.07256624847650528, 0.0022836585994809866, -0.03598089888691902, 0.060730449855327606, 0.01989886723458767, 0.011780744418501854, 0.05118183046579361, -0.04610482230782509, -0.009701802395284176, 0.05521214008331299, 0.0007971703307703137, 0.052572693675756454, 0.027494505047798157, 0.004604831337928772, -0.022301724180579185, 0.030061669647693634, -0.003457675687968731, 0.01198830921202898, 0.02543647401034832, -0.027013767510652542, 0.048052627593278885, 0.07071448117494583, -0.025684427469968796, 0.0013000329490751028, -0.011997356079518795, -0.09586773067712784, -0.015469806268811226, 0.019897017627954483, 0.048317696899175644, -0.014548443257808685, 0.06763248145580292, -0.00495500210672617, -0.022125182673335075, 0.020973023027181625, 0.0017154290108010173, -0.027304839342832565, 0.0008204756304621696, 0.03342656418681145, -0.04432442784309387, -0.029414033517241478, 0.023478228598833084, -0.05347954481840134, 0.00982725527137518, -0.06330782920122147, -0.0009411377250216901, -0.0066898176446557045, 0.015967827290296555, -0.018351322039961815, 0.028051434084773064, -0.017602380365133286, -0.008008556440472603, -0.010502060875296593, -0.03449717164039612, -0.022118309512734413, -0.04883486032485962, 0.02103092521429062, 0.037233639508485794, 0.04851740971207619, 0.008620399050414562, -0.021203985437750816, -0.007176660932600498, -0.023198571056127548, -0.022592563182115555, 0.037623364478349686, -0.02084413543343544, 0.029392361640930176, 0.014320909045636654, -0.009814777411520481, -0.0014894460327923298, -0.05299930274486542, -0.003628452541306615, 0.009459810331463814, -0.006322289351373911, -0.045373979955911636, -0.024336855858564377, -0.0299367755651474, -0.03179262578487396, 0.06795243173837662, -0.023134781047701836, -0.0771508440375328, -0.002840787172317505, -0.019463520497083664, -0.019097788259387016, -0.035678260028362274, -0.0008623732719570398, -0.04963051527738571, 0.044200558215379715, -0.030162867158651352, -0.0476747564971447, -0.013090992346405983, 0.06425158679485321, 0.004136429168283939, -0.014733294025063515, 0.0038498626090586185, -0.04237997904419899, 0.0258198045194149, -0.015430360101163387, 0.01613086462020874, 0.0017183249583467841, -0.02726799249649048, -0.06828289479017258, 0.06356226652860641, -0.0047904374077916145, -0.00864378735423088, -0.0162627175450325, -0.006590963341295719, -0.017567653208971024, -0.02536449208855629, 0.018177460879087448, -0.03815518319606781, -0.06207850202918053, -0.028137262910604477, 0.05783192068338394, -0.0044964151456952095, -0.0010731278453022242, 0.001679273322224617, 0.016727300360798836, 0.028653092682361603, 0.016540521755814552, -0.03537077456712723, 0.005131750833243132, 0.024659907445311546, -0.05827469378709793, 0.03356530889868736, -0.019066279754042625, -0.007493293844163418, 0.14332592487335205, -0.02018802799284458, 0.012611101381480694, 0.07631701976060867, -0.00019331231305841357, -0.004293249920010567, -0.033762820065021515, -0.01274863164871931, -0.02852769009768963, -0.03272956982254982, -0.01590237393975258, -0.08926254510879517, -0.0042477319948375225, 0.01252597663551569, -0.03131941705942154, 0.03812199458479881, -0.034431274980306625, -0.056097276508808136, 0.004676193930208683, -0.041940025985240936, -0.02415413223206997, 0.017484350129961967, 0.019216740503907204, 0.04066862910985947, 0.009961804375052452, 0.05609976872801781, -0.009958085604012012, -0.05485197901725769, -0.016148250550031662, -0.003370089689269662, -0.07667656987905502, -0.014134743250906467, -0.0229943860322237, 0.006855375599116087, 0.043627042323350906, -0.02563532255589962, -0.048698678612709045, -0.04164591431617737, 0.02163327857851982, -0.03904026001691818, -0.03861002251505852, 0.04356018081307411, -0.0527489148080349, -0.031622447073459625, 0.015779918059706688, -0.01393045298755169, 0.0239106435328722, 0.011592602357268333, -0.06640150398015976, -0.02916344627737999, -0.05421663448214531, 0.01537124440073967, 0.003305491991341114, 0.011106528341770172, -0.008256503380835056, -0.034302808344364166, 0.013634218834340572, -0.015200911089777946, -0.03624744713306427, -0.02023409679532051, 0.03638383746147156, -0.036505188792943954, -0.012186376377940178, -0.0007188076269812882, 0.04513135179877281, -0.05518301576375961, 0.08821661025285721, -0.0010373241966590285, 0.04347306862473488, 0.044040415436029434, -0.019727706909179688, -0.050771113485097885, 0.003704521805047989, 0.04435482621192932, 0.050339434295892715, 0.010663142427802086, -0.019004836678504944, -0.004451122134923935, 0.00902986153960228, 0.025210410356521606, -0.02596760354936123, 0.032160479575395584, 0.025910889729857445, -0.02321687899529934, -0.001730309217236936, -0.01698523573577404, 0.013016929849982262, -0.027775418013334274, 0.027585122734308243, -0.024091070517897606, -0.04938916489481926, -0.021681329235434532, 0.029053550213575363, -0.022136708721518517, -0.021257001906633377, 0.054071828722953796, 0.014907262288033962, -0.045563727617263794, -0.0654873475432396, -0.007408818230032921, -0.04204077646136284, -0.037745602428913116, 0.07384008169174194, 0.012383338063955307, -0.030369000509381294, 0.03485063090920448, 0.05278632789850235, -0.017381520941853523, 0.011443396098911762, -0.009041615761816502, 0.0822351947426796, 0.005820182617753744, 0.007507337257266045, 0.08666107803583145, -0.012000326067209244, -0.03214890509843826, 0.06585799157619476, 0.003861937439069152, -0.019794469699263573, -0.01804462820291519, 0.015558960847556591, 0.021803269162774086, -0.02250860631465912, 0.030652161687612534, 0.03332226723432541, 0.02136692963540554, -0.039696794003248215, 0.03282386064529419, -0.04103254899382591, 0.025576580315828323, 0.030321402475237846, -0.008359227329492569, -0.02257797122001648, -0.0006571706617251039, 0.022769199684262276, 0.032260309904813766, 0.0028852589894086123, 0.08144557476043701, -0.029151352122426033, 0.0038278570864349604, 0.021727755665779114, -0.08033184707164764, -0.03863832727074623, -0.013444502837955952, 0.002743845572695136, 0.0693555399775505, 0.053887221962213516, 0.04174366220831871, -0.045392200350761414, 0.03679246827960014, -0.012925191782414913, 0.03507475182414055, -0.03764301910996437, -0.040799807757139206, 0.05030236765742302, 0.07365290075540543, 0.006935232784599066, 0.023419635370373726, -0.05810641124844551, -0.035034965723752975, 0.014812987297773361, -0.02622029185295105, -0.01099850982427597, -0.04246443510055542, 0.041048403829336166, -0.007444399408996105, 0.06855809688568115, -0.011765792034566402, 0.042375728487968445, 0.0959402546286583, -0.043357834219932556, 0.017071031033992767, 0.02478780969977379, -0.020616987720131874, 0.014868402853608131, -0.04040302708745003, -0.03324533626437187, 0.013533364050090313, -0.030394356697797775, -0.0038455561734735966, 0.05522744357585907, 0.002671645488590002, -0.007807260844856501, 0.03487791493535042, -0.011256746016442776, 0.005017236340790987, 0.0016473621362820268, -0.013258077204227448, 0.010206309147179127, -0.06210020184516907, -0.03720630705356598, -0.0437711738049984, 0.0651150718331337, 0.05355025455355644, -0.024369562044739723, 0.027782708406448364, -0.036974020302295685, -0.05755509063601494, 0.011800871230661869, 0.07610104233026505, 0.055636391043663025, 0.007577364332973957, 0.013819362036883831, 0.10159019380807877, -0.015966476872563362, 0.010026476345956326, 0.021942906081676483, 0.003129018936306238, -0.052084945142269135, 0.033083055168390274, -0.08104066550731659, 0.004000592976808548, 0.0291634239256382, 0.0019680571276694536, -0.061753496527671814, -0.07806048542261124, 0.0034919818863272667, -0.004189511761069298, -0.03627052530646324, 0.03990708664059639, 0.05217350274324417, 0.037884727120399475, -0.028394827619194984, -0.027933917939662933, 0.0467454232275486, 0.01952885463833809, 0.02932528220117092, -0.03096623159945011, -0.02447807416319847, -0.06148873269557953, 0.00925862230360508, -0.06590278446674347, 0.038371652364730835, -0.001791259739547968, 0.062071505934000015, -0.05879785120487213, -0.04186476022005081, -0.004578882362693548, -0.01641640067100525, -0.032146912068128586, 0.024827517569065094, -0.04240160435438156, 0.025450313463807106, 0.01934606395661831, 0.02479706145823002, -0.07403770834207535, -0.0007184850983321667, -0.013981406576931477, 0.0022281287238001823, 0.03244193643331528, 0.0007853744318708777, 0.009161845780909061, -0.005545556079596281, -0.019308526068925858, -0.025776581838726997, -0.03359867259860039, -0.005131829530000687, 0.04966201260685921, 0.06158946454524994, 0.0038514481857419014, 0.06452570110559464, 0.019942913204431534, 0.01272929459810257, -0.00043944825301878154, -0.026472019031643867, 0.06398683041334152, 0.007193669211119413, -0.03314611315727234, 0.0801330953836441, 0.042784374207258224, -0.0032699534203857183, 0.03933100402355194, 0.04808931052684784, 0.014477415941655636, -0.01054339949041605, 0.012501492165029049, -0.04544294625520706, 0.0008890404715202749, -0.06928610056638718, -0.010971046052873135, 0.0021035359241068363, 0.016282251104712486, 0.0069146789610385895, 0.027171362191438675, -0.019721653312444687, 0.0008559491252526641, 0.015937695279717445, -0.0024727981071919203, 0.01518061850219965, 0.04767641797661781, 0.02429964393377304, 0.022987565025687218, -0.028878046199679375, 0.08912766724824905, 0.011013421230018139, 0.01083212811499834, 0.04029426351189613, 0.05717813968658447, -0.001609030645340681, 0.029313664883375168, -0.054498881101608276, -0.004412512760609388, -0.057002320885658264, 0.025354484096169472, 0.04505184665322304, 0.004645225591957569, -0.0301100742071867, -0.018433960154652596, -0.01068610604852438, -0.013311357237398624, 0.0072669414803385735, 0.04741222783923149, -0.014062042348086834, -0.0504625178873539, 0.010217561386525631, -0.021126437932252884, -0.07236196100711823, 0.044138114899396896, 0.014094316400587559, -0.017408376559615135, -0.056520070880651474, 0.027482399716973305, 0.05779547244310379, -0.01496678777039051, 0.029490267857909203, -0.040927693247795105, -0.01509326882660389, 0.04082363843917847, 0.04180929809808731, -0.005982365924865007, 0.03337852656841278, 0.00614081509411335, -0.06440385431051254, 0.0018003368750214577, 0.006028803996741772, -0.00902539398521185, 0.015101389959454536, -0.062309060245752335, 0.014335826970636845, 0.015365964733064175, -0.039690051227808, -0.008096404373645782, -0.044946059584617615, -0.04673844948410988, 0.014670727774500847, -0.01552989799529314, 0.03347630426287651, 0.02261749655008316, 0.05838654190301895, -0.050050221383571625, -0.06866398453712463, 0.06664415448904037, 0.03967918083071709, -0.0179887842386961, 0.0678979828953743, -0.00768341775983572, 0.000701849814504385, 0.04044142737984657, -0.011923106387257576, -0.03892280533909798, 0.01412491500377655, -0.048292238265275955, 0.031578462570905685, 0.03318003937602043, -0.026226146146655083, 0.05465405061841011, -0.01619970239698887, 0.018727706745266914, -0.010341801680624485, 0.02212277613580227, 0.0599045492708683, -0.024565277621150017, 0.07961239665746689, -0.017744552344083786, -0.015091895125806332, 0.024977175518870354, -0.006230389699339867, -0.06683455407619476, -0.04034798964858055, -0.006024282891303301, 0.02826070785522461, -0.022790895774960518, -0.04902209714055061, 0.0048800804652273655, 0.00011316938616801053, 0.04805879294872284, -0.003123435191810131, -0.013054626062512398, -0.03492731973528862, 0.027241215109825134, -0.026513714343309402, 0.004709633532911539, 0.01041177287697792, 0.04133906215429306, 0.0025046796072274446, -0.039166904985904694, -0.06455700844526291, 0.0054597510024905205, -0.03523756563663483, -0.019671620801091194, -0.0767400935292244, -0.011515645310282707, 0.029660696163773537, -0.051549702882766724, -0.015893401578068733, 0.01179573405534029, 0.033678214997053146, 0.0005525634624063969, 0.009371328167617321, -0.04962138086557388, 0.038302164524793625, -0.037233252078294754, -0.06276144832372665, -0.05112456530332565, 0.026358310133218765, -0.01638525165617466, -0.05723027512431145, -0.06526689231395721, 0.03884884715080261, 0.03701719269156456, -0.0008339315536431968, 0.049954988062381744, 0.0061966413632035255, 0.019740035757422447, -0.0030975656118243933, 0.0402514673769474, 0.0005746717215515673, 0.00003975361687480472, 0.014521108940243721, 0.035218749195337296, -0.015574637800455093, 0.007565010339021683, 0.04835256189107895, -0.0050106048583984375, 0.002538017462939024, -0.01516801118850708, -0.00682039326056838, -0.05758066475391388, 0.04819463938474655, 0.04759937524795532, -0.03832267224788666, 0.001464111846871674, 0.030063219368457794, 0.007960253395140171, -0.0010769024956971407, -0.019557645544409752, 0.043956659734249115, 0.04769952967762947, 0.02811133861541748, -0.03594054654240608, -0.000479562790133059, -0.004533424973487854, 0.009579010307788849, -0.05110027641057968, -0.040666256099939346, -0.017185095697641373, -0.012973925098776817, 0.03737884759902954, -0.017354216426610947, 0.010137724690139294, -0.029817907139658928, 0.06082547828555107, -0.04267514869570732, -0.035296712070703506, -0.016115186735987663, -0.004484369419515133, -0.010518189519643784, 0.02664961665868759, -0.002041576197370887, -0.0030522586312144995, -0.05349064618349075, -0.03201976791024208, -0.008690555579960346, 0.022059617564082146, -0.03893887251615524, -0.006343897897750139, -0.008208460174500942, -0.00590529153123498, 0.05007445067167282, 0.002332189353182912, -0.06444451212882996, -0.06504951417446136, 0.018755627796053886, 0.09336403012275696, -0.03727896139025688, -0.1015365868806839, 0.0024087214842438698, -0.0011907495791092515, -0.01032852940261364, -0.06231047958135605, -0.005629641469568014, -0.03543007746338844, -0.00897150207310915, -0.004120214376598597, 0.015266695991158485, 0.023450680077075958, 0.028647197410464287 ]
<p>I got given this question and im just lost.</p> <blockquote> <p>An object that weighs 25 kg experiences two perpendicular forces of 80N and 50N respectively. </p> <p>What's the acceleration that object gets?</p> </blockquote> <p>What i don't understand is how i would use that information to work out the answer.</p> <p>Any Thought, I would like to know how you worked it out and what the answer is..</p> <p><em>I believe that it would be 30N as gravity is not in play here, nor would be mass of the object affect the acceleration due to unknown factors.</em></p>
g4085
[ 0.0822162926197052, 0.09204865992069244, 0.01085922122001648, -0.028289446607232094, 0.04923771694302559, 0.04709995537996292, 0.014883741736412048, 0.01654616929590702, -0.08584445714950562, -0.05561063811182976, -0.006365941371768713, 0.02467186748981476, 0.0004982426762580872, -0.021438341587781906, 0.03501398116350174, 0.004424883984029293, 0.04176909476518631, -0.07317411154508591, -0.011064437218010426, 0.037577513605356216, -0.00781663041561842, 0.026389140635728836, -0.040610481053590775, -0.05289255455136299, -0.012529240921139717, 0.02126140147447586, 0.018130697309970856, -0.018863415345549583, -0.0908459946513176, 0.014290588907897472, 0.021380074322223663, -0.035837847739458084, 0.036918506026268005, -0.059742629528045654, -0.06995685398578644, -0.022812915965914726, 0.03507576510310173, 0.03956601768732071, 0.02552032470703125, -0.010663209483027458, 0.04256511107087135, -0.04937780275940895, 0.004335347563028336, -0.030725780874490738, -0.004444328136742115, 0.010751187801361084, -0.010271265171468258, 0.0022015057038515806, -0.02360863797366619, -0.015720799565315247, -0.09252327680587769, 0.017188047990202904, 0.043977003544569016, 0.018314208835363388, 0.006877785548567772, 0.030804578214883804, 0.05661189556121826, -0.011545475572347641, 0.06410878896713257, 0.047508176416158676, -0.042703744024038315, 0.019222648814320564, 0.0368969663977623, -0.04183177277445793, 0.0795389711856842, -0.011692311614751816, -0.021203268319368362, 0.047562409192323685, 0.046704042702913284, 0.01909532956779003, 0.025311581790447235, -0.006521862465888262, -0.029788197949528694, -0.02215619385242462, -0.043483152985572815, 0.0006782030686736107, -0.007027581799775362, 0.005864945240318775, -0.0037413528189063072, 0.04885640740394592, 0.0017268294468522072, 0.0488138310611248, 0.011615092866122723, -0.002756495028734207, 0.07128278911113739, -0.033913109451532364, -0.024588311091065407, 0.0538170263171196, -0.04339123144745827, -0.03373764827847481, 0.07240740954875946, -0.026105863973498344, 0.06486165523529053, 0.051058217883110046, -0.008763130754232407, -0.04609863460063934, -0.012597552500665188, 0.08533371239900589, -0.03140237182378769, -0.018019424751400948, -0.014024900272488594, 0.026484835892915726, -0.018249254673719406, -0.04691087454557419, 0.021753542125225067, 0.013323436491191387, 0.04207277297973633, 0.019537538290023804, -0.03491608798503876, -0.07613486051559448, -0.05740536004304886, -0.02997920662164688, -0.03220862150192261, -0.056308597326278687, -0.040140267461538315, -0.06849120557308197, 0.06860321760177612, 0.02211044169962406, -0.011028251610696316, 0.032300520688295364, -0.01246507465839386, 0.024234170094132423, -0.008876065723598003, 0.061277467757463455, -0.01857512630522251, -0.024375291541218758, -0.015699828043580055, 0.000889289251063019, -0.037225864827632904, -0.10275761783123016, 0.043917931616306305, 0.019819047302007675, 0.03247011825442314, -0.019703952595591545, 0.014976797625422478, 0.011992068961262703, -0.0706506222486496, 0.04539787024259567, -0.02458103746175766, -0.018496621400117874, -0.011060758493840694, -0.018473345786333084, -0.012064811773598194, -0.022520922124385834, -0.017326438799500465, 0.010305581614375114, 0.0005475645884871483, 0.034949664026498795, 0.04922979697585106, 0.004589749034494162, 0.0008157692500390112, 0.04882191866636276, -0.01105736568570137, -0.06323201954364777, 0.06667600572109222, -0.038549378514289856, 0.0391693077981472, -0.006806256715208292, -0.009494406171143055, -0.03049885295331478, 0.06154293194413185, 0.04398338869214058, 0.05825767293572426, -0.011954193003475666, -0.06906913965940475, 0.02525179460644722, -0.0018867107573896646, -0.016283906996250153, -0.015537383034825325, -0.050060804933309555, -0.04054480046033859, -0.026012985035777092, 0.03498367220163345, 0.06020089238882065, 0.0033752131275832653, 0.027734946459531784, 0.05943255499005318, -0.03224583715200424, 0.02351718582212925, 0.05546921119093895, 0.024383744224905968, -0.04063916951417923, 0.02797585539519787, -0.0281844325363636, -0.01918097399175167, -0.02723061665892601, 0.03175336867570877, 0.0798083171248436, -0.010977162048220634, 0.032203465700149536, -0.06263554096221924, -0.03703152760863304, 0.010002714581787586, 0.007566706743091345, -0.05102868005633354, -0.04053616151213646, -0.003999671898782253, 0.02393689565360546, -0.03747853636741638, -0.007351799868047237, -0.035010579973459244, 0.017610818147659302, 0.049947481602430344, 0.021417848765850067, 0.02599390782415867, 0.02272643707692623, -0.01669578067958355, 0.013874325901269913, 0.03411439061164856, -0.03843937814235687, 0.013142237439751625, 0.033596958965063095, 0.008596934378147125, 0.060338519513607025, 0.02421080879867077, 0.008623997680842876, 0.014115521684288979, 0.01915563829243183, -0.005256266798824072, -0.023004096001386642, 0.030494144186377525, -0.02598673105239868, 0.029430469498038292, -0.011358183808624744, -0.05746833607554436, -0.04193808138370514, 0.01956355944275856, -0.020519547164440155, 0.024297721683979034, 0.024499842897057533, -0.052103277295827866, -0.019070042297244072, 0.0026338815223425627, -0.006149922031909227, 0.041854243725538254, 0.03245971351861954, 0.016223333775997162, 0.003961487207561731, -0.022369030863046646, 0.009967765770852566, 0.014239482581615448, 0.019776824861764908, -0.013136163353919983, -0.02994488552212715, 0.01796623319387436, -0.06721411645412445, 0.08783546090126038, -0.0045452541671693325, 0.03003695420920849, 0.029785512015223503, -0.019202783703804016, -0.025021256878972054, -0.06375568360090256, 0.02096199430525303, 0.029487701132893562, 0.021578941494226456, -0.07349564880132675, 0.0006515395361930132, -0.04137969762086868, -0.012386282905936241, -0.008940757252275944, -0.013450045138597488, 0.0322347991168499, 0.06933090090751648, -0.11116546392440796, -0.02070598304271698, -0.04537762328982353, -0.00220106216147542, 0.029993249103426933, -0.00021263177040964365, -0.017722297459840775, 0.03085201233625412, -0.026717951521277428, 0.032143786549568176, 0.004601369611918926, -0.02524499222636223, 0.002836576197296381, -0.01715460792183876, -0.004965662024915218, -0.015131878666579723, -0.022789176553487778, 0.03782249987125397, -0.012639040127396584, 0.06051381304860115, 0.028522014617919922, 0.029749182984232903, -0.015970442444086075, -0.01980551891028881, -0.0009929140796884894, -0.016077673062682152, -0.052097927778959274, 0.05920666083693504, 0.07066948711872101, -0.004114243667572737, 0.060222920030355453, 0.06335597485303879, 0.0032737513538450003, -0.0008490981417708099, -0.024239923804998398, -0.007351500913500786, 0.008126995526254177, -0.05426345765590668, 0.02475862391293049, 0.004648246802389622, -0.02366849035024643, -0.02656025066971779, -0.029785383492708206, -0.052263643592596054, -0.0068196384236216545, 0.02187471278011799, -0.06016502529382706, 0.048419058322906494, 0.008686022832989693, 0.014597835019230843, -0.07136783003807068, -0.03157051280140877, 0.022737745195627213, -0.014062696136534214, 0.023702125996351242, -0.07593775540590286, -0.02139212004840374, -0.10728437453508377, 0.003940036986023188, 0.023897899314761162, -0.00834875088185072, 0.044057004153728485, -0.029088133946061134, 0.027006937190890312, 0.058238111436367035, -0.06022607535123825, 