Datasets:
bowen-upenn
/
GeoGrid_Bench

Dataset card Data Studio Files
xet
Community
1
Question ID
stringlengths
36
36
Question
stringlengths
147
367
Type
stringclasses
7 values
data_modality
stringclasses
4 values
image_path
stringlengths
58
77
⌀
Radius
int64
48
72
Correct Answer
stringclasses
4 values
All Options
stringlengths
165
1.21k
Data Titles
stringclasses
256 values
Data 1
stringclasses
560 values
Data 2
stringclasses
514 values
Data 3
stringclasses
294 values
Data 4
stringclasses
305 values
Data 5
stringclasses
87 values
Data 6
stringclasses
87 values
Data 7
stringclasses
87 values
Data 8
stringclasses
87 values
Filled Values
stringclasses
544 values
Template Question
stringclasses
8 values
Filled Template Question
stringclasses
563 values
d85ba1d6-f67d-426f-b992-b7ce1ad2f0f3
As a meteorologist analyzing temperature trends for a report on regional climate patterns, I'm curious to know which city, Bakersfield, CA, or Brownsville, TX, has shown a greater variation in maximum annual temperature from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP4.5.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1370/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(b) Bakersfield, CA, United States experienced a greater change than Brownsville, TX, United States.', '(c) The Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Bakersfield, CA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Bakersfield, CA, United States and Brownsville, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Bakersfield, CA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Bakersfield, CA, United States in historical period', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Brownsville, TX, United States in historical period']
{"199":{"119":80.94689941,"118":81.06710052,"117":81.33309937,"116":81.13259888,"115":80.57150269,"114":80.49089813,"113":78.90149689,"112":73.53630066},"200":{"119":80.85520172,"118":81.01920319,"117":81.20089722,"116":81.39499664,"115":81.69950104,"114":82.23500061,"113":81.67430115,"112":75.37460327},"201":{"119":80.81400299,"118":80.78250122,"117":80.91329956,"116":81.32250214,"115":81.92379761,"114":82.61969757,"113":82.25260162,"112":77.32779694},"202":{"119":80.47180176,"118":80.0625,"117":80.09290314,"116":80.73889923,"115":82.08270264,"114":82.66770172,"113":82.87760162,"112":79.95629883},"203":{"119":null,"118":77.37680054,"117":76.99459839,"116":78.35269928,"115":80.30509949,"114":81.32440186,"113":80.57700348,"112":78.123703},"204":{"119":null,"118":72.11029816,"117":71.22889709,"116":72.68229675,"115":75.38780212,"114":76.36250305,"113":73.88739777,"112":69.78119659},"205":{"119":null,"118":65.56189728,"117":66.06559753,"116":67.07219696,"115":68.81909943,"114":70.50740051,"113":67.65070343,"112":63.33660126}}
{"199":{"119":76.98590088,"118":77.10050201,"117":77.38569641,"116":77.17839813,"115":76.57530212,"114":76.45659637,"113":74.78220367,"112":69.0759964},"200":{"119":76.83719635,"118":76.94539642,"117":77.11650085,"116":77.31800079,"115":77.56069946,"114":78.18859863,"113":77.626297,"112":71.06839752},"201":{"119":76.70410156,"118":76.65869904,"117":76.77539825,"116":77.15879822,"115":77.77510071,"114":78.45449829,"113":78.10099792,"112":73.0134964},"202":{"119":76.30560303,"118":75.83660126,"117":75.8003006,"116":76.4917984,"115":77.84940338,"114":78.42510223,"113":78.57009888,"112":75.55509949},"203":{"119":null,"118":72.98500061,"117":72.55979919,"116":73.92790222,"115":76.00900269,"114":76.95320129,"113":76.18900299,"112":73.6332016},"204":{"119":null,"118":67.62419891,"117":66.62519836,"116":68.08380127,"115":70.80709839,"114":71.83809662,"113":69.38089752,"112":65.39900208},"205":{"119":null,"118":60.9917984,"117":61.50880051,"116":62.64410019,"115":64.4571991,"114":66.19529724,"113":63.34769821,"112":58.96870041}}
{"367":{"29":84.24919891,"28":84.27960205,"27":84.34750366,"26":null},"368":{"29":83.93190002,"28":83.95189667,"27":84.02050018,"26":null},"369":{"29":83.50939941,"28":83.6427002,"27":83.64179993,"26":null},"370":{"29":82.84729767,"28":83.05349731,"27":83.11830139,"26":83.15650177},"371":{"29":82.02590179,"28":82.22000122,"27":82.72119904,"26":82.66110229},"372":{"29":80.58570099,"28":81.09629822,"27":82.04979706,"26":82.18229675},"373":{"29":78.01200104,"28":78.35959625,"27":81.14589691,"26":81.42140198},"374":{"29":78.07080078,"28":78.12190247,"27":78.30090332,"26":null}}
{"367":{"29":80.68900299,"28":80.72270203,"27":80.80560303,"26":null},"368":{"29":80.46060181,"28":80.45130157,"27":80.5585022,"26":null},"369":{"29":80.09410095,"28":80.20960236,"27":80.2492981,"26":null},"370":{"29":79.64420319,"28":79.77970123,"27":79.81330109,"26":79.95950317},"371":{"29":78.94400024,"28":79.08380127,"27":79.45600128,"26":79.46260071},"372":{"29":77.62509918,"28":78.1013031,"27":78.81939697,"26":78.96970367},"373":{"29":75.30370331,"28":75.60119629,"27":78.16190338,"26":78.30390167},"374":{"29":75.45220184,"28":75.49710083,"27":75.64199829,"26":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Bakersfield, CA, United States", "location2": "Brownsville, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Bakersfield, CA, United States or Brownsville, TX, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and historical period?
67de1bd5-1468-47cc-921d-a278e037a125
As a wildfire management specialist attending a conference on fire behavior trends, I'm curious: between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, which location has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index during the spring of the end-century period compared to the historical spring period?
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in historical period']
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":5.62085009,"164":4.84872007,"163":4.76074982,"162":4.95480013,"161":5.31969023,"160":5.91426992,"159":4.30280018,"158":4.90903997,"157":6.21290016,"156":2.92055011},"302":{"165":6.21612978,"164":5.76262999,"163":5.28178978,"162":4.97638988,"161":4.20699978,"160":5.78572989,"159":6.75208998,"158":8.23066044,"157":8.68577003,"156":4.8915801},"303":{"165":7.58950996,"164":8.00899982,"163":7.11774015,"162":6.9061799,"161":6.10505009,"160":6.78951979,"159":8.17768002,"158":10.24289989,"157":11.09360027,"156":9.45932961},"304":{"165":8.79185009,"164":8.24979019,"163":7.61789989,"162":7.87169981,"161":7.96097994,"160":8.08759022,"159":9.27711964,"158":11.0387001,"157":12.18809986,"156":11.98970032},"305":{"165":9.52054024,"164":8.39888954,"163":7.84692001,"162":8.03864002,"161":8.23468971,"160":8.7055397,"159":9.68504047,"158":11.22819996,"157":11.97469997,"156":12.38169956},"306":{"165":9.19664955,"164":8.74359989,"163":8.24423027,"162":8.33516026,"161":8.46401978,"160":8.74182034,"159":9.55844975,"158":10.99359989,"157":12.07909966,"156":12.32619953},"307":{"165":8.90606976,"164":8.68146038,"163":8.30879021,"162":8.56235027,"161":8.73970032,"160":8.96022987,"159":9.61680031,"158":10.91170025,"157":11.92889977,"156":12.33329964},"308":{"165":9.05134964,"164":8.69721031,"163":8.40577984,"162":8.64295006,"161":8.95878029,"160":9.37903976,"159":10.19270039,"158":10.9822998,"157":11.65060043,"156":12.16380024},"309":{"165":9.33864975,"164":8.77721977,"163":8.46543026,"162":8.83518982,"161":9.27493,"160":9.72152996,"159":10.45479965,"158":11.14019966,"157":11.73890018,"156":null},"310":{"165":9.24328995,"164":8.55210972,"163":8.41493988,"162":9.08176994,"161":9.53048038,"160":9.74032974,"159":10.05669975,"158":10.84529972,"157":11.46010017,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.99787998,"225":4.94229984,"224":4.69643021,"223":4.31271982,"222":4.4415102,"221":5.15291977,"220":5.35118008,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.4918201,"226":3.32270002,"225":4.50883007,"224":4.44500017,"223":4.11640978,"222":4.10663986,"221":4.39066982,"220":4.95477009,"219":4.60098982},"226":{"227":2.77378011,"226":3.3734901,"225":4.34965992,"224":4.34518003,"223":4.09694004,"222":3.98235011,"221":4.12118006,"220":4.20397997,"219":4.09538984},"227":{"227":3.20040011,"226":3.29233003,"225":4.04036999,"224":4.26388979,"223":4.12691021,"222":4.04478979,"221":4.01438999,"220":3.87365007,"219":3.70265007},"228":{"227":2.49339008,"226":3.1863699,"225":3.87360001,"224":4.11639977,"223":4.36288023,"222":3.99971008,"221":3.83578992,"220":3.5647099,"219":3.34820008},"229":{"227":2.49564004,"226":3.11178994,"225":3.21797991,"224":3.42108989,"223":3.71816993,"222":3.48302007,"221":3.38054991,"220":3.24764991,"219":3.02305007},"230":{"227":2.59519005,"226":2.4598,"225":2.06708002,"224":2.41263008,"223":3.03944993,"222":2.72490001,"221":2.90863991,"220":2.97375011,"219":2.71960998},"231":{"227":2.49205995,"226":2.24850988,"225":1.91366994,"224":2.23225999,"223":2.78034997,"222":2.41517997,"221":2.68562007,"220":2.76453996,"219":2.37224007},"232":{"227":2.25342989,"226":2.27530003,"225":2.20879006,"224":2.2193501,"223":2.33919001,"222":2.17754006,"221":2.32165003,"220":2.42073011,"219":2.15733004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and spring in historical period?
