Datasets:
bowen-upenn
/
GeoGrid_Bench

Dataset card Data Studio Files
xet
Community
1
Question ID
stringlengths
36
36
Question
stringlengths
147
367
Type
stringclasses
7 values
data_modality
stringclasses
4 values
image_path
stringlengths
58
77
⌀
Radius
int64
48
72
Correct Answer
stringclasses
4 values
All Options
stringlengths
165
1.21k
Data Titles
stringclasses
256 values
Data 1
stringclasses
560 values
Data 2
stringclasses
514 values
Data 3
stringclasses
294 values
Data 4
stringclasses
305 values
Data 5
stringclasses
87 values
Data 6
stringclasses
87 values
Data 7
stringclasses
87 values
Data 8
stringclasses
87 values
Filled Values
stringclasses
544 values
Template Question
stringclasses
8 values
Filled Template Question
stringclasses
563 values
a617a32f-268c-4428-b9f1-a44901782ff9
As a meteorologist preparing for a conference on regional temperature trends, I'm curious to know which city experienced a greater shift in maximum annual temperature during the historical period and the mid-century period under RCP4.5: Bakersfield, CA, or Brownsville, TX?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1369/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(b) The Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Bakersfield, CA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Bakersfield, CA, United States experienced a greater change than Brownsville, TX, United States.']
['Bakersfield, CA, United States in historical period', 'Bakersfield, CA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in historical period', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"199":{"119":76.98590088,"118":77.10050201,"117":77.38569641,"116":77.17839813,"115":76.57530212,"114":76.45659637,"113":74.78220367,"112":69.0759964},"200":{"119":76.83719635,"118":76.94539642,"117":77.11650085,"116":77.31800079,"115":77.56069946,"114":78.18859863,"113":77.626297,"112":71.06839752},"201":{"119":76.70410156,"118":76.65869904,"117":76.77539825,"116":77.15879822,"115":77.77510071,"114":78.45449829,"113":78.10099792,"112":73.0134964},"202":{"119":76.30560303,"118":75.83660126,"117":75.8003006,"116":76.4917984,"115":77.84940338,"114":78.42510223,"113":78.57009888,"112":75.55509949},"203":{"119":null,"118":72.98500061,"117":72.55979919,"116":73.92790222,"115":76.00900269,"114":76.95320129,"113":76.18900299,"112":73.6332016},"204":{"119":null,"118":67.62419891,"117":66.62519836,"116":68.08380127,"115":70.80709839,"114":71.83809662,"113":69.38089752,"112":65.39900208},"205":{"119":null,"118":60.9917984,"117":61.50880051,"116":62.64410019,"115":64.4571991,"114":66.19529724,"113":63.34769821,"112":58.96870041}}
{"199":{"119":79.83270264,"118":79.95909882,"117":80.24089813,"116":80.07640076,"115":79.5164032,"114":79.41899872,"113":77.67790222,"112":72.11100006},"200":{"119":79.75219727,"118":79.896698,"117":80.07219696,"116":80.28089905,"115":80.59570313,"114":81.28140259,"113":80.57209778,"112":74.06279755},"201":{"119":79.61470032,"118":79.55259705,"117":79.69989777,"116":80.14019775,"115":80.78669739,"114":81.58679962,"113":81.21970367,"112":75.99019623},"202":{"119":79.25859833,"118":78.79370117,"117":78.83329773,"116":79.54129791,"115":80.91059875,"114":81.64389801,"113":81.80370331,"112":78.73799896},"203":{"119":null,"118":76.06739807,"117":75.75730133,"116":77.13890076,"115":79.2358017,"114":80.13580322,"113":79.4763031,"112":76.85220337},"204":{"119":null,"118":70.81159973,"117":69.79850006,"116":71.26850128,"115":74.05909729,"114":74.99919891,"113":72.52020264,"112":68.40450287},"205":{"119":null,"118":64.05329895,"117":64.4536972,"116":65.59120178,"115":67.50060272,"114":69.17250061,"113":66.20420074,"112":61.84609985}}
{"367":{"29":80.68900299,"28":80.72270203,"27":80.80560303,"26":null},"368":{"29":80.46060181,"28":80.45130157,"27":80.5585022,"26":null},"369":{"29":80.09410095,"28":80.20960236,"27":80.2492981,"26":null},"370":{"29":79.64420319,"28":79.77970123,"27":79.81330109,"26":79.95950317},"371":{"29":78.94400024,"28":79.08380127,"27":79.45600128,"26":79.46260071},"372":{"29":77.62509918,"28":78.1013031,"27":78.81939697,"26":78.96970367},"373":{"29":75.30370331,"28":75.60119629,"27":78.16190338,"26":78.30390167},"374":{"29":75.45220184,"28":75.49710083,"27":75.64199829,"26":null}}
{"367":{"29":82.37689972,"28":82.42089844,"27":82.4536972,"26":null},"368":{"29":82.15550232,"28":82.17680359,"27":82.21379852,"26":null},"369":{"29":81.82409668,"28":81.97579956,"27":81.91230011,"26":null},"370":{"29":81.27639771,"28":81.47599792,"27":81.4763031,"26":81.51170349},"371":{"29":80.48090363,"28":80.64859772,"27":81.05470276,"26":81.03230286},"372":{"29":79.08940125,"28":79.57080078,"27":80.36579895,"26":80.51589966},"373":{"29":76.77510071,"28":77.09660339,"27":79.46749878,"26":79.69259644},"374":{"29":76.90019989,"28":76.92269897,"27":77.06390381,"26":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Bakersfield, CA, United States", "location2": "Brownsville, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bakersfield, CA, United States or Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout historical period and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
c81ee041-09f3-4a29-9778-abf378ccfc14
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns for an urban development project, I need to determine which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-century projections under RCP8.5 to historical data.
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":76.80899811,"223":63.7405014,"222":57.93790054,"221":57.35969925,"220":57.9367981,"219":null},"191":{"227":109.78199768,"226":110.21499634,"225":97.62419891,"224":77.62220001,"223":62.66460037,"222":55.58480072,"221":52.57939911,"220":50.89310074,"219":null},"192":{"227":111.32499695,"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":44.52009964,"219":41.58359909},"193":{"227":105.5490036,"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":43.75419998,"219":40.64630127},"194":{"227":76.30419922,"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896,"219":46.46749878},"195":{"227":49.64609909,"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008,"219":53.54719925},"196":{"227":37.54729843,"226":43.49380112,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132,"219":55.09769821},"197":{"227":33.20529938,"226":37.61159897,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935,"219":51.03340149},"198":{"227":null,"226":38.66460037,"225":38.56840134,"224":42.47439957,"223":37.58670044,"222":38.23669815,"221":38.8891983,"220":42.3465004,"219":50.05849838}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":73.72429657,"75":85.45379639,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":58.42879868,"75":64.79820251,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":47.47660065,"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123,"67":null},"490":{"77":43.72660065,"76":42.19829941,"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074,"67":66.04859924},"491":{"77":39.99969864,"76":42.07929993,"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888,"67":57.87739944},"492":{"77":36.38180161,"76":40.30820084,"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821,"67":49.98289871},"493":{"77":34.9939003,"76":35.90710068,"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067,"67":46.26240158},"494":{"77":34.29309845,"76":34.87110138,"75":35.52619934,"74":34.89860153,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888,"67":42.45920181},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":33.71820068,"74":33.22689819,"73":33.40169907,"72":33.82920074,"71":33.73949814,"70":34.97389984,"69":35.13270187,"68":37.32540131,"67":40.68880081},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":33.10710144,"71":32.64690018,"70":33.81620026,"69":34.33369827,"68":36.24530029,"67":38.40190125}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
eae7d44b-89e4-47a1-b7a9-67adf48cc474
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns for an urban development project, I need to determine which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-century projections under RCP8.5 to historical data.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":76.80899811,"223":63.7405014,"222":57.93790054,"221":57.35969925,"220":57.9367981,"219":null},"191":{"227":109.78199768,"226":110.21499634,"225":97.62419891,"224":77.62220001,"223":62.66460037,"222":55.58480072,"221":52.57939911,"220":50.89310074,"219":null},"192":{"227":111.32499695,"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":44.52009964,"219":41.58359909},"193":{"227":105.5490036,"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":43.75419998,"219":40.64630127},"194":{"227":76.30419922,"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896,"219":46.46749878},"195":{"227":49.64609909,"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008,"219":53.54719925},"196":{"227":37.54729843,"226":43.49380112,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132,"219":55.09769821},"197":{"227":33.20529938,"226":37.61159897,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935,"219":51.03340149},"198":{"227":null,"226":38.66460037,"225":38.56840134,"224":42.47439957,"223":37.58670044,"222":38.23669815,"221":38.8891983,"220":42.3465004,"219":50.05849838}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":73.72429657,"75":85.45379639,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":58.42879868,"75":64.79820251,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":47.47660065,"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123,"67":null},"490":{"77":43.72660065,"76":42.19829941,"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074,"67":66.04859924},"491":{"77":39.99969864,"76":42.07929993,"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888,"67":57.87739944},"492":{"77":36.38180161,"76":40.30820084,"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821,"67":49.98289871},"493":{"77":34.9939003,"76":35.90710068,"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067,"67":46.26240158},"494":{"77":34.29309845,"76":34.87110138,"75":35.52619934,"74":34.89860153,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888,"67":42.45920181},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":33.71820068,"74":33.22689819,"73":33.40169907,"72":33.82920074,"71":33.73949814,"70":34.97389984,"69":35.13270187,"68":37.32540131,"67":40.68880081},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":33.10710144,"71":32.64690018,"70":33.81620026,"69":34.33369827,"68":36.24530029,"67":38.40190125}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
e45c8207-b915-47a4-a1c0-63c451402a09
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns for an urban development project, I need to determine which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-century projections under RCP8.5 to historical data.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":76.80899811,"223":63.7405014,"222":57.93790054,"221":57.35969925,"220":57.9367981,"219":null},"191":{"227":109.78199768,"226":110.21499634,"225":97.62419891,"224":77.62220001,"223":62.66460037,"222":55.58480072,"221":52.57939911,"220":50.89310074,"219":null},"192":{"227":111.32499695,"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":44.52009964,"219":41.58359909},"193":{"227":105.5490036,"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":43.75419998,"219":40.64630127},"194":{"227":76.30419922,"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896,"219":46.46749878},"195":{"227":49.64609909,"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008,"219":53.54719925},"196":{"227":37.54729843,"226":43.49380112,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132,"219":55.09769821},"197":{"227":33.20529938,"226":37.61159897,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935,"219":51.03340149},"198":{"227":null,"226":38.66460037,"225":38.56840134,"224":42.47439957,"223":37.58670044,"222":38.23669815,"221":38.8891983,"220":42.3465004,"219":50.05849838}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":73.72429657,"75":85.45379639,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":58.42879868,"75":64.79820251,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":47.47660065,"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123,"67":null},"490":{"77":43.72660065,"76":42.19829941,"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074,"67":66.04859924},"491":{"77":39.99969864,"76":42.07929993,"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888,"67":57.87739944},"492":{"77":36.38180161,"76":40.30820084,"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821,"67":49.98289871},"493":{"77":34.9939003,"76":35.90710068,"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067,"67":46.26240158},"494":{"77":34.29309845,"76":34.87110138,"75":35.52619934,"74":34.89860153,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888,"67":42.45920181},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":33.71820068,"74":33.22689819,"73":33.40169907,"72":33.82920074,"71":33.73949814,"70":34.97389984,"69":35.13270187,"68":37.32540131,"67":40.68880081},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":33.10710144,"71":32.64690018,"70":33.81620026,"69":34.33369827,"68":36.24530029,"67":38.40190125}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
245d1901-0afb-4602-bc09-a7488650d51b
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns for an urban development project, I need to determine which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-century projections under RCP8.5 to historical data.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":76.80899811,"223":63.7405014,"222":57.93790054,"221":57.35969925,"220":57.9367981,"219":null},"191":{"227":109.78199768,"226":110.21499634,"225":97.62419891,"224":77.62220001,"223":62.66460037,"222":55.58480072,"221":52.57939911,"220":50.89310074,"219":null},"192":{"227":111.32499695,"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":44.52009964,"219":41.58359909},"193":{"227":105.5490036,"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":43.75419998,"219":40.64630127},"194":{"227":76.30419922,"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896,"219":46.46749878},"195":{"227":49.64609909,"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008,"219":53.54719925},"196":{"227":37.54729843,"226":43.49380112,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132,"219":55.09769821},"197":{"227":33.20529938,"226":37.61159897,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935,"219":51.03340149},"198":{"227":null,"226":38.66460037,"225":38.56840134,"224":42.47439957,"223":37.58670044,"222":38.23669815,"221":38.8891983,"220":42.3465004,"219":50.05849838}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":73.72429657,"75":85.45379639,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":58.42879868,"75":64.79820251,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":47.47660065,"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123,"67":null},"490":{"77":43.72660065,"76":42.19829941,"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074,"67":66.04859924},"491":{"77":39.99969864,"76":42.07929993,"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888,"67":57.87739944},"492":{"77":36.38180161,"76":40.30820084,"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821,"67":49.98289871},"493":{"77":34.9939003,"76":35.90710068,"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067,"67":46.26240158},"494":{"77":34.29309845,"76":34.87110138,"75":35.52619934,"74":34.89860153,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888,"67":42.45920181},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":33.71820068,"74":33.22689819,"73":33.40169907,"72":33.82920074,"71":33.73949814,"70":34.97389984,"69":35.13270187,"68":37.32540131,"67":40.68880081},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":33.10710144,"71":32.64690018,"70":33.81620026,"69":34.33369827,"68":36.24530029,"67":38.40190125}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
78daf741-d411-46fa-9279-0f6eacdb7503
As a wildland firefighter assessing future operational challenges, I need to know which location—Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA—has seen a more significant increase in the fire weather index during the autumn and summer of the end-century period?
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":24.41449928,"164":22.35910034,"163":21.82379913,"162":22.13579941,"161":23.44029999,"160":24.60300064,"159":18.81240082,"158":17.5848999,"157":19.70660019,"156":11.89239979},"302":{"165":23.22260094,"164":21.99300003,"163":20.63159943,"162":19.55520058,"161":17.06349945,"160":19.6541996,"159":20.94330025,"158":22.52949905,"157":22.77519989,"156":15.95349979},"303":{"165":24.69599915,"164":25.31200027,"163":23.18300056,"162":22.0666008,"161":19.95879936,"160":19.67320061,"159":21.3125,"158":24.31599998,"157":25.61020088,"156":24.27680016},"304":{"165":26.93400002,"164":25.31340027,"163":23.90589905,"162":23.42760086,"161":22.88059998,"160":21.77039909,"159":22.46489906,"158":24.63500023,"157":26.07749939,"156":26.17130089},"305":{"165":28.0298996,"164":25.98010063,"163":24.65990067,"162":24.21249962,"161":23.67230034,"160":23.03009987,"159":23.39620018,"158":24.66480064,"157":25.55509949,"156":25.96980095},"306":{"165":26.9015007,"164":26.07939911,"163":25.21890068,"162":24.75160027,"161":24.09219933,"160":23.24780083,"159":23.46380043,"158":24.48940086,"157":25.44650078,"156":25.88240051},"307":{"165":26.35840034,"164":26.06060028,"163":25.19050026,"162":24.9185009,"161":24.61009979,"160":23.92300034,"159":23.82909966,"158":24.65999985,"157":25.54059982,"156":26.14489937},"308":{"165":26.17099953,"164":25.91390038,"163":25.24029922,"162":24.92840004,"161":24.80859947,"160":24.64590073,"159":24.57419968,"158":24.93040085,"157":25.38979912,"156":26.01479912},"309":{"165":26.66469955,"164":26.16519928,"163":25.34390068,"162":25.12389946,"161":24.96220016,"160":25.06290054,"159":25.14959908,"158":25.49939919,"157":25.78849983,"156":null},"310":{"165":26.64119911,"164":25.88500023,"163":25.32719994,"162":25.33639908,"161":25.3560009,"160":25.07379913,"159":24.87599945,"158":25.12299919,"157":25.57320023,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":28.11730003,"225":31.21279907,"224":32.40010071,"223":32.86410141,"222":33.96049881,"221":35.85499954,"220":36.87620163,"219":null},"225":{"227":23.37779999,"226":26.42810059,"225":30.04780006,"224":31.72870064,"223":32.29059982,"222":33.22520065,"221":34.40370178,"220":35.74250031,"219":35.19839859},"226":{"227":23.86170006,"226":26.59499931,"225":30.4211998,"224":31.29910088,"223":31.8878994,"222":32.84529877,"221":33.45090103,"220":33.94710159,"219":34.05580139},"227":{"227":25.2534008,"226":25.78689957,"225":29.2507,"224":30.79439926,"223":31.69689941,"222":32.32460022,"221":32.69100189,"220":32.92039871,"219":33.01589966},"228":{"227":22.41239929,"226":25.87560081,"225":28.48539925,"224":29.46529961,"223":30.47389984,"222":31.65010071,"221":31.80540085,"220":31.79820061,"219":31.71859932},"229":{"227":22.76869965,"226":26.37179947,"225":27.14450073,"224":27.76720047,"223":29.42440033,"222":30.01989937,"221":30.19079971,"220":30.41679955,"219":30.40609932},"230":{"227":23.17830086,"226":23.61109924,"225":22.6257,"224":24.11709976,"223":27.4666996,"222":26.30439949,"221":28.63660049,"220":29.63599968,"219":29.10099983},"231":{"227":22.0102005,"226":21.86079979,"225":21.16049957,"224":23.14039993,"223":26.34350014,"222":24.71150017,"221":28.06360054,"220":28.63190079,"219":27.09480095},"232":{"227":20.80380058,"226":21.39819908,"225":21.91530037,"224":22.77750015,"223":23.82769966,"222":22.86790085,"221":24.55200005,"220":26.09289932,"219":24.29809952}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in end-century period?
cadb77e5-60a2-4c38-b11d-8943d837e669
As a wildland firefighter assessing future operational challenges, I need to know which location—Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA—has seen a more significant increase in the fire weather index during the autumn and summer of the end-century period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1240/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":24.41449928,"164":22.35910034,"163":21.82379913,"162":22.13579941,"161":23.44029999,"160":24.60300064,"159":18.81240082,"158":17.5848999,"157":19.70660019,"156":11.89239979},"302":{"165":23.22260094,"164":21.99300003,"163":20.63159943,"162":19.55520058,"161":17.06349945,"160":19.6541996,"159":20.94330025,"158":22.52949905,"157":22.77519989,"156":15.95349979},"303":{"165":24.69599915,"164":25.31200027,"163":23.18300056,"162":22.0666008,"161":19.95879936,"160":19.67320061,"159":21.3125,"158":24.31599998,"157":25.61020088,"156":24.27680016},"304":{"165":26.93400002,"164":25.31340027,"163":23.90589905,"162":23.42760086,"161":22.88059998,"160":21.77039909,"159":22.46489906,"158":24.63500023,"157":26.07749939,"156":26.17130089},"305":{"165":28.0298996,"164":25.98010063,"163":24.65990067,"162":24.21249962,"161":23.67230034,"160":23.03009987,"159":23.39620018,"158":24.66480064,"157":25.55509949,"156":25.96980095},"306":{"165":26.9015007,"164":26.07939911,"163":25.21890068,"162":24.75160027,"161":24.09219933,"160":23.24780083,"159":23.46380043,"158":24.48940086,"157":25.44650078,"156":25.88240051},"307":{"165":26.35840034,"164":26.06060028,"163":25.19050026,"162":24.9185009,"161":24.61009979,"160":23.92300034,"159":23.82909966,"158":24.65999985,"157":25.54059982,"156":26.14489937},"308":{"165":26.17099953,"164":25.91390038,"163":25.24029922,"162":24.92840004,"161":24.80859947,"160":24.64590073,"159":24.57419968,"158":24.93040085,"157":25.38979912,"156":26.01479912},"309":{"165":26.66469955,"164":26.16519928,"163":25.34390068,"162":25.12389946,"161":24.96220016,"160":25.06290054,"159":25.14959908,"158":25.49939919,"157":25.78849983,"156":null},"310":{"165":26.64119911,"164":25.88500023,"163":25.32719994,"162":25.33639908,"161":25.3560009,"160":25.07379913,"159":24.87599945,"158":25.12299919,"157":25.57320023,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":28.11730003,"225":31.21279907,"224":32.40010071,"223":32.86410141,"222":33.96049881,"221":35.85499954,"220":36.87620163,"219":null},"225":{"227":23.37779999,"226":26.42810059,"225":30.04780006,"224":31.72870064,"223":32.29059982,"222":33.22520065,"221":34.40370178,"220":35.74250031,"219":35.19839859},"226":{"227":23.86170006,"226":26.59499931,"225":30.4211998,"224":31.29910088,"223":31.8878994,"222":32.84529877,"221":33.45090103,"220":33.94710159,"219":34.05580139},"227":{"227":25.2534008,"226":25.78689957,"225":29.2507,"224":30.79439926,"223":31.69689941,"222":32.32460022,"221":32.69100189,"220":32.92039871,"219":33.01589966},"228":{"227":22.41239929,"226":25.87560081,"225":28.48539925,"224":29.46529961,"223":30.47389984,"222":31.65010071,"221":31.80540085,"220":31.79820061,"219":31.71859932},"229":{"227":22.76869965,"226":26.37179947,"225":27.14450073,"224":27.76720047,"223":29.42440033,"222":30.01989937,"221":30.19079971,"220":30.41679955,"219":30.40609932},"230":{"227":23.17830086,"226":23.61109924,"225":22.6257,"224":24.11709976,"223":27.4666996,"222":26.30439949,"221":28.63660049,"220":29.63599968,"219":29.10099983},"231":{"227":22.0102005,"226":21.86079979,"225":21.16049957,"224":23.14039993,"223":26.34350014,"222":24.71150017,"221":28.06360054,"220":28.63190079,"219":27.09480095},"232":{"227":20.80380058,"226":21.39819908,"225":21.91530037,"224":22.77750015,"223":23.82769966,"222":22.86790085,"221":24.55200005,"220":26.09289932,"219":24.29809952}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in end-century period?
c6cde9b7-c28d-4f15-9b92-4b687b432b4e
As a wildland firefighter assessing future operational challenges, I need to know which location—Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA—has seen a more significant increase in the fire weather index during the autumn and summer of the end-century period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1240/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":24.41449928,"164":22.35910034,"163":21.82379913,"162":22.13579941,"161":23.44029999,"160":24.60300064,"159":18.81240082,"158":17.5848999,"157":19.70660019,"156":11.89239979},"302":{"165":23.22260094,"164":21.99300003,"163":20.63159943,"162":19.55520058,"161":17.06349945,"160":19.6541996,"159":20.94330025,"158":22.52949905,"157":22.77519989,"156":15.95349979},"303":{"165":24.69599915,"164":25.31200027,"163":23.18300056,"162":22.0666008,"161":19.95879936,"160":19.67320061,"159":21.3125,"158":24.31599998,"157":25.61020088,"156":24.27680016},"304":{"165":26.93400002,"164":25.31340027,"163":23.90589905,"162":23.42760086,"161":22.88059998,"160":21.77039909,"159":22.46489906,"158":24.63500023,"157":26.07749939,"156":26.17130089},"305":{"165":28.0298996,"164":25.98010063,"163":24.65990067,"162":24.21249962,"161":23.67230034,"160":23.03009987,"159":23.39620018,"158":24.66480064,"157":25.55509949,"156":25.96980095},"306":{"165":26.9015007,"164":26.07939911,"163":25.21890068,"162":24.75160027,"161":24.09219933,"160":23.24780083,"159":23.46380043,"158":24.48940086,"157":25.44650078,"156":25.88240051},"307":{"165":26.35840034,"164":26.06060028,"163":25.19050026,"162":24.9185009,"161":24.61009979,"160":23.92300034,"159":23.82909966,"158":24.65999985,"157":25.54059982,"156":26.14489937},"308":{"165":26.17099953,"164":25.91390038,"163":25.24029922,"162":24.92840004,"161":24.80859947,"160":24.64590073,"159":24.57419968,"158":24.93040085,"157":25.38979912,"156":26.01479912},"309":{"165":26.66469955,"164":26.16519928,"163":25.34390068,"162":25.12389946,"161":24.96220016,"160":25.06290054,"159":25.14959908,"158":25.49939919,"157":25.78849983,"156":null},"310":{"165":26.64119911,"164":25.88500023,"163":25.32719994,"162":25.33639908,"161":25.3560009,"160":25.07379913,"159":24.87599945,"158":25.12299919,"157":25.57320023,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":28.11730003,"225":31.21279907,"224":32.40010071,"223":32.86410141,"222":33.96049881,"221":35.85499954,"220":36.87620163,"219":null},"225":{"227":23.37779999,"226":26.42810059,"225":30.04780006,"224":31.72870064,"223":32.29059982,"222":33.22520065,"221":34.40370178,"220":35.74250031,"219":35.19839859},"226":{"227":23.86170006,"226":26.59499931,"225":30.4211998,"224":31.29910088,"223":31.8878994,"222":32.84529877,"221":33.45090103,"220":33.94710159,"219":34.05580139},"227":{"227":25.2534008,"226":25.78689957,"225":29.2507,"224":30.79439926,"223":31.69689941,"222":32.32460022,"221":32.69100189,"220":32.92039871,"219":33.01589966},"228":{"227":22.41239929,"226":25.87560081,"225":28.48539925,"224":29.46529961,"223":30.47389984,"222":31.65010071,"221":31.80540085,"220":31.79820061,"219":31.71859932},"229":{"227":22.76869965,"226":26.37179947,"225":27.14450073,"224":27.76720047,"223":29.42440033,"222":30.01989937,"221":30.19079971,"220":30.41679955,"219":30.40609932},"230":{"227":23.17830086,"226":23.61109924,"225":22.6257,"224":24.11709976,"223":27.4666996,"222":26.30439949,"221":28.63660049,"220":29.63599968,"219":29.10099983},"231":{"227":22.0102005,"226":21.86079979,"225":21.16049957,"224":23.14039993,"223":26.34350014,"222":24.71150017,"221":28.06360054,"220":28.63190079,"219":27.09480095},"232":{"227":20.80380058,"226":21.39819908,"225":21.91530037,"224":22.77750015,"223":23.82769966,"222":22.86790085,"221":24.55200005,"220":26.09289932,"219":24.29809952}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in end-century period?
3cb3a556-0bdd-4313-b479-77e3de5cd06a
As a wildland firefighter assessing future operational challenges, I need to know which location—Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA—has seen a more significant increase in the fire weather index during the autumn and summer of the end-century period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1240/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":24.41449928,"164":22.35910034,"163":21.82379913,"162":22.13579941,"161":23.44029999,"160":24.60300064,"159":18.81240082,"158":17.5848999,"157":19.70660019,"156":11.89239979},"302":{"165":23.22260094,"164":21.99300003,"163":20.63159943,"162":19.55520058,"161":17.06349945,"160":19.6541996,"159":20.94330025,"158":22.52949905,"157":22.77519989,"156":15.95349979},"303":{"165":24.69599915,"164":25.31200027,"163":23.18300056,"162":22.0666008,"161":19.95879936,"160":19.67320061,"159":21.3125,"158":24.31599998,"157":25.61020088,"156":24.27680016},"304":{"165":26.93400002,"164":25.31340027,"163":23.90589905,"162":23.42760086,"161":22.88059998,"160":21.77039909,"159":22.46489906,"158":24.63500023,"157":26.07749939,"156":26.17130089},"305":{"165":28.0298996,"164":25.98010063,"163":24.65990067,"162":24.21249962,"161":23.67230034,"160":23.03009987,"159":23.39620018,"158":24.66480064,"157":25.55509949,"156":25.96980095},"306":{"165":26.9015007,"164":26.07939911,"163":25.21890068,"162":24.75160027,"161":24.09219933,"160":23.24780083,"159":23.46380043,"158":24.48940086,"157":25.44650078,"156":25.88240051},"307":{"165":26.35840034,"164":26.06060028,"163":25.19050026,"162":24.9185009,"161":24.61009979,"160":23.92300034,"159":23.82909966,"158":24.65999985,"157":25.54059982,"156":26.14489937},"308":{"165":26.17099953,"164":25.91390038,"163":25.24029922,"162":24.92840004,"161":24.80859947,"160":24.64590073,"159":24.57419968,"158":24.93040085,"157":25.38979912,"156":26.01479912},"309":{"165":26.66469955,"164":26.16519928,"163":25.34390068,"162":25.12389946,"161":24.96220016,"160":25.06290054,"159":25.14959908,"158":25.49939919,"157":25.78849983,"156":null},"310":{"165":26.64119911,"164":25.88500023,"163":25.32719994,"162":25.33639908,"161":25.3560009,"160":25.07379913,"159":24.87599945,"158":25.12299919,"157":25.57320023,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":28.11730003,"225":31.21279907,"224":32.40010071,"223":32.86410141,"222":33.96049881,"221":35.85499954,"220":36.87620163,"219":null},"225":{"227":23.37779999,"226":26.42810059,"225":30.04780006,"224":31.72870064,"223":32.29059982,"222":33.22520065,"221":34.40370178,"220":35.74250031,"219":35.19839859},"226":{"227":23.86170006,"226":26.59499931,"225":30.4211998,"224":31.29910088,"223":31.8878994,"222":32.84529877,"221":33.45090103,"220":33.94710159,"219":34.05580139},"227":{"227":25.2534008,"226":25.78689957,"225":29.2507,"224":30.79439926,"223":31.69689941,"222":32.32460022,"221":32.69100189,"220":32.92039871,"219":33.01589966},"228":{"227":22.41239929,"226":25.87560081,"225":28.48539925,"224":29.46529961,"223":30.47389984,"222":31.65010071,"221":31.80540085,"220":31.79820061,"219":31.71859932},"229":{"227":22.76869965,"226":26.37179947,"225":27.14450073,"224":27.76720047,"223":29.42440033,"222":30.01989937,"221":30.19079971,"220":30.41679955,"219":30.40609932},"230":{"227":23.17830086,"226":23.61109924,"225":22.6257,"224":24.11709976,"223":27.4666996,"222":26.30439949,"221":28.63660049,"220":29.63599968,"219":29.10099983},"231":{"227":22.0102005,"226":21.86079979,"225":21.16049957,"224":23.14039993,"223":26.34350014,"222":24.71150017,"221":28.06360054,"220":28.63190079,"219":27.09480095},"232":{"227":20.80380058,"226":21.39819908,"225":21.91530037,"224":22.77750015,"223":23.82769966,"222":22.86790085,"221":24.55200005,"220":26.09289932,"219":24.29809952}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in end-century period?
68f1c56a-a5c8-4ee3-bc89-6e5e3f682a53
As a climatologist analyzing regional temperature trends for our upcoming report, could you inform me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP4.5)?