0.0014322781935334206, -0.016015324741601944, -0.04281672462821007, 0.0008184806210920215, -0.020532261580228806, 0.007925690151751041, 0.021650899201631546, 0.0024156307335942984, 0.048221878707408905, 0.07472803443670273, -0.0138331213966012, -0.048424653708934784, -0.018216218799352646, 0.010090956464409828, 0.006456688512116671, 0.032497651875019073, 0.019508948549628258, -0.018968455493450165, -0.0074651483446359634, -0.0066122510470449924, 0.0514603853225708, -0.04305468872189522, -0.03786158561706543, -0.012086675502359867, 0.032446298748254776, -0.023701567202806473, 0.02331523410975933, 0.002650905167683959, -0.06913381814956665, 0.03751453757286072, 0.014206509105861187, 0.0190158411860466, -0.0024618247989565134, 0.029366249218583107, -0.012193271890282631, -0.002544715767726302, -0.01883861981332302, 0.10278413444757462, -0.04242770001292229, -0.0386824756860733, 0.01291037630289793, -0.04959120601415634, -0.0022540735080838203, -0.0265513826161623, 0.02847209759056568, -0.0489300973713398, 0.05622856318950653, -0.05494794249534607, -0.006055379752069712, 0.02479724958539009, 0.025433829054236412, 0.03944600373506546, 0.012376259081065655, 0.015767084434628487, 0.031120672821998596, -0.005960582755506039, -0.016943547874689102, -0.02779928781092167, 0.0691571906208992, -0.049720700830221176, -0.005988162010908127, -0.039003510028123856, -0.05775998532772064, 0.02076605148613453, 0.03111443482339382, 0.01326312031596899, 0.004378749057650566, -0.027398068457841873, -0.0023586817551404238, 0.02835267409682274, 0.021543510258197784, 0.031136082485318184, 0.0355929397046566, -0.0218791700899601, -0.0579848513007164, 0.0672348216176033, 0.03606390953063965, -0.024098355323076248, 0.001332045765593648, 0.04300369322299957, 0.035060204565525055, 0.04140700772404671, -0.013779490254819393, -0.037439364939928055, 0.006322494242340326, -0.028841504827141762, 0.0608239471912384, 0.06326744705438614, -0.008585335686802864, 0.007871218025684357, 0.004289141856133938, 0.05974438041448593, -0.05147779732942581, -0.05101059377193451, -0.0008339474443346262, 0.030949648469686508, 0.01227518916130066, -0.018079178407788277, 0.005875065922737122, 0.03700624406337738, 0.013927454128861427, 0.031241415068507195, 0.016544662415981293, 0.029917752370238304, -0.03858239948749542, 0.09225120395421982, 0.024904118850827217, 0.057753998786211014, 0.040837228298187256, -0.007232163101434708, -0.0002426954306429252, 0.014391500502824783, -0.006180155090987682, 0.0028491474222391844, -0.013807696290314198, 0.06399639695882797, 0.021726349368691444, -0.05882927402853966, -0.00975489430129528, 0.009160749614238739, -0.003687387565150857, -0.02544114552438259, -0.0065189553424716, -0.05685582384467125, 0.053279511630535126, 0.03475676476955414, 0.0494118332862854, -0.004537545144557953, -0.03245153650641441, 0.0018533292459324002, -0.07783985882997513, -0.024366894736886024, -0.0008053079363889992, -0.01949150487780571, -0.03567919507622719, -0.04560890048742294, -0.006688574329018593, 0.022913139313459396, -0.03189901262521744, 0.04195272549986839, -0.021162694320082664, -0.05006866902112961, 0.012609175406396389, 0.03450018912553787, 0.04865989461541176, 0.034506697207689285, 0.00047190155601128936, -0.024138690903782845, 0.06534941494464874, 0.0026477870997041464, -0.04265205189585686, -0.02099028415977955, 0.029415886849164963, -0.033256106078624725, -0.0008536131936125457, -0.016051677986979485, -0.060106150805950165, 0.024236518889665604, 0.06306587159633636, -0.03257004916667938, -0.02022014558315277, 0.03274013474583626, -0.06626784056425095, -0.024917511269450188, -0.07232550531625748, 0.038517169654369354, -0.04404649883508682, -0.00542202964425087, 0.027360539883375168, -0.025745568796992302, -0.03632846847176552, 0.008875694125890732, 0.016803691163659096, 0.014762903563678265, 0.011964322067797184, 0.05059421434998512, 0.012990270741283894, -0.04536664858460426, 0.07163292169570923, 0.051533255726099014, -0.015035100281238556, 0.04290245100855827, 0.0399104468524456, -0.011440342292189598, -0.019909722730517387, -0.015124899335205555, 0.052431244403123856, 0.01564675010740757, -0.0004889002302661538, -0.022867335006594658, 0.04866940528154373, -0.013834862969815731, 0.013714903965592384, -0.016130903735756874, 0.007456218358129263, 0.017963694408535957, -0.03878374770283699, 0.007396413013339043, 0.008007270283997059, -0.00027642626082524657, 0.019514095038175583, -0.004546063020825386, 0.026084385812282562, -0.08845207840204239, -0.04813867434859276, -0.029940370470285416, 0.07372241467237473, -0.012857276014983654, 0.047573186457157135, -0.06146363541483879, -0.03393173590302467, -0.0007559893419966102, 0.0019274699734523892, 0.04539981484413147, 0.0007217579404823482, 0.0035817071329802275, -0.02842697687447071, -0.023568645119667053, 0.05950465425848961, -0.022901860997080803, -0.005444969981908798, 0.06424300372600555, 0.022463591769337654, 0.0029546995647251606, 0.04222777113318443, 0.06834519654512405, 0.031832288950681686, 0.004014097154140472, -0.016402937471866608, -0.0405103862285614, 0.058348774909973145, -0.007945055142045021, 0.06533719599246979, -0.01543200109153986, 0.034302935004234314, -0.04655551537871361, -0.00581970252096653, -0.004529647529125214, 0.03781158849596977, -0.01339746080338955, -0.026219749823212624, 0.020671267062425613, -0.04763435572385788, 0.03305421024560928, 0.06645885854959488, 0.03511133790016174, -0.01909097656607628, 0.03175561875104904, -0.04650436341762543, 0.04455742612481117, -0.0025775048416107893, 0.008023377507925034, -0.005479727406054735, -0.005606969818472862, -0.03476394712924957, -9.172693182790681e-8, -0.015531913377344608, 0.0002839926746673882, 0.0414874367415905, -0.05809831619262695, -0.0465717688202858, 0.02406618557870388, -0.014193828217685223, -0.0697656199336052, -0.06996332854032516, -0.003967370372265577, 0.019220782443881035, -0.006576036103069782, -0.020907310768961906, 0.03176768869161606, 0.01860175095498562, 0.02687443606555462, 0.03757103160023689, -0.014277867041528225, 0.04990597814321518, -0.023042120039463043, -0.0608966238796711, -0.003826048457995057, -0.0569249652326107, -0.048942070454359055, -0.02956380881369114, 0.03921731188893318, 0.005734398495405912, 0.021429697051644325, -0.006624546833336353, 0.0157232154160738, 0.006362895015627146, -0.019287709146738052, -0.04895859211683273, -0.03152761235833168, 0.017291327938437462, -0.014969859272241592, 0.0013606236316263676, -0.05463719740509987, -0.009025203995406628, -0.029493847861886024, -0.04004506766796112, -0.0016906692180782557, 0.01611415110528469, -0.008294990286231041, -0.027810541912913322, 0.016085185110569, 0.027097580954432487, 0.013861279934644699, 0.0013281796127557755, 0.06010240316390991, 0.0006871767691336572, 0.024543214589357376, 0.022671936079859734, 0.004086269997060299, 0.02386516146361828, 0.00422607222571969, -0.0713692232966423, 0.023858720436692238, -0.07469584047794342, -0.01582658477127552, -0.0026866011321544647, 0.01745404675602913, -0.019044682383537292, -0.03702196851372719, -0.02040390484035015, -0.04620523378252983, 0.004424697253853083, 0.003689805744215846, -0.04373598098754883, 0.012430057860910892, 0.0815059095621109, -0.030696015805006027, 0.029431801289319992, -0.039336785674095154, -0.080386683344841, -0.05419238284230232, 0.008298808708786964, 0.032390471547842026, -0.05398663878440857, -0.021797576919198036, -0.04185381159186363, 0.016491970047354698, 0.001147410017438233, 0.04951050505042076, -0.060280345380306244, -0.015698246657848358, -0.012094298377633095, 0.03729476034641266, 0.013946007937192917, 0.03099125623703003, -0.050134673714637756, -0.03580257669091225, 0.005283081438392401, 0.02403825893998146, -0.0008612211677245796, 0.0706256553530693, -0.037956297397613525, 0.004067759960889816, -0.02704728953540325, 0.0180421881377697, -0.03218337148427963, 0.012683253735303879, 0.031877193599939346, -0.024796677753329277, 0.011641793884336948, 0.06965354084968567, 0.04285269230604172, 0.0021605787333101034, -0.045154936611652374, 0.004204006399959326, -0.037044838070869446, 0.035359714180231094, 0.016962075605988503, 0.02433301880955696, -0.026958085596561432, -0.026303039863705635, -0.004035471938550472, -0.004967565182596445, -0.04942067712545395, 0.018017403781414032, -0.01869121752679348, -0.012627885676920414, -0.010323455557227135, -0.011288768611848354, 0.04319944977760315, -0.04258185997605324, 0.019759653136134148, -0.021756578236818314, 0.02138826623558998, 0.06090598553419113, -0.0043951161205768585, 0.024136077612638474, 0.01655680499970913, -0.0016328325727954507, 0.017301583662629128, 0.03680935502052307, 0.00035308144288137555, -0.05770237371325493, -0.03480587154626846, -0.057560063898563385, -0.06104523688554764, 0.03645804151892662, -0.027361318469047546, 0.008492384105920792, 0.011638590134680271, 0.011031350120902061, -0.007435872219502926, -0.010653452016413212, 0.014019821770489216, 0.02256871573626995, 0.03939150273799896, -0.055326636880636215, -0.01563204638659954, 0.024544674903154373, 0.021234067156910896, -0.009064365178346634, -0.05058211088180542, 0.017304230481386185, -0.010218434035778046, -0.0355939157307148, -0.0644344687461853, 0.055503346025943756, 0.018940813839435577, -0.014277816750109196, 0.0390140675008297, -0.02491859905421734, -0.037153150886297226, 0.02298361249268055, -0.03337959572672844, -0.03303385153412819, -0.050611745566129684, 0.04676634445786476, -0.019675852730870247, -0.01743731088936329, 0.03693830221891403, 0.05530257150530815, -0.00944022461771965, -0.025389179587364197, 0.018358081579208374, -0.010412628762423992, -0.05661001056432724, 0.03568428009748459 ]
<p>Is the flow of time regular? How would we come to know if the <strong>our</strong> galaxy along with everything in it stops for a while(may be a century) <strong>w.r.t to the galaxies far beyond our reach</strong>. Is there a way to know if flow of time is smooth,or irregular?</p> <p>PS I would describe myself as an illiterate physics enthusiast, so I hope you'll forgive me if my ignorance is borderline offensive.</p>
g4086
[ 0.0563003309071064, 0.008313455618917942, -0.0027400690596550703, -0.02227969840168953, 0.003624427830800414, -0.015050839632749557, 0.032856859266757965, 0.019470196217298508, 0.02878112904727459, -0.02637011744081974, 0.03404621034860611, 0.0010952709708362818, 0.029417481273412704, 0.03286981210112572, 0.03128843009471893, -0.03280257433652878, 0.03344140201807022, -0.02813061699271202, 0.04668431729078293, 0.031068934127688408, -0.012193904258310795, -0.019465306773781776, 0.08829976618289948, -0.012999371625483036, -0.01579771377146244, -0.03439924865961075, -0.023928998038172722, -0.02910766564309597, -0.006225030403584242, -0.04902033880352974, 0.039585549384355545, -0.0054553234949707985, 0.04893197491765022, -0.025568634271621704, 0.0025752561632543802, -0.0012818488758057356, -0.014581620693206787, -0.01754682883620262, 0.06210216507315636, 0.03398977965116501, -0.008395169861614704, 0.015586765483021736, -0.016942637041211128, 0.009743288159370422, 0.024406611919403076, 0.027822593227028847, -0.05713570490479469, 0.009090859442949295, 0.013039562851190567, 0.02438151091337204, -0.09216409921646118, 0.013548311777412891, -0.004351571202278137, -0.000025698145691421814, -0.03704885020852089, 0.0250029806047678, 0.027093855664134026, -0.037918850779533386, 0.01900802180171013, -0.013785082846879959, -0.03508272394537926, -0.029520342126488686, 0.06310448050498962, 0.013774758204817772, -0.0030768956057727337, -0.013251194730401039, -0.06464064866304398, -0.0191641878336668, 0.03189241513609886, 0.006701305508613586, 0.022771114483475685, -0.032900743186473846, -0.0023770909756422043, 0.00648904824629426, -0.038361556828022, 0.08019737899303436, -0.00381358340382576, 0.06542782485485077, -0.017260096967220306, 0.014565582387149334, -0.01743406429886818, -0.018623651936650276, -0.028020545840263367, 0.011715570464730263, 0.0003909086808562279, 0.0046987878158688545, -0.028609102591872215, -0.017322836443781853, 0.04270165041089058, 0.05306162312626839, 0.023691916838288307, -0.05336550995707512, 0.04699334502220154, -0.006223251577466726, 0.03982199728488922, -0.05039903521537781, -0.015077623538672924, 0.05990985035896301, -0.029508931562304497, 0.04062328115105629, -0.013625860214233398, 0.03343601152300835, -0.011679868213832378, -0.026944458484649658, -0.023160384967923164, -0.02242608368396759, -0.044814206659793854, -0.006245319731533527, -0.0019100750796496868, -0.06581417471170425, -0.015921859070658684, -0.014884617179632187, -0.0068205236457288265, 0.08564861118793488, -0.008657269179821014, 0.017358602955937386, 0.03237667679786682, 0.024468176066875458, 0.009944322519004345, 0.01984219066798687, 0.003979130182415247, -0.005881491582840681, -0.023413926362991333, -0.011440139263868332, -0.05873429775238037, 0.005897833965718746, 0.031985580921173096, 0.0043185558170080185, 0.026272300630807877, 0.057543788105249405, 0.014840968884527683, 0.04480239748954773, 0.022947993129491806, 0.01699168235063553, -0.018230151385068893, -0.009367656894028187, 0.027413979172706604, -0.006519924383610487, -0.007245171349495649, 0.03153766691684723, 0.06852460652589798, -0.033383868634700775, 0.011952381581068039, -0.026495838537812233, -0.062331072986125946, 0.008181610144674778, -0.024692853912711143, -0.01599046029150486, 0.031025124713778496, 0.007647158578038216, 0.003765868954360485, 0.07184072583913803, 0.03090718388557434, -0.011779118329286575, -0.026432933285832405, -0.0449376180768013, -0.011428373865783215, 0.02483055181801319, 0.025481950491666794, 0.03897901996970177, 0.02526337467133999, -0.021621454507112503, 0.04424257576465607, 0.0004632791387848556, -0.0636160671710968, -0.012286034412682056, -0.014284689910709858, -0.03920035436749458, 0.05218297988176346, -0.018000053241848946, -0.045554909855127335, -0.011692938394844532, 0.02572414092719555, 0.010340762324631214, 0.009529375471174717, -0.028630657121539116, 0.0484701506793499, -0.03634297102689743, -0.013939496129751205, -0.022049076855182648, -0.04002605006098747, -0.014162651263177395, 0.029381858184933662, -0.04659592732787132, -0.029368309304118156, 0.031968384981155396, -0.042347442358732224, -0.07213009893894196, -0.0011566068278625607, -0.01928248070180416, -0.005055589135736227, -0.04661014676094055, 0.02471318282186985, 0.004079843871295452, 0.02654389664530754, -0.027977537363767624, -0.022255387157201767, -0.05196192115545273, -0.07074003666639328, -0.024913808330893517, -0.009402398951351643, 0.050863634794950485, 0.025497304275631905, 0.025986939668655396, 0.018412910401821136, -0.0022524246014654636, 0.011127264238893986, 0.008557802066206932, 0.029200566932559013, 0.022339781746268272, 0.08359626680612564, -0.008883251808583736, 0.003674086881801486, 0.02262924052774906, -0.04091536998748779, 0.02154877781867981, -0.009293043054640293, 0.02573978714644909, 0.0017928789602592587, 0.01202352810651064, -0.0004651028721127659, -0.024327391758561134, -0.033228207379579544, -0.01905592903494835, 0.02168392762541771, -0.06863124668598175, -0.06313642114400864, -0.02674730122089386, -0.007233546581119299, 0.020088529214262962, 0.0015594081487506628, -0.03338025510311127, 0.0060964180156588554, -0.001851889188401401, 0.024459844455122948, 0.011876414529979229, -0.0022616118658334017, -0.08227133005857468, 0.010295035317540169, -0.01761440932750702, 0.025950420647859573, -0.05165731534361839, -0.023127662017941475, 0.0063287364318966866, 0.004815614782273769, -0.06546080857515335, 0.03929611295461655, -0.05059807747602463, -0.004217834211885929, -0.03197373449802399, 0.10680019855499268, -0.056314025074243546, -0.0341823510825634, 0.013474799692630768, -0.03928157687187195, -0.0356246754527092, 0.031129317358136177, 0.08494067192077637, -0.11187329888343811, -0.013749413192272186, 0.01970861852169037, 0.038482073694467545, 0.02900991216301918, 0.007252511568367481, -0.017439570277929306, -0.04635671526193619, -0.025150422006845474, 0.09308549761772156, -0.036185286939144135, 0.010165642946958542, 0.07215303182601929, 0.028350260108709335, 0.03972778469324112, 0.03910095989704132, -0.012533186934888363, 0.05355256423354149, -0.05487851798534393, -0.005111366510391235, -0.010050353594124317, 0.051893021911382675, -0.007443701382726431, 0.028035836294293404, -0.018693793565034866, 0.03532623499631882, -0.07915917783975601, -0.06748268753290176, 0.0466688871383667, 0.05615786090493202, -0.006730515975505114, 0.04837822541594505, 0.005225254688411951, -0.03398778289556503, -0.020798947662115097, 0.03522961959242821, -0.04094218835234642, 0.02871038392186165, 0.019663477316498756, -0.025438278913497925, -0.030220877379179, -0.01936482824385166, 0.006144575774669647, -0.04830775782465935, 0.040136948227882385, 0.0061983224004507065, 0.007081963587552309, -0.012407137081027031, -0.005075216293334961, -0.021124262362718582, 0.007257375400513411, -0.05850743129849434, 0.05870583653450012, 0.07265754789113998, 0.045161083340644836, 0.059565190225839615, -0.00917202141135931, -0.0017920896643772721, -0.08388271182775497, 0.030797863379120827, 0.014849810861051083, 0.025044653564691544, 0.009198182262480259, -0.0806615799665451, -0.052609048783779144, -0.0382600873708725, 0.016766563057899475, -0.033395346254110336, -0.0011970322811976075, -0.0433901846408844, -0.08986334502696991, 0.03222634270787239, -0.05183936282992363, -0.03324640914797783, -0.06009596958756447, 0.010278867557644844, -0.030647695064544678, 0.017272133380174637, 0.02422255650162697, 0.03308591619133949, 0.049729738384485245, 0.027063269168138504, -0.017870858311653137, -0.04091133177280426, -0.05058496445417404, -0.0030515037942677736, -0.057573746889829636, 0.0027890033088624477, -0.015984540805220604, -0.057682961225509644, -0.0007685315213166177, -0.03118135780096054, 0.06321787089109421, -0.03643990680575371, 0.015509923920035362, -0.07639696449041367, 0.02208530344069004, 0.029494311660528183, 0.02466667629778385, 0.03776301443576813, 0.018728310242295265, -0.011637748219072819, -0.015875093638896942, -0.016350064426660538, -0.003875150578096509, 0.03819571062922478, -0.046697188168764114, -0.013687691651284695, 0.03089507482945919, 0.05854671820998192, 0.01427489798516035, -0.0009910217486321926, 0.03422793745994568, 0.025992639362812042, -0.022599507123231888, 0.04775358363986015, 0.02559954673051834, 0.022492356598377228, 0.012566611170768738, 0.02659696154296398, 0.05962880700826645, 0.02981683984398842, 0.03183921426534653, 0.006451773922890425, 0.015450096689164639, -0.001494595897383988, 0.006250916980206966, -0.009980193339288235, -0.03333514183759689, -0.02127261832356453, -0.0020027225837111473, -0.08042789250612259, 0.10334273427724838, -0.07034379243850708, 0.02129250019788742, -0.02586103416979313, 0.0395098514854908, -0.048276908695697784, 0.031009899452328682, 0.03162232041358948, -0.002372119575738907, -0.021210405975580215, 0.00026036304188892245, 0.030120214447379112, -0.009263685904443264, -0.000821146066300571, -0.0011399436043575406, 0.01682872511446476, 0.01023987028747797, -0.061807963997125626, 0.000023665654225624166, -0.04205813258886337, -0.008332648314535618, -0.059650953859090805, 0.015245522372424603, -0.08296936005353928, 0.021371085196733475, -0.05676880478858948, 0.015315879136323929, -0.044182293117046356, -0.0011119511909782887, -0.016337241977453232, 0.06404143571853638, 0.0402025431394577, 0.027538521215319633, -0.003325769677758217, -0.039117950946092606, 0.02449590526521206, 0.021596645936369896, -0.004047073889523745, -0.004062887746840715, -0.008575002662837505, 0.012219175696372986, -0.006094140466302633, -0.0006832507206127048, 0.07112221419811249, -0.03279607743024826, 0.0015936464769765735, 0.017046110704541206, 0.02608790621161461, -0.0005427657742984593, 0.007423647213727236, 0.02784176543354988, -0.06319368630647659, 0.05928594246506691, 0.02955658733844757, -0.037836261093616486, 0.06888175755739212, -0.029063688591122627, -0.0049448078498244286, -0.039641089737415314, -0.006894153077155352, -0.08009456843137741, 0.005205577705055475, -0.0665617287158966, 0.029198726639151573, -0.023866945877671242, -0.004097906406968832, -0.017088577151298523, 0.040990378707647324, 0.013195541687309742, 0.061468709260225296, -0.07451993227005005, 0.0002713896392378956, 0.01055009476840496, 0.046705212444067, -0.0585823580622673, -0.013931783847510815, 0.0025019580498337746, -0.0700274184346199, -0.03004785068333149, 0.03499370813369751, -0.023185010999441147, 0.024215828627347946, 0.02581668272614479, 0.008295668289065361, -0.04751468822360039, -0.002213750733062625, -0.03560231253504753, -0.030662737786769867, 0.010056053288280964, -0.019953981041908264, -0.019237017259001732, -0.020056694746017456, 0.023799465969204903, -0.022743701934814453, 0.011487061157822609, -0.007962444797158241, -0.018953463062644005, -0.04933619499206543, 0.005090153310447931, 0.01764305680990219, -0.032284341752529144, -0.014161444269120693, 0.05052375793457031, -0.024303479120135307, -0.03950536623597145, -0.02312765270471573, -0.023586856201291084, -0.013025043532252312, -0.02258281409740448, -0.07549815624952316, -0.04117854684591293, 0.07491263747215271, -0.02570311538875103, 0.02389504387974739, -0.0122003722935915, 0.06427326798439026, -0.030580516904592514, -0.05786799639463425, -0.05843978002667427, 0.039734553545713425, 0.01876075565814972, 0.04929236322641373, 0.03566353768110275, 0.03592117875814438, 0.041268087923526764, 0.0008046044385991991, 0.01744573377072811, 0.0029417145997285843, 0.031118953600525856, 0.0032462975941598415, -0.054685577750205994, 0.0071060447953641415, 