0b7427c1-6890-42d8-ae15-1f8f3a686982
As a wildfire management specialist attending a conference on fire behavior trends, I'm curious: between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, which location has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index during the spring of the end-century period compared to the historical spring period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1244/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in historical period']
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":5.62085009,"164":4.84872007,"163":4.76074982,"162":4.95480013,"161":5.31969023,"160":5.91426992,"159":4.30280018,"158":4.90903997,"157":6.21290016,"156":2.92055011},"302":{"165":6.21612978,"164":5.76262999,"163":5.28178978,"162":4.97638988,"161":4.20699978,"160":5.78572989,"159":6.75208998,"158":8.23066044,"157":8.68577003,"156":4.8915801},"303":{"165":7.58950996,"164":8.00899982,"163":7.11774015,"162":6.9061799,"161":6.10505009,"160":6.78951979,"159":8.17768002,"158":10.24289989,"157":11.09360027,"156":9.45932961},"304":{"165":8.79185009,"164":8.24979019,"163":7.61789989,"162":7.87169981,"161":7.96097994,"160":8.08759022,"159":9.27711964,"158":11.0387001,"157":12.18809986,"156":11.98970032},"305":{"165":9.52054024,"164":8.39888954,"163":7.84692001,"162":8.03864002,"161":8.23468971,"160":8.7055397,"159":9.68504047,"158":11.22819996,"157":11.97469997,"156":12.38169956},"306":{"165":9.19664955,"164":8.74359989,"163":8.24423027,"162":8.33516026,"161":8.46401978,"160":8.74182034,"159":9.55844975,"158":10.99359989,"157":12.07909966,"156":12.32619953},"307":{"165":8.90606976,"164":8.68146038,"163":8.30879021,"162":8.56235027,"161":8.73970032,"160":8.96022987,"159":9.61680031,"158":10.91170025,"157":11.92889977,"156":12.33329964},"308":{"165":9.05134964,"164":8.69721031,"163":8.40577984,"162":8.64295006,"161":8.95878029,"160":9.37903976,"159":10.19270039,"158":10.9822998,"157":11.65060043,"156":12.16380024},"309":{"165":9.33864975,"164":8.77721977,"163":8.46543026,"162":8.83518982,"161":9.27493,"160":9.72152996,"159":10.45479965,"158":11.14019966,"157":11.73890018,"156":null},"310":{"165":9.24328995,"164":8.55210972,"163":8.41493988,"162":9.08176994,"161":9.53048038,"160":9.74032974,"159":10.05669975,"158":10.84529972,"157":11.46010017,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.99787998,"225":4.94229984,"224":4.69643021,"223":4.31271982,"222":4.4415102,"221":5.15291977,"220":5.35118008,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.4918201,"226":3.32270002,"225":4.50883007,"224":4.44500017,"223":4.11640978,"222":4.10663986,"221":4.39066982,"220":4.95477009,"219":4.60098982},"226":{"227":2.77378011,"226":3.3734901,"225":4.34965992,"224":4.34518003,"223":4.09694004,"222":3.98235011,"221":4.12118006,"220":4.20397997,"219":4.09538984},"227":{"227":3.20040011,"226":3.29233003,"225":4.04036999,"224":4.26388979,"223":4.12691021,"222":4.04478979,"221":4.01438999,"220":3.87365007,"219":3.70265007},"228":{"227":2.49339008,"226":3.1863699,"225":3.87360001,"224":4.11639977,"223":4.36288023,"222":3.99971008,"221":3.83578992,"220":3.5647099,"219":3.34820008},"229":{"227":2.49564004,"226":3.11178994,"225":3.21797991,"224":3.42108989,"223":3.71816993,"222":3.48302007,"221":3.38054991,"220":3.24764991,"219":3.02305007},"230":{"227":2.59519005,"226":2.4598,"225":2.06708002,"224":2.41263008,"223":3.03944993,"222":2.72490001,"221":2.90863991,"220":2.97375011,"219":2.71960998},"231":{"227":2.49205995,"226":2.24850988,"225":1.91366994,"224":2.23225999,"223":2.78034997,"222":2.41517997,"221":2.68562007,"220":2.76453996,"219":2.37224007},"232":{"227":2.25342989,"226":2.27530003,"225":2.20879006,"224":2.2193501,"223":2.33919001,"222":2.17754006,"221":2.32165003,"220":2.42073011,"219":2.15733004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and spring in historical period?
d1ee9746-bb44-4961-b69b-d5b203ad1f9c
As a wildfire management specialist attending a conference on fire behavior trends, I'm curious: between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, which location has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index during the spring of the end-century period compared to the historical spring period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1244/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in historical period']
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":5.62085009,"164":4.84872007,"163":4.76074982,"162":4.95480013,"161":5.31969023,"160":5.91426992,"159":4.30280018,"158":4.90903997,"157":6.21290016,"156":2.92055011},"302":{"165":6.21612978,"164":5.76262999,"163":5.28178978,"162":4.97638988,"161":4.20699978,"160":5.78572989,"159":6.75208998,"158":8.23066044,"157":8.68577003,"156":4.8915801},"303":{"165":7.58950996,"164":8.00899982,"163":7.11774015,"162":6.9061799,"161":6.10505009,"160":6.78951979,"159":8.17768002,"158":10.24289989,"157":11.09360027,"156":9.45932961},"304":{"165":8.79185009,"164":8.24979019,"163":7.61789989,"162":7.87169981,"161":7.96097994,"160":8.08759022,"159":9.27711964,"158":11.0387001,"157":12.18809986,"156":11.98970032},"305":{"165":9.52054024,"164":8.39888954,"163":7.84692001,"162":8.03864002,"161":8.23468971,"160":8.7055397,"159":9.68504047,"158":11.22819996,"157":11.97469997,"156":12.38169956},"306":{"165":9.19664955,"164":8.74359989,"163":8.24423027,"162":8.33516026,"161":8.46401978,"160":8.74182034,"159":9.55844975,"158":10.99359989,"157":12.07909966,"156":12.32619953},"307":{"165":8.90606976,"164":8.68146038,"163":8.30879021,"162":8.56235027,"161":8.73970032,"160":8.96022987,"159":9.61680031,"158":10.91170025,"157":11.92889977,"156":12.33329964},"308":{"165":9.05134964,"164":8.69721031,"163":8.40577984,"162":8.64295006,"161":8.95878029,"160":9.37903976,"159":10.19270039,"158":10.9822998,"157":11.65060043,"156":12.16380024},"309":{"165":9.33864975,"164":8.77721977,"163":8.46543026,"162":8.83518982,"161":9.27493,"160":9.72152996,"159":10.45479965,"158":11.14019966,"157":11.73890018,"156":null},"310":{"165":9.24328995,"164":8.55210972,"163":8.41493988,"162":9.08176994,"161":9.53048038,"160":9.74032974,"159":10.05669975,"158":10.84529972,"157":11.46010017,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.99787998,"225":4.94229984,"224":4.69643021,"223":4.31271982,"222":4.4415102,"221":5.15291977,"220":5.35118008,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.4918201,"226":3.32270002,"225":4.50883007,"224":4.44500017,"223":4.11640978,"222":4.10663986,"221":4.39066982,"220":4.95477009,"219":4.60098982},"226":{"227":2.77378011,"226":3.3734901,"225":4.34965992,"224":4.34518003,"223":4.09694004,"222":3.98235011,"221":4.12118006,"220":4.20397997,"219":4.09538984},"227":{"227":3.20040011,"226":3.29233003,"225":4.04036999,"224":4.26388979,"223":4.12691021,"222":4.04478979,"221":4.01438999,"220":3.87365007,"219":3.70265007},"228":{"227":2.49339008,"226":3.1863699,"225":3.87360001,"224":4.11639977,"223":4.36288023,"222":3.99971008,"221":3.83578992,"220":3.5647099,"219":3.34820008},"229":{"227":2.49564004,"226":3.11178994,"225":3.21797991,"224":3.42108989,"223":3.71816993,"222":3.48302007,"221":3.38054991,"220":3.24764991,"219":3.02305007},"230":{"227":2.59519005,"226":2.4598,"225":2.06708002,"224":2.41263008,"223":3.03944993,"222":2.72490001,"221":2.90863991,"220":2.97375011,"219":2.71960998},"231":{"227":2.49205995,"226":2.24850988,"225":1.91366994,"224":2.23225999,"223":2.78034997,"222":2.41517997,"221":2.68562007,"220":2.76453996,"219":2.37224007},"232":{"227":2.25342989,"226":2.27530003,"225":2.20879006,"224":2.2193501,"223":2.33919001,"222":2.17754006,"221":2.32165003,"220":2.42073011,"219":2.15733004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and spring in historical period?
ac9a700d-cb34-4f69-8f02-9890263918b4
As a wildfire management specialist attending a conference on fire behavior trends, I'm curious: between Cheyenne, WY, and Spokane, WA, which location has shown a more significant shift in fire weather index during the spring of the end-century period compared to the historical spring period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1244/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in historical period']
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":5.62085009,"164":4.84872007,"163":4.76074982,"162":4.95480013,"161":5.31969023,"160":5.91426992,"159":4.30280018,"158":4.90903997,"157":6.21290016,"156":2.92055011},"302":{"165":6.21612978,"164":5.76262999,"163":5.28178978,"162":4.97638988,"161":4.20699978,"160":5.78572989,"159":6.75208998,"158":8.23066044,"157":8.68577003,"156":4.8915801},"303":{"165":7.58950996,"164":8.00899982,"163":7.11774015,"162":6.9061799,"161":6.10505009,"160":6.78951979,"159":8.17768002,"158":10.24289989,"157":11.09360027,"156":9.45932961},"304":{"165":8.79185009,"164":8.24979019,"163":7.61789989,"162":7.87169981,"161":7.96097994,"160":8.08759022,"159":9.27711964,"158":11.0387001,"157":12.18809986,"156":11.98970032},"305":{"165":9.52054024,"164":8.39888954,"163":7.84692001,"162":8.03864002,"161":8.23468971,"160":8.7055397,"159":9.68504047,"158":11.22819996,"157":11.97469997,"156":12.38169956},"306":{"165":9.19664955,"164":8.74359989,"163":8.24423027,"162":8.33516026,"161":8.46401978,"160":8.74182034,"159":9.55844975,"158":10.99359989,"157":12.07909966,"156":12.32619953},"307":{"165":8.90606976,"164":8.68146038,"163":8.30879021,"162":8.56235027,"161":8.73970032,"160":8.96022987,"159":9.61680031,"158":10.91170025,"157":11.92889977,"156":12.33329964},"308":{"165":9.05134964,"164":8.69721031,"163":8.40577984,"162":8.64295006,"161":8.95878029,"160":9.37903976,"159":10.19270039,"158":10.9822998,"157":11.65060043,"156":12.16380024},"309":{"165":9.33864975,"164":8.77721977,"163":8.46543026,"162":8.83518982,"161":9.27493,"160":9.72152996,"159":10.45479965,"158":11.14019966,"157":11.73890018,"156":null},"310":{"165":9.24328995,"164":8.55210972,"163":8.41493988,"162":9.08176994,"161":9.53048038,"160":9.74032974,"159":10.05669975,"158":10.84529972,"157":11.46010017,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.99787998,"225":4.94229984,"224":4.69643021,"223":4.31271982,"222":4.4415102,"221":5.15291977,"220":5.35118008,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.4918201,"226":3.32270002,"225":4.50883007,"224":4.44500017,"223":4.11640978,"222":4.10663986,"221":4.39066982,"220":4.95477009,"219":4.60098982},"226":{"227":2.77378011,"226":3.3734901,"225":4.34965992,"224":4.34518003,"223":4.09694004,"222":3.98235011,"221":4.12118006,"220":4.20397997,"219":4.09538984},"227":{"227":3.20040011,"226":3.29233003,"225":4.04036999,"224":4.26388979,"223":4.12691021,"222":4.04478979,"221":4.01438999,"220":3.87365007,"219":3.70265007},"228":{"227":2.49339008,"226":3.1863699,"225":3.87360001,"224":4.11639977,"223":4.36288023,"222":3.99971008,"221":3.83578992,"220":3.5647099,"219":3.34820008},"229":{"227":2.49564004,"226":3.11178994,"225":3.21797991,"224":3.42108989,"223":3.71816993,"222":3.48302007,"221":3.38054991,"220":3.24764991,"219":3.02305007},"230":{"227":2.59519005,"226":2.4598,"225":2.06708002,"224":2.41263008,"223":3.03944993,"222":2.72490001,"221":2.90863991,"220":2.97375011,"219":2.71960998},"231":{"227":2.49205995,"226":2.24850988,"225":1.91366994,"224":2.23225999,"223":2.78034997,"222":2.41517997,"221":2.68562007,"220":2.76453996,"219":2.37224007},"232":{"227":2.25342989,"226":2.27530003,"225":2.20879006,"224":2.2193501,"223":2.33919001,"222":2.17754006,"221":2.32165003,"220":2.42073011,"219":2.15733004}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and spring in historical period?