trend
tabular
null
72
(d)
['(a) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":43.76580048,"211":42.1413002,"210":41.51610184,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":44.5727005,"204":43.3451004},"471":{"213":43.71440125,"212":42.2887001,"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004,"205":42.24729919,"204":41.66490173},"472":{"213":43.51160049,"212":41.82770157,"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067,"205":41.39250183,"204":40.51169968},"473":{"213":41.95479965,"212":41.47740173,"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034,"205":40.11500168,"204":39.61869812},"474":{"213":41.66379929,"212":41.20370102,"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879,"205":39.06990051,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":41.09329987,"211":40.35300064,"210":40.41790009,"209":39.7159996,"208":38.93569946,"207":38.64609909,"206":38.49209976,"205":38.06600189,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":40.08950043,"209":38.99369812,"208":38.20100021,"207":37.92760086,"206":37.85739899,"205":37.60210037,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":44.2262001,"177":44.09120178,"176":44.04109955,"175":44.14189911,"174":44.40309906,"173":44.6794014,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":44.33269882,"177":44.38299942,"176":44.45280075,"175":44.47019958,"174":44.57920074,"173":44.72069931,"172":44.87409973,"171":45.07249832,"170":45.26119995},"451":{"179":44.167099,"178":44.29510117,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183,"170":45.33530045},"452":{"179":44.1678009,"178":44.31629944,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959,"170":45.36510086},"453":{"179":43.9659996,"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172,"170":45.5243988},"454":{"179":43.46989822,"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079,"170":45.61750031},"455":{"179":43.17969894,"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":45.74269867,"170":45.75569916},"456":{"179":43.27330017,"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":45.49819946,"170":null},"457":{"179":43.29850006,"178":43.48040009,"177":44.07289886,"176":44.10739899,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":45.34609985,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":44.09609985,"176":44.38880157,"175":44.39989853,"174":44.6108017,"173":44.90110016,"172":44.94620132,"171":45.14070129,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
d9e26814-7e81-4c53-bd5e-30140d35f4f1
As a climatologist analyzing regional temperature trends for our upcoming report, could you inform me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP4.5)?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":43.76580048,"211":42.1413002,"210":41.51610184,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":44.5727005,"204":43.3451004},"471":{"213":43.71440125,"212":42.2887001,"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004,"205":42.24729919,"204":41.66490173},"472":{"213":43.51160049,"212":41.82770157,"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067,"205":41.39250183,"204":40.51169968},"473":{"213":41.95479965,"212":41.47740173,"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034,"205":40.11500168,"204":39.61869812},"474":{"213":41.66379929,"212":41.20370102,"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879,"205":39.06990051,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":41.09329987,"211":40.35300064,"210":40.41790009,"209":39.7159996,"208":38.93569946,"207":38.64609909,"206":38.49209976,"205":38.06600189,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":40.08950043,"209":38.99369812,"208":38.20100021,"207":37.92760086,"206":37.85739899,"205":37.60210037,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":44.2262001,"177":44.09120178,"176":44.04109955,"175":44.14189911,"174":44.40309906,"173":44.6794014,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":44.33269882,"177":44.38299942,"176":44.45280075,"175":44.47019958,"174":44.57920074,"173":44.72069931,"172":44.87409973,"171":45.07249832,"170":45.26119995},"451":{"179":44.167099,"178":44.29510117,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183,"170":45.33530045},"452":{"179":44.1678009,"178":44.31629944,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959,"170":45.36510086},"453":{"179":43.9659996,"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172,"170":45.5243988},"454":{"179":43.46989822,"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079,"170":45.61750031},"455":{"179":43.17969894,"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":45.74269867,"170":45.75569916},"456":{"179":43.27330017,"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":45.49819946,"170":null},"457":{"179":43.29850006,"178":43.48040009,"177":44.07289886,"176":44.10739899,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":45.34609985,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":44.09609985,"176":44.38880157,"175":44.39989853,"174":44.6108017,"173":44.90110016,"172":44.94620132,"171":45.14070129,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
c977af8c-4c1e-421c-8f76-e7eb85db79d0
As a climatologist analyzing regional temperature trends for our upcoming report, could you inform me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP4.5)?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":43.76580048,"211":42.1413002,"210":41.51610184,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":44.5727005,"204":43.3451004},"471":{"213":43.71440125,"212":42.2887001,"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004,"205":42.24729919,"204":41.66490173},"472":{"213":43.51160049,"212":41.82770157,"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067,"205":41.39250183,"204":40.51169968},"473":{"213":41.95479965,"212":41.47740173,"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034,"205":40.11500168,"204":39.61869812},"474":{"213":41.66379929,"212":41.20370102,"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879,"205":39.06990051,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":41.09329987,"211":40.35300064,"210":40.41790009,"209":39.7159996,"208":38.93569946,"207":38.64609909,"206":38.49209976,"205":38.06600189,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":40.08950043,"209":38.99369812,"208":38.20100021,"207":37.92760086,"206":37.85739899,"205":37.60210037,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":44.2262001,"177":44.09120178,"176":44.04109955,"175":44.14189911,"174":44.40309906,"173":44.6794014,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":44.33269882,"177":44.38299942,"176":44.45280075,"175":44.47019958,"174":44.57920074,"173":44.72069931,"172":44.87409973,"171":45.07249832,"170":45.26119995},"451":{"179":44.167099,"178":44.29510117,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183,"170":45.33530045},"452":{"179":44.1678009,"178":44.31629944,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959,"170":45.36510086},"453":{"179":43.9659996,"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172,"170":45.5243988},"454":{"179":43.46989822,"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079,"170":45.61750031},"455":{"179":43.17969894,"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":45.74269867,"170":45.75569916},"456":{"179":43.27330017,"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":45.49819946,"170":null},"457":{"179":43.29850006,"178":43.48040009,"177":44.07289886,"176":44.10739899,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":45.34609985,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":44.09609985,"176":44.38880157,"175":44.39989853,"174":44.6108017,"173":44.90110016,"172":44.94620132,"171":45.14070129,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
e304ab88-64f4-4524-9aeb-e97e3e394932
As a climatologist analyzing regional temperature trends for our upcoming report, could you inform me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP4.5)?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":43.76580048,"211":42.1413002,"210":41.51610184,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":44.5727005,"204":43.3451004},"471":{"213":43.71440125,"212":42.2887001,"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004,"205":42.24729919,"204":41.66490173},"472":{"213":43.51160049,"212":41.82770157,"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067,"205":41.39250183,"204":40.51169968},"473":{"213":41.95479965,"212":41.47740173,"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034,"205":40.11500168,"204":39.61869812},"474":{"213":41.66379929,"212":41.20370102,"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879,"205":39.06990051,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":41.09329987,"211":40.35300064,"210":40.41790009,"209":39.7159996,"208":38.93569946,"207":38.64609909,"206":38.49209976,"205":38.06600189,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":40.08950043,"209":38.99369812,"208":38.20100021,"207":37.92760086,"206":37.85739899,"205":37.60210037,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":44.2262001,"177":44.09120178,"176":44.04109955,"175":44.14189911,"174":44.40309906,"173":44.6794014,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":44.33269882,"177":44.38299942,"176":44.45280075,"175":44.47019958,"174":44.57920074,"173":44.72069931,"172":44.87409973,"171":45.07249832,"170":45.26119995},"451":{"179":44.167099,"178":44.29510117,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183,"170":45.33530045},"452":{"179":44.1678009,"178":44.31629944,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959,"170":45.36510086},"453":{"179":43.9659996,"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172,"170":45.5243988},"454":{"179":43.46989822,"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079,"170":45.61750031},"455":{"179":43.17969894,"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":45.74269867,"170":45.75569916},"456":{"179":43.27330017,"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":45.49819946,"170":null},"457":{"179":43.29850006,"178":43.48040009,"177":44.07289886,"176":44.10739899,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":45.34609985,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":44.09609985,"176":44.38880157,"175":44.39989853,"174":44.6108017,"173":44.90110016,"172":44.94620132,"171":45.14070129,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
35bc0c0c-734f-4928-8f3d-c14a9e08b281
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional environmental conference, I would like to know which city—Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL—has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-of-century projections (RCP8.5) to historical data?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"192":{"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":null},"193":{"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":null},"194":{"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896},"195":{"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008},"196":{"226":null,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132},"197":{"226":null,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106},"489":{"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123},"490":{"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074},"491":{"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888},"492":{"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821},"493":{"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
fe87383c-95d3-46be-ab97-ccdfa962f158
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional environmental conference, I would like to know which city—Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL—has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-of-century projections (RCP8.5) to historical data?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"192":{"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":null},"193":{"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":null},"194":{"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896},"195":{"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008},"196":{"226":null,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132},"197":{"226":null,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106},"489":{"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123},"490":{"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074},"491":{"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888},"492":{"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821},"493":{"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
89c2cc38-2f67-4979-bc48-836e8d8096fe
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional environmental conference, I would like to know which city—Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL—has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-of-century projections (RCP8.5) to historical data?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"192":{"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":null},"193":{"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":null},"194":{"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896},"195":{"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008},"196":{"226":null,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132},"197":{"226":null,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106},"489":{"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123},"490":{"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074},"491":{"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888},"492":{"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821},"493":{"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
5afd55cd-5928-4aea-9507-43217ba299c4
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional environmental conference, I would like to know which city—Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL—has shown a more significant variation in annual total precipitation when comparing the end-of-century projections (RCP8.5) to historical data?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1337/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"192":{"226":104.89399719,"225":87.32440186,"224":69.95210266,"223":59.0780983,"222":54.97539902,"221":50.20349884,"220":null},"193":{"226":86.77469635,"225":68.08979797,"224":57.82419968,"223":52.27600098,"222":51.35319901,"221":48.99879837,"220":null},"194":{"226":64.04199982,"225":54.28960037,"224":48.97980118,"223":45.60520172,"222":45.417099,"221":45.46139908,"220":45.67689896},"195":{"226":50.07350159,"225":48.94400024,"224":44.68799973,"223":41.40039825,"222":40.80080032,"221":41.52769852,"220":45.6291008},"196":{"226":null,"225":44.4640007,"224":46.23799896,"223":45.76380157,"222":38.28620148,"221":36.98870087,"220":41.76010132},"197":{"226":null,"225":39.27740097,"224":38.27659988,"223":37.92300034,"222":37.96039963,"221":35.60540009,"220":37.77339935}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":74.76879883,"73":64.06169891,"72":62.70780182,"71":60.05580139,"70":60.56430054,"69":61.76029968,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":64.37460327,"73":61.07789993,"72":61.55189896,"71":58.47940063,"70":54.56330109,"69":63.56169891,"68":78.50640106},"489":{"75":50.4272995,"74":49.06529999,"73":48.98180008,"72":48.96260071,"71":53.18209839,"70":56.88290024,"69":56.15499878,"68":66.02970123},"490":{"75":42.10089874,"74":43.28030014,"73":47.12250137,"72":47.56510162,"71":55.3348999,"70":70.92649841,"69":null,"68":59.39310074},"491":{"75":40.6733017,"74":38.99560165,"73":40.9681015,"72":46.51210022,"71":48.40829849,"70":51.17789841,"69":56.90129852,"68":55.63119888},"492":{"75":41.42959976,"74":41.65869904,"73":40.48450089,"72":41.49089813,"71":42.91070175,"70":43.67150116,"69":45.88779831,"68":47.91019821},"493":{"75":37.11709976,"74":38.15090179,"73":35.61660004,"72":35.03749847,"71":38.22949982,"70":39.05369949,"69":39.84320068,"68":42.97100067},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":34.39500046,"72":36.38669968,"71":35.74250031,"70":37.20740128,"69":36.14720154,"68":38.88119888}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
188e4077-7199-4313-a71d-9bfa4e9234c4
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference, I'm looking to evaluate the historical temperature trends in the northeastern United States; could you tell me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature from historical records to the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
tabular
null
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(c) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in historical period', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in historical period', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":36.95780182,"210":36.46590042,"209":39.64199829,"208":36.91770172,"207":39.48080063,"206":39.71789932},"472":{"211":36.7798996,"210":36.15999985,"209":39.7784996,"208":39.66690063,"207":36.51979828,"206":37.03390121},"473":{"211":36.53990173,"210":36.26800156,"209":36.07659912,"208":35.99909973,"207":36.03319931,"206":35.53779984},"474":{"211":36.11339951,"210":36.07300186,"209":35.97850037,"208":35.68119812,"207":35.07260132,"206":34.70970154}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":40.77980042,"176":40.96849823,"175":41.2419014,"174":41.43980026,"173":41.48379898,"172":41.62170029,"171":41.80899811},"452":{"178":null,"177":40.8158989,"176":41.02349854,"175":41.27690125,"174":41.53120041,"173":41.72570038,"172":41.89459991,"171":42.09909821},"453":{"178":40.54550171,"177":40.8382988,"176":41.17300034,"175":45.34540176,"174":44.35309982,"173":41.99629974,"172":42.21889877,"171":42.37969971},"454":{"178":40.20940018,"177":40.6114006,"176":41.05709839,"175":45.15890121,"174":41.81019974,"173":42.17539978,"172":42.37189865,"171":42.49810028},"455":{"178":39.83409882,"177":40.11100006,"176":40.63219833,"175":41.17419815,"174":41.81729889,"173":42.15729904,"172":42.31230164,"171":null},"456":{"178":39.81570053,"177":40.06919861,"176":40.42720032,"175":41.02050018,"174":41.55139923,"173":41.80270004,"172":41.86510086,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":40.77899933,"174":41.12670135,"173":41.38550186,"172":41.81829834,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout historical period and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
fba31f07-e10a-475d-8277-f3f9de993425
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference, I'm looking to evaluate the historical temperature trends in the northeastern United States; could you tell me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature from historical records to the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1390/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(c) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in historical period', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in historical period', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":36.95780182,"210":36.46590042,"209":39.64199829,"208":36.91770172,"207":39.48080063,"206":39.71789932},"472":{"211":36.7798996,"210":36.15999985,"209":39.7784996,"208":39.66690063,"207":36.51979828,"206":37.03390121},"473":{"211":36.53990173,"210":36.26800156,"209":36.07659912,"208":35.99909973,"207":36.03319931,"206":35.53779984},"474":{"211":36.11339951,"210":36.07300186,"209":35.97850037,"208":35.68119812,"207":35.07260132,"206":34.70970154}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":40.77980042,"176":40.96849823,"175":41.2419014,"174":41.43980026,"173":41.48379898,"172":41.62170029,"171":41.80899811},"452":{"178":null,"177":40.8158989,"176":41.02349854,"175":41.27690125,"174":41.53120041,"173":41.72570038,"172":41.89459991,"171":42.09909821},"453":{"178":40.54550171,"177":40.8382988,"176":41.17300034,"175":45.34540176,"174":44.35309982,"173":41.99629974,"172":42.21889877,"171":42.37969971},"454":{"178":40.20940018,"177":40.6114006,"176":41.05709839,"175":45.15890121,"174":41.81019974,"173":42.17539978,"172":42.37189865,"171":42.49810028},"455":{"178":39.83409882,"177":40.11100006,"176":40.63219833,"175":41.17419815,"174":41.81729889,"173":42.15729904,"172":42.31230164,"171":null},"456":{"178":39.81570053,"177":40.06919861,"176":40.42720032,"175":41.02050018,"174":41.55139923,"173":41.80270004,"172":41.86510086,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":40.77899933,"174":41.12670135,"173":41.38550186,"172":41.81829834,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout historical period and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
1d9b747c-85a1-42e9-a81a-d2ab183f8e25
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference, I'm looking to evaluate the historical temperature trends in the northeastern United States; could you tell me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature from historical records to the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1390/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(c) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in historical period', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in historical period', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":36.95780182,"210":36.46590042,"209":39.64199829,"208":36.91770172,"207":39.48080063,"206":39.71789932},"472":{"211":36.7798996,"210":36.15999985,"209":39.7784996,"208":39.66690063,"207":36.51979828,"206":37.03390121},"473":{"211":36.53990173,"210":36.26800156,"209":36.07659912,"208":35.99909973,"207":36.03319931,"206":35.53779984},"474":{"211":36.11339951,"210":36.07300186,"209":35.97850037,"208":35.68119812,"207":35.07260132,"206":34.70970154}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":40.77980042,"176":40.96849823,"175":41.2419014,"174":41.43980026,"173":41.48379898,"172":41.62170029,"171":41.80899811},"452":{"178":null,"177":40.8158989,"176":41.02349854,"175":41.27690125,"174":41.53120041,"173":41.72570038,"172":41.89459991,"171":42.09909821},"453":{"178":40.54550171,"177":40.8382988,"176":41.17300034,"175":45.34540176,"174":44.35309982,"173":41.99629974,"172":42.21889877,"171":42.37969971},"454":{"178":40.20940018,"177":40.6114006,"176":41.05709839,"175":45.15890121,"174":41.81019974,"173":42.17539978,"172":42.37189865,"171":42.49810028},"455":{"178":39.83409882,"177":40.11100006,"176":40.63219833,"175":41.17419815,"174":41.81729889,"173":42.15729904,"172":42.31230164,"171":null},"456":{"178":39.81570053,"177":40.06919861,"176":40.42720032,"175":41.02050018,"174":41.55139923,"173":41.80270004,"172":41.86510086,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":40.77899933,"174":41.12670135,"173":41.38550186,"172":41.81829834,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout historical period and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
6914bcb7-c5a6-4c73-8929-f6a27779036e
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference, I'm looking to evaluate the historical temperature trends in the northeastern United States; could you tell me which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature from historical records to the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1390/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(c) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in historical period', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in historical period', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":36.95780182,"210":36.46590042,"209":39.64199829,"208":36.91770172,"207":39.48080063,"206":39.71789932},"472":{"211":36.7798996,"210":36.15999985,"209":39.7784996,"208":39.66690063,"207":36.51979828,"206":37.03390121},"473":{"211":36.53990173,"210":36.26800156,"209":36.07659912,"208":35.99909973,"207":36.03319931,"206":35.53779984},"474":{"211":36.11339951,"210":36.07300186,"209":35.97850037,"208":35.68119812,"207":35.07260132,"206":34.70970154}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":40.77980042,"176":40.96849823,"175":41.2419014,"174":41.43980026,"173":41.48379898,"172":41.62170029,"171":41.80899811},"452":{"178":null,"177":40.8158989,"176":41.02349854,"175":41.27690125,"174":41.53120041,"173":41.72570038,"172":41.89459991,"171":42.09909821},"453":{"178":40.54550171,"177":40.8382988,"176":41.17300034,"175":45.34540176,"174":44.35309982,"173":41.99629974,"172":42.21889877,"171":42.37969971},"454":{"178":40.20940018,"177":40.6114006,"176":41.05709839,"175":45.15890121,"174":41.81019974,"173":42.17539978,"172":42.37189865,"171":42.49810028},"455":{"178":39.83409882,"177":40.11100006,"176":40.63219833,"175":41.17419815,"174":41.81729889,"173":42.15729904,"172":42.31230164,"171":null},"456":{"178":39.81570053,"177":40.06919861,"176":40.42720032,"175":41.02050018,"174":41.55139923,"173":41.80270004,"172":41.86510086,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":40.77899933,"174":41.12670135,"173":41.38550186,"172":41.81829834,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout historical period and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
f04b8b52-604f-4db5-933b-d5ea93df0586
As a city planner evaluating the impact of rising temperatures on community resilience, which city between Columbia, SC, and Raleigh, NC has shown a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 105°F during the summer in both the historical and projected end-century periods?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(b) Columbia, SC, United States experienced a greater change than Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Columbia, SC, United States.']
['Columbia, SC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Columbia, SC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in historical period']
{"480":{"131":null,"130":104.67367808,"129":104.49802907,"128":104.22798665,"127":104.4026947,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":104.47771962,"129":104.86864471,"128":104.89114126,"127":108.00789897,"126":103.75562541,"125":103.86618042,"124":104.47186534},"482":{"131":103.74072011,"130":104.16809845,"129":105.13431803,"128":105.36697133,"127":104.67216492,"126":104.30345408,"125":104.33462779,"124":104.90238444},"483":{"131":104.13031769,"130":103.82535807,"129":104.80014801,"128":105.8703715,"127":105.81468455,"126":105.16291809,"125":104.71059672,"124":105.36537425},"484":{"131":104.68594869,"130":104.43065643,"129":104.47838847,"128":104.75147756,"127":106.75270081,"126":106.11667887,"125":105.52853648,"124":106.09367116},"485":{"131":105.50572205,"130":105.53328451,"129":105.27067566,"128":105.72998047,"127":107.16199493,"126":106.97716522,"125":106.28477987,"124":106.68306986},"486":{"131":105.67066701,"130":107.11413574,"129":106.36725108,"128":106.44829559,"127":107.52614085,"126":107.78529104,"125":107.02929179,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":107.10673269,"128":107.61429342,"127":108.3698705,"126":108.10055542,"125":107.68267314,"124":null}}
{"480":{"131":null,"130":88.13982391,"129":88.04748027,"128":87.84898122,"127":87.85672251,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":87.98475901,"129":88.19387054,"128":88.03085073,"127":87.63951619,"126":87.69615428,"125":87.75732676,"124":88.10734304},"482":{"131":87.50974274,"130":87.71620433,"129":88.20118968,"128":88.37795003,"127":88.2191747,"126":88.0313797,"125":88.00899251,"124":88.28249613},"483":{"131":87.71914673,"130":87.5449117,"129":88.02211507,"128":88.6958669,"127":88.89978536,"126":88.47029114,"125":88.17670949,"124":88.43710073},"484":{"131":88.00246429,"130":87.85137431,"129":88.15146383,"128":89.41805267,"127":89.26863607,"126":88.93296305,"125":88.44881185,"124":88.67670186},"485":{"131":88.37779999,"130":88.57177989,"129":88.51158142,"128":88.66477966,"127":89.21444194,"126":89.20446523,"125":88.75521088,"124":88.86039225},"486":{"131":88.54678853,"130":89.04342906,"129":88.93136851,"128":88.89100138,"127":89.31206512,"126":89.32860565,"125":88.96283722,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":89.05826314,"128":89.18718211,"127":89.41707611,"126":89.44038645,"125":89.2044576,"124":null}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":100.27670542,"150":100.78192902,"149":101.49919128,"148":101.92943827,"147":102.18273926,"146":null},"493":{"152":100.76464844,"151":101.49528503,"150":101.27377065,"149":102.27130127,"148":102.51672109,"147":103.12692006,"146":103.51754506},"494":{"152":101.14872233,"151":101.76997375,"150":101.93864441,"149":101.97853597,"148":102.21056112,"147":102.60025533,"146":103.30922699},"495":{"152":101.36516825,"151":101.60191091,"150":101.93216705,"149":101.6429952,"148":102.66585032,"147":102.73478699,"146":103.45061493},"496":{"152":101.74239858,"151":101.73141225,"150":102.43359375,"149":103.17438761,"148":103.4331665,"147":103.32438914,"146":103.92068227},"497":{"152":102.22806549,"151":102.64806875,"150":102.76686096,"149":103.43634542,"148":103.69246674,"147":103.96383921,"146":104.40803019},"498":{"152":102.70836385,"151":102.96325684,"150":103.27556101,"149":103.38446045,"148":103.92997742,"147":104.74274699,"146":104.72667694}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":85.09859975,"150":85.44670868,"149":85.95890808,"148":86.21758525,"147":86.4758021,"146":null},"493":{"152":85.41419983,"151":86.08327484,"150":86.97571055,"149":86.41147868,"148":86.58870188,"147":86.87223053,"146":87.05684916},"494":{"152":85.74001312,"151":86.18342845,"150":86.21973928,"149":86.24650574,"148":86.32286072,"147":86.5308787,"146":86.82008362},"495":{"152":85.70913442,"151":85.91559855,"150":86.24632517,"149":87.13426208,"148":86.3211263,"147":86.47602081,"146":86.91768138},"496":{"152":85.85537211,"151":85.85732524,"150":86.27374776,"149":86.60590871,"148":86.71157074,"147":86.85225169,"146":87.12237803},"497":{"152":86.04092407,"151":86.41228739,"150":86.41332245,"149":86.62849172,"148":86.95069885,"147":87.21248881,"146":87.26013947},"498":{"152":86.30155436,"151":86.62032064,"150":86.80579631,"149":86.87948608,"148":87.13800049,"147":87.42942301,"146":87.50773366}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Columbia, SC, United States", "location2": "Raleigh, NC, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Columbia, SC, United States or Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
b30f95c9-4fd4-483c-91f1-9bd5e0815dae
As a city planner evaluating the impact of rising temperatures on community resilience, which city between Columbia, SC, and Raleigh, NC has shown a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 105°F during the summer in both the historical and projected end-century periods?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1385/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(b) Columbia, SC, United States experienced a greater change than Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Columbia, SC, United States.']
['Columbia, SC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Columbia, SC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in historical period']
{"480":{"131":null,"130":104.67367808,"129":104.49802907,"128":104.22798665,"127":104.4026947,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":104.47771962,"129":104.86864471,"128":104.89114126,"127":108.00789897,"126":103.75562541,"125":103.86618042,"124":104.47186534},"482":{"131":103.74072011,"130":104.16809845,"129":105.13431803,"128":105.36697133,"127":104.67216492,"126":104.30345408,"125":104.33462779,"124":104.90238444},"483":{"131":104.13031769,"130":103.82535807,"129":104.80014801,"128":105.8703715,"127":105.81468455,"126":105.16291809,"125":104.71059672,"124":105.36537425},"484":{"131":104.68594869,"130":104.43065643,"129":104.47838847,"128":104.75147756,"127":106.75270081,"126":106.11667887,"125":105.52853648,"124":106.09367116},"485":{"131":105.50572205,"130":105.53328451,"129":105.27067566,"128":105.72998047,"127":107.16199493,"126":106.97716522,"125":106.28477987,"124":106.68306986},"486":{"131":105.67066701,"130":107.11413574,"129":106.36725108,"128":106.44829559,"127":107.52614085,"126":107.78529104,"125":107.02929179,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":107.10673269,"128":107.61429342,"127":108.3698705,"126":108.10055542,"125":107.68267314,"124":null}}
{"480":{"131":null,"130":88.13982391,"129":88.04748027,"128":87.84898122,"127":87.85672251,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":87.98475901,"129":88.19387054,"128":88.03085073,"127":87.63951619,"126":87.69615428,"125":87.75732676,"124":88.10734304},"482":{"131":87.50974274,"130":87.71620433,"129":88.20118968,"128":88.37795003,"127":88.2191747,"126":88.0313797,"125":88.00899251,"124":88.28249613},"483":{"131":87.71914673,"130":87.5449117,"129":88.02211507,"128":88.6958669,"127":88.89978536,"126":88.47029114,"125":88.17670949,"124":88.43710073},"484":{"131":88.00246429,"130":87.85137431,"129":88.15146383,"128":89.41805267,"127":89.26863607,"126":88.93296305,"125":88.44881185,"124":88.67670186},"485":{"131":88.37779999,"130":88.57177989,"129":88.51158142,"128":88.66477966,"127":89.21444194,"126":89.20446523,"125":88.75521088,"124":88.86039225},"486":{"131":88.54678853,"130":89.04342906,"129":88.93136851,"128":88.89100138,"127":89.31206512,"126":89.32860565,"125":88.96283722,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":89.05826314,"128":89.18718211,"127":89.41707611,"126":89.44038645,"125":89.2044576,"124":null}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":100.27670542,"150":100.78192902,"149":101.49919128,"148":101.92943827,"147":102.18273926,"146":null},"493":{"152":100.76464844,"151":101.49528503,"150":101.27377065,"149":102.27130127,"148":102.51672109,"147":103.12692006,"146":103.51754506},"494":{"152":101.14872233,"151":101.76997375,"150":101.93864441,"149":101.97853597,"148":102.21056112,"147":102.60025533,"146":103.30922699},"495":{"152":101.36516825,"151":101.60191091,"150":101.93216705,"149":101.6429952,"148":102.66585032,"147":102.73478699,"146":103.45061493},"496":{"152":101.74239858,"151":101.73141225,"150":102.43359375,"149":103.17438761,"148":103.4331665,"147":103.32438914,"146":103.92068227},"497":{"152":102.22806549,"151":102.64806875,"150":102.76686096,"149":103.43634542,"148":103.69246674,"147":103.96383921,"146":104.40803019},"498":{"152":102.70836385,"151":102.96325684,"150":103.27556101,"149":103.38446045,"148":103.92997742,"147":104.74274699,"146":104.72667694}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":85.09859975,"150":85.44670868,"149":85.95890808,"148":86.21758525,"147":86.4758021,"146":null},"493":{"152":85.41419983,"151":86.08327484,"150":86.97571055,"149":86.41147868,"148":86.58870188,"147":86.87223053,"146":87.05684916},"494":{"152":85.74001312,"151":86.18342845,"150":86.21973928,"149":86.24650574,"148":86.32286072,"147":86.5308787,"146":86.82008362},"495":{"152":85.70913442,"151":85.91559855,"150":86.24632517,"149":87.13426208,"148":86.3211263,"147":86.47602081,"146":86.91768138},"496":{"152":85.85537211,"151":85.85732524,"150":86.27374776,"149":86.60590871,"148":86.71157074,"147":86.85225169,"146":87.12237803},"497":{"152":86.04092407,"151":86.41228739,"150":86.41332245,"149":86.62849172,"148":86.95069885,"147":87.21248881,"146":87.26013947},"498":{"152":86.30155436,"151":86.62032064,"150":86.80579631,"149":86.87948608,"148":87.13800049,"147":87.42942301,"146":87.50773366}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Columbia, SC, United States", "location2": "Raleigh, NC, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Columbia, SC, United States or Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
f93682be-4d56-4038-b424-d6589c5406eb
As a city planner evaluating the impact of rising temperatures on community resilience, which city between Columbia, SC, and Raleigh, NC has shown a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 105°F during the summer in both the historical and projected end-century periods?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1385/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(b) Columbia, SC, United States experienced a greater change than Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Columbia, SC, United States.']
['Columbia, SC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Columbia, SC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in historical period']
{"480":{"131":null,"130":104.67367808,"129":104.49802907,"128":104.22798665,"127":104.4026947,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":104.47771962,"129":104.86864471,"128":104.89114126,"127":108.00789897,"126":103.75562541,"125":103.86618042,"124":104.47186534},"482":{"131":103.74072011,"130":104.16809845,"129":105.13431803,"128":105.36697133,"127":104.67216492,"126":104.30345408,"125":104.33462779,"124":104.90238444},"483":{"131":104.13031769,"130":103.82535807,"129":104.80014801,"128":105.8703715,"127":105.81468455,"126":105.16291809,"125":104.71059672,"124":105.36537425},"484":{"131":104.68594869,"130":104.43065643,"129":104.47838847,"128":104.75147756,"127":106.75270081,"126":106.11667887,"125":105.52853648,"124":106.09367116},"485":{"131":105.50572205,"130":105.53328451,"129":105.27067566,"128":105.72998047,"127":107.16199493,"126":106.97716522,"125":106.28477987,"124":106.68306986},"486":{"131":105.67066701,"130":107.11413574,"129":106.36725108,"128":106.44829559,"127":107.52614085,"126":107.78529104,"125":107.02929179,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":107.10673269,"128":107.61429342,"127":108.3698705,"126":108.10055542,"125":107.68267314,"124":null}}
{"480":{"131":null,"130":88.13982391,"129":88.04748027,"128":87.84898122,"127":87.85672251,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":87.98475901,"129":88.19387054,"128":88.03085073,"127":87.63951619,"126":87.69615428,"125":87.75732676,"124":88.10734304},"482":{"131":87.50974274,"130":87.71620433,"129":88.20118968,"128":88.37795003,"127":88.2191747,"126":88.0313797,"125":88.00899251,"124":88.28249613},"483":{"131":87.71914673,"130":87.5449117,"129":88.02211507,"128":88.6958669,"127":88.89978536,"126":88.47029114,"125":88.17670949,"124":88.43710073},"484":{"131":88.00246429,"130":87.85137431,"129":88.15146383,"128":89.41805267,"127":89.26863607,"126":88.93296305,"125":88.44881185,"124":88.67670186},"485":{"131":88.37779999,"130":88.57177989,"129":88.51158142,"128":88.66477966,"127":89.21444194,"126":89.20446523,"125":88.75521088,"124":88.86039225},"486":{"131":88.54678853,"130":89.04342906,"129":88.93136851,"128":88.89100138,"127":89.31206512,"126":89.32860565,"125":88.96283722,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":89.05826314,"128":89.18718211,"127":89.41707611,"126":89.44038645,"125":89.2044576,"124":null}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":100.27670542,"150":100.78192902,"149":101.49919128,"148":101.92943827,"147":102.18273926,"146":null},"493":{"152":100.76464844,"151":101.49528503,"150":101.27377065,"149":102.27130127,"148":102.51672109,"147":103.12692006,"146":103.51754506},"494":{"152":101.14872233,"151":101.76997375,"150":101.93864441,"149":101.97853597,"148":102.21056112,"147":102.60025533,"146":103.30922699},"495":{"152":101.36516825,"151":101.60191091,"150":101.93216705,"149":101.6429952,"148":102.66585032,"147":102.73478699,"146":103.45061493},"496":{"152":101.74239858,"151":101.73141225,"150":102.43359375,"149":103.17438761,"148":103.4331665,"147":103.32438914,"146":103.92068227},"497":{"152":102.22806549,"151":102.64806875,"150":102.76686096,"149":103.43634542,"148":103.69246674,"147":103.96383921,"146":104.40803019},"498":{"152":102.70836385,"151":102.96325684,"150":103.27556101,"149":103.38446045,"148":103.92997742,"147":104.74274699,"146":104.72667694}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":85.09859975,"150":85.44670868,"149":85.95890808,"148":86.21758525,"147":86.4758021,"146":null},"493":{"152":85.41419983,"151":86.08327484,"150":86.97571055,"149":86.41147868,"148":86.58870188,"147":86.87223053,"146":87.05684916},"494":{"152":85.74001312,"151":86.18342845,"150":86.21973928,"149":86.24650574,"148":86.32286072,"147":86.5308787,"146":86.82008362},"495":{"152":85.70913442,"151":85.91559855,"150":86.24632517,"149":87.13426208,"148":86.3211263,"147":86.47602081,"146":86.91768138},"496":{"152":85.85537211,"151":85.85732524,"150":86.27374776,"149":86.60590871,"148":86.71157074,"147":86.85225169,"146":87.12237803},"497":{"152":86.04092407,"151":86.41228739,"150":86.41332245,"149":86.62849172,"148":86.95069885,"147":87.21248881,"146":87.26013947},"498":{"152":86.30155436,"151":86.62032064,"150":86.80579631,"149":86.87948608,"148":87.13800049,"147":87.42942301,"146":87.50773366}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Columbia, SC, United States", "location2": "Raleigh, NC, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Columbia, SC, United States or Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
ae9aebce-845d-4ec6-aecc-51963b07149f
As a city planner evaluating the impact of rising temperatures on community resilience, which city between Columbia, SC, and Raleigh, NC has shown a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 105°F during the summer in both the historical and projected end-century periods?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1385/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(b) Columbia, SC, United States experienced a greater change than Raleigh, NC, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Columbia, SC, United States and Raleigh, NC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Columbia, SC, United States.']