0.03481582552194595, -0.00854179635643959, 0.08560506999492645, -0.0158037468791008, -0.032578419893980026, -0.014763099141418934, 0.08265917003154755, -0.025495266541838646, 0.06711505353450775, 0.01726614683866501, -0.05544562265276909, -0.025997348129749298, 0.021299492567777634, -0.01817062869668007, 0.030934033915400505, -0.01666877046227455, -0.0008304088842123747, -0.018667906522750854, -0.03732804208993912, 0.0009972089901566505, -0.05192644149065018, 0.011286857537925243, 0.02733047865331173, 0.028635546565055847, 0.029575370252132416, 0.019273482263088226, 0.07677524536848068, -0.06283867359161377, -0.017650378867983818, -0.021455086767673492, -0.020534569397568703, 0.039128031581640244, -0.05503500998020172, 0.01225414127111435, 0.0629705861210823, -0.015693075954914093, -0.03376307711005211, 0.02464420534670353, -0.011231467127799988, -0.007667092606425285, 0.009431121870875359, -0.05477042868733406, 0.024864720180630684, -0.05274270847439766, -0.02178448624908924, -0.010569806210696697, 0.03017893061041832, 0.02657565474510193, 0.003440092084929347, 0.018711276352405548, 0.010230272077023983, 0.0009115199209190905, 0.034818779677152634, -0.029760047793388367, -0.05950113758444786, 0.05102114751935005, -0.021214788779616356, -0.0008303978247568011, -0.02467646822333336, 0.015280392952263355, 0.04944482445716858, -0.051616519689559937, 0.05174001678824425, 0.025194359943270683, -0.010828567668795586, 0.03568772226572037, 0.014041041024029255, 0.03397320210933685, 0.007268797606229782, -0.020007114857435226, 0.01695348136126995, -0.06677844375371933, -0.01683971658349037, -0.00519720371812582, 0.01377955824136734, -0.051013994961977005, -0.012843770906329155, 0.04862861707806587, -0.06612568348646164, 0.011661961674690247, 0.03635787591338158, -0.039222102612257004, 0.003336081514135003, -0.014723485335707664, 0.02720089629292488, 0.031329505145549774, 0.01331064198166132, -0.003987148404121399, 0.08306913077831268, 0.035624805837869644, 0.04821249842643738, -0.009094012901186943, -0.04660689830780029, 0.0008077060338109732, 0.032239727675914764, -0.0041426788084208965, -0.002278014551848173, -0.010711781680583954, 0.030974363908171654, -0.02385149709880352, 0.04920186474919319, 0.015757596120238304, 0.03882429003715515, 0.04694948345422745, -0.017721479758620262, 0.008223596028983593, -0.023694587871432304, -0.04681866988539696, 0.024219898506999016, 0.04188401252031326, 0.043130576610565186, -0.0038149303290992975, -0.0005048543098382652, -0.010563015006482601, -0.1045214906334877, 0.06657534092664719, 0.02579289861023426, 0.04196349158883095, 0.0474589467048645, 0.01293972134590149, 0.016899142414331436, 0.02022763341665268, -0.0341135710477829, -0.028321783989667892, 0.02019220031797886, 0.012398731894791126, -0.051353633403778076, -0.04877164959907532, 0.04128745198249817, -0.056624699383974075, 0.019682349637150764, 0.002735392190515995, -0.026519713923335075, 0.06729324162006378, 0.0252897497266531, 0.030546346679329872, -0.041664935648441315, -0.08957979083061218, 0.05604066699743271, -0.005750596988946199, -0.01953730545938015, 0.04826539382338524, 0.004968973342329264, 0.06272231042385101, 0.020168010145425797, -0.08287068456411362, 0.006666835397481918, -0.028628921136260033, -0.01148891355842352, -0.04096154868602753, -0.054527588188648224, 0.015298170037567616, 0.03649185225367546, -0.015156958252191544, -0.06360717117786407, -0.01293925940990448, 0.06859925389289856, -0.013704732060432434, -0.00680937385186553, 0.06419017910957336, -0.059640780091285706, 0.05635097250342369, -0.025974705815315247, 0.03978040814399719, 0.007749382872134447, -0.025541016831994057, -0.057818129658699036, -0.0002298528706887737, -0.030600523576140404, 0.0535062737762928, 0.0014110311167314649, -0.026388173922896385, -0.01839691773056984, -0.05761918053030968, 0.014707295224070549, 0.019092615693807602, -0.03791330009698868, 0.02167464792728424, -0.01112290471792221, 0.057208407670259476, 0.020603829994797707, -0.006363671738654375, 0.005945742595940828, -0.027812354266643524, -0.07058724015951157, 0.024431291967630386, -0.043961051851511, 0.004953807219862938, 0.04854748025536537, 0.037716127932071686, -0.013972665183246136, -0.015497377142310143, -0.046009380370378494, -0.020020226016640663, 0.009711152873933315, -0.003934562671929598, 0.06593935936689377, -0.00808667577803135, -0.043293870985507965, -0.05199375003576279, 0.015597086399793625, -0.020577609539031982, 0.013455321080982685, 0.05341912806034088, 0.011968311853706837, -0.06013071537017822, 0.010171680711209774, -0.007863597013056278, 0.044709332287311554, 0.010075424797832966, 0.013214470818638802, 0.040164459496736526, -0.022240182384848595, 0.0440128929913044, 0.043460823595523834, -0.023239072412252426, -0.01640242524445057, -0.035648588091135025, 0.0083706583827734, 0.011706581339240074, -0.0203708428889513, 0.02398594655096531, 0.02633877471089363, -0.059703610837459564, 0.028958138078451157, 0.042166415601968765, 0.053915951400995255, -0.023857349529862404, 0.05313967540860176, 0.09156090766191483, 0.02117343619465828, 0.014711059629917145, 0.012216364033520222, -0.04041155427694321, -0.0441814586520195, 0.007988770492374897, -0.03884260356426239, 0.017362240701913834, -0.027144141495227814, -0.004443022422492504, 0.018067853525280952, 0.020920297130942345, 0.011941061355173588, -0.02911449410021305, -0.02290196157991886, 0.01069700438529253 ]
<p>In this <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/26617/how-to-determine-day-night-based-on-latitude-longitude-and-a-date-time">question about how to calculate sunrise</a>, there is a link to a page that describes a <a href="http://williams.best.vwh.net/sunrise_sunset_algorithm.htm">algorithm to calculate sunrise sunset</a>.</p> <p>But when I start to follow the instructions I find that there is a lot of magical constants in that instruction and it is hard to understand what is going on.</p> <p>Can someone help me a little with the magic numbers.</p> <p>For example this part:</p> <pre><code>3. calculate the Sun's mean anomaly M = (0.9856 * t) - 3.289 </code></pre> <p>Where did he find 0.9856 and 3.289?</p> <p>And in the next part</p> <pre><code>4. calculate the Sun's true longitude L = M + (1.916 * sin(M)) + (0.020 * sin(2 * M)) + 282.634 NOTE: L potentially needs to be adjusted into the range [0,360) by adding/subtracting 360 </code></pre> <p>Where did he find 1.916, 0.020 and 282.634? </p>
g4087
[ 0.007734786719083786, -0.037201426923274994, -0.013922101818025112, -0.03174411132931709, 0.026554597541689873, -0.019824663177132607, 0.056259527802467346, 0.04003922641277313, -0.033544596284627914, -0.007320708129554987, -0.033752117305994034, 0.03421754017472267, 0.016353541985154152, 0.061230674386024475, -0.008152097463607788, 0.03061177395284176, 0.06656641513109207, 0.03354808688163757, 0.024605341255664825, -0.033545881509780884, 0.005518245976418257, 0.025828586891293526, -0.03728552162647247, -0.0307613555341959, -0.01870899274945259, -0.02873045951128006, -0.053360145539045334, 0.07181863486766815, -0.020119594410061836, -0.034062422811985016, 0.01915867067873478, 0.025705045089125633, 0.06941018998622894, -0.03794574365019798, 0.004705050494521856, -0.014869502745568752, 0.0634891539812088, 0.02497045323252678, 0.02711448445916176, -0.013395197689533234, -0.027075637131929398, -0.030249031260609627, 0.037164825946092606, 0.073001429438591, -0.013410132378339767, 0.006104018073529005, 0.0010539789218455553, 0.014683292247354984, 0.00848811399191618, -0.03710433840751648, 0.030006494373083115, 0.0018254441674798727, 0.02573883906006813, 0.012656844221055508, -0.015345726162195206, 0.06293132156133652, 0.03404143452644348, -0.046211495995521545, 0.058284297585487366, 0.08721320331096649, 0.0609903484582901, -0.03206982836127281, 0.046959277242422104, -0.011385787278413773, 0.019305501133203506, 0.027353713288903236, 0.012717864476144314, 0.007916012778878212, -0.049689553678035736, 0.04141385853290558, 0.020789068192243576, -0.02963857725262642, -0.01537162996828556, -0.022063128650188446, -0.05518689751625061, 0.011266357265412807, 0.09706185758113861, -0.030694691464304924, 0.007915390655398369, 0.05816594511270523, -0.022366289049386978, 0.013589595444500446, 0.030175860971212387, -0.012362970970571041, -0.0021197088062763214, -0.008292868733406067, 0.022957758978009224, 0.0250999853014946, 0.02812628634274006, -0.03934638202190399, 0.02132500149309635, -0.004906006623059511, 0.09851744771003723, 0.0019733498338609934, -0.0046266899444162846, -0.013695341534912586, 0.0018278791103512049, 0.06221136078238487, -0.023899491876363754, -0.04252082481980324, -0.010810279287397861, 0.001618485781364143, 0.04258577525615692, 0.01915225200355053, -0.05995055288076401, -0.00119123631156981, 0.040360331535339355, -0.006556816399097443, -0.02038121037185192, 0.005020882934331894, -0.02195400930941105, -0.04275735840201378, -0.012294777669012547, -0.08248043805360794, -0.05340727046132088, 0.0039560748264193535, 0.05246791988611221, 0.021095741540193558, 0.06611232459545135, -0.01695607416331768, 0.008654966950416565, 0.046592872589826584, 0.00008811231964500621, 0.08992601186037064, -0.013807413168251514, -0.012075689621269703, -0.009912080131471157, -0.0027109028305858374, 0.021713361144065857, -0.02858811430633068, 0.02667241171002388, 0.006033661309629679, 0.002949823858216405, 0.07725808024406433, -0.036039263010025024, 0.04275692254304886, 0.0515018105506897, 0.034304603934288025, 0.002245112555101514, 0.012425565160810947, -0.03555353730916977, -0.03643351420760155, 0.02281912975013256, -0.08705686032772064, -0.051444076001644135, 0.015006582252681255, -0.07116862386465073, -0.0356266014277935, 0.023156359791755676, 0.007138581946492195, 0.059326447546482086, 0.03695358335971832, 0.005819007288664579, 0.02147984690964222, -0.02009451575577259, -0.035288289189338684, 0.009708463214337826, 0.005202149040997028, -0.030848244205117226, 0.05337262898683548, 0.08704326301813126, -0.0704156905412674, 0.010128053836524487, -0.0009833936346694827, -0.04668224975466728, 0.0000866578338900581, -0.03572526574134827, 0.02499309740960598, -0.031397219747304916, 0.0003631949075497687, 0.0004461851203814149, -0.0014648850774392486, 0.017395146191120148, -0.042680524289608, -0.006101913284510374, 0.07969938218593597, 0.07221518456935883, 0.020383169874548912, -0.003043107222765684, 0.058805983513593674, 0.01883615180850029, 0.0024410728365182877, 0.04439404234290123, -0.040787842124700546, -0.057762086391448975, -0.03230315074324608, -0.021988091990351677, -0.06856925040483475, -0.08320610225200653, -0.04659787192940712, 0.013371379114687443, 0.007475814316421747, 0.019804129377007484, -0.03868135064840317, 0.02665482461452484, -0.019247308373451233, 0.0043324814178049564, 0.0012320849345996976, -0.0597556047141552, 0.05551184341311455, -0.027793563902378082, 0.031090330332517624, 0.0017198373097926378, 0.0039471290074288845, -0.005908576305955648, 0.06416603177785873, 0.04836378991603851, -0.021420719102025032, 0.00014083515270613134, -0.007794037461280823, -0.024683568626642227, 0.016420355066657066, 0.011448986828327179, 0.08032765984535217, 0.016421470791101456, 0.03019108809530735, -0.032327815890312195, -0.018072621896862984, 0.014560182578861713, -0.036156706511974335, 0.0013281514402478933, -0.009737839922308922, 0.03546881675720215, -0.014321605674922466, -0.003805689048022032, 0.04335538670420647, -0.05068318918347359, -0.006755055859684944, 0.020223157480359077, -0.018116280436515808, -0.019697990268468857, 0.02182110957801342, -0.05195993185043335, 0.029994850978255272, 0.03391975909471512, 0.021140912547707558, -0.00050632149213925, 0.013776657171547413, 0.030134133994579315, 0.05314702168107033, -0.0032204638700932264, -0.003392244456335902, -0.02866435796022415, 0.05640498921275139, 0.04832456260919571, -0.013744033873081207, 0.040520668029785156, 0.019396008923649788, -0.04077041149139404, 0.03211885318160057, 0.019409798085689545, 0.004050407093018293, -0.025648334994912148, 0.0084781963378191, -0.009627845138311386, -0.03497286140918732, -0.0687679722905159, -0.009643437340855598, -0.052042242139577866, 0.038547199219465256, -0.005913445260375738, -0.007083181291818619, 0.020218007266521454, 0.008867827244102955, 0.04205755889415741, 0.005526750348508358, -0.06270479410886765, -0.007998398505151272, 0.014685375615954399, -0.07811124622821808, -0.001969666685909033, 0.001846769591793418, 0.053464289754629135, 0.01415784191340208, -0.05656985193490982, -0.00036555781844072044, 0.020186088979244232, 0.025111211463809013, 0.013298057951033115, 0.027236146852374077, 0.00790801178663969, -0.03458557650446892, -0.042993538081645966, 0.035751719027757645, -0.03365502879023552, 0.0050893002189695835, -0.01272719819098711, 0.049115411937236786, -0.0024417694658041, -0.05304737389087677, 0.04443327710032463, 0.0031294908840209246, 0.009162330068647861, -0.005854351911693811, -0.011589333415031433, -0.02275899425148964, 0.04071532189846039, 0.03187336027622223, -0.013177278451621532, -0.02417553961277008, 0.00009593678987585008, 0.05099475383758545, 0.006650648079812527, -0.011784923262894154, 0.02249634824693203, 0.02476433292031288, 0.054691653698682785, -0.026827745139598846, 0.008266283199191093, -0.027939368039369583, 0.006405170075595379, 0.015401751734316349, -0.00856282003223896, -0.022700581699609756, 0.04995562881231308, 0.0983140617609024, -0.025427142158150673, -0.00413175206631422, 0.022665923461318016, 0.020258020609617233, -0.058755695819854736, -0.005138417240232229, 0.028272442519664764, -0.004360781982541084, 0.03640275076031685, 0.058744363486766815, -0.01592447981238365, 0.03228505328297615, -0.0395725779235363, -0.02484758011996746, -0.024415181949734688, -0.014860355295240879, -0.02239711955189705, -0.022455116733908653, -0.02756461501121521, -0.025931647047400475, -0.004881815519183874, 0.022240713238716125, -0.010161119513213634, -0.020281020551919937, -0.04611750319600105, -0.031222138553857803, -0.03338036686182022, -0.028246497735381126, 0.03880678117275238, -0.031950391829013824, -0.02367842011153698, -0.02544531598687172, -0.004311173688620329, 0.03764060139656067, 0.04677882418036461, -0.026844151318073273, -0.022788802161812782, -0.016112051904201508, 0.017434049397706985, 0.09051205962896347, -0.03881862387061119, 0.04713164269924164, -0.03177715092897415, -0.013752400875091553, 0.015908150002360344, 0.01308696810156107, -0.04226384311914444, 0.00411025807261467, 0.024125268682837486, 0.009357875213027, 0.01443492155522108, 0.09331944584846497, 0.008054306730628014, -0.04622219130396843, 0.030149979516863823, 0.05116957053542137, 0.004932262469083071, -0.0718742311000824, -0.003383486531674862, -0.02770380862057209, 0.013283392414450645, 0.0007729849312454462, 0.007070905528962612, 0.06759810447692871, 0.0379999540746212, 0.023485658690333366, -0.010796409100294113, -0.00024217573809437454, 0.0530136376619339, 0.04662295803427696, -0.02779516763985157, -0.020686723291873932, 0.02261589653789997, -0.08893712610006332, 0.009836958721280098, -0.07007113844156265, -0.026133036240935326, -0.02298223413527012, 0.028797727078199387, -0.06551793217658997, -0.004870095290243626, 0.041995882987976074, -0.031409937888383865, 0.0006061255699023604, 0.024512099102139473, 0.00840169470757246, 0.06916042417287827, 0.03597765043377876, -0.04816627874970436, 0.020725304260849953, -0.007770523428916931, -0.02957206964492798, 0.07459714263677597, 0.047712232917547226, 0.02620593272149563, 0.06010456383228302, 0.03551063314080238, -0.05071626603603363, 0.040131568908691406, 0.05062377452850342, 0.04563705623149872, -0.0195742379873991, -0.038477834314107895, -0.008223028853535652, -0.0700160339474678, 0.07152241468429565, -0.02768496796488762, -0.06981869786977768, -0.008006119169294834, 0.029321586713194847, 0.002399708842858672, -0.03130529075860977, 0.04964017868041992, -0.048515137284994125, -0.007635119371116161, 0.041690438985824585, -0.0001377455919282511, 0.0009232200100086629, -0.043320994824171066, 0.06206837296485901, -0.0217965766787529, 0.03564877435564995, -0.005579659249633551, -0.032077111303806305, 0.017200998961925507, 0.02247050404548645, 0.008153487928211689, -0.015620286576449871, -0.029622826725244522, 0.042386580258607864, -0.04843366891145706, -0.073781818151474, -0.0027203059289604425, -0.002215744461864233, 0.009880159981548786, -0.010112435556948185, -0.03117188811302185, -0.002304680645465851, 0.03166873753070831, -0.033338479697704315, -0.009154114872217178, 0.020073097199201584, -0.018763989210128784, 0.0373029001057148, -0.06996966898441315, -0.01607447676360607, -0.00246052211150527, 0.028367983177304268, 0.04376129060983658, 0.019103139638900757, -0.038807932287454605, -0.031226404011249542, -0.009920580312609673, 0.032303351908922195, -0.006122069898992777, 0.02685130573809147, 0.0058419848792254925, -0.017214376479387283, -0.0022851487156003714, -0.012755460105836391, 0.003740675514563918, 0.00017620946164242923, 0.052079685032367706, 0.01110184658318758, -0.04054412990808487, 0.053074490278959274, -0.042163554579019547, 0.0564371794462204, -0.029305554926395416, 0.055250220000743866, 0.013752894476056099, -0.03788606449961662, 0.01545525249093771, 0.004656457807868719, -0.002083590952679515, -0.0412282720208168, 0.06401075422763824, -0.07861612737178802, -0.010101507417857647, -0.019243331626057625, 0.014842584729194641, 0.04344768822193146, 0.022578055039048195, -0.04974422976374626, -0.028565814718604088, 0.00936269760131836, 0.00567422853782773, -0.01559255737811327, 0.024585511535406113, -0.00013904906518291682, 0.02270221710205078, 0.02172217331826687, 0.03959907591342926, -0.017971482127904892, 0.021091381087899208, 0.008123878389596939, 0.013216175138950348, 0.005122615490108728, 0.03668047487735748, -0.06908588856458664, 0.03212090954184532, 0.02714928612112999, -0.018439309671521187, -0.028407273814082146, 0.02330729365348816, 0.03344648703932762, -0.001052237581461668, -0.011032777838408947, -0.004756511189043522, -0.05526670068502426, -0.031953729689121246, -0.04007325321435928, -0.035111889243125916, -0.0477951280772686, -0.054788436740636826, 0.02077207714319229, -0.041299909353256226, -0.04393823817372322, 0.02605554275214672, -0.013133961707353592, 0.00791881512850523, -0.04084963724017143, 0.01911199279129505, -0.01450216956436634, -0.003068677382543683, 0.004851833451539278, 0.004311409313231707, 0.027640609070658684, -0.03591328486800194, -0.06151914596557617, -0.0020612431690096855, 0.04818089306354523, 0.00732447812333703, -0.010064050555229187, -0.008930030278861523, 0.00852945540100336, 0.019645435735583305, -0.018431594595313072, -0.033029913902282715, 0.007235524244606495, -0.061939407140016556, -0.014797773212194443, -0.04270274192094803, 0.019488267600536346, 0.026451172307133675, -0.010750481858849525, -0.033533867448568344, 0.037851665169000626, 0.02765188179910183, -0.03238202631473541, 0.0006857229163870215, -0.03396183252334595, 0.054219506680965424, 0.04339618608355522, -0.009787050075829029, -0.0497455969452858, -0.04772842302918434, -0.025925539433956146, 0.06030848249793053, 0.00685463659465313, -0.04131481051445007, -0.029962141066789627, -0.03742204234004021, -0.015913696959614754, 0.0010851010447368026, 0.01848028413951397, 0.030431488528847694, -0.07830914109945297, -0.023022394627332687, 0.013542533852159977, -0.08193222433328629, 0.008528636768460274, -0.03064332716166973, -0.03183893859386444, -0.009239623323082924, 0.08620452135801315, 0.020543135702610016, 0.00476065743714571, -0.008363809436559677, -0.04361214116215706, 0.01725952886044979, -0.0065088290721178055, -0.010464673861861229, -0.029897350817918777, 0.016993870958685875, -0.034961991012096405, 0.08651600778102875, 0.02239895612001419, -0.0062035489827394485, 0.026247462257742882, -0.01741398312151432, 0.048664890229701996, -0.001724787405692041, -0.027983669191598892, 0.006154898088425398, 0.061046093702316284, -0.01219154056161642, 0.07166815549135208, -0.045573774725198746, -0.017882684245705605, -0.02428167127072811, 0.005476534366607666, -0.01480313390493393, -0.04038064181804657, 0.029908014461398125, 0.018393253907561302, -0.027056565508246422, -0.015407404862344265, 0.027315491810441017, 0.0187205970287323, -0.021794429048895836, -0.018405858427286148, 0.03948779031634331, 0.006882537622004747, -0.030594514682888985, -0.05406603589653969, -0.012347414158284664, 0.04292970150709152, 0.022661952301859856, 0.010746646672487259, -0.008207409642636776, 0.09190825372934341, -0.03863000497221947, 0.1223612129688263, -0.018595142289996147, -0.005302970763295889, 0.007157522719353437, -0.024986226111650467, -0.01858408749103546, -0.07727443426847458, -0.0012887747725471854, -0.025337615981698036, -0.08674252778291702, 0.05245006084442139, 0.048001352697610855, -0.01802222430706024, -0.022947749122977257, 0.07162788510322571, 0.05104394257068634, 0.05470222607254982, -0.04288544878363609, -0.039317503571510315, 0.0014832377200946212, -0.061311233788728714, 0.016622470691800117, 0.015250448137521744, -0.003811452304944396, 0.009528578259050846, 0.028612252324819565, 0.027558591216802597, 0.008974281139671803, 0.017507879063487053, -0.011107356287539005, -0.08484765142202377, -0.07232930511236191, 0.027359535917639732, -0.0510101243853569, -0.016467735171318054, -0.007686261553317308, 0.026997875422239304, -0.018559984862804413, 0.016413815319538116, -0.052234068512916565, -0.0450696237385273, -0.005278064403682947, 0.05431252717971802, -0.09803195297718048, -0.021317223086953163, 0.022623563185334206, 0.007018860429525375, -0.05408012866973877, 0.000634148542303592, -0.0012327927397564054, -0.028025440871715546, -0.02694849483668804, 0.04979640990495682, -0.035944923758506775, -0.032878682017326355, 0.0029907391872256994, -0.021446960046887398, 0.02949383296072483, -0.0069895279593765736, 0.04764373600482941, -0.043813467025756836, 0.020323026925325394, -0.01399999763816595, 0.0307140052318573, -0.0027096718549728394, -0.004293979611247778, 0.012946004047989845, -0.05776608735322952, -0.009639695286750793, -0.013112504035234451, -0.03255993872880936, 0.005793347489088774, -0.01144299004226923, -0.018579253926873207, 0.029273003339767456, 0.028707878664135933, 0.01453984621912241, 0.03967658802866936, 0.008700435981154442, -0.0883510485291481, -0.009781274013221264, -0.021455619484186172, -0.021452555432915688, 0.01583177223801613, -0.05734005570411682, -0.04418158531188965, -0.06870690733194351, -0.01544377114623785, 0.009288965724408627, 0.03777940571308136, -0.03671082854270935, 0.03583880513906479, -0.049677301198244095, 0.0036987867206335068, -0.007302347104996443, -0.016417978331446648, -0.00544825941324234, 0.0008891432080417871, -0.04762790724635124, 0.05151056498289108, 0.0076478286646306515, -0.04366772249341011, -0.07479703426361084, 0.06924481689929962, -0.07470188289880753, 0.02406320534646511, -0.0173405259847641, -0.06667458266019821, 0.08666044473648071, 0.0543263740837574, -0.035037893801927567, 0.004486879799515009, 0.007225880399346352, -0.038048889487981796, -0.015632621943950653, -0.007401906419545412, 0.020108439028263092, 0.018732795491814613, -0.04239467903971672, 0.03763926774263382, -0.0361739806830883, 0.003297259798273444, -0.05291210487484932, -0.011139621958136559, 0.037161242216825485, 0.014864012598991394, -0.013201563619077206, -0.03971176594495773, -0.041381001472473145 ]
