question
stringlengths
37
38.8k
group_id
stringlengths
2
6
sentence_embeddings
listlengths
768
768
<p>I know that the maximum shear stress </p> <p>$$\tau = \frac{T}{J}\rho$$</p> <p>where $\rho$ is the radial distance from the center of the cross section. I have also determined the torsional constant $J$, which is equal to $\frac{\pi}{2}(R_o^4-R_i^4)$ for this particular cross section. The following boundary condition applies: </p> <p>$$\nabla^2\phi = F$$ </p> <p>I know that $\phi$ would be zero for a solid cross section, but I do not understand how I should calculate it with torsion equivalence. Any help is appreciated.</p>
g1590
[ 0.06328455358743668, -0.027857597917318344, -0.008396639488637447, -0.005252236966043711, 0.05688504874706268, -0.009068899787962437, -0.002359658246859908, 0.01630769483745098, -0.04272836074233055, 0.06180634722113609, -0.0057848612777888775, 0.019267026335000992, -0.025276362895965576, -0.035898756235837936, 0.04171953722834587, -0.014030549675226212, -0.0006989585235714912, -0.003721625776961446, 0.021505260840058327, 0.022989772260189056, 0.005442178342491388, -0.013291499577462673, -0.0015112224500626326, -0.04478572681546211, 0.0843057855963707, 0.009107385762035847, -0.08261679112911224, 0.04754023253917694, -0.04480694979429245, 0.0591496042907238, 0.020335858687758446, -0.027609607204794884, 0.020758336409926414, -0.05630442500114441, -0.007774095982313156, 0.017700938507914543, -0.012704188004136086, 0.06423334777355194, 0.044277649372816086, -0.0438024140894413, -0.020663339644670486, -0.07010357826948166, -0.01813783310353756, 0.00432695122435689, -0.006844482850283384, -0.024179881438612938, -0.024047046899795532, 0.014256330206990242, -0.009423110634088516, 0.03744994476437569, -0.04135764017701149, 0.026253867894411087, 0.0832505151629448, -0.027803970500826836, -0.0336248055100441, 0.008171871304512024, 0.0399399995803833, -0.033107832074165344, -0.013580413535237312, 0.08893392980098724, 0.0024509853683412075, 0.03720294311642647, -0.03285533934831619, 0.00296390731818974, -0.012216542847454548, 0.05134831741452217, 0.008673233911395073, 0.010285383090376854, -0.004373769275844097, -0.007705661002546549, 0.021588629111647606, -0.03145632892847061, 0.028588825836777687, -0.0259702168405056, -0.049575310200452805, -0.05571436136960983, 0.036800067871809006, 0.006426393054425716, 0.0398450531065464, -0.035424552857875824, 0.024385973811149597, -0.04291687533259392, -0.031912244856357574, -0.04893818125128746, -0.04416881874203682, 0.03155755624175072, 0.06091896817088127, 0.00746289873495698, -0.020950568839907646, 0.03336706757545471, 0.02511642314493656, -0.03439509496092796, -0.03754814714193344, -0.032565027475357056, 0.09559755772352219, 0.004139673430472612, -0.02636479027569294, 0.03910192847251892, -0.0807441920042038, -0.0335015133023262, 0.024933580309152603, -0.0005682226619683206, 0.016240008175373077, 0.0056121996603906155, 0.0012340479297563434, -0.10295269638299942, 0.09851924329996109, -0.024634594097733498, -0.0295576099306345, -0.033669814467430115, -0.0031048208475112915, 0.04665476456284523, -0.024700360372662544, -0.07946612685918808, -0.004434487782418728, -0.01109939906746149, 0.016384154558181763, -0.0059690880589187145, -0.02418377622961998, 0.007895597256720066, 0.0038517811335623264, -0.02510322444140911, 0.0023634752724319696, 0.12120569497346878, 0.012692995369434357, -0.01751094125211239, -0.012230259366333485, -0.026763102039694786, 0.0659283995628357, -0.03302547708153725, -0.015549089759588242, -0.014164278283715248, 0.03456476703286171, -0.03575804829597473, 0.02519555762410164, 0.07040691375732422, -0.08203286677598953, -0.014640756882727146, -0.01597883366048336, 0.011360647156834602, 0.0029076726641505957, -0.03091912902891636, -0.018481116741895676, 0.055124882608652115, -0.01999460905790329, -0.01950402371585369, -0.009229058399796486, -0.02028396725654602, 0.01536928117275238, 0.012878484092652798, 0.05075613409280777, 0.04212174192070961, 0.0016428220551460981, 0.001586796366609633, -0.005387390963733196, -0.0019782623276114464, 0.023720650002360344, 0.002185203367844224, 0.024802647531032562, 0.017377283424139023, 0.013388373889029026, -0.002495233900845051, 0.030813397839665413, -0.004695029929280281, -0.06057592108845711, -0.014217867515981197, -0.06398644298315048, 0.0210561640560627, 0.050864141434431076, -0.023234834894537926, -0.03827768936753273, 0.006680534686893225, 0.020190712064504623, -0.0353812649846077, -0.014574405737221241, 0.004237963352352381, -0.03916318342089653, 0.03408254683017731, 0.08212141692638397, 0.0372774712741375, -0.026150982826948166, -0.0784689262509346, 0.0669366642832756, 0.032799504697322845, -0.09230204671621323, -0.0027571183163672686, 0.04128171131014824, -0.002240201458334923, -0.038853634148836136, 0.044818002730607986, 0.0002424168778816238, 0.016793590039014816, 0.0013721173163503408, -0.006941210012882948, -0.03735729679465294, 0.023208729922771454, 0.004740255884826183, -0.013260540552437305, 0.018382994458079338, 0.024626215919852257, 0.04138016328215599, 0.033471524715423584, 0.01952570118010044, 0.02736656367778778, -0.010353831574320793, 0.04615824669599533, 0.018412766978144646, -0.0383944995701313, 0.0072288052178919315, 0.06545999646186829, -0.00011248635564697906, 0.0004893460427410901, 0.019871067255735397, 0.04704688861966133, -0.0030233014840632677, 0.010637703351676464, 0.04328281804919243, 0.015114444307982922, -0.011086725629866123, 0.012385586276650429, -0.027805417776107788, 0.010736414231359959, 0.0682462826371193, 0.0008271425613202155, 0.017438210546970367, 0.015780193731188774, 0.02387283742427826, -0.013561650179326534, 0.015927918255329132, -0.058670297265052795, -0.03616281598806381, 0.06723877787590027, -0.0096171535551548, -0.013716916553676128, -0.02047889679670334, -0.015777528285980225, -0.03128301352262497, 0.058667682111263275, -0.028887595981359482, -0.03832697123289108, 0.023061469197273254, -0.041083309799432755, -0.040981072932481766, -0.007614023983478546, 0.03154468908905983, -0.03584735095500946, 0.013279440812766552, -0.01767968200147152, 0.002827441319823265, -0.02004237286746502, 0.060477521270513535, 0.006714089307934046, -0.010064133442938328, 0.019505666568875313, -0.00500350771471858, -0.046140458434820175, 0.004739938769489527, 0.0653223767876625, -0.03696178272366524, -0.012630365788936615, -0.037340618669986725, 0.004966044798493385, 0.033902935683727264, 0.017744414508342743, -0.11961923539638519, 0.017358096316456795, -0.005968797951936722, -0.015231769531965256, 0.042289044708013535, 0.014813311398029327, -0.06166236102581024, 0.11511634290218353, 0.005424295086413622, 0.09202934801578522, 0.002141636097803712, -0.07800907641649246, -0.01273804809898138, -0.007496458012610674, -0.09271872788667679, 0.0629083514213562, 0.017291171476244926, -0.009950862266123295, 0.016712652519345284, 0.058490023016929626, -0.05273362621665001, -0.013171232305467129, -0.038537606596946716, 0.010701790452003479, 0.023130496963858604, 0.012892554514110088, -0.01609182544052601, 0.03562575578689575, -0.018754485994577408, -0.013980934396386147, 0.019442450255155563, 0.03105013258755207, 0.030281228944659233, -0.0010958791244775057, 0.022175131365656853, -0.012520221062004566, -0.005880975630134344, -0.018594935536384583, -0.03338644281029701, 0.009952515363693237, -0.046689216047525406, 0.029326222836971283, -0.0011149271158501506, -0.05653133988380432, -0.023328520357608795, 0.019603539258241653, -0.052242401987314224, -0.024543140083551407, 0.03693905472755432, 0.003401740686967969, -0.0023956703953444958, -0.01665979065001011, 0.004856749437749386, -0.01664310321211815, -0.0038961677346378565, 0.05998678505420685, -0.019945433363318443, -0.025979576632380486, 0.02137896791100502, 0.018754061311483383, -0.026716280728578568, 0.05827465280890465, -0.09549228847026825, 0.03378259763121605, -0.02507895790040493, -0.0007161190151236951, -0.0024908604100346565, 0.029161419719457626, 0.005945750977844, 0.008001944981515408, -0.020201105624437332, -0.03320992738008499, -0.026606300845742226, 0.06168216094374657, 0.015650341287255287, 0.011032655835151672, -0.010811902582645416, -0.0027508854400366545, -0.006105554290115833, 0.003929746802896261, -0.0434122197329998, 0.009221979416906834, -0.025390155613422394, 0.024870172142982483, 0.025010045617818832, -0.017539264634251595, -0.023981893435120583, 0.030048919841647148, -0.05474698543548584, -0.03257568180561066, 0.04682965949177742, -0.0023944333661347628, 0.0073183272033929825, -0.0008397912024520338, -0.04085719585418701, -0.008963835425674915, 0.07744922488927841, -0.02705696038901806, 0.01930783875286579, -0.0038791054394096136, -0.006375536788254976, -0.01340561918914318, 0.038251154124736786, -0.004335993900895119, 0.023829607293009758, -0.006469640415161848, -0.055652305483818054, -0.045081790536642075, 0.061755746603012085, 0.026927264407277107, 0.002654045121744275, -0.05004086345434189, -0.023604707792401314, 0.020068278536200523, 0.02128196507692337, 0.07376124709844589, 0.04834121838212013, -0.050669919699430466, -0.021400319412350655, -0.010679332539439201, -0.011449035257101059, 0.018723290413618088, 0.0032132999040186405, -0.00589523371309042, 0.03298540040850639, -0.009197961539030075, 0.023003563284873962, -0.06810826063156128, 0.002352224662899971, 0.028127383440732956, 0.026968546211719513, -0.05505573749542236, 0.008731563575565815, 0.04307423532009125, -0.04925075173377991, -0.01001741737127304, 0.06926164031028748, 0.01377703808248043, 0.006861837115138769, 0.031663667410612106, -0.034660566598176956, 0.014762834645807743, 0.014595115557312965, 0.011269757524132729, -0.01837030053138733, 0.006580120883882046, -0.011900567449629307, -0.049759265035390854, 0.04181189090013504, -0.05564328655600548, 0.05909505486488342, -0.031030703336000443, -0.039023566991090775, -0.0024576380383223295, -0.009119308553636074, 0.007465057540684938, -0.0048432061448693275, -0.024902639910578728, 0.05286354199051857, 0.004002198576927185, 0.08362686634063721, -0.01579245738685131, -0.004066341556608677, 0.02201911062002182, -0.010859792120754719, -0.02194051630795002, -0.02845483273267746, -0.010809964500367641, -0.029971661046147346, 0.015054415911436081, -0.0017758322646841407, 0.06523609906435013, -0.06268832832574844, -0.010123776271939278, -0.04312749207019806, -0.012436449527740479, -0.06132899969816208, 0.0380457304418087, 0.05004039779305458, 0.04606069624423981, 0.024965131655335426, 0.05087228864431381, 0.005988541524857283, -0.03638642653822899, -0.019982079043984413, -0.018599409610033035, -0.08473166823387146, -0.06410335749387741, 0.04066559299826622, 0.009004575200378895, -0.0033306542318314314, -0.048370540142059326, -0.044217679649591446, -0.06800960749387741, -0.028170226141810417, 0.015554798766970634, -0.05695861950516701, -0.030481675639748573, 0.053915683180093765, 0.005304350052028894, 0.026802724227309227, 0.01028414350003004, -0.04365023225545883, 0.011586119420826435, -0.07616356015205383, -0.021890711039304733, 0.013168036937713623, 0.02030389942228794, 0.022038452327251434, 0.009219578467309475, -0.026784224435687065, 0.07361428439617157, -0.05352471023797989, -0.0184403657913208, -0.012139398604631424, -0.022698869928717613, 0.0034161212388426065, 0.006006602197885513, -0.003659892827272415, 0.0019209298770874739, 0.04260573163628578, 0.01959139108657837, 0.0017765574157238007, -0.016855357214808464, 0.02183595485985279, -0.011651374399662018, 0.02828391268849373, 0.022547487169504166, -0.06090620160102844, 0.0007216657395474613, 0.029030200093984604, 0.005886696744710207, 0.05752198398113251, -0.016688767820596695, -0.034443121403455734, 0.0076949261128902435, -0.012865101918578148, 0.007113616447895765, 0.009897062554955482, 0.06434856355190277, -0.02215174213051796, 0.05947704240679741, 0.051700010895729065, -0.031915824860334396, -0.0022503724321722984, 0.07636359333992004, -0.05224878713488579, -0.029196182265877724, -0.018451955169439316, -0.003981947433203459, 0.006108250934630632, 0.03754662349820137, 0.04302159696817398, 0.04180559143424034, -0.06220567971467972, -0.03599041327834129, 0.001479776343330741, -0.0375962033867836, 0.016367994248867035, -0.026821285486221313, 0.0022878895979374647, 0.0013813372934237123, -0.02281278185546398, 0.011023531667888165, -0.03533586859703064, -0.015145545825362206, -0.035563256591558456, -0.07300954312086105, -0.02346477285027504, -0.008184744045138359, -0.029223069548606873, -0.015638716518878937, -0.0019945488311350346, -0.027798624709248543, 0.012669636867940426, -0.051759883761405945, 0.030431928113102913, -0.053272493183612823, 0.05081723630428314, 0.021224556490778923, -0.055852990597486496, 0.03279895707964897, -0.033075034618377686, 0.01798330619931221, 0.009131197817623615, 0.0028549134731292725, -0.003686157986521721, 0.043913789093494415, 0.017800332978367805, -0.027584560215473175, 0.07313336431980133, 0.0394253209233284, 0.005644276738166809, -0.03185238689184189, -0.006723130587488413, -0.05627681687474251, 0.06015521287918091, -0.00795767456293106, -0.07714848220348358, 0.07491300255060196, 0.04518609493970871, -0.059849873185157776, -0.022402282804250717, -0.08689404278993607, 0.06479596346616745, 0.005079139024019241, -0.002052929252386093, 0.009938566014170647, 0.0350491926074028, -0.006705036852508783, 0.06488528847694397, 0.03490744158625603, -0.03974095359444618, -0.03134693577885628, 0.005837639328092337, 0.028940808027982712, -0.0071550458669662476, 0.011924906633794308, 0.043460119515657425, -0.047531608492136, 0.016798850148916245, 0.08306419849395752, -0.004614812321960926, -0.030470483005046844, 0.009266065433621407, 0.024324901401996613, -0.016815802082419395, -0.005112356506288052, 0.038872331380844116, 0.0432099774479866, 0.07061545550823212, -0.033218082040548325, 0.021355528384447098, 0.007616405375301838, 0.012878612615168095, -0.014007741585373878, 0.031566016376018524, 0.005288233514875174, 0.05832540616393089, -0.013633250258862972, 0.03070210851728916, 0.006521392613649368, -0.01968477852642536, -0.004250275902450085, -0.03448444977402687, -0.017006758600473404, 0.06466928124427795, 0.05088701471686363, 0.04416777193546295, 0.05063489452004433, 0.025454597547650337, 0.0036728959530591965, -0.034298937767744064, -0.024862710386514664, 0.02793041430413723, -0.018520845100283623, 0.05543793365359306, -0.011943413875997066, 0.015021088533103466, -0.04541698843240738, -0.014071139506995678, 0.026920707896351814, -0.04748709872364998, 0.046314749866724014, -0.005087332334369421, -0.014562159776687622, 0.029244499281048775, 0.018187470734119415, -0.009616074152290821, 0.03252764418721199, 0.01565069891512394, -0.005828996188938618, -0.026604801416397095, -0.04659786447882652, -0.014185096137225628, 0.032694872468709946, -0.012978375889360905, 0.015428573824465275, 0.03967449069023132, 0.01886003278195858, -0.06340998411178589, -0.03482092171907425, -0.02151477336883545, -0.026381900534033775, -0.09160967916250229, -0.027141185477375984, 0.02062261290848255, -0.012199833057820797, -0.009439758025109768, 0.0015737134963274002, -0.03581060841679573, -0.07404092699289322, -0.034540772438049316, 0.0369112528860569, -0.012625720351934433, 0.0492263026535511, 0.035949014127254486, 0.060452576726675034, -0.011797667481005192, -0.05827410891652107, -0.002616938902065158, 0.06791125982999802, 0.054852377623319626, -0.015217370353639126, -0.018010221421718597, -0.027669459581375122, 0.006047694943845272, 0.0307172741740942, -0.0070538995787501335, 0.02378106862306595, 0.00754326768219471, 0.02657301537692547, -0.012410751543939114, -0.012850982137024403, -0.012160373851656914, 0.030611548572778702, -0.01887669786810875, 0.002633832162246108, -0.037759438157081604, 0.008814623579382896, 0.029169848188757896, 0.02245383709669113, -0.048835381865501404, 0.010136879980564117, 0.02879033237695694, -0.01039836835116148, -0.029679734259843826, 0.007487243041396141, 0.047405727207660675, 0.005580344703048468, -0.0501500703394413, 0.010952005162835121, 0.028000790625810623, -0.0003491611569188535, 0.018835263326764107, 0.0012335233623161912, 0.026983648538589478, -0.04930916801095009, -0.014564869925379753, 0.025267399847507477, -0.006927084177732468, 0.013450752012431622, -0.020219437777996063, -0.02373426966369152, -0.04339320585131645, -0.015108373016119003, 0.08055076748132706, 0.023537682369351387, 0.013177919201552868, -0.0212313961237669, -0.01436019316315651, 0.003914316184818745, -0.0290585495531559, 0.02107669785618782, -0.026414815336465836, -0.046097032725811005, 0.02407422848045826, -0.03561434522271156, -0.037881795316934586, -0.1101805716753006, -0.05053526535630226, 0.03363924100995064, -0.023391801863908768, -0.06627552211284637, 0.03933362290263176, 0.008720095269382, 0.027924003079533577, 0.003290104679763317, -0.022523978725075722, -0.029812319204211235, -0.04183736816048622, 0.0252744872123003, 0.04054588824510574, -0.034399084746837616, 0.035926058888435364, 0.05139971151947975, 0.03214842826128006, 0.008350949734449387, -0.06221986934542656, 0.03154633566737175, -0.05847061797976494, -0.005227620247751474, -0.011780237779021263, 0.021028349176049232, 0.012477991171181202, -0.005219584796577692, 0.01854700595140457, 0.055028971284627914, 0.048136841505765915, -0.023998577147722244, -0.01094446424394846, -0.07710376381874084, -0.04835756495594978, -0.0038477906491607428, 0.05616282671689987, 0.015369624830782413, -0.014437730424106121, 0.007971665821969509, 0.0034374960232526064, -0.01377047784626484, 0.06470098346471786, -0.08158551901578903, -0.04941059276461601, -0.0034365856554359198 ]
<p>Frequently when trying to solve cosmology questions physicists turn to computer simulations of the universe (albeit massively simplified) in order to verify or disprove their hypotheses. This got me thinking.</p> <p>My question is about the theoretical maximum possible complexity of these systems.</p> <p>Let me give an example, if we imagine a tennis ball bouncing on a flat surface if we want to accurately simulate and measure the results of every single facet of the collision right down to the atomic and quantum effects you could actually find a tennis ball and drop it over your surface. In this case the universe is "simulating" the collision for you.</p> <p>Would it be possible to simulate this same event just as accurately using a computer? Is there a theoretical reason why the computer would need to have more mass than the two colliding objects? (in this case a tennis ball and the planet!)</p> <p>Now I have always assumed that the answer to this question is "yes you need a more massive computer to simulate any object with total physical accuracy" because if that were not the case there would be no reason why a computer less massive than the universe could not simulate the entire universe with total accuracy, which seems to me to be counterintuitive.</p> <p>I hope I was clear with my question! I would like to find a hard and fast answer to this question with a reason preferably, been mulling it over for a little while now. Thanks for any help.</p>
g1591
[ 0.02562062069773674, 0.05382641777396202, 0.015435770153999329, 0.010190418921411037, -0.011007202789187431, 0.04404457286000252, 0.021469149738550186, 0.02145598642528057, -0.02894807979464531, -0.009025301784276962, 0.010625415481626987, -0.055966347455978394, 0.040045835077762604, -0.004046080633997917, -0.011908960528671741, -0.01601019874215126, 0.003609234932810068, -0.023162804543972015, -0.009524624794721603, 0.017969541251659393, 0.02071000449359417, 0.004215574357658625, 0.011731548234820366, -0.06981489807367325, -0.07122675329446793, 0.007663989905267954, -0.03354448452591896, -0.01105668768286705, -0.03964686393737793, 0.02852248214185238, -0.022437691688537598, -0.035260964184999466, -0.005074610002338886, -0.06753300875425339, -0.03788265585899353, 0.0004099902871530503, -0.0023442492820322514, -0.018781451508402824, 0.03937707468867302, -0.014627139084041119, 0.007344947196543217, -0.004215178545564413, -0.01434314250946045, -0.015424175187945366, -0.00016621140821371228, -0.015104849822819233, 0.014907915145158768, -0.010054356418550014, 0.02442861534655094, -0.017543073743581772, -0.02765805646777153, -0.027836648747324944, 0.03653786703944206, 0.03142052888870239, 0.009084729477763176, 0.028206661343574524, 0.01812908612191677, -0.034711603075265884, 0.07039573788642883, -0.012866450473666191, 0.023087278008461, -0.00576317124068737, -0.014690185897052288, -0.0018567118095234036, 0.002822453621774912, 0.021384259685873985, 0.0035868152044713497, 0.0028011873364448547, 0.004998669493943453, -0.052426695823669434, 0.013511602766811848, -0.04602808877825737, 0.014266453683376312, -0.06040716543793678, -0.0014710527611896396, -0.014639911241829395, -0.009118652902543545, -0.033806510269641876, 0.0145341157913208, 0.054787520319223404, 0.014252790249884129, -0.030815042555332184, 0.025375327095389366, -0.02388324961066246, -0.023759042844176292, -0.03857559338212013, -0.052466414868831635, -0.00995418056845665, -0.023171406239271164, 0.031070927157998085, 0.015476628206670284, -0.0067955669946968555, 0.047760091722011566, 0.03639344125986099, 0.005886399187147617, 0.05012909695506096, -0.06539499759674072, 0.05480823665857315, 0.03237925469875336, 0.032288890331983566, -0.01902623288333416, -0.0031054308637976646, 0.06144806742668152, -0.00608090590685606, -0.03503852337598801, -0.025566712021827698, 0.033058833330869675, 0.01837613247334957, -0.011121127754449844, -0.015669116750359535, -0.02250637672841549, -0.03934319689869881, -0.012483090162277222, -0.009468760341405869, -0.04000471904873848, 0.026792868971824646, 0.028192779049277306, 0.0458528995513916, -0.014481271617114544, 0.06274238973855972, -0.01053336076438427, -0.006189929787069559, -0.045564912259578705, 0.002779361791908741, -0.04891299083828926, -0.05218914523720741, 0.03416517376899719, 0.0063855755142867565, 0.019576584920287132, -0.035404812544584274, -0.022580280900001526, 0.0021387350279837847, -0.02247246727347374, -0.006213197950273752, -0.02274877391755581, -0.027539534494280815, 0.0017528204480186105, -0.03819281980395317, 0.051563430577516556, -0.0007486642571166158, 0.04797752946615219, -0.03634374961256981, -0.06725151836872101, -0.04074579477310181, -0.04937611147761345, 0.025774458423256874, 0.01745479926466942, 0.03981542959809303, -0.03652213141322136, -0.056143566966056824, 0.011664105579257011, 0.03182648867368698, 0.05069416016340256, -0.06120472028851509, 0.017688460648059845, 0.03252130374312401, -0.016085311770439148, 0.028838548809289932, -0.005118020344525576, -0.002065497450530529, -0.01003953069448471, -0.018603147938847542, 0.013532081618905067, -0.0186846312135458, 0.020741702988743782, 0.058131396770477295, 0.0267085749655962, -0.07367003709077835, -0.008703535422682762, -0.0030580039601773024, -0.04177602380514145, -0.027771074324846268, 0.0073603359051048756, 0.01084077823907137, -0.0046815103851258755, -0.006866508163511753, 0.042179081588983536, -0.054964929819107056, -0.03192706033587456, 0.01398050133138895, -0.016020305454730988, -0.033152952790260315, -0.041949544101953506, 0.05007171258330345, 0.015548097901046276, -0.04870355501770973, 0.01125346589833498, 0.025387275964021683, 0.05137054622173309, 0.004740765783935785, -0.03375144675374031, -0.005248872563242912, 0.020206505432724953, -0.05699281767010689, 0.005229678936302662, 0.00032438631751574576, 0.08249571919441223, 0.00896268431097269, -0.06485214084386826, -0.02640942670404911, 0.004617827478796244, 0.06879844516515732, 0.03995450213551521, 0.028000768274068832, -0.004929276183247566, 0.022445296868681908, -0.0024908152408897877, 0.0388200506567955, -0.02932145819067955, -0.02182503044605255, 0.03867389261722565, 0.03187188878655434, 0.045390378683805466, 0.0361342579126358, 0.0017873488832265139, -0.022189555689692497, -0.032173871994018555, -0.013890093192458153, -0.020123176276683807, 0.009914989583194256, 0.023928705602884293, -0.02832961268723011, 0.05995595082640648, 0.00561026344075799, 0.022925512865185738, 0.05455426499247551, -0.028529388830065727, 0.013665606267750263, -0.015670794993638992, 0.045300111174583435, 0.007986721582710743, 0.06592123210430145, 0.07861801981925964, 0.03358011692762375, 0.03991580009460449, 0.02221057005226612, -0.005778098478913307, -0.011102575808763504, 0.016677603125572205, 0.02932683937251568, 0.030862299725413322, -0.03936672955751419, -0.038130659610033035, -0.008733440190553665, 0.013660898432135582, -0.0913628414273262, 0.014404562301933765, -0.011138470843434334, -0.04652879759669304, 0.03740445524454117, -0.01139964908361435, -0.029763318598270416, -0.023719076067209244, -0.03014766424894333, 0.016188664361834526, 0.023678964003920555, 0.008200357668101788, 0.007283325307071209, -0.015926023945212364, 0.028510682284832, 0.06124509498476982, -0.03170165419578552, 0.04204317554831505, 0.04982991889119148, -0.006982267368584871, 0.046766187995672226, -0.05285856872797012, -0.03662852570414543, -0.051822878420352936, 0.024843264371156693, -0.009324131533503532, -0.010627846233546734, -0.009070424363017082, 0.011783652938902378, 0.006965315900743008, 0.005688293371349573, 0.011410381644964218, -0.017247648909687996, 0.029444372281432152, -0.0020395410247147083, -0.027745841071009636, 0.01010228507220745, -0.0046128383837640285, -0.007069410756230354, 0.057343337684869766, -0.049769699573516846, -0.05534949526190758, 0.04005633667111397, 0.015971966087818146, 0.02514026314020157, 0.022272445261478424, 0.025463370606303215, -0.034135572612285614, 0.05530039593577385, -0.026572462171316147, 0.07267028838396072, -0.034435197710990906, 0.011151912622153759, 0.0010212091729044914, 0.0653393343091011, 0.04337247088551521, -0.025598399341106415, 0.0024896212853491306, 0.046497609466314316, -0.017836380749940872, 0.04856516048312187, -0.022627754136919975, 0.01201792061328888, 0.0025406384374946356, -0.07221712917089462, -0.02752082236111164, 0.07045458257198334, 0.02949867770075798, 0.034054309129714966, 0.012359799817204475, 0.031730007380247116, 0.05482592061161995, 0.02836614102125168, -0.021895043551921844, 0.0369812473654747, -0.00131778116337955, 0.004579018801450729, -0.032887283712625504, -0.012552812695503235, 0.045489225536584854, 0.08062980324029922, -0.07029745727777481, -0.05578328296542168, -0.025869857519865036, -0.02137156017124653, 0.024957694113254547, 0.026265623047947884, -0.007960877381265163, 0.05208165571093559, -0.09304569661617279, -0.03272956609725952, 0.001986469142138958, -0.03423117473721504, 0.056194283068180084, 0.022628288716077805, -0.0261609498411417, 0.01742822863161564, -0.0238389503210783, -0.03858738765120506, 0.012403283268213272, 0.060615651309490204, -0.0032852529548108578, -0.02852325327694416, -0.009407764300704002, -0.060933612287044525, 0.11286895722150803, 0.005761073436588049, -0.03554891049861908, -0.029169348999857903, 0.008465515449643135, 0.02666633203625679, -0.0026851780712604523, -0.002279565902426839, -0.009268417954444885, 0.0168259609490633, 0.027344975620508194, 0.010197700001299381, -0.007793751545250416, -0.017216119915246964, -0.009818069636821747, -0.011730708181858063, -0.045798130333423615, -0.019127272069454193, -0.04615865275263786, 0.008177032694220543, -0.04871230944991112, 0.027450835332274437, -0.032366834580898285, -0.010959031991660595, 0.11442240327596664, -0.03653249517083168, 0.0413682647049427, -0.05118366330862045, 0.03845036402344704, -0.019069593399763107, 0.028722338378429413, 0.006405256688594818, 0.05054750293493271, -0.004440760239958763, 0.017573071643710136, -0.001169538707472384, -0.02185099571943283, -0.04529862478375435, -0.020217128098011017, 0.004219672176986933, 0.0529402419924736, -0.1004374697804451, -0.04210585728287697, 0.055763788521289825, 0.018312735483050346, -0.013433345593512058, -0.07924385368824005, -0.02746943198144436, 0.013902535662055016, 0.02594618871808052, 0.0313844159245491, -0.05060795694589615, -0.006175389513373375, -0.010575398802757263, 0.0026024009566754103, 0.008864201605319977, 0.007048434112221003, 0.016421372070908546, -0.03177790343761444, -0.03266988322138786, 0.06568274646997452, 0.0005632788524962962, 0.007203133311122656, -0.029303042218089104, 0.003166318405419588, -0.003490356495603919, -0.060547880828380585, 0.015107488259673119, 0.010279061272740364, 0.01907268911600113, 0.009007810615003109, -0.01623283512890339, -0.01660034991800785, -0.015727803111076355, -0.017800597473978996, 0.013508826494216919, 0.011649632826447487, 0.014072367921471596, -0.0494573675096035, 0.04037352278828621, 0.045700374990701675, 0.00860670767724514, 0.008537703193724155, 0.08942720293998718, 0.002809882164001465, 0.03463589400053024, 0.05942481383681297, -0.007201679516583681, 0.016136707738041878, -0.02673286572098732, 0.024486051872372627, -0.02694208361208439, 0.007472943514585495, -0.015515200793743134, 0.02282598614692688, 0.058666542172431946, -0.0320856049656868, -0.04898757487535477, -0.07535841315984726, -0.0657794401049614, -0.01174400094896555, -0.003265334526076913, -0.020302414894104004, 0.012832211330533028, -0.04955161362886429, -0.025908706709742546, 0.011333760805428028, 0.06015541031956673, -0.004412082955241203, 0.052962567657232285, -0.02613953687250614, 0.037482213228940964, 0.0151827372610569, 0.033155858516693115, 0.01693812757730484, -0.003324931487441063, -0.04013959690928459, 0.014872810803353786, -0.09583643823862076, 0.019483759999275208, -0.011543171480298042, 0.004843734670430422, 0.07056683301925659, 0.062250830233097076, -0.03862646967172623, -0.038464367389678955, -0.0879998430609703, -0.01612740196287632, 0.027529632672667503, -0.006879921071231365, -0.028881153091788292, 0.008493557572364807, -0.02536899968981743, 0.05067966505885124, -0.02090275101363659, 0.0634000226855278, -0.05210321769118309, 0.020706715062260628, 0.03653149679303169, 0.02760329283773899, 0.061551306396722794, 0.014438712038099766, -0.0021578646264970303, 0.0009582218481227756, -0.022894294932484627, -0.07100289314985275, 0.0035923137329518795, -0.03548337519168854, 0.016419317573308945, 0.043830160051584244, 0.0026650531217455864, 0.025735242292284966, 0.0577094703912735, -0.03580724075436592, -0.07098003476858139, 0.01384373102337122, -0.004151619505137205, -0.03610016405582428, 0.012668334878981113, 0.06912019848823547, 0.006618373095989227, 0.06923764944076538, 0.0006718186778016388, 0.050326406955718994, -0.034828927367925644, -0.02020116150379181, 0.03476354479789734, -0.008683587424457073, -0.02611200138926506, -0.09676139056682587, 0.028093738481402397, 0.0248346459120512, 0.041750870645046234, 0.03042208030819893, -0.02083498053252697, 0.007040414027869701, 0.015809161588549614, -0.055588725954294205, -0.014644063077867031, 0.006711726542562246, 0.04446300491690636, 0.006207298021763563, -0.047940947115421295, -0.017028769478201866, -0.08469176292419434, -0.02018028125166893, -0.025306137278676033, -0.019004546105861664, 0.025151187554001808, 0.027727168053388596, 0.033744506537914276, 0.03408070653676987, 0.006165790371596813, 0.05469328537583351, 0.03781234845519066, -0.043644167482852936, 0.016507243737578392, 0.06350956112146378, 0.0653705894947052, -0.06285719573497772, -0.03402304649353027, 0.040352724492549896, 0.00018408280448056757, 0.010020003654062748, 0.0007459116168320179, 0.042090363800525665, -0.004757687449455261, -0.007703471928834915, 0.006106470245867968, -0.01140899769961834, -0.047215379774570465, 0.006273884326219559, -0.0004317985149100423, -0.05481763929128647, -0.048698581755161285, -0.04415105655789375, -0.04795634001493454, -0.03005552850663662, 0.04780948907136917, 0.01706644892692566, 0.016674291342496872, -0.03412186726927757, -0.016047444194555283, 0.02493813820183277, 0.04895404353737831, -0.02213345840573311, 0.002251026453450322, -0.026844944804906845, -0.039280060678720474, -0.02700829692184925, -0.013853160664439201, -0.05652069300413132, -0.004663264378905296, -0.009390936233103275, 0.08113889396190643, -0.010599181987345219, -0.062436576932668686, 0.015512396581470966, 0.0197947695851326, -0.0391867533326149, -0.016104508191347122, -0.028588224202394485, 0.006868851836770773, -0.08413936197757721, -0.014582421630620956, -0.07793723791837692, 0.02363497205078602, -0.04294018819928169, -0.08388432115316391, 0.04487525671720505, -0.003953116480261087, 0.009678716771304607, 0.0552581250667572, 0.012155234813690186, 0.007941489107906818, 0.04942391812801361, -0.04286713898181915, 0.013611441478133202, 0.04329163208603859, -0.024726280942559242, -0.01353721134364605, 0.013958792202174664, 0.023056991398334503, 0.022877287119627, -0.012635667808353901, -0.011051332578063011, 0.05454849451780319, -0.10246673226356506, 0.029658541083335876, -0.05711564049124718, 0.02973215840756893, -0.03170546889305115, 0.034211091697216034, -0.025183631107211113, -0.0269821435213089, -0.023255450651049614, -0.015422657132148743, 0.08347330242395401, 0.0945349931716919, 0.00607597129419446, 0.0625004917383194, 0.0007594443159177899, 0.059592049568891525, 0.06993725150823593, 0.02592279203236103, 0.07073020935058594, -0.0296007189899683, -0.006569475866854191, -0.014378784224390984, 0.022304758429527283, 0.0005899618263356388, 0.007193169556558132, 0.0023687572684139013, 0.08657854050397873, 0.0011473750928416848, -0.021502960473299026, 0.04751377925276756, -0.03819572925567627, -0.0050996532663702965, -0.01576998271048069, -0.05124722793698311, -0.0005204645567573607, -0.014471322298049927, -0.008012816309928894, -0.06294257938861847, 0.00013020999904256314, -0.06845345348119736, 0.003555844072252512, 0.0014105706941336393, -0.07672298699617386, -0.007108122110366821, -0.0012240710202604532, -0.03480060026049614, -0.04046207666397095, 0.009477687068283558, 0.04099838435649872, -0.006122753955423832, -0.034907277673482895, -0.019662607461214066, -0.0021825041621923447, -0.002182155614718795, -0.01793430931866169, -0.08158194273710251, 0.046883177012205124, 0.08533493429422379, -0.08311726152896881, -0.04457097128033638, -0.03036935068666935, 0.015127941034734249, 0.02382262609899044, 0.02451692521572113, 0.028142405673861504, -0.00012634892482310534, 0.07454320043325424, 0.03127408027648926, 0.0013542743399739265, 0.013315356336534023, 0.05124523863196373, -0.04834829270839691, -0.04555165395140648, 0.012211095541715622, -0.02608351968228817, 0.004831086844205856, 0.004794341046363115, -0.017832672223448753, 0.05650170147418976, -0.021458689123392105, 0.031738415360450745, 0.12465416640043259, -0.02042124792933464, -0.003623463213443756, -0.0034966845996677876, 0.00520265894010663, -0.0033337969798594713, 0.06589539349079132, 0.02330026403069496, -0.05223698168992996, 0.030624235048890114, 0.007710858713835478, 0.00342304608784616, 0.03537234663963318, 0.0415775440633297, -0.035925377160310745, -0.030377309769392014, -0.019544322043657303, -0.020974447950720787, -0.0310650821775198, -0.01852598413825035, -0.028576839715242386, -0.023200789466500282, 0.02007891610264778, -0.012371609918773174, -0.0019967015832662582, -0.043818846344947815, 0.009650847874581814, -0.0011815964244306087, -0.0012083156034350395, -0.0504729226231575, -0.055189669132232666, 0.012374326586723328, 0.04907715320587158, -0.05088333413004875, -0.029302658513188362, 0.018838273361325264, -0.000527023512404412, 0.036976784467697144, -0.06393652409315109, 0.02088434062898159, -0.08648520708084106, -0.04682489112019539, -0.01153175812214613, -0.0515672005712986, 0.017037563025951385, 0.005801807157695293, 0.0045936559326946735, -0.032690275460481644, -0.025126900523900986, -0.0025250930339097977, 0.05197608098387718, 0.010097222402691841, -0.00930857751518488, -0.008438743650913239, 0.042640216648578644, 0.05006737634539604, 0.013636634685099125, 0.02891378104686737, 0.003301755990833044, -0.022464299574494362, -0.04899883270263672, -0.0005225241766311228, 0.0333622470498085, 0.0037953027058392763, 0.014179261401295662, -0.019136622548103333, 0.039183977991342545, -0.015372537076473236, 0.002165089827030897, 0.060882240533828735 ]
<p>I'm reading through Novotny and Hecht's book on Nano-Optics (Principles of Nano-Optics), and I've come across a subtlety in the boundary conditions for evanescent wave generation (via total internal reflection) that I don't understand.</p> <p>In the 2nd edition of the book the equation I'm struggling with is labelled 2.104, but exactly the same content is available online <a href="http://www.photonics.ethz.ch/fileadmin/user_upload/optics/Courses/NanoOptics/foundations.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a> where it's labelled 2.91.</p> <p>My question is this: where does the negative sign come from in the x component of the transmitted field $\textbf{E}_2$? I understand that the parallel components of the electric field must be conserved across the boundary, but where does the factor of $-1$ arise?</p> <p>Many thanks!</p>
g1592
[ 0.02311452478170395, 0.015967536717653275, 0.0032719136215746403, -0.00795108824968338, 0.055262818932533264, 0.05798543617129326, 0.04759906232357025, 0.03594489395618439, -0.007416649721562862, -0.001493530347943306, -0.009204166010022163, 0.04323919489979744, 0.02086263708770275, -0.01953870803117752, -0.020026743412017822, -0.0010265185264870524, 0.07218389958143234, 0.005939210299402475, 0.03488442301750183, 0.03546283394098282, -0.06978734582662582, 0.014574254862964153, -0.015379891730844975, -0.05158546566963196, 0.0031302908901125193, 0.036209024488925934, 0.023620370775461197, -0.040395479649305344, -0.039810340851545334, -0.06891831755638123, 0.011202261783182621, 0.025168290361762047, 0.044661082327365875, 0.004636816214770079, -0.0032194568775594234, 0.03832234814763069, -0.040465790778398514, 0.05862414836883545, -0.016855856403708458, 0.027211954817175865, 0.03238613158464432, -0.0267555620521307, -0.03434295579791069, -0.02811642922461033, -0.009023191407322884, -0.005793897435069084, -0.047858819365501404, -0.03189750388264656, 0.01701728254556656, -0.052624430507421494, 0.03746315836906433, -0.00840546004474163, 0.050012100487947464, 0.015087926760315895, 0.03500216826796532, 0.037188928574323654, 0.001377947279252112, -0.040387772023677826, 0.033898357301950455, 0.026129063218832016, 0.038347695022821426, -0.006807766389101744, -0.01917043887078762, 0.038951002061367035, 0.037358395755290985, -0.044664785265922546, -0.06639303267002106, 0.04715476930141449, -0.020865576341748238, -0.017141742631793022, -0.016237840056419373, -0.018102722242474556, 0.0024996649008244276, -0.012132465839385986, -0.006101879291236401, 0.011157293803989887, 0.03147124499082565, 0.008688434027135372, -0.012927155941724777, 0.030846411362290382, -0.024722697213292122, -0.03573698550462723, 0.0005062924465164542, 0.022311663255095482, 0.015578816644847393, 0.027778349816799164, 0.023658227175474167, 0.002186483470723033, -0.03381674736738205, -0.0023919446393847466, 0.00782807357609272, 0.028015661984682083, 0.036341533064842224, -0.06614125519990921, 0.05512275546789169, 0.00131772190798074, 0.013387070968747139, 0.02347937412559986, -0.050185512751340866, 0.0012574103893712163, 0.02175019681453705, -0.03045808896422386, -0.04462702199816704, -0.010071123950183392, -0.034488461911678314, 0.011906691826879978, 0.03092706762254238, -0.021989595144987106, -0.01059166993945837, 0.0026187028270214796, -0.056352145969867706, -0.06757435947656631, -0.0769672840833664, -0.04524668678641319, -0.03871328756213188, -0.0045547871850430965, 0.031805187463760376, 0.013797794468700886, 0.03565506637096405, 0.08019043505191803, -0.007203390821814537, -0.02568042278289795, -0.018557162955403328, -0.009049376472830772, -0.0677880048751831, 0.017656289041042328, 0.015944911167025566, 0.009297446347773075, 0.04903138801455498, -0.012278995476663113, 0.009542549028992653, 0.011121619492769241, -0.019551292061805725, -0.02231181040406227, 0.02431991510093212, 0.02567235380411148, 0.015703698620200157, 0.001193524687550962, 0.0003812842769548297, 0.024815984070301056, -0.008172177709639072, -0.027864821255207062, -0.008725171908736229, -0.038338422775268555, -0.05211079120635986, 0.013173321262001991, 0.01055801473557949, -0.04718254879117012, 0.08206704258918762, 0.008304149843752384, 0.017628071829676628, 0.020125050097703934, 0.019114332273602486, -0.04306739196181297, -0.008152864873409271, -0.014048472978174686, 0.0008878778317011893, -0.07243408262729645, 0.00660571688786149, -0.018309060484170914, 0.07065192610025406, -0.03679540008306503, -0.03175986930727959, 0.055586621165275574, -0.06980782747268677, -0.07006719708442688, -0.019681889563798904, -0.08777054399251938, 0.0064474474638700485, -0.024402661249041557, -0.020971786230802536, 0.03184513747692108, 0.04225818067789078, 0.019704164937138557, 0.04363078624010086, 0.10246915370225906, 0.06598721444606781, -0.03239184617996216, -0.0017750528641045094, 0.05905015021562576, -0.07549645751714706, -0.03389779105782509, -0.010090294294059277, 0.023904666304588318, 0.04087701439857483, -0.08202195912599564, -0.019119828939437866, 0.04305485263466835, -0.053395211696624756, 0.020830679684877396, 0.0012325805146247149, -0.001906828605569899, -0.023357927799224854, -0.016178352758288383, -0.041979167610406876, 0.018294254317879677, -0.00838412530720234, -0.07827792316675186, 0.012362131848931313, -0.022378312423825264, -0.02725362963974476, 0.08482485264539719, 0.04309564456343651, 0.03424396738409996, 0.02588064596056938, 0.00872946996241808, 0.035567447543144226, -0.0011770296841859818, 0.023874392732977867, 0.01543104276061058, -0.07563068717718124, -0.020083216950297356, -0.02416347526013851, -0.010221113450825214, -0.0034433191176503897, -0.015513495542109013, 0.00659832963719964, 0.020447367802262306, -0.04811244457960129, 0.03417481482028961, -0.04146426171064377, 0.06994243711233139, 0.025945812463760376, -0.021918807178735733, -0.06880094110965729, -0.0030896924436092377, -0.050649967044591904, 0.032972898334264755, -0.021429166197776794, 0.021282171830534935, -0.07712282985448837, -0.016049694269895554, -0.054182808846235275, -0.0452541820704937, -0.015833331272006035, 0.016213536262512207, -0.00774781871587038, 0.05114288255572319, -0.010720578022301197, -0.01746944710612297, 0.05682223662734032, 0.030005469918251038, -0.038639236241579056, 0.03639144077897072, -0.00474694324657321, -0.007385202217847109, 0.07434968650341034, -0.006050871219485998, -0.043010737746953964, -0.0007656373782083392, 0.05836866796016693, -0.03302698954939842, 0.00614561140537262, 0.017096776515245438, -0.02597721852362156, -0.05669901892542839, -0.01178356446325779, 0.07891829311847687, -0.013026715256273746, -0.008936571888625622, -0.015595792792737484, -0.05252204090356827, 0.014483640901744366, 0.03230274096131325, -0.061355747282505035, -0.0070716883055865765, -0.00882960669696331, 0.022307733073830605, 0.024071699008345604, 0.006257936824113131, -0.01658167876303196, 0.07358528673648834, -0.03771582245826721, 0.013782658614218235, 0.03393720090389252, -0.04455161467194557, -0.022873684763908386, -0.030276212841272354, 0.012051042169332504, 0.03055836632847786, -0.013200927525758743, 0.021433096379041672, -0.0031217229552567005, 0.0381668396294117, 0.010007771663367748, -0.030478598549962044, -0.015018492937088013, -0.008673135191202164, 0.005644683726131916, 0.027908656746149063, -0.07692944258451462, -0.010965436697006226, 0.005630146712064743, 0.03715305030345917, 0.033855367451906204, 0.001771079027093947, -0.0050505101680755615, -0.023341014981269836, 0.013505185954272747, 0.017209185287356377, -0.053648076951503754, 0.01443582121282816, -0.027898581698536873, -0.06735002994537354, -0.025521865114569664, -0.017304997891187668, -0.04042884334921837, -0.027213850989937782, 0.04864645004272461, 0.027427254244685173, -0.021036606281995773, -0.007143184542655945, 0.011039284989237785, -0.01893990859389305, -0.021937180310487747, 0.03928658366203308, 0.014501911588013172, 0.02421942912042141, -0.0490269660949707, -0.02116600051522255, -0.07447956502437592, 0.019613809883594513, 0.06720849126577377, 0.04148324579000473, 0.02413901686668396, 0.007675509434193373, -0.004476787988096476, -0.0062302942387759686, -0.0016760891303420067, -0.00838569737970829, 0.011360025964677334, -0.04605411738157272, -0.007243772502988577, -0.01638021692633629, 0.019490255042910576, -0.08827138692140579, -0.0502701960504055, 0.04146542400121689, 0.03272956237196922, 0.001520980498753488, 0.027840809896588326, 0.0076517388224601746, -0.059639450162649155, -0.027758244425058365, 0.0285332091152668, -0.017362819984555244, -0.04704510420560837, 0.03493160381913185, 0.024431969970464706, -0.014771404676139355, -0.013543644919991493, 0.06650522351264954, 0.003581396769732237, 0.016586553305387497, -0.0386018231511116, 0.02135695144534111, -0.008619863539934158, 0.0506003312766552, 0.0007443598005920649, -0.0056499578058719635, -0.012937778607010841, -0.006100378464907408, 0.05443385988473892, -0.03865954279899597, -0.0017533344216644764, -0.06964071840047836, 0.016551567241549492, 0.002320411615073681, -0.028069350868463516, 0.0004035287711303681, -0.01721648871898651, -0.03686949610710144, -0.04035577178001404, -0.0002288394171046093, -0.06303957104682922, -0.0516706183552742, 0.015912815928459167, 0.011875026859343052, -0.028488921001553535, 0.02661142870783806, 0.001956348307430744, -0.00005731221608584747, 0.036314766854047775, -0.024535274133086205, 0.07053013145923615, 0.07510089129209518, -0.05959643796086311, -0.03791273385286331, 0.012563629075884819, -0.06600239127874374, -0.0009914934635162354, 0.013117576017975807, 0.037419117987155914, -0.011872000992298126, -0.005597664508968592, -0.04199714958667755, -0.021562572568655014, 0.01871836930513382, 0.01899356208741665, 0.002449726453050971, 0.048451513051986694, 0.01140736322849989, -0.02464580163359642, 0.012377678416669369, 0.011053213849663734, -0.014335292391479015, 0.03771962597966194, 0.024626096710562706, -0.0335979200899601, -0.03090265393257141, -0.034549277275800705, 0.012714103795588017, -0.017725039273500443, -0.04820551723241806, 0.028934096917510033, 0.035989273339509964, 0.08258398622274399, -0.032614272087812424, 0.06571298837661743, -0.021560348570346832, 0.01528723444789648, 0.001922947820276022, -0.014131482690572739, -0.017566153779625893, 0.02513911947607994, 0.04086105525493622, 0.01500439178198576, -0.01255589909851551, -0.027263842523097992, 0.0016694666119292378, -0.01565997488796711, 0.05493544787168503, -0.055060163140296936, 0.04113025218248367, -0.06407298892736435, 0.06575438380241394, -0.053591061383485794, 0.06431552767753601, 0.03523927554488182, 0.010677969083189964, 0.06627685576677322, -0.001858605071902275, 0.041250649839639664, -0.017874794080853462, -0.017595605924725533, 0.037778180092573166, -0.03936861827969551, -0.04777195304632187, 0.03751794993877411, -0.05836171656847, -0.019124489277601242, 0.0020572824869304895, 0.008341978304088116, -0.06502100825309753, 0.005217800848186016, -0.03444928303360939, 0.027310071513056755, 0.048958223313093185, -0.016682831570506096, -0.025998177006840706, -0.036953285336494446, 0.030191553756594658, -0.019801897928118706, 0.04085390642285347, 0.07091156393289566, -0.003991376142948866, -0.02160544879734516, 0.008961833082139492, -0.04172910749912262, -0.018809659406542778, 0.05746040120720863, 0.035244591534137726, 0.05210494250059128, 0.003403289010748267, 0.029703442007303238, 0.007466986309736967, -0.013681113719940186, 0.03593675047159195, -0.07820481806993484, -0.02493664063513279, 0.02296254225075245, -0.021428696811199188, 0.07986082136631012, 0.034275781363248825, -0.020054450258612633, 0.00043701299000531435, -0.028856532648205757, 0.09797453880310059, -0.0075569674372673035, -0.058565836399793625, 0.006585828494280577, -0.04128555580973625, -0.014657099731266499, -0.04528554528951645, -0.0379866287112236, 0.0014384138630703092, 0.09305281937122345, 0.011651121079921722, -0.0014974679797887802, -0.03332405909895897, -0.04325972869992256, 0.011872838251292706, -0.02126992680132389, 0.024260487407445908, 0.014346201904118061, 0.07622455805540085, 0.027697809040546417, -0.033032309263944626, 0.051697492599487305, -0.012626939453184605, -0.014393866062164307, -0.043359506875276566, 0.01742776483297348, -0.014675646089017391, 0.014234536327421665, -0.011477218009531498, -0.03350179269909859, 0.03734702244400978, -0.035102784633636475, 0.010409495793282986, -0.01444811001420021, -0.018249424174427986, -0.023430325090885162, 0.0008975476375781, 0.036020323634147644, 0.058897655457258224, -0.009072263725101948, -0.029240669682621956, 0.012103834189474583, 0.0019188321894034743, 0.03944559395313263, 0.05990259349346161, -0.032175689935684204, 0.01695186458528042, 0.06391739100217819, -0.08659642189741135, 0.03411126881837845, -0.009147542528808117, 0.009161063469946384, 0.0333586260676384, 0.006252996623516083, -0.024503987282514572, 0.027332419529557228, 0.011449836194515228, 0.0037198297213763, 0.013666169717907906, 0.052162040024995804, 0.004759776871651411, -0.006772659253329039, 0.0012229038402438164, 0.029458062723279, -0.021942999213933945, 0.02829436957836151, 0.02696823887526989, 0.038045484572649, 0.035067107528448105, 0.021811503916978836, 0.00920776929706335, -0.026801666244864464, -0.07845862209796906, 0.0540957972407341, 0.03036756068468094, -0.025080526247620583, -0.04277563840150833, -0.018423888832330704, 0.027343478053808212, 0.021999556571245193, 0.024524038657546043, 0.031112952157855034, -0.001988966716453433, 0.036096084862947464, 0.03788742050528526, 0.04121173918247223, 0.005418933928012848, 0.0007853272254578769, 0.016885122284293175, 0.012100284919142723, -0.04245300590991974, -0.07829272001981735, 0.041161149740219116, 0.0192865040153265, -0.012846985831856728, 0.012592913582921028, -0.05121251195669174, -0.02584092505276203, -0.022527087479829788, -0.011688783764839172, -0.052263617515563965, 0.09527023136615753, -0.029491005465388298, -0.024980993941426277, -0.007972637191414833, 0.04448406770825386, 0.0010864227078855038, 0.03404427319765091, -0.05386835336685181, 0.012086805887520313, 0.04572879523038864, -0.0046037971042096615, -0.0035531865432858467, -0.023850539699196815, -0.007336976006627083, 0.017914904281497, 0.007845820859074593, 0.06697435677051544, 0.05133064091205597, 0.006806413177400827, 0.020426584407687187, -0.04222970828413963, 0.07784224301576614, 0.004705697763711214, 0.024823039770126343, 0.0005518714897334576, -0.013478398323059082, 0.006435717456042767, -0.048662807792425156, 0.007098243106156588, 0.05334937199950218, -0.018432028591632843, 0.006843719631433487, 0.002993866102769971, -0.028550295159220695, -0.03022950515151024, 0.0442454032599926, 0.026262914761900902, 0.04659067466855049, -0.019136453047394753, -0.011800570413470268, 0.02337404526770115, 0.026097372174263, 0.028241444379091263, 0.010445679537951946, -0.018673313781619072, 0.0449041873216629, -0.0043619051575660706, 0.004772975109517574, 0.023300757631659508, 0.0035754807759076357, 0.04274693503975868, -0.043657634407281876, -0.023450899869203568, 0.015375019982457161, 0.04194772616028786, 0.015924615785479546, -0.046665217727422714, 0.03564244881272316, -0.022106338292360306, -0.04391797259449959, -0.09430155903100967, 0.02271278202533722, 0.026216745376586914, -0.025090789422392845, -0.0019718047697097063, -0.056915532797575, 0.01889648847281933, -0.005357963033020496, 0.007268751505762339, -0.023494776338338852, -0.05382789298892021, 0.03914099186658859, -0.02405562251806259, -0.07309510558843613, -0.024377061054110527, -0.0022178329527378082, 0.012158378958702087, 0.05593351274728775, 0.03766877204179764, 0.008029903285205364, 0.004697146359831095, -0.039457205682992935, -0.0030860796105116606, -0.03391367197036743, -0.010475069284439087, -0.03198830783367157, -0.052846670150756836, 0.02941998653113842, -0.029675405472517014, 0.05903814360499382, -0.026370901614427567, -0.0366104431450367, 0.07016465812921524, 0.003774690441787243, 0.022523751482367516, -0.07911967486143112, -0.05777342990040779, -0.08004549145698547, -0.027467332780361176, -0.03052266500890255, 0.027152132242918015, -0.01800519786775112, -0.015887891873717308, 0.016214042901992798, 0.025935295969247818, -0.00402455311268568, -0.017195221036672592, 0.00485202856361866, 0.061850450932979584, 0.08139154314994812, -0.009579820558428764, 0.01222069002687931, -0.005444447509944439, -0.011377036571502686, 0.021697264164686203, -0.005352867301553488, 0.029053838923573494, -0.02816779538989067, 0.00019325519679114223, -0.03630901128053665, 0.04785612225532532, -0.059753596782684326, 0.016163425520062447, -0.03548835963010788, 0.042776431888341904, -0.03232649341225624, 0.0555814728140831, 0.019677644595503807, 0.00037949607940390706, 0.02337857522070408, -0.022106032818555832, 0.032254938036203384, -0.0031484970822930336, 0.04017256200313568, -0.030287688598036766, -0.001092093880288303, 0.006000780966132879, -0.029735449701547623, 0.013376113958656788, -0.0025810739025473595, 0.038977719843387604, -0.0336650125682354, -0.054772503674030304, 0.0691460371017456, -0.011897037737071514, -0.041674256324768066, -0.013344543054699898, 0.005258582066744566, 0.014944387599825859, -0.02074636146426201, 0.0212690532207489, 0.012891851365566254, 0.05180824548006058, -0.0398377925157547, 0.019307542592287064, -0.045583419501781464, -0.03641543537378311, 0.028436731547117233, -0.07836801558732986, 0.002757109235972166, -0.01150565780699253, -0.01739937998354435, 0.005893956869840622, -0.024923471733927727, -0.01332190353423357, 0.0842304602265358, 0.08858943730592728, -0.13423575460910797, 0.016539134085178375, 0.019106421619653702, -0.0162399560213089, -0.003618877148255706, -0.0789102092385292, -0.019614234566688538, 0.023792287334799767, 0.030481398105621338, -0.01978299580514431, -0.05109270289540291, -0.08114758878946304, 0.03527739644050598 ]
<p>As far as I understand it the photon propagator, $P(A\rightarrow B)$, described in Feynman's QED book, gives the amplitude that a photon moves from spacetime point A to spacetime point B.</p> <p>I was wondering if in quantum field theory terms $P(A\rightarrow B)$ is made up of the product of the following two amplitudes:</p> <ol> <li>the amplitude that a photon is created at $B$ given that there is a photon at $A$.</li> <li>the amplitude that a photon is annihilated at $A$ given that there is a photon at $B$.</li> </ol> <p>Is this the correct approach to describing a photon moving from $A$ to $B$ using creation and annihilation operators?</p>
g1593
[ -0.00011236578575335443, -0.006826785858720541, -0.022280707955360413, -0.015642141923308372, 0.028660617768764496, 0.025495219975709915, 0.051456015557050705, 0.02837243489921093, -0.021036410704255104, 0.032774895429611206, 0.006131838541477919, 0.027921339496970177, 0.004747943952679634, 0.005673521663993597, 0.018697991967201233, -0.0012345243012532592, 0.06165619194507599, 0.0152267562225461, 0.0511719174683094, -0.03372620791196823, -0.016122005879878998, 0.017908647656440735, -0.021809250116348267, 0.025749215856194496, -0.027239592745900154, -0.02938997745513916, -0.012242649681866169, -0.014000198803842068, -0.018785949796438217, -0.08178595453500748, 0.024561496451497078, 0.015594120137393475, 0.00010029903205577284, -0.030069885775446892, -0.020551014691591263, -0.02464386820793152, 0.04702938348054886, 0.09094554930925369, 0.04732402041554451, 0.02255912497639656, 0.009974650107324123, 0.013810769654810429, 0.026531508192420006, -0.017779987305402756, 0.018055476248264313, -0.04337400943040848, -0.005690398626029491, 0.011334286071360111, -0.024361813440918922, 0.005415927618741989, -0.04414111375808716, 0.01664634421467781, 0.016013415530323982, -0.021405663341283798, 0.032700348645448685, 0.024454960599541664, -0.019254175946116447, -0.012958057224750519, 0.0937577411532402, 0.031241804361343384, 0.003320770338177681, 0.008868305012583733, 0.054767221212387085, 0.009717351756989956, 0.0778501108288765, -0.012537051923573017, 0.015001395717263222, -0.029052581638097763, -0.06967820972204208, 0.004198553506284952, 0.009338894858956337, -0.04894224926829338, -0.025376221165060997, -0.0005776411271654069, 0.024314958602190018, 0.030536450445652008, -0.04069098085165024, -0.05361279100179672, 0.0334748700261116, 0.03308035805821419, -0.03598222881555557, -0.04031224176287651, 0.012807223945856094, -0.004136889241635799, 0.020259931683540344, -0.021119549870491028, 0.0008644137415103614, 0.009880293160676956, -0.016504129394888878, -0.023442259058356285, 0.00048081419663503766, 0.02039952203631401, 0.03432527557015419, 0.05561285838484764, -0.023836547508835793, -0.026198631152510643, -0.07768427580595016, 0.04031260311603546, -0.04027567058801651, 0.019127102568745613, -0.06839188188314438, 0.051987532526254654, 0.019407156854867935, 0.028884844854474068, 0.014150229282677174, 0.004593735095113516, 0.04720854014158249, -0.0869356021285057, 0.021501993760466576, 0.02985072135925293, -0.021914230659604073, -0.024171404540538788, -0.04321269318461418, -0.05613848194479942, -0.06530524045228958, -0.018895570188760757, 0.013302029110491276, -0.0415453240275383, 0.04649057611823082, 0.03467414155602455, 0.007090662140399218, -0.0060283164493739605, -0.00586174288764596, 0.0033618826419115067, 0.025591623038053513, 0.041503433138132095, -0.0424511581659317, 0.018614239990711212, 0.02141021192073822, 0.026607265695929527, 0.08949247002601624, 0.005531993694603443, 0.0021391662303358316, 0.03576163575053215, 0.020812908187508583, 0.02089090831577778, 0.04698627069592476, 0.013292355462908745, 0.02213377133011818, -0.019269540905952454, 0.04949501156806946, -0.008454011753201485, 0.018220441415905952, -0.03252021595835686, -0.05715275928378105, 0.032328732311725616, 0.03642747178673744, -0.02846856787800789, 0.03222038224339485, 0.059009335935115814, 0.03203053027391434, 0.1127813458442688, -0.010429111309349537, 0.03216344863176346, 0.05593647435307503, -0.01763778366148472, 0.053236521780490875, -0.011310837231576443, -0.06764458864927292, -0.07412468641996384, 0.06150765344500542, -0.05128932744264603, 0.0014709862880408764, -0.027477094903588295, -0.0033595457207411528, -0.017340436577796936, -0.007436809595674276, -0.06962832808494568, -0.03884057328104973, -0.03694118931889534, 0.038870371878147125, 0.04752815142273903, 0.027947576716542244, 0.016568485647439957, -0.01713024266064167, 0.08127178251743317, -0.013388335704803467, 0.07042092829942703, -0.008222179487347603, 0.005738737992942333, -0.015461950562894344, -0.0380072146654129, 0.032872702926397324, -0.022962644696235657, -0.029177427291870117, -0.037196625024080276, -0.05648604780435562, 0.004326405469328165, -0.06323302537202835, 0.027653245255351067, 0.01724938675761223, 0.004350131377577782, 0.01857759989798069, 0.05824899673461914, -0.023650111630558968, 0.02252618782222271, -0.03365569934248924, -0.04571399465203285, 0.02174491435289383, 0.021243276074528694, -0.0001344402553513646, 0.05692590773105621, -0.00900344830006361, -0.03318624943494797, 0.0311262346804142, 0.023765770718455315, -0.0715034231543541, 0.03880450874567032, -0.024263985455036163, 0.05780591443181038, -0.0057508982717990875, -0.050827756524086, 0.05266597121953964, 0.04386692866683006, -0.016230175271630287, -0.06548001617193222, -0.029892578721046448, 0.04033610224723816, -0.009061879478394985, 0.04231899231672287, -0.03836354240775108, -0.0331619493663311, 0.04278936609625816, -0.01297747902572155, -0.02406979165971279, 0.05379639193415642, -0.046796299517154694, -0.008361468091607094, -0.02695300243794918, 0.03534500300884247, -0.0438176691532135, 0.005472574848681688, -0.07350003719329834, -0.051412131637334824, 0.024961814284324646, 0.017292141914367676, -0.0035859961062669754, -0.010578347370028496, 0.006479309406131506, 0.01662106066942215, 0.0034651379100978374, 0.030228368937969208, -0.0423395037651062, 0.04399395361542702, 0.003322033444419503, -0.06533803045749664, 0.032485540956258774, 0.027013206854462624, -0.039914898574352264, 0.03515639901161194, 0.04155019298195839, -0.045027464628219604, 0.03690366819500923, -0.01806906796991825, -0.000985948950983584, -0.002188045997172594, 0.0024448286276310682, 0.061084114015102386, -0.046669892966747284, -0.029562845826148987, -0.012353203259408474, 0.0028285838197916746, -0.0674678161740303, -0.02346009947359562, -0.007768112234771252, -0.004159999080002308, -0.005804507527500391, 0.017316624522209167, -0.004410285037010908, 0.02062412165105343, -0.06355676800012589, 0.04392588511109352, 0.06804625689983368, -0.0075355637818574905, 0.022476833313703537, 0.011504421010613441, 0.03113541379570961, -0.011862150393426418, -0.011222073808312416, -0.061623040586709976, 0.018946880474686623, -0.031092312186956406, -0.06310289353132248, -0.03238565847277641, 0.006159695331007242, -0.08620163053274155, 0.05289749056100845, 0.02317197248339653, -0.040815651416778564, 0.04311361908912659, -0.053093381226062775, 0.027517244219779968, 0.003134267870336771, -0.031037434935569763, -0.026140186935663223, 0.02748139575123787, 0.0004282570444047451, -0.04740709066390991, -0.007809133734554052, 0.04577939212322235, -0.009617495350539684, -0.03942561149597168, -0.04798828810453415, -0.022892706096172333, 0.04529678821563721, 0.004341411869972944, -0.07724924385547638, -0.056308113038539886, -0.035460811108350754, 0.028458813205361366, -0.017606565728783607, 0.03051750920712948, 0.030675314366817474, -0.00027369227609597147, -0.003573582973331213, 0.0033012067433446646, -0.01758555881679058, 0.011642271652817726, 0.03439565747976303, 0.021054305136203766, -0.05836743116378784, 0.011160509660840034, 0.00777233624830842, 0.04445662349462509, 0.09299935400485992, 0.012621857225894928, -0.030684392899274826, 0.035627882927656174, -0.04120933264493942, -0.025366777554154396, -0.009245216846466064, -0.010682392865419388, -0.017441101372241974, -0.004589487332850695, 0.016397980973124504, 0.014643684029579163, 0.004007176961749792, 0.024403778836131096, -0.01752365194261074, -0.009180057793855667, 0.02601686120033264, 0.0015017898986116052, -0.027945633977651596, 0.006515699904412031, 0.005162603687494993, 0.011866430751979351, 0.025399314239621162, 0.012636544182896614, 0.01783802919089794, -0.024617420509457588, 0.0020709733944386244, -0.049997180700302124, 0.005024295765906572, 0.029455380514264107, -0.0406019389629364, 0.06121357902884483, 0.005113930441439152, 0.010374639183282852, 0.06218986585736275, -0.03346790745854378, -0.03688930720090866, 0.015059912577271461, 0.05445307493209839, 0.030059058219194412, -0.003900895593687892, -0.011408679187297821, -0.04260462895035744, 0.004492260981351137, -0.012775863520801067, 0.019485140219330788, 0.037191350013017654, 0.014629937708377838, 0.005969291087239981, 0.04431818798184395, -0.04176042601466179, -0.08061176538467407, -0.008890580385923386, -0.06174933910369873, -0.06524065136909485, 0.056519459933042526, -0.04852578043937683, 0.03491652384400368, 0.0470116063952446, 0.053355686366558075, 0.04338906332850456, 0.00849869754165411, -0.051844675093889236, 0.010046988725662231, 0.030706411227583885, -0.028682999312877655, 0.028578773140907288, -0.03802838549017906, -0.02056455798447132, -0.04154912382364273, 0.010231444612145424, 0.04035891592502594, 0.0028592124581336975, -0.0008551071514375508, -0.018418926745653152, 0.018719078972935677, 0.017402837052941322, 0.022949716076254845, 0.01092042401432991, 0.02234032191336155, -0.01077085267752409, -0.0005584661848843098, 0.0643787831068039, -0.05747397243976593, -0.03708357736468315, -0.003538983641192317, -0.006259056739509106, 0.0072209397330880165, -0.04809406027197838, -0.0523591972887516, 0.002865465125069022, 0.055383987724781036, 0.0709422379732132, -0.006322077009826899, 0.026012681424617767, 0.006904346868395805, 0.0035694956313818693, 0.03346685320138931, 0.07478249818086624, -0.0742158591747284, 0.03157970309257507, 0.05528940260410309, 0.023479511961340904, -0.019949451088905334, -0.0048270937986671925, -0.02498817816376686, 0.0009486031485721469, 0.006840333808213472, 0.009958716109395027, 0.048573337495326996, -0.05599918216466904, 0.038441143929958344, -0.008495902642607689, 0.0378057025372982, 0.08054323494434357, -0.046694181859493256, 0.08782581984996796, -0.04994763433933258, 0.0603463351726532, -0.009769465774297714, 0.01125557254999876, 0.027858668938279152, -0.029428550973534584, -0.08876895904541016, 0.0224190391600132, -0.012427903711795807, -0.007149459328502417, 0.05533905327320099, 0.042767804116010666, -0.07066163420677185, -0.005934316664934158, 0.03946637362241745, 0.0044650244526565075, 0.014605498872697353, 0.016815099865198135, 0.017000433057546616, -0.03332652151584625, -0.07574423402547836, 0.016110826283693314, 0.0014538966352120042, -0.005689573474228382, -0.045123908668756485, -0.07796798646450043, 0.01907169446349144, -0.0980181097984314, -0.02945913001894951, 0.05788196250796318, -0.03481519594788551, -0.015126406215131283, -0.026012979447841644, -0.008422449231147766, -0.02090981975197792, -0.026161517947912216, 0.012248639948666096, -0.06894268095493317, -0.04562279209494591, 0.03628096729516983, -0.033963438123464584, 0.02297787554562092, -0.07267092168331146, -0.04001200199127197, -0.005300966557115316, -0.003380622947588563, -0.027599282562732697, -0.009670568630099297, -0.055202800780534744, -0.04007819667458534, -0.03903434798121452, -0.003923328127712011, 0.006469018757343292, -0.02709478698670864, 0.01074035745114088, -0.01364707201719284, 0.012124949134886265, 0.014406604692339897, 0.00737619586288929, -0.012768610380589962, -0.0006213095039129257, -0.01980811357498169, 0.021240754052996635, -0.04077695310115814, 0.008548551239073277, 0.041596267372369766, 0.006691633258014917, 0.008316010236740112, 0.016587719321250916, 0.03794074058532715, 0.0016210851026698947, -0.02234969660639763, 0.003924570046365261, 0.037014469504356384, 0.021055232733488083, -0.010205085389316082, 0.027641581371426582, 0.014581145718693733, -0.012051669880747795, 0.01654701866209507, 0.022629428654909134, -0.024286337196826935, -0.01967090740799904, 0.06875962764024734, 0.034203868359327316, -0.03998895362019539, 0.004464555531740189, 0.037745825946331024, 0.020925411954522133, 0.07059486210346222, 0.05931277945637703, 0.028948312625288963, 0.0063013010658323765, -0.016766641288995743, -0.05138201266527176, 0.053878121078014374, 0.02237834222614765, 0.038488417863845825, -0.07182321697473526, -0.04545443505048752, -0.02534041926264763, -0.05310868099331856, 0.03019683249294758, 0.012758997268974781, 0.04669170081615448, -0.05568523332476616, -0.008993434719741344, -0.001838738564401865, -0.0524800643324852, -0.027905240654945374, -0.03313456103205681, 0.036674100905656815, -0.003917120862752199, 0.015099745243787766, 0.03715704381465912, -0.04455940052866936, -0.0018344683339819312, -0.006720967125147581, -0.004875700455158949, 0.042710039764642715, 0.05887087062001228, 0.03297637403011322, -0.002950313501060009, -0.009570254012942314, -0.017885472625494003, 0.046372029930353165, -0.031209614127874374, 0.0319964699447155, 0.021560650318861008, -0.018250221386551857, 0.044600337743759155, -0.030924998223781586, 0.04975965991616249, 0.012707271613180637, 0.010868368670344353, 0.040218643844127655, -0.034645531326532364, -0.12834198772907257, 0.04685278981924057, -0.0001522332604508847, 0.063716821372509, 0.011526520363986492, -0.03407025709748268, -0.03367200866341591, 0.009666607715189457, -0.06509288400411606, 0.02276274375617504, 0.08009234070777893, 0.05789121985435486, 0.007302460260689259, 0.03010183945298195, -0.019618963822722435, -0.014740245416760445, -0.030834782868623734, -0.004184310790151358, -0.023746369406580925, -0.04520827531814575, 0.013776568695902824, -0.012978148646652699, -0.008883323520421982, 0.0031132653821259737, -0.006079478655010462, 0.010680656880140305, 0.018264224752783775, 0.08510338515043259, -0.055610399693250656, 0.018588528037071228, 0.022441647946834564, -0.002492906991392374, -0.001925069373100996, 0.0024374963250011206, 0.007515359204262495, -0.0068062045611441135, 0.016498573124408722, -0.007894386537373066, -0.004070919938385487, 0.059044092893600464, -0.024036956951022148, 0.07671704143285751, 0.07005497813224792, 0.004682318307459354, -0.06184864044189453, 0.01572563126683235, 0.02353549376130104, 0.08477521687746048, 0.008970214053988457, -0.01116690319031477, -0.0374283567070961, -0.03844430297613144, -0.037596169859170914, -0.03211648017168045, -0.007510134018957615, 0.05262881517410278, 0.020779453217983246, 0.030721919611096382, -0.06776294857263565, 0.013642575591802597, -0.057168882340192795, -0.0064206356182694435, 0.0038361919578164816, 0.025776859372854233, 0.028643103316426277, 0.005548184271901846, -0.01762295886874199, 0.02177066169679165, -0.012063758447766304, -0.00897702481597662, -0.04598512127995491, 0.030261527746915817, 0.00005136599429533817, 0.01302680466324091, -0.0598505362868309, 0.03663124516606331, -0.009190943092107773, -0.012838208116590977, -0.003552375128492713, 0.049763988703489304, -0.026218513026833534, -0.06675252318382263, -0.007431610953062773, -0.09104582667350769, -0.024005666375160217, -0.0033554211258888245, 0.016588710248470306, 0.012007755227386951, -0.009539268910884857, -0.013611474074423313, 0.0011613506358116865, 0.021994300186634064, 0.014370701275765896, -0.050429489463567734, -0.058497827500104904, 0.04334934055805206, -0.029262730851769447, 0.0007814515847712755, -0.013093387708067894, 0.04853026196360588, -0.04699218273162842, -0.035250600427389145, 0.010357853956520557, -0.04484190046787262, -0.039274293929338455, -0.03551342710852623, 0.023219052702188492, 0.028529882431030273, 0.009626480750739574, 0.0015369676984846592, 0.027338597923517227, 0.010052324272692204, 0.009526475332677364, -0.020575618371367455, 0.0018317814683541656, -0.08195144683122635, -0.005821845959872007, 0.020034275949001312, 0.007163933478295803, 0.013899006880819798, -0.053677722811698914, 0.03935405611991882, 0.025507701560854912, -0.029928889125585556, -0.02575785480439663, -0.038494616746902466, 0.03190786391496658, 0.0007399333990179002, 0.045957352966070175, -0.03816070407629013, 0.022653361782431602, -0.02318238466978073, 0.02264903485774994, 0.022336358204483986, 0.035661499947309494, -0.006175072863698006, 0.004798054229468107, 0.013606092892587185, -0.015227330848574638, 0.07801537215709686, 0.012321661226451397, -0.00972289964556694, 0.008029933087527752, 0.02425345778465271, -0.06758386641740799, -0.018127446994185448, 0.021323135122656822, 0.035154812037944794, 0.015532182529568672, -0.029308853670954704, 0.008374744094908237, -0.07073262333869934, -0.010176436975598335, 0.002425969112664461, -0.08813745528459549, 0.027357934042811394, -0.019913218915462494, 0.00180574762634933, -0.011608568951487541, -0.014196089468896389, 0.05016814544796944, -0.011458797380328178, -0.0337897352874279, -0.07555127888917923, -0.016636574640870094, -0.027061376720666885, -0.03567446768283844, -0.020904673263430595, -0.02031007595360279, -0.03943731635808945, 0.03329124301671982, -0.03979722782969475, -0.006500364746898413, 0.05423879623413086, -0.010223806835711002, 0.06162474304437637, 0.052305083721876144, -0.035436857491731644, 0.03269882872700691, 0.008173995651304722, 0.0180060938000679, -0.009469689801335335, -0.001230225432664156, -0.040364015847444534, 0.0380474254488945, -0.04599568992853165, -0.06587929278612137, -0.011030307039618492, -0.013556309975683689, 0.000579375890083611 ]
<p>Although I have informed myself in string theory through reading books and watching videos, I do not know or understand what superstrings are made of. History has definitely shown us that when we think something is fundemental, there is always something smaller.</p> <p>What are superstrings made of? Can we go smaller than strings?</p>
g24
[ 0.050006162375211716, 0.09232049435377121, -0.0038459652569144964, -0.039280638098716736, -0.012659297324717045, 0.03366737812757492, -0.02550659142434597, -0.019553707912564278, 0.0350162498652935, -0.08538264781236649, -0.05474855378270149, 0.003850032342597842, 0.03986496850848198, -0.025494860485196114, 0.03001655451953411, -0.022938016802072525, -0.03892495483160019, -0.0061292084865272045, 0.0005181132582947612, -0.02334270067512989, 0.04535602033138275, 0.006441136356443167, 0.034383658319711685, 0.00478509021922946, -0.050348736345767975, 0.043960992246866226, -0.058422818779945374, 0.00790763832628727, 0.042908284813165665, -0.038566429167985916, -0.02418225258588791, 0.011395313777029514, 0.017747074365615845, 0.022539231926202774, 0.05677146464586258, -0.05201398953795433, -0.012330922298133373, 0.005906508304178715, 0.04262210801243782, -0.0013475394807755947, -0.03826142102479935, -0.026006119325757027, 0.017976807430386543, -0.05730200558900833, -0.04000294208526611, -0.029427476227283478, 0.018732277676463127, -0.0292869471013546, 0.03472103551030159, -0.03757443279027939, -0.005734887905418873, 0.011184663511812687, 0.012234440073370934, 0.01477243471890688, -0.02993173524737358, 0.0052295890636742115, 0.039044592529535294, 0.010034061037003994, 0.05557834357023239, 0.009812611155211926, -0.02653159387409687, 0.008066457696259022, -0.005287529900670052, 0.05890730395913124, 0.022048672661185265, 0.010453945025801659, 0.026015425100922585, 0.007961245253682137, 0.0830482542514801, 0.06678851693868637, -0.001700468361377716, 0.015897635370492935, 0.006978103891015053, -0.017034465447068214, -0.0290176160633564, 0.04531969502568245, -0.01783236488699913, 0.0328858345746994, -0.02497420832514763, 0.028667155653238297, 0.058012597262859344, -0.06933962553739548, -0.034179605543613434, -0.04434141889214516, 0.005957502406090498, -0.028856106102466583, -0.023106500506401062, 0.011434394866228104, 0.007193571422249079, 0.07052047550678253, 0.017270144075155258, 0.004159474745392799, 0.01870880462229252, 0.006829412654042244, 0.016517851501703262, -0.022229712456464767, 0.012508709914982319, 0.034969769418239594, -0.040593501180410385, -0.09680362045764923, 0.0177574772387743, 0.0271463505923748, 0.01274073962122202, -0.016638323664665222, 0.0470627136528492, 0.02518763579428196, -0.007897487841546535, -0.04268224909901619, 0.009438018314540386, -0.011433162726461887, -0.01061751414090395, 0.026991361752152443, -0.05406929552555084, -0.028632286936044693, -0.05019880458712578, 0.05074335262179375, 0.023249059915542603, 0.012703577056527138, 0.05513918399810791, -0.0005801484221592546, -0.035700906068086624, -0.04761732369661331, 0.08412796258926392, 0.004032101947814226, -0.037075623869895935, -0.025156904011964798, 0.011348606087267399, 0.019823772832751274, -0.0024144561029970646, 0.002169298008084297, -0.007488315925002098, -0.012455548159778118, -0.019052710384130478, -0.020814159885048866, 0.051071297377347946, 0.07320510596036911, -0.0245455801486969, 0.005131762940436602, 0.03565472364425659, -0.023624738678336143, 0.031983714550733566, 0.004444085992872715, 0.018717575818300247, 0.00971179362386465, 0.009389610029757023, -0.024892648681998253, -0.05445734038949013, 0.01084885559976101, -0.05495518445968628, 0.022325875237584114, 0.05872051417827606, 0.0483856126666069, 0.0038732856046408415, -0.03169255331158638, -0.026063397526741028, -0.0018077975837513804, -0.005396124441176653, -0.0076205250807106495, 0.002292315009981394, -0.009922053664922714, 0.013731245882809162, -0.010595898143947124, -0.035716865211725235, -0.05345165729522705, -0.03341817483305931, 0.03771783038973808, 0.02559567056596279, 0.043054793030023575, -0.017349595203995705, 0.014167016372084618, 0.0023218286223709583, 0.017696883529424667, 0.01950058713555336, 0.0790485218167305, -0.01811090111732483, 0.033238425850868225, 0.025459598749876022, -0.02381674386560917, 0.07724715024232864, 0.053714215755462646, 0.0029203358571976423, -0.03269423916935921, 0.018551340326666832, -0.06407371908426285, 0.016995234414935112, 0.048740603029727936, -0.032022103667259216, 0.007732646074146032, -0.013337818905711174, 0.015659328550100327, -0.03858039900660515, -0.06438083946704865, 0.02281590923666954, 0.00922300759702921, -0.019061123952269554, -0.035360176116228104, -0.024272331967949867, -0.02437162585556507, 0.018406590446829796, 0.01921866647899151, -0.003399549750611186, 0.008699926547706127, -0.020164556801319122, -0.019999342039227486, 0.055857643485069275, 0.040292888879776, -0.04457346349954605, 0.0035820731427520514, -0.001386674353852868, 0.0006833309307694435, 0.008979571051895618, -0.03197872266173363, -0.03589963540434837, 0.012273239903151989, -0.058608755469322205, -0.002850267104804516, -0.038340479135513306, -0.01017704512923956, 0.018545985221862793, 0.0616350993514061, 0.07519639283418655, -0.03956819698214531, 0.03373483568429947, -0.01605592481791973, -0.010982857085764408, 0.021924031898379326, 0.011888619512319565, -0.029622267931699753, 0.0645241066813469, -0.03149404004216194, -0.043093081563711166, -0.055328354239463806, 0.021112944930791855, -0.028993286192417145, 0.011018904857337475, 0.00523257115855813, 0.0175397340208292, -0.06603453308343887, 0.021592777222394943, 0.03342769667506218, 0.04113619029521942, 0.04083358868956566, 0.07220394909381866, 0.018821517005562782, 0.04444317892193794, 0.018886104226112366, 0.0006375404191203415, -0.018466085195541382, 0.0008737181778997183, 0.03491378575563431, 0.00168184086214751, -0.01765263080596924, 0.004171010572463274, 0.028416018933057785, -0.028478475287556648, -0.020554494112730026, 0.023702358826994896, 0.04958881810307503, -0.009964695200324059, -0.05149325728416443, 0.02583303116261959, 0.017702624201774597, 0.019907698035240173, -0.006063008215278387, -0.027541596442461014, -0.03170844539999962, -0.037366997450590134, -0.014313843101263046, -0.032357148826122284, -0.0031787315383553505, -0.004118030890822411, 0.04174984246492386, -0.004394675604999065, -0.04769730567932129, -0.011183963157236576, -0.013728030025959015, -0.00233865762129426, 0.04689576476812363, 0.024675864726305008, -0.016688622534275055, -0.01839362271130085, -0.014744702726602554, -0.023982543498277664, 0.016873590648174286, -0.00031927262898534536, -0.025737058371305466, -0.02308819442987442, -0.03745511546730995, 0.014266841113567352, -0.02500171959400177, -0.029626481235027313, 0.025706060230731964, 0.022818798199295998, -0.05407020077109337, 0.01981731317937374, 0.06805825233459473, -0.010651320219039917, -0.0022675474174320698, -0.052910998463630676, 0.006398885510861874, 0.0010267595062032342, 0.02978966198861599, 0.03333717957139015, 0.014350857585668564, -0.02887588180601597, 0.0364748053252697, -0.03387853503227234, -0.04787275940179825, -0.026847412809729576, -0.01627960056066513, -0.0028912974521517754, 0.053186994045972824, 0.07990714907646179, 0.04692291095852852, -0.019587134942412376, 0.011988983489573002, 0.00543264439329505, 0.02190965972840786, 0.017083078622817993, -0.01768149435520172, -0.057353947311639786, -0.040286894887685776, 0.01816745102405548, 0.020386952906847, 0.013706495054066181, 0.018330838531255722, -0.0886620432138443, -0.02491520531475544, -0.04532722011208534, -0.05921826511621475, -0.0446196049451828, -0.05189857631921768, -0.08026845753192902, 0.008571183308959007, -0.03585601970553398, -0.04098857194185257, -0.019803907722234726, 0.035154033452272415, 0.03424748405814171, -0.047659650444984436, 0.0092342933639884, -0.008571005426347256, -0.028094230219721794, 0.0005385358817875385, -0.00013153802137821913, 0.10015814006328583, -0.00796025525778532, -0.044108010828495026, 0.03450680151581764, -0.01364879310131073, 0.03626608848571777, 0.05585036426782608, 0.0004223992582410574, 0.01104942336678505, 0.005058824550360441, 0.13771402835845947, 0.021027980372309685, 0.048310536891222, 0.04357316344976425, -0.03334999084472656, -0.006793820299208164, -0.012542697601020336, -0.01485575083643198, -0.03330397978425026, 0.008293986320495605, -0.030062686651945114, 0.006372230593115091, -0.0572127103805542, 0.05512390658259392, 0.046888332813978195, 0.0010076806647703052, 0.045359056442976, 0.005869261920452118, -0.0016604438424110413, 0.05136499181389809, -0.035846054553985596, 0.03371086344122887, 0.05569300055503845, 0.004594234749674797, -0.06413500756025314, 0.06033805012702942, 0.08819545060396194, 0.008146692998707294, -0.09290645271539688, -0.025281837210059166, -0.042589180171489716, -0.016366714611649513, -0.026059746742248535, -0.07499151676893234, -0.025320129469037056, 0.022342292591929436, -0.05911047384142876, 0.03513159602880478, -0.08729568123817444, -0.005485151428729296, 0.015375356189906597, 0.026167508214712143, -0.005548012908548117, 0.0012565274955704808, 0.01841098442673683, 0.016431020572781563, 0.035318005830049515, -0.07326900959014893, -0.0673753097653389, 0.007573330774903297, 0.05279366299510002, 0.023114772513508797, -0.01221461035311222, -0.053870052099227905, -0.05248856171965599, 0.07768560945987701, 0.03115166164934635, -0.030135855078697205, -0.07473933696746826, -0.0027705347165465355, 0.02395574562251568, -0.041577551513910294, -0.06652823090553284, 0.04676038399338722, 0.014466837979853153, -0.008507243357598782, 0.035662468522787094, 0.05918020382523537, -0.01589461974799633, -0.016164230182766914, 0.025522476062178612, -0.03158578649163246, 0.01507790107280016, -0.005710072349756956, -0.0035857062321156263, 0.02870691381394863, 0.002554657170549035, 0.0363091342151165, -0.00466078519821167, 0.017776574939489365, 0.006566879339516163, 0.019187340512871742, -0.01542632281780243, -0.005296393763273954, 0.036108486354351044, -0.021984459832310677, -0.008001810871064663, 0.012273028492927551, 0.04269064962863922, -0.009573581628501415, -0.008177266456186771, -0.03906222805380821, 0.03966769948601723, -0.010245261713862419, 0.01938362419605255, -0.08330752700567245, 0.04292306303977966, -0.03630927950143814, -0.0825735554099083, -0.03702772781252861, 0.007461237721145153, -0.07351330667734146, -0.002976716961711645, 0.023927997797727585, -0.006415782030671835, -0.003145769005641341, -0.025419749319553375, 0.032293274998664856, 0.05222198739647865, 0.06071474775671959, 0.0034875599667429924, 0.0005944520817138255, -0.037255581468343735, 0.024693012237548828, 0.009583559818565845, -0.03947897627949715, -0.018176259472966194, -0.018076837062835693, -0.07549668848514557, 0.016563089564442635, -0.04296845570206642, -0.06320978701114655, -0.025705106556415558, 0.0036494573578238487, 0.008523033000528812, -0.008025690913200378, 0.008659141138195992, 0.00833168812096119, -0.036127980798482895, 0.012369669042527676, 0.0018352295737713575, -0.020704207941889763, 0.027551455423235893, -0.027396900579333305, -0.04430169612169266, -0.0747111439704895, 0.0023121521808207035, 0.06500118970870972, -0.03948940709233284, -0.06337810307741165, -0.01968691311776638, 0.01636119745671749, -0.03401026874780655, 0.014488644897937775, -0.02435060776770115, -0.043697237968444824, 0.056294750422239304, 0.00847900565713644, 0.056866634637117386, 0.040569763630628586, 0.044182129204273224, 0.05316275730729103, -0.013454449363052845, -0.020497098565101624, 0.008978327736258507, -0.022194484248757362, 0.03292999416589737, -0.07174563407897949, -0.007795306388288736, 0.051441408693790436, -0.03170716017484665, 0.0017949821194633842, -0.0008276827866211534, 0.048148661851882935, 0.043746210634708405, -0.05014804005622864, 0.02708716318011284, 0.0507601723074913, -0.04212932661175728, 0.036400940269231796, 0.03788876160979271, -0.025665076449513435, 0.005227218382060528, 0.049176182597875595, -0.013713410124182701, 0.07017340511083603, 0.0029157507233321667, 0.027687788009643555, -0.003308941377326846, 0.02590756304562092, 0.026653200387954712, 0.010379013605415821, -0.02805248275399208, -0.018210740759968758, 0.0007270331843756139, -0.03246054798364639, 0.013200926594436169, -0.007992117665708065, 0.01510106772184372, 0.0305674709379673, -0.023188048973679543, 0.010512005537748337, 0.02397530898451805, 0.05114509537816048, -0.0035134772770106792, -0.040751148015260696, 0.043313074856996536, -0.013599489815533161, 0.03537625074386597, 0.016324128955602646, 0.08826393634080887, -0.02434772439301014, -0.010676764883100986, 0.031168662011623383, -0.000588054012041539, 0.035363685339689255, -0.0004289235803298652, -0.07164925336837769, -0.03766828030347824, 0.006031353957951069, -0.04592293128371239, 0.010684657841920853, -0.05416587367653847, 0.06809648126363754, 0.036605354398489, -0.022872453555464745, 0.051636703312397, -0.02641230821609497, 0.019500790163874626, -0.031151942908763885, -0.029202936217188835, -0.012703998945653439, -0.07636258751153946, 0.0026585960295051336, -0.04619409888982773, 0.032565560191869736, 0.04212533310055733, 0.02123493328690529, -0.04955083876848221, -0.028051860630512238, 0.03047354519367218, -0.027425669133663177, -0.04681409150362015, 0.050710760056972504, 0.050798140466213226, 0.00532300490885973, 0.07077044248580933, -0.0008602409507147968, 0.04956222325563431, -0.0037020279560238123, -0.036759376525878906, -0.006065623834729195, 0.021396856755018234, -0.009352704510092735, 0.025436704978346825, -0.03560829535126686, 0.011524682864546776, 0.09128720313310623, -0.006582019384950399, -0.013292670249938965, 0.05192769318819046, 0.07363041490316391, 0.035883087664842606, 0.01954512856900692, 0.031043298542499542, 0.0195783544331789, 0.025445982813835144, -0.04290517047047615, 0.01839105784893036, -0.005900432821363211, -0.05976923182606697, -0.005908537656068802, -0.03244072571396828, -0.026131074875593185, -0.011577777564525604, 0.04810471832752228, -0.039002884179353714, -0.0296980869024992, 0.0019389952067285776, -0.034860558807849884, 0.004848490934818983, 0.0077230376191437244, 0.07401464879512787, 0.00013709356426261365, -0.011926135048270226, -0.04517405852675438, -0.021491440013051033, 0.05087467283010483, 0.08338098973035812, -0.04597271606326103, 0.06419537961483002, -0.04004308953881264, 0.046116456389427185, -0.03662469983100891, -0.008943255990743637, 0.007482596207410097, -0.019042909145355225, -0.012976293452084064, -0.03882124274969101, 0.000586631940677762, 0.04531241953372955, 0.02897251583635807, -0.030734490603208542, -0.050177931785583496, -0.029958480969071388, 0.025287386029958725, 0.011309991590678692, 0.0037448694929480553, -0.0012105919886380434, -0.010313541628420353, -0.08576713502407074, -0.05064133554697037, -0.029592500999569893, 0.01883748359978199, -0.03150817006826401, -0.02536812797188759, 0.035671886056661606, -0.001661458401940763, -0.0393836684525013, -0.01197564136236906, 0.05802164226770401, 0.013635190203785896, -0.04024610295891762, -0.03796305134892464, -0.019317694008350372, -0.010586612857878208, -0.02153448946774006, -0.008414310403168201, -0.04490925371646881, 0.007870500907301903, -0.009461616165935993, -0.0262432973831892, 0.013512218371033669, 0.01642325520515442, 0.02448558434844017, 0.016391634941101074, 0.06322140991687775, 0.026207808405160904, -0.018737953156232834, 0.011446936056017876, 0.004911178257316351, -0.03514834865927696, -0.033602066338062286, -0.022380240261554718, -0.05560111999511719, 0.055290643125772476, -0.019627371802926064, -0.012209164910018444, -0.030985942110419273, -0.0020235867705196142, -0.04327559471130371, -0.06520185619592667, 0.020751003175973892, 0.004783642943948507, -0.00626217108219862, -0.025530874729156494, -0.023580046370625496, 0.04276333376765251, 0.012360597960650921, 0.029397115111351013, 0.0005588806816376746, -0.02344880998134613, 0.0103534497320652, -0.1223045215010643, -0.040328364819288254, 0.00299825775437057, -0.026917874813079834, 0.03287385404109955, 0.013493887148797512, 0.07019661366939545, -0.02446666732430458, 0.019719991832971573, 0.01718655228614807, -0.022458486258983612, -0.02018902823328972, 0.026200756430625916, 0.03187904134392738, 0.059669818729162216, -0.005334164015948772, -0.06385698169469833, -0.00324359443038702, 0.04361971467733383, -0.036102909594774246, -0.04791157692670822, 0.026158548891544342, -0.09970123320817947, 0.01880859024822712, 0.045616284012794495, -0.026745272800326347, -0.010617153719067574, 0.007702993229031563, 0.010423771105706692, -0.035356711596250534, 0.023545797914266586, -0.01242954470217228, 0.031739383935928345, -0.002033073455095291, -0.044012416154146194, 0.033548809587955475, -0.06022168695926666, -0.01944386214017868, -0.0315779373049736, 0.03219512477517128, -0.012435268610715866, -0.04870811849832535, 0.012412658892571926, 0.011567546986043453, 0.08400538563728333, 0.08296968787908554, 0.018457237631082535, -0.0018381327390670776, -0.03028232976794243, 0.028706414625048637, 0.016249632462859154, 0.017658600583672523, 0.004987187683582306, 0.04275360703468323, 0.0479845255613327, -0.005749584175646305, -0.0002826161216944456, -0.03708823025226593, 0.02145202085375786, 0.009443255141377449 ]
<p>2+1D lattice gauge theory can emerge in a spin system through fractionalization. Usually if the gauge structure is broken down to $\mathbb{Z}_N$, it is believed that the fractionalized spinons are deconfined. However in general, $\mathbb{Z}_N$ gauge theory also have a confined phase. The question is how to determine if the discrete emergent gauge theory is really deconfined or not?</p> <p>For example, I am considering a $\mathbb{Z}_3$ gauge-Higgs model defined on the Kagome lattice with the Hamiltonian $H=J\sum_{\langle i j\rangle}\cos(\theta_i-\theta_j-A_{ij})$, where $\theta_i=0,\pm2\pi/3$ is the matter field and $A_{ij}=0,\pm2\pi/3$ is the gauge field. If the matter field is in a ferromagnetic phase, then I can understand that the gauge field will be Higgs out. But the matter field here is a Kagome antiferromagnet, which is strongly frustrated and may not order at low temperature. So in this case, I would suspect that the effective $\mathbb{Z}_3$ gauge theory will be driven into a confined phase. Is my conjecture right? How to prove or disprove that?</p> <p>Thanks in advance.</p>
g1594
[ -0.007519298233091831, -0.008325915783643723, 0.028106000274419785, 0.04766306281089783, 0.010959293693304062, -0.023978639394044876, 0.025742607191205025, 0.04626091569662094, 0.007754831109195948, -0.04572029039263725, -0.020642254501581192, 0.03237485513091087, -0.019926754757761955, -0.009781645610928535, 0.018670404329895973, 0.011344855651259422, 0.02208903431892395, -0.009319019503891468, 0.0031738069374114275, -0.0432278998196125, 0.029642662033438683, 0.04395543038845062, 0.02980513498187065, -0.054033879190683365, 0.04303007200360298, 0.0007987923454493284, 0.04216074198484421, -0.012105979025363922, -0.012537327595055103, 0.012054081074893475, -0.016651445999741554, -0.03285631164908409, 0.010068584233522415, -0.03220600634813309, 0.0004198507231194526, -0.023222940042614937, 0.07743460685014725, 0.008922792039811611, -0.0283906701952219, -0.014096178114414215, -0.01147395744919777, -0.05251209810376167, 0.02058248221874237, -0.023999277502298355, -0.039109643548727036, 0.01622588187456131, -0.00934397242963314, 0.017602287232875824, -0.011143648996949196, 0.10032059997320175, 0.026490898802876472, 0.020321916788816452, 0.013094509951770306, -0.003161475993692875, -0.034817297011613846, 0.0844457745552063, -0.03356432914733887, 0.0166916623711586, 0.06915529072284698, -0.041382499039173126, -0.010632297955453396, 0.04113245755434036, -0.002460217336192727, -0.031518034636974335, 0.03844071179628372, 0.0023873234167695045, -0.09590638428926468, 0.009820982813835144, 0.04001251608133316, -0.02392529882490635, -0.04094735160470009, -0.07196486741304398, -0.01654636301100254, -0.030161239206790924, -0.03512970730662346, 0.03494543209671974, -0.037028536200523376, -0.060680415481328964, -0.047383178025484085, 0.0066302744671702385, -0.05599382519721985, -0.012490598484873772, 0.017040466889739037, -0.023525051772594452, 0.028798827901482582, -0.010658166371285915, -0.021801920607686043, -0.06894094496965408, 0.03690240532159805, 0.026079334318637848, 0.003987259231507778, -0.00679710041731596, 0.0068968809209764, 0.017783237621188164, 0.011492004618048668, 0.04675998166203499, 0.01248980313539505, -0.015001512132585049, 0.015093824826180935, -0.023826440796256065, -0.028654271736741066, -0.001182446489110589, -0.0018339669331908226, -0.0680101215839386, -0.006052469369024038, -0.019093584269285202, 0.06510280072689056, -0.008649271912872791, 0.008055882528424263, 0.02737300470471382, 0.02065126970410347, 0.07672526687383652, -0.09181302040815353, 0.025978103280067444, -0.032841458916664124, 0.06558097898960114, 0.019460847601294518, 0.010931855998933315, -0.0029209463391453028, -0.09026815742254257, 0.036909326910972595, 0.022223662585020065, 0.04831868037581444, -0.005990513134747744, -0.016529010608792305, 0.06383638828992844, 0.007211113348603249, -0.022372007369995117, -0.013707194477319717, -0.032703522592782974, -0.024759594351053238, 0.008350081741809845, 0.04458581656217575, -0.012255244888365269, -0.027123793959617615, -0.007292963098734617, 0.02670588716864586, -0.022985372692346573, -0.01098333764821291, -0.004572682548314333, -0.009548651985824108, -0.06603968888521194, 0.003023398807272315, -0.031432896852493286, 0.03267766535282135, -0.015499125234782696, -0.0038142905104905367, 0.024521250277757645, 0.008637755177915096, 0.04130125045776367, -0.007433430291712284, 0.10033120959997177, 0.016585838049650192, -0.06568610668182373, 0.02025166153907776, 0.022359570488333702, 0.06327361613512039, -0.0381719209253788, 0.012858747504651546, -0.04213525727391243, 0.04631009325385094, -0.030785951763391495, 0.044037576764822006, 0.04899150878190994, -0.005131583195179701, -0.025024624541401863, -0.014336289837956429, -0.00434217369183898, -0.0037683623377233744, -0.076178178191185, -0.016056673601269722, 0.010408757254481316, -0.007543446030467749, 0.02331525646150112, 0.02682344801723957, 0.11893609166145325, -0.047713059931993484, -0.019928431138396263, 0.036446668207645416, -0.03508342429995537, 0.06674293428659439, 0.03758607804775238, -0.009957395493984222, 0.015547331422567368, -0.04924759641289711, 0.008057206869125366, 0.07080968469381332, 0.028019092977046967, 0.06165795028209686, -0.031632307916879654, 0.03467278927564621, 0.008278610184788704, -0.002930006245151162, -0.0002159345749532804, 0.027089497074484825, -0.03526308760046959, 0.004250697325915098, -0.0764075368642807, 0.0013486345997080207, -0.04216651991009712, 0.027614891529083252, 0.02483421005308628, 0.010768703185021877, -0.06179608777165413, 0.025931907817721367, 0.007496051024645567, -0.04265086352825165, 0.004885673522949219, 0.02460119128227234, 0.009670347906649113, -0.017396269366145134, -0.06804395467042923, -0.06955888122320175, 0.016293736174702644, -0.01921004056930542, -0.02093031071126461, 0.023256246000528336, 0.030605383217334747, 0.01234014518558979, 0.015123585239052773, -0.0235480647534132, 0.04638849198818207, 0.041157882660627365, 0.0483039990067482, -0.01919815130531788, 0.0039655244909226894, -0.018127495422959328, 0.0238935723900795, -0.0336051881313324, 0.019676484167575836, -0.03520698472857475, -0.0601501390337944, -0.0367487333714962, -0.06682358682155609, 0.04554160311818123, -0.015396058559417725, -0.07023917883634567, -0.014553442597389221, 0.035771653056144714, -0.033884041011333466, 0.04454328864812851, -0.012198888696730137, -0.002711597131565213, -0.009614828042685986, 0.05651724711060524, -0.015057542361319065, 0.028257792815566063, 0.04055037721991539, -0.027941280975937843, 0.025257058441638947, 0.03136005997657776, -0.010002289898693562, -0.043630361557006836, -0.02567240223288536, -0.03826584666967392, -0.024086762219667435, 0.059096116572618484, 0.031382400542497635, -0.07444775849580765, -0.0589536614716053, 0.04254760593175888, -0.028873847797513008, 0.01293262094259262, 0.04225381836295128, 0.023900320753455162, 0.048901695758104324, 0.0547894723713398, 0.00034411673550494015, -0.03788032755255699, -0.006690593436360359, 0.012743962928652763, 0.02190881408751011, -0.04666581377387047, -0.05042359605431557, 0.052789296954870224, -0.0351245179772377, -0.007772610988467932, -0.009892284870147705, 0.06430187076330185, -0.018727216869592667, -0.04991939663887024, -0.005404448136687279, -0.03403129801154137, 0.016157051548361778, -0.008465656079351902, -0.046531353145837784, -0.03933962807059288, -0.0026539117097854614, -0.0007695112144574523, 0.021943392232060432, 0.0603446401655674, 0.07352643460035324, 0.03310653567314148, 0.018837150186300278, -0.006583849899470806, -0.009749524295330048, -0.026192663237452507, 0.0463649220764637, 0.017923856154084206, 0.013899273239076138, 0.03189491480588913, -0.020404662936925888, 0.008862940594553947, -0.007366332225501537, 0.029735194519162178, 0.003226696979254484, -0.01912234164774418, 0.053847990930080414, 0.002570340409874916, -0.07313266396522522, -0.06497281789779663, 0.06948862224817276, 0.017436401918530464, -0.0211788360029459, -0.017036765813827515, -0.03222782909870148, 0.0100813964381814, 0.03766825422644615, 0.0408015102148056, -0.008570927195250988, -0.02033849246799946, 0.030507683753967285, 0.054169345647096634, -0.021140623837709427, 0.003224184736609459, 0.008869960904121399, -0.05550163984298706, 0.01976104825735092, -0.02235589362680912, 0.009625604376196861, 0.02391604706645012, -0.05202420428395271, -0.06602467596530914, -0.04499208182096481, -0.030706528574228287, 0.008622066117823124, -0.04117682948708534, 0.034084636718034744, 0.030973762273788452, 0.0313410609960556, -0.043728332966566086, -0.020036378875374794, -0.008253336884081364, 0.004293336533010006, 0.003604502184316516, -0.04519833251833916, -0.042350511997938156, -0.06546621024608612, 0.024584248661994934, 0.0044378237798810005, 0.015893815085291862, -0.05320645496249199, 0.012081002816557884, -0.03065013326704502, -0.04836084321141243, -0.0010872409911826253, 0.003612942062318325, 0.056370314210653305, 0.01609874702990055, -0.03583895415067673, 0.044964730739593506, -0.014232758432626724, 0.029546083882451057, -0.06074981391429901, -0.013146345503628254, -0.00420210137963295, 0.024979477748274803, 0.047366201877593994, 0.012412247247993946, -0.006073320284485817, 0.006300556939095259, -0.014527151361107826, 0.0021315892226994038, 0.023889444768428802, 0.050883594900369644, -0.05686219036579132, -0.057140037417411804, -0.05760272592306137, -0.002176679437980056, 0.016349956393241882, -0.05118695646524429, 0.036917731165885925, 0.021445831283926964, 0.004456811584532261, -0.04919273778796196, 0.019471323117613792, 0.008051196113228798, 0.027627717703580856, -0.02641206607222557, -0.021383246406912804, -0.08400939404964447, -0.02403213270008564, -0.015724649652838707, 0.023386504501104355, -0.04519002512097359, 0.018683023750782013, -0.0033451539929956198, 0.026067567989230156, -0.007952472195029259, -0.01908150501549244, 0.02320309728384018, 0.01904160901904106, -0.05425377935171127, -0.027713624760508537, 0.026203976944088936, -0.06583528220653534, -0.01768769696354866, -0.012311390601098537, 0.018944982439279556, 0.004012477584183216, -0.01986008696258068, 0.021668758243322372, -0.038407742977142334, -0.009862354956567287, -0.0006669405265711248, -0.1129242405295372, 0.04469618946313858, -0.03231276944279671, 0.021579967811703682, 0.029178958386182785, -0.002229843521490693, 0.029380375519394875, 0.023120921105146408, -0.03738599643111229, 0.01628626137971878, 0.0430600568652153, -0.016129635274410248, 0.0031272696796804667, -0.04487408325076103, 0.0025230201426893473, 0.020254086703062057, 0.009947187267243862, -0.016138680279254913, 0.025321954861283302, -0.08345571160316467, -0.019503263756632805, -0.04296422377228737, 0.0706866979598999, 0.011616867035627365, -0.0003564594080671668, 0.016637399792671204, 0.0018715732730925083, 0.025506630539894104, 0.016915027052164078, 0.0063952854834496975, 0.0156263317912817, -0.027832239866256714, -0.06496939808130264, 0.03493943065404892, -0.035624317824840546, 0.02099609561264515, 0.015613434836268425, -0.02351730316877365, 0.02341373823583126, 0.06285038590431213, 0.02044462040066719, -0.09494014829397202, 0.06000185385346413, -0.024957677349448204, 0.014607908204197884, -0.014718236401677132, -0.04190220683813095, -0.006627646740525961, 0.03268326818943024, 0.004562996327877045, 0.015159502625465393, -0.03660854697227478, -0.01857023499906063, -0.015645572915673256, -0.03636511415243149, 0.0139906145632267, 0.018283572047948837, 0.05499180406332016, -0.08249875158071518, -0.0019584866240620613, 0.038434822112321854, 0.013294218108057976, 0.04848036915063858, -0.0051221842877566814, -0.019171880558133125, -0.0035568950697779655, 0.009512052871286869, 0.03322427347302437, 0.008100212551653385, -0.012250441126525402, 0.006766704376786947, -0.005097380839288235, 0.0035739189479500055, -0.08169251680374146, -0.014723205007612705, -0.015127958729863167, -0.025648191571235657, 0.03712151199579239, -0.020187783986330032, 0.004452123306691647, -0.03288983553647995, -0.01698465459048748, 0.015649238601326942, 0.0031830475199967623, 0.0112928980961442, -0.0027863136492669582, 0.008065339177846909, 0.03933326154947281, 0.02443448081612587, -0.06066051498055458, 0.04965406656265259, 0.020526211708784103, -0.04357100650668144, -0.02321787364780903, -0.05734258145093918, -0.06018607318401337, -0.010329876095056534, -0.03999665006995201, 0.03125215321779251, 0.07162631303071976, -0.046800483018159866, -0.053878962993621826, 0.010907711461186409, 0.06163445860147476, -0.09046206623315811, 0.0008624907350167632, 0.018106067553162575, -0.016022920608520508, -0.025591261684894562, -0.012546545825898647, 0.024129929021000862, 0.002296365099027753, -0.0170269925147295, -0.006431292742490768, 0.013495640829205513, 0.025108078494668007, 0.004719607066363096, 0.0035500209778547287, 0.040887072682380676, 0.02508174628019333, 0.048024777323007584, 0.03544151410460472, 0.0030462066642940044, -0.0016928438562899828, 0.04550488293170929, 0.0017925684805959463, -0.053445663303136826, -0.00921210553497076, -0.03379009664058685, -0.0026764944195747375, 0.01946837082505226, 0.03318459168076515, -0.0291158314794302, 0.0035244952887296677, -0.03868389502167702, -0.045588359236717224, 0.02656496688723564, -0.04645588621497154, 0.01011680532246828, -0.020242439582943916, 0.043405648320913315, -0.004302948247641325, -0.028685251250863075, -0.024900319054722786, 0.001992924138903618, -0.006586986593902111, 0.06723102927207947, 0.003989949356764555, 0.03208387270569801, -0.005674267187714577, -0.032848846167325974, 0.019536348059773445, -0.03176843374967575, 0.02911074087023735, -0.011161236092448235, -0.02235948108136654, 0.051863886415958405, 0.0391312874853611, 0.056916046887636185, 0.0033326037228107452, 0.04756549745798111, -0.031057754531502724, 0.016587071120738983, -0.045782774686813354, 0.0047792368568480015, 0.018435241654515266, 0.06398776173591614, 0.032954853028059006, -0.03235394135117531, 0.07159017026424408, 0.033984728157520294, -0.007937570102512836, -0.0031403349712491035, -0.003986240364611149, 0.04437118023633957, 0.019321225583553314, 0.032263148576021194, -0.0366792269051075, 0.012750267051160336, 0.006629081442952156, 0.008134660311043262, 0.0625746101140976, 0.042057547718286514, -0.01262625027447939, 0.06806724518537521, 0.03134731203317642, -0.023469403386116028, -0.013426428660750389, -0.04128928855061531, -0.02775268256664276, 0.04001164063811302, 0.05242035537958145, 0.023040099069476128, 0.04778384789824486, -0.018719853833317757, -0.0233206357806921, 0.004531936254352331, 0.07015421241521835, 0.002874853787943721, 0.060136254876852036, -0.014553746208548546, 0.03756866604089737, 0.015510765835642815, 0.006977465003728867, -0.01020662672817707, 0.022402189671993256, 0.0612221397459507, -0.010314259678125381, -0.04977012425661087, 0.04148317128419876, -0.00240795174613595, 0.013680723495781422, -0.07387910783290863, 0.0780467689037323, 0.031001662835478783, 0.022173143923282623, -0.0210881307721138, 0.009628950618207455, 0.00812552124261856, -0.008797287940979004, -0.035194117575883865, -0.006570500321686268, -0.018467016518115997, -0.0036578637082129717, -0.01898811012506485, 0.043015528470277786, 0.0466875396668911, 0.03238306939601898, -0.040080513805150986, 0.01539639662951231, 0.0377778559923172, 0.008655359968543053, 0.03139331564307213, 0.008867972530424595, 0.04022229090332985, 0.015981188043951988, -0.056927599012851715, -0.07971125841140747, 0.01849740743637085, -0.03778128698468208, 0.017125101760029793, -0.007527243345975876, -0.010475512593984604, -0.027464576065540314, -0.02054588869214058, -0.059429436922073364, -0.018015164881944656, 0.046667519956827164, -0.03997933492064476, -0.049689698964357376, -0.0060868822038173676, -0.012091114185750484, 0.0010591817554086447, -0.004009770695120096, -0.039972566068172455, -0.006822482217103243, -0.051229141652584076, -0.030730146914720535, 0.005169854033738375, -0.02879311516880989, -0.09902292490005493, 0.013170591555535793, 0.03017186000943184, 0.057823244482278824, -0.0037038959562778473, 0.044170115143060684, 0.0641089677810669, 0.05919613689184189, 0.012439255602657795, 0.04806666821241379, 0.0007744577596895397, 0.04883437231183052, -0.027454685419797897, -0.002902099397033453, 0.0005128166521899402, 0.04694334790110588, 0.011876430362462997, 0.023728255182504654, 0.03619745373725891, -0.03328933194279671, -0.010136637836694717, 0.0660238191485405, 0.018590709194540977, 0.018086545169353485, 0.01656367816030979, -0.04495493322610855, 0.019447630271315575, -0.032146044075489044, 0.007600484881550074, -0.015376109629869461, 0.018686778843402863, -0.029398949816823006, -0.001014109468087554, -0.07599472999572754, -0.047962088137865067, -0.034613270312547684, 0.004661829210817814, 0.050253551453351974, 0.04158764332532883, 0.03699742630124092, -0.035585738718509674, -0.07504383474588394, -0.045553941279649734, 0.04568026587367058, -0.004175875335931778, -0.027371061965823174, 0.0006197131588123739, 0.013097820803523064, 0.0183469969779253, -0.021758288145065308, -0.054175928235054016, 0.044119782745838165, -0.0069795832969248295, 0.008929609321057796, 0.03631073981523514, -0.029688071459531784, 0.042454369366168976, -0.034121543169021606, 0.02319166250526905, -0.02842020057141781, 0.015747863799333572, 0.022631485015153885, -0.044359929859638214, 0.06460431218147278, -0.0299959909170866, -0.022937746718525887, 0.058667395263910294, 0.06583979725837708, -0.052354034036397934, 0.022590123116970062, 0.06359732151031494, -0.02166220359504223, 0.008094779215753078, 0.022802557796239853, 0.026094509288668633, -0.048456333577632904, -0.05815406143665314, 0.025525249540805817, -0.025172799825668335, 0.04076356440782547, -0.09383824467658997, -0.04374641180038452, -0.007518368773162365, -0.05715480074286461, -0.06756418943405151, -0.0010565632255747914, -0.020564602687954903, 0.02422540821135044, 0.07810527086257935, -0.09222587198019028, 0.012663288041949272, 0.05120411142706871, 0.04617583751678467 ]
<p>I read that the field that have simultaneously minimum divergence and minimal transversal extension is the fundamental Gaussian mode. What are the good references in this subject, to prove the assertion above?</p>
g1595
[ 0.0763956606388092, 0.019943607971072197, 0.02203649841248989, -0.052129920572042465, 0.001967839663848281, 0.018825681880116463, -0.00695614842697978, 0.006433313712477684, 0.004975811578333378, -0.03426609933376312, -0.024469273164868355, -0.03628029674291611, -0.015199998393654823, 0.03757685050368309, -0.00048548096674494445, -0.021026531234383583, -0.03407812491059303, 0.044016722589731216, 0.04964997619390488, 0.020754333585500717, -0.04147638380527496, -0.012843153439462185, 0.08378742635250092, 0.04088137298822403, -0.00402445811778307, -0.0489896722137928, 0.058825455605983734, -0.0040890369564294815, -0.05146019905805588, -0.005471716169267893, 0.08013753592967987, -0.03987491503357887, 0.05595199391245842, -0.03131327033042908, -0.0061145662330091, 0.015543302521109581, -0.018476011231541634, 0.015100945718586445, -0.013744259253144264, 0.015455754473805428, 0.027468038722872734, -0.009093443863093853, 0.030685903504490852, 0.030198559165000916, -0.018949225544929504, 0.012299703434109688, -0.006080816965550184, 0.0028855563141405582, -0.020384913310408592, -0.020314082503318787, -0.025393106043338776, 0.0428614504635334, 0.09919384121894836, 0.0005463487468659878, -0.027800889685750008, 0.025989243760704994, -0.06785959750413895, 0.012581865303218365, 0.046358104795217514, -0.01403914112597704, -0.007935088127851486, -0.010524868033826351, -0.07819143682718277, -0.04456740990281105, -0.03446890041232109, 0.04635658860206604, -0.03672577440738678, -0.05665178596973419, 0.018274331465363503, 0.012550368905067444, 0.025807112455368042, -0.054265134036540985, -0.015173335559666157, 0.0226656012237072, 0.002159894211217761, 0.011056710965931416, 0.03148483857512474, -0.06685545295476913, -0.0677121952176094, -0.05013718456029892, -0.018202122300863266, -0.014632399193942547, -0.0006840380956418812, -0.020412057638168335, 0.061872851103544235, -0.03256148099899292, -0.001964920200407505, 0.012774650938808918, 0.008352303877472878, 0.018758317455649376, -0.027166035026311874, 0.0532943457365036, 0.034310802817344666, -0.0065802340395748615, -0.017840564250946045, 0.03277089446783066, -0.02004493586719036, -0.004935439210385084, -0.024903176352381706, -0.006780251860618591, 0.005482112057507038, 0.03200039267539978, 0.012566307559609413, -0.06221120059490204, -0.02565883658826351, 0.005355666857212782, 0.04388052597641945, -0.020573696121573448, 0.018302220851182938, -0.008409291505813599, -0.03878017142415047, 0.043723687529563904, -0.044663138687610626, -0.027832068502902985, -0.008308029733598232, -0.07088689506053925, 0.00965384766459465, 0.0328792966902256, 0.019482672214508057, 0.007196372840553522, 0.007863873615860939, 0.051204949617385864, -0.0115848733112216, 0.044338371604681015, -0.01295230258256197, 0.037784431129693985, -0.027835529297590256, 0.0082022063434124, 0.010681860148906708, 0.022199388593435287, -0.012981041334569454, 0.016179349273443222, 0.017054185271263123, -0.021919487044215202, 0.014729565940797329, 0.04252340644598007, -0.024447830393910408, 0.024545293301343918, -0.026075655594468117, 0.014773107133805752, -0.029709678143262863, -0.028641464188694954, 0.019836895167827606, -0.0498771034181118, 0.002272154437378049, 0.030312450602650642, 0.06368111073970795, -0.01110820285975933, -0.004200530704110861, -0.013446515426039696, 0.02594447322189808, 0.05532091483473778, 0.009990690276026726, 0.013955391943454742, -0.01181462686508894, 0.025812994688749313, 0.07483980059623718, -0.0660405382514, -0.02992584928870201, 0.0007595841307193041, 0.00871374923735857, 0.013243941590189934, 0.05343296006321907, 0.0668635368347168, -0.03793689236044884, -0.024984799325466156, -0.010414490476250648, -0.02875395119190216, 0.029649829491972923, -0.03688432276248932, -0.006612272933125496, 0.03770516812801361, 0.027046823874115944, 0.07350125163793564, 0.02334757335484028, 0.03183417767286301, -0.06306371092796326, -0.07812526822090149, -0.0280984528362751, 0.07394234091043472, -0.060074467211961746, -0.0013340921141207218, -0.00962608028203249, -0.022477388381958008, -0.002247473457828164, -0.04096006602048874, -0.0295809768140316, -0.020799608901143074, -0.04253073036670685, 0.011766119860112667, 0.048458244651556015, 0.03339551016688347, 0.0189753957092762, 0.04627325385808945, 0.005255976226180792, 0.016523851081728935, 0.05271309241652489, -0.04452411085367203, 0.015473483130335808, -0.0049073765985667706, -0.0033081702422350645, 0.03699496388435364, 0.010438857600092888, 0.04904734715819359, 0.0033679751213639975, 0.04530193284153938, 0.012682694010436535, 0.014341729693114758, 0.04408858343958855, -0.018514497205615044, -0.015094312839210033, -0.019838472828269005, -0.03933876007795334, -0.001199742080643773, -0.022152766585350037, -0.013357345946133137, 0.022950980812311172, 0.012286577373743057, 0.01971518062055111, 0.035911925137043, -0.0015506811905652285, 0.04451291263103485, 0.08091847598552704, 0.060086119920015335, 0.008396356366574764, 0.02848832495510578, -0.0434093102812767, 0.0007390838582068682, -0.01634230650961399, 0.0003141827473882586, -0.09431453794240952, -0.06666118651628494, 0.039859700947999954, -0.0163565743714571, 0.012329072691500187, 0.06335271894931793, -0.015330437570810318, 0.0633130818605423, 0.03690236434340477, 0.0047957212664186954, 0.012047598138451576, -0.02855312079191208, 0.02457750402390957, 0.012955044396221638, -0.03485189378261566, -0.0032406579703092575, -0.003482003463432193, -0.01358446292579174, 0.03419150412082672, -0.02809489145874977, -0.0022397348657250404, 0.00790101382881403, -0.03784932568669319, -0.0396653413772583, -0.04818890988826752, -0.011961475014686584, 0.030322778970003128, 0.05305393785238266, -0.023788658902049065, -0.057512544095516205, -0.003830904606729746, -0.07752443850040436, 0.03356485068798065, 0.004175722599029541, 0.026172485202550888, 0.005229499191045761, 0.0008410068694502115, 0.024285970255732536, -0.03722241520881653, -0.0477052740752697, 0.011570572853088379, 0.07087206095457077, -0.027398694306612015, 0.013935391791164875, -0.04553298279643059, -0.005858257412910461, 0.0001977862266357988, -0.012336309999227524, -0.06892836838960648, -0.024899156764149666, -0.020279770717024803, -0.03046736866235733, -0.002977295545861125, 0.030978839844465256, 0.031340185552835464, -0.058149147778749466, 0.054056912660598755, 0.05965639650821686, -0.04344192147254944, 0.03971753641963005, 0.004510905127972364, 0.039804186671972275, 0.06195449456572533, -0.015662318095564842, -0.000949547509662807, 0.04831654205918312, 0.0449298620223999, -0.05389828234910965, 0.010036755353212357, -0.015076694078743458, -0.026194987818598747, 0.005589418578892946, -0.040512051433324814, 0.006294878665357828, -0.0036528019700199366, -0.0653296485543251, -0.05689636245369911, -0.0630897656083107, -0.015461201779544353, 0.045451801270246506, -0.02493528090417385, -0.046232935041189194, 0.021312139928340912, 0.014201716519892216, -0.029150711372494698, 0.002950240857899189, -0.04610547423362732, 0.01444062776863575, -0.009822428226470947, 0.013159059919416904, -0.033748120069503784, -0.007768088951706886, -0.00913340225815773, -0.0325690358877182, 0.055958688259124756, 0.055877115577459335, -0.004560098052024841, -0.016582079231739044, -0.0564701110124588, 0.03599930182099342, 0.04250913858413696, 0.012827255763113499, -0.021316394209861755, -0.027935292571783066, -0.01087892521172762, -0.06653787940740585, -0.0016398627776652575, 0.041978053748607635, 0.039434466511011124, -0.03502002730965614, 0.033790431916713715, -0.014555033296346664, -0.048583440482616425, -0.001968683674931526, 0.0036609601229429245, 0.02327069826424122, 0.022628022357821465, -0.0067737712524831295, -0.0035131662152707577, -0.060755405575037, -0.03293897211551666, -0.008304211311042309, -0.013005977496504784, 0.0034136774484068155, -0.042169131338596344, 0.03266502171754837, 0.04954138025641441, 0.038162339478731155, 0.016504155471920967, -0.00672490056604147, 0.020218443125486374, -0.007587209343910217, -0.016007075086236, 0.01522132195532322, 0.03706473857164383, 0.022767113521695137, -0.00870413240045309, 0.05663735419511795, -0.007705872878432274, 0.022562889382243156, 0.006209575571119785, -0.023205092176795006, -0.01881592907011509, 0.0006195363821461797, -0.043425433337688446, -0.026607124134898186, 0.018868133425712585, 0.004380593542009592, -0.036523524671792984, 0.007975396700203419, 0.052034929394721985, 0.019217250868678093, 0.03916445001959801, 0.07804922759532928, -0.037348829209804535, 0.024905983358621597, -0.02391732484102249, -0.03952616825699806, 0.039484720677137375, 0.010723309591412544, -0.016020694747567177, 0.011736646294593811, 0.010550407692790031, 0.02503230608999729, -0.01859118975698948, 0.012808493338525295, -0.006089088972657919, 0.06041310727596283, -0.015701668336987495, 0.05272435396909714, 0.014236214570701122, 0.00873045064508915, -0.04281357303261757, -0.0067101954482495785, -0.03514557704329491, -0.005716391839087009, 0.027469763532280922, 0.019563283771276474, -0.010811889544129372, -0.010382852517068386, 0.039119601249694824, -0.022752562537789345, -0.0275187436491251, -0.04568690061569214, 0.058054253458976746, 0.058496542274951935, 0.010835125111043453, -0.007041494827717543, 0.04815572872757912, 0.0056315879337489605, 0.026284437626600266, -0.0020930690225213766, -0.02752293273806572, -0.019707445055246353, -0.04318187013268471, 0.032701220363378525, 0.05320369452238083, -0.0004943907842971385, -0.01744430884718895, 0.022103268653154373, 0.02092016115784645, -0.026978986337780952, -0.035932283848524094, 0.024540897458791733, -0.005218207836151123, 0.031415924429893494, -0.05386482551693916, 0.04729838669300079, -0.050689324736595154, -0.000832222169265151, 0.06754448264837265, -0.06406106054782867, 0.04354904219508171, 0.025764182209968567, -0.02475421130657196, 0.02179347164928913, -0.005829109810292721, -0.02089661918580532, 0.044684432446956635, -0.04720679670572281, -0.00686524948105216, 0.05001978203654289, -0.019092269241809845, 0.02883577160537243, 0.007652238477021456, -0.06036006286740303, 0.005285922903567553, 0.015044070780277252, 0.029875164851546288, -0.02984132058918476, 0.0025700770784169436, 0.05878487229347229, -0.02560535818338394, 0.038332290947437286, 0.04748940467834473, -0.04504851624369621, -0.02348019927740097, -0.0023118960671126842, -0.03983383998274803, -0.03602497652173042, 0.04868271201848984, 0.0066856155171990395, 0.03464893996715546, 0.02196788415312767, -0.007409268524497747, -0.004987940192222595, 0.012026666663587093, 0.001049710437655449, -0.004136241041123867, -0.02782689593732357, -0.03352084755897522, -0.05583810433745384, -0.017854249104857445, 0.03148747980594635, -0.04223114624619484, 0.02236396260559559, -0.0011864741099998355, -0.07291106134653091, -0.018061591312289238, 0.012988285161554813, -0.03437047451734543, -0.0024077482521533966, 0.02146981842815876, 0.04223255440592766, 0.008340134285390377, -0.03642017021775246, 0.018038157373666763, -0.062061041593551636, 0.004840628243982792, -0.056868795305490494, -0.0947040542960167, 0.02799980714917183, 0.041235264390707016, 0.03321061283349991, -0.02848558872938156, 0.06016497313976288, 0.09532098472118378, -0.0009001436410471797, -0.04756690561771393, 0.08309346437454224, -0.02579973265528679, -0.012143608182668686, -0.007049310952425003, -0.05344506725668907, -0.004046016838401556, -0.03930189460515976, -0.013291889801621437, -0.035755328834056854, -0.038794416934251785, -0.11537569016218185, 0.04198205843567848, -0.020309414714574814, 0.016260692849755287, 0.034365709871053696, 0.013157960958778858, -0.026227286085486412, -0.07236173748970032, -0.0639704093337059, 0.0241624116897583, 0.020009977743029594, -0.01069090235978365, 0.03943023085594177, 0.024882417172193527, 0.007702469360083342, 0.026132700964808464, 0.005233694799244404, -0.01936430111527443, -0.0252688005566597, -0.03139567747712135, 0.020561574026942253, -0.038051459938287735, -0.06818234920501709, 0.055741097778081894, -0.0024192333221435547, -0.044921886175870895, 0.020538069307804108, 0.012051635421812534, 0.034129779785871506, 0.06957709044218063, -0.09158695489168167, -0.036555130034685135, 0.037521496415138245, -0.041033223271369934, -0.022537963464856148, 0.021268300712108612, 0.029252251610159874, -0.08345061540603638, 0.013622056692838669, -0.03975450620055199, 0.014086578041315079, -0.0008437446085736156, -0.025076625868678093, 0.0009687613346613944, -0.08524256199598312, -0.01945810765028, -0.007428647484630346, 0.0030794155318289995, -0.03509947657585144, 0.044480711221694946, 0.005763625726103783, -0.06969042867422104, -0.011214717291295528, 0.08334331959486008, 0.0473804846405983, 0.006933622062206268, -0.032190922647714615, 0.04131939634680748, -0.08450782299041748, -0.03684747591614723, -0.006525280419737101, -0.01343603152781725, -0.0021515125408768654, -0.030280759558081627, -0.03487514331936836, -0.0001304544712183997, 0.048257410526275635, -0.06786298751831055, -0.02926093339920044, 0.02806731127202511, 0.0638015940785408, -0.0006101744365878403, 0.03527944162487984, 0.03918338939547539, 0.009982394985854626, 0.048742685467004776, -0.019585534930229187, 0.014149410650134087, 0.031141167506575584, -0.013751615770161152, -0.02562439814209938, -0.0008579446584917605, -0.00953596644103527, 0.003457434242591262, -0.02009217068552971, 0.01854846626520157, 0.0592028982937336, -0.022951574996113777, 0.009432724677026272, -0.05808272212743759, 0.020095111802220345, -0.04391142353415489, 0.00805056095123291, 0.03817985579371452, 0.013550498522818089, -0.038814906030893326, 0.01563113182783127, -0.05272645503282547, -0.035782843828201294, -0.027603156864643097, 0.050523314625024796, 0.036173395812511444, 0.026753265410661697, 0.039659250527620316, 0.004224929492920637, -0.07275813072919846, 0.040650494396686554, 0.036835603415966034, -0.017003336921334267, 0.03187961503863335, -0.06301276385784149, -0.00013094741734676063, 0.0380629226565361, -0.03222160041332245, -0.02509278431534767, 0.006350710988044739, 0.04666763171553612, -0.07447833567857742, 0.03452306613326073, 0.029561299830675125, 0.007292569149285555, 0.011691241525113583, 0.034022100269794464, 0.03629923239350319, -0.025625532492995262, -0.013593840412795544, -0.010971931740641594, -0.012667463161051273, 0.050138961523771286, -0.00963778980076313, -0.004596770741045475, 0.046320460736751556, 0.0746297612786293, 0.045917898416519165, -0.03483984246850014, -0.016312038525938988, 0.06992457807064056, 0.03823867812752724, 0.0050942543894052505, -0.017596594989299774, 0.013055361807346344, -0.00030822932603769004, -0.016413558274507523, 0.030541472136974335, -0.04588976129889488, 0.026647698134183884, 0.03261566162109375, -0.015561645850539207, -0.044477831572294235, -0.035914476960897446, -0.059367936104536057, 0.01878504641354084, -0.0843765139579773, -0.044620905071496964, 0.04519863426685333, -0.03975478932261467, 0.023979829624295235, -0.09880385547876358, 0.08478840440511703, -0.0007379209855571389, 0.001396181178279221, 0.007006829604506493, 0.06053328141570091, -0.019214164465665817, -0.03174898400902748, -0.018253717571496964, -0.04317346587777138, 0.07524935901165009, -0.029238231480121613, 0.01707185059785843, -0.057277146726846695, -0.03103252686560154, -0.0164759773761034, 0.04171115532517433, -0.06174459308385849, -0.01594558358192444, 0.05703577771782875, 0.0008097889367491007, 0.03545789048075676, 0.024472512304782867, 0.034790948033332825, 0.021289566531777382, -0.017441600561141968, -0.025438498705625534, 0.028610723093152046, 0.0008812841260805726, -0.005145595874637365, 0.024969831109046936, 0.013751739636063576, -0.04216422513127327, 0.015362442471086979, 0.01122437883168459, -0.02793354168534279, 0.026194123551249504, 0.003417281899601221, 0.05738993361592293, 0.004319620318710804, -0.07605980336666107, 0.015083926729857922, -0.038174279034137726, 0.026296604424715042, 0.02636030502617359, -0.02901146374642849, -0.048087190836668015, -0.050248950719833374, -0.10135480761528015, -0.024071525782346725, -0.07241542637348175, -0.020998366177082062, 0.06501144915819168, -0.040879957377910614, -0.00012277791392989457, -0.030369173735380173, -0.04433142766356468, 0.014842087402939796, -0.05462468042969704, 0.05004546418786049, 0.0030598617158830166, 0.030598584562540054, 0.01202940009534359, 0.05077153071761131, 0.021081527695059776, 0.026376347988843918, 0.04969694837927818, -0.027475357055664062, -0.01981402188539505, -0.0046642194502055645, -0.021214157342910767, 0.036378271877765656, 0.01739833690226078, 0.0007629022002220154, 0.003243681974709034, 0.020230848342180252, 0.04495592787861824, 0.012623626738786697, 0.04799316078424454, -0.022902676835656166, -0.001158215687610209, 0.04014865681529045, 0.07731463015079498, -0.01633855327963829, -0.010340509004890919, -0.03578319400548935, 0.027816884219646454, 0.030030934140086174, -0.035737551748752594, -0.04883918911218643, -0.011511070653796196, 0.021760769188404083 ]
<p>I know how to derive below equations found on <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creation_and_annihilation_operators#cite_note-4" rel="nofollow">wikipedia</a> and have done it myselt too: </p> <p>\begin{align} \hat{H} &amp;= \hbar \omega \left(\hat{a}^\dagger\hat{a} + \frac{1}{2}\right)\\ \hat{H} &amp;= \hbar \omega \left(\hat{a}\hat{a}^\dagger - \frac{1}{2}\right)\\ \end{align} </p> <p>where $\hat{a}=\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\hat{P} - i \hat{X}\right)$ is a annihilation operator and $\hat{a}^\dagger=\tfrac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \left(\hat{P} + i \hat{X}\right)$ a creation operator. Let me write also that:</p> <p>\begin{align} \hat{P}&amp;= \frac{1}{p_0}\hat{p} = -\frac{i\hbar}{\sqrt{\hbar m \omega}} \frac{d}{dx}\\ \hat{X}&amp;=\frac{1}{x_0} \hat{x}=\sqrt{\frac{m\omega}{\hbar}}x \end{align}</p> <p>In order to continue i need a proof that operators $\hat{a}$ and $\hat{a}^\dagger$ give a following commutator with hamiltonian $\hat{H}$: </p> <p>\begin{align} \left[\hat{H},\hat{a} \right] &amp;= -\hbar\omega \, \hat{a}\\ \left[\hat{H},\hat{a}^\dagger \right] &amp;= +\hbar\omega \, \hat{a}^\dagger \end{align}</p> <p>These statements can be found on wikipedia as well as <a href="http://quantummechanics.ucsd.edu/ph130a/130_notes/node170.html#section%3aHOraise" rel="nofollow">here</a>, but nowhere it is proven that the above relations for commutator really hold. I tried to derive $\left[\hat{H},\hat{a} \right]$ and my result was: </p> <p>$$ \left[\hat{H},\hat{a} \right] \psi = -i \sqrt{\frac{\omega \hbar^3}{4m}}\psi $$</p> <p>You should know that this this is 3rd commutator that i have ever calculated so it probably is wrong, but here is a <a href="http://www.2shared.com/photo/9tGw_Zv_/Image1646.html" rel="nofollow">photo</a> of my attempt on paper. I would appreciate if anyone has any link to a proof of the commutator relations (one will do) or could post a proof here.</p>
g1596
[ -0.018372857943177223, -0.021329645067453384, -0.009958209469914436, 0.012276438996195793, 0.06798689812421799, -0.0531492717564106, 0.0626421794295311, 0.004566785879433155, 0.006283568684011698, 0.05703235790133476, -0.05630403384566307, 0.0019158569630235434, 0.004389425273984671, 0.02383488044142723, 0.03141387552022934, 0.015449433587491512, -0.006926537957042456, -0.0025715625379234552, -0.037422724068164825, 0.05147489532828331, -0.05149514228105545, 0.013942224904894829, 0.018615014851093292, -0.04477549344301224, 0.06597314774990082, -0.04969386011362076, 0.013946779072284698, 0.0008183548343367875, -0.023101061582565308, -0.009321379475295544, 0.05568748340010643, 0.039554663002491, -0.007453586906194687, -0.012880089692771435, -0.029430648311972618, -0.023557208478450775, 0.06838925182819366, 0.014531642198562622, 0.02389313280582428, -0.00488504720851779, -0.005325658246874809, 0.008153275586664677, 0.011917896568775177, -0.031722597777843475, -0.004393292590975761, -0.056732915341854095, 0.0022588232532143593, 0.0146914292126894, -0.05707957595586777, -0.023656301200389862, 0.05875512957572937, 0.04890098422765732, 0.05899176746606827, -0.04051802307367325, -0.012658657506108284, 0.06963060796260834, 0.0038870261050760746, -0.025674518197774887, 0.06493797898292542, -0.012842558324337006, -0.062231626361608505, -0.013253492303192616, 0.025373540818691254, 0.014908414334058762, 0.014351430349051952, -0.02955973520874977, 0.03943009674549103, -0.00494985468685627, 0.024250609800219536, -0.0196932852268219, 0.011298071593046188, 0.0006929655792191625, 0.061785757541656494, 0.00897766649723053, 0.028198588639497757, 0.018412921577692032, 0.006776217836886644, -0.014293970540165901, 0.023416152223944664, -0.0037688487209379673, -0.03933194652199745, -0.020330308005213737, -0.01208115741610527, 0.020667001605033875, -0.007300165947526693, -0.012927187606692314, -0.03292352333664894, -0.016398312523961067, 0.05005757510662079, -0.0095328688621521, -0.00030303382663987577, 0.05685606598854065, 0.05715367570519447, 0.023799238726496696, 0.01575765199959278, -0.0056207007728517056, -0.03356452286243439, 0.07207327336072922, -0.014929134398698807, 0.010974427685141563, -0.016702421009540558, 0.020708680152893066, 0.032973844558000565, -0.027879679575562477, 0.052543483674526215, -0.01875094138085842, 0.018290109932422638, -0.03644287958741188, -0.057673145085573196, -0.004753479268401861, -0.04784982651472092, 0.006686346139758825, -0.041648637503385544, 0.006717562209814787, 0.025059396401047707, -0.058297984302043915, -0.02393210120499134, 0.01724221184849739, 0.031604450196027756, 0.04190785065293312, -0.02617337927222252, 0.03688754886388779, -0.03542215749621391, 0.019463710486888885, 0.010716674849390984, -0.018208250403404236, 0.00621036859229207, 0.01780773513019085, 0.04694218933582306, 0.004327734466642141, 0.030850334092974663, -0.02106550708413124, 0.05447044223546982, 0.09827316552400589, 0.033656585961580276, 0.0400298610329628, 0.01750229485332966, -0.018047459423542023, 0.0008814387256279588, -0.05781504884362221, 0.019582033157348633, -0.014721083454787731, 0.007546489592641592, -0.031063126400113106, -0.01265857182443142, 0.003077220404520631, 0.020572632551193237, -0.03910708427429199, -0.034200362861156464, 0.0390876904129982, 0.009141541086137295, 0.01900310069322586, -0.0050363000482320786, 0.01244503352791071, 0.02133050560951233, -0.012248397804796696, 0.026035185903310776, -0.06091993302106857, -0.056775156408548355, -0.06366638094186783, -0.014770503155887127, -0.0469234362244606, 0.013177904300391674, 0.021989597007632256, 0.007353698369115591, 0.025148218497633934, -0.03767167404294014, -0.07322462648153305, -0.030937181785702705, -0.03609796613454819, -0.022344518452882767, 0.05909964069724083, 0.025418799370527267, 0.04894541576504707, 0.036697693169116974, 0.04312615096569061, -0.05150680989027023, 0.05265785753726959, -0.003769561881199479, 0.0073480429127812386, 0.02109002321958542, 0.007058517541736364, 0.07953239977359772, -0.04343718662858009, 0.032749585807323456, 0.009983017109334469, 0.011714184656739235, -0.006538283545523882, -0.034840721637010574, 0.004979141987860203, 0.001032061642035842, 0.03563651442527771, 0.0355992391705513, 0.03305220603942871, 0.01603354513645172, 0.05671516805887222, -0.01011019665747881, -0.07848212867975235, 0.041630297899246216, 0.03266212344169617, 0.011023600585758686, 0.05064907297492027, -0.026163538917899132, -0.03653699904680252, -0.011762167327105999, -0.0248381569981575, 0.026303347200155258, -0.011265620589256287, 0.017528079450130463, 0.009650328196585178, -0.0517115443944931, -0.02382034994661808, -0.012549566105008125, -0.018297096714377403, 0.001466889400035143, -0.014746875502169132, 0.01131793949753046, 0.018475888296961784, -0.053279709070920944, 0.015316911041736603, 0.03223680332303047, -0.0025097744073718786, -0.014494974166154861, -0.020296042785048485, -0.023372523486614227, 0.05172079801559448, -0.0009215311147272587, -0.03773088753223419, -0.02969176135957241, -0.020006882026791573, 0.022074399515986443, -0.011524432338774204, 0.010548188351094723, -0.07025785744190216, 0.01278210710734129, 0.06317195296287537, 0.06061037629842758, 0.015549586154520512, 0.008750297129154205, 0.03340654447674751, -0.03384307771921158, -0.005668629892170429, -0.001380745554342866, -0.00036172138061374426, 0.02819615602493286, -0.013730129227042198, 0.03575151786208153, 0.017455879598855972, 0.004987246822565794, 0.006352459546178579, -0.011565705761313438, -0.03802245855331421, -0.021598687395453453, -0.051531918346881866, 0.007853779941797256, -0.04250109940767288, 0.02036994881927967, -0.002023516921326518, 0.024780994281172752, 0.02493354119360447, -0.034901510924100876, 0.030040377750992775, -0.06612096726894379, 0.03122573532164097, -0.0684850811958313, -0.04959145560860634, -0.049309149384498596, -0.055570077151060104, 0.030601276084780693, -0.007409582380205393, -0.03888457641005516, -0.018621832132339478, 0.030526604503393173, 0.010683614760637283, -0.01064399816095829, -0.06807814538478851, 0.003641720861196518, 0.013480705209076405, 0.022754894569516182, 0.0006439919234253466, -0.02059948816895485, 0.05339193344116211, -0.06607705354690552, 0.03712309151887894, 0.011077355593442917, -0.03673853352665901, 0.004868827294558287, 0.026014920324087143, -0.049001988023519516, 0.006852779537439346, -0.0017460556700825691, 0.010771232657134533, -0.05274384096264839, -0.08311691880226135, -0.021593870595097542, 0.03508928418159485, 0.018170928582549095, -0.04764202982187271, 0.012521586380898952, -0.004215835593640804, 0.02078212797641754, 0.00011347592226229608, 0.018858367577195168, 0.012841729447245598, 0.04622100666165352, 0.017967738211154938, -0.008529785089194775, -0.05568837746977806, 0.029063105583190918, 0.034348227083683014, 0.005408031865954399, 0.006439415272325277, 0.03250053897500038, -0.048789456486701965, 0.06296858936548233, -0.0019935492891818285, -0.02192322351038456, -0.05648236721754074, -0.004894142970442772, -0.06301913410425186, -0.041302889585494995, -0.0843663364648819, 0.01462854165583849, -0.031572241336107254, 0.026583781465888023, 0.0327749103307724, -0.07837694138288498, 0.018325448036193848, 0.04534849151968956, -0.03378435596823692, 0.03664476051926613, -0.0032619833946228027, 0.0517536923289299, -0.03964924439787865, -0.05984867364168167, -0.04273322969675064, 0.05370711162686348, 0.0036925291642546654, -0.02276424691081047, -0.028575150296092033, 0.04833672195672989, -0.013006404042243958, -0.019110839813947678, 0.008032535202801228, -0.04695791378617287, 0.03346981480717659, 0.004231065511703491, 0.052863605320453644, 0.04541908577084541, -0.05844821780920029, -0.005667379125952721, -0.04497398063540459, 0.027395835146307945, -0.015598660334944725, -0.020029177889227867, -0.009615684859454632, 0.030821682885289192, 0.015915192663669586, 0.01468345895409584, 0.007799974642693996, -0.008034011349081993, -0.05008285865187645, 0.06833911687135696, 0.035423796623945236, 0.002643255051225424, -0.0020173420198261738, 0.0011889986926689744, 0.0159906018525362, 0.004626133479177952, -0.042707350105047226, 0.03556714579463005, -0.01765506900846958, -0.0029065869748592377, -0.057570599019527435, -0.0065638599917292595, -0.011238151229918003, 0.043758004903793335, 0.04912393540143967, -0.003702882444486022, 0.015309463255107403, 0.010629197582602501, 0.024804582819342613, -0.0011797066545113921, 0.05682995542883873, 0.026365913450717926, 0.08388803154230118, 0.03912559524178505, 0.0010435684816911817, 0.026568997651338577, -0.0373741090297699, -0.00005767410038970411, -0.024400459602475166, -0.015261491760611534, 0.001702577224932611, 0.027599090710282326, 0.03829380124807358, -0.04692644253373146, -0.04736824333667755, -0.02854085899889469, 0.030095990747213364, -0.05532331392168999, -0.05941091477870941, 0.03782142698764801, 0.009480652399361134, 0.007135269697755575, -0.040937118232250214, 0.03833964094519615, 0.03979068994522095, 0.02794228307902813, -0.0262376070022583, -0.07221103459596634, -0.005810428876429796, 0.020199596881866455, 0.014701350592076778, -0.05002572014927864, -0.0011649687075987458, -0.014723479747772217, -0.03547704219818115, 0.028222961351275444, -0.005700949113816023, -0.006365968845784664, 0.011265293695032597, 0.06886554509401321, -0.02194823883473873, 0.030398163944482803, 0.017194531857967377, -0.004591688048094511, -0.07324380427598953, 0.04899261146783829, -0.015246815979480743, 0.02385144680738449, -0.0035276231355965137, 0.008291365578770638, 0.021804699674248695, -0.05069366469979286, -0.021193236112594604, -0.043620917946100235, 0.05441559851169586, 0.024405639618635178, -0.01945560611784458, 0.031529221683740616, -0.004947810899466276, 0.04448768123984337, -0.04077260196208954, 0.007866168394684792, 0.009285821579396725, -0.03560484200716019, -0.06270016729831696, -0.037327591329813004, -0.008225372061133385, 0.020450260490179062, 0.03686051443219185, 0.0235274825245142, -0.03161055967211723, -0.06948243081569672, -0.016914233565330505, -0.027031129226088524, 0.00866041798144579, 0.0020146635361015797, 0.016308749094605446, -0.008117027580738068, -0.0406297966837883, -0.005040823947638273, -0.0003348038881085813, -0.0013682987773790956, -0.01169111579656601, -0.036333367228507996, 0.06282415986061096, -0.06696344166994095, 0.0005786193651147187, 0.016733866184949875, 0.030490342527627945, -0.011695705354213715, -0.017584314569830894, -0.023334134370088577, -0.044991716742515564, 0.0671994611620903, 0.00825478509068489, -0.02983829937875271, 0.03726115822792053, 0.0191069133579731, -0.050713758915662766, -0.03418675437569618, -0.00930815376341343, 0.04415242001414299, 0.10584767907857895, -0.0015176745364442468, -0.03936368599534035, 0.006771815475076437, -0.027395600453019142, -0.02422438934445381, -0.03481145203113556, -0.020704876631498337, -0.0038422499783337116, -0.04067863151431084, -0.020952502265572548, -0.001583297154866159, -0.020117392763495445, 0.03528585657477379, -0.0020691435784101486, -0.09121624380350113, 0.005004687700420618, -0.03105725161731243, 0.01556149311363697, 0.019935764372348785, 0.006416890770196915, 0.09938648343086243, 0.0349666103720665, 0.0409306064248085, 0.012993380427360535, 0.03217241168022156, -0.012070917524397373, 0.04188603162765503, -0.0408940464258194, -0.007274648640304804, 0.07657792419195175, -0.010492365807294846, 0.026876330375671387, -0.07023655623197556, -0.03719809651374817, 0.028009504079818726, 0.027747977524995804, 0.08211611956357956, 0.028536472469568253, 0.02820178121328354, 0.05561113730072975, -0.0388716459274292, -0.05316917970776558, -0.00546684255823493, 0.018811136484146118, -0.03554780036211014, 0.05336369574069977, -0.0310033168643713, -0.023002665489912033, -0.013022346422076225, -0.06426490098237991, -0.05952341482043266, 0.024157388135790825, 0.012610472738742828, -0.02632305584847927, 0.029858307912945747, 0.03181442618370056, -0.018633387982845306, 0.04055443033576012, -0.014986453577876091, 0.05535279959440231, -0.04396621137857437, 0.025525765493512154, -0.01118894200772047, 0.004949764348566532, -0.0654921904206276, -0.02454441972076893, -0.011937592178583145, -0.0440867617726326, 0.019029736518859863, 0.022035742178559303, -0.021258195862174034, -0.031233686953783035, -0.062061868607997894, -0.03122665174305439, 0.04624349623918533, 0.06784375756978989, 0.003445839276537299, 0.0015112371183931828, -0.05325911194086075, 0.028937360271811485, 0.011542254127562046, 0.04692661389708519, 0.03608911484479904, 0.06508821249008179, 0.0009400253184139729, 0.022419437766075134, -0.049174658954143524, 0.028297290205955505, 0.05206219479441643, 0.06030659377574921, 0.037511635571718216, -0.08022455126047134, -0.06780732423067093, -0.003447135677561164, 0.03843971714377403, -0.04415059834718704, -0.03908711299300194, -0.0075935195200145245, -0.05830959975719452, 0.022095030173659325, 0.008305625058710575, -0.007793922908604145, 0.004511355888098478, 0.007865527644753456, -0.024163808673620224, 0.015338771045207977, -0.0014144200831651688, -0.024141883477568626, 0.04541514441370964, 0.028080610558390617, 0.04949748143553734, 0.030545376241207123, -0.004095087759196758, -0.009450733661651611, 0.015988100320100784, -0.022317415103316307, -0.038016606122255325, -0.027271326631307602, -0.0010226897429674864, 0.0488334558904171, -0.07404560595750809, 0.06182808056473732, 0.016681881621479988, -0.015026331879198551, -0.1087765172123909, 0.024834658950567245, 0.02426445297896862, 0.04893384501338005, -0.029515523463487625, 0.00640692375600338, 0.007705686613917351, 0.03321932256221771, -0.013046357780694962, 0.07855783402919769, 0.05678235739469528, -0.014736641198396683, -0.024093087762594223, 0.004194555804133415, -0.01572893001139164, 0.09161733090877533, 0.020511502400040627, -0.008661560714244843, 0.0014886612771078944, -0.04584619402885437, -0.025009047240018845, -0.024026984348893166, 0.007346462924033403, 0.05288585275411606, -0.003002517158165574, 0.030409447848796844, -0.016212627291679382, 0.011998788453638554, 0.005507111083716154, 0.055058207362890244, -0.013206413015723228, 0.01579875312745571, 0.025655176490545273, -0.042761944234371185, -0.06499261409044266, -0.004318110179156065, 0.05479944497346878, -0.03951696678996086, -0.10354730486869812, 0.01873413473367691, -0.033690690994262695, -0.0059515037573874, 0.008900345303118229, 0.00917004607617855, 0.00039404185372404754, -0.01884549856185913, 0.00966474786400795, -0.019586380571126938, -0.021707477048039436, -0.04461108520627022, 0.003310050815343857, 0.018494311720132828, 0.004164947662502527, 0.00563165033236146, -0.019614651799201965, -0.019126951694488525, 0.014853830449283123, 0.03244340792298317, 0.040853288024663925, -0.02238231711089611, -0.027147207409143448, 0.005634828470647335, 0.007310665212571621, -0.008310412056744099, -0.057295192033052444, 0.04810643568634987, 0.05850370228290558, 0.0658629760146141, -0.018575038760900497, -0.06063723564147949, -0.02951798215508461, -0.008107386529445648, -0.08567807078361511, -0.06132030114531517, 0.003436925122514367, -0.002896822290495038, -0.029679950326681137, 0.01910867728292942, 0.04220004007220268, 0.045890241861343384, -0.04739049822092056, 0.00031521025812253356, 0.02315966784954071, -0.025874018669128418, 0.024986622855067253, 0.01851404272019863, 0.04661167040467262, 0.03617719188332558, 0.043551769107580185, -0.019297566264867783, 0.0011726828524842858, -0.062076978385448456, 0.005472172982990742, -0.03622579202055931, -0.02424793690443039, 0.05302378162741661, 0.027577674016356468, 0.021832598373293877, 0.012946510687470436, -0.009788584895431995, -0.023356782272458076, -0.032165560871362686, -0.0669463574886322, -0.057113803923130035, 0.019285699352622032, -0.012810359708964825, -0.023318566381931305, 0.07490213960409164, 0.04599602147936821, -0.01282453816384077, 0.030378902330994606, -0.04223105311393738, -0.028278637677431107, -0.04280818626284599, -0.0004218888934701681, -0.024120373651385307, 0.021147292107343674, 0.024685636162757874, -0.017092108726501465, -0.031157968565821648, -0.013297632336616516, -0.028492402285337448, -0.03379698470234871, 0.08281269669532776, -0.01948612555861473, -0.03629264608025551, 0.004307569935917854, -0.04952723905444145, 0.0611998625099659, -0.013942145742475986, 0.0004929789574816823, -0.08660224825143814, 0.05343667045235634, -0.08860265463590622, 0.02062559500336647, -0.0873749777674675, 0.0192573145031929, 0.025172816589474678, -0.007428970653563738, -0.07361366599798203, 0.053268011659383774, 0.07007735222578049, -0.01890539936721325, 0.0004368324007373303, 0.05157630890607834, -0.03756076097488403, 0.029025837779045105, 0.06306587904691696, 0.05552857741713524, 0.05944083258509636, 0.013912786729633808, -0.008480643853545189, -0.019936472177505493, -0.016556836664676666, -0.007560934405773878, -0.06347425282001495, 0.002691107802093029, 0.009242546744644642 ]
<p><a href="http://www.google.com/search?as_q=invariable" rel="nofollow">Invariable</a> means which is not variable i.e. can't be changed.</p> <p>Recently I have seen a sentence when reading a chapter based on measurement:</p> <blockquote> <p><em>The accepted standards must be accessible to those who need to calibrate their secondary standards, and they must be <strong>invariable</strong> to change with the passage of time or with changes in the environment (temperature, humidity, etc.).</em></p> </blockquote> <p>What does 'invariable to change' mean here?</p>
g1597
[ 0.01291846577078104, -0.016709305346012115, -0.012508034706115723, -0.03701067343354225, 0.028763001784682274, 0.01966824196279049, 0.047828517854213715, 0.045151907950639725, -0.027553187683224678, 0.045833975076675415, -0.0071782865561544895, 0.05271004140377045, -0.004616458434611559, -0.016550898551940918, -0.005027400329709053, 0.007071640342473984, 0.06570624560117722, -0.017939351499080658, 0.030893294140696526, 0.013374977745115757, 0.03461108356714249, -0.006686371751129627, -0.012050806544721127, -0.04442480206489563, -0.045529354363679886, -0.011186206713318825, 0.046324897557497025, 0.01682088151574135, -0.006769630126655102, -0.006280922330915928, -0.010166452266275883, 0.0007098214700818062, 0.0506199486553669, -0.04768117144703865, 0.009597910568118095, -0.0077094146981835365, 0.050657276064157486, 0.043436694890260696, 0.08572567254304886, 0.021167460829019547, 0.04034325107932091, 0.044291459023952484, 0.035001225769519806, 0.024966446682810783, -0.006732973735779524, 0.05008571594953537, 0.07700717449188232, 0.0219438374042511, 0.0444328747689724, -0.023261601105332375, -0.0007707051699981093, -0.03957144916057587, 0.011662840843200684, 0.05515368655323982, 0.03322828188538551, 0.013699439354240894, 0.059389177709817886, 0.03396354243159294, 0.022152788937091827, 0.01318665873259306, 0.05700277164578438, -0.08080126345157623, 0.004084200598299503, -0.011845055967569351, 0.043661464005708694, -0.0005621896707452834, 0.010241283103823662, -0.04887997359037399, -0.008591520600020885, 0.02283218502998352, 0.024941740557551384, -0.023145806044340134, -0.042273249477148056, 0.01038357149809599, -0.02126883529126644, -0.015562358312308788, -0.008369033224880695, -0.021358802914619446, 0.034791249781847, -0.0026461577508598566, -0.0003122098569292575, 0.061145197600126266, 0.02981037087738514, 0.06649760901927948, 0.07025201618671417, -0.0012083635665476322, 0.014563089236617088, 0.016404135152697563, -0.005041876807808876, 0.021751733496785164, 0.029948865994811058, -0.019634272903203964, 0.03416066616773605, -0.0017972956411540508, -0.04134402051568031, -0.10779144614934921, -0.03760651499032974, 0.032068926841020584, 0.027302375063300133, 0.07512401789426804, -0.0353403203189373, -0.05469445139169693, 0.02521444857120514, -0.03738347068428993, -0.02726328745484352, 0.07473403215408325, 0.017924586310982704, -0.03946647047996521, -0.05788994953036308, -0.09826391190290451, 0.011073855683207512, 0.005661326926201582, -0.01576600968837738, -0.042597416788339615, -0.051309503614902496, -0.0051077282987535, 0.013405751436948776, 0.015455621294677258, 0.019818458706140518, -0.011369390413165092, 0.02772635780274868, -0.02070513740181923, 0.027760811150074005, 0.0860166847705841, -0.01704266294836998, -0.008206618018448353, -0.016116298735141754, 0.024934139102697372, 0.03714216873049736, -0.02764577977359295, 0.034154973924160004, 0.053229328244924545, -0.0069082919508218765, 0.013936725445091724, -0.03149048611521721, -0.000810328230727464, 0.08431322127580643, -0.010543502867221832, -0.0027882445137947798, 0.020196355879306793, -0.027495862916111946, 0.02123960666358471, 0.006409891415387392, 0.013388078659772873, 0.011010159738361835, 0.016574829816818237, -0.008114608004689217, -0.024702847003936768, 0.08197984844446182, -0.0372501015663147, 0.02631593495607376, 0.07134883105754852, -0.026556678116321564, -0.03395412862300873, -0.00003959276000387035, -0.016977515071630478, -0.02516818605363369, 0.06703180819749832, 0.010193121619522572, 0.010506192222237587, 0.06067201495170593, 0.0676291286945343, -0.060336634516716, -0.004655820317566395, -0.05875779688358307, 0.014534242451190948, -0.04809324070811272, 0.04277393966913223, -0.012003435753285885, -0.05131761357188225, -0.0120064876973629, -0.002453380962833762, -0.003599722171202302, 0.01783868856728077, 0.015268665738403797, 0.0012421696446835995, 0.061025235801935196, 0.030212437734007835, -0.008788752369582653, -0.06676963716745377, -0.04544100910425186, 0.014396989718079567, 0.021217474713921547, -0.1071573868393898, -0.04925281181931496, -0.01651211455464363, -0.016987718641757965, -0.022938204929232597, -0.08935517817735672, -0.01707063801586628, -0.04381704330444336, -0.08218329399824142, 0.006226808298379183, 0.025210268795490265, -0.006450317334383726, -0.04339636117219925, 0.004191685933619738, 0.03451858460903168, 0.006480042822659016, 0.03119424544274807, 0.028296729549765587, 0.03210293501615524, 0.011433153413236141, 0.04507355019450188, -0.04227098822593689, 0.016970353201031685, -0.0388345941901207, -0.01838185265660286, -0.014560180716216564, -0.001553581329062581, 0.06303215771913528, 0.01948586478829384, -0.03774525225162506, -0.010683789849281311, 0.044066786766052246, 0.03252366557717323, 0.016560938209295273, -0.004954592790454626, -0.028330817818641663, 0.026384856551885605, -0.0052166893146932125, -0.058774933218955994, 0.02294239029288292, 0.024168971925973892, 0.020288655534386635, -0.03462336212396622, -0.029646411538124084, -0.05383981764316559, 0.08255967497825623, 0.003967138938605785, -0.0023893595207482576, -0.011283914558589458, -0.07034315913915634, 0.061454206705093384, -0.01469216588884592, 0.048849817365407944, 0.0033507831394672394, 0.02010626345872879, 0.07825468480587006, -0.011582702398300171, 0.06729692220687866, -0.06305325031280518, 0.04245201125741005, 0.02220168337225914, 0.0159793421626091, -0.01731286756694317, 0.042325496673583984, -0.009341304190456867, 0.016847675666213036, 0.07108692824840546, -0.028567666187882423, -0.05068865045905113, -0.035817477852106094, -0.022162167355418205, -0.009164679795503616, 0.003710641758516431, 0.023493992164731026, 0.014811478555202484, -0.05035398527979851, 0.05418086051940918, 0.01570074073970318, -0.060097306966781616, 0.04543468728661537, 0.05294182896614075, 0.024590522050857544, -0.016434278339147568, -0.04384581744670868, 0.04416916146874428, 0.0227655116468668, -0.05658956244587898, 0.04058525711297989, 0.07910158485174179, 0.0013716180110350251, 0.0164453387260437, -0.0007180089014582336, -0.004019836895167828, -0.06832288205623627, -0.010714508593082428, 0.03983201086521149, -0.052324339747428894, -0.0018285339465364814, -0.004773723427206278, -0.04570198059082031, 0.013644211925566196, 0.0516495406627655, 0.020472124218940735, 0.020771877840161324, -0.0551484040915966, -0.03543969243764877, -0.032105132937431335, 0.020417306572198868, -0.023374758660793304, -0.020329611375927925, -0.02235042117536068, -0.0042509716004133224, 0.00732671283185482, -0.013629654422402382, -0.007420998997986317, -0.0019482854986563325, 0.037519633769989014, -0.019351575523614883, 0.021519673988223076, -0.05142352357506752, 0.011799594387412071, 0.06747827678918839, 0.06322551518678665, -0.006747860461473465, 0.03842095658183098, 0.004361536353826523, 0.03554750606417656, -0.04514627903699875, -0.01727789267897606, -0.035752590745687485, -0.03425540402531624, -0.03987063467502594, 0.03519849106669426, -0.040744632482528687, -0.015744172036647797, 0.00277518667280674, -0.08095306903123856, -0.05806100368499756, -0.017694415524601936, 0.06528471410274506, 0.05902426689863205, -0.020846961066126823, -0.02749028615653515, 0.005863268859684467, -0.04134385660290718, -0.052929069846868515, -0.03884340077638626, -0.04373326897621155, 0.021909749135375023, -0.02403249219059944, 0.008387589827179909, -0.012628565542399883, -0.06682030856609344, 0.021633906289935112, -0.005734862759709358, 0.01920776627957821, -0.017246248200535774, 0.06663982570171356, -0.061444174498319626, -0.03352285921573639, 0.08909137547016144, 0.023697156459093094, -0.015933189541101456, 0.026052875444293022, -0.02708929404616356, 0.009945143014192581, 0.040154118090867996, 0.07408985495567322, 0.00449430150911212, -0.02073213830590248, -0.024806274101138115, -0.002223244169726968, 0.036954931914806366, 0.024354824796319008, -0.007844260893762112, -0.07873296737670898, 0.005990485195070505, -0.002711991313844919, -0.02149713784456253, 0.039137858897447586, 0.014975829049944878, -0.04672935977578163, 0.061013735830783844, 0.01983269490301609, 0.028859613463282585, -0.004649769980460405, -0.004979008808732033, 0.031825825572013855, 0.030180294066667557, -0.013110185042023659, 0.03145911917090416, -0.008062025532126427, -0.028319688513875008, 0.03592263534665108, 0.03792083263397217, 0.009159444831311703, 0.023330535739660263, 0.029601506888866425, 0.0027987787034362555, -0.02076958492398262, -0.047745008021593094, 0.005647250916808844, -0.06037447229027748, -0.019346732646226883, 0.04582982510328293, 0.0036790857557207346, -0.051681749522686005, -0.015940723940730095, 0.02465301752090454, -0.028847480192780495, 0.00039776929770596325, 0.02838888205587864, 0.014396161772310734, -0.01029643788933754, 0.034883689135313034, 0.059104859828948975, 0.009951593354344368, 0.043329667299985886, 0.03239086642861366, 0.009834349155426025, 0.019555963575839996, 0.005660584662109613, -0.023816227912902832, 0.05317993834614754, -0.03149779513478279, -0.009147313423454762, -0.04625551775097847, 0.01588772051036358, -0.01857171766459942, -0.005019690841436386, -0.07418467849493027, -0.018347935751080513, 0.025184500962495804, -0.017996205016970634, -0.04295140132308006, -0.007379600312560797, 0.03749793395400047, -0.0015668270643800497, -0.0066060274839401245, -0.009487583301961422, -0.019274458289146423, 0.0660056471824646, 0.04308077320456505, 0.01574178785085678, -0.00926730502396822, 0.03442186117172241, -0.029117943719029427, 0.0225575752556324, -0.01033972017467022, 0.00905807688832283, 0.03130091354250908, 0.027938654646277428, 0.03376675397157669, -0.03286252170801163, -0.009299514815211296, 0.0034966072998940945, -0.0792665034532547, -0.009824147447943687, -0.023702969774603844, -0.0192167479544878, -0.01772664301097393, -0.01860954612493515, -0.0008110030903480947, 0.01580829545855522, 0.007258034311234951, 0.014462769962847233, -0.020360494032502174, -0.04234982654452324, 0.030529839918017387, 0.03846799209713936, -0.027051817625761032, 0.01870628446340561, -0.06603200733661652, 0.02322068065404892, -0.028146661818027496, -0.008641691878437996, 0.03797953203320503, -0.029730018228292465, -0.03603673726320267, -0.008088197559118271, 0.028870996087789536, -0.013985160738229752, 0.012593932449817657, -0.0702175572514534, -0.02002556063234806, -0.05024697259068489, 0.010281500406563282, -0.009107567369937897, -0.02324490435421467, -0.028451159596443176, 0.024191061034798622, 0.03898250684142113, 0.022862348705530167, 0.016196630895137787, -0.05305449664592743, 0.03922833874821663, -0.05985918268561363, -0.04460896551609039, 0.017635520547628403, 0.03127705305814743, 0.010468955151736736, 0.022374842315912247, 0.012347233481705189, -0.015465691685676575, -0.01953294686973095, 0.042184893041849136, 0.017338205128908157, 0.031208088621497154, 0.030242711305618286, 0.0940207988023758, 0.017517056316137314, -0.05296358838677406, 0.004181455820798874, -0.014106418006122112, -0.05690288171172142, 0.04969984292984009, -0.05050013214349747, -0.050570644438266754, 0.025072818621993065, 0.07301320135593414, 0.003748276038095355, -0.036096807569265366, 0.012668817304074764, 0.007538504898548126, 0.013917404226958752, -0.0004235498490743339, 0.017664926126599312, 0.06659600883722305, 0.004615378100425005, 0.0337824784219265, 0.0008520330302417278, 0.02830570749938488, -0.0025713874492794275, -0.030123338103294373, -0.00023442000383511186, 0.012820880860090256, -0.02613295614719391, 0.011735007166862488, -0.04686899110674858, 0.023718900978565216, -0.028467727825045586, -0.0738493800163269, -0.009238461032509804, -0.055420342832803726, -0.09182443469762802, 0.03568260744214058, 0.005347191821783781, -0.018928583711385727, 0.03783610090613365, -0.001685991999693215, -0.04840729385614395, -0.06152500584721565, -0.02385915070772171, -0.043341998010873795, -0.01132911629974842, -0.02796497941017151, 0.07481086254119873, -0.022463645786046982, 0.0325913242995739, 0.01550855953246355, 0.014225464314222336, 0.00884223822504282, -0.011684603057801723, -0.00188758026342839, -0.029997199773788452, 0.01836693473160267, 0.06237887218594551, -0.024094531312584877, -0.04173727706074715, 0.026396891102194786, -0.03992852568626404, 0.03380536660552025, 0.012731495313346386, 0.034096140414476395, 0.08139333128929138, -0.008994005620479584, -0.059741828590631485, 0.028179578483104706, 0.00144876295235008, -0.014943110756576061, -0.036370545625686646, -0.03383956104516983, -0.0654943585395813, 0.003951473627239466, 0.023640744388103485, 0.019770285114645958, 0.045920561999082565, -0.019895313307642937, -0.009878333657979965, 0.04050030559301376, -0.028773419559001923, -0.03692443296313286, -0.006742036901414394, -0.10777542740106583, -0.026137547567486763, 0.020770031958818436, -0.02892131358385086, -0.0042612263932824135, 0.022615564987063408, 0.020166514441370964, -0.056820373982191086, -0.01155439019203186, -0.016031980514526367, -0.017751259729266167, -0.0023348871618509293, -0.03206322342157364, 0.07541193813085556, -0.05166936293244362, -0.013211805373430252, -0.03102703019976616, 0.015523036941885948, -0.008818292059004307, 0.01810920611023903, -0.06980208307504654, 0.0496273934841156, -0.0005622979369945824, -0.007621625903993845, -0.022401444613933563, -0.03538466617465019, 0.025422409176826477, -0.003958888351917267, 0.03778127580881119, 0.05162277817726135, -0.018249819055199623, -0.029316989704966545, -0.015585998073220253, -0.015535987913608551, -0.00933699868619442, -0.0007449678378179669, 0.0738641545176506, 0.042131826281547546, 0.004169100429862738, -0.009238620288670063, -0.06070715934038162, 0.009273356758058071, 0.0025002688635140657, -0.013402773067355156, -0.017625464126467705, -0.011949240230023861, 0.06829671561717987, -0.007578974589705467, -0.0008855133783072233, 0.08328692615032196, -0.008022570051252842, 0.04553862288594246, 0.006298305466771126, -0.03258379548788071, -0.07355543971061707, 0.011985472403466702, -0.021797431632876396, 0.029200933873653412, -0.057907093316316605, 0.015717381611466408, 0.00777219096198678, 0.012352732010185719, 0.04351798817515373, -0.025363096967339516, -0.0037063134368509054, -0.007506674155592918, -0.01909000799059868, -0.026124922558665276, -0.004507441073656082, 0.00027002417482435703, 0.009969588369131088, -0.051906079053878784, -0.012908189557492733, 0.03710247203707695, -0.013453954830765724, 0.008898797444999218, -0.055742841213941574, 0.012999489903450012, 0.01222604513168335, 0.038510024547576904, 0.0032963757403194904, -0.05353105813264847, 0.044790685176849365, 0.013122180476784706, -0.0523303747177124, -0.03733057901263237, 0.03016096167266369, 0.05252071097493172, 0.0106350714340806, 0.02665325254201889, 0.003379127010703087, -0.11685764789581299, -0.015312380157411098, -0.0014126264723017812, 0.03020298294723034, -0.014902153983712196, 0.04154447466135025, -0.03639981895685196, 0.005167872179299593, 0.009324589744210243, -0.01837804540991783, 0.06376821547746658, 0.010056552477180958, -0.023712461814284325, 0.03324229642748833, -0.011082280427217484, 0.027031295001506805, -0.007279208395630121, -0.007743626832962036, -0.044132933020591736, -0.0014513678615912795, -0.04191499948501587, 0.0635504350066185, -0.008434507995843887, -0.019771896302700043, -0.04750021919608116, 0.02834361046552658, -0.0027614738792181015, -0.01591094769537449, -0.006331251002848148, 0.09377936273813248, 0.018817037343978882, -0.010633337311446667, -0.06939326226711273, 0.007272681687027216, -0.008609048090875149, -0.015508844517171383, -0.010260301642119884, 0.009347430430352688, 0.021196547895669937, -0.028959667310118675, -0.035128556191921234, -0.0867915153503418, -0.004443412180989981, -0.045562583953142166, 0.01579190604388714, 0.047774046659469604, 0.030334319919347763, -0.0051634423434734344, -0.007365259807556868, 0.017750825732946396, -0.021334880962967873, -0.010396008379757404, -0.01773850806057453, -0.0343267023563385, -0.020922360941767693, 0.016970401629805565, -0.0480392687022686, -0.046398717910051346, -0.060952018946409225, 0.057964906096458435, 0.00662850309163332, -0.025910509750247, -0.009972384199500084, -0.030955510213971138, -0.03472160920500755, 0.028874043375253677, 0.050628289580345154, 0.007472287863492966, 0.052573081105947495, 0.04422921687364578, 0.02665218897163868, -0.07542867213487625, 0.04668787494301796, 0.03515876829624176, 0.014762983657419682, -0.040879517793655396, 0.04829394444823265, -0.05695096030831337, -0.03448381647467613, 0.019053861498832703, -0.0003805911692325026, -0.031205782666802406, -0.029303284361958504, -0.006314674858003855, -0.015700865536928177, -0.005233753938227892, 0.019147589802742004, -0.02809988334774971, -0.04898405075073242, -0.08200989663600922, -0.006158156786113977, 0.02745760791003704, 0.02354997768998146, 0.006831849459558725, 0.013721313327550888, -0.023771081119775772, -0.005651059560477734, -0.001009895815514028, -0.05182436481118202, -0.045851029455661774, 0.027707692235708237 ]
<p>Studying quantum mechanics, I've found an exercise I don't know how to solve it. Given the radial Schrödinger equation, </p> <p>$$\left [ \frac{d^2}{dr^2}+k^2-\frac{2m}{\hbar^2}\lambda U\left ( r \right ) \right ]\psi_\lambda {\left ( r \right )}= 0$$</p> <p>and doing whatever integrals are required, I have to show that:</p> <p>$$\int_{0}^{R}\psi_\lambda {\left ( r \right )}U\psi_\lambda {\left ( r \right )}dr=\left [ \psi_\lambda \frac{\partial^2 \psi_\lambda}{\partial r\partial\lambda}-\frac{\partial \psi_\lambda}{\partial r}\frac{\partial \psi_\lambda}{\partial \lambda} \right ]_{0}^{R}.$$</p> <p>I tried to see if integration by parts, or <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hellmann%E2%80%93Feynman_theorem" rel="nofollow">Hellmann-Feynman theorem</a> may help, but no luck. Any ideas?</p> <p>Updated: Following the indications given by @joshphysics (thanks!), I get, for the first step:</p> <p>$$ \frac{\partial }{\partial \lambda} \frac{d^2\psi_\lambda}{dr^2}+k^2\frac{\partial \psi_\lambda}{\partial \lambda}-\frac{2m}{\hbar^2}\lambda U\left ( r \right ) \frac{\partial \psi_\lambda}{\partial \lambda}-\frac{2m}{\hbar^2}U\left ( r \right ) \psi_\lambda =0$$ And using the original equation, to eliminate the lambda-dependent term, I get: $$\frac{\partial }{\partial \lambda} \frac{d^2\psi_\lambda}{dr^2}+k^2\frac{\partial \psi_\lambda}{\partial \lambda}-\frac{d^2\psi_\lambda {\left ( r \right )}}{dr^2}-k^2\psi_\lambda {\left ( r \right )}-\frac{2m}{\hbar^2}U\left ( r \right ) \psi_\lambda= 0$$. How do I eliminate the k dependent terms?</p>
g1598
[ 0.023185906931757927, -0.014370681717991829, 0.017335260286927223, -0.07644347101449966, 0.03292672708630562, -0.03274520859122276, 0.0006552331615239382, 0.02523512952029705, -0.03381796553730965, 0.022146837785840034, -0.02886100672185421, 0.01689179241657257, -0.06100277602672577, 0.047594476491212845, 0.02654963545501232, 0.018026165664196014, 0.019875722005963326, 0.0009546906803734601, -0.021907329559326172, -0.021457092836499214, -0.0846557691693306, 0.05774671584367752, -0.010332491248846054, -0.0295609962195158, 0.02172861248254776, -0.058835286647081375, -0.016882576048374176, -0.0023617080878466368, -0.03611904755234718, 0.010557053610682487, -0.00023782979405950755, 0.011326087638735771, 0.02553458884358406, -0.050351761281490326, 0.04227199777960777, 0.01521963533014059, 0.0634685754776001, 0.01742449402809143, -0.023407280445098877, -0.03876281529664993, 0.010123293846845627, -0.031591031700372696, -0.024851011112332344, -0.0322793610394001, 0.033881962299346924, -0.04418826475739479, 0.05371321737766266, 0.040850020945072174, 0.010087914764881134, 0.04045173153281212, 0.01926468312740326, 0.02840113453567028, 0.05743572115898132, -0.0329558365046978, 0.014619882218539715, 0.015574165619909763, 0.023163095116615295, -0.05915576219558716, 0.06766314804553986, 0.019797755405306816, 0.0751265212893486, -0.06578855961561203, -0.03248265013098717, 0.026404011994600296, 0.04663959518074989, -0.04343119636178017, 0.007963084615767002, -0.007458162028342485, -0.05342363566160202, 0.030359137803316116, -0.006303379312157631, -0.07444576919078827, 0.006039302796125412, 0.013717739842832088, -0.01567709445953369, 0.014649728313088417, 0.04108825698494911, 0.012955689802765846, 0.049901027232408524, -0.0074463896453380585, -0.050034962594509125, -0.0013257196405902505, 0.00865101907402277, -0.012997491285204887, -0.022832732647657394, 0.024542860686779022, -0.017889026552438736, -0.05082043260335922, -0.025975391268730164, 0.04808729887008667, 0.02664746716618538, 0.029316866770386696, 0.029405273497104645, -0.025253240019083023, 0.03754008188843727, -0.021931182593107224, -0.024678505957126617, 0.045419931411743164, 0.015793466940522194, -0.04583460092544556, -0.01695939153432846, -0.025087805464863777, 0.048008307814598083, -0.006624977570027113, 0.00571237551048398, -0.02168489247560501, 0.00832300167530775, 0.03181788697838783, 0.010396607220172882, -0.03155042231082916, -0.025672541931271553, 0.006017006002366543, -0.030887721106410027, -0.0359920971095562, -0.010434523224830627, -0.024098224937915802, 0.021185634657740593, -0.009104478172957897, -0.008074733428657055, 0.05276660993695259, 0.03909798711538315, 0.012427335605025291, 0.04133057966828346, 0.01767967827618122, 0.0035531918983906507, -0.004645841661840677, -0.08101709932088852, -0.004959197714924812, 0.0421157032251358, -0.015025628730654716, -0.00294365081936121, -0.0012573135318234563, 0.03392587602138519, -0.0019625136628746986, -0.014166966080665588, 0.06398990750312805, -0.02245689556002617, -0.00979419145733118, -0.01422673836350441, -0.007451416924595833, 0.007996872067451477, -0.04538080096244812, -0.016368664801120758, 0.061843141913414, -0.032617732882499695, -0.017265580594539642, 0.004699463956058025, -0.05187930911779404, 0.002596466103568673, -0.012422203086316586, 0.018796438351273537, 0.021297669038176537, -0.027674999088048935, 0.0215299129486084, -0.0045927781611680984, 0.006171399261802435, 0.02225121483206749, -0.04944195598363876, 0.05334526300430298, -0.04047408327460289, 0.009005405008792877, 0.05485355854034424, -0.007454743608832359, -0.029386913403868675, -0.01870029978454113, 0.07880382984876633, 0.010300002992153168, -0.013354050926864147, 0.042839184403419495, -0.04758918285369873, 0.0260337982326746, -0.014234364964067936, -0.05612822249531746, 0.01482208538800478, 0.009878774173557758, 0.14221054315567017, -0.03183114528656006, -0.0029689182993024588, -0.05027924105525017, 0.02712579444050789, -0.010276240296661854, -0.07228374481201172, 0.054894011467695236, -0.046387385576963425, 0.0059614419005811214, 0.007950096391141415, 0.012116195634007454, 0.039989277720451355, -0.03279896080493927, -0.08948531001806259, 0.0173772182315588, 0.029525119811296463, 0.07231036573648453, 0.007142296992242336, -0.016643326729536057, -0.012621749192476273, -0.011172234080731869, -0.029171215370297432, 0.018768399953842163, 0.03419217839837074, 0.026530321687459946, 0.00982210785150528, 0.05311194434762001, 0.0054144649766385555, 0.0327179841697216, -0.045080702751874924, -0.016688020899891853, -0.016336575150489807, 0.0749438926577568, -0.0402560718357563, 0.02571718394756317, 0.022458000108599663, 0.04010041058063507, 0.00388487265445292, 0.009055129252374172, -0.013052641414105892, -0.004811495076864958, -0.028475357219576836, -0.020665038377046585, 0.012854455038905144, 0.005419187247753143, 0.015407580882310867, 0.021612515673041344, 0.019421229138970375, 0.05238909274339676, 0.06540706753730774, -0.041815705597400665, 0.028601106256246567, -0.09128878265619278, 0.009307095780968666, 0.005695037543773651, 0.01606503687798977, -0.018248964101076126, -0.054197441786527634, 0.05868912115693092, 0.017709881067276, -0.008239686489105225, 0.030858788639307022, -0.008646347559988499, 0.04162422940135002, -0.0025180766824632883, 0.013751978054642677, 0.0026321117766201496, -0.010346981696784496, 0.029464032500982285, 0.01416809018701315, 0.028859999030828476, -0.00700315972790122, -0.027961205691099167, 0.0035595009103417397, 0.017098035663366318, -0.018754413351416588, 0.0005578383570536971, -0.05693754181265831, -0.022578518837690353, 0.03078441321849823, -0.03957858309149742, 0.00644685560837388, 0.017010077834129333, -0.058335479348897934, -0.05130118876695633, -0.005886416882276535, 0.03057851828634739, 0.05444116145372391, -0.07501295208930969, -0.02514719031751156, -0.029569173231720924, -0.0335213765501976, 0.050987184047698975, 0.013853565789759159, -0.04593956470489502, 0.05385133624076843, -0.07337720692157745, 0.022319160401821136, 0.004109929781407118, -0.04884977266192436, 0.007916281931102276, 0.016558008268475533, 0.010082190856337547, 0.0700412467122078, 0.05052504315972328, -0.043550554662942886, -0.03908936679363251, 0.06683614104986191, -0.015148580074310303, -0.021449266001582146, -0.0108120646327734, 0.06854002177715302, 0.03869521990418434, -0.02005460113286972, 0.041792429983615875, 0.03097154013812542, 0.00932676624506712, -0.004520537797361612, 0.006209804676473141, -0.04466704651713371, 0.045942582190036774, -0.01851963810622692, 0.017890773713588715, 0.01603391207754612, 0.007537452038377523, 0.004632301162928343, -0.009435112588107586, 0.004024236463010311, -0.0064471145160496235, -0.02113441936671734, -0.06904562562704086, -0.060627084225416183, -0.0015868858899921179, -0.01354367844760418, 0.04863922670483589, -0.011033196933567524, -0.02704436704516411, -0.0019235084764659405, 0.010843740776181221, 0.053435154259204865, 0.018145903944969177, -0.006713257171213627, 0.05215977132320404, 0.017168007791042328, -0.03529757633805275, -0.06490711122751236, 0.00995734054595232, -0.01992681436240673, 0.026625240221619606, 0.0046562980860471725, -0.02999676764011383, -0.011842732317745686, -0.02084708772599697, 0.0008353898883797228, -0.006271077319979668, 0.015096660703420639, 0.02430771477520466, -0.03788398578763008, -0.07577519863843918, -0.048831868916749954, -0.032811883836984634, 0.007980086840689182, 0.02547561377286911, -0.003058353206142783, -0.02888161689043045, -0.03889555111527443, -0.010875792242586613, -0.0055144187062978745, -0.04570950195193291, -0.01964395120739937, -0.029840078204870224, 0.03444019332528114, 0.05470012128353119, 0.009517713449895382, -0.03723626956343651, 0.0285513736307621, 0.03204081580042839, -0.020622435957193375, -0.017010601237416267, 0.004377157427370548, 0.015951670706272125, 0.012054016813635826, 0.004204460419714451, -0.026575984433293343, 0.01538139209151268, -0.03982989490032196, -0.045353010296821594, 0.010747500695288181, 0.009315394796431065, -0.06711243838071823, 0.04326638579368591, 0.0562068335711956, -0.025681113824248314, -0.04087274149060249, 0.006082761101424694, 0.01657763496041298, 0.012113179080188274, 0.051227789372205734, -0.005296688061207533, -0.027586380019783974, -0.05199255794286728, 0.015849092975258827, -0.0308032538741827, 0.04027397558093071, -0.0638934001326561, 0.09785039722919464, -0.016835814341902733, 0.06626482307910919, 0.042107269167900085, 0.01547031570225954, 0.019177978858351707, -0.020191989839076996, 0.043759752064943314, 0.055671028792858124, 0.0025810636579990387, -0.0107375243678689, -0.05354643240571022, 0.044631801545619965, -0.040761902928352356, 0.013510116375982761, 0.03959245607256889, -0.00380143360234797, -0.02675631269812584, 0.041159603744745255, -0.0066253431141376495, 0.005383556243032217, 0.016469821333885193, -0.022743267938494682, -0.04127582907676697, -0.011147111654281616, -0.005469636991620064, -0.02793307602405548, 0.028462745249271393, 0.010351630859076977, -0.00584512809291482, -0.005415385123342276, 0.013474611565470695, -0.02242456190288067, 0.007280015852302313, -0.033532265573740005, 0.02311735600233078, -0.03408243507146835, -0.01499131042510271, -0.025741592049598694, 0.0075514307245612144, 0.00998060591518879, -0.012751066125929356, 0.004220576025545597, 0.034650105983018875, -0.00906483456492424, 0.06937924772500992, 0.04384899511933327, -0.015388588421046734, -0.0524132139980793, -0.020434202626347542, -0.03416626900434494, 0.011195805855095387, 0.04040643572807312, -0.013888061046600342, -0.009969741106033325, -0.031246507540345192, -0.026555873453617096, -0.020036492496728897, 0.032748688012361526, 0.004199762362986803, -0.021823691204190254, -0.023857656866312027, -0.012244469486176968, -0.010946626774966717, 0.048431023955345154, -0.04551059752702713, -0.06035972386598587, 0.0028778831474483013, -0.007793407887220383, -0.029379764571785927, 0.038820501416921616, 0.03766689449548721, 0.03525899723172188, -0.04925912991166115, -0.024575332179665565, -0.06343625485897064, 0.030260035768151283, 0.07282421737909317, 0.01582598127424717, -0.08019033819437027, -0.016884323209524155, -0.017908133566379547, -0.0042821550741791725, 0.03823313117027283, -0.021914232522249222, -0.02133055031299591, 0.04628148302435875, -0.05882594734430313, -0.03655704855918884, 0.015797749161720276, 0.0011827939888462424, 0.03665582463145256, -0.05790606513619423, -0.015332071110606194, -0.014524855650961399, 0.006793123669922352, -0.045349277555942535, 0.062048815190792084, -0.021917270496487617, 0.018711088225245476, -0.005082169082015753, 0.03232717141509056, 0.06819744408130646, 0.011107048951089382, 0.018790485337376595, -0.024271629750728607, -0.017881594598293304, -0.0693855807185173, -0.020504847168922424, 0.007274927105754614, 0.05281069502234459, -0.005505541805177927, 0.02482684515416622, 0.009116485714912415, 0.044476576149463654, 0.05144123360514641, -0.036474473774433136, 0.042496271431446075, -0.005302090663462877, -0.028335200622677803, 0.02793952450156212, -0.007091763895004988, -0.06177704036235809, -0.03883996978402138, 0.05597367137670517, 0.05188988521695137, 0.03099329210817814, 0.04890459030866623, 0.007706175558269024, -0.0028745532035827637, -0.0635773092508316, 0.016173990443348885, -0.005778148304671049, -0.0007369224331341684, -0.009668892249464989, -0.0461813248693943, 0.012049495242536068, -0.015843577682971954, -0.006195006892085075, 0.09859085828065872, 0.028491076081991196, 0.010166270658373833, -0.015828413888812065, 0.0290414709597826, 0.0025320551358163357, -0.03781436011195183, -0.03601020202040672, -0.042751312255859375, 0.025687985122203827, 0.01067068986594677, -0.0501461923122406, -0.01564626581966877, -0.004098349250853062, 0.033621203154325485, 0.006454582791775465, 0.015594241209328175, -0.008127260021865368, -0.006435798946768045, 0.029290955513715744, 0.03962908685207367, 0.013485699892044067, 0.02368985489010811, -0.013872259296476841, -0.12955182790756226, -0.003994153346866369, 0.03340651094913483, -0.017121819779276848, 0.031224854290485382, -0.02384576015174389, -0.007810530252754688, -0.038764555007219315, -0.037639111280441284, -0.012106135487556458, 0.04228057339787483, -0.03299560770392418, 0.034357670694589615, -0.05547480657696724, -0.03836028650403023, 0.030803540721535683, 0.08605090528726578, -0.04252219572663307, 0.04659070819616318, 0.021408651024103165, -0.009313486516475677, -0.03511257469654083, -0.03882183879613876, -0.026775451377034187, 0.06349539756774902, 0.026775071397423744, -0.07349512726068497, 0.03458463028073311, -0.01632315292954445, 0.008646654896438122, 0.02755897119641304, 0.01593589223921299, -0.005523958243429661, -0.008269860409200191, 0.05182019993662834, 0.014170544221997261, -0.04989444464445114, 0.05407014489173889, 0.08195964992046356, -0.05609550327062607, -0.022191815078258514, 0.0775841772556305, -0.034128881990909576, 0.0018787089502438903, 0.0020010245498269796, 0.05447693169116974, -0.037773389369249344, 0.0560290664434433, -0.043113332241773605, -0.03311024606227875, -0.0021666213870048523, -0.06812290102243423, 0.07465074956417084, -0.01132832933217287, -0.012841233983635902, 0.026603711768984795, -0.016356876119971275, -0.05318804085254669, 0.03250022605061531, 0.01181197352707386, 0.044334474951028824, -0.03719085454940796, -0.04483863711357117, -0.042337268590927124, 0.015513567253947258, 0.04088030755519867, -0.056637007743120193, 0.0407358817756176, 0.005329192150384188, 0.032065290957689285, 0.02322789840400219, -0.08379639685153961, 0.06828027963638306, 0.06651799380779266, 0.010169523768126965, -0.014213528484106064, 0.08013729751110077, 0.024755684658885002, 0.01015075109899044, 0.0036359350197017193, -0.001967990305274725, 0.010967963375151157, -0.014066223986446857, -0.008651706390082836, 0.04558902978897095, -0.013530654832720757, 0.03987567871809006, -0.0005773741868324578, -0.013084663078188896, -0.00010581617971183732, -0.021859128028154373, 0.026325605809688568, -0.02662120945751667, -0.01643204130232334, 0.06288883090019226, 0.02514202892780304, -0.0209368783980608, -0.03136663883924484, 0.038593877106904984, -0.05829375609755516, -0.06456650793552399, 0.01293880119919777, 0.012344672344624996, -0.02513471245765686, -0.08851385861635208, 0.009247880429029465, 0.058701492846012115, 0.008847703225910664, -0.021648168563842773, -0.038550715893507004, -0.01885262504220009, -0.03988872841000557, -0.023194899782538414, 0.04139463230967522, 0.0019175148336216807, -0.09031626582145691, -0.04297500103712082, -0.00620733667165041, -0.000020524101273622364, -0.027218889445066452, -0.028658133000135422, 0.05848978832364082, 0.008973958902060986, 0.04127667471766472, 0.004458996932953596, -0.057575732469558716, 0.0002212635736213997, 0.040336474776268005, -0.0027449207846075296, 0.008544997312128544, -0.002378792269155383, 0.012842997908592224, 0.05289900675415993, 0.0060761128552258015, -0.011127145029604435, 0.0023484278935939074, -0.04774788022041321, 0.024098850786685944, -0.04487621411681175, -0.02867979183793068, 0.006416113581508398, -0.03290968015789986, 0.0606524832546711, -0.028562750667333603, 0.02433309145271778, 0.07769913226366043, -0.011413872241973877, 0.05688564479351044, -0.013926749117672443, 0.01709638722240925, -0.014195618219673634, -0.016884544864296913, 0.035038791596889496, -0.012435725890100002, 0.035332273691892624, 0.007445776369422674, -0.0051992288790643215, -0.07582730799913406, -0.01717469096183777, 0.052930645644664764, 0.017757687717676163, 0.02435632050037384, -0.06278978288173676, -0.07297253608703613, 0.02176305465400219, -0.009059485048055649, 0.0390818789601326, -0.0038940373342484236, -0.029098888859152794, 0.03961004316806793, 0.06987618654966354, -0.01720314845442772, -0.015493707731366158, 0.07287237793207169, 0.04511069506406784, -0.05836182087659836, -0.002598205814138055, 0.01718338020145893, 0.022264359518885612, -0.024264037609100342, -0.022005945444107056, -0.044696707278490067, -0.032741107046604156, -0.005287219304591417, 0.0028536233585327864, -0.030192781239748, 0.02202954888343811, 0.003928110934793949, -0.03012397140264511, 0.04895733669400215, 0.011187036521732807, -0.03173192963004112, -0.08468791097402573, -0.002993862610310316, 0.0002223327028332278, -0.03704579919576645, -0.004983144346624613, -0.0649932473897934, -0.023656558245420456, -0.034927137196063995, 0.0016839101444929838, -0.09331537783145905, -0.010119173675775528, 0.04671715945005417, 0.10034965723752975, -0.016541365534067154, -0.028158394619822502, -0.007505504414439201, -0.028338033705949783, -0.029083682224154472, 0.03958750516176224, -0.059537991881370544, 0.001677732914686203, 0.055063653737306595, 0.037938155233860016, 0.03136838600039482, 0.036379192024469376, -0.032471925020217896, -0.009159011766314507, 0.06783903390169144, 0.026501696556806564, -0.03886505961418152, -0.018370987847447395, -0.005084679462015629 ]
<p>Let's say you have two dipole type antennas. Antenna A has a gain of 2.15 dBi, a horizontal beam width of 360 deg and a vertical beam width of 45 deg. Antenna B is similar to antenna A, but has a horizontal beam width of 360 deg and a vertical beam width of 42 deg. Can you use the ratio of the vertical beam widths to predict the gain of antenna B?</p> <p>Note: In the application I'm asking about I'm not sure what method they used to calculate the beam widths. Maybe someone else knows which methods are most commonly used for dipole antennas.</p>
g1599
[ 0.0006799212424084544, -0.007722027599811554, 0.021884558722376823, -0.007587659638375044, -0.003943424206227064, -0.07018987834453583, 0.04418059065937996, -0.002827078104019165, 0.009081746451556683, -0.03591005131602287, -0.017501484602689743, 0.060765113681554794, 0.009062756784260273, -0.007114069070667028, 0.053215980529785156, -0.022210724651813507, 0.00801174808293581, -0.003927229437977076, -0.010949964635074139, -0.006079808343201876, 0.009892638772726059, 0.009850195609033108, -0.035744380205869675, -0.03900952264666557, -0.09797269850969315, 0.004328897688537836, -0.0772290825843811, 0.014934173785150051, -0.08274908363819122, 0.019451020285487175, -0.016672588884830475, -0.0028004662599414587, 0.06299386918544769, 0.0082933334633708, -0.03301355242729187, -0.04138750955462456, -0.021574070677161217, 0.01901770755648613, -0.043356455862522125, -0.024488195776939392, -0.01175914891064167, 0.007456128019839525, -0.05703982710838318, 0.04623470827937126, -0.021775882691144943, -0.0650893896818161, -0.023151783272624016, 0.010352848097682, -0.029567450284957886, 0.00437129195779562, -0.040131840854883194, 0.014860037714242935, 0.047852616757154465, -0.06572683155536652, 0.01629055291414261, -0.025217808783054352, -0.016605447977781296, -0.07710731029510498, 0.03196793049573898, 0.03966039791703224, 0.014960183762013912, 0.03802315890789032, -0.022544022649526596, -0.0008257019217126071, 0.0675804391503334, 0.018286271020770073, 0.007769130170345306, -0.05453992635011673, -0.04286637902259827, -0.007715889252722263, -0.026855913922190666, 0.0005257579032331705, 0.02831254154443741, -0.018420394510030746, -0.046837497502565384, -0.03905193880200386, 0.0004953888710588217, 0.012673933058977127, -0.012929612770676613, 0.058107711374759674, 0.011693447828292847, 0.015854503959417343, 0.007319807540625334, 0.0345192588865757, 0.02968974970281124, 0.033211011439561844, 0.03367786109447479, 0.012445541098713875, 0.029283542186021805, 0.027248505502939224, 0.015126204118132591, -0.025139888748526573, -0.000437362672528252, 0.06598193943500519, -0.01607504114508629, -0.05700144171714783, 0.007827352732419968, 0.03122694231569767, 0.02778111770749092, -0.020013228058815002, 0.005324856378138065, 0.05684715509414673, 0.026976391673088074, -0.007366891484707594, -0.0428677536547184, 0.047959472984075546, 0.02491539530456066, -0.05204504355788231, -0.016814982518553734, 0.01636430434882641, -0.027558187022805214, -0.041997019201517105, -0.025147275999188423, 0.03137871250510216, -0.0748591497540474, -0.035661179572343826, 0.01789378747344017, -0.03669978678226471, 0.028100423514842987, 0.07420013099908829, 0.03470912203192711, 0.007534923497587442, -0.040792159736156464, 0.042712584137916565, 0.017568521201610565, 0.017069442197680473, -0.03579873591661453, 0.03201736509799957, 0.06495051831007004, -0.003274237271398306, 0.02195540815591812, -0.06230907887220383, 0.00652345921844244, 0.05686977878212929, 0.04403579607605934, 0.03906203806400299, 0.03895706683397293, 0.03598242625594139, -0.017101747915148735, 0.015589023940265179, -0.011329792439937592, -0.016486898064613342, 0.026914410293102264, -0.0784033015370369, 0.007493336219340563, 0.04690806567668915, -0.025691716000437737, 0.006948417983949184, -0.005316602531820536, 0.06854847818613052, -0.03366756811738014, -0.007252014707773924, 0.02521102875471115, -0.019112715497612953, -0.021168217062950134, 0.016303889453411102, -0.038271065801382065, -0.01390133798122406, 0.04125658795237541, -0.012890617363154888, 0.007503808476030827, 0.004605629947036505, 0.0168080385774374, -0.04844451695680618, -0.0010008297394961119, -0.0064399950206279755, -0.005537788383662701, -0.03613532334566116, -0.0473572239279747, -0.04772228002548218, 0.04415459558367729, -0.005178928840905428, 0.041510459035634995, -0.03555247560143471, 0.016420943662524223, 0.055222611874341965, 0.0033437309321016073, 0.000668504333589226, 0.01982264034450054, 0.0523393452167511, -0.061958566308021545, 0.07540737092494965, 0.011552165262401104, 0.019361261278390884, 0.02177528291940689, -0.05399676784873009, 0.045819055289030075, -0.006016038823872805, -0.05210305005311966, 0.01698337495326996, -0.0034633453469723463, 0.005110653582960367, -0.0017800724599510431, 0.02072974108159542, -0.0759691447019577, -0.005179964937269688, 0.061247676610946655, 0.014818604104220867, 0.037557441741228104, 0.040855977684259415, -0.056098125874996185, 0.025791015475988388, 0.05958760529756546, 0.027112474665045738, 0.020904140546917915, -0.03472938761115074, -0.003560323966667056, 0.03291662409901619, 0.0713760256767273, -0.03735038638114929, 0.0152138601988554, 0.003875706112012267, 0.01128966175019741, 0.04995988309383392, 0.021846432238817215, -0.0007940572686493397, -0.0445982962846756, 0.053730957210063934, -0.039375726133584976, 0.0066782450303435326, -0.062243565917015076, -0.0233912393450737, 0.018628554418683052, -0.0006046776543371379, -0.050980422645807266, -0.06296356767416, 0.0258336178958416, 0.007496500387787819, 0.02224942296743393, -0.02168448455631733, -0.01384344045072794, -0.05598999932408333, -0.01626664027571678, 0.0077126650139689445, 0.03436289727687836, -0.004630516283214092, 0.012457475066184998, 0.052999332547187805, 0.04494300112128258, 0.039425138384103775, 0.0024235208984464407, -0.015207191929221153, 0.020934637635946274, 0.08146542310714722, -0.04498566314578056, -0.005769573617726564, 0.02822408825159073, -0.024430321529507637, -0.027120405808091164, 0.059708546847105026, -0.022194329649209976, 0.02429799921810627, -0.017141610383987427, 0.04212271794676781, -0.059417974203825, -0.021331235766410828, -0.07354447990655899, -0.007550104986876249, -0.007775672245770693, 0.03279712796211243, -0.0015953179681673646, 0.01686740852892399, 0.08103048801422119, 0.013755781576037407, -0.02749785967171192, -0.016237329691648483, -0.009919531643390656, -0.035193461924791336, -0.01736787147819996, 0.03494163230061531, -0.014242932200431824, 0.024079401046037674, -0.023157095536589622, 0.007716820575296879, -0.013714227825403214, -0.06772493571043015, 0.02438102848827839, 0.006983614526689053, 0.007637117989361286, -0.005646879784762859, -0.021810313686728477, 0.017764335498213768, -0.014966532588005066, 0.0971418172121048, 0.06840305775403976, -0.03158378601074219, -0.02841520681977272, -0.0019170799059793353, -0.020245105028152466, 0.03116999752819538, -0.04562116414308548, 0.018853073939681053, 0.13334016501903534, 0.0021916553378105164, -0.00982634350657463, -0.040708161890506744, 0.11716253310441971, -0.03211159631609917, 0.01178089901804924, 0.03827277570962906, -0.036791905760765076, 0.00012647519179154187, -0.014831947162747383, -0.032748717814683914, 0.08652839809656143, 0.06032691150903702, -0.03755622357130051, -0.03748922795057297, 0.015543373301625252, -0.039054568856954575, -0.07186166197061539, 0.03217305615544319, 0.057205576449632645, -0.06996221095323563, -0.03549639880657196, -0.03692571073770523, -0.0010400150204077363, -0.0019329336937516928, 0.015409871004521847, 0.018778249621391296, -0.004084029700607061, -0.046248659491539, 0.0025847824290394783, -0.0036095224786549807, -0.023182552307844162, 0.002170380437746644, -0.026109805330634117, 0.048940129578113556, -0.03186638653278351, -0.009483099915087223, -0.00862131081521511, -0.011360605247318745, -0.022671835497021675, 0.00500635476782918, 0.06708015501499176, -0.02704884111881256, 0.04061226546764374, -0.03902433440089226, -0.05599287524819374, -0.0035986555740237236, 0.01803550124168396, -0.041951075196266174, -0.026613660156726837, -0.01998603343963623, -0.03510332852602005, 0.012755746953189373, -0.008372833952307701, 0.05395856499671936, -0.023554762825369835, -0.02571284957230091, -0.0057097310200333595, 0.014410500414669514, 0.003837173106148839, 0.03153357282280922, 0.025817450135946274, 0.04799116402864456, 0.0017634937539696693, 0.00923664215952158, -0.019139420241117477, 0.01900678128004074, 0.03685545176267624, -0.005213149823248386, 0.005900392308831215, -0.045885976403951645, -0.023657644167542458, -0.010534718632698059, -0.009795163758099079, 0.030650068074464798, -0.001276451046578586, -0.08001372218132019, -0.027249973267316818, 0.0038864477537572384, -0.025812290608882904, -0.01427603792399168, -0.002949789399281144, -0.01770096644759178, -0.006291334982961416, -0.01937589794397354, -0.033013440668582916, 0.030116409063339233, -0.03859539330005646, 0.06866425275802612, -0.02827615849673748, 0.03394750505685806, -0.029369764029979706, -0.08629364520311356, -0.05483816936612129, 0.010184675455093384, 0.05792440474033356, 0.004905214533209801, 0.006892355624586344, -0.002161637879908085, -0.04196745902299881, 0.006375852506607771, -0.006039617583155632, -0.05454672873020172, 0.012657945044338703, 0.05687259882688522, -0.008052886463701725, 0.024631354957818985, 0.02102370746433735, 0.04097183793783188, -0.04111107066273689, -0.028232036158442497, 0.015753157436847687, -0.029409058392047882, -0.0009092930122278631, 0.0173711646348238, -0.055644240230321884, -0.005775886587798595, 0.02911536768078804, 0.0264586228877306, 0.03562808409333229, -0.02388004958629608, 0.018767498433589935, 0.002492002211511135, 0.025305645540356636, -0.07080762833356857, 0.052664779126644135, 0.05394012853503227, 0.014887995086610317, 0.058246877044439316, -0.012750244699418545, -0.027609551325440407, -0.00003281031968072057, 0.023029720410704613, 0.02190498076379299, 0.018947705626487732, 0.021896282210946083, -0.02462623454630375, 0.023990875110030174, -0.01540960744023323, -0.00798484031111002, -0.05786888673901558, 0.023923108354210854, 0.006493280176073313, 0.014444464817643166, 0.020670371130108833, 0.03062809631228447, 0.0029832751024514437, 0.002238920656964183, 0.0006477212882600725, -0.009883279912173748, 0.007783763110637665, -0.0012637877371162176, 0.062416139990091324, -0.06113378703594208, -0.015866676345467567, -0.005242368672043085, 0.019776957109570503, -0.0031498561147600412, -0.0015124049969017506, 0.00392011646181345, -0.07923820614814758, 0.03006339818239212, -0.014712481759488583, -0.022384481504559517, -0.0495326891541481, 0.08893236517906189, 0.02531193569302559, 0.006595809943974018, -0.039093345403671265, 0.009165698662400246, -0.00029327432275749743, 0.03334420919418335, 0.019728565588593483, -0.005724392831325531, -0.02554778754711151, -0.04267488792538643, -0.04500342905521393, -0.07026735693216324, -0.024300696328282356, 0.03776948153972626, 0.04162461310625076, 0.020084761083126068, 0.024266468361020088, -0.026938285678625107, -0.03651535138487816, 0.01783871278166771, 0.059640053659677505, -0.07438678294420242, -0.08492396026849747, -0.02498052828013897, 0.02773449383676052, -0.011472825892269611, -0.05609061196446419, 0.02914922684431076, 0.01944262534379959, 0.05130128562450409, -0.07884020358324051, -0.021829457953572273, -0.02295157127082348, -0.00587365822866559, -0.009580849669873714, -0.07714865356683731, -0.047241296619176865, -0.009947866201400757, -0.03261418268084526, -0.05689813569188118, 0.045156706124544144, 0.010509729385375977, 0.013092899695038795, 0.016576163470745087, 0.008761378936469555, -0.014969747513532639, 0.034372247755527496, 0.06626422703266144, -0.030832452699542046, 0.027532881125807762, 0.03283819556236267, -0.00588243966922164, -0.0007990543381310999, 0.025063732638955116, 0.004765630234032869, 0.01297549158334732, -0.05944450944662094, 0.0012472121743485332, 0.09835328161716461, -0.014301516115665436, 0.008486215956509113, 0.033105477690696716, -0.02613605186343193, 0.004737586248666048, 0.021120909601449966, -0.017581254243850708, -0.022321561351418495, -0.09525833278894424, 0.012673387303948402, 0.016925299540162086, 0.004847239702939987, 0.026126589626073837, 0.034641798585653305, -0.00794380996376276, 0.019536184147000313, 0.01922871358692646, -0.035919688642024994, 0.07019060105085373, 0.035123683512210846, -0.04531446471810341, 0.010782345198094845, 0.01426320243626833, 0.023825613781809807, 0.0834868848323822, -0.009712831117212772, 0.05200476199388504, -0.03612666577100754, -0.013651006855070591, -0.0035212424118071795, -0.03337930887937546, 0.05402756109833717, 0.006776393391191959, 0.007464423775672913, -0.025939444079995155, 0.02341621369123459, 0.03863530606031418, -0.024713700637221336, 0.02229788340628147, -0.03172273188829422, 0.0243991632014513, 0.023670392110943794, 0.030514877289533615, -0.02489146962761879, 0.004514316096901894, 0.026363803073763847, 0.004492903593927622, 0.000016149593648151495, 0.012159560807049274, 0.03774300590157509, -0.00386344688013196, 0.0651550143957138, -0.02654249407351017, -0.02642814815044403, -0.015301372855901718, 0.02648012340068817, -0.011638049967586994, -0.0076282816007733345, -0.0044330270029604435, -0.016231974586844444, 0.03323861211538315, -0.042237915098667145, 0.056344907730817795, 0.017291225492954254, -0.011036817915737629, -0.0315822958946228, -0.010466567240655422, 0.03087496943771839, -0.030376646667718887, 0.02412683516740799, -0.038367580622434616, -0.026924652978777885, -0.04423148185014725, -0.007810098119080067, 0.010450758039951324, -0.08040520548820496, -0.005071617662906647, 0.014980859123170376, -0.05881780758500099, 0.08979549258947372, 0.04982079938054085, 0.07932835072278976, 0.050847575068473816, -0.010525429621338844, 0.004332650452852249, 0.04407366365194321, 0.03248138725757599, -0.03380323573946953, 0.01922825165092945, -0.0008748929831199348, -0.01824977435171604, -0.06967686861753464, 0.0016934834420681, -0.012403594329953194, 0.017118491232395172, -0.021509062498807907, 0.05192827060818672, -0.03540869802236557, 0.025580167770385742, 0.0016387542709708214, 0.020645827054977417, 0.03883393481373787, -0.011190541088581085, -0.020279334858059883, -0.0350654274225235, -0.08415383100509644, 0.002510832156985998, 0.05028502270579338, -0.012860869988799095, 0.0149755934253335, 0.01179052796214819, -0.04785803705453873, -0.002170242602005601, 0.06424687057733536, 0.005335628520697355, 0.0034769373014569283, -0.008345888927578926, 0.044198598712682724, 0.014922159723937511, 0.038286805152893066, -0.019459327682852745, 0.03130630776286125, 0.00625274796038866, 0.00261296727694571, 0.0008235917193815112, 0.03113224171102047, 0.049651067703962326, -0.01683914102613926, 0.01992703229188919, -0.019368989393115044, -0.0059095583856105804, -0.005954204127192497, 0.01620876044034958, -0.04321175813674927, 0.02561144530773163, 0.0037929555401206017, 0.018216481432318687, 0.0001821292971726507, 0.03229659050703049, 0.008514339104294777, 0.06840542703866959, 0.04955768585205078, 0.04014243930578232, -0.040956102311611176, 0.048420500010252, -0.013452630490064621, 0.042763665318489075, -0.06164105609059334, 0.016214240342378616, -0.032699041068553925, -0.00748213566839695, -0.01798935979604721, 0.010932425037026405, -0.03590337932109833, -0.041342832148075104, 0.055195171386003494, -0.010653654113411903, 0.01480854768306017, -0.07700225710868835, -0.037816427648067474, -0.07000457495450974, -0.03634331002831459, -0.03379778936505318, 0.011402648873627186, -0.013383401557803154, -0.017835024744272232, -0.015518068335950375, 0.00030766447889618576, -0.05942906439304352, -0.04385478422045708, 0.03931191936135292, 0.00023475184570997953, -0.09580399841070175, -0.01710452139377594, 0.04050005227327347, -0.023922240361571312, -0.07560983300209045, 0.049081649631261826, -0.030450396239757538, 0.05857263505458832, 0.023798532783985138, 0.0009129762183874846, 0.019862374290823936, 0.07288572192192078, 0.007845301181077957, -0.03927595540881157, 0.00005124790550325997, -0.023020567372441292, 0.02498726174235344, 0.019955433905124664, -0.03377487510442734, 0.0028006548527628183, 0.014255182817578316, 0.00398503290489316, 0.06711903214454651, 0.04662937670946121, -0.07886717468500137, 0.005684852600097656, -0.040764328092336655, 0.00821895245462656, 0.0037264269776642323, 0.013987220823764801, 0.021290387958288193, -0.03510256111621857, 0.0016314589884132147, -0.07801897823810577, 0.03889757767319679, -0.0370996855199337, 0.006128635723143816, 0.046576857566833496, -0.023909129202365875, 0.03460470587015152, 0.04308827593922615, -0.02099434845149517, -0.031543977558612823, -0.04558248445391655, 0.01496930606663227, 0.03644217178225517, 0.01756211370229721, 0.0009262794046662748, -0.05373398959636688, 0.0665016621351242, -0.033012114465236664, 0.0012870589271187782, -0.007532651536166668, 0.003465600311756134, -0.008761163800954819, 0.008944638073444366, -0.008884689770638943, 0.01867952011525631, 0.024182884022593498, 0.040029652416706085, -0.10082754492759705, -0.04977227374911308, -0.03367510437965393, 0.06895594298839569, 0.03055780753493309, 0.013887535780668259, -0.06964541226625443, 0.023646540939807892, 0.015534164384007454, -0.016077479347586632, -0.056174386292696, 0.05843232199549675, -0.01763717271387577, -0.03103753924369812, -0.0223056823015213, 0.010477010160684586, -0.051894575357437134, 0.011768917553126812 ]
<p>How much memory would we need to represent a human? How would each atom be stored as? Bytes? Something more complex?</p>
g1600
[ -0.030216185376048088, 0.06736239045858383, 0.01323101855814457, -0.07356478273868561, -0.03371180593967438, -0.002994840033352375, -0.029122332111001015, 0.0037981481291353703, -0.04493691772222519, -0.01125946082174778, -0.06094254553318024, -0.0296121034771204, 0.01799112558364868, -0.00948438048362732, 0.0157676562666893, -0.0023472656030207872, 0.037369199097156525, -0.010069629177451134, -0.016233311966061592, 0.05561968311667442, 0.08578275889158249, 0.017620716243982315, -0.011389941908419132, 0.0021717522758990526, -0.061033908277750015, 0.020740969106554985, -0.021031944081187248, -0.01774432510137558, -0.023151682689785957, 0.06086910516023636, 0.04051324352622032, -0.01104543637484312, -0.0624392144382, -0.061240971088409424, -0.018137244507670403, -0.046628423035144806, -0.025125985965132713, -0.018553612753748894, 0.05998237431049347, -0.0007002916536293924, 0.026461755856871605, -0.029106786474585533, -0.03633107617497444, -0.03692694008350372, -0.011000802740454674, 0.05419081076979637, -0.0020533662755042315, -0.01882806047797203, -0.007230179850012064, 0.04239801689982414, -0.002170050051063299, 0.031129498034715652, 0.002754852408543229, 0.03850631043314934, 0.045159172266721725, -0.016633879393339157, -0.007764995563775301, -0.036232974380254745, 0.032763976603746414, 0.042441677302122116, 0.04235721379518509, -0.029270518571138382, -0.053992751985788345, 0.017552467063069344, 0.03195890039205551, 0.03427274897694588, -0.007603289559483528, 0.05338828265666962, 0.05030097812414169, -0.01828165166079998, 0.06267748028039932, -0.04094226285815239, -0.02607899159193039, 0.028642479330301285, -0.016473686322569847, 0.002474703826010227, -0.03802727535367012, 0.06388393044471741, 0.03271102160215378, 0.06332182139158249, -0.028629876673221588, -0.0499231293797493, 0.049796104431152344, -0.04944588616490364, 0.032320357859134674, -0.01910454034805298, -0.09016355872154236, -0.03128065541386604, -0.034389909356832504, 0.09131059050559998, -0.06889685988426208, 0.025373902171850204, 0.07106386870145798, 0.024630799889564514, 0.04052533209323883, -0.017933951690793037, -0.02061026357114315, 0.02813825197517872, -0.06840502470731735, -0.02226646989583969, -0.022494331002235413, -0.001157808699645102, 0.05086434632539749, -0.032146796584129333, 0.01422265823930502, 0.000813747348729521, -0.021679865196347237, 0.021446874365210533, -0.011885887011885643, -0.028747733682394028, -0.022272035479545593, -0.00007600850949529558, -0.013509845361113548, 0.10953866690397263, -0.020672300830483437, -0.021573476493358612, 0.03647977486252785, 0.0012613862054422498, 0.002741542411968112, 0.039152368903160095, -0.01827402412891388, -0.017603455111384392, 0.09128287434577942, -0.0026294556446373463, -0.018973151221871376, -0.009441168047487736, -0.011479917913675308, 0.008954198099672794, -0.012790863402187824, -0.021513627842068672, 0.023060232400894165, 0.012338567525148392, -0.03805288299918175, 0.008132602088153362, -0.012022443115711212, -0.013978201895952225, -0.04361313208937645, -0.011438933201134205, -0.03570983186364174, 0.021975625306367874, 0.02561235800385475, -0.006595428567379713, -0.019779464229941368, -0.011650186963379383, -0.011278062127530575, -0.050643667578697205, -0.043152473866939545, 0.013379962183535099, -0.009577985852956772, 0.020346764475107193, -0.020490948110818863, 0.02460167184472084, 0.0725189745426178, -0.025783926248550415, 0.023676041513681412, -0.03248901665210724, 0.035248834639787674, 0.010175123810768127, -0.018880028277635574, 0.05147034674882889, 0.03117273934185505, 0.021027149632573128, -0.0012137505691498518, 0.02747555822134018, -0.01240210235118866, -0.01661428064107895, 0.056731726974248886, -0.03459697961807251, 0.0335380882024765, -0.01754000224173069, 0.07668991386890411, -0.0062795402482151985, -0.03639225289225578, 0.02381270006299019, -0.03953036665916443, -0.020252497866749763, 0.015857910737395287, -0.026650983840227127, 0.02796601876616478, -0.020201366394758224, 0.009285135194659233, -0.034805066883563995, -0.013864504173398018, -0.06350737065076828, -0.050162456929683685, -0.009212839417159557, -0.014519551768898964, 0.012689057737588882, 0.006048486102372408, -0.007619781419634819, -0.00572535116225481, -0.00460208160802722, 0.05412719398736954, -0.0042895544320344925, 0.00108050974085927, -0.02060241997241974, 0.037508510053157806, -0.0389830581843853, -0.0038597651291638613, 0.07779425382614136, 0.010698903352022171, 0.017580391839146614, -0.004178300034254789, 0.05515765771269798, 0.04312635585665703, -0.03433728590607643, -0.006389837246388197, -0.014612170867621899, -0.001218239194713533, -0.021107705309987068, 0.07080812007188797, 0.022345593199133873, -0.012351373210549355, 0.03645680472254753, -0.008962303400039673, -0.003515089862048626, -0.0039795381017029285, -0.04879174381494522, -0.035861097276210785, 0.017747512087225914, -0.004465005360543728, -0.09404780715703964, -0.012738214805722237, -0.018578140065073967, 0.002036880934610963, 0.00855239387601614, 0.04940858483314514, -0.012892615981400013, 0.0016255129594355822, 0.036847107112407684, -0.0239973533898592, 0.06158002093434334, 0.01927288807928562, -0.007209135685116053, -0.015174223110079765, 0.07687564194202423, -0.023030869662761688, 0.03760026395320892, -0.017700042575597763, -0.029701249673962593, -0.02944689244031906, -0.022602854296565056, 0.008365055546164513, 0.019381608814001083, -0.060850661247968674, -0.04982270672917366, -0.013674033805727959, -0.041872788220644, 0.002088440116494894, 0.022898733615875244, -0.08102791011333466, -0.07618851214647293, -0.05326080322265625, -0.01060169842094183, 0.04995346441864967, -0.00505684083327651, 0.03292576223611832, 0.014397942461073399, -0.06006469577550888, 0.01991812139749527, 0.006646229885518551, -0.0521957203745842, -0.07263968139886856, 0.007671100553125143, 0.008497152477502823, -0.06612859666347504, 0.0026265971828252077, 0.0049384464509785175, 0.03674408420920372, 0.008539990521967411, 0.041255682706832886, 0.00926731526851654, -0.007841212674975395, -0.00285775912925601, -0.02609320729970932, -0.013518432155251503, 0.0443992055952549, -0.04390207305550575, 0.014196502044796944, 0.005823794286698103, -0.030302071943879128, 0.02253567986190319, -0.055148646235466, -0.015931913629174232, 0.006576365325599909, -0.03775303065776825, -0.02069178596138954, 0.06575634330511093, 0.004310102201998234, -0.0005972248036414385, -0.06514988839626312, 0.02438485249876976, 0.004995093215256929, 0.021822938695549965, -0.022340308874845505, 0.01860628090798855, 0.055319372564554214, -0.0011548970360308886, -0.02766801044344902, 0.05762946978211403, 0.0038888556882739067, -0.01244147028774023, 0.04028098285198212, 0.023358626291155815, -0.07192269712686539, -0.0045093041844666, -0.017421282827854156, -0.0051459940150380135, -0.010410886257886887, -0.07369948923587799, -0.021496161818504333, 0.022004561498761177, 0.016756027936935425, 0.06560134142637253, -0.04905114322900772, -0.025771986693143845, -0.00003469317016424611, 0.011719209142029285, 0.010399451479315758, -0.06428308039903641, 0.04915085807442665, -0.03844555467367172, -0.005549553781747818, -0.03665583208203316, 0.00535869225859642, 0.04866230487823486, -0.016400381922721863, -0.03761447221040726, -0.04493454471230507, 0.0003087961522396654, 0.03645654022693634, 0.005706948693841696, -0.005577565170824528, 0.07479896396398544, -0.049354009330272675, -0.022280562669038773, -0.007241357117891312, -0.07984514534473419, -0.01759730838239193, -0.013658841140568256, -0.0018945211777463555, -0.0026377616450190544, 0.07025729864835739, -0.06043587625026703, 0.019597157835960388, 0.0023605336900800467, -0.01704978011548519, -0.021036185324192047, -0.010662522166967392, -0.037947505712509155, -0.04702610895037651, -0.007245177403092384, -0.012763084843754768, -0.013746506534516811, 0.027309102937579155, 0.01752159744501114, 0.040541891008615494, 0.062460433691740036, -0.030217722058296204, 0.03009065054357052, -0.004628611728549004, 0.008785202167928219, 0.0460655651986599, 0.015248383395373821, 0.009980199858546257, 0.0008662967011332512, 0.002992774825543165, -0.024293802678585052, 0.016598420217633247, -0.0014519569231197238, -0.03623827546834946, -0.018071908503770828, 0.009575996547937393, -0.020019251853227615, 0.023344889283180237, -0.06689807027578354, 0.015381861478090286, 0.009325445629656315, -0.027481790632009506, -0.012006714940071106, -0.03270493820309639, -0.061872512102127075, 0.015860665589571, -0.04576437920331955, -0.031954292207956314, -0.08683950453996658, 0.023958951234817505, -0.0070470175705850124, 0.01966708153486252, 0.04306253045797348, -0.03159761056303978, -0.07248712331056595, -0.041676558554172516, -0.031673822551965714, 0.027527937665581703, -0.044822514057159424, 0.020964384078979492, -0.0016121846856549382, -0.026754913851618767, 0.0355779305100441, -0.008200792595744133, 0.023235701024532318, 0.02635924145579338, 0.02792186290025711, 0.009140889160335064, 0.035175569355487823, 0.006690633948892355, -0.06276094913482666, 0.006556420587003231, -0.02424629032611847, 0.01663254015147686, 0.007331801578402519, 0.024180248379707336, -0.028835682198405266, -0.022790452465415, -0.0013875671429559588, -0.019251715391874313, 0.033205173909664154, 0.020304951816797256, 0.03289204463362694, 0.05378149077296257, 0.03734789043664932, -0.001725179492495954, -0.0018159139435738325, 0.002218998735770583, 0.02575630694627762, 0.020782470703125, 0.010247699916362762, 0.011623989790678024, 0.012737938202917576, 0.020710593089461327, 0.01430415641516447, 0.020867250859737396, 0.10927607864141464, -0.0026020267978310585, -0.027706926688551903, 0.012258442118763924, 0.0016501272330060601, 0.07149332016706467, -0.02005121111869812, 0.021367663517594337, 0.042626142501831055, 0.02377498708665371, 0.01183368545025587, -0.049350325018167496, 0.04324643686413765, -0.009410914033651352, 0.009464317001402378, -0.04776749387383461, 0.032976459711790085, -0.019328240305185318, 0.02747592143714428, -0.009591421112418175, -0.029978644102811813, 0.047577302902936935, 0.025698238983750343, -0.017314821481704712, -0.0216481015086174, 0.010456463322043419, 0.03665783256292343, -0.046653829514980316, 0.015951737761497498, -0.001572697306983173, -0.0006023399182595313, -0.007089972496032715, -0.03757011145353317, 0.011835302226245403, 0.001069938763976097, 0.022422555834054947, -0.0009778341045603156, 0.018450694158673286, -0.08923526853322983, 0.03562468662858009, 0.026371901854872704, 0.060906052589416504, 0.042540986090898514, 0.002692105947062373, -0.10201060771942139, 0.03221891075372696, -0.004347916692495346, -0.016100095584988594, 0.08127682656049728, 0.008836109191179276, 0.04772454872727394, 0.003618489718064666, 0.004730074666440487, -0.03694135323166847, 0.04909225180745125, -0.0052706035785377026, 0.030058857053518295, -0.009210050106048584, -0.0014077442465350032, -0.009275485761463642, -0.005178447347134352, -0.05636342242360115, -0.06323514133691788, -0.08723203837871552, -0.03142601624131203, 0.007531855255365372, 0.04022897779941559, -0.031399019062519073, 0.07008343935012817, -0.0032449220307171345, -0.08699385076761246, -0.00941416248679161, 0.0016693172510713339, 0.008740161545574665, 0.036938704550266266, -0.044842883944511414, 0.01689516380429268, -0.005055078770965338, 0.021661488339304924, -0.07970535755157471, -0.03262518718838692, -0.011009778827428818, 0.0509524904191494, -0.019859706982970238, 0.030816106125712395, -0.04499276727437973, 0.00728342542424798, 0.001218604389578104, 0.05410134419798851, 0.07606004923582077, -0.009172648191452026, -0.0921059176325798, 0.04500614479184151, -0.022141605615615845, -0.08052033185958862, -0.01026128325611353, 0.06527285277843475, 0.06876365095376968, -0.0340939536690712, -0.03995482996106148, -0.05627036467194557, -0.010054466314613819, -0.00012655294267460704, -0.012840877287089825, 0.04529930278658867, 0.07601255923509598, 0.021123630926012993, 0.028226012364029884, 0.025344911962747574, -0.015301876701414585, 0.07841852307319641, 0.024373935535550117, -0.037484366446733475, 0.007432607002556324, 0.07121454179286957, 0.01706693135201931, -0.020738359540700912, -0.0010538288624957204, -0.015072095207870007, 0.006566198542714119, 0.016424329951405525, 0.01725112646818161, 0.011148759163916111, 0.017243800684809685, -0.02016768790781498, 0.028615392744541168, 0.05722721666097641, -0.05948622152209282, 0.07192074507474899, -0.009825974702835083, -0.018345817923545837, 0.020840423181653023, -0.06184287741780281, -0.02313079684972763, -0.02151395007967949, 0.030530322343111038, -0.024504275992512703, 0.06600546091794968, -0.0717373862862587, -0.010074031539261341, -0.013710355386137962, -0.01767677254974842, -0.02903475984930992, 0.0028928755782544613, 0.007155168801546097, -0.02377108484506607, -0.0038692806847393513, -0.007159010972827673, -0.05538390204310417, -0.024303844198584557, 0.010803616605699062, 0.03446205332875252, 0.022361766546964645, 0.035636965185403824, 0.018469102680683136, 0.022479765117168427, -0.004865637049078941, 0.04341818764805794, -0.006767479237169027, 0.05194271355867386, -0.0895780399441719, -0.0085397157818079, 0.015596823766827583, 0.02848745509982109, -0.08172843605279922, -0.03990421071648598, -0.004214733839035034, 0.05716868117451668, 0.023027166724205017, 0.009281715378165245, -0.020797930657863617, 0.09178034961223602, 0.048237599432468414, -0.04089188575744629, 0.04547813534736633, -0.0024216307792812586, -0.039653606712818146, -0.0004640803672373295, 0.017095910385251045, -0.009663966484367847, 0.021183326840400696, 0.03627246245741844, -0.04108218476176262, 0.06655764579772949, 0.0219973586499691, -0.013690639287233353, 0.05957748368382454, -0.024313736706972122, -0.006043130997568369, 0.011050941422581673, -0.0014443855034187436, 0.02119135670363903, -0.01186657976359129, -0.028287526220083237, 0.12555432319641113, -0.005357467103749514, 0.027108443900942802, 0.018573274835944176, 0.015289580449461937, 0.09193216264247894, 0.0781986266374588, 0.031683214008808136, 0.045930612832307816, -0.04600990191102028, -0.01392822340130806, -0.03808926045894623, 0.021578622981905937, 0.01000978983938694, -0.040954720228910446, 0.0007117791101336479, 0.01314006932079792, -0.05240859463810921, 0.013012615963816643, 0.06510582566261292, 0.001772901858203113, -0.01775999367237091, -0.0471525676548481, 0.02542591653764248, 0.00916487630456686, -0.05122146010398865, 0.058591291308403015, -0.05941879376769066, -0.018279265612363815, -0.029773717746138573, 0.026933062821626663, 0.014375697821378708, -0.047822918742895126, -0.0027308317366987467, 0.02262328565120697, -0.007932943291962147, -0.09729311615228653, -0.005287577398121357, 0.03652419149875641, 0.019864918664097786, -0.03355718404054642, -0.002512028208002448, 0.018419016152620316, 0.005011992063373327, -0.00473324628546834, 0.006562450900673866, 0.04230603575706482, 0.009088474325835705, -0.018753942102193832, -0.01142402458935976, -0.05435267090797424, -0.025232389569282532, -0.025737976655364037, -0.03621673211455345, 0.03630909323692322, 0.013081650249660015, 0.007711960002779961, -0.005157467909157276, 0.022625483572483063, 0.038010433316230774, 0.011263126507401466, 0.008685613051056862, 0.029249027371406555, 0.04639481008052826, -0.02131958119571209, -0.021230248734354973, -0.025421470403671265, -0.012691652402281761, 0.01634802483022213, -0.02137012965977192, -0.018716320395469666, 0.08030234277248383, -0.028297875076532364, 0.007457863539457321, -0.01164185255765915, 0.04543950781226158, 0.0478619821369648, 0.05167851969599724, -0.007603322621434927, -0.054074760526418686, 0.03798931464552879, -0.01994834467768669, -0.040109582245349884, -0.03802095726132393, 0.09772182255983353, 0.04230014979839325, 0.06263130903244019, 0.03860502690076828, -0.023911921307444572, -0.035538963973522186, -0.012602020986378193, 0.018707629293203354, -0.005199566017836332, 0.02241678722202778, 0.008057011291384697, -0.04007045552134514, 0.038168132305145264, -0.005864249542355537, 0.01778627745807171, 0.018109476193785667, 0.007555685937404633, 0.049636103212833405, -0.003115774365141988, -0.01867091655731201, 0.023669742047786713, -0.02358374185860157, 0.03022039122879505, 0.013099088333547115, -0.013504978269338608, -0.03219228610396385, 0.0030768041033297777, -0.07349687069654465, -0.02840481698513031, -0.0168010201305151, -0.011681224219501019, -0.002378006698563695, -0.023169441148638725, -0.007044224534183741, -0.03668946027755737, -0.08278622478246689, -0.026325376704335213, 0.09177801758050919, -0.004804650787264109, -0.02543671242892742, -0.060892295092344284, -0.012344947084784508, -0.003806993830949068, -0.005050304811447859, -0.0004763085744343698, 0.032560039311647415, 0.025028085336089134, 0.0018583845812827349, -0.0003549358225427568, 0.02196815237402916, 0.015465911477804184, 0.009183463640511036, 0.01664193719625473, 0.00813561026006937, -0.0029342942871153355, -0.03599743917584419, -0.02400018647313118 ]
<p>The Feynman lectures are universally admired, it seems, but also a half-century old. Taking them as a source for self-study, what compensation for their age, if any, should today's reader undertake? I'm interested both in pointers to particular topics where the physics itself is out-of-date, or topics where the pedagogical approach now admits attestable improvements.</p>
g997
[ -0.035358838737010956, 0.023174913600087166, 0.001185618806630373, -0.05678527429699898, 0.05355900153517723, -0.034728169441223145, 0.04861907288432121, 0.035917140543460846, 0.005811772774904966, 0.003708979580551386, 0.032000262290239334, 0.002599391620606184, -0.014323538169264793, 0.0993194729089737, 0.01674794964492321, 0.014803384430706501, -0.01157404761761427, 0.03417881205677986, 0.020615162327885628, -0.0026282418984919786, 0.013613655231893063, 0.022284260019659996, 0.013693400658667088, 0.0006352908094413579, -0.0588003471493721, -0.03526421636343002, -0.053028929978609085, -0.039334993809461594, 0.01948484592139721, -0.02633797749876976, 0.05005424842238426, -0.027334820479154587, 0.03332999348640442, -0.0639670193195343, -0.06101134419441223, -0.023027388378977776, 0.0287069920450449, 0.011251700110733509, 0.0006198413320817053, 0.02625904604792595, 0.05105315521359444, 0.0026521433610469103, -0.04760897159576416, 0.02259240299463272, 0.003192139556631446, -0.007632407359778881, -0.054777029901742935, -0.012889713048934937, -0.0193009115755558, 0.06650561094284058, -0.02580883726477623, 0.028050299733877182, 0.09258915483951569, 0.021598566323518753, 0.04690438508987427, -0.013865468092262745, -0.02932567521929741, 0.0391741581261158, 0.08610717207193375, -0.0015178872272372246, 0.027918616309762, 0.04623463749885559, -0.014657557010650635, -0.020154232159256935, 0.03305067494511604, 0.01619340479373932, -0.05697092413902283, 0.0031841599848121405, -0.02410820871591568, 0.06604690849781036, 0.02937815524637699, -0.07005079090595245, -0.018871821463108063, 0.014310446567833424, 0.052147675305604935, -0.010607358068227768, -0.04999352991580963, -0.014581701718270779, 0.08619491010904312, 0.00009455581312067807, -0.09961892664432526, 0.015757966786623, -0.00916343741118908, -0.07146373391151428, 0.09582409262657166, -0.06138721853494644, -0.023097433149814606, 0.01660676673054695, 0.012032459490001202, 0.04828140139579773, 0.03280886262655258, 0.01601204089820385, 0.01278276089578867, -0.06442324817180634, -0.0014553881483152509, -0.05966701731085777, -0.0016235117800533772, 0.012611852027475834, 0.0008853461476974189, 0.035553913563489914, -0.07607133686542511, 0.00512508861720562, 0.01330990344285965, 0.018297215923666954, -0.01194940134882927, 0.03015897236764431, 0.028166135773062706, 0.006871585734188557, 0.045302364975214005, -0.003467385657131672, -0.07348593324422836, 0.011426525190472603, -0.04247259721159935, 0.041130855679512024, -0.06225796416401863, 0.006920931860804558, 0.01260982546955347, 0.010198050178587437, 0.015692947432398796, 0.09764762222766876, 0.012093092314898968, 0.048033978790044785, 0.024906007573008537, -0.009243433363735676, 0.015977807343006134, 0.02924330160021782, -0.06971270591020584, 0.009407421573996544, -0.03362032771110535, 0.015118129551410675, -0.010386161506175995, 0.00520742405205965, -0.05368510261178017, -0.00470254011452198, -0.009262407198548317, 0.07437591999769211, -0.03377910703420639, 0.03263116255402565, 0.024764323607087135, -0.018930841237306595, 0.031015438959002495, -0.04387276992201805, -0.035713691264390945, -0.029416587203741074, 0.021598244085907936, -0.006812036503106356, -0.022783061489462852, -0.054924700409173965, -0.03722772374749184, 0.06122852861881256, 0.0028142440132796764, 0.05883849412202835, 0.05737846717238426, -0.010987887158989906, 0.006390569731593132, 0.017608139663934708, 0.04190885275602341, -0.0677204504609108, 0.014347431249916553, 0.0001996179489651695, 0.008165857754647732, 0.018604237586259842, -0.025858838111162186, -0.0019211278995499015, -0.019446762278676033, 0.06762946397066116, -0.013950801454484463, -0.10439924895763397, 0.038508571684360504, -0.024241279810667038, -0.01822575367987156, -0.008863778784871101, 0.038394711911678314, 0.0524623729288578, -0.021280528977513313, 0.00010137385106645525, -0.03894675895571709, -0.08888212591409683, 0.011239948682487011, 0.023846745491027832, 0.022762546315789223, -0.01956208050251007, 0.04273701086640358, 0.009066835977137089, 0.0075257038697600365, -0.013625863008201122, -0.043282877653837204, 0.038708142936229706, -0.025883009657263756, -0.009364822879433632, -0.00898753385990858, -0.013360376469790936, -0.06727054715156555, -0.012167681939899921, -0.024796070531010628, -0.05004631355404854, -0.011804664507508278, 0.022597359493374825, 0.004418019205331802, 0.02056346833705902, -0.04144473373889923, 0.004987394902855158, 0.08834013342857361, 0.028145115822553635, 0.020307336002588272, 0.054026421159505844, -0.045022591948509216, -0.025124143809080124, 0.03595958277583122, -0.02312222495675087, 0.052817702293395996, 0.015221196226775646, 0.03385251760482788, 0.009768121875822544, -0.004837114363908768, 0.01097029447555542, -0.07095427811145782, -0.014340769499540329, 0.010912030003964901, 0.05961792171001434, -0.03327175974845886, -0.014128175564110279, 0.02137603797018528, -0.006848086137324572, 0.015029738657176495, 0.001105119357816875, 0.0308320764452219, 0.012537078931927681, -0.07704905420541763, 0.05343574658036232, -0.03859938681125641, 0.009992257691919804, -0.07531589269638062, -0.0033659827895462513, 0.03702438622713089, -0.012499744072556496, -0.02284727245569229, -0.023264043033123016, 0.052805401384830475, 0.02656480111181736, 0.012286192737519741, 0.006876189261674881, 0.038340453058481216, -0.02398468740284443, -0.042511358857154846, -0.011474036611616611, 0.0038270577788352966, 0.019749002531170845, -0.00022002799960318953, 0.001240511890500784, 0.0443243645131588, -0.040729817003011703, -0.002527335425838828, 0.02930651418864727, 0.005509916227310896, 0.05465758219361305, 0.004757334478199482, 0.06107727810740471, 0.011588729918003082, 0.010309831239283085, 0.018853871151804924, -0.02079002931714058, -0.03072594292461872, 0.008912385441362858, -0.019496381282806396, -0.005484122317284346, -0.051212213933467865, 0.03696667402982712, -0.015261718071997166, -0.06173155829310417, 0.030093755573034286, 0.0439581535756588, 0.023049097508192062, -0.00514754094183445, 0.003079682821407914, 0.013599377125501633, -0.019923517480492592, 0.04670035466551781, 0.05403910577297211, -0.017723264172673225, -0.04105200991034508, -0.049537692219018936, -0.00972008891403675, 0.043039947748184204, 0.017080940306186676, -0.08379961550235748, -0.03452792763710022, 0.0009734220220707357, 0.05599894002079964, -0.002770064165815711, -0.069691002368927, 0.01916116662323475, -0.016219761222600937, -0.02246004529297352, -0.010789573192596436, -0.027781808748841286, 0.006987480912357569, -0.01339328195899725, -0.08678154647350311, 0.0042094397358596325, 0.003509951289743185, -0.008850840851664543, -0.02708120457828045, 0.019524024799466133, 0.04803506284952164, -0.018420372158288956, -0.0714404284954071, -0.009019534103572369, -0.031635262072086334, -0.052904143929481506, 0.011562407948076725, 0.039529889822006226, 0.014283061027526855, -0.024037813767790794, -0.05578131973743439, 0.0011559008853510022, -0.012102873995900154, 0.019979774951934814, 0.01047523319721222, -0.0753379613161087, -0.06526610255241394, 0.015027571469545364, 0.02765657939016819, -0.08782447129487991, 0.07675133645534515, 0.004106011241674423, 0.05223039537668228, -0.07595743983983994, -0.048081278800964355, 0.0057480172254145145, 0.037308044731616974, -0.06326162070035934, -0.024754228070378304, -0.0034144138917326927, -0.06927241384983063, -0.06026221439242363, -0.02128428779542446, -0.0057358392514288425, -0.021219290792942047, -0.01862071081995964, -0.03199566900730133, 0.010284683667123318, -0.028158066794276237, -0.035235874354839325, 0.03092089667916298, -0.06659840047359467, -0.001055493950843811, 0.02669655717909336, 0.0315566323697567, -0.03118382766842842, 0.03677838295698166, 0.04595532640814781, 0.008787735365331173, 0.04440746828913689, -0.002589397132396698, 0.04390617460012436, 0.01976681686937809, 0.04419400542974472, 0.0401666983962059, 0.00046199062489904463, -0.06086188927292824, 0.014887241646647453, -0.033122215420007706, -0.012251068837940693, 0.0031329388730227947, -0.0345647968351841, -0.060538168996572495, 0.04163962975144386, 0.04394242540001869, 0.010101563297212124, -0.024543434381484985, 0.05740036815404892, 0.02255571261048317, 0.012531885877251625, -0.09311484545469284, -0.026610583066940308, -0.03210797160863876, 0.04543645307421684, -0.009344994090497494, 0.003914264030754566, -0.03941742703318596, 0.02734501101076603, -0.026332484558224678, -0.012102286331355572, 0.027523279190063477, 0.03180178254842758, -0.04479130357503891, -0.039589978754520416, -0.04898785799741745, -0.0005027478910051286, 0.08271677792072296, 0.0198555588722229, 0.038786713033914566, 0.08004309237003326, -0.023968640714883804, -0.038190580904483795, 0.027556437999010086, 0.001081123249605298, -0.007472068537026644, 0.06478404998779297, 0.02620529942214489, 0.012720351107418537, 0.0064129699021577835, -0.036990489810705185, 0.024337220937013626, 0.011469028890132904, -0.010772058740258217, -0.06270117312669754, 0.044151656329631805, -0.02747179940342903, -0.034551460295915604, 0.011206681840121746, 0.05419037491083145, -0.06440898030996323, 0.019116325303912163, -0.021554287523031235, -0.03125547990202904, -0.07799475640058517, 0.008509195409715176, -0.019017014652490616, 0.029137207195162773, -0.012853123247623444, -0.028133302927017212, 0.006203982979059219, 0.009829672053456306, -0.027744123712182045, 0.01810196042060852, -0.0011790563585236669, 0.03222300857305527, -0.0024335214402526617, 0.04395526275038719, -0.02185695618391037, -0.06943100690841675, -0.03111867792904377, -0.000912589835934341, -0.01964130997657776, 0.033060941845178604, -0.010211645625531673, -0.05403215438127518, 0.06016113981604576, 0.10601802170276642, -0.03773025423288345, -0.03173769637942314, -0.0038436653558164835, -0.00042931517236866057, 0.02110425755381584, -0.022431476041674614, -0.03370868042111397, 0.008184853009879589, -0.011387679725885391, -0.008797829039394855, -0.02341650053858757, 0.10685516148805618, -0.037962984293699265, -0.011057914234697819, -0.04431214928627014, -0.02595548890531063, -0.02401665970683098, 0.047165874391794205, -0.03026004321873188, -0.07021699845790863, 0.004245465155690908, 0.009736523032188416, -0.003238702891394496, -0.017583314329385757, -0.005403614137321711, -0.025407923385500908, -0.012005827389657497, -0.02487197145819664, -0.01628066971898079, 0.0011727400124073029, -0.031143028289079666, 0.04046555235981941, -0.058694299310445786, -0.03597692772746086, -0.016474073752760887, 0.0006201427895575762, -0.016232788562774658, -0.007683366537094116, 0.03311163932085037, 0.0061873020604252815, 0.007039785385131836, 0.016806872561573982, -0.005465182941406965, -0.012580112554132938, -0.010672738775610924, -0.0018936207052320242, 0.003902653930708766, -0.06398562341928482, -0.0643271654844284, 0.06719344109296799, -0.014918370172381401, 0.019111143425107002, -0.06646192073822021, -0.03926527872681618, -0.011806164868175983, 0.03148415684700012, -0.0018113984260708094, 0.05043543875217438, -0.007480528671294451, 0.0050211152993142605, 0.03162377327680588, 0.002343863481655717, -0.04853960871696472, 0.006441501434892416, 0.008567336946725845, 0.0060651954263448715, -0.05861643701791763, -0.061133064329624176, -0.006955043412744999, 0.011258289217948914, 0.02075648121535778, 0.023979322984814644, 0.03294550999999046, 0.02644660696387291, 0.03761744126677513, 0.011442722752690315, -0.02685873582959175, 0.021456927061080933, 0.010436317883431911, 0.019404450431466103, -0.016148744150996208, 0.04337173327803612, -0.03361496701836586, 0.048191387206315994, 0.012773986905813217, -0.06877188384532928, -0.04328985884785652, 0.016898782923817635, -0.001070115133188665, 0.019043592736124992, -0.03288519009947777, -0.007803811226040125, -0.01548064686357975, -0.04999980330467224, 0.03560668230056763, -0.03840867802500725, 0.01321070920675993, -0.0019324548775330186, 0.03542659804224968, -0.001037897658534348, -0.04735560715198517, 0.007272873539477587, 0.06421800702810287, 0.0684778094291687, 0.0054915715008974075, 0.02729567140340805, -0.005490607116371393, 0.07256603986024857, -0.05896083265542984, -0.03640016168355942, -0.041953831911087036, 0.01572350040078163, -0.036542899906635284, 0.04847085848450661, 0.04771961271762848, 0.004840843379497528, -0.005420280154794455, 0.018376251682639122, 0.047755900770425797, 0.03550957888364792, 0.022327981889247894, 0.009924684651196003, -0.01032429188489914, -0.0287421066313982, 0.010668249800801277, -0.009404664859175682, -0.07387229800224304, 0.04603243246674538, -0.0038539785891771317, -0.023492081090807915, -0.0006817668909206986, 0.020079895853996277, 0.006216071080416441, 0.014174073003232479, -0.020281972363591194, 0.0014982838183641434, -0.025745850056409836, -0.03741078823804855, -0.06382522732019424, -0.01742631196975708, 0.03987925499677658, 0.09727597236633301, -0.007591264322400093, 0.0302925705909729, 0.026453204452991486, -0.0075677623972296715, 0.019916389137506485, 0.0028870520181953907, 0.037452805787324905, -0.044653717428445816, -0.01556610967963934, 0.009975150227546692, -0.05634292587637901, -0.018392987549304962, 0.003562821540981531, 0.09253920614719391, 0.03555271029472351, -0.046965502202510834, 0.029703184962272644, 0.0012898502172902226, -0.001077342894859612, -0.004961686674505472, 0.007082769181579351, 0.04922807589173317, 0.0378444604575634, -0.02495025284588337, 0.029523683711886406, 0.010096651501953602, -0.018762826919555664, -0.02427850104868412, 0.0004782119067385793, -0.05957493558526039, -0.0002759093476925045, 0.011071973480284214, -0.014376131817698479, -0.005039709620177746, -0.0025850224774330854, -0.04983887821435928, 0.02118508145213127, 0.01637553796172142, 0.03087986260652542, 0.02280420809984207, -0.06595645844936371, -0.02559821680188179, 0.03944401443004608, 0.0035744928754866123, -0.004256703890860081, 0.04019508510828018, 0.015567748807370663, -0.014478534460067749, 0.02136044390499592, 0.035746946930885315, -0.011104182340204716, 0.015475427731871605, 0.10476870834827423, 0.0342508964240551, -0.010691046714782715, -0.052123479545116425, 0.0016556173795834184, -0.008968139998614788, -0.04856087267398834, 0.020009202882647514, -0.03374515101313591, 0.021666202694177628, -0.07211645692586899, -0.017602236941456795, 0.047888532280921936, -0.005379390902817249, 0.03816597908735275, 0.020855197682976723, -0.05015019699931145, -0.04028790071606636, -0.02766984887421131, -0.03620203211903572, -0.0017887236317619681, -0.027252361178398132, 0.044777750968933105, 0.10911966115236282, -0.06172497570514679, -0.02277909219264984, -0.020219342783093452, 0.023271404206752777, -0.017280669882893562, -0.018462536856532097, 0.04207351431250572, -0.02643354795873165, -0.024236008524894714, -0.00028542691143229604, 0.024588804692029953, -0.011287611909210682, -0.011841840110719204, -0.014398204162716866, 0.011884859763085842, 0.05156022682785988, -0.019454414024949074, -0.026546578854322433, 0.04441613331437111, -0.04970583692193031, -0.002403904451057315, -0.023853423073887825, 0.03864983096718788, -0.03445422276854515, 0.008189410902559757, -0.009433215484023094, 0.010292954742908478, -0.057662174105644226, -0.011195721104741096, 0.046331096440553665, -0.005323717836290598, 0.03686419874429703, 0.0028590315487235785, 0.009443636983633041, 0.014700273983180523, -0.007510124705731869, 0.013492480851709843, 0.08318513631820679, -0.04136563837528229, 0.02863069251179695, -0.013522839173674583, 0.0330565981566906, -0.022032367065548897, -0.019938001409173012, -0.02680252119898796, 0.016804533079266548, -0.014936944469809532, 0.039500340819358826, -0.0319531112909317, 0.005680926144123077, -0.004818124230951071, 0.006588667165488005, 0.04489908739924431, 0.016529196873307228, 0.021009411662817, 0.06355668604373932, 0.016206299886107445, -0.003922271076589823, -0.017426379024982452, 0.0647827759385109, -0.011038691736757755, 0.07675507664680481, 0.027925828471779823, -0.0032316669821739197, -0.008284425362944603, -0.018541347235441208, -0.031268201768398285, -0.005700319539755583, 0.0038204099982976913, -0.03515758737921715, 0.034091703593730927, 0.07265564799308777, 0.009279646910727024, 0.025351636111736298, 0.02717718482017517, -0.0032372185960412025, -0.029054487124085426, 0.050600696355104446, 0.025629308074712753, -0.012775781564414501, -0.006485524121671915, 0.020282289013266563, 0.030216580256819725, -0.009617640636861324, 0.022490601986646652, -0.00825332198292017, -0.05704623833298683, -0.03720581904053688, -0.010024989023804665, -0.009036356583237648, -0.009195624850690365, -0.042216140776872635, 0.014854894950985909, 0.004581569228321314, 0.04711674153804779, 0.009467141702771187, -0.005728182848542929, 0.02702656388282776, 0.017356248572468758, 0.024984164163470268, 0.04301421716809273, 0.01175820454955101, 0.018123367801308632, 0.05220194160938263, -0.0018161529442295432, -0.0477440282702446, -0.0030215145088732243, 0.008482778444886208, -0.0453384593129158 ]