['Columbia, SC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Columbia, SC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Raleigh, NC, United States in summer in historical period']
{"480":{"131":null,"130":104.67367808,"129":104.49802907,"128":104.22798665,"127":104.4026947,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":104.47771962,"129":104.86864471,"128":104.89114126,"127":108.00789897,"126":103.75562541,"125":103.86618042,"124":104.47186534},"482":{"131":103.74072011,"130":104.16809845,"129":105.13431803,"128":105.36697133,"127":104.67216492,"126":104.30345408,"125":104.33462779,"124":104.90238444},"483":{"131":104.13031769,"130":103.82535807,"129":104.80014801,"128":105.8703715,"127":105.81468455,"126":105.16291809,"125":104.71059672,"124":105.36537425},"484":{"131":104.68594869,"130":104.43065643,"129":104.47838847,"128":104.75147756,"127":106.75270081,"126":106.11667887,"125":105.52853648,"124":106.09367116},"485":{"131":105.50572205,"130":105.53328451,"129":105.27067566,"128":105.72998047,"127":107.16199493,"126":106.97716522,"125":106.28477987,"124":106.68306986},"486":{"131":105.67066701,"130":107.11413574,"129":106.36725108,"128":106.44829559,"127":107.52614085,"126":107.78529104,"125":107.02929179,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":107.10673269,"128":107.61429342,"127":108.3698705,"126":108.10055542,"125":107.68267314,"124":null}}
{"480":{"131":null,"130":88.13982391,"129":88.04748027,"128":87.84898122,"127":87.85672251,"126":null,"125":null,"124":null},"481":{"131":null,"130":87.98475901,"129":88.19387054,"128":88.03085073,"127":87.63951619,"126":87.69615428,"125":87.75732676,"124":88.10734304},"482":{"131":87.50974274,"130":87.71620433,"129":88.20118968,"128":88.37795003,"127":88.2191747,"126":88.0313797,"125":88.00899251,"124":88.28249613},"483":{"131":87.71914673,"130":87.5449117,"129":88.02211507,"128":88.6958669,"127":88.89978536,"126":88.47029114,"125":88.17670949,"124":88.43710073},"484":{"131":88.00246429,"130":87.85137431,"129":88.15146383,"128":89.41805267,"127":89.26863607,"126":88.93296305,"125":88.44881185,"124":88.67670186},"485":{"131":88.37779999,"130":88.57177989,"129":88.51158142,"128":88.66477966,"127":89.21444194,"126":89.20446523,"125":88.75521088,"124":88.86039225},"486":{"131":88.54678853,"130":89.04342906,"129":88.93136851,"128":88.89100138,"127":89.31206512,"126":89.32860565,"125":88.96283722,"124":null},"487":{"131":null,"130":null,"129":89.05826314,"128":89.18718211,"127":89.41707611,"126":89.44038645,"125":89.2044576,"124":null}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":100.27670542,"150":100.78192902,"149":101.49919128,"148":101.92943827,"147":102.18273926,"146":null},"493":{"152":100.76464844,"151":101.49528503,"150":101.27377065,"149":102.27130127,"148":102.51672109,"147":103.12692006,"146":103.51754506},"494":{"152":101.14872233,"151":101.76997375,"150":101.93864441,"149":101.97853597,"148":102.21056112,"147":102.60025533,"146":103.30922699},"495":{"152":101.36516825,"151":101.60191091,"150":101.93216705,"149":101.6429952,"148":102.66585032,"147":102.73478699,"146":103.45061493},"496":{"152":101.74239858,"151":101.73141225,"150":102.43359375,"149":103.17438761,"148":103.4331665,"147":103.32438914,"146":103.92068227},"497":{"152":102.22806549,"151":102.64806875,"150":102.76686096,"149":103.43634542,"148":103.69246674,"147":103.96383921,"146":104.40803019},"498":{"152":102.70836385,"151":102.96325684,"150":103.27556101,"149":103.38446045,"148":103.92997742,"147":104.74274699,"146":104.72667694}}
{"492":{"152":null,"151":85.09859975,"150":85.44670868,"149":85.95890808,"148":86.21758525,"147":86.4758021,"146":null},"493":{"152":85.41419983,"151":86.08327484,"150":86.97571055,"149":86.41147868,"148":86.58870188,"147":86.87223053,"146":87.05684916},"494":{"152":85.74001312,"151":86.18342845,"150":86.21973928,"149":86.24650574,"148":86.32286072,"147":86.5308787,"146":86.82008362},"495":{"152":85.70913442,"151":85.91559855,"150":86.24632517,"149":87.13426208,"148":86.3211263,"147":86.47602081,"146":86.91768138},"496":{"152":85.85537211,"151":85.85732524,"150":86.27374776,"149":86.60590871,"148":86.71157074,"147":86.85225169,"146":87.12237803},"497":{"152":86.04092407,"151":86.41228739,"150":86.41332245,"149":86.62849172,"148":86.95069885,"147":87.21248881,"146":87.26013947},"498":{"152":86.30155436,"151":86.62032064,"150":86.80579631,"149":86.87948608,"148":87.13800049,"147":87.42942301,"146":87.50773366}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Columbia, SC, United States", "location2": "Raleigh, NC, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Columbia, SC, United States or Raleigh, NC, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
d0190580-7e04-4dc8-bf56-39e22d8f99c8
As a wildfire risk analyst evaluating patterns in fire weather indices for future forest management strategies, which location has shown a greater shift in its fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century and summer during the mid-century: Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":17.82970047,"163":16.65570068,"162":16.05279922,"161":14.18809986,"160":16.44000053,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":20.75849915,"163":18.84630013,"162":17.89710045,"161":16.4076004,"160":16.34090042,"159":17.30940056,"158":19.6644001},"304":{"164":20.58930016,"163":19.60890007,"162":19.20919991,"161":18.68829918,"160":17.5007,"159":18.26160049,"158":20.11269951},"305":{"164":21.02059937,"163":19.95350075,"162":19.69099998,"161":19.13669968,"160":18.59490013,"159":19.30179977,"158":20.44260025},"306":{"164":21.06520081,"163":20.01339912,"162":19.83740044,"161":19.6840992,"160":19.23329926,"159":19.32060051,"158":20.47920036},"307":{"164":21.0781002,"163":20.34160042,"162":20.20400047,"161":20.0678997,"160":19.59350014,"159":19.72299957,"158":20.71380043},"308":{"164":21.34589958,"163":20.77400017,"162":20.65159988,"161":20.36129951,"160":20.18790054,"159":20.50860023,"158":21.06760025}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":27.8920002,"223":28.50769997,"222":29.26840019,"221":30.70560074,"220":null},"226":{"226":23.02359962,"225":26.84119987,"224":27.42849922,"223":28.09959984,"222":28.95879936,"221":29.81769943,"220":null},"227":{"226":22.1067009,"225":25.48329926,"224":26.92480087,"223":27.96170044,"222":28.52860069,"221":28.86630058,"220":29.06999969},"228":{"226":22.13269997,"225":24.70779991,"224":25.73789978,"223":26.80850029,"222":27.60330009,"221":27.75830078,"220":27.72360039},"229":{"226":22.73740005,"225":23.01740074,"224":23.83370018,"223":25.41640091,"222":25.62080002,"221":25.83839989,"220":26.17580032},"230":{"226":null,"225":18.94050026,"224":20.31889915,"223":23.53039932,"222":22.07419968,"221":24.20420074,"220":24.83499908},"231":{"226":null,"225":17.73929977,"224":19.36860085,"223":22.23410034,"222":20.52549934,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
11201139-8a95-472c-b26f-bac38c01eef4
As a wildfire risk analyst evaluating patterns in fire weather indices for future forest management strategies, which location has shown a greater shift in its fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century and summer during the mid-century: Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1241/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":17.82970047,"163":16.65570068,"162":16.05279922,"161":14.18809986,"160":16.44000053,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":20.75849915,"163":18.84630013,"162":17.89710045,"161":16.4076004,"160":16.34090042,"159":17.30940056,"158":19.6644001},"304":{"164":20.58930016,"163":19.60890007,"162":19.20919991,"161":18.68829918,"160":17.5007,"159":18.26160049,"158":20.11269951},"305":{"164":21.02059937,"163":19.95350075,"162":19.69099998,"161":19.13669968,"160":18.59490013,"159":19.30179977,"158":20.44260025},"306":{"164":21.06520081,"163":20.01339912,"162":19.83740044,"161":19.6840992,"160":19.23329926,"159":19.32060051,"158":20.47920036},"307":{"164":21.0781002,"163":20.34160042,"162":20.20400047,"161":20.0678997,"160":19.59350014,"159":19.72299957,"158":20.71380043},"308":{"164":21.34589958,"163":20.77400017,"162":20.65159988,"161":20.36129951,"160":20.18790054,"159":20.50860023,"158":21.06760025}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":27.8920002,"223":28.50769997,"222":29.26840019,"221":30.70560074,"220":null},"226":{"226":23.02359962,"225":26.84119987,"224":27.42849922,"223":28.09959984,"222":28.95879936,"221":29.81769943,"220":null},"227":{"226":22.1067009,"225":25.48329926,"224":26.92480087,"223":27.96170044,"222":28.52860069,"221":28.86630058,"220":29.06999969},"228":{"226":22.13269997,"225":24.70779991,"224":25.73789978,"223":26.80850029,"222":27.60330009,"221":27.75830078,"220":27.72360039},"229":{"226":22.73740005,"225":23.01740074,"224":23.83370018,"223":25.41640091,"222":25.62080002,"221":25.83839989,"220":26.17580032},"230":{"226":null,"225":18.94050026,"224":20.31889915,"223":23.53039932,"222":22.07419968,"221":24.20420074,"220":24.83499908},"231":{"226":null,"225":17.73929977,"224":19.36860085,"223":22.23410034,"222":20.52549934,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
28cee86c-d02a-4856-8cd5-627ae82b83ac
As a wildfire risk analyst evaluating patterns in fire weather indices for future forest management strategies, which location has shown a greater shift in its fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century and summer during the mid-century: Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1241/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":17.82970047,"163":16.65570068,"162":16.05279922,"161":14.18809986,"160":16.44000053,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":20.75849915,"163":18.84630013,"162":17.89710045,"161":16.4076004,"160":16.34090042,"159":17.30940056,"158":19.6644001},"304":{"164":20.58930016,"163":19.60890007,"162":19.20919991,"161":18.68829918,"160":17.5007,"159":18.26160049,"158":20.11269951},"305":{"164":21.02059937,"163":19.95350075,"162":19.69099998,"161":19.13669968,"160":18.59490013,"159":19.30179977,"158":20.44260025},"306":{"164":21.06520081,"163":20.01339912,"162":19.83740044,"161":19.6840992,"160":19.23329926,"159":19.32060051,"158":20.47920036},"307":{"164":21.0781002,"163":20.34160042,"162":20.20400047,"161":20.0678997,"160":19.59350014,"159":19.72299957,"158":20.71380043},"308":{"164":21.34589958,"163":20.77400017,"162":20.65159988,"161":20.36129951,"160":20.18790054,"159":20.50860023,"158":21.06760025}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":27.8920002,"223":28.50769997,"222":29.26840019,"221":30.70560074,"220":null},"226":{"226":23.02359962,"225":26.84119987,"224":27.42849922,"223":28.09959984,"222":28.95879936,"221":29.81769943,"220":null},"227":{"226":22.1067009,"225":25.48329926,"224":26.92480087,"223":27.96170044,"222":28.52860069,"221":28.86630058,"220":29.06999969},"228":{"226":22.13269997,"225":24.70779991,"224":25.73789978,"223":26.80850029,"222":27.60330009,"221":27.75830078,"220":27.72360039},"229":{"226":22.73740005,"225":23.01740074,"224":23.83370018,"223":25.41640091,"222":25.62080002,"221":25.83839989,"220":26.17580032},"230":{"226":null,"225":18.94050026,"224":20.31889915,"223":23.53039932,"222":22.07419968,"221":24.20420074,"220":24.83499908},"231":{"226":null,"225":17.73929977,"224":19.36860085,"223":22.23410034,"222":20.52549934,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
4d95e113-b16f-4dbd-af25-de51d966c6a7
As a wildfire risk analyst evaluating patterns in fire weather indices for future forest management strategies, which location has shown a greater shift in its fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century and summer during the mid-century: Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1241/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":17.82970047,"163":16.65570068,"162":16.05279922,"161":14.18809986,"160":16.44000053,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":20.75849915,"163":18.84630013,"162":17.89710045,"161":16.4076004,"160":16.34090042,"159":17.30940056,"158":19.6644001},"304":{"164":20.58930016,"163":19.60890007,"162":19.20919991,"161":18.68829918,"160":17.5007,"159":18.26160049,"158":20.11269951},"305":{"164":21.02059937,"163":19.95350075,"162":19.69099998,"161":19.13669968,"160":18.59490013,"159":19.30179977,"158":20.44260025},"306":{"164":21.06520081,"163":20.01339912,"162":19.83740044,"161":19.6840992,"160":19.23329926,"159":19.32060051,"158":20.47920036},"307":{"164":21.0781002,"163":20.34160042,"162":20.20400047,"161":20.0678997,"160":19.59350014,"159":19.72299957,"158":20.71380043},"308":{"164":21.34589958,"163":20.77400017,"162":20.65159988,"161":20.36129951,"160":20.18790054,"159":20.50860023,"158":21.06760025}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":27.8920002,"223":28.50769997,"222":29.26840019,"221":30.70560074,"220":null},"226":{"226":23.02359962,"225":26.84119987,"224":27.42849922,"223":28.09959984,"222":28.95879936,"221":29.81769943,"220":null},"227":{"226":22.1067009,"225":25.48329926,"224":26.92480087,"223":27.96170044,"222":28.52860069,"221":28.86630058,"220":29.06999969},"228":{"226":22.13269997,"225":24.70779991,"224":25.73789978,"223":26.80850029,"222":27.60330009,"221":27.75830078,"220":27.72360039},"229":{"226":22.73740005,"225":23.01740074,"224":23.83370018,"223":25.41640091,"222":25.62080002,"221":25.83839989,"220":26.17580032},"230":{"226":null,"225":18.94050026,"224":20.31889915,"223":23.53039932,"222":22.07419968,"221":24.20420074,"220":24.83499908},"231":{"226":null,"225":17.73929977,"224":19.36860085,"223":22.23410034,"222":20.52549934,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
1dde5776-b5a0-4c7c-ad22-46b1bf9c985f
As a hydrologist presenting at a regional water management conference, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":86.31430054,"223":69.71749878,"222":62.43809891,"221":62.16930008,"220":63.73609924,"219":null},"191":{"227":122.50499725,"226":125.8259964,"225":113.10800171,"224":87.97440338,"223":69.50769806,"222":60.83950043,"221":56.0632019,"220":53.50650024,"219":null},"192":{"227":120.11199951,"226":117.18699646,"225":96.99299622,"224":76.31169891,"223":63.41930008,"222":59.83319855,"221":54.90819931,"220":47.49720001,"219":43.8044014},"193":{"227":112.43900299,"226":94.71080017,"225":72.66629791,"224":60.65230179,"223":53.74330139,"222":53.41740036,"221":53.12850189,"220":48.4693985,"219":44.27140045},"194":{"227":80.85250092,"226":68.43689728,"225":58.8891983,"224":51.7466011,"223":47.14160156,"222":46.70149994,"221":47.4056015,"220":49.48400116,"219":52.17060089},"195":{"227":52.14170074,"226":53.52320099,"225":54.12400055,"224":48.4294014,"223":43.51409912,"222":42.88740158,"221":42.81790161,"220":46.8105011,"219":58.46250153},"196":{"227":39.93880081,"226":46.58200073,"225":48.59560013,"224":51.43349838,"223":54.69919968,"222":40.64419937,"221":39.07519913,"220":41.55619812,"219":56.10950089},"197":{"227":35.68579865,"226":40.19200134,"225":41.93199921,"224":40.88159943,"223":40.63010025,"222":40.92580032,"221":39.01679993,"220":39.27410126,"219":50.46379852},"198":{"227":null,"226":45.50439835,"225":42.46519852,"224":50.08129883,"223":39.72230148,"222":40.70700073,"221":42.93050003,"220":47.5326004,"219":52.04679871}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":88.28430176,"75":98.82050323,"74":85.32810211,"73":72.52310181,"72":72.31279755,"71":67.78659821,"70":68.28019714,"69":69.23020172,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":70.31880188,"75":78.16799927,"74":78.57710266,"73":73.44120026,"72":74.18379974,"71":71.02429962,"70":65.53220367,"69":73.23249817,"68":87.17839813,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":56.26990128,"75":59.77119827,"74":59.60219955,"73":58.6955986,"72":58.99470139,"71":63.22710037,"70":64.28160095,"69":63.61769867,"68":73.97280121,"67":null},"490":{"77":51.28950119,"76":50.0041008,"75":49.34659958,"74":51.17010117,"73":56.09790039,"72":56.83050156,"71":65.69219971,"70":79.88179779,"69":null,"68":66.05680084,"67":73.61530304},"491":{"77":46.68259811,"76":48.10200119,"75":46.60169983,"74":45.70780182,"73":47.81420135,"72":53.62179947,"71":56.52389908,"70":60.75880051,"69":66.48449707,"68":65.92160034,"67":67.74069977},"492":{"77":42.58039856,"76":45.46300125,"75":47.49069977,"74":47.4958992,"73":46.65599823,"72":48.39360046,"71":50.63700104,"70":51.73210144,"69":54.00979996,"68":56.15480042,"67":58.03570175},"493":{"77":40.37929916,"76":41.25569916,"75":42.99639893,"74":44.05699921,"73":42.16080093,"72":42.84569931,"71":45.75059891,"70":46.37229919,"69":46.92139816,"68":49.92699814,"67":52.8390007},"494":{"77":40.24779892,"76":40.58710098,"75":41.56159973,"74":41.4693985,"73":40.91650009,"72":44.22180176,"71":42.51459885,"70":43.17779922,"69":41.70460129,"68":44.62799835,"67":48.0381012},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":39.84209824,"74":38.8594017,"73":39.68610001,"72":39.96910095,"71":39.71580124,"70":41.06990051,"69":40.51520157,"68":42.01900101,"67":45.35649872},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":39.32939911,"71":38.6114006,"70":40.13460159,"69":40.18080139,"68":41.67660141,"67":42.7840004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
dde6389c-2eb9-4a9e-9c7a-060291157a01
As a hydrologist presenting at a regional water management conference, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1336/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":86.31430054,"223":69.71749878,"222":62.43809891,"221":62.16930008,"220":63.73609924,"219":null},"191":{"227":122.50499725,"226":125.8259964,"225":113.10800171,"224":87.97440338,"223":69.50769806,"222":60.83950043,"221":56.0632019,"220":53.50650024,"219":null},"192":{"227":120.11199951,"226":117.18699646,"225":96.99299622,"224":76.31169891,"223":63.41930008,"222":59.83319855,"221":54.90819931,"220":47.49720001,"219":43.8044014},"193":{"227":112.43900299,"226":94.71080017,"225":72.66629791,"224":60.65230179,"223":53.74330139,"222":53.41740036,"221":53.12850189,"220":48.4693985,"219":44.27140045},"194":{"227":80.85250092,"226":68.43689728,"225":58.8891983,"224":51.7466011,"223":47.14160156,"222":46.70149994,"221":47.4056015,"220":49.48400116,"219":52.17060089},"195":{"227":52.14170074,"226":53.52320099,"225":54.12400055,"224":48.4294014,"223":43.51409912,"222":42.88740158,"221":42.81790161,"220":46.8105011,"219":58.46250153},"196":{"227":39.93880081,"226":46.58200073,"225":48.59560013,"224":51.43349838,"223":54.69919968,"222":40.64419937,"221":39.07519913,"220":41.55619812,"219":56.10950089},"197":{"227":35.68579865,"226":40.19200134,"225":41.93199921,"224":40.88159943,"223":40.63010025,"222":40.92580032,"221":39.01679993,"220":39.27410126,"219":50.46379852},"198":{"227":null,"226":45.50439835,"225":42.46519852,"224":50.08129883,"223":39.72230148,"222":40.70700073,"221":42.93050003,"220":47.5326004,"219":52.04679871}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":88.28430176,"75":98.82050323,"74":85.32810211,"73":72.52310181,"72":72.31279755,"71":67.78659821,"70":68.28019714,"69":69.23020172,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":70.31880188,"75":78.16799927,"74":78.57710266,"73":73.44120026,"72":74.18379974,"71":71.02429962,"70":65.53220367,"69":73.23249817,"68":87.17839813,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":56.26990128,"75":59.77119827,"74":59.60219955,"73":58.6955986,"72":58.99470139,"71":63.22710037,"70":64.28160095,"69":63.61769867,"68":73.97280121,"67":null},"490":{"77":51.28950119,"76":50.0041008,"75":49.34659958,"74":51.17010117,"73":56.09790039,"72":56.83050156,"71":65.69219971,"70":79.88179779,"69":null,"68":66.05680084,"67":73.61530304},"491":{"77":46.68259811,"76":48.10200119,"75":46.60169983,"74":45.70780182,"73":47.81420135,"72":53.62179947,"71":56.52389908,"70":60.75880051,"69":66.48449707,"68":65.92160034,"67":67.74069977},"492":{"77":42.58039856,"76":45.46300125,"75":47.49069977,"74":47.4958992,"73":46.65599823,"72":48.39360046,"71":50.63700104,"70":51.73210144,"69":54.00979996,"68":56.15480042,"67":58.03570175},"493":{"77":40.37929916,"76":41.25569916,"75":42.99639893,"74":44.05699921,"73":42.16080093,"72":42.84569931,"71":45.75059891,"70":46.37229919,"69":46.92139816,"68":49.92699814,"67":52.8390007},"494":{"77":40.24779892,"76":40.58710098,"75":41.56159973,"74":41.4693985,"73":40.91650009,"72":44.22180176,"71":42.51459885,"70":43.17779922,"69":41.70460129,"68":44.62799835,"67":48.0381012},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":39.84209824,"74":38.8594017,"73":39.68610001,"72":39.96910095,"71":39.71580124,"70":41.06990051,"69":40.51520157,"68":42.01900101,"67":45.35649872},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":39.32939911,"71":38.6114006,"70":40.13460159,"69":40.18080139,"68":41.67660141,"67":42.7840004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
3ff045c4-53d3-4b69-813c-f7dd56e3abe8
As a hydrologist presenting at a regional water management conference, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1336/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":86.31430054,"223":69.71749878,"222":62.43809891,"221":62.16930008,"220":63.73609924,"219":null},"191":{"227":122.50499725,"226":125.8259964,"225":113.10800171,"224":87.97440338,"223":69.50769806,"222":60.83950043,"221":56.0632019,"220":53.50650024,"219":null},"192":{"227":120.11199951,"226":117.18699646,"225":96.99299622,"224":76.31169891,"223":63.41930008,"222":59.83319855,"221":54.90819931,"220":47.49720001,"219":43.8044014},"193":{"227":112.43900299,"226":94.71080017,"225":72.66629791,"224":60.65230179,"223":53.74330139,"222":53.41740036,"221":53.12850189,"220":48.4693985,"219":44.27140045},"194":{"227":80.85250092,"226":68.43689728,"225":58.8891983,"224":51.7466011,"223":47.14160156,"222":46.70149994,"221":47.4056015,"220":49.48400116,"219":52.17060089},"195":{"227":52.14170074,"226":53.52320099,"225":54.12400055,"224":48.4294014,"223":43.51409912,"222":42.88740158,"221":42.81790161,"220":46.8105011,"219":58.46250153},"196":{"227":39.93880081,"226":46.58200073,"225":48.59560013,"224":51.43349838,"223":54.69919968,"222":40.64419937,"221":39.07519913,"220":41.55619812,"219":56.10950089},"197":{"227":35.68579865,"226":40.19200134,"225":41.93199921,"224":40.88159943,"223":40.63010025,"222":40.92580032,"221":39.01679993,"220":39.27410126,"219":50.46379852},"198":{"227":null,"226":45.50439835,"225":42.46519852,"224":50.08129883,"223":39.72230148,"222":40.70700073,"221":42.93050003,"220":47.5326004,"219":52.04679871}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":88.28430176,"75":98.82050323,"74":85.32810211,"73":72.52310181,"72":72.31279755,"71":67.78659821,"70":68.28019714,"69":69.23020172,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":70.31880188,"75":78.16799927,"74":78.57710266,"73":73.44120026,"72":74.18379974,"71":71.02429962,"70":65.53220367,"69":73.23249817,"68":87.17839813,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":56.26990128,"75":59.77119827,"74":59.60219955,"73":58.6955986,"72":58.99470139,"71":63.22710037,"70":64.28160095,"69":63.61769867,"68":73.97280121,"67":null},"490":{"77":51.28950119,"76":50.0041008,"75":49.34659958,"74":51.17010117,"73":56.09790039,"72":56.83050156,"71":65.69219971,"70":79.88179779,"69":null,"68":66.05680084,"67":73.61530304},"491":{"77":46.68259811,"76":48.10200119,"75":46.60169983,"74":45.70780182,"73":47.81420135,"72":53.62179947,"71":56.52389908,"70":60.75880051,"69":66.48449707,"68":65.92160034,"67":67.74069977},"492":{"77":42.58039856,"76":45.46300125,"75":47.49069977,"74":47.4958992,"73":46.65599823,"72":48.39360046,"71":50.63700104,"70":51.73210144,"69":54.00979996,"68":56.15480042,"67":58.03570175},"493":{"77":40.37929916,"76":41.25569916,"75":42.99639893,"74":44.05699921,"73":42.16080093,"72":42.84569931,"71":45.75059891,"70":46.37229919,"69":46.92139816,"68":49.92699814,"67":52.8390007},"494":{"77":40.24779892,"76":40.58710098,"75":41.56159973,"74":41.4693985,"73":40.91650009,"72":44.22180176,"71":42.51459885,"70":43.17779922,"69":41.70460129,"68":44.62799835,"67":48.0381012},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":39.84209824,"74":38.8594017,"73":39.68610001,"72":39.96910095,"71":39.71580124,"70":41.06990051,"69":40.51520157,"68":42.01900101,"67":45.35649872},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":39.32939911,"71":38.6114006,"70":40.13460159,"69":40.18080139,"68":41.67660141,"67":42.7840004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
da7a9db3-8d44-41cd-902b-7ef159962c9f
As a hydrologist presenting at a regional water management conference, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation during the mid-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the end-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1336/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":88.66459656,"223":70.62290192,"222":62.88510132,"221":62.77230072,"220":64.67479706,"219":null},"191":{"227":125.65799713,"226":130.36999512,"225":117.36699677,"224":90.26820374,"223":70.6257019,"222":61.5603981,"221":55.79529953,"220":52.78969955,"219":null},"192":{"227":121.15599823,"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":47.05519867,"219":43.29729843},"193":{"227":112.60800171,"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":49.7580986,"219":45.16640091},"194":{"227":79.34519958,"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912,"219":54.48699951},"195":{"227":50.39780045,"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093,"219":60.70880127},"196":{"227":38.68650055,"226":45.79330063,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103,"219":56.12360001},"197":{"227":34.9612999,"226":39.52939987,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881,"219":49.93899918},"198":{"227":null,"226":47.12149811,"225":44.44509888,"224":51.43859863,"223":40.80730057,"222":41.96960068,"221":45.25780106,"220":50.10800171,"219":53.19219971}}
{"190":{"227":null,"226":null,"225":null,"224":86.31430054,"223":69.71749878,"222":62.43809891,"221":62.16930008,"220":63.73609924,"219":null},"191":{"227":122.50499725,"226":125.8259964,"225":113.10800171,"224":87.97440338,"223":69.50769806,"222":60.83950043,"221":56.0632019,"220":53.50650024,"219":null},"192":{"227":120.11199951,"226":117.18699646,"225":96.99299622,"224":76.31169891,"223":63.41930008,"222":59.83319855,"221":54.90819931,"220":47.49720001,"219":43.8044014},"193":{"227":112.43900299,"226":94.71080017,"225":72.66629791,"224":60.65230179,"223":53.74330139,"222":53.41740036,"221":53.12850189,"220":48.4693985,"219":44.27140045},"194":{"227":80.85250092,"226":68.43689728,"225":58.8891983,"224":51.7466011,"223":47.14160156,"222":46.70149994,"221":47.4056015,"220":49.48400116,"219":52.17060089},"195":{"227":52.14170074,"226":53.52320099,"225":54.12400055,"224":48.4294014,"223":43.51409912,"222":42.88740158,"221":42.81790161,"220":46.8105011,"219":58.46250153},"196":{"227":39.93880081,"226":46.58200073,"225":48.59560013,"224":51.43349838,"223":54.69919968,"222":40.64419937,"221":39.07519913,"220":41.55619812,"219":56.10950089},"197":{"227":35.68579865,"226":40.19200134,"225":41.93199921,"224":40.88159943,"223":40.63010025,"222":40.92580032,"221":39.01679993,"220":39.27410126,"219":50.46379852},"198":{"227":null,"226":45.50439835,"225":42.46519852,"224":50.08129883,"223":39.72230148,"222":40.70700073,"221":42.93050003,"220":47.5326004,"219":52.04679871}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":92.07959747,"75":102.66600037,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":72.37339783,"75":81.06169891,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":57.60549927,"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965,"67":null},"490":{"77":53.1916008,"76":51.81650162,"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907,"67":73.96340179},"491":{"77":49.18360138,"76":50.56230164,"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996,"67":72.71749878},"492":{"77":44.84379959,"76":47.7254982,"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985,"67":64.90329742},"493":{"77":42.45389938,"76":42.71500015,"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036,"67":58.14339828},"494":{"77":42.3504982,"76":42.27859879,"75":43.10639954,"74":43.76800156,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056,"67":51.66640091},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":41.63679886,"74":41.40670013,"73":42.10039902,"72":42.90380096,"71":41.99319839,"70":43.55130005,"69":43.71170044,"68":45.06639862,"67":48.21879959},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":41.72779846,"71":40.83369827,"70":42.27030182,"69":42.40850067,"68":43.57210159,"67":45.07450104}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":88.28430176,"75":98.82050323,"74":85.32810211,"73":72.52310181,"72":72.31279755,"71":67.78659821,"70":68.28019714,"69":69.23020172,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":70.31880188,"75":78.16799927,"74":78.57710266,"73":73.44120026,"72":74.18379974,"71":71.02429962,"70":65.53220367,"69":73.23249817,"68":87.17839813,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":56.26990128,"75":59.77119827,"74":59.60219955,"73":58.6955986,"72":58.99470139,"71":63.22710037,"70":64.28160095,"69":63.61769867,"68":73.97280121,"67":null},"490":{"77":51.28950119,"76":50.0041008,"75":49.34659958,"74":51.17010117,"73":56.09790039,"72":56.83050156,"71":65.69219971,"70":79.88179779,"69":null,"68":66.05680084,"67":73.61530304},"491":{"77":46.68259811,"76":48.10200119,"75":46.60169983,"74":45.70780182,"73":47.81420135,"72":53.62179947,"71":56.52389908,"70":60.75880051,"69":66.48449707,"68":65.92160034,"67":67.74069977},"492":{"77":42.58039856,"76":45.46300125,"75":47.49069977,"74":47.4958992,"73":46.65599823,"72":48.39360046,"71":50.63700104,"70":51.73210144,"69":54.00979996,"68":56.15480042,"67":58.03570175},"493":{"77":40.37929916,"76":41.25569916,"75":42.99639893,"74":44.05699921,"73":42.16080093,"72":42.84569931,"71":45.75059891,"70":46.37229919,"69":46.92139816,"68":49.92699814,"67":52.8390007},"494":{"77":40.24779892,"76":40.58710098,"75":41.56159973,"74":41.4693985,"73":40.91650009,"72":44.22180176,"71":42.51459885,"70":43.17779922,"69":41.70460129,"68":44.62799835,"67":48.0381012},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":39.84209824,"74":38.8594017,"73":39.68610001,"72":39.96910095,"71":39.71580124,"70":41.06990051,"69":40.51520157,"68":42.01900101,"67":45.35649872},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":39.32939911,"71":38.6114006,"70":40.13460159,"69":40.18080139,"68":41.67660141,"67":42.7840004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
e8eadf8f-7347-4d22-a603-ed618d674fd5
As a wildland firefighter preparing for the upcoming season, I'm curious to know which city has experienced a more significant change in fire weather index during the autumn months historically and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
c256d876-c2b9-4a15-a09c-f630acefeb2e
As a wildland firefighter preparing for the upcoming season, I'm curious to know which city has experienced a more significant change in fire weather index during the autumn months historically and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1329/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
0c5f8924-a37c-417c-a6c5-cf89f50b7f8d
As a wildland firefighter preparing for the upcoming season, I'm curious to know which city has experienced a more significant change in fire weather index during the autumn months historically and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1329/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
e01fedb8-9106-45b6-ab26-de1f21b9f1ef
As a wildland firefighter preparing for the upcoming season, I'm curious to know which city has experienced a more significant change in fire weather index during the autumn months historically and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1329/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
75b7cb49-e970-4582-9e85-e3a4449ed48e
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating the fire weather index trends, I'm trying to determine which city experienced a greater shift: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, during autumn in the end-century period and summer in the mid-century period?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
9005b9ff-a73c-4b87-bb42-2de44d1a6e1a
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating the fire weather index trends, I'm trying to determine which city experienced a greater shift: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, during autumn in the end-century period and summer in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1308/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
e00a17f9-516f-4a69-a6f7-76d6874443d8
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating the fire weather index trends, I'm trying to determine which city experienced a greater shift: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, during autumn in the end-century period and summer in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1308/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
69d9d0cc-3a7b-4eb6-b7ca-df244a769c33
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating the fire weather index trends, I'm trying to determine which city experienced a greater shift: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, during autumn in the end-century period and summer in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1308/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
5a3c0d94-58cb-413e-b3e9-339ea396e26a
As a meteorologist presenting at a conference on regional temperature trends, I would like to know which location, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, has undergone more significant variations in minimum seasonal temperatures during the summer historically and in winter during the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
tabular
null
48
(d)
['(a) The Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in summer in historical period', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in summer in historical period', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"326":{"216":null,"215":57.63219833,"214":57.65710068,"213":57.89649963,"212":58.13800049,"211":58.49060059,"210":58.97570038},"327":{"216":null,"215":57.55699921,"214":57.77399826,"213":58.10739899,"212":58.41960144,"211":58.4864006,"210":58.8512001},"328":{"216":null,"215":57.08300018,"214":57.3103981,"213":57.95970154,"212":58.4211998,"211":58.73830032,"210":58.79930115},"329":{"216":57.02740097,"215":56.96179962,"214":57.05059814,"213":57.49119949,"212":58.40869904,"211":58.54650116,"210":58.9836998},"330":{"216":56.73099899,"215":56.7439003,"214":57.12120056,"213":57.72790146,"212":58.15629959,"211":58.61859894,"210":59.00130081},"331":{"216":56.5760994,"215":56.69620132,"214":57.04380035,"213":57.20980072,"212":58.1291008,"211":58.34130096,"210":58.75690079}}
{"326":{"216":null,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979},"327":{"216":null,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977},"328":{"216":null,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998},"329":{"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906},"330":{"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978},"331":{"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":57.71910095,"217":57.28680038,"216":57.43569946,"215":57.55089951,"214":57.48199844,"213":null},"486":{"219":56.54489899,"218":56.5265007,"217":57.08089828,"216":58.07830048,"215":57.50839996,"214":57.02489853,"213":55.94300079},"487":{"219":56.29430008,"218":56.38819885,"217":57.11059952,"216":57.65179825,"215":57.2580986,"214":56.16799927,"213":55.11270142},"488":{"219":56.03820038,"218":56.50740051,"217":56.93270111,"216":62.33620071,"215":56.53649902,"214":55.30749893,"213":54.30070114},"489":{"219":56.00490189,"218":59.78490067,"217":57.2276001,"216":56.8390007,"215":55.60210037,"214":54.50180054,"213":53.99290085},"490":{"219":55.85160065,"218":57.00849915,"217":56.92020035,"216":55.67010117,"215":54.39799881,"214":53.8465004,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":56.4516983,"216":55.15950012,"215":54.06750107,"214":53.53760147,"213":null}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":null},"486":{"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977},"487":{"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056},"488":{"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917},"489":{"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035},"490":{"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout summer in historical period and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
3f8153ec-09a4-4867-8ca3-7c2836491b9a
As a meteorologist presenting at a conference on regional temperature trends, I would like to know which location, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, has undergone more significant variations in minimum seasonal temperatures during the summer historically and in winter during the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1282/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in summer in historical period', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in summer in historical period', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"326":{"216":null,"215":57.63219833,"214":57.65710068,"213":57.89649963,"212":58.13800049,"211":58.49060059,"210":58.97570038},"327":{"216":null,"215":57.55699921,"214":57.77399826,"213":58.10739899,"212":58.41960144,"211":58.4864006,"210":58.8512001},"328":{"216":null,"215":57.08300018,"214":57.3103981,"213":57.95970154,"212":58.4211998,"211":58.73830032,"210":58.79930115},"329":{"216":57.02740097,"215":56.96179962,"214":57.05059814,"213":57.49119949,"212":58.40869904,"211":58.54650116,"210":58.9836998},"330":{"216":56.73099899,"215":56.7439003,"214":57.12120056,"213":57.72790146,"212":58.15629959,"211":58.61859894,"210":59.00130081},"331":{"216":56.5760994,"215":56.69620132,"214":57.04380035,"213":57.20980072,"212":58.1291008,"211":58.34130096,"210":58.75690079}}
{"326":{"216":null,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979},"327":{"216":null,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977},"328":{"216":null,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998},"329":{"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906},"330":{"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978},"331":{"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":57.71910095,"217":57.28680038,"216":57.43569946,"215":57.55089951,"214":57.48199844,"213":null},"486":{"219":56.54489899,"218":56.5265007,"217":57.08089828,"216":58.07830048,"215":57.50839996,"214":57.02489853,"213":55.94300079},"487":{"219":56.29430008,"218":56.38819885,"217":57.11059952,"216":57.65179825,"215":57.2580986,"214":56.16799927,"213":55.11270142},"488":{"219":56.03820038,"218":56.50740051,"217":56.93270111,"216":62.33620071,"215":56.53649902,"214":55.30749893,"213":54.30070114},"489":{"219":56.00490189,"218":59.78490067,"217":57.2276001,"216":56.8390007,"215":55.60210037,"214":54.50180054,"213":53.99290085},"490":{"219":55.85160065,"218":57.00849915,"217":56.92020035,"216":55.67010117,"215":54.39799881,"214":53.8465004,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":56.4516983,"216":55.15950012,"215":54.06750107,"214":53.53760147,"213":null}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":null},"486":{"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977},"487":{"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056},"488":{"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917},"489":{"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035},"490":{"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout summer in historical period and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
5b4621dd-59f3-4564-9471-d65bcbb356db
As a meteorologist presenting at a conference on regional temperature trends, I would like to know which location, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, has undergone more significant variations in minimum seasonal temperatures during the summer historically and in winter during the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1282/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in summer in historical period', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in summer in historical period', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"326":{"216":null,"215":57.63219833,"214":57.65710068,"213":57.89649963,"212":58.13800049,"211":58.49060059,"210":58.97570038},"327":{"216":null,"215":57.55699921,"214":57.77399826,"213":58.10739899,"212":58.41960144,"211":58.4864006,"210":58.8512001},"328":{"216":null,"215":57.08300018,"214":57.3103981,"213":57.95970154,"212":58.4211998,"211":58.73830032,"210":58.79930115},"329":{"216":57.02740097,"215":56.96179962,"214":57.05059814,"213":57.49119949,"212":58.40869904,"211":58.54650116,"210":58.9836998},"330":{"216":56.73099899,"215":56.7439003,"214":57.12120056,"213":57.72790146,"212":58.15629959,"211":58.61859894,"210":59.00130081},"331":{"216":56.5760994,"215":56.69620132,"214":57.04380035,"213":57.20980072,"212":58.1291008,"211":58.34130096,"210":58.75690079}}
{"326":{"216":null,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979},"327":{"216":null,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977},"328":{"216":null,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998},"329":{"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906},"330":{"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978},"331":{"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":57.71910095,"217":57.28680038,"216":57.43569946,"215":57.55089951,"214":57.48199844,"213":null},"486":{"219":56.54489899,"218":56.5265007,"217":57.08089828,"216":58.07830048,"215":57.50839996,"214":57.02489853,"213":55.94300079},"487":{"219":56.29430008,"218":56.38819885,"217":57.11059952,"216":57.65179825,"215":57.2580986,"214":56.16799927,"213":55.11270142},"488":{"219":56.03820038,"218":56.50740051,"217":56.93270111,"216":62.33620071,"215":56.53649902,"214":55.30749893,"213":54.30070114},"489":{"219":56.00490189,"218":59.78490067,"217":57.2276001,"216":56.8390007,"215":55.60210037,"214":54.50180054,"213":53.99290085},"490":{"219":55.85160065,"218":57.00849915,"217":56.92020035,"216":55.67010117,"215":54.39799881,"214":53.8465004,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":56.4516983,"216":55.15950012,"215":54.06750107,"214":53.53760147,"213":null}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":null},"486":{"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977},"487":{"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056},"488":{"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917},"489":{"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035},"490":{"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout summer in historical period and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
ef5c0c49-70fc-4698-a722-b5f0a23477e2
As a meteorologist presenting at a conference on regional temperature trends, I would like to know which location, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, has undergone more significant variations in minimum seasonal temperatures during the summer historically and in winter during the mid-century period under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1282/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in summer in historical period', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in summer in historical period', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"326":{"216":null,"215":57.63219833,"214":57.65710068,"213":57.89649963,"212":58.13800049,"211":58.49060059,"210":58.97570038},"327":{"216":null,"215":57.55699921,"214":57.77399826,"213":58.10739899,"212":58.41960144,"211":58.4864006,"210":58.8512001},"328":{"216":null,"215":57.08300018,"214":57.3103981,"213":57.95970154,"212":58.4211998,"211":58.73830032,"210":58.79930115},"329":{"216":57.02740097,"215":56.96179962,"214":57.05059814,"213":57.49119949,"212":58.40869904,"211":58.54650116,"210":58.9836998},"330":{"216":56.73099899,"215":56.7439003,"214":57.12120056,"213":57.72790146,"212":58.15629959,"211":58.61859894,"210":59.00130081},"331":{"216":56.5760994,"215":56.69620132,"214":57.04380035,"213":57.20980072,"212":58.1291008,"211":58.34130096,"210":58.75690079}}
{"326":{"216":null,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979},"327":{"216":null,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977},"328":{"216":null,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998},"329":{"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906},"330":{"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978},"331":{"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":57.71910095,"217":57.28680038,"216":57.43569946,"215":57.55089951,"214":57.48199844,"213":null},"486":{"219":56.54489899,"218":56.5265007,"217":57.08089828,"216":58.07830048,"215":57.50839996,"214":57.02489853,"213":55.94300079},"487":{"219":56.29430008,"218":56.38819885,"217":57.11059952,"216":57.65179825,"215":57.2580986,"214":56.16799927,"213":55.11270142},"488":{"219":56.03820038,"218":56.50740051,"217":56.93270111,"216":62.33620071,"215":56.53649902,"214":55.30749893,"213":54.30070114},"489":{"219":56.00490189,"218":59.78490067,"217":57.2276001,"216":56.8390007,"215":55.60210037,"214":54.50180054,"213":53.99290085},"490":{"219":55.85160065,"218":57.00849915,"217":56.92020035,"216":55.67010117,"215":54.39799881,"214":53.8465004,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":56.4516983,"216":55.15950012,"215":54.06750107,"214":53.53760147,"213":null}}
{"485":{"219":null,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":null},"486":{"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977},"487":{"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056},"488":{"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917},"489":{"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035},"490":{"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":null},"491":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout summer in historical period and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
cd5e60ea-c52b-4862-b580-c55e0b890757
As a wildland firefighter assessing long-term trends in fire behavior, which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—showed a more significant variation in fire weather index during mid-century summers and winters?