<p>The all-electron code Wien2K will optionally calculate the character tables for a specified list of $k$-points. I'd like to know the parity eigenvalue for a given $k$-point and band index. Is there some way to compute the parity eigenvalue from the irreducible representation of the group given that $\{i\}$ is a symmetry class? This would be handy to compute the value of $Z_2$. </p>
g4088
[ -0.031633514910936356, -0.052212849259376526, -0.019344231113791466, -0.0446397103369236, 0.022589249536395073, -0.023822860792279243, 0.014123364351689816, 0.0477764829993248, -0.010519210249185562, 0.04592415317893028, -0.010665737092494965, 0.0689423456788063, 0.04453006386756897, 0.0003498818550724536, 0.04295792058110237, -0.037115294486284256, 0.045543696731328964, 0.06331842392683029, -0.02262573502957821, -0.015458694659173489, 0.029652904719114304, 0.04547768086194992, 0.0078226737678051, -0.04496605321764946, 0.07866464555263519, 0.03726520016789436, 0.044439882040023804, -0.016859618946909904, -0.07062479108572006, -0.011993853375315666, 0.005105261690914631, 0.03141625225543976, 0.014502132311463356, -0.02432243898510933, -0.022730425000190735, 0.0014827229315415025, 0.041028667241334915, 0.0423998162150383, -0.029304422438144684, 0.006401732563972473, 0.0080439243465662, -0.04599316418170929, -0.0005587763153016567, 0.03942194953560829, -0.048152826726436615, -0.03508483245968819, 0.008478552103042603, 0.02161448635160923, -0.09684479236602783, 0.01652109995484352, 0.028575196862220764, 0.029472660273313522, 0.06356710940599442, -0.04180936515331268, -0.04208004102110863, -0.016123590990900993, -0.06501612067222595, -0.03354179486632347, 0.045297861099243164, 0.055032916367053986, 0.003880434902384877, 0.043663159012794495, -0.021981364116072655, -0.01200998667627573, 0.00656516756862402, -0.00027167442021891475, -0.027469243854284286, 0.027431195601820946, -0.03423290327191353, -0.011938237585127354, -0.016140028834342957, -0.02587546966969967, 0.004131041467189789, -0.035572510212659836, -0.04493508115410805, 0.0047695217654109, -0.03176933526992798, 0.0221084151417017, 0.04945489391684532, 0.02245999686419964, 0.019546397030353546, -0.008092024363577366, -0.03925609961152077, -0.062121499329805374, -0.0482955127954483, -0.002837400184944272, 0.01412815973162651, 0.0281672365963459, -0.035915307700634, 0.007966619916260242, -0.010953317396342754, -0.011625510640442371, -0.013257553800940514, 0.009279586374759674, 0.03169893100857735, 0.05903423950076103, 0.03743430972099304, 0.025897620245814323, -0.05877525359392166, -0.04754161462187767, 0.03852548822760582, 0.05009590461850166, 0.040286771953105927, -0.01127321831882, -0.001215734868310392, -0.03247096762061119, 0.03985363617539406, -0.02382778748869896, 0.028966831043362617, 0.00034706731094047427, -0.032955072820186615, 0.015659695491194725, -0.03621659055352211, 0.041575826704502106, -0.02876916714012623, -0.01388792134821415, 0.04000557214021683, -0.056602321565151215, -0.020052064210176468, 0.019657433032989502, 0.028748556971549988, -0.05213882774114609, 0.04380664974451065, 0.03970416635274887, 0.017437025904655457, -0.02158966474235058, -0.02299218811094761, 0.018194496631622314, 0.0343509316444397, -0.039331160485744476, -0.06432344019412994, 0.013115749694406986, 0.005952809471637011, 0.04740138351917267, 0.024431316182017326, -0.0486210472881794, -0.022677699103951454, 0.05418970063328743, -0.04246245324611664, -0.038842055946588516, -0.009384182281792164, 0.02231731079518795, -0.06910140812397003, -0.009363444522023201, 0.010268241167068481, -0.10132424533367157, -0.05728108435869217, -0.08115774393081665, 0.06511707603931427, 0.048080265522003174, -0.016821833327412605, 0.008577721193432808, 0.0014988430775702, -0.040089916437864304, -0.02277371473610401, -0.049346987158060074, 0.04732176661491394, 0.011605927720665932, 0.015710921958088875, 0.05505793169140816, -0.03233811631798744, -0.03345692902803421, 0.03110720030963421, 0.05262751877307892, -0.016673618927598, -0.05470713600516319, -0.0072707319632172585, -0.02393963560461998, -0.025529662147164345, -0.005693476181477308, -0.03945717215538025, 0.024868158623576164, 0.016052773222327232, -0.023417210206389427, -0.03729894012212753, 0.030427539721131325, -0.07877793163061142, 0.01882050931453705, 0.053016118705272675, 0.02836046740412712, -0.013173630461096764, -0.023842424154281616, 0.06244419887661934, 0.07364879548549652, -0.024933136999607086, -0.006917877588421106, -0.03669977933168411, 0.009260295890271664, -0.00700620049610734, -0.028853649273514748, 0.021484605967998505, 0.04124747961759567, 0.04121174290776253, 0.010026815347373486, 0.0023487003054469824, -0.11596544831991196, 0.011798364110291004, 0.0010990725131705403, -0.04655415937304497, -0.021514996886253357, 0.016557546332478523, 0.04744340851902962, -0.0693921372294426, 0.014471158385276794, -0.017574045807123184, -0.00046467158244922757, -0.028363635763525963, -0.04306450113654137, 0.02199234813451767, 0.0011323720682412386, -0.04256916418671608, 0.008219762705266476, 0.019996026530861855, 0.04153650999069214, 0.04633248597383499, 0.027054330334067345, -0.01167287677526474, -0.01316168811172247, -0.011902033351361752, 0.021683521568775177, 0.004976020194590092, -0.03436676412820816, -0.03694336861371994, 0.06518370658159256, 0.01589822955429554, 0.023277396336197853, 0.0017509808531031013, 0.054228927940130234, -0.02553642727434635, -0.03261658921837807, -0.048979081213474274, 0.018753312528133392, -0.09908673167228699, -0.006480818148702383, 0.0038870293647050858, 0.09714125841856003, -0.025289753451943398, 0.03125714138150215, 0.03594164550304413, 0.0025988135021179914, 0.012873891741037369, 0.023131979629397392, -0.0009888856438919902, 0.03994152322411537, 0.02292785793542862, 0.00201738765463233, 0.025495195761322975, 0.001782259321771562, -0.07117938995361328, 0.027352429926395416, -0.05499716475605965, -0.03639930486679077, -0.023670416325330734, 0.04049884155392647, 0.0012585254153236747, -0.022637667134404182, 0.029403870925307274, -0.005863901227712631, 0.012336703948676586, 0.0545463003218174, 0.05443357303738594, -0.016522621735930443, 0.011515720747411251, 0.004717556294053793, -0.05712790787220001, -0.010320838540792465, 0.027895061299204826, -0.03159269690513611, 0.02449905499815941, 0.0021821933332830667, -0.03495253622531891, 0.054657887667417526, -0.00891049113124609, 0.000014624094546888955, 0.009428916499018669, -0.08915707468986511, 0.04241408035159111, 0.014727874659001827, -0.005479402840137482, -0.03416888415813446, -0.028451604768633842, -0.02246810309588909, -0.009222498163580894, 0.007143938448280096, 0.031418271362781525, -0.011807074770331383, -0.0006106164073571563, 0.07417315989732742, -0.02506135031580925, -0.01075362041592598, -0.043296363204717636, -0.031802933663129807, -0.0026656233239918947, 0.038756195455789566, -0.011072876863181591, -0.011411675252020359, -0.002924323780462146, -0.04441319778561592, -0.022292040288448334, 0.04516229033470154, 0.026378149166703224, -0.01860719919204712, 0.01036370825022459, -0.024690303951501846, 0.010279501788318157, 0.03426054120063782, 0.012972951866686344, -0.03354716673493385, 0.00053058797493577, -0.0710163563489914, -0.031020384281873703, -0.013453311286866665, -0.014188316650688648, -0.04768937826156616, -0.005958634428679943, 0.008461191318929195, -0.010199898853898048, -0.00994647853076458, -0.003652996616438031, -0.013776984997093678, -0.08714567869901657, -0.012207448482513428, 0.11889488250017166, 0.0003862245939671993, 0.0025898185558617115, 0.029634660109877586, -0.0526447668671608, -0.004327467177063227, 0.02556733600795269, -0.007682075258344412, -0.017529478296637535, 0.005018310155719519, 0.025501441210508347, 0.046227484941482544, 0.0026275794953107834, -0.04974948614835739, -0.019878549501299858, 0.021740339696407318, -0.03445134684443474, -0.036553483456373215, -0.06298422068357468, -0.032464802265167236, -0.011093879118561745, -0.014119183644652367, -0.009050356224179268, -0.03318804129958153, -0.031915631145238876, -0.012685293331742287, -0.05503151938319206, -0.028359955176711082, -0.01563078910112381, 0.03814111277461052, 0.01546547468751669, 0.01455563772469759, 0.0037348701152950525, 0.025085752829909325, -0.01160393375903368, -0.05254701152443886, -0.04647195711731911, 0.05219666659832001, 0.0292925164103508, -0.021062877029180527, -0.0013090294087305665, -0.03857361897826195, 0.013667624443769455, -0.015370441600680351, -0.017561819404363632, 0.06357118487358093, 0.03906029462814331, 0.0039239865727722645, -0.02118191309273243, -0.06500069797039032, 0.05150570720434189, -0.032267943024635315, 0.02460774965584278, -0.062876395881176, -0.03269662335515022, -0.005909588187932968, -0.006850593723356724, 0.05521928891539574, -0.022659124806523323, -0.07224591076374054, 0.08725778013467789, 0.010620301589369774, 0.002069126581773162, -0.017550835385918617, -0.015394025482237339, 0.06967393308877945, 0.034703679382801056, 0.031851090490818024, 0.035792622715234756, -0.06993478536605835, -0.0010699474951252341, 0.007383738644421101, -0.021781738847494125, -0.010819043032824993, -0.029381100088357925, -0.003759797429665923, 0.03327861800789833, 0.051755569875240326, -0.007764930836856365, -0.030358141288161278, 0.043122343719005585, 0.040677011013031006, 0.047577790915966034, 0.04639345407485962, 0.009123370982706547, -0.009603849612176418, 0.00819663517177105, -0.02124764770269394, -0.05101789906620979, 0.02631223201751709, 0.0827622264623642, -0.029300833120942116, -0.031217152252793312, 0.011447770521044731, -0.017761945724487305, -0.04795103147625923, 0.042103081941604614, -0.07317137718200684, 0.006918422412127256, -0.009036928415298462, 0.04342101141810417, -0.06232506409287453, 0.009062634781002998, 0.018042711541056633, 0.04015703499317169, -0.006825522053986788, 0.018499331548810005, 0.04699108377099037, -0.05150016397237778, -0.005191808100789785, 0.02508440613746643, 0.019004493951797485, -0.04541538655757904, -0.015833178535103798, -0.010489912703633308, 0.026834648102521896, 0.014098540879786015, 0.017429988831281662, 0.028491973876953125, -0.043815985321998596, -0.015508162789046764, 0.026128938421607018, -0.013978837989270687, -0.05039011687040329, -0.0391395129263401, 0.010784287005662918, 0.018276862800121307, 0.005643948446959257, 0.009105400182306767, -0.028881633654236794, -0.00782963540405035, 0.05883820727467537, -0.006550585385411978, 0.009335319511592388, -0.019849345088005066, 0.038349710404872894, 0.03663162887096405, -0.0077545433305203915, 0.0018363044364377856, -0.03104248084127903, -0.057670626789331436, -0.011266659945249557, 0.015516354702413082, 0.025462139397859573, -0.006345209199935198, 0.027854083105921745, -0.015433285385370255, -0.0028561241924762726, 0.04992228373885155, 0.024531444534659386, 0.032710716128349304, -0.05909735709428787, 0.05671102553606033, 0.04426969215273857, -0.007004089653491974, -0.03212863951921463, -0.0547221340239048, 0.01129415724426508, -0.0014654737897217274, -0.007389148231595755, 0.018463298678398132, 0.03295561298727989, 0.000768396770581603, 0.01777648739516735, -0.010544752702116966, 0.014006944373250008, -0.05756184831261635, -0.008855425752699375, -0.017531724646687508, 0.017422931268811226, 0.052678223699331284, -0.0123071214184165, -0.00041762457112781703, 0.0037708915770053864, 0.05488912761211395, 0.0368133969604969, 0.014038784429430962, -0.0005244207568466663, -0.00654034037142992, 0.028289159759879112, 0.02022808976471424, 0.0022527584806084633, 0.05816114321351051, -0.03634137660264969, 0.08579781651496887, 0.024504264816641808, 0.008084855042397976, -0.025498216971755028, 0.02738354727625847, -0.030082937330007553, 0.06392813473939896, -0.04045245051383972, 0.037589579820632935, 0.03629722446203232, -0.04962005466222763, 0.011428327299654484, -0.010972571559250355, -0.05689585581421852, 0.07324744015932083, 0.008914094418287277, 0.03522834554314613, -0.0338902473449707, 0.007983628660440445, 0.010512933135032654, 0.007080109789967537, -0.03818386420607567, 0.00910655502229929, 0.006679598242044449, 0.028185706585645676, -0.05313384532928467, -0.041776303201913834, -0.03410518541932106, 0.10895860195159912, -0.06684651970863342, 0.016393424943089485, -0.016746971756219864, 0.004077631048858166, 0.06634759157896042, 0.028686856850981712, 0.008559904992580414, 0.017110532149672508, -0.015277826227247715, 0.013095354661345482, -0.006304415874183178, -0.021565908566117287, 0.02558489330112934, -0.00921613909304142, -0.02034541592001915, -0.022705327719449997, 0.04182598739862442, 0.0027666371315717697, -0.007284616120159626, -0.02049267292022705, 0.014966817572712898, 0.022448958829045296, 0.00986915547400713, 0.06524404883384705, 0.00963112898170948, 0.06663435697555542, 0.00001629774305911269, -0.010805673897266388, 0.003385196439921856, 0.053998515009880066, -0.010295988991856575, -0.06793448328971863, -0.010841317474842072, 0.06892743706703186, -0.01175527274608612, -0.03149262070655823, 0.00450520683079958, 0.004613478202372789, 0.03494076803326607, 0.0010380265302956104, 0.00666750967502594, 0.0416543148458004, 0.005811196751892567, 0.06964930891990662, -0.05971426144242287, -0.039573345333337784, -0.002264644717797637, 0.021357497200369835, 0.05039212480187416, -0.016778716817498207, 0.007751003373414278, 0.012103725224733353, 0.029758943244814873, -0.012703612446784973, 0.06209516525268555, -0.08263851702213287, -0.009039027616381645, 0.012466244399547577, 0.018818844109773636, 0.03161849081516266, 0.029590347781777382, 0.0059378789737820625, 0.00813776720315218, -0.00942471344023943, 0.0550982728600502, 0.1130402609705925, 0.0005340461502783, -0.008300337940454483, 0.018434487283229828, -0.010994458571076393, -0.025172729045152664, -0.08240651339292526, -0.011908452026546001, -0.046622514724731445, -0.018012505024671555, -0.02977488562464714, 0.01648315228521824, -0.03607005253434181, 0.009426001459360123, 0.00489996699616313, 0.050645094364881516, 0.044549163430929184, 0.03568575158715248, -0.06052141264081001, -0.019660452380776405, 0.031200628727674484, -0.04180837422609329, -0.0797649547457695, -0.02961551584303379, 0.0973014310002327, 0.035221535712480545, -0.02237521857023239, 0.016469961032271385, 0.03953348845243454, 0.02860218659043312, -0.021709542721509933, 0.010586243122816086, 0.06554245203733444, -0.013538675382733345, -0.000490585807710886, -0.00427863048389554, -0.05028069391846657, 0.005763640161603689, -0.01799902506172657, 0.07424573600292206, -0.037130799144506454, -0.003948812838643789, 0.005373755469918251, 0.049284275621175766, -0.040636371821165085, 0.04866550490260124, -0.012931802310049534, 0.016351619735360146, -0.0376933217048645, -0.026690596714615822, 0.041712697595357895, 0.014689681120216846, 0.018386507406830788, 0.02371974103152752, -0.014012416824698448, -0.05365737900137901, 0.026237590238451958, 0.007655708584934473, 0.008987351320683956, 0.05747305229306221, -0.03117247298359871, 0.041931089013814926, 0.04797527939081192, -0.06767722219228745, 0.0014446185668930411, -0.00792884174734354, -0.023989304900169373, -0.030875423923134804, 0.011340882629156113, -0.021665358915925026, -0.03081963211297989, -0.015568018890917301, 0.029814565554261208, 0.0042922161519527435, 0.027812903746962547, 0.03702983260154724, -0.024654751643538475, -0.014505468308925629, -0.0902659147977829, 0.0009460650617256761, -0.10242343693971634, -0.03941664099693298, 0.02700885385274887, -0.06225581839680672, -0.052877072244882584, -0.01619955524802208, 0.00005935407898505218, 0.0072842808440327644, -0.005440960172563791, 0.032624997198581696, -0.008206045255064964, -0.0539509616792202, 0.04130641371011734, -0.05540122091770172, 0.03124760277569294, 0.020915769040584564, -0.039347197860479355, -0.01584709994494915, 0.02358609065413475, -0.003299455624073744, 0.0636441633105278, -0.053173501044511795, 0.013325785286724567, -0.02186182513833046, 0.0379314050078392, -0.007947961799800396, 0.039331406354904175, -0.02112121507525444, -0.00252021593041718, -0.03934357315301895, -0.0035761077888309956, 0.025534190237522125, -0.026570511981844902, -0.004342928063124418, 0.036478061228990555, 0.01040453277528286, -0.0336972251534462, 0.014369840733706951, 0.012250319123268127, 0.05690167471766472, 0.020311230793595314, -0.030165378004312515, 0.023704254999756813, 0.011137065477669239, -0.06868888437747955, -0.03564782068133354, 0.03498042747378349, 0.03764256462454796, 0.04825127124786377, -0.005684411618858576, -0.040842894464731216, 0.00627939123660326, 0.019088197499513626, 0.015253528952598572, 0.022307612001895905, 0.027240637689828873, -0.013470509089529514, -0.05360817164182663, 0.023969003930687904, 0.01090920064598322, -0.039660342037677765, -0.03720126673579216, 0.015707993879914284, 0.014617602340877056, -0.06258075684309006, -0.012821163050830364, -0.037839267402887344, -0.036429744213819504, 0.022886253893375397, 0.011855543591082096, -0.04887111485004425, 0.002505653537809849, 0.020098233595490456, 0.024917393922805786, 0.06048561632633209, 0.012742996215820312, 0.039055850356817245, -0.07101386040449142, 0.006762400269508362, 0.057331763207912445, -0.036839809268713, 0.06320952624082565, -0.046515271067619324, 0.04224711284041405, -0.009112843312323093, -0.06779234111309052, -0.042669881135225296, 0.031033407896757126 ]
<p>Consider a block sliding down an incline plane at an angle $\theta$ with the horizontal. For the acceleration as a function of $\theta$ I find $$\ddot{x}=g \ \sin\theta $$ My text then claims we can find the block's velocity after it moves a distance $x_0$ from rest by multiplying both sides by $2\dot{x}$ and doing the following:</p> <p>$$2\dot{x}\ddot{x}=2\dot{x}g \ \sin \theta$$ $$\frac{d}{dt}(\dot{x}^2)=2g \sin\theta\frac{dx}{dt}$$ $$\int_0^{v_0^2}d(\dot{x}^2)=2g\sin\theta\int_0^{x_0}dx$$ $${v_0}^2=2g\sin\theta \ x_0$$ $$v_0=\sqrt{2g\sin\theta \ x_0}$$</p> <p>I think I understand up until the 3rd line. The $dt$'s disappear because both sides are exact differentials, yes? Then in the next step, why does $\dot{x}$ (the velocity) vary from 0 to ${v_0}^2$? Thanks in advance.</p> <p>Also, is there another way to do this?</p>
g4089