<p>Ok, although this question arises out of the global warming debate, this is a question purely for physicists and not intended to branch into that particular debate.</p> <p>We are told that LWIR from the Earth to the atmosphere is absorbed by greenhouse gasses and then re-radiated (in the form of backradiation) partially to the surface of the planet, "...thus warming the surface...". </p> <p>My specific question is this:</p> <p>How exactly can the re-radiated LWIR from a cooler atmosphere warm the original source of its absorbed energy? </p> <p>Edit: I am editing this question as several people have stated this is a duplicate question. I disagree. The other question quoted three alternatives and some answers stated the 2nd Law of Thermodynamics was not compromised. Please re-read my question: can the backradiated energy possibly warm a surface which was the original source of that energy? In other words, how can the surface heat itself further when there is no other energy source? I hope this clarifies, and thanks to all that have answered.</p>
g25
[ 0.05515681952238083, -0.026618920266628265, 0.007649858482182026, 0.032156672328710556, -0.017368920147418976, 0.027723953127861023, 0.012672056443989277, 0.01939232461154461, -0.03524065017700195, -0.0386013425886631, -0.02951328083872795, 0.05450853332877159, -0.03449786826968193, -0.011151785962283611, 0.05520126596093178, 0.011210554279386997, 0.019608186557888985, -0.01763669215142727, 0.06046876683831215, 0.06528163701295853, -0.07140650600194931, -0.08338277041912079, 0.006674988195300102, -0.03540582209825516, -0.11256355792284012, -0.07559734582901001, -0.021029187366366386, 0.05461663380265236, -0.012142200954258442, -0.09442918747663498, -0.014068837277591228, -0.026530878618359566, 0.02623419649899006, -0.03927933797240257, -0.013072924688458443, -0.007646748796105385, -0.00002633292751852423, 0.004126266110688448, -0.021474311128258705, 0.03422419726848602, 0.002771385945379734, 0.0152555787935853, 0.07440706342458725, 0.07838036119937897, 0.07577650994062424, 0.015174848027527332, -0.021223148331046104, -0.029335319995880127, 0.04566169157624245, -0.015981867909431458, -0.011852101422846317, -0.00020366495300550014, 0.004707880783826113, 0.006349736358970404, -0.02172143943607807, -0.04099621623754501, -0.007795808371156454, 0.0028015440329909325, 0.05564422905445099, 0.04838798940181732, 0.00042819647933356464, 0.015551037155091763, -0.002791282022371888, -0.03539194539189339, -0.005869857035577297, -0.007248282432556152, -0.0677012950181961, -0.0016049908008426428, 0.021318713203072548, -0.04571611434221268, 0.06982462853193283, 0.012658941559493542, -0.06409919261932373, -0.06869664788246155, 0.007527499459683895, -0.019634734839200974, 0.0020026585552841425, 0.019065413624048233, 0.009212966077029705, 0.022482208907604218, -0.017534861341118813, -0.02392902970314026, -0.050041571259498596, 0.03359095752239227, 0.04669056832790375, 0.00974599365144968, -0.013054592534899712, -0.005271383095532656, -0.05815372243523598, -0.01467299647629261, 0.006882991176098585, 0.016246013343334198, 0.09319885820150375, 0.006468827836215496, 0.030504576861858368, -0.06342010945081711, 0.021107548847794533, -0.0035677996929734945, -0.0617249496281147, -0.019268257543444633, -0.029949994757771492, -0.03220212087035179, -0.00455271452665329, 0.03723626956343651, 0.01648099347949028, 0.021603088825941086, 0.031111203134059906, -0.06854008138179779, -0.04986410588026047, 0.042826905846595764, 0.005079460330307484, -0.04214034229516983, 0.008927811868488789, -0.0044654496014118195, 0.0025593123864382505, -0.03048771061003208, 0.05384644865989685, -0.012783880345523357, 0.02551010623574257, 0.10232202708721161, 0.0240616537630558, 0.05457410588860512, -0.03449022397398949, 0.007955789566040039, 0.02785075455904007, -0.0015794280916452408, 0.0065339189022779465, -0.04493125528097153, 0.04537264257669449, 0.007636111229658127, 0.015389688313007355, 0.020287925377488136, -0.034832026809453964, 0.05613711476325989, -0.00521345529705286, -0.027482153847813606, 0.0030287171248346567, 0.05218050256371498, -0.0022541629150509834, 0.0010152682662010193, 0.02171727456152439, 0.005512465722858906, 0.038955457508563995, -0.0019917122554033995, -0.009719994850456715, 0.07095123827457428, -0.020659932866692543, -0.014504301361739635, 0.03474295139312744, 0.06809385865926743, 0.011940548196434975, 0.06048465892672539, 0.0446791872382164, -0.08574597537517548, 0.05292356014251709, -0.025639750063419342, -0.0017560406122356653, -0.04237210378050804, 0.05804135277867317, -0.004395314026623964, 0.07030284404754639, -0.029041841626167297, 0.045408010482788086, 0.010607055388391018, -0.0008246944053098559, 0.050329480320215225, -0.026182889938354492, -0.10647652298212051, -0.035067372024059296, 0.019613690674304962, -0.046147383749485016, 0.03045068494975567, -0.014181680977344513, 0.00895252451300621, -0.021573608741164207, 0.04475736245512962, 0.07451218366622925, 0.009905899874866009, -0.024812297895550728, -0.048079125583171844, 0.0005885735736228526, 0.014353781938552856, 0.013052844442427158, -0.03641491383314133, 0.04841828718781471, -0.06255370378494263, -0.012421052902936935, 0.005142809823155403, 0.0027675582095980644, 0.011923336423933506, -0.0280744731426239, 0.0020763471256941557, -0.002810979727655649, -0.013466193340718746, -0.00962779950350523, -0.03457159176468849, 0.014308496378362179, -0.0013691708445549011, -0.03534639626741409, 0.021772142499685287, 0.009906974621117115, -0.02490139938890934, 0.0327792763710022, -0.008639028295874596, -0.004783444572240114, 0.04455634951591492, -0.014811715111136436, -0.021675990894436836, 0.003463957691565156, -0.04856649413704872, -0.008961754851043224, -0.08370879292488098, 0.04816233366727829, -0.02262103743851185, 0.009220467880368233, 0.0007248989422805607, -0.07203773409128189, 0.014793636277318, -0.026438865810632706, -0.03584671765565872, -0.0302540585398674, 0.07694387435913086, 0.0624246783554554, -0.011129938066005707, 0.019473183900117874, 0.05726378411054611, -0.06034151837229729, -0.03733763098716736, -0.026415621861815453, 0.08413034677505493, 0.005091617815196514, -0.017995113506913185, -0.05430847033858299, 0.0053583490662276745, 0.04239354282617569, 0.033283576369285583, -0.00484863854944706, 0.004860037472099066, -0.0019223716808483005, -0.005130525212734938, 0.004264682065695524, -0.03308539465069771, -0.0013434162829071283, 0.05289808288216591, 0.004104746971279383, 0.009630577638745308, 0.04185585305094719, -0.0188007615506649, 0.0165809765458107, -0.032175324857234955, 0.014871743507683277, 0.023266999050974846, 0.01221347227692604, 0.0062767514027655125, -0.0022166832350194454, -0.05846792086958885, -0.008265973068773746, 0.0062653967179358006, -0.013207894749939442, -0.090508371591568, 0.029872307553887367, -0.034890227019786835, 0.010914333164691925, 0.03325438126921654, -0.05172928795218468, 0.033869266510009766, -0.05342302471399307, 0.019682420417666435, -0.019204730167984962, 0.0013038290198892355, 0.02518153190612793, 0.035125523805618286, -0.020562725141644478, 0.07267928868532181, 0.03715627267956734, 0.028350993990898132, 0.005976384039968252, -0.009171269834041595, 0.04896003007888794, -0.025415929034352303, 0.04843861982226372, -0.011179306544363499, -0.04141554608941078, -0.03998428210616112, 0.03699139133095741, -0.04825451597571373, -0.05948067829012871, 0.024629898369312286, 0.013631784357130527, -0.015946393832564354, -0.004681934602558613, -0.055481355637311935, 0.026497969403862953, 0.027071068063378334, -0.03814569115638733, 0.017719445750117302, 0.03792029619216919, -0.017404217272996902, -0.010058628395199776, 0.04948415234684944, 0.03191990777850151, -0.06926821917295456, 0.005376296117901802, -0.011218948289752007, -0.02245139144361019, -0.0016387704527005553, -0.07532796263694763, -0.041120365262031555, 0.04818732291460037, -0.016606925055384636, -0.021367592737078667, 0.03395320102572441, -0.06373444944620132, 0.011443515308201313, 0.033155594021081924, -0.052756134420633316, -0.07804331928491592, -0.04029769077897072, 0.10795784741640091, 0.0038189529441297054, -0.06757543981075287, 0.029919583350419998, 0.0172733161598444, -0.022581472992897034, 0.002451179549098015, 0.013151265680789948, -0.02842547371983528, -0.02870754711329937, -0.013667929917573929, -0.04234274476766586, -0.029502203688025475, 0.05154856666922569, 0.008478316478431225, -0.040599726140499115, 0.028354523703455925, -0.020744439214468002, -0.017246071249246597, 0.032753124833106995, 0.0426798015832901, 0.09071164578199387, 0.007716601714491844, 0.0008071056217886508, -0.07308682054281235, -0.02106127329170704, 0.04401383176445961, 0.021912308409810066, -0.03085724450647831, -0.04786895588040352, -0.09559047967195511, -0.013562862761318684, 0.02828289568424225, 0.037234753370285034, -0.023258594796061516, 0.03879094123840332, -0.002450664760544896, 0.06297844648361206, -0.008138933219015598, 0.040560971945524216, 0.07102470844984055, 0.007662390824407339, 0.0033615503925830126, -0.036416009068489075, 0.05123985931277275, -0.03272959217429161, 0.004683888517320156, -0.006428131368011236, 0.048065219074487686, -0.047531530261039734, -0.022044233977794647, 0.002956382930278778, 0.04425427317619324, -0.04414038732647896, -0.021536029875278473, 0.03598584979772568, -0.014728016220033169, -0.0031019458547234535, 0.012511382810771465, 0.019290708005428314, -0.003714991267770529, 0.04247065261006355, -0.0018155428115278482, 0.03464885428547859, -0.03040505200624466, 0.026380954310297966, 0.020256241783499718, -0.00008968445763457566, -0.021741939708590508, -0.005574497394263744, 0.035129111260175705, 0.029499758034944534, 0.0177543256431818, 0.009750536642968655, -0.006720108445733786, 0.006354501936584711, 0.011760644614696503, -0.016375984996557236, 0.002404061146080494, -0.023697689175605774, 0.000662229722365737, 0.05327225103974342, 0.02048577554523945, 0.06258068978786469, 0.03848763555288315, -0.012977655977010727, -0.027304986491799355, 0.012852787971496582, 0.04466519504785538, -0.015690414234995842, -0.03488178178668022, 0.003921931143850088, 0.013978146016597748, 0.026537908241152763, -0.07142528891563416, -0.05209798738360405, 0.03689312934875488, -0.039730608463287354, 0.03943841531872749, -0.055533912032842636, 0.015386625193059444, -0.018379271030426025, -0.05451665446162224, -0.03774493932723999, 0.012261639349162579, -0.025707941502332687, -0.009493425488471985, 0.06612343341112137, 0.05924359709024429, -0.02325170859694481, -0.05106642097234726, -0.04226129129528999, 0.05917069688439369, -0.032707296311855316, -0.038397178053855896, -0.005920927040278912, -0.03212295100092888, -0.012050841003656387, 0.0003034095570910722, 0.009338464587926865, -0.003333179047331214, -0.017486240714788437, 0.08114422112703323, -0.019121093675494194, 0.005091153550893068, 0.03901807963848114, -0.007140255533158779, 0.058226682245731354, -0.008648337796330452, -0.05096530541777611, -0.0007968478021211922, 0.00872730277478695, -0.03687756881117821, -0.010516122914850712, 0.05340544134378433, 0.02357281558215618, -0.021800868213176727, 0.004818773362785578, -0.029556211084127426, 0.015626173466444016, -0.0638546273112297, 0.029838522896170616, 0.004192051477730274, 0.0004677331307902932, 0.08565477281808853, -0.013435570523142815, 0.01592959091067314, -0.027272405102849007, -0.011568422429263592, 0.04259924218058586, -0.0473913848400116, -0.015371989458799362, 0.006687195971608162, 0.05219366028904915, -0.02465512976050377, 0.05435223877429962, 0.013833259232342243, -0.010814417153596878, 0.024518083781003952, -0.01042961236089468, -0.002017237711697817, -0.013786212541162968, -0.004950962960720062, -0.026146238669753075, -0.02518669329583645, 0.03601427376270294, 0.02639002539217472, 0.012689903378486633, -0.03155306354165077, -0.01648598536849022, -0.019129257649183273, 0.0015911264345049858, -0.012832904234528542, 0.07491882145404816, -0.009047098457813263, 0.0062203481793403625, -0.015165384858846664, 0.0252260509878397, 0.006652656011283398, -0.051022738218307495, -0.0295206680893898, 0.06314390897750854, 0.008661222644150257, 0.0017489187885075808, -0.026562780141830444, 0.06510064750909805, 0.00930693093687296, -0.022850194945931435, -0.0004039355553686619, -0.010231774300336838, -0.009053998626768589, -0.02505701594054699, -0.009351585991680622, 0.0081605464220047, -0.03409431874752045, -0.009235719218850136, 0.07283364236354828, -0.03787042945623398, -0.00841726828366518, 0.017160234972834587, 0.004796342924237251, 0.010778077878057957, -0.009241159074008465, -0.027683256193995476, 0.0003112701524514705, -0.004823349416255951, -0.026083404198288918, 0.004599119536578655, -0.06451831758022308, -0.0009765460854396224, -0.016327746212482452, 0.002067748224362731, -0.002573528327047825, 0.07789256423711777, -0.024473709985613823, 0.02181500568985939, 0.033129237592220306, -0.04303818568587303, -0.029788276180624962, -0.0037423400208353996, 0.017781896516680717, 0.031134115532040596, -0.001276484108529985, -0.06794236600399017, 0.05574900284409523, 0.03828413784503937, 0.04356599971652031, -0.025603385642170906, 0.01758543774485588, 0.03231222927570343, 0.0358274020254612, -0.0417930893599987, -0.024877499788999557, -0.0037826632615178823, 0.018516378477215767, 0.008671330288052559, 0.04130884259939194, -0.0328303687274456, 0.009763523004949093, 0.03582337126135826, 0.07440872490406036, -0.05102119594812393, 0.025640450417995453, 0.0332028865814209, 0.02325327694416046, -0.011923144571483135, 0.000834611535537988, -0.04122588783502579, -0.06062505394220352, -0.03039710782468319, 0.01650042086839676, -0.022197015583515167, 0.021242154762148857, -0.03441829979419708, -0.018315119668841362, -0.015054840594530106, 0.007828514091670513, 0.007027280051261187, -0.004127513151615858, -0.003797222161665559, -0.014276595786213875, -0.024676991626620293, -0.039207588881254196, -0.029646094888448715, 0.007356548216193914, -0.050298433750867844, 0.022905346006155014, 0.024744020774960518, -0.04141927883028984, 0.02149282768368721, 0.012415059842169285, 0.01584704965353012, 0.010242338292300701, -0.041100166738033295, -0.017032034695148468, -0.051829855889081955, -0.06528951227664948, -0.03348705172538757, -0.005965827964246273, 0.06787373870611191, -0.03031700663268566, 0.0056556640192866325, 0.008679943159222603, -0.00461964076384902, 0.023479191586375237, -0.0626511201262474, 0.07305087894201279, -0.025741683319211006, 0.024947794154286385, 0.001149791874922812, 0.044404275715351105, -0.009870431385934353, -0.06891312450170517, -0.02699890360236168, 0.029040418565273285, -0.027179045602679253, -0.03194887191057205, -0.006854280363768339, -0.025420475751161575, 0.021007193252444267, 0.016522901132702827, 0.020177112892270088, -0.0022300647106021643, -0.05015698820352554, 0.04270360246300697, -0.025083767250180244, 0.0006957435980439186, -0.017228800803422928, -0.02167653851211071, 0.08328007906675339, 0.08790454268455505, 0.035981327295303345, 0.002809037221595645, 0.0031766050960868597, -0.008913911879062653, 0.01320425420999527, 0.04215262830257416, 0.006307422183454037, 0.05477717146277428, -0.06270471960306168, -0.05222801864147186, 0.03793146088719368, -0.05224182456731796, 0.006123305298388004, 0.025338206440210342, 0.020818553864955902, -0.058034177869558334, 0.020168989896774292, -0.0025637224316596985, -0.03540379926562309, -0.04666846618056297, -0.0007885931991040707, -0.0312618687748909, -0.04121898487210274, -0.07248596101999283, 0.05443011596798897, -0.019109776243567467, 0.01666875369846821, -0.07599959522485733, 0.02497287467122078, 0.047733984887599945, -0.01847359724342823, 0.024691764265298843, -0.061626121401786804, 0.038550589233636856, -0.033235739916563034, 0.008558232337236404, 0.06801287829875946, 0.05498957633972168, -0.036437418311834335, 0.01983175054192543, -0.01456004660576582, 0.004231208004057407, -0.10063637793064117, 0.00021219372865743935, -0.02444162592291832, 0.013499905355274677, 0.012999959290027618, 0.03572763875126839, 0.038679949939250946, 0.04315722733736038, 0.012436454184353352, 0.03296320512890816, 0.015752920880913734, -0.05641292408108711, -0.00031113962177187204, 0.002911366755142808, 0.0350566990673542, -0.004427419044077396, 0.07283104956150055, -0.019040796905755997, -0.01901433616876602, -0.07197564095258713, 0.03341261297464371, 0.005128835793584585, 0.03685326129198074, -0.023236358538269997, 0.007134304381906986, 0.02997731789946556, 0.0005364311509765685, -0.007111785002052784, -0.017131159082055092, -0.026047540828585625, -0.04214411601424217, -0.026305370032787323, -0.022917231544852257, 0.040242280811071396, -0.01883125863969326, 0.0027593402191996574, -0.014504279009997845, -0.026926858350634575, -0.03472093120217323, -0.06971316039562225, 0.0041776723228394985, 0.06172967702150345, 0.05022582411766052, 0.01870659366250038, 0.014617047272622585, -0.013498184271156788, 0.027401026338338852, 0.008340304717421532, -0.04721270501613617, 0.010841201059520245, 0.023913312703371048, -0.028566507622599602, -0.02081594429910183, 0.050915345549583435, 0.019406884908676147, 0.021407416090369225, -0.0597384013235569, 0.020772134885191917, -0.012398823164403439, 0.028154468163847923, 0.07579069584608078, 0.013700956478714943, -0.03585033491253853, 0.00982722733169794, 0.01877770759165287, 0.02221011556684971, -0.04438299313187599, 0.04385656118392944, 0.031112540513277054, 0.0417478010058403, -0.03089456632733345, 0.016781523823738098, -0.07579968124628067, -0.0403013676404953, 0.00285787764005363, -0.007564120460301638, -0.0019218355882912874, 0.04965100809931755, -0.003877065610140562, -0.016888225451111794, 0.013682276010513306, -0.012963390909135342, 0.0016083365771919489, 0.05298301950097084, -0.024356914684176445, -0.037076566368341446, 0.017757633700966835, -0.052876852452754974, 0.02692330814898014, -0.04820305481553078, 0.03050781600177288, 0.03652393817901611, -0.05916697159409523, -0.03147754818201065, -0.02470971830189228, -0.029714709147810936, 0.01704636961221695 ]
<p>If I look through the microwave window I can see through, which means visible radiation can get out. We know also that there is a mesh on the microwave window which prevents microwave from coming out.</p> <p>My question is how does this work? how come making stripes or mesh of metals can attenuate microwave radiation yet allow visible radiation?</p> <p>Looks like an electrodynamics problem to me with periodic boundary conditions (because of the partitions on the microwave oven window). Is it discussed in any textbook?</p>
g1601
[ 0.057825811207294464, 0.014279011636972427, 0.0024977317079901695, -0.010397064499557018, 0.011820629239082336, 0.027021290734410286, 0.04726096987724304, 0.05893958732485771, -0.012580132111907005, -0.03159066289663315, 0.02892761491239071, 0.09188774973154068, -0.0259543489664793, 0.04969079792499542, 0.024014370515942574, 0.004010590724647045, 0.011151261627674103, 0.009077447466552258, -0.004811043385416269, 0.024926835671067238, -0.008888055570423603, 0.0009479282307438552, 0.008978545665740967, -0.024557823315262794, -0.016024954617023468, 0.02464606799185276, 0.023506280034780502, -0.0436696782708168, 0.006709292996674776, -0.0028421683236956596, 0.03480689227581024, -0.02986527793109417, 0.0723179280757904, -0.013562907464802265, -0.026343848556280136, 0.010101239196956158, 0.017421791329979897, 0.008794124238193035, -0.03394652158021927, -0.0010651281336322427, 0.01396948006004095, 0.005219428334385157, 0.013137605972588062, 0.028248697519302368, 0.011255032382905483, 0.03893616423010826, -0.05610127002000809, -0.02855624072253704, -0.015069405548274517, -0.04659208655357361, 0.01071702130138874, -0.03396609425544739, 0.026712603867053986, -0.03105415403842926, -0.030135750770568848, -0.033302001655101776, -0.006536771543323994, -0.018719801679253578, 0.12276531010866165, 0.03362752124667168, -0.0005033396300859749, 0.04265889525413513, -0.08080466091632843, -0.00895480066537857, -0.0027918433770537376, 0.023326165974140167, -0.02046368643641472, -0.011815227568149567, -0.008654385805130005, 0.012013629078865051, 0.01769213005900383, -0.020619697868824005, -0.008633702993392944, -0.09680718928575516, 0.004851092584431171, 0.020367072895169258, -0.02635103464126587, 0.003444664878770709, 0.013760623522102833, 0.049520377069711685, -0.05034783482551575, 0.026532599702477455, -0.05565407872200012, 0.010912391357123852, 0.002218571025878191, 0.017602378502488136, -0.01188402995467186, 0.039127033203840256, -0.022284161299467087, -0.03454742580652237, -0.023830221965909004, -0.010457487776875496, -0.027780918404459953, 0.005170577205717564, 0.0362415574491024, 0.007009975612163544, -0.015121879987418652, 0.050358742475509644, -0.04101628437638283, -0.01630549319088459, 0.05314547196030617, -0.01992122270166874, 0.024834705516695976, 0.03441905975341797, 0.021225713193416595, -0.007176180835813284, 0.057077303528785706, 0.02339860051870346, 0.01172709558159113, 0.03855125233530998, -0.04089830443263054, -0.06089813634753227, -0.068814717233181, 0.006357680540531874, 0.018128318712115288, 0.01925470679998398, 0.1019633486866951, 0.009821777231991291, 0.0609707236289978, 0.050888363271951675, 0.032961469143629074, 0.011149299331009388, -0.0071569159626960754, -0.014257997274398804, 0.016750799492001534, 0.0070144301280379295, 0.0017556885723024607, 0.004713069181889296, 0.03983662277460098, 0.0033497950062155724, 0.06658939272165298, 0.03921651095151901, -0.002492740284651518, 0.061177417635917664, 0.031395990401506424, 0.004122012760490179, 0.0273701511323452, -0.01580829918384552, 0.027301350608468056, -0.010237069800496101, 0.008141354657709599, -0.043382562696933746, -0.02230568416416645, -0.07989469915628433, -0.010443597100675106, -0.005376908928155899, -0.018070640042424202, -0.0007805718341842294, 0.025823131203651428, -0.017432665452361107, -0.002801052527502179, 0.0812784880399704, -0.05491412803530693, -0.018825002014636993, -0.010618122294545174, -0.021949324756860733, 0.02637205645442009, 0.0091541213914752, 0.04548049718141556, 0.025710107758641243, 0.06163013353943825, -0.009467273950576782, -0.0035017565824091434, -0.035199448466300964, 0.0014953818172216415, 0.014202308841049671, -0.03847487270832062, -0.06883666664361954, 0.00024909648345783353, -0.028181154280900955, -0.036455243825912476, -0.011394779197871685, -0.009105709381401539, 0.04962910711765289, -0.06181764230132103, 0.05188211053609848, 0.07526907324790955, -0.007000552490353584, 0.06268882751464844, -0.02284877747297287, -0.015560081228613853, -0.029007205739617348, 0.05481160804629326, -0.06005048379302025, 0.017526596784591675, -0.03789687529206276, -0.018239188939332962, -0.01988285966217518, -0.05934607982635498, 0.03519322723150253, 0.010419497266411781, 0.03769489750266075, 0.01909455843269825, -0.012380952946841717, -0.00010456660675117746, -0.05017329752445221, 0.05268588662147522, -0.011870463378727436, 0.05715576931834221, -0.06311096251010895, -0.02795674465596676, 0.041378118097782135, 0.024808308109641075, 0.027509858831763268, 0.08779969811439514, 0.015279068611562252, -0.015877187252044678, 0.047770868986845016, 0.0029885154217481613, 0.04557286947965622, -0.0025883365888148546, -0.0014743796782568097, 0.028074905276298523, -0.02088257297873497, 0.04745934531092644, 0.03532381355762482, -0.033174000680446625, 0.021523520350456238, -0.017622606828808784, 0.01275840774178505, 0.016491297632455826, -0.049701862037181854, -0.026521826162934303, -0.030830521136522293, -0.054845500737428665, -0.04295112192630768, -0.04122752323746681, -0.032503530383110046, -0.00903247483074665, 0.03288198634982109, -0.05998730659484863, -0.04966367408633232, 0.01465928927063942, -0.027186503633856773, -0.0003351849445607513, -0.002153475768864155, -0.0648469403386116, 0.0493638776242733, -0.03535395860671997, -0.03408792242407799, 0.0046849059872329235, -0.022982299327850342, 0.001495310221798718, -0.03457573428750038, 0.0004820294852834195, -0.03252449631690979, 0.025889869779348373, 0.009951145388185978, 0.0025678672827780247, -0.021035069599747658, 0.07903256267309189, -0.0399651974439621, 0.00093926175031811, 0.0018861631397157907, -0.02936566062271595, -0.050548430532217026, -0.03820497915148735, 0.0434671975672245, -0.004129140172153711, 0.0010717971017584205, 0.006557889748364687, -0.0554945170879364, 0.05621113255620003, 0.00794118270277977, 0.0009579663746990263, -0.025453142821788788, -0.02437177672982216, 0.015559885650873184, -0.0017580841667950153, 0.008392256684601307, -0.041337016969919205, 0.0216622743755579, 0.010990401729941368, -0.003070998936891556, 0.03586285188794136, -0.022289685904979706, 0.034150630235672, -0.05138431116938591, 0.05672871321439743, 0.008108245208859444, -0.0543283112347126, 0.00889422558248043, -0.07396592199802399, -0.0070846062153577805, 0.026236586272716522, -0.047125186771154404, -0.025756079703569412, -0.013416413217782974, 0.021150648593902588, -0.03221529349684715, -0.07921856641769409, -0.011889019049704075, 0.0058518084697425365, -0.0072175911627709866, -0.06640004366636276, 0.02063557133078575, 0.022694934159517288, -0.03354029357433319, -0.024076813831925392, -0.06020016223192215, -0.03314390033483505, 0.00806760136038065, -0.02261536940932274, -0.049886975437402725, -0.010781757533550262, 0.02600005269050598, -0.031933464109897614, -0.008486113511025906, 0.06451136618852615, -0.06090162694454193, -0.01172844972461462, 0.04867149889469147, -0.015932312235236168, 0.014459091238677502, -0.02522832341492176, 0.042383626103401184, -0.017059190198779106, 0.004014184698462486, 0.025058768689632416, 0.028791991993784904, -0.06261208653450012, 0.010691034607589245, -0.0014283036580309272, -0.08212243765592575, 0.036372486501932144, -0.007830620743334293, 0.058855924755334854, -0.043566588312387466, -0.0225512757897377, 0.001123122638091445, 0.03614279255270958, 0.037357110530138016, -0.039192087948322296, -0.026448719203472137, 0.03359469398856163, 0.010967765003442764, -0.07153282314538956, 0.03225555643439293, -0.006697214674204588, -0.012585574761033058, 0.012387244030833244, -0.04795612022280693, -0.008406272158026695, -0.03882851079106331, 0.07766891270875931, 0.016292963176965714, -0.01524541899561882, -0.040142472833395004, 0.0026297150179743767, 0.011296877637505531, 0.05630974471569061, 0.059445708990097046, 0.001898049027658999, -0.03396819904446602, -0.036963533610105515, 0.03086947835981846, -0.005158033687621355, 0.004316231701523066, 0.09288031607866287, 0.0006269855075515807, -0.006651583593338728, -0.04584861174225807, -0.013890770263969898, -0.0575227327644825, -0.0036022216081619263, -0.05675092339515686, 0.10902515053749084, 0.07051686942577362, 0.011763528920710087, -0.044546861201524734, -0.03591938316822052, -0.049465809017419815, 0.022807851433753967, 0.004737288691103458, 0.029108857735991478, 0.020991727709770203, -0.031741395592689514, 0.05411742255091667, 0.01910608634352684, 0.03869067505002022, -0.05952148512005806, -0.010875718668103218, -0.004779437556862831, 0.011208241805434227, 0.05357888713479042, 0.019905852153897285, 0.022396590560674667, 0.02946236915886402, -0.02788078412413597, -0.051307275891304016, 0.05431205406785011, 0.0032770370598882437, -0.005729274824261665, 0.006444177124649286, 0.0022301203571259975, -0.07185550034046173, -0.006159604527056217, 0.001777221797965467, -0.012926658615469933, -0.017005741596221924, 0.09010174125432968, 0.08372864872217178, -0.05706416070461273, 0.011044862680137157, 0.030466502532362938, 0.028363261371850967, 0.020328804850578308, 0.03821142390370369, 0.025726139545440674, -0.024608703330159187, -0.011199040338397026, -0.022570570930838585, -0.034271690994501114, -0.024732103571295738, 0.03770456463098526, -0.00034283087006770074, 0.011761502362787724, -0.007357858121395111, -0.02772030606865883, 0.01677272468805313, -0.06682202219963074, 0.04648338258266449, -0.022973764687776566, 0.014530262909829617, 0.0710393413901329, 0.10373243689537048, 0.02167384885251522, -0.03212842345237732, -0.0030040026176720858, -0.060409560799598694, 0.03283669054508209, -0.0013609587913379073, -0.08050765842199326, -0.0320495069026947, -0.02436225488781929, -0.010767819359898567, -0.07696108520030975, 0.019763553515076637, -0.0103392219170928, 0.053919609636068344, 0.032399024814367294, -0.04848955571651459, -0.000005955764663667651, 0.02185576595366001, -0.0077179172076284885, 0.042714208364486694, -0.02092943899333477, -0.004482302349060774, 0.0036857114173471928, 0.036133259534835815, -0.0504542700946331, -0.04449347406625748, -0.05734986439347267, -0.024287087842822075, -0.014584950171411037, -0.049668796360492706, -0.06335607916116714, -0.00857028178870678, 0.08463523536920547, 0.015367594547569752, -0.02129303477704525, -0.02349882572889328, -0.01980694755911827, 0.06748682260513306, 0.03774258494377136, -0.037557076662778854, -0.0007502470980398357, -0.012280501425266266, -0.06297565251588821, 0.023069314658641815, 0.022707846015691757, 0.07700646668672562, 0.009457492269575596, 0.011710935272276402, -0.017378855496644974, -0.000875115511007607, -0.04131997376680374, 0.00177907629404217, 0.004126997664570808, -0.0038532870821654797, 0.014460505917668343, 0.04466935247182846, 0.024406109005212784, 0.041599202901124954, -0.014932893216609955, -0.0036397664807736874, -0.0023542821872979403, 0.05123020336031914, -0.02544238045811653, -0.014853189699351788, 0.0021521919406950474, -0.03387977555394173, 0.010051483288407326, 0.04078668728470802, 0.0033852742053568363, -0.02729683369398117, 0.05369646102190018, 0.029641972854733467, -0.032180193811655045, -0.05861702188849449, 0.04530149698257446, -0.09910766035318375, -0.030619744211435318, -0.018822507932782173, -0.0015845660818740726, 0.05673927441239357, 0.041126884520053864, 0.015358862467110157, 0.01472021359950304, 0.001964706927537918, -0.01758529804646969, -0.025508075952529907, -0.03366929665207863, -0.039461515843868256, 0.04408429563045502, -0.0664755329489708, -0.04897242784500122, -0.04082157462835312, -0.028137842193245888, -0.028241369873285294, -0.0309828519821167, 0.04537232965230942, -0.006494726520031691, -0.02649630792438984, 0.02906150184571743, -0.004083395469933748, -0.045378390699625015, 0.04201815649867058, 0.016997603699564934, -0.0031933311838656664, 0.043408434838056564, 0.026602057740092278, -0.0392112135887146, 0.016741327941417694, 0.02472137287259102, -0.0014202698366716504, 0.07451031357049942, 0.03246421366930008, -0.018888331949710846, 0.09916850179433823, -0.00424811989068985, 0.004322290886193514, 0.0817967876791954, 0.04772545397281647, 0.003207490546628833, -0.0006891965749673545, 0.019303401932120323, 0.0895894393324852, 0.01116466149687767, 0.02900085411965847, 0.014117884449660778, -0.014488361775875092, 0.030473222956061363, 0.016238389536738396, 0.0004977622302249074, 0.03416529670357704, 0.04876627400517464, -0.02945714443922043, 0.026726573705673218, -0.037691630423069, 0.055215999484062195, 0.007268394809216261, -0.023973751813173294, -0.03868138790130615, 0.009591820649802685, -0.013459883630275726, -0.017522292211651802, 0.0258470606058836, 0.02840377390384674, 0.019208380952477455, 0.04864883050322533, -0.016687223687767982, 0.02374839037656784, 0.01794721744954586, -0.05953827500343323, 0.055866796523332596, -0.03371425345540047, 0.002560870721936226, -0.02598770335316658, 0.012141467072069645, 0.061551935970783234, 0.05291890352964401, -0.04210515320301056, -0.03189659118652344, -0.02225920930504799, 0.017090031877160072, -0.025050247088074684, -0.03260670229792595, 0.015216788277029991, -0.019934076815843582, -0.04467257484793663, -0.01043420098721981, 0.05000902712345123, 0.09547911584377289, 0.023042762652039528, -0.036616481840610504, -0.024357417598366737, 0.04073294252157211, -0.03644600138068199, 0.06587766855955124, 0.038068514317274094, -0.08219010382890701, -0.01122933067381382, 0.027564777061343193, 0.025321297347545624, 0.01589999906718731, 0.041398294270038605, -0.023087868466973305, -0.003294174326583743, -0.01185155101120472, -0.015455493703484535, 0.01410504151135683, 0.030253401026129723, 0.0006523834890685976, -0.005347110331058502, -0.04902958869934082, -0.0280359648168087, 0.03307664021849632, -0.025158248841762543, 0.006243439391255379, -0.048734549432992935, -0.034620437771081924, -0.02850412018597126, -0.009189139120280743, 0.05307965725660324, -0.006371466908603907, -0.037051647901535034, -0.000559500593226403, 0.12221498042345047, -0.020742317661643028, -0.015464718453586102, -0.029877975583076477, 0.008810058236122131, -0.018949050456285477, 0.03927050158381462, 0.0065603856928646564, -0.0387999452650547, -0.040260616689920425, 0.030988873913884163, 0.05487244576215744, -0.0010673527140170336, 0.01439901813864708, 0.051635682582855225, 0.044446226209402084, -0.040714066475629807, 0.047117020934820175, -0.019436772912740707, -0.0647498145699501, -0.0862356498837471, -0.0026993548963218927, -0.011565481312572956, -0.0462460070848465, -0.06314858794212341, 0.027534624561667442, 0.017359156161546707, 0.012659476138651371, -0.0494193360209465, -0.0329715795814991, -0.036492880433797836, -0.014929002150893211, -0.000956737669184804, 0.00729965278878808, -0.012920105829834938, 0.03701026365160942, -0.009886334650218487, -0.018496863543987274, 0.05484096333384514, -0.009505736641585827, 0.013104311190545559, -0.03631358966231346, -0.03464662283658981, -0.030755512416362762, -0.012896699830889702, -0.021892141550779343, 0.018829382956027985, -0.05244723707437515, -0.03146681189537048, 0.04743737354874611, -0.006698837969452143, -0.043356556445360184, 0.01033173780888319, -0.009292896836996078, 0.031031517311930656, -0.057177409529685974, 0.039491936564445496, 0.005054372828453779, -0.006736306939274073, -0.002400602214038372, 0.0014234621776267886, -0.017386222258210182, 0.01825615018606186, -0.00666262861341238, 0.02463638223707676, 0.016035012900829315, 0.01181551069021225, 0.023458020761609077, -0.002159925876185298, 0.035721924155950546, 0.01587209478020668, 0.0027750269509851933, -0.0025135737378150225, 0.021554553881287575, -0.012844826094806194, 0.005705013871192932, 0.010085687972605228, 0.06235193833708763, 0.020216163247823715, -0.031682442873716354, -0.04860923811793327, -0.03149394690990448, -0.00939260609447956, 0.0529266856610775, 0.028950540348887444, -0.032557081431150436, 0.005251995287835598, 0.003416813677176833, -0.08733471482992172, 0.030099865049123764, -0.01978512667119503, -0.018699131906032562, 0.06531418859958649, 0.007752204779535532, -0.017476795241236687, -0.03700808808207512, 0.03476986289024353, 0.009837988764047623, 0.00923686008900404, -0.045331016182899475, 0.002824510680511594, 0.008922144770622253, 0.013947869651019573, 0.02750561200082302, -0.006590413860976696, -0.016110215336084366, -0.014082388021051884, -0.04459980130195618, 0.047558750957250595, 0.014485045336186886, 0.03174935653805733, 0.00247538136318326, 0.02965586632490158, -0.017556745558977127, -0.0032936090137809515, -0.0479808934032917, -0.0460355170071125, 0.018518494442105293, -0.06668739765882492, -0.01388750784099102, -0.005224091932177544, 0.04284586384892464, -0.05102716386318207, -0.033408790826797485, -0.039152830839157104, -0.003491985844448209, 0.05585264042019844, -0.06949979066848755, 0.009383078664541245, -0.018272636458277702, 0.0026796027086675167, 0.009007111191749573, -0.007248155772686005, 0.01683654822409153, -0.025554347783327103, -0.04008786380290985, -0.03078896552324295, -0.017857367172837257, -0.003644991433247924, -0.06566277891397476 ]
<p>My apologies if this question has already been answered. Using the notation of Sakurai, we have an energy eigenket N and an eigenvalue n.</p> <p>$$N | n \rangle = n | n \rangle$$</p> <p>For the number operator $N = a^\dagger a $. My question is precisely why does n have to be an integer. I do understand that it must be positive definite due to the norm condition on $ a | n \rangle $:</p> <p>$$\langle n | a^\dagger a | n \rangle \geq 0$$</p> <p>I can see that we can show:</p> <p>$$ a | n \rangle = \sqrt{n-1} | n-1 \rangle $$ and similarly for $a^\dagger | n \rangle$</p> <p>Sakurai argues that the sequential operation of $a$ operators leads to the form which he does not write, but I will write here for clarity:</p> <p>$$ a^k | n \rangle = \left(\sqrt{n}\sqrt{n-1}...\sqrt{n-k+1}\right) | n - k + 1 \rangle $$ </p> <p>Since</p> <p>$$ a|0 \rangle = 0 $$</p> <p>the sequence must terminate, but can only terminate if n is an integer. How can we make that jump? Is there a formal mathematical proof that the sequence $\left(\sqrt{n}\sqrt{n-1}...\sqrt{n-k+1}\right)$ will terminate if and only if n is an integer?</p>
g1602
[ 0.027858605608344078, 0.05246900022029877, -0.003383090253919363, 0.009007555432617664, -0.018325474113225937, -0.057724133133888245, 0.01404552161693573, -0.020008960738778114, -0.023581543937325478, -0.02985120750963688, -0.02571740373969078, 0.021395869553089142, -0.01540526282042265, 0.056558333337306976, 0.0673968568444252, -0.036496296525001526, 0.026979397982358932, -0.04272669181227684, -0.028067370876669884, -0.030267704278230667, -0.08122037351131439, 0.04693116620182991, -0.007420992478728294, -0.004610935691744089, 0.08039934933185577, -0.06812851130962372, 0.030747277662158012, -0.011499248445034027, -0.059705350548028946, 0.004560869187116623, 0.07692839205265045, -0.056220751255750656, 0.04754991829395294, -0.022370774298906326, 0.006769200786948204, 0.028114663437008858, 0.05835409462451935, -0.009803760796785355, 0.020470162853598595, -0.03795783221721649, -0.02230311557650566, 0.023708602413535118, 0.015722516924142838, -0.008782027289271355, -0.024864865466952324, 0.005690368823707104, 0.030426012352108955, 0.0015478134155273438, 0.0064341300167143345, 0.029558943584561348, -0.02092823199927807, 0.008103467524051666, 0.021176407113671303, -0.05094407871365547, -0.039937812834978104, 0.018490206450223923, -0.053882159292697906, 0.004761138930916786, -0.060274384915828705, 0.058709774166345596, 0.022884001955389977, -0.03355395048856735, 0.04568345844745636, -0.014628265984356403, 0.01661604270339012, -0.03148049861192703, 0.008400720544159412, 0.01155846193432808, 0.04634496942162514, 0.05772959068417549, -0.01045810617506504, -0.0390065535902977, 0.03745869919657707, -0.007104974240064621, 0.0468665212392807, 0.002431032247841358, 0.026733752340078354, -0.0076612988486886024, -0.04843038320541382, 0.04383671656250954, -0.006215224042534828, -0.002310427138581872, 0.014977691695094109, -0.04009128361940384, -0.00812250841408968, 0.015699898824095726, 0.02498072199523449, -0.030744194984436035, -0.001770676113665104, 0.028727369382977486, -0.010651799850165844, 0.04346737638115883, 0.01888158544898033, 0.05155207961797714, 0.02062581665813923, -0.04523952677845955, -0.04785766825079918, 0.07424528896808624, 0.053895194083452225, -0.01342314574867487, 0.027773676440119743, 0.03441064804792404, 0.022714324295520782, -0.05166737362742424, -0.010238776914775372, -0.040468133985996246, 0.012585237622261047, -0.029771462082862854, 0.039304040372371674, -0.007039885967969894, -0.0035489397123456, 0.004850812256336212, -0.04896588996052742, -0.025954250246286392, 0.0003131794510409236, 0.0695267990231514, 0.020401714369654655, 0.005684973672032356, -0.05556443706154823, 0.026997800916433334, -0.019297851249575615, -0.03561443090438843, 0.0030493291560560465, 0.030382376164197922, 0.015909135341644287, -0.019790099933743477, 0.00989503227174282, 0.02123844064772129, -0.0021099653095006943, -0.0011155467946082354, 0.02430073358118534, 0.022263556718826294, 0.011397450231015682, 0.04276954010128975, 0.012967568822205067, 0.012605322524905205, -0.007125857751816511, 0.013044390827417374, 0.0821240171790123, -0.07389416545629501, 0.01984134130179882, -0.03533061966300011, 0.016251729801297188, -0.02097589708864689, 0.024585748091340065, 0.04892732575535774, 0.007406159769743681, -0.03887994959950447, -0.033135559409856796, 0.052624162286520004, -0.03287607431411743, 0.0456489697098732, -0.04809039458632469, -0.039094869047403336, 0.026621276512742043, -0.027115795761346817, 0.032653115689754486, -0.023453671485185623, -0.025774670764803886, -0.0001529118890175596, 0.020515771582722664, 0.009608670137822628, -0.03466818481683731, 0.05770665407180786, -0.06285606324672699, -0.04122437536716461, -0.031171889975667, -0.06395050883293152, -0.040463756769895554, -0.05956988409161568, -0.017240146175026894, 0.05572262033820152, 0.03382216393947601, -0.0053522041998803616, 0.04577265679836273, 0.05816798657178879, -0.02556745894253254, 0.01219662930816412, 0.036907751113176346, -0.04090140759944916, -0.03765169903635979, -0.0020105072762817144, 0.023459019139409065, 0.016531042754650116, 0.02186967246234417, 0.006360233295708895, -0.06477149575948715, -0.007096895016729832, 0.027622750028967857, 0.013262555003166199, 0.052664950489997864, 0.008940585888922215, 0.0058150514960289, 0.03831985965371132, 0.00900376308709383, -0.018745355308055878, -0.017790256068110466, -0.03189945966005325, 0.021117817610502243, -0.007238372694700956, 0.057980939745903015, -0.01402221154421568, -0.0475815124809742, -0.006165520288050175, 0.02676229551434517, 0.00010413036216050386, 0.01856330595910549, -0.001785246771760285, -0.02849148027598858, -0.07062643021345139, 0.025639604777097702, -0.05845285579562187, -0.08338095992803574, 0.015930885449051857, 0.009975242428481579, 0.043266937136650085, 0.03996919095516205, -0.006379894446581602, 0.012985628098249435, 0.018155105412006378, -0.044734369963407516, -0.01573089510202408, -0.014409015886485577, 0.017620496451854706, -0.06128465384244919, 0.054130081087350845, -0.01774017885327339, -0.0340043380856514, 0.01890099234879017, -0.024410348385572433, -0.0864124596118927, -0.025555040687322617, -0.03441298380494118, -0.06406836211681366, 0.017677834257483482, 0.027379367500543594, 0.03120320849120617, 0.05380198732018471, 0.044054318219423294, 0.01092563010752201, 0.016066163778305054, 0.02115483209490776, 0.003073275089263916, 0.035784557461738586, -0.048096783459186554, -0.0010883962968364358, -0.030397498980164528, -0.013069143518805504, -0.07371901720762253, 0.02588520385324955, -0.028926977887749672, -0.043006692081689835, -0.011340733617544174, 0.10108233243227005, -0.009465794079005718, -0.031942419707775116, -0.02292378805577755, 0.017736151814460754, 0.025463290512561798, 0.031722523272037506, 0.03225579112768173, 0.060978420078754425, 0.008009292185306549, 0.029837146401405334, -0.058604829013347626, 0.03539968654513359, -0.03956402838230133, 0.02884088084101677, -0.02756679058074951, 0.018202371895313263, 0.01057223230600357, 0.061950281262397766, 0.02480762079358101, -0.013286363333463669, -0.058142196387052536, -0.0886431410908699, -0.023225756362080574, -0.06385940313339233, 0.05729658529162407, 0.025249553844332695, -0.02464887872338295, 0.028596555814146996, -0.06740552186965942, 0.024936625733971596, 0.03122575767338276, -0.07982966303825378, 0.0037354102823883295, 0.005609311629086733, -0.034162335097789764, -0.013896605931222439, -0.032147787511348724, -0.024746602401137352, -0.007387711200863123, -0.037367984652519226, 0.024107737466692924, -0.03796262666583061, -0.046087123453617096, 0.003399262670427561, 0.04281558468937874, 0.06275226920843124, -0.03383808210492134, -0.035242170095443726, -0.04186079278588295, -0.06799046695232391, 0.029946841299533844, -0.009345749393105507, -0.01298507396131754, -0.039147987961769104, -0.027546972036361694, 0.018608571961522102, 0.04087371751666069, 0.07510561496019363, -0.03178861364722252, -0.04889767989516258, -0.03053378500044346, -0.03342774510383606, -0.05710428208112717, -0.010724518448114395, -0.01311704982072115, -0.03760990500450134, -0.07398280501365662, -0.04935408756136894, 0.05242282152175903, 0.02212020941078663, -0.022127019241452217, 0.039061225950717926, -0.08425512164831161, 0.06614439189434052, 0.0072172414511442184, -0.008632705546915531, -0.01426269393414259, -0.012237774208188057, 0.007002036087214947, -0.028425168246030807, -0.04529177397489548, -0.009480006992816925, -0.040019188076257706, 0.025165371596813202, 0.04161807522177696, 0.06654806435108185, 0.017864998430013657, 0.007024156861007214, -0.07254121452569962, -0.014586622826755047, 0.007693851832300425, 0.05682513117790222, 0.005066328682005405, 0.01234434638172388, -0.03388937562704086, -0.011469933204352856, 0.03653912991285324, -0.04769840091466904, 0.04522046446800232, -0.031926676630973816, -0.021243000403046608, 0.01546543836593628, -0.0430423840880394, 0.022189462557435036, 0.03741743415594101, -0.04320056736469269, 0.022836945950984955, 0.03780675679445267, 0.0398944653570652, 0.011343015357851982, 0.01454916875809431, 0.04243995249271393, -0.021424729377031326, 0.05920635536313057, 0.032849472016096115, 0.01973659358918667, 0.04032176360487938, -0.03546956181526184, 0.006547751370817423, -0.04198263958096504, -0.012850702740252018, -0.0487026646733284, -0.02490374818444252, -0.05520020052790642, 0.10329978168010712, 0.050085581839084625, -0.017330119386315346, -0.008416548371315002, -0.0037164047826081514, 0.007321547716856003, 0.00200578267686069, 0.07620248943567276, 0.018961841240525246, -0.04333091899752617, 0.0016105743125081062, -0.08314331620931625, 0.023969091475009918, -0.09201826900243759, 0.017142483964562416, -0.037758901715278625, 0.031128544360399246, 0.053617220371961594, -0.030413564294576645, -0.03503342717885971, -0.08145133405923843, 0.033935654908418655, -0.027292395010590553, -0.022004546597599983, 0.003550513880327344, -0.03362879902124405, 0.05473708361387253, 0.0362461619079113, 0.02418515644967556, 0.021574940532445908, 0.03453962132334709, -0.04339306056499481, -0.008836133405566216, -0.01984667032957077, -0.021651610732078552, -0.012475582771003246, -0.026855282485485077, -0.031108539551496506, 0.01431191898882389, -0.023588132113218307, 0.022477462887763977, 0.0009484791080467403, 0.007220933213829994, 0.018250197172164917, -0.028627604246139526, 0.011074922047555447, -0.03026973083615303, 0.006446077488362789, 0.03061649017035961, 0.024156449362635612, 0.04638135805726051, 0.01590457558631897, -0.02749142050743103, 0.054279036819934845, 0.04311082884669304, 0.03601248189806938, -0.04117492213845253, 0.03732675313949585, 0.008790859021246433, 0.033638015389442444, 0.016296567395329475, 0.014896408654749393, -0.01446518674492836, 0.010500699281692505, 0.0031407370697706938, 0.031040746718645096, 0.07790633291006088, 0.0019108843989670277, -0.054340045899152756, -0.030514176934957504, 0.007561180274933577, 0.03127063438296318, 0.06287650018930435, 0.025912821292877197, -0.04819924756884575, -0.036436133086681366, 0.005220666527748108, -0.06501606106758118, -0.09491317719221115, 0.0397186242043972, 0.013613412156701088, 0.07795832306146622, 0.02378937415778637, -0.014142348431050777, 0.0008358206832781434, 0.045136164873838425, -0.01033814251422882, 0.01842707395553589, 0.01144682988524437, -0.000549383694306016, -0.016002988442778587, 0.032502807676792145, 0.041725173592567444, 0.04744798690080643, 0.036167874932289124, 0.0063655986450612545, -0.003854612587019801, -0.07621396332979202, 0.021076908335089684, -0.0036268960684537888, 0.014507979154586792, -0.00044352785334922373, 0.0032903500832617283, -0.048548631370067596, -0.0566357783973217, 0.06512977927923203, -0.0027729657012969255, 0.001123510766774416, -0.014117330312728882, -0.06469470262527466, -0.0074383956380188465, 0.007022467441856861, 0.046345047652721405, 0.01674613356590271, 0.050135865807533264, 0.03267527371644974, 0.022964609786868095, -0.011584728956222534, 0.007704759947955608, 0.019403651356697083, -0.024254348129034042, -0.03835520148277283, -0.05735258758068085, -0.07211388647556305, -0.06400476396083832, 0.014250252395868301, 0.01266927644610405, -0.03862449899315834, 0.08936768025159836, -0.014884267933666706, 0.009205025620758533, -0.012466378509998322, 0.031114960089325905, -0.04796982929110527, 0.06309172511100769, 0.016932521015405655, 0.061874400824308395, 0.011589257046580315, -0.021853717043995857, -0.0025185924023389816, -0.036545682698488235, 0.00988649483770132, 0.013574983924627304, -0.020457858219742775, -0.0018065324984490871, -0.018763061612844467, 0.03433094546198845, 0.0384470596909523, -0.06644153594970703, -0.0752168521285057, -0.022339332848787308, 0.06461218744516373, 0.004773617722094059, 0.028749622404575348, -0.028179742395877838, -0.026869388297200203, -0.020971786230802536, 0.020489618182182312, -0.009524633176624775, -0.055448420345783234, -0.020472394302487373, 0.032817497849464417, 0.016578897833824158, -0.00404185289517045, 0.0177631713449955, 0.04538176208734512, -0.006546906661242247, 0.03582306578755379, -0.010330521501600742, 0.056854259222745895, -0.042871516197919846, -0.045794133096933365, -0.01669487915933132, 0.00026666049961932003, -0.08537443727254868, -0.016814589500427246, 0.018879476934671402, -0.023996829986572266, 0.056197360157966614, 0.0007426149677485228, -0.032354164868593216, -0.01928984746336937, 0.0120740020647645, -0.007470728363841772, 0.034695640206336975, 0.005247554741799831, 0.0681808665394783, -0.04308517277240753, 0.009453081525862217, 0.019149426370859146, 0.0035822358913719654, 0.04432829096913338, -0.009745749644935131, 0.045911747962236404, -0.008750836364924908, 0.027693534269928932, 0.006085942033678293, 0.005411449354141951, -0.06137126684188843, -0.05167297273874283, -0.031039157882332802, 0.02825048565864563, -0.02329935133457184, -0.002871505217626691, 0.018017124384641647, 0.004467525519430637, -0.0001093713945010677, 0.03998001292347908, -0.02781451866030693, 0.015324302017688751, 0.05144340544939041, -0.000697145180311054, -0.015162041410803795, -0.02120988629758358, -0.03238267824053764, -0.011156816966831684, -0.03687937185168266, 0.05500862002372742, -0.012890475802123547, 0.0135977016761899, -0.013598906807601452, 0.0044362531043589115, 0.07325636595487595, 0.048648759722709656, 0.07289350777864456, -0.043693285435438156, -0.09792091697454453, 0.0544266402721405, -0.0389733649790287, -0.007743418216705322, -0.02446097321808338, 0.07202787697315216, -0.029636038467288017, 0.02693057991564274, 0.010040177032351494, -0.015481549315154552, -0.02983473800122738, 0.015761643648147583, 0.006046502385288477, 0.03115968406200409, -0.016440974548459053, 0.03170797973871231, 0.1013525202870369, 0.01446503959596157, 0.04526366665959358, -0.050908464938402176, 0.017896877601742744, 0.013794242404401302, -0.014118379913270473, 0.014358912594616413, 0.003848832566291094, -0.012471762485802174, -0.0390348918735981, -0.01647098921239376, -0.027856064960360527, 0.06520193070173264, 0.0014803900849074125, 0.013074209913611412, -0.04347121715545654, 0.056447699666023254, 0.012774054892361164, 0.03404464200139046, -0.022444963455200195, 0.03299824520945549, 0.02220294252038002, -0.02796000987291336, 0.030923020094633102, -0.025322426110506058, 0.04118908569216728, 0.041837457567453384, -0.053789976984262466, -0.037157487124204636, 0.008584151044487953, 0.00392767833545804, -0.05289534851908684, -0.016311444342136383, -0.023243149742484093, 0.019955571740865707, -0.022175049409270287, -0.0020610785577446222, 0.004298003856092691, -0.035918526351451874, 0.02902756817638874, 0.0374261848628521, 0.017469093203544617, -0.03621354326605797, 0.005925310309976339, 0.022166110575199127, 0.025165796279907227, -0.0023592091165483, 0.0323372520506382, -0.04263763502240181, -0.004191109910607338, -0.006592951249331236, -0.04006093367934227, 0.019986828789114952, -0.0016814091941341758, 0.08340200036764145, -0.028908418491482735, 0.0292896069586277, 0.0004360901948530227, -0.0032800359185785055, 0.016811687499284744, 0.0032779627945274115, -0.02713857963681221, -0.06784364581108093, -0.04207359626889229, 0.08895393460988998, -0.019777273759245872, 0.007050130516290665, -0.007576060015708208, 0.008326761424541473, 0.008005271665751934, -0.026088716462254524, 0.04030705243349075, 0.00181076698936522, 0.019564097747206688, -0.015050950460135937, -0.02264735847711563, 0.025828490033745766, 0.032577771693468094, 0.03279908001422882, 0.025578657165169716, 0.021898740902543068, 0.002102492144331336, -0.006403325591236353, -0.043114710599184036, 0.026150420308113098, -0.03387054428458214, 0.034167125821113586, -0.0013642393751069903, -0.035043857991695404, -0.03511673957109451, -0.04615631327033043, -0.042310941964387894, 0.04243357852101326, 0.01719088852405548, -0.020233428105711937, -0.016038598492741585, 0.02796543389558792, 0.006416623946279287, -0.04573534056544304, 0.016611717641353607, -0.017489148303866386, 0.02134585939347744, 0.007991965860128403, -0.03852277249097824, 0.010061189532279968, 0.006211956962943077, 0.022284142673015594, 0.017035318538546562, 0.024362411350011826, 0.010530239902436733, -0.038242124021053314, -0.035914693027734756, 0.026434998959302902, -0.07307737320661545, -0.00015024864114820957, -0.02216353453695774, 0.011783502995967865, 0.0345199853181839, -0.03915497660636902, 0.0026321655604988337, -0.021869130432605743, 0.01767725497484207, 0.007393488194793463, 0.020509909838438034, -0.019303129985928535, -0.015258637256920338, 0.00003992598067270592, 0.01092278491705656, -0.03811420127749443, -0.030011527240276337, 0.019571391865611076, -0.02167063020169735, 0.12082722038030624, 0.039485011249780655, 0.022966355085372925, -0.02635403349995613, 0.05914566293358803, -0.008457404561340809, -0.012609764002263546, 0.013434630818665028, -0.020816754549741745, -0.045107074081897736, -0.05814523994922638, -0.0012085221242159605, -0.05497271195054054, 0.028905514627695084, -0.033864982426166534 ]
<p>Can someone show me, without glossing over anything, why $F = E - TS$ is minimized when $p_i = e^{-U_i/k_bT}/\sum_ie^{-U_i/k_bT}$? I understand it conceptually, but am having difficulty showing it formally.</p>
g1603
[ -0.02424323745071888, 0.06662363559007645, -0.01206230465322733, 0.014433312229812145, 0.03625866770744324, -0.027538510039448738, 0.01970992423593998, 0.07269072532653809, -0.015696892514824867, 0.041132282465696335, -0.07264456897974014, -0.04078679159283638, 0.07397838681936264, 0.045481614768505096, -0.03777549788355827, 0.03535287454724312, -0.02667335793375969, -0.017136508598923683, -0.006638744380325079, 0.015282782725989819, -0.006012736354023218, 0.00583301018923521, 0.028449637815356255, -0.008287318982183933, 0.14208431541919708, 0.023898806422948837, 0.00851432979106903, 0.04738246649503708, -0.07322421669960022, -0.03963297978043556, 0.025442184880375862, 0.03667787089943886, 0.007648361846804619, -0.0022979709319770336, -0.03949422389268875, -0.031208867207169533, 0.0747319906949997, 0.056628093123435974, -0.010462640784680843, -0.008991185575723648, 0.00801447220146656, 0.012215757742524147, 0.0008153183152899146, 0.016719646751880646, -0.0803942084312439, -0.07438570261001587, -0.00005718584725400433, 0.0550520233809948, -0.046332452446222305, -0.02048856019973755, -0.04346373677253723, 0.011283673346042633, 0.022305548191070557, -0.05743527412414551, 0.009079920127987862, -0.0562446154654026, -0.058640256524086, -0.019060606136918068, 0.0007490178104490042, 0.04804059863090515, 0.031079186126589775, -0.03245021402835846, -0.022084178403019905, 0.03961252421140671, 0.02783345617353916, -0.013040019199252129, 0.005080713424831629, 0.028090883046388626, 0.051230840384960175, 0.028709085658192635, -0.056634172797203064, 0.033743735402822495, 0.005080453585833311, -0.029778283089399338, -0.014706330373883247, -0.01767217367887497, -0.00275173201225698, 0.03254938870668411, -0.01729082502424717, -0.00016626701108179986, 0.018956821411848068, -0.00207670615054667, 0.03932400047779083, 0.020859189331531525, -0.03479019179940224, -0.0049931565299630165, 0.03273935243487358, -0.019061800092458725, 0.0056607979349792, -0.010217605158686638, -0.023090414702892303, -0.05926571413874626, 0.03761449083685875, -0.013371129520237446, -0.03684882074594498, -0.010951709002256393, -0.009831500239670277, -0.020411523059010506, 0.019554361701011658, -0.0031758302357047796, 0.027314791455864906, -0.008093301206827164, 0.020871158689260483, 0.004691909998655319, -0.006619455758482218, 0.0425606369972229, 0.0409582294523716, 0.03133394196629524, 0.018436463549733162, -0.004089313559234142, -0.002082876395434141, -0.008959874510765076, -0.06131862848997116, -0.032250456511974335, -0.036135923117399216, 0.018574120476841927, -0.03404388204216957, -0.03487453609704971, -0.050983279943466187, 0.03525850176811218, 0.002059976803138852, -0.03349359706044197, -0.03264767304062843, 0.03410394862294197, -0.030636023730039597, 0.05073261260986328, 0.017467627301812172, -0.023891905322670937, 0.05773394927382469, -0.0022728401236236095, -0.017972523346543312, -0.0038668455090373755, -0.01205079723149538, -0.049727313220500946, 0.049226123839616776, 0.07735241204500198, -0.10034782439470291, 0.022148635238409042, 0.02529281936585903, -0.009173219092190266, -0.10332012921571732, 0.012891828082501888, 0.008351653814315796, -0.06053050979971886, -0.045282766222953796, -0.022228045389056206, 0.02077510952949524, -0.015393316745758057, 0.03374866023659706, 0.006685929838567972, -0.021935144439339638, 0.07773781567811966, -0.003543857019394636, -0.012428686022758484, -0.014342558570206165, -0.012321858666837215, 0.03517739102244377, -0.053675681352615356, -0.02863689884543419, -0.031740717589855194, -0.03269714117050171, 0.03774435818195343, -0.0030442592687904835, -0.004129799548536539, -0.0824710950255394, 0.049929872155189514, -0.050859928131103516, -0.050334639847278595, -0.0233498252928257, -0.02760721556842327, -0.02493046224117279, 0.05330660939216614, 0.06450626254081726, 0.057076647877693176, -0.029924847185611725, 0.040012162178754807, 0.07710175961256027, 0.008547882549464703, 0.011303527280688286, 0.053725454956293106, -0.01899118535220623, -0.014820476993918419, 0.007976186461746693, 0.03600342944264412, 0.004934097174555063, -0.03295809030532837, -0.006586840841919184, 0.02223312482237816, 0.008446143940091133, 0.044196199625730515, 0.01553410291671753, -0.013696255162358284, -0.030235597863793373, 0.013452325016260147, -0.037557706236839294, 0.026968354359269142, -0.048123959451913834, -0.02958453819155693, -0.016375258564949036, 0.015972310677170753, -0.008944899775087833, -0.017144542187452316, 0.03644346818327904, -0.0214058980345726, -0.05328584834933281, -0.021261846646666527, -0.03187805786728859, 0.02295348048210144, 0.03288641199469566, 0.03521620109677315, -0.03930417075753212, -0.06774607300758362, -0.012762438505887985, 0.05615111440420151, 0.02020161971449852, 0.04410794377326965, 0.003961885813623667, 0.013574525713920593, -0.050997503101825714, 0.019232947379350662, -0.037826184183359146, -0.05775946006178856, -0.012786103412508965, 0.07843880355358124, -0.03305908665060997, -0.013613003306090832, 0.015464521013200283, 0.011731643229722977, -0.0478539764881134, 0.008323428221046925, -0.11151419579982758, 0.022235151380300522, -0.016002964228391647, 0.0001222828432219103, -0.01648125797510147, 0.00321570853702724, 0.04467324540019035, 0.00837791245430708, -0.003352360101416707, 0.02068079262971878, 0.010198996402323246, 0.0043840836733579636, -0.006390328519046307, 0.09398582577705383, 0.036796774715185165, 0.019105009734630585, 0.006723075173795223, -0.008367705158889294, -0.05042984336614609, 0.01777615025639534, -0.06975919753313065, 0.04124429076910019, 0.015907393768429756, -0.009151780977845192, 0.0073333727195858955, -0.06203218922019005, 0.014452747069299221, -0.03137533366680145, 0.042188599705696106, 0.07248014956712723, -0.01381591521203518, 0.03737043961882591, 0.018575794994831085, -0.0109458202496171, -0.07197306305170059, 0.03164311498403549, -0.009676753543317318, -0.01689411886036396, 0.03739103674888611, -0.03257886692881584, 0.003891163971275091, 0.08786486089229584, -0.027340887114405632, 0.038738153874874115, -0.029800454154610634, -0.051471881568431854, 0.0003304750134702772, -0.010886231437325478, -0.009469137527048588, 0.03638896718621254, -0.01714731939136982, -0.011008844710886478, -0.0034746851306408644, 0.002941097831353545, 0.004527703858911991, 0.009218680672347546, 0.010680646635591984, 0.05871857702732086, -0.03291410207748413, 0.06460762768983841, -0.029613403603434563, -0.005779951810836792, 0.03372922167181969, -0.025604041293263435, -0.025089995935559273, 0.005588862579315901, 0.0029931040480732918, -0.07195933908224106, -0.05740641802549362, 0.009825154207646847, -0.013481078669428825, 0.03603094816207886, 0.002027075504884124, -0.005722674075514078, -0.0003950500104110688, 0.018098050728440285, 0.02622666023671627, -0.06903722882270813, -0.043868228793144226, 0.022185467183589935, -0.0035003090742975473, 0.04404370114207268, -0.001325258519500494, 0.007477328181266785, -0.03674284368753433, 0.04633946716785431, 0.0072826300747692585, 0.04023166000843048, -0.022100284695625305, -0.04549221321940422, -0.002676872769370675, -0.03468587249517441, 0.015920819714665413, -0.023914523422718048, 0.024360572919249535, 0.03778284415602684, -0.02459442988038063, -0.008207381702959538, 0.00795886293053627, 0.0059622423723340034, 0.019391413778066635, -0.03148579224944115, 0.009178363718092442, -0.011335470713675022, -0.046869490295648575, 0.018672330304980278, 0.014148878864943981, 0.05107986927032471, -0.010655026882886887, 0.0038049756549298763, 0.007956924848258495, -0.009416591376066208, -0.029092000797390938, -0.058588121086359024, -0.0378342904150486, -0.025431454181671143, -0.03648107871413231, 0.015843965113162994, 0.050712767988443375, -0.013106574304401875, 0.020132435485720634, 0.005587163846939802, 0.01641041785478592, 0.0012429391499608755, 0.021185267716646194, 0.04116641730070114, 0.04373323172330856, -0.029372185468673706, 0.01368336658924818, -0.004858202766627073, 0.05009783059358597, -0.03733927011489868, -0.027093365788459778, 0.055872779339551926, -0.02771861106157303, -0.034999821335077286, 0.039996255189180374, 0.05041663348674774, -0.024576647207140923, 0.04004167020320892, -0.017723314464092255, 0.061643753200769424, 0.03234654292464256, 0.033263277262449265, -0.01734950952231884, -0.052219878882169724, -0.017864473164081573, 0.0627722516655922, 0.012027074582874775, -0.0035264177713543177, 0.02722238004207611, -0.010705017484724522, -0.002455492503941059, 0.023633752018213272, 0.060028184205293655, -0.000546569237485528, -0.04812920466065407, 0.008473061956465244, 0.035407353192567825, 0.034533072263002396, -0.0025028246454894543, 0.0062304106540977955, -0.009134456515312195, 0.02686840482056141, 0.01970863901078701, 0.027202140539884567, 0.02097560092806816, 0.012048508040606976, -0.024419570341706276, 0.0591362901031971, 0.06647425889968872, -0.0065763951279222965, 0.017888154834508896, -0.015387600287795067, -0.03362570330500603, -0.018690980970859528, -0.01837313547730446, 0.01785741187632084, 0.029614536091685295, -0.06431737542152405, 0.03955374285578728, 0.0008856999920681119, -0.036607012152671814, 0.00036502076545730233, -0.03027486242353916, -0.000946106156334281, -0.025989126414060593, -0.004678120370954275, 0.09687751531600952, 0.011217056773602962, 0.049540434032678604, -0.0324401818215847, -0.00469735823571682, -0.022549498826265335, -0.020107358694076538, 0.07774407416582108, -0.013661228120326996, 0.01195081602782011, -0.024721642956137657, -0.03257446736097336, -0.07345003634691238, 0.04706398397684097, -0.0202316977083683, 0.020831193774938583, -0.03791822865605354, 0.025804951786994934, -0.014045201241970062, 0.09386057406663895, -0.07923414558172226, 0.007519399747252464, 0.023947017267346382, -0.06226814165711403, -0.03942586109042168, -0.017057856544852257, -0.009225542657077312, -0.03716002032160759, -0.007390120066702366, -0.06575734913349152, 0.006283507216721773, 0.005935720633715391, -0.003015088150277734, 0.01607450842857361, 0.04862341284751892, 0.01452694647014141, -0.03573852777481079, -0.02782360278069973, -0.011272349394857883, 0.025911442935466766, 0.040607694536447525, 0.030333811417222023, -0.012409577146172523, 0.030367624014616013, -0.022747376933693886, 0.01932712271809578, 0.042387042194604874, 0.0015964985359460115, -0.022781120613217354, 0.038827985525131226, -0.006732435896992683, 0.0428890734910965, 0.02666299231350422, 0.03718477487564087, 0.03649617359042168, 0.02968681789934635, 0.04151804745197296, 0.03426657244563103, -0.04147431254386902, 0.03496190905570984, -0.04137268289923668, 0.006005300674587488, 0.007715839892625809, -0.05826243385672569, -0.04195742309093475, 0.0166797898709774, -0.02460399828851223, 0.037501685321331024, 0.00989794172346592, -0.03634940832853317, 0.007439213339239359, 0.00013899689656682312, 0.06012118607759476, 0.05449177697300911, 0.02299617975950241, 0.018950870260596275, -0.028840182349085808, -0.05591283366084099, 0.04009268060326576, 0.02734442986547947, 0.02776969224214554, -0.02008759416639805, -0.06650123745203018, -0.01566138304769993, -0.013362478464841843, 0.01861415058374405, 0.052382491528987885, -0.0009569107205606997, 0.07208723574876785, -0.07150963693857193, 0.00009283190593123436, 0.028045838698744774, 0.009657547809183598, 0.031224051490426064, -0.03624001517891884, -0.032830365002155304, -0.06599953025579453, -0.017586179077625275, -0.03329480066895485, -0.052840717136859894, -0.021915128454566002, -0.019337350502610207, 0.05734144151210785, 0.006901645101606846, -0.02046813629567623, -0.004110322799533606, 0.005620222073048353, -0.02073965035378933, -0.017706619575619698, -0.039769649505615234, -0.010707846842706203, 0.04249613359570503, 0.005342090502381325, 0.035910505801439285, -0.0006522487383335829, 0.0174493957310915, 0.0016739611746743321, 0.028934001922607422, 0.0392446406185627, -0.00008712209819350392, 0.03232815861701965, 0.019214129075407982, 0.0016970338765531778, -0.032057713717222214, -0.04253081604838371, 0.06555461138486862, 0.008970998227596283, -0.040506601333618164, 0.012322306632995605, -0.019846968352794647, 0.03266540542244911, -0.03501145541667938, 0.01021936908364296, 0.056009095162153244, -0.0079078683629632, -0.054602403193712234, 0.020856434479355812, 0.039194799959659576, -0.010295914486050606, 0.01638447865843773, 0.010587967932224274, -0.07231679558753967, 0.012871184386312962, -0.015429295599460602, -0.046510614454746246, 0.012676340527832508, 0.03028682991862297, -0.05530771240592003, 0.05631192773580551, 0.056485895067453384, 0.0178071316331625, 0.05106696859002113, -0.02725101262331009, -0.025968167930841446, 0.047486841678619385, -0.013327899388968945, -0.007018617819994688, 0.002339593367651105, 0.008995487354695797, -0.01542159728705883, -0.007246972993016243, -0.035232167690992355, 0.01290855836123228, 0.02921699546277523, 0.004773947410285473, -0.015670303255319595, 0.03001619316637516, 0.007539040874689817, -0.03510340675711632, -0.04421482980251312, 0.05441432446241379, 0.06097739189863205, -0.047425638884305954, -0.024237636476755142, 0.022124169394373894, 0.052105266600847244, 0.039295222610235214, 0.051221393048763275, 0.006464648060500622, 0.05841101333498955, 0.015051468275487423, -0.0363503098487854, 0.024530047550797462, 0.03840212896466255, 0.03407562896609306, -0.02003081887960434, -0.027720823884010315, 0.10671978443861008, 0.06461145728826523, 0.01215375866740942, -0.039621882140636444, 0.02765721082687378, -0.03150240331888199, 0.03972778469324112, -0.04377935826778412, 0.026970796287059784, -0.041733771562576294, -0.06684607267379761, -0.046441450715065, -0.0031046189833432436, -0.06379950791597366, -0.02996012195944786, 0.050682008266448975, -0.0722341537475586, 0.013895884156227112, -0.014703893102705479, 0.04881487786769867, 0.008537612855434418, 0.0354166217148304, -0.019795533269643784, -0.009855427779257298, -0.06006663292646408, 0.020997563377022743, 0.009151255711913109, -0.04621172323822975, 0.030429081991314888, -0.01026623323559761, 0.0352545790374279, -0.0560525618493557, 0.06471030414104462, -0.06248133257031441, 0.05665028840303421, -0.00656826002523303, 0.0649426132440567, 0.03616955131292343, 0.02743462286889553, -0.07076890766620636, 0.030227089300751686, 0.024063698947429657, -0.020395705476403236, -0.04881582409143448, -0.015627628192305565, 0.05048966780304909, 0.056079864501953125, -0.05435876548290253, -0.017952607944607735, -0.02741018310189247, -0.06710295379161835, -0.008283930830657482, -0.02725839987397194, 0.05430622771382332, 0.0009638922638259828, -0.06413793563842773, 0.01516841072589159, -0.032734889537096024, 0.021829621866345406, 0.07046917080879211, 0.009704978205263615, 0.04389441758394241, -0.0159731637686491, -0.008101599290966988, -0.0911087915301323, -0.019210321828722954, -0.02879784069955349, -0.031708501279354095, 0.015584864653646946, 0.02228117547929287, -0.011739352717995644, 0.01186459418386221, 0.0007436281885020435, -0.048839714378118515, -0.023851865902543068, 0.0032071308232843876, 0.026918580755591393, -0.03458137437701225, -0.06725936383008957, -0.044820498675107956, -0.023513231426477432, 0.017841044813394547, 0.014698616228997707, -0.02614133246243, -0.03453393653035164, 0.004157915245741606, 0.046010881662368774, 0.06184304505586624, 0.0428873635828495, 0.007909324020147324, 0.02516336180269718, -0.03424666076898575, -0.03927268832921982, -0.006983296480029821, 0.02278120443224907, 0.031100021675229073, -0.004106196109205484, 0.014829212799668312, -0.012242387980222702, 0.010104899294674397, 0.0010943962261080742, 0.055355947464704514, -0.022355172783136368, -0.022453857585787773, -0.07117623090744019, -0.03927682712674141, -0.04672233760356903, -0.005962795112282038, -0.004871896468102932, 0.044362589716911316, -0.029634911566972733, -0.06053889915347099, -0.007497010286897421, -0.04911772534251213, -0.017824193462729454, 0.019120603799819946, -0.02501055970788002, 0.023743173107504845, -0.05700831115245819, -0.06432212144136429, -0.02267594076693058, 0.0031838975846767426, -0.019198209047317505, 0.034092191606760025, 0.05725380778312683, -0.025434328243136406, -0.04066535830497742, 0.021684812381863594, -0.003815561765804887, -0.03891816362738609, 0.026060711592435837, 0.0053931428119540215, -0.013089373707771301, -0.017992038279771805, 0.019590798765420914, -0.054238852113485336, -0.05583800747990608, 0.007115903776139021, 0.043589163571596146, -0.020978182554244995, 0.010752432979643345, -0.020529204979538918, -0.05810773745179176, 0.02241045981645584, 0.014003274030983448, -0.019448546692728996, -0.026370182633399963, -0.06384231895208359, 0.06308628618717194, 0.05015653744339943, -0.003507232526317239, 0.059101253747940063, 0.01137411966919899, 0.0021093098912388086, 0.02003607712686062, -0.04672544077038765, -0.012810125946998596, -0.04629253223538399, 0.04434151574969292, 0.008854006417095661, 0.00730070099234581, 0.03912317752838135, -0.026891065761446953 ]
<p>On my textbook is written that gravitational force is the force that attracts bodies with mass. But I've seen on a book that It actually attracts bodies with energy. I'm having a class tomorrow and I would like to know some argumments to use with - against my professor.</p>
g1604
[ 0.02088742144405842, 0.024982059374451637, 0.008428042754530907, 0.01658616214990616, 0.00695765670388937, 0.03286295011639595, -0.05539270490407944, 0.02345195971429348, -0.06464765220880508, -0.009633611887693405, 0.06805150210857391, -0.020733684301376343, 0.028707638382911682, 0.01857205107808113, -0.026550007984042168, 0.010171717032790184, 0.04371252655982971, -0.010608511976897717, -0.017273494973778725, 0.04922238737344742, -0.013023162260651588, 0.02147260122001171, -0.016076132655143738, -0.007806301582604647, -0.06368233263492584, 0.011631449684500694, 0.030149808153510094, -0.020819077268242836, 0.007827207446098328, -0.07515759766101837, 0.01396073680371046, 0.01622876152396202, 0.0872834324836731, -0.09073856472969055, -0.055110860615968704, -0.03462224453687668, 0.01420761737972498, -0.0029077192302793264, -0.024844132363796234, -0.009187513031065464, 0.01270854938775301, -0.04248596727848053, 0.002270343480631709, -0.013050318695604801, 0.03727446123957634, 0.022115113213658333, 0.006239448208361864, -0.010091452859342098, 0.027617037296295166, 0.020123379305005074, -0.0061377426609396935, 0.0328860767185688, 0.015234366059303284, -0.04045899212360382, -0.018003322184085846, 0.009495776146650314, 0.03039855882525444, -0.006259552668780088, 0.023116188123822212, 0.023611806333065033, 0.03460798040032387, 0.05844515562057495, -0.010230639949440956, -0.04004467651247978, 0.03633280098438263, -0.013376948423683643, -0.039445746690034866, -0.005746746901422739, 0.006439258344471455, 0.022735513746738434, 0.011662040837109089, 0.0013631645124405622, 0.02550111524760723, -0.06693820655345917, -0.026779383420944214, 0.00024508050410076976, 0.02102772518992424, -0.012686439789831638, 0.019139140844345093, -0.03758033737540245, 0.018433241173624992, -0.02081095427274704, 0.009984780102968216, -0.021601177752017975, 0.07929220795631409, -0.030944863334298134, -0.04716261476278305, 0.006243042182177305, 0.023366130888462067, 0.006818602327257395, 0.01785735972225666, 0.01945531740784645, 0.08546285331249237, 0.031490303575992584, -0.026300381869077682, -0.006604851223528385, 0.024093303829431534, 0.04648348316550255, -0.02011592872440815, -0.03149557486176491, -0.02635303884744644, 0.011078505776822567, 0.012699357233941555, 0.028120743110775948, 0.029731275513768196, -0.021666135638952255, 0.004988217260688543, -0.012503684498369694, -0.04413140192627907, -0.004125000908970833, -0.0025812210515141487, 0.009472888894379139, -0.006236478220671415, -0.04545560106635094, -0.06803319603204727, -0.02312193252146244, 0.09461002796888351, -0.02103092148900032, 0.0493793785572052, 0.05381933972239494, -0.04561737924814224, 0.03418990224599838, -0.03726431354880333, 0.027523770928382874, -0.08480928838253021, -0.07001416385173798, 0.029825197532773018, -0.006700728554278612, -0.04692269489169121, -0.06074567884206772, 0.07456889003515244, -0.059980958700180054, -0.04251912236213684, -0.0728558674454689, 0.002073732204735279, 0.035761456936597824, -0.01349715981632471, -0.05270543321967125, 0.025428645312786102, 0.0016461452469229698, 0.005521908402442932, 0.021825043484568596, 0.05399724468588829, -0.018981756642460823, -0.025238459929823875, 0.04154869168996811, -0.05645853281021118, 0.04530296474695206, 0.047677818685770035, 0.05804973468184471, -0.006841007154434919, 0.0690983459353447, 0.018438391387462616, -0.09107249230146408, 0.044918619096279144, -0.038634054362773895, 0.0007568707806058228, 0.002511081751435995, -0.012645802460610867, 0.005021154880523682, 0.07892726361751556, -0.02226424589753151, 0.09260988235473633, -0.027733121067285538, 0.020852932706475258, 0.028055576607584953, -0.020184051245450974, -0.04596533998847008, -0.0022708699107170105, 0.04852013662457466, -0.06911951303482056, -0.06194090098142624, 0.024220015853643417, 0.06498847901821136, -0.017238546162843704, -0.002680502599105239, -0.00927191972732544, -0.06042834371328354, 0.018655704334378242, -0.02034139819443226, 0.030444122850894928, -0.042905036360025406, 0.03205692395567894, -0.016553986817598343, -0.012439909391105175, -0.032562002539634705, -0.020162906497716904, 0.055227044969797134, -0.045167047530412674, 0.060871854424476624, -0.05473453924059868, -0.0153600899502635, -0.007310719229280949, 0.04901253804564476, 0.039426594972610474, -0.0003458081337157637, 0.018590737134218216, 0.012524258345365524, -0.05456729605793953, 0.0429757721722126, -0.032850220799446106, 0.016278069466352463, 0.025096800178289413, -0.017696788534522057, 0.028874274343252182, -0.00040557823376730084, 0.006255826912820339, 0.028830159455537796, 0.016932159662246704, -0.008626170456409454, 0.021706929430365562, -0.010010624304413795, 0.051268961280584335, -0.0057885670103132725, -0.041567813605070114, 0.03304635360836983, -0.06327982991933823, 0.04968545585870743, 0.025543270632624626, -0.016013095155358315, -0.041350092738866806, 0.009379420429468155, -0.03786199912428856, 0.00580233009532094, -0.002414640737697482, 0.009306606836616993, -0.03573578596115112, -0.05859723314642906, 0.02745717763900757, -0.04192410036921501, -0.036083344370126724, 0.026095252484083176, 0.037262991070747375, 0.008001154288649559, 0.05902647599577904, 0.025465892627835274, 0.0019070864655077457, 0.015638496726751328, 0.017528561875224113, -0.013051384128630161, -0.013606003485620022, -0.03612852096557617, 0.0161147303879261, -0.06678788363933563, 0.0470537394285202, -0.04837037995457649, 0.0317269004881382, 0.007354425732046366, 0.043000560253858566, 0.02079152688384056, 0.01909058354794979, 0.01830902136862278, -0.05137625336647034, 0.05524435266852379, 0.05139140412211418, 0.012285237200558186, -0.06426490843296051, 0.006386295892298222, -0.08482401818037033, -0.002619461389258504, 0.02249021828174591, -0.06166176125407219, 0.03298526629805565, 0.05115154758095741, -0.05674929916858673, -0.041251834481954575, -0.05356696620583534, -0.03727206960320473, -0.01676923595368862, -0.022397778928279877, -0.026919418945908546, 0.03301176428794861, -0.051623959094285965, 0.021226366981863976, 0.00014758015458937734, -0.017669137567281723, 0.018352285027503967, -0.004430255852639675, 0.011683141812682152, -0.01881987415254116, 0.022057676687836647, 0.0074400706216692924, -0.01563291996717453, -0.0068329996429383755, 0.04244844242930412, -0.033797554671764374, -0.0260974932461977, 0.023635080084204674, 0.005204842425882816, -0.06059480831027031, -0.0020059349481016397, 0.005712628830224276, 0.04089052230119705, 0.011385077610611916, -0.02023867703974247, 0.01031776238232851, 0.023692741990089417, 0.040755100548267365, -0.0037025294732302427, -0.0225268192589283, -0.001141209970228374, 0.005816791206598282, 0.005541836377233267, -0.020945843309164047, -0.04221605509519577, 0.04014817252755165, -0.031022269278764725, -0.05092918500304222, -0.00977390818297863, -0.009436869993805885, -0.02060597762465477, 0.045622218400239944, 0.051836591213941574, 0.012925558723509312, -0.023416021838784218, -0.017728352919220924, -0.0032363974023610353, -0.030522063374519348, -0.05107972025871277, -0.03945360705256462, -0.011147059500217438, -0.037100620567798615, 0.069078728556633, -0.042661432176828384, -0.018079983070492744, 0.05762315168976784, -0.030568121001124382, -0.013619177043437958, -0.012518573552370071, -0.010586383752524853, 0.029179569333791733, -0.04289466515183449, -0.027881596237421036, 0.024621175602078438, -0.05883846804499626, -0.022115880623459816, 0.0067353518679738045, 0.004547535441815853, 0.02405211515724659, 0.06659581512212753, 0.0413597896695137, 0.028878921642899513, -0.016091657802462578, -0.02555193193256855, -0.03046787902712822, 0.04468461126089096, 0.018163930624723434, -0.044245049357414246, 0.051846928894519806, -0.025691106915473938, 0.007602670695632696, 0.006125337444245815, 0.04450574144721031, 0.002194735687226057, 0.014963003806769848, -0.04421158879995346, 0.030079755932092667, 0.017004894092679024, -0.0394737534224987, 0.014711607247591019, -0.02070666290819645, 0.03866341710090637, 0.031299665570259094, 0.0675916075706482, -0.014508687891066074, -0.06186239421367645, -0.02534979023039341, 0.0028767436742782593, -0.028325708582997322, -0.011731118895113468, 0.04258839413523674, -0.0495944507420063, -0.002993438858538866, 0.027515221387147903, 0.046291783452034, -0.0656873881816864, 0.0448649637401104, -0.00007944643584778532, 0.038269225507974625, -0.04075159132480621, 0.023630183190107346, 0.0045589907094836235, -0.013852846808731556, 0.046907730400562286, 0.014152453280985355, 0.005984282586723566, -0.05836080014705658, 0.0246534775942564, 0.10620498657226562, -0.03145156800746918, -0.029422543942928314, -0.05975118279457092, -0.04341183230280876, -0.012200279161334038, -0.012950358912348747, -0.0484069287776947, 0.06528054177761078, -0.004538433160632849, 0.06761352717876434, 0.019518619403243065, -0.004392870236188173, 0.06348638236522675, 0.00816313922405243, -0.00021980587916914374, 0.002990452107042074, 0.06225157529115677, 0.026657219976186752, -0.017956441268324852, -0.0145305460318923, -0.028394795954227448, 0.033404864370822906, -0.03217989578843117, 0.007158484775573015, -0.06586140394210815, -0.035981208086013794, 0.008091025054454803, -0.06814968585968018, 0.017930960282683372, 0.0288388691842556, 0.025419220328330994, -0.0004070843569934368, 0.03883065655827522, -0.019862981513142586, -0.014866510406136513, -0.04458063840866089, 0.06760958582162857, 0.08022548258304596, 0.009412478655576706, -0.016852356493473053, 0.05086759105324745, -0.015598630532622337, -0.013315500691533089, 0.00781698152422905, 0.05873763933777809, -0.027308151125907898, 0.05006036162376404, 0.011480896733701229, 0.036310672760009766, 0.045544639229774475, -0.027219338342547417, 0.05862867459654808, 0.08173691481351852, -0.00034926808439195156, 0.0001838016469264403, -0.012437229044735432, 0.03476526588201523, -0.021950319409370422, -0.013769029639661312, -0.06024709716439247, -0.014032970182597637, -0.01979135535657406, -0.04922827333211899, -0.0033874339424073696, 0.024964772164821625, -0.01223727222532034, 0.023475980386137962, -0.03362315148115158, 0.04916638880968094, 0.0015791429905220866, 0.0040928213857114315, 0.024958118796348572, -0.04041435569524765, 0.09471015632152557, 0.03331869840621948, 0.02013147436082363, -0.01825409010052681, -0.010864277370274067, -0.013543665409088135, 0.009273668751120567, -0.03781920671463013, -0.022750960662961006, 0.06907904893159866, 0.030317863449454308, 0.022371843457221985, 0.032377690076828, 0.018570683896541595, 0.02660905010998249, -0.04642387479543686, 0.046900682151317596, -0.0015535138081759214, -0.023012062534689903, 0.033569201827049255, -0.008566397242248058, 0.011885415762662888, -0.030241144821047783, -0.030608369037508965, 0.008492140099406242, 0.05678176507353783, 0.021440371870994568, -0.036113642156124115, -0.003539555473253131, 0.0321723110973835, -0.01481154840439558, -0.03712699934840202, -0.02549106813967228, 0.03441808000206947, -0.01743488945066929, -0.006774572189897299, 0.03763013705611229, 0.07535051554441452, 0.0034741791896522045, 0.006614081561565399, -0.007743122987449169, 0.019518494606018066, 0.028617925941944122, 0.04637720808386803, 0.03630921244621277, 0.008563429117202759, -0.045432962477207184, 0.055225033313035965, -0.044322554022073746, 0.04886641725897789, 0.015957357361912727, 0.02395639196038246, -0.03751138225197792, 0.013383196666836739, 0.022783268243074417, 0.040848247706890106, 0.02841622196137905, 0.07486915588378906, 0.0666092112660408, -0.05322958528995514, 0.031047621741890907, 0.003102522809058428, 0.00795338861644268, 0.0011456701904535294, -0.028676116839051247, 0.02031134068965912, 0.008633682504296303, 0.045097485184669495, 0.014263320714235306, 0.005704864393919706, 0.020953968167304993, 0.019985811784863472, -0.03824926167726517, -0.026244664564728737, 0.0489596426486969, 0.005923246964812279, 0.046969883143901825, 0.02284289337694645, -0.012415200471878052, -0.01750689186155796, 0.018063100054860115, -0.014135140925645828, 0.01790417544543743, -0.009203141555190086, -0.01307839434593916, -0.004551521968096495, 0.02238876186311245, -0.018777916207909584, -0.0624820701777935, 0.019182957708835602, -0.021483350545167923, -0.03610783442854881, 0.002143674995750189, 0.017139339819550514, -0.009719524532556534, -0.05949137359857559, -0.03596175089478493, 0.0005169087089598179, -0.01762440986931324, -0.013631687499582767, 0.019102847203612328, -0.021383728832006454, 0.014639558270573616, -0.05344650521874428, 0.002654292853549123, -0.08140863478183746, 0.0532887801527977, -0.05073601007461548, 0.01889083907008171, 0.05272642523050308, 0.010681990534067154, -0.06822075694799423, 0.03058427758514881, -0.02794337272644043, 0.0151992691680789, -0.05305149033665657, -0.05714940279722214, 0.004382208455353975, 0.05756736174225807, -0.015716128051280975, 0.029241513460874557, -0.06536397337913513, -0.0213445033878088, 0.0211359653621912, -0.05197790637612343, 0.013306986540555954, 0.010198837146162987, -0.054553091526031494, -0.0059183519333601, -0.03929971903562546, -0.015471791848540306, -0.028587600216269493, -0.05124615505337715, -0.02706742286682129, -0.008689391426742077, 0.03679722920060158, -0.02866349369287491, 0.03023013286292553, -0.01033878419548273, 0.01659250631928444, 0.009675941430032253, -0.015694361180067062, 0.05024394765496254, -0.035277482122182846, -0.03728076443076134, -0.0021924967877566814, 0.01182977668941021, -0.022486597299575806, -0.05456744506955147, 0.0034602985251694918, 0.009547255001962185, 0.0005585986655205488, -0.007436495274305344, -0.06208959221839905, -0.03521498292684555, 0.04915376007556915, -0.012018573470413685, -0.049006421118974686, 0.01841539517045021, -0.029905520379543304, 0.06636495888233185, -0.03989565744996071, 0.07789478451013565, 0.04445461556315422, -0.07560139149427414, 0.06088661402463913, 0.05569371581077576, -0.027584578841924667, -0.046592023223638535, -0.017154322937130928, 0.011142578907310963, 0.027563706040382385, 0.04082738235592842, 0.06793559342622757, -0.021728137508034706, -0.000763299991376698, 0.05461767688393593, 0.015084058977663517, -0.016757240518927574, 0.016492167487740517, -0.016900015994906425, -0.03222207725048065, -0.06421446800231934, 0.017486337572336197, -0.016073884442448616, 0.033280257135629654, -0.00796380266547203, -0.046336181461811066, -0.014621571637690067, -0.07039501518011093, 0.0037434790283441544, 0.02924364246428013, -0.11871398240327835, 0.08159340918064117, -0.02467612363398075, -0.04278719052672386, 0.054919298738241196, -0.04960549622774124, -0.022841641679406166, -0.01286910567432642, 0.003590682055801153, 0.028922270983457565, -0.04339789226651192, 0.06347273290157318, -0.00466562295332551, -0.004573649261146784, -0.02939317189157009, 0.06284172087907791, -0.0014454721240326762, -0.006973878480494022, -0.014663556590676308, -0.02452843263745308, -0.051110826432704926, -0.02730892226099968, -0.03804909437894821, -0.026649238541722298, 0.07281085103750229, -0.013334723189473152, -0.05138201639056206, 0.06634148210287094, -0.0017432011663913727, 0.0466466024518013, -0.06692491471767426, 0.04252970591187477, -0.008227994665503502, -0.0014644887996837497, -0.00700971856713295, 0.034772563725709915, -0.012314030900597572, 0.0018858594121411443, -0.03516711667180061, -0.014106693677604198, -0.04705820977687836, -0.08342021703720093, -0.0037765756715089083, 0.03156770393252373, 0.007142066024243832, -0.005151504650712013, -0.019389716908335686, -0.019472995772957802, -0.020988941192626953, -0.008566068485379219, 0.04310368373990059, 0.03567831218242645, -0.023623183369636536, -0.021837575361132622, -0.023400701582431793, 0.020606402307748795, 0.05602732300758362, 0.018830420449376106, 0.03821193054318428, 0.02293619140982628, -0.006915861740708351, 0.047611091285943985, -0.0480438694357872, 0.046583324670791626, -0.005393107421696186, -0.04166518524289131, 0.013088292442262173, 0.0029346139635890722, -0.017977429553866386, -0.04285329952836037, -0.047825396060943604, -0.023453259840607643, 0.03466953709721565, 0.020718472078442574, -0.024430789053440094, -0.01919626072049141, -0.006849120371043682, -0.029422491788864136, 0.038533248007297516, -0.02131577953696251, -0.04948423057794571, 0.022073784843087196, 0.013766618445515633, -0.07311740517616272, -0.022691277787089348, 0.014441153965890408, 0.002790330443531275, -0.031798236072063446, -0.03753717988729477, 0.022552501410245895, 0.029927993193268776, -0.02554338611662388, -0.052926499396562576, 0.055409885942935944, 0.06253433972597122, 0.04126930236816406, -0.020257839933037758, 0.04038207605481148, -0.020811384543776512, 0.021750885993242264, -0.052685271948575974, -0.07384097576141357, 0.012343295849859715, 0.015686724334955215, 0.01808183267712593, -0.020061815157532692, -0.007679443806409836, 0.02264750748872757, 0.00272097485139966, -0.027646545320749283, -0.006893188692629337, -0.02088910900056362, 0.03720846399664879, -0.027848301455378532 ]
<p><a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/8626/if-all-conserved-quantities-of-a-system-are-known-can-they-be-explained-by-symme">This question</a> resulted, rather as by-product, the discussion on how to count degrees of freedom (DOF). I extend that question here:</p> <ul> <li>Are necessary<sup>1</sup> derivatives such as velocities counted as individual DOFs or together with the respective coordinate<sup>2</sup>?</li> <li>Should complex valued DOFs be counted twice as in "two real-valued DOFs" or once as in "one complex-valued DOF"? (I mean, when one does not want to specify this explicitly)</li> </ul> <p>Please answer with some reference, unless it turns out this is actually a matter of taste rather than a strictly defined thing.</p> <hr> <p><sup>1)</sup> I mean those a value of which is <em>required</em> as an initial condition<br> <sup>2)</sup> I count fields in QFT as coordinates as well, while space-time-coordinates are parameters to me, if that matters. I know a field actually has $\infty$ (or rather, $2^\aleph$) DOFs itself, but let's say e.g. "one $\mathbb R^3$ continous DOF" in that case</p>
g1605
[ 0.05347141996026039, 0.0516568198800087, 0.0015439895214512944, 0.008207099512219429, 0.09117191284894943, -0.018001634627580643, 0.04695091396570206, 0.040442317724227905, -0.0067602465860545635, -0.008084576576948166, -0.0624866858124733, -0.009978977032005787, 0.02102603204548359, -0.0031744171865284443, -0.028665900230407715, -0.04583330452442169, 0.04599355533719063, 0.0372762456536293, 0.0009437674889340997, 0.0030442478600889444, -0.019100051373243332, 0.007959640584886074, 0.03319114074110985, -0.01735122688114643, 0.0328621082007885, 0.031117722392082214, 0.03990429639816284, -0.014805972576141357, -0.03048359975218773, -0.0120775755494833, 0.036915894597768784, 0.02932571806013584, 0.0025192322209477425, -0.024925168603658676, 0.02304907701909542, -0.029063057154417038, 0.0004283746820874512, 0.050583887845277786, 0.041489116847515106, 0.002005841350182891, -0.008793490938842297, 0.00182211899664253, 0.01920895278453827, -0.004036604426801205, 0.013246186077594757, 0.04752006754279137, -0.02813243679702282, -0.010564330033957958, 0.06650739908218384, -0.009361916221678257, 0.02161131054162979, 0.017102980986237526, 0.02610175870358944, 0.06034556403756142, -0.026892129331827164, 0.039759766310453415, -0.023553520441055298, -0.0043825325556099415, -0.006086667999625206, 0.05610364302992821, 0.038773201406002045, -0.034741826355457306, -0.0189877450466156, 0.006434316746890545, 0.03874259069561958, 0.037653110921382904, -0.03851151093840599, 0.0009404374868609011, -0.03166680783033371, 0.002844220958650112, -0.04420023784041405, -0.04266677051782608, 0.02750980295240879, 0.022407708689570427, -0.033280156552791595, 0.06512324512004852, -0.015690471976995468, -0.04309731349349022, 0.058589354157447815, -0.0028233055491000414, -0.07153592258691788, -0.016259942203760147, 0.03645960986614227, 0.048479076474905014, 0.053306758403778076, -0.026296231895685196, -0.019199160858988762, 0.00020772409334313124, 0.003483136650174856, 0.0695393979549408, 0.059086911380290985, -0.02598700486123562, 0.04820742458105087, 0.012238197959959507, 0.01652960665524006, 0.002833056030794978, 0.008885160088539124, 0.04835410788655281, 0.026619290933012962, 0.016380680724978447, 0.01954830065369606, 0.031772930175065994, -0.007533215451985598, -0.04796387627720833, 0.019041627645492554, -0.04972447454929352, 0.07287057489156723, -0.0148914884775877, -0.010477895848453045, -0.02914733812212944, -0.020264266058802605, 0.03779105097055435, -0.04578080028295517, 0.02934349700808525, -0.048389725387096405, 0.009961769916117191, 0.034465596079826355, -0.007853135466575623, 0.020824583247303963, 0.006270411890000105, -0.05682048946619034, -0.032427504658699036, 0.08917119354009628, 0.045381590723991394, 0.000889425806235522, 0.0007402109331451356, 0.024054644629359245, 0.03704662621021271, 0.011262091808021069, 0.0037981972564011812, 0.01033957302570343, 0.009089071303606033, -0.007421441841870546, 0.003160974243655801, -0.06839533150196075, 0.03290046006441116, 0.000024613224013592117, 0.04980028420686722, -0.07273681461811066, -0.04318614676594734, 0.014296034350991249, -0.05809827521443367, 0.005751033313572407, -0.08176107704639435, 0.03649551793932915, -0.032117534428834915, -0.021014584228396416, -0.029976269230246544, 0.09372859448194504, -0.004652985371649265, -0.012779299169778824, 0.0249165091663599, -0.023517120629549026, 0.00872859638184309, 0.02881670743227005, -0.011146009899675846, -0.01686493679881096, -0.04602435603737831, -0.051108863204717636, 0.010312371887266636, 0.017577607184648514, -0.010220511816442013, 0.00978564191609621, -0.04452378675341606, 0.018607614561915398, 0.006358228158205748, -0.001991267316043377, -0.05718144401907921, -0.004123767372220755, -0.07532579451799393, -0.05995135009288788, -0.00848622526973486, 0.0177445150911808, 0.016654357314109802, 0.014641243033111095, -0.005666963756084442, 0.016759341582655907, 0.0011131331557407975, -0.042856842279434204, -0.0010964139364659786, -0.0426461286842823, -0.07765985280275345, 0.00932029914110899, -0.008056478574872017, -0.02556224726140499, -0.012088716961443424, 0.020694423466920853, 0.020660191774368286, -0.08506585657596588, 0.06616956740617752, 0.016637884080410004, 0.024206049740314484, 0.01298072375357151, 0.020550262182950974, -0.01909976825118065, 0.05333687737584114, -0.004187496844679117, 0.022475171834230423, -0.02541082166135311, 0.03165435045957565, -0.02668837271630764, -0.008156152442097664, -0.003655205247923732, -0.01805775798857212, 0.004468161147087812, 0.03342876583337784, -0.08136101812124252, 0.03828785941004753, 0.012273864820599556, -0.018994875252246857, 0.09625343978404999, -0.03660060837864876, -0.05047568306326866, 0.017715444788336754, -0.0303936917334795, -0.01826288364827633, -0.02442800998687744, -0.04773537069559097, -0.020733285695314407, 0.005561102647334337, 0.01040067058056593, 0.009072447195649147, 0.06976690888404846, 0.05427347496151924, 0.019324610009789467, 0.028422843664884567, -0.06090174615383148, -0.02921861596405506, 0.007982700131833553, -0.0023006603587418795, -0.04502634331583977, 0.023198271170258522, 0.002686134073883295, -0.06375007331371307, -0.022965772077441216, 0.038068342953920364, -0.04300622642040253, 0.00810618232935667, 0.05799264460802078, 0.06411092728376389, 0.05951647460460663, -0.0028741590213030577, 0.029849478974938393, 0.03245436027646065, 0.04965605586767197, -0.01954030804336071, -0.01741037890315056, 0.02099015936255455, -0.025721924379467964, 0.009074628353118896, -0.0359671525657177, -0.06908076256513596, -0.02774023823440075, -0.0135697852820158, -0.02174256183207035, 0.04923974722623825, 0.023764055222272873, 0.021101009100675583, -0.013610819354653358, 0.01566236838698387, 0.032034795731306076, -0.04579595476388931, 0.0062800208106637, 0.03361772745847702, -0.024673832580447197, -0.022537346929311752, 0.009779526852071285, 0.012642310932278633, 0.05107216164469719, -0.020282387733459473, 0.0014796253526583314, 0.044836390763521194, -0.029874106869101524, 0.02199750393629074, -0.011852678842842579, 0.012539130635559559, 0.008893562480807304, -0.0058855474926531315, -0.01986263133585453, 0.030149009078741074, -0.01631902903318405, -0.0485248938202858, -0.005858574062585831, 0.05538207292556763, 0.029610324651002884, -0.04647216573357582, -0.01457833219319582, 0.020306210964918137, 0.028080636635422707, 0.02104608528316021, -0.010740384459495544, 0.07351658493280411, 0.012126456014811993, -0.056061454117298126, -0.03428497165441513, 0.05707206949591637, 0.003219239180907607, -0.0844636857509613, -0.007481842767447233, 0.016690079122781754, 0.06793484091758728, 0.0015883785672485828, 0.059969231486320496, 0.04223533347249031, 0.001983393682166934, 0.007957698777318, -0.09259461611509323, -0.033412158489227295, 0.03544127941131592, -0.014412407763302326, 0.02030133083462715, 0.0019861520268023014, -0.05252319201827049, -0.048175182193517685, -0.06147221848368645, -0.023199716582894325, 0.020060643553733826, -0.012098871171474457, -0.018543418496847153, -0.040120575577020645, -0.012368160299956799, -0.03889917582273483, 0.004888070747256279, -0.030129484832286835, 0.06507186591625214, 0.07980212569236755, -0.0482439287006855, 0.027956509962677956, -0.03422466292977333, -0.07644543796777725, 0.01837998814880848, 0.013899949379265308, 0.007172353100031614, -0.019064947962760925, -0.04168962687253952, -0.01707286946475506, -0.08287166804075241, -0.005794443655759096, 0.047698237001895905, -0.007242387160658836, -0.07356720417737961, 0.03228195384144783, -0.03769975155591965, -0.03252808749675751, 0.005772565025836229, 0.02344353124499321, -0.026327496394515038, 0.0036769912112504244, 0.003629226703196764, 0.00944514013826847, 0.005319563671946526, -0.07114876806735992, -0.023680204525589943, 0.012886907905340195, 0.03290063887834549, 0.04195414483547211, 0.04060327634215355, 0.056857265532016754, 0.007515628356486559, -0.006547861732542515, -0.022230176255106926, -0.02497437596321106, -0.012232234701514244, -0.011584626510739326, 0.05306612327694893, -0.036158978939056396, 0.025435684248805046, 0.020174795761704445, -0.017988650128245354, -0.02564907819032669, -0.0032210845965892076, -0.003947657532989979, 0.01550778467208147, -0.0253165103495121, 0.038093581795692444, -0.02686935104429722, 0.04859835281968117, -0.02545940689742565, -0.01367803756147623, 0.03626347705721855, 0.007761131040751934, 0.018439309671521187, 0.02605910412967205, -0.0036991769447922707, -0.029701588675379753, -0.02237655222415924, -0.00892183743417263, 0.032929595559835434, 0.016660386696457863, 0.01109380554407835, 0.013895888812839985, -0.007127442397177219, -0.03205762803554535, -0.05530113726854324, 0.07036637514829636, -0.038930315524339676, 0.03373214602470398, -0.03517105430364609, 0.012612228281795979, 0.05649542436003685, 0.0490431934595108, -0.002845524810254574, 0.012891261838376522, -0.0048331911675632, -0.04316997900605202, -0.010749762877821922, 0.0061497860588133335, -0.03974624350667, 0.06745653599500656, -0.030036693438887596, -0.03695385903120041, -0.003679963294416666, 0.03870372101664543, -0.03886773809790611, -0.0035017291083931923, 0.02400922402739525, -0.05627968907356262, -0.07450474798679352, 0.0076997969299554825, -0.01417984627187252, 0.04594718664884567, 0.023942308500409126, 0.01325394120067358, -0.04743438959121704, 0.004460603930056095, 0.020158015191555023, 0.058176252990961075, -0.018476229161024094, -0.03860398009419441, -0.0462464839220047, 0.04852387309074402, 0.009803124703466892, 0.021349776536226273, 0.02158939838409424, -0.06126291677355766, -0.03886706754565239, -0.03943859785795212, 0.07240811735391617, -0.027192790061235428, 0.049930963665246964, -0.009505792520940304, -0.010460657067596912, 0.022997602820396423, -0.022747788578271866, -0.030073102563619614, -0.0396561436355114, -0.016881510615348816, -0.028264405205845833, -0.017415020614862442, -0.019486060366034508, 0.022136544808745384, 0.05474546551704407, -0.03298734128475189, -0.01728631742298603, -0.04476715624332428, -0.0031130288261920214, -0.01714250259101391, -0.010596790350973606, -0.04554310068488121, 0.007272721268236637, -0.027528885751962662, -0.02560981549322605, 0.027484485879540443, -0.0006124157807789743, -0.002111330395564437, 0.004061234649270773, -0.04755140468478203, -0.05960593745112419, -0.08700049668550491, -0.037002772092819214, 0.07120683789253235, -0.0431341826915741, 0.024656835943460464, -0.002731048734858632, 0.013591750524938107, -0.005008144304156303, -0.001393584068864584, 0.017084673047065735, -0.04743450507521629, -0.05418584868311882, -0.02947109192609787, 0.03791947662830353, 0.04403167963027954, 0.04454032704234123, 0.013649886474013329, -0.036743100732564926, 0.019822966307401657, -0.09022358804941177, 0.015741951763629913, 0.006805186625570059, 0.03453516960144043, 0.019928358495235443, 0.01447985414415598, 0.05798904225230217, -0.05246065929532051, 0.02534341998398304, -0.03426191955804825, -0.03390811011195183, -0.004137651529163122, -0.015441187657415867, -0.07321243733167648, 0.10356627404689789, -0.008865180425345898, -0.010611210949718952, -0.011095765978097916, 0.002012475160881877, 0.02032243087887764, -0.039423588663339615, -0.019390413537621498, -0.01802685111761093, 0.05362551659345627, 0.02529524639248848, -0.019657250493764877, -0.02476212941110134, 0.04330095648765564, 0.008773686364293098, -0.006219093222171068, -0.040627025067806244, -0.023249072954058647, -0.03487033769488335, 0.08642929792404175, 0.012722617015242577, 0.028944212943315506, -0.07017004489898682, 0.01266363076865673, -0.005757461301982403, -0.0768849104642868, -0.06122449412941933, 0.03395681083202362, 0.07891154289245605, 0.06587418168783188, -0.04483520984649658, -0.058984894305467606, -0.020029950886964798, -0.029250703752040863, 0.042053062468767166, -0.031915031373500824, -0.03487022593617439, 0.03649810329079628, 0.05734818056225777, -0.05633718520402908, 0.027784233912825584, -0.010683104395866394, 0.03915748745203018, 0.008709306828677654, -0.06358272582292557, 0.04811452701687813, -0.040123578161001205, 0.06941148638725281, -0.003182203508913517, -0.0648379996418953, -0.03484805300831795, 0.014630815014243126, -0.04017247259616852, -0.001514039235189557, 0.009929964318871498, -0.010244602337479591, -0.02142985910177231, -0.004044809844344854, 0.016648320481181145, -0.03210235759615898, 0.009088179096579552, 0.06152326613664627, 0.004716984461992979, -0.04083075374364853, -0.04849511757493019, 0.047083061188459396, -0.02865079790353775, 0.043243277817964554, 0.08372051268815994, -0.043756645172834396, -0.021500099450349808, -0.030448460951447487, -0.005549113731831312, 0.050755150616168976, 0.05299721285700798, -0.030574027448892593, -0.0032019682694226503, -0.013317780569195747, -0.01712578907608986, -0.047745704650878906, 0.023686237633228302, 0.006373326759785414, -0.09468916803598404, -0.03817484527826309, 0.0134191969409585, -0.010061081498861313, -0.004537723958492279, 0.027170255780220032, -0.0044986410066485405, 0.021176213398575783, 0.0025277899112552404, -0.028157463297247887, 0.03956131637096405, -0.022101039066910744, 0.0010317418491467834, 0.05350974574685097, 0.039077870547771454, -0.029537515714764595, 0.013250751420855522, 0.0372728556394577, -0.02038651704788208, 0.05927580967545509, -0.08484681695699692, -0.00884144939482212, 0.055337093770504, -0.043134767562150955, -0.03552253916859627, 0.029006794095039368, 0.0017074443167075515, -0.014317302964627743, 0.00245027057826519, 0.015094595961272717, 0.025536460801959038, -0.015649467706680298, -0.003884900826960802, -0.005327978171408176, 0.03929319232702255, -0.0035948287695646286, 0.04660659655928612, 0.04093702509999275, -0.03839747607707977, -0.009088239632546902, 0.018721289932727814, -0.019745908677577972, 0.013296650722622871, 0.0193037036806345, 0.026772180572152138, 0.033641062676906586, -0.01710810512304306, -0.028080370277166367, 0.042138706892728806, -0.004589867778122425, -0.004957286175340414, 0.055099308490753174, 0.014297342859208584, -0.062127888202667236, -0.000005934968612564262, 0.03998418524861336, -0.00534444535151124, 0.0033128608483821154, 0.030275879427790642, -0.004669832065701485, 0.07063531130552292, -0.03386607766151428, -0.024752655997872353, 0.06409391015768051, -0.010707389563322067, -0.04257708042860031, -0.017317166551947594, 0.05640602856874466, 0.01373741403222084, -0.05010730028152466, 0.03020009584724903, -0.030757779255509377, 0.010276593267917633, 0.044749461114406586, 0.0010531500447541475, -0.07271983474493027, -0.01250422652810812, -0.05840732157230377, -0.02151336334645748, -0.019299982115626335, -0.006174203474074602, -0.054269399493932724, 0.02543613128364086, 0.006110450252890587, 0.014519523829221725, 0.05331241711974144, -0.03198283538222313, -0.01591491512954235, -0.004222608171403408, -0.020148007199168205, 0.029518265277147293, -0.01002980675548315, -0.011801122687757015, -0.0014388052513822913, -0.01851983554661274, 0.017478596419095993, 0.07024986296892166, -0.03455033525824547, 0.03943008929491043, -0.01969330757856369, -0.07562229037284851, -0.046521659940481186, 0.054839298129081726, 0.006464066449552774, -0.01574392057955265, 0.03546932712197304, -0.03236289322376251, -0.0340234711766243, 0.0425969623029232, 0.012257170863449574, -0.015065646730363369, -0.07274734973907471, 0.027017813175916672, 0.09154246747493744, 0.00687659764662385, 0.010206074453890324, 0.04070116579532623, 0.026931969448924065, -0.044852178543806076, 0.03698927164077759, 0.034426141530275345, 0.0957678034901619, 0.058255817741155624, 0.039710063487291336, -0.018508443608880043, -0.03451703116297722, 0.03013678267598152, 0.017425216734409332, -0.006909823976457119, -0.01370283868163824, -0.026471398770809174, 0.020136358216404915, -0.0006699779769405723, -0.004023324232548475, 0.01380318496376276, -0.007690358906984329, -0.05441083759069443, 0.006336675025522709, 0.02675510384142399, 0.0051857237704098225, -0.0414770282804966, -0.00009650876745581627, -0.009129583835601807, -0.011345203034579754, -0.04757276922464371, -0.01014100294560194, -0.011046900413930416, -0.0026016980409622192, -0.025320934131741524, -0.029595712199807167, 0.06714879721403122, -0.022286493331193924, -0.007140761241316795, -0.0163801908493042, -0.011560562066733837, -0.06573227792978287, 0.009958062320947647, 0.0035300778690725565, 0.008507263846695423, 0.010005822405219078, 0.007984609343111515, -0.04860156029462814, -0.01045074313879013, 0.005538133904337883, 0.039472952485084534, 0.07980984449386597, 0.013021389953792095, -0.03038645349442959, 0.018307244405150414, -0.021030060946941376, 0.024601947516202927, 0.0580524317920208, -0.02246454358100891, -0.018321411684155464, -0.009341279044747353, 0.051762655377388, 0.013861915096640587, -0.016809934750199318, 0.055491480976343155, -0.0009426279575563967, 0.022754652425646782, -0.04408452287316322, -0.08592669665813446, -0.018316226080060005, 0.04451543837785721 ]
<p>Is there a formal definition of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_%28physics%29" rel="nofollow">drag</a>, say, as some surface integral of normal and shear forces? There seem to be a lot of formulas for specific cases, but is there a general one?</p> <p>I need to accurately calculate the drag of three cylinders placed between two plates. </p>
g1606
[ 0.08973131328821182, 0.03209942951798439, -0.045685525983572006, -0.04367305338382721, 0.027725109830498695, 0.022363072261214256, 0.04308563098311424, -0.00886676274240017, -0.12812089920043945, 0.018845461308956146, -0.004461281932890415, -0.012472555041313171, 0.013657166622579098, -0.048765748739242554, 0.0007237803656607866, 0.027124369516968727, 0.03443635255098343, 0.013459611684083939, 0.039963603019714355, 0.01968952640891075, -0.0008755108574405313, 0.07682526111602783, -0.03745981678366661, -0.047406572848558426, 0.10007620602846146, -0.016788382083177567, -0.029120851308107376, -0.01281864382326603, -0.08467061072587967, 0.004414990544319153, -0.009299969300627708, 0.018850252032279968, 0.05285527557134628, 0.006758472416549921, -0.006257729139178991, -0.02303207851946354, 0.02127818949520588, 0.024173099547624588, 0.03372913971543312, -0.027978982776403427, -0.0006971695693209767, 0.011934148147702217, 0.014589237049221992, 0.003878324758261442, -0.00862614344805479, -0.05088476464152336, -0.03433053568005562, -0.06642571836709976, 0.004183721728622913, -0.015692412853240967, 0.0411360040307045, 0.024389469996094704, -0.034805454313755035, -0.038697611540555954, -0.06502315402030945, 0.012205494567751884, 0.05096793919801712, -0.05222173407673836, -0.012562179006636143, 0.02812885493040085, -0.018841074779629707, -0.02996375411748886, -0.004586514085531235, -0.0064126658253371716, 0.016015570610761642, -0.009368253871798515, -0.013018704950809479, -0.023047758266329765, -0.01040151622146368, -0.01803622394800186, 0.027996910735964775, 0.013815509155392647, 0.07743407785892487, -0.058632154017686844, -0.09496330469846725, 0.03193884715437889, 0.029333015903830528, 0.004919585771858692, 0.011236671358346939, -0.026375990360975266, -0.01666927896440029, 0.015084209851920605, 0.009982886724174023, 0.04458201304078102, 0.03690965473651886, 0.03485577926039696, 0.011119154281914234, 0.01089010015130043, 0.02720814384520054, -0.018070699647068977, -0.001491260714828968, 0.03214810788631439, 0.042861152440309525, 0.022678526118397713, -0.0194682776927948, -0.054889749735593796, -0.023349475115537643, 0.05711686611175537, -0.05812128633260727, 0.016396626830101013, -0.030992161482572556, 0.017207879573106766, -0.03332964703440666, 0.04117562621831894, 0.005432478152215481, -0.03825395181775093, 0.024383343756198883, 0.057024285197257996, 0.04286794736981392, -0.0666050910949707, -0.026166431605815887, -0.003503965213894844, -0.024267470464110374, -0.0031166288536041975, 0.052564870566129684, -0.05773079767823219, -0.020573897287249565, -0.031588856130838394, 0.020254379138350487, 0.023097623139619827, 0.0423896424472332, 0.03313680738210678, 0.06023235619068146, 0.06247592344880104, 0.012040635570883751, -0.02608233317732811, -0.01666746661067009, 0.00844365730881691, 0.014362766407430172, -0.002821149304509163, 0.04724261909723282, -0.007809221278876066, 0.030188145115971565, -0.02254844456911087, -0.019037453457713127, 0.03693694248795509, -0.05713552236557007, 0.01265920139849186, 0.012593782506883144, 0.046824272722005844, 0.03377768397331238, -0.06500214338302612, -0.04089776799082756, -0.055957674980163574, 0.002087737200781703, 0.0016461301129311323, -0.06359652429819107, -0.005097886547446251, 0.003592593362554908, -0.009729653596878052, 0.04253106564283371, 0.05745719373226166, 0.03448360785841942, -0.06961268186569214, -0.00407251575961709, 0.04120154678821564, -0.000502661510836333, 0.008052300661802292, -0.0035202731378376484, 0.04837556183338165, 0.014265545643866062, -0.021656762808561325, 0.03414108604192734, -0.017987215891480446, -0.04410773143172264, 0.016835849732160568, -0.06985560059547424, -0.07431723177433014, 0.009496621787548065, -0.06879215687513351, 0.035426750779151917, 0.0043747927993535995, -0.011049785651266575, -0.001346995704807341, 0.03832435980439186, -0.0032978986855596304, 0.04483069106936455, 0.018208133056759834, 0.004711308982223272, -0.023879269137978554, -0.026527326554059982, -0.013838223181664944, 0.02014256827533245, 0.00046087001101113856, -0.034304313361644745, 0.003455216996371746, 0.001793764648027718, -0.11949490755796432, -0.04636175185441971, 0.023982655256986618, -0.03348425030708313, 0.029897339642047882, 0.0716463178396225, -0.019582659006118774, -0.04733247682452202, 0.011347092688083649, 0.007330127060413361, -0.04176739603281021, -0.0030897955875843763, -0.04845500364899635, 0.021869629621505737, 0.04107663035392761, 0.01926463469862938, -0.020388035103678703, 0.02805919758975506, 0.018947193399071693, 0.0651574581861496, -0.026535553857684135, 0.037491217255592346, -0.0013591694878414273, 0.029110893607139587, 0.032301295548677444, 0.05399405583739281, 0.03888589143753052, 0.015014591626822948, -0.022623512893915176, -0.00039029211620800197, 0.00780876912176609, -0.040402889251708984, -0.024219030514359474, -0.01706804148852825, 0.015681257471442223, -0.020555123686790466, -0.006567737087607384, -0.04908525198698044, -0.00601657060906291, 0.022300980985164642, 0.004153649788349867, 0.003610420972108841, 0.009078005328774452, -0.025742223486304283, -0.06062670424580574, -0.0164831280708313, -0.05310215428471565, 0.03999875858426094, 0.0464266762137413, -0.030642107129096985, -0.0064562647603452206, -0.006591485813260078, 0.08076963573694229, 0.0499127060174942, -0.0036357955541461706, -0.029828358441591263, -0.04236270859837532, -0.003959438763558865, -0.041109032928943634, 0.0048474217765033245, -0.02586659975349903, 0.019131651148200035, 0.037748947739601135, 0.002333147218450904, -0.011629651300609112, 0.014999142847955227, 0.05446380004286766, 0.026053285226225853, 0.05071360990405083, -0.07423693686723709, 0.011214329861104488, -0.04240266606211662, -0.024417860433459282, 0.004859411623328924, 0.003056412795558572, 0.01671597734093666, 0.035783544182777405, -0.08004601299762726, -0.03643399849534035, -0.05884493514895439, -0.012287807650864124, 0.029797250404953957, 0.012886990793049335, -0.01899389922618866, -0.0016664157155901194, 0.013559345155954361, -0.06790871173143387, 0.033080779016017914, -0.010110510513186455, -0.03624210134148598, -0.011929748579859734, -0.027578221634030342, 0.007226929999887943, 0.052969492971897125, -0.01406500581651926, -0.010310233570635319, -0.0004496647452469915, -0.006844553165137768, 0.009381216019392014, 0.01645328290760517, 0.03357083722949028, 0.020936449989676476, 0.0056061954237520695, -0.05212266743183136, 0.004657450132071972, 0.025299429893493652, -0.028110885992646217, 0.029208559542894363, 0.08123098313808441, 0.03517445921897888, -0.035844337195158005, -0.028469853103160858, 0.0013728964840993285, -0.04989666864275932, -0.006095683667808771, 0.04284030199050903, -0.017512721940875053, 0.04916837066411972, 0.06415601819753647, 0.02497495710849762, -0.12416328489780426, 0.005676941480487585, -0.030339781194925308, -0.032128822058439255, 0.007005469873547554, 0.03751932829618454, 0.03235187381505966, -0.05270516872406006, 0.006642931140959263, 0.050315991044044495, -0.009744339622557163, -0.0038186018355190754, 0.09673216193914413, -0.013090385124087334, -0.06791796535253525, -0.028803575783967972, 0.008317732252180576, 0.0009064908954314888, 0.017806552350521088, -0.04105222970247269, -0.001401820220053196, -0.010098486207425594, 0.018591266125440598, -0.005644373595714569, 0.025895817205309868, -0.013262337073683739, 0.011828581802546978, 0.002903778338804841, -0.003667448414489627, 0.06704062968492508, 0.014506993815302849, -0.05360615998506546, -0.024467652663588524, 0.03970871493220329, -0.04357646405696869, 0.002891954267397523, -0.042121805250644684, -0.059372175484895706, 0.014307389035820961, 0.0496315062046051, 0.041933104395866394, -0.006980216130614281, 0.03265630826354027, 0.07162588834762573, -0.012074434198439121, 0.01246698945760727, -0.02292880043387413, -0.012964267283678055, 0.018457798287272453, -0.017611421644687653, -0.015817753970623016, -0.017610350623726845, 0.032295867800712585, 0.02000502683222294, 0.021153956651687622, -0.036279480904340744, 0.04212859645485878, 0.04543311521410942, -0.05115142837166786, -0.03897129371762276, 0.09976930916309357, -0.05495409667491913, -0.05603517219424248, 0.013328680768609047, -0.0521821491420269, -0.028604110702872276, 0.01745222695171833, 0.026360752061009407, -0.06742031127214432, 0.02105962671339512, 0.039683807641267776, 0.015805251896381378, 0.022602375596761703, 0.05478206276893616, 0.045196060091257095, -0.01541503518819809, 0.022990424185991287, -0.00704755587503314, -0.012560841627418995, -0.01728428527712822, 0.029016783460974693, 0.08109691739082336, -0.05919500067830086, -0.07381587475538254, -0.025622045621275902, -0.058274999260902405, -0.012539222836494446, 0.031292110681533813, -0.010209053754806519, 0.016637463122606277, -0.004252840764820576, -0.002771309344097972, -0.018663445487618446, 0.04020126163959503, 0.00022571010049432516, -0.006305147428065538, 0.03617836907505989, -0.030194874852895737, 0.03627072274684906, 0.0651211142539978, -0.009205851703882217, 0.0379384309053421, 0.02082419954240322, -0.004476817790418863, -0.03007124550640583, 0.05529220774769783, 0.005925304256379604, 0.05524304509162903, 0.02379988506436348, -0.05446663126349449, -0.01234727818518877, -0.02626095898449421, 0.017822040244936943, 0.041214801371097565, 0.05074809491634369, 0.00829293392598629, -0.010413384065032005, -0.11274044215679169, 0.007039818912744522, 0.07886907458305359, 0.0008554474916309118, 0.0027997056022286415, -0.046213097870349884, -0.005044479854404926, -0.006686982698738575, -0.06692193448543549, 0.04512031003832817, -0.01990590989589691, 0.02428547292947769, -0.022254517301917076, 0.010130442678928375, 0.00022578993230126798, -0.007992180064320564, -0.04791165888309479, 0.041784752160310745, 0.00032317472505383193, 0.03467680513858795, 0.0021468568593263626, 0.07900947332382202, -0.005640114191919565, -0.03617266193032265, -0.03282035142183304, -0.012791789136826992, -0.07551637291908264, -0.07365118712186813, -0.03713774308562279, 0.056573085486888885, -0.043817490339279175, 0.07169126719236374, 0.02912595309317112, -0.01919877715408802, 0.02881535515189171, -0.008661911822855473, -0.02239234372973442, 0.029613079503178596, 0.0026926498394459486, -0.02064608223736286, -0.051192037761211395, -0.023628629744052887, -0.04828733950853348, 0.03232700005173683, 0.008579762652516365, -0.03286151960492134, 0.004858371336013079, -0.03921172395348549, 0.008081624284386635, 0.04698912054300308, -0.026986606419086456, -0.0034239485394209623, 0.023522473871707916, 0.0061109429225325584, -0.008709627203643322, -0.03866303712129593, -0.015666533261537552, -0.01886569894850254, 0.0402458980679512, -0.011348226107656956, 0.012805969454348087, -0.018750347197055817, -0.01905902288854122, 0.02593730017542839, -0.00891285203397274, 0.054726116359233856, 0.003986838739365339, 0.009388257749378681, -0.057673875242471695, -0.018183400854468346, -0.03853369131684303, 0.010374813340604305, -0.007800072431564331, 0.0005448350566439331, -0.01868305541574955, -0.040484827011823654, -0.006996768526732922, 0.021729527041316032, 0.03396182879805565, -0.01892545260488987, -0.007635930553078651, 0.023692555725574493, 0.020503496751189232, -0.026254883036017418, -0.024940617382526398, 0.04643986001610756, 0.030842287465929985, 0.013090379536151886, 0.006654832046478987, -0.05138150602579117, -0.03764037415385246, 0.0674579069018364, 0.032392315566539764, -0.00912483874708414, -0.017603140324354172, 0.026738177984952927, 0.02306537516415119, 0.020649321377277374, -0.008443678729236126, 0.03562043979763985, -0.04047301784157753, -0.01702800579369068, -0.029668733477592468, 0.004125174134969711, 0.001289810985326767, -0.010272584855556488, -0.06360630691051483, -0.02863544225692749, 0.03740805760025978, 0.01969039812684059, -0.033580098301172256, -0.02140696533024311, 0.030226988717913628, -0.03164820745587349, 0.07255447655916214, -0.036652788519859314, -0.051558203995227814, 0.007202757056802511, -0.014840738847851753, 0.04590142145752907, -0.017627231776714325, 0.011374810710549355, -0.009363432414829731, -0.011536112055182457, 0.0941045805811882, -0.045426901429891586, -0.001570128370076418, -0.014142265543341637, 0.009856699034571648, 0.0019743628799915314, 0.005232078023254871, 0.05050693824887276, 0.03236539289355278, -0.021448243409395218, -0.022507963702082634, -0.005887414328753948, 0.004561432637274265, 0.02094213105738163, 0.028596213087439537, -0.032678134739398956, -0.006060786545276642, -0.012454703450202942, -0.03777921944856644, 0.02062227390706539, 0.005050330888479948, 0.029123282060027122, -0.0044402917847037315, -0.017020968720316887, 0.017537744715809822, -0.004542602691799402, 0.08514293283224106, 0.012798617593944073, -0.07228583842515945, -0.04190555587410927, -0.04188712686300278, 0.04283387213945389, 0.05741138383746147, 0.013763247057795525, 0.0034613977186381817, -0.054022256284952164, -0.05776393041014671, 0.025419654324650764, -0.011240680702030659, -0.03489033877849579, 0.07516676932573318, 0.0006060412270016968, 0.017343319952487946, 0.05364111810922623, -0.024043872952461243, 0.015196316875517368, 0.002079671947285533, -0.06262435019016266, 0.005783393979072571, 0.06634270399808884, 0.07377468794584274, 0.03032909333705902, -0.011443110182881355, 0.07401837408542633, 0.03098246641457081, -0.005432669539004564, 0.08099421113729477, -0.0008528574253432453, 0.05962981656193733, -0.018547147512435913, -0.04806751385331154, -0.06737913191318512, 0.0191215667873621, 0.011598248034715652, -0.04305529594421387, 0.005627714563161135, 0.000282871478702873, -0.03866888955235481, -0.015663577243685722, -0.040684107691049576, 0.05545846000313759, -0.011418330483138561, -0.01724829524755478, -0.04278029128909111, 0.0134420245885849, -0.003510977141559124, -0.023625627160072327, -0.002194393193349242, -0.09294082969427109, -0.017098909243941307, 0.0006654944736510515, -0.026339689269661903, 0.022891679778695107, -0.010129387490451336, 0.04885009303689003, 0.047086428850889206, -0.013826409354805946, 0.00982747320085764, -0.009037505835294724, 0.014728059060871601, 0.02308841049671173, 0.10658787190914154, -0.08173702657222748, 0.023925425484776497, 0.0475759319961071, 0.03324460610747337, -0.032386019825935364, -0.05774414911866188, -0.030740398913621902, -0.02441735379397869, -0.0737524926662445, -0.004916980396956205, -0.01550647895783186, -0.05620617792010307, 0.01838674396276474, 0.07892810553312302, -0.020318109542131424, 0.034653693437576294, -0.00876394659280777, 0.002409877721220255, -0.007775544188916683, -0.017328929156064987, 0.009614056907594204, 0.008761433884501457, 0.005209043622016907, -0.014226880855858326, -0.006433836650103331, 0.02267269790172577, 0.0010872987331822515, -0.013250753283500671, -0.021144555881619453, 0.042140889912843704, 0.021811440587043762, -0.002402477664873004, -0.00668364018201828, 0.04804437607526779, 0.022449523210525513, -0.01318871695548296, 0.03259626775979996, -0.02477402240037918, -0.003135178703814745, 0.0039390078745782375, -0.022071121260523796, 0.033003535121679306, 0.002049243077635765, -0.01657157391309738, -0.03139224648475647, -0.039286818355321884, 0.02044438011944294, 0.017596779391169548, -0.034298598766326904, -0.00749862939119339, 0.023792408406734467, 0.005956805776804686, -0.0660020038485527, -0.043484240770339966, -0.025025416165590286, 0.004476282745599747, 0.03873773664236069, 0.025151442736387253, 0.04820287600159645, 0.03135419264435768, -0.007528309244662523, -0.02434227429330349, -0.005407185293734074, -0.043155867606401443, -0.0066130799241364, 0.008052990771830082, -0.035721730440855026, 0.04250942915678024, 0.0018652189755812287, -0.009458143264055252, -0.012108494527637959, 0.010098697617650032, 0.03769272193312645, -0.02565246820449829, -0.007470967248082161, 0.007670508231967688, 0.0022230176255106926, -0.005096051376312971, -0.04993918165564537, -0.008463459089398384, 0.04097006469964981, 0.02771894261240959, 0.03258711099624634, -0.05095575004816055, -0.03108260966837406, 0.04991725832223892, -0.05154845863580704, -0.014638829976320267, 0.03897900879383087, 0.013638517819344997, -0.012407726608216763, -0.02974129468202591, 0.025919631123542786, 0.08016877621412277, -0.03001835197210312, -0.0017923824489116669, 0.06078663468360901, -0.00284878583624959, 0.04041434824466705, 0.046987712383270264, 0.035627759993076324, -0.028652044013142586, -0.017897889018058777, -0.0444064661860466, 0.012885070405900478, -0.05386606231331825, 0.007369121070951223, 0.06405098736286163, -0.01158902794122696, 0.0001277817355003208, 0.06317457556724548, 0.04232220724225044, 0.05492173507809639, -0.02366543933749199, 0.0015328116714954376, -0.07411729544401169, -0.05093616247177124, -0.0019267434254288673, 0.026918910443782806, 0.020956503227353096, -0.04403045028448105, 0.013540132902562618, -0.015580565668642521, -0.041496820747852325, 0.00813101977109909, -0.05338400602340698, -0.051448967307806015, 0.006492464803159237 ]
<p>The world is full of nuclear warheads being stockpiled. Controlled fusion power seems a long way away. Could we put these warheads to better use by exploding them in a controlled way and capturing the energy they produce?</p> <p>By useful work I mean the power is then available for the national grid to boil kettles or have a shower!</p> <p>Extra points for looking at the practicalities of building a facility to do this (although I guess that would get the question closed :-(... )</p>
g1607
[ -0.0627923533320427, 0.06393218040466309, 0.01753082498908043, 0.012089923024177551, -0.006164847407490015, -0.03190949931740761, -0.021806329488754272, 0.04180771857500076, -0.018058307468891144, -0.00943261943757534, -0.007996858097612858, 0.03536732494831085, -0.0004906252725049853, -0.031872205436229706, 0.040716465562582016, -0.00790622178465128, 0.026281602680683136, 0.006821599788963795, -0.0407118983566761, 0.08969563245773315, 0.003291499335318804, -0.01600620709359646, 0.018157387152314186, 0.00871292408555746, -0.05121252313256264, 0.018451709300279617, -0.010704929009079933, -0.04744204506278038, -0.028588971123099327, -0.07219132035970688, 0.010489133186638355, -0.03940391167998314, -0.011940655298531055, -0.0020492838229984045, -0.06537467241287231, -0.06943200528621674, -0.04049944505095482, -0.026641597971320152, 0.0504353791475296, -0.06235886365175247, -0.07295884191989899, 0.015817299485206604, -0.008888312615454197, 0.015734905377030373, -0.031863655894994736, 0.0033210187684744596, 0.023244524374604225, -0.011386366561055183, -0.014498444274067879, -0.01342667918652296, 0.028570739552378654, -0.016843272373080254, -0.015177675522863865, 0.0001071795413736254, 0.061466384679079056, -0.057071756571531296, -0.011937839910387993, 0.00027299701469019055, 0.027684813365340233, -0.060481853783130646, 0.005055771674960852, 0.07077302038669586, 0.0319577232003212, -0.04689032584428787, 0.021191585808992386, 0.047157566994428635, -0.01781248301267624, 0.0006856220425106585, 0.10866273939609528, 0.04991500824689865, 0.0061014252714812756, -0.0394790880382061, -0.0034895711578428745, -0.03763535991311073, 0.009103390388190746, 0.05276520177721977, 0.03347640857100487, 0.00022277841344475746, -0.005258569028228521, 0.0010370966047048569, 0.009290685877203941, -0.08649781346321106, -0.00856026541441679, -0.06952393800020218, 0.01614142209291458, 0.0036453427746891975, 0.043643929064273834, 0.009923423640429974, 0.018873820081353188, 0.02333182469010353, 0.07695424556732178, 0.05570851266384125, 0.02285066246986389, 0.015987863764166832, 0.025954188778996468, 0.01758291758596897, 0.02260475605726242, -0.016765734180808067, -0.055635713040828705, 0.07631353288888931, -0.02814849652349949, -0.0724918469786644, -0.03781663253903389, -0.013825922273099422, -0.022228093817830086, 0.00524792168289423, 0.023869553580880165, 0.01947486214339733, 0.006868205964565277, -0.009015467949211597, 0.06735745817422867, -0.006049295421689749, 0.028950445353984833, 0.02922138199210167, 0.03585165739059448, 0.012326845899224281, 0.0075086746364831924, -0.016153862699866295, -0.07062375545501709, 0.049199409782886505, 0.018677448853850365, 0.007404839154332876, -0.06129316985607147, -0.0036626416258513927, -0.012761288322508335, -0.013259842991828918, 0.028721218928694725, -0.0026397486217319965, -0.013046199455857277, 0.002875326434150338, 0.027960490435361862, 0.00960284098982811, -0.047520339488983154, 0.04703044891357422, 0.03337852284312248, 0.08741286396980286, -0.015907756984233856, 0.01977698877453804, 0.04000616446137428, -0.02751542441546917, 0.03927106782793999, 0.013140460476279259, -0.0697479248046875, 0.0009462596499361098, -0.008320648223161697, 0.07924635708332062, -0.05505125969648361, 0.02266649529337883, -0.07026855647563934, 0.0706879198551178, -0.05348049849271774, 0.023177538067102432, 0.02806951478123665, -0.057732194662094116, 0.012136721052229404, -0.011591246351599693, 0.042152438312768936, -0.016183065250515938, -0.028865475207567215, -0.049914054572582245, 0.01971588283777237, 0.03335310146212578, 0.0048353481106460094, -0.026648610830307007, 0.06290506571531296, -0.024746283888816833, 0.08324234187602997, -0.062207262963056564, 0.014036825858056545, -0.025428153574466705, -0.05631256103515625, -0.01624428667128086, 0.012074033729732037, 0.01336351502686739, 0.015684233978390694, -0.03401781991124153, 0.06499841064214706, 0.001597280497662723, -0.00509216682985425, -0.009122868068516254, -0.0632464811205864, -0.019432444125413895, 0.010755256749689579, -0.03437094762921333, -0.007262321189045906, 0.025061819702386856, -0.018842492252588272, -0.026036623865365982, -0.015442909672856331, 0.025271153077483177, -0.027501139789819717, 0.02693714015185833, 0.02962477318942547, 0.023494957014918327, -0.007327556144446135, -0.03686656057834625, -0.031057419255375862, -0.024270378053188324, 0.018381698057055473, -0.010698588564991951, -0.018260011449456215, 0.03314369544386864, -0.017051268368959427, -0.03794410824775696, 0.01573748141527176, 0.020771151408553123, 0.030737806111574173, 0.03810209780931473, 0.013748418539762497, -0.059022799134254456, 0.049262840300798416, 0.001337869674898684, 0.026525849476456642, 0.006318998523056507, -0.03435368835926056, -0.002039779908955097, -0.0456620417535305, 0.013371193781495094, -0.050573255866765976, -0.033316951245069504, -0.01949811913073063, 0.036218758672475815, 0.07180343568325043, 0.03896148502826691, 0.007816207595169544, -0.008895591832697392, -0.046204108744859695, 0.0055855349637568, -0.01353354100137949, -0.03962109237909317, -0.03765927255153656, 0.02888205461204052, 0.020723622292280197, -0.05070166289806366, 0.02960820496082306, 0.017631545662879944, 0.012051897123456001, 0.03583682328462601, -0.0022701560519635677, 0.032117486000061035, -0.03050059638917446, -0.08506922423839569, -0.04055096209049225, -0.0375170037150383, -0.05404716730117798, -0.05896921455860138, -0.021409127861261368, 0.03216630592942238, 0.009389200247824192, -0.02838624268770218, 0.02948210947215557, 0.0011941317934542894, -0.038698259741067886, -0.007011172827333212, 0.008843732066452503, -0.02441471256315708, 0.016270477324724197, 0.047012943774461746, -0.018889574334025383, 0.0051517849788069725, 0.010745123960077763, -0.042447369545698166, 0.040997907519340515, 0.046177126467227936, 0.03021971695125103, -0.0198842640966177, -0.028479406610131264, -0.011898882687091827, -0.0010326129850000143, 0.003355438355356455, 0.0011154285166412592, -0.0032687350176274776, 0.05785708129405975, 0.05264555662870407, -0.013995842076838017, -0.025530770421028137, 0.05417036637663841, 0.008885757066309452, 0.02949663996696472, 0.003426960902288556, -0.04317335784435272, 0.00875182170420885, 0.007134030573070049, 0.003030044725164771, -0.015438180416822433, -0.024447333067655563, -0.04049285501241684, -0.021452801302075386, -0.000909423572011292, -0.04846630617976189, 0.012653607875108719, -0.03454660251736641, 0.006374298594892025, -0.08563753962516785, -0.083568274974823, -0.008178411982953548, 0.013824338093400002, -0.044362183660268784, -0.03397136926651001, -0.039743442088365555, 0.002303956774994731, -0.03369472548365593, -0.02179388888180256, 0.03666650503873825, -0.04681829735636711, 0.03805579990148544, -0.01041131466627121, 0.023340456187725067, -0.022563183680176735, -0.023163888603448868, 0.02026587910950184, 0.051410920917987823, 0.00672755716368556, 0.002337931888177991, -0.03149557486176491, -0.06132950261235237, -0.0009696036577224731, -0.02874474599957466, 0.011446715332567692, -0.03365836665034294, -0.0032423879019916058, -0.023541636765003204, 0.022965196520090103, 0.009866091422736645, -0.048349346965551376, 0.06879980862140656, 0.023262713104486465, -0.06754270195960999, 0.011494417674839497, 0.008601733483374119, -0.01915249601006508, 0.024455435574054718, 0.02463223785161972, 0.0016175040509551764, -0.08994439989328384, -0.05574128031730652, 0.07193053513765335, 0.05282994359731674, 0.03464469313621521, 0.0359785333275795, -0.011068593710660934, 0.015397148206830025, -0.0389413945376873, 0.013387634418904781, 0.03771429881453514, 0.04364767670631409, 0.011078798212110996, -0.0039069922640919685, -0.03572501614689827, 0.026149891316890717, 0.03172075003385544, -0.01216715294867754, -0.0014455249765887856, -0.05106653645634651, 0.011942436918616295, 0.0018296639900654554, 0.009203579276800156, 0.014150286093354225, -0.03499579057097435, 0.03449622169137001, -0.07347989082336426, 0.040795303881168365, -0.008386874571442604, -0.025300469249486923, -0.015262328088283539, 0.026080211624503136, -0.024675440043210983, 0.01857968419790268, -0.01235545426607132, 0.025789612904191017, -0.009265782311558723, 0.012639288790524006, 0.0016326289623975754, -0.0380280576646328, -0.08474113792181015, 0.027451718226075172, 0.015937643125653267, 0.00980684906244278, -0.01530811470001936, -0.006224529817700386, -0.033974967896938324, -0.023466022685170174, -0.025027083232998848, -0.022990411147475243, -0.053305741399526596, 0.015011169016361237, 0.015976008027791977, 0.005284169223159552, -0.016693944111466408, -0.00034665389102883637, -0.0013622165424749255, -0.06636269390583038, 0.02164645679295063, -0.007166444789618254, -0.08459093421697617, -0.016610082238912582, -0.045034684240818024, -0.02057502046227455, 0.015008230693638325, 0.059278618544340134, 0.0007904840749688447, -0.000014451607967203017, 0.05836298689246178, -0.0068756756372749805, -0.00472372816875577, -0.07255620509386063, -0.017194699496030807, -0.030910015106201172, -0.02865935117006302, -0.059150341898202896, 0.024865608662366867, -0.033987049013376236, 0.004871327895671129, 0.0015807413728907704, 0.009825914166867733, -0.06455855071544647, -0.019600875675678253, -0.0026506586000323296, 0.03554980456829071, 0.0622272714972496, 0.009643318131566048, -0.042772069573402405, 0.037806037813425064, 0.028526127338409424, -0.0029520702082663774, 0.017338907346129417, -0.018469033762812614, -0.018639693036675453, 0.06519240140914917, -0.01121235080063343, 0.12049387395381927, 0.004582238383591175, 0.009770376607775688, -0.026645706966519356, 0.0275968536734581, -0.044281236827373505, -0.08887929469347, -0.0001730851799948141, 0.012364974245429039, 0.08441092073917389, 0.03306533396244049, 0.0028112041763961315, -0.01686207950115204, 0.035942886024713516, 0.0028566455002874136, 0.02929551526904106, -0.009625410661101341, -0.002930247224867344, -0.016579225659370422, -0.042702917009592056, -0.035415347665548325, -0.038330551236867905, -0.033954884856939316, 0.006243842653930187, 0.028445208445191383, 0.046719908714294434, 0.012182554230093956, -0.03975199535489082, 0.022517280653119087, 0.0031830607913434505, -0.01257576048374176, -0.04197069630026817, 0.07748425006866455, -0.060551393777132034, 0.006124462466686964, 0.0070893228985369205, -0.04322120547294617, 0.0015310506569221616, -0.053227975964546204, -0.00451419223099947, -0.0200622770935297, 0.03789957985281944, 0.033594753593206406, 0.03271212801337242, -0.020591793581843376, -0.04603802412748337, 0.04960010573267937, -0.02133496291935444, 0.0532970204949379, -0.0021054097451269627, 0.021999485790729523, -0.017296932637691498, -0.008924095891416073, 0.0041338722221553326, 0.037249594926834106, 0.01347627304494381, -0.025623789057135582, 0.014436540193855762, -0.003117571584880352, -0.03273552283644676, 0.02239082381129265, 0.032890595495700836, 0.019418202340602875, 0.0036115010734647512, 0.03435639664530754, -0.050363924354314804, 0.010457830503582954, 0.020068425685167313, -0.0269306730479002, 0.007084512151777744, 0.023247292265295982, -0.03533729538321495, -0.08147398382425308, 0.03376147523522377, -0.039436474442481995, 0.016519952565431595, 0.05094587430357933, 0.0463130883872509, -0.020134586840867996, -0.01325171533972025, 0.01807771436870098, -0.018263179808855057, -0.019877515733242035, -0.0029201400466263294, 0.060274794697761536, -0.0021823416464030743, -0.07578622549772263, -0.02301446907222271, -0.048428725451231, -0.002796052023768425, 0.021551309153437614, 0.031844690442085266, 0.05976535379886627, -0.00002077725548588205, -0.028706461191177368, -0.01051686704158783, -0.06399326026439667, 0.06369978934526443, 0.027284711599349976, 0.010721657425165176, 0.047678142786026, 0.015469033271074295, -0.055176205933094025, 0.007329314015805721, 0.023637834936380386, 0.06830347329378128, -0.05571683123707771, 0.027412932366132736, -0.003038463881239295, 0.010781093500554562, 0.063595250248909, -0.03489995747804642, 0.05060657486319542, -0.04147787764668465, 0.021715380251407623, -0.04401347413659096, -0.025860494002699852, 0.03583411127328873, -0.03135525807738304, -0.02624901570379734, -0.02069811150431633, 0.0387413464486599, 0.01067308895289898, -0.04789285361766815, 0.07208391278982162, -0.055165987461805344, 0.004588238894939423, -0.03252813592553139, 0.018703822046518326, -0.09423060715198517, -0.02073676325380802, 0.04038500040769577, -0.010764199309051037, 0.06946245580911636, 0.014303822070360184, -0.04790228605270386, -0.03954731300473213, 0.04832982271909714, -0.04024062305688858, 0.03145034983754158, 0.051356371492147446, 0.014452354982495308, 0.004491611383855343, 0.006260151043534279, 0.04981984198093414, -0.02960854209959507, 0.04509473964571953, 0.05034308880567551, -0.007700469810515642, -0.005319312680512667, 0.03216363489627838, -0.028601761907339096, 0.022172454744577408, -0.023355592042207718, 0.006721383426338434, 0.08098927140235901, 0.029833663254976273, 0.059355881065130234, -0.09033317118883133, -0.013000118546187878, 0.028500238433480263, -0.03998398408293724, 0.02951093204319477, -0.006219519302248955, -0.0026929208543151617, 0.04331570491194725, -0.013806530274450779, -0.00039776862831786275, -0.04716595634818077, -0.026012146845459938, -0.04968355596065521, 0.008448410779237747, -0.007165492046624422, -0.016231728717684746, -0.03677371144294739, 0.022687960416078568, -0.01573462225496769, 0.02636447735130787, -0.0072318376041948795, -0.05423017591238022, -0.01477703545242548, -0.0011194891994819045, 0.0031786849722266197, -0.010738231241703033, -0.03373240679502487, 0.015356374904513359, 0.03852083534002304, -0.03643089160323143, 0.06171363964676857, 0.06033666431903839, 0.02512059547007084, 0.007010866422206163, 0.02572586201131344, -0.028366442769765854, -0.006689875386655331, -0.018365366384387016, -0.0658055767416954, -0.0025491081178188324, 0.0016832900000736117, 0.027390964329242706, 0.006639380939304829, 0.07761652767658234, 0.057991236448287964, 0.063740573823452, 0.0008429030422121286, 0.04173184558749199, 0.015846332535147667, 0.021586185321211815, 0.0030930808279663324, -0.025462063029408455, -0.10854322463274002, -0.02075902558863163, -0.03903596103191376, 0.06133372336626053, 0.0068203154951334, 0.044311780482530594, 0.055601201951503754, 0.026250893250107765, -0.027567677199840546, 0.05072144418954849, -0.07223189622163773, -0.03994867578148842, -0.04836481064558029, -0.04189196974039078, -0.0649157464504242, 0.007373328320682049, -0.03278142213821411, 0.05135445296764374, -0.04772689566016197, -0.040854014456272125, 0.06050143390893936, 0.05965902656316757, 0.038098398596048355, -0.011843857355415821, -0.009392870590090752, -0.0016337225679308176, 0.04292502999305725, 0.056108154356479645, 0.003395383246243, 0.028116369619965553, -0.01323019154369831, -0.005002823192626238, -0.038487423211336136, -0.04514757916331291, 0.0441073402762413, -0.008044250309467316, 0.032370030879974365, 0.04548337310552597, 0.023695599287748337, 0.0350840762257576, -0.013091775588691235, -0.08612798154354095, -0.01853075623512268, -0.02468840964138508, 0.017580708488821983, 0.020273521542549133, -0.0266505666077137, 0.02132566273212433, -0.00029207905754446983, 0.053153324872255325, -0.03416157886385918, 0.023323938250541687, 0.08250211179256439, -0.003520798869431019, -0.0407569482922554, 0.004423152655363083, 0.07493780553340912, -0.007607676088809967, 0.010488344356417656, 0.003905883990228176, 0.019496064633131027, 0.003343981923535466, 0.06667447835206985, -0.043024174869060516, -0.023215943947434425, 0.019447574391961098, 0.039551060646772385, 0.02161359041929245, -0.034518055617809296, 0.03238296136260033, 0.03314085677266121, 0.00907197967171669, 0.040224213153123856, 0.0005008899606764317, 0.01161004789173603, 0.0012104721972718835, -0.0021823702845722437, -0.015959182754158974, 0.08286742866039276, 0.012626434676349163, 0.0001102316819014959, 0.010237515904009342, -0.03277329355478287, -0.007299656514078379, 0.03782489150762558, 0.0225408636033535, 0.0118442103266716, -0.04025515913963318, -0.013962829485535622, -0.03206832334399223, 0.06844387203454971, -0.006977207027375698, 0.022546200081706047, 0.005629401188343763, 0.04891769215464592, -0.0683184415102005, 0.040559038519859314, -0.01736525446176529, -0.035020191222429276, 0.06411989778280258, 0.0260710921138525, -0.027586106210947037, -0.02428813837468624, -0.024429794400930405, 0.04107477888464928, 0.030343225225806236, -0.0008966108434833586, 0.023495059460401535, 0.006012616213411093, 0.01352597400546074, 0.0008393212920054793, 0.005419825203716755, -0.053808972239494324, -0.015030349604785442, 0.0025786173064261675, 0.006994090974330902, 0.014311613515019417, 0.007444064598530531, 0.006106851156800985, 0.03312301263213158, 0.00684278504922986, 0.026554353535175323, -0.05161299929022789, -0.01825670525431633, -0.02418658509850502, 0.006834634114056826, -0.04151967912912369, -0.018247995525598526 ]
<p>At present the only way we can produce anti-matter is through high powered collisions. New matter is created from the energy produced in these collisions and some of them are anti-matter particles such as positrons, anti-protons etc.</p> <p>My question is, normal matter and anti-matter are so similar. They both appear to react to the fundamental forces in the same way. Is it conceivable that we could find a way of "switching" matter to become "anti-matter" through some low energy technique? E.g. find a way to flick a few "quantum switches" and voila your proton is now an anti-proton, ready for annihilation and limitless energy for humanity!</p> <p>Would we be breaking a great deal of the fundamental laws of physics if this was found to be possible (i.e. should I give up now)?</p>
g1608
[ 0.05181032046675682, 0.010214162059128284, 0.037495166063308716, -0.0051221647299826145, 0.04827022925019264, 0.03441213071346283, -0.03928656503558159, 0.011727585457265377, -0.0647706463932991, -0.01545788999646902, 0.06733668595552444, 0.034293536096811295, 0.0016993191093206406, -0.0471753291785717, -0.03379444032907486, 0.03728747367858887, 0.008409932255744934, -0.02382679656147957, -0.00037332382635213435, 0.0034284077119082212, -0.024039605632424355, -0.007775993086397648, 0.0023563264403492212, -0.05748673155903816, -0.042589426040649414, -0.022664552554488182, -0.0369991697371006, -0.015387501567602158, 0.006246446631848812, 0.02584194950759411, -0.021725011989474297, -0.05896605923771858, 0.020597992464900017, -0.07044576853513718, -0.016300641000270844, -0.011296024546027184, 0.04497108981013298, -0.012285212054848671, -0.00118501135148108, 0.033415358513593674, -0.014750269241631031, -0.0333225317299366, -0.028860431164503098, -0.01457774918526411, 0.016017485409975052, 0.05728930979967117, -0.004165947902947664, -0.03496507182717323, 0.012284697033464909, -0.028118515387177467, -0.00570412864908576, 0.00648321770131588, 0.007593664340674877, 0.05764368176460266, 0.009708911180496216, -0.029948972165584564, 0.02639990858733654, -0.014618664048612118, 0.08972291648387909, -0.03707270324230194, -0.06192878261208534, 0.030240923166275024, 0.008825520053505898, -0.006409772671759129, 0.028647033497691154, -0.015678154304623604, -0.03010507859289646, -0.00506499782204628, 0.013879313133656979, 0.04292033240199089, -0.005365798715502024, -0.06728817522525787, -0.025622183457016945, 0.0006783973658457398, 0.0028880261816084385, 0.00666262349113822, 0.05669311806559563, -0.028046084567904472, 0.01373829785734415, -0.037773583084344864, -0.042802710086107254, -0.04671226069331169, 0.05582509562373161, 0.025561628863215446, 0.02832610532641411, -0.05851759761571884, -0.02898089587688446, 0.011347630992531776, 0.0009802451822906733, 0.022133946418762207, -0.029421428218483925, 0.021692374721169472, -0.0135172288864851, -0.030988626182079315, -0.00008834361506160349, 0.016048002988100052, 0.009003138169646263, -0.008273031562566757, -0.07981734722852707, -0.008873926475644112, -0.01632307656109333, -0.011376207694411278, 0.02330373413860798, -0.005010940134525299, -0.010128536261618137, -0.02928593009710312, 0.04812666401267052, -0.03887954354286194, 0.02631969563663006, 0.015316542237997055, 0.0033140701707452536, -0.023087896406650543, -0.05695514380931854, -0.01063456665724516, 0.01518385112285614, -0.027157092466950417, 0.030846135690808296, 0.029065309092402458, -0.010293628089129925, 0.06738216429948807, -0.013584993779659271, 0.03153907135128975, -0.01255164947360754, 0.030479367822408676, -0.010862922295928001, -0.07702059298753738, 0.015317906625568867, 0.0019492418505251408, 0.01245492696762085, -0.03379744663834572, 0.012110782787203789, -0.048377033323049545, 0.009856495074927807, -0.003658625530079007, 0.03284859284758568, 0.07054053992033005, 0.02173161320388317, 0.014704382047057152, 0.03313520923256874, -0.09636267274618149, -0.01202558632940054, -0.017325323075056076, -0.03745998814702034, 0.030886337161064148, -0.042285460978746414, 0.04623933881521225, -0.06956440210342407, 0.03849728778004646, -0.05174051597714424, 0.09053084254264832, 0.021444613113999367, 0.025635311380028725, 0.016569525003433228, -0.00947523396462202, 0.01551414281129837, 0.04774783179163933, 0.015297967940568924, 0.009369849227368832, -0.03912583738565445, -0.01075818482786417, 0.036610715091228485, -0.02429160289466381, -0.027289561927318573, -0.02711089327931404, -0.03398260474205017, 0.050530798733234406, -0.03129088878631592, 0.05211798846721649, 0.01963605359196663, 0.016822069883346558, -0.026142608374357224, 0.01793145202100277, 0.0013666196027770638, 0.015685804188251495, 0.04524987190961838, -0.056317463517189026, 0.006400476209819317, -0.0769510269165039, -0.09313561767339706, -0.05374665930867195, -0.007277814671397209, 0.036645859479904175, -0.014566241763532162, -0.03206207603216171, 0.07024505734443665, 0.091512031853199, 0.017022276297211647, 0.05164770036935806, 0.05107493698596954, 0.020364949479699135, -0.06420005112886429, 0.03080381266772747, -0.008910654112696648, 0.0034715402871370316, 0.05842725560069084, -0.053074296563863754, -0.04076278209686279, 0.010939528234302998, 0.020379075780510902, -0.020077913999557495, -0.0019845394417643547, 0.050642259418964386, -0.023860473185777664, -0.058324869722127914, 0.06827610731124878, 0.015623580664396286, 0.025739489123225212, -0.016412027180194855, 0.041185878217220306, 0.009976200759410858, 0.06613501161336899, 0.04303424432873726, -0.016343943774700165, -0.029855558648705482, -0.05423527956008911, 0.02307598479092121, 0.02279696799814701, -0.011377237737178802, 0.0012962832115590572, 0.016859276220202446, -0.021488649770617485, -0.00466170534491539, 0.009996114298701286, 0.026434801518917084, 0.031504031270742416, -0.010862153023481369, -0.00970370788127184, -0.0037596290931105614, -0.033630162477493286, -0.021090831607580185, -0.03968675062060356, 0.05878513306379318, 0.03853200748562813, -0.059944309294223785, 0.0019627870060503483, 0.015203344635665417, -0.01281319372355938, 0.017580179497599602, 0.02534891478717327, -0.018200144171714783, -0.0062393308617174625, -0.011192815378308296, -0.03685736283659935, 0.04157339036464691, -0.03119882382452488, -0.0885293111205101, 0.0019317333353683352, -0.05645182356238365, -0.015720678493380547, -0.00887246336787939, 0.07138646394014359, -0.005405252333730459, -0.05197560414671898, -0.048029422760009766, 0.01876971498131752, 0.005474348086863756, -0.014089871197938919, 0.06280221045017242, -0.029516637325286865, -0.035616185516119, -0.014566251076757908, 0.034556008875370026, 0.020537234842777252, 0.04317658767104149, -0.03455285355448723, -0.03020486608147621, -0.05006715655326843, 0.06254003196954727, -0.07226666808128357, 0.03582403436303139, 0.010816171765327454, 0.04354546591639519, -0.026778066530823708, 0.030935456976294518, -0.008690892718732357, 0.027769483625888824, -0.0017812177538871765, -0.038078438490629196, 0.061509452760219574, -0.0034216877538710833, -0.07846786081790924, 0.026560813188552856, -0.04646237939596176, -0.07623021304607391, -0.012699838727712631, -0.010475735180079937, -0.004567049443721771, -0.04556044563651085, -0.05632876232266426, 0.017209762707352638, -0.06508112698793411, -0.03196210414171219, 0.019030677154660225, -0.0406663678586483, -0.0134812593460083, 0.03200962767004967, 0.08562430739402771, -0.009007763117551804, -0.06588722765445709, 0.024848464876413345, -0.012374404817819595, -0.04521569237112999, 0.018973810598254204, 0.01593468338251114, -0.01594710350036621, -0.008605835027992725, -0.06032386049628258, -0.0005003744154237211, -0.03980632871389389, 0.00845371838659048, 0.017846105620265007, 0.08967490494251251, -0.030349135398864746, 0.06609811633825302, 0.008024465292692184, -0.010710986331105232, 0.013898923061788082, 0.05554598942399025, 0.03350650891661644, -0.026435503736138344, -0.020377906039357185, -0.017156004905700684, 0.025968702509999275, -0.05851006135344505, -0.004548355471342802, -0.002274630591273308, -0.06336196511983871, -0.025115737691521645, -0.07351086288690567, -0.033814936876297, 0.0961185172200203, -0.04623038321733475, -0.033595189452171326, 0.03085179068148136, -0.060385435819625854, -0.022752588614821434, 0.0473201721906662, 0.00018781263497658074, 0.05488086864352226, 0.06178756803274155, 0.033325567841529846, 0.0030288826674222946, -0.07536784559488297, 0.012714218348264694, -0.034870076924562454, 0.06856324523687363, 0.013488821685314178, -0.03134915232658386, -0.019945742562413216, 0.0335143581032753, 0.022409172728657722, -0.026874857023358345, 0.07600423693656921, -0.0001736401318339631, 0.03401767089962959, -0.011984202079474926, 0.06252629309892654, 0.0646253228187561, 0.03709252178668976, -0.02133427932858467, -0.044209327548742294, -0.01754843257367611, 0.04478897154331207, 0.0037883492186665535, 0.00022114085732027888, 0.004396085627377033, -0.048427555710077286, -0.03506193682551384, -0.03302300348877907, -0.05508352443575859, 0.05747942626476288, -0.085054412484169, 0.024351896718144417, -0.03098299168050289, -0.026228610426187515, 0.03939169645309448, 0.030156511813402176, 0.038326364010572433, -0.011907345615327358, 0.024186313152313232, -0.023890160024166107, 0.03423765301704407, -0.012226637452840805, -0.03316742554306984, 0.0012813741341233253, 0.01747285947203636, -0.06827608495950699, -0.004745058715343475, -0.015196756459772587, 0.007471281103789806, -0.01944180764257908, -0.03403252363204956, 0.03229745849967003, 0.007591781206429005, -0.04051527380943298, 0.0038814975414425135, 0.01121485698968172, -0.06077974662184715, 0.022693119943141937, 0.0337984636425972, 0.009850257076323032, 0.0482649989426136, -0.008072588592767715, -0.04448918253183365, 0.03302134945988655, -0.037736907601356506, 0.027206888422369957, 0.03192596510052681, -0.01774694211781025, -0.07567712664604187, 0.04597107693552971, -0.00401831790804863, -0.03160371631383896, -0.006239577662199736, -0.008460276760160923, -0.006640207953751087, -0.04831598699092865, 0.028690900653600693, 0.03807457908987999, -0.015408135950565338, 0.026624415069818497, 0.03646260127425194, -0.01815648376941681, 0.043829843401908875, -0.027543403208255768, 0.06793978065252304, 0.017325077205896378, -0.0011367897968739271, -0.01812233403325081, -0.058266058564186096, -0.01024844590574503, 0.008382701314985752, -0.0009780314285308123, -0.009272225201129913, 0.01593402586877346, -0.007013141177594662, -0.02459089830517769, 0.0013675186783075333, 0.03375019133090973, -0.01554014254361391, 0.09232145547866821, 0.028523212298750877, 0.04796990007162094, -0.06169772520661354, -0.0006877398700453341, 0.03701261430978775, -0.038952894508838654, 0.02135865017771721, -0.015166415832936764, -0.048457078635692596, -0.007052393164485693, -0.03616808354854584, 0.02944152057170868, -0.03956366702914238, -0.032887715846300125, 0.0011050155153498054, 0.009478962048888206, -0.019676482304930687, -0.016092147678136826, 0.05789383128285408, -0.030324293300509453, 0.008347133174538612, 0.03172539174556732, -0.01765579916536808, 0.031187187880277634, 0.038460973650217056, -0.054440587759017944, -0.04511664807796478, 0.03578478842973709, -0.04365198686718941, 0.006559147499501705, 0.028027690947055817, -0.017485352233052254, 0.018693478778004646, -0.011619344353675842, -0.04734563082456589, -0.011991274543106556, 0.003952879924327135, -0.009824269451200962, 0.0007950059953145683, 0.02422531321644783, 0.009858262725174427, 0.036340877413749695, -0.035922639071941376, -0.01117930468171835, 0.012342837639153004, -0.0728062242269516, 0.04512618109583855, -0.04048342630267143, -0.012300074100494385, -0.04063188657164574, -0.0075766826048493385, 0.02588856965303421, -0.04700334742665291, 0.05820857733488083, 0.025939226150512695, -0.018653392791748047, 0.01633937656879425, -0.0891614481806755, 0.03652495518326759, -0.0018765858840197325, -0.0008640814921818674, -0.005478629842400551, -0.0009373184875585139, 0.025184864178299904, 0.01988520845770836, 0.056122105568647385, 0.010468537919223309, 0.003312189830467105, 0.009964956901967525, -0.02375967428088188, 0.00452070077881217, 0.011064223945140839, 0.033780537545681, -0.07005088776350021, 0.022656980901956558, -0.022171594202518463, -0.025983206927776337, 0.015202896669507027, -0.12311725318431854, -0.014159293845295906, -0.02722206525504589, 0.025369420647621155, 0.028246814385056496, -0.0012151499977335334, -0.011449098587036133, -0.0017293584533035755, 0.053085457533597946, -0.007658518850803375, -0.0009353920468129218, 0.01261615939438343, 0.05383579432964325, 0.000036890975025016814, -0.012204890139400959, -0.02963024191558361, 0.01887783594429493, 0.009182837791740894, 0.04046792536973953, 0.02766961231827736, -0.0007279608398675919, -0.006442869547754526, -0.08537060022354126, 0.10058742761611938, 0.06499624252319336, 0.008692232891917229, 0.022941164672374725, -0.03411626070737839, -0.01689407415688038, 0.010067769326269627, -0.07454178482294083, -0.04086213931441307, 0.020875684916973114, 0.019746793434023857, 0.005093961022794247, 0.016796845942735672, 0.01349014975130558, -0.01286333054304123, -0.0219095591455698, -0.005049330182373524, -0.00015167052333708853, 0.04502156376838684, -0.004062270745635033, 0.025733204558491707, 0.04645143449306488, 0.03207864612340927, -0.03227045387029648, -0.027192991226911545, -0.041972897946834564, -0.01764690689742565, -0.03156646713614464, 0.009142039343714714, 0.062419820576906204, -0.01980530098080635, -0.024884909391403198, 0.03773237019777298, -0.06610383093357086, 0.032641615718603134, 0.017924850806593895, -0.02593160606920719, 0.012330484576523304, 0.046498384326696396, -0.04990217834711075, 0.005006762687116861, -0.014224507845938206, 0.020290274173021317, 0.014525970444083214, -0.026438916102051735, 0.009825337678194046, 0.02007814310491085, -0.012102153152227402, -0.03588135540485382, -0.03199288249015808, -0.020315201953053474, 0.03723901882767677, 0.010106518864631653, 0.006431252229958773, -0.01255677081644535, -0.051829755306243896, -0.0023098576348274946, 0.026997702196240425, 0.018177056685090065, -0.00035387687967158854, -0.021881096065044403, -0.012919592671096325, -0.0037519950419664383, 0.058055710047483444, 0.02112516574561596, 0.05549611896276474, 0.007829401642084122, -0.03224112093448639, 0.009737466461956501, -0.03181150555610657, -0.032812636345624924, 0.005014545284211636, -0.05945383757352829, 0.0068853991106152534, -0.04064840450882912, -0.05260321870446205, 0.011236704885959625, 0.017294006422162056, 0.017661279067397118, 0.0467679537832737, -0.006550867110490799, -0.03106275573372841, -0.029615918174386024, 0.03864889219403267, 0.0017759334295988083, 0.11100000143051147, 0.06833940744400024, 0.04009326919913292, 0.004366250243037939, -0.016023928299546242, 0.037224218249320984, -0.002408083761110902, -0.0768745169043541, -0.006085425615310669, -0.01287032850086689, -0.018446573987603188, -0.0465523898601532, -0.009893245995044708, 0.03368581086397171, 0.0029627836775034666, 0.032508715987205505, -0.02231491357088089, -0.015942290425300598, 0.03803004324436188, 0.037139926105737686, 0.005470218602567911, -0.015460084192454815, 0.02731914632022381, 0.0011027524014934897, -0.027992745861411095, -0.006827780976891518, -0.02090568095445633, -0.043676458299160004, 0.06705659627914429, 0.04984315112233162, 0.04679141566157341, -0.004096675664186478, -0.05427917093038559, 0.041493359953165054, 0.0022373960819095373, 0.01701141521334648, -0.046763647347688675, -0.01806247979402542, 0.013997087255120277, 0.027443088591098785, 0.005299602635204792, 0.03140535205602646, -0.004976197611540556, -0.011408151127398014, -0.04077698290348053, -0.0971067026257515, 0.004680657759308815, 0.012391569092869759, -0.027978327125310898, 0.03223675861954689, 0.04957550764083862, 0.04987919703125954, -0.017250925302505493, 0.040414366871118546, 0.0074190967716276646, -0.004122099839150906, 0.04247824102640152, -0.008840818889439106, 0.05236126855015755, -0.007978997193276882, 0.03941288962960243, -0.035489536821842194, 0.012114397250115871, 0.01761290803551674, -0.032020196318626404, 0.05474371835589409, 0.008697410114109516, -0.021864725276827812, -0.03261231258511543, 0.07779522985219955, 0.014626527205109596, -0.016556404531002045, 0.0130775086581707, 0.03344497084617615, -0.010447053238749504, -0.03094199299812317, -0.001095013227313757, -0.05056573078036308, 0.04679696261882782, 0.0053655304946005344, -0.04255214333534241, -0.0740031823515892, 0.014786751009523869, 0.06875227391719818, 0.09029566496610641, 0.028769155964255333, 0.058907635509967804, 0.008427622728049755, 0.017679838463664055, 0.05694669857621193, -0.020422643050551414, 0.04152929037809372, 0.03616230562329292, -0.07686781138181686, -0.011905317194759846, -0.018679851666092873, -0.005975672043859959, 0.008006456308066845, 0.013099555857479572, 0.014433702453970909, -0.03492606431245804, -0.02678278461098671, 0.03641580417752266, -0.014012117870151997, 0.017812032252550125, 0.021155716851353645, -0.025292981415987015, 0.011225249618291855, -0.036044418811798096, 0.00917130708694458, -0.024959726259112358, -0.036774471402168274, 0.03153378888964653, -0.0007984411786310375, 0.04750480502843857, -0.03045322559773922, -0.024040767922997475, 0.016239367425441742, -0.03896152600646019, 0.019161701202392578, 0.04914897680282593, 0.021495738998055458, -0.05829695612192154, 0.044654227793216705, 0.02893340401351452, -0.01698162965476513, 0.04045715183019638, 0.10455918312072754, -0.021293403580784798, -0.00917732436209917, -0.01959916576743126, -0.02867104485630989, 0.00964025966823101, -0.0006350320181809366, 0.01842689700424671, -0.030916593968868256, 0.024813633412122726, -0.02457268163561821, 0.019191715866327286, -0.02905934676527977, 0.041441746056079865 ]
<p>It is easy to observe that on a windy day, the wind does not blow for several hours at constant speed, then gradually subside. Instead, on a time scale of seconds or tens of seconds, there are stronger gusts of wind followed by lulls.</p> <p>Presumably this is an effect of turbulence. If so, is this turbulence due to the complicated geometry around me - buildings, trees, hills, etc.? If we removed these features and had wind blowing over a flat ocean surface or a flat plain for hundreds of miles, would we still observe the wind to blow in the same sorts of gusts, or should I expect a more steady flow?</p>
g1609
[ 0.07278134673833847, -0.022871054708957672, -0.015320713631808758, -0.026781924068927765, 0.055157359689474106, 0.02529904618859291, 0.047961052507162094, 0.02010365016758442, -0.03256971389055252, -0.03814677149057388, 0.04561156406998634, 0.022727707400918007, 0.03374772146344185, 0.034981995820999146, 0.009237367659807205, 0.027024688199162483, 0.025555351749062538, -0.025990178808569908, 0.0037635909393429756, -0.022027969360351562, -0.020110763609409332, -0.04269853234291077, 0.05102367699146271, -0.0064677647314965725, -0.053379207849502563, -0.005731628276407719, -0.01791015826165676, 0.020432857796549797, -0.0573437362909317, 0.008054508827626705, -0.012165040709078312, 0.047459881752729416, 0.05437731370329857, -0.08345747739076614, -0.06322062760591507, -0.008239928632974625, -0.04396997392177582, 0.0032711459789425135, 0.047814492136240005, -0.006502724252641201, 0.007296575699001551, 0.012041594833135605, 0.011203979142010212, 0.06857278943061829, 0.02865670807659626, -0.007437234744429588, -0.011869838461279869, 0.013836880214512348, -0.007942751049995422, -0.05138752982020378, -0.025036176666617393, -0.04892464354634285, 0.018867574632167816, -0.0024643270298838615, -0.03822283819317818, 0.03055291622877121, 0.07426726818084717, 0.0018643646035343409, 0.02887737564742565, 0.029001420363783836, 0.026526758447289467, -0.022038117051124573, 0.014368947595357895, 0.03295841068029404, -0.001409010961651802, 0.02132650464773178, -0.008873104117810726, -0.05948372557759285, 0.014294962398707867, 0.0035177702084183693, 0.0176478810608387, -0.028567777946591377, -0.013907555490732193, -0.08276855945587158, -0.019138051196932793, 0.052316438406705856, -0.019152550026774406, 0.01336606964468956, -0.010078766383230686, 0.03898847848176956, 0.033094268292188644, -0.021253202110528946, -0.04362652450799942, 0.047319818288087845, 0.028136663138866425, -0.011013082228600979, 0.000837628380395472, -0.014159836806356907, 0.006082912441343069, -0.009549427777528763, 0.03216145187616348, -0.024064987897872925, 0.034899547696113586, -0.00965287908911705, -0.0017595604294911027, -0.08456465601921082, -0.0005278630997054279, 0.08028188347816467, -0.06131578981876373, 0.05552956461906433, -0.06559605151414871, -0.04354117065668106, 0.020382734015583992, 0.03846066817641258, 0.001437215250916779, -0.028453625738620758, -0.04273543506860733, 0.02052352949976921, -0.007056694012135267, -0.05209426209330559, 0.010560061782598495, 0.0272380243986845, -0.009729241952300072, 0.02701423317193985, -0.03543321415781975, 0.0005466454313136637, 0.014251066371798515, 0.011256281286478043, 0.027154352515935898, 0.009769088588654995, -0.018976233899593353, -0.025509728118777275, 0.022230448201298714, 0.014037499204277992, 0.04282689094543457, -0.008792493492364883, 0.04009491950273514, 0.05945088341832161, 0.043908510357141495, 0.0050789350643754005, 0.07537166774272919, 0.007158154621720314, -0.06467840075492859, 0.03576340898871422, 0.013052856549620628, 0.00586495827883482, 0.0023115985095500946, 0.03804731369018555, -0.02652743086218834, 0.04654460400342941, 0.041549619287252426, -0.033675484359264374, 0.04764989763498306, -0.06644222140312195, -0.06221223995089531, 0.005428495351225138, -0.007893283851444721, -0.003945710137486458, 0.0288707222789526, -0.029030224308371544, -0.03310687467455864, -0.018102556467056274, 0.05974455922842026, -0.001917502493597567, -0.02304757572710514, 0.07507584989070892, -0.01616891659796238, 0.04271157085895538, 0.03883390873670578, 0.061726633459329605, 0.023467721417546272, 0.02321457862854004, 0.06363814324140549, -0.014260112307965755, -0.03750322386622429, -0.009675951674580574, -0.04483569413423538, -0.03291905298829079, -0.025370001792907715, 0.040233299136161804, -0.030252711847424507, 0.003196528647094965, 0.016742637380957603, 0.0131940683349967, 0.019693026319146156, 0.0073323724791407585, 0.08102556318044662, -0.0276437159627676, -0.006008131895214319, -0.0679682046175003, -0.029741806909441948, 0.04078693315386772, -0.05045529454946518, -0.05590154603123665, 0.0752820149064064, -0.005802193656563759, 0.014302575960755348, -0.0034221517853438854, -0.00686092022806406, -0.01957947574555874, 0.025748226791620255, -0.07712551951408386, -0.06871277093887329, 0.05061101168394089, -0.026965118944644928, 0.008742126636207104, -0.01859864965081215, -0.07020591199398041, -0.04827972874045372, -0.04249805584549904, -0.011538843624293804, 0.03325266018509865, 0.10861457139253616, -0.006131294183433056, -0.049871403723955154, 0.06567641347646713, 0.039567213505506516, 0.01841789111495018, 0.007535160984843969, -0.01383144035935402, 0.03260565176606178, -0.04021264240145683, 0.003943157382309437, 0.02876550331711769, 0.0544467568397522, -0.0013879288453608751, -0.013607052154839039, 0.006793288514018059, 0.04851308465003967, 0.028419287875294685, 0.006898188032209873, -0.02070533111691475, 0.014623948372900486, -0.0010720620630308986, 0.016258804127573967, -0.051832959055900574, 0.02162708342075348, -0.007485875394195318, -0.0036451455671340227, 0.016097048297524452, 0.028317438438534737, 0.0346667505800724, -0.021253403276205063, 0.03579876944422722, 0.0007256102981045842, 0.007307770196348429, 0.0438535138964653, -0.023301202803850174, 0.004994637798517942, -0.07820195704698563, -0.0028617163188755512, -0.040200263261795044, -0.007694669533520937, -0.0023607180919498205, 0.00930614210665226, -0.06153635308146477, 0.005206427536904812, -0.02894815057516098, 0.03795726224780083, 0.012410501949489117, 0.018596967682242393, -0.046972185373306274, 0.022839121520519257, 0.06509118527173996, 0.008654208853840828, -0.028746359050273895, 0.007272388320416212, -0.004557207226753235, -0.0347771979868412, 0.03700772672891617, -0.04156964272260666, 0.0010953302262350917, -0.03037717379629612, 0.007005193270742893, 0.008433704264461994, 0.02192487008869648, 0.0011983496369794011, 0.08935059607028961, -0.03818248212337494, -0.009271935559809208, 0.029690952971577644, 0.0324847586452961, 0.004753999877721071, 0.02154897339642048, -0.05594669282436371, 0.015474898740649223, -0.043856002390384674, 0.05037905275821686, -0.02762296050786972, 0.04053480178117752, 0.021971479058265686, -0.029902812093496323, -0.0654885545372963, 0.05788830667734146, 0.044961996376514435, -0.07403852045536041, -0.04979084059596062, 0.06951001286506653, -0.04791932553052902, 0.0021761986427009106, -0.026233235374093056, 0.0693754106760025, 0.041577305644750595, -0.01237346138805151, -0.01333433948457241, 0.022889649495482445, 0.007987921126186848, -0.0019409882370382547, -0.05904461443424225, 0.011316918767988682, -0.041010528802871704, -0.00778388325124979, 0.024093694984912872, 0.027095485478639603, -0.0417117178440094, 0.021717313677072525, -0.00026727336808107793, -0.026986993849277496, 0.005199768114835024, -0.050413426011800766, -0.01319397147744894, 0.0234609916806221, -0.019233740866184235, 0.1180589497089386, -0.040597472339868546, 0.011361772194504738, -0.008724799379706383, 0.036781810224056244, -0.05944391340017319, 0.07162599265575409, 0.009975584223866463, 0.006199438590556383, 0.000320155406370759, 0.026019176468253136, 0.048654984682798386, 0.00474889762699604, 0.02903975360095501, 0.0007778393919579685, -0.011655963957309723, 0.01037122868001461, 0.01267081219702959, -0.035190947353839874, -0.02453618310391903, -0.00459849601611495, -0.05485335364937782, 0.047242965549230576, 0.06756417453289032, -0.015378797426819801, 0.018259983509778976, -0.053733643144369125, 0.012632281519472599, 0.009588757529854774, -0.08042807877063751, -0.022409189492464066, -0.013028927147388458, 0.03895441070199013, -0.014401573687791824, -0.06918973475694656, -0.035365067422389984, -0.006984314415603876, 0.03425713628530502, -0.03806119039654732, -0.009228627197444439, -0.1132035031914711, 0.013465620577335358, -0.0514373853802681, 0.001366669894196093, 0.031920988112688065, 0.01843363046646118, -0.02540886588394642, 0.031755346804857254, -0.005986970383673906, -0.021380964666604996, -0.013488288037478924, -0.016489775851368904, -0.015969548374414444, 0.016781466081738472, 0.03510436415672302, -0.03992115706205368, 0.009101977571845055, 0.014124567620456219, -0.013169347308576107, -0.025531873106956482, 0.021465370431542397, 0.029558315873146057, 0.0576070211827755, 0.07275093346834183, 0.038929712027311325, 0.035642001777887344, 0.05402813479304314, 0.032674822956323624, 0.00639632111415267, -0.014912514947354794, 0.001477872603572905, -0.026276037096977234, -0.027999917045235634, -0.041597142815589905, 0.003652952378615737, 0.018411526456475258, -0.0775827094912529, 0.029435355216264725, 0.003875072579830885, 0.01852165162563324, 0.01477902103215456, 0.010668559931218624, -0.0674191266298294, -0.023834936320781708, 0.07710729539394379, -0.014646205119788647, 0.05331265553832054, 0.052462220191955566, 0.05071720853447914, -0.11359476298093796, 0.03591566160321236, 0.0062235272489488125, -0.04290974140167236, 0.005149202886968851, 0.0025986849796026945, -0.04113580286502838, -0.011655036360025406, 0.019538402557373047, -0.04383603483438492, 0.02693988010287285, -0.06822425872087479, -0.016518360003829002, 0.03876812383532524, 0.03214658051729202, -0.0101137300953269, 0.029889943078160286, -0.05212382599711418, -0.021020956337451935, 0.08279277384281158, 0.027558540925383568, -0.031053215265274048, -0.039338499307632446, 0.018601642921566963, 0.04890139773488045, -0.028501512482762337, -0.03171633929014206, 0.01235850341618061, 0.053155142813920975, 0.02077186107635498, -0.010873359628021717, -0.018229596316814423, -0.015997307375073433, 0.00971818808466196, -0.011001466773450375, 0.009634413756430149, 0.05694396793842316, 0.0022057220339775085, 0.014128502458333969, 0.0031120264902710915, 0.0025876800063997507, -0.008930629119277, -0.020856458693742752, 0.010106077417731285, 0.004723384976387024, -0.0443371944129467, -0.013371515087783337, -0.0125639159232378, -0.07157830148935318, 0.020296452566981316, 0.026853809133172035, -0.04648243263363838, -0.0042840708047151566, -0.014708426780998707, -0.05616691708564758, -0.02309923805296421, -0.0028300639241933823, 0.008247225545346737, -0.07293866574764252, 0.010057773441076279, -0.005928695667535067, 0.012101272121071815, -0.03294921666383743, -0.040608011186122894, 0.019402820616960526, -0.03131401538848877, -0.09911397099494934, -0.05760110914707184, 0.019525373354554176, 0.02132975496351719, 0.0024169229436665773, 0.012925852090120316, -0.00014562906289938837, -0.020756008103489876, -0.018969126045703888, -0.007689185440540314, 0.02678772248327732, 0.014797085896134377, 0.03055005520582199, -0.012078597210347652, 0.028353512287139893, -0.007569010369479656, 0.031405258923769, -0.030502647161483765, 0.0008695271681062877, 0.00447469437494874, 0.0663355141878128, -0.018277594819664955, 0.02550324611365795, -0.0026852439623326063, -0.054713305085897446, 0.011145769618451595, -0.00818026065826416, -0.04519300162792206, 0.04149995744228363, -0.05383098125457764, -0.022586515173316002, -0.044088367372751236, -0.038683757185935974, 0.00284710549749434, 0.039915841072797775, 0.032034892588853836, -0.004164555110037327, 0.026839055120944977, 0.013913457281887531, -0.011033573187887669, -0.014144455082714558, 0.08895191550254822, -0.054013460874557495, -0.04479508101940155, -0.06223908066749573, -0.01512922067195177, 0.024974465370178223, -0.046275217086076736, -0.03300262987613678, -0.010336436331272125, 0.02627304568886757, -0.005091245751827955, 0.0624668262898922, 0.0312226302921772, -0.059184204787015915, -0.015339886769652367, -0.0054074362851679325, 0.0715760588645935, -0.041221149265766144, 0.008298642933368683, -0.03336561471223831, 0.008771229535341263, 0.0007575876079499722, -0.018457291647791862, 0.005987280514091253, -0.002676689298823476, 0.035432010889053345, 0.009424837306141853, 0.030820272862911224, -0.0033744152169674635, -0.004615772049874067, 0.037675995379686356, -0.045175936073064804, -0.0040700859390199184, 0.018763892352581024, 0.031055577099323273, -0.018886737525463104, -0.008122897706925869, 0.05853700637817383, 0.024596184492111206, 0.0680929645895958, -0.05428343638777733, -0.01675480790436268, -0.009263632819056511, 0.01858222670853138, 0.007234616670757532, -0.11003781110048294, -0.014735803008079529, 0.018880736082792282, -0.018867410719394684, 0.02169037237763405, -0.05138149484992027, -0.009144770912826061, 0.04554281756281853, 0.011317083612084389, -0.013216684572398663, 0.051390763372182846, 0.007310742512345314, -0.00531851127743721, -0.029693808406591415, 0.03886852040886879, 0.05331648886203766, 0.020679250359535217, -0.014675447717308998, 0.048659346997737885, 0.00068394880509004, -0.007728593423962593, -0.023677963763475418, -0.022942842915654182, 0.00913334358483553, -0.03059137985110283, 0.021819094195961952, -0.02882356010377407, -0.040266502648591995, 0.045616719871759415, -0.06048772856593132, 0.01043897308409214, -0.02318447083234787, 0.015819689258933067, 0.011909576132893562, 0.0028012616094201803, 0.07001621276140213, -0.01863499917089939, -0.06841113418340683, -0.020850585773587227, -0.02340010367333889, -0.006732963025569916, -0.0033233948051929474, -0.007207663729786873, 0.0006734581547789276, -0.0346975177526474, -0.036534834653139114, -0.011198731139302254, 0.00027795671485364437, 0.0527082160115242, -0.05759003013372421, 0.011354001238942146, -0.033455993980169296, 0.024936404079198837, 0.015007849782705307, 0.04006832465529442, 0.003908920101821423, 0.09753408282995224, 0.023593517020344734, 0.007636938709765673, 0.03875783458352089, -0.016497116535902023, -0.0052438718266785145, -0.004603041335940361, -0.0006948074442334473, 0.02221655659377575, -0.03336578235030174, 0.00994174275547266, -0.020766479894518852, 0.022495687007904053, -0.005252005532383919, -0.009859631769359112, 0.07460019737482071, -0.040692828595638275, 0.009420852176845074, 0.023838534951210022, 0.005898111965507269, 0.013396902941167355, 0.004441764205694199, -0.015914158895611763, 0.009242533706128597, -0.046732380986213684, -0.017648857086896896, -0.0007433414575643837, 0.05111144483089447, 0.006653472315520048, 0.05198505520820618, 0.023911166936159134, 0.08200890570878983, 0.02619010955095291, 0.006632092408835888, -0.0380648709833622, -0.05935641750693321, 0.021208127960562706, -0.027151931077241898, 0.004239392001181841, -0.006921953987330198, 0.002768738893792033, -0.06212593615055084, 0.018956460058689117, 0.0006070678355172276, 0.0370917022228241, 0.0015893761301413178, -0.019916154444217682, -0.04555318132042885, 0.02474823035299778, -0.02878418006002903, -0.011686100624501705, 0.005056028254330158, -0.03401388227939606, 0.03412710875272751, -0.004712357651442289, 0.03552411496639252, 0.025990089401602745, 0.00036159821320325136, -0.011772388592362404, -0.0065056756138801575, 0.04825570434331894, -0.020740680396556854, 0.03240220993757248, 0.02972503751516342, 0.01823224313557148, 0.006110173650085926, -0.07908624410629272, 0.00044855111627839506, 0.05101412534713745, -0.016933565959334373, 0.05003948137164116, 0.022145094349980354, -0.007750493939965963, 0.02879844233393669, 0.04463006928563118, 0.05653984844684601, -0.059442706406116486, 0.022344008088111877, -0.02804102934896946, -0.07909581065177917, -0.043727338314056396, 0.04285459592938423, 0.010455147363245487, -0.013282987289130688, -0.00804344192147255, -0.02138533443212509, 0.11131946742534637, -0.07235968112945557, 0.016223955899477005, -0.004223650321364403, 0.001252366928383708, 0.04658963531255722, 0.010911374352872372, -0.04664352536201477, 0.02397284284234047, -0.003954287618398666, 0.004972994793206453, -0.02556784264743328, -0.01989399455487728, -0.004753919318318367, 0.025564540177583694, -0.005175338126718998, -0.0008219077135436237, -0.0010035180021077394, -0.0606379359960556, -0.06913789361715317, -0.002267911098897457, -0.05490488186478615, -0.04928393289446831, 0.04719303175806999, -0.05527025833725929, -0.0033556167036294937, -0.041733257472515106, -0.05060045048594475, 0.0062840767204761505, -0.007603401318192482, -0.017966218292713165, -0.08711345493793488, 0.03482450172305107, 0.010853600688278675, -0.018784571439027786, -0.015992963686585426, 0.021575478836894035, -0.02253461442887783, 0.004810395650565624, -0.03846012428402901, 0.082548126578331, 0.003450279124081135, -0.060636211186647415, -0.011783197522163391, -0.01477210596203804, 0.07719959318637848, -0.042077116668224335, 0.029542798176407814, -0.006399525795131922, -0.014562677592039108, 0.03941259905695915, -0.011512256227433681, -0.03825090453028679, -0.07278545200824738, 0.027642086148262024, 0.04411859065294266, -0.05545663461089134, -0.008285763673484325, 0.04403408244252205, 0.01502232439815998, 0.0213325135409832, -0.019910205155611038, -0.004008706193417311, -0.054381363093853, -0.0670253112912178, -0.02704058215022087, 0.009843562729656696, -0.018159568309783936, -0.0035951221361756325, -0.03423762321472168, 0.009604200720787048, 0.02669970691204071 ]
<blockquote> <blockquote> <blockquote> <blockquote> <p>Here the problem states to find the steady state charges on the condensers.&lt;&lt;&lt;&lt; <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/5MwH2.png" alt="enter image description here"></p> </blockquote> </blockquote> </blockquote> </blockquote> <p>According to me the charges on second at steady must be zero else there would be some current in the resistance in it's parallel(which can't be true because then $C$ too will have current in it and it will not be steady state) . Is this argument correct or there would be something else in this case?</p> <h2>EDIT:additional question</h2> <p>How does the charge initially that started accumulating on the $2C$ capacitor goes away at steady state? </p> <p>Initially the capacitor does not pose resistance so, maximum charges pass through the capacitor instead of the resistance.But finally the charge on it is zero,please explain what happens in mean time.</p>
g1610
[ 0.0766160637140274, 0.008413389325141907, 0.013512705452740192, -0.012613317929208279, 0.09908894449472427, -0.01037505641579628, 0.07004719972610474, 0.023476717993617058, -0.04315243661403656, -0.01777772232890129, -0.053957242518663406, 0.02946341037750244, -0.08203594386577606, 0.04834946617484093, 0.030056321993470192, 0.010286237113177776, 0.05265308916568756, -0.00842001847922802, 0.0286388099193573, -0.0074875736609101295, 0.017423780634999275, -0.05258689075708389, -0.01555748749524355, -0.016359595581889153, -0.05082203075289726, -0.008978979662060738, 0.03823523595929146, 0.0038108990993350744, -0.045856524258852005, -0.041416458785533905, -0.004734010435640812, 0.01599942333996296, 0.02183094434440136, -0.02184639871120453, -0.04036933556199074, -0.015109434723854065, 0.05853874236345291, 0.01232181116938591, 0.0159438569098711, 0.0001596240181243047, 0.04653722792863846, 0.005329648964107037, 0.006214347202330828, 0.01779753901064396, -0.02304266206920147, -0.01990828476846218, -0.007362316828221083, 0.00238800304941833, -0.05213017016649246, -0.04049311578273773, 0.01783088408410549, 0.039771657437086105, 0.06441962718963623, 0.007416927721351385, 0.008526820689439774, 0.03896234557032585, -0.011069163680076599, 0.011704555712640285, 0.008666246198117733, 0.01383910421282053, -0.0027302801609039307, 0.013576952740550041, 0.06313055008649826, -0.019015781581401825, 0.029319623485207558, -0.058576177805662155, -0.007069175597280264, 0.018592845648527145, 0.009296036325395107, 0.10082241892814636, -0.04385538026690483, -0.08498233556747437, -0.020134087651968002, -0.018989184871315956, -0.03563511371612549, 0.021894000470638275, 0.0624956451356411, -0.027984444051980972, 0.041986916214227676, -0.031467974185943604, -0.07891795039176941, -0.05291939899325371, 0.06591081619262695, -0.008792110718786716, 0.0744817927479744, -0.011408942751586437, -0.007079260423779488, 0.02886595018208027, -0.06367941200733185, -0.021109137684106827, -0.06807134300470352, -0.01334003359079361, 0.0932130217552185, 0.024124586954712868, 0.03916672617197037, -0.06416617333889008, -0.05732157081365585, 0.010239056311547756, -0.028074325993657112, 0.024363800883293152, -0.060488011687994, -0.01861419901251793, 0.016745558008551598, 0.03805553913116455, -0.005034307949244976, 0.01573454774916172, 0.05216050520539284, 0.03653302788734436, -0.02336730621755123, -0.0687485784292221, 0.04005241021513939, 0.014744476415216923, -0.019606109708547592, -0.0036465320736169815, -0.044366661459207535, 0.014124413020908833, 0.05367133766412735, -0.015907589346170425, 0.02589109167456627, 0.0026535403449088335, -0.016345402225852013, 0.013447096571326256, -0.025608709082007408, 0.020307421684265137, 0.01924142614006996, 0.026110760867595673, 0.05506472662091255, 0.000020712046534754336, 0.02140488661825657, 0.04831460863351822, 0.04603717848658562, 0.03433775156736374, -0.002824504394084215, 0.003325853031128645, -0.025681691244244576, -0.001388860517181456, 0.010076019912958145, -0.02373102866113186, 0.03824050351977348, -0.0367647260427475, 0.02398011088371277, -0.03842286393046379, 0.03777727484703064, -0.00986000057309866, 0.013883855193853378, -0.01414270605891943, -0.018769649788737297, 0.022442033514380455, 0.064352847635746, -0.002914935117587447, -0.014873959124088287, 0.07273517549037933, 0.05790585279464722, 0.00781522411853075, -0.003140979679301381, 0.006355299614369869, 0.070149727165699, -0.02422119677066803, 0.0012355324579402804, 0.030506731942296028, -0.0034658496733754873, 0.012430512346327305, -0.03673172742128372, -0.010271257720887661, -0.06102193519473076, 0.01728321984410286, -0.01210413035005331, -0.03513150289654732, -0.015652811154723167, -0.01565474458038807, -0.043744951486587524, 0.006404718849807978, -0.005898780655115843, 0.059645362198352814, 0.07247937470674515, -0.00027265536482445896, 0.03657990321516991, 0.029157904908061028, 0.08741317689418793, -0.02917388081550598, 0.009082471951842308, 0.0525553822517395, 0.0365593284368515, -0.04347943514585495, -0.0012086016358807683, -0.029525302350521088, -0.042729005217552185, 0.03491275757551193, 0.003791236551478505, -0.052830491214990616, -0.003716099541634321, 0.06443417072296143, -0.01917024701833725, 0.04157218709588051, -0.046811092644929886, -0.021529793739318848, 0.007633592467755079, -0.03823778033256531, 0.008252114988863468, -0.058164045214653015, 0.03163931891322136, -0.00433550588786602, 0.05141579359769821, 0.0068659596145153046, -0.016713494434952736, 0.04137096926569939, -0.016309980303049088, -0.0446559339761734, 0.05787727236747742, 0.015840889886021614, 0.00020854575268458575, -0.009609142318367958, -0.05820933356881142, 0.030356360599398613, 0.006641428917646408, -0.046681709587574005, 0.013594795018434525, 0.010012771002948284, -0.028089147061109543, 0.02977164089679718, -0.00485371146351099, 0.00103118852712214, 0.0029168089386075735, 0.027503512799739838, -0.01788339577615261, -0.004690764006227255, -0.014227044768631458, -0.021163033321499825, -0.051923494786024094, 0.013453644700348377, -0.011584382504224777, -0.0011336860479786992, -0.008965515531599522, 0.003355636028572917, 0.006937819067388773, 0.018093710765242577, -0.010902722366154194, 0.028868451714515686, -0.03470063582062721, 0.005618801340460777, -0.004235193133354187, -0.05536616966128349, -0.02156263031065464, 0.007882285863161087, 0.029476257041096687, -0.0238372553139925, 0.01965150237083435, 0.007744594011455774, -0.016477294266223907, -0.010660293512046337, 0.06841181218624115, -0.019343778491020203, -0.04281603917479515, 0.033790793269872665, -0.010223882272839546, -0.06874117255210876, 0.02230505459010601, -0.008738203905522823, -0.028010688722133636, -0.06139791011810303, -0.01839233748614788, -0.054641470313072205, 0.004799218848347664, 0.03722570091485977, -0.06465820223093033, -0.005689654033631086, -0.049488626420497894, 0.02060958743095398, 0.03538641706109047, -0.0005315899616107345, -0.017854703590273857, 0.04196685552597046, -0.016076212748885155, -0.00003856209514196962, -0.01875525712966919, 0.009724553674459457, 0.012190370820462704, -0.007825925946235657, 0.014562208205461502, -0.0071700639091432095, -0.006493831053376198, 0.04370010644197464, -0.016648389399051666, -0.028147483244538307, 0.018708014860749245, -0.046883486211299896, -0.031661394983530045, 0.031008832156658173, 0.03580908104777336, -0.02300354093313217, -0.02779928408563137, -0.006619132123887539, 0.05476531758904457, 0.007056101690977812, 0.042464982718229294, -0.008628715761005878, 0.0470888577401638, -0.032825078815221786, -0.014439832419157028, 0.06650769710540771, 0.008098968304693699, -0.01802506111562252, 0.007074646186083555, -0.04204665869474411, 0.04485428333282471, 0.029832832515239716, 0.002362198429182172, -0.031307537108659744, -0.0050705368630588055, 0.02385205775499344, -0.01817096769809723, 0.03529498353600502, -0.010982559993863106, 0.0122067891061306, 0.028456231579184532, 0.03669421747326851, 0.007247467525303364, 0.00008497368253301829, -0.00614364817738533, -0.02505258470773697, 0.014268693514168262, -0.006558276247233152, 0.03833797946572304, 0.01683073304593563, 0.009936012327671051, 0.03047315403819084, -0.062255859375, 0.008058184757828712, -0.04419029876589775, -0.025222301483154297, 0.06300799548625946, 0.0410589762032032, 0.012986906804144382, -0.012433068826794624, 0.020690321922302246, -0.05226285010576248, -0.014009998179972172, 0.06354769319295883, 0.0262440275400877, 0.029307888820767403, -0.02017304301261902, 0.01101478561758995, -0.07282702624797821, -0.04615326598286629, -0.030834252014756203, -0.044856958091259, -0.03195926547050476, -0.03560689091682434, -0.02033407986164093, -0.024727249518036842, 0.08933945745229721, -0.011342600919306278, -0.007994644343852997, 0.03189903497695923, -0.04968467354774475, -0.05107047036290169, -0.014074927195906639, 0.00781515333801508, -0.07781445980072021, 0.06360429525375366, 0.016497226431965828, -0.03339701145887375, 0.07155276089906693, 0.059212010353803635, 0.007049745414406061, -0.05653945356607437, -0.054004739969968796, 0.05317102372646332, 0.0008073275675997138, -0.08678730577230453, 0.004587854724377394, 0.03541887551546097, -0.008480928838253021, 0.016562819480895996, -0.0034297772217541933, -0.04603510722517967, -0.007807502523064613, 0.011286464519798756, -0.050372280180454254, 0.0925481915473938, -0.018778366968035698, -0.038780465722084045, -0.05608641356229782, -0.013406740501523018, -0.024352753534913063, 0.03825518488883972, 0.024620916694402695, 0.03626998886466026, -0.014322980307042599, -0.04001312330365181, -0.005733704660087824, 0.002618868136778474, -0.013624031096696854, 0.0038924424443393946, -0.008236903697252274, -0.02838900312781334, 0.028683748096227646, -0.028754262253642082, 0.011182713322341442, -0.006293409038335085, -0.023103103041648865, -0.028255479410290718, 0.002610086929053068, 0.0008067172602750361, 0.02357749454677105, -0.019248440861701965, 0.03543088212609291, -0.03918599337339401, 0.03944981098175049, 0.021397637203335762, -0.007884141989052296, -0.010159441269934177, -0.02487904392182827, -0.03793909400701523, 0.01608373038470745, -0.0790676698088646, 0.034410711377859116, 0.023334600031375885, 0.042485568672418594, 0.00895469170063734, -0.003455893835052848, 0.005995249375700951, 0.005517005920410156, -0.049597904086112976, 0.07325564324855804, 0.014977174811065197, 0.02918357402086258, 0.016402194276452065, 0.004636174067854881, -0.021387875080108643, -0.0035848149564117193, 0.033928032964468, -0.004128511995077133, 0.06312812119722366, -0.02777126617729664, 0.06629419326782227, 0.009199931286275387, 0.009930710308253765, -0.08548951894044876, 0.05026622116565704, 0.019187232479453087, 0.04209543764591217, -0.010819941759109497, -0.0014655853156000376, -0.024224121123552322, 0.04639421030879021, -0.04616215452551842, -0.01492256484925747, 0.012291738763451576, -0.047350186854600906, -0.027241241186857224, 0.0005629712832160294, -0.02824774943292141, 0.02848055027425289, -0.016706569120287895, 0.0010111110750585794, 0.008111181668937206, 0.006521641276776791, -0.022170167416334152, 0.07013127207756042, -0.016822464764118195, 0.008530471473932266, 0.03603015094995499, -0.057321224361658096, -0.0191262885928154, -0.07135994732379913, -0.0065350946970283985, -0.0549326129257679, -0.04565563052892685, -0.051395684480667114, 0.025008803233504295, -0.0018313371110707521, 0.04458073154091835, 0.04565387964248657, -0.00576862134039402, -0.05295412614941597, 0.044352494180202484, 0.05640582740306854, -0.023713156580924988, 0.06694798171520233, -0.02594761550426483, 0.013222837820649147, -0.01011800579726696, 0.015565807931125164, -0.03191395103931427, -0.014983982779085636, -0.01207095105201006, 0.004779218230396509, -0.009791851975023746, -0.030206354334950447, 0.02351532131433487, 0.07052034139633179, 0.02158886380493641, 0.04169231653213501, 0.022146102041006088, 0.00801949854940176, -0.0037736771628260612, 0.02834228053689003, -0.007399346213787794, 0.023266496136784554, 0.004822649527341127, 0.02392488345503807, 0.051450882107019424, 0.043011222034692764, -0.020564788952469826, 0.046653784811496735, 0.0501728318631649, -0.040520381182432175, 0.02953106164932251, 0.014645891264081001, -0.042188841849565506, 0.056119922548532486, 0.05128020793199539, 0.028491297736763954, 0.006565656512975693, 0.053926482796669006, -0.028514398261904716, -0.05113116279244423, -0.05178550258278847, 0.003105437383055687, 0.047132622450590134, 0.018149688839912415, 0.03341779485344887, -0.005037069320678711, -0.05118278041481972, -0.03552602231502533, -0.025554794818162918, -0.03559157997369766, -0.0011979510309174657, 0.06926693767309189, -0.017651205882430077, 0.004861083347350359, -0.00664480309933424, -0.058846525847911835, 0.0039063128642737865, -0.019033728167414665, -0.030273249372839928, -0.018336450681090355, 0.006789258681237698, 0.01972872018814087, 0.010751909576356411, -0.042871393263339996, -0.027025919407606125, 0.10148638486862183, 0.004202024545520544, -0.021673651412129402, -0.004491577390581369, -0.0058639878407120705, 0.056280434131622314, -0.06585144996643066, -0.0403013601899147, 0.038579460233449936, -0.023373637348413467, 0.020417576655745506, 0.02227209508419037, 0.015231423079967499, -0.010193578898906708, -0.011738602072000504, -0.02311454527080059, -0.010113639757037163, 0.008674832992255688, 0.04126688092947006, 0.02950635924935341, 0.027766361832618713, -0.030438357964158058, -0.0029544683638960123, -0.04635993391275406, 0.039715614169836044, 0.06263487040996552, 0.0062113311141729355, 0.02914855070412159, -0.01734505221247673, 0.040901970118284225, -0.024854445829987526, 0.02421056479215622, 0.022868843749165535, -0.08427638560533524, 0.05034733563661575, 0.02659253589808941, 0.018476596102118492, -0.020764339715242386, 0.029464395716786385, 0.029104603454470634, 0.004437537863850594, 0.06252052634954453, 0.05930061638355255, -0.009563896805047989, -0.031009303405880928, 0.014818352647125721, 0.027238918468356133, -0.05995133891701698, 0.025031188502907753, 0.03176829591393471, -0.0176237802952528, 0.045520830899477005, -0.023577842861413956, 0.014221242628991604, 0.0015161442570388317, -0.0414990559220314, -0.040681712329387665, 0.02024570293724537, 0.030635718256235123, 0.0532202422618866, 0.001058768481016159, -0.0028400574810802937, 0.029807215556502342, -0.011976168490946293, -0.008930371142923832, -0.041810523718595505, 0.02599439211189747, -0.08975476771593094, -0.02586439624428749, 0.019645560532808304, -0.030055545270442963, -0.0013934492599219084, -0.02638525888323784, 0.02045680582523346, 0.08267879486083984, -0.05053027346730232, 0.02404177375137806, 0.10494466125965118, 0.04721474274992943, -0.018855610862374306, 0.006930713541805744, 0.037493232637643814, 0.08683434873819351, -0.0016743162414059043, -0.0325264111161232, 0.0930740162730217, 0.008549878373742104, -0.003240747842937708, -0.003621072042733431, 0.01754826121032238, -0.02323778346180916, 0.019268739968538284, 0.009976092725992203, -0.05383962392807007, 0.004933428950607777, 0.0017606790643185377, -0.0036920816637575626, 0.03967365249991417, 0.019435400143265724, 0.02129209041595459, -0.010335704311728477, 0.0011027477448806167, -0.02141864039003849, 0.034612368792295456, 0.006453528534621, -0.03639409318566322, -0.026867661625146866, 0.007438880857080221, -0.06807146221399307, 0.053496453911066055, 0.030425094068050385, -0.06510215252637863, -0.010146780870854855, 0.0624532550573349, 0.0020125447772443295, 0.026170065626502037, -0.003007424995303154, -0.03589843586087227, -0.04098067432641983, -0.0594884492456913, -0.009029862470924854, 0.010409105569124222, 0.022233981639146805, -0.026537107303738594, -0.0363854356110096, 0.03268695995211601, -0.09363754093647003, -0.023700805380940437, -0.09352068603038788, -0.04037611559033394, -0.04085203632712364, 0.056962642818689346, -0.036581020802259445, 0.04974590241909027, 0.0015302570536732674, -0.0014481486286967993, -0.03761427477002144, 0.011223725974559784, -0.007692723069339991, -0.005356489215046167, -0.017565269023180008, -0.01566227898001671, 0.04552168771624565, -0.02943340316414833, 0.008102409541606903, 0.00788807962089777, -0.009577368386089802, 0.06038787588477135, 0.012026327662169933, 0.034546058624982834, 0.007295882795006037, -0.03241425007581711, 0.022774305194616318, -0.03797851875424385, 0.03699836879968643, 0.050634872168302536, -0.05073925480246544, -0.00028743341681547463, -0.042272474616765976, 0.017782216891646385, 0.0013759583234786987, -0.009093656204640865, 0.0003544727514963597, -0.061173465102910995, -0.06773573160171509, -0.006919699255377054, -0.008247677236795425, -0.024460287764668465, 0.034726645797491074, -0.01830478385090828, -0.036105357110500336, -0.009853793308138847, -0.029000507667660713, -0.07828350365161896, -0.0628170445561409, -0.0410376600921154, -0.00848095491528511, -0.09140575677156448, -0.04915415868163109, -0.02623298391699791, 0.007474760990589857, 0.008547387085855007, -0.013167413882911205, -0.0536729097366333, 0.05516690015792847, -0.04919789731502533, 0.03348320350050926, -0.010049433447420597, -0.031794290989637375, 0.009898229502141476, 0.004551480524241924, -0.003977869171649218, -0.011363138444721699, 0.04656452313065529, 0.016499031335115433, 0.024189934134483337, -0.020157763734459877, -0.03363117575645447, -0.043800581246614456, -0.04043648764491081, -0.040488820523023605, 0.02341797575354576, -0.019079094752669334, -0.03964858502149582, 0.007976808585226536, 0.0558401383459568, -0.030910402536392212, 0.09709891676902771, -0.015086662955582142, -0.04725613072514534, -0.010994480922818184, -0.0002079470723401755, -0.04466252774000168, 0.029560375958681107, 0.009611186571419239, 0.016637640073895454, -0.0018034849781543016, -0.03342343866825104, -0.024138404056429863, -0.04941779747605324, -0.022583963349461555, 0.08197497576475143, -0.07289831340312958, -0.058646779507398605, -0.04874148219823837 ]
<p>I’m trying to convince my boss that the mixers we are using are too much. I’m trying to prove that we are over-mixing our product. Our product is ink…just your basic ink found in your printer at home. We mix in a 23 inch diameter 50 gallon vessel using a 2.75 inch diameter axial flow impeller going at 1050 rpm with a 3 inch rotor stator 5 inches below it. The inks have a viscosity of around 3. What Reynolds number should be sufficient for this process or can you give me any further input? Any help would be GREATLY appreciated. Thanks.</p>
g1611
[ 0.0050127157010138035, 0.023198457434773445, -0.00250787241384387, -0.05722878500819206, 0.009067720733582973, -0.0230562686920166, 0.03202657774090767, -0.013025927357375622, -0.02469029650092125, 0.012343848124146461, 0.033557504415512085, 0.03868358954787254, -0.02623014710843563, 0.04208242893218994, 0.03981450945138931, -0.018304893746972084, 0.019207114353775978, -0.028891565278172493, -0.013763891533017159, 0.05206023529171944, -0.014838718809187412, -0.004143178462982178, -0.001477368758060038, 0.02927234396338463, -0.00398910092189908, -0.08656692504882812, -0.039108362048864365, -0.011346633546054363, -0.05193613842129707, 0.03352484107017517, 0.02080082893371582, 0.030967343598604202, -0.029477015137672424, -0.03805447742342949, -0.02826075628399849, -0.022240007296204567, -0.02527092583477497, 0.03677643835544586, 0.040456511080265045, -0.01386076770722866, -0.022653300315141678, 0.02537897415459156, -0.0012213753070682287, -0.005525665357708931, 0.0018636013846844435, -0.012898552231490612, 0.043574415147304535, 0.013777732849121094, -0.022472470998764038, -0.025656048208475113, -0.0161073449999094, -0.07812052220106125, -0.03644753620028496, 0.036159202456474304, -0.04167528823018074, 0.010296843014657497, -0.028337230905890465, 0.014674948528409004, -0.04796416684985161, 0.050119198858737946, -0.011403672397136688, -0.053784266114234924, -0.036569803953170776, 0.033734388649463654, -0.03441575542092323, 0.01139425951987505, 0.041686251759529114, -0.023148944601416588, 0.03790886327624321, 0.011117993853986263, 0.0060181813314557076, -0.059122487902641296, 0.06618976593017578, -0.02031177282333374, -0.04779202863574028, 0.00020192093506921083, -0.00013002118794247508, 0.00026005806284956634, 0.10305575281381607, -0.013200548477470875, 0.046668943017721176, 0.04643062502145767, 0.03798610717058182, -0.0966368317604065, 0.049520909786224365, 0.0044848499819636345, 0.006704607512801886, -0.03487532213330269, 0.005115977488458157, -0.008683760650455952, 0.048263728618621826, -0.04624631628394127, -0.008833947591483593, -0.003129340708255768, 0.05563419684767723, -0.00010451117850607261, -0.02746337465941906, 0.04342188313603401, -0.0008080768748186529, 0.003856068942695856, 0.011946956627070904, -0.0007388024241663516, 0.017816748470067978, -0.03697558864951134, -0.04144248366355896, 0.059355493634939194, 0.07385759055614471, 0.03627854585647583, 0.0183059424161911, -0.047228287905454636, -0.033102549612522125, -0.05385272949934006, -0.012059326283633709, -0.020447097718715668, -0.0013562332605943084, -0.008013295941054821, 0.03599490970373154, 0.03951354697346687, -0.010203376412391663, -0.0326467901468277, 0.031354524195194244, -0.026938587427139282, -0.030028583481907845, -0.0001290170766878873, 0.020200124010443687, 0.02134804055094719, 0.020598823204636574, 0.03948185220360756, 0.02620788849890232, 0.03719078749418259, 0.043937548995018005, -0.011625741608440876, 0.003887047292664647, -0.03578892722725868, 0.03250529244542122, 0.004196277353912592, 0.01292282436043024, -0.011403588578104973, -0.03839769959449768, -0.009055058471858501, 0.07510712742805481, -0.00966683030128479, 0.04241522029042244, 0.03513387590646744, -0.018468689173460007, -0.009652283973991871, 0.021062908694148064, -0.03357130289077759, 0.02333867736160755, -0.00212892796844244, -0.01623351499438286, -0.059258732944726944, 0.04940056428313255, 0.020060645416378975, -0.04059850797057152, 0.019822020083665848, -0.023551668971776962, 0.012552986852824688, 0.013459495268762112, 0.02839449793100357, -0.006493968423455954, -0.015250587835907936, 0.011204942129552364, -0.0498528815805912, -0.04287513718008995, 0.028630468994379044, -0.02945680357515812, 0.012893538922071457, -0.07348775118589401, 0.08241409063339233, -0.03370847553014755, -0.008112946525216103, 0.004939468577504158, -0.07964523881673813, -0.024249548092484474, -0.0033932167571038008, 0.0887034460902214, -0.03528257831931114, -0.0014339130138978362, 0.038076870143413544, 0.0284836757928133, -0.018972288817167282, 0.06218596547842026, -0.03656378015875816, 0.0514821857213974, 0.014952585101127625, 0.007596771232783794, -0.05205010250210762, -0.08451572805643082, 0.04391339793801308, 0.001072246814146638, 0.011004534550011158, 0.024923140183091164, -0.011389091610908508, -0.07501906156539917, -0.0015330063179135323, 0.0010702494764700532, -0.041670218110084534, -0.08263004571199417, -0.000358480290742591, 0.0055374084040522575, -0.028647875413298607, 0.009958254173398018, 0.042818959802389145, -0.0028084758669137955, -0.01464897021651268, -0.028169328346848488, 0.06014947220683098, 0.0010708977933973074, 0.01259553711861372, -0.03514866158366203, -0.024513844400644302, -0.039510663598775864, 0.006859404034912586, 0.03128939867019653, -0.016263486817479134, 0.0656939372420311, 0.03871951252222061, -0.03826383873820305, 0.033129673451185226, 0.02694854512810707, -0.07749728858470917, 0.03409632295370102, 0.02366923913359642, -0.031686991453170776, 0.02066916599869728, 0.03617927432060242, 0.016528060659766197, 0.050890710204839706, 0.0065806894563138485, 0.05097299441695213, -0.04197553172707558, -0.0006588255055248737, -0.038558587431907654, -0.05367391183972359, -0.002521099988371134, -0.019118979573249817, 0.016600966453552246, -0.03247224539518356, 0.05212506279349327, -0.005734013859182596, 0.05721144378185272, -0.05245430767536163, 0.003292561275884509, -0.00045124522875994444, -0.011968765407800674, -0.0020169506315141916, -0.03828611224889755, 0.020650653168559074, 0.009431841783225536, 0.013291731476783752, -0.044247817248106, 0.03456776961684227, 0.013480965979397297, 0.022811004891991615, 0.0773514062166214, 0.018141157925128937, 0.018676239997148514, -0.014188609085977077, 0.027156803756952286, -0.006752141285687685, 0.05244278535246849, 0.020752152428030968, 0.012978221289813519, -0.07102525234222412, -0.007967439480125904, -0.05895775556564331, 0.0015461475122720003, 0.07010174542665482, 0.0506945364177227, 0.034614790230989456, -0.03405200317502022, -0.006883555557578802, 0.001417210209183395, 0.026474488899111748, -0.012507324106991291, -0.027439802885055542, 0.01998119242489338, 0.029499482363462448, 0.0806511789560318, 0.00016757765843067318, -0.018757352605462074, 0.032252341508865356, 0.0258286464959383, -0.02417941950261593, -0.019800221547484398, -0.0195630956441164, 0.05832459405064583, -0.00126757996622473, 0.053426824510097504, -0.01784672401845455, 0.08097513020038605, -0.059117745608091354, -0.04352976381778717, 0.01707613281905651, 0.044629182666540146, 0.05375986546278, -0.028493868187069893, 0.056634243577718735, -0.0027619479224085808, 0.029876599088311195, 0.04251058027148247, -0.06617359071969986, 0.0016818869626149535, 0.02998405694961548, 0.010523736476898193, -0.013744138181209564, 0.024667566642165184, -0.01906297355890274, 0.016649216413497925, -0.004720006138086319, -0.04396245256066322, -0.016345009207725525, -0.008805040270090103, 0.002549504628404975, 0.0193218644708395, 0.016653617843985558, -0.012363146990537643, 0.015939196571707726, -0.005511560011655092, -0.01829623617231846, -0.0038631693460047245, 0.041535504162311554, -0.010968176648020744, 0.007557370699942112, 0.010910865850746632, 0.04588978737592697, 0.042836446315050125, -0.04365990683436394, 0.012895921245217323, 0.024940023198723793, 0.013839426450431347, 0.0020035351626574993, 0.04547901079058647, 0.07538124173879623, 0.016772393137216568, 0.013094821944832802, -0.0027182623744010925, -0.012827042490243912, 0.0030607490334659815, 0.02903779037296772, 0.03168720379471779, 0.01870252750813961, -0.07763738185167313, -0.026587022468447685, 0.02395206317305565, 0.011232749558985233, 0.05144377052783966, -0.03609701246023178, -0.00458153709769249, 0.07933282852172852, -0.02364133857190609, -0.020001670345664024, -0.0610455721616745, 0.010806203819811344, 0.0055878907442092896, 0.039026785641908646, 0.06566023081541061, -0.014462471939623356, 0.0104520907625556, -0.006308176554739475, 0.024711597710847855, -0.009620461612939835, -0.05061578378081322, 0.0021944388281553984, 0.03002104163169861, 0.011063575744628906, -0.034193795174360275, -0.03955083340406418, -0.011994915083050728, -0.055492501705884933, -0.04024293273687363, 0.0046125841327011585, -0.013916685245931149, -0.06294608116149902, -0.0336880199611187, 0.06340565532445908, 0.04860347881913185, 0.013438357040286064, -0.0017507156589999795, 0.019202660769224167, 0.058573175221681595, -0.08571736514568329, -0.010902851819992065, -0.027763640508055687, 0.011707128956913948, -0.03724834695458412, 0.023072712123394012, -0.00950896181166172, -0.05340084061026573, -0.011264871805906296, -0.08786367624998093, -0.0276010911911726, -0.04465743154287338, 0.022086815908551216, 0.011035677045583725, 0.009997593238949776, -0.012633753009140491, -0.01677507348358631, 0.020440781489014626, 0.0046120937913656235, -0.024022480472922325, 0.023914871737360954, 0.04227269068360329, -0.012968811206519604, -0.0003421292349230498, 0.013969514518976212, 0.01660200208425522, -0.011656835675239563, 0.006054613273590803, 0.032264307141304016, 0.04046747833490372, -0.02798091620206833, -0.017649292945861816, -0.06428591161966324, -0.019628051668405533, -0.03939182311296463, -0.01635606959462166, 0.007281050086021423, 0.0023366992827504873, -0.026710741221904755, 0.04471571743488312, -0.010877333581447601, 0.02266908809542656, -0.03282630443572998, 0.023712635040283203, 0.027392279356718063, -0.025986837223172188, 0.024937935173511505, -0.02697613276541233, 0.015018467791378498, 0.010079056955873966, -0.04296204820275307, 0.06471939384937286, 0.05431632697582245, 0.0038787606172263622, 0.05198144540190697, 0.00806636642664671, 0.045328207314014435, -0.05710214003920555, -0.04091263189911842, 0.01975918374955654, -0.011990143917500973, -0.006058792117983103, -0.022349119186401367, 0.05427226051688194, -0.00111667241435498, -0.031774867326021194, -0.024980677291750908, 0.025825999677181244, 0.01880713179707527, 0.04489651322364807, -0.03907054290175438, -0.02093033865094185, -0.04169052839279175, 0.06386979669332504, -0.04644232615828514, -0.024582011625170708, -0.02854170836508274, -0.02071978896856308, 0.007195683661848307, 0.04365043342113495, 0.06502752006053925, -0.03403870761394501, -0.003910430707037449, 0.008221008814871311, 0.02644830197095871, -0.04755670949816704, -0.06636831909418106, -0.06814724951982498, -0.005713168065994978, -0.02055227942764759, 0.06957604736089706, 0.05383594334125519, -0.02039579674601555, 0.03204457834362984, -0.009264497086405754, -0.0013273857766762376, -0.035479698330163956, -0.005178090650588274, 0.05869639664888382, 0.015263086184859276, 0.010510052554309368, 0.022551093250513077, 0.023067263886332512, -0.030143078416585922, -0.02817404270172119, -0.06430300325155258, 0.061663467437028885, -0.018784480169415474, 0.009654670022428036, 0.039263904094696045, -0.016405384987592697, -0.013864795677363873, -0.04924381524324417, 0.03142867237329483, 0.010117786936461926, -0.05361570790410042, 0.017244871705770493, 0.0143473194912076, -0.005727055482566357, -0.019735505804419518, -0.02777385525405407, -0.01362417172640562, -0.035578396171331406, -0.07028071582317352, -0.040069419890642166, -0.009432482533156872, -0.00990581139922142, 0.0734163150191307, 0.024443423375487328, -0.05053633451461792, 0.05928182229399681, -0.03344094380736351, -0.00856148824095726, 0.007753702346235514, 0.030872324481606483, 0.012778932228684425, -0.019967341795563698, 0.003202856983989477, 0.05191408470273018, -0.016707221046090126, 0.04737500846385956, -0.0023146693129092455, -0.07194718718528748, 0.02013378031551838, -0.061159320175647736, 0.015099316835403442, 0.027881326153874397, 0.021466871723532677, -0.026572180911898613, 0.07134686410427094, -0.007767078001052141, 0.028710324317216873, -0.034238699823617935, 0.010219267569482327, 0.08298282325267792, 0.037069566547870636, 0.040759678930044174, 0.04079738259315491, -0.0014071783516556025, -0.008428639732301235, -0.05683495104312897, 0.025385767221450806, -0.01644197478890419, 0.00011517309758346528, 0.012042836286127567, -0.0029029082506895065, 0.021336421370506287, -0.05909658968448639, 0.03152758255600929, -0.000301223190035671, 0.049588512629270554, 0.0036807763390243053, 0.024009760469198227, -0.026171650737524033, 0.0008554770611226559, 0.015456692315638065, 0.07642824202775955, 0.040694065392017365, 0.03221098333597183, 0.0013684482546523213, 0.007613667286932468, 0.022374756634235382, -0.015677230432629585, -0.011771471239626408, -0.03493451327085495, 0.010818199254572392, -0.013752770610153675, 0.016125408932566643, -0.06376717239618301, -0.04616948217153549, 0.011586816981434822, -0.012155395932495594, 0.09452623873949051, 0.014143342152237892, 0.021960172802209854, -0.015523599460721016, -0.025476405397057533, 0.017631934955716133, -0.02824455499649048, 0.007007270120084286, -0.019995039328932762, -0.027023322880268097, -0.017478276044130325, 0.012834296561777592, -0.03926130011677742, 0.03697546198964119, -0.05683809146285057, 0.002371781272813678, -0.038455162197351456, -0.06443322449922562, 0.03383275866508484, -0.02094939537346363, 0.032155510038137436, -0.01570768468081951, -0.035992249846458435, 0.027829868718981743, 0.014819270931184292, -0.006511936895549297, -0.009586906991899014, 0.0030393677297979593, -0.0035900757648050785, 0.009753305464982986, -0.05300034582614899, -0.031688522547483444, -0.04231037572026253, -0.0009747350122779608, -0.10258720815181732, 0.03622710704803467, 0.02538452111184597, -0.04774760082364082, 0.014335638843476772, 0.003936626482754946, -0.004537360742688179, 0.0022012759000062943, 0.03681563213467598, -0.019960254430770874, 0.0345279723405838, -0.04005284979939461, 0.004586417227983475, -0.05621722713112831, 0.034475576132535934, 0.06190416216850281, -0.008711550384759903, -0.04537074267864227, -0.01680079475045204, -0.013834064826369286, 0.05429697036743164, 0.004583971109241247, 0.0666995421051979, -0.0048753125593066216, 0.04537993669509888, -0.0021648332476615906, 0.010193203575909138, -0.07368706166744232, -0.05650363117456436, 0.018122870475053787, -0.011898779310286045, 0.09814086556434631, -0.02060806192457676, 0.04037678241729736, 0.014553715474903584, 0.06767662614583969, -0.018869170919060707, -0.04462619498372078, 0.04934435337781906, 0.03914522007107735, -0.016450291499495506, -0.015488110482692719, 0.02965955063700676, -0.016824422404170036, -0.01914341002702713, 0.005132400430738926, -0.03077554516494274, 0.02596745267510414, 0.0008229006780311465, 0.02258143573999405, 0.01907697319984436, -0.023905914276838303, 0.07821600884199142, 0.014023756608366966, -0.0061522554606199265, -0.019084729254245758, -0.027443239465355873, 0.060091231018304825, -0.03749050199985504, 0.01822362095117569, -0.021189948543906212, -0.07972059398889542, -0.03328460082411766, -0.003928895574063063, -0.0897340327501297, 0.018496766686439514, 0.029392356052994728, -0.04152950644493103, 0.026261577382683754, 0.009530800394713879, 0.00022731730132363737, -0.012286634184420109, 0.009488372132182121, 0.0038446099497377872, -0.035243548452854156, 0.051423631608486176, -0.06411835551261902, -0.001869714236818254, -0.031534869223833084, -0.011533270590007305, -0.0009717600769363344, 0.011060500517487526, -0.008765078149735928, 0.010844667442142963, 0.03527172654867172, 0.00612327316775918, -0.0537613108754158, 0.06237846612930298, -0.008605037815868855, 0.01069986168295145, 0.042148977518081665, 0.05533302202820778, 0.0628250390291214, -0.0056256200186908245, 0.009089694358408451, 0.08162173628807068, -0.04229538142681122, 0.008273802697658539, 0.037145525217056274, -0.05399930104613304, -0.005478371866047382, -0.07062823325395584, -0.03765222430229187, -0.008212858811020851, -0.04476821795105934, 0.01247982494533062, -0.003972211387008429, -0.030277086421847343, -0.035303276032209396, -0.08729466050863266, -0.03316720202565193, -0.02545016258955002, 0.0037756117526441813, 0.07739274203777313, 0.01588144712150097, -0.029891792684793472, -0.029708579182624817, -0.1173308938741684, 0.0016072761500254273, -0.06234079971909523, -0.021974414587020874, -0.016827672719955444, -0.044773317873477936, -0.016794154420495033, -0.0645718052983284, 0.09091711789369583, -0.03894218057394028, -0.025388551875948906, 0.0340355709195137, 0.007915659807622433, -0.04885225370526314, 0.03141384944319725, 0.015683358535170555, -0.0030571746174246073, -0.04268087074160576, 0.03228732943534851, -0.015002401545643806, -0.021491462364792824, -0.002457774244248867, 0.031115811318159103, -0.04729687422513962, -0.023650307208299637, 0.05033191293478012, 0.0011581178987398744, 0.04926912486553192, 0.023715484887361526, 0.021466856822371483, -0.10360409319400787, 0.016783520579338074, 0.047035206109285355, -0.04622110351920128, -0.051243118941783905, 0.0006359211984090507, 0.042095888406038284, -0.006996989715844393, -0.02801477536559105, -0.030091043561697006, 0.0012750431196764112, -0.011644454672932625, -0.05812166631221771 ]
<p>I would like to write a Gaussian state with density matrix $\rho$ (single mode) as a squeezed, displaced thermal state: \begin{gather} \rho = \hat{S}(\zeta) \hat{D}(\alpha) \rho_{\bar{n}} \hat{D}^\dagger(\alpha) \hat{S}^\dagger(\zeta) . \end{gather} Here, \begin{gather} \rho_{\bar{n}} = \int_{\mathbb{C}} P_{\bar{n}}(\alpha) |\alpha\rangle\langle\alpha|d\alpha \text{ with } P_{\bar{n}}(\alpha) = \frac{1}{\pi \bar{n}} e^{- |\alpha|^2 / \bar{n}} \end{gather} is a thermal state with occupation $\bar{n}$, \begin{gather} \hat{S}(\zeta) = e^{(\zeta^* \hat{a}^2 + \zeta \hat{a}^{\dagger 2}) / 2} \end{gather} is the squeezing operator, and \begin{gather} \hat{D}(\alpha) = e^{\alpha^* \hat{a} - \alpha \hat{a}^\dagger} . \end{gather} is the displacement operator. I prefer to use the convention $\hat{x} = (\hat{a} + \hat{a}^\dagger) / \sqrt{2}$ and $\hat{p} = (\hat{a} - \hat{a}^\dagger) / \sqrt{2} i$.</p> <p>I assume that the way to accomplish this is to derive the mean and variance of our Gaussian state $\rho$ and thereby determine $\zeta$ and $\alpha$. However, I have been unsuccessful in doing so. That is, given the mean and variance of our Gaussian state $\rho$, what are $\zeta$ and $\alpha$?</p> <p>On a side note, I was also wondering if there is a standard result for the commutator of $\hat{S}(\zeta)$ and $\hat{D}(\alpha)$?</p>
g1612