trend
tabular
null
72
(d)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout summer in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
28417bed-6e29-4987-8f4c-60a829cee054
As a wildland firefighter assessing long-term trends in fire behavior, which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—showed a more significant variation in fire weather index during mid-century summers and winters?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1321/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout summer in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
db3c2a9f-8d4f-4923-b2ee-a0a9ffb028e7
As a wildland firefighter assessing long-term trends in fire behavior, which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—showed a more significant variation in fire weather index during mid-century summers and winters?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1321/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout summer in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
1d11507a-3c67-49fe-96b1-8fdb9b989cc5
As a wildland firefighter assessing long-term trends in fire behavior, which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—showed a more significant variation in fire weather index during mid-century summers and winters?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1321/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":8.80613041,"152":6.56428003,"151":6.95568991,"150":8.94396973,"149":11.4151001,"148":8.31756973,"147":5.08137989,"146":5.26443005,"145":8.49427986,"144":12.09560013},"301":{"153":12.00559998,"152":9.91683006,"151":8.6205101,"150":9.33808041,"149":10.70479965,"148":11.38659954,"147":8.46942043,"146":8.36077976,"145":9.63018036,"144":8.49335003},"302":{"153":16.21929932,"152":17.1576004,"151":17.16810036,"150":14.29590034,"149":13.86859989,"148":14.92949963,"147":14.19519997,"146":13.30669975,"145":14.35550022,"144":12.70979977},"303":{"153":19.92630005,"152":21.64049911,"151":22.10840034,"150":20.38389969,"149":19.4382,"148":19.93910027,"147":18.16609955,"146":16.65320015,"145":18.2621994,"144":18.49710083},"304":{"153":21.89179993,"152":22.52230072,"151":22.66699982,"150":22.28540039,"149":22.17499924,"148":21.98900032,"147":21.89690018,"146":21.17060089,"145":20.09700012,"144":18.36160088},"305":{"153":21.57920074,"152":21.50530052,"151":21.48089981,"150":21.6317997,"149":21.89220047,"148":20.99769974,"147":20.9810009,"146":21.89159966,"145":20.60059929,"144":18.31599998},"306":{"153":21.58569908,"152":21.17560005,"151":21.04330063,"150":21.12960052,"149":20.98509979,"148":20.65139961,"147":20.5454998,"146":20.24259949,"145":20.0258007,"144":19.08880043},"307":{"153":21.43610001,"152":20.90600014,"151":20.74370003,"150":20.70050049,"149":20.41040039,"148":19.76659966,"147":19.20070076,"146":18.72909927,"145":18.23889923,"144":17.56399918},"308":{"153":21.66329956,"152":21.27319908,"151":20.9734993,"150":20.98469925,"149":20.48550034,"148":20.00749969,"147":19.55579948,"146":18.81509972,"145":18.33600044,"144":17.46980095},"309":{"153":22.13439941,"152":21.77289963,"151":21.33720016,"150":21.27779961,"149":21.0632,"148":20.72920036,"147":20.41769981,"146":19.78179932,"145":19.01440048,"144":18.79199982}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":54.4919014,"119":52.40610123,"118":53.4076004,"117":56.292099,"116":56.80059814,"115":57.23149872},"226":{"124":52.64770126,"123":49.94200134,"122":46.01290131,"121":44.54219818,"120":46.61259842,"119":49.13850021,"118":49.05830002,"117":51.65219879,"116":55.3166008,"115":58.16279984},"227":{"124":48.74890137,"123":46.31510162,"122":38.35789871,"121":28.82309914,"120":30.80279922,"119":39.7961998,"118":47.59659958,"117":49.88259888,"116":53.06309891,"115":56.57519913},"228":{"124":49.9695015,"123":49.22129822,"122":48.00799942,"121":34.42599869,"120":30.52589989,"119":38.49959946,"118":46.19440079,"117":48.10039902,"116":51.97650146,"115":54.20700073},"229":{"124":51.95320129,"123":53.44319916,"122":56.87319946,"121":55.24940109,"120":47.57830048,"119":48.04570007,"118":52.42029953,"117":53.19850159,"116":55.44779968,"115":55.59749985},"230":{"124":51.3783989,"123":52.80649948,"122":57.02799988,"121":59.66759872,"120":57.40060043,"119":55.78030014,"118":56.78099823,"117":57.37680054,"116":58.41730118,"115":57.3044014},"231":{"124":37.16009903,"123":34.33779907,"122":40.77920151,"121":53.32830048,"120":58.19329834,"119":57.44549942,"118":57.17869949,"117":57.5401001,"116":57.77529907,"115":56.99580002},"232":{"124":37.5821991,"123":37.53850174,"122":43.85720062,"121":53.13550186,"120":58.99219894,"119":60.2798996,"118":59.81259918,"117":60.18920135,"116":60.91139984,"115":61.0481987},"233":{"124":53.51890182,"123":54.51589966,"122":57.06679916,"121":60.10219955,"120":62.75299835,"119":65.01850128,"118":66.86990356,"117":68.66819763,"116":70.15930176,"115":70.87770081},"234":{"124":56.07139969,"123":56.4280014,"122":58.52349854,"121":61.7439003,"120":63.9178009,"119":66.10369873,"118":70.20970154,"117":73.63770294,"116":75.01570129,"115":75.70300293},"235":{"124":57.01079941,"123":56.09180069,"122":57.87950134,"121":61.05239868,"120":62.99259949,"119":65.51260376,"118":70.00509644,"117":73.69490051,"116":74.86219788,"115":74.56999969}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout summer in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
666cdb50-cc49-4cc7-a301-bd4859cf08b6
As a city planner working on sustainability initiatives, I'm interested in understanding which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant change in minimum annual temperature between the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP4.5 scenarios.
trend
tabular
null
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.72919846,"210":41.28609848,"209":44.3370018,"208":41.58459854,"207":44.29560089,"206":44.54729843},"472":{"211":41.54029846,"210":41.00379944,"209":44.49940109,"208":44.28300095,"207":41.12900162,"206":41.59159851},"473":{"211":41.27629852,"210":40.95500183,"209":40.71080017,"208":40.57490158,"207":40.58349991,"206":40.08950043},"474":{"211":40.81949997,"210":40.72330093,"209":40.54330063,"208":40.19329834,"207":39.53540039,"206":39.19839859}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.12720108,"176":44.27349854,"175":44.48690033,"174":44.67229843,"173":44.7030983,"172":44.83779907,"171":44.98419952},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.17969894,"176":44.38159943,"175":44.54850006,"174":44.79759979,"173":44.99169922,"172":45.14839935,"171":45.25709915},"453":{"178":43.99150085,"177":44.25159836,"176":44.56510162,"175":48.3995018,"174":47.33560181,"173":45.22409821,"172":45.3404007,"171":45.42229843},"454":{"178":43.70320129,"177":44.06060028,"176":44.47019958,"175":48.31209946,"174":45.11360168,"173":45.3810997,"172":45.44260025,"171":45.53969955},"455":{"178":43.32870102,"177":43.55260086,"176":44.08620071,"175":44.59889984,"174":45.11429977,"173":45.34889984,"172":45.41080093,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.36769867,"177":43.57849884,"176":43.92910004,"175":44.40940094,"174":44.82339859,"173":44.97190094,"172":44.93059921,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.09730148,"174":44.34019852,"173":44.57239914,"172":44.97249985,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
dc02014e-4c8c-407b-8212-8dda16596778
As a city planner working on sustainability initiatives, I'm interested in understanding which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant change in minimum annual temperature between the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP4.5 scenarios.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1388/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.72919846,"210":41.28609848,"209":44.3370018,"208":41.58459854,"207":44.29560089,"206":44.54729843},"472":{"211":41.54029846,"210":41.00379944,"209":44.49940109,"208":44.28300095,"207":41.12900162,"206":41.59159851},"473":{"211":41.27629852,"210":40.95500183,"209":40.71080017,"208":40.57490158,"207":40.58349991,"206":40.08950043},"474":{"211":40.81949997,"210":40.72330093,"209":40.54330063,"208":40.19329834,"207":39.53540039,"206":39.19839859}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.12720108,"176":44.27349854,"175":44.48690033,"174":44.67229843,"173":44.7030983,"172":44.83779907,"171":44.98419952},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.17969894,"176":44.38159943,"175":44.54850006,"174":44.79759979,"173":44.99169922,"172":45.14839935,"171":45.25709915},"453":{"178":43.99150085,"177":44.25159836,"176":44.56510162,"175":48.3995018,"174":47.33560181,"173":45.22409821,"172":45.3404007,"171":45.42229843},"454":{"178":43.70320129,"177":44.06060028,"176":44.47019958,"175":48.31209946,"174":45.11360168,"173":45.3810997,"172":45.44260025,"171":45.53969955},"455":{"178":43.32870102,"177":43.55260086,"176":44.08620071,"175":44.59889984,"174":45.11429977,"173":45.34889984,"172":45.41080093,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.36769867,"177":43.57849884,"176":43.92910004,"175":44.40940094,"174":44.82339859,"173":44.97190094,"172":44.93059921,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.09730148,"174":44.34019852,"173":44.57239914,"172":44.97249985,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
ce6cf792-719a-4b94-811f-19b14345c1c7
As a city planner working on sustainability initiatives, I'm interested in understanding which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant change in minimum annual temperature between the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP4.5 scenarios.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1388/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.72919846,"210":41.28609848,"209":44.3370018,"208":41.58459854,"207":44.29560089,"206":44.54729843},"472":{"211":41.54029846,"210":41.00379944,"209":44.49940109,"208":44.28300095,"207":41.12900162,"206":41.59159851},"473":{"211":41.27629852,"210":40.95500183,"209":40.71080017,"208":40.57490158,"207":40.58349991,"206":40.08950043},"474":{"211":40.81949997,"210":40.72330093,"209":40.54330063,"208":40.19329834,"207":39.53540039,"206":39.19839859}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.12720108,"176":44.27349854,"175":44.48690033,"174":44.67229843,"173":44.7030983,"172":44.83779907,"171":44.98419952},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.17969894,"176":44.38159943,"175":44.54850006,"174":44.79759979,"173":44.99169922,"172":45.14839935,"171":45.25709915},"453":{"178":43.99150085,"177":44.25159836,"176":44.56510162,"175":48.3995018,"174":47.33560181,"173":45.22409821,"172":45.3404007,"171":45.42229843},"454":{"178":43.70320129,"177":44.06060028,"176":44.47019958,"175":48.31209946,"174":45.11360168,"173":45.3810997,"172":45.44260025,"171":45.53969955},"455":{"178":43.32870102,"177":43.55260086,"176":44.08620071,"175":44.59889984,"174":45.11429977,"173":45.34889984,"172":45.41080093,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.36769867,"177":43.57849884,"176":43.92910004,"175":44.40940094,"174":44.82339859,"173":44.97190094,"172":44.93059921,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.09730148,"174":44.34019852,"173":44.57239914,"172":44.97249985,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
7df83f74-c056-4ee6-978a-42c8059396c2
As a city planner working on sustainability initiatives, I'm interested in understanding which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has seen a more significant change in minimum annual temperature between the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP4.5 scenarios.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1388/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.72919846,"210":41.28609848,"209":44.3370018,"208":41.58459854,"207":44.29560089,"206":44.54729843},"472":{"211":41.54029846,"210":41.00379944,"209":44.49940109,"208":44.28300095,"207":41.12900162,"206":41.59159851},"473":{"211":41.27629852,"210":40.95500183,"209":40.71080017,"208":40.57490158,"207":40.58349991,"206":40.08950043},"474":{"211":40.81949997,"210":40.72330093,"209":40.54330063,"208":40.19329834,"207":39.53540039,"206":39.19839859}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.12720108,"176":44.27349854,"175":44.48690033,"174":44.67229843,"173":44.7030983,"172":44.83779907,"171":44.98419952},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.17969894,"176":44.38159943,"175":44.54850006,"174":44.79759979,"173":44.99169922,"172":45.14839935,"171":45.25709915},"453":{"178":43.99150085,"177":44.25159836,"176":44.56510162,"175":48.3995018,"174":47.33560181,"173":45.22409821,"172":45.3404007,"171":45.42229843},"454":{"178":43.70320129,"177":44.06060028,"176":44.47019958,"175":48.31209946,"174":45.11360168,"173":45.3810997,"172":45.44260025,"171":45.53969955},"455":{"178":43.32870102,"177":43.55260086,"176":44.08620071,"175":44.59889984,"174":45.11429977,"173":45.34889984,"172":45.41080093,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.36769867,"177":43.57849884,"176":43.92910004,"175":44.40940094,"174":44.82339859,"173":44.97190094,"172":44.93059921,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.09730148,"174":44.34019852,"173":44.57239914,"172":44.97249985,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
4e6e91a7-7878-48af-bb72-a8844de2cb71
As a meteorologist analyzing regional weather patterns during a conference on water resource management in Tennessee, I would like to know which city, Memphis or Nashville, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation between the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"411":{"125":null,"124":52.61270142,"123":51.98460007,"122":51.59019852,"121":51.95619965,"120":52.11410141,"119":52.24599838,"118":53.10570145,"117":54.17910004,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":52.49409866,"123":52.47320175,"122":52.78559875,"121":53.21569824,"120":53.15829849,"119":53.47629929,"118":54.44530106,"117":54.98040009,"116":55.07289886,"115":55.41220093},"413":{"125":null,"124":52.78310013,"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875,"116":55.6637001,"115":55.77539825},"414":{"125":null,"124":54.28609848,"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945,"116":56.29570007,"115":56.68939972},"415":{"125":54.13389969,"124":54.97869873,"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964,"116":57.00830078,"115":57.69760132},"416":{"125":54.01200104,"124":54.17910004,"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957,"116":58.12770081,"115":59.47930145},"417":{"125":54.64509964,"124":55.31259918,"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052,"116":58.8885994,"115":60.49779892},"418":{"125":55.09030151,"124":56.41999817,"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875,"116":59.03359985,"115":59.8288002},"419":{"125":55.12120056,"124":56.83349991,"123":56.59970093,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832,"116":59.45140076,"115":59.4117012},"420":{"125":55.12969971,"124":56.42710114,"123":56.62620163,"122":55.78239822,"121":55.41790009,"120":56.10020065,"119":56.35509872,"118":55.25159836,"117":56.33909988,"116":58.3390007,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":54.77149963,"120":56.34519958,"119":57.32659912,"118":55.1067009,"117":55.00299835,"116":58.47340012,"115":null}}
{"411":{"125":null,"124":47.75979996,"123":47.69599915,"122":46.90449905,"121":47.40750122,"120":47.58420181,"119":47.89479828,"118":49.26910019,"117":50.46300125,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":47.79000092,"123":47.86830139,"122":47.80680084,"121":47.78300095,"120":48.11500168,"119":49.10200119,"118":49.70740128,"117":50.08259964,"116":50.39649963,"115":50.2181015},"413":{"125":null,"124":47.54309845,"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985,"116":50.62939835,"115":50.56029892},"414":{"125":null,"124":48.41270065,"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083,"116":51.45080185,"115":51.70959854},"415":{"125":48.68230057,"124":48.89989853,"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985,"116":52.12070084,"115":53.13370132},"416":{"125":48.92490005,"124":48.67860031,"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913,"116":53.34120178,"115":54.57310104},"417":{"125":49.30270004,"124":49.40879822,"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101,"116":53.96120071,"115":55.44279861},"418":{"125":49.81299973,"124":50.33520126,"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897,"116":54.41939926,"115":54.85879898},"419":{"125":50.3207016,"124":51.3708992,"123":50.68600082,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093,"116":54.72669983,"115":54.69189835},"420":{"125":50.44789886,"124":51.03990173,"123":50.98310089,"122":50.37670135,"121":50.34280014,"120":51.05189896,"119":51.87509918,"118":51.41059875,"117":52.21680069,"116":54.01050186,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":49.32640076,"120":51.19279861,"119":52.58769989,"118":51.53290176,"117":51.34379959,"116":53.85549927,"115":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":52.80569839,"137":54.29470062,"136":54.2317009,"135":51.73830032,"134":50.0304985,"133":50.13439941,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":52.97040176,"137":54.85689926,"136":55.29959869,"135":54.23469925,"134":51.09970093,"133":49.56760025,"132":50.38439941,"131":52.99549866,"130":57.56140137},"434":{"139":51.02980042,"138":53.06269836,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":51.85910034,"130":56.66389847},"435":{"139":52.97869873,"138":54.22190094,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176,"130":55.28900146},"436":{"139":52.45740128,"138":53.62879944,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009,"130":54.51190186},"437":{"139":51.66260147,"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939,"130":55.51710129},"438":{"139":52.54729843,"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872,"130":55.9612999},"439":{"139":54.35169983,"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101,"130":56.62360001},"440":{"139":54.74549866,"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":57.40250015,"130":56.99060059},"441":{"139":54.63830185,"138":57.09000015,"137":65.60019684,"136":65.23539734,"135":58.88980103,"134":57.91690063,"133":62.90449905,"132":64.5719986,"131":60.23059845,"130":58.57929993},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":66.26210022,"135":59.03010178,"134":56.20840073,"133":60.44520187,"132":63.25870132,"131":58.8946991,"130":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":49.18569946,"137":50.31729889,"136":50.66490173,"135":49.15570068,"134":47.88610077,"133":47.47079849,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":49.39289856,"137":50.8893013,"136":51.74720001,"135":50.94340134,"134":48.54919815,"133":47.32109833,"132":47.61380005,"131":49.92679977,"130":54.26070023},"434":{"139":48.25370026,"138":50.04029846,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":48.80139923,"130":53.05899811},"435":{"139":50.13359833,"138":51.71440125,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038,"130":51.99240112},"436":{"139":50.2804985,"138":51.42449951,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046,"130":51.04140091},"437":{"139":49.58430099,"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011,"130":52.00249863},"438":{"139":49.49269867,"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098,"130":52.36220169},"439":{"139":50.5155983,"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002,"130":52.92089844},"440":{"139":50.95809937,"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":54.22740173,"130":53.82970047},"441":{"139":51.15890121,"138":53.23939896,"137":60.2655983,"136":60.1969986,"135":55.44269943,"134":54.36149979,"133":58.1189003,"132":59.81949997,"131":57.19630051,"130":55.67869949},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":60.24100113,"135":55.34230042,"134":53.27289963,"133":56.36619949,"132":59.58860016,"131":56.3844986,"130":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
9d309808-124d-42fb-a7c5-16ff5dbaf64d
As a meteorologist analyzing regional weather patterns during a conference on water resource management in Tennessee, I would like to know which city, Memphis or Nashville, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation between the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"411":{"125":null,"124":52.61270142,"123":51.98460007,"122":51.59019852,"121":51.95619965,"120":52.11410141,"119":52.24599838,"118":53.10570145,"117":54.17910004,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":52.49409866,"123":52.47320175,"122":52.78559875,"121":53.21569824,"120":53.15829849,"119":53.47629929,"118":54.44530106,"117":54.98040009,"116":55.07289886,"115":55.41220093},"413":{"125":null,"124":52.78310013,"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875,"116":55.6637001,"115":55.77539825},"414":{"125":null,"124":54.28609848,"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945,"116":56.29570007,"115":56.68939972},"415":{"125":54.13389969,"124":54.97869873,"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964,"116":57.00830078,"115":57.69760132},"416":{"125":54.01200104,"124":54.17910004,"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957,"116":58.12770081,"115":59.47930145},"417":{"125":54.64509964,"124":55.31259918,"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052,"116":58.8885994,"115":60.49779892},"418":{"125":55.09030151,"124":56.41999817,"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875,"116":59.03359985,"115":59.8288002},"419":{"125":55.12120056,"124":56.83349991,"123":56.59970093,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832,"116":59.45140076,"115":59.4117012},"420":{"125":55.12969971,"124":56.42710114,"123":56.62620163,"122":55.78239822,"121":55.41790009,"120":56.10020065,"119":56.35509872,"118":55.25159836,"117":56.33909988,"116":58.3390007,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":54.77149963,"120":56.34519958,"119":57.32659912,"118":55.1067009,"117":55.00299835,"116":58.47340012,"115":null}}
{"411":{"125":null,"124":47.75979996,"123":47.69599915,"122":46.90449905,"121":47.40750122,"120":47.58420181,"119":47.89479828,"118":49.26910019,"117":50.46300125,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":47.79000092,"123":47.86830139,"122":47.80680084,"121":47.78300095,"120":48.11500168,"119":49.10200119,"118":49.70740128,"117":50.08259964,"116":50.39649963,"115":50.2181015},"413":{"125":null,"124":47.54309845,"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985,"116":50.62939835,"115":50.56029892},"414":{"125":null,"124":48.41270065,"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083,"116":51.45080185,"115":51.70959854},"415":{"125":48.68230057,"124":48.89989853,"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985,"116":52.12070084,"115":53.13370132},"416":{"125":48.92490005,"124":48.67860031,"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913,"116":53.34120178,"115":54.57310104},"417":{"125":49.30270004,"124":49.40879822,"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101,"116":53.96120071,"115":55.44279861},"418":{"125":49.81299973,"124":50.33520126,"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897,"116":54.41939926,"115":54.85879898},"419":{"125":50.3207016,"124":51.3708992,"123":50.68600082,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093,"116":54.72669983,"115":54.69189835},"420":{"125":50.44789886,"124":51.03990173,"123":50.98310089,"122":50.37670135,"121":50.34280014,"120":51.05189896,"119":51.87509918,"118":51.41059875,"117":52.21680069,"116":54.01050186,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":49.32640076,"120":51.19279861,"119":52.58769989,"118":51.53290176,"117":51.34379959,"116":53.85549927,"115":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":52.80569839,"137":54.29470062,"136":54.2317009,"135":51.73830032,"134":50.0304985,"133":50.13439941,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":52.97040176,"137":54.85689926,"136":55.29959869,"135":54.23469925,"134":51.09970093,"133":49.56760025,"132":50.38439941,"131":52.99549866,"130":57.56140137},"434":{"139":51.02980042,"138":53.06269836,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":51.85910034,"130":56.66389847},"435":{"139":52.97869873,"138":54.22190094,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176,"130":55.28900146},"436":{"139":52.45740128,"138":53.62879944,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009,"130":54.51190186},"437":{"139":51.66260147,"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939,"130":55.51710129},"438":{"139":52.54729843,"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872,"130":55.9612999},"439":{"139":54.35169983,"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101,"130":56.62360001},"440":{"139":54.74549866,"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":57.40250015,"130":56.99060059},"441":{"139":54.63830185,"138":57.09000015,"137":65.60019684,"136":65.23539734,"135":58.88980103,"134":57.91690063,"133":62.90449905,"132":64.5719986,"131":60.23059845,"130":58.57929993},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":66.26210022,"135":59.03010178,"134":56.20840073,"133":60.44520187,"132":63.25870132,"131":58.8946991,"130":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":49.18569946,"137":50.31729889,"136":50.66490173,"135":49.15570068,"134":47.88610077,"133":47.47079849,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":49.39289856,"137":50.8893013,"136":51.74720001,"135":50.94340134,"134":48.54919815,"133":47.32109833,"132":47.61380005,"131":49.92679977,"130":54.26070023},"434":{"139":48.25370026,"138":50.04029846,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":48.80139923,"130":53.05899811},"435":{"139":50.13359833,"138":51.71440125,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038,"130":51.99240112},"436":{"139":50.2804985,"138":51.42449951,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046,"130":51.04140091},"437":{"139":49.58430099,"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011,"130":52.00249863},"438":{"139":49.49269867,"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098,"130":52.36220169},"439":{"139":50.5155983,"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002,"130":52.92089844},"440":{"139":50.95809937,"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":54.22740173,"130":53.82970047},"441":{"139":51.15890121,"138":53.23939896,"137":60.2655983,"136":60.1969986,"135":55.44269943,"134":54.36149979,"133":58.1189003,"132":59.81949997,"131":57.19630051,"130":55.67869949},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":60.24100113,"135":55.34230042,"134":53.27289963,"133":56.36619949,"132":59.58860016,"131":56.3844986,"130":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
d2dce8c5-7379-45d5-8c51-78ca52ccb470
As a meteorologist analyzing regional weather patterns during a conference on water resource management in Tennessee, I would like to know which city, Memphis or Nashville, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation between the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"411":{"125":null,"124":52.61270142,"123":51.98460007,"122":51.59019852,"121":51.95619965,"120":52.11410141,"119":52.24599838,"118":53.10570145,"117":54.17910004,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":52.49409866,"123":52.47320175,"122":52.78559875,"121":53.21569824,"120":53.15829849,"119":53.47629929,"118":54.44530106,"117":54.98040009,"116":55.07289886,"115":55.41220093},"413":{"125":null,"124":52.78310013,"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875,"116":55.6637001,"115":55.77539825},"414":{"125":null,"124":54.28609848,"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945,"116":56.29570007,"115":56.68939972},"415":{"125":54.13389969,"124":54.97869873,"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964,"116":57.00830078,"115":57.69760132},"416":{"125":54.01200104,"124":54.17910004,"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957,"116":58.12770081,"115":59.47930145},"417":{"125":54.64509964,"124":55.31259918,"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052,"116":58.8885994,"115":60.49779892},"418":{"125":55.09030151,"124":56.41999817,"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875,"116":59.03359985,"115":59.8288002},"419":{"125":55.12120056,"124":56.83349991,"123":56.59970093,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832,"116":59.45140076,"115":59.4117012},"420":{"125":55.12969971,"124":56.42710114,"123":56.62620163,"122":55.78239822,"121":55.41790009,"120":56.10020065,"119":56.35509872,"118":55.25159836,"117":56.33909988,"116":58.3390007,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":54.77149963,"120":56.34519958,"119":57.32659912,"118":55.1067009,"117":55.00299835,"116":58.47340012,"115":null}}
{"411":{"125":null,"124":47.75979996,"123":47.69599915,"122":46.90449905,"121":47.40750122,"120":47.58420181,"119":47.89479828,"118":49.26910019,"117":50.46300125,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":47.79000092,"123":47.86830139,"122":47.80680084,"121":47.78300095,"120":48.11500168,"119":49.10200119,"118":49.70740128,"117":50.08259964,"116":50.39649963,"115":50.2181015},"413":{"125":null,"124":47.54309845,"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985,"116":50.62939835,"115":50.56029892},"414":{"125":null,"124":48.41270065,"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083,"116":51.45080185,"115":51.70959854},"415":{"125":48.68230057,"124":48.89989853,"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985,"116":52.12070084,"115":53.13370132},"416":{"125":48.92490005,"124":48.67860031,"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913,"116":53.34120178,"115":54.57310104},"417":{"125":49.30270004,"124":49.40879822,"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101,"116":53.96120071,"115":55.44279861},"418":{"125":49.81299973,"124":50.33520126,"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897,"116":54.41939926,"115":54.85879898},"419":{"125":50.3207016,"124":51.3708992,"123":50.68600082,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093,"116":54.72669983,"115":54.69189835},"420":{"125":50.44789886,"124":51.03990173,"123":50.98310089,"122":50.37670135,"121":50.34280014,"120":51.05189896,"119":51.87509918,"118":51.41059875,"117":52.21680069,"116":54.01050186,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":49.32640076,"120":51.19279861,"119":52.58769989,"118":51.53290176,"117":51.34379959,"116":53.85549927,"115":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":52.80569839,"137":54.29470062,"136":54.2317009,"135":51.73830032,"134":50.0304985,"133":50.13439941,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":52.97040176,"137":54.85689926,"136":55.29959869,"135":54.23469925,"134":51.09970093,"133":49.56760025,"132":50.38439941,"131":52.99549866,"130":57.56140137},"434":{"139":51.02980042,"138":53.06269836,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":51.85910034,"130":56.66389847},"435":{"139":52.97869873,"138":54.22190094,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176,"130":55.28900146},"436":{"139":52.45740128,"138":53.62879944,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009,"130":54.51190186},"437":{"139":51.66260147,"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939,"130":55.51710129},"438":{"139":52.54729843,"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872,"130":55.9612999},"439":{"139":54.35169983,"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101,"130":56.62360001},"440":{"139":54.74549866,"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":57.40250015,"130":56.99060059},"441":{"139":54.63830185,"138":57.09000015,"137":65.60019684,"136":65.23539734,"135":58.88980103,"134":57.91690063,"133":62.90449905,"132":64.5719986,"131":60.23059845,"130":58.57929993},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":66.26210022,"135":59.03010178,"134":56.20840073,"133":60.44520187,"132":63.25870132,"131":58.8946991,"130":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":49.18569946,"137":50.31729889,"136":50.66490173,"135":49.15570068,"134":47.88610077,"133":47.47079849,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":49.39289856,"137":50.8893013,"136":51.74720001,"135":50.94340134,"134":48.54919815,"133":47.32109833,"132":47.61380005,"131":49.92679977,"130":54.26070023},"434":{"139":48.25370026,"138":50.04029846,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":48.80139923,"130":53.05899811},"435":{"139":50.13359833,"138":51.71440125,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038,"130":51.99240112},"436":{"139":50.2804985,"138":51.42449951,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046,"130":51.04140091},"437":{"139":49.58430099,"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011,"130":52.00249863},"438":{"139":49.49269867,"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098,"130":52.36220169},"439":{"139":50.5155983,"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002,"130":52.92089844},"440":{"139":50.95809937,"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":54.22740173,"130":53.82970047},"441":{"139":51.15890121,"138":53.23939896,"137":60.2655983,"136":60.1969986,"135":55.44269943,"134":54.36149979,"133":58.1189003,"132":59.81949997,"131":57.19630051,"130":55.67869949},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":60.24100113,"135":55.34230042,"134":53.27289963,"133":56.36619949,"132":59.58860016,"131":56.3844986,"130":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
65cbe259-b397-4a3f-bffa-6e11f245b8b3
As a meteorologist analyzing regional weather patterns during a conference on water resource management in Tennessee, I would like to know which city, Memphis or Nashville, experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation between the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"411":{"125":null,"124":52.61270142,"123":51.98460007,"122":51.59019852,"121":51.95619965,"120":52.11410141,"119":52.24599838,"118":53.10570145,"117":54.17910004,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":52.49409866,"123":52.47320175,"122":52.78559875,"121":53.21569824,"120":53.15829849,"119":53.47629929,"118":54.44530106,"117":54.98040009,"116":55.07289886,"115":55.41220093},"413":{"125":null,"124":52.78310013,"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875,"116":55.6637001,"115":55.77539825},"414":{"125":null,"124":54.28609848,"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945,"116":56.29570007,"115":56.68939972},"415":{"125":54.13389969,"124":54.97869873,"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964,"116":57.00830078,"115":57.69760132},"416":{"125":54.01200104,"124":54.17910004,"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957,"116":58.12770081,"115":59.47930145},"417":{"125":54.64509964,"124":55.31259918,"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052,"116":58.8885994,"115":60.49779892},"418":{"125":55.09030151,"124":56.41999817,"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875,"116":59.03359985,"115":59.8288002},"419":{"125":55.12120056,"124":56.83349991,"123":56.59970093,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832,"116":59.45140076,"115":59.4117012},"420":{"125":55.12969971,"124":56.42710114,"123":56.62620163,"122":55.78239822,"121":55.41790009,"120":56.10020065,"119":56.35509872,"118":55.25159836,"117":56.33909988,"116":58.3390007,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":54.77149963,"120":56.34519958,"119":57.32659912,"118":55.1067009,"117":55.00299835,"116":58.47340012,"115":null}}
{"411":{"125":null,"124":47.75979996,"123":47.69599915,"122":46.90449905,"121":47.40750122,"120":47.58420181,"119":47.89479828,"118":49.26910019,"117":50.46300125,"116":null,"115":null},"412":{"125":null,"124":47.79000092,"123":47.86830139,"122":47.80680084,"121":47.78300095,"120":48.11500168,"119":49.10200119,"118":49.70740128,"117":50.08259964,"116":50.39649963,"115":50.2181015},"413":{"125":null,"124":47.54309845,"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985,"116":50.62939835,"115":50.56029892},"414":{"125":null,"124":48.41270065,"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083,"116":51.45080185,"115":51.70959854},"415":{"125":48.68230057,"124":48.89989853,"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985,"116":52.12070084,"115":53.13370132},"416":{"125":48.92490005,"124":48.67860031,"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913,"116":53.34120178,"115":54.57310104},"417":{"125":49.30270004,"124":49.40879822,"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101,"116":53.96120071,"115":55.44279861},"418":{"125":49.81299973,"124":50.33520126,"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897,"116":54.41939926,"115":54.85879898},"419":{"125":50.3207016,"124":51.3708992,"123":50.68600082,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093,"116":54.72669983,"115":54.69189835},"420":{"125":50.44789886,"124":51.03990173,"123":50.98310089,"122":50.37670135,"121":50.34280014,"120":51.05189896,"119":51.87509918,"118":51.41059875,"117":52.21680069,"116":54.01050186,"115":null},"421":{"125":null,"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":49.32640076,"120":51.19279861,"119":52.58769989,"118":51.53290176,"117":51.34379959,"116":53.85549927,"115":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":52.80569839,"137":54.29470062,"136":54.2317009,"135":51.73830032,"134":50.0304985,"133":50.13439941,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":52.97040176,"137":54.85689926,"136":55.29959869,"135":54.23469925,"134":51.09970093,"133":49.56760025,"132":50.38439941,"131":52.99549866,"130":57.56140137},"434":{"139":51.02980042,"138":53.06269836,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":51.85910034,"130":56.66389847},"435":{"139":52.97869873,"138":54.22190094,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176,"130":55.28900146},"436":{"139":52.45740128,"138":53.62879944,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009,"130":54.51190186},"437":{"139":51.66260147,"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939,"130":55.51710129},"438":{"139":52.54729843,"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872,"130":55.9612999},"439":{"139":54.35169983,"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101,"130":56.62360001},"440":{"139":54.74549866,"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":57.40250015,"130":56.99060059},"441":{"139":54.63830185,"138":57.09000015,"137":65.60019684,"136":65.23539734,"135":58.88980103,"134":57.91690063,"133":62.90449905,"132":64.5719986,"131":60.23059845,"130":58.57929993},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":66.26210022,"135":59.03010178,"134":56.20840073,"133":60.44520187,"132":63.25870132,"131":58.8946991,"130":null}}
{"432":{"139":null,"138":49.18569946,"137":50.31729889,"136":50.66490173,"135":49.15570068,"134":47.88610077,"133":47.47079849,"132":null,"131":null,"130":null},"433":{"139":null,"138":49.39289856,"137":50.8893013,"136":51.74720001,"135":50.94340134,"134":48.54919815,"133":47.32109833,"132":47.61380005,"131":49.92679977,"130":54.26070023},"434":{"139":48.25370026,"138":50.04029846,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":48.80139923,"130":53.05899811},"435":{"139":50.13359833,"138":51.71440125,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038,"130":51.99240112},"436":{"139":50.2804985,"138":51.42449951,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046,"130":51.04140091},"437":{"139":49.58430099,"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011,"130":52.00249863},"438":{"139":49.49269867,"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098,"130":52.36220169},"439":{"139":50.5155983,"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002,"130":52.92089844},"440":{"139":50.95809937,"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":54.22740173,"130":53.82970047},"441":{"139":51.15890121,"138":53.23939896,"137":60.2655983,"136":60.1969986,"135":55.44269943,"134":54.36149979,"133":58.1189003,"132":59.81949997,"131":57.19630051,"130":55.67869949},"442":{"139":null,"138":null,"137":null,"136":60.24100113,"135":55.34230042,"134":53.27289963,"133":56.36619949,"132":59.58860016,"131":56.3844986,"130":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
b4bf5a69-951a-45b9-8976-a3787f8593a0
As a climate scientist analyzing temperature trends for a report, which city, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, showed a more significant variation in minimum seasonal temperatures during the winter in the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the winter in the mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
tabular
null
72
(d)
['(a) The Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"325":{"217":26.11610031,"216":25.97459984,"215":25.66419983,"214":25.8029995,"213":26.17560005,"212":26.47249985,"211":27.15769958,"210":27.29490089,"209":27.02440071},"326":{"217":25.74740028,"216":25.82690048,"215":25.91480064,"214":26.03899956,"213":26.34449959,"212":26.63929939,"211":26.94479942,"210":27.38150024,"209":27.33729935},"327":{"217":25.51499939,"216":25.67180061,"215":25.97960091,"214":26.24270058,"213":26.5904007,"212":26.86849976,"211":26.80080032,"210":27.04190063,"209":27.67749977},"328":{"217":25.26269913,"216":25.14719963,"215":25.34679985,"214":25.80439949,"213":26.5734005,"212":26.94860077,"211":26.94440079,"210":26.82769966,"209":27.5284996},"329":{"217":24.97200012,"216":24.83889961,"215":24.89139938,"214":25.23460007,"213":26.04319954,"212":26.97450066,"211":26.7602005,"210":26.92980003,"209":27.72900009},"330":{"217":24.67510033,"216":24.68799973,"215":24.8192997,"214":25.3560009,"213":26.19079971,"212":26.63570023,"211":26.81010056,"210":26.91990089,"209":27.14299965},"331":{"217":24.4368,"216":24.64620018,"215":24.87479973,"214":25.3416996,"213":25.6779995,"212":26.65200043,"211":26.59410095,"210":26.42090034,"209":26.71150017},"332":{"217":24.29980087,"216":24.64769936,"215":24.82819939,"214":25.11070061,"213":25.63570023,"212":26.01510048,"211":26.33699989,"210":25.5923996,"209":25.82169914},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":24.97559929,"214":25.14850044,"213":25.54059982,"212":25.9810009,"211":26.05960083,"210":25.53919983,"209":25.46030045}}
{"325":{"217":20.07439995,"216":19.90029907,"215":19.62660027,"214":19.80120087,"213":20.22750092,"212":20.53470039,"211":21.3451004,"210":21.41290092,"209":21.14669991},"326":{"217":19.58320045,"216":19.70140076,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979,"209":21.44639969},"327":{"217":19.27109909,"216":19.49239922,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977,"209":21.83720016},"328":{"217":18.93589973,"216":18.83620071,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998,"209":21.58620071},"329":{"217":18.55249977,"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906,"209":21.68219948},"330":{"217":18.22089958,"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978,"209":20.94960022},"331":{"217":17.93059921,"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033,"209":20.46680069},"332":{"217":17.74620056,"216":18.11039925,"215":18.2840004,"214":18.58539963,"213":19.1590004,"212":19.60429955,"211":19.88349915,"210":19.15049934,"209":19.46479988},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":18.38890076,"214":18.57119942,"213":19.01619911,"212":19.51740074,"211":19.63260078,"210":19.13669968,"209":19.06500053}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":30.1026001,"218":30.27589989,"217":30.27709961,"216":29.95420074,"215":30.20319939,"214":30.52759933,"213":30.70499992,"212":null},"485":{"220":29.9878006,"219":29.95800018,"218":29.82500076,"217":29.67550087,"216":29.88619995,"215":30.11120033,"214":30.26269913,"213":30.28619957,"212":30.23010063},"486":{"220":29.38220024,"219":29.16570091,"218":29.24340057,"217":29.66519928,"216":30.16650009,"215":29.6359005,"214":29.31389999,"213":28.8166008,"212":29.13710022},"487":{"220":28.18530083,"219":28.89119911,"218":29.21109962,"217":29.78569984,"216":29.82480049,"215":29.16379929,"214":28.25119972,"213":27.64690018,"212":28.25329971},"488":{"220":27.41069984,"219":28.6012001,"218":29.33130074,"217":29.8635006,"216":30.8654995,"215":28.65629959,"214":27.4090004,"213":26.99029922,"212":27.5007},"489":{"220":26.83740044,"219":28.67919922,"218":29.75239944,"217":29.60070038,"216":28.94619942,"215":27.73889923,"214":26.92270088,"213":26.83049965,"212":27.10860062},"490":{"220":26.66609955,"219":28.91060066,"218":29.81069946,"217":28.94879913,"216":27.58340073,"215":26.71299934,"214":26.55439949,"213":26.72789955,"212":27.08259964},"491":{"220":27.16869926,"219":28.70009995,"218":29.09090042,"217":28.45549965,"216":27.16130066,"215":26.39909935,"214":26.26300049,"213":26.57670021,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":28.53089905,"217":27.7220993,"216":27.00200081,"215":26.7147007,"214":26.50769997,"213":26.6909008,"212":null}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":22.73620033,"218":23.36669922,"217":23.39940071,"216":23.16180038,"215":23.52860069,"214":23.98990059,"213":24.33300018,"212":null},"485":{"220":22.53790092,"219":22.94809914,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":23.77059937,"212":23.82889938},"486":{"220":22.36750031,"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977,"212":22.6718998},"487":{"220":21.21369934,"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056,"212":21.91300011},"488":{"220":20.47310066,"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917,"212":21.15519905},"489":{"220":19.86720085,"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035,"212":20.80960083},"490":{"220":19.7159996,"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":20.43759918,"212":20.82900047},"491":{"220":20.2887001,"219":21.8946991,"218":22.34390068,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":20.33130074,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":21.81999969,"217":21.12319946,"216":20.53860092,"215":20.33390045,"214":20.21940041,"213":20.44809914,"212":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout winter in end-century period (RCP8.5) and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