[ 0.06463728845119476, 0.016694065183401108, -0.017579134553670883, 0.03560458496212959, 0.043711692094802856, 0.02816108800470829, 0.06892306357622147, 0.01219034381210804, -0.07228455692529678, -0.035831015557050705, -0.055258315056562424, 0.033117201179265976, 0.04009571671485901, 0.0006468117935582995, 0.04261624440550804, -0.0060825892724096775, 0.04443381354212761, -0.030939122661948204, 0.007997313514351845, -0.0036621768958866596, -0.030382001772522926, 0.038531772792339325, 0.018219664692878723, -0.04015691950917244, 0.04278435930609703, -0.0513487309217453, 0.04489956423640251, -0.06062835082411766, -0.03623979166150093, 0.03334059938788414, 0.006681818049401045, -0.008166038431227207, 0.009528325870633125, -0.03221530839800835, -0.006227133795619011, 0.0006679967627860606, 0.06212607026100159, 0.013783706352114677, 0.029475923627614975, -0.015059467405080795, 0.0503569059073925, -0.0627947673201561, 0.05419487506151199, -0.020075155422091484, 0.04526843875646591, -0.03559093549847603, -0.037024568766355515, -0.003197825513780117, -0.01436536479741335, 0.0235698651522398, 0.0038565886206924915, 0.016755485907197, 0.03499646857380867, -0.020453236997127533, -0.06405758857727051, 0.011807127855718136, 0.0015393942594528198, -0.022142531350255013, -0.000569785654079169, 0.030455386266112328, -0.026215383782982826, -0.0723205953836441, 0.04218968376517296, -0.05180256441235542, 0.09725183248519897, -0.045676276087760925, -0.05889008939266205, -0.005663208197802305, 0.03379140794277191, 0.013209519907832146, -0.005063101649284363, 0.005592805333435535, -0.02096278965473175, -0.013813445344567299, -0.09314784407615662, -0.03933727741241455, 0.04669429361820221, -0.03209299594163895, -0.011323308572173119, 0.019311383366584778, -0.049501147121191025, 0.04726601392030716, 0.053090352565050125, 0.029930952936410904, -0.005460171028971672, 0.020740844309329987, 0.017618082463741302, 0.04044092074036598, -0.046074479818344116, 0.011988327838480473, 0.010858973488211632, -0.03165397793054581, 0.040871407836675644, 0.06503584235906601, -0.013414508663117886, -0.028837038204073906, -0.04210429638624191, 0.09431380033493042, 0.02946615219116211, 0.016940608620643616, -0.014742735773324966, -0.01922420971095562, 0.08480226248502731, -0.028995083644986153, 0.030884474515914917, 0.02637513354420662, 0.020424505695700645, 0.00300232064910233, 0.01964578777551651, -0.012592842802405357, 0.03141503781080246, -0.05988874286413193, -0.056379470974206924, -0.09278649091720581, 0.018537189811468124, -0.04726451262831688, -0.02054411545395851, 0.03421605005860329, -0.01987149752676487, 0.04408126324415207, -0.015950262546539307, 0.029940372332930565, -0.023081736639142036, 0.06570775806903839, 0.022662051022052765, 0.01951724663376808, -0.01654542051255703, -0.004091155715286732, 0.029358932748436928, 0.028139544650912285, -0.012130317278206348, 0.03921017050743103, -0.005359122529625893, 0.045868515968322754, 0.031557511538267136, 0.011129654012620449, -0.015255695208907127, 0.027571454644203186, -0.03448972478508949, 0.024350080639123917, -0.025468099862337112, -0.02333502471446991, -0.03336578607559204, 0.021215250715613365, -0.02098887227475643, 0.010369258001446724, -0.02336159162223339, 0.010142024606466293, 0.009630708023905754, -0.043739330023527145, -0.008619853295385838, 0.08385826647281647, -0.02603200264275074, 0.036456815898418427, 0.022589733824133873, -0.01570378988981247, 0.07211022824048996, -0.0012502711033448577, 0.024994811043143272, 0.04746345430612564, 0.057620819658041, -0.06619403511285782, 0.02032601460814476, 0.0073227547109127045, -0.05851571261882782, 0.04724857211112976, -0.050571899861097336, -0.017313601449131966, 0.033230703324079514, -0.038292694836854935, -0.04048756882548332, 0.027828561142086983, 0.030493304133415222, 0.03907107561826706, -0.045219920575618744, 0.03905700147151947, 0.019025426357984543, -0.034283362329006195, -0.03510218486189842, 0.029228918254375458, -0.010167819447815418, 0.010098264552652836, 0.03612245246767998, -0.02504408173263073, 0.03630279377102852, -0.015212202444672585, 0.01896110735833645, -0.03465866670012474, -0.022181417793035507, -0.003895383095368743, 0.04003272205591202, -0.05585280433297157, 0.03070034086704254, 0.052404191344976425, -0.032593633979558945, 0.05595502629876137, 0.0425356961786747, -0.03130638226866722, -0.016253065317869186, 0.07057316601276398, -0.0062799034640192986, 0.05965343862771988, 0.03774898499250412, 0.0029462636448442936, -0.005482377950102091, -0.016239115968346596, 0.04696308448910713, 0.015296263620257378, -0.007016514427959919, 0.021363453939557076, 0.007815742865204811, 0.030099991708993912, -0.019355326890945435, 0.052858658134937286, 0.00657846312969923, -0.07825645059347153, 0.05107460170984268, 0.012147534638643265, -0.002833529142662883, -0.04711584374308586, -0.05270754545927048, -0.06348647177219391, -0.011677304282784462, -0.02738085761666298, -0.01826552115380764, -0.010383368469774723, -0.028547000139951706, -0.03951432183384895, -0.021314233541488647, 0.04294180870056152, -0.03902284428477287, -0.009982828050851822, -0.026350921019911766, -0.008876700885593891, 0.08082165569067001, 0.013667534105479717, 0.000280032807495445, 0.020514383912086487, 0.07580244541168213, 0.009607486426830292, 0.05173356831073761, -0.0441872701048851, -0.037144146859645844, -0.04453755542635918, 0.034989818930625916, -0.021107284352183342, 0.017397185787558556, 0.04927694797515869, 0.03215853497385979, 0.00857225526124239, -0.009293710812926292, 0.0011103027500212193, -0.021245520561933517, 0.012350457720458508, -0.004081368446350098, -0.0351390466094017, -0.035928357392549515, -0.02267776057124138, -0.0021266755647957325, -0.02491830103099346, -0.06665586680173874, 0.016429923474788666, -0.009735123254358768, 0.03191586211323738, -0.011416337452828884, 0.02420119382441044, -0.025926241651177406, -0.01489674486219883, 0.0401805154979229, 0.019551116973161697, 0.0003628708072938025, 0.009011967107653618, 0.03288165479898453, 0.07313495874404907, -0.030354132875800133, -0.008641516789793968, 0.030050471425056458, -0.05512988939881325, -0.03771761804819107, 0.02745368704199791, -0.007172006648033857, 0.008502351120114326, -0.0735008716583252, 0.00198678788729012, 0.030908703804016113, 0.0003462887543719262, 0.004929214715957642, 0.022846199572086334, -0.044311266392469406, -0.029036229476332664, -0.017495037987828255, 0.020689787343144417, 0.055374953895807266, -0.004676573909819126, 0.048592135310173035, 0.05029793456196785, -0.05183067172765732, -0.028129562735557556, -0.03274405747652054, -0.014235751703381538, -0.024388911202549934, -0.052265338599681854, 0.010097783990204334, -0.001544739119708538, 0.004524687770754099, 0.004051793832331896, 0.0024196167942136526, -0.04382001608610153, -0.024783482775092125, 0.02064947783946991, 0.04422762989997864, -0.016378246247768402, 0.026683740317821503, -0.03128555789589882, -0.029545852914452553, -0.016762750223279, 0.02933444455265999, -0.05381482467055321, -0.017039502039551735, 0.06507425755262375, -0.04084484279155731, -0.026433777064085007, -0.03363875672221184, 0.058711376041173935, 0.002004127949476242, -0.011139906011521816, -0.02385971136391163, 0.06317700445652008, -0.03464098647236824, -0.012452431954443455, -0.005648288410156965, 0.04951108619570732, -0.0017581728752702475, -0.02064039558172226, 0.0379958301782608, -0.011350691318511963, 0.016323236748576164, 0.045249972492456436, 0.0732945054769516, -0.011999017558991909, -0.04380796104669571, -0.014860130846500397, -0.012994777411222458, 0.035060442984104156, 0.031360700726509094, -0.038616687059402466, -0.00016327020421158522, 0.014661616645753384, -0.024960115551948547, 0.037486813962459564, 0.045467521995306015, -0.05641808733344078, -0.006832882296293974, 0.005574728827923536, -0.008291507139801979, 0.028358161449432373, 0.032857462763786316, 0.004536799155175686, -0.04546322301030159, -0.016119103878736496, 0.015405455604195595, -0.03564269840717316, -0.006639670580625534, 0.02894425578415394, 0.017519252374768257, -0.012163358740508556, 0.014590658247470856, 0.03919946774840355, -0.03650074824690819, -0.023785870522260666, 0.033591289073228836, -0.051474735140800476, -0.027981329709291458, -0.04390177130699158, 0.016458045691251755, -0.06014310196042061, 0.0040532792918384075, -0.0031488093081861734, -0.03929833695292473, 0.057526297867298126, 0.033153969794511795, 0.007519608363509178, -0.020788168534636497, 0.019337747246026993, 0.002831554738804698, 0.03028983622789383, -0.043139055371284485, 0.0007156248902902007, 0.041788965463638306, -0.046640072017908096, 0.032876498997211456, -0.0010597434593364596, -0.014754396863281727, -0.012726987712085247, -0.03628741577267647, -0.0579502247273922, 0.023701319471001625, 0.046726617962121964, -0.03181111067533493, 0.027097882702946663, -0.034036654978990555, -0.03658154979348183, -0.024230288341641426, 0.046967267990112305, -0.043036434799432755, 0.08527917414903641, 0.04196436330676079, -0.01786152273416519, 0.03035901114344597, 0.022938743233680725, -0.026731817051768303, -0.06236957386136055, 0.0019579462241381407, 0.02390556037425995, 0.03053325228393078, 0.002188402693718672, 0.060503583401441574, 0.060490675270557404, -0.02822556160390377, -0.006175127811729908, -0.0023391915019601583, 0.03748156502842903, -0.0006858432316221297, -0.04028909653425217, 0.04296053200960159, 0.05832556635141373, 0.046422410756349564, -0.0003218701167497784, -0.03767886012792587, -0.00004729227293864824, -0.023985741659998894, 0.03552224114537239, -0.017467301338911057, 0.009686343371868134, -0.032172903418540955, 0.06576472520828247, 0.007034755777567625, 0.024976754561066628, -0.04967920482158661, 0.07972995936870575, 0.038504935801029205, 0.06754299253225327, 0.01916852779686451, 0.01952742040157318, -0.0006441565928980708, 0.010756350122392178, -0.0030205289367586374, -0.024437373504042625, 0.09838153421878815, 0.02868221513926983, -0.032964419573545456, 0.003808326553553343, 0.006019174586981535, -0.013553785160183907, -0.016068093478679657, -0.006833838298916817, -0.045982442796230316, 0.05575927346944809, -0.04564625024795532, -0.03015574999153614, 0.02523196116089821, 0.038696710020303726, -0.034289922565221786, -0.011872894130647182, 0.00884892139583826, -0.00871666707098484, -0.04183901101350784, 0.013511679135262966, -0.05990544334053993, -0.007951359264552593, 0.022694431245326996, 0.016399919986724854, -0.023423954844474792, 0.03652740642428398, 0.0076835984364151955, 0.07633991539478302, -0.05549866333603859, 0.06840953975915909, 0.02910013496875763, -0.049047715961933136, -0.05924735963344574, -0.02166079916059971, 0.03292626142501831, -0.023140212520956993, -0.005115037318319082, -0.06578608602285385, -0.062456827610731125, -0.03751957044005394, 0.045404884964227676, -0.051462043076753616, 0.0026778390165418386, 0.038969047367572784, -0.03196747228503227, -0.01991058699786663, -0.05352228507399559, -0.0007399186142720282, 0.01696012169122696, -0.007941578514873981, 0.007178883068263531, 0.014484700746834278, -0.07092210650444031, -0.009785114787518978, 0.0491613931953907, -0.043151989579200745, 0.05963744595646858, 0.04016459360718727, 0.04279841110110283, 0.0004968276480212808, -0.01558688934892416, 0.035460904240608215, -0.019653266295790672, 0.029918383806943893, 0.010205091908574104, 0.04078742489218712, -0.004519039765000343, -0.043862905353307724, 0.05599309504032135, 0.027846956625580788, -0.03712545335292816, 0.009147885255515575, 0.0740986317396164, -0.021868443116545677, 0.007084558717906475, 0.005795968696475029, 0.054265912622213364, 0.031714245676994324, -0.0706377699971199, -0.055772535502910614, -0.0628114715218544, 0.037128373980522156, -0.003835878102108836, -0.031026529148221016, -0.036258015781641006, 0.009245559573173523, -0.011959850788116455, -0.04139383137226105, -0.006437273230403662, -0.08035892248153687, 0.00009008762572193518, -0.05478036776185036, -0.10037451237440109, -0.011850923299789429, 0.02281809225678444, 0.030678285285830498, -0.02697749249637127, 0.03874526545405388, -0.008846609853208065, -0.07014665007591248, -0.006794074084609747, -0.03858530521392822, -0.04225582256913185, 0.009172596037387848, -0.008492720313370228, -0.015381316654384136, -0.07432573288679123, 0.04425456002354622, 0.012407601810991764, -0.002556513762101531, 0.001528633525595069, 0.004220524337142706, 0.0032768372911959887, -0.04695592075586319, 0.015875451266765594, 0.013486693613231182, 0.0351928174495697, -0.06622723489999771, 0.03066067025065422, 0.014987314119935036, 0.06692785769701004, -0.032067276537418365, -0.04235533997416496, -0.006403075996786356, -0.02007407322525978, 0.06435244530439377, 0.04508619382977486, 0.03392044082283974, -0.06608564406633377, -0.02933502569794655, -0.006293859798461199, 0.014688733965158463, -0.049824487417936325, -0.0031337388791143894, 0.0026949255261570215, -0.029587309807538986, -0.009344342164695263, -0.007376387715339661, -0.07132603228092194, -0.03265310823917389, 0.06689079105854034, -0.0513906329870224, -0.038217268884181976, 0.027089662849903107, -0.03866318613290787, -0.01975039765238762, -0.054645195603370667, -0.05680737644433975, 0.013089904561638832, 0.037515342235565186, 0.017275432124733925, 0.005345833487808704, 0.07389296591281891, 0.01582225225865841, 0.016930416226387024, -0.04628577083349228, 0.05493733286857605, -0.029677793383598328, -0.0034702580887824297, -0.010053031146526337, 0.011036123149096966, -0.015692176297307014, 0.011338691227138042, 0.04868173226714134, 0.021378986537456512, 0.017738038673996925, -0.03974952921271324, -0.015101244673132896, 0.031406220048666, -0.017414530739188194, -0.04525128751993179, -0.02636450156569481, 0.04458390921354294, 0.03345583751797676, 0.04758402705192566, -0.03678525984287262, 0.03460575267672539, -0.027364984154701233, -0.023196928203105927, -0.04065385460853577, -0.026902133598923683, 0.0007864470244385302, 0.01105312630534172, -0.01482679694890976, -0.05247919633984566, -0.026120124384760857, -0.015073202550411224, 0.04371735453605652, -0.01656407304108143, 0.057125743478536606, 0.028068967163562775, 0.038726385682821274, 0.050375767052173615, 0.0530414804816246, -0.05142083391547203, -0.04657651111483574, 0.007104179821908474, -0.0240473672747612, -0.011864949017763138, 0.03215493634343147, -0.05156833678483963, -0.002825063420459628, 0.06574531644582748, -0.0011348320404067636, -0.020456045866012573, 0.0213319044560194, -0.005974723957479, 0.006143477745354176, 0.059809304773807526, -0.022269926965236664, 0.016272565349936485, -0.040546614676713943, -0.016598910093307495, -0.10018370300531387, 0.044667575508356094, 0.06373608857393265, -0.05757243558764458, 0.03974305838346481, -0.05113445594906807, -0.03453905135393143, 0.01730431243777275, 0.01363992691040039, 0.024530010297894478, -0.021288320422172546, -0.007755530998110771, 0.04683041572570801, -0.0032445532269775867, 0.02544155903160572, -0.009614414535462856, -0.028741996735334396, -0.03162186220288277, -0.007559608202427626, 0.06112825497984886, 0.04079543799161911, 0.005601022858172655, -0.042541101574897766, -0.020488956943154335, 0.0406857430934906, -0.0013858142774552107, -0.03924623504281044, -0.023608524352312088, 0.030226675793528557, -0.018990540876984596, 0.0436549112200737, -0.007390766404569149, -0.017063971608877182, -0.002849094569683075, 0.00570242153480649, 0.010108736343681812, 0.01839161291718483, -0.08499211072921753, 0.026113290339708328, 0.03674524277448654, -0.024553006514906883, 0.025509370490908623, 0.0345265194773674, -0.0358910970389843, 0.007120748516172171, 0.0055445278994739056, -0.005836176220327616, -0.0221408661454916, 0.0030812916811555624, 0.0777599886059761, 0.00539188040420413, -0.018313564360141754, -0.03413214907050133, 0.002049914561212063, 0.01568020135164261, 0.0008899930398911238, 0.027804473415017128, -0.009413993917405605, -0.020405465736985207, -0.04052422195672989, -0.04602234810590744, 0.00010045606904895976, -0.1065961942076683, -0.010962597094476223, -0.04927419498562813, -0.03713032230734825, 0.002480224007740617, 0.0005036280490458012, -0.007936448790133, -0.001974652288481593, 0.03196866437792778, 0.02837265096604824, -0.0017487530130892992, -0.019692253321409225, 0.02810349315404892, -0.002518753055483103, -0.04586265981197357, -0.0033923534210771322, 0.027089010924100876, 0.017793895676732063, 0.005821479018777609, -0.021813388913869858, 0.02399645559489727, -0.0217698123306036, 0.007571178022772074, 0.07650090008974075, 0.05015841871500015, -0.011949380859732628, -0.040612123906612396, 0.05559460073709488, 0.050040435045957565, -0.044408392161130905, 0.02342832274734974, -0.024501491338014603, -0.002551343524828553, 0.004724878817796707, -0.00923839583992958, -0.03268526867032051, -0.04776346683502197, -0.04170634225010872, -0.03334423154592514, 0.0039703031070530415, -0.03693246468901634, -0.0008551565115340054, -0.05795559287071228, -0.015109487809240818, 0.001183934509754181 ]
<p>As far as my knowledge goes, Higgs field is only currently formulated in term of classical gauge theory. What is the importance of Higgs field being formulated in term of quantum gauge theory? In other words, why do we need to formulate Higgs field in term of quantum gauge theory?</p> <p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Higgs_field_%28classical%29&amp;diff=618826334&amp;oldid=555240452" rel="nofollow">Reference</a>: "However, no adequate mathematical model of this Higgs vacuum has been suggested in the framework of quantum gauge theory, though somebody treats it as <em>sui generis</em> a condensate by analogy with that of Cooper pairs in condensed matter physics." </p>
g4090
[ -0.0033327152486890554, 0.04491053894162178, 0.004213235341012478, -0.01903994381427765, 0.025839312002062798, 0.01914663426578045, 0.0021704856771975756, 0.03745492175221443, -0.0032531532924622297, -0.045580070465803146, 0.001657685381360352, -0.020186003297567368, -0.003317768219858408, 0.03352722153067589, -0.00792114157229662, 0.009381556883454323, 0.015596181154251099, 0.022490430623292923, 0.03277936950325966, -0.028993498533964157, 0.03100496716797352, -0.03883707523345947, -0.000714343914296478, -0.01748805120587349, -0.08394666761159897, 0.019249912351369858, 0.0809645801782608, -0.00902856606990099, 0.1007646694779396, 0.0004919689381495118, 0.08108847588300705, 0.0325213298201561, 0.04864231497049332, -0.08662179112434387, 0.010310682468116283, -0.0370626263320446, 0.04538147523999214, 0.03825850784778595, -0.02411980926990509, -0.03062114119529724, 0.03521908074617386, 0.008044464513659477, -0.01284787431359291, -0.004228709731251001, -0.021915189921855927, 0.04095372185111046, 0.0003989584220107645, -0.03016352839767933, 0.015130436979234219, -0.04141872748732567, 0.018391763791441917, -0.012008791789412498, 0.039815377444028854, 0.006978535559028387, 0.06759192049503326, 0.037635501474142075, 0.04631206765770912, -0.006913711316883564, 0.04343174025416374, -0.036287110298871994, -0.016214869916439056, 0.08199826627969742, -0.012477015145123005, 0.021325385197997093, 0.06564969569444656, -0.02977437525987625, -0.056845828890800476, -0.032275717705488205, 0.007050394080579281, 0.028264367952942848, -0.013540040701627731, -0.08538256585597992, -0.002972607035189867, 0.06604187190532684, 0.012959473766386509, 0.007240127772092819, 0.0032780165784060955, -0.013121413066983223, 0.025628451257944107, -0.0206685159355402, 0.022179752588272095, -0.04322259873151779, 0.048302389681339264, 0.0026150343474000692, 0.066497802734375, -0.06066737696528435, 0.007055746391415596, -0.005832151044160128, -0.02368486113846302, -0.01418699137866497, -0.04105735942721367, 0.014710000716149807, 0.0533975213766098, 0.03851800411939621, -0.0007530245929956436, -0.0029017189517617226, -0.025352349504828453, -0.008024272508919239, -0.012211969122290611, 0.05138612911105156, -0.06636100262403488, -0.011152233928442001, 0.034531183540821075, -0.028444143012166023, 0.04375012591481209, -0.008385197259485722, 0.056437186896800995, 0.06036471575498581, -0.012449484318494797, 0.014482173137366772, -0.0750226080417633, 0.07068485766649246, -0.03846118599176407, -0.03297759220004082, -0.03533393517136574, 0.05838216841220856, 0.07098271697759628, -0.005206830333918333, -0.0060086846351623535, -0.007238888181746006, -0.02689882181584835, 0.007445795927196741, 0.06076999008655548, -0.027993187308311462, -0.041456326842308044, 0.0021531523671001196, -0.015082750469446182, 0.004192043095827103, 0.03348201513290405, -0.04020307585597038, 0.03397176042199135, 0.02668374963104725, -0.015190872363746166, 0.015883002430200577, 0.011825439520180225, 0.012384336441755295, 0.006684146821498871, -0.02979988045990467, 0.07685142010450363, -0.017425959929823875, -0.020620957016944885, -0.019602488726377487, -0.013085447251796722, 0.004951565992087126, 0.0229547880589962, 0.033626507967710495, 0.04471564665436745, 0.023835863918066025, -0.01978827640414238, -0.00044414453441277146, 0.025306226685643196, 0.07043047994375229, 0.016994869336485863, -0.0013210553443059325, 0.027144504711031914, 0.016067050397396088, 0.012821112759411335, 0.004941054619848728, -0.03879518806934357, -0.09002622961997986, 0.03427089750766754, -0.030787231400609016, 0.00034468271769583225, -0.022984663024544716, -0.01161552406847477, 0.0011195886181667447, 0.03569367527961731, -0.07496426999568939, 0.0006140912882983685, -0.044165827333927155, -0.03536216542124748, 0.015978680923581123, -0.06438475847244263, 0.03704614192247391, 0.05065756291151047, 0.04460420086979866, 0.029402146115899086, 0.007461150176823139, -0.02625318057835102, -0.03991955146193504, -0.019233951345086098, -0.047287438064813614, 0.011467191390693188, -0.03374907374382019, -0.08256007730960846, 0.042107537388801575, 0.037873875349760056, -0.016593053936958313, -0.006223638076335192, 0.017234493046998978, -0.00700778653845191, -0.0012276223860681057, -0.005702487658709288, 0.03429125249385834, 0.010202639736235142, 0.0434342585504055, 0.0023015819024294615, 0.013836025260388851, -0.016197776421904564, 0.015909135341644287, -0.0368981659412384, -0.0000439962386735715, -0.0020043179392814636, -0.00796187948435545, 0.02256842330098152, 0.013495792634785175, -0.06721479445695877, 0.016031436622142792, 0.026269331574440002, -0.039806172251701355, -0.01007870677858591, -0.0282684788107872, 0.0300473440438509, 0.017839333042502403, -0.013115238398313522, -0.030908694490790367, -0.00968922022730112, 0.029674841091036797, -0.0484444834291935, 0.04382245987653732, -0.03874064236879349, -0.05487909913063049, 0.06064965948462486, -0.008042595349252224, -0.0538272000849247, -0.038590434938669205, 0.019519176334142685, -0.019513655453920364, -0.030700480565428734, 0.0049506365321576595, -0.053488001227378845, -0.017504790797829628, -0.05079035088419914, -0.010918290354311466, -0.0013471737038344145, 0.03197779878973961, 0.0011514973593875766, -0.027500862255692482, 0.044582728296518326, 0.08300457894802094, 0.04396394267678261, 0.029885435476899147, -0.0132514713332057, -0.01342829316854477, 0.03276219591498375, -0.001265285536646843, 0.05564461648464203, -0.024910518899559975, -0.07285385578870773, 0.004599991720169783, -0.005726526957005262, -0.0232151597738266, -0.028096016496419907, -0.08417727798223495, 0.03311169892549515, 0.0025303433649241924, 0.02425558865070343, -0.035964399576187134, -0.056212376803159714, -0.044235099107027054, 