[ -0.05526600405573845, -0.03720508888363838, -0.03698918595910072, -0.04054799675941467, 0.014976151287555695, -0.002855502301827073, 0.025668734684586525, 0.025737041607499123, 0.018929334357380867, -0.01548940222710371, -0.032591868191957474, 0.0065812598913908005, 0.05128134787082672, -0.019621629267930984, 0.039307188242673874, 0.0470459908246994, 0.006660193204879761, 0.07498148828744888, -0.057028356939554214, 0.029061980545520782, -0.08613613992929459, -0.00044052835437469184, 0.06367673724889755, -0.031015310436487198, 0.050922371447086334, -0.08423706144094467, 0.01319255493581295, 0.02494804933667183, -0.029581574723124504, -0.03469251096248627, 0.01239038910716772, 0.0072898282669484615, 0.038393229246139526, -0.019315728917717934, -0.03249279782176018, -0.05547384172677994, 0.05845135077834129, -0.03505115583539009, -0.0340694934129715, -0.02283276803791523, -0.030219659209251404, -0.02460147999227047, 0.05777943879365921, 0.033636245876550674, 0.07148414850234985, 0.06642880290746689, -0.00613934313878417, -0.007680314593017101, -0.04591086134314537, 0.013169955462217331, 0.04565155506134033, 0.06324603408575058, 0.009710568003356457, -0.031529512256383896, 0.015764711424708366, -0.05274993181228638, -0.02670339308679104, 0.03035552427172661, 0.045072779059410095, -0.008139043115079403, 0.010945388115942478, -0.021423717960715294, -0.05494644120335579, -0.0330621562898159, -0.014172122813761234, 0.020449405536055565, 0.0021951363887637854, 0.03372083604335785, 0.027809450402855873, -0.044996146112680435, 0.031109143048524857, -0.05018336698412895, 0.049176961183547974, -0.03176024556159973, -0.006294239312410355, -0.019801948219537735, -0.003918391652405262, -0.035558540374040604, 0.0037225321866571903, -0.012138688005506992, -0.06362836807966232, -0.022380268201231956, 0.09255043417215347, -0.015304693020880222, 0.010167009197175503, -0.02129189670085907, -0.011173537001013756, 0.07145142555236816, 0.027088167145848274, 0.018008841201663017, -0.0039644609205424786, 0.03730964660644531, 0.07090619206428528, 0.06613457947969437, 0.01656733825802803, -0.010232901200652122, -0.07077667862176895, 0.007635988760739565, 0.0013224235735833645, -0.00700624892488122, 0.04415581002831459, -0.04020611196756363, -0.030806489288806915, -0.08584092557430267, 0.01569172367453575, -0.033715199679136276, -0.0032032157760113478, -0.030923165380954742, -0.003858767217025161, -0.013071557506918907, -0.04516507312655449, 0.04861222952604294, -0.01238756999373436, -0.007717275060713291, -0.008707694709300995, -0.06718719750642776, -0.02556726336479187, -0.007311909459531307, -0.02998039871454239, 0.019068364053964615, -0.008809531107544899, 0.05481572076678276, -0.025700004771351814, 0.030117208138108253, -0.004088569898158312, 0.009967513382434845, -0.03225221857428551, 0.01771697960793972, 0.005074386950582266, 0.021240264177322388, 0.0025183313991874456, -0.021765535697340965, 0.0022511756978929043, 0.05677780508995056, -0.059128180146217346, 0.04335537180304527, -0.0694705918431282, 0.01854831352829933, -0.026291601359844208, -0.0008157959673553705, 0.062190596014261246, 0.002131013898178935, -0.0420289970934391, -0.04204782843589783, 0.03844096511602402, 0.010562127456068993, -0.009900151751935482, -0.07599508762359619, -0.004499906674027443, -0.05149039253592491, 0.024950280785560608, 0.022523798048496246, -0.01646512746810913, -0.022194482386112213, 0.05828625708818436, 0.04209565743803978, 0.10270286351442337, 0.011609167791903019, 0.013276808895170689, 0.0481080636382103, 0.03527449816465378, -0.07297857105731964, 0.04378492385149002, 0.06316190212965012, 0.037932176142930984, 0.0011680368334054947, -0.01885291375219822, -0.021250834688544273, -0.01592726819217205, -0.0006981156184338033, -0.024115728214383125, -0.016906648874282837, -0.045161280781030655, 0.00010498687333893031, -0.04005715250968933, 0.022673344239592552, -0.04619866982102394, -0.03554588556289673, 0.061513736844062805, 0.032715823501348495, -0.03546952083706856, -0.02240946516394615, 0.06792686134576797, -0.08053033798933029, 0.058880724012851715, -0.026794470846652985, -0.06397490203380585, 0.017439551651477814, -0.03866484761238098, 0.016466381028294563, -0.006814116612076759, -0.006495751440525055, 0.034374408423900604, 0.008661869913339615, 0.07566776871681213, -0.0101083442568779, 0.0968213602900505, -0.05179565027356148, -0.05662825331091881, 0.05623680353164673, -0.02202439308166504, -0.015712937340140343, 0.04837473854422569, -0.005213444586843252, -0.016199002042412758, 0.030813630670309067, -0.004706369712948799, 0.017158247530460358, -0.05443117767572403, -0.039983779191970825, -0.0229963269084692, -0.022833429276943207, -0.0714661180973053, -0.00015051230730023235, 0.032358262687921524, 0.0348479263484478, 0.0328105203807354, -0.01990259625017643, 0.0369887538254261, -0.028796875849366188, -0.043809693306684494, 0.03229140862822533, 0.024112466722726822, 0.011288469657301903, 0.0018063872121274471, 0.07046832144260406, -0.07781066745519638, 0.0168964471668005, 0.03047931380569935, 0.027193233370780945, -0.08343769609928131, 0.00972232036292553, 0.012386004440486431, -0.04302433505654335, -0.0046725040301680565, 0.061128728091716766, 0.00810515321791172, 0.07442671060562134, 0.0013443963835015893, -0.013408188708126545, -0.053661104291677475, -0.026583600789308548, 0.005513542797416449, 0.0032165448646992445, -0.06694375723600388, 0.02171504870057106, -0.0018731141462922096, 0.029100939631462097, 0.044628728181123734, -0.003801344893872738, -0.04900112375617027, -0.00797038059681654, 0.012732213363051414, -0.053601816296577454, 0.02889464981853962, -0.01238900888711214, 0.05501049757003784, -0.04005180299282074, 0.024212658405303955, 0.0011041491525247693, -0.022630052641034126, -0.02031024917960167, 0.021523455157876015, 0.011210862547159195, -0.0019814036786556244, 0.006742099765688181, 0.021920915693044662, -0.014907903969287872, -0.01661825366318226, 0.009580609388649464, 0.038562845438718796, 0.035224832594394684, 0.041912972927093506, 0.012250730767846107, 0.06290082633495331, -0.051098283380270004, -0.02559625171124935, -0.050517186522483826, 0.0057663037441670895, -0.01697847992181778, -0.025966018438339233, 0.014002311043441296, -0.03970570117235184, 0.02778727188706398, -0.01880968175828457, -0.07460238039493561, 0.020669858902692795, 0.042493388056755066, -0.02878941409289837, 0.007023223675787449, 0.03999682515859604, 0.09494902938604355, 0.006014626007527113, -0.06382910907268524, -0.007968658581376076, 0.05981816351413727, 0.019477255642414093, -0.045105572789907455, 0.029188135638833046, 0.055733561515808105, -0.05453726276755333, -0.055029623210430145, -0.013352928683161736, 0.0003936502034775913, 0.00889921747148037, 0.018928663805127144, -0.048814643174409866, -0.028053518384695053, 0.0009567129891365767, 0.029826337471604347, 0.005296887829899788, -0.0004934499738737941, 0.012417424470186234, -0.004929209128022194, -0.004165051970630884, -0.07909202575683594, -0.07295011729001999, -0.10082412511110306, -0.02173371985554695, -0.0012987768277525902, 0.00567402970045805, -0.06090344861149788, 0.023679669946432114, 0.0030165649950504303, 0.038482896983623505, 0.012442318722605705, -0.04841836914420128, 0.017304902896285057, 0.009729990735650063, -0.04734078049659729, -0.028481923043727875, 0.013568422757089138, 0.009637316688895226, -0.09393462538719177, -0.05261187627911568, -0.03770684078335762, -0.01143947709351778, -0.01678374595940113, 0.05101814866065979, -0.013616702519357204, -0.038635142147541046, -0.04372921958565712, 0.016680683940649033, -0.03232865408062935, -0.007047354243695736, -0.012405273504555225, 0.02093607746064663, 0.032212499529123306, 0.07545574009418488, -0.00016022591444198042, -0.024562077596783638, -0.009854402393102646, 0.05175977945327759, 0.002732599852606654, -0.015741607174277306, 0.048398517072200775, 0.09396518021821976, 0.010745832696557045, 0.02737734280526638, -0.012699609622359276, 0.03629735857248306, -0.05364667996764183, -0.03579983115196228, -0.015950677916407585, 0.028637303039431572, -0.02210700511932373, 0.01719653233885765, 0.06606113165616989, -0.020573006942868233, 0.06729870289564133, 0.01355061586946249, 0.007440584246069193, 0.011155180633068085, -0.00478077307343483, -0.030964743345975876, 0.03022894635796547, 0.03329057991504669, 0.02034611627459526, -0.03670274838805199, 0.06685326993465424, 0.016460496932268143, 0.04847332462668419, 0.009372656233608723, 0.01740514300763607, 0.023690400645136833, 0.007928024046123028, 0.02217397838830948, 0.04841955006122589, 0.0002332405565539375, -0.07120960205793381, 0.004092221613973379, -0.045528702437877655, 0.03188367560505867, 0.007411923259496689, 0.014566932804882526, 0.019146621227264404, 0.06045081838965416, 0.035030923783779144, -0.08355548232793808, 0.06910378485918045, -0.018018724396824837, -0.009701927192509174, 0.03941773995757103, -0.03952575847506523, -0.05573011562228203, -0.024215277284383774, 0.0051648179069161415, 0.016958091408014297, -0.009213224984705448, -0.04971887916326523, -0.07902881503105164, -0.004402722232043743, 0.025022827088832855, -0.010993294417858124, 0.022674480453133583, -0.030301397666335106, 0.023427512496709824, -0.01091928593814373, -0.03600209206342697, 0.017300762236118317, -0.02756556309759617, -0.002885678317397833, 0.020868906751275063, 0.030495524406433105, 0.00885764416307211, -0.04151524603366852, 0.05939551815390587, 0.04152462258934975, 0.05398981645703316, -0.04459281638264656, 0.0007780424202792346, -0.04806661605834961, -0.013271107338368893, 0.04485826939344406, 0.011315745301544666, -0.03627800568938255, -0.07171197980642319, -0.026077888906002045, -0.020603099837899208, -0.012129392474889755, -0.03038201294839382, -0.07805059105157852, 0.014901231043040752, -0.0018037251429632306, 0.027782825753092766, 0.005678761750459671, 0.06730370223522186, -0.03260303661227226, -0.03692889213562012, 0.033182065933942795, -0.017779111862182617, -0.0005909395404160023, -0.015161155723035336, -0.05851537361741066, 0.007057097274810076, 0.016689427196979523, 0.02117074653506279, 0.025316910818219185, 0.010243644006550312, -0.001730114920064807, -0.011469773948192596, 0.030930761247873306, -0.014224916696548462, -0.05606061965227127, -0.030707992613315582, -0.011014295741915703, -0.030183186754584312, 0.09503809362649918, -0.004536529071629047, -0.02042904682457447, -0.015490032732486725, 0.02732389234006405, 0.01748763397336006, 0.007544294930994511, 0.010065843351185322, 0.049475256353616714, -0.01509795244783163, -0.010832703672349453, -0.011653037741780281, 0.008860583417117596, -0.026534564793109894, 0.007795535959303379, 0.0019122781231999397, -0.022036420181393623, -0.002532872837036848, 0.03161396086215973, 0.021159732714295387, -0.05468945950269699, -0.011369201354682446, 0.012646672315895557, 0.0013332280796021223, -0.014140146784484386, 0.01636536233127117, 0.03307044878602028, -0.010742773301899433, 0.01572047919034958, -0.009400730952620506, -0.000909285678062588, -0.006166438572108746, 0.04108066484332085, -0.0577094592154026, -0.007851576432585716, 0.0303608700633049, 0.020013120025396347, 0.013892807066440582, 0.013398079201579094, 0.023486504331231117, 0.03379005938768387, 0.02718333899974823, 0.050798188894987106, 0.04800915718078613, 0.01457216590642929, 0.07424666732549667, -0.03413965925574303, -0.004577731713652611, 0.01896088570356369, -0.010992423631250858, 0.007345486432313919, -0.0009901492157950997, -0.062109291553497314, 0.03339613601565361, 0.006232985761016607, 0.03864026814699173, -0.016382135450839996, 0.012898126617074013, 0.04121750593185425, -0.05866590142250061, 0.014426588080823421, -0.017428269609808922, -0.054544612765312195, -0.03825793042778969, 0.028730720281600952, 0.012173931114375591, -0.05582432076334953, 0.012472030706703663, -0.06855929642915726, -0.0746818333864212, -0.01144081074744463, -0.020028425380587578, 0.005056224763393402, -0.007606808561831713, -0.009736331179738045, -0.01751052588224411, 0.03145251050591469, -0.005067175254225731, 0.040852632373571396, -0.030870599672198296, -0.0011353291338309646, 0.014947157353162766, 0.025449875742197037, -0.03032934106886387, -0.008137105032801628, -0.08364111930131912, 0.0030751065351068974, 0.023562774062156677, -0.05892910435795784, 0.008167346008121967, -0.01462800893932581, -0.04008684679865837, 0.03525278717279434, -0.012013643980026245, 0.02943386882543564, 0.04923109710216522, 0.03424759954214096, 0.03472604602575302, -0.08650235831737518, 0.03473183512687683, -0.010399121791124344, 0.022030342370271683, 0.06868802756071091, -0.009678345173597336, -0.007951704785227776, 0.03220498561859131, 0.013378763571381569, 0.04200390353798866, 0.023129990324378014, -0.0269299503415823, -0.008693300187587738, 0.0021412898786365986, 0.016746629029512405, -0.041987527161836624, 0.016035549342632294, 0.018683377653360367, 0.0083953607827425, -0.013781344518065453, 0.017403701320290565, 0.0007879911572672427, -0.006147807464003563, 0.006777957547456026, 0.020305786281824112, 0.021774839609861374, 0.007676124107092619, -0.02810143493115902, -0.007644217927008867, -0.030270082876086235, 0.026184463873505592, 0.021149735897779465, -0.01869933307170868, -0.03866937384009361, 0.011206304654479027, 0.025589870288968086, -0.03416573628783226, -0.022576170042157173, -0.07873895019292831, 0.0026870418805629015, -0.005531736649572849, -0.06683570146560669, 0.03940468281507492, -0.008579668588936329, -0.033398691564798355, -0.0462983138859272, 0.023528967052698135, 0.010467569343745708, 0.00016105972463265061, 0.0008686456130817533, 0.025255728513002396, -0.023152120411396027, 0.046899594366550446, -0.06272262334823608, 0.0033509505447000265, 0.030237965285778046, 0.015855630859732628, -0.02347596362233162, -0.04024529829621315, 0.02373414859175682, 0.03397728502750397, -0.018230825662612915, -0.043984949588775635, 0.04480284824967384, -0.002557870000600815, 0.007965665310621262, 0.006609000265598297, 0.017614861950278282, 0.024695776402950287, -0.002511441707611084, 0.06227825954556465, -0.053526870906353, 0.07221108675003052, 0.07346010953187943, 0.028827346861362457, 0.0161429475992918, 0.030943777412176132, -0.03215984255075455, 0.0034859005827456713, -0.03497941419482231, 0.031163722276687622, 0.008397521451115608, 0.03312627971172333, -0.032493285834789276, 0.04899221286177635, 0.0177094005048275, 0.036069467663764954, -0.011518333107233047, -0.03531292453408241, 0.01139446347951889, 0.07000270485877991, 0.045466456562280655, 0.03188232704997063, -0.014322610571980476, -0.022447379305958748, -0.005866888910531998, 0.002577050356194377, -0.0014730095863342285, -0.0013644633581861854, -0.008558521047234535, 0.07141997665166855, 0.017127593979239464, -0.005517387762665749, 0.04485979676246643, -0.059535156935453415, -0.0016209629829972982, -0.05612478777766228, -0.026135029271245003, -0.020057402551174164, -0.033370859920978546, -0.0032862843945622444, -0.03446448966860771, 0.04101491719484329, -0.062035925686359406, -0.02076137252151966, -0.04670792445540428, -0.003458199556916952, -0.016046002507209778, 0.009029406122863293, -0.002283936133608222, 0.047480832785367966, 0.03171860799193382, -0.0029484773986041546, 0.043020445853471756, 0.028941338881850243, -0.0744238793849945, 0.019511092454195023, -0.018430959433317184, 0.008261134847998619, 0.03488309681415558, 0.014737565070390701, 0.008760965429246426, 0.055121127516031265, -0.021585268899798393, -0.009510749951004982, -0.030702874064445496, 0.060575589537620544, 0.017892220988869667, -0.01572205126285553, -0.023506291210651398, 0.006290752440690994, -0.02037903666496277, 0.005722453817725182, 0.03505966439843178, -0.021761160343885422, 0.0378405787050724, -0.026904981583356857, -0.03989897668361664, -0.00020292909175623208, 0.052589431405067444, 0.008791547268629074, -0.05193883925676346, -0.015539417043328285, 0.0035008173435926437, -0.04880208522081375, 0.03534649685025215, 0.03589532896876335, -0.037187837064266205, -0.036820512264966965, 0.015992866829037666, -0.03501996770501137, -0.011441160924732685, 0.060050491243600845, 0.026401514187455177, -0.015981175005435944, 0.016389429569244385, -0.012672563083469868, -0.035778384655714035, 0.020016832277178764, -0.00694543169811368, 0.032864656299352646, 0.011487019248306751, 0.03964069113135338, 0.06304579973220825, 0.02299642749130726, -0.07247160375118256, -0.0008134852978400886, 0.06215386837720871, -0.028827238827943802, 0.02447148784995079, 0.00566811254248023, -0.032489337027072906, -0.05728454515337944, 0.041479263454675674, 0.016032524406909943, -0.002941478043794632, -0.038077518343925476, -0.031736183911561966, -0.007403634488582611, -0.03390701115131378, -0.018743067979812622, 0.021179962903261185, 0.004739582538604736, 0.04811183735728264, -0.030612580478191376, 0.03615672513842583, -0.04425216093659401, -0.09982053935527802, 0.004314846824854612, -0.03234250098466873, -0.013495595194399357, 0.03849407657980919, 0.028337251394987106 ]
<p>If we describe spacetime with a Lorentzian manifold, it is always possible to choose a coordinate system such that at any particular point $x^\alpha$, the components of the metric are: $$ g_{\mu\nu}(x^\alpha) = \left( \begin{array}{cccc} 1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp;-1 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp;-1 &amp; 0 \\ 0 &amp; 0 &amp; 0 &amp;-1 \end{array} \right) $$</p> <p>But our freedom is much greater than this. In curved spacetime, the equivalence principle suggests we can choose coordinates such that the metric is of that form for every point along a chosen time-like geodesic. And in flat spacetime, we can see an explicit example that it doesn't even need to be a geodesic, for the Rindler metric has that form on every point of a particular worldline with constant proper acceleration. I have a feeling this is possible for any time-like worldine.</p> <p>So my question is:</p> <p>Given a coordinate system and metric for a Lorentzian manifold and a time-like worldline on this spacetime, is it always possible to find a coordinate transformation such that <em>for every point on the world line</em> the components of the metric in this coordinate system are just (1,-1,-1,-1) on the diagonal?</p> <p>I realize that even for simplified cases (say a geodesic on the Schwarzschild background), such a coordinate system could be incredibly complicated. So if someone creates an incredibly complicated explicit construction, please also show that the solution to the equations you setup exist with some kind of existence proof.</p> <p>This originally started from trying to find such a local coordinate chart for a free falling observer towards a blackhole, but realized I didn't know a good mathematical way to represent such coordinate freedom to get me started. Eventually I ended up pondering this current question. So even if you can't give a full answer, but can suggest some mathematical tools or where to read up on them, any help would be appreciated.</p>
g1613
[ -0.02184653840959072, 0.006128435488790274, 0.00987821165472269, -0.04816565290093422, 0.015496441163122654, 0.019724570214748383, -0.010160773992538452, -0.038232602179050446, -0.0657208040356636, 0.02251024916768074, 0.03964858129620552, -0.021462278440594673, 0.03939308971166611, -0.011926359497010708, -0.034306421875953674, -0.003347919788211584, 0.042717378586530685, 0.001017587841488421, 0.0048796916380524635, -0.0680476501584053, 0.07953930646181107, 0.03586737439036369, 0.034154828637838364, -0.057584498077631, 0.012276666238904, -0.002626506146043539, 0.053473081439733505, -0.054674386978149414, -0.09310060739517212, -0.005231969989836216, 0.004935570061206818, 0.004137795884162188, 0.011205552145838737, 0.012189404107630253, 0.018400032073259354, -0.03353087976574898, 0.01236324105411768, 0.025032710283994675, 0.0015909378416836262, 0.017719190567731857, 0.014307077042758465, 0.011864873580634594, 0.03009195812046528, 0.03571196645498276, 0.015149371698498726, -0.04378696531057358, -0.015216276049613953, 0.025073247030377388, 0.03505432978272438, 0.03850084915757179, -0.03523413836956024, 0.02991371415555477, 0.015135535970330238, -0.037925757467746735, -0.03426118567585945, 0.03215353935956955, 0.06774275749921799, 0.01932591199874878, 0.011694271117448807, 0.07533244788646698, -0.10083509236574173, -0.03747789189219475, 0.06520114094018936, -0.03534315153956413, 0.03676280379295349, 0.014473378658294678, -0.015390448272228241, -0.03346828371286392, -0.0021114067640155554, 0.039915066212415695, 0.012632034718990326, -0.04542473703622818, 0.0018470471259206533, 0.013855595141649246, -0.015009921975433826, 0.067364402115345, -0.05319734662771225, 0.022138845175504684, 0.024328550323843956, -0.0012943119509145617, 0.01658373884856701, 0.03990985453128815, 0.018938515335321426, -0.04889517277479172, 0.07548113167285919, -0.016380583867430687, 0.04859219491481781, -0.0014839244540780783, -0.03993375599384308, 0.029750844463706017, 0.04208916053175926, 0.01601334661245346, 0.00339974882081151, 0.0398629754781723, 0.006686300504952669, -0.0239986851811409, -0.003648970741778612, 0.030979108065366745, 0.01710425689816475, -0.04161183908581734, -0.02893916703760624, -0.0182618647813797, -0.0211690291762352, 0.027004199102520943, -0.0021246359683573246, -0.04031013324856758, 0.029412971809506416, -0.005254699848592281, 0.010276192799210548, -0.0594039186835289, 0.035561997443437576, -0.03290452063083649, 0.02110517956316471, -0.02648250386118889, -0.030620409175753593, -0.08968453854322433, 0.02780335582792759, 0.019931383430957794, -0.007012447342276573, 0.09484808892011642, -0.02035224251449108, 0.0003276701318100095, -0.015404179692268372, 0.02795328199863434, 0.00640757055953145, -0.005296909250319004, -0.07821448892354965, -0.011712881736457348, 0.011351550929248333, -0.01937064714729786, 0.014099929481744766, 0.021817689761519432, 0.022964324802160263, -0.014115171507000923, -0.08790341019630432, 0.008563731797039509, 0.0432492233812809, 0.013011224567890167, -0.01711881347000599, -0.033091649413108826, 0.006910226307809353, -0.053879912942647934, -0.02372000552713871, -0.02438865229487419, -0.02792174555361271, 0.03874097391963005, -0.0003992590063717216, -0.04126564413309097, 0.07668106257915497, -0.031999923288822174, -0.041133929044008255, 0.10014213621616364, 0.005112760234624147, 0.042488403618335724, -0.004023367073386908, -0.0006537816952914, -0.07605484873056412, -0.0221306923776865, 0.010252716019749641, -0.04156116396188736, 0.06598328053951263, -0.00727103790268302, 0.013454640284180641, -0.016198676079511642, 0.028561580926179886, -0.006945454515516758, -0.022692764177918434, -0.02683032490313053, -0.02978437766432762, -0.05801635980606079, -0.024449547752738, -0.019446371123194695, -0.0015242284862324595, 0.00662370678037405, -0.03402021527290344, 0.04094474017620087, -0.05154578387737274, 0.010571587830781937, 0.03362865746021271, -0.024067966267466545, -0.00699977483600378, -0.06754901260137558, 0.00753446388989687, -0.052084557712078094, 0.014066989533603191, -0.03724440932273865, -0.004683776758611202, 0.04839692264795303, 0.003222829895094037, 0.03141828626394272, 0.05850329250097275, -0.029911570250988007, -0.025248385965824127, 0.05078970268368721, 0.03219880536198616, 0.014870129525661469, 0.04486194625496864, -0.007314632181078196, 0.01579730398952961, 0.04500569775700569, 0.014644209295511246, 0.08711303025484085, 0.018112778663635254, 0.05251914635300636, -0.0030788572039455175, -0.009458829648792744, -0.008349450305104256, 0.0066800788044929504, -0.007316713221371174, -0.013534105382859707, 0.09435074776411057, -0.00009589071851223707, 0.0003487732610665262, -0.016554974019527435, -0.06560951471328735, 0.00677880272269249, -0.0425526462495327, 0.002909361617639661, -0.03234858438372612, -0.00410400191321969, -0.01983657479286194, -0.014271363615989685, 0.01905824989080429, -0.005135209299623966, -0.012135613709688187, -0.015379920601844788, -0.029586682096123695, -0.07731257379055023, 0.04625185206532478, -0.03696747496724129, -0.00699622044339776, -0.004549695644527674, -0.0027097060810774565, -0.040224362164735794, 0.06281880289316177, 0.04162849113345146, 0.005435362458229065, -0.0021465362515300512, 0.021386919543147087, 0.014324437826871872, 0.057064417749643326, -0.01141385082155466, -0.04049038514494896, -0.0008286337251774967, 0.09344729781150818, -0.023240797221660614, 0.03151056915521622, 0.01655755005776882, -0.020429257303476334, 0.010361569933593273, -0.030548393726348877, -0.027999229729175568, -0.04140655696392059, -0.019861742854118347, -0.02369583025574684, 0.005662108771502972, 0.038972556591033936, 0.03519092872738838, -0.10370655357837677, -0.021723488345742226, -0.018272865563631058, 0.024245485663414, -0.03725868836045265, 0.06951785832643509, -0.04221097007393837, 0.02478315681219101, -0.0288151316344738, 0.006499398034065962, 0.008718420751392841, 0.03978549689054489, -0.018195411190390587, 0.021155167371034622, 0.036268364638090134, 0.06271794438362122, -0.07170432806015015, 0.02406732738018036, -0.020161019638180733, -0.019179807975888252, -0.028723323717713356, 0.05272446200251579, 0.030510013923048973, -0.010383332148194313, -0.020746616646647453, 0.035573456436395645, 0.010162078775465488, -0.008695948868989944, 0.014357087202370167, 0.03221255913376808, -0.0078107574954628944, 0.017429687082767487, -0.011305255815386772, 0.029031753540039062, -0.029071848839521408, -0.027764828875660896, -0.0450747087597847, 0.025945203378796577, -0.008897334337234497, -0.043379705399274826, 0.003978695720434189, 0.036904241889715195, 0.008345218375325203, -0.0523107647895813, 0.05866270139813423, 0.049919694662094116, 0.019177637994289398, 0.035315532237291336, -0.037545520812273026, -0.06930211931467056, -0.050826627761125565, 0.00226082862354815, 0.04282097518444061, 0.019075507298111916, -0.02572416514158249, 0.029541900381445885, 0.02381712757050991, -0.0033453803043812513, -0.0193529911339283, -0.031623683869838715, -0.014948704279959202, 0.04544106125831604, -0.001979326829314232, -0.008560821413993835, -0.03971417620778084, 0.011590634472668171, 0.05367875099182129, 0.009643622674047947, -0.034752123057842255, 0.006313852034509182, -0.0637240782380104, 0.0062118214555084705, 0.010451050475239754, 0.01940923184156418, 0.02769644558429718, 0.05173325166106224, -0.027294397354125977, -0.044337231665849686, -0.02879192866384983, 0.004465610720217228, 0.011759355664253235, -0.011458112858235836, -0.060038011521101, 0.006341941189020872, -0.06601016223430634, 0.05449921637773514, 0.01800435595214367, 0.012442844919860363, 0.028367185965180397, -0.02536841668188572, 0.007820706814527512, 0.014973616227507591, 0.012566782534122467, -0.05381550267338753, 0.06729938089847565, -0.004576005972921848, 0.03209587559103966, -0.005436871666461229, 0.07874088734388351, 0.03988513723015785, -0.02608247846364975, -0.0007921486394479871, 0.029489891603589058, -0.019710447639226913, 0.028696902096271515, -0.04624323546886444, -0.03059789352118969, -0.024445215240120888, 0.015312557108700275, 0.01305019948631525, -0.025361081585288048, -0.01811496913433075, 0.06713204085826874, 0.006895639002323151, 0.039395689964294434, 0.018124617636203766, -0.057614050805568695, -0.06495687365531921, -0.0007235050434246659, 0.006014160346239805, 0.02295309491455555, 0.034707896411418915, -0.011042232625186443, 0.027368254959583282, 0.008805000223219395, -0.01298199687153101, 0.01719793677330017, -0.00028614114853553474, -0.001224860898219049, 0.006213049404323101, 0.003753478405997157, -0.03826415166258812, 0.044296059757471085, -0.04957345500588417, 0.004547927528619766, -0.029243947938084602, -0.02022440731525421, -0.023151369765400887, -0.007561220321804285, -0.008404245600104332, 0.044415708631277084, -0.0015356624498963356, 0.03199068456888199, 0.04718530923128128, -0.021398095414042473, 0.011961549520492554, -0.004476807080209255, -0.019785843789577484, 0.03078402951359749, -0.017667731270194054, -0.00046744104474782944, -0.009897513315081596, 0.046562038362026215, -0.011281115934252739, 0.0762670636177063, -0.019012199714779854, 0.019993966445326805, 0.006715983152389526, -0.04609068110585213, -0.020448070019483566, 0.013661093078553677, -0.016452539712190628, -0.03356952592730522, 0.05236690863966942, 0.062363747507333755, -0.021591249853372574, 0.047787971794605255, 0.02858850359916687, 0.08432938903570175, 0.016123319044709206, -0.002930418122559786, 0.019370507448911667, 0.04273182898759842, -0.0077307759784162045, 0.03049093298614025, 0.006481337361037731, -0.051092278212308884, 0.004191136918962002, -0.01108974777162075, 0.021925436332821846, -0.016293123364448547, 0.029605990275740623, -0.012902438640594482, -0.02971450611948967, 0.05451127886772156, -0.04571095481514931, -0.037362731993198395, 0.05641445890069008, -0.014280163682997227, -0.008050794713199139, -0.036197759211063385, 0.016465039923787117, -0.03462287411093712, -0.02170032635331154, -0.02625943161547184, -0.0038043581880629063, -0.03781654313206673, -0.009791814722120762, -0.028947601094841957, 0.016880491748452187, -0.011449378915131092, 0.05977312847971916, -0.02057253196835518, -0.06601686775684357, -0.0011815958423539996, 0.0698985606431961, -0.033256351947784424, -0.017380358651280403, -0.09057584404945374, 0.007704583462327719, -0.06898914277553558, -0.017086440697312355, 0.015557443723082542, 0.034743692725896835, -0.015878885984420776, -0.03607736900448799, 0.014258873648941517, 0.03751752898097038, -0.03437798097729683, -0.03295065462589264, -0.02051570452749729, -0.05876917392015457, -0.07836955040693283, -0.017597433179616928, 0.0211394764482975, -0.0018206388922408223, -0.03120892122387886, 0.05102507397532463, 0.03045521304011345, 0.023539680987596512, 0.01697833091020584, 0.012831253930926323, -0.020310670137405396, -0.03426669165492058, 0.01685250550508499, 0.004851219244301319, 0.027871547266840935, -0.0008491197368130088, -0.017741147428750992, -0.05776379629969597, 0.011962421238422394, 0.026197897270321846, -0.06363925337791443, 0.022424878552556038, 0.07175203412771225, -0.004905931651592255, -0.01121875736862421, 0.026258200407028198, 0.015470917336642742, 0.047088079154491425, -0.05863594263792038, 0.0790601372718811, -0.014136484824120998, 0.04594549909234047, -0.0015040801372379065, 0.018659649416804314, 0.006827202625572681, -0.017218656837940216, -0.06343701481819153, 0.0036683273501694202, 0.0030980356968939304, -0.05976935848593712, -0.027278052642941475, 0.03517593443393707, 0.010018556378781796, 0.026297295466065407, 0.01868640072643757, 0.06012386083602905, -0.03844111040234566, -0.05255003646016121, -0.02440631203353405, -0.03127472475171089, -0.003488064045086503, -0.03169779106974602, -0.029443765059113503, -0.016747983172535896, 0.06084682047367096, -0.026967892423272133, 0.03710399940609932, 0.05065353959798813, 0.07352551072835922, -0.0324636735022068, -0.014761676080524921, -0.09756218641996384, 0.06197204813361168, 0.021572934463620186, -0.014611267484724522, 0.019780514761805534, -0.0023677486460655928, 0.04708408564329147, -0.04708307236433029, -0.03735920041799545, -0.09070215374231339, 0.023165717720985413, -0.015133599750697613, 0.028781143948435783, -0.05671949312090874, 0.031310878694057465, 0.027958834543824196, -0.037672583013772964, -0.06790950149297714, -0.036691535264253616, 0.053400736302137375, 0.04645839333534241, 0.0013226917944848537, 0.06766681373119354, -0.07289636880159378, -0.008755942806601524, 0.009750451892614365, 0.003643972100690007, 0.11021609604358673, 0.019143573939800262, -0.009700685739517212, -0.009859303012490273, -0.0055090454407036304, 0.026641255244612694, -0.012900100089609623, -0.01459148433059454, -0.03299301862716675, 0.026863116770982742, -0.007584106642752886, 0.06235800310969353, -0.00822681188583374, 0.026781978085637093, 0.0128108449280262, -0.0750274658203125, -0.07170096039772034, -0.0040703387930989265, -0.04756850004196167, -0.00005274845170788467, -0.023363882675766945, 0.006017161067575216, -0.012275982648134232, -0.022121431306004524, 0.022228382527828217, -0.003396558342501521, -0.010609074495732784, -0.024498941376805305, 0.0071249050088226795, -0.027512846514582634, -0.052794452756643295, 0.007872436195611954, 0.016985146328806877, 0.031748414039611816, 0.04077104851603508, -0.006550085265189409, 0.005425608716905117, 0.003340753959491849, -0.08450549840927124, -0.06723014265298843, 0.03384484350681305, -0.05479494109749794, 0.02109459601342678, 0.06674695014953613, -0.06844888627529144, 0.04115620627999306, 0.04745232313871384, -0.029138745740056038, -0.010840644128620625, 0.0005876358482055366, -0.06005922704935074, -0.016614031046628952, 0.06620052456855774, 0.03651963919401169, -0.02956165373325348, 0.022156918421387672, -0.011911038309335709, -0.011076005175709724, 0.009036148898303509, 0.05078529566526413, 0.0014242652105167508, -0.0166575126349926, 0.004286265466362238, -0.05384809523820877, -0.038158439099788666, -0.011021050624549389, -0.027995947748422623, 0.04008772596716881, 0.01632126048207283, -0.01982000470161438, 0.049948081374168396, 0.030438745394349098, 0.021917346864938736, -0.021848810836672783, -0.000548480311408639, 0.055888831615448, -0.02147558145225048, -0.004105054307729006, 0.07726796716451645, -0.036150217056274414, -0.08537614345550537, 0.08498122543096542, 0.07741472125053406, -0.017014596611261368, -0.045783597975969315, 0.04010370373725891, -0.02420744113624096, -0.0008300008485093713, -0.06166130676865578, 0.035670675337314606, -0.041885118931531906, -0.07460644096136093, 0.020946787670254707, -0.0218054112046957, 0.0277431420981884, -0.001385325682349503, -0.04099180921912193, 0.035784538835287094, -0.01575559563934803, 0.01731030084192753, 0.011234221048653126, 0.025681765750050545, -0.053396835923194885, -0.0092040179297328, 0.03481150045990944, 0.006894607562571764, 0.01638665236532688, 0.003405924653634429, 0.004993290640413761, 0.041238486766815186, -0.02559790015220642, 0.03961927816271782, 0.025331122800707817, 0.06413844972848892, -0.011205802671611309, 0.01729549653828144, -0.02264983020722866, -0.006516012828797102, 0.015319262631237507, -0.00669719185680151, -0.010714863426983356, 0.0035480624064803123, -0.041415128856897354, 0.03387245535850525, -0.00806716363877058, -0.03349234536290169, 0.015475371852517128, -0.014806726947426796, 0.04118606820702553, 0.03379935026168823, -0.043125975877046585, -0.05426938831806183, 0.0483175627887249, 0.0015548182418569922, -0.03083629161119461, 0.03469601646065712, 0.014735540375113487, -0.010857849381864071, -0.03382017835974693, -0.03790612891316414, -0.032952167093753815, 0.028166381642222404, 0.009482640773057938, 0.027910690754652023, -0.026777727529406548, -0.03847265988588333, -0.0063034528866410255, 0.024416454136371613, 0.003217423101887107, -0.007512361276894808, -0.047018736600875854, -0.01383103709667921, -0.016266368329524994, -0.010425371117889881, -0.011571511626243591, -0.0757196843624115, 0.034948624670505524, 0.04358804225921631, 0.0009894506074488163, -0.04611372575163841, -0.006983242928981781, -0.06447335332632065, -0.015462826937437057, -0.018145404756069183, -0.019540470093488693, 0.05571636185050011, 0.0212433822453022, -0.0399412140250206, -0.06203720346093178, -0.021634280681610107, -0.05999479070305824, -0.0149695398285985, -0.05666978284716606, 0.0009341879049316049, -0.02419094927608967, 0.007945890538394451, -0.029056163504719734, 0.029947437345981598, 0.04543701186776161, 0.05261649936437607, 0.025805357843637466, -0.018672410398721695, 0.005634589120745659, 0.07332970201969147, 0.02493799850344658, -0.016122261062264442, 0.006691602058708668, -0.05267616733908653, 0.020913874730467796, -0.0073714712634682655, 0.03754427284002304, 0.04218760132789612, 0.01893816888332367, 0.0554237887263298, -0.0017787134274840355, 0.05761757865548134, -0.015656376257538795, -0.00469000730663538, -0.014354166574776173, 0.06712883710861206 ]
<p><em>[Again I am unsure as to whether this is appropriate for this site since this is again from standard graduate text-books and not research level. Please do not answer the question if you think that this will eventually get closed. Since otherwise the software doesn't allow me to delete questions once it has answers!]</em> </p> <ul> <li><p>A priori the technique of quantization using the background gauge field seems to be a "mere" redefinition of the good old Lagrangian whereby one "artificially" seems to double the number of variables by writing all of the fileds like say the fermions $\psi$, the gauge field $A_\alpha^\mu$, the ghosts $\omega_\alpha$ and $\omega_\alpha ^*$ as a sum of two fields one with a prime (the quantum fluctuation) and one unprimed (the classical background) - like replace every $A_\alpha ^\mu$ by $A_\alpha ^\mu + A_\alpha^{\mu&#39;}$. Till this step nothing seems to distinguish the primed from the unprimed fields. </p></li> <li><p>Then one defines the a new set of covariant derivatives where the the connection is defined only by the classical background gauge field (the unprimed fields) only. </p></li> </ul> <p>Then one rewrites the Lgrangian in terms of these new covariant derivatives and these doubled the number of fields. But I would think that the Lagrangian is still exactly the same and nothing conceptually has changed. </p> <p>Now two statements come in which seem to be somewhat "magical" and thats where it seems that the crux lies, </p> <ol> <li><p>Firstly one says that it is possible to set the background fields such that all the unprimed gauge fields are constant and every other unprimed field is 0. </p></li> <li><p>Then one says that the 1-loop contribution to the running of the coupling constant (and also the effective action?) is completely determined by looking at only that part of the orginal action which is quadratic in the primed fields ("quantum fluctuations"?)</p></li> </ol> <p>I would like to understand why the above two steps are consistent and correct and how to understand them. Also if there is some larger philosophy from which this comes out and if there are generalizations of this. </p> <p>{This technique and idea seems quite powerful since after one says the above it is almost routine calculation to get the beta-function of a $SU(N_c)$ Yang-Mill's theory with say $N_f$ flavours - and hence asymptotic freedom of QCD! - things which I would think are corner stones of physics! } </p>
g1614
[ 0.06203274056315422, -0.03610944747924805, -0.021866170689463615, -0.12189752608537674, 0.05977680906653404, 0.018821539357304573, 0.08624018728733063, 0.013084684498608112, -0.01617507077753544, -0.01171625405550003, 0.017774194478988647, 0.05296934023499489, 0.03506491705775261, 0.06019219383597374, 0.03300546854734421, 0.006561728194355965, 0.03500090911984444, -0.011884112842381, 0.03801668435335159, -0.09377869963645935, -0.013459439389407635, 0.040123604238033295, 0.049716439098119736, -0.05008348077535629, -0.03327571973204613, -0.030477818101644516, 0.024066856130957603, -0.001146698952652514, -0.006728457752615213, -0.033342145383358, 0.03774406015872955, -0.013276015408337116, 0.040433119982481, -0.024435216560959816, -0.011374426074326038, 0.015280765481293201, 0.044718001037836075, 0.040632374584674835, 0.0024634080473333597, 0.010987362824380398, 0.03549843281507492, -0.04040130227804184, 0.027929183095693588, -0.043862175196409225, -0.046622440218925476, 0.017377527430653572, 0.0013904959196224809, -0.03336208686232567, 0.012319724075496197, 0.05923143029212952, 0.011484327726066113, 0.03724842146039009, 0.03212148696184158, -0.010449226945638657, 0.009535170160233974, 0.031677037477493286, 0.018963295966386795, 0.06591188162565231, 0.05279399827122688, 0.028184965252876282, 0.04855528101325035, -0.05079944431781769, 0.017810799181461334, -0.003094690153375268, 0.010605737566947937, 0.005475874058902264, -0.01144710835069418, -0.03645847737789154, -0.029498044401407242, 0.014391197822988033, -0.04451918974518776, -0.08721121400594711, -0.03833618015050888, 0.005348346196115017, 0.031160946935415268, 0.03799381107091904, -0.006747107952833176, 0.007064622826874256, 0.016485052183270454, -0.04238734766840935, -0.05849780514836311, -0.07045448571443558, -0.01901141181588173, 0.028076142072677612, 0.11669241636991501, -0.055853527039289474, -0.021778518334031105, -0.008256480097770691, -0.03616015240550041, 0.004849516786634922, 0.014818359166383743, -0.0585857592523098, 0.0279901921749115, -0.017779555171728134, -0.006218195427209139, -0.004654199816286564, -0.004003569949418306, 0.008324043825268745, -0.0019064216176047921, -0.007531056180596352, -0.08302973210811615, 0.05790892243385315, 0.041647009551525116, 0.017051834613084793, -0.09352835267782211, 0.04575393721461296, 0.0612742118537426, -0.0254813339561224, -0.019763795658946037, -0.0016679340042173862, -0.038695577532052994, 0.045227836817502975, -0.002450023777782917, -0.02238074317574501, -0.08065640926361084, -0.04066479951143265, 0.06507453322410583, -0.013342783786356449, -0.04575377330183983, 0.026194436475634575, -0.0697108581662178, 0.01776731386780739, 0.029256990179419518, -0.02072410099208355, -0.002715237205848098, 0.015664048492908478, -0.03926939144730568, 0.006804036442190409, 0.056258708238601685, -0.03283771872520447, 0.06969253718852997, -0.004308634903281927, -0.06097375974059105, 0.06749636679887772, 0.02531621791422367, -0.006926313042640686, 0.02578992210328579, 0.037442877888679504, 0.024641601368784904, 0.029684605076909065, -0.049939852207899094, -0.08231145888566971, -0.05090903863310814, -0.050940051674842834, 0.010688131675124168, 0.058457374572753906, 0.016276197507977486, -0.01455769781023264, 0.009458684362471104, 0.006112692411988974, 0.056074630469083786, 0.04288394749164581, -0.010677250102162361, 0.03354911506175995, -0.0189666710793972, -0.0024370311293751, -0.006733255460858345, -0.05895094573497772, 0.0001424028305336833, -0.03029187209904194, 0.07349125295877457, -0.045794855803251266, 0.08396945893764496, -0.027450120076537132, 0.020995935425162315, 0.02529291622340679, 0.00974285788834095, 0.007830765098333359, 0.01104535348713398, -0.023574458435177803, -0.034967418760061264, 0.03811704367399216, -0.04058421030640602, -0.016546767204999924, 0.026197252795100212, 0.09821708500385284, 0.021418839693069458, -0.051600683480501175, -0.017796291038393974, 0.008328111842274666, 0.021056460216641426, -0.0014091604389250278, -0.01291514653712511, -0.024211809039115906, -0.0010012289276346564, -0.022854071110486984, -0.03395889326930046, 0.010747767053544521, -0.001660497160628438, -0.018085289746522903, -0.04123635217547417, -0.011887814849615097, -0.018641600385308266, 0.010805830359458923, -0.06313738226890564, 0.041273705661296844, 0.01580755040049553, -0.028518959879875183, -0.019687555730342865, -0.017571814358234406, -0.0011216722195968032, 0.03498772904276848, -0.00024273291637655348, -0.016596585512161255, 0.03316577151417732, 0.031721532344818115, -0.013248248025774956, 0.006521592848002911, 0.005338863003998995, -0.049948520958423615, 0.02141757309436798, -0.005825612228363752, 0.06595012545585632, -0.027363795787096024, -0.01882500946521759, -0.02668384648859501, 0.03582926094532013, 0.01815887913107872, -0.02921089343726635, 0.011840990744531155, 0.0349508672952652, 0.042428892105817795, 0.11509320139884949, 0.003891635686159134, -0.03839077800512314, 0.030855592340230942, 0.011690929532051086, 0.015558839775621891, -0.04048021137714386, 0.017255952581763268, -0.06546877324581146, -0.007835128344595432, -0.04469955340027809, -0.014342437498271465, 0.02620219998061657, 0.02118808962404728, 0.013742968440055847, 0.003817244665697217, 0.04597431793808937, 0.034147292375564575, 0.04654724523425102, 0.0322059728205204, -0.0008397990022785962, 0.03348613530397415, 0.037384986877441406, -0.018230047076940536, 0.06494981050491333, 0.01906653121113777, -0.08197198063135147, 0.006554051302373409, 0.011350078508257866, 0.0028247602749615908, -0.054114047437906265, -0.0181875117123127, 0.017390046268701553, -0.019626064226031303, 0.03966150060296059, -0.018039902672171593, -0.042311593890190125, 0.031081877648830414, 0.043985750526189804, -0.026714198291301727, 0.0025684975553303957, 0.0742277055978775, -0.018276462331414223, 0.0016750990180298686, -0.021330812945961952, -0.0032311563845723867, -0.02779083326458931, -0.05496445670723915, 0.00019635104399640113, 0.041020385921001434, 0.04400009661912918, 0.022442473098635674, 0.04818486049771309, -0.008154322393238544, -0.02020072564482689, 0.02813030779361725, 0.03573410212993622, -0.03531576693058014, -0.002784661017358303, -0.01855381764471531, -0.013214046135544777, -0.01158798299729824, 0.028149424120783806, -0.034007761627435684, -0.025097716599702835, -0.02945319376885891, 0.036974355578422546, 0.03625483810901642, 0.006649227812886238, 0.014400879852473736, 0.0031392076052725315, -0.016427384689450264, -0.05810878798365593, 0.025682872161269188, -0.000049399885028833523, -0.018341101706027985, -0.024734416976571083, 0.03330104053020477, -0.0019157018978148699, -0.025470269843935966, -0.034450821578502655, 0.011421297676861286, 0.03049308806657791, -0.019610252231359482, -0.04618320241570473, 0.019636889919638634, -0.03556685522198677, 0.008947880007326603, -0.024607999250292778, -0.007562555372714996, -0.028255457058548927, -0.03681308031082153, 0.0026015553157776594, -0.014820527285337448, 0.035527609288692474, -0.00609063683077693, 0.05441291630268097, 0.015775125473737717, -0.06297585368156433, 0.009223584085702896, 0.005639233626425266, -0.03677365183830261, 0.020825857296586037, 0.026960060000419617, -0.041732147336006165, -0.01256236806511879, -0.04117702692747116, -0.011271953582763672, 0.05716237425804138, 0.010558967478573322, -0.00944897998124361, -0.02188674546778202, -0.026936175301671028, -0.03351219370961189, -0.05211687460541725, -0.011578286066651344, 0.03213820233941078, 0.019743310287594795, -0.02728142961859703, -0.018613655120134354, -0.07085094600915909, 0.0550595298409462, 0.00862426683306694, 0.003198944730684161, 0.020067812874913216, -0.07253989577293396, 0.020776182413101196, -0.02528761513531208, -0.0002733333094511181, -0.0244327150285244, -0.009303859435021877, 0.03426051139831543, 0.03366367146372795, -0.011795277707278728, 0.006684541702270508, 0.053406354039907455, 0.06879134476184845, 0.00403583562001586, 0.0022459328174591064, -0.034332435578107834, -0.006080938968807459, -0.015749024227261543, 0.0017801392823457718, 0.02120955102145672, -0.01763487234711647, 0.0012436119141057134, -0.0509168766438961, -0.003623915370553732, 0.01990947127342224, 0.04436037316918373, -0.032457564026117325, 0.010182804428040981, 0.006683250889182091, -0.004827781114727259, 0.025631118565797806, -0.011439246125519276, -0.05374210327863693, 0.007042038720101118, 0.0043509770184755325, -0.0012749608140438795, 0.023384567350149155, 0.06705988943576813, 0.008458646945655346, 0.04521157965064049, -0.04449955001473427, 0.014922766014933586, 0.02064032480120659, -0.026170840486884117, -0.029106393456459045, 0.02676309086382389, -0.0313030406832695, -0.013117291033267975, 0.011294899508357048, 0.024603627622127533, 0.009388293139636517, -0.0018012827495113015, 0.049847181886434555, -0.0016916784225031734, 0.014245742931962013, -0.0025927743408828974, 0.016958676278591156, -0.029875263571739197, -0.030042819678783417, -0.00404968811199069, 0.02088371478021145, -0.018816305324435234, 0.050840578973293304, -0.050649914890527725, -0.0012983657652512193, 0.059824395924806595, 0.059965863823890686, -0.10785311460494995, 0.06587857007980347, -0.02888282760977745, -0.013603266328573227, -0.0618843212723732, 0.003401278518140316, -0.04712817072868347, 0.04319677874445915, 0.020297229290008545, 0.02530568651854992, -0.02097577229142189, 0.027409354224801064, 0.05350957810878754, 0.02172194793820381, 0.009041227400302887, 0.0017096161609515548, -0.0438414141535759, 0.043208830058574677, 0.014110592193901539, -0.0028359233401715755, 0.024309396743774414, -0.060251589864492416, 0.0008041256805881858, -0.06657148152589798, 0.04876089096069336, -0.005374455824494362, 0.06077049300074577, 0.1067965030670166, -0.03857393190264702, 0.01585518755018711, -0.01899697817862034, 0.017197074368596077, 0.029657721519470215, -0.057894267141819, -0.006326495204120874, 0.013265860266983509, -0.009304283186793327, -0.009653627872467041, 0.06499532610177994, -0.028990652412176132, 0.005350031889975071, 0.020927809178829193, -0.08780524879693985, 0.013028702698647976, 0.05692635476589203, -0.01056564599275589, 0.02266753278672695, -0.09706160426139832, -0.005374540574848652, -0.0061158230528235435, 0.0032804629299789667, 0.00972098857164383, -0.019296439364552498, -0.0731036365032196, -0.007050441578030586, -0.056149810552597046, -0.04480066895484924, 0.03878520056605339, -0.011498347856104374, 0.031523123383522034, -0.03532220423221588, -0.022353023290634155, -0.016250967979431152, -0.020411154255270958, 0.05788378044962883, 0.01791987195611, -0.01970704458653927, 0.023277372121810913, -0.037535298615694046, 0.020987095311284065, -0.021648498252034187, -0.03009220026433468, 0.010295992717146873, -0.003940554801374674, -0.07020825147628784, -0.037503261119127274, -0.0040602716617286205, 0.034798514097929, -0.010525096207857132, 0.08854195475578308, -0.005135683808475733, 0.06359278410673141, 0.015872756019234657, 0.003208307083696127, 0.086420938372612, 0.017933543771505356, -0.011941704899072647, -0.08148414641618729, 0.0743556022644043, -0.024749724194407463, -0.036961138248443604, -0.0008679243037477136, -0.00515919690951705, 0.05249578133225441, -0.01278901007026434, -0.013645834289491177, 0.04130343720316887, -0.032595254480838776, 0.02331698127090931, -0.019746161997318268, -0.024910185486078262, 0.006680971942842007, 0.02491692267358303, -0.029652269557118416, -0.018737098202109337, -0.02590487338602543, -0.024702997878193855, 0.0027058636769652367, 0.015860257670283318, -0.010975061915814877, -0.0028493176214396954, -0.010209672152996063, 0.022042566910386086, 0.0059959739446640015, -0.03800802677869797, 0.01427669171243906, 0.048488833010196686, -0.02745073474943638, 0.0310723464936018, -0.007006211671978235, -0.015436792746186256, -0.012020901776850224, -0.03054477460682392, -0.0057963537983596325, -0.003539028810337186, 0.005747699644416571, 0.016055062413215637, 0.023104196414351463, 0.022527704015374184, 0.029721707105636597, 0.01613599807024002, 0.02078554779291153, -0.020203623920679092, -0.0031431361567229033, 0.01823306642472744, 0.0007816054858267307, -0.1519966572523117, -0.04720357805490494, -0.026801807805895805, 0.03269273415207863, -0.0029125167056918144, -0.05381989851593971, -0.01096402294933796, 0.008899246342480183, -0.056262001395225525, 0.01584411971271038, 0.039082687348127365, -0.008089476265013218, -0.031430941075086594, 0.036896757781505585, -0.015824994072318077, 0.009829755872488022, -0.005463502369821072, 0.025372307747602463, -0.04175657033920288, 0.006700207479298115, 0.04726304113864899, 0.0009301596437580884, 0.04315062239766121, -0.021740708500146866, 0.038921914994716644, -0.000935831107199192, 0.026806892827153206, -0.03194331005215645, -0.04468993842601776, -0.0673951730132103, -0.004888226743787527, -0.008943367749452591, 0.03957732766866684, 0.0014859550865367055, -0.07766442745923996, -0.005713020451366901, 0.0179124865680933, -0.03292221575975418, 0.034349676221609116, -0.01315497886389494, 0.025773687288165092, 0.005311249289661646, -0.012116330675780773, -0.014152079820632935, -0.05302303656935692, 0.030984118580818176, -0.009336454793810844, 0.0181416068226099, -0.005876232869923115, -0.03280561789870262, -0.016904478892683983, 0.010544326156377792, -0.010957369580864906, -0.03163227066397667, -0.04203354939818382, 0.04445457458496094, 0.06971123069524765, -0.03271559998393059, 0.001005475060082972, 0.002200918737798929, 0.021281540393829346, 0.005367915146052837, -0.058592233806848526, -0.01257113553583622, 0.0005878937663510442, 0.001515236683189869, -0.041914407163858414, -0.04595939815044403, 0.061925750225782394, 0.015634531155228615, 0.029699981212615967, 0.02670888788998127, 0.02104794979095459, 0.022419171407818794, 0.013211799785494804, 0.009229552932083607, 0.03902529552578926, 0.006600663997232914, -0.04211400821805, 0.025817973539233208, -0.04705197364091873, -0.01970226690173149, 0.02456209436058998, 0.022157540544867516, 0.05091525614261627, -0.0017739913892000914, 0.07901294529438019, -0.027069438248872757, 0.03664489462971687, -0.022715408354997635, -0.013575506396591663, -0.03812982887029648, 0.07585806399583817, 0.08814579248428345, -0.0038054902106523514, -0.023584645241498947, 0.0006205221870914102, 0.0576612651348114, 0.013765553012490273, -0.055879466235637665, 0.003802309511229396, -0.0037134080193936825, 0.009181433357298374, 0.03396257385611534, 0.007919221185147762, -0.07086841017007828, 0.03870493918657303, 0.03342565521597862, 0.018931541591882706, -0.007778468541800976, -0.08082792162895203, -0.015918133780360222, -0.04853987693786621, -0.002283764537423849, -0.018538642674684525, 0.046584758907556534, 0.0329229012131691, -0.01619279757142067, -0.002596220700070262, 0.032767027616500854, 0.010706261731684208, 0.0019067521207034588, -0.06822926551103592, -0.005724200047552586, 0.03949867933988571, 0.036817893385887146, -0.006576147396117449, -0.018951619043946266, 0.07801074534654617, -0.05111619085073471, -0.01100741233676672, 0.004502591211348772, 0.03237400949001312, -0.038565125316381454, -0.041157543659210205, -0.08321312069892883, -0.03866034001111984, -0.05584539473056793, 0.008184363134205341, -0.03080867975950241, -0.008414349518716335, -0.01006039883941412, -0.02242659591138363, 0.000766049837693572, 0.030451389029622078, -0.010108442045748234, 0.04987368360161781, 0.005207791458815336, -0.015768319368362427, 0.060898710042238235, 0.05095900967717171, 0.011816270649433136, -0.027916189283132553, -0.0756712555885315, 0.00696873664855957, 0.04875245690345764, -0.009829889051616192, 0.024211160838603973, 0.007064389996230602, -0.045434705913066864, 0.030802378430962563, -0.04244149476289749, 0.027990520000457764, -0.028689218685030937, 0.03641502559185028, 0.04667823016643524, -0.012576873414218426, -0.012715568765997887, 0.034525882452726364, -0.010692857205867767, -0.0003865108883474022, 0.019367191940546036, 0.00860359612852335, -0.020438404753804207, -0.008044686168432236, 0.021649273112416267, 0.0016284352168440819, 0.0010013161227107048, -0.01944437250494957, 0.0028931715060025454, -0.036313530057668686, -0.06719449162483215, -0.03569833189249039, -0.04814619570970535, 0.03387197107076645, -0.03245886415243149, 0.0748525932431221, -0.058111049234867096, -0.024421177804470062, 0.01807791367173195, -0.012760029174387455, 0.01022612676024437, -0.06558633595705032, -0.006666834466159344, -0.009628652594983578, -0.0009435651591047645, -0.012401445768773556, 0.0067695812322199345, 0.013785026967525482, -0.03584042564034462, -0.0006042871973477304, 0.04864761233329773, 0.02854326367378235, -0.047985099256038666, 0.063020721077919, 0.06722129881381989, -0.036819253116846085, 0.005383495707064867, 0.0377703532576561, 0.08935768902301788, -0.029357483610510826, -0.019885892048478127, -0.003455727593973279, 0.02477831207215786, -0.0015355816576629877, -0.07303106784820557, -0.03425049036741257, 0.011019347235560417, 0.022318024188280106 ]
<p>First off, let me just say that I am unsure if this question is appropriate for this site, and if the community deems it necessary, the question should be closed.</p> <p>So right now I am a fourth year mathematics and physics major whose research interests lie in quantum field theory / quantum gravity. In particular, I would like to go into theoretical physics. However, I have found that most physicists do not achieve a level of rigor I would strive for in my work, and so I am reluctant to apply for graduate school in physics. On the other hand, it seems that in most mathematics departments in the U.S., there are at most a couple of mathematicians working in what you might all theoretical physics, and I would not feel comfortable applying to a graduate school banking on the fact I could work with a specific one or two persons.</p> <p>What possible routes are there that I could take if my interests lie in theoretical physics, but I wish to practice theoretical physics as a mathematician would? Furthermore, are there any (not necessarily American) universities with a joint mathematics-physics department (like the DAMTP at Cambridge), or, the next best thing, a mathematics and physics department that collaborate frequently? What about theoretical physicists working in quantum field theory/quantum gravity who don't shy away from rigor?</p> <p>Any and all input is greatly appreciated!</p>
g1615
[ 0.009448102675378323, 0.0546320378780365, 0.010128623805940151, -0.015801677480340004, 0.003016725881025195, 0.015534228645265102, 0.00657280907034874, 0.0015982103068381548, -0.00998891144990921, -0.02224837616086006, 0.05845385789871216, 0.0009501780150458217, -0.006253290921449661, -0.010889287106692791, -0.03327658772468567, -0.00016478465113323182, 0.045762281864881516, 0.0058954013511538506, -0.01117654051631689, -0.019515059888362885, -0.024048523977398872, 0.013073856011033058, 0.06289474666118622, -0.02887578494846821, -0.08634229749441147, 0.0005119768902659416, -0.03906555846333504, -0.04556633159518242, 0.00043193728197366, 0.005879268050193787, -0.04532129317522049, -0.01245214231312275, 0.0656464695930481, -0.009685620665550232, -0.050075605511665344, -0.04224170371890068, 0.005570438224822283, 0.019259745255112648, 0.05630488693714142, -0.019489971920847893, 0.028268007561564445, -0.029378199949860573, 0.010884633287787437, -0.020088844001293182, -0.009030647575855255, 0.035240888595581055, 0.04419344663619995, 0.006673919036984444, 0.052700117230415344, 0.04048005864024162, 0.02619520202279091, 0.054919444024562836, 0.010963683016598225, 0.00479506142437458, -0.010796843096613884, -0.008448470383882523, 0.0048547592014074326, 0.009358424693346024, 0.013180908747017384, -0.003512284718453884, 0.01825517788529396, 0.02678888477385044, -0.00019487016834318638, -0.014307694509625435, 0.03867138549685478, 0.07328197360038757, -0.034599460661411285, -0.05191471055150032, 0.03418160229921341, -0.012864883989095688, -0.012981142848730087, -0.03349755331873894, 0.04343276098370552, 0.032861001789569855, 0.04200112074613571, 0.08229726552963257, 0.027666054666042328, -0.0578979067504406, 0.025276750326156616, 0.008534297347068787, -0.018898114562034607, 0.028975676745176315, 0.03548719733953476, 0.014898454770445824, 0.033613353967666626, -0.049505483359098434, -0.021906280890107155, 0.003145879600197077, -0.023763004690408707, 0.03739282488822937, -0.022000154480338097, 0.027691401541233063, 0.03990771993994713, -0.009573153220117092, -0.015554796904325485, 0.0154030229896307, 0.02475748024880886, 0.05274583026766777, 0.027682151645421982, 0.014731843024492264, 0.0025968572590500116, 0.0596163235604763, 0.026995433494448662, 0.074771448969841, 0.011269791051745415, -0.012548566795885563, -0.005932018160820007, 0.026617182418704033, 0.08001324534416199, 0.06564179062843323, -0.10728389024734497, 0.02039337530732155, -0.014233463443815708, 0.011688079684972763, -0.033848050981760025, 0.029795566573739052, -0.02010590396821499, -0.07038029283285141, -0.012641167268157005, 0.07558269053697586, -0.008807656355202198, -0.012164938263595104, 0.014375066384673119, 0.04698260501027107, -0.027305763214826584, 0.06124820187687874, -0.011004157364368439, 0.030010715126991272, 0.006355296354740858, 0.04490625485777855, 0.058920424431562424, -0.05205458402633667, -0.013984871096909046, 0.07770352065563202, -0.06387069076299667, 0.07324089854955673, -0.006045858841389418, 0.009003130719065666, 0.0327720083296299, 0.04431160166859627, 0.03487224131822586, -0.01857433281838894, 0.0075004068203270435, -0.011027890257537365, -0.032245904207229614, 0.020238639786839485, -0.019203104078769684, -0.0184602253139019, -0.012110092677175999, 0.04582568630576134, 0.037960879504680634, 0.014202586375176907, 0.0352962464094162, -0.011649715714156628, 0.001964360009878874, 0.012380698695778847, 0.00409265561029315, -0.03403213620185852, 0.01908344216644764, -0.01792309619486332, 0.07754881680011749, 0.007504576817154884, -0.016159744933247566, -0.008796274662017822, 0.021306771785020828, 0.004699247889220715, 0.018122419714927673, -0.04124059900641441, -0.02145201340317726, -0.007535992655903101, 0.011088668368756771, 0.00094379618531093, 0.05533447489142418, 0.04738058149814606, 0.009380543604493141, 0.001963365124538541, 0.018620038405060768, -0.007642991375178099, -0.037493303418159485, 0.01377139799296856, 0.022093772888183594, -0.05995083972811699, 0.003914428409188986, -0.04260823875665665, -0.026845702901482582, 0.00559045048430562, 0.02135503478348255, 0.035840954631567, -0.03698843717575073, 0.01117636263370514, 0.026532050222158432, 0.013890817761421204, 0.007812239695340395, -0.0027470914646983147, 0.037215545773506165, -0.02393997088074684, -0.03793586418032646, -0.01764816977083683, -0.03614713251590729, -0.016963228583335876, -0.009224465116858482, 0.05643494799733162, 0.03079662285745144, -0.001088774180971086, 0.033955201506614685, 0.05429850518703461, -0.0346178337931633, -0.024880027398467064, 0.07515046000480652, -0.03580637276172638, 0.04060698300600052, 0.035389624536037445, 0.025385500863194466, 0.016874810680747032, -0.03811381012201309, -0.01842036284506321, -0.01913241110742092, -0.05009499192237854, -0.042453303933143616, 0.06103295087814331, -0.020757922902703285, 0.015275317244231701, 0.01712903380393982, -0.034105006605386734, -0.020391199737787247, 0.018226871266961098, -0.08069662004709244, -0.017958268523216248, -0.02493506483733654, 0.004614109173417091, -0.00568644143640995, -0.006010143551975489, 0.013610304333269596, -0.04635993763804436, 0.041784267872571945, 0.025326399132609367, -0.035613030195236206, -0.04949550703167915, 0.059655770659446716, 0.018892165273427963, -0.03320998698472977, 0.03819709271192551, -0.03744940459728241, 0.00222451682202518, -0.021388854831457138, -0.02482737973332405, 0.03811149671673775, 0.060885317623615265, 0.027034562081098557, 0.013034120202064514, 0.07820239663124084, -0.05089906230568886, -0.031640928238630295, -0.009548579342663288, 0.016147905960679054, 0.050192683935165405, 0.029975492507219315, -0.009873011149466038, 0.02145598642528057, 0.01032797060906887, -0.030312390998005867, -0.07671502977609634, 0.025577187538146973, 0.01368155237287283, -0.04021940007805824, 0.0093167033046484, -0.08987163007259369, 0.012077285908162594, -0.048015911132097244, -0.00018760398961603642, -0.02945859543979168, 0.024960098788142204, 0.02243068441748619, 0.006725240498781204, 0.012161455117166042, 0.012378331273794174, -0.01459389179944992, 0.010390122421085835, 0.04153415188193321, -0.057982441037893295, 0.03626272454857826, -0.03409864008426666, -0.018515847623348236, 0.03201226145029068, 0.05209994688630104, -0.05532331019639969, -0.03372428938746452, -0.051588013768196106, -0.013564862310886383, -0.0436403863132, 0.009950913488864899, -0.009266175329685211, 0.03722091391682625, -0.02570711448788643, -0.04550773277878761, 0.011244767345488071, -0.006615004036575556, -0.025110775604844093, -0.06242254003882408, 0.03877565637230873, 0.0092755863443017, 0.03238819167017937, 0.0020979868713766336, 0.02532915212213993, 0.021635355427861214, 0.005260041914880276, -0.0799681544303894, -0.03297717869281769, 0.008734897710382938, -0.0062565249390900135, 0.0019514851737767458, 0.05514024943113327, 0.027690932154655457, -0.011731198988854885, 0.00758999353274703, -0.014715314842760563, 0.006216190755367279, 0.04617355763912201, 0.04328708350658417, -0.04085737466812134, -0.024486035108566284, 0.04192812368273735, 0.04219808056950569, -0.03761421516537666, -0.006433387286961079, 0.08313383907079697, -0.04601077362895012, 0.003268874017521739, -0.029303984716534615, -0.031497448682785034, -0.006496605928987265, -0.04031069204211235, 0.0023471044842153788, -0.039258867502212524, -0.06193581596016884, 0.013577017933130264, 0.04454244300723076, -0.03090589866042137, -0.0038307919166982174, -0.023366879671812057, 0.030520951375365257, -0.00911024585366249, 0.00623505050316453, -0.037279125303030014, -0.0006036741542629898, 0.023831749334931374, -0.03434525430202484, 0.041065335273742676, 0.0028257097583264112, 0.026751307770609856, 0.001981091685593128, 0.024185072630643845, 0.024484459310770035, 0.05500015243887901, 0.05053962394595146, -0.006788469851016998, 0.02420549839735031, 0.039763834327459335, -0.005550262052565813, -0.01460316963493824, -0.07300567626953125, -0.020528554916381836, -0.03304209187626839, -0.02574053965508938, -0.020502174273133278, -0.00842334609478712, -0.011764319613575935, -0.02609100192785263, -0.044276461005210876, 0.006186536513268948, -0.002229818608611822, 0.024134980514645576, -0.0016377521678805351, -0.024510856717824936, 0.0316755473613739, -0.0692785382270813, -0.018618334084749222, -0.05349913239479065, -0.030817052349448204, -0.029390184208750725, -0.004110148176550865, 0.033455394208431244, -0.018154526129364967, -0.012081766501069069, 0.06062088534235954, 0.021479742601513863, -0.020890550687909126, -0.0055388049222528934, 0.07411859929561615, 0.03197468817234039, 0.00047873708535917103, 0.0026183028239756823, 0.0013569548027589917, 0.03813157230615616, -0.010329317301511765, -0.0025561449583619833, -0.010468184016644955, -0.018850579857826233, 0.026245644316077232, 0.021250808611512184, -0.01678515411913395, 0.0015887179179117084, -0.025302443653345108, 0.004336091224104166, -0.043168891221284866, -0.0584678091108799, -0.015212290920317173, 0.0032419580966234207, -0.006542885676026344, -0.04780886694788933, 0.038613200187683105, -0.06179305538535118, 0.013967939652502537, 0.007151362951844931, 0.020049190148711205, -0.03873151168227196, -0.06976045668125153, -0.030127866193652153, 0.030282611027359962, 0.017410248517990112, 0.05044977366924286, 0.04673813655972481, 0.04111623018980026, 0.023363729938864708, -0.0019901881460100412, 0.005945485085248947, -0.025585098192095757, 0.024439742788672447, -0.03713501617312431, 0.028484633192420006, 0.09759608656167984, 0.0013323577586561441, 0.011979657225310802, -0.03528665751218796, 0.007455585058778524, -0.04264754801988602, -0.046429406851530075, -0.012204727157950401, 0.005889985244721174, -0.0028202510438859463, 0.03654798865318298, -0.026207761839032173, -0.06020661070942879, -0.0019213927444070578, -0.055288586765527725, 0.04131186380982399, -0.033138953149318695, 0.003571460023522377, -0.004583235830068588, -0.0020885122939944267, -0.08274879306554794, -0.02976999804377556, -0.025033054873347282, -0.054390016943216324, -0.05330707132816315, -0.04945144057273865, -0.005000283010303974, 0.005751768592745066, 0.02096867561340332, 0.0018642786890268326, -0.06458565592765808, 0.03449792042374611, -0.04014073684811592, 0.03634825348854065, -0.0049187843687832355, -0.003415215527638793, -0.06736835092306137, 0.007413341663777828, -0.04240979626774788, -0.07689559459686279, -0.03911124914884567, 0.027205875143408775, 0.008461053483188152, 0.023462174460291862, 0.02433139644563198, -0.03254816681146622, -0.031242426484823227, -0.011075478047132492, -0.020480921491980553, -0.089481882750988, 0.01363828219473362, 0.024655014276504517, 0.04959569871425629, -0.0018444458255544305, 0.00036126485792919993, 0.007618101313710213, -0.0032635286916047335, 0.01423345785588026, -0.000014293211279436946, -0.0345267727971077, 0.043342746794223785, -0.06392820924520493, 0.026112889871001244, 0.011616085655987263, -0.07816001772880554, -0.01217361818999052, -0.011462964117527008, 0.014746900647878647, 0.013865153305232525, -0.02131545916199684, 0.06736461073160172, -0.0007177743245847523, 0.014569917693734169, 0.020793801173567772, -0.005065999925136566, -0.00018510856898501515, 0.042911265045404434, -0.00813969410955906, -0.0025879470631480217, -0.00622223736718297, -0.005821076687425375, 0.007872559130191803, -0.017737537622451782, 0.01508052833378315, 0.033315327018499374, 0.04309811070561409, 0.02627004124224186, 0.0104741919785738, 0.003916693385690451, -0.05015334114432335, 0.011599230580031872, -0.05521469935774803, -0.017410287633538246, -0.00874168612062931, 0.10376853495836258, -0.0034103950019925833, -0.10218891501426697, 0.037268802523612976, 0.006878637708723545, 0.03575832024216652, 0.023295892402529716, 0.006589180789887905, 0.03078090026974678, 0.03279600664973259, -0.03263639286160469, -0.012470507994294167, 0.03796933591365814, -0.04659409821033478, -0.02439384162425995, 0.02589825540781021, -0.031029751524329185, -0.02196640893816948, -0.0017345990054309368, 0.04439837858080864, -0.03326164931058884, -0.0030699262861162424, 0.09235962480306625, 0.029469119384884834, 0.06165990233421326, -0.07089557498693466, -0.12908947467803955, -0.03698777034878731, -0.004610692150890827, 0.007056024391204119, -0.01041014026850462, -0.016288187354803085, -0.06635522097349167, -0.013154763728380203, 0.00032953693880699575, 0.05959504470229149, 0.03978137671947479, -0.02158048003911972, -0.013010297901928425, -0.033008262515068054, -0.008041411638259888, -0.007686989847570658, 0.028849847614765167, -0.009487997740507126, 0.032559119164943695, -0.007023822981864214, -0.043159086257219315, -0.0410003699362278, -0.04338663071393967, 0.015487080439925194, 0.02659888193011284, 0.015787020325660706, 0.022073863074183464, -0.051705874502658844, 0.045509595423936844, -0.05645162612199783, 0.07698150724172592, 0.03893831744790077, 0.02009633742272854, -0.10168763250112534, -0.03482440486550331, 0.08594397455453873, -0.02582327462732792, -0.024630820378661156, -0.038272157311439514, -0.02509663999080658, -0.06545738130807877, 0.023766664788126945, -0.04293380305171013, 0.015677878633141518, -0.014883805066347122, -0.030864208936691284, 0.071724534034729, 0.03141376003623009, -0.01613730937242508, 0.041197631508111954, -0.03802010416984558, -0.017900390550494194, 0.019598539918661118, 0.00490591861307621, 0.03917951136827469, 0.0454685352742672, -0.013031437061727047, 0.00716745387762785, 0.00966901145875454, 0.007374993059784174, 0.02520635910332203, 0.022364040836691856, -0.019836504012346268, 0.06353778392076492, -0.013694742694497108, -0.044692132622003555, 0.005670338403433561, 0.0205717533826828, -0.041150111705064774, -0.009849298745393753, -0.011264835484325886, -0.006170942913740873, -0.01480856817215681, -0.03363539278507233, -0.054585766047239304, -0.03777555003762245, -0.02078789472579956, 0.040062662214040756, 0.060385171324014664, -0.05992822349071503, 0.06389138847589493, 0.013979252427816391, 0.09781140834093094, -0.02513968199491501, 0.018921345472335815, 0.0601070374250412, 0.013526431284844875, -0.0483529157936573, -0.015247529372572899, -0.04942857846617699, -0.01815277338027954, 0.08305477350950241, 0.039223529398441315, -0.01468256488442421, -0.019717784598469734, -0.07099095731973648, 0.022872459143400192, -0.020324062556028366, -0.06128937005996704, 0.050453510135412216, -0.017423871904611588, -0.06938299536705017, -0.04007907211780548, -0.01963680610060692, -0.014686615206301212, 0.07157769799232483, 0.001635837834328413, -0.034327708184719086, 0.02154816873371601, -0.017029203474521637, 0.0038125920109450817, -0.02466706931591034, -0.012345077469944954, -0.02096242643892765, 0.032136376947164536, -0.010734076611697674, 0.0037431346718221903, -0.00018928214558400214, 0.003356863046064973, 0.01757141947746277, 0.06455864012241364, -0.04751606285572052, -0.10436289757490158, 0.03447192907333374, 0.0302946325391531, -0.04786406457424164, -0.02487405203282833, 0.02768074907362461, -0.0005239521851763129, -0.0380026213824749, -0.008768376894295216, -0.02252230793237686, -0.0018943436443805695, -0.00974506326019764, 0.004515951033681631, 0.025428561493754387, 0.013557805679738522, -0.013921291567385197, -0.057456716895103455, 0.01150747574865818, -0.020009726285934448, -0.03456038609147072, 0.014109182171523571, -0.014813744463026524, 0.0016644047573208809, 0.05520480126142502, 0.05803719535470009, -0.014625385403633118, 0.031769707798957825, 0.010920492000877857, -0.041807159781455994, 0.007731847930699587, 0.05176166817545891, -0.07826973497867584, 0.06812784820795059, 0.01852274313569069, -0.012281609699130058, 0.01875617913901806, 0.006551783066242933, 0.05109703168272972, -0.06692659854888916, 0.04126190394163132, 0.06991938501596451, 0.04642091318964958, 0.026369309052824974, 0.014896386303007603, -0.04920831695199013, -0.03581271693110466, 0.06597059965133667, -0.0003446388873271644, 0.02074863389134407, -0.06313659250736237, 0.01721162348985672, -0.03397189825773239, -0.02819882333278656, -0.043836578726768494, -0.00964166596531868, -0.047317538410425186, 0.016528839245438576, -0.054823342710733414, 0.0032025312539190054, -0.03267079219222069, 0.030108166858553886, 0.005411447957158089, -0.0416330024600029, 0.0009487498900853097, 0.0074111963622272015, -0.007326160091906786, 0.05806690454483032, -0.009017511270940304, 0.0012766992440447211, -0.0363595224916935, -0.002863051602616906, -0.021476522088050842, 0.012706306762993336, 0.005818119738250971, -0.027822837233543396, 0.014439437538385391, 0.04063616320490837, -0.022285280749201775, 0.013145009987056255, 0.025803538039326668, -0.03470882400870323, 0.1122455969452858, -0.046476565301418304, -0.0356682725250721, 0.034955546259880066, 0.076370008289814, -0.011427885852754116, -0.008055906742811203, 0.050844259560108185, -0.026746556162834167, 0.012537326663732529, -0.002018333412706852, -0.0824752226471901, 0.0014874506741762161, 0.004166192375123501, -0.016302689909934998 ]
<p>In probability theory, <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schramm%E2%80%93Loewner_evolution" rel="nofollow">the Schramm–Loewner evolution</a>, also known as stochastic Loewner evolution or SLE, is a conformally invariant stochastic process. It is a family of random planar curves that are generated by solving Loewner's differential equation with Brownian motion as input. The motivation for SLE was as a candidate for the scaling limit of "loop-erased random walk" (LERW) and, later, as a scaling limit of various other planar processes. </p> <p>My question is about connections of SLE with theoretical physics, applications of SLE to theoretical physics and also applications of (other) theoretical physics to SLE. I will be happy to learn about various examples of such connections/applications preferably described as much as possible in a non-technical way. </p>
g1616
[ 0.023148920387029648, 0.002410100307315588, 0.012629606761038303, 0.0018674877937883139, 0.0030223564244806767, 0.04630395397543907, -0.004227069206535816, 0.0394902341067791, -0.01745506376028061, 0.006345559377223253, -0.017202556133270264, -0.018111292272806168, 0.054463427513837814, 0.04026498273015022, 0.007595107890665531, -0.06953252851963043, 0.0005078602116554976, 0.02111237496137619, 0.02630205638706684, -0.02393932081758976, -0.006355160381644964, 0.05249468982219696, 0.023013131693005562, -0.03871231526136398, 0.0008019284578040242, 0.0066480571404099464, -0.0009820127161219716, -0.026904305443167686, -0.012401513755321503, -0.05195615813136101, 0.056292712688446045, -0.0144224613904953, 0.03926998749375343, -0.07166845351457596, 0.02284674160182476, -0.04708484560251236, 0.03731841966509819, -0.026886271312832832, 0.05225753039121628, 0.019892357289791107, 0.02108513005077839, 0.017224835231900215, 0.029863456264138222, -0.06059616431593895, 0.025795599445700645, 0.05456938594579697, -0.04441827908158302, 0.008074858225882053, 0.02637510560452938, 0.01183704100549221, -0.020884361118078232, -0.013752680271863937, 0.042877789586782455, -0.0018017407273873687, -0.005265077110379934, -0.020656408742070198, 0.010766862891614437, -0.04513028636574745, 0.04906628653407097, 0.010173093527555466, -0.03686941787600517, 0.03156193345785141, -0.021397246047854424, -0.02947700209915638, 0.05777943506836891, 0.027928119525313377, -0.002313871867954731, -0.004278984852135181, 0.0890008956193924, 0.023255376145243645, 0.09460552781820297, -0.021573564037680626, -0.06308471411466599, -0.035575345158576965, 0.032768771052360535, 0.057534392923116684, 0.03908691555261612, -0.008851471357047558, 0.027030209079384804, 0.005757568404078484, -0.1104351207613945, 0.012681156396865845, -0.041708435863256454, 0.03320835903286934, 0.07503719627857208, 0.027951063588261604, -0.03008952923119068, 0.043054431676864624, -0.026514362543821335, 0.0017037270590662956, 0.019155550748109818, 0.009838171303272247, 0.0035989931784570217, -0.044098399579524994, -0.07030370086431503, -0.06060527265071869, -0.009942904114723206, 0.07572934776544571, 0.0015030369395390153, 0.0276945773512125, -0.032589830458164215, -0.006827501114457846, 0.0347425639629364, 0.025136709213256836, 0.050705499947071075, 0.037954602390527725, 0.018890758976340294, -0.012461712583899498, 0.035229943692684174, 0.03724890574812889, -0.009315235540270805, -0.00874884333461523, -0.015420332551002502, 0.04490246623754501, -0.01160525530576706, 0.012880153022706509, 0.03164901211857796, -0.03188299760222435, 0.06242351979017258, 0.038879070430994034, 0.03320928290486336, 0.037896979600191116, 0.0519566535949707, -0.014430252835154533, -0.0364922359585762, 0.005213082768023014, 0.010306833311915398, -0.04510418698191643, -0.01622183434665203, -0.046698197722435, 0.018291063606739044, -0.00863353256136179, -0.00795477069914341, -0.006790317595005035, 0.0063661388121545315, 0.021078601479530334, -0.017021017149090767, 0.0343419574201107, 0.0558716244995594, -0.019889824092388153, 0.020051131024956703, -0.05792269483208656, 0.03120812401175499, 0.0047978623770177364, -0.0054425341077148914, 0.06643172353506088, -0.05432127043604851, -0.025034863501787186, -0.059324417263269424, -0.005690432153642178, -0.05707331374287605, 0.03920844569802284, -0.09012138843536377, -0.06558991968631744, 0.025232495740056038, 0.02986207604408264, -0.05865653231739998, -0.06355077773332596, 0.009992644190788269, 0.04039197042584419, 0.021131331101059914, -0.06304417550563812, 0.05948568880558014, 0.022142214700579643, -0.03167012333869934, 0.05021650344133377, 0.02095421776175499, -0.05964118614792824, -0.004040971864014864, -0.02048116736114025, -0.015231428667902946, -0.014901033602654934, 0.06112075597047806, 0.027224207296967506, -0.013020271435379982, 0.08522312343120575, -0.01866159774363041, -0.026602253317832947, -0.015516777522861958, -0.010288218036293983, 0.00144704501144588, -0.017925838008522987, 0.022051488980650902, -0.05275652930140495, 0.030464591458439827, 0.005380434915423393, 0.023896902799606323, 0.03487833961844444, 0.003644594457000494, -0.04713234305381775, 0.027872908860445023, -0.03421855345368385, -0.07975886017084122, -0.014336368069052696, -0.019834432750940323, -0.06509407609701157, -0.05267158895730972, -0.0682564452290535, 0.014025728218257427, -0.05963116139173508, -0.028712119907140732, -0.00571346003562212, 0.04274434596300125, -0.011003309860825539, 0.02159281075000763, -0.0035511397290974855, -0.03262457624077797, -0.045381877571344376, -0.03189782053232193, 0.02333633229136467, 0.039667245000600815, -0.010704902932047844, 0.0555037185549736, -0.04555787891149521, 0.02212369255721569, 0.04959970340132713, -0.004939727950841188, -0.006724159698933363, -0.010827268473803997, 0.044110506772994995, 0.07881282269954681, -0.03906296566128731, -0.0002363998064538464, 0.019467012956738472, 0.001839110511355102, -0.01001768745481968, -0.0593903623521328, -0.03542948141694069, 0.005910725798457861, 0.03241174668073654, -0.04875026270747185, 0.06307537108659744, -0.0479796826839447, -0.0007479276973754168, 0.06966761499643326, 0.02938202954828739, -0.0023512395564466715, -0.03387613967061043, -0.007666416931897402, -0.013964774087071419, -0.01991945318877697, 0.005799694452434778, -0.03849203139543533, -0.010713672265410423, 0.04675585776567459, 0.0017517800442874432, -0.008985551074147224, -0.028829781338572502, 0.033479709178209305, 0.03782789409160614, 0.010515480302274227, -0.045203108340501785, -0.028516197577118874, -0.020811935886740685, 0.00460775988176465, 0.002745594596490264, 0.036006905138492584, 0.0421249084174633, -0.017519712448120117, -0.014615939930081367, -0.04548196122050285, 0.06560291349887848, -0.02446485124528408, 0.009796530939638615, 0.008921227417886257, 0.011110062710940838, -0.001550166285596788, -0.034717172384262085, -0.05921294912695885, -0.034205932170152664, 0.012712342664599419, 0.05081646144390106, 0.0035028657875955105, -0.000246400129981339, 0.03797190263867378, -0.023382311686873436, -0.011251227930188179, -0.050058167427778244, 0.04472697153687477, -0.06418014317750931, 0.03632509708404541, -0.06658562272787094, -0.03156227245926857, 0.02643791027367115, -0.019558202475309372, -0.04078669100999832, 0.05267878994345665, -0.01145720761269331, 0.02495083026587963, 0.05811178684234619, -0.030246267095208168, 0.025010792538523674, 0.037999093532562256, -0.05205082520842552, -0.025712979957461357, 0.06786013394594193, -0.015453875996172428, -0.03758438676595688, -0.056294236332178116, 0.05485989525914192, -0.012570774182677269, -0.04157231003046036, 0.037352483719587326, 0.03277813270688057, 0.05584489926695824, 0.03569629788398743, -0.06497939676046371, -0.00024959861184470356, 0.0018812307389453053, 0.06925909221172333, -0.04308927804231644, 0.012963415123522282, 0.0240465197712183, 0.006073508877307177, -0.026536036282777786, -0.012480382807552814, 0.01263838354498148, 0.01267909538000822, 0.018823688849806786, -0.09599341452121735, -0.028751403093338013, 0.02024461328983307, -0.0026336153969168663, -0.041262004524469376, 0.03482159227132797, -0.03820843994617462, -0.042301952838897705, 0.006232504732906818, -0.05025732144713402, -0.05996723100543022, -0.0027342771645635366, -0.005013446789234877, 0.023505685850977898, -0.018647952005267143, -0.02533203363418579, -0.04745461419224739, -0.11106546223163605, -0.030444161966443062, 0.037354446947574615, -0.04511687532067299, -0.011486711911857128, -0.018989993259310722, -0.02763153426349163, 0.010340598411858082, 0.023960215970873833, 0.009079758077859879, 0.011147853918373585, -0.033313825726509094, 0.011866358108818531, -0.06946215778589249, 0.021511798724532127, 0.00013097508053760976, 0.035938192158937454, -0.0004196508089080453, -0.030280811712145805, 0.000961554585956037, 0.030269624665379524, 0.025204258039593697, 0.019468609243631363, 0.013296309858560562, -0.04442742466926575, -0.0012401051353663206, -0.05024145916104317, 0.04419977217912674, -0.019152535125613213, -0.021995633840560913, 0.021201880648732185, 0.03235858306288719, 0.042266156524419785, -0.04784756153821945, 0.04658134654164314, 0.0021297663915902376, -0.005448529031127691, -0.01698116399347782, 0.013522890396416187, 0.049518730491399765, -0.003390781581401825, 0.06118234992027283, -0.08908896893262863, 0.0070617650635540485, 0.02482064999639988, 0.020571907982230186, 0.030383501201868057, 0.06040187552571297, -0.013211689889431, -0.029784230515360832, -0.052636973559856415, -0.01922396570444107, -0.08371274173259735, -0.006900671869516373, 0.014966064132750034, -0.027839448302984238, -0.03725571930408478, -0.01550686452537775, -0.013921336270868778, -0.012354054488241673, 0.0019397665746510029, 0.0034648324362933636, 0.06794852763414383, 0.010357742197811604, 0.03003702685236931, -0.022242939099669456, -0.009018155746161938, -0.05243247002363205, -0.011339740827679634, 0.007326831575483084, 0.03306767717003822, 0.001443582004867494, -0.012726916931569576, -0.02597653865814209, 0.009446297772228718, 0.017939547076821327, 0.006710763089358807, -0.061924729496240616, -0.01491567213088274, -0.025972669944167137, -0.030233336612582207, -0.09968940913677216, -0.01584712229669094, 0.051069457083940506, 0.00910349190235138, -0.030616000294685364, 0.016944561153650284, 0.012663043104112148, -0.0059494697488844395, 0.047463905066251755, 0.004992923699319363, 0.0012462894665077329, -0.03423527628183365, -0.11180984973907471, 0.036229878664016724, 0.06453147530555725, 0.043801117688417435, -0.000006950207989575574, -0.0495871864259243, 0.02447640895843506, 0.02761741913855076, 0.07861094176769257, -0.09120193123817444, 0.019122174009680748, 0.035128165036439896, -0.04158167541027069, 0.08931000530719757, 0.028073756024241447, 0.014040125533938408, 0.033392664045095444, -0.08954596519470215, -0.02390875108540058, -0.015641093254089355, -0.00018185815133620054, -0.05240849032998085, 0.022165721282362938, -0.011303210631012917, 0.007022649049758911, 0.00773861538618803, -0.03673332929611206, -0.027518395334482193, 0.07756687700748444, -0.002658064477145672, 0.02104557678103447, -0.03817910701036453, 0.004099431447684765, -0.033296771347522736, -0.016137145459651947, 0.0034188651479780674, -0.05488601326942444, -0.016379687935113907, 0.00860456470400095, -0.013586966320872307, -0.049470748752355576, -0.005014058202505112, -0.03358830511569977, -0.0011783504160121083, 0.00963421817868948, -0.06656549870967865, -0.05401145666837692, 0.007258654106408358, -0.01576029323041439, 0.008014751598238945, -0.05133121833205223, -0.02699754200875759, -0.021361157298088074, -0.011840784922242165, -0.05475257337093353, -0.06289564818143845, 0.033757034689188004, -0.035853780806064606, 0.00480959378182888, -0.06097434461116791, -0.006197175942361355, 0.010502361692488194, 0.032257501035928726, 0.08343812078237534, 0.03280871361494064, -0.019948581233620644, -0.012965726666152477, 0.03874368593096733, 0.02452661469578743, -0.027533113956451416, 0.021896785125136375, -0.031774651259183884, -0.00875493511557579, 0.004192849155515432, -0.0035891735460609198, 0.017218513414263725, 0.05515356734395027, 0.024673942476511, 0.023510994389653206, -0.026327695697546005, -0.0011748017277568579, -0.006331040058284998, 0.06659980118274689, -0.016142163425683975, -0.008519728668034077, 0.01633603684604168, 0.008155188523232937, -0.057884566485881805, -0.033988527953624725, 0.0019231569021940231, -0.03662986308336258, -0.0030416781082749367, 0.02088085375726223, -0.015146493911743164, -0.030491845682263374, 0.014676407910883427, 0.020654793828725815, -0.03493561968207359, 0.02922331728041172, -0.029166650027036667, 0.053836505860090256, 0.01685378886759281, -0.011436975561082363, 0.007161315996199846, 0.0398242212831974, 0.008431484922766685, -0.013566589914262295, -0.025224564597010612, 0.04426179081201553, -0.009810264222323895, 0.023852050304412842, -0.041812289506196976, -0.007229874841868877, -0.0019795820116996765, 0.02614135481417179, -0.056540973484516144, 0.018605783581733704, 0.01397651806473732, 0.0006701373495161533, 0.02576746605336666, -0.048759713768959045, -0.050004828721284866, -0.011429397389292717, 0.04180987551808357, -0.02482893504202366, 0.0025917966850101948, -0.007700206246227026, 0.015592618845403194, -0.014703063294291496, -0.019466163590550423, 0.05509790778160095, 0.04329349100589752, -0.020722009241580963, 0.07556766271591187, -0.008528248406946659, 0.007130882237106562, 0.01736481674015522, 0.002652978291735053, -0.05611412972211838, 0.030330268666148186, 0.04695935174822807, 0.038775574415922165, 0.016583295539021492, 0.014147168025374413, 0.055247023701667786, -0.01432419940829277, -0.04995034262537956, 0.017396245151758194, -0.0464567169547081, -0.04425717517733574, -0.009096848778426647, -0.01929977349936962, 0.08092817664146423, 0.04092906415462494, -0.037661802023649216, -0.052229661494493484, 0.015301606617867947, -0.04646375775337219, -0.03546047955751419, 0.018926195800304413, -0.026497317478060722, -0.07875102758407593, 0.005316790658980608, -0.017230534926056862, 0.004534812178462744, 0.0011892449110746384, -0.03087347000837326, 0.025659458711743355, -0.014075059443712234, -0.03609336540102959, 0.02496439404785633, -0.04836713895201683, -0.015633147209882736, 0.016422346234321594, 0.03789621591567993, 0.00015680264914408326, -0.003952878061681986, -0.06728775054216385, 0.027105683460831642, 0.0633077397942543, -0.0249168761074543, 0.008673220872879028, -0.00872440729290247, -0.003894063178449869, 0.02270538918673992, 0.02153143659234047, -0.0167859960347414, -0.021613778546452522, 0.006550376303493977, -0.05253833904862404, -0.02025992050766945, 0.04800824448466301, 0.052710458636283875, -0.012570034712553024, -0.02546493336558342, -0.06919366121292114, 0.018099717795848846, 0.005731701850891113, 0.0174576286226511, -0.007475913502275944, 0.0033826709259301424, -0.02875611186027527, 0.013671067543327808, 0.014221171848475933, 0.04250441491603851, 0.041025079786777496, 0.08647904545068741, -0.0014767729444429278, -0.024285651743412018, 0.05639703944325447, 0.052161604166030884, 0.036815788596868515, -0.019644418731331825, 0.07724407315254211, 0.029071995988488197, -0.03417414426803589, -0.0017255173297598958, -0.03484995290637016, 0.014465331099927425, -0.014136572368443012, -0.0060874768532812595, 0.036026787012815475, 0.01788627915084362, -0.04241525009274483, -0.015953082591295242, -0.004805953241884708, 0.0020850361324846745, -0.024559250101447105, 0.06475180387496948, 0.03325163200497627, -0.04363667219877243, -0.038926612585783005, 0.017071383073925972, 0.03221406415104866, -0.04983266443014145, -0.02529768832027912, 0.045134738087654114, -0.021973662078380585, -0.020605918020009995, -0.01728689856827259, 0.039943061769008636, -0.00363039318472147, -0.049926143139600754, -0.03556828200817108, 0.0011488173622637987, -0.014016426168382168, 0.009977436624467373, 0.0002568500058259815, 0.017199549823999405, 0.006037600804120302, 0.029237762093544006, -0.008978079073131084, 0.018653351813554764, -0.005446454044431448, -0.04920594021677971, -0.03206940367817879, 0.0581224299967289, 0.01156962476670742, 0.027920937165617943, -0.027250679209828377, -0.013017360121011734, -0.04152604565024376, 0.047711849212646484, 0.013705691322684288, -0.007263799197971821, 0.024316947907209396, 0.011163929477334023, -0.004571014083921909, -0.026435645297169685, 0.03073006682097912, 0.10347165912389755, 0.06528246402740479, -0.043407175689935684, -0.007505204528570175, -0.025144001469016075, 0.020650630816817284, -0.0020771557465195656, 0.013571822084486485, -0.029908742755651474, -0.02414301224052906, -0.018472997471690178, -0.0481630377471447, 0.019645020365715027, 0.03942444175481796, 0.009780023247003555, 0.07403741776943207, 0.07123268395662308, 0.05030675232410431, -0.01171074528247118, 0.02041047438979149, 0.010865273885428905, 0.028194187209010124, 0.01008964516222477, -0.004215703811496496, -0.024704448878765106, 0.032057151198387146, 0.05603032186627388, -0.03594743832945824, 0.0025058581959456205, 0.021588489413261414, -0.0077409204095602036, 0.0168147012591362, -0.021666983142495155, -0.0217430517077446, 0.02358199656009674, -0.09257380664348602, 0.004633749835193157, 0.03535100445151329, 0.045015834271907806, -0.01414357591420412, 0.0019562197849154472, 0.03534293174743652, -0.029988309368491173, 0.060917794704437256, 0.0017986457096412778, 0.004212675150483847, -0.050190430134534836, 0.0048850299790501595, 0.011670920997858047, -0.01759333722293377, 0.05934334173798561, -0.00217207008972764, 0.039709459990262985, 0.031006351113319397, 0.058858588337898254, 0.01797350123524666, -0.01972111687064171, -0.009159297682344913, -0.009935546666383743, 0.05228450149297714, 0.026538051664829254, -0.023482350632548332, 0.00486418604850769, 0.058548714965581894, -0.029256947338581085, -0.07979472726583481, 0.0051780277863144875, -0.01162363588809967, 0.031997617334127426 ]
<p>Are we fooled into thinking that expansion of the universe is accelerating, when in fact, time itself is slowing?</p> <p>Or if dark energy does exist?</p>
g26
[ 0.10342509299516678, 0.07165074348449707, 0.026244696229696274, -0.018395856022834778, -0.0020302291959524155, 0.010945059359073639, -0.04103967174887657, 0.010509739629924297, -0.03268221393227577, -0.05544569343328476, 0.10258114337921143, -0.02110729180276394, -0.03556758910417557, -0.0006158016039989889, 0.01829681359231472, -0.021233323961496353, -0.002449789084494114, -0.04329609498381615, 0.008072854951024055, 0.004936120938509703, -0.006373252719640732, -0.024850724264979362, 0.04001476988196373, -0.0219899769872427, -0.014855355024337769, -0.008313721977174282, -0.02070911042392254, -0.06972275674343109, 0.026551898568868637, -0.0496613085269928, 0.022815048694610596, 0.0036905158776789904, 0.021641142666339874, 0.03822333738207817, 0.01333364937454462, -0.011194754391908646, 0.029962783679366112, -0.020689792931079865, 0.03012191317975521, -0.02416209690272808, -0.04603889212012291, 0.04362626001238823, -0.02868708036839962, 0.010558653622865677, 0.05805099010467529, 0.020627489313483238, -0.030343038961291313, 0.03133995085954666, 0.03347006067633629, -0.06790028512477875, -0.0393306165933609, 0.02070567198097706, 0.04763198271393776, 0.07036067545413971, -0.008450296707451344, 0.012707360088825226, -0.007613097783178091, -0.01963982917368412, 0.07445253431797028, 0.02424210123717785, -0.010405429638922215, -0.005349649116396904, 0.13065548241138458, 0.005195550620555878, 0.014719538390636444, 0.032758936285972595, -0.0026297038421034813, -0.01777307689189911, 0.09250189363956451, -0.04643038287758827, 0.0532020628452301, -0.040268540382385254, -0.02508966438472271, -0.007722849957644939, 0.006015146151185036, 0.0034515822771936655, 0.009894589893519878, -0.03704031929373741, -0.03492375463247299, 0.001498543075285852, -0.030743293464183807, 0.017659751698374748, -0.061490289866924286, 0.0036655680742114782, -0.00788114033639431, -0.034548934549093246, -0.014075961895287037, 0.018058937042951584, 0.03196510672569275, 0.035681966692209244, 0.027166659012436867, -0.01926545985043049, 0.04991666227579117, 0.007358983159065247, -0.034913092851638794, 0.011186824180185795, -0.022567076608538628, 0.07098768651485443, 0.00927756167948246, 0.00774031225591898, -0.07918021082878113, 0.029899369925260544, 0.006905438378453255, -0.022766241803765297, 0.03664626181125641, -0.028822600841522217, -0.024437500163912773, -0.08546958118677139, -0.008848733268678188, -0.028346329927444458, 0.02610505372285843, -0.04790165275335312, -0.0029397406615316868, -0.042294278740882874, -0.008208941668272018, -0.03314264491200447, 0.029001621529459953, 0.043726466596126556, -0.014222226105630398, -0.009051513858139515, 0.006572841666638851, 0.03640824183821678, 0.0016029366524890065, 0.014856750145554543, 0.002206397708505392, -0.02616172470152378, -0.009903780184686184, -0.044980838894844055, -0.02860633097589016, -0.028117844834923744, -0.0008377268677577376, 0.0320453867316246, 0.028761185705661774, 0.06690308451652527, 0.022537456825375557, 0.003004919271916151, 0.007364267483353615, -0.03731520101428032, -0.03413094952702522, 0.06888768821954727, 0.022308913990855217, -0.020130135118961334, 0.02458113804459572, -0.007491379510611296, -0.011374576017260551, 0.004873254336416721, -0.049526430666446686, -0.0411481149494648, -0.004168848041445017, 0.03883339464664459, -0.03435909003019333, 0.10861372202634811, 0.016310708597302437, -0.009860989637672901, -0.002367951674386859, 0.022673428058624268, 0.00976310484111309, -0.005678712390363216, 0.00997560191899538, 0.022301722317934036, 0.031152015551924706, -0.008638786152005196, 0.018984738737344742, -0.012550437822937965, 0.023140396922826767, -0.012445094995200634, 0.0631742924451828, -0.05344001576304436, 0.007825245149433613, 0.034094374626874924, -0.032296549528837204, -0.008554572239518166, 0.013922409154474735, -0.03310421109199524, 0.029344450682401657, 0.029774000868201256, 0.0761755108833313, -0.04743211716413498, -0.13338235020637512, -0.008441311307251453, -0.006913905497640371, -0.03464522957801819, -0.044362351298332214, -0.04836180806159973, 0.07826678454875946, -0.016858257353305817, -0.018383700400590897, -0.01971559226512909, 0.012995533645153046, -0.0011289232643321157, 0.02982049249112606, -0.009024934843182564, 0.05913868546485901, 0.044590070843696594, 0.016403719782829285, 0.005620996002107859, 0.0015904970932751894, -0.03616325929760933, -0.029244907200336456, 0.01896532066166401, 0.05272570997476578, -0.009272769093513489, 0.02642701379954815, -0.04095001146197319, 0.06273005902767181, -0.0004597694205585867, -0.03517436608672142, 0.0042210170067846775, 0.1071820855140686, -0.02648892067372799, 0.06831876188516617, -0.011041569523513317, -0.017756983637809753, 0.007248684298247099, 0.006609790958464146, -0.010362695902585983, -0.013607548549771309, 0.0655834972858429, 0.017496472224593163, 0.027745358645915985, -0.030311955139040947, 0.004900258034467697, -0.02404634840786457, 0.0036734433379024267, 0.013993807137012482, -0.016843361780047417, -0.07287795096635818, -0.06861486285924911, -0.026474272832274437, 0.02143675647675991, -0.04358060285449028, 0.03944190591573715, -0.013126928359270096, 0.022935861721634865, 0.04839462414383888, -0.0019258047686889768, -0.040925122797489166, -0.004811193328350782, 0.04012444615364075, 0.04779377207159996, -0.026546496897935867, -0.027446523308753967, -0.018744144588708878, 0.016704289242625237, 0.024567166343331337, -0.08146833628416061, 0.050746507942676544, -0.05672338604927063, 0.030853930860757828, 0.016577869653701782, 0.03525492548942566, -0.01832231879234314, -0.02047058939933777, 0.009495304897427559, 0.0372769795358181, 0.0018162454944103956, -0.0338025763630867, 0.028215700760483742, -0.04773382842540741, -0.0023177473340183496, 0.045070499181747437, 0.04103347659111023, 0.05046097934246063, -0.00846811756491661, -0.012634661048650742, -0.007056079804897308, -0.05387676879763603, -0.023819249123334885, -0.033996179699897766, 0.01819230057299137, 0.006327228154987097, -0.008717261254787445, -0.003157480852678418, -0.032766569405794144, 0.03854789957404137, 0.03393283486366272, -0.011231458745896816, -0.019187351688742638, 0.03997237980365753, -0.023493152111768723, -0.07267400622367859, -0.009748348034918308, -0.04622944816946983, 0.0471787266433239, 0.01908324658870697, -0.08111226558685303, -0.04655890166759491, -0.04505567625164986, -0.015422951430082321, 0.01783604361116886, 0.0012204101076349616, 0.021503111347556114, 0.007267992943525314, 0.021362151950597763, -0.04845289885997772, 0.015246247872710228, -0.0523882731795311, -0.037690840661525726, -0.010386854410171509, -0.02401408925652504, 0.03415975347161293, -0.052637066692113876, -0.006873298902064562, 0.01833709329366684, 0.05109237879514694, 0.041011594235897064, 0.005718185566365719, 0.006134899333119392, -0.04436398670077324, -0.04882745072245598, -0.0012014316162094474, 0.02225332520902157, 0.012373064644634724, 0.06648378074169159, 0.01128263771533966, -0.0013912474969401956, 0.0010048593394458294, 0.016291696578264236, 0.07002019137144089, 0.022655697539448738, 0.05600186809897423, -0.02496587485074997, -0.050927598029375076, 0.032241616398096085, 0.028257165104150772, 0.006807714235037565, 0.0011129933409392834, -0.02455674670636654, -0.04778241738677025, -0.0046460931189358234, -0.026095345616340637, -0.07863447070121765, -0.024751143530011177, 0.03334104269742966, -0.0034331874921917915, -0.020168466493487358, 0.016052307561039925, 0.048173703253269196, 0.04280814155936241, 0.0423586405813694, -0.05989964306354523, 0.02630229853093624, -0.016542958095669746, 0.08030775189399719, -0.0017218609573319554, 0.019050372764468193, -0.04140137508511543, -0.022339187562465668, -0.003320443443953991, 0.0008492380729876459, 0.04065275564789772, -0.011719392612576485, 0.010784938000142574, 0.0256367027759552, -0.0046004378236830235, 0.03666524589061737, 0.0004715699760708958, -0.016772398725152016, 0.02425176091492176, -0.030194612219929695, 0.005487953312695026, 0.03131541237235069, 0.03768753260374069, 0.0018717123894020915, -0.04267653450369835, 0.01988036558032036, -0.011688482016324997, 0.040168698877096176, 0.005974084138870239, 0.01651945151388645, 0.02885422483086586, 0.016319798305630684, 0.0032135623041540384, 0.0730106309056282, 0.07668525725603104, -0.007402829360216856, -0.018521372228860855, 0.01726655848324299, 0.027742182835936546, -0.011975469067692757, 0.04649157077074051, 0.018767891451716423, 0.010775323957204819, 0.04853162541985512, -0.03622734174132347, 0.01564100570976734, -0.039245668798685074, -0.08359350264072418, 0.004334220662713051, -0.03066609613597393, 0.0815281793475151, 0.06330054253339767, 0.019147004932165146, 0.008299237117171288, -0.010671325959265232, -0.03712664544582367, 0.0248245969414711, -0.006824228446930647, -0.01284247450530529, -0.033327654004096985, 0.024084491655230522, -0.020013678818941116, 0.01927104778587818, -0.013850534334778786, -0.02033074013888836, 0.037171944975852966, 0.0286629106849432, -0.02458576299250126, 0.00437207380309701, -0.016533248126506805, 0.038872409611940384, 0.026722971349954605, -0.03342287242412567, -0.03237026184797287, 0.051928646862506866, -0.017553070560097694, 0.03203975409269333, -0.09006861597299576, -0.0023249536752700806, 0.023087361827492714, 0.011499792337417603, 0.02039673738181591, -0.035793568938970566, 0.013009218499064445, -0.06116986647248268, 0.07291770726442337, 0.014743206091225147, -0.02288343757390976, -0.06266175955533981, 0.02291078120470047, 0.006407660432159901, -0.004319879692047834, 0.018441030755639076, 0.03241613507270813, 0.04685143008828163, 0.004239555448293686, 0.029781075194478035, 0.05821410194039345, 0.007543778046965599, 0.018827607855200768, 0.01905311830341816, -0.006242683157324791, 0.04974258318543434, 0.0658380389213562, -0.01664607599377632, 0.06679479777812958, -0.06301650404930115, -0.01871718466281891, 0.01684887707233429, 0.037536248564720154, -0.0449468195438385, 0.062097806483507156, 0.02421029843389988, -0.01621071808040142, 0.030683450400829315, -0.018905922770500183, -0.01391852367669344, 0.005100802052766085, -0.06791552156209946, 0.06382883340120316, -0.07315900921821594, 0.04215718060731888, -0.008505591191351414, 0.016377151012420654, -0.005277619231492281, 0.0019793196115642786, -0.034481462091207504, -0.04596361890435219, -0.022490832954645157, -0.007305601611733437, -0.031668443232774734, -0.025331737473607063, -0.06261765956878662, -0.024144522845745087, -0.005994837731122971, -0.039058707654476166, -0.020756753161549568, -0.0025568995624780655, -0.020526550710201263, 0.04354238137602806, -0.0775374248623848, -0.007079632021486759, 0.04000690206885338, -0.04847848042845726, -0.013543060049414635, 0.05424966290593147, -0.02208681032061577, 0.017840581014752388, 0.0035061959642916918, -0.02622399292886257, 0.06180281564593315, -0.003704262198880315, 0.028278958052396774, -0.0242364089936018, -0.03198698163032532, 0.0844416469335556, 0.011500854045152664, -0.00046541966730728745, -0.03191334009170532, 0.03628365322947502, -0.05723056569695473, 0.007406746502965689, -0.030995430424809456, -0.052519943565130234, 0.01138131134212017, 0.06485339254140854, 0.027966396883130074, 0.004440858494490385, -0.012211188673973083, 0.0164767075330019, 0.02788695879280567, 0.009197083301842213, 0.011342328041791916, 0.023468587547540665, 0.037203434854745865, -0.07487063854932785, 0.00847612414509058, 0.01699216663837433, 0.006517588626593351, -0.0639837458729744, -0.026502804830670357, -0.0017531565390527248, 0.026861166581511497, 0.030378710478544235, 0.08642140030860901, 0.01751038059592247, 0.06230919435620308, -0.013951838947832584, 0.0059187342412769794, 0.027156876400113106, 0.07729924470186234, -0.01764608919620514, 0.012062594294548035, -0.08225715160369873, 0.011512457393109798, 0.07454525679349899, -0.00544841168448329, -0.011235957033932209, 0.011282588355243206, -0.05398835614323616, -0.014893461018800735, -0.024613162502646446, -0.004828259348869324, 0.000713692104909569, -0.028231807053089142, 0.06931023299694061, -0.05414627864956856, 0.01713642105460167, 0.02038601040840149, -0.07195459306240082, 0.030206162482500076, -0.05434759333729744, -0.024737941101193428, 0.021491942927241325, -0.014808556996285915, -0.01904214546084404, 0.014819035306572914, -0.005911628715693951, -0.03247366473078728, -0.01737244240939617, -0.02757111005485058, 0.014182094484567642, 0.0002984046295750886, -0.0326908677816391, 0.0010920956265181303, -0.056675706058740616, 0.03491000086069107, -0.029069339856505394, -0.025404872372746468, -0.05633823573589325, -0.027474476024508476, 0.061763934791088104, 0.006614224053919315, -0.017765207216143608, 0.013318762183189392, -0.02536182291805744, 0.027092570438981056, -0.03932000324130058, -0.05735361948609352, -0.0338885597884655, 0.020076502114534378, -0.037463583052158356, 0.03718085587024689, 0.009823378175497055, 0.06934888660907745, -0.012010561302304268, -0.0331844836473465, 0.052984971553087234, 0.011731045320630074, 0.015240038745105267, -0.006277407053858042, 0.030876342207193375, 0.013759609311819077, -0.06606729328632355, -0.09161940217018127, -0.039675336331129074, -0.0309390090405941, -0.022778648883104324, -0.04022974520921707, -0.021158279851078987, -0.05146324262022972, -0.04506291076540947, 0.055840298533439636, -0.03756353259086609, 0.07151485234498978, -0.07727702707052231, -0.052660971879959106, 0.04872678965330124, 0.04094041883945465, -0.0018881545402109623, 0.005340054631233215, 0.001000246382318437, -0.005018162541091442, 0.020088981837034225, -0.026032794266939163, 0.011453118175268173, 0.04602453112602234, -0.0070468042977154255, 0.02714161016047001, 0.038163017481565475, 0.05207992345094681, -0.003410730743780732, 0.008517362177371979, 0.056833524256944656, 0.013839839026331902, 0.009754573926329613, -0.0740661770105362, -0.016519511118531227, -0.00018136107246391475, -0.0040620435029268265, -0.007303770165890455, -0.013940527103841305, -0.03437045216560364, 0.03385533392429352, 0.0038067179266363382, 0.02709318697452545, 0.01756850816309452, 0.0612589456140995, -0.02491472288966179, -0.043289151042699814, -0.004381272010505199, -0.01539391465485096, 0.0027107500936836004, -0.0028905472718179226, -0.031064119189977646, -0.006478288676589727, 0.0015438977861776948, 0.00936271995306015, -0.021232565864920616, -0.049998246133327484, -0.022354213520884514, -0.07186903804540634, 0.015032858587801456, -0.027784716337919235, -0.010650010779500008, 0.00900019146502018, -0.0006102167535573244, -0.0308749508112669, 0.0047561596147716045, -0.0627840906381607, 0.040332116186618805, -0.03324050083756447, -0.07165072113275528, -0.01052229292690754, -0.0048683504574000835, 0.05013759061694145, 0.015285334549844265, -0.0218744445592165, -0.004183601122349501, -0.03328147158026695, 0.012220695614814758, 0.024939140304923058, -0.01648680679500103, 0.006089799106121063, -0.003248969092965126, -0.036435164511203766, -0.05261087790131569, -0.06551356613636017, 0.05659230425953865, 0.01050606183707714, 0.03269663453102112, 0.030074698850512505, -0.005603645462542772, 0.06573288142681122, 0.013037147000432014, 0.055649951100349426, 0.026113932952284813, -0.0715799629688263, -0.063980333507061, -0.010657207109034061, -0.0189767275005579, 0.010959870181977749, -0.024535899981856346, 0.013374865055084229, 0.03059610165655613, 0.039454441517591476, -0.01473475992679596, -0.013837090693414211, -0.07845891267061234, -0.012446805834770203, -0.08035806566476822, 0.04460534080862999, 0.042000118643045425, 0.022262468934059143, 0.009282441809773445, 0.0065599530935287476, 0.01234959065914154, 0.002552875317633152, -0.0571148656308651, 0.007503981236368418, 0.038209643214941025, -0.002428053878247738, -0.030541477724909782, -0.008168250322341919, 0.06337674707174301, -0.03264211490750313, -0.004875658079981804, -0.04028773307800293, 0.032349009066820145, -0.051708921790122986, -0.007265627384185791, -0.04079780355095863, -0.025632590055465698, -0.04880855977535248, 0.03508055582642555, 0.013107547536492348, 0.006948020774871111, 0.0032740384340286255, -0.006159015465527773, -0.03609190881252289, 0.015812156721949577, 0.01471477560698986, 0.0032185078598558903, -0.001684517483226955, -0.06304284185171127, 0.04245065525174141, 0.011078056879341602, 0.01423665601760149, -0.02043694071471691, 0.0018758211517706513, -0.008175818249583244, -0.032164983451366425, -0.012556960806250572, 0.043076470494270325, 0.009746672585606575, -0.046884890645742416, 0.026109805330634117, -0.0017796983011066914, 0.04392661526799202, 0.02349594607949257, 0.006658018101006746, -0.004710500128567219, -0.06975636631250381, 0.017498355358839035, 0.0378018319606781, -0.00945206731557846, -0.009510884061455727, 0.007318953983485699, -0.05726819857954979, 0.009862946346402168, 0.01949191279709339, -0.010284763760864735, 0.027912942692637444, -0.06891518831253052, 0.03165488317608833, -0.054400958120822906, -0.02102033980190754, 0.016042418777942657 ]
<p>I am a little bit perplexed as to how to compute the three-point correlation function for a massive scalar field, I know that it should be equal to zero.</p> <p>I need to show that: $\lim_{T\rightarrow \infty (1-i\epsilon)} \int D\phi \phi(x_1) \phi(x_2) \phi(x_3) = 0$</p> <p>How to show this?</p> <p>Edit: I forgot to mention without using the generating founction, $Z[J]$.</p>
g1617
[ 0.02211557887494564, 0.007918871007859707, 0.015702757984399796, -0.040242526680231094, 0.05049625039100647, 0.03470982611179352, 0.03918309509754181, 0.10181167721748352, -0.02789883315563202, 0.00926081370562315, -0.04128338024020195, 0.015269334428012371, -0.004495874512940645, -0.006946846842765808, -0.04179589822888374, -0.037370678037405014, 0.018815333023667336, 0.03555574268102646, -0.02461910806596279, -0.00011852800525957718, 0.011509919539093971, 0.051303841173648834, 0.011987011879682541, -0.012029359117150307, 0.05111360177397728, -0.042540017515420914, -0.029547924175858498, -0.03505337983369827, 0.03533434122800827, 0.017117192968726158, 0.06648415327072144, 0.06982627511024475, -0.014393489807844162, -0.017060255631804466, 0.04937468096613884, 0.009078062139451504, -0.013619122095406055, 0.07075031846761703, -0.03644568845629692, -0.019148750230669975, -0.05077771097421646, 0.03338780254125595, 0.0019194891210645437, 0.0202486589550972, -0.07747654616832733, -0.038060519844293594, 0.004423234146088362, 0.05380550026893616, -0.0308517012745142, -0.034656938165426254, -0.027936307713389397, 0.06067822128534317, 0.08806408941745758, 0.0200592540204525, -0.06939782947301865, 0.06054108962416649, -0.004777786321938038, -0.03760309889912605, 0.025576991960406303, 0.07832711189985275, -0.02103363163769245, -0.06897984445095062, -0.0082766218110919, 0.004598518367856741, 0.03127874806523323, -0.006337054073810577, -0.043286338448524475, -0.046418774873018265, -0.004670071415603161, -0.006966528482735157, -0.018074875697493553, -0.04306858032941818, 0.053718674927949905, -0.021344268694519997, -0.08667492866516113, 0.048820070922374725, 0.0368179976940155, -0.02832634747028351, 0.004637186881154776, 0.020755207166075706, -0.0053673917427659035, -0.0009132973500527442, 0.01028185710310936, 0.05424729362130165, -0.006634030025452375, -0.012599899433553219, 0.06946197897195816, -0.021375082433223724, -0.02210657112300396, 0.0016768795903772116, -0.007091802544891834, 0.08521981537342072, -0.017553560435771942, -0.02219582349061966, 0.00388486310839653, 0.0020043125841766596, -0.026462389156222343, 0.05992443487048149, 0.0036854478530585766, -0.020314937457442284, -0.007501333486288786, 0.02952389605343342, 0.07780472934246063, 0.0032395394518971443, -0.015963805839419365, -0.015280070714652538, 0.047395046800374985, -0.0011697814334183931, 0.003202633233740926, 0.015622854232788086, -0.0911707952618599, -0.02918068878352642, -0.009365566074848175, -0.04744146019220352, -0.007826144807040691, -0.007427476812154055, 0.031568992882966995, -0.03381550312042236, -0.0001288640924030915, 0.028287431225180626, -0.023641344159841537, -0.07237759232521057, 0.03195910528302193, 0.04959356039762497, -0.012033957988023758, 0.035527266561985016, -0.031345054507255554, 0.0062976498156785965, -0.027936089783906937, -0.025033488869667053, 0.02891233004629612, -0.000004690811238106107, -0.04874887689948082, 0.0017983870347961783, -0.015919804573059082, 0.045070815831422806, -0.05766822025179863, 0.0020719266030937433, -0.01568155363202095, 0.0659073069691658, -0.05003399774432182, -0.043706152588129044, -0.03426612168550491, -0.002282580593600869, -0.03667248412966728, 0.005209336988627911, 0.040582068264484406, -0.0774766132235527, 0.05852696672081947, -0.02581150084733963, 0.03148118779063225, 0.04158621281385422, -0.05278339982032776, 0.018977243453264236, 0.003037735354155302, 0.024589411914348602, 0.0038783778436481953, -0.026071052998304367, -0.01573314517736435, -0.052157867699861526, -0.018065953627228737, 0.014788846485316753, 0.05573335289955139, 0.011076982133090496, 0.02500220388174057, -0.03040008433163166, 0.03725649416446686, -0.05894516408443451, -0.06138036400079727, 0.005684159696102142, -0.04852307215332985, 0.04711923003196716, 0.048107217997312546, -0.05995138734579086, -0.029069731011986732, -0.002445208141580224, -0.04780951514840126, -0.022755905985832214, 0.03314933553338051, 0.025925016030669212, 0.0028317284304648638, -0.025906741619110107, -0.008954311721026897, 0.021033955737948418, -0.0020652220118790865, 0.005837264936417341, 0.04475853219628334, 0.033679552376270294, -0.04759557172656059, 0.04466409236192703, 0.0105861471965909, -0.003026444697752595, 0.016705850139260292, 0.009385665878653526, -0.018367890268564224, 0.05844391509890556, 0.04675093665719032, -0.07201458513736725, -0.008633400313556194, -0.0801454409956932, 0.0036917580291628838, 0.023764891549944878, 0.026110241189599037, 0.04080628976225853, -0.0426495261490345, -0.04658661410212517, 0.022768361493945122, 0.02296258881688118, -0.02006419375538826, 0.04579078406095505, -0.07770473510026932, -0.09761955589056015, -0.013121929951012135, -0.04788331687450409, 0.04250294715166092, -0.0409141406416893, -0.04969675466418266, -0.018942417576909065, -0.034082189202308655, 0.05189530551433563, -0.04106251895427704, -0.0213663037866354, 0.048268161714076996, 0.04137973487377167, 0.010018037632107735, 0.04514976218342781, -0.04141879081726074, -0.026937060058116913, 0.008902834728360176, -0.016808412969112396, -0.040218502283096313, 0.06713177263736725, -0.035020358860492706, 0.0062354751862585545, -0.006369423121213913, 0.016594380140304565, -0.027560895308852196, -0.023792091757059097, -0.005776966921985149, 0.11812668293714523, -0.03770752251148224, 0.03260260075330734, 0.01638578437268734, -0.012803200632333755, 0.028081616386771202, -0.08084466308355331, -0.013890440575778484, 0.004976323340088129, -0.03943370282649994, 0.01777184195816517, -0.02218373492360115, 0.054982006549835205, -0.004102935548871756, -0.0145093509927392, 0.01606670953333378, -0.033584799617528915, 0.060839053243398666, -0.011714942753314972, 0.050344571471214294, -0.06042609363794327, 0.017451658844947815, -0.10216221213340759, -0.010130178183317184, -0.002178825903683901, 0.011002594605088234, -0.025305679067969322, 0.006542530842125416, -0.037411388009786606, -0.01766962558031082, -0.013238082639873028, -0.024724388495087624, 0.024758176878094673, 0.07130397856235504, 0.01102143432945013, -0.034713611006736755, -0.03563361614942551, -0.06297516822814941, 0.04319360852241516, 0.06922869384288788, -0.05932529643177986, 0.014157658442854881, 0.0334477536380291, 0.014095807448029518, 0.0786469578742981, 0.044055402278900146, -0.01586649939417839, -0.018288616091012955, 0.0256779957562685, -0.01478634774684906, 0.02340991050004959, 0.019977634772658348, -0.00135959149338305, -0.030198588967323303, -0.007369623053818941, -0.007193134631961584, 0.000327344867400825, 0.028507323935627937, -0.0830782800912857, 0.020835254341363907, 0.034063518047332764, 0.057156678289175034, -0.03200085088610649, 0.05650026351213455, -0.046299368143081665, 0.05195287987589836, -0.009779778309166431, 0.016018424183130264, 0.0017311712726950645, -0.002209611237049103, 0.003483409993350506, -0.012739761732518673, -0.004027699586004019, -0.02479434758424759, -0.025419054552912712, 0.00801259744912386, 0.0410337969660759, 0.08885178714990616, 0.02380317449569702, 0.011095685884356499, -0.024189744144678116, -0.020874476060271263, -0.045396123081445694, 0.001043634139932692, -0.01696140319108963, 0.052836451679468155, 0.030376248061656952, -0.06545275449752808, 0.0020277239382267, -0.047091420739889145, -0.014530882239341736, -0.025239596143364906, -0.04164234548807144, 0.04512089863419533, -0.000984869198873639, -0.07490856200456619, -0.007644809316843748, -0.00826483778655529, 0.003896958427503705, 0.015367187559604645, -0.08206199109554291, -0.02905724011361599, 0.035431940108537674, -0.03740529343485832, -0.03662973642349243, 0.0003633159212768078, 0.03458806127309799, 0.0058550457470119, 0.032975953072309494, 0.022458955645561218, -0.016802532598376274, -0.01648145727813244, -0.018150262534618378, 0.008196026086807251, -0.00987032987177372, 0.0011421573581174016, 0.04881312698125839, 0.024290656670928, -0.01077418215572834, -0.023717638105154037, -0.04543551057577133, -0.024897783994674683, -0.014958522282540798, 0.014021233655512333, 0.014815508387982845, -0.017464911565184593, 0.014865286648273468, -0.0048130229115486145, -0.00034532835707068443, 0.035884350538253784, 0.048616327345371246, 0.026839645579457283, -0.004515625536441803, 0.060285262763500214, 0.029145315289497375, -0.02907295897603035, -0.11066341400146484, 0.026938345283269882, -0.028014738112688065, -0.009825777262449265, 0.023458002135157585, 0.03332073241472244, -0.0005798229249194264, 0.024210305884480476, -0.035989563912153244, 0.011114519089460373, 0.005166816990822554, -0.06140671670436859, 0.0005396443884819746, 0.060771383345127106, 0.029745811596512794, 0.03086595982313156, -0.04516930505633354, 0.02440638840198517, 0.029288915917277336, 0.03669709339737892, -0.04434569925069809, -0.011342913843691349, 0.045285165309906006, -0.027933180332183838, -0.02374083735048771, -0.005518186371773481, 0.008004225790500641, 0.051604703068733215, -0.05481037497520447, -0.03124861791729927, -0.048259325325489044, 0.0005422724061645567, -0.03083702363073826, 0.03467094153165817, -0.08269011974334717, 0.0017485169228166342, 0.028908386826515198, 0.041323207318782806, -0.04047699272632599, -0.0037663730327039957, -0.03789790719747543, 0.04360662400722504, 0.01893295906484127, 0.07380599528551102, 0.00021007373288739473, 0.02322498895227909, 0.006356966681778431, 0.03619561716914177, -0.003897806629538536, -0.026854006573557854, 0.050048116594552994, 0.00012059638538630679, -0.023792266845703125, -0.047966666519641876, 0.025452319532632828, 0.07145797461271286, 0.051198363304138184, 0.018791846930980682, 0.06772740930318832, 0.009731866419315338, 0.04085487872362137, -0.051754891872406006, 0.09079495817422867, 0.00682574138045311, -0.022124342620372772, 0.01578587479889393, -0.02370435558259487, 0.05111267790198326, 0.010292427614331245, -0.05562128499150276, -0.025094596669077873, -0.09182152152061462, -0.01884305477142334, 0.008678978309035301, 0.00006561376358149573, -0.005387482233345509, -0.01510081347078085, 0.0019220958929508924, 0.005333298817276955, 0.029520181939005852, -0.011920974589884281, 0.0009499987936578691, 0.03445405885577202, 0.012635686434805393, 0.026121316477656364, -0.020620819181203842, 0.018733825534582138, -0.021067146211862564, 0.026865726336836815, 0.0567207932472229, -0.014479474164545536, 0.009213844314217567, -0.031084494665265083, 0.0022206229623407125, -0.038429055362939835, 0.028935208916664124, -0.011575163342058659, 0.006500088144093752, 0.003209491493180394, -0.04170527681708336, -0.011761106550693512, -0.004342463333159685, -0.017552735283970833, -0.06499674916267395, -0.02854994870722294, 0.06695160269737244, -0.0003636106848716736, -0.0342550203204155, 0.003038734430447221, 0.018192818388342857, 0.0002448824525345117, -0.011420462280511856, -0.031203173100948334, -0.047182414680719376, -0.02600470371544361, 0.031129248440265656, 0.0046804919838905334, 0.01473721768707037, 0.020927442237734795, -0.01696147210896015, -0.03194722905755043, -0.005945970304310322, -0.03655330836772919, 0.03290558606386185, -0.008649099618196487, -0.06989295780658722, -0.020337505266070366, -0.04534696415066719, 0.006608203519135714, -0.019142771139740944, 0.014316419139504433, 0.011847692541778088, 0.0034624722320586443, 0.035914096981287, 0.0793905183672905, -0.04120832309126854, 0.05208088830113411, 0.013028072193264961, -0.007768677547574043, -0.043880004435777664, 0.005763712339103222, -0.02736472897231579, -0.03250209987163544, -0.018807528540492058, -0.03692373260855675, 0.05955387279391289, -0.02700185962021351, 0.02070874348282814, -0.022354362532496452, -0.0822099894285202, 0.02965894341468811, -0.019070783630013466, -0.044398240745067596, -0.01855526678264141, -0.023042701184749603, -0.03068694844841957, -0.04811018332839012, -0.043718371540308, -0.008241231553256512, -0.0004246840253472328, 0.016922948881983757, 0.02392435446381569, 0.007140295580029488, 0.03114522062242031, 0.03756170719861984, 0.05179288983345032, 0.00436436990275979, 0.024874718859791756, 0.020727613940835, -0.028972966596484184, 0.013997325673699379, -0.005650979932397604, -0.0014017182402312756, 0.054184723645448685, -0.005920349154621363, -0.00007308444764930755, 0.018057826906442642, 0.009166926145553589, -0.0485822819173336, 0.03298025205731392, -0.0018294707406312227, 0.04045088589191437, 0.005897575058043003, -0.014881577342748642, 0.02434573695063591, -0.04241747409105301, -0.0220012329518795, 0.021163174882531166, -0.05527305230498314, -0.007010658737272024, -0.03551269322633743, -0.02280835062265396, -0.01774352602660656, 0.016089260578155518, 0.01471351645886898, 0.026820018887519836, 0.013517329469323158, 0.004095845390111208, 0.03778765723109245, 0.06924187391996384, 0.06450408697128296, 0.03540230542421341, -0.012191629968583584, -0.030547456815838814, -0.012776963412761688, 0.025486968457698822, 0.047101277858018875, 0.07772542536258698, -0.07953662425279617, 0.004342195577919483, 0.036440715193748474, -0.022710729390382767, -0.04021008312702179, 0.03183767944574356, 0.01623125560581684, -0.05789119377732277, 0.011137152090668678, -0.026094533503055573, -0.0327804833650589, -0.005904254503548145, -0.077830471098423, 0.009433156810700893, 0.03892170637845993, -0.0016744165914133191, -0.003332811873406172, 0.023905958980321884, 0.058076854795217514, 0.007837465032935143, -0.06391128897666931, -0.029671503230929375, 0.022697001695632935, -0.014949237927794456, -0.027466624975204468, -0.0017494831699877977, 0.015529274940490723, 0.03290337324142456, 0.007316408678889275, 0.000844079942908138, 0.0437479205429554, 0.04945715516805649, -0.04420967027544975, 0.057636555284261703, 0.03378666564822197, -0.02809068374335766, 0.0009893750539049506, -0.02930089831352234, -0.013220679946243763, -0.008905616588890553, -0.015276863239705563, 0.02749590016901493, 0.01605243980884552, -0.020990418270230293, -0.009139534085988998, -0.02149238996207714, -0.041483182460069656, -0.00934103038161993, 0.024241773411631584, 0.007114752195775509, 0.060547780245542526, -0.019098442047834396, -0.023524966090917587, -0.00782890897244215, 0.01894211769104004, 0.035100165754556656, 0.07745791226625443, -0.015968376770615578, 0.049753859639167786, -0.03513365611433983, -0.028053807094693184, -0.05785193294286728, 0.0134373027831316, 0.03470715507864952, 0.04794255271553993, -0.060561418533325195, 0.009606923907995224, 0.038964640349149704, 0.023250142112374306, 0.03831084072589874, -0.037376392632722855, -0.030240947380661964, 0.003689943579956889, 0.06013502553105354, -0.02352793887257576, -0.03060263954102993, 0.037457309663295746, -0.05778452008962631, -0.0021369107998907566, -0.011982221156358719, 0.0012179074110463262, -0.03269259259104729, 0.03574644774198532, 0.013090231455862522, -0.060539282858371735, 0.02885044552385807, 0.000038025853427825496, 0.035359010100364685, 0.005970094818621874, -0.053009264171123505, 0.040384676307439804, -0.0015460585709661245, -0.02749261073768139, 0.0018696573097258806, -0.005812793504446745, 0.021663784980773926, 0.0024829744361341, -0.042993903160095215, 0.013200714252889156, -0.01849961467087269, -0.03228006139397621, -0.04108080267906189, -0.017895998433232307, -0.0138927660882473, 0.011809353716671467, -0.01084583718329668, 0.00015852588694542646, -0.014926154166460037, 0.026024851948022842, 0.01987113431096077, -0.05455540493130684, 0.06056896969676018, 0.05715792626142502, 0.04395301640033722, -0.056308235973119736, 0.042029060423374176, 0.08483575284481049, 0.02612042985856533, -0.022524284198880196, -0.021168865263462067, -0.048796702176332474, 0.03742656111717224, 0.04473868012428284, 0.01997309923171997, -0.00786055251955986, 0.007479170802980661, 0.05128227546811104, 0.04440722614526749, -0.016455791890621185, -0.07428573071956635, -0.026494644582271576, 0.03136298060417175, 0.02796032652258873, -0.050202831625938416, 0.007968194782733917, 0.00004696860196418129, -0.048579562455415726, -0.027637818828225136, 0.02857205830514431, -0.02105618081986904, -0.05751034617424011, -0.02024562656879425, 0.034811656922101974, 0.0012954941485077143, 0.0014927468728274107, 0.06179612874984741, 0.06627901643514633, -0.07275178283452988, 0.002993885660544038, -0.030505163595080376, -0.018720591440796852, -0.07176092267036438, -0.005143285728991032, -0.01256496924906969, 0.006808428559452295, 0.022868666797876358, -0.01683754287660122, 0.016011862084269524, 0.03313092887401581, 0.008728502318263054, -0.0659836009144783, 0.018516646698117256, -0.03437858819961548, -0.028485847637057304, 0.01730654388666153, 0.05376696214079857, -0.01284202840179205, -0.019184457138180733, 0.020505454391241074, 0.016764840111136436, 0.03683082386851311, 0.03180321678519249, 0.015002512373030186, -0.013634865172207355, -0.007706363219767809, 0.06907876580953598, -0.035304050892591476, 0.004317264072597027, -0.01190537866204977, 0.005516144912689924, 0.03187086433172226, -0.004913758020848036, -0.009131967090070248, -0.03768022730946541, 0.013416686095297337 ]
<p>Why are the strong and weak nuclear forces short range?</p> <p>Are quarks confined or welded together?</p> <p>Why are elementary particles confined at short range?</p> <p>Or is color confinement color welding?</p> <hr> <p>the quarks are glued together by strong nuclear force, (but not at high energy) it seems to me that its a kind of elementary welding process.</p>
g1618
[ 0.04001560062170029, 0.030950307846069336, -0.009332087822258472, -0.05311046913266182, 0.032871313393116, 0.04524439200758934, -0.05251249298453331, 0.0036259260959923267, -0.031560834497213364, -0.07938072830438614, 0.03654084354639053, 0.008693596348166466, -0.030831754207611084, -0.013273960910737514, -0.013070115819573402, 0.01769999787211418, -0.0020676469430327415, 0.0005254621501080692, 0.019875511527061462, 0.05876970663666725, -0.011409126222133636, 0.02616528421640396, -0.052278753370046616, -0.04131642356514931, -0.01142871379852295, 0.0003294238413218409, 0.02044537663459778, -0.030053170397877693, -0.0064559513702988625, -0.03897104784846306, 0.04685494676232338, -0.02510085515677929, 0.08260419964790344, -0.0426807776093483, 0.03872021660208702, -0.044087063521146774, 0.02642424963414669, -0.02995825931429863, 0.0021074600517749786, -0.011574476025998592, 0.015493086539208889, -0.022747019305825233, 0.028705023229122162, -0.060071978718042374, -0.020782053470611572, -0.00220059254206717, -0.030875137075781822, -0.061026643961668015, -0.004752742126584053, 0.0006233119638636708, -0.0653829276561737, 0.024641171097755432, -0.04247958958148956, -0.010664812289178371, 0.07970207929611206, 0.01538957841694355, -0.0003491673560347408, 0.018204838037490845, 0.0833350196480751, 0.01701875776052475, 0.05411406606435776, 0.067099928855896, 0.008389439433813095, -0.008401698432862759, 0.08045554161071777, 0.011068032123148441, 0.0026384657248854637, 0.05919685587286949, 0.027212925255298615, 0.021106529980897903, -0.07658642530441284, -0.050177525728940964, -0.06022697687149048, -0.03956618160009384, -0.011737245135009289, 0.040707603096961975, 0.021203508600592613, 0.02989211305975914, -0.0447581484913826, 0.035725660622119904, -0.046374838799238205, 0.02567172795534134, -0.009742174297571182, 0.026651285588741302, 0.019617805257439613, 0.01258383970707655, -0.07099559158086777, -0.003967339172959328, 0.020174158737063408, -0.014389502815902233, 0.010353954508900642, 0.005636776331812143, 0.023625731468200684, 0.02022460661828518, -0.013073613867163658, -0.03621266037225723, 0.026700206100940704, 0.06861861795186996, 0.03380701318383217, 0.004190757405012846, -0.004024934954941273, -0.01669771410524845, -0.014166980981826782, -0.03781205043196678, -0.04008091986179352, -0.06157685071229935, 0.04659172147512436, 0.048331715166568756, 0.013703708536922932, 0.02545505203306675, -0.02669471502304077, 0.022985607385635376, -0.03634146600961685, -0.02254655584692955, 0.021035127341747284, 0.021939286962151527, 0.04338689148426056, -0.01005033403635025, 0.06403183937072754, 0.029353437945246696, 0.03022211417555809, 0.0014627280179411173, -0.021533116698265076, -0.007701341528445482, -0.004709293134510517, -0.04184437543153763, 0.015226980671286583, 0.01492968201637268, -0.027777187526226044, -0.04556532949209213, 0.02366350218653679, -0.021813280880451202, -0.017959997057914734, 0.004304781090468168, -0.02202831767499447, -0.001251707784831524, -0.015267517417669296, 0.025273939594626427, -0.01235634833574295, -0.012052199803292751, -0.04530084878206253, 0.002261718735098839, -0.0284897331148386, -0.0426754467189312, -0.010393734090030193, 0.024970725178718567, -0.04972982406616211, 0.014530414715409279, -0.014544743113219738, 0.04951637238264084, 0.039767179638147354, 0.03026324324309826, 0.021321509033441544, 0.02172546647489071, -0.02045312523841858, -0.00821551214903593, 0.07969974726438522, -0.013456898741424084, 0.020792588591575623, 0.005773347336798906, 0.0766732320189476, 0.0008388794376514852, 0.03536452353000641, 0.018311772495508194, -0.056824684143066406, 0.055398378521203995, 0.04962218180298805, -0.03454617038369179, 0.020622501149773598, 0.011807267554104328, -0.07098477333784103, -0.04356319457292557, -0.027156801894307137, 0.0897812694311142, 0.002034436445683241, 0.059246186167001724, 0.05576814338564873, -0.06946387887001038, 0.014748984016478062, -0.032291244715452194, 0.0229699295014143, -0.010771578177809715, 0.013263450935482979, -0.023499419912695885, -0.023994892835617065, 0.004917281214147806, -0.026002101600170135, 0.03081633150577545, 0.03125803545117378, 0.025639746338129044, -0.051218267530202866, -0.02480941079556942, 0.0050933947786688805, -0.004116236697882414, -0.02126307040452957, -0.08244617283344269, -0.01668795756995678, -0.0031276424415409565, -0.009299792349338531, -0.0033945967443287373, -0.05452171340584755, -0.0036197961308062077, -0.022987857460975647, -0.0004497416375670582, 0.08396866917610168, 0.026902860030531883, -0.018213363364338875, 0.08081566542387009, 0.018064558506011963, -0.011227541603147984, -0.03272363543510437, 0.033060479909181595, -0.002083582105115056, -0.02967636100947857, 0.013568324968218803, -0.05936155840754509, 0.0037447751965373755, -0.009421009570360184, 0.00399076147004962, 0.01622363179922104, -0.06365495920181274, -0.055683527141809464, 0.08108805865049362, 0.019167544320225716, 0.0007210457697510719, 0.0032778189051896334, -0.07737842202186584, 0.015213730745017529, 0.032561592757701874, 0.014290113002061844, -0.08935480564832687, 0.042904626578092575, -0.06915493309497833, -0.010423808358609676, 0.003280441742390394, 0.028697695583105087, 0.026332244277000427, -0.0400116890668869, 0.022260818630456924, 0.010088286362588406, 0.04551317170262337, -0.0806395411491394, 0.013236422091722488, -0.01691887527704239, -0.010669313371181488, -0.06139253079891205, 0.01764397695660591, -0.032731570303440094, 0.008872181177139282, 0.004984097555279732, 0.04867814853787422, -0.01901818998157978, -0.04655564948916435, 0.01065746694803238, -0.01983509585261345, -0.002218017354607582, -0.024487927556037903, 0.04189905896782875, -0.06630222499370575, -0.11028489470481873, -0.01958591118454933, -0.012913363985717297, -0.014600073918700218, 0.012698356993496418, 0.014446984976530075, 0.03582068160176277, -0.030820438638329506, 0.04016759619116783, 0.0049900757148861885, -0.02159871719777584, -0.028771378099918365, 0.029198139905929565, -0.02196573279798031, -0.075993113219738, 0.0317072756588459, -0.08693502843379974, 0.01734793558716774, -0.059952158480882645, 0.018752779811620712, -0.00941567961126566, -0.013185789808630943, 0.011131259612739086, -0.06451908499002457, -0.05499125272035599, -0.020967191085219383, -0.025148872286081314, -0.03700001910328865, -0.022777574136853218, 0.02290550246834755, -0.0021187702659517527, -0.022654807195067406, -0.011748687364161015, 0.04579416289925575, -0.033275626599788666, -0.03012876585125923, 0.05107684060931206, 0.015270278789103031, 0.029470214620232582, 0.03372803330421448, 0.056467533111572266, 0.013569328933954239, -0.02690967358648777, -0.0019252084894105792, 0.01664433814585209, -0.01696952059864998, 0.03143484890460968, -0.012549138627946377, -0.00846628937870264, -0.04081020504236221, 0.036396197974681854, 0.011975937522947788, 0.06948527693748474, 0.029475970193743706, 0.06392811238765717, -0.04448895901441574, -0.05636022612452507, 0.0033531696535646915, 0.028151584789156914, 0.015178272500634193, -0.10706887394189835, -0.03995218873023987, -0.04194295406341553, 0.0014828088460490108, -0.07957833260297775, 0.045517243444919586, 0.005493743345141411, 0.027656376361846924, -0.004130944609642029, -0.026489118114113808, -0.0009719624067656696, -0.0006463773315772414, -0.015709612518548965, 0.018748214468359947, -0.011387360282242298, -0.0697573870420456, -0.07195144891738892, -0.026358194649219513, -0.019371824339032173, -0.017981579527258873, 0.015687670558691025, 0.05235639587044716, -0.026629425585269928, -0.04991849884390831, 0.04492197930812836, 0.009491508826613426, 0.04618160054087639, 0.007632747758179903, -0.04325984790921211, 0.007376429159194231, 0.01389059703797102, -0.029810776934027672, 0.05893152952194214, -0.02912648394703865, -0.008242581970989704, -0.017118478193879128, 0.0053147124126553535, -0.02071160450577736, 0.0008344799862243235, 0.029578037559986115, 0.0011199100408703089, 0.03672409802675247, 0.0022208387963473797, 0.015222927555441856, -0.07151138782501221, -0.0807364359498024, -0.02753419801592827, 0.029570432379841805, 0.024331703782081604, 0.015028764493763447, 0.028205154463648796, -0.02280120737850666, -0.0011023071128875017, -0.014537771232426167, 0.005810236092656851, 0.009230202995240688, 0.0018410023767501116, 0.048692263662815094, -0.004431968089193106, -0.02191649191081524, -0.014500230550765991, 0.019466683268547058, 0.026748836040496826, 0.022862542420625687, 0.05476031452417374, 0.02210448868572712, -0.04078151285648346, -0.03763125091791153, -0.01015019416809082, -0.06777589023113251, -0.04451802372932434, -0.03389805182814598, -0.004095589742064476, -0.05420134589076042, 0.03601484373211861, -0.035769734531641006, -0.04926307499408722, 0.06653517484664917, 0.000936838798224926, 0.032795533537864685, -0.01122080348432064, -0.04233464598655701, 0.03041028417646885, -0.05235550180077553, -0.07867284119129181, -0.026606490835547447, -0.0010248932521790266, -0.007633318193256855, 0.04688839241862297, 0.014754170551896095, -0.006721212528645992, 0.026500053703784943, 0.005513312760740519, -0.018101414665579796, -0.06358696520328522, 0.015432478860020638, -0.029949447140097618, 0.049580689519643784, 0.0402928963303566, -0.019270479679107666, 0.00703680282458663, 0.021224072203040123, 0.045316461473703384, 0.028167076408863068, 0.023972507566213608, 0.03174429014325142, 0.07271934300661087, -0.029754381626844406, 0.0402795746922493, 0.08863252401351929, -0.003491088515147567, 0.06684094667434692, -0.01867293007671833, -0.017390605062246323, -0.05279884114861488, -0.011622683145105839, 0.026828056201338768, -0.037816934287548065, 0.005049402825534344, 0.05432421714067459, 0.10971210151910782, 0.027741793543100357, 0.005018542520701885, 0.05100538581609726, 0.028321828693151474, 0.027476677671074867, 0.045791126787662506, -0.03140293061733246, 0.009413826279342175, -0.07102179527282715, -0.03387449309229851, 0.009900875389575958, -0.025535162538290024, -0.08345457166433334, -0.04906724393367767, 0.05900033190846443, -0.03081471100449562, -0.023802461102604866, 0.010035563260316849, 0.05109042301774025, 0.04995254799723625, -0.06290550529956818, -0.018705779686570168, 0.05842576548457146, 0.003952445462346077, 0.020088011398911476, 0.036413248628377914, -0.034266147762537, -0.029296934604644775, -0.05568681284785271, 0.030482621863484383, 0.0030253371223807335, 0.033289823681116104, 0.04214674234390259, 0.015501121059060097, 0.023822635412216187, 0.02108161710202694, 0.004695931449532509, 0.014397645369172096, 0.050985995680093765, -0.061063386499881744, 0.0341869555413723, 0.03495138883590698, -0.01313875149935484, 0.0029639569111168385, -0.07611967623233795, -0.00006457950075855479, -0.034856971353292465, 0.013983070850372314, -0.04462878778576851, 0.030602747574448586, 0.014876233413815498, -0.03243378922343254, 0.059589702636003494, 0.05664190277457237, 0.03565482795238495, -0.019560309126973152, -0.0009327346342615783, 0.04148073121905327, 0.014796778559684753, -0.007578683085739613, 0.03779840096831322, -0.050364792346954346, 0.007776087149977684, 0.05527130886912346, -0.02273571491241455, 0.02841808833181858, 0.06380528211593628, -0.035356223583221436, 0.04311193898320198, -0.0160889383405447, -0.015737291425466537, 0.05901132896542549, -0.005129039287567139, -0.0706925019621849, -0.020533261820673943, -0.024905940517783165, -0.03426160663366318, -0.00023653460084460676, -0.020135823637247086, -0.002260479610413313, 0.011916115880012512, 0.03157560154795647, 0.006476336624473333, -0.01868690550327301, -0.034177932888269424, 0.012873264960944653, -0.025154056027531624, 0.046237263828516006, 0.05388684943318367, 0.015605191700160503, 0.030660610646009445, 0.022407235577702522, 0.03745865449309349, 0.026461640372872353, 0.02940681390464306, 0.021353578194975853, 0.03976859152317047, -0.008026265539228916, -0.07928425818681717, -0.014187567867338657, 0.06456729769706726, -0.043886538594961166, -0.02647133730351925, 0.05975843966007233, -0.012850647792220116, 0.0015200782800093293, 0.006990830879658461, 0.009423546493053436, 0.06040600314736366, -0.006769777741283178, -0.00861634872853756, -0.026610177010297775, -0.009405452758073807, -0.02619139477610588, 0.023958809673786163, 0.010709277354180813, 0.011267310008406639, -0.07485461235046387, 0.0006544939824379981, -0.03199885040521622, 0.019003460183739662, 0.06909075379371643, -0.03111095540225506, 0.00524474959820509, 0.07389792054891586, -0.032910265028476715, -0.025631526485085487, 0.010617280378937721, 0.022832699120044708, 0.07445977628231049, 0.039110422134399414, -0.004750704392790794, 0.051935501396656036, 0.049080900847911835, -0.016986392438411713, 0.04874500632286072, -0.025731850415468216, 0.025482602417469025, -0.06043190136551857, -0.007374449633061886, -0.008558926172554493, 0.053660135716199875, -0.03015495091676712, -0.044230204075574875, -0.053932059556245804, 0.046377599239349365, 0.009291314519941807, 0.0033121295273303986, 0.04269341379404068, 0.020166758447885513, 0.035292673856019974, -0.006925246212631464, -0.04802212491631508, 0.06094729155302048, -0.05340953543782234, 0.016466524451971054, 0.002077295444905758, -0.0405987910926342, -0.05388261005282402, 0.01681799627840519, -0.019977372139692307, 0.02235989272594452, 0.028716256842017174, 0.027553653344511986, 0.03347047045826912, 0.007796377409249544, 0.015080172568559647, 0.03377525135874748, -0.015491431578993797, 0.055549055337905884, 0.003113887505605817, 0.024984214454889297, 0.0030251755379140377, -0.079325832426548, -0.0018947571516036987, -0.037913065403699875, 0.012148023582994938, 0.010592286475002766, -0.023899702355265617, -0.018639305606484413, -0.01582334376871586, -0.02182563953101635, 0.020300934091210365, -0.0015066489577293396, 0.014334148727357388, 0.020431095734238625, -0.07056334614753723, 0.019224824383854866, 0.03822997584939003, -0.02757541835308075, 0.00029831918072886765, -0.023599686101078987, 0.04205736145377159, -0.01425577700138092, -0.07743175327777863, 0.004494874272495508, -0.03150530532002449, -0.0076332660391926765, 0.0005068171885795891, -0.01459147222340107, -0.017589014023542404, -0.00324876606464386, 0.020019475370645523, -0.0016984794056043029, -0.0279704499989748, 0.05145431309938431, -0.015980780124664307, 0.019416479393839836, -0.017433680593967438, 0.02019195258617401, -0.02290891669690609, -0.02402806654572487, -0.04555535316467285, -0.0030145994387567043, 0.004063427448272705, 0.032706018537282944, -0.040940165519714355, 0.006166997365653515, -0.027197854593396187, -0.043771613389253616, 0.006886480841785669, -0.0007052008877508342, -0.020442236214876175, 0.021875837817788124, -0.0014898133231326938, 0.03817740082740784, 0.034014225006103516, -0.054930269718170166, -0.013474608771502972, 0.018658889457583427, 0.007344679441303015, -0.013842862099409103, -0.020109940320253372, -0.0716213807463646, 0.011002346873283386, -0.0015564700588583946, -0.05171525105834007, 0.06044028326869011, 0.08308423310518265, 0.007226312533020973, -0.0039944639429450035, 0.005406827200204134, -0.0010803152108564973, -0.011272772215306759, 0.036983560770750046, 0.06395365297794342, 0.006198754999786615, 0.00656293798238039, 0.006729076616466045, -0.030234403908252716, 0.005549424793571234, 0.022624546661973, 0.010139157995581627, -0.034443411976099014, 0.03958382084965706, -0.04305179417133331, -0.009913861751556396, -0.020558128133416176, 0.013104570098221302, 0.020997116342186928, 0.009548621252179146, -0.05855738744139671, 0.028668880462646484, -0.02061481773853302, 0.02250833809375763, 0.025058496743440628, -0.018327761441469193, 0.025145338848233223, -0.012527122162282467, -0.03315138444304466, 0.03172648325562477, 0.029591184109449387, 0.07391732931137085, 0.022153468802571297, 0.03012162633240223, -0.0077018882147967815, -0.017197957262396812, -0.0012660948559641838, 0.03578875586390495, -0.015052023343741894, 0.03439672291278839, -0.03317549079656601, 0.011699537746608257, 0.0017610107315704226, 0.0033133465331047773, 0.006993493530899286, 0.0245131216943264, -0.053433459252119064, -0.027670089155435562, 0.008125835098326206, -0.020744964480400085, 0.008397526107728481, -0.008303484879434109, -0.019483111798763275, -0.004753933288156986, -0.005460167303681374, 0.029340768232941628, -0.02061471715569496, -0.009694046340882778, 0.06890516728162766, -0.0049086157232522964, 0.03282390162348747, -0.07262291014194489, 0.013301137834787369, -0.028804440051317215, -0.056307945400476456, -0.045158352702856064, 0.022835183888673782, 0.014563321135938168, -0.007163452450186014, -0.03517415374517441, -0.01138779241591692, 0.02061096578836441, 0.024640798568725586, 0.08228780329227448, -0.09224798530340195, 0.002057637320831418, 0.025399459525942802, 0.02360977791249752, 0.003944540396332741, -0.013747232034802437, 0.08944433182477951, -0.029527392238378525, -0.02493552304804325, 0.007586447987705469, 0.02829819545149803, -0.04768162593245506, -0.024242190644145012 ]
<p>I think of an NMR experiment, but with a single spin half nucleus initially set to the excited state.</p> <p>When the nucleus finally returns to its ground state, it will emit a photon. An observer in the lab frame will see a photon in the Larmor frequency. An observer in a rotating frame, very close to the Larmor frequency, will see a photon with a very very low frequency. </p> <p>My question is: Because of the frequency difference, will it take the detector of the rotating frame observer longer time to tick (i.e., detect the photon) compared to the lab frame observer?</p> <p>Also, and i know it sounds silly, if there is a different, does this somehow relates to time dilution in general relativity? </p>
g1619
[ 0.05683688446879387, 0.026878103613853455, 0.01627122238278389, -0.02574755996465683, 0.035433534532785416, -0.026835884898900986, 0.055317871272563934, 0.04679562896490097, 0.004715456627309322, -0.00009753990889294073, 0.019080117344856262, 0.023792613297700882, 0.006475274451076984, 0.005791118834167719, -0.021455565467476845, -0.02538217604160309, 0.07706214487552643, -0.012133538722991943, -0.013888583518564701, 0.029972989112138748, 0.03394678607583046, 0.07442605495452881, -0.035390280187129974, -0.020142875611782074, -0.03698889911174774, -0.03109918348491192, 0.018633373081684113, 0.016556279733777046, -0.06867814064025879, 0.019463643431663513, -0.00801876187324524, -0.05498024448752403, 0.009641051292419434, 0.023903831839561462, 0.03203840181231499, -0.06936304271221161, 0.00009059187141247094, 0.02754741907119751, -0.016936447471380234, 0.0060010687448084354, 0.01651502028107643, 0.013537767343223095, 0.013284067623317242, -0.04066367447376251, 0.07152761518955231, 0.038225095719099045, 0.013709898106753826, 0.03355323523283005, 0.06195969879627228, -0.007111942395567894, -0.058609575033187866, 0.0027445387095212936, -0.02009221911430359, 0.051795750856399536, 0.04083915799856186, 0.02818068116903305, -0.06938215345144272, 0.01503861602395773, 0.029334532096982002, -0.00789128802716732, -0.000017230775483767502, -0.06544741988182068, -0.05207283794879913, -0.01865384168922901, 0.011500083841383457, 0.009445585310459137, -0.0019348817877471447, -0.02843560092151165, 0.04139178991317749, 0.015679456293582916, -0.03268648311495781, 0.030859138816595078, -0.01098627969622612, -0.005599013064056635, 0.030581898987293243, 0.02842988260090351, 0.0011334422742947936, -0.035271454602479935, -0.0009620034252293408, 0.034126024693250656, -0.07297654449939728, 0.013172811828553677, -0.013130179606378078, 0.059461209923028946, 0.04674584046006203, 0.023094255477190018, -0.03454615920782089, 0.010043433867394924, 0.012111708521842957, 0.06796198338270187, 0.10428379476070404, -0.07788064330816269, 0.08485656976699829, 0.002591195050626993, -0.015739023685455322, 0.03897734731435776, -0.014916382730007172, 0.06398624926805496, -0.0048889657482504845, 0.04345165193080902, -0.006092007737606764, 0.01834339089691639, -0.015612233430147171, -0.0007399384630843997, -0.020535489544272423, -0.028083546087145805, -0.013834046199917793, -0.041278522461652756, -0.0554521344602108, -0.013911502435803413, -0.010764029808342457, -0.029771318659186363, 0.01685910113155842, -0.02882334217429161, -0.0771385133266449, -0.018753737211227417, 0.018763776868581772, -0.022502928972244263, -0.028508538380265236, -0.0017818835331127048, 0.03991347923874855, 0.05488115921616554, -0.0519060380756855, 0.09497641772031784, 0.005853191018104553, 0.015458769164979458, 0.03508639708161354, 0.027039339765906334, 0.005559986922889948, 0.040622927248477936, -0.004867863841354847, 0.048807546496391296, -0.019385868683457375, 0.010989578440785408, -0.02286624349653721, 0.04284701496362686, 0.07450958341360092, 0.030894199386239052, 0.02349068410694599, -0.008746486157178879, 0.03313237428665161, -0.03325725346803665, 0.03505973517894745, -0.04191731661558151, -0.024367298930883408, 0.048507433384656906, 0.014390533789992332, -0.020476030185818672, -0.00777279119938612, 0.03796909749507904, -0.003720358246937394, 0.03679158538579941, 0.0036858050152659416, -0.0051466417498886585, 0.09393049031496048, 0.0010642802808433771, 0.013698377646505833, -0.012999054975807667, 0.019832730293273926, 0.03856153413653374, 0.03034662827849388, -0.03191220015287399, 0.007739331107586622, -0.01517567690461874, -0.059720978140830994, -0.0056506069377064705, 0.005501984618604183, -0.04906921833753586, 0.0052580684423446655, -0.09452134370803833, -0.03670438379049301, -0.03213883563876152, 0.01854315958917141, 0.02061060443520546, -0.0016108008567243814, 0.05804801732301712, 0.014180900529026985, -0.049722157418727875, -0.04662761837244034, 0.06034846976399422, -0.04026932269334793, -0.052878402173519135, -0.01757238619029522, -0.07098032534122467, 0.0386485755443573, -0.0006949250819161534, 0.0073302811942994595, -0.073952816426754, -0.07369757443666458, -0.008329851552844048, 0.024661030620336533, -0.05009249597787857, -0.03519958257675171, 0.051521528512239456, -0.07191405445337296, -0.0059262956492602825, -0.01629190519452095, -0.011058378964662552, -0.0010601957328617573, 0.04490433260798454, -0.06431125104427338, -0.009524939581751823, 0.03235248848795891, 0.026612235233187675, 0.01883758418262005, -0.024962149560451508, -0.03255584090948105, -0.029547324404120445, 0.0015952070243656635, 0.0026728338561952114, 0.004176588263362646, 0.007205359637737274, -0.027394216507673264, 0.039911385625600815, -0.007668768055737019, 0.009394078515470028, 0.044306445866823196, 0.051132068037986755, 0.03373512625694275, 0.0643194168806076, 0.02473553456366062, 0.0023755417205393314, 0.04068155214190483, -0.018336789682507515, 0.0034752320498228073, -0.04719952121376991, -0.006299888715147972, -0.013227422721683979, -0.006328153889626265, 0.03097735531628132, -0.031181616708636284, 0.05012959986925125, -0.007619958836585283, 0.024407925084233284, 0.037131115794181824, 0.026048360392451286, 0.004535305313766003, 0.02675693854689598, 0.054698411375284195, -0.03397070989012718, -0.0020997044630348682, 0.03382547199726105, -0.03226287290453911, 0.005953599698841572, 0.011712194420397282, -0.03633315861225128, 0.040346160531044006, -0.02869388461112976, -0.016953669488430023, -0.044119540601968765, -0.01031153742223978, -0.00015209165576379746, -0.01556829921901226, -0.0049324315041303635, -0.034666791558265686, -0.02130766399204731, -0.00129505165386945, 0.022684721276164055, -0.1282452642917633, -0.035028669983148575, 0.00555726233869791, -0.052616581320762634, 0.004238194320350885, 0.008658057078719139, 0.020066045224666595, -0.026101943105459213, -0.015980467200279236, 0.04020099341869354, -0.045211538672447205, -0.015447528101503849, -0.03696669265627861, 0.017695382237434387, 0.04785207286477089, -0.006170378997921944, -0.029880831018090248, 0.006759901065379381, 0.0050873300060629845, -0.009274829179048538, 0.021323058754205704, -0.0572485476732254, -0.04980700463056564, -0.012892446480691433, -0.11516425013542175, -0.03743118792772293, 0.006373926531523466, -0.04607759788632393, 0.001969460863620043, -0.007198614999651909, -0.035474684089422226, 0.02945411391556263, -0.056416332721710205, 0.0583900585770607, 0.06612022966146469, -0.016619635745882988, 0.00459333835169673, 0.03215647116303444, 0.0292805265635252, 0.01146612223237753, -0.039671607315540314, 0.062478866428136826, 0.050893690437078476, -0.03930490463972092, 0.03305463120341301, 0.021582651883363724, 0.0027762348763644695, -0.051342643797397614, -0.06989023834466934, -0.044872134923934937, -0.0232912115752697, 0.01845496892929077, -0.05726246535778046, 0.010512451641261578, 0.028199508786201477, -0.028184253722429276, -0.00850779376924038, -0.06760287284851074, -0.025236105546355247, 0.044962648302316666, -0.00851447694003582, 0.009406862780451775, 0.0073699974454939365, 0.05788658186793327, -0.0411425419151783, -0.048183590173721313, 0.04745820164680481, 0.001941947964951396, -0.016262535005807877, -0.014112508855760098, -0.11466268450021744, -0.010919163934886456, -0.020978733897209167, -0.004926081281155348, -0.04867252707481384, 0.0006946399225853384, -0.013043257407844067, 0.029132217168807983, -0.03337893635034561, 0.03793347254395485, 0.006698546931147575, -0.031214874237775803, 0.03323313221335411, 0.03644849359989166, -0.05389077588915825, 0.008888410404324532, 0.0450231097638607, 0.0174818467348814, -0.00005098358087707311, -0.03945447877049446, -0.039154939353466034, -0.062338218092918396, 0.012071650475263596, -0.04162825271487236, -0.02168259210884571, -0.042120277881622314, 0.005477565806359053, -0.027276504784822464, 0.05568463355302811, 0.018693391233682632, -0.001060368842445314, -0.03282960131764412, 0.02385188639163971, -0.002216457389295101, 0.05489995330572128, 0.005539522971957922, -0.011152980849146843, 0.010798501782119274, -0.00471628038212657, 0.0494530126452446, 0.03212722763419151, -0.0338306687772274, -0.028559712693095207, 0.015205154195427895, -0.006310074124485254, 0.028707217425107956, -0.008345397189259529, -0.03810432553291321, 0.025014236569404602, -0.0010368404909968376, -0.03306732699275017, 0.04149887338280678, -0.06372139602899551, -0.0000026550069378572516, -0.02604927495121956, -0.027719395235180855, 0.05728456750512123, 0.028546158224344254, -0.0032473017927259207, -0.0160226970911026, -0.008082936517894268, -0.03762361779808998, 0.0030595792923122644, -0.006618390791118145, -0.03905061259865761, 0.013341392390429974, 0.02869311347603798, -0.0023941134568303823, 0.017682978883385658, -0.011685024946928024, 0.015763944014906883, 0.02046881429851055, -0.012493334710597992, 0.023941993713378906, -0.03752347454428673, -0.025065084919333458, -0.006727713625878096, 0.023910794407129288, 0.005818366538733244, 0.004526202101260424, -0.05067780986428261, 0.04800071194767952, -0.03998325392603874, -0.008230282925069332, -0.052634347230196, -0.044570427387952805, 0.002266424475237727, 0.002676571486517787, 0.003622723277658224, 0.018931999802589417, -0.010347085073590279, -0.0002342701773159206, -0.08064115792512894, 0.08148806542158127, 0.0144245820119977, -0.008592530153691769, -0.009787521325051785, 0.04151669144630432, 0.011148055084049702, 0.0708996132016182, -0.024520687758922577, -0.07971066981554031, 0.05442171171307564, -0.009198944084346294, 0.002743116347119212, -0.01406837347894907, -0.06362619996070862, 0.03305869549512863, -0.011440783739089966, 0.012252037413418293, 0.07567054778337479, 0.06613818556070328, 0.04797608405351639, 0.00920749083161354, -0.008145803585648537, 0.003666926408186555, -0.00018515576084610075, 0.029511988162994385, -0.02238250896334648, -0.03337487950921059, -0.0219415295869112, -0.0018559376476332545, -0.024481499567627907, 0.04226338118314743, -0.06515463441610336, 0.004849704448133707, -0.010965343564748764, 0.027371611446142197, 0.0016643665730953217, 0.0123990997672081, -0.005244378931820393, 0.05600856617093086, -0.014722342602908611, 0.03208976611495018, -0.04503775015473366, -0.014904697425663471, -0.01828603446483612, -0.014190404675900936, -0.045453429222106934, -0.0742182508111, -0.06612914800643921, -0.0012303092516958714, 0.0019594181794673204, -0.03635825961828232, 0.046785563230514526, 0.022096917033195496, 0.00016972584126051515, 0.03348874673247337, 0.0224705059081316, 0.03971447795629501, 0.016947999596595764, -0.01686064712703228, -0.06374052911996841, 0.0188178438693285, 0.03261667862534523, 0.00374677125364542, 0.01526140607893467, 0.00112374487798661, -0.0426957942545414, -0.019024312496185303, 0.02324354276061058, -0.08474339544773102, 0.007679955568164587, 0.021461181342601776, -0.010346942581236362, 0.018552282825112343, 0.04374181479215622, 0.011989586986601353, 0.039679545909166336, -0.035248495638370514, 0.004219615366309881, -0.04309291020035744, -0.013691214844584465, 0.04033111035823822, 0.027514507994055748, 0.0032517313957214355, -0.034168392419815063, 0.038103245198726654, -0.009417325258255005, 0.013834822922945023, 0.008778276853263378, 0.09598658978939056, -0.07343170791864395, 0.00533641641959548, -0.036285605281591415, 0.054382503032684326, -0.008541606366634369, -0.03414923697710037, 0.020812414586544037, -0.01996581442654133, -0.005561598110944033, -0.07486981153488159, -0.05558691918849945, 0.07367360591888428, 0.04109743982553482, -0.018983565270900726, 0.008403564803302288, -0.00905288103967905, -0.05546284839510918, 0.056774601340293884, 0.031825337558984756, -0.015344754792749882, 0.07639260590076447, 0.015210668556392193, 0.05758082866668701, 0.0580781027674675, 0.04089377820491791, -0.0011467757867649198, 0.018478771671652794, -0.026251861825585365, -0.007697950582951307, 0.007416918408125639, -0.04941249638795853, -0.017697809264063835, 0.07682599872350693, -0.015338362194597721, 0.028291700407862663, -0.04334365203976631, -0.0007313691894523799, -0.03663865849375725, 0.059661198407411575, -0.024292616173624992, -0.02037578821182251, 0.012212133966386318, 0.036322902888059616, 0.03571148216724396, -0.030519237741827965, 0.03358669579029083, -0.001612173393368721, 0.0038867101538926363, 0.01817481964826584, 0.034818798303604126, 0.022334329783916473, 0.05365050211548805, 0.03971131518483162, -0.013981470838189125, 0.015183476731181145, -0.01662188395857811, -0.01599479280412197, -0.0463661253452301, 0.06609512865543365, -0.022360578179359436, -0.006654397118836641, -0.05137862265110016, -0.03763561695814133, 0.0051598032005131245, 0.004670162685215473, 0.05416958034038544, -0.005800878629088402, -0.01644078642129898, -0.07275561988353729, 0.02513710781931877, -0.04552456736564636, 0.012377940118312836, -0.011795802041888237, -0.0019256161758676171, 0.04239293932914734, 0.01648961566388607, -0.01475331000983715, 0.0032614499796181917, 0.02518560364842415, 0.022268375381827354, -0.0016302306903526187, -0.059069450944662094, -0.0016187288565561175, -0.05502084642648697, -0.042565830051898956, 0.033492133021354675, -0.01939593441784382, -0.03444089740514755, -0.02831173688173294, 0.02394339255988598, 0.009076781570911407, -0.04121125862002373, 0.10279533267021179, -0.0023384650703519583, -0.026622453704476357, 0.024747516959905624, -0.060745276510715485, -0.01664622128009796, 0.08217565715312958, -0.00410530436784029, 0.009826713241636753, -0.016452565789222717, 0.021561861038208008, 0.023696418851614, -0.019005808979272842, 0.0023586417082697153, 0.06568735092878342, 0.04923326522111893, 0.019450025632977486, 0.017546603456139565, 0.03829367458820343, -0.0011468081502243876, -0.03929392620921135, -0.02493903785943985, -0.009955315850675106, 0.03668158873915672, -0.027008701115846634, -0.032871488481760025, 0.035129446536302567, 0.01617826521396637, 0.043105024844408035, 0.0033862837590277195, -0.03666481375694275, 0.012775124981999397, 0.034278955310583115, 0.016276691108942032, -0.05441576987504959, 0.0010994048789143562, 0.006405131425708532, 0.0002540105488151312, 0.028236303478479385, 0.05614837631583214, 0.03650975972414017, -0.008562280796468258, -0.06482954323291779, 0.016408676281571388, 0.03272261843085289, 0.034780457615852356, -0.017252052202820778, 0.04247874766588211, -0.05088059976696968, -0.09466063231229782, -0.03867488354444504, 0.02049623243510723, -0.00967214722186327, 0.014455062337219715, 0.012325593270361423, -0.0018688071286305785, 0.0744190514087677, -0.04367280378937721, -0.03297363966703415, -0.0320163294672966, -0.08262751996517181, -0.02406121790409088, -0.017713895067572594, 0.011802795343101025, -0.03519847244024277, -0.038368649780750275, -0.0032056178897619247, -0.007942695170640945, 0.056832555681467056, -0.030279604718089104, -0.0826803520321846, 0.0029542818665504456, 0.029233943670988083, -0.005543997976928949, -0.06749380379915237, -0.031162410974502563, -0.017421964555978775, -0.04246761277318001, -0.04640048369765282, 0.0023403356317430735, 0.02203625813126564, 0.03232502564787865, -0.024614382535219193, 0.08409801125526428, -0.03438364714384079, -0.030574407428503036, 0.0017781902570277452, -0.031681329011917114, 0.01087482925504446, 0.02561108022928238, 0.03157157823443413, 0.026911448687314987, -0.0416247621178627, -0.02150224894285202, 0.09744095802307129, -0.012999570928514004, 0.040180109441280365, 0.009606429375708103, -0.03432825580239296, 0.0011598292039707303, 0.018778521567583084, 0.02246255800127983, 0.004687200766056776, -0.013790125027298927, -0.03324334695935249, -0.04263933375477791, 0.00019926407549064606, 0.006104764994233847, 0.035682424902915955, 0.03170505166053772, -0.015347891487181187, 0.01751362904906273, -0.02249179035425186, -0.022725362330675125, -0.08586026728153229, -0.031086202710866928, 0.04874095320701599, -0.040758583694696426, -0.014366788789629936, -0.016508180648088455, -0.02132292464375496, -0.018854552879929543, 0.002538158558309078, -0.020059088245034218, 0.030610661953687668, 0.00651532644405961, 0.07298154383897781, -0.032696980983018875, 0.0013951808214187622, 0.02033630572259426, -0.05003385618329048, 0.013231560587882996, 0.00739618856459856, 0.033957481384277344, 0.03880029916763306, -0.02583450637757778, -0.006100389640778303, 0.03880675509572029, -0.00909330416470766, -0.0007339444709941745, 0.0029183803126215935, -0.02077733352780342, 0.044599030166864395, 0.02478908747434616, 0.03374597057700157, 0.030454430729150772, 0.0355054996907711, -0.06906390935182571, -0.019546575844287872, 0.04639649763703346, -0.0014041825197637081, 0.05254879966378212, 0.07455114275217056, -0.022211892530322075, 0.016989096999168396, -0.003189493902027607, -0.019859766587615013, -0.0018599650356918573, -0.0372590571641922, 0.02755938470363617, 0.002595306606963277, -0.03178118169307709, -0.022756412625312805, -0.0033645934890955687, 0.05450987070798874, 0.007840164937078953 ]
<p>These facts are taken for granted in a QM text I read. The purportedly guaranteed non-normalizability of eigenfunctions which correspond to a continuous eigenvalue spectrum is only partly justified by the author, who merely states that the non-normalizability is linked to the fact that such eigenfunctions do not tend to zero at infinity.</p> <p>Not a very satisfying answer. What I'm really after is an explanation based in functional analysis. I believe there is a generalized result about inner products being finite for discrete spectra but infinite for continuous spectra.</p> <p>Can anyone shed some light on this?</p>
g1021
[ 0.002720929915085435, -0.011960506439208984, 0.032840196043252945, -0.035712141543626785, 0.06338676065206528, 0.0098774004727602, 0.013501432724297047, 0.032753001898527145, -0.01649264246225357, -0.06298946589231491, -0.03783451020717621, -0.056730516254901886, -0.02420315332710743, 0.013715136796236038, 0.0005736049497500062, -0.028496529906988144, 0.016180865466594696, -0.004317519720643759, -0.00829550251364708, 0.017529787495732307, -0.046641431748867035, 0.024806475266814232, -0.018148820847272873, -0.039150360971689224, -0.017365142703056335, 0.025794994086027145, 0.05678509175777435, 0.05670365318655968, 0.06693798303604126, 0.02567625418305397, 0.0008630463853478432, 0.05765081197023392, -0.015334952622652054, 0.03545484319329262, 0.07078196853399277, 0.019086536020040512, 0.03375055640935898, -0.00942015741020441, 0.05329867824912071, -0.01199550461024046, 0.024867793545126915, 0.020531130954623222, -0.02522079460322857, -0.027498483657836914, -0.027969809249043465, -0.032506294548511505, 0.025990474969148636, 0.04699679836630821, -0.003190018702298403, 0.01142369955778122, -0.002047297079116106, -0.012524065561592579, 0.04789046198129654, -0.00485352473333478, 0.010497466661036015, 0.004378386773169041, 0.0253483597189188, 0.0494200736284256, -0.05659210681915283, 0.00987321138381958, 0.03901617228984833, 0.0037492706906050444, 0.03124384395778179, 0.0028532843571156263, -0.010415185242891312, -0.06545329093933105, 0.004908838775008917, -0.0016671577468514442, -0.04180759936571121, 0.0314023531973362, -0.01118498109281063, -0.02950632944703102, 0.0024611393455415964, 0.040084343403577805, -0.014579953625798225, 0.010830018669366837, 0.013416177593171597, 0.008197763003408909, -0.020809322595596313, 0.037473730742931366, -0.026103803887963295, -0.011796458624303341, 0.016544820740818977, 0.0010304086608812213, 0.03549952059984207, 0.046164654195308685, 0.004889742936939001, -0.023232024163007736, 0.04852248355746269, 0.01862175390124321, 0.031240351498126984, -0.026669200509786606, -0.0009214485180564225, -0.00201515038497746, 0.015329563990235329, -0.05795111134648323, 0.0013285428285598755, 0.04601340740919113, -0.02107897587120533, -0.0068138232454657555, 0.04150740057229996, 0.018168015405535698, 0.07219246029853821, 0.015511655248701572, -0.0015624597435817122, -0.007516568060964346, 0.013380652293562889, -0.010120110586285591, 0.009343462996184826, -0.008192058652639389, 0.030839374288916588, -0.0005353478481993079, -0.05301385000348091, -0.04576906934380531, -0.029088879004120827, 0.03262469545006752, 0.03552916273474693, -0.03150757774710655, -0.002576021011918783, 0.06078016385436058, 0.036538783460855484, -0.017275122925639153, 0.00796671211719513, -0.010489695705473423, -0.036818377673625946, -0.006589830387383699, -0.0029477765783667564, 0.006936895195394754, 0.047618936747312546, -0.0516754612326622, -0.01527474820613861, 0.027997436001896858, 0.0032535677310079336, 0.02966679446399212, 0.04341859370470047, -0.01325320452451706, 0.00722122099250555, -0.004246735945343971, -0.017510786652565002, 0.02128581888973713, 0.012236237525939941, -0.03007190115749836, -0.008070074953138828, 0.00908828154206276, -0.0018808224704116583, -0.04105863347649574, -0.017305990681052208, -0.04423920810222626, -0.002227923134341836, 0.01630331203341484, -0.002803548937663436, 0.08301037549972534, 0.04364639148116112, -0.026927590370178223, 0.03448757529258728, 0.012841528281569481, 0.016780979931354523, -0.000985197490081191, -0.042998306453228, 0.005217041354626417, 0.03428294509649277, 0.026487210765480995, 0.002762043382972479, -0.010655178688466549, -0.06536450982093811, 0.005814239848405123, -0.025560447946190834, -0.04621225595474243, -0.0061748153530061245, -0.01323476992547512, -0.05378216505050659, 0.06687356531620026, 0.051882609724998474, 0.0759914442896843, 0.04470042884349823, 0.02578028291463852, 0.0007458830368705094, -0.017472758889198303, -0.003446852555498481, -0.03026488795876503, -0.0329454131424427, 0.04885318875312805, -0.01959255151450634, -0.000818336324300617, 0.030177617445588112, 0.047763336449861526, -0.006781380157917738, 0.012166834436357021, 0.01652437634766102, 0.03098752535879612, -0.02077697217464447, 0.034305915236473083, 0.0014762021601200104, -0.01316614355891943, 0.0021521570160984993, 0.014471405185759068, -0.00916131678968668, -0.006208811420947313, 0.0067161559127271175, -0.03704250603914261, -0.0192051250487566, 0.00954218115657568, -0.019183382391929626, -0.05409689247608185, -0.016742287203669548, 0.005077510606497526, 0.01738661341369152, -0.07221555709838867, 0.012921055778861046, -0.0686979740858078, -0.01645592600107193, -0.04686543345451355, -0.05962735414505005, 0.05292545258998871, 0.07338284701108932, 0.009453831240534782, -0.021474767476320267, -0.03221840038895607, -0.002467644400894642, 0.008423692546784878, 0.008746633306145668, 0.007643338292837143, 0.020124338567256927, 0.0542895570397377, 0.029403097927570343, -0.01210471149533987, 0.017514612525701523, 0.020016970112919807, 0.002427167259156704, 0.026892855763435364, -0.04145936667919159, -0.05671251565217972, 0.028656015172600746, -0.0024890305940061808, -0.022779569029808044, 0.04204199090600014, -0.026628121733665466, -0.040332067757844925, 0.10474087297916412, 0.08518248051404953, 0.03742167353630066, -0.045149065554142, -0.051358845084905624, 0.0446491502225399, -0.023209072649478912, -0.03987780585885048, -0.04786647483706474, -0.07302034646272659, -0.027936061844229698, 0.05067303404211998, -0.04261932894587517, 0.043334607034921646, 0.04785774275660515, 0.022417377680540085, -0.020326120778918266, -0.03683112934231758, -0.0022719912230968475, 0.01057090051472187, 0.027231669053435326, -0.0021361184772104025, -0.058953821659088135, 0.06737738847732544, -0.01625617779791355, -0.02183525450527668, -0.03886605426669121, 0.006681411061435938, -0.015283908694982529, 0.030663201585412025, -0.009047807194292545, 0.01060849241912365, 0.028009021654725075, 0.034737709909677505, 0.002399456687271595, 0.031768202781677246, -0.02199321985244751, -0.015866504982113838, -0.04909031093120575, 0.0019723735749721527, 0.008718766272068024, -0.05501812696456909, -0.0369376502931118, -0.03168725222349167, -0.03678659349679947, -0.01692202314734459, -0.015597112476825714, 0.0055820532143116, 0.002548664342612028, 0.06327605992555618, -0.0169049222022295, -0.0071460832841694355, -0.024017462506890297, -0.006806779187172651, 0.006211364641785622, -0.01654357649385929, -0.05519433319568634, 0.04541099816560745, 0.03009442239999771, -0.04823369160294533, -0.0310157872736454, 0.07245930284261703, -0.0393170528113842, 0.0424603708088398, -0.01716587506234646, -0.036660321056842804, 0.03356941044330597, -0.03442508727312088, -0.030427610501646996, 0.008961140178143978, -0.032725535333156586, 0.021738993003964424, 0.03271055594086647, 0.006963429506868124, -0.11009086668491364, 0.00798012875020504, 0.0019818730652332306, 0.049865782260894775, -0.05002176761627197, 0.05797622725367546, 0.03204764798283577, -0.047182559967041016, -0.055421844124794006, -0.048153676092624664, 0.022702593356370926, -0.029722223058342934, 0.07085881382226944, -0.03796577826142311, -0.08899728208780289, 0.00431864382699132, 0.026203157380223274, -0.01679832860827446, 0.03198205307126045, -0.015061884187161922, -0.009227740578353405, -0.013553096912801266, -0.022960679605603218, -0.002488180063664913, -0.06035513058304787, 0.01677788607776165, 0.0684017762541771, 0.07910197228193283, 0.003049655584618449, -0.004643826745450497, -0.09754060208797455, -0.04745398834347725, -0.03711728751659393, -0.0008198285941034555, -0.04292106255888939, 0.0758982002735138, -0.04688704013824463, 0.030709514394402504, -0.0113222049549222, -0.026438850909471512, 0.023586753755807877, 0.0379687063395977, -0.04243345558643341, 0.04394584521651268, -0.014347849413752556, 0.05091824755072594, 0.028743594884872437, -0.01740110293030739, -0.014191343449056149, -0.07588934153318405, 0.032418470829725266, -0.04496438428759575, 0.056352753192186356, 0.03738357126712799, -0.0066449884325265884, 0.035905975848436356, 0.001186827546916902, 0.0027266477700322866, 0.02153964340686798, -0.007773503195494413, 0.042877282947301865, -0.03050840087234974, -0.0058537693694233894, 0.03330561891198158, 0.04362529516220093, -0.018411191180348396, -0.023211129009723663, 0.06981100887060165, 0.010880401358008385, 0.006087595596909523, 0.04067186266183853, -0.014690576121211052, 0.023625927045941353, 0.01020442321896553, -0.013803896494209766, 0.008320831693708897, 0.007042250130325556, 0.04085788503289223, 0.0057479022070765495, -0.055191706866025925, 0.04410265386104584, -0.011613879352807999, -0.011894099414348602, -0.0259954035282135, -0.07865231484174728, -0.043018437922000885, -0.02699146792292595, 0.04495864361524582, 0.007237565238028765, -0.023702306672930717, -0.04737049713730812, -0.0011856049532070756, 0.05037550628185272, 0.01900068297982216, 0.010778381489217281, 0.041992075741291046, -0.010424532927572727, -0.0760842114686966, 0.012643695808947086, -0.011814406141638756, -0.018548257648944855, 0.001173751545138657, 0.027913600206375122, 0.04700753092765808, 0.02133403718471527, -0.0839921087026596, 0.007066077087074518, -0.04647926241159439, -0.03890344500541687, -0.04342446103692055, -0.07278440147638321, 0.04058932512998581, 0.041303765028715134, 0.04272504150867462, 0.041361693292856216, -0.0179368257522583, 0.006646375637501478, -0.020792925730347633, -0.0003048813669010997, 0.008025226183235645, 0.024947689846158028, 0.005977918393909931, -0.05737416446208954, 0.03914263844490051, -0.05211716890335083, 0.03277967870235443, -0.008340319618582726, -0.027027418836951256, 0.02320140413939953, 0.01990271359682083, 0.014025422744452953, 0.023959815502166748, 0.0024627423845231533, -0.012594418600201607, -0.02308306097984314, 0.004993801936507225, -0.04382488131523132, -0.01744008995592594, 0.04410277307033539, -0.007529705762863159, -0.038040608167648315, -0.031356703490018845, -0.03132240101695061, -0.09195339679718018, -0.05238436162471771, 0.009667984209954739, 0.03708520904183388, 0.017611190676689148, -0.006768290884792805, -0.03450591862201691, -0.033294014632701874, 0.014375582337379456, 0.0007755940314382315, 0.0336233489215374, -0.012398194521665573, 0.013017977587878704, -0.03132021427154541, 0.040476422756910324, 0.05286660045385361, 0.028897590935230255, 0.057149093598127365, 0.01624779775738716, -0.011141233146190643, -0.047689907252788544, -0.006077541504055262, 0.02121971733868122, -0.032657768577337265, -0.027059027925133705, -0.007182610686868429, -0.056446854025125504, 0.034510139375925064, 0.06290469318628311, -0.002181626157835126, 0.0007192326011136174, -0.029780613258481026, -0.042307183146476746, -0.04200121387839317, 0.03750132396817207, 0.06049354374408722, 0.017598586156964302, 0.0497605986893177, -0.024359121918678284, 0.03752997890114784, -0.0031792037189006805, 0.014563820324838161, -0.03878256678581238, -0.012037360109388828, -0.030805053189396858, -0.04256041720509529, -0.017085880041122437, -0.004732149187475443, -0.01884992979466915, 0.03200926631689072, -0.0045630354434251785, 0.009816789999604225, -0.02447841875255108, 0.031783461570739746, 0.0018750546732917428, 0.012238457798957825, 0.02694820985198021, 0.0163174569606781, 0.03569994121789932, 0.02457052655518055, -0.0001948368881130591, -0.0980258658528328, -0.06970822066068649, -0.02528485283255577, -0.028712928295135498, -0.006082743871957064, -0.01714363507926464, -0.015206214040517807, -0.03992113098502159, -0.0018014585366472602, 0.04544024541974068, -0.012389413081109524, -0.06888779997825623, -0.048041775822639465, 0.09121424704790115, 0.09353823959827423, 0.04294261708855629, 0.01815856248140335, -0.06098657473921776, -0.011806237511336803, 0.07508603483438492, -0.012613092549145222, 0.004313607234507799, -0.02868642657995224, 0.07910005003213882, 0.03116242028772831, -0.03752148523926735, 0.025074968114495277, 0.052458930760622025, 0.040988411754369736, -0.002215660410001874, 0.005055377259850502, 0.06258321553468704, 0.010092840529978275, -0.03070787340402603, -0.03715141862630844, -0.002354786731302738, -0.03138408437371254, -0.029170691967010498, 0.053826820105314255, 0.0436832495033741, -0.0113350385800004, 0.020496122539043427, -0.06997443735599518, -0.03374200314283371, 0.027018455788493156, 0.007270839996635914, 0.0163323525339365, -0.02048080787062645, -0.004850005265325308, -0.03882500156760216, 0.03673694655299187, 0.01730351150035858, 0.01820244826376438, 0.051580868661403656, -0.0426051951944828, 0.05295544117689133, 0.039634257555007935, 0.04137521982192993, -0.007199483457952738, -0.012750979512929916, -0.007345980498939753, -0.07219703495502472, 0.010531594976782799, -0.07820985466241837, 0.01090840995311737, 0.009358836337924004, 0.015421564690768719, 0.007587813306599855, -0.007419839967042208, 0.026783693581819534, 0.02889503352344036, -0.050437070429325104, 0.07158758491277695, 0.025376595556735992, -0.04508534446358681, -0.0074032084085047245, -0.015594718046486378, 0.005447327625006437, -0.00500889029353857, 0.011148957535624504, -0.015376191586256027, 0.01762452907860279, 0.02408001571893692, -0.08721163123846054, 0.05141476169228554, 0.028881562873721123, 0.05399522930383682, 0.02696601115167141, -0.026539769023656845, 0.04859897494316101, 0.0013782338937744498, -0.030105827376246452, -0.02221582643687725, 0.033989716321229935, -0.055942416191101074, -0.0410800464451313, 0.03858764469623566, -0.04846992716193199, 0.004186862614005804, -0.011778661049902439, -0.0406358502805233, 0.03633448854088783, -0.006474191322922707, 0.047727327793836594, 0.04510493203997612, -0.04236678406596184, 0.02066706120967865, -0.012162873521447182, -0.013020593672990799, 0.04752032831311226, -0.017995450645685196, -0.02425462380051613, 0.028300192207098007, 0.005940012633800507, -0.05790010839700699, -0.03594813495874405, 0.029059944674372673, -0.02912946604192257, -0.05313475802540779, 0.0060945963487029076, -0.07952985167503357, -0.00975201465189457, 0.02756750024855137, -0.035733189433813095, 0.00025115814059972763, 0.013457699678838253, 0.05598447099328041, -0.0008219371666200459, -0.028869615867733955, 0.04643785580992699, 0.03617185354232788, -0.001150775351561606, -0.055959854274988174, -0.013597273267805576, 0.07378963381052017, 0.015407843515276909, 0.01362601574510336, 0.008847442455589771, -0.02164154127240181, 0.0024312601890414953, -0.008157487027347088, -0.042950525879859924, -0.039361193776130676, -0.021017661318182945, -0.003918818663805723, 0.04804154112935066, -0.01374615915119648, 0.0194824431091547, 0.03512624278664589, 0.001668852288275957, 0.006181018892675638, -0.02799312397837639, -0.00032752021797932684, -0.03773249685764313, 0.04733121395111084, 0.020047202706336975, 0.028620246797800064, -0.031469035893678665, -0.01046711578965187, 0.03897111117839813, -0.0005735157174058259, 0.031308364123106, -0.015614505857229233, 0.01962730474770069, 0.03924509510397911, 0.029019447043538094, -0.0044287689961493015, 0.026952454820275307, -0.09650024771690369, 0.038298480212688446, -0.030862169340252876, -0.0067654200829565525, -0.019541999325156212, -0.005675151478499174, -0.07030925899744034, -0.006258117500692606, -0.06187128648161888, -0.04595618322491646, 0.024734392762184143, 0.050712063908576965, 0.04731952026486397, -0.024251772090792656, 0.03280012682080269, 0.019180702045559883, 0.009496813639998436, -0.051374927163124084, -0.018809514120221138, -0.040591057389974594, 0.05648854747414589, -0.021868938580155373, 0.02836555801331997, -0.07415932416915894, 0.004450369626283646, -0.03366217017173767, -0.004476259928196669, -0.05596977472305298, -0.079034224152565, -0.015255970880389214, -0.011654162779450417, -0.021971460431814194, -0.017408808693289757, -0.01654108054935932, -0.014821631833910942, -0.010766066610813141, 0.036749474704265594, 0.0622384212911129, 0.03912527486681938, -0.015169422142207623, -0.04202744737267494, 0.015443738549947739, -0.030825702473521233, -0.06092020124197006, 0.0010095055913552642, -0.0014881648821756244, -0.07353630661964417, 0.037938762456178665, 0.009185291826725006, -0.00848714541643858, -0.07334752380847931, -0.02616477943956852, -0.011607499793171883, -0.0006328015006147325, -0.02251274511218071, 0.06989317387342453, -0.03077661618590355, 0.056894451379776, -0.04606786370277405, 0.02126578614115715, 0.011480887420475483, 0.031432412564754486, -0.003811779199168086, -0.06532711535692215, 0.03858928009867668, 0.02646869421005249, -0.04729241505265236, 0.02859456092119217, -0.03488133102655411, 0.15479889512062073, 0.06947945803403854, -0.04259994626045227, -0.008070498704910278, 0.029037246480584145, 0.05265677720308304, 0.035536814481019974, 0.000554414524231106, 0.02846336178481579, -0.021858325228095055, -0.020978480577468872, -0.04902666434645653, -0.057068273425102234, -0.009905965998768806, 0.02370995469391346 ]
<p>A 2+1D topological field theory (topologically ordered states), implies that the topological ground state degeneracy (GSD) on $T^2$ torus (2D manifold <strong>without boundary</strong>). For example a level k U(1) Chern-Simons theory implies a GSD$=k$.</p> <p>If we put the topological field theory on a 2D manifold <strong>with 1D boundary</strong>, we expect 1+1D gapless edge states; and there are central charges $c$, which roughly measures the degree of freedom of the gapless edge states. </p> <p>My question is: are there some explicit formula relates: <strong>topological ground state degeneracy GSD</strong> and <strong>central charges c</strong>?</p> <p>Say,</p> <p>$$\text{GSD}=\text{GSD}(c,\dots)$$</p> <p>and </p> <p>$$c=c(\text{GSD},\dots)$$</p> <p>here $\dots$ are other possible data. RHS are the desired functions of my questions. It will be better to take some examples of <strong>non-Abelian</strong> topological field theory (topologically ordered states) to test its formula's validity.</p>
g1620
[ 0.014675322920084, -0.015357485972344875, -0.011686816811561584, 0.00038411442073993385, 0.07457956671714783, -0.0009531429968774319, 0.04206940531730652, 0.05937792733311653, 0.003486270783469081, -0.006339502055197954, 0.0013019790640100837, -0.03321877121925354, 0.017868781462311745, -0.009370310232043266, -0.03332067281007767, 0.0464966706931591, -0.001350525999441743, 0.0653000921010971, 0.01560697890818119, -0.03450178727507591, -0.03756137564778328, -0.04222641885280609, 0.016686279326677322, -0.04924529045820236, 0.011134433560073376, -0.012233531102538109, 0.010530445724725723, 0.013915644027292728, -0.051341526210308075, -0.03300587832927704, -0.01064434926956892, -0.010610812343657017, 0.045931097120046616, 0.02240779623389244, -0.04007242992520332, 0.05935676395893097, 0.06271616369485855, 0.0022209088783711195, 0.04954785108566284, -0.0824689045548439, 0.01707644760608673, -0.016364004462957382, 0.023273391649127007, -0.034155141562223434, -0.09965796768665314, -0.011997788213193417, -0.03239539638161659, 0.017523575574159622, -0.030479226261377335, -0.03462665155529976, -0.0005937688983976841, 0.07683462649583817, 0.04814022034406662, -0.04276927933096886, 0.00797092355787754, 0.00236816075630486, -0.025490345433354378, -0.009981933981180191, 0.07987307012081146, 0.008716891519725323, -0.029325630515813828, 0.008493755012750626, 0.011949458159506321, 0.007106250151991844, -0.0014261110918596387, 0.01051295641809702, -0.010542837902903557, -0.015591789968311787, 0.029864639043807983, -0.04749356955289841, -0.011731589213013649, -0.037256576120853424, 0.013102591969072819, -0.01145789586007595, 0.05383888632059097, 0.006969112902879715, -0.022606849670410156, -0.057243429124355316, 0.00241288635879755, 0.018503960222005844, 0.00145121687091887, -0.05520324409008026, -0.00868302769958973, -0.01861165277659893, 0.08103103190660477, -0.05182591453194618, 0.009007072076201439, 0.0014043765841051936, -0.01103154942393303, 0.041187141090631485, -0.04159310832619667, 0.03268804773688316, 0.04781060665845871, -0.010003762319684029, 0.008387868292629719, -0.02513972856104374, 0.04092591628432274, 0.007302042096853256, -0.011222214438021183, -0.029168589040637016, -0.04400242865085602, -0.003841303987428546, 0.008046669885516167, 0.01858391799032688, 0.006820350419729948, -0.013659106567502022, -0.018800759688019753, 0.012124070897698402, -0.024185478687286377, -0.015540543012320995, -0.02553248219192028, 0.08447391539812088, 0.006359136197715998, 0.037940941751003265, -0.002029096009209752, 0.0721578374505043, 0.08378786593675613, -0.07295025885105133, -0.010916933417320251, -0.03478631004691124, 0.08509976416826248, 0.0006418508710339665, -0.00784656498581171, 0.013785998336970806, 0.0012944686459377408, 0.023234115913510323, -0.03519845008850098, -0.03284883871674538, 0.04618135839700699, 0.029122527688741684, 0.01490046177059412, -0.015743879601359367, 0.05324292927980423, 0.021375777199864388, -0.010543940588831902, 0.04144887626171112, -0.0036768275313079357, -0.008942855522036552, 0.04750244691967964, -0.028419366106390953, -0.0396389439702034, -0.03983516991138458, -0.009371006861329079, -0.03956072777509689, 0.004822708200663328, 0.029323264956474304, 0.07201723009347916, -0.03857053443789482, 0.048898156732320786, 0.007544337306171656, 0.054532118141651154, -0.021721214056015015, 0.06608705222606659, -0.03578926995396614, 0.03899836912751198, 0.028651803731918335, 0.07328920066356659, -0.00486754160374403, -0.004624547436833382, 0.015237292274832726, -0.013075871393084526, 0.038779377937316895, 0.04752594232559204, -0.02230575866997242, -0.009533371776342392, -0.06636299192905426, 0.02043856307864189, -0.04689588025212288, -0.04823445528745651, 0.009656536392867565, 0.005819921847432852, 0.0642220750451088, 0.06681522727012634, 0.04801323637366295, 0.0009929835796356201, -0.002910282462835312, -0.0697290450334549, 0.032649677246809006, 0.06577403843402863, -0.002074249554425478, -0.021429989486932755, 0.03591743856668472, 0.00942076276987791, 0.07472226023674011, 0.016461046412587166, -0.011324743740260601, -0.00035849728737957776, -0.019230447709560394, 0.01958640292286873, 0.01745867170393467, -0.02760312333703041, 0.056409090757369995, -0.0401400625705719, 0.07565007358789444, 0.011990124359726906, 0.016611050814390182, 0.06815585494041443, -0.033317871391773224, 0.01619788073003292, -0.014359398745000362, 0.00794027280062437, 0.04298705607652664, -0.015605606138706207, -0.05010690912604332, -0.02918124757707119, 0.029083648696541786, -0.010947749018669128, 0.01573125459253788, 0.005117762368172407, -0.028290944173932076, -0.019005557522177696, 0.03209882602095604, -0.03783474862575531, 0.07952339947223663, -0.001011663698591292, -0.047708384692668915, 0.01313063409179449, -0.03335166722536087, -0.03717342019081116, -0.03951040282845497, -0.028489774093031883, 0.013459304347634315, 0.09332266449928284, 0.059994351118803024, -0.014805806800723076, 0.023765355348587036, 0.028091546148061752, 0.011753816157579422, -0.049210235476493835, -0.04320328310132027, -0.0025250210892409086, -0.015949029475450516, -0.02991674095392227, -0.09215902537107468, 0.036390189081430435, 0.03708736225962639, -0.0766354650259018, -0.01583457738161087, 0.07420852780342102, -0.032803867012262344, -0.033024489879608154, -0.01904401183128357, -0.027592623606324196, -0.004999848548322916, -0.03237380459904671, -0.04328642785549164, 0.026935070753097534, 0.013668329454958439, 0.007642575539648533, 0.029801256954669952, 0.05611572042107582, 0.007725476287305355, -0.03673762083053589, 0.013797005638480186, -0.014520136639475822, 0.006326974835246801, -0.006238266360014677, -0.001595226814970374, 0.0016883212374523282, -0.07663733512163162, 0.019767485558986664, -0.03734888881444931, 0.007784506306052208, 0.03164616972208023, -0.08156640082597733, -0.025494245812296867, 0.012483678758144379, -0.00720929866656661, -0.001950722187757492, 0.017238082364201546, 0.01708633080124855, 0.08518414199352264, 0.007780780550092459, 0.04944184049963951, 0.02446484938263893, -0.028572309762239456, -0.029483210295438766, 0.028514942154288292, -0.028021225705742836, -0.00363150960765779, -0.01074336376041174, 0.021457310765981674, 0.05777807906270027, 0.10184859484434128, 0.04463773965835571, -0.09297818690538406, 0.0013320172438398004, 0.008288613520562649, -0.0315791554749012, 0.039830707013607025, 0.008854391984641552, 0.05565859004855156, 0.059327591210603714, -0.028334476053714752, 0.029038652777671814, 0.00796500500291586, -0.05434515327215195, -0.02205985225737095, 0.006818724796175957, 0.08366355299949646, -0.0024240536149591208, -0.02978605031967163, 0.00010153684706892818, 0.004091201815754175, -0.00960572063922882, -0.017722636461257935, -0.06978744268417358, -0.018637731671333313, 0.054622992873191833, -0.002300882013514638, -0.009024185128509998, 0.04385298863053322, 0.06859157979488373, -0.013983397744596004, 0.005692305974662304, 0.03629978001117706, -0.0077485558576881886, -0.013234001584351063, -0.023212891072034836, 0.05155632644891739, 0.013356871902942657, -0.030590148642659187, 0.03022320568561554, 0.009583660401403904, -0.005158057902008295, 0.06032881140708923, -0.05829046666622162, 0.0022775819525122643, -0.052710406482219696, -0.04992958530783653, 0.06892602890729904, -0.013884277082979679, 0.01036525797098875, -0.013360507786273956, -0.013304106891155243, -0.025231746956706047, -0.03818555176258087, 0.02034872956573963, 0.0767279639840126, 0.00999433733522892, -0.06094871461391449, 0.0005906354053877294, -0.04479329288005829, -0.008273501880466938, 0.03617893531918526, -0.042777977883815765, -0.0172380693256855, -0.0025615564081817865, -0.03783406689763069, -0.020361270755529404, 0.0022437567822635174, -0.016605891287326813, 0.033750467002391815, 0.004938505124300718, -0.044158220291137695, 0.002870814176276326, -0.010017124004662037, 0.03308788686990738, -0.043671637773513794, 0.013285528868436813, 0.05997228994965553, 0.007223083637654781, -0.05032235011458397, -0.002365201013162732, 0.023075001314282417, -0.011712046340107918, 0.0060249753296375275, -0.039913468062877655, -0.009082304313778877, -0.006589145865291357, -0.003612107364460826, -0.0014724450884386897, 0.01742037571966648, -0.0043428437784314156, 0.032819949090480804, -0.015015522949397564, -0.01385066844522953, -0.0015594830038025975, -0.029783470556139946, -0.013787656091153622, 0.012991797178983688, 0.04342523217201233, 0.019724441692233086, 0.039951641112565994, -0.024218648672103882, -0.0025902229826897383, -0.02484351024031639, 0.024860821664333344, -0.018690526485443115, -0.042938873171806335, -0.06400949507951736, -0.0739021822810173, -0.00015227036783471704, 0.0010042338399216533, 0.01761552318930626, 0.0022845063358545303, 0.03133280202746391, -0.013038156554102898, 0.02822302281856537, 0.0004279339627828449, 0.011560657061636448, -0.036588042974472046, -0.04004878178238869, -0.042726606130599976, 0.019780289381742477, -0.025070570409297943, -0.0044510443694889545, -0.007654694374650717, -0.011085214093327522, -0.02884954959154129, 0.032959405332803726, -0.045916467905044556, -0.0001905247918330133, -0.04448188468813896, 0.02878587506711483, -0.06296747177839279, -0.014716996811330318, -0.03470565378665924, -0.025441186502575874, -0.011618797667324543, 0.06628929078578949, 0.014234881848096848, 0.05032145604491234, -0.04351339116692543, -0.06242584064602852, 0.0028649684973061085, -0.09107136726379395, -0.004902807995676994, -0.027674823999404907, 0.017486535012722015, -0.022857671603560448, 0.019560672342777252, -0.09957394748926163, 0.024574486538767815, -0.01393795758485794, 0.0589897520840168, -0.06330152601003647, 0.05174350365996361, -0.04879206791520119, -0.042458124458789825, 0.021185938268899918, 0.005930972285568714, -0.03479880839586258, -0.027163628488779068, -0.04731004685163498, 0.0025650972966104746, -0.018833212554454803, 0.03155902028083801, 0.021329006180167198, -0.007724323775619268, -0.04025770351290703, 0.015547331422567368, 0.007914731279015541, -0.0225636288523674, 0.020952589809894562, -0.04665445536375046, 0.000107380430563353, 0.01061344239860773, -0.014761020429432392, 0.022433679550886154, -0.05482633411884308, 0.024725062772631645, 0.04196073114871979, -0.03992587700486183, 0.07580219954252243, -0.039826638996601105, -0.11441677063703537, 0.03113885037600994, -0.012246344238519669, -0.0019388014916330576, 0.030942736193537712, -0.052000779658555984, -0.0247047021985054, -0.0717427060008049, -0.009724943898618221, 0.03185524791479111, -0.02043575793504715, 0.02650005929172039, -0.010285419411957264, -0.05530865117907524, -0.0025573493912816048, -0.0037085670046508312, -0.008030091412365437, 0.025928199291229248, 0.00101673963945359, 0.036382876336574554, 0.031467460095882416, 0.04023725166916847, -0.014355354011058807, -0.013831661082804203, -0.010584328323602676, 0.005135499406605959, 0.01666918210685253, 0.02402430772781372, 0.019125664606690407, -0.05988936871290207, 0.009042074903845787, -0.03333346173167229, -0.07385396957397461, 0.008171042427420616, -0.0677146464586258, 0.04660811647772789, 0.02233949489891529, 0.08060301840305328, -0.011810858733952045, 0.06676151603460312, 0.03232066333293915, -0.06160261109471321, -0.03368965908885002, -0.018726421520113945, -0.03451739624142647, 0.007588648237287998, 0.02542280964553356, 0.03882064297795296, 0.015280448831617832, 0.07025980204343796, 0.0024244715459644794, 0.00013134058099240065, 0.019044971093535423, -0.015279475599527359, 0.04149695113301277, 0.0221087783575058, 0.04683749005198479, 0.00026962414267472923, 0.009707178920507431, 0.014265565201640129, -0.04855335131287575, -0.05032956600189209, -0.00908620748668909, 0.06476093828678131, -0.03521902486681938, -0.007371970452368259, -0.03148983418941498, 0.006853774655610323, -0.01846648007631302, -0.007470367010682821, 0.03189258649945259, -0.006059738341718912, 0.026778116822242737, 0.0074644070118665695, -0.00798000767827034, -0.015906069427728653, 0.010713966563344002, -0.01808640919625759, 0.03609585016965866, -0.0301742572337389, -0.0526992604136467, -0.010751559399068356, -0.013640149496495724, -0.0631653442978859, -0.03068643808364868, 0.005078182090073824, -0.026423869654536247, -0.03363736346364021, -0.02162158116698265, 0.013137801550328732, -0.02474074810743332, -0.04813474044203758, -0.0038944729603827, 0.0109248710796237, -0.030774075537919998, 0.047698959708213806, 0.06983790546655655, 0.0918436273932457, -0.01872326247394085, 0.014013418927788734, 0.02564210258424282, -0.03894058242440224, 0.08257055282592773, -0.045222342014312744, 0.03900595381855965, 0.02874581702053547, -0.001413977355696261, 0.010285542346537113, -0.01191563718020916, -0.020967703312635422, -0.10198194533586502, -0.03947644680738449, 0.005944224074482918, -0.004642085172235966, -0.016497287899255753, 0.03392266854643822, 0.0444779098033905, -0.03850964084267616, -0.0009715081541799009, 0.010539878159761429, -0.02433365024626255, -0.04437629133462906, 0.008963157422840595, 0.06600930541753769, -0.0073020318523049355, 0.05441761389374733, -0.033872347325086594, -0.01269916258752346, 0.010822389274835587, -0.0402802936732769, 0.0590214766561985, -0.006181757431477308, -0.02885335683822632, 0.03456206992268562, 0.02019665576517582, -0.03992462158203125, -0.008722669444978237, -0.037775199860334396, 0.024309000000357628, 0.07803840935230255, 0.05570286139845848, -0.02542205899953842, 0.014115655794739723, -0.02749314345419407, -0.005044509656727314, -0.01554143987596035, -0.03816186636686325, -0.030308956280350685, 0.02555704303085804, -0.03996431455016136, -0.030263734981417656, -0.03262278065085411, -0.0029267026111483574, 0.039948783814907074, 0.020347319543361664, 0.00459446432068944, -0.01472391840070486, 0.01821662299335003, 0.06638111174106598, 0.06383831799030304, 0.02086436003446579, -0.02627009153366089, 0.026125114411115646, -0.042952172458171844, 0.01581290364265442, 0.005687030032277107, -0.0034040468744933605, 0.034812889993190765, 0.02668912708759308, 0.0007572540198452771, -0.0007593004847876728, -0.006298420485109091, -0.008804931305348873, 0.030934374779462814, -0.031137824058532715, 0.03981615975499153, 0.07632110267877579, 0.008398127742111683, -0.0014562616124749184, -0.028300819918513298, -0.021220631897449493, 0.013007573783397675, -0.02575596049427986, -0.0013798641739413142, -0.0019729568157345057, -0.0038616363890469074, -0.019506148993968964, -0.02677459828555584, 0.0020057223737239838, -0.04775361716747284, 0.004743482451885939, -0.017045684158802032, -0.021820008754730225, -0.005075585097074509, -0.024796608835458755, 0.009677420370280743, -0.012220828793942928, 0.011506135575473309, -0.03957242891192436, 0.026951968669891357, 0.03569762036204338, 0.009594103321433067, -0.010665901005268097, -0.07600864768028259, 0.024909386411309242, 0.001518315402790904, -0.029103867709636688, 0.013477510772645473, -0.045693330466747284, -0.024914661422371864, -0.04688296467065811, 0.04996497556567192, -0.0034512379206717014, -0.03152834251523018, 0.04784185066819191, 0.0540468655526638, 0.03420872613787651, -0.022047804668545723, -0.037599410861730576, 0.00767445657402277, 0.03454115241765976, 0.048771120607852936, 0.019669530913233757, 0.034641657024621964, 0.021703260019421577, -0.03767244145274162, -0.004015346523374319, 0.02408260479569435, -0.06053498014807701, 0.00458301929756999, -0.015651533380150795, 0.03848012536764145, 0.013568282127380371, -0.014089352451264858, 0.017537515610456467, -0.04377426952123642, -0.08074219524860382, -0.021332843229174614, 0.06247463822364807, -0.019034836441278458, 0.008136407472193241, 0.010446962900459766, -0.0646967664361, 0.03919917717576027, -0.013421770185232162, 0.002656158059835434, 0.002034987322986126, -0.012209469452500343, -0.030683863908052444, 0.017771095037460327, -0.02819065935909748, 0.013230250217020512, 0.04619035869836807, 0.014012507162988186, -0.04830503091216087, -0.04697735607624054, 0.014930741861462593, 0.02985166385769844, 0.004706889856606722, -0.024327317252755165, 0.03336166962981224, 0.010087007656693459, 0.03365094214677811, 0.0575677864253521, -0.0050971475429832935, -0.03874492272734642, 0.0028460966423153877, 0.03166161850094795, -0.037770770490169525, 0.04718328267335892, 0.04173090681433678, -0.06388473510742188, 0.08418203145265579, -0.0009878049604594707, -0.03365490585565567, 0.025313418358564377, 0.0037062799092382193, -0.08965478092432022, -0.0018905411707237363, 0.1039363443851471, -0.00489131361246109, 0.011998290196061134, 0.02557557262480259, -0.01935078576207161, 0.05482538044452667, -0.06227780878543854, 0.06952814757823944, 0.017478328198194504, 0.00966344028711319, 0.012715261429548264, 0.04047113656997681, -0.007070241495966911, -0.005067489575594664, 0.030774805694818497, -0.02259734645485878, -0.000793067563790828, -0.01058255322277546, 0.005576846655458212, -0.030842861160635948, -0.07511470466852188, -0.035873591899871826, 0.016912095248699188 ]
<p>Related: <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/79074/2451">What is meant by boiling off electrons in a heater coil?</a></p> <p>In the Thomson tube we used in our class to produce an electron beam, the lab manual stated that the tube was filled with a low pressure argon gas. When the electrons collided with the argon gas, electrons in the gas molecules were excited and when they de-excite, green light is emitted. However, when one looks at the atomic spectra of argon, there are two green lines, as shown below.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/kihYy.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>Is one able to distinguished between these two green lines in this experiment or am I actually seeing both of these lines? I assume that because the Thomson tube sends in a range of electron velocities, that maybe its both green lines that I am seeing. However, I don't know for sure.</p>
g1621
[ 0.008075185120105743, -0.029439905658364296, -0.004085504449903965, -0.04597509279847145, 0.1044728010892868, 0.03824223205447197, -0.03704032674431801, -0.002911248477175832, -0.00461028004065156, -0.02039739303290844, 0.04279198870062828, 0.026592396199703217, 0.08040963858366013, 0.013593249954283237, -0.010949899442493916, -0.09047024697065353, 0.0681924968957901, -0.034852005541324615, -0.029890112578868866, 0.04506254941225052, -0.009828390553593636, 0.015231618657708168, -0.045205071568489075, -0.05235622450709343, 0.0042572347447276115, -0.037531670182943344, -0.040762703865766525, 0.015362582169473171, 0.02711561694741249, -0.03480280935764313, 0.0024897551629692316, 0.042377110570669174, 0.01731736771762371, -0.03778766095638275, -0.049727026373147964, -0.014702503569424152, 0.05916007608175278, 0.007919907569885254, -0.029561342671513557, -0.05251053348183632, 0.01647776924073696, 0.021359864622354507, 0.012687310576438904, -0.01467976812273264, 0.06620457768440247, 0.021171074360609055, 0.015398111194372177, 0.018467145040631294, -0.043113429099321365, 0.01951826550066471, 0.0032523097470402718, 0.05260162055492401, -0.06340200453996658, -0.012367742136120796, -0.021643705666065216, 0.020126303657889366, -0.048944998532533646, -0.010289691388607025, 0.08508684486150742, 0.03575644642114639, 0.05158070847392082, 0.02653072588145733, 0.015934055671095848, -0.033412810415029526, 0.03200149908661842, -0.04353579506278038, -0.02436634711921215, 0.020607154816389084, -0.016762301325798035, 0.044926345348358154, -0.0027462856378406286, -0.08488152921199799, -0.005873112007975578, -0.004957607015967369, 0.0047820270992815495, -0.02910725213587284, 0.022356994450092316, 0.010080356150865555, 0.0011790404096245766, -0.0011152065126225352, -0.07601337879896164, -0.01724701002240181, -0.052767738699913025, 0.03399456664919853, -0.024530673399567604, -0.026435643434524536, -0.02161373756825924, -0.05383923649787903, -0.015962332487106323, 0.03473653271794319, -0.011984641663730145, 0.012217485345900059, 0.05068274959921837, 0.03774593025445938, -0.0407625287771225, -0.030423203483223915, -0.00180385063868016, 0.04740443080663681, -0.0037887347862124443, 0.010616356506943703, -0.03931311517953873, -0.025255277752876282, 0.02083078771829605, -0.0220734141767025, -0.04112587869167328, -0.014743467792868614, -0.028974536806344986, -0.029568573459982872, -0.06351173669099808, -0.015627888962626457, -0.03207177668809891, -0.018528738990426064, -0.029740892350673676, 0.015004604123532772, -0.025379348546266556, 0.0008142226142808795, 0.00023916306963656098, -0.010112601332366467, 0.011632655747234821, 0.0618501715362072, 0.08814667165279388, 0.04280482232570648, -0.026777468621730804, -0.009041951969265938, 0.014788264408707619, -0.01603483222424984, 0.019563721492886543, -0.0582282654941082, 0.03440051153302193, 0.03737844526767731, -0.02264133282005787, -0.0223399568349123, -0.04673292487859726, 0.04304185137152672, 0.07002358138561249, 0.018210837617516518, 0.016713377088308334, 0.024072306230664253, 0.010115536861121655, 0.026779809966683388, 0.020085306838154793, -0.00930284895002842, -0.029253054410219193, -0.07194114476442337, -0.0048912083730101585, 0.0052872016094625, -0.014381210319697857, -0.020985107868909836, 0.048203226178884506, 0.03130248934030533, -0.004242672584950924, 0.0026403486263006926, 0.04094218835234642, 0.020463626831769943, 0.023209478706121445, -0.02611110359430313, 0.029447423294186592, -0.09247560054063797, 0.06550418585538864, 0.03339174762368202, -0.028059380128979683, -0.0717298686504364, 0.004193496890366077, 0.020252441987395287, -0.0717923566699028, 0.03383830562233925, 0.029849065467715263, -0.09304129332304001, 0.06276167184114456, -0.06294380873441696, -0.07137186080217361, -0.003341078059747815, 0.004785315599292517, -0.0460520014166832, 0.06038447842001915, 0.03987951576709747, 0.038697388023138046, -0.00271789962425828, 0.011173207312822342, 0.0032920311205089092, -0.0339263379573822, 0.015367927961051464, -0.045026686042547226, -0.017010651528835297, 0.04372876510024071, 0.03480998054146767, -0.046618424355983734, -0.00042317435145378113, 0.012507753446698189, -0.000523827678989619, 0.020369665697216988, 0.007122790440917015, -0.033514201641082764, -0.016654128208756447, 0.0005985017050988972, -0.0759124755859375, -0.015454624779522419, -0.009282378479838371, -0.0372764952480793, 0.027437511831521988, -0.024349024519324303, 0.01938256062567234, -0.02494128793478012, 0.03507063537836075, 0.03685964643955231, -0.01081021036952734, 0.0021551665849983692, -0.027727097272872925, -0.004858991131186485, -0.048986513167619705, 0.01944546401500702, 0.07530857622623444, 0.016283120959997177, 0.05047374963760376, -0.05867345258593559, 0.00951013807207346, 0.020192548632621765, 0.024177487939596176, -0.007810120936483145, 0.00167406618129462, 0.0032443006057292223, 0.027420513331890106, -0.05005437880754471, -0.023396488279104233, 0.022603007033467293, -0.06941541284322739, 0.0032136193476617336, -0.02150159515440464, -0.06020311266183853, -0.030815940350294113, -0.03853738680481911, 0.01009354554116726, -0.020413517951965332, -0.10153139382600784, 0.033116962760686874, -0.010393727570772171, 0.00294691976159811, -0.031570836901664734, -0.024026865139603615, 0.03302231431007385, 0.008862929418683052, -0.02591138519346714, -0.01046910509467125, -0.01898861862719059, 0.03949147090315819, 0.024407466873526573, -0.025106627494096756, 0.0063299015164375305, 0.0020225339103490114, 0.015615156851708889, 0.00025304919108748436, 0.027580922469496727, -0.013304437510669231, 0.10834579169750214, 0.02492412179708481, 0.005398071836680174, -0.026736250147223473, -0.020313216373324394, -0.029008641839027405, -0.01996028982102871, -0.00005028273517382331, 0.0011768937110900879, -0.025130145251750946, 0.017201537266373634, -0.007016002666205168, -0.03639468178153038, -0.004720231518149376, 0.014154435135424137, 0.012102866545319557, -0.01745741255581379, -0.02977311983704567, 0.025159837678074837, -0.08371426910161972, -0.06298542022705078, 0.049539122730493546, -0.01936759427189827, -0.0028990190476179123, -0.05656493082642555, 0.036112744361162186, -0.04581683874130249, -0.01786169968545437, -0.02299518696963787, -0.04660020023584366, 0.018106143921613693, 0.041075341403484344, -0.0032772794365882874, -0.03557819873094559, 0.04870018735527992, 0.0017758627654984593, 0.03617877513170242, -0.03767725080251694, -0.016619564965367317, 0.02179708331823349, -0.015916291624307632, -0.04399329796433449, -0.009887320920825005, 0.0313066765666008, 0.04359094798564911, -0.00046464864863082767, 0.012889178469777107, -0.04553834721446037, -0.0559253990650177, -0.0677371621131897, 0.015086013823747635, 0.010440964251756668, 0.010801429860293865, -0.04269386827945709, -0.013353321701288223, -0.030189523473381996, -0.032803673297166824, -0.004019121173769236, -0.014746754430234432, 0.00701519288122654, 0.05382296070456505, 0.0007193569908849895, 0.02050185017287731, -0.037637628614902496, -0.002533961785957217, 0.04236522689461708, 0.04639819636940956, -0.055532749742269516, 0.007865319028496742, 0.03278585523366928, -0.011701274663209915, -0.00271405978128314, 0.003065584460273385, 0.016083933413028717, -0.07172245532274246, 0.021904142573475838, -0.033100128173828125, -0.02101893350481987, -0.08286385983228683, -0.06069124862551689, -0.05989744886755943, -0.03867688402533531, -0.01983659341931343, -0.006724169477820396, 0.06195822358131409, -0.0028413033578544855, 0.027785632759332657, 0.0383271723985672, 0.028682246804237366, -0.03020106814801693, -0.03713718056678772, 0.013380538672208786, -0.04466228187084198, -0.032941803336143494, -0.016002796590328217, 0.023094182834029198, -0.027814505621790886, 0.0843048170208931, 0.052960995584726334, 0.08079225569963455, -0.020799098536372185, -0.029530929401516914, -0.048388801515102386, 0.01515729445964098, -0.01039069052785635, -0.009574631229043007, 0.0003073092084378004, -0.03057967871427536, 0.002223887015134096, 0.020568866282701492, -0.03235027939081192, -0.03350837156176567, -0.04633716866374016, -0.041016511619091034, 0.06848035007715225, 0.05838724970817566, -0.023895500227808952, -0.04687489941716194, -0.016039635986089706, -0.022819876670837402, 0.019092941656708717, 0.03939905762672424, -0.02969653159379959, 0.003845404600724578, 0.050889916718006134, -0.014645165763795376, 0.05923972278833389, -0.07649853080511093, -0.0028971247375011444, 0.016214212402701378, -0.0026175871025770903, 0.02326100319623947, -0.013103577308356762, 0.03380350023508072, 0.01132305059581995, 0.0018726333510130644, -0.09754558652639389, -0.012594952248036861, 0.013933500275015831, -0.010092712938785553, -0.009774018079042435, -0.0023226062767207623, 0.011350660584867, 0.031108075752854347, 0.005611897446215153, 0.032585348933935165, 0.032317861914634705, -0.01830429397523403, -0.005838155280798674, 0.0020845201797783375, -0.02800491265952587, -0.020756559446454048, 0.0036050279159098864, 0.0573321208357811, 0.02094123512506485, 0.027028925716876984, -0.054731886833906174, -0.009645146317780018, 0.03138549625873566, 0.0134197399020195, -0.009251323528587818, -0.004718597512692213, -0.05756377801299095, -0.03792889043688774, -0.0001695367827778682, -0.011668387800455093, -0.0015140522737056017, 0.04897160828113556, 0.006157122552394867, 0.0710996612906456, 0.0010320644360035658, -0.0031812202651053667, 0.05974862724542618, 0.022748157382011414, 0.049760520458221436, 0.002117918571457267, -0.02114909701049328, -0.011280257254838943, -0.035546720027923584, -0.0522649884223938, -0.005927857477217913, -0.0228758305311203, 0.05544376000761986, -0.02863270975649357, -0.019858937710523605, 0.037403713911771774, 0.07182389497756958, 0.10423126816749573, -0.017692066729068756, 0.00765865296125412, 0.015889065340161324, 0.04852825030684471, -0.029017560184001923, 0.005823981948196888, 0.0026922922115772963, -0.04287652298808098, -0.012838408350944519, 0.029421478509902954, -0.0166909322142601, -0.07202643156051636, -0.010400921106338501, 0.01454315148293972, 0.001934765954501927, -0.030008500441908836, 0.013020364567637444, -0.06389313191175461, 0.05445481836795807, -0.04473717883229256, 0.013005878776311874, -0.0017307255184277892, 0.0045816185884177685, 0.05809301882982254, -0.010885519906878471, -0.08934066444635391, -0.02802976965904236, 0.0026814700104296207, -0.05953843146562576, 0.004715665243566036, -0.013364083133637905, 0.03952185809612274, -0.01337048877030611, 0.019281819462776184, -0.02241622842848301, -0.018387839198112488, 0.01462568063288927, 0.0028046208899468184, -0.04921186715364456, -0.014490948989987373, -0.006429124623537064, 0.026763301342725754, 0.042283620685338974, 0.0299998726695776, -0.02348538488149643, -0.050716888159513474, 0.102012038230896, 0.0173631701618433, 0.00951095949858427, 0.042027559131383896, 0.02778174914419651, 0.03598138317465782, 0.01958531327545643, -0.03200015053153038, -0.025803644210100174, 0.027194393798708916, 0.024487923830747604, -0.029918186366558075, 0.06972954422235489, -0.0418851263821125, -0.040975891053676605, -0.010630623437464237, -0.015723610296845436, -0.022610703483223915, 0.030563371255993843, 0.004231623839586973, 0.010715133510529995, 0.04316205531358719, -0.0287715345621109, -0.02749427780508995, -0.052182238548994064, -0.021043360233306885, 0.012002101168036461, 0.0035712618846446276, 0.030972620472311974, -0.05525198578834534, -0.030089804902672768, -0.027855509892106056, -0.013852065429091454, 0.020185068249702454, 0.016315704211592674, 0.028349461033940315, 0.0013735017273575068, -0.017344245687127113, 0.008010116405785084, 0.015607868321239948, 0.039424724876880646, 0.11034078896045685, 0.07292991131544113, 0.034291721880435944, 0.028743315488100052, 0.06846998631954193, 0.02984328381717205, 0.02629583515226841, -0.007690697908401489, -0.04777976870536804, -0.004926297813653946, 0.04531964287161827, 0.0314970538020134, 0.029785191640257835, -0.022979116067290306, 0.004964352585375309, 0.01431795209646225, 0.08418451994657516, 0.01686113327741623, -0.02358577400445938, -0.01966814137995243, 0.05073968321084976, 0.021585464477539062, 0.06977853924036026, -0.006849538069218397, 0.03032720275223255, -0.041471216827631, 0.04862562566995621, 0.004365863278508186, 0.05758011341094971, -0.024205463007092476, 0.03905656561255455, 0.030727913603186607, 0.042801838368177414, 0.020128630101680756, 0.07744364440441132, 0.01777574233710766, 0.06107919663190842, 0.003627491183578968, -0.03732624277472496, -0.00724482536315918, -0.02241990715265274, -0.0025706046726554632, 0.009864039719104767, -0.03293737396597862, 0.03857075795531273, -0.0002920209080912173, 0.03567652031779289, -0.011355669237673283, -0.025361433625221252, 0.0558466799557209, -0.017107125371694565, 0.007400307804346085, 0.05246419087052345, 0.05431906133890152, -0.017141101881861687, -0.018234318122267723, -0.013809174299240112, -0.02671266905963421, 0.03521507605910301, 0.09118576347827911, 0.033330321311950684, 0.01730016991496086, -0.02800065092742443, -0.0450718067586422, -0.016544533893465996, -0.01785542070865631, 0.0442768819630146, -0.05738966166973114, -0.019623655825853348, -0.046803515404462814, -0.003797433339059353, -0.028326943516731262, 0.06242530792951584, 0.03508802875876427, -0.01278125960379839, -0.01013658195734024, 0.02303309366106987, -0.035635460168123245, 0.03640799596905708, 0.02770395018160343, -0.029216550290584564, -0.014196927659213543, -0.06636162847280502, 0.01894529163837433, 0.003987140022218227, -0.04483773931860924, 0.029223406687378883, -0.010522413067519665, -0.0054646022617816925, -0.014275699853897095, 0.04410289227962494, 0.009130038321018219, 0.030777111649513245, -0.0007677197572775185, 0.03784165158867836, -0.013179768808186054, 0.09288402646780014, 0.026786085218191147, -0.03710553050041199, 0.003490342292934656, 0.022985359653830528, -0.00544612156227231, -0.025779232382774353, 0.0023273180704563856, 0.012960647232830524, -0.015094532631337643, 0.01790008880198002, 0.04656526818871498, 0.0035225264728069305, -0.006372795440256596, 0.056183770298957825, 0.03188185393810272, -0.055098168551921844, 0.011532420292496681, 0.0372183658182621, -0.04527420178055763, -0.02622045762836933, 0.025841668248176575, 0.023912640288472176, -0.04046130180358887, -0.04631689935922623, -0.003607199527323246, -0.03770558536052704, -0.07408583909273148, 0.011667638085782528, 0.01784989796578884, 0.02494264394044876, -0.003966945223510265, -0.013636198826134205, 0.028651069849729538, 0.01628745347261429, -0.028493987396359444, 0.0032549879979342222, -0.01443894486874342, -0.023750251159071922, -0.004450115375220776, 0.024206332862377167, 0.013357004150748253, -0.05806373432278633, -0.05298442766070366, -0.011706487275660038, -0.0354757122695446, 0.01464021299034357, -0.03861008211970329, -0.009065965190529823, -0.009309520944952965, 0.00953415036201477, 0.016645489260554314, -0.032448023557662964, 0.035386212170124054, -0.025197679176926613, -0.017792051658034325, -0.05290460214018822, 0.05952619016170502, 0.0514654740691185, -0.05075140669941902, -0.011723615229129791, -0.04685422405600548, 0.015053458511829376, -0.03057524561882019, -0.04381955787539482, -0.026310153305530548, -0.016921164467930794, -0.01759684830904007, 0.04319336637854576, -0.009344564750790596, 0.023600531741976738, -0.010146562941372395, -0.009044984355568886, -0.03141383081674576, 0.03330935165286064, -0.0183330699801445, 0.016377562656998634, 0.02251187525689602, 0.006395811215043068, -0.014729142189025879, 0.008120761252939701, 0.016237245872616768, 0.05879681929945946, 0.0009018030832521617, -0.06531669944524765, 0.0021979431621730328, 0.037169087678194046, 0.025357894599437714, 0.054368820041418076, 0.032296471297740936, 0.012827341444790363, 0.014481896534562111, -0.03499246761202812, 0.0013953812886029482, 0.05257093906402588, 0.0301402285695076, -0.011721113696694374, 0.006738145370036364, -0.03140045329928398, 0.05991945415735245, 0.008001350797712803, -0.0065241241827607155, -0.0072976951487362385, 0.09707823395729065, 0.049567658454179764, 0.03337181359529495, -0.053545329719781876, 0.03326595574617386, -0.02381054311990738, -0.0344696082174778, -0.056506358087062836, 0.051649123430252075, 0.06234707683324814, -0.04462268576025963, 0.049467891454696655, -0.0036661101039499044, 0.05538373813033104, 0.06245170161128044, 0.041427746415138245, -0.023115478456020355, -0.06248623877763748, -0.050383273512125015, 0.0075582535937428474, -0.026999322697520256, 0.034072145819664, 0.00017023415421135724, 0.09148410707712173, -0.058124613016843796, -0.01948234997689724, 0.027581628412008286, 0.02818984165787697, -0.05928454175591469, -0.027631662786006927, 0.04292922094464302, -0.01626269891858101, -0.004381329286843538, -0.016893630847334862, 0.054162852466106415, -0.014676726423203945, 0.018125886097550392, -0.006140224635601044, -0.03453555703163147, -0.03836570307612419, -0.024350685998797417 ]
<p>Imagine an eruption of energy/mass $E$ from a singularity $O$, as in a Big Bang. After the energy/mass $E$ is all at more than a distance $d$ from $O$, is it for some value of $d$ possible that there could be a new eruption of energy/mass from $O$, i.e. a new Big Bang? If yes, is there an upper limit to the number of succeeding Big Bangs? </p>
g1622
[ 0.013461977243423462, 0.01802453026175499, 0.029635114595294, -0.007048599887639284, -0.05180845782160759, 0.04208377003669739, -0.029518108814954758, 0.04833649843931198, -0.030186394229531288, -0.03148987889289856, -0.01949378475546837, 0.009099762886762619, 0.06421657651662827, -0.030882075428962708, 0.0008710376569069922, -0.0517246350646019, 0.03626183792948723, -0.1132546067237854, -0.020792830735445023, 0.05768878385424614, -0.011782675050199032, -0.014616827480494976, 0.05444467067718506, -0.01914554461836815, -0.04892827942967415, 0.028480159118771553, 0.019505975767970085, 0.011002114042639732, -0.026194391772150993, -0.06877215206623077, 0.0442570224404335, -0.008286931551992893, 0.0561382994055748, 0.014120937325060368, 0.002964406507089734, -0.026936955749988556, -0.023106969892978668, -0.035749077796936035, 0.03796471282839775, 0.00561032397672534, 0.05465487763285637, 0.017538025975227356, 0.048016127198934555, -0.05834058299660683, -0.030979109928011894, -0.007962960749864578, -0.00030635728035122156, 0.053786903619766235, 0.08506473898887634, -0.06232323497533798, -0.023347215726971626, 0.002661872422322631, 0.04244481772184372, 0.004696034826338291, -0.01394877303391695, 0.059159696102142334, 0.0022803416941314936, -0.028261281549930573, 0.07453402131795883, 0.05236509069800377, -0.016547488048672676, 0.006470631342381239, 0.023603858426213264, -0.017348287627100945, 0.029588110744953156, -0.004403136670589447, -0.06523256003856659, 0.024364637210965157, -0.011046149767935276, -0.049623627215623856, 0.1000404879450798, -0.008603873662650585, -0.015723802149295807, -0.027036959305405617, -0.057161249220371246, -0.005833080969750881, 0.011080232448875904, -0.011121304705739021, -0.03852444887161255, 0.020954560488462448, -0.0021892443764954805, 0.04506649821996689, 0.029506592079997063, -0.005859721917659044, 0.023301148787140846, -0.011147779412567616, 0.009548351168632507, 0.025151090696454048, -0.0016533007146790624, -0.014468329958617687, 0.006792689207941294, 0.036709852516651154, 0.0195163581520319, 0.0018903142772614956, 0.04237623140215874, -0.06342270970344543, 0.003543806727975607, 0.08539073169231415, -0.07218492031097412, 0.017081288620829582, -0.00412871316075325, -0.00981669221073389, 0.03161432594060898, 0.003563109552487731, 0.013609853573143482, -0.04478081315755844, -0.02424364909529686, -0.009198106825351715, 0.04255617409944534, 0.011108764447271824, 0.0276553463190794, -0.05065889284014702, -0.004155678674578667, 0.02293732948601246, -0.08020564168691635, 0.029704416170716286, 0.061200596392154694, -0.032014962285757065, -0.06493538618087769, 0.04809727519750595, 0.039926234632730484, -0.030597228556871414, -0.06310541182756424, 0.024044178426265717, -0.04683087021112442, 0.016993721947073936, 0.014170325361192226, 0.004160257056355476, 0.0006077840807847679, 0.03267195448279381, -0.02901601418852806, -0.0010720192221924663, 0.03724240884184837, -0.04102552682161331, 0.07287297397851944, -0.02519315481185913, 0.013132522813975811, 0.031032197177410126, 0.05208803340792656, -0.03817502036690712, 0.0422702394425869, 0.0025686882436275482, -0.006210851017385721, 0.02764953300356865, -0.010321629233658314, 0.04198448732495308, 0.05509866401553154, 0.04324743151664734, 0.010747001506388187, 0.05179262533783913, -0.00877818651497364, 0.03559427708387375, -0.013050172477960587, -0.04483535885810852, 0.004964263178408146, 0.039970941841602325, -0.023026704788208008, 0.02318098396062851, -0.035804662853479385, -0.07346518337726593, -0.00427823094651103, -0.03162307292222977, 0.04650159925222397, -0.030664941295981407, 0.006687000393867493, 0.015282443724572659, 0.0064047956839203835, -0.017483998090028763, -0.04986150562763214, 0.012176384218037128, -0.02784160152077675, -0.00108625169377774, 0.07684473693370819, 0.004085645079612732, 0.03358925133943558, -0.01357751153409481, 0.03447498753666878, -0.04044375196099281, -0.03877302631735802, -0.03468344733119011, -0.05257432162761688, -0.01341921929270029, -0.0197307039052248, 0.0083206407725811, 0.04683336615562439, -0.004023226909339428, 0.02503179758787155, 0.019111691042780876, 0.041068144142627716, 0.0177947785705328, -0.027632970362901688, -0.008639002218842506, 0.02894909679889679, 0.03275519609451294, 0.06158154457807541, 0.042018819600343704, 0.024599650874733925, 0.0022802778985351324, -0.020122002810239792, 0.010506699793040752, 0.05337423458695412, 0.07706309109926224, -0.002110384637489915, -0.0030330526642501354, 0.035565219819545746, 0.04371274635195732, 0.0248968917876482, -0.002239392139017582, 0.02726440504193306, -0.002464487450197339, 0.028470272198319435, -0.048289891332387924, -0.032591480761766434, -0.002809787169098854, -0.0282572153955698, 0.004793882369995117, 0.03274333104491234, 0.028198033571243286, 0.0069442386738955975, 0.006685130763798952, -0.06325484812259674, 0.0398254320025444, 0.03190815448760986, -0.003328792518004775, 0.06270074099302292, 0.01000162586569786, 0.0030479880515486, -0.03835625946521759, -0.03281109780073166, -0.002667035674676299, -0.078575499355793, 0.05153636261820793, 0.05594775825738907, -0.0718776136636734, 0.0456007681787014, -0.02146802842617035, 0.04303038865327835, -0.08611048758029938, -0.02265658974647522, 0.006806627381592989, 0.018277302384376526, -0.06637928634881973, -0.027188610285520554, -0.06315333396196365, 0.031145477667450905, -0.11348488181829453, -0.0016942293150350451, 0.06298708915710449, 0.009337518364191055, 0.01418506633490324, 0.019373375922441483, -0.07450992614030838, -0.010506191290915012, 0.05359896272420883, -0.014058167114853859, -0.04925849288702011, -0.04046463593840599, 0.04483923316001892, -0.045571792870759964, -0.02819357067346573, -0.01740918681025505, -0.019630329683423042, 0.032795608043670654, -0.026967661455273628, -0.02851763926446438, -0.02444606088101864, -0.007325689774006605, -0.030672572553157806, -0.06394043564796448, 0.01599274016916752, -0.010241789743304253, 0.06500109285116196, 0.02966810204088688, 0.04288747161626816, -0.014827708713710308, 0.0383305698633194, 0.011215562000870705, -0.0033526469487696886, 0.07338938117027283, 0.011142551898956299, -0.053775593638420105, 0.03149013593792915, -0.038303520530462265, 0.004808981902897358, 0.015106362290680408, -0.036711446940898895, 0.010432851500809193, -0.011135894805192947, 0.03260286897420883, -0.004353666678071022, 0.01931646838784218, -0.024460462853312492, 0.04119744896888733, 0.04259561374783516, -0.021200504153966904, 0.03366794437170029, -0.03356967121362686, 0.0272148996591568, -0.020734108984470367, 0.0196925587952137, 0.03761274740099907, -0.05744420737028122, -0.034747105091810226, -0.03366924449801445, 0.009434652514755726, 0.02292126603424549, -0.017332078889012337, -0.009943933226168156, -0.027569741010665894, -0.06156482174992561, 0.038915906101465225, 0.07514096051454544, 0.03434544429183006, 0.03280144929885864, 0.009749289602041245, -0.03572392836213112, -0.0036739856004714966, -0.010774481110274792, 0.040488895028829575, -0.02827109582722187, -0.051988162100315094, -0.01368496473878622, 0.005654939915984869, -0.044596027582883835, 0.037045709788799286, 0.00866316631436348, -0.0850188210606575, 0.016339831054210663, -0.048270780593156815, 0.014863861724734306, -0.037433259189128876, 0.007306365296244621, -0.07550796121358871, -0.026196012273430824, -0.008398286066949368, -0.01242565643042326, 0.03786976635456085, 0.05439149960875511, 0.09843164682388306, 0.11160281300544739, -0.016228636726737022, 0.05714527890086174, 0.015242081135511398, -0.0340607687830925, 0.053713373839855194, 0.0642453283071518, -0.019737999886274338, -0.015107337385416031, 0.025178419426083565, -0.04997272416949272, 0.003854819806292653, -0.0485551692545414, 0.037399742752313614, 0.02782825194299221, 0.021969228982925415, -0.03036000207066536, 0.025320550426840782, -0.02318892441689968, 0.04795122891664505, -0.07455208152532578, 0.01112288236618042, -0.015854215249419212, 0.05004900321364403, 0.018786540254950523, -0.022106925025582314, -0.04506918787956238, -0.044869109988212585, -0.03277291730046272, -0.02503718063235283, -0.019553666934370995, 0.05303236097097397, -0.02976885624229908, -0.013436870649456978, -0.021133003756403923, 0.030972754582762718, -0.01581007055938244, -0.007668484002351761, 0.026464471593499184, -0.029135921970009804, -0.016074245795607567, 0.00826183333992958, -0.02434895560145378, 0.03492167219519615, -0.006806692108511925, -0.07017717510461807, 0.019874142482876778, -0.01347180362790823, -0.0432526059448719, 0.012899464927613735, 0.013183108530938625, 0.016243258491158485, -0.06408922374248505, 0.023440329357981682, -0.019699471071362495, -0.014140231534838676, -0.05766469985246658, -0.003975476138293743, -0.0670003890991211, -0.017893893644213676, 0.03140387684106827, 0.002598230727016926, -0.0354158841073513, 0.014462423510849476, -0.03011327236890793, -0.002163937548175454, 0.0007461993955075741, 0.057855430990457535, 0.028657875955104828, 0.013166219927370548, -0.06180243566632271, 0.027071593329310417, -0.05832909792661667, -0.025605646893382072, -0.03603764995932579, -0.012496255338191986, -0.060747019946575165, 0.012461837381124496, 0.007402161601930857, 0.03494651988148689, 0.04465731233358383, -0.008758297190070152, -0.026692701503634453, 0.0034561329521238804, 0.05167039483785629, -0.0010987132554873824, 0.03393130376935005, -0.0014229535590857267, -0.04155287146568298, -0.045922957360744476, 0.0025947140529751778, 0.031546346843242645, 0.04502558708190918, 0.01103963702917099, 0.012346267700195312, -0.022544370964169502, 0.052299752831459045, -0.031948696821928024, 0.012201076373457909, 0.012849009595811367, -0.0075180563144385815, 0.05867284908890724, 0.018872935324907303, 0.027029233053326607, 0.06439086049795151, 0.060493484139442444, 0.057005640119314194, -0.007531424984335899, -0.008305702358484268, -0.023341692984104156, 0.041479893028736115, -0.012194188311696053, -0.018209414556622505, -0.020003309473395348, -0.022521890699863434, 0.011468923650681973, -0.05839766561985016, -0.05990275740623474, 0.034921832382678986, 0.024713221937417984, 0.01664401777088642, -0.010395707562565804, -0.000316769874189049, 0.02186340093612671, 0.05422181263566017, 0.010214756242930889, -0.054742053151130676, -0.05933623015880585, -0.012720908969640732, -0.05853380262851715, 0.0076502044685184956, -0.0281214639544487, 0.03019510954618454, 0.016560163348913193, 0.02658962272107601, -0.04668368399143219, -0.06845437735319138, -0.0233327466994524, -0.04546656459569931, -0.0070545729249715805, -0.02372843399643898, 0.02052275650203228, -0.028223158791661263, -0.032507531344890594, 0.013724229298532009, -0.0006825364544056356, 0.030348578467965126, -0.04813665524125099, -0.035138506442308426, 0.023910442367196083, -0.0007117711938917637, 0.0059935119934380054, 0.014796528965234756, 0.021821854636073112, 0.03763391077518463, 0.03633576259016991, 0.025596635416150093, 0.03368168696761131, 0.010245953686535358, -0.034908466041088104, 0.026460671797394753, -0.007506709545850754, 0.03938452526926994, -0.02948828786611557, 0.023769913241267204, -0.019844714552164078, 0.038700614124536514, 0.02194911614060402, -0.013687883503735065, 0.020028695464134216, -0.016679925844073296, -0.03970629349350929, 0.01939835213124752, 0.001933773630298674, 0.02822374366223812, 0.016768332570791245, -0.021416066214442253, -0.014000278897583485, 0.03197573125362396, -0.011125844903290272, -0.029798487201333046, 0.06681782007217407, -0.06868182867765427, 0.016520798206329346, 0.026596974581480026, -0.000051150320359738544, -0.025230396538972855, -0.043454136699438095, 0.008258327841758728, 0.012024246156215668, 0.04925284907221794, 0.019322875887155533, -0.014569857157766819, -0.04913169518113136, 0.00048720906488597393, -0.025264130905270576, 0.0537581592798233, -0.05286799743771553, 0.014491298235952854, -0.02993578277528286, -0.02723359316587448, 0.026784727349877357, -0.0183867197483778, 0.03243982419371605, 0.0375526025891304, 0.06383676826953888, 0.007566448301076889, -0.011257979087531567, 0.02274763211607933, 0.05104948952794075, 0.00022347341291606426, -0.050410233438014984, 0.01621297001838684, -0.02513141557574272, -0.02197759598493576, -0.004180892836302519, 0.054341088980436325, 0.01583762839436531, -0.04712576046586037, -0.026190830394625664, -0.032440025359392166, -0.007591079454869032, 0.01525714248418808, 0.0357174351811409, 0.04491312801837921, -0.045580875128507614, -0.056131429970264435, -0.01699010282754898, -0.07268863171339035, 0.04238342493772507, -0.0022538478951901197, 0.01589987613260746, 0.014754951000213623, 0.012941512279212475, -0.003228824120014906, -0.01863289065659046, -0.07917537540197372, 0.03312268853187561, 0.014996754005551338, 0.038228992372751236, 0.028076400980353355, -0.026590032503008842, 0.016195101663470268, 0.06389403343200684, 0.040060028433799744, 0.02805631421506405, -0.027385899797081947, -0.08963963389396667, 0.05655481666326523, 0.0328541025519371, 0.0008617878775112331, 0.008437620475888252, -0.06198837608098984, -0.015534023754298687, -0.0430925190448761, -0.0729014202952385, -0.004438827279955149, 0.013805891387164593, -0.04799661040306091, -0.05601794272661209, -0.004227000754326582, 0.028384344652295113, 0.02539896033704281, 0.07230738550424576, 0.02299126796424389, -0.006723661441355944, 0.033172961324453354, -0.06868497282266617, 0.06690841913223267, 0.017456091940402985, 0.004426670726388693, 0.02836897037923336, -0.044873278588056564, 0.029723068699240685, -0.021899130195379257, -0.001281755161471665, -0.007864049635827541, 0.03420267999172211, -0.011040553450584412, 0.04809388890862465, -0.03054708056151867, 0.061524294316768646, -0.037678077816963196, 0.006078159436583519, -0.03975487872958183, -0.015176823362708092, -0.03147037699818611, -0.034280575811862946, 0.0030617844313383102, 0.027797048911452293, 0.022544745355844498, 0.022117596119642258, 0.0006125691579654813, -0.05256902053952217, 0.06011661887168884, 0.011400390416383743, 0.07738914340734482, -0.001237130956724286, -0.001994743011891842, -0.05028636381030083, -0.016474291682243347, -0.00837177224457264, -0.001344095217064023, 0.02035002037882805, 0.035862766206264496, -0.03256183862686157, 0.015881050378084183, -0.020511355251073837, 0.021996688097715378, 0.004667287226766348, -0.03507337346673012, -0.015004321001470089, 0.005364415235817432, -0.036392178386449814, 0.02996867336332798, -0.07568208873271942, -0.012339392676949501, -0.046614550054073334, -0.06102626770734787, 0.02038387767970562, -0.07931748032569885, 0.00823395885527134, -0.040743257850408554, -0.01748272031545639, -0.04923127964138985, 0.03091350942850113, -0.013887613080441952, 0.03621787577867508, -0.04633045196533203, 0.001640220289118588, -0.039979446679353714, 0.05209070071578026, -0.02539491467177868, -0.09539484232664108, -0.026164310052990913, -0.025978440418839455, -0.055612362921237946, -0.000012339904969849158, 0.03734324872493744, 0.0437626838684082, 0.028805358335375786, 0.05411149561405182, 0.025235606357455254, 0.00102549500297755, 0.06292928755283356, 0.013333108276128769, 0.04973017796874046, -0.006965624634176493, 0.05848317965865135, -0.008786499500274658, 0.01392944622784853, -0.03755445033311844, -0.003993765451014042, 0.04329865798354149, -0.022853130474686623, 0.007487672381103039, -0.03860700502991676, 0.002222997136414051, -0.015567048452794552, -0.017034966498613358, -0.005851252004504204, -0.04784620553255081, 0.03376511111855507, -0.01128891110420227, -0.01457065250724554, 0.012536471709609032, 0.02329438365995884, -0.004214052110910416, -0.006825124844908714, -0.003976196050643921, 0.016386009752750397, 0.002113612135872245, 0.042013611644506454, -0.039809808135032654, 0.05665438994765282, 0.01023583672940731, 0.030575349926948547, -0.015925515443086624, -0.02699483372271061, 0.03782137483358383, -0.033837638795375824, -0.08506805449724197, 0.031140169128775597, -0.046460337936878204, -0.03200383111834526, -0.0020416802726686, -0.012421706691384315, -0.0020872813183814287, 0.01189789455384016, 0.009779717773199081, -0.019926952198147774, 0.03903011232614517, -0.009982374496757984, -0.03725418075919151, -0.02315549924969673, 0.00013367469364311546, -0.015415993519127369, 0.023927824571728706, -0.003532575909048319, 0.009050484746694565, -0.0378897562623024, 0.03247138485312462, -0.005827530287206173, 0.002200441900640726, -0.022113878279924393, -0.006173295900225639, -0.017865946516394615, 0.009171316400170326, 0.04572441801428795, 0.07007244974374771, -0.0119182663038373, -0.01965750940144062, -0.028225824236869812, 0.019791871309280396, 0.03927440941333771, 0.019069170579314232, -0.01422856841236353, -0.018784373998641968, -0.004289406817406416, -0.06507529318332672, -0.022342709824442863, 0.03345018997788429, 0.05783866345882416, 0.029096083715558052, -0.09054180979728699, 0.0029793893918395042, -0.0231340155005455, 0.0166060458868742, -0.03404651954770088 ]