8460e9ec-31b7-4aa1-834d-8ba7fb63f9e7
As a climate scientist analyzing temperature trends for a report, which city, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, showed a more significant variation in minimum seasonal temperatures during the winter in the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the winter in the mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1280/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"325":{"217":26.11610031,"216":25.97459984,"215":25.66419983,"214":25.8029995,"213":26.17560005,"212":26.47249985,"211":27.15769958,"210":27.29490089,"209":27.02440071},"326":{"217":25.74740028,"216":25.82690048,"215":25.91480064,"214":26.03899956,"213":26.34449959,"212":26.63929939,"211":26.94479942,"210":27.38150024,"209":27.33729935},"327":{"217":25.51499939,"216":25.67180061,"215":25.97960091,"214":26.24270058,"213":26.5904007,"212":26.86849976,"211":26.80080032,"210":27.04190063,"209":27.67749977},"328":{"217":25.26269913,"216":25.14719963,"215":25.34679985,"214":25.80439949,"213":26.5734005,"212":26.94860077,"211":26.94440079,"210":26.82769966,"209":27.5284996},"329":{"217":24.97200012,"216":24.83889961,"215":24.89139938,"214":25.23460007,"213":26.04319954,"212":26.97450066,"211":26.7602005,"210":26.92980003,"209":27.72900009},"330":{"217":24.67510033,"216":24.68799973,"215":24.8192997,"214":25.3560009,"213":26.19079971,"212":26.63570023,"211":26.81010056,"210":26.91990089,"209":27.14299965},"331":{"217":24.4368,"216":24.64620018,"215":24.87479973,"214":25.3416996,"213":25.6779995,"212":26.65200043,"211":26.59410095,"210":26.42090034,"209":26.71150017},"332":{"217":24.29980087,"216":24.64769936,"215":24.82819939,"214":25.11070061,"213":25.63570023,"212":26.01510048,"211":26.33699989,"210":25.5923996,"209":25.82169914},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":24.97559929,"214":25.14850044,"213":25.54059982,"212":25.9810009,"211":26.05960083,"210":25.53919983,"209":25.46030045}}
{"325":{"217":20.07439995,"216":19.90029907,"215":19.62660027,"214":19.80120087,"213":20.22750092,"212":20.53470039,"211":21.3451004,"210":21.41290092,"209":21.14669991},"326":{"217":19.58320045,"216":19.70140076,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979,"209":21.44639969},"327":{"217":19.27109909,"216":19.49239922,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977,"209":21.83720016},"328":{"217":18.93589973,"216":18.83620071,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998,"209":21.58620071},"329":{"217":18.55249977,"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906,"209":21.68219948},"330":{"217":18.22089958,"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978,"209":20.94960022},"331":{"217":17.93059921,"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033,"209":20.46680069},"332":{"217":17.74620056,"216":18.11039925,"215":18.2840004,"214":18.58539963,"213":19.1590004,"212":19.60429955,"211":19.88349915,"210":19.15049934,"209":19.46479988},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":18.38890076,"214":18.57119942,"213":19.01619911,"212":19.51740074,"211":19.63260078,"210":19.13669968,"209":19.06500053}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":30.1026001,"218":30.27589989,"217":30.27709961,"216":29.95420074,"215":30.20319939,"214":30.52759933,"213":30.70499992,"212":null},"485":{"220":29.9878006,"219":29.95800018,"218":29.82500076,"217":29.67550087,"216":29.88619995,"215":30.11120033,"214":30.26269913,"213":30.28619957,"212":30.23010063},"486":{"220":29.38220024,"219":29.16570091,"218":29.24340057,"217":29.66519928,"216":30.16650009,"215":29.6359005,"214":29.31389999,"213":28.8166008,"212":29.13710022},"487":{"220":28.18530083,"219":28.89119911,"218":29.21109962,"217":29.78569984,"216":29.82480049,"215":29.16379929,"214":28.25119972,"213":27.64690018,"212":28.25329971},"488":{"220":27.41069984,"219":28.6012001,"218":29.33130074,"217":29.8635006,"216":30.8654995,"215":28.65629959,"214":27.4090004,"213":26.99029922,"212":27.5007},"489":{"220":26.83740044,"219":28.67919922,"218":29.75239944,"217":29.60070038,"216":28.94619942,"215":27.73889923,"214":26.92270088,"213":26.83049965,"212":27.10860062},"490":{"220":26.66609955,"219":28.91060066,"218":29.81069946,"217":28.94879913,"216":27.58340073,"215":26.71299934,"214":26.55439949,"213":26.72789955,"212":27.08259964},"491":{"220":27.16869926,"219":28.70009995,"218":29.09090042,"217":28.45549965,"216":27.16130066,"215":26.39909935,"214":26.26300049,"213":26.57670021,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":28.53089905,"217":27.7220993,"216":27.00200081,"215":26.7147007,"214":26.50769997,"213":26.6909008,"212":null}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":22.73620033,"218":23.36669922,"217":23.39940071,"216":23.16180038,"215":23.52860069,"214":23.98990059,"213":24.33300018,"212":null},"485":{"220":22.53790092,"219":22.94809914,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":23.77059937,"212":23.82889938},"486":{"220":22.36750031,"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977,"212":22.6718998},"487":{"220":21.21369934,"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056,"212":21.91300011},"488":{"220":20.47310066,"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917,"212":21.15519905},"489":{"220":19.86720085,"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035,"212":20.80960083},"490":{"220":19.7159996,"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":20.43759918,"212":20.82900047},"491":{"220":20.2887001,"219":21.8946991,"218":22.34390068,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":20.33130074,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":21.81999969,"217":21.12319946,"216":20.53860092,"215":20.33390045,"214":20.21940041,"213":20.44809914,"212":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout winter in end-century period (RCP8.5) and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
366702a0-010e-4a05-9719-f7087fb548c0
As a climate scientist analyzing temperature trends for a report, which city, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, showed a more significant variation in minimum seasonal temperatures during the winter in the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the winter in the mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1280/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"325":{"217":26.11610031,"216":25.97459984,"215":25.66419983,"214":25.8029995,"213":26.17560005,"212":26.47249985,"211":27.15769958,"210":27.29490089,"209":27.02440071},"326":{"217":25.74740028,"216":25.82690048,"215":25.91480064,"214":26.03899956,"213":26.34449959,"212":26.63929939,"211":26.94479942,"210":27.38150024,"209":27.33729935},"327":{"217":25.51499939,"216":25.67180061,"215":25.97960091,"214":26.24270058,"213":26.5904007,"212":26.86849976,"211":26.80080032,"210":27.04190063,"209":27.67749977},"328":{"217":25.26269913,"216":25.14719963,"215":25.34679985,"214":25.80439949,"213":26.5734005,"212":26.94860077,"211":26.94440079,"210":26.82769966,"209":27.5284996},"329":{"217":24.97200012,"216":24.83889961,"215":24.89139938,"214":25.23460007,"213":26.04319954,"212":26.97450066,"211":26.7602005,"210":26.92980003,"209":27.72900009},"330":{"217":24.67510033,"216":24.68799973,"215":24.8192997,"214":25.3560009,"213":26.19079971,"212":26.63570023,"211":26.81010056,"210":26.91990089,"209":27.14299965},"331":{"217":24.4368,"216":24.64620018,"215":24.87479973,"214":25.3416996,"213":25.6779995,"212":26.65200043,"211":26.59410095,"210":26.42090034,"209":26.71150017},"332":{"217":24.29980087,"216":24.64769936,"215":24.82819939,"214":25.11070061,"213":25.63570023,"212":26.01510048,"211":26.33699989,"210":25.5923996,"209":25.82169914},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":24.97559929,"214":25.14850044,"213":25.54059982,"212":25.9810009,"211":26.05960083,"210":25.53919983,"209":25.46030045}}
{"325":{"217":20.07439995,"216":19.90029907,"215":19.62660027,"214":19.80120087,"213":20.22750092,"212":20.53470039,"211":21.3451004,"210":21.41290092,"209":21.14669991},"326":{"217":19.58320045,"216":19.70140076,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979,"209":21.44639969},"327":{"217":19.27109909,"216":19.49239922,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977,"209":21.83720016},"328":{"217":18.93589973,"216":18.83620071,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998,"209":21.58620071},"329":{"217":18.55249977,"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906,"209":21.68219948},"330":{"217":18.22089958,"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978,"209":20.94960022},"331":{"217":17.93059921,"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033,"209":20.46680069},"332":{"217":17.74620056,"216":18.11039925,"215":18.2840004,"214":18.58539963,"213":19.1590004,"212":19.60429955,"211":19.88349915,"210":19.15049934,"209":19.46479988},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":18.38890076,"214":18.57119942,"213":19.01619911,"212":19.51740074,"211":19.63260078,"210":19.13669968,"209":19.06500053}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":30.1026001,"218":30.27589989,"217":30.27709961,"216":29.95420074,"215":30.20319939,"214":30.52759933,"213":30.70499992,"212":null},"485":{"220":29.9878006,"219":29.95800018,"218":29.82500076,"217":29.67550087,"216":29.88619995,"215":30.11120033,"214":30.26269913,"213":30.28619957,"212":30.23010063},"486":{"220":29.38220024,"219":29.16570091,"218":29.24340057,"217":29.66519928,"216":30.16650009,"215":29.6359005,"214":29.31389999,"213":28.8166008,"212":29.13710022},"487":{"220":28.18530083,"219":28.89119911,"218":29.21109962,"217":29.78569984,"216":29.82480049,"215":29.16379929,"214":28.25119972,"213":27.64690018,"212":28.25329971},"488":{"220":27.41069984,"219":28.6012001,"218":29.33130074,"217":29.8635006,"216":30.8654995,"215":28.65629959,"214":27.4090004,"213":26.99029922,"212":27.5007},"489":{"220":26.83740044,"219":28.67919922,"218":29.75239944,"217":29.60070038,"216":28.94619942,"215":27.73889923,"214":26.92270088,"213":26.83049965,"212":27.10860062},"490":{"220":26.66609955,"219":28.91060066,"218":29.81069946,"217":28.94879913,"216":27.58340073,"215":26.71299934,"214":26.55439949,"213":26.72789955,"212":27.08259964},"491":{"220":27.16869926,"219":28.70009995,"218":29.09090042,"217":28.45549965,"216":27.16130066,"215":26.39909935,"214":26.26300049,"213":26.57670021,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":28.53089905,"217":27.7220993,"216":27.00200081,"215":26.7147007,"214":26.50769997,"213":26.6909008,"212":null}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":22.73620033,"218":23.36669922,"217":23.39940071,"216":23.16180038,"215":23.52860069,"214":23.98990059,"213":24.33300018,"212":null},"485":{"220":22.53790092,"219":22.94809914,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":23.77059937,"212":23.82889938},"486":{"220":22.36750031,"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977,"212":22.6718998},"487":{"220":21.21369934,"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056,"212":21.91300011},"488":{"220":20.47310066,"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917,"212":21.15519905},"489":{"220":19.86720085,"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035,"212":20.80960083},"490":{"220":19.7159996,"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":20.43759918,"212":20.82900047},"491":{"220":20.2887001,"219":21.8946991,"218":22.34390068,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":20.33130074,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":21.81999969,"217":21.12319946,"216":20.53860092,"215":20.33390045,"214":20.21940041,"213":20.44809914,"212":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout winter in end-century period (RCP8.5) and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
6318ec72-23a9-454d-8e0f-1f444936c7bc
As a climate scientist analyzing temperature trends for a report, which city, Bismarck, ND, or Syracuse, NY, showed a more significant variation in minimum seasonal temperatures during the winter in the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the winter in the mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1280/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) The Bismarck, ND, United States experienced a greater change than Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Bismarck, ND, United States and Syracuse, NY, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Bismarck, ND, United States.']
['Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Bismarck, ND, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Syracuse, NY, United States in winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"325":{"217":26.11610031,"216":25.97459984,"215":25.66419983,"214":25.8029995,"213":26.17560005,"212":26.47249985,"211":27.15769958,"210":27.29490089,"209":27.02440071},"326":{"217":25.74740028,"216":25.82690048,"215":25.91480064,"214":26.03899956,"213":26.34449959,"212":26.63929939,"211":26.94479942,"210":27.38150024,"209":27.33729935},"327":{"217":25.51499939,"216":25.67180061,"215":25.97960091,"214":26.24270058,"213":26.5904007,"212":26.86849976,"211":26.80080032,"210":27.04190063,"209":27.67749977},"328":{"217":25.26269913,"216":25.14719963,"215":25.34679985,"214":25.80439949,"213":26.5734005,"212":26.94860077,"211":26.94440079,"210":26.82769966,"209":27.5284996},"329":{"217":24.97200012,"216":24.83889961,"215":24.89139938,"214":25.23460007,"213":26.04319954,"212":26.97450066,"211":26.7602005,"210":26.92980003,"209":27.72900009},"330":{"217":24.67510033,"216":24.68799973,"215":24.8192997,"214":25.3560009,"213":26.19079971,"212":26.63570023,"211":26.81010056,"210":26.91990089,"209":27.14299965},"331":{"217":24.4368,"216":24.64620018,"215":24.87479973,"214":25.3416996,"213":25.6779995,"212":26.65200043,"211":26.59410095,"210":26.42090034,"209":26.71150017},"332":{"217":24.29980087,"216":24.64769936,"215":24.82819939,"214":25.11070061,"213":25.63570023,"212":26.01510048,"211":26.33699989,"210":25.5923996,"209":25.82169914},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":24.97559929,"214":25.14850044,"213":25.54059982,"212":25.9810009,"211":26.05960083,"210":25.53919983,"209":25.46030045}}
{"325":{"217":20.07439995,"216":19.90029907,"215":19.62660027,"214":19.80120087,"213":20.22750092,"212":20.53470039,"211":21.3451004,"210":21.41290092,"209":21.14669991},"326":{"217":19.58320045,"216":19.70140076,"215":19.79980087,"214":19.97979927,"213":20.32439995,"212":20.64909935,"211":21.03269958,"210":21.54759979,"209":21.44639969},"327":{"217":19.27109909,"216":19.49239922,"215":19.80450058,"214":20.10910034,"213":20.47949982,"212":20.81110001,"211":20.73530006,"210":21.11639977,"209":21.83720016},"328":{"217":18.93589973,"216":18.83620071,"215":19.07589912,"214":19.56279945,"213":20.37540054,"212":20.80170059,"211":20.88100052,"210":20.7954998,"209":21.58620071},"329":{"217":18.55249977,"216":18.44820023,"215":18.52610016,"214":18.9008007,"213":19.73489952,"212":20.75180054,"211":20.51059914,"210":20.77809906,"209":21.68219948},"330":{"217":18.22089958,"216":18.24740028,"215":18.39069939,"214":18.95490074,"213":19.82869911,"212":20.29940033,"211":20.51309967,"210":20.67469978,"209":20.94960022},"331":{"217":17.93059921,"216":18.16340065,"215":18.37590027,"214":18.8791008,"213":19.21879959,"212":20.24309921,"211":20.15699959,"210":20.11260033,"209":20.46680069},"332":{"217":17.74620056,"216":18.11039925,"215":18.2840004,"214":18.58539963,"213":19.1590004,"212":19.60429955,"211":19.88349915,"210":19.15049934,"209":19.46479988},"333":{"217":null,"216":null,"215":18.38890076,"214":18.57119942,"213":19.01619911,"212":19.51740074,"211":19.63260078,"210":19.13669968,"209":19.06500053}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":30.1026001,"218":30.27589989,"217":30.27709961,"216":29.95420074,"215":30.20319939,"214":30.52759933,"213":30.70499992,"212":null},"485":{"220":29.9878006,"219":29.95800018,"218":29.82500076,"217":29.67550087,"216":29.88619995,"215":30.11120033,"214":30.26269913,"213":30.28619957,"212":30.23010063},"486":{"220":29.38220024,"219":29.16570091,"218":29.24340057,"217":29.66519928,"216":30.16650009,"215":29.6359005,"214":29.31389999,"213":28.8166008,"212":29.13710022},"487":{"220":28.18530083,"219":28.89119911,"218":29.21109962,"217":29.78569984,"216":29.82480049,"215":29.16379929,"214":28.25119972,"213":27.64690018,"212":28.25329971},"488":{"220":27.41069984,"219":28.6012001,"218":29.33130074,"217":29.8635006,"216":30.8654995,"215":28.65629959,"214":27.4090004,"213":26.99029922,"212":27.5007},"489":{"220":26.83740044,"219":28.67919922,"218":29.75239944,"217":29.60070038,"216":28.94619942,"215":27.73889923,"214":26.92270088,"213":26.83049965,"212":27.10860062},"490":{"220":26.66609955,"219":28.91060066,"218":29.81069946,"217":28.94879913,"216":27.58340073,"215":26.71299934,"214":26.55439949,"213":26.72789955,"212":27.08259964},"491":{"220":27.16869926,"219":28.70009995,"218":29.09090042,"217":28.45549965,"216":27.16130066,"215":26.39909935,"214":26.26300049,"213":26.57670021,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":28.53089905,"217":27.7220993,"216":27.00200081,"215":26.7147007,"214":26.50769997,"213":26.6909008,"212":null}}
{"484":{"220":null,"219":22.73620033,"218":23.36669922,"217":23.39940071,"216":23.16180038,"215":23.52860069,"214":23.98990059,"213":24.33300018,"212":null},"485":{"220":22.53790092,"219":22.94809914,"218":22.90730095,"217":22.76490021,"216":23.10860062,"215":23.44099998,"214":23.71890068,"213":23.77059937,"212":23.82889938},"486":{"220":22.36750031,"219":22.13360023,"218":22.31310081,"217":22.79680061,"216":23.44910049,"215":23.00620079,"214":22.78919983,"213":22.24139977,"212":22.6718998},"487":{"220":21.21369934,"219":21.95569992,"218":22.30970001,"217":22.96109962,"216":23.12929916,"215":22.59950066,"214":21.77400017,"213":21.24760056,"212":21.91300011},"488":{"220":20.47310066,"219":21.71710014,"218":22.52000046,"217":23.12610054,"216":24.09269905,"215":22.15200043,"214":20.99069977,"213":20.62719917,"212":21.15519905},"489":{"220":19.86720085,"219":21.8064003,"218":22.65180016,"217":22.87960052,"216":22.38430023,"215":21.26210022,"214":20.54059982,"213":20.48130035,"212":20.80960083},"490":{"220":19.7159996,"219":22.11949921,"218":23.09950066,"217":22.26580048,"216":21.0326004,"215":20.2595005,"214":20.19050026,"213":20.43759918,"212":20.82900047},"491":{"220":20.2887001,"219":21.8946991,"218":22.34390068,"217":21.79680061,"216":20.66580009,"215":19.97450066,"214":19.93659973,"213":20.33130074,"212":null},"492":{"220":null,"219":null,"218":21.81999969,"217":21.12319946,"216":20.53860092,"215":20.33390045,"214":20.21940041,"213":20.44809914,"212":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum seasonal temperature", "location1": "Bismarck, ND, United States", "location2": "Syracuse, NY, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bismarck, ND, United States or Syracuse, NY, United States experienced a greater change in minimum seasonal temperature throughout winter in end-century period (RCP8.5) and winter in mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
59fd0579-fd86-4187-b872-32ad33b2bbcf
As a wildfire management officer evaluating historical data to optimize resource allocation, I'm interested in which city between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index trends during autumn from the historical period to the end-century projection.
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "autumn in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and autumn in historical period?
8094e5c0-d2b9-402e-b21f-126e8efac783
As a wildfire management officer evaluating historical data to optimize resource allocation, I'm interested in which city between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index trends during autumn from the historical period to the end-century projection.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1235/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "autumn in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and autumn in historical period?
7433cb39-24db-40c6-8df7-3b511b24b357
As a wildfire management officer evaluating historical data to optimize resource allocation, I'm interested in which city between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index trends during autumn from the historical period to the end-century projection.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1235/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "autumn in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and autumn in historical period?
eef7f209-1ce8-491e-ab9e-032098e198ab
As a wildfire management officer evaluating historical data to optimize resource allocation, I'm interested in which city between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index trends during autumn from the historical period to the end-century projection.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1235/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period']
{"301":{"165":24.78170013,"164":22.18230057,"163":21.5359993,"162":22.00569916,"161":22.92589951,"160":25.27039909,"159":19.07979965,"158":18.82769966,"157":22.09199905,"156":14.05230045},"302":{"165":26.55660057,"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":23.06699944,"158":23.25860023,"157":23.70569992,"156":15.86600018},"303":{"165":28.97949982,"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937,"157":24.82329941,"156":22.0510006},"304":{"165":31.18930054,"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045,"157":25.61230087,"156":24.57259941},"305":{"165":31.84679985,"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086,"157":26.12789917,"156":25.69610023},"306":{"165":30.15979958,"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042,"157":26.94829941,"156":26.35619926},"307":{"165":29.2140007,"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009,"157":26.82970047,"156":26.3885994},"308":{"165":28.51329994,"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007,"157":26.71920013,"156":26.4218998},"309":{"165":28.35750008,"164":27.89900017,"163":27.25250053,"162":27.50160027,"161":27.47509956,"160":27.11560059,"159":26.76110077,"158":26.76749992,"157":26.69949913,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.19519997,"164":27.38059998,"163":27.06369972,"162":27.5067997,"161":27.42020035,"160":26.89319992,"159":26.62369919,"158":26.84090042,"157":26.76449966,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":13.86610031,"225":15.93470001,"224":16.67589951,"223":16.62680054,"222":16.76379967,"221":17.53389931,"220":18.14620018,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.24540043,"226":13.33129978,"225":15.1086998,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":17.54770088,"219":17.30940056},"226":{"227":12.76749992,"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":16.92580032,"219":16.94580078},"227":{"227":13.87609959,"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044,"219":16.86240005},"228":{"227":12.00899982,"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079,"219":16.87229919},"229":{"227":12.10249996,"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952,"219":16.80349922},"230":{"227":12.20020008,"226":12.80679989,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937,"219":16.62879944},"231":{"227":12.08889961,"226":12.26280022,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":15.73950005,"220":16.6310997,"219":15.83370018},"232":{"227":11.50790024,"226":11.82520008,"225":12.1875,"224":12.13210011,"223":13.0717001,"222":12.59549999,"221":13.48740005,"220":14.82579994,"219":13.95870018}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "autumn in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and autumn in historical period?
324880e5-869d-4de9-8edb-65e86f03fe9e
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on heat-related health issues, I'm curious: which location has seen a greater variation in maximum seasonal heat index during the summer between the historical period and the end-century period: Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(b) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period']
{"430":{"83":null,"82":114.29908752,"81":115.47489166,"80":116.80410258,"79":118.24965668},"431":{"83":null,"82":114.99489848,"81":116.15186564,"80":117.40893555,"79":119.07707723},"432":{"83":null,"82":115.84094747,"81":116.77384949,"80":118.21387482,"79":119.82306163},"433":{"83":116.10830434,"82":116.72666677,"81":117.6232427,"80":119.0770518,"79":121.30142975},"434":{"83":116.81502024,"82":117.47808838,"81":118.36641439,"80":120.16819509,"79":126.95307922},"435":{"83":116.98486074,"82":118.34583282,"81":119.04996236,"80":120.95856222,"79":123.3375117},"436":{"83":116.63974762,"82":118.68644969,"81":120.18824005,"80":122.00797526,"79":127.42913055},"437":{"83":116.47566477,"82":118.28816986,"81":120.29496511,"80":122.2644043,"79":127.64105733}}
{"430":{"83":null,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"83":null,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"83":null,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":95.48002879,"168":95.38298289,"167":95.48829397,"166":96.00617472,"165":96.61983744,"164":null},"431":{"170":95.25752513,"169":95.24199677,"168":95.32129924,"167":95.61095428,"166":96.23701223,"165":96.85983022,"164":97.39466858},"432":{"170":95.25984955,"169":95.41473134,"168":95.73072561,"167":96.33268992,"166":97.0057195,"165":97.36201731,"164":97.54164886},"433":{"170":95.69987996,"169":95.80229441,"168":96.12500254,"167":96.60927327,"166":97.03498586,"165":97.3702062,"164":97.41025035},"434":{"170":95.83483887,"169":95.92216237,"168":96.38761648,"167":96.28755442,"166":96.75217183,"165":97.08296458,"164":97.08935547},"435":{"170":95.55097707,"169":95.64427948,"168":95.86776988,"167":96.28699748,"166":96.89730581,"165":97.32364909,"164":97.45929718},"436":{"170":94.96092733,"169":95.06641642,"168":95.4910965,"167":96.14209493,"166":96.74804942,"165":97.27880096,"164":97.68227386}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":null},"431":{"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464},"432":{"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847},"433":{"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966},"434":{"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213},"435":{"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619},"436":{"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
ed83d1bb-b412-4962-b1e7-25f61f220b0d
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on heat-related health issues, I'm curious: which location has seen a greater variation in maximum seasonal heat index during the summer between the historical period and the end-century period: Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1346/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(b) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period']
{"430":{"83":null,"82":114.29908752,"81":115.47489166,"80":116.80410258,"79":118.24965668},"431":{"83":null,"82":114.99489848,"81":116.15186564,"80":117.40893555,"79":119.07707723},"432":{"83":null,"82":115.84094747,"81":116.77384949,"80":118.21387482,"79":119.82306163},"433":{"83":116.10830434,"82":116.72666677,"81":117.6232427,"80":119.0770518,"79":121.30142975},"434":{"83":116.81502024,"82":117.47808838,"81":118.36641439,"80":120.16819509,"79":126.95307922},"435":{"83":116.98486074,"82":118.34583282,"81":119.04996236,"80":120.95856222,"79":123.3375117},"436":{"83":116.63974762,"82":118.68644969,"81":120.18824005,"80":122.00797526,"79":127.42913055},"437":{"83":116.47566477,"82":118.28816986,"81":120.29496511,"80":122.2644043,"79":127.64105733}}
{"430":{"83":null,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"83":null,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"83":null,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":95.48002879,"168":95.38298289,"167":95.48829397,"166":96.00617472,"165":96.61983744,"164":null},"431":{"170":95.25752513,"169":95.24199677,"168":95.32129924,"167":95.61095428,"166":96.23701223,"165":96.85983022,"164":97.39466858},"432":{"170":95.25984955,"169":95.41473134,"168":95.73072561,"167":96.33268992,"166":97.0057195,"165":97.36201731,"164":97.54164886},"433":{"170":95.69987996,"169":95.80229441,"168":96.12500254,"167":96.60927327,"166":97.03498586,"165":97.3702062,"164":97.41025035},"434":{"170":95.83483887,"169":95.92216237,"168":96.38761648,"167":96.28755442,"166":96.75217183,"165":97.08296458,"164":97.08935547},"435":{"170":95.55097707,"169":95.64427948,"168":95.86776988,"167":96.28699748,"166":96.89730581,"165":97.32364909,"164":97.45929718},"436":{"170":94.96092733,"169":95.06641642,"168":95.4910965,"167":96.14209493,"166":96.74804942,"165":97.27880096,"164":97.68227386}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":null},"431":{"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464},"432":{"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847},"433":{"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966},"434":{"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213},"435":{"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619},"436":{"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
da3255f4-e4c0-41e5-873c-97e9dab87c42
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on heat-related health issues, I'm curious: which location has seen a greater variation in maximum seasonal heat index during the summer between the historical period and the end-century period: Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1346/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(b) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period']
{"430":{"83":null,"82":114.29908752,"81":115.47489166,"80":116.80410258,"79":118.24965668},"431":{"83":null,"82":114.99489848,"81":116.15186564,"80":117.40893555,"79":119.07707723},"432":{"83":null,"82":115.84094747,"81":116.77384949,"80":118.21387482,"79":119.82306163},"433":{"83":116.10830434,"82":116.72666677,"81":117.6232427,"80":119.0770518,"79":121.30142975},"434":{"83":116.81502024,"82":117.47808838,"81":118.36641439,"80":120.16819509,"79":126.95307922},"435":{"83":116.98486074,"82":118.34583282,"81":119.04996236,"80":120.95856222,"79":123.3375117},"436":{"83":116.63974762,"82":118.68644969,"81":120.18824005,"80":122.00797526,"79":127.42913055},"437":{"83":116.47566477,"82":118.28816986,"81":120.29496511,"80":122.2644043,"79":127.64105733}}
{"430":{"83":null,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"83":null,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"83":null,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":95.48002879,"168":95.38298289,"167":95.48829397,"166":96.00617472,"165":96.61983744,"164":null},"431":{"170":95.25752513,"169":95.24199677,"168":95.32129924,"167":95.61095428,"166":96.23701223,"165":96.85983022,"164":97.39466858},"432":{"170":95.25984955,"169":95.41473134,"168":95.73072561,"167":96.33268992,"166":97.0057195,"165":97.36201731,"164":97.54164886},"433":{"170":95.69987996,"169":95.80229441,"168":96.12500254,"167":96.60927327,"166":97.03498586,"165":97.3702062,"164":97.41025035},"434":{"170":95.83483887,"169":95.92216237,"168":96.38761648,"167":96.28755442,"166":96.75217183,"165":97.08296458,"164":97.08935547},"435":{"170":95.55097707,"169":95.64427948,"168":95.86776988,"167":96.28699748,"166":96.89730581,"165":97.32364909,"164":97.45929718},"436":{"170":94.96092733,"169":95.06641642,"168":95.4910965,"167":96.14209493,"166":96.74804942,"165":97.27880096,"164":97.68227386}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":null},"431":{"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464},"432":{"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847},"433":{"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966},"434":{"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213},"435":{"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619},"436":{"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
3f093822-989c-496e-9ca1-7c0aecb04981
As a climate scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on heat-related health issues, I'm curious: which location has seen a greater variation in maximum seasonal heat index during the summer between the historical period and the end-century period: Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1346/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(b) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period']
{"430":{"83":null,"82":114.29908752,"81":115.47489166,"80":116.80410258,"79":118.24965668},"431":{"83":null,"82":114.99489848,"81":116.15186564,"80":117.40893555,"79":119.07707723},"432":{"83":null,"82":115.84094747,"81":116.77384949,"80":118.21387482,"79":119.82306163},"433":{"83":116.10830434,"82":116.72666677,"81":117.6232427,"80":119.0770518,"79":121.30142975},"434":{"83":116.81502024,"82":117.47808838,"81":118.36641439,"80":120.16819509,"79":126.95307922},"435":{"83":116.98486074,"82":118.34583282,"81":119.04996236,"80":120.95856222,"79":123.3375117},"436":{"83":116.63974762,"82":118.68644969,"81":120.18824005,"80":122.00797526,"79":127.42913055},"437":{"83":116.47566477,"82":118.28816986,"81":120.29496511,"80":122.2644043,"79":127.64105733}}
{"430":{"83":null,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"83":null,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"83":null,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":95.48002879,"168":95.38298289,"167":95.48829397,"166":96.00617472,"165":96.61983744,"164":null},"431":{"170":95.25752513,"169":95.24199677,"168":95.32129924,"167":95.61095428,"166":96.23701223,"165":96.85983022,"164":97.39466858},"432":{"170":95.25984955,"169":95.41473134,"168":95.73072561,"167":96.33268992,"166":97.0057195,"165":97.36201731,"164":97.54164886},"433":{"170":95.69987996,"169":95.80229441,"168":96.12500254,"167":96.60927327,"166":97.03498586,"165":97.3702062,"164":97.41025035},"434":{"170":95.83483887,"169":95.92216237,"168":96.38761648,"167":96.28755442,"166":96.75217183,"165":97.08296458,"164":97.08935547},"435":{"170":95.55097707,"169":95.64427948,"168":95.86776988,"167":96.28699748,"166":96.89730581,"165":97.32364909,"164":97.45929718},"436":{"170":94.96092733,"169":95.06641642,"168":95.4910965,"167":96.14209493,"166":96.74804942,"165":97.27880096,"164":97.68227386}}
{"430":{"170":null,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":null},"431":{"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464},"432":{"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847},"433":{"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966},"434":{"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213},"435":{"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619},"436":{"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
adea113c-a5b0-4ae0-966d-08fc9dabf05b
As an environmental scientist analyzing historical fire weather patterns, I'm interested in understanding which area has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn and winter of the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
tabular
null
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
19d70393-473f-436c-b8a9-947fc022e75a
As an environmental scientist analyzing historical fire weather patterns, I'm interested in understanding which area has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn and winter of the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1317/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
18e77876-622e-4e95-b85a-42b87f4d769f
As an environmental scientist analyzing historical fire weather patterns, I'm interested in understanding which area has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn and winter of the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1317/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
704aed42-05a0-4e20-9f66-2cb5e9c3cd7b
As an environmental scientist analyzing historical fire weather patterns, I'm interested in understanding which area has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn and winter of the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1317/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
24c27efb-5b10-4cb5-9298-ec6a88f3c344
As a hydrologist presenting to a local government panel discussing water resource management, I would like to know which city has seen a more significant shift in average annual precipitation over the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP8.5: Memphis, TN, or Nashville, TN?
trend
tabular
null
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"413":{"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875},"414":{"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945},"415":{"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964},"416":{"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957},"417":{"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052},"418":{"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875},"419":{"123":null,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832}}
{"413":{"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985},"414":{"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083},"415":{"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985},"416":{"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913},"417":{"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101},"418":{"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897},"419":{"123":null,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176},"436":{"138":null,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009},"437":{"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939},"438":{"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872},"439":{"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101},"440":{"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":null}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038},"436":{"138":null,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046},"437":{"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011},"438":{"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098},"439":{"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002},"440":{"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
ccd8ce08-c5ce-43da-bdb7-6a6a810d3e1a
As a hydrologist presenting to a local government panel discussing water resource management, I would like to know which city has seen a more significant shift in average annual precipitation over the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP8.5: Memphis, TN, or Nashville, TN?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"413":{"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875},"414":{"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945},"415":{"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964},"416":{"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957},"417":{"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052},"418":{"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875},"419":{"123":null,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832}}
{"413":{"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985},"414":{"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083},"415":{"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985},"416":{"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913},"417":{"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101},"418":{"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897},"419":{"123":null,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176},"436":{"138":null,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009},"437":{"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939},"438":{"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872},"439":{"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101},"440":{"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":null}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038},"436":{"138":null,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046},"437":{"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011},"438":{"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098},"439":{"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002},"440":{"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
75f7ab3a-9e50-49b4-904e-0c7abe832736
As a hydrologist presenting to a local government panel discussing water resource management, I would like to know which city has seen a more significant shift in average annual precipitation over the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP8.5: Memphis, TN, or Nashville, TN?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"413":{"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875},"414":{"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945},"415":{"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964},"416":{"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957},"417":{"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052},"418":{"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875},"419":{"123":null,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832}}
{"413":{"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985},"414":{"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083},"415":{"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985},"416":{"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913},"417":{"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101},"418":{"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897},"419":{"123":null,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176},"436":{"138":null,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009},"437":{"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939},"438":{"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872},"439":{"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101},"440":{"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":null}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038},"436":{"138":null,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046},"437":{"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011},"438":{"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098},"439":{"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002},"440":{"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
a2cbffa5-c66c-4a35-aeca-7334f2e332c7
As a hydrologist presenting to a local government panel discussing water resource management, I would like to know which city has seen a more significant shift in average annual precipitation over the mid-century and end-century periods under RCP8.5: Memphis, TN, or Nashville, TN?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1348/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States.', '(b) The Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Memphis, TN, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Memphis, TN, United States and Nashville, TN, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) Memphis, TN, United States experienced a greater change than Nashville, TN, United States.']