0.04094798117876053, -0.04133224859833717, -0.05024341866374016, 0.018641408532857895, -0.03231872618198395, 0.011981741525232792, 0.07090532779693604, 0.006131079513579607, -0.01784510724246502, -0.06719785928726196, -0.037536319345235825, 0.0029978628735989332, -0.053622517734766006, -0.03206618130207062, 0.01465296559035778, -0.09419529885053635, -0.04548099637031555, 0.04460715875029564, 0.07957390695810318, -0.05709424987435341, 0.0039102002047002316, -0.00920102745294571, -0.0031332143116742373, 0.04127601906657219, -0.007009588647633791, -0.10688186436891556, -0.05160187557339668, -0.02429758757352829, 0.03448902815580368, 0.030075756832957268, 0.06564860790967941, 0.02897314727306366, -0.04468875378370285, 0.04663991555571556, -0.008365237154066563, 0.02650434896349907, 0.018071336671710014, 0.015564464032649994, -0.042804356664419174, 0.017174530774354935, -0.006713921669870615, 0.023511148989200592, -0.014153352938592434, -0.013716482557356358, 0.020013477653265, -0.00004030887794215232, -0.016541307792067528, -0.022962365299463272, -0.04436997324228287, -0.09315429627895355, 0.008185461163520813, 0.03228304907679558, -0.018378157168626785, 0.009736446663737297, -0.044406596571207047, -0.012648229487240314, 0.0781230553984642, 0.035256244242191315, -0.03962792456150055, -0.016642974689602852, -0.0169791541993618, 0.008264075964689255, 0.05131904408335686, -0.001961086643859744, 0.03912631422281265, 0.05911538377404213, -0.02638407237827778, 0.023532720282673836, 0.0025617231149226427, -0.019532205536961555, 0.014579745009541512, -0.09722712635993958, -0.011721312999725342, -0.032035943120718, -0.011518063023686409, -0.0057259914465248585, -0.013753609731793404, 0.006402349099516869, 0.01197035051882267, -0.023971235379576683, 0.029954982921481133, -0.025036774575710297, -0.058154962956905365, 0.05400523170828819, -0.022569291293621063, -0.00862468034029007, -0.02312586084008217, -0.022052550688385963, 0.06291679292917252, -0.03437419980764389, -0.0021660870406776667, 0.019993087276816368, 0.03128853067755699, 0.007557759061455727, -0.08996789157390594, -0.004908361937850714, 0.0026354750152677298, 0.029755378141999245, 0.04866925999522209, -0.040213391184806824, 0.010837527923285961, 0.01922883465886116, 0.027795055881142616, 0.043457020074129105, -0.014099850319325924, 0.005523075815290213, -0.02829810418188572, -0.03627966716885567, -0.04089083895087242, -0.0012106387875974178, -0.06552045792341232, -0.04354196786880493, -0.034604717046022415, 0.03365961089730263, 0.04740346595644951, -0.07432514429092407, 0.031123559921979904, 0.003305374877527356, -0.0024219562765210867, -0.039315950125455856, -0.022722087800502777, 0.06322798877954483, 0.04196804016828537, 0.00022266397718340158, 0.021316824480891228, -0.025358617305755615, -0.02326216548681259, 0.04464482143521309, -0.00019406202773097903, 0.006640434730798006, -0.11820009350776672, 0.03522888943552971, -0.05157783254981041, 0.017644450068473816, -0.020482299849390984, 0.03835361823439598, 0.04439051076769829, 0.002521004294976592, -0.013648049905896187, -0.06649017333984375, 0.047455333173274994, -0.01586274616420269, 0.0145287299528718, -0.002225153846666217, 0.003999379463493824, -0.030719749629497528, 0.0648404136300087, -0.06854722648859024, 0.00034958860487677157, -0.02557607740163803, 0.0007044907542876899, 0.020416704937815666, -0.00908882450312376, -0.027631299570202827, 0.04208427667617798, -0.01750900037586689, -0.0035048837307840586, -0.0408473014831543, 0.036073751747608185, 0.016241740435361862, 0.06907882541418076, 0.006014364305883646, 0.10421976447105408, 0.00035790621768683195, -0.003253840608522296, 0.05874542519450188, 0.0039560431614518166, 0.06032516807317734, -0.04357539862394333, -0.05156060308218002, 0.027792368084192276, 0.02996359020471573, -0.004717396106570959, 0.009433074854314327, -0.01153205893933773, 0.018363654613494873, -0.06932327151298523, -0.00728184450417757, -0.02333570457994938, -0.005735144019126892, 0.010434242896735668, 0.009974216111004353, 0.007208562456071377, 0.005886159371584654, -0.0596899539232254, -0.0010946446564048529, -0.015879351645708084, 0.015582181513309479, -0.03458111733198166, -0.04867390915751457, 0.006555233150720596, 0.037848398089408875, 0.007994920946657658, -0.03436507284641266, 0.04423202574253082, 0.026700401678681374, 0.002747287740930915, -0.039041876792907715, 0.008750392124056816, 0.013804595917463303, -0.07247710227966309, 0.044946931302547455, 0.026262899860739708, 0.027415703982114792, 0.037402939051389694, -0.04970584064722061, -0.05971404165029526, -0.0454423688352108, -0.05456574261188507, -0.0620298832654953, 0.009674644097685814, -0.05838361382484436, 0.022902777418494225, -0.06312166899442673, 0.051055897027254105, 0.039603397250175476, 0.0001535901246825233, -0.06669463217258453, -0.007001911755651236, -0.03713015094399452, -0.02865687385201454, -0.007848384790122509, 0.03345199301838875, 0.051806025207042694, -0.02363988757133484, -0.012251834385097027, -0.03698280453681946, 0.07265724986791611, -0.021499400958418846, -0.059901829808950424, -0.016921525821089745, 0.009401148185133934, 0.03364478424191475, 0.005553747992962599, -0.006299015134572983, -0.027101224288344383, 0.006902127992361784, -0.02316475659608841, -0.009938832372426987, -0.017445355653762817, -0.03558795899152756, 0.033960819244384766, -0.01855725236237049, 0.00468502938747406, -0.021798569709062576, 0.05107979476451874, 0.033333420753479004, -0.0001765962952049449, 0.04159136116504669, -0.03468293696641922, 0.0432005301117897, -0.04268530756235123, -0.04703822731971741, 0.06354910880327225, 0.06371419876813889, -0.027781154960393906, 0.008941500447690487, -0.036686379462480545, 0.010835563763976097, -0.01776205562055111, 0.01321476325392723, 0.0011142096482217312, -0.026067083701491356, -0.011126776225864887, 0.01745176874101162, 0.03208369016647339, -0.039571668952703476, -0.03869229182600975, 0.031363703310489655, 0.03269561007618904, 0.006892470642924309, 0.0061013102531433105, 0.06681831926107407, 0.037949904799461365, -0.0071864137426018715, 0.047960225492715836, -0.041299980133771896, 0.01638590730726719, 0.03938637673854828, 0.02533409744501114, -0.08621659874916077, 0.014282727614045143, 0.0008903553243726492, 0.010879839770495892, 0.0561671108007431, 0.011877086013555527, -0.025180159136652946, -0.03352469578385353, 0.08873984962701797, -0.002022889442741871, -0.06488144397735596, -0.015440830960869789, 0.03949220851063728, 0.020632954314351082, 0.0046955253928899765, -0.03642697632312775, 0.003844796447083354, -0.00883639045059681, -0.03652250021696091, 0.005377264693379402, 0.01405651867389679, 0.052403610199689865, 0.011920653283596039, 0.045824937522411346, -0.03697687387466431, 0.015488591976463795, 0.04869841784238815, -0.0025314062368124723, 0.018046604469418526, -0.009660233743488789, -0.02187884971499443, 0.025163186714053154, -0.010919172316789627, -0.008722974918782711, -0.01495541725307703, 0.022183574736118317, -0.013265978544950485, -0.026111263781785965, -0.03157646954059601, -0.015425552614033222, 0.027528757229447365, -0.02286870963871479, 0.013226859271526337, -0.09668933600187302, -0.02001895196735859, 0.0016898263711482286, -0.010123212821781635, 0.0016130923759192228, 0.032836053520441055, 0.10049204528331757, -0.013486891053617, 0.040315959602594376, 0.013511771336197853, 0.01815875992178917, -0.006156557239592075, 0.013550102710723877, 0.01726674661040306, 0.08042018115520477, -0.0016492108115926385, -0.026098446920514107, -0.006374378688633442, 0.09186393767595291, -0.023283103480935097, 0.01635723188519478, 0.037718646228313446, 0.09468545019626617, -0.0025517847388982773, -0.005904488265514374, -0.01542968675494194, -0.0008400757797062397, 0.009779122658073902, -0.04104703292250633, -0.008130540139973164, -0.01751999743282795, -0.0020569548942148685, 0.04634096473455429, 0.02475876361131668, 0.06272252649068832, -0.051266610622406006, -0.003884839592501521, 0.019825978204607964, -0.009386292658746243, 0.004345192573964596, 0.03240220993757248, 0.026428038254380226, 0.005412187427282333, -0.047613777220249176, 0.05838915705680847, 0.05522938072681427, -0.002007444156333804, 0.03755057603120804, -0.012132532894611359, -0.011680752970278263, 0.04018406569957733, -0.016002418473362923, 0.021363114938139915, -0.020773500204086304, -0.007422769907861948, 0.0022440783213824034, -0.03422503173351288, -0.05691702663898468, -0.0015852696960791945, 0.020659519359469414, 0.008951094001531601, -0.04136526584625244, 0.015432045795023441, 0.016559738665819168, -0.03026833012700081, -0.06710221618413925, -0.025822462514042854, -0.05234404280781746, -0.018183140084147453, 0.014678183011710644, -0.01850046217441559, 0.0029456650372594595, -0.02580813504755497, 0.00297495536506176, 0.027339298278093338, 0.009243646636605263, -0.04894484579563141, -0.007288884371519089, -0.00018340015958528966, 0.008748592808842659, 0.03718062490224838, -0.006878932472318411, 0.01787898689508438, 0.010719266720116138, -0.04264819622039795, 0.06407433748245239, -0.02075137011706829, 0.001893502427265048, -0.04872705787420273, -0.01098719984292984, -0.04545862600207329, 0.014648850075900555, -0.004473390057682991, 0.017112312838435173, 0.0024771152529865503, -0.008569353260099888, 0.014655673876404762, -0.030816050246357918, 0.03985530883073807, 0.02529912441968918, -0.0034810882061719894, 0.003931226674467325, 0.005014551337808371, 0.04175131767988205, 0.001148211071267724, -0.02168969064950943, 0.051472797989845276, 0.06913769990205765, -0.0377344973385334, 0.0006328689050860703, -0.03274060785770416, 0.02639445848762989, 0.031453173607587814, 0.038412801921367645, -0.013733277097344398, 0.013466453179717064, 0.011366425082087517, -0.021712565794587135, -0.021777896210551262, -0.007153647486120462, -0.01753011904656887, 0.06145518273115158, -0.000379315169993788, 0.05668596923351288, -0.002366604283452034, -0.06551232933998108, -0.01030249334871769, -0.031784538179636, 0.013225832022726536, 0.06795810908079147, 0.05884648114442825, 0.01511472463607788, -0.036781396716833115, -0.0564410425722599, 0.0074433195404708385, -0.04795626550912857, -0.0841486006975174, 0.0045301346108317375, -0.011935104615986347, 0.011000529862940311, 0.009357603266835213, -0.038820985704660416, 0.022810587659478188, 0.03398345410823822, 0.011930379085242748, 0.014268108643591404, -0.03675917536020279, -0.026604000478982925, 0.014642915688455105, -0.0271014291793108, 0.014942219480872154, -0.0703883245587349, 0.06315085291862488, 0.01846402697265148, 0.0026976389344781637, 0.022964119911193848, 0.028280001133680344, 0.0668305829167366, -0.029008183628320694, 0.03040776401758194, -0.035712964832782745, -0.004027137067168951, -0.05423213914036751, -0.0005059319082647562, -0.046677280217409134, 0.010980190709233284, 0.024121100082993507, -0.03974149003624916, -0.03816172853112221, -0.025963351130485535, 0.0433417409658432, 0.03036310151219368, -0.06553615629673004, 0.021546263247728348, -0.009726588614284992, 0.016194557771086693, 0.013381103053689003, 0.017033623531460762, -0.0060255685821175575, 0.07116491347551346, 0.024203242734074593, -0.04495679959654808, -0.01943589560687542, 0.015140942297875881, -0.005448640789836645 ]
<p>My layman understanding of the Uncertainty Principle is that you can't determine the both the position and momentum of a particle at the same point in time, because measuring one variable changes the other, and both cannot be measured at once.</p> <p>But what happens if I measure a charged particle with any number of detectors over a period of time? Can I use a multitude of measurements to infer these properties for some point in the past? If not, how close can we get? That is, how precise can our estimate be?</p>
g4091
[ 0.020179977640509605, 0.023257657885551453, -0.014428158290684223, 0.026324434205889702, 0.07962095737457275, 0.004008209332823753, 0.009380101226270199, 0.002389254281297326, -0.026816774159669876, -0.0020906245335936546, -0.053758248686790466, 0.005121902097016573, -0.06077669933438301, -0.012452404014766216, -0.036282505840063095, -0.033338576555252075, 0.0964740663766861, 0.01220641378313303, 0.04171627014875412, 0.06257621198892593, 0.07380035519599915, 0.01424231007695198, -0.02378038875758648, -0.028377944603562355, -0.05369720607995987, -0.01548899244517088, -0.021514801308512688, -0.005586057901382446, -0.02492693066596985, -0.02864149399101734, 0.02026117593050003, -0.04547513648867607, 0.022176720201969147, -0.015878548845648766, 0.013678596355021, -0.10892875492572784, 0.04546472802758217, -0.056012626737356186, 0.02029307186603546, 0.010072125121951103, 0.015445822849869728, -0.013340752571821213, 0.03262178972363472, -0.030103925615549088, 0.028278112411499023, 0.06523720920085907, -0.009773427620530128, -0.013291924260556698, -0.00160007004160434, -0.008294614031910896, -0.06155126169323921, 0.01254053134471178, -0.024640491232275963, 0.08811307698488235, 0.009355820715427399, 0.0662420392036438, 0.04296553507447243, -0.004191785119473934, 0.0488477423787117, 0.021467875689268112, 0.02459336444735527, -0.01650553196668625, -0.04011792689561844, 0.012298508547246456, 0.016833683475852013, 0.0097604189068079, -0.07615246623754501, -0.014193248003721237, -0.025299984961748123, -0.027161484584212303, 0.025741957128047943, -0.0423714853823185, -0.02734508365392685, -0.02074466645717621, -0.030409937724471092, 0.022231338545680046, -0.03284856304526329, 0.023893577978014946, 0.007547874469310045, 0.012407989241182804, -0.03511463478207588, -0.01490560919046402, 0.0183744914829731, -0.01714947074651718, 0.05961570516228676, -0.0009238673374056816, 0.023876618593931198, 0.0436551608145237, 0.019259095191955566, -0.010155608877539635, -0.004371659830212593, -0.047243181616067886, 0.046815916895866394, -0.0011424532858654857, 0.020288212224841118, -0.03290967270731926, -0.04986543580889702, 0.06001890078186989, -0.033665891736745834, 0.020924879238009453, -0.04326417297124863, 0.04975181818008423, -0.017727207392454147, 0.006462872959673405, -0.04218215495347977, -0.007744967006146908, 0.025373036041855812, -0.014975822530686855, 0.04337888956069946, -0.04369668662548065, -0.038401439785957336, -0.04113065451383591, -0.0016291816718876362, 0.009450476616621017, -0.07994133979082108, -0.004915735684335232, 0.027992917224764824, 0.016397232189774513, -0.03207473084330559, -0.014706501737236977, -0.001572637353092432, 0.014195413328707218, 0.018862798810005188, 0.09116799384355545, -0.06919290125370026, 0.03650282695889473, -0.021481899544596672, 0.06530948728322983, -0.023059315979480743, 0.0606100894510746, -0.023168550804257393, -0.015108643099665642, -0.010618685744702816, 0.06427844613790512, -0.04719061031937599, -0.011147511191666126, 0.0003864143800456077, 0.04488102346658707, 0.013399978168308735, 0.04004255309700966, 0.0523100271821022, -0.014129316434264183, 0.007326287683099508, -0.029299084097146988, 0.011495271697640419, 0.009780799970030785, -0.0372614823281765, -0.04350683465600014, -0.00943090207874775, 0.03884436935186386, -0.02574748545885086, 0.05031183362007141, 0.04855496808886528, 0.03477529436349869, 0.04826176539063454, -0.03070208989083767, -0.0002670933317858726, 0.029441840946674347, 0.010017763823270798, -0.016037331894040108, -0.0008960050763562322, -0.0010860762558877468, 0.032205358147621155, 0.014793462119996548, -0.009046589024364948, -0.008280257694423199, 0.014418616890907288, -0.03772370517253876, 0.0017376464093104005, -0.06173140928149223, -0.03082379326224327, -0.02894112840294838, 0.017924107611179352, -0.046087268739938736, 0.03862832859158516, 0.02783551625907421, -0.04508218914270401, -0.04997529089450836, 0.029861178249120712, 0.04435410723090172, -0.026246342808008194, 0.04845397546887398, 0.012223071418702602, -0.04903998598456383, -0.06060532107949257, 0.04387041926383972, 0.023775462061166763, -0.0294360164552927, -0.019385192543268204, 0.002858200576156378, 0.011256486177444458, -0.07280883193016052, -0.04311945661902428, 0.028078103438019753, -0.02768312208354473, -0.00219865795224905, 0.047057170420885086, -0.018036462366580963, -0.00546076986938715, 0.028797142207622528, -0.015768179669976234, 0.053229205310344696, 0.012573879212141037, 0.05315825715661049, 0.07871624827384949, -0.016559746116399765, -0.012735781259834766, -0.027629924938082695, -0.012984178960323334, -0.012846110388636589, 0.07316266000270844, 0.01900622621178627, -0.04676390066742897, 0.05028017982840538, -0.03823315352201462, -0.03293142095208168, 0.01025321800261736, 0.01575341820716858, 0.10021266341209412, -0.008140794932842255, -0.09222756326198578, -0.004585841204971075, 0.0467321053147316, -0.0023812633007764816, 0.007019401527941227, 0.044828515499830246, -0.004999743774533272, 0.007530363742262125, -0.04054070636630058, 0.029574647545814514, -0.018531134352087975, 0.0161556676030159, -0.01754515804350376, 0.02037215605378151, 0.05128186196088791, 0.06304463744163513, -0.01925216242671013, -0.057833440601825714, 0.04347992688417435, -0.005500019993633032, -0.04302244633436203, -0.017445480450987816, -0.006304862909018993, -0.00422240374609828, 0.010223345831036568, -0.021831050515174866, 0.005577449686825275, 0.04112415388226509, -0.00773242674767971, 0.03052704967558384, -0.017955463379621506, 0.046317458152770996, 0.021185895428061485, -0.006389528047293425, -0.024695446714758873, 0.022519096732139587, 0.0360037162899971, 0.0429856963455677, -0.10696318745613098, -0.017188861966133118, 0.04395977780222893, -0.0003467389615252614, -0.04896382614970207, -0.006587420590221882, 0.05515091121196747, -0.05220554769039154, -0.00589384138584137, 0.06858056783676147, 0.008281504735350609, -0.0143769271671772, 0.0301129799336195, 0.050157494843006134, 0.05200878530740738, 0.03480834141373634, -0.011718304827809334, 0.01104551088064909, 0.0016876333393156528, -0.022074587643146515, 0.056670982390642166, -0.05413774773478508, -0.03426159918308258, 0.028582394123077393, -0.08347288519144058, 0.019120730459690094, -0.02087392844259739, 0.003726139897480607, 0.010971982963383198, -0.022638073191046715, -0.013508477248251438, 0.03629389777779579, -0.012167821638286114, -0.01051623560488224, 0.11352019011974335, -0.01416549738496542, -0.029942160472273827, 0.01928490214049816, 0.023624615743756294, -0.027889829128980637, 0.0067876349203288555, -0.007601299788802862, 0.005204038228839636, 0.015590960159897804, -0.024042604491114616, -0.007900143042206764, 0.10014421492815018, 0.010242716409265995, -0.03742598742246628, 0.007325144950300455, 0.036111846566200256, -0.035201866179704666, -0.01583056151866913, 0.05106222257018089, 0.006587520707398653, -0.004279763903468847, 0.010594619438052177, -0.040708523243665695, -0.01540791429579258, 0.05030415952205658, -0.04801422357559204, -0.0037495947908610106, 0.0066683185286819935, -0.034468114376068115, 0.06237315759062767, -0.04038306325674057, 0.09937503933906555, 0.023014836013317108, -0.06858456879854202, 0.008477826602756977, -0.07373331487178802, -0.008748172782361507, 0.0033410347532480955, -0.00699283042922616, 0.04002365842461586, -0.02799408882856369, 0.0002010952157434076, -0.03487219288945198, 0.029548518359661102, 0.008602390997111797, 0.05231700465083122, 0.031175825744867325, -0.009382398799061775, -0.0050450642593204975, -0.054112184792757034, -0.01557486318051815, -0.010886878706514835, 0.004499115981161594, 0.030474625527858734, -0.014459874480962753, 0.0034547531977295876, -0.006848023738712072, 0.05614549666643143, 0.00011860996892210096, -0.013887889683246613, 0.02109786681830883, 0.025543948635458946, 0.056868620216846466, 0.016659656539559364, 0.02954673208296299, -0.013989675790071487, 0.00880652479827404, -0.0009555288124829531, -0.027892721816897392, 0.0061232359148561954, -0.03290199860930443, 0.020521339029073715, 0.003191315336152911, -0.0067773908376693726, 0.04506766051054001, 0.04132452234625816, -0.022447040304541588, -0.057090241461992264, 0.011984147131443024, 0.03246953710913658, 0.0326000452041626, 0.02906530536711216, -0.007962957955896854, 0.044167015701532364, -0.027487026527523994, -0.02705325186252594, 0.014372527599334717, -0.012044372037053108, 0.07009528577327728, 0.026670342311263084, -0.0697755441069603, -0.004898353945463896, 0.030188532546162605, -0.04545922949910164, 0.028363177552819252, 0.0042573497630655766, -0.0743066668510437, 0.020123643800616264, -0.042120110243558884, -0.059522733092308044, -0.018620522692799568, 0.04726763442158699, -0.06654080748558044, 0.007054928224533796, -0.06808328628540039, 0.0244449432939291, -0.019423305988311768, 0.027164703235030174, 0.053977031260728836, -0.011412053368985653, -0.015522307716310024, 0.011830221861600876, -0.0015010419301688671, 0.03666185960173607, -0.011151265352964401, -0.010434390977025032, -0.01680890843272209, -0.04861394688487053, -0.03709573671221733, 0.033156342804431915, -0.03135734423995018, -0.039552342146635056, 0.026561351493000984, -0.011820336803793907, -0.07339487224817276, -0.0051565999165177345, 0.057624801993370056, 0.052723612636327744, 0.03943648189306259, 0.030416345223784447, -0.02355971559882164, -0.07975345849990845, 0.026567060500383377, 0.022777682170271873, 0.006354073993861675, -0.009868025779724121, -0.02790461666882038, 0.024556322023272514, -0.014679123647511005, 0.026387521997094154, -0.0007243567961268127, 0.0059052021242678165, -0.00893576443195343, 0.014263506978750229, -0.022548208013176918, -0.0036399730015546083, 0.05311565473675728, 0.06270439922809601, 0.030139083042740822, 0.019999854266643524, -0.028193574398756027, -0.04284530133008957, 0.038154684007167816, -0.017046013846993446, -0.013131367042660713, 