b7035e1c-9a60-45d8-bb7b-117d0c7a972b
As a meteorologist analyzing heat trends for urban planning in the southern United States, I'm interested in understanding which city, Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX, has seen a larger increase in the number of summer days when the daily heat index surpassed 125°F comparing end-century projections to historical data?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":96.62912242,"141":96.58281453,"140":96.58889516,"139":97.63120778,"138":98.77882131,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":97.42397563,"141":97.66926829,"140":97.94989777,"139":98.46144613,"138":98.97911326,"137":99.63204956,"136":100.50670369,"135":101.42937469,"134":null},"478":{"143":97.48841858,"142":97.81379445,"141":97.95294189,"140":98.40597788,"139":98.8578008,"138":99.03678385,"137":99.45100911,"136":100.41240692,"135":101.74777476,"134":102.60155996},"479":{"143":98.01563517,"142":98.19065857,"141":98.43391927,"140":98.84765625,"139":99.44153086,"138":99.30931091,"137":99.87841797,"136":100.47449239,"135":101.42925262,"134":102.50734965},"480":{"143":98.51256816,"142":98.43490092,"141":98.99050395,"140":99.54781596,"139":99.89485423,"138":100.61260732,"137":100.66964976,"136":100.97580719,"135":101.39692434,"134":102.09545135},"481":{"143":98.94766998,"142":98.86212921,"141":99.33110809,"140":99.73254395,"139":100.05275218,"138":99.9760259,"137":101.24872335,"136":101.94156901,"135":101.8725001,"134":102.34201304},"482":{"143":99.15183767,"142":99.11097463,"141":99.74413554,"140":100.20358276,"139":100.49896749,"138":100.58090719,"137":101.22206879,"136":101.62275441,"135":102.22152964,"134":102.89230347},"483":{"143":99.30738322,"142":99.36870321,"141":100.21485392,"140":101.00005849,"139":100.83859507,"138":100.89480845,"137":100.97265879,"136":101.55325317,"135":102.08893585,"134":102.83522542},"484":{"143":99.51789856,"142":99.71444956,"141":100.60461426,"140":101.44193776,"139":101.776769,"138":101.52756755,"137":101.27813466,"136":101.56187948,"135":101.90971629,"134":102.31547292},"485":{"143":99.80005646,"142":100.40722148,"141":101.35170746,"140":102.26110077,"139":102.46482849,"138":102.0390269,"137":101.74587504,"136":101.92242432,"135":102.27494303,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":100.92581177,"141":102.28872935,"140":103.10078176,"139":103.30834707,"138":102.88120778,"137":102.53168742,"136":102.36402384,"135":102.66618347,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":114.41584015,"67":114.79113007,"66":115.9100825,"65":116.74692535,"64":117.52345276,"63":117.75920614,"62":118.34572093,"61":118.66526794,"60":119.20296733,"59":119.94780223},"380":{"69":114.30449422,"68":114.74985758,"67":115.27753703,"66":116.07616933,"65":116.85052745,"64":117.39586385,"63":118.26546987,"62":119.03372447,"61":119.29266866,"60":119.35352071,"59":120.06895447},"381":{"69":115.17376709,"68":115.56781006,"67":115.96087138,"66":116.63524882,"65":117.30165354,"64":117.83509827,"63":118.49472046,"62":118.75806173,"61":119.37572225,"60":120.33795929,"59":120.3391215},"382":{"69":115.51904043,"68":115.93115489,"67":116.05532328,"66":116.7046992,"65":117.21785736,"64":117.92831167,"63":118.5765686,"62":118.83317566,"61":119.56974284,"60":120.80581411,"59":121.3180186},"383":{"69":115.95760091,"68":116.41821798,"67":116.76771037,"66":116.98437754,"65":117.33874766,"64":116.52110036,"63":117.38830058,"62":119.42846171,"61":119.79332733,"60":120.57126363,"59":121.33074697},"384":{"69":116.83889771,"68":117.76669312,"67":117.90550995,"66":117.53673553,"65":116.37954203,"64":117.10382334,"63":117.94067891,"62":119.88965352,"61":120.23681386,"60":121.13417562,"59":122.10926565},"385":{"69":117.87281036,"68":119.03739421,"67":119.32582855,"66":119.39088186,"65":119.17925517,"64":118.02770487,"63":118.88122304,"62":120.90121206,"61":121.9830602,"60":122.22477468,"59":123.25493876},"386":{"69":119.22291311,"68":119.94926707,"67":120.40424093,"66":120.87188212,"65":121.22360992,"64":121.50042979,"63":121.41730245,"62":122.00137329,"61":123.23659515,"60":123.70563761,"59":125.86209361},"387":{"69":120.52353923,"68":121.1272049,"67":121.87033335,"66":121.5806605,"65":122.33788808,"64":122.96925354,"63":123.65279388,"62":124.40618134,"61":125.17963918,"60":125.91519928,"59":127.28033956},"388":{"69":120.36374156,"68":121.08152008,"67":121.84726969,"66":122.96068827,"65":124.65318298,"64":126.59896851,"63":null,"62":131.01216634,"61":127.06760661,"60":132.52031962,"59":131.76837158},"389":{"69":121.08804067,"68":122.09561412,"67":122.76809184,"66":123.44632467,"65":125.97194417,"64":132.77036031,"63":132.4190038,"62":132.56948853,"61":132.09894816,"60":132.11223348,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
8a82d232-2239-449e-a382-2c38aa8b0396
As a meteorologist analyzing heat trends for urban planning in the southern United States, I'm interested in understanding which city, Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX, has seen a larger increase in the number of summer days when the daily heat index surpassed 125°F comparing end-century projections to historical data?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1333/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":96.62912242,"141":96.58281453,"140":96.58889516,"139":97.63120778,"138":98.77882131,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":97.42397563,"141":97.66926829,"140":97.94989777,"139":98.46144613,"138":98.97911326,"137":99.63204956,"136":100.50670369,"135":101.42937469,"134":null},"478":{"143":97.48841858,"142":97.81379445,"141":97.95294189,"140":98.40597788,"139":98.8578008,"138":99.03678385,"137":99.45100911,"136":100.41240692,"135":101.74777476,"134":102.60155996},"479":{"143":98.01563517,"142":98.19065857,"141":98.43391927,"140":98.84765625,"139":99.44153086,"138":99.30931091,"137":99.87841797,"136":100.47449239,"135":101.42925262,"134":102.50734965},"480":{"143":98.51256816,"142":98.43490092,"141":98.99050395,"140":99.54781596,"139":99.89485423,"138":100.61260732,"137":100.66964976,"136":100.97580719,"135":101.39692434,"134":102.09545135},"481":{"143":98.94766998,"142":98.86212921,"141":99.33110809,"140":99.73254395,"139":100.05275218,"138":99.9760259,"137":101.24872335,"136":101.94156901,"135":101.8725001,"134":102.34201304},"482":{"143":99.15183767,"142":99.11097463,"141":99.74413554,"140":100.20358276,"139":100.49896749,"138":100.58090719,"137":101.22206879,"136":101.62275441,"135":102.22152964,"134":102.89230347},"483":{"143":99.30738322,"142":99.36870321,"141":100.21485392,"140":101.00005849,"139":100.83859507,"138":100.89480845,"137":100.97265879,"136":101.55325317,"135":102.08893585,"134":102.83522542},"484":{"143":99.51789856,"142":99.71444956,"141":100.60461426,"140":101.44193776,"139":101.776769,"138":101.52756755,"137":101.27813466,"136":101.56187948,"135":101.90971629,"134":102.31547292},"485":{"143":99.80005646,"142":100.40722148,"141":101.35170746,"140":102.26110077,"139":102.46482849,"138":102.0390269,"137":101.74587504,"136":101.92242432,"135":102.27494303,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":100.92581177,"141":102.28872935,"140":103.10078176,"139":103.30834707,"138":102.88120778,"137":102.53168742,"136":102.36402384,"135":102.66618347,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":114.41584015,"67":114.79113007,"66":115.9100825,"65":116.74692535,"64":117.52345276,"63":117.75920614,"62":118.34572093,"61":118.66526794,"60":119.20296733,"59":119.94780223},"380":{"69":114.30449422,"68":114.74985758,"67":115.27753703,"66":116.07616933,"65":116.85052745,"64":117.39586385,"63":118.26546987,"62":119.03372447,"61":119.29266866,"60":119.35352071,"59":120.06895447},"381":{"69":115.17376709,"68":115.56781006,"67":115.96087138,"66":116.63524882,"65":117.30165354,"64":117.83509827,"63":118.49472046,"62":118.75806173,"61":119.37572225,"60":120.33795929,"59":120.3391215},"382":{"69":115.51904043,"68":115.93115489,"67":116.05532328,"66":116.7046992,"65":117.21785736,"64":117.92831167,"63":118.5765686,"62":118.83317566,"61":119.56974284,"60":120.80581411,"59":121.3180186},"383":{"69":115.95760091,"68":116.41821798,"67":116.76771037,"66":116.98437754,"65":117.33874766,"64":116.52110036,"63":117.38830058,"62":119.42846171,"61":119.79332733,"60":120.57126363,"59":121.33074697},"384":{"69":116.83889771,"68":117.76669312,"67":117.90550995,"66":117.53673553,"65":116.37954203,"64":117.10382334,"63":117.94067891,"62":119.88965352,"61":120.23681386,"60":121.13417562,"59":122.10926565},"385":{"69":117.87281036,"68":119.03739421,"67":119.32582855,"66":119.39088186,"65":119.17925517,"64":118.02770487,"63":118.88122304,"62":120.90121206,"61":121.9830602,"60":122.22477468,"59":123.25493876},"386":{"69":119.22291311,"68":119.94926707,"67":120.40424093,"66":120.87188212,"65":121.22360992,"64":121.50042979,"63":121.41730245,"62":122.00137329,"61":123.23659515,"60":123.70563761,"59":125.86209361},"387":{"69":120.52353923,"68":121.1272049,"67":121.87033335,"66":121.5806605,"65":122.33788808,"64":122.96925354,"63":123.65279388,"62":124.40618134,"61":125.17963918,"60":125.91519928,"59":127.28033956},"388":{"69":120.36374156,"68":121.08152008,"67":121.84726969,"66":122.96068827,"65":124.65318298,"64":126.59896851,"63":null,"62":131.01216634,"61":127.06760661,"60":132.52031962,"59":131.76837158},"389":{"69":121.08804067,"68":122.09561412,"67":122.76809184,"66":123.44632467,"65":125.97194417,"64":132.77036031,"63":132.4190038,"62":132.56948853,"61":132.09894816,"60":132.11223348,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
6ca3e26f-8f61-475f-b55a-3949ed5e3f02
As a meteorologist analyzing heat trends for urban planning in the southern United States, I'm interested in understanding which city, Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX, has seen a larger increase in the number of summer days when the daily heat index surpassed 125°F comparing end-century projections to historical data?