['Memphis, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Memphis, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Nashville, TN, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"413":{"123":52.71960068,"122":53.28329849,"121":53.92250061,"120":54.3166008,"119":54.41790009,"118":54.66180038,"117":54.59949875},"414":{"123":54.24369812,"122":53.93230057,"121":54.95899963,"120":55.0583992,"119":54.7989006,"118":54.99349976,"117":55.68849945},"415":{"123":55.18790054,"122":54.49980164,"121":54.79650116,"120":54.82180023,"119":54.43640137,"118":55.69309998,"117":56.52009964},"416":{"123":54.51869965,"122":54.3382988,"121":54.95909882,"120":55.62250137,"119":59.33470154,"118":58.47340012,"117":56.03689957},"417":{"123":54.38579941,"122":53.96860123,"121":54.85689926,"120":55.85400009,"119":59.41849899,"118":55.5381012,"117":56.44350052},"418":{"123":55.3606987,"122":54.86040115,"121":55.66669846,"120":56.20230103,"119":56.81880188,"118":56.13510132,"117":57.78699875},"419":{"123":null,"122":55.84980011,"121":55.72940063,"120":55.64239883,"119":56.26779938,"118":56.23339844,"117":58.76139832}}
{"413":{"123":47.73450089,"122":47.67300034,"121":48.24010086,"120":48.48509979,"119":49.22119904,"118":49.48180008,"117":49.4068985},"414":{"123":48.06570053,"122":48.19710159,"121":49.02999878,"120":49.14759827,"119":49.66579819,"118":49.80319977,"117":50.30960083},"415":{"123":48.84949875,"122":48.98550034,"121":49.3227005,"120":49.31840134,"119":49.60319901,"118":50.60089874,"117":51.0929985},"416":{"123":49.02140045,"122":49.15190125,"121":50.08169937,"120":50.18619919,"119":53.43280029,"118":53.18849945,"117":51.38629913},"417":{"123":48.90029907,"122":49.2378006,"121":50.45849991,"120":50.62630081,"119":53.2179985,"118":51.12860107,"117":51.83150101},"418":{"123":49.37659836,"122":49.31549835,"121":50.35390091,"120":51.22439957,"119":51.78540039,"118":51.7071991,"117":53.11159897},"419":{"123":null,"122":50.05950165,"121":50.45330048,"120":50.82500076,"119":51.91790009,"118":52.11489868,"117":54.28720093}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":53.73220062,"136":53.42750168,"135":54.82360077,"134":54.60290146,"133":52.01689911,"132":50.70500183,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":53.31869888,"136":52.36220169,"135":53.79560089,"134":56.98659897,"133":55.79990005,"132":52.24940109,"131":51.65930176},"436":{"138":null,"137":52.75859833,"136":52.36589813,"135":53.77999878,"134":55.04150009,"133":53.91469955,"132":52.28150177,"131":52.1692009},"437":{"138":52.62540054,"137":53.34410095,"136":54.5265007,"135":57.00540161,"134":57.50289917,"133":56.66490173,"132":54.32329941,"131":52.88999939},"438":{"138":52.72180176,"137":55.07649994,"136":58.09749985,"135":59.90100098,"134":59.1556015,"133":60.24639893,"132":52.86389923,"131":52.91759872},"439":{"138":54.62220001,"137":58.32139969,"136":61.83359909,"135":60.1067009,"134":60.8608017,"133":61.11240005,"132":56.19150162,"131":53.89260101},"440":{"138":56.7242012,"137":62.75419998,"136":64.12460327,"135":59.80450058,"134":59.71440125,"133":63.57550049,"132":61.08369827,"131":null}}
{"434":{"138":null,"137":50.92089844,"136":50.57649994,"135":51.44390106,"134":51.42829895,"133":49.3708992,"132":48.20539856,"131":null},"435":{"138":null,"137":51.09859848,"136":49.84909821,"135":50.89080048,"134":53.11169815,"133":52.10549927,"132":49.16859818,"131":48.60070038},"436":{"138":null,"137":50.81869888,"136":49.73419952,"135":50.19710159,"134":51.32509995,"133":50.5890007,"132":49.19229889,"131":49.08110046},"437":{"138":49.92779922,"137":50.10400009,"136":51.01229858,"135":52.93899918,"134":53.75270081,"133":52.89839935,"132":51.15459824,"131":50.47480011},"438":{"138":49.11109924,"137":51.09619904,"136":53.83969879,"135":56.2541008,"134":55.16479874,"133":55.48279953,"132":50.29539871,"131":50.46210098},"439":{"138":50.48559952,"137":53.88460159,"136":57.10440063,"135":56.70759964,"134":56.5367012,"133":56.59069824,"132":52.78440094,"131":51.1427002},"440":{"138":52.33720016,"137":57.77170181,"136":59.29140091,"135":55.48389816,"134":55.60129929,"133":58.4054985,"132":56.81299973,"131":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Memphis, TN, United States", "location2": "Nashville, TN, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Memphis, TN, United States or Nashville, TN, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
24e93af8-bd73-4fb9-b540-0449cc0d90e3
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical fire risks, I'm curious about which city experienced a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring and winter in the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.80856001,"152":0.88230801,"151":0.85782897,"150":1.46490002,"149":2.47985005,"148":2.22733998,"147":1.59478998,"146":1.77372003,"145":3.30330992,"144":5.30946016},"301":{"153":5.68661022,"152":4.51341009,"151":3.24585009,"150":3.23196006,"149":3.94488001,"148":4.78283024,"147":4.1363101,"146":4.44339991,"145":5.1073699,"144":4.51373005},"302":{"153":10.95409966,"152":11.5323,"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966,"144":7.4735198},"303":{"153":12.7166996,"152":13.58609962,"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961,"144":10.91740036},"304":{"153":12.59679985,"152":12.78829956,"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008,"144":10.68939972},"305":{"153":12.28250027,"152":11.97980022,"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023,"144":10.09459972},"306":{"153":12.16790009,"152":11.60470009,"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027,"144":10.16329956},"307":{"153":11.81739998,"152":11.40699959,"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897,"144":9.46259022},"308":{"153":11.59939957,"152":11.28660011,"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309,"144":9.86046982},"309":{"153":11.46560001,"152":11.25339985,"151":11.23499966,"150":11.07520008,"149":10.89449978,"148":10.72000027,"147":10.60739994,"146":10.51570034,"145":10.68789959,"144":10.8142004}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":32.54959869,"119":33.20849991,"118":33.88700104,"117":33.91740036,"116":31.8390007,"115":32.03499985},"226":{"124":32.28879929,"123":30.24080086,"122":24.74480057,"121":20.71179962,"120":22.41040039,"119":26.46050072,"118":30.58289909,"117":33.65990067,"116":34.35979843,"115":34.13079834},"227":{"124":30.95999908,"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":34.77819824,"115":36.56669998},"228":{"124":32.29470062,"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":32.25550079,"115":36.47900009},"229":{"124":32.8512001,"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":34.35520172,"115":37.57049942},"230":{"124":29.53249931,"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918,"115":37.86259842},"231":{"124":20.17650032,"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186,"115":38.69490051},"232":{"124":18.73859978,"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109,"115":41.23379898},"233":{"124":30.24920082,"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175,"115":43.4742012},"234":{"124":35.09629822,"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":42.2602005,"118":44.53549957,"117":44.69319916,"116":44.80099869,"115":45.69390106},"235":{"124":35.92200089,"123":37.05699921,"122":38.19879913,"121":38.45000076,"120":38.13740158,"119":40.70610046,"118":43.01580048,"117":43.31069946,"116":43.729599,"115":44.20930099}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
5080e265-98fe-44dd-b0ed-5f39f9d47d16
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical fire risks, I'm curious about which city experienced a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring and winter in the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1303/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.80856001,"152":0.88230801,"151":0.85782897,"150":1.46490002,"149":2.47985005,"148":2.22733998,"147":1.59478998,"146":1.77372003,"145":3.30330992,"144":5.30946016},"301":{"153":5.68661022,"152":4.51341009,"151":3.24585009,"150":3.23196006,"149":3.94488001,"148":4.78283024,"147":4.1363101,"146":4.44339991,"145":5.1073699,"144":4.51373005},"302":{"153":10.95409966,"152":11.5323,"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966,"144":7.4735198},"303":{"153":12.7166996,"152":13.58609962,"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961,"144":10.91740036},"304":{"153":12.59679985,"152":12.78829956,"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008,"144":10.68939972},"305":{"153":12.28250027,"152":11.97980022,"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023,"144":10.09459972},"306":{"153":12.16790009,"152":11.60470009,"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027,"144":10.16329956},"307":{"153":11.81739998,"152":11.40699959,"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897,"144":9.46259022},"308":{"153":11.59939957,"152":11.28660011,"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309,"144":9.86046982},"309":{"153":11.46560001,"152":11.25339985,"151":11.23499966,"150":11.07520008,"149":10.89449978,"148":10.72000027,"147":10.60739994,"146":10.51570034,"145":10.68789959,"144":10.8142004}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":32.54959869,"119":33.20849991,"118":33.88700104,"117":33.91740036,"116":31.8390007,"115":32.03499985},"226":{"124":32.28879929,"123":30.24080086,"122":24.74480057,"121":20.71179962,"120":22.41040039,"119":26.46050072,"118":30.58289909,"117":33.65990067,"116":34.35979843,"115":34.13079834},"227":{"124":30.95999908,"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":34.77819824,"115":36.56669998},"228":{"124":32.29470062,"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":32.25550079,"115":36.47900009},"229":{"124":32.8512001,"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":34.35520172,"115":37.57049942},"230":{"124":29.53249931,"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918,"115":37.86259842},"231":{"124":20.17650032,"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186,"115":38.69490051},"232":{"124":18.73859978,"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109,"115":41.23379898},"233":{"124":30.24920082,"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175,"115":43.4742012},"234":{"124":35.09629822,"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":42.2602005,"118":44.53549957,"117":44.69319916,"116":44.80099869,"115":45.69390106},"235":{"124":35.92200089,"123":37.05699921,"122":38.19879913,"121":38.45000076,"120":38.13740158,"119":40.70610046,"118":43.01580048,"117":43.31069946,"116":43.729599,"115":44.20930099}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
76bda837-9f3b-41f8-a862-0e52fa83423b
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical fire risks, I'm curious about which city experienced a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring and winter in the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1303/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.80856001,"152":0.88230801,"151":0.85782897,"150":1.46490002,"149":2.47985005,"148":2.22733998,"147":1.59478998,"146":1.77372003,"145":3.30330992,"144":5.30946016},"301":{"153":5.68661022,"152":4.51341009,"151":3.24585009,"150":3.23196006,"149":3.94488001,"148":4.78283024,"147":4.1363101,"146":4.44339991,"145":5.1073699,"144":4.51373005},"302":{"153":10.95409966,"152":11.5323,"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966,"144":7.4735198},"303":{"153":12.7166996,"152":13.58609962,"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961,"144":10.91740036},"304":{"153":12.59679985,"152":12.78829956,"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008,"144":10.68939972},"305":{"153":12.28250027,"152":11.97980022,"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023,"144":10.09459972},"306":{"153":12.16790009,"152":11.60470009,"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027,"144":10.16329956},"307":{"153":11.81739998,"152":11.40699959,"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897,"144":9.46259022},"308":{"153":11.59939957,"152":11.28660011,"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309,"144":9.86046982},"309":{"153":11.46560001,"152":11.25339985,"151":11.23499966,"150":11.07520008,"149":10.89449978,"148":10.72000027,"147":10.60739994,"146":10.51570034,"145":10.68789959,"144":10.8142004}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":32.54959869,"119":33.20849991,"118":33.88700104,"117":33.91740036,"116":31.8390007,"115":32.03499985},"226":{"124":32.28879929,"123":30.24080086,"122":24.74480057,"121":20.71179962,"120":22.41040039,"119":26.46050072,"118":30.58289909,"117":33.65990067,"116":34.35979843,"115":34.13079834},"227":{"124":30.95999908,"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":34.77819824,"115":36.56669998},"228":{"124":32.29470062,"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":32.25550079,"115":36.47900009},"229":{"124":32.8512001,"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":34.35520172,"115":37.57049942},"230":{"124":29.53249931,"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918,"115":37.86259842},"231":{"124":20.17650032,"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186,"115":38.69490051},"232":{"124":18.73859978,"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109,"115":41.23379898},"233":{"124":30.24920082,"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175,"115":43.4742012},"234":{"124":35.09629822,"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":42.2602005,"118":44.53549957,"117":44.69319916,"116":44.80099869,"115":45.69390106},"235":{"124":35.92200089,"123":37.05699921,"122":38.19879913,"121":38.45000076,"120":38.13740158,"119":40.70610046,"118":43.01580048,"117":43.31069946,"116":43.729599,"115":44.20930099}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
3b0fdc3c-7dc2-4ffd-a831-5c7676d85f40
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical fire risks, I'm curious about which city experienced a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring and winter in the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1303/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.80856001,"152":0.88230801,"151":0.85782897,"150":1.46490002,"149":2.47985005,"148":2.22733998,"147":1.59478998,"146":1.77372003,"145":3.30330992,"144":5.30946016},"301":{"153":5.68661022,"152":4.51341009,"151":3.24585009,"150":3.23196006,"149":3.94488001,"148":4.78283024,"147":4.1363101,"146":4.44339991,"145":5.1073699,"144":4.51373005},"302":{"153":10.95409966,"152":11.5323,"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966,"144":7.4735198},"303":{"153":12.7166996,"152":13.58609962,"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961,"144":10.91740036},"304":{"153":12.59679985,"152":12.78829956,"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008,"144":10.68939972},"305":{"153":12.28250027,"152":11.97980022,"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023,"144":10.09459972},"306":{"153":12.16790009,"152":11.60470009,"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027,"144":10.16329956},"307":{"153":11.81739998,"152":11.40699959,"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897,"144":9.46259022},"308":{"153":11.59939957,"152":11.28660011,"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309,"144":9.86046982},"309":{"153":11.46560001,"152":11.25339985,"151":11.23499966,"150":11.07520008,"149":10.89449978,"148":10.72000027,"147":10.60739994,"146":10.51570034,"145":10.68789959,"144":10.8142004}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":32.54959869,"119":33.20849991,"118":33.88700104,"117":33.91740036,"116":31.8390007,"115":32.03499985},"226":{"124":32.28879929,"123":30.24080086,"122":24.74480057,"121":20.71179962,"120":22.41040039,"119":26.46050072,"118":30.58289909,"117":33.65990067,"116":34.35979843,"115":34.13079834},"227":{"124":30.95999908,"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":34.77819824,"115":36.56669998},"228":{"124":32.29470062,"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":32.25550079,"115":36.47900009},"229":{"124":32.8512001,"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":34.35520172,"115":37.57049942},"230":{"124":29.53249931,"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918,"115":37.86259842},"231":{"124":20.17650032,"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186,"115":38.69490051},"232":{"124":18.73859978,"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109,"115":41.23379898},"233":{"124":30.24920082,"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175,"115":43.4742012},"234":{"124":35.09629822,"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":42.2602005,"118":44.53549957,"117":44.69319916,"116":44.80099869,"115":45.69390106},"235":{"124":35.92200089,"123":37.05699921,"122":38.19879913,"121":38.45000076,"120":38.13740158,"119":40.70610046,"118":43.01580048,"117":43.31069946,"116":43.729599,"115":44.20930099}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in mid-century period and winter in mid-century period?
1dc2417c-6bff-4d8f-88c0-26fbf2a6b03d
As a wildland fire management officer preparing for the upcoming fire season, I need to know which location has experienced a more significant variation in the fire weather index during the spring in the historical period and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.31524003,"152":0.619596,"151":0.55138701,"150":0.94072801,"149":1.88978004,"148":1.75115001,"147":1.19489002,"146":1.18508005,"145":2.37792993,"144":4.11140013},"301":{"153":4.86624002,"152":3.81557012,"151":2.57723999,"150":2.55531001,"149":3.32156992,"148":4.11527014,"147":3.56525993,"146":3.53311992,"145":4.03119993,"144":3.5165},"302":{"153":10.16539955,"152":10.8210001,"151":9.05478954,"150":6.57073021,"149":6.69637012,"148":7.204,"147":6.55584002,"146":6.31709003,"145":6.95903015,"144":6.10653019},"303":{"153":12.3185997,"152":13.35649967,"151":12.77649975,"150":10.69709969,"149":10.16590023,"148":10.08899975,"147":8.66674995,"146":7.9025898,"145":9.02875996,"144":9.37164021},"304":{"153":12.41069984,"152":12.7258997,"151":12.58290005,"150":11.82999992,"149":11.52190018,"148":11.13659954,"147":10.87559986,"146":10.41709995,"145":10.11369991,"144":9.17160034},"305":{"153":12.14540005,"152":11.94120026,"151":11.73260021,"150":11.50179958,"149":11.37889957,"148":10.81449986,"147":10.78909969,"146":11.14649963,"145":10.39750004,"144":8.91819},"306":{"153":11.87300014,"152":11.27050018,"151":11.41469955,"150":11.36170006,"149":11.14799976,"148":10.76710033,"147":10.41790009,"146":10.26910019,"145":9.98412991,"144":9.20388985},"307":{"153":11.44610023,"152":11.02289963,"151":11.31340027,"150":11.00559998,"149":10.6317997,"148":10.29119968,"147":9.8666296,"146":9.41722965,"145":9.01189041,"144":8.5571804},"308":{"153":11.20890045,"152":10.97509956,"151":11.29030037,"150":10.97329998,"149":10.46870041,"148":10.07600021,"147":9.77276039,"146":9.47632027,"145":9.17617989,"144":8.7897501},"309":{"153":11.1559,"152":11.00510025,"151":11.15089989,"150":11.03960037,"149":10.77289963,"148":10.5692997,"147":10.30200005,"146":10.08090019,"145":9.96220016,"144":9.83850002}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":29.89760017,"119":29.79859924,"118":29.82749939,"117":29.51469994,"116":27.49150085,"115":28.2859993},"226":{"124":28.17670059,"123":26.03350067,"122":20.60479927,"121":16.63439941,"120":18.45120049,"119":23.29210091,"118":27.37490082,"117":30.42700005,"116":30.57360077,"115":30.35149956},"227":{"124":27.01740074,"123":24.83370018,"122":17.9253006,"121":10.01930046,"120":8.69935036,"119":14.38790035,"118":22.38209915,"117":27.51409912,"116":31.94560051,"115":33.08349991},"228":{"124":28.95540047,"123":27.8743,"122":23.31850052,"121":13.71829987,"120":9.79880047,"119":13.26360035,"118":20.15279961,"117":23.98990059,"116":29.29140091,"115":33.42670059},"229":{"124":29.90309906,"123":31.7310009,"122":32.00690079,"121":28.09770012,"120":22.85199928,"119":22.37719917,"118":25.55719948,"117":26.83919907,"116":30.38209915,"115":34.15449905},"230":{"124":25.79710007,"123":25.93149948,"122":28.76379967,"121":33.09579849,"120":33.69309998,"119":33.85189819,"118":34.40790176,"117":33.65879822,"116":33.45550156,"115":33.54050064},"231":{"124":16.07099915,"123":13.41419983,"122":16.58340073,"121":25.65019989,"120":33.08729935,"119":36.06890106,"118":36.8409996,"117":36.02659988,"116":35.17630005,"115":34.16970062},"232":{"124":14.8835001,"123":14.30370045,"122":18.08860016,"121":26.73500061,"120":34.88190079,"119":37.86869812,"118":37.79899979,"117":36.96300125,"116":37.25719833,"115":36.60789871},"233":{"124":25.31979942,"123":27.03019905,"122":30.30680084,"121":34.27870178,"120":37.28210068,"119":39.15840149,"118":39.49760056,"117":39.33660126,"116":39.35380173,"115":38.41949844},"234":{"124":30.52689934,"123":32.53689957,"122":34.87070084,"121":35.8003006,"120":35.52529907,"119":37.22579956,"118":39.52759933,"117":39.87680054,"116":40.0041008,"115":40.87139893},"235":{"124":31.0734005,"123":32.26599884,"122":33.54639816,"121":33.4231987,"120":33.30130005,"119":35.82229996,"118":38.10969925,"117":38.42919922,"116":39.11429977,"115":39.74720001}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
2380263a-587e-472b-8bc6-b660253c9645
As a wildland fire management officer preparing for the upcoming fire season, I need to know which location has experienced a more significant variation in the fire weather index during the spring in the historical period and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1319/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.31524003,"152":0.619596,"151":0.55138701,"150":0.94072801,"149":1.88978004,"148":1.75115001,"147":1.19489002,"146":1.18508005,"145":2.37792993,"144":4.11140013},"301":{"153":4.86624002,"152":3.81557012,"151":2.57723999,"150":2.55531001,"149":3.32156992,"148":4.11527014,"147":3.56525993,"146":3.53311992,"145":4.03119993,"144":3.5165},"302":{"153":10.16539955,"152":10.8210001,"151":9.05478954,"150":6.57073021,"149":6.69637012,"148":7.204,"147":6.55584002,"146":6.31709003,"145":6.95903015,"144":6.10653019},"303":{"153":12.3185997,"152":13.35649967,"151":12.77649975,"150":10.69709969,"149":10.16590023,"148":10.08899975,"147":8.66674995,"146":7.9025898,"145":9.02875996,"144":9.37164021},"304":{"153":12.41069984,"152":12.7258997,"151":12.58290005,"150":11.82999992,"149":11.52190018,"148":11.13659954,"147":10.87559986,"146":10.41709995,"145":10.11369991,"144":9.17160034},"305":{"153":12.14540005,"152":11.94120026,"151":11.73260021,"150":11.50179958,"149":11.37889957,"148":10.81449986,"147":10.78909969,"146":11.14649963,"145":10.39750004,"144":8.91819},"306":{"153":11.87300014,"152":11.27050018,"151":11.41469955,"150":11.36170006,"149":11.14799976,"148":10.76710033,"147":10.41790009,"146":10.26910019,"145":9.98412991,"144":9.20388985},"307":{"153":11.44610023,"152":11.02289963,"151":11.31340027,"150":11.00559998,"149":10.6317997,"148":10.29119968,"147":9.8666296,"146":9.41722965,"145":9.01189041,"144":8.5571804},"308":{"153":11.20890045,"152":10.97509956,"151":11.29030037,"150":10.97329998,"149":10.46870041,"148":10.07600021,"147":9.77276039,"146":9.47632027,"145":9.17617989,"144":8.7897501},"309":{"153":11.1559,"152":11.00510025,"151":11.15089989,"150":11.03960037,"149":10.77289963,"148":10.5692997,"147":10.30200005,"146":10.08090019,"145":9.96220016,"144":9.83850002}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":29.89760017,"119":29.79859924,"118":29.82749939,"117":29.51469994,"116":27.49150085,"115":28.2859993},"226":{"124":28.17670059,"123":26.03350067,"122":20.60479927,"121":16.63439941,"120":18.45120049,"119":23.29210091,"118":27.37490082,"117":30.42700005,"116":30.57360077,"115":30.35149956},"227":{"124":27.01740074,"123":24.83370018,"122":17.9253006,"121":10.01930046,"120":8.69935036,"119":14.38790035,"118":22.38209915,"117":27.51409912,"116":31.94560051,"115":33.08349991},"228":{"124":28.95540047,"123":27.8743,"122":23.31850052,"121":13.71829987,"120":9.79880047,"119":13.26360035,"118":20.15279961,"117":23.98990059,"116":29.29140091,"115":33.42670059},"229":{"124":29.90309906,"123":31.7310009,"122":32.00690079,"121":28.09770012,"120":22.85199928,"119":22.37719917,"118":25.55719948,"117":26.83919907,"116":30.38209915,"115":34.15449905},"230":{"124":25.79710007,"123":25.93149948,"122":28.76379967,"121":33.09579849,"120":33.69309998,"119":33.85189819,"118":34.40790176,"117":33.65879822,"116":33.45550156,"115":33.54050064},"231":{"124":16.07099915,"123":13.41419983,"122":16.58340073,"121":25.65019989,"120":33.08729935,"119":36.06890106,"118":36.8409996,"117":36.02659988,"116":35.17630005,"115":34.16970062},"232":{"124":14.8835001,"123":14.30370045,"122":18.08860016,"121":26.73500061,"120":34.88190079,"119":37.86869812,"118":37.79899979,"117":36.96300125,"116":37.25719833,"115":36.60789871},"233":{"124":25.31979942,"123":27.03019905,"122":30.30680084,"121":34.27870178,"120":37.28210068,"119":39.15840149,"118":39.49760056,"117":39.33660126,"116":39.35380173,"115":38.41949844},"234":{"124":30.52689934,"123":32.53689957,"122":34.87070084,"121":35.8003006,"120":35.52529907,"119":37.22579956,"118":39.52759933,"117":39.87680054,"116":40.0041008,"115":40.87139893},"235":{"124":31.0734005,"123":32.26599884,"122":33.54639816,"121":33.4231987,"120":33.30130005,"119":35.82229996,"118":38.10969925,"117":38.42919922,"116":39.11429977,"115":39.74720001}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
210df29f-827d-495f-92c5-e00be6601231
As a wildland fire management officer preparing for the upcoming fire season, I need to know which location has experienced a more significant variation in the fire weather index during the spring in the historical period and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1319/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.31524003,"152":0.619596,"151":0.55138701,"150":0.94072801,"149":1.88978004,"148":1.75115001,"147":1.19489002,"146":1.18508005,"145":2.37792993,"144":4.11140013},"301":{"153":4.86624002,"152":3.81557012,"151":2.57723999,"150":2.55531001,"149":3.32156992,"148":4.11527014,"147":3.56525993,"146":3.53311992,"145":4.03119993,"144":3.5165},"302":{"153":10.16539955,"152":10.8210001,"151":9.05478954,"150":6.57073021,"149":6.69637012,"148":7.204,"147":6.55584002,"146":6.31709003,"145":6.95903015,"144":6.10653019},"303":{"153":12.3185997,"152":13.35649967,"151":12.77649975,"150":10.69709969,"149":10.16590023,"148":10.08899975,"147":8.66674995,"146":7.9025898,"145":9.02875996,"144":9.37164021},"304":{"153":12.41069984,"152":12.7258997,"151":12.58290005,"150":11.82999992,"149":11.52190018,"148":11.13659954,"147":10.87559986,"146":10.41709995,"145":10.11369991,"144":9.17160034},"305":{"153":12.14540005,"152":11.94120026,"151":11.73260021,"150":11.50179958,"149":11.37889957,"148":10.81449986,"147":10.78909969,"146":11.14649963,"145":10.39750004,"144":8.91819},"306":{"153":11.87300014,"152":11.27050018,"151":11.41469955,"150":11.36170006,"149":11.14799976,"148":10.76710033,"147":10.41790009,"146":10.26910019,"145":9.98412991,"144":9.20388985},"307":{"153":11.44610023,"152":11.02289963,"151":11.31340027,"150":11.00559998,"149":10.6317997,"148":10.29119968,"147":9.8666296,"146":9.41722965,"145":9.01189041,"144":8.5571804},"308":{"153":11.20890045,"152":10.97509956,"151":11.29030037,"150":10.97329998,"149":10.46870041,"148":10.07600021,"147":9.77276039,"146":9.47632027,"145":9.17617989,"144":8.7897501},"309":{"153":11.1559,"152":11.00510025,"151":11.15089989,"150":11.03960037,"149":10.77289963,"148":10.5692997,"147":10.30200005,"146":10.08090019,"145":9.96220016,"144":9.83850002}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":29.89760017,"119":29.79859924,"118":29.82749939,"117":29.51469994,"116":27.49150085,"115":28.2859993},"226":{"124":28.17670059,"123":26.03350067,"122":20.60479927,"121":16.63439941,"120":18.45120049,"119":23.29210091,"118":27.37490082,"117":30.42700005,"116":30.57360077,"115":30.35149956},"227":{"124":27.01740074,"123":24.83370018,"122":17.9253006,"121":10.01930046,"120":8.69935036,"119":14.38790035,"118":22.38209915,"117":27.51409912,"116":31.94560051,"115":33.08349991},"228":{"124":28.95540047,"123":27.8743,"122":23.31850052,"121":13.71829987,"120":9.79880047,"119":13.26360035,"118":20.15279961,"117":23.98990059,"116":29.29140091,"115":33.42670059},"229":{"124":29.90309906,"123":31.7310009,"122":32.00690079,"121":28.09770012,"120":22.85199928,"119":22.37719917,"118":25.55719948,"117":26.83919907,"116":30.38209915,"115":34.15449905},"230":{"124":25.79710007,"123":25.93149948,"122":28.76379967,"121":33.09579849,"120":33.69309998,"119":33.85189819,"118":34.40790176,"117":33.65879822,"116":33.45550156,"115":33.54050064},"231":{"124":16.07099915,"123":13.41419983,"122":16.58340073,"121":25.65019989,"120":33.08729935,"119":36.06890106,"118":36.8409996,"117":36.02659988,"116":35.17630005,"115":34.16970062},"232":{"124":14.8835001,"123":14.30370045,"122":18.08860016,"121":26.73500061,"120":34.88190079,"119":37.86869812,"118":37.79899979,"117":36.96300125,"116":37.25719833,"115":36.60789871},"233":{"124":25.31979942,"123":27.03019905,"122":30.30680084,"121":34.27870178,"120":37.28210068,"119":39.15840149,"118":39.49760056,"117":39.33660126,"116":39.35380173,"115":38.41949844},"234":{"124":30.52689934,"123":32.53689957,"122":34.87070084,"121":35.8003006,"120":35.52529907,"119":37.22579956,"118":39.52759933,"117":39.87680054,"116":40.0041008,"115":40.87139893},"235":{"124":31.0734005,"123":32.26599884,"122":33.54639816,"121":33.4231987,"120":33.30130005,"119":35.82229996,"118":38.10969925,"117":38.42919922,"116":39.11429977,"115":39.74720001}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
d91e0176-fb37-42dc-a38d-5eaa3a4b3b3f
As a wildland fire management officer preparing for the upcoming fire season, I need to know which location has experienced a more significant variation in the fire weather index during the spring in the historical period and in the winter during the mid-century period: Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1319/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":1.31524003,"152":0.619596,"151":0.55138701,"150":0.94072801,"149":1.88978004,"148":1.75115001,"147":1.19489002,"146":1.18508005,"145":2.37792993,"144":4.11140013},"301":{"153":4.86624002,"152":3.81557012,"151":2.57723999,"150":2.55531001,"149":3.32156992,"148":4.11527014,"147":3.56525993,"146":3.53311992,"145":4.03119993,"144":3.5165},"302":{"153":10.16539955,"152":10.8210001,"151":9.05478954,"150":6.57073021,"149":6.69637012,"148":7.204,"147":6.55584002,"146":6.31709003,"145":6.95903015,"144":6.10653019},"303":{"153":12.3185997,"152":13.35649967,"151":12.77649975,"150":10.69709969,"149":10.16590023,"148":10.08899975,"147":8.66674995,"146":7.9025898,"145":9.02875996,"144":9.37164021},"304":{"153":12.41069984,"152":12.7258997,"151":12.58290005,"150":11.82999992,"149":11.52190018,"148":11.13659954,"147":10.87559986,"146":10.41709995,"145":10.11369991,"144":9.17160034},"305":{"153":12.14540005,"152":11.94120026,"151":11.73260021,"150":11.50179958,"149":11.37889957,"148":10.81449986,"147":10.78909969,"146":11.14649963,"145":10.39750004,"144":8.91819},"306":{"153":11.87300014,"152":11.27050018,"151":11.41469955,"150":11.36170006,"149":11.14799976,"148":10.76710033,"147":10.41790009,"146":10.26910019,"145":9.98412991,"144":9.20388985},"307":{"153":11.44610023,"152":11.02289963,"151":11.31340027,"150":11.00559998,"149":10.6317997,"148":10.29119968,"147":9.8666296,"146":9.41722965,"145":9.01189041,"144":8.5571804},"308":{"153":11.20890045,"152":10.97509956,"151":11.29030037,"150":10.97329998,"149":10.46870041,"148":10.07600021,"147":9.77276039,"146":9.47632027,"145":9.17617989,"144":8.7897501},"309":{"153":11.1559,"152":11.00510025,"151":11.15089989,"150":11.03960037,"149":10.77289963,"148":10.5692997,"147":10.30200005,"146":10.08090019,"145":9.96220016,"144":9.83850002}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":29.89760017,"119":29.79859924,"118":29.82749939,"117":29.51469994,"116":27.49150085,"115":28.2859993},"226":{"124":28.17670059,"123":26.03350067,"122":20.60479927,"121":16.63439941,"120":18.45120049,"119":23.29210091,"118":27.37490082,"117":30.42700005,"116":30.57360077,"115":30.35149956},"227":{"124":27.01740074,"123":24.83370018,"122":17.9253006,"121":10.01930046,"120":8.69935036,"119":14.38790035,"118":22.38209915,"117":27.51409912,"116":31.94560051,"115":33.08349991},"228":{"124":28.95540047,"123":27.8743,"122":23.31850052,"121":13.71829987,"120":9.79880047,"119":13.26360035,"118":20.15279961,"117":23.98990059,"116":29.29140091,"115":33.42670059},"229":{"124":29.90309906,"123":31.7310009,"122":32.00690079,"121":28.09770012,"120":22.85199928,"119":22.37719917,"118":25.55719948,"117":26.83919907,"116":30.38209915,"115":34.15449905},"230":{"124":25.79710007,"123":25.93149948,"122":28.76379967,"121":33.09579849,"120":33.69309998,"119":33.85189819,"118":34.40790176,"117":33.65879822,"116":33.45550156,"115":33.54050064},"231":{"124":16.07099915,"123":13.41419983,"122":16.58340073,"121":25.65019989,"120":33.08729935,"119":36.06890106,"118":36.8409996,"117":36.02659988,"116":35.17630005,"115":34.16970062},"232":{"124":14.8835001,"123":14.30370045,"122":18.08860016,"121":26.73500061,"120":34.88190079,"119":37.86869812,"118":37.79899979,"117":36.96300125,"116":37.25719833,"115":36.60789871},"233":{"124":25.31979942,"123":27.03019905,"122":30.30680084,"121":34.27870178,"120":37.28210068,"119":39.15840149,"118":39.49760056,"117":39.33660126,"116":39.35380173,"115":38.41949844},"234":{"124":30.52689934,"123":32.53689957,"122":34.87070084,"121":35.8003006,"120":35.52529907,"119":37.22579956,"118":39.52759933,"117":39.87680054,"116":40.0041008,"115":40.87139893},"235":{"124":31.0734005,"123":32.26599884,"122":33.54639816,"121":33.4231987,"120":33.30130005,"119":35.82229996,"118":38.10969925,"117":38.42919922,"116":39.11429977,"115":39.74720001}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
58abee9e-3a28-4647-8853-4b1f3e54a47b
As a climate scientist attending a conference on regional temperature trends, I'm interested in knowing which city, Hartford, CT, or Helena, MT, has shown a greater variation in heating degree days when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) The Hartford, CT, United States experienced a greater change than Helena, MT, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change than Hartford, CT, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States.']