0.04330116882920265, 0.04340153932571411, -0.03362349793314934, -0.0028136384207755327, -0.0958118736743927, 0.0030236775055527687, -0.0060087996535003185, -0.010750030167400837, -0.015227057971060276, 0.019848059862852097, 0.016231844201683998, 0.06385556608438492, -0.04923214390873909, 0.002555304206907749, 0.0028240473475307226, 0.009790454059839249, -0.016197074204683304, -0.05257365480065346, -0.07295553386211395, -0.045029766857624054, -0.07513769716024399, -0.0033928982447832823, -0.02291586808860302, 0.009986840188503265, 0.05313769727945328, 0.024097895249724388, 0.036274705082178116, -0.05368427559733391, -0.009989659301936626, -0.009685096330940723, 0.035007137805223465, -0.051617275923490524, -0.041464418172836304, 0.02039911411702633, -0.010408451780676842, -0.009917829185724258, -0.03980201855301857, 0.015148725360631943, -0.0766291618347168, 0.026220915839076042, 0.014511196874082088, -0.027823209762573242, 0.02880128100514412, -0.009140239097177982, 0.08814330399036407, -0.03469206392765045, 0.003251179587095976, 0.01239863596856594, -0.03508073091506958, 0.0028332837391644716, -0.033941127359867096, 0.04884602501988411, -0.010859428904950619, 0.024684041738510132, 0.00343728088773787, 0.020951956510543823, 0.0005962906870990992, 0.038612302392721176, 0.039670493453741074, -0.05045776814222336, -0.05585189536213875, 0.019011082127690315, 0.00166384968906641, 0.031007766723632812, -0.05019441619515419, 0.007836268283426762, 0.03935284540057182, 0.019759630784392357, -0.04449434205889702, -0.003613334149122238, -0.04376259446144104, 0.006945976056158543, 0.00021536082203965634, 0.009536290541291237, 0.06576893478631973, 0.03475908190011978, -0.0081913648173213, -0.07318664342164993, -0.048016782850027084, -0.010443340986967087, 0.001656681182794273, 0.018432358279824257, 0.061552662402391434, -0.020792493596673012, -0.006281050853431225, -0.053465764969587326, -0.0287003256380558, 0.01118656899780035, -0.023757679387927055, -0.052289050072431564, 0.023889701813459396, -0.025610070675611496, -0.014567654579877853, -0.03522254154086113, 0.045114610344171524, 0.05759085342288017, -0.009467781521379948, 0.014147443696856499, -0.01941045932471752, 0.012617211788892746, 0.01462932862341404, -0.045982375741004944, 0.02159544639289379, 0.024585293605923653, -0.03146601468324661, 0.007624450605362654, -0.037128038704395294, 0.027472196146845818, 0.010292552411556244, -0.005339985713362694, -0.04968578368425369, 0.015029164031147957, 0.0386345200240612, -0.028931953012943268, 0.013812493532896042, -0.014000044204294682, -0.009209134615957737, -0.0098560256883502, -0.014220968820154667, -0.00901800487190485, 0.008609449490904808, 0.04415325075387955, 0.011567245237529278, -0.004686504136770964, 0.012257515452802181, 0.005065876059234142, 0.0035626657772809267, 0.04746277630329132, -0.032886210829019547, 0.0390576608479023, -0.03133520111441612, -0.042150236666202545, 0.01699521392583847, 0.0521092489361763, 0.01997077837586403, 0.004634812008589506, 0.05136459693312645, 0.09683878719806671, -0.010259549133479595, 0.015255311504006386, 0.03757835552096367, 0.015430732630193233, 0.01736045628786087, -0.06191073730587959, -0.0033396512735635042, -0.04463766887784004, -0.12297416478395462, 0.01129259541630745, 0.05080677568912506, -0.06268837302923203, -0.021052144467830658, 0.05186324194073677, 0.019565461203455925, 0.00010817649308592081, 0.018520185723900795, -0.02216850407421589, 0.001605236204341054, 0.008448408916592598, -0.011974099092185497, -0.007807937916368246, 0.03851931542158127, -0.06508102267980576, -0.021474497392773628, -0.00921534188091755, 0.02173258736729622, 0.03607277572154999, -0.011037410236895084, 0.014869009144604206, 0.043275218456983566, -0.0037280351389199495, -0.031143847852945328, 0.01183843333274126, 0.05895104631781578, 0.024549832567572594, -0.04745175689458847, 0.016217302531003952, -0.03357348218560219, 0.0054568215273320675, -0.009224734269082546, 0.017186561599373817, 0.04794643819332123, 0.004554189741611481, 0.028169916942715645, 0.008857756853103638, 0.09022612124681473, 0.04769224300980568, -0.06046394258737564, 0.03131909668445587, 0.049840133637189865, 0.05131254345178604, -0.02093677781522274, -0.002210189588367939, 0.02900276705622673, 0.00893219280987978, -0.002248192671686411, 0.004585601389408112, -0.04895341023802757, -0.028427602723240852, 0.05873784422874451, -0.01908360980451107, -0.004596698563545942, -0.010678418911993504, -0.0317251943051815, -0.04232395440340042, -0.00465237395837903, 0.025354253128170967, -0.009843618609011173, 0.037132587283849716, 0.058965347707271576, -0.04327067732810974, 0.021085472777485847, -0.041840698570013046, -0.040722161531448364, -0.06797786802053452, -0.02339988201856613, -0.07614455372095108, -0.008531007915735245, 0.02038554847240448, -0.00064377166563645, -0.12200450152158737, 0.0058219353668391705, -0.08340863138437271, 0.0411909818649292, -0.013702883385121822, -0.02202596329152584, 0.006198798771947622, 0.026416635140776634, -0.01686640828847885, -0.02367202192544937, 0.041645877063274384, -0.02336978353559971, 0.05568884313106537, -0.01847304217517376, 0.06623769551515579, 0.013241618871688843, 0.038647186011075974, -0.04269631952047348, 0.008459051139652729, -0.06050039827823639, 0.03592824935913086, -0.01041130069643259, -0.06345117092132568, -0.012221019715070724, -0.048611849546432495, 0.05505063012242317, -0.07021620869636536, 0.002199226524680853, 0.015731673687696457, 0.07117251306772232, -0.02775670774281025, 0.013904061168432236, -0.04099097102880478, -0.02010374143719673, 0.0020086171571165323, 0.048453643918037415, -0.039786748588085175, 0.007990715093910694, -0.03737117350101471, -0.05603427067399025, 0.003970049787312746, 0.0004080861108377576, 0.019878460094332695, 0.038576655089855194, 0.027382003143429756, -0.0013405113713815808, -0.003977661952376366, -0.05327422544360161, -0.015579676255583763, -0.06878621131181717, -0.029417870566248894, 0.02596387453377247, -0.0015481373993679881, -0.015409949235618114, -0.04076896607875824, -0.005612690933048725, -0.022037683054804802, 0.01749863661825657, -0.04073057323694229, -0.024937856942415237, 0.032130125910043716, 0.048283983021974564, -0.017695773392915726, -0.017438068985939026, -0.0417412593960762, -0.05461195856332779, 0.0036357215140014887, -0.020460495725274086, 0.03504149615764618, 0.044894397258758545, 0.025319324806332588, -0.014927231706678867, -0.026143597438931465, -0.014271772466599941, -0.017870420590043068, -0.006098262034356594, 0.04706110805273056, -0.03479374200105667, -0.02231377735733986, -0.019066480919718742, 0.050748661160469055, 0.0519261509180069, -0.028488565236330032, -0.015204156748950481, 0.011527778580784798, 0.009986909106373787, 0.06340967863798141, 0.0023738592863082886, -0.0403166264295578, -0.03227024897933006, 0.016392657533288002, 0.01592583768069744, -0.02419932559132576, 0.035474132746458054, 0.014535524882376194, -0.016039617359638214, -0.011399573646485806, -0.03586577624082565, -0.032644789665937424, 0.022577829658985138, -0.0013677934184670448 ]
<p>I am trying to figure out if Snell's Law for refraction can be derived from <a href="http://www.google.com/search?q=scalar+diffraction+theory" rel="nofollow">Scalar Diffraction Theory</a>.</p> <p>The setup is this: light (plane wave, with wave vector $\vec k_i = (k_x, k_y, k_z)$ ) falls on a flat interface which is taken to be x-y plane; the incident side has refractive index $n_i$ . I want to figure out the refracted ray wave vector $\vec k$, on the otherside of the interface, which has refractive index $n$. Of course, I assume that the magnitutes of wave vectors are proportional to the refractive indices of respective media; i.e. $ |k|/|k_i| = n/n_i$.</p> <p>I start with the Fresnel Diffraction Integral, with plane wave light $$U(\xi,\eta,z=0) = \exp( i \left[k_x \xi + k_y \eta + 0 \right] )$$ and got to the point of showing that $$U(x,y,z) = \exp( i \left[ k_x x + k_y y + k_z^{\prime} z \right] ),$$ where $$ k_z^{\prime} = k - \frac{k_x^2 + k_y^2}{2k}. $$</p> <p>I was happy to see that this field has the same $k_x$ and $k_y$ values, but no matter how I play with $k_z^{\prime}$, I am unable to show that it is consistent with Snell's Law.</p> <p>Any pointers? </p>
g4092
[ 0.0006902372697368264, 0.023329423740506172, -0.028309935703873634, 0.00475323386490345, -0.016287783160805702, -0.003254907438531518, 0.005710311699658632, -0.009886452928185463, 0.02155683934688568, -0.030265767127275467, 0.024912049993872643, -0.0007530928123742342, 0.0011976596433669329, 0.03767644241452217, 0.014843042008578777, 0.013684799894690514, 0.08831728994846344, -0.013061294332146645, 0.05328693985939026, 0.02706650085747242, -0.01238797977566719, 0.007402646355330944, -0.10717231035232544, -0.03582988679409027, 0.03413700684905052, -0.02509908750653267, 0.06090851128101349, -0.028839319944381714, -0.037975847721099854, -0.011962812393903732, -0.007921825163066387, -0.03578978031873703, 0.01942175254225731, -0.05708484724164009, 0.03543895110487938, -0.006483759731054306, 0.016128282994031906, -0.026928236708045006, 0.024683289229869843, -0.024215426295995712, -0.020164255052804947, -0.012845244258642197, -0.04609380289912224, 0.011469501070678234, 0.04986114799976349, -0.019615905359387398, -0.054594747722148895, 0.02510746568441391, -0.028751002624630928, 0.024854063987731934, -0.01037437655031681, 0.0632949247956276, 0.07073242962360382, -0.018978886306285858, -0.07685832679271698, 0.05100814253091812, -0.011907991021871567, 0.004442331846803427, 0.07092560827732086, 0.04494200646877289, 0.001826873398385942, 0.0035573034547269344, -0.01573481597006321, 0.031964629888534546, 0.04282744973897934, -0.0059287152253091335, -0.050517406314611435, 0.002481931820511818, 0.008804748766124249, -0.01792311668395996, -0.011162563227117062, -0.038656238466501236, 0.007707287557423115, -0.004777594469487667, -0.056088969111442566, 0.006980774458497763, -0.012936526909470558, 0.017226772382855415, -0.020196301862597466, 0.01959662139415741, 0.06588249653577805, -0.07355989515781403, -0.000060713082348229364, 0.04936548322439194, -0.02304600179195404, 0.0025277994573116302, 0.060189858078956604, -0.05038044601678848, -0.003295252798125148, -0.03655068203806877, -0.011877676472067833, 0.016818426549434662, 0.07124555855989456, 0.04422721266746521, 0.07753974944353104, -0.012864206917583942, 0.0032641710713505745, -0.021501250565052032, -0.025938449427485466, -0.03944407403469086, -0.03418124094605446, -0.012582734227180481, 0.04799826443195343, -0.010594043880701065, 0.03626362234354019, 0.04988221451640129, 0.014684797264635563, 0.03095257468521595, -0.04752737656235695, -0.0018836172530427575, 0.0012332061305642128, -0.03283135965466499, -0.008839399553835392, -0.04998112469911575, 0.0041925315745174885, -0.053534507751464844, 0.01988394930958748, -0.015171496197581291, -0.003709125565364957, 0.05849844589829445, 0.013350547291338444, -0.006590754259377718, 0.006934696342796087, 0.10895289480686188, 0.03715518116950989, 0.029501022771000862, -0.012496097944676876, -0.019712014123797417, 0.047134969383478165, 0.01783945970237255, -0.0005294432048685849, -0.04317798838019371, 0.03920280560851097, -0.020175041630864143, 0.011371863074600697, 0.01895741932094097, 0.04221298545598984, -0.024583086371421814, -0.027839872986078262, 0.021306365728378296, -0.05790894478559494, 0.037078775465488434, -0.025831274688243866, -0.004694854374974966, 0.013652486726641655, 0.01612435095012188, 0.006265887059271336, 0.018140317872166634, 0.011420429684221745, -0.06621425598859787, -0.007013976573944092, 0.02868899330496788, -0.00421252753585577, 0.02652915194630623, -0.01796107180416584, -0.032808829098939896, 0.004597926512360573, -0.06518077105283737, -0.01063895970582962, -0.034727729856967926, 0.054531559348106384, -0.00443073408678174, 0.034484557807445526, 0.06410715728998184, 0.036978304386138916, -0.00001142993824032601, -0.010867243632674217, -0.020941849797964096, -0.02099798247218132, -0.0215587355196476, -0.047529809176921844, 0.0011993899242952466, -0.025342769920825958, -0.05547796189785004, -0.021508313715457916, 0.06525233387947083, 0.023254893720149994, 0.030120933428406715, 0.04604190215468407, 0.054029274731874466, -0.04520570486783981, 0.025325678288936615, 0.0026944130659103394, -0.004527151118963957, 0.009134801104664803, -0.009284194558858871, 0.002258715685456991, -0.00929767545312643, -0.026414914056658745, -0.009410033002495766, 0.007134768180549145, -0.01631942391395569, 0.008749264292418957, 0.061483222991228104, 0.018030455335974693, 0.022364845499396324, 0.012301964685320854, -0.046697620302438736, 0.0013504537055268884, -0.03517771512269974, -0.040543749928474426, 0.06822992116212845, 0.047075964510440826, 0.06218366697430611, -0.007368679158389568, -0.0314609594643116, -0.06683970987796783, 0.023716751486063004, 0.02401631511747837, -0.013284039683640003, 0.003910853993147612, 0.0032696945127099752, 0.00045683709322474897, -0.0048347520641982555, -0.006299215834587812, 0.011977287009358406, 0.0014438510406762362, 0.013472742401063442, -0.045116301625967026, 0.03188290074467659, -0.034607816487550735, 0.007640613708645105, 0.024967869743704796, 0.07125762850046158, -0.04794301092624664, -0.01784229464828968, 0.02777298539876938, 0.07240018993616104, 0.03551564738154411, 0.03457793593406677, -0.04475771263241768, -0.05281359329819679, 0.011445756070315838, 0.021185552701354027, 0.026475822553038597, 0.023375406861305237, -0.0195536557585001, 0.03519650176167488, 0.0163154024630785, 0.0323907695710659, -0.029621481895446777, 0.0422767773270607, -0.04212651774287224, -0.00566127710044384, -0.02029581554234028, -0.002776473993435502, -0.020942939445376396, -0.008107109926640987, 0.032137151807546616, 0.057790059596300125, 0.034327201545238495, 0.06714548170566559, 0.01138291321694851, 0.03357480466365814, -0.012346486561000347, -0.0017389144049957395, 0.007959756068885326, 0.020780649036169052, -0.02290198765695095, -0.004048769362270832, 0.018942805007100105, 0.016739189624786377, -0.04562927410006523, -0.01651124097406864, -0.055801767855882645, 0.03356180340051651, 0.019148962572216988, 0.09218800812959671, 0.027843868359923363, -0.0009626731043681502, -0.048848699778318405, -0.001409046584740281, 0.0006970672984607518, -0.0017243269830942154, -0.0033925448078662157, -0.03735721483826637, 0.04938028007745743, 0.004825733136385679, 0.02236776053905487, 0.0020224573090672493, 0.04247035086154938, -0.010632043704390526, -0.015618869103491306, 0.010282863862812519, 0.029565561562776566, -0.010065081529319286, -0.013535472564399242, 0.035385869443416595, -0.002993021160364151, -0.001612936845049262, -0.04714862257242203, -0.018526552245020866, -0.015742920339107513, -0.012102406471967697, -0.040659379214048386, -0.009588113985955715, 0.044911518692970276, -0.0033534991089254618, 0.045474834740161896, 0.050708506256341934, -0.0137653648853302, -0.0246400348842144, 0.013429620303213596, 0.014809364452958107, 0.004465037491172552, 0.045416101813316345, -0.011684282682836056, -0.09926269948482513, 0.014896129257977009, -0.03810153156518936, 0.03495592251420021, 0.03663690760731697, 0.05512305721640587, -0.006862269248813391, 0.017600325867533684, 0.04984627664089203, 0.020025676116347313, 0.018903633579611778, 0.011227850802242756, 0.047144047915935516, -0.026142671704292297, -0.022417539730668068, -0.0007834843127056956, 0.029731497168540955, 0.002303759567439556, -0.0532449334859848, -0.006968485191464424, 0.057501088827848434, 0.001965440111234784, 0.01942717283964157, 0.03318135440349579, 0.0374770388007164, -0.026926133781671524, -0.038731370121240616, -0.028819389641284943, 0.01867099106311798, -0.02445307932794094, 0.03537224233150482, 0.06395650655031204, 0.037308234721422195, 0.01741890050470829, -0.024251939728856087, -0.06783101707696915, 0.013495197519659996, 0.010320045985281467, -0.009956732392311096, -0.008757859468460083, 0.0528128482401371, 0.025646645575761795, 0.0007490288699045777, 0.04205533489584923, 0.005633204709738493, 0.005074965767562389, -0.0029832215514034033, -0.04603864997625351, 0.04203197732567787, 0.0374738834798336, 0.05559094250202179, 0.011113143526017666, -0.023046141490340233, 0.07245451956987381, 0.0030709889251738787, 0.024078357964754105, -0.032860953360795975, -0.02001609280705452, 0.011120734736323357, 0.01808338426053524, 0.016203884035348892, -0.027811046689748764, -0.03204226866364479, 0.0039060909766703844, -0.06030851602554321, -0.013792291283607483, 0.003604819066822529, -0.0769057646393776, -0.04265262186527252, -0.06473734229803085, -0.009271313436329365, -0.026774032041430473, 0.025898369029164314, -0.017401481047272682, 0.05274837464094162, 0.0389285646378994, 0.020899271592497826, 0.0053743962198495865, 0.061661068350076675, -0.0022281664423644543, -0.04650268703699112, 0.057916976511478424, 0.034923236817121506, 0.020753389224410057, -0.038089487701654434, -0.014473860152065754, 0.06342876702547073, -0.0028772279620170593, -0.004055630415678024, -0.036798637360334396, -0.02082572504878044, -0.032629191875457764, 0.007953769527375698, 0.05348454415798187, 0.0014634514227509499, 0.027676302939653397, -0.020377811044454575, -0.05615231394767761, 0.05857227370142937, 0.03500029072165489, 0.012424108572304249, -0.019811103120446205, -0.004273985978215933, -0.037331342697143555, 0.01433477457612753, 0.01344840507954359, -0.05489201098680496, 0.009141659364104271, 0.0076437960378825665, 0.012090611271560192, -0.03344576060771942, -0.005296747200191021, 0.004099106416106224, 0.011034292168915272, 0.03571883589029312, -0.07900241017341614, -0.07884331792593002, 0.022120602428913116, 0.07905691862106323, 0.049441635608673096, -0.04704531282186508, -0.015030785463750362, -0.03977605700492859, -0.07665777951478958, 0.05737265199422836, -0.039875466376543045, 0.044184766709804535, -0.03253839537501335, 0.022549444809556007, -0.0365917831659317, -0.030905915424227715, 0.0037299480754882097, 0.03139743581414223, 0.023752247914671898, 0.011744013987481594, -0.02375727891921997, 0.023945435881614685, 0.05620041862130165, 0.06005574390292168, -0.07550852000713348, -0.011548920534551144, 0.03791595995426178, -0.03535991162061691, -0.03395042568445206, -0.07062374800443649, 0.016208449378609657, -0.03275269642472267, -0.023891285061836243, -0.001658346620388329, -0.06670919060707092, 0.011239718645811081, 0.010295243002474308, 0.025730907917022705, -0.0009196417522616684, 0.008678482845425606, -0.0033735507167875767, -0.05204065144062042, 0.06843628734350204, -0.021785810589790344, -0.04078536853194237, -0.03176795318722725, -0.051765795797109604, -0.012611639685928822, 0.06602128595113754, -0.015744565054774284, 0.045755401253700256, -0.06814879179000854, -0.007929502055048943, -0.017581095919013023, -0.06226307526230812, 0.040070291608572006, -0.02295353077352047, -0.004505629651248455, -0.02187921851873398, 0.02545207552611828, 0.009366292506456375, 0.02762463316321373, 0.023073622956871986, -0.03307202085852623, -0.03180858492851257, 0.02549183927476406, -0.011329677887260914, -0.028372805565595627, 0.02334696426987648, -0.11762165278196335, -0.043214160948991776, -0.011471198871731758, 0.021871402859687805, -0.014124618843197823, 0.02353072352707386, -0.04342884197831154, -0.010472176596522331, 0.01926346868276596, -0.0322880819439888, -0.04337846487760544, -0.007822060957551003, -0.03592155873775482, -0.03682120889425278, -0.000055112886911956593, 0.06393103301525116, 0.007902023382484913, 0.035164862871170044, 0.07785897701978683, 0.03451423719525337, -0.07455983012914658, 0.030041951686143875, 0.0077393571846187115, -0.03882107511162758, -0.007969247177243233, -0.024095013737678528, 0.01041222084313631, -0.027376985177397728, 0.04204189032316208, 0.04065321385860443, 0.020598551258444786, -0.055119436234235764, -0.06942117214202881, -0.040352094918489456, 0.009964949451386929, -0.01769813522696495, -0.04337408021092415, -0.05816877260804176, -0.039649415761232376, 0.020544541999697685, 0.022394362837076187, 0.04529091715812683, -0.012461936101317406, 0.04833415523171425, -0.04070112481713295, -0.007252554874867201, -0.02601403184235096, 0.008059949614107609, 0.05076061189174652, -0.09005843847990036, 0.030602049082517624, 0.01375021506100893, -0.016873182728886604, -0.004402401391416788, 0.02889457903802395, -0.036392346024513245, 0.007277012336999178, 0.05290874093770981, 0.03995209559798241, 0.05324622616171837, -0.00471250806003809, 0.007422581315040588, 0.016923867166042328, -0.01835707388818264, 0.03074302338063717, -0.012218992225825787, -0.01141783595085144, -0.08354129642248154, -0.00036004764842800796, 0.0359366200864315, 0.0353194996714592, -0.05458619445562363, 0.03169001638889313, -0.06194642558693886, -0.05416382476687431, 0.0014462152030318975, 0.0223016869276762, -0.011063763871788979, -0.04036487266421318, -0.06827947497367859, 0.006022187415510416, -0.03520141914486885, -0.0004820878093596548, 0.03941502049565315, 0.04891255870461464, 0.002134195528924465, 0.0022387767676264048, 0.021786674857139587, 0.01788971573114395, 0.018075790256261826, 0.03956345468759537, -0.04012314975261688, -0.041761185973882675, -0.06720425933599472, 0.025712905451655388, -0.045154593884944916, -0.04332251474261284, -0.00704024825245142, -0.05932260677218437, 0.02446603775024414, -0.036682672798633575, -0.05213792622089386, -0.0014452749164775014, -0.03501034900546074, -0.0929589718580246, 0.04683656245470047, 0.08979799598455429, -0.029932744801044464, 0.09958703815937042, 0.0983390063047409, -0.016179583966732025, 0.012686977162957191, -0.052379053086042404, 