<p>I'm writing my first MD simulation (ever) for liquid Argon. The code is up and running. I am supposed to do the calculations in the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microcanonical_ensemble" rel="nofollow">NVE ensemble</a>. Having implemented a 4th order <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symplectic_integrator" rel="nofollow">symplectic integrator</a> (forest-ruth) the total energy of my system (approx 1000 atoms) oscillates (as expected).</p> <p>Now I am "measuring" the heat capacity of my system, which I do by calculating the mean total energy and it's fluctuations for several distinct simulations (using the same parameters).</p> <p>This is exactly the point that I don't get (conceptually). By definition, the total energy of a system is fixed in the microcanonical ensemble. Am I in the microcanonical or in the canonical ensemble when I do an MD simulation? The literature (I have) is somewhat sloppy when it comes to this.</p>
g1623
[ -0.008745549246668816, -0.04322022199630737, 0.010724165476858616, -0.04853165149688721, -0.0272190123796463, -0.028153184801340103, 0.006382687948644161, 0.06232042983174324, -0.065691277384758, 0.016748249530792236, 0.024728860706090927, 0.032439474016427994, -0.013753318227827549, 0.04873459041118622, -0.023478642106056213, 0.033508241176605225, -0.014094246551394463, 0.06198754534125328, -0.02620674856007099, 0.04978126659989357, -0.08329864591360092, -0.020339829847216606, -0.03163834661245346, -0.03258707746863365, 0.07518325746059418, -0.00706642447039485, 0.031691018491983414, 0.018910543993115425, -0.05676278844475746, 0.03230762109160423, 0.042254459112882614, 0.029873212799429893, 0.04966996982693672, 0.003110347082838416, -0.027466049417853355, 0.06865142285823822, 0.06281008571386337, -0.016991673037409782, 0.033247701823711395, -0.07279852777719498, -0.004379592835903168, -0.004556039348244667, 0.00822348054498434, 0.009987480007112026, 0.00629050238057971, 0.06110415607690811, 0.006822771392762661, -0.029159631580114365, -0.082711361348629, 0.0590670183300972, 0.08836229145526886, 0.06473352015018463, 0.019756807014346123, -0.0014907773584127426, -0.01730387657880783, 0.04982076212763786, -0.02986627258360386, 0.015779798850417137, -0.01287768129259348, 0.11037326604127884, 0.055689167231321335, -0.038156069815158844, -0.020197629928588867, 0.013156788423657417, 0.039155423641204834, -0.024076249450445175, -0.027492044493556023, -0.008071986958384514, -0.016801901161670685, -0.034875862300395966, -0.010842522606253624, -0.08519306033849716, -0.016710083931684494, -0.005921195261180401, -0.02379598096013069, -0.06127536669373512, 0.0032594166696071625, 0.009464501403272152, -0.01644544117152691, -0.0505228154361248, -0.03692508116364479, -0.013872041366994381, 0.0434650182723999, -0.00042152078822255135, 0.023242121562361717, -0.03808628395199776, -0.056573670357465744, -0.040826961398124695, -0.03388146683573723, 0.06930974870920181, 0.017450155690312386, 0.04596386104822159, 0.06567499786615372, 0.016683802008628845, 0.0310064684599638, -0.02526925690472126, -0.056989625096321106, 0.06128179281949997, -0.013909146189689636, 0.014853171072900295, -0.048317957669496536, 0.012171823531389236, -0.00039054660010151565, -0.003337252652272582, -0.021297896280884743, -0.01636800542473793, -0.018273726105690002, 0.018240829929709435, -0.042718712240457535, -0.026627235114574432, -0.03874877467751503, 0.028218712657690048, -0.04424522817134857, 0.008344766683876514, -0.09623213857412338, -0.026248503476381302, 0.034757357090711594, 0.00592337129637599, -0.013816163875162601, 0.01991434395313263, 0.0071111139841377735, 0.02660544030368328, 0.0226617231965065, 0.06489887833595276, -0.02340077795088291, 0.03460722789168358, -0.02007215842604637, 0.051066942512989044, 0.011995027773082256, -0.02366580441594124, 0.03004474751651287, -0.035328686237335205, -0.055777549743652344, -0.0172431617975235, 0.09146927297115326, -0.020072223618626595, -0.029250239953398705, -0.004999167751520872, -0.010699056088924408, 0.02228325419127941, -0.062097519636154175, -0.04299359768629074, -0.008265255019068718, -0.0274382084608078, 0.00341916736215353, -0.048548366874456406, -0.021540582180023193, -0.027872342616319656, 0.026832519099116325, 0.005980561021715403, 0.019853699952363968, 0.07710219919681549, 0.020785575732588768, -0.07345528155565262, 0.0024815767537802458, 0.05370591580867767, -0.011259252205491066, -0.03821645677089691, -0.013164482079446316, -0.0018456954276189208, -0.0017421215306967497, 0.011585427448153496, 0.05776716768741608, -0.005571071989834309, -0.03827894479036331, 0.05119236186146736, 0.08504907041788101, -0.048544224351644516, -0.0353861004114151, -0.031234536319971085, 0.009128628298640251, -0.016677066683769226, -0.04643256962299347, 0.01708095148205757, 0.00877430010586977, 0.07118450850248337, 0.011218628846108913, -0.05728483945131302, 0.01040632650256157, -0.0004826521035283804, 0.04051543399691582, 0.036505963653326035, 0.032715991139411926, -0.09257086366415024, 0.01005085464566946, 0.022227274253964424, 0.007468613795936108, 0.005548040382564068, -0.03242240846157074, -0.03362104296684265, 0.03190598636865616, 0.04247339069843292, 0.004541854374110699, -0.03250417858362198, 0.0259711891412735, 0.021765731275081635, -0.020903460681438446, -0.044146303087472916, 0.00786050595343113, -0.021033888682723045, 0.02109811268746853, 0.014645221643149853, -0.025019001215696335, 0.05176444724202156, 0.024755695834755898, 0.035274166613817215, 0.009353088214993477, -0.023468680679798126, -0.04195549339056015, -0.006934850476682186, 0.05722712352871895, -0.005946557968854904, -0.0031575739849358797, 0.015370103530585766, -0.022760501131415367, 0.0072962394915521145, 0.00021711125737056136, -0.030970850959420204, -0.015631839632987976, 0.0005377110210247338, -0.041378602385520935, 0.0009516277932561934, 0.0050073959864676, 0.013669376261532307, -0.023145798593759537, 0.035131629556417465, -0.03912541642785072, 0.03634026646614075, 0.0006839054985903203, -0.010921272449195385, -0.03771211951971054, 0.04097267612814903, -0.03935997933149338, -0.02109694480895996, 0.00991011131554842, 0.04435756057500839, -0.012475746683776379, 0.0053973752073943615, 0.032270900905132294, 0.03412468358874321, 0.05729704722762108, -0.0004051647847518325, -0.022970912978053093, -0.0021108556538820267, 0.03553396090865135, -0.004704332910478115, 0.0052435146644711494, 0.013009864836931229, -0.0015458476264029741, 0.009092744439840317, -0.005018904339522123, -0.010960010811686516, -0.03534523770213127, -0.018801333382725716, 0.004209510982036591, -0.03724245727062225, -0.0707123801112175, -0.028474487364292145, -0.02634643018245697, 0.03379220888018608, 0.023634646087884903, -0.0005618961877189577, -0.05168953910470009, -0.030069684609770775, -0.07481327652931213, -0.010967126116156578, -0.01222043763846159, -0.051508065313100815, -0.037455830723047256, -0.006789590697735548, -0.028991742059588432, 0.020085949450731277, 0.022146815434098244, 0.00664274487644434, 0.016548631712794304, -0.010980945080518723, 0.03391795977950096, -0.011686049401760101, 0.020557234063744545, -0.04230226203799248, -0.08391350507736206, -0.006495913956314325, 0.007452213671058416, 0.0033727462869137526, 0.07262757420539856, -0.02171199955046177, 0.0021130109671503305, -0.035497765988111496, 0.03435108810663223, -0.0006164985825307667, 0.0183569248765707, 0.023940371349453926, -0.02345847338438034, 0.036088645458221436, -0.06129622459411621, -0.013298379257321358, 0.018603870645165443, 0.01763298362493515, 0.054957322776317596, 0.09776122868061066, -0.024549249559640884, 0.010735510848462582, 0.039350513368844986, 0.015282578766345978, 0.002915558172389865, 0.034809891134500504, -0.048284415155649185, 0.0003814691153820604, 0.033412523567676544, -0.019850241020321846, -0.026581838726997375, -0.02390732616186142, -0.06862867623567581, -0.017212342470884323, -0.00912835355848074, 0.04687586426734924, -0.001992934849113226, -0.041244372725486755, 0.012069634161889553, -0.07369726151227951, -0.017734134569764137, -0.0403306819498539, 0.03874003514647484, -0.02094145305454731, -0.0032527181319892406, 0.024648765102028847, -0.02068064920604229, -0.08351883292198181, -0.009879841469228268, 0.040366705507040024, 0.023185959085822105, 0.03653516620397568, 0.01236477680504322, 0.047707799822092056, -0.013206933625042439, -0.050764963030815125, -0.09132473170757294, -0.03757515549659729, -0.0287330225110054, 0.026378897950053215, -0.03624234348535538, -0.013724234886467457, -0.002207905985414982, 0.008247381076216698, -0.011602147482335567, -0.02370741404592991, -0.04795725271105766, 0.019471168518066406, -0.03776732459664345, -0.010168347507715225, 0.013044501654803753, -0.009150735102593899, 0.02637854404747486, -0.005466253962367773, -0.012023655697703362, -0.01666995882987976, -0.04383908584713936, -0.04574352875351906, -0.0439186617732048, 0.07074815034866333, -0.04315442219376564, -0.03275832533836365, -0.022751756012439728, 0.014705290086567402, -0.011815453879535198, 0.034498732537031174, -0.06080390885472298, 0.04167652502655983, 0.01941715180873871, -0.03452374041080475, -0.022988781332969666, -0.0018306599231436849, -0.04367147013545036, -0.03730352222919464, 0.03911391273140907, 0.005286301951855421, 0.05074620991945267, 0.0036150177475064993, -0.01773449219763279, 0.02062423899769783, 0.022428957745432854, -0.04187282547354698, 0.022914383560419083, 0.019115973263978958, -0.03364761546254158, 0.03746417909860611, -0.012940757907927036, 0.025466684252023697, -0.04849575087428093, -0.047696445137262344, -0.010346167720854282, -0.015607606619596481, -0.061615731567144394, 0.024808520451188087, 0.03571813553571701, 0.031763628125190735, 0.02874911203980446, -0.011968509294092655, 0.02721431665122509, 0.018566424027085304, 0.027160517871379852, -0.020114853978157043, -0.005569794215261936, -0.04403951019048691, 0.055779699236154556, 0.047198519110679626, 0.01991887390613556, 0.01272832415997982, -0.03130705654621124, 0.008123903535306454, 0.018402479588985443, 0.03109295293688774, 0.019009331241250038, -0.06394636631011963, -0.025545092299580574, -0.021426450461149216, 0.025197500362992287, -0.044721443206071854, -0.04922976344823837, 0.034767311066389084, -0.03293399140238762, -0.04186006635427475, -0.003266383660957217, -0.0023365651722997427, 0.017114758491516113, 0.05737302452325821, 0.060082681477069855, -0.01526192482560873, -0.04430195316672325, -0.026814935728907585, 0.011488269083201885, 0.04612882062792778, 0.0048615834675729275, 0.06311563402414322, -0.046685840934515, -0.007292498834431171, -0.04470390826463699, -0.024382850155234337, 0.047652553766965866, 0.06229117512702942, -0.0029977550730109215, 0.05508839711546898, 0.007638703100383282, -0.0022971241269260645, 0.0017908019945025444, 0.062350768595933914, -0.011417325586080551, -0.020223500207066536, -0.050236452370882034, 0.0032877097837626934, -0.005782340187579393, 0.013351223431527615, -0.013637583702802658, 0.029053254052996635, 0.07804884016513824, 0.006582406349480152, -0.0470593236386776, -0.026688411831855774, -0.006728811655193567, 0.028391048312187195, -0.004782217089086771, 0.012024607509374619, -0.06870472431182861, -0.01729988120496273, 0.0023097023367881775, -0.014984714798629284, -0.017034338787198067, 0.018016567453742027, -0.06904106587171555, 0.02392863854765892, 0.11846882104873657, -0.05544348433613777, -0.031914301216602325, -0.007850251160562038, 0.03062541037797928, -0.00014703578199259937, 0.01874074898660183, 0.022556232288479805, 0.08193014562129974, 0.02595343068242073, -0.027656441554427147, 0.04647925868630409, -0.03596360981464386, 0.05360480770468712, 0.05228375643491745, 0.06302745640277863, -0.03349902480840683, -0.05376344919204712, 0.047911614179611206, 0.016087891533970833, 0.04227561503648758, 0.050129156559705734, -0.0026400452479720116, -0.04514535889029503, 0.05535277724266052, 0.023882213979959488, 0.020908884704113007, 0.007471637800335884, -0.01164782140403986, -0.05071825906634331, -0.026618361473083496, 0.0005885203718207777, 0.034751929342746735, -0.0069288271479308605, -0.01695704273879528, 0.08628182858228683, 0.03152645751833916, 0.024918556213378906, 0.03001912124454975, 0.058360278606414795, -0.00941543560475111, 0.0086338697001338, 0.015708427876234055, 0.08606518059968948, -0.014916309155523777, -0.014964885078370571, 0.0073930127546191216, 0.004465383477509022, -0.051854509860277176, -0.0369841568171978, 0.012781879864633083, -0.0026082133408635855, 0.03201261907815933, -0.012954761274158955, -0.01874461956322193, 0.028921950608491898, 0.02209015004336834, -0.03463813662528992, 0.002603342989459634, 0.06925257295370102, -0.03588360548019409, -0.0035449001006782055, -0.048946917057037354, 0.0031765953171998262, -0.020309999585151672, -0.04326567426323891, -0.0735018402338028, -0.00799138005822897, 0.05134781822562218, 0.0708446279168129, -0.00513451686128974, -0.032296545803546906, -0.013052440248429775, -0.007369189988821745, -0.00844226498156786, 0.026308352127671242, -0.01541244424879551, 0.033872753381729126, 0.025560995563864708, -0.028776615858078003, -0.0019342383602634072, -0.034970786422491074, 0.012118521146476269, -0.04859386011958122, 0.038431182503700256, 0.03711291030049324, -0.04753755405545235, 0.006791359279304743, -0.04203415662050247, 0.02533106692135334, -0.00377746787853539, -0.01340592559427023, -0.0031814780086278915, -0.051129452884197235, 0.026734666898846626, -0.049716390669345856, 0.004218705464154482, -0.02448047697544098, -0.04492243751883507, -0.016480593010783195, 0.05304022505879402, -0.03570690378546715, 0.06627804785966873, -0.011917936615645885, 0.05755462497472763, 0.0047818878665566444, -0.032902635633945465, -0.0192518699914217, -0.013482405804097652, -0.015681179240345955, -0.031003540381789207, -0.008858419954776764, 0.002908982103690505, 0.06329946964979172, 0.06055217981338501, -0.023812267929315567, -0.04042573645710945, -0.03250262886285782, -0.05811580270528793, 0.0008244632044807076, 0.012661782093346119, -0.007043292745947838, -0.02416883036494255, 0.06886289268732071, -0.00029075751081109047, -0.0002567014016676694, -0.00635059317573905, 0.004993798211216927, -0.02405707538127899, 0.018527435138821602, 0.014446903951466084, -0.052116405218839645, 0.022718409076333046, -0.12007403373718262, -0.021983254700899124, -0.005715783219784498, -0.08078157156705856, 0.07930135726928711, -0.029620738700032234, 0.053208477795124054, -0.024994179606437683, 0.01281523797661066, 0.07075335085391998, -0.03336024284362793, 0.00025485039805062115, -0.019478753209114075, -0.018110744655132294, 0.009367445483803749, 0.03316640481352806, 0.043092187494039536, -0.02423911727964878, -0.008169540204107761, 0.028277169913053513, -0.024099061265587807, 0.055998723953962326, 0.025088725611567497, -0.06946171820163727, -0.01192463282495737, 0.04098134487867355, -0.01646254025399685, -0.006578751839697361, -0.009946035221219063, 0.025781327858567238, 0.04130874574184418, 0.015695203095674515, 0.0176443699747324, -0.05832088738679886, -0.07135443389415741, 0.047626618295907974, 0.020747361704707146, -0.022175680845975876, 0.07149046659469604, 0.00009832795331021771, 0.007658033631742001, 0.0240364670753479, -0.008548504672944546, 0.06907115876674652, 0.0017560088308528066, -0.04067373648285866, -0.024894656613469124, 0.05251148343086243, -0.043400514870882034, 0.000887456291820854, 0.026781762018799782, -0.03997756913304329, 0.03221587464213371, -0.045901618897914886, 0.02169695869088173, 0.053239598870277405, -0.00020165537716820836, -0.03261638060212135, -0.0035075934138149023, -0.02526887319982052, 0.01801210083067417, 0.05507076904177666, 0.015683148056268692, 0.014921218156814575, -0.04772372916340828, 0.02618163451552391, -0.0033704033121466637, 0.02838626690208912, 0.003148556686937809, -0.036861903965473175, 0.03424921631813049, 0.009218458086252213, -0.0209706611931324, 0.014339104294776917, 0.045199573040008545, 0.04432391747832298, 0.00947794783860445, 0.027195429429411888, -0.01411733590066433, 0.01155773364007473, 0.01791943795979023, -0.003263154299929738, -0.044932082295417786, -0.0440872497856617, -0.01323934830725193, -0.030327599495649338, -0.014267412945628166, 0.016295138746500015, 0.009476792998611927, -0.001968573546037078, 0.07893815636634827, -0.03095286712050438, 0.03690418601036072, 0.04687598720192909, 0.03962527588009834, 0.041919492185115814, -0.019536783918738365, 0.004919121973216534, -0.033845651894807816, 0.008822493255138397, 0.030477400869131088, 0.034074366092681885, 0.0053205653093755245, 0.022190727293491364, 0.013169403187930584, 0.0002984548918902874, -0.0737292543053627, -0.031173119321465492, 0.015440523624420166, -0.03768856078386307, -0.026951340958476067, 0.05741611123085022, -0.003030400024726987, -0.05668118596076965, -0.04885244369506836, -0.008203879930078983, -0.0050875660963356495, -0.03879598528146744, 0.032498549669981, 0.0015383028658106923, -0.002079552970826626, 0.035556547343730927, -0.11369389295578003, -0.01494219247251749, 0.029269486665725708, 0.03142808377742767, 0.014835385605692863, -0.04447547718882561, -0.027073059231042862, -0.001363661140203476, -0.005526884458959103, 0.017925256863236427, -0.01051327120512724, 0.03257088363170624, 0.04553648829460144, 0.046205785125494, -0.031557995826005936, -0.048405710607767105, -0.03665889799594879, 0.07902828603982925, -0.02183523401618004, 0.028252696618437767, -0.030774174258112907, -0.045849334448575974, -0.020549101755023003, 0.0435352623462677, 0.016623005270957947, -0.021332427859306335, -0.014229235239326954, 0.024984091520309448, -0.0028413743712008, 0.03786681592464447, -0.005059701390564442, 0.054412197321653366, 0.019944876432418823, 0.02328125201165676, 0.05734233558177948, 0.010274158790707588, -0.0424063503742218, -0.007945873774588108, -0.023640194907784462, -0.01123296469449997, 0.02514849789440632, 0.016967229545116425, 0.013855857774615288 ]
<p>I have the following problem to solve:</p> <blockquote> <p>A particle of mass $m$ and charge $e$ moves in the laboratory in crossed, static, uniform, electric and magnetic fields. $\mathbf{E}$ is parallel to the $x$-axis; $\mathbf{B}$ is parallel to the $y$-axis. Find the EOM for $|\mathbf{E}|&lt;|\mathbf{B}|$ and $|\mathbf{B}|&lt;|\mathbf{E}|$.</p> </blockquote> <p>I was planning on using the following: $$\vec{E}&#39;=\gamma(\vec{E}+\vec{\beta}\times\vec{B})-\frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma +1}\vec{\beta}(\vec{\beta}\cdot \vec{E})$$ $$\vec{B}&#39;=\gamma(\vec{B}-\vec{\beta}\times\vec{E})-\frac{\gamma^2}{\gamma +1}\vec{\beta}(\vec{\beta}\cdot \vec{B})$$ along with $$t&#39;=\gamma (t-\vec{\beta}\cdot\vec{x})$$ $$ \vec{x}&#39;=\vec{x}+\frac{(\gamma -1)}{\beta^2}(\vec{\beta}\cdot \vec{x})\vec{\beta}-\gamma \vec{\beta}t$$ with the addition constraints $$\frac{d\vec{p}}{dt}=e\left[ \vec{E}+\frac{\vec{u}}{c}\times \vec{B}\right]$$ and $$\frac{dU}{dt}=e\vec{u}\cdot \vec{E}$$ To solve this I am going to switch to a frame with $$\vec{\beta}=\frac{E}{B}\hat{z}$$for the first case. With this case $dU/dt=0$ and i can solve the equations of motion to find $\vec{x}(t)$ directly, and then boost back to get the trajectories in the original frame. However for the the second case I was wondering if my procedure is correct. I am going to switch to a frame with $\vec{\beta}=(B/E) \hat{z}$ to remove the magnetic field. Now here it seems that $\vec{u}_0$ is perdepdicular to $\vec{E}$ to start in the new frame, but that it will be accelerated in the $x$ direction and hence $dU/dt\neq 0$ and I can't just straightforwardly solve the EOMs. How would I proceed from here?</p> <p>Thanks,</p>
g1624
[ 0.062370557337999344, 0.053020939230918884, -0.008695315569639206, -0.05984770134091377, 0.09732551127672195, 0.0005288600223138928, 0.12086080014705658, -0.008697504177689552, -0.003886123653501272, 0.06752350181341171, -0.008207560516893864, 0.06810864806175232, -0.017423195764422417, -0.02561340667307377, -0.027881259098649025, 0.010167067870497704, 0.07666373252868652, 0.018012862652540207, -0.049393147230148315, 0.011980541981756687, 0.019507933408021927, 0.08149415254592896, 0.04327799379825592, -0.041037850081920624, 0.028186334297060966, 0.0045237368904054165, -0.024613061919808388, -0.02020087279379368, -0.019525831565260887, 0.018994327634572983, 0.0317976251244545, 0.005998601671308279, 0.03768486902117729, -0.0020495245698839426, 0.024817723780870438, -0.010896218940615654, 0.004749830346554518, 0.03283796086907387, 0.024636512622237206, 0.010867508128285408, 0.03365957364439964, -0.042726561427116394, 0.044717125594615936, -0.0021910860668867826, 0.022520242258906364, 0.00704914191737771, -0.023254426196217537, 0.04179084300994873, -0.0028577407356351614, 0.010915239341557026, -0.03648972511291504, 0.04898139834403992, 0.0012578974710777402, -0.023356543853878975, -0.015481124632060528, 0.0013314890675246716, 0.003532141214236617, -0.024755364283919334, 0.03936471417546272, 0.040750253945589066, 0.03211008012294769, -0.03840010613203049, 0.015839608386158943, -0.08325041830539703, -0.001114641665481031, -0.02459576725959778, -0.03880619630217552, 0.03893665596842766, -0.06415384262800217, 0.00011954830551985651, -0.007121451664716005, -0.05118928477168083, 0.031010273844003677, -0.004805294331163168, -0.01039175596088171, -0.026078851893544197, 0.012749806977808475, -0.0464472770690918, 0.013854664750397205, -0.007560472935438156, -0.030283289030194283, 0.013040698133409023, 0.035684604197740555, 0.0195454154163599, 0.031093914061784744, -0.024418508633971214, 0.0000973776332102716, 0.06883016228675842, -0.045520104467868805, -0.08796337246894836, -0.014036782085895538, -0.050460755825042725, 0.05492348223924637, -0.003704940900206566, 0.025275738909840584, 0.0049613346345722675, -0.040679145604372025, 0.026838738471269608, 0.03474043682217598, -0.022229790687561035, -0.008020328357815742, -0.013127571903169155, -0.03859112784266472, 0.04157033562660217, -0.009230460040271282, -0.032551996409893036, 0.045968491584062576, 0.03154055029153824, -0.03361279517412186, -0.027756141498684883, -0.060848742723464966, 0.011642176657915115, -0.03959612920880318, -0.04839680716395378, -0.048820141702890396, -0.03411068394780159, 0.03022441640496254, 0.00849804189056158, -0.028523117303848267, 0.022756393998861313, -0.053342316299676895, 0.00945732370018959, -0.01536023709923029, 0.052093755453825, -0.014326834119856358, -0.030799446627497673, -0.014148239977657795, 0.028893891721963882, -0.01182433683425188, -0.03008493408560753, -0.004712989088147879, 0.021655572578310966, 0.04034959524869919, 0.038594119250774384, -0.05080375447869301, -0.00772947957739234, 0.02266622893512249, 0.04248284548521042, 0.02725481428205967, -0.0046646916307508945, -0.007755978498607874, -0.03844160586595535, 0.03968142345547676, -0.02662259340286255, -0.0724257156252861, 0.021599136292934418, 0.015483004972338676, -0.029501669108867645, 0.04887125641107559, 0.026966439560055733, -0.019007474184036255, 0.0634612962603569, -0.031125284731388092, 0.06625741720199585, 0.034662988036870956, -0.04093644767999649, 0.04673238843679428, -0.006060866639018059, -0.0034988252446055412, -0.04379916191101074, -0.0011565026361495256, 0.02626967802643776, -0.0454840362071991, -0.00673490297049284, -0.0269460529088974, -0.025151913985610008, 0.05081351846456528, 0.0068037728779017925, 0.004647714085876942, -0.04043659567832947, -0.05878870189189911, -0.03322751820087433, 0.08748533576726913, 0.03330526873469353, -0.015196013264358044, 0.06959057599306107, -0.04493335261940956, -0.07461840659379959, 0.00044207953033037484, -0.022405173629522324, 0.011195186525583267, -0.01200609840452671, 0.017047418281435966, 0.01882767863571644, -0.018760528415441513, -0.03468858078122139, -0.09779976308345795, 0.0029835207387804985, -0.06677954643964767, -0.03209473192691803, 0.011133871041238308, 0.0325540155172348, -0.006920278538018465, 0.020393580198287964, -0.022869132459163666, -0.0010537449270486832, 0.01863132044672966, -0.02269720658659935, 0.007282060105353594, 0.018447641283273697, -0.059454161673784256, 0.05269220843911171, 0.07287817448377609, 0.006486797705292702, 0.03447995334863663, -0.036833133548498154, -0.001402726280502975, -0.07384204864501953, 0.05788770690560341, -0.013018405064940453, -0.03631316125392914, 0.013569517061114311, -0.05916190519928932, 0.011289997957646847, -0.01780387945473194, -0.07734481990337372, 0.022184371948242188, -0.0264314915984869, -0.03854462876915932, 0.056603893637657166, -0.0738806203007698, -0.05700203403830528, 0.04058657959103584, -0.07586503028869629, 0.04146229475736618, -0.052230969071388245, 0.0028983226511627436, 0.02970515377819538, -0.03642087057232857, 0.024164529517292976, -0.03858380764722824, 0.017464522272348404, -0.0005178450956009328, -0.0816047340631485, 0.03512969985604286, -0.024354342371225357, -0.06818535178899765, 0.007188429124653339, 0.009837526828050613, 0.017554443329572678, 0.02245817519724369, 0.06234698370099068, -0.007291119080036879, -0.039324767887592316, 0.026763303205370903, -0.05671418458223343, 0.06844663619995117, 0.029317766427993774, 0.024120578542351723, -0.008818140253424644, 0.05680559203028679, -0.01897253841161728, -0.04274846985936165, 0.03752497211098671, 0.0022311219945549965, -0.026791099458932877, -0.04873606190085411, 0.008908218704164028, -0.047249555587768555, 0.0013267184840515256, -0.0384252592921257, -0.0145792867988348, -0.019130002707242966, 0.08510842174291611, -0.007076913490891457, 0.017454540356993675, -0.07602345198392868, 0.007585425861179829, 0.013452029787003994, -0.02456476539373398, -0.029232924804091454, 0.031076055020093918, -0.005884530022740364, -0.003395181382074952, -0.027057116851210594, -0.03099631331861019, 0.04096950218081474, -0.0005626820493489504, 0.014182587154209614, -0.00013707365724258125, -0.019084623083472252, -0.04118134081363678, 0.007097192574292421, 0.0017304697539657354, 0.028422558680176735, -0.016273127868771553, 0.026526862755417824, -0.010141775943338871, -0.02004026435315609, 0.017717022448778152, -0.04474594444036484, 0.04466765746474266, 0.07222755998373032, 0.00988035835325718, 0.03253812715411186, 0.02994716167449951, 0.006981748156249523, -0.0194991584867239, -0.017441054806113243, 0.014924376271665096, -0.02685192972421646, 0.02475333958864212, -0.004266857169568539, 0.03573574498295784, 0.021968137472867966, -0.059962254017591476, -0.10111132264137268, -0.03318231180310249, -0.022862542420625687, 0.03706485778093338, -0.021817056462168694, -0.03481871262192726, 0.029758049175143242, -0.01986950822174549, -0.0007961281226016581, -0.022562282159924507, -0.0009545668726786971, -0.017713181674480438, 0.024848531931638718, 0.04559044539928436, -0.000419587449869141, 0.014105703681707382, 0.04640531539916992, -0.03250156342983246, 0.010947145521640778, 0.06096625328063965, 0.020299799740314484, 0.014626593329012394, -0.06489069759845734, 0.010543656535446644, 0.02975958026945591, 0.036556389182806015, 0.06066514924168587, -0.01499014999717474, 0.011117427609860897, 0.0014167826157063246, -0.006638290360569954, 0.03696958348155022, -0.013895455747842789, -0.03333194553852081, 0.0023432474117726088, -0.02956956811249256, -0.03729061037302017, -0.06144414097070694, -0.024129390716552734, -0.03270148113369942, 0.017324432730674744, 0.0005681036855094135, 0.022784514352679253, -0.03489129617810249, 0.011095832102000713, -0.01709328405559063, 0.019787060096859932, 0.044684670865535736, -0.026924338191747665, -0.0233792532235384, 0.076235830783844, 0.03060051053762436, 0.0032916772179305553, -0.03212267905473709, 0.010330173186957836, 0.0009892593370750546, -0.0295358058065176, -0.010308037512004375, -0.023298505693674088, -0.023423438891768456, -0.013741493225097656, 0.019069146364927292, 0.012334995903074741, -0.056071408092975616, -0.0025531193241477013, 0.01452227495610714, -0.0077012632973492146, 0.012100967578589916, -0.031722839921712875, -0.05293327942490578, -0.009005948901176453, -0.010601027868688107, -0.02725798264145851, 0.015504937618970871, 0.02210824377834797, 0.03422095999121666, -0.04764533415436745, 0.006608190480619669, 0.04267990216612816, -0.0036005910951644182, 0.02823496423661709, 0.05287523195147514, 0.02004399523139, 0.05899245664477348, 0.011120837181806564, 0.030540576204657555, -0.039845921099185944, 0.009684436023235321, -0.0022475006990134716, -0.05926192179322243, 0.021866101771593094, -0.020876547321677208, -0.013783412985503674, -0.019991736859083176, -0.0020258198492228985, 0.033442046493291855, -0.007610065396875143, -0.034480564296245575, -0.056282080709934235, -0.04087189957499504, 0.012029050849378109, 0.02346229925751686, 0.04881470650434494, -0.021698646247386932, -0.019542455673217773, 0.020668553188443184, -0.040112316608428955, -0.04209977388381958, 0.0125652514398098, -0.0012976819416508079, -0.0021098307333886623, 0.06148996949195862, 0.011147236451506615, -0.054878219962120056, 0.02632015198469162, 0.05354198068380356, 0.018992038443684578, -0.07053833454847336, -0.03522658348083496, 0.07691434770822525, 0.052938614040613174, 0.024596670642495155, -0.042614445090293884, -0.011437034234404564, -0.06040848419070244, 0.043256521224975586, -0.05512826517224312, 0.024202654138207436, -0.017201410606503487, 0.07473982125520706, -0.026069190353155136, -0.012111451476812363, 0.04991205036640167, 0.043019331991672516, 0.06771761924028397, -0.03480186313390732, -0.0010580102680251002, -0.04204742982983589, -0.06195481866598129, 0.06592582166194916, -0.047689881175756454, -0.08533087372779846, 0.0015723073156550527, -0.028441186994314194, 0.03452184051275253, 0.023930279538035393, 0.008290458470582962, 0.030367370694875717, 0.01326660718768835, -0.018004881218075752, -0.040234796702861786, 0.022289548069238663, 0.02525840885937214, 0.021610889583826065, -0.04654365032911301, 0.004904907662421465, 0.001270498731173575, -0.0017481993418186903, 0.01851234771311283, 0.026735587045550346, -0.006813360843807459, -0.036786820739507675, -0.02199765108525753, 0.013173781335353851, 0.019965913146734238, 0.0429818257689476, 0.018639298155903816, -0.006426320876926184, -0.0044322931207716465, 0.026929542422294617, 0.004451056011021137, 0.04187764972448349, 0.01431727409362793, -0.034937452524900436, -0.026157503947615623, -0.03297322243452072, 0.004663919098675251, 0.024865055456757545, 0.019108140841126442, -0.012904316186904907, -0.0319741852581501, 0.04404754936695099, 0.045875195413827896, -0.0303786713629961, 0.020257648080587387, 0.02918858267366886, -0.012247027829289436, -0.05564982816576958, 0.020955068990588188, 0.005343964323401451, -0.011675005778670311, -0.004755319096148014, -0.03458590433001518, 0.015298561193048954, -0.013839149847626686, -0.0025102877989411354, -0.063644178211689, -0.012877903878688812, -0.007470840122550726, 0.037135396152734756, 0.06281173229217529, 0.0026523685082793236, 0.015289919450879097, 0.012011762708425522, -0.013534745201468468, -0.005211337003856897, 0.027746643871068954, -0.029228653758764267, -0.02660463936626911, 0.020276248455047607, -0.015793099999427795, -0.03402940556406975, 0.01963542029261589, -0.09023226052522659, 0.06965363770723343, 0.0028075703885406256, -0.0029856585897505283, -0.010633335448801517, 0.03407369554042816, -0.01873643510043621, -0.042701803147792816, 0.031913820654153824, -0.003244478954002261, 0.07136593014001846, -0.01027047261595726, -0.05918432027101517, -0.03161225840449333, 0.017366331070661545, -0.034196268767118454, -0.06684040278196335, 0.009019964374601841, -0.04803112894296646, 0.00245959241874516, -0.001534240785986185, -0.005935357417911291, -0.0756164938211441, 0.05988143011927605, -0.003929096274077892, -0.04900457337498665, -0.00565884355455637, 0.02212865650653839, -0.0019884221255779266, 0.035949256271123886, -0.041137319058179855, -0.004076697863638401, 0.016769852489233017, 0.006545268464833498, -0.022648414596915245, -0.03536857292056084, 0.028379125520586967, 0.020721547305583954, -0.023964475840330124, -0.0380113422870636, 0.0026985604781657457, 0.02017025463283062, -0.03341282531619072, 0.057565197348594666, 0.0452389121055603, 0.0035378271713852882, -0.01628189906477928, -0.02549300715327263, 0.0004575438506435603, 0.013571948744356632, 0.004678666125983, 0.010569412261247635, -0.03538290411233902, -0.018863502889871597, 0.04793976992368698, 0.024194367229938507, 0.04361101612448692, -0.040356364101171494, 0.026496518403291702, -0.04486348479986191, 0.02211572416126728, -0.02595883421599865, 0.07169526070356369, -0.020509591326117516, -0.03842793405056, -0.006712398491799831, 0.004414220806211233, -0.04334569722414017, -0.04647522792220116, 0.024853767827153206, -0.021668173372745514, -0.03983847424387932, -0.0641898587346077, 0.007318486925214529, -0.005579629447311163, -0.08128595352172852, 0.014567956328392029, -0.018124382942914963, -0.02401328645646572, 0.023512693122029305, 0.10215498507022858, 0.04287056624889374, 0.011583353392779827, -0.01802063174545765, 0.012516428716480732, 0.05615238845348358, 0.003634689375758171, -0.044233180582523346, -0.023047231137752533, -0.053863782435655594, -0.017828550189733505, 0.04078856483101845, 0.010776047594845295, -0.018386710435152054, 0.05407249182462692, -0.026338469237089157, -0.018521131947636604, 0.009609680622816086, 0.03491222485899925, 0.019740674644708633, 0.027317870408296585, 0.02460966818034649, -0.029305556789040565, -0.03888348117470741, -0.021465931087732315, 0.03664521872997284, -0.020461430773139, -0.026124300435185432, -0.061941005289554596, 0.09202957898378372, -0.03335176035761833, 0.06648952513933182, -0.027062179520726204, -0.02722606435418129, 0.015084778890013695, -0.0004142786201555282, 0.0097836684435606, -0.002707257168367505, 0.014294043183326721, 0.011945988051593304, 0.03220510855317116, 0.035970982164144516, 0.05233646184206009, -0.009533402509987354, 0.0019176771165803075, -0.008477712981402874, 0.012785119004547596, 0.019705526530742645, -0.0016133233439177275, -0.06016208603978157, 0.030087726190686226, 0.013273500837385654, 0.010385111905634403, -0.029383566230535507, 0.024020787328481674, -0.06760083138942719, 0.010656948201358318, 0.05744395777583122, 0.01109946146607399, 0.04644016548991203, -0.00039756964542903006, -0.053354643285274506, -0.02732607163488865, -0.026414193212985992, -0.0030057404655963182, 0.027033187448978424, 0.004622471984475851, -0.017140734940767288, 0.01122321467846632, 0.04625725373625755, -0.022344937548041344, 0.01692459173500538, 0.004295581951737404, -0.055561523884534836, 0.07312081754207611, 0.049693044275045395, 0.004717219155281782, 0.008813316933810711, 0.05374904349446297, -0.023965248838067055, -0.03514062240719795, -0.0336218886077404, -0.002293893601745367, -0.04451070353388786, 0.017420759424567223, 0.015576867386698723, 0.05200960114598274, 0.010411946102976799, 0.019069578498601913, 0.005272814072668552, 0.05789830535650253, 0.030021006241440773, 0.06008245795965195, 0.06493940204381943, 0.00036480158451013267, -0.026710666716098785, 0.025454197078943253, -0.010048255324363708, -0.009303286671638489, 0.10922335088253021, 0.00699587119743228, -0.009751636534929276, 0.0015638308832421899, 0.01573558710515499, 0.002021769993007183, -0.05633062869310379, 0.016873307526111603, -0.040479544550180435, -0.046302471309900284, 0.030968639999628067, 0.010167221538722515, -0.05076293647289276, 0.036169324070215225, 0.005055718123912811, 0.0542711578309536, 0.02266881801187992, 0.019099334254860878, -0.016898946836590767, 0.05834702402353287, 0.03419741988182068, 0.03968517482280731, -0.0624987967312336, 0.027698606252670288, -0.06748449802398682, 0.03621411696076393, 0.04407397657632828, -0.04855016618967056, -0.052829355001449585, 0.006163350772112608, 0.040086861699819565, -0.045279644429683685, 0.01883501559495926, -0.09472118318080902, -0.029720760881900787, -0.0009540665778331459, -0.024814117699861526, -0.007881286554038525, 0.0028675480280071497, -0.09395404905080795, 0.031525254249572754, 0.006266207899898291, -0.03912559151649475, -0.07263543456792831, -0.07485860586166382, -0.0017886608839035034, -0.01782996393740177, 0.005971153732389212, 0.007776469457894564, 0.05555015802383423, 0.02942446619272232, 0.05201190337538719, 0.03877252712845802, -0.026754945516586304, -0.034567978233098984, 0.08284009248018265, 0.04562951251864433, -0.021902719512581825, 0.020850770175457, 0.005989099852740765, 0.04684149846434593, 0.018760036677122116, 0.01893768645823002, -0.022524267435073853, 0.00745932012796402, 0.017476217821240425, 0.0016268877079710364, -0.015397190116345882, 0.014325537718832493, 0.05747799947857857 ]
<p>Let the free electromagnetic current $J_\mu(x)$ be = $:\bar{\psi}(x)\gamma_\mu Q \psi(x):$ where $::$ is the normal ordering. </p> <ul> <li>In this expression why is $Q$ thought of as a "charge operator" instead of just a number?...its quite pesky to keep track of this operator while doing the current-current OPEs though I don't see anything changing conceptually if I just thought of it as a number...</li> </ul> <p>After a lot of (I found it very subtle!) calculations one can show that in the light-cone limit $x^2 \rightarrow 0$ the commutator, $[J_\mu(x),J_\nu (0)]$ has one of its terms (say X), </p> <p>$$X = \frac{iTr[Q^2]}{\pi^3}\{\frac{2}{3}g_{\mu \nu}\delta&#39;&#39;(x^2)\epsilon(x_0) + \frac{1}{6}\partial_\mu \partial_\nu [\delta&#39;(x^2)\epsilon(x_0)]\}$$</p> <p>Now one wants to compare the contribution of this term to two different situations, </p> <ul> <li>The total hadronic cross-section, </li> </ul> <p>$\sigma(e^+e^- \rightarrow hadrons) = \frac{8\pi^2\alpha^2}{3(q^2)^2}\int d^4x e^{iq.x}&lt;0|[J_\mu(x),J^\mu(0)]0&gt;$</p> <ul> <li>The inclusive hadronic tensor in deep inelastic lepton-nucleon scattering, </li> </ul> <p>$W_{\mu \nu}(p,q) = \frac{1}{M} \sum _{\sigma} \int \frac{d^4x}{2\pi} e^{iq.x}&lt;p,\sigma|[J_\mu(x), J_\nu(0)]|p,\sigma&gt;$</p> <p>In the derivation/argument for the expression for $W_{\mu \nu}$ it is kind of clear that the initial and final states have to be $|p,\sigma&gt;$ - the initial state of the proton. </p> <ul> <li><p>But I am unable to pin down as to exactly why the initial and final states in the first case had to be vacuum $|0&gt;$. It would be great if someone can explain this conceptual point about the difference in the initial and final states. </p></li> <li><p>Hence if someone can explain as to why the term $X$ contributes (and is infact the leading contributor!) to $\sigma$ but does not contribute to $W_{\mu \nu}$!?</p></li> </ul> <p>(..my vague understanding is that this difference stems from the difference in the initial and final states..but can't make this precise..) </p> <ul> <li>Though initially $W_{\mu \nu}$ is defined in terms of the correlator $[J_\mu(x), J_\nu(0)]$, often I see that during calculations one is in practice evaluating $[J_\mu(\frac{x}{2}), J_\nu(-\frac{x}{2})]$. Why this change? </li> </ul>
g1625
[ 0.013980778865516186, -0.026378054171800613, -0.008039078675210476, -0.0507405549287796, 0.09257092326879501, -0.011338846758008003, 0.05897912755608559, -0.012487633153796196, -0.011686967685818672, -0.02118557132780552, -0.029859231784939766, 0.051645006984472275, 0.0045608761720359325, 0.02489032968878746, 0.024431683123111725, -0.03650245815515518, 0.060596808791160583, 0.014215628616511822, 0.053720854222774506, -0.06419805437326431, -0.03260926902294159, 0.03701094537973404, -0.006717957090586424, -0.05312950536608696, -0.007798479404300451, 0.0014267289079725742, 0.07289120554924011, 0.022100787609815598, 0.0011501781409606338, -0.037470608949661255, 0.04710011929273605, -0.013034161180257797, 0.06181253865361214, 0.026419909670948982, -0.09542646259069443, -0.010926371440291405, 0.06846075505018234, 0.032508913427591324, 0.04769524186849594, 0.022042831405997276, -0.019461873918771744, 0.0018626482924446464, 0.026293013244867325, -0.009578301571309566, -0.011680729687213898, 0.015458440408110619, -0.06017020344734192, 0.005995884537696838, -0.01380070485174656, -0.012472271919250488, -0.033620838075876236, -0.00740416394546628, 0.05106429383158684, -0.015949420630931854, 0.06134629622101784, 0.007266269531100988, -0.025108221918344498, -0.006976382341235876, 0.04449383169412613, 0.10162264108657837, 0.001998618943616748, -0.01393812894821167, 0.04520833119750023, -0.016380824148654938, 0.06686164438724518, -0.0341501422226429, 0.010576273314654827, 0.002119803801178932, -0.0070023429580032825, 0.027883948758244514, -0.051072582602500916, -0.060777343809604645, -0.018681833520531654, 0.012593105435371399, 0.05027035251259804, 0.04243773594498634, -0.017358358949422836, 0.03537334129214287, 0.0853777676820755, -0.04979322850704193, -0.04292053356766701, -0.05190611630678177, 0.02865470200777054, 0.07874441891908646, 0.042835213243961334, -0.04492569714784622, -0.020814307034015656, 0.019943885505199432, 0.04741748049855232, 0.02460620366036892, 0.05352824926376343, -0.029181042686104774, 0.03463824465870857, 0.01576833426952362, -0.0006605038070119917, -0.05191043019294739, 0.015250585041940212, 0.00013341248268261552, 0.03984427824616432, 0.025858130306005478, -0.02806045114994049, 0.018648292869329453, 0.003681829432025552, 0.0380251407623291, -0.019893724471330643, 0.023680593818426132, -0.02109706401824951, 0.025083797052502632, 0.0006040696753188968, -0.03641262277960777, -0.023330261930823326, 0.01048459392040968, 0.008183526806533337, -0.038982756435871124, -0.04350854456424713, 0.023448660969734192, 0.004171203356236219, -0.008929562754929066, 0.008482053875923157, 0.035870861262083054, -0.01759258285164833, -0.001697943196631968, -0.007460972759872675, 0.011617924086749554, 0.01597059890627861, -0.08300764113664627, -0.00957922637462616, 0.0385839119553566, -0.017505811527371407, 0.011416452936828136, -0.010030330158770084, -0.008340345695614815, 0.0012602084316313267, 0.07723846286535263, -0.017641324549913406, -0.032947052270174026, 0.0046921768225729465, -0.027570994570851326, 0.022141961380839348, -0.045644521713256836, -0.003028030274435878, -0.007366782985627651, -0.0013303108280524611, -0.08518508076667786, -0.005333344917744398, -0.018614888191223145, 0.003953628242015839, -0.08547607809305191, 0.05134451389312744, -0.013874766416847706, 0.06612294912338257, 0.03180241212248802, 0.0030873590148985386, -0.020194541662931442, 0.013696668669581413, -0.024802757427096367, 0.008581158705055714, -0.06275857985019684, -0.05319545418024063, -0.01264791190624237, 0.03370736539363861, 0.01985774002969265, 0.021618543192744255, -0.017761504277586937, -0.017354952171444893, -0.04665560647845268, 0.04283522069454193, -0.08868183195590973, -0.02707003802061081, -0.0669901892542839, -0.003971800208091736, -0.01797771267592907, 0.0418369360268116, 0.04992566630244255, 0.03715677931904793, 0.05995073541998863, 0.07723508030176163, -0.034329500049352646, 0.012163138017058372, 0.0829763188958168, -0.05144314840435982, -0.021048059687018394, 0.00651739165186882, -0.0338604561984539, -0.03066013939678669, -0.040636640042066574, -0.03914777934551239, 0.04522344842553139, -0.00009870402573142201, 0.011079469695687294, -0.053982190787792206, 0.015976056456565857, -0.023103270679712296, 0.065547876060009, -0.04466988146305084, 0.015267875976860523, -0.043073222041130066, -0.019468512386083603, -0.04794175550341606, 0.028560474514961243, -0.010831616818904877, -0.015088832937180996, 0.0371544323861599, 0.0290535781532526, 0.03858424723148346, 0.019505515694618225, -0.017880268394947052, 0.0052224211394786835, 0.03936393931508064, -0.01658511534333229, 0.06150610372424126, -0.020656777545809746, 0.02279510349035263, 0.012773302383720875, 0.020746642723679543, -0.03596162796020508, -0.031054947525262833, 0.005824684631079435, -0.02098601683974266, 0.00907793827354908, -0.0026989872567355633, -0.058979637920856476, 0.1154019832611084, -0.0335538350045681, -0.05027429014444351, 0.023002253845334053, 0.03175259754061699, -0.02530132420361042, -0.042460616677999496, -0.04505961015820503, -0.035648051649332047, 0.02730231173336506, -0.020344505086541176, 0.00921780988574028, -0.010455730371177197, 0.022504320368170738, -0.026476193219423294, -0.0010341277811676264, 0.021601850166916847, -0.002550483914092183, 0.0026219647843390703, -0.011756446212530136, 0.003953204955905676, 0.03355717658996582, -0.024958981201052666, -0.006096407305449247, 0.00008142182196024805, 0.003856243100017309, -0.07263308018445969, 0.008246543817222118, -0.00593144865706563, -0.018337881192564964, -0.030043164268136024, 0.009559613652527332, -0.015799108892679214, -0.05389312654733658, -0.014867337420582771, 0.007734190206974745, -0.06103689596056938, 0.010037356056272984, 0.017356717959046364, -0.033615682274103165, -0.021074682474136353, 0.01173383928835392, -0.05981740355491638, 0.019112419337034225, -0.01436065323650837, 0.03613927587866783, 0.03567219898104668, -0.015031524933874607, -0.03729601204395294, 0.05608707666397095, 0.02508149854838848, -0.01848967932164669, 0.025442957878112793, -0.04559742286801338, -0.03587822616100311, -0.011113207787275314, 0.06298457086086273, -0.0033602414187043905, 0.00930783897638321, 0.053447287529706955, -0.043470341712236404, 0.03824993968009949, 0.020507382228970528, -0.07790753990411758, 0.021739313378930092, 0.016281120479106903, 0.01655111461877823, -0.015160052105784416, 0.04074612632393837, 0.024085132405161858, 0.03932015225291252, -0.05422530695796013, -0.001555836177431047, 0.011216569691896439, 0.06444505602121353, -0.015786323696374893, -0.005733337718993425, 0.04763966053724289, 0.021411778405308723, -0.0014117015525698662, 0.03440805897116661, 0.017409799620509148, 0.018066272139549255, 0.06267906725406647, -0.02217813767492771, -0.02350563369691372, -0.029093366116285324, -0.004991570487618446, 0.00129029992967844, 0.04371296614408493, -0.04583247750997543, -0.0489470437169075, -0.022153902798891068, 0.0030211566481739283, -0.04120761901140213, -0.01339046936482191, -0.05978197976946831, 0.02620641142129898, -0.0552804060280323, -0.0046637593768537045, 0.053316835314035416, -0.006785004865378141, -0.016511013731360435, 0.003228546818718314, -0.04857231676578522, 0.018550021573901176, -0.030561048537492752, -0.0014987565809860826, 0.03737862780690193, 0.0038577651139348745, 0.0505816750228405, -0.027134647592902184, -0.015744704753160477, -0.03924814611673355, -0.028491253033280373, -0.01108790934085846, 0.03896774724125862, -0.044118087738752365, -0.009132828563451767, -0.03165828436613083, -0.07941367477178574, 0.029777228832244873, 0.007399152033030987, -0.013308851979672909, -0.0002994952956214547, 0.013129094615578651, -0.013159007765352726, -0.004960833583027124, -0.00004254680607118644, 0.013883108273148537, -0.03367340564727783, 0.02986191399395466, -0.024178287014365196, 0.007503526285290718, 0.007547641173005104, 0.062134530395269394, -0.005727636627852917, 0.04104018583893776, -0.011801873333752155, -0.01433775294572115, 0.045118920505046844, 0.022741476073861122, -0.007394647225737572, 0.02766922488808632, -0.017318177968263626, -0.006354966666549444, -0.014013740234076977, -0.038313429802656174, -0.021379578858613968, 0.02666541561484337, -0.022696727886795998, 0.0568656288087368, -0.08103352040052414, -0.024687977507710457, -0.0018830010667443275, 0.0010661646956577897, -0.019811399281024933, 0.042581506073474884, 0.005184889771044254, 0.003473742166534066, 0.01953730173408985, -0.026573585346341133, 0.04461129754781723, 0.03898928314447403, -0.030852625146508217, -0.02368617057800293, -0.023264361545443535, -0.02889826148748398, 0.0327480174601078, 0.018731674179434776, -0.026492085307836533, -0.000057266272051492706, 0.057260673493146896, -0.03544054180383682, 0.04106900095939636, -0.020439980551600456, -0.006332158576697111, 0.0038677863776683807, 0.015521330758929253, -0.046758122742176056, 0.058492060750722885, -0.061033640056848526, 0.015789352357387543, -0.024834854528307915, 0.05000876262784004, -0.056126877665519714, 0.06287169456481934, -0.06127741560339928, -0.04139040410518646, -0.009314914233982563, -0.015260412357747555, -0.011354861781001091, 0.019077898934483528, -0.06354004889726639, -0.016463901847600937, -0.016249747946858406, 0.014120283536612988, -0.0032284799963235855, 0.04005265235900879, 0.00615787785500288, 0.03287219628691673, 0.0003720589156728238, 0.03167632594704628, 0.04881086200475693, 0.03576976805925369, 0.05044637992978096, 0.028966031968593597, -0.057520996779203415, -0.0197907742112875, 0.08517710864543915, 0.02755662426352501, -0.0035150027833878994, -0.08625312894582748, 0.019988127052783966, -0.029915206134319305, 0.06892899423837662, -0.047887738794088364, 0.03044271282851696, 0.07954258471727371, 0.04321711137890816, 0.022664964199066162, -0.023860150948166847, 0.04301014542579651, -0.03396062180399895, -0.029256882146000862, 0.010640254244208336, -0.024113057181239128, -0.017386484891176224, -0.006674740929156542, 0.031120270490646362, 0.007870526984333992, -0.08786619454622269, 0.060711756348609924, -0.0103737348690629, 0.03489184007048607, -0.036632344126701355, 0.02598179131746292, 0.002128232503309846, -0.07064227014780045, -0.003909587860107422, -0.010115314275026321, -0.0015313976909965277, 0.04792390763759613, 0.034676048904657364, -0.02600671723484993, -0.021202756091952324, -0.11049870401620865, -0.004765916150063276, 0.016845446079969406, 0.04338536784052849, 0.04150509834289551, -0.06326407939195633, 0.031420014798641205, 0.03392167016863823, -0.0011069896863773465, -0.00024250528076663613, -0.11595503985881805, -0.02986554428935051, -0.040657106786966324, -0.040071744471788406, 0.009344225749373436, -0.01508646085858345, -0.041282881051301956, 0.044037457555532455, -0.021546926349401474, -0.02919360063970089, -0.07346422225236893, -0.019584421068429947, 0.07968227565288544, 0.0518423467874527, 0.03311753273010254, -0.0001221984130097553, -0.008972601033747196, 0.08759288489818573, 0.014791267924010754, 0.001344712101854384, -0.02471853233873844, -0.01675141416490078, -0.043205518275499344, 0.025805579498410225, -0.029131896793842316, 0.01598658412694931, -0.045141659677028656, 0.051175810396671295, 0.06595061719417572, -0.01886858604848385, 0.04165169596672058, 0.00891992636024952, 0.08786828070878983, 0.0037856416311115026, 0.09394359588623047, -0.013234212063252926, 0.012654830701649189, 0.034251511096954346, -0.036842744797468185, -0.023845186457037926, -0.008560530841350555, -0.0430796779692173, -0.00476439343765378, -0.006349377334117889, 0.03651289641857147, -0.010245785117149353, -0.0006864492897875607, 0.058107711374759674, 0.010129175148904324, -0.09297645092010498, 0.00663416925817728, -0.009407628327608109, 0.03411778062582016, 0.018493538722395897, 0.030456483364105225, -0.01617351733148098, -0.04557768628001213, -0.011032267473638058, -0.014105165377259254, -0.007959578186273575, 0.018032336607575417, -0.005799940321594477, 0.01840781792998314, -0.00041354625136591494, -0.028846940025687218, 0.04686107486486435, 0.022379130125045776, 0.015752045437693596, 0.011105158366262913, -0.03504830598831177, -0.01630372554063797, -0.03580131754279137, -0.00421459274366498, -0.03091641329228878, -0.003849272383376956, -0.03402971476316452, 0.04437701031565666, 0.008574913255870342, 0.019390283152461052, 0.007779005449265242, -0.06482449918985367, 0.023748116567730904, 0.014329785481095314, 0.007956605404615402, -0.015481001697480679, 0.0948994979262352, 0.02886219695210457, -0.053661372512578964, 0.008177458308637142, -0.018688147887587547, 0.0010256189852952957, 0.011136561632156372, -0.009048497304320335, 0.037379954010248184, -0.04131210222840309, -0.04624416306614876, 0.0382935032248497, -0.001040091272443533, 0.004875595215708017, -0.024714717641472816, -0.037809960544109344, 0.00020722176122944802, 0.03416545316576958, -0.020189587026834488, -0.005130991339683533, -0.057192713022232056, -0.04309411719441414, 0.05998335778713226, -0.024052442982792854, -0.0028618136420845985, 0.025494858622550964, -0.021159205585718155, -0.019544459879398346, 0.024003123864531517, 0.014188004657626152, 0.009347849525511265, 0.006802182178944349, 0.019855596125125885, 0.0027119230944663286, -0.030461210757493973, 0.012329216115176678, 0.03494127839803696, 0.05443722754716873, 0.006019840948283672, -0.030187614262104034, 0.014623257331550121, 0.0736643373966217, 0.02987363189458847, -0.042680490761995316, 0.02100255899131298, 0.0061870901845395565, 0.023787079378962517, -0.0141045106574893, -0.04263501241803169, -0.027604488655924797, -0.019218454137444496, 0.007184778805822134, -0.048825688660144806, -0.0022098803892731667, 0.05532045662403107, -0.058625590056180954, 0.05759311094880104, 0.01783052086830139, 0.032031845301389694, -0.011857028119266033, -0.019114026799798012, 0.026852387934923172, 0.0726521834731102, 0.032288625836372375, 0.008240648545324802, -0.022260349243879318, 0.0025227891746908426, -0.06130972504615784, 0.03115500696003437, 0.00413515092805028, 0.04466179013252258, -0.0007110385340638459, -0.035830698907375336, -0.04212334379553795, -0.02168327011168003, 0.04414927214384079, 0.02363249659538269, -0.03716539964079857, -0.02187904715538025, 0.042928360402584076, -0.028004158288240433, -0.05240270495414734, -0.02260347083210945, 0.06088700890541077, -0.019417142495512962, -0.0658428892493248, 0.040450915694236755, -0.06268101185560226, -0.01235636230558157, 0.0206289105117321, 0.01449694111943245, -0.0298247579485178, -0.008498632349073887, 0.022636162117123604, 0.02584293857216835, 0.023379405960440636, -0.03357687219977379, -0.02925480343401432, 0.02341044321656227, -0.03960009291768074, 0.015927650034427643, 0.059077706187963486, 0.017022544518113136, 0.023670604452490807, -0.05983375385403633, 0.06280989199876785, -0.06665230542421341, -0.04931801185011864, -0.04986782744526863, -0.034857530146837234, -0.05441645532846451, 0.0351804718375206, -0.000915791024453938, -0.00590586056932807, 0.08839961886405945, -0.0371447429060936, 0.019776729866862297, -0.019800039008259773, 0.04445303604006767, -0.043319009244441986, -0.025072811171412468, -0.04100516811013222, 0.046156786382198334, -0.0670151561498642, 0.0011765891686081886, -0.0059224520809948444, 0.019989920780062675, 0.0036812995094805956, -0.008347316645085812, 0.05415498837828636, 0.0027974997647106647, 0.011891343630850315, 0.03660004958510399, -0.001638983841985464, 0.051023781299591064, 0.074177585542202, 0.03727520629763603, 0.03329532593488693, -0.030667614191770554, -0.03001914732158184, -0.01672559790313244, 0.0048376573249697685, 0.016316678375005722, -0.037626031786203384, -0.03617788106203079, -0.0190482959151268, -0.0614338144659996, -0.041039176285266876, -0.018003493547439575, 0.003438116516917944, 0.037299469113349915, 0.03136735409498215, 0.023508332669734955, 0.014269310981035233, 0.031610552221536636, 0.006693920120596886, 0.023859795182943344, 0.022609908133745193, -0.015456846915185452, 0.002231277758255601, -0.0022389686200767756, -0.002599473111331463, 0.018666649237275124, 0.032429639250040054, 0.047059156000614166, -0.07062549144029617, 0.024787647649645805, -0.03621090576052666, -0.03596526384353638, -0.04890124872326851, 0.0010973598109558225, -0.021542586386203766, -0.009504374116659164, -0.023455621674656868, 0.00980185717344284, 0.028667954728007317, 0.019228707998991013, -0.029346207156777382, -0.026551181450486183, -0.011233639903366566, -0.022059420123696327, -0.05391073599457741, -0.01164750661700964, -0.001797987730242312, 0.018805954605340958, 0.0322294719517231, -0.03952600061893463, -0.006921814754605293, 0.02750328555703163, -0.05313791334629059, 0.07424304634332657, 0.04475516825914383, -0.005175483878701925, 0.023419765755534172, 0.01847424916923046, 0.032154493033885956, 0.05420658737421036, -0.004922493360936642, -0.016071805730462074, -0.011248314753174782, -0.027765164151787758, 0.020413223654031754, -0.054314982146024704, -0.04706386476755142, 0.008763007819652557 ]
<p>I have this question that I dont know how to solve correctly :</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/HsYdc.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p>My question is, how do I find $V_B$ ? I will find the angular velocities myself, but I want to know the method to get $V_B$ ?</p> <p>I know I can start by using $V_C=V_B+V_{C/B}$, but then I'm not sure what to do next...is the direction of $V_B$ and $V_{C/B}$ the same ? I'm using vector algebra (cross product with i and j etc).</p> <p>More specifically : </p> <p>$$\vec{V}_C=\vec{V}_B+\vec{V}_{C/B}$$</p> <p>$$\vec{V}_C = -1 \hat{j}$$</p> <p>$$\vec{V}_B= ?$$</p> <p>$$\vec{V}_{C/B}= \omega_{CB} \hat{k} \times \vec{r}_{CB}$$</p> <p>Shouldn't $\vec{V}_B = \omega_{CB} \hat{k} \times \vec{r}_CB$ ??? If not, then what should it be ?</p> <p>If you need more info please let me know.</p>
g1626
[ 0.08871492743492126, -0.008381004445254803, 0.0017191700171679258, 0.008325721137225628, 0.06371191889047623, -0.09578970819711685, 0.08787219971418381, -0.026254355907440186, -0.003482675179839134, 0.032655902206897736, -0.022665414959192276, 0.05554797500371933, 0.037879422307014465, -0.01437945757061243, 0.01419217698276043, -0.037149179726839066, -0.02317456528544426, -0.050113700330257416, 0.004298591520637274, -0.004102209582924843, -0.03420305252075195, -0.011259056627750397, 0.01885644905269146, 0.03532589226961136, 0.0402229018509388, -0.06016689911484718, -0.003484826534986496, 0.009875028394162655, -0.08460365235805511, 0.02375309355556965, 0.00001550159322505351, -0.03077186644077301, 0.038030851632356644, -0.024008823558688164, 0.013674253597855568, 0.003083233954384923, 0.039428770542144775, 0.020519746467471123, 0.022239120677113533, -0.007964309304952621, 0.0027235797606408596, 0.00026252612587995827, 0.04175499826669693, 0.003443995025008917, 0.02883841097354889, -0.04255412146449089, -0.008474349975585938, -0.005778834223747253, -0.020414261147379875, 0.0019194060005247593, -0.041824426501989365, 0.07544655352830887, 0.02797841839492321, -0.05091476067900658, -0.023930054157972336, 0.010549512691795826, 0.006228522397577763, -0.010579576715826988, 0.0020910208113491535, 0.0272044837474823, 0.019294466823339462, -0.021503381431102753, 0.04150868579745293, 0.005803658161312342, 0.07240952551364899, -0.01067582331597805, -0.01683288812637329, -0.009726578369736671, -0.022895701229572296, -0.002555834362283349, 0.02568851225078106, -0.010553949512541294, 0.09671175479888916, 0.002515386091545224, -0.05743476748466492, -0.036093804985284805, 0.039369598031044006, -0.07227222621440887, 0.0244609285145998, 0.047774672508239746, -0.031426429748535156, -0.014509178698062897, 0.04754059016704559, -0.004137332085520029, 0.03572598844766617, -0.021211158484220505, 0.04771959036588669, 0.05785982310771942, -0.03562270849943161, -0.01848517172038555, -0.014701110310852528, -0.06654892861843109, -0.01713705249130726, 0.06303422898054123, -0.00880313478410244, -0.08634617924690247, -0.07374944537878036, 0.08883078396320343, 0.011111017316579819, 0.004011193756014109, -0.0011799910571426153, 0.009048545733094215, -0.000988209038041532, -0.016928846016526222, -0.006584810093045235, -0.029790643602609634, 0.041552748531103134, -0.005684427451342344, -0.03159014880657196, -0.04574623331427574, -0.04199410602450371, -0.10900311172008514, 0.007791533600538969, 0.01143200695514679, -0.04930802434682846, 0.009276474826037884, 0.057617515325546265, -0.03326781094074249, -0.0035403307992964983, 0.028341254219412804, -0.02225472778081894, -0.014226472936570644, -0.03310663253068924, 0.0483262799680233, 0.042390838265419006, 0.025415997952222824, -0.0030110471416264772, 0.010650661773979664, 0.049379147589206696, 0.025176169350743294, 0.04322211071848869, -0.03492865711450577, 0.04781150445342064, 0.04958593472838402, 0.001117875101044774, 0.011006110347807407, -0.008337176404893398, 0.05511230602860451, 0.024914586916565895, 0.010899274609982967, -0.032644376158714294, -0.007174248341470957, 0.00007283857848960906, -0.026945561170578003, -0.026806777343153954, -0.05167544260621071, -0.01714136265218258, -0.060694556683301926, 0.020724689587950706, -0.042936697602272034, -0.03304178640246391, 0.10822846740484238, -0.03762127831578255, -0.033031806349754333, -0.0018767506117001176, -0.037216320633888245, 0.039991315454244614, 0.012102588079869747, 0.02340083010494709, -0.05301015451550484, 0.055162884294986725, 0.006167208775877953, 0.04365784674882889, -0.036867592483758926, -0.014053958468139172, -0.022104276344180107, -0.005582623649388552, 0.035789597779512405, -0.0024075540713965893, -0.1117304116487503, -0.046329841017723083, 0.007556552533060312, 0.03093688189983368, 0.007002031430602074, 0.02540319785475731, -0.012875105254352093, -0.02309991791844368, -0.011736412532627583, -0.029722293838858604, 0.041022732853889465, -0.06260496377944946, -0.031955286860466, 0.08188686519861221, 0.03615538775920868, 0.006964895408600569, -0.020592359825968742, -0.029369935393333435, 0.004388314671814442, -0.05205366760492325, -0.015444399788975716, 0.002958275843411684, 0.031104829162359238, 0.01758643239736557, 0.018981344997882843, -0.033243577927351, 0.03518017381429672, 0.02904592454433441, -0.07107885181903839, -0.04830838739871979, 0.03707218915224075, 0.025961387902498245, 0.014916055835783482, 0.061099573969841, 0.05210115760564804, -0.06405874341726303, -0.033306434750556946, -0.005675222724676132, -0.01479035709053278, 0.013950088992714882, 0.03395513445138931, 0.0347803570330143, -0.02153731882572174, -0.050305791199207306, 0.02055276744067669, -0.00510504050180316, 0.037365660071372986, 0.04043339565396309, 0.02418927475810051, -0.040382638573646545, 0.0351073257625103, -0.006008231546729803, -0.004119912628084421, 0.005183456465601921, -0.027682902291417122, -0.018041668459773064, 0.044974565505981445, 0.004108903929591179, -0.02891823835670948, 0.026717137545347214, 0.003310098312795162, 0.0035805352963507175, 0.03125693276524544, 0.004216260276734829, 0.008107230067253113, 0.018279680982232094, -0.016362784430384636, 0.0013646753504872322, 0.007396782748401165, 0.019453315064311028, 0.03157345950603485, 0.03150412440299988, -0.009005321189761162, 0.023946169763803482, 0.035670481622219086, 0.06931518018245697, 0.0213505607098341, 0.05383231118321419, 0.01217937096953392, 0.027140220627188683, 0.017370786517858505, -0.024581948295235634, -0.010342222638428211, 0.007867099717259407, -0.044344883412122726, -0.0027846687007695436, 0.03433028236031532, -0.0296073816716671, 0.020372912287712097, -0.02068278007209301, -0.046867672353982925, -0.07943785190582275, 0.020630406215786934, 0.030774423852562904, 0.02504779025912285, 0.03791237249970436, -0.0335892029106617, -0.046097446233034134, -0.00788374338299036, 0.009017733857035637, -0.00646609952673316, -0.07318505644798279, -0.0018113339319825172, 0.024245155975222588, -0.018752863630652428, -0.038925088942050934, -0.014079246670007706, 0.03998570516705513, -0.031908996403217316, -0.06068608537316322, 0.07504373788833618, -0.02841787599027157, -0.005013199523091316, 0.028644395992159843, -0.04001155123114586, 0.034588996320962906, 0.015858352184295654, 0.026323748752474785, 0.07489495724439621, 0.038187023252248764, -0.04148230329155922, -0.05339934676885605, 0.03557232394814491, -0.02462758496403694, -0.017751168459653854, 0.05125504732131958, 0.03169599175453186, 0.04021558538079262, -0.022842172533273697, 0.018641214817762375, 0.017647817730903625, -0.009993570856750011, -0.016520394012331963, 0.011640369892120361, -0.03952421993017197, -0.01568164862692356, -0.026130473241209984, -0.04614001512527466, -0.007083541247993708, -0.041655831038951874, 0.04823824018239975, 0.005266345106065273, -0.04093385115265846, 0.017322750762104988, -0.020458299666643143, 0.0031509757973253727, -0.03397274389863014, -0.0294122863560915, 0.02405015006661415, 0.008274663239717484, 0.043698813766241074, -0.048590030521154404, -0.04334788769483566, -0.003335721557959914, 0.06301639974117279, 0.00825531966984272, 0.028430413454771042, -0.06478466838598251, 0.031095001846551895, 0.050152044743299484, -0.036645542830228806, -0.041063688695430756, 0.009300309233367443, 0.07639142125844955, 0.020499510690569878, -0.011162820272147655, -0.009745189920067787, -0.027990102767944336, 0.05944822356104851, 0.000999707612209022, -0.03800322860479355, -0.022835711017251015, -0.0032635279931128025, -0.013198408298194408, -0.038471098989248276, -0.038609638810157776, -0.016873382031917572, -0.02548915706574917, 0.06668437272310257, -0.019066154956817627, 0.0016065221279859543, -0.02239862084388733, -0.05766450986266136, -0.017364850267767906, 0.012491525150835514, 0.02122516743838787, 0.01039596926420927, -0.03074648790061474, 0.025537176057696342, 0.031467705965042114, -0.0463966503739357, -0.047193657606840134, -0.013080544769763947, 0.010772996582090855, 0.06388647109270096, 0.024396060034632683, -0.019842231646180153, -0.007732205092906952, 0.06278510391712189, -0.019230233505368233, -0.00006386784662026912, 0.02261568419635296, -0.03569035977125168, 0.03125206008553505, -0.0063438755460083485, -0.05242372676730156, -0.02457147091627121, -0.007683406583964825, 0.03214326128363609, -0.012641198933124542, 0.00419866805896163, -0.003259465331211686, 0.06067182868719101, -0.003840586170554161, 0.08009979128837585, -0.06325328350067139, -0.05922287330031395, -0.05926309898495674, 0.035815563052892685, 0.047247063368558884, 0.030114030465483665, 0.032913994044065475, 0.011984970420598984, 0.004496715031564236, 0.02880609780550003, -0.035759519785642624, -0.04092814773321152, -0.0038249350618571043, 0.042973842471838, -0.0341230072081089, 0.027531592175364494, -0.034997474402189255, -0.02940862812101841, 0.012624378316104412, -0.010630182921886444, 0.0044579156674444675, 0.06291035562753677, -0.008101256564259529, 0.024696772918105125, 0.02659999020397663, 0.027677975594997406, -0.028436103835701942, -0.039933349937200546, -0.0063520632684230804, -0.040356121957302094, -0.0162188857793808, 0.017492355778813362, -0.007518497761338949, -0.0326959602534771, 0.027772027999162674, -0.022097676992416382, -0.05932406336069107, 0.0012104978086426854, 0.022608350962400436, -0.07525202631950378, 0.0477675125002861, 0.044133350253105164, 0.0384867787361145, -0.035362839698791504, 0.054525960236787796, -0.02561350353062153, -0.0054167695343494415, 0.02936655469238758, -0.03499947860836983, 0.05192820727825165, -0.033713582903146744, 0.08884044736623764, 0.06637611240148544, 0.02348371222615242, 0.019718468189239502, -0.007348446641117334, 0.029025480151176453, 0.021933529525995255, 0.028396083042025566, -0.04637593775987625, -0.04367135837674141, 0.04882843419909477, -0.0357002317905426, -0.009425005875527859, 0.021043719723820686, -0.06129419803619385, -0.0016683543799445033, 0.028403695672750473, 0.024175100028514862, -0.028053468093276024, -0.017600351944565773, -0.01927020587027073, -0.04500095173716545, 0.01647384837269783, -0.002179480390623212, 0.01032763347029686, -0.034331563860177994, 0.0025406356435269117, -0.00024431213387288153, -0.024355163797736168, -0.0042304787784814835, -0.009154101833701134, -0.017819125205278397, -0.015456856228411198, -0.047507286071777344, 0.00536092184484005, -0.03261151537299156, -0.025779103860259056, 0.037550341337919235, 0.029202008619904518, -0.036300137639045715, 0.029248163104057312, 0.00026539649115875363, 0.0615561418235302, -0.07837878167629242, -0.022018084302544594, -0.07185975462198257, -0.012060889974236488, 0.019609779119491577, 0.059911035001277924, -0.028009142726659775, -0.028152156621217728, -0.007934611290693283, -0.1171814426779747, 0.019712770357728004, -0.003480153391137719, -0.0021131259854882956, 0.06167976185679436, -0.029462531208992004, -0.01985328458249569, 0.0036269635893404484, -0.022281046956777573, -0.02604569122195244, -0.0015383519930765033, 0.013858169317245483, 0.008378332480788231, -0.026950359344482422, -0.007431041449308395, -0.0444708876311779, -0.00901617668569088, 0.03370276466012001, 0.061084337532520294, 0.05004554241895676, 0.023945974186062813, 0.00478533236309886, -0.005431581754237413, 0.07266153395175934, 0.021033721044659615, -0.003298011375591159, 0.01966768316924572, -0.04278317838907242, -0.02286410517990589, -0.006721192505210638, 0.0324208065867424, -0.004317296668887138, -0.03611673787236214, 0.03631061688065529, 0.001230911584571004, -0.06910987198352814, -0.0034294251818209887, 0.06028147041797638, -0.049344751983881, -0.03232979774475098, -0.05196124687790871, 0.028825828805565834, 0.04925490915775299, -0.007161587942391634, -0.04908723011612892, -0.017722738906741142, 0.004243592265993357, -0.03558995947241783, -0.009397136978805065, 0.02289486490190029, -0.042740046977996826, 0.020107608288526535, 0.0014296314911916852, -0.026377221569418907, -0.0014548698673024774, 0.028553666546940804, -0.00879435520619154, -0.01526144053786993, -0.013258022256195545, 0.008493347093462944, -0.020159214735031128, 0.01860201358795166, 0.021798565983772278, -0.04340723901987076, 0.02239818312227726, -0.005146309733390808, -0.06676026433706284, 0.0035580855328589678, 0.03221072629094124, -0.06514431536197662, 0.0012328680604696274, 0.00036303800879977643, -0.01996232010424137, 0.05303599312901497, -0.034839797765016556, 0.016486117616295815, 0.025127429515123367, -0.011536138132214546, -0.012965443544089794, 0.07091163843870163, 0.06250955909490585, 0.007764384616166353, 0.0664900541305542, -0.06801217794418335, -0.03430698439478874, -0.013173147104680538, 0.01796191744506359, 0.07332676649093628, 0.05226318910717964, -0.01114608533680439, -0.021293707191944122, -0.06909169256687164, 0.020778894424438477, 0.02193431183695793, 0.013651027344167233, -0.016307007521390915, 0.01350810844451189, 0.015894316136837006, 0.013394221663475037, 0.011911734007298946, -0.02222362719476223, -0.0067736683413386345, -0.009760023094713688, -0.02679847925901413, 0.06184015050530434, -0.04970325529575348, -0.035715244710445404, -0.04542166739702225, -0.00790957547724247, -0.00015037991397548467, 0.01753811165690422, -0.03356268256902695, -0.04704878851771355, 0.010738063603639603, 0.0319230780005455, -0.012162397615611553, -0.020990543067455292, 0.024184493348002434, 0.024029547348618507, -0.03235989063978195, -0.008839915506541729, -0.027195502072572708, -0.0003581236524041742, -0.044741176068782806, 0.015172339044511318, 0.03805636987090111, 0.07817262411117554, 0.03397733345627785, 0.07282264530658722, -0.001288542989641428, 0.012939892709255219, 0.0343552827835083, 0.004286316689103842, 0.027920695021748543, 0.02536647580564022, -0.01427735947072506, 0.03565223142504692, 0.07410231232643127, 0.03504438325762749, -0.01486445963382721, -0.03757121413946152, 0.031516894698143005, 0.005908718332648277, 0.02900988981127739, 0.0008233324624598026, -0.0398821160197258, 0.018194539472460747, 0.04419441521167755, -0.010214487090706825, -0.047150444239377975, 0.0750478133559227, 0.02473014034330845, 0.05541900172829628, -0.010730772279202938, 0.01479381788522005, -0.01162270363420248, -0.00401345593854785, -0.015028811991214752, -0.03824741393327713, -0.004223750438541174, -0.03779551014304161, -0.013736950233578682, -0.043141406029462814, 0.07517962157726288, 0.03250909596681595, -0.013936112634837627, -0.024810390546917915, -0.02774028293788433, -0.05101022496819496, 0.053989022970199585, -0.0016788142966106534, 0.02549784816801548, 0.010274435393512249, -0.07160338014364243, -0.058044228702783585, -0.009123919531702995, 0.007106489036232233, 0.01594023033976555, -0.021034397184848785, -0.09289722144603729, 0.06581193953752518, 0.04064842313528061, -0.004343897569924593, -0.0028968278784304857, 0.006311568897217512, -0.06868253648281097, 0.04276605322957039, 0.028894731774926186, -0.01999228075146675, -0.011237053200602531, 0.0306767076253891, -0.05975533649325371, -0.018248485401272774, 0.040326423943042755, 0.02430863305926323, -0.07673642784357071, 0.034384582191705704, -0.01683802530169487, 0.025145666673779488, -0.03974568471312523, 0.006314686965197325, -0.010173395276069641, 0.008315345272421837, -0.030451791360974312, 0.06285832077264786, 0.03741713613271713, -0.03169698268175125, -0.009755375795066357, 0.033690351992845535, 0.006616886239498854, 0.02055986598134041, -0.02342839352786541, 0.03713982552289963, 0.03395438939332962, 0.011094324290752411, 0.011209111660718918, 0.08099471032619476, 0.010007089003920555, 0.06515908986330032, -0.007025379221886396, -0.05723380297422409, -0.022630803287029266, 0.03009030409157276, -0.02765248715877533, -0.0281373243778944, -0.006241428665816784, -0.04007159546017647, 0.005579923279583454, 0.002764469012618065, -0.021137690171599388, 0.0578303225338459, -0.00027106786728836596, -0.02670980617403984, -0.045982252806425095, -0.019059570506215096, 0.03257766738533974, -0.0029147465247660875, 0.029562605544924736, -0.06867680698633194, -0.01694202423095703, -0.015796678140759468, -0.0028939382173120975, 0.02011316455900669, 0.03185371309518814, -0.012047765776515007, -0.04833831265568733, 0.057067256420850754, -0.015869196504354477, 0.03126135468482971, 0.025213873013854027, -0.04734516888856888, 0.026043564081192017, 0.043728720396757126, -0.04166242852807045, -0.06203634291887283, -0.018900787457823753, 0.003990956582129002, -0.03506709635257721, -0.011597095988690853, 0.05446360632777214, 0.03583671525120735, 0.007083224598318338, -0.0445869043469429, 0.01798071525990963, 0.009050088003277779, 0.003245260799303651, 0.015705808997154236, -0.03552221134305, 0.0475175566971302, -0.0012641173088923097, 0.022612661123275757, -0.01064172200858593, 0.024255549535155296, -0.0383545458316803, 0.0107562355697155, -0.013881080783903599, 0.03354530781507492, 0.06797612458467484, -0.06168851628899574, -0.11891825497150421, -0.008717453107237816 ]
<p>I'm confused about the terminology in the two contexts since I can't figure out if they have a similar motivation. Afaik, the definitions state that quantum processes should be very <em>slow</em> to be called <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adiabatic_theorem">adiabatic</a> while <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adiabatic_process">adiabatic thermodynamic processes</a> are supposed to be those that don't lose heat. Based on my current intuition, this would mean that the thermodynamic process is typically <em>fast</em> (not leaving enough time for heat transfer). What gives, why the apparent mismatch?</p>
g1627
[ 0.07600155472755432, -0.016033316031098366, 0.015136280097067356, -0.020226672291755676, 0.014417999424040318, -0.0165045615285635, 0.06043296307325363, 0.026521967723965645, -0.014920944347977638, 0.020429013296961784, 0.027311792597174644, 0.0023200837895274162, 0.03541580215096474, 0.00459295092150569, -0.007548995781689882, -0.04556380957365036, 0.09595263004302979, 0.036332421004772186, 0.018070818856358528, 0.037453919649124146, 0.001762928208336234, 0.025477737188339233, -0.01804821752011776, -0.00503004202619195, -0.012277264147996902, -0.05289078503847122, -0.029434699565172195, -0.04782130569219589, 0.02501397579908371, -0.011577269993722439, -0.0016736699035391212, 0.000891882402356714, 0.06890165060758591, -0.014884005300700665, -0.018461598083376884, -0.02571164071559906, 0.0926835909485817, -0.0036248392425477505, 0.030353719368577003, -0.020366130396723747, 0.03289996087551117, 0.006820246577262878, 0.008846457116305828, -0.04314812645316124, 0.022990278899669647, -0.007494134828448296, -0.039437051862478256, 0.029199952259659767, -0.0651203989982605, -0.01737387292087078, 0.045547064393758774, 0.026059111580252647, 0.035192493349313736, -0.0009381469571962953, 0.05934283509850502, -0.03318396955728531, 0.04072675108909607, 0.04883899912238121, 0.011822209693491459, -0.025892863050103188, 0.05801701173186302, -0.015321969985961914, 0.026671016588807106, 0.03333112969994545, 0.02710076794028282, 0.06058517098426819, 0.025992270559072495, -0.03593636304140091, 0.021122606471180916, -0.009413158521056175, -0.007341703400015831, -0.054490961134433746, -0.018289092928171158, -0.023084621876478195, 0.04200267046689987, -0.05119503289461136, 0.0277258213609457, -0.10111214220523834, 0.010480783879756927, 0.0157956313341856, -0.06496255844831467, -0.021299170330166817, 0.035582780838012695, 0.04254641383886337, 0.03775910288095474, 0.031611859798431396, -0.05006150156259537, -0.0014754863223060966, 0.016474060714244843, 0.037547770887613297, -0.002805479569360614, -0.039676483720541, 0.03201377019286156, 0.03547254577279091, -0.08180645108222961, 0.053796615451574326, -0.04015818238258362, 0.014866461046040058, -0.049022044986486435, 0.009911496192216873, -0.006516110152006149, 0.0065142507664859295, 0.022654978558421135, 0.0004684147716034204, 0.04079331457614899, -0.05111902207136154, -0.013927374966442585, 0.00407249853014946, -0.0359431654214859, -0.0035228764172643423, -0.0022757742553949356, -0.001031376188620925, -0.05482765659689903, -0.02192780002951622, -0.016416510567069054, -0.008262640796601772, -0.014198792167007923, 0.011815941892564297, 0.0051357499323785305, 0.012154540047049522, 0.041226111352443695, 0.06080096215009689, 0.0028962157666683197, -0.009436244145035744, -0.03424753248691559, 0.051283203065395355, -0.03307192772626877, -0.012453378178179264, 0.031224096193909645, 0.01180644053965807, 0.038529761135578156, 0.004331044852733612, 0.023495780304074287, 0.01424398273229599, -0.05125781521201134, 0.00560338981449604, 0.058938659727573395, -0.06638365238904953, 0.006502686999738216, -0.02775970660150051, 0.044564638286828995, -0.0273838322609663, 0.039148710668087006, 0.005400208290666342, -0.05509093776345253, 0.01987135224044323, -0.04929574206471443, -0.0029955673962831497, 0.04205897077918053, 0.0026771598495543003, 0.015603790991008282, 0.02563602477312088, 0.01933414302766323, -0.02772163413465023, 0.015832044184207916, 0.05458617955446243, -0.008658930659294128, 0.019056063145399094, 0.017025569453835487, 0.01611800119280815, 0.0572500117123127, 0.019737759605050087, 0.017574984580278397, -0.031796738505363464, -0.013824821449816227, -0.009718181565403938, 0.023375390097498894, -0.032326605170965195, 0.014907876029610634, -0.07518205046653748, -0.017198923975229263, -0.04403495043516159, -0.023414723575115204, 0.03529109060764313, -0.00386326527222991, 0.07523208111524582, -0.001555647817440331, 0.012539505958557129, -0.06469136476516724, -0.05569136142730713, -0.02245280146598816, -0.049468446522951126, 0.03202285245060921, -0.06002239137887955, 0.01610613241791725, 0.040083739906549454, 0.02044469490647316, -0.00124580308329314, -0.0421290285885334, 0.03522730618715286, -0.015668552368879318, -0.05092279613018036, -0.009781674481928349, 0.05928372964262962, 0.00018845278827939183, 0.0049406434409320354, -0.02106025442481041, -0.0003899105649907142, -0.06623983383178711, 0.02272249571979046, 0.04088855907320976, -0.013109169900417328, 0.008235543966293335, -0.03247687593102455, 0.013398876413702965, 0.05506965517997742, -0.05856737121939659, -0.006638862658292055, 0.03394680470228195, -0.039717089384794235, 0.007830636575818062, 0.018654583021998405, -0.0034396988339722157, -0.013921347446739674, 0.03476239740848541, -0.004200862720608711, 0.02659301832318306, 0.05457298085093498, -0.04027101770043373, 0.016065143048763275, 0.0022446324583142996, 0.01620320789515972, 0.046459462493658066, -0.035964932292699814, 0.004719763062894344, -0.027264708653092384, -0.062488529831171036, -0.031176909804344177, -0.06403382867574692, 0.05232597142457962, -0.030912764370441437, 0.04308411851525307, -0.017696280032396317, -0.017845863476395607, -0.046239230781793594, 0.05700176581740379, 0.06675908714532852, 0.06755079329013824, 0.04295571520924568, 0.05369138345122337, -0.007143136579543352, -0.03298421576619148, -0.01765819452702999, 0.07383964955806732, -0.022357014939188957, -0.030600884929299355, 0.02438555657863617, -0.04222554713487625, -0.0006979003082960844, -0.024467183277010918, 0.0021053736563771963, -0.006554779130965471, -0.04220814257860184, -0.038820601999759674, 0.01615896075963974, -0.05675060674548149, 0.00903773307800293, -0.028489315882325172, -0.018999388441443443, 0.020962245762348175, 0.0017411549342796206, -0.011602729558944702, 0.014440909028053284, -0.0072616096585989, -0.03902502730488777, -0.009778986684978008, -0.005064669530838728, -0.018148148432374, -0.021766308695077896, -0.03995892032980919, -0.017312850803136826, 0.04622042179107666, -0.07022085785865784, -0.027937985956668854, -0.005771009251475334, -0.07735104113817215, 0.012449014000594616, -0.01768091693520546, -0.007896455936133862, -0.03741556033492088, -0.0281356293708086, -0.06638739258050919, -0.023729577660560608, -0.00994390994310379, 0.010900446213781834, -0.07587889581918716, -0.0326826386153698, 0.02574317902326584, -0.026178669184446335, -0.0013121353695169091, 0.0029497386422008276, 0.04078816622495651, -0.015437783673405647, 0.04362088441848755, -0.029653552919626236, 0.013346638530492783, -0.014880011789500713, -0.04305502027273178, -0.010600889101624489, 0.011536763980984688, 0.0670848861336708, -0.009430610574781895, -0.026366252452135086, 0.021434852853417397, 0.08235803246498108, 0.04136832803487778, -0.10688520222902298, -0.05963811278343201, -0.043408188968896866, -0.0048465728759765625, 0.034050069749355316, -0.032981082797050476, -0.025087418034672737, 0.039012882858514786, -0.014210342429578304, -0.0473378524184227, -0.0049899304285645485, -0.009881887584924698, 0.11223152279853821, -0.061619196087121964, -0.040754303336143494, -0.034319762140512466, -0.0061206878162920475, -0.0030524886678904295, 0.028193479403853416, 0.03989904746413231, -0.03667411953210831, -0.01034596562385559, -0.015638457611203194, -0.04871173948049545, -0.02609395422041416, 0.01572359725832939, -0.025643261149525642, -0.03267977759242058, -0.0845251977443695, -0.03495299071073532, -0.027766652405261993, 0.034367967396974564, -0.02714301459491253, -0.029030777513980865, 0.03674110025167465, 0.08559554815292358, 0.00491287000477314, 0.028074895963072777, 0.011962135322391987, -0.0030631504487246275, -0.014341783709824085, 0.015979111194610596, 0.01639702543616295, 0.007813462987542152, 0.021525820717215538, -0.010970622301101685, 0.03967920318245888, 0.02876991033554077, -0.11272972822189331, -0.001210650778375566, -0.0024064600002020597, 0.013990639708936214, 0.023304319009184837, -0.001019882969558239, 0.024782970547676086, 0.025251921266317368, 0.049611032009124756, -0.006155406124889851, -0.045993871986866, 0.02925696223974228, -0.0380258671939373, 0.014340370893478394, -0.016815906390547752, 0.001765549648553133, 0.009752052836120129, -0.014295746572315693, -0.07022950053215027, 0.014962447807192802, 0.08889666199684143, -0.014624915085732937, 0.07766519486904144, 0.0491420142352581, -0.048062022775411606, -0.024327818304300308, 0.031550515443086624, 0.03784208372235298, 0.012245334684848785, 0.013236246071755886, 0.05186020955443382, -0.02358313836157322, -0.05319221317768097, 0.012363739311695099, -0.02583279088139534, -0.06897488981485367, -0.016156014055013657, 0.021877756342291832, -0.01607150211930275, 0.04283051937818527, -0.010091732256114483, 0.0362071767449379, 0.056560713797807693, -0.02091333083808422, 0.037634290754795074, 0.051168378442525864, -0.05370258167386055, -0.01176719181239605, -0.06945905834436417, -0.023725805804133415, -0.0004390226677060127, -0.031136246398091316, -0.010889794677495956, -0.019490918144583702, -0.023158501833677292, -0.0140330595895648, -0.01205990370362997, 0.007932154461741447, 0.01018093153834343, -0.005156133323907852, -0.028265247121453285, 0.004484826698899269, -0.012123385444283485, -0.04931219294667244, 0.008883653208613396, 0.008127555251121521, -0.01676361635327339, 0.006436292082071304, -0.008550387807190418, 0.049744006246328354, 0.03633599728345871, 0.01517917588353157, 0.07014299929141998, 0.004366963170468807, 0.015942193567752838, -0.03703498840332031, 0.027989231050014496, -0.017849646508693695, 0.012864360585808754, 0.020425787195563316, 0.023324673995375633, 0.03822016716003418, -0.02242986671626568, 0.01094728522002697, 0.05375434830784798, 0.016419004648923874, 0.07201551645994186, 0.026728609576821327, -0.010803776793181896, -0.0006794091896153986, 0.007610798347741365, 0.038861263543367386, -0.0298446174710989, -0.05895145982503891, -0.03537573292851448, -0.11794410645961761, -0.014813859947025776, 0.06851201504468918, 0.014446688815951347, 0.027158336713910103, 0.0010484929662197828, 0.003425932489335537, -0.000611535448115319, 0.046844370663166046, -0.006003667134791613, 0.08526908606290817, -0.05794745311141014, 0.004799267277121544, 0.03075634501874447, 0.0006085009663365781, -0.02699633128941059, -0.0030771191231906414, 0.004956658463925123, -0.001064448500983417, -0.13462233543395996, -0.027462266385555267, 0.019623786211013794, 0.008511681109666824, -0.04647957906126976, 0.09208027273416519, 0.026774819940328598, 0.0005707363015972078, 0.045529935508966446, -0.04542684927582741, 0.0047916229814291, -0.0258325282484293, -0.016362329944968224, 0.000528684351593256, 0.016827180981636047, 0.03029700182378292, -0.004997064359486103, -0.011805204674601555, -0.004425684921443462, -0.009119699709117413, 0.011373341083526611, 0.01130974292755127, 0.028153691440820694, 0.03944842889904976, -0.009647629223763943, -0.0055838217958807945, -0.0008732567657716572, 0.048926010727882385, 0.029925337061285973, -0.0023426832631230354, -0.053754400461912155, 0.010184054262936115, -0.0644126906991005, 0.01112925261259079, -0.05661942437291145, -0.0026604044251143932, -0.024861177429556847, 0.03829895704984665, 0.0609193779528141, 0.049312856048345566, -0.025594761595129967, -0.016411112621426582, -0.025470154359936714, 0.03488415107131004, 0.015181507915258408, -0.04847618564963341, 0.025043770670890808, 0.05545805022120476, -0.007252449635416269, -0.028061242774128914, 0.024410972371697426, -0.018451238051056862, 0.053301647305488586, 0.0012284808326512575, -0.01337283756583929, -0.01209017913788557, 0.04658849164843559, -0.020063351839780807, -0.03232380375266075, 0.020049910992383957, 0.015147029422223568, 0.07711414992809296, 0.01817438192665577, 0.019093051552772522, 0.05495541915297508, 0.022959794849157333, -0.041151925921440125, 0.033013880252838135, -0.01183362677693367, 0.04134821891784668, 0.002158108400180936, 0.049004219472408295, 0.008300782181322575, 0.0008069174946285784, -0.021253427490592003, 0.03566744178533554, -0.008305845782160759, -0.042344801127910614, 0.0295040812343359, -0.03230152279138565, 0.06635275483131409, 0.0027214372530579567, -0.02880948968231678, -0.04340619966387749, 0.03230173885822296, -0.060728758573532104, 0.006125595886260271, 0.008764692582190037, 0.05076408386230469, -0.015142878517508507, -0.02337695099413395, -0.016435042023658752, -0.013712918385863304, 0.062285877764225006, 0.06016496196389198, -0.02090839296579361, -0.018028628081083298, -0.02313743345439434, -0.014242539182305336, -0.012987647205591202, 0.013458610512316227, 0.013728441670536995, 0.03805162012577057, -0.027997614815831184, 0.040217019617557526, -0.04130101576447487, -0.022720929235219955, 0.053921885788440704, -0.04899797588586807, -0.037437379360198975, -0.07635098695755005, -0.044857628643512726, -0.05040781944990158, -0.025302356109023094, -0.00034134447923861444, -0.03736817091703415, 0.0077534690499305725, -0.00881741102784872, -0.0140715716406703, 0.016195150092244148, 0.038509950041770935, 0.08307725191116333, 0.0011041200486943126, 0.006089601665735245, -0.02932848408818245, 0.008223493583500385, -0.03546649590134621, 0.0011747225653380156, -0.04681742191314697, -0.005950321443378925, -0.06754652410745621, 0.027398088946938515, -0.04311857372522354, -0.06956584751605988, 0.05152500048279762, -0.0037199417129158974, 0.0404108464717865, 0.06352484226226807, 0.021965468302369118, 0.05390629172325134, -0.02045512944459915, 0.04303610324859619, -0.033002302050590515, 0.03327510505914688, 0.026655245572328568, 0.013690146617591381, -0.039227329194545746, -0.009801759384572506, -0.042958710342645645, -0.002596504520624876, 0.002265227260068059, 0.004388237372040749, 0.017020422965288162, -0.0005602913442999125, 0.03743155673146248, 0.06165985018014908, 0.03581271693110466, 0.010660748928785324, -0.04880122095346451, 0.059385742992162704, -0.008890477940440178, -0.0203997902572155, -0.01665259152650833, -0.04583696648478508, -0.022417841479182243, 0.01742437109351158, 0.010222438722848892, -0.029565494507551193, -0.037216149270534515, -0.06882402300834656, 0.016760805621743202, -0.0007432422717101872, -0.010672483593225479, -0.005219742655754089, 0.031107254326343536, 0.04454579949378967, -0.03642410412430763, 0.014183145016431808, 0.007345112040638924, -0.034747373312711716, -0.06986953318119049, -0.05443420261144638, -0.026715299114584923, 0.022696608677506447, -0.09231041371822357, 0.024618934839963913, 0.010844718664884567, 0.013079462572932243, -0.02733900398015976, 0.023647654801607132, 0.02199127897620201, -0.0229102224111557, 0.014997999183833599, 0.03882286325097084, -0.015341565944254398, 0.011404326185584068, 0.022081764414906502, 0.03903587907552719, -0.0007165474817156792, -0.04121854901313782, -0.019142944365739822, -0.0026008514687418938, 0.04547262564301491, -0.02583315037190914, -0.019912511110305786, -0.025801770389080048, 0.027820775285363197, 0.007825285196304321, 0.045884788036346436, 0.018605055287480354, 0.0014555474044755101, -0.038211625069379807, -0.016117185354232788, -0.05559306964278221, -0.0003390835481695831, 0.030698692426085472, 0.0012295171618461609, 0.07784748822450638, -0.10094412416219711, 0.00462076161056757, 0.010366545058786869, 0.03590724989771843, -0.02647359110414982, 0.019182438030838966, 0.0004300292057450861, -0.008478418923914433, 0.032558754086494446, 0.04245338216423988, 0.03926229104399681, -0.02775060385465622, -0.021034467965364456, 0.02732774242758751, -0.03872119262814522, -0.008238399401307106, 0.02404911257326603, 0.04837624356150627, -0.0004816729051526636, 0.015466945245862007, 0.034646980464458466, 0.00002784995194815565, 0.02107742615044117, -0.041920728981494904, 0.03469933569431305, 0.0718727633357048, 0.019565923139452934, 0.014246786944568157, 0.020873384550213814, -0.049794308841228485, -0.0706862211227417, -0.07009714841842651, 0.006640358828008175, -0.07959116250276566, 0.044677942991256714, -0.0010243437718600035, -0.012578103691339493, -0.0816722884774208, 0.0026635690592229366, -0.02616266719996929, 0.0408778190612793, -0.02137058973312378, -0.022062670439481735, -0.031210225075483322, -0.011379611678421497, 0.010789346881210804, 0.05054480582475662, 0.004616138990968466, -0.05452034994959831, 0.014050327241420746, 0.059391602873802185, 0.035276010632514954, -0.015582626685500145, 0.006958466488867998, 0.04354219138622284, 0.009366815909743309, 0.03649946302175522, 0.0018634502775967121, 0.020496515557169914, -0.08860350400209427, -0.019715679809451103, 0.019632520154118538, 0.0461813323199749, -0.01665802113711834, 0.0005899997777305543, 0.0010694597149267793, -0.05679265037178993, 0.028321249410510063, 0.00019889502436853945, 0.03750158101320267, 0.02662542276084423, 0.03457219526171684, 0.03497921675443649, 0.022294895723462105, -0.028047360479831696, 0.015107455663383007, -0.029782965779304504, -0.021497774869203568, -0.03256542235612869, -0.050583891570568085, -0.04325791448354721, -0.01472961250692606 ]
<p>So I was writing a lab report for Physics I, where I was describing projectile motion. I had written </p> <blockquote> <p>Since gravity on Earth does not have a horizontal force, the object will not lose horizontal velocity (velocity in the x direction).</p> </blockquote> <p>Then this made me think, is there any gravitational force found in nature that has both vertical <em>and horizontal</em> components? </p>
g1628
[ 0.08662576973438263, 0.006961100269109011, 0.0055968728847801685, 0.010207434184849262, 0.05944756045937538, 0.030299203470349312, -0.022937411442399025, -0.025231188163161278, -0.07528931647539139, -0.06582436710596085, 0.03301915153861046, -0.0006920775049366057, 0.017514584586024284, 0.007950246334075928, -0.03930211812257767, -0.014986539259552956, 0.06491870433092117, -0.05605519190430641, 0.042055193334817886, 0.06833882629871368, -0.018143480643630028, 0.000011911909496120643, 0.008476849645376205, -0.03410746157169342, -0.03728877380490303, 0.01329275406897068, 0.038379769772291183, -0.048994820564985275, -0.06813597679138184, -0.007148290053009987, 0.004181943833827972, -0.024584736675024033, 0.011320145800709724, -0.07343534380197525, -0.04526006057858467, -0.01702219992876053, 0.02750334143638611, -0.008364896290004253, 0.0167145486921072, -0.011260774917900562, 0.021044248715043068, -0.013151661492884159, 0.005552208982408047, 0.021161027252674103, 0.04727720469236374, -0.01920822635293007, 0.03948252648115158, 0.011047291569411755, 0.029854383319616318, -0.06647564470767975, -0.05732381343841553, 0.012034798040986061, -0.0021742405369877815, -0.011440162546932697, 0.01655551977455616, -0.01282333955168724, 0.051921550184488297, 0.006319799460470676, 0.023076973855495453, 0.011435710825026035, -0.009233524091541767, 0.0035045836120843887, -0.014004566706717014, -0.019718868657946587, 0.04181113839149475, -0.040208879858255386, -0.058828502893447876, -0.05684028938412666, 0.035595111548900604, -0.026851147413253784, 0.025151126086711884, -0.01269448921084404, -0.012699639424681664, -0.015798917040228844, -0.0063649374060332775, 0.018032092601060867, -0.0012796929804608226, 0.006745544727891684, -0.007543414831161499, -0.022556830197572708, 0.06027083471417427, 0.040578294545412064, 0.050381850451231, 0.026297304779291153, 0.056958794593811035, -0.05613921582698822, 0.005082791205495596, -0.017398791387677193, -0.029385287314653397, 0.031237507238984108, 0.020046494901180267, 0.00008431827154709026, 0.007644752040505409, 0.046591974794864655, -0.02697194740176201, -0.022670414298772812, 0.010274818167090416, 0.09014623612165451, 0.037117213010787964, -0.007580415811389685, -0.05735088512301445, -0.023328496143221855, -0.0031808139756321907, -0.007537784054875374, 0.07674950361251831, -0.022166593000292778, 0.02178182452917099, 0.011771809309720993, -0.07058525085449219, -0.04068400710821152, 0.03896961733698845, 0.003956867381930351, -0.03350915387272835, -0.10221757739782333, -0.024999914690852165, -0.04540161043405533, 0.05122973024845123, -0.020828742533922195, 0.06966982036828995, 0.08509611338376999, 0.012258360162377357, 0.022560181096196175, -0.009495096281170845, 0.04979410395026207, -0.06926576793193817, -0.0067937918938696384, 0.0020750234834849834, 0.028995079919695854, -0.023273644968867302, -0.041230689734220505, 0.04307406395673752, -0.01225819531828165, 0.011079716496169567, -0.000574476842302829, -0.001249906257726252, 0.006593120750039816, -0.0027825231663882732, 0.03273215889930725, 0.0037160059437155724, 0.009846063330769539, -0.03744511306285858, 0.0286681167781353, 0.03698967024683952, 0.023969953879714012, 0.0016667373711243272, 0.01901100017130375, -0.019224923104047775, 0.03356561437249184, 0.003947120159864426, -0.04787151515483856, -0.02060287445783615, 0.06719950586557388, -0.004432357847690582, -0.05747707188129425, 0.014408809132874012, -0.04240473732352257, 0.03731061890721321, 0.022720754146575928, -0.01064132060855627, 0.004276400897651911, 0.0537567138671875, 0.051244765520095825, 0.06644392013549805, -0.021936705335974693, 0.011776294559240341, 0.015452559106051922, -0.027961822226643562, 0.006009902339428663, 0.021234670653939247, 0.010725092142820358, -0.07838743925094604, -0.010840390808880329, 0.042620155960321426, 0.03802986815571785, -0.02908935956656933, 0.03189267963171005, 0.015019414015114307, -0.04467862471938133, -0.027599582448601723, -0.026231156662106514, -0.017701074481010437, -0.018195336684584618, -0.04413570836186409, -0.004285220056772232, 0.0589008554816246, 0.0036243402864784002, 0.053403232246637344, 0.06625667959451675, -0.025514012202620506, 0.001452205702662468, -0.05560831353068352, -0.021139681339263916, -0.003675107378512621, 0.03535667434334755, 0.02390722744166851, -0.025856995955109596, -0.004793334752321243, -0.024865802377462387, -0.029916394501924515, 0.05540015920996666, -0.022477716207504272, 0.05026581510901451, 0.01557494793087244, 0.025235667824745178, -8.702022000761644e-7, 0.008842278271913528, -0.005931716877967119, -0.022199779748916626, 0.04510639235377312, -0.05109991505742073, 0.05460932105779648, -0.01677512936294079, 0.027992170304059982, -0.06006799265742302, 0.022819697856903076, -0.0002173579268855974, -0.02343495935201645, 0.027643756940960884, -0.08349626511335373, 0.0034025583881884813, -0.052856698632240295, 0.028378115966916084, 0.012357587926089764, 0.0023450034204870462, 0.007108705583959818, -0.043124258518218994, 0.0028187204152345657, -0.022581951692700386, -0.000906039378605783, -0.05931299924850464, -0.01890716888010502, 0.017315268516540527, 0.02580847404897213, -0.00702468678355217, 0.04514484107494354, 0.08476337790489197, -0.007999608293175697, 0.0043852608650922775, 0.018699122592806816, -0.02531358413398266, 0.022901935502886772, -0.006403204053640366, 0.012733753770589828, -0.024853071197867393, 0.06625654548406601, -0.049535464495420456, 0.01037558726966381, 0.04509463906288147, 0.08695957809686661, 0.022472554817795753, 0.027545014396309853, -0.08184771984815598, -0.03802695497870445, 0.05042533576488495, -0.004157430958002806, 0.012147066183388233, -0.010212182998657227, -0.023467745631933212, -0.04751821234822273, -0.061372388154268265, -0.04812090843915939, -0.06311043351888657, 0.03280531242489815, 0.031211022287607193, -0.06132517009973526, -0.039146456867456436, -0.05426858365535736, 0.0007988216821104288, -0.01474195346236229, 0.026296483352780342, -0.03817110136151314, -0.002398156328126788, -0.02477283775806427, -0.003190902993083, -0.01178541500121355, 0.0013526841066777706, -0.022417593747377396, 0.02319275587797165, -0.0031594932079315186, 0.01779293827712536, 0.03372320532798767, 0.03052373044192791, 0.0023226847406476736, -0.027564682066440582, 0.0323801189661026, 0.039777010679244995, -0.03855646029114723, 0.0024204531218856573, -0.032871998846530914, 0.04491628333926201, -0.012055763974785805, 0.025721922516822815, 0.05235389247536659, -0.022360606119036674, 0.011515486054122448, -0.006590068340301514, -0.0031384380999952555, -0.0018821469275280833, -0.029757145792245865, -0.009766935370862484, -0.008182144723832607, -0.016469337046146393, 0.057706188410520554, 0.04650815203785896, 0.0034977688919752836, 0.009038801304996014, -0.060875337570905685, -0.031361836940050125, -0.003964839968830347, 0.016458652913570404, 0.014894730411469936, 0.08389583230018616, 0.006597239524126053, 0.006278574466705322, -0.05038965493440628, 0.0000013882340681448113, -0.017373280599713326, -0.022292016074061394, -0.03820864111185074, -0.021558988839387894, -0.04985838010907173, -0.09090085327625275, 0.013307662680745125, 0.01748150773346424, -0.026565544307231903, 0.07740568369626999, -0.04747132956981659, 0.03552328422665596, -0.017021343111991882, -0.003446813439950347, -0.0045442781411111355, 0.011010780930519104, 0.013581174425780773, 0.018135379999876022, -0.07059191912412643, 0.02581825852394104, 0.027537785470485687, -0.03335953876376152, 0.06339829415082932, 0.03507542237639427, 0.05480462312698364, 0.031962260603904724, -0.006280502770096064, -0.02288137376308441, 0.028238734230399132, 0.0097089484333992, -0.006591875571757555, 0.043111223727464676, 0.042898546904325485, 0.03250261768698692, -0.004305084701627493, -0.03170750290155411, 0.08811505883932114, -0.04210815951228142, -0.0002847741707228124, 0.0018029231578111649, 0.04827074706554413, -0.02226611040532589, -0.08038519322872162, 0.03864818811416626, -0.024916693568229675, -0.026274625211954117, 0.03693215921521187, 0.0599975548684597, -0.0027878459077328444, -0.010720600374042988, 0.01159717608243227, -0.007232785224914551, -0.011379562318325043, 0.015694906935095787, 0.062371328473091125, -0.007908935658633709, -0.02599523589015007, 0.000866763642989099, -0.0035007568076252937, -0.10079321265220642, 0.04020455479621887, -0.053017355501651764, 0.007243196479976177, -0.01517701055854559, 0.0551774762570858, 0.022005949169397354, 0.04202785715460777, 0.08213405311107635, 0.05881771817803383, -0.04523412138223648, -0.02290280908346176, 0.016764163970947266, 0.09406230598688126, -0.025687359273433685, 0.004879736807197332, 0.005013726651668549, -0.014918983913958073, 0.03085920214653015, -0.022573281079530716, 0.004442616365849972, 0.03339436277747154, -0.0038611057680100203, 0.01916123554110527, 0.0009877235861495137, 0.02714833803474903, 0.03245526924729347, -0.004543711896985769, 0.010156474076211452, 0.012863160111010075, 0.07771158963441849, 0.05691631883382797, 0.020480647683143616, -0.04203037545084953, -0.059585146605968475, 0.04660416021943092, 0.04807528480887413, -0.024024978280067444, 0.03448724001646042, 0.022900709882378578, 0.003055129898712039, -0.036481823772192, 0.02820585109293461, 0.02736346796154976, -0.018419787287712097, 0.03238039091229439, 0.12214285880327225, 0.0018079307628795505, -0.001991443568840623, -0.003941257018595934, 0.011426824145019054, -0.006523961666971445, 0.03680131584405899, -0.04570816457271576, 0.007625015918165445, 0.015836484730243683, -0.0274954941123724, 0.04797610640525818, -0.03195521980524063, 0.024200810119509697, 0.005141992121934891, 0.013891627080738544, -0.05186789855360985, 0.005318411160260439, 0.015848511829972267, 0.031206954270601273, 0.007033803034573793, 0.04062351584434509, 0.0009053786052390933, -0.006659300532191992, 0.09964310377836227, 0.03315034881234169, 0.023507295176386833, -0.035868387669324875, -0.01681429333984852, 0.00709803169593215, -0.019733378663659096, -0.04415202885866165, -0.022922039031982422, -0.04187168553471565, 0.05003323405981064, -0.03203883394598961, -0.0010849343379959464, -0.024068627506494522, 0.009503664448857307, -0.029515286907553673, -0.031319741159677505, 0.030544394627213478, 0.03574187308549881, 0.00953126884996891, -0.028249135240912437, -0.034533582627773285, -0.013225223869085312, -0.03748679906129837, -0.03760763630270958, -0.026905711740255356, 0.025858884677290916, -0.011503627523779869, 0.070124551653862, 0.02359697036445141, 0.007345954421907663, -0.021179651841521263, -0.025829175487160683, 0.008068222552537918, -0.03605428338050842, -0.04388017952442169, 0.01914355345070362, -0.0014977845130488276, -0.05077832192182541, -0.01751319319009781, -0.047769684344530106, -0.013296157121658325, 0.006960474886000156, 0.03513554111123085, -0.016450216993689537, 0.003139620181173086, -0.05226711928844452, -0.05135321244597435, -0.05650245398283005, -0.052717119455337524, -0.009508596733212471, -0.030789338052272797, -0.024111449718475342, 0.046303242444992065, 0.028416741639375687, -0.019188089296221733, -0.029738884419202805, 0.01188535988330841, 0.04858394339680672, 0.048410993069410324, 0.04011162370443344, -0.012197502888739109, 0.035998936742544174, -0.06339651346206665, 0.03723205253481865, -0.05808788537979126, -0.0234235767275095, -0.04480201005935669, 0.02384771592915058, 0.00005751997377956286, -0.004075745120644569, 0.010443114675581455, 0.03804085776209831, -0.03922373801469803, 0.03286280855536461, 0.02218768373131752, -0.07357380539178848, 0.054122112691402435, 0.03429003804922104, 0.048984188586473465, 0.039648402482271194, -0.05327551066875458, 0.008348861709237099, -0.005273099988698959, 0.06376907974481583, 0.007039315067231655, -0.022535938769578934, 0.03741184249520302, -0.029423216357827187, 0.006508758291602135, -0.0545465461909771, 0.053773798048496246, 0.023285580798983574, 0.04299912974238396, -0.029856640845537186, -0.04837210476398468, -0.01700214482843876, 0.015738941729068756, 0.011553321033716202, -0.021768199279904366, 0.015899773687124252, -0.04151458665728569, -0.004565173294395208, 0.030535884201526642, -0.025677040219306946, -0.045601923018693924, 0.009673279710114002, 0.0016474479343742132, 0.026767879724502563, -0.025466131046414375, -0.024094536900520325, -0.019280117005109787, -0.02419138327240944, -0.00945348385721445, -0.03891376778483391, 0.030455270782113075, 0.011506378650665283, -0.034234628081321716, -0.021182049065828323, -0.022458849474787712, -0.0502641424536705, 0.021766746416687965, -0.07185813784599304, 0.023526053875684738, -0.022458139806985855, 0.011285991407930851, -0.013853373937308788, -0.08308130502700806, 0.030454305931925774, 0.03611142560839653, -0.018933698534965515, -0.025840913876891136, -0.022671813145279884, -0.032866161316633224, -0.0013274841476231813, 0.07552149891853333, -0.026543866842985153, 0.031183432787656784, -0.06104364991188049, -0.06613367795944214, 0.030986208468675613, -0.0750952884554863, 0.008683071471750736, 0.010726654902100563, -0.024342238903045654, -0.010155453346669674, 0.008909349329769611, -0.05674054101109505, -0.018610186874866486, -0.03480818122625351, -0.04230852797627449, -0.004420327953994274, 0.016550486907362938, 0.0003162915527354926, 0.026043159887194633, 0.049319177865982056, 0.003058644011616707, 0.013754875399172306, -0.026770545169711113, 0.03051343373954296, 0.028414105996489525, -0.007010859437286854, 0.026902388781309128, 0.011971332132816315, -0.027375606819987297, -0.040076155215501785, 0.018322616815567017, -0.008604240603744984, 0.0042395759373903275, -0.04114508628845215, -0.060417648404836655, 0.011928848922252655, -0.04767916351556778, -0.057725075632333755, -0.0006451818626374006, -0.02012023515999317, -0.02766740880906582, 0.003193602664396167, -0.0066845351830124855, -0.010152645409107208, 0.00944977905601263, -0.05401049554347992, 0.05487942695617676, 0.03769417107105255, -0.045236505568027496, -0.03774023428559303, -0.030437050387263298, 0.050677571445703506, -0.01452908106148243, 0.024223923683166504, 0.021177424117922783, -0.033166203647851944, -0.025874705985188484, 0.007793800439685583, 0.001580788753926754, 0.02059667743742466, 0.003924766555428505, 0.0009130513062700629, 0.008464454673230648, -0.003063821466639638, 0.06850970536470413, 0.021102609112858772, -0.038070376962423325, -0.00778949074447155, 0.0008521315758116543, -0.008771037682890892, -0.001284893834963441, 0.010586894117295742, 0.03686830401420593, -0.09537745267152786, 0.04599057510495186, 0.011330200359225273, -0.053377632051706314, 0.07101483643054962, -0.027599073946475983, -0.04230897128582001, -0.007491147145628929, 0.06803882122039795, 0.028539981693029404, -0.0397258959710598, 0.03406158462166786, -0.04584089666604996, -0.04498356208205223, -0.04810301586985588, 0.0704420730471611, 0.01015565823763609, -0.015087285079061985, 0.05452292412519455, 0.01189190149307251, -0.018581947311758995, 0.0068669808097183704, -0.0427277535200119, -0.031481850892305374, 0.0637628361582756, -0.013319696299731731, -0.012096519581973553, 0.04994221031665802, -0.037603914737701416, 0.06320233643054962, -0.06082653999328613, 0.018162410706281662, 0.03824581578373909, -0.02401038631796837, 0.021080946549773216, 0.008682476356625557, -0.01729741320014, 0.07220727950334549, 0.04690764844417572, -0.06122630089521408, 0.019940964877605438, -0.06099501624703407, 0.004004267510026693, 0.035828717052936554, -0.02402590401470661, -0.026392444968223572, -0.02193005569279194, -0.02383909560739994, 0.016004251316189766, -0.03195459023118019, 0.006395925767719746, 0.018821945413947105, -0.024502407759428024, -0.008737817406654358, -0.04317954182624817, -0.018285134807229042, 0.009415543638169765, 0.03788796067237854, 0.028982285410165787, -0.0003018094867002219, 0.010540497489273548, 0.06375659257173538, -0.03807621821761131, 0.021994855254888535, 0.05170222371816635, -0.005747771356254816, -0.04481847584247589, -0.042284924536943436, -0.014421817846596241, -0.07793134450912476, -0.08082276582717896, 0.030043648555874825, -0.001294574816711247, -0.0433516725897789, 0.032938361167907715, -0.0029275657143443823, -0.004140084609389305, -0.02927062287926674, 0.01527334749698639, -0.01889931783080101, -0.03506093472242355, 0.019649840891361237, 0.008006340824067593, -0.009100043214857578, -0.027692541480064392, 0.0218312069773674, -0.027242548763751984, -0.005089314188808203, -0.052760448306798935, -0.04812092334032059, 0.04629483446478844, -0.043163739144802094, -0.005367885809391737, 0.032026637345552444, 0.04267672076821327, 0.015106011182069778, 0.0682879090309143, 0.029448607936501503, 0.01975582167506218, 0.04864134266972542, -0.018687475472688675, -0.054013315588235855, -0.0024101308081299067, 0.07649019360542297, -0.009472678415477276, -0.04008590057492256, -0.0008767811232246459, 0.0538409985601902, 0.040194228291511536, -0.05114699527621269, -0.02023402974009514, -0.0053344545885920525, -0.0010944840032607317, 0.08256097137928009 ]
<p>As the title suggests, Can the effects of a person's mass upon the local gravitational field be detected and measured remotely?</p> <p>I am aware any mass produces and effects gravity but couldn't find anything in my searching if it is possible or theoretically possible to detect this effect remotely.</p>
g1629
[ 0.024490583688020706, -0.011234619654715061, 0.014324655756354332, -0.021735699847340584, -0.022128641605377197, 0.06122329831123352, -0.02598271146416664, 0.037244684994220734, -0.03060508519411087, -0.0011547876056283712, 0.0028870119713246822, -0.03555605188012123, 0.0070966752246022224, -0.009526453912258148, -0.026804853230714798, -0.019446704536676407, 0.06652364879846573, -0.02032991498708725, 0.003662337549030781, 0.04668239504098892, 0.006878927815705538, 0.0009825789602473378, 0.005833168514072895, 0.02554747834801674, -0.05595788359642029, 0.05190131813287735, 0.05451975390315056, -0.005524229723960161, 0.013183553703129292, -0.02914023958146572, -0.08792071044445038, -0.0317993126809597, -0.010386504232883453, -0.05116267129778862, -0.01850884035229683, -0.01864410936832428, -0.011841022409498692, -0.02468804083764553, -0.022414397448301315, 0.016023309901356697, -0.04824881628155708, -0.019785450771450996, 0.005787029396742582, -0.02545388601720333, 0.007487798575311899, 0.059177570044994354, 0.043520618230104446, 0.0316377729177475, 0.01056728232651949, 0.011571154929697514, -0.05836673453450203, -0.05484697222709656, 0.0337415486574173, 0.04401478171348572, -0.012961871922016144, -0.02572944387793541, 0.01250233594328165, 0.04299211874604225, 0.041702087968587875, -0.031510330736637115, 0.014392169192433357, 0.03041383996605873, 0.004561020061373711, -0.020567957311868668, -0.007782682776451111, 0.022443462163209915, -0.04363417625427246, -0.0046519069001078606, -0.02772340178489685, 0.05483170226216316, 0.015484592877328396, 0.02359204739332199, -0.06704337149858475, 0.02781211957335472, 0.029976267367601395, 0.009146459400653839, 0.007179614622145891, 0.03432055190205574, -0.02752128429710865, 0.00292711122892797, -0.04307440668344498, -0.06190810725092888, 0.020352991297841072, 0.03440158814191818, 0.06889569014310837, -0.08166860044002533, 0.014699003659188747, 0.008554485626518726, -0.01976078562438488, -0.01670236699283123, 0.015481235459446907, 0.019064439460635185, -0.001690022530965507, 0.03772661089897156, 0.007956131361424923, -0.03888893127441406, 0.005956311710178852, 0.01589839905500412, -0.04154440388083458, -0.02225567027926445, -0.05362395569682121, 0.02177875116467476, -0.008292759768664837, 0.01747659221291542, 0.01932169310748577, 0.005845160223543644, 0.027824966236948967, 0.04668870195746422, 0.047650907188653946, -0.04150709509849548, 0.013123640790581703, -0.07135570794343948, 0.0026961900293827057, 0.04084017127752304, -0.0758683905005455, -0.04315013810992241, 0.02357008494436741, -0.0001402078487444669, -0.04134419187903404, 0.05125195160508156, -0.020775392651557922, 0.058228809386491776, -0.04961501061916351, 0.04622862488031387, -0.04454505816102028, 0.013392995111644268, -0.04592227190732956, 0.02720562368631363, 0.015725646167993546, 0.033513620495796204, -0.005890676751732826, 0.03264058008790016, -0.010492210276424885, -0.02910325676202774, -0.022218132391572, -0.0009669282590039074, -0.008278043940663338, 0.05656764656305313, -0.021201899275183678, -0.06905343383550644, 0.005885384511202574, 0.021191895008087158, 0.008985701017081738, 0.0000723810589988716, 0.0006358834216371179, 0.015968697145581245, 0.03407244011759758, 0.007795238867402077, 0.04206158593297005, 0.05415808781981468, 0.04116643965244293, -0.027881477028131485, 0.0366915762424469, -0.05210300162434578, 0.07046031951904297, 0.012736605480313301, -0.08652815967798233, 0.036806002259254456, 0.016686469316482544, -0.023957034572958946, 0.04580036923289299, -0.010068060830235481, 0.054340820759534836, -0.006043762434273958, 0.018692942336201668, 0.01621929742395878, -0.024295441806316376, 0.0148618770763278, 0.010327453725039959, -0.034794241189956665, -0.06493712216615677, -0.02633250504732132, -0.000291658187052235, 0.06549807637929916, -0.039110589772462845, 0.007642732933163643, 0.006537300534546375, -0.025602830573916435, -0.0025258464738726616, 0.02442724071443081, -0.01539529487490654, -0.04818709194660187, -0.02803361974656582, -0.08685639500617981, 0.005704475101083517, -0.045822449028491974, 0.04629986733198166, 0.008279244415462017, -0.0023413437884300947, 0.02670656330883503, -0.05205921456217766, 0.0010810778476297855, -0.024447612464427948, 0.020759865641593933, -0.015924042090773582, 0.023761222139000893, 0.05602913349866867, 0.06288602948188782, -0.03210371360182762, 0.06364157050848007, -0.03341776132583618, -0.006577088963240385, 0.04932865872979164, -0.025933165103197098, 0.01650261878967285, -0.016286443918943405, -0.0032607594039291143, -0.038320522755384445, -0.007579717319458723, -0.0993063747882843, 0.017097357660531998, -0.01648031547665596, 0.03908425197005272, -0.0364837609231472, 0.018451757729053497, 0.09962445497512817, -0.04236023128032684, 0.000048575788241578266, 0.05452743545174599, -0.029537374153733253, 0.013583308085799217, 0.03597530722618103, -0.015344186685979366, -0.026834242045879364, 0.0027790272142738104, -0.011324457824230194, -0.04913775250315666, -0.016056235879659653, 0.0001247654145117849, -0.050747085362672806, 0.033603161573410034, 0.05436509847640991, 0.059139758348464966, 0.005317836534231901, 0.025224782526493073, 0.01618834212422371, -0.025490770116448402, -0.04841028153896332, -0.02824842371046543, -0.03115781769156456, 0.02750086784362793, -0.05118503049015999, -0.021878588944673538, -0.00302290846593678, 0.015247377566993237, -0.06302345544099808, -0.019590934738516808, 0.06180513650178909, 0.043627068400382996, -0.0017333828145638108, -0.011370882391929626, 0.01973288133740425, -0.050040069967508316, 0.033101215958595276, 0.005221968051046133, -0.023706212639808655, -0.01346195861697197, 0.0757388025522232, -0.054395999759435654, -0.012856090441346169, -0.053117796778678894, 0.01565445587038994, -0.0018233982846140862, 0.06074811518192291, 0.030946366488933563, -0.03865456581115723, -0.01536691002547741, -0.016468942165374756, 0.008126377128064632, 0.03428667038679123, -0.02998661808669567, 0.07525549829006195, 0.018176186829805374, 0.09417568147182465, 0.00017291867698077112, -0.011526075191795826, -0.011710252612829208, 0.00858259666711092, 0.03416890650987625, 0.01059218030422926, -0.030072009190917015, -0.012719675898551941, -0.013615664094686508, 0.014446187764406204, 0.04603341966867447, -0.0584227629005909, -0.049237076193094254, -0.042714379727840424, 0.018926383927464485, 0.023141033947467804, 0.053328465670347214, 0.001380454283207655, 0.04241461306810379, 0.03641834855079651, -0.033248431980609894, 0.034365855157375336, -0.013471974059939384, 0.018234627321362495, 0.003739716252312064, -0.004356435500085354, 0.04154924303293228, -0.0662834420800209, 0.031584449112415314, 0.018117811530828476, -0.06307800114154816, -0.00421721488237381, -0.060661859810352325, 0.016112864017486572, 0.040840793401002884, -0.061147212982177734, -0.051244884729385376, 0.013378962874412537, 0.06016867607831955, 0.0063510169275105, -0.03763235732913017, -0.0017531007761135697, -0.018595144152641296, 0.014817476272583008, -0.05362163484096527, -0.04746556282043457, 0.00847440492361784, -0.006519859191030264, -0.04690816253423691, -0.02771151065826416, 0.023532085120677948, 0.03558262810111046, 0.022455917671322823, 0.03673520311713219, -0.0060370909050107, -0.05647019296884537, 0.006761241238564253, -0.05748188868165016, -0.041030049324035645, -0.035245273262262344, -0.05276597663760185, 0.05015522986650467, -0.02103659324347973, 0.013952444307506084, 0.02403583563864231, 0.030721524730324745, 0.02411692775785923, 0.06593674421310425, -0.03115236572921276, -0.029854770749807358, -0.038568850606679916, 0.09579984098672867, -0.02596827782690525, -0.03337964415550232, 0.009323219768702984, -0.01982099749147892, 0.04992200434207916, -0.02443920262157917, 0.0098147913813591, 0.013405736535787582, 0.013013907708227634, -0.019051872193813324, 0.02602113038301468, 0.01569877192378044, -0.04398757591843605, -0.021494559943675995, 0.006568769924342632, 0.029011087492108345, 0.025716084986925125, -0.006147324573248625, 0.008146971464157104, 0.011117950081825256, 0.00949108600616455, -0.030144700780510902, -0.013858741149306297, -0.004324696958065033, -0.00912960059940815, -0.03654462844133377, 0.009728122502565384, -0.03821249678730965, 0.03647558018565178, -0.02556685358285904, 0.06578344106674194, -0.022191818803548813, 0.027415171265602112, 0.028466224670410156, -0.013276024721562862, 0.03752908855676651, 0.010548031888902187, 0.0010493238223716617, 0.012471725232899189, -0.02338644303381443, -0.06361106038093567, -0.008694717660546303, 0.06289959698915482, -0.007952423766255379, -0.01751195453107357, -0.13851508498191833, 0.022691061720252037, 0.02477971650660038, 0.03675420209765434, 0.024653227999806404, -0.009081529453396797, -0.04584317281842232, 0.08293677866458893, 0.05678398907184601, 0.02604627050459385, 0.06548160314559937, 0.014927663840353489, 0.04399333894252777, -0.027339791879057884, -0.01877526380121708, 0.02745545096695423, 0.012683728709816933, -0.0649409294128418, 0.013667763210833073, 0.010411509312689304, -0.06022597476840019, -0.02139890007674694, -0.04547734186053276, -0.025716450065374374, 0.05909096449613571, -0.02181989699602127, 0.010350697673857212, 0.06659241020679474, 0.031108031049370766, 0.020272791385650635, -0.009968866594135761, -0.004432575311511755, 0.008458607830107212, -0.07050582766532898, 0.06356751173734665, 0.029441477730870247, -0.061485111713409424, -0.007846924476325512, 0.03350365161895752, 0.03542391583323479, 0.009238545782864094, -0.001051156548783183, 0.03069363906979561, 0.018071213737130165, 0.02972167544066906, -0.002991331508383155, -0.006780649535357952, 0.0559188574552536, -0.03066425770521164, 0.012517500668764114, 0.023897672072052956, -0.0015076345298439264, 0.02309381030499935, -0.011793124489486217, 0.042855605483055115, -0.02624763548374176, -0.010679017752408981, -0.00022530222486238927, 0.004602604545652866, -0.06792289763689041, -0.08628460019826889, -0.03011920675635338, -0.04683082550764084, -0.003647034289315343, 0.06700308620929718, -0.027125008404254913, -0.03422586992383003, 0.03580806404352188, -0.025935078039765358, -0.0008977428078651428, -0.048410564661026, 0.0398947037756443, 0.05229899659752846, -0.05354955047369003, 0.01995277777314186, -0.07146953046321869, -0.01248443964868784, -0.017302557826042175, -0.029290687292814255, -0.06168785318732262, 0.0013801837339997292, -0.0004872965218964964, 0.023707687854766846, -0.06461051851511002, 0.00031733239302411675, -0.02440098486840725, -0.03448402136564255, 0.02832828462123871, -0.0685325562953949, -0.006131909321993589, 0.037839166820049286, 0.04035355895757675, -0.02866537868976593, -0.002000748412683606, 0.043827854096889496, -0.057842448353767395, 0.0384816899895668, 0.016166135668754578, -0.07754611223936081, 0.01836579665541649, 0.016255829483270645, 0.013273356482386589, -0.020092343911528587, -0.0036078596021980047, 0.005326130427420139, -0.016787080094218254, -0.0038077796343714, -0.015332544222474098, -0.00165971415117383, 0.04666679725050926, 0.04399154707789421, 0.03159439191222191, 0.0031860340386629105, -0.029771268367767334, -0.003609453095123172, -0.025483259931206703, -0.05786379426717758, -0.002076880307868123, 0.03094641864299774, -0.07083494961261749, 0.032808493822813034, -0.014652200043201447, -0.03080512396991253, 0.015820564702153206, -0.004967230372130871, -0.02500128746032715, 0.01614180952310562, -0.008737985044717789, -0.006334330420941114, 0.01626402884721756, -0.06876406818628311, 0.020513473078608513, 0.02713281847536564, -0.010381068103015423, -0.03797971084713936, -0.022127602249383926, 0.02674124203622341, 0.008820704184472561, 0.02148122526705265, 0.023127000778913498, -0.0045625437051057816, -0.0021030607167631388, -0.0010309608187526464, -0.015356959775090218, -0.06403221189975739, 0.018361298367381096, 0.04315149784088135, 0.0288839153945446, 0.026871291920542717, -0.00229401933029294, -0.07612255215644836, 0.028697006404399872, -0.0007707540062256157, 0.0218740813434124, -0.008359394967556, 0.03738712519407272, -0.022968852892518044, 0.018176604062318802, 0.004813889507204294, -0.061166584491729736, 0.034781135618686676, -0.032607465982437134, 0.02424524910748005, -0.021016135811805725, 0.029731951653957367, -0.051224179565906525, 0.029666613787412643, -0.05494384095072746, -0.008661650121212006, 0.029171815142035484, 0.05513911694288254, 0.027314208447933197, -0.04896291345357895, 0.007426190655678511, 0.018787559121847153, 0.021814633160829544, -0.03790779411792755, 0.01334279403090477, -0.04444325342774391, -0.02025151252746582, -0.010178733617067337, -0.0014382447116076946, -0.03225782886147499, -0.01867847517132759, 0.043395087122917175, 0.01804402656853199, -0.0021082416642457247, 0.02085704542696476, -0.02612524852156639, 0.026655396446585655, 0.023721951991319656, 0.04455780237913132, -0.054021358489990234, 0.018450742587447166, 0.06165372580289841, -0.0354253426194191, 0.07405625283718109, 0.032899998128414154, -0.00011882817489095032, 0.016327759250998497, -0.053638312965631485, -0.038694366812705994, 0.013701003976166248, -0.07090280205011368, -0.05617327615618706, -0.034766603261232376, 0.03561647981405258, -0.05413123592734337, 0.027625177055597305, 0.017891759052872658, -0.008417529053986073, 0.09156328439712524, 0.012592257931828499, -0.045471642166376114, 0.005847956985235214, -0.02096206322312355, 0.0076194340363144875, 0.025283358991146088, -0.066280297935009, -0.05584077537059784, 0.0018865279853343964, 0.018728425726294518, 0.006754138972610235, 0.017136473208665848, -0.04928887262940407, -0.01890917867422104, -0.011804199777543545, -0.06512896716594696, -0.040864523500204086, 0.0030288712587207556, -0.02764262817800045, 0.041112348437309265, -0.08725851029157639, -0.03390573710203171, 0.06756789982318878, -0.004605682101100683, 0.018950795754790306, 0.003152277087792754, 0.01693655736744404, -0.034910719841718674, 0.021105075255036354, 0.041434500366449356, 0.03277627006173134, 0.02487088553607464, 0.05662314221262932, 0.024340827018022537, 0.020229250192642212, 0.08186061680316925, 0.005709748715162277, 0.04227446764707565, -0.023512832820415497, -0.03410125896334648, 0.002875985810533166, -0.08266747742891312, 0.0004229409387335181, 0.02425842545926571, 0.04416291415691376, -0.02218036912381649, -0.0302162766456604, -0.0454786941409111, -0.007920742966234684, 0.030604172497987747, 0.02834296226501465, -0.014629536308348179, 0.06323525309562683, -0.020644748583436012, 0.008085540495812893, 0.034118227660655975, -0.06340456753969193, -0.06218549236655235, 0.015453476458787918, 0.014640847221016884, -0.010186825878918171, 0.023785026744008064, 0.018948344513773918, 0.028771819546818733, -0.028613708913326263, 0.01718820631504059, 0.052597615867853165, 0.012481524609029293, -0.0869431123137474, -0.028506945818662643, 0.004800902213901281, 0.05051983520388603, -0.07006274908781052, -0.03239387646317482, -0.019298473373055458, 0.0055243088863790035, 0.03212155029177666, -0.02000138722360134, 0.01781713217496872, -0.006391259375959635, 0.0559820830821991, -0.004632133524864912, -0.0033060540445148945, 0.004829075187444687, 0.05849888175725937, 0.05237496271729469, -0.013659065589308739, -0.033796489238739014, 0.0020450737792998552, -0.03729432448744774, 0.002454547444358468, -0.019648414105176926, -0.013917695730924606, 0.02381872572004795, 0.06623939424753189, 0.0002543852897360921, -0.004551537334918976, -0.024895094335079193, 0.010456180199980736, -0.014622276648879051, -0.008915034122765064, 0.0574912428855896, -0.006055420730262995, -0.0644865334033966, 0.01944500207901001, -0.050429943948984146, 0.018358979374170303, 0.050959859043359756, 0.042883746325969696, 0.044032737612724304, 0.0038795089349150658, 0.025296607986092567, 0.007422210648655891, -0.03059058077633381, 0.02655145898461342, -0.017192339524626732, -0.0333094447851181, 0.008778724819421768, 0.03699041157960892, 0.050749268382787704, -0.0765870213508606, -0.051081106066703796, 0.02763940766453743, 0.05715898424386978, 0.06956475973129272, 0.07005725055932999, -0.009594935923814774, 0.01614920236170292, 0.013018080964684486, -0.03532940894365311, -0.09468141198158264, 0.010560073889791965, -0.004813528619706631, 0.03537171334028244, 0.02169804275035858, -0.009169734083116055, -0.0018809247994795442, -0.005743419285863638, -0.004383189138025045, 0.028895236551761627, -0.01205061562359333, 0.05140875279903412, 0.028813453391194344, -0.01866614818572998, 0.03507586196064949, -0.0001637258828850463, 0.006178462877869606, 0.027122817933559418, 0.01954779215157032, -0.022532902657985687, 0.018980130553245544, -0.03929716348648071, -0.013636385090649128, -0.01659753918647766, -0.047752682119607925, -0.0363987497985363, -0.046173349022865295, -0.004471477586776018, 0.01132793165743351, -0.050604090094566345, 0.006311240140348673, -0.05426185950636864, -0.005689114332199097, 0.06709091365337372, 0.056645963340997696 ]
<p>For my research work i am trying to calculate band gap of zinc oxide theoratically and found this <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/adma.200304904" rel="nofollow">paper (Determination of the Particle Size Distribution of Quantum Nanocrystals from Absorbance Spectr)</a>. What i am doing is I am making a small matlab programm which will reporduce the results using the same values from the above paper. I used the values given in the paper to make the program</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/v8Fbp.jpg" alt="enter image description here"></p> <p><strong>Absorbtion onset</strong> </p> <p>$\lambda ^{onset}=\frac{c*h}{E^{*}}$</p> <pre><code> Values used for calculating Band gap 8.85418782 × 10^-12 permittivity of free space 1.60217657 × 10^-19 charge of an electron 9.11 × 10^-31 free electron mass 1.05457173 × 10^-34 hcut 0.59 effective mass of holes 0.26 effective mass of electrons 8.5 relative permittivity 3.2 zno bandgap c velocity of light </code></pre> <p>But after running the programm i got these results</p> <pre><code>Size Absorbtion Onset 1 6.21E-26 1.5 6.21E-26 2 6.21E-26 2.5 6.21E-26 3 6.21E-26 3.5 6.21E-26 4 6.21E-26 4.5 6.21E-26 5 6.21E-26 5.5 6.21E-26 6 6.21E-26 6.5 6.21E-26 7 6.21E-26 7.5 6.21E-26 8 6.21E-26 8.5 6.21E-26 9 6.21E-26 9.5 6.21E-26 10 6.21E-26 </code></pre> <p>The results i got doesnt match with tha paper and I belive that my coding in matlab is correct but i am doubtful about the values i have taken for calculating band gap. </p> <p>Can you help me with this</p>
g1630
[ 0.06233324855566025, -0.013588136993348598, 0.011229458265006542, -0.02140006609261036, -0.014987234026193619, 0.01748405396938324, 0.04503488913178444, 0.003212661948055029, 0.019187038764357567, 0.01625402458012104, 0.047685425728559494, 0.05655594542622566, 0.037023428827524185, 0.007235746365040541, 0.006817822344601154, 0.007315584924072027, 0.06932955980300903, 0.0036040106788277626, -0.037197984755039215, 0.030070718377828598, -0.029569348320364952, -0.025515081360936165, -0.09291030466556549, -0.0986272469162941, -0.07004532963037491, 0.015595418401062489, -0.02322947233915329, 0.01711798645555973, 0.036139052361249924, -0.038860879838466644, 0.024883516132831573, 0.03418809920549393, 0.055096328258514404, -0.00046160907368175685, -0.03991597518324852, 0.0058678872883319855, 0.025521066039800644, -0.012790082953870296, -0.01651507429778576, 0.008075122721493244, -0.0053837778978049755, -0.027018077671527863, -0.00482944818213582, 0.01999715156853199, -0.022535692900419235, -0.04439414665102959, 0.02693517506122589, -0.013638881035149097, -0.014185147359967232, -0.031146381050348282, 0.027695469558238983, 0.0992482453584671, 0.02785314992070198, 0.017794854938983917, -0.006139092613011599, 0.035725969821214676, -0.020409051328897476, -0.07033220678567886, 0.05854203552007675, 0.043581273406744, 0.02616514079272747, 0.037612996995449066, -0.05056024715304375, -0.009207981638610363, -0.00838975515216589, 0.006424972787499428, 0.002605302259325981, -0.025248369202017784, -0.06047268956899643, -0.054694727063179016, -0.011079049669206142, 0.0017655243864282966, -0.036986976861953735, 0.022899102419614792, -0.07738444209098816, -0.031467076390981674, -0.05727444589138031, 0.032373588532209396, -0.012598280794918537, -0.02181427739560604, -0.08106880635023117, -0.010916046798229218, -0.0028129061684012413, 0.045804012566804886, -0.039681293070316315, -0.04192957654595375, -0.03051157481968403, -0.03576713055372238, -0.0309685580432415, 0.00367140700109303, 0.03900071233510971, -0.05740433558821678, 0.018457872793078423, -0.0035229637287557125, 0.0602911151945591, 0.0341111496090889, -0.024100199341773987, 0.004718034528195858, 0.014704881235957146, -0.053458791226148605, 0.035086505115032196, -0.032565779983997345, -0.0006607005489058793, 0.018538128584623337, -0.03129073604941368, -0.015958435833454132, 0.005808302201330662, -0.009812052361667156, -0.058314044028520584, 0.013890117406845093, 0.007402310147881508, -0.036594558507204056, 0.0379980243742466, 0.005939560476690531, -0.055216386914253235, -0.00806385651230812, 0.07048213481903076, -0.025250358507037163, -0.00924693327397108, -0.03203795850276947, -0.001524604856967926, 0.017035990953445435, 0.03827472776174545, 0.0020991347264498472, -0.0350036658346653, -0.08372633159160614, 0.0014539280673488975, -0.022970756515860558, -0.02408084273338318, -0.006698341108858585, 0.011827072128653526, -0.005781443323940039, -0.0005837721400894225, 0.07065004110336304, -0.014361266978085041, -0.03873274847865105, 0.054890502244234085, 0.02774069271981716, -0.04155160114169121, 0.08072367310523987, 0.013195051811635494, -0.04921647533774376, 0.016678502783179283, -0.04483542591333389, 0.024630839005112648, -0.03724515810608864, -0.047633931040763855, -0.022072937339544296, 0.01621750369668007, -0.005367867648601532, 0.030623706057667732, -0.02090233750641346, -0.01260590460151434, -0.01698044128715992, -0.029705630615353584, -0.001567023922689259, 0.07870052754878998, -0.002734582405537367, 0.013867060653865337, 0.02143457904458046, -0.0186367966234684, -0.01735943928360939, 0.04142975062131882, 0.006060250103473663, -0.01922733709216118, -0.07195867598056793, 0.08777186274528503, -0.08057482540607452, -0.023855149745941162, -0.006464838515967131, 0.03780495002865791, 0.010284962132573128, 0.007404537871479988, 0.005547541659325361, 0.0019181681564077735, 0.06733422726392746, 0.03788486868143082, 0.02869037166237831, 0.018176892772316933, 0.021941913291811943, 0.09803573787212372, 0.0023134462535381317, 0.019926518201828003, 0.027475662529468536, 0.04090613126754761, 0.00797457154840231, 0.025809379294514656, 0.009299145080149174, 0.01155533455312252, -0.014704053290188313, -0.07715152949094772, 0.0038235255051404238, 0.06836915761232376, -0.013856569305062294, -0.03895385190844536, 0.006070112343877554, 0.040340207517147064, -0.021486658602952957, -0.03247053548693657, -0.021602412685751915, 0.026298798620700836, 0.054783083498477936, 0.001996181905269623, -0.019022230058908463, 0.0873132273554802, -0.01771639846265316, -0.0819641724228859, -0.030428603291511536, -0.03643256798386574, -0.019282065331935883, -0.06459163129329681, 0.004373382776975632, -0.04127255454659462, -0.009123635478317738, -0.02311328612267971, -0.03192265331745148, -0.0008892954792827368, 0.008772280067205429, -0.038657642900943756, 0.026368465274572372, -0.001641922863200307, -0.042937662452459335, -0.004172318149358034, -0.014604625292122364, -0.029547251760959625, -0.022150808945298195, -0.01272833812981844, -0.002419747645035386, -0.0003557907184585929, 0.03489629551768303, -0.048176489770412445, -0.028209028765559196, -0.041486095637083054, -0.04018326848745346, -0.015932198613882065, 0.049449238926172256, -0.0033301394432783127, 0.009789747186005116, 0.055628702044487, -0.020735222846269608, 0.027256503701210022, 0.018444139510393143, -0.018806999549269676, -0.045638784766197205, -0.009796341881155968, -0.037592921406030655, -0.01575804501771927, -0.009667245671153069, -0.028945118188858032, 0.03543329983949661, 0.019679518416523933, 0.010769287124276161, 0.04288860782980919, 0.004900604020804167, 0.05374201759696007, 0.018364954739809036, 0.01023941207677126, -0.048573270440101624, 0.056273482739925385, 0.038798704743385315, 0.032586269080638885, -0.004121694713830948, 0.010884887538850307, 0.04451162740588188, 0.013116998597979546, -0.059163447469472885, 0.018178623169660568, -0.00020340739865787327, -0.03349379822611809, -0.02317337691783905, 0.03426985442638397, 0.05438438802957535, 0.0427696630358696, 0.03213650360703468, 0.07645948976278305, 0.004628499038517475, 0.005067895632237196, -0.05172737315297127, 0.025104571133852005, -0.013482335023581982, -0.07013050466775894, -0.06017441302537918, -0.027743790298700333, 0.036674678325653076, 0.031859107315540314, -0.031606294214725494, 0.006808770354837179, -0.013122132048010826, 0.012723181396722794, -0.014519673772156239, 0.021250398829579353, 0.030791006982326508, 0.028247935697436333, 0.06800297647714615, -0.002445125486701727, -0.0009299838566221297, 0.017387080937623978, -0.03614195063710213, -0.053219374269247055, 0.06311263144016266, 0.04938475415110588, -0.0017374259186908603, -0.020930305123329163, -0.0013945016544312239, 0.016476916149258614, 0.046584971249103546, -0.018681194633245468, 0.00978439673781395, -0.023419301956892014, -0.04886434227228165, -0.04564526677131653, 0.013424268923699856, 0.005417142994701862, -0.027045054361224174, -0.001556274713948369, 0.03728828579187393, -0.03330281376838684, 0.0099712572991848, 0.015758497640490532, -0.08203946053981781, -0.009080211631953716, -0.014540343545377254, 0.03706099092960358, -0.001718671410344541, -0.040103569626808167, -0.012635286897420883, 0.002292601391673088, -0.02915964275598526, 0.06294169276952744, -0.004420697223395109, 0.020205039530992508, 0.02019323594868183, -0.006679167505353689, -0.04030686989426613, 0.09350927174091339, -0.12665295600891113, 0.041245236992836, 0.048111651092767715, 0.014150899834930897, -0.05523158982396126, -0.048094239085912704, -0.04060409963130951, -0.009268850088119507, -0.04293686896562576, -0.04002644494175911, 0.025609493255615234, -0.0005309726111590862, 0.023778187111020088, -0.038456980139017105, -0.005010929889976978, -0.007852146402001381, -0.016957463696599007, -0.039072487503290176, -0.023430973291397095, 0.008290398865938187, 0.06174071133136749, 0.03009360283613205, -0.014418091624975204, 0.06638187915086746, 0.005330647341907024, 0.06322512775659561, -0.054473526775836945, 0.019827526062726974, -0.027773413807153702, -0.03398200124502182, 0.015065494924783707, 0.008401621133089066, 0.04098530113697052, 0.03495156392455101, -0.03162559121847153, -0.07017698884010315, -0.0012097429716959596, -0.002101308200508356, 0.010622247122228146, 0.001475495402701199, -0.07317840307950974, -0.040340621024370193, 0.02604590728878975, 0.058836065232753754, -0.008940160274505615, 0.01088839489966631, -0.008225791156291962, -0.0023669241927564144, -0.022025929763913155, 0.03866323083639145, -0.025130780413746834, 0.05463780462741852, 0.027010800316929817, -0.04928945004940033, -0.0293348990380764, -0.021119223907589912, -0.04506779462099075, -0.032578859478235245, 0.002820368157699704, -0.011207043193280697, -0.004769444465637207, -0.005951852537691593, 0.0426233746111393, 0.03878729045391083, 0.03605002164840698, -0.016967138275504112, 0.015758348628878593, 0.028523599728941917, -0.01134040392935276, 0.002135226735845208, 0.017057262361049652, -0.0038305940106511116, -0.0012919055297970772, -0.0370962917804718, -0.01146156620234251, -0.011898365803062916, 0.026294507086277008, 0.038794901221990585, 0.0005747500690631568, -0.03708212077617645, 0.006455080583691597, -0.04093575477600098, -0.04123909771442413, 0.02913832664489746, -0.0025840981397777796, 0.004546083509922028, 0.027812518179416656, -0.007128517609089613, -0.011188779957592487, -0.018283337354660034, 0.07703927159309387, -0.004744166973978281, 0.0003816727548837662, 0.028456995263695717, 0.03665315732359886, -0.03802121803164482, 0.03680819272994995, -0.009642418473958969, 0.03673845902085304, -0.1013985350728035, 0.06546100229024887, 0.014709925279021263, -0.010827749036252499, 0.03707215189933777, -0.011285739950835705, 0.026053303852677345, -0.0009126386721618474, 0.01005892176181078, 0.009467198513448238, 0.009532961994409561, 0.024736672639846802, -0.031698115170001984, 0.044356003403663635, 0.026741813868284225, 0.007551129907369614, 0.01838960126042366, 0.00342574343085289, -0.041913870722055435, -0.02802242338657379, -0.022837014868855476, -0.024373508989810944, -0.028173675760626793, 0.032614074647426605, 0.08216477930545807, 0.05693254619836807, -0.008267047815024853, 0.0643966794013977, 0.0018393946811556816, -0.006042387802153826, -0.01269615814089775, -0.007065897807478905, -0.03333139792084694, 0.027953293174505234, 0.018881604075431824, 0.017620133236050606, -0.017179466784000397, -0.03028740920126438, 0.005347066093236208, -0.010964340530335903, 0.08439622074365616, -0.014752721413969994, 0.010420707985758781, 0.006062985863536596, 0.02848717011511326, 0.02020256221294403, -0.027265096083283424, -0.005800649989396334, 0.006496062967926264, 0.025107815861701965, 0.034584298729896545, 0.026412218809127808, -0.05389724299311638, 0.04729234427213669, 0.0011270743561908603, -0.05756170302629471, 0.03807871416211128, -0.0373547188937664, -0.054710086435079575, -0.07504203170537949, 0.01940940134227276, -0.013319585472345352, 0.021585680544376373, 0.075865238904953, 0.03301381692290306, 0.027080988511443138, 0.009011735208332539, -0.008942206390202045, -0.08351796865463257, 0.0038542523980140686, 0.022848259657621384, 0.005025764461606741, 0.043392207473516464, 0.030919965356588364, 0.01673777587711811, 0.017140323296189308, 0.046619515866041183, 0.047164589166641235, 0.06650825589895248, 0.011003492400050163, -0.045749299228191376, -0.038810551166534424, -0.006663764361292124, 0.02149905450642109, -0.06894846260547638, -0.02682669088244438, 0.06166120246052742, 0.02358800545334816, -0.0037919003516435623, -0.028454627841711044, -0.02753213420510292, 0.03391133248806, -0.008654177188873291, -0.053954582661390305, 0.039988432079553604, -0.028606390580534935, -0.024831729009747505, 0.028416205197572708, -0.052384115755558014, -0.0038653381634503603, 0.011301880702376366, 0.0031137042678892612, 0.015314403921365738, -0.05016651004552841, -0.01398355234414339, -0.03680919483304024, 0.018637914210557938, 0.030280090868473053, 0.00008906886068871245, 0.024780167266726494, -0.005381172988563776, -0.022719992324709892, -0.014154721982777119, 0.026926785707473755, -0.0015344921266660094, -0.01391430664807558, 0.030297085642814636, 0.05616608262062073, -0.06879960745573044, -0.018501685932278633, 0.04449889808893204, 0.04686315357685089, -0.010458773002028465, -0.020760687068104744, -0.020924804732203484, 0.01200343668460846, 0.08958026766777039, 0.025046249851584435, -0.04874323308467865, -0.04514116421341896, 0.04667827486991882, 0.016618015244603157, -0.0011376987677067518, 0.037407491356134415, 0.02002764865756035, -0.01104640495032072, -0.010380523279309273, 0.006699456833302975, -0.016677577048540115, -0.024516934528946877, 0.010674934834241867, 0.06415174901485443, 0.039424434304237366, 0.011404521763324738, -0.03792005777359009, -0.02437949925661087, 0.018975889310240746, -0.01984333246946335, -0.04419959709048271, 0.03826954960823059, 0.012916586361825466, 0.025281842797994614, 0.02007589116692543, -0.035175811499357224, -0.021465789526700974, -0.06341597437858582, -0.015014381147921085, -0.0009835539385676384, 0.04309988394379616, -0.07423003017902374, 0.0031277257949113846, -0.023942388594150543, 0.03680868819355965, -0.04826373606920242, -0.024212563410401344, 0.04318573325872421, -0.01800815388560295, 0.0032108468003571033, -0.026718582957983017, -0.014173896983265877, 0.039822038263082504, -0.003830076428130269, -0.019007176160812378, -0.021148119121789932, -0.01625811867415905, -0.019693151116371155, -0.02610395848751068, 0.035099927335977554, 0.05492605268955231, 0.05364329367876053, 0.006020694505423307, -0.044657859951257706, 0.0030287993140518665, 0.0305924154818058, 0.04065327346324921, 0.043556809425354004, -0.03188860043883324, 0.004713502246886492, -0.03553225100040436, 0.0013891465496271849, 0.0594078004360199, 0.07642122358083725, -0.08039792627096176, 0.017778033390641212, 0.06933396309614182, -0.04017491638660431, -0.0015288519207388163, -0.03518994525074959, 0.06312426179647446, 0.01375595573335886, 0.0022705018054693937, 0.05545446649193764, 0.045925673097372055, -0.04589913412928581, 0.028446264564990997, 0.05462014675140381, -0.0259824451059103, -0.04545463249087334, 0.052498433738946915, -0.006449478212743998, -0.008568395860493183, -0.01705217733979225, 0.02497728541493416, 0.08316671848297119, -0.01569131202995777, -0.040857065469026566, 0.01044771634042263, 0.010419286787509918, -0.004363111685961485, -0.007924159057438374, 0.021794898435473442, 0.03402496874332428, 0.023433400318026543, -0.009917122311890125, 0.027313288301229477, -0.025138333439826965, -0.02155938558280468, -0.08691038936376572, 0.009561874903738499, -0.0053512174636125565, 0.00015397385868709534, 0.03766295686364174, 0.022839380428195, -0.003769724164158106, -0.027110885828733444, -0.0864516869187355, -0.010984157212078571, -0.019329629838466644, -0.026355892419815063, -0.004681230988353491, 0.0010518769267946482, -0.0007051907596178353, 0.009979545138776302, 0.00251689157448709, -0.0574549101293087, -0.03076726570725441, -0.030348150059580803, -0.03078519180417061, -0.02659958228468895, -0.05042504519224167, 0.06160400062799454, -0.003950861282646656, -0.09122217446565628, -0.0409412607550621, 0.07397329062223434, 0.029864966869354248, -0.026609983295202255, 0.03677532449364662, 0.0740337148308754, -0.05836710333824158, 0.010109717957675457, 0.04373735561966896, -0.04256846010684967, 0.04539342224597931, 0.04810160771012306, 0.03350003436207771, 0.07854428142309189, -0.030809659510850906, -0.004866281524300575, -0.02929113432765007, 0.04280802607536316, 0.01688014343380928, -0.033811088651418686, 0.055059246718883514, -0.03311425447463989, -0.050478722900152206, 0.032499659806489944, -0.010622979141771793, 0.009230383671820164, 0.03069881722331047, 0.04235978424549103, -0.022588316351175308, -0.014473940245807171, 0.005204278510063887, 0.0003655895416159183, 0.00597293209284544, 0.051656536757946014, -0.06234792247414589, 0.03527609258890152, -0.06474726647138596, -0.03684602305293083, -0.09528356790542603, -0.04586181417107582, 0.06203014403581619, 0.004974476061761379, -0.0044691250659525394, -0.038648512214422226, -0.0008268625824712217, -0.0755530521273613, -0.003333435393869877, 0.007995912805199623, 0.05456176772713661, 0.008864132687449455, 0.02067130245268345, 0.03947087377309799, 0.0108074601739645, 0.002089844550937414, 0.001926734228618443, 0.0010023562936112285, -0.003561722580343485, -0.011650622822344303, -0.017512649297714233, -0.020811038091778755, 0.021366270259022713, 0.037346210330724716, -0.019420649856328964, -0.06599920988082886, 0.011259342543780804, -0.009269381873309612, 0.04367911070585251, 0.019285161048173904, -0.0703636184334755, -0.011562773957848549, -0.01116076298058033, 0.012956647202372551, -0.05740144103765488, -0.008750242181122303, 0.021838435903191566, 0.0017199330031871796, 0.03828686475753784, 0.03754507750272751, -0.027347605675458908, -0.022912632673978806, -0.036212626844644547 ]
<p>If I had a semi infinite, 1-D object and a finite 1-D object, both heated at the same constant rate at one end each for the same time period and both begin at the same initial temperature, is it physically meaningful for me to integrate along the length of the object and consider this integral as a function of time and a measure of the 'amount' of heat on the object?</p>
g1631
[ 0.04137648269534111, -0.005754496436566114, 0.014452197588980198, -0.06870443373918533, 0.014575774781405926, 0.0021973811089992523, 0.014880537986755371, 0.029519541189074516, -0.06905811280012131, 0.00211695465259254, -0.059184279292821884, -0.0012219689087942243, -0.01693747006356716, 0.022935807704925537, 0.004482082556933165, -0.01940390281379223, 0.01865510642528534, -0.027923863381147385, -0.015759142115712166, 0.06693389266729355, 0.03628716245293617, 0.026020977646112442, 0.02820754237473011, -0.0054306406527757645, -0.007334527093917131, -0.06425632536411285, 0.03398090973496437, -0.015079759061336517, -0.005002146121114492, -0.056993260979652405, 0.021810948848724365, 0.014424839988350868, 0.009083664044737816, -0.010277633555233479, -0.04489165171980858, -0.033548541367053986, 0.010527796112000942, -0.027441658079624176, 0.011892247013747692, -0.02470269612967968, 0.022039445117115974, 0.011867222376167774, 0.04685142636299133, 0.03356609120965004, 0.03603528439998627, 0.049837470054626465, -0.03359159454703331, 0.0319615863263607, 0.043868619948625565, 0.02164158970117569, 0.036660145968198776, 0.054499465972185135, -0.004033422563225031, -0.02786445990204811, 0.008659117855131626, 0.037717852741479874, 0.06353992968797684, -0.013013482093811035, 0.0034103626385331154, 0.07131271809339523, 0.06222493201494217, -0.019662486389279366, -0.05259959027171135, -0.05875956267118454, 0.0793537124991417, 0.02863761968910694, -0.009654243476688862, 0.0012869263300672174, -0.041519612073898315, 0.03553633764386177, 0.010808025486767292, -0.010396735742688179, 0.022051779553294182, 0.009310266003012657, -0.02636449970304966, 0.026951387524604797, 0.07622876763343811, -0.002592235803604126, -0.0023791140411049128, 0.002545228460803628, -0.05801578611135483, -0.020279215648770332, 0.0500493161380291, 0.03570348769426346, 0.03850652649998665, -0.0036230129189789295, 0.009952293708920479, -0.024817803874611855, -0.07981684058904648, 0.03959526866674423, -0.0012287227436900139, 0.0017614056123420596, 0.027060408145189285, 0.05093811824917793, 0.020127423107624054, -0.06652837246656418, -0.029094424098730087, 0.025868579745292664, -0.03245318681001663, 0.0453808456659317, -0.027225330471992493, 0.075861357152462, 0.002092745155096054, 0.0028433885890990496, -0.004635922610759735, -0.0021479972638189793, -0.024313198402523994, 0.014663721434772015, -0.038584936410188675, -0.022277668118476868, 0.013853104785084724, -0.06268060207366943, -0.06698290258646011, -0.012017565779387951, -0.003391530830413103, 0.006223655771464109, 0.03829998895525932, 0.013081366196274757, -0.03617740795016289, 0.02305253967642784, 0.026002531871199608, 0.02491219900548458, 0.05850435048341751, 0.05310658738017082, -0.005371753592044115, 0.0060385107062757015, -0.01669997349381447, 0.027524001896381378, 0.016537044197320938, -0.005628583487123251, 0.03208686783909798, 0.053561966866254807, 0.003248012624680996, -0.014404892921447754, -0.045295748859643936, 0.04585529863834381, -0.006808822508901358, -0.004122065380215645, -0.04622172936797142, 0.058785878121852875, -0.04801132157444954, -0.08232050389051437, -0.047699637711048126, -0.049350887537002563, -0.0169491246342659, 0.10072774440050125, -0.030643654987215996, -0.04545962065458298, -0.038741059601306915, -0.029584204778075218, -0.01709093153476715, 0.1215125024318695, 0.006863417569547892, -0.018742207437753677, -0.03196807578206062, 0.02340698055922985, -0.03785375505685806, 0.018729571253061295, 0.0723315179347992, -0.04966207221150398, 0.000590068637393415, 0.054965704679489136, 0.06847329437732697, -0.02982359379529953, -0.05440644547343254, 0.04370332881808281, -0.01284733321517706, -0.046314239501953125, -0.01725202053785324, -0.04712732881307602, -0.021474536508321762, 0.03613416105508804, -0.030121492221951485, -0.019948268309235573, -0.022631797939538956, -0.02920960821211338, 0.010625896975398064, 0.028017757460474968, -0.022321831434965134, -0.033990152180194855, -0.019500648602843285, 0.010019347071647644, 0.0155611177906394, -0.0499781109392643, 0.005769478622823954, 0.0056667206808924675, 0.009891281835734844, 0.009519060142338276, -0.07786916941404343, 0.04152348265051842, -0.03730085864663124, -0.04632940515875816, -0.019701926037669182, 0.08774346858263016, -0.003413315862417221, 0.0036818678490817547, 0.02064475417137146, 0.007273622322827578, -0.08817779272794724, -0.033497028052806854, -0.005564322229474783, 0.04776554927229881, 0.09217528998851776, 0.004058530554175377, 0.016950473189353943, 0.0032653582748025656, 0.008707216940820217, 0.01481978502124548, -0.013082195073366165, -0.05974102392792702, 0.03570106625556946, -0.002254367107525468, -0.01829519122838974, 0.059759169816970825, 0.03930189833045006, -0.014946923591196537, 0.010150895453989506, 0.013538520783185959, 0.011387854814529419, -0.053625501692295074, -0.019180798903107643, 0.052957918494939804, 0.08149848133325577, -0.048250727355480194, -0.03813920170068741, -0.026639753952622414, 0.019858606159687042, -0.02286149188876152, -0.012088829651474953, 0.02088025212287903, -0.06648353487253189, 0.026664255186915398, 0.036577414721250534, -0.030619056895375252, 0.03222748264670372, 0.028699494898319244, 0.003203496802598238, 0.0075385114178061485, -0.01209876500070095, 0.008786791935563087, 0.006324498448520899, -0.05024563521146774, -0.02103758603334427, 0.02675565518438816, -0.019693145528435707, -0.020486649125814438, -0.022316157817840576, 0.010523575358092785, 0.00466801505535841, 0.017399584874510765, -0.03539491072297096, -0.0013494042214006186, -0.03829003497958183, 0.02500307373702526, -0.006164352409541607, -0.019832400605082512, -0.010465530678629875, -0.034215863794088364, -0.05468518286943436, -0.017695972695946693, 0.0242133978754282, -0.006014849524945021, 0.012789665721356869, -0.0076982066966593266, -0.04339468479156494, -0.015981554985046387, -0.010351775214076042, 0.01577679254114628, 0.027581747621297836, 0.03398306667804718, -0.011807821691036224, -0.01696385256946087, 0.03715069591999054, 0.011466758325695992, 0.04765060544013977, 0.01394470315426588, -0.004412447102367878, -0.05718099698424339, 0.058297865092754364, -0.01726067066192627, 0.023017773404717445, -0.0219833143055439, -0.07211533933877945, 0.035279590636491776, 0.0020768819376826286, -0.05911051109433174, 0.005764921195805073, 0.07403700053691864, -0.0032201779540628195, 0.01646735705435276, 0.03779415786266327, 0.06742753088474274, 0.019799834117293358, -0.01718302071094513, -0.04255127161741257, 0.036468442529439926, 0.0799512192606926, -0.032633524388074875, 0.0395217128098011, -0.011960268951952457, -0.03145136311650276, -0.037695810198783875, -0.029299959540367126, -0.023732924833893776, 0.04308711737394333, -0.02345931902527809, -0.04082457721233368, -0.03603910282254219, 0.025407932698726654, -0.05488162860274315, 0.05015634745359421, 0.060025762766599655, -0.01372538786381483, -0.010509093292057514, -0.025622496381402016, -0.013795161619782448, -0.01303069107234478, -0.005498360376805067, 0.011239376850426197, 0.021229075267910957, -0.0203100573271513, -0.05005830526351929, -0.009231789037585258, -0.023033371195197105, 0.019016999751329422, -0.019011037424206734, 0.033899471163749695, -0.05248938128352165, -0.0069869267754256725, 0.07481496781110764, -0.04581327363848686, -0.01612505316734314, -0.006843749433755875, 0.013712091371417046, -0.007956868968904018, -0.00981614738702774, -0.04087160527706146, -0.02808694913983345, 0.04698710888624191, 0.10045702755451202, -0.08804913610219955, -0.020625099539756775, -0.002381775761023164, 0.015643956139683723, 0.054850414395332336, -0.04325591027736664, -0.016585901379585266, 0.05472937226295471, 0.005273332353681326, 0.0008169696666300297, 0.0016934979939833283, -0.01968340389430523, 0.020344680175185204, -0.03481866046786308, -0.03573869168758392, 0.02546847052872181, 0.07941173017024994, 0.0768582746386528, -0.0684381052851677, 0.01755787804722786, 0.020564574748277664, 0.010876264423131943, 0.03130365535616875, -0.022259129211306572, 0.00820177048444748, -0.025661345571279526, -0.03981613367795944, 0.05333174392580986, 0.004626811482012272, 0.0021117813885211945, -0.03993812948465347, -0.0007268772460520267, -0.025744851678609848, 0.005536348093301058, 0.00834768544882536, 0.010877285152673721, 0.015770910307765007, 0.023847119882702827, -0.04052084684371948, 0.026925547048449516, 0.029321489855647087, 0.035475969314575195, 0.01067765150219202, 0.02942614257335663, 0.013577044010162354, 0.016385743394494057, -0.023656247183680534, -0.023421626538038254, 0.04056232050061226, -0.08629230409860611, 0.061329539865255356, -0.016010260209441185, -0.023684607818722725, 0.03946853056550026, 0.04201864078640938, -0.03969048336148262, -0.029404936358332634, -0.08444393426179886, 0.03491790220141411, -0.015285603702068329, 0.025587428361177444, -0.017352325841784477, 0.015361687168478966, -0.02827182598412037, -0.0034312077332288027, -0.03771103918552399, 0.06717299669981003, -0.0009652010048739612, -0.002839910564944148, -0.040918979793787, -0.04365335777401924, -0.020335223525762558, 0.04222262278199196, -0.016415895894169807, -0.0024433997459709644, -0.03153420612215996, -0.0012633176520466805, -0.03650172799825668, 0.011075538583099842, 0.006440142635256052, -0.04621284827589989, -0.007656067609786987, -0.051866620779037476, 0.02138444222509861, -0.04596101865172386, -0.004164028447121382, 0.04018200561404228, 0.027703063562512398, -0.04497798904776573, -0.07255040854215622, -0.01936245523393154, 0.030408252030611038, -0.005588310770690441, -0.004830616991966963, -0.0397978201508522, 0.026443330571055412, 0.005401053931564093, 0.05846313759684563, -0.03070784918963909, 0.035651206970214844, -0.03234635293483734, 0.01508976612240076, -0.04823876917362213, 0.010709302499890327, 0.009416795335710049, 0.01615127921104431, 0.001980094937607646, -0.12195152044296265, -0.054260216653347015, -0.04615403339266777, 0.006191547494381666, 0.05946367606520653, -0.08013028651475906, -0.025351140648126602, 0.01322376262396574, 0.02085340954363346, -0.00669525284320116, 0.028402339667081833, 0.0389399491250515, -0.06659922748804092, -0.045527826994657516, 0.04890718311071396, -0.05132010579109192, 0.0021081198938190937, -0.02402055636048317, -0.10725957155227661, 0.008759242482483387, 0.03802689537405968, -0.040352750569581985, 0.06577910482883453, 0.029917297884821892, 0.030544085428118706, 0.004173342604190111, 0.03384961932897568, 0.06169213727116585, -0.02410963363945484, 0.0001125766066252254, -0.00043208530405536294, 0.03776901587843895, -0.05216950923204422, -0.061442192643880844, -0.022010723128914833, 0.016329145058989525, -0.021017324179410934, -0.005099398549646139, -0.017666436731815338, -0.0832839235663414, 0.024387313053011894, 0.005358281545341015, 0.038748614490032196, 0.07974135130643845, -0.020166737958788872, 0.06146412715315819, 0.05043383687734604, -0.014859058894217014, 0.00582814821973443, 0.005961745046079159, -0.030349411070346832, 0.0320713110268116, 0.006900088395923376, -0.012719865888357162, 0.047534797340631485, -0.01578945852816105, 0.02488505281507969, -0.02366361767053604, 0.06511075794696808, 0.0057515245862305164, -0.009527845308184624, -0.05979495868086815, 0.039760760962963104, 0.05266160890460014, 0.044269103556871414, 0.019556811079382896, -0.02081438899040222, -0.010948223061859608, -0.0061589572578668594, -0.012486118823289871, -0.11036667227745056, 0.0022735409438610077, -0.005295869428664446, 0.036054592579603195, 0.008512094616889954, -0.04345160350203514, 0.0173481497913599, 0.02598283439874649, 0.009179224260151386, 0.009840612299740314, -0.04054301604628563, -0.02213944122195244, 0.05345163494348526, 0.042756859213113785, 0.03211844339966774, -0.04933101683855057, -0.024980977177619934, -0.09899444878101349, 0.015346545726060867, -0.035241734236478806, -0.005211185663938522, 0.042122140526771545, 0.00245264102704823, -0.021011795848608017, -0.02825416624546051, -0.0012350978795439005, 0.04503197222948074, -0.048804476857185364, -0.039114732295274734, 0.0334712415933609, -0.016825567930936813, 0.04243333265185356, -0.04954741895198822, 0.043121617287397385, -0.008439192548394203, 0.029374675825238228, -0.027157684788107872, 0.05270921811461449, 0.0321696400642395, 0.009836346842348576, 0.032897062599658966, 0.05234735086560249, 0.01292941253632307, 0.03598325699567795, -0.006463576573878527, 0.030680594965815544, -0.0058813816867768764, -0.029506361111998558, -0.08318129926919937, -0.00263845338486135, -0.06387951225042343, 0.03271622210741043, 0.03878842294216156, 0.03719710186123848, -0.07140902429819107, 0.010182010009884834, -0.049856435507535934, 0.0465981550514698, -0.021980103105306625, -0.04218752309679985, 0.0017545211594551802, -0.021162550896406174, -0.019989408552646637, -0.03208149969577789, 0.0006000899593345821, -0.007588377222418785, 0.030280310660600662, 0.041528914123773575, 0.025133704766631126, -0.040349025279283524, -0.04693855345249176, 0.013148273341357708, 0.007159228436648846, -0.04811835289001465, -0.04031571373343468, 0.00765281543135643, -0.03457498550415039, 0.0004371207032818347, -0.0004193134664092213, -0.0019715905655175447, -0.05466920882463455, -0.014917642809450626, 0.03863149136304855, -0.00665922649204731, -0.04048283025622368, -0.03140518069267273, -0.044835176318883896, -0.014623133465647697, 0.021255547180771828, -0.006283350754529238, -0.030002465471625328, 0.03046288527548313, -0.016056017950177193, 0.005924874451011419, 0.07729873061180115, 0.0074998498894274235, 0.000842528825160116, -0.00831236969679594, 0.0033828339073807, -0.006892889738082886, -0.06848598271608353, -0.01023987215012312, 0.0019180939998477697, 0.05726189538836479, 0.013407843187451363, -0.039644960314035416, -0.024461708962917328, 0.00867744442075491, 0.01387563906610012, -0.0656314566731453, 0.04806865006685257, 0.031828057020902634, 0.024876704439520836, -0.0004101193917449564, -0.006618276238441467, -0.01132577657699585, 0.04078740254044533, 0.03308800980448723, 0.02776559256017208, 0.019734978675842285, 0.01696065627038479, -0.007660886738449335, 0.07650149613618851, 0.003974867518991232, -0.015533410012722015, 0.027222687378525734, 0.04914005100727081, -0.04119820520281792, -0.0343235582113266, 0.03308432176709175, -0.03240087628364563, -0.06254950165748596, 0.015710819512605667, -0.009784613735973835, 0.05414356291294098, -0.0338711179792881, 0.036139003932476044, -0.008493974804878235, -0.017544547095894814, 0.0014872250612825155, -0.009240034967660904, -0.0235538762062788, 0.022194383665919304, -0.0011074363719671965, -0.019008494913578033, -0.035376910120248795, -0.03526836261153221, -0.013245979323983192, 0.04286587983369827, 0.0657360702753067, -0.033560026437044144, 0.006328640505671501, -0.06156890466809273, 0.013535055331885815, -0.010170293040573597, 0.020418183878064156, 0.03107772395014763, 0.030247975140810013, 0.04705687612295151, 0.006853713653981686, 0.0251281950622797, -0.00478123314678669, 0.03221717104315758, 0.033280543982982635, 0.014331103302538395, 0.031723905354738235, 0.04852733388543129, 0.0010394183918833733, -0.016389884054660797, 0.008184281177818775, -0.02410542219877243, 0.020166020840406418, 0.00574423698708415, -0.0589892640709877, 0.022633079439401627, 0.025423362851142883, 0.011968746781349182, 0.042059991508722305, 0.008170787245035172, 0.03603126108646393, 0.025010565295815468, 0.039166443049907684, 0.009817059151828289, 0.017620418220758438, 0.018161576241254807, 0.04090594872832298, -0.005493915174156427, -0.0028173201717436314, 0.04619298875331879, 0.005544556304812431, -0.012548783794045448, 0.022535763680934906, -0.02463678829371929, -0.0038711305242031813, 0.04947838932275772, 0.032786764204502106, 0.052152954041957855, -0.0232658963650465, -0.033986207097768784, -0.075617715716362, -0.08563732355833054, 0.009391389787197113, -0.007510568480938673, -0.005033787339925766, 0.002008020645007491, -0.007015957031399012, -0.045670151710510254, 0.03254568576812744, -0.0040071760304272175, -0.05756666883826256, -0.06913207471370697, -0.008369031362235546, 0.00014281831681728363, 0.055834248661994934, 0.009989733807742596, -0.058236878365278244, 0.025106118991971016, -0.010822603479027748, 0.024734923616051674, 0.015626979991793633, 0.03303028270602226, 0.01695908047258854, 0.012733716517686844, -0.01450712513178587, -0.06559749692678452, -0.007520820014178753, 0.011596792377531528, 0.010618002153933048, -0.014212362468242645, -0.05048706755042076, 0.012592356652021408, 0.06686612963676453, 0.01760556735098362, 0.014265336096286774, -0.010924560949206352, -0.05450429022312164, -0.004660924896597862, 0.025763923302292824, 0.01757100597023964, -0.03947673365473747, -0.008794499561190605, -0.017471816390752792, 0.051046814769506454, 0.025074059143662453, -0.028001004830002785, -0.018704844638705254, 0.00859822053462267, -0.052423667162656784, -0.02567957155406475, 0.027680957689881325, 0.004460066556930542 ]
<p>The discussion on <a href="http://www.physicsforums.com/showthread.php?t=178383" rel="nofollow">this</a> webpage mentions that shining a laser beam at a hair produces an effect like that of the double-slit experiment. Does classical physics predict the effect you observe when you do this (since light is a wave)?</p>
g1632
[ 0.028169378638267517, 0.04783114790916443, 0.01778898946940899, -0.0246097631752491, 0.025899529457092285, 0.016775641590356827, 0.045258779078722, 0.05608995631337166, 0.03896529972553253, -0.061737630516290665, -0.013517369516193867, 0.02433948777616024, 0.01907789334654808, -0.011283685453236103, 0.0040791211649775505, -0.025286735966801643, 0.058323320001363754, -0.027140971273183823, 0.03524402156472206, 0.018273230642080307, -0.09174549579620361, 0.00007053894660202786, -0.05288116633892059, -0.07880546897649765, -0.012346729636192322, 0.040064018219709396, -0.0004913380835205317, -0.001101184287108481, -0.0006643125088885427, -0.002256728010252118, -0.0003335921501275152, -0.007331699598580599, -0.01776023395359516, -0.013605273328721523, -0.0432535782456398, -0.061321958899497986, -0.016540462151169777, -0.010167299769818783, -0.04645350202918053, 0.03242725506424904, 0.009867755696177483, 0.01226435974240303, -0.03214412182569504, -0.0062599764205515385, 0.03609040752053261, -0.048986949026584625, 0.04426030442118645, -0.00688467500731349, 0.020091770216822624, 0.01316513679921627, 0.003650233382359147, 0.008970225229859352, 0.04119225963950157, 0.0565120205283165, 0.08118602633476257, 0.009755481965839863, -0.01687595620751381, -0.007537080440670252, 0.08469545841217041, -0.0024916301481425762, 0.030479051172733307, -0.011159796267747879, 0.0049880794249475, -0.028289489448070526, 0.004627353046089411, -0.033953435719013214, -0.03084445931017399, -0.026952872052788734, 0.008436555042862892, -0.004566321149468422, -0.00552892591804266, 0.001862549688667059, -0.01569867506623268, 0.008362258784472942, 0.01052902452647686, 0.0026795046869665384, 0.03647352755069733, 0.026594027876853943, -0.042665593326091766, 0.017566001042723656, -0.039988793432712555, -0.06034907326102257, -0.06386607140302658, 0.024742430076003075, -0.02653011679649353, -0.018553931266069412, -0.007731805555522442, -0.0044733453541994095, 0.008444461040198803, -0.008495822548866272, 0.010847329162061214, 0.012936677783727646, 0.050406165421009064, -0.000051800285291392356, -0.022884506732225418, -0.04609876871109009, 0.027476325631141663, 0.06916986405849457, 0.013923428021371365, 0.021926922723650932, -0.05438031256198883, -0.014743838459253311, 0.03163145110011101, 0.039826445281505585, -0.03562374785542488, -0.011800643987953663, 0.01317741721868515, -0.028362922370433807, -0.06380095332860947, 0.026749541983008385, -0.06366948783397675, -0.023532245308160782, -0.0382494181394577, -0.013521593995392323, -0.07637892663478851, -0.017766844481229782, 0.030415719375014305, -0.07430066168308258, 0.04279569163918495, 0.03763987123966217, 0.06294427812099457, 0.030567314475774765, -0.014634162187576294, 0.06562954187393188, 0.03619671240448952, 0.0046792966313660145, -0.02049480378627777, -0.02783138118684292, 0.011928880587220192, 0.01983582228422165, -0.006701750680804253, -0.014743708074092865, 0.0008953159558586776, 0.061134543269872665, 0.05363137647509575, 0.055837612599134445, 0.04446748271584511, 0.016255715861916542, 0.06130455434322357, -0.02245526947081089, 0.033967792987823486, 0.003960273694247007, -0.022044137120246887, -0.03965023159980774, -0.002066344954073429, 0.013259446248412132, -0.03887801989912987, 0.010556421242654324, 0.023640945553779602, 0.037793777883052826, -0.009526977315545082, 0.024360744282603264, -0.021561479195952415, -0.030329985544085503, 0.031046347692608833, 0.012682213447988033, 0.006262445822358131, -0.025184812024235725, -0.03811423107981682, 0.01054523978382349, 0.06831570714712143, -0.040589071810245514, 0.057220980525016785, 0.009829016402363777, -0.01771668717265129, -0.026942268013954163, 0.027337701991200447, -0.05438205227255821, 0.03319667652249336, 0.0012815181398764253, -0.018002377822995186, -0.0032471762970089912, -0.03041316382586956, 0.01988663151860237, 0.008089795708656311, 0.06241532042622566, 0.04071652889251709, -0.020845048129558563, 0.029011450707912445, -0.0057550109922885895, -0.03949497267603874, 0.02476925402879715, -0.050141021609306335, -0.06102459132671356, 0.020155230537056923, -0.0022491016425192356, 0.009078743867576122, 0.026722971349954605, -0.055712129920721054, -0.031079748645424843, -0.035178519785404205, -0.04359329864382744, 0.017276141792535782, -0.003485568566247821, -0.015215975232422352, -0.01832355372607708, -0.01246633566915989, 0.029808852821588516, -0.025270121172070503, 0.055066317319869995, -0.05148753151297569, 0.08576109260320663, -0.016925491392612457, -0.024754364043474197, -0.018469184637069702, 0.05372077599167824, -0.00012177409371361136, -0.035161249339580536, 0.016830027103424072, -0.06197843328118324, 0.04991932958364487, 0.05183497443795204, 0.03683532029390335, 0.03252003341913223, -0.005917048547416925, -0.014182466082274914, -0.03143550083041191, -0.02274487167596817, -0.03230305388569832, 0.014860152266919613, -0.07237856090068817, 0.019008733332157135, 0.011124426499009132, -0.011292771436274052, 0.04700849577784538, -0.025871070101857185, -0.047663282603025436, -0.05406147614121437, -0.0013505640672519803, 0.0067078243009746075, -0.030083108693361282, -0.011882204562425613, -0.014603424817323685, -0.02217053435742855, 0.08394932001829147, 0.040739260613918304, -0.008881427347660065, 0.03655635938048363, 0.08439069986343384, -0.004438446369022131, 0.03924587368965149, -0.040795888751745224, -0.08563131839036942, 0.010228498838841915, 0.00407427316531539, -0.03537004813551903, 0.020361071452498436, 0.012001469731330872, -0.01206317450851202, -0.026555120944976807, 0.05566994845867157, 0.03606758266687393, 0.003373919054865837, -0.010678598657250404, 0.015887048095464706, 0.02747495286166668, -0.03912762925028801, 0.06166863068938255, -0.07378441095352173, -0.0007398715242743492, -0.023340264335274696, 0.047249361872673035, -0.02953377366065979, -0.06895231455564499, 0.01992434449493885, -0.03474494442343712, 0.030665116384625435, -0.00734918424859643, -0.031120717525482178, -0.00666597718372941, 0.04058398678898811, 0.09466702491044998, -0.023431504145264626, -0.022435253486037254, 0.03807708993554115, -0.01248736772686243, -0.021856077015399933, -0.00964513048529625, 0.03742120414972305, -0.05192236602306366, -0.0564785972237587, 0.005888304673135281, -0.06520281732082367, 0.047670189291238785, 0.03970462083816528, -0.06522668153047562, 0.03122781775891781, 0.021419398486614227, 0.005917721893638372, 0.021877476945519447, -0.06136460229754448, 0.02945610322058201, 0.01944318227469921, -0.028680307790637016, -0.027628235518932343, -0.019039971753954887, 0.019866665825247765, 0.030245747417211533, -0.02441311627626419, 0.01753656566143036, -0.013132352381944656, -0.05325402319431305, 0.002236365107819438, 0.018575185909867287, 0.02345331571996212, 0.01852875016629696, -0.027919184416532516, -0.0538799948990345, 0.07966338098049164, -0.008617333136498928, -0.03756945580244064, 0.04506774619221687, 0.04849446564912796, -0.010667222552001476, -0.033657047897577286, -0.08168826997280121, -0.02890811488032341, 0.03114170953631401, 0.03390680253505707, 0.007428761571645737, 0.039310067892074585, 0.03365233540534973, 0.0322878435254097, -0.0015447861514985561, -0.000008394948054046836, -0.029961083084344864, 0.04318486899137497, -0.008171690627932549, -0.02181888557970524, 0.004097773693501949, -0.013865034095942974, 0.0002983063750434667, -0.09204067289829254, -0.028731437399983406, 0.03811532258987427, -0.05431040748953819, -0.028690282255411148, 0.030271219089627266, -0.03013654239475727, 0.06806736439466476, 0.019098132848739624, -0.04367006570100784, -0.03520562872290611, -0.034859731793403625, 0.05506281927227974, 0.02596072480082512, -0.013770298101007938, 0.015773504972457886, -0.014851574786007404, 0.007158075924962759, 0.07052713632583618, 0.00391120370477438, -0.05756556615233421, -0.05011073872447014, -0.03841385617852211, -0.0006018906715326011, 0.039099499583244324, 0.04264623299241066, 0.06451655924320221, -0.05023803189396858, -0.021916978061199188, -0.0033494012895971537, 0.012114549987018108, -0.10502994060516357, 0.010054761543869972, 0.006171770393848419, -0.010253990069031715, 0.024680962786078453, 0.027096522971987724, 0.004400042351335287, -0.04600580409169197, -0.04061725735664368, 0.0072895800694823265, 0.021032225340604782, -0.012250673025846481, 0.07896304130554199, 0.055581074208021164, -0.00543805118650198, -0.03192698210477829, 0.05703158676624298, -0.03335632383823395, 0.08040168881416321, 0.04903128743171692, 0.03146294131875038, -0.04120703041553497, -0.01693541556596756, -0.018981315195560455, -0.02695200964808464, 0.013388866558670998, -0.032558873295784, 0.001113207428716123, 0.015809278935194016, -0.03376335650682449, -0.002666423562914133, -0.02118414267897606, -0.01735144667327404, 0.04620426520705223, -0.019832074642181396, -0.049999337643384933, -0.026329131796956062, 0.04942324385046959, 0.025258859619498253, 0.01720750704407692, 0.012016844004392624, -0.04097358137369156, -0.0280145350843668, 0.04586406797170639, 0.0018641253700479865, -0.025158924981951714, 0.03200146555900574, 0.007157579530030489, 0.018907982856035233, -0.02283531241118908, -0.0476243682205677, 0.005462124943733215, 0.03317192941904068, 0.000928674649912864, -0.020127614960074425, -0.003381623886525631, 0.0163114070892334, 0.008171829394996166, 0.031382545828819275, 0.038312580436468124, 0.015882646664977074, -0.05821479856967926, 0.0078695397824049, 0.04410374537110329, -0.011468457989394665, -0.004946174565702677, -0.06970236450433731, 0.004996879026293755, 0.005534434225410223, -0.027516590431332588, -0.012562816962599754, -0.008678529411554337, 0.04957212507724762, -0.014316022396087646, 0.012213402427732944, 0.018932046368718147, 0.05184315890073776, 0.03355603665113449, -0.018702123314142227, 0.013946429826319218, -0.003771939780563116, -0.002868904499337077, 0.05708656087517738, -0.0489116795361042, -0.025672124698758125, -0.027107272297143936, -0.045347850769758224, -0.07608270645141602, -0.014045785181224346, -0.0190183874219656, -0.05159793049097061, 0.0035244342871010303, 0.0057767461985349655, -0.036069270223379135, 0.017000408843159676, 0.04099394008517265, 0.033355407416820526, -0.05211301147937775, -0.005416756495833397, 0.004240138456225395, 0.028817635029554367, 0.08969779312610626, 0.034837208688259125, -0.039593104273080826, -0.03788183629512787, -0.06538715958595276, -0.06563247740268707, -0.00007736149564152583, -0.023659320548176765, 0.019439764320850372, 0.02725263312458992, 0.01263615395873785, -0.036694154143333435, -0.03167780488729477, 0.02299744263291359, 0.03154229745268822, -0.026044528931379318, 0.0017997587565332651, -0.017483877018094063, 0.054027900099754333, -0.08414797484874725, -0.0073265996761620045, 0.005401239264756441, -0.030781039968132973, 0.054870255291461945, -0.014398683793842793, -0.030309749767184258, 0.01794360764324665, -0.010676945559680462, -0.052794430404901505, -0.046140190213918686, -0.03664201870560646, 0.025662736967206, 0.03817802295088768, -0.004202693235129118, -0.007751470897346735, 0.0321737676858902, -0.050746381282806396, 0.054229773581027985, 0.01353495940566063, 0.00010659526742529124, -0.01486570667475462, 0.023358797654509544, 0.00020783866057172418, -0.03985654190182686, 0.018317969515919685, 0.028852887451648712, -0.025352776050567627, 0.02007715217769146, 0.012712466530501842, 0.02431129850447178, 0.03355381265282631, -0.04458184912800789, -0.0014868015423417091, 0.025745194405317307, -0.031704291701316833, -0.06312131881713867, -0.01887531764805317, -0.019010255113244057, 0.016648977994918823, 0.04579105228185654, 0.02781434915959835, 0.022142857313156128, -0.04021255299448967, 0.028162455186247826, 0.01720873825252056, -0.000122587924124673, -0.03274912387132645, 0.02368466928601265, 0.003884193953126669, 0.01914287358522415, 0.061040762811899185, -0.05921319127082825, 0.049260109663009644, 0.026781782507896423, -0.044104453176259995, 0.010166147723793983, -0.012611977756023407, 0.02522183209657669, 0.06232684478163719, 0.02060038596391678, 0.02153008058667183, -0.024899207055568695, -0.004434333182871342, 0.004783269949257374, 0.040723349899053574, -0.024548940360546112, 0.008632943965494633, -0.03887757286429405, -0.005890117958188057, 0.06413102149963379, 0.06532669067382812, 0.006876369472593069, -0.002930511487647891, -0.04945995658636093, 0.011190948076546192, -0.03832525387406349, 0.046960826963186264, 0.06981046497821808, 0.036407340317964554, -0.0016561743104830384, 0.07098168134689331, 0.01172660756856203, 0.01756412535905838, -0.048361800611019135, 0.05353095009922981, 0.023197850212454796, -0.03098510392010212, -0.0039367699064314365, -0.020672092214226723, -0.03908781707286835, 0.018496224656701088, 0.035053800791502, -0.004053025506436825, -0.07502418011426926, -0.07293906807899475, -0.00130791577976197, 0.057677365839481354, -0.0043675098568201065, 0.045984864234924316, -0.005762680433690548, 0.006932375952601433, -0.00802065059542656, -0.03879868611693382, 0.04749877750873566, 0.01538512296974659, 0.04886144772171974, -0.05989336594939232, -0.021403292194008827, -0.04240187630057335, 0.004422576166689396, 0.017365245148539543, -0.029983146116137505, -0.02472081407904625, 0.04087650403380394, -0.0006420125719159842, 0.02262844145298004, 0.002785678021609783, -0.019108278676867485, 0.043371230363845825, 0.028668757528066635, 0.026915714144706726, 0.030034350231289864, -0.001886544399894774, -0.00031170874717645347, 0.030066370964050293, -0.009926196187734604, -0.04632733762264252, 0.014954549260437489, -0.023588253185153008, -0.017671095207333565, -0.01837010309100151, -0.018537277355790138, 0.008677863515913486, -0.003093344857916236, 0.062133777886629105, 0.005696290172636509, -0.010639154352247715, -0.051312822848558426, 0.04138582944869995, -0.04288613423705101, -0.011156080290675163, 0.07990124821662903, -0.06250391900539398, 0.014355162158608437, 0.0898301899433136, 0.032690804451704025, -0.015533874742686749, -0.01568663865327835, 0.016280636191368103, 0.0973353385925293, -0.038742877542972565, 0.004048318602144718, -0.02394235134124756, 0.012439889833331108, 0.03418825939297676, 0.013416680507361889, 0.05794476717710495, 0.0620223768055439, 0.06406399607658386, -0.029638756066560745, -0.034929659217596054, 0.025499818846583366, -0.026062266901135445, -0.018120374530553818, -0.028381220996379852, -0.04922397807240486, -0.06209481880068779, -0.04120955243706703, 0.027415238320827484, 0.01659809798002243, 0.053042951971292496, 0.02464163489639759, 0.04106888547539711, 0.02683062106370926, 0.018419938161969185, -0.08769157528877258, -0.03441394865512848, -0.05365610122680664, -0.022780748084187508, -0.01719135046005249, -0.0029430456925183535, -0.035983286798000336, 0.01694408431649208, -0.06016460433602333, -0.005751172546297312, 0.024213554337620735, -0.009685087017714977, -0.0555763840675354, -0.023111900314688683, 0.04764827340841293, -0.0011336469324305654, 0.00016426946967840195, -0.024928808212280273, 0.010951966978609562, -0.03994770348072052, -0.03695712238550186, -0.01243386697024107, 0.07718169689178467, 0.005906424950808287, -0.006138812284916639, -0.045984964817762375, 0.041759904474020004, -0.04142940789461136, 0.003018132410943508, -0.0031605404801666737, -0.025471901521086693, -0.019147031009197235, -0.02152343839406967, -0.023562034592032433, -0.04093283414840698, 0.009825291112065315, 0.010119701735675335, 0.11713701486587524, 0.027402110397815704, -0.00826015044003725, 0.051392752677202225, -0.05930143967270851, 0.04042162373661995, -0.021573610603809357, -0.030905386433005333, 0.03284671902656555, 0.038215767592191696, 0.01635689288377762, 0.01573389768600464, -0.012075599282979965, -0.012434175238013268, 0.005428509786725044, 0.00322618312202394, 0.011983725242316723, 0.06564132869243622, 0.036164671182632446, 0.011369851417839527, -0.014276371337473392, 0.07285068929195404, 0.038785189390182495, 0.008008766919374466, -0.004276118241250515, -0.010449220426380634, -0.048639412969350815, 0.00782871711999178, 0.0342400036752224, -0.01714695245027542, -0.01809324137866497, -0.013103585690259933, 0.01702023111283779, 0.0330771841108799, 0.05076366290450096, -0.03920680657029152, -0.04501570761203766, -0.03745099529623985, -0.013662064447999, -0.03234148398041725, 0.03359828516840935, 0.047277260571718216, 0.014533733017742634, 0.015653647482395172, 0.027917997911572456, -0.0696863904595375, -0.04570849984884262, -0.0501728318631649, 0.018539097160100937, -0.041030216962099075, 0.010996636003255844, -0.0029956987127661705, -0.014229008927941322, 0.0009080554591491818, -0.009552218951284885, -0.009138585068285465, -0.005570818670094013, 0.05596402287483215, 0.09426182508468628, -0.05333179235458374, -0.0731886476278305, -0.0037993276491761208, 0.041088223457336426, -0.004137332551181316, -0.05354161560535431, -0.024406854063272476, -0.05225091800093651, -0.03387238830327988, -0.04352864250540733, -0.061928991228342056, 0.017119040712714195, -0.00507076270878315 ]
<p>I am trying to create a machine that moves on two points (Wheels or legs). Because of the extremely difficult nature of perfectly balancing the parts, I am wondering is there any way to create a mechanical mechanism to balance it. I know that it can be done with many different electric circuits, but I am wondering is it even theoretically possible to create such a system? And if it's possible, does anyone know of any systems that do that?</p> <p>P.S. Could someone retag this appropriately? I'm new to this SE, and I'm not sure how to tag it.</p>
g1633
[ 0.014801530167460442, 0.025363797321915627, 0.0011276941513642669, 0.027500126510858536, 0.09529992192983627, -0.018354786559939384, -0.01338110864162445, 0.007294164504855871, -0.04338885843753815, -0.018944591283798218, -0.03244950994849205, -0.035529594868421555, 0.03494234383106232, 0.011390638537704945, -0.028390804305672646, 0.03247595205903053, 0.009828721173107624, 0.03502072021365166, 0.034867919981479645, 0.058020781725645065, 0.07762185484170914, 0.024100862443447113, 0.006901415530592203, 0.0010583053808659315, 0.020060086622834206, 0.03408605232834816, -0.026727739721536636, 0.0155178876593709, 0.01495083887130022, 0.030017217621207237, -0.10996043682098389, -0.03430025652050972, -0.014279453083872795, 0.0045930673368275166, -0.052926793694496155, -0.017404671758413315, 0.02662496641278267, -0.02159242331981659, -0.09339842200279236, -0.001210119342431426, -0.011098453775048256, -0.057664841413497925, -0.04817332327365875, 0.008571031503379345, 0.03737722709774971, 0.02220434695482254, 0.0133440513163805, -0.004109539557248354, -0.028870198875665665, 0.019507596269249916, 0.005300175864249468, -0.03370805084705353, 0.013065443374216557, 0.03362394869327545, 0.0166068896651268, -0.015674013644456863, 0.04606042802333832, 0.005574447568506002, -0.026039332151412964, -0.03519774228334427, -0.07406216114759445, 0.01917644962668419, 0.034962717443704605, 0.07998053729534149, 0.0032292762771248817, 0.01025152113288641, -0.015066995285451412, -0.04030681028962135, 0.014443079009652138, 0.009466052055358887, 0.008455977775156498, -0.0038289416115731, -0.002537889638915658, -0.007617815397679806, 0.021562961861491203, 0.028095722198486328, -0.019106507301330566, 0.01680837944149971, 0.04160216823220253, 0.01527221966534853, 0.00480045797303319, -0.012725613079965115, 0.012408904731273651, 0.025418058037757874, 0.01469679269939661, -0.011122191324830055, 0.024235626682639122, 0.028244752436876297, -0.05207107588648796, 0.03964274376630783, -0.03989095985889435, -0.02012641169130802, 0.05534060299396515, -0.00282250065356493, -0.02860509417951107, -0.053137101233005524, -0.021535607054829597, 0.05440530553460121, -0.014985939487814903, -0.04676797240972519, -0.014885271899402142, 0.02608271688222885, 0.023949211463332176, -0.00483539467677474, -0.01537375245243311, -0.028597982600331306, 0.04463551566004753, -0.02592129074037075, 0.03630255162715912, -0.013067434541881084, -0.00012563998461700976, -0.04821249470114708, -0.04430307075381279, -0.01598253659904003, 0.014026712626218796, -0.00020908824808429927, 0.05377819761633873, 0.030870161950588226, 0.03148765489459038, 0.019797181710600853, 0.036040425300598145, 0.0012215502792969346, -0.06506623327732086, 0.011245961301028728, 0.02616741694509983, 0.0037081073969602585, -0.05239451676607132, -0.025965258479118347, 0.046833377331495285, -0.004972297698259354, 0.033891789615154266, 0.006057302001863718, 0.00014320122136268765, -0.032620869576931, -0.04279996082186699, 0.03560647368431091, -0.005171563941985369, -0.01685057394206524, 0.02962891198694706, -0.03356757014989853, -0.0055280630476772785, -0.03055584989488125, -0.02574918419122696, -0.01729242131114006, 0.013088573701679707, 0.06261792033910751, 0.01896241307258606, 0.018831638619303703, 0.00995001569390297, 0.01359945721924305, -0.034950438886880875, 0.036401521414518356, -0.007820858620107174, -0.034938327968120575, 0.043013058602809906, -0.003997719381004572, 0.012834352441132069, 0.033210620284080505, 0.013886217959225178, -0.05805196985602379, 0.057612765580415726, -0.03510617837309837, 0.004182565491646528, -0.04417193681001663, -0.02279508300125599, -0.003804116742685437, -0.041992686688899994, 0.04544578492641449, -0.00842882040888071, -0.0219890084117651, -0.07229536026716232, -0.013554250821471214, -0.024756984785199165, 0.08248353004455566, 0.027455490082502365, -0.009618537500500679, 0.014198464341461658, 0.0005490543553605676, 0.04625634849071503, -0.04322788864374161, -0.0349818654358387, -0.04642249643802643, -0.03610333427786827, 0.038984265178442, -0.031047923490405083, -0.05680501088500023, 0.05166012421250343, 0.0379556380212307, -0.05814611539244652, 0.012048574164509773, 0.03823208436369896, 0.04282114654779434, -0.02371019683778286, 0.013188394717872143, -0.05170237645506859, -0.009195948950946331, 0.04593851789832115, -0.054600853472948074, 0.0007713634986430407, 0.007465272210538387, 0.06926273554563522, 0.016444804146885872, -0.022781193256378174, -0.018872227519750595, 0.003726787632331252, -0.03794170916080475, 0.011250900104641914, 0.0027499969583004713, -0.030509723350405693, 0.01455796416848898, 0.01570286974310875, 0.04559583589434624, -0.022970478981733322, 0.0008523032302036881, -0.024088839069008827, -0.029648307710886, -0.004990058485418558, -0.02352180890738964, 0.019297927618026733, -0.03285537287592888, 0.002316833008080721, 0.0009728886652737856, -0.003370555816218257, 0.019779613241553307, -0.03571606054902077, -0.036265451461076736, 0.026664050295948982, -0.00015832541976124048, -0.06472483277320862, 0.013268807902932167, -0.018208671361207962, -0.0027083000168204308, 0.06531909853219986, -0.045409947633743286, 0.034788455814123154, -0.002439935924485326, -0.032515328377485275, 0.02221263013780117, -0.009247363545000553, -0.01489750575274229, 0.09641117602586746, -0.04553067311644554, -0.0004868157848250121, -0.011277750134468079, 0.0021363147534430027, -0.023216936737298965, 0.06709563732147217, 0.03294968232512474, -0.018733138218522072, 0.004041433800011873, 0.04947534203529358, -0.08411573618650436, -0.074071504175663, -0.05055724084377289, -0.008651865646243095, -0.039737969636917114, 0.01926085725426674, 0.03726022318005562, -0.012587850913405418, 0.019485054537653923, 0.04086511954665184, -0.011091997846961021, 0.0296036247164011, 0.019255319610238075, -0.015565277077257633, -0.05935902148485184, 0.031102502718567848, -0.12314292043447495, 0.009562434628605843, 0.07399354875087738, -0.04690174013376236, -0.01665566861629486, 0.01513935811817646, 0.05873727425932884, -0.035218119621276855, -0.08779352903366089, 0.0057180533185601234, -0.03499438241124153, 0.016981229186058044, 0.08161022514104843, 0.06497940421104431, -0.05267468839883804, 0.011642451398074627, -0.0005104236770421267, 0.029072800651192665, 0.002754123182967305, 0.019505470991134644, 0.003122774651274085, -0.04003027454018593, 0.044155918061733246, -0.04751382768154144, -0.02909642644226551, 0.039480485022068024, -0.029087072238326073, -0.008984963409602642, 0.0709671676158905, -0.04322831705212593, -0.014475364238023758, -0.04740604758262634, -0.030957408249378204, -0.009553492069244385, -0.02980649285018444, 0.00005424979099188931, 0.005265079438686371, 0.01918456330895424, 0.06512489914894104, 0.0033354233019053936, 0.06812245398759842, 0.06580871343612671, 0.02879924140870571, -0.00596538046374917, 0.04721042141318321, 0.019940121099352837, -0.02106974646449089, -0.0670018196105957, 0.04815249890089035, -0.010801674798130989, -0.03384983539581299, -0.013757460750639439, -0.012720535509288311, 0.02672225795686245, -0.0587272085249424, -0.0007041046628728509, -0.01724272035062313, 0.0905037373304367, 0.09874679893255234, -0.04385015740990639, 0.05254053696990013, -0.05660295858979225, -0.010946688242256641, 0.05308049917221069, 0.010346144437789917, -0.01987340860068798, -0.01786685734987259, -0.039462942630052567, 0.004031691700220108, -0.01316599827259779, -0.01611969619989395, 0.09141978621482849, 0.0036452312488108873, -0.014395630918443203, 0.028435606509447098, -0.02989385463297367, -0.058512501418590546, 0.00841840635985136, 0.02986834943294525, 0.0018020732095465064, 0.033100686967372894, 0.03836967051029205, -0.02485356479883194, 0.02721467614173889, -0.012570803984999657, 0.03407847508788109, 0.0019531046273186803, 0.02190134860575199, -0.024483773857355118, -0.008219587616622448, 0.023770155385136604, -0.05883840098977089, -0.0050707049667835236, -0.04761185124516487, -0.012074035592377186, -0.022758724167943, -0.015142066404223442, 0.04591718688607216, -0.00024939817376434803, -0.021817678585648537, 0.01669527217745781, -0.0009819655679166317, -0.021465325728058815, 0.027067061513662338, -0.057821985334157944, 0.004452909808605909, -0.028069566935300827, 0.025437790900468826, -0.02868538349866867, 0.1019132137298584, 0.023087669163942337, -0.08402667194604874, 0.04518401622772217, -0.0023404506500810385, 0.040947526693344116, 0.0030125039629638195, 0.029384424909949303, -0.00809457153081894, 0.005551392212510109, -0.03973656892776489, 0.037498556077480316, 0.05398903042078018, 0.0596315860748291, -0.017851276323199272, -0.0841875821352005, -0.06103125959634781, -0.04467012733221054, 0.08030467480421066, 0.05904889106750488, -0.04300029203295708, -0.07004085928201675, 0.009471699595451355, 0.02655958943068981, 0.04700843244791031, 0.08560614287853241, -0.02165558934211731, 0.0577486976981163, -0.027470706030726433, -0.002992443274706602, -0.0011974751250818372, -0.0025535349268466234, 0.022539852187037468, 0.003149493597447872, -0.005341520067304373, -0.009362919256091118, 0.01443159393966198, -0.04410738870501518, -0.008386134169995785, 0.01649167388677597, -0.030142011120915413, -0.004660616163164377, 0.06316308677196503, -0.004457073751837015, -0.015074671246111393, 0.06753583252429962, 0.04769846051931381, 0.0005681234179064631, -0.02622804045677185, 0.032653145492076874, -0.023001527413725853, -0.08594796806573868, 0.012727250345051289, -0.027369143441319466, -0.017889197915792465, 0.006131596863269806, 0.004931073170155287, 0.02881469950079918, 0.03898138925433159, 0.021261589601635933, -0.04343714565038681, -0.017163271084427834, -0.0005019255913794041, 0.0312246922403574, 0.047406453639268875, -0.04795432463288307, 0.00578415859490633, 0.02657351642847061, -0.023512033745646477, 0.011772961355745792, -0.08630411326885223, -0.04293106123805046, -0.07618105411529541, -0.02826598659157753, -0.005970674566924572, 0.01847822591662407, -0.0048764972016215324, 0.02170250006020069, -0.06832030415534973, 0.0032006532419472933, -0.03456650301814079, 0.019764693453907967, 0.00040990792331285775, 0.0076062059961259365, -0.03785695135593414, -0.07316812872886658, -0.007699672132730484, -0.007708475925028324, -0.002727888524532318, 0.027506908401846886, 0.0031511904671788216, -0.011501500383019447, -0.07870760560035706, -0.03368140384554863, 0.028163092210888863, 0.03079681098461151, -0.0020449215080589056, 0.08259808272123337, 0.02614487148821354, -0.033013422042131424, -0.027663741260766983, -0.022296756505966187, -0.017381081357598305, 0.0018484654137864709, -0.0281036626547575, -0.03827980160713196, 0.0023154201917350292, -0.047323111444711685, 0.01132228970527649, -0.008662430569529533, -0.00198220438323915, 0.021622521802783012, 0.013851094990968704, -0.014731831848621368, -0.00927963200956583, 0.03232055902481079, 0.0005676521686837077, -0.02873998135328293, 0.028497610241174698, -0.028534626588225365, -0.02705991268157959, -0.027949687093496323, -0.048721082508563995, -0.0017909407615661621, 0.007947292178869247, 0.02506345696747303, -0.008849062956869602, 0.0042621782049536705, 0.048789918422698975, -0.021770959720015526, -0.022069687023758888, -0.026732800528407097, 0.0024010424967855215, 0.016062268987298012, -0.006049622781574726, 0.035606998950242996, -0.03437826409935951, 0.03573133796453476, 0.012273984029889107, 0.02848670445382595, 0.032249610871076584, -0.03417012095451355, -0.00803811103105545, -0.048471469432115555, 0.025449272245168686, -0.016517404466867447, 0.030439814552664757, -0.000868543516844511, -0.05775114893913269, 0.00012125608191126958, -0.03639178350567818, 0.012640606611967087, -0.002805904019623995, 0.06770360469818115, 0.010205196216702461, -0.0714871734380722, 0.03578827530145645, -0.02217002958059311, -0.0636671632528305, -0.025242898613214493, 0.012784954160451889, 0.03830944746732712, 0.03828819468617439, 0.02878308668732643, 0.0136260362342, -0.03792629763484001, 0.011905292049050331, 0.06042313575744629, 0.025975635275244713, -0.036275714635849, -0.06591681391000748, -0.009857749566435814, 0.02055198885500431, -0.016423173248767853, -0.021160254254937172, 0.04127524793148041, 0.006477700546383858, 0.01666860096156597, -0.030778098851442337, 0.052700016647577286, -0.08737955242395401, -0.03176803141832352, -0.005143588874489069, -0.05420250818133354, 0.02209799364209175, 0.04815443232655525, 0.03987050801515579, 0.04072001948952675, -0.025986433029174805, 0.05327833071351051, -0.0525282621383667, 0.0251887459307909, 0.04362237825989723, 0.0458991639316082, 0.029594628140330315, 0.001786322332918644, -0.029071426019072533, 0.03218884393572807, -0.017507994547486305, -0.028959807008504868, -0.03638270124793053, 0.013417206704616547, -0.04712393507361412, 0.017423121258616447, -0.010748292319476604, 0.06012262403964996, -0.05538244545459747, 0.02972329780459404, -0.0594780258834362, 0.014963855035603046, -0.028831426054239273, -0.0017804515082389116, 0.015069467946887016, 0.02643405832350254, 0.002196159679442644, 0.017075350508093834, -0.07192182540893555, -0.022728048264980316, 0.06634094566106796, 0.0021722689270973206, -0.04819049686193466, 0.008053970523178577, 0.040483955293893814, 0.04477249085903168, 0.06001445651054382, -0.015383122488856316, -0.03945263475179672, 0.014004578813910484, -0.05653797462582588, 0.06128358468413353, -0.0316094271838665, 0.03640355169773102, 0.00458806287497282, -0.021724902093410492, -0.043662093579769135, 0.0029265626799315214, -0.00719517283141613, 0.01788169890642166, 0.012160840444266796, 0.031060853973031044, 0.02742673084139824, -0.010972606018185616, -0.026189349591732025, -0.01774561032652855, 0.002792471321299672, -0.02933783456683159, -0.02932099811732769, -0.0576295480132103, -0.03438624367117882, -0.03351033478975296, 0.007231113035231829, 0.01843866892158985, 0.09646876901388168, 0.013131044805049896, 0.014368655160069466, -0.008320244960486889, -0.02311904914677143, 0.07516966015100479, 0.05267268046736717, 0.02860436774790287, -0.026730850338935852, -0.008009360171854496, 0.09572240710258484, 0.035384029150009155, -0.03299765661358833, 0.03545304760336876, -0.016155395656824112, 0.055352773517370224, -0.020855030044913292, -0.006744110491126776, 0.04502575099468231, -0.0036732570733875036, -0.006014576647430658, -0.007291225716471672, -0.012271669693291187, -0.005511314142495394, -0.023436596617102623, -0.0030032158829271793, -0.03119322657585144, 0.01190306805074215, 0.006593767087906599, -0.02044566161930561, 0.03408360481262207, -0.051098357886075974, 0.013868712820112705, 0.0022833377588540316, 0.04580787941813469, -0.03998536616563797, 0.001130795106291771, 0.009586002677679062, -0.032537948340177536, 0.048422712832689285, -0.05507775768637657, 0.029403598979115486, 0.008695610798895359, -0.007420804817229509, 0.01372083555907011, 0.0522337332367897, -0.01665627211332321, -0.061005156487226486, 0.0431482158601284, 0.004215982276946306, 0.007268726825714111, -0.06603372097015381, 0.008925551548600197, -0.039289526641368866, -0.022816229611635208, -0.018688376992940903, -0.016545740887522697, -0.001411114470101893, 0.02616414614021778, 0.06472846120595932, 0.020089145749807358, -0.02901546284556389, 0.05980421602725983, 0.022824591025710106, -0.018148329108953476, -0.03499402105808258, -0.04585927724838257, 0.044199466705322266, 0.01949622482061386, 0.04459581524133682, 0.011200104840099812, -0.006814981810748577, -0.004426985047757626, -0.009457443840801716, 0.001502961735241115, 0.06429086625576019, 0.029336877167224884, 0.010024421848356724, -0.05208659917116165, -0.012986063957214355, -0.034068431705236435, 0.015456974506378174, 0.006529523525387049, 0.037195030599832535, -0.047600239515304565, 0.011347443796694279, -0.022802116349339485, -0.043588895350694656, 0.0200215931981802, 0.08583531528711319, -0.023969387635588646, 0.1037762388586998, 0.0012453566305339336, -0.0061775450594723225, 0.014918049797415733, -0.06472758948802948, -0.03542522341012955, -0.015123710036277771, 0.07209839671850204, -0.00914720818400383, -0.002876435173675418, 0.06284474581480026, 0.06299885362386703, -0.0031530605629086494, -0.025100387632846832, 0.01042281836271286, -0.005787086673080921, -0.026713915169239044, -0.04681115224957466, -0.024043025448918343, -0.031657155603170395, -0.012078853324055672, -0.03937657177448273, -0.07848893105983734, 0.01613546535372734, -0.05541560426354408, -0.0103684077039361, -0.006137664895504713, -0.010132255963981152, 0.049775272607803345, 0.03611081466078758, 0.00787432212382555, -0.02021060325205326, 0.017353016883134842, -0.000028164673494757153, -0.05688466131687164, 0.017038118094205856, 0.039246976375579834, -0.024695899337530136, -0.005453135352581739, -0.03554822504520416, -0.00008131867798510939, 0.02687726356089115, 0.028523754328489304, -0.004428059794008732, -0.026278257369995117, -0.04048173502087593, 0.05763227492570877, 0.01600784808397293, -0.03807889670133591 ]
<p>If you take a giant whale out of the water and put it on land for long enough, <a href="http://books.google.com/books?id=8bFcJgX0lIUC&amp;pg=PA185&amp;lpg=PA185&amp;dq=orca%20crush%20itself%20under%20its%20own%20weight&amp;source=bl&amp;ots=M0cCc-fMyD&amp;sig=gRvN795BpgGYwLIMd9GCEmbvzog&amp;hl=en&amp;sa=X&amp;ei=M36sT8SGDsqSiALp0pmwBw&amp;ved=0CJAFEOgBMAM#v=onepage&amp;q=orca%20crush%20itself%20under%20its%20own%20weight&amp;f=false" rel="nofollow">it will crush itself under its own weight</a>. Why doesn't the animal get crushed under its own weight when it's in water?</p>
g1634
[ 0.05644288659095764, 0.011564075015485287, 0.0025875067804008722, -0.06822486966848373, 0.051223017275333405, 0.04085864871740341, 0.039129700511693954, 0.008100788109004498, -0.05718960985541344, -0.015416909009218216, -0.015146865509450436, 0.03229086846113205, -0.011999211274087429, 0.02039279229938984, 0.013609729707241058, 0.019587300717830658, 0.045731958001852036, -0.047521159052848816, 0.042506348341703415, -0.013423662632703781, -0.056630026549100876, -0.014729653485119343, 0.01664748787879944, 0.030564481392502785, -0.07542575150728226, 0.015158161520957947, 0.03558317944407463, -0.015558375976979733, 0.022760335355997086, -0.018522154539823532, -0.056104518473148346, -0.007238573860377073, -0.04435252398252487, -0.08471015095710754, -0.004366565030068159, 0.006716829724609852, 0.009485160931944847, -0.03702813759446144, -0.0064131407998502254, -0.07883206009864807, -0.003313907654955983, 0.017854351550340652, -0.008815069682896137, 0.002401400124654174, -0.03724220395088196, 0.004915559198707342, -0.034051764756441116, -0.018527453765273094, -0.041330575942993164, -0.012434255331754684, 0.029522743076086044, 0.004827567841857672, -0.021741501986980438, 0.00800115242600441, 0.012726548127830029, -0.027025636285543442, 0.0341016985476017, -0.027503905817866325, -0.013154057785868645, -0.02506761997938156, -0.05326932296156883, -0.007851770147681236, -0.018396591767668724, 0.032793864607810974, 0.03566175326704979, -0.07336844503879547, -0.02550867572426796, 0.00310480035841465, 0.024313779547810555, 0.014546504244208336, 0.02300296537578106, -0.02660270221531391, -0.056481774896383286, -0.06164505332708359, -0.026464764028787613, -0.0002104184968629852, -0.00409533130005002, 0.02331290766596794, 0.032266177237033844, 0.04612210392951965, 0.05312689393758774, 0.035764046013355255, -0.01075757760554552, 0.027203228324651718, 0.017318883910775185, -0.01241481676697731, -0.0009239971404895186, -0.021760715171694756, 0.008667639456689358, 0.03815774619579315, 0.006091738119721413, -0.013161733746528625, 0.011377304792404175, 0.012826708145439625, -0.014651543460786343, -0.04621998220682144, -0.03373891860246658, 0.07319305092096329, -0.09697652608156204, -0.004186337813735008, -0.00820506364107132, 0.0016309705097228289, -0.016115758568048477, -0.023260848596692085, 0.029625725001096725, 0.006318382453173399, 0.06736911088228226, 0.032452542334795, -0.007851402275264263, -0.031950172036886215, -0.017460031434893608, -0.0008507099119015038, 0.029749657958745956, 0.023503972217440605, -0.0033904772717505693, -0.00874918419867754, 0.07028608024120331, 0.012851313687860966, 0.00804830901324749, 0.018221227452158928, 0.012768123298883438, -0.0016863247146829963, -0.06912644952535629, 0.0335342101752758, -0.008477510884404182, 0.015679996460676193, 0.03322526440024376, 0.04521550238132477, 0.010857612825930119, 0.013485225848853588, 0.03819487988948822, 0.06314727663993835, -0.036898743361234665, 0.021091768518090248, 0.012879965826869011, 0.007662668824195862, -0.04852784797549248, 0.031980063766241074, 0.004160173702985048, 0.019899532198905945, 0.014710837975144386, 0.04395721107721329, -0.026351995766162872, 0.0723794549703598, 0.003077683737501502, -0.036359380930662155, -0.036433592438697815, 0.06261593848466873, 0.015266821719706059, 0.028645679354667664, -0.018668262287974358, -0.010492726229131222, 0.021906090900301933, 0.0004663230793084949, 0.06499041616916656, 0.04540172964334488, 0.024451671168208122, 0.024647466838359833, 0.021197935566306114, 0.03720302879810333, 0.006279457826167345, 0.03198602423071861, 0.002347252331674099, 0.043726611882448196, -0.048086017370224, 0.043678492307662964, 0.000012371471711958293, 0.0033697732724249363, 0.004220249596983194, 0.04894954711198807, -0.02013394981622696, 0.03664000704884529, -0.019097907468676567, 0.07963716238737106, 0.02608475089073181, 0.03532758355140686, 0.01978379301726818, -0.0066241309978067875, 0.05074276775121689, -0.0478813461959362, 0.00338049721904099, 0.022212397307157516, -0.021041102707386017, -0.018514081835746765, 0.016412541270256042, -0.028430970385670662, 0.039099935442209244, -0.02867230959236622, -0.008058800362050533, 0.026295585557818413, -0.0062841507606208324, 0.012439198791980743, -0.03205394744873047, 0.02062901481986046, -0.02374025620520115, 0.01599067449569702, 0.03724592924118042, -0.03556780517101288, -0.06212561950087547, -0.05533909052610397, 0.06577228754758835, -0.022628458216786385, 0.024939170107245445, 0.008316011168062687, -0.05138307809829712, -0.029021980240941048, -0.01522001251578331, -0.015194193460047245, 0.034021392464637756, -0.029143117368221283, 0.02509450539946556, -0.029779966920614243, -0.009264561347663403, -0.02660220116376877, -0.01878730021417141, 0.0003841875877697021, -0.057587988674640656, 0.03571607545018196, -0.05389288440346718, -0.038901690393686295, 0.002595372963696718, 0.02262234315276146, -0.01361736748367548, 0.00672973832115531, 0.0007427908712998033, -0.008429075591266155, -0.061575572937726974, -0.011693075299263, 0.013123453594744205, 0.0034272349439561367, 0.0078496765345335, -0.05862040817737579, 0.011142131872475147, -0.0026423539966344833, -0.0045884959399700165, 0.10689476132392883, -0.007013310678303242, 0.038549114018678665, -0.020828209817409515, 0.007387720979750156, 0.015495923347771168, -0.011234110221266747, -0.029227638617157936, -0.04577014595270157, -0.0150372926145792, -0.02702808566391468, -0.016177203506231308, -0.020153561607003212, 0.04886976256966591, 0.05807946249842644, -0.016067909076809883, 0.023647166788578033, 0.026722799986600876, 0.013940921984612942, 0.04315833002328873, 0.04118489846587181, -0.01425392460078001, -0.015648841857910156, 0.0013507960829883814, 0.022732289507985115, -0.02092193253338337, 0.029323648661375046, -0.011319074779748917, -0.016192622482776642, -0.11954702436923981, -0.04174378514289856, -0.02743707224726677, -0.000021237379769445397, 0.06086820363998413, 0.004596318118274212, -0.004251890815794468, 0.01782611571252346, 0.047146376222372055, 0.07570502907037735, -0.04172196611762047, 0.02352123335003853, -0.08586933463811874, -0.010869639925658703, 0.0191486943513155, -0.054049547761678696, -0.016087213531136513, -0.013587181456387043, -0.04001840204000473, 0.04416584223508835, 0.05428856983780861, -0.0031234128400683403, -0.044846341013908386, -0.023098880425095558, 0.05569532513618469, -0.023337630555033684, 0.0524083748459816, 0.009972755797207355, 0.06506112962961197, 0.028177285566926003, 0.03727137669920921, 0.06060677021741867, -0.02183464728295803, 0.06113673001527786, -0.022902214899659157, 0.0666220411658287, 0.030287140980362892, -0.006292879581451416, 0.025416988879442215, -0.013177125714719296, 0.009601076133549213, 0.08748213201761246, 0.003501481842249632, -0.018785445019602776, -0.007682968862354755, 0.014372057281434536, -0.021585974842309952, -0.013674432411789894, -0.0013694865629076958, 0.005757112987339497, -0.050467610359191895, -0.026803595945239067, -0.0385732464492321, -0.038079097867012024, 0.00841402355581522, -0.05760309845209122, -0.021782448515295982, -0.019371211528778076, -0.009577968157827854, -0.0003032626409549266, 0.03442848473787308, -0.048074278980493546, -0.02568398416042328, -0.017973754554986954, 0.010116889141499996, -0.06489129364490509, -0.0014268880477175117, 0.03266523778438568, 0.055038176476955414, -0.07025772333145142, -0.009487705305218697, 0.06759294122457504, -0.005085605196654797, 0.035622768104076385, 0.0018342601833865047, 0.0070464713498950005, -0.0544188991189003, -0.01779233291745186, -0.011534782126545906, -0.0146707184612751, -0.007338512223213911, -0.026522766798734665, 0.061031512916088104, -0.030904486775398254, -0.043958306312561035, 0.012513935565948486, 0.021876726299524307, 0.005949076265096664, -0.018086064606904984, -0.02497505210340023, -0.01881275326013565, -0.03284823149442673, -0.014911950565874577, 0.055842820554971695, 0.009506293572485447, -0.00922978576272726, 0.07538867741823196, 0.012598319910466671, 0.043108243495225906, 0.03318388760089874, 0.022592920809984207, -0.024547988548874855, -0.03873993828892708, 0.05102529004216194, -0.03021230921149254, 0.07610443234443665, 0.029172243550419807, -0.03392279893159866, 0.014486614614725113, -0.0026786827947944403, 0.05829736962914467, -0.0006692370516248047, 0.06889081746339798, 0.03050943836569786, -0.022252490743994713, -0.030117591843008995, 0.10227730125188828, -0.06573323160409927, -0.022683734074234962, -0.056822896003723145, -0.01242850162088871, -0.003472801297903061, 0.00506233936175704, 0.0007892264984548092, 0.009876731783151627, 0.06388284265995026, 0.017635969445109367, -0.008281389251351357, 0.03853888437151909, 0.007090704515576363, 0.04711532220244408, 0.05007699877023697, 0.023918310180306435, -0.011753021739423275, -0.05006122589111328, 0.018165992572903633, -0.02458888478577137, 0.052497684955596924, -0.024792730808258057, 0.009325814433395863, 0.028724920004606247, 0.05529305338859558, 0.05832811817526817, -0.037824034690856934, -0.10817011445760727, -0.05535460263490677, 0.026575030758976936, 0.0038162902928888798, -0.031554121524095535, -0.04934535175561905, 0.0071173314936459064, 0.007417336106300354, 0.013953296467661858, 0.005928870290517807, -0.048316873610019684, -0.00962816458195448, -0.05531194061040878, -0.004474800545722246, 0.008891738951206207, 0.016492187976837158, -0.06033109128475189, 0.013841599225997925, -0.04520314931869507, 0.023272961378097534, 0.052908096462488174, -0.014247971586883068, 0.036267828196287155, 0.03442078083753586, -0.011936135590076447, 0.012330583296716213, 0.010088752023875713, 0.09363462030887604, 0.012740017846226692, 0.05594221502542496, 0.032572925090789795, 0.003787293331697583, 0.02803860604763031, -0.007484928704798222, -0.018896302208304405, 0.04748418927192688, 0.012767765671014786, 0.04941510781645775, 0.01476129237562418, -0.003986855503171682, 0.003590959357097745, -0.041603147983551025, -0.018443768844008446, -0.00045434272033162415, -0.005960600916296244, -0.06296206265687943, -0.03823637589812279, -0.007540786173194647, -0.011855719611048698, -0.031928110867738724, -0.056013405323028564, -0.03236433118581772, 0.03150353208184242, -0.02266732044517994, 0.0464119128882885, -0.009573714807629585, 0.025479167699813843, -0.00036343614920042455, 0.019510919228196144, -0.0013204662827774882, -0.0007157507352530956, 0.0949280858039856, -0.006880923639982939, -0.0025222450494766235, -0.013747037388384342, 0.0978776067495346, -0.049806464463472366, 0.041351448744535446, 0.03010733425617218, -0.04612940177321434, 0.03036172315478325, -0.03244490548968315, -0.022292008623480797, -0.05118143931031227, -0.02524092234671116, -0.02226915769279003, 0.003772932570427656, 0.024279823526740074, -0.014799081720411777, -0.004284787457436323, -0.00548867741599679, 0.015693223103880882, -0.06035659462213516, -0.04831809177994728, 0.0077331396751105785, -0.030586756765842438, -0.0035984066780656576, -0.009121101349592209, -0.03179727494716644, -0.01937914825975895, -0.0013422707561403513, -0.090086430311203, -0.026001838967204094, -0.04992194473743439, 0.015017563477158546, 0.005009100306779146, -0.05500546470284462, 0.01746632345020771, 0.0149532500654459, -0.010418541729450226, -0.00594963226467371, 0.02792557328939438, -0.004085516091436148, 0.0230368934571743, -0.0021992968395352364, -0.05837472528219223, 0.05506350100040436, -0.067960225045681, 0.052672941237688065, -0.024168461561203003, 0.0379621796309948, 0.027780655771493912, 0.03495843708515167, -0.03138073906302452, 0.006693465169519186, -0.0019334349781274796, 0.016276588663458824, 0.012383264489471912, -0.023605717346072197, -0.041234780102968216, 0.00024286170082632452, -0.022979579865932465, 0.03145083412528038, -0.046242982149124146, 0.0589732751250267, -0.007931708358228207, -0.023056045174598694, -0.0224542785435915, 0.012454169802367687, 0.02978907898068428, 0.08302053809165955, -0.07814861088991165, 0.01660868339240551, 0.013153068721294403, -0.019115375354886055, 0.08695156872272491, 0.05253225192427635, -0.031096911057829857, 0.004353333730250597, -0.03504197299480438, 0.031143920496106148, -0.0048349532298743725, -0.0369778648018837, 0.021054286509752274, -0.03561655804514885, -0.015248257666826248, -0.0019155724439769983, -0.03316700831055641, -0.05169767513871193, -0.02434917539358139, -0.005653705447912216, -0.04489661753177643, 0.0018791819456964731, -0.0066275643184781075, 0.05287947505712509, -0.015470518730580807, 0.03686913102865219, 0.017399942502379417, -0.005446976982057095, 0.04037369415163994, 0.14976631104946136, 0.00972849503159523, 0.010713605210185051, 0.02432275377213955, 0.0414963960647583, -0.038713954389095306, 0.030428433790802956, 0.012782495468854904, -0.04965977743268013, 0.014723962172865868, 0.056509148329496384, -0.05211847275495529, 0.08354158699512482, -0.06582193076610565, 0.03245173767209053, -0.047119054943323135, -0.006476935464888811, 0.008979219011962414, -0.05079112946987152, -0.00856614951044321, 0.07058592885732651, -0.016239622607827187, -0.004383100662380457, 0.014301006682217121, -0.009912085719406605, -0.06273404508829117, -0.03952164575457573, -0.06063756346702576, 0.02110176905989647, 0.028413113206624985, -0.022544071078300476, -0.039769235998392105, 0.028178174048662186, 0.035441357642412186, 0.0808301717042923, -0.026747871190309525, -0.024072056636214256, -0.026265153661370277, 0.011870632879436016, -0.013972519896924496, -0.0067093707621097565, 0.026314472779631615, -0.0541621632874012, 0.05852122977375984, 0.009595703333616257, -0.04479137808084488, -0.030220558866858482, -0.03374416381120682, -0.04413730651140213, -0.0351581834256649, 0.007123047951608896, 0.001212917733937502, -0.014182068407535553, -0.004872191697359085, 0.023527316749095917, 0.006492718122899532, 0.028481828048825264, 0.002290041884407401, -0.059625741094350815, -0.011646296828985214, 0.07548478245735168, -0.042498014867305756, 0.014387460425496101, -0.03221935033798218, 0.026979297399520874, 0.0035736053250730038, -0.004202915821224451, 0.016919149085879326, -0.03750411793589592, 0.03684813529253006, 0.014825076796114445, -0.0037393150851130486, 0.0023741780314594507, 0.02205715700984001, -0.005588741973042488, -0.011114013381302357, -0.037381913512945175, 0.037869155406951904, 0.018186554312705994, -0.07715198397636414, -0.07781714200973511, -0.040284428745508194, 0.016741355881094933, 0.03641996905207634, -0.0524999238550663, -0.04008660838007927, -0.013751188293099403, -0.04620152711868286, -0.05075214058160782, -0.029538094997406006, -0.023043375462293625, -0.00885703507810831, -0.010052429512143135, -0.05079604685306549, 0.03998642414808273, 0.0304828193038702, 0.07846043258905411, 0.025086810812354088, -0.008267140947282314, -0.056336354464292526, 0.044418781995773315, 0.07126326858997345, 0.004164108540862799, 0.0023946771398186684, -0.04432062432169914, -0.02502143569290638, 0.057398099452257156, -0.022459883242845535, -0.003404479706659913, -0.02054613269865513, 0.03666553273797035, 0.014569908380508423, 0.07505057752132416, 0.04674716666340828, -0.013900880701839924, 0.00691167451441288, -0.008936210535466671, -0.025233756750822067, 0.02017183043062687, 0.06569083034992218, 0.03140108659863472, -0.034202612936496735, 0.014495071955025196, 0.04666423052549362, -0.02040020376443863, 0.04800928384065628, -0.043648723512887955, 0.01701749488711357, 0.017611971125006676, 0.006118522956967354, -0.01981116458773613, -0.03669849410653114, -0.0021424260921776295, 0.003006729995831847, 0.023805631324648857, -0.031324394047260284, 0.030843114480376244, -0.018212510272860527, 0.0030996103305369616, 0.032774485647678375, -0.03001478686928749, -0.025447681546211243, -0.03810121491551399, -0.016983291134238243, -0.01597602292895317, -0.06642092764377594, 0.013880888000130653, -0.019176585599780083, -0.024525590240955353, 0.03190828487277031, -0.03514394909143448, -0.04989245533943176, -0.03283008560538292, -0.016520816832780838, 0.03921996429562569, -0.00962225440889597, 0.004037843551486731, -0.022298509255051613, -0.005431143566966057, 0.04180087149143219, -0.029067881405353546, -0.02718634530901909, -0.006172386929392815, -0.018582941964268684, -0.04480207338929176, -0.0727582722902298, 0.03986382484436035, 0.010859384201467037, 0.026987656950950623, -0.010656051337718964, -0.020205147564411163, 0.011154178529977798, -0.029204251244664192, 0.06211407482624054, -0.06617484986782074, 0.015115310437977314, 0.0072306739166378975, -0.058388758450746536, -0.014342055656015873, 0.0667191669344902, -0.01427858229726553, -0.06370128691196442, 0.06089373677968979, -0.04043449088931084, 0.015135285444557667, -0.008698507212102413, 0.06966224312782288, 0.06244271993637085, -0.01856173388659954, -0.04655631631612778, -0.0016779961297288537, -0.03076920472085476, 0.029839113354682922, -0.006799037102609873, 0.037433553487062454, -0.04159348085522652, 0.013660070486366749, -0.05794839560985565, -0.009176275692880154, 0.0022955609019845724 ]
<p>After studying the definition (&amp; derivation) of the potential to an electric field and the Poisson equation I'm currently wondering whether the following is possible:</p> <ul> <li>Can one give an example of a physical setup where the Poission equation fails to provide the electric field?</li> </ul> <p>I have tried to come up with an example but failed. What I thought of was, that considering a valid solution of the Poisson equation, the electric field derived from the solution would have to be differentiable (since the second derivative of the potential appears in the differential equation). If one were to find a setup with a discontinuous electric field, would the Poisson equation fail?</p>
g1635