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1333/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":96.62912242,"141":96.58281453,"140":96.58889516,"139":97.63120778,"138":98.77882131,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":97.42397563,"141":97.66926829,"140":97.94989777,"139":98.46144613,"138":98.97911326,"137":99.63204956,"136":100.50670369,"135":101.42937469,"134":null},"478":{"143":97.48841858,"142":97.81379445,"141":97.95294189,"140":98.40597788,"139":98.8578008,"138":99.03678385,"137":99.45100911,"136":100.41240692,"135":101.74777476,"134":102.60155996},"479":{"143":98.01563517,"142":98.19065857,"141":98.43391927,"140":98.84765625,"139":99.44153086,"138":99.30931091,"137":99.87841797,"136":100.47449239,"135":101.42925262,"134":102.50734965},"480":{"143":98.51256816,"142":98.43490092,"141":98.99050395,"140":99.54781596,"139":99.89485423,"138":100.61260732,"137":100.66964976,"136":100.97580719,"135":101.39692434,"134":102.09545135},"481":{"143":98.94766998,"142":98.86212921,"141":99.33110809,"140":99.73254395,"139":100.05275218,"138":99.9760259,"137":101.24872335,"136":101.94156901,"135":101.8725001,"134":102.34201304},"482":{"143":99.15183767,"142":99.11097463,"141":99.74413554,"140":100.20358276,"139":100.49896749,"138":100.58090719,"137":101.22206879,"136":101.62275441,"135":102.22152964,"134":102.89230347},"483":{"143":99.30738322,"142":99.36870321,"141":100.21485392,"140":101.00005849,"139":100.83859507,"138":100.89480845,"137":100.97265879,"136":101.55325317,"135":102.08893585,"134":102.83522542},"484":{"143":99.51789856,"142":99.71444956,"141":100.60461426,"140":101.44193776,"139":101.776769,"138":101.52756755,"137":101.27813466,"136":101.56187948,"135":101.90971629,"134":102.31547292},"485":{"143":99.80005646,"142":100.40722148,"141":101.35170746,"140":102.26110077,"139":102.46482849,"138":102.0390269,"137":101.74587504,"136":101.92242432,"135":102.27494303,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":100.92581177,"141":102.28872935,"140":103.10078176,"139":103.30834707,"138":102.88120778,"137":102.53168742,"136":102.36402384,"135":102.66618347,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":114.41584015,"67":114.79113007,"66":115.9100825,"65":116.74692535,"64":117.52345276,"63":117.75920614,"62":118.34572093,"61":118.66526794,"60":119.20296733,"59":119.94780223},"380":{"69":114.30449422,"68":114.74985758,"67":115.27753703,"66":116.07616933,"65":116.85052745,"64":117.39586385,"63":118.26546987,"62":119.03372447,"61":119.29266866,"60":119.35352071,"59":120.06895447},"381":{"69":115.17376709,"68":115.56781006,"67":115.96087138,"66":116.63524882,"65":117.30165354,"64":117.83509827,"63":118.49472046,"62":118.75806173,"61":119.37572225,"60":120.33795929,"59":120.3391215},"382":{"69":115.51904043,"68":115.93115489,"67":116.05532328,"66":116.7046992,"65":117.21785736,"64":117.92831167,"63":118.5765686,"62":118.83317566,"61":119.56974284,"60":120.80581411,"59":121.3180186},"383":{"69":115.95760091,"68":116.41821798,"67":116.76771037,"66":116.98437754,"65":117.33874766,"64":116.52110036,"63":117.38830058,"62":119.42846171,"61":119.79332733,"60":120.57126363,"59":121.33074697},"384":{"69":116.83889771,"68":117.76669312,"67":117.90550995,"66":117.53673553,"65":116.37954203,"64":117.10382334,"63":117.94067891,"62":119.88965352,"61":120.23681386,"60":121.13417562,"59":122.10926565},"385":{"69":117.87281036,"68":119.03739421,"67":119.32582855,"66":119.39088186,"65":119.17925517,"64":118.02770487,"63":118.88122304,"62":120.90121206,"61":121.9830602,"60":122.22477468,"59":123.25493876},"386":{"69":119.22291311,"68":119.94926707,"67":120.40424093,"66":120.87188212,"65":121.22360992,"64":121.50042979,"63":121.41730245,"62":122.00137329,"61":123.23659515,"60":123.70563761,"59":125.86209361},"387":{"69":120.52353923,"68":121.1272049,"67":121.87033335,"66":121.5806605,"65":122.33788808,"64":122.96925354,"63":123.65279388,"62":124.40618134,"61":125.17963918,"60":125.91519928,"59":127.28033956},"388":{"69":120.36374156,"68":121.08152008,"67":121.84726969,"66":122.96068827,"65":124.65318298,"64":126.59896851,"63":null,"62":131.01216634,"61":127.06760661,"60":132.52031962,"59":131.76837158},"389":{"69":121.08804067,"68":122.09561412,"67":122.76809184,"66":123.44632467,"65":125.97194417,"64":132.77036031,"63":132.4190038,"62":132.56948853,"61":132.09894816,"60":132.11223348,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
6e6874c1-1265-4b41-8da9-5bebf9144e17
As a meteorologist analyzing heat trends for urban planning in the southern United States, I'm interested in understanding which city, Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX, has seen a larger increase in the number of summer days when the daily heat index surpassed 125°F comparing end-century projections to historical data?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1333/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":96.62912242,"141":96.58281453,"140":96.58889516,"139":97.63120778,"138":98.77882131,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":97.42397563,"141":97.66926829,"140":97.94989777,"139":98.46144613,"138":98.97911326,"137":99.63204956,"136":100.50670369,"135":101.42937469,"134":null},"478":{"143":97.48841858,"142":97.81379445,"141":97.95294189,"140":98.40597788,"139":98.8578008,"138":99.03678385,"137":99.45100911,"136":100.41240692,"135":101.74777476,"134":102.60155996},"479":{"143":98.01563517,"142":98.19065857,"141":98.43391927,"140":98.84765625,"139":99.44153086,"138":99.30931091,"137":99.87841797,"136":100.47449239,"135":101.42925262,"134":102.50734965},"480":{"143":98.51256816,"142":98.43490092,"141":98.99050395,"140":99.54781596,"139":99.89485423,"138":100.61260732,"137":100.66964976,"136":100.97580719,"135":101.39692434,"134":102.09545135},"481":{"143":98.94766998,"142":98.86212921,"141":99.33110809,"140":99.73254395,"139":100.05275218,"138":99.9760259,"137":101.24872335,"136":101.94156901,"135":101.8725001,"134":102.34201304},"482":{"143":99.15183767,"142":99.11097463,"141":99.74413554,"140":100.20358276,"139":100.49896749,"138":100.58090719,"137":101.22206879,"136":101.62275441,"135":102.22152964,"134":102.89230347},"483":{"143":99.30738322,"142":99.36870321,"141":100.21485392,"140":101.00005849,"139":100.83859507,"138":100.89480845,"137":100.97265879,"136":101.55325317,"135":102.08893585,"134":102.83522542},"484":{"143":99.51789856,"142":99.71444956,"141":100.60461426,"140":101.44193776,"139":101.776769,"138":101.52756755,"137":101.27813466,"136":101.56187948,"135":101.90971629,"134":102.31547292},"485":{"143":99.80005646,"142":100.40722148,"141":101.35170746,"140":102.26110077,"139":102.46482849,"138":102.0390269,"137":101.74587504,"136":101.92242432,"135":102.27494303,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":100.92581177,"141":102.28872935,"140":103.10078176,"139":103.30834707,"138":102.88120778,"137":102.53168742,"136":102.36402384,"135":102.66618347,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":114.41584015,"67":114.79113007,"66":115.9100825,"65":116.74692535,"64":117.52345276,"63":117.75920614,"62":118.34572093,"61":118.66526794,"60":119.20296733,"59":119.94780223},"380":{"69":114.30449422,"68":114.74985758,"67":115.27753703,"66":116.07616933,"65":116.85052745,"64":117.39586385,"63":118.26546987,"62":119.03372447,"61":119.29266866,"60":119.35352071,"59":120.06895447},"381":{"69":115.17376709,"68":115.56781006,"67":115.96087138,"66":116.63524882,"65":117.30165354,"64":117.83509827,"63":118.49472046,"62":118.75806173,"61":119.37572225,"60":120.33795929,"59":120.3391215},"382":{"69":115.51904043,"68":115.93115489,"67":116.05532328,"66":116.7046992,"65":117.21785736,"64":117.92831167,"63":118.5765686,"62":118.83317566,"61":119.56974284,"60":120.80581411,"59":121.3180186},"383":{"69":115.95760091,"68":116.41821798,"67":116.76771037,"66":116.98437754,"65":117.33874766,"64":116.52110036,"63":117.38830058,"62":119.42846171,"61":119.79332733,"60":120.57126363,"59":121.33074697},"384":{"69":116.83889771,"68":117.76669312,"67":117.90550995,"66":117.53673553,"65":116.37954203,"64":117.10382334,"63":117.94067891,"62":119.88965352,"61":120.23681386,"60":121.13417562,"59":122.10926565},"385":{"69":117.87281036,"68":119.03739421,"67":119.32582855,"66":119.39088186,"65":119.17925517,"64":118.02770487,"63":118.88122304,"62":120.90121206,"61":121.9830602,"60":122.22477468,"59":123.25493876},"386":{"69":119.22291311,"68":119.94926707,"67":120.40424093,"66":120.87188212,"65":121.22360992,"64":121.50042979,"63":121.41730245,"62":122.00137329,"61":123.23659515,"60":123.70563761,"59":125.86209361},"387":{"69":120.52353923,"68":121.1272049,"67":121.87033335,"66":121.5806605,"65":122.33788808,"64":122.96925354,"63":123.65279388,"62":124.40618134,"61":125.17963918,"60":125.91519928,"59":127.28033956},"388":{"69":120.36374156,"68":121.08152008,"67":121.84726969,"66":122.96068827,"65":124.65318298,"64":126.59896851,"63":null,"62":131.01216634,"61":127.06760661,"60":132.52031962,"59":131.76837158},"389":{"69":121.08804067,"68":122.09561412,"67":122.76809184,"66":123.44632467,"65":125.97194417,"64":132.77036031,"63":132.4190038,"62":132.56948853,"61":132.09894816,"60":132.11223348,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in historical period?
5aee7a80-456b-4631-8346-e675b696b4bb
As a wildfire risk assessment specialist presenting findings to a team of emergency responders, I’d like to know: during historical autumn periods and mid-century spring periods, which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, exhibited a more significant variation in fire weather index?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in mid-century period?
158b8e68-023c-4bbe-b117-427a5d57ed05
As a wildfire risk assessment specialist presenting findings to a team of emergency responders, I’d like to know: during historical autumn periods and mid-century spring periods, which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, exhibited a more significant variation in fire weather index?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1330/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in mid-century period?
c551b4eb-ab92-47c1-93cf-a222622579a4
As a wildfire risk assessment specialist presenting findings to a team of emergency responders, I’d like to know: during historical autumn periods and mid-century spring periods, which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, exhibited a more significant variation in fire weather index?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1330/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in mid-century period?
e177858b-1f05-40d0-af80-df50969bfc00
As a wildfire risk assessment specialist presenting findings to a team of emergency responders, I’d like to know: during historical autumn periods and mid-century spring periods, which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, exhibited a more significant variation in fire weather index?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1330/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":21.20170021,"150":17.85549927,"149":18.2947998,"148":18.96489906,"147":17.01580048,"146":15.98009968,"145":17.35099983},"303":{"151":24.90629959,"150":22.77400017,"149":22.69449997,"148":22.62779999,"147":20.00650024,"146":18.69519997,"145":20.6154995},"304":{"151":24.4654007,"150":23.67970085,"149":23.39489937,"148":22.82209969,"147":22.18639946,"146":21.86359978,"145":21.55069923},"305":{"151":23.68280029,"150":23.20100021,"149":22.96269989,"148":21.87350082,"147":21.29459953,"146":22.06979942,"145":21.26749992},"306":{"151":23.67709923,"150":23.30120087,"149":22.69330025,"148":22.29109955,"147":21.91589928,"146":21.55349922,"145":21.1128006},"307":{"151":24.0510006,"150":23.25860023,"149":22.53240013,"148":22.27899933,"147":21.71310043,"146":21.32970047,"145":20.91760063},"308":{"151":24.63669968,"150":23.90519905,"149":23.28490067,"148":22.87290001,"147":22.44720078,"146":22.19759941,"145":22.12879944}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":36.09780121,"122":27.89850044,"121":19.14439964,"120":18.80200005,"119":26.04409981,"118":35.5705986,"117":41.35540009,"116":null},"228":{"123":37.26620102,"122":33.5141983,"121":24.3227005,"120":20.2784996,"119":25.04430008,"118":33.80659866,"117":37.7120018,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.67879868,"122":43.48419952,"121":41.03089905,"120":34.53919983,"119":33.9518013,"118":37.39530182,"117":38.4510994,"116":null},"230":{"123":38.45339966,"122":41.06549835,"121":43.73400116,"120":42.04199982,"119":40.88029861,"118":41.70140076,"117":42.20539856,"116":43.42900085},"231":{"123":23.75300026,"122":26.32299995,"121":35.20780182,"120":40.64500046,"119":41.8927002,"118":42.18809891,"117":42.43130112,"116":42.69309998},"232":{"123":24.7942009,"122":29.85160065,"121":38.78659821,"120":45.09659958,"119":46.21229935,"118":44.37900162,"117":43.68259811,"116":44.26929855},"233":{"123":39.34519958,"122":43.06579971,"121":47.375,"120":50.76570129,"119":50.7826004,"118":48.104599,"117":46.51779938,"116":46.88499832},"234":{"123":41.80569839,"122":44.75299835,"121":46.89920044,"120":47.90409851,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in mid-century period?