['Hartford, CT, United States in historical period', 'Hartford, CT, United States in mid-century period', 'Helena, MT, United States in historical period', 'Helena, MT, United States in mid-century period']
{"509":{"219":null,"218":7936.24023438,"217":7919.91992188,"216":7748.35986328,"215":7528.60986328,"214":7441.62988281,"213":7284.43994141,"212":7035.41992188,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":7509.99023438,"217":7595.45996094,"216":7567.18017578,"215":7443.75,"214":7372.50976563,"213":7236.41992188,"212":6981.75,"211":6763.58984375,"210":6685.31005859},"511":{"219":7140.56005859,"218":7128.22021484,"217":7126.52978516,"216":7135.24023438,"215":7089.54003906,"214":7053.37011719,"213":7017.68994141,"212":6871.27001953,"211":6687.10009766,"210":6601.58007813},"512":{"219":7002.56982422,"218":6776.5,"217":6815.83984375,"216":6794.97021484,"215":6783.29003906,"214":6775.91992188,"213":6775.66015625,"212":6713.91015625,"211":6608.41015625,"210":6494.97021484},"513":{"219":7032.06982422,"218":6731.52001953,"217":6652.04980469,"216":6662.54003906,"215":6538.41992188,"214":6481.79980469,"213":6591.60986328,"212":6559.08984375,"211":6482.22021484,"210":6329.83007813},"514":{"219":7121.58007813,"218":7027.56982422,"217":6875.64990234,"216":6730.81005859,"215":6629.37988281,"214":6538.18017578,"213":6522.62988281,"212":6503.41015625,"211":6356.54003906,"210":6204.16015625},"515":{"219":7180.95019531,"218":7142.97021484,"217":6963.47998047,"216":6805.72998047,"215":6721.29980469,"214":6606.45996094,"213":6509.56982422,"212":6418.54980469,"211":6260.14013672,"210":5546.68017578},"516":{"219":7060.75,"218":6990.43994141,"217":6874.5,"216":6726.47998047,"215":6651.0,"214":6579.18994141,"213":6437.81982422,"212":6266.89990234,"211":6146.04003906,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":6814.33984375,"217":6725.54980469,"216":6586.06982422,"215":6488.25,"214":6430.00976563,"213":6305.72021484,"212":6143.93017578,"211":5474.14013672,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":6497.83007813,"215":6393.79980469,"214":6293.66015625,"213":6174.14013672,"212":5494.14990234,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"509":{"219":null,"218":6786.66015625,"217":6762.91015625,"216":6611.39990234,"215":6436.97021484,"214":6365.37011719,"213":6240.89013672,"212":6049.54980469,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":6470.27978516,"217":6530.02001953,"216":6497.04003906,"215":6388.43994141,"214":6324.58007813,"213":6210.20996094,"212":6009.81005859,"211":5847.60009766,"210":5795.14013672},"511":{"219":6173.50976563,"218":6169.06982422,"217":6170.81982422,"216":6174.08984375,"215":6131.27978516,"214":6095.12011719,"213":6054.72021484,"212":5933.85009766,"211":5790.56982422,"210":5728.22998047},"512":{"219":6061.87011719,"218":5996.10009766,"217":5935.85986328,"216":5919.81982422,"215":5904.68994141,"214":5889.72998047,"213":5878.12988281,"212":5820.66992188,"211":5732.79980469,"210":5642.87988281},"513":{"219":6084.49023438,"218":5960.85986328,"217":5854.33007813,"216":5819.14013672,"215":5808.25,"214":5747.56982422,"213":5736.54980469,"212":5705.37988281,"211":5635.77001953,"210":5520.39990234},"514":{"219":6149.93994141,"218":6074.81982422,"217":5959.20996094,"216":5850.56005859,"215":5773.06982422,"214":5698.93994141,"213":5675.87988281,"212":5649.72021484,"211":5535.39013672,"210":5410.58007813},"515":{"219":6198.79003906,"218":6163.50976563,"217":6021.04003906,"216":5900.02001953,"215":5834.08984375,"214":5737.77978516,"213":5656.27978516,"212":5579.16015625,"211":5446.77001953,"210":4823.66992188},"516":{"219":6105.81982422,"218":6049.60009766,"217":5951.12988281,"216":5836.93017578,"215":5778.85009766,"214":5711.02978516,"213":5594.02001953,"212":5461.25976563,"211":5352.47021484,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":5909.56005859,"217":5832.95996094,"216":5722.22021484,"215":5649.12011719,"214":5595.18994141,"213":5486.58007813,"212":5345.89013672,"211":4751.68017578,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":5648.31982422,"215":5563.06982422,"214":5476.64013672,"213":5365.95019531,"212":4763.79003906,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"256":{"214":10296.5,"213":10188.70019531,"212":10140.09960938,"211":9603.91015625,"210":9208.46972656,"209":9241.0,"208":9729.74023438,"207":9927.5,"206":null},"257":{"214":10365.70019531,"213":10380.59960938,"212":10356.79980469,"211":10004.29980469,"210":9876.13964844,"209":10534.5,"208":11024.59960938,"207":10983.29980469,"206":null},"258":{"214":10029.59960938,"213":9718.38964844,"212":9614.08007813,"211":9697.12011719,"210":9921.01953125,"209":10529.79980469,"208":10509.20019531,"207":10338.90039063,"206":10493.29980469},"259":{"214":9082.13964844,"213":9122.63964844,"212":8888.54003906,"211":8814.62988281,"210":9009.20019531,"209":9529.24023438,"208":9743.20996094,"207":9515.94042969,"206":9216.54980469},"260":{"214":8581.1796875,"213":8865.54003906,"212":8542.79003906,"211":8197.54003906,"210":8490.50976563,"209":9260.36035156,"208":10172.0,"207":9661.30957031,"206":8822.26953125},"261":{"214":8910.41015625,"213":9351.70019531,"212":8873.69042969,"211":8255.40039063,"210":8440.01953125,"209":9429.49023438,"208":10489.59960938,"207":9807.91015625,"206":8785.98046875},"262":{"214":9449.3203125,"213":10178.40039063,"212":10112.59960938,"211":9135.19042969,"210":8532.9296875,"209":8712.37988281,"208":8974.16992188,"207":8569.03027344,"206":8145.20996094},"263":{"214":9037.63964844,"213":9899.0,"212":10465.70019531,"211":10115.40039063,"210":9269.80957031,"209":8499.54980469,"208":8132.45996094,"207":7950.33007813,"206":8010.70019531},"264":{"214":8949.45996094,"213":9356.99023438,"212":9585.11035156,"211":9762.53027344,"210":10145.70019531,"209":9946.0,"208":9194.91015625,"207":8767.95019531,"206":8734.71972656}}
{"256":{"214":8822.75,"213":8719.90039063,"212":8678.6796875,"211":8205.76953125,"210":7878.04003906,"209":7914.72021484,"208":8346.45019531,"207":8549.3203125,"206":null},"257":{"214":8844.03027344,"213":8851.25,"212":8826.98046875,"211":8505.87011719,"210":8429.5703125,"209":9081.16015625,"208":9519.41015625,"207":9482.98046875,"206":null},"258":{"214":8533.94042969,"213":8257.58984375,"212":8161.89013672,"211":8222.28027344,"210":8428.83984375,"209":8999.95996094,"208":9032.12988281,"207":8892.54003906,"206":9031.98046875},"259":{"214":7780.97998047,"213":7789.64013672,"212":7597.64990234,"211":7536.60986328,"210":7694.31982422,"209":8098.41992188,"208":8272.91015625,"207":8091.58007813,"206":7871.50976563},"260":{"214":7370.79980469,"213":7592.37011719,"212":7351.20019531,"211":7080.60986328,"210":7271.08007813,"209":7881.60009766,"208":8639.71972656,"207":8251.36035156,"206":7547.81005859},"261":{"214":7640.02978516,"213":7994.00976563,"212":7617.60986328,"211":7117.02001953,"210":7243.74023438,"209":8027.52001953,"208":8923.71972656,"207":8385.00976563,"206":7538.29980469},"262":{"214":8073.27978516,"213":8676.62988281,"212":8636.8203125,"211":7833.12988281,"210":7315.20019531,"209":7446.64990234,"208":7674.87011719,"207":7397.33984375,"206":7072.97021484},"263":{"214":7729.35986328,"213":8412.19042969,"212":8891.51953125,"211":8612.12988281,"210":7896.52978516,"209":7293.25976563,"208":7037.97998047,"207":6901.08984375,"206":6917.04980469},"264":{"214":7653.25,"213":7953.75,"212":8113.10009766,"211":8257.11035156,"210":8620.51953125,"209":8488.55957031,"208":7876.97998047,"207":7498.37011719,"206":7465.00976563}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "heating degree", "location1": "Hartford, CT, United States", "location2": "Helena, MT, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Hartford, CT, United States or Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change in heating degree throughout historical period and mid-century period?
3b169d40-cb98-494b-93e9-d1140b7daa56
As a climate scientist attending a conference on regional temperature trends, I'm interested in knowing which city, Hartford, CT, or Helena, MT, has shown a greater variation in heating degree days when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1376/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Hartford, CT, United States experienced a greater change than Helena, MT, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change than Hartford, CT, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States.']
['Hartford, CT, United States in historical period', 'Hartford, CT, United States in mid-century period', 'Helena, MT, United States in historical period', 'Helena, MT, United States in mid-century period']
{"509":{"219":null,"218":7936.24023438,"217":7919.91992188,"216":7748.35986328,"215":7528.60986328,"214":7441.62988281,"213":7284.43994141,"212":7035.41992188,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":7509.99023438,"217":7595.45996094,"216":7567.18017578,"215":7443.75,"214":7372.50976563,"213":7236.41992188,"212":6981.75,"211":6763.58984375,"210":6685.31005859},"511":{"219":7140.56005859,"218":7128.22021484,"217":7126.52978516,"216":7135.24023438,"215":7089.54003906,"214":7053.37011719,"213":7017.68994141,"212":6871.27001953,"211":6687.10009766,"210":6601.58007813},"512":{"219":7002.56982422,"218":6776.5,"217":6815.83984375,"216":6794.97021484,"215":6783.29003906,"214":6775.91992188,"213":6775.66015625,"212":6713.91015625,"211":6608.41015625,"210":6494.97021484},"513":{"219":7032.06982422,"218":6731.52001953,"217":6652.04980469,"216":6662.54003906,"215":6538.41992188,"214":6481.79980469,"213":6591.60986328,"212":6559.08984375,"211":6482.22021484,"210":6329.83007813},"514":{"219":7121.58007813,"218":7027.56982422,"217":6875.64990234,"216":6730.81005859,"215":6629.37988281,"214":6538.18017578,"213":6522.62988281,"212":6503.41015625,"211":6356.54003906,"210":6204.16015625},"515":{"219":7180.95019531,"218":7142.97021484,"217":6963.47998047,"216":6805.72998047,"215":6721.29980469,"214":6606.45996094,"213":6509.56982422,"212":6418.54980469,"211":6260.14013672,"210":5546.68017578},"516":{"219":7060.75,"218":6990.43994141,"217":6874.5,"216":6726.47998047,"215":6651.0,"214":6579.18994141,"213":6437.81982422,"212":6266.89990234,"211":6146.04003906,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":6814.33984375,"217":6725.54980469,"216":6586.06982422,"215":6488.25,"214":6430.00976563,"213":6305.72021484,"212":6143.93017578,"211":5474.14013672,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":6497.83007813,"215":6393.79980469,"214":6293.66015625,"213":6174.14013672,"212":5494.14990234,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"509":{"219":null,"218":6786.66015625,"217":6762.91015625,"216":6611.39990234,"215":6436.97021484,"214":6365.37011719,"213":6240.89013672,"212":6049.54980469,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":6470.27978516,"217":6530.02001953,"216":6497.04003906,"215":6388.43994141,"214":6324.58007813,"213":6210.20996094,"212":6009.81005859,"211":5847.60009766,"210":5795.14013672},"511":{"219":6173.50976563,"218":6169.06982422,"217":6170.81982422,"216":6174.08984375,"215":6131.27978516,"214":6095.12011719,"213":6054.72021484,"212":5933.85009766,"211":5790.56982422,"210":5728.22998047},"512":{"219":6061.87011719,"218":5996.10009766,"217":5935.85986328,"216":5919.81982422,"215":5904.68994141,"214":5889.72998047,"213":5878.12988281,"212":5820.66992188,"211":5732.79980469,"210":5642.87988281},"513":{"219":6084.49023438,"218":5960.85986328,"217":5854.33007813,"216":5819.14013672,"215":5808.25,"214":5747.56982422,"213":5736.54980469,"212":5705.37988281,"211":5635.77001953,"210":5520.39990234},"514":{"219":6149.93994141,"218":6074.81982422,"217":5959.20996094,"216":5850.56005859,"215":5773.06982422,"214":5698.93994141,"213":5675.87988281,"212":5649.72021484,"211":5535.39013672,"210":5410.58007813},"515":{"219":6198.79003906,"218":6163.50976563,"217":6021.04003906,"216":5900.02001953,"215":5834.08984375,"214":5737.77978516,"213":5656.27978516,"212":5579.16015625,"211":5446.77001953,"210":4823.66992188},"516":{"219":6105.81982422,"218":6049.60009766,"217":5951.12988281,"216":5836.93017578,"215":5778.85009766,"214":5711.02978516,"213":5594.02001953,"212":5461.25976563,"211":5352.47021484,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":5909.56005859,"217":5832.95996094,"216":5722.22021484,"215":5649.12011719,"214":5595.18994141,"213":5486.58007813,"212":5345.89013672,"211":4751.68017578,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":5648.31982422,"215":5563.06982422,"214":5476.64013672,"213":5365.95019531,"212":4763.79003906,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"256":{"214":10296.5,"213":10188.70019531,"212":10140.09960938,"211":9603.91015625,"210":9208.46972656,"209":9241.0,"208":9729.74023438,"207":9927.5,"206":null},"257":{"214":10365.70019531,"213":10380.59960938,"212":10356.79980469,"211":10004.29980469,"210":9876.13964844,"209":10534.5,"208":11024.59960938,"207":10983.29980469,"206":null},"258":{"214":10029.59960938,"213":9718.38964844,"212":9614.08007813,"211":9697.12011719,"210":9921.01953125,"209":10529.79980469,"208":10509.20019531,"207":10338.90039063,"206":10493.29980469},"259":{"214":9082.13964844,"213":9122.63964844,"212":8888.54003906,"211":8814.62988281,"210":9009.20019531,"209":9529.24023438,"208":9743.20996094,"207":9515.94042969,"206":9216.54980469},"260":{"214":8581.1796875,"213":8865.54003906,"212":8542.79003906,"211":8197.54003906,"210":8490.50976563,"209":9260.36035156,"208":10172.0,"207":9661.30957031,"206":8822.26953125},"261":{"214":8910.41015625,"213":9351.70019531,"212":8873.69042969,"211":8255.40039063,"210":8440.01953125,"209":9429.49023438,"208":10489.59960938,"207":9807.91015625,"206":8785.98046875},"262":{"214":9449.3203125,"213":10178.40039063,"212":10112.59960938,"211":9135.19042969,"210":8532.9296875,"209":8712.37988281,"208":8974.16992188,"207":8569.03027344,"206":8145.20996094},"263":{"214":9037.63964844,"213":9899.0,"212":10465.70019531,"211":10115.40039063,"210":9269.80957031,"209":8499.54980469,"208":8132.45996094,"207":7950.33007813,"206":8010.70019531},"264":{"214":8949.45996094,"213":9356.99023438,"212":9585.11035156,"211":9762.53027344,"210":10145.70019531,"209":9946.0,"208":9194.91015625,"207":8767.95019531,"206":8734.71972656}}
{"256":{"214":8822.75,"213":8719.90039063,"212":8678.6796875,"211":8205.76953125,"210":7878.04003906,"209":7914.72021484,"208":8346.45019531,"207":8549.3203125,"206":null},"257":{"214":8844.03027344,"213":8851.25,"212":8826.98046875,"211":8505.87011719,"210":8429.5703125,"209":9081.16015625,"208":9519.41015625,"207":9482.98046875,"206":null},"258":{"214":8533.94042969,"213":8257.58984375,"212":8161.89013672,"211":8222.28027344,"210":8428.83984375,"209":8999.95996094,"208":9032.12988281,"207":8892.54003906,"206":9031.98046875},"259":{"214":7780.97998047,"213":7789.64013672,"212":7597.64990234,"211":7536.60986328,"210":7694.31982422,"209":8098.41992188,"208":8272.91015625,"207":8091.58007813,"206":7871.50976563},"260":{"214":7370.79980469,"213":7592.37011719,"212":7351.20019531,"211":7080.60986328,"210":7271.08007813,"209":7881.60009766,"208":8639.71972656,"207":8251.36035156,"206":7547.81005859},"261":{"214":7640.02978516,"213":7994.00976563,"212":7617.60986328,"211":7117.02001953,"210":7243.74023438,"209":8027.52001953,"208":8923.71972656,"207":8385.00976563,"206":7538.29980469},"262":{"214":8073.27978516,"213":8676.62988281,"212":8636.8203125,"211":7833.12988281,"210":7315.20019531,"209":7446.64990234,"208":7674.87011719,"207":7397.33984375,"206":7072.97021484},"263":{"214":7729.35986328,"213":8412.19042969,"212":8891.51953125,"211":8612.12988281,"210":7896.52978516,"209":7293.25976563,"208":7037.97998047,"207":6901.08984375,"206":6917.04980469},"264":{"214":7653.25,"213":7953.75,"212":8113.10009766,"211":8257.11035156,"210":8620.51953125,"209":8488.55957031,"208":7876.97998047,"207":7498.37011719,"206":7465.00976563}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "heating degree", "location1": "Hartford, CT, United States", "location2": "Helena, MT, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Hartford, CT, United States or Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change in heating degree throughout historical period and mid-century period?
cd791e49-0b1c-4cae-8a66-0c54f0d5e29c
As a climate scientist attending a conference on regional temperature trends, I'm interested in knowing which city, Hartford, CT, or Helena, MT, has shown a greater variation in heating degree days when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1376/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Hartford, CT, United States experienced a greater change than Helena, MT, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change than Hartford, CT, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States.']
['Hartford, CT, United States in historical period', 'Hartford, CT, United States in mid-century period', 'Helena, MT, United States in historical period', 'Helena, MT, United States in mid-century period']
{"509":{"219":null,"218":7936.24023438,"217":7919.91992188,"216":7748.35986328,"215":7528.60986328,"214":7441.62988281,"213":7284.43994141,"212":7035.41992188,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":7509.99023438,"217":7595.45996094,"216":7567.18017578,"215":7443.75,"214":7372.50976563,"213":7236.41992188,"212":6981.75,"211":6763.58984375,"210":6685.31005859},"511":{"219":7140.56005859,"218":7128.22021484,"217":7126.52978516,"216":7135.24023438,"215":7089.54003906,"214":7053.37011719,"213":7017.68994141,"212":6871.27001953,"211":6687.10009766,"210":6601.58007813},"512":{"219":7002.56982422,"218":6776.5,"217":6815.83984375,"216":6794.97021484,"215":6783.29003906,"214":6775.91992188,"213":6775.66015625,"212":6713.91015625,"211":6608.41015625,"210":6494.97021484},"513":{"219":7032.06982422,"218":6731.52001953,"217":6652.04980469,"216":6662.54003906,"215":6538.41992188,"214":6481.79980469,"213":6591.60986328,"212":6559.08984375,"211":6482.22021484,"210":6329.83007813},"514":{"219":7121.58007813,"218":7027.56982422,"217":6875.64990234,"216":6730.81005859,"215":6629.37988281,"214":6538.18017578,"213":6522.62988281,"212":6503.41015625,"211":6356.54003906,"210":6204.16015625},"515":{"219":7180.95019531,"218":7142.97021484,"217":6963.47998047,"216":6805.72998047,"215":6721.29980469,"214":6606.45996094,"213":6509.56982422,"212":6418.54980469,"211":6260.14013672,"210":5546.68017578},"516":{"219":7060.75,"218":6990.43994141,"217":6874.5,"216":6726.47998047,"215":6651.0,"214":6579.18994141,"213":6437.81982422,"212":6266.89990234,"211":6146.04003906,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":6814.33984375,"217":6725.54980469,"216":6586.06982422,"215":6488.25,"214":6430.00976563,"213":6305.72021484,"212":6143.93017578,"211":5474.14013672,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":6497.83007813,"215":6393.79980469,"214":6293.66015625,"213":6174.14013672,"212":5494.14990234,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"509":{"219":null,"218":6786.66015625,"217":6762.91015625,"216":6611.39990234,"215":6436.97021484,"214":6365.37011719,"213":6240.89013672,"212":6049.54980469,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":6470.27978516,"217":6530.02001953,"216":6497.04003906,"215":6388.43994141,"214":6324.58007813,"213":6210.20996094,"212":6009.81005859,"211":5847.60009766,"210":5795.14013672},"511":{"219":6173.50976563,"218":6169.06982422,"217":6170.81982422,"216":6174.08984375,"215":6131.27978516,"214":6095.12011719,"213":6054.72021484,"212":5933.85009766,"211":5790.56982422,"210":5728.22998047},"512":{"219":6061.87011719,"218":5996.10009766,"217":5935.85986328,"216":5919.81982422,"215":5904.68994141,"214":5889.72998047,"213":5878.12988281,"212":5820.66992188,"211":5732.79980469,"210":5642.87988281},"513":{"219":6084.49023438,"218":5960.85986328,"217":5854.33007813,"216":5819.14013672,"215":5808.25,"214":5747.56982422,"213":5736.54980469,"212":5705.37988281,"211":5635.77001953,"210":5520.39990234},"514":{"219":6149.93994141,"218":6074.81982422,"217":5959.20996094,"216":5850.56005859,"215":5773.06982422,"214":5698.93994141,"213":5675.87988281,"212":5649.72021484,"211":5535.39013672,"210":5410.58007813},"515":{"219":6198.79003906,"218":6163.50976563,"217":6021.04003906,"216":5900.02001953,"215":5834.08984375,"214":5737.77978516,"213":5656.27978516,"212":5579.16015625,"211":5446.77001953,"210":4823.66992188},"516":{"219":6105.81982422,"218":6049.60009766,"217":5951.12988281,"216":5836.93017578,"215":5778.85009766,"214":5711.02978516,"213":5594.02001953,"212":5461.25976563,"211":5352.47021484,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":5909.56005859,"217":5832.95996094,"216":5722.22021484,"215":5649.12011719,"214":5595.18994141,"213":5486.58007813,"212":5345.89013672,"211":4751.68017578,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":5648.31982422,"215":5563.06982422,"214":5476.64013672,"213":5365.95019531,"212":4763.79003906,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"256":{"214":10296.5,"213":10188.70019531,"212":10140.09960938,"211":9603.91015625,"210":9208.46972656,"209":9241.0,"208":9729.74023438,"207":9927.5,"206":null},"257":{"214":10365.70019531,"213":10380.59960938,"212":10356.79980469,"211":10004.29980469,"210":9876.13964844,"209":10534.5,"208":11024.59960938,"207":10983.29980469,"206":null},"258":{"214":10029.59960938,"213":9718.38964844,"212":9614.08007813,"211":9697.12011719,"210":9921.01953125,"209":10529.79980469,"208":10509.20019531,"207":10338.90039063,"206":10493.29980469},"259":{"214":9082.13964844,"213":9122.63964844,"212":8888.54003906,"211":8814.62988281,"210":9009.20019531,"209":9529.24023438,"208":9743.20996094,"207":9515.94042969,"206":9216.54980469},"260":{"214":8581.1796875,"213":8865.54003906,"212":8542.79003906,"211":8197.54003906,"210":8490.50976563,"209":9260.36035156,"208":10172.0,"207":9661.30957031,"206":8822.26953125},"261":{"214":8910.41015625,"213":9351.70019531,"212":8873.69042969,"211":8255.40039063,"210":8440.01953125,"209":9429.49023438,"208":10489.59960938,"207":9807.91015625,"206":8785.98046875},"262":{"214":9449.3203125,"213":10178.40039063,"212":10112.59960938,"211":9135.19042969,"210":8532.9296875,"209":8712.37988281,"208":8974.16992188,"207":8569.03027344,"206":8145.20996094},"263":{"214":9037.63964844,"213":9899.0,"212":10465.70019531,"211":10115.40039063,"210":9269.80957031,"209":8499.54980469,"208":8132.45996094,"207":7950.33007813,"206":8010.70019531},"264":{"214":8949.45996094,"213":9356.99023438,"212":9585.11035156,"211":9762.53027344,"210":10145.70019531,"209":9946.0,"208":9194.91015625,"207":8767.95019531,"206":8734.71972656}}
{"256":{"214":8822.75,"213":8719.90039063,"212":8678.6796875,"211":8205.76953125,"210":7878.04003906,"209":7914.72021484,"208":8346.45019531,"207":8549.3203125,"206":null},"257":{"214":8844.03027344,"213":8851.25,"212":8826.98046875,"211":8505.87011719,"210":8429.5703125,"209":9081.16015625,"208":9519.41015625,"207":9482.98046875,"206":null},"258":{"214":8533.94042969,"213":8257.58984375,"212":8161.89013672,"211":8222.28027344,"210":8428.83984375,"209":8999.95996094,"208":9032.12988281,"207":8892.54003906,"206":9031.98046875},"259":{"214":7780.97998047,"213":7789.64013672,"212":7597.64990234,"211":7536.60986328,"210":7694.31982422,"209":8098.41992188,"208":8272.91015625,"207":8091.58007813,"206":7871.50976563},"260":{"214":7370.79980469,"213":7592.37011719,"212":7351.20019531,"211":7080.60986328,"210":7271.08007813,"209":7881.60009766,"208":8639.71972656,"207":8251.36035156,"206":7547.81005859},"261":{"214":7640.02978516,"213":7994.00976563,"212":7617.60986328,"211":7117.02001953,"210":7243.74023438,"209":8027.52001953,"208":8923.71972656,"207":8385.00976563,"206":7538.29980469},"262":{"214":8073.27978516,"213":8676.62988281,"212":8636.8203125,"211":7833.12988281,"210":7315.20019531,"209":7446.64990234,"208":7674.87011719,"207":7397.33984375,"206":7072.97021484},"263":{"214":7729.35986328,"213":8412.19042969,"212":8891.51953125,"211":8612.12988281,"210":7896.52978516,"209":7293.25976563,"208":7037.97998047,"207":6901.08984375,"206":6917.04980469},"264":{"214":7653.25,"213":7953.75,"212":8113.10009766,"211":8257.11035156,"210":8620.51953125,"209":8488.55957031,"208":7876.97998047,"207":7498.37011719,"206":7465.00976563}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "heating degree", "location1": "Hartford, CT, United States", "location2": "Helena, MT, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Hartford, CT, United States or Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change in heating degree throughout historical period and mid-century period?
4fce1800-2144-4379-a812-8f9e9d769c9c
As a climate scientist attending a conference on regional temperature trends, I'm interested in knowing which city, Hartford, CT, or Helena, MT, has shown a greater variation in heating degree days when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1376/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) The Hartford, CT, United States experienced a greater change than Helena, MT, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change than Hartford, CT, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Hartford, CT, United States and Helena, MT, United States.']
['Hartford, CT, United States in historical period', 'Hartford, CT, United States in mid-century period', 'Helena, MT, United States in historical period', 'Helena, MT, United States in mid-century period']
{"509":{"219":null,"218":7936.24023438,"217":7919.91992188,"216":7748.35986328,"215":7528.60986328,"214":7441.62988281,"213":7284.43994141,"212":7035.41992188,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":7509.99023438,"217":7595.45996094,"216":7567.18017578,"215":7443.75,"214":7372.50976563,"213":7236.41992188,"212":6981.75,"211":6763.58984375,"210":6685.31005859},"511":{"219":7140.56005859,"218":7128.22021484,"217":7126.52978516,"216":7135.24023438,"215":7089.54003906,"214":7053.37011719,"213":7017.68994141,"212":6871.27001953,"211":6687.10009766,"210":6601.58007813},"512":{"219":7002.56982422,"218":6776.5,"217":6815.83984375,"216":6794.97021484,"215":6783.29003906,"214":6775.91992188,"213":6775.66015625,"212":6713.91015625,"211":6608.41015625,"210":6494.97021484},"513":{"219":7032.06982422,"218":6731.52001953,"217":6652.04980469,"216":6662.54003906,"215":6538.41992188,"214":6481.79980469,"213":6591.60986328,"212":6559.08984375,"211":6482.22021484,"210":6329.83007813},"514":{"219":7121.58007813,"218":7027.56982422,"217":6875.64990234,"216":6730.81005859,"215":6629.37988281,"214":6538.18017578,"213":6522.62988281,"212":6503.41015625,"211":6356.54003906,"210":6204.16015625},"515":{"219":7180.95019531,"218":7142.97021484,"217":6963.47998047,"216":6805.72998047,"215":6721.29980469,"214":6606.45996094,"213":6509.56982422,"212":6418.54980469,"211":6260.14013672,"210":5546.68017578},"516":{"219":7060.75,"218":6990.43994141,"217":6874.5,"216":6726.47998047,"215":6651.0,"214":6579.18994141,"213":6437.81982422,"212":6266.89990234,"211":6146.04003906,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":6814.33984375,"217":6725.54980469,"216":6586.06982422,"215":6488.25,"214":6430.00976563,"213":6305.72021484,"212":6143.93017578,"211":5474.14013672,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":6497.83007813,"215":6393.79980469,"214":6293.66015625,"213":6174.14013672,"212":5494.14990234,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"509":{"219":null,"218":6786.66015625,"217":6762.91015625,"216":6611.39990234,"215":6436.97021484,"214":6365.37011719,"213":6240.89013672,"212":6049.54980469,"211":null,"210":null},"510":{"219":null,"218":6470.27978516,"217":6530.02001953,"216":6497.04003906,"215":6388.43994141,"214":6324.58007813,"213":6210.20996094,"212":6009.81005859,"211":5847.60009766,"210":5795.14013672},"511":{"219":6173.50976563,"218":6169.06982422,"217":6170.81982422,"216":6174.08984375,"215":6131.27978516,"214":6095.12011719,"213":6054.72021484,"212":5933.85009766,"211":5790.56982422,"210":5728.22998047},"512":{"219":6061.87011719,"218":5996.10009766,"217":5935.85986328,"216":5919.81982422,"215":5904.68994141,"214":5889.72998047,"213":5878.12988281,"212":5820.66992188,"211":5732.79980469,"210":5642.87988281},"513":{"219":6084.49023438,"218":5960.85986328,"217":5854.33007813,"216":5819.14013672,"215":5808.25,"214":5747.56982422,"213":5736.54980469,"212":5705.37988281,"211":5635.77001953,"210":5520.39990234},"514":{"219":6149.93994141,"218":6074.81982422,"217":5959.20996094,"216":5850.56005859,"215":5773.06982422,"214":5698.93994141,"213":5675.87988281,"212":5649.72021484,"211":5535.39013672,"210":5410.58007813},"515":{"219":6198.79003906,"218":6163.50976563,"217":6021.04003906,"216":5900.02001953,"215":5834.08984375,"214":5737.77978516,"213":5656.27978516,"212":5579.16015625,"211":5446.77001953,"210":4823.66992188},"516":{"219":6105.81982422,"218":6049.60009766,"217":5951.12988281,"216":5836.93017578,"215":5778.85009766,"214":5711.02978516,"213":5594.02001953,"212":5461.25976563,"211":5352.47021484,"210":null},"517":{"219":null,"218":5909.56005859,"217":5832.95996094,"216":5722.22021484,"215":5649.12011719,"214":5595.18994141,"213":5486.58007813,"212":5345.89013672,"211":4751.68017578,"210":null},"518":{"219":null,"218":null,"217":null,"216":5648.31982422,"215":5563.06982422,"214":5476.64013672,"213":5365.95019531,"212":4763.79003906,"211":null,"210":null}}
{"256":{"214":10296.5,"213":10188.70019531,"212":10140.09960938,"211":9603.91015625,"210":9208.46972656,"209":9241.0,"208":9729.74023438,"207":9927.5,"206":null},"257":{"214":10365.70019531,"213":10380.59960938,"212":10356.79980469,"211":10004.29980469,"210":9876.13964844,"209":10534.5,"208":11024.59960938,"207":10983.29980469,"206":null},"258":{"214":10029.59960938,"213":9718.38964844,"212":9614.08007813,"211":9697.12011719,"210":9921.01953125,"209":10529.79980469,"208":10509.20019531,"207":10338.90039063,"206":10493.29980469},"259":{"214":9082.13964844,"213":9122.63964844,"212":8888.54003906,"211":8814.62988281,"210":9009.20019531,"209":9529.24023438,"208":9743.20996094,"207":9515.94042969,"206":9216.54980469},"260":{"214":8581.1796875,"213":8865.54003906,"212":8542.79003906,"211":8197.54003906,"210":8490.50976563,"209":9260.36035156,"208":10172.0,"207":9661.30957031,"206":8822.26953125},"261":{"214":8910.41015625,"213":9351.70019531,"212":8873.69042969,"211":8255.40039063,"210":8440.01953125,"209":9429.49023438,"208":10489.59960938,"207":9807.91015625,"206":8785.98046875},"262":{"214":9449.3203125,"213":10178.40039063,"212":10112.59960938,"211":9135.19042969,"210":8532.9296875,"209":8712.37988281,"208":8974.16992188,"207":8569.03027344,"206":8145.20996094},"263":{"214":9037.63964844,"213":9899.0,"212":10465.70019531,"211":10115.40039063,"210":9269.80957031,"209":8499.54980469,"208":8132.45996094,"207":7950.33007813,"206":8010.70019531},"264":{"214":8949.45996094,"213":9356.99023438,"212":9585.11035156,"211":9762.53027344,"210":10145.70019531,"209":9946.0,"208":9194.91015625,"207":8767.95019531,"206":8734.71972656}}
{"256":{"214":8822.75,"213":8719.90039063,"212":8678.6796875,"211":8205.76953125,"210":7878.04003906,"209":7914.72021484,"208":8346.45019531,"207":8549.3203125,"206":null},"257":{"214":8844.03027344,"213":8851.25,"212":8826.98046875,"211":8505.87011719,"210":8429.5703125,"209":9081.16015625,"208":9519.41015625,"207":9482.98046875,"206":null},"258":{"214":8533.94042969,"213":8257.58984375,"212":8161.89013672,"211":8222.28027344,"210":8428.83984375,"209":8999.95996094,"208":9032.12988281,"207":8892.54003906,"206":9031.98046875},"259":{"214":7780.97998047,"213":7789.64013672,"212":7597.64990234,"211":7536.60986328,"210":7694.31982422,"209":8098.41992188,"208":8272.91015625,"207":8091.58007813,"206":7871.50976563},"260":{"214":7370.79980469,"213":7592.37011719,"212":7351.20019531,"211":7080.60986328,"210":7271.08007813,"209":7881.60009766,"208":8639.71972656,"207":8251.36035156,"206":7547.81005859},"261":{"214":7640.02978516,"213":7994.00976563,"212":7617.60986328,"211":7117.02001953,"210":7243.74023438,"209":8027.52001953,"208":8923.71972656,"207":8385.00976563,"206":7538.29980469},"262":{"214":8073.27978516,"213":8676.62988281,"212":8636.8203125,"211":7833.12988281,"210":7315.20019531,"209":7446.64990234,"208":7674.87011719,"207":7397.33984375,"206":7072.97021484},"263":{"214":7729.35986328,"213":8412.19042969,"212":8891.51953125,"211":8612.12988281,"210":7896.52978516,"209":7293.25976563,"208":7037.97998047,"207":6901.08984375,"206":6917.04980469},"264":{"214":7653.25,"213":7953.75,"212":8113.10009766,"211":8257.11035156,"210":8620.51953125,"209":8488.55957031,"208":7876.97998047,"207":7498.37011719,"206":7465.00976563}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "heating degree", "location1": "Hartford, CT, United States", "location2": "Helena, MT, United States", "time_frame1": "historical period", "time_frame2": "mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Hartford, CT, United States or Helena, MT, United States experienced a greater change in heating degree throughout historical period and mid-century period?