[ 0.04187459498643875, 0.03707138076424599, -0.010154803283512592, -0.05995010957121849, 0.0889618843793869, -0.02913636900484562, -0.047271937131881714, 0.011890541762113571, -0.03376810997724533, 0.005942035932093859, -0.028897589072585106, -0.02002938836812973, -0.028634408488869667, -0.045485351234674454, 0.007907726801931858, -0.019974075257778168, 0.07300575077533722, -0.05079962685704231, 0.03465448319911957, -0.021565403789281845, -0.017421282827854156, 0.05567990615963936, 0.006548482459038496, 0.016424380242824554, -0.005331526510417461, -0.02107527107000351, 0.025191185995936394, -0.016710670664906502, -0.036763567477464676, -0.11136060208082199, -0.0561346635222435, -0.01925111748278141, 0.052601467818021774, 0.003377381945028901, -0.027744190767407417, -0.025724926963448524, 0.017255526036024094, 0.014661503955721855, -0.028440287336707115, 0.013088852167129517, 0.062337152659893036, 0.01749582402408123, 0.05729048699140549, 0.015490098856389523, -0.04073279723525047, -0.022521071135997772, -0.009031116031110287, 0.03564878925681114, 0.0025101967621594667, 0.009937124326825142, 0.0013110621366649866, 0.01814848743379116, -0.011710341088473797, -0.006910042371600866, 0.020018085837364197, 0.00020679231965914369, 0.05631241947412491, -0.023047558963298798, 0.0262520220130682, -0.03184007853269577, 0.019882773980498314, -0.009577442891895771, -0.016250643879175186, -0.06606467068195343, 0.03533073142170906, -0.048856914043426514, -0.0513039194047451, -0.020356029272079468, -0.00817970372736454, 0.0038106406573206186, -0.0010845428332686424, -0.0037614598404616117, 0.0076465182937681675, -0.04678541049361229, 0.04026500880718231, 0.003653605468571186, -0.008192046545445919, -0.03200741112232208, 0.03718598932027817, -0.03089076094329357, -0.030265673995018005, 0.026745930314064026, 0.00663640396669507, 0.029658691957592964, 0.06475827842950821, -0.021026644855737686, 0.020471666008234024, -0.0036576592829078436, -0.031929221004247665, 0.013693802990019321, -0.05747750401496887, 0.06266435235738754, 0.03242843225598335, -0.028415018692612648, -0.04143330082297325, -0.029324159026145935, -0.02429807558655739, 0.03983872011303902, -0.015766503289341927, 0.02305019088089466, 0.0016885799122974277, -0.031136134639382362, -0.021293282508850098, -0.0022095299791544676, -0.022569913417100906, 0.0021914648823440075, 0.013768523000180721, 0.04956281557679176, 0.0071504851803183556, -0.019182637333869934, -0.00787899736315012, 0.010335871949791908, -0.04741460829973221, -0.0029747632797807455, 0.01517726294696331, -0.016119053587317467, 0.040954191237688065, -0.04759936034679413, -0.02171149104833603, 0.0462862104177475, -0.08859606087207794, 0.03919900953769684, 0.005758427083492279, 0.016290951520204544, -0.011408442631363869, -0.004643116146326065, -0.022204523906111717, 0.03040478751063347, 0.07775135338306427, 0.0020500754471868277, 0.0635465756058693, -0.04568292945623398, -0.013778368011116982, 0.007474022451788187, 0.02985023520886898, 0.06753606349229813, 0.03350686654448509, -0.01178447064012289, 0.017765557393431664, 0.003541788086295128, -0.009410586208105087, -0.032952673733234406, -0.03889797627925873, -0.018717633560299873, -0.001996091566979885, 0.05738143250346184, 0.019108353182673454, -0.00010857881716219708, 0.007872473448514938, 0.07697077095508575, -0.038056667894124985, -0.011984826065599918, -0.008843888528645039, -0.03502822294831276, -0.014601393602788448, 0.025799624621868134, 0.058223120868206024, -0.015617798082530499, -0.00014199363067746162, -0.04030519351363182, 0.06550996005535126, 0.0014942255802452564, 0.027018919587135315, 0.0032424309756606817, 0.018806515261530876, -0.03194373846054077, 0.008990800939500332, 0.05796222388744354, -0.04249352216720581, -0.02524816431105137, -0.022098779678344727, 0.008515081368386745, 0.06362058967351913, 0.04386766627430916, 0.05818985402584076, 0.051051974296569824, 0.02949647419154644, 0.006093790754675865, 0.004480935633182526, 0.004587903618812561, -0.04779646545648575, 0.005337167996913195, -0.0022881370969116688, -0.08520156890153885, 0.029052523896098137, -0.018338518217206, -0.016339082270860672, 0.05071844533085823, -0.030917182564735413, -0.01981685683131218, -0.034430619329214096, 0.042011696845293045, -0.03237328678369522, 0.02133585885167122, -0.0470174141228199, 0.05609947070479393, 0.03940381109714508, -0.024923034012317657, 0.007072823587805033, -0.01972806267440319, -0.015694983303546906, 0.04586993157863617, 0.03590504452586174, -0.007168970070779324, -0.010018507950007915, -0.0783802792429924, -0.09644390642642975, -0.034189920872449875, 0.03473038971424103, -0.046133678406476974, 0.008328537456691265, -0.011760137975215912, 0.011485176160931587, 0.0035255395341664553, -0.014267731457948685, -0.06945390999317169, 0.005305995233356953, -0.06196225807070732, -0.04739571735262871, 0.016478344798088074, -0.07086881250143051, -0.041407182812690735, 0.04947293922305107, 0.03651578724384308, -0.026142248883843422, 0.039289895445108414, -0.013525904156267643, -0.028328554704785347, -0.057771917432546616, 0.02195025607943535, -0.004566245712339878, -0.016899719834327698, 0.05345630273222923, -0.07100582867860794, 0.012380873784422874, -0.008425758220255375, -0.05560356751084328, -0.055198099464178085, 0.004259432200342417, 0.003939085174351931, -0.04380287602543831, -0.04714880511164665, -0.03484615683555603, 0.0848386362195015, 0.0016765574691817164, -0.04183002933859825, 0.06791339069604874, -0.007134894374758005, 0.05757114663720131, 0.019304918125271797, 0.011816347017884254, 0.008758923038840294, -0.051706548780202866, 0.022351471707224846, -0.02082725800573826, -0.05337856337428093, 0.02218419872224331, 0.03948919475078583, -0.0006271254387684166, -0.04605160653591156, -0.04033370688557625, 0.027271408587694168, 0.02860335260629654, 0.08971458673477173, -0.059424951672554016, 0.01911497488617897, -0.018040098249912262, -0.007518047466874123, 0.0016209302702918649, 0.008973157964646816, 0.0013814698904752731, 0.005011092871427536, 0.008015180937945843, -0.017426269128918648, 0.04626445472240448, -0.032497670501470566, 0.007956902496516705, 0.025158248841762543, 0.06257771700620651, 0.026465322822332382, -0.02957030013203621, -0.010845012031495571, -0.03032287396490574, 0.07618196308612823, 0.05030954256653786, -0.0437556728720665, -0.004612306132912636, -0.0013921634526923299, 0.027605557814240456, 0.04629696160554886, -0.03319663554430008, 0.008470993489027023, -0.007854989729821682, -0.05410122498869896, -0.04845040664076805, -0.0033140622545033693, -0.013238068670034409, -0.06876521557569504, -0.02120155654847622, -0.07477813214063644, 0.024106500670313835, -0.005560360848903656, -0.018331235274672508, 0.031191613525152206, 0.030572373420000076, 0.013251213356852531, -0.008896023035049438, -0.00003758571619982831, 0.009490742348134518, -0.007906829938292503, -0.0217291209846735, 0.03396691754460335, -0.005492358468472958, -0.057027608156204224, -0.02450927533209324, 0.0022734892554581165, 0.03021998703479767, -0.018303897231817245, 0.03349670395255089, -0.02276736870408058, 0.05314883962273598, -0.03792937844991684, -0.007186578586697578, -0.011063510552048683, 0.05465231463313103, 0.04685136675834656, -0.04552098363637924, 0.02995104156434536, -0.02875596098601818, -0.027903005480766296, 0.020066581666469574, 0.02197263017296791, 0.03902062028646469, -0.02050476148724556, 0.0154504319652915, -0.0177597813308239, -0.0066708168014883995, 0.037571508437395096, 0.013556879945099354, 0.009619825519621372, 0.036385104060173035, -0.053773537278175354, -0.08695265650749207, 0.0004075267934240401, -0.12175153195858002, 0.0012953662080690265, 0.006186883430927992, -0.045441240072250366, 0.038509588688611984, -0.01580152101814747, 0.025212299078702927, -0.021828748285770416, -0.017565039917826653, 0.017557885497808456, -0.020769407972693443, -0.021219413727521896, 0.019881052896380424, 0.035892289131879807, -0.010595989413559437, 0.027798108756542206, 0.013532030396163464, -0.04767058417201042, 0.043690409511327744, -0.036947548389434814, 0.057312242686748505, 0.019006242975592613, 0.026552962139248848, 0.03716406598687172, -0.05846887826919556, -0.034905899316072464, -0.006056998856365681, 0.05129709467291832, -0.013137152418494225, -0.07231344282627106, -0.025842396542429924, -0.044743575155735016, -0.0010887493845075369, 0.040710628032684326, -0.030453599989414215, 0.01911195181310177, 0.012587922625243664, 0.04480595886707306, 0.056408561766147614, 0.06035243347287178, 0.020720085129141808, -0.005354122258722782, -0.018241070210933685, -0.008095132187008858, -0.0018055010586977005, 0.01037841197103262, -0.026509447023272514, 0.03584596514701843, -0.006257989909499884, 0.027908802032470703, -0.001073341933079064, -0.07083290070295334, -0.00969548337161541, -0.05369750037789345, 0.013802477158606052, 0.021159231662750244, 0.05959140881896019, -0.08283515274524689, 0.05675889924168587, 0.015930702909827232, -0.02291279099881649, -0.03813862428069115, 0.07758244127035141, -0.014491387642920017, 0.007662291172891855, -0.02666821889579296, -0.046896182000637054, -0.04578772932291031, -0.011684706434607506, -0.040991608053445816, -0.020326174795627594, -0.009392903186380863, 0.024205604568123817, 0.024415267631411552, 0.05160791799426079, 0.06684238463640213, 0.040519505739212036, 0.035468410700559616, -0.012366771697998047, 0.0048047322779893875, -0.016936754807829857, 0.014200814999639988, 0.037977419793605804, -0.026650477200746536, -0.01219235174357891, -0.031293366104364395, -0.0023887434508651495, 0.0711229145526886, 0.0030318531207740307, 0.017048878595232964, -0.040601715445518494, 0.018352992832660675, -0.04950326308608055, 0.026373060420155525, -0.02906295657157898, 0.06175299361348152, -0.015396003611385822, -0.051344096660614014, 0.044148270040750504, -0.01162857934832573, -0.010234354995191097, 0.045150112360715866, 0.008723185397684574, -0.041357774287462234, 0.005785913672298193, -0.01151092816144228, 0.025706294924020767, 0.03672764450311661, -0.020943978801369667, -0.009892212226986885, -0.06943845748901367, -0.039392583072185516, 0.029435597360134125, -0.02112467586994171, -0.03137243911623955, -0.02183152548968792, 0.01629604585468769, -0.04736258089542389, -0.030828021466732025, 0.012491266243159771, 0.010375531390309334, -0.049232132732868195, -0.027796531096100807, -0.027148954570293427, -0.04174254089593887, -0.05073883384466171, -0.017728140577673912, 0.07243688404560089, 0.030878117308020592, 0.047009289264678955, 0.05537768453359604, -0.025288386270403862, -0.001156606595031917, 0.0450495146214962, -0.010722314938902855, -0.06452485918998718, -0.005083637312054634, 0.0066294679418206215, -0.012109433300793171, 0.014225633814930916, -0.02942424826323986, -0.007182201370596886, -0.031538691371679306, 0.06459039449691772, 0.0069303372874855995, -0.021154170855879784, 0.07826279103755951, 0.04682356119155884, 0.04118286073207855, 0.005733714438974857, -0.014174368232488632, -0.0000222791095438879, -0.007815334014594555, 0.07569785416126251, -0.019001387059688568, 0.030261199921369553, -0.040454961359500885, -0.0016526328399777412, -0.04199684038758278, 0.0009584525832906365, 0.0008250413229689002, -0.012418615631759167, 0.056189607828855515, -0.005427685100585222, -0.008664194494485855, -0.04800691083073616, 0.013755816034972668, 0.04194017872214317, -0.00013628863962367177, -0.03683045506477356, -0.0072226147167384624, 0.02650049328804016, -0.1106906607747078, -0.0018627723911777139, -0.027352990582585335, -0.07983950525522232, 0.050420720130205154, 0.03580894693732262, -0.010077128186821938, -0.027719004079699516, 0.00792140793055296, 0.021838538348674774, -0.0446457639336586, -0.011012807488441467, -0.010536725632846355, 0.053722184151411057, 0.02297028712928295, 0.028453361243009567, -0.018992431461811066, -0.010725758038461208, -0.04103061184287071, -0.043160371482372284, -0.024403905496001244, -0.02591121383011341, 0.015741104260087013, 0.029752716422080994, -0.030004344880580902, -0.04075543209910393, 0.060660071671009064, -0.0011742871720343828, 0.05328209698200226, 0.009920180775225163, -0.023039808496832848, 0.038434527814388275, 0.0637330636382103, -0.07462936639785767, 0.017894184216856956, 0.03589566797018051, -0.03864002227783203, 0.013074862770736217, -0.03250297158956528, -0.004251809325069189, -0.0021103147882968187, 0.002455493900924921, -0.01914101652801037, -0.02127881534397602, 0.04806751012802124, -0.017672445625066757, -0.008789118379354477, 0.008605869486927986, 0.044347506016492844, -0.04083864390850067, 0.056538648903369904, 0.048769254237413406, 0.006510697305202484, 0.054094720631837845, -0.016271738335490227, -0.0020539143588393927, 0.003557107411324978, -0.034226417541503906, -0.024722496047616005, -0.031967852264642715, 0.04612412303686142, -0.02009008266031742, 0.010958152823150158, 0.03578115627169609, -0.031594015657901764, 0.030586350709199905, 0.05139074847102165, -0.004501854069530964, -0.051594652235507965, 0.00910905934870243, -0.03347520902752876, 0.007712659891694784, 0.017241762951016426, -0.0252027977257967, 0.008083490654826164, 0.017529847100377083, 0.005142504349350929, -0.03623650223016739, 0.018776241689920425, 0.0017259246669709682, -0.015576628036797047, -0.03840400278568268, -0.033001143485307693, 0.0793120414018631, 0.04039720818400383, 0.01026821881532669, -0.04901283234357834, -0.01548921037465334, 0.047551024705171585, -0.015665441751480103, 0.007338599301874638, 0.04483027756214142, 0.0847531333565712, -0.03370048105716705, 0.0499546118080616, 0.026007939130067825, -0.015172288753092289, 0.0040959883481264114, -0.024298276752233505, 0.01429098378866911, 0.016951652243733406, 0.04745003208518028, -0.025130828842520714, 0.01996578648686409, 0.011924516409635544, -0.022499769926071167, 0.010477486997842789, -0.0007995193591341376, -0.03883941099047661, -0.021328242495656013, -0.02649109996855259, 0.04790651798248291, 0.06474214047193527, 0.0032994586508721113, 0.04291892796754837, 0.0008955862722359598, 0.01733728125691414, 0.051082562655210495, -0.030940890312194824, 0.022013559937477112, 0.02141050063073635, -0.013799607753753662, 0.08666712045669556, -0.0013289852067828178, -0.009290183894336224, 0.06908301264047623, 0.0828738585114479, -0.004464286845177412, -0.04761515557765961, 0.017839012667536736, 0.01571141928434372, 0.044366080313920975, -0.026230402290821075, -0.010538882575929165, 0.07579715549945831, 0.006476746406406164, 0.03777182474732399, -0.017334438860416412, -0.02386443503201008, 0.05074641481041908, -0.03511233255267143, -0.0025295265950262547, 0.022886069491505623, -0.00755715649574995, -0.004097452852874994, 0.01970619522035122, -0.054147109389305115, -0.011393125168979168, 0.002650838578119874, -0.010840902104973793, 0.011197278276085854, -0.07984936982393265, 0.007040579337626696, 0.01577853038907051, -0.0007226803572848439, -0.05577470734715462, -0.022460581734776497, 0.04519463703036308, -0.03706631436944008, -0.018549812957644463, 0.040177758783102036, 0.06817587465047836, 0.023977231234312057, -0.04125887155532837, -0.00667758472263813, 0.03864191845059395, -0.0541091188788414, -0.07051844894886017, -0.010339837521314621, 0.011567850597202778, -0.0017123098950833082, 0.01931876130402088, 0.04319661483168602, 0.05172176659107208, -0.01679261028766632, 0.010249692015349865, -0.0027626273222267628, -0.02248365618288517, -0.03981557860970497, -0.0072163729928433895, 0.016049332916736603, 0.024751929566264153, 0.09702838212251663, -0.0185907781124115, 0.024799441918730736, -0.030552471056580544, -0.009733865968883038, -0.019657475873827934, -0.03247557207942009, -0.013891072943806648, -0.00886751152575016, 0.01301664486527443, -0.08147241920232773, 0.025300784036517143, 0.030725443735718727, 0.07604128122329712, -0.06503009051084518, 0.032625552266836166, 0.0381910614669323, -0.0031868782825767994, -0.03925613686442375, 0.014850137755274773, -0.04496521130204201, 0.004888345953077078, 0.0057159001007676125, 0.04322892427444458, 0.0032078546937555075, -0.03265576809644699, 0.07358555495738983, 0.004668452311307192, -0.0161270871758461, 0.002733558416366577, -0.015572834759950638, 0.004843558184802532, 0.014757917262613773, 0.032055821269750595, 0.011345761828124523, -0.03306962177157402, -0.02495420165359974, -0.03940790519118309, -0.02474200911819935, 0.003676203079521656, 0.0395808145403862, -0.07087733596563339, 0.009440725669264793, -0.04114655405282974, -0.03215736150741577, -0.02741367369890213, 0.09813432395458221, -0.022487545385956764, -0.056568823754787445, 0.032843876630067825, 0.04162309691309929, -0.03272499889135361, -0.03417762741446495, 0.0028852263931185007, -0.07049807161092758, 0.027465583756566048, 0.061406731605529785, -0.05335912108421326, 0.0033006740268319845, -0.02003525011241436, 0.0484737865626812, 0.03439072519540787, -0.009773940779268742, -0.0015956743154674768, 0.02258347161114216, -0.026493793353438377, -0.039100952446460724, -0.03279900178313255, 0.018096337094902992, 0.05298186466097832 ]
<p>I heard at least three claims about the development of the heat of the sun. In an old book, I read, that nothing dramatically will happen in the next few billion years. Wikipedia states, that the average temperature will hit 30° in a billion years, 100° a billion years later, and in an internet forum, someone claimed that in 500 million years, the oceans would cook.</p> <p>Which of this claims is true? How reliable are the claims about events in such far future?</p>
g1636
[ 0.06892453134059906, 0.05156794562935829, 0.007993070408701897, 0.05820447579026222, -0.01834532991051674, 0.03422270342707634, 0.005018489435315132, 0.0007821522885933518, 0.0075730192475020885, -0.06183775141835213, 0.04183872044086456, 0.05646669492125511, 0.05108240991830826, -0.027989773079752922, -0.00536756357178092, -0.009323212318122387, -0.02319764532148838, -0.0037305078003555536, 0.03294702246785164, 0.07093054801225662, -0.016752969473600388, -0.07257360965013504, 0.026113728061318398, -0.025713026523590088, -0.08371556550264359, -0.014731756411492825, -0.006548629142343998, 0.036162033677101135, 0.014007236808538437, -0.061787597835063934, 0.0708681270480156, -0.0024916117545217276, 0.005036620423197746, -0.04283761605620384, -0.02288719452917576, -0.10550772398710251, -0.038512345403432846, -0.030218882486224174, 0.026151735335588455, -0.046675555408000946, -0.01482968870550394, 0.041625190526247025, 0.09245140850543976, -0.005410169716924429, 0.0442885123193264, -0.013940655626356602, -0.038122110068798065, 0.04172208905220032, -0.00941768754273653, 0.0020664427429437637, 0.03775527700781822, 0.005609151441603899, 0.03688261657953262, -0.005276297684758902, 0.007740153465420008, -0.03617311269044876, 0.005272019654512405, -0.011588435620069504, 0.046269673854112625, 0.030967019498348236, 0.08203456550836563, 0.024611499160528183, -0.02684622071683407, -0.038305461406707764, 0.028554057702422142, 0.038758985698223114, -0.046392329037189484, 0.017569560557603836, 0.0205303356051445, 0.011720173992216587, 0.008283811621367931, -0.0327187106013298, -0.06295301765203476, -0.008028577081859112, -0.03768283128738403, -0.007409415207803249, -0.030882060527801514, -0.011169265024363995, 0.021432889625430107, 0.07557741552591324, -0.01402263343334198, 0.03969171643257141, 0.02660749852657318, 0.003749730996787548, -0.03667592257261276, -0.05834200978279114, -0.027967702597379684, 0.06774517893791199, 0.012714691460132599, 0.013126303441822529, 0.036911655217409134, 0.027881957590579987, 0.05387873947620392, 0.0035165969748049974, 0.021249311044812202, 0.008594714105129242, -0.02487299032509327, 0.006711097434163094, -0.04239702224731445, 0.005359253380447626, -0.03832584619522095, -0.02665483020246029, 0.039760783314704895, -0.030765770003199577, -0.03000044636428356, 0.007237723562866449, -0.04173310473561287, -0.03572753071784973, 0.024720121175050735, -0.022333741188049316, -0.0001955363986780867, 0.059212710708379745, -0.02755068801343441, -0.013207710348069668, -0.06976086646318436, 0.015032771043479443, -0.002702259225770831, 0.005377280525863171, 0.06123882904648781, 0.011980251409113407, 0.005605322774499655, 0.042872436344623566, 0.020015869289636612, 0.05254319682717323, -0.019283965229988098, -0.03257233276963234, 0.0031659197993576527, -0.0069759865291416645, -0.03414783999323845, 0.0005963395233266056, -0.02493167296051979, 0.08221396058797836, -0.043984074145555496, 0.02596612274646759, 0.006980588659644127, -0.0015194079605862498, -0.00257081538438797, 0.04728357493877411, -0.008922330103814602, 0.011304676532745361, 0.05498567223548889, 0.010265917517244816, 0.025605887174606323, -0.07148758322000504, -0.04004862904548645, 0.035707563161849976, -0.014015804044902325, 0.02909211814403534, 0.05248405039310455, 0.010848959907889366, -0.00970003567636013, 0.013374059461057186, 0.010203426703810692, -0.024637723341584206, -0.041289035230875015, 0.04112451896071434, -0.0037539643235504627, -0.029013287276029587, 0.048589084297418594, -0.03878540173172951, 0.003796319244429469, -0.012295565567910671, 0.07292593270540237, -0.014448371715843678, -0.07500115782022476, -0.018793877214193344, -0.002038688398897648, -0.03062523528933525, -0.07612043619155884, 0.00043595233000814915, -0.012026366777718067, 0.010114581324160099, -0.026259807869791985, 0.038842279464006424, 0.007937202230095863, -0.041112203150987625, 0.026982130482792854, -0.013485130853950977, -0.0785905197262764, -0.09006166458129883, -0.055747728794813156, -0.01724652387201786, 0.012454304844141006, 0.013709635473787785, 0.02665936015546322, 0.026321126148104668, -0.03902503475546837, -0.04265058785676956, -0.003152996301651001, -0.009392651729285717, -0.04295742139220238, -0.006323297042399645, 0.0347815603017807, 0.0017020480008795857, 0.03355299308896065, -0.031542371958494186, -0.008404704742133617, 0.0034499599132686853, -0.042095329612493515, 0.013095589354634285, 0.03036952018737793, 0.01818670704960823, -0.025410400703549385, -0.025905705988407135, -0.008511917665600777, 0.05875767767429352, 0.017606373876333237, -0.010886618867516518, -0.01207675039768219, 0.03165777027606964, 0.06394622474908829, 0.00500841299071908, -0.04776298627257347, -0.05133179575204849, 0.02460334636271, 0.025304188951849937, -0.07107335329055786, 0.034896280616521835, 0.05306952819228172, -0.0514671728014946, -0.0005810090224258602, 0.09894999116659164, 0.03710739687085152, -0.03951650485396385, 0.05525364726781845, 0.04001380130648613, -0.07182887196540833, -0.01895809732377529, -0.006541237700730562, 0.07829876244068146, -0.07811684906482697, -0.031196344643831253, -0.01281337533146143, -0.005304521881043911, -0.01891065016388893, 0.02752520702779293, 0.06440531462430954, -0.04868520796298981, 0.06403607130050659, 0.04862018674612045, -0.01464876439422369, -0.0125323086977005, -0.010103589855134487, 0.026643281802535057, -0.013657492585480213, -0.07687897980213165, -0.0003962876508012414, -0.018590955063700676, 0.009199794381856918, 0.02277878299355507, 0.06521367281675339, -0.007097267080098391, -0.017505822703242302, 0.07361433655023575, -0.016370277851819992, -0.00975197646766901, 0.022001268342137337, 0.020575406029820442, -0.03802529349923134, -0.017902811989188194, -0.02526581846177578, -0.018347032368183136, 0.014855093322694302, -0.07403616607189178, 0.0055447653867304325, -0.041608281433582306, -0.027176493778824806, -0.018055884167551994, 0.01846747286617756, 0.009295166470110416, 0.018538178876042366, -0.010458484292030334, 0.024926789104938507, 0.05891147628426552, 0.03113027662038803, -0.014851013198494911, -0.04043516144156456, 0.020320547744631767, 0.03798606991767883, -0.05853499472141266, -0.0010668204631656408, -0.027153262868523598, 0.04500554874539375, 0.030865255743265152, 0.03021978959441185, -0.05843128636479378, -0.0950271412730217, 0.009219139814376831, 0.08398395776748657, 0.012672164477407932, 0.02378886565566063, -0.018163638189435005, 0.05133765563368797, -0.008101087994873524, -0.012081856839358807, 0.038821350783109665, 0.04006557911634445, 0.04138268530368805, -0.012745688669383526, -0.04357623681426048, 0.05125192552804947, -0.03390156850218773, -0.05357950180768967, 0.022830834612250328, 0.041988812386989594, -0.005748789291828871, -0.07563965022563934, -0.056029289960861206, 0.033079843968153, -0.08600839972496033, -0.005285424645990133, -0.0290993545204401, 0.0063309879042208195, -0.018904825672507286, -0.02461397461593151, 0.03777081146836281, 0.0015448022168129683, 0.0653233453631401, 0.060944750905036926, -0.0040856413543224335, 0.008541545830667019, 0.005730227567255497, -0.03263680264353752, -0.027342133224010468, 0.005334617104381323, 0.0628538727760315, -0.01139172911643982, -0.06956923753023148, -0.018484564498066902, 0.009931322187185287, -0.012252436019480228, 0.003480489132925868, -0.0633559376001358, 0.01732967607676983, 0.00767329940572381, -0.013207929208874702, -0.004091496113687754, 0.00477658910676837, 0.0060819643549621105, -0.0026968098245561123, 0.0481896735727787, -0.0026671409141272306, 0.0173590499907732, -0.0034431880339980125, 0.04651717096567154, 0.06810778379440308, -0.006451948080211878, -0.07400050014257431, -0.015018953010439873, 0.019703064113855362, 0.07126320898532867, -0.04553725942969322, -0.03150934725999832, -0.001960037276148796, -0.015681732445955276, 0.043887630105018616, -0.040906619280576706, -0.0035314694978296757, -0.007351118605583906, 0.004559971392154694, 0.02932668663561344, 0.04809615761041641, 0.0670727863907814, -0.006690820679068565, 0.020935697481036186, 0.03272660821676254, -0.018218109384179115, 0.02507057599723339, 0.013740050606429577, -0.03883818909525871, -0.0031678667291998863, -0.016477659344673157, -0.0037507330998778343, 0.019176054745912552, 0.051084212958812714, 0.039520472288131714, 0.0634002685546875, -0.009830447845160961, 0.003961827140301466, 0.03755555301904678, 0.02751060761511326, 0.06883323937654495, 0.0010448179673403502, 0.06295798718929291, 0.016577253118157387, -0.009451995603740215, -0.02782709151506424, -0.031073635444045067, -0.051126718521118164, -0.07496330142021179, 0.040259700268507004, -0.0259772427380085, 0.08002425730228424, 0.02239602617919445, -0.0025614327751100063, -0.09332932531833649, -0.0072190831415355206, 0.02893761545419693, 0.020842213183641434, -0.004002439323812723, 0.017900504171848297, -0.013564160093665123, 0.027110209688544273, -0.003142519388347864, -0.0019125890685245395, -0.013057803735136986, 0.01434430480003357, -0.04834924265742302, -0.061609819531440735, -0.03577041998505592, 0.04075303673744202, 0.02731160819530487, 0.005562523379921913, -0.0203460231423378, 0.02810482680797577, 0.0048523107543587685, -0.012885579839348793, -0.04263962060213089, 0.03337456285953522, 0.05391102284193039, -0.059921350330114365, 0.013823582790791988, -0.06231120228767395, 0.022779639810323715, 0.01313548069447279, -0.01319929026067257, 0.02435748092830181, -0.05142746493220329, 0.015200729481875896, -0.007857332937419415, 0.04367174953222275, 0.045416805893182755, -0.004379769321531057, 0.019657259806990623, 0.034286413341760635, 0.04259413853287697, -0.003999815322458744, 0.00892244279384613, -0.044390127062797546, -0.03166980296373367, 0.02695348672568798, 0.07176273316144943, 0.03785676881670952, 0.042573925107717514, 0.06716971844434738, 0.05253709852695465, 0.006014304235577583, -0.009312617592513561, 0.019094619899988174, -0.023530710488557816, -0.019728315994143486, 0.04886477068066597, -0.03413693234324455, 0.009271832183003426, 0.0008452361798845232, -0.04346926510334015, -0.017877696081995964, 0.001631950493901968, -0.06971517950296402, 0.024712419137358665, -0.04936843737959862, 0.00587727315723896, 0.018872670829296112, 0.0185201745480299, -0.013701624237000942, -0.041722722351551056, 0.0016607949510216713, -0.006746702827513218, 0.008755187503993511, 0.028231153264641762, -0.008619165048003197, 0.011213303543627262, 0.0402548648416996, 0.0001352843246422708, -0.028534501791000366, -0.02054203301668167, 0.009186951443552971, -0.06837620586156845, -0.0037191552110016346, 0.011091471649706364, -0.04495837539434433, 0.024862859398126602, -0.013476510532200336, 0.05938032642006874, 0.005407041870057583, -0.012486475519835949, -0.003899348434060812, -0.003292536363005638, 0.03185136243700981, 0.02742227353155613, 0.0108562670648098, -0.028663955628871918, 0.021781206130981445, 0.03307807818055153, -0.08526989817619324, -0.016498476266860962, -0.002123516518622637, -0.01036814134567976, 0.02105865068733692, 0.045734331011772156, -0.017074650153517723, 0.05823880806565285, 0.016123350709676743, -0.025179050862789154, 0.03545656427741051, 0.004950524773448706, 0.018778247758746147, -0.02160201035439968, 0.012986394576728344, 0.04968230053782463, 0.051113855093717575, 0.02925875596702099, -0.012897688895463943, 0.026175176724791527, 0.0634796991944313, -0.04503463953733444, 0.015976687893271446, -0.0823323056101799, 0.033074818551540375, -0.02502274513244629, 0.027760088443756104, -0.07072928547859192, -0.03447669371962547, 0.03575815632939339, 0.05412714555859566, -0.034037306904792786, -0.017887603491544724, 0.011471734382212162, 0.02698538638651371, -0.00589117594063282, -0.00008428087312495336, 0.044285744428634644, 0.0196746326982975, -0.0347055047750473, -0.010784680023789406, 0.03625531122088432, -0.0032530154567211866, -0.019298294559121132, 0.05537900701165199, -0.03795531764626503, 0.008695547468960285, 0.03099762089550495, 0.01546886283904314, 0.07811997830867767, 0.038584884256124496, 0.046957939863204956, -0.027143413200974464, 0.04927040636539459, 0.010219698771834373, -0.016408413648605347, 0.03083258867263794, 0.03728849068284035, 0.04875778779387474, -0.07558253407478333, 0.023190516978502274, 0.031923696398735046, 0.05178872123360634, -0.022676268592476845, 0.04922126233577728, -0.023952508345246315, 0.016717100515961647, -0.010556013323366642, 0.011075364425778389, 0.01867363601922989, -0.05728130042552948, 0.0015342023689299822, -0.011752495542168617, -0.06026797369122505, -0.01953800767660141, 0.08231094479560852, 0.06294350326061249, -0.03028271161019802, 0.006045028101652861, -0.03686921298503876, 0.024924010038375854, -0.05436181649565697, 0.057732898741960526, -0.04789941757917404, -0.028487417846918106, -0.07148046791553497, -0.01614777185022831, -0.06377124041318893, -0.04099263250827789, 0.009443541057407856, 0.03456857055425644, 0.04925477132201195, -0.013766986317932606, -0.012596391141414642, 0.0013297386467456818, 0.02238783799111843, 0.0023737316951155663, 0.013600368984043598, -0.04157823696732521, -0.05177406221628189, -0.017596835270524025, -0.0653245747089386, -0.006345147732645273, 0.002174962777644396, -0.004981391131877899, -0.021122358739376068, -0.020738212391734123, -0.06076914817094803, 0.029182257130742073, -0.039185330271720886, 0.010097061283886433, -0.004237210378050804, 0.05708518251776695, 0.0698256641626358, 0.039626069366931915, -0.04424688592553139, 0.05282304808497429, -0.008801531046628952, 0.031178325414657593, -0.0465695820748806, -0.0028335393872112036, -0.03813432529568672, 0.007298714015632868, -0.0011354583548381925, 0.010000808164477348, 0.012221693992614746, 0.004090575501322746, 0.02159282937645912, -0.06663365662097931, -0.04860110580921173, -0.029112625867128372, 0.07039990276098251, -0.0163944773375988, 0.000649257272016257, 0.009306959807872772, -0.02325417473912239, 0.02418607845902443, -0.05455828085541725, 0.0063992817886173725, 0.047821950167417526, 0.013644933700561523, -0.024239301681518555, -0.008374344557523727, -0.025361770763993263, -0.03134532645344734, -0.002058674581348896, -0.026871703565120697, -0.05597967281937599, 0.04960939288139343, 0.013779478147625923, 0.016138922423124313, -0.017808666452765465, -0.0504550077021122, -0.04738007113337517, -0.020713137462735176, -0.02972877025604248, -0.04199490696191788, -0.07399634271860123, -0.02364358678460121, 0.0008307183743454516, 0.027000805363059044, 0.03803844377398491, -0.018278619274497032, -0.033520977944135666, 0.025593416765332222, -0.018317434936761856, 0.022223081439733505, -0.049603357911109924, 0.013102921657264233, 0.009857135824859142, 0.012968001887202263, 0.04597478359937668, 0.008886494673788548, -0.08464986085891724, 0.005288536194711924, -0.008284377865493298, 0.04979633912444115, -0.02689356915652752, -0.03316713869571686, -0.027179211378097534, -0.007248764391988516, 0.004069930873811245, -0.03298694267868996, 0.0018018413102254272, 0.028336750343441963, 0.050266582518815994, -0.015977991744875908, -0.01354603935033083, -0.018862489610910416, -0.00408678175881505, 0.07346564531326294, 0.006820173002779484, -0.0005343026714399457, 0.004198803566396236, -0.026686126366257668, 0.018214130774140358, -0.08772065490484238, -0.007271417882293463, -0.005796062760055065, -0.02590622380375862, 0.02694888226687908, 0.00861803162842989, -0.006718074902892113, -0.025227660313248634, 0.022170396521687508, 0.00544850854203105, -0.016087230294942856, 0.0015918969875201583, -0.027579372748732567, -0.015718916431069374, -0.026075312867760658, 0.05160141736268997, 0.015892038121819496, 0.024355171248316765, -0.025307873263955116, -0.004851812031120062, 0.06713112443685532, 0.019010288640856743, 0.020695429295301437, 0.02034822478890419, -0.04796552658081055, -0.017859281972050667, -0.053694091737270355, -0.07937316596508026, -0.01718086749315262, -0.013720689341425896, 0.008295925334095955, 0.007727042306214571, -0.01679972931742668, -0.024684041738510132, -0.004127850756049156, 0.017687836661934853, -0.006906347349286079, -0.008417793549597263, -0.011928838677704334, -0.05015115812420845, 0.03214747831225395, -0.02070673368871212, -0.03693120554089546, 0.024531714618206024, -0.04016632214188576, -0.0036014614161103964, -0.02693997137248516, -0.025485292077064514, 0.050065912306308746, 0.0039049505721777678, -0.00032449932768940926, 0.04440952092409134, -0.0025064863730221987, -0.023047978058457375, -0.0013979654759168625, 0.0015574432909488678, -0.03434433788061142, 0.03300495818257332, -0.045077260583639145, -0.03524872660636902, 0.006613129284232855, 0.025360871106386185, -0.07064472883939743, 0.007314677350223064, 0.02468474581837654, 0.02610776387155056, -0.048723164945840836, -0.008336715400218964, 0.0210597924888134, -0.05549655854701996, -0.005199803039431572, -0.023922424763441086, 0.06604907661676407, -0.044380877166986465, -0.020212825387716293, -0.011132564395666122, -0.026647502556443214, -0.03478090837597847 ]
<p>Lorentz length contractions states that the length of any moving object gets divided by the <a href="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lorentz_factor" rel="nofollow">Lorentz factor</a> equal to the Lorentz factor for that object (always $\geq 1$), equal to $$ \gamma=\frac{1}{\sqrt { 1-\frac { { v }^{ 2 } }{ { c }^{ 2 } } } } $$ However, in massless particles $v=c$, so the Lorentz factor becomes $\infty$, meaning that an object traveling at $c$ will have $0$ length. However, photons and obviously all forms of electromagnetic waves move at c when traveling through a vacuum, such as from a space shuttle to a space station or back to Earth. Does this mean that photons have no length? How does this affect wavelength?</p>
g1637
[ -0.016480714082717896, -0.001978808082640171, -0.012248335406184196, 0.015071782283484936, 0.002556314691901207, 0.040679119527339935, 0.0164584219455719, 0.004924055654555559, -0.023903828114271164, -0.014230495318770409, -0.012508882209658623, 0.028512511402368546, -0.012682037428021431, 0.009435335174202919, -0.0003616256290115416, -0.01750425435602665, 0.11555644869804382, 0.013294689357280731, 0.003330657258629799, 0.01687277853488922, 0.018194524571299553, -0.011751293204724789, -0.0017470872262492776, -0.06658213585615158, -0.006153069902211428, 0.002389976754784584, 0.0647018551826477, -0.01651262491941452, -0.026282934471964836, -0.043475620448589325, -0.0014394681202247739, -0.004995513707399368, -0.019664805382490158, -0.012387494556605816, 0.0004955138429068029, -0.03756001591682434, 0.008544586598873138, 0.02139972895383835, 0.031551338732242584, 0.058769360184669495, 0.007851699367165565, -0.0005310651031322777, -0.0035079321824014187, -0.0036024621222168207, 0.044991832226514816, 0.0015879992861300707, -0.01282662246376276, 0.04320090264081955, 0.02384342812001705, -0.006431855261325836, 0.00809523556381464, -0.00300218746997416, -0.03688179329037666, 0.02517930418252945, 0.05442182719707489, -0.038939159363508224, 0.008088731206953526, 0.0060523031279444695, 0.061213310807943344, 0.04498884081840515, 0.017817309126257896, -0.01628866419196129, 0.039168741554021835, 0.04450284317135811, -0.02163456752896309, 0.0026053895708173513, -0.02889404073357582, -0.023207752034068108, -0.031623974442481995, -0.030263248831033707, -0.021421749144792557, -0.02758023887872696, -0.05103680491447449, 0.0026541671250015497, -0.029226915910840034, 0.03863155096769333, 0.00370596069842577, 0.026587892323732376, 0.015480495058000088, 0.0004832413687836379, -0.05245164409279823, -0.020970838144421577, 0.029802652075886726, -0.029179254546761513, 0.08445564657449722, -0.005210487637668848, -0.016936544328927994, -0.043970778584480286, 0.003974731080234051, -0.026145445182919502, 0.01958290860056877, -0.06688598543405533, 0.03736500069499016, 0.028770409524440765, 0.018651098012924194, -0.017287462949752808, 0.05024316906929016, 0.0715705081820488, -0.017736036330461502, 0.0022712908685207367, -0.03111487813293934, 0.03649107366800308, -0.05752834677696228, 0.014122211374342442, 0.019879858940839767, 0.004846635740250349, -0.014906675554811954, -0.02300134114921093, 0.004341474734246731, -0.055571697652339935, -0.0348699651658535, -0.041239216923713684, -0.00027789658633992076, -0.04060781002044678, -0.04036591947078705, -0.017115935683250427, 0.016657643020153046, 0.023607881739735603, 0.03269253671169281, 0.02066454291343689, 0.044839419424533844, 0.029408523812890053, -0.019269000738859177, -0.01159249059855938, 0.001120011555030942, -0.015066773630678654, 0.019460972398519516, 0.01319888886064291, -0.0025810522492974997, -0.03831976279616356, 0.0005252782721072435, 0.0714629590511322, -0.0410822331905365, 0.025197716429829597, -0.04910248517990112, 0.024915795773267746, 0.03731531277298927, 0.003288132604211569, -0.021338462829589844, 0.01523931697010994, 0.005181248299777508, -0.033173318952322006, 0.037415627390146255, 0.004845657851547003, -0.009609885513782501, 0.08701565861701965, 0.0016113512683659792, -0.008169231005012989, 0.024711119011044502, -0.0152805270627141, 0.012679887935519218, 0.07796350866556168, -0.001734591438435018, -0.0008270569960586727, 0.013360182754695415, -0.0080397455021739, 0.04624664783477783, -0.02382342517375946, -0.04254617169499397, -0.03714177384972572, 0.06152742728590965, 0.02871662937104702, -0.005082281772047281, -0.005865611135959625, -0.09388069808483124, 0.020675355568528175, -0.028224049136042595, -0.026746144518256187, -0.05036570876836777, -0.05678973346948624, -0.045120492577552795, -0.007480043917894363, 0.03379719704389572, 0.03860805183649063, -0.05221039056777954, 0.044943761080503464, 0.021006906405091286, 0.01588563248515129, -0.05628390982747078, -0.050861477851867676, -0.06050388142466545, -0.00638923142105341, 0.014120516367256641, -0.030932528898119926, -0.03855745121836662, 0.01644779182970524, -0.05832264944911003, -0.03364589810371399, -0.058998942375183105, 0.006781220436096191, -0.0034495696891099215, -0.0035657070111483335, 0.012279970571398735, -0.016936199739575386, -0.04362687095999718, -0.03348839282989502, -0.017793839797377586, -0.056200187653303146, -0.05438067391514778, 0.012686753645539284, -0.07135682553052902, 0.048996973782777786, 0.05865395441651344, -0.04618636146187782, 0.03627396747469902, -0.06911352276802063, -0.026911376044154167, 0.012142151594161987, 0.011694289743900299, 0.010000604204833508, 0.07995229214429855, -0.0020040252711623907, 0.04684104025363922, -0.01717356964945793, -0.011040178127586842, -0.021555569022893906, -0.02166604995727539, -0.0030842514242976904, -0.023091275244951248, 0.014323901385068893, 0.009295213036239147, -0.020827796310186386, 0.05792917311191559, -0.03454473242163658, -0.004522225819528103, -0.06077194586396217, -0.03937185928225517, -0.01600562036037445, 0.03018217347562313, 0.052744511514902115, -0.016641011461615562, 0.04417383298277855, -0.042539533227682114, 0.02043752372264862, 0.03140253201127052, 0.018883761018514633, -0.019625427201390266, -0.006213730201125145, 0.03352580964565277, -0.014248223975300789, 0.06540175527334213, -0.03690178692340851, -0.01873929426074028, 0.006937202997505665, 0.048040177673101425, -0.07319485396146774, 0.00777864595875144, -0.0035011665895581245, -0.05390411987900734, -0.023792650550603867, 0.02671055682003498, -0.019708119332790375, 0.027927931398153305, 0.04054764285683632, -0.009231913834810257, -0.009310233406722546, -0.02721119113266468, 0.07445407658815384, -0.12701521813869476, -0.02272426150739193, -0.007838090881705284, 0.008462928235530853, 0.015725942328572273, -0.026486791670322418, 0.0013020526384934783, 0.014843208715319633, -0.027404965832829475, 0.09167703986167908, 0.015498802997171879, -0.020405616611242294, -0.021237919107079506, 0.012703937478363514, 0.02921394445002079, -0.0608244389295578, 0.044673990458250046, -0.0015265721594914794, 0.06826083362102509, 0.013931150548160076, -0.009511291980743408, -0.06434808671474457, 0.021504847332835197, -0.0015778681263327599, -0.06786778569221497, -0.03682418167591095, -0.0013763870811089873, -0.08869009464979172, -0.012868975289165974, 0.0015859737759456038, -0.0362544059753418, -0.05293092131614685, -0.009809091687202454, 0.05939618498086929, 0.06618619710206985, 0.011578237637877464, 0.060250621289014816, -0.004397965036332607, 0.07068145275115967, -0.0023408543784171343, -0.05057315528392792, 0.012875746935606003, 0.031192271038889885, -0.034190114587545395, -0.01014129351824522, -0.024320852011442184, -0.04349660128355026, 0.01622244529426098, -0.08095917850732803, -0.08772172033786774, -0.007926885038614273, 0.006974040064960718, -0.0014724297216162086, 0.07301140576601028, 0.013775723055005074, 0.026437997817993164, -0.031086904928088188, -0.026119353249669075, -0.00612220261245966, 0.04586772248148918, -0.04838860034942627, 0.055621128529310226, 0.020738298073410988, -0.07114289700984955, 0.013017087243497372, -0.002282846486195922, 0.07317893207073212, 0.018867095932364464, 0.016608400270342827, -0.02146119810640812, -0.03434310853481293, 0.03796302154660225, -0.0008972435025498271, -0.040622565895318985, 0.026501841843128204, -0.03680666163563728, 0.017093531787395477, -0.02232905849814415, 0.013452162966132164, 0.022028326988220215, 0.0012455577962100506, 0.02931835502386093, -0.03191129490733147, -0.027543310075998306, -0.061900921165943146, 0.09298224002122879, 0.04207785800099373, 0.013789255172014236, -0.004183392506092787, -0.014708217233419418, 0.003766920417547226, -0.010400958359241486, 0.007279637735337019, -0.055117759853601456, -0.02894716151058674, -0.014721043407917023, -0.03172209858894348, 0.0029509493615478277, 0.012088513001799583, 0.02162201888859272, 0.04471655935049057, 0.011932930909097195, 0.018246270716190338, 0.016077131032943726, 0.014997649937868118, -0.0006960298051126301, -0.0475023128092289, 0.016872813925147057, 0.04226695001125336, 0.02568868175148964, 0.0445067435503006, 0.0037953995633870363, 0.0004925483954139054, 0.004680912476032972, -0.00903115514665842, 0.012400509789586067, -0.04946088790893555, -0.03646879643201828, 0.06871805340051651, -0.00708396453410387, -0.013556299731135368, 0.050522249191999435, -0.006305555813014507, 0.06717697530984879, 0.06492878496646881, -0.04377860948443413, -0.022665588185191154, -0.024588346481323242, -0.07142636924982071, 0.018954725936055183, -0.003404126036912203, 0.028117040172219276, -0.019769007340073586, -0.008468957617878914, 0.00771307572722435, -0.04029976949095726, -0.006011669058352709, -0.04869319126009941, 0.07360279560089111, -0.005125625059008598, 0.045997150242328644, 0.028034167364239693, 0.001604261458851397, 0.08440539985895157, 0.013073979876935482, -0.024108046665787697, 0.019380461424589157, 0.031453631818294525, 0.031053252518177032, -0.019777478650212288, -0.002578580752015114, 0.015971574932336807, -0.04338963329792023, -0.011860165745019913, -0.010617387481033802, -0.06120593100786209, 0.05960235744714737, 0.03802962228655815, -0.0271745715290308, -0.052078623324632645, -0.028035804629325867, -0.020714731886982918, -0.013506273739039898, 0.023023314774036407, 0.05355071276426315, -0.02515464834868908, -0.029438583180308342, 0.05450280010700226, 0.043707024306058884, 0.0649871975183487, -0.0018443036824464798, 0.016514085233211517, 0.03979141265153885, 0.04675767943263054, -0.018225768581032753, 0.03027133271098137, 0.007060034666210413, 0.0499500073492527, 0.019059263169765472, 0.052877750247716904, 0.07709755003452301, 0.031743694096803665, 0.06803039461374283, -0.004435161128640175, 0.048055294901132584, -0.000931729911826551, -0.03583788499236107, 0.02731543965637684, -0.04290938377380371, -0.09217473864555359, -0.0609060674905777, -0.0035007705446332693, -0.009403889998793602, 0.039918240159749985, -0.03275732696056366, -0.03959539905190468, 0.021747039631009102, 0.04299738630652428, -0.015749279409646988, 0.019959313794970512, 0.06166260689496994, -0.007082934956997633, -0.06145322695374489, 0.011308981105685234, 0.03480803221464157, 0.015128708444535732, 0.01268797367811203, -0.0314127653837204, -0.01305193267762661, 0.02213103510439396, -0.09636549651622772, 0.09318032115697861, -0.009691894054412842, 0.02457856759428978, -0.009252016432583332, 0.02628532610833645, 0.02502843551337719, -0.0036047648172825575, -0.0375199131667614, 0.03162370249629021, -0.05613042414188385, -0.054089102894067764, 0.023448148742318153, -0.07564406096935272, 0.025228042155504227, -0.06877011060714722, 0.016276704147458076, 0.048551782965660095, -0.00446671899408102, 0.05880647152662277, 0.02847689762711525, -0.03738335520029068, 0.013591728173196316, 0.009194382466375828, -0.03927059844136238, -0.011664955876767635, -0.07764243334531784, 0.03608151152729988, 0.004655054304748774, -0.0017684443155303597, 0.032141558825969696, -0.027889296412467957, -0.003816846292465925, 0.0076862904243171215, 0.034710779786109924, -0.007933239452540874, -0.07730285823345184, 0.014140247367322445, -0.043585505336523056, 0.013217397034168243, -0.05397716537117958, 0.04504796862602234, 0.02259436994791031, 0.008173086680471897, 0.015810001641511917, -0.021787339821457863, 0.046512290835380554, -0.023807400837540627, -0.0068497080355882645, 0.023932112380862236, 0.04868629574775696, 0.029789261519908905, 0.016154341399669647, 0.028211401775479317, 0.03902333229780197, -0.010321542620658875, 0.04045042768120766, 0.018976610153913498, -0.06936728209257126, -0.0161137618124485, -0.007867179811000824, -0.0046254112385213375, 0.025747861713171005, 0.005561606027185917, 0.09917337447404861, -0.02243734709918499, -0.0005423646653071046, -0.009902398101985455, 0.06645893305540085, -0.02924461103975773, 0.004086322616785765, 0.009161997586488724, -0.045939136296510696, -0.02215234935283661, -0.024964170530438423, 0.07038585096597672, -0.012796425260603428, 0.01604647934436798, 0.04212907329201698, -0.04959451034665108, 0.01893111877143383, -0.020133836194872856, -0.03635771572589874, -0.010873611085116863, 0.01869748905301094, -0.05108484998345375, -0.03624962270259857, 0.03330889344215393, -0.013391834683716297, -0.00416049687191844, -0.03515677526593208, -0.04523468390107155, 0.03661947697401047, 0.04246361181139946, 0.029536442831158638, -0.017131419852375984, -0.04024646431207657, -0.030911840498447418, 0.007157678250223398, -0.05737585574388504, 0.03312218189239502, 0.02229255624115467, -0.023686468601226807, 0.06034516915678978, 0.01735476218163967, 0.005151997320353985, -0.025539390742778778, -0.0019937874749302864, 0.04009266942739487, -0.06839556246995926, -0.096760593354702, -0.011698875576257706, 0.009631696157157421, 0.04152678698301315, -0.03131289407610893, -0.05085805058479309, -0.05063294246792793, 0.026770422235131264, 0.0021688384003937244, -0.016737723723053932, 0.074940025806427, 0.015322405844926834, -0.016141710802912712, 0.011991026811301708, -0.009188995696604252, -0.034037236124277115, -0.04135758429765701, -0.02548363246023655, 0.021670572459697723, -0.019485455006361008, 0.01294087152928114, 0.058656804263591766, 0.023330816999077797, 0.058730598539114, 0.00015259621432051063, 0.020667633041739464, 0.03835713118314743, 0.0040498157031834126, -0.07996988296508789, -0.018802572041749954, 0.04210865870118141, 0.034291282296180725, -0.020728550851345062, 0.0068773627281188965, -0.012721603736281395, -0.027364494279026985, 0.01860676519572735, -0.06743352860212326, 0.000903731444850564, 0.009074462577700615, 0.037342168390750885, -0.0022790031507611275, -0.03540085256099701, -0.021010693162679672, -0.0484352633357048, -0.0006267306162044406, 0.028969427570700645, 0.08307959884405136, 0.01934847980737686, 0.024899790063500404, 0.005953884217888117, -0.02466331422328949, -0.004486913792788982, 0.005704457871615887, 0.0017640256555750966, 0.05830514803528786, 0.04252244159579277, -0.004793567582964897, -0.0671643614768982, 0.006439684424549341, 0.05610140413045883, 0.007808937691152096, 0.03652709349989891, -0.05992209538817406, 0.054811906069517136, -0.013562324456870556, -0.0251883864402771, 0.04873848706483841, 0.039303913712501526, -0.02269594930112362, -0.08758580684661865, 0.001575706759467721, -0.054393596947193146, 0.006454551126807928, -0.027733808383345604, 0.06511134654283524, -0.028139937669038773, -0.013010960072278976, -0.07009492814540863, -0.006646351423114538, -0.0703459233045578, -0.06870812177658081, 0.0011462547117844224, -0.042279958724975586, 0.03408016264438629, 0.020243991166353226, 0.009426313452422619, 0.05396571382880211, -0.004428072366863489, -0.033386342227458954, 0.016115641221404076, -0.014448119327425957, -0.008571621961891651, 0.0025693238712847233, 0.0014914844650775194, 0.00227170018479228, 0.016088049858808517, 0.007528137881308794, -0.013239149004220963, 0.021297600120306015, -0.01605326496064663, -0.0105782775208354, 0.03604242950677872, 0.009699666872620583, -0.022707931697368622, 0.010116258636116982, -0.03786415606737137, 0.03606494516134262, -0.011871849186718464, -0.03441503643989563, 0.033362556248903275, -0.006348945200443268, 0.032679229974746704, -0.028825730085372925, -0.0020462721586227417, -0.026619302108883858, 0.0004508676938712597, -0.04222552105784416, 0.04553604498505592, 0.06532727181911469, -0.007230471819639206, 0.008213458582758904, 0.007730026263743639, 0.01242745015770197, 0.017113694921135902, 0.023922238498926163, 0.05165664106607437, 0.039476726204156876, 0.021188726648688316, -0.056652385741472244, -0.025952273979783058, -0.0026901259552687407, 0.019887618720531464, -0.04408147931098938, -0.034396540373563766, 0.034925494343042374, -0.00458414014428854, 0.010491338558495045, 0.02723700925707817, 0.045154303312301636, 0.06173982843756676, -0.03613564744591713, -0.05966408550739288, 0.003708138596266508, 0.025038765743374825, -0.021698882803320885, -0.02431618794798851, -0.025176122784614563, 0.016733789816498756, -0.04093929007649422, -0.05660182982683182, -0.04303067550063133, -0.005600570235401392, 0.02583784982562065, -0.053360238671302795, 0.011211098171770573, 0.0052872514352202415, 0.02053876779973507, -0.04255221039056778, 0.006623352877795696, -0.013114545494318008, 0.04034408554434776, -0.0070791966281831264, -0.04664309322834015, -0.06378395110368729, -0.009699770249426365, 0.01551680825650692, 0.005553278140723705, -0.049168653786182404, -0.011574006639420986, 0.017379920929670334, 0.012241174466907978, 0.00047852942952886224, 0.04996713250875473, 0.033754993230104446, 0.10753105580806732, -0.0015018421690911055, -0.03572023659944534, -0.0044736480340361595, -0.030602004379034042, 0.005284829996526241, -0.0051689138635993, 0.00695960596203804, 0.01676236465573311, -0.014390835538506508, 0.019008630886673927, -0.032151639461517334, -0.01383210439234972, 0.002708347048610449, 0.046065352857112885 ]
<p>The most simplified version of the energy equation (which is also the most known) is $E=mc^2$<br> However, I understand that this <em>only</em> applies to objects with non-zero mass and zero velocity. I also read that "relativistic mass" is equal to the "rest mass" multiplied by the Lorentz factor: $$ m=\gamma m_0 =\frac { { m }_{ 0 } }{ \sqrt { 1-\frac { { v }^{ 2 } }{ { c }^{ 2 } } } } $$ What exactly <em>IS</em> the "complete" equation for objects with non-zero mass that can be applied to objects with any velocity?</p> <p>My knowledge would suggest that the equation is: $$ E=\sqrt { { (\gamma m{ c }^{ 2 }) }^{ 2 }+{ (\gamma pc) }^{ 2 } } $$ where E is energy, $\gamma$ is the Lorentz factor, $m$ is the mass, $c$ is obviously the speed of light, and $p$ is the momentum of the object (defined as $p=mv$ but multiplied by the Lorentz factor because the mass increases with velocity)</p>
g1638
[ 0.05142645165324211, -0.027295134961605072, -0.0019647181034088135, 0.023610856384038925, 0.031199974939227104, -0.017796531319618225, 0.0489576980471611, 0.058207862079143524, -0.045422911643981934, -0.0005480586551129818, -0.033520348370075226, -0.01891394332051277, 0.01096309069544077, -0.011588683351874352, -0.023722372949123383, -0.032254356890916824, 0.06103856489062309, 0.0021345780696719885, -0.024648111313581467, 0.03574682027101517, 0.02670086920261383, -0.012787645682692528, 0.03306310996413231, -0.038610126823186874, -0.012169068679213524, 0.035340361297130585, 0.013307086192071438, 0.012353522703051567, -0.06492438167333603, -0.02760099433362484, 0.010227475315332413, 0.03625262528657913, 0.04984600841999054, -0.04980152100324631, 0.005954906344413757, -0.018883217126131058, 0.025452367961406708, 0.014574471861124039, 0.0206344872713089, 0.04631348326802254, 0.013797614723443985, 0.006090195849537849, -0.0024303270038217306, -0.031342748552560806, 0.01645727828145027, 0.010231967084109783, -0.028972633183002472, -0.025955483317375183, -0.02997073344886303, 0.007946096360683441, 0.003780250670388341, 0.02731126733124256, 0.09783506393432617, -0.031029177829623222, -0.027978021651506424, 0.00017078172822948545, 0.01687636971473694, -0.0000449142353318166, 0.018977968022227287, 0.05656002461910248, 0.045584674924612045, -0.05241808667778969, -0.027217922732234, -0.015507920645177364, 0.015227200463414192, 0.010773878544569016, -0.05656324699521065, -0.016580116003751755, 0.06281991302967072, -0.0033087781630456448, 0.018697969615459442, 0.008191283792257309, -0.04822476953268051, -0.02304140105843544, -0.024272339418530464, -0.060346346348524094, -0.02614995650947094, -0.020757699385285378, -0.01794304884970188, -0.03602252155542374, 0.023419354110956192, 0.02412067912518978, 0.026773255318403244, -0.03004547581076622, 0.05029040947556496, -0.032846901565790176, -0.020449664443731308, 0.002022374887019396, -0.003663980634883046, -0.020835338160395622, 0.03613407909870148, -0.026307865977287292, 0.025628596544265747, -0.041553325951099396, 0.047549400478601456, -0.015640011057257652, -0.00922686792910099, 0.07214511930942535, -0.013793105259537697, -0.0168546624481678, -0.021148717030882835, -0.023514140397310257, -0.0017923383275046945, 0.02809140831232071, 0.030188502743840218, -0.019726045429706573, -0.043195780366659164, 0.001940417685545981, 0.004944020416587591, 0.001990992808714509, -0.025530150160193443, -0.020241504535079002, 0.021618254482746124, -0.010849323123693466, -0.12280945479869843, -0.029015325009822845, 0.08440764248371124, -0.03644908219575882, -0.04327968508005142, 0.0792497843503952, 0.052513763308525085, 0.07257674634456635, 0.008414999581873417, 0.05495961010456085, -0.05171286687254906, -0.05377444624900818, 0.0037383430171757936, -0.007489004638046026, 0.013227771036326885, -0.04593190178275108, 0.013620981946587563, 0.016756998375058174, 0.018961388617753983, -0.03556402400135994, -0.03680509328842163, 0.053947027772665024, -0.005790060851722956, -0.01206955499947071, -0.027287054806947708, 0.0052885995246469975, 0.03218114748597145, -0.00270919781178236, 0.005395390558987856, 0.00020985507580917329, -0.06277046352624893, 0.050166044384241104, -0.027928194031119347, 0.02999904379248619, 0.028443273156881332, 0.06998461484909058, -0.04229328781366348, 0.0613119974732399, -0.029306482523679733, -0.0013907647226005793, 0.04744010046124458, -0.016986485570669174, 0.022516274824738503, -0.03121008351445198, -0.007536083925515413, 0.04739949479699135, 0.048721183091402054, 0.03631553053855896, 0.08679033815860748, -0.02444712072610855, -0.04623430222272873, 0.03961769491434097, 0.010701143182814121, -0.018056415021419525, -0.016119910404086113, -0.06872619688510895, -0.064128577709198, -0.03429732844233513, 0.00036513840314000845, 0.07283849269151688, -0.018414108082652092, -0.006514967884868383, 0.05906533822417259, -0.016343368217349052, -0.05052977427840233, -0.0398666150867939, 0.0014118151739239693, -0.04862133413553238, 0.05946891009807587, -0.016319984570145607, -0.00671370467171073, 0.015431195497512817, -0.026433255523443222, 0.09502887725830078, 0.0131043316796422, 0.03130918741226196, -0.03411628678441048, 0.02999681606888771, 0.008953258395195007, 0.02366410568356514, -0.005258241202682257, 0.07802173495292664, -0.014722888357937336, -0.00232298718765378, -0.04275819659233093, 0.011813849210739136, -0.007337087765336037, 0.047564417123794556, 0.001226288266479969, 0.011634266003966331, 0.079061359167099, -0.02689743973314762, 0.025492824614048004, -0.013581661507487297, 0.020695235580205917, 0.004212075844407082, 0.08224048465490341, -0.03631648048758507, -0.0017203601310029626, 0.032688822597265244, -0.012073936872184277, -0.029725871980190277, -0.05032988265156746, 0.019675254821777344, -0.03760277479887009, -0.004838910419493914, -0.03186138719320297, -0.004264818038791418, 0.05534720793366432, -0.010296626947820187, 0.005310641601681709, 0.020165791735053062, -0.036399468779563904, -0.049299806356430054, 0.02357511781156063, 0.013351015746593475, -0.010385788045823574, 0.07557501643896103, -0.01358059048652649, 0.028205307200551033, 0.059447288513183594, -0.029821127653121948, -0.04834332317113876, -0.0031048040837049484, 0.02307511493563652, 0.014833509922027588, 0.045169729739427567, -0.010310960933566093, 0.001814007293432951, -0.029638268053531647, 0.021311359480023384, -0.07114814966917038, 0.07713337242603302, -0.004396463744342327, 0.027470191940665245, 0.024613382294774055, 0.007740464061498642, -0.06031717732548714, -0.03897405415773392, 0.010403801687061787, 0.02528921328485012, -0.0173757616430521, -0.03410015627741814, 0.027357377111911774, -0.1241610050201416, -0.0020544356666505337, -0.028865111991763115, 0.0033380838576704264, 0.0008599847787991166, 0.04599030688405037, -0.061460237950086594, -0.020467650145292282, -0.03756715729832649, 0.03580345958471298, 0.03818019479513168, -0.010222532786428928, -0.017288705334067345, 0.03380340337753296, -0.04120444878935814, -0.017831096425652504, -0.00012847628386225551, -0.07133035361766815, 0.004213863052427769, 0.000741171243134886, 0.022348353639245033, -0.03035537153482437, 0.012934418395161629, 0.0025607217103242874, -0.017049700021743774, 0.00667935237288475, -0.026826554909348488, -0.08501830697059631, 0.027162674814462662, 0.02231500670313835, 0.015681080520153046, -0.031515270471572876, 0.017273908481001854, 0.023934660479426384, 0.003658593399450183, -0.003297224408015609, 0.018549226224422455, 0.058331046253442764, 0.037183262407779694, -0.015145395882427692, -0.023225590586662292, 0.014226861298084259, 0.011317107826471329, -0.01845572330057621, -0.005590563174337149, -0.04218530282378197, -0.029304729774594307, -0.008535332046449184, -0.015623558312654495, -0.06762389838695526, -0.0019207763252779841, -0.0103940824046731, -0.03873969987034798, 0.06570600718259811, 0.051572319120168686, 0.050542376935482025, -0.04296348616480827, 0.04567151144146919, -0.02128162421286106, -0.02740556374192238, 0.0016878849128261209, -0.03589487075805664, -0.022760558873414993, -0.05427878350019455, 0.05386042222380638, -0.032790981233119965, 0.03448415547609329, 0.035357795655727386, 0.021526454016566277, -0.016507595777511597, -0.05045067146420479, 0.028664302080869675, 0.01520837564021349, 0.03770604729652405, 0.00913910660892725, 0.015798574313521385, 0.011582146398723125, 0.0004186545265838504, 0.02065064013004303, 0.015272170305252075, 0.06328538060188293, 0.016510121524333954, 0.016892220824956894, -0.001149377436377108, -0.03088708035647869, 0.05490952730178833, 0.017034493386745453, 0.0021466773469001055, -0.03214498609304428, -0.04942271113395691, 0.03906675800681114, -0.06028635427355766, -0.010038215667009354, -0.013249536044895649, 0.006758378352969885, 0.004313318058848381, -0.04081064462661743, 0.006871174089610577, 0.007393040228635073, 0.0250919871032238, 0.05786552280187607, 0.01495642215013504, 0.04399961605668068, -0.019172513857483864, 0.04246494174003601, 0.04183664172887802, -0.00963485799729824, -0.07596773654222488, -0.021141454577445984, -0.012141798622906208, -0.022997388616204262, -0.04766714572906494, 0.03779209777712822, -0.0383434034883976, 0.01658014953136444, 0.02606864459812641, -0.006893746554851532, -0.023175431415438652, 0.022629840299487114, -0.018886346369981766, -0.06036762520670891, -0.018916748464107513, 0.04535137489438057, -0.07108055055141449, -0.02062266692519188, 0.03206681087613106, -0.04187744855880737, -0.017508523538708687, -0.06560447812080383, 0.0037326610181480646, 0.06071029230952263, 0.014356960542500019, 0.00533772399649024, -0.04568854719400406, -0.008717004209756851, 0.055386804044246674, 0.04040452837944031, -0.042338643223047256, 0.034198783338069916, -0.08329734951257706, -0.017712455242872238, 0.09081035852432251, -0.028149859979748726, 0.0872795581817627, 0.04523756355047226, -0.03041733242571354, -0.010250881314277649, 0.06983640044927597, 0.015633750706911087, -0.034405577927827835, 0.02875887043774128, -0.020600156858563423, 0.01947954297065735, -0.010484695434570312, 0.00817971769720316, -0.059700340032577515, 0.04805712029337883, -0.005999203305691481, -0.014360840432345867, -0.050930626690387726, -0.025273242965340614, 0.01568337343633175, -0.0109259570017457, -0.04568038880825043, -0.01642129383981228, -0.05363016948103905, -0.02680596336722374, 0.04073004052042961, 0.09313858300447464, 0.07489249110221863, -0.024844203144311905, 0.01928868517279625, 0.0634298175573349, 0.01635294035077095, 0.023627538233995438, 0.07305130362510681, -0.05194937810301781, 0.03996213153004646, 0.04922858625650406, 0.04240959510207176, 0.02333347499370575, -0.014420709572732449, 0.04941733926534653, 0.033334746956825256, 0.037491947412490845, 0.01879788003861904, -0.013706042431294918, 0.0361260324716568, -0.00496183056384325, -0.06279541552066803, -0.04538063332438469, -0.0013204232091084123, -0.022768571972846985, 0.02496655471622944, -0.019946914166212082, 0.009554990567266941, -0.013541357591748238, -0.023054691031575203, -0.04716207832098007, 0.03470255434513092, 0.07169356942176819, -0.011989260092377663, -0.06420575082302094, -0.011590502224862576, 0.062437523156404495, 0.01426233071833849, 0.07541866600513458, -0.012903059832751751, -0.029579386115074158, 0.009625653736293316, -0.0635092481970787, 0.0014073094353079796, -0.007323384750634432, 0.00012928164505865425, 0.009235930629074574, -0.01919999159872532, 0.005726515781134367, 0.009928855113685131, -0.02855680324137211, -0.04023756831884384, 0.006548683624714613, -0.02057328075170517, -0.03134380653500557, -0.0319443941116333, -0.005757697392255068, -0.02962062880396843, 0.008165246807038784, 0.03642162308096886, -0.02364162914454937, 0.07128461450338364, 0.03944210708141327, 0.02600581757724285, 0.020827822387218475, 0.04515323415398598, -0.07694768905639648, -0.052881985902786255, 0.02044193260371685, 0.054030921310186386, 0.006854477804154158, -0.0428098700940609, 0.03336988389492035, 0.0020172849763184786, -0.05988873541355133, 0.02755804918706417, 0.004746542777866125, 0.032897550612688065, 0.00955977663397789, 0.0003188285045325756, -0.030709972605109215, -0.010312921367585659, -0.011315198615193367, 0.05964681878685951, 0.00042917183600366116, 0.018657641485333443, 0.022222446277737617, 0.0025338397826999426, -0.016642717644572258, -0.026633521541953087, -0.011001876555383205, -0.00582636334002018, 0.034928031265735626, 0.029466748237609863, 0.012040816247463226, -0.04177911579608917, 0.0056941332295536995, 0.03210750222206116, 0.005643692333251238, 0.005208224523812532, -0.016491757705807686, -0.003295071190223098, 0.007822130806744099, 0.06814321875572205, -0.00048337827320210636, -0.03449036926031113, 0.06469670683145523, -0.03375638276338577, -0.0463530458509922, -0.036085497587919235, -0.0018687963020056486, -0.0030312216840684414, 0.00692117540165782, -0.0003993089485447854, -0.0072183022275567055, -0.011600840836763382, 0.017498373985290527, 0.07455966621637344, -0.014682913199067116, 0.02635454759001732, 0.030888551846146584, -0.013677784241735935, -0.010806670412421227, -0.06937722116708755, -0.03858397528529167, -0.04559873789548874, 0.021469034254550934, -0.02416631020605564, 0.016332468017935753, -0.0038197904359549284, 0.024968989193439484, 0.0024612676352262497, -0.050272222608327866, -0.056510794907808304, -0.0011834395118057728, -0.0223216749727726, 0.05659123882651329, 0.021033206954598427, -0.020714379847049713, -0.09184598922729492, -0.00966991763561964, -0.06569952517747879, 0.010847981087863445, -0.016188986599445343, -0.05986367166042328, 0.06232820451259613, -0.005623788107186556, -0.02091403491795063, 0.01599792391061783, 0.0035492866300046444, -0.0019986603874713182, -0.05188910290598869, -0.05676168575882912, -0.011180976405739784, 0.02774994820356369, 0.028114108368754387, -0.003746709553524852, -0.00788079109042883, 0.0061409128829836845, 0.0343334898352623, -0.014330486766994, -0.029122617095708847, 0.031692907214164734, 0.02002597413957119, -0.0036474340595304966, 0.022931253537535667, -0.03246498852968216, -0.06654153019189835, -0.044103365391492844, 0.008235589601099491, 0.04125324264168739, -0.027901066467165947, 0.013251278549432755, 0.04610145464539528, -0.020835578441619873, 0.037365250289440155, 0.001351859187707305, 0.03234049677848816, 0.06562761962413788, -0.0031183490063995123, -0.06038755550980568, -0.011539819650352001, -0.02462141029536724, -0.04872734472155571, -0.03289136663079262, 0.03325534239411354, 0.031129762530326843, -0.05688079819083214, -0.051146626472473145, 0.0036926064640283585, -0.06740321218967438, 0.07151441276073456, 0.022786004468798637, -0.0434882678091526, -0.028634589165449142, -0.050067443400621414, 0.04059867188334465, -0.04187336191534996, 0.0368158333003521, 0.025707952678203583, 0.019496725872159004, 0.05562031641602516, 0.027552777901291847, -0.06830655038356781, -0.00866627786308527, 0.006897762417793274, 0.001956064021214843, 0.021504279226064682, 0.026905087754130363, 0.017586229369044304, -0.024482471868395805, -0.00018381279369350523, 0.04896737262606621, 0.009623877704143524, 0.004262865986675024, 0.0029140098486095667, -0.009424889460206032, -0.00379617209546268, -0.07091793417930603, -0.00014769454719498754, 0.036686986684799194, 0.018080979585647583, -0.11048929393291473, -0.051077693700790405, -0.05780830979347229, -0.024553827941417694, -0.006619791034609079, 0.0037887259386479855, -0.08211146295070648, 0.013331446796655655, -0.02751966193318367, 0.01869184896349907, 0.02792307361960411, -0.04542941972613335, 0.009794296696782112, 0.0020911593455821276, 0.021652834489941597, -0.011773507110774517, -0.05208258703351021, 0.07300393283367157, 0.005825858563184738, -0.031533148139715195, 0.007187332957983017, 0.018673058599233627, 0.013833641074597836, -0.0407714769244194, -0.044297099113464355, 0.004560818430036306, -0.05722036585211754, 0.021536365151405334, -0.027239060029387474, 0.020543213933706284, -0.03064657188951969, -0.031273018568754196, 0.009373004548251629, 0.06778129935264587, -0.03849545866250992, 0.011897819116711617, -0.015660544857382774, -0.0011703865602612495, -0.0013700518757104874, 0.008468163199722767, 0.004902325104922056, 0.020870598033070564, -0.045710038393735886, 0.0503493957221508, 0.04165475443005562, -0.03363622725009918, -0.046992480754852295, -0.028441499918699265, 0.006911018863320351, 0.037734851241111755, 0.02589038759469986, 0.022888269275426865, -0.004699926823377609, -0.043987955898046494, -0.014962722547352314, 0.029782462865114212, -0.00026177207473665476, 0.04324774816632271, 0.012525181286036968, -0.02532259188592434, -0.016433632001280785, 0.00481715053319931, 0.033267583698034286, -0.021260710433125496, -0.006305698771029711, 0.013483874499797821, -0.03021070919930935, -0.0007574779447168112, -0.028317010030150414, 0.06991787999868393, -0.008807254023849964, -0.022209199145436287, 0.014765871688723564, 0.040221959352493286, 0.007733460050076246, -0.05164463073015213, -0.01008223369717598, -0.007582721300423145, -0.039181869477033615, -0.003945971839129925, 0.053104329854249954, -0.02722811885178089, -0.0031685701105743647, 0.015651885420084, -0.03729447349905968, 0.0936104878783226, 0.008257860317826271, 0.007643954362720251, -0.018150754272937775, -0.02070244587957859, 0.035164084285497665, 0.035125553607940674, 0.01554629672318697, -0.05145268514752388, -0.04719070717692375, 0.024808920919895172, 0.006862340960651636, -0.00045104316086508334, 0.012501407414674759, -0.005772293545305729, 0.07047619670629501, 0.001657938351854682, 0.03821178153157234, 0.0296921543776989, -0.01332262996584177, 0.05510430783033371, 0.06328241527080536, -0.07988771051168442, 0.052326496690511703, -0.038622017949819565, -0.015329557470977306, -0.011167647317051888, -0.027074670419096947, 0.016530580818653107, -0.014150772243738174, 0.007414135150611401, 0.01610025018453598, -0.07350441068410873, -0.010357504710555077, 0.05816034600138664 ]
<p>I'm quite lost what $B$ and $H$ is. It seams to me that most of the texts I read do quite poor job in explaining them properly. They are explained only in cases when magnetic susceptibility is constant in the space. </p> <p>First <em>law</em> says that $M = \chi H$, $M$ is magnetization and to my understanding $H$ is something like external magnetic field (for example Earth magnetic field when I do experiment in some lab).</p> <p>Next <em>law</em> says that magnetic field is $B = \mu_0(M+H) = \mu H$. This has to be wrong when $\chi$ is not constant because than we are not guarantied that divergence of $B$ is zero. $$ \nabla \cdot B = \nabla \cdot (\mu H ) \neq \mu \nabla \cdot H = 0 $$</p> <p>Can you please direct me to some book when this is explained properly?</p> <p>My aim: I want to calculate magnetic field around paramagnetic material. I cannot use formula $B = \mu H$ because outside paramagnet is $\mu = \mu_0$ so magnetic field would be unchanged.</p>
g1639
[ 0.03692040964961052, 0.005841647740453482, -0.016909271478652954, 0.02352929301559925, 0.013801652006804943, 0.027084676548838615, 0.01112966425716877, 0.0769796296954155, -0.042313579469919205, -0.026596833020448685, -0.07036145776510239, 0.060014013200998306, -0.0027405761647969484, -0.000302046857541427, 0.055705584585666656, -0.0313187800347805, -0.01483935583382845, 0.022190172225236893, -0.01503701414912939, -0.03713016211986542, -0.032379407435655594, 0.06566216796636581, -0.022066596895456314, -0.057109393179416656, -0.03115314431488514, 0.036156509071588516, 0.014475387521088123, 0.0273792315274477, -0.0051822783425450325, -0.07876604050397873, -0.004783874377608299, -0.005139462649822235, 0.08261370658874512, -0.033150821924209595, 0.003602227196097374, 0.02323397994041443, -0.01684088073670864, -0.014333071187138557, 0.00551047595217824, -0.0002118678530678153, 0.03949851542711258, -0.049758180975914, 0.036175623536109924, -0.03278016671538353, -0.011222436092793941, 0.0134381502866745, -0.04378966614603996, -0.019651595503091812, 0.014997744001448154, 0.011003227904438972, -0.04191431403160095, 0.019689077511429787, 0.16765587031841278, 0.0056158388033509254, 0.033247604966163635, 0.025428585708141327, 0.057984232902526855, -0.039924219250679016, 0.01383126899600029, 0.0016172484029084444, 0.024876801297068596, 0.02657204121351242, -0.02845568209886551, 0.01068464107811451, 0.014328230172395706, -0.02488299459218979, -0.031175898388028145, -0.06803691387176514, -0.05620722100138664, 0.05101896822452545, 0.04568924009799957, -0.06477952003479004, 0.02794899046421051, -0.025476744398474693, -0.08885761350393295, 0.014769291505217552, 0.011974846944212914, -0.015950238332152367, 0.05347130820155144, 0.042353272438049316, -0.02710496075451374, 0.027611147612333298, 0.01115602906793356, 0.04942289739847183, 0.014060371555387974, 0.01740710809826851, -0.021732639521360397, 0.008201193064451218, -0.007588907610625029, -0.01979794353246689, -0.009268730878829956, 0.012766867876052856, 0.022628823295235634, -0.018186677247285843, 0.011140353977680206, 0.006672474090009928, 0.026381487026810646, 0.012354418635368347, -0.014094119891524315, 0.0013966145925223827, -0.029463239014148712, 0.0118981609120965, 0.00363127957098186, 0.02478092722594738, 0.02504749596118927, 0.04610656574368477, 0.06567395478487015, 0.01527028065174818, -0.03684941306710243, 0.006996029056608677, -0.05540166050195694, 0.008451107889413834, -0.07391706109046936, -0.04356536269187927, -0.037329040467739105, -0.00469565112143755, 0.023190921172499657, -0.07835406810045242, 0.030982092022895813, 0.0608089305460453, 0.031923457980155945, 0.010836182162165642, 0.06082513928413391, 0.04416031762957573, -0.020984645932912827, 0.0027823171112686396, -0.024221818894147873, 0.02663707360625267, 0.0576595664024353, -0.04247239977121353, 0.031662147492170334, -0.004483355209231377, 0.02842842973768711, 0.0003799745172727853, -0.008385399356484413, 0.022778747603297234, 0.03148329630494118, 0.011270432732999325, -0.052340105175971985, -0.016140958294272423, -0.03040669485926628, -0.030634580180048943, 0.0314619205892086, -0.05924524366855621, -0.04741707444190979, 0.03164874389767647, 0.0009567373781464994, -0.01696750521659851, 0.029463907703757286, -0.01400439441204071, 0.03925425186753273, 0.11111095547676086, 0.012803463265299797, 0.03565937653183937, 0.0031268270686268806, -0.022034812718629837, 0.04040547087788582, -0.023183060809969902, 0.015390820801258087, 0.008114030584692955, 0.016373861581087112, -0.023763595148921013, -0.04225040227174759, 0.029114361852407455, 0.023268256336450577, -0.007917974144220352, 0.023386048153042793, -0.01774541288614273, -0.001398057327605784, -0.03451284021139145, -0.028983991593122482, 0.010989787988364697, 0.04722455516457558, 0.07823323458433151, -0.023031003773212433, 0.024963224306702614, 0.02627282589673996, -0.024173682555556297, -0.003432363970205188, 0.016377469524741173, 0.0035981007385998964, -0.00025393840041942894, 0.05310690775513649, 0.012695138342678547, -0.057977233082056046, 0.03534039855003357, -0.03106437437236309, -0.019627051427960396, -0.06932143867015839, -0.05365453287959099, -0.027448490262031555, 0.0034511436242610216, 0.006071317009627819, 0.04455269128084183, 0.0016877142479643226, 0.0121390325948596, -0.013615231029689312, 0.0666886642575264, 0.029538922011852264, -0.015061208978295326, -0.0024652592837810516, 0.045458052307367325, 0.07311984151601791, -0.018989739939570427, 0.020630912855267525, 0.008618763647973537, 0.0043760547414422035, -0.0029514252673834562, 0.026644857600331306, 0.009052380919456482, -0.008345412090420723, -0.02990904450416565, -0.007671615574508905, 0.03992287069559097, -0.009173495694994926, -0.008847110904753208, -0.04039081558585167, 0.029629282653331757, -0.05491568520665169, -0.0034199021756649017, 0.013284442946314812, 0.0017720715841278434, 0.07039787620306015, 0.034288953989744186, -0.07720528542995453, 0.02472301572561264, 0.006030399352312088, 0.05249043181538582, 0.030322277918457985, -0.05680156871676445, -0.02824321575462818, -0.032841432839632034, 0.02397872507572174, -0.01911226287484169, 0.008250830695033073, 0.004831795115023851, 0.021970044821500778, -0.044488925486803055, 0.07290305197238922, 0.01880219765007496, -0.04665004834532738, 0.026049364358186722, 0.023262059316039085, 0.02959574945271015, 0.02736307494342327, -0.04929417744278908, 0.06795526295900345, -0.04004848003387451, -0.011518326587975025, 0.007337565999478102, 0.008609242737293243, -0.0217505544424057, 0.0263433326035738, 0.03009958565235138, -0.03221280500292778, 0.025899682193994522, -0.02827683463692665, -0.025436971336603165, -0.12022346258163452, -0.010076667182147503, 0.02694711647927761, -0.053889039903879166, 0.03940214589238167, 0.05832056701183319, -0.08832324296236038, -0.05425866320729256, -0.04029421880841255, 0.0025058020837605, 0.05587969347834587, -0.03609350323677063, -0.052047450095415115, 0.07039427012205124, 0.03157919645309448, 0.021089911460876465, -0.03659159690141678, -0.055055372416973114, 0.04677269607782364, -0.03025195747613907, 0.0033210651017725468, -0.007087842561304569, -0.04162883386015892, 0.010967813432216644, -0.054982736706733704, -0.06423977017402649, 0.009196925908327103, 0.0009908110368996859, -0.04571075737476349, 0.011372669599950314, -0.01740191876888275, 0.030104154720902443, 0.003258849959820509, 0.013830116018652916, 0.03765080124139786, 0.04027966782450676, -0.01169427577406168, 0.09169944375753403, 0.06071418523788452, -0.013512242585420609, -0.03593693673610687, 0.03161601722240448, -0.01016074139624834, -0.0026065753772854805, -0.0009314756607636809, 0.011851239949464798, -0.01537144836038351, -0.013919888064265251, -0.030406588688492775, -0.09257178753614426, -0.023812310770154, 0.07692031562328339, -0.07379903644323349, -0.03163778409361839, 0.01756344363093376, -0.012331010773777962, 0.03886988386511803, -0.0019409776432439685, -0.0485507994890213, 0.026019470766186714, 0.06283117830753326, 0.0006349114119075239, -0.024043135344982147, -0.06694362312555313, 0.04507381096482277, -0.0025740289129316807, 0.03902935981750488, 0.00548228994011879, -0.05463764816522598, 0.006098794750869274, -0.026157068088650703, -0.018387869000434875, -0.026289092376828194, -0.014619067311286926, 0.02165904827415943, -0.020852001383900642, -0.0792514979839325, -0.03247265890240669, 0.05120808258652687, 0.007569152861833572, -0.01067219115793705, -0.02664334885776043, 0.04175984486937523, -0.004679722711443901, -0.0495925173163414, 0.013713200576603413, -0.017820270732045174, -0.0016261825803667307, 0.016692029312253, -0.018042685464024544, 0.01572776772081852, 0.00352112902328372, 0.026460057124495506, 0.0292393509298563, 0.08598419278860092, 0.026425421237945557, -0.03486856818199158, 0.05062226951122284, 0.033414121717214584, -0.02483821101486683, -0.05593689903616905, 0.011528807692229748, -0.03396207466721535, 0.00023724370112176985, 0.02084248512983322, 0.046362172812223434, -0.036706000566482544, -0.008194437250494957, 0.03806300461292267, 0.02242608368396759, 0.007711539976298809, -0.06578158587217331, 0.03930693119764328, 0.0034586945548653603, -0.005695239175111055, 0.023039115592837334, -0.00407278910279274, -0.052540089935064316, 0.0229252427816391, 0.012212930247187614, -0.03496327996253967, 0.00700879143550992, 0.00922875665128231, 0.03340904042124748, 0.021910082548856735, 0.09666603058576584, 0.02500789985060692, 0.00016931565187405795, -0.008198786526918411, 0.04987660050392151, 0.05649137496948242, 0.02525925077497959, -0.0012092601973563433, 0.02086450718343258, 0.012334533035755157, -0.015789320692420006, 0.02668156661093235, 0.007395535707473755, -0.026759998872876167, 0.0318063348531723, -0.006516275927424431, -0.012115268036723137, 0.04759744554758072, -0.02159617282450199, -0.030485542491078377, 0.018382513895630836, -0.00791084673255682, -0.003664243733510375, 0.024939630180597305, 0.004739631433039904, 0.09277582913637161, -0.0022449230309575796, 0.03027990460395813, -0.022945430129766464, -0.08205728977918625, -0.02896788902580738, 0.07545919716358185, 0.012293839827179909, 0.009751982055604458, -0.009214017540216446, -0.014459104277193546, -0.05356360971927643, -0.02280455268919468, 0.01013642456382513, -0.006340972613543272, -0.09456198662519455, -0.006632708944380283, -0.00233003799803555, 0.034763872623443604, 0.029224127531051636, 0.04443319886922836, -0.01192587148398161, 0.033394500613212585, 0.03626834973692894, -0.04076075181365013, 0.026637179777026176, -0.09660495817661285, 0.007417839486151934, -0.05101747438311577, 0.022237205877900124, -0.03358607366681099, -0.020283129066228867, 0.05749017745256424, 0.030298501253128052, 0.012266043573617935, 0.03210567682981491, -0.05184509977698326, 0.009832235984504223, -0.03881113603711128, -0.04322810843586922, -0.021723072975873947, -0.053807877004146576, -0.029180381447076797, 0.028898900374770164, 0.004804129712283611, -0.035392407327890396, -0.029737042263150215, -0.03166153281927109, -0.003428748808801174, 0.02814745530486107, 0.061863698065280914, 0.041321948170661926, -0.06011578440666199, 0.028960557654500008, 0.009320495650172234, 0.02417008951306343, -0.010490751825273037, 0.00040196042391471565, -0.023062221705913544, -0.017077187076210976, -0.004699051380157471, 0.06514357775449753, 0.0030851245392113924, 0.060575321316719055, 0.05546879395842552, -0.08999926596879959, 0.06868745386600494, 0.05421469733119011, 0.016185542568564415, 0.014845849946141243, -0.01439873967319727, -0.04864617809653282, -0.02000318095088005, -0.006493130698800087, 0.012285945937037468, 0.0804186463356018, -0.034755196422338486, 0.017163898795843124, -0.004543649964034557, 0.0002959873527288437, -0.01999783329665661, -0.029575679451227188, -0.03529898077249527, -0.03755655139684677, 0.036743566393852234, -0.00880725309252739, 0.0006906601483933628, -0.018561754375696182, -0.03672876954078674, -0.05128374695777893, -0.04034293070435524, -0.04358821362257004, -0.047720763832330704, -0.0024692669976502657, -0.004679532255977392, -0.006815608590841293, -0.0013360566226765513, 0.05847321078181267, 0.023584460839629173, -0.0382247120141983, 0.01846243441104889, 0.020713098347187042, -0.008743775077164173, 0.03177876025438309, -0.01186042744666338, -0.009982150048017502, 0.03965630754828453, -0.007627201732248068, -0.007404107600450516, 0.009745588526129723, 0.010344848036766052, -0.021629752591252327, 0.02317880094051361, -0.01470737624913454, 0.03139505162835121, -0.00951400212943554, 0.016062429174780846, -0.017197245731949806, -0.044305071234703064, -0.01448096614331007, 0.01031478587538004, 0.11257345974445343, 0.009624369442462921, 0.02901768870651722, 0.03314870595932007, -0.027522435411810875, 0.018727513030171394, -0.011190271936357021, 0.028180500492453575, 0.003609380219131708, 0.0038606049492955208, 0.06979796290397644, -0.023686638101935387, -0.024187253788113594, 0.004993528127670288, -0.00655733235180378, -0.00436669634655118, 0.022872215136885643, -0.003167251357808709, 0.011122402735054493, 0.018542243167757988, -0.024878889322280884, -0.06896700710058212, 0.011163781397044659, 0.026059679687023163, -0.025413276627659798, -0.003978951834142208, 0.015070847235620022, 0.0243371594697237, 0.005216565914452076, -0.0011486191069707274, 0.02102871984243393, 0.031078670173883438, -0.020354826003313065, -0.06654542684555054, 0.012820722535252571, 0.008425865322351456, -0.04949900880455971, 0.009410693310201168, 0.027410758659243584, 0.033705852925777435, 0.022555062547326088, -0.034833017736673355, 0.009633436799049377, -0.008577191270887852, -0.009674977511167526, 0.04530513286590576, 0.05334780737757683, 0.0019255237421020865, -0.06320007145404816, -0.03894156590104103, 0.009520836174488068, 0.04703068733215332, 0.020225167274475098, -0.0006914825644344091, -0.02978208288550377, -0.028794869780540466, 0.05050729960203171, -0.06922611594200134, -0.04618682339787483, 0.040774017572402954, -0.02470225654542446, 0.04038441181182861, 0.002342886058613658, -0.014113321900367737, -0.005247348453849554, 0.020075427368283272, -0.015034248121082783, -0.008919461630284786, -0.0036161181051284075, -0.0215230043977499, -0.050450123846530914, -0.01694214716553688, -0.023918649181723595, -0.033884987235069275, -0.03015735372900963, 0.039927106350660324, 0.013599079102277756, -0.012870832346379757, -0.028133219107985497, -0.029603149741888046, -0.009522788226604462, 0.037395134568214417, -0.047817084938287735, -0.04971824213862419, 0.019124172627925873, 0.024273522198200226, -0.03511623665690422, -0.05036826431751251, 0.08530031144618988, -0.027400121092796326, 0.037222351878881454, -0.04448341205716133, -0.06526961177587509, -0.015199387446045876, -0.010317374020814896, 0.03580493479967117, 0.04845696687698364, 0.02247694879770279, 0.011273577809333801, 0.003201262792572379, -0.016565846279263496, -0.006151146255433559, 0.006897693034261465, 0.006089351139962673, 0.03594371676445007, -0.012697764672338963, -0.02812384068965912, 0.03455887734889984, 0.02910703420639038, 0.013679763302206993, 0.04909948632121086, -0.037315353751182556, -0.05438447371125221, 0.031233301386237144, 0.031080972403287888, 0.014398911967873573, -0.05639040842652321, 0.009960968978703022, -0.04298533871769905, -0.030514802783727646, 0.02711813524365425, -0.024887820705771446, -0.023254329338669777, 0.0015359313692897558, -0.033460844308137894, -0.038292866200208664, 0.03448060154914856, 0.053176358342170715, 0.03022065944969654, -0.009374363347887993, -0.08408291637897491, 0.0012217777548357844, 0.0013580151135101914, 0.0059666079469025135, -0.009964440949261189, 0.05109444633126259, -0.017606904730200768, 0.0022661311086267233, -0.00414984580129385, 0.018120769411325455, -0.034083291888237, -0.022335808724164963, 0.001403607428073883, 0.007561265490949154, 0.04272899776697159, -0.05784657225012779, 0.024688735604286194, -0.028335915878415108, 0.027777893468737602, 0.0002502072893548757, -0.007480727508664131, -0.011238466016948223, -0.013414835557341576, -0.025283530354499817, -0.02394472435116768, -0.017604190856218338, -0.026467973366379738, -0.08874259144067764, 0.03588562458753586, 0.057009078562259674, 0.017168719321489334, -0.019814930856227875, -0.049428801983594894, 0.03478313982486725, -0.05071796104311943, -0.00473368912935257, -0.018113749101758003, 0.06893015652894974, 0.06724787503480911, 0.0694735199213028, -0.04423583671450615, -0.009839472360908985, -0.02900448627769947, -0.014430704526603222, 0.0007452552672475576, -0.005544964224100113, -0.0012525797355920076, 0.009084283374249935, -0.024469325318932533, -0.026825886219739914, -0.023446939885616302, -0.03908314183354378, 0.035541895776987076, 0.06173047050833702, -0.01334408950060606, -0.0068443333730101585, 0.026918014511466026, -0.05995043367147446, -0.04022400453686714, -0.04940824955701828, -0.019207924604415894, -0.011059963144361973, 0.018513832241296768, 0.025098131969571114, -0.07530716806650162, -0.02336067147552967, -0.055593639612197876, -0.045775916427373886, 0.019694963470101357, -0.032272979617118835, 0.0047473241575062275, -0.07629307359457016, -0.01971953921020031, -0.018287690356373787, -0.030606498941779137, -0.03331732749938965, 0.034401506185531616, 0.02305701933801174, -0.05639885365962982, 0.020885249599814415, -0.0011427383869886398, 0.027138540521264076, -0.05492154881358147, -0.04752662777900696, 0.020918581634759903, -0.029844503849744797, 0.004720623604953289, -0.06400174647569656, 0.033235132694244385, 0.05181248113512993, -0.02037227898836136, 0.0051917158998548985, 0.03217945992946625, -0.016542859375476837, 0.023585299029946327, 0.08194462954998016, -0.05052373185753822, 0.0026278423611074686, 0.06625901162624359, 0.04813697561621666, 0.04795496538281441, -0.018894409760832787, -0.04126482084393501, -0.016349339857697487, 0.03182750940322876, 0.01032287161797285, 0.020616063848137856, -0.024776073172688484, 0.018458465114235878 ]
<ol> <li><p>If any configuration of matter can fall into a black hole and hit the singularity, and ditto for the big crunch, and there is time reversal CPT invariance, does it mean anything can pop out of the big bang singularity, and there is unpredictability at the big bang? </p></li> <li><p>How do we explain the very low entropy of the big bang then?</p></li> </ol>
g1640
[ 0.03390903398394585, 0.009856033138930798, -0.0009585358202457428, -0.04177870601415634, 0.02640359103679657, 0.0508008748292923, 0.025634363293647766, 0.048986587673425674, -0.08633044362068176, -0.030760632827878, 0.018814409151673317, -0.011119662784039974, 0.05462346971035004, -0.03620384633541107, -0.04813593998551369, -0.011837044730782509, 0.03469602391123772, -0.0017913960618898273, 0.02593851648271084, 0.04326311871409416, -0.001579049858264625, 0.0042432439513504505, 0.011597794480621815, -0.049931421875953674, -0.01139940693974495, -0.01335992943495512, 0.026691677048802376, -0.0015300216618925333, -0.02921888791024685, -0.015511577017605305, 0.08278167992830276, 0.008752538822591305, 0.001182461972348392, -0.06593149155378342, -0.02228611893951893, -0.011866804212331772, 0.036974094808101654, -0.048985496163368225, 0.031320735812187195, -0.03158962354063988, 0.016948731616139412, 0.011640030890703201, 0.03343994542956352, -0.07748600095510483, -0.05465039983391762, 0.028385113924741745, 0.020415298640727997, 0.05446429178118706, -0.001670352416113019, -0.04903067648410797, -0.009680056944489479, -0.047545719891786575, 0.05863361060619354, -0.008275655098259449, 0.022235160693526268, 0.03737436607480049, 0.049946129322052, -0.00914998259395361, 0.03518040478229523, 0.007524557411670685, -0.0029986421577632427, 0.008010060526430607, 0.03893740102648735, 0.044359225779771805, 0.024913640692830086, -0.03763452172279358, -0.020726343616843224, -0.015528900548815727, 0.015743786469101906, -0.03674318641424179, 0.017747487872838974, -0.019731177017092705, -0.004237540066242218, 0.026857562363147736, -0.059997525066137314, 0.06218542903661728, -0.010914086364209652, -0.006865821313112974, -0.018522609025239944, -0.03123796544969082, -0.0759921446442604, 0.03024470806121826, -0.029659492895007133, 0.042235080152750015, 0.06339073181152344, -0.01180395856499672, 0.004108283668756485, 0.013827386312186718, 0.01099559385329485, 0.021264411509037018, 0.02491939067840576, -0.015308334492146969, 0.025895744562149048, -0.02755524404346943, 0.01733269728720188, 0.018507709726691246, 0.032933030277490616, 0.043072886765003204, -0.04570302739739418, 0.026811236515641212, -0.051804956048727036, 0.04515676572918892, -0.02283870242536068, -0.015730852261185646, -0.0427670031785965, -0.013298732228577137, -0.013780356384813786, -0.008402546867728233, -0.0162651464343071, -0.0161125548183918, -0.0032969152089208364, -0.024381952360272408, 0.017522556707262993, 0.007460134569555521, -0.06275609880685806, 0.05500701442360878, 0.0838744044303894, -0.027513941749930382, -0.03204009681940079, 0.0381917878985405, 0.022949695587158203, -0.007046299055218697, -0.01931937038898468, 0.05131066218018532, -0.04835439845919609, 0.05269108712673187, -0.007548867259174585, -0.015570406801998615, 0.01688220724463463, -0.026902128010988235, -0.026161840185523033, -0.0003576013259589672, -0.006830697413533926, 0.01293314341455698, 0.03577880561351776, -0.01850724034011364, 0.015158253721892834, 0.02056919038295746, 0.03269615024328232, 0.014380324631929398, -0.0005260956240817904, -0.0015886510955169797, -0.022319873794913292, 0.04771491140127182, 0.0220938827842474, -0.025733167305588722, -0.037855248898267746, 0.03215930610895157, -0.00556403212249279, 0.018950624391436577, 0.02899126522243023, 0.05965530872344971, -0.015897052362561226, -0.02896525338292122, -0.041604261845350266, 0.01565963216125965, 0.05074526369571686, 0.0348186269402504, 0.007984653115272522, -0.005919343791902065, 0.04822657257318497, -0.03079569898545742, 0.026862556114792824, 0.014863929711282253, -0.0464230477809906, 0.026467885822057724, 0.003025887766852975, -0.0004850239783991128, 0.013146639801561832, -0.042593758553266525, -0.050205595791339874, -0.0016137100756168365, 0.000578631937969476, 0.0639922246336937, 0.030445607379078865, -0.0330260694026947, -0.040392182767391205, 0.023775318637490273, 0.011099345982074738, -0.05223757028579712, -0.003873127978295088, 0.031578171998262405, -0.014590775594115257, 0.01685381680727005, 0.040064696222543716, -0.017713280394673347, 0.043037984520196915, 0.017762983217835426, -0.04842295125126839, 0.0077618686482310295, 0.012359293177723885, -0.015738198533654213, -0.020259303972125053, 0.03644929453730583, 0.07574889808893204, -0.03556909039616585, 0.06018004193902016, 0.0009413189254701138, -0.03634246066212654, -0.02365092746913433, 0.051517460495233536, 0.012597491964697838, 0.045621082186698914, 0.029423857107758522, 0.003206957597285509, 0.037572987377643585, -0.06292682886123657, 0.03817867487668991, 0.049974340945482254, -0.016896814107894897, -0.0005447661387734115, -0.04460473731160164, -0.016504058614373207, -0.02802933380007744, -0.04965047910809517, 0.026840446516871452, -0.01177394762635231, 0.013210552744567394, -0.03343253582715988, 0.0024933344684541225, -0.0026936957146972418, 0.002625727327540517, -0.027157066389918327, 0.01418901327997446, 0.0110885389149189, 0.051937445998191833, -0.05048929527401924, -0.07034526020288467, -0.016166385263204575, 0.012469937093555927, -0.07500842213630676, 0.054941754788160324, -0.043889351189136505, 0.02136748470366001, 0.024544019252061844, 0.0634077787399292, 0.05844014137983322, -0.09529837965965271, 0.033712662756443024, 0.011323903687298298, -0.012619467452168465, -0.042600367218256, -0.07972630113363266, -0.03145259618759155, 0.03955573961138725, -0.05848788842558861, 0.07039763778448105, -0.05639300495386124, 0.00820149015635252, 0.0124204708263278, 0.010074427351355553, -0.024503076449036598, -0.02227836102247238, -0.03322744369506836, 0.013405026867985725, -0.02817908488214016, 0.050756875425577164, 0.06847700476646423, -0.09885355085134506, 0.0025311491917818785, 0.054765138775110245, 0.014974928461015224, -0.05534213036298752, 0.0677507147192955, -0.03516848012804985, -0.03918525576591492, -0.03582027181982994, -0.03948678448796272, -0.018572280183434486, -0.004307822789996862, 0.0286752600222826, 0.002961184363812208, 0.06964860111474991, 0.019991738721728325, 0.0187801755964756, 0.03241490572690964, -0.043956927955150604, 0.009540009312331676, 0.018273744732141495, -0.05737654119729996, -0.07835905253887177, 0.03997386619448662, -0.03306415304541588, 0.012120183557271957, 0.010097047314047813, -0.030079111456871033, -0.06163058802485466, 0.0020028112921863794, 0.021741988137364388, 0.056808024644851685, 0.0017968453466892242, -0.01729794219136238, 0.010543244890868664, 0.06831561774015427, 0.01360045000910759, 0.014661784283816814, -0.026810500770807266, -0.002379093784838915, -0.024189351126551628, 0.039960552006959915, 0.01552425604313612, -0.014840219169855118, -0.0060233124531805515, 0.0034033101983368397, -0.040560923516750336, 0.05180932581424713, 0.021191097795963287, -0.037433214485645294, -0.04191994294524193, -0.03236347809433937, -0.028273524716496468, 0.03412892296910286, 0.023549847304821014, -0.001533749746158719, -0.020152976736426353, 0.02220921218395233, 0.0012224302627146244, 0.000032470703445142135, 0.05023089051246643, -0.004619681742042303, 0.01757390797138214, -0.009141245856881142, -0.03512493893504143, -0.024709736928343773, 0.026700519025325775, 0.036883220076560974, -0.08106721937656403, -0.06731458008289337, -0.019495194777846336, 0.013701210729777813, -0.04548444598913193, -0.0704396590590477, 0.007933161221444607, 0.01682266592979431, -0.04675780609250069, -0.04689473658800125, -0.01834748312830925, 0.0017706535290926695, 0.047005124390125275, 0.058130260556936264, 0.049123577773571014, 0.0011226326460018754, 0.033946312963962555, -0.0024960734881460667, -0.0015635479940101504, 0.07411753386259079, 0.00035400505294092, -0.008901488967239857, 0.021840250119566917, 0.012244070880115032, 0.02346057817339897, -0.05543055385351181, 0.0413556843996048, -0.050702814012765884, 0.011995765380561352, 0.025498880073428154, 0.009582583792507648, -0.008785811252892017, 0.04075431451201439, -0.024123193696141243, 0.01736701838672161, -0.06557299941778183, 0.01767713576555252, 0.042347606271505356, -0.009570525959134102, -0.023589028045535088, -0.009565629065036774, 0.0010371336247771978, -0.021335406228899956, 0.0704134851694107, -0.004845618270337582, 0.013337407261133194, 0.009794017300009727, 0.028087904676795006, 0.03952224180102348, -0.03393394127488136, 0.048128142952919006, 0.05624332278966904, -0.008243206888437271, -0.02536400780081749, 0.011163398623466492, -0.04301047697663307, 0.017142219468951225, -0.02297959476709366, 0.020625770092010498, -0.018514633178710938, -0.027089539915323257, -0.00827312096953392, -0.0400511659681797, -0.04524668678641319, -0.009098305366933346, 0.01201343908905983, -0.018449358642101288, -0.025252172723412514, -0.006646165158599615, -0.005513142328709364, 0.06745646893978119, -0.005594857037067413, 0.0017688022926449776, -0.02276182547211647, -0.006005782634019852, 0.033827975392341614, -0.010659427382051945, -0.03742318972945213, 0.06305960565805435, -0.05329315364360809, 0.004143615253269672, -0.01590714417397976, -0.018530970439314842, -0.08274395018815994, -0.0159465204924345, -0.018538985401391983, -0.012824621982872486, -0.0566089004278183, -0.0022314470261335373, -0.023629074916243553, 0.03393258526921272, -0.0230461023747921, 0.07922108471393585, 0.015368856489658356, 0.06433138251304626, -0.010875244624912739, 0.02042756788432598, 0.020899904891848564, -0.026739010587334633, 0.014073429629206657, 0.02903657779097557, 0.025267377495765686, -0.010682633146643639, 0.024995045736432076, 0.04931605979800224, 0.017468994483351707, -0.021110903471708298, 0.05762597918510437, -0.004489008337259293, 0.07915381342172623, -0.06252170354127884, 0.023749902844429016, -0.00624510645866394, 0.041350699961185455, 0.05369013175368309, -0.07574716955423355, 0.02809084765613079, -0.02597031183540821, -0.03756028041243553, 0.09179916232824326, -0.00502131087705493, -0.0043598804622888565, -0.013899563811719418, -0.00819689966738224, -0.04720522090792656, 0.006752378772944212, -0.020063553005456924, -0.05714777112007141, -0.037063755095005035, 0.009855862706899643, 0.013453139923512936, 0.07402250170707703, -0.039044659584760666, 0.04378345608711243, -0.05835694819688797, -0.039118919521570206, 0.013012547045946121, 0.03380541503429413, 0.013323022983968258, -0.047863028943538666, -0.07603328675031662, 0.02173764444887638, 0.0022470743861049414, -0.01782274805009365, -0.03547760844230652, 0.012522747740149498, 0.00037755779339931905, 0.005464323330670595, 0.010120570659637451, 0.0631973072886467, 0.017624445259571075, -0.07080584764480591, 0.0016617593355476856, 0.01847578026354313, -0.010042565874755383, -0.029357068240642548, 0.0011224785121157765, 0.012421446852385998, 0.015743909403681755, 0.04462987184524536, 0.05405805632472038, -0.008592155762016773, 0.03700178861618042, -0.03718702495098114, 0.033996861428022385, 0.019956553354859352, 0.0759328082203865, 0.02910730056464672, -0.025148097425699234, 0.029814081266522408, 0.015625612810254097, 0.04286011680960655, -0.04328007996082306, -0.019750384613871574, -0.0628514364361763, 0.033805761486291885, 0.04351167380809784, 0.048190243542194366, -0.04403045400977135, 0.03321884199976921, 0.030519209802150726, 0.03236017003655434, 0.01858602464199066, -0.0094293262809515, -0.00463184155523777, 0.06675595045089722, -0.00019301543943583965, 0.0494767390191555, 0.0024599595926702023, -0.018973959609866142, -0.025455813854932785, -0.020707478746771812, -0.009497960098087788, -0.03347368165850639, -0.052041806280612946, 0.052650343626737595, 0.019934864714741707, -0.007411300204694271, -0.001259004115127027, -0.012873179279267788, -0.050071556121110916, -0.0200140830129385, 0.09400977194309235, 0.004813340492546558, -0.000799542001914233, 0.006899053230881691, 0.06096777319908142, -0.04402507096529007, 0.024892570450901985, 0.06485231220722198, -0.0205669105052948, -0.016119085252285004, 0.00727562140673399, 0.003293226705864072, -0.01880563050508499, 0.024574078619480133, -0.045290257781744, 0.001004282385110855, 0.06821191310882568, 0.013376209884881973, -0.0542743019759655, 0.04060986265540123, -0.023119034245610237, -0.04347806051373482, -0.016397567465901375, 0.01825869269669056, -0.06992359459400177, 0.03432982414960861, -0.015663476660847664, -0.005132133606821299, 0.03251667320728302, -0.051602307707071304, -0.035671524703502655, -0.020392021164298058, -0.006409109570086002, 0.052419938147068024, 0.04977455735206604, -0.03975372388958931, 0.018665656447410583, -0.05896412208676338, -0.0021725946571677923, -0.02520548738539219, 0.0520891509950161, -0.0004125885316170752, -0.034556400030851364, 0.05895783752202988, 0.029832923784852028, -0.003540538717061281, -0.029711298644542694, -0.029606033116579056, -0.02930513024330139, 0.022441767156124115, -0.004202977754175663, -0.020091041922569275, 0.0378999300301075, -0.02724912390112877, 0.057948123663663864, -0.017220962792634964, 0.026999840512871742, -0.014608507044613361, -0.08234470337629318, 0.06809058040380478, -0.013155007734894753, 0.04907016083598137, 0.015071048401296139, 0.023211706429719925, 0.028361693024635315, -0.01990393176674843, -0.026254802942276, 0.02367822267115116, -0.020308494567871094, -0.0848325714468956, -0.09779183566570282, -0.09675008058547974, -0.04513915255665779, 0.04913115128874779, 0.025359706953167915, 0.01998959854245186, 0.01839413307607174, 0.028227584436535835, -0.06327620148658752, 0.020212195813655853, 0.01318091806024313, 0.08689892292022705, 0.016391193494200706, 0.012520422227680683, 0.023943454027175903, 0.027901362627744675, 0.03180867061018944, 0.029083704575896263, -0.02379356510937214, -0.01581813581287861, 0.020774580538272858, -0.002808032091706991, 0.050468072295188904, -0.003856346709653735, -0.0342060849070549, -0.04331957921385765, -0.008347258903086185, 0.06865885853767395, -0.015715839341282845, 0.02783704735338688, -0.007903413847088814, 0.012923085130751133, 0.019124725833535194, 0.018464386463165283, -0.00010438479512231424, 0.028401752933859825, -0.020084798336029053, 0.04605307802557945, -0.031187649816274643, 0.014029035344719887, -0.006567100062966347, -0.0264209546148777, 0.06095591187477112, 0.0033116221893578768, 0.003279702505096793, 0.015238098800182343, -0.05074940621852875, 0.0779530331492424, 0.00845760852098465, -0.014476152136921883, -0.0418669655919075, -0.04940028116106987, 0.027760300785303116, -0.011693663895130157, -0.024747274816036224, -0.01668115146458149, -0.012400886975228786, -0.018104838207364082, -0.030515341088175774, 0.026609251275658607, 0.024825897067785263, -0.06353996694087982, 0.0018648137338459492, -0.015318004414439201, -0.04300031438469887, -0.009066162630915642, 0.06078610569238663, 0.03282234072685242, 0.05604994669556618, -0.06672338396310806, 0.020802132785320282, -0.0761946439743042, -0.01271605771034956, -0.014023718424141407, -0.07518792152404785, 0.00004978674041922204, -0.011806301772594452, -0.060599613934755325, -0.06997603923082352, 0.04266652464866638, 0.033346328884363174, 0.03939848393201828, 0.000774222135078162, 0.05577274411916733, 0.0015788034070283175, 0.0474456250667572, -0.05998830124735832, 0.07199268788099289, -0.033823996782302856, 0.05258699879050255, -0.03393170237541199, 0.0013133743777871132, -0.06503959000110626, 0.0005059905233792961, -0.029528554528951645, -0.019726915284991264, -0.03136709704995155, -0.03177472949028015, 0.06684378534555435, 0.03359301760792732, -0.05107754468917847, -0.037212178111076355, -0.0074090915732085705, 0.01549086719751358, -0.03508903831243515, -0.019475294277071953, 0.013640551827847958, 0.028743891045451164, -0.001626363955438137, -0.029001450166106224, -0.08138954639434814, 0.03461775183677673, 0.019522378221154213, 0.030184229835867882, -0.016987202689051628, -0.009127121418714523, 0.02331358939409256, -0.005934558808803558, -0.016363801434636116, -0.03723423555493355, 0.012793361209332943, -0.028965916484594345, -0.024278096854686737, 0.004724545869976282, 0.009346215054392815, -0.0065375021658837795, -0.05444468557834625, -0.06759482622146606, -0.03323269635438919, -0.00016808861983008683, 0.031136957928538322, 0.0017144245794042945, -0.017863236367702484, -0.00279851327650249, -0.013225376605987549, -0.010877548716962337, -0.014979292638599873, 0.094779372215271, 0.00475241569802165, 0.01734323613345623, -0.0034169296268373728, 0.003404495771974325, -0.03540460020303726, 0.013050142675638199, -0.007509344723075628, -0.01687142252922058, -0.05326109007000923, -0.02116592973470688, -0.02926979400217533, -0.04001926630735397, 0.057372868061065674, -0.06315891444683075, 0.052120406180620193, -0.07024461776018143, -0.00563211552798748, -0.0032639240380376577, 0.009045125916600227, 0.01646619290113449, -0.022769184783101082, -0.028363607823848724, -0.028233645483851433, 0.01896429806947708, 0.003614877350628376, -0.007583907805383205, -0.0023054126650094986, -0.00888139009475708, 0.022168001160025597, 0.009516696445643902, -0.01318206824362278, 0.004734178073704243 ]
<p>I am reading David J. Griffiths and have a problem understanding the concept of discontinuity for E-field.</p> <p>The E-field has apparently to components. (How does he decompose the vector field into the following?) The tangential and the normal component. The normal component is discontinuous? (Question 1: Why?) But the tangential components are <em>not</em> discontinuous? (Question 2: Why?).</p> <p>My suggestion for question 1: I tried drawing it, and the way I see it, the size of the E-field is continuous, but the direction is not a continuous!</p> <p>My suggestion for question 2: The tangential components has a direction that changes continuously. </p> <p>The understanding of the word Continuous, that I am applying is this: If I can take the vector field, imagine it in a $\mathrm{R}^2$ graph, and if it is continuous (not abruptly stopped), then.. That's it!</p> <p>Can anyone please give me the explanation I am missing or another source? </p> <p>Also why does this have anything to do with ANYTHING: $$ {E}_{above} - E_{below} = \frac{\sigma}{\epsilon_0}\hat{n} $$</p>
g1641
[ 0.05782996118068695, -0.015003018081188202, -0.006156315095722675, -0.04806912690401077, 0.04892640933394432, -0.006831510458141565, 0.06234600767493248, 0.027571290731430054, -0.03464924171566963, 0.003818362485617399, -0.009602442383766174, -0.009139238856732845, 0.012781199999153614, -0.02066986635327339, -0.00498920027166605, 0.018863504752516747, -0.019179807975888252, -0.033702749758958817, -0.047885261476039886, -0.00815192423760891, -0.010776439681649208, 0.0005561023135669529, 0.07026836276054382, 0.008983064442873001, 0.060133080929517746, -0.05451931804418564, 0.05561432987451553, 0.0062437476590275764, -0.008440595120191574, -0.046912696212530136, 0.010055256076157093, 0.02885475941002369, 0.0582096129655838, -0.03884517401456833, -0.01793440617620945, -0.007044702302664518, 0.018514979630708694, 0.07298033684492111, 0.026655280962586403, 0.0077232313342392445, 0.04172370582818985, -0.0011351550929248333, -0.006940079852938652, -0.010152967646718025, -0.01627597212791443, -0.039819613099098206, -0.01250369381159544, -0.029681861400604248, 0.02775515988469124, -0.0038300466258078814, 0.021437881514430046, 0.005669955629855394, 0.024818601086735725, 0.011587162502110004, 0.02532450295984745, -0.01675458624958992, 0.03757798671722412, 0.019030356779694557, 0.05479184165596962, -0.035547807812690735, 0.03775310516357422, -0.02562990039587021, -0.04249739274382591, 0.0065122004598379135, 0.06707381457090378, -0.08057736605405807, -0.0344044491648674, -0.00577487563714385, -0.04537665843963623, -0.010484147816896439, -0.010045484639704227, -0.13227052986621857, 0.04372783005237579, 0.04242754727602005, 0.0034937646705657244, -0.03260696306824684, 0.0039034869987517595, 0.011782574467360973, 0.015501117333769798, 0.010159160010516644, 0.013495106250047684, 0.015706999227404594, -0.00963988620787859, 0.028816642239689827, 0.07880181074142456, -0.01792074553668499, -0.016496483236551285, -0.014730309136211872, -0.03393819183111191, -0.06396612524986267, -0.009258979931473732, 0.04337500035762787, 0.005383602809160948, 0.01866048201918602, -0.006432103458791971, -0.025142978876829147, -0.03299267962574959, 0.0507269911468029, -0.007910382933914661, 0.01339368149638176, 0.03688085824251175, -0.00426083616912365, 0.03658219426870346, -0.011890040710568428, -0.01602201908826828, 0.023170555010437965, 0.004054427146911621, 0.024509143084287643, 0.016341889277100563, -0.024707980453968048, -0.028398102149367332, -0.02052905410528183, -0.0685037299990654, 0.022898804396390915, -0.003801430342718959, 0.056942809373140335, 0.11937674880027771, -0.0497782938182354, 0.013189233839511871, 0.013092686422169209, -0.0275406651198864, 0.012068209238350391, 0.02276005782186985, 0.00009960534953279421, -0.016088975593447685, -0.02531406283378601, 0.06058226898312569, 0.017611758783459663, 0.02887779474258423, -0.021334802731871605, 0.016671188175678253, 0.011585626751184464, 0.006550726480782032, 0.009266736917197704, 0.0017582559958100319, 0.011243118904531002, -0.035476554185152054, -0.01134677417576313, 0.008421100676059723, -0.008231816813349724, 0.024537883698940277, -0.020478980615735054, 0.028428591787815094, -0.020509537309408188, -0.05515659600496292, -0.005258398596197367, 0.04572983458638191, -0.08193447440862656, 0.0801965519785881, -0.022606700658798218, 0.02430110052227974, -0.009691834449768066, -0.04393921419978142, -0.043071966618299484, 0.011279033496975899, 0.040670379996299744, 0.05461035296320915, -0.06224973499774933, -0.009628466330468655, -0.0051283761858940125, 0.005027743522077799, 0.058963287621736526, 0.024635586887598038, 0.036544319242239, 0.011577153578400612, -0.04092773050069809, -0.01183744240552187, -0.06353243440389633, -0.01402683649212122, -0.02207120880484581, -0.0342913456261158, 0.03220969811081886, 0.005512090399861336, 0.027659326791763306, 0.015081499703228474, 0.07909490913152695, 0.04527416080236435, -0.0445638969540596, -0.010970759205520153, 0.0027440395206212997, -0.0178279560059309, 0.06932391226291656, 0.01428458746522665, 0.009823611006140709, 0.04975452646613121, -0.007317587733268738, -0.013963399454951286, 0.01999697834253311, -0.010345514863729477, -0.003787416499108076, -0.021577296778559685, 0.0009825591696426272, -0.06710246950387955, 0.055271267890930176, -0.030692296102643013, 0.023308919742703438, -0.005811115261167288, -0.0621228851377964, -0.05938998609781265, 0.003589451080188155, 0.004219188820570707, -0.015139514580368996, 0.00913106556981802, 0.07594969868659973, 0.01836499385535717, -0.05504404008388519, -0.08628363907337189, -0.006451562512665987, 0.02735169231891632, 0.020827701315283775, 0.0515875406563282, -0.05877427011728287, 0.004063286818563938, 0.025653552263975143, 0.027543729171156883, -0.012840422801673412, 0.026207566261291504, -0.022375330328941345, -0.004436630290001631, -0.015063357539474964, 0.02629067748785019, -0.05847281217575073, 0.07855969667434692, -0.04735251143574715, -0.030764877796173096, 0.005224152468144894, 0.005162687040865421, -0.013671550899744034, -0.02855662815272808, -0.04567977041006088, -0.04043387994170189, -0.004495525266975164, -0.017709238454699516, -0.030301598832011223, 0.041479501873254776, 0.009525389410555363, -0.03865713253617287, -0.020219136029481888, 0.007864885963499546, -0.010050471872091293, 0.05324152112007141, -0.04811878502368927, 0.028467094525694847, 0.01502279844135046, 0.046753399074077606, -0.06332352757453918, 0.09756510704755783, -0.02146410383284092, 0.01541205495595932, 0.04597539082169533, -0.0032286604400724173, -0.043666522949934006, -0.07724969834089279, 0.06405046582221985, 0.0012659189524129033, -0.060290995985269547, 0.0032231055665761232, 0.032387763261795044, 0.03650515154004097, -0.03571264073252678, -0.0619640126824379, -0.004707102198153734, 0.05182567611336708, 0.06760188192129135, -0.04497796297073364, -0.030726071447134018, -0.028660528361797333, 0.055810436606407166, 0.027586080133914948, -0.0709839016199112, -0.05319938436150551, 0.027645790949463844, -0.005048766732215881, 0.01355244591832161, 0.014514653012156487, -0.009451771154999733, -0.0007072535227052867, -0.009629910811781883, 0.026449572294950485, -0.018984144553542137, -0.06701350957155228, 0.029940471053123474, 0.016624975949525833, 0.0413549542427063, 0.04802040755748749, 0.012935605831444263, -0.018268004059791565, 0.05130121856927872, -0.04682792350649834, 0.052972134202718735, 0.0027068627532571554, 0.04633970931172371, -0.029430150985717773, -0.08104884624481201, 0.021497804671525955, 0.019941508769989014, -0.04281732439994812, -0.11574336886405945, -0.05242021754384041, -0.005069776903837919, -0.023296426981687546, -0.011894669383764267, -0.024648351594805717, -0.02846270613372326, 0.0007050877320580184, -0.007702776230871677, -0.057948652654886246, -0.0409369058907032, -0.030216939747333527, 0.00996622908860445, 0.008758299984037876, -0.02121603488922119, 0.0077389879152178764, 0.018936127424240112, -0.005919147748500109, 0.014307820238173008, 0.007670130115002394, 0.06991733610630035, -0.015504831448197365, 0.005829199682921171, -0.01765526831150055, -0.0205512885004282, 0.022279350087046623, -0.021787496283650398, -0.011719755828380585, 0.03367115184664726, -0.0023007120471447706, 0.010572696104645729, 0.004436001181602478, -0.01452384889125824, -0.015346023254096508, -0.05888931080698967, 0.034858133643865585, -0.033130209892988205, 0.0034300207626074553, -0.007384642958641052, -0.008877426385879517, 0.049091096967458725, 0.003262462792918086, 0.013541705906391144, 0.02276192605495453, 0.04071330651640892, -0.06176314502954483, -0.03771001473069191, -0.025913821533322334, -0.027726631611585617, 0.056685399264097214, -0.024972591549158096, -0.0066825877875089645, -0.005833292379975319, 0.01023196056485176, -0.01799066737294197, 0.091888427734375, -0.045808061957359314, -0.07539790868759155, -0.0317951962351799, -0.027981054037809372, -0.03174915164709091, -0.017878683283925056, -0.02318105474114418, 0.027045482769608498, -0.033492837101221085, 0.03214156627655029, 0.029931236058473587, 0.00381377711892128, -0.02486802451312542, 0.025949085131287575, 0.07041112333536148, 0.00971580483019352, -0.02010931819677353, 0.09266508370637894, 0.007534092292189598, -0.02625831961631775, 0.030698928982019424, -0.05627330765128136, -0.05469904839992523, 0.020667672157287598, 0.02210753783583641, 0.008069923147559166, 0.0400971844792366, 0.03171426057815552, 0.07997448742389679, -0.024048352614045143, -0.011959068477153778, 0.036435265094041824, 0.038298964500427246, 0.028855392709374428, -0.040597766637802124, 0.020195432007312775, -0.005337996408343315, 0.07237911969423294, -0.01934633031487465, 0.0021628232207149267, -0.01813681237399578, -0.029726874083280563, -0.014522389508783817, -0.073084257543087, 0.07884349673986435, -0.023838067427277565, 0.015729481354355812, 0.07369057834148407, -0.03351849317550659, -0.02342146448791027, 0.0624711737036705, -0.007746238261461258, -0.02276504971086979, 0.02402668632566929, 0.01724230870604515, 0.03457337245345116, -0.06900740414857864, 0.05445868521928787, 0.02050718292593956, -0.031557343900203705, -0.035266801714897156, 0.0489640012383461, -0.006076496560126543, 0.037698522210121155, 0.0700993463397026, -0.012051461264491081, -0.026809580624103546, 0.01729685813188553, -0.030873145908117294, -0.05070572718977928, -0.03035704977810383, 0.07241597026586533, 0.05176393687725067, 0.005335885565727949, 0.02273526042699814, -0.03034985437989235, 0.035399384796619415, -0.0003027232305612415, 0.08875460922718048, -0.03864607587456703, -0.028950512409210205, -0.05842919275164604, 0.05105121433734894, -0.0199431199580431, 0.08272864669561386, -0.004176755901426077, -0.009448261931538582, 0.039195746183395386, -0.056316617876291275, 0.036508310586214066, -0.031523846089839935, -0.05692107975482941, 0.01182455662637949, -0.06454500555992126, -0.039387721568346024, -0.012779595330357552, -0.040899477899074554, -0.04206770658493042, 0.021276351064443588, -0.03649497777223587, -0.016068125143647194, -0.023882362991571426, -0.10981457680463791, -0.029362114146351814, -0.00866737961769104, 0.004514148458838463, 0.018174685537815094, -0.025709856301546097, -0.01958593539893627, -0.031760767102241516, 0.02645391970872879, 0.030576689168810844, -0.019350171089172363, -0.0629957988858223, -0.031329963356256485, 0.030370458960533142, -0.0000015010040215202025, -0.009577718563377857, 0.029039571061730385, 0.018883327022194862, 0.012439370155334473, 0.03462373837828636, -0.032526131719350815, -0.031230440363287926, 0.054948996752500534, -0.0334535613656044, -0.021789688616991043, -0.04085124656558037, -0.06938757002353668, 0.034767232835292816, 0.03435960039496422, -0.026246456429362297, -0.03487015515565872, 0.03348102420568466, -0.019986962899565697, 0.02603319101035595, 0.046886146068573, 0.01965579390525818, 0.0527808777987957, -0.019653979688882828, 0.015307593159377575, 0.035998035222291946, -0.05060751363635063, 0.005692060571163893, 0.01488017663359642, -0.019027411937713623, -0.04728660732507706, -0.05101625248789787, 0.023695990443229675, -0.0648718848824501, 0.0012064831098541617, 0.013346130028367043, 0.03168772906064987, 0.07137831300497055, -0.014167256653308868, 0.005485108587890863, 0.04349542781710625, -0.008353759534657001, 0.015426555648446083, 0.03581773862242699, 0.0020941426046192646, -0.004480155184864998, 0.03136756643652916, -0.040343575179576874, -0.013531512580811977, -0.034383624792099, -0.009049640037119389, 0.045057687908411026, 0.020451374351978302, -0.056593745946884155, -0.05304594710469246, 0.0033055490348488092, 0.013075887225568295, -0.004962820094078779, -0.058489810675382614, -0.02353445068001747, 0.04052981361746788, 0.015596996992826462, 0.05722483992576599, -0.026047931984066963, -0.02679183892905712, -0.05151636153459549, -0.024105310440063477, -0.0266123004257679, -0.02463291585445404, 0.04764373227953911, -0.00221075932495296, -0.051114920526742935, -0.051170408725738525, -0.004385924432426691, 0.013907424174249172, -0.030953729525208473, 0.006326879840344191, 0.03858046233654022, -0.0162819754332304, 0.006763342767953873, -0.023145891726017, 0.022438472136855125, -0.025835197418928146, -0.0036144230980426073, -0.054243266582489014, -0.045422788709402084, -0.002983379876241088, -0.01345420815050602, 0.02328145131468773, -0.027584204450249672, -0.03791363164782524, 0.024607110768556595, 0.0020968657918274403, -0.012783044949173927, -0.001967366086319089, -0.02792704664170742, 0.019440561532974243, 0.05222711339592934, 0.014206898398697376, 0.04211282730102539, 0.04015043005347252, -0.013542281463742256, -0.022822462022304535, 0.037042271345853806, 0.09185723215341568, -0.003899556351825595, 0.005401307251304388, 0.013438072986900806, -0.024038780480623245, -0.02644270285964012, 0.054511658847332, 0.026070501655340195, -0.0010687625035643578, 0.02264247089624405, -0.0323801189661026, -0.03379639610648155, 0.05190178379416466, -0.06822473555803299, -0.05894677713513374, 0.020820269361138344, 0.029767757281661034, -0.02880210429430008, 0.03381313756108284, -0.01095559261739254, 0.012600883841514587, 0.006499914452433586, -0.011301394551992416, -0.005621563643217087, 0.06941135972738266, 0.04244138300418854, 0.017789116129279137, -0.013004440814256668, 0.040825117379426956, 0.05848491191864014, -0.02737610600888729, -0.011785279959440231, 0.09805156290531158, 0.027338137850165367, 0.01654466800391674, -0.03267538920044899, -0.027491029351949692, 0.033760782331228256, 0.013821258209645748, 0.0038606494199484587, -0.00727991433814168, 0.03591275215148926, -0.030762523412704468, -0.06192270666360855, 0.002676046686246991, -0.0589573048055172, 0.04838615655899048, -0.023852458223700523, -0.017162814736366272, -0.03932618349790573, 0.00633462006226182, -0.027111181989312172, 0.03145056962966919, -0.015564331784844398, 0.0070120408199727535, 0.0032854715827852488, 0.010366055183112621, 0.0010010123951360583, -0.04355279356241226, 0.0017118436517193913, 0.0060271769762039185, 0.006080567371100187, 0.008449763990938663, -0.07000070810317993, 0.01581164263188839, 0.02937646396458149, 0.02129647135734558, 0.026426920667290688, 0.043738171458244324, 0.024100080132484436, -0.01054284069687128, -0.023562703281641006, 0.02204805612564087, 0.06002829968929291, 0.011900962330400944, -0.058335643261671066, 0.02534998580813408, 0.06465701758861542, 0.06595796346664429, 0.02562752366065979, -0.003365888725966215, 0.005341433919966221, 0.05544963851571083, -0.001714853337034583, -0.019373323768377304, -0.019879940897226334, -0.043755337595939636, -0.03236912190914154, 0.0307840034365654, 0.01027269009500742, 0.024373359978199005, -0.0585348941385746, 0.012519583106040955, 0.039347659796476364, 0.029347293078899384, -0.01168263889849186, -0.044142697006464005, -0.025118431076407433, -0.032577332109212875, -0.02675047144293785, -0.013035895302891731, 0.010113435797393322, 0.03765254095196724, 0.0013374461559578776, 0.048504799604415894, -0.0011893355986103415, -0.0360843725502491, 0.006753562483936548, 0.05338243767619133, 0.008480332791805267, -0.060193583369255066, -0.06630494445562363, 0.005883048754185438, -0.06949743628501892, 0.003109679091721773, 0.029508773237466812, 0.01252120640128851, 0.011442192830145359, 0.05742856487631798, -0.0529659241437912, 0.009146753698587418, 0.025355974212288857, -0.01386080589145422, -0.023584099486470222, 0.001986304298043251, -0.020281728357076645, -0.0035075887572020292, 0.018587751314044, -0.004551263991743326, 0.022117841988801956, -0.02658686973154545, 0.0234542153775692, 0.03768188878893852, 0.013862892054021358, -0.005740150343626738, -0.03696561977267265, -0.009376621805131435, -0.06475156545639038, -0.03417951241135597, 0.00966213271021843, 0.0292507316917181, 0.028628088533878326, 0.03135199099779129, 0.014089609496295452, -0.011299140751361847, -0.06410948932170868, 0.013045720756053925, -0.043450333178043365, -0.001845984486863017, -0.02525736764073372, -0.020255673676729202, -0.022423284128308296, -0.012372156605124474, -0.009135100990533829, -0.0005312832072377205, 0.043737493455410004, -0.007897702045738697, -0.01016282755881548, 0.040802668780088425, -0.038250453770160675, 0.014106462709605694, -0.059208568185567856, -0.017815716564655304, 0.06502605229616165, -0.04235667362809181, 0.014619667083024979, -0.0262749046087265, 0.01027286984026432, -0.054829102009534836, 0.04148067533969879, 0.006457248702645302, 0.05244353786110878, 0.0415162667632103, -0.003530120709910989, 0.029213853180408478, 0.031244603917002678, 0.024907710030674934, -0.016340347006917, 0.01391228660941124, -0.005108002107590437, 0.009111874736845493, 0.01585693657398224, -0.023650815710425377, 0.006089421454817057, 0.03968048468232155, 0.06904284656047821, -0.07416355609893799, -0.01812688820064068, 0.029995771124958992, -0.0032092928886413574, -0.019372887909412384, -0.04506196454167366, -0.0016916670138016343, -0.019656628370285034, 0.07873319089412689 ]
<p>dewitt claimed in his paper </p> <blockquote> <p>Bryce S. DeWitt. Quantum theory without electromagnetic potentials, <em>Phys. Rev.</em> <strong>125</strong> no. 6 (1962), pp. 2189-2191, <a href="http://dx.doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.125.2189" rel="nofollow">DOI: 10.1103/PhysRev.125.2189</a>,</p> </blockquote> <p>that the discovery of the Aharonov and Bohm that electromagnetic potentials play primary role in quantum mechanical theory is false. Who won? What are the errors in the argument of the losing side in this battle?</p>
g1642
[ 0.03406617417931557, 0.012946696020662785, 0.04177592694759369, -0.021026941016316414, 0.012741169892251492, 0.016803249716758728, -0.009365186095237732, -0.03365345299243927, 0.028339412063360214, 0.00869755633175373, 0.05362614616751671, -0.018867893144488335, 0.015062910504639149, 0.036615632474422455, -0.019395602867007256, 0.006755508482456207, 0.03618020564317703, -0.002988842548802495, 0.0037619085051119328, 0.037201300263404846, -0.05511431768536568, 0.030916381627321243, -0.07433460652828217, -0.03299663960933685, -0.038799628615379333, -0.05015666037797928, -0.009282196871936321, -0.04447456821799278, -0.00648032920435071, 0.01749410852789879, 0.01679476536810398, 0.02265721932053566, 0.10232371091842651, 0.03246882185339928, -0.019661948084831238, -0.013897991739213467, 0.023398499935865402, 0.06219475343823433, 0.00043107388773933053, -0.04047112911939621, -0.04430726170539856, -0.0008783108205534518, -0.02542477659881115, 0.014127364382147789, -0.019051896408200264, -0.05198236554861069, -0.0312851183116436, 0.03300890699028969, -0.015927579253911972, 0.007622197270393372, 0.06424859166145325, -0.043150171637535095, 0.05992010235786438, -0.00481080450117588, 0.04582984372973442, -0.029819803312420845, 0.03064938820898533, 0.0496160164475441, 0.04319457709789276, -0.008524737320840359, -0.006935555022209883, 0.08236930519342422, 0.02088833600282669, -0.00875513069331646, 0.008587992750108242, -0.021786736324429512, -0.0011040441459044814, -0.044604554772377014, 0.027871720492839813, -0.02113264612853527, -0.006643335800617933, -0.0793452113866806, -0.06143645569682121, 0.008044587448239326, -0.01595894619822502, 0.05317266285419464, 0.04378388077020645, -0.004889588803052902, 0.0070375907234847546, -0.0520787350833416, -0.010032576508820057, -0.013942479155957699, -0.00024820934049785137, -0.0486905463039875, 0.018933257088065147, -0.023960229009389877, -0.04545419290661812, -0.014615057036280632, -0.004263590089976788, -0.001905254670418799, 0.00185996457003057, 0.026394158601760864, 0.052196186035871506, 0.020096667110919952, 0.009233835153281689, 0.03380292281508446, 0.028706688433885574, 0.006606922950595617, 0.026144903153181076, 0.007324455305933952, -0.024683138355612755, 0.015945522114634514, -0.07949640601873398, -0.031862933188676834, 0.022373726591467857, 0.01076729316264391, -0.02643263153731823, 0.0012540968600660563, 0.0074699027463793755, 0.006886807270348072, -0.016474096104502678, -0.0001031485153362155, -0.03247293829917908, -0.06383805721998215, -0.004152026493102312, 0.00460396520793438, 0.03956112265586853, -0.044107891619205475, 0.021470388397574425, 0.03355669975280762, -0.00698118144646287, 0.0607929602265358, 0.029260974377393723, 0.052296221256256104, -0.019307250156998634, 0.0039014937356114388, -0.001127659808844328, -0.009326827712357044, 0.02045474201440811, -0.018348177894949913, 0.009030947461724281, 0.0023691956885159016, -0.007924450561404228, 0.0022436717990785837, -0.0016833621775731444, 0.0003001292352564633, 0.06400619447231293, -0.04952924698591232, 0.027413401752710342, 0.010754775255918503, 0.009722620248794556, 0.003150257747620344, 0.008685944601893425, 0.0161556676030159, 0.03702181205153465, 0.026910433545708656, 0.0032893174793571234, 0.024010052904486656, -0.0173262320458889, 0.03342263028025627, 0.054120052605867386, 0.03315375745296478, 0.008250094950199127, -0.04398760572075844, -0.047668084502220154, 0.009984098374843597, 0.05686034634709358, -0.0009366010781377554, -0.04858269542455673, 0.026978136971592903, -0.016702981665730476, -0.005062351003289223, 0.040187180042266846, 0.011082817800343037, 0.010172244161367416, 0.03994079306721687, 0.025676563382148743, -0.060320597141981125, -0.026839466765522957, 0.0017965997103601694, -0.010033411905169487, -0.026408908888697624, 0.021889105439186096, 0.00615497725084424, 0.023769613355398178, 0.07148029655218124, -0.035765957087278366, 0.015566162765026093, 0.04864337295293808, 0.02419276349246502, 0.012459239922463894, 0.03720538690686226, -0.02815672568976879, 0.0249922052025795, -0.008349306881427765, 0.03320162370800972, -0.009986727498471737, 0.05786893889307976, -0.028813570737838745, -0.05223306640982628, -0.06808850169181824, 0.009982331655919552, -0.030182933434844017, 0.0033902546856552362, -0.00846877321600914, 0.04441949352622032, 0.042880043387413025, 0.020230460911989212, 0.04127628356218338, 0.0017503555864095688, -0.005628718063235283, 0.06354764103889465, 0.0020989743061363697, -0.02956029772758484, 0.0094248466193676, -0.031195344403386116, 0.04108178988099098, -0.043328747153282166, 0.022808969020843506, -0.04895852133631706, -0.006968438625335693, 0.048072051256895065, 0.009118822403252125, 0.01687655784189701, -0.023121649399399757, -0.07701507955789566, -0.10342429578304291, 0.03222763165831566, -0.044751331210136414, 0.036446329206228256, -0.043483562767505646, 0.005333473905920982, -0.009101222269237041, -0.03135962784290314, -0.005908865015953779, -0.01851927489042282, -0.014577425085008144, -0.0634097084403038, -0.07973983138799667, 0.02095823734998703, 0.005170411430299282, -0.04712491109967232, 0.016685103997588158, -0.013193235732614994, 0.03084438666701317, 0.04622197523713112, -0.00044683326268568635, -0.001512930728495121, 0.10021998733282089, 0.05923419073224068, -0.00226222793571651, -0.014526721090078354, -0.040729325264692307, 0.03428226336836815, 0.012743518687784672, -0.011863487772643566, 0.045521680265665054, -0.03734452277421951, -0.0030927134212106466, 0.01647566445171833, -0.013722061179578304, 0.0015768310986459255, -0.0047840517945587635, 0.005632189102470875, -0.027414001524448395, 0.008209492079913616, 0.03803088515996933, -0.01043238677084446, 0.018638664856553078, 0.022997740656137466, -0.046225059777498245, -0.04314257577061653, 0.030604956671595573, -0.03180597350001335, -0.03644704818725586, 0.031199727207422256, -0.0677236020565033, -0.004340470768511295, 0.006069642025977373, -0.06029853597283363, 0.03063013032078743, 0.05081748589873314, -0.023367872461676598, -0.0716262012720108, -0.01033734530210495, -0.06711228936910629, -0.004835567437112331, -0.025104891508817673, 0.019316986203193665, -0.04243415594100952, -0.055378761142492294, -0.046138398349285126, 0.03305555135011673, -0.004181009717285633, 0.04135815054178238, -0.07965369522571564, -0.036804672330617905, -0.014536887407302856, -0.013846275396645069, -0.015000411309301853, -0.03985684737563133, 0.0301553662866354, 0.030652372166514397, 0.06328123807907104, -0.05272961035370827, 0.0026166874449700117, 0.03647443279623985, -0.013551761396229267, -0.030957618728280067, -0.024941634386777878, -0.0019875289872288704, 0.06840623170137405, -0.050522156059741974, 0.016820412129163742, 0.0705951601266861, -0.016375133767724037, -0.02396848425269127, -0.010466503910720348, -0.025040103122591972, -0.017246384173631668, 0.04578074812889099, 0.025032365694642067, 0.024909982457756996, 0.021411456167697906, -0.032767537981271744, 0.023712780326604843, 0.004408863838762045, -0.012736247852444649, 0.030404414981603622, -0.010074756108224392, -0.02121867425739765, 0.0032810773700475693, 0.039452336728572845, -0.02722439169883728, 0.07036153972148895, 0.0007626931183040142, -0.04848381504416466, 0.028973858803510666, -0.0678330734372139, -0.023203473538160324, -0.04078185558319092, -0.04596324265003204, -0.00192105898167938, -0.05342544615268707, -0.06784331053495407, -0.06308530271053314, 0.08298191428184509, -0.045376524329185486, 0.02001723274588585, 0.048439834266901016, 0.01782301813364029, -0.0023693686816841364, -0.05923627316951752, -0.009708985686302185, 0.01818864606320858, 0.002495677676051855, -0.0022891240660101175, -0.004856035113334656, -0.012942777015268803, 0.0032496899366378784, -0.0012444963213056326, -0.0017489171586930752, 0.0696662962436676, 0.04513891786336899, -0.025417784228920937, 0.02673197351396084, 0.04798547178506851, 0.03483307361602783, 0.0028292271308600903, 0.0357087105512619, 0.010653220117092133, 0.0068443333730101585, 0.025881899520754814, -0.07655124366283417, -0.004565824754536152, 0.033844709396362305, -0.04974202439188957, 0.01745527610182762, -0.0018989912932738662, -0.05828384310007095, 0.010931089520454407, 0.02639641799032688, -0.014736860990524292, 0.05140712857246399, 0.07095877826213837, -0.058073438704013824, 0.05860138684511185, -0.031582918018102646, -0.03461547568440437, -0.02643432654440403, 0.02331695333123207, 0.12800365686416626, 0.01391318254172802, 0.025361577048897743, 0.02945384569466114, -0.03151901438832283, -0.01432769000530243, 0.04093800112605095, 0.002049581613391638, 0.011659739539027214, -0.019310439005494118, 0.07178312540054321, -0.05791376158595085, 0.030222827568650246, -0.06321152299642563, 0.06215730682015419, 0.030569039285182953, -0.05198153480887413, 0.03891420364379883, -0.0038087666034698486, 0.03696710616350174, 0.023348616436123848, -0.05128972604870796, -0.01822325587272644, 0.05296584218740463, -0.025633350014686584, 0.019179200753569603, -0.005933594889938831, 0.01350347138941288, -0.02214200235903263, 0.02697490155696869, -0.008839653804898262, -0.06068984419107437, -0.020953144878149033, 0.038018327206373215, 0.000739484908990562, -0.017268875613808632, -0.020801588892936707, 0.01586916297674179, -0.008916833437979221, -0.06597144156694412, 0.005654014181345701, 0.004317798651754856, -0.01711851917207241, -0.02894658036530018, 0.0171218104660511, 0.0037429314106702805, 0.05484052747488022, 0.008023769594728947, -0.019379515200853348, -0.016937483102083206, 0.029792679473757744, -0.037974029779434204, 0.051875729113817215, -0.021838925778865814, 0.05840011686086655, -0.06626982986927032, 0.024871621280908585, 0.09128498286008835, 0.0448329895734787, 0.046598341315984726, -0.028946613892912865, -0.013449424877762794, 0.0174889974296093, 0.031634170562028885, 0.051426321268081665, -0.016004402190446854, -0.042479511350393295, -0.005827760323882103, -0.02454802393913269, -0.022647855803370476, 0.026700474321842194, 0.007155627477914095, 0.025473760440945625, -0.04033992066979408, 0.010553169064223766, -0.002029049675911665, 0.04247346892952919, 0.07491455972194672, 0.0674712061882019, -0.033523742109537125, 0.014629784040153027, 0.0038745657075196505, 0.008058360777795315, 0.07340000569820404, 0.01520308293402195, -0.027117174118757248, 0.04799564182758331, -0.10274101793766022, -0.085045225918293, 0.0029153914656490088, -0.010341895744204521, 0.030261550098657608, -0.010685407556593418, 0.03355542942881584, -0.03302212059497833, 0.026684056967496872, -0.031280696392059326, -0.024738704785704613, 0.08157165348529816, 0.012161694467067719, -0.05719980597496033, -0.017690997570753098, 0.03959490358829498, -0.009385610930621624, 0.07482585310935974, -0.061641693115234375, 0.032633718103170395, -0.09365899860858917, -0.07334574311971664, 0.021400369703769684, 0.022759225219488144, -0.020059753209352493, -0.051997601985931396, -0.0069680288434028625, 0.003763957880437374, 0.0196695476770401, 0.05713559314608574, -0.035464223474264145, 0.03459583595395088, -0.0367160439491272, 0.0191404577344656, 0.01679207570850849, 0.0034329823683947325, -0.03174010291695595, -0.004769864026457071, 0.02465139888226986, 0.02636323869228363, -0.01986527070403099, -0.0062432484701275826, -0.04120993614196777, -0.05747615545988083, -0.003639455419033766, 0.02157282643020153, 0.046703845262527466, 0.01602815091609955, -0.05599546432495117, -0.02255825325846672, -0.07238184660673141, -0.022840220481157303, 0.0521966777741909, 0.04461006820201874, 0.05378768593072891, -0.011315863579511642, 0.05672717094421387, -0.021037012338638306, -0.042232006788253784, -0.0284839179366827, 0.02002369984984398, 0.08333038538694382, -0.0007830180693417788, 0.011103867553174496, 0.07631624490022659, 0.010435766540467739, 0.05168934166431427, -0.009516178630292416, 0.0099681681022048, -0.04022558778524399, -0.015648895874619484, 0.05011216923594475, -0.01405846606940031, 0.011167140677571297, 0.02789968252182007, 0.020039783790707588, -0.06173250079154968, 0.059719525277614594, -0.035075314342975616, 0.004013373516499996, 0.035126928240060806, -0.012835228815674782, -0.06362753361463547, 0.04643237590789795, -0.0463632196187973, 0.03422006219625473, -0.01130747515708208, -0.03136895224452019, -0.05349064990878105, -0.00017350476991850883, -0.039867695420980453, 0.015714937821030617, 0.04240773245692253, 0.012443424202501774, 0.0015225416282191873, 0.05068035423755646, -0.012705906294286251, -0.03644498437643051, -0.05727706849575043, -0.020330604165792465, 0.021340686827898026, -0.025279058143496513, -0.006316773127764463, 0.0652967020869255, -0.037806205451488495, 0.015996474772691727, 0.01650625467300415, 0.01951131410896778, -0.03954577445983887, -0.04073139652609825, -0.02359607070684433, -0.06419043987989426, -0.02465304173529148, 0.05859411135315895, 0.006096348166465759, -0.09719894081354141, -0.006158517207950354, 0.023771440610289574, -0.01540766004472971, -0.01470870990306139, 0.0556027851998806, 0.06630222499370575, -0.01618073508143425, -0.01199874933809042, -0.007516135461628437, -0.03502901643514633, -0.04815221205353737, 0.016094693914055824, 0.04627814143896103, 0.022998018190264702, -0.012801921926438808, 0.041263334453105927, 0.053130198270082474, -0.04466364160180092, 0.024188827723264694, 0.06137752905488014, 0.059808891266584396, -0.02523309923708439, -0.014634857885539532, -0.02211225964128971, 0.00014713197015225887, 0.009760386310517788, -0.08782562613487244, 0.00573535542935133, -0.007058765739202499, -0.03153219819068909, -0.005896270740777254, -0.013735195621848106, -0.006479501724243164, -0.005337086506187916, -0.013939907774329185, -0.023479200899600983, 0.01695285178720951, -0.030436616390943527, 0.01577036641538143, 0.03851217404007912, -0.0035438528284430504, 0.021213345229625702, -0.016282733529806137, 0.023880187422037125, 0.04298828914761543, -0.005587512161582708, -0.01592608354985714, -0.04006751999258995, 0.031630780547857285, -0.015793276950716972, -0.028384510427713394, -0.012808145955204964, -0.01576972007751465, -0.05705121159553528, 0.01724173128604889, 0.010701432824134827, -0.04094374179840088, 0.02990867756307125, 0.05315858870744705, -0.01209451723843813, -0.07763880491256714, 0.036601580679416656, 0.02938810922205448, 0.01465100608766079, -0.05835171416401863, -0.01844855770468712, -0.009762408211827278, 0.022876305505633354, -0.043740954250097275, 0.05023306980729103, -0.03614986315369606, -0.033384062349796295, -0.026104293763637543, 0.014854110777378082, 0.049910809844732285, -0.030781297013163567, -0.02681575156748295, -0.038927771151065826, -0.03498499467968941, -0.013929756358265877, -0.011551517061889172, 0.004268374759703875, -0.05193512886762619, -0.036715324968099594, 0.008497167378664017, 0.012100299820303917, 0.01800214685499668, 0.050292469561100006, -0.010773304849863052, -0.0026323203928768635, 0.0004082845407538116, -0.04808022826910019, 0.005996239371597767, 0.017548758536577225, 0.01673077791929245, -0.0013934856979176402, -0.04200538247823715, -0.011380824260413647, -0.015179093927145004, -0.016912460327148438, -0.03672094643115997, -0.013758935034275055, -0.039450351148843765, -0.015199230052530766, -0.031467504799366, 0.019811362028121948, -0.004006409551948309, -0.04120057448744774, 0.0037999413907527924, 0.0143806217238307, -0.017969800159335136, -0.0005790811264887452, 0.024165507405996323, 0.03608483076095581, 0.06333056092262268, 0.0019447756931185722, 0.0044241598807275295, -0.020549019798636436, 0.01823185570538044, -0.004626458045095205, 0.003182570217177272, 0.02179694175720215, -0.023772867396473885, 0.0020525718573480844, -0.034038394689559937, 0.05300888791680336, 0.010509001091122627, -0.00220830412581563, 0.03462842106819153, 0.05604127049446106, 0.024885347113013268, 0.05467315390706062, -0.0420614629983902, 0.0073467944748699665, 0.048821453005075455, -0.03058171086013317, 0.03700297698378563, -0.061145659536123276, -0.02752883918583393, -0.010833590291440487, -0.05529961362481117, 0.00368879153393209, 0.044451892375946045, -0.01716405525803566, 0.022482136264443398, -0.024564215913414955, 0.0005637317080982029, -0.03686850517988205, 0.0043075066059827805, -0.0598909817636013, -0.0908745750784874, -0.03822877258062363, 0.0006410851492546499, 0.0367235504090786, -0.016089780256152153, -0.05358519405126572, -0.006235927809029818, -0.06492604315280914, -0.01334139984101057, 0.017710428684949875, -0.009657327085733414, -0.025879714637994766, -0.04309710115194321, -0.0010287235490977764, 0.04454850032925606, 0.02921346388757229, 0.007410274352878332, 0.004422148689627647, -0.0158498827368021, 0.06043408066034317, 0.055252499878406525, -0.0074058580212295055, 0.041156865656375885, 0.04540204629302025, 0.07656635344028473, 0.033758800476789474, 0.013175389729440212, -0.033178821206092834, 0.012858997099101543, -0.007905211299657822, -0.08405987918376923, 0.0037781447172164917, 0.004418497905135155, 0.025755267590284348 ]
<p>Understanding <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atmospheric_refraction" rel="nofollow">atmospheric refraction</a>, particularly of ultraviolet, and into the blue part of the visible spectrum is of great interest to me. Although, I have a strong background in trigonometry and geometry, I am very much interested in how these are applied in the context mentioned.</p> <p>Are there any references (books, papers and the like), that are mathematically rigourous, but also have examples of how the mathematics is applied to atmospheric refraction? Are there any other mathematical knowledge that would be required?</p>
g1643
[ 0.036599673330783844, -0.01732371188700199, 0.008245381526648998, 0.0016523458762094378, -0.022521013393998146, 0.003079627174884081, -0.000857232604175806, -0.011673402041196823, 0.02706986665725708, 0.02146786078810692, 0.04494514316320419, 0.044324178248643875, 0.05199591442942619, 0.014605889096856117, -0.009170465171337128, 0.03701382875442505, 0.004613174591213465, 0.03562978282570839, 0.03540120646357536, 0.010175485163927078, 0.05257903411984444, -0.04601028189063072, -0.015458527021110058, -0.03230125829577446, -0.06009541451931, 0.04252941906452179, 0.014128824695944786, -0.03599504381418228, -0.006631270982325077, -0.010203473269939423, 0.017823483794927597, -0.01868380419909954, 0.024232923984527588, -0.059646014124155045, 0.026590630412101746, 0.023430272936820984, 0.0454903207719326, 0.006990721449255943, -0.0010262842988595366, -0.00567090418189764, 0.01907508634030819, 0.01624569296836853, -0.044216059148311615, 0.05174405872821808, 0.006042096763849258, 0.013577115722000599, -0.03934302553534508, -0.028378717601299286, -0.03454748913645744, -0.01998775079846382, -0.015190533362329006, 0.052717424929142, 0.004457344301044941, 0.004784952383488417, -0.055599600076675415, -0.0010690968483686447, 0.04937058314681053, -0.02988291345536709, 0.04014049842953682, 0.020307384431362152, 0.01584642380475998, -0.01372578926384449, -0.05257316306233406, -0.020290549844503403, 0.04046260565519333, 0.02410666085779667, -0.034176815301179886, 0.001067470875568688, 0.01572861708700657, 0.027592858299613, -0.019081229344010353, -0.03885158896446228, -0.024141516536474228, 0.0026799270417541265, 0.0001227519678650424, -0.05948413163423538, -0.021381309255957603, -0.013976427726447582, -0.0059172422625124454, 0.07708059996366501, 0.020227452740073204, -0.009987757541239262, -0.01093786396086216, -0.0011272807605564594, -0.0009556897566653788, -0.06969228386878967, 0.017151253297924995, 0.04454757645726204, -0.0009813468204811215, -0.03374714031815529, 0.0344141460955143, 0.006315392907708883, 0.017424507066607475, 0.002398325130343437, 0.05429048463702202, -0.002955061849206686, -0.013300017453730106, 0.05452058091759682, -0.050596293061971664, 0.02887796051800251, -0.06671537458896637, -0.0187742430716753, -0.0009551186230964959, 0.06064631789922714, 0.05095153674483299, 0.025681495666503906, 0.042474184185266495, 0.03642565757036209, -0.019082240760326385, -0.006275464780628681, -0.082046277821064, -0.02766689471900463, -0.07357599586248398, -0.029914088547229767, -0.052564237266778946, -0.015722695738077164, 0.03790803253650665, -0.02923894114792347, 0.08355963975191116, 0.1244613379240036, 0.09894701838493347, 0.05208141356706619, 0.03871819004416466, 0.04063592851161957, 0.015479971654713154, -0.004231656435877085, -0.028662871569395065, -0.054896097630262375, 0.019229980185627937, -0.030773401260375977, 0.06386194378137589, -0.020511798560619354, 0.029365165159106255, 0.019595101475715637, 0.0063248067162930965, 0.005063209682703018, 0.031584762036800385, -0.025910818949341774, -0.02545168623328209, 0.030364990234375, 0.007681750226765871, 0.0010992598254233599, 0.044676631689071655, -0.014414378441870213, -0.0467940978705883, -0.06714609265327454, -0.018386049196124077, 0.005822809413075447, 0.006367001682519913, -0.037590786814689636, -0.039047472178936005, 0.005191016010940075, 0.040217477828264236, -0.012547132559120655, -0.023997878655791283, -0.03139309585094452, 0.03190970420837402, -0.03623073920607567, 0.044348571449518204, 0.017325742170214653, 0.04705755040049553, -0.012377067469060421, -0.01721089333295822, 0.0258303415030241, -0.030505523085594177, -0.03250851482152939, -0.04155399650335312, -0.06494031846523285, 0.023021766915917397, -0.0706600695848465, -0.083393894135952, -0.012986263260245323, -0.005271852482110262, -0.008159744553267956, -0.043921831995248795, 0.06248285248875618, 0.1302628219127655, 0.019840553402900696, -0.05368994176387787, 0.03130314499139786, -0.03374664857983589, -0.021661870181560516, -0.01705360598862171, -0.05172749608755112, -0.005336036439985037, -0.018413586542010307, -0.028913255780935287, -0.00615260424092412, 0.008210140280425549, -0.0029217074625194073, -0.0037931278347969055, -0.003779027611017227, 0.010300648398697376, 0.02102590724825859, -0.005090647842735052, -0.0006638181512244046, 0.015617153607308865, 0.015302049927413464, -0.026839395985007286, 0.04233076050877571, -0.018142592161893845, 0.02201930619776249, 0.09938213229179382, 0.05059712007641792, 0.05833910033106804, 0.09436814486980438, -0.011429056525230408, 0.037979625165462494, 0.010762232355773449, 0.038045186549425125, -0.05297918617725372, 0.02394319511950016, 0.10544274747371674, -0.010207688435912132, 0.005736927501857281, 0.09618651121854782, -0.057470180094242096, 0.008343786932528019, -0.012421445921063423, 0.02239522896707058, -0.010822688229382038, -0.007751085329800844, -0.0033027257304638624, 0.0024226270616054535, 0.018791668117046356, 0.02516157552599907, -0.0763857439160347, 0.04094001650810242, 0.11237926781177521, -0.024135902523994446, -0.015787260606884956, 0.0012721018865704536, -0.01970241591334343, 0.00819135271012783, 0.003150269156321883, 0.014132965356111526, -0.02341754175722599, 0.02599233388900757, 0.008860260248184204, 0.03562837839126587, 0.012895804829895496, -0.04645701125264168, -0.03444572538137436, 0.032585788518190384, -0.019224397838115692, 0.00750967301428318, 0.034162960946559906, 0.0038542156107723713, -0.028970682993531227, 0.014591827988624573, -0.015158568508923054, 0.013100706040859222, -0.039505068212747574, 0.01589776575565338, -0.030698876827955246, 0.00837952271103859, -0.03239085152745247, 0.013581148348748684, -0.039291538298130035, -0.03518608212471008, -0.020311100408434868, -0.0009387061581946909, 0.013440643437206745, -0.043641552329063416, -0.033961113542318344, 0.0025263538118451834, -0.037533219903707504, 0.07816296815872192, 0.03238134831190109, -0.02146255224943161, 0.061470068991184235, 0.10504162311553955, 0.02898748777806759, -0.038035232573747635, -0.024894213303923607, -0.04192312806844711, -0.0017185157630592585, 0.011564082466065884, 0.01711251586675644, 0.011897461488842964, -0.008639942854642868, -0.047999702394008636, -0.03869054839015007, 0.029490552842617035, 0.06286948174238205, 0.01493728905916214, -0.02755594253540039, 0.068313367664814, 0.01283322274684906, 0.01868094503879547, -0.02609151601791382, 0.034255851060152054, 0.022353895008563995, 0.029384354129433632, -0.04750591143965721, 0.010728665627539158, 0.03242132067680359, 0.00724441884085536, 0.010797670111060143, 0.03246006369590759, -0.091471828520298, 0.0025927762035280466, -0.005512122064828873, -0.006527257151901722, 0.032200951129198074, 0.02128676511347294, -0.02706960216164589, -0.020728042349219322, 0.05164526402950287, 0.00490545853972435, -0.020368559285998344, 0.022314444184303284, -0.025188086554408073, 0.03539304807782173, -0.00678189005702734, 0.030213840305805206, -0.0021765881683677435, 0.0222338680177927, 0.019879302009940147, 0.0059279948472976685, -0.05174137279391289, -0.04292852059006691, 0.031095948070287704, -0.01088029146194458, 0.06473062187433243, -0.029511990025639534, 0.009097087197005749, 0.026327205821871758, 0.028373776003718376, -0.008294410072267056, -0.0063063958659768105, 0.020491834729909897, -0.033610787242650986, -0.005593264941126108, -0.03908070549368858, -0.004215958062559366, -0.006372925825417042, -0.03599527105689049, -0.008757784962654114, -0.001642279326915741, 0.05422468110918999, -0.023399678990244865, -0.06250419467687607, -0.0868815928697586, 0.007260303478688002, -0.004745510406792164, 0.003556981449946761, 0.03738851100206375, -0.004298355896025896, -0.050342902541160583, 0.04587513580918312, -0.010325245559215546, 0.01670505665242672, 0.004366245586425066, -0.02178249880671501, 0.05771061033010483, 0.011390050873160362, 0.059974636882543564, 0.05112887918949127, -0.06187306344509125, -0.011780121363699436, 0.022341594099998474, 0.005552838556468487, 0.0060491557233035564, -0.009285724721848965, -0.04151298850774765, 0.04152998700737953, 0.024132268503308296, 0.001717304578050971, 0.023484308272600174, -0.0323629304766655, -0.020977407693862915, -0.014895737171173096, -0.011745226569473743, -0.03502136841416359, 0.019490087404847145, 0.020502140745520592, 0.014973674900829792, -0.03111105225980282, 0.061134275048971176, -0.0020527909509837627, 0.048941873013973236, 0.06503457576036453, 0.030259745195508003, 0.02105894312262535, -0.009744835086166859, -0.007083144970238209, -0.031845010817050934, -0.013133062049746513, -0.035898271948099136, 0.028564482927322388, -0.00978559534996748, -0.02779717743396759, 0.03414585068821907, 0.04789870232343674, -0.06883569061756134, -0.019150707870721817, 0.031850408762693405, -0.0069025843404233456, 0.04269709810614586, 0.04994456097483635, 0.011075470596551895, 0.003444301662966609, 0.045003075152635574, 0.004310605116188526, -0.00384474522434175, 0.05849367752671242, 0.0524684302508831, -0.0025638833176344633, 0.0038390171248465776, 0.003259436460211873, -0.043046072125434875, -0.02255938947200775, -0.07669853419065475, 0.034730300307273865, 0.045626331120729446, -0.04451209679245949, -0.06545522809028625, 0.020259596407413483, 0.05985381454229355, -0.016782840713858604, 0.017589380964636803, -0.03806430101394653, -0.05506331846117973, -0.01266105193644762, 0.06227805092930794, 0.027305081486701965, -0.024772221222519875, 0.006948409136384726, -0.019443057477474213, 0.05130961164832115, 0.004617018159478903, 0.010335247032344341, -0.005715101957321167, -0.006640325300395489, -0.01779886893928051, -0.02070055902004242, 0.026536988094449043, 0.01845506764948368, -0.02162517048418522, 0.028237052261829376, 0.025641025975346565, 0.023855682462453842, -0.0287607591599226, -0.02789662592113018, 0.04359370470046997, -0.07484583556652069, -0.013729902915656567, -0.009908994659781456, -0.004024604335427284, -0.009248686954379082, -0.04543587565422058, 0.009253466501832008, 0.018493039533495903, -0.0693906769156456, -0.036150529980659485, -0.07188247889280319, 0.004118252545595169, -0.013528616167604923, 0.02774088829755783, -0.006192299071699381, -0.001869537285529077, -0.016884665936231613, 0.015658650547266006, 0.03583654761314392, -0.03858797252178192, -0.029326915740966797, -0.00000507241065861308, -0.045787159353494644, -0.026336373761296272, -0.05229458957910538, 0.01468045637011528, -0.03265924006700516, -0.028183525428175926, 0.04410361126065254, -0.045653924345970154, -0.06731687486171722, -0.004069674760103226, -0.002318534068763256, -0.00009801694977795705, -0.0008103115833364427, 0.06322184950113297, 0.053857479244470596, 0.05483250319957733, -0.060264065861701965, -0.0071942624635994434, -0.02251029759645462, -0.00945120956748724, -0.00031397660495713353, -0.05082094669342041, 0.010294669307768345, -0.0364210419356823, 0.02465401031076908, -0.010475242510437965, -0.04030952230095863, -0.03819917142391205, 0.0490499809384346, -0.01809087023139, -0.014080536551773548, -0.000582461419980973, -0.010327947326004505, -0.010044842958450317, -0.011306369677186012, -0.06594200432300568, 0.019459791481494904, 0.012002158910036087, 0.03005092963576317, -0.024737266823649406, 0.033180274069309235, 0.021349238231778145, 0.037952590733766556, -0.08035136014223099, -0.02865203097462654, 0.014282754622399807, 0.012962203472852707, -0.026854269206523895, -0.03579812869429588, 0.012373850680887699, -0.007392918691039085, -0.02205539494752884, 0.029988858848810196, 0.008296397514641285, -0.07760535925626755, 0.01065828837454319, 0.024024546146392822, -0.013212932273745537, -0.04418937861919403, -0.016228100284934044, -0.055558256804943085, -0.04500756040215492, -0.0307389497756958, -0.024754103273153305, -0.0170951709151268, -0.012931866571307182, -0.003842397592961788, -0.013304585590958595, 0.021689025685191154, 0.04605589434504509, 0.02685297653079033, 0.03555265814065933, -0.06009071320295334, 0.0006890566437505186, 0.031036123633384705, 0.06822939217090607, 0.03249266371130943, -0.003946489188820124, 0.01221869233995676, 0.09966763108968735, 0.09941768646240234, 0.050542157143354416, -0.01071951724588871, 0.040255337953567505, 0.042691756039857864, -0.02355983667075634, 0.013130143284797668, -0.008285176008939743, -0.023017967119812965, 0.026001151651144028, -0.0361502431333065, 0.01196802593767643, 0.035839613527059555, 0.000005482650522026233, -0.03791875019669533, -0.027262050658464432, -0.005083378870040178, -0.025403553619980812, -0.011864711530506611, 0.027408184483647346, 0.025415735319256783, -0.01763550378382206, -0.011349602602422237, -0.027127478271722794, -0.0669502541422844, 0.017615757882595062, -0.01513680536299944, -0.016691716387867928, -0.03455449640750885, -0.06593500822782516, 0.008210822008550167, -0.03959500417113304, 0.07855316996574402, 0.04540600627660751, 0.035076603293418884, -0.04227330535650253, -0.06557044386863708, 0.02774285152554512, -0.02043493092060089, 0.0016705546295270324, 0.018565593287348747, -0.040176574140787125, 0.014406376518309116, -0.004407172091305256, -0.03558693826198578, 0.028441786766052246, -0.016142500564455986, -0.002417215844616294, 0.04333366081118584, 0.058854978531599045, -0.047113966196775436, 0.01227479986846447, 0.04775606468319893, -0.06271354854106903, 0.029593773186206818, -0.03702392801642418, 0.001452788827009499, 0.0009536888101138175, 0.023868266493082047, -0.029144730418920517, 0.076082743704319, 0.0237163994461298, -0.04707718268036842, -0.002853305544704199, 0.0029419376514852047, 0.004567145835608244, -0.04765769839286804, -0.05865515023469925, -0.026108572259545326, -0.035153232514858246, 0.020723329856991768, -0.09104571491479874, 0.04044460505247116, -0.06884255260229111, 0.07120130956172943, -0.031998082995414734, -0.017063861712813377, -0.000830613833386451, -0.005114709958434105, -0.014269239269196987, 0.02734016627073288, -0.02728431671857834, 0.019610559567809105, -0.008839575573801994, 0.0528424046933651, -0.006863177753984928, 0.06523948907852173, 0.057084519416093826, -0.0408809594810009, -0.013807338662445545, -0.015794118866324425, 0.04414863511919975, -0.04160674288868904, -0.03412087634205818, -0.009984700940549374, -0.005932952743023634, -0.017027709633111954, -0.05269623175263405, -0.009820443578064442, -0.08907178789377213, -0.05694195628166199, -0.0036894092336297035, 0.003043603152036667, -0.059339649975299835, -0.0059343441389501095, 0.007833066396415234, -0.04473969712853432, 0.038029640913009644, -0.07272137701511383, 0.03700433671474457, -0.009366624057292938, -0.021742578595876694, -0.039505504071712494, 0.06426291167736053, -0.013335596770048141, 0.0012661739019677043, -0.017752042040228844, -0.01389333326369524, 0.02042042464017868, -0.013895328156650066, -0.012573075480759144, -0.000009473687896388583, 0.019761091098189354, 0.010103188455104828, -0.0341869592666626, -0.0034986892715096474, -0.008464482612907887, 0.005871624685823917, -0.00710039958357811, -0.027090419083833694, -0.017856234684586525, -0.01255433727055788, 0.04692050814628601, 0.02660970948636532, 0.03090875968337059, -0.021987158805131912, -0.017066912725567818, 0.005688181146979332, -0.07427505403757095, 0.0325649231672287, -0.001268482650630176, -0.06895042210817337, -0.03170099854469299, 0.021024880930781364, 0.003918258938938379, -0.031994614750146866, 0.02996453270316124, 0.020048562437295914, 0.08701988309621811, -0.0014026355929672718, 0.04582882300019264, -0.04272435978055, 0.011346271261572838, -0.03025796078145504, 0.022066613659262657, -0.017724759876728058, 0.07753440737724304, -0.008010867983102798, -0.02569855935871601, 0.016198845580220222, -0.012423500418663025, -0.03636035695672035, 0.030452154576778412, 0.05278608575463295, 0.03715403378009796, 0.0060660457238554955, 0.005425383802503347, -0.020625455304980278, -0.025496002286672592, 0.03936900570988655, -0.04854600876569748, 0.033827949315309525, 0.049729906022548676, -0.06043721362948418, 0.03890750929713249, -0.06635776162147522, 0.018866801634430885, 0.02582305297255516, 0.026310637593269348, -0.024797825142741203, 0.001644354546442628, -0.04296066239476204, 0.017671477049589157, 0.06811581552028656, -0.01768787018954754, 0.03413698822259903, -0.04358838126063347, -0.01418671291321516, 0.03329142555594444, -0.04580633342266083, 0.059918250888586044, 0.028457215055823326, 0.013781672343611717, 0.03357381373643875, -0.036418866366147995, -0.06374643743038177, -0.01875665783882141, -0.01542965229600668, -0.015727542340755463, 0.001752140698954463, 0.015293283388018608, -0.022748976945877075, -0.04167936369776726, 0.052207909524440765, 0.0359676256775856, 0.038751669228076935, -0.01007892657071352, -0.055052537471055984, 0.06357621401548386, -0.03749734163284302, 0.004996113479137421, -0.002818136475980282, 0.022562552243471146, 0.0024735708720982075, 0.01766258478164673, 0.006096389144659042, -0.059095095843076706, -0.023079246282577515, -0.05217493698000908, -0.021422797814011574 ]
<p>This is a problem from school. I will show my attempt.</p> <p>The question:</p> <p>"The gas constant for dry air R is 287 $\frac{m^2}{s^2*K}$. Assuming the temperature is 330 K and the pressure is 1050 hPa, what is the atmospheric density."</p> <p>The professor said DO NOT produce an answer by finding a formula, but to use the magic of unit conversion to try to solve things.</p> <p>I know density is measured in kg/m^3 or thereabouts so I tried the following:</p> <p>1050 hPA = 105, 000 Pa</p> <p>1 Pa = 1 kg/m*s^2</p> <p>105,000 $\frac{kg}{m*s^2}$ * 330 K * 287 $\frac{m^2}{s^2*K}$.</p> <p>This cancels some units... but not enough...in fact it cancels just K, so far as I understand, far from what I need for my density unit.</p> <p>Any ideas on what Im doing foolishly here?</p>
g1644
[ 0.04224906116724014, -0.03064606711268425, 0.016763200983405113, -0.027180299162864685, -0.02742559090256691, 0.05480619892477989, 0.015337572433054447, 0.04480005428195, -0.03185795247554779, 0.033123333007097244, 0.03599396347999573, -0.014729130081832409, 0.021204032003879547, -0.0006036743288859725, 0.03925613686442375, 0.0774226039648056, 0.01743205450475216, 0.007682314142584801, -0.014544462785124779, 0.007905535399913788, -0.027619093656539917, -0.05075725167989731, -0.01467469334602356, -0.07889378070831299, -0.009290122427046299, -0.06478619575500488, 0.013573713600635529, 0.04308196157217026, -0.06703609228134155, -0.00358550320379436, -0.00046439075958915055, 0.030566349625587463, 0.03883744403719902, -0.016402646899223328, -0.04653260484337807, -0.062354981899261475, 0.029655756428837776, 0.0046243262477219105, 0.01790199801325798, -0.0377386249601841, 0.0008487302693538368, -0.028241939842700958, -0.021611889824271202, 0.024565456435084343, 0.0013029754627496004, 0.06121450290083885, -0.05976509302854538, -0.039594151079654694, -0.007944012992084026, -0.015224863775074482, 0.019330978393554688, 0.04512646049261093, -0.026669083163142204, -0.022970028221607208, -0.06364922225475311, 0.04726698622107506, -0.01117712166160345, -0.007806150242686272, 0.03602370247244835, 0.03945668041706085, -0.00691230921074748, -0.03478047996759415, -0.0067559294402599335, -0.019357454031705856, 0.08194068819284439, 0.000851090531796217, -0.02601294219493866, -0.016911547631025314, -0.011106347665190697, -0.013337243348360062, 0.014619543217122555, -0.040273863822221756, 0.05291978642344475, -0.012011928483843803, -0.03333764523267746, -0.015818599611520767, -0.010440069250762463, 0.0184161514043808, 0.0876331701874733, 0.010273688472807407, 0.011369495652616024, -0.04291690140962601, 0.035772405564785004, -0.045854099094867706, 0.007601961027830839, -0.04375841096043587, -0.01718478836119175, -0.026380132883787155, -0.03610977903008461, -0.04774676263332367, 0.015241125598549843, 0.02510983496904373, 0.06282529979944229, 0.0031423657201230526, 0.05125505104660988, 0.0038311907555907965, 0.017616044729948044, 0.05145396664738655, -0.015709305182099342, -0.020390313118696213, 0.004284556955099106, -0.012126314453780651, 0.014810428954660892, 0.022745054215192795, -0.022574275732040405, -0.04139705002307892, -0.00404535373672843, -0.0022166024427860975, 0.01668558642268181, -0.037821270525455475, -0.03891649469733238, 0.019016969949007034, -0.024641074240207672, -0.02174459956586361, -0.056146107614040375, -0.07228299975395203, 0.06074674800038338, -0.02815863862633705, -0.0030131235253065825, -0.01771588996052742, 0.017481429502367973, 0.02990799769759178, 0.005860089790076017, 0.010862460359930992, 0.017826395109295845, -0.03304056078195572, 0.00808043871074915, 0.009550267830491066, 0.012545422650873661, -0.05073380470275879, 0.014032451435923576, -0.021101782098412514, -0.07549763470888138, 0.022326789796352386, -0.03133881464600563, -0.022302832454442978, -0.01831144094467163, 0.01986541785299778, 0.012530873529613018, 0.04719684273004532, 0.04070833697915077, 0.0230192132294178, 0.02122703194618225, -0.021358728408813477, -0.0064513529650866985, -0.01544417254626751, -0.04774962738156319, -0.020230406895279884, 0.027918314561247826, -0.022564800456166267, 0.04147466644644737, -0.0016796054551377892, 0.009398018009960651, -0.0017954958602786064, -0.00692276144400239, -0.04981627315282822, 0.036442831158638, 0.07793955504894257, 0.04164576902985573, -0.00003999486216343939, 0.024731947109103203, -0.0029270602390170097, -0.0031439377926290035, 0.06228995695710182, 0.010990257374942303, 0.05525370314717293, -0.01935170404613018, -0.002352985553443432, 0.004299292806535959, 0.008479784242808819, -0.05120307579636574, -0.010509452782571316, -0.04475218430161476, -0.00796465389430523, 0.02144050970673561, -0.0007989120786078274, 0.09610845148563385, 0.02926511876285076, 0.004382256418466568, -0.01020455826073885, 0.049836184829473495, -0.0009149363613687456, 0.06704218685626984, -0.04149673879146576, -0.03331996127963066, 0.05820333957672119, 0.018183831125497818, -0.001078662695363164, -0.053835734724998474, 0.000035871013096766546, 0.010245542041957378, 0.012725851498544216, 0.0008911347249522805, 0.00697479909285903, 0.03131765499711037, -0.008281802758574486, 0.009591479785740376, 0.00584552064538002, -0.00670945318415761, -0.009329426102340221, -0.054117850959300995, 0.00025743499281816185, 0.07649596780538559, -0.0040438054129481316, 0.06719280779361725, 0.004767916165292263, 0.010136771015822887, 0.0004909596755169332, 0.014224719256162643, 0.0026438874192535877, -0.063482865691185, -0.03539511188864708, 0.01731307990849018, 0.07709755003452301, 0.07800751179456711, -0.0012107107322663069, -0.02106272242963314, 0.02019871026277542, -0.05643817409873009, -0.0019859494641423225, -0.02758059836924076, 0.034070950001478195, 0.013070056214928627, -0.007568747270852327, -0.011359068565070629, -0.054297544062137604, 0.05334701016545296, -0.03154000639915466, -0.00107844197191298, -0.02299295738339424, -0.01363056618720293, 0.05522745102643967, -0.019078588113188744, -0.0022934977896511555, 0.021863408386707306, 0.06698954850435257, -0.026353517547249794, 0.005143595393747091, -0.0038378748577088118, 0.016653109341859818, -0.045871976763010025, -0.0412200503051281, -0.003162764711305499, 0.018207211047410965, 0.08642271161079407, -0.02653135359287262, -0.05278213694691658, 0.023131931200623512, 0.04993146285414696, 0.0016473245341330767, -0.03496399149298668, 0.059463948011398315, -0.02089746855199337, 0.027757955715060234, -0.000647475419100374, -0.006871734280139208, -0.07216039299964905, -0.01066217664629221, 0.020229151472449303, -0.05947510525584221, 0.0069407201372087, -0.030654961243271828, 0.005189926363527775, 0.012979294173419476, -0.11408810317516327, -0.02997138723731041, -0.072535440325737, 0.03893427178263664, 0.05646585300564766, 0.03442571684718132, 0.10121005028486252, 0.023257287219166756, 0.010322622023522854, 0.03618251904845238, 0.021340206265449524, -0.00845890399068594, 0.049307651817798615, -0.010300729423761368, 0.04673073813319206, -0.021566420793533325, 0.07621251791715622, 0.011861084029078484, 0.006658849772065878, 0.04724723473191261, 0.060295503586530685, -0.02834191732108593, -0.0018172352574765682, 0.05507221072912216, 0.04975185543298721, 0.030536789447069168, 0.05082928016781807, 0.050843480974435806, -0.04095280542969704, 0.04005918279290199, 0.014012543484568596, 0.05869435891509056, 0.03769560903310776, -0.03373771160840988, 0.004593994002789259, 0.0015210063429549336, 0.049450863152742386, -0.05152445659041405, 0.00722747016698122, 0.008923092857003212, -0.0371076725423336, 0.019155379384756088, -0.03129477798938751, -0.0021151816472411156, -0.0363600067794323, -0.0018455962417647243, -0.00028713338542729616, -0.02275766432285309, -0.013503353111445904, -0.03884725645184517, -0.016580896452069283, -0.00836612842977047, 0.036787040531635284, -0.0027757480274885893, 0.05905097723007202, 0.04683393985033035, 0.0013278021942824125, -0.029239606112241745, -0.005663587711751461, -0.008041073568165302, -0.004114383365958929, 0.056247420608997345, -0.051097627729177475, 0.007147647440433502, -0.061417363584041595, -0.06020363047719002, -0.028090965002775192, -0.030683202669024467, -0.020835500210523605, -0.015744464471936226, -0.10326237976551056, -0.028583254665136337, -0.026677215471863747, 0.0026646293699741364, -0.029958270490169525, -0.01615765132009983, -0.05858165770769119, -0.0007249221089296043, -0.024363959208130836, -0.06064949929714203, -0.004455546848475933, 0.04037107527256012, -0.027520470321178436, 0.02763262577354908, -0.02493138052523136, 0.016615521162748337, -0.001144150155596435, -0.020836928859353065, 0.016304796561598778, -0.026310233399271965, -0.03815864771604538, 0.004630304407328367, 0.03255476802587509, 0.0023946226574480534, 0.02915913239121437, -0.025298302993178368, 0.035037364810705185, -0.08041179180145264, 0.02822580747306347, 0.0035568405874073505, -0.008478594943881035, -0.013037077151238918, -0.0031021523755043745, 0.041720252484083176, 0.052692875266075134, 0.0015299933729693294, -0.018862109631299973, -0.008723066188395023, 0.028040051460266113, 0.044334132224321365, 0.024776117876172066, -0.06381966173648834, -0.024516042321920395, 0.002278476022183895, -0.016001706942915916, 0.09708389639854431, 0.016726704314351082, 0.020682044327259064, -0.020826756954193115, -0.026014123111963272, 0.02104208990931511, 0.045196015387773514, 0.015485954470932484, -0.008639587089419365, 0.055470600724220276, -0.08948960900306702, -0.023076441138982773, -0.03580232709646225, -0.04816252738237381, 0.043961312621831894, 0.017758650705218315, -0.06478334218263626, -0.0003462376771494746, 0.00979103147983551, -0.07409889996051788, 0.020631346851587296, 0.04778099060058594, -0.026405028998851776, 0.023751892149448395, -0.023089928552508354, -0.007873311638832092, -0.034084148705005646, 0.05259248986840248, -0.03477349504828453, 0.052124712616205215, 0.025239331647753716, -0.008753790520131588, 0.031055374071002007, -0.025994159281253815, -0.055880118161439896, -0.0250573568046093, -0.014322412200272083, -0.01455233246088028, 0.0026104063726961613, 0.014360887929797173, -0.015753114596009254, -0.003675886895507574, 0.05716557055711746, -0.058985497802495956, -0.025762515142560005, 0.031577978283166885, 0.015414170920848846, 0.08063037693500519, -0.003949707839637995, -0.03812523931264877, -0.007056273054331541, 0.03860202431678772, -0.03406012803316116, 0.04238888621330261, 0.00177000614348799, -0.023420237004756927, 0.04182499647140503, -0.06751854717731476, -0.006724471691995859, 0.003917444497346878, 0.030470486730337143, -0.015806715935468674, -0.014251152984797955, 0.006361720617860556, 0.007196752354502678, 0.009545006789267063, 0.0035834284499287605, -0.010605414398014545, -0.025643374770879745, -0.01358769927173853, 0.05665137246251106, 0.008041010238230228, -0.015595415607094765, -0.02645372971892357, -0.02381330542266369, -0.052584923803806305, 0.005419989116489887, -0.014128340408205986, -0.007500787265598774, -0.028393886983394623, 0.05452754348516464, -0.07597215473651886, 0.006481382064521313, 0.01719762571156025, 0.013737866654992104, 0.08997302502393723, -0.02483302541077137, -0.01953151635825634, 0.025129826739430428, 0.006948093883693218, -0.025492846965789795, -0.008087912574410439, 0.017266863957047462, -0.00569191575050354, 0.05638474225997925, 0.05438283458352089, 0.07080402225255966, -0.031510476022958755, -0.029265690594911575, -0.003991616889834404, -0.004563464317470789, 0.03548717871308327, 0.016196981072425842, -0.01878148317337036, 0.05572709068655968, 0.0008010732708498836, 0.06032347306609154, -0.02768804132938385, 0.04964878782629967, -0.005503848195075989, -0.03923267871141434, 0.007705005817115307, 0.008221167139708996, 0.01517434697598219, 0.01117814052850008, -0.020603517070412636, -0.05973271280527115, 0.003289114451035857, -0.046050023287534714, -0.04318466782569885, -0.05281447619199753, -0.01859278231859207, 0.013467960990965366, -0.0353989414870739, 0.023016279563307762, -0.009383158758282661, 0.022590212523937225, 0.031259935349226, 0.020594868808984756, 0.015928152948617935, 0.10324493795633316, 0.02126956731081009, -0.021852876991033554, 0.06008636951446533, 0.020985526964068413, -0.011325601488351822, -0.010613448917865753, -0.0013801869936287403, 0.02187282219529152, -0.03376375138759613, -0.0765281468629837, 0.030504491180181503, 0.03684878721833229, 0.005075644701719284, -0.021575916558504105, -0.023506151512265205, -0.022641371935606003, -0.061482906341552734, -0.0409843884408474, 0.01843694970011711, 0.013626995496451855, -0.07344939559698105, -0.058154601603746414, 0.038748323917388916, -0.06993072479963303, -0.015471057035028934, 0.01940031349658966, -0.04936009645462036, -0.009807774797081947, 0.05057739466428757, -0.008626223541796207, 0.009010905399918556, 0.005984236486256123, -0.014290817081928253, -0.03206924721598625, 0.0001354510459350422, 0.014550568535923958, -0.03467271849513054, 0.007006146479398012, 0.044519051909446716, 0.04497252032160759, 0.014074974693357944, 0.020665587857365608, -0.03391413390636444, -0.10185188055038452, 0.016831425949931145, -0.03536931052803993, 0.03116660751402378, 0.04292915388941765, 0.01145512517541647, 0.03503865748643875, -0.005414918530732393, 0.08089932799339294, 0.03273582458496094, 0.02889908477663994, -0.007410346996039152, -0.041642557829618454, -0.02735670655965805, 0.01969345472753048, 0.02173524908721447, -0.03064495511353016, -0.02981153503060341, 0.021009214222431183, 0.02517845295369625, -0.006098421756178141, 0.06582356244325638, 0.019399801269173622, 0.002714738016948104, 0.011176517233252525, 0.020362528041005135, -0.001250973204150796, 0.02401222474873066, -0.012905281037092209, 0.026212578639388084, -0.03538057953119278, -0.06468869745731354, -0.009367432445287704, -0.000942682905588299, -0.01615424081683159, -0.09789180755615234, -0.005812445655465126, -0.01055342610925436, 0.011541815474629402, -0.018775131553411484, -0.011315712705254555, -0.007792151533067226, -0.07312719523906708, 0.018983783200383186, -0.006017586216330528, 0.009072876535356045, -0.034041229635477066, 0.03476927429437637, 0.037161581218242645, 0.0035688409116119146, -0.027498813346028328, 0.04346875846385956, -0.012886458076536655, -0.005051009822636843, -0.006644210312515497, -0.03715769201517105, -0.026987621560692787, -0.012380260974168777, 0.026225771754980087, 0.024558715522289276, 0.010074692778289318, 0.058134280145168304, -0.017029473558068275, 0.07024191319942474, 0.08640770614147186, -0.0333591029047966, 0.0194928590208292, -0.0173199325799942, -0.029103325679898262, -0.022152528166770935, -0.060025639832019806, 0.0179545097053051, 0.0029598644468933344, 0.030102141201496124, -0.00604196498170495, 0.056787196546792984, 0.017342640087008476, 0.03652077540755272, -0.02259029448032379, 0.0016624516574665904, -0.01611240766942501, -0.011797960847616196, 0.05632961913943291, -0.06482832878828049, 0.045762646943330765, 0.055012885481119156, 0.008919641375541687, -0.027893023565411568, -0.03981509804725647, 0.012506247498095036, -0.006021538283675909, -0.03997676819562912, -0.01431471947580576, 0.012843201868236065, -0.05020900443196297, -0.06673329323530197, 0.01292710192501545, -0.02964477241039276, -0.010023077018558979, 0.014468460343778133, 0.027412865310907364, -0.007794030476361513, 0.05078292638063431, 0.06904760748147964, 0.010781659744679928, 0.04315701872110367, -0.028276152908802032, -0.0106101855635643, -0.023608937859535217, 0.056595899164676666, 0.02916799858212471, -0.016764597967267036, 0.048279184848070145, 0.006212261505424976, 0.005375721957534552, 0.023028429597616196, -0.14235933125019073, -0.04298188164830208, 0.021529585123062134, -0.05994468554854393, -0.021790992468595505, 0.06085707247257233, 0.07318174839019775, 0.007370352279394865, 0.004252362996339798, 0.008098980411887169, -0.027165303006768227, -0.018506670370697975, -0.013275761157274246, -0.042604390531778336, -0.05594633147120476, -0.022503463551402092, -0.0017932332120835781, -0.06448874622583389, -0.005486208014190197, 0.07809080183506012, 0.06677938997745514, -0.007277651224285364, 0.04132897034287453, 0.06538846343755722, -0.006993541028350592, -0.07160920649766922, 0.005618093069642782, 0.03699648007750511, -0.04270041733980179, 0.018286067992448807, -0.04995284974575043, -0.006251519545912743, -0.0020620401483029127, -0.03138897567987442, -0.0074256714433431625, -0.005650277715176344, 0.0031596471089869738, 0.05466413497924805, -0.025800710543990135, -0.01606394350528717, 0.031013980507850647, 0.03257400169968605, -0.042125314474105835, 0.01940901018679142, -0.01940867118537426, 0.048341188579797745, -0.013253862038254738, -0.018263814970850945, -0.011239053681492805, 0.008422297425568104, -0.06659875065088272, -0.024905826896429062, -0.05034006014466286, -0.011738747358322144, -0.02210625261068344, 0.008788653649389744, -0.022230658680200577, -0.008755077607929707, 0.036111488938331604, 0.025446603074669838, 0.01984304189682007, -0.014857633970677853, 0.022745413705706596, -0.02764790877699852, 0.03991371765732765, -0.008456931449472904, -0.03355424851179123, 0.021802417933940887, -0.015295825898647308, 0.0029054132755845785, 0.05842134729027748, -0.059804026037454605, -0.004708120133727789, 0.034792717546224594, 0.020267829298973083, 0.000779640453401953, -0.09482257068157196, -0.05930311232805252, 0.10115303844213486, 0.06295908242464066, -0.0173462126404047, -0.034520473331213, -0.0009177934261970222, -0.006048090290278196, -0.03986724466085434, -0.019453592598438263, -0.03935462608933449, 0.049300726503133774, 0.007243040483444929, 0.03384343534708023, -0.046201709657907486, -0.005966230295598507, -0.010997629724442959, 0.0008244250784628093, 0.020455075427889824, 0.0141423549503088, 0.0025855302810668945, 0.00018928239296656102, -0.03236968442797661 ]
<p><a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poynting%27s_theorem" rel="nofollow">Poynting's theorem</a> is given by</p> <p>$$\frac{\partial}{\partial t}\int_{v}Udv + \oint_{A}\vec S\cdot \vec {dA} +\int_{v}\vec E\cdot\vec J dv =0 $$</p> <p>Where,</p> <ul> <li>the total electromagnetic energy inside the volume v is $U = \frac 1 2 (\vec E\cdot\vec D+\vec B\cdot\vec H)$</li> <li>the Poynting vector $\vec S=\vec E\times \vec H$</li> </ul> <p>This equation is interpreted as the conservation of electromagnetic and mechanical energy for a volume of space with each term representing respectively the rate at which</p> <ol> <li>electromagnetic energy changes inside the volume</li> <li>electromagnetic energy crosses the boundary of the enclosing surface</li> <li>mechanical work is done on charges inside the volume </li> </ol> <p>Now take the case of a charge accelerating from rest by a static electric field, and initially at the centre of a spherical volume fixed in space with radius cT where c is the speed of light and T the time taken for electromagnetic fields to propagate from the center to the spherical boundary. For 0 &lt; t &lt; T both the magnetic and mechanical energy inside the volume increases without electromagnetic energy crossing the boundary.</p> <p>So during this time, where does the negative term come from to maintain the RHS = 0 in Poynting's theorem?</p>
g1645
[ 0.06334854662418365, 0.017405524849891663, 0.0062906695529818535, -0.02250848338007927, -0.005450873170047998, -0.015693828463554382, 0.025027602910995483, 0.0058581773191690445, -0.0560387521982193, 0.011723705567419529, 0.011782307177782059, -0.021516652777791023, -0.05040663108229637, 0.011989668942987919, -0.0037203654646873474, 0.022382142022252083, 0.05311460420489311, -0.012902913615107536, 0.004357589408755302, -0.01156683824956417, -0.003367547644302249, 0.018752720206975937, -0.023878270760178566, -0.06442420184612274, -0.0015961071476340294, 0.018618686124682426, 0.07242678850889206, 0.011495254933834076, -0.007355130277574062, -0.077052041888237, 0.07463914901018143, 0.013343489728868008, 0.00968588050454855, -0.08700738847255707, -0.019467933103442192, 0.03502662479877472, 0.034273870289325714, 0.05780050531029701, 0.05341232940554619, -0.0009068528888747096, 0.07014930248260498, -0.08127591758966446, 0.04967803508043289, 0.015610558912158012, -0.04599906876683235, -0.0017772132996469736, -0.07036234438419342, -0.022263024002313614, -0.022208914160728455, 0.010936398059129715, 0.033290572464466095, 0.0021234205923974514, 0.00919042993336916, -0.01194023247808218, -0.006054216995835304, -0.042104944586753845, -0.010205444879829884, -0.058423854410648346, 0.004088880028575659, 0.014315233565866947, 0.01333948876708746, -0.016771191731095314, -0.02450125478208065, 0.03465279936790466, 0.08780620247125626, -0.046034689992666245, -0.026930730789899826, -0.011295407079160213, 0.012014105916023254, 0.010130406357347965, 0.019231535494327545, -0.01611930876970291, -0.021617848426103592, -0.029320377856492996, 0.01607118733227253, -0.0244363434612751, 0.012743360362946987, -0.006632691714912653, 0.019360430538654327, -0.03405393660068512, -0.06990388035774231, 0.009674696251749992, -0.009854232892394066, 0.0037787840701639652, 0.0332057848572731, 0.005663684569299221, 0.0161371398717165, -0.035755548626184464, -0.026256054639816284, 0.013127785176038742, -0.0063775693997740746, 0.02667156234383583, 0.03163386136293411, -0.06709466129541397, -0.011103191412985325, 0.03985568881034851, 0.019269118085503578, 0.03937417268753052, -0.03131808713078499, 0.0021861570421606302, -0.012884034775197506, -0.0500609315931797, -0.04514315351843834, 0.029183465987443924, 0.08679354190826416, 0.033885713666677475, -0.06801026314496994, -0.04262835159897804, -0.03695668280124664, 0.029558584094047546, 0.00008731777052162215, -0.022765934467315674, -0.08570471405982971, -0.020321235060691833, -0.004479929804801941, -0.006025590002536774, 0.07722077518701553, -0.03708309680223465, -0.018885772675275803, 0.024819936603307724, -0.03557087108492851, 0.022966597229242325, -0.00987149029970169, 0.007543446961790323, -0.00250476342625916, 0.04427295923233032, 0.007412355858832598, -0.0034015465062111616, 0.009812396951019764, 0.0041270144283771515, -0.0002260031906189397, -0.0020927400328218937, 0.00254839938133955, 0.0032558392267674208, 0.010303330607712269, 0.03225944563746452, 0.05454307049512863, 0.04062619432806969, 0.021888308227062225, -0.007651689928025007, -0.02545151673257351, -0.04376921057701111, 0.003799427067860961, -0.07298395782709122, -0.005891915410757065, 0.024331338703632355, 0.03318289294838905, -0.006090832874178886, 0.017094962298870087, 0.05456506460905075, -0.008727080188691616, 0.09329420328140259, 0.012937190942466259, -0.04755978658795357, 0.025162724778056145, -0.005460316315293312, 0.054765306413173676, 0.021680638194084167, 0.04415583610534668, -0.006306993775069714, 0.050421539694070816, 0.030045537278056145, 0.015409598127007484, 0.00028221317916177213, -0.03187383711338043, 0.031157324090600014, -0.05133157968521118, -0.06141098961234093, 0.015147325582802296, -0.06603116542100906, -0.06155850365757942, -0.011272098869085312, 0.023918217048048973, 0.030728258192539215, -0.02681046351790428, 0.03573589399456978, 0.0030452103819698095, 0.0026772809214890003, -0.03731650486588478, -0.030596178025007248, -0.047910600900650024, -0.07934290915727615, 0.05030057206749916, -0.057747967541217804, -0.036536429077386856, 0.04266834631562233, -0.01816093735396862, 0.018518809229135513, -0.10564874857664108, 0.05217856913805008, -0.027024736627936363, 0.03459187224507332, -0.0428067147731781, 0.06982330232858658, -0.06395868957042694, 0.01131812110543251, 0.028432706370949745, -0.008826954290270805, -0.006753112655133009, 0.010484742932021618, 0.02088063210248947, 0.03967137634754181, 0.007493288721889257, -0.014614646323025227, 0.055308058857917786, 0.005052448716014624, -0.03229918330907822, 0.030157845467329025, 0.020215552300214767, 0.002673783339560032, -0.007078039925545454, -0.0009688640129752457, 0.013864921405911446, 0.04766635596752167, 0.011292028240859509, 0.025182005017995834, -0.055288925766944885, -0.00922774150967598, -0.02308034710586071, -0.006258760113269091, -0.0887608602643013, 0.02864644303917885, 0.024087974801659584, -0.006455948110669851, 0.01056036539375782, -0.017602987587451935, -0.016236474737524986, -0.012032333761453629, -0.031606268137693405, -0.007882227189838886, -0.053657978773117065, 0.03541465103626251, 0.034356217831373215, -0.04757809638977051, 0.03690626099705696, 0.020547490566968918, -0.05569598823785782, 0.026016565039753914, 0.0016559904906898737, 0.015252940356731415, -0.029644755646586418, -0.02552769146859646, -0.04795731604099274, -0.009944846853613853, -0.013904212042689323, -0.04853261634707451, 0.0637408047914505, -0.02918490581214428, 0.013748633675277233, 0.04242008551955223, 0.013937711715698242, -0.01870066672563553, 0.012292037717998028, 0.0215362086892128, 0.008603277616202831, -0.017669837921857834, -0.11457892507314682, -0.006593218073248863, -0.026268186047673225, -0.06255249679088593, 0.01480186078697443, 0.03128255531191826, 0.06564995646476746, -0.012098662555217743, -0.07300692796707153, 0.029750043526291847, -0.07360222935676575, 0.04178725928068161, 0.054255835711956024, 0.0313640721142292, -0.03442995622754097, 0.07088623195886612, 0.012112538330256939, 0.007991401478648186, 0.02702859789133072, -0.04526393488049507, 0.009291448630392551, -0.014377332292497158, 0.04653603211045265, -0.0017324760556221008, -0.06437284499406815, -0.06582704931497574, -0.011281515471637249, 0.03309551253914833, -0.026885898783802986, -0.04182830825448036, -0.0029587990138679743, -0.02370443381369114, 0.005284341983497143, -0.0106540247797966, -0.037710029631853104, 0.04856724664568901, 0.029971512034535408, -0.024341102689504623, 0.050863537937402725, 0.022764183580875397, 0.02432951144874096, -0.004008293151855469, 0.005975353065878153, 0.025965554639697075, 0.034864988178014755, -0.06268405169248581, -0.028626123443245888, 0.016492752358317375, 0.02588040567934513, 0.03760150820016861, -0.07742883265018463, -0.03410077095031738, 0.020840363577008247, 0.016720270738005638, 0.021427417173981667, 0.005183015018701553, 0.04950810223817825, -0.016543617472052574, -0.009375191293656826, 0.015487823635339737, -0.005018768832087517, -0.0703561082482338, 0.0305922944098711, -0.023772040382027626, -0.037485044449567795, 0.012233080342411995, 0.0638909563422203, -0.03970358148217201, 0.011460976675152779, 0.027478765696287155, 0.0007675705710425973, -0.02404257468879223, -0.01265493594110012, 0.028022879734635353, -0.008916291408240795, -0.02184605412185192, -0.015575453639030457, -0.02508680708706379, -0.0007811698596924543, -0.03743131831288338, -0.006621901877224445, 0.029297146946191788, 0.025168053805828094, 0.0784427747130394, 0.028943240642547607, -0.03338279947638512, -0.08174606412649155, -0.0016541602090001106, -0.017887001857161522, -0.017215436324477196, -0.012995781376957893, -0.06330221146345139, 0.07321881502866745, -0.012792048044502735, 0.07285641878843307, -0.02803279086947441, 0.023570004850625992, -0.008905663155019283, -0.03301187604665756, 0.00034092669375240803, 0.009192275814712048, 0.04552808776497841, -0.05289333686232567, -0.02052895538508892, 0.024569764733314514, 0.02134411409497261, 0.03931150957942009, -0.02480310946702957, -0.022480890154838562, 0.03650210052728653, -0.015185967087745667, 0.03550443798303604, 0.018196843564510345, -0.048446670174598694, -0.011949955485761166, -0.0069685145281255245, -0.0588608980178833, 0.012523490004241467, 0.06309331208467484, -0.01052760612219572, 0.007191048935055733, 0.03511781617999077, -0.0025224254932254553, 0.01084856130182743, 0.042335376143455505, 0.01936643198132515, -0.012071079574525356, 0.01946658454835415, -0.0072139655239880085, 0.022251833230257034, -0.06049715355038643, -0.025964876636862755, 0.06553781032562256, -0.019400205463171005, 0.031372055411338806, 0.045181795954704285, 0.030082017183303833, -0.0050882906652987, 0.03430476784706116, -0.03289792314171791, 0.015337864868342876, -0.01288889441639185, -0.037065088748931885, -0.005366188008338213, 0.02906288206577301, 0.0018104766495525837, -0.042901910841464996, 0.0012424931628629565, 0.004075977951288223, -0.03584398329257965, 0.09158192574977875, 0.011826028116047382, -0.005142701789736748, 0.004943887237459421, -0.0018406491726636887, -0.06738299876451492, -0.018559986725449562, -0.041281260550022125, 0.036441605538129807, 0.0026008656714111567, 0.04124317318201065, 0.022069543600082397, -0.003926181234419346, -0.005667945835739374, 0.03030756302177906, 0.0703512504696846, 0.05146120861172676, -0.038323525339365005, -0.022514628246426582, 0.0394473597407341, 0.069984570145607, -0.0018018074333667755, 0.0000054654551604471635, -0.04968879371881485, 0.016249002888798714, 0.035289231687784195, 0.017841661348938942, 0.017774544656276703, -0.06423734128475189, 0.0979076623916626, -0.019436711445450783, 0.011944296769797802, -0.026893019676208496, -0.0455232597887516, 0.07681125402450562, -0.008043111301958561, -0.0018212514696642756, -0.03821996971964836, -0.003980625886470079, 0.06837556511163712, -0.023838629946112633, -0.07078702747821808, 0.030042938888072968, -0.020540907979011536, -0.008545011281967163, 0.013903619721531868, 0.04953000321984291, -0.04533103108406067, 0.004345602355897427, -0.03524905815720558, -0.0212460495531559, -0.035899169743061066, 0.04153257608413696, 0.006932345684617758, -0.018475918099284172, 0.040865201503038406, -0.024393068626523018, 0.03410369157791138, 0.04770640283823013, -0.011185158975422382, -0.046799592673778534, 0.007103807758539915, 0.015156164765357971, 0.028538234531879425, 0.051826201379299164, 0.0638214722275734, -0.002652785275131464, -0.007526841945946217, -0.00930026639252901, -0.01860983856022358, 0.028634829446673393, 0.0018135684076696634, 0.03617649897933006, -0.07265938818454742, 0.022801607847213745, 0.019764630123972893, -0.00023502594558522105, 0.0194803848862648, 0.001567799597978592, 0.032512206584215164, -0.005624530371278524, -0.000038668615161441267, 0.0033794406335800886, -0.011447123251855373, 0.00840981025248766, -0.04503771290183067, 0.019797012209892273, 0.023429255932569504, -0.011435171589255333, 0.05945570766925812, -0.00466481177136302, -0.03457014262676239, -0.029590371996164322, -0.00816353503614664, -0.02910301461815834, -0.0008984674350358546, -0.04237896576523781, 0.006984420586377382, 0.01633051224052906, 0.016446653753519058, 0.015345168299973011, 0.02544357255101204, 0.028000835329294205, 0.018548617139458656, -0.010116441175341606, 0.03571661561727524, 0.030116114765405655, 0.027316754683852196, 0.0319720022380352, -0.04762730747461319, -0.042962148785591125, 0.0015626369277015328, -0.03451148048043251, 0.05262831598520279, 0.047137655317783356, 0.009224086068570614, 0.028663644567131996, 0.00023146210878621787, 0.04294716566801071, 0.06220844015479088, -0.027995169162750244, -0.055769842118024826, -0.019748324528336525, 0.0403795950114727, -0.029918283224105835, -0.07658246904611588, 0.008740155957639217, 0.004886212293058634, -0.0349203497171402, -0.007458331063389778, -0.04026620462536812, -0.016984833404421806, 0.053171344101428986, -0.06456595659255981, -0.028194738551974297, -0.061476096510887146, 0.011549016460776329, -0.0033508746419101954, -0.06662005931138992, 0.03736118599772453, -0.03246413916349411, -0.0037605175748467445, 0.01579929329454899, -0.060918230563402176, 0.02076815627515316, 0.013013687916100025, -0.030221326276659966, -0.019738586619496346, -0.012793352827429771, 0.01994897425174713, 0.02542683482170105, -0.031681109219789505, -0.032001420855522156, -0.020787129178643227, 0.022365152835845947, -0.013518583960831165, -0.022949552163481712, 0.03374229744076729, 0.045472368597984314, -0.09934308379888535, -0.008179228752851486, -0.010807335376739502, 0.022502990439534187, -0.013122138567268848, -0.010756652802228928, 0.015260599553585052, -0.007222344167530537, 0.007914281450212002, 0.05980195477604866, 0.0017192389350384474, -0.028687166050076485, -0.08322466164827347, -0.09455689042806625, 0.004495769739151001, 0.025163596495985985, 0.017678679898381233, 0.07981489598751068, -0.06525104492902756, 0.012200498953461647, 0.008256439119577408, -0.028401361778378487, 0.022880475968122482, 0.08938847482204437, -0.032544925808906555, 0.038223087787628174, -0.007640737574547529, 0.006695616990327835, 0.01149452943354845, -0.08093155920505524, -0.03053860366344452, 0.006196191534399986, 0.014858669601380825, -0.01273236982524395, 0.06972922384738922, -0.03488323837518692, 0.04483761265873909, 0.03775031492114067, -0.038695190101861954, 0.028812577947974205, -0.030249284580349922, 0.00018177002493757755, -0.03500083461403847, 0.014251597225666046, 0.02671918086707592, 0.005536269396543503, 0.017672156915068626, 0.05085663124918938, 0.003204261651262641, -0.017754333093762398, 0.016124200075864792, 0.0019157828064635396, -0.017690327018499374, 0.04478836432099342, -0.033253174275159836, 0.014474097639322281, -0.04399310424923897, 0.03445350378751755, -0.004704102408140898, 0.07366099208593369, 0.0007110378937795758, -0.05266173183917999, -0.011585521511733532, 0.014971775934100151, 0.0020598764531314373, -0.006357017904520035, 0.023334676399827003, -0.0478210523724556, 0.06158239766955376, -0.004158989526331425, -0.04017651453614235, 0.028969233855605125, -0.01895795576274395, 0.016553467139601707, -0.06005721911787987, -0.03498292341828346, 0.04251517355442047, 0.06723744422197342, 0.013121486641466618, -0.07241863012313843, -0.04704387113451958, -0.0028621077071875334, -0.030440401285886765, -0.01349019818007946, -0.0012314128689467907, -0.008148491382598877, -0.03529917821288109, 0.012735884636640549, 0.03109806217253208, -0.03627217188477516, 0.017972532659769058, -0.01433478482067585, -0.014039088040590286, -0.0014515711227431893, -0.0264787245541811, 0.01638273149728775, 0.029941899701952934, 0.00334037933498621, 0.011955955997109413, 0.030246855691075325, 0.03764797002077103, -0.0323328971862793, -0.04548465460538864, 0.02979157492518425, -0.031167007982730865, -0.01137544959783554, -0.0035775096621364355, -0.031838178634643555, 0.04713699594140053, 0.019240975379943848, -0.003455894300714135, -0.026168446987867355, 0.061363585293293, 0.023099053651094437, 0.011816300451755524, -0.024513211101293564, 0.004401738289743662, -0.08539356291294098, -0.00036697243922390044, 0.0041140117682516575, 0.012414240278303623, -0.050697989761829376, 0.0052021159790456295, 0.026558702811598778, 0.02470610849559307, 0.02499532885849476, -0.05130873993039131, 0.058778081089258194, 0.03300971910357475, -0.027366630733013153, -0.02070184238255024, 0.04411850497126579, 0.03977316990494728, 0.028494084253907204, -0.043110329657793045, -0.048601776361465454, -0.03385729342699051, 0.009372396394610405, 0.026591023430228233, -0.04824507236480713, 0.014142182655632496, -0.015416746027767658, -0.05557836964726448, -0.009494563564658165, 0.06450507789850235, 0.011479789391160011, 0.034778889268636703, 0.0045321001671254635, 0.012953569181263447, 0.032255154103040695, 0.029781818389892578, -0.007028820924460888, 0.0023412599693983793, -0.015399111434817314, 0.01714642159640789, -0.03405612334609032, 0.0019454712746664882, -0.012747395783662796, -0.05998050794005394, 0.02060728147625923, -0.0223114974796772, 0.001441329368390143, -0.05586126819252968, 0.04855507239699364, -0.028002841398119926, -0.012512643821537495, -0.01321261003613472, 0.0032234503887593746, -0.03540205582976341, -0.023619599640369415, 0.02134171687066555, 0.03453429788351059, -0.016950173303484917, 0.02699299342930317, -0.012016176246106625, 0.03949837386608124, -0.0824582576751709, 0.01596144773066044, -0.03030785731971264, -0.0050028967671096325, 0.038292501121759415, -0.04613007605075836, 0.05993044376373291, 0.04478663578629494, -0.0587359294295311, 0.11287326365709305, 0.0009592209244146943, -0.07703797519207001, 0.04962608590722084, 0.06038705259561539, -0.025585412979125977, 0.06103701889514923, -0.016915883868932724, -0.021414775401353836, 0.03266286477446556, 0.015728892758488655, -0.037766747176647186, 0.06668630987405777, -0.03661710396409035, 0.013643193989992142, -0.06691160053014755, -0.008766422979533672, 0.03682735562324524 ]
<p>Can particles emit a virtual Higgs boson in a similar manner to the way a virtual photon is emitted?</p>
g1646
[ 0.025688428431749344, 0.023767035454511642, 0.02988342009484768, -0.018921280279755592, 0.03052508644759655, 0.002895186422392726, -0.023319778963923454, 0.018002642318606377, 0.0059042079374194145, -0.01184761617332697, -0.03173079341650009, 0.07461701333522797, -0.005235022399574518, 0.02855096571147442, -0.019184011965990067, -0.013647281564772129, 0.0359543077647686, -0.0016237101517617702, 0.037327684462070465, -0.005612017586827278, 0.012134934775531292, 0.014519894495606422, -0.019565802067518234, -0.021947886794805527, -0.06622473150491714, -0.015360923483967781, -0.022631974890828133, -0.03273535519838333, 0.03730738162994385, -0.005589968059211969, 0.05393076688051224, -0.05918024852871895, 0.061816949397325516, 0.017796335741877556, 0.03677268698811531, -0.04954337701201439, 0.02009531855583191, 0.009164023213088512, -0.049109652638435364, -0.00838734395802021, -0.03306039795279503, -0.010493015870451927, 0.006439313292503357, -0.0038565215654671192, -0.000146207312354818, 0.05258946493268013, 0.0704922080039978, 0.03574720025062561, 0.018419919535517693, -0.017088616266846657, -0.011976980604231358, -0.024274341762065887, -0.02405199408531189, 0.027760116383433342, 0.03378374129533768, 0.018356774002313614, 0.02416963502764702, 0.004822627641260624, 0.07779771834611893, 0.026251718401908875, -0.0357576422393322, 0.01550746988505125, -0.013616655953228474, -0.016913361847400665, 0.048912230879068375, -0.005957575514912605, -0.05002261698246002, -0.020909955725073814, -0.026739899069070816, 0.011539093218743801, 0.021401667967438698, 0.02489437162876129, -0.006114122923463583, -0.01998564787209034, 0.030469264835119247, 0.02014269307255745, -0.01586960069835186, -0.029587915167212486, -0.03745526447892189, 0.009977615438401699, -0.033823199570178986, -0.027030514553189278, -0.040272098034620285, -0.009322190657258034, 0.08232985436916351, -0.0909944400191307, -0.014834301546216011, -0.03083408996462822, -0.020223084837198257, -0.032451555132865906, -0.004519852809607983, -0.055435240268707275, 0.03949465602636337, 0.02669411338865757, -0.04075697064399719, -0.037012454122304916, -0.005188442766666412, 0.043087899684906006, 0.01966906525194645, -0.04719884693622589, -0.0239730067551136, -0.02010507881641388, 0.015066716820001602, -0.02896152250468731, -0.020075788721442223, -0.04212697595357895, 0.041619814932346344, -0.01385924220085144, 0.012261243537068367, -0.005937538575381041, -0.03635886684060097, -0.06681667268276215, -0.009892221540212631, -0.036841779947280884, -0.056186702102422714, 0.06714053452014923, 0.07156678289175034, -0.013602863065898418, -0.0028469241224229336, 0.08096309006214142, 0.06576582789421082, -0.020403875038027763, -0.03256855905056, 0.0023233757819980383, -0.0009445600444450974, 0.014548377133905888, -0.025349566712975502, 0.008291466161608696, -0.013324934989213943, -0.000796876207459718, 0.03642294183373451, -0.006614497862756252, -0.0036174790002405643, 0.022334109991788864, -0.010771628469228745, -0.004440162796527147, 0.09276401251554489, 0.0019072837894782424, 0.07923643290996552, -0.026118697598576546, -0.014312054961919785, -0.06487453728914261, -0.020285338163375854, 0.008291738107800484, -0.052381712943315506, 0.037219468504190445, 0.002537716645747423, 0.01095731183886528, -0.023673394694924355, 0.037674397230148315, 0.034986864775419235, 0.0487830676138401, 0.06909433752298355, -0.009892715141177177, 0.025101670995354652, 0.006321029271930456, 0.04248788580298424, 0.043591778725385666, -0.0565565750002861, -0.013464837335050106, 0.0032404994126409292, -0.06407168507575989, -0.004415431525558233, -0.053905028849840164, 0.02943476475775242, -0.002551978686824441, 0.03447530418634415, -0.03306739777326584, -0.026516292244195938, -0.02361884154379368, -0.0072946082800626755, 0.010753669776022434, -0.028753381222486496, 0.06660884618759155, 0.01415829174220562, -0.020631346851587296, -0.06517632305622101, -0.03266489878296852, 0.006247608922421932, 0.027803324162960052, -0.026562128216028214, -0.05524615943431854, -0.01526287104934454, 0.004300497937947512, 0.041923582553863525, 0.02931138686835766, -0.02039513736963272, -0.016328971832990646, 0.07680153101682663, -0.02057098038494587, -0.0698118582367897, -0.004181405529379845, 0.014291804283857346, -0.0061364490538835526, 0.021021809428930283, -0.048949092626571655, 0.014388822950422764, -0.03450359031558037, 0.0044993991032242775, 0.05305137857794762, 0.004077311605215073, 0.05998720973730087, -0.00806337594985962, -0.030087701976299286, 0.04486873745918274, -0.04593532904982567, 0.01430857926607132, -0.02439478412270546, 0.008872252888977528, -0.03459237515926361, 0.04256987199187279, -0.010980449616909027, 0.018853135406970978, 0.0076545290648937225, -0.03421720117330551, 0.01282521989196539, -0.03479438275098801, 0.025360161438584328, 0.010304387658834457, 0.016617946326732635, -0.062309615314006805, -0.004832828417420387, 0.0852135568857193, -0.03430148586630821, -0.007017685100436211, -0.004959405865520239, -0.05843467265367508, -0.07206820696592331, 0.009433547966182232, -0.006900280248373747, 0.029128026217222214, -0.01306319609284401, 0.0004039067425765097, -0.05886431783437729, 0.009696132503449917, 0.0444318950176239, -0.025199076160788536, 0.04216621071100235, 0.02589556574821472, 0.006390235852450132, 0.05854158475995064, -0.059466343373060226, 0.008593889884650707, -0.01053617149591446, 0.05236390233039856, -0.03305928781628609, 0.047893524169921875, 0.025810470804572105, -0.0035469678696244955, -0.02710971049964428, 0.01879780739545822, -0.03810194879770279, -0.013773156329989433, -0.04647522792220116, 0.03484295308589935, 0.011058750562369823, 0.028027096763253212, 0.04227058216929436, -0.05231763422489166, -0.058406367897987366, 0.007484239060431719, -0.07399699836969376, -0.03589623048901558, 0.060562245547771454, 0.047795042395591736, 0.013237114064395428, 0.04969694837927818, -0.05054960399866104, -0.006684483028948307, 0.027373353019356728, 0.0036432347260415554, -0.005437020678073168, 0.018320614472031593, 0.0117067014798522, -0.03632695600390434, 0.026018602773547173, -0.024960514158010483, 0.055420249700546265, 0.01541917398571968, -0.04312075674533844, -0.026449717581272125, 0.03348540514707565, -0.0017070291796699166, -0.0427447073161602, 0.02196923829615116, -0.07430551946163177, -0.05122600495815277, -0.05783607065677643, -0.08002147078514099, -0.020713869482278824, 0.023991167545318604, -0.030330907553434372, 0.01731964759528637, 0.04015413299202919, -0.042570047080516815, 0.05703696608543396, 0.05382688343524933, 0.045615263283252716, -0.02141457423567772, 0.07742654532194138, -0.03044062666594982, -0.03336985036730766, -0.051254499703645706, -0.02488921768963337, 0.02285495214164257, 0.0016401157481595874, -0.08741139620542526, 0.015631558373570442, -0.006203355733305216, -0.02755887806415558, -0.027658827602863312, 0.056550852954387665, -0.01774730533361435, 0.046631839126348495, 0.02905110828578472, -0.04493395984172821, -0.0027245800010859966, 0.08999477326869965, -0.03760768845677376, -0.0017878406215459108, -0.041214458644390106, 0.02247343398630619, 0.01764000579714775, 0.01288428995758295, 0.034462038427591324, 0.05415322631597519, 0.0005681386683136225, -0.03553803265094757, -0.04664028435945511, -0.02200043946504593, 0.011243336834013462, -0.07968474924564362, -0.048597898334264755, 0.042588625103235245, -0.012976890429854393, -0.030405109748244286, 0.021670717746019363, 0.019396178424358368, 0.022076139226555824, 0.029292382299900055, 0.045285504311323166, 0.017868196591734886, -0.06606413424015045, 0.02106953226029873, -0.0067059798166155815, 0.027658114209771156, -0.004273307975381613, -0.012588556855916977, 0.029133232310414314, -0.03196694701910019, 0.048708394169807434, 0.021056802943348885, 0.018209543079137802, -0.003965827636420727, -0.0021239754278212786, -0.012512259185314178, 0.03167226165533066, 0.06426612287759781, 0.0557171069085598, -0.03934008255600929, -0.024691235274076462, -0.051049601286649704, 0.0981433168053627, 0.02040133811533451, -0.03203119710087776, -0.00378882372751832, -0.0021610052790492773, 0.011275442317128181, -0.023034796118736267, 0.03864840790629387, 0.0070641362108290195, -0.008899482898414135, 0.017873961478471756, 0.03999553248286247, -0.051141783595085144, -0.01601075567305088, 0.04831583425402641, -0.03240811824798584, 0.0015737428329885006, -0.0033480830024927855, -0.06132171303033829, 0.06521957367658615, 0.06753584742546082, 0.04489485174417496, 0.02727680467069149, -0.00993487797677517, -0.03883861005306244, -0.0133121432736516, 0.035383544862270355, -0.01044004037976265, 0.02526603452861309, -0.003658164292573929, -0.006714223884046078, -0.012716598808765411, 0.01970529370009899, -0.022167593240737915, -0.006964532658457756, -0.014689912088215351, 0.03757726401090622, -0.04155658558011055, 0.0038509629666805267, 0.05450771376490593, 0.0008147762273438275, -0.01562928967177868, 0.02726104110479355, -0.023177219554781914, 0.0397951640188694, 0.006202672608196735, -0.04574991762638092, -0.03444717451930046, -0.0266721248626709, 0.005533675197511911, 0.018902692943811417, 0.06330696493387222, 0.03331364691257477, -0.00312483380548656, 0.005713759455829859, 0.05103727802634239, 0.05412804335355759, 0.024478068575263023, -0.008020615205168724, -0.046830933541059494, 0.048578906804323196, 0.011308539658784866, 0.005828164983540773, 0.06960586458444595, 0.031589992344379425, 0.021844739094376564, -0.060673151165246964, -0.005667229648679495, 0.05196095257997513, -0.017438221722841263, 0.05962425842881203, -0.00939247477799654, 0.03428148478269577, 0.02154769003391266, -0.06951150298118591, -0.033938951790332794, 0.07558788359165192, 0.04915820434689522, 0.007977758534252644, -0.019381394609808922, 0.08965552598237991, -0.02346731908619404, 0.06141132861375809, 0.04453974589705467, -0.05674413964152336, -0.013323317281901836, -0.011061171069741249, 0.0031974660232663155, 0.02474834956228733, -0.016176637262105942, -0.04595001041889191, -0.021346086636185646, 0.015112095512449741, -0.027931874617934227, -0.0040345583111047745, 0.008936458267271519, -0.04856101796030998, -0.039338868111371994, -0.06488874554634094, 0.01074583362787962, 0.08176324516534805, -0.00040586519753560424, 0.0040394943207502365, -0.01634533703327179, -0.09351981431245804, -0.030951935797929764, -0.02964344061911106, -0.049885619431734085, -0.021736783906817436, -0.018324455246329308, 0.018573850393295288, 0.007161153946071863, 0.06010676920413971, -0.05215480551123619, -0.02468518540263176, -0.01343709696084261, -0.03435083106160164, -0.04288433492183685, 0.00029386571259237826, -0.004599949810653925, 0.006559586618095636, -0.02775951474905014, -0.0430784747004509, 0.00008470085595035926, -0.050413064658641815, 0.05256534740328789, -0.009410005062818527, -0.014456340111792088, -0.03286753594875336, -0.025389166548848152, -0.003997277468442917, -0.02255217544734478, 0.06926612555980682, -0.014843464829027653, -0.036973387002944946, 0.0173934455960989, -0.03270702809095383, 0.08174155652523041, -0.011450503021478653, -0.06442268937826157, -0.018003035336732864, -0.01995357684791088, 0.018756259232759476, 0.10524801909923553, 0.024285510182380676, -0.0025569277349859476, -0.0008962902356870472, -0.0166384968906641, -0.046145327389240265, -0.04204122722148895, -0.042588382959365845, 0.01403401605784893, 0.024134308099746704, 0.037272416055202484, -0.023321185261011124, 0.016432959586381912, 0.02794746682047844, -0.012797366827726364, -0.01276329904794693, -0.006851967424154282, -0.0024664979428052902, 0.01195654645562172, -0.01020234078168869, -0.0034219243098050356, -0.06362465769052505, -0.013545884750783443, 0.0663246437907219, 0.00011657427239697427, 0.013498358428478241, 0.009397126734256744, 0.014413290657103062, 0.05794790759682655, -0.017807597294449806, -0.008614604361355305, 0.017305489629507065, 0.00046560962800867856, 0.0026177421677857637, 0.058855749666690826, -0.029883956536650658, -0.03817684203386307, 0.0515449084341526, 0.002655371557921171, 0.0659480169415474, -0.009211943484842777, -0.00815026368945837, 0.03607131913304329, 0.03826102241873741, -0.04130106791853905, -0.09000895917415619, 0.07239318639039993, 0.0346040241420269, 0.029951628297567368, 0.002002590335905552, 0.005894682835787535, -0.01004934124648571, 0.027478812262415886, 0.08828101307153702, -0.023043204098939896, -0.011186824180185795, 0.0018595329020172358, -0.002826157258823514, -0.02129078283905983, 0.03616898134350777, 0.035863246768713, 0.0011140446877107024, -0.032079871743917465, 0.0011871872702613473, -0.024467414245009422, -0.005655496846884489, 0.0016356537817046046, -0.03056775964796543, -0.003024650039151311, 0.0008449220331385732, -0.030150998383760452, 0.031780414283275604, 0.004075841512531042, -0.037473954260349274, 0.02477494813501835, 0.02986372448503971, -0.01192402932792902, 0.013037992641329765, 0.007256380282342434, 0.010830533690750599, -0.017011472955346107, -0.010246225632727146, 0.028785690665245056, -0.010296192020177841, 0.0657866895198822, -0.038873091340065, -0.03129203990101814, -0.0701494887471199, -0.027370965108275414, -0.004181481432169676, 0.014860155060887337, -0.01746157743036747, -0.035071007907390594, -0.060903940349817276, -0.02711600996553898, 0.022923171520233154, -0.011358392424881458, -0.08775436133146286, -0.004688024055212736, 0.011617067269980907, 0.04353262856602669, -0.025105008855462074, 0.061674270778894424, 0.008709925226867199, 0.02983102947473526, -0.039265453815460205, -0.002359983278438449, -0.005141779780387878, -0.015734991058707237, 0.045342911034822464, -0.02407713420689106, 0.019821666181087494, 0.04358695447444916, 0.07646298408508301, 0.03495059907436371, -0.002724163932725787, -0.07662617415189743, 0.03010689839720726, -0.046856675297021866, 0.0044126748107373714, 0.025022855028510094, 0.016861770302057266, 0.05828879773616791, 0.026853371411561966, 0.04103061184287071, -0.014883438125252724, -0.015843544155359268, 0.006411649286746979, 0.052385300397872925, 0.01168322004377842, 0.02333134599030018, -0.030249906703829765, -0.015912408009171486, -0.07370823621749878, -0.00870387814939022, -0.018909253180027008, -0.009525042958557606, 0.0020059433300048113, 0.02582477778196335, -0.0934254452586174, 0.06975816190242767, -0.012940196320414543, -0.009500599466264248, -0.0034528994001448154, 0.03657681867480278, 0.02409827522933483, -0.01816214621067047, -0.01571245677769184, 0.003512259339913726, -0.01368959341198206, -0.029584361240267754, -0.018227938562631607, 0.01701565645635128, 0.028351519256830215, -0.015701500698924065, -0.053461186587810516, 0.0027120192535221577, 0.05556850507855415, -0.062282904982566833, 0.0388307124376297, 0.0036806415300816298, -0.026990488171577454, -0.049407411366701126, -0.025675971060991287, 0.018802784383296967, 0.014712488278746605, -0.058415841311216354, -0.0761951431632042, -0.006944318301975727, -0.012220462784171104, -0.07308453321456909, -0.047010842710733414, 0.10535619407892227, -0.01976405829191208, 0.05473494902253151, 0.01983002759516239, 0.042609211057424545, 0.009101862087845802, 0.0345015823841095, 0.01082221046090126, -0.024283038452267647, 0.0117697324603796, -0.016836732625961304, 0.03716254606842995, 0.03209592401981354, -0.01053193025290966, -0.01603449508547783, 0.02545219473540783, -0.03311117738485336, 0.010236118920147419, 0.038115132600069046, 0.07206927984952927, -0.035655342042446136, 0.0014011852908879519, -0.0050881123170256615, -0.08901965618133545, 0.03839579224586487, 0.019208667799830437, -0.040002573281526566, 0.007269982248544693, -0.0062521835789084435, 0.02412058599293232, 0.008149632252752781, -0.02658674865961075, -0.053513772785663605, 0.03691022843122482, 0.03908121585845947, 0.04461907222867012, 0.09000518918037415, -0.004670973867177963, -0.02157415822148323, -0.02008291520178318, 0.06261273473501205, 0.00903014000505209, -0.04280510172247887, -0.038136329501867294, 0.021291686221957207, -0.012701116502285004, 0.015755435451865196, 0.029131293296813965, -0.05908176302909851, 0.002423166995868087, -0.005723295267671347, -0.019527122378349304, 0.01577012985944748, 0.01339254155755043, -0.03173515945672989, -0.017139006406068802, -0.0009852242656052113, -0.03880888596177101, -0.013516396284103394, 0.011510804295539856, 0.05121258273720741, 0.04106864333152771, -0.007316606119275093, 0.0003926404460798949, -0.05289602652192116, 0.022467637434601784, -0.006241301540285349, 0.013268749229609966, -0.023052845150232315, -0.03895699232816696, -0.03757305443286896, 0.00455369520932436, -0.0016396339051425457, -0.0044248285703361034, 0.00762479892000556, -0.02139083668589592, 0.04192423075437546, 0.06616920977830887, -0.06901157647371292, -0.041292525827884674, 0.057086847722530365, -0.02057718299329281, -0.02825753577053547, -0.017109908163547516, -0.0007061425712890923, 0.012102880515158176, -0.025392543524503708, -0.0005664845812134445, -0.031006673350930214, -0.0043768687173724174, 0.034509945660829544 ]
<p>Why did they used to make the mill chimneys so tall?</p> <p>This question was asked in an Engineering Interview at Cambridge University.</p>
g1647
[ 0.07341530919075012, 0.023788131773471832, -0.004606716334819794, -0.026484554633498192, 0.04343874379992485, 0.043245043605566025, 0.0008185040787793696, 0.034109927713871, -0.031358666718006134, -0.022995389997959137, -0.045728810131549835, -0.010673906654119492, 0.07668855041265488, 0.03385161980986595, 0.0014082875568419695, 0.009007210843265057, -0.021597502753138542, -0.032369013875722885, -0.01205055695027113, -0.016873307526111603, -0.0745314508676529, -0.05171191319823265, 0.024974139407277107, -0.05034736543893814, -0.09515401721000671, -0.03569813817739487, -0.03694618493318558, 0.003687736578285694, 0.03870267793536186, 0.03445124626159668, -0.0038581914268434048, 0.01804523356258869, 0.0009019654244184494, 0.01733148843050003, -0.0029380405321717262, -0.04741048440337181, -0.009537860751152039, 0.00011003642430296168, 0.01478468906134367, -0.03866912052035332, 0.022075319662690163, -0.05762960761785507, -0.006494039203971624, -0.031458187848329544, -0.005661786999553442, 0.00912478007376194, -0.01021326333284378, 0.02455618418753147, 0.0012960119638592005, -0.037225887179374695, 0.011318042874336243, -0.06400121748447418, 0.00642850948497653, 0.05579249560832977, 0.058898214250802994, 0.0017459731316193938, 0.03443355858325958, -0.007536671590059996, 0.06070202589035034, 0.027661491185426712, -0.059653349220752716, 0.023606691509485245, 0.03406756743788719, 0.06051133573055267, 0.01697660982608795, -0.023667780682444572, 0.03939298167824745, -0.0005400548689067364, -0.015287863090634346, 0.022855471819639206, -0.0017017333302646875, -0.05792224407196045, 0.02848338708281517, 0.01775135099887848, -0.045455604791641235, 0.026794571429491043, 0.008311500772833824, 0.025117726996541023, -0.012957879342138767, 0.00935248751193285, 0.022598808631300926, -0.020377635955810547, -0.016577448695898056, -0.008601869456470013, 0.02701777033507824, 0.035550303757190704, -0.007212763652205467, -0.03588048741221428, 0.0064017279073596, 0.003984290640801191, -0.0396769717335701, -0.016244500875473022, 0.08044291287660599, 0.048996493220329285, -0.04478893056511879, -0.049631617963314056, -0.021927155554294586, 0.002082552295178175, 0.03338419646024704, 0.022100217640399933, -0.037766534835100174, -0.056823644787073135, 0.010011293925344944, 0.020219312980771065, 0.026829931885004044, 0.009495525620877743, 0.024033132940530777, -0.020101748406887054, 0.005276366136968136, -0.021933654323220253, -0.03235015645623207, 0.018129637464880943, -0.06462123990058899, -0.011288177222013474, 0.0001472741278121248, 0.05192876607179642, 0.09078919142484665, 0.0072754728607833385, 0.028775908052921295, 0.015092313289642334, 0.010604549199342728, -0.09168535470962524, -0.09171164780855179, -0.048337120562791824, -0.011861579492688179, -0.028316279873251915, 0.018711846321821213, -0.03061654046177864, 0.009996636770665646, -0.050319571048021317, 0.03331324830651283, 0.010030610486865044, -0.05286743491888046, -0.005389214027673006, 0.06369025260210037, 0.06471586972475052, -0.03960896283388138, -0.04407966881990433, 0.027560824528336525, 0.03174485266208649, -0.0343148410320282, -0.033020392060279846, 0.015169532969594002, -0.019604548811912537, 0.058144908398389816, 0.026043616235256195, 0.020092399790883064, -0.0132827740162611, -0.07583801448345184, -0.018792863935232162, 0.019208045676350594, 0.012723993510007858, 0.0487697459757328, -0.02046891488134861, -0.0010429826797917485, -0.0015752646140754223, 0.00894633773714304, 0.055766236037015915, -0.017938999459147453, 0.04311675578355789, 0.0030678934417665005, -0.007538897451013327, -0.0023302927147597075, 0.014200805686414242, -0.06082291528582573, 0.038836780935525894, -0.029292626306414604, 0.0064441435970366, 0.04336659610271454, -0.03550035506486893, -0.02115795947611332, 0.03756715729832649, 0.0419139638543129, 0.039486903697252274, -0.031264521181583405, 0.0062557910569012165, 0.06251136213541031, -0.10372120141983032, 0.01009790226817131, -0.060940247029066086, -0.007239805534482002, 0.02796199358999729, 0.007874340750277042, -0.01213764026761055, -0.012013480067253113, -0.020556703209877014, 0.05985778942704201, -0.027511898428201675, -0.000727858510799706, -0.0044290111400187016, -0.03199084848165512, -0.031212182715535164, -0.011884372681379318, 0.021844571456313133, 0.007784751709550619, -0.06676812469959259, 0.004656810313463211, 0.031068678945302963, -0.02342519722878933, 0.01573297753930092, -0.010753387585282326, 0.005932818166911602, 0.026530852541327477, -0.021288469433784485, -0.01259766798466444, 0.03228692710399628, -0.005034992005676031, 0.056409165263175964, 0.01910846121609211, -0.039474427700042725, -0.047893159091472626, 0.03470466658473015, -0.01380250882357359, -0.015832362696528435, -0.004880643915385008, -0.0030573857948184013, 0.0054120090790092945, -0.027236174792051315, -0.008359085768461227, 0.05415577441453934, -0.014402620494365692, -0.08254977315664291, 0.05782205983996391, 0.032295018434524536, 0.08076705783605576, -0.0628558099269867, -0.0024905866011977196, -0.010469864122569561, -0.03650107607245445, -0.038804538547992706, -0.043215759098529816, 0.01599758304655552, 0.0036709634587168694, -0.00494577270001173, 0.00023322795459534973, 0.050180405378341675, 0.012164277024567127, -0.03817801550030708, 0.03162624314427376, 0.0070694321766495705, 0.008740141987800598, -0.0882987529039383, 0.017892584204673767, -0.06195788085460663, -0.016964713111519814, 0.005951365921646357, 0.03916124254465103, -0.042361266911029816, 0.019647255539894104, 0.01765107735991478, 0.03380764648318291, -0.02034258283674717, 0.03300775587558746, -0.01705082878470421, -0.017534539103507996, -0.0639963150024414, 0.016937974840402603, 0.05514617636799812, -0.05373173952102661, 0.0010942296357825398, -0.037619296461343765, -0.054211460053920746, 0.033915430307388306, -0.035953037440776825, 0.019871428608894348, 0.04497115686535835, -0.0650232806801796, -0.014087922871112823, 0.015559270046651363, 0.011989732272922993, 0.01864556595683098, 0.01712990738451481, 0.05405531823635101, -0.020813390612602234, -0.04991131275892258, -0.057733505964279175, -0.031641874462366104, 0.03145971521735191, 0.017997950315475464, 0.016014304012060165, 0.0022815456613898277, -0.00954450573772192, -0.09358560293912888, 0.015118274837732315, 0.0651162713766098, -0.027349382638931274, -0.04180293157696724, -0.047414153814315796, 0.015670171007514, -0.022207222878932953, -0.03598622977733612, 0.009096302092075348, 0.01183534786105156, -0.012792140245437622, 0.008788729086518288, 0.050316765904426575, -0.020218398422002792, -0.012621311470866203, -0.07658706605434418, 0.007941391319036484, 0.009809364564716816, 0.0179731547832489, -0.05199635401368141, -0.015880318358540535, 0.0023403549566864967, 0.0046177813783288, -0.004721926990896463, -0.022701114416122437, -0.07637931406497955, -0.03225011005997658, -0.042069561779499054, 0.031062977388501167, 0.01046709343791008, 0.048084158450365067, -0.0854031965136528, 0.016569219529628754, 0.05521455407142639, 0.01678532361984253, 0.047247085720300674, 0.03415229916572571, 0.013673361390829086, -0.002052940661087632, -0.027706265449523926, -0.06166401505470276, -0.026854265481233597, -0.026965461671352386, 0.04235783591866493, 0.017351578921079636, 0.02534014917910099, -0.006516482215374708, 0.038621269166469574, -0.0609520860016346, 0.013593370094895363, -0.0196684543043375, 0.000340229831635952, 0.026970669627189636, 0.03383582457900047, -0.009791138581931591, 0.008601105771958828, -0.04156312718987465, 0.004749580752104521, 0.05779735743999481, -0.10634740442037582, 0.007285332772880793, 0.007440913934260607, 0.010359569452702999, -0.011523292399942875, -0.032132454216480255, -0.00028549061971716583, 0.013102726079523563, -0.004669115878641605, 0.015985434874892235, -0.018785810098052025, 0.00419692974537611, 0.022725986316800117, 0.012293869629502296, -0.03139428421854973, 0.020838938653469086, 0.01564577966928482, -0.03200338035821915, 0.06272264569997787, 0.010536571964621544, -0.003081530099734664, -0.0661843940615654, -0.03199778124690056, 0.02279837802052498, -0.054305240511894226, 0.06683790683746338, 0.06419176608324051, 0.016301343217492104, 0.017618119716644287, 0.03114900179207325, -0.07343961298465729, 0.018572749570012093, -0.0008171482477337122, 0.04260828346014023, 0.010751713067293167, 0.006781210191547871, -0.030170444399118423, -0.0013052388094365597, 0.0011208297219127417, 0.0268928911536932, -0.02524358034133911, -0.0418253019452095, -0.025540856644511223, -0.0019093950977548957, -0.07407805323600769, -0.0035478638019412756, 0.03524500131607056, -0.04560364410281181, -0.009305308572947979, 0.004666970111429691, -0.03764922544360161, 0.0065054758451879025, -0.023952942341566086, -0.014433883130550385, -0.007600430399179459, -0.006699793040752411, 0.021973496302962303, -0.03852646425366402, -0.003100128611549735, -0.0353703610599041, 0.03049248456954956, 0.0707007348537445, -0.02712620049715042, -0.023742977529764175, 0.054667770862579346, -0.01777666248381138, -0.005049597006291151, -0.008046559058129787, -0.007932166568934917, 0.02719114162027836, 0.009293216280639172, -0.04105820134282112, 0.010415741242468357, -0.029807385057210922, 0.05583329498767853, 0.047196775674819946, -0.041160065680742264, 0.0019257426029071212, 0.024233011528849602, -0.0007875742739997804, -0.037712469696998596, -0.04511243849992752, 0.10907848924398422, 0.058425866067409515, -0.049110688269138336, -0.06663099676370621, -0.06849803775548935, 0.0018821604317054152, 0.06771817803382874, -0.005799852777272463, 0.004716289229691029, -0.03658897429704666, 0.05763830989599228, 0.01335762720555067, -0.014320755377411842, 0.013425301760435104, -0.02213585190474987, 0.03271358460187912, 0.00651962123811245, -0.011736446060240269, 0.0350751131772995, -0.025403019040822983, 0.009547735564410686, -0.04142747074365616, 0.014178846962749958, 0.006133112125098705, -0.03662347421050072, 0.06892022490501404, 0.025523889809846878, -0.0034797785338014364, -0.036609407514333725, 0.03246810659766197, 0.04941052943468094, -0.04442715272307396, 0.002988711930811405, 0.011918153613805771, 0.026134604588150978, 0.03212429955601692, -0.014496195130050182, -0.0711018368601799, -0.026492714881896973, -0.006171691231429577, 0.0033275000751018524, -0.0015740569215267897, -0.03196122869849205, -0.059967972338199615, -0.04405933618545532, -0.015679089352488518, -0.009515346959233284, -0.031221605837345123, -0.002008480951189995, 0.07348448038101196, -0.011131266131997108, 0.011831170879304409, -0.01617341674864292, -0.018400859087705612, 0.006419650744646788, -0.027812276035547256, 0.014401489868760109, 0.004660455510020256, 0.020596561953425407, -0.01186705008149147, 0.0012665539979934692, 0.005603882949799299, -0.016507793217897415, 0.03481229767203331, 0.00998157262802124, -0.038869261741638184, 0.02293138951063156, 0.0022098408080637455, -0.049836959689855576, 0.008987168781459332, -0.022829029709100723, -0.05746069923043251, 0.01062503457069397, -0.011557462625205517, 0.07715913653373718, -0.021664487197995186, 0.004446516744792461, 0.044544149190187454, -0.05717708170413971, -0.018987668678164482, 0.009884153492748737, -0.003584058489650488, -0.011089864186942577, 0.017206447198987007, 0.028887474909424782, -0.014716122299432755, 0.037928253412246704, -0.039819978177547455, 0.004234276711940765, 0.00011080358672188595, 0.10337129980325699, 0.010122312232851982, 0.007394837215542793, 0.014630469493567944, 0.014421210624277592, -0.011517704464495182, 0.0397200733423233, -0.011346803978085518, 0.03908238932490349, -0.021939409896731377, -0.034843672066926956, 0.032042697072029114, -0.021132027730345726, -0.04424683749675751, 0.02443443424999714, 0.015398789197206497, -0.007201997097581625, -0.03415830433368683, 0.03228036314249039, -0.022564956918358803, -0.0065537611953914165, 0.07645392417907715, 0.02005821280181408, -0.01670697145164013, -0.004945050925016403, -0.020875439047813416, 0.005829388741403818, -0.031080469489097595, -0.0017471937462687492, 0.014579209499061108, 0.018663577735424042, -0.009226018562912941, 0.08265932649374008, 0.06964021176099777, 0.09447228908538818, 0.019080037251114845, 0.0307024959474802, 0.0177410077303648, 0.06583496183156967, -0.07785949856042862, -0.030866777524352074, 0.032424651086330414, 0.02209583669900894, -0.023281453177332878, -0.014096364378929138, -0.033341631293296814, 0.058183539658784866, -0.02656160481274128, -0.03888549655675888, -0.019467374309897423, -0.05105586722493172, 0.0035781271290034056, -0.002917551901191473, 0.023931216448545456, 0.0390513613820076, 0.04610108211636543, 0.050865281373262405, 0.008044691756367683, 0.08157233893871307, -0.029509441927075386, -0.003946303389966488, -0.0017624254105612636, -0.015898579731583595, 0.06372156739234924, -0.04622529447078705, -0.0171620175242424, 0.006130424328148365, 0.04422200843691826, 0.02698167972266674, -0.037095241248607635, -0.003827053355053067, -0.023765699937939644, 0.010535471141338348, 0.05353321507573128, 0.07540005445480347, 0.021850550547242165, 0.02497953176498413, -0.07461035996675491, -0.031138664111495018, 0.03346527740359306, 0.036832861602306366, -0.04984404891729355, 0.026687948033213615, 0.07159622013568878, -0.02425718680024147, -0.06009833142161369, 0.010432119481265545, -0.028857391327619553, 0.01417401060461998, 0.014278870075941086, 0.07310739904642105, 0.04995422437787056, 0.06844774633646011, -0.02025783248245716, 0.014388312585651875, -0.012395489029586315, 0.003522102488204837, 0.0408371239900589, -0.03218349814414978, -0.01765572838485241, -0.04226028174161911, -0.015469747595489025, -0.0069458866491913795, -0.015491466969251633, -0.000994412461295724, -0.003723239293321967, 0.01473974622786045, 0.02232387848198414, -0.06674455851316452, -0.07688552886247635, 0.03213382139801979, -0.009092094376683235, 0.021259380504488945, 0.0345957912504673, 0.04387284442782402, 0.03228726238012314, -0.03170312941074371, 0.0490887388586998, -0.026510227471590042, -0.0064825559966266155, -0.06438720226287842, 0.011430510319769382, 0.0040523153729736805, -0.024281183257699013, -0.022310903295874596, 0.007060520350933075, 0.025998437777161598, -0.03316391259431839, -0.06694825738668442, -0.003997313790023327, -0.015515008941292763, -0.04575382173061371, -0.003952715080231428, 0.00039561145240440965, -0.004318216349929571, 0.0006649449351243675, -0.06015462055802345, 0.02590213157236576, -0.03911393880844116, 0.011820651590824127, 0.012860885821282864, -0.052504200488328934, -0.004778191912919283, 0.010611606761813164, 0.0022342833690345287, -0.028301754966378212, 0.05034446343779564, -0.005452550947666168, 0.035164725035429, 0.0032183704897761345, 0.004523968789726496, 0.019856827333569527, 0.04534260928630829, 0.008476718328893185, -0.004814561922103167, 0.03331596404314041, 0.0016236718511208892, 0.004936229437589645, 0.0026258600410073996, -0.027767900377511978, 0.0010284761665388942, -0.04958099126815796, 0.0012762745609506965, 0.04443807154893875, 0.015886835753917694, -0.02773623913526535, 0.019404403865337372, -0.019306913018226624, 0.06009042635560036, -0.036656275391578674, -0.05125386267900467, 0.002973780734464526, -0.01932428404688835, 0.06902433186769485, 0.08941885083913803, 0.017156140878796577, 0.005757173523306847, 0.04398776963353157, 0.008195594884455204, -0.03635219484567642, 0.06648050993680954, -0.019097618758678436, 0.02860935777425766, -0.04424826428294182, -0.009513100609183311, -0.05347670242190361, 0.011507545597851276, -0.0008320208871737123, 0.013786816038191319, -0.002788666170090437, -0.0017328212270513177, -0.016348017379641533, 0.007907466031610966, 0.06583492457866669, -0.04229415953159332, 0.060110267251729965, -0.027247989550232887, 0.015921873971819878, 0.06144356727600098, 0.05970386415719986, 0.06411146372556686, -0.012290584854781628, -0.011071543209254742, -0.024622544646263123, -0.04707799851894379, 0.020189153030514717, -0.023112131282687187, 0.029900867491960526, 0.01466353703290224, -0.04861339554190636, -0.019115498289465904, 0.06241946294903755, 0.07501522451639175, -0.02033618465065956, -0.08001986145973206, -0.010092529468238354, 0.026520302519202232, 0.03814959153532982, 0.015173813328146935, 0.08290775865316391, -0.04862058162689209, -0.050734829157590866, 0.0068168300203979015, 0.06314487755298615, -0.030772719532251358, 0.001737335347570479, 0.0186472050845623, 0.020427240058779716, -0.0128320949152112, 0.023531809449195862, -0.02816213108599186, -0.07000957429409027, 0.01986115239560604, -0.008116590790450573, -0.060498934239149094, -0.005789182148873806, 0.051321905106306076, 0.03881075978279114, -0.0106876315549016, 0.027518201619386673, 0.03816959261894226, -0.090970978140831, 0.06385696679353714, 0.06333591043949127, 0.020313723012804985, -0.025652147829532623, 0.028140762820839882, 0.0035401582717895508, 0.04730033129453659, -0.025006525218486786, 0.013722078874707222, -0.037451982498168945, -0.008704251609742641, -0.027314305305480957 ]
<p>The context is that I'm building a simulation of a starfield, as seen from a relativistic spaceship. (EDIT: the simulation can now be found <a href="http://tinyurl.com/pt8h6j4" rel="nofollow">here</a>.)</p> <p>One reference that I'm using is this paper by John M. McKinley (1980) "Relativistic transformation of solid angle":</p> <p><a href="http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1980AmJPh..48..612M" rel="nofollow">http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1980AmJPh..48..612M</a></p> <p><a href="http://cartan.e-moka.net/content/download/248/1479/file/Astronave%20relativistica.pdf" rel="nofollow">http://cartan.e-moka.net/content/download/248/1479/file/Astronave%20relativistica.pdf</a></p> <p>There are two formulas, one with D^2, and one with D^4 (D being the Doppler factor). The logic stated by the above paper seems to be the following:</p> <p>Use D^2 for:</p> <ul> <li>comparing two detectors in relative motion</li> <li>plane waves</li> <li>stars</li> </ul> <p>Use D^4 for:</p> <ul> <li>comparing a moving source of radiation, relative to a fixed source</li> <li>extended sources: galaxies, cosmic microwave background, astrophysical jets, and so on</li> </ul> <p>Question: is the above breakdown of when to use D^2 versus D^4 correct?</p> <p>Here is the last paragraph of the paper in its entirety:</p> <blockquote> <p>It is hoped that this presentation can clarify the role of the solid-angle transformation. Because it is a necessary consequence of aberration, there is always a change in the solid angle associated with light when one changes reference frame (except for the case of idealized plane waves). Its effect effect upon the transformation of intensity must be included in the study of cosmic microwave background radiation, where the angle is associated with convergence into the detector of radiation from different parts of the primordial fireball. It must also be included when a moving source is compared to an equivalent fixed source, both at the same apparent distance measured in the reference frame of the detector. In this case the angle represents divergence from the compact source to the detector. The change in solid angle does not contribute to the transformation of intensity measured at the same event point by detectors in relative motion. Note particularly that the amount of divergence of the light, or equivalently the curvature of the wavefronts, does not determine which intensity transformation is correct. Thus, in considering the appearance of stars from a moving spaceship, a typical source distance is 1-1000 pc but the intensity transformation is equivalent to that for plane waves. On the other hand, typical receding galaxies are 10^6 times further away (so their light can is actually more nearly plane), but their light cannot be treated as plane waves in finding its intensity transformation.</p> </blockquote>
g1648