e153aef8-0d18-40f5-b9eb-0795e60dea06
As a climate analyst tasked with presenting findings on temperature trends to local government officials, how do the minimum annual temperature changes in Buffalo, NY, compared to Columbus, OH, across the end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
59068517-c730-4469-aa7b-654b46c743ae
As a climate analyst tasked with presenting findings on temperature trends to local government officials, how do the minimum annual temperature changes in Buffalo, NY, compared to Columbus, OH, across the end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
2ef05de5-156e-4c6c-b623-075cb4401d15
As a climate analyst tasked with presenting findings on temperature trends to local government officials, how do the minimum annual temperature changes in Buffalo, NY, compared to Columbus, OH, across the end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
70619396-7a05-43a6-a59e-d9490fb49f77
As a climate analyst tasked with presenting findings on temperature trends to local government officials, how do the minimum annual temperature changes in Buffalo, NY, compared to Columbus, OH, across the end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1392/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":41.58769989,"210":41.20119858,"209":44.28789902,"208":41.72650146,"207":43.89979935,"206":44.1590004},"472":{"211":41.36449814,"210":41.01639938,"209":44.48300171,"208":44.31340027,"207":41.2989006,"206":41.59740067},"473":{"211":41.1556015,"210":40.97129822,"209":40.76480103,"208":40.6576004,"207":40.5666008,"206":40.04660034},"474":{"211":40.73009872,"210":40.71870041,"209":40.60839844,"208":40.17060089,"207":39.50239944,"206":39.15359879}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":44.39369965,"176":44.56169891,"175":44.79349899,"174":44.95220184,"173":44.96319962,"172":45.07460022,"171":45.20500183},"452":{"178":null,"177":44.42890167,"176":44.63570023,"175":44.87220001,"174":45.09809875,"173":45.26390076,"172":45.36259842,"171":45.40629959},"453":{"178":44.25260162,"177":44.5135994,"176":44.85179901,"175":48.7201004,"174":47.68280029,"173":45.54130173,"172":45.64260101,"171":45.66910172},"454":{"178":43.91999817,"177":44.26819992,"176":44.73690033,"175":48.54449844,"174":45.44630051,"173":45.74010086,"172":45.80879974,"171":45.81940079},"455":{"178":43.53710175,"177":43.77719879,"176":44.3185997,"175":44.84199905,"174":45.37480164,"173":45.63029861,"172":45.69480133,"171":null},"456":{"178":43.52190018,"177":43.73960114,"176":44.06969833,"175":44.64009857,"174":45.06769943,"173":45.22900009,"172":45.18939972,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":44.36709976,"174":44.6106987,"173":44.74219894,"172":45.1427002,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
3fcdc1ff-28fc-42bd-9c19-76e5d1bfe26c
As a wildfire management specialist conducting research for an upcoming report, I’m trying to determine which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during the winter months when comparing historical data to mid-century projections.
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079},"303":{"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633},"304":{"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387},"305":{"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284},"306":{"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354},"307":{"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107},"308":{"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":null},"228":{"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":null},"229":{"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678},"231":{"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852},"232":{"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695},"233":{"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288},"234":{"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
5d9887a6-03cf-4b01-ada4-71d4de25a14b
As a wildfire management specialist conducting research for an upcoming report, I’m trying to determine which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during the winter months when comparing historical data to mid-century projections.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079},"303":{"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633},"304":{"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387},"305":{"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284},"306":{"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354},"307":{"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107},"308":{"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":null},"228":{"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":null},"229":{"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678},"231":{"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852},"232":{"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695},"233":{"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288},"234":{"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
51451bc5-7c3f-403b-91d0-7a7556047913
As a wildfire management specialist conducting research for an upcoming report, I’m trying to determine which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during the winter months when comparing historical data to mid-century projections.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079},"303":{"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633},"304":{"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387},"305":{"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284},"306":{"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354},"307":{"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107},"308":{"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":null},"228":{"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":null},"229":{"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678},"231":{"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852},"232":{"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695},"233":{"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288},"234":{"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
b319116e-4ccc-4e4c-9ee0-2157a38a07ef
As a wildfire management specialist conducting research for an upcoming report, I’m trying to determine which city—Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV—has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during the winter months when comparing historical data to mid-century projections.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(b) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079},"303":{"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633},"304":{"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387},"305":{"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284},"306":{"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354},"307":{"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107},"308":{"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":null},"228":{"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":null},"229":{"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678},"231":{"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852},"232":{"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695},"233":{"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288},"234":{"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
28852de0-a11a-4f28-a656-8600e390f67a
As an environmental scientist analyzing urban heat trends, I'm curious about which city has shown a more significant shift in maximum annual temperature between Fort Myers, FL, and Tampa, FL, over the historical period and the projected end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":79.79879761,"64":79.72059631,"63":79.52349854,"62":78.63819885,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":79.88909912,"65":79.91190338,"64":79.99189758,"63":79.84400177,"62":79.33719635,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":79.9803009,"65":80.09190369,"64":80.13739777,"63":79.90619659,"62":78.0236969,"61":77.99700165,"60":77.91490173,"59":null},"497":{"66":80.13140106,"65":80.28569794,"64":80.3035965,"63":80.28279877,"62":80.20279694,"61":80.09449768,"60":79.81770325,"59":78.03079987},"498":{"66":80.22270203,"65":80.3986969,"64":80.47679901,"63":80.46269989,"62":80.48509979,"61":80.44480133,"60":80.15650177,"59":78.3085022},"499":{"66":80.37380219,"65":80.49089813,"64":80.56500244,"63":80.62020111,"62":80.76239777,"61":80.78980255,"60":80.66480255,"59":80.28250122},"500":{"66":80.35610199,"65":80.56030273,"64":80.6013031,"63":80.77600098,"62":80.90419769,"61":80.90399933,"60":80.90019989,"59":80.78340149},"501":{"66":80.42620087,"65":80.61889648,"64":80.72730255,"63":80.85320282,"62":80.98329926,"61":81.0,"60":81.03790283,"59":81.06259918},"502":{"66":80.50830078,"65":80.67420197,"64":80.78759766,"63":80.91519928,"62":81.05069733,"61":81.11620331,"60":81.19049835,"59":81.19200134},"503":{"66":80.54570007,"65":80.69869995,"64":80.83270264,"63":80.96230316,"62":81.07879639,"61":81.15979767,"60":81.26119995,"59":81.30770111},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":80.74079895,"63":80.96920013,"62":81.10109711,"61":81.16449738,"60":81.33660126,"59":81.4571991}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":76.80750275,"75":75.62529755,"74":75.73100281,"73":75.85369873,"72":75.97270203,"71":76.06610107,"70":76.16190338,"69":76.22389984,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":77.74980164,"75":77.88310242,"74":78.04119873,"73":78.2539978,"72":78.36489868,"71":78.49410248,"70":79.03250122,"69":78.13600159,"68":76.36660004,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":77.93250275,"75":78.15640259,"74":78.45600128,"73":78.64309692,"72":78.77400208,"71":78.27200317,"70":77.56690216,"69":79.18250275,"68":76.54720306,"67":null},"490":{"77":78.19750214,"76":78.16809845,"75":78.30139923,"74":78.64389801,"73":78.98329926,"72":79.92749786,"71":79.82050323,"70":76.97119904,"69":null,"68":76.75489807,"67":76.77220154},"491":{"77":78.44740295,"76":78.47650146,"75":78.521698,"74":78.77230072,"73":79.06860352,"72":79.23729706,"71":79.30690002,"70":79.2335968,"69":79.29090118,"68":79.26989746,"67":79.27780151},"492":{"77":78.59079742,"76":78.70619965,"75":78.76599884,"74":78.93000031,"73":79.10690308,"72":79.31759644,"71":79.40260315,"70":79.4151001,"69":79.42780304,"68":79.50700378,"67":79.49919891},"493":{"77":78.66760254,"76":78.88610077,"75":78.9681015,"74":79.00740051,"73":79.1427002,"72":79.28410339,"71":79.40809631,"70":79.41680145,"69":79.43589783,"68":79.51439667,"67":79.55860138},"494":{"77":78.7410965,"76":78.95400238,"75":79.01889801,"74":79.09619904,"73":79.97129822,"72":79.31479645,"71":79.36209869,"70":79.40280151,"69":79.46130371,"68":79.540802,"67":79.65370178},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":79.05049896,"74":79.15730286,"73":79.27890015,"72":79.35549927,"71":79.42250061,"70":79.50370026,"69":79.56990051,"68":79.70290375,"67":79.79740143},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":79.47730255,"71":79.5483017,"70":79.65019989,"69":79.7378006,"68":79.83409882,"67":79.90910339}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
ba2d354e-235b-4566-9b5d-819c49c564fb