0.05132954567670822, -0.021740678697824478, -0.060135647654533386, -0.014504886232316494, 0.08234085887670517, 0.03088594786822796, 0.04069432243704796, 0.031085168942809105, -0.06373865157365799, 0.008146975189447403, 0.018622536212205887, -0.09470044076442719, -0.005109037738293409, 0.04184127599000931, -0.06629184633493423, -0.048482589423656464, 0.032132357358932495, 0.019627738744020462, -0.03720416873693466, 0.008421915583312511, 0.03340259566903114, -0.01461033895611763, -0.04237143695354462, -0.016973961144685745, 0.0624515637755394, 0.05520211160182953, 0.05538785457611084, -0.019227737560868263, 0.05153331905603409, 0.013855472207069397, 0.03471715375781059, 0.0009506129426881671, -0.038315363228321075, 0.005703572649508715, 0.0022550332359969616, 0.06638508290052414, -0.00668088486418128, 0.06257859617471695, 0.002981780795380473, 0.022520001977682114, -0.027527419850230217, -0.03172025457024574, 0.008618548512458801, -0.024551570415496826, -0.06200408190488815, -0.036170594394207, 0.011490686796605587, -0.01992097869515419, -0.003925722558051348, 0.01261598989367485, -0.01592249423265457, 0.03681132197380066, -0.011764791794121265, -0.027063051238656044, 0.012472951784729958, -0.034267354756593704, 0.001472148927859962, -0.09397628903388977, -0.0018308445578441024, 0.0015120686730369925, -0.07062198966741562, 0.03584076091647148, -0.010829415172338486, -0.04134122654795647, 0.047214943915605545, -0.00947360135614872, 0.013414516113698483, -0.05471537262201309, -0.015031871385872364, 0.000531711324583739, -0.018556859344244003, 0.019653385505080223, -0.022219203412532806, 0.02555972710251808, -0.0028310269117355347, 0.052418094128370285, 0.022860923781991005, 0.06724483519792557, -0.012249253690242767, -0.0005192725802771747, 0.01825673319399357, 0.019715240225195885, 0.026450326666235924, 0.004695733077824116, 0.008275668136775494, -0.014811677858233452, -0.020093029364943504, -0.030546246096491814, 0.001578588504344225, 0.022705378010869026, 0.029337063431739807, -0.021070124581456184, 0.060293231159448624, 0.022516785189509392, 0.03720809519290924, 0.048117369413375854, -0.0236789733171463, -0.021323347464203835, -0.051670610904693604, 0.024035217240452766, 0.011129330843687057, -0.03615076467394829, -0.04530550166964531, -0.020897990092635155, -0.017843129113316536, -0.01484307087957859, 0.028628991916775703, -0.013609725050628185, -0.020757615566253662, -0.018753042444586754, 0.015173216350376606, 0.04163823649287224, -0.008957798592746258, -0.01521394494920969, 0.004719350952655077, 0.014641336165368557, -0.03777039423584938, -0.06380271166563034, -0.01947159506380558, -0.05773109942674637, 0.014395670033991337, -0.002467160811647773, -0.013377517461776733, -0.010010196827352047, -0.03256875276565552, -0.016329145058989525, -0.011174858547747135, 0.026303716003894806, -0.06430221349000931, 0.0063346875831484795, 0.003029220039024949, 0.019066907465457916, 0.005967828445136547, -0.03946015611290932, 0.03108575940132141, 0.006224018521606922, 0.03929852694272995, -0.059684623032808304, 0.014155854471027851, -0.09815484285354614, -0.06140892952680588, -0.010991601273417473, 0.07123372703790665, -0.03061414137482643, -0.011678319424390793, -0.021947644650936127, -0.010658955201506615, 0.0008799812640063465, -0.021823734045028687, 0.04638902097940445, 0.02698315680027008, -0.07673075795173645, 0.029009705409407616, -0.02363312803208828, 0.05050358921289444, -0.019924230873584747, 0.025407182052731514, -0.056217942386865616, 0.005099737085402012, -0.0052921706810593605, 0.007878579199314117, -0.0008397985366173089, -0.004779305309057236, 0.010387208312749863 ]
<p>There are a number of factors that I can think of:</p> <ul> <li><strong>The larger mass of the hammer</strong> would cause more force to be applied due to F=MA.</li> <li><strong>The larger surface area of the pillow</strong> would spread out the force of the impact, applying less pressure at any given point.</li> <li><strong>Air resistance due to the pillow's larger surface area</strong> seems like it would also reduce the acceleration of the pillow, which would affect the force due to F=MA. Or perhaps it would just reduce the speed the pillow could be swung at, which would lower the pillow's momentum (does that matter?)</li> <li><strong>The pillow is more compressible</strong>, which I believe should absorb some of the energy of the impact.</li> </ul> <p>So the question is two-fold:</p> <ol> <li>Are there other factors which I've missed?</li> <li>What is the relative importance of the factors in determining the overall harm that a pillow versus a hammer would cause?</li> </ol> <p>Note: Don't hit people with hammers. Question for fun only ;)</p>
g4093
[ 0.08124649524688721, 0.038731250911951065, 0.017776845023036003, 0.015324941836297512, 0.02433958649635315, 0.040977586060762405, 0.005154534708708525, 0.044583484530448914, -0.062224820256233215, -0.008841089904308319, 0.025880148634314537, -0.05160504952073097, 0.028400789946317673, -0.0037648496218025684, 0.028808142989873886, -0.019892534241080284, 0.02626650221645832, -0.055596768856048584, -0.03413509204983711, 0.035543959587812424, -0.012692390941083431, 0.002106220694258809, -0.05485154688358307, -0.043189045041799545, -0.08529060333967209, -0.010793594643473625, -0.008170857094228268, -0.01372432243078947, -0.07180462777614594, -0.029457299038767815, 0.008679160848259926, 0.00019209831953048706, -0.02679695188999176, -0.036723796278238297, -0.0612785778939724, -0.025748731568455696, -0.03561484441161156, 0.03156666457653046, 0.004125016741454601, 0.02648765780031681, -0.03339819237589836, -0.008218985050916672, 0.029701605439186096, 0.02381463162600994, -0.04935627058148384, -0.032620158046483994, -0.010378526523709297, -0.015408407896757126, 0.0002397172647761181, -0.048754554241895676, -0.03047417849302292, -0.06244930252432823, -0.009941350668668747, -0.008564851246774197, 0.05064799264073372, -0.0030096641276031733, 0.044940900057554245, -0.015321969985961914, -0.04465106502175331, 0.03727994114160538, -0.041829630732536316, 0.00654063792899251, -0.05540123209357262, -0.02229687012732029, -0.01784060150384903, -0.02807556837797165, 0.00042904980364255607, -0.0029867361299693584, 0.05845271795988083, -0.0006811428465880454, 0.030407125130295753, 0.02580447867512703, -0.00766218826174736, -0.05901864171028137, -0.024469343945384026, 0.031672827899456024, 0.019255124032497406, 0.002418856369331479, -0.004187008831650019, -0.002688394393771887, 0.01317122858017683, 0.00637639919295907, 0.1000998392701149, -0.044621024280786514, -0.0018273289315402508, 0.002749157603830099, -0.07943934202194214, 0.008125010877847672, -0.00012246961705386639, -0.00703791156411171, 0.024875685572624207, -0.05640879645943642, 0.006818118505179882, -0.017888668924570084, -0.0364348404109478, -0.0017250620294362307, 0.04165366664528847, 0.03408544883131981, -0.0066141714341938496, 0.04927201196551323, 0.014835875481367111, -0.020845217630267143, -0.02125692367553711, 0.03790706768631935, 0.029376162216067314, -0.033410053700208664, 0.05964195728302002, 0.03147485852241516, -0.03939375653862953, 0.03584260120987892, 0.02045506238937378, -0.01617242582142353, 0.01384095847606659, -0.0634738877415657, 0.01331561803817749, -0.044749099761247635, 0.05838587507605553, -0.02400350570678711, 0.009780953638255596, 0.06602615863084793, 0.03326699882745743, -0.0000900932282092981, -0.050276897847652435, -0.02160211279988289, -0.014802836813032627, -0.034300707280635834, -0.010595508851110935, -0.009668504819273949, -0.004524562507867813, -0.027203595265746117, 0.03301728889346123, -0.01055872067809105, -0.006844672374427319, 0.004030310548841953, 0.015901988372206688, 0.04495779797434807, -0.02798253670334816, 0.08406544476747513, -0.001667217817157507, 0.02373681031167507, 0.007815862074494362, 0.010322029702365398, -0.008062910288572311, -0.02669098973274231, -0.07498819380998611, 0.09261034429073334, 0.007649820763617754, 0.04201831296086311, -0.015979839488863945, 0.06400584429502487, 0.02509695664048195, 0.030948763713240623, -0.004742137622088194, -0.0073482743464410305, 0.03465299680829048, -0.000314955017529428, -0.011298357509076595, 0.0585327073931694, 0.04234286770224571, 0.030147189274430275, 0.04395628720521927, 0.045582618564367294, 0.08326657116413116, -0.012188115157186985, -0.015351328998804092, 0.07035868614912033, -0.004280413035303354, -0.023975102230906487, -0.06435892730951309, 0.024362707510590553, -0.028773918747901917, 0.009594298899173737, 0.014573195017874241, 0.06263916194438934, 0.05287943780422211, 0.00829862430691719, 0.07670173048973083, -0.04669356346130371, 0.00820189993828535, -0.01137341558933258, 0.024879546836018562, -0.027322037145495415, -0.025098299607634544, -0.07482778280973434, 0.004238223657011986, 0.0048737009055912495, 0.06061475723981857, 0.03635597974061966, -0.0725797787308693, 0.04412417486310005, -0.008548768237233162, -0.023081142455339432, 0.04695809260010719, -0.007862895727157593, -0.07159551978111267, -0.013003665022552013, 0.012637129984796047, 0.05161285772919655, -0.054123274981975555, 0.01957804523408413, -0.05028291791677475, 0.04915393888950348, 0.04786074161529541, -0.008669326081871986, -0.05107401683926582, 0.06700918823480606, -0.019691981375217438, 0.013461515307426453, -0.014420661143958569, -0.06835485249757767, 0.002531993668526411, 0.036787088960409164, 0.057029981166124344, 0.028164735063910484, 0.03268091753125191, 0.02361227385699749, -0.01221601851284504, 0.052009548991918564, -0.008683724328875542, 0.008930694311857224, 0.038809988647699356, 0.03482440486550331, 0.014072607271373272, -0.018241608515381813, -0.019252875819802284, -0.006095744203776121, 0.0060269772075116634, -0.047750018537044525, -0.015302613377571106, 0.03497355803847313, -0.03625498339533806, -0.005020878277719021, 0.026364685967564583, 0.0015419777482748032, 0.015611470676958561, 0.014839212410151958, -0.005944134201854467, -0.014640825800597668, 0.0209836196154356, -0.020286522805690765, 0.028183143585920334, -0.044561717659235, -0.020852984860539436, -0.02224225550889969, 0.01906457543373108, -0.05442219227552414, -0.04427238926291466, -0.05229025334119797, -0.00015010981587693095, 0.04023946821689606, -0.03465680405497551, 0.05273910611867905, -0.03371810540556908, 0.00382953486405313, -0.005630004685372114, -0.01788995787501335, -0.04364786669611931, -0.018843578174710274, -0.03732801601290703, 0.029271665960550308, -0.0007183228153735399, -0.040294501930475235, -0.01981220208108425, 0.018582627177238464, -0.02891390398144722, 0.033213015645742416, -0.002829248085618019, 0.007180380169302225, 0.051916953176259995, -0.004536651074886322, -0.000518598360940814, 0.022777756676077843, 0.01460936851799488, 0.040965937077999115, 0.055709704756736755, 0.006266844924539328, 0.024139778688549995, -0.007502078078687191, -0.0480552576482296, -0.03556957468390465, 0.0204384233802557, 0.015943747013807297, -0.06637328863143921, -0.0066171749494969845, 0.07749783247709274, -0.035734619945287704, -0.017643239349126816, 0.01516740396618843, -0.022497830912470818, -0.0864918977022171, -0.0576133169233799, 0.0170306209474802, 0.004568537697196007, -0.00029987184097990394, 0.03913891315460205, 0.07414960861206055, 0.017495429143309593, -0.0016949326964095235, -0.028163839131593704, -0.002097829943522811, 0.01634339429438114, 0.0005283012869767845, -0.014715325087308884, -0.015357555821537971, -0.018699387088418007, 0.05438779294490814, -0.006918699946254492, -0.04904856160283089, -0.03377874195575714, 0.005123503040522337, -0.07688625156879425, 0.07367199659347534, -0.014662706293165684, 0.04552297294139862, -0.09728741645812988, -0.0823255181312561, 0.04969503730535507, 0.0041840774938464165, -0.03749972581863403, 0.0378296785056591, 0.03965340554714203, -0.09681544452905655, 0.0035987012088298798, -0.009428726509213448, -0.0338258296251297, 0.004946642555296421, -0.012729044072329998, 0.0298555176705122, 0.038284264504909515, -0.03286992013454437, -0.003974928054958582, 0.019036997109651566, -0.04444926232099533, -0.03373613581061363, -0.049114786088466644, 0.01320187933743, 0.03585172817111015, 0.013579117134213448, -0.01714872568845749, 0.02691524289548397, 0.06506604701280594, -0.02751854807138443, 0.02436014637351036, -0.030707184225320816, 0.005130245815962553, 0.05050656571984291, 0.016818242147564888, -0.006494061090052128, -0.012725591659545898, -0.03417610377073288, 0.0974956527352333, -0.036867592483758926, -0.026050353422760963, 0.020152829587459564, 0.060540370643138885, -0.034907735884189606, -0.01031707227230072, 0.043151307851076126, -0.008266746066510677, 0.009357865899801254, -0.0014212917303666472, 0.011474615894258022, -0.034799057990312576, 0.005561444908380508, -0.017565209418535233, -0.0046141971834003925, -0.0767516940832138, 0.019544772803783417, -0.06922151148319244, 0.007493271958082914, 0.06554505228996277, -0.045099880546331406, -0.002037694677710533, -0.007317214738577604, 0.02402266301214695, 0.006279271095991135, 0.05601551756262779, 0.04004516080021858, 0.031990885734558105, 0.0029498243238776922, 0.06304607540369034, 0.027362337335944176, -0.027505969628691673, 0.014573409222066402, -0.012065944261848927, -0.03736598789691925, -0.009448838420212269, 0.02868731878697872, 0.03435429185628891, 0.005588344763964415, -0.016169430688023567, -0.030828332528471947, -0.013775666244328022, 0.0895630419254303, 0.021957488730549812, 0.008930190466344357, -0.007258994970470667, -0.01371164433658123, -0.02441118098795414, 0.03683198243379593, 0.021702533587813377, 0.02412927895784378, 0.026100222021341324, 0.02206728607416153, -0.0010095518082380295, 0.02539941668510437, 0.004415677860379219, 0.06824679672718048, 0.020424263551831245, 0.023664720356464386, 0.010652437806129456, -0.07183191925287247, -0.06398184597492218, -0.015552869997918606, 0.02484128251671791, -0.009431722573935986, -0.0055261398665606976, 0.11371327191591263, -0.0014896882930770516, 0.010618588887155056, -0.036377403885126114, 0.013224230147898197, -0.010070513002574444, -0.006438957992941141, -0.03919792175292969, 0.027881836518645287, 0.06935480237007141, -0.015140242874622345, 0.014173390343785286, -0.018163606524467468, 0.06705605983734131, 0.03686652332544327, -0.0293032918125391, -0.005930512212216854, 0.059860363602638245, 0.060308635234832764, 0.048384130001068115, -0.023305468261241913, 0.03474222496151924, 0.0004467955732252449, -0.004191094543784857, 0.026699407026171684, -0.009880892001092434, 0.03193994238972664, -0.022156333550810814, 0.005084799602627754, -0.02540610544383526, -0.015223593451082706, -0.012521406635642052, 0.0027729691937565804, -0.056874360889196396, -0.06611277908086777, 0.032414231449365616, -0.05719694122672081, -0.03945241495966911, 0.05123775824904442, -0.004869438707828522, 0.03585343062877655, 0.043362751603126526, 0.07647877931594849, 0.025348007678985596, -0.005759301129728556, 0.004230210091918707, -0.023464404046535492, -0.03454054147005081, 0.013181078247725964, -0.05267087742686272, 0.013597520999610424, -0.05877267196774483, -0.010417372919619083, -0.041317686438560486, -0.0009903841419145465, -0.0029769388493150473, 0.07372328639030457, 0.02015359327197075, 0.06214252859354019, -0.009496130980551243, -0.06183771789073944, -0.010591655969619751, -0.025372151285409927, -0.0011511314660310745, -0.039941202849149704, 0.04581012949347496, -0.04673299193382263, -0.0018313704058527946, -0.04205736890435219, -0.032070282846689224, 0.01694761961698532, -0.013280916959047318, 0.014137090183794498, 0.014880454167723656, 0.07619476318359375, -0.05355657637119293, -0.008130443282425404, 0.010067183524370193, 0.03723036125302315, 0.0001994649792322889, -0.02138534002006054, -0.004472448490560055, -0.024722356349229813, -0.02831319347023964, 0.029474234208464622, 0.03184729814529419, -0.0016527539119124413, -0.04539388045668602, -0.02180173434317112, 0.06286010146141052, -0.019518570974469185, 0.04750996455550194, 0.07467027008533478, -0.02932661399245262, -0.0005210614181123674, -0.025445371866226196, -0.05059238150715828, 0.0050642299465835094, 0.01975373923778534, 0.0020125643350183964, 0.04182082787156105, 0.007700110320001841, 0.015718737617135048, 0.005667021963745356, -0.01853282004594803, 0.06988131254911423, 0.00007658742106286809, -0.011704220436513424, -0.03272086754441261, -0.011193083599209785, -0.06318285316228867, -0.026187006384134293, -0.02622457966208458, 0.022574342787265778, -0.04499545320868492, 0.0016919320914894342, -0.006657925434410572, 0.002695373957976699, -0.013566488400101662, 0.06240590289235115, -0.006302578374743462, 0.015250585973262787, -0.016561729833483696, -0.060898493975400925, -0.017402827739715576, 0.03931228816509247, 0.06058770790696144, -0.010787957347929478, -0.024403981864452362, -0.009984628297388554, -0.007029509637504816, -0.011982394382357597, 0.025957373902201653, -0.00057526322780177, 0.0366545207798481, 0.0036940232384949923, 0.05177723243832588, 0.0035190305206924677, 0.015849919989705086, 0.06960835307836533, -0.02014179900288582, 0.03907649591565132, -0.0669243335723877, 0.002404204336926341, 0.03012819215655327, -0.00953867007046938, 0.00040736657683737576, 0.07917062938213348, -0.0054296753369271755, -0.04756290093064308, -0.0970151424407959, 0.049241434782743454, 0.0029213204979896545, 0.00036716595059260726, -0.020656581968069077, 0.02876107394695282, -0.006455948110669851, 0.00800409447401762, 0.030175451189279556, -0.01875515654683113, 0.0030743833631277084, -0.03166510537266731, 0.004458234179764986, 0.04948744550347328, -0.0062550432048738, 0.018052656203508377, -0.0490921251475811, 0.04332543909549713, -0.018974831327795982, -0.060533057898283005, -0.003837497439235449, 0.05750587210059166, -0.019641641527414322, -0.02892288938164711, -0.03149660304188728, 0.02711164578795433, -0.020298615097999573, -0.06533021479845047, -0.024133358150720596, 0.022242292761802673, 0.0010719209676608443, -0.03711767867207527, 0.011362375691533089, 0.05380216985940933, 0.04821218177676201, 0.08640745282173157, -0.010289021767675877, -0.031172681599855423, 0.02247883938252926, 0.03614678978919983, -0.04635363072156906, 0.053136128932237625, -0.040769994258880615, -0.07147940248250961, 0.06457625329494476, 0.01779017224907875, -0.012721016071736813, 0.04371822997927666, -0.013290547765791416, -0.04548853263258934, -0.07847319543361664, -0.026852035894989967, -0.027632467448711395, 0.010297116823494434, -0.03967323526740074, 0.03571689501404762, -0.06036151945590973, -0.01499217376112938, -0.01902720518410206, -0.0934436172246933, 0.08012234419584274, -0.037475500255823135, 0.013843003660440445, 0.010669408366084099, 0.001588690560311079, 0.008840176276862621, 0.05254824832081795, -0.020890915766358376, 0.039516568183898926, 0.0045341313816607, 0.012363015674054623, -0.02991378679871559, -0.0009960002498701215, 0.005945097655057907, 0.03570656478404999, -0.013198381289839745, 0.07260525226593018, -0.04625391587615013, -0.027410360053181648, -0.009560680016875267, -0.034897319972515106, -0.04848860576748848, 0.00798510666936636, -0.07956776022911072, -0.01603689417243004, -0.08929520100355148, -0.023496700450778008, -0.0033273843582719564, 0.026930004358291626, -0.0074840690940618515, -0.007439053617417812, 0.08320672065019608, 0.022935155779123306, -0.014343027025461197, -0.026566017419099808, 0.012433112598955631, 0.001077538006938994, -0.043348316103219986, 0.03260722756385803, -0.012593859806656837, -0.04497762396931648, 0.023734355345368385, 0.016109712421894073, 0.010706155560910702, -0.024340009316802025, -0.020087601616978645, 0.016617055982351303, 0.0319538339972496, 0.001166971051134169, 0.0046593379229307175, -0.07278438657522202, -0.017639711499214172, 0.010100043378770351, -0.0032326304353773594, 0.0516178123652935, 0.012507558800280094, -0.023598147556185722, -0.019711488857865334, 0.012995295226573944, -0.015742428600788116, 0.08214404433965683, -0.02179477922618389, -0.046903058886528015, -0.04066164419054985, -0.02248959429562092, 0.018852073699235916, 0.052530042827129364, -0.03362872451543808, -0.02428431063890457, 0.017665572464466095, 0.04888118430972099, -0.014667497016489506, -0.02200806885957718, -0.022388653829693794, -0.02537272311747074, 0.05224965885281563, -0.04818619042634964, -0.00399802578613162, 0.05867176502943039, -0.06938138604164124, 0.03254776448011398, -0.038938239216804504, -0.03162788599729538, 0.03234641253948212, 0.0033602691255509853, 0.008738686330616474, -0.037902314215898514, 0.04015533626079559, 0.026551514863967896, 0.012426313012838364, -0.012805439531803131, -0.025453276932239532, -0.04907327517867088, -0.013673546724021435, 0.014061045832931995, 0.03339722380042076, -0.046991247683763504, 0.010318724438548088, -0.05034511908888817, 0.026419837027788162, -0.012709463946521282, -0.00018373334023635834, 0.04136791452765465, 0.0036144268233329058, -0.03723106160759926, 0.01941387914121151, 0.017757950350642204, -0.016634199768304825, -0.021751917898654938, 0.060291387140750885, 0.017301173880696297, 0.006778901908546686, -0.013882076367735863, -0.022625168785452843, 0.02092147246003151, -0.034323133528232574, -0.034308064728975296, -0.03339226543903351, -0.009051329456269741, -0.035778164863586426, 0.02366446517407894, 0.03688344731926918, 0.008758891373872757, 0.03954257816076279, 0.006946449633687735, -0.06107495725154877, 0.02523941546678543, -0.005717925261706114, 0.0113992253318429, -0.037835802882909775, 0.0077433097176253796, 0.031144388020038605, -0.041070543229579926, 0.01628599315881729, 0.016917968168854713, -0.026092061772942543, -0.03511897101998329, 0.046781137585639954, 0.0010626259027048945, -0.020060338079929352, 0.005406287033110857 ]