[ 0.020080508664250374, 0.012322924099862576, 0.02105437032878399, -0.07411613315343857, 0.03806016221642494, -0.004137046169489622, 0.0811619684100151, 0.001611202722415328, -0.04010811075568199, 0.005335755180567503, -0.013592865318059921, 0.015606990084052086, 0.035501766949892044, 0.00878502894192934, 0.0487108938395977, -0.03364567831158638, 0.06602891534566879, -0.011537689715623856, -0.008340041153132915, 0.026612374931573868, -0.003003219375386834, -0.01847272366285324, 0.04131539538502693, -0.0536339171230793, 0.006142050493508577, -0.03013630211353302, 0.0057795410975813866, -0.006105117034167051, -0.039346639066934586, 0.011841995641589165, 0.044041652232408524, -0.01738274097442627, 0.05992940813302994, -0.01786269061267376, -0.00962316244840622, -0.007249573245644569, -0.014293673448264599, 0.05802065506577492, 0.015799937769770622, -0.015566922724246979, -0.02690550871193409, 0.008222104981541634, 0.005923864897340536, 0.03380203992128372, -0.0021945065818727016, -0.02732080966234207, -0.030238578096032143, -0.05206799507141113, 0.017851147800683975, 0.060516856610774994, -0.042854901403188705, 0.024335991591215134, 0.05899263545870781, -0.023380406200885773, 0.008890688419342041, 0.06004053354263306, -0.059777721762657166, -0.018428804352879524, 0.04075228050351143, 0.05153258889913559, 0.01519009005278349, -0.01733090542256832, -0.012232175096869469, 0.015745632350444794, 0.023556504398584366, 0.021804535761475563, -0.012727507390081882, -0.017762769013643265, -0.017870482057332993, -0.07869510352611542, -0.0022732799407094717, -0.07054313272237778, -0.02965826354920864, 0.0077405404299497604, -0.040817540138959885, -0.02993592992424965, 0.01705867424607277, -0.04192250967025757, -0.02597668394446373, -0.0000677802599966526, -0.017396695911884308, -0.04430627077817917, 0.011126082390546799, 0.02202853374183178, 0.09403011947870255, 0.02109653875231743, 0.03827408328652382, 0.0066104065626859665, 0.016733305528759956, 0.0001835380244301632, 0.029147500172257423, -0.0077652037143707275, 0.05720667168498039, -0.008966888301074505, 0.00525357061997056, -0.024642301723361015, -0.04820242151618004, 0.07418768107891083, -0.017439281567931175, -0.0028740474954247475, -0.046911995857954025, -0.02080577425658703, -0.009571158327162266, 0.05983914062380791, -0.028881918638944626, -0.04814838245511055, -0.008719642646610737, -0.010989141650497913, -0.07754474133253098, -0.057241350412368774, -0.049910593777894974, -0.09656823426485062, 0.054139379411935806, -0.000041350860556121916, -0.046289317309856415, -0.032750751823186874, 0.04385063052177429, -0.0037991120480000973, -0.025786107406020164, 0.07088066637516022, 0.03812588378787041, 0.011448252946138382, -0.012383567169308662, 0.0710495263338089, 0.0026805067900568247, -0.03925635293126106, -0.02585725300014019, -0.0046164472587406635, 0.07957082986831665, 0.02884339541196823, -0.010897832922637463, -0.005857971962541342, 0.01802796684205532, 0.02607405185699463, 0.013998802751302719, 0.030082108452916145, 0.01814648136496544, -0.0756726861000061, -0.030560502782464027, 0.02453642338514328, 0.051198042929172516, -0.008125672116875648, 0.014119264669716358, -0.03775525838136673, -0.024972407147288322, 0.03241237998008728, -0.020952610298991203, 0.024489352479577065, 0.08732670545578003, 0.024285297840833664, 0.02360115572810173, 0.05184222012758255, -0.032741472125053406, 0.018098415806889534, 0.029198279604315758, -0.0022135404869914055, -0.005310363601893187, -0.012136255390942097, -0.008252414874732494, 0.02085225097835064, 0.037411369383335114, -0.0255154799669981, -0.04469910264015198, -0.01577303558588028, -0.011292075738310814, 0.020620694383978844, -0.016039520502090454, -0.060047704726457596, 0.020883603021502495, -0.05816363915801048, 0.0024792077019810677, 0.026210466399788857, 0.017672698944807053, 0.011115215718746185, 0.032468464225530624, 0.08167706429958344, 0.06384555250406265, 0.01322736032307148, -0.03340151906013489, -0.020756231620907784, -0.028322219848632812, -0.00797218270599842, 0.01932048797607422, -0.007766518741846085, -0.01121069211512804, -0.049582600593566895, 0.015935782343149185, -0.027464065700769424, -0.09286896884441376, 0.03120133839547634, -0.020838221535086632, -0.032823286950588226, -0.0526423454284668, 0.06618102639913559, -0.03695260360836983, 0.012117900885641575, 0.026327569037675858, 0.033004436641931534, -0.04814157634973526, 0.06775649636983871, 0.0006047483184374869, 0.05740099400281906, 0.017284980043768883, 0.032858897000551224, 0.030914733186364174, -0.00287874904461205, -0.024597391486167908, 0.03794436901807785, 0.026237396523356438, -0.011513098143041134, 0.05856538563966751, 0.02915351279079914, -0.037021368741989136, 0.03230852261185646, -0.00887384545058012, 0.010616498067975044, -0.039122868329286575, 0.005537417251616716, 0.012311065569519997, 0.05108695104718208, -0.039932139217853546, -0.04812021180987358, 0.0803612470626831, 0.0077490550465881824, -0.05449036881327629, -0.04440300166606903, -0.036658503115177155, 0.036744389683008194, 0.0408288836479187, 0.049313850700855255, -0.049846988171339035, 0.037251293659210205, -0.004813140723854303, -0.0216203685849905, 0.013374119065701962, -0.021970443427562714, -0.004935740493237972, 0.020796388387680054, 0.036666952073574066, 0.007732711732387543, -0.0028205730486661196, 0.04617547243833542, -0.052442073822021484, -0.029847444966435432, 0.04782235249876976, -0.02872934564948082, 0.05903797224164009, 0.018430238589644432, 0.01052883081138134, 0.03320123255252838, 0.02016783505678177, 0.026157058775424957, -0.03210332617163658, -0.0067398156970739365, -0.009738168679177761, -0.009905439801514149, -0.043516527861356735, 0.04809798672795296, -0.036973029375076294, 0.027572618797421455, -0.029545599594712257, -0.027414370328187943, -0.01309126429259777, 0.020733075216412544, -0.010565458796918392, -0.004523483105003834, -0.04970024153590202, 0.03868352621793747, 0.005453303921967745, -0.05514759570360184, -0.03603243827819824, 0.029344184324145317, 0.023301638662815094, 0.06955145299434662, 0.024069681763648987, 0.027673399075865746, 0.03223170340061188, -0.037562839686870575, -0.002731501590460539, 0.017927095293998718, 0.006697848439216614, 0.013638164848089218, -0.023116135969758034, 0.04101572930812836, 0.03768905997276306, -0.03391141816973686, 0.006386156193912029, 0.016408758237957954, -0.02818913571536541, 0.029653148725628853, 0.009473106823861599, 0.06467476487159729, -0.0032337973825633526, -0.004775878973305225, 0.021835336461663246, -0.0028709208127111197, 0.06750412285327911, -0.006372973322868347, 0.05036384239792824, 0.03989897295832634, -0.0069115483202040195, 0.027826810255646706, -0.022266369313001633, 0.010265972465276718, 0.003519289894029498, 0.027871327474713326, -0.04242590069770813, -0.07330971211194992, 0.0051054866053164005, -0.03246429190039635, -0.010020576417446136, -0.02472338080406189, -0.005931330379098654, 0.006798141170293093, -0.020250383764505386, -0.007773225195705891, 0.010383539833128452, -0.01695571467280388, 0.015617085620760918, 0.05896640568971634, 0.0055798739194869995, -0.0152500094845891, -0.04970270395278931, -0.036603573709726334, 0.042931798845529556, 0.024556459859013557, 0.07169974595308304, 0.03374628722667694, -0.0592505969107151, -0.04200129583477974, 0.011410425417125225, 0.007306286133825779, -0.027189671993255615, 0.033942509442567825, -0.052426766604185104, 0.008486366830766201, -0.05429569259285927, 0.02456388622522354, -0.013762240298092365, 0.03813178464770317, -0.005656377412378788, 0.0011576368706300855, -0.02952028624713421, -0.013160987757146358, 0.014126801863312721, -0.008250457234680653, 0.05338522046804428, -0.05561022460460663, -0.027856670320034027, -0.06832924485206604, 0.0023714147973805666, 0.017661094665527344, -0.0006538874586112797, -0.0036084626335650682, -0.02024140954017639, -0.021477138623595238, 0.011613811366260052, 0.035030752420425415, 0.02048342674970627, 0.05230173096060753, 0.03278527036309242, -0.043609995394945145, -0.01678386516869068, -0.025500252842903137, -0.050119683146476746, 0.011169386096298695, -0.010774988681077957, -0.01753484643995762, -0.03008906915783882, -0.012049829587340355, -0.018284955993294716, -0.0017995141679421067, -0.06585172563791275, 0.009317737072706223, -0.01873883791267872, -0.027962733060121536, 0.04831039160490036, 0.031743746250867844, -0.05060453712940216, 0.0365016907453537, 0.03645665571093559, 0.08152776956558228, 0.015115338377654552, 0.01819881610572338, 0.019065016880631447, -0.004394594579935074, 0.0031220302917063236, -0.013707674108445644, 0.022754186764359474, -0.0502934493124485, 0.018210388720035553, 0.011558865197002888, 0.019343426451086998, 0.010714023374021053, 0.006997168529778719, -0.048266518861055374, 0.007192032411694527, 0.03974561765789986, 0.010235002264380455, 0.03170659393072128, -0.0034746129531413317, 0.03582291305065155, 0.012278151698410511, -0.00493237841874361, -0.022942157462239265, -0.038772668689489365, 0.04716947674751282, -0.06008566915988922, -0.026790842413902283, 0.0009247424895875156, -0.014692059718072414, -0.022888032719492912, -0.008769557811319828, -0.06601694226264954, 0.04453824833035469, 0.017832212150096893, -0.012902827002108097, 0.01914813742041588, 0.03352753818035126, -0.005053178407251835, -0.01649404503405094, 0.06140429526567459, 0.0320509634912014, 0.004563754424452782, 0.026841145008802414, 0.06629528105258942, 0.10235492140054703, 0.015597033314406872, 0.0036906322930008173, -0.01644184999167919, 0.03833986073732376, 0.018921218812465668, -0.02151443623006344, 0.041378721594810486, -0.09644412249326706, 0.07659497112035751, -0.05674349144101143, 0.07556812465190887, 0.029283175244927406, 0.04125092178583145, 0.011007963679730892, 0.0005332291475497186, 0.03739692270755768, -0.020329907536506653, 0.0020899916999042034, 0.11002305150032043, -0.06568588316440582, -0.0345228835940361, -0.025073444470763206, -0.021163202822208405, -0.05710377171635628, 0.04742395132780075, 0.03904658928513527, 0.0040008872747421265, 0.021597452461719513, -0.015961376950144768, -0.03831003978848457, -0.01298886351287365, 0.02304162085056305, 0.00763823464512825, 0.0026325939688831568, 0.026288112625479698, 0.0025469805113971233, -0.05020970106124878, 0.01433892548084259, 0.0158297810703516, -0.08717276155948639, -0.0507676787674427, -0.030639277771115303, 0.043845873326063156, -0.024726543575525284, -0.04069666936993599, -0.013548796065151691, 0.026019997894763947, -0.010409923270344734, 0.02634192816913128, -0.00970305036753416, -0.02732105366885662, -0.005634996108710766, -0.055596545338630676, -0.05030133202672005, -0.02605108730494976, 0.036708347499370575, 0.020014876499772072, -0.01682872138917446, 0.0912976861000061, -0.02234569750726223, -0.005811103153973818, 0.03971691057085991, -0.028161155059933662, -0.008261376991868019, -0.07067567110061646, 0.03170317783951759, -0.07526417821645737, 0.007335002068430185, 0.08252961188554764, 0.030289486050605774, -0.04697053134441376, -0.059567175805568695, -0.010433041490614414, -0.060694266110658646, 0.059586137533187866, 0.04925510287284851, 0.01599802076816559, -0.032471913844347, 0.0077421520836651325, 0.09493042528629303, -0.03967935964465141, 0.02158602513372898, -0.009218166582286358, -0.002579707885161042, -0.007122799288481474, 0.0300846416503191, 0.01008649356663227, 0.003893120912835002, -0.03117251768708229, 0.022841237485408783, 0.0645354688167572, 0.016983244568109512, -0.05913028120994568, -0.007248367182910442, 0.021772950887680054, -0.004868214018642902, 0.007213077042251825, 0.030613183975219727, -0.012061074376106262, 0.0062947869300842285, -0.047713249921798706, -0.013346852734684944, -0.02072828821837902, 0.01035277172923088, 0.009932261891663074, 0.006554094143211842, 0.05537671968340874, -0.021193936467170715, -0.016102809458971024, -0.050127062946558, -0.02645169012248516, -0.013023055158555508, -0.03533277288079262, -0.10941038280725479, 0.02368316613137722, 0.014773363247513771, 0.030852332711219788, -0.029172195121645927, 0.027947712689638138, 0.018412211909890175, 0.018042804673314095, 0.029653355479240417, -0.006477148737758398, -0.016772743314504623, -0.013300885446369648, 0.028220219537615776, -0.04322364553809166, -0.00023027366842143238, 0.003993550781160593, -0.013187754899263382, -0.013719112612307072, -0.011490999720990658, -0.03634977713227272, -0.030016230419278145, 0.04839775338768959, 0.020968321710824966, 0.02884761244058609, 0.03457691892981529, -0.024364594370126724, 0.038248639553785324, -0.030943430960178375, 0.07063587754964828, -0.009088626131415367, -0.04635504260659218, -0.010653381235897541, -0.0389338918030262, -0.021501123905181885, 0.005060542840510607, 0.0490071177482605, -0.008481621742248535, -0.07790189981460571, -0.010652289725840092, 0.052927952259778976, 0.001736897393129766, -0.02607579156756401, 0.021687690168619156, -0.043620336800813675, -0.0417635515332222, -0.013565385714173317, -0.025274332612752914, 0.013498755171895027, 0.004847007337957621, -0.0697965994477272, -0.0011307154782116413, 0.0133778415620327, 0.021722462028265, -0.03115447424352169, -0.07458774745464325, -0.0846194326877594, 0.031141722574830055, 0.020627714693546295, -0.01296849176287651, 0.036814384162425995, 0.021696925163269043, -0.007850616239011288, 0.04838500916957855, -0.03676452860236168, 0.04025895521044731, -0.07036612182855606, -0.05250665917992592, -0.00507054990157485, 0.04424005001783371, -0.027829239144921303, 0.01015445962548256, 0.004355527460575104, 0.014528807252645493, 0.010559710673987865, 0.009134134277701378, -0.019255096092820168, -0.00027727626729756594, -0.02349431812763214, 0.03713149204850197, -0.035654231905937195, 0.03653215244412422, -0.03241019323468208, 0.031487636268138885, 0.010242685675621033, -0.022429583594202995, 0.0622888021171093, -0.0845242589712143, 0.004608835559338331, 0.041522007435560226, -0.01452641561627388, 0.023946773260831833, -0.019054479897022247, -0.027737364172935486, 0.024793390184640884, 0.014910592697560787, 0.010501701384782791, 0.01418180763721466, 0.009576401673257351, 0.05552170053124428, 0.060630954802036285, -0.034977544099092484, 0.04548830911517143, -0.011373107321560383, -0.002938436344265938, -0.017610151320695877, -0.04925629869103432, 0.019506046548485756, -0.059197381138801575, -0.09285221248865128, -0.017771340906620026, 0.001584786456078291, -0.029980437830090523, -0.036117471754550934, -0.01623302325606346, -0.08630818128585815, 0.036995064467191696, -0.020726986229419708, 0.026682885363698006, 0.0011142827570438385, -0.08498063683509827, 0.009800433181226254, -0.06391903758049011, -0.06540092825889587, -0.010468854568898678, -0.026960572227835655, 0.013489549048244953, 0.022913780063390732, 0.004211698658764362, 0.034782230854034424, -0.008225749246776104, 0.03564560413360596, -0.001517868135124445, -0.027881668880581856, 0.030206551775336266, 0.013485660776495934, 0.003448324277997017, -0.011724282056093216, -0.017365405336022377, 0.01650720089673996, 0.029976733028888702, 0.02651122771203518, 0.08055230230093002, -0.023944992572069168, -0.00045492584467865527, -0.05636592581868172, -0.023785026744008064, -0.04231950268149376, -0.05745847150683403, 0.03881966695189476, -0.00010443364590173587, -0.016224537044763565, 0.021050473675131798, -0.010509571991860867, 0.019410831853747368, -0.06042856350541115, 0.013256169855594635, 0.04249868541955948, 0.055777501314878464, 0.010079707019031048, 0.011367942206561565, -0.046203918755054474, 0.01552124135196209, -0.03406032919883728, 0.05507321655750275, 0.012639297172427177, 0.02392726019024849, 0.025740312412381172, 0.015161258168518543, 0.011936371214687824, 0.04467564821243286, 0.04844694212079048, -0.007692543789744377, 0.008402285166084766, -0.061891160905361176, -0.04178905114531517, 0.004312937147915363, -0.027212191373109818, 0.010828392580151558, -0.01705739088356495, 0.008503865450620651, 0.02484361082315445, -0.02663397416472435, -0.04983482137322426, 0.018116770312190056, 0.061553411185741425, -0.09532928466796875, 0.010975654236972332, -0.024772223085165024, 0.018101418390870094, -0.030389981344342232, -0.0017962740967050195, 0.02687954157590866, -0.058933697640895844, -0.01464586891233921, -0.03901377320289612, -0.017844509333372116, -0.019387267529964447, -0.013985815457999706, -0.010471290908753872, 0.026265522465109825, 0.010948332026600838, 0.02574377879500389, -0.005915244109928608, -0.017895463854074478, -0.03009643964469433, -0.031232405453920364, 0.03221846744418144, 0.061923444271087646, 0.047014668583869934, -0.06967991590499878, 0.015914753079414368, 0.0393497534096241, -0.006245746277272701, -0.025676438584923744, 0.028782306239008904, -0.001273628557100892, 0.004655004944652319, -0.09999993443489075, 0.052129290997982025, -0.06073012202978134, 0.03574429452419281, -0.026620496064424515, 0.024423355236649513, -0.024354638531804085, -0.009346711449325085, -0.03797973319888115, -0.029664473608136177, 0.04456312954425812 ]
<p>Car batteries are usually 12 V. What is the difference between buying a car battery and hooking up a bunch of cheap household batteries in series? Both would register at 12 V. I assume that cars need much more current to start an engine then regular household things like lamps and toys. Does that mean that a car battery holds more charge within it?</p> <p>If we think of a simple cell battery, where there are two electrodes and an electrolyte. One electrode eventually, through chemical reaction, becomes positive and the other becomes negative. Thus in a car battery, does that mean the electrodes (if we can reduce a car battery to a primitive cell), have more charge separated on each electrode? But if that was the case, wouldn't a greater charge separation mean that the voltage would be greater between the terminals as well?</p> <p>In general, what is the relation between charge and voltage? I know the equation V = U/q, just like E = F/q (similar form, in the limit that the test charge is small as to not effect the PE or electric field. V = U/q is sorta useless too, since differences matter, but nevertheless that is how we defined it). If charges are separated further, does that mean greater voltage? If more charge is separated, does that mean greater voltage?</p> <p>Lastly, what is the difference b/w the charge in a 12 V car battery, and the charge in a 12 V makeshift, series strung battery from home? </p>
g1649
[ 0.024195058271288872, 0.022677907720208168, -0.027282506227493286, 0.0003079154121223837, 0.07810099422931671, -0.01639983057975769, -0.015712527558207512, 0.02030589058995247, -0.0331709049642086, 0.006898477673530579, -0.0509948693215847, -0.0032108169980347157, 0.009987151250243187, -0.006323722656816244, 0.01816495507955551, -0.02980886772274971, -0.004995253402739763, 0.00485066045075655, 0.02664761245250702, 0.006317950785160065, 0.049057602882385254, 0.027651606127619743, -0.054278988391160965, 0.009353098459541798, -0.021720388904213905, -0.0035590571351349354, -0.023953713476657867, -0.020159490406513214, -0.02128680609166622, -0.09736473113298416, 0.0012515346752479672, -0.006593542639166117, 0.07189960032701492, -0.00284518557600677, -0.06215126812458038, -0.0034597625490278006, 0.018089396879076958, -0.036639805883169174, 0.012455377727746964, 0.021070463582873344, -0.008290925994515419, 0.036430176347494125, 0.08153670281171799, -0.0032279116567224264, -0.03307677060365677, -0.05542391911149025, -0.06202348694205284, -0.006954894866794348, -0.005131029058247805, 0.016485946252942085, -0.053048644214868546, -0.050505734980106354, -0.010965602472424507, 0.09710200130939484, 0.05668698996305466, -0.06215566769242287, 0.08825153857469559, -0.032724037766456604, 0.017278334125876427, 0.07006890326738358, -0.006924574729055166, 0.03310742974281311, 0.0037408636417239904, 0.044019896537065506, 0.015097812749445438, -0.017598168924450874, -0.029384151101112366, 0.01704927161335945, 0.03821517527103424, 0.0653570145368576, -0.02838013879954815, -0.059199828654527664, -0.030589066445827484, -0.05536670610308647, 0.02906711958348751, -0.010892597027122974, 0.039642926305532455, -0.054349228739738464, 0.08455925434827805, 0.004704641178250313, 0.04566887393593788, -0.004426766652613878, -0.004576379433274269, 0.05101523920893669, 0.059579234570264816, -0.025408390909433365, -0.01795644871890545, -0.012504613026976585, -0.02163410186767578, 0.03481318801641464, 0.07029233127832413, 0.012586109340190887, 0.05535905435681343, -0.02192302793264389, -0.07232850790023804, -0.019231772050261497, -0.013788593001663685, 0.01128961518406868, 0.051468659192323685, 0.037305086851119995, -0.02873915806412697, -0.03829343616962433, 0.04039904475212097, -0.007611928507685661, -0.0449473112821579, 0.027891289442777634, 0.013304343447089195, -0.01376372016966343, -0.012025043368339539, -0.024798335507512093, -0.041047003120183945, -0.021931959316134453, -0.03527539595961571, 0.021818136796355247, -0.023652605712413788, 0.0917426347732544, 0.058680396527051926, 0.0032256501726806164, 0.013415301218628883, -0.06992726773023605, -0.0538756363093853, 0.10530805587768555, 0.011657326482236385, 0.015502968803048134, -0.02147652767598629, 0.03932936489582062, 0.0032789926044642925, 0.034604161977767944, -0.02059701830148697, 0.011793052777647972, -0.0008305743103846908, -0.024883968755602837, -0.030682703480124474, -0.020033275708556175, 0.016825586557388306, 0.0409037210047245, 0.0059933969751000404, 0.007121953181922436, 0.04054104536771774, -0.01149925496429205, 0.04278961941599846, 0.04070517048239708, -0.02874661795794964, -0.021101130172610283, -0.007596800569444895, 0.0007466263487003744, -0.053361956030130386, -0.023155471310019493, 0.014926624484360218, 0.013538670726120472, 0.08112125098705292, -0.061389002948999405, 0.006231989711523056, -0.03252387046813965, 0.023665791377425194, -0.02597096934914589, 0.04249534383416176, -0.02390182949602604, -0.013896592892706394, -0.012476935982704163, 0.04054451733827591, -0.03299497067928314, 0.005119580775499344, 0.0028468796517699957, -0.02315129153430462, -0.05610913410782814, 0.019109629094600677, -0.02596115693449974, -0.019294045865535736, 0.009732820093631744, 0.02340320684015751, -0.006619662512093782, -0.060907214879989624, 0.056050561368465424, 0.01642790250480175, 0.01112810056656599, 0.06040039658546448, -0.04649867117404938, 0.0030887662433087826, 0.0015452131628990173, -0.01564215123653412, -0.027963683009147644, 0.023686787113547325, -0.028586499392986298, -0.015564585104584694, 0.00921651627868414, -0.055459506809711456, -0.06498383730649948, -0.05000558868050575, 0.041721466928720474, -0.025638990104198456, -0.02425890788435936, -0.017863938584923744, 0.025119580328464508, -0.056890714913606644, -0.017799053341150284, -0.03524302691221237, 0.02563989721238613, -0.014905045740306377, -0.015950949862599373, 0.007642901968210936, -0.01511071901768446, -0.006480671465396881, 0.04418191686272621, 0.05668136104941368, 0.03122209757566452, -0.06313487887382507, -0.07843679934740067, 0.017155300825834274, -0.03039335086941719, 0.006450262852013111, -0.008588867262005806, -0.01517264824360609, 0.035074856132268906, -0.020477116107940674, -0.016129011288285255, -0.012066462077200413, -0.01590808480978012, -0.02160094864666462, -0.029992826282978058, -0.002885092282667756, -0.05992511287331581, 0.03739321231842041, 0.03209966421127319, -0.01981401816010475, 0.07001663744449615, 0.06614670157432556, -0.05853314697742462, -0.005647443700581789, 0.0006209906423464417, -0.0021666050888597965, 0.004069134127348661, 0.021462103351950645, -0.05026260390877724, -0.045390572398900986, 0.07854685187339783, 0.013972898945212364, -0.03717558830976486, -0.006862274836748838, -0.039661604911088943, -0.028255227953195572, -0.037011921405792236, 0.014986882917582989, 0.060372378677129745, 0.012501097284257412, -0.061245616525411606, 0.05249668285250664, 0.004994154907763004, -0.0318765789270401, 0.021019455045461655, -0.033269960433244705, 0.033086761832237244, -0.03702127933502197, 0.03273302689194679, -0.008941983804106712, -0.011055326089262962, 0.027480047196149826, 0.06417825073003769, -0.012838737107813358, 0.030887698754668236, 0.0016581269446760416, -0.019680844619870186, -0.04884295165538788, 0.009910217486321926, 0.001507535227574408, -0.002543562324717641, -0.0013782564783468843, -0.01809515431523323, 0.045167382806539536, -0.07621252536773682, 0.000882378255482763, 0.06625285744667053, -0.030396372079849243, -0.10502912104129791, 0.007279560901224613, -0.06570684909820557, 0.012401863001286983, -0.05864129588007927, 0.07228823751211166, -0.016508007422089577, 0.014333130791783333, -0.010851668193936348, -0.025692176073789597, 0.007063678465783596, 0.002595166675746441, -0.000999719719402492, 0.018149223178625107, -0.03431963920593262, -0.010240006260573864, -0.04350977763533592, -0.013049042783677578, 0.0006733410409651697, 0.04929400607943535, -0.05819190666079521, 0.034121811389923096, 0.02350558340549469, 0.033830489963293076, 0.011617304757237434, -0.03792126104235649, -0.03468425199389458, -0.013917269185185432, -0.014333943836390972, 0.05331389605998993, 0.0059567163698375225, 0.02165844477713108, 0.0974646508693695, -0.027695221826434135, -0.021822307258844376, -0.013456201180815697, 0.026499761268496513, -0.0386076346039772, -0.03686748445034027, 0.024532265961170197, -0.0030252737924456596, -0.04953278228640556, -0.03340863063931465, 0.011952957138419151, 0.02173338644206524, -0.048478785902261734, 0.021665159612894058, -0.0013659060932695866, -0.015915701165795326, 0.024352669715881348, 0.010364498011767864, 0.03376379236578941, 0.013559447601437569, -0.016440952196717262, 0.018526775762438774, -0.02632254734635353, 0.001502467319369316, -0.053110599517822266, 0.06742426007986069, 0.020255044102668762, -0.04055749997496605, 0.031752560287714005, 0.022927403450012207, -0.02508208528161049, 0.033844243735075, 0.02137918584048748, -0.04351632297039032, 0.08815654367208481, 0.05342366173863411, -0.02690793387591839, -0.02819940075278282, -0.03412943333387375, -0.004428213462233543, 0.026275718584656715, -0.014068077318370342, -0.016002751886844635, -0.048517946153879166, 0.009861817583441734, -0.016398224979639053, -0.004588544834405184, 0.017211882397532463, -0.02560209296643734, -0.01647137477993965, -0.05219738557934761, 0.0003304417768958956, -0.02865905500948429, 0.026629427447915077, 0.047140829265117645, 0.010292653925716877, -0.01462802104651928, 0.011834423989057541, -0.0033164499327540398, 0.01628950424492359, -0.00476521160453558, 0.012669283896684647, -0.04050687327980995, -0.0815810039639473, -0.003337073139846325, 0.02395479753613472, -0.05305909737944603, 0.027511870488524437, 0.026776837185025215, -0.0050778742879629135, 0.05341599881649017, -0.01751781441271305, -0.004494624212384224, 0.007268981076776981, 0.01624762825667858, -0.022245680913329124, 0.03410521522164345, 0.03138075768947601, -0.009162245318293571, -0.05574340000748634, -0.019819194450974464, 0.038506124168634415, -0.02222665771842003, -0.011447085998952389, -0.03509438782930374, 0.03764891251921654, -0.04334166273474693, 0.018679611384868622, 0.014625796116888523, 0.00641968147829175, 0.0350395143032074, 0.004057752434164286, -0.005920873023569584, 0.044970378279685974, 0.0058882287703454494, 0.012258138507604599, -0.015750974416732788, 0.013752398081123829, 0.016505349427461624, 0.042448852211236954, 0.024792354553937912, -0.03639204427599907, -0.011628181673586369, -0.020062513649463654, 0.018274595960974693, -0.023643378168344498, -0.023539364337921143, -0.041800107806921005, -0.0023358878679573536, 0.031015176326036453, 0.029388800263404846, 0.027813728898763657, 0.050492335110902786, 0.024975813925266266, -0.02900863252580166, -0.032717689871788025, -0.020689303055405617, -0.0026760578621178865, -0.023748498409986496, 0.030105065554380417, -0.01210591197013855, 0.007793735712766647, -0.016084738075733185, -0.022083960473537445, 0.034535862505435944, 0.024160092696547508, -0.030716000124812126, -0.001726534334011376, 0.023748774081468582, 0.001852846471592784, -0.008915293961763382, 0.03081464394927025, -0.0026564437430351973, 0.005035501439124346, 0.0893307775259018, 0.058474525809288025, -0.002712039742618799, 0.014924032613635063, -0.010373641736805439, -0.015237672254443169, -0.0897817611694336, 0.05963634327054024, -0.028427451848983765, -0.06109531223773956, -0.03575800731778145, 0.057889845222234726, 0.005041357595473528, -0.03904013708233833, 0.0059649706818163395, -0.021060170605778694, -0.008677735924720764, -0.08467308431863785, 0.02249019965529442, 0.008494991809129715, -0.020588137209415436, -0.0014236494898796082, 0.06006421521306038, 0.045309558510780334, 0.04399556666612625, -0.028560500591993332, -0.03462326154112816, -0.03890654444694519, -0.051377877593040466, 0.035282883793115616, -0.04775942489504814, 0.010485656559467316, 0.027933640405535698, -0.021123070269823074, 0.0164088886231184, -0.03671722486615181, 0.047785717993974686, 0.03726394101977348, -0.09297291934490204, -0.05818304046988487, -0.017517054453492165, 0.019559383392333984, -0.02118447609245777, 0.008016737177968025, 0.009457447566092014, 0.007108969613909721, 0.018901266157627106, -0.055373068898916245, 0.0294510405510664, -0.0169980451464653, 0.04759163036942482, 0.022369656711816788, 0.05589894950389862, 0.010274247266352177, -0.008900078944861889, 0.008312133140861988, -0.001052205334417522, -0.011743096634745598, -0.04019687697291374, 0.009168123826384544, 0.025054071098566055, 0.02317855879664421, -0.025128556415438652, -0.004073759540915489, 0.012214848771691322, 0.0543200857937336, 0.06455391645431519, -0.06582988053560257, 0.0609588585793972, 0.029165083542466164, 0.02051570639014244, 0.009671807289123535, -0.015249263495206833, 0.01754647120833397, 0.04101075604557991, 0.037044916301965714, -0.0524539053440094, -0.011903660371899605, 0.015754006803035736, 0.059666238725185394, 0.02931411750614643, -0.023479022085666656, 0.07391611486673355, -0.01722049154341221, -0.03304125741124153, -0.012870779260993004, -0.026190483942627907, -0.06387419998645782, 0.05168399587273598, -0.004462959710508585, -0.0018814350478351116, 0.07117020338773727, 0.015793627128005028, -0.005873493384569883, -0.06310413032770157, 0.012443267740309238, -0.021360425278544426, -0.04322312772274017, 0.09274116903543472, 0.04088153317570686, -0.043132904917001724, -0.052013397216796875, 0.021301478147506714, 0.05572205036878586, 0.01770206354558468, -0.04879863187670708, 0.0013740607537329197, -0.0073658195324242115, 0.021182231605052948, 0.016829276457428932, -0.06110192462801933, 0.0012104491470381618, -0.034158095717430115, 0.017247594892978668, -0.029167355969548225, 0.0207742340862751, 0.051739223301410675, -0.01860949955880642, -0.054967258125543594, 0.015362391248345375, -0.009987988509237766, 0.017410151660442352, -0.006679903250187635, 0.0025983217637985945, 0.036342866718769073, -0.006128170061856508, 0.01964619755744934, 0.011673791334033012, 0.0036337708588689566, 0.05521164461970329, 0.06040611118078232, -0.029304469004273415, 0.024032434448599815, -0.053696125745773315, 0.01939370669424534, -0.03945162892341614, -0.007712572813034058, 0.020983217284083366, -0.01029085461050272, 0.023481080308556557, -0.012078743427991867, -0.008005105890333652, 0.03747543692588806, 0.043285857886075974, 0.032533831894397736, 0.0644233301281929, -0.018451746553182602, -0.04585897549986839, -0.008682729676365852, -0.05880781635642052, 0.022274909541010857, 0.007773655466735363, 0.028463993221521378, -0.05288814380764961, 0.002428845502436161, -0.01262103021144867, 0.041497621685266495, 0.011920204386115074, 0.049638718366622925, 0.030346114188432693, 0.05528352037072182, 0.06285640597343445, 0.027170425280928612, -0.002776193432509899, 0.054439280182123184, 0.021009836345911026, 0.058819565922021866, 0.03366226702928543, -0.010297990404069424, -0.03829365223646164, 0.011494566686451435, 0.02013803832232952, -0.007821610197424889, 0.02505102939903736, 0.008542977273464203, 0.03937467932701111, -0.015620775520801544, -0.009422126226127148, 0.013884996995329857, 0.01825319230556488, -0.009001404047012329, 0.00837613269686699, 0.04783010855317116, 0.04774855077266693, 0.06119436398148537, 0.05687632039189339, 0.022299224510788918, 0.033716391772031784, 0.02902441844344139, -0.04832069203257561, -0.06174757331609726, -0.043533045798540115, 0.026043448597192764, 0.06708309799432755, 0.025985220447182655, -0.025363922119140625, -0.036641281098127365, 0.030624788254499435, 0.0021915787365287542, -0.04604677855968475, -0.05255052074790001, 0.019733697175979614, 0.04452093318104744, 0.08021499961614609, -0.0013554893666878343, -0.06862941384315491, 0.053536925464868546, -0.021740812808275223, -0.004374762997031212, -0.02094452828168869, -0.03588064759969711, -0.019062737002968788, -0.05623319372534752, -0.005248040892183781, -0.04049327224493027, 0.07090704143047333, -0.013020155020058155, 0.0035655414685606956, 0.04317999631166458, -0.03401166945695877, 0.01753966137766838, 0.04482684284448624, -0.03064313530921936, 0.03701742738485336, -0.001762625528499484, 0.04752641171216965, -0.03707908093929291, -0.07274381071329117, -0.00342129566706717, 0.000755038985516876, 0.004293115343898535, -0.023273564875125885, -0.013617493212223053, -0.007295094896107912, 0.025483572855591774, -0.013805791735649109, -0.04485362023115158, 0.04535897821187973, -0.0071857040748000145, -0.03578509762883186, -0.013437203131616116, -0.0316498726606369, -0.01242413092404604, 0.01401283498853445, -0.013237586244940758, 0.015106669627130032, -0.04963546618819237, 0.022577237337827682, 0.00267086667008698, -0.065816231071949, -0.0241374671459198, -0.09660100191831589, 0.02375083975493908, 0.0050187730230391026, 0.047598060220479965, 0.002478867769241333, -0.00826951488852501, 0.027657056227326393, 0.026580801233649254, 0.0221989955753088, 0.020283222198486328, -0.024146590381860733, -0.003382441122084856, 0.0018017119728028774, 0.029887111857533455, -0.011452564969658852, -0.030785610899329185, -0.02068946696817875, -0.0799487829208374, -0.018367057666182518, -0.018535522744059563, 0.015249097719788551, 0.008078682236373425, 0.016531996428966522, 0.01762118749320507, -0.07219289988279343, 0.059099745005369186, 0.02023433893918991, -0.06317161023616791, 0.039034709334373474, -0.0620199553668499, -0.05073339492082596, 0.06611616909503937, -0.010198420844972134, 0.005833743140101433, 0.032795485109090805, 0.0371139757335186, -0.005444237031042576, 0.027062419801950455, -0.038627203553915024, -0.018940970301628113, -0.01792336069047451, 0.03901371359825134, 0.023014968261122704, 0.010862712748348713, -0.000750839535612613, 0.022524258121848106, 0.02678106725215912, -0.01977844350039959, -0.0015480704605579376, -0.0423569455742836, -0.00009643425437388942, -0.004179535899311304, -0.028912339359521866, -0.0631396546959877, -0.011553162708878517, -0.05320511758327484, 0.09559087455272675, 0.022164180874824524, -0.029179856181144714, -0.053431276232004166, -0.03690651059150696, -0.09012199193239212, 0.03492715582251549, 0.062019914388656616, -0.028669685125350952, -0.0006862733862362802, 0.002091123955324292, 0.004925992339849472, -0.06635831296443939, -0.02636820636689663, 0.06949826329946518, -0.022849498316645622, 0.0005219500162638724, -0.0019083521328866482, -0.025389570742845535, -0.03216443210840225, -0.04338446259498596 ]
<p>So, we're fairly sure that the universe is infinitely large. We're also fairly sure that it is expanding. My question is how do these two facts relate to the multiverse? My favorite interpretation was given by Michio Kaku, who stated that in the multiverse each individual universe is like a bubble, and all of these bubbles are floating around in some space (and sometimes interact?). </p> <p>How can there be an infinitely large object in a space with other presumably infinitely large objects? Is this in like math where there are different "sizes" of infinities, where some are larger than others? What is the space that the universe is expanding into? Does that have a boundary, or is it also some infinity? </p>
g1650
[ -0.007278710603713989, 0.042350511997938156, 0.012872896157205105, -0.014202910475432873, -0.028186053037643433, 0.027163708582520485, 0.001139504718594253, 0.06875915825366974, 0.030834538862109184, -0.06144655868411064, -0.03431344032287598, -0.06811423599720001, 0.0015812953934073448, 0.04285338893532753, 0.031679101288318634, -0.03607141971588135, -0.0009290957823395729, -0.03594247251749039, 0.023516042158007622, -0.03908058628439903, 0.04634859040379524, -0.019383784383535385, -0.002218913286924362, -0.007263140752911568, -0.037967998534440994, -0.005632608197629452, 0.02427832782268524, 0.02773621864616871, 0.05040595307946205, -0.009149431250989437, 0.0028134065214544535, -0.001810699701309204, -0.04107556864619255, 0.0010500461794435978, 0.03783606365323067, -0.012345762923359871, -0.05038280412554741, 0.022286467254161835, 0.05097157135605812, -0.029243983328342438, 0.011897608637809753, -0.00196075183339417, 0.027038706466555595, 0.004336011596024036, 0.007068490143865347, 0.027811188250780106, -0.04838614538311958, 0.05708436667919159, 0.09244874119758606, -0.05810108408331871, -0.03705679625272751, 0.012558448128402233, -0.012801550328731537, 0.08955059200525284, 0.0540904700756073, 0.028440142050385475, 0.03263000771403313, -0.016402794048190117, 0.04473624378442764, 0.009404847398400307, -0.03699171543121338, -0.007410889491438866, 0.021968873217701912, -0.008151364512741566, 0.01879950240254402, 0.0012513769324868917, -0.0262337327003479, -0.008425441570580006, 0.036620862782001495, 0.011109266430139542, 0.04251754283905029, -0.02598429284989834, 0.013964058831334114, -0.05183977261185646, -0.0525975301861763, 0.06697796285152435, 0.05226011201739311, 0.0011655486887320876, -0.026383765041828156, 0.03894292563199997, 0.006971254479140043, 0.0030893851071596146, 0.027018176391720772, 0.015011074021458626, 0.014075507409870625, -0.032010484486818314, -0.025893239304423332, -0.05436117574572563, -0.05107024684548378, -0.005740813910961151, 0.008669722825288773, 0.0570729561150074, 0.036993514746427536, -0.010107847861945629, -0.04618487507104874, -0.02407028339803219, -0.001620907336473465, 0.02328118495643139, -0.04005878418684006, 0.014610192738473415, -0.06310778111219406, 0.05932726711034775, 0.05208638310432434, 0.0012782124103978276, 0.03787030652165413, 0.018514251336455345, -0.00013560963270720094, -0.02580532431602478, 0.0000549089781998191, -0.016116639599204063, -0.07123430073261261, -0.01986617222428322, -0.023241529241204262, -0.02600911259651184, -0.06914203613996506, -0.004921243991702795, 0.0395018495619297, 0.058577124029397964, 0.036985404789447784, 0.0846017450094223, 0.0014752987772226334, 0.02381197363138199, -0.024670539423823357, -0.00746125727891922, -0.033197272568941116, -0.020687248557806015, 0.010664422996342182, -0.00021914493117947131, 0.00788062158972025, 0.004518655128777027, 0.023619292303919792, 0.014187045395374298, 0.029080389067530632, 0.04168887063860893, -0.04714081063866615, 0.008441570214927197, -0.0287692341953516, -0.07093682885169983, -0.028078721836209297, 0.03236766904592514, -0.05299230292439461, -0.039437778294086456, -0.012142805382609367, -0.006828861311078072, -0.013389001600444317, 0.01473837997764349, 0.011683267541229725, -0.014638704247772694, -0.01953883469104767, -0.03224067762494087, 0.026191625744104385, 0.07793354988098145, 0.024773437529802322, -0.02983199432492256, -0.04432639479637146, 0.04597868025302887, -0.0011046977015212178, 0.004267400596290827, 0.01973734237253666, 0.0178399495780468, 0.03969145193696022, -0.001813863986171782, 0.021870629861950874, -0.018026728183031082, -0.03890588507056236, 0.012487558647990227, -0.02108457311987877, -0.03949344903230667, 0.01252026204019785, -0.020822810009121895, -0.022076647728681564, -0.04298637434840202, 0.005954067688435316, -0.01061688270419836, -0.002749423496425152, 0.008341771550476551, 0.033597275614738464, -0.02891797199845314, -0.049482133239507675, 0.0061685992404818535, -0.0793658047914505, -0.031768519431352615, 0.02291346713900566, 0.02045871503651142, 0.02042139507830143, -0.03231833502650261, -0.01720421016216278, 0.005428760312497616, 0.025851799175143242, 0.017300676554441452, -0.027350643649697304, -0.051403146237134933, 0.0699666291475296, 0.027078796178102493, 0.03760812431573868, 0.023302268236875534, 0.0429127961397171, 0.000006972523351578275, -0.04726624861359596, -0.05907997116446495, -0.00948761310428381, 0.02239871583878994, 0.014953890815377235, -0.00880340114235878, -0.0008838795474730432, 0.002021052176132798, -0.07826338708400726, 0.05045882612466812, 0.03918646275997162, -0.007762562949210405, 0.07959628850221634, -0.08129279315471649, 0.017346490174531937, 0.02618440054357052, -0.025906868278980255, 0.03447271138429642, -0.06737218052148819, 0.036948975175619125, 0.022584784775972366, 0.0014846475096419454, 0.0033282721415162086, -0.02870277129113674, 0.07377675920724869, -0.055892907083034515, 0.07728417962789536, 0.030803730711340904, -0.02446633391082287, -0.024230562150478363, 0.05124456807971001, 0.05256405845284462, -0.10828091949224472, -0.021488025784492493, 0.007092279382050037, 0.022374436259269714, -0.04794995114207268, 0.025136247277259827, -0.01316532026976347, 0.062396906316280365, -0.06466855108737946, 0.05147239938378334, 0.0330183319747448, 0.013238310813903809, -0.04315494745969772, 0.008647989481687546, 0.0066093457862734795, -0.0601297989487648, 0.026159007102251053, -0.04586464911699295, -0.02334645763039589, 0.037846945226192474, -0.011139933951199055, -0.014516523107886314, -0.0008864410337992013, 0.013814655132591724, 0.03443301096558571, -0.041257042437791824, 0.0025907917879521847, 0.04963013902306557, -0.04207274690270424, -0.07274413853883743, 0.052464619278907776, -0.014766359701752663, 0.007158338557928801, 0.04954511299729347, -0.006553718354552984, -0.006537244655191898, -0.03523033857345581, -0.009814909659326077, -0.00250373687595129, 0.024697668850421906, 0.019230470061302185, -0.011057613417506218, -0.006016718689352274, -0.018252043053507805, 0.03308464214205742, 0.038185037672519684, -0.05221570283174515, -0.03325032442808151, 0.04489521682262421, -0.03314172849059105, 0.000016841842807480134, 0.03138335794210434, -0.050619129091501236, 0.012919431552290916, 0.044645071029663086, -0.013725651428103447, -0.036818332970142365, 0.010915297083556652, 0.02712269499897957, -0.002993702655658126, -0.0060919299721717834, -0.014070112258195877, 0.015897154808044434, 0.0006385082378983498, -0.025759952142834663, 0.032375454902648926, -0.017538469284772873, 0.057556524872779846, -0.02815566584467888, -0.03615244850516319, -0.03136741369962692, -0.061606209725141525, 0.04084308445453644, -0.06511478871107101, 0.007307117804884911, 0.06903137266635895, -0.014574596658349037, 0.056482236832380295, 0.002861985471099615, -0.05711514875292778, -0.04393814131617546, 0.022220052778720856, 0.00801969226449728, 0.0254603810608387, 0.0350487157702446, 0.023742998018860817, 0.02404700592160225, 0.06460823118686676, 0.060806408524513245, -0.017439041286706924, -0.014263673685491085, -0.003476029960438609, 0.0370267815887928, 0.07111333310604095, 0.01918083243072033, 0.013487081974744797, -0.024856436997652054, -0.04304719343781471, -0.025179237127304077, 0.018756171688437462, -0.056782495230436325, -0.05910496413707733, -0.01626519300043583, 0.01780003122985363, -0.028537778183817863, 0.02784092351794243, -0.044068701565265656, -0.025434691458940506, 0.0519685335457325, -0.022305989637970924, 0.02379024401307106, 0.0007071732543408871, 0.025599146261811256, 0.03633568063378334, -0.007702883332967758, 0.051426224410533905, 0.013288380578160286, 0.025867732241749763, 0.03419642522931099, -0.033039964735507965, 0.045118171721696854, 0.023061348125338554, 0.038037560880184174, 0.01093227043747902, -0.02776952087879181, -0.03176580369472504, 0.02174105867743492, 0.025678087025880814, 0.02817636728286743, -0.05810999870300293, -0.020869726315140724, -0.06014050915837288, 0.02713490091264248, 0.07362806797027588, -0.014519748277962208, -0.04920266941189766, 0.04877942427992821, -0.06715863198041916, -0.004488184582442045, -0.01687541976571083, 0.02479441650211811, -0.011832920834422112, -0.09486573934555054, -0.004694308154284954, 0.06493096798658371, -0.05095204338431358, 0.04869385436177254, -0.011171603575348854, 0.03544285520911217, 0.011191187426447868, 0.059103984385728836, 0.01695573516190052, 0.02842431142926216, -0.012174241244792938, -0.0007750680088065565, 0.01968936249613762, 0.01022571325302124, -0.05912770703434944, 0.0005629911320284009, -0.07666502892971039, 0.059646204113960266, -0.04319851100444794, 0.030621612444519997, 0.023990100249648094, 0.06546171754598618, -0.05446570739150047, -0.011678585782647133, -0.022731389850378036, 0.017087474465370178, -0.04592334106564522, 0.010211588814854622, 0.006078775506466627, -0.01413643080741167, -0.04334265738725662, 0.03218868002295494, 0.016038095578551292, 0.04089514538645744, -0.013760431669652462, 0.007687598001211882, -0.05710337311029434, 0.016828779131174088, 0.04176006093621254, 0.0037107954267412424, -0.01052580215036869, 0.03565719351172447, -0.005914451088756323, 0.027597473934292793, -0.047485124319791794, 0.046913329511880875, 0.017061112448573112, -0.005548127926886082, 0.011554411612451077, -0.0026091146282851696, 0.012516849674284458, 0.009482147172093391, -0.00007003363134572282, -0.014587442390620708, -0.0022807747591286898, -0.03421912342309952, 0.018153565004467964, -0.020989833399653435, 0.019765017554163933, 0.010626304894685745, 0.10269167274236679, -0.008985294960439205, -0.0077570159919559956, 0.012512014247477055, 0.04471707344055176, 0.019396815448999405, -0.07248091697692871, 0.09337406605482101, 0.030023319646716118, -0.03965725004673004, 0.05502472072839737, 0.014135409146547318, 0.018937410786747932, -0.005304006393998861, 0.023370295763015747, -0.02157076634466648, -0.009059219621121883, -0.054209619760513306, 0.030317552387714386, -0.013447261415421963, -0.005498675629496574, 0.004953054711222649, -0.05297400429844856, 0.044988203793764114, 0.013240671716630459, -0.030743161216378212, -0.016310878098011017, -0.08364169299602509, -0.018773114308714867, -0.021371835842728615, 0.12074236571788788, 0.039176568388938904, -0.00755898654460907, -0.02089063636958599, -0.07316857576370239, -0.056444115936756134, 0.0343969352543354, -0.02173864096403122, 0.058935925364494324, 0.028166567906737328, 0.03203189745545387, 0.023361943662166595, -0.020787034183740616, -0.019379997625947, -0.03449149802327156, -0.006918833591043949, -0.03034382313489914, -0.038102541118860245, -0.033231690526008606, 0.022067200392484665, -0.021380074322223663, 0.014666606672108173, 0.011716392822563648, -0.0020379475317895412, 0.0446859635412693, -0.002812579507008195, 0.03721453994512558, 0.010836427100002766, 0.01623767986893654, 0.0647309273481369, 0.03576967120170593, -0.03456414118409157, -0.030926788225769997, 0.004546960815787315, -0.056829847395420074, 0.009558213874697685, -0.025055594742298126, 0.03378389775753021, -0.0025612798053771257, -0.01070458721369505, -0.02838044986128807, -0.040152471512556076, -0.014294865541160107, -0.027719175443053246, -0.01808394491672516, -0.005354468245059252, -0.0034977009054273367, 0.014986827969551086, 0.01259005255997181, -0.04538407921791077, 0.03823556751012802, 0.03697500750422478, -0.05534461885690689, -0.04684877768158913, -0.032204512506723404, 0.0358092337846756, -0.005112527869641781, -0.04315631836652756, -0.033745456486940384, -0.008561954833567142, -0.017260655760765076, 0.06933341920375824, 0.04832720011472702, 0.029052235186100006, -0.03242609649896622, 0.03481746092438698, -0.01330083329230547, 0.04553550109267235, 0.026320692151784897, -0.010878143832087517, -0.0562686026096344, -0.023445991799235344, 0.008274458348751068, 0.007206527050584555, -0.024215256795287132, 0.057203058153390884, 0.011597645469009876, 0.03937464952468872, 0.006964417640119791, -0.04459381103515625, 0.011714399792253971, -0.01867525838315487, -0.030191758647561073, 0.0011098807444795966, 0.029179006814956665, 0.0587446503341198, -0.0012630689889192581, -0.0643022432923317, 0.04380722716450691, 0.008857423439621925, 0.03699363395571709, 0.011349113658070564, 0.046625714749097824, 0.012325155548751354, 0.038733962923288345, -0.009942729957401752, -0.07899734377861023, -0.03536217659711838, -0.011539192870259285, -0.010651103220880032, -0.07561331242322922, -0.058889251202344894, -0.02484029158949852, 0.030422156676650047, -0.05736873671412468, 0.013368448242545128, 0.0014063373673707247, -0.02906004898250103, 0.04536958783864975, 0.08621615916490555, -0.017254702746868134, 0.0537857748568058, 0.0038273935206234455, 0.009025678038597107, 0.0013892026618123055, -0.011969714425504208, 0.007879352197051048, 0.010345958173274994, -0.04132742062211037, 0.04612746834754944, -0.04207542911171913, -0.005894094239920378, 0.028824586421251297, -0.012123308144509792, -0.07478104531764984, 0.05512460321187973, -0.07394081354141235, -0.006421168800443411, -0.022227762266993523, 0.041963767260313034, -0.021538449451327324, -0.006736216600984335, -0.028192896395921707, 0.011410927399992943, -0.015368303284049034, -0.011141546070575714, -0.049111489206552505, -0.013604586943984032, 0.06321335583925247, 0.04716043919324875, 0.011294988915324211, 0.02130875177681446, -0.014795291237533092, -0.04520392045378685, -0.04994932934641838, 0.005276625044643879, -0.017541715875267982, 0.023008475080132484, 0.012411294505000114, 0.009098964743316174, 0.005904309451580048, 0.0008002400863915682, -0.03865557909011841, 0.037315111607313156, -0.054058730602264404, 0.033023517578840256, 0.005436609964817762, -0.006094953510910273, -0.043067336082458496, -0.03378631919622421, 0.05475267022848129, -0.01695161871612072, 0.013924953527748585, -0.04185635223984718, 0.011853747069835663, -0.005291792564094067, -0.012659396976232529, 0.005373320076614618, 0.029327526688575745, 0.052514415234327316, 0.04197340086102486, -0.004825814627110958, 0.021576927974820137, -0.011139856651425362, 0.017931142821907997, -0.021071525290608406, 0.015359479002654552, -0.014745301567018032, -0.026070721447467804, 0.027078676968812943, 0.04228740930557251, 0.009561299346387386, 0.001059113536030054, -0.010988806374371052, 0.02289729379117489, -0.0458701029419899, -0.0475861057639122, -0.026921484619379044, -0.037876516580581665, -0.028377845883369446, 0.03217730671167374, -0.06041806936264038, 0.0024798938538879156, -0.03663984686136246, -0.07908321171998978, -0.07016672939062119, -0.042780350893735886, 0.000030750066798646, 0.031068798154592514, -0.007545479107648134, -0.03508712723851204, -0.06667538732290268, 0.04952045902609825, 0.061930712312459946, -0.043468452990055084, -0.03608640655875206, -0.013409053906798363, -0.0016477502649649978, 0.04968148469924927, -0.06924308091402054, 0.020325511693954468, 0.032540105283260345, -0.014925382100045681, -0.04885590076446533, 0.006444048602133989, 0.046555109322071075, 0.04540914297103882, 0.024257969111204147, 0.056468985974788666, 0.01884584315121174, 0.020086487755179405, -0.04839448258280754, 0.03303689509630203, 0.02117554098367691, -0.02503134310245514, -0.062418121844530106, -0.056402914226055145, -0.009625141508877277, -0.07680247724056244, -0.007808849215507507, -0.027967479079961777, 0.020699597895145416, 0.0648270845413208, 0.011870757676661015, 0.036068495362997055, 0.02565879561007023, -0.012483587488532066, -0.07008267939090729, -0.01222318410873413, -0.05393049865961075, -0.04407232627272606, 0.06114361807703972, 0.013955811969935894, -0.05152002349495888, 0.04609832912683487, 0.04148967191576958, -0.01764722913503647, 0.022827396169304848, 0.012380894273519516, -0.017194945365190506, -0.015422765165567398, -0.0016239716205745935, 0.02895529195666313, -0.015355559065937996, 0.026531659066677094, -0.018493983894586563, -0.004376757889986038, -0.0092048030346632, -0.0013774052495136857, 0.06684008985757828, -0.05873921513557434, -0.04259829223155975, -0.007065628655254841, -0.012298442423343658, -0.008737921714782715, -0.10160013288259506, 0.025173339992761612, -0.018188167363405228, -0.017020467668771744, -0.0009754927596077323, 0.021044064313173294, -0.029026329517364502, 0.01823738031089306, 0.018728451803326607, 0.031025825068354607, -0.04172500967979431, -0.019395481795072556, 0.06561469286680222, -0.038735371083021164, 0.028282133862376213, 0.005339186172932386, -0.02828538976609707, -0.02385585568845272, -0.028729630634188652, -0.0013463031500577927, 0.005863006226718426, -0.022712599486112595, 0.0059844935312867165, 0.002933939453214407, 0.029641905799508095, 0.06453628838062286, 0.01602703519165516, 0.012283742427825928, -0.025889402255415916, 0.07396350055932999, 0.012159866280853748, -0.003640045877546072, 0.004775876644998789, 0.06287889182567596, -0.024531204253435135, 0.005908867809921503, 0.011803261935710907, -0.04744867980480194, -0.05129799619317055, 0.060604844242334366 ]
<p>I'm mostly wondering about radio frequencies. I understand that voltage is the movement of electrons, and that the antenna acts as a light bulb, emitting at radio frequencies, following the reverse square law, some materials are opaque, some are transparent. Yet, at the receiver end, it's almost the same as having the two antennas connected, except with a voltage drop. Are photons and electrons the same thing? (It is called the electromagnetic spectrum). It's obviously not quite the same as electrons moving through the air, as this creates lightning, or something similar.</p> <p>Is anything I've said incorrect? What happens when an electron goes through an antenna? </p>
g1651
[ 0.0003561887424439192, 0.014164118096232414, -0.006965576205402613, 0.021944858133792877, 0.06566320359706879, 0.013833063654601574, -0.014888714998960495, 0.009016078896820545, 0.01605715975165367, -0.013915957883000374, 0.014847910962998867, 0.06461039185523987, 0.02047278918325901, -0.01753019168972969, -0.0293300598859787, -0.04762103408575058, 0.00994029175490141, 0.020590314641594887, 0.0036529332865029573, 0.03845516964793205, 0.024680782109498978, 0.003945478703826666, -0.013468475081026554, -0.05175334960222244, -0.04222000390291214, -0.0056007299572229385, 0.023021956905722618, -0.027231179177761078, 0.011296067386865616, -0.05338125675916672, 0.008033927530050278, -0.023494744673371315, 0.07505571097135544, -0.01985696516931057, -0.025336487218737602, -0.02548380009829998, -0.029293471947312355, 0.004156401846557856, -0.0061590722762048244, 0.00575343519449234, 0.0008462776313535869, 0.0005238740122877061, -0.034087784588336945, 0.0009357545059174299, 0.0402689054608345, -0.038861848413944244, -0.03189244866371155, -0.004179804120212793, 0.008721021935343742, -0.016749506816267967, -0.021123914048075676, -0.00017168741032946855, -0.008541356772184372, 0.05814171954989433, 0.0522400364279747, -0.03759927675127983, 0.00774439238011837, 0.003831800539046526, 0.13359735906124115, 0.032596420496702194, 0.0055900271981954575, 0.03599737584590912, -0.0005831607850268483, 0.00463455356657505, 0.04470585659146309, 0.010903253220021725, -0.04162504896521568, -0.007801228668540716, 0.002355092903599143, 0.02687058411538601, -0.012420599348843098, -0.030985528603196144, -0.0537378154695034, -0.05207107961177826, 0.08991798758506775, -0.025642316788434982, 0.021978899836540222, -0.06783340871334076, 0.06362622231245041, 0.0433381013572216, -0.04477514326572418, -0.03496359661221504, -0.015614945441484451, 0.03502320870757103, 0.06151745095849037, 0.02496424689888954, -0.014680343680083752, -0.013663223944604397, -0.032307855784893036, -0.049566853791475296, 0.051976483315229416, -0.03850633278489113, 0.04684619605541229, 0.005796548444777727, -0.02538069523870945, -0.0617620013654232, -0.010356752201914787, 0.03700841963291168, 0.02567136287689209, -0.01275841798633337, -0.01458052359521389, -0.02077636495232582, 0.010611329227685928, 0.009418860077857971, -0.010720423422753811, -0.004499554634094238, 0.02556464821100235, -0.041701540350914, 0.015033753588795662, 0.01618323102593422, -0.05841752514243126, -0.07096788287162781, -0.015239264816045761, -0.016617290675640106, -0.017012476921081543, 0.003519813297316432, 0.046386491507291794, -0.007553360424935818, 0.022155916318297386, 0.08196452260017395, 0.08432547003030777, 0.09736528247594833, -0.003775377757847309, 0.006871772464364767, 0.004932443145662546, 0.022738371044397354, 0.058022379875183105, 0.01375820953398943, -0.011680496856570244, -0.029198870062828064, -0.0012244312092661858, 0.000814068887848407, -0.025881588459014893, 0.016895243898034096, 0.06799657642841339, 0.024008875712752342, 0.03610633313655853, 0.007922281511127949, 0.0017800338100641966, -0.04177478700876236, 0.053144995123147964, -0.05768788233399391, -0.03477030619978905, -0.0646352544426918, -0.009348287247121334, 0.02599499560892582, -0.013526950031518936, 0.022989550605416298, 0.031288109719753265, -0.003349808743223548, 0.017887333407998085, 0.021467175334692, 0.016980411484837532, -0.08532976359128952, 0.01650364324450493, -0.056730758398771286, 0.06496003270149231, -0.018319008871912956, -0.008155216462910175, 0.02595769613981247, 0.05256760120391846, -0.005915237125009298, 0.06236084923148155, 0.013653523288667202, 0.006283784285187721, -0.025219647213816643, -0.033807992935180664, -0.022193046286702156, 0.016774358227849007, -0.03423936292529106, -0.002539451001212001, -0.019505703821778297, -0.0033650039695203304, 0.07768344134092331, 0.010416211560368538, 0.04678725078701973, 0.05198844149708748, -0.008713295683264732, 0.022517947480082512, -0.008970718830823898, -0.07460818439722061, -0.02869001217186451, 0.03836065158247948, -0.013600369915366173, 0.020582562312483788, -0.02268494851887226, -0.021831924095749855, -0.006028931122273207, -0.07608294486999512, 0.006810685619711876, -0.005408368539065123, -0.0387587733566761, -0.007452910300344229, 0.005204917397350073, -0.03968723118305206, -0.050252120941877365, -0.025920944288372993, -0.000024124297851813026, 0.011450204066932201, -0.0336296446621418, -0.004193469882011414, 0.023269210010766983, 0.050182174891233444, 0.05877593532204628, 0.05392531678080559, 0.04506676271557808, -0.045540858060121536, 0.0077039748430252075, 0.014033266343176365, 0.005914691369980574, 0.03118942677974701, -0.0180575679987669, 0.05188940465450287, 0.03211719170212746, -0.007212101016193628, 0.015527157112956047, -0.07429639995098114, -0.01814831607043743, -0.013271243311464787, 0.008446247316896915, -0.03904656320810318, -0.08233091980218887, 0.008659920655190945, -0.055917639285326004, -0.05391836538910866, -0.017290662974119186, -0.07081150263547897, -0.031243717297911644, 0.025950174778699875, 0.009533940814435482, -0.026982424780726433, 0.03558919578790665, -0.029455706477165222, -0.022227030247449875, -0.0026679937727749348, 0.007192959543317556, -0.04413110390305519, -0.004633578937500715, 0.028462527319788933, -0.10178396850824356, -0.026369843631982803, -0.034132905304431915, 0.04441279172897339, 0.056188713759183884, 0.016369350254535675, -0.01726398803293705, 0.013766379095613956, -0.01754499413073063, -0.023183051496744156, -0.016812780871987343, 0.06279722601175308, -0.028208361938595772, -0.025474490597844124, 0.08277460187673569, -0.027827715501189232, -0.046626195311546326, -0.025436336174607277, 0.03193468227982521, -0.0414176881313324, 0.017506122589111328, -0.004926908295601606, -0.015348941087722778, 0.003085814882069826, -0.01452192384749651, -0.004674991592764854, -0.01743754744529724, 0.05208342522382736, 0.06376403570175171, 0.025943826884031296, -0.05161883682012558, -0.07093190401792526, 0.040878839790821075, -0.03749289736151695, -0.08612310886383057, 0.02603650838136673, -0.08470563590526581, 0.02548433654010296, -0.06540973484516144, 0.03820497542619705, -0.06344585120677948, 0.02867644838988781, 0.012671194039285183, -0.017762070521712303, 0.01321579422801733, -0.0014948641182854772, -0.09038978815078735, 0.019064059481024742, -0.030195996165275574, -0.028735769912600517, -0.0034600012004375458, -0.06003837659955025, -0.024089021608233452, 0.06373058259487152, -0.007196325808763504, -0.05181971192359924, 0.01387678924947977, 0.08664961159229279, 0.02945243939757347, -0.06168230623006821, 0.04162396490573883, -0.0528249554336071, -0.023091740906238556, -0.007261200807988644, -0.02033604308962822, 0.008046265691518784, 0.06781768053770065, -0.041275665163993835, -0.01251794770359993, -0.0006315810605883598, -0.0001520332443760708, -0.021990202367305756, 0.045947033911943436, -0.018655486404895782, -0.0192554984241724, -0.02152695506811142, -0.03225800395011902, -0.039406195282936096, 0.05672519654035568, 0.0110121238976717, 0.0616673119366169, -0.02823655679821968, -0.015316749922931194, 0.03253107890486717, -0.012770579196512699, 0.04959394782781601, 0.005282156635075808, 0.020602310076355934, 0.03401071950793266, 0.0034484220668673515, -0.040949366986751556, -0.011783053167164326, -0.010228346101939678, -0.04630377143621445, -0.011183684691786766, 0.027796560898423195, 0.03899717703461647, -0.01804499700665474, 0.02447180449962616, 0.0005783334490843117, -0.011604196391999722, 0.05435408279299736, -0.05129265785217285, -0.03743217512965202, 0.02439860813319683, 0.017771627753973007, 0.016903745010495186, -0.02786373533308506, -0.05511884763836861, -0.005272751674056053, -0.07260499894618988, 0.026772722601890564, -0.018867196515202522, -0.0055463057942688465, -0.0028419760055840015, -0.06689873337745667, -0.01602533645927906, 0.008657150901854038, -0.038868773728609085, 0.012838564813137054, -0.01303862500935793, 0.04183061793446541, -0.030623488128185272, 0.0498197041451931, -0.039017319679260254, -0.0467221662402153, -0.03339081630110741, -0.01446059811860323, 0.04924909397959709, -0.007311665453016758, -0.019713586196303368, -0.03207689896225929, -0.003178860992193222, -0.013296716846525669, 0.03015829250216484, -0.018406253308057785, -0.018795525655150414, 0.005873572546988726, 0.01286692451685667, -0.0205935537815094, 0.041058871895074844, -0.024142909795045853, 0.052274588495492935, 0.05325154587626457, 0.009218243882060051, 0.06963680684566498, -0.012682564556598663, -0.031459297984838486, 0.05130520090460777, -0.002516882959753275, -0.03228339925408363, 0.023763108998537064, -0.007228480186313391, 0.01941683143377304, 0.0001523719256510958, 0.025468328967690468, -0.04096168652176857, 0.020932139828801155, -0.01444223616272211, 0.045750271528959274, 0.022200031206011772, 0.03965581953525543, 0.041174501180648804, -0.0033349397126585245, -0.02556588687002659, 0.030853718519210815, 0.04362807050347328, 0.041337672621011734, -0.026025354862213135, -0.004267859272658825, -0.014347590506076813, -0.045799966901540756, 0.0033927597105503082, 0.019908584654331207, -0.006664840504527092, 0.0012808716855943203, 0.060413699597120285, 0.013039917685091496, -0.02116992138326168, 0.0014789300039410591, -0.006099711637943983, 0.006213916931301355, 0.0319875031709671, 0.019316677004098892, -0.01904391311109066, -0.004447368439286947, 0.09600767493247986, 0.06563181430101395, 0.00642461096867919, -0.026136428117752075, 0.008530331775546074, 0.04078469052910805, 0.02279391698539257, 0.013411876745522022, 0.03092821128666401, 0.004196068737655878, 0.048523399978876114, -0.0016801200108602643, -0.007987042888998985, 0.04638410359621048, 0.06663494557142258, 0.11462905257940292, -0.03668256849050522, 0.02355159819126129, 0.020739564672112465, 0.001382278511300683, 0.01665458455681801, 0.00751046696677804, 0.03326075151562691, -0.004448276478797197, 0.03675669804215431, -0.017637547105550766, 0.05779077485203743, -0.05460292473435402, -0.07980373501777649, -0.0023641856387257576, -0.034825649112463, -0.010786850936710835, -0.046089980751276016, 0.05124727636575699, -0.009613528847694397, -0.03251367434859276, -0.016990387812256813, 0.024882445111870766, 0.013142397627234459, 0.043546684086322784, 0.010405977256596088, -0.019052065908908844, -0.038156989961862564, -0.07091076672077179, -0.0037446897476911545, -0.025442643091082573, 0.03624216094613075, -0.007753151934593916, 0.03157113492488861, 0.06870655715465546, -0.04263968765735626, -0.05832384154200554, -0.015280918218195438, -0.010823273099958897, -0.020023968070745468, -0.020001893863081932, -0.04841524362564087, 0.009362997487187386, 0.01017915178090334, -0.07812445610761642, -0.06277357041835785, 0.006214043591171503, 0.0731692910194397, 0.03694521635770798, -0.07576476782560349, -0.03964350372552872, -0.009454582817852497, -0.01541187148541212, -0.026924261823296547, -0.06266177445650101, -0.025065859779715538, 0.010073976591229439, 0.05051000043749809, -0.03302236646413803, 0.005147859919816256, 0.011074773967266083, -0.03231387212872505, -0.017231369391083717, -0.0077991788275539875, 0.01947656273841858, 0.012652803212404251, 0.024504151195287704, -0.05800408869981766, -0.018635211512446404, -0.002452692249789834, -0.022298168390989304, -0.011466791853308678, -0.035215213894844055, 0.02605871483683586, 0.02697102725505829, -0.006444548722356558, -0.09378992021083832, -0.0028928674291819334, -0.014773792587220669, -0.029645873233675957, -0.04412245377898216, 0.01922844722867012, -0.0019198377849534154, 0.0033336752094328403, 0.05316593125462532, -0.01095404289662838, -0.04931064695119858, 0.005293991416692734, 0.029828814789652824, 0.03966686874628067, 0.0015806647716090083, 0.03926176205277443, 0.050683122128248215, 0.05304735153913498, -0.05309547856450081, -0.03916771337389946, 0.062078848481178284, -0.04547368735074997, 0.058597397059202194, 0.04203324392437935, 0.01247432827949524, 0.013252561911940575, 0.017094995826482773, 0.09447973966598511, 0.037332553416490555, 0.008252782747149467, 0.05268372222781181, -0.015095134265720844, 0.0018296331400051713, 0.029450707137584686, -0.018599551171064377, -0.02583478018641472, 0.014739321544766426, 0.038406454026699066, 0.001867818646132946, 0.04527317360043526, 0.012388898059725761, 0.014339332468807697, -0.013212519697844982, -0.04139036685228348, 0.05757283791899681, 0.05854669213294983, -0.04041600972414017, -0.0020268606022000313, 0.04214431345462799, 0.031004615128040314, 0.009741788730025291, 0.0051710461266338825, -0.0071434383280575275, 0.07198257744312286, 0.0249788835644722, -0.010876690037548542, -0.005472706165164709, 0.003370472230017185, -0.047337986528873444, 0.03196534514427185, 0.016764622181653976, -0.07625418901443481, -0.06429897993803024, -0.04580458253622055, 0.08410435914993286, -0.006957563105970621, 0.006542460527271032, 0.00579330837354064, -0.011895835399627686, 0.006594248581677675, -0.03957432135939598, 0.002787286415696144, 0.05918563902378082, -0.010918527841567993, -0.019298017024993896, -0.005267450585961342, -0.005107773933559656, 0.0007390673854388297, -0.05314285680651665, -0.02410414256155491, 0.033339664340019226, -0.02498643472790718, 0.018234791234135628, 0.08328704535961151, 0.05341465771198273, -0.021817266941070557, 0.01056696567684412, 0.012053107842803001, 0.03290699049830437, -0.013625186868011951, -0.012677088379859924, 0.005008168052881956, 0.022270727902650833, -0.04140465334057808, -0.0334005206823349, -0.02436882257461548, -0.012688477523624897, -0.04366014525294304, 0.0127091770991683, -0.057125817984342575, -0.03212519735097885, 0.020420264452695847, 0.0039273882284760475, 0.00677366042509675, -0.08196018636226654, -0.04521239921450615, -0.009396770969033241, 0.046661730855703354, -0.00900360383093357, 0.043856050819158554, 0.024657951667904854, 0.054828666150569916, 0.06351758539676666, -0.03329073265194893, -0.02000824362039566, 0.003185262670740485, 0.03168284893035889, 0.00558533426374197, 0.029700079932808876, 0.03278982266783714, 0.009601006284356117, -0.01220488827675581, 0.028088834136724472, 0.0009272157330997288, 0.024852795526385307, 0.04827370494604111, 0.043346669524908066, 0.060960352420806885, 0.00456436350941658, -0.002479869406670332, -0.000450385850854218, -0.03806890919804573, -0.03890330344438553, -0.001786732696928084, -0.030144231393933296, -0.050013136118650436, -0.035854607820510864, 0.005690258927643299, 0.05269128829240799, 0.0054695215076208115, 0.007858454249799252, 0.05467134341597557, -0.01996195875108242, -0.03570995479822159, -0.009697365574538708, -0.02180308662354946, 0.006262154318392277, 0.0648430809378624, 0.04801655188202858, -0.017548702657222748, -0.010482518002390862, -0.10095814615488052, -0.01603231579065323, 0.02068285271525383, 0.011106416583061218, -0.05788782238960266, 0.026448898017406464, 0.008094185963273048, -0.0393342524766922, -0.03070736490190029, -0.06607525050640106, 0.035811327397823334, -0.034978996962308884, -0.04910453408956528, 0.010352831333875656, 0.04265240952372551, 0.03387310728430748, -0.030520683154463768, 0.008470571599900723, 0.015064474195241928, -0.03589224815368652, 0.003104154486209154, -0.024804767221212387, -0.04536789655685425, 0.021455060690641403, -0.048482999205589294, 0.023726778104901314, -0.00008841804810799658, -0.021787455305457115, 0.0073929536156356335, 0.03028685227036476, -0.015755392611026764, 0.004773299675434828, 0.009401108138263226, -0.011120849289000034, 0.05401432141661644, 0.018134698271751404, -0.020274607464671135, 0.07041918486356735, 0.04959671571850777, 0.0004558200016617775, -0.0353604257106781, -0.06310971081256866, -0.00604622159153223, 0.01279657706618309, 0.02719406597316265, 0.044881559908390045, -0.007191716227680445, -0.01750878058373928, 0.007343165576457977, -0.011813689954578876, 0.057644642889499664, -0.028422288596630096, -0.020375743508338928, -0.009017703123390675, -0.000512097030878067, -0.009951416403055191, -0.03744424134492874, -0.011511565186083317, 0.0746554434299469, 0.022169942036271095, -0.009686281904578209, 0.008163504302501678, 0.003826454281806946, 0.00001747501482896041, 0.03363855183124542, -0.006646514404565096, -0.02998690865933895, -0.027341045439243317, 0.0029341140761971474, 0.026537200435996056, 0.003796797012910247, 0.00002173295979446266, 0.011425165459513664, 0.020497813820838928, -0.0065799071453511715, -0.07251957058906555, -0.01288182009011507, -0.018484244123101234, -0.017759788781404495, 0.0030821384862065315, -0.0016312627121806145, 0.03634713962674141, -0.027802878990769386, -0.05451050400733948, 0.007739155553281307, -0.0497051402926445, 0.0935986265540123, 0.062080103904008865, 0.0008283781353384256, -0.02725471928715706, 0.02199549973011017, 0.02103455737233162, 0.011511209420859814, -0.03473643958568573, 0.013295584358274937, -0.02398253232240677, -0.04730530083179474, -0.03716444969177246, -0.04473969340324402, -0.052675969898700714, 0.05427275970578194 ]
<p>I am learning about nuclear fissions and learned about the fission fragment distribution. It was interesting to see that the fission fragments have unequal masses.</p> <p>I was wondering as to what governs which fission products are generated in each fission?</p> <p>What parameters decide which fission products will have higher yield?</p>
g1652
[ 0.019537096843123436, 0.05656564235687256, 0.005893141496926546, 0.03490762412548065, 0.028321415185928345, 0.0528206042945385, -0.04219011217355728, 0.039158184081315994, -0.028432367369532585, -0.07264005392789841, -0.026147490367293358, -0.07591976225376129, 0.018115753307938576, -0.01638895459473133, 0.0534217469394207, 0.0030143449548631907, 0.04810299724340439, -0.03860177844762802, -0.0018206757958978415, 0.07760291546583176, -0.02035888284444809, 0.029907027259469032, -0.05960416793823242, -0.0018609019462019205, -0.024306517094373703, -0.0019037224119529128, -0.03229821100831032, -0.0028842161409556866, -0.05695708096027374, 0.007906305603682995, 0.028246194124221802, 0.04800530523061752, 0.020949576050043106, 0.017582112923264503, 0.002893115859478712, -0.04465492069721222, -0.025869879871606827, 0.016080163419246674, 0.05169721692800522, 0.048829302191734314, -0.00941929779946804, 0.009049229323863983, 0.032417550683021545, 0.010793750174343586, -0.04866553097963333, -0.006045544520020485, -0.01059043500572443, 0.004426801111549139, -0.022089974954724312, 0.03756739944219589, -0.0025248087476938963, -0.005935049615800381, 0.0066816979087889194, 0.0065944320522248745, -0.00045277128810994327, -0.005650486331433058, -0.02218632586300373, -0.027098864316940308, 0.07060635834932327, -0.013437068089842796, -0.006149772554636002, -0.003704141126945615, -0.02050015702843666, -0.06570570170879364, 0.08055616915225983, -0.002554425736889243, -0.06540784239768982, 0.03638533502817154, 0.057840097695589066, -0.0018034485401585698, -0.01710161380469799, 0.01349236536771059, -0.07308540493249893, -0.03713325783610344, 0.0009172250865958631, -0.015732580795884132, 0.04921633005142212, -0.01982198841869831, -0.02979140914976597, 0.04051347076892853, -0.0016890413826331496, -0.02584792673587799, 0.011176584288477898, 0.05033843591809273, 0.009111319668591022, 0.006297460291534662, 0.014858159236609936, -0.001642098417505622, -0.029525132849812508, 0.023449040949344635, 0.005040546879172325, 0.020259032025933266, 0.034346818923950195, -0.011512847617268562, -0.018361734226346016, 0.0009870424401015043, -0.06683152914047241, 0.023254258558154106, 0.00713634816929698, 0.010007372125983238, 0.0016383857000619173, 0.06238982081413269, 0.07468660920858383, -0.031119031831622124, -0.06238222494721413, 0.011577623896300793, -0.021780459210276604, -0.012109572067856789, 0.01262009795755148, -0.022979194298386574, -0.0038907406851649284, -0.0068582808598876, -0.039060670882463455, 0.01479057502001524, -0.02457236498594284, -0.021301424130797386, 0.019320528954267502, -0.010000202804803848, 0.028781024739146233, 0.07945825904607773, 0.042145922780036926, 0.006950389593839645, -0.05290114879608154, 0.01465754583477974, 0.023243555799126625, -0.0153889125213027, 0.0251395795494318, 0.026088746264576912, 0.008547313511371613, 0.027509909123182297, 0.02208872325718403, -0.01764097809791565, -0.00302360812202096, -0.005406483542174101, 0.015778254717588425, 0.03846585378050804, 0.006737153511494398, 0.06240176036953926, 0.0021489900536835194, -0.06136830523610115, -0.033457860350608826, 0.05018113553524017, 0.03534571826457977, -0.04157833382487297, -0.060230568051338196, -0.0571947805583477, -0.0006569027318619192, 0.03184378519654274, -0.038854654878377914, 0.02689221501350403, 0.02526651695370674, -0.011370684951543808, -0.016369208693504333, -0.013699582777917385, 0.02652129903435707, -0.0015950599918141961, -0.035484496504068375, -0.05968421697616577, -0.019372722133994102, -0.06370359659194946, 0.0576525554060936, 0.003253842005506158, -0.007961934432387352, 0.010268084704875946, -0.004009956028312445, 0.01385840866714716, 0.0858423039317131, 0.0035538841038942337, 0.007875507697463036, 0.011347824707627296, -0.010237479582428932, -0.051121264696121216, -0.06303359568119049, 0.04288221150636673, -0.004079664126038551, 0.00622595613822341, 0.05768203362822533, 0.0027652177959680557, 0.07146026194095612, 0.037709981203079224, 0.005055733025074005, -0.007130637764930725, -0.009539823979139328, 0.0025599279906600714, 0.03323006629943848, -0.019528139382600784, -0.010891125537455082, -0.021890373900532722, 0.03571689501404762, 0.05012219771742821, -0.01419614814221859, -0.026033904403448105, 0.005069533828645945, -0.03641926497220993, -0.011025846935808659, -0.04216554015874863, -0.041954513639211655, -0.04505392536520958, 0.044784557074308395, 0.00666043208912015, -0.04353054612874985, -0.010307218879461288, -0.03766792640089989, -0.04047735035419464, 0.02552267722785473, -0.011916197836399078, -0.05793970450758934, 0.05968008190393448, 0.03226111829280853, -0.020913172513246536, -0.03777144104242325, -0.021388966590166092, 0.0031006266362965107, 0.019487788900732994, -0.052484944462776184, 0.025110403075814247, -0.0317092165350914, 0.0056450217962265015, 0.07398685067892075, -0.04853514954447746, -0.022853238508105278, -0.018234778195619583, -0.026710934937000275, 0.05035621300339699, 0.007283431012183428, 0.018143581226468086, -0.02299773320555687, 0.02283943071961403, 0.0435040183365345, 0.01946992799639702, -0.048632510006427765, 0.0029212511144578457, -0.003197510726749897, -0.04816540703177452, -0.0006553371204063296, -0.003330618841573596, 0.0021000243723392487, 0.0201425701379776, 0.0340329073369503, -0.03967231512069702, -0.057647258043289185, -0.05235090106725693, -0.03259404003620148, 0.04545597732067108, 0.008061549626290798, -0.0729188472032547, 0.052051346749067307, -0.026728782802820206, -0.02121410146355629, 0.03793523088097572, -0.006776993162930012, 0.02895725518465042, -0.030722418799996376, -0.01969078928232193, -0.01910078525543213, -0.037495918571949005, -0.005481255706399679, 0.0601450651884079, -0.06731966882944107, 0.004326619207859039, 0.0023610542993992567, -0.041565801948308945, 0.02831251546740532, 0.028735041618347168, -0.028370020911097527, 0.014766057953238487, 0.019607719033956528, -0.042752161622047424, 0.020615624263882637, 0.002003369154408574, 0.0007502415683120489, 0.02829628624022007, -0.04478731378912926, 0.02875196374952793, 0.012714991346001625, -0.015696320682764053, 0.01456818450242281, -0.009784471243619919, -0.018663857132196426, 0.0007661184063181281, 0.0394541397690773, 0.01136569119989872, 0.02527764067053795, -0.06142917275428772, 0.011875692754983902, 0.008244744502007961, 0.00013498131011147052, -0.03808002546429634, 0.03698010370135307, 0.06751100718975067, -0.09930412471294403, 0.01987934485077858, 0.0642113909125328, -0.0441964715719223, -0.009225844405591488, 0.04114317521452904, 0.015593355521559715, -0.026767492294311523, -0.055676668882369995, -0.030457254499197006, -0.004090104717761278, -0.06449584662914276, -0.025771481916308403, -0.015184547752141953, -0.03937922790646553, 0.021543152630329132, -0.004649726673960686, 0.019477661699056625, -0.043029457330703735, 0.00889921560883522, -0.010597984306514263, 0.05612938851118088, 0.004285880364477634, -0.015941912308335304, -0.030581818893551826, -0.03043670952320099, 0.005077311769127846, 0.050055913627147675, 0.015781676396727562, -0.09387771785259247, -0.08600983768701553, -0.0045030973851680756, 0.043495431542396545, -0.01720804162323475, -0.05871943011879921, 0.029467232525348663, 0.04233892261981964, -0.031142642721533775, 0.0030922689475119114, -0.046993594616651535, 0.053020402789115906, -0.004035560414195061, -0.08571828156709671, -0.008320056833326817, -0.03408871963620186, -0.008671620860695839, 0.035945285111665726, -0.02148480899631977, 0.012912332080304623, -0.02099534682929516, 0.08071186393499374, 0.04043973982334137, -0.03599255159497261, 0.006501508876681328, -0.0384058840572834, 0.00358014227822423, -0.00053063640370965, -0.05977187678217888, -0.004658346995711327, -0.0031194339971989393, 0.02533295936882496, 0.004192243795841932, 0.008423138409852982, 0.051617976278066635, 0.030271565541625023, 0.03736775368452072, -0.034105706959962845, -0.0168362557888031, 0.04463813453912735, 0.032952334731817245, 0.008438864722847939, -0.036898817867040634, 0.018968340009450912, -0.014406545087695122, -0.0250150877982378, -0.00891047902405262, 0.011889270506799221, -0.0015291249146685004, 0.015387688763439655, -0.005774341057986021, -0.025404267013072968, 0.00579308345913887, 0.06038794293999672, -0.015756972134113312, -0.03776032105088234, 0.01411568932235241, 0.06374107301235199, 0.0743066743016243, 0.002944979118183255, -0.0809590294957161, -0.020944107323884964, -0.022608108818531036, 0.03325469791889191, -0.003690004115924239, -0.013485009782016277, -0.018605051562190056, -0.004244649317115545, -0.03310699388384819, -0.01775534264743328, -0.038507357239723206, 0.018867289647459984, -0.07580418884754181, -0.08489365875720978, 0.02980063110589981, -0.0003493388066999614, -0.010399652644991875, 0.002241070382297039, 0.016101259738206863, 0.033268917351961136, 0.006329372059553862, -0.029621750116348267, 0.031475480645895004, -0.02608330361545086, -0.03790142014622688, 0.03184151649475098, 0.02610502578318119, -0.04138980805873871, -0.03445899859070778, -0.01695011742413044, -0.02026195079088211, 0.04888710752129555, 0.048760104924440384, 0.02177269198000431, 0.03035358525812626, 0.03625606745481491, -0.027634814381599426, 0.027792884036898613, -0.023881077766418457, 0.023304790258407593, 0.06344310939311981, -0.0002708638203330338, -0.015195602551102638, -0.0005188061622902751, 0.003866813611239195, -0.019450336694717407, 0.06939160078763962, 0.03157699853181839, -0.03839312493801117, 0.003459081519395113, -0.0023684885818511248, 0.026484308764338493, -0.0017418427160009742, 0.000322791951475665, -0.026396065950393677, -0.05660109966993332, -0.004838909488171339, -0.004318649880588055, -0.03109319694340229, 0.006501438561826944, 0.03665701299905777, 0.02709883078932762, -0.008810405619442463, -0.008486194536089897, 0.02692045457661152, 0.0784621462225914, 0.04048920422792435, 0.03200008347630501, 0.039870671927928925, -0.059021249413490295, -0.05047500133514404, 0.013023690320551395, -0.027161328122019768, -0.06131592392921448, -0.0804639682173729, 0.023198241367936134, 0.02914876863360405, -0.03115393966436386, 0.03828516602516174, 0.006404527463018894, 0.03493368998169899, -0.006826286669820547, 0.0016758647980168462, 0.0553145557641983, -0.020746590569615364, 0.00640950258821249, -0.03666386753320694, -0.018106240779161453, -0.005937125533819199, -0.071965791285038, 0.032525502145290375, 0.014884534291923046, -0.019318174570798874, 0.006861911155283451, 0.029318034648895264, 0.04572943598031998, 0.007095389999449253, -0.013139151968061924, -0.022808199748396873, 0.012509762309491634, -0.06383664160966873, -0.012556440196931362, -0.022312408313155174, -0.023276865482330322, 0.025854555889964104, -0.009635196067392826, 0.00023881925153546035, 0.03481524437665939, -0.022405175492167473, 0.07999769598245621, -0.07582549750804901, 0.02307773008942604, 0.03127304092049599, 0.02584485523402691, 0.04598189517855644, 0.059518881142139435, -0.07019677013158798, 0.0489937961101532, -0.020113028585910797, 0.054576050490140915, 0.0011869862210005522, -0.030880747362971306, -0.020499814301729202, 0.000011470939170976635, 0.010564294643700123, 0.026848802343010902, 0.06893200427293777, 0.02527686208486557, -0.06168804317712784, 0.005681534297764301, -0.016807671636343002, -0.000004072956016898388, 0.04143499583005905, 0.01916596293449402, -0.005242631770670414, 0.0005757063627243042, -0.036349065601825714, -0.04610348492860794, 0.013987117446959019, 0.019869321957230568, -0.014655093662440777, 0.01878022588789463, -0.01812935248017311, 0.01794927753508091, -0.006606001406908035, -0.012771226465702057, -0.07524757087230682, -0.05859224498271942, -0.04233696311712265, 0.027958625927567482, -0.001983508700504899, 0.03996583819389343, -0.020464004948735237, 0.007721223868429661, 0.03951004520058632, 0.05576581135392189, -0.0014629780780524015, 0.0004232657083775848, 0.009654895402491093, 0.014709074050188065, 0.029430102556943893, 0.03928361460566521, -0.015989230945706367, 0.03069409914314747, 0.021461457014083862, -0.016583720222115517, -0.060066673904657364, -0.014828183688223362, 0.06801160424947739, -0.008896621875464916, -0.03233711048960686, -0.011911456473171711, 0.07927970588207245, 0.03050066903233528, -0.05863955616950989, 0.036390166729688644, -0.020789839327335358, -0.0013305179309099913, 0.006587674375623465, -0.02965402416884899, -0.009959706105291843, -0.057355448603630066, 0.08521168678998947, 0.03461606055498123, 0.04371411353349686, 0.024700520560145378, -0.12342789024114609, -0.011735829524695873, -0.0043420335277915, -0.03781408071517944, 0.047596488147974014, 0.026822419837117195, -0.009998410940170288, -0.007686887867748737, 0.03221303969621658, -0.005595692433416843, 0.0003243259561713785, -0.01097012497484684, -0.06868480890989304, 0.016914458945393562, 0.038488563150167465, 0.057276252657175064, 0.027878865599632263, -0.026551302522420883, 0.006252300925552845, -0.06616447120904922, 0.08037374913692474, 0.01288541778922081, 0.009426699951291084, -0.04788324609398842, -0.008048555813729763, -0.006592960562556982, -0.0026009452994912863, 0.03392220288515091, -0.03649734705686569, -0.01459207758307457, 0.02830844558775425, -0.022108949720859528, 0.0345521904528141, -0.033583980053663254, -0.07203618437051773, -0.009303240105509758, 0.04328593984246254, 0.0770006999373436, 0.045318782329559326, 0.005315776448696852, -0.01825845241546631, -0.037085097283124924, 0.03427291288971901, 0.022915372624993324, 0.04449593275785446, 0.01830674521625042, -0.02848799340426922, 0.012622194364666939, -0.027864862233400345, -0.04240084066987038, 0.006743676960468292, -0.029352115467190742, 0.033555805683135986, -0.042220231145620346, -0.00979950837790966, 0.050924789160490036, -0.03032729960978031, 0.008914495818316936, -0.045786816626787186, 0.024669649079442024, 0.028329646214842796, -0.029299834743142128, -0.0033138361759483814, 0.025190236046910286, 0.005975216161459684, -0.03915242850780487, -0.008751285262405872, -0.008243081159889698, 0.030470414087176323, -0.06010858342051506, 0.03982092812657356, -0.07207833975553513, 0.03717905655503273, 0.05243261158466339, -0.024496201425790787, 0.03916434198617935, -0.032389603555202484, 0.03901396691799164, 0.08052868396043777, -0.007116124965250492, 0.03749881684780121, 0.0025065515656024218, 0.06804113835096359, 0.006990173831582069, -0.01272368710488081, -0.043312668800354004, -0.015459253452718258, -0.022212043404579163, 0.0489049069583416, 0.021928226575255394, 0.02992863580584526, -0.008840459398925304, -0.00437932601198554, 0.03602728620171547, 0.020947100594639778, -0.01534744817763567, 0.016168508678674698, 0.007300025317817926, -0.0013560657389461994, 0.0348607674241066, -0.02105260267853737, 0.04048703983426094, 0.0519292838871479, -0.046165864914655685, 0.017394017428159714, -0.024303460493683815, 0.013698994182050228, -0.04099239408969879, -0.014210251159965992, 0.018108651041984558, -0.03364879637956619, -0.028536228463053703, 0.0337325744330883, 0.03306359425187111, -0.0056491210125386715, -0.07231121510267258, -0.04064112529158592, -0.060671284794807434, -0.020688822492957115, -0.00852951779961586, 0.050883449614048004, -0.12106465548276901, -0.005542882718145847, 0.0033529866486787796, 0.004301139619201422, -0.048711054027080536, 0.00979949627071619, 0.02742794156074524, -0.0636877790093422, -0.08640238642692566, -0.011029988527297974, -0.006921238265931606, -0.03567326441407204, 0.01208721473813057, 0.026211092248558998, 0.023809680715203285, 0.02018754743039608, -0.01124613732099533, -0.01241635624319315, 0.06085319072008133, -0.022968702018260956, -0.019127722829580307, 0.06971544772386551, 0.036868128925561905, -0.034488920122385025, 0.04772237688302994, -0.0074584223330020905, 0.00165586918592453, -0.03926108777523041, -0.025356292724609375, 0.004446668084710836, -0.08074162155389786, -0.023525508120656013, -0.015278816223144531, 0.011631414294242859, 0.03302660956978798, 0.016692662611603737, 0.005744638852775097, -0.023160917684435844, 0.04029815271496773, -0.04917828366160393, 0.022875551134347916, -0.004872659221291542, -0.009501675143837929, 0.04601113498210907, -0.022024422883987427, 0.01890583522617817, -0.0006134204450063407, -0.014385801739990711, 0.002996860072016716, 0.02857993170619011, 0.08495107293128967, 0.0064277187921106815, -0.07826138287782669, 0.03326956555247307, 0.06326513737440109, -0.032375793904066086, -0.017022032290697098, -0.006332491524517536, -0.05614812299609184, -0.01479087583720684, 0.000930045556742698, 0.04406604915857315, -0.0068835546262562275, 0.009732273407280445, -0.08168640732765198, 0.05329958349466324, 0.025165773928165436, 0.0798148438334465, 0.06169130280613899, -0.06735783815383911, 0.05505931377410889, 0.09046158939599991, -0.01614636369049549, 0.04400752857327461, -0.007776282727718353, 0.01177325751632452, -0.009595963172614574, -0.012329081073403358, -0.05044993385672569, 0.07164253294467926, -0.015094254165887833, -0.03335927426815033 ]
<p>The name of the question is rather contradictory and counter-intuitive since sound is <em>produced</em> by vibration. However, very low frequencies around 32Hz and receding are bass. </p> <p>From what I have read online, you can feel frequencies below 20Hz which is what we normally hear, yet you can hear as low as 12Hz while amplifying very high frequencies (above 20k Hz? I'm not an expert). So again, which frequency(ies) should I amplify in my equalizer to achieve this effect?</p>
g1653
[ 0.06708632409572601, 0.03936699777841568, 0.0227117408066988, 0.004989500157535076, 0.040363211184740067, 0.00016856782895047218, -0.023488208651542664, 0.019748173654079437, 0.024453606456518173, -0.03378564119338989, -0.025623148307204247, 0.06379447132349014, -0.04088423773646355, 0.03996151685714722, -0.021059546619653702, -0.011164965108036995, -0.00957670621573925, 0.038604408502578735, -0.026231683790683746, 0.04347015917301178, -0.0022505519445985556, -0.00510238204151392, -0.031353909522295, -0.01406233012676239, -0.013656930066645145, 0.04030261188745499, 0.0018771031172946095, -0.020535603165626526, -0.007059228606522083, 0.010422345250844955, -0.0015872023068368435, -0.04706018418073654, 0.06929589062929153, 0.028367847204208374, 0.002575682708993554, -0.008459007367491722, -0.001269831438548863, 0.03642585501074791, 0.0347994863986969, -0.05714337155222893, 0.051697928458452225, -0.020950380712747574, 0.00869937613606453, -0.023254450410604477, -0.03549078851938248, 0.03333858400583267, -0.005112241953611374, 0.052286867052316666, -0.005096105393022299, -0.006210102699697018, -0.03455745056271553, -0.02169608883559704, 0.02919274941086769, 0.06853809207677841, 0.026182861998677254, -0.008131575770676136, -0.056388601660728455, 0.023864585906267166, -0.05550789088010788, 0.032427601516246796, 0.03038124367594719, 0.03312046080827713, 0.01763715036213398, 0.02063838765025139, 0.031031524762511253, 0.026604963466525078, -0.036086928099393845, -0.0009080322925001383, 0.050843242555856705, 0.04517591372132301, -0.0483957938849926, -0.03404451534152031, -0.042234208434820175, -0.020439818501472473, -0.035893458873033524, -0.010684185661375523, 0.05444468930363655, -0.040437471121549606, 0.005675586871802807, 0.05939440056681633, 0.004064813256263733, 0.05588368698954582, 0.022886665537953377, -0.026227153837680817, 0.041307028383016586, -0.005622876342386007, 0.02022860385477543, -0.005570238921791315, 0.06283426284790039, -0.007763430010527372, 0.04944932460784912, -0.0581488274037838, 0.04853812977671623, -0.006907960865646601, -0.02951301820576191, -0.032716505229473114, -0.032770801335573196, 0.037467338144779205, 0.005498082377016544, -0.02687646821141243, -0.013736107386648655, 0.040809545665979385, 0.04493692144751549, -0.059740081429481506, -0.06982380151748657, 0.03431973233819008, 0.043511684983968735, -0.031701795756816864, 0.04843166843056679, 0.0051212855614721775, 0.005923866294324398, -0.037961192429065704, 0.04119591414928436, -0.05134238302707672, -0.06885570287704468, 0.0735316127538681, 0.030641423538327217, 0.04315639287233353, -0.015049884095788002, 0.022328931838274002, 0.053182367235422134, 0.004176063928753138, -0.0005596451228484511, 0.052954960614442825, -0.05843575298786163, -0.014367750845849514, 0.02450147271156311, 0.045691173523664474, 0.03706701844930649, 0.005250195972621441, -0.019140319898724556, 0.026141764596104622, 0.015283435583114624, -0.023178592324256897, 0.03602780029177666, 0.02985399030148983, 0.031502615660429, -0.04714615270495415, 0.044708214700222015, 0.00710297143086791, 0.01756432093679905, -0.008860443718731403, 0.07076236605644226, -0.10509169846773148, -0.041715819388628006, 0.04338469356298447, 0.0001532406167825684, -0.03400930017232895, 0.07637320458889008, 0.007832355797290802, -0.03201531618833542, -0.011746694333851337, 0.055016130208969116, 0.00020017559290863574, -0.006538352929055691, -0.004965126980096102, 0.04975311830639839, -0.0399663932621479, -0.008655243553221226, 0.06634274870157242, 0.01663937233388424, 0.009594895876944065, 0.04026272892951965, 0.02218686416745186, -0.012544063851237297, -0.0024670439306646585, -0.05579333379864693, -0.023772619664669037, 0.001183711807243526, 0.018183521926403046, -0.009096409194171429, 0.038167960941791534, 0.03526110574603081, 0.08095380663871765, 0.03375723958015442, 0.029834436252713203, -0.008061951026320457, -0.06696107238531113, 0.010200447402894497, -0.013810276053845882, -0.006961051374673843, -0.03075709193944931, -0.02493440732359886, -0.009431906044483185, -0.0014461337123066187, -0.04696502909064293, 0.04037436097860336, -0.040033090859651566, -0.016026243567466736, 0.03691960871219635, 0.029845228418707848, -0.03947458788752556, -0.02334286831319332, -0.061969585716724396, -0.06448782980442047, 0.006606324575841427, 0.0067692347802221775, -0.04455392435193062, -0.027409154921770096, 0.046008218079805374, 0.0033647227101027966, -0.006815047934651375, 0.04263753443956375, -0.02481965161859989, -0.022708144038915634, -0.021474314853549004, -0.0642634779214859, -0.0599697083234787, -0.05014953017234802, -0.009363250806927681, -0.00483113806694746, -0.036708004772663116, -0.03592335432767868, 0.03790891170501709, -0.0037638084031641483, 0.06176725775003433, -0.021134501323103905, -0.014795511029660702, 0.029627246782183647, 0.0547880120575428, -0.01745494082570076, -0.004207586869597435, 0.041164837777614594, 0.00410661892965436, -0.024352962151169777, -0.025481410324573517, -0.030980538576841354, 0.015279614366590977, 0.01658099703490734, -0.02751493640244007, 0.06332657486200333, -0.07737640291452408, 0.017456378787755966, -0.04676565155386925, -0.036985598504543304, 0.025490395724773407, 0.05100425332784653, 0.005664116702973843, -0.0007223025313578546, 0.036949194967746735, -0.04688567295670509, 0.029705291613936424, 0.04520479962229729, -0.01611463353037834, -0.034819528460502625, -0.0064688934944570065, 0.017019828781485558, -0.04709812253713608, -0.026407664641737938, -0.018721848726272583, 0.02378232404589653, -0.015449460595846176, 0.011324882507324219, 0.005940871778875589, -0.024710988625884056, 0.012047520838677883, 0.034575365483760834, 0.0894806757569313, -0.04370851069688797, -0.008743029087781906, -0.04620819538831711, 0.018885578960180283, 0.0256229005753994, -0.0077737062238156796, -0.044194091111421585, -0.03035835362970829, -0.010984329506754875, 0.01075153611600399, -0.0021450978238135576, -0.013772152364253998, 0.018648091703653336, 0.012025706470012665, -0.052697427570819855, 0.03043430484831333, 0.01795387826859951, -0.040968216955661774, 0.028672493994235992, -0.025820985436439514, 0.028750412166118622, 0.006246374454349279, -0.014163976535201073, 0.015792114660143852, 0.03525828197598457, -0.05207774415612221, 0.03612527251243591, -0.020784026011824608, 0.04273839667439461, -0.02904403582215309, -0.04536253586411476, 0.027659958228468895, -0.06592707335948944, -0.003117064479738474, 0.002127299318090081, 0.015875784680247307, -0.012368464842438698, 0.012611743994057178, 0.06560851633548737, -0.05342478305101395, -0.03904072195291519, 0.0252529326826334, 0.04138092324137688, -0.015924789011478424, 0.045113302767276764, 0.011667422018945217, -0.04520343616604805, -0.0405622161924839, 0.0192097295075655, 0.00054439518135041, -0.039712149649858475, 0.01071459986269474, -0.034648846834897995, -0.029421934857964516, 0.02288794331252575, -0.04486680030822754, -0.021631481125950813, 0.007737158332020044, 0.0016929960111156106, -0.011895909905433655, -0.034398265182971954, -0.05060549080371857, 0.037492312490940094, -0.027490241453051567, 0.08295771479606628, -0.004573282320052385, -0.0015476748812943697, -0.036521848291158676, 0.017293136566877365, -0.026784321293234825, -0.07438850402832031, -0.007176341023296118, 0.011251762509346008, -0.04233330860733986, -0.040895976126194, 0.015308459289371967, -0.01041988842189312, 0.0037958177272230387, -0.018390581011772156, -0.007298453710973263, 0.04337889701128006, 0.061952441930770874, 0.02058350294828415, 0.020844794809818268, 0.04727230593562126, -0.06392738968133926, -0.007779370062053204, 0.015327736735343933, -0.059487808495759964, -0.0009546183282509446, -0.04865069314837456, -0.0490250326693058, -0.07516265660524368, -0.034567441791296005, -0.019075440242886543, -0.008849620819091797, -0.028471888974308968, -0.02247847244143486, 0.057010773569345474, 0.010535750538110733, 0.003526688553392887, -0.03506025671958923, 0.054140981286764145, -0.0334920808672905, 0.033151205629110336, -0.06158211827278137, 0.02537267655134201, -0.02323773130774498, -0.0553302988409996, 0.021687611937522888, -0.048793137073516846, 0.02116777002811432, 0.01487245038151741, 0.024743836373090744, -0.013949873857200146, 0.05110097676515579, -0.02149241976439953, -0.0585516095161438, 0.04525632783770561, 0.025731032714247704, -0.042225588113069534, -0.01707049086689949, -0.020599324256181717, 0.06670299172401428, 0.002262060297653079, -0.0451347790658474, -0.008529926650226116, -0.02337818406522274, -0.05069099739193916, 0.03361472859978676, 0.008380236104130745, 0.031775251030921936, -0.024169616401195526, -0.0003877889539580792, 0.03868760168552399, -0.036831971257925034, -0.0016457041492685676, -0.0389786958694458, 0.022513290867209435, 0.001909547601826489, -0.008415325544774532, 0.08217865973711014, 0.036681924015283585, 0.0033073541708290577, -0.010617071762681007, 0.06645161658525467, 0.022149333730340004, 0.0026654526591300964, 0.01670714281499386, 0.026244845241308212, -0.024333098903298378, -0.05397295951843262, -0.009671514853835106, -0.000831328216008842, -0.014661724679172039, -0.02848837710916996, -0.049827225506305695, 0.08126953989267349, 0.005201034713536501, 0.004425034858286381, 0.06457003206014633, 0.061142656952142715, 0.005583748687058687, 0.04453321918845177, -0.024058133363723755, 0.03763607516884804, 0.026214027777314186, 0.047712087631225586, 0.01325377356261015, -0.046556223183870316, 0.0039057189133018255, 0.016495617106556892, -0.021552354097366333, -0.08925974369049072, -0.02004668116569519, -0.0777105838060379, -0.06720348447561264, -0.005447199568152428, 0.004371120128780603, 0.026485063135623932, 0.017761308699846268, -0.011741897091269493, -0.010331430472433567, -0.027741584926843643, 0.01430065929889679, 0.02558613382279873, -0.04454251751303673, 0.04979398101568222, -0.029117126017808914, -0.02278117462992668, 0.00715121254324913, -0.0325046107172966, -0.05885936692357063, 0.029332997277379036, -0.006421094294637442, -0.03797801584005356, -0.00921565294265747, 0.016221020370721817, -0.00841017346829176, 0.03462879732251167, -0.02888435684144497, -0.06135133281350136, 0.012906696647405624, -0.03324327617883682, -0.03747144713997841, -0.0523654967546463, 0.006384706124663353, 0.08068343251943588, 0.031715501099824905, -0.0726843923330307, -0.00413903733715415, 0.01995433121919632, -0.01572994329035282, -0.02139887772500515, 0.0019299006089568138, 0.03050854429602623, -0.0036708577536046505, 0.0765799954533577, 0.03215167671442032, -0.0393529050052166, 0.014139981009066105, -0.03496485948562622, -0.031709980219602585, -0.07107049971818924, -0.007600779645144939, 0.00938939768821001, -0.027089262381196022, 0.010064726695418358, -0.049464546144008636, 0.02837403677403927, -0.004513552878051996, -0.035006944090127945, 0.01517266221344471, -0.0012551478575915098, 0.016746699810028076, 0.01349538192152977, -0.004806177690625191, 0.025689199566841125, 0.01617840863764286, -0.04175245761871338, -0.05777229741215706, 0.006292953621596098, -0.0688306987285614, 0.0006407376495189965, -0.0006438473355956376, -0.00669132499024272, 0.009955762885510921, -0.05997050926089287, 0.05575009435415268, -0.023114800453186035, 0.03371617943048477, 0.0028949601110070944, 0.008685578592121601, -0.047627970576286316, 0.0045393770560622215, -0.05543811619281769, 0.040942199528217316, -0.020382389426231384, -0.022322099655866623, 0.08798172324895859, -0.005011080764234066, 0.008581786416471004, -0.008795211091637611, -0.04562557861208916, 0.017189444974064827, -0.020984336733818054, -0.04992497339844704, -0.01844901777803898, -0.022485878318548203, 0.0435526967048645, 0.0690227597951889, 0.03036509081721306, 0.020142460241913795, 0.09858091175556183, 0.0199423935264349, 0.00029092899058014154, 0.05354700982570648, 0.018155669793486595, 0.018495436757802963, -0.017643427476286888, -0.10089768469333649, 0.030887646600604057, -0.019939741119742393, 0.03022831492125988, -0.028702907264232635, 0.031148875132203102, 0.01485647726804018, -0.04781164973974228, 0.0008728032698854804, 0.04095637425780296, 0.0289914608001709, 0.015429150313138962, -0.04182647913694382, 0.03939644247293472, 0.018617600202560425, 0.05975916236639023, 0.0011882500257343054, -0.0012179369805380702, 0.024433452636003494, 0.040256962180137634, -0.013057897798717022, -0.06922228634357452, 0.02506747469305992, 0.0570564940571785, -0.01022542268037796, -0.043879445642232895, 0.019263967871665955, -0.060968317091464996, 0.06022759899497032, 0.06362311542034149, 0.0276457741856575, 0.0686182752251625, -0.04310267046093941, -0.024057656526565552, 0.009258662350475788, 0.04435337334871292, 0.06169912591576576, 0.0196610726416111, 0.04129846766591072, -0.06364800781011581, 0.01119985617697239, 0.029455257579684258, -0.036137815564870834, -0.028322072699666023, -0.023121550679206848, 0.06175975874066353, 0.007601049263030291, 0.03387562185525894, -0.006278329994529486, -0.0023683251347392797, 0.03392592817544937, -0.03724544122815132, -0.014356842264533043, 0.008880071341991425, -0.003387944772839546, 0.05751646310091019, 0.017937010154128075, -0.04052739962935448, -0.004752718843519688, 0.08684957027435303, -0.023114988580346107, -0.03751935437321663, 0.02165469527244568, -0.0008584437891840935, 0.04465761408209801, 0.012468872591853142, 0.0021060288418084383, -0.0002516279346309602, 0.000813670048955828, 0.027853840962052345, -0.011035542003810406, 0.00915648601949215, -0.06046430394053459, 0.02880793809890747, 0.09500966221094131, -0.019952137023210526, -0.01110785361379385, 0.023380713537335396, -0.020462580025196075, 0.004132898990064859, 0.037000566720962524, 0.06316255778074265, 0.0330936461687088, 0.03344329446554184, -0.029104623943567276, 0.01686352863907814, 0.003855781862512231, 0.0401933379471302, -0.008047729730606079, -0.026227304711937904, 0.06186658516526222, -0.02692442014813423, -0.044415008276700974, 0.02099497802555561, 0.046007949858903885, 0.03323707357048988, -0.030181992799043655, -0.020686723291873932, 0.0003707542782649398, -0.010693029500544071, -0.05253256857395172, -0.003811081638559699, 0.00731408828869462, -0.001141156768426299, 0.028668629005551338, 0.01832498423755169, -0.023196609690785408, -0.03336257487535477, 0.06628376245498657, -0.012782145291566849, 0.007746168412268162, -0.0014891477767378092, -0.005960228852927685, -0.051361359655857086, 0.00533321313560009, 0.02130388654768467, -0.003707961644977331, -0.013554814271628857, 0.005627110600471497, 0.029208863154053688, 0.05777109041810036, 0.013260355219244957, 0.005161720793694258, -0.039490751922130585, 0.0023170930799096823, -0.007447315379977226, -0.030081884935498238, 0.0014688553055748343, -0.0030399684328585863, -0.019720055162906647, -0.01986236311495304, 0.014315248467028141, 0.04029669240117073, -0.11450765281915665, 0.006506213452666998, -0.062175970524549484, 0.002334236167371273, 0.014430126175284386, -0.04019434005022049, 0.04034384712576866, 0.020726382732391357, 0.018752321600914, -0.021557364612817764, 0.012766054831445217, -0.016850365325808525, -0.0722789317369461, -0.04978896304965019, -0.019204087555408478, -0.08799568563699722, 0.02109687216579914, -0.056890375912189484, 0.007359582930803299, -0.1024153009057045, 0.005710784811526537, -0.04028790071606636, 0.01758439838886261, -0.005195609759539366, 0.00788645725697279, 0.025243891403079033, -0.0023681791499257088, -0.03099980764091015, -0.0024519148282706738, -0.0374261699616909, -0.008035835810005665, -0.010247812606394291, 0.04800979048013687, 0.025357766076922417, 0.04162326082587242, 0.021343547850847244, -0.003754675853997469, -0.004716105759143829, -0.05974283441901207, 0.011499102227389812, -0.0034029316157102585, 0.03897688537836075, 0.04642210528254509, 0.007211678195744753, -0.014372086152434349, -0.051347509026527405, -0.026122156530618668, -0.008974609896540642, -0.07855010777711868, 0.02083483710885048, 0.010079066269099712, 0.033341966569423676, 0.02915186807513237, -0.010688774287700653, -0.005457684397697449, -0.024150561541318893, -0.019917095080018044, -0.0025939999613910913, -0.026315541937947273, 0.010329832322895527, 0.0036419136449694633, 0.002786948811262846, -0.060734186321496964, -0.005199792794883251, -0.008817341178655624, 0.030744770541787148, 0.10461384057998657, 0.0106021948158741, 0.0368998683989048, 0.037605516612529755, 0.0676368847489357, -0.06169533729553223, 0.05538857728242874, 0.013486456125974655, 0.019269486889243126, -0.004217928275465965, 0.013020776212215424, 0.071448914706707, -0.041589099913835526, -0.051209937781095505, 0.008327104151248932, -0.07340695708990097, 0.009723354130983353, 0.02767653577029705, -0.06065714359283447, 0.03872472420334816, -0.03864708170294762, 0.04494473338127136, -0.059598539024591446, -0.025143858045339584, 0.0229959599673748, 0.0043515535071492195, -0.004040090832859278, -0.01650417596101761, -0.02816718816757202, -0.01550995372235775, 0.005352319218218327 ]
<p>So in this Youtube video <a href="http://youtu.be/ZjaaSUHG7Xo" rel="nofollow">http://youtu.be/ZjaaSUHG7Xo</a> The guy says, around 6:15, that the total energy of the universe is zero because of gravitational potential (or something like that i dont understand completely which is why I'm asking this question) so since the totally energy of the universe is zero, the law of conservation would not have been violated by the universe coming into existence at the big bang. I heard about a similar argument made in one of Stephen Hawking's books. Could someone explain the idea to me in its fullness? Thanks. And if you disagree with the idea that the universe could have created itself, hopefully this goes without saying in a forum like this, please no responses based on religious dogma.</p>
g27
[ 0.05201258137822151, -0.006394609808921814, 0.021357480436563492, -0.004594848025590181, -0.002181656425818801, 0.02173040248453617, 0.013833464123308659, 0.06590522825717926, -0.05898340791463852, -0.01391638070344925, 0.020799545571208, -0.0756445899605751, -0.0018684269161894917, 0.040430665016174316, -0.00687223207205534, 0.0033625573851168156, 0.009213527664542198, -0.03860519826412201, -0.013504620641469955, 0.04425012320280075, -0.030247772112488747, -0.06516522914171219, -0.04567782208323479, -0.04572400823235512, -0.035819947719573975, -0.007639399729669094, 0.03642231225967407, -0.01479108352214098, -0.052046794444322586, -0.05379663035273552, 0.026164637878537178, 0.024293076246976852, 0.03586490824818611, -0.04850853607058525, -0.022607412189245224, -0.001981043256819248, 0.0300117377191782, -0.014905065298080444, 0.04951164126396179, -0.034302983433008194, -0.009258199483156204, 0.013109652325510979, -0.025383317843079567, -0.03731865435838699, 0.0073378803208470345, -0.006585871335119009, -0.02014153264462948, 0.03284413740038872, 0.01438285131007433, 0.017144717276096344, 0.03253494203090668, -0.011112868785858154, 0.0566525012254715, -0.037846505641937256, 0.033375661820173264, 0.020058374851942062, 0.007109592668712139, -0.0020101258996874094, 0.013816291466355324, 0.025202380493283272, -0.028351927176117897, 0.033868011087179184, 0.0443643219769001, 0.04897557944059372, 0.02638339065015316, -0.021157177165150642, -0.00026281620375812054, -0.007693447172641754, 0.06754202395677567, -0.01326734945178032, 0.04236847907304764, -0.031953636556863785, -0.03495661914348602, -0.01824820414185524, -0.010019662790000439, 0.04457031935453415, 0.027720307931303978, 0.023147042840719223, 0.006726437248289585, -0.010643753223121166, -0.06049017980694771, -0.03258967772126198, 0.04657704010605812, 0.06751611083745956, 0.023618444800376892, -0.02928795851767063, -0.03671163320541382, -0.021886911243200302, -0.008531959727406502, 0.04096164554357529, -0.017917277291417122, 0.019722016528248787, 0.0945066586136818, -0.018918903544545174, 0.05143572762608528, -0.001872538821771741, -0.0008111793431453407, 0.075267493724823, -0.043204210698604584, -0.006863812915980816, -0.06634460389614105, -0.015562605112791061, 0.02916416898369789, -0.00810329057276249, 0.03724677115678787, 0.015139009803533554, -0.01256223488599062, 0.015822507441043854, -0.030850976705551147, -0.021756082773208618, 0.0444464273750782, 0.005695081315934658, -0.03184735029935837, 0.01629861630499363, -0.018403680995106697, 0.020567776635289192, 0.1317226141691208, -0.044133398681879044, 0.02422478049993515, 0.0367264561355114, -0.020401010289788246, 0.04536695033311844, -0.07077024132013321, -0.005419863387942314, -0.04381019249558449, -0.017665313556790352, 0.01342063955962658, -0.0009657822083681822, 0.004245077259838581, -0.03795959800481796, -0.025900976732373238, -0.031160227954387665, -0.04078541696071625, -0.029865901917219162, 0.05586277320981026, -0.019495684653520584, 0.004487610422074795, -0.003767640795558691, -0.004860593006014824, 0.009472562931478024, 0.01994059421122074, -0.024761106818914413, -0.013451620936393738, -0.011062882840633392, 0.02722921036183834, 0.03610963374376297, -0.02082894742488861, 0.04042604938149452, 0.01555204764008522, 0.021681498736143112, -0.011606724932789803, 0.0873836800456047, -0.0041358210146427155, -0.09006284922361374, -0.017685893923044205, -0.02536965347826481, -0.017249900847673416, -0.01589416339993477, -0.027040744200348854, 0.01129424199461937, 0.05787282809615135, -0.044167060405015945, 0.08731687068939209, 0.0017484781565144658, -0.03721994161605835, 0.08224069327116013, -0.01191795151680708, -0.1042436733841896, 0.01598990149796009, 0.025551019236445427, -0.05747256055474281, 0.0275399312376976, 0.016305945813655853, 0.051150958985090256, 0.021577488631010056, 0.03240230679512024, 0.019585516303777695, 0.002997834235429764, -0.02318817377090454, -0.0029480387456715107, -0.013131802901625633, -0.0714205875992775, 0.0017262883484363556, -0.002816016785800457, 0.008619195781648159, -0.003331019077450037, 0.030211059376597404, 0.01052703708410263, -0.02444438822567463, -0.00276557425968349, 0.004578777588903904, 0.02274579368531704, 0.02332238480448723, -0.017497211694717407, 0.022323234006762505, 0.057012561708688736, 0.029689816758036613, -0.008490486070513725, -0.03579850494861603, 0.0042280047200620174, 0.02184566669166088, 0.03875621780753136, 0.021326713263988495, -0.03198164328932762, -0.008814793080091476, -0.0017359118210151792, -0.007369773928076029, 0.004825570620596409, -0.017516329884529114, -0.0003269118897151202, 0.01439922396093607, -0.020720914006233215, 0.010379831306636333, -0.019117312505841255, -0.0004687334003392607, -0.012715674005448818, -0.062178660184144974, 0.034610871225595474, -0.054860904812812805, 0.015826474875211716, -0.05280574783682823, 0.06235261261463165, -0.0045966035686433315, 0.035192470997571945, 0.03874880447983742, -0.015568602830171585, -0.022930199280381203, -0.015588859096169472, -0.04160579293966293, 0.04169193282723427, 0.007630377076566219, -0.014339625835418701, 0.010764706879854202, -0.006500863470137119, 0.026621945202350616, 0.053421501070261, -0.004774768371134996, 0.012903120368719101, -0.00001574014822836034, 0.04260016605257988, -0.0020691710524260998, 0.013456746935844421, -0.018354931846261024, -0.014878867194056511, 0.07791432738304138, -0.049728620797395706, 0.04286377131938934, -0.07463430613279343, 0.02351199835538864, 0.0011670736130326986, 0.06007125973701477, -0.028361918404698372, 0.005291836801916361, -0.03173559904098511, 0.005091552156955004, -0.020466970279812813, 0.04170853644609451, 0.05627736449241638, -0.05102766677737236, -0.04580102115869522, 0.07705476135015488, -0.015942567959427834, -0.005886554718017578, 0.03163759410381317, -0.020693469792604446, -0.0005752238794229925, -0.06293057650327682, -0.036369115114212036, -0.055164236575365067, -0.027806058526039124, -0.04404272884130478, 0.027407221496105194, -0.008125741966068745, 0.0007305560866370797, 0.028056655079126358, -0.026249105110764503, -0.004624865483492613, -0.009700392372906208, 0.054536089301109314, -0.039397697895765305, -0.05189470946788788, 0.021495701745152473, -0.03382313996553421, 0.03974427655339241, 0.049884043633937836, -0.06485261768102646, -0.06570069491863251, -0.05063948407769203, 0.019707530736923218, -0.05724584311246872, 0.01540339831262827, 0.03029157780110836, 0.020597735419869423, 0.03443865105509758, -0.006446693558245897, 0.03731970489025116, -0.029514003545045853, -0.011011060327291489, -0.0648941695690155, 0.0015837287064641714, -0.019198104739189148, -0.005150319077074528, -0.001238676835782826, -0.014492115005850792, -0.050629664212465286, 0.08951211720705032, -0.00857935007661581, -0.027404816821217537, -0.037057943642139435, -0.02502439357340336, -0.02920224331319332, 0.03664311394095421, 0.03608002886176109, -0.003946674522012472, -0.013827299699187279, 0.07686006277799606, -0.02316370978951454, -0.04002639651298523, 0.0017910635797306895, -0.0018237227341160178, -0.019558420404791832, 0.03756721317768097, 0.024605734273791313, 0.007520635146647692, 0.044015463441610336, 0.0580630861222744, -0.06681042164564133, -0.007777162361890078, 0.009812682867050171, 0.008324123919010162, -0.0016538990894332528, -0.04120105132460594, 0.011952410452067852, 0.018159564584493637, -0.014497345313429832, -0.03089527226984501, -0.04166531190276146, -0.043779611587524414, 0.07355333119630814, 0.06843525916337967, 0.006192754488438368, 0.02377624623477459, -0.0013891541166231036, 0.04661180078983307, -0.025001313537359238, 0.06177259609103203, 0.01140771433711052, -0.021697930991649628, -0.036029163748025894, -0.011156502179801464, 0.07185117900371552, 0.012378094717860222, -0.01530449464917183, -0.01934838853776455, -0.04098225012421608, 0.0008086910820566118, -0.03409454599022865, 0.061845410615205765, 0.04561052471399307, -0.008906143717467785, 0.0352436862885952, -0.017666520550847054, 0.041061434894800186, 0.0007023712969385087, 0.02006414160132408, -0.007472091820091009, -0.06961821764707565, -0.0768796056509018, -0.003302465658634901, 0.03296039626002312, 0.013590265065431595, -0.0376848541200161, -0.04678557068109512, -0.031919535249471664, 0.04480352997779846, -0.03203654661774635, 0.06578809767961502, 0.00291456189006567, -0.00860605575144291, 0.05198435112833977, 0.02439669519662857, 0.03344453498721123, 0.03170223534107208, 0.04675612226128578, 0.019702507182955742, -0.034800197929143906, -0.05121452361345291, -0.0309317447245121, 0.012719189748167992, -0.020474907010793686, 0.04244333878159523, -0.07211725413799286, 0.03365340083837509, -0.05399101600050926, 0.009077859111130238, 0.05388962849974632, -0.02990701049566269, -0.01761646941304207, 0.023961853235960007, 0.018012546002864838, 0.022114481776952744, 0.02354423515498638, 0.01933157444000244, -0.009763166308403015, 0.059272401034832, 0.021678699180483818, 0.055346306413412094, -0.0430263876914978, 0.0229586660861969, -0.039360251277685165, 0.02859116718173027, -0.011872067116200924, -0.04169405624270439, -0.047875307500362396, 0.0024880897253751755, -0.0013379293959587812, 0.0250813327729702, -0.07537403702735901, 0.037165090441703796, 0.008265946991741657, 0.026150234043598175, -0.021354246884584427, -0.0038479301147162914, -0.0249040424823761, 0.009799864143133163, 0.06151528283953667, -0.020948927849531174, 0.006593290250748396, -0.04644859954714775, 0.052433013916015625, -0.020092464983463287, 0.03876213729381561, 0.012928524054586887, 0.0633700042963028, -0.05413312464952469, 0.047951146960258484, -0.012766781263053417, 0.07454054057598114, -0.0071057481691241264, 0.011989353224635124, 0.08321697264909744, 0.008659422397613525, 0.028314093127846718, 0.0632142573595047, 0.008552654646337032, 0.07301803678274155, -0.02654670737683773, -0.08857767283916473, -0.010497855953872204, -0.025121508166193962, -0.014779464341700077, 0.03724519908428192, 0.004176052752882242, -0.010621892288327217, -0.027812721207737923, -0.001707191113382578, -0.029388049617409706, 0.035487100481987, -0.007814341224730015, 0.07431363314390182, -0.04863801598548889, -0.005540767684578896, 0.02961539290845394, 0.05662907660007477, 0.06550899893045425, -0.05087478458881378, -0.01137908361852169, 0.02517535910010338, -0.03615805134177208, -0.022303970530629158, 0.0026482557877898216, 0.034477680921554565, 0.02003128081560135, 0.04426848888397217, -0.0023230910301208496, -0.025642938911914825, 0.020206531509757042, -0.03545872122049332, 0.00453068595379591, 0.00789825338870287, -0.01855393312871456, 0.02528715506196022, 0.052339643239974976, 0.019783249124884605, 0.04784897342324257, 0.06254248321056366, -0.08013119548559189, 0.016930291429162025, 0.006832958664745092, -0.0051949541084468365, 0.012840665876865387, -0.052337463945150375, 0.02134046144783497, -0.035968929529190063, 0.030711345374584198, 0.006484465207904577, 0.03516891971230507, -0.05423729866743088, -0.02861803025007248, 0.01840883493423462, -0.0032677697017788887, 0.019371265545487404, 0.007512310985475779, -0.030397990718483925, -0.01723240688443184, 0.00396897504106164, -0.0182099137455225, 0.0275872852653265, 0.011553316377103329, -0.005658536218106747, -0.05721613019704819, -0.00020106656302232295, 0.021084532141685486, 0.04821443557739258, 0.03304612636566162, -0.03261516988277435, 0.00037458803853951395, -0.02000350132584572, 0.0006981841288506985, 0.022489717230200768, -0.007238292600959539, 0.02829662710428238, 0.024219270795583725, 0.009540176950395107, 0.013832036405801773, 0.03566499799489975, -0.0062933131121098995, 0.001243938459083438, 0.0006519051385112107, 0.024883512407541275, -0.04021479934453964, 0.014813895337283611, 0.007993883453309536, 0.011908908374607563, -0.021256737411022186, 0.014383634552359581, -0.0731148049235344, 0.038120072335004807, 0.02680285833775997, -0.00273260660469532, 0.020253151655197144, -0.012844654731452465, -0.010893836617469788, -0.01021514367312193, -0.020108379423618317, 0.017778415232896805, -0.09610535204410553, -0.017244920134544373, -0.01374274305999279, -0.07496961206197739, -0.047980330884456635, 0.03681075572967529, 0.025853125378489494, 0.03545357659459114, -0.016367211937904358, 0.07433530688285828, -0.0018675565952435136, 0.011296853423118591, -0.01760358363389969, -0.08103759586811066, 0.003953289240598679, 0.06708000600337982, -0.03154821693897247, 0.01266415324062109, -0.01596817560493946, 0.0017450401792302728, -0.028566863387823105, -0.1052280068397522, 0.040936678647994995, 0.004443420097231865, -0.021171601489186287, 0.05359835922718048, -0.002421122044324875, -0.02071342244744301, -0.030563656240701675, -0.03801076114177704, 0.011892525479197502, -0.018180876970291138, -0.05205385014414787, -0.029403645545244217, 0.05471878498792648, -0.03309815376996994, 0.04759309068322182, -0.10070569813251495, 0.0030554996337741613, -0.0014630224322900176, 0.001965426607057452, -0.0005246835644356906, 0.03372376412153244, 0.04160085320472717, 0.045794811099767685, -0.01970987766981125, -0.02962047979235649, 0.008020870387554169, 0.03603753075003624, -0.051703836768865585, 0.03243575990200043, -0.06594809889793396, -0.028211023658514023, -0.0056378901936113834, -0.04181244224309921, 0.0036189674865454435, 0.02775270864367485, -0.00870823860168457, 0.06849443167448044, -0.02100832387804985, -0.04696493223309517, 0.012066277675330639, 0.06493759900331497, 0.00998727884143591, -0.05148345232009888, 0.034054312855005264, 0.0010081249056383967, -0.06356814503669739, 0.021446077153086662, -0.00035752399708144367, 0.005973410326987505, -0.00442960811778903, -0.004214204382151365, -0.00010202228440903127, 0.028583601117134094, 0.020940279588103294, 0.011727288365364075, -0.008351643569767475, 0.012335862033069134, 0.019977405667304993, -0.06606385856866837, 0.07650910317897797, 0.07787118852138519, 0.01960683800280094, -0.01618359051644802, 0.011376566253602505, -0.0005444830749183893, 0.0305301733314991, -0.0466003492474556, 0.06957363337278366, -0.00891177635639906, -0.023653456941246986, 0.015559237450361252, -0.016430169343948364, 0.004967792890965939, 0.021146614104509354, 0.046461138874292374, -0.010347031988203526, -0.039871979504823685, 0.027450324967503548, -0.015387902036309242, -0.030300460755825043, -0.027052002027630806, -0.040588270872831345, -0.036619607359170914, -0.024694621562957764, 0.002727695507928729, -0.0014669453958049417, -0.034977205097675323, 0.017420243471860886, -0.09811543673276901, -0.03178764134645462, -0.01612383872270584, -0.12952543795108795, 0.04676026850938797, -0.010476119816303253, 0.009565820917487144, 0.02859697863459587, 0.00984202791005373, 0.037227511405944824, 0.027825763449072838, -0.026678871363401413, 0.004300987813621759, -0.004434838425368071, -0.011847687885165215, -0.011437973938882351, -0.08035879582166672, 0.014380774460732937, -0.027574447914958, -0.04873094707727432, 0.010055841878056526, 0.03287244588136673, 0.042280662804841995, -0.020258326083421707, -0.015534826554358006, 0.04903888329863548, -0.05070875585079193, -0.014643458649516106, -0.043233346194028854, 0.0049888561479747295, 0.027858680114150047, 0.007441405206918716, -0.02703697606921196, -0.018303917720913887, -0.05242971330881119, 0.024874409660696983, 0.024165013805031776, -0.05399211496114731, 0.0033223412465304136, -0.002037727041170001, 0.07209356874227524, 0.036211047321558, 0.008896811865270138, -0.06865613162517548, 0.008548702113330364, -0.023706255480647087, -0.09250111132860184, -0.015105974860489368, 0.010106964968144894, 0.06287536025047302, 0.026671329513192177, -0.007917184382677078, -0.07976459711790085, 0.012572303414344788, 0.06028023362159729, -0.03635542467236519, 0.003959028981626034, 0.022154787555336952, 0.015835365280508995, -0.008078319951891899, -0.0276507418602705, -0.00498222466558218, -0.006677683908492327, -0.04597260802984238, 0.007751051336526871, -0.018132345750927925, -0.0028732919599860907, -0.05933097004890442, -0.022980118170380592, 0.03904048725962639, -0.03441610932350159, 0.018349099904298782, -0.011175491847097874, -0.018219389021396637, 0.00505230575799942, 0.011623183265328407, -0.009784840978682041, -0.012684986926615238, -0.03818954899907112, 0.029069509357213974, 0.00444734375923872, -0.033522121608257294, 0.0035215166863054037, 0.002008891897276044, -0.03317249193787575, 0.01844818890094757, -0.001778191071934998, -0.07464947551488876, 0.00839388556778431, -0.0646042600274086, -0.054702140390872955, 0.018344126641750336, 0.0787765309214592, -0.014240570366382599, 0.0184455756098032, -0.048180874437093735, -0.0017475769855082035, 0.04616941884160042, 0.022051643580198288, -0.04550202563405037, 0.022025682032108307, -0.016634484753012657, -0.08369670063257217, 0.04152180626988411, 0.018428361043334007, 0.009439063258469105, 0.013359353877604008, -0.003028504317626357, 0.018940316513180733, -0.008077978156507015, 0.03650371730327606, -0.0010126944398507476 ]
<p>Before I am inundated by myriad and vociferous claims that conservation of energy is the single most well-attested and experimentally verified principle in all of science, let me say that I am well aware of the ever-growing body of evidence which seemingly bears this principle out. However there seems to be, in my view at least, an abiding problem inherent to a principle of conservation with respect to how we could ever truly verify such a thing empirically. That no humanly constructed device can be perfectly accurate or precise is an incontrovertible and obvious truth. As a result, I am unsure as to how we could ever be sure that energy (or any other conserved quantity) is not being lost or gained (in defiant violation of physical principles) at length and/or time scales orders of magnitude below the resolution of our best instruments. I mean, how could we ever know? Ontologically speaking, it's almost inconceivable that energy could not be conserved. But epistemologically speaking, I am at a loss as to how we might ever verify—via experimentation or measurement—that energy is in fact being conserved to the precision guaranteed by a conservation law.</p>
g1654
[ 0.0639018565416336, -0.003923589829355478, 0.03707725182175636, 0.027031296864151955, 0.061498746275901794, -0.00029690517112612724, -0.01612222194671631, 0.023687511682510376, -0.03314918279647827, -0.006991425063461065, 0.011070799082517624, -0.04874719679355621, -0.02468521147966385, 0.006940684746950865, 0.043072912842035294, -0.03539425879716873, 0.06475681811571121, -0.03990519419312477, 0.04024975001811981, 0.0744742602109909, 0.004304263740777969, -0.015117047354578972, -0.0017178775742650032, -0.015971681103110313, -0.08626101911067963, -0.016086699441075325, 0.021579347550868988, -0.010019242763519287, -0.00710755679756403, -0.07817623764276505, 0.022465979680418968, -0.02618384175002575, 0.061249010264873505, -0.017184674739837646, -0.018173091113567352, -0.04530752822756767, 0.03652043640613556, 0.005604865029454231, 0.09740061312913895, -0.008942828513681889, 0.03438827767968178, 0.025064999237656593, -0.02339365892112255, 0.025593113154172897, 0.011306993663311005, 0.007653488777577877, -0.012589594349265099, -0.050809867680072784, 0.05657253786921501, -0.027445113286376, 0.041039448231458664, 0.04679816588759422, 0.06827747821807861, 0.05212758481502533, 0.016703953966498375, 0.0019949341658502817, -0.004195996094495058, 0.03146978095173836, 0.021510140970349312, 0.0029490094166249037, 0.04854099452495575, 0.006001387257128954, 0.019786197692155838, 0.058752935379743576, 0.0338740311563015, -0.0428653359413147, -0.05715305730700493, -0.0062917848117649555, 0.06684842705726624, 0.007671194151043892, 0.04637112095952034, -0.04322419688105583, 0.0077473255805671215, 0.041209399700164795, 0.025172941386699677, -0.012275556102395058, 0.029076246544718742, 0.04772375524044037, -0.0036714053712785244, 0.0025606281124055386, -0.02704169787466526, 0.028752882033586502, 0.017801018431782722, 0.0665053129196167, 0.010872933082282543, 0.023766394704580307, -0.04576423764228821, 0.004790925420820713, -0.013632303103804588, 0.025071652606129646, 0.006693780887871981, -0.019544344395399094, 0.07696382701396942, -0.01077045127749443, 0.01626589521765709, -0.005264231935143471, 0.03965721279382706, 0.0011696849251165986, -0.023839229717850685, 0.030761543661355972, 0.004309419076889753, -0.03300079330801964, -0.03529732674360275, -0.007422720082104206, 0.02363189496099949, 0.0006024570320732892, 0.004869842901825905, -0.0007896680617704988, -0.007862712256610394, -0.000099060547654517, 0.011616612784564495, -0.01781431771814823, -0.03592068701982498, 0.0019348138011991978, -0.07709288597106934, -0.031141886487603188, 0.05209722742438316, 0.042105309665203094, 0.008209237828850746, 0.029025591909885406, -0.010831652209162712, 0.032832544296979904, 0.04051957651972771, 0.019672585651278496, -0.03363955020904541, 0.04022323712706566, -0.026541205123066902, -0.007670195773243904, 0.01890409179031849, 0.009589828550815582, -0.09434344619512558, 0.010801193304359913, -0.01336543820798397, -0.011045044288039207, -0.0011289017274975777, 0.005100257694721222, -0.010849803686141968, 0.03642144426703453, 0.016538815572857857, 0.014415212906897068, -0.014760435558855534, -0.023842105641961098, -0.03819456696510315, 0.0156016293913126, -0.0023868430871516466, 0.046515993773937225, 0.0005726116360165179, -0.041846152395009995, 0.05139055848121643, 0.004877455532550812, -0.007817741483449936, 0.10172789543867111, 0.011026370339095592, -0.04300836846232414, 0.02288023941218853, -0.010191183537244797, -0.0036995778791606426, -0.025915568694472313, -0.01886710710823536, 0.02236727625131607, 0.02870848961174488, 0.02375037409365177, -0.019996091723442078, -0.0010928588453680277, 0.010208064690232277, -0.007675635162740946, 0.011960774660110474, -0.054027240723371506, 0.0419369675219059, -0.03032834269106388, -0.10576852411031723, -0.02976553700864315, 0.04828841611742973, 0.025985535234212875, -0.014218647964298725, 0.048317842185497284, 0.007478478364646435, -0.03848662227392197, -0.009627746418118477, -0.06767493486404419, -0.036296237260103226, 0.012387147173285484, 0.024500753730535507, -0.003025365062057972, 0.009099945425987244, 0.05969105288386345, 0.016070328652858734, -0.05164823308587074, 0.01854478195309639, -0.011180914007127285, 0.0002710276748985052, 0.036298856139183044, -0.015056140720844269, 0.011976328678429127, 0.004984620958566666, 0.05687785521149635, -0.007364249788224697, -0.05615213140845299, -0.038274504244327545, 0.0023029795847833157, -0.05632995441555977, -0.004201116040349007, 0.031429506838321686, 0.036125972867012024, 0.023505302146077156, -0.037792354822158813, -0.007448274176567793, -0.0017660846933722496, -0.023811273276805878, -0.015594136901199818, 0.024059878662228584, 0.01452053152024746, -0.052567258477211, 0.015059486962854862, 0.03179531171917915, -0.016694530844688416, -0.043306488543748856, 0.0005657179281115532, -0.03108741156756878, -0.035119786858558655, -0.08059454709291458, 0.011349639855325222, 0.0454084537923336, 0.04467054829001427, -0.009462411515414715, -0.01129113882780075, -0.07747698575258255, -0.05922221392393112, -0.08641761541366577, -0.0021088181529194117, -0.013950412161648273, 0.06799045950174332, 0.02394333854317665, 0.0003395492967683822, 0.018572432920336723, -0.0029418235644698143, -0.01991588994860649, -0.021989407017827034, 0.042915817350149155, 0.04614567011594772, 0.021402157843112946, -0.051584359258413315, -0.027779461815953255, 0.023307286202907562, 0.01573716476559639, 0.0016699826810508966, -0.02212572656571865, -0.011126035824418068, 0.03244413062930107, -0.010011577047407627, 0.014206934720277786, 0.05157891660928726, -0.01921677030622959, -0.004020099528133869, 0.00041637898539192975, 0.005572933237999678, 0.013615959323942661, 0.016819695010781288, -0.04259460046887398, 0.022527579218149185, 0.011690747924149036, -0.008582809008657932, 0.024303607642650604, 0.008237936533987522, -0.014861865900456905, -0.029308293014764786, -0.04597419127821922, 0.008261938579380512, -0.035783395171165466, -0.015602534636855125, -0.006198137067258358, 0.04106197506189346, 0.032191578298807144, 0.041890114545822144, 0.0058930120430886745, 0.03754507005214691, 0.006927791517227888, -0.042238157242536545, 0.10036328434944153, -0.036812491714954376, -0.04900331422686577, 0.023795781657099724, -0.01785692572593689, 0.05579396337270737, 0.025120679289102554, -0.05182280018925667, -0.06136299669742584, -0.022440440952777863, 0.023735998198390007, -0.019752217456698418, -0.03092341125011444, 0.010182586498558521, -0.02246103808283806, -0.005542927421629429, -0.05892133340239525, 0.019267283380031586, -0.0028236887883394957, -0.01889653131365776, -0.041596803814172745, 0.007443946320563555, 0.043495431542396545, -0.007832671515643597, 0.0069124591536819935, 0.080885149538517, 0.049377258867025375, 0.08215764909982681, -0.06873664259910583, -0.028928333893418312, 0.07421104609966278, 0.008447692729532719, -0.014923382550477982, 0.019439315423369408, -0.04172947257757187, -0.033387310802936554, -0.05746360868215561, 0.0009101849282160401, 0.00917933601886034, -0.03348187729716301, -0.028840772807598114, -0.0010180874960497022, 0.011099940165877342, 0.041728440672159195, 0.011975621804594994, -0.027820775285363197, 0.010305341333150864, 0.01490178145468235, -0.11852460354566574, 0.007641694974154234, -0.04670778661966324, 0.02476334571838379, 0.00690222205594182, 0.022717732936143875, 0.008307881653308868, -0.022855587303638458, 0.0014701522886753082, -0.02194005809724331, -0.04664289206266403, -0.02450646460056305, 0.030837351456284523, 0.00442906329408288, -0.010616393759846687, 0.031527191400527954, -0.0030518327839672565, -0.008188468404114246, 0.013848681002855301, 0.03481457754969597, -0.0532514750957489, -0.036816488951444626, -0.0004942349623888731, -0.003268532222136855, 0.08269395679235458, -0.02844594419002533, -0.02290278859436512, -0.002138257957994938, 0.02121611498296261, 0.047935910522937775, -0.012864913791418076, 0.0425584614276886, -0.011426256038248539, 0.0028344537131488323, -0.012614849954843521, 0.0244496650993824, 0.07739517092704773, -0.06501022726297379, 0.008277246728539467, -0.005759958177804947, -0.0300170686095953, -0.0025550583377480507, 0.04449041560292244, 0.03198834881186485, 0.014634869992733002, -0.018899869173765182, -0.03265153616666794, 0.056533828377723694, 0.036978866904973984, -0.041857652366161346, 0.04259948432445526, 0.008116538636386395, -0.030806967988610268, 0.041481830179691315, -0.034966908395290375, -0.00048267649253830314, -0.03493206948041916, -0.0245358869433403, 0.03485605865716934, 0.02962414175271988, -0.0728004202246666, -0.02024499513208866, 0.04859493300318718, 0.006008713040500879, -0.0008277653250843287, -0.017401378601789474, -0.02202213555574417, -0.018607040867209435, 0.0016071867430582643, -0.019844308495521545, 0.012600980699062347, -0.04994358867406845, -0.012397687882184982, -0.017606103792786598, 0.02071272023022175, 0.00612082052975893, -0.010776123031973839, -0.04404391348361969, -0.022755039855837822, -0.04076201096177101, 0.02858388051390648, -0.01053786650300026, 0.0028300343547016382, -0.0395953468978405, 0.03818361088633537, 0.009830936789512634, -0.01962432451546192, -0.04380534216761589, -0.017223430797457695, -0.002538702916353941, -0.03231648728251457, -0.0676606222987175, 0.05672016367316246, 0.019658949226140976, 0.011725613847374916, -0.02650304324924946, -0.028794720768928528, -0.031833525747060776, -0.006154938135296106, 0.07708121091127396, 0.007264997810125351, -0.04541241377592087, 0.006585307419300079, -0.03466707840561867, 0.05737415328621864, -0.013472704216837883, 0.04996510222554207, 0.019383378326892853, -0.00012331901234574616, 0.027974456548690796, -0.017861202359199524, 0.023888539522886276, -0.002066713059321046, 0.09040605276823044, 0.06216077134013176, -0.044921934604644775, 0.04180869460105896, 0.06271820515394211, -0.012212244793772697, 0.054445281624794006, 0.0028846440836787224, -0.025416987016797066, 0.04687051847577095, -0.000869105220772326, -0.0003847345942631364, -0.014893286861479282, -0.02887599915266037, 0.004318701568990946, -0.02942761406302452, -0.004278847947716713, -0.05390746518969536, 0.0026170711498707533, 0.0452994778752327, 0.004933584947139025, -0.09145426750183105, -0.00997267197817564, -0.0034377214033156633, 0.07170835137367249, 0.0002024024142883718, 0.023330705240368843, -0.013432524167001247, -0.003764136927202344, -0.033340971916913986, -0.01919681206345558, -0.017572667449712753, 0.04210786893963814, 0.03151271864771843, 0.0035824119113385677, 0.014469567686319351, -0.02533699944615364, -0.016924647614359856, 0.02221071533858776, 0.005187064874917269, -0.00951217021793127, -0.06972847878932953, 0.03382861614227295, 0.005399394314736128, 0.06677916646003723, -0.00944112241268158, 0.015307102352380753, -0.07519818842411041, 0.03153904899954796, -0.00037534110015258193, 0.018936755135655403, 0.011290615424513817, 0.04059436917304993, 0.033040620386600494, -0.03265833854675293, 0.03687194734811783, -0.01532936841249466, -0.013441996648907661, -0.024379147216677666, -0.03799603879451752, -0.035784631967544556, -0.051178351044654846, 0.03980099409818649, -0.0347980372607708, 0.0034087314270436764, 0.018241556361317635, 0.01961638405919075, 0.038171615451574326, 0.010837350971996784, -0.07809722423553467, 0.01475859060883522, -0.05120815709233284, 0.00025053106946870685, -0.036511898040771484, 0.04572650045156479, 0.05082947388291359, 0.014527174644172192, 0.019921662285923958, 0.008779920637607574, -0.024699987843632698, -0.03946595638990402, 0.011629965156316757, 0.043773699551820755, 0.03736848011612892, 0.03211076930165291, -0.013586492277681828, 0.013561696745455265, 0.023587597534060478, -0.03320059925317764, -0.01240372285246849, 0.023970909416675568, 0.04465765133500099, -0.022373685613274574, -0.06257372349500656, -0.07553364336490631, -0.06490485370159149, 0.03816526010632515, -0.02946425974369049, -0.06424308568239212, 0.020667919889092445, 0.025704296305775642, 0.006587071344256401, 0.01840272545814514, 0.03359046205878258, 0.04452373832464218, 0.050911448895931244, 0.01974453590810299, -0.04457484930753708, -0.027324924245476723, 0.010734662413597107, -0.06950438767671585, -0.012781419791281223, 0.011521941982209682, -0.05295081436634064, 0.026256714016199112, 0.015484861098229885, -0.01306093204766512, 0.0745602697134018, -0.07603141665458679, -0.011307061649858952, 0.01740196906030178, -0.014261376112699509, 0.025115028023719788, -0.03747165575623512, 0.005288885440677404, 0.0033270460553467274, -0.06372710317373276, -0.003915274981409311, -0.08092200011014938, -0.04586167261004448, 0.06615883111953735, -0.030148901045322418, 0.032383792102336884, 0.04054596275091171, 0.025650259107351303, 0.032509587705135345, -0.01607668213546276, -0.04509928822517395, 0.016931677237153053, -0.01845444180071354, -0.09133882075548172, 0.0033694610465317965, -0.010246487334370613, 0.03049243986606598, -0.019978048279881477, 0.0073594083078205585, -0.00859056320041418, -0.003038478782400489, -0.010435403324663639, 0.008188541047275066, 0.011428932659327984, 0.08049760013818741, -0.0159178227186203, 0.014275791123509407, -0.016342995688319206, -0.04416791722178459, -0.10580839216709137, 0.0705849900841713, 0.0148306330665946, -0.031279101967811584, 0.017087740823626518, -0.02953605353832245, -0.010601907968521118, -0.018649814650416374, -0.038705676794052124, 0.024118885397911072, 0.011219263076782227, -0.02063741907477379, 0.05612971633672714, 0.0320536307990551, -0.04237569868564606, -0.055268581956624985, 0.04271373525261879, 0.04563625156879425, -0.04284900054335594, -0.04659328609704971, -0.027165638282895088, 0.05554430931806564, 0.012863507494330406, -0.04527198523283005, 0.05073044076561928, 0.03220761939883232, 0.011184768751263618, 0.02387528121471405, 0.012843094766139984, 0.03473266586661339, -0.04089146479964256, -0.012831422500312328, 0.04493830353021622, 0.060275375843048096, 0.0025967129040509462, -0.05352211743593216, 0.030283339321613312, 0.018725309520959854, 0.05339917168021202, 0.025547385215759277, 0.059191808104515076, -0.059584666043519974, 0.01371481642127037, 0.02207375131547451, -0.0018664846429601312, -0.033230625092983246, 0.02873780019581318, 0.06824738532304764, 0.0477861650288105, -0.07729772478342056, 0.04575439542531967, 0.02306748367846012, -0.002168303355574608, -0.014544708654284477, -0.019232390448451042, 0.0037995767779648304, -0.029387611895799637, -0.028288016095757484, -0.03140939399600029, 0.008715633302927017, 0.09001351147890091, -0.054676637053489685, -0.03393226116895676, 0.004671105183660984, -0.09097743779420853, 0.06212463229894638, -0.05555631220340729, 0.06870248168706894, -0.057004306465387344, -0.04810807853937149, 0.013461173512041569, -0.040367353707551956, -0.06944187730550766, 0.006656812038272619, -0.05625557154417038, 0.028436722233891487, -0.05537685751914978, -0.04455460608005524, -0.004960265941917896, 0.008607549592852592, -0.01958339288830757, -0.0004026919195894152, 0.03604605421423912, -0.03002110868692398, -0.0081148911267519, -0.05059608444571495, -0.021699920296669006, 0.005014932714402676, -0.026953041553497314, -0.013969962485134602, -0.0056570349261164665, -0.01887921616435051, 0.039144136011600494, -0.07231763005256653, 0.027722371742129326, -0.07893137633800507, -0.004313050303608179, 0.03873750567436218, -0.048188865184783936, 0.024496715515851974, -0.019477762281894684, 0.04962158203125, -0.022770272567868233, -0.00016427563969045877, -0.02337426133453846, -0.027746230363845825, -0.05402379110455513, 0.059491660445928574, 0.04287304729223251, 0.021500954404473305, 0.006553985644131899, 0.001074131578207016, -0.0001358156732749194, -0.04414300620555878, 0.0790456086397171, -0.008563438430428505, -0.02877313271164894, -0.011903161182999611, 0.026554521173238754, 0.0695776492357254, -0.08053294569253922, -0.03637395426630974, -0.013539793901145458, -0.037492092698812485, -0.027353059500455856, 0.020443933084607124, 0.021172817796468735, -0.04098008945584297, -0.032469797879457474, 0.02838611602783203, 0.022563185542821884, 0.014888816513121128, -0.02207687497138977, -0.005228414665907621, -0.021352043375372887, -0.013245608657598495, 0.025940313935279846, 0.04097071290016174, 0.002957730321213603, 0.004646485671401024, 0.053780511021614075, 0.02238389290869236, 0.025144655257463455, -0.0653601884841919, -0.04627687856554985, 0.019204560667276382, -0.02735571563243866, -0.025309061631560326, 0.004679989535361528, -0.009759151376783848, -0.0379331149160862, -0.007467948831617832, 0.05006294697523117, 0.049827396869659424, -0.01718800887465477, 0.024807753041386604, 0.01325700432062149, -0.0007823192281648517, 0.04072390869259834, 0.02059721015393734, -0.024784062057733536, 0.05102968588471413, -0.02841176465153694, -0.013920900411903858, 0.05060942843556404, -0.037150945514440536, 0.0037533470895141363, 0.01635941118001938, -0.006528260186314583, -0.06708645075559616, -0.023367753252387047, 0.04800071194767952, 0.010850723832845688 ]
<p>This <a href="http://arxiv.org/pdf/hep-th/9303048v2.pdf" rel="nofollow">paper</a> describes a way to find the entanglement entropy of $N$ entangled harmonic oscillators, after tracing out the first $n$. A few statement made within have royally confused me, and I haven't been able to find a solution.</p> <p>It starts at equation (10): I understand that $\Omega$ has to be a symmetric matrix with positive eigenvalues. I suppose it's useful to split it into parts, based on which oscillators are traced over and which aren't. I think this is the reason for the split into $A$ and $C$. Is this all that goes into the construction of $\Omega$, or am I missing something?</p> <p>Then equation (11): comparison with equation (3) shows a lot of similarities, with $x$ and $x'$ now vectors and $\beta$ and $\gamma$ now matrices. However, I do not understand by what method the integrals are 'carried out explicitly', or how the matrices $\beta$ and $\gamma$ are constructed from the entries of $\Omega$.</p> <p>At the top of page four, the author writes:</p> <blockquote> <p>To find [the eigenvalues], we note that the appropriate generalization of Eq. (4) implies that (det $G$) $\rho_{out}(Gx, Gx')$ has the same eigenvalues as $\rho_{out}(x, x')$, where $G$ is any nonsingular matrix.</p> </blockquote> <p>Equation (4) is the eigenvalue equation for the case of two oscillators:</p> <p>$$\int_{-\infty}^{+\infty} dx' \rho_{out}(x, x') f_n(x') = p_n f_n(x)$$</p> <p>where each possible state is indexed by $n$. I have no clue what this appropriate generalisation is, nor how the quoted statement follows. I first thought it was simply subsituting $x$ and $x'$ for their $N-n$ vectors, but I can't even begin to visualise what $\rho_{out}$ looks like if that's the case.</p> <p>I have interpreted all the matrix transforms between here and equation (13) as just a way to eventually write the new reduced density matrix (of $N-n$ oscillators) as a product of reduced density matrices of 2 oscillators. If that is the case, then I understand this part.</p> <p>My last question relates to the block of text directly beneath equation (13), specifically the entropy. The statement is that since the new density matrix can be written as a product, the entropy is simply the sum of the entropies of its parts. I've heard this statement before, but I run into trouble when I try to derive it. The statement is that</p> <p>$$S = \sum_i S(\xi_i)$$</p> <p>So lets say we look at the simple case where the total reduced density matrix $\rho$ is just the product of two reduced density matrices $\rho_1$ and $\rho_2$.</p> <p>$$S = Tr[\rho \; log(\rho)] = Tr[\rho_1 \rho_2 \; log(\rho_1 \rho_2)] = Tr[\rho_1 \rho_2 \; log(\rho_1) + \rho_1 \rho_2 \; log(\rho_2)] \neq Tr[\rho_1 \; log(\rho_1)] + Tr[\rho_2 \; log(\rho_2)] = S_1 + S_2$$</p> <p>Is this incorrect?</p> <p>I realise this is a lot of work to answer, since you'd probably need to read the paper as well. Hence, I would be grateful for an answer to any of my questions.</p>
g1655
[ -0.018522681668400764, -0.031600017100572586, -0.0027904806192964315, -0.06846708804368973, 0.03475223481655121, -0.04845498502254486, 0.04494580999016762, 0.05710195004940033, -0.0442381426692009, 0.02324710786342621, -0.06872113049030304, -0.02017776481807232, -0.0007421807385981083, 0.020547961816191673, 0.04284882918000221, -0.003584731835871935, 0.006382685154676437, 0.061931710690259933, -0.027664657682180405, -0.031203672289848328, -0.05199528858065605, 0.01848483644425869, -0.009193259291350842, -0.02017359994351864, 0.002573499921709299, -0.05497242137789726, 0.004673397168517113, -0.04525060951709747, -0.01647164113819599, -0.029044168069958687, 0.003644907847046852, 0.0024968734942376614, 0.049062035977840424, -0.049403876066207886, -0.03550350293517113, 0.020314449444413185, 0.0373489111661911, -0.04029456898570061, 0.011516008526086807, 0.04402346536517143, 0.016496380791068077, -0.038444649428129196, -0.005265781190246344, -0.038198426365852356, -0.0015564552741125226, -0.008543741889297962, 0.006516621448099613, 0.01825009472668171, -0.014334742911159992, 0.0006424380117096007, 0.028833946213126183, 0.057263508439064026, 0.053698182106018066, 0.011057257652282715, 0.011461763642728329, 0.027327315881848335, 0.02604658156633377, -0.03504760190844536, 0.06256840378046036, 0.04382476955652237, 0.03721209987998009, -0.06449225544929504, -0.048583172261714935, 0.04975151643157005, -0.001490629743784666, -0.029533661901950836, 0.04790007323026657, -0.03670128807425499, -0.011258874088525772, 0.003687651129439473, -0.012647680938243866, 0.0263762716203928, 0.03767998516559601, -0.028893686830997467, 0.04630015417933464, -0.00987633503973484, 0.0687352865934372, 0.025458980351686478, 0.07048183679580688, 0.002078048186376691, -0.019139420241117477, -0.015850095078349113, 0.005601160228252411, 0.01725037209689617, 0.03589437156915665, 0.008872746489942074, -0.014282654970884323, -0.047189317643642426, -0.013193191029131413, 0.015284888446331024, -0.037847716361284256, 0.004437439609318972, 0.008299131877720356, -0.046136900782585144, -0.02055668644607067, 0.00996221974492073, -0.03675020486116409, -0.017723064869642258, 0.025095254182815552, -0.01774117909371853, -0.025319773703813553, -0.05586354807019234, 0.059838030487298965, -0.01283349096775055, -0.007477075792849064, -0.015057679265737534, -0.010483607649803162, -0.022385265678167343, -0.04447272792458534, 0.014693443663418293, -0.05883697047829628, 0.028811149299144745, 0.024901244789361954, -0.03296095132827759, -0.041053496301174164, 0.027364417910575867, 0.09611427783966064, -0.051520202308893204, -0.021790018305182457, 0.024715520441532135, -0.025944504886865616, 0.0666004940867424, 0.03738505393266678, 0.06926577538251877, 0.03358061611652374, 0.05731575936079025, 0.0350983552634716, 0.010947746224701405, 0.01886489987373352, -0.025434205308556557, 0.07351333647966385, 0.00932910107076168, 0.01072755828499794, 0.05938148871064186, 0.014417259022593498, 0.057209599763154984, -0.020061083137989044, 0.03633151575922966, 0.01904783956706524, -0.013965288177132607, -0.003168505383655429, -0.013138034380972385, -0.015694519504904747, -0.03030003234744072, 0.052973657846450806, 0.0023743289057165384, -0.04720492288470268, -0.050379443913698196, 0.0020381209906190634, -0.009303169324994087, -0.03602781519293785, -0.01883097179234028, 0.0004388797970023006, -0.00937473215162754, -0.02016267739236355, 0.040185194462537766, 0.028992054983973503, -0.09307463467121124, 0.003978101070970297, 0.08039066195487976, 0.01878180354833603, 0.002641884842887521, 0.0794980600476265, 0.013472733087837696, -0.0078101996332407, 0.04700155556201935, -0.00047683363663963974, -0.10263750702142715, -0.016286171972751617, -0.03416869044303894, -0.029145177453756332, 0.012067731469869614, -0.019157588481903076, 0.011505184695124626, 0.0030100573785603046, 0.024903107434511185, 0.03433557599782944, -0.02520269900560379, 0.0770973488688469, 0.010338760912418365, -0.025257065892219543, 0.0048972237855196, 0.04503454640507698, -0.017529813572764397, 0.014632152393460274, -0.036736804991960526, -0.04450755938887596, -0.05916494503617287, -0.04778224974870682, 0.01709355227649212, 0.0014149309135973454, 0.04439845681190491, 0.0032478701323270798, -0.02354736439883709, 0.023043744266033173, 0.015577903017401695, -0.008449534885585308, -0.05291639268398285, -0.06126119941473007, -0.009223155677318573, 0.012220912612974644, -0.000166439131135121, 0.006180720869451761, -0.004869045689702034, 0.02445201575756073, 0.07081080973148346, -0.026630908250808716, -0.0019111648434773088, -0.02732478827238083, 0.006553764455020428, -0.06236598640680313, -0.09222601354122162, -0.00629462581127882, 0.023469777777791023, 0.013979798182845116, 0.009701957926154137, 0.01748945377767086, -0.022677762433886528, -0.01239866390824318, 0.031097879633307457, 0.018186207860708237, -0.019319681450724602, 0.00822953600436449, -0.031703025102615356, -0.017303263768553734, 0.05670435354113579, -0.06633414328098297, -0.030473556369543076, -0.02373192459344864, -0.0053671980276703835, -0.0699053704738617, -0.03551451861858368, -0.0027505592443048954, -0.05080452188849449, 0.003250680398195982, 0.014122127555310726, 0.022050440311431885, 0.05110098794102669, -0.037053801119327545, 0.018301354721188545, 0.02544674277305603, 0.013005726970732212, 0.005664164200425148, 0.010400471277534962, 0.007184557616710663, -0.029846882447600365, -0.007352231536060572, -0.03541391342878342, -0.014368281699717045, 0.04606043919920921, -0.012024247087538242, 0.0084897605702281, 0.04398593679070473, -0.017520057037472725, 0.023391960188746452, -0.03455585613846779, 0.03851580247282982, -0.026699243113398552, 0.015256186947226524, 0.021329643204808235, -0.061502035707235336, -0.014850519597530365, -0.04540509358048439, 0.0001425859227310866, -0.06186186522245407, -0.01928793452680111, -0.03858224302530289, -0.020113127306103706, 0.028021054342389107, -0.023371322080492973, -0.0010329855140298605, 0.03978831693530083, -0.032250940799713135, 0.016612285748124123, -0.02950586937367916, -0.03263050317764282, -0.014910899102687836, 0.01163441501557827, 0.0008327398682013154, 0.024531809613108635, -0.007869869470596313, 0.03517948463559151, -0.0570414736866951, 0.0007231737836264074, 0.055919673293828964, -0.0921994224190712, -0.028664259240031242, 0.013944282196462154, 0.07899358868598938, 0.026723802089691162, -0.0017110053449869156, 0.016942227259278297, -0.02222234569489956, -0.0436428040266037, -0.0426197275519371, 0.02147156558930874, 0.017359431833028793, -0.048636894673109055, 0.026723546907305717, 0.039429374039173126, -0.04215909540653229, 0.035704005509614944, 0.03624558448791504, 0.020632240921258926, 0.05083020403981209, 0.04761110618710518, -0.05350383371114731, -0.01458144374191761, -0.023242877796292305, 0.0007017819443717599, 0.01651190035045147, -0.05342146009206772, 0.063297338783741, -0.020765095949172974, 0.02973584644496441, -0.037197377532720566, -0.023063717409968376, -0.08585287630558014, -0.01074212696403265, -0.03425685688853264, -0.05059507116675377, -0.04851750284433365, 0.04885463789105415, -0.04245583713054657, 0.05808262526988983, -0.0509963184595108, -0.03130626678466797, 0.020460035651922226, -0.04481106624007225, -0.021846694871783257, 0.013858570717275143, -0.057750627398490906, 0.066318079829216, 0.004017831292003393, -0.05360639467835426, -0.05323931947350502, -0.024935642257332802, -0.002477434929460287, 0.018228305503726006, -0.007696522865444422, 0.04295506700873375, -0.024073680862784386, -0.0006894582766108215, -0.0035985754802823067, -0.014604133553802967, -0.043817006051540375, -0.08255631476640701, 0.02036215178668499, 0.023566007614135742, -0.0095608439296484, -0.0007182637928053737, 0.01106333825737238, 0.02648738957941532, 0.0001885186939034611, -0.00038388604298233986, 0.0004608065646607429, -0.019453946501016617, 0.0019633600022643805, 0.05014777556061745, -0.018877441063523293, 0.0000687738211126998, -0.045699525624513626, 0.05519682168960571, -0.017224838957190514, 0.023197883740067482, -0.007347804959863424, 0.00518786208704114, -0.005324496887624264, -0.031225446611642838, 0.0071098594926297665, 0.01755189709365368, 0.0024378313682973385, -0.024648787453770638, 0.03180443122982979, -0.01644773967564106, -0.0767040029168129, 0.02151600643992424, 0.007176387123763561, 0.04461498558521271, 0.033834390342235565, 0.015600454062223434, -0.05620657652616501, 0.021755164489150047, -0.011429592035710812, 0.11978980898857117, -0.012922986410558224, -0.0069221328012645245, 0.0031491208355873823, -0.02666863612830639, -0.03937803953886032, 0.02610228769481182, 0.04758760333061218, -0.02697932906448841, -0.030666125938296318, -0.019307797774672508, 0.01441278774291277, 0.052168410271406174, 0.03968097269535065, -0.05762182176113129, 0.052291639149188995, -0.04150163754820824, -0.023499129340052605, 0.0020092937629669905, 0.004031564109027386, 0.031658075749874115, 0.001133846933953464, 0.005467162933200598, 0.0423070453107357, -0.0018482374725863338, -0.007361305877566338, -0.02402767539024353, 0.02107144519686699, 0.012044725008308887, -0.007784978486597538, -0.002788604935631156, 0.024965869262814522, 0.035408858209848404, -0.04427236691117287, -0.003062247997149825, -0.029852677136659622, -0.04206576570868492, 0.023918770253658295, -0.01852859929203987, 0.027669738978147507, -0.039260029792785645, 0.031250085681676865, 0.07694555819034576, 0.0348808616399765, 0.03249802067875862, -0.027010731399059296, 0.03421948105096817, -0.02927098050713539, -0.009709125384688377, 0.054923731833696365, -0.06851059943437576, 0.02877313457429409, -0.052713822573423386, 0.043827202171087265, -0.016843358054757118, -0.03207450732588768, 0.05912197008728981, 0.04626256600022316, 0.0011578118428587914, -0.019698884338140488, 0.01692763715982437, 0.016338421031832695, 0.028282396495342255, -0.021187549456954002, -0.027944019064307213, 0.02016160450875759, -0.012266060337424278, -0.004726233892142773, 0.048056140542030334, -0.05090763792395592, -0.009851854294538498, 0.007456093095242977, 0.027449551969766617, 0.07677901536226273, 0.030366571620106697, 0.019314587116241455, -0.013773927465081215, -0.0357598215341568, 0.008951258845627308, -0.05513808876276016, 0.013738836161792278, -0.005850223824381828, -0.022290965542197227, 0.07351316511631012, 0.004648931790143251, -0.011381099931895733, 0.05305684357881546, 0.021920157596468925, 0.003701134119182825, 0.004746836610138416, 0.0057462053373456, -0.02442304976284504, -0.03291579708456993, 0.008640355430543423, -0.042555201798677444, -0.008514179848134518, -0.028750985860824585, -0.0050719366408884525, 0.0377839170396328, 0.04541640356183052, 0.05441681295633316, 0.002734914654865861, 0.03514111042022705, -0.05007925257086754, -0.017310602590441704, 0.016493597999215126, 0.013615207746624947, 0.05456811934709549, -0.002970614703372121, 0.03266407921910286, -0.00824193935841322, 0.010290066711604595, -0.005298570729792118, 0.0027285756077617407, -0.029964882880449295, 0.00751709658652544, -0.02562768943607807, 0.10119913518428802, -0.0588003471493721, 0.008806207217276096, -0.001506724045611918, -0.010608564130961895, 0.028373150154948235, -0.004760943818837404, -0.032635994255542755, 0.0142781687900424, 0.0084131034091115, 0.00707374420017004, -0.056454647332429886, 0.03444322198629379, -0.0005803992389701307, -0.023667098954319954, -0.0867445096373558, -0.0002468229504302144, 0.030507100746035576, 0.039015524089336395, 0.03382665663957596, -0.030253717675805092, 0.032297227531671524, -0.0643840804696083, 0.025674225762486458, 0.045624975115060806, -0.07754579931497574, -0.024377688765525818, 0.02207215502858162, 0.06503068655729294, -0.023721404373645782, 0.011845413595438004, 0.03270040452480316, -0.011220027692615986, 0.029036391526460648, -0.014793511480093002, -0.050007618963718414, -0.031837962567806244, 0.017784910276532173, 0.04369135573506355, 0.05165088176727295, -0.060224827378988266, -0.03362361714243889, 0.08500278741121292, -0.01952766627073288, 0.005395475309342146, 0.013286222703754902, -0.03303160518407822, -0.06363585591316223, 0.048065684735774994, -0.050098832696676254, -0.015420706011354923, -0.049865078181028366, -0.0012187919346615672, 0.0029250532388687134, 0.00237397407181561, 0.04269058629870415, -0.011798777617514133, 0.0359637476503849, 0.0693933442234993, 0.03586225584149361, -0.009714425541460514, -0.016664443537592888, 0.021040277555584908, -0.01646604761481285, 0.009871764108538628, 0.02895916998386383, 0.019208230078220367, 0.014967855997383595, 0.11017423868179321, 0.007591762114316225, 0.005814872682094574, 0.003747801296412945, -0.007134853862226009, 0.03250764310359955, 0.017160095274448395, -0.06428568065166473, -0.07127401232719421, -0.04231712222099304, -0.01367435697466135, -0.07948260754346848, -0.0031098334584385157, 0.019122973084449768, -0.004630489274859428, -0.06423794478178024, 0.06362098455429077, -0.04878978058695793, -0.024194994941353798, 0.022490747272968292, 0.03019716404378414, -0.03938945382833481, 0.02772418037056923, -0.02572011388838291, -0.04812338575720787, -0.018531212583184242, -0.028697609901428223, 0.03948701173067093, 0.05635595694184303, 0.012956126593053341, -0.00040286820149049163, 0.022680681198835373, -0.03981155529618263, 0.05436430498957634, -0.02609706111252308, 0.017598813399672508, 0.04402478039264679, 0.0066927047446370125, 0.0067169563844799995, -0.03347764536738396, -0.0020451347809284925, -0.06604444980621338, -0.027019090950489044, 0.009699943475425243, -0.034986987709999084, 0.062077805399894714, 0.020570795983076096, -0.012323449365794659, 0.021940166130661964, 0.03246193751692772, 0.052812714129686356, 0.023082593455910683, 0.029316654428839684, -0.012688721530139446, -0.0090817054733634, 0.03579598665237427, 0.09948738664388657, 0.01072675734758377, -0.059303853660821915, 0.02058451436460018, 0.06000009924173355, -0.012328420765697956, -0.04229065030813217, 0.025953195989131927, 0.044652871787548065, 0.010647485964000225, -0.06042204424738884, -0.0278195571154356, 0.05326756089925766, 0.032614778727293015, 0.01797247678041458, -0.02629508636891842, 0.0014169313944876194, 0.03400007635354996, 0.015430611558258533, -0.05198667198419571, 0.022545253857970238, 0.06753242760896683, -0.016457566991448402, -0.08380012214183807, -0.006192815490067005, 0.025318382307887077, 0.0014536846429109573, -0.0669003427028656, 0.015552770346403122, -0.05483503267168999, 0.017508212476968765, -0.017265906557440758, 0.01852349191904068, 0.07093409448862076, -0.0037242863327264786, 0.02436642535030842, -0.03201325237751007, 0.014745466411113739, 0.03047565370798111, -0.05579034611582756, 0.04166688397526741, 0.07829783111810684, 0.025588707998394966, 0.0006873232196085155, -0.07305753976106644, 0.021460801362991333, -0.023323336616158485, 0.027474163100123405, 0.018470192328095436, 0.027287296950817108, 0.02278248593211174, 0.011717469431459904, 0.02112261764705181, -0.05782896280288696, -0.05838772654533386, -0.027774134650826454, -0.012335680425167084, -0.06620542705059052, -0.007588715758174658, -0.006738582160323858, 0.05769990384578705, -0.07982418686151505, 0.006624326575547457, -0.0602392815053463, 0.030405594035983086, -0.034196022897958755, 0.017687160521745682, -0.01303708367049694, -0.04882080480456352, -0.01630893349647522, 0.015825165435671806, 0.04288524389266968, 0.04104671999812126, -0.024976780638098717, 0.0015145426150411367, 0.008590701036155224, -0.03432714566588402, 0.018991313874721527, -0.003101394511759281, 0.01112906914204359, -0.00980974268168211, -0.007552780210971832, -0.07030079513788223, 0.03456750512123108, 0.0005126640317030251, -0.026341106742620468, -0.04759396240115166, -0.03867756202816963, -0.012496844865381718, -0.013417473062872887, 0.03329825773835182, -0.025596491992473602, 0.020912816748023033, 0.026720700785517693, -0.010117164812982082, -0.006399151869118214, 0.059607040137052536, -0.019193310290575027, -0.003465485293418169, -0.010463275015354156, 0.019164806231856346, 0.036894962191581726, 0.032188042998313904, 0.009369908832013607, -0.04696663096547127, -0.006709172856062651, -0.04734525829553604, -0.007328570354729891, 0.050788283348083496, -0.01378779485821724, 0.023762982338666916, 0.04694383963942528, -0.015474740415811539, 0.08135392516851425, 0.012503051199018955, 0.03662843629717827, -0.039997000247240067, 0.012393908575177193, -0.0351121760904789, -0.023246515542268753, -0.04019094631075859, -0.10894285142421722, -0.011895215138792992, 0.013380561955273151, -0.051175471395254135, -0.008963292464613914, 0.009749174118041992, -0.019670171663165092, 0.0485134981572628, 0.05236567184329033, -0.05202838405966759, 0.024656247347593307, 0.01471654511988163, 0.06147873401641846, 0.027365049347281456, 0.06136225163936615, 0.027923112735152245, -0.03085176832973957, -0.0052981190383434296, -0.007013053633272648, -0.03733121603727341, -0.0013992568710818887, -0.0044911992736160755 ]
<h2>Background</h2> <p>Let me start this question by a long introduction, because I assume that only few readers will be familiar with <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coherence_theory" rel="nofollow">the theory of partial coherent light</a> and concepts like a mutual coherence function or a mutual intensity. The <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polarization_(waves)#Coherency_matrix" rel="nofollow">coherency matrix</a> and <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stokes_parameters" rel="nofollow">Stokes parameters</a> descriptions of partially polarized light are related concepts which are more widely known.</p> <p>Correct treatment of partial coherent light is important for an appropriate modeling of optical pattern transfer in computer simulations of proximity and projection lithography as currently used by the semiconductor manufacturing industry. When I came to this industry, my previous optics "training" was insufficient in this area. I found chapter X "Interference and diffraction with partially coherent light" in <a href="https://archive.org/details/PrinciplesOfOptics" rel="nofollow"><em>Principles of Optics</em></a> by Max Born and Emil Wolf most helpful for filling my gaps in this area. Later, I also "browsed" through "Statistical Optics" by Joseph W. Goodman, which has a nice paragraph in the introduction explaining why insufficient familiarity with statistical optics is so common:</p> <blockquote> <p>Surely the preferred way to solve a problem must be the deterministic way, with statistics entering only as a sign of our own weakness or limitations. Partially as a consequence of this viewpoint, the subject of statistical optics is usually left for the more advanced students, particularly those with a mathematical flair.</p> </blockquote> <p>The interesting thing is that Hermitian matrices and eigenvalue decompositions like the Karhunen-Loève expansion are used quite routinely in this field, and they somehow feel quite similar to modeling of coherence and decoherence in quantum-mechanics. I know that there are important obvious (physical) difference between the two fields, but my actual question is what they have in common.</p> <h2>Question</h2> <p>Some elementary experiments like the double slit experiment are often used to illustrate the particle wave duality of light. However, the theory of partially coherent light is completely sufficient to describe and predict the outcome of these experiments. There are no particles at all in the theory of partially coherent light, only waves, statistics and uncertainty. The global phase is an unobservable parameter in both theories, but the amplitude of a wave function is only important for the theory of partial coherent light and is commonly normalized away in quantum-mechanics. This leads to a crucial difference with respect to the possible transformations treated by the respective theories. But is this really a fundamental difference, or just a difference in the common practices of the respective theories? How much of the strange phenomena of quantum-mechanics can be explained by the theory of partial coherent light alone, without any reference to particles or measurement processes?</p> <hr> <h2>More information on what I would actually like to learn</h2> <p>One reason for this question is to find out how much familiarity with partial coherence can be assumed when asking questions here. Therefore it explains why this familiarity cannot be taken for granted, and is written in a style to allow quite general answers. However, it also contains specific questions, indicated by question marks:</p> <blockquote> <ul> <li>How is the theory of partial coherent light related to quantum-mechanics?</li> <li>... the amplitude of a wave function ... But is this really a fundamental difference, or just a difference in the common practices of the respective theories?</li> <li>How much of the strange phenomena of quantum-mechanics can be explained by the theory of partial coherent light alone, without any reference to particles or measurement processes?</li> </ul> </blockquote> <p>Don't be distracted by my remark about the double slit experiment. Using it to illustrate the particle wave duality of light seemed kind of cheating to me long before I had to cope with partial coherence. I could effortlessly predict the outcome of all these supposedly counter-intuitive experiments without even being familiar with the formalism of quantum-mechanics. Still, the outcome of these experiments is predicted correctly by quantum-mechanics, and independently by the theory of partial coherent light. So these two theories do share some common parts.</p> <p>An interesting aspect of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coherence_theory" rel="nofollow">the theory of partial coherent light</a> is that things like the mutual intensity or the Stokes parameters can in principle be observed. A simple analogy to the density matrix in quantum-mechanics is the coherency matrix description of is partial polarization. It can be computed in terms of the Stokes parameters $$J=\begin{bmatrix} E(u_{x}u_{x}^{\ast})&amp;E(u_{x}u_{y}^{\ast})\\ E(u_{y}u_{x}^{\ast})&amp;E(u_{y}u_{y}^{\ast}) \end{bmatrix}=\frac12\begin{bmatrix} S_0+S_1&amp;S_2+iS_3\\ S_2-iS_3&amp;S_0-S_1 \end{bmatrix} $$ and hence can in principle be observed. But can the density matrix in quantum-mechanics in principle be observed? Well, the measurement process of the Stokes parameters can be described by the following Hermitian matrices $\hat{S}_0=\begin{bmatrix}1&amp;0\\0&amp;1\end{bmatrix}$, $\hat{S}_1=\begin{bmatrix}1&amp;0\\0&amp;-1\end{bmatrix}$, $\hat{S}_2=\begin{bmatrix}0&amp;1\\1&amp;0\end{bmatrix}$ and $\hat{S}_3=\begin{bmatrix}0&amp;i\\-i&amp;0\end{bmatrix}$. Only $\hat{S}_0$ commutes with all other Hermitian matrices, which somehow means that each individual part of the density matrix can be observed in isolation, but the entire density matrix itself is not observable. But we don't measure all Stokes parameters simultaneous either, or at least that's not what we mean when we say that the Stokes parameters can be measured in principle. Also note the relation of the fact that $\hat{S}_0$ commutes with all other Hermitian matrices and the fact that the amplitude of a wave function is commonly normalized away in quantum-mechanics. But the related question is really a serious question for me, because the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mueller_calculus" rel="nofollow">Mueller calculus</a> for Stokes parameters allows (slightly unintuitive) transformations which seem to be ruled out for quantum-mechanics.</p>
g1656
[ 0.03485998511314392, -0.03936494514346123, 0.03262444585561752, -0.02213079296052456, 0.010156432166695595, 0.022154873237013817, 0.03426709026098251, 0.028842618688941002, 0.022152267396450043, 0.019086746498942375, 0.07796114683151245, -0.03167865425348282, 0.048766911029815674, 0.005065764766186476, -0.03032815270125866, 0.0014475893694907427, 0.07863090187311172, 0.041903264820575714, -0.00545769976451993, 0.041058868169784546, -0.05463511124253273, 0.040367454290390015, 0.02921144850552082, -0.05230049788951874, -0.028826313093304634, -0.02028357982635498, -0.017811881378293037, -0.07661933451890945, 0.0297804344445467, 0.04134463146328926, -0.0031540782656520605, -0.07677429914474487, 0.03287084028124809, -0.03480052202939987, -0.005471238866448402, 0.03756455332040787, 0.024471143260598183, 0.007342856377363205, 0.04657125473022461, 0.07381497323513031, 0.04853326082229614, -0.005127748474478722, 0.0007578530348837376, -0.08296600729227066, 0.020143400877714157, 0.005944214295595884, 0.0051483954302966595, -0.023280013352632523, -0.017642028629779816, -0.02295229770243168, 0.00991570483893156, 0.0017188404453918338, 0.04065839573740959, 0.0719192624092102, 0.021250609308481216, 0.03425515443086624, 0.04655197635293007, 0.039469972252845764, 0.07695697247982025, 0.023555943742394447, 0.04127316176891327, 0.012030563317239285, 0.027568351477384567, 0.041918523609638214, -0.02202066034078598, 0.037632256746292114, 0.026907904073596, -0.015191533602774143, 0.039681002497673035, 0.010693710297346115, -0.011470219120383263, -0.037487924098968506, -0.007260867394506931, -0.012980242259800434, 0.005566158797591925, -0.006688280496746302, -0.021879618987441063, -0.022490529343485832, 0.037795715034008026, -0.002535008592531085, -0.016355503350496292, -0.044980451464653015, -0.008643199689686298, 0.028059575706720352, 0.03546719625592232, -0.0003261991951148957, -0.00805716309696436, -0.03456110507249832, -0.012338527478277683, -0.005332777742296457, 0.029743900522589684, 0.05455121025443077, 0.05430929362773895, 0.015562104061245918, -0.01839134842157364, 0.05381397157907486, -0.010038092732429504, 0.007192536257207394, -0.05029579997062683, 0.006826821714639664, -0.02399618923664093, -0.01960420235991478, -0.021969998255372047, 0.006823092233389616, -0.03086170181632042, 0.012701405212283134, -0.027886075899004936, 0.03663800656795502, -0.01663529872894287, 0.01915617845952511, -0.10148531943559647, 0.00809358898550272, -0.06595218926668167, 0.011119014583528042, 0.029943274334073067, -0.07663939148187637, 0.06414355337619781, -0.010010278783738613, 0.007449707947671413, -0.01041486393660307, 0.010153690353035927, 0.03118681162595749, 0.047465626150369644, 0.053312599658966064, 0.0009991759434342384, 0.06656553596258163, 0.005494117271155119, -0.0024281626101583242, 0.021210309118032455, -0.014721488580107689, 0.033637240529060364, 0.07077311724424362, 0.031844232231378555, 0.026407359167933464, 0.001656872802414, 0.007221574429422617, 0.012469010427594185, 0.025667766109108925, 0.07144022732973099, 0.028332803398370743, -0.00861925259232521, -0.019009344279766083, -0.023862918838858604, 0.020438706502318382, 0.005499657243490219, 0.009948806837201118, -0.028982853516936302, 0.031467340886592865, -0.00882392656058073, 0.03812486305832863, -0.04248940572142601, 0.03057176060974598, 0.018742311745882034, 0.010734707117080688, -0.031743235886096954, 0.014388902112841606, -0.026553427800536156, -0.0907825455069542, -0.0022427563089877367, 0.011578320525586605, 0.05848756060004234, -0.03592101112008095, 0.009502806700766087, 0.01690720021724701, 0.00933565478771925, -0.0250422190874815, -0.0223712045699358, -0.07867299020290375, 0.028365856036543846, -0.08619596064090729, 0.01374004129320383, 0.016487322747707367, -0.016516901552677155, 0.016287801787257195, 0.04795060306787491, 0.0606461726129055, 0.03946227207779884, -0.014307591132819653, 0.021357357501983643, 0.005611053667962551, -0.03859669715166092, 0.02390255592763424, -0.006084086839109659, -0.07737427949905396, 0.017743902280926704, -0.044552385807037354, 0.06113552674651146, -0.03709784895181656, -0.10333598405122757, 0.03999214991927147, 0.03650471195578575, -0.005986414849758148, -0.07489049434661865, 0.009881196543574333, -0.022864945232868195, -0.057108074426651, 0.006318986415863037, -0.0029539703391492367, 0.02675141580402851, -0.025936566293239594, -0.03982590138912201, 0.06740473210811615, 0.03718377649784088, 0.06188385188579559, 0.042999181896448135, 0.023738006129860878, 0.02452503703534603, -0.00673831719905138, -0.000748649996239692, 0.021568922325968742, 0.006440226919949055, -0.0016281356802210212, -0.006138479802757502, 0.011738929897546768, 0.01537235639989376, 0.0031707927118986845, -0.014250103384256363, 0.025088747963309288, -0.06230755150318146, -0.01191557664424181, -0.013015381060540676, 0.04352712258696556, 0.013427350670099258, 0.002259502885863185, -0.02738063409924507, 0.05225036293268204, -0.060993462800979614, 0.01175242755562067, -0.078398197889328, 0.09973952919244766, -0.07761797308921814, -0.014733743853867054, 0.006383858155459166, -0.004302407149225473, 0.031035806983709335, 0.07292278856039047, -0.01752709597349167, -0.007727377116680145, 0.05092376470565796, 0.05193226784467697, 0.012226363644003868, -0.015304524451494217, -0.014414409175515175, 0.037224359810352325, -0.009620665572583675, -0.017384380102157593, -0.02233842760324478, -0.004921641666442156, 0.01344849169254303, 0.016418956220149994, -0.005991282872855663, 0.003952520899474621, -0.0027982057072222233, -0.04945996031165123, 0.044582296162843704, -0.016171840950846672, -0.01508626714348793, 0.01115056499838829, -0.0437382273375988, 0.02534020133316517, 0.012595024891197681, -0.033393532037734985, -0.02703150361776352, 0.028151491656899452, -0.028965769335627556, 0.0021889873314648867, 0.0016594736371189356, 0.029179660603404045, -0.011087845079600811, -0.07757332921028137, 0.006077075842767954, 0.08365654200315475, 0.003076838795095682, 0.007972941733896732, 0.006553194019943476, 0.047250501811504364, -0.045652274042367935, -0.01842144876718521, 0.033999428153038025, -0.04655537009239197, -0.00414262805134058, -0.012786772102117538, -0.020885637030005455, 0.012660590000450611, -0.013280232436954975, -0.05919903889298439, 0.02860824204981327, 0.04070599004626274, 0.03461698442697525, 0.06991764903068542, -0.07248998433351517, 0.04883996769785881, 0.0011638448340818286, 0.03312763571739197, -0.039405398070812225, -0.009345552884042263, -0.0120353102684021, -0.05821419507265091, -0.011058807373046875, 0.054474279284477234, -0.014538908377289772, -0.015932077541947365, -0.016654474660754204, 0.02163073979318142, 0.06936696916818619, 0.03862229362130165, -0.051254916936159134, -0.022429782897233963, -0.029966993257403374, 0.05014953762292862, -0.0371769517660141, -0.016940664499998093, 0.011878776364028454, -0.006618294399231672, -0.006079924292862415, 0.003696694504469633, -0.02732166461646557, 0.020142793655395508, -0.03341348096728325, 0.0017756830202415586, -0.06494299322366714, 0.034513939172029495, -0.041958875954151154, -0.025827139616012573, 0.026471706107258797, -0.006489875260740519, 0.04344144091010094, 0.007540208753198385, -0.024841826409101486, -0.010606308467686176, 0.006162948906421661, -0.026048600673675537, -0.009611467830836773, -0.03979865089058876, 0.009636688977479935, -0.07182137668132782, -0.03289534151554108, -0.022849172353744507, 0.03571585193276405, -0.009753982536494732, -0.006252845283597708, -0.03609536960721016, -0.053836844861507416, -0.004683130420744419, -0.04933108761906624, -0.049175962805747986, 0.025655614212155342, -0.025228479877114296, 0.010000336915254593, 0.0059434096328914165, 0.023950671777129173, -0.004908953793346882, -0.025191985070705414, -0.020880678668618202, -0.02916671335697174, 0.03380856290459633, 0.011165444739162922, 0.03992384299635887, 0.06704490631818771, 0.002902583684772253, 0.045909833163022995, -0.017299558967351913, -0.01094020064920187, -0.04419410973787308, -0.01023982185870409, -0.0006564052309840918, -0.009403624571859837, 0.0577893927693367, -0.020682569593191147, 0.008828717283904552, -0.06434964388608932, 0.0305852759629488, -0.03648179769515991, -0.02095440961420536, -0.00004893897857982665, -0.056132446974515915, 0.029692403972148895, -0.01799679920077324, -0.0768965408205986, 0.02783074416220188, -0.03289357200264931, 0.05620160326361656, -0.009516730904579163, 0.055354028940200806, 0.06951230764389038, 0.014283393509685993, -0.04926898330450058, -0.000331198243657127, 0.043281156569719315, -0.04041683301329613, 0.01629151590168476, -0.029699867591261864, -0.028346529230475426, 0.010807440616190434, 0.030663471668958664, -0.014624260365962982, -0.0030799400992691517, -0.013660751283168793, 0.0646766871213913, -0.018325146287679672, -0.010711933486163616, -0.04955644533038139, -0.025695977732539177, -0.007485156878829002, -0.01026814617216587, -0.00689843762665987, 0.0022705961018800735, -0.054519977420568466, -0.04220712557435036, -0.027030885219573975, 0.03432977944612503, 0.027671976014971733, 0.007163601461797953, -0.0399768091738224, -0.01819434203207493, 0.06705845147371292, -0.0186384879052639, -0.024036524817347527, 0.03271156921982765, 0.021532822400331497, 0.02087843418121338, 0.04272642731666565, -0.045345354825258255, -0.01343586016446352, 0.029746733605861664, 0.02388777956366539, 0.05632881820201874, -0.024738546460866928, -0.03458229824900627, -0.06365210562944412, 0.022250516340136528, 0.005503542721271515, 0.01467185840010643, 0.04739009588956833, -0.054241713136434555, -0.008023309521377087, -0.05212868005037308, 0.02480095811188221, 0.04096139594912529, 0.04406774789094925, 0.046326931565999985, -0.01227866392582655, 0.011298567056655884, -0.016588643193244934, 0.007727943826466799, 0.014676935039460659, 0.014059022068977356, -0.009552081115543842, -0.00826690997928381, -0.037305645644664764, -0.043740663677453995, 0.03868532553315163, -0.03520224988460541, -0.05760619044303894, -0.06774324923753738, -0.01757879927754402, -0.013990825042128563, 0.06093573570251465, 0.016830649226903915, 0.0074770525097846985, -0.06921236962080002, 0.0031695757061243057, -0.05261960253119469, -0.03622734546661377, 0.03631017729640007, 0.010900158435106277, -0.12288787215948105, -0.025773601606488228, -0.06508106738328934, -0.05674825236201286, -0.001955603249371052, -0.02244972623884678, 0.03816955164074898, 0.0198548324406147, -0.013838861137628555, -0.05080902948975563, -0.0035665284376591444, -0.018136041238904, -0.008613494224846363, -0.012115431018173695, -0.0009474981343373656, -0.055522385984659195, 0.06569261103868484, -0.014604444615542889, -0.009397288784384727, 0.04873719811439514, 0.024518363177776337, 0.08586442470550537, 0.01193452812731266, -0.05974792316555977, -0.03044738806784153, -0.01104676816612482, -0.01564856804907322, -0.00759207783266902, -0.01945694349706173, -0.04217962920665741, 0.027849623933434486, -0.008404908701777458, -0.04293033480644226, 0.022085266187787056, -0.04342266917228699, 0.022815432399511337, 0.026419734582304955, -0.03162692114710808, -0.0011318621691316366, -0.04046225547790527, 0.07334519922733307, -0.026381704956293106, -0.018231293186545372, 0.06993935257196426, 0.013260837644338608, -0.025933120399713516, -0.01568295806646347, -0.007319838739931583, 0.02645718678832054, -0.03361789509654045, -0.017935359850525856, -0.02331901527941227, -0.038267832249403, -0.08565852791070938, 0.026833821088075638, -0.0041284095495939255, 0.0006274342304095626, -0.004321458283811808, 0.034096796065568924, -0.008730624802410603, -0.0753820613026619, 0.032603632658720016, -0.014045852236449718, 0.05359145998954773, 0.004509882535785437, 0.05010339990258217, 0.014284507371485233, 0.0022100787609815598, 0.0035746784415096045, -0.07715176790952682, -0.0064252819865942, 0.013322592712938786, -0.021114753559231758, -0.013911143876612186, -0.05795198678970337, 0.024444781243801117, 0.00032412828295491636, 0.04413274675607681, 0.018303439021110535, 0.0016958321211859584, 0.06580006331205368, -0.04581141844391823, 0.030642131343483925, -0.002332160482183099, -0.00951449479907751, 0.01964050903916359, -0.03226258233189583, -0.04160606861114502, 0.0051166219636797905, -0.011813568882644176, 0.008926277980208397, -0.021836305037140846, 0.024134349077939987, 0.006048338953405619, 0.030928850173950195, 0.03611838072538376, -0.002003378001973033, -0.05285849794745445, 0.03324850648641586, 0.032281383872032166, -0.01906098611652851, -0.016165873035788536, 0.028784971684217453, 0.059956520795822144, -0.04259156808257103, -0.012390606105327606, 0.00534119363874197, -0.025554755702614784, -0.004617630969733, 0.0541025809943676, -0.025976546108722687, -0.04173395037651062, -0.05486194044351578, 0.01213004719465971, -0.02927960455417633, 0.033106088638305664, 0.059180304408073425, 0.030672989785671234, -0.07886792719364166, -0.009953032247722149, -0.040995098650455475, 0.0017340582562610507, 0.08312950283288956, -0.034793347120285034, -0.04753930866718292, 0.009875931777060032, -0.011016546748578548, -0.04409296438097954, 0.0026550607290118933, -0.053791292011737823, 0.06022468954324722, 0.05589870736002922, -0.013191405683755875, 0.008175242692232132, -0.00591771537438035, -0.019263392314314842, 0.04561414569616318, 0.002992326393723488, 0.005853341892361641, 0.05468186363577843, 0.002534023020416498, 0.0002488132449798286, -0.02122981660068035, 0.003085160395130515, -0.04190255329012871, 0.026778722181916237, -0.0603809617459774, 0.0110460314899683, -0.008333476260304451, -0.026401618495583534, -0.0998036116361618, 0.00042861595284193754, -0.0047061871737241745, -0.012043635360896587, 0.003239197190850973, -0.036236874759197235, -0.022102689370512962, -0.016774848103523254, 0.02008185163140297, 0.000806627213023603, -0.0017178818816319108, -0.02670682966709137, 0.03129182383418083, 0.01580253802239895, 0.038185007870197296, -0.0429411306977272, 0.03983260691165924, 0.060062311589717865, -0.015544870868325233, 0.0023057833313941956, -0.0801694467663765, 0.007843831554055214, 0.026494523510336876, -0.020788397639989853, 0.02161744423210621, 0.047235146164894104, 0.037762656807899475, 0.03351878002285957, -0.033474572002887726, -0.013219303451478481, 0.030142026022076607, -0.04316045343875885, -0.07680612057447433, -0.01083091739565134, -0.00673975283280015, 0.01627936214208603, -0.012157118879258633, 0.04475744441151619, -0.024568680673837662, 0.09012589603662491, 0.0810835063457489, 0.0008869722369126976, -0.028986705467104912, -0.020773425698280334, -0.04227111488580704, -0.010110614821314812, 0.004150158725678921, -0.08510415256023407, -0.012874380685389042, 0.009462696500122547, -0.007450031582266092, -0.018197761848568916, -0.03876815736293793, 0.006179482210427523, 0.032239507883787155, 0.013073647394776344, -0.025435077026486397, 0.06161380559206009, 0.03242935612797737, -0.03353186324238777, -0.025883547961711884, 0.06828498095273972, -0.041220229119062424, -0.026711076498031616, 0.018880730494856834, 0.03784723952412605, 0.008022998459637165, 0.05730544775724411, -0.006695517338812351, -0.006889795418828726, 0.012397143058478832, 0.003245583502575755, -0.004616851452738047, -0.03145197406411171, -0.036398615688085556, -0.051721230149269104, -0.021147042512893677, -0.013362953439354897, 0.020960474386811256, 0.04289904236793518, 0.07574129849672318, 0.03899279981851578, 0.02972852811217308, 0.06503212451934814, -0.026964236050844193, -0.01825380139052868, -0.022176481783390045, -0.058705464005470276, 0.013503377325832844, -0.021901695057749748, 0.02795632742345333, -0.03660391643643379, 0.020979229360818863, 0.021857943385839462, -0.00313023803755641, 0.03576909378170967, 0.011797615326941013, -0.007524183951318264, -0.03137270361185074, -0.032966624945402145, -0.002335803583264351, -0.025594357401132584, -0.02892480231821537, 0.0343630351126194, 0.01627454347908497, -0.02208203263580799, -0.02124141901731491, -0.00579338101670146, 0.0568600557744503, 0.014980894513428211, 0.034062325954437256, -0.010465183295309544, 0.0632665827870369, 0.01711897924542427, -0.0009007141343317926, 0.0032171395141631365, -0.03650500252842903, 0.004236129112541676, -0.003764290129765868, 0.054389502853155136, 0.0053628673776984215, 0.016444073989987373, 0.026126505807042122, 0.013446427881717682, 0.0463503859937191, -0.045516807585954666, 0.041502323001623154, -0.06310152262449265, -0.0015578942839056253, -0.034639012068510056, -0.004710697568953037, -0.00823163241147995, -0.04998764395713806, -0.007417560089379549, -0.08386614918708801, 0.059491172432899475, 0.03304068371653557, 0.0967240184545517, 0.07362000644207001, -0.04068148136138916, -0.017688609659671783, -0.011423545889556408, 0.0595005601644516, -0.03956180065870285, 0.03448111563920975, -0.0566302090883255, -0.025569379329681396, 0.0031363419257104397, -0.029863236472010612, -0.04112750664353371, -0.02768658474087715, 0.007851730100810528 ]
<p>I've been trying to find papers that list various properties of idealized cigarette smoke( ex. the molar mass, gas compressibility factor, density of smoke exiting a cigarette) but I have had very little luck.</p> <p>Does anyone know what these properties are or where I should be able to find them?</p> <p>I'm building a volumetric measurement tool for use in psychological studies in case anyone wonders why I'm looking for this information.</p> <p>I posted this question in chemistry.stackexchange first but I think physics is a better forum for it.</p>
g1657
[ -0.014424263499677181, -0.013719616457819939, -0.0012002589646726847, -0.0385499969124794, 0.01526318397372961, -0.075484499335289, -0.06375470012426376, 0.046256422996520996, -0.05567537620663643, 0.01184824202209711, 0.013020125217735767, -0.05338236689567566, 0.03052271530032158, 0.020220739766955376, 0.02400977723300457, -0.019033323973417282, -0.004215659108012915, -0.03460508584976196, 0.008110597729682922, 0.032365575432777405, -0.020636048167943954, -0.09026913344860077, 0.030871540307998657, -0.05105172097682953, -0.007776047568768263, -0.0031241560354828835, -0.0018244487000629306, -0.011852291412651539, -0.027147851884365082, -0.04301417991518974, 0.020284635946154594, 0.017421748489141464, -0.04044494405388832, -0.0283158328384161, -0.016021279618144035, 0.02304907888174057, -0.05761633813381195, -0.01768062263727188, 0.009201418608427048, -0.028159616515040398, 0.05344803258776665, -0.03326558321714401, 0.004229621030390263, 0.006732604466378689, -0.05652398243546486, 0.10424881428480148, -0.025067271664738655, 0.05357746779918671, -0.004418215248733759, 0.026726676151156425, -0.019000183790922165, 0.012626522220671177, -0.023495683446526527, 0.04823184013366699, 0.04129965975880623, 0.028732210397720337, 0.0468626394867897, -0.028139671310782433, 0.06901443749666214, -0.030045220628380775, -0.02501767687499523, -0.012048200704157352, -0.020301032811403275, -0.002652851166203618, 0.0408446341753006, -0.03702318295836449, -0.028515102341771126, -0.0234377384185791, 0.02649029530584812, -0.0010554918553680182, 0.04622300714254379, 0.00832957774400711, -0.011806528083980083, -0.012541770935058594, -0.017264794558286667, -0.01627325639128685, 0.012462745420634747, 0.003956605214625597, 0.03257405757904053, 0.004602139350026846, 0.008566636592149734, -0.016660280525684357, 0.06259509921073914, -0.03298993781208992, 0.0813656821846962, -0.005164507310837507, 0.028858909383416176, -0.05101601779460907, 0.0706704780459404, -0.032885655760765076, -0.03428180515766144, -0.008748284541070461, 0.10721713304519653, -0.007248896174132824, 0.02257511205971241, 0.0025023422203958035, 0.010557618923485279, 0.03422657772898674, -0.06045430153608322, -0.021597305312752724, 0.01782362163066864, -0.06904095411300659, 0.06387479603290558, 0.043918125331401825, -0.03275500237941742, 0.04452989622950554, -0.0018103648908436298, -0.008988240733742714, -0.025341251865029335, -0.016004500910639763, -0.08840677887201309, 0.033385854214429855, -0.06679210811853409, -0.023287836462259293, -0.040364690124988556, -0.0447000116109848, 0.04542133957147598, 0.00369387143291533, 0.05282337963581085, 0.06747953593730927, 0.021588260307908058, 0.0048636263236403465, 0.012495887465775013, -0.01635359786450863, -0.0056855143047869205, 0.005868685431778431, 0.0011496612569317222, -0.021236509084701538, -0.0378749705851078, -0.054112471640110016, 0.031076300889253616, -0.012416994199156761, -0.025871068239212036, -0.008837827481329441, 0.02644064649939537, -0.018606960773468018, -0.013346202671527863, 0.052931517362594604, 0.014967980794608593, 0.022632597014307976, 0.08878017216920853, 0.046159449964761734, -0.009022623300552368, 0.0407547764480114, -0.04915877804160118, -0.036650996655225754, -0.010977649129927158, 0.06184901297092438, 0.006221326999366283, -0.014709430746734142, 0.057334933429956436, -0.01556712668389082, 0.006292024161666632, -0.03425320237874985, -0.03386903926730156, -0.04032338038086891, -0.039574217051267624, 0.008744967170059681, -0.014931447803974152, -0.018039464950561523, -0.036206793040037155, -0.03187960758805275, -0.03860212489962578, -0.0007535418262705207, -0.004170204047113657, 0.013068325817584991, -0.0051022302359342575, -0.03679317235946655, 0.0005810187431052327, -0.04750160872936249, -0.028610510751605034, 0.0472591258585453, -0.031565435230731964, 0.08825718611478806, -0.011761940084397793, -0.0025297331158071756, 0.06558740139007568, 0.06424226611852646, 0.012748613953590393, -0.017636852338910103, 0.007350766099989414, -0.017647888511419296, -0.004888181574642658, -0.030842620879411697, 0.0021208422258496284, -0.0392693467438221, 0.02695462293922901, -0.051884885877370834, -0.042747706174850464, 0.027348844334483147, -0.029182910919189453, 0.007852096110582352, 0.017939802259206772, -0.03355390578508377, -0.01970498450100422, -0.021327663213014603, 0.060095470398664474, -0.005694306921213865, -0.002201976254582405, -0.034201543778181076, -0.04194941371679306, 0.02097879722714424, 0.033783234655857086, -0.002504310104995966, -0.042869001626968384, 0.021074708551168442, -0.008669097907841206, 0.06416760385036469, 0.04468655213713646, -0.0009883356979116797, -0.04432361200451851, -0.03933584317564964, 0.05312585458159447, -0.013022022321820259, 0.021849580109119415, 0.018883109092712402, -0.014337080530822277, -0.006212566513568163, -0.0054166573099792, -0.01276618242263794, 0.021713076159358025, -0.06219589710235596, -0.05037544295191765, 0.05406172573566437, 0.024667007848620415, -0.07288698107004166, -0.0007998507935553789, -0.029970262199640274, 0.04733032360672951, 0.0008086039451882243, -0.06378825008869171, 0.03830165043473244, 0.02681201882660389, 0.015120633877813816, -0.010446448810398579, 0.07530289888381958, -0.04558776319026947, -0.027657460421323776, 0.04649060592055321, -0.007472360972315073, 0.013212335295975208, -0.0016879671020433307, -0.00990880187600851, 0.025824232026934624, 0.02364981919527054, -0.12062472105026245, -0.04708993434906006, -0.02544521540403366, 0.05784998834133148, 0.03515703231096268, -0.05966200307011604, 0.026179315522313118, -0.014118216000497341, -0.014545812271535397, -0.02153361216187477, -0.013705790974199772, 0.03874585032463074, -0.008112072013318539, -0.030059853568673134, 0.033635206520557404, 0.022688105702400208, -0.02903793193399906, -0.014863812364637852, -0.02478347346186638, -0.03228137642145157, -0.03078983910381794, -0.026249872520565987, -0.029613282531499863, -0.03993362933397293, -0.0005669278907589614, 0.05437048152089119, -0.010228151455521584, 0.013047439977526665, -0.0235160980373621, 0.023207176476716995, -0.018650449812412262, -0.02076338231563568, -0.028309019282460213, -0.008259378373622894, 0.003715741215273738, 0.006506923120468855, 0.019502248615026474, -0.05491240695118904, 0.060078512877225876, 0.028883349150419235, -0.02119031921029091, -0.018888626247644424, 0.03307943046092987, -0.025537043809890747, -0.01528525073081255, -0.010404826141893864, 0.029649287462234497, 0.03096664696931839, -0.034798890352249146, 0.005211526993662119, 0.0585920475423336, -0.022867392748594284, -0.014910317026078701, -0.022619808092713356, -0.009257817640900612, 0.03817325830459595, 0.00975329615175724, 0.03415679931640625, -0.06942550092935562, -0.06960834562778473, 0.06154944747686386, -0.035578180104494095, 0.020266374573111534, -0.013564599677920341, 0.015490278601646423, -0.019291851669549942, -0.0017340023769065738, -0.02478943020105362, 0.018917996436357498, 0.00581563264131546, 0.006328642833977938, 0.07891369611024857, 0.04369080811738968, -0.028104934841394424, -0.006408231798559427, 0.01075053308159113, -0.028880206868052483, 0.016230996698141098, 0.00020377233158797026, 0.0918920487165451, -0.02135578542947769, -0.02359294518828392, -0.012278983369469643, 0.02463674359023571, -0.003612842410802841, 0.04650741443037987, 0.030321763828396797, 0.0075022210367023945, -0.03250909224152565, -0.0443270280957222, -0.0018117473227903247, -0.02091062441468239, 0.011237271130084991, 0.06297001242637634, -0.060286227613687515, 0.04510892182588577, -0.03086218424141407, -0.0016716222744435072, -0.020494084805250168, -0.006134301424026489, -0.012131312862038612, 0.012617838568985462, -0.004144537262618542, 0.07066745311021805, -0.003598084906116128, 0.014256451278924942, -0.030480895191431046, -0.003183890599757433, -0.030923351645469666, 0.024112341925501823, 0.0027162134647369385, 0.0006316907820291817, -0.04226275533437729, 0.02377396449446678, 0.01720200665295124, -0.060456059873104095, -0.032503508031368256, 0.03647719323635101, -0.007956665009260178, -0.04466262832283974, -0.03326060250401497, 0.015967577695846558, 0.04566776752471924, 0.006538086105138063, 0.016317857429385185, 0.029104433953762054, 0.022137995809316635, -0.018131345510482788, 0.018165897578001022, 0.020114222541451454, -0.020890595391392708, -0.01621650531888008, 0.010296778753399849, -0.05710986256599426, 0.018298955634236336, 0.01916583813726902, 0.04054752737283707, 0.01238334458321333, 0.03482240065932274, -0.0026456459891051054, -0.020175855606794357, -0.06936076283454895, 0.057736191898584366, 0.02859499864280224, -0.052218351513147354, -0.03514845669269562, -0.0017008645227178931, -0.07264676690101624, 0.011687953025102615, 0.03160363808274269, 0.015331560745835304, -0.02685563452541828, -0.009298496879637241, 0.01184977125376463, 0.03568043187260628, 0.021196113899350166, 0.04383843392133713, 0.02623644843697548, -0.015306998044252396, -0.038388609886169434, 0.05718841776251793, 0.027677366510033607, 0.01273356843739748, 0.0058531747199594975, -0.040472760796546936, -0.010104459710419178, 0.05281776934862137, 0.007068928796797991, -0.00893464870750904, -0.004544055089354515, 0.06507738679647446, 0.02132079005241394, -0.02265126258134842, 0.03721104562282562, 0.012305114418268204, -0.0009054767433553934, 0.0021063804160803556, -0.016685135662555695, -0.03817664831876755, -0.01565321534872055, 0.024107815697789192, 0.048085618764162064, -0.004852708429098129, 0.03223792463541031, 0.019690165296196938, 0.06331899017095566, -0.05927377566695213, 0.035450324416160583, 0.06724380701780319, -0.006762148812413216, 0.04536477103829384, 0.0011459573870524764, 0.011163543909788132, -0.03724728524684906, 0.021170059219002724, -0.0315905436873436, 0.0025000968016684055, 0.086940698325634, -0.051545631140470505, 0.012225648388266563, -0.000050511986046331, -0.0545007698237896, 0.04010807350277901, -0.08244319260120392, 0.03190690651535988, 0.019412079825997353, -0.03361716866493225, -0.06122201308608055, -0.0285123810172081, -0.032534997910261154, -0.013415682129561901, 0.02565840445458889, 0.04574928805232048, 0.055599622428417206, 0.014891899190843105, -0.0013489683624356985, -0.019790520891547203, 0.015857556834816933, 0.010105208493769169, -0.04797343164682388, 0.05398775264620781, -0.032675255089998245, 0.031572770327329636, -0.005455355159938335, 0.06561876833438873, -0.07009367644786835, 0.0038601227570325136, 0.014933543279767036, 0.0350337028503418, 0.0012571749975904822, 0.055186718702316284, -0.019323108717799187, -0.007492964621633291, -0.07211562246084213, -0.026756519451737404, 0.014967921189963818, 0.0499911867082119, 0.005186798050999641, 0.0025760685093700886, -0.0043638041242957115, 0.0010979017242789268, -0.017698107287287712, -0.0020716397557407618, 0.012973674573004246, -0.06091245263814926, -0.0010629486059769988, 0.08493039757013321, 0.018437989056110382, -0.026181267574429512, -0.0019767337944358587, -0.015398262068629265, 0.02072908729314804, 0.025762317702174187, 0.01054280623793602, -0.015135863795876503, 0.02319956384599209, 0.007218861021101475, -0.02155081182718277, -0.00937617290765047, -0.0265645794570446, 0.018949046730995178, -0.00006883011519676074, -0.027627399191260338, -0.04176856949925423, -0.030580347403883934, -0.0038957346696406603, 0.0289657860994339, 0.002225391333922744, 0.018660932779312134, -0.013102388940751553, 0.03707730397582054, -0.011037404648959637, 0.02187991514801979, 0.048047833144664764, -0.01076563447713852, 0.005356611218303442, -0.004181804601103067, 0.03644959256052971, 0.03403019905090332, 0.006917817518115044, 0.01902982033789158, -0.01856597140431404, -0.07336415350437164, 0.051531560719013214, 0.03601599112153053, -0.04359084740281105, 0.008720778860151768, 0.06374309957027435, -0.02994658797979355, -0.08149231970310211, -0.004687150940299034, 0.009753391146659851, 0.020545605570077896, 0.012571089901030064, 0.046778157353401184, -0.0317564383149147, -0.013202995993196964, -0.08479287475347519, 0.04254033789038658, 0.09256594628095627, -0.032191287726163864, 0.049196191132068634, -0.036567457020282745, 0.02078297920525074, 0.020748209208250046, -0.0536922961473465, 0.017831899225711823, 0.0197299737483263, -0.02192685939371586, 0.025445325300097466, -0.0035436127800494432, -0.00798146240413189, 0.031950801610946655, 0.008402612060308456, -0.012102046981453896, -0.04526784271001816, 0.028134802356362343, -0.004235118627548218, -0.002851649187505245, 0.028636043891310692, -0.04829099029302597, -0.01161778625100851, -0.007538427598774433, 0.034959807991981506, 0.054456841200590134, -0.02499239146709442, -0.0070382836274802685, 0.06950858235359192, 0.011183982715010643, 0.01950363628566265, -0.024606559425592422, 0.03726659715175629, -0.011353139765560627, 0.010157465003430843, 0.03599996492266655, 0.056281477212905884, 0.013987477868795395, 0.04332862049341202, -0.0363236740231514, -0.0025193437468260527, -0.029006879776716232, -0.006142063066363335, 0.022703303024172783, -0.056951943784952164, -0.006931520067155361, 0.04768221452832222, 0.029015380889177322, -0.0010365054477006197, -0.053766701370477676, 0.03221968188881874, -0.018578778952360153, 0.016354676336050034, 0.031436942517757416, -0.061850760132074356, -0.006583453621715307, -0.0042752609588205814, 0.00799668487161398, -0.064690001308918, -0.03075399063527584, 0.02596106007695198, 0.06344428658485413, 0.035068679600954056, 0.01171373762190342, -0.04141218960285187, -0.02891293726861477, -0.08457113057374954, 0.03588562831282616, -0.0332518145442009, -0.0035187809262424707, 0.01473693735897541, -0.015306277200579643, 0.020558545365929604, 0.016948137432336807, -0.004170137923210859, -0.050267595797777176, -0.03414957597851753, 0.019839705899357796, 0.09330914914608002, -0.0021057012490928173, -0.0009822392603382468, 0.013194616883993149, -0.005308237392455339, 0.043519534170627594, -0.00569258164614439, -0.0613853856921196, 0.02539259009063244, -0.007484603673219681, 0.0795290395617485, 0.012616865336894989, -0.01087008323520422, 0.006564126815646887, -0.07226022332906723, -0.009456881321966648, 0.058564286679029465, -0.014178640209138393, 0.002709857653826475, -0.022480497136712074, -0.0056783840991556644, 0.04655572026968002, -0.053947705775499344, -0.02022911049425602, 0.008412071503698826, -0.010838901624083519, 0.025108078494668007, -0.02438245713710785, 0.04896992817521095, -0.053207673132419586, 0.018602751195430756, 0.05088365823030472, -0.07074694335460663, 0.007357880473136902, 0.03654146194458008, -0.09826065599918365, 0.02485300414264202, -0.021381357684731483, -0.036669205874204636, -0.022526608780026436, 0.04853571578860283, 0.019442807883024216, -0.04491225630044937, 0.05613568052649498, 0.08354469388723373, -0.009225440211594105, -0.02234463393688202, -0.04252978786826134, 0.00481892516836524, -0.022206129506230354, -0.04466809332370758, -0.01164072472602129, -0.008935848250985146, -0.0215864609926939, -0.04311072453856468, 0.04501406103372574, 0.08970028162002563, -0.06825630366802216, -0.02141793631017208, 0.049171965569257736, -0.033310625702142715, 0.010716247372329235, -0.00940655916929245, 0.028696076944470406, -0.03476272523403168, 0.011337514966726303, 0.03562512248754501, 0.04884110391139984, 0.008628985844552517, -0.04661975055932999, 0.03259643167257309, -0.09282470494508743, -0.0009427933837287128, 0.04396871477365494, 0.059605829417705536, -0.022733477875590324, -0.04184611141681671, -0.012511144392192364, 0.04517674818634987, -0.045136939734220505, -0.02484958991408348, -0.03965522721409798, -0.005941292271018028, -0.020445307716727257, 0.00047648660256527364, 0.06660666316747665, -0.07457444816827774, 0.003914876375347376, 0.03384663164615631, -0.015909431502223015, 0.03153255954384804, 0.020582489669322968, 0.04356454685330391, -0.014139918610453606, -0.10106805711984634, 0.011430403217673302, 0.01618940383195877, 0.049078021198511124, -0.023979566991329193, -0.013787811622023582, 0.031263723969459534, 0.0016524487873539329, 0.05635323002934456, -0.05947650969028473, -0.047033172100782394, 0.05293469876050949, -0.00045919540571048856, 0.013906245119869709, -0.006662335712462664, 0.005342080257833004, 0.021877937018871307, -0.04281390830874443, -0.03171241283416748, 0.033259209245443344, 0.07996608316898346, 0.010001552291214466, -0.02085871808230877, 0.01604033075273037, 0.01794975996017456, 0.033584073185920715, 0.005423347000032663, -0.009958509355783463, 0.03606313467025757, -0.1298111379146576, -0.05973539501428604, 0.029083630070090294, -0.011010442860424519, 0.0010786409256979823, -0.018204668536782265, 0.02251116745173931, 0.01357282791286707, 0.004897895269095898, 0.003826780477538705, -0.07774101197719574, 0.04519035294651985, -0.0018148168455809355, -0.023795180022716522, -0.016084028407931328, 0.024685725569725037, 0.03175077214837074, 0.017202090471982956, 0.014262504875659943, -0.02715984173119068, -0.036876074969768524, 0.033719539642333984, -0.008921302855014801 ]
<p>I would like some help to find</p> <p>good and detailed books on the history of physics.</p> <p>Which are the classics in this domain? Which are your favorite?</p>
g1658
[ 0.07707329839468002, 0.07755988091230392, 0.011131269857287407, -0.011760792694985867, 0.020954567939043045, -0.015862885862588882, -0.002216748660430312, 0.011543193832039833, 0.00888369046151638, 0.04553117975592613, 0.017080144956707954, -0.0024897053372114897, -0.01520973164588213, -0.045080043375492096, 0.004755746107548475, -0.0663691908121109, -0.0017546996241435409, 0.06784025579690933, 0.017874328419566154, 0.012996485456824303, 0.02615472860634327, -0.003124072216451168, 0.03081340342760086, -0.028822289779782295, -0.06872905790805817, -0.016526561230421066, -0.04399094730615616, -0.08774017542600632, 0.009857160970568657, -0.03856870159506798, -0.009854990057647228, 0.007780483458191156, -0.005278458818793297, -0.016729747876524925, 0.06834737211465836, -0.011450715363025665, 0.00183679920155555, 0.004019676707684994, 0.03915190324187279, 0.03283844515681267, 0.038535941392183304, -0.03490123152732849, 0.01067220326513052, -0.020139947533607483, 0.05913051217794418, 0.009008902125060558, -0.025622325018048286, -0.015040269121527672, -0.044533468782901764, 0.03345000371336937, -0.019950054585933685, 0.06376398354768753, 0.010232389904558659, 0.011106393299996853, 0.012766718864440918, 0.006334911100566387, 0.010713144205510616, 0.030800603330135345, 0.07185687869787216, -0.04182560741901398, -0.01885509490966797, 0.017911380156874657, -0.0025764969177544117, -0.07503142207860947, 0.017014700919389725, 0.012430349364876747, 0.010883673094213009, -0.02995207905769348, 0.044245246797800064, 0.017383839935064316, 0.002138144336640835, -0.0247157234698534, -0.015380592085421085, 0.004885539878159761, 0.0016426054062321782, -0.01071956381201744, 0.0012308937730267644, -0.00382381328381598, 0.02204722724854946, -0.009691913612186909, -0.004140270408242941, 0.00006860787834739313, 0.029153766110539436, -0.008095522411167622, 0.06692850589752197, -0.0005586282350122929, -0.04593914374709129, 0.025659523904323578, -0.039877962321043015, -0.07368817925453186, -0.05374664440751076, -0.014884857460856438, 0.06923115253448486, -0.017367923632264137, -0.03228349611163139, -0.0318170003592968, 0.023379111662507057, 0.005607025232166052, -0.0021247316617518663, 0.04266798868775368, -0.03804774582386017, -0.051401082426309586, 0.09203596413135529, 0.022281145676970482, 0.00029089825693517923, -0.012251071631908417, 0.014571239240467548, -0.017641324549913406, -0.011500546708703041, 0.029203001409769058, -0.015455195680260658, -0.01718008890748024, -0.004295962862670422, -0.0013225981965661049, -0.04485616832971573, 0.030313676223158836, 0.06382754445075989, -0.02612925134599209, -0.027484701946377754, 0.029522990807890892, 0.006079126615077257, 0.03136095404624939, 0.014921808615326881, -0.017165761440992355, -0.0414111502468586, -0.029113788157701492, -0.0025467907544225454, -0.04015312343835831, 0.023679595440626144, -0.03554515168070793, 0.03126470744609833, -0.014186843298375607, -0.08226068317890167, 0.012191930785775185, -0.034297432750463486, 0.05900287628173828, 0.015045424923300743, 0.024188607931137085, 0.03019922599196434, -0.008357220329344273, 0.06465882062911987, -0.008788072504103184, 0.035372547805309296, -0.013421814888715744, 0.04209168627858162, 0.02465769089758396, -0.03615930676460266, -0.05467545986175537, 0.002504561096429825, 0.00019515449821483344, 0.006471356377005577, 0.03407865762710571, -0.05309556424617767, 0.017690736800432205, 0.01450514979660511, 0.03097454458475113, 0.04894232377409935, -0.002503064228221774, 0.021004807204008102, -0.030045945197343826, -0.03135215863585472, -0.0200809258967638, -0.06271403282880783, 0.01733626239001751, 0.014765814878046513, 0.053770512342453, 0.0014123665168881416, -0.09499617666006088, 0.034312859177589417, 0.0682469829916954, -0.026026876643300056, 0.025301311165094376, 0.04616576060652733, 0.07915830612182617, -0.04239428788423538, -0.015922974795103073, 0.042039014399051666, -0.038035646080970764, 0.019293606281280518, 0.009650553576648235, -0.05462197959423065, -0.02327781729400158, 0.025551574304699898, 0.03268380090594292, -0.06537354737520218, 0.0654524490237236, -0.022805968299508095, 0.01115124486386776, -0.0858420729637146, -0.014477676711976528, -0.04306728392839432, 0.0007128126453608274, -0.003959544934332371, 0.01670175790786743, 0.008605861105024815, -0.005503604654222727, -0.002337951445952058, -0.020777467638254166, -0.014756989665329456, 0.019578706473112106, 0.02171396277844906, 0.031363293528556824, 0.07389936596155167, 0.041737254709005356, -0.02772117778658867, -0.03666633367538452, 0.039364662021398544, 0.0047131311148405075, -0.02319285087287426, -0.013902800157666206, -0.06559369713068008, 0.06072131171822548, 0.06035077944397926, -0.01304207555949688, -0.005306493956595659, -0.047941531985998154, -0.017292547971010208, -0.026052705943584442, 0.018776576966047287, 0.01584791950881481, -0.07971279323101044, 0.010997704230248928, -0.0412149578332901, -0.02359023131430149, 0.016469892114400864, -0.025805752724409103, 0.046781986951828, -0.02614428475499153, 0.00726463133469224, -0.022628743201494217, -0.09799131751060486, -0.009102443233132362, -0.017127741128206253, -0.010005203075706959, 0.057538121938705444, 0.028982141986489296, -0.015869811177253723, -0.017433874309062958, 0.049215640872716904, -0.01192434411495924, -0.02325349487364292, -0.028087174519896507, 0.00438673747703433, -0.0769878476858139, -0.00813969224691391, -0.06949310004711151, -0.023193910717964172, -0.052373193204402924, -0.030741237103939056, -0.03293664753437042, 0.038619644939899445, -0.0409029982984066, -0.037115372717380524, 0.0024331151507794857, -0.03240710496902466, 0.02457241341471672, 0.009132522158324718, 0.019871126860380173, -0.0654679387807846, -0.08572385460138321, -0.04377390816807747, 0.017575018107891083, -0.013366234488785267, 0.012742758728563786, 0.02044133096933365, -0.015364899300038815, -0.017673788592219353, -0.03262116760015488, -0.026922963559627533, -0.0321003682911396, 0.05333269387483597, 0.051721200346946716, 0.03504466265439987, -0.05913478136062622, 0.041977658867836, 0.023787878453731537, -0.006459178868681192, 0.04798520356416702, -0.01621834933757782, -0.05094796046614647, -0.006662188563495874, -0.014915768057107925, 0.045122724026441574, -0.003046152414754033, 0.0355091355741024, -0.08673924952745438, -0.061206091195344925, -0.03401295095682144, 0.005826927721500397, -0.03859446570277214, 0.0063853999599814415, 0.06203819438815117, 0.025036746636033058, -0.04746977239847183, -0.025933414697647095, 0.053688906133174896, -0.0006665154942311347, -0.03359784558415413, -0.08361946791410446, -0.003835325362160802, 0.024033188819885254, -0.036749888211488724, 0.01792168989777565, 0.018139703199267387, 0.006116213742643595, -0.0450386181473732, -0.04785056412220001, 0.03393467143177986, -0.0035344765055924654, 0.023350097239017487, 0.024910880252718925, 0.032006192952394485, 0.029047207906842232, 0.0412474125623703, -0.05523126572370529, 0.016789115965366364, 0.05705060064792633, 0.011954469606280327, -0.0070787593722343445, -0.06119919568300247, -0.03619471564888954, 0.01981360651552677, 0.0692630261182785, -0.05183698609471321, 0.039408400654792786, 0.05391240492463112, 0.01947556808590889, -0.02981976419687271, 0.0016924284864217043, 0.014843184500932693, 0.01562147494405508, -0.06175938993692398, 0.020954685285687447, 0.002093279268592596, -0.07186280190944672, -0.020573914051055908, -0.029547734186053276, -0.030853960663080215, -0.01994701847434044, 0.028053043410182, 0.011864748783409595, -0.0010921868961304426, -0.05258692428469658, -0.00553236436098814, -0.038038209080696106, 0.03662899509072304, -0.019721530377864838, 0.017119858413934708, 0.02660844475030899, -0.037175580859184265, 0.05782105028629303, 0.019633250311017036, -0.01053970493376255, -0.007605280261486769, -0.057717494666576385, 0.04220139607787132, 0.0560106486082077, -0.016656892374157906, 0.020826715975999832, -0.005786740221083164, -0.06999548524618149, 0.04875887557864189, -0.005807981826364994, 0.013402530923485756, -0.05705117806792259, 0.021913042291998863, -0.0339055061340332, -0.013744484633207321, -0.013129078783094883, -0.012511597014963627, 0.005019505508244038, 0.013277526013553143, 0.003488269168883562, 0.009357703849673271, -0.015821682289242744, -0.028412941843271255, 0.006682003848254681, 0.03436366096138954, -0.0687180906534195, -0.007625428028404713, 0.006644984241575003, -0.0024521383456885815, 0.044505804777145386, 0.06483792513608932, 0.027382362633943558, -0.010336823761463165, 0.03633620962500572, -0.03198742866516113, -0.006364739965647459, -0.015092790126800537, 0.0589958131313324, -0.01601957529783249, -0.057925619184970856, 0.05278950184583664, -0.00414296705275774, 0.01625046879053116, 0.013460559770464897, 0.044095057994127274, -0.04614517092704773, 0.005640397779643536, -0.025810400024056435, 0.017780492082238197, -0.01191757246851921, 0.015038636513054371, 0.04035177826881409, 0.07435809075832367, 0.02529519982635975, -0.03457337245345116, 0.012877465225756168, -0.0026419467758387327, 0.013402635231614113, -0.027580831199884415, 0.005415451247245073, -0.03945749253034592, -0.009655199013650417, 0.00851414818316698, -0.0026021155063062906, -0.07694254070520401, 0.04052377864718437, -0.023865489289164543, -0.03535199537873268, 0.05702296271920204, 0.006143794395029545, -0.05914006009697914, 0.0012900694273412228, -0.015458913519978523, 0.020797248929739, -0.025923533365130424, -0.00923253782093525, 0.05735093355178833, 0.016337476670742035, -0.024566011503338814, 0.005891694221645594, 0.04524457827210426, 0.008485952392220497, -0.021348565816879272, 0.02210264652967453, 0.00039352921885438263, 0.002224968746304512, 0.029623722657561302, 0.04811803251504898, -0.008825395256280899, 0.007028993684798479, -0.008221341297030449, -0.038065169006586075, 0.052910223603248596, -0.0012280622031539679, 0.05757330730557442, -0.011310347355902195, -0.002841444918885827, -0.010292659513652325, 0.015078668482601643, -0.04141142964363098, 0.04900320619344711, -0.0458720326423645, 0.030366020277142525, -0.009358189068734646, -0.05599680915474892, 0.04101363569498062, 0.013449681922793388, -0.01676826737821102, 0.050559766590595245, -0.00145142269320786, 0.05245029181241989, -0.02585921436548233, -0.04952468350529671, -0.030822742730379105, -0.02807915024459362, -0.056106165051460266, -0.034635357558727264, 0.048933301120996475, -0.005578967276960611, 0.03671194985508919, -0.010924828238785267, 0.03207362815737724, 0.03255567327141762, -0.004456283058971167, 0.02379392832517624, -0.018440373241901398, 0.03371847793459892, 0.027833977714180946, -0.009666024707257748, -0.0284271240234375, -0.005021880846470594, 0.02330111339688301, -0.02422318235039711, 0.01845654658973217, 0.05833296477794647, 0.027552668005228043, -0.06985896080732346, -0.001082591013982892, -0.012523135170340538, 0.07447635382413864, -0.05486385151743889, -0.03597588837146759, -0.0605289489030838, 0.046510376036167145, 0.030245043337345123, 0.04305865243077278, 0.036265961825847626, 0.007701611611992121, 0.004523147363215685, -0.05448267236351967, 0.002356596291065216, 0.02224368043243885, 0.0025200946256518364, 0.010122353211045265, 0.04455699399113655, -0.062009476125240326, -0.014985396526753902, -0.006786812096834183, 0.027178248390555382, 0.02602321468293667, 0.024104002863168716, -0.009499379433691502, 0.009900922887027264, 0.028505781665444374, 0.018234504386782646, -0.023885734379291534, -0.009447267279028893, -0.043822091072797775, -0.030449815094470978, 0.052650291472673416, -0.0034600330982357264, 0.0536486878991127, 0.04728628695011139, -0.06180226430296898, -0.008435435593128204, 0.042859502136707306, -0.014467296190559864, -0.02146945521235466, -0.030295725911855698, 0.03256300464272499, -0.045232534408569336, -0.06711187213659286, 0.007358966860920191, 0.007097342517226934, 0.004087220411747694, -0.041957687586545944, 0.05306904762983322, -0.04993043839931488, -0.003295749658718705, -0.015829142183065414, 0.0071713742800056934, 0.006104229483753443, 0.047094203531742096, 0.06381998211145401, 0.020729947835206985, 0.03875744342803955, -0.03756159916520119, 0.005539156496524811, 0.01714031770825386, -0.06602757424116135, -0.0515727661550045, -0.023175831884145737, 0.012072669342160225, 0.0050056492909789085, 0.008076516911387444, 0.03188445046544075, 0.010223359800875187, -0.017174622043967247, -0.03609052300453186, 0.003874011104926467, -0.011439047753810883, -0.07304374128580093, -0.0025018814485520124, -0.010126270353794098, -0.08684050291776657, 0.049461398273706436, 0.012349501252174377, -0.005355243105441332, -0.010905247181653976, -0.03185873106122017, -0.010788680985569954, 0.03583968058228493, 0.05454186350107193, -0.041577208787202835, -0.04862022027373314, 0.015215737745165825, 0.010318053886294365, -0.005700173322111368, 0.024959636852145195, 0.016254806891083717, -0.05099604278802872, -0.008331581950187683, -0.012841539457440376, -0.015101714991033077, 0.03895718231797218, -0.04927728325128555, 0.007361709140241146, 0.04600903391838074, 0.0059214746579527855, -0.009020392782986164, -0.051559872925281525, -0.004357600584626198, -0.040423568338155746, 0.016416402533650398, 0.06990639865398407, -0.020145965740084648, 0.01935419626533985, 0.011078833602368832, -0.02924591675400734, 0.024895818904042244, 0.02623407170176506, 0.028314903378486633, 0.0074701933190226555, 0.04279400035738945, -0.03012853115797043, 0.02724984474480152, 0.036753300577402115, -0.00915500894188881, 0.03157544881105423, -0.05492234230041504, -0.053878460079431534, -0.05855678766965866, -0.04145616292953491, 0.02921224944293499, 0.02960563451051712, 0.031314682215452194, -0.048039648681879044, 0.0169527605175972, 0.045733492821455, 0.04636691138148308, -0.04264545068144798, 0.02977679669857025, 0.015999341383576393, -0.0004974185139872134, 0.05615011230111122, 0.03829837217926979, -0.03974325209856033, 0.014807521365582943, 0.029622329398989677, 0.02386007271707058, 0.05803191289305687, -0.016420064494013786, 0.05336141958832741, -0.030051803216338158, -0.029382875189185143, -0.026138655841350555, -0.005880373530089855, 0.032880496233701706, -0.0006057795253582299, 0.0435199998319149, -0.01334924902766943, -0.031025277450680733, -0.051460668444633484, -0.04879944026470184, -0.02967648394405842, -0.03479854390025139, 0.03204347938299179, 0.05544058233499527, 0.029750021174550056, 0.000021565219867625274, 0.0023912035394459963, -0.008471197448670864, 0.0007562913233414292, 0.07184895128011703, 0.05102600157260895, 0.03157905861735344, -0.058456674218177795, 0.029684558510780334, 0.009024116210639477, -0.016667211428284645, 0.011023066937923431, -0.017333580181002617, 0.11685160547494888, 0.011109160259366035, 0.0025802745949476957, 0.002019922249019146, 0.012201180681586266, 0.01476366352289915, 0.057307787239551544, -0.07069937884807587, -0.003413492813706398, 0.026275958865880966, -0.011624624021351337, -0.009522248059511185, -0.012315087951719761, 0.05327324941754341, -0.04539661481976509, 0.005965364631265402, 0.04849262908101082, -0.05392484739422798, -0.02986743114888668, -0.04402649402618408, 0.041742052882909775, -0.022463751956820488, -0.04577537998557091, 0.09852305054664612, 0.035051971673965454, -0.02798389084637165, -0.02005521021783352, 0.02514040842652321, -0.08067285269498825, -0.0009911470115184784, -0.04447583109140396, 0.05226654186844826, -0.045387182384729385, -0.0142407501116395, -0.046542830765247345, -0.011999784968793392, 0.013878434896469116, -0.0020490428432822227, 0.00033357192296534777, -0.015412344597280025, -0.00043220058432780206, -0.018579285591840744, 0.01252095028758049, 0.011351394467055798, 0.10622919350862503, -0.023074783384799957, 0.01777062565088272, 0.04499426484107971, -0.024553243070840836, 0.044434309005737305, 0.044888686388731, -0.023078925907611847, 0.05292941629886627, -0.04210347682237625, -0.014424050226807594, -0.005451733246445656, -0.04303435608744621, -0.014580070041120052, -0.028256935998797417, -0.019450979307293892, 0.006570159457623959, -0.0068122209049761295, -0.002871520584449172, -0.05076117813587189, 0.046379219740629196, 0.03308209031820297, 0.0023053993936628103, -0.026671700179576874, 0.009950630366802216, -0.010734783485531807, -0.0156296044588089, 0.04386046901345253, -0.0060590957291424274, 0.05594681203365326, -0.010938184335827827, 0.01702117547392845, -0.04606039077043533, -0.05699734762310982, 0.05402315780520439, -0.04517336189746857, -0.08702272176742554, -0.0743904560804367, 0.018038077279925346, -0.008173484355211258, -0.024421999230980873, -0.014663144946098328, 0.023632360622286797, 0.05972864106297493, 0.08164940029382706, -0.029056742787361145, -0.0038182756397873163, 0.04574909806251526, 0.059066757559776306, 0.05232304707169533, 0.040117163211107254, -0.0009510846575722098, -0.01966368593275547, 0.05618899688124657, -0.036063432693481445, -0.07544813305139542, 0.022195694968104362, 0.014409605413675308, 0.002266442636027932 ]
<p>I've just begun learning capacitance, and my lecture notes have a section on calculating capacitance for capacitors in vacuum of various shapes, e.g. two parallel plates and concentric spherical shells.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/0s7wd.png" alt="the cylindrical capacitor"></p> <p>For a cylindrical capacitor, comprising of a <em>long cylindrical conductor</em> with radius $r_a$ and linear charge density $+\lambda$, and a <em>coaxial cylindrical conducting shell</em> with radius $r_b$ and linear charge density $-\lambda$, to calculate its <em>capacitance per unit length</em>, the notes lay out the steps as follows:</p> <ul> <li>A point outside a long line of charge a distance r from axis has potential $V = \frac{\lambda}{2\pi\epsilon_0}ln\frac{r_0}{r}(1)$. Holds here also because charge on outer cylinder doesn't contribute to field between cylinders.</li> <li>Then $V_{ab} = V_a - V_b = \frac{\lambda}{2\pi\epsilon_0}ln\frac{r_b}{r_a}$</li> <li>Total charge $Q = \lambda L$ in a length $L$, so $C = \frac{Q}{V_{ab}} = \frac{2\pi\epsilon_0L}{ln(r_b/r_a)}$</li> <li>Therefore $\frac{C}{L} = \frac{2\pi\epsilon_0}{ln(r_b/r_a)}$</li> </ul> <p>There are a couple of things in here which I don't understand:</p> <ul> <li>The first bullet mentions "charge on outer cylinder doesn't contribute to field between cylinders". Is this true? Shouldn't the electric field strength double since there is both a positive charge $+\lambda$ and a negative charge $-\lambda$?</li> <li>The second bullet assigns $r_b$ as $r_0$ and $r_a$ as $r$ in equation $(1)$. Why is this so? As far as I understand, $r_0$ denotes the arbitrary distance where $V_b = 0$, which suggests that the potential on the coaxial shell is 0. Why is this not, say, the other way around? Why don't we take the potential at the edge of the inner cylinder as 0? Would that cause $r_b$ and $r_a$ to switch places in the fraction? Why is it possible to assign the potential on the coaxial shell as 0 in the first place?</li> </ul>
g1659