As an environmental scientist analyzing urban heat trends, I'm curious about which city has shown a more significant shift in maximum annual temperature between Fort Myers, FL, and Tampa, FL, over the historical period and the projected end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1257/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":79.79879761,"64":79.72059631,"63":79.52349854,"62":78.63819885,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":79.88909912,"65":79.91190338,"64":79.99189758,"63":79.84400177,"62":79.33719635,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":79.9803009,"65":80.09190369,"64":80.13739777,"63":79.90619659,"62":78.0236969,"61":77.99700165,"60":77.91490173,"59":null},"497":{"66":80.13140106,"65":80.28569794,"64":80.3035965,"63":80.28279877,"62":80.20279694,"61":80.09449768,"60":79.81770325,"59":78.03079987},"498":{"66":80.22270203,"65":80.3986969,"64":80.47679901,"63":80.46269989,"62":80.48509979,"61":80.44480133,"60":80.15650177,"59":78.3085022},"499":{"66":80.37380219,"65":80.49089813,"64":80.56500244,"63":80.62020111,"62":80.76239777,"61":80.78980255,"60":80.66480255,"59":80.28250122},"500":{"66":80.35610199,"65":80.56030273,"64":80.6013031,"63":80.77600098,"62":80.90419769,"61":80.90399933,"60":80.90019989,"59":80.78340149},"501":{"66":80.42620087,"65":80.61889648,"64":80.72730255,"63":80.85320282,"62":80.98329926,"61":81.0,"60":81.03790283,"59":81.06259918},"502":{"66":80.50830078,"65":80.67420197,"64":80.78759766,"63":80.91519928,"62":81.05069733,"61":81.11620331,"60":81.19049835,"59":81.19200134},"503":{"66":80.54570007,"65":80.69869995,"64":80.83270264,"63":80.96230316,"62":81.07879639,"61":81.15979767,"60":81.26119995,"59":81.30770111},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":80.74079895,"63":80.96920013,"62":81.10109711,"61":81.16449738,"60":81.33660126,"59":81.4571991}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":76.80750275,"75":75.62529755,"74":75.73100281,"73":75.85369873,"72":75.97270203,"71":76.06610107,"70":76.16190338,"69":76.22389984,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":77.74980164,"75":77.88310242,"74":78.04119873,"73":78.2539978,"72":78.36489868,"71":78.49410248,"70":79.03250122,"69":78.13600159,"68":76.36660004,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":77.93250275,"75":78.15640259,"74":78.45600128,"73":78.64309692,"72":78.77400208,"71":78.27200317,"70":77.56690216,"69":79.18250275,"68":76.54720306,"67":null},"490":{"77":78.19750214,"76":78.16809845,"75":78.30139923,"74":78.64389801,"73":78.98329926,"72":79.92749786,"71":79.82050323,"70":76.97119904,"69":null,"68":76.75489807,"67":76.77220154},"491":{"77":78.44740295,"76":78.47650146,"75":78.521698,"74":78.77230072,"73":79.06860352,"72":79.23729706,"71":79.30690002,"70":79.2335968,"69":79.29090118,"68":79.26989746,"67":79.27780151},"492":{"77":78.59079742,"76":78.70619965,"75":78.76599884,"74":78.93000031,"73":79.10690308,"72":79.31759644,"71":79.40260315,"70":79.4151001,"69":79.42780304,"68":79.50700378,"67":79.49919891},"493":{"77":78.66760254,"76":78.88610077,"75":78.9681015,"74":79.00740051,"73":79.1427002,"72":79.28410339,"71":79.40809631,"70":79.41680145,"69":79.43589783,"68":79.51439667,"67":79.55860138},"494":{"77":78.7410965,"76":78.95400238,"75":79.01889801,"74":79.09619904,"73":79.97129822,"72":79.31479645,"71":79.36209869,"70":79.40280151,"69":79.46130371,"68":79.540802,"67":79.65370178},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":79.05049896,"74":79.15730286,"73":79.27890015,"72":79.35549927,"71":79.42250061,"70":79.50370026,"69":79.56990051,"68":79.70290375,"67":79.79740143},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":79.47730255,"71":79.5483017,"70":79.65019989,"69":79.7378006,"68":79.83409882,"67":79.90910339}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
5b8a36e2-0eb9-43ec-b841-baf89be7f15c
As an environmental scientist analyzing urban heat trends, I'm curious about which city has shown a more significant shift in maximum annual temperature between Fort Myers, FL, and Tampa, FL, over the historical period and the projected end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1257/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":79.79879761,"64":79.72059631,"63":79.52349854,"62":78.63819885,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":79.88909912,"65":79.91190338,"64":79.99189758,"63":79.84400177,"62":79.33719635,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":79.9803009,"65":80.09190369,"64":80.13739777,"63":79.90619659,"62":78.0236969,"61":77.99700165,"60":77.91490173,"59":null},"497":{"66":80.13140106,"65":80.28569794,"64":80.3035965,"63":80.28279877,"62":80.20279694,"61":80.09449768,"60":79.81770325,"59":78.03079987},"498":{"66":80.22270203,"65":80.3986969,"64":80.47679901,"63":80.46269989,"62":80.48509979,"61":80.44480133,"60":80.15650177,"59":78.3085022},"499":{"66":80.37380219,"65":80.49089813,"64":80.56500244,"63":80.62020111,"62":80.76239777,"61":80.78980255,"60":80.66480255,"59":80.28250122},"500":{"66":80.35610199,"65":80.56030273,"64":80.6013031,"63":80.77600098,"62":80.90419769,"61":80.90399933,"60":80.90019989,"59":80.78340149},"501":{"66":80.42620087,"65":80.61889648,"64":80.72730255,"63":80.85320282,"62":80.98329926,"61":81.0,"60":81.03790283,"59":81.06259918},"502":{"66":80.50830078,"65":80.67420197,"64":80.78759766,"63":80.91519928,"62":81.05069733,"61":81.11620331,"60":81.19049835,"59":81.19200134},"503":{"66":80.54570007,"65":80.69869995,"64":80.83270264,"63":80.96230316,"62":81.07879639,"61":81.15979767,"60":81.26119995,"59":81.30770111},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":80.74079895,"63":80.96920013,"62":81.10109711,"61":81.16449738,"60":81.33660126,"59":81.4571991}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":76.80750275,"75":75.62529755,"74":75.73100281,"73":75.85369873,"72":75.97270203,"71":76.06610107,"70":76.16190338,"69":76.22389984,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":77.74980164,"75":77.88310242,"74":78.04119873,"73":78.2539978,"72":78.36489868,"71":78.49410248,"70":79.03250122,"69":78.13600159,"68":76.36660004,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":77.93250275,"75":78.15640259,"74":78.45600128,"73":78.64309692,"72":78.77400208,"71":78.27200317,"70":77.56690216,"69":79.18250275,"68":76.54720306,"67":null},"490":{"77":78.19750214,"76":78.16809845,"75":78.30139923,"74":78.64389801,"73":78.98329926,"72":79.92749786,"71":79.82050323,"70":76.97119904,"69":null,"68":76.75489807,"67":76.77220154},"491":{"77":78.44740295,"76":78.47650146,"75":78.521698,"74":78.77230072,"73":79.06860352,"72":79.23729706,"71":79.30690002,"70":79.2335968,"69":79.29090118,"68":79.26989746,"67":79.27780151},"492":{"77":78.59079742,"76":78.70619965,"75":78.76599884,"74":78.93000031,"73":79.10690308,"72":79.31759644,"71":79.40260315,"70":79.4151001,"69":79.42780304,"68":79.50700378,"67":79.49919891},"493":{"77":78.66760254,"76":78.88610077,"75":78.9681015,"74":79.00740051,"73":79.1427002,"72":79.28410339,"71":79.40809631,"70":79.41680145,"69":79.43589783,"68":79.51439667,"67":79.55860138},"494":{"77":78.7410965,"76":78.95400238,"75":79.01889801,"74":79.09619904,"73":79.97129822,"72":79.31479645,"71":79.36209869,"70":79.40280151,"69":79.46130371,"68":79.540802,"67":79.65370178},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":79.05049896,"74":79.15730286,"73":79.27890015,"72":79.35549927,"71":79.42250061,"70":79.50370026,"69":79.56990051,"68":79.70290375,"67":79.79740143},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":79.47730255,"71":79.5483017,"70":79.65019989,"69":79.7378006,"68":79.83409882,"67":79.90910339}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
b99126ac-ba53-48fa-88c4-9e8f15e7b168
As an environmental scientist analyzing urban heat trends, I'm curious about which city has shown a more significant shift in maximum annual temperature between Fort Myers, FL, and Tampa, FL, over the historical period and the projected end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1257/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) The Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a much greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in historical period', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in historical period']
{"494":{"66":null,"65":86.29129791,"64":86.09909821,"63":85.69819641,"62":84.45149994,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":86.53130341,"65":86.47100067,"64":86.47160339,"63":86.17120361,"62":85.46179962,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":86.6638031,"65":86.71929932,"64":86.66809845,"63":86.22080231,"62":83.78410339,"61":83.66349792,"60":83.53089905,"59":null},"497":{"66":86.88680267,"65":86.9897995,"64":86.89759827,"63":86.73889923,"62":86.45359802,"61":86.26280212,"60":85.83170319,"59":83.62339783},"498":{"66":87.01789856,"65":87.15370178,"64":87.15579987,"63":87.03900146,"62":86.96459961,"61":86.80410004,"60":86.25779724,"59":83.87979889},"499":{"66":87.19010162,"65":87.27829742,"64":87.29090118,"63":87.27559662,"62":87.37470245,"61":87.26550293,"60":86.94120026,"59":86.29389954},"500":{"66":87.12000275,"65":87.32089996,"64":87.32180023,"63":87.47740173,"62":87.54370117,"61":87.43730164,"60":87.31340027,"59":87.02120209},"501":{"66":87.16300201,"65":87.32499695,"64":87.44290161,"63":87.55349731,"62":87.64440155,"61":87.57649994,"60":87.54109955,"59":87.41600037},"502":{"66":87.21949768,"65":87.36419678,"64":87.48370361,"63":87.61440277,"62":87.69760132,"61":87.71829987,"60":87.71890259,"59":87.61329651},"503":{"66":87.19830322,"65":87.33630371,"64":87.48269653,"63":87.62819672,"62":87.74340057,"61":87.77500153,"60":87.81150055,"59":87.76190186},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":87.33360291,"63":87.61699677,"62":87.73529816,"61":87.74980164,"60":87.90509796,"59":87.94650269}}
{"494":{"66":null,"65":79.79879761,"64":79.72059631,"63":79.52349854,"62":78.63819885,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"495":{"66":79.88909912,"65":79.91190338,"64":79.99189758,"63":79.84400177,"62":79.33719635,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"66":79.9803009,"65":80.09190369,"64":80.13739777,"63":79.90619659,"62":78.0236969,"61":77.99700165,"60":77.91490173,"59":null},"497":{"66":80.13140106,"65":80.28569794,"64":80.3035965,"63":80.28279877,"62":80.20279694,"61":80.09449768,"60":79.81770325,"59":78.03079987},"498":{"66":80.22270203,"65":80.3986969,"64":80.47679901,"63":80.46269989,"62":80.48509979,"61":80.44480133,"60":80.15650177,"59":78.3085022},"499":{"66":80.37380219,"65":80.49089813,"64":80.56500244,"63":80.62020111,"62":80.76239777,"61":80.78980255,"60":80.66480255,"59":80.28250122},"500":{"66":80.35610199,"65":80.56030273,"64":80.6013031,"63":80.77600098,"62":80.90419769,"61":80.90399933,"60":80.90019989,"59":80.78340149},"501":{"66":80.42620087,"65":80.61889648,"64":80.72730255,"63":80.85320282,"62":80.98329926,"61":81.0,"60":81.03790283,"59":81.06259918},"502":{"66":80.50830078,"65":80.67420197,"64":80.78759766,"63":80.91519928,"62":81.05069733,"61":81.11620331,"60":81.19049835,"59":81.19200134},"503":{"66":80.54570007,"65":80.69869995,"64":80.83270264,"63":80.96230316,"62":81.07879639,"61":81.15979767,"60":81.26119995,"59":81.30770111},"504":{"66":null,"65":null,"64":80.74079895,"63":80.96920013,"62":81.10109711,"61":81.16449738,"60":81.33660126,"59":81.4571991}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":82.73860168,"75":81.7888031,"74":81.84909821,"73":81.95320129,"72":82.03790283,"71":82.10739899,"70":82.16790009,"69":82.2397995,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":83.89790344,"75":83.99089813,"74":84.17220306,"73":84.40679932,"72":84.52670288,"71":84.69020081,"70":85.32099915,"69":84.18199921,"68":82.36710358,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":84.22519684,"75":84.46040344,"74":84.78130341,"73":84.97650146,"72":85.08260345,"71":84.46170044,"70":83.94950104,"69":85.48809814,"68":82.51730347,"67":null},"490":{"77":84.59380341,"76":84.57250214,"75":84.68669891,"74":85.08429718,"73":85.38710022,"72":86.45330048,"71":86.2492981,"70":83.10769653,"69":null,"68":82.70050049,"67":82.69909668},"491":{"77":84.93910217,"76":84.95469666,"75":85.00350189,"74":85.26029968,"73":85.57820129,"72":85.68219757,"71":85.69599915,"70":85.51589966,"69":85.51550293,"68":85.48130035,"67":85.47239685},"492":{"77":85.16850281,"76":85.26170349,"75":85.31569672,"74":85.47039795,"73":85.64569855,"72":85.87809753,"71":85.93840027,"70":85.92089844,"69":85.87989807,"68":85.93579865,"67":85.89289856},"493":{"77":85.25689697,"76":85.48190308,"75":85.58699799,"74":85.58630371,"73":85.73239899,"72":85.93769836,"71":86.03520203,"70":86.00710297,"69":86.01100159,"68":86.05149841,"67":86.05400085},"494":{"77":85.34760284,"76":85.57820129,"75":85.62599945,"74":85.73660278,"73":86.74150085,"72":86.00350189,"71":86.03939819,"70":86.07800293,"69":86.13939667,"68":86.18890381,"67":86.27030182},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":85.73439789,"74":85.86569977,"73":86.00559998,"72":86.07839966,"71":86.15059662,"70":86.23419952,"69":86.30110168,"68":86.42030334,"67":86.49060059},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":86.24189758,"71":86.31240082,"70":86.4190979,"69":86.49500275,"68":86.57990265,"67":86.63249969}}