9637ce2a-802e-4f4e-9a63-450f258583a7
As a city planner in New Orleans working on a sustainability report, I'm trying to determine which city has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation from the mid-century period (RCP4.5) to the end-century period (RCP8.5): New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC?
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.39609909,"77":53.41450119,"76":55.85250092,"75":59.22100067,"74":60.81090164,"73":57.24219894,"72":55.33539963,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":53.12519836,"77":55.5489006,"76":59.4090004,"75":64.80580139,"74":64.83380127,"73":59.24900055,"72":57.41930008,"71":57.08580017,"70":57.45949936,"69":58.17789841,"68":61.11330032},"422":{"79":null,"78":53.40420151,"77":58.13119888,"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":58.53269958,"69":59.0318985,"68":62.89860153},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.25790024,"77":61.54729843,"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189,"69":63.9836998,"68":68.60679626},"424":{"79":null,"78":55.88479996,"77":64.85250092,"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145,"69":70.06420135,"68":78.13500214},"425":{"79":53.71519852,"78":57.88479996,"77":65.29119873,"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875,"69":73.01860046,"68":81.66819763},"426":{"79":53.50419998,"78":58.7655983,"77":65.12809753,"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076,"69":77.08550262,"68":73.25389862},"427":{"79":53.79520035,"78":59.32939911,"77":64.18689728,"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965,"69":77.3526001,"68":68.38629913},"428":{"79":54.14970016,"78":60.96220016,"77":68.57279968,"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266,"69":74.1359024,"68":null},"429":{"79":56.34329987,"78":62.96310043,"77":74.5019989,"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":81.27449799,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365,"69":70.57360077,"68":null},"430":{"79":59.94779968,"78":69.64880371,"77":88.28320313,"76":104.15200043,"75":92.30960083,"74":80.87580109,"73":77.44380188,"72":75.5401001,"71":74.44860077,"70":73.17620087,"69":71.01799774,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.30480194,"74":80.9210968,"73":76.90709686,"72":75.22389984,"71":73.73629761,"70":72.52629852,"69":70.50740051,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":42.28310013,"181":41.42570114,"180":39.73830032,"179":39.20140076,"178":39.06919861,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":40.1529007,"182":40.01169968,"181":39.54940033,"180":39.31919861,"179":39.36059952,"178":39.29779816,"177":38.89889908,"176":39.40039825,"175":39.91360092},"493":{"184":null,"183":38.58779907,"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":39.7254982,"175":39.69300079},"494":{"184":39.25400162,"183":38.81489944,"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954,"175":39.06969833},"495":{"184":40.0340004,"183":39.87360001,"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082,"175":40.80939865},"496":{"184":41.08869934,"183":42.43130112,"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997,"175":40.51210022},"497":{"184":43.88800049,"183":45.57550049,"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006,"175":41.59260178},"498":{"184":45.61090088,"183":46.93080139,"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":41.11740112,"175":42.52019882},"499":{"184":45.50080109,"183":54.87540054,"182":50.55369949,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":41.96789932,"175":41.73410034},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":48.81620026,"180":48.77619934,"179":48.35800171,"178":51.59980011,"177":43.06880188,"176":42.41790009,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
dc4675f7-4c1b-44c7-ba92-eed2f0a0ee14
As a city planner in New Orleans working on a sustainability report, I'm trying to determine which city has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation from the mid-century period (RCP4.5) to the end-century period (RCP8.5): New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.39609909,"77":53.41450119,"76":55.85250092,"75":59.22100067,"74":60.81090164,"73":57.24219894,"72":55.33539963,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":53.12519836,"77":55.5489006,"76":59.4090004,"75":64.80580139,"74":64.83380127,"73":59.24900055,"72":57.41930008,"71":57.08580017,"70":57.45949936,"69":58.17789841,"68":61.11330032},"422":{"79":null,"78":53.40420151,"77":58.13119888,"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":58.53269958,"69":59.0318985,"68":62.89860153},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.25790024,"77":61.54729843,"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189,"69":63.9836998,"68":68.60679626},"424":{"79":null,"78":55.88479996,"77":64.85250092,"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145,"69":70.06420135,"68":78.13500214},"425":{"79":53.71519852,"78":57.88479996,"77":65.29119873,"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875,"69":73.01860046,"68":81.66819763},"426":{"79":53.50419998,"78":58.7655983,"77":65.12809753,"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076,"69":77.08550262,"68":73.25389862},"427":{"79":53.79520035,"78":59.32939911,"77":64.18689728,"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965,"69":77.3526001,"68":68.38629913},"428":{"79":54.14970016,"78":60.96220016,"77":68.57279968,"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266,"69":74.1359024,"68":null},"429":{"79":56.34329987,"78":62.96310043,"77":74.5019989,"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":81.27449799,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365,"69":70.57360077,"68":null},"430":{"79":59.94779968,"78":69.64880371,"77":88.28320313,"76":104.15200043,"75":92.30960083,"74":80.87580109,"73":77.44380188,"72":75.5401001,"71":74.44860077,"70":73.17620087,"69":71.01799774,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.30480194,"74":80.9210968,"73":76.90709686,"72":75.22389984,"71":73.73629761,"70":72.52629852,"69":70.50740051,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":42.28310013,"181":41.42570114,"180":39.73830032,"179":39.20140076,"178":39.06919861,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":40.1529007,"182":40.01169968,"181":39.54940033,"180":39.31919861,"179":39.36059952,"178":39.29779816,"177":38.89889908,"176":39.40039825,"175":39.91360092},"493":{"184":null,"183":38.58779907,"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":39.7254982,"175":39.69300079},"494":{"184":39.25400162,"183":38.81489944,"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954,"175":39.06969833},"495":{"184":40.0340004,"183":39.87360001,"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082,"175":40.80939865},"496":{"184":41.08869934,"183":42.43130112,"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997,"175":40.51210022},"497":{"184":43.88800049,"183":45.57550049,"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006,"175":41.59260178},"498":{"184":45.61090088,"183":46.93080139,"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":41.11740112,"175":42.52019882},"499":{"184":45.50080109,"183":54.87540054,"182":50.55369949,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":41.96789932,"175":41.73410034},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":48.81620026,"180":48.77619934,"179":48.35800171,"178":51.59980011,"177":43.06880188,"176":42.41790009,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
6e847523-fdd9-478e-a616-024c3845d38f
As a city planner in New Orleans working on a sustainability report, I'm trying to determine which city has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation from the mid-century period (RCP4.5) to the end-century period (RCP8.5): New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.39609909,"77":53.41450119,"76":55.85250092,"75":59.22100067,"74":60.81090164,"73":57.24219894,"72":55.33539963,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":53.12519836,"77":55.5489006,"76":59.4090004,"75":64.80580139,"74":64.83380127,"73":59.24900055,"72":57.41930008,"71":57.08580017,"70":57.45949936,"69":58.17789841,"68":61.11330032},"422":{"79":null,"78":53.40420151,"77":58.13119888,"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":58.53269958,"69":59.0318985,"68":62.89860153},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.25790024,"77":61.54729843,"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189,"69":63.9836998,"68":68.60679626},"424":{"79":null,"78":55.88479996,"77":64.85250092,"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145,"69":70.06420135,"68":78.13500214},"425":{"79":53.71519852,"78":57.88479996,"77":65.29119873,"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875,"69":73.01860046,"68":81.66819763},"426":{"79":53.50419998,"78":58.7655983,"77":65.12809753,"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076,"69":77.08550262,"68":73.25389862},"427":{"79":53.79520035,"78":59.32939911,"77":64.18689728,"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965,"69":77.3526001,"68":68.38629913},"428":{"79":54.14970016,"78":60.96220016,"77":68.57279968,"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266,"69":74.1359024,"68":null},"429":{"79":56.34329987,"78":62.96310043,"77":74.5019989,"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":81.27449799,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365,"69":70.57360077,"68":null},"430":{"79":59.94779968,"78":69.64880371,"77":88.28320313,"76":104.15200043,"75":92.30960083,"74":80.87580109,"73":77.44380188,"72":75.5401001,"71":74.44860077,"70":73.17620087,"69":71.01799774,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.30480194,"74":80.9210968,"73":76.90709686,"72":75.22389984,"71":73.73629761,"70":72.52629852,"69":70.50740051,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":42.28310013,"181":41.42570114,"180":39.73830032,"179":39.20140076,"178":39.06919861,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":40.1529007,"182":40.01169968,"181":39.54940033,"180":39.31919861,"179":39.36059952,"178":39.29779816,"177":38.89889908,"176":39.40039825,"175":39.91360092},"493":{"184":null,"183":38.58779907,"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":39.7254982,"175":39.69300079},"494":{"184":39.25400162,"183":38.81489944,"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954,"175":39.06969833},"495":{"184":40.0340004,"183":39.87360001,"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082,"175":40.80939865},"496":{"184":41.08869934,"183":42.43130112,"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997,"175":40.51210022},"497":{"184":43.88800049,"183":45.57550049,"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006,"175":41.59260178},"498":{"184":45.61090088,"183":46.93080139,"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":41.11740112,"175":42.52019882},"499":{"184":45.50080109,"183":54.87540054,"182":50.55369949,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":41.96789932,"175":41.73410034},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":48.81620026,"180":48.77619934,"179":48.35800171,"178":51.59980011,"177":43.06880188,"176":42.41790009,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
cd83d21b-760c-4a0e-aabd-3c611bfe87ae
As a city planner in New Orleans working on a sustainability report, I'm trying to determine which city has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation from the mid-century period (RCP4.5) to the end-century period (RCP8.5): New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.39609909,"77":53.41450119,"76":55.85250092,"75":59.22100067,"74":60.81090164,"73":57.24219894,"72":55.33539963,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":53.12519836,"77":55.5489006,"76":59.4090004,"75":64.80580139,"74":64.83380127,"73":59.24900055,"72":57.41930008,"71":57.08580017,"70":57.45949936,"69":58.17789841,"68":61.11330032},"422":{"79":null,"78":53.40420151,"77":58.13119888,"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":58.53269958,"69":59.0318985,"68":62.89860153},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.25790024,"77":61.54729843,"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189,"69":63.9836998,"68":68.60679626},"424":{"79":null,"78":55.88479996,"77":64.85250092,"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145,"69":70.06420135,"68":78.13500214},"425":{"79":53.71519852,"78":57.88479996,"77":65.29119873,"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875,"69":73.01860046,"68":81.66819763},"426":{"79":53.50419998,"78":58.7655983,"77":65.12809753,"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076,"69":77.08550262,"68":73.25389862},"427":{"79":53.79520035,"78":59.32939911,"77":64.18689728,"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965,"69":77.3526001,"68":68.38629913},"428":{"79":54.14970016,"78":60.96220016,"77":68.57279968,"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266,"69":74.1359024,"68":null},"429":{"79":56.34329987,"78":62.96310043,"77":74.5019989,"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":81.27449799,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365,"69":70.57360077,"68":null},"430":{"79":59.94779968,"78":69.64880371,"77":88.28320313,"76":104.15200043,"75":92.30960083,"74":80.87580109,"73":77.44380188,"72":75.5401001,"71":74.44860077,"70":73.17620087,"69":71.01799774,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.30480194,"74":80.9210968,"73":76.90709686,"72":75.22389984,"71":73.73629761,"70":72.52629852,"69":70.50740051,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":42.28310013,"181":41.42570114,"180":39.73830032,"179":39.20140076,"178":39.06919861,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":40.1529007,"182":40.01169968,"181":39.54940033,"180":39.31919861,"179":39.36059952,"178":39.29779816,"177":38.89889908,"176":39.40039825,"175":39.91360092},"493":{"184":null,"183":38.58779907,"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":39.7254982,"175":39.69300079},"494":{"184":39.25400162,"183":38.81489944,"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954,"175":39.06969833},"495":{"184":40.0340004,"183":39.87360001,"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082,"175":40.80939865},"496":{"184":41.08869934,"183":42.43130112,"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997,"175":40.51210022},"497":{"184":43.88800049,"183":45.57550049,"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006,"175":41.59260178},"498":{"184":45.61090088,"183":46.93080139,"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":41.11740112,"175":42.52019882},"499":{"184":45.50080109,"183":54.87540054,"182":50.55369949,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":41.96789932,"175":41.73410034},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":48.81620026,"180":48.77619934,"179":48.35800171,"178":51.59980011,"177":43.06880188,"176":42.41790009,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
3b5a8c62-b060-48d8-baf7-e5bc2666c85d
As a climate scientist analyzing long-term temperature trends, I'm interested in determining which city has experienced a more significant increase in maximum annual temperature during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario: Fort Myers, FL, or Tampa, FL?
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":82.67359924,"64":82.5161972,"63":82.14219666,"62":81.04910278,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":82.81549835,"65":82.790802,"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":82.90779877,"65":82.99459839,"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"66":83.09500122,"65":83.21890259,"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"66":83.17279816,"65":83.31819916,"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"66":83.29579926,"65":83.38680267,"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"66":83.27259827,"65":83.46779633,"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"66":83.34580231,"65":83.55770111,"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"66":83.43689728,"65":83.63760376,"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145},"503":{"66":83.48280334,"65":83.69229889,"64":83.87169647,"63":84.04650116,"62":84.15720367,"61":84.20300293,"60":84.26119995,"59":84.26049805},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":83.7460022,"63":83.97239685,"62":84.12129974,"61":84.19129944,"60":84.36309814,"59":84.44319916}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":79.0089035,"75":77.88189697,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":80.01689911,"75":80.21379852,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":80.32009888,"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071,"67":null},"490":{"77":80.61049652,"76":80.62319946,"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785,"67":79.02020264},"491":{"77":80.92199707,"76":80.97779846,"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153,"67":81.92590332},"492":{"77":81.10299683,"76":81.24639893,"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949,"67":82.24230194},"493":{"77":81.14880371,"76":81.41200256,"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792,"67":82.3884964},"494":{"77":81.25119781,"76":81.5177002,"75":81.63349915,"74":81.77110291,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646,"67":82.56069946},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.71679688,"74":81.86389923,"73":82.05599976,"72":82.18190002,"71":82.27799988,"70":82.35220337,"69":82.43640137,"68":82.60579681,"67":82.73889923},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":82.33280182,"71":82.39700317,"70":82.52400208,"69":82.66030121,"68":82.81289673,"67":82.9088974}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
10c2a122-7eb4-4fa6-8370-8ea78969978f
As a climate scientist analyzing long-term temperature trends, I'm interested in determining which city has experienced a more significant increase in maximum annual temperature during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario: Fort Myers, FL, or Tampa, FL?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1258/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":82.67359924,"64":82.5161972,"63":82.14219666,"62":81.04910278,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":82.81549835,"65":82.790802,"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":82.90779877,"65":82.99459839,"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"66":83.09500122,"65":83.21890259,"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"66":83.17279816,"65":83.31819916,"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"66":83.29579926,"65":83.38680267,"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"66":83.27259827,"65":83.46779633,"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"66":83.34580231,"65":83.55770111,"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"66":83.43689728,"65":83.63760376,"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145},"503":{"66":83.48280334,"65":83.69229889,"64":83.87169647,"63":84.04650116,"62":84.15720367,"61":84.20300293,"60":84.26119995,"59":84.26049805},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":83.7460022,"63":83.97239685,"62":84.12129974,"61":84.19129944,"60":84.36309814,"59":84.44319916}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":79.0089035,"75":77.88189697,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":80.01689911,"75":80.21379852,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":80.32009888,"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071,"67":null},"490":{"77":80.61049652,"76":80.62319946,"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785,"67":79.02020264},"491":{"77":80.92199707,"76":80.97779846,"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153,"67":81.92590332},"492":{"77":81.10299683,"76":81.24639893,"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949,"67":82.24230194},"493":{"77":81.14880371,"76":81.41200256,"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792,"67":82.3884964},"494":{"77":81.25119781,"76":81.5177002,"75":81.63349915,"74":81.77110291,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646,"67":82.56069946},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.71679688,"74":81.86389923,"73":82.05599976,"72":82.18190002,"71":82.27799988,"70":82.35220337,"69":82.43640137,"68":82.60579681,"67":82.73889923},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":82.33280182,"71":82.39700317,"70":82.52400208,"69":82.66030121,"68":82.81289673,"67":82.9088974}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
424446a1-3972-467c-918b-0db4c5c2d8a4
As a climate scientist analyzing long-term temperature trends, I'm interested in determining which city has experienced a more significant increase in maximum annual temperature during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario: Fort Myers, FL, or Tampa, FL?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1258/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":82.67359924,"64":82.5161972,"63":82.14219666,"62":81.04910278,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":82.81549835,"65":82.790802,"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":82.90779877,"65":82.99459839,"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"66":83.09500122,"65":83.21890259,"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"66":83.17279816,"65":83.31819916,"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"66":83.29579926,"65":83.38680267,"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"66":83.27259827,"65":83.46779633,"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"66":83.34580231,"65":83.55770111,"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"66":83.43689728,"65":83.63760376,"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145},"503":{"66":83.48280334,"65":83.69229889,"64":83.87169647,"63":84.04650116,"62":84.15720367,"61":84.20300293,"60":84.26119995,"59":84.26049805},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":83.7460022,"63":83.97239685,"62":84.12129974,"61":84.19129944,"60":84.36309814,"59":84.44319916}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":79.0089035,"75":77.88189697,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":80.01689911,"75":80.21379852,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":80.32009888,"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071,"67":null},"490":{"77":80.61049652,"76":80.62319946,"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785,"67":79.02020264},"491":{"77":80.92199707,"76":80.97779846,"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153,"67":81.92590332},"492":{"77":81.10299683,"76":81.24639893,"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949,"67":82.24230194},"493":{"77":81.14880371,"76":81.41200256,"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792,"67":82.3884964},"494":{"77":81.25119781,"76":81.5177002,"75":81.63349915,"74":81.77110291,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646,"67":82.56069946},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.71679688,"74":81.86389923,"73":82.05599976,"72":82.18190002,"71":82.27799988,"70":82.35220337,"69":82.43640137,"68":82.60579681,"67":82.73889923},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":82.33280182,"71":82.39700317,"70":82.52400208,"69":82.66030121,"68":82.81289673,"67":82.9088974}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
4825ba35-23ff-406e-ab89-8788af546554
As a climate scientist analyzing long-term temperature trends, I'm interested in determining which city has experienced a more significant increase in maximum annual temperature during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP8.5 scenario: Fort Myers, FL, or Tampa, FL?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1258/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":82.67359924,"64":82.5161972,"63":82.14219666,"62":81.04910278,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":82.81549835,"65":82.790802,"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":82.90779877,"65":82.99459839,"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"66":83.09500122,"65":83.21890259,"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"66":83.17279816,"65":83.31819916,"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"66":83.29579926,"65":83.38680267,"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"66":83.27259827,"65":83.46779633,"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"66":83.34580231,"65":83.55770111,"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"66":83.43689728,"65":83.63760376,"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145},"503":{"66":83.48280334,"65":83.69229889,"64":83.87169647,"63":84.04650116,"62":84.15720367,"61":84.20300293,"60":84.26119995,"59":84.26049805},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":83.7460022,"63":83.97239685,"62":84.12129974,"61":84.19129944,"60":84.36309814,"59":84.44319916}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":79.0089035,"75":77.88189697,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":80.01689911,"75":80.21379852,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":80.32009888,"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071,"67":null},"490":{"77":80.61049652,"76":80.62319946,"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785,"67":79.02020264},"491":{"77":80.92199707,"76":80.97779846,"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153,"67":81.92590332},"492":{"77":81.10299683,"76":81.24639893,"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949,"67":82.24230194},"493":{"77":81.14880371,"76":81.41200256,"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792,"67":82.3884964},"494":{"77":81.25119781,"76":81.5177002,"75":81.63349915,"74":81.77110291,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646,"67":82.56069946},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.71679688,"74":81.86389923,"73":82.05599976,"72":82.18190002,"71":82.27799988,"70":82.35220337,"69":82.43640137,"68":82.60579681,"67":82.73889923},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":82.33280182,"71":82.39700317,"70":82.52400208,"69":82.66030121,"68":82.81289673,"67":82.9088974}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
557f47fb-5240-45b1-9e18-4e6c253a00ff
As a meteorologist analyzing temperature trends for a report on regional climate patterns, I'm curious to know which city, Bakersfield, CA, or Brownsville, TX, has shown a greater variation in maximum annual temperature from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP4.5.
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(b) Bakersfield, CA, United States experienced a greater change than Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(c) The Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Bakersfield, CA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Bakersfield, CA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Bakersfield, CA, United States in historical period', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in historical period']
{"199":{"119":80.94689941,"118":81.06710052,"117":81.33309937,"116":81.13259888,"115":80.57150269,"114":80.49089813,"113":78.90149689,"112":73.53630066},"200":{"119":80.85520172,"118":81.01920319,"117":81.20089722,"116":81.39499664,"115":81.69950104,"114":82.23500061,"113":81.67430115,"112":75.37460327},"201":{"119":80.81400299,"118":80.78250122,"117":80.91329956,"116":81.32250214,"115":81.92379761,"114":82.61969757,"113":82.25260162,"112":77.32779694},"202":{"119":80.47180176,"118":80.0625,"117":80.09290314,"116":80.73889923,"115":82.08270264,"114":82.66770172,"113":82.87760162,"112":79.95629883},"203":{"119":null,"118":77.37680054,"117":76.99459839,"116":78.35269928,"115":80.30509949,"114":81.32440186,"113":80.57700348,"112":78.123703},"204":{"119":null,"118":72.11029816,"117":71.22889709,"116":72.68229675,"115":75.38780212,"114":76.36250305,"113":73.88739777,"112":69.78119659},"205":{"119":null,"118":65.56189728,"117":66.06559753,"116":67.07219696,"115":68.81909943,"114":70.50740051,"113":67.65070343,"112":63.33660126}}
{"199":{"119":76.98590088,"118":77.10050201,"117":77.38569641,"116":77.17839813,"115":76.57530212,"114":76.45659637,"113":74.78220367,"112":69.0759964},"200":{"119":76.83719635,"118":76.94539642,"117":77.11650085,"116":77.31800079,"115":77.56069946,"114":78.18859863,"113":77.626297,"112":71.06839752},"201":{"119":76.70410156,"118":76.65869904,"117":76.77539825,"116":77.15879822,"115":77.77510071,"114":78.45449829,"113":78.10099792,"112":73.0134964},"202":{"119":76.30560303,"118":75.83660126,"117":75.8003006,"116":76.4917984,"115":77.84940338,"114":78.42510223,"113":78.57009888,"112":75.55509949},"203":{"119":null,"118":72.98500061,"117":72.55979919,"116":73.92790222,"115":76.00900269,"114":76.95320129,"113":76.18900299,"112":73.6332016},"204":{"119":null,"118":67.62419891,"117":66.62519836,"116":68.08380127,"115":70.80709839,"114":71.83809662,"113":69.38089752,"112":65.39900208},"205":{"119":null,"118":60.9917984,"117":61.50880051,"116":62.64410019,"115":64.4571991,"114":66.19529724,"113":63.34769821,"112":58.96870041}}
{"367":{"29":84.24919891,"28":84.27960205,"27":84.34750366,"26":null},"368":{"29":83.93190002,"28":83.95189667,"27":84.02050018,"26":null},"369":{"29":83.50939941,"28":83.6427002,"27":83.64179993,"26":null},"370":{"29":82.84729767,"28":83.05349731,"27":83.11830139,"26":83.15650177},"371":{"29":82.02590179,"28":82.22000122,"27":82.72119904,"26":82.66110229},"372":{"29":80.58570099,"28":81.09629822,"27":82.04979706,"26":82.18229675},"373":{"29":78.01200104,"28":78.35959625,"27":81.14589691,"26":81.42140198},"374":{"29":78.07080078,"28":78.12190247,"27":78.30090332,"26":null}}
{"367":{"29":80.68900299,"28":80.72270203,"27":80.80560303,"26":null},"368":{"29":80.46060181,"28":80.45130157,"27":80.5585022,"26":null},"369":{"29":80.09410095,"28":80.20960236,"27":80.2492981,"26":null},"370":{"29":79.64420319,"28":79.77970123,"27":79.81330109,"26":79.95950317},"371":{"29":78.94400024,"28":79.08380127,"27":79.45600128,"26":79.46260071},"372":{"29":77.62509918,"28":78.1013031,"27":78.81939697,"26":78.96970367},"373":{"29":75.30370331,"28":75.60119629,"27":78.16190338,"26":78.30390167},"374":{"29":75.45220184,"28":75.49710083,"27":75.64199829,"26":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Bakersfield, CA, United States", "location2": "Brownsville, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bakersfield, CA, United States or Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and historical period?
b93c2e4b-ca64-4167-b6ef-6cae5a09e880
As a meteorologist analyzing temperature trends for a report on regional climate patterns, I'm curious to know which city, Bakersfield, CA, or Brownsville, TX, has shown a greater variation in maximum annual temperature from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP4.5.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1370/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(b) Bakersfield, CA, United States experienced a greater change than Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(c) The Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Bakersfield, CA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Bakersfield, CA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Bakersfield, CA, United States in historical period', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in historical period']
{"199":{"119":80.94689941,"118":81.06710052,"117":81.33309937,"116":81.13259888,"115":80.57150269,"114":80.49089813,"113":78.90149689,"112":73.53630066},"200":{"119":80.85520172,"118":81.01920319,"117":81.20089722,"116":81.39499664,"115":81.69950104,"114":82.23500061,"113":81.67430115,"112":75.37460327},"201":{"119":80.81400299,"118":80.78250122,"117":80.91329956,"116":81.32250214,"115":81.92379761,"114":82.61969757,"113":82.25260162,"112":77.32779694},"202":{"119":80.47180176,"118":80.0625,"117":80.09290314,"116":80.73889923,"115":82.08270264,"114":82.66770172,"113":82.87760162,"112":79.95629883},"203":{"119":null,"118":77.37680054,"117":76.99459839,"116":78.35269928,"115":80.30509949,"114":81.32440186,"113":80.57700348,"112":78.123703},"204":{"119":null,"118":72.11029816,"117":71.22889709,"116":72.68229675,"115":75.38780212,"114":76.36250305,"113":73.88739777,"112":69.78119659},"205":{"119":null,"118":65.56189728,"117":66.06559753,"116":67.07219696,"115":68.81909943,"114":70.50740051,"113":67.65070343,"112":63.33660126}}
{"199":{"119":76.98590088,"118":77.10050201,"117":77.38569641,"116":77.17839813,"115":76.57530212,"114":76.45659637,"113":74.78220367,"112":69.0759964},"200":{"119":76.83719635,"118":76.94539642,"117":77.11650085,"116":77.31800079,"115":77.56069946,"114":78.18859863,"113":77.626297,"112":71.06839752},"201":{"119":76.70410156,"118":76.65869904,"117":76.77539825,"116":77.15879822,"115":77.77510071,"114":78.45449829,"113":78.10099792,"112":73.0134964},"202":{"119":76.30560303,"118":75.83660126,"117":75.8003006,"116":76.4917984,"115":77.84940338,"114":78.42510223,"113":78.57009888,"112":75.55509949},"203":{"119":null,"118":72.98500061,"117":72.55979919,"116":73.92790222,"115":76.00900269,"114":76.95320129,"113":76.18900299,"112":73.6332016},"204":{"119":null,"118":67.62419891,"117":66.62519836,"116":68.08380127,"115":70.80709839,"114":71.83809662,"113":69.38089752,"112":65.39900208},"205":{"119":null,"118":60.9917984,"117":61.50880051,"116":62.64410019,"115":64.4571991,"114":66.19529724,"113":63.34769821,"112":58.96870041}}
{"367":{"29":84.24919891,"28":84.27960205,"27":84.34750366,"26":null},"368":{"29":83.93190002,"28":83.95189667,"27":84.02050018,"26":null},"369":{"29":83.50939941,"28":83.6427002,"27":83.64179993,"26":null},"370":{"29":82.84729767,"28":83.05349731,"27":83.11830139,"26":83.15650177},"371":{"29":82.02590179,"28":82.22000122,"27":82.72119904,"26":82.66110229},"372":{"29":80.58570099,"28":81.09629822,"27":82.04979706,"26":82.18229675},"373":{"29":78.01200104,"28":78.35959625,"27":81.14589691,"26":81.42140198},"374":{"29":78.07080078,"28":78.12190247,"27":78.30090332,"26":null}}
{"367":{"29":80.68900299,"28":80.72270203,"27":80.80560303,"26":null},"368":{"29":80.46060181,"28":80.45130157,"27":80.5585022,"26":null},"369":{"29":80.09410095,"28":80.20960236,"27":80.2492981,"26":null},"370":{"29":79.64420319,"28":79.77970123,"27":79.81330109,"26":79.95950317},"371":{"29":78.94400024,"28":79.08380127,"27":79.45600128,"26":79.46260071},"372":{"29":77.62509918,"28":78.1013031,"27":78.81939697,"26":78.96970367},"373":{"29":75.30370331,"28":75.60119629,"27":78.16190338,"26":78.30390167},"374":{"29":75.45220184,"28":75.49710083,"27":75.64199829,"26":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Bakersfield, CA, United States", "location2": "Brownsville, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bakersfield, CA, United States or Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and historical period?
5ad3d00e-b6cc-4828-b15b-30f8a921ab3b
As a meteorologist analyzing temperature trends for a report on regional climate patterns, I'm curious to know which city, Bakersfield, CA, or Brownsville, TX, has shown a greater variation in maximum annual temperature from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP4.5.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1370/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(b) Bakersfield, CA, United States experienced a greater change than Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(c) The Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Bakersfield, CA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Bakersfield, CA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Bakersfield, CA, United States in historical period', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in historical period']
{"199":{"119":80.94689941,"118":81.06710052,"117":81.33309937,"116":81.13259888,"115":80.57150269,"114":80.49089813,"113":78.90149689,"112":73.53630066},"200":{"119":80.85520172,"118":81.01920319,"117":81.20089722,"116":81.39499664,"115":81.69950104,"114":82.23500061,"113":81.67430115,"112":75.37460327},"201":{"119":80.81400299,"118":80.78250122,"117":80.91329956,"116":81.32250214,"115":81.92379761,"114":82.61969757,"113":82.25260162,"112":77.32779694},"202":{"119":80.47180176,"118":80.0625,"117":80.09290314,"116":80.73889923,"115":82.08270264,"114":82.66770172,"113":82.87760162,"112":79.95629883},"203":{"119":null,"118":77.37680054,"117":76.99459839,"116":78.35269928,"115":80.30509949,"114":81.32440186,"113":80.57700348,"112":78.123703},"204":{"119":null,"118":72.11029816,"117":71.22889709,"116":72.68229675,"115":75.38780212,"114":76.36250305,"113":73.88739777,"112":69.78119659},"205":{"119":null,"118":65.56189728,"117":66.06559753,"116":67.07219696,"115":68.81909943,"114":70.50740051,"113":67.65070343,"112":63.33660126}}
{"199":{"119":76.98590088,"118":77.10050201,"117":77.38569641,"116":77.17839813,"115":76.57530212,"114":76.45659637,"113":74.78220367,"112":69.0759964},"200":{"119":76.83719635,"118":76.94539642,"117":77.11650085,"116":77.31800079,"115":77.56069946,"114":78.18859863,"113":77.626297,"112":71.06839752},"201":{"119":76.70410156,"118":76.65869904,"117":76.77539825,"116":77.15879822,"115":77.77510071,"114":78.45449829,"113":78.10099792,"112":73.0134964},"202":{"119":76.30560303,"118":75.83660126,"117":75.8003006,"116":76.4917984,"115":77.84940338,"114":78.42510223,"113":78.57009888,"112":75.55509949},"203":{"119":null,"118":72.98500061,"117":72.55979919,"116":73.92790222,"115":76.00900269,"114":76.95320129,"113":76.18900299,"112":73.6332016},"204":{"119":null,"118":67.62419891,"117":66.62519836,"116":68.08380127,"115":70.80709839,"114":71.83809662,"113":69.38089752,"112":65.39900208},"205":{"119":null,"118":60.9917984,"117":61.50880051,"116":62.64410019,"115":64.4571991,"114":66.19529724,"113":63.34769821,"112":58.96870041}}
{"367":{"29":84.24919891,"28":84.27960205,"27":84.34750366,"26":null},"368":{"29":83.93190002,"28":83.95189667,"27":84.02050018,"26":null},"369":{"29":83.50939941,"28":83.6427002,"27":83.64179993,"26":null},"370":{"29":82.84729767,"28":83.05349731,"27":83.11830139,"26":83.15650177},"371":{"29":82.02590179,"28":82.22000122,"27":82.72119904,"26":82.66110229},"372":{"29":80.58570099,"28":81.09629822,"27":82.04979706,"26":82.18229675},"373":{"29":78.01200104,"28":78.35959625,"27":81.14589691,"26":81.42140198},"374":{"29":78.07080078,"28":78.12190247,"27":78.30090332,"26":null}}
{"367":{"29":80.68900299,"28":80.72270203,"27":80.80560303,"26":null},"368":{"29":80.46060181,"28":80.45130157,"27":80.5585022,"26":null},"369":{"29":80.09410095,"28":80.20960236,"27":80.2492981,"26":null},"370":{"29":79.64420319,"28":79.77970123,"27":79.81330109,"26":79.95950317},"371":{"29":78.94400024,"28":79.08380127,"27":79.45600128,"26":79.46260071},"372":{"29":77.62509918,"28":78.1013031,"27":78.81939697,"26":78.96970367},"373":{"29":75.30370331,"28":75.60119629,"27":78.16190338,"26":78.30390167},"374":{"29":75.45220184,"28":75.49710083,"27":75.64199829,"26":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Bakersfield, CA, United States", "location2": "Brownsville, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bakersfield, CA, United States or Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and historical period?