[ 0.01834452897310257, -0.02466311678290367, 0.004490950144827366, 0.0032910595182329416, 0.06074010580778122, 0.02983819507062435, 0.02660246193408966, -0.010542460717260838, -0.06588653475046158, 0.006505089346319437, -0.09333591163158417, 0.053982824087142944, 0.03595339506864548, 0.027438268065452576, 0.06594998389482498, -0.006089719478040934, 0.045775145292282104, -0.020640727132558823, 0.04661407694220543, 0.016887418925762177, -0.007600460201501846, -0.009805725887417793, 0.01703632064163685, -0.022756829857826233, 0.012803643010556698, 0.009058472700417042, 0.037998050451278687, 0.04995020851492882, -0.0474974699318409, -0.0703711062669754, 0.03707727789878845, 0.04075408726930618, 0.020435471087694168, -0.00020932930056005716, -0.0035329137463122606, 0.0014196853153407574, 0.011050757020711899, 0.008821099996566772, -0.0032293975818902254, 0.026962649077177048, 0.001019797520712018, -0.008210324682295322, 0.043218664824962616, 0.016491226851940155, -0.00013024924555793405, -0.042152971029281616, -0.04874880984425545, 0.030749082565307617, 0.008221480995416641, -0.053403161466121674, 0.01683882437646389, -0.03509021922945976, 0.03696119785308838, -0.004172309301793575, 0.03737591952085495, -0.020312655717134476, -0.024871181696653366, -0.012589878402650356, 0.09284473210573196, 0.008032255806028843, 0.003687729826197028, 0.009671471081674099, -0.039658475667238235, 0.006768444087356329, 0.040586333721876144, -0.04619092866778374, -0.00450495257973671, -0.010277023538947105, -0.03412517160177231, 0.03900984302163124, 0.014751692302525043, -0.09619108587503433, -0.005911290645599365, -0.04788728430867195, -0.03526940941810608, 0.0023919097147881985, 0.03354806452989578, -0.015183710493147373, 0.053548913449048996, -0.07438519597053528, -0.021761320531368256, -0.02279956266283989, 0.03684985265135765, -0.0018236713949590921, 0.01833801530301571, -0.02138226293027401, -0.01393093355000019, -0.015708759427070618, -0.05844859033823013, 0.04219122976064682, 0.009906452149152756, -0.01451168954372406, 0.050334565341472626, -0.03412147983908653, -0.011920332908630371, -0.017297178506851196, -0.0223124660551548, 0.04102982580661774, 0.014267919585108757, 0.004800064489245415, -0.00872087199240923, 0.05744758993387222, 0.050376635044813156, 0.04985024780035019, 0.002463241806253791, 0.05390316992998123, 0.02017422765493393, 0.01233360730111599, -0.016642821952700615, -0.03373321518301964, -0.05557854473590851, -0.060221005231142044, -0.030862437561154366, 0.003357740817591548, -0.045234598219394684, -0.009923676960170269, 0.07045742124319077, -0.08262880891561508, 0.045217365026474, 0.04731704667210579, -0.025778675451874733, 0.035962264984846115, -0.011598903685808182, -0.05561535060405731, -0.02515275590121746, 0.0011815225007012486, 0.05427183583378792, -0.00970025546848774, 0.02818804793059826, -0.03382537141442299, 0.0412902794778347, 0.002889837371185422, -0.006746544037014246, -0.01067085936665535, 0.022833822295069695, 0.013932785950601101, -0.03283281996846199, 0.012204284779727459, 0.02861797995865345, -0.06112363561987877, -0.007059986237436533, -0.020508747547864914, -0.001807773602195084, 0.008613384328782558, 0.007725870702415705, 0.005989428143948317, -0.05274238809943199, 0.0016207295702770352, 0.015234041027724743, -0.02095811441540718, 0.0394737534224987, 0.053078390657901764, -0.006858346983790398, -0.013980451039969921, -0.007817271165549755, 0.01602983847260475, 0.05510477349162102, 0.003651772625744343, 0.023803874850273132, 0.022129517048597336, 0.02416045591235161, 0.013853885233402252, 0.020976155996322632, 0.010410362854599953, -0.012601437978446484, 0.031430043280124664, -0.044122591614723206, -0.02090589702129364, -0.0013410118408501148, -0.0557020902633667, 0.01139757502824068, -0.03856327012181282, 0.014577243477106094, 0.03959578275680542, 0.02265053614974022, 0.028605762869119644, 0.05110062658786774, 0.05809352174401283, 0.00638225581496954, 0.012769551947712898, -0.056872401386499405, -0.0021715888287872076, 0.034564923495054245, 0.00041837591561488807, 0.026455236598849297, -0.021269725635647774, 0.017779158428311348, 0.04215427488088608, -0.056804876774549484, -0.012893221341073513, -0.05139017850160599, -0.002711594570428133, -0.020519988611340523, 0.05020966753363609, -0.03233420476317406, 0.002445219550281763, 0.03641409054398537, -0.061109576374292374, -0.02758307009935379, -0.05580893158912659, -0.04185333102941513, 0.0049594696611166, 0.028820648789405823, 0.050077784806489944, 0.05739976093173027, 0.0282722320407629, 0.0112057039514184, -0.04008631780743599, 0.07124108821153641, 0.0226542167365551, 0.0070387315936386585, -0.033736638724803925, 0.019510041922330856, 0.009561717510223389, 0.0477793924510479, -0.01544812973588705, -0.020551607012748718, 0.05302776023745537, -0.07462716847658157, -0.008278780616819859, 0.002515393076464534, -0.02328546531498432, 0.021960269659757614, -0.03665850684046745, -0.06896150857210159, 0.031931765377521515, -0.013405175879597664, 0.06161349266767502, -0.04478111118078232, -0.017654115334153175, -0.025699591264128685, 0.019191082566976547, 0.0124664893373847, -0.03039107471704483, -0.008542844094336033, 0.05300044268369675, -0.010988802649080753, -0.02287127636373043, -0.01888282597064972, -0.015921322628855705, -0.0032630350906401873, -0.061393484473228455, -0.02201739139854908, 0.03332879766821861, 0.014103539288043976, -0.021749872714281082, 0.03799444064497948, -0.021910736337304115, 0.005429286975413561, 0.0022808522917330265, -0.007200971711426973, 0.02351480908691883, -0.009406679309904575, 0.07659397274255753, 0.03111405111849308, -0.014628301374614239, -0.020071879029273987, 0.028797071427106857, -0.01976223662495613, -0.004595897160470486, 0.012865073047578335, -0.02088232710957527, -0.023126069456338882, 0.03147609159350395, -0.06913470476865768, 0.019478218629956245, -0.05232105031609535, 0.011036913841962814, 0.05066276714205742, -0.06148070469498634, -0.025694794952869415, 0.10721828043460846, 0.008226554840803146, -0.026758534833788872, 0.06862662732601166, -0.02520873211324215, -0.0024286957923322916, 0.006304105743765831, 0.033597540110349655, 0.017535820603370667, 0.013446834869682789, 0.012316320091485977, -0.026510071009397507, 0.009973880834877491, 0.03256823867559433, -0.021246930584311485, 0.027168383821845055, 0.028945935890078545, 0.04524607211351395, -0.006471602711826563, -0.04794264957308769, 0.04936378821730614, 0.01732686161994934, -0.05724354833364487, 0.1193072721362114, 0.04907551035284996, 0.06470883637666702, -0.015022816136479378, -0.019828174263238907, -0.029172619804739952, -0.037000998854637146, 0.028640447184443474, -0.06653307378292084, -0.03496819734573364, 0.0393039807677269, 0.027836237102746964, -0.012994416058063507, -0.10947577655315399, -0.006115840282291174, 0.06859070062637329, -0.016225570812821388, 0.016156258061528206, 0.019555244594812393, -0.05161255970597267, 0.004615317098796368, -0.008246272802352905, -0.026124127209186554, 0.040644362568855286, -0.043191179633140564, 0.03949947655200958, -0.0037032950203865767, -0.062047529965639114, 0.017897438257932663, 0.019265450537204742, -0.009438523091375828, 0.02028782106935978, -0.06728143990039825, -0.023837240412831306, 0.009254873730242252, 0.017364859580993652, 0.005919299088418484, 0.03710602968931198, 0.045048993080854416, -0.061248596757650375, -0.0325765460729599, -0.03967878594994545, -0.0038276042323559523, 0.04660063609480858, 0.01430879719555378, -0.003456362523138523, -0.0404525063931942, -0.03019980899989605, -0.03787718340754509, -0.0375574454665184, -0.058098841458559036, 0.059145718812942505, -0.005522000137716532, 0.015493733808398247, 0.018559321761131287, -0.036368146538734436, 0.03458845615386963, -0.03253250569105148, 0.06194601207971573, 0.030984200537204742, -0.0323847196996212, 0.01633329689502716, 0.005762425716966391, 0.03340468928217888, -0.034920938313007355, 0.0446840338408947, 0.013784117065370083, -0.05126279965043068, 0.009556730277836323, -0.007137236185371876, 0.03403768315911293, -0.03311972692608833, -0.006758224684745073, 0.08036880195140839, -0.011046609841287136, -0.0990811139345169, -0.032102588564157486, -0.03609044477343559, -0.04039642587304115, 0.039606522768735886, 0.02312595024704933, -0.018909895792603493, -0.05026712268590927, 0.0297737717628479, -0.01874719373881817, 0.05045240372419357, 0.022416073828935623, 0.011019599623978138, 0.012857494875788689, -0.03117358312010765, -0.028057564049959183, -0.023367270827293396, 0.004064224194735289, 0.013608737848699093, -0.0024426134768873453, -0.048131056129932404, -0.022003279998898506, -0.03753006085753441, -0.04597330093383789, -0.03363548591732979, -0.01059857290238142, -0.03448745608329773, 0.03157028555870056, -0.007986599579453468, 0.03945544734597206, -0.009468480944633484, 0.018890181556344032, -0.04438202083110809, 0.009530327282845974, -0.015124914236366749, -0.006918848026543856, -0.02836563065648079, 0.06322944909334183, 0.00222636666148901, 0.007661635521799326, -0.006746920291334391, 0.05262351036071777, -0.019801851361989975, -0.027051381766796112, -0.0328003466129303, 0.03273289278149605, -0.04289111867547035, 0.0016622357070446014, 0.032335247844457626, -0.003099898574873805, 0.006674794014543295, -0.01717190444469452, -0.01307801716029644, 0.02713140659034252, -0.02001471258699894, 0.041026514023542404, 0.011719145812094212, 0.041829951107501984, 0.027338963001966476, 0.027641259133815765, 0.03048366867005825, -0.017379676923155785, 0.0335838608443737, -0.015122458338737488, 0.0747201219201088, -0.0321052260696888, 0.042682237923145294, -0.038887906819581985, 0.05885407701134682, -0.029808606952428818, -0.018315810710191727, 0.04227534309029579, -0.06586863845586777, 0.036306414753198624, -0.051646213978528976, -0.0013903048820793629, 0.024414507672190666, -0.06708190590143204, -0.01759542152285576, 0.014255469664931297, -0.011339548975229263, -0.039719369262456894, 0.027853066101670265, 0.029226208105683327, -0.029573161154985428, -0.018344489857554436, -0.049211811274290085, 0.06812091171741486, -0.0014408256392925978, 0.04288556054234505, -0.025427820160984993, -0.05267314612865448, 0.0322028249502182, 0.0023307777009904385, -0.04818404093384743, 0.018157154321670532, -0.0077812280505895615, -0.020635992288589478, -0.054318867623806, -0.0527842678129673, -0.033562276512384415, 0.0334249772131443, 0.03842472285032272, 0.02249850519001484, -0.03701652213931084, 0.015296600759029388, -0.028370501473546028, -0.016108542680740356, 0.028069643303751945, -0.09307572990655899, -0.05320117622613907, -0.04776817187666893, -0.0033108640927821398, -0.012122313492000103, 0.007401992566883564, -0.030192703008651733, 0.025818180292844772, 0.0007955011678859591, 0.011625370942056179, -0.03707311302423477, 0.006284739822149277, 0.014738342724740505, 0.0205514058470726, 0.020681070163846016, 0.04467781260609627, 0.0018436359241604805, 0.01857646182179451, 0.07794486731290817, -0.007423697039484978, -0.06344437599182129, 0.02807850018143654, -0.0265421811491251, 0.0032649191562086344, -0.023630376905202866, 0.007752345409244299, -0.03579346463084221, 0.008654533885419369, -0.00822046585381031, 0.022896304726600647, 0.036753639578819275, 0.007323197554796934, 0.03534829616546631, 0.04285639151930809, 0.05455342307686806, 0.018137086182832718, -0.003146833274513483, 0.028623376041650772, -0.05239885672926903, -0.028861787170171738, -0.0208117738366127, 0.06885669380426407, 0.053739942610263824, 0.022093012928962708, -0.015889057889580727, -0.009305421262979507, -0.0339445099234581, 0.026688462123274803, -0.02540501393377781, -0.10083915293216705, -0.0042602503672242165, 0.03709602355957031, -0.029716387391090393, 0.05391479656100273, -0.012219586409628391, -0.005480437073856592, -0.042748115956783295, -0.021916475147008896, -0.03300746902823448, -0.04937656223773956, 0.0656706839799881, -0.006844028364866972, -0.012623823247849941, -0.050676245242357254, -0.04237867891788483, 0.0674181878566742, -0.030856778845191002, -0.03119722381234169, 0.01171900238841772, 0.01530088298022747, 0.02913702465593815, 0.018336176872253418, -0.05206480994820595, -0.022421441972255707, -0.0024654159788042307, -0.019507503136992455, 0.053062885999679565, -0.045101165771484375, 0.017630228772759438, -0.06726724654436111, 0.00030040208366699517, -0.010648628696799278, 0.041098952293395996, 0.0438951812684536, -0.012215443886816502, 0.024136262014508247, -0.01087660901248455, -0.0072162519209086895, 0.008997189812362194, 0.02037472277879715, 0.08252566307783127, 0.01446410734206438, 0.007449576631188393, -0.03296312317252159, -0.008404875174164772, -0.09027989208698273, 0.06122041121125221, 0.017433037981390953, -0.0356978103518486, 0.02564656175673008, 0.000496859138365835, -0.0016045072115957737, 0.0023244922049343586, -0.0090585146099329, 0.023100081831216812, -0.03962692618370056, 0.007044295780360699, 0.05663441866636276, 0.04898589104413986, -0.06604874134063721, 0.09426921606063843, -0.07213552296161652, -0.03375888243317604, -0.008802722208201885, 0.06103958189487457, -0.08174002915620804, -0.033027563244104385, -0.047447364777326584, 0.02161814086139202, 0.0213614534586668, 0.008705539628863335, 0.031089182943105698, 0.05015181377530098, 0.018218738958239555, 0.0035020560026168823, -0.012049770914018154, 0.05567479878664017, 0.0017735811416059732, -0.02766028419137001, -0.022951636463403702, -0.04581284150481224, 0.012629298493266106, -0.024846874177455902, 0.021375488489866257, -0.06191881373524666, -0.0003025959595106542, -0.01139865443110466, 0.006976049393415451, 0.018579410389065742, -0.010506803169846535, -0.0530330091714859, 0.020245013758540154, 0.03791434317827225, 0.02812378667294979, -0.037101056426763535, 0.05746426433324814, -0.015659073367714882, 0.060437384992837906, -0.02720486745238304, 0.012416374869644642, 0.05638466775417328, -0.015545659698545933, -0.0210597924888134, 0.0203353613615036, 0.05088290944695473, 0.11152466386556625, 0.0041423374786973, 0.01907774619758129, -0.026787862181663513, -0.04938381537795067, 0.013936443254351616, -0.0028608746360987425, 0.019523857161402702, 0.0036400819662958384, 0.0497223399579525, 0.019568167626857758, 0.0158535223454237, -0.022124245762825012, 0.08380722254514694, 0.008481833152472973, -0.041930630803108215, 0.00582229346036911, -0.01292743906378746, 0.025693273171782494, -0.024020975455641747, 0.05809127166867256, -0.013684399425983429, -0.017390452325344086, 0.03187946230173111, -0.0013324900064617395, -0.011928935535252094, -0.042060736566782, -0.01640334539115429, 0.01528680045157671, 0.004426329862326384, -0.038335222750902176, 0.04547436907887459, 0.00021542242029681802, 0.008630985394120216, -0.0611007921397686, 0.021311944350600243, -0.08514395356178284, 0.009801717475056648, 0.00970762874931097, -0.0636381208896637, 0.04613173380494118, 0.04721175134181976, 0.010510142892599106, 0.0052018617279827595, 0.013656847178936005, -0.05212591215968132, -0.004628142341971397, 0.019230380654335022, -0.02398504689335823, -0.011467035859823227, -0.03154306858778, -0.0895472913980484, 0.011918537318706512, 0.010814772918820381, -0.03536254167556763, 0.01233390998095274, 0.019497156143188477, 0.023710552603006363, 0.02644176594913006, 0.01380343921482563, -0.0015241072978824377, -0.054518453776836395, 0.043625518679618835, 0.02933923341333866, 0.03941689059138298, 0.044354815036058426, 0.02331620082259178, 0.06161244958639145, -0.0630679503083229, -0.015100319869816303, -0.03126790001988411, 0.023163344711065292, 0.010142476297914982, -0.028072873130440712, 0.03548777848482132, -0.02147364616394043, 0.0009020605939440429, 0.0052422271110117435, 0.014026418328285217, 0.017537537962198257, 0.012119019404053688, 0.02648639865219593, 0.014608320780098438, -0.04809301719069481, 0.07342944294214249, -0.00044755058479495347, 0.011428674682974815, -0.048683181405067444, -0.06292731314897537, 0.054794419556856155, -0.05544813722372055, -0.0006111126858741045, -0.024103647097945213, -0.010107140056788921, 0.02211979404091835, -0.03993171453475952, -0.008024829439818859, -0.010815674439072609, -0.03769432753324509, -0.011504468508064747, 0.008577757515013218, -0.01884109526872635, -0.029001858085393906, 0.016828754916787148, 0.06533247977495193, 0.06392671912908554, -0.04593157023191452, -0.0012270489241927862, -0.045763421803712845, 0.0240448247641325, -0.041759882122278214, -0.038599539548158646, -0.021514924243092537, -0.08113265782594681, 0.0475296713411808, 0.0689539909362793, 0.029135283082723618, 0.01465531438589096, -0.02698454260826111, -0.05000779405236244, -0.008726503700017929, -0.00013860709441360086, -0.055157434195280075, 0.03111751191318035, 0.016457412391901016, 0.030953552573919296, -0.008454381488263607, -0.012882140465080738, -0.0020252575632184744, 0.01524239219725132, -0.060065507888793945, 0.040963564068078995, -0.04290866106748581, -0.032314687967300415, -0.013131325133144855 ]
<p>I think of <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coulomb%27s_constant" rel="nofollow">Coulomb's constant</a> as a conversion factor (not sure if this is correct). Kind of like how you would do calculations in kg and then times it by the conversion constant to convert your answer to pounds. The conversion factor would be $2.2\: \mathrm{lbs/kg}$.</p> <p>Since the units for Coulomb's constant is $\mathrm{N \cdot m^2/C^2}$, would it make sense to define the Newton as:</p> <p>$1\:\text{Newton} = \frac{1}{1/1\: \mathrm{meter^2} \cdot 1\: \mathrm{Coulomb^2}}$</p> <p>Would the above definition be valid?</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> So if $k$ is not a conversion factor since the above definition for a Newton is invalid and $k$ is not just a scaling factor, since it has units, then what is it? If its just a proportionality constant to adjust the magnitude then why does it have units? Shouldn't it be a unit less constant?</p> <p><strong>EDIT:</strong> So $k$ is not just a scaling factor (since it has units) and its not a conversion factor since a Newton can't be expressed as the other units. So if its unit just exists so that things cancel out "nicely" doesn't this make dimensional analysis useless since you can add in random constants and units to cancel out whatever you want? </p> <p><strong>My question is not about the meaning of $k$. Its about its units.</strong> </p>
g1660
[ 0.03485558554530144, -0.03331468626856804, 0.033857785165309906, -0.06422427296638489, 0.03545166924595833, 0.040041178464889526, -0.014153307303786278, 0.06550547480583191, -0.02734193578362465, 0.04682173952460289, -0.015231093391776085, 0.0026117467787116766, 0.005450007040053606, 0.006438978482037783, -0.005550873000174761, -0.018530089408159256, 0.054195791482925415, -0.01697266288101673, 0.03265460953116417, 0.018168501555919647, -0.03339141607284546, 0.003849039087072015, -0.021884668618440628, -0.07205868512392044, -0.0038190134800970554, -0.030344489961862564, 0.021087879315018654, 0.006401862483471632, -0.03867003321647644, -0.003953475039452314, 0.016375597566366196, -0.0010714603122323751, 0.05762884020805359, -0.05628538131713867, -0.06790336221456528, 0.01239200308918953, -0.016693534329533577, 0.036663323640823364, 0.0592212900519371, 0.008459820412099361, -0.014104415662586689, -0.018490131944417953, -0.003547545289620757, 0.01343876775354147, -0.017826054245233536, 0.006462205667048693, -0.049897536635398865, -0.03790026530623436, -0.004637551959604025, -0.021326404064893723, -0.0325169712305069, 0.00003929687227355316, 0.012133204378187656, 0.0398898683488369, 0.01075852569192648, 0.03934308886528015, 0.011672219261527061, 0.019328458234667778, -0.005381634924560785, 0.054557591676712036, 0.05513184890151024, 0.0025857777800410986, 0.028218619525432587, -0.014393995516002178, 0.09315689653158188, -0.00801523495465517, 0.011900914832949638, -0.0013673595385625958, -0.03986581787467003, 0.012136491015553474, -0.003167646937072277, -0.06555615365505219, 0.012448214925825596, -0.016036219894886017, 0.02331412024796009, 0.010071752592921257, 0.06589201837778091, 0.042255762964487076, 0.03815212845802307, -0.004000892862677574, -0.006733435671776533, 0.014516105875372887, 0.04522889852523804, 0.0020920359529554844, 0.027676919475197792, -0.04136748984456062, -0.032166849821805954, 0.0339888297021389, 0.005280432756990194, 0.010794839821755886, -0.029804332181811333, 0.016637947410345078, 0.06354203820228577, 0.00044355104910209775, -0.011753160506486893, -0.08823833614587784, 0.015236376784741879, 0.02025124430656433, -0.04057905450463295, 0.011265875771641731, -0.021735958755016327, 0.025399893522262573, 0.021919820457696915, 0.0349583700299263, -0.036921512335538864, 0.015351383946835995, 0.045268550515174866, 0.030289046466350555, 0.007401647046208382, -0.10242532193660736, -0.03983702138066292, 0.004485420882701874, 0.03779418766498566, -0.001447419635951519, -0.03407694399356842, -0.010316983796656132, 0.038087986409664154, -0.048168886452913284, 0.04250037670135498, -0.03333858773112297, -0.010750841349363327, -0.03910220041871071, 0.017194367945194244, 0.018255744129419327, -0.09849658608436584, -0.018754182383418083, 0.039865896105766296, 0.036979641765356064, 0.027654292061924934, -0.07284025847911835, 0.06287024170160294, -0.011514398269355297, -0.09090366959571838, 0.014051335863769054, 0.05977369099855423, 0.05495654046535492, -0.031779490411281586, 0.005237838719040155, -0.03231047838926315, 0.03631723299622536, -0.01390775851905346, -0.03883519768714905, -0.008527989499270916, 0.018787940964102745, -0.007571131456643343, 0.0022753714583814144, -0.040860969573259354, -0.008294292725622654, 0.0612126961350441, 0.04249568283557892, 0.016363872215151787, 0.05462401732802391, -0.024249615147709846, -0.06399448215961456, -0.009829777292907238, -0.022871144115924835, 0.03246401250362396, 0.032778121531009674, -0.005321723408997059, 0.016455860808491707, 0.05678171664476395, 0.01814117096364498, -0.012472238391637802, 0.016842104494571686, -0.035320766270160675, -0.03906576707959175, -0.033625517040491104, 0.0005724757211282849, 0.007617997005581856, -0.037182871252298355, -0.024464357644319534, 0.03496280685067177, 0.007438970729708672, 0.004240330774337053, -0.024968596175312996, 0.011708160862326622, 0.051670487970113754, 0.0709337443113327, 0.0018672531004995108, -0.06703002750873566, -0.0654025599360466, 0.023317184299230576, 0.09238731116056442, 0.006945517845451832, -0.04202625900506973, 0.010017722845077515, -0.005987160373479128, 0.03410317003726959, -0.03635919466614723, 0.016756374388933182, -0.02985169179737568, -0.029605455696582794, -0.03648765757679939, 0.033980533480644226, 0.0001982667890843004, -0.038600288331508636, -0.051588013768196106, 0.007405827287584543, -0.02990172989666462, -0.0488184355199337, 0.019839756190776825, 0.02619440294802189, 0.03723333030939102, -0.0007633648347109556, 0.05101776123046875, 0.0390574112534523, -0.00476850476115942, 0.03820531815290451, 0.012310107238590717, -0.015546190552413464, 0.05199854075908661, 0.004546251613646746, -0.030146142467856407, 0.06234074756503105, 0.0002448258164804429, -0.016979029402136803, -0.013236550614237785, -0.015509978868067265, -0.06171760708093643, 0.0419677197933197, -0.03309044614434242, 0.00481457868590951, 0.037755295634269714, -0.0052780346013605595, -0.03090740740299225, -0.013765250332653522, -0.02444683387875557, 0.011445032432675362, 0.029571127146482468, -0.008272037841379642, -0.05501823127269745, 0.05585573986172676, -0.041476670652627945, 0.03656364977359772, 0.0014309089165180922, 0.07379836589097977, -0.05980236455798149, -0.01180335134267807, 0.0009896107949316502, 0.05493669956922531, 0.013757501728832722, -0.03139924257993698, -0.0021653305739164352, -0.020696911960840225, -0.011246132664382458, -0.07038408517837524, -0.013829007744789124, -0.000331345247104764, -0.004661864135414362, 0.004993101116269827, -0.03965841233730316, -0.06111481785774231, -0.0035279206931591034, 0.014624069444835186, 0.03328380361199379, 0.012475546449422836, 0.018516341224312782, 0.01805751770734787, -0.044822536408901215, 0.005754075013101101, 0.07353229820728302, -0.019742758944630623, 0.004684878513216972, 0.08958733081817627, -0.028857694938778877, -0.03611837327480316, -0.06420603394508362, 0.034972093999385834, 0.04198243468999863, -0.0032904604449868202, 0.0010358738945797086, 0.058985743671655655, 0.024818554520606995, 0.02989060804247856, -0.02536262385547161, -0.04355289787054062, 0.06502404808998108, -0.01053797546774149, 0.01324217114597559, -0.06250908970832825, 0.016740474849939346, 0.06410892307758331, -0.03526043891906738, 0.043430253863334656, 0.011626712046563625, -0.020095322281122208, -0.005110271740704775, 0.006028353702276945, 0.022124219685792923, 0.029546555131673813, 0.025874057784676552, 0.032306261360645294, -0.026874151080846786, -0.03254517540335655, 0.012593298219144344, 0.05349164456129074, 0.07771386206150055, -0.0868445485830307, 0.006953128147870302, 0.06455684453248978, -0.03956082835793495, -0.055470697581768036, 0.01901768334209919, -0.009809302166104317, -0.011164301075041294, 0.05907091498374939, 0.025409173220396042, -0.020393487066030502, -0.09337865561246872, -0.03842556104063988, -0.012853299267590046, 0.04324828088283539, 0.018870865926146507, 0.016964823007583618, -0.06243511661887169, -0.032563064247369766, 0.009273610077798367, -0.009345593862235546, 0.0040422785095870495, -0.020502468571066856, -0.01047490444034338, -0.08027085661888123, 0.01473697368055582, -0.02188003621995449, 0.027212148532271385, 0.03959183394908905, -0.09139223396778107, -0.014703850261867046, 0.0033030868507921696, -0.07476748526096344, -0.029101859778165817, -0.047035180032253265, 0.015073692426085472, 0.02136528119444847, -0.09641218185424805, -0.0579509399831295, -0.062288906425237656, 0.011538460850715637, 0.016556790098547935, -0.026635469868779182, -0.04348430037498474, -0.02404913865029812, -0.06818205863237381, -0.007586465682834387, -0.025006471201777458, 0.03950980305671692, 0.01824161969125271, -0.013722379691898823, -0.004631704650819302, -0.04080193489789963, 0.016276251524686813, 0.009220404550433159, 0.007362353149801493, -0.01386337447911501, 0.005236410535871983, 0.006856738589704037, 0.04785613343119621, 0.06423746049404144, -0.09235814958810806, -0.012152683921158314, 0.021657146513462067, -0.0497627854347229, 0.006521622650325298, 0.02893943525850773, -0.024217704311013222, 0.019963040947914124, 0.054759833961725235, 0.05195410177111626, -0.022127725183963776, -0.01836630515754223, -0.026600930839776993, 0.0035193804651498795, 0.024319065734744072, 0.004329117480665445, -0.028677785769104958, -0.035533782094717026, 0.022396765649318695, -0.0027927730698138475, 0.0020396478939801455, -0.011187584139406681, 0.026790324598550797, 0.019771156832575798, 0.030911238864064217, -0.00010876620945055038, 0.01698778010904789, 0.002135514747351408, -0.04430447146296501, -0.0052960035391151905, 0.017777511849999428, -0.050478871911764145, 0.00009632353612687439, -0.012729831971228123, 0.0016273828223347664, -0.003269813721999526, 0.01007252000272274, 0.019234029576182365, -0.0261676125228405, -0.03574586287140846, 0.0264267735183239, -0.019936442375183105, 0.03663516417145729, -0.061060648411512375, -0.026534026488661766, 0.011342493817210197, -0.0006609815754927695, 0.0015304365660995245, 0.0594305582344532, -0.014153902418911457, 0.023405106738209724, -0.016110451892018318, -0.032812152057886124, 0.014358622953295708, 0.07231131196022034, -0.05078975856304169, 0.006460865493863821, 0.055397290736436844, -0.04449113830924034, 0.017709555104374886, 0.07399188727140427, -0.015473862178623676, 0.010843419469892979, -0.0031491154804825783, -0.02341652289032936, 0.010088377632200718, 0.030879732221364975, 0.014958294108510017, 0.05874822288751602, 0.00865350291132927, -0.0051384586840868, -0.0030312116723507643, 0.006175979971885681, 0.07442591339349747, 0.08451587706804276, -0.022819891571998596, -0.010018027387559414, 0.025592142716050148, -0.0479535311460495, 0.018497394397854805, -0.013111397624015808, -0.02760610543191433, 0.03553350269794464, 0.07084409147500992, -0.0013252308126538992, 0.006383857689797878, -0.010796207003295422, -0.015449276193976402, 0.017838075757026672, 0.000677356612868607, 0.01844046823680401, -0.001082363072782755, -0.06485139578580856, 0.039410192519426346, -0.029341477900743484, -0.04043827950954437, -0.03427399694919586, -0.004901663865894079, -0.01723260059952736, -0.03660252317786217, 0.004804293159395456, 0.04173916205763817, -0.07395242899656296, -0.01791074126958847, -0.0327598862349987, 0.01110665313899517, 0.02269737608730793, -0.0035062164533883333, -0.05500734969973564, 0.005850045941770077, -0.03339546173810959, -0.01026577316224575, 0.016414381563663483, -0.005500934086740017, -0.004604324698448181, 0.031824640929698944, 0.08248624205589294, -0.018532555550336838, 0.002345894929021597, -0.03075437992811203, -0.028199659660458565, -0.03875589743256569, 0.038457758724689484, -0.02647331729531288, 0.08015912026166916, 0.04586269333958626, -0.01790393330156803, 0.05958173796534538, -0.022221151739358902, 0.030279669910669327, -0.0375310555100441, -0.057648710906505585, 0.01578151248395443, 0.04754987359046936, 0.05705263838171959, -0.026864519342780113, 0.0042646764777600765, 0.06747730821371078, 0.036286208778619766, -0.03688514605164528, 0.005207083187997341, 0.015230256132781506, 0.012384477071464062, 0.05578078329563141, -0.03626761585474014, 0.05701650306582451, -0.02596079185605049, 0.011627075262367725, 0.0062848422676324844, -0.025639215484261513, 0.020490488037467003, 0.06270971149206161, 0.053552161902189255, 0.02286773920059204, -0.014413384720683098, 0.009498377330601215, 0.00817515142261982, -0.004294821061193943, 0.011776910163462162, -0.020491361618041992, -0.0287479255348444, -0.0021175185684114695, -0.006993329152464867, 0.009435471147298813, -0.014306508004665375, -0.04500706121325493, -0.0008531946805305779, 0.02497613988816738, 0.003836643183603883, -0.04029640182852745, 0.023113861680030823, 0.05888090282678604, 0.00434805266559124, -0.02050342597067356, 0.019186776131391525, 0.008779406547546387, -0.0073669529519975185, -0.0244815181940794, -0.0000838364940136671, 0.04450375959277153, -0.011156567372381687, -0.02264050394296646, -0.054888926446437836, 0.06411456316709518, 0.014079313725233078, -0.02100825496017933, -0.007450052071362734, -0.011895908042788506, 0.06925272196531296, -0.0015347289154306054, 0.009544175118207932, -0.041878681629896164, -0.035430509597063065, 0.054840315133333206, 0.03561181202530861, -0.0616108737885952, -0.002126072533428669, 0.012177089229226112, -0.009004668332636356, 0.017821241170167923, -0.011423739604651928, -0.0302511528134346, -0.03809916228055954, 0.04368128627538681, -0.0021619501058012247, 0.031186280772089958, 0.003374009858816862, -0.04221895709633827, 0.02882280945777893, -0.0014387676492333412, 0.08758841454982758, 0.012262494303286076, -0.07262922823429108, 0.011913890950381756, 0.0026257114950567484, -0.04650581255555153, -0.0019917720928788185, 0.011440586298704147, -0.024114565923810005, 0.015379766002297401, -0.0019492597784847021, 0.009410968981683254, 0.07193540036678314, -0.028397275134921074, 0.0009661831427365541, -0.04485863447189331, -0.13244043290615082, -0.03135634958744049, -0.02233298495411873, -0.01649002730846405, 0.04581212252378464, -0.01685941033065319, -0.023085588589310646, -0.011667123064398766, -0.055898670107126236, 0.034632615745067596, 0.01968071237206459, -0.07888916879892349, -0.005920924711972475, -0.001315887551754713, -0.00247112731449306, 0.013976295478641987, 0.055243056267499924, 0.023806827142834663, 0.027407102286815643, -0.011613891460001469, 0.04619479179382324, 0.0827091634273529, -0.01671084202826023, 0.006549035664647818, -0.006049640942364931, 0.0385853573679924, 0.02953144907951355, 0.020927416160702705, -0.00820442195981741, 0.008122525177896023, 0.06493505835533142, -0.04887755960226059, -0.004343345761299133, -0.036927077919244766, -0.06393717229366302, 0.025675911456346512, 0.050326552242040634, -0.002772711683064699, -0.005832330789417028, -0.0049599697813391685, -0.0006690859445370734, 0.07404030114412308, -0.007823718711733818, 0.08151024580001831, 0.04310521110892296, -0.0405956469476223, -0.057632192969322205, 0.04030928388237953, 0.009138223715126514, 0.04539325460791588, 0.0028467325028032064, 0.05450516939163208, -0.03403627499938011, 0.022269709035754204, 0.017232581973075867, 0.008054057136178017, -0.041639309376478195, -0.030175602063536644, 0.049488600343465805, -0.007483787834644318, -0.023396071046590805, 0.021011389791965485, 0.0372319258749485, 0.03460875526070595, -0.09111230820417404, 0.01822260208427906, -0.026655273512005806, -0.007960563525557518, 0.004189631436020136, -0.05678228661417961, -0.007824738509953022, 0.04663265869021416, 0.0445939265191555, 0.0020438903011381626, 0.008971193805336952, -0.010578003711998463, -0.03301660344004631, -0.050332315266132355, 0.02929624915122986, -0.032865215092897415, -0.037270355969667435, 0.04101690649986267, 0.013934274204075336, -0.0356539711356163, 0.024200519546866417, -0.07337463647127151, -0.03316532075405121, 0.014692913740873337, 0.01986822299659252, 0.00834946520626545, 0.0752100944519043, 0.008565357886254787, -0.04564504697918892, -0.009964680299162865, 0.018601397052407265, -0.005164268892258406, -0.0008990797796286643, -0.004753551911562681, 0.033585160970687866, -0.04508740454912186, -0.07021229714155197, 0.0038005239330232143, -0.03219691291451454, -0.02676388807594776, 0.05147920921444893, -0.016619984060525894, 0.047694314271211624, 0.01960473135113716, 0.07108768075704575, 0.003559678327292204, -0.009834854863584042, 0.019062025472521782, 0.031034020707011223, 0.0088424663990736, 0.05629681795835495, 0.0018699023639783263, 0.02709152363240719, -0.013984818011522293, -0.02556733600795269, -0.04523058980703354, 0.012721006758511066, 0.008191276341676712, -0.026278477162122726, 0.001016858033835888, -0.04183633625507355, 0.020877784118056297, -0.005069979932159185, 0.0103301415219903, 0.0024378264788538218, 0.01077387947589159, 0.03232068195939064, 0.04612329229712486, -0.014120455831289291, -0.05989862605929375, -0.00928953755646944, -0.07195404171943665, -0.0405697226524353, -0.059434693306684494, -0.012781357392668724, -0.03552297130227089, -0.0032729380764067173, -0.029758373275399208, 0.005181464366614819, -0.03618823364377022, -0.04556570202112198, -0.0014787331456318498, 0.000658037606626749, 0.011241720989346504, 0.028352346271276474, 0.0328102670609951, -0.02987748384475708, -0.009310314431786537, -0.027955995872616768, 0.01018354669213295, -0.0891023725271225, 0.04239535704255104, -0.007054949179291725, -0.02543468028306961, -0.004768660292029381, 0.020688293501734734, -0.042069971561431885, -0.06079734116792679, -0.10224807262420654, 0.051423922181129456, 0.025104381144046783, 0.0056227222084999084, -0.011697288602590561, 0.04068160429596901, 0.026956042274832726, 0.010823492892086506, -0.01698119193315506, -0.017687063664197922, -0.01804634928703308, 0.012895523570477962, 0.00626335246488452, -0.049309901893138885, 0.006493064109236002, 0.00419676722958684, 0.011831487528979778, 0.03510171175003052, 0.03090400993824005, -0.033236876130104065, -0.0918516218662262, 0.021468253806233406 ]
<p>Suppose you have a quantum system with a Hamiltonian having some number (greater than 2, possibly infinite) of eigenfunctions, and that the system is prepared in the ground state.</p> <p>When can you approximate it as by two-level system (using just the ground state and first excited state)? Is there some property that will make it better approximated by a two-level system (e.g., something like a bigger energy gap between the second and third energy levels)?</p>
g1661
[ 0.016628438606858253, 0.04575846716761589, -0.014887474477291107, -0.003461595159024, -0.008015974424779415, 0.020559528842568398, 0.030704764649271965, 0.0473671555519104, -0.026740973815321922, -0.0022937932517379522, -0.03045746311545372, 0.0006152219721116126, 0.021069608628749847, 0.060780543833971024, 0.018087774515151978, -0.008123931474983692, 0.0784171000123024, -0.02670704945921898, 0.050127651542425156, -0.029264064505696297, -0.023876966908574104, 0.003517665434628725, -0.031015664339065552, -0.01646074466407299, 0.013655822724103928, 0.004591505043208599, 0.013939732685685158, 0.006480825133621693, -0.019273461773991585, -0.001995236147195101, -0.05215659737586975, 0.018249476328492165, 0.050560906529426575, -0.006765399593859911, 0.016697639599442482, 0.022612662985920906, 0.042396824806928635, -0.0011023322585970163, -0.017718173563480377, -0.07541778683662415, 0.03786056116223335, -0.047915104776620865, -0.0031851734966039658, -0.005482856184244156, -0.024692567065358162, -0.04635295644402504, 0.023485802114009857, 0.0005134194507263601, 0.036944352090358734, -0.007087895181030035, -0.0068284315057098866, 0.09532138705253601, 0.0008913184865377843, 0.07386279851198196, 0.0309748575091362, 0.0069128768518567085, -0.019814269617199898, 0.0101308049634099, 0.009650392457842827, 0.04049420356750488, 0.05655233561992645, 0.028512077406048775, -0.01562059111893177, -0.009709104895591736, -0.034234270453453064, 0.042431361973285675, -0.012328139506280422, 0.041135869920253754, 0.02612944319844246, -0.002040624851360917, -0.00478399358689785, -0.0010966801783069968, -0.025205787271261215, -0.03568345308303833, -0.0006847831537015736, -0.02938292920589447, -0.044308241456747055, -0.0008527576574124396, 0.01411884743720293, 0.0661834329366684, -0.0039488282054662704, 0.01731797493994236, 0.013415610417723656, -0.0673302412033081, 0.016324389725923538, 0.030359579250216484, 0.0014783765655010939, 0.019028738141059875, 0.025909362360835075, 0.08183831721544266, -0.05443949997425079, 0.012000417336821556, 0.03852790966629982, -0.01922702230513096, -0.012956805527210236, -0.027537425979971886, 0.015573742799460888, 0.030622774735093117, 0.021753014996647835, 0.03420448303222656, -0.006751994602382183, -0.01077787671238184, 0.005486129783093929, -0.04531748965382576, -0.01599779725074768, 0.03912367299199104, 0.04348045587539673, -0.05612821877002716, -0.012879139743745327, 0.010206851176917553, -0.035468898713588715, 0.0019277837127447128, 0.009996553882956505, -0.013003073632717133, -0.046056121587753296, 0.0381518118083477, 0.06057962775230408, -0.015116916038095951, -0.0632801502943039, -0.004605535417795181, 0.063727006316185, -0.010705024003982544, -0.008094838820397854, 0.038552384823560715, 0.05098828673362732, 0.00781990960240364, -0.06631071120500565, -0.024141624569892883, -0.00759275583550334, -0.0017530290642753243, -0.02261364832520485, -0.053389646112918854, 0.034523360431194305, -0.00222300598397851, 0.005835758987814188, 0.01560609508305788, 0.046794891357421875, -0.011608821339905262, -0.015384472906589508, 0.04848841205239296, -0.006005340255796909, -0.060433708131313324, -0.007607402745634317, -0.04097829386591911, -0.003392515005543828, -0.01152857206761837, 0.025639817118644714, 0.01209742110222578, 0.003227147040888667, -0.013665821403265, -0.022649720311164856, 0.03160364180803299, 0.09080614894628525, -0.008642105385661125, 0.03236715495586395, 0.013641510158777237, 0.041648220270872116, 0.0090061379596591, -0.002253397135064006, 0.007932784967124462, 0.004492770414799452, -0.006412738002836704, -0.021500438451766968, -0.012768607586622238, 0.02754521183669567, 0.03037886880338192, -0.01962163858115673, -0.0784798339009285, -0.037498839199543, -0.03702382743358612, 0.020555077120661736, 0.025793973356485367, -0.008534041233360767, 0.03541061654686928, -0.034555789083242416, 0.02059447206556797, 0.0414448082447052, -0.062100134789943695, 0.008189736865460873, 0.015752185136079788, 0.006722090765833855, -0.023772867396473885, -0.0626053437590599, 0.06525163352489471, 0.012136992998421192, 0.020020004361867905, 0.031200440600514412, -0.008528475649654865, 0.028754938393831253, 0.04298591986298561, -0.0061629279516637325, 0.0017005676636472344, -0.003402955597266555, -0.00119019765406847, -0.06998605281114578, 0.02000013180077076, 0.08570314943790436, -0.022720249369740486, -0.023415254428982735, 0.004402099642902613, 0.02259380742907524, 0.03237409517168999, -0.046257369220256805, -0.030744465067982674, 0.05493420735001564, 0.06385412812232971, -0.024747971445322037, 0.0377122238278389, -0.08019433170557022, -0.004253306891769171, -0.013543406501412392, -0.015065401792526245, 0.010283853858709335, 0.062013089656829834, 0.03654096648097038, -0.042700644582509995, -0.007564346306025982, 0.0600312240421772, 0.022241482511162758, 0.027246573939919472, -0.017270734533667564, -0.013508612290024757, 0.05653010308742523, 0.014928221702575684, 0.06429052352905273, -0.030858952552080154, -0.08765346556901932, 0.07989463210105896, -0.06456325948238373, 0.03216150403022766, -0.04688126593828201, -0.027606897056102753, -0.05114172771573067, -0.029173510149121284, 0.0009650051943026483, 0.02882096730172634, -0.032500576227903366, -0.06555530428886414, 0.12475993484258652, 0.014845947735011578, 0.012473571114242077, 0.04545550048351288, 0.03450086712837219, 0.05782920867204666, -0.0017468510195612907, 0.021762289106845856, -0.06800711154937744, 0.011130833998322487, -0.06048674136400223, 0.029304560273885727, -0.05517188459634781, 0.021031644195318222, -0.017744481563568115, 0.008969164453446865, -0.014268875122070312, 0.008404986932873726, -0.01411769725382328, 0.022773683071136475, 0.025658724829554558, -0.06891879439353943, 0.030929943546652794, 0.002219832269474864, 0.011436848901212215, -0.006592717953026295, -0.009691026993095875, -0.0017627456691116095, 0.0035752078983932734, -0.020589714869856834, 0.023751134052872658, -0.07865475118160248, -0.0014406252885237336, 0.08484308421611786, -0.0033081243745982647, 0.0318688228726387, 0.011916995979845524, -0.02560453861951828, 0.023991700261831284, -0.01667022332549095, 0.00010389648377895355, -0.042984507977962494, -0.054592013359069824, -0.06571845710277557, 0.01751326210796833, 0.062498655170202255, 0.02397330477833748, -0.04040319845080376, -0.009696890600025654, -0.013228558003902435, -0.02942652441561222, 0.0012657885672524571, -0.03989043086767197, -0.00391427194699645, 0.025889141485095024, 0.016204260289669037, -0.06644554436206818, -0.01760121062397957, 0.015203717164695263, -0.04920140281319618, -0.013017562218010426, 0.10003864765167236, 0.05620328709483147, -0.04002881422638893, -0.021599436178803444, -0.015889307484030724, 0.0080144964158535, 0.001188920228742063, 0.013050730340182781, 0.022075364366173744, -0.02367970533668995, 0.04990766942501068, -0.0885508805513382, 0.014940432272851467, -0.021302418783307076, -0.022017208859324455, -0.01652143895626068, 0.026565182954072952, 0.008661845698952675, 0.00713455630466342, -0.03706044703722, -0.022904101759195328, -0.019776491448283195, -0.043518614023923874, 0.06326955556869507, 0.0035755890421569347, 0.01129525899887085, 0.04068883880972862, -0.06559699028730392, -0.061260707676410675, -0.03237146511673927, -0.06544175744056702, 0.06866580992937088, -0.06082705035805702, -0.054130807518959045, 0.02130310982465744, -0.00910636130720377, -0.042435575276613235, 0.0030905413441359997, -0.0400969423353672, 0.005135116167366505, 0.018487464636564255, -0.05367579311132431, 0.012735237367451191, 0.02805219404399395, -0.023476015776395798, 0.02138061635196209, -0.04038523882627487, -0.0520964190363884, 0.024492263793945312, -0.07282622158527374, -0.018775347620248795, 0.0107093071565032, -0.027964677661657333, 0.00855135265737772, 0.029029378667473793, -0.042820196598768234, 0.030381569638848305, 0.011305727064609528, 0.036724064499139786, -0.012962001375854015, 0.0011115818051621318, 0.030794231221079826, 0.0018824449507519603, 0.046727944165468216, -0.004034065175801516, 0.00461024371907115, -0.06032118946313858, -0.029422137886285782, 0.010585782118141651, 0.05548293516039848, -0.02587241120636463, -0.017298623919487, 0.044950053095817566, 0.05094318091869354, -0.023101234808564186, 0.06421437114477158, -0.07572273164987564, 0.021732425317168236, -0.0039001931436359882, -0.029649807140231133, -0.01693214476108551, -0.004436251241713762, -0.0029542529955506325, -0.01477795746177435, -0.014876614324748516, 0.007333421614021063, 0.007884528487920761, -0.00984219554811716, -0.004891243763267994, 0.04750292748212814, 0.01913747750222683, -0.0005192602402530611, -0.06662189960479736, -0.000199090747628361, 0.06397710740566254, 0.011718809604644775, 0.006671184673905373, 0.0023103326093405485, 0.007962455041706562, 0.0095370477065444, 0.10390584915876389, -0.019938999786973, -0.023704076185822487, -0.030007610097527504, 0.05562343820929527, -0.012106088921427727, -0.020751452073454857, 0.0597335547208786, -0.025131504982709885, -0.03063664399087429, -0.028467850759625435, 0.021931851282715797, 0.014837944880127907, -0.011680474504828453, 0.008096620440483093, -0.03669339045882225, -0.02484229765832424, -0.01535156462341547, -0.04639316722750664, 0.02212083898484707, 0.04065026715397835, -0.02160242199897766, 0.07370945066213608, 0.00008742437785258517, 0.034725017845630646, -0.051810428500175476, 0.04581407085061073, 0.007011515088379383, -0.016404205933213234, 0.009175722487270832, -0.04030223563313484, 0.07836126536130905, -0.006733521819114685, 0.014570026658475399, -0.02072114124894142, -0.06363318860530853, 0.001924222451634705, -0.003428572788834572, -0.014026319608092308, -0.020664850249886513, 0.01296910084784031, 0.02475096844136715, 0.00612439401447773, -0.015404406934976578, 0.047098662704229355, 0.03693090379238129, 0.020871473476290703, -0.035509660840034485, -0.028370872139930725, -0.01782248169183731, -0.021481256932020187, -0.006369014736264944, 0.012918165884912014, -0.019823264330625534, -0.03450397402048111, -0.019670985639095306, -0.05595821887254715, -0.06218455359339714, 0.02401179075241089, -0.01267075166106224, 0.03312534838914871, 0.013223194517195225, -0.019399678334593773, -0.046512678265571594, -0.011399162001907825, -0.009867047891020775, -0.02390243485569954, -0.09490223228931427, 0.037842243909835815, -0.04783600568771362, 0.024542000144720078, 0.016559481620788574, -0.022047385573387146, 0.06636074930429459, 0.028013968840241432, 0.040624119341373444, -0.06490924954414368, -0.006205915939062834, 0.04961415380239487, 0.0582195445895195, -0.030963802710175514, -0.0031984595116227865, -0.02526339702308178, 0.005667993798851967, 0.02789360098540783, -0.018404928967356682, -0.015647834166884422, 0.030303532257676125, 0.0030649714171886444, 0.041244618594646454, -0.02451556734740734, 0.013492973521351814, 0.009950041770935059, 0.01212063804268837, 0.047539833933115005, 0.027900826185941696, -0.0017961905105039477, 0.00018972968973685056, -0.047095030546188354, 0.016881778836250305, 0.035057272762060165, -0.036789387464523315, 0.03034380078315735, -0.006680702790617943, 0.02345898188650608, 0.02566639892756939, 0.015882108360528946, 0.03222128376364708, -0.09879929572343826, -0.006342372391372919, 0.029491985216736794, -0.04432424530386925, -0.030952034518122673, 0.031090939417481422, 0.013675014488399029, 0.026702260598540306, 0.0046372925862669945, 0.005239860620349646, 0.057853732258081436, -0.04473872855305672, -0.054214224219322205, 0.027338629588484764, -0.04197424650192261, 0.03483733907341957, 0.0018801888218149543, -0.037902168929576874, 0.013944417238235474, -0.007923978380858898, -0.05331721901893616, -0.04576156288385391, 0.0864991545677185, 0.06651125848293304, 0.07370144873857498, -0.04300199821591377, -0.023592177778482437, 0.0075301965698599815, 0.0461859256029129, -0.04697954282164574, -0.0071870749816298485, -0.010761922225356102, 0.029012370854616165, -0.004120274912565947, -0.07619689404964447, 0.009825940243899822, 0.057916250079870224, 0.06072087958455086, -0.029453085735440254, -0.03878764808177948, 0.006553639657795429, 0.034924451261758804, -0.06704248487949371, -0.07691315561532974, -0.0008466395083814859, -0.04955730587244034, -0.008700166828930378, 0.012175030075013638, 0.04874476045370102, -0.04543030634522438, 0.03774464502930641, 0.023482877761125565, 0.07024700939655304, 0.046032749116420746, 0.007414109539240599, 0.05319428816437721, 0.0014545570593327284, 0.011716430075466633, 0.014559042640030384, -0.04273670166730881, 0.04061879590153694, 0.005675162188708782, 0.004017157014459372, -0.00820979941636324, -0.04477531462907791, 0.045536670833826065, 0.025522811338305473, 0.05026537925004959, 0.02092606946825981, -0.0016149585135281086, -0.041603971272706985, -0.014619656838476658, 0.01859268546104431, -0.06399698555469513, 0.01222305279225111, 0.02583603747189045, 0.04783304035663605, -0.035336852073669434, 0.061483126133680344, -0.02457468770444393, -0.026727095246315002, 0.04705652967095375, 0.02576659806072712, -0.014029532670974731, -0.04934453219175339, -0.022123374044895172, -0.04292527586221695, 0.017952285706996918, 0.001330821542069316, -0.003906778525561094, -0.0069512780755758286, -0.05302292853593826, 0.00836220383644104, 0.12080324441194534, -0.0682854875922203, 0.039576783776283264, -0.05797530338168144, 0.008374430239200592, 0.07871215790510178, -0.04119899496436119, -0.016778405755758286, 0.003686186159029603, 0.04876193776726723, -0.03747982904314995, -0.053966693580150604, -0.007214072626084089, -0.009489534422755241, 0.005861023440957069, -0.037061262875795364, 0.030616506934165955, 0.031516093760728836, 0.0002523699658922851, 0.014502923004329205, 0.0324888676404953, -0.030259311199188232, 0.01684829592704773, -0.0033504830207675695, 0.011052712798118591, 0.04347582533955574, -0.006910719908773899, 0.05849619582295418, 0.060214363038539886, -0.03293547034263611, 0.019581085070967674, -0.037454936653375626, -0.005998318549245596, 0.03659559786319733, 0.012335755862295628, -0.0318862609565258, 0.009928938001394272, -0.03688700869679451, -0.05128790810704231, 0.013153829611837864, -0.03622093424201012, 0.0199589803814888, -0.0002096647658618167, 0.05040304735302925, -0.005420007277280092, -0.04579374939203262, 0.054468341171741486, -0.009636957198381424, -0.02013765461742878, 0.022910980507731438, 0.023249883204698563, -0.03875216469168663, -0.07248396426439285, 0.036975473165512085, 0.014745060354471207, -0.003479071194306016, 0.0051030986942350864, -0.00007457385800080374, 0.04189630597829819, 0.012113667093217373, 0.008270426653325558, -0.006446316838264465, 0.03169408068060875, -0.004066781606525183, -0.015235104598104954, 0.061203934252262115, 0.01388726755976677, -0.05402998998761177, -0.03180083632469177, -0.009919923730194569, 0.029660046100616455, -0.08509543538093567, -0.03121180832386017, 0.03793352097272873, -0.04897142946720123, 0.005111589562147856, -0.016352493315935135, 0.01547746267169714, -0.03377796337008476, -0.055026762187480927, -0.0381154865026474, -0.025006478652358055, 0.03280773013830185, -0.012096930295228958, -0.020201610401272774, 0.044704679399728775, -0.011056821793317795, 0.003410108620300889, -0.060702938586473465, -0.04906933382153511, -0.0034765705931931734, -0.0005701438640244305, -0.027916518971323967, 0.005643748212605715, -0.02416747622191906, 0.05194641277194023, 0.026536835357546806, -0.03472761809825897, 0.042812854051589966, -0.01027266401797533, -0.009777812287211418, -0.048327866941690445, 0.04573090374469757, -0.06343861669301987, 0.006474441848695278, -0.03877323865890503, 0.012666402384638786, -0.012086019851267338, -0.02915821224451065, -0.04057862609624863, -0.0018597024027258158, 0.0014162674779072404, 0.01639634184539318, 0.0569571778178215, -0.045342426747083664, -0.004889930598437786, -0.02357690967619419, -0.014583160169422626, -0.03961541876196861, -0.024779321625828743, -0.01861952804028988, -0.015058530494570732, -0.01578553020954132, -0.0010545827681198716, 0.011838709935545921, -0.0034534670412540436, 0.013855820521712303, -0.06576833873987198, 0.019149307161569595, -0.025849778205156326, 0.0033614879939705133, -0.0022026924416422844, 0.022993065416812897, 0.02384617179632187, -0.04666192829608917, 0.016018008813261986, -0.01319901179522276, -0.032309334725141525, -0.00974156055599451, 0.0057068788446486, -0.06382980197668076, -0.05403699353337288, 0.01643017679452896, 0.0072193448431789875, 0.03944486007094383, 0.014142847619950771, 0.016299784183502197, 0.03790868818759918, 0.06482244282960892, 0.005515873897820711, -0.03732050210237503, 0.03914269059896469, -0.02219121716916561, 0.07086796313524246, 0.1015511080622673, -0.01549199316650629, 0.027877729386091232, -0.0001278728450415656, -0.05515650659799576, 0.0077163539826869965, -0.07352306693792343, 0.059380799531936646, 0.010982871986925602, -0.04703909158706665, -0.028026806190609932, -0.02696848288178444, 0.002845204435288906, -0.024504784494638443 ]
<p>I'm trying to calculate the 'instantaneous' semi-major axis of a binary system with two equal (known) mass stars for an $N$-body simulation. I know their velocities and positions at a given time, but am unsure how best to calculate the semi-major axis. I tried using the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vis-viva_equation" rel="nofollow">vis-viva equation</a> </p> <p>$$v^2 ~=~ G(M_1 + M_2)\cdot(2/r - 1/a) $$</p> <p>However I'm not sure if $r$ should be the distance between the two masses or the distance to the centre of mass and whether the $M$'s should be the masses or the sum and the reduced mass? Whatever I try the semi-major axis seems to oscillate over the orbit at around the correct value, but surely it should be constant? Any advice would be brilliant, thanks.</p> <p>edit: Not allowed to answer my own question yet, but I'm an idiot and wasn't doing relative velocities, thanks guys.</p>
g1662
[ 0.028504978865385056, 0.007122419774532318, 0.02214222587645054, 0.008561670780181885, -0.009988187812268734, -0.0564437136054039, 0.03415980935096741, 0.011692737229168415, -0.02262144722044468, 0.05437843129038811, -0.007958533242344856, 0.06154043599963188, -0.01870054192841053, 0.009283558465540409, 0.08560007810592651, -0.02669062279164791, -0.043781474232673645, -0.024531861767172813, -0.010192293673753738, 0.06963540613651276, 0.041080523282289505, 0.001919835340231657, 0.012846935540437698, 0.021991530433297157, 0.042886193841695786, -0.009398738853633404, -0.008104633539915085, 0.04392053931951523, -0.012293682433664799, 0.028784500434994698, 0.01354271825402975, 0.03285941109061241, 0.06644661724567413, -0.001858687843196094, -0.002832947298884392, 0.06477872282266617, -0.0692143365740776, -0.04613248631358147, 0.0016512334113940597, -0.04257533699274063, 0.0037017595022916794, -0.06168747693300247, 0.03090488351881504, 0.030165761709213257, 0.0009292099857702851, -0.06784046441316605, -0.034230221062898636, -0.03175981715321541, -0.049758706241846085, -0.011353809386491776, 0.0003640242211986333, 0.00910928100347519, 0.1066894680261612, -0.012586049735546112, -0.017421983182430267, 0.02229635789990425, 0.05585446208715439, -0.017064262181520462, -0.009501469321548939, 0.04883241280913353, 0.0680386945605278, -0.06336858123540878, -0.06004595011472702, -0.009445970878005028, 0.026327557861804962, -0.021756285801529884, -0.07251853495836258, 0.025945084169507027, -0.01649777777493, 0.013789942488074303, 0.003752028103917837, 0.021743841469287872, 0.03424011915922165, -0.028495650738477707, -0.045839786529541016, -0.036561597138643265, 0.004827879834920168, -0.04976219683885574, 0.01700356788933277, -0.0015436605317518115, 0.045337382704019547, 0.0072179026901721954, 0.06874607503414154, 0.0699138343334198, -0.007409786339849234, -0.043412044644355774, 0.015651246532797813, -0.00217048660852015, -0.03184632584452629, 0.0006909483345225453, 0.014374179765582085, 0.0028469946701079607, 0.030635258182883263, 0.00375157012604177, 0.0005900682299397886, -0.044363513588905334, -0.06963884830474854, 0.09588822722434998, 0.005332413595169783, 0.055212803184986115, 0.011311428621411324, 0.04722825437784195, -0.004107280168682337, -0.0309801883995533, 0.0041237156838178635, -0.027102816849946976, 0.03513287007808685, 0.0360848531126976, -0.05313101038336754, -0.019403185695409775, -0.06386381387710571, -0.124491386115551, -0.007898068986833096, 0.0059156534262001514, -0.0609886571764946, -0.0060196490958333015, 0.023541992530226707, -0.010616584680974483, -0.013360539451241493, 0.024388011544942856, -0.019331246614456177, 0.010950879193842411, -0.054217882454395294, 0.04806313291192055, -0.006486610975116491, -0.056861814111471176, -0.03833979368209839, 0.04831115901470184, 0.018914025276899338, 0.0206459891051054, -0.03101462684571743, -0.04389889910817146, 0.0036230075638741255, 0.02852972038090229, -0.017911601811647415, 0.06593833118677139, -0.011894055642187595, -0.05589304119348526, -0.03433958441019058, -0.023918338119983673, 0.021764986217021942, -0.021490588784217834, -0.04892801493406296, -0.005938997957855463, 0.004066862165927887, 0.024439238011837006, -0.04648738354444504, -0.034930240362882614, 0.04806248098611832, -0.014018557965755463, 0.017320731654763222, 0.07226710766553879, -0.014540131203830242, -0.03786624222993851, 0.0012707874411717057, 0.01142212375998497, 0.0077386233024299145, 0.003480785060673952, -0.05040135607123375, -0.0287068709731102, 0.03848595917224884, 0.002744010416790843, 0.05196210369467735, -0.04743768274784088, -0.014072919264435768, 0.04868145287036896, 0.02304822951555252, -0.05500497296452522, -0.006949150003492832, -0.034166205674409866, -0.03311127424240112, -0.04199805110692978, 0.02922705188393593, 0.03454512357711792, 0.014636180363595486, -0.022573521360754967, -0.007676714099943638, -0.010066869668662548, -0.01904449425637722, 0.02328980155289173, -0.026484360918402672, 0.00039111339719966054, -0.020264461636543274, -0.017808394506573677, -0.03359314426779747, -0.05109219625592232, 0.002376600168645382, 0.0527128241956234, -0.07953369617462158, 0.0002700038894545287, 0.011656975373625755, -0.03515412658452988, 0.02621442824602127, 0.011276844888925552, -0.0381728895008564, 0.04582328721880913, 0.011446771211922169, -0.05443901568651199, 0.002917727455496788, 0.03767425939440727, -0.017320239916443825, -0.005721271503716707, 0.06130264699459076, 0.03311232477426529, -0.0005746243987232447, -0.015102339908480644, -0.03128451481461525, -0.018037116155028343, 0.018461227416992188, -0.016671914607286453, -0.0018135696882382035, -0.028355147689580917, 0.004481387324631214, 0.009412053041160107, -0.04993767291307449, -0.000056938060879474506, -0.021458934992551804, -0.007242998108267784, -0.023937232792377472, 0.04735080152750015, 0.048680540174245834, -0.0245363786816597, 0.0738048404455185, -0.016556059941649437, -0.00929651502519846, -0.011894372291862965, 0.00017127746832557023, 0.050717033445835114, 0.002908717142418027, -0.00995935034006834, -0.002836280968040228, 0.03539876267313957, 0.03130234032869339, 0.005446185357868671, 0.04407554492354393, -0.02355608530342579, -0.025805285200476646, 0.05552658066153526, 0.057877082377672195, 0.014254286885261536, 0.07608546316623688, -0.025457872077822685, 0.02416292205452919, 0.034892015159130096, -0.010195443406701088, -0.04710491746664047, 0.06866423785686493, 0.033102985471487045, 0.032584842294454575, 0.025371231138706207, -0.01977061666548252, -0.005093749146908522, -0.037889834493398666, -0.013772829435765743, 0.011134552769362926, 0.002428349107503891, -0.06632005423307419, 0.007900217548012733, -0.06248863786458969, 0.03223530948162079, -0.043525636196136475, -0.020954586565494537, -0.004590763244777918, 0.0592457577586174, 0.03090081550180912, 0.014695118181407452, -0.030300989747047424, -0.04451510310173035, 0.021958939731121063, -0.019385622814297676, -0.030477453023195267, 0.004383634310215712, -0.04584309458732605, 0.022196250036358833, -0.03403734415769577, -0.002409260254353285, 0.023636510595679283, 0.011843595653772354, -0.011549210175871849, 0.05151202902197838, -0.01817511022090912, -0.022117845714092255, -0.014559897594153881, 0.01960861124098301, 0.06262581795454025, -0.006450322922319174, 0.057197414338588715, 0.03778189793229103, 0.023384835571050644, -0.023747963830828667, 0.019670238718390465, 0.04262407124042511, -0.008475266396999359, 0.045224759727716446, -0.04425987973809242, 0.08680285513401031, 0.05250422656536102, 0.022329486906528473, 0.040610626339912415, 0.015454416163265705, 0.042141351848840714, -0.046972669661045074, 0.008074408397078514, 0.014157693833112717, -0.051641348749399185, -0.022580008953809738, -0.013178117573261261, -0.06252582371234894, 0.014493291266262531, -0.006909775082021952, 0.024746792390942574, -0.020970415323972702, -0.004200560972094536, -0.02604801580309868, -0.012827946804463863, 0.013902134262025356, 0.020317522808909416, -0.01862744241952896, 0.009416187182068825, 0.019612392410635948, -0.041985347867012024, -0.02868889644742012, 0.01919654756784439, 0.05505375191569328, -0.007562519051134586, 0.011427541263401508, 0.0458134301006794, -0.0015166301745921373, -0.03329984098672867, 0.02378072962164879, -0.012008302845060825, 0.04517577216029167, -0.022104771807789803, 0.015577255748212337, 0.008601966314017773, -0.07606656104326248, 0.04755225032567978, 0.004289789590984583, -0.027227865532040596, -0.017464090138673782, -0.02645999938249588, -0.021928761154413223, -0.017088858410716057, -0.010721567086875439, -0.0025394330732524395, -0.001866486738435924, 0.014271545223891735, -0.029280660673975945, 0.017174813896417618, -0.07346093654632568, -0.003338680136948824, -0.005455031059682369, -0.013323484919965267, -0.031773295253515244, -0.01860322803258896, 0.05317075178027153, 0.014996115118265152, -0.0036612972617149353, 0.001756848650984466, -0.014351263642311096, -0.026762710884213448, -0.038538333028554916, -0.04039056971669197, 0.10572651028633118, 0.014389358460903168, -0.04254229739308357, -0.026366908103227615, -0.004399821162223816, 0.006563270930200815, -0.02777389995753765, -0.059299226850271225, 0.01657726801931858, 0.05655880272388458, -0.046830303966999054, -0.03649544343352318, -0.05384963005781174, 0.029347309842705727, -0.009169595316052437, -0.030765926465392113, 0.040669143199920654, 0.024273937568068504, -0.01935088448226452, 0.014254097826778889, 0.009452283382415771, -0.03023790940642357, -0.01506069116294384, -0.04439038038253784, 0.030500680208206177, 0.09326832741498947, -0.09703094512224197, 0.04405265301465988, -0.03726103901863098, -0.021005971357226372, -0.015037006698548794, 0.03908400237560272, -0.018284358084201813, -0.0028588525019586086, -0.009612630121409893, -0.0161063764244318, -0.02261657640337944, 0.013519340194761753, -0.006246645003557205, -0.03434640169143677, -0.019175978377461433, -0.02907555364072323, 0.031246915459632874, -0.0509396456182003, -0.02636164054274559, 0.015645595267415047, 0.044555362313985825, -0.0005338738556019962, 0.03019958734512329, 0.035257838666439056, -0.03524959459900856, 0.005505355540663004, 0.033564601093530655, -0.04594474285840988, 0.0014265753561630845, 0.03394823148846626, 0.0809640884399414, -0.027577929198741913, -0.03078465722501278, -0.03072579950094223, -0.08570906519889832, 0.0019937267061322927, 0.054166119545698166, 0.04561491683125496, -0.029311155900359154, 0.0394308939576149, 0.009081144817173481, 0.03421560302376747, 0.020381290465593338, 0.019957538694143295, 0.10042459517717361, -0.0701298713684082, 0.06575125455856323, 0.033084336668252945, 0.007669629994779825, 0.03313051909208298, -0.02820114605128765, 0.024333694949746132, 0.0036334721371531487, -0.018270079046487808, -0.01655746065080166, -0.056053563952445984, 0.00383524177595973, 0.013988403603434563, -0.05088137835264206, -0.008390596136450768, -0.11032161116600037, -0.04540148004889488, 0.018788672983646393, 0.0605708509683609, -0.01840795762836933, -0.0005182941094972193, -0.030139045789837837, -0.01614217273890972, -0.004425064194947481, 0.03322120010852814, 0.012467268854379654, 0.022659270092844963, 0.012339059263467789, 0.02879084274172783, 0.03709588199853897, 0.04166116192936897, -0.009884540922939777, 0.010406077839434147, -0.016662469133734703, 0.033754460513591766, -0.010603290982544422, -0.06693436950445175, 0.008275803178548813, 0.0321829691529274, 0.002192479558289051, 0.00013391401444096118, -0.0034863115288317204, -0.022894328460097313, -0.016455747187137604, 0.03988141939043999, 0.027657123282551765, -0.08012771606445312, 0.006431694142520428, 0.01773783378303051, 0.04686674475669861, 0.03015277534723282, 0.020171362906694412, -0.023174656555056572, -0.05258188769221306, 0.04581191763281822, 0.00895704049617052, 0.00021051205112598836, -0.05337417125701904, -0.025362584739923477, -0.05863858759403229, 0.05695867910981178, -0.07430770248174667, 0.012899341993033886, 0.0007061462383717299, -0.010216092690825462, -0.004651753231883049, -0.0523558109998703, 0.04947798699140549, 0.009930672124028206, -0.007869753986597061, -0.022662537172436714, 0.038347505033016205, 0.011394545435905457, -0.018103154376149178, -0.04083928093314171, 0.06441617757081985, 0.020196877419948578, 0.0016298139235004783, 0.048370361328125, 0.02664453163743019, -0.07561319321393967, -0.052051473408937454, 0.0427481010556221, 0.01649177074432373, 0.01244585495442152, -0.11245396733283997, 0.02295503206551075, -0.026627546176314354, 0.016350654885172844, 0.03177081048488617, 0.049627210944890976, -0.04002373293042183, -0.014413625001907349, -0.014375928789377213, -0.07745787501335144, -0.0031380571890622377, -0.07778976112604141, -0.06633090227842331, -0.06531019508838654, 0.027230551466345787, -0.03917160630226135, -0.003184146713465452, -0.05578942596912384, -0.03471497818827629, -0.0035528051666915417, -0.00892610289156437, -0.0703936442732811, 0.00290498579852283, -0.010172692127525806, 0.031610533595085144, -0.023176075890660286, 0.016344456002116203, -0.021175911650061607, -0.06145157292485237, 0.046753376722335815, -0.024916205555200577, -0.02758479304611683, 0.028239384293556213, -0.014829471707344055, -0.020828764885663986, 0.006736366543918848, 0.05326404795050621, -0.02904871106147766, 0.009975001215934753, -0.004885928705334663, 0.05265206843614578, 0.07511477172374725, -0.024037528783082962, -0.015877051278948784, 0.04946925863623619, -0.039095766842365265, -0.031155208125710487, -0.0006461977609433234, 0.02435128577053547, 0.06977418810129166, -0.02690032497048378, -0.05215875804424286, -0.0020027202554047108, -0.0022724661976099014, -0.016702434048056602, 0.03549623861908913, 0.04845191165804863, 0.011185528710484505, -0.026864461600780487, -0.0384000688791275, 0.02393011376261711, -0.018877927213907242, -0.005251796916127205, -0.006236208602786064, 0.0264017041772604, 0.04480285942554474, 0.02577008493244648, -0.05337528884410858, -0.03725145012140274, -0.032278575003147125, 0.007878920994699001, 0.017919406294822693, -0.02581319399178028, -0.049367304891347885, -0.08760068565607071, 0.008479871787130833, -0.03682252764701843, -0.006252913270145655, -0.00298508838750422, 0.02134319208562374, 0.01625189743936062, -0.0259229838848114, 0.010769699700176716, 0.04591407626867294, 0.0035897158086299896, 0.018390102311968803, -0.0009415692766197026, -0.026500606909394264, 0.03479127585887909, 0.0006019689026288688, -0.03639444708824158, 0.03400060161948204, 0.06651293486356735, 0.013289385475218296, 0.043648336082696915, 0.03833044692873955, -0.005875007249414921, 0.0022969807032495737, 0.0746736004948616, -0.03143012151122093, 0.0650339424610138, -0.04431860148906708, 0.0024712695740163326, -0.011292217299342155, 0.018419519066810608, 0.06909184902906418, 0.004626729991286993, -0.03608379513025284, -0.042366378009319305, 0.04914624243974686, 0.00023220086586661637, 0.06904049962759018, -0.038576919585466385, -0.004764962941408157, -0.025085175409913063, 0.03567476198077202, 0.03215538337826729, 0.001434622099623084, 0.03452419489622116, 0.010876240208745003, 0.0032249100040644407, 0.005100051872432232, -0.01575525291264057, -0.03972237929701805, 0.027579177170991898, 0.046836238354444504, -0.013436082750558853, 0.029382720589637756, 0.025769703090190887, 0.009731033816933632, -0.0013073352165520191, 0.015022593550384045, 0.011209219694137573, -0.0201286468654871, 0.02023906446993351, -0.03353159502148628, -0.003951892256736755, 0.011025143787264824, 0.023100411519408226, 0.008673522621393204, 0.03681119531393051, -0.03220498189330101, -0.05476285517215729, -0.02105533331632614, -0.007426307536661625, 0.02929280884563923, 0.05015251412987709, 0.051586855202913284, -0.024161256849765778, 0.01797003671526909, 0.027308566495776176, -0.022008845582604408, -0.04940631613135338, -0.02679498866200447, 0.03681102767586708, -0.012709110043942928, 0.007309303153306246, -0.0062687573954463005, -0.023108210414648056, -0.003117478219792247, 0.007031886372715235, -0.013185195624828339, 0.005343091674149036, -0.02123856171965599, 0.030886052176356316, 0.002631593495607376, 0.025695255026221275, -0.014174722135066986, 0.019702419638633728, 0.013172397390007973, -0.026823420077562332, -0.005253779701888561, 0.003923998214304447, 0.008895431645214558, 0.016463816165924072, -0.0179806686937809, 0.01578613370656967, -0.025238053873181343, 0.08039792627096176, 0.07036636769771576, 0.015174304135143757, 0.04106007143855095, 0.023949075490236282, 0.022155694663524628, 0.07810400426387787, 0.03766908869147301, 0.028063660487532616, 0.020619655027985573, -0.02208658680319786, 0.015278068371117115, -0.0017614152748137712, 0.028047053143382072, 0.008832748979330063, 0.025554709136486053, -0.02313923090696335, -0.05636420100927353, -0.06103590503334999, -0.0569872222840786, 0.011311947368085384, 0.047372087836265564, 0.03457385674118996, -0.03527885675430298, 0.01887221448123455, 0.011329893954098225, -0.04406382888555527, 0.0252585057169199, -0.021122334524989128, -0.005197510123252869, -0.06258216500282288, 0.0076711708679795265, -0.07016653567552567, -0.030774425715208054, -0.023775367066264153, -0.021168582141399384, 0.07382619380950928, -0.016689781099557877, 0.03686574846506119, -0.0076102265156805515, 0.014099462889134884, -0.053561363369226456, 0.0035794146824628115, -0.013097233138978481, -0.09922703355550766, 0.013907387852668762, -0.00899142399430275, 0.02522473782300949, 0.011611652560532093, 0.04318965971469879, 0.04288609325885773, 0.07339442521333694, -0.011301960796117783, 0.06440098583698273, 0.017848169431090355, -0.03626358509063721, 0.003277044277638197, 0.02999209053814411, -0.017287811264395714, -0.035434361547231674, -0.04453517124056816, -0.07665003091096878, 0.008872092701494694, -0.07233143597841263, -0.029742226004600525, -0.01215312909334898, 0.014828747138381004, 0.057573676109313965, -0.0479574017226696, -0.015644516795873642, 0.04239990934729576 ]
<p>Are there any ways to convert an <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Autocorrelation" rel="nofollow">autocorrelation function</a> to a <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radial_distribution_function" rel="nofollow">pair correlation function</a>, and vice versa?</p>
g1663
[ 0.042721785604953766, -0.04988420009613037, 0.013959364965558052, -0.1005699560046196, 0.053316403180360794, -0.044249072670936584, 0.05287403240799904, 0.015361757017672062, -0.04431309178471565, -0.031635832041502, 0.00145564170088619, 0.024408916011452675, 0.05456547811627388, 0.026814712211489677, 0.008111066184937954, -0.029514607042074203, 0.04894562438130379, 0.019593100994825363, 0.015116130001842976, -0.013922142796218395, -0.0005306671955622733, 0.024326791986823082, 0.012305567972362041, -0.02375621721148491, 0.023072492331266403, -0.028360722586512566, -0.029324907809495926, -0.016537731513381004, -0.06516328454017639, 0.034297190606594086, 0.017679739743471146, 0.005655248183757067, 0.0780080184340477, -0.02167491428554058, 0.034995730966329575, 0.059837158769369125, 0.002032156568020582, -0.029591668397188187, -0.02480180561542511, 0.038122329860925674, 0.011249917559325695, 0.05162287503480911, -0.005418424494564533, 0.014673723839223385, 0.041986215859651566, -0.0009320793324150145, -0.03989657014608383, 0.0005219531012699008, 0.015761686488986015, -0.012768634594976902, 0.03726005554199219, 0.10871009528636932, 0.03798532113432884, 0.04711262509226799, 0.038584254682064056, 0.04233238101005554, 0.07617789506912231, 0.0046311416663229465, 0.028451332822442055, 0.03401691094040871, -0.06070265173912048, 0.018108321353793144, 0.03594791144132614, 0.006522280164062977, 0.035042546689510345, 0.015891065821051598, 0.004815336782485247, -0.001428664312697947, 0.015407949686050415, -0.0045052627101540565, -0.01237428281456232, 0.005618626717478037, 0.05009394511580467, 0.013725116848945618, -0.0319889597594738, -0.02842123433947563, 0.06407523900270462, -0.035612087696790695, 0.06568325310945511, 0.014693474397063255, -0.020081620663404465, 0.0045556784607470036, -0.003043533070012927, 0.022742051631212234, -0.02967316471040249, -0.02770104818046093, 0.01797429844737053, 0.020889658480882645, 0.008594089187681675, 0.03703050687909126, 0.011513683944940567, 0.050196267664432526, 0.07018090039491653, 0.0344252772629261, -0.04754476994276047, 0.02777121029794216, -0.08632244169712067, 0.06972359120845795, 0.0015667297411710024, -0.027345122769474983, -0.044136758893728256, 0.050993409007787704, 0.04379941150546074, 0.0017714780988171697, -0.05516280606389046, -0.07447968423366547, 0.03885103389620781, 0.013098739087581635, -0.0485394224524498, -0.01893063262104988, -0.04374247416853905, -0.02700958400964737, -0.01290351152420044, 0.014771299436688423, 0.0035764388740062714, -0.05144761875271797, 0.007747883442789316, -0.038436803966760635, -0.0038438700139522552, 0.03026900440454483, 0.03221413493156433, -0.039767395704984665, -0.008834106847643852, 0.02758227288722992, -0.0030139521695673466, 0.0024226319510489702, -0.014756829477846622, 0.021491989493370056, 0.004827841650694609, -0.09258993715047836, 0.05035387724637985, -0.05845329165458679, 0.0407680869102478, 0.032743096351623535, -0.06102431192994118, -0.011154289357364178, -0.0021134326234459877, 0.03054613247513771, 0.00012411695206537843, 0.023121170699596405, -0.012914055958390236, -0.05352611839771271, 0.007082595955580473, 0.01928645558655262, 0.03619999811053276, 0.008619827218353748, -0.035522330552339554, -0.018071694299578667, -0.03401651605963707, 0.06994123756885529, 0.022534333169460297, -0.036904171109199524, -0.06391304731369019, 0.02006976492702961, -0.012297612614929676, -0.004378355108201504, -0.03955361247062683, -0.028913108631968498, -0.020083745941519737, -0.05298444256186485, -0.03267673775553703, -0.04190874472260475, 0.039205633103847504, 0.014947690069675446, 0.011072991415858269, -0.002949206391349435, 0.03550111502408981, -0.0025385399349033833, -0.04571983218193054, -0.022393660619854927, 0.0077235400676727295, 0.005200815387070179, -0.029538428410887718, -0.02741098590195179, 0.03623727336525917, 0.0700242817401886, -0.0430472195148468, 0.00018645123054739088, -0.03279491886496544, 0.0028432270046323538, 0.024860700592398643, 0.0024686495307832956, 0.014997359365224838, -0.03162410110235214, 0.01965579204261303, 0.006714219227433205, 0.0026687104254961014, 0.02756364643573761, -0.11145850270986557, 0.015555198304355145, 0.01135199423879385, -0.015419448725879192, -0.04044923186302185, -0.037775810807943344, -0.026124006137251854, 0.012740510515868664, -0.028851300477981567, -0.023469218984246254, 0.003902277909219265, 0.0016852690605446696, 0.012956143356859684, 0.01931167207658291, 0.023340966552495956, 0.04226969555020332, -0.02260197140276432, -0.027295125648379326, -0.0037002938333898783, -0.021527638658881187, -0.002665941836312413, -0.05424656346440315, -0.05205802246928215, 0.02427035942673683, -0.06458370387554169, -0.01197900716215372, 0.022704625502228737, -0.02867579087615013, 0.006120435893535614, -0.012739213183522224, -0.06914142519235611, 0.03183526545763016, -0.019741090014576912, -0.01668725721538067, 0.04583241418004036, -0.028424659743905067, 0.0077353655360639095, 0.05238369479775429, 0.04236004874110222, 0.027006952092051506, -0.05097617208957672, -0.019771352410316467, -0.01759529858827591, 0.0057733673602342606, -0.00938563235104084, -0.05447171628475189, -0.007425537798553705, 0.045958466827869415, -0.007920119911432266, 0.02475796826183796, -0.04267711937427521, 0.09087122231721878, -0.024327391758561134, 0.025652460753917694, 0.0005787721020169556, 0.040712643414735794, 0.03237537294626236, -0.023253073915839195, 0.00044808172970078886, 0.012115096673369408, 0.028165262192487717, -0.0021563097834587097, 0.018760018050670624, 0.03239000216126442, -0.07697669416666031, -0.015095258131623268, -0.008602206595242023, 0.03896734118461609, -0.022206692025065422, 0.018389329314231873, 0.04033117741346359, -0.06257779896259308, -0.012452980503439903, 0.007547767832875252, 0.03870414197444916, -0.007341452874243259, -0.005834196228533983, -0.05801009014248848, 0.015312006697058678, -0.07494198530912399, -0.004548098426312208, -0.012841903604567051, -0.005966865923255682, 0.04020540416240692, 0.06105998530983925, 0.006511191837489605, -0.038768231868743896, -0.017262261360883713, 0.00327747012488544, 0.008067247457802296, 0.013365507125854492, -0.006899635773152113, 0.06287475675344467, -0.00471249595284462, -0.020144859328866005, 0.020785506814718246, 0.023001056164503098, 0.0027102676685899496, 0.020979156717658043, 0.06604651361703873, -0.00958194024860859, 0.07271263748407364, -0.03473733365535736, -0.00381060061044991, -0.011678372509777546, 0.03174126148223877, 0.017296573147177696, -0.0003336410445626825, 0.08385051786899567, -0.08556393533945084, 0.06876968592405319, 0.04282281547784805, -0.002889145165681839, -0.042209018021821976, -0.0018610057886689901, 0.02120901271700859, 0.019261682406067848, -0.010983172804117203, -0.048903461545705795, -0.004647710360586643, -0.032384343445301056, 0.04140648990869522, 0.0024936061818152666, -0.020076917484402657, -0.023256322368979454, 0.018405131995677948, 0.040927935391664505, -0.011277989484369755, 0.05782675743103027, 0.03281544893980026, 0.0700739324092865, -0.012456358410418034, -0.035008031874895096, -0.1054498627781868, 0.008738101460039616, -0.029042426496744156, 0.04586964473128319, 0.04624782130122185, -0.029631469398736954, 0.05296357348561287, 0.010416386649012566, -0.0361882708966732, -0.0422818548977375, 0.0321209542453289, 0.040704093873500824, -0.03134462982416153, -0.06830292195081711, 0.013784082606434822, -0.01995108835399151, -0.004884077236056328, -0.02316940389573574, 0.026685373857617378, 0.0007559747318737209, 0.008712180890142918, -0.0030551350209861994, 0.031363051384687424, -0.025965668261051178, 0.10094347596168518, 0.028368258848786354, 0.060191016644239426, 0.048894308507442474, -0.06678316742181778, -0.005427761934697628, -0.026341509073972702, 0.06643437594175339, -0.002912119496613741, -0.015505787916481495, 0.004742694087326527, 0.016749810427427292, -0.02726312167942524, -0.0007971260929480195, 0.01440172828733921, -0.01581350900232792, -0.05297181382775307, 0.021600697189569473, 0.05906325578689575, -0.022995082661509514, -0.014361848123371601, -0.04073115810751915, 0.05046168714761734, -0.00660672876983881, -0.05230625346302986, -0.014689736999571323, -0.0267975851893425, 0.04134700819849968, 0.016738712787628174, -0.008961822837591171, -0.02932974323630333, 0.020085148513317108, 0.023283088579773903, 0.021877169609069824, 0.08280065655708313, -0.02432980015873909, 0.014276948757469654, 0.04305027052760124, 0.020684631541371346, 0.029259679839015007, -0.06978869438171387, -0.022423414513468742, -0.008757549338042736, 0.05684173107147217, -0.028119653463363647, 0.014247553423047066, -0.04359130933880806, -0.019133131951093674, 0.0076156542636454105, 0.030618401244282722, 0.01581747643649578, 0.0209602490067482, 0.030098695307970047, -0.01245653536170721, 0.06448369473218918, -0.09195075184106827, -0.04973359405994415, -0.015529762022197247, -0.015957916155457497, -0.050976287573575974, -0.04463443532586098, -0.048372071236371994, -0.008913092315196991, 0.009694733656942844, -0.05426318570971489, -0.04660624638199806, 0.009566946886479855, 0.03783399984240532, -0.00603728462010622, 0.027791867032647133, -0.016140833497047424, 0.04023026302456856, 0.010460978373885155, 0.038001492619514465, -0.009188303723931313, -0.05253112316131592, 0.029667364433407784, 0.01659434661269188, 0.039214637130498886, -0.0007488662376999855, 0.012903235852718353, 0.03741386532783508, -0.02942994050681591, 0.0026654964312911034, 0.0022938621696084738, 0.06210942566394806, 0.022937104105949402, 0.05279753729701042, -0.0036741269286721945, -0.03565068542957306, -0.033872250467538834, -0.002408208092674613, 0.0011004541302099824, 0.06823650747537613, -0.05538390949368477, 0.0013543593231588602, 0.02097085863351822, 0.0006114036659710109, 0.0602523609995842, -0.028860440477728844, 0.06048401817679405, -0.07815591990947723, 0.0270164106041193, 0.007632632274180651, -0.035403136163949966, -0.002135535702109337, 0.02952890656888485, 0.01838466338813305, -0.035717424005270004, -0.030263056978583336, -0.013705766759812832, 0.04614344611763954, 0.029476912692189217, 0.05053534358739853, -0.019626285880804062, -0.08611662685871124, 0.034760020673274994, -0.0512043833732605, -0.0477319061756134, 0.02352803945541382, -0.009809345938265324, -0.019444841891527176, -0.031028246507048607, -0.032332852482795715, -0.03341669589281082, -0.01638094335794449, -0.015282115899026394, -0.03890470787882805, -0.026822810992598534, 0.010179281234741211, -0.018740277737379074, 0.004708307329565287, -0.053542349487543106, 0.032667145133018494, -0.012995620258152485, -0.015902794897556305, 0.014627383090555668, -0.0014018940273672342, -0.05473095923662186, 0.01381936389952898, 0.016460219398140907, 0.006575410254299641, -0.06232510507106781, 0.03845711052417755, -0.0022733286023139954, 0.011615392751991749, -0.012456933036446571, 0.021128583699464798, 0.03697377070784569, 0.021647535264492035, -0.04549136757850647, -0.009540366940200329, -0.059763360768556595, -0.000815544743090868, -0.029477447271347046, -0.061002232134342194, 0.02106166072189808, 0.00969171617180109, 0.05009699612855911, 0.009762355126440525, 0.042689722031354904, 0.025740692391991615, 0.022571098059415817, 0.01796635240316391, 0.04300834983587265, -0.0024499602150171995, -0.01099474634975195, -0.008899201638996601, 0.017940523102879524, -0.042497631162405014, 0.0060590822249650955, -0.04403724521398544, 0.04402196407318115, -0.031172936782240868, -0.09687641263008118, 0.04641110077500343, -0.0027371251489967108, 0.003280195640400052, 0.03266439214348793, -0.059465017169713974, -0.021855592727661133, -0.03505684807896614, -0.0010758584830909967, 0.018229549750685692, 0.011879357509315014, -0.06552481651306152, -0.005833310540765524, 0.04190972447395325, 0.002837597858160734, -0.002334421733394265, -0.04894706979393959, -0.03206036984920502, 0.02657783403992653, 0.008221554569900036, 0.03227565437555313, 0.003235582960769534, 0.049343567341566086, 0.02035488933324814, -0.04267166554927826, -0.06267315149307251, -0.034007586538791656, -0.00967312976717949, -0.01237629447132349, 0.01667318120598793, 0.043410345911979675, 0.0004176159854978323, 0.00742515129968524, -0.025028230622410774, -0.023072902113199234, -0.008074101991951466, -0.04519835114479065, 0.009988724254071712, -0.009487278759479523, -0.0005896992515772581, 0.019663579761981964, 0.02630181610584259, -0.0238896906375885, 0.09352367371320724, 0.007577120792120695, -0.03301888331770897, -0.048008207231760025, -0.03030538372695446, 0.00043152616126462817, -0.020894357934594154, 0.021887699142098427, 0.017548825591802597, -0.08501971513032913, -0.01590139977633953, 0.0006354585057124496, 0.017259519547224045, 0.0032851481810212135, 0.011127252131700516, 0.014414983801543713, 0.012768581509590149, -0.04904237389564514, -0.009983642026782036, -0.012454047799110413, -0.027313126251101494, -0.008255070075392723, -0.0757826492190361, 0.0343550369143486, 0.02664465270936489, 0.0184604674577713, -0.0021219414193183184, -0.0038159082178026438, -0.038638919591903687, -0.0044821701012551785, -0.027898583561182022, 0.022566135972738266, -0.00035202913568355143, -0.03007001057267189, 0.009306533262133598, 0.07802131772041321, 0.004685449413955212, 0.019228888675570488, -0.010771770030260086, 0.02669953554868698, 0.11859125643968582, -0.0064832898788154125, -0.009574508294463158, 0.0074916197918355465, -0.03315066918730736, 0.04465961083769798, -0.007572503760457039, 0.001145453774370253, -0.018783019855618477, -0.020879339426755905, 0.05433055758476257, 0.04330369830131531, 0.008931558579206467, -0.02979566715657711, -0.012440730817615986, 0.007796914782375097, -0.028131479397416115, 0.047197211533784866, 0.01770736090838909, -0.046582095324993134, -0.06115490943193436, -0.027242204174399376, 0.0047407909296453, 0.053639911115169525, -0.01680207997560501, 0.0018472655210644007, 0.014720509760081768, -0.06591252237558365, -0.002910844748839736, 0.0298299603164196, -0.006187302991747856, 0.04011775553226471, -0.008137388154864311, 0.06510315090417862, -0.034877438098192215, -0.0006086107459850609, 0.08410493284463882, 0.04532541707158089, -0.01792912743985653, 0.06757985800504684, 0.021347064524888992, 0.017636215314269066, -0.00955563597381115, -0.05666714534163475, 0.05701642110943794, -0.01861073262989521, -0.07214532792568207, 0.026579640805721283, 0.005542014725506306, 0.002557196421548724, -0.03466473147273064, 0.012153212912380695, 0.013126346282660961, 0.07212849706411362, 0.0629139244556427, 0.04837008938193321, 0.023330874741077423, 0.024868687614798546, -0.026705166324973106, -0.014162257313728333, -0.016938479617238045, -0.045224811881780624, -0.03871970996260643, 0.008230754174292088, 0.019195498898625374, -0.04442009702324867, -0.01650295779109001, -0.03924189507961273, 0.004451632499694824, -0.02983800321817398, -0.011830710805952549, 0.008952186442911625, 0.028467005118727684, 0.031689878553152084, 0.022152651101350784, -0.043586403131484985, 0.0038933136966079473, 0.02063515968620777, -0.08919211477041245, -0.027672452852129936, 0.042401473969221115, 0.0016016614390537143, -0.034281522035598755, 0.050864119082689285, 0.00362820434384048, 0.03741508722305298, 0.08799050003290176, -0.019558843225240707, -0.09288731217384338, 0.012768695130944252, -0.00516210962086916, -0.012702523730695248, -0.021330341696739197, 0.015896420925855637, 0.02399701625108719, -0.03848481550812721, -0.02520928718149662, 0.030256273224949837, 0.005617993418127298, 0.0069189355708658695, -0.07654067128896713, -0.06057567149400711, 0.041833728551864624, 0.008023640140891075, -0.003940115682780743, -0.011044585146009922, 0.0012924206675961614, -0.06501276791095734, 0.03375599533319473, 0.02989860251545906, -0.10022985190153122, -0.006180482916533947, -0.023508422076702118, -0.005947622004896402, 0.017630083486437798, 0.07694949954748154, -0.023603908717632294, -0.042443275451660156, -0.008928068913519382, -0.04785110056400299, 0.029549166560173035, -0.01728041283786297, -0.052634596824645996, -0.0018475347897037864, 0.037568915635347366, 0.0005127029726281762, -0.01995091885328293, -0.01548728346824646, 0.02086031809449196, 0.00570518197491765, -0.018710076808929443, 0.022628990933299065, 0.0011922185076400638, 0.01611419953405857, -0.061341580003499985, 0.05578698217868805, -0.027189120650291443, 0.030347945168614388, -0.02477177418768406, 0.004588482901453972, 0.015324665233492851, -0.04959157109260559, 0.04410292208194733, -0.06657619029283524, 0.010319123975932598, 0.04963962361216545, -0.005175067577511072, -0.021168285980820656, -0.03763897716999054, 0.020674854516983032, 0.02634347230195999, 0.02750793658196926, 0.004074534866958857, 0.0212491974234581, -0.0545438751578331, -0.004234285559505224, 0.0526750423014164, -0.012111217714846134, 0.033057089895009995, 0.013996786437928677, -0.06997185200452805, 0.01685147173702717, -0.025697847828269005, -0.026567569002509117, -0.08195756375789642, 0.009255736134946346 ]
<p>If a gas, such as hydrogen, is pressurized into an air tight container, a force in terms of pascals (or whatever unit you want to use) is exerted, correct? That is what pushes against every surface within the container. But what I don't understand is how the gas can constantly push against the walls without being supplied more energy. Does the force of pressure not need energy, or am I missing something? What about when the force is used to move something, such as in a hydraulics system? </p>
g1664
[ 0.0069873034954071045, 0.05330151319503784, 0.023233868181705475, 0.01620660349726677, 0.012936660088598728, -0.02051536925137043, -0.01552275288850069, 0.017673473805189133, -0.11234065145254135, -0.023061132058501244, 0.004880312830209732, -0.03206164762377739, -0.03905406594276428, -0.01407662034034729, 0.032916486263275146, 0.04646474868059158, -0.002860067645087838, -0.012813422828912735, 0.03455445542931557, 0.04391603544354439, 0.0017924868734553456, 0.01938815601170063, 0.007397866807878017, -0.04188457131385803, 0.011705387383699417, 0.03731142729520798, 0.05462534725666046, -0.0656106024980545, -0.021446719765663147, -0.047483980655670166, -0.0011982112191617489, 0.0037947718519717455, 0.04305311292409897, -0.08572503179311752, -0.016456805169582367, -0.026652323082089424, 0.04809354618191719, -0.03867531940340996, 0.03989894688129425, -0.0487462617456913, -0.0007411068654619157, 0.017482563853263855, 0.010043668560683727, 0.00001249605975317536, -0.017573462799191475, 0.020182045176625252, -0.028393665328621864, -0.03902347758412361, -0.016289735212922096, -0.0042512258514761925, -0.025080904364585876, -0.0032118118833750486, -0.043126482516527176, -0.001135219819843769, 0.06301792711019516, 0.022666096687316895, -0.01614980213344097, -0.01777702383697033, 0.05767330899834633, 0.011292614974081516, 0.014529461972415447, 0.02108020894229412, 0.04275064170360565, -0.0126364566385746, 0.039529383182525635, -0.05731063708662987, -0.025016218423843384, -0.02263820543885231, 0.01889638602733612, 0.041001152247190475, 0.011559922248125076, -0.011687175370752811, 0.03612448275089264, -0.055600039660930634, 0.029685495421290398, 0.02404550090432167, 0.020299002528190613, -0.006451019085943699, 0.012474380433559418, -0.004169348161667585, 0.037631649523973465, -0.05025477707386017, 0.052695583552122116, -0.041104331612586975, 0.09283298999071121, -0.037041958421468735, -0.056790053844451904, 0.015124088153243065, 0.022234352305531502, 0.023408183827996254, -0.013562284409999847, 0.00744006410241127, 0.08834154158830643, 0.04352787137031555, -0.029969625174999237, -0.003998177126049995, 0.012659270316362381, 0.023418962955474854, -0.019216779619455338, -0.0037111928686499596, 0.0003299415693618357, -0.027256207540631294, -0.0013514311285689473, -0.04125151410698891, -0.02887459099292755, -0.022834811359643936, -0.013417419977486134, 0.040040742605924606, -0.0013815495185554028, -0.0691923126578331, 0.02769790031015873, 0.03755000978708267, -0.02576841600239277, -0.03077288530766964, -0.009343638084828854, -0.011841892264783382, 0.08732978999614716, -0.0013497053878381848, 0.0008689929381944239, 0.06046563759446144, -0.019729560241103172, 0.07756394892930984, -0.016678525134921074, -0.03563403710722923, -0.05681813135743141, -0.03291194140911102, 0.048835042864084244, -0.025108318775892258, -0.032109711319208145, -0.028918400406837463, 0.06576637178659439, 0.01720929890871048, -0.016368957236409187, -0.02889731340110302, 0.0318833626806736, -0.01759227178990841, -0.08517783880233765, -0.03910400718450546, 0.01735646277666092, 0.006697845179587603, 0.044461365789175034, 0.03125029802322388, -0.043121565133333206, 0.026597121730446815, 0.00963069498538971, -0.005165270995348692, -0.05083133652806282, 0.024437176063656807, 0.04655888304114342, 0.0018986533395946026, -0.031954556703567505, 0.06952010840177536, 0.013081846758723259, -0.058074165135622025, 0.1007954478263855, -0.021894728764891624, 0.06529270112514496, -0.006356557831168175, 0.01951606571674347, 0.058560263365507126, 0.07858261466026306, 0.01853814162313938, 0.0326257087290287, 0.004105009138584137, -0.08502910286188126, 0.017633890733122826, -0.016222750768065453, 0.005943106021732092, 0.04186682030558586, 0.01672980934381485, -0.05918726697564125, -0.01850321516394615, -0.01033276878297329, 0.0629044845700264, 0.010958343744277954, -0.008622277528047562, 0.08500605821609497, -0.00474817119538784, 0.0346793606877327, -0.04861811548471451, -0.010111602023243904, -0.022663770243525505, 0.06791245192289352, -0.031268101185560226, -0.05671008676290512, 0.02282024174928665, -0.040727101266384125, 0.03842765465378761, -0.050879184156656265, 0.021228406578302383, -0.022176561877131462, 0.03505399078130722, 0.024658771231770515, 0.027750365436077118, -0.0019230484031140804, 0.0007945834076963365, 0.010770531371235847, -0.10536638647317886, -0.02064613811671734, -0.07327844202518463, -0.05890979245305061, 0.011921091936528683, 0.08716471493244171, 0.03893105685710907, 0.041481174528598785, 0.043899185955524445, -0.039389945566654205, -0.007567620370537043, 0.05510133504867554, 0.02049068547785282, 0.01209139171987772, 0.02413029782474041, 0.021717987954616547, 0.01036161556839943, -0.025660837069153786, -0.029075289145112038, -0.017201270908117294, -0.023311078548431396, -0.013637001626193523, 0.018874548375606537, -0.0752580463886261, 0.0004983918042853475, 0.007280952762812376, 0.023797351866960526, -0.09606938064098358, -0.017884161323308945, -0.035341259092092514, 0.0012510461965575814, -0.007352545857429504, -0.007125292904675007, -0.0025149211287498474, -0.014877334237098694, 0.03728710114955902, 0.022656189277768135, 0.0069821784272789955, -0.01595977135002613, 0.004061464685946703, 0.052259404212236404, -0.011068228632211685, -0.01677425391972065, -0.016803499311208725, -0.0671088844537735, -0.02477622777223587, -0.01046141516417265, 0.047261398285627365, -0.04965195432305336, 0.03232903778553009, -0.00710568530485034, 0.06179089844226837, 0.010853614658117294, 0.0055655911564826965, -0.016807399690151215, -0.007885599508881569, 0.02582138031721115, -0.00045222564949654043, 0.012806316837668419, -0.00637632142752409, -0.015635933727025986, -0.0339086651802063, -0.047299839556217194, 0.04598221927881241, 0.024826262146234512, -0.013692104257643223, 0.04535109922289848, -0.0353308729827404, -0.008647502399981022, -0.009276552125811577, 0.02407938614487648, 0.0541686937212944, 0.0034795068204402924, 0.028199441730976105, 0.07568053901195526, 0.030267054215073586, 0.015698300674557686, 0.011208390817046165, -0.03339530527591705, 0.021907251328229904, -0.033931665122509, 0.040489718317985535, -0.012184739112854004, -0.0019963604863733053, -0.0073915766552090645, -0.021219033747911453, 0.0155972670763731, -0.008881421759724617, -0.033471476286649704, 0.055529460310935974, 0.026386456564068794, -0.023370513692498207, -0.0014062681002542377, 0.025784790515899658, 0.023419832810759544, -0.0245368629693985, 0.01401161402463913, -0.04312976822257042, 0.08240587264299393, 0.0008229882805608213, -0.03705306723713875, 0.025061361491680145, 0.022212399169802666, -0.017688294872641563, -0.04379289969801903, 0.003084678901359439, 0.05017167702317238, -0.033951908349990845, 0.018695682287216187, -0.03155703470110893, -0.05109085887670517, -0.06850279122591019, 0.007125156465917826, -0.008198969066143036, 0.015545612201094627, 0.04001632705330849, 0.044897571206092834, -0.07398641854524612, -0.06252222508192062, 0.006518060341477394, -0.023821020498871803, -0.03625926375389099, -0.014678980223834515, -0.03343149274587631, -0.01965467818081379, -0.013241040520370007, -0.018144717440009117, 0.020613448694348335, 0.036323510110378265, -0.017090965062379837, 0.011804039590060711, -0.02789592184126377, -0.037258733063936234, 0.04364107921719551, 0.03629593923687935, -0.02596202678978443, -0.051207270473241806, -0.07756172120571136, -0.024463633075356483, -0.013081556186079979, 0.03809652850031853, 0.020153049379587173, 0.07709800451993942, -0.001723851659335196, 0.011901389807462692, -0.07130099833011627, 0.019816657528281212, -0.013347752392292023, 0.05027026683092117, 0.04366859793663025, -0.014016336761415005, 0.0069242375902831554, -0.015853745862841606, 0.05888926610350609, 0.003674946026876569, 0.030470451340079308, 0.009094356559216976, 0.01618019863963127, -0.028288330882787704, -0.006670166272670031, 0.006696176715195179, 0.010244862176477909, -0.002825741656124592, 0.03142230212688446, -0.02357667312026024, -0.0053618960082530975, 0.04108765348792076, -0.028739802539348602, -0.058529362082481384, 0.03222539648413658, 0.018241221085190773, -0.028706589713692665, -0.029965275898575783, 0.028421800583600998, -0.033409249037504196, 0.016275877133011818, 0.01764451339840889, 0.046728409826755524, -0.06313005834817886, -0.0063402350060641766, -0.06370163708925247, -0.021160418167710304, 0.007147733587771654, 0.041969142854213715, 0.03464018180966377, -0.01281933207064867, 0.02801656536757946, 0.00968679878860712, 0.0034018796868622303, -0.013708754442632198, 0.04826296865940094, 0.09017840027809143, -0.039556749165058136, -0.037496618926525116, -0.003661165479570627, -0.029090290889143944, 0.027869777753949165, 0.011752624996006489, -0.004342858679592609, 0.02199934422969818, -0.015566796995699406, -0.041621409356594086, 0.01101289689540863, 0.04889276996254921, -0.008660470135509968, -0.04137192294001579, 0.005088196136057377, -0.015701226890087128, 0.024609822779893875, 0.05545317009091377, -0.005367138423025608, 0.037457793951034546, -0.011255930177867413, 0.0013866560766473413, -0.023828407749533653, -0.03442802280187607, -0.03275506570935249, 0.02098880335688591, -0.015810996294021606, 0.018039945513010025, -0.0024103273171931505, -0.01404513604938984, 0.060066983103752136, 0.013226509094238281, 0.0055672540329396725, 0.012121670879423618, 0.01745688170194626, -0.005985526368021965, 0.050194598734378815, 0.05228672921657562, 0.048044972121715546, 0.046276193112134933, -0.06799916923046112, -0.02814595215022564, -0.002308735391125083, 0.03156404197216034, -0.01990680769085884, 0.01070429291576147, 0.036757346242666245, -0.02090040035545826, -0.004914045799523592, 0.0282860416918993, 0.0827217698097229, 0.06038341298699379, 0.0331670381128788, 0.02923576720058918, 0.03571266308426857, 0.004850872792303562, 0.004647428169846535, -0.039343543350696564, -0.018822787329554558, 0.007163662929087877, -0.03381738439202309, -0.07537826150655746, -0.0390816368162632, -0.017623689025640488, -0.0634189024567604, -0.014464220032095909, 0.0324837900698185, -0.057075172662734985, -0.030136805027723312, -0.025336863473057747, 0.018378321081399918, -0.019494542852044106, -0.012920443899929523, 0.009443002752959728, 0.04429781809449196, -0.01803993433713913, 0.005026304628700018, -0.030146973207592964, 0.009581777267158031, 0.005906302481889725, 0.01566467620432377, 0.04162805527448654, 0.028411276638507843, 0.027958573773503304, 0.057132817804813385, 0.05173971876502037, 0.00609293207526207, 0.01783210225403309, 0.015050409361720085, -0.005265232175588608, -0.06904520094394684, 0.026315201073884964, 0.00009819403203437105, 0.03029578924179077, 0.025585372000932693, 0.005957044195383787, -0.014183944091200829, 0.007657976355403662, -0.010086351074278355, -0.04162004217505455, 0.026244264096021652, 0.007135941181331873, 0.08338582515716553, 0.016200054436922073, -0.011242181994020939, -0.016061965376138687, -0.008099978789687157, 0.03138445317745209, -0.007488889154046774, -0.0026431898586452007, -0.011295752599835396, -0.022345654666423798, -0.037484314292669296, -0.026662450283765793, -0.010159450583159924, -0.010384669527411461, 0.02613413892686367, 0.02975517511367798, -0.05169469490647316, 0.04211220517754555, 0.052982937544584274, -0.005977310240268707, 0.03677073121070862, 0.007344390731304884, 0.0326080359518528, 0.011452097445726395, -0.03437840938568115, -0.04078174754977226, 0.013792737387120724, -0.06068389117717743, -0.0009019362623803318, 0.06153566762804985, 0.03149151802062988, 0.020432675257325172, -0.04150467738509178, 0.021601436659693718, 0.014412864111363888, -0.03281443193554878, -0.017732953652739525, -0.02961728908121586, 0.0521165132522583, 0.00224857684224844, -0.016473108902573586, 0.008004317991435528, -0.04411157965660095, -0.03566897287964821, -0.00787418708205223, 0.011680679395794868, 0.05161016806960106, 0.07454562187194824, -0.09226416051387787, -0.023040568456053734, -0.02832890674471855, -0.01878318190574646, 0.011990667320787907, 0.0021068830974400043, 0.027627449482679367, -0.06418343633413315, -0.010061218403279781, 0.05052727833390236, 0.003619623836129904, -0.05440162494778633, 0.02868085354566574, -0.06414216011762619, -0.01189742237329483, 0.003527652006596327, 0.027807261794805527, 0.06077517196536064, -0.049529872834682465, -0.0017208053031936288, -0.021572351455688477, 0.0051594749093055725, 0.04439181089401245, -0.0005263820057734847, 0.018357766792178154, 0.05024715140461922, -0.0012036270927637815, -0.030829789116978645, 0.004473809152841568, -0.003315854351967573, 0.0758470743894577, 0.0227363184094429, 0.01907261461019516, 0.055349741131067276, -0.00019097639597021043, 0.012110000476241112, -0.01010545901954174, -0.05187546834349632, -0.024859318509697914, -0.026194266974925995, 0.03856195881962776, -0.02496468648314476, -0.034455556422472, 0.020947787910699844, -0.057960573583841324, 0.05453461781144142, 0.003554607043042779, -0.030171051621437073, -0.023906752467155457, 0.06915353238582611, -0.024332789704203606, 0.0695890337228775, -0.04242932051420212, -0.03881821036338806, -0.0002990208740811795, -0.002617484889924526, 0.005467008333653212, -0.013768243603408337, 0.0533745102584362, 0.06602995097637177, -0.028097467496991158, 0.036305300891399384, 0.06898005306720734, 0.029377005994319916, -0.0782025158405304, -0.01640603132545948, -0.05193042382597923, -0.014509588479995728, -0.006003209389746189, -0.03227613866329193, 0.011906342580914497, -0.03525964543223381, 0.027010707184672356, -0.02524227276444435, -0.016913630068302155, 0.011307703331112862, -0.06282877177000046, -0.027388207614421844, 0.0014281164621934295, 0.015899430960416794, -0.054955095052719116, -0.022210944443941116, -0.026325739920139313, 0.05114216357469559, -0.07566084712743759, 0.028454165905714035, -0.02553228661417961, -0.08128723502159119, 0.057943399995565414, 0.05570334941148758, 0.008069697767496109, 0.004571542609483004, -0.01744607649743557, -0.019114796072244644, 0.004323153290897608, -0.03328688070178032, 0.006444016937166452, -0.061750903725624084, 0.04778534173965454, 0.03386269137263298, 0.04161784425377846, -0.050409577786922455, -0.0010361755266785622, -0.020082274451851845, 0.06608089059591293, -0.05470171198248863, -0.013767080381512642, 0.0027115694247186184, -0.04919308423995972, -0.05052901431918144, 0.013880069367587566, -0.029495859518647194, -0.06956125795841217, -0.022921379655599594, 0.030436351895332336, -0.08217082917690277, 0.05773565173149109, -0.04867296293377876, -0.04347814992070198, -0.014946729876101017, -0.051193397492170334, -0.006875335704535246, -0.0022646000143140554, -0.01744823530316353, 0.0481535904109478, 0.0049065109342336655, 0.09089147299528122, 0.012358617037534714, 0.0011058897944167256, 0.055536460131406784, -0.022530261427164078, 0.01490980014204979, -0.021328773349523544, -0.021658141165971756, 0.011680323630571365, 0.005996672436594963, 0.01364358700811863, 0.024950752034783363, 0.015937838703393936, 0.023055871948599815, -0.030356591567397118, -0.023176519200205803, -0.010436909273266792, 0.013409513980150223, -0.0017616015393286943, -0.01562846638262272, 0.02302263304591179, -0.010927039198577404, -0.011614632792770863, 0.014321320690214634, -0.007338156457990408, 0.07474402338266373, 0.008330895565450191, 0.05101103335618973, 0.05984426662325859, -0.034002114087343216, 0.031465254724025726, 0.04241811856627464, -0.024291103705763817, -0.02717091143131256, -0.05276251211762428, -0.015948975458741188, -0.03151614964008331, -0.0237970519810915, 0.020427528768777847, -0.010740317404270172, 0.044275764375925064, -0.014313271269202232, 0.03122016414999962, -0.032140858471393585, -0.01684391498565674, -0.0050664134323596954, -0.025952041149139404, 0.0024014951195567846, -0.051646288484334946, 0.08050061762332916, -0.007072868291288614, -0.030045265331864357, 0.008820903487503529, 0.03541791811585426, -0.05551251769065857, 0.006949834059923887, -0.01605108007788658, -0.020440639927983284, 0.007084863260388374, -0.026220180094242096, 0.012717563658952713, -0.02578771859407425, -0.042506612837314606, -0.06247127056121826, 0.006882586050778627, -0.012502790428698063, -0.04152418300509453, 0.016053790226578712, 0.02111915685236454, -0.026777982711791992, -0.05286069214344025, 0.06985267251729965, -0.014014228247106075, -0.002770661376416683, 0.014091198332607746, -0.016116080805659294, -0.027963271364569664, -0.027017654851078987, 0.048336561769247055, 0.05257664620876312, -0.03566404804587364, -0.05729646235704422, 0.023372525349259377, 0.07078863680362701, 0.03413792699575424, 0.021227387711405754, -0.026316700503230095, 0.005129954777657986, -0.05823664739727974, -0.026280546560883522, -0.10941417515277863, -0.0342593789100647, 0.04195770248770714, -0.024778222665190697, -0.024885453283786774, -0.013930766843259335, 0.034593626856803894, 0.008438311517238617, -0.07207213342189789, 0.025722810998558998, -0.06063584238290787, 0.012047075666487217, -0.00987231731414795 ]
<p>I worked in my masters thesis with $^{87}Rb$ and $^{40}K$, really small beta emitters. But there are so many other things around in the lab, that I want to keep track on all the things I might get in contact with.</p> <p>Is there any computer program to calculate the dose of the whole decay chain to get a picture of the artificial radiation and supports logging. I don't want to look up all the individual numbers and calculate it manually.</p> <p>Also in my apparatus various clusters (Cr, Ni, Co, Cu, Ag, Pd, Ca....) are produced. E.g. I know chromium(VI) is carcinogen, but the pure metal is not. But in the nanoworld things may change. So is there a database around where I can lookup the toxity of various substances, with an emphasize on nanoparticles? I use nitrile rubber gloves and try to do not inhale something if I clean the apparatus. But this might be not enough precaution. The laser dyes are not healthy too.</p>
g1665
[ 0.04351022094488144, -0.01903269812464714, 0.009478889405727386, -0.03770120441913605, -0.0016080053756013513, -0.031112652271986008, 0.0002346901164855808, 0.04032933712005615, -0.021814174950122833, -0.046662941575050354, 0.0204485971480608, 0.06886459141969681, 0.05812050402164459, -0.010239739902317524, -0.004268385469913483, -0.013680771924555302, 0.04980464652180672, 0.002485239179804921, 0.0011293601710349321, 0.05857185274362564, 0.038986027240753174, -0.021759048104286194, -0.02252882532775402, -0.04761974513530731, -0.02120361663401127, 0.04253848269581795, -0.02530204877257347, 0.02596920356154442, -0.030444517731666565, -0.02322186529636383, -0.010865249671041965, 0.008143954910337925, -0.015080736950039864, 0.03484165668487549, 0.03438359126448631, -0.04266459122300148, 0.027859216555953026, -0.0024379838723689318, -0.0647323876619339, 0.000986760831438005, -0.02477828785777092, -0.00011154721141792834, 0.126962810754776, -0.00495712086558342, -0.007303392980247736, 0.04057561233639717, -0.0027384446002542973, -0.010138396173715591, -0.000996616086922586, 0.010635475628077984, 0.002867880044505, -0.02075314335525036, -0.023265710100531578, 0.0016549528809264302, 0.039852291345596313, -0.013258883729577065, -0.08205734193325043, -0.05317212641239166, 0.010188879445195198, -0.04664458706974983, 0.059530697762966156, -0.006672373507171869, -0.03939422219991684, -0.043133851140737534, 0.002607493894174695, 0.012835592962801456, -0.05001417174935341, -0.01471604686230421, -0.025779126212000847, 0.002730989595875144, -0.012605116702616215, 0.04313873127102852, 0.03045778162777424, 0.02688448876142502, -0.002288141520693898, -0.003112715668976307, -0.003859654301777482, -0.003162165405228734, 0.061697009950876236, 0.04536992684006691, -0.051541250199079514, 0.004007650073617697, 0.06478539109230042, -0.017035406082868576, 0.011052483692765236, 0.020705340430140495, -0.0666782408952713, 0.00024213548749685287, 0.03838658705353737, 0.0005091807106509805, 0.003133655758574605, 0.038551945239305496, 0.04637682065367699, -0.005654580425471067, 0.07107016444206238, 0.010516179725527763, -0.029939085245132446, 0.08091273158788681, -0.013360532000660896, 0.017010565847158432, 0.03424125164747238, -0.03255770355463028, -0.003963754512369633, 0.02508600801229477, -0.020955009385943413, -0.08530934900045395, -0.0011602342128753662, -0.05231558531522751, 0.03575831279158592, 0.023425467312335968, 0.0032075783237814903, -0.021824181079864502, -0.06808145344257355, 0.016533659771084785, 0.08093561977148056, 0.0176630150526762, 0.0300261452794075, -0.08219102770090103, 0.01052501704543829, 0.08022601157426834, 0.01778644137084484, 0.0010185124119743705, -0.03497740998864174, -0.01192212849855423, -0.008497190661728382, -0.035444073379039764, 0.0013523533707484603, 0.0100364089012146, -0.03808065131306648, 0.012415974400937557, -0.02420569211244583, -0.0394003726541996, -0.06781362742185593, 0.08464758098125458, 0.03187140077352524, 0.06852761656045914, -0.026496436446905136, 0.050222769379615784, -0.014920473098754883, -0.06245705857872963, 0.027837228029966354, -0.018776891753077507, -0.041084595024585724, 0.029754342511296272, -0.07317809015512466, 0.06337230652570724, -0.027548188343644142, 0.01292176079005003, 0.011724322102963924, 0.015138483606278896, 0.022128839045763016, -0.06703325361013412, -0.011798283085227013, -0.04810431972146034, -0.03728046640753746, -0.031814370304346085, -0.011100690811872482, -0.045855965465307236, -0.05076293647289276, 0.046454597264528275, -0.007262461353093386, -0.07759879529476166, -0.007971911691129208, -0.0016283289296552539, -0.03359397128224373, -0.003548735287040472, 0.0706588476896286, -0.03188425675034523, -0.009716661646962166, -0.018097003921866417, -0.025571536272764206, 0.026132961735129356, 0.03021305240690708, -0.04083207622170448, -0.01928933523595333, 0.045579198747873306, -0.03917696326971054, -0.004241887014359236, 0.04508034139871597, -0.02032468654215336, 0.018958736211061478, -0.0074632056057453156, 0.06432094424962997, 0.010004820302128792, 0.03361693024635315, -0.032166268676519394, -0.002460067393258214, 0.01807730831205845, 0.042565103620290756, -0.008931285701692104, 0.0277574360370636, -0.010103597305715084, 0.02722507156431675, -0.03554873913526535, -0.0019037482561543584, -0.05978813394904137, 0.0018208075780421495, -0.016986873000860214, 0.02692633867263794, -0.0643184632062912, -0.018219999969005585, 0.0644354298710823, -0.08094852417707443, 0.07330936938524246, 0.03295406699180603, -0.027110930532217026, 0.010226272977888584, 0.00440418254584074, -0.006408544257283211, -0.05265668034553528, 0.03483663499355316, 0.044738590717315674, 0.02019801363348961, 0.020000047981739044, -0.018067343160510063, 0.00759485550224781, -0.008453300222754478, -0.013038787059485912, 0.0355391688644886, 0.012466007843613625, -0.016950055956840515, -0.008492809720337391, 0.030345508828759193, -0.027596620842814445, 0.0375678688287735, 0.030711162835359573, -0.03795205429196358, 0.00713626854121685, 0.03745937719941139, -0.030427370220422745, -0.06977441906929016, -0.020432472229003906, -0.04209074750542641, -0.04403231665492058, 0.047823384404182434, 0.03067515790462494, -0.05832105129957199, -0.03979361057281494, 0.0023293234407901764, 0.05677356570959091, 0.021348275244235992, -0.009948231279850006, -0.034921810030937195, -0.028876207768917084, 0.00589160667732358, -0.04015312343835831, 0.004426606465131044, -0.008079227060079575, -0.02190866693854332, 0.03948646038770676, -0.010272336192429066, -0.012688931077718735, 0.0022040633484721184, 0.03379203379154205, 0.02633882872760296, 0.053452398627996445, -0.06959179043769836, 0.010151359252631664, 0.030131777748465538, 0.02208871580660343, 0.022416356950998306, -0.05892977863550186, -0.0228678360581398, 0.0041779037564992905, 0.0189974308013916, -0.012760523706674576, -0.039220258593559265, -0.028487246483564377, 0.008916765451431274, 0.018396170809864998, -0.0024726539850234985, -0.00493326410651207, -0.016550570726394653, 0.03783852607011795, -0.0030769945587962866, 0.055218107998371124, 0.016678420826792717, 0.06495081633329391, 0.03408431261777878, -0.016194207593798637, -0.033429332077503204, 0.03639071062207222, -0.005580902565270662, -0.02564961649477482, 0.03929806128144264, -0.021499257534742355, 0.0014548029284924269, 0.014593581669032574, 0.051033973693847656, -0.03316650539636612, -0.05646579712629318, -0.037653204053640366, 0.015326589345932007, -0.005433354061096907, -0.06062225252389908, -0.022923115640878677, 0.033796317875385284, 0.022136930376291275, 0.00840954389423132, 0.052973728626966476, 0.045378752052783966, -0.0169583261013031, 0.029322363436222076, -0.025983545929193497, -0.016835356131196022, 0.008303169161081314, -0.1200784295797348, -0.0036369396839290857, 0.06977840512990952, 0.009605596773326397, -0.08901575207710266, -0.04774731025099754, 0.0023468444123864174, -0.007336368318647146, 0.044054847210645676, -0.015030069276690483, 0.053472910076379776, 0.006546374876052141, 0.02936413884162903, 0.023100655525922775, 0.033747702836990356, -0.019741231575608253, 0.039812177419662476, -0.03904682397842407, 0.059052351862192154, -0.0038923511747270823, -0.013915480114519596, -0.05694669857621193, -0.00824601761996746, -0.0007926268735900521, 0.031966958194971085, 0.026990510523319244, -0.03106537088751793, 0.034295205026865005, -0.053162332624197006, -0.03915666416287422, -0.05442452058196068, -0.006209635641425848, -0.04453975707292557, -0.026945745572447777, -0.02096697688102722, -0.016728339716792107, 0.003453022101894021, -0.05147281661629677, 0.07548487931489944, 0.025600491091609, 0.0017040283419191837, 0.03422662615776062, -0.0116642527282238, -0.05929034948348999, 0.03348454833030701, 0.017023442313075066, -0.03367038816213608, -0.044884227216243744, -0.012264625169336796, -0.0009351623593829572, -0.025746718049049377, -0.01036897860467434, 0.05208980292081833, 0.00939762219786644, -0.030220257118344307, -0.03736376017332077, 0.01963106542825699, -0.028930706903338432, -0.036735836416482925, 0.02385738119482994, -0.02012109011411667, 0.06450848281383514, 0.08096539974212646, -0.016123468056321144, -0.03615608438849449, 0.008464870974421501, 0.016782503575086594, -0.04455496743321419, 0.010386071167886257, 0.01778903417289257, 0.010652577504515648, -0.0007386822835542262, -0.06288553029298782, 0.060569293797016144, 0.004307547118514776, -0.001088836812414229, 0.0932191014289856, -0.020156346261501312, 0.0005637487047351897, -0.015246466733515263, -0.0043653398752212524, -0.0011909320019185543, -0.024427779018878937, 0.018503760918974876, -0.02185032144188881, -0.11671086400747299, -0.0680837631225586, 0.01324587594717741, -0.01020761951804161, -0.05162426084280014, 0.019748134538531303, 0.03144870325922966, 0.05973958969116211, 0.03570828586816788, -0.03246232867240906, -0.015415315516293049, 0.026910649612545967, 0.006981037091463804, 0.013839834369719028, 0.03038528561592102, -0.04898373410105705, -0.021724237129092216, 0.03346637263894081, 0.020069804042577744, -0.009389160200953484, -0.006073415279388428, 0.03816986083984375, 0.00577477877959609, 0.044708654284477234, 0.009776853024959564, 0.04265565425157547, -0.04564029350876808, -0.0016415378777310252, -0.03950168564915657, -0.026366136968135834, -0.014855191111564636, -0.0063898079097270966, -0.04143109172582626, -0.019898299127817154, 0.04778487607836723, -0.00009737673099152744, 0.05053957924246788, 0.02964816242456436, 0.029805703088641167, 0.021306032314896584, 0.012208269909024239, -0.035562772303819656, 0.006436135619878769, -0.020086463540792465, -0.017377177253365517, 0.03773319348692894, 0.0051950728520751, 0.014559254050254822, 0.01384380180388689, 0.06726585328578949, 0.016114437952637672, 0.012963552959263325, 0.0029417870100587606, -0.049704018980264664, 0.055501680821180344, -0.057319581508636475, 0.0027724038809537888, -0.050019364804029465, 0.02056111954152584, 0.03450365364551544, -0.0026361371856182814, -0.0779510959982872, 0.006332327611744404, 0.017697298899292946, 0.006644228007644415, 0.03473397716879845, 0.029148539528250694, 0.08856082707643509, 0.04121401160955429, -0.08894117921590805, 0.02448933571577072, 0.0396571159362793, 0.007939856499433517, -0.025583412498235703, 0.03743676096200943, -0.040619488805532455, 0.040131427347660065, -0.0062947953119874, -0.009320852346718311, -0.048016030341386795, -0.0661013051867485, 0.056612394750118256, -0.03893548995256424, 0.029549086466431618, -0.06083928793668747, -0.03372463211417198, -0.020137030631303787, -0.013706430792808533, 0.055573347955942154, -0.019660739228129387, 0.06890998035669327, -0.05086749047040939, -0.0074016558937728405, -0.013601420447230339, -0.0178776066750288, -0.04714618995785713, 0.030531011521816254, 0.012653949670493603, 0.031918466091156006, -0.0005963255534879863, 0.07044360041618347, 0.07424486428499222, -0.03962620720267296, -0.023783361539244652, -0.004911207593977451, 0.015503729693591595, -0.004282159265130758, 0.004934297874569893, -0.012718760408461094, -0.03839081898331642, -0.005681120790541172, -0.10242871940135956, -0.013728347606956959, 0.034821923822164536, 0.041961897164583206, 0.0036158801522105932, 0.032524507492780685, -0.0029711450915783644, 0.03636566177010536, 0.0565292052924633, 0.025565898045897484, 0.028396179899573326, 0.06550273299217224, -0.04912774637341499, 0.02115638181567192, -0.036424122750759125, 0.06792569905519485, -0.02611127309501171, -0.05040191486477852, -0.013662420213222504, 0.02792721800506115, 0.029387809336185455, 0.018391789868474007, 0.01646057516336441, -0.00207146885804832, -0.01088332012295723, 0.00977846048772335, 0.03237326443195343, 0.005920662544667721, 0.002520805923268199, -0.010700385086238384, -0.10285055637359619, 0.019395725801587105, -0.039152972400188446, 0.003945932257920504, -0.029472025111317635, 0.038954660296440125, 0.0020298361778259277, 0.08069437742233276, -0.020808495581150055, 0.03357210382819176, -0.008347149938344955, 0.011266167275607586, -0.012609395198523998, -0.04209709167480469, 0.02175159379839897, 0.03412947058677673, 0.01573098637163639, 0.051435429602861404, 0.021106915548443794, -0.020198913291096687, 0.15606868267059326, 0.004341030027717352, 0.05589653551578522, 0.0014454525662586093, 0.029693834483623505, 0.03240424022078514, -0.015927130356431007, 0.0015296867350116372, -0.03650446608662605, 0.03563366457819939, 0.013937362469732761, 0.002474371111020446, 0.0068451096303761005, -0.03428320214152336, -0.0323454812169075, -0.042732130736112595, 0.016829054802656174, 0.002455087611451745, 0.0034144818782806396, -0.017988957464694977, -0.018551254644989967, -0.056702423840761185, 0.02397705428302288, 0.032009586691856384, -0.001054590567946434, -0.037646085023880005, 0.04496074840426445, 0.009982646442949772, 0.03276556730270386, -0.017849134281277657, -0.02595609799027443, 0.018302155658602715, 0.009960954077541828, -0.026321135461330414, -0.0253343153744936, -0.0005291820270940661, -0.049909766763448715, -0.038564104586839676, -0.004209073260426521, 0.040171608328819275, -0.03188376501202583, -0.012606932781636715, -0.04302401840686798, -0.03692757710814476, -0.040622442960739136, 0.018977416679263115, 0.0049805729649960995, 0.03302381932735443, -0.053828269243240356, -0.003948900382965803, -0.05142976716160774, -0.05889372155070305, 0.04642867296934128, -0.06872859597206116, -0.02077966369688511, 0.015061531215906143, 0.014797881245613098, -0.03154278174042702, -0.016270240768790245, -0.02880559116601944, -0.0511040985584259, 0.03740619868040085, 0.031822338700294495, -0.05927228555083275, 0.04720509797334671, 0.018829209730029106, -0.04590708017349243, 0.014192936010658741, -0.0022552560549229383, -0.06840166449546814, 0.003982852678745985, -0.011574731208384037, 0.05777677521109581, 0.05598157271742821, -0.017949538305401802, 0.030838919803500175, 0.04212523251771927, 0.0181418526917696, -0.051026906818151474, 0.039806824177503586, 0.02865114063024521, 0.004696427378803492, -0.007363308686763048, 0.04361077398061752, -0.008860213682055473, -0.009863805025815964, 0.00810675323009491, 0.03025963343679905, 0.004984548781067133, -0.06485754996538162, 0.00923902727663517, 0.010318090207874775, -0.023338576778769493, 0.022947268560528755, 0.01908038929104805, 0.03533047065138817, -0.007693712133914232, -0.012581421993672848, 0.03269562870264053, -0.04507995769381523, 0.025915075093507767, 0.0005061203264631331, -0.005290245171636343, 0.020893901586532593, 0.011118099093437195, 0.022585522383451462, -0.0271588284522295, -0.049238868057727814, 0.007754757534712553, -0.05469610542058945, 0.00804220698773861, -0.06530154496431351, 0.01267479732632637, 0.021109193563461304, -0.011165176518261433, 0.034159284085035324, -0.00930758100003004, -0.0855027288198471, -0.015701858326792717, -0.0009017307311296463, -0.06452208012342453, 0.0053002187050879, 0.0431731715798378, 0.013713547959923744, 0.01980561390519142, 0.011225973255932331, -0.009112383238971233, -0.01504242792725563, -0.011156290769577026, 0.023689821362495422, -0.0006764053832739592, 0.024683557450771332, -0.0005790379364043474, -0.012059109285473824, -0.07288190722465515, 0.02391842007637024, 0.025447538122534752, -0.00966279674321413, -0.033937811851501465, -0.012343003414571285, 0.006990903522819281, -0.05835492163896561, -0.010545734316110611, -0.02130134589970112, -0.002801559865474701, -0.019010890275239944, 0.040514349937438965, 0.04480438306927681, 0.07694964855909348, 0.008789143525063992, 0.023206837475299835, -0.017215028405189514, -0.003102822694927454, 0.06657969206571579, 0.034819096326828, 0.018564723432064056, 0.014335567131638527, -0.033147964626550674, -0.023133601993322372, 0.014522718265652657, 0.02312934212386608, -0.013188013806939125, -0.0025353096425533295, 0.045485783368349075, -0.008277102373540401, -0.0021802184637635946, 0.041947491466999054, 0.02739541418850422, -0.08359000086784363, 0.059220392256975174, -0.003524240106344223, 0.006604983936995268, 0.02243732661008835, -0.015832150354981422, -0.04528272524476051, 0.0755099505186081, -0.0136200450360775, 0.023141955956816673, -0.010601857677102089, -0.003874418558552861, -0.02078246884047985, -0.004021042492240667, -0.007198240142315626, 0.04046505689620972, 0.013890844769775867, -0.022259743884205818, -0.03765753284096718, 0.000836139835882932, 0.037009939551353455, -0.02358429878950119, -0.05163468420505524, 0.004198293201625347, -0.046835388988256454, -0.04944401606917381, -0.008823464624583721, -0.005388745106756687, 0.045579809695482254, -0.044593095779418945, 0.0013525229878723621, 0.045866094529628754, 0.09015311300754547, 0.010314786806702614, -0.0012295590713620186, -0.01356496848165989, 0.060204505920410156, 0.008311047218739986, 0.019295141100883484, -0.017001435160636902, -0.015986008569598198, -0.019698120653629303, -0.03508368879556656, 0.006623538210988045, 0.011224360205233097, -0.03411444276571274, -0.010435306467115879, -0.0286247581243515 ]
<p>So I know re-normalization has bean "beaten to death". I want to understand something a bit specific which might seem trivial. Independence of the bare parameters on $\mu$ and relevance to the beta function derivation. This seems to be an important assumption or rather fact that is built upon in making further renormalization and renormalization group arguments. In fact, even explicit statements about locality trace to this assumption. Again there is a chance this is an extremely lousy question, but can someone give me a precise mathematical argument describing this independence.</p> <p>I am also looking to put together some reading lists comprising of the original papers treating the subject at a pedagogic level($\phi ^{\text{something}}$ theories). Not those directly addressing the QED problems yet still assuming ignorance of the reasons behind the divergences. Papers making explicit and hopefully proven statements accounting for some of the assumptions taken.</p> <p>I want to know the deal with independence of the bare parameters. </p>
g1666
[ 0.030575282871723175, -0.02699880860745907, 0.005795614793896675, -0.02397638000547886, 0.005320585332810879, 0.013297962956130505, 0.028300093486905098, 0.07880311459302902, -0.011802280321717262, 0.004908093251287937, -0.06991111487150192, 0.043408751487731934, 0.0022896467708051205, 0.03252553567290306, -0.010151181370019913, -0.036586642265319824, -0.03141698241233826, 0.02399115264415741, 0.02575201354920864, 0.014183586463332176, -0.014815425500273705, 0.03302038088440895, 0.05822143331170082, -0.0740714967250824, 0.0032484137918800116, 0.009365895763039589, 0.010026459582149982, 0.01959279365837574, -0.010243665426969528, -0.019337248057127, -0.05388982594013214, -0.017085280269384384, 0.08247512578964233, -0.037207070738077164, -0.05122851952910423, 0.050223663449287415, 0.0791664645075798, -0.0030767028219997883, -0.0012388982577249408, 0.014225136488676071, -0.02165970578789711, 0.025975506752729416, -0.021361788734793663, 0.06173117086291313, -0.013826928101480007, 0.07591798156499863, -0.00472883228212595, 0.018361875787377357, -0.012942432425916195, 0.035725027322769165, 0.04091988131403923, 0.006092582363635302, 0.0890469029545784, -0.005644741002470255, -0.02022000029683113, 0.013240165077149868, 0.014985538087785244, 0.055750418454408646, -0.006515762768685818, -0.0015141877811402082, 0.0012748994631692767, 0.01498123537749052, -0.005086339544504881, 0.030672980472445488, 0.01765403337776661, -0.032459162175655365, -0.015299826860427856, -0.009531262330710888, -0.084129698574543, 0.03316638991236687, -0.024343885481357574, -0.055946871638298035, -0.05235898867249489, -0.009935052134096622, -0.06421316415071487, 0.0071424138732254505, 0.003137766383588314, -0.0427316389977932, -0.016252335160970688, -0.012832711450755596, -0.0517360083758831, -0.0031855027191340923, 0.051875364035367966, 0.029248172417283058, 0.06352228671312332, -0.027332928031682968, -0.00018487700435798615, 0.0026100175455212593, -0.02149169147014618, 0.023113207891583443, 0.04260629042983055, -0.04284230247139931, 0.0025109804701060057, 0.0031853339169174433, 0.013173557817935944, 0.02118602767586708, -0.01033097691833973, 0.007967857643961906, 0.0011679872404783964, 0.02706035040318966, -0.010407567955553532, 0.03250787407159805, -0.006208436563611031, 0.035019293427467346, -0.07418908923864365, 0.022909941151738167, 0.012990925461053848, -0.02298060432076454, 0.032150764018297195, -0.002395806135609746, -0.04882675036787987, -0.004730601795017719, -0.030440349131822586, -0.008851664140820503, -0.0397733636200428, -0.08135658502578735, 0.07822903990745544, -0.07083737105131149, -0.01510382629930973, 0.03363189846277237, -0.04569368064403534, 0.011568362824618816, 0.0019347716588526964, 0.00861404463648796, -0.020641012117266655, -0.03352300822734833, 0.01779271475970745, 0.016229871660470963, 0.004619257524609566, -0.022835521027445793, -0.009254075586795807, -0.05602523684501648, 0.0026273594703525305, 0.0047388640232384205, 0.0033383488189429045, 0.0007304557366296649, 0.0059286728501319885, 0.01822689175605774, 0.010247690603137016, -0.029351186007261276, 0.007805495988577604, 0.011265342123806477, 0.007041426375508308, -0.04985281080007553, 0.04226744920015335, -0.0134971272200346, 0.06404325366020203, -0.02718636579811573, -0.007115751970559359, 0.06714135408401489, 0.003591169137507677, 0.04271627962589264, 0.007801524829119444, 0.022561242803931236, -0.03685366362333298, 0.039072614163160324, 0.042843956500291824, -0.06389053165912628, 0.003881862387061119, 0.0027007523458451033, 0.04880092665553093, -0.07062479853630066, -0.005340742878615856, -0.01878223568201065, -0.025894660502672195, 0.03663034737110138, 0.018286865204572678, -0.08871676027774811, -0.00010616908548399806, -0.05337899550795555, -0.024682285264134407, 0.053542159497737885, 0.019201744347810745, 0.062363892793655396, -0.024683337658643723, 0.04334423318505287, -0.028214652091264725, -0.08202848583459854, -0.043147679418325424, -0.027499910444021225, 0.02447092905640602, 0.05114993453025818, 0.004442101810127497, 0.014710560441017151, 0.03347000852227211, 0.004461305215954781, -0.011696049012243748, 0.07700124382972717, 0.026706162840127945, -0.05140593647956848, -0.009178927168250084, 0.028408169746398926, -0.0477248877286911, -0.014431552961468697, -0.004118920303881168, -0.004199159797281027, -0.015666121616959572, -0.00454611424356699, 0.04927891865372658, 0.0030337681528180838, -0.05332797393202782, 0.04114113375544548, 0.024506565183401108, 0.008261236362159252, 0.013112874701619148, 0.04802539572119713, 0.01067384984344244, -0.007339224684983492, 0.00550119299441576, 0.008457711897790432, 0.016819419339299202, -0.019613994285464287, 0.011662877164781094, 0.016559669747948647, 0.0377875491976738, -0.07028768956661224, -0.005969399586319923, -0.023339446634054184, -0.0062956600449979305, -0.016088087111711502, -0.061498526483774185, -0.03355490416288376, 0.015498146414756775, 0.04661358520388603, -0.003240527817979455, 0.005465076770633459, -0.008297194726765156, 0.0036923238076269627, 0.0034117400646209717, 0.05327347666025162, -0.08412585407495499, -0.05980372801423073, 0.012174874544143677, -0.006441962439566851, 0.0028822962194681168, 0.05268433317542076, -0.017173701897263527, -0.04127794876694679, 0.053808119148015976, 0.036610014736652374, 0.04747631028294563, 0.029184991493821144, 0.012958499602973461, -0.0025281361304223537, -0.011727719567716122, 0.012242858298122883, 0.05868808552622795, -0.05997597426176071, -0.005271051079034805, 0.014594579115509987, -0.0037820686120539904, 0.0322985015809536, -0.0394594743847847, 0.049094416201114655, -0.014705547131597996, -0.04862465709447861, 0.09000151604413986, -0.023083984851837158, -0.01485663652420044, -0.0613231286406517, -0.005856025498360395, -0.023948920890688896, 0.007689098361879587, 0.07665961235761642, -0.03337308391928673, 0.02178478240966797, -0.009064523503184319, 0.042980462312698364, -0.021679874509572983, -0.02834797278046608, 0.03377138450741768, 0.007789884228259325, 0.020832465961575508, 0.06334858387708664, 0.062369219958782196, 0.005838683340698481, -0.011812924407422543, 0.002067748224362731, -0.02094203233718872, 0.024819303303956985, -0.008396288380026817, -0.06994760781526566, -0.030197367072105408, 0.0011151485377922654, -0.021983440965414047, -0.00822229404002428, -0.025553971529006958, 0.015704970806837082, -0.02685941942036152, 0.034874919801950455, -0.0490734837949276, 0.031969912350177765, -0.01545250229537487, 0.04908981919288635, -0.01142914779484272, 0.05367590859532356, -0.019478250294923782, -0.07064519822597504, 0.012432531453669071, 0.02727487124502659, -0.038481470197439194, 0.0028991899453103542, -0.03667616471648216, -0.01386071927845478, -0.0010623658308759332, -0.01573965512216091, -0.041194841265678406, -0.020431647077202797, -0.0687081590294838, 0.008343209512531757, -0.01585506647825241, -0.03704684600234032, -0.0028422861360013485, -0.012678535655140877, 0.023631133139133453, 0.022756164893507957, -0.027430852875113487, -0.023150773718953133, 0.06488018482923508, -0.004667505156248808, -0.059586137533187866, -0.07132846862077713, 0.04713010787963867, -0.03395477682352066, 0.063724584877491, -0.009897172451019287, -0.07035478204488754, 0.023623330518603325, 0.007838662713766098, 0.0223254207521677, 0.08903258293867111, 0.032917626202106476, 0.029057888314127922, -0.0021308143623173237, -0.054762907326221466, -0.04987620562314987, -0.05630948767066002, 0.021531658247113228, 0.045482877641916275, -0.033268481492996216, 0.0027681950014084578, -0.045450255274772644, -0.01415362861007452, 0.03540932387113571, -0.0020849048160016537, 0.04350583627820015, -0.011957201175391674, -0.049222443252801895, 0.01774834468960762, -0.03523671254515648, 0.07069303840398788, -0.004769147373735905, 0.016027897596359253, -0.01288403570652008, 0.007831403985619545, 0.06785329431295395, 0.016324739903211594, -0.018076593056321144, 0.020022012293338776, 0.012799386866390705, 0.015164900571107864, -0.03494313359260559, -0.042544133961200714, -0.010777977295219898, -0.030099432915449142, -0.040045369416475296, -0.009170879609882832, -0.0032358525786548853, -0.04766478389501572, -0.07059022039175034, 0.025626158341765404, 0.028750363737344742, -0.032387252897024155, 0.06370270252227783, -0.01930609717965126, 0.022616911679506302, 0.04445537179708481, 0.041350193321704865, -0.02832457236945629, 0.05382753536105156, 0.03480560705065727, -0.008139443583786488, -0.029844161123037338, 0.053667206317186356, 0.005969275254756212, 0.012334940023720264, -0.03921281918883324, 0.009408248588442802, -0.0005027783336117864, -0.03914840146899223, 0.03666452318429947, 0.008416101336479187, -0.01111001055687666, 0.01801350899040699, 0.02533019334077835, -0.017656920477747917, 0.0025428058579564095, -0.026230240240693092, 0.007629557512700558, 0.09911039471626282, -0.03041892871260643, -0.0382850281894207, 0.01853911019861698, 0.018164826557040215, -0.0214065108448267, 0.013796388171613216, -0.031648579984903336, 0.0012145958608016372, -0.008419699035584927, -0.05441508814692497, -0.029934752732515335, -0.022579265758395195, 0.03250503167510033, -0.04566822573542595, 0.08352798223495483, -0.005187639966607094, 0.03925162926316261, -0.09616047143936157, 0.005643460899591446, -0.026007551699876785, 0.00556159345433116, -0.026828842237591743, -0.019831454381346703, 0.0003935716231353581, 0.046390604227781296, 0.0619928352534771, 0.04950455576181412, 0.004722360987216234, 0.025960370898246765, -0.058185648173093796, 0.059784792363643646, 0.05401228368282318, -0.05059012770652771, 0.016963601112365723, -0.07445845007896423, -0.02304658852517605, -0.047622520476579666, 0.08867296576499939, -0.05726580694317818, -0.058008380234241486, 0.02115868777036667, -0.08499681949615479, 0.010258621536195278, -0.013741843402385712, -0.010160512290894985, 0.004878744017332792, -0.015712378546595573, 0.00797346793115139, -0.05129091441631317, 0.026229429990053177, 0.029461365193128586, 0.05734274908900261, 0.023111317306756973, -0.009706203825771809, -0.009057254530489445, -0.020794115960597992, -0.011648164130747318, 0.006189554464071989, 0.09979157894849777, -0.02551162615418434, -0.052803851664066315, -0.029868394136428833, -0.0446820929646492, 0.011385620571672916, -0.01058733556419611, -0.018538882955908775, -0.0365249328315258, 0.08780749142169952, -0.01019834540784359, 0.03475571423768997, 0.02442750334739685, -0.020077206194400787, 0.05751604214310646, -0.04521734640002251, -0.017661068588495255, 0.01701713539659977, 0.03617420047521591, -0.01694478653371334, -0.013777023181319237, 0.03267606347799301, -0.004063956439495087, -0.04640280827879906, 0.029690081253647804, 0.011555260978639126, -0.005645759403705597, 0.024706853553652763, 0.009675350040197372, -0.07581585645675659, 0.008283986710011959, -0.05588280037045479, -0.005938058253377676, 0.02673274651169777, 0.049247730523347855, -0.029000408947467804, 0.02390093170106411, -0.033400438725948334, 0.05246525630354881, 0.05215071141719818, 0.00017063562700059265, -0.009238813072443008, -0.04170800745487213, 0.0684024915099144, 0.07640228420495987, 0.01677148975431919, 0.001366306096315384, 0.0062039741314947605, 0.03731763735413551, -0.013710950501263142, -0.003032987704500556, -0.007106241304427385, 0.021580036729574203, 0.04287979006767273, 0.02053184248507023, -0.055272407829761505, -0.044754937291145325, -0.018915396183729172, -0.03664330020546913, 0.004496696405112743, -0.022118378430604935, -0.049986470490694046, 0.06717485934495926, 0.0005155539838597178, 0.05416056513786316, -0.07358258962631226, -0.014791009947657585, -0.0171529371291399, -0.07401303201913834, -0.006250485312193632, -0.0294974185526371, -0.010500647127628326, -0.013909800909459591, -0.0002183643518947065, -0.03800390288233757, -0.0012147579109296203, -0.039290908724069595, 0.008445206098258495, -0.0067227124236524105, 0.0029965878929942846, -0.02153930254280567, -0.022853005677461624, -0.054109036922454834, 0.010955419391393661, 0.007083072327077389, 0.0194216500967741, -0.049970727413892746, -0.015882287174463272, -0.006563978735357523, -0.009776771068572998, 0.03792308270931244, -0.03469713404774666, -0.03630944713950157, -0.03463376685976982, 0.003911375068128109, -0.01478536892682314, -0.015871234238147736, 0.05355530604720116, 0.014825744554400444, 0.008272207342088223, -0.08419284224510193, -0.0011938604293391109, 0.028415139764547348, 0.0017528128810226917, 0.06613106280565262, 0.054469034075737, -0.07144947350025177, -0.06929462403059006, 0.07756999880075455, -0.045584775507450104, 0.012541132979094982, 0.04298347234725952, 0.004958576522767544, 0.0075878240168094635, 0.04126863181591034, 0.008531792089343071, 0.00423364108428359, 0.018680576235055923, -0.02874857187271118, -0.0147688128054142, 0.02191942185163498, -0.009834414348006248, 0.018633708357810974, 0.0519019290804863, 0.0042211455292999744, -0.06531741470098495, -0.03765692189335823, 0.06263916939496994, -0.04611192271113396, -0.00010512426524655893, -0.007130139507353306, 0.0007024859660305083, 0.038508471101522446, 0.013080582022666931, 0.012188250198960304, -0.03070945292711258, -0.0018571255495771766, -0.005833367817103863, 0.04089292138814926, -0.005238314159214497, -0.0038858612533658743, -0.03098423220217228, 0.011088641360402107, 0.014251275919377804, 0.007476957514882088, -0.00034553345176391304, 0.0123484181240201, 0.031748779118061066, -0.017955521121621132, -0.010400641709566116, 0.018358197063207626, -0.003852980677038431, -0.0006451812805607915, 0.022984633222222328, -0.003538282588124275, -0.010816624388098717, 0.010516569949686527, -0.036601703613996506, -0.06335075199604034, 0.011219696141779423, -0.02661547064781189, 0.04205703362822533, 0.06978864967823029, -0.036553893238306046, -0.003320506773889065, 0.013125196099281311, 0.005188386421650648, 0.024031680077314377, 0.024302881211042404, -0.011956470087170601, 0.03643296658992767, -0.0009998875902965665, 0.0009994260035455227, 0.026958409696817398, 0.0047721718437969685, 0.06449303030967712, 0.00003227146953577176, 0.08403090387582779, -0.051578719168901443, 0.015402806922793388, -0.05912488326430321, -0.030830981209874153, 0.0012658153427764773, 0.032630257308483124, 0.011014886200428009, 0.006475199479609728, -0.045020826160907745, -0.0736692026257515, 0.02253037318587303, 0.03462699428200722, -0.025345103815197945, 0.07109901309013367, 0.04464075341820717, 0.03409389406442642, -0.018271956592798233, -0.02103075198829174, -0.04214644059538841, 0.01089882105588913, -0.05768222734332085, 0.021504869684576988, -0.058014895766973495, -0.0009178694454021752, -0.023352736607193947, 0.0014507974265143275, 0.018699947744607925, -0.05345556512475014, 0.011004715226590633, -0.019518371671438217, 0.01913447305560112, -0.027454795315861702, 0.07410656660795212, 0.012274223379790783, -0.00014938101230654866, -0.04889417812228203, 0.016685666516423225, -0.01467610988765955, 0.021816054359078407, -0.039665624499320984, -0.0041591511107981205, 0.04691120237112045, -0.058300819247961044, 0.06235330179333687, 0.06840973347425461, 0.040742117911577225, 0.012675357051193714, -0.019024359062314034, -0.028550950810313225, 0.024773841723799706, 0.027896031737327576, 0.039290040731430054, -0.005788569804280996, -0.012461477890610695, -0.043838270008563995, -0.016283312812447548, -0.009148458950221539, 0.020663058385252953, 0.013509460724890232, 0.03462814539670944, 0.04807448759675026, 0.018425611779093742, 0.04829408973455429, 0.026857193559408188, 0.025358209386467934, -0.09857778251171112, -0.06459157913923264, -0.04871177673339844, 0.08275546133518219, 0.0027236633468419313, 0.04732371121644974, -0.024402087554335594, -0.03569089621305466, -0.024190861731767654, -0.0016238613752648234, -0.03266330063343048, 0.03151490539312363, 0.01046049501746893, 0.04382991045713425, 0.03659776598215103, -0.015358409844338894, -0.0056184567511081696, 0.0001095351399271749, 0.027475232258439064, 0.03102678619325161, -0.021276751533150673, 0.008202535100281239, -0.056324511766433716, 0.013095714151859283, -0.020252173766493797, -0.058881912380456924, -0.011632250621914864, -0.0523940734565258, 0.018995976075530052, -0.05127350240945816, 0.0024742265231907368, -0.02102055586874485, 0.0681614875793457, -0.015882570296525955, 0.0391991101205349, 0.05043182149529457, 0.018409917131066322, -0.02130161039531231, -0.012196708470582962, -0.0068789394572377205, 0.034227415919303894, 0.004998463671654463, 0.04200053587555885, -0.07850119471549988, -0.04560263827443123, -0.027342818677425385, 0.02184976451098919, 0.008767420426011086, -0.04992659017443657, -0.011599976569414139, 0.014369887299835682, -0.04765419661998749, 0.024731041863560677, 0.004561532288789749, -0.059227313846349716, 0.005757154896855354, 0.034152187407016754, 0.014744761399924755, 0.0006584731745533645, 0.0022058458998799324, -0.022444970905780792, 0.005872227717190981, 0.00907194335013628, -0.041884299367666245, -0.047408197075128555, -0.023701895028352737, 0.06833972036838531 ]
<p>Just a simple question regarding $\epsilon$, the absolute permittivity. I read that it measures the resistance to of certain medium to 'permit' the formation of an electrical field. Does this mean that given a electrical field $E$, one needs more energy to produce it in a medium with a higher $\epsilon$ ? Thanks in advance. </p>
g1667
[ -0.01584601402282715, 0.029631659388542175, -0.011140692047774792, -0.06022726744413376, 0.04163553565740585, 0.001976780826225877, -0.015793612226843834, 0.0366160050034523, -0.045260000973939896, 0.01493856031447649, -0.022464139387011528, -0.0026913888286799192, 0.044072702527046204, 0.002931221155449748, -0.011802193708717823, -0.020735958591103554, 0.08284246176481247, -0.013602767139673233, 0.001612454536370933, -0.008131036534905434, -0.07592538744211197, -0.026589877903461456, -0.009957024827599525, -0.04023157060146332, 0.10399949550628662, 0.01016770489513874, 0.007749717216938734, -0.004444123711436987, 0.023510277271270752, -0.013778016902506351, 0.009121780283749104, -0.005626849364489317, 0.0662849023938179, -0.0007034686277620494, 0.00024624873185530305, -0.0020883590914309025, 0.010426558554172516, 0.09347932785749435, 0.013176525011658669, 0.014079094864428043, -0.015525326132774353, -0.014628482982516289, -0.04432860016822815, 0.017964420840144157, -0.03422476723790169, 0.025422297418117523, -0.015302379615604877, 0.0009385673911310732, -0.020558098331093788, -0.02930362895131111, -0.004777030553668737, -0.02297240123152733, 0.0073359631933271885, 0.03667992725968361, 0.001375216175802052, -0.022783193737268448, 0.04398655891418457, -0.007330174557864666, 0.05206497013568878, 0.008069364354014397, 0.018013836815953255, 0.03251194208860397, -0.03192904591560364, -0.028503136709332466, 0.04966042935848236, -0.030124109238386154, -0.015656357631087303, 0.034249983727931976, -0.007946294732391834, 0.016754869371652603, -0.007404856383800507, -0.029927315190434456, -0.04416042938828468, -0.04465831071138382, -0.012018308974802494, -0.02307981066405773, 0.02141926810145378, -0.012681704945862293, -0.00625411095097661, 0.022922158241271973, 0.02294505573809147, -0.010462173260748386, 0.009273115545511246, 0.011065990664064884, 0.008553793653845787, -0.02587282471358776, 0.022802159190177917, -0.020036421716213226, 0.009975580498576164, 0.01560173649340868, 0.001074375817552209, 0.0071151042357087135, 0.050519734621047974, -0.0024607961531728506, 0.015785668045282364, -0.009273423813283443, -0.031003106385469437, 0.059979360550642014, 0.011220285668969154, 0.01869075559079647, 0.027898820117115974, -0.05024002492427826, 0.05606890469789505, 0.0007011950365267694, -0.013159084133803844, -0.014336196705698967, 0.024386124685406685, -0.0198656152933836, 0.029326695948839188, 0.009622367098927498, -0.05943857133388519, -0.003643640549853444, -0.03600156307220459, -0.008012287318706512, -0.04752320796251297, 0.04748161882162094, 0.0278830174356699, -0.025612782686948776, -0.013599368743598461, 0.07131551206111908, -0.003745452966541052, 0.059985943138599396, 0.045025087893009186, -0.037035249173641205, -0.06412690877914429, 0.05811117962002754, 0.032897334545850754, 0.009807578288018703, 0.04164442420005798, -0.018551737070083618, 0.005140047986060381, -0.022303227335214615, -0.016860628500580788, -0.07089067995548248, 0.0063535370863974094, -0.01972970739006996, -0.01576097123324871, -0.014760746620595455, -0.008868885226547718, 0.029071321710944176, -0.036275796592235565, -0.03053225576877594, 0.009955511428415775, -0.02341039478778839, -0.015594766475260258, 0.028265463188290596, -0.01807314343750477, 0.025681022554636, 0.058502670377492905, 0.038991477340459824, 0.037209779024124146, 0.0013265867019072175, -0.020457139238715172, -0.04134050011634827, 0.0019899108447134495, -0.030426401644945145, 0.0495171919465065, 0.027150386944413185, 0.008956790901720524, -0.012131291441619396, 0.0010918148327618837, 0.032201915979385376, 0.031655676662921906, -0.0019304287852719426, -0.01667177863419056, 0.03994941711425781, -0.06136155501008034, 0.011209375225007534, 0.012297241017222404, 0.0331261120736599, -0.026227639988064766, 0.028035733848810196, 0.02874032035470009, 0.053547829389572144, 0.0023347740061581135, 0.044585101306438446, 0.03204857185482979, 0.011667096056044102, 0.01789928786456585, -0.0384647399187088, -0.031472671777009964, -0.010457408614456654, -0.008116673678159714, -0.08661212772130966, 0.005006065126508474, -0.03052961453795433, -0.005405055359005928, 0.02576390840113163, -0.06851398199796677, 0.07018505781888962, -0.0036984614562243223, -0.016718490049242973, -0.0035907491110265255, 0.06897975504398346, 0.026846231892704964, 0.04750910773873329, -0.01954486407339573, -0.056598275899887085, -0.007789153605699539, -0.02921181730926037, 0.015466704033315182, 0.04544655233621597, 0.005264657083898783, -0.0012433761730790138, -0.004775916691869497, 0.04834559187293053, -0.09524930268526077, -0.03930189460515976, 0.03282437101006508, 0.027401097118854523, 0.04788945987820625, -0.03209671750664711, 0.048026230186223984, -0.02144118957221508, -0.002281593857333064, 0.0031496440060436726, -0.0050909449346363544, -0.02576589025557041, -0.045993681997060776, -0.02770145796239376, -0.014902872033417225, -0.028048668056726456, 0.01958262175321579, 0.04656866937875748, -0.047370679676532745, -0.06406934559345245, -0.022146178409457207, 0.0002707852690946311, -0.030218694359064102, 0.014196458272635937, -0.01715337671339512, 0.008410784415900707, 0.004362113773822784, -0.031124519184231758, -0.009678634814918041, 0.0473681204020977, -0.05239653214812279, -0.0400627925992012, 0.02302084118127823, -0.07583331316709518, -0.008379309438169003, -0.015299510210752487, -0.04565063491463661, 0.039758507162332535, 0.00034226360730826855, -0.020338866859674454, 0.02424617111682892, -0.0025837868452072144, -0.05088014900684357, -0.03666764870285988, -0.009467856958508492, 0.028403952717781067, 0.004930618219077587, 0.016138315200805664, 0.015857063233852386, -0.0356796570122242, 0.0010001921327784657, 0.0730547159910202, -0.027940431609749794, 0.021142197772860527, 0.0015089163789525628, -0.03047008439898491, 0.030014755204319954, -0.021902387961745262, -0.012577724643051624, 0.06256625056266785, 0.0023717910517007113, 0.027358463034033775, 0.020550139248371124, -0.013923135586082935, 0.012543374672532082, 0.06991194933652878, -0.05397797003388405, -0.02479849010705948, 0.020946547389030457, -0.07200005650520325, 0.02792169526219368, -0.04048852622509003, 0.06367857754230499, -0.08476552367210388, -0.04191448539495468, -0.030432064086198807, -0.03807548061013222, 0.020109280943870544, -0.011375660076737404, -0.027469389140605927, 0.033514559268951416, -0.004817411303520203, -0.03248818591237068, -0.04483594000339508, -0.021038718521595, -0.019849305972456932, -0.013242371380329132, -0.013190392404794693, -0.0748845562338829, 0.018728801980614662, 0.08821488916873932, -0.035314153879880905, -0.006904507987201214, 0.03375273197889328, -0.006014025770127773, -0.05199365317821503, -0.04964033514261246, -0.06583321839570999, 0.028754128143191338, 0.027022216469049454, -0.05069022625684738, -0.02906966395676136, -0.02543051168322563, 0.054211996495723724, -0.058307819068431854, 0.032621655613183975, -0.014076653867959976, 0.036780912429094315, -0.03748589754104614, 0.0376681312918663, 0.03667604923248291, 0.02233925275504589, -0.004633425269275904, -0.018228694796562195, 0.007416598033159971, -0.02726024016737938, 0.03963933512568474, 0.059842754155397415, 0.04926353320479393, -0.005000713746994734, -0.012489576824009418, 0.02272416651248932, -0.009392676874995232, -0.0011015707859769464, 0.005429103970527649, 0.005199109204113483, 0.0030000535771250725, -0.028342103585600853, -0.029226059094071388, -0.014345720410346985, -0.08744940161705017, 0.0230034701526165, -0.0010459846816956997, 0.026162967085838318, -0.002821164671331644, 0.021480202674865723, -0.030105946585536003, 0.021221263334155083, 0.0006384666194207966, 0.00036404348793439567, -0.00774988392367959, -0.04345377907156944, 0.00856617372483015, 0.002654863288626075, 0.017319630831480026, 0.0010501670185476542, 0.01117128599435091, 0.013141734525561333, -0.042833391577005386, -0.00855720229446888, 0.02902761474251747, -0.020014647394418716, 0.01330077275633812, -0.058932140469551086, 0.005916315130889416, -0.05125686898827553, 0.006800430361181498, -0.05370546132326126, -0.06198649853467941, -0.007864530198276043, 0.006218457594513893, 0.028455153107643127, -0.020072154700756073, 0.0405183844268322, 0.034846749156713486, -0.040177859365940094, -0.030427539721131325, 0.06649160385131836, 0.05526462569832802, -0.06223490461707115, -0.018431497737765312, 0.02471972070634365, -0.07670442759990692, 0.006429131608456373, 0.02447464130818844, 0.010884393006563187, 0.013609987683594227, 0.009631709195673466, 0.026217667385935783, 0.0018841661512851715, -0.026847882196307182, 0.046214766800403595, 0.0077425530180335045, -0.06874620914459229, 0.0069607459008693695, -0.023946402594447136, -0.030020227655768394, 0.008372432552278042, -0.018264098092913628, -0.06346346437931061, 0.023397022858262062, 0.006096597295254469, 0.02615445666015148, 0.02692333608865738, 0.06744733452796936, 0.03204305097460747, 0.028178855776786804, 0.0031627104617655277, -0.01814667321741581, 0.005005664192140102, 0.03103918395936489, 0.026436038315296173, 0.04256121441721916, -0.029096107929944992, -0.016701286658644676, -0.005677197128534317, -0.02802797220647335, -0.09101829677820206, -0.011068800464272499, 0.06758785247802734, -0.0034450036473572254, -0.033507682383060455, 0.06604956835508347, 0.00041796479490585625, -0.009957012720406055, -0.026264483109116554, -0.021273044869303703, -0.00986159685999155, -0.0035867791157215834, 0.10984375327825546, 0.04880460724234581, 0.006299737840890884, -0.029600748792290688, -0.040969401597976685, -0.0012361385161057115, 0.014744261279702187, -0.06234719976782799, 0.03971501439809799, -0.0912734866142273, 0.041122354567050934, -0.022301675751805305, 0.06629016995429993, 0.034293096512556076, -0.001431998796761036, 0.08762185275554657, -0.04553736746311188, 0.05348867177963257, -0.03589349612593651, -0.04641396552324295, 0.04176623001694679, -0.05375378578901291, -0.027072638273239136, -0.020347116515040398, -0.004050725605338812, -0.00816276017576456, -0.0011831849114969373, -0.026667296886444092, 0.0008637336432002485, -0.0038961018435657024, -0.053661514073610306, 0.016648566350340843, 0.022766893729567528, 0.09345665574073792, 0.026280073449015617, -0.04707735776901245, -0.03642585873603821, 0.0021951855160295963, 0.06822053343057632, 0.10001371800899506, -0.0006036091363057494, -0.02776329219341278, -0.03858869522809982, -0.05330979451537132, -0.008521748706698418, 0.020373018458485603, 0.015758786350488663, 0.06374403089284897, 0.013621537946164608, 0.042934101074934006, -0.04870913550257683, -0.01632571592926979, 0.0382402278482914, -0.07292622327804565, -0.03037811443209648, -0.025378894060850143, -0.06096009537577629, 0.006765398662537336, 0.006610696669667959, -0.028166571632027626, 0.03492836281657219, -0.009422071278095245, 0.028169982135295868, 0.07146693021059036, -0.06225718930363655, 0.023118317127227783, 0.08384901285171509, 0.014790143817663193, 0.028061790391802788, -0.03596000373363495, -0.0011540795676410198, 0.027446702122688293, 0.02920987270772457, -0.000242863388848491, -0.005926463752985001, 0.02658465877175331, -0.0018416409147903323, -0.0669839009642601, 0.02796589955687523, -0.029044652357697487, -0.019582195207476616, 0.04251038655638695, 0.031039424240589142, 0.04710468277335167, 0.015781451016664505, -0.08392167091369629, -0.011803309433162212, 0.03320430591702461, -0.05765784904360771, 0.05239957943558693, -0.011856053955852985, -0.10603565722703934, -0.0010292594088241458, -0.03562822565436363, -0.02227538265287876, 0.07519761472940445, -0.025016844272613525, -0.017601964995265007, -0.09323375672101974, -0.00991316232830286, 0.04858142510056496, -0.06596623361110687, 0.02532103843986988, 0.05332352966070175, 0.011597770266234875, 0.05140447989106178, 0.03242691233754158, -0.0154753802344203, -0.057805385440588, 0.03192449361085892, -0.036847297102212906, 0.0323285236954689, -0.01297666598111391, 0.0035006068646907806, 0.06848427653312683, 0.0051515609957277775, 0.015317689627408981, 0.054625146090984344, 0.059393979609012604, 0.012204461731016636, 0.008452849462628365, 0.011933405883610249, 0.0028508410323411226, 0.03213831037282944, 0.041905976831912994, -0.023219561204314232, -0.03430614620447159, 0.03002655692398548, -0.012112094089388847, -0.012735867872834206, 0.06650152802467346, 0.061361223459243774, 0.005932532250881195, -0.013386494480073452, -0.034899357706308365, 0.009377430193126202, 0.01600373536348343, 0.012671318836510181, -0.030248967930674553, 0.039389513432979584, -0.09099425375461578, 0.0461580753326416, -0.012129561975598335, 0.02850494720041752, 0.05239727720618248, 0.02218473143875599, 0.03979778662323952, 0.0208739060908556, 0.027208108454942703, -0.024459753185510635, 0.028552796691656113, -0.038782741874456406, -0.014784595929086208, -0.017759796231985092, 0.048539649695158005, 0.021411309018731117, -0.015712764114141464, 0.037673644721508026, -0.01751953735947609, 0.00025836375425569713, 0.03893827646970749, -0.023680323734879494, -0.057662658393383026, 0.05998930707573891, -0.03484431654214859, -0.010566486045718193, -0.025227203965187073, 0.03759872540831566, 0.02566288597881794, -0.013463035225868225, 0.04869886860251427, -0.04128235951066017, -0.06873922049999237, 0.02226703241467476, 0.050992317497730255, 0.01312696561217308, -0.030854476615786552, 0.0056414068676531315, 0.01420689933001995, -0.0030723796226084232, 0.023080725222826004, 0.04373195022344589, 0.016723303124308586, -0.009784131310880184, 0.021998416632413864, 0.008450303226709366, 0.005293199792504311, -0.021135451272130013, -0.0181586891412735, -0.062125999480485916, -0.06016111001372337, -0.018239500001072884, -0.010396805591881275, -0.017276378348469734, 0.028318453580141068, 0.023200098425149918, -0.06391622126102448, -0.0017853535246104002, 0.013868473470211029, -0.0017400331562384963, 0.03699773922562599, 0.002858008723706007, 0.04418499395251274, 0.04983916133642197, -0.05764520540833473, -0.03491899371147156, 0.005079576279968023, -0.00717563321813941, 0.06114530935883522, -0.013592427596449852, -0.022067373618483543, 0.027364816516637802, -0.0512191541492939, 0.02978239394724369, 0.011189255863428116, -0.007693915627896786, 0.00964202918112278, 0.06660891324281693, 0.04588300734758377, 0.0196616742759943, -0.017201999202370644, 0.014607572928071022, 0.034455716609954834, -0.002100470010191202, 0.02717544138431549, 0.02901359647512436, 0.014346146024763584, 0.027833014726638794, -0.04813308268785477, -0.02140028215944767, 0.04883095994591713, -0.027976030483841896, -0.032348357141017914, -0.04859475418925285, -0.028980880975723267, 0.016156019642949104, -0.05405424162745476, -0.04349111393094063, 0.027699178084731102, -0.037419550120830536, 0.06966355443000793, -0.01396601740270853, -0.0046213841997087, -0.0026374475564807653, -0.037757400423288345, 0.03107205219566822, -0.010807189159095287, 0.018901517614722252, -0.016474051401019096, -0.045265939086675644, -0.029866298660635948, -0.017640894278883934, 0.02912822738289833, -0.007641573902219534, -0.06729374080896378, -0.035245686769485474, 0.023068062961101532, -0.027216080576181412, -0.09865156561136246, -0.028336867690086365, -0.02742316760122776, -0.09706433862447739, 0.016085287556052208, 0.0754900574684143, 0.0017775999149307609, 0.01611713133752346, -0.021778874099254608, 0.02734087035059929, -0.009088930673897266, 0.04106830060482025, -0.021128803491592407, -0.0019262050045654178, 0.0416402705013752, 0.028203098103404045, 0.01697239652276039, 0.02697005309164524, 0.005837155040353537, -0.01598132774233818, -0.023387489840388298, -0.027509577572345734, 0.030155308544635773, -0.03217318281531334, -0.03595494478940964, -0.07471593469381332, 0.02940637804567814, -0.03044208325445652, 0.009163755923509598, 0.04627562686800957, -0.0015228098491206765, 0.0869121327996254, 0.018551470711827278, -0.024728555232286453, 0.006294702645391226, 0.04314890503883362, -0.022713862359523773, 0.014036196283996105, 0.01701725460588932, -0.015719115734100342, -0.02258075773715973, -0.042479198426008224, 0.00037329905899241567, -0.05065412446856499, -0.06795899569988251, 0.08374728262424469, 0.0009856071555987, 0.02900877222418785, 0.028789911419153214, 0.012665702030062675, -0.022645287215709686, -0.0917002260684967, -0.010365444235503674, 0.00976356491446495, 0.06005720794200897, 0.013186084106564522, 0.0394669733941555, 0.009319419041275978, 0.0022866546642035246, -0.014558272436261177, 0.022027887403964996, -0.0036398759111762047, 0.04283735901117325, -0.027664771303534508, 0.06708883494138718, 0.005852570757269859, 0.021589459851384163, -0.040563683956861496, -0.02501070126891136, -0.020439768210053444, 0.055049262940883636, 0.05310147628188133, -0.04738287255167961, 0.0322808176279068, -0.024068817496299744, 0.03935735300183296, -0.007933425717055798, -0.045751046389341354, 0.004473364446312189, 0.011083274148404598, 0.016078468412160873, -0.02439507469534874, -0.047022756189107895, -0.01813405565917492, -0.03767189010977745 ]
<p>The atoms in my table "stick together" to form a rectangle. Why? What makes them stick together?</p> <p>I know about ionic/covalent bonding etc., but consider a sheet of pure iron. Just atoms of one element. The atoms still stick together to form a sheet instead of being "everywhere".But if I place ten balls on the ground beside each other they are completely independent of each other.</p> <p>So what "connects" the atoms?</p>
g1668
[ -0.008482137694954872, 0.0358600914478302, -0.0007728487253189087, -0.041457828134298325, 0.07564809173345566, 0.021026790142059326, -0.05212059244513512, 0.051723599433898926, -0.028001951053738594, -0.011964257806539536, -0.041664429008960724, -0.0015931829111650586, -0.0025611303281039, -0.002585434587672353, 0.004137376323342323, 0.019980045035481453, -0.03505542874336243, 0.01305951178073883, 0.015343691222369671, 0.016168801113963127, 0.053291358053684235, 0.013745510019361973, 0.03826935589313507, -0.03784807026386261, -0.05957287549972534, 0.015369890257716179, -0.00329189607873559, -0.034589655697345734, -0.03432081639766693, 0.022368373349308968, 0.01394363958388567, 0.01982547715306282, 0.07125169038772583, -0.0724179595708847, -0.0009653135202825069, -0.052452657371759415, -0.03717496618628502, 0.01298894640058279, 0.0024262082297354937, -0.04376091808080673, -0.006623316556215286, -0.025856558233499527, -0.023101018741726875, -0.04567285627126694, 0.028478028252720833, -0.00027903440059162676, 0.0070951227098703384, -0.020207267254590988, -0.013775619678199291, 0.044466376304626465, 0.028557676821947098, 0.040574077516794205, 0.004720361903309822, 0.018780682235956192, -0.04581869766116142, 0.020988307893276215, 0.03501506522297859, -0.009666699916124344, 0.0851074606180191, 0.03880186006426811, 0.015557438135147095, -0.00951734371483326, -0.03325551748275757, 0.000060950202168896794, 0.030203256756067276, 0.005049616098403931, -0.07742759585380554, 0.04397343844175339, 0.00398717075586319, 0.0041784970089793205, 0.0072037396021187305, -0.01953018456697464, 0.013505863025784492, 0.011343437246978283, -0.0563872829079628, -0.037972211837768555, 0.013635746203362942, 0.01837593875825405, 0.04830020293593407, 0.010553767904639244, 0.01689108833670616, -0.05078328400850296, -0.03512081503868103, -0.059021178632974625, 0.018913518637418747, 0.005102984607219696, 0.01251991931349039, -0.09856973588466644, -0.07716220617294312, 0.05028924345970154, 0.028612952679395676, 0.03841990977525711, 0.01712404377758503, -0.019812365993857384, -0.046721987426280975, -0.013257062062621117, 0.017357351258397102, 0.057316068559885025, -0.000807976524811238, -0.031393468379974365, -0.021696530282497406, 0.0069890739396214485, 0.05769611522555351, 0.00703418580815196, 0.023782745003700256, -0.01581234112381935, -0.03647070378065109, 0.03728093206882477, 0.029185695573687553, 0.010337780229747295, -0.006143274717032909, 0.08296369761228561, -0.03539477288722992, -0.01502801664173603, 0.010130193084478378, -0.0140770822763443, 0.06945911794900894, -0.017954416573047638, 0.032464414834976196, 0.03277430683374405, 0.03942325338721275, -0.009776021353900433, 0.05323752015829086, 0.004000319167971611, -0.05070730298757553, -0.033900149166584015, 0.06795578449964523, -0.0006719882949255407, -0.0337490513920784, -0.0350726842880249, 0.04170321300625801, 0.033342596143484116, -0.012391177006065845, -0.012967055663466454, -0.0461643785238266, 0.007589565124362707, -0.05523448437452316, -0.024538833647966385, 0.00502523360773921, -0.02402493730187416, -0.002033392433077097, -0.008082701824605465, -0.0033414303325116634, -0.05243070423603058, 0.010246754623949528, 0.012886438518762589, -0.02633892558515072, 0.011178919114172459, 0.051459718495607376, 0.04200855642557144, -0.01907486468553543, -0.05213984474539757, 0.005557268857955933, -0.014755656011402607, -0.0151223661378026, -0.012296662665903568, 0.04816310852766037, -0.09033852070569992, 0.06385931372642517, 0.028729135170578957, 0.09715313464403152, -0.008058195002377033, -0.02093791402876377, 0.0024533038958907127, 0.01732509396970272, 0.04392242431640625, 0.03838832303881645, -0.015495679341256618, -0.01612585410475731, 0.0186156015843153, 0.009276896715164185, -0.03284250199794769, -0.038080327212810516, 0.08668201416730881, -0.005864968989044428, 0.031753357499837875, 0.05040977522730827, -0.042577922344207764, 0.024331560358405113, -0.05303892865777016, 0.02345898374915123, -0.02874612994492054, 0.010035316459834576, -0.03256479650735855, 0.024113839492201805, 0.015390881337225437, -0.056702252477407455, -0.010770476423203945, -0.013768341392278671, 0.00858219526708126, -0.035716138780117035, -0.07591395080089569, 0.01798485592007637, 0.006352328695356846, 0.013423419557511806, -0.03485869988799095, 0.0143400514498353, -0.022497201338410378, 0.015391534194350243, -0.04084859415888786, -0.04164770618081093, 0.01245090365409851, -0.038268305361270905, 0.04392082244157791, 0.023989571258425713, -0.04070104658603668, -0.04316464066505432, 0.030477464199066162, 0.010127948597073555, 0.05191119760274887, 0.004958536475896835, 0.008728125132620335, -0.021094368770718575, -0.0010233343346044421, -0.005310823675245047, -0.015490763820707798, 0.01114067155867815, -0.039439309388399124, -0.06443064659833908, 0.0537395216524601, -0.008251940831542015, -0.05604997277259827, 0.006135018076747656, -0.007257490418851376, 0.028849201276898384, -0.030430858954787254, 0.0268380306661129, 0.031114105135202408, 0.012664178386330605, 0.032799962908029556, -0.07590893656015396, 0.018264099955558777, -0.0036248527467250824, 0.023795098066329956, -0.018624790012836456, 0.05323364585638046, 0.0008316936437040567, 0.025776976719498634, -0.06255914270877838, -0.03289474546909332, 0.011874869465827942, -0.06630177050828934, -0.025907248258590698, -0.029570739716291428, 0.03205101937055588, 0.016589660197496414, 0.07203496992588043, 0.005500438157469034, -0.012700376100838184, 0.038585443049669266, 0.0692620575428009, 0.011727388016879559, -0.05865437909960747, 0.07811170071363449, -0.011560428887605667, -0.012693810276687145, 0.03601318970322609, 0.03462107479572296, -0.05885572358965874, -0.08984004706144333, 0.007953650318086147, -0.05716818571090698, 0.024426952004432678, -0.013989443890750408, -0.06806163489818573, -0.013822544366121292, -0.019518567249178886, 0.006519447546452284, 0.029374584555625916, -0.04078206419944763, -0.04811331257224083, 0.04743234068155289, 0.022849490866065025, -0.003784662112593651, -0.01178102008998394, -0.015987955033779144, -0.01949005201458931, -0.030340202152729034, -0.0019016357837244868, 0.004837431944906712, 0.004689245484769344, 0.06411874294281006, -0.05985390022397041, -0.036766842007637024, 0.004219895228743553, 0.04895607382059097, -0.018438011407852173, 0.02626475691795349, -0.012220514938235283, 0.004839703906327486, 0.0026151007041335106, -0.02842688001692295, 0.05765597149729729, 0.0057968259789049625, -0.011384471319615841, 0.004173366352915764, 0.08679410815238953, 0.006544397212564945, -0.05906923487782478, 0.08786400407552719, -0.002496568486094475, 0.040623851120471954, 0.014200851321220398, 0.06280136108398438, 0.005624983459711075, 0.03251213580369949, 0.025873571634292603, 0.0011954837245866656, -0.05425291880965233, -0.1007593646645546, 0.013795270584523678, 0.024836555123329163, 0.05974768474698067, -0.007200700230896473, -0.057956356555223465, -0.00489018764346838, -0.006183934397995472, 0.06929223984479904, -0.013690433464944363, -0.034250691533088684, -0.030162282288074493, 0.007506420370191336, 0.0687151551246643, -0.052611012011766434, 0.005816896446049213, 0.03111974708735943, 0.0023267241194844246, -0.0768161490559578, 0.013313820585608482, -0.026977481320500374, -0.025277433916926384, 0.015359744429588318, -0.005668239202350378, 0.01567571982741356, -0.08683480322360992, -0.06550639867782593, -0.021297575905919075, -0.034875914454460144, -0.014086989685893059, 0.020460164174437523, -0.028761060908436775, -0.035051923245191574, 0.02048363722860813, -0.02781139314174652, 0.012920797802507877, 0.049224235117435455, -0.021299762651324272, -0.009391811676323414, 0.012887874618172646, -0.059077754616737366, -0.013867959380149841, 0.015546762384474277, -0.009063027799129486, -0.06569883972406387, 0.016923679038882256, 0.008689207024872303, -0.02186274528503418, -0.03580233454704285, -0.04635296016931534, -0.039831776171922684, 0.0100831538438797, 0.005389067810028791, -0.028202611953020096, 0.03940296545624733, -0.06631479412317276, 0.020702363923192024, 0.027747541666030884, 0.04410089924931526, 0.03896678611636162, -0.015374270267784595, -0.09053024649620056, 0.012482253834605217, 0.02310553938150406, 0.035510025918483734, 0.03989573195576668, 0.0049239094369113445, 0.007776772603392601, -0.003446536837145686, 0.05851033329963684, 0.002719849580898881, 0.020440295338630676, 0.05474717915058136, -0.029057838022708893, 0.04767550900578499, 0.027652787044644356, -0.00623069703578949, -0.002893633907660842, 0.018804673105478287, -0.03480212762951851, -0.028107276186347008, -0.007385266944766045, 0.00918230414390564, -0.028293829411268234, -0.0025195295456796885, -0.01971662975847721, -0.02279474027454853, -0.013734533451497555, 0.07103180140256882, 0.027488866820931435, -0.008876384235918522, 0.0011002573883160949, -0.002789463847875595, -0.05639133229851723, -0.03974730148911476, 0.04680265858769417, 0.03870869427919388, -0.012133638374507427, 0.0007656647940166295, -0.011826879344880581, -0.01978517696261406, 0.02051922306418419, 0.008729270659387112, -0.0002031562471529469, -0.020681016147136688, 0.007297464180737734, 0.01744258590042591, 0.027926180511713028, 0.049291715025901794, -0.07095276564359665, -0.05113575980067253, -0.021991433575749397, 0.044665172696113586, 0.030325481668114662, -0.010142020881175995, 0.05534018576145172, 0.06131024658679962, -0.02135099284350872, 0.019907932728528976, 0.015422767028212547, 0.026903703808784485, -0.05318179726600647, 0.05663088709115982, 0.023426560685038567, -0.029561659321188927, -0.11890345066785812, -0.0004581946996040642, 0.0037894046399742365, 0.06871642172336578, 0.0020999687258154154, 0.016663366928696632, 0.04151720181107521, 0.06402304023504257, -0.010995766147971153, 0.05102406442165375, -0.008225830271840096, -0.003298188326880336, -0.08199463784694672, 0.023246238008141518, -0.06529884040355682, -0.03437511995434761, 0.015944544225931168, -0.005294179543852806, -0.06213779002428055, 0.010220518335700035, -0.013086019083857536, -0.02937888726592064, 0.005850030574947596, 0.026083841919898987, 0.03479005768895149, 0.036685045808553696, -0.01629858836531639, 0.01942785643041134, 0.0006285404087975621, 0.061387285590171814, 0.023534445092082024, -0.002571281511336565, 0.030890539288520813, -0.020631132647395134, -0.045835889875888824, 0.019525345414876938, 0.04661552608013153, 0.03762010857462883, -0.02390945330262184, 0.039884962141513824, 0.09212756156921387, 0.00854677613824606, -0.023604197427630424, -0.01733105443418026, 0.05407075211405754, -0.059950605034828186, -0.006750233005732298, 0.03248422592878342, -0.0011182798771187663, 0.018092822283506393, 0.005567734129726887, -0.04210875555872917, -0.016881978139281273, 0.03899997100234032, 0.01943272165954113, 0.012261425144970417, 0.02224838174879551, -0.035129763185977936, 0.008233717642724514, -0.041003718972206116, 0.021183636039495468, -0.09578852355480194, -0.01839388720691204, -0.04030930995941162, 0.012226026505231857, -0.004365227650851011, -0.04230385646224022, 0.023947931826114655, 0.018317928537726402, -0.027076615020632744, -0.007383990567177534, 0.013731810264289379, 0.0623980388045311, -0.03690925985574722, 0.07322439551353455, -0.03212655335664749, -0.054767027497291565, -0.03920583799481392, -0.0031616019550710917, -0.03542708232998848, -0.0279152300208807, 0.007225062698125839, -0.004840458743274212, -0.029152672737836838, -0.011319372802972794, 0.07446246594190598, 0.0038677023258060217, -0.009032711386680603, -0.018162142485380173, -0.03850940987467766, -0.05735519528388977, 0.020581405609846115, -0.051987435668706894, 0.018800489604473114, 0.011707138270139694, 0.05440689995884895, -0.024252286180853844, -0.03413153812289238, 0.02020762488245964, 0.030795173719525337, 0.0021853516809642315, 0.019173255190253258, -0.006303736474364996, -0.05269794166088104, 0.019976723939180374, 0.022421820089221, 0.048778001219034195, 0.0315651074051857, -0.004550660960376263, 0.029942799359560013, -0.0038615111261606216, -0.03870586305856705, 0.02636457048356533, 0.026289060711860657, 0.056713975965976715, 0.03269888460636139, 0.0074596102349460125, 0.04073140025138855, -0.009067336097359657, -0.036786094307899475, 0.01810566708445549, 0.010292562656104565, 0.04729077219963074, -0.026465168222784996, 0.014574622735381126, -0.008907468989491463, 0.03212578222155571, 0.025138510391116142, -0.018598785623908043, 0.021523945033550262, 0.046248458325862885, -0.004197453614324331, -0.06122472882270813, -0.013506672345101833, 0.029979120939970016, 0.04883540794253349, -0.00013146370474714786, -0.05531024932861328, 0.06769279390573502, -0.008333288133144379, -0.04399125277996063, 0.013047663494944572, -0.061088357120752335, 0.02886628918349743, -0.017297551035881042, 0.016277343034744263, 0.029052410274744034, 0.02835770696401596, 0.0034856495913118124, -0.056807421147823334, 0.021144388243556023, 0.005316713824868202, -0.014992453157901764, -0.03226258233189583, 0.025728991255164146, -0.056877583265304565, -0.040621522814035416, 0.02515239082276821, 0.01473492756485939, -0.03798950836062431, -0.0005451616016216576, -0.030688384547829628, -0.0023029171861708164, 0.04500335454940796, -0.02516845613718033, 0.007542724255472422, -0.03361670672893524, 0.0035099051892757416, 0.050251349806785583, 0.04241066053509712, 0.02523798681795597, -0.02199859358370304, 0.022253016009926796, -0.03818888962268829, -0.04354948550462723, 0.016998140141367912, -0.04357471317052841, 0.043453965336084366, -0.005904730875045061, -0.0005886144936084747, 0.001096519990824163, -0.03352968394756317, 0.054536961019039154, 0.06119999289512634, -0.03482264652848244, -0.019423356279730797, 0.0012171081034466624, -0.03279949724674225, -0.0372779481112957, -0.02790996991097927, 0.021561171859502792, -0.0015403826255351305, -0.025953121483325958, 0.018762711435556412, -0.006462438497692347, -0.020392173901200294, -0.050623055547475815, 0.014597957022488117, 0.03615223988890648, 0.01658870093524456, -0.025495991110801697, 0.07946159690618515, -0.02275698259472847, -0.019270654767751694, 0.06726586073637009, 0.045384228229522705, -0.05965792387723923, 0.0033038840629160404, 0.0017079676035791636, 0.03673047944903374, 0.018510576337575912, 0.0077383979223668575, 0.043065428733825684, -0.054826367646455765, -0.06480922549962997, 0.01276104710996151, -0.007184229791164398, -0.0022001073230057955, -0.0296064130961895, 0.03917200490832329, -0.028619816526770592, -0.010937148705124855, -0.048174045979976654, 0.002512318780645728, -0.01218017190694809, 0.003918438218533993, -0.05674554780125618, 0.02923552878201008, -0.026905540376901627, -0.008745268918573856, -0.021578045561909676, 0.053730301558971405, 0.06586004048585892, -0.05586922913789749, -0.0443272665143013, 0.001232870388776064, -0.018980685621500015, -0.016433723270893097, 0.027285531163215637, -0.02702491544187069, 0.01053627859801054, 0.03760925307869911, -0.0004885259550064802, -0.026074398308992386, 0.030157987028360367, -0.06286202371120453, -0.010468101128935814, 0.06364935636520386, 0.05025220289826393, -0.024639539420604706, -0.03425653651356697, 0.04947047680616379, 0.048073142766952515, 0.03520151227712631, -0.037230972200632095, -0.02825050801038742, 0.052255187183618546, 0.003520584898069501, -0.028609499335289, 0.021827278658747673, 0.02143143117427826, -0.0382627472281456, 0.021078059449791908, -0.020168593153357506, 0.0026785710360854864, -0.02707245759665966, 0.030262306332588196, -0.023331772536039352, 0.03136635944247246, -0.006831479258835316, 0.07628409564495087, -0.015324159525334835, -0.02688019722700119, 0.04633898660540581, -0.035318683832883835, -0.04449208080768585, 0.052090320736169815, 0.028932662680745125, 0.08591753244400024, -0.012189427390694618, 0.029140081256628036, 0.020918983966112137, -0.04409388452768326, -0.005161026492714882, -0.029407506808638573, -0.008105354383587837, -0.037208251655101776, -0.02505382150411606, 0.00795719027519226, -0.021704627200961113, 0.014290734194219112, 0.04062248766422272, 0.017517196014523506, -0.012144168838858604, 0.014856701716780663, 0.016900189220905304, -0.028388820588588715, 0.039578113704919815, -0.045740216970443726, 0.0466095469892025, -0.05031266435980797, 0.0010234732180833817, 0.03703787177801132, -0.05782328173518181, -0.01577586680650711, -0.04074396938085556, 0.026556650176644325, -0.04710904881358147, -0.016766490414738655, -0.020641207695007324, -0.030846750363707542, -0.04186698794364929, -0.027086347341537476, 0.06574519723653793, 0.07270477712154388, -0.0013709121849387884, -0.04417518526315689, -0.007649610750377178, -0.0008079338585957885, 0.03298595920205116, 0.056638170033693314, -0.04572932422161102, -0.012166532687842846, 0.06566289812326431, 0.0494769886136055, 0.01492325495928526, -0.012498598545789719, 0.06800508499145508, -0.039384350180625916, 0.02964833565056324, 0.05054374784231186, -0.008055821992456913, -0.0708797499537468, -0.01746934838593006 ]
<p>Say you have a neutral rod, and you bring a positively charged rod beside it (call the side the charged rod is brought near side A and the other side side B). The electrons from the side B will start moving towards side A and the positively charged nuclei in side A will start moving to side B. </p> <p>After a large part of side A consists of only of electrons, the electrons would start repelling each other and the movement of charges will stop. But at this point a very large portion of side A consists of electrons and a large part of side B consists only of positively charged nuclei. The system is at equilibrium.</p> <p>But the rod has now been mostly split into a electron side and a positively charged nuclei side, however it doesn't look different at all? Why? Shouldn't a rod made of atoms look and be completely different than a rod that is mostly made up of electrons on one side and nuclei on the other?</p> <p>I know that electrons are very small, and since side A mostly consists of electrons, shouldn't it be almost invisible? </p>
g1669
[ -0.0035124649293720722, 0.0662355124950409, -0.004188546910881996, -0.05495642498135567, 0.09504640847444534, 0.017052842304110527, 0.006941805128008127, 0.051232535392045975, 0.025552477687597275, -0.005133857950568199, 0.018137793987989426, 0.05266464874148369, 0.019106006249785423, -0.007077159360051155, 0.025199923664331436, 0.0028148575220257044, 0.0606403723359108, -0.06321147829294205, 0.040862075984478, 0.08705233782529831, 0.0263748150318861, 0.014692225493490696, -0.0032583349384367466, 0.018215177580714226, 0.0009348007151857018, -0.015544178895652294, -0.03040245547890663, -0.014628693461418152, 0.016854366287589073, -0.027802394703030586, -0.007333026733249426, 0.007912402972579002, 0.008919162675738335, -0.0022920260671526194, -0.059616245329380035, -0.04397907853126526, 0.05548550933599472, 0.006008385214954615, 0.049304794520139694, -0.03074905462563038, -0.010143234394490719, -0.02433057315647602, 0.0061169154942035675, -0.07307608425617218, 0.005894740577787161, -0.013457427732646465, 0.016138311475515366, -0.019683480262756348, -0.03564684838056564, -0.036750677973032, 0.0074436357244849205, 0.03325489163398743, -0.05080415681004524, 0.004830626305192709, 0.01341197919100523, 0.02040288597345352, 0.034526173025369644, -0.004684482701122761, 0.06926410645246506, 0.05993843823671341, 0.013940081931650639, 0.06492540240287781, -0.007955356501042843, 0.03425479307770729, 0.039432503283023834, -0.028637642040848732, -0.009972269646823406, 0.02931012026965618, 0.0013691135682165623, 0.026223348453640938, 0.01395450346171856, -0.04413856938481331, -0.0054416232742369175, -0.05728814750909805, -0.024011734873056412, 0.008282155729830265, -0.023437075316905975, 0.020664595067501068, -0.009930605068802834, -0.03162318840622902, -0.07608279585838318, -0.03251921758055687, -0.012713588774204254, 0.024225549772381783, 0.09902361780405045, 0.06987839937210083, 0.024783898144960403, -0.031191524118185043, -0.042319443076848984, 0.022625230252742767, 0.015840018168091774, -0.04172962158918381, 0.043881192803382874, 0.02364104427397251, -0.04192540422081947, -0.0509503073990345, 0.005559281911700964, 0.06508651375770569, -0.01707114838063717, -0.0226384699344635, -0.004023711662739515, -0.025923093780875206, -0.0033466469030827284, 0.03181085363030434, -0.039593037217855453, -0.007779287174344063, 0.005402793176472187, -0.003258404089137912, -0.02188265509903431, -0.010528021492064, -0.031743161380290985, -0.05624710023403168, -0.049678269773721695, 0.005847873166203499, 0.01970551908016205, 0.0026699965819716454, 0.04230077564716339, -0.05245976895093918, -0.015214269049465656, -0.005137625150382519, 0.08884212374687195, 0.023559734225273132, 0.02227894403040409, 0.013315384276211262, 0.008252755738794804, -0.024324042722582817, 0.004683382343500853, 0.01600836031138897, 0.07427939027547836, -0.019516147673130035, 0.057179976254701614, -0.03394457325339317, 0.016683140769600868, 0.011568711139261723, 0.07580707222223282, 0.011099071241915226, 0.027644146233797073, 0.005389383062720299, 0.001188476919196546, -0.02060241438448429, 0.01600966788828373, -0.015309290029108524, -0.05131833627820015, -0.0016013990389183164, 0.029230386018753052, -0.04636400565505028, -0.017554638907313347, -0.011402457021176815, -0.012079698033630848, 0.00465337885543704, 0.008801054209470749, 0.030246257781982422, 0.006475105416029692, 0.006427195388823748, -0.041839759796857834, -0.039857201278209686, 0.07078420370817184, -0.041876170784235, 0.0072246212512254715, -0.025282474234700203, 0.03563529998064041, -0.02802269160747528, -0.0014466684078797698, -0.033974114805459976, -0.07849633693695068, 0.015590215101838112, 0.003968246281147003, -0.05834287777543068, 0.03489804267883301, -0.007443348411470652, -0.02426503598690033, -0.005758135113865137, 0.022027751430869102, 0.04448487609624863, 0.04693473130464554, 0.0936548113822937, 0.013700519688427448, -0.04541666433215141, 0.051966968923807144, 0.052838534116744995, -0.055132023990154266, 0.03313227370381355, 0.031652335077524185, 0.037457067519426346, 0.022749103605747223, -0.010653317905962467, 0.003130926750600338, 0.06174939498305321, -0.08345834910869598, 0.016007518395781517, 0.022136706858873367, -0.004414976574480534, -0.023129288107156754, 0.019675277173519135, -0.005975465755909681, -0.0645441934466362, -0.008292588405311108, -0.03189500421285629, 0.020122552290558815, -0.024265287443995476, 0.029293060302734375, 0.022769952192902565, -0.008474281057715416, 0.05005037784576416, 0.005031467881053686, -0.04689404368400574, -0.06729400902986526, 0.012460137717425823, 0.03319472819566727, -0.0014477802906185389, 0.00735638290643692, 0.007961839437484741, -0.009089473634958267, 0.020059077069163322, -0.04046019911766052, -0.022902442142367363, -0.01062166877090931, 0.06846513599157333, -0.031139595434069633, 0.05594359710812569, 0.005928307771682739, -0.03741038218140602, -0.022818509489297867, -0.006254968699067831, 0.01782200112938881, 0.025833291932940483, -0.018016422167420387, 0.002708373125642538, -0.02867700718343258, 0.04163895547389984, -0.037677716463804245, -0.0029688761569559574, -0.0336788073182106, 0.0009694737964309752, 0.024134641513228416, 0.023735230788588524, 0.004833976738154888, -0.0069217560812830925, -0.011692308820784092, -0.08062754571437836, -0.008282512426376343, 0.017388662323355675, -0.01593349315226078, 0.015178871341049671, 0.03483809158205986, -0.022025102749466896, 0.00020885364210698754, -0.013511890545487404, 0.013899062760174274, 0.015082074329257011, 0.043373607099056244, -0.013860144652426243, -0.02850295975804329, 0.07998710125684738, 0.003997711464762688, -0.022268518805503845, -0.05128176510334015, -0.0018096750136464834, 0.0013545278925448656, -0.011441939510405064, -0.019587595015764236, -0.03388843685388565, -0.004019356332719326, 0.029643312096595764, -0.044027622789144516, -0.013677210547029972, -0.007903223857283592, -0.03613816201686859, 0.038593824952840805, 0.02647387608885765, -0.06982555985450745, 0.032515931874513626, 0.0005633843247778714, -0.003720624139532447, 0.008205379359424114, 0.012040319852530956, 0.019195590168237686, -0.01914619468152523, -0.014339244924485683, 0.028112148866057396, 0.03785985708236694, 0.04272116720676422, -0.013267707079648972, 0.008063245564699173, 0.024528563022613525, -0.006064135115593672, 0.003434434300288558, -0.018585339188575745, 0.03125159814953804, 0.07882873713970184, -0.10574720799922943, -0.018190447241067886, 0.09468594938516617, -0.06149689108133316, -0.015963148325681686, -0.0036289594136178493, 0.02299482375383377, -0.029343197122216225, -0.07246630638837814, 0.002612062729895115, -0.06653188914060593, 0.012846790254116058, 0.05537266656756401, 0.027931595221161842, 0.03385172784328461, 0.061640314757823944, -0.04038044065237045, -0.05229737609624863, -0.05278365686535835, -0.015701713040471077, -0.056974370032548904, 0.023989951238036156, 0.02207053452730179, -0.012263049371540546, 0.009586109779775143, -0.015607016161084175, -0.04652884975075722, 0.00972613226622343, 0.0033913059160113335, 0.00870166439563036, -0.04226895794272423, -0.03273135796189308, 0.024408385157585144, 0.02940981276333332, 0.024530010297894478, -0.0037802213337272406, -0.03231790289282799, -0.019957317039370537, -0.010907399468123913, 0.0012355904327705503, 0.03671567514538765, 0.043122999370098114, 0.05560414865612984, -0.011275987140834332, -0.06360030174255371, -0.01802682690322399, -0.015176380053162575, 0.047403279691934586, 0.00411622878164053, 0.03845857456326485, -0.016457974910736084, 0.014309882186353207, -0.015627389773726463, 0.0016657899832352996, 0.02117924578487873, -0.008187353610992432, -0.0013543713139370084, -0.04211488738656044, 0.04147423803806305, -0.01060354895889759, 0.05330986529588699, 0.037690456956624985, -0.007944498211145401, -0.03457971289753914, -0.06329730153083801, 0.030818091705441475, 0.011305232532322407, -0.04193303734064102, 0.002267538569867611, 0.011795111000537872, 0.030792662873864174, -0.04450555518269539, 0.04690404236316681, -0.007770861033350229, 0.017907394096255302, 0.007099953014403582, 0.006092686206102371, 0.0019511179998517036, 0.00981591735035181, -0.04223719239234924, -0.02376524731516838, 0.004865327849984169, -0.029668524861335754, -0.01991172879934311, 0.02694745734333992, -0.051963090896606445, 0.024461932480335236, 0.0542280375957489, -0.022936437278985977, 0.018676068633794785, 0.014214195311069489, -0.03897051140666008, -0.04393337666988373, -0.024156006053090096, 0.007933889515697956, 0.02946385368704796, 0.01989065483212471, -0.017355751246213913, -0.07283855974674225, -0.01164918765425682, 0.028226299211382866, 0.0046994928270578384, -0.014970440417528152, 0.033958420157432556, 0.021900149062275887, 0.027450723573565483, 0.04070065915584564, -0.004171998240053654, 0.08128083497285843, -0.02881884016096592, -0.05488419160246849, -0.00826198235154152, -0.00423484668135643, -0.0512709803879261, 0.027706993743777275, 0.00030009669717401266, 0.010775679722428322, -0.023539407178759575, -0.016108686104416847, -0.03102557174861431, -0.023783549666404724, 0.05740005522966385, -0.0023696536663919687, -0.008269078098237514, -0.034430406987667084, 0.03509069234132767, -0.009219824336469173, 0.07451936602592468, 0.0292380228638649, -0.00005566976324189454, -0.01970040239393711, 0.06001130864024162, -0.04546339064836502, -0.04315472021698952, -0.016891561448574066, 0.10634579509496689, 0.028568487614393234, 0.04218892753124237, 0.006877807900309563, -0.030716167762875557, -0.001881993724964559, 0.041125185787677765, -0.02028563991189003, -0.05231788009405136, -0.06129349768161774, 0.0336151123046875, -0.07807563990354538, 0.010199193842709064, 0.0011132361833006144, 0.08104293793439865, 0.0770772323012352, -0.009460044093430042, 0.03174242749810219, 0.014293611980974674, 0.021914280951023102, -0.01078660786151886, 0.019131513312458992, -0.020229199901223183, -0.03962228074669838, -0.04234424605965614, -0.056569091975688934, 0.024918323382735252, -0.02415786311030388, -0.02008969523012638, -0.008832731284201145, -0.05067172646522522, -0.06857878714799881, -0.0007634965586476028, -0.007581212092190981, -0.002896765246987343, -0.06063934788107872, -0.002879147883504629, 0.006888184696435928, 0.0026424541138112545, -0.04322109743952751, 0.000810644356533885, 0.016235265880823135, -0.04870651662349701, -0.01916067861020565, -0.03353762626647949, -0.006952036637812853, 0.02364286407828331, 0.022639822214841843, 0.00217344774864614, 0.004847646225243807, -0.003432417055591941, -0.012450775131583214, -0.009681138209998608, 0.004902346525341272, -0.015360016375780106, -0.03268217295408249, -0.026562465354800224, -0.00929189845919609, 0.022494452074170113, -0.0010255444794893265, 0.004038512706756592, 0.010327093303203583, 0.055536091327667236, -0.03883812576532364, -0.04350736364722252, 0.02049984037876129, 0.004796385765075684, -0.02139461413025856, -0.026578404009342194, 0.02494887448847294, -0.07689663022756577, -0.01834714412689209, 0.018249066546559334, -0.025852223858237267, 0.09517285972833633, -0.08873402327299118, -0.01658662036061287, -0.01261869352310896, 0.046745020896196365, -0.019969187676906586, 0.05882563814520836, 0.037752024829387665, -0.04301769286394119, 0.0223054401576519, 0.0024542799219489098, -0.0528203547000885, -0.038128022104501724, 0.0016225753352046013, -0.05260448530316353, -0.044316615909338, 0.011288262903690338, -0.07213961333036423, -0.004365519154816866, -0.05898797884583473, 0.021054759621620178, -0.003300339449197054, -0.013209326192736626, 0.010924987494945526, -0.04911226034164429, 0.04104986786842346, 0.00946139171719551, -0.03361682966351509, -0.02815415896475315, 0.015872342512011528, 0.010867361910641193, 0.07024331390857697, 0.025593383237719536, -0.0047218878753483295, 0.08703504502773285, 0.02404467947781086, -0.06036066263914108, -0.0017903638072311878, -0.022471711039543152, 0.03931127116084099, 0.02413826622068882, 0.07966036349534988, -0.02536373771727085, 0.06565619260072708, 0.06636158376932144, -0.04879220202565193, 0.0055417451076209545, -0.02581988088786602, -0.03708649054169655, 0.007700037211179733, 0.02392764389514923, -0.001925970776937902, 0.06701264530420303, -0.016361933201551437, 0.06902142614126205, 0.06410853564739227, 0.03965715318918228, 0.004406122490763664, -0.008235245011746883, 0.02673286758363247, -0.00679407175630331, 0.064188152551651, 0.023828085511922836, 0.01007931586354971, 0.03856198117136955, 0.06312668323516846, -0.017013192176818848, -0.067105233669281, 0.014967734925448895, -0.026386961340904236, 0.04424629732966423, 0.030641265213489532, -0.0413011759519577, 0.03954436257481575, 0.0221344493329525, 0.02811099775135517, 0.010463250800967216, -0.07705085724592209, 0.009684712626039982, -0.058876145631074905, 0.04787814989686012, 0.010001231916248798, 0.019964788109064102, -0.07564005255699158, -0.017412031069397926, -0.015942774713039398, 0.029218366369605064, -0.011992430314421654, -0.006758313160389662, 0.049961499869823456, 0.010459930635988712, -0.08654585480690002, -0.024927444756031036, 0.027763275429606438, -0.034088414162397385, 0.00907258503139019, -0.019053008407354355, -0.06559190154075623, -0.04752166196703911, -0.04334603622555733, 0.05453196540474892, 0.03144955262541771, 0.009772470220923424, -0.03366352245211601, -0.001641825889237225, 0.05328304320573807, 0.015253004617989063, 0.006318152416497469, 0.013906031847000122, -0.007232506759464741, 0.051619693636894226, -0.0008052311604842544, 0.03920813649892807, -0.030019523575901985, -0.01979401893913746, 0.005340662784874439, -0.03682707995176315, -0.003922532312572002, 0.03534668684005737, -0.025131208822131157, 0.01449520606547594, -0.03475556522607803, -0.04550132155418396, -0.022044533863663673, 0.027432139962911606, 0.05375080555677414, 0.026583485305309296, -0.07371723651885986, -0.002537061460316181, 0.06309416145086288, -0.017252085730433464, -0.013700122013688087, 0.008594290353357792, 0.03707977756857872, 0.045145198702812195, 0.01393104624003172, -0.004605126101523638, 0.04111431539058685, 0.0022508888505399227, 0.015448197722434998, 0.0447249710559845, -0.02425575442612171, -0.002274776343256235, 0.05900315195322037, 0.028143184259533882, 0.00747333699837327, 0.011039835400879383, 0.018298078328371048, -0.007534530945122242, -0.08773201704025269, 0.0006556490552611649, -0.018761858344078064, -0.042523372918367386, -0.034744009375572205, 0.03493788465857506, 0.00997813418507576, -0.02927323430776596, -0.02407260797917843, 0.015203280374407768, 0.024293899536132812, -0.025917675346136093, -0.048910509794950485, 0.026174478232860565, -0.006459703668951988, 0.015536879189312458, 0.0026559066027402878, 0.0048006633296608925, 0.01893133670091629, -0.016224414110183716, -0.019576162099838257, 0.0021728912834078074, -0.004928031470626593, -0.05386873707175255, 0.015067904256284237, 0.05686572939157486, 0.07469264417886734, -0.010837500914931297, 0.006263511721044779, -0.03324957937002182, 0.022635627537965775, -0.03520039841532707, 0.034172944724559784, 0.03912288323044777, 0.027206197381019592, 0.011694381944835186, 0.0032238177955150604, -0.00410674000158906, 0.0056252251379191875, -0.02893376350402832, -0.04871722683310509, -0.0005898316157981753, 0.03135169297456741, -0.005901668220758438, 0.087404265999794, 0.011600066907703876, -0.035667747259140015, 0.05636237934231758, -0.02351997420191765, -0.0020855050534009933, 0.035663902759552, 0.02334241382777691, 0.016711119562387466, 0.007643801160156727, 0.04081207513809204, -0.03660183772444725, 0.08319385349750519, -0.009629450738430023, -0.023074502125382423, -0.020570319145917892, -0.014044590294361115, -0.04610338434576988, 0.015503671951591969, 0.07202502340078354, 0.03900373727083206, -0.028070921078324318, -0.05635317414999008, -0.040019989013671875, -0.08867190033197403, 0.03758547455072403, 0.02385232225060463, 0.07329916208982468, -0.026131005957722664, -0.03407725691795349, -0.03403875231742859, -0.04373258352279663, -0.034007247537374496, -0.028905091807246208, 0.04587685316801071, -0.00900631956756115, 0.034763965755701065, 0.005079125519841909, -0.036691926419734955, 0.002738786395639181, -0.042286068201065063, -0.029711978510022163, -0.04028308391571045, -0.01756572350859642, 0.029208660125732422, -0.054330021142959595, -0.017352880910038948, -0.05992773547768593, -0.0482582189142704, -0.05613097921013832, -0.02710995264351368, -0.08177068829536438, -0.03020302578806877, 0.0033938433043658733, -0.04166891798377037, 0.02706105262041092, -0.010206302627921104, -0.02888324484229088, -0.05167875811457634, -0.04527301341295242, -0.030488472431898117, 0.04075230285525322, 0.08292757719755173, 0.056645430624485016, 0.05708126723766327, 0.034174978733062744, -0.06561416387557983, 0.05094105377793312, -0.003616487141698599, -0.014574590139091015, 0.0061949179507792, -0.0002650142414495349, -0.006029861513525248, -0.018368879333138466, -0.05132260546088219, -0.002724910154938698 ]
<p>I would like to have a general interpretation of the coefficients of the stiffness matrix that appears in <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finite_element_method">FEM</a>. For instance if we are solving a linear elasticity problem and we modelize the relation between a node $i$ and a node $j$ as a spring system, then $K_{i,j}$ (where $K$ is the stiffness matrix of the system) can be seen as the stiffness constant of the virtual spring between the two nodes. But does there exist a more general interpretation? Perhaps in terms of internal work? </p> <p>Another similar question is: What could be an interpretation of the coefficients $M_{i,j}$ of the mass matrix $M$?</p>
g1670
[ 0.030618960037827492, -0.016756564378738403, 0.015392064116895199, 0.006097035016864538, 0.0834677591919899, -0.043003469705581665, 0.020861582830548286, 0.041457463055849075, -0.00015439465641975403, 0.020466437563300133, -0.04642362892627716, 0.004694665782153606, -0.0068710194900631905, -0.0136037552729249, -0.02959916554391384, -0.010729583911597729, 0.05461040511727333, -0.010751922614872456, 0.00351341743953526, -0.0010967751732096076, 0.030637597665190697, 0.030300302430987358, 0.003896869719028473, 0.03738958016037941, 0.063515804708004, 0.07847214490175247, 0.053670916706323624, 0.03171801567077637, -0.03174324706196785, -0.006773518864065409, 0.02052278071641922, -0.050467349588871, 0.0668451189994812, -0.06922473013401031, -0.044359251856803894, 0.03262430056929588, -0.01563091389834881, 0.04986414313316345, 0.02177019603550434, -0.011411788873374462, -0.0009020104189403355, -0.049984581768512726, -0.055203165858983994, 0.058812037110328674, 0.004229507874697447, 0.03098158724606037, -0.021376533433794975, -0.03326256573200226, -0.060504380613565445, -0.025882521644234657, 0.024986853823065758, 0.02402716688811779, 0.004535928834229708, -0.022155214101076126, 0.03709268942475319, 0.04631354659795761, 0.05636806786060333, 0.027631955221295357, 0.07197431474924088, 0.03599890321493149, 0.00039606846985407174, 0.039980124682188034, -0.027193494141101837, -0.05244523286819458, 0.025634245947003365, 0.026161745190620422, -0.0011490737088024616, -0.018581736832857132, -0.01213794108480215, 0.02616489678621292, 0.011219627223908901, 0.013099228963255882, 0.01629585586488247, -0.026987558230757713, -0.025307314470410347, 0.015646224841475487, 0.009900154545903206, 0.011067858897149563, 0.060146018862724304, -0.023333102464675903, 0.016777290031313896, 0.042983412742614746, -0.031061682850122452, 0.03293851390480995, 0.05670743063092232, 0.024464188143610954, 0.010173088870942593, 0.04474438726902008, 0.051642708480358124, 0.036342211067676544, 0.005937555804848671, 0.02492629364132881, 0.010590646415948868, 0.023912586271762848, -0.06282685697078705, -0.0724988728761673, -0.01791684329509735, 0.03244767338037491, -0.02001241222023964, -0.03645749017596245, -0.0206120777875185, 0.02104182355105877, -0.008484307676553726, 0.0033160110469907522, -0.017869556322693825, 0.0075467489659786224, 0.012064353562891483, -0.006048956885933876, -0.022984517738223076, -0.004734022542834282, -0.06950873136520386, 0.01561854686588049, -0.0344308577477932, -0.025362659245729446, -0.01577857695519924, -0.09237644076347351, 0.0401926152408123, -0.03703125938773155, 0.007536045275628567, 0.020162392407655716, -0.005487645510584116, -0.01796562783420086, 0.010542103089392185, 0.02539926767349243, 0.011674442328512669, -0.020369427278637886, 0.053316690027713776, 0.041990235447883606, -0.019721275195479393, -0.04883057251572609, 0.014426820911467075, -0.050070468336343765, 0.025980990380048752, -0.04377303272485733, -0.004230713006108999, 0.023729488253593445, -0.04257206991314888, 0.006805612239986658, 0.025755809620022774, 0.04178258776664734, -0.026516342535614967, -0.03839971497654915, -0.04980434477329254, -0.08248621225357056, -0.017633266746997833, 0.043085869401693344, -0.0023803331423550844, -0.02188311330974102, 0.018109772354364395, 0.05994334816932678, 0.008078383281826973, 0.06630343198776245, -0.036224789917469025, 0.003749019932001829, 0.012357228435575962, 0.037161216139793396, -0.06602095812559128, -0.05007099732756615, 0.012637055478990078, -0.016351619735360146, -0.0025526194367557764, -0.02487879805266857, 0.010188601911067963, -0.04823647066950798, -0.012770304456353188, -0.023750683292746544, -0.05585866793990135, -0.06569317728281021, 0.00668041268363595, -0.028085049241781235, -0.06408392637968063, -0.02932988852262497, -0.0027050350327044725, 0.025226114317774773, -0.004975064191967249, -0.0022721814457327127, 0.01085744984447956, -0.07797053456306458, 0.021063508465886116, 0.07273958623409271, -0.0055038053542375565, 0.0235347468405962, 0.05448710173368454, -0.019861873239278793, -0.044951070100069046, -0.01871459372341633, 0.028188373893499374, 0.014294871129095554, -0.04830516129732132, -0.005841022823005915, -0.010217184200882912, 0.04023047536611557, 0.03907272219657898, 0.07091829180717468, 0.008958308026194572, -0.04983498901128769, -0.0019588759168982506, 0.04219084233045578, -0.00946919433772564, -0.03771016374230385, 0.04094818979501724, 0.019145533442497253, 0.004955357871949673, 0.05183937028050423, -0.027750903740525246, -0.012808711268007755, -0.02467874437570572, -0.017517734318971634, 0.03622064366936684, 0.021003814414143562, 0.019819214940071106, -0.010657771490514278, -0.025763055309653282, 0.03454301878809929, -0.006533933337777853, -0.04247605428099632, 0.022754492238163948, -0.07688473165035248, 0.0017749457620084286, 0.02295456826686859, -0.02790519781410694, -0.036072321236133575, -0.013435096479952335, -0.01709013804793358, -0.11926843225955963, -0.03490953519940376, 0.03764848783612251, -0.003169965697452426, -0.002650305861607194, 0.0008646784699521959, -0.013693399727344513, 0.043711163103580475, -0.014114531688392162, -0.019594766199588776, 0.00864784698933363, 0.019559113308787346, 0.0019780758302658796, 0.0361398309469223, -0.042566560208797455, -0.01415108423680067, 0.0342562310397625, -0.030549725517630577, 0.0035041235387325287, -0.010042968206107616, 0.008448376320302486, -0.013507230207324028, 0.040654972195625305, -0.004596387036144733, 0.05089171230792999, 0.021962841972708702, -0.03350809961557388, -0.006154101807624102, -0.04413369670510292, 0.05232733488082886, -0.01146402396261692, -0.07613388448953629, -0.007022505160421133, 0.011668907478451729, -0.0005994918174110353, -0.05795039236545563, -0.0006529060774482787, -0.07332626730203629, -0.01107208151370287, 0.060041580349206924, -0.10838157683610916, -0.04408568516373634, 0.0026236779522150755, -0.03981903940439224, 0.023827675729990005, 0.01675015687942505, 0.01176325511187315, 0.0555749386548996, 0.06349358707666397, 0.06206599622964859, -0.00598033145070076, -0.05621969327330589, -0.01842283457517624, 0.04088487848639488, -0.03251318261027336, 0.013887066394090652, -0.04474484920501709, -0.005244898144155741, -0.02391798049211502, -0.012303538620471954, 0.07574336975812912, -0.0010467589600011706, -0.04964049533009529, 0.02683699131011963, -0.008467844687402248, 0.0011449632002040744, -0.004604801069945097, 0.000660062360111624, -0.04697559028863907, -0.018215108662843704, -0.06355919688940048, 0.0891762524843216, 0.02488180436193943, -0.09781152009963989, -0.024201171472668648, 0.11405541747808456, -0.007385218515992165, -0.028745487332344055, -0.010112138465046883, -0.013077042996883392, -0.030949044972658157, 0.019877389073371887, -0.0243909303098917, -0.0002942877181340009, -0.004259715788066387, -0.032617658376693726, -0.013122658245265484, -0.015220029279589653, 0.04752302169799805, -0.01758110709488392, -0.06849152594804764, 0.04632012918591499, -0.03936192765831947, -0.003815846052020788, -0.008009769022464752, -0.04446715861558914, -0.03821129351854324, -0.09014198929071426, 0.07032694667577744, 0.00324198417365551, 0.006466641090810299, 0.001121997949667275, -0.03653724119067192, 0.016667986288666725, -0.006215622648596764, -0.009580196812748909, 0.006944157648831606, -0.013351901434361935, -0.08456334471702576, 0.015048782341182232, -0.09280356764793396, -0.06757082045078278, -0.05205828323960304, 0.01953175663948059, 0.029811076819896698, -0.006519617047160864, 0.007063207682222128, 0.017112761735916138, 0.011177667416632175, 0.011397985741496086, -0.028384268283843994, -0.0192006453871727, -0.0309346504509449, 0.031986743211746216, 0.030842790380120277, -0.0419965423643589, 0.06252086907625198, 0.03327484056353569, 0.014213614165782928, 0.004788063932210207, -0.03111969865858555, -0.005852358415722847, 0.0304753165692091, 0.009609752334654331, -0.09340067952871323, 0.012344129383563995, 0.05182797461748123, -0.005482698790729046, 0.025166483595967293, 0.03379485011100769, -0.02545272558927536, -0.02261178568005562, 0.0038310796953737736, 0.05250021442770958, 0.039145126938819885, -0.026927370578050613, 0.009974132291972637, -0.02953103929758072, 0.018214432522654533, 0.032688673585653305, -0.01570897176861763, 0.014839675277471542, 0.043824102729558945, 0.057475388050079346, -0.0232539139688015, -0.018566688522696495, 0.04223690927028656, 0.04494548216462135, 0.0173835176974535, 0.03645763546228409, 0.06738670915365219, -0.037806328386068344, -0.028994949534535408, 0.026438647881150246, 0.011452260427176952, -0.03689766302704811, 0.043832968920469284, -0.053268104791641235, -0.026721427217125893, 0.06837053596973419, 0.05264747887849808, -0.002742560813203454, -0.012071247212588787, 0.011487865820527077, -0.032567478716373444, 0.04015802964568138, -0.02384772337973118, 0.024163343012332916, -0.028680900111794472, 0.05778055638074875, 0.010900451801717281, 0.0646006241440773, -0.020244291052222252, -0.006717008538544178, 0.011549028567969799, -0.02958032302558422, -0.016348958015441895, -0.0288771353662014, 0.008142833597958088, -0.0077490368857979774, 0.007867436856031418, 0.08032885193824768, -0.008692875504493713, -0.025958048179745674, 0.029812276363372803, -0.05196034908294678, 0.017750298604369164, 0.0328199602663517, -0.05890703573822975, -0.0041736396960914135, 0.01890702173113823, 0.03588491305708885, 0.025195909664034843, -0.04271169751882553, -0.029958151280879974, -0.05513355880975723, -0.01799650304019451, -0.005108869634568691, 0.0018671153811737895, 0.0003689640434458852, 0.022475983947515488, 0.03988919407129288, -0.012696254067122936, 0.02616317756474018, -0.033087972551584244, -0.02539772540330887, -0.033378757536411285, 0.022451696917414665, 0.03420434147119522, 0.03566805273294449, -0.03300793841481209, -0.045486241579055786, -0.06342694908380508, 0.06660383194684982, -0.07461974024772644, -0.024464711546897888, -0.03371158987283707, 0.01185810286551714, 0.03799198567867279, -0.038087692111730576, -0.05537141487002373, -0.011597055941820145, 0.004301881417632103, 0.0018815133953467011, 0.0038040713407099247, -0.03226876258850098, 0.03269359469413757, -0.04895627498626709, -0.030852822586894035, 0.05432493984699249, -0.029053833335638046, 0.004891939926892519, -0.027092965319752693, 0.04142221063375473, -0.04270495846867561, 0.04613994061946869, 0.03796552121639252, -0.021005377173423767, -0.03987077996134758, 0.01886904612183571, 0.07126833498477936, 0.018425816670060158, -0.009533137083053589, -0.03725259751081467, 0.026733340695500374, -0.04182637110352516, 0.008924842812120914, 0.030553830787539482, 0.01546166930347681, 0.00468113599345088, 0.03340654447674751, -0.03735166788101196, 0.0334676168859005, 0.00519772432744503, -0.004222087562084198, -0.004753960762172937, 0.022564349696040154, 0.07587391883134842, -0.024670163169503212, 0.018318697810173035, -0.04474141448736191, 0.01035730354487896, 0.019330767914652824, -0.014195037074387074, -0.0016782747115939856, -0.01601724699139595, 0.007982752285897732, 0.02842900902032852, 0.012988314032554626, -0.006620165891945362, 0.007432893849909306, 0.016092101112008095, 0.02604811079800129, -0.06442192196846008, 0.013265223242342472, 0.014778981916606426, 0.04035518318414688, -0.02166292443871498, 0.024719683453440666, 0.06088778376579285, 0.009095419198274612, 0.03197978064417839, 0.043787673115730286, -0.012083572335541248, -0.016050327569246292, -0.018047969788312912, 0.035035811364650726, -0.039421502500772476, 0.049119725823402405, -0.08179992437362671, -0.014585827477276325, -0.00807085633277893, -0.00009553624113323167, -0.007304193452000618, -0.02337375096976757, 0.05276920273900032, -0.023242229595780373, 0.016712237149477005, -0.03573467582464218, 0.019149955362081528, -0.020206008106470108, -0.035455916076898575, 0.01236345898360014, -0.03646688535809517, -0.00008081742271315306, 0.024785926565527916, 0.0038615213707089424, 0.025181716307997704, 0.05884698033332825, -0.008365805260837078, -0.010004017502069473, 0.0003859248827211559, 0.06460022926330566, -0.01113259606063366, 0.05716755986213684, 0.002545831957831979, -0.002369215711951256, 0.021669961512088776, -0.057117145508527756, -0.010394089855253696, 0.028703998774290085, 0.087786003947258, 0.020323242992162704, -0.04216931015253067, -0.031148113310337067, 0.023492775857448578, 0.01081712543964386, 0.06976399570703506, -0.019113313406705856, -0.04519302397966385, 0.02261948771774769, -0.05624235421419144, 0.004878159146755934, -0.011542132124304771, 0.022481633350253105, 0.030768711119890213, 0.00031098045292310417, -0.001584160141646862, 0.027946654707193375, 0.048664480447769165, -0.0038236090913414955, 0.010165593586862087, -0.03363984823226929, -0.048410817980766296, -0.0018196339951828122, -0.0035476330667734146, 0.031163234263658524, -0.01122990995645523, 0.05714689567685127, 0.023374054580926895, -0.013445439748466015, -0.02662792056798935, -0.0468277670443058, -0.032693613320589066, 0.026430925354361534, -0.02536931075155735, -0.00692629674449563, -0.013973810710012913, -0.03057202324271202, 0.05237099155783653, -0.014351911842823029, 0.053907379508018494, -0.0022523514926433563, 0.028295177966356277, -0.006015676073729992, 0.06348718702793121, 0.060640595853328705, 0.04922182112932205, 0.04657712206244469, -0.04540286958217621, 0.02882157824933529, -0.044695496559143066, 0.0070197065360844135, 0.006139806006103754, -0.060402218252420425, -0.03940451145172119, 0.036012303084135056, 0.07648667693138123, -0.049917008727788925, 0.04648687317967415, 0.07037319242954254, -0.026047971099615097, -0.06282752752304077, 0.005313580390065908, -0.05538425222039223, -0.02667597495019436, -0.022518249228596687, -0.07173841446638107, 0.019826294854283333, -0.025199227035045624, -0.004351862706243992, 0.022238023579120636, -0.02843654714524746, 0.05227307230234146, 0.0054780300706624985, 0.028826119378209114, -0.011349650099873543, 0.004843158647418022, 0.022577213123440742, 0.0228365957736969, 0.0534953847527504, 0.030162567272782326, -0.043154675513505936, 0.0158983264118433, 0.03454289957880974, 0.08830073475837708, -0.04691882058978081, -0.024589689448475838, -0.002486793790012598, 0.014352969825267792, -0.04664108529686928, -0.02112574130296707, 0.03815612196922302, -0.016638867557048798, -0.036779265850782394, 0.00957962404936552, 0.023513203486800194, 0.0313706137239933, 0.022277098149061203, 0.025249643251299858, 0.03424353152513504, 0.01765519753098488, -0.011646215803921223, -0.034913770854473114, 0.07952796667814255, -0.05279827490448952, -0.06574888527393341, 0.03396747261285782, 0.04692838713526726, -0.050532013177871704, -0.05287071689963341, 0.04109776020050049, 0.03666926547884941, -0.019182827323675156, -0.014524724334478378, 0.012142407707870007, 0.009274040348827839, -0.04509338364005089, 0.08086313307285309, -0.0006430152570828795, -0.02814149297773838, 0.010915926657617092, -0.04347056522965431, 0.010435150004923344, 0.0009004484745673835, 0.0001537954231025651, -0.01607893966138363, 0.04025115817785263, -0.005873192101716995, 0.05076897516846657, -0.021470818668603897, 0.02031293325126171, -0.0022514788433909416, -0.03656263276934624, -0.05512164160609245, 0.02157694101333618, -0.02465575560927391, 0.012225012294948101, -0.013217821717262268, -0.013626121915876865, -0.034747250378131866, -0.037647586315870285, 0.018117565661668777, 0.06814443320035934, 0.04393773898482323, 0.011737707071006298, -0.02544063702225685, 0.02829185500741005, -0.02775675058364868, 0.0254710391163826, 0.027569618076086044, 0.001108782016672194, -0.04057343676686287, 0.004827205557376146, -0.014453768730163574, 0.0006131297559477389, -0.03139704093337059, 0.023867908865213394, 0.02321949601173401, 0.023643165826797485, -0.04827504605054855, 0.028229253366589546, -0.03979314863681793, 0.015866633504629135, 0.002787234727293253, -0.04531589522957802, -0.031590089201927185, 0.027020163834095, 0.03994538635015488, -0.07007783651351929, -0.016623957082629204, -0.006674427539110184, 0.018144896253943443, 0.02857833355665207, -0.017155952751636505, 0.01612754352390766, 0.01869267225265503, -0.05881017446517944, 0.00839785486459732, 0.004563337191939354, -0.015853554010391235, 0.04778539761900902, 0.06598639488220215, -0.07579822093248367, -0.032108161598443985, 0.059577371925115585, -0.02346917800605297, -0.05122372508049011, 0.00024104659678414464, 0.023831943050026894, 0.020311370491981506, -0.058632563799619675, -0.06748490780591965, 0.027999242767691612, 0.022780312225222588, -0.03374712914228439, 0.020860832184553146, -0.046612195670604706, 0.020373722538352013, 0.034421343356370926, -0.030209410935640335, -0.029071222990751266, -0.036344967782497406, 0.017309535294771194, -0.014944200403988361, -0.009985321201384068, -0.016194049268960953, 0.012801095843315125, -0.037762437015771866, 0.023071391507983208, -0.0557357557117939, -0.03281863033771515, -0.06718512624502182, 0.06887977570295334 ]
<p>I've seen the Kaluza-Klein metric presented in two different ways., cf. Refs. 1 and 2. </p> <ol> <li><p>In one, there is a constant as well as an additional scalar field introduced: $$\tilde{g}_{AB}=\begin{pmatrix} g_{\mu \nu}+k_1^2\phi^2 A_\mu A_\nu &amp; k_1\phi^2 A_\mu \\ k_1\phi^2 A_\nu &amp; \phi^2 \end{pmatrix}.$$</p></li> <li><p>In the other, only a constant is introduced:</p></li> </ol> <p>$$\tilde{g}_{AB}=\begin{pmatrix} g_{\mu \nu}+k_2A_\mu A_\nu &amp; k_2A_\mu \\ k_2A_\nu &amp; k_2 \end{pmatrix}.$$</p> <p>Doesn't the second take care of any problems associated with an unobserved scalar field? Or is there some reason why the first is preferred?</p> <p>References:</p> <ol> <li><p>William O. Straub, <em>Kaluza-Klein Theory,</em> Lecture notes, Pasadena, California, 2008. The pdf file is available <a href="http://math.arizona.edu/~vpiercey/KaluzaKlein.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>.</p></li> <li><p>Victor I. Piercey, <em>Kaluza-Klein Gravity,</em> Lecture notes for PHYS 569, University of Arizona, 2008. The pdf file is available <a href="http://www.weylmann.com/kaluza.pdf" rel="nofollow">here</a>.</p></li> </ol>
g1671
[ 0.043073829263448715, 0.03902991861104965, -0.009045426733791828, 0.003323775716125965, 0.021172305569052696, 0.005887847859412432, 0.015977544710040092, 0.02174808457493782, -0.048249855637550354, -0.0015887023182585835, 0.008092166855931282, -0.030773958191275597, 0.0366947203874588, 0.0072813741862773895, 0.008607310242950916, -0.03266928344964981, 0.019461898133158684, -0.033300984650850296, 0.03259224444627762, 0.032057568430900574, -0.051765378564596176, -0.001701841363683343, 0.019429069012403488, -0.041063498705625534, 0.04027818888425827, -0.01476579811424017, 0.03981325030326843, -0.0034384233877062798, -0.01530412770807743, -0.07973866909742355, 0.04197593033313751, 0.011174364946782589, 0.04764588177204132, -0.028624504804611206, 0.015446938574314117, 0.0024114286061376333, 0.055781520903110504, 0.004152628593146801, -0.012674126774072647, -0.02952963300049305, -0.008360768668353558, 0.02385186031460762, 0.009143617935478687, 0.051651593297719955, -0.008226324804127216, -0.05795860290527344, -0.024774901568889618, 0.044217415153980255, -0.0020076874643564224, 0.006221248768270016, 0.02159060165286064, 0.05803044140338898, -0.005180627107620239, 0.06089092046022415, 0.026216672733426094, 0.03954748436808586, 0.04541180282831192, 0.022972863167524338, 0.032839108258485794, 0.020602431148290634, -0.038192056119441986, -0.012098724953830242, 0.010255741886794567, -0.0012219651835039258, -0.017087019979953766, -0.05542043596506119, -0.05556732043623924, -0.059105873107910156, 0.02597472257912159, 0.010629269294440746, -0.013034502975642681, 0.010682590305805206, 0.023737063631415367, 0.015689553692936897, -0.04463886097073555, 0.02320089377462864, -0.023219559341669083, 0.023738054558634758, 0.014756097458302975, -0.0011647632345557213, -0.007543834391981363, 0.0371682271361351, 0.07252839207649231, 0.012582136318087578, 0.07872049510478973, -0.006385411601513624, 0.014854745008051395, 0.012078912928700447, 0.019320152699947357, 0.03026897832751274, 0.008124767802655697, -0.017695464193820953, 0.029782261699438095, 0.012359348125755787, -0.01792329177260399, -0.07253852486610413, -0.021673591807484627, 0.011400441639125347, -0.03081938438117504, 0.015629131346940994, 0.02039109542965889, 0.06293898075819016, 0.04665476828813553, 0.03573621064424515, 0.0040372745133936405, -0.043704260140657425, 0.040626440197229385, 0.009376998990774155, -0.062083128839731216, -0.026151875033974648, 0.009786299429833889, 0.038349464535713196, -0.016769669950008392, -0.06503625214099884, -0.06179049238562584, -0.052766986191272736, 0.07055964320898056, 0.022045820951461792, 0.04744158312678337, 0.016386549919843674, -0.06764467805624008, 0.03669431433081627, 0.057368457317352295, -0.003616977483034134, -0.01861480250954628, -0.0025823344476521015, 0.040933866053819656, -0.03507542982697487, 0.020860301330685616, -0.06572071462869644, 0.030951283872127533, 0.01402285322546959, 0.01421420369297266, 0.037383370101451874, -0.015744701027870178, 0.020427487790584564, 0.008819175884127617, 0.023015443235635757, -0.051593948155641556, 0.03669043257832527, -0.05949273705482483, -0.07156270742416382, -0.02513500675559044, -0.02760045975446701, 0.032523319125175476, 0.03276628628373146, -0.004672234877943993, 0.017297180369496346, 0.053103525191545486, -0.07361975312232971, 0.04587065055966377, 0.08459194749593735, -0.041332706809043884, 0.037778839468955994, -0.0186005886644125, 0.03143208101391792, 0.014802874997258186, -0.005395958200097084, 0.03233863040804863, -0.01982295699417591, 0.046768445521593094, 0.010064428672194481, 0.05131209269165993, -0.003818358527496457, -0.02780713513493538, 0.004499964881688356, 0.01138664036989212, -0.007765634451061487, 0.05067704617977142, -0.06508422642946243, 0.04600660130381584, -0.008729375898838043, 0.0159158892929554, 0.10562510043382645, 0.008336121216416359, 0.02633948251605034, 0.04041649028658867, 0.009733743965625763, 0.043756891041994095, -0.02508232556283474, -0.04804156348109245, 0.015897143632173538, -0.011490087024867535, 0.0024554820265620947, 0.0013564894907176495, -0.06041477993130684, -0.02763100154697895, 0.030344845727086067, -0.07246101647615433, 0.024776611477136612, -0.010027945041656494, -0.0070638833567500114, -0.046089187264442444, 0.0677700787782669, -0.01921684853732586, 0.05760924890637398, 0.026738567277789116, -0.046569645404815674, -0.05281633138656616, 0.02377123385667801, -0.004845520947128534, 0.04890744388103485, -0.055149052292108536, -0.00133350002579391, -0.026054931804537773, 0.009632490575313568, -0.032692134380340576, 0.02946017123758793, 0.0977945551276207, -0.037470493465662, -0.03041449375450611, -0.04274563491344452, 0.023236162960529327, 0.014481596648693085, 0.049246057868003845, 0.028621219098567963, -0.016239861026406288, 0.026178376749157906, -0.03766975179314613, 0.0372883640229702, 0.013981289230287075, 0.02276783250272274, 0.04875633865594864, 0.0002266508381580934, -0.04338381439447403, -0.02687004581093788, -0.050202563405036926, -0.013735959306359291, -0.020298374816775322, -0.011003701947629452, -0.060734882950782776, -0.09735836833715439, 0.011629574000835419, 0.08469534665346146, 0.003616944421082735, -0.012359016574919224, -0.013057791627943516, 0.01852039247751236, 0.05386088043451309, 0.007018717005848885, 0.054260626435279846, -0.014766807667911053, 0.02611146867275238, 0.045903682708740234, 0.0372922383248806, -0.04190009459853172, 0.026426536962389946, -0.04310520365834236, 0.03522631898522377, 0.013200579211115837, 0.03666918724775314, -0.030091332271695137, 0.010168850421905518, -0.058957163244485855, 0.016366425901651382, -0.04530130326747894, 0.048842478543519974, 0.03453904017806053, -0.04840119555592537, 0.007590057794004679, 0.01593160815536976, -0.06605303287506104, -0.030415711924433708, 0.03112884610891342, -0.04697638750076294, -0.0002250403631478548, -0.028314366936683655, 0.0755254477262497, -0.006858691573143005, -0.06626924872398376, -0.03481503948569298, 0.032968856394290924, 0.048033103346824646, 0.02046556957066059, -0.036867037415504456, -0.02819640375673771, 0.014355628751218319, -0.02006552740931511, -0.02059643156826496, 0.008758874610066414, 0.0012582851340994239, -0.031150395050644875, -0.00969539862126112, 0.003193192183971405, 0.08113835006952286, -0.02183801867067814, -0.04735632613301277, 0.0032981906551867723, 0.017177991569042206, 0.03838155418634415, -0.009421865455806255, 0.09174662828445435, 0.05581545829772949, -0.034826770424842834, 0.018364502117037773, 0.04495781660079956, 0.004435370676219463, -0.05982731282711029, 0.009646342135965824, -0.009106233716011047, 0.028888016939163208, -0.039488330483436584, 0.0006178916082717478, -0.06704574823379517, -0.008769048377871513, -0.05636817216873169, -0.04720987007021904, -0.09796380996704102, 0.001953595317900181, 0.023821823298931122, 0.001774754375219345, 0.042296167463064194, 0.0073276907205581665, 0.0006067196372896433, -0.07801909744739532, -0.017431560903787613, -0.004146773833781481, -0.021008135750889778, -0.054141249507665634, 0.0008901517721824348, -0.0009871718939393759, -0.006469746585935354, -0.017606325447559357, 0.033504992723464966, -0.038255609571933746, 0.039440613240003586, -0.010617191903293133, 0.04110093414783478, -0.009844576939940453, 0.004917668178677559, 0.008396015502512455, 0.018480179831385612, -0.045707955956459045, 0.014602264389395714, -0.01265072263777256, 0.04937545955181122, -0.04390895739197731, -0.0061307852156460285, 0.051075492054224014, -0.003888930892571807, 0.02158363349735737, 0.006488746032118797, -0.07290012389421463, 0.010090628638863564, -0.013948515988886356, -0.0603557750582695, 0.013941160403192043, -0.006673178635537624, -0.00892755389213562, -0.021825896576046944, 0.01361401379108429, -0.0011953512439504266, 0.02795100398361683, 0.03852911293506622, -0.009567316621541977, 0.024305637925863266, 0.01945658028125763, 0.03328603878617287, -0.023751139640808105, 0.0027156316209584475, 0.02487165853381157, -0.03538317233324051, -0.00394798768684268, 0.06856068223714828, -0.024514030665159225, -0.062470123171806335, 0.04698379710316658, -0.04094644635915756, -0.061587657779455185, -0.006949744652956724, 0.03232292830944061, 0.056846849620342255, -0.008216173388063908, 0.0334194116294384, -0.041664738208055496, -0.07271220535039902, 0.04340474680066109, -0.008185573853552341, 0.021669242531061172, 0.015454608015716076, -0.004604635294526815, 0.003151119453832507, -0.03955591470003128, 0.010056637227535248, 0.033062711358070374, 0.030535895377397537, 0.020524734631180763, -0.00928656104952097, 0.003790410002693534, 0.008738841861486435, -0.05397085100412369, 0.03170010820031166, -0.033720266073942184, 0.032955389469861984, -0.017195913940668106, 0.01836884580552578, -0.01975623518228531, 0.02056625857949257, 0.01840445213019848, 0.009211065247654915, 0.00833829864859581, 0.023487746715545654, -0.011153257451951504, -0.04390020668506622, -0.026507079601287842, -0.029406432062387466, 0.02964693307876587, -0.04240395128726959, 0.04396296292543411, 0.039031676948070526, -0.029895106330513954, 0.007390867918729782, -0.007535963319242001, -0.08725600689649582, 0.07076285779476166, -0.006656935438513756, -0.009639491327106953, 0.05545990914106369, -0.010548699647188187, 0.003536639967933297, 0.027136465534567833, 0.014798711985349655, 0.012908809818327427, -0.05303717032074928, 0.021913837641477585, 0.0535651259124279, 0.03763945773243904, -0.021142570301890373, -0.05634380877017975, -0.0639200210571289, 0.023319566622376442, 0.05311369150876999, -0.0026201228611171246, 0.013018419966101646, -0.04556404799222946, 0.04605453461408615, -0.09398071467876434, 0.03895261511206627, 0.014577362686395645, -0.01751616969704628, -0.00936712883412838, 0.047071002423763275, 0.05723924562335014, -0.0687081515789032, -0.02950277365744114, 0.00146284990478307, -0.04713624715805054, 0.004694907460361719, -0.014387805014848709, -0.049013156443834305, -0.0077748047187924385, 0.029078472405672073, 0.007237331476062536, -0.021764256060123444, -0.018120907247066498, -0.02661321684718132, -0.022798428311944008, 0.05407700315117836, -0.010113800875842571, 0.011916693300008774, -0.041443951427936554, -0.003532636445015669, 0.05189523100852966, -0.02749878354370594, 0.035888854414224625, -0.029292652383446693, -0.09514547884464264, -0.0006742067052982748, -0.06329204142093658, -0.016043657436966896, 0.041726935654878616, 0.05526081100106239, -0.014231887646019459, -0.0004340480372775346, 0.057499900460243225, 0.06507908552885056, -0.027185361832380295, 0.06496207416057587, -0.05620934069156647, -0.08046986162662506, -0.00968718808144331, -0.05466269329190254, 0.01663827896118164, 0.03177450969815254, -0.0070681264623999596, 0.04860135167837143, 0.034812528640031815, -0.03314465284347534, -0.017508607357740402, -0.00708378478884697, 0.0020004280377179384, -0.03647901862859726, 0.026255102828145027, 0.019431617110967636, 0.010400190949440002, 0.0532541386783123, 0.00892995111644268, -0.04745645448565483, 0.05511566996574402, -0.02060079574584961, -0.06457743048667908, 0.04392778128385544, -0.002705478109419346, -0.034542281180620193, -0.015265108086168766, 0.030979501083493233, 0.03946783021092415, 0.03725571557879448, 0.0214719008654356, 0.02400311268866062, -0.028510235249996185, -0.0651727169752121, -0.03530643880367279, 0.017793620005249977, -0.025458823889493942, 0.0033892791252583265, -0.006212352775037289, -0.04495871439576149, -0.02170325629413128, -0.0825958177447319, 0.011774915270507336, 0.00915802177041769, -0.01330745592713356, -0.009261483326554298, 0.06500144302845001, 0.03464599698781967, -0.01883549802005291, 0.0022402636241167784, 0.016468126326799393, -0.018257975578308105, 0.04397719353437424, -0.0006919344887137413, -0.021251771599054337, 0.01737300492823124, 0.03231211379170418, -0.03085988201200962, 0.017604395747184753, 0.05236155912280083, 0.02973358705639839, -0.003136960556730628, -0.05475543439388275, -0.026123905554413795, -0.0026881673838943243, 0.04135356843471527, -0.023691801354289055, -0.029053548350930214, 0.07639811933040619, 0.0015498193679377437, 0.03856228291988373, -0.04021619260311127, -0.025859275832772255, -0.031327422708272934, 0.016916893422603607, 0.052593894302845, -0.02917761541903019, 0.0001924163952935487, 0.01842781901359558, -0.03646725043654442, -0.04015790671110153, -0.04111367091536522, -0.030786752700805664, -0.059669360518455505, 0.02045770175755024, -0.017016831785440445, 0.008162625133991241, -0.061525702476501465, 0.020620305091142654, -0.08326416462659836, 0.07576941698789597, 0.01445162482559681, -0.03153858333826065, -0.0109230512753129, 0.00619894452393055, 0.051630835980176926, 0.031458448618650436, 0.04465709254145622, -0.03412557765841484, -0.006509058177471161, -0.04394196718931198, 0.035044170916080475, -0.020788324996829033, -0.0013315541436895728, 0.008882761001586914, -0.05991123989224434, -0.0011463366681709886, 0.04265560209751129, -0.04680550843477249, -0.0718793049454689, 0.027309542521834373, -0.013135404326021671, 0.04170200228691101, -0.013200446963310242, -0.014494286850094795, -0.016694387421011925, -0.024805957451462746, -0.001716439495794475, -0.04459946230053902, 0.03780369088053703, -0.07026179879903793, 0.0028929568361490965, 0.03583519905805588, 0.01933034136891365, 0.026133721694350243, 0.0027590617537498474, 0.0032590841874480247, 0.04349350556731224, -0.03064444474875927, -0.026784468442201614, 0.05448948219418526, 0.030288012698292732, -0.031593821942806244, 0.04445961117744446, -0.06101158261299133, 0.018178513273596764, 0.021371589973568916, -0.0927242785692215, 0.03146513178944588, 0.035338543355464935, -0.0037675942294299603, 0.0354275144636631, -0.03648579120635986, -0.01181391254067421, -0.01956576481461525, 0.02660626545548439, -0.0027318482752889395, -0.0344071090221405, -0.03641422465443611, 0.016809940338134766, 0.024746041744947433, 0.020833123475313187, -0.011999037116765976, 0.02618653140962124, 0.00802120566368103, 0.022058384492993355, 0.006374327000230551, -0.0038852316793054342, -0.10507797449827194, 0.04973134770989418, 0.07684985548257828, -0.02829657308757305, 0.017955830320715904, 0.02722763642668724, 0.01585077866911888, -0.022839495912194252, 0.007071876898407936, 0.032434288412332535, 0.02236059308052063, 0.05029560253024101, -0.0824085995554924, 0.028394797816872597, 0.0030116632115095854, -0.03165207803249359, -0.054116085171699524, -0.04726770892739296, -0.03130471333861351, 0.02742888405919075, 0.00018658699991647154, 0.005316345952451229, 0.06050409749150276, -0.03868955746293068, 0.030507588759064674, 0.019110634922981262, -0.009265417233109474, 0.013580985367298126, -0.08748529851436615, -0.0027169575914740562, 0.020575447008013725, -0.01946873962879181, 0.0411715991795063, 0.05553062632679939, 0.005211265757679939, -0.011731667444109917, -0.003165740054100752, 0.011238466016948223, 0.01275538932532072, 0.004105285741388798, -0.036384087055921555, -0.014359946362674236, -0.0241057351231575, -0.009810528717935085, -0.04815927892923355, 0.05039120838046074, -0.001799702295102179, -0.028900744393467903, -0.045917198061943054, 0.009567752480506897, 0.002806160831823945, -0.04284438118338585, 0.018774796277284622, 0.017996201291680336, 0.026606326922774315, -0.0030241587664932013, 0.05128498375415802, 0.01513220276683569, 0.021536465734243393, 0.013048090040683746, -0.02952992171049118, 0.06405819952487946, -0.005368565209209919, -0.0011643341276794672, 0.004100834019482136, -0.004673391580581665, -0.028148779645562172, 0.027035994455218315, 0.015774577856063843, -0.0234430693089962, -0.02301952801644802, -0.02713661640882492, 0.008835607208311558, -0.03304002434015274, -0.01572209969162941, -0.03612641245126724, -0.04494976997375488, 0.03038376197218895, -0.030999774113297462, -0.006291708908975124, -0.07203663140535355, -0.015886232256889343, 0.008742684498429298, 0.011330402456223965, -0.004463983699679375, -0.07165754586458206, 0.051947563886642456, -0.018451474606990814, 0.010541255585849285, -0.014305107295513153, -0.04513304680585861, 0.00840210821479559, -0.059379156678915024, 0.03392569348216057, -0.029148997738957405, -0.0034955162554979324, -0.008782175369560719, 0.021721353754401207, -0.049575574696063995, 0.021059095859527588, -0.009981782175600529, -0.01744190603494644, 0.04741887375712395, 0.011059215292334557, -0.0006294749910011888, -0.007577236276119947, -0.02556425705552101, 0.043937306851148605, -0.01983140967786312, -0.001075733220204711, -0.02229193039238453, 0.03200305253267288, 0.05525045469403267, -0.05399564653635025, 0.02079666033387184, 0.041915059089660645, -0.00794288981705904, -0.009603396989405155, -0.04322253167629242, -0.03204771876335144, 0.013420764356851578, 0.0726439505815506, 0.008308762684464455, -0.05687222257256508, -0.014106303453445435, -0.053180992603302, -0.07071962207555771, 0.01872522570192814, -0.011065241880714893, 0.00977545976638794, 0.010464182123541832, 0.006359740160405636 ]