{"487":{"77":null,"76":76.80750275,"75":75.62529755,"74":75.73100281,"73":75.85369873,"72":75.97270203,"71":76.06610107,"70":76.16190338,"69":76.22389984,"68":null,"67":null},"488":{"77":null,"76":77.74980164,"75":77.88310242,"74":78.04119873,"73":78.2539978,"72":78.36489868,"71":78.49410248,"70":79.03250122,"69":78.13600159,"68":76.36660004,"67":null},"489":{"77":null,"76":77.93250275,"75":78.15640259,"74":78.45600128,"73":78.64309692,"72":78.77400208,"71":78.27200317,"70":77.56690216,"69":79.18250275,"68":76.54720306,"67":null},"490":{"77":78.19750214,"76":78.16809845,"75":78.30139923,"74":78.64389801,"73":78.98329926,"72":79.92749786,"71":79.82050323,"70":76.97119904,"69":null,"68":76.75489807,"67":76.77220154},"491":{"77":78.44740295,"76":78.47650146,"75":78.521698,"74":78.77230072,"73":79.06860352,"72":79.23729706,"71":79.30690002,"70":79.2335968,"69":79.29090118,"68":79.26989746,"67":79.27780151},"492":{"77":78.59079742,"76":78.70619965,"75":78.76599884,"74":78.93000031,"73":79.10690308,"72":79.31759644,"71":79.40260315,"70":79.4151001,"69":79.42780304,"68":79.50700378,"67":79.49919891},"493":{"77":78.66760254,"76":78.88610077,"75":78.9681015,"74":79.00740051,"73":79.1427002,"72":79.28410339,"71":79.40809631,"70":79.41680145,"69":79.43589783,"68":79.51439667,"67":79.55860138},"494":{"77":78.7410965,"76":78.95400238,"75":79.01889801,"74":79.09619904,"73":79.97129822,"72":79.31479645,"71":79.36209869,"70":79.40280151,"69":79.46130371,"68":79.540802,"67":79.65370178},"495":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":79.05049896,"74":79.15730286,"73":79.27890015,"72":79.35549927,"71":79.42250061,"70":79.50370026,"69":79.56990051,"68":79.70290375,"67":79.79740143},"496":{"77":null,"76":null,"75":null,"74":null,"73":null,"72":79.47730255,"71":79.5483017,"70":79.65019989,"69":79.7378006,"68":79.83409882,"67":79.90910339}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
186e88ba-c97a-4f6f-93c7-e80704a55732
As a city planner in Charlotte, NC, preparing for an upcoming environmental impact report, I'm curious about which city has seen a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 125°F during the summer months—Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX—when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
tabular
null
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":89.45798492,"141":89.38520559,"140":89.33666992,"139":90.23955536,"138":91.12098948,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":89.98033396,"141":90.25719961,"140":90.41290538,"139":90.82424672,"138":91.21479034,"137":91.7603658,"136":92.50110372,"135":93.09327443,"134":null},"478":{"143":90.08864848,"142":90.35022481,"141":90.3916804,"140":90.73822784,"139":91.09702301,"138":91.23492686,"137":91.56772868,"136":92.28656006,"135":93.24359131,"134":93.79062907},"479":{"143":90.4715449,"142":90.58521016,"141":90.75126902,"140":91.07529449,"139":91.6210378,"138":91.7088267,"137":91.89215597,"136":92.28401947,"135":92.91343435,"134":93.61058299},"480":{"143":90.80605062,"142":90.67249298,"141":91.06708527,"140":91.59278361,"139":91.97226206,"138":92.44652812,"137":92.47184245,"136":92.61990356,"135":92.8343633,"134":93.26151784},"481":{"143":91.11996714,"142":91.03754425,"141":91.40578461,"140":91.75019073,"139":91.96606445,"138":92.28785451,"137":92.7980779,"136":93.32165782,"135":93.11760203,"134":93.4728419},"482":{"143":91.20727539,"142":91.18673452,"141":91.7526118,"140":92.04035441,"139":92.34963989,"138":92.25216929,"137":92.63973236,"136":92.98084768,"135":93.35458883,"134":93.86599477},"483":{"143":91.30744425,"142":91.32961528,"141":92.03634644,"140":92.55491384,"139":92.44487762,"138":92.38898214,"137":92.48681386,"136":92.83335368,"135":93.25165304,"134":93.81462351},"484":{"143":91.40001424,"142":91.48335012,"141":92.1885732,"140":92.90832011,"139":93.09187063,"138":92.78419749,"137":92.66270955,"136":92.84100596,"135":93.08175151,"134":93.37043254},"485":{"143":91.52228038,"142":91.9004542,"141":92.66552734,"140":93.35417684,"139":93.507665,"138":93.20394389,"137":92.97327677,"136":93.09639486,"135":93.36033376,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":92.18870544,"141":93.23332723,"140":93.87346649,"139":94.02696482,"138":93.75175476,"137":93.56523132,"136":93.4484965,"135":93.7125473,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":104.26004283,"67":104.27422587,"66":104.71524302,"65":105.07711538,"64":105.3049469,"63":105.43315379,"62":105.58296712,"61":105.59477234,"60":105.62835185,"59":105.63521322},"380":{"69":104.24872589,"68":104.20529683,"67":104.27147166,"66":104.66060384,"65":104.94124095,"64":105.13073476,"63":105.39308929,"62":105.65589396,"61":105.60009003,"60":105.59282176,"59":105.63689931},"381":{"69":104.68231455,"68":104.52719625,"67":104.57208761,"66":104.9016037,"65":105.18325043,"64":105.32562764,"63":105.45691172,"62":105.58450572,"61":105.6442159,"60":105.68914286,"59":105.73829142},"382":{"69":104.51274618,"68":104.62084452,"67":104.70028432,"66":104.89001465,"65":105.09442393,"64":105.3665212,"63":105.43612162,"62":105.49339294,"61":105.58650716,"60":105.75151825,"59":105.83447011},"383":{"69":104.36745453,"68":104.84699249,"67":105.08017985,"66":104.96725464,"65":105.16298421,"64":104.69278971,"63":104.96627045,"62":105.52370962,"61":105.47647349,"60":105.60466512,"59":105.58220418},"384":{"69":104.61238352,"68":105.16128286,"67":105.22434235,"66":104.93763224,"65":104.48727671,"64":104.73415629,"63":104.86899312,"62":105.30891164,"61":105.25524902,"60":105.40397135,"59":105.37552897},"385":{"69":104.9188029,"68":105.45729065,"67":105.47927602,"66":105.39281718,"65":105.18344116,"64":104.62691752,"63":104.61546326,"62":105.21126302,"61":105.27413686,"60":105.19931539,"59":105.2102534},"386":{"69":105.21754964,"68":105.4444987,"67":105.55696869,"66":105.67610931,"65":105.46055857,"64":105.32840983,"63":105.15311941,"62":105.01550293,"61":105.10227966,"60":104.9529953,"59":105.48542277},"387":{"69":105.54194387,"68":105.55379232,"67":105.80876923,"66":105.53162384,"65":105.48449198,"64":105.44847616,"63":105.21254222,"62":105.27232869,"61":105.2774531,"60":104.91109975,"59":104.73601023},"388":{"69":105.17012024,"68":105.17998759,"67":105.35989126,"66":105.38344065,"65":105.62269592,"64":105.77224731,"63":null,"62":108.85149129,"61":105.38987478,"60":109.50287374,"59":108.76417033},"389":{"69":105.17116801,"68":105.34819794,"67":105.49271139,"66":105.47119649,"65":105.66152445,"64":109.80835215,"63":109.55023702,"62":109.61615753,"61":109.22366587,"60":109.07183075,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
4db7dc4c-c166-4c9a-abbb-a40519e296a3
As a city planner in Charlotte, NC, preparing for an upcoming environmental impact report, I'm curious about which city has seen a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 125°F during the summer months—Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX—when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1335/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":89.45798492,"141":89.38520559,"140":89.33666992,"139":90.23955536,"138":91.12098948,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":89.98033396,"141":90.25719961,"140":90.41290538,"139":90.82424672,"138":91.21479034,"137":91.7603658,"136":92.50110372,"135":93.09327443,"134":null},"478":{"143":90.08864848,"142":90.35022481,"141":90.3916804,"140":90.73822784,"139":91.09702301,"138":91.23492686,"137":91.56772868,"136":92.28656006,"135":93.24359131,"134":93.79062907},"479":{"143":90.4715449,"142":90.58521016,"141":90.75126902,"140":91.07529449,"139":91.6210378,"138":91.7088267,"137":91.89215597,"136":92.28401947,"135":92.91343435,"134":93.61058299},"480":{"143":90.80605062,"142":90.67249298,"141":91.06708527,"140":91.59278361,"139":91.97226206,"138":92.44652812,"137":92.47184245,"136":92.61990356,"135":92.8343633,"134":93.26151784},"481":{"143":91.11996714,"142":91.03754425,"141":91.40578461,"140":91.75019073,"139":91.96606445,"138":92.28785451,"137":92.7980779,"136":93.32165782,"135":93.11760203,"134":93.4728419},"482":{"143":91.20727539,"142":91.18673452,"141":91.7526118,"140":92.04035441,"139":92.34963989,"138":92.25216929,"137":92.63973236,"136":92.98084768,"135":93.35458883,"134":93.86599477},"483":{"143":91.30744425,"142":91.32961528,"141":92.03634644,"140":92.55491384,"139":92.44487762,"138":92.38898214,"137":92.48681386,"136":92.83335368,"135":93.25165304,"134":93.81462351},"484":{"143":91.40001424,"142":91.48335012,"141":92.1885732,"140":92.90832011,"139":93.09187063,"138":92.78419749,"137":92.66270955,"136":92.84100596,"135":93.08175151,"134":93.37043254},"485":{"143":91.52228038,"142":91.9004542,"141":92.66552734,"140":93.35417684,"139":93.507665,"138":93.20394389,"137":92.97327677,"136":93.09639486,"135":93.36033376,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":92.18870544,"141":93.23332723,"140":93.87346649,"139":94.02696482,"138":93.75175476,"137":93.56523132,"136":93.4484965,"135":93.7125473,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":104.26004283,"67":104.27422587,"66":104.71524302,"65":105.07711538,"64":105.3049469,"63":105.43315379,"62":105.58296712,"61":105.59477234,"60":105.62835185,"59":105.63521322},"380":{"69":104.24872589,"68":104.20529683,"67":104.27147166,"66":104.66060384,"65":104.94124095,"64":105.13073476,"63":105.39308929,"62":105.65589396,"61":105.60009003,"60":105.59282176,"59":105.63689931},"381":{"69":104.68231455,"68":104.52719625,"67":104.57208761,"66":104.9016037,"65":105.18325043,"64":105.32562764,"63":105.45691172,"62":105.58450572,"61":105.6442159,"60":105.68914286,"59":105.73829142},"382":{"69":104.51274618,"68":104.62084452,"67":104.70028432,"66":104.89001465,"65":105.09442393,"64":105.3665212,"63":105.43612162,"62":105.49339294,"61":105.58650716,"60":105.75151825,"59":105.83447011},"383":{"69":104.36745453,"68":104.84699249,"67":105.08017985,"66":104.96725464,"65":105.16298421,"64":104.69278971,"63":104.96627045,"62":105.52370962,"61":105.47647349,"60":105.60466512,"59":105.58220418},"384":{"69":104.61238352,"68":105.16128286,"67":105.22434235,"66":104.93763224,"65":104.48727671,"64":104.73415629,"63":104.86899312,"62":105.30891164,"61":105.25524902,"60":105.40397135,"59":105.37552897},"385":{"69":104.9188029,"68":105.45729065,"67":105.47927602,"66":105.39281718,"65":105.18344116,"64":104.62691752,"63":104.61546326,"62":105.21126302,"61":105.27413686,"60":105.19931539,"59":105.2102534},"386":{"69":105.21754964,"68":105.4444987,"67":105.55696869,"66":105.67610931,"65":105.46055857,"64":105.32840983,"63":105.15311941,"62":105.01550293,"61":105.10227966,"60":104.9529953,"59":105.48542277},"387":{"69":105.54194387,"68":105.55379232,"67":105.80876923,"66":105.53162384,"65":105.48449198,"64":105.44847616,"63":105.21254222,"62":105.27232869,"61":105.2774531,"60":104.91109975,"59":104.73601023},"388":{"69":105.17012024,"68":105.17998759,"67":105.35989126,"66":105.38344065,"65":105.62269592,"64":105.77224731,"63":null,"62":108.85149129,"61":105.38987478,"60":109.50287374,"59":108.76417033},"389":{"69":105.17116801,"68":105.34819794,"67":105.49271139,"66":105.47119649,"65":105.66152445,"64":109.80835215,"63":109.55023702,"62":109.61615753,"61":109.22366587,"60":109.07183075,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