<p>Tensor equations are supposed to stay invariant in <em>form</em> wrt coordinate transformations where the metric is preserved. It is important to take note of the fact that invariance in form of the tensor equations is consistent with the fact that the individual components of the tensor may change on passing from one frame to another.[Incidentally,Preservation of the metric implies preservation of norm, angles etc.]</p> <p>But in General Relativity the tensor equations (examples: the geodesic equation, Maxwell's equations in covariant form) are considered to be invariant in form when we pass from one manifold to another. The metric is not preserved in such situations. Preservation of the value of the line element is consistent with the fact that $g_{\mu\nu}$ may be considered as a covariant tensor of second rank:</p> <p>$ds&#39;^2=ds^2$</p> <p>${=&gt;}g&#39;_{\mu\nu}dx&#39;^{\mu}dx&#39;^{\nu}=g_{\alpha\beta}dx^{\alpha}dx^{\beta}$</p> <p>${=&gt;}g&#39;_{\mu\nu}=g_{\alpha\beta}\frac{dx^{\alpha}}{dx&#39;^{\mu}}\frac{dx^{\beta}}{dx&#39;^{\nu}}$ </p> <p>Rigorous Calculations:</p> <p>$ds&#39;^2=g&#39;_{\mu\nu}dx&#39;^\alpha dx&#39;^\beta$</p> <p>$=g&#39;_{\mu\nu}\frac{\partial x&#39;^\mu}{\partial x^\alpha}{d x^\alpha}\frac{\partial x&#39;^\nu}{\partial x^\beta}{d x^\beta}$</p> <p>$=g&#39;_{\mu\nu}\frac{\partial x&#39;^\mu}{\partial x^\alpha}\frac{\partial x&#39;^\nu}{\partial x^\beta}{d x^\alpha}{d x^\beta}$</p> <p>$=&gt;g_{\alpha\beta}=\frac{\partial x&#39;^\mu}{\partial x^\alpha}\frac{\partial x&#39;^\nu}{\partial x^\beta}g&#39;_{\mu\nu}$</p> <p>Therefore $g_{\mu\nu}$ is a covariant tensor of rank two.</p> <p>But in the above proof we have assumed the value of $ds^2$ as invariant wrt to our transformation.This not true when different types of manifolds are in consideration.</p> <p>Non-conservation of the value of $ds^2$ will result in dismissing $g_{\mu\nu}$ as a second rank tensor of covariant type. This will be the situation if we pass from one manifold to another.*It is important to emphasize the fact that the problem will remain even if when we pass from an arbitrary manifold to flat spacetime in particular to the local inertial frame.*Differential considerations are not improving matters as indicated in the above calculation. The very concept of a tensor gets upset by considering different/distinct manifold. </p> <p>What is the mathematical foundation for the invariance of form of the tensor equations in such applications where we consider different/distinct manifolds?</p>
g1672
[ 0.005493897944688797, -0.04230163246393204, -0.006810203660279512, -0.04082230105996132, 0.05538523942232132, 0.036258816719055176, 0.09233801066875458, 0.0004561993118841201, -0.0747150406241417, -0.006464890204370022, 0.021889636293053627, 0.016706807538866997, 0.0072812242433428764, -0.05342390388250351, 0.048319604247808456, -0.002049776026979089, 0.09119287878274918, -0.04681725054979324, 0.04982343688607216, 0.015696031972765923, 0.004943197127431631, 0.06294601410627365, 0.03992664813995361, 0.00029405622626654804, -0.00470937043428421, 0.004259418696165085, 0.09174232184886932, 0.01645537093281746, -0.02930796891450882, -0.03689396753907204, 0.07864350825548172, -0.0022430543322116137, 0.07593447715044022, -0.027618471533060074, 0.019967123866081238, -0.04871073365211487, 0.008695363998413086, 0.009973161853849888, 0.07082372158765793, -0.01227897871285677, 0.06314926594495773, -0.01484663039445877, 0.00547852274030447, 0.01718916930258274, 0.05631667748093605, 0.0018266403349116445, -0.04923694208264351, 0.009033272042870522, 0.001827141735702753, -0.00736274104565382, -0.0005131465150043368, 0.03896624222397804, 0.031485624611377716, -0.010885990224778652, -0.050196871161460876, -0.03087460622191429, 0.007373268716037273, -0.009662955068051815, 0.014755187556147575, -0.008855273947119713, -0.007242135237902403, -0.032349467277526855, 0.017481837421655655, -0.019583875313401222, 0.006440041121095419, -0.05788296088576317, -0.0830933004617691, -0.03923717513680458, 0.05248098820447922, 0.017180945724248886, 0.020525159314274788, 0.01650429703295231, 0.06650158017873764, 0.03898116946220398, 0.04605640470981598, -0.0073628812097013, 0.019706517457962036, -0.004949610214680433, -0.00026045984122902155, 0.0166990477591753, -0.014900156296789646, 0.06146050617098808, 0.03562166541814804, 0.060894664376974106, 0.08145730197429657, 0.00781335961073637, 0.05584331601858139, 0.03581617772579193, -0.0670415386557579, 0.061647120863199234, 0.03811962530016899, 0.015035497024655342, 0.015747329220175743, 0.028371168300509453, 0.0232983585447073, 0.00041617086390033364, -0.02051389589905739, 0.017728829756379128, 0.00922909751534462, -0.01296481303870678, -0.03752924129366875, 0.03350122645497322, -0.0066754985600709915, 0.00962040014564991, 0.07924965769052505, 0.008839531801640987, 0.02794330194592476, 0.06272593140602112, 0.004328953102231026, -0.03513513505458832, -0.028739571571350098, -0.0025524937082082033, 0.032334551215171814, 0.02033068612217903, -0.0567745678126812, -0.05279043689370155, 0.031001904979348183, -0.03931289166212082, 0.0776694044470787, -0.0036415238864719868, 0.0005383698735386133, -0.008695644326508045, -0.0751134529709816, 0.06930634379386902, 0.007802619133144617, -0.011987595818936825, -0.014490814879536629, -0.007267252076417208, 0.09272217750549316, -0.012357943691313267, -0.012963849119842052, 0.004673026967793703, 0.01858465000987053, 0.004508894868195057, -0.012728815898299217, -0.033192045986652374, 0.013909314759075642, -0.02144545130431652, 0.011961689218878746, -0.00943206436932087, -0.030689813196659088, 0.022319095209240913, 0.031236164271831512, -0.024732591584324837, 0.00298117334023118, 0.022807147353887558, 0.012283079326152802, -0.04807928949594498, 0.053026556968688965, 0.021450815722346306, 0.016004960983991623, 0.03298483043909073, -0.000607814290560782, 0.005573180038481951, 0.06233258917927742, -0.04019852727651596, -0.010379279963672161, -0.04381725192070007, 0.007623991463333368, -0.011760324239730835, 0.10378190129995346, -0.012017671950161457, 0.026202108711004257, 0.012122253887355328, 0.02103436179459095, -0.009146316908299923, -0.027518032118678093, -0.03289023041725159, -0.0018100586021319032, -0.06193200498819351, -0.04253868758678436, 0.04898403212428093, 0.06661482155323029, -0.0031692739576101303, -0.015124477446079254, 0.0014973890502005816, -0.0105844521895051, -0.009930606000125408, -0.008545280434191227, 0.0016718559199944139, -0.02876351773738861, -0.03371921926736832, -0.013065909035503864, -0.10814758390188217, 0.010189197957515717, 0.019905833527445793, -0.04134063422679901, 0.019212743267416954, -0.05653078854084015, 0.018809163942933083, 0.015811862424016, 0.010229198262095451, -0.004327835980802774, 0.08132580667734146, 0.03280036896467209, 0.05747832730412483, 0.02155107446014881, 0.009516735561192036, -0.044745493680238724, 0.1349494606256485, -0.04123502969741821, 0.03300198167562485, -0.006415890529751778, -0.010559014976024628, -0.04746883362531662, -0.03239206597208977, -0.042896367609500885, 0.019838741049170494, 0.030649125576019287, -0.06926178932189941, 0.03864235430955887, -0.037463486194610596, 0.004327527713030577, -0.1007332056760788, -0.02019589953124523, 0.0027867774479091167, 0.038387466222047806, 0.001675337553024292, -0.08143465220928192, 0.012106966227293015, -0.008569389581680298, 0.0018537839641794562, 0.035987649112939835, 0.02691369690001011, -0.05833965539932251, -0.023718945682048798, -0.030619977042078972, -0.019264621660113335, 0.01964331977069378, -0.007736746221780777, 0.03097892552614212, 0.05664154142141342, -0.025776803493499756, -0.001171155832707882, 0.009434754960238934, 0.03322416916489601, -0.04604775831103325, -0.008151469752192497, 0.06773973256349564, 0.03023463673889637, 0.035536035895347595, 0.007706206291913986, 0.010852632112801075, -0.019364342093467712, 0.004651114344596863, 0.01649552211165428, 0.02220742218196392, -0.015152094885706902, 0.057441405951976776, 0.04217517003417015, -0.012700017541646957, -0.058843936771154404, -0.0030781293753534555, -0.053552962839603424, 0.03570132330060005, 0.012985698878765106, 0.017660681158304214, 0.021892141550779343, -0.03926512971520424, -0.024266233667731285, -0.006471138447523117, -0.032502345740795135, -0.03141512721776962, 0.021001212298870087, -0.03128493204712868, 0.04713403433561325, 0.04946564510464668, 0.035883061587810516, 0.017473295331001282, -0.0190315879881382, -0.01356365717947483, 0.030069664120674133, -0.042554739862680435, 0.04445544630289078, -0.040746014565229416, -0.00021517065761145204, -0.07281516492366791, -0.026607008650898933, -0.03727545961737633, 0.05230589956045151, -0.06772080063819885, -0.02487095817923546, -0.03512617573142052, -0.012051843106746674, 0.05098187178373337, -0.0431884303689003, -0.01158544048666954, 0.023900017142295837, 0.02372099459171295, 0.05225687101483345, -0.009443624876439571, 0.07141312956809998, 0.03900846093893051, -0.05061217024922371, -0.006403041537851095, -0.04161086305975914, -0.05947735905647278, -0.044942401349544525, -0.07950856536626816, 0.009184853173792362, 0.041223447769880295, -0.012197338975965977, 0.02591307833790779, -0.039554186165332794, -0.005305618979036808, -0.022631477564573288, -0.04722437262535095, -0.04755287244915962, 0.006926245521754026, 0.006990919355303049, 0.0016481635393574834, 0.02416960708796978, -0.05502217262983322, -0.039614200592041016, -0.005211761221289635, -0.048226822167634964, 0.04276048392057419, -0.04909806326031685, -0.027087250724434853, 0.030723800882697105, -0.024106647819280624, 0.022568047046661377, 0.02397748827934265, -0.017948586493730545, -0.012831308878958225, 0.01722661219537258, -0.002515052678063512, 0.027063680812716484, -0.0025984204839915037, 0.02073562890291214, -0.04254752770066261, -0.021932540461421013, -0.024585384875535965, 0.006491418462246656, -0.0029136529192328453, 0.0026009397115558386, -0.0633484497666359, -0.03872866556048393, 0.05004158988595009, -0.03605896234512329, 0.008808434940874577, -0.050231873989105225, -0.05892607569694519, 0.013932861387729645, -0.018971635028719902, -0.017300637438893318, 0.04421189799904823, -0.02905324287712574, -0.005839180666953325, -0.023195918649435043, 0.005407514050602913, -0.04761656001210213, 0.048557478934526443, -0.030157851055264473, -0.05392707139253616, 0.009811938740313053, 0.045725151896476746, 0.038161035627126694, -0.0280251894146204, 0.016348637640476227, 0.026402898132801056, -0.036163296550512314, -0.02462768740952015, 0.032622963190078735, -0.0045439996756613255, 0.005356220994144678, 0.02124120481312275, 0.00825245026499033, -0.0021556271240115166, 0.05550442636013031, 0.04177931323647499, 0.030613157898187637, -0.03598521649837494, -0.015924187377095222, -0.030109750106930733, -0.04141295328736305, 0.04504029080271721, -0.015782136470079422, 0.010152213275432587, 0.023985927924513817, -0.004401465877890587, -0.026557516306638718, 0.017867043614387512, -0.028201639652252197, 0.005760935600847006, -0.06093481555581093, 0.010504011064767838, -0.03664486110210419, 0.05996192619204521, -0.021891359239816666, -0.016741370782256126, 0.02954944409430027, -0.005827946588397026, -0.04776965454220772, 0.011108613573014736, 0.011883512139320374, 0.004357113968580961, 0.0519455187022686, -0.011159008368849754, -0.010698108933866024, -0.03297469764947891, -0.022772304713726044, -0.031597454100847244, -0.011103572323918343, -0.01604808121919632, -0.015140124596655369, -0.02208934724330902, -0.030344417318701744, 0.002243869472295046, 0.03488870710134506, 0.020472029224038124, -0.02224617823958397, -0.006131266243755817, -0.05601966008543968, 0.08586855232715607, -0.03639237582683563, -0.05858314409852028, -0.05357758328318596, -0.02439495548605919, -0.02211635373532772, 0.016831103712320328, 0.05650484561920166, 0.03661768510937691, -0.019682874903082848, 0.04060005396604538, 0.019968517124652863, 0.05548814684152603, 0.004405457992106676, -0.024061664938926697, 0.04005352407693863, 0.015243160538375378, -0.022108502686023712, -0.003354548942297697, -0.028589455410838127, -0.02104472555220127, 0.021434849128127098, -0.03522343561053276, 0.02713286131620407, -0.02473689801990986, 0.0004695576208177954, 0.08537980169057846, 0.004684665706008673, 0.06796567142009735, -0.05364635959267616, -0.057205699384212494, 0.018726123496890068, 0.008270390331745148, 0.02733685076236725, -0.017118122428655624, -0.016928749158978462, -0.04415116459131241, -0.00027113317628391087, 0.03523552045226097, -0.04569704830646515, -0.052007045596838, -0.0020471808966249228, -0.01899772509932518, -0.021625138819217682, 0.0014619681751355529, 0.04399793595075607, -0.01774188131093979, 0.021827198565006256, 0.013618049211800098, 0.03587740287184715, 0.012286529876291752, -0.008994913659989834, -0.07199855893850327, 0.05363942310214043, -0.023755105212330818, -0.04510156437754631, -0.002247963333502412, 0.0011188036296516657, -0.01702108606696129, -0.04004313051700592, 0.0651995912194252, 0.04957406222820282, -0.02095600590109825, 0.02695431187748909, 0.027725402265787125, -0.05102107673883438, -0.0503728985786438, 0.02742066979408264, 0.035024214535951614, 0.017383456230163574, 0.03247477114200592, 0.018721846863627434, -0.009085562080144882, -0.006721902638673782, -0.005920026451349258, -0.024666601791977882, -0.019055552780628204, 0.01273376401513815, 0.059539951384067535, 0.014441581442952156, 0.058031968772411346, 0.027397817000746727, -0.02368599735200405, 0.0028246301226317883, 0.00464699836447835, -0.057930465787649155, -0.02607721835374832, -0.011557257734239101, 0.0013453230494633317, -0.04725881665945053, 0.005767283029854298, 0.01146741397678852, 0.015764016658067703, 0.04565964639186859, -0.02191668562591076, 0.06404107064008713, 0.012146786786615849, -0.000028058906536898576, -0.026865040883421898, 0.017955314368009567, 0.0034106585662811995, -0.00046781578566879034, 0.006484691984951496, -0.0036591116804629564, 0.013454319909214973, -0.06895419955253601, -0.00476163811981678, -0.008764870464801788, 0.037058208137750626, -0.018717549741268158, -0.006052909418940544, 0.11570758372545242, -0.021637851372361183, -0.06736412644386292, 0.004392403177917004, 0.03390636667609215, 0.018794000148773193, -0.0444127693772316, -0.028962042182683945, -0.016514107584953308, -0.003095455002039671, -0.03684719279408455, -0.035041749477386475, -0.03195923566818237, 0.04210008308291435, 0.02194393426179886, -0.047127049416303635, 0.000784671981818974, 0.006879306398332119, -0.0009207366383634508, 0.005622587166726589, -0.004802792798727751, -0.017731092870235443, 0.000059561214584391564, -0.01445769239217043, -0.0437159426510334, -0.05307597666978836, -0.030670352280139923, -0.030339431017637253, 0.0009174185106530786, 0.008768545463681221, -0.05123212933540344, -0.016450289636850357, -0.05186580494046211, 0.01641741767525673, 0.020653506740927696, 0.031526532024145126, 0.044864729046821594, 0.019574284553527832, 0.03215024247765541, -0.007792703341692686, -0.0462992899119854, 0.04737719148397446, -0.010394354350864887, 0.08237908035516739, 0.015151936560869217, -0.013868818990886211, 0.01986864022910595, -0.06265373528003693, 0.027754133567214012, -0.006709281820803881, -0.05351002514362335, -0.03254035487771034, -0.02448379434645176, 0.0017164291348308325, 0.004764920566231012, -0.020666491240262985, 0.02870786190032959, 0.06148155778646469, -0.09839154779911041, -0.0696476548910141, -0.007258971221745014, -0.03675901144742966, -0.016825085505843163, 0.036588188260793686, 0.029020076617598534, 0.0313321016728878, 0.01668822392821312, -0.05290692672133446, 0.007740644738078117, -0.015111328102648258, -0.03414738550782204, 0.016529278829693794, 0.03850126639008522, -0.013211854733526707, 0.029964249581098557, -0.00357461953535676, 0.009891312569379807, 0.06269305944442749, -0.00043491245014593005, 0.06854870915412903, -0.03019578382372856, -0.08471526205539703, -0.027187945321202278, 0.023274825885891914, 0.021351996809244156, 0.039878908544778824, 0.035177771002054214, -0.016878142952919006, 0.029828786849975586, 0.017529942095279694, 0.019661657512187958, -0.011416121385991573, 0.02791764587163925, 0.009271257556974888, -0.013883668929338455, 0.02356768399477005, -0.03157826140522957, 0.04733533784747124, 0.03811696916818619, 0.009760287590324879, 0.04151230305433273, -0.00941603071987629, 0.02346162311732769, -0.03194503113627434, 0.02449520118534565, -0.07009735703468323, -0.04545983299612999, -0.058396678417921066, 0.0057050748728215694, -0.0010232003405690193, -0.00021723560348618776, -0.02917131781578064, 0.003415303537622094, 0.02991316467523575, 0.04810049384832382, -0.01956825517117977, 0.003159470856189728, 0.037345290184020996, -0.017420398071408272, -0.012448241002857685, 0.05529637262225151, 0.026356110349297523, -0.024263696745038033, -0.10302286595106125, 0.04350448399782181, 0.0297390166670084, 0.04459936171770096, -0.022727426141500473, 0.010147268883883953, -0.023230280727148056, 0.007153745740652084, -0.05282791331410408, 0.013821575790643692, 0.02555830404162407, -0.024179350584745407, 0.019055837765336037, 0.008978328667581081, 0.023613033816218376, 0.03237259015440941, -0.015771275386214256, -0.001771278795786202, 0.03609244525432587, -0.09317686408758163, 0.053530652076005936, 0.03743031993508339, -0.007020333781838417, 0.013062010519206524, 0.051179226487874985, 0.001835104078054428, 0.04069293290376663, 0.008404645137488842, -0.060991931706666946, -0.027120977640151978, 0.030051574110984802, 0.04607011377811432, -0.08160737156867981, 0.028604215011000633, 0.02500665932893753, 0.010745941661298275, -0.022480551153421402, -0.004304778296500444, 0.06745270639657974, -0.008845233358442783, -0.04479176178574562, -0.031922318041324615, -0.02089865319430828, 0.07852763682603836, 0.0061904857866466045, 0.015178875997662544, -0.0553273931145668, -0.02867584303021431, 0.02153625711798668, 0.042522281408309937, -0.013339742086827755, -0.006808540318161249, 0.004815405234694481, -0.042812079191207886, -0.06704306602478027, -0.016453944146633148, 0.029052702710032463, -0.006339323706924915, -0.02783573605120182, -0.04766269400715828, -0.020670704543590546, -0.002840363187715411, 0.05959153547883034, -0.0041587441228330135, 0.045088909566402435, 0.03171848878264427, 0.022157900035381317, 0.0009823907166719437, -0.04267856478691101, -0.03870699554681778, 0.0015952560352161527, -0.027110133320093155, -0.036493513733148575, -0.014300992712378502, 0.0045438725501298904, -0.04096702113747597, 0.000517909589689225, -0.017807507887482643, 0.0103371050208807, -0.02418588101863861, 0.03504471853375435, -0.0052145072259008884, -0.057061128318309784, -0.021204624325037003, -0.03605378419160843, 0.03796361759305, 0.06308335810899734, 0.05526313930749893, 0.04166516289114952, -0.03959919139742851, -0.054564982652664185, -0.034325290471315384, 0.08087030798196793, -0.061722274869680405, -0.034117795526981354, 0.0026454052422195673, -0.04630224034190178, 0.01760275289416313, 0.006936666090041399, 0.0049816919490695, -0.07908356189727783, -0.054881155490875244, 0.0052822609432041645, 0.007505098823457956, -0.01715272292494774, 0.04113414138555527, 0.027131911367177963, -0.051602333784103394, 0.008325855247676373, 0.00948923546820879, 0.0190786961466074, 0.026339780539274216, -0.007445457391440868, -0.01251301635056734, -0.03785077482461929, 0.0006078531150706112, -0.014090344309806824, -0.01848583109676838, -0.023040149360895157, 0.013952650129795074 ]
<p>My general premise is that I want to investigate the transformations between two distinct sets of vertices on n-dimensional manifolds and then find applications to theoretical physics by:</p> <ul> <li><p>Minimalizing the change in the fundamental shape of the vertices (I want a convex polytope to stay a convex polytope).</p></li> <li><p>Describing the dynamics of the transformation. (Possible applications to theoretical physics)</p></li> <li><p>Finding constraint conditions on what can and cannot occur when the space in which the transformation is occurring is not "regular". This includes not-everywhere-differentiable manifolds, singularities, and other pathological cases.</p></li> </ul> <p>Well, what an ambitious project. But in any case I have made some progress for the n-dimensional case with n-vertices where the space is "regular" and I haven't introduced advanced mathematics yet. I'm mostly playing around in configuration space for vertices in euclidean space or something similar.</p> <p>I have defined a functional in configuration space that gives the length of all possible paths in configuration space between two distinct sets of vertices in $\mathbb{R^n}$ as follows:</p> <p>$$T = \int\limits_{\lambda_{1}}^{\lambda_{2}} \sqrt{\sum_{I=1}^{n} \sum_{i=1}^{d} \left(\frac{d}{d\lambda}\left(\sum_{j=1}^{d} s(\lambda)R_{j}^{i}(\lambda)(q_{I}^{j}(\lambda) + a^{j}(\lambda))\right)\right)^2} d\lambda$$</p> <p>Where $\lambda_{1}$ and $\lambda_{2}$ correspond to the start-point and end-point of the transformation. The members of the gauge group are $s$ (dilatation), $R$ (rotation), and $a$ (translation). $q_{I}^{j}$ corresponds to a point in configuration space representing $I$ vertices and it lives in $j$ dimensions. ($i$ is also a dimension index)</p> <p>You can think of the equation as finding the straight line between two points (in configuration space) given all of the varied paths when you solve for constraint conditions in the Euler-Lagrange equation (recall): $$\frac{\partial{f}}{\partial{x}} - \frac{d}{d \lambda} \left(\frac{\partial{f}}{\partial{\dot{x}}}\right) = 0$$ This is represented in the figure below when the space has no curvature.</p> <p><img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/JFxCH.png" alt="Transformative Norm Equation Figure"></p> <p>Hopefully, you have a general idea about what I'm talking about, this is at about page 5 in the paper where this is introduced, there is a lot of background that I'm not going to discuss. I've constructed an explicit example with tetrahedra where a tetrahedron is approximated to another tetrahedron in a minimalized manner. Here's a figure I made: <img src="http://i.stack.imgur.com/xvn4u.png" alt="Tetrahedral Approximation"> that may help you understand what I'm trying to work with... in any case I'll ask my questions now.</p> <p>-</p> <p><em>[Optional for the intrigued reader]</em>:</p> <p>How can I begin to generalize this geodesic equation so that it can comment on spaces with different metrics, or irregular behaviour? As an example of what I am trying to reach for, I would be interested in seeing how a set of vertices could geodesically traverse a singularity in a smooth 2-manifold, and if I could define a general functional for any behaviour on any manifold (I would attempt to restrict it to 2-dimensions to start) eventually. There are two main types of singularities I would be interested in investigating, the first would be the "black hole type" in which a diffeomorphism in the manifold causes "a hole at the bottom". This means that there would be an exponential increase in curvature around the vicinity of the singularity, and I want to find out how a set of vertices deals with those imposed conditions. The other would be for a 2-manifold with no curvature and I know that for a particular configuration of vertices, with the geodesic (based on the equation above) lying along a certain line. If I create a hole (simply remove a point in the same way you can create a hole in a single-variable piecewise defined real function), what happens to the geodesic? How can I encode this information, so it either pushes right through the hole somehow, or defines a new path around it?</p> <p>-</p> <p><strong>Main Question:</strong> For a functional (assuming I could derive one) that gives the path from a distinct set of vertices to another in an n-dimensional smooth manifold with shape preserving characteristics. When a singularity is introduced into the manifold, will the geodesic equation:</p> <ul> <li><p>Somehow push through the singularity/ignore it is present.</p></li> <li><p>Define an alternate path around the singularity (this is what I hope, so I can investigate further with applications to black hole dynamics)</p></li> <li><p>Become undefined and nothing useful results</p></li> </ul>
g1673
[ 0.03744914382696152, 0.023921234533190727, 0.004876586142927408, 0.00464088236913085, -0.004144339822232723, -0.07481600344181061, 0.03791971877217293, 0.030810346826910973, -0.024188442155718803, -0.01554727740585804, 0.05094210430979729, -0.021117500960826874, 0.06625372916460037, -0.03022102639079094, -0.017904480919241905, -0.023473240435123444, 0.022469190880656242, 0.002426298800855875, -0.018547605723142624, 0.004179587587714195, 0.038995299488306046, 0.014519660733640194, 0.11201096326112747, -0.03895624354481697, 0.003412183141335845, -0.04707074910402298, 0.037559233605861664, 0.018235355615615845, -0.04802732169628143, -0.001966610085219145, 0.059787649661302567, -0.026526479050517082, 0.0545550137758255, 0.03677334636449814, -0.013846206478774548, 0.04710334911942482, 0.02728603035211563, -0.043677009642124176, -0.0029775679577142, 0.0313836969435215, -0.0004636307421606034, -0.015818176791071892, 0.0293592419475317, 0.03784998506307602, -0.024075159803032875, 0.008318288251757622, 0.029852328822016716, -0.01899106241762638, 0.04303208738565445, 0.01997719332575798, 0.021732043474912643, 0.05271965265274048, 0.040403466671705246, -0.018256939947605133, -0.016128208488225937, 0.03291895613074303, 0.02943054959177971, 0.04432119056582451, 0.04280412569642067, 0.013042544946074486, -0.08363786339759827, 0.00395847437903285, -0.012321867980062962, 0.014855243265628815, -0.004475162364542484, -0.027677102014422417, -0.035304680466651917, -0.030539032071828842, -0.0018159447936341166, -0.03791160136461258, -0.0075311800464987755, -0.0008171824738383293, 0.100527822971344, -0.0029694708064198494, -0.004660957958549261, 0.0008863143157213926, 0.05097305774688721, -0.023625848814845085, -0.04622703418135643, -0.06713814288377762, -0.07080620527267456, 0.023975398391485214, 0.013349323533475399, -0.0650971457362175, 0.05048969015479088, -0.005124206189066172, 0.03240020573139191, -0.011431798338890076, -0.03724180907011032, 0.03512360900640488, 0.028326358646154404, 0.06711609661579132, 0.038263313472270966, -0.014971173368394375, -0.03356338292360306, 0.0002589898940641433, 0.020106501877307892, 0.02343020774424076, 0.029051827266812325, 0.04072941467165947, -0.013495285995304585, 0.025633592158555984, -0.02397114410996437, 0.007778233848512173, 0.008089951239526272, 0.009268405847251415, -0.0015718459617346525, 0.035194847732782364, 0.044830672442913055, -0.03949127718806267, -0.01573665253818035, 0.012952730059623718, -0.0064616454765200615, 0.010367387905716896, -0.039754778146743774, -0.040834296494722366, 0.01784580573439598, 0.016737977042794228, -0.028422227129340172, 0.040583085268735886, 0.03185055032372475, 0.020279472693800926, -0.0014635034603998065, 0.059122614562511444, 0.021637078374624252, 0.04476281628012657, -0.037620291113853455, 0.022870227694511414, 0.03320174291729927, 0.04290218651294708, 0.008386357687413692, 0.03725648298859596, -0.027727710083127022, 0.022796442732214928, -0.05090221017599106, 0.01772746443748474, -0.007335940841585398, 0.03992816433310509, 0.044125545769929886, 0.03420596197247505, -0.0511416532099247, -0.06971609592437744, -0.059987589716911316, -0.007027551531791687, -0.010835093446075916, 0.0522836372256279, -0.01268101204186678, -0.04204867035150528, -0.02911359816789627, 0.01583082042634487, -0.006330396048724651, 0.06776735931634903, 0.016320398077368736, -0.019377684220671654, 0.007136930245906115, -0.0003596011083573103, 0.03544112667441368, -0.0006747478037141263, 0.035959988832473755, -0.06940288841724396, -0.004519832320511341, 0.02716873213648796, -0.022007394582033157, 0.041622474789619446, -0.020817745476961136, -0.049524493515491486, 0.00461473548784852, -0.013867242261767387, 0.010323973372578621, -0.06355860829353333, -0.040660254657268524, -0.031134380027651787, 0.028144143521785736, 0.10113870352506638, 0.002985904226079583, 0.04771055281162262, -0.03006742149591446, -0.03363727033138275, -0.03173116594552994, -0.04438898712396622, -0.02098948135972023, -0.016979873180389404, 0.027298184111714363, -0.04407523572444916, 0.03307105973362923, 0.03785528987646103, -0.023679934442043304, 0.02074483223259449, -0.07032214850187302, -0.01572694629430771, -0.028659624978899956, -0.016810571774840355, -0.022751547396183014, 0.005654097534716129, 0.05013471841812134, 0.02814488112926483, 0.061670564115047455, -0.06435485184192657, 0.04206621274352074, -0.011484319344162941, -0.00831932108849287, 0.019720153883099556, 0.012780318967998028, 0.014870824292302132, -0.021006500348448753, 0.021028049290180206, -0.0071969241835176945, -0.018144413828849792, -0.030982209369540215, 0.03199819102883339, 0.0546661838889122, -0.010176530107855797, -0.008820462971925735, -0.03247886151075363, -0.03573966398835182, -0.03302435949444771, -0.02434358559548855, -0.060582052916288376, 0.04488973319530487, 0.001255158567801118, 0.04730840027332306, -0.011123612523078918, -0.01061331294476986, 0.06030420586466789, -0.013070427812635899, -0.012546708807349205, -0.0048826877027750015, -0.048208970576524734, -0.02899107150733471, 0.018039824441075325, -0.06254424154758453, 0.02926914021372795, 0.03983231261372566, -0.04889952763915062, 0.012201419100165367, 0.02738633006811142, -0.03539780527353287, -0.08484223484992981, 0.02056656964123249, 0.013410917483270168, 0.06140141189098358, 0.01731570065021515, -0.04363839700818062, 0.011994078755378723, 0.02677207626402378, -0.03126267343759537, -0.0057819983921945095, -0.003065552795305848, -0.0010384984780102968, 0.03881021589040756, 0.0153537318110466, -0.046127744019031525, -0.03506934270262718, -0.02509983815252781, -0.022751040756702423, -0.043568190187215805, 0.03703352436423302, 0.05197230353951454, -0.005928760394454002, -0.0674673542380333, -0.011745263822376728, -0.014217846095561981, -0.05243932083249092, 0.09487974643707275, -0.04063279926776886, -0.04563460126519203, -0.009348747320473194, 0.021726591512560844, -0.05424461513757706, 0.03258540481328964, 0.027519136667251587, 0.02087632566690445, 0.04907998442649841, 0.00009375744411954656, -0.017527984455227852, -0.036305010318756104, -0.06180296465754509, 0.0042110164649784565, 0.015535344369709492, 0.0328664667904377, 0.000012648427400563378, -0.004941385705024004, -0.0909024104475975, -0.0068369521759450436, -0.017297420650720596, -0.021558282896876335, 0.012099917978048325, 0.0006905572954565287, -0.01849908009171486, 0.05221261829137802, -0.01621643826365471, 0.009158063679933548, 0.02212863229215145, 0.028235383331775665, 0.0035127715673297644, -0.020559702068567276, -0.067008838057518, -0.01098265778273344, -0.022164538502693176, -0.001841532182879746, -0.042584728449583054, -0.061485663056373596, -0.004166231490671635, 0.0625864565372467, -0.024293864145874977, -0.016000380739569664, -0.0305214561522007, -0.11017729341983795, 0.007032213266938925, 0.035313680768013, -0.0021627028472721577, -0.0076549542136490345, 0.009115147404372692, 0.0227355994284153, 0.03324034437537193, -0.01694420911371708, -0.0031147077679634094, 0.01901882514357567, -0.00559124955907464, -0.04490284249186516, 0.019442835822701454, -0.07356450706720352, 0.013332155533134937, -0.0050893137231469154, 0.08454322814941406, 0.01662343367934227, -0.005064449738711119, -0.028547251597046852, -0.01563143916428089, -0.02399839647114277, 0.027745652943849564, -0.03996015340089798, -0.016653217375278473, -0.07870956510305405, -0.002903015585616231, -0.06360315531492233, -0.048727963119745255, -0.004535127896815538, 0.07270897924900055, -0.017160844057798386, -0.03852641209959984, -0.03775976970791817, -0.021493135020136833, 0.015859460458159447, 0.016054460778832436, -0.03750535845756531, -0.03601192310452461, 0.00814697053283453, 0.055762987583875656, -0.03823215514421463, -0.003724260488525033, -0.05624118074774742, 0.052907925099134445, 0.0065692332573235035, 0.0233557540923357, -0.031982894986867905, 0.002963586710393429, -0.009790940210223198, 0.006758449599146843, 0.020899586379528046, -0.005763558205217123, -0.07221606373786926, -0.025970734655857086, 0.005481816362589598, -0.03883090615272522, -0.005875397007912397, 0.05124511197209358, 0.018933450803160667, 0.016347834840416908, 0.03374722972512245, 0.02204992063343525, 0.02595440484583378, -0.02762141078710556, -0.06659787893295288, 0.0014068324817344546, -0.03211057186126709, 0.008413098752498627, 0.05513677000999451, -0.01610509306192398, 0.05845595896244049, -0.023564666509628296, -0.013188294135034084, 0.08686131983995438, 0.005635220557451248, -0.028791792690753937, 0.0034658147487789392, -0.025089669972658157, 0.027599245309829712, 0.0007670659688301384, 0.017534563317894936, 0.020469974726438522, -0.0248311348259449, 0.0025979045312851667, -0.004076035693287849, -0.008680193684995174, 0.007779746316373348, 0.001681052497588098, -0.031550198793411255, -0.05649079754948616, 0.020757749676704407, -0.05932684615254402, 0.044694941490888596, -0.013783074915409088, -0.01938583143055439, 0.03738664463162422, -0.09946927428245544, 0.011461029760539532, 0.06378384679555893, -0.0031418472062796354, -0.006199595518410206, 0.014049558900296688, -0.05510600656270981, 0.029798468574881554, -0.06911236047744751, 0.01260919775813818, 0.01257962267845869, -0.04461033269762993, -0.0830768570303917, -0.025786081328988075, -0.021081071346998215, -0.041805434972047806, 0.05819838121533394, -0.0060415430925786495, 0.07222844660282135, 0.02396828681230545, 0.05649915710091591, 0.07355569303035736, 0.010459894314408302, -0.019239522516727448, -0.02751022018492222, -0.04296085983514786, 0.001746184192597866, 0.0027899015694856644, 0.03025086596608162, -0.08148261159658432, 0.01869218610227108, -0.02376035414636135, -0.01533091813325882, -0.04436938092112541, 0.013051851652562618, 0.041177526116371155, -0.005628449842333794, 0.04147350415587425, -0.02640300989151001, -0.053624797612428665, -0.0063346088863909245, -0.056651122868061066, -0.03172991797327995, -0.019384030252695084, 0.019541464745998383, -0.023437118157744408, -0.019604278728365898, 0.014940286055207253, 0.011869587004184723, -0.026007506996393204, 0.04118380323052406, -0.0028689485043287277, 0.03496840223670006, 0.021023821085691452, -0.012033249251544476, -0.008822054602205753, 0.009599873796105385, -0.05683920904994011, -0.023362042382359505, -0.054811637848615646, 0.0055000935681164265, -0.04386477172374725, 0.04107097163796425, 0.020460648462176323, -0.02036774717271328, -0.01843995973467827, 0.021476248279213905, 0.0047829644754529, 0.015067735686898232, 0.010450184345245361, -0.017350392416119576, 0.052891094237565994, 0.026317140087485313, -0.008706276305019855, -0.03297644481062889, -0.010660667903721333, -0.013896254822611809, 0.07099112123250961, 0.04939652606844902, -0.025789443403482437, 0.039046719670295715, 0.006532968021929264, -0.024264534935355186, -0.04180222377181053, 0.0430244505405426, -0.028163153678178787, -0.044773850589990616, 0.0619555339217186, 0.03144041821360588, -0.006598117761313915, -0.0005185137270018458, -0.007428579498082399, -0.010756752453744411, -0.02784397266805172, -0.01088783424347639, 0.021967841312289238, 0.0654369592666626, 0.0479900948703289, -0.01509066578000784, -0.0034384317696094513, -0.015051888301968575, 0.12378580868244171, -0.015327568165957928, -0.002965882420539856, -0.0037190786097198725, 0.021090751513838768, 0.04084644839167595, -0.0030855205841362476, 0.030452115461230278, -0.0027824367862194777, 0.015252926386892796, -0.04093628004193306, 0.0041676596738398075, 0.004286607727408409, -0.043751444667577744, 0.04480741173028946, 0.005647468380630016, 0.045080460608005524, 0.00020655730622820556, 0.05425233766436577, 0.056633129715919495, -0.03387835621833801, -0.004818038083612919, 0.010231212712824345, 0.0473550483584404, -0.014734298922121525, -0.011913635767996311, -0.04307786375284195, -0.006448168307542801, -0.04550107941031456, 0.002498901914805174, -0.011391027830541134, -0.021890753880143166, 0.025372911244630814, -0.07680389285087585, -0.04841025173664093, -0.03308792784810066, -0.002393556060269475, 0.024885499849915504, -0.030690446496009827, 0.02110404521226883, 0.009495923295617104, -0.005184517707675695, 0.00008210957457777113, 0.00373830646276474, -0.07309413701295853, -0.04120238870382309, -0.027457213029265404, -0.026356728747487068, -0.0011301541235297918, -0.03350917622447014, 0.03087814524769783, -0.050447870045900345, -0.020649971440434456, -0.03089427761733532, 0.04813014715909958, -0.024692809209227562, 0.04186607897281647, -0.024153022095561028, -0.02557433396577835, -0.02765204943716526, -0.0313682034611702, -0.0496051199734211, 0.06711113452911377, 0.022531351074576378, -0.006925962865352631, -0.01083985436707735, 0.050057463347911835, -0.016106361523270607, -0.00562444981187582, -0.00034181514638476074, -0.002497537527233362, -0.053871240466833115, -0.06824702769517899, -0.006337428465485573, -0.046306099742650986, 0.02786901779472828, 0.05047633498907089, -0.024635883048176765, -0.025515399873256683, 0.029583772644400597, -0.04143581911921501, -0.03654204681515694, -0.06579189747571945, 0.01033097691833973, -0.008200274780392647, 0.036477189511060715, 0.039006613194942474, 0.02160761132836342, 0.026823369786143303, 0.035832472145557404, 0.015626750886440277, 0.01218104362487793, -0.0239394661039114, 0.06324877589941025, -0.0038736932910978794, 0.04872917756438255, 0.07035747915506363, 0.04686453938484192, -0.055486373603343964, 0.0586354024708271, -0.03616802394390106, -0.01467546634376049, 0.02866983227431774, -0.036091700196266174, 0.016072439029812813, 0.01032010093331337, -0.058090437203645706, 0.03957224264740944, -0.043130338191986084, -0.0003836807154584676, -0.027671540156006813, -0.03226646035909653, 0.024486443027853966, -0.03810664266347885, 0.020033355802297592, 0.02398296818137169, -0.01506713591516018, -0.016095932573080063, -0.0184769444167614, 0.057185593992471695, -0.06948254257440567, -0.01191363949328661, 0.05700083076953888, -0.03498794138431549, 0.05912153422832489, -0.015117119997739792, 0.007046927697956562, 0.0799209401011467, 0.003178894054144621, 0.06655783951282501, -0.015910113230347633, 0.03737660124897957, 0.07860059291124344, 0.015344424173235893, 0.04364603012800217, 0.013304361142218113, 0.0017631558002904058, -0.002893376862630248, 0.014802072197198868, -0.023697979748249054, -0.013796600513160229, 0.006388163194060326, -0.06080849841237068, 0.03458134084939957, 0.011318379081785679, 0.04124154895544052, -0.08600446581840515, 0.028452910482883453, 0.0003016306727658957, 0.0270867757499218, -0.06582282483577728, -0.006166558712720871, 0.019756842404603958, -0.0127391517162323, -0.0316716730594635, 0.023746473714709282, 0.014934874139726162, -0.03407412767410278, -0.015397919341921806, -0.010972114279866219, -0.014534412883222103, -0.029703089967370033, 0.02355637401342392, -0.028553985059261322, 0.03064584918320179, 0.006174685899168253, -0.0406426377594471, 0.07090969383716583, 0.0010264337761327624, -0.04428926855325699, 0.0406663604080677, 0.07523453235626221, -0.0027240326162427664, 0.031232520937919617, 0.06438324600458145, 0.048147980123758316, 0.06398839503526688, -0.0342579260468483, -0.012633366510272026, -0.023152990266680717, 0.012061335146427155, 0.01642472669482231, -0.05355329439043999, 0.02573365718126297, -0.052772849798202515, -0.035891175270080566, -0.04138263687491417, 0.001157022430561483, -0.005242340266704559, 0.014972931705415249, 0.06237556040287018, 0.018304284662008286, 0.04666388779878616, 0.01222141832113266, 0.02545291557908058, -0.02828250825405121, -0.04591237008571625, -0.0006353818462230265, 0.008327013812959194, 0.009797402657568455, -0.028341906145215034, -0.048463091254234314, 0.0374271534383297, 0.0587465837597847, -0.0038350806571543217, 0.042852241545915604, -0.09637939929962158, 0.025749100372195244, 0.028456110507249832, 0.016019510105252266, 0.015030695125460625, -0.012552146799862385, 0.02430761232972145, 0.01226470060646534, -0.020967667922377586, -0.03268616273999214, -0.0032660618890076876, -0.02806675061583519, 0.00596276018768549, -0.07613254338502884, -0.0069223567843437195, -0.06104019284248352, -0.02148403413593769, 0.02820691466331482, -0.004718499723821878, 0.0054124025627970695, 0.0021343526896089315, 0.0014880455564707518, 0.017606563866138458, 0.011045421473681927, -0.02550284005701542, -0.03336510434746742, 0.029764221981167793, 0.006391788367182016, -0.03748433291912079, -0.028958098962903023, -0.005844093393534422, -0.05820383504033089, -0.02222433313727379, 0.019035184755921364, -0.005501630250364542, 0.07022891193628311, 0.03359372913837433, -0.07722353935241699, 0.019994769245386124, 0.04907306283712387, 0.027096547186374664, 0.023529576137661934, 0.012267949990928173, 0.002467256272211671, 0.014783238992094994, 0.048587821424007416, -0.026395326480269432, 0.014101652428507805, 0.009524342603981495, 0.06487389653921127, 0.0017535166116431355, 0.07554741203784943, -0.0788782387971878, 0.0048158238641917706, 0.038282494992017746, 0.06092540919780731 ]
<p>I am looking for some references which discuss Fourier transform methods in GR. Specifically supposing you have a metric $g_{\mu \nu}(x)$ and its Fourier transform $\tilde{g}_{\mu \nu}(k)$, what does this tell you about the Fourier transform of the inverse metric $\tilde{g}^{\mu \nu}(k)$ or the Riemann tensor $\tilde{R}^{\mu}{}_{\nu \rho \sigma}(k)$. There are some obvious identities you can derive and I am looking for a references which discusses these and says if they are useful or not. </p> <p>An example of what I mean is the following identity:</p> <p>$g^{\mu \alpha}(x)g_{\alpha \nu}(x) = \delta^{\mu}_{\nu} \implies (\tilde{g}^{\mu \alpha} \ast \tilde{g}_{\alpha \nu})(k) = \delta^{\mu}_{\nu} \delta^{4}(k)$. (This can be made sensible on a compact manifold or for metrics which are asymptotically flat etc.)</p>
g1674
[ 0.03648024797439575, -0.0163698960095644, -0.006149036344140768, -0.05418482795357704, 0.057070549577474594, 0.005542301572859287, 0.009438985958695412, 0.013351880013942719, -0.09858426451683044, -0.016918586567044258, -0.0027729158755391836, -0.0059207952581346035, 0.07641474157571793, -0.03445442020893097, -0.05003518983721733, -0.036521557718515396, -0.008680838160216808, 0.03647087886929512, -0.0244287122040987, 0.00802959967404604, -0.018590591847896576, 0.029442576691508293, 0.0467451736330986, 0.0024638997856527567, -0.015360004268586636, -0.007214314304292202, 0.06061820313334465, -0.020624948665499687, -0.0005326262908056378, -0.0630616769194603, -0.041829731315374374, 0.012548388913273811, 0.05077291652560234, -0.01866050623357296, -0.049861595034599304, 0.021384350955486298, 0.048303570598363876, 0.03149740770459175, 0.02635555900633335, -0.007319270633161068, 0.030651159584522247, -0.0668322890996933, 0.042054954916238785, 0.09560398012399673, 0.01857208088040352, 0.03717605397105217, -0.06498639285564423, 0.03760954737663269, 0.014205996878445148, 0.05266041308641434, 0.0027332366444170475, 0.07900667190551758, 0.006068106275051832, -0.025910349562764168, -0.05056086927652359, -0.037543777376413345, -0.0006485371268354356, 0.00372294127009809, -0.008901935070753098, -0.07640156894922256, -0.033459730446338654, -0.04852886497974396, -0.05480792745947838, -0.015591324307024479, 0.01078453753143549, -0.04697984829545021, 0.012740892358124256, -0.05401188135147095, 0.05096689984202385, 0.0023348291870206594, 0.03184652701020241, 0.00753752188757062, 0.07386446744203568, 0.007094083819538355, -0.002844993956387043, 0.0017334393924102187, -0.005102792754769325, 0.012695024721324444, -0.05654138699173927, -0.0023540130350738764, 0.036354199051856995, -0.06903555989265442, 0.03159717842936516, 0.03821174055337906, 0.04063870757818222, 0.011261086910963058, 0.019871778786182404, 0.09416259825229645, 0.036233555525541306, 0.04371059313416481, -0.015346091240644455, 0.012903355062007904, -0.004719313234090805, 0.0037618789356201887, 0.026231158524751663, 0.04175189137458801, -0.033529575914144516, 0.022053895518183708, -0.028304623439908028, -0.028257964178919792, 0.017681624740362167, 0.00992436334490776, -0.01621645875275135, -0.024899106472730637, 0.016788151115179062, 0.011448239907622337, -0.0004228004836477339, 0.052174028009176254, -0.005622396245598793, -0.02199624665081501, -0.08144334703683853, 0.03932942450046539, 0.012865511700510979, -0.04208441823720932, -0.042639750987291336, -0.036896802484989166, 0.013541982509195805, -0.052973657846450806, 0.05599742382764816, 0.053310759365558624, -0.031286757439374924, 0.0035578494425863028, -0.04871071130037308, -0.013331535272300243, -0.03077227994799614, -0.044965263456106186, -0.010462485253810883, -0.00416070781648159, 0.0521942600607872, -0.0075935907661914825, 0.030422942712903023, 0.015504205599427223, -0.0359855517745018, 0.0018197649624198675, 0.01640225015580654, 0.06455715745687485, -0.01555248349905014, 0.0657259002327919, -0.011947162449359894, 0.012992579489946365, -0.02512090839445591, 0.023198595270514488, -0.011582578532397747, -0.03673524409532547, 0.034184008836746216, 0.051927633583545685, 0.019467703998088837, -0.08828213065862656, 0.050777483731508255, -0.018637455999851227, 0.01472507044672966, 0.09043530374765396, 0.039665527641773224, 0.013119339942932129, 0.024048320949077606, -0.015810184180736542, -0.07266218960285187, -0.045701444149017334, -0.020703762769699097, -0.03718014061450958, 0.05825963243842125, 0.01420498825609684, 0.028480229899287224, 0.0013832361437380314, 0.003509238827973604, 0.0603688582777977, -0.008233435451984406, -0.04017465561628342, -0.01166466809809208, -0.07186225801706314, -0.03700730577111244, 0.06399332731962204, 0.07013420015573502, 0.029262494295835495, -0.01169232465326786, -0.004089968744665384, 0.006683713756501675, -0.06184858828783035, 0.004037402104586363, 0.029068177565932274, -0.051946673542261124, -0.04228735342621803, 0.018407482653856277, -0.055642422288656235, 0.008989337831735611, -0.051621902734041214, 0.017780570313334465, -0.0036244303919374943, -0.010651840828359127, 0.04797064885497093, -0.05820291489362717, 0.0008400073274970055, 0.017345596104860306, 0.0692947581410408, 0.03131796792149544, 0.01856997422873974, -0.006533402018249035, -0.02782905288040638, -0.012143107131123543, 0.04695519432425499, -0.0234452523291111, 0.017525849863886833, 0.029560590162873268, 0.017333483323454857, 0.02955346740782261, 0.027456747367978096, -0.04699840396642685, -0.012976249679923058, 0.0568414181470871, -0.039248693734407425, 0.007489750161767006, -0.046094540506601334, 0.07537064701318741, 0.02689417265355587, -0.02980208583176136, 0.0456780381500721, -0.009427269920706749, 0.0052556367591023445, -0.008147606626152992, 0.0034244218841195107, 0.08588389307260513, -0.010695816949009895, -0.011090259067714214, 0.03330084681510925, -0.03385788947343826, -0.01783878542482853, -0.07694347947835922, -0.001360029447823763, -0.02718893438577652, 0.0015718756476417184, -0.0788620188832283, -0.06796077638864517, 0.016082510352134705, -0.03619793429970741, 0.004575266968458891, -0.002533531980589032, -0.022274203598499298, -0.03542991727590561, 0.019709622487425804, 0.06342937052249908, 0.06050167977809906, -0.052355580031871796, -0.026261383667588234, -0.013952911831438541, -0.06143299490213394, 0.07396890968084335, -0.016989056020975113, -0.012804461643099785, -0.005472411867231131, 0.0035475287586450577, -0.00019351454102434218, 0.06093108281493187, -0.02522578090429306, -0.032621148973703384, -0.029240047559142113, -0.0013062374200671911, -0.004610762465745211, -0.005879218690097332, -0.09842497855424881, 0.0029860595241189003, -0.009899596683681011, -0.06162835657596588, -0.01848033256828785, 0.011822037398815155, -0.05540912598371506, -0.0002505979791749269, 0.002037358470261097, 0.08694135397672653, -0.043119411915540695, 0.019906118512153625, 0.024373048916459084, 0.024273114278912544, 0.059601396322250366, 0.008072401396930218, -0.02263602428138256, 0.0024965235497802496, 0.04503738880157471, -0.00948629155755043, 0.023847801610827446, 0.03673833608627319, -0.012327741831541061, -0.06740698218345642, -0.046823650598526, 0.0015961133176460862, 0.006963690742850304, -0.05907319113612175, 0.010555261746048927, 0.05872349068522453, 0.011306407861411572, 0.013931525871157646, 0.026983603835105896, 0.03577382490038872, 0.01966622844338417, -0.02645851857960224, -0.10484403371810913, 0.014293699525296688, -0.007087016943842173, -0.02526727505028248, 0.0019434106070548296, 0.008137290365993977, 0.051161028444767, -0.04610329121351242, -0.007447175215929747, 0.003482874482870102, 0.021154776215553284, -0.013255064375698566, -0.04596872255206108, -0.06800527125597, 0.01952236145734787, 0.025256140157580376, 0.02182113751769066, 0.028960611671209335, 0.007446449715644121, 0.020739233121275902, 0.0003221750375814736, -0.03986326977610588, -0.01216625515371561, -0.007770395837724209, -0.02983306534588337, 0.021982723847031593, 0.00016481801867485046, -0.024455692619085312, -0.006893958896398544, -0.044943176209926605, 0.02537594363093376, -0.0039509874768555164, -0.03836842253804207, 0.020613059401512146, -0.006209775805473328, -0.000122775774798356, -0.004058022517710924, 0.002641452942043543, -0.00008669119415571913, 0.008441012352705002, -0.043286312371492386, -0.008856885135173798, -0.05566577985882759, 0.023695649579167366, -0.005761106964200735, -0.00798177532851696, 0.010203861631453037, -0.024513591080904007, -0.045953575521707535, -0.023707153275609016, 0.03575043007731438, 0.07457432150840759, 0.02419835887849331, 0.01174126472324133, -0.011043906211853027, -0.009443869814276695, -0.05137336626648903, -0.0031355563551187515, 0.04521213471889496, -0.06146111711859703, 0.017174581065773964, 0.029035668820142746, 0.04245756193995476, 0.07156787812709808, 0.05939365178346634, -0.012555972672998905, 0.002105660503730178, 0.0218674186617136, -0.013680231757462025, -0.014867317862808704, 0.024576008319854736, -0.020588187500834465, 0.057667504996061325, -0.007381271570920944, -0.05895819514989853, 0.05164968967437744, 0.06466663628816605, 0.04127306863665581, 0.044318787753582, 0.006602462846785784, -0.09206473082304001, -0.02533111907541752, -0.03129466623067856, 0.038926102221012115, 0.007556178607046604, 0.015033787116408348, -0.03217543661594391, 0.01963965594768524, 0.03462069109082222, -0.01427496038377285, 0.0415303073823452, -0.06357653439044952, -0.011851773597300053, -0.015618323348462582, 0.055313508957624435, -0.07267163693904877, 0.04342754930257797, 0.0025708007160574198, 0.003406001953408122, 0.01944716088473797, -0.02051718905568123, -0.036299929022789, 0.03013308346271515, 0.03465275466442108, 0.001341507420875132, 0.046787604689598083, 0.007542094681411982, 0.019125202670693398, -0.02177635207772255, 0.02381000854074955, -0.036435727030038834, 0.02191733941435814, -0.0293528251349926, -0.0487748421728611, -0.01351300161331892, -0.038579221814870834, -0.06493598222732544, -0.0032564441207796335, -0.0025764834135770798, -0.10330755263566971, 0.06716644018888474, -0.011642892844974995, -0.02421790175139904, -0.09255442023277283, 0.014969597570598125, 0.02973209321498871, 0.005170586984604597, -0.03696141764521599, -0.011047830805182457, 0.04143738001585007, -0.004610750824213028, 0.05109848827123642, 0.09671103209257126, 0.00638218130916357, -0.0023944624699652195, 0.011778422631323338, 0.004519275389611721, -0.003391790669411421, -0.020172229036688805, 0.02989141456782818, 0.005591702647507191, -0.026864023879170418, -0.038161080330610275, -0.025005031377077103, 0.01759745366871357, -0.08880007266998291, 0.041951343417167664, 0.05462012067437172, -0.040245722979307175, -0.024048149585723877, -0.05164354667067528, 0.009479611180722713, -0.03853708878159523, 0.0018059526337310672, -0.009031282737851143, 0.03398643061518669, 0.02026803232729435, -0.020263884216547012, -0.009780981577932835, -0.04638342559337616, -0.03272287920117378, 0.04196670278906822, 0.025765519589185715, -0.00576763553544879, 0.0027689875569194555, -0.020242534577846527, -0.002374946605414152, 0.027260905131697655, 0.0002758520713541657, 0.020649276673793793, 0.011419955641031265, 0.0027094418182969093, -0.04720025137066841, 0.07129990309476852, -0.033327843993902206, -0.05051552504301071, 0.007437324617058039, 0.00997507106512785, 0.01243568118661642, -0.08744116872549057, 0.03728022426366806, 0.05461439862847328, -0.005483746528625488, 0.030007587745785713, 0.01440220233052969, -0.004052402917295694, -0.03642774373292923, -0.01894496940076351, 0.08109206706285477, 0.005369078367948532, 0.008668720722198486, 0.012922339141368866, 0.023673061281442642, -0.02160055935382843, 0.023844748735427856, -0.06876719743013382, -0.01259750034660101, 0.000281964719761163, 0.03812427818775177, 0.008935722522437572, -0.04623198136687279, 0.05894621089100838, -0.005589169450104237, -0.028745362535119057, -0.001174581702798605, 0.012216993607580662, -0.0035394984297454357, 0.035150058567523956, 0.032136525958776474, -0.01753912679851055, 0.028314249590039253, 0.06208883598446846, 0.05822322517633438, -0.006269571837037802, -0.02751462534070015, 0.05444718524813652, -0.012290936894714832, -0.005854913964867592, -0.010776561684906483, 0.010185210034251213, 0.00822975393384695, -0.006283027119934559, -0.03691178932785988, -0.009193009696900845, 0.009583886712789536, -0.020325202494859695, -0.03183296322822571, -0.029764313250780106, 0.01276997197419405, -0.05023880675435066, 0.0780629962682724, 0.023227401077747345, 0.008893539197742939, -0.007300358731299639, 0.03773089125752449, 0.022393885999917984, 0.044502802193164825, 0.005109218414872885, -0.019405322149395943, 0.02529500611126423, 0.0019887848757207394, 0.018844714388251305, 0.0257243849337101, 0.026988808065652847, 0.012705894187092781, 0.011885005049407482, -0.05345267057418823, 0.07875627279281616, -0.0335601270198822, -0.04428730905056, -0.030995959416031837, 0.013907009735703468, 0.07676953077316284, -0.0750402882695198, -0.011630305089056492, -0.010258272290229797, 0.027856817469000816, -0.020389800891280174, -0.012825638055801392, -0.038014885038137436, -0.04567509889602661, 0.01270340010523796, 0.03211326524615288, -0.034185461699962616, -0.03705752640962601, 0.041242849081754684, 0.009227416478097439, -0.029182465746998787, 0.004705904517322779, 0.004697001539170742, -0.014014113694429398, -0.06415942311286926, 0.0034291590563952923, -0.0186452753841877, 0.04712063819169998, 0.019243963062763214, -0.0630328357219696, -0.02187536470592022, -0.004293934907764196, -0.03426149860024452, 0.005651573184877634, -0.01457929890602827, 0.009047450497746468, -0.10279528051614761, 0.0023610307835042477, -0.03974565863609314, 0.06375540792942047, 0.017092082649469376, 0.009693617932498455, -0.07106427103281021, -0.1143336296081543, -0.01485714502632618, -0.024223433807492256, 0.03251498192548752, -0.004843439441174269, 0.027557846158742905, 0.014859616756439209, 0.00003983964415965602, 0.011910898610949516, -0.0008071952615864575, -0.0019122431986033916, -0.06178612634539604, 0.020091921091079712, 0.05634294077754021, 0.0006165129016153514, -0.0008723866194486618, -0.022293061017990112, 0.025572706013917923, 0.06689827889204025, -0.011805122718214989, -0.012272719293832779, -0.043217193335294724, 0.004528343211859465, -0.026819217950105667, -0.011765066534280777, 0.044220902025699615, 0.03432947024703026, 0.057780712842941284, 0.013679010793566704, -0.012304376810789108, -0.0006333867786452174, -0.026249151676893234, -0.03867542743682861, 0.008609126321971416, -0.02710181288421154, -0.024870293214917183, 0.07130666822195053, -0.011502141132950783, -0.0038926240522414446, -0.045297324657440186, 0.0952376052737236, 0.016241716220974922, 0.010126499459147453, 0.01161715667694807, -0.0067847552709281445, -0.050023145973682404, -0.005686032585799694, 0.008965072222054005, -0.0010807279031723738, 0.04348503053188324, -0.003976502455770969, 0.044034916907548904, -0.07756099104881287, 0.03991071507334709, 0.055191271007061005, 0.03854145482182503, -0.014920997433364391, -0.031137065961956978, -0.003969021141529083, -0.0215451717376709, -0.027777954936027527, 0.036535464227199554, 0.01887330412864685, -0.03631920740008354, -0.08730769902467728, 0.007338306400924921, 0.027325903996825218, -0.0312093086540699, 0.012155999429523945, -0.0016062273643910885, -0.03513310104608536, 0.011622314341366291, -0.0037525484804064035, 0.07976292818784714, 0.023900244385004044, -0.0023953497875481844, -0.02063606306910515, 0.005465138703584671, -0.026960017159581184, 0.02949945628643036, -0.014918667264282703, 0.01810888573527336, 0.05029711127281189, 0.008904986083507538, 0.02892892248928547, 0.03180636465549469, 0.022665437310934067, 0.0034236053470522165, 0.025557637214660645, 0.014227734878659248, 0.02172352932393551, -0.01356472633779049, 0.009095460176467896, 0.011696423403918743, -0.05381627753376961, 0.0028842203319072723, -0.0321645587682724, 0.0327782966196537, 0.019817540422081947, 0.019199490547180176, -0.017564572393894196, 0.01609174907207489, 0.038141146302223206, 0.028507325798273087, -0.025661973282694817, -0.012846961617469788, -0.06795474141836166, 0.04444057494401932, -0.014194566756486893, -0.014099003747105598, -0.002702992642298341, -0.0042062061838805676, -0.03753664344549179, 0.055829573422670364, -0.005968389101326466, -0.026340993121266365, 0.011318325065076351, -0.01430052611976862, 0.017488494515419006, -0.024145204573869705, 0.02405114285647869, 0.024408837780356407, -0.02655915543437004, -0.04167008027434349, 0.002855034079402685, 0.004602761007845402, 0.05260397121310234, -0.04407769814133644, -0.011627198196947575, 0.002897875150665641, -0.04114045575261116, 0.04627605527639389, 0.01085300836712122, -0.007905197329819202, 0.02037334069609642, -0.02733706682920456, 0.054085176438093185, -0.003947637975215912, -0.010976217687129974, -0.06130460649728775, -0.052385106682777405, 0.02064569480717182, -0.012918130494654179, 0.009133505634963512, 0.015704341232776642, -0.00808916985988617, -0.006343428045511246, 0.02011237107217312, -0.04882645606994629, -0.01853003352880478, 0.024682924151420593, 0.04627591371536255, 0.00005879916716367006, -0.03567331284284592, 0.01921049878001213, 0.012347429059445858, 0.05893668904900551, -0.008123118430376053, 0.002672887407243252, 0.00907730869948864, -0.06368695944547653, -0.034225791692733765, 0.032008592039346695, 0.012800500728189945, -0.02864084392786026, -0.005924742668867111, 0.0049409689381718636, 0.039098404347896576, 0.07345584779977798, 0.02179308980703354, -0.0104279275983572, -0.054717306047677994, 0.0013223118148744106, 0.029894376173615456, 0.02274116314947605, -0.029506733641028404, 0.03783257678151131, -0.0028425371274352074, -0.03556382283568382, 0.05277632176876068, -0.045490797609090805, -0.037129029631614685, -0.029721785336732864, -0.014260401949286461 ]
<p>A symmetry is anomalous when the path-integral measure does not respect it. One way this manifests itself is in the inability to regularize certain diagrams containing fermion loops in a way compatible with the symmetry. Specifically, it seems that the effect is completely determined by studying 1-loop diagrams. Can someone give a heuristic explanation as to why this is the case? And is there a more rigorous derivation that "I just can't find any good way to regularize this thing."?</p> <p>An alternative approach, due to to Fujikawa, is to study the path integral of the fermions in an instanton background. Then one sees that the zero modes are not balanced with respect to their transformation under the symmetries, leading to an anomalous transformation of the measure under this symmetry. Specifically, the violation is proportional to the instanton number, and thus one finds the non-conservation of the current is proportional to the instanton density. This is also found by the perturbative method above.</p> <p>My question, which is a little heuristic, is how is it that the effect seems perturbative (and exact at 1-loop) on the one hand, and yet related to instantons, which are non-perturbative, on the other?</p>
g1675
[ 0.016407497227191925, 0.010758887976408005, 0.002172427251935005, -0.04492237791419029, 0.04935954883694649, 0.01577559858560562, 0.022703304886817932, 0.07892341911792755, -0.023049868643283844, 0.018015414476394653, -0.04610772803425789, -0.053662851452827454, -0.0445365346968174, 0.06506471335887909, 0.014740807935595512, 0.03253971412777901, 0.03556055575609207, 0.06197137013077736, 0.05423010140657425, -0.02302738092839718, 0.01647563837468624, -0.03152865171432495, 0.015565757639706135, 0.0047357347793877125, 0.09139224886894226, -0.014475787989795208, 0.06707028299570084, -0.03407258540391922, -0.07655911147594452, -0.00527994055300951, 0.021768230944871902, 0.016315041109919548, 0.0000219615176320076, -0.05735768750309944, -0.045378316193819046, -0.03579161688685417, 0.06136126071214676, 0.013061669655144215, 0.03456065431237221, 0.061391185969114304, 0.012335213832557201, 0.0014104010770097375, 0.0030269611161202192, -0.00686088390648365, -0.027643315494060516, 0.0023443850222975016, -0.03131529316306114, -0.010296567343175411, 0.006715798284858465, 0.028234658762812614, 0.0010003491770476103, 0.010220465250313282, 0.09941066056489944, -0.011251196265220642, -0.009381817653775215, 0.007354339584708214, 0.007567991968244314, -0.03285791724920273, 0.024431833997368813, 0.03142152726650238, -0.018903696909546852, -0.026559334248304367, 0.08076203614473343, 0.020136909559369087, -0.0035887116100639105, -0.043155718594789505, -0.021191222593188286, -0.004348163492977619, -0.01657707802951336, 0.01661803014576435, -0.014123396947979927, -0.007985245436429977, -0.01624962128698826, 0.0022699867840856314, 0.003891552099958062, 0.057589057832956314, 0.017140844836831093, -0.01626897044479847, 0.014274119399487972, -0.0006393226212821901, -0.0629626214504242, -0.0036880536936223507, -0.028476327657699585, 0.062368616461753845, 0.056832026690244675, -0.009731346741318703, -0.0009186381357721984, 0.006410201545804739, 0.0032704926561564207, 0.00590724078938365, 0.02112242951989174, -0.031145760789513588, 0.04101448878645897, -0.03695638105273247, 0.007786661386489868, 0.01789350062608719, 0.028755564242601395, 0.07529164105653763, -0.018985744565725327, 0.04357524961233139, -0.02595549076795578, 0.030961109325289726, -0.04077351838350296, 0.020343758165836334, -0.02531503699719906, 0.011481263674795628, 0.02054658718407154, -0.03291577100753784, 0.03374037146568298, -0.00883688498288393, -0.0018096623243764043, -0.062124043703079224, -0.039977554231882095, 0.0145940613001585, 0.008573674596846104, -0.0349658764898777, 0.06985825300216675, -0.0521627739071846, -0.009120091795921326, 0.026950934901833534, 0.030550803989171982, 0.028223995119333267, -0.03554588183760643, 0.07895869761705399, -0.007406891323626041, 0.040842484682798386, -0.06840269267559052, 0.032449398189783096, 0.03731426224112511, -0.02694404497742653, -0.012158195488154888, 0.0020148414187133312, 0.013535781763494015, 0.05130409821867943, -0.014993706718087196, -0.057322993874549866, 0.013608567416667938, 0.042923569679260254, 0.0043182531371712685, -0.03026716411113739, 0.003065326251089573, -0.041486866772174835, -0.04768642783164978, 0.02603314444422722, 0.0020198896527290344, -0.045520663261413574, -0.008249525912106037, 0.006409312132745981, 0.04471706226468086, -0.010660579428076744, -0.00477120466530323, 0.014845208264887333, -0.055883679538965225, 0.024759238585829735, -0.043557826429605484, -0.028184397146105766, 0.051359619945287704, 0.01663426123559475, 0.04121014475822449, -0.008871105499565601, 0.0466630794107914, 0.011166587471961975, -0.000491200655233115, 0.01698319800198078, -0.06288262456655502, -0.03897527605295181, 0.05006306245923042, -0.00592430355027318, -0.03989822417497635, -0.07215578854084015, -0.0552092008292675, 0.03949710726737976, 0.0005612095701508224, 0.0554484985768795, -0.04008043557405472, 0.04569527879357338, -0.07063084840774536, 0.019496941938996315, 0.02295549213886261, -0.03040926717221737, -0.05752003192901611, 0.022660309448838234, 0.01148483157157898, 0.028413301333785057, -0.022801406681537628, -0.04339519515633583, -0.038229770958423615, 0.036446504294872284, -0.02209997922182083, -0.014348292723298073, 0.021578175947070122, -0.01568964309990406, 0.0078034596517682076, 0.05295241251587868, -0.023708011955022812, -0.021641353145241737, -0.02571452595293522, -0.03989895060658455, -0.06749771535396576, -0.045854028314352036, -0.006525394972413778, 0.015838073566555977, 0.0016596850473433733, -0.017656339332461357, 0.009182983078062534, -0.014948958531022072, 0.003909381106495857, -0.0416947565972805, 0.044485196471214294, -0.05096731334924698, 0.005878120195120573, -0.022210173308849335, 0.0012207957915961742, -0.01821909099817276, -0.018335238099098206, 0.014740253798663616, 0.023005515336990356, 0.016644015908241272, -0.010276004672050476, -0.05185258761048317, -0.024722758680582047, -0.0035548843443393707, 0.07901117950677872, 0.07749368995428085, -0.009492890909314156, 0.03637420013546944, 0.010593531653285027, -0.0407571978867054, -0.03813162446022034, 0.013036551885306835, -0.0788213387131691, -0.0031394283287227154, -0.04597259685397148, 0.03137454017996788, -0.0056925988756120205, -0.004097732715308666, 0.003159496234729886, 0.009135623462498188, 0.04167511314153671, -0.029229139909148216, -0.037490665912628174, -0.00623552268370986, -0.011742480099201202, 0.03568660840392113, 0.06643643975257874, 0.012848535552620888, 0.05045732855796814, 0.00908453669399023, -0.021241435781121254, 0.014511806890368462, 0.04639323428273201, 0.02422298491001129, 0.00887518934905529, -0.050047583878040314, 0.02727353200316429, -0.026266388595104218, 0.0924074575304985, 0.06814520061016083, -0.03197971358895302, -0.0520932637155056, 0.040643151849508286, -0.011917689815163612, -0.008046061731874943, 0.04121652618050575, -0.012244798243045807, -0.007908712141215801, 0.05918281897902489, -0.028775250539183617, -0.028537854552268982, 0.0003639394126366824, 0.00006587816460523754, 0.06376738846302032, -0.03470790386199951, -0.010980907827615738, 0.014118083752691746, -0.017891617491841316, 0.004047930706292391, -0.015116776339709759, 0.05290067568421364, -0.02254738099873066, -0.03785627707839012, 0.0289748702198267, -0.03270071744918823, 0.019591664895415306, 0.029804879799485207, -0.02864302136003971, 0.027863450348377228, -0.006396986544132233, 0.02208198606967926, 0.04588710516691208, -0.047327809035778046, -0.0007953578024171293, 0.00040124281076714396, 0.02837977558374405, -0.02166898548603058, -0.0012652729637920856, -0.01110144704580307, -0.10460854321718216, -0.009776980616152287, 0.0126655837520957, -0.005510922521352768, 0.0216692928224802, -0.022837020456790924, 0.02804928831756115, 0.0748290866613388, -0.059591129422187805, -0.014757615514099598, -0.04315495491027832, 0.06021683290600777, 0.052162881940603256, -0.007398348301649094, 0.031058112159371376, -0.04579963907599449, -0.01110273227095604, 0.06444326043128967, 0.05233553797006607, -0.08841212838888168, 0.0013170716119930148, -0.01748870126903057, -0.00935280416160822, -0.058147549629211426, 0.010316917672753334, 0.0001712053781375289, 0.037233322858810425, 0.025532450526952744, -0.008648987859487534, 0.018560847267508507, -0.0030089151114225388, -0.00035682585439644754, -0.042733609676361084, 0.020739074796438217, -0.03826184198260307, -0.009981117211282253, -0.06784777343273163, -0.011625061742961407, -0.07120946794748306, -0.013411793857812881, -0.017026929184794426, -0.037467002868652344, 0.00872218981385231, -0.05950753018260002, -0.05663169175386429, 0.0004711606015916914, -0.06286414712667465, 0.046537648886442184, -0.0015910816146060824, -0.0259211678057909, 0.01773178018629551, 0.00023605469323229045, 0.00922871008515358, 0.024847790598869324, 0.0242790374904871, 0.016113117337226868, -0.04851526767015457, -0.015690745785832405, -0.014315815642476082, 0.026957379654049873, 0.06921233236789703, 0.02772008627653122, 0.022493921220302582, 0.02841118909418583, -0.006346935406327248, -0.02440127544105053, -0.029511859640479088, 0.0024439922999590635, -0.0012039685389027, -0.043648090213537216, -0.004623482469469309, 0.03691618889570236, 0.0023673337418586016, 0.040835537016391754, 0.023443682119250298, 0.003070571692660451, -0.024758577346801758, 0.033955298364162445, -0.017168311402201653, 0.018238108605146408, 0.030259180814027786, -0.061004262417554855, 0.044604476541280746, 0.016153717413544655, -0.007414703723043203, 0.0033920591231435537, 0.020486120134592056, 0.047307614237070084, 0.04345421865582466, -0.09254277497529984, 0.021360011771321297, -0.04638372361660004, 0.00006825792661402375, 0.045571014285087585, 0.007641656789928675, 0.004478894639760256, -0.014652365818619728, 0.012686746194958687, -0.007578813936561346, -0.008637061342597008, -0.059374839067459106, 0.005907850805670023, 0.03781238943338394, -0.019073478877544403, -0.015019036829471588, 0.030503708869218826, -0.021258458495140076, -0.00030061378492973745, -0.0623338520526886, -0.00046274723717942834, -0.031839579343795776, -0.03639043867588043, 0.00698499521240592, -0.009046045131981373, 0.05579705536365509, 0.03734918311238289, -0.08666913211345673, -0.011430785991251469, 0.01017926074564457, -0.00651225820183754, -0.08072458952665329, 0.050510358065366745, -0.04706421121954918, 0.01076487172394991, -0.007062979973852634, -0.02585858292877674, 0.003178745973855257, 0.016508817672729492, 0.062113672494888306, 0.04430115595459938, -0.017231307923793793, 0.015035000629723072, -0.06035616248846054, 0.013839880004525185, 0.014176802709698677, -0.052028778940439224, 0.004814369138330221, -0.0494811125099659, 0.056157805025577545, -0.04047747328877449, 0.09022644907236099, 0.0029083581175655127, 0.06237450987100601, 0.1113077774643898, -0.00599531689658761, -0.037003643810749054, 0.019354315474629402, -0.04475543648004532, -0.04324881732463837, -0.06391120702028275, 0.006770244799554348, -0.013789770193397999, -0.001688959775492549, -0.03950361907482147, 0.009315310046076775, -0.015533368103206158, -0.02998044714331627, -0.042404815554618835, -0.078402578830719, 0.006060285493731499, 0.07271008938550949, 0.05495518073439598, 0.008306903764605522, -0.08126754313707352, -0.04539122432470322, -0.02288132905960083, -0.01589971035718918, -0.011332175694406033, -0.025152605026960373, -0.010325189679861069, 0.01937156543135643, -0.05705232173204422, -0.02681339532136917, 0.03974049538373947, -0.019602222368121147, -0.021335076540708542, -0.01301206462085247, 0.03852877393364906, 0.051421284675598145, -0.008023987524211407, 0.009109904058277607, -0.038734618574380875, -0.01975918933749199, -0.0020612776279449463, -0.0023674853146076202, 0.03917267918586731, 0.0177460964769125, -0.042859889566898346, 0.009246643632650375, -0.01726827770471573, 0.008581684902310371, -0.013208938762545586, -0.0343916118144989, 0.04263933002948761, 0.024965323507785797, 0.04289370775222778, -0.01656951941549778, 0.08907163143157959, -0.00476273987442255, 0.033345166593790054, 0.0787963941693306, 0.01505147386342287, -0.07025501877069473, -0.02617572620511055, 0.022659489884972572, 0.015567103400826454, -0.008778266608715057, -0.017674459144473076, 0.0422077514231205, 0.05634743347764015, -0.009361254051327705, 0.009228895418345928, -0.05256784334778786, -0.017440441995859146, -0.009134440682828426, 0.018068935722112656, 0.007018812466412783, 0.03107266314327717, 0.009012635797262192, -0.0538427010178566, -0.05135922133922577, -0.018348971381783485, -0.05683513730764389, -0.00927224475890398, 0.08382342010736465, -0.04226330667734146, -0.037741005420684814, 0.03413877636194229, -0.03798382356762886, -0.0327615924179554, -0.04007468372583389, 0.006343492306768894, 0.0026132974307984114, -0.006882492918521166, 0.0028861442115157843, 0.0162844005972147, 0.048934388905763626, 0.0254153311252594, -0.03271050751209259, 0.01493609044700861, -0.021004224196076393, 0.013120009563863277, 0.03165551647543907, 0.02692502923309803, 0.026675859466195107, 0.0127378199249506, -0.03917412459850311, -0.015424174256622791, -0.06367218494415283, -0.004472683183848858, -0.009106971323490143, -0.01772049441933632, -0.07018755376338959, -0.0624467171728611, -0.009663528762757778, -0.026472628116607666, -0.004708423744887114, -0.04560278356075287, 0.02008672058582306, 0.009980043396353722, 0.013647397980093956, -0.02925129048526287, -0.06833163648843765, 0.031307291239500046, -0.03534722700715065, 0.05895856395363808, -0.047033801674842834, 0.025500018149614334, -0.013463620096445084, -0.05670095607638359, -0.024257304146885872, 0.05273032188415527, 0.07431279122829437, -0.001930961268953979, 0.038939062505960464, 0.016573365777730942, 0.01658683270215988, -0.030675578862428665, 0.01384956669062376, -0.0059142326936125755, -0.0709923729300499, -0.005560736171901226, -0.025400158017873764, -0.01947428658604622, 0.016933783888816833, 0.03390312194824219, -0.05705002695322037, 0.016947582364082336, 0.015560653991997242, -0.0003810963244177401, -0.02857295423746109, 0.07083335518836975, 0.07390299439430237, -0.04634799435734749, 0.024734394624829292, -0.04414289444684982, 0.04741930961608887, 0.010833166539669037, 0.026801960542798042, -0.036422330886125565, -0.04358261823654175, -0.00602869875729084, 0.03523693233728409, 0.012090014293789864, 0.01984977163374424, 0.005104483105242252, 0.02845652587711811, 0.03739381209015846, 0.04298383370041847, 0.03165877237915993, 0.06280743330717087, -0.05037331581115723, -0.004786497913300991, 0.08244413137435913, 0.035261787474155426, -0.030761193484067917, 0.010028823278844357, 0.005740664433687925, 0.002887302776798606, -0.04623127728700638, -0.04636811465024948, -0.023404639214277267, 0.01520064752548933, 0.03357508033514023, -0.024882417172193527, -0.047834306955337524, -0.029219556599855423, 0.03384540230035782, 0.034172967076301575, 0.003284263890236616, -0.009746070019900799, 0.0338602177798748, -0.022542720660567284, -0.053535182029008865, 0.044644951820373535, -0.018957119435071945, 0.042636383324861526, -0.037818290293216705, 0.06577089428901672, -0.020485376939177513, 0.03891250491142273, -0.0019372876267880201, 0.048413895070552826, -0.02076258324086666, 0.021146146580576897, 0.005965856835246086, -0.04017990827560425, -0.039296165108680725, -0.006081479135900736, 0.027774110436439514, 0.019085559993982315, -0.050076816231012344, -0.030993936583399773, 0.0407174788415432, 0.04460719972848892, 0.03981808200478554, -0.053374554961919785, -0.0074698952957987785, -0.05547567456960678, -0.004937485326081514, 0.0395243763923645, 0.031472381204366684, -0.05091852322220802, -0.02481633611023426, 0.040423184633255005, 0.009407886303961277, -0.017499389126896858, 0.08239702135324478, -0.011801378801465034, -0.02792658843100071, -0.006919886451214552, -0.03005857951939106, 0.013944145292043686, -0.019933106377720833, -0.033958759158849716, 0.0011529695475474, -0.0049061584286391735, 0.060920488089323044, -0.00458561023697257, -0.007816105149686337, 0.036935705691576004, -0.06839994341135025, 0.004188599064946175, 0.022090543061494827, -0.025775756686925888, 0.003251532092690468, -0.015863170847296715, -0.038635414093732834, 0.030435146763920784, -0.01907280646264553, 0.018313612788915634, -0.022213874384760857, 0.0199970081448555, -0.01612580567598343, 0.03935985267162323, -0.03723621368408203, -0.044942837208509445, 0.023617902770638466, 0.08313186466693878, 0.06081573665142059, 0.0050191935151815414, -0.018346071243286133, -0.022173065692186356, 0.06291233003139496, -0.08164858818054199, -0.006268847268074751, 0.021082159131765366, 0.07100152969360352, -0.033633384853601456, 0.04466966912150383, -0.0500526949763298, -0.014464663341641426, 0.06071936711668968, -0.054117847234010696, 0.012839599512517452, -0.010612004436552525, 0.005553819704800844, 0.03251616656780243, -0.03704332932829857, -0.04547818750143051, -0.02283230610191822, 0.03022160939872265, 0.0206660944968462, -0.003732389071956277, -0.015790991485118866, -0.05600643530488014, 0.001965942559763789, -0.011731090024113655, -0.011626088991761208, 0.030436892062425613, 0.028060119599103928, 0.059100501239299774, 0.046627458184957504, 0.014010452665388584, 0.05402947962284088, -0.04960468411445618, 0.012312748469412327, -0.029985258355736732, 0.0007414639112539589, -0.044014912098646164, -0.06796034425497055, -0.044248100370168686, -0.004202865995466709, 0.04497848078608513, -0.022755660116672516, 0.021325182169675827, 0.01572493091225624, -0.012355799786746502, 0.01713399775326252, 0.031682610511779785, 0.0016898103058338165, 0.024965506047010422, -0.05072575807571411, 0.03185540810227394, 0.027503004297614098, -0.018229149281978607, -0.0024575269781053066, -0.0365457721054554, 0.046778351068496704, 0.002364697866141796, -0.05064288526773453, -0.0419929139316082, 0.04159383848309517, 0.024947281926870346, 0.025534432381391525, 0.012914139777421951, 0.04798223823308945, -0.008583879098296165, 0.0035933044273406267, -0.002198365516960621, -0.029266366735100746 ]
<p>What lessons do we have from string theory regarding the fate of singularities in general relativity?</p> <p>What happens to black hole singularities? What happens to cosmological singularities?</p> <p>Which points of view on string theory yielded results in this respect? String field theory? AdS/CFT? Matrix theory? I suppose perturbative string theory is not applicable in the vicinity of singularities.</p>
g1676
[ 0.03779258206486702, -0.018296191468834877, 0.03314143419265747, -0.02841990254819393, 0.020680246874690056, 0.05518874153494835, 0.03336752951145172, 0.031012361869215965, -0.004409000277519226, -0.014987709932029247, 0.0048752762377262115, -0.0023652869276702404, 0.03180203214287758, -0.00969930924475193, -0.008536734618246555, -0.05299278348684311, 0.015461715869605541, 0.014089290052652359, -0.003660463262349367, 0.011348887346684933, 0.023358872160315514, -0.00955674983561039, 0.07801991701126099, 0.006390081252902746, -0.03930192068219185, 0.016888823360204697, 0.05427064746618271, 0.04319034889340401, 0.010260541923344135, -0.023189302533864975, 0.013661717996001244, 0.05424601212143898, 0.063905730843544, -0.04473589360713959, 0.008896885439753532, -0.03879835456609726, 0.0024829015601426363, 0.020325208082795143, 0.05071249231696129, -0.013574864715337753, 0.035321492701768875, -0.03732544556260109, -0.03642508387565613, -0.046139415353536606, -0.0031762428116053343, -0.04475725069642067, -0.05486166104674339, -0.003078511916100979, 0.09840196371078491, 0.02458534762263298, 0.01854483224451542, 0.030867082998156548, 0.027899308130145073, -0.010062281042337418, 0.05875629559159279, 0.0017399442149326205, 0.016491683200001717, 0.0013889289693906903, 0.09465502202510834, 0.012167497538030148, -0.010964781977236271, 0.02058306708931923, 0.03955698385834694, -0.006399664096534252, -0.012653403915464878, -0.017167015001177788, -0.011587010696530342, -0.0329977422952652, 0.014082655310630798, 0.017758751288056374, 0.05909281596541405, 0.053644970059394836, 0.09171051532030106, 0.040923379361629486, -0.033704448491334915, 0.07533683627843857, 0.01848534867167473, 0.007581391837447882, -0.05348539724946022, 0.0006636336911469698, -0.02077748440206051, -0.058148059993982315, -0.016888096928596497, -0.02219494804739952, 0.05419262498617172, 0.0008862451650202274, 0.009877495467662811, 0.018824918195605278, 0.00012352403427939862, 0.031413424760103226, 0.025570597499608994, 0.0312640443444252, 0.0037067977245897055, -0.010812313295900822, 0.011869588866829872, -0.018911151215434074, 0.0303927194327116, 0.05526082590222359, -0.000030964329198468477, 0.005441651213914156, -0.007807078771293163, 0.022416042163968086, -0.020502131432294846, -0.0012583439238369465, 0.04811970517039299, -0.028054289519786835, -0.022509492933750153, 0.027761900797486305, 0.0200112983584404, 0.019309066236019135, -0.04057226702570915, 0.0005501285195350647, -0.020905600860714912, -0.04028555378317833, -0.06670685857534409, 0.022262059152126312, 0.05604948848485947, -0.05846560373902321, 0.007220796309411526, 0.03486800193786621, -0.0034552779980003834, 0.016529427841305733, 0.019650112837553024, 0.02510651759803295, 0.019180065020918846, -0.006070571951568127, -0.004389672074466944, -0.052657321095466614, -0.0021858399268239737, 0.017312461510300636, -0.003363178111612797, -0.020013147965073586, -0.003408521879464388, 0.027623716741800308, -0.007902604527771473, 0.029757117852568626, -0.005694530438631773, -0.01065902505069971, 0.05332767590880394, -0.0273299477994442, 0.03363453224301338, -0.014219608157873154, 0.007043090183287859, 0.06274837255477905, 0.059030089527368546, -0.028706178069114685, 0.00996637437492609, 0.05067639797925949, -0.009433487430214882, 0.014381207525730133, 0.03641340509057045, 0.09367065876722336, -0.0017118301475420594, 0.00535178417339921, 0.0011987673351541162, 0.03105226531624794, -0.0022704540751874447, -0.01339366938918829, -0.010856734588742256, -0.01731727086007595, 0.036481864750385284, -0.012387556955218315, 0.0021846075542271137, 0.0005907071754336357, -0.029279205948114395, -0.007024890277534723, -0.008355517871677876, -0.09468773752450943, 0.015497968532145023, -0.0016856557922437787, -0.04201614856719971, 0.03372124955058098, 0.034868594259023666, 0.0403892919421196, 0.023403100669384003, -0.05363737791776657, -0.0635322779417038, 0.044229041785001755, -0.026258565485477448, -0.029884731397032738, -0.011316066607832909, -0.03558649122714996, -0.014283264987170696, -0.03291456028819084, 0.038829706609249115, -0.006273068953305483, -0.055085502564907074, -0.030024155974388123, -0.013102216646075249, 0.08705870807170868, -0.031123558059334755, -0.023405054584145546, 0.014486067928373814, 0.0915675014257431, -0.009912549518048763, 0.00895925983786583, 0.05751188099384308, 0.023004449903964996, 0.014395616017282009, 0.056299470365047455, -0.0011767616961151361, 0.03196199983358383, -0.0019223598064854741, 0.03202294185757637, 0.03365316241979599, -0.04720587283372879, -0.009602619335055351, -0.012424327433109283, 0.06957715004682541, -0.008171836845576763, 0.019992729648947716, -0.0519741028547287, 0.017144806683063507, -0.029086997732520103, -0.06984063237905502, 0.0018575252033770084, -0.04969208687543869, 0.02848835103213787, 0.006649907678365707, 0.049574315547943115, 0.0508987121284008, 0.015652615576982498, 0.01802165061235428, 0.031847983598709106, 0.022898029536008835, 0.0282015148550272, -0.05009090527892113, -0.045815836638212204, -0.018728671595454216, -0.014407625421881676, -0.10171952843666077, 0.031910017132759094, -0.008120186626911163, -0.026945894584059715, 0.02945476956665516, 0.024885527789592743, 0.0017839233623817563, -0.08982104808092117, 0.043665096163749695, 0.013012082315981388, -0.022105541080236435, -0.00589268421754241, -0.013288743793964386, -0.05463440716266632, 0.009266780689358711, -0.03130457550287247, 0.039107028394937515, -0.0005656027351506054, -0.0061180912889540195, 0.007679200731217861, 0.024485891684889793, 0.0018313934560865164, -0.03289129585027695, 0.05259326845407486, 0.01141380611807108, -0.033234067261219025, 0.01573469489812851, 0.04332941398024559, -0.03330906853079796, -0.042992591857910156, 0.0011275160359218717, -0.019182683899998665, -0.021004434674978256, 0.023476464673876762, -0.023939399048686028, -0.007202674634754658, 0.01472968515008688, -0.0234169140458107, 0.006213314365595579, -0.03459326550364494, -0.024405529722571373, 0.023986268788576126, -0.009334863163530827, -0.02891012653708458, 0.0063102468848228455, 0.0340581014752388, -0.025638170540332794, 0.05973947048187256, -0.009972798638045788, -0.018200306221842766, -0.03350524976849556, 0.00019756109395530075, -0.04318416863679886, -0.06170273944735527, -0.0006293370388448238, -0.07737772166728973, -0.013132017105817795, 0.003718261606991291, 0.018275363370776176, 0.010164428502321243, 0.03173724561929703, 0.05604896694421768, 0.020058386027812958, -0.019298650324344635, 0.04058343544602394, 0.03848998248577118, -0.07199827581644058, 0.04744978994131088, -0.06661488115787506, 0.008230097591876984, 0.05586374178528786, -0.004980049096047878, -0.0333256870508194, 0.019036537036299706, -0.06567000597715378, 0.004230564460158348, -0.048435281962156296, -0.07614202797412872, -0.019445331767201424, -0.05169334635138512, 0.043767113238573074, 0.014895402826368809, 0.02466776967048645, 0.01797855645418167, -0.02445397898554802, 0.03303466737270355, -0.005916227586567402, -0.0017195009859278798, -0.016654862090945244, -0.043962713330984116, -0.010940763168036938, 0.03670592978596687, -0.009199211373925209, -0.01836119033396244, 0.01891993172466755, 0.07204832136631012, -0.015528419986367226, 0.0017950511537492275, -0.04755263030529022, 0.04733142629265785, -0.06463147699832916, -0.050246961414813995, -0.044149287045001984, 0.0060860710218548775, -0.017121680080890656, -0.014794174581766129, 0.007884794846177101, -0.019453007727861404, 0.02432578057050705, -0.006095293443650007, 0.07184871286153793, 0.014667188748717308, -0.00131981389131397, -0.002756974659860134, 0.01806984655559063, 0.0765838548541069, 0.045333582907915115, -0.004012248013168573, 0.021153805777430534, -0.007944855839014053, -0.02104601450264454, -0.04920921102166176, 0.06780901551246643, 0.004087579902261496, -0.01720975525677204, 0.08710446208715439, 0.02871599607169628, 0.03541700169444084, 0.08072590082883835, 0.0031440353486686945, -0.002879824722185731, 0.004644058644771576, -0.02588805928826332, 0.05543980002403259, 0.02057461440563202, -0.02281890995800495, -0.01395483873784542, -0.07347302883863449, 0.018871860578656197, 0.04573385417461395, 0.03394085541367531, 0.07078304141759872, 0.00028749380726367235, -0.004161416552960873, -0.00042045130976475775, -0.0286337248980999, 0.011569558642804623, 0.03453820198774338, -0.013463237322866917, -0.027194272726774216, -0.0008693651761859655, 0.007626972161233425, -0.02263791114091873, -0.026192154735326767, -0.014950226061046124, -0.025411002337932587, -0.011167843826115131, -0.029957560822367668, -0.08404552936553955, 0.003803067374974489, -0.04208163172006607, -0.01672232709825039, -0.006210362073034048, -0.07166251540184021, -0.021891407668590546, -0.01370940264314413, -0.042518798261880875, 0.02563847415149212, 0.028546495363116264, 0.008935113437473774, 0.015079738572239876, 0.03967561945319176, -0.015310335904359818, -0.03249155730009079, 0.028887126594781876, -0.03918345645070076, -0.03788891062140465, -0.05790649726986885, -0.0018164025386795402, -0.032316844910383224, 0.08156954497098923, -0.012908348813652992, -0.03484337031841278, -0.02873125672340393, 0.04390313848853111, -0.025122640654444695, -0.021860415115952492, -0.03413327410817146, 0.01979084685444832, -0.03147195279598236, 0.05069408193230629, -0.010149914771318436, -0.008780197240412235, 0.0015829259064048529, -0.03290242701768875, -0.03936024755239487, -0.02403244376182556, 0.013736451976001263, 0.027540108188986778, 0.023334989324212074, 0.03936215490102768, -0.011455765925347805, -0.02983546070754528, -0.01562365423887968, -0.060988835990428925, 0.04670913517475128, 0.018860312178730965, -0.054048895835876465, 0.012937992811203003, 0.029523637145757675, 0.056446898728609085, 0.01840893365442753, 0.026486417278647423, 0.0022428787779062986, -0.07337969541549683, 0.0038830237463116646, -0.00944480113685131, 0.03126905858516693, 0.026388419792056084, -0.0003776723751798272, -0.07151283323764801, -0.04175695404410362, 0.010444951243698597, -0.04430535435676575, -0.054115165024995804, -0.019222324714064598, -0.03666379675269127, 0.031399525701999664, 0.02339581400156021, 0.051637858152389526, -0.03657925873994827, -0.002901738742366433, -0.021800953894853592, 0.06214379146695137, 0.017981790006160736, -0.012993012554943562, -0.0440608412027359, -0.0283881314098835, -0.020256469026207924, -0.05602804943919182, -0.06123640015721321, -0.024370567873120308, -0.008838018402457237, -0.09103091061115265, -0.023578882217407227, -0.018873369321227074, -0.05189993232488632, -0.050672825425863266, -0.021116528660058975, -0.015152049250900745, 0.005424997303634882, -0.060751236975193024, 0.04284094646573067, -0.02674776315689087, -0.008963442407548428, 0.027415459975600243, 0.0036967569030821323, 0.002674537245184183, -0.009114581160247326, -0.024065304547548294, -0.024603020399808884, 0.001903295866213739, 0.004581274930387735, 0.010187902487814426, -0.06458623707294464, 0.008724864572286606, -0.0022071802522987127, 0.004131249617785215, -0.046693675220012665, -0.020289186388254166, -0.033405840396881104, -0.01272108405828476, 0.05032214894890785, 0.04247727617621422, -0.040121451020240784, 0.04247664660215378, 0.05592608079314232, -0.03186176344752312, 0.019655488431453705, 0.03523915633559227, 0.0014058825327083468, 0.0160592682659626, -0.021984633058309555, 0.06087486445903778, 0.022809350863099098, -0.03398745507001877, -0.008722856640815735, -0.0011641929158940911, 0.02873704768717289, -0.053003162145614624, -0.05189914628863335, 0.03173111379146576, 0.011361359618604183, -0.0015445563476532698, 0.10882289707660675, 0.0014648570213466883, -0.04162900894880295, 0.037095293402671814, 0.026845009997487068, -0.017155306413769722, 0.03447025269269943, 0.013729826547205448, -0.007642866112291813, -0.022009817883372307, -0.04383917525410652, 0.01819101721048355, -0.0022112326696515083, -0.030031468719244003, 0.038510750979185104, -0.03349612280726433, -0.06177462637424469, 0.10096915811300278, -0.03605683520436287, 0.03573301061987877, 0.01723085716366768, 0.012671196833252907, -0.03433888778090477, 0.006336398888379335, 0.07582017034292221, -0.026041191071271896, -0.07704578340053558, 0.00929316971451044, -0.07017400860786438, 0.0421280674636364, -0.004576209932565689, 0.057009242475032806, 0.03368338197469711, -0.08751422166824341, 0.017836596816778183, 0.0010245915036648512, -0.02155929058790207, 0.05192546918988228, -0.038468845188617706, -0.010337616316974163, 0.02158578485250473, -0.012983240187168121, 0.007476520258933306, -0.03925088420510292, 0.09330051392316818, 0.01880200020968914, -0.07190466672182083, 0.03351851552724838, 0.014677220955491066, -0.0019381812307983637, -0.06490462273359299, -0.049363236874341965, 0.015950236469507217, -0.06653933972120285, -0.009279191493988037, -0.042309049516916275, -0.03743394836783409, 0.015055188909173012, 0.11111791431903839, -0.05382320657372475, -0.060110609978437424, -0.0019080708734691143, -0.017227454110980034, -0.023448050022125244, 0.0600823275744915, 0.026721594855189323, 0.04657760262489319, 0.06068217754364014, 0.01702563837170601, 0.026825055480003357, -0.039248090237379074, -0.018292445689439774, 0.03847145289182663, 0.02655869722366333, -0.036457035690546036, 0.0004328494251240045, -0.012185227125883102, 0.031436774879693985, 0.08707636594772339, 0.04801667854189873, 0.013167067430913448, 0.010595208965241909, -0.0022824762854725122, -0.03549068421125412, 0.0015774464700371027, 0.003880310570821166, 0.049871768802404404, 0.019227230921387672, -0.06471578776836395, 0.07905483990907669, -0.026503577828407288, 0.043777063488960266, 0.024556633085012436, -0.025357862934470177, 0.0007620018441230059, -0.023439547047019005, 0.013643368147313595, -0.016173940151929855, 0.00972213689237833, 0.013199270702898502, -0.0031077393796294928, 0.03543306887149811, -0.03836881369352341, 0.002983470680192113, -0.03562070056796074, 0.014270536601543427, -0.0299349557608366, 0.02815910056233406, 0.03055059351027012, 0.018157508224248886, 0.02088109776377678, 0.024787092581391335, -0.018270278349518776, -0.03258799389004707, -0.03365538641810417, 0.01199328899383545, -0.013131744228303432, -0.01691719889640808, 0.05878956988453865, -0.01141069084405899, -0.06641890108585358, 0.04374931752681732, 0.03509967774152756, -0.017251264303922653, -0.04582542926073074, -0.005713967606425285, -0.006241762079298496, -0.04172905534505844, -0.0063216849230229855, 0.008426876738667488, -0.0358549989759922, -0.028190115466713905, -0.057314977049827576, -0.051745474338531494, 0.045219581574201584, -0.05135910212993622, -0.029188377782702446, 0.02187182940542698, -0.024360056966543198, -0.016051514074206352, -0.010467315092682838, 0.005171297583729029, 0.06787867844104767, -0.06783019006252289, 0.008589011617004871, -0.0021219111513346434, 0.012046553194522858, -0.014625158160924911, -0.039634913206100464, -0.05359106883406639, -0.02420756220817566, -0.0658821314573288, -0.03462742269039154, 0.03470923751592636, -0.022205328568816185, 0.06707672029733658, 0.007009579334408045, 0.025388697162270546, -0.0017890511080622673, -0.008219276554882526, 0.021415119990706444, 0.037138812243938446, -0.01274956576526165, 0.02387644723057747, -0.09381517767906189, -0.026314005255699158, -0.010098753497004509, -0.04209433123469353, -0.05089380964636803, -0.033082105219364166, 0.05334196984767914, -0.05203142762184143, 0.02537781000137329, 0.08184753358364105, -0.009363580495119095, 0.03157133609056473, -0.04889364540576935, 0.00086026027565822, -0.006850136909633875, -0.0294052604585886, 0.026685670018196106, -0.024216489866375923, -0.012826209887862206, -0.04970549792051315, -0.05616345256567001, 0.018252987414598465, 0.02417176589369774, 0.00306353229098022, 0.00645854976028204, 0.046080082654953, -0.0036454307846724987, 0.01639874279499054, 0.03707433119416237, -0.03232615068554878, 0.009063047356903553, -0.03490859642624855, -0.002395760966464877, 0.015345008112490177, 0.031473930925130844, 0.025298945605754852, -0.03710351884365082, -0.00428563030436635, 0.04885990545153618, -0.04732869192957878, 0.0005551709327846766, -0.033052846789360046, -0.012661846354603767, -0.0011392798041924834, -0.06034597381949425, 0.018415294587612152, -0.030647460371255875, 0.07128477841615677, 0.006872965022921562, -0.041975803673267365, 0.021641599014401436, -0.036999911069869995, 0.047746140509843826, 0.035364143550395966, 0.028128942474722862, -0.003426985116675496, -0.007452910766005516, 0.00008067537419265136, 0.008871829137206078, 0.01821873150765896, -0.02909885346889496, -0.03681882843375206, -0.01198576483875513, 0.038024406880140305, 0.08193310350179672, 0.05543147027492523, 0.02482636459171772, 0.013416193425655365, -0.009487169794738293, -0.054741863161325455, 0.030673310160636902, -0.028637569397687912, -0.017383262515068054, 0.025522517040371895, 0.00793566182255745, -0.016537189483642578, -0.009421775117516518, -0.02890603058040142, 0.0729452520608902, -0.021258682012557983 ]
<p>Consider the following scenario: On earth, I pulse a laser focused at a far away mirror such that the time it takes for the light to reflect off the mirror and arrive back at me is at least a few seconds. Immediately after the laser pulse, I place a second mirror where the reflected beam will arrive. In the photon's frame, it would appear that the universe is moving around passed the photon at the speed of light. Furthermore, time on the moving universe would be infinitely dilated. Thus, the photon would never see the second mirror being raised. So how does it reflect off of it?</p> <hr> <p>EDIT: To be clear, I don't think moving frame velocity being equal to the speed of light here is necessary. I've written a similar example to my question below:</p> <p>Consider an electron accelerated to 0.9c and then released in some arbitrary direction. After some amount of time, let the electron encounter an infinitely strong potential such that it reflects back to its release point. Meanwhile, an experimentalist calculates when they expect the electron to arrive and turns on an electric field right before it arrives that will curve the electron's trajectory so that it collides into a detector. In the electron's frame, the universe's time is dilated so that it never sees the electric field being turned on. Thus, how does it interact with the field and get detected?</p>
g1677
[ 0.05716512352228165, 0.017509259283542633, 0.020203834399580956, 0.011890367604792118, 0.06355893611907959, 0.0056266020983457565, 0.028080103918910027, 0.06283974647521973, -0.008885614573955536, -0.0328957661986351, -0.013345434330403805, 0.0388469360768795, 0.04268588498234749, 0.011997921392321587, -0.01651272177696228, -0.03275608271360397, 0.1432901918888092, 0.022328056395053864, 0.01480033528059721, 0.0475585050880909, -0.03779803588986397, 0.011697255074977875, -0.008821530267596245, -0.05973466485738754, -0.018602831289172173, -0.02494225464761257, 0.04212932288646698, 0.007060213480144739, -0.01103655993938446, -0.04988812282681465, -0.022751566022634506, -0.03677746281027794, -0.016187671571969986, -0.04079936072230339, 0.03348780423402786, -0.04923734441399574, -0.0003586917882785201, 0.01090500969439745, 0.007777935825288296, -0.012823116034269333, -0.013488170690834522, -0.006451630499213934, -0.016846727579832077, -0.004163655918091536, 0.06588495522737503, 0.021717404946684837, 0.013446994125843048, 0.013244098983705044, 0.03174927458167076, -0.019678745418787003, -0.03768547996878624, 0.010232350789010525, -0.023570552468299866, 0.0004962365492247045, 0.07170457392930984, 0.0157071091234684, -0.01339178066700697, -0.0010006176307797432, 0.03621680289506912, -0.04474979639053345, 0.018292220309376717, -0.06762777268886566, 0.020122310146689415, 0.0100545734167099, 0.03383607417345047, 0.013964538462460041, -0.08252692222595215, 0.015184927731752396, -0.01210191659629345, -0.0029319857712835073, -0.025766097009181976, 0.008150060661137104, -0.07446169853210449, -0.05883237347006798, 0.021120980381965637, -0.02875233069062233, 0.02907770872116089, -0.0720868781208992, 0.0012097111903131008, 0.06014883890748024, -0.06646601855754852, 0.028893187642097473, -0.0044954996556043625, -0.015302510000765324, -0.008129801601171494, -0.010426382534205914, 0.007140239235013723, 0.046894561499357224, -0.023549269884824753, -0.018465472385287285, 0.048279233276844025, 0.00012320397945586592, 0.08021862059831619, 0.01715913787484169, -0.026832465082406998, -0.01764235459268093, -0.035301852971315384, 0.045398760586977005, 0.024434586986899376, 0.007059128489345312, -0.03137493133544922, -0.019382495433092117, 0.002340684412047267, 0.0194901954382658, 0.02334684319794178, -0.012247944250702858, -0.023421868681907654, 0.0162294190376997, -0.02053234912455082, -0.07163729518651962, -0.05844806507229805, -0.09917019307613373, -0.0401371531188488, -0.05185352638363838, -0.05147136002779007, -0.042636387050151825, 0.03836087882518768, 0.045118771493434906, -0.02101321890950203, 0.06203967332839966, 0.032788779586553574, 0.0374014675617218, -0.022558754310011864, 0.025840837508440018, -0.019246673211455345, 0.015390109270811081, -0.018827181309461594, -0.002891075797379017, 0.02346496656537056, -0.005709041375666857, 0.0013194180792197585, 0.058906439691782, 0.008855869062244892, 0.03869897499680519, -0.05153250694274902, 0.027194563299417496, 0.030630651861429214, -0.015984170138835907, 0.0015192406717687845, 0.03658590093255043, 0.023671364411711693, -0.06107156351208687, -0.023544462397694588, -0.01725037582218647, -0.01370879728347063, 0.03219440579414368, -0.03144283592700958, -0.007831321097910404, 0.050481267273426056, -0.03275865688920021, -0.0480228066444397, 0.06284207105636597, 0.0000311036710627377, -0.023560013622045517, 0.05200083181262016, -0.03046412393450737, 0.05280099809169769, -0.024310972541570663, -0.006379690952599049, -0.011706002987921238, 0.09386163204908371, -0.038900624960660934, -0.02479245513677597, -0.04074008762836456, -0.06547762453556061, -0.010773186571896076, 0.028599388897418976, -0.06384769082069397, 0.05369548499584198, -0.03666584566235542, -0.0037730084732174873, -0.016276879236102104, 0.016577091068029404, 0.014337120577692986, -0.009939538314938545, 0.06724543124437332, -0.011506234295666218, -0.0411539152264595, -0.055375613272190094, 0.02726396545767784, -0.04624604433774948, -0.09344054758548737, 0.019494052976369858, 0.005127103999257088, -0.001011021202430129, -0.063161201775074, -0.021503766998648643, 0.002373210620135069, -0.031958479434251785, -0.016826169565320015, -0.008099851198494434, -0.08265075832605362, -0.01660117879509926, -0.003949015401303768, -0.06076124310493469, 0.009676015004515648, 0.02217538096010685, -0.06558284908533096, -0.07103490829467773, -0.023252936080098152, -0.02559347078204155, 0.08202914148569107, -0.002923025516793132, 0.024092670530080795, 0.02573012001812458, 0.012754925526678562, -0.025509227067232132, -0.0009067623177543283, -0.04453541338443756, 0.00018425496818963438, 0.0910637304186821, 0.007835335098206997, -0.027800776064395905, 0.0331009104847908, -0.010321589186787605, -0.01148738618940115, -0.058131106197834015, 0.01312627550214529, -0.013325249776244164, 0.04786563664674759, -0.016090353950858116, 0.009530974552035332, 0.03532828018069267, -0.052878424525260925, -0.017336895689368248, -0.0307332631200552, -0.07020212709903717, 0.0005743208457715809, 0.0034410725347697735, 0.05898032337427139, -0.04151158779859543, 0.03859703242778778, -0.04892436042428017, -0.021067770197987556, 0.0548955462872982, 0.008107904344797134, -0.024248799309134483, 0.04009266570210457, 0.026954708620905876, -0.0058904788456857204, 0.014519711025059223, -0.007295465562492609, -0.02365810237824917, -0.004098059143871069, 0.03338804095983505, -0.0643240287899971, 0.03859284520149231, -0.0016343847382813692, -0.011333538219332695, 0.0038077651988714933, 0.014807591214776039, 0.0016662288689985871, -0.022103453055024147, -0.021706800907850266, -0.008848458528518677, -0.07407304644584656, -0.012646455317735672, 0.028125235810875893, -0.08592767268419266, -0.05772847309708595, 0.011278861202299595, -0.014022167772054672, 0.0012389178154990077, 0.023397766053676605, -0.005304127465933561, -0.01785738579928875, -0.021287932991981506, 0.03343989700078964, -0.027563808485865593, -0.008004788309335709, -0.014011829160153866, 0.023056669160723686, 0.03953096643090248, -0.04162211716175079, 0.03921883553266525, 0.005868488922715187, 0.009048792533576488, -0.08883845806121826, 0.0781768336892128, -0.026094088330864906, -0.059385042637586594, -0.05587692931294441, -0.038987401872873306, -0.039374738931655884, 0.03348039835691452, -0.07903841882944107, 0.002012921730056405, 0.051205720752477646, 0.03032112680375576, 0.0028141785878688097, -0.04516476020216942, 0.054696157574653625, 0.022648749873042107, 0.010778763331472874, -0.010766247287392616, 0.055669624358415604, 0.03035619854927063, -0.0016560460207983851, -0.040332719683647156, 0.02409755066037178, 0.028911488130688667, -0.052074138075113297, -0.0019857429433614016, 0.009442384354770184, 0.02576807327568531, -0.029715241864323616, -0.04220138490200043, -0.01772869937121868, 0.015526801347732544, 0.011676243506371975, 0.01136950496584177, 0.04411669820547104, 0.01042723935097456, -0.011396868154406548, -0.03423386812210083, -0.0005646710051223636, 0.0025258748792111874, 0.024885298684239388, 0.07831821590662003, 0.09795327484607697, 0.01650712452828884, 0.0035760123282670975, -0.01964111253619194, -0.004018688574433327, 0.03918127715587616, 0.017368467524647713, 0.0007397400913760066, 0.027121659368276596, -0.03619964048266411, 0.011080857366323471, -0.0113986786454916, 0.01655419170856476, -0.0222794096916914, -0.02982654981315136, -0.027256598696112633, 0.010948083363473415, -0.03401460126042366, 0.038950998336076736, 0.05876950919628143, 0.002755096647888422, 0.025545457378029823, 0.0011314646108075976, -0.048312049359083176, 0.010972720570862293, 0.05740315467119217, -0.031199146062135696, 0.01581747829914093, -0.016214240342378616, -0.037976108491420746, -0.06500080227851868, 0.03495000675320625, -0.040630701929330826, -0.02491491287946701, -0.03531321883201599, -0.0175724346190691, 0.029099663719534874, 0.009992094710469246, 0.01253389660269022, 0.008172945119440556, -0.050046809017658234, -0.022235402837395668, -0.0013959723291918635, -0.0030884630978107452, 0.00999191403388977, 0.014693468809127808, -0.003753286087885499, -0.014516000635921955, 0.03601624816656113, 0.03986310586333275, 0.0431051030755043, 0.01509954035282135, -0.047249164432287216, -0.04886710271239281, 0.05783303827047348, 0.003607857972383499, -0.03848424181342125, 0.04157927259802818, -0.030361589044332504, -0.027701476588845253, 0.024795325472950935, 0.0017634296091273427, 0.019217610359191895, 0.008671507239341736, -0.007737304549664259, 0.03925129771232605, 0.01779300905764103, -0.012439463287591934, -0.023288890719413757, 0.002978093922138214, 0.007889833301305771, 0.0716056078672409, -0.005121171474456787, 0.020699121057987213, 0.014490043744444847, 0.013645912520587444, -0.01947629451751709, 0.039299383759498596, -0.0019759885035455227, -0.002043964806944132, -0.04616926237940788, 0.055679019540548325, 0.06361585855484009, -0.028279321268200874, -0.0364527590572834, -0.04811558127403259, -0.01530096773058176, 0.04325704276561737, -0.045536961406469345, 0.00021779877715744078, -0.021207574754953384, -0.0508471317589283, 0.018794206902384758, -0.03804786875844002, -0.04100700467824936, 0.012584593147039413, 0.008065903559327126, 0.02443869039416313, -0.03386760503053665, -0.01491124089807272, 0.0005699208122678101, -0.028878740966320038, 0.015617790631949902, 0.05566990748047829, 0.010472025722265244, -0.021746359765529633, 0.06847705692052841, 0.04779578000307083, 0.04131811112165451, 0.014889311045408249, -0.03590046986937523, 0.04777183011174202, 0.03630876541137695, -0.0015081340679898858, 0.0969616249203682, -0.015461581759154797, 0.0649385079741478, 0.03326254338026047, 0.025268100202083588, 0.044795941561460495, 0.09301949292421341, 0.09252718091011047, -0.03368210420012474, 0.016460513696074486, 0.015461290255188942, -0.05834801495075226, 0.09794994443655014, -0.08568444848060608, -0.06186326965689659, -0.022825760766863823, -0.0662386417388916, -0.05213123559951782, 0.039739448577165604, -0.04543488845229149, 0.006396383047103882, -0.029210176318883896, -0.03853679448366165, 0.0018371660262346268, 0.0397370345890522, 0.013586919754743576, -0.0008729533874429762, -0.03245849907398224, -0.004032712429761887, -0.00515781668946147, -0.005067742895334959, -0.0069338483735919, -0.0035599838010966778, -0.020390478894114494, -0.010564381256699562, -0.08438084274530411, -0.008129348047077656, -0.020829597488045692, 0.008713196031749249, 0.0121469646692276, 0.047041554003953934, -0.008956266567111015, 0.01330836396664381, -0.008955259807407856, 0.0009582203347235918, 0.009238550439476967, 0.016096046194434166, -0.030096080154180527, -0.038583315908908844, 0.041620515286922455, 0.025476645678281784, -0.016925321891903877, -0.02968701720237732, -0.029533378779888153, 0.03464946523308754, -0.03606173396110535, -0.04099560156464577, -0.016461484134197235, -0.015145231038331985, -0.004167063627392054, -0.0466063916683197, -0.03323076665401459, 0.052564021199941635, 0.04050862044095993, 0.02004428207874298, 0.03378365933895111, 0.03523522987961769, -0.018114546313881874, -0.009366726502776146, -0.008306866511702538, -0.006013659294694662, -0.0569862462580204, 0.00909552164375782, 0.0293701384216547, 0.0066019403748214245, 0.00018091096717398614, 0.04278584197163582, 0.010212169960141182, 0.007150169927626848, -0.004846802446991205, 0.023875446990132332, 0.030645618215203285, -0.07469341158866882, 0.002041198778897524, -0.03563594073057175, 0.007129216566681862, -0.04263436794281006, -0.005718315485864878, 0.02596331760287285, 0.025356890633702278, -0.0175464004278183, 0.06380856037139893, -0.023475108668208122, -0.020046714693307877, 0.006854522041976452, 0.020665433257818222, 0.005706241820007563, 0.04996088892221451, 0.020975247025489807, 0.006604833994060755, 0.01876845583319664, 0.04800034686923027, -0.04144509881734848, 0.054901476949453354, 0.015524077229201794, 0.028749380260705948, -0.021543921902775764, -0.06535356491804123, 0.014420544728636742, 0.033352915197610855, 0.05509911850094795, 0.03837483003735542, -0.03277288004755974, 0.018894191831350327, 0.0012631980935111642, 0.0781269520521164, -0.03471021354198456, -0.01598835550248623, -0.004426171537488699, 0.016157623380422592, -0.007664354983717203, -0.006326158996671438, 0.03219609335064888, 0.03355083242058754, -0.01691628247499466, -0.0455462783575058, -0.05116187408566475, 0.06954709440469742, 0.024590851739048958, 0.02445410005748272, -0.036215078085660934, 0.015989340841770172, -0.012001820839941502, 0.02819858305156231, -0.010882839560508728, 0.049144089221954346, 0.009754125028848648, 0.015064527280628681, -0.0012255236506462097, 0.0019382517784833908, -0.06218703091144562, -0.01023541297763586, 0.03691966459155083, -0.059777140617370605, -0.023003578186035156, -0.09432539343833923, -0.012318073771893978, 0.008459426462650299, 0.017135657370090485, 0.05378897488117218, -0.007421474438160658, 0.05064016580581665, 0.017795661464333534, -0.00046661184751428664, -0.0387965627014637, 0.09928689152002335, -0.006410693284124136, -0.03903593868017197, -0.0482177808880806, 0.043002884835004807, -0.06311951577663422, -0.0601787306368351, -0.04748266935348511, -0.010908972471952438, -0.011747387237846851, -0.054967865347862244, 0.07409415394067764, -0.002027791226282716, -0.029907485470175743, 0.05781286209821701, -0.00887459609657526, 0.03254171460866928, 0.003770941635593772, -0.04473229870200157, -0.005552386399358511, 0.0801795944571495, 0.026342978700995445, 0.0027658541221171618, -0.017024947330355644, 0.005052895750850439, 0.05716978758573532, -0.043347474187612534, -0.006239140406250954, -0.011223090812563896, -0.016516419127583504, 0.001936296932399273, 0.01856672577559948, 0.01917005144059658, -0.057448167353868484, 0.02357720211148262, -0.02218025177717209, 0.0004235939122736454, 0.014867674559354782, -0.06652718037366867, 0.006045322399586439, 0.06083029508590698, 0.014407838694751263, 0.05795309692621231, 0.011828901246190071, 0.0217669066041708, 0.07412412017583847, 0.0630452111363411, 0.06875915825366974, -0.028207262977957726, 0.06447961181402206, -0.02078239805996418, -0.020103314891457558, 0.007831103168427944, 0.02949448861181736, 0.009233318269252777, 0.020943760871887207, -0.03307046368718147, 0.021689604967832565, -0.02939596399664879, -0.006047493312507868, -0.0376141183078289, 0.02390536479651928, -0.01906048320233822, -0.047013167291879654, -0.004625700879842043, 0.04109760373830795, -0.02365078032016754, -0.011139401234686375, -0.03258863463997841, 0.009208166971802711, -0.007663226220756769, -0.06399966776371002, -0.018089361488819122, -0.05478566884994507, -0.06477610766887665, -0.023341068997979164, 0.03444400429725647, -0.0063209086656570435, -0.05132421478629112, -0.06840170174837112, -0.0022969155106693506, 0.012858751229941845, 0.008893966674804688, -0.03405630961060524, -0.0434165820479393, 0.027193643152713776, 0.04811607673764229, -0.026643481105566025, -0.02065005898475647, 0.03419210761785507, -0.0048832157626748085, 0.01745748519897461, -0.010668822564184666, 0.06155828759074211, 0.017716091126203537, -0.01835308037698269, 0.0008757051546126604, 0.04169986769556999, -0.002364987274631858, 0.011577708646655083, 0.0028313600923866034, -0.06439446657896042, 0.003944622818380594, 0.027945034205913544, 0.003962191287428141, -0.007502810563892126, -0.01951729506254196, 0.028258495032787323, 0.04240070655941963, -0.020257873460650444, 0.03312133997678757, 0.014963864348828793, -0.05515015870332718, 0.006843621376901865, 0.04369489476084709, 0.021698595955967903, 0.052104756236076355, -0.017654282972216606, 0.0030159344896674156, -0.041996635496616364, 0.01743008941411972, 0.016641510650515556, 0.029264623299241066, 0.05316359922289848, -0.0007836348959244788, 0.029708290472626686, 0.0038185021840035915, -0.024485457688570023, -0.014190089888870716, 0.06886870414018631, 0.04002691060304642, 0.015812290832400322, 0.006125194951891899, 0.016772830858826637, 0.012366894632577896, -0.020490456372499466, 0.040022701025009155, -0.015691205859184265, -0.010601907968521118, 0.00702267000451684, 0.003290297696366906, -0.024171914905309677, -0.0025279424153268337, 0.03486596792936325, -0.04278282821178436, -0.005007650703191757, -0.04503786563873291, 0.01844952255487442, -0.0035769741516560316, -0.03342818096280098, -0.021390603855252266, 0.00151465751696378, -0.015566574409604073, -0.0980655699968338, -0.013073827140033245, 0.018960144370794296, 0.011379308067262173, -0.03417591005563736, 0.012584767304360867, 0.013297499157488346, 0.02396334707736969, -0.0076617528684437275, 0.04077015072107315, 0.053795889019966125, -0.024723036214709282, 0.03438013419508934, 0.10882124304771423, -0.013500753790140152, -0.012017358094453812, 0.0120082451030612, -0.0007298517157323658, 0.006195236928761005, -0.0005388331483118236, -0.026547903195023537, -0.01754995435476303, -0.015173723921179771, 0.011269246228039265, -0.06505822390317917, -0.0322907529771328, 0.0023461240343749523 ]
<p>A few months ago <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/q/78442/25794">I asked about phonons</a>. I got some very good answers but I still have difficulty getting an intuition for phonons, while somehow photons, which in many ways are similar and which I realize I hardly understand anything about, seem more accessible to intuition.</p> <p>In <a href="http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/18564/25794">Ron Maimon's answer</a> to the question "What exactly is a quantum of light?" he asserts that </p> <blockquote> <p>A quantum of light of wavelength λ is the minimum amount of energy which can be stored in an electromagnetic wave at that wavelength</p> </blockquote> <p>and </p> <blockquote> <p>the classical wave is a superposition of a large number of photons</p> </blockquote> <p>Translating this to vibrations in a crystal lattice, could we say that a phonon is the minimal amount of energy which can be stored in an lattice vibration in a given mode and that a classical vibration is a superposition of a large number of phonons?</p> <p>I hope I am correct when I say that the electromagnetic field can interact with matter through the absorption of a photon, and it is this interaction that makes the photon into something particle-like. Do we have the same for phonon-interactions? I.e. that when a crystal vibration interacts with matter it does so by the creation/destruction of whole phonons at a time, which may also get absorbed at more or less precise locations, e.g. the energy of a single phonon is absorbed by a localized electron. </p> <p>Finally I would like to understand how phonon exchange can effectively establish an attractive force between electrons, but I cannot say I have any intuition for how photons mediate the electromagnetic force either. I am afraid that for the moment this is beyond the scope of my background.</p>
g1678
[ 0.05180663615465164, 0.04579003527760506, 0.012166041880846024, -0.025264190509915352, 0.042692869901657104, -0.044869255274534225, 0.0208273995667696, -0.005104913841933012, -0.001573974615894258, -0.02683407813310623, -0.018596986308693886, 0.002509102923795581, -0.044169072061777115, -0.0014955786755308509, -0.035647254437208176, 0.02381477691233158, 0.11024542152881622, -0.015603529289364815, 0.04421139508485794, 0.07685218751430511, -0.05338991433382034, -0.0022302709985524416, -0.016198068857192993, -0.06246340647339821, -0.01337113045156002, 0.05393609032034874, 0.030499359592795372, -0.031168755143880844, 0.034420426934957504, -0.06085263565182686, -0.002661054255440831, -0.060010023415088654, 0.05084886774420738, -0.00032223190646618605, -0.016430126503109932, -0.05666104331612587, 0.03621748089790344, 0.0070287808775901794, 0.033565349876880646, 0.015344695188105106, 0.024078043177723885, 0.006743233185261488, -0.0032054693438112736, -0.005165521986782551, 0.015270637348294258, 0.0010824439814314246, -0.023940639570355415, -0.034907229244709015, -0.02617424912750721, 0.002856926526874304, 0.04923618584871292, 0.005311439745128155, 0.03862179443240166, 0.06366000324487686, 0.017970258370041847, -0.0005095041124150157, 0.05406694859266281, -0.017891181632876396, 0.09450104087591171, 0.0047657978720963, 0.006929125636816025, 0.023153815418481827, 0.03731143847107887, 0.06403018534183502, 0.035613540560007095, 0.028039345517754555, -0.02969973348081112, -0.04160496965050697, 0.031989794224500656, -0.04810232296586037, -0.026800958439707756, -0.04069432243704796, -0.04259456321597099, 0.015577330254018307, -0.017753703519701958, -0.001538940821774304, -0.009133519604802132, 0.0057228789664804935, 0.008062563836574554, -0.0049967956729233265, 0.013718503527343273, 0.017008863389492035, 0.022561686113476753, -0.03302262723445892, 0.043796200305223465, -0.00820955354720354, -0.025744760408997536, -0.03711898997426033, -0.017975717782974243, 0.01754869520664215, 0.034529440104961395, -0.0030370098538696766, 0.07462537288665771, -0.033398546278476715, -0.024859482422471046, 0.042075373232364655, -0.005296511109918356, 0.044876579195261, -0.0074043069034814835, 0.007107252720743418, -0.02796313725411892, -0.061466749757528305, 0.020510733127593994, 0.008909771218895912, -0.028288640081882477, -0.016430726274847984, 0.00008421446545980871, -0.028487330302596092, -0.028762489557266235, 0.07317061722278595, -0.07752744108438492, 0.0030577578581869602, -0.02744738571345806, -0.029717307537794113, -0.04707646742463112, -0.019416769966483116, 0.0580693744122982, 0.05286417528986931, 0.03708057105541229, 0.08640966564416885, 0.037966080009937286, 0.06123729795217514, 0.009996548295021057, -0.023156289011240005, -0.0016926240641623735, -0.012781386263668537, 0.015282138250768185, -0.025760775431990623, -0.01576463133096695, -0.012795966118574142, 0.062410321086645126, 0.037860337644815445, -0.009483029134571552, -0.025886865332722664, 0.0247297715395689, 0.0501062385737896, 0.025715280324220657, -0.001433053519576788, 0.009899039752781391, -0.030712926760315895, 0.007257027551531792, -0.014182589016854763, -0.04064062610268593, -0.053515493869781494, -0.026790369302034378, 0.05239870026707649, -0.03399098664522171, -0.010108046233654022, -0.014556540176272392, 0.0692613273859024, 0.034037914127111435, 0.04803645610809326, 0.04471869394183159, -0.02887403592467308, 0.007324439473450184, -0.015740452334284782, 0.04798119142651558, -0.03140220418572426, -0.04245149716734886, 0.024658041074872017, 0.03287860378623009, 0.0013855471042916179, -0.017010454088449478, -0.04881007969379425, 0.017774265259504318, -0.024102315306663513, 0.0039176372811198235, -0.06118518114089966, 0.017945479601621628, 0.007739612367004156, -0.002406708663329482, -0.02088119648396969, -0.025205092504620552, 0.0876188799738884, -0.005298255477100611, 0.06811659038066864, 0.021203545853495598, -0.014029424637556076, -0.0031195254996418953, -0.029805729165673256, 0.01821223273873329, -0.026634592562913895, 0.009684063494205475, -0.022868813946843147, -0.014642152935266495, 0.02323314920067787, -0.0011965588200837374, -0.00922008603811264, -0.011599145829677582, 0.016940800473093987, -0.019825099036097527, -0.05271144583821297, 0.03981694206595421, 0.007468100171536207, -0.014965778216719627, -0.0217021182179451, -0.024032317101955414, 0.006848090328276157, -0.0579117052257061, -0.06261223554611206, -0.023641595616936684, 0.04412386938929558, 0.0169206652790308, -0.026223689317703247, 0.0918058529496193, 0.0456455759704113, -0.046589020639657974, -0.04264165833592415, -0.01160324178636074, 0.002794019877910614, 0.023565279319882393, -0.05309122055768967, -0.0005887231091037393, 0.0051723080687224865, 0.010938038118183613, 0.01588468626141548, -0.021628817543387413, -0.009839167818427086, 0.016223257407546043, 0.021772854030132294, -0.03669240325689316, -0.03164897859096527, 0.04493093118071556, 0.03892498090863228, -0.04141860082745552, -0.04393231123685837, -0.009509812109172344, 0.021400587633252144, 0.048001568764448166, 0.00048443867126479745, -0.06732197105884552, 0.06895796954631805, 0.02069767378270626, -0.04340311884880066, 0.045020945370197296, 0.032217804342508316, -0.07083394378423691, -0.03960288688540459, 0.028523342683911324, 0.016356825828552246, 0.05005722865462303, 0.0013277713442221284, -0.06503240019083023, -0.012017562985420227, -0.01785767637193203, -0.024939039722085, -0.033658623695373535, -0.015431876294314861, 0.008404459804296494, -0.0012258829083293676, 0.0839543491601944, -0.02934844419360161, -0.01602846570312977, -0.02541217766702175, 0.010768174193799496, -0.024828752502799034, 0.014751007780432701, 0.05596558749675751, -0.025615215301513672, -0.005612627603113651, 0.010234765708446503, -0.03373222425580025, -0.05960405245423317, 0.02561396360397339, -0.015388380736112595, -0.02149461954832077, -0.012885318137705326, 0.03389310836791992, -0.05357535183429718, -0.04702632874250412, -0.02097570337355137, 0.038482703268527985, 0.01657555252313614, -0.0464177243411541, 0.02965562790632248, 0.00698516983538866, 0.007060099858790636, -0.023769820109009743, 0.06066032499074936, -0.045827142894268036, -0.04056977853178978, -0.049283258616924286, -0.03413531556725502, -0.08892969787120819, -0.020504210144281387, -0.06749960780143738, -0.013714536093175411, -0.031083911657333374, 0.03920358046889305, -0.0048774234019219875, 0.009705010801553726, 0.0025132170412689447, -0.007832222618162632, 0.012935102917253971, -0.04914082959294319, 0.017480751499533653, -0.016963187605142593, 0.002484183991327882, -0.09874141961336136, 0.09337782859802246, 0.014897359535098076, -0.04022952541708946, 0.008982621133327484, -0.009540621191263199, -0.02525794878602028, 0.023120276629924774, -0.07206597179174423, -0.052434515208005905, -0.019636036828160286, 0.013198545202612877, -0.003668161341920495, 0.010122750885784626, 0.0037203750107437372, -0.03293600678443909, -0.06480132788419724, 0.022660093382000923, -0.006621395703405142, 0.014689905568957329, 0.006012436468154192, 0.00376807595603168, -0.04127488285303116, 0.04512638598680496, 0.08008324354887009, -0.08437228947877884, 0.0067489561624825, 0.034265901893377304, -0.034449949860572815, 0.023469693958759308, -0.04556438699364662, -0.02776772901415825, -0.00969715602695942, -0.12501175701618195, -0.03438807651400566, 0.0010488522239029408, -0.004232507664710283, -0.02157888375222683, -0.020174391567707062, -0.00857364572584629, 0.016334185376763344, 0.007384851109236479, 0.009729208424687386, -0.00017028888396453112, -0.04161027446389198, 0.029019426554441452, -0.03861664608120918, 0.037683527916669846, -0.052910417318344116, -0.037245023995637894, 0.0074543822556734085, -0.010369215160608292, 0.020451273769140244, -0.037142571061849594, -0.00525306724011898, 0.0008464648853987455, 0.0011856822529807687, 0.0034676501527428627, -0.00031744749867357314, 0.06900717318058014, 0.02656625397503376, -0.006233078893274069, 0.02262934297323227, -0.04286660626530647, 0.058218806982040405, -0.04707533121109009, -0.07009698450565338, -0.018966732546687126, -0.029402349144220352, -0.004085393622517586, 0.0144734475761652, 0.01875358074903488, 0.02688494510948658, -0.05230160057544708, -0.02275441214442253, 0.005689598619937897, 0.008561068214476109, -0.05703408643603325, 0.011585574597120285, -0.019048137590289116, 0.00903305597603321, 0.018576379865407944, -0.036693938076496124, 0.02784067764878273, 0.0393233560025692, 0.011397426016628742, 0.08604851365089417, -0.007057501468807459, -0.019149605184793472, 0.016069738194346428, -0.05252216383814812, -0.004391858819872141, -0.019169142469763756, -0.00836944580078125, -0.039579976350069046, -0.007734240964055061, 0.021777397021651268, -0.031871188431978226, 0.012222101911902428, -0.029563216492533684, 0.020983576774597168, 0.05181404575705528, 0.018705613911151886, 0.026736529543995857, 0.0020126174204051495, -0.03967674449086189, -0.003408794989809394, 0.039731211960315704, 0.028616148978471756, -0.048261333256959915, -0.023567646741867065, -0.0597430020570755, 0.00710361497476697, 0.04139929264783859, 0.011597149074077606, -0.05369456112384796, -0.05716002359986305, 0.04826326668262482, -0.04759399965405464, -0.054511480033397675, 0.06715194135904312, 0.014783110469579697, 0.002892130520194769, 0.03931222856044769, -0.04252171888947487, 0.004937665071338415, -0.01988513208925724, 0.0751008689403534, 0.07421769946813583, -0.06113480404019356, -0.005671375431120396, -0.03228965401649475, 0.045622408390045166, -0.0015640099300071597, 0.06603386998176575, 0.009922497905790806, -0.0023585602175444365, 0.018991783261299133, -0.0358741357922554, -0.013352260924875736, 0.061458609998226166, 0.02924150787293911, 0.07821853458881378, -0.006300889886915684, 0.005331838503479958, -0.004721511155366898, 0.037023719400167465, -0.01773088611662388, -0.0609787292778492, -0.028821144253015518, 0.004702595993876457, -0.018434938043355942, 0.037351083010435104, 0.023825936019420624, -0.05542481318116188, -0.059148866683244705, 0.009070772677659988, 0.029728302732110023, -0.014226478524506092, -0.01603318564593792, 0.03688618168234825, 0.02034902200102806, -0.011964403092861176, -0.0047348677180707455, 0.02271127514541149, 0.04753060266375542, 0.024274511262774467, 0.009605555795133114, -0.06294737756252289, 0.0002729855477809906, -0.04704864323139191, -0.03900507465004921, 0.015272083692252636, -0.023957401514053345, 0.04112957417964935, 0.0025280339177697897, 0.04047734662890434, -0.03663497418165207, -0.06508661806583405, -0.01872425712645054, 0.03831293061375618, -0.03733077272772789, 0.01745673082768917, 0.021101640537381172, 0.001994768390432, 0.02962893433868885, -0.04792192950844765, -0.0159145575016737, -0.007726913318037987, 0.028536172583699226, -0.03607191517949104, -0.006502464413642883, 0.00289384787902236, -0.05231579393148422, -0.02710939757525921, -0.049738842993974686, 0.0050492906011641026, 0.0028902494814246893, -0.021723872050642967, 0.017230691388249397, 0.022577110677957535, 0.02445298805832863, 0.03581104800105095, 0.03271456062793732, 0.0036278385668992996, -0.03980917111039162, -0.028569433838129044, -0.05188832804560661, 0.04825645685195923, 0.0072553725913167, -0.0808388963341713, 0.04729679599404335, 0.030894948169589043, -0.020156631246209145, -0.03538784012198448, 0.10719456523656845, -0.022167081013321877, -0.004991030786186457, 0.00023598190455231816, 0.017624590545892715, -0.0037605497054755688, -0.038118597120046616, -0.04694980010390282, 0.02621058188378811, -0.020801471546292305, -0.02846081182360649, 0.015852168202400208, 0.00935216061770916, -0.010916774161159992, -0.016057301312685013, 0.08239283412694931, 0.016330035403370857, 0.008681823499500751, 0.03689795359969139, 0.024572426453232765, 0.06838933378458023, 0.026740726083517075, -0.014521914534270763, 0.005501351319253445, -0.013478905893862247, -0.007080234587192535, 0.07399705052375793, 0.0018795582000166178, -0.055879246443510056, 0.007425940595567226, 0.030279716476798058, 0.07526958733797073, 0.052359096705913544, 0.07205438613891602, 0.013070338405668736, 0.04413261637091637, 0.022591758519411087, -0.017164362594485283, -0.014316486194729805, -0.030022211372852325, -0.03188765421509743, 0.0038355067372322083, 0.02467585913836956, 0.026903612539172173, -0.049517419189214706, 0.038155168294906616, -0.025307662785053253, 0.055967964231967926, 0.08362098783254623, -0.0075395540334284306, -0.0035808715038001537, 0.001983067486435175, 0.007095817010849714, -0.0001009535335469991, -0.05234874412417412, 0.01667456515133381, 0.015540114603936672, 0.01151374913752079, 0.06063207983970642, -0.024071481078863144, -0.0063421656377613544, 0.01884796842932701, 0.013955344446003437, -0.019743362441658974, -0.03488953784108162, -0.05580704286694527, 0.03913460671901703, 0.03626764938235283, -0.008927741087973118, -0.0066382805816829205, 0.0051052081398665905, 0.015037745237350464, 0.02450513280928135, 0.017964262515306473, 0.019613830372691154, 0.060213733464479446, -0.02348712459206581, 0.02289949730038643, -0.022565575316548347, -0.05254650115966797, -0.046064723283052444, 0.025937121361494064, -0.026384593918919563, 0.03694624826312065, -0.009706503711640835, -0.011707885190844536, 0.10638327151536942, 0.017850525677204132, -0.0019027963280677795, 0.03267833963036537, -0.01248836424201727, 0.034660544246435165, 0.02636595070362091, 0.006094618234783411, -0.003863575402647257, -0.04450830817222595, 0.012393700890243053, -0.04266214743256569, 0.02819446660578251, -0.015353351831436157, 0.03144208341836929, 0.029700923711061478, -0.07033392786979675, -0.00819574948400259, 0.008736460469663143, -0.022695904597640038, 0.0051725152879953384, -0.057849083095788956, -0.04318259283900261, -0.022244643419981003, -0.058615606278181076, -0.0146633917465806, 0.038226041942834854, -0.0730571523308754, 0.019481534138321877, 0.05810229480266571, 0.0014569390332326293, 0.019613826647400856, -0.009268028661608696, 0.02956121787428856, 0.0705704391002655, 0.015926359221339226, 0.02359999530017376, -0.01694359816610813, -0.03219073265790939, 0.023863522335886955, 0.0033269620034843683, 0.004541429225355387, 0.0015811687335371971, 0.04863959923386574, 0.04429614543914795, -0.048248156905174255, 0.02059003710746765, 0.0066228932701051235, -0.009630902670323849, -0.037408675998449326, 0.03408154472708702, -0.03287401795387268, -0.019199972972273827, -0.010004778392612934, -0.0004872287099715322, -0.008878872729837894, 0.0529775395989418, 0.0013883850770071149, 0.05170358717441559, -0.03419967368245125, -0.050187814980745316, -0.04126625508069992, -0.004507139790803194, 0.003129627089947462, -0.015716571360826492, -0.005850545130670071, 0.026245703920722008, -0.0032887430861592293, -0.035283152014017105, -0.005206483416259289, -0.005142565816640854, -0.04050079733133316, -0.04152928292751312, -0.03113248012959957, -0.023963525891304016, -0.003686045529320836, 0.0014153141528367996, -0.015082260593771935, 0.03605898097157478, 0.025127097964286804, -0.04584740474820137, -0.020519273355603218, 0.061037324368953705, 0.02347111701965332, -0.018827488645911217, 0.03585558012127876, 0.0433826707303524, -0.0008777930052019656, 0.005194921977818012, -0.017817409709095955, -0.009477650746703148, -0.0001445492380298674, 0.019038062542676926, -0.03633369505405426, -0.015180864371359348, -0.060578182339668274, -0.026081565767526627, 0.08114534616470337, 0.06657124310731888, -0.008846694603562355, 0.04622592031955719, -0.042657624930143356, -0.03028537519276142, -0.02148015983402729, -0.05195074528455734, 0.03368612378835678, -0.0069988989271223545, 0.07533743232488632, -0.015286295674741268, 0.00396047392860055, 0.03730451315641403, 0.031117763370275497, 0.0006510231178253889, 0.011173064820468426, 0.04721587151288986, 0.06765349209308624, 0.023364083841443062, 0.02903960645198822, 0.08458321541547775, 0.000001386044459650293, 0.028344616293907166, -0.028824910521507263, 0.007387002930045128, -0.023445002734661102, -0.06439851969480515, -0.02801285684108734, -0.02352362684905529, 0.05177328735589981, -0.011520348489284515, -0.02999054454267025, 0.016745254397392273, -0.0014555406523868442, 0.002784566255286336, -0.020559560507535934, 0.020245205610990524, -0.006288440898060799, 0.04963403567671776, 0.015445778146386147, -0.018215488642454147, 0.0000033926876312762033, -0.0067206318490207195, 0.04809097200632095, -0.02357279136776924, -0.03196311742067337, -0.025012319907546043, -0.0009299044031649828, -0.029730863869190216, -0.04249700903892517, 0.06937084347009659, 0.025744935497641563, -0.08622205257415771, -0.0559929721057415, 0.0873696357011795, 0.019361700862646103, 0.032458916306495667, 0.04241764545440674, -0.1046157255768776, 0.0029667052440345287, -0.0116836903616786, 0.004369849804788828, -0.05565608665347099, 0.008113937452435493, 0.044116534292697906, -0.05300681293010712, 0.018518658354878426, 0.002082518767565489, 0.06334740668535233, -0.006261294241994619, -0.03342350199818611 ]
<p>In quantum mechanics, we talk about (1) vectors, (2) states, and (3) ensembles (e.g., a beam in a particle accelerator). Suppose we want to translate this into mathematical definitions. If I'd never heard of the von Neumann density matrix, I'd approach this problem as follows. Two vectors can represent the same state if they differ only by a phase, so we should define states as equivalence classes of vectors that differ by a phase. However, I would not see any reason to go a second step and define a further level of equivalence-classing, in which a hydrogen atom in its ground state is considered to be equivalent to a beam of hydrogen atoms in their ground states.</p> <p>Von Neumann is obviously a lot smarter than I am, and his notion of a density matrix appears to be universally accepted as the right way to describe a state. We use the same density matrix to describe one hydrogen atom or a beam of them. Can anyone offer any insight into why there seems to be no useful notion of state that works the way I'd have thought, rather than the way von Neumann did it?</p> <p>Does it matter whether we're talking about classical QM or QFT? Do we not want to distinguish states from ensembles because in QFT particles can be created and annihilated, so fixing the particle number is not really what we want to do in defining the notion of a state?</p> <p>Related: <a href="http://mathoverflow.net/q/117125/21349">http://mathoverflow.net/q/117125/21349</a></p>
g1679
[ -0.029017720371484756, 0.030962610617280006, 0.02093270793557167, -0.05379100888967514, 0.03765867277979851, -0.02593604475259781, -0.038673434406518936, 0.045029833912849426, -0.03483908995985985, 0.006953196134418249, 0.027643149718642235, 0.012847133912146091, 0.004699463956058025, 0.03433021157979965, 0.006680389866232872, 0.013468158431351185, 0.008775762282311916, 0.04187129810452461, -0.020693033933639526, 0.0032283025793731213, 0.0010752652306109667, -0.01582716591656208, 0.001346419914625585, -0.025373943150043488, 0.033078476786613464, -0.007200536783784628, 0.018652193248271942, -0.06804957985877991, 0.009475874714553356, 0.004612575750797987, -0.01657365821301937, -0.0022869620006531477, 0.01620442606508732, -0.052442047744989395, -0.004245540127158165, -0.012850253842771053, 0.009611316956579685, 0.017997220158576965, 0.039180777966976166, -0.04808273911476135, -0.0025111085269600153, -0.02306855469942093, -0.04512133076786995, -0.03074297495186329, 0.05118822678923607, 0.027488231658935547, 0.0038113838527351618, -0.027440086007118225, 0.00020151128410361707, 0.03638498857617378, 0.022576825693249702, 0.01810184307396412, 0.06615044921636581, -0.009353747591376305, 0.06115495413541794, -0.008686701767146587, -0.05985177680850029, 0.001550520770251751, 0.061971161514520645, 0.01989959366619587, 0.024301018565893173, 0.023394178599119186, 0.022815780714154243, 0.018324021250009537, 0.022160664200782776, 0.022006860002875328, -0.010486462153494358, 0.03767327219247818, 0.03258165344595909, 0.011182582005858421, -0.0398661233484745, -0.056077662855386734, -0.027729244902729988, 0.05718151852488518, 0.04206357151269913, -0.01272323913872242, -0.010231833904981613, -0.004311343189328909, 0.052853602916002274, 0.005097540561109781, -0.057099275290966034, -0.03511766716837883, 0.05255986750125885, 0.016418466344475746, 0.03329424560070038, 0.019593754783272743, -0.018485940992832184, 0.024030348286032677, 0.010366793721914291, 0.042417675256729126, -0.019686516374349594, 0.014726552180945873, 0.08157031983137131, 0.04805056378245354, -0.07278693467378616, -0.04539048299193382, -0.004309029784053564, 0.08532332628965378, -0.00937027670443058, -0.009358443319797516, -0.029364096000790596, 0.013013727962970734, 0.036626916378736496, -0.041743338108062744, -0.014511997811496258, -0.011405840516090393, 0.022108638659119606, 0.029968583956360817, 0.0019349512876942754, 0.0015944517217576504, -0.06229812651872635, 0.04219454154372215, -0.037107914686203, 0.010266022756695747, -0.0713791772723198, 0.007033887319266796, 0.08271657675504684, -0.051453497260808945, -0.04151301831007004, -0.0015955979470163584, 0.02118198573589325, 0.017680002376437187, 0.0622132234275341, 0.045322105288505554, -0.005129776429384947, -0.005879741162061691, -0.013974709436297417, 0.017538003623485565, -0.03462783247232437, -0.0088950851932168, 0.02970205247402191, -0.017776301130652428, 0.019723543897271156, -0.0010054352460429072, -0.011552165262401104, 0.018862087279558182, -0.02215057797729969, -0.04625426605343819, 0.00496439216658473, -0.008534553460776806, 0.0421847440302372, 0.0012118053855374455, -0.03410528227686882, -0.040506068617105484, 0.04318426921963692, -0.02379470504820347, -0.0736108124256134, -0.03757862746715546, 0.04376889392733574, 0.040802039206027985, 0.013793084770441055, 0.04059895873069763, -0.011774913407862186, -0.04475884139537811, 0.020166615024209023, 0.05115003138780594, 0.027173111215233803, -0.017810707911849022, -0.005444228183478117, 0.031016364693641663, 0.03617658466100693, 0.00003256025956943631, 0.014499945566058159, -0.03943665325641632, 0.028670217841863632, -0.021534232422709465, 0.02276964671909809, -0.10165505111217499, 0.037939004600048065, -0.014722107909619808, 0.013181259855628014, -0.03344029560685158, -0.07168391346931458, 0.04656762629747391, -0.046429239213466644, 0.028053179383277893, -0.020249124616384506, -0.03747904300689697, 0.03173761069774628, 0.003749808995053172, -0.00669231079518795, 0.0007925676763989031, 0.05390208214521408, 0.0057365926913917065, -0.011761199682950974, 0.03686239570379257, -0.015289229340851307, -0.012461479753255844, -0.05850823596119881, 0.03372407704591751, -0.00798929762095213, 0.01609080471098423, 0.017092276364564896, -0.011988137848675251, -0.003260832978412509, 0.010735683143138885, -0.011730699799954891, -0.021635711193084717, -0.03983380272984505, -0.015865864232182503, -0.004200448747724295, 0.00723531236872077, -0.046812403947114944, 0.09026464819908142, 0.04066013917326927, 0.023239588364958763, 0.015909647569060326, 0.019762057811021805, 0.01197239849716425, -0.006831862032413483, 0.06385421752929688, -0.01970815099775791, -0.022947508841753006, 0.09182251989841461, -0.020435141399502754, 0.018458623439073563, 0.000815683975815773, -0.010096782818436623, -0.019861746579408646, 0.002984125865623355, -0.10259687900543213, -0.04877723753452301, 0.07237644493579865, 0.01678197830915451, -0.0597572922706604, 0.06286313384771347, -0.022871753200888634, -0.016606546938419342, -0.02948027290403843, 0.01291098166257143, -0.062335968017578125, 0.013561507686972618, -0.04605359956622124, -0.04619663208723068, 0.014141972176730633, 0.033838704228401184, 0.015057369135320187, 0.02168167009949684, 0.030476629734039307, -0.004545027390122414, -0.00962980929762125, -0.010974861681461334, -0.038999974727630615, 0.017774034291505814, 0.02999257855117321, -0.047284405678510666, -0.02252737618982792, -0.017188526690006256, 0.0376320518553257, 0.047964829951524734, -0.03302782401442528, -0.023903075605630875, -0.028402278199791908, -0.01366514340043068, 0.023116718977689743, -0.03927275165915489, -0.013379300944507122, -0.016215916723012924, 0.034386154264211655, -0.02007313072681427, 0.008738922886550426, -0.03972109034657478, -0.027703581377863884, -0.0045907748863101006, -0.03285474702715874, 0.007162869442254305, 0.016455918550491333, -0.006025340408086777, -0.04858607053756714, -0.04932057484984398, -0.005751537159085274, 0.06915361434221268, 0.018698597326874733, -0.017420444637537003, -0.004502578638494015, 0.004878696519881487, -0.04175731912255287, -0.03293750062584877, 0.03449016436934471, -0.034641411155462265, -0.08308032900094986, 0.016148289665579796, -0.023288482800126076, 0.023824959993362427, 0.07343835383653641, -0.02913663163781166, 0.014398489147424698, 0.05272221192717552, 0.03168582543730736, 0.0036455101799219847, 0.0042913006618618965, 0.040757253766059875, 0.006328291725367308, -0.0058168512769043446, -0.06247267872095108, 0.03772253170609474, -0.021781476214528084, -0.06980619579553604, 0.031997185200452805, 0.04767751321196556, -0.06566790491342545, 0.008916562423110008, 0.052264515310525894, -0.027588358148932457, 0.021296769380569458, 0.03962414711713791, -0.04583637788891792, -0.005140772555023432, -0.09744599461555481, -0.042058899998664856, -0.03470192849636078, 0.0011195760453119874, -0.040925201028585434, -0.054507914930582047, -0.05468287691473961, -0.030460931360721588, -0.005676943808794022, -0.02102537639439106, 0.043621934950351715, -0.054919321089982986, -0.04332078620791435, -0.017841516062617302, 0.07372666895389557, -0.0433906689286232, 0.05867742374539375, 0.07893695682287216, -0.038166195154190063, 0.01523213367909193, -0.012695757672190666, -0.05223248526453972, 0.04555905610322952, -0.01268552616238594, -0.016934188082814217, -0.0117257758975029, -0.038167066872119904, -0.07947701960802078, -0.03517448157072067, -0.025879397988319397, 0.019816461950540543, -0.0018772609764710069, -0.0033378954976797104, 0.018116604536771774, 0.0001000262564048171, 0.009829733520746231, -0.005122896749526262, -0.02774425782263279, 0.012952343560755253, -0.004630498122423887, 0.020362956449389458, -0.03759331256151199, 0.007703380659222603, 0.008706578053534031, 0.06143266707658768, 0.02595369517803192, -0.05133165046572685, 0.029628291726112366, 0.02151082083582878, -0.02901202067732811, 0.08573532104492188, 0.04860986769199371, 0.014096632599830627, -0.055690947920084, 0.007045515347272158, 0.00011181252193637192, -0.022503819316625595, -0.025816693902015686, -0.011937826871871948, -0.0011128284968435764, 0.0257308017462492, -0.01295890286564827, -0.03802412003278732, -0.08519526571035385, -0.0007009351975284517, 0.022587943822145462, -0.005914326757192612, -0.04658570885658264, 0.05616692081093788, -0.05012648180127144, -0.04808686673641205, 0.018540700897574425, 0.03410917893052101, 0.01871836744248867, 0.06957358866930008, -0.005920189432799816, 0.007781903259456158, 0.010908308438956738, -0.028303753584623337, 0.02513849548995495, -0.03276170790195465, 0.03884533420205116, 0.005138527601957321, -0.03195049986243248, -0.0347302220761776, 0.010521394200623035, 0.026807770133018494, 0.08876712620258331, 0.032677553594112396, 0.02979944460093975, -0.04562912508845329, 0.07122809439897537, 0.014489643275737762, -0.06974954158067703, -0.04736685752868652, 0.00303169758990407, 0.04445047676563263, -0.055315013974905014, 0.03095109947025776, -0.06164420023560524, -0.0017622590530663729, -0.03614512458443642, -0.010935481637716293, 0.008087387308478355, 0.023111840710043907, -0.020174259319901466, 0.02958597056567669, 0.009182910434901714, -0.021429749205708504, 0.003979876171797514, -0.030538516119122505, 0.029306266456842422, -0.05848158523440361, 0.05241881683468819, 0.02382565476000309, -0.015434431843459606, 0.053484853357076645, 0.03582744300365448, 0.0595836378633976, 0.025955162942409515, 0.004773055203258991, -0.058437954634428024, 0.04902716353535652, 0.005765086971223354, -0.008954326622188091, 0.012291024439036846, 0.0071718948893249035, -0.06403591483831406, -0.0920066311955452, 0.05520264059305191, -0.012303817085921764, 0.005460094660520554, 0.04843267425894737, 0.03278977423906326, -0.04270564019680023, 0.050618045032024384, 0.0019420958124101162, -0.01474758144468069, -0.015584711916744709, 0.016864513978362083, -0.07571703940629959, -0.006965320091694593, -0.03109821304678917, 0.012034876272082329, -0.02211211621761322, -0.052394330501556396, -0.00046894425759091973, -0.03328261896967888, -0.040030717849731445, -0.026182277128100395, 0.004576380830258131, 0.06271101534366608, 0.010077172890305519, 0.011725976131856441, -0.022334715351462364, -0.020453382283449173, 0.007691559847444296, 0.018974512815475464, -0.10815854370594025, 0.054351989179849625, -0.0530632883310318, -0.03217998892068863, 0.03645695745944977, -0.05660803243517876, -0.00818420760333538, -0.006640096660703421, 0.02488621138036251, 0.014926611445844173, -0.020462097600102425, -0.03480895608663559, 0.005660637281835079, -0.0606955885887146, 0.01493868138641119, 0.0069413636811077595, 0.06936341524124146, 0.045286353677511215, 0.03400358185172081, 0.008219213224947453, 0.007521572522819042, -0.023248082026839256, -0.00660931970924139, -0.08890249580144882, 0.040071986615657806, -0.0022461938206106424, -0.003670011181384325, 0.027208959683775902, 0.008914127014577389, -0.04877901449799538, -0.02559736929833889, -0.052224695682525635, -0.04170755296945572, 0.022173868492245674, -0.048313453793525696, 0.051014143973588943, 0.031649887561798096, 0.006027324590831995, 0.01791844703257084, 0.046352170407772064, 0.06916432827711105, -0.013348009437322617, -0.01487183477729559, 0.03310753032565117, 0.004086364526301622, 0.030280781909823418, 0.0027240742929279804, 0.04363415017724037, 0.028892898932099342, 0.055077146738767624, 0.008043606765568256, 0.030331680551171303, -0.007382721174508333, -0.01666218228638172, -0.020331351086497307, -0.028323408216238022, -0.007453291676938534, -0.05567682534456253, 0.015522531233727932, 0.000929074885789305, -0.04033796489238739, -0.03741002455353737, -0.04827796667814255, 0.056588318198919296, 0.03227986395359039, -0.004219429101794958, -0.011015895754098892, -0.03777855262160301, -0.024429507553577423, -0.01820611208677292, -0.023355407640337944, 0.03851595148444176, 0.046892452985048294, 0.05736193805932999, -0.030726559460163116, -0.03132143244147301, 0.00403112405911088, -0.00770688708871603, 0.046143222600221634, 0.0003823516017291695, -0.025405218824744225, -0.04524754360318184, 0.0368431881070137, 0.000340577244060114, -0.06842470914125443, -0.049876511096954346, -0.06002454459667206, -0.07259815186262131, 0.02786143124103546, 0.05765999108552933, 0.01766890473663807, 0.01258076075464487, 0.011690206825733185, 0.040850743651390076, 0.011048441752791405, 0.06467271596193314, 0.009092639200389385, 0.01572042889893055, 0.07072271406650543, 0.0020770856644958258, -0.004876213613897562, 0.008245991542935371, 0.032606471329927444, -0.02362777665257454, 0.02187022939324379, -0.00010538446076679975, 0.017852896824479103, -0.013702986761927605, 0.048003632575273514, -0.031384795904159546, -0.0315697155892849, -0.04314463585615158, -0.033556465059518814, 0.016696780920028687, 0.005972744431346655, -0.0034290249459445477, 0.022648517042398453, -0.01961558312177658, -0.03227827697992325, 0.008642392233014107, 0.021700263023376465, -0.056343723088502884, 0.05528368428349495, 0.03337685391306877, -0.059285372495651245, 0.016359202563762665, -0.02315361239016056, -0.01964949443936348, -0.04112830013036728, 0.047264549881219864, 0.04052417725324631, 0.0030100757721811533, -0.0317089781165123, -0.02532493881881237, 0.035407546907663345, 0.007970771752297878, -0.005594498943537474, 0.006718162447214127, 0.0095567237585783, 0.06180300563573837, -0.03159872815012932, -0.012608017772436142, -0.00963954720646143, -0.012797568924725056, -0.0383145734667778, -0.005543854087591171, -0.07243078202009201, -0.011210883967578411, 0.043787650763988495, 0.0028288487810641527, 0.03234504908323288, 0.02314792387187481, -0.03440745174884796, 0.029784144833683968, 0.008955203928053379, 0.007216188125312328, 0.053690165281295776, -0.03546369448304176, 0.03378356248140335, 0.06080177053809166, -0.00033860269468277693, 0.06304183602333069, 0.10000567138195038, 0.05474187806248665, 0.023555992171168327, -0.05460897833108902, 0.00009494466939941049, 0.01638800837099552, -0.008413750678300858, 0.005455520004034042, -0.028459148481488228, 0.03490341454744339, 0.0580931156873703, -0.005226558074355125, -0.06334436684846878, 0.04093187674880028, 0.019561756402254105, -0.038302723318338394, -0.03307252377271652, -0.03870883584022522, 0.03319230675697327, -0.04758942127227783, -0.07621833682060242, 0.030140891671180725, 0.004934447351843119, 0.012757524847984314, -0.04192174971103668, -0.05098909139633179, -0.011043770238757133, 0.06064805015921593, 0.046086471527814865, 0.024691149592399597, 0.05653296783566475, -0.03778201341629028, -0.010552367195487022, -0.010580558329820633, 0.012038950808346272, 0.03983428701758385, 0.028757164254784584, -0.025359561666846275, 0.02199561707675457, 0.02823506109416485, -0.01493248250335455, -0.03665561228990555, 0.02429860271513462, -0.05126725882291794, -0.014381113462150097, -0.04498817399144173, 0.011724477633833885, -0.02966225892305374, 0.01472297590225935, 0.08316526561975479, -0.06112513691186905, 0.0013036656891927123, 0.007961375638842583, 0.03391101583838463, 0.0019553734455257654, 0.036700572818517685, -0.007038693875074387, 0.017933182418346405, 0.003519772319123149, -0.01423161942511797, -0.007528074085712433, -0.017708826810121536, 0.012815237045288086, -0.027807239443063736, 0.026649195700883865, 0.010827280580997467, 0.02559869922697544, 0.06714838743209839, 0.04263251647353172, 0.033668335527181625, 0.01221719104796648, -0.028954045847058296, -0.042936764657497406, -0.005476758815348148, 0.03469327092170715, 0.002678888849914074, 0.031910646706819534, -0.0017450114246457815, 0.014497754164040089, 0.002909399103373289, 0.002614368684589863, -0.04559870809316635, -0.02251889929175377, 0.011719461530447006, 0.019930265843868256, 0.0003342880227137357, -0.02735954523086548, -0.028373757377266884, -0.06597623229026794, 0.03383936733007431, 0.04870287701487541, -0.0416865199804306, 0.00469672866165638, 0.025010928511619568, -0.015238487161695957, 0.025803519412875175, 0.025218848139047623, -0.05933899059891701, 0.028983868658542633, 0.06392215937376022, -0.016811786219477654, -0.025885114446282387, -0.00024499325081706047, -0.05192391201853752, 0.009931388311088085, 0.04127281531691551, -0.008504744619131088, 0.037919268012046814, 0.027705438435077667, 0.009182780981063843, 0.03798019513487816, 0.03758801519870758, -0.08938554674386978, -0.023559316992759705, 0.0803559347987175, -0.040022511035203934, -0.0034887981601059437, -0.03716958686709404, -0.010473961010575294, -0.010366898030042648, 0.04220926761627197, -0.019642595201730728, -0.061329640448093414, -0.006336235906928778, -0.021070191636681557, 0.05166425183415413, 0.029006153345108032, -0.009639722295105457, 0.06323663145303726, 0.0011860632803291082, 0.08416576683521271, -0.022296372801065445, 0.00459366524592042, -0.012092438526451588, -0.015213518403470516, -0.029307223856449127, -0.08326873928308487, -0.027056990191340446, -0.04675598442554474, -0.017076212912797928 ]
<p>I recently came across two nice papers on the foundations of quantum mechancis, Aaronson 2004 and Hardy 2001. Aaronson makes the statement, which was new to me, that nonlinearity in QM leads to superluminal signaling (as well as the solvability of hard problems in computer science by a nonlinear quantum computer). Can anyone offer an argument with crayons for why this should be so?</p> <p>It seems strange to me that a principle so fundamental and important can be violated simply by having some nonlinearity. When it comes to mechanical waves, we're used to thinking of a linear wave equation as an approximation that is <em>always</em> violated at some level. Does even the teensiest bit of nonlinearity in QM bring causality to its knees, or can the damage be limited in some sense?</p> <p>Does all of this have any implications for quantum gravity -- e.g., does it help to explain why it's hard to make a theory of quantum gravity, since it's not obvious that quantum gravity can be unitary and linear?</p> <blockquote> <p>S. Aaronson, "Is Quantum Mechanics An Island In Theoryspace?," 2004, <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0401062">arXiv:quant-ph/0401062</a>.</p> <p>L. Hardy, "Quantum theory from five reasonable axioms," 2001, <a href="http://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0101012">arXiv:quant-ph/0101012</a>.</p> </blockquote>
g1680
[ 0.038778070360422134, 0.06515486538410187, 0.004128231201320887, 0.0014317735331133008, 0.026042217388749123, 0.006923852022737265, 0.015366165898740292, -0.03325274959206581, -0.027023468166589737, 0.0047432733699679375, -0.005208303220570087, -0.03884303197264671, 0.02009374462068081, 0.05328397825360298, -0.030729535967111588, -0.0439523346722126, 0.0014967500464990735, 0.033663276582956314, 0.043797750025987625, -0.035088468343019485, -0.00913387630134821, 0.023311251774430275, 0.01775944232940674, -0.09150021523237228, -0.021541202440857887, 0.03131263330578804, 0.049496665596961975, -0.04295540601015091, 0.006939791142940521, 0.03285248950123787, -0.016912871971726418, -0.020646696910262108, 0.02155994437634945, -0.04378417134284973, -0.07482857257127762, -0.003482755506411195, 0.0029376845341175795, -0.027443889528512955, 0.04013335704803467, 0.012958887964487076, 0.020055601373314857, -0.019277427345514297, -0.020802045240998268, -0.0025990086141973734, -0.029043663293123245, -0.040682580322027206, 0.04194512218236923, 0.03496783599257469, 0.045630279928445816, -0.037969496101140976, 0.018336301669478416, -0.0027716057375073433, 0.051349613815546036, 0.0288881566375494, 0.06384475529193878, 0.06530497223138809, -0.0403878390789032, 0.0812712237238884, 0.016699841246008873, -0.01727067492902279, 0.012460521422326565, 0.028323814272880554, 0.09109048545360565, 0.022776372730731964, 0.04729233309626579, 0.025791410356760025, -0.012258432805538177, -0.061858467757701874, 0.01849859580397606, 0.01604796014726162, -0.03657887130975723, -0.0530535988509655, -0.025653790682554245, -0.01212762389332056, -0.008466310799121857, 0.09918473660945892, 0.005089796148240566, 0.03823428973555565, -0.04970109462738037, 0.02168244495987892, -0.06562638282775879, -0.051148880273103714, 0.03289330005645752, 0.029946189373731613, 0.040583524852991104, 0.007326675113290548, 0.037334512919187546, -0.058671850711107254, -0.00884311180561781, 0.0425037182867527, 0.022404709830880165, -0.007212933152914047, 0.0348721407353878, 0.014022985473275185, -0.02588781528174877, -0.007981762290000916, 0.0007137173670344055, 0.031184645369648933, -0.0101259620860219, 0.0038047130219638348, -0.035558346658945084, 0.030279725790023804, 0.02416941523551941, -0.035906434059143066, -0.043616656213998795, -0.004182692151516676, -0.026482300832867622, -0.019320912659168243, 0.0021896352991461754, -0.03554476425051689, 0.004623628221452236, 0.008539587259292603, -0.010769081301987171, -0.06916888803243637, -0.035011447966098785, -0.021369200199842453, 0.04223564267158508, -0.00464419461786747, 0.022539490833878517, 0.01775932125747204, -0.025192907080054283, 0.019541040062904358, -0.021782703697681427, 0.02187705785036087, 0.007310006767511368, -0.02235085889697075, 0.013777539134025574, 0.021986685693264008, 0.03430376574397087, -0.034279074519872665, 0.014703542925417423, 0.013006108812987804, -0.036926090717315674, 0.03255893662571907, -0.013905148953199387, 0.00661452254280448, -0.04871292784810066, -0.028658494353294373, 0.05815465375781059, -0.030250340700149536, -0.008846833370625973, -0.05595013499259949, -0.023338288068771362, 0.03148217499256134, 0.002013034885749221, -0.059799209237098694, 0.05060555040836334, 0.014515753835439682, 0.018376456573605537, 0.0038493734318763018, -0.023811552673578262, 0.06212271749973297, 0.013727940618991852, -0.03541180118918419, 0.03120267204940319, 0.0713408887386322, 0.03351036086678505, -0.008555901236832142, -0.024947402998805046, -0.037635527551174164, 0.03086944669485092, 0.004063419997692108, -0.03176555782556534, 0.010001449845731258, -0.06293027848005295, 0.05532066151499748, 0.01821201853454113, -0.06394492089748383, 0.011604847386479378, 0.02971762605011463, -0.01127731055021286, 0.0010678927646949887, 0.015890421345829964, 0.027729609981179237, 0.02215764857828617, 0.039636850357055664, 0.05581367760896683, -0.06486055999994278, -0.0010659019462764263, -0.04285270348191261, -0.027816856279969215, -0.01959361508488655, -0.004561243113130331, -0.04302487522363663, -0.03509439900517464, 0.021814847365021706, 0.0435185544192791, 0.045560240745544434, -0.0037788727786391973, -0.034449320286512375, -0.017122836783528328, 0.027387289330363274, 0.005156181287020445, 0.018384693190455437, -0.03262494131922722, -0.029470691457390785, 0.015255676582455635, 0.011765792034566402, -0.01488296315073967, -0.017390627413988113, 0.02806958556175232, 0.027700237929821014, -0.017763832584023476, -0.05269482359290123, -0.001243431237526238, 0.056701719760894775, -0.01654098741710186, 0.03574834764003754, 0.014240906573832035, -0.026898417621850967, 0.014333963394165039, 0.02988433837890625, -0.008053426630795002, -0.009738084860146046, -0.0034330403432250023, -0.038356490433216095, 0.06545592844486237, 0.0014455060008913279, -0.02377282828092575, 0.07207010686397552, -0.004406272433698177, 0.03287636861205101, 0.06281323730945587, 0.018445780500769615, -0.03189050778746605, 0.02251242846250534, -0.018335014581680298, -0.04894965514540672, -0.06776512414216995, 0.0033254665322601795, -0.05681411921977997, 0.008602282032370567, 0.009680698625743389, 0.02514060214161873, 0.028766918927431107, 0.020341278985142708, 0.024420997127890587, -0.044617537409067154, 0.05779681354761124, 0.043676283210515976, 0.06095181405544281, 0.023846983909606934, -0.010901045054197311, -0.00846155546605587, -0.010501502081751823, -0.039751749485731125, -0.0358608216047287, -0.016453176736831665, -0.03543472662568092, 0.04591690003871918, 0.034250445663928986, -0.05053451657295227, -0.08860515058040619, 0.00024015162489376962, 0.00004046046160510741, 0.014967436902225018, 0.05321897566318512, 0.018004216253757477, -0.025956377387046814, -0.004642438143491745, 0.030659031122922897, 0.002791990991681814, -0.06252362579107285, -0.02107132412493229, -0.029426243156194687, -0.05541288107633591, -0.004624254535883665, 0.0557592548429966, -0.033128611743450165, -0.02706444077193737, -0.028468400239944458, 0.03539649397134781, 0.03486763685941696, 0.04914391040802002, 0.03727542236447334, -0.026920408010482788, -0.020095042884349823, 0.015217217616736889, 0.03632641211152077, -0.05179567262530327, -0.023799456655979156, -0.040688350796699524, -0.05871579796075821, -0.017838841304183006, 0.01840178668498993, -0.051546432077884674, -0.006589560303837061, 0.0052678766660392284, -0.020084336400032043, 0.003702430287376046, -0.001929098041728139, 0.02365265227854252, -0.0642976239323616, 0.02389969304203987, -0.10132693499326706, 0.04948817566037178, -0.012060810811817646, -0.03118932992219925, -0.005774457473307848, -0.010169653221964836, 0.01720360666513443, 0.03495486453175545, 0.03921615704894066, 0.06788340955972672, 0.013689001090824604, 0.05203361436724663, -0.05166100338101387, -0.013486378826200962, 0.021976517513394356, 0.03635413572192192, 0.010661379434168339, 0.025807779282331467, -0.006827112287282944, 0.019962184131145477, -0.028411881998181343, 0.011927763931453228, -0.030619464814662933, -0.0012579642934724689, 0.014933230355381966, -0.057674944400787354, -0.07241913676261902, -0.07941434532403946, -0.029052097350358963, -0.026483727619051933, 0.07393231987953186, 0.01814950257539749, -0.04021180793642998, 0.02747739851474762, 0.0031854165717959404, -0.026873541995882988, 0.0506681464612484, -0.030021898448467255, 0.029956627637147903, 0.024514231830835342, -0.028493328019976616, -0.08218897134065628, -0.03582944720983505, -0.040500544011592865, 0.00008097210229607299, 0.04275314137339592, -0.027671635150909424, -0.006228019017726183, -0.04464581236243248, -0.04318290203809738, 0.010434846393764019, 0.022487986832857132, -0.005831362679600716, 0.010431136935949326, -0.015049921348690987, 0.003781769657507539, -0.0065811267122626305, -0.013373281806707382, 0.04895634949207306, 0.033725809305906296, 0.02696506306529045, 0.06422151625156403, 0.08011547476053238, 0.013827520422637463, 0.022142319008708, -0.005362312775105238, -0.019630443304777145, 0.001177626778371632, 0.019475597888231277, -0.0299054142087698, 0.020122652873396873, 0.005137348081916571, -0.004978373646736145, -0.001951161539182067, -0.04963655024766922, 0.014083482325077057, 0.008066278882324696, 0.021966619417071342, -0.03480701521039009, 0.028108952566981316, 0.011169089004397392, -0.018936023116111755, 0.013460464775562286, -0.05226770415902138, -0.005001859739422798, -0.013878130353987217, 0.05453558266162872, 0.018904104828834534, 0.04210670664906502, 0.008481588214635849, 0.07265534996986389, 0.053581904619932175, -0.00636811600998044, -0.0019598824437707663, 0.03163347393274307, 0.006277303211390972, -0.008402680046856403, -0.06867606192827225, -0.021784940734505653, 0.02801084890961647, -0.012269401922821999, 0.06703538447618484, 0.017660224810242653, -0.026992779225111008, 0.021404100582003593, 0.031007062643766403, 0.03081282041966915, -0.010468315333127975, 0.0016787467757239938, 0.022272756323218346, -0.03180510550737381, -0.021992439404129982, 0.03061366267502308, 0.022671284154057503, -0.0017830970464274287, -0.023319320753216743, 0.059668511152267456, 0.0036955338437110186, -0.043930865824222565, -0.07624267041683197, 0.03685280680656433, 0.014924629591405392, 0.037099260836839676, -0.03344736248254776, 0.01989406906068325, -0.015417961403727531, 0.062272049486637115, 0.03709804639220238, 0.03081669844686985, -0.0119588952511549, 0.0031907232478260994, 0.008388162590563297, -0.0019522709771990776, -0.0282135047018528, 0.01819366030395031, -0.03951314464211464, -0.0012806813465431333, 0.0014993920922279358, 0.030981674790382385, -0.007453720085322857, 0.048250652849674225, -0.03190673515200615, -0.051982004195451736, 0.053470514714717865, 0.016551844775676727, 0.006124285981059074, 0.08253428339958191, -0.0149917621165514, 0.028307048603892326, -0.007725386414676905, 0.05583463981747627, 0.04258338734507561, -0.0436336025595665, 0.028203368186950684, -0.06236181780695915, -0.03085632622241974, -0.016022909432649612, 0.022630838677287102, 0.05934770405292511, -0.03555753827095032, -0.02646327018737793, -0.07337118685245514, -0.01380030158907175, 0.008436578325927258, 0.06018749251961708, -0.0033566502388566732, -0.026829587295651436, -0.0209773201495409, -0.01655156910419464, 0.017421148717403412, 0.014122942462563515, 0.047516901046037674, -0.07784855365753174, 0.05983944609761238, -0.04120185226202011, -0.0554221048951149, 0.03269673511385918, 0.018117602914571762, 0.021540338173508644, 0.06450198590755463, -0.004631903488188982, -0.04605522006750107, -0.03329983353614807, -0.0072555686347186565, -0.002937337849289179, -0.06514741480350494, 0.007163699250668287, -0.030506858602166176, 0.053732678294181824, 0.011462515220046043, -0.03085342049598694, 0.012057950720191002, -0.025337254628539085, 0.009486546739935875, -0.046298492699861526, 0.0017682183533906937, 0.06585146486759186, -0.012454341165721416, 0.0011020316742360592, 0.020616743713617325, -0.04163392633199692, -0.025930289179086685, 0.06086532026529312, 0.01774623617529869, -0.017204608768224716, 0.001623511896468699, -0.049296602606773376, 0.07161054760217667, 0.030848192051053047, -0.058944351971149445, -0.004161644261330366, 0.009966262616217136, 0.024556944146752357, -0.004963374231010675, 0.0017193552339449525, 0.03161522001028061, -0.005759356543421745, -0.0648246705532074, -0.059890154749155045, 0.02730940841138363, 0.07381877303123474, -0.03439481556415558, 0.030460232868790627, -0.019505362957715988, -0.07454100996255875, 0.023592760786414146, -0.0034860081505030394, -0.006596119608730078, 0.05522461608052254, -0.06606031209230423, 0.012032090686261654, -0.0002789792779367417, -0.04694858938455582, -0.020311135798692703, 0.01966429315507412, 0.020366817712783813, 0.020537089556455612, 0.054970964789390564, 0.03351645544171333, -0.012858050875365734, 0.02777780033648014, -0.01050468161702156, 0.05716991797089577, -0.015900123864412308, -0.057427458465099335, 0.03499928116798401, -0.001077082590200007, -0.023417672142386436, -0.014711305499076843, 0.09659995883703232, -0.023731958121061325, -0.03912188857793808, -0.023041000589728355, -0.024204090237617493, 0.01835995353758335, -0.03821351006627083, -0.027976589277386665, 0.0005312185967341065, -0.005285279359668493, 0.027049968019127846, 0.015552065335214138, 0.03087650239467621, -0.08386623859405518, -0.019186215475201607, -0.07375989109277725, 0.019425274804234505, 0.05326519533991814, 0.09669195115566254, 0.030760398134589195, -0.06750227510929108, 0.03575195372104645, 0.03389474377036095, -0.0007958000642247498, -0.06158582866191864, 0.029347289353609085, 0.05233766511082649, -0.034700773656368256, 0.08350808173418045, 0.007440038491040468, 0.04069565609097481, -0.037696365267038345, 0.03985116630792618, -0.0065816850401461124, -0.07332558184862137, -0.0755704864859581, -0.029117068275809288, -0.027874397113919258, 0.04095691442489624, 0.028778953477740288, -0.07285899668931961, 0.00851413980126381, 0.024689562618732452, -0.03947431221604347, -0.004461424425244331, 0.10884791612625122, 0.0310653168708086, 0.019998570904135704, 0.0003125161456409842, -0.022399120032787323, -0.020167652517557144, -0.03730452433228493, -0.005448020063340664, 0.04521683230996132, -0.056355103850364685, -0.013190893456339836, 0.0064924489706754684, 0.04549432173371315, -0.001963471295312047, 0.007096259389072657, -0.013244444504380226, -0.01826167106628418, 0.025886576622724533, 0.006118296645581722, 0.029855376109480858, -0.0024302443489432335, 0.004754405468702316, -0.07254708558320999, 0.031644027680158615, 0.017679516226053238, -0.05657663568854332, -0.0011884566629305482, -0.038140811026096344, -0.00502265989780426, -0.008505322970449924, 0.003898556111380458, -0.010431450791656971, 0.017824247479438782, -0.002767777070403099, 0.018459759652614594, 0.01811402291059494, -0.027390681207180023, 0.003386165015399456, -0.04552418738603592, 0.03485865890979767, 0.029413020238280296, -0.0024782861582934856, -0.019086334854364395, 0.03575236350297928, 0.005504022818058729, 0.007482919842004776, -0.05303378403186798, 0.02175769954919815, -0.04079282283782959, -0.022074297070503235, 0.013324512168765068, -0.0689074918627739, -0.019039662554860115, 0.0432790108025074, 0.015174256637692451, -0.012962098233401775, 0.039168838411569595, -0.019872216507792473, 0.03359665721654892, -0.01344508957117796, -0.08452818542718887, -0.012799719348549843, 0.019673271104693413, 0.022546084597706795, -0.017598221078515053, 0.045276179909706116, -0.05230652168393135, 0.0644788146018982, -0.05500471964478493, -0.0045039416290819645, 0.031491924077272415, -0.015050932765007019, -0.02746904455125332, -0.03204004466533661, 0.01739426515996456, -0.021559393033385277, 0.0061552212573587894, 0.011947055347263813, 0.011645784601569176, -0.04763232171535492, 0.005428234115242958, 0.015919934958219528, 0.033058539032936096, -0.022027062252163887, 0.02720419503748417, 0.040920235216617584, -0.003466579131782055, -0.03136235103011131, 0.027498340234160423, -0.013919833116233349, -0.019674621522426605, -0.0096050426363945, 0.008372110314667225, -0.033672187477350235, 0.026747411116957664, -0.02071426436305046, -0.01816830411553383, -0.039113160222768784, -0.007587415166199207, 0.003165751462802291, -0.045196209102869034, 0.0031427214853465557, 0.023394083604216576, -0.07212106138467789, 0.003216535085812211, -0.004957788158208132, 0.06642233580350876, -0.0024373717606067657, -0.004818758927285671, 0.08030965179204941, 0.015515252016484737, 0.03564850986003876, -0.017507465556263924, 0.02959461510181427, -0.04035530611872673, 0.024718116968870163, 0.03136739879846573, 0.007941024377942085, 0.028887366876006126, -0.04313236474990845, 0.006877004634588957, -0.035857971757650375, -0.060199759900569916, 0.002959584817290306, 0.01120701339095831, 0.018858151510357857, 0.07749146968126297, -0.02017149329185486, -0.03466568514704704, 0.00008843691466609016, 0.010212053544819355, -0.05427985265851021, -0.00964940432459116, 0.06148799881339073, -0.013557636179029942, -0.02380605973303318, -0.05353274568915367, -0.05596878379583359, 0.03356708586215973, -0.01329985074698925, -0.07570816576480865, 0.058371178805828094, 0.0029347650706768036, -0.05417213961482048, -0.021803012117743492, -0.011227044276893139, -0.04191518947482109, 0.007360734045505524, -0.02975885570049286, 0.03913285955786705, 0.07101919502019882, -0.00520938029512763, 0.018113024532794952, -0.028273815289139748, -0.04562972113490105, -0.0332525372505188, 0.040868692100048065, -0.01572033204138279, -0.03135322406888008, -0.051157958805561066, 0.030643805861473083, -0.06426849216222763, -0.02565791644155979, -0.01963510550558567, 0.019370559602975845, 0.06730906665325165, 0.012955153360962868, -0.02309546060860157, -0.019390376284718513, -0.0033860935363918543, 0.0983935073018074, -0.04678495228290558, 0.026915661990642548, -0.05795270577073097, -0.0017845099791884422, -0.07694236934185028, -0.0684417113661766, -0.016291426494717598, 0.007487529888749123, 0.006853829137980938 ]
<p>Einstein postulated that the speed of light in free space is the same for all observers, regardless of their motion relative to the light source, where we may think of an observer as an <em>imaginary entity</em> with a sophisticated set of measurement devices, <em>at rest with respect to itself</em>, that perfectly records the positions and times of all events in space and time. </p> <p>It is really exciting to understand Einsteins thoughts. I have a doubt with respect Einsteins above postulate, </p> <ul> <li>Is there any significance in saying an <em>observer</em> as an <em>imaginary entity</em>? I thought light could be called as some thing imaginary, rather than calling observer as an imaginary entity. </li> <li>What does it mean <em>one being at rest with respect to one self</em>? I think it mean that, observer is not under motion due to its own virtue, but the observer may be under motion, if considered inside a moving frame of reference. I don't know whether I am right with respect to this, if I have misunderstood, please explain. </li> <li>Why is <em>speed of light considered same for all observers (imaginary entity which is at rest with respect to itself) regardless of their motion relative to the light source</em>? I thought, if we consider observer inside a moving frame of reference, speed of light should be different for the observer, due to relative motion with respect to light. </li> </ul>
g1681
[ -0.004331197123974562, 0.026466095820069313, 0.021415013819932938, -0.0173615925014019, 0.02570464462041855, 0.0031756442040205, 0.04988176003098488, 0.027207348495721817, -0.027656642720103264, -0.014175706543028355, 0.02298298291862011, -0.021948395296931267, 0.03431260585784912, 0.001523141167126596, -0.0034259732346981764, -0.037281252443790436, 0.1242154985666275, -0.04890751466155052, 0.019560623914003372, -0.05254250392317772, 0.022515421733260155, 0.05072756111621857, -0.019536063075065613, -0.0005653288098983467, 0.014115751720964909, -0.02152404375374317, 0.01689855195581913, -0.06854429841041565, -0.06659190356731415, -0.020808428525924683, 0.08373887091875076, -0.030075054615736008, 0.015192082151770592, -0.01314553339034319, 0.03544062376022339, -0.03676560893654823, 0.015674609690904617, 0.07929421961307526, 0.022282661870121956, 0.03333365544676781, -0.005441228859126568, 0.032997727394104004, -0.013876632787287235, -0.021370423957705498, 0.050773829221725464, 0.058018602430820465, 0.011784217320382595, -0.01475038193166256, 0.017702927812933922, 0.012035926803946495, 0.0250519011169672, 0.0463147908449173, 0.008135220035910606, 0.07408174872398376, 0.05017976835370064, -0.008615901693701744, -0.026145104318857193, -0.0065284171141684055, 0.01281485240906477, 0.05726134404540062, 0.004450673703104258, -0.08989355713129044, 0.012895184569060802, -0.015104126185178757, 0.015150835737586021, -0.012507954612374306, -0.04244979843497276, -0.03693009912967682, 0.04937727749347687, -0.05636734887957573, -0.006191098131239414, -0.01498807780444622, -0.06819555163383484, -0.008849804289638996, -0.03305816277861595, 0.027655446901917458, 0.030280670151114464, -0.03530712425708771, 0.04051825404167175, -0.00934826210141182, -0.04588232934474945, -0.023251812905073166, 0.058977603912353516, 0.032440003007650375, 0.054566070437431335, -0.0009082132601179183, -0.042630162090063095, 0.014936811290681362, 0.012398164719343185, 0.004103601444512606, 0.05126830190420151, -0.04970169439911842, 0.08488991856575012, -0.0032470854930579662, -0.062284376472234726, -0.023075120523571968, -0.03020710125565529, 0.009397965855896473, 0.04167889431118965, 0.061547860503196716, -0.06742418557405472, -0.0027767980936914682, -0.022023074328899384, 0.024420306086540222, 0.054579928517341614, -0.01683354750275612, -0.052591416984796524, 0.021863821893930435, -0.04427315294742584, -0.03874248266220093, 0.023132286965847015, -0.08954465389251709, -0.010012895800173283, -0.035185959190130234, -0.04595739766955376, -0.069460928440094, 0.032866302877664566, -0.0037453584372997284, -0.001472159055992961, 0.05001670867204666, 0.023524519056081772, 0.055168475955724716, 0.011934208683669567, 0.042021434754133224, -0.014190157875418663, 0.009698734618723392, 0.07432961463928223, -0.05167246237397194, -0.01659141108393669, 0.011574066244065762, -0.03538856282830238, 0.00361413462087512, -0.03958112746477127, 0.00019133159366901964, -0.06886953860521317, 0.014101958833634853, 0.0316288061439991, -0.06714597344398499, 0.05245761200785637, 0.028125641867518425, 0.011282071471214294, -0.012403320521116257, -0.0045412140898406506, -0.0784352719783783, -0.029395077377557755, 0.0087725929915905, -0.03896080330014229, -0.002139967866241932, 0.06403924524784088, 0.048773109912872314, 0.011001638136804104, 0.0467497892677784, -0.04009762033820152, -0.06696324795484543, -0.004200398456305265, -0.023278918117284775, -0.060378625988960266, 0.06638351082801819, -0.024400707334280014, 0.02836615778505802, 0.0258187148720026, 0.021609248593449593, 0.033760033547878265, -0.017715375870466232, -0.025790702551603317, 0.031162133440375328, -0.007914111949503422, -0.04275071993470192, -0.0109439417719841, -0.09361238032579422, 0.011564616113901138, -0.03591528162360191, 0.025963598862290382, 0.06553691625595093, 0.033806610852479935, 0.0025024295318871737, 0.011379620060324669, -0.017234882339835167, -0.04687618464231491, 0.022660598158836365, -0.032160304486751556, -0.08346764743328094, -0.0233168788254261, -0.05262196063995361, -0.016298405826091766, 0.013248492032289505, 0.02309691160917282, -0.04936276376247406, -0.05988248065114021, 0.04207240790128708, -0.008642848581075668, 0.0017849649302661419, 0.009613266214728355, 0.05564536899328232, 0.019005242735147476, 0.05308525264263153, -0.02544272318482399, -0.019365238025784492, -0.0034265187568962574, 0.02166694961488247, -0.02227066457271576, 0.013796443119645119, -0.029678164049983025, -0.018992818892002106, 0.0035694751422852278, -0.02701270580291748, -0.0019046637462452054, -0.009203203022480011, 0.015119951218366623, 0.013760051690042019, 0.07172729074954987, -0.009719554334878922, 0.06826256215572357, 0.03725045174360275, 0.0035540820099413395, -0.015353013761341572, -0.01657511666417122, -0.009963439777493477, -0.006342877168208361, 0.03074328415095806, -0.004799749236553907, 0.012344757094979286, 0.028233328834176064, -0.049202002584934235, -0.015279250219464302, -0.053990986198186874, -0.05859159678220749, -0.029277920722961426, 0.04229943826794624, 0.0693814605474472, -0.04359821602702141, -0.0008737167227081954, 0.019981062039732933, 0.04295545071363449, 0.036984704434871674, 0.02785537764430046, -0.012494070455431938, 0.035462744534015656, 0.04791087657213211, -0.011235874146223068, 0.01470652874559164, 0.013069371692836285, -0.011342261917889118, -0.045973435044288635, -0.008708561770617962, 0.0008746180683374405, 0.055828627198934555, -0.056814298033714294, -0.02462293952703476, -0.012533771805465221, -0.03543085977435112, 0.01993141882121563, -0.025282667949795723, -0.020245252177119255, -0.0049583748914301395, -0.010961443185806274, -0.004813686478883028, 0.03997744992375374, -0.03427496552467346, 0.012844797223806381, 0.023529646918177605, -0.07545922696590424, 0.013833649456501007, -0.0029721735045313835, -0.010106286033987999, 0.014214198105037212, -0.015516875311732292, 0.06964050978422165, -0.004446206148713827, -0.008676321245729923, -0.020655719563364983, 0.026098230853676796, -0.024912413209676743, 0.02615973725914955, -0.009404468350112438, 0.022126279771327972, -0.039022982120513916, -0.0460306741297245, 0.02775295451283455, -0.028302116319537163, 0.049049388617277145, 0.038885053247213364, -0.0774058923125267, -0.041570860892534256, -0.02345561981201172, -0.09285954385995865, -0.013397712260484695, 0.005852479953318834, 0.034728407859802246, -0.04050295054912567, 0.0128835653886199, 0.021057793870568275, 0.014707094989717007, 0.037648700177669525, 0.0026524921413511038, 0.11755259335041046, 0.013205052353441715, 0.0005962170544080436, -0.09896750003099442, 0.01708976924419403, 0.023698803037405014, -0.016519814729690552, 0.01509767398238182, 0.044174596667289734, 0.020314378663897514, -0.016867857426404953, -0.05077270045876503, -0.03497457131743431, 0.0022137307096272707, 0.018652798607945442, 0.001245562918484211, 0.007662925869226456, -0.019170841202139854, -0.061693690717220306, -0.02899400144815445, 0.0581100769340992, -0.059438567608594894, -0.019920408725738525, -0.00272971554659307, -0.0016221991972997785, -0.027934657409787178, 0.06156080216169357, -0.02431427501142025, 0.01754096709191799, 0.03532987833023071, -0.008702958934009075, 0.048977166414260864, 0.006642471998929977, -0.038843683898448944, 0.01151890680193901, 0.004725380335003138, -0.004596414510160685, 0.008879955857992172, 0.007066669873893261, -0.0025182643439620733, -0.029593002051115036, -0.05756106972694397, 0.032792847603559494, 0.031948067247867584, -0.02480633556842804, 0.04192226380109787, 0.007253457326442003, -0.003973976243287325, 0.04344112053513527, 0.06632976979017258, 0.01852145418524742, -0.05956236273050308, -0.013563117012381554, -0.04548051580786705, -0.0031435901764780283, 0.0445980578660965, 0.026704253628849983, -0.05062723532319069, -0.05277910456061363, -0.004987889435142279, 0.0349733792245388, 0.005264698527753353, 0.04894786328077316, -0.022588979452848434, -0.020262546837329865, 0.062453001737594604, 0.007825098000466824, 0.050910063087940216, -0.024550937116146088, 0.014781835488975048, -0.005881019402295351, 0.003636711509898305, -0.008767054416239262, 0.012070789933204651, 0.005827953107655048, -0.010500334203243256, -0.03327557444572449, -0.0365462563931942, -0.012175275012850761, 0.01814734749495983, -0.061721071600914, 0.07288642972707748, 0.022785870358347893, -0.05344030261039734, 0.009905158542096615, 0.017802035436034203, 0.007668823469430208, -0.0016404333291575313, -0.018710365518927574, 0.05269596353173256, 0.013859041966497898, 0.00002935925658675842, -0.018467161804437637, 0.01853294111788273, -0.037244025617837906, 0.06404423713684082, -0.03398739919066429, -0.058870699256658554, -0.001549890381284058, 0.03140333294868469, 0.04593914747238159, 0.0399370975792408, -0.010000955313444138, -0.004254470579326153, -0.0050856913439929485, 0.03593144193291664, 0.033303335309028625, 0.008172061294317245, 0.039127808064222336, -0.020267058163881302, -0.01265555527061224, 0.04336782917380333, -0.03612648695707321, 0.048778027296066284, 0.004108985420316458, -0.0217288751155138, 0.04085508733987808, -0.012218820862472057, -0.02165408246219158, -0.009240101091563702, 0.028044385835528374, -0.004252052865922451, -0.012125453911721706, 0.043997619301080704, 0.011991864070296288, 0.02048923633992672, 0.0007403378840535879, 0.05136170610785484, -0.01976373977959156, -0.016516949981451035, 0.04632790386676788, 0.05120159685611725, 0.03335566073656082, -0.053479116410017014, -0.02970271185040474, -0.004181919619441032, 0.00012148699897807091, 0.01461531687527895, 0.053368739783763885, -0.03099157102406025, 0.006048527546226978, 0.06405407190322876, 0.04113147035241127, 0.011613777838647366, 0.04197452589869499, 0.016474734991788864, 0.007166143972426653, 0.026669152081012726, 0.0013542425585910678, -0.004557243548333645, 0.028080681338906288, -0.057302411645650864, -0.034738700836896896, -0.006451982539147139, -0.03719339519739151, 0.007543942425400019, 0.05286913365125656, -0.011166875250637531, -0.02331249788403511, 0.01265690941363573, -0.04282718896865845, 0.012537060305476189, -0.041970204561948776, 0.031094780191779137, -0.012700311839580536, 0.029772257432341576, 0.017602642998099327, 0.01576816849410534, 0.0028158763889223337, 0.054219502955675125, 0.009815013036131859, -0.06771472841501236, -0.02713674120604992, -0.09029001742601395, -0.009157291613519192, 0.013134307228028774, -0.011960742995142937, 0.009348425082862377, 0.019010059535503387, 0.03861584886908531, 0.06254449486732483, 0.009796224534511566, -0.020962122827768326, -0.08156610280275345, -0.02246684953570366, -0.04491826891899109, -0.0003232434391975403, 0.014502966776490211, -0.041732318699359894, 0.02713312767446041, -0.010076558217406273, -0.015681298449635506, 0.00797541718930006, -0.02920074388384819, -0.048015035688877106, 0.017082642763853073, -0.035383567214012146, -0.001913187326863408, -0.03840794414281845, -0.061429962515830994, 0.005220732651650906, -0.01931145042181015, -0.0197463221848011, -0.0386756956577301, -0.0035547621082514524, -0.06523654609918594, 0.03795059397816658, 0.06859398633241653, -0.012002307921648026, -0.02748274803161621, -0.03508583456277847, 0.03563923016190529, 0.00820931326597929, -0.04340069368481636, 0.04743872210383415, 0.0180155448615551, 0.0274202860891819, 0.00714157335460186, 0.002654797863215208, 0.022223759442567825, -0.03086952120065689, 0.02101163938641548, -0.022288182750344276, 0.06976158916950226, 0.018409835174679756, -0.014341568574309349, 0.02432241290807724, 0.05971451476216316, -0.016225764527916908, 0.011949830688536167, 0.004755325615406036, -0.008619716390967369, -0.008050717413425446, 0.0036240138579159975, 0.03233518823981285, -0.012241597287356853, -0.013482118025422096, 0.05932364612817764, -0.08154377341270447, 0.006884656380861998, 0.0006363334832713008, -0.018145432695746422, -0.06625915318727493, 0.015145951882004738, 0.0034861562307924032, -0.04429293051362038, 0.027183067053556442, -0.014213262125849724, 0.0655583068728447, -0.016861792653799057, 0.0007753419922664762, -0.02542438730597496, -0.033338408917188644, 0.01983811892569065, -0.01640932261943817, -0.02603253908455372, 0.014574570581316948, -0.03422549366950989, 0.027786297723650932, -0.0019305242458358407, 0.027780288830399513, 0.02665511891245842, 0.015544562600553036, -0.030534815043210983, -0.058347541838884354, 0.0025257295928895473, 0.002469193423166871, 0.016084473580121994, 0.005807253997772932, -0.00819148775190115, -0.05652174353599548, 0.011063561774790287, -0.03821152076125145, -0.055556587874889374, 0.013141721487045288, 0.008032015524804592, -0.038888681679964066, -0.011464751325547695, -0.0007752379169687629, 0.006925250869244337, -0.01278719399124384, -0.018070049583911896, -0.028049951419234276, -0.06331399828195572, 0.014828518964350224, -0.0045058513060212135, -0.07401996105909348, 0.07024993747472763, -0.04525775834918022, -0.00500133354216814, -0.016096286475658417, 0.02111462689936161, 0.006410123780369759, 0.024643754586577415, -0.05341542512178421, -0.014634865336120129, 0.032966844737529755, -0.04402339458465576, -0.005067278631031513, -0.06907288730144501, 0.018816882744431496, -0.035303205251693726, -0.025395838543772697, -0.04655598849058151, 0.04306492209434509, -0.01353878527879715, -0.03628363832831383, 0.037016164511442184, -0.021400874480605125, 0.007204465102404356, 0.038093335926532745, -0.08908523619174957, -0.01912274770438671, 0.0361296646296978, -0.017271630465984344, -0.0062325503677129745, 0.03890072554349899, 0.006883534137159586, 0.04000990465283394, -0.037339989095926285, -0.0004493963497225195, 0.011546185240149498, 0.03389854356646538, -0.04348651319742203, 0.03065541572868824, 0.03495240584015846, -0.026348406448960304, -0.003636237932369113, 0.00879368744790554, -0.007344379555433989, 0.04554184153676033, -0.029406718909740448, 0.01798243075609207, 0.012828153558075428, 0.03453843668103218, -0.0056067947298288345, -0.009392859414219856, -0.009169960394501686, 0.02590952441096306, 0.06928616017103195, 0.02191079407930374, 0.002213799860328436, -0.014001804403960705, 0.04832789674401283, 0.008356384932994843, -0.024660276249051094, -0.0037663662806153297, -0.0033493912778794765, -0.021124983206391335, -0.06587392836809158, 0.010153481736779213, 0.01843379996716976, -0.03660829737782478, -0.0274204034358263, 0.03159978240728378, -0.021593334153294563, -0.0025977350305765867, 0.035090066492557526, 0.03251328319311142, -0.01869877241551876, 0.007680900394916534, -0.04398700222373009, 0.017868192866444588, -0.009684213437139988, -0.12910664081573486, -0.05726345255970955, 0.015470755286514759, -0.05347486585378647, 0.0001697616680758074, -0.04190392792224884, 0.036790210753679276, -0.023450549691915512, -0.05541785806417465, 0.0012991513358429074, -0.004486792255192995, 0.029172515496611595, 0.006024687085300684, -0.03483640402555466, -0.01391115877777338, -0.011007565073668957, 0.020810222253203392, -0.030599307268857956, 0.07653731107711792, -0.0328400693833828, 0.030508676543831825, -0.01428312435746193, 0.11479240655899048, -0.0059077078476548195, 0.004439591430127621, -0.08886002004146576, 0.04544432833790779, 0.027005447074770927, -0.06743383407592773, -0.006352805066853762, -0.062249984592199326, -0.04418197274208069, 0.06896363198757172, 0.017188526690006256, -0.02930266410112381, -0.042609333992004395, 0.03350088372826576, 0.05683552101254463, 0.054065607488155365, 0.028882397338747978, -0.01820376329123974, -0.08255310356616974, -0.010505475103855133, -0.0004877678002230823, 0.028442788869142532, 0.014185050502419472, 0.0019214283674955368, -0.009291823022067547, 0.013645468279719353, 0.020482484251260757, 0.031772397458553314, 0.007998114451766014, 0.0016128314891830087, 0.04021485894918442, -0.025674637407064438, -0.012797537259757519, -0.0205941554158926, -0.01662782020866871, 0.012862415984272957, 0.0007763421745039523, -0.02221049554646015, 0.03352442383766174, 0.0008421905222348869, -0.0019066710956394672, -0.0072956383228302, 0.03756538778543472, 0.019160376861691475, 0.07892449200153351, 0.01966789923608303, -0.024792876094579697, -0.0502195842564106, 0.0019055523443967104, 0.03664932772517204, -0.016294529661536217, 0.045245133340358734, -0.019786475226283073, 0.07792673259973526, 0.006175912916660309, -0.010156767442822456, -0.009973661974072456, 0.02706434205174446, -0.02427871897816658, -0.03119727037847042, 0.015285314060747623, 0.08566213399171829, 0.04099590331315994, -0.05089825764298439, 0.009916971437633038, -0.015055746771395206, -0.0420072115957737, 0.002328597940504551, -0.003718891879543662, 0.10593729466199875, -0.05521243438124657, 0.06502068042755127, 0.04251464083790779, -0.020263327285647392, 0.013100631535053253, -0.027604499831795692, -0.019026795402169228, 0.049471233040094376, -0.018118347972631454, 0.024753747507929802, 0.011723378673195839, -0.00181388680357486, -0.022369740530848503, -0.08024345338344574, 0.007962326519191265, 0.07028701156377792 ]
<p>We can see diffraction of light if we allow light to pass through a slit, but why doesn't diffraction occur if we obstruct light using some other object, say a block? Why are shadows formed? Why doesn't light diffract around the obstruction as it does around the slit?</p>
g1682
[ 0.020379995927214622, 0.03270424157381058, 0.008303424343466759, -0.012626644223928452, -0.014272002503275871, 0.014851569198071957, 0.026550181210041046, 0.09677832573652267, -0.028748271986842155, -0.03871604800224304, 0.05402795225381851, 0.02930445224046707, 0.012541687116026878, 0.0157322958111763, -0.005047758109867573, 0.03708312287926674, 0.027068261057138443, -0.038550522178411484, -0.010205729864537716, 0.036372289061546326, 0.020672887563705444, 0.011127278208732605, 0.024887116625905037, -0.0571100115776062, 0.0015533070545643568, 0.06880665570497513, 0.05534059554338455, -0.0537860170006752, -0.019104797393083572, 0.019969768822193146, 0.02494645118713379, -0.004744078032672405, 0.005152352154254913, -0.06430847197771072, -0.024008197709918022, 0.011396120302379131, 0.030636359006166458, -0.013347668573260307, 0.031293392181396484, 0.0049569872207939625, -0.011528923176229, 0.0295410118997097, -0.042224667966365814, -0.031606823205947876, -0.01281123049557209, -0.05478888377547264, -0.014048448763787746, 0.03770414739847183, 0.043310295790433884, -0.030393678694963455, 0.03709222748875618, 0.012363126501441002, -0.018326392397284508, 0.004439681302756071, 0.039936963468790054, -0.0015742362011224031, -0.0048345476388931274, 0.0014419301878660917, 0.11260098963975906, -0.005438496358692646, -0.019431794062256813, 0.012306412681937218, 0.02687928080558777, 0.04995033144950867, 0.043182313442230225, -0.005552780814468861, -0.02997652068734169, -0.019539806991815567, 0.060456834733486176, -0.017872756347060204, 0.027878334745764732, 0.030628155916929245, -0.01750541850924492, -0.022453416138887405, -0.020086906850337982, 0.03757039085030556, 0.016452554613351822, 0.08347334712743759, -0.020962832495570183, 0.04488829895853996, 0.03125505521893501, -0.0029134717769920826, -0.03413901478052139, 0.009231065399944782, 0.04927322641015053, 0.017682617530226707, -0.020855318754911423, -0.051061078906059265, 0.01820000447332859, 0.014408564195036888, 0.006268814671784639, 0.04215571656823158, 0.092400923371315, 0.02867058664560318, -0.028054334223270416, 0.0006517545552924275, -0.00486623914912343, 0.0010150492889806628, -0.057638052850961685, 0.05815155804157257, -0.005020547658205032, -0.04849172383546829, 0.022035446017980576, 0.05444236099720001, 0.055112048983573914, -0.009156441316008568, -0.004594283178448677, -0.0158814936876297, -0.002467456739395857, -0.007832430303096771, -0.013300704769790173, 0.000678884272929281, -0.03663187474012375, -0.0176584180444479, -0.005683222785592079, -0.04772697016596794, 0.06530022621154785, 0.011940112337470055, 0.038092099130153656, 0.02317208983004093, 0.0046361275017261505, 0.04553679749369621, -0.006957590114325285, 0.04717472195625305, 0.02539454959332943, 0.010267417877912521, 0.024601483717560768, -0.0023910675663501024, 0.07482171058654785, -0.018219610676169395, 0.02285335585474968, 0.04176154360175133, -0.058233924210071564, 0.047845128923654556, 0.037764597684144974, 0.006467811763286591, 0.07271426171064377, -0.033365435898303986, -0.0031766118481755257, -0.014889692887663841, -0.009445969946682453, 0.008351325988769531, 0.012989900074899197, -0.016912762075662613, -0.027700595557689667, -0.02375674992799759, -0.005559886340051889, 0.044503651559352875, -0.04801357537508011, 0.012033604085445404, -0.04572993144392967, 0.07713401317596436, -0.015755437314510345, 0.032700251787900925, -0.012242624536156654, -0.011542664840817451, 0.05845620483160019, -0.038806866854429245, -0.012139331549406052, 0.06659559905529022, 0.07328994572162628, 0.04065096750855446, -0.06597044318914413, 0.029776310548186302, -0.0520138293504715, -0.034569062292575836, -0.003274079877883196, -0.06777248531579971, 0.011268584989011288, -0.06317020952701569, -0.03458290547132492, 0.04354916512966156, -0.02482152171432972, 0.029596872627735138, 0.037920910865068436, 0.05157932639122009, 0.04626467451453209, 0.029939690604805946, 0.0328049473464489, 0.06841523200273514, -0.032814301550388336, -0.06251946091651917, 0.01589740626513958, -0.059511948376894, -0.035577043890953064, -0.049258094280958176, -0.015060782432556152, -0.04963143914937973, -0.04686813801527023, 0.023568643257021904, 0.016507970169186592, -0.0715327113866806, -0.005747698713093996, -0.0015586460940539837, -0.007762079127132893, -0.011130290105938911, 0.051532357931137085, -0.0160614512860775, 0.002901248401030898, -0.01023781020194292, -0.041424889117479324, 0.04821353033185005, 0.027172528207302094, 0.0398811399936676, -0.009125771932303905, 0.0547720231115818, -0.0739445611834526, 0.02584977261722088, 0.027097659185528755, 0.002320575760677457, -0.026929259300231934, -0.021161271259188652, 0.036385081708431244, -0.00905479583889246, -0.02338874526321888, 0.021869778633117676, 0.015479028224945068, -0.002772785723209381, -0.0404944121837616, 0.03932587057352066, -0.022194737568497658, -0.03505339100956917, -0.050404224544763565, -0.02600935474038124, -0.0519232377409935, 0.028132762759923935, -0.06084539741277695, -0.0004295223334338516, 0.022509591653943062, 0.027129193767905235, -0.06292910128831863, -0.049093376845121384, -0.027092233300209045, -0.03562178462743759, 0.05822349339723587, 0.018517734482884407, -0.05813226103782654, 0.07788129150867462, 0.03332121670246124, -0.04852043837308884, 0.019180580973625183, -0.04353310912847519, -0.030087817460298538, 0.02697848714888096, 0.03324446827173233, -0.0684402734041214, -0.03152960166335106, -0.034828394651412964, -0.004711020737886429, 0.00024853204376995564, -0.0041097491048276424, 0.04925554245710373, -0.014753746800124645, -0.01898283325135708, -0.02600335329771042, -0.08527787029743195, -0.00742753641679883, 0.03298585116863251, -0.020964737981557846, 0.00010835042485268787, -0.01140294224023819, 0.0023875378537923098, -0.014575737528502941, -0.032040152698755264, -0.03834841400384903, -0.015617186203598976, 0.05928950384259224, 0.008691363036632538, 0.03431684151291847, -0.018640870228409767, 0.016157465055584908, 0.0544210821390152, 0.03929408639669418, -0.026544589549303055, -0.00893567968159914, -0.03046487085521221, -0.021159129217267036, -0.04375386983156204, 0.04006442427635193, 0.020621323958039284, -0.020528504624962807, 0.018540997058153152, -0.06445053219795227, -0.023387696593999863, 0.079254150390625, -0.006970783695578575, -0.010594493709504604, -0.019357135519385338, 0.008631676435470581, -0.05319548770785332, -0.09006600826978683, 0.031958308070898056, -0.0573069304227829, 0.004719589836895466, 0.007676379755139351, 0.019566288217902184, -0.05705098435282707, 0.04999755322933197, -0.07336831092834473, -0.03593473508954048, -0.08235851675271988, 0.023157265037298203, -0.0061791124753654, 0.010644415393471718, 0.014950985088944435, -0.010594435036182404, 0.024842632934451103, -0.02987655997276306, 0.011640775017440319, 0.035910770297050476, 0.010100284591317177, 0.029419418424367905, 0.026554428040981293, 0.054240066558122635, -0.04013960063457489, -0.01639178767800331, 0.004354139324277639, 0.013722417876124382, -0.009453637525439262, 0.015208357945084572, 0.004305990878492594, 0.07477086037397385, -0.011365334503352642, -0.04598778113722801, 0.028611494228243828, -0.06412053853273392, 0.029502185061573982, 0.034999243915081024, 0.024698490276932716, -0.04006379470229149, 0.011385530233383179, -0.019651344045996666, -0.037497688084840775, -0.0124537143856287, -0.018501143902540207, -0.002820168621838093, 0.050715718418359756, -0.015945501625537872, 0.04353839159011841, -0.0019275053637102246, 0.03539680317044258, 0.02517104335129261, -0.06481555849313736, 0.02276867814362049, 0.022231565788388252, -0.02595331147313118, 0.004663496743887663, 0.005572110880166292, -0.002943238243460655, -0.0024464991874992847, 0.04307214915752411, 0.04662496596574783, -0.03428894281387329, -0.04490462318062782, -0.02818167954683304, 0.05456577241420746, 0.003329092636704445, 0.030057767406105995, 0.0698428750038147, -0.044112373143434525, 0.0478508435189724, -0.03252023458480835, 0.03732085973024368, -0.08296404033899307, -0.037993572652339935, 0.035694558173418045, 0.0920436903834343, -0.021016716957092285, -0.020496133714914322, 0.01563549041748047, 0.051671288907527924, -0.03141104802489281, -0.041747938841581345, -0.01232562493532896, 0.08413206785917282, -0.05418875068426132, 0.04394851624965668, 0.089779794216156, -0.006136752665042877, -0.028681788593530655, -0.02129352279007435, 0.000777640612795949, 0.022520732134580612, -0.01305931992828846, 0.028533169999718666, 0.006705248728394508, 0.06647040694952011, -0.006260909140110016, -0.009681022725999355, -0.05346667394042015, -0.05628640577197075, 0.05373876541852951, -0.012673744931817055, -0.00805374514311552, -0.032542381435632706, 0.028689878061413765, 0.00891285389661789, -0.023277990520000458, 0.002603505039587617, -0.02259773015975952, 0.06063355877995491, 0.01302459929138422, -0.03908031806349754, 0.000013565814697358292, -0.011900191195309162, 0.0012131249532103539, 0.0427987240254879, -0.023162417113780975, 0.007863372564315796, 0.036906830966472626, -0.016833508387207985, 0.03214849531650543, -0.048576243221759796, -0.0017800545319914818, -0.04969928786158562, 0.030913401395082474, 0.03954252973198891, 0.05809647589921951, -0.015499226748943329, -0.014846467413008213, 0.0040426854975521564, 0.01942342333495617, -0.004349829629063606, 0.02340644970536232, 0.02999792993068695, 0.06214532256126404, 0.0026458546053618193, -0.04229050129652023, -0.04045719653367996, -0.03141176328063011, -0.03972741961479187, 0.043914858251810074, -0.052486713975667953, -0.054657842963933945, -0.03252080827951431, -0.027944767847657204, -0.06665952503681183, 0.018655139952898026, 0.0002428749285172671, 0.05040661618113518, 0.032785966992378235, 0.005951496306806803, 0.0256047286093235, -0.01471568364650011, 0.017743142321705818, -0.017924821004271507, 0.001456103753298521, 0.0006832988001406193, 0.03394496440887451, 0.0230451337993145, -0.016586298123002052, -0.024904100224375725, -0.0011253060074523091, -0.04623841866850853, -0.05909182131290436, -0.02556738071143627, -0.011170616373419762, -0.015011164359748363, -0.0034728499595075846, 0.03670231252908707, -0.07028966397047043, 0.012996461242437363, 0.0033329627476632595, -0.03489984944462776, -0.00547857815399766, 0.02942848764359951, -0.015907762572169304, -0.01665453612804413, -0.03060363233089447, 0.008282558992505074, -0.0016602466348558664, 0.03973779082298279, -0.033999159932136536, 0.03916263207793236, 0.07202664762735367, 0.03984113782644272, -0.08500707149505615, 0.010073349811136723, -0.01869218423962593, -0.0226951465010643, 0.012481892481446266, 0.009753024205565453, 0.08011222630739212, -0.03435831516981125, -0.006693178787827492, -0.014663911424577236, -0.011642836034297943, 0.05984315276145935, -0.009546591900289059, -0.048478864133358, -0.019225388765335083, -0.029644237831234932, -0.010751067660748959, 0.010534312576055527, 0.010276048444211483, 0.028311925008893013, 0.054983194917440414, 0.08408088237047195, 0.0010253801010549068, -0.027036534622311592, -0.044934164732694626, -0.008304345421493053, -0.06240755319595337, -0.029315432533621788, 0.02492377907037735, 0.04719970375299454, 0.033477965742349625, -0.03353829309344292, 0.013046964071691036, 0.028439836576581, -0.010811425745487213, -0.05613795667886734, -0.0556827187538147, -0.011229388415813446, 0.03168577328324318, -0.018288282677531242, 0.013871969655156136, -0.03353993594646454, -0.02750106155872345, -0.01928452029824257, -0.03731084614992142, 0.005791526287794113, 0.012906464748084545, -0.01549743115901947, 0.08679106086492538, -0.0027484416496008635, -0.01645587757229805, 0.0031604685354977846, -0.037448905408382416, -0.004815302323549986, 0.00897978711873293, 0.03111959435045719, 0.03151893988251686, -0.012842768803238869, -0.028893906623125076, -0.023764584213495255, 0.03752770274877548, 0.014525074511766434, -0.021520327776670456, 0.01607547514140606, -0.012076492421329021, -0.032563306391239166, 0.029817020520567894, 0.057104334235191345, -0.013846321031451225, -0.027412036433815956, 0.014867161400616169, -0.02671690098941326, -0.02841087058186531, 0.011486813426017761, 0.03848522529006004, 0.02017015963792801, -0.06055425852537155, 0.015148770995438099, -0.04427105933427811, 0.06374456733465195, -0.03969598188996315, -0.056259635835886, -0.033962905406951904, -0.05523770675063133, 0.06269483268260956, 0.030487077310681343, -0.029698748141527176, -0.004030337557196617, 0.02223603054881096, -0.032382782548666, 0.004698764532804489, 0.010595892556011677, 0.024549592286348343, 0.031367819756269455, 0.007140922360122204, -0.04664020240306854, 0.0021799264941364527, 0.01853637583553791, 0.023589812219142914, 0.005893323104828596, -0.023073317483067513, -0.03796137496829033, -0.026545651257038116, -0.0010762133169919252, -0.007871323265135288, 0.0223899744451046, 0.041953641921281815, -0.05088796839118004, -0.045203231275081635, -0.00015158236783463508, -0.014961354434490204, 0.01438101101666689, 0.07703470438718796, -0.02694983407855034, -0.01862350106239319, -0.004785026423633099, -0.01887880265712738, -0.0220822561532259, 0.006162791978567839, -0.040393054485321045, 0.0007111811428330839, 0.07112772762775421, -0.003078919369727373, -0.024151286110281944, 0.03928839787840843, -0.069225013256073, 0.047701120376586914, 0.01269062701612711, 0.011734232306480408, 0.026818785816431046, -0.022499078884720802, -0.008492324501276016, 0.06400305032730103, -0.003127307165414095, 0.031082112342119217, 0.06792084127664566, 0.0013942830264568329, 0.009450889192521572, -0.06247077137231827, -0.06050054356455803, -0.07287289202213287, -0.04245597496628761, -0.021197205409407616, -0.032098498195409775, 0.011408871971070766, -0.01376123633235693, -0.038152601569890976, -0.03479817882180214, -0.02756338380277157, 0.01354767195880413, -0.05391423776745796, -0.014555665664374828, 0.052127450704574585, 0.058181773871183395, -0.035184938460588455, -0.029831107705831528, 0.010047528892755508, 0.01157541386783123, -0.03888849914073944, 0.050722911953926086, -0.03725169226527214, 0.06629061698913574, 0.008152895607054234, 0.03917710483074188, 0.05039599910378456, 0.030163820832967758, -0.00040769155020825565, 0.04682321473956108, -0.0022673748899251223, 0.04248053580522537, 0.020786043256521225, -0.010443060658872128, -0.0862671285867691, -0.05215955898165703, -0.01584811881184578, 0.005491076037287712, 0.004964008927345276, 0.009095058776438236, 0.016876140609383583, 0.004122378770262003, -0.04915262386202812, -0.018540026620030403, 0.003716512117534876, -0.05510453134775162, -0.04984699934720993, -0.030966151505708694, -0.045970261096954346, 0.04438425973057747, 0.006932214833796024, -0.005728298332542181, -0.0030379665549844503, -0.02170160785317421, -0.020863713696599007, 0.004494388587772846, 0.02973734214901924, -0.05841439217329025, 0.004690148402005434, 0.015031649731099606, 0.034048475325107574, -0.01863132044672966, -0.0001889318082248792, 0.061100758612155914, 0.0006371766794472933, -0.035704802721738815, -0.04065489023923874, 0.09016520529985428, -0.020759262144565582, -0.021865306422114372, -0.044445861130952835, -0.006994280498474836, 0.032993756234645844, -0.019462114199995995, -0.012220140546560287, -0.03909983113408089, -0.019922055304050446, -0.006334443110972643, -0.017796119675040245, -0.038988225162029266, -0.005703201051801443, 0.010627982206642628, 0.08385911583900452, 0.002967746462672949, -0.0041482411324977875, 0.05580819398164749, -0.02748343162238598, -0.04650840908288956, -0.014910620637238026, -0.03061717003583908, 0.025747181847691536, -0.008011359721422195, -0.000492895080242306, 0.046778228133916855, -0.02726460061967373, 0.00754170399159193, 0.053164493292570114, 0.0197712741792202, 0.019417067989706993, 0.008117230609059334, -0.01813352480530739, 0.020963838323950768, -0.026297058910131454, 0.014389939606189728, 0.0011142815928906202, 0.04785357788205147, 0.023790638893842697, -0.06839863210916519, -0.026774121448397636, -0.04201146960258484, -0.023143667727708817, -0.02683193050324917, 0.09269487112760544, -0.003278444753959775, -0.04342440888285637, -0.000536506820935756, 0.05794890969991684, 0.04471410810947418, -0.008505698293447495, -0.027051499113440514, -0.03427597135305405, 0.005142549518495798, 0.00896309781819582, -0.04982609674334526, 0.03924594819545746, -0.02290170267224312, 0.04992934316396713, 0.05181322991847992, -0.046971794217824936, -0.005776362959295511, 0.050778284668922424, -0.029550572857260704, 0.013726074248552322, -0.01827053725719452, 0.01171896979212761, -0.002410427201539278, -0.0548940971493721, 0.04546978324651718, -0.028861697763204575, 0.019166145473718643, 0.08700396120548248, -0.06580883264541626, -0.0467122346162796, -0.042788464576005936, -0.03973659500479698, 0.016063181683421135, 0.014163446612656116, 0.0064607043750584126, -0.024117806926369667, -0.015966210514307022, -0.03918571397662163, -0.008323549292981625, -0.030400296673178673, -0.0005073823849670589 ]
<p>I have a friend who has just show me his medical prescription for hyperopia (farsightedness) correction and he needs glasses with 4,25 diopters for that, which seemed to be weird for me because I had learned, from the mirror equation, that the maximum correction possible for hyperopia is 4 diopters:</p> <p>$$ \frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{p} + \frac{1}{p'} $$</p> <p>If we have $0.25m$ for the normal eye distant point and more than $0.25m$ for the farsighted eye distant point (negative sign, because it's a virtual image), then we would have:</p> <p>$$ \frac{1}{f} = \frac{1}{0.25} + \frac{1}{p'} = 4 - \frac{1}{|p'|} \in\quad ]0,4[, \quad\text{since}\quad |p'| \geq 0.25m \quad\text{and}\quad p'&lt;0 $$</p> <p>I did some google search and find out that, indeed, <a href="http://www.essilor.com/EN/EYEHEALTH/VISIONDEFECTS/Pages/Hyperopia.aspx" rel="nofollow">hyperopia can reach values even greater, such as 20 diopters</a>, but I can't find pages where doctors explain that with equations or physics teachers explain how things really work in ophthalmology.</p> <p>Either I am doing some terrible mistake, or doctors are doing some terrible mistake, or this equation just don't apply to hyperopia at all... Which one is true?</p>
g1683
[ 0.030968734994530678, -0.0038195771630853415, -0.00528781907632947, -0.019066303968429565, -0.00010684475273592398, -0.02250717394053936, 0.01815132424235344, 0.05481073632836342, -0.009855891577899456, 0.007037182338535786, 0.01290095504373312, 0.006264274008572102, 0.11235775053501129, 0.014321163296699524, 0.01524470653384924, 0.035034794360399246, 0.041467875242233276, -0.032660771161317825, -0.012052889913320541, -0.0003263807448092848, 0.0068265171721577644, -0.01912182755768299, -0.01553499698638916, -0.042412169277668, -0.08108103275299072, -0.023697102442383766, 0.01806742697954178, -0.009162441827356815, -0.038097869604825974, 0.06556626409292221, 0.028533032163977623, 0.025568092241883278, 0.034387052059173584, -0.06509710103273392, -0.023419447243213654, 0.001968917204067111, 0.07134614139795303, 0.0014379489002749324, 0.051418788731098175, 0.01039305329322815, -0.02281883917748928, 0.01027736533433199, -0.0016602438408881426, -0.03611651435494423, 0.024741297587752342, -0.0013379626907408237, -0.00798766314983368, 0.011477159336209297, 0.010515602305531502, -0.04425690695643425, 0.03173525631427765, 0.04541220888495445, 0.02286878228187561, 0.012828825041651726, -0.01725286804139614, 0.03658948466181755, 0.005667122080922127, -0.02789461798965931, 0.10107532888650894, 0.05094113200902939, 0.008336123079061508, -0.04628142714500427, 0.015291566029191017, 0.06700004637241364, 0.017065616324543953, 0.05152277275919914, -0.006886597257107496, 0.002272107172757387, 0.05299052968621254, -0.02065070904791355, 0.04581592231988907, -0.013026791624724865, -0.02066439762711525, -0.03518331050872803, -0.0052534122951328754, 0.010699295438826084, 0.0017413742607459426, -0.007920019328594208, -0.020952755585312843, 0.021867576986551285, -0.012725891545414925, -0.0005197209538891912, -0.04141513630747795, 0.023215578868985176, 0.023185929283499718, 0.0010941444197669625, 0.012172968126833439, 0.03707726672291756, 0.02779018133878708, -0.012431159615516663, 0.02275872603058815, 0.040104255080223083, -0.006151808891445398, -0.00205614254809916, 0.04343445226550102, -0.013624768704175949, 0.013311360962688923, -0.036014556884765625, -0.08455969393253326, -0.04501788690686226, -0.02047974057495594, -0.020657004788517952, 0.056766003370285034, -0.012694035656750202, -0.03415772691369057, 0.014692098833620548, 0.07487144321203232, 0.00896871741861105, -0.03227514773607254, -0.032162826508283615, -0.05860545113682747, -0.027714980766177177, 0.0004227574681863189, -0.06950239092111588, -0.1015380397439003, -0.03712703287601471, 0.01090821623802185, 0.0457305945456028, -0.009439888410270214, 0.0009523272747173905, 0.04541323333978653, 0.05682724341750145, -0.013403310440480709, 0.10414920002222061, 0.00208573741838336, 0.02478184551000595, -0.02292816713452339, -0.008449610322713852, 0.027837080880999565, 0.031848322600126266, -0.02432994917035103, -0.00859072431921959, 0.037608347833156586, -0.03433743491768837, -0.04880454018712044, 0.03413534164428711, 0.06600289791822433, -0.022689396515488625, -0.008239604532718658, 0.03328521549701691, -0.02368914894759655, -0.0042187669314444065, 0.09565553814172745, -0.012507212348282337, -0.06402678042650223, -0.05634003132581711, -0.024525925517082214, 0.03568264842033386, 0.03944140672683716, -0.05994990095496178, 0.022860677912831306, 0.027411658316850662, 0.036896806210279465, 0.005198428872972727, -0.023959321901202202, 0.01429689396172762, -0.05359231308102608, -0.0017094755312427878, 0.019855165854096413, -0.0011982751311734319, 0.08031734079122543, 0.03318672999739647, -0.004021280910819769, 0.0041225021705031395, -0.07330535352230072, 0.01366786751896143, -0.021317044273018837, 0.007076089736074209, -0.03789776191115379, 0.008978771977126598, -0.08589781820774078, -0.044400326907634735, 0.07076067477464676, 0.017564209178090096, 0.032551828771829605, 0.046905167400836945, 0.008285492658615112, 0.016639113426208496, -0.04558983072638512, 0.09779538214206696, 0.002500950125977397, 0.009389406070113182, 0.01265912875533104, -0.0035989468451589346, -0.008232725784182549, 0.033988405019044876, 0.012611416168510914, -0.05118612200021744, -0.015507587231695652, 0.021607156842947006, -0.01804998330771923, 0.03436446934938431, 0.05323636531829834, 0.02209295891225338, 0.05479983985424042, 0.05567179620265961, -0.012579512782394886, -0.06265661865472794, -0.01644490845501423, 0.017939941957592964, -0.0345771461725235, 0.021852167323231697, 0.05435575917363167, -0.006141018122434616, -0.009891989640891552, 0.007857643067836761, 0.016172029078006744, -0.0035393699072301388, 0.010494866408407688, -0.03360512852668762, -0.03603554889559746, -0.01910981349647045, -0.02052428014576435, 0.018391331657767296, 0.003905814839527011, -0.020041272044181824, -0.059549298137426376, -0.01913435384631157, -0.05120698735117912, -0.006225129123777151, -0.004300409462302923, -0.00299933273345232, 0.067967489361763, -0.013811334036290646, 0.018622953444719315, 0.0156661756336689, -0.01566978357732296, -0.06119108572602272, 0.05934889614582062, 0.014432408846914768, -0.02517840638756752, -0.022772986441850662, -0.00513097271323204, -0.04954501986503601, 0.02236456796526909, -0.0015412125503644347, 0.04730704799294472, 0.06368578225374222, -0.004487157333642244, 0.06082608923316002, 0.046313025057315826, -0.0245820302516222, -0.06950896233320236, -0.011002136394381523, -0.004559271968901157, -0.03909791260957718, -0.02201700024306774, 0.013403017073869705, -0.051112234592437744, 0.06639212369918823, -0.004694462288171053, 0.04835515469312668, 0.02379850670695305, 0.003388667944818735, -0.019334517419338226, 0.0339658260345459, -0.0333833247423172, 0.05866864696145058, -0.03519822284579277, 0.01028550323098898, -0.033573273569345474, 0.07904470711946487, 0.06523100286722183, -0.040954235941171646, -0.08350834995508194, 0.0024141387548297644, -0.025438204407691956, 0.037109192460775375, 0.024258263409137726, 0.025037646293640137, 0.04953422769904137, 0.04822683334350586, -0.0027935223188251257, 0.03798061981797218, -0.0048396773636341095, 0.008576614782214165, -0.005751685705035925, -0.005028276704251766, 0.023968815803527832, -0.004936030600219965, -0.027951650321483612, 0.01229445356875658, -0.051803287118673325, -0.018472470343112946, 0.05146650969982147, -0.010171349160373211, 0.000040563045331509784, -0.02357749454677105, -0.003467290196567774, -0.002648564986884594, -0.04703924432396889, 0.020099228248000145, -0.00787440687417984, 0.0016641400288790464, -0.000838175299577415, 0.02640576660633087, 0.06564194709062576, 0.0023436960764229298, 0.010904517024755478, 0.02412097156047821, -0.05250876769423485, 0.013894110918045044, 0.008550595492124557, 0.0016500588972121477, 0.0500909686088562, 0.022561507299542427, -0.023008262738585472, -0.08604006469249725, 0.03665173426270485, -0.007569092325866222, -0.0008640026790089905, 0.057811617851257324, -0.037767887115478516, 0.031508732587099075, 0.013885182328522205, 0.00784575380384922, 0.028824064880609512, -0.009746779687702656, 0.028051426634192467, -0.038039181381464005, -0.03664964437484741, 0.011691397055983543, -0.07027339190244675, -0.02587788552045822, -0.0005565717001445591, -0.013419640250504017, -0.005366817116737366, -0.010710651986300945, -0.06644376367330551, 0.05102023109793663, 0.09889110922813416, -0.020112736150622368, -0.039964012801647186, -0.0247678030282259, -0.013196474872529507, -0.009552567265927792, -0.026416050270199776, 0.026090869680047035, 0.047270894050598145, -0.04235345870256424, 0.010679681785404682, 0.027423696592450142, -0.0735548734664917, -0.058849968016147614, 0.044949181377887726, 0.03687889128923416, -0.03660929575562477, 0.07914894074201584, 0.0048452881164848804, -0.01456853561103344, 0.0045870705507695675, 0.018554098904132843, -0.03167637437582016, -0.039266735315322876, 0.01635602116584778, -0.017041340470314026, 0.049178287386894226, 0.06333141773939133, 0.010593115352094173, -0.002376361284404993, 0.05286891385912895, 0.0016318941488862038, -0.010523895733058453, -0.01992160640656948, -0.01301634032279253, -0.010097038000822067, 0.005005696322768927, 0.0018179705366492271, -0.03344043344259262, -0.044383756816387177, -0.007561769802123308, -0.05372956022620201, -0.02067498490214348, 0.021994052454829216, -0.02131025679409504, -0.014502760022878647, 0.04035424813628197, -0.060850754380226135, -0.05637471750378609, 0.030043020844459534, 0.047431305050849915, 0.008476189337670803, 0.023289205506443977, -0.029631715267896652, -0.005494306795299053, 0.014468293637037277, -0.021123459562659264, -0.10978712886571884, 0.0011819421779364347, 0.03135028854012489, 0.03966386616230011, -0.06864692270755768, 0.0313718281686306, 0.06058572605252266, 0.00013584834232460707, 0.0004694056115113199, -0.03844866901636124, -0.00845897663384676, -0.0037045928183943033, 0.010579366236925125, 0.02832834981381893, 0.022626081481575966, 0.0469653494656086, 0.05345603823661804, -0.019828198477625847, -0.03181692585349083, 0.045843906700611115, 0.058710988610982895, -0.032288823276758194, 0.027654418721795082, -0.002711112843826413, 0.03050999715924263, 0.013614681549370289, -0.08355095237493515, 0.0305409487336874, 0.11128143221139908, -0.006243525072932243, -0.03263353183865547, 0.09778741747140884, 0.009927963837981224, -0.00011563302541617304, 0.029389891773462296, -0.018342381343245506, -0.017616217955946922, 0.05748714879155159, 0.07621686905622482, 0.013275067321956158, -0.054410796612501144, -0.005176391918212175, -0.014493614435195923, 0.05860811099410057, 0.028543202206492424, 0.007712380029261112, 0.061514705419540405, 0.006703213322907686, 0.06792835891246796, -0.018431618809700012, 0.007979068905115128, -0.009090167470276356, 0.032826684415340424, 0.010278740897774696, 0.05140160396695137, 0.043377265334129333, -0.03725632652640343, 0.0076305619440972805, -0.020343217998743057, -0.0510617271065712, -0.011548110283911228, -0.019654888659715652, 0.013680133037269115, -0.004066250752657652, 0.004436714109033346, 0.03840013965964317, -0.037800900638103485, -0.005183296278119087, -0.05150935798883438, -0.02069215103983879, 0.04820198193192482, -0.00694107823073864, 0.021617036312818527, -0.01483164168894291, -0.008957314305007458, -0.0390009768307209, 0.03636981546878815, 0.05628912150859833, -0.01600617729127407, -0.006327667739242315, -0.05393941327929497, -0.04851068556308746, -0.026761231943964958, -0.005079471040517092, -0.007722184062004089, -0.017476053908467293, 0.03982021287083626, -0.046075183898210526, -0.033161211758852005, -0.041488055139780045, 0.003676067339256406, -0.04107101634144783, 0.008195122703909874, -0.025456424802541733, 0.02278333343565464, 0.052563559263944626, -0.016912097111344337, -0.01512838527560234, 0.014360384084284306, -0.007420270703732967, 0.024069052189588547, 0.01345650665462017, -0.056312140077352524, -0.03458436205983162, -0.0057437666691839695, -0.005755916237831116, -0.010849195532500744, -0.010437175631523132, 0.03207777068018913, 0.012461374513804913, 0.03497358784079552, -0.0004547767457552254, 0.012929813005030155, -0.009705777280032635, 0.02383003570139408, -0.010225034318864346, -0.07877989858388901, 0.01139893103390932, 0.045866455882787704, 0.0712488517165184, -0.044677071273326874, 0.017142534255981445, 0.04109825938940048, 0.021046241745352745, -0.050091084092855453, 0.08411125093698502, 0.016950400546193123, -0.0003445630136411637, -0.0348101444542408, -0.04010898247361183, 0.02341490052640438, -0.007933251559734344, -0.047911252826452255, 0.011233547702431679, -0.020667029544711113, 0.00648002652451396, 0.05141418054699898, -0.03827863931655884, -0.01879265531897545, -0.02470775693655014, -0.029623160138726234, -0.005435010883957148, -0.029184242710471153, 0.010991458781063557, 0.020965931937098503, 0.027574792504310608, 0.01872265711426735, -0.02137787453830242, -0.0041234660893678665, -0.01925252191722393, 0.027788646519184113, 0.05817580595612526, 0.01790573261678219, 0.010362616740167141, 0.028089025989174843, 0.017966371029615402, 0.05739855766296387, 0.005146127659827471, 0.004746148828417063, -0.029689213261008263, 0.012469461187720299, 0.02536970190703869, 0.0252237468957901, -0.03406320884823799, 0.0036919298581779003, -0.013576682657003403, -0.02436028979718685, 0.0041416301392018795, 0.0519697479903698, 0.007530911825597286, 0.01200491189956665, 0.00816131941974163, -0.0648091584444046, 0.009964761324226856, 0.010011053644120693, -0.03735625743865967, -0.056329380720853806, -0.029840169474482536, -0.03505857288837433, 0.020700499415397644, 0.012706312350928783, 0.024287410080432892, -0.017073146998882294, -0.017732936888933182, -0.0026392925065010786, -0.005991332232952118, 0.0047613647766411304, 0.020884674042463303, 0.02830045484006405, 0.0030335914343595505, -0.03361521288752556, -0.009355542249977589, -0.020875869318842888, -0.0410144105553627, -0.017041737213730812, -0.02547893300652504, 0.0012624466326087713, -0.024457208812236786, -0.002846056129783392, -0.0691087394952774, 0.0005277739255689085, -0.02762463502585888, -0.06971690058708191, -0.029548553749918938, -0.0005799741484224796, -0.014804134145379066, -0.007554450538009405, 0.019326185807585716, -0.04921986535191536, 0.035139117389917374, 0.0461944118142128, -0.08282764256000519, 0.007326140534132719, 0.028521878644824028, 0.0032998172100633383, 0.04319185018539429, 0.01755070686340332, 0.037174660712480545, -0.00569385988637805, -0.04585779830813408, 0.05371575802564621, -0.023710807785391808, -0.05573544278740883, 0.029343118891119957, 0.04160163924098015, 0.0025497651658952236, 0.04621683806180954, -0.008330319076776505, -0.04379501938819885, 0.004313156008720398, 0.02358585223555565, -0.05559185892343521, -0.022310232743620872, 0.0075897169299423695, -0.04906720668077469, -0.005703060422092676, -0.06625047326087952, 0.008367585949599743, 0.015982024371623993, 0.057479970157146454, -0.029460256919264793, 0.031219083815813065, -0.006963815540075302, -0.01900406740605831, -0.10865936428308487, -0.03790783882141113, 0.049378883093595505, -0.004791840445250273, 0.03791140019893646, -0.055449873208999634, -0.007136797998100519, -0.015335794538259506, 0.008668546564877033, -0.011681072413921356, -0.05211910605430603, 0.004443906247615814, -0.016802946105599403, -0.03403187543153763, -0.004881212022155523, -0.024788694456219673, -0.010944264009594917, -0.10332790017127991, -0.006394187454134226, -0.005783626809716225, -0.046828389167785645, 0.014868590049445629, 0.06566814333200455, -0.02786371111869812, 0.018407227471470833, -0.06917595863342285, 0.0614919476211071, 0.02729269489645958, -0.06281402707099915, 0.034753333777189255, 0.029269469901919365, 0.02207961305975914, 0.022706540301442146, -0.005347453057765961, -0.022909585386514664, -0.01704839989542961, -0.04831511154770851, -0.01390343438833952, -0.06126983463764191, 0.02967565320432186, -0.00543949194252491, -0.040433451533317566, 0.009968616999685764, 0.05526741221547127, 0.006660879589617252, -0.03776809200644493, -0.0017930807080119848, -0.01205449178814888, 0.01526712067425251, -0.011371338739991188, 0.019173894077539444, 0.018640071153640747, -0.03206760808825493, -0.10734710842370987, 0.005154604557901621, 0.024539107456803322, 0.001471534837037325, -0.009764543734490871, 0.03425121679902077, -0.014290759339928627, -0.016843732446432114, 0.04452922195196152, -0.01184315700083971, -0.004313879180699587, 0.005609131883829832, 0.051056183874607086, 0.028071587905287743, 0.007405928801745176, -0.08261986821889877, -0.0008451117319054902, -0.05747026205062866, 0.013617067597806454, -0.03216586634516716, 0.03804314509034157, 0.04035785049200058, -0.029414642602205276, 0.00836985930800438, 0.004311375319957733, -0.02636401541531086, 0.006004737224429846, -0.01772010698914528, -0.016255341470241547, -0.022496342658996582, 0.028259271755814552, -0.0037903052289038897, -0.026022031903266907, -0.024650204926729202, -0.030354537069797516, -0.003378510707989335, 0.014643212780356407, -0.00547826336696744, -0.02175271138548851, -0.11569013446569443, -0.07500584423542023, 0.020911065861582756, -0.028882289305329323, -0.03567418456077576, 0.013093194924294949, -0.03728250041604042, 0.004000143148005009, 0.0180725809186697, -0.060237251222133636, 0.03711824119091034, 0.02090965025126934, -0.01066385768353939, -0.03412407264113426, -0.018395166844129562, -0.02413131482899189, 0.055576831102371216, 0.04535936936736107, -0.0767490342259407, 0.003996032290160656, -0.05450861528515816, 0.003724857000634074, 0.002226775512099266, -0.04193315654993057, 0.006572520360350609, 0.009479825384914875, -0.008175666444003582, -0.036541327834129333, 0.0838208720088005, 0.013001244515180588, 0.010364566929638386, 0.03823748975992203, -0.019571490585803986, 0.06598673015832901, -0.038632217794656754, 0.05929809808731079, 0.01424364373087883, 0.004743577446788549, -0.025837337598204613, 0.031623587012290955, 0.045039284974336624, -0.0032976598013192415, -0.05763848125934601, -0.04834860935807228, 0.005555720534175634 ]