1a4f9d71-9ea3-4deb-84f4-1cff4911ccd6
As a city planner in Charlotte, NC, preparing for an upcoming environmental impact report, I'm curious about which city has seen a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 125°F during the summer months—Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX—when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1335/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":89.45798492,"141":89.38520559,"140":89.33666992,"139":90.23955536,"138":91.12098948,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":89.98033396,"141":90.25719961,"140":90.41290538,"139":90.82424672,"138":91.21479034,"137":91.7603658,"136":92.50110372,"135":93.09327443,"134":null},"478":{"143":90.08864848,"142":90.35022481,"141":90.3916804,"140":90.73822784,"139":91.09702301,"138":91.23492686,"137":91.56772868,"136":92.28656006,"135":93.24359131,"134":93.79062907},"479":{"143":90.4715449,"142":90.58521016,"141":90.75126902,"140":91.07529449,"139":91.6210378,"138":91.7088267,"137":91.89215597,"136":92.28401947,"135":92.91343435,"134":93.61058299},"480":{"143":90.80605062,"142":90.67249298,"141":91.06708527,"140":91.59278361,"139":91.97226206,"138":92.44652812,"137":92.47184245,"136":92.61990356,"135":92.8343633,"134":93.26151784},"481":{"143":91.11996714,"142":91.03754425,"141":91.40578461,"140":91.75019073,"139":91.96606445,"138":92.28785451,"137":92.7980779,"136":93.32165782,"135":93.11760203,"134":93.4728419},"482":{"143":91.20727539,"142":91.18673452,"141":91.7526118,"140":92.04035441,"139":92.34963989,"138":92.25216929,"137":92.63973236,"136":92.98084768,"135":93.35458883,"134":93.86599477},"483":{"143":91.30744425,"142":91.32961528,"141":92.03634644,"140":92.55491384,"139":92.44487762,"138":92.38898214,"137":92.48681386,"136":92.83335368,"135":93.25165304,"134":93.81462351},"484":{"143":91.40001424,"142":91.48335012,"141":92.1885732,"140":92.90832011,"139":93.09187063,"138":92.78419749,"137":92.66270955,"136":92.84100596,"135":93.08175151,"134":93.37043254},"485":{"143":91.52228038,"142":91.9004542,"141":92.66552734,"140":93.35417684,"139":93.507665,"138":93.20394389,"137":92.97327677,"136":93.09639486,"135":93.36033376,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":92.18870544,"141":93.23332723,"140":93.87346649,"139":94.02696482,"138":93.75175476,"137":93.56523132,"136":93.4484965,"135":93.7125473,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":104.26004283,"67":104.27422587,"66":104.71524302,"65":105.07711538,"64":105.3049469,"63":105.43315379,"62":105.58296712,"61":105.59477234,"60":105.62835185,"59":105.63521322},"380":{"69":104.24872589,"68":104.20529683,"67":104.27147166,"66":104.66060384,"65":104.94124095,"64":105.13073476,"63":105.39308929,"62":105.65589396,"61":105.60009003,"60":105.59282176,"59":105.63689931},"381":{"69":104.68231455,"68":104.52719625,"67":104.57208761,"66":104.9016037,"65":105.18325043,"64":105.32562764,"63":105.45691172,"62":105.58450572,"61":105.6442159,"60":105.68914286,"59":105.73829142},"382":{"69":104.51274618,"68":104.62084452,"67":104.70028432,"66":104.89001465,"65":105.09442393,"64":105.3665212,"63":105.43612162,"62":105.49339294,"61":105.58650716,"60":105.75151825,"59":105.83447011},"383":{"69":104.36745453,"68":104.84699249,"67":105.08017985,"66":104.96725464,"65":105.16298421,"64":104.69278971,"63":104.96627045,"62":105.52370962,"61":105.47647349,"60":105.60466512,"59":105.58220418},"384":{"69":104.61238352,"68":105.16128286,"67":105.22434235,"66":104.93763224,"65":104.48727671,"64":104.73415629,"63":104.86899312,"62":105.30891164,"61":105.25524902,"60":105.40397135,"59":105.37552897},"385":{"69":104.9188029,"68":105.45729065,"67":105.47927602,"66":105.39281718,"65":105.18344116,"64":104.62691752,"63":104.61546326,"62":105.21126302,"61":105.27413686,"60":105.19931539,"59":105.2102534},"386":{"69":105.21754964,"68":105.4444987,"67":105.55696869,"66":105.67610931,"65":105.46055857,"64":105.32840983,"63":105.15311941,"62":105.01550293,"61":105.10227966,"60":104.9529953,"59":105.48542277},"387":{"69":105.54194387,"68":105.55379232,"67":105.80876923,"66":105.53162384,"65":105.48449198,"64":105.44847616,"63":105.21254222,"62":105.27232869,"61":105.2774531,"60":104.91109975,"59":104.73601023},"388":{"69":105.17012024,"68":105.17998759,"67":105.35989126,"66":105.38344065,"65":105.62269592,"64":105.77224731,"63":null,"62":108.85149129,"61":105.38987478,"60":109.50287374,"59":108.76417033},"389":{"69":105.17116801,"68":105.34819794,"67":105.49271139,"66":105.47119649,"65":105.66152445,"64":109.80835215,"63":109.55023702,"62":109.61615753,"61":109.22366587,"60":109.07183075,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
7b7f8fcf-c7ba-4114-ba7f-ae84913c84e0
As a city planner in Charlotte, NC, preparing for an upcoming environmental impact report, I'm curious about which city has seen a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index exceeding 125°F during the summer months—Charlotte, NC, or Houston, TX—when comparing historical data to mid-century projections?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1335/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Charlotte, NC, United States experienced a greater change than Houston, TX, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Charlotte, NC, United States and Houston, TX, United States.', '(d) Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change than Charlotte, NC, United States.']
['Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in historical period', 'Charlotte, NC, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in historical period', 'Houston, TX, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"476":{"143":null,"142":83.43277232,"141":83.42940013,"140":83.35821533,"139":84.01877085,"138":84.78377279,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":83.88170624,"141":84.08683268,"140":84.23316447,"139":84.55910238,"138":84.88878377,"137":85.29949443,"136":85.84629313,"135":86.37991587,"134":null},"478":{"143":83.91579183,"142":84.17280833,"141":84.25309499,"140":84.53925069,"139":84.84012604,"138":84.91368612,"137":85.11159007,"136":85.66218821,"135":86.48003896,"134":86.95243581},"479":{"143":84.26789856,"142":84.40750885,"141":84.52728271,"140":84.83858999,"139":85.31779989,"138":85.77753957,"137":85.40328217,"136":85.75976563,"135":86.23381805,"134":86.80650584},"480":{"143":84.58238729,"142":84.54541016,"141":84.8180364,"140":85.24022929,"139":85.55967712,"138":85.86476898,"137":85.8942922,"136":85.95421346,"135":86.16873678,"134":86.52603149},"481":{"143":84.82811991,"142":84.776179,"141":85.08839925,"140":85.40878042,"139":85.57221731,"138":86.2074,"137":86.11143748,"136":86.61604309,"135":86.36598714,"134":86.68269348},"482":{"143":84.9224294,"142":84.89337667,"141":85.37743632,"140":85.61322021,"139":85.94602966,"138":85.7185262,"137":86.03278097,"136":86.31576538,"135":86.59827169,"134":86.9469045},"483":{"143":84.9463501,"142":84.96901957,"141":85.53240204,"140":85.97399394,"139":85.90773265,"138":85.80135854,"137":85.93763733,"136":86.19639333,"135":86.50043742,"134":86.88419851},"484":{"143":85.0308787,"142":85.04027812,"141":85.60866547,"140":86.20348867,"139":86.36103821,"138":86.12636566,"137":86.04015859,"136":86.1727829,"135":86.34405772,"134":86.54230499},"485":{"143":85.04999288,"142":85.35334524,"141":85.95329539,"140":86.53878784,"139":86.68929291,"138":86.46916707,"137":86.28328451,"136":86.37280273,"135":86.56254323,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":85.56819407,"141":86.38408915,"140":86.93279012,"139":87.08815257,"138":86.89114126,"137":86.70300293,"136":86.64039612,"135":86.89763133,"134":null}}
{"476":{"143":null,"142":89.45798492,"141":89.38520559,"140":89.33666992,"139":90.23955536,"138":91.12098948,"137":null,"136":null,"135":null,"134":null},"477":{"143":null,"142":89.98033396,"141":90.25719961,"140":90.41290538,"139":90.82424672,"138":91.21479034,"137":91.7603658,"136":92.50110372,"135":93.09327443,"134":null},"478":{"143":90.08864848,"142":90.35022481,"141":90.3916804,"140":90.73822784,"139":91.09702301,"138":91.23492686,"137":91.56772868,"136":92.28656006,"135":93.24359131,"134":93.79062907},"479":{"143":90.4715449,"142":90.58521016,"141":90.75126902,"140":91.07529449,"139":91.6210378,"138":91.7088267,"137":91.89215597,"136":92.28401947,"135":92.91343435,"134":93.61058299},"480":{"143":90.80605062,"142":90.67249298,"141":91.06708527,"140":91.59278361,"139":91.97226206,"138":92.44652812,"137":92.47184245,"136":92.61990356,"135":92.8343633,"134":93.26151784},"481":{"143":91.11996714,"142":91.03754425,"141":91.40578461,"140":91.75019073,"139":91.96606445,"138":92.28785451,"137":92.7980779,"136":93.32165782,"135":93.11760203,"134":93.4728419},"482":{"143":91.20727539,"142":91.18673452,"141":91.7526118,"140":92.04035441,"139":92.34963989,"138":92.25216929,"137":92.63973236,"136":92.98084768,"135":93.35458883,"134":93.86599477},"483":{"143":91.30744425,"142":91.32961528,"141":92.03634644,"140":92.55491384,"139":92.44487762,"138":92.38898214,"137":92.48681386,"136":92.83335368,"135":93.25165304,"134":93.81462351},"484":{"143":91.40001424,"142":91.48335012,"141":92.1885732,"140":92.90832011,"139":93.09187063,"138":92.78419749,"137":92.66270955,"136":92.84100596,"135":93.08175151,"134":93.37043254},"485":{"143":91.52228038,"142":91.9004542,"141":92.66552734,"140":93.35417684,"139":93.507665,"138":93.20394389,"137":92.97327677,"136":93.09639486,"135":93.36033376,"134":null},"486":{"143":null,"142":92.18870544,"141":93.23332723,"140":93.87346649,"139":94.02696482,"138":93.75175476,"137":93.56523132,"136":93.4484965,"135":93.7125473,"134":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":95.23483276,"67":95.2700119,"66":95.4501063,"65":95.73351542,"64":95.97081248,"63":96.10933177,"62":96.14376831,"61":96.09974162,"60":96.05211385,"59":96.00342306},"380":{"69":95.25221252,"68":95.17941793,"67":95.23960114,"66":95.45422363,"65":95.6717453,"64":95.81086222,"63":96.01213582,"62":96.11326345,"61":96.05982208,"60":96.0303243,"59":96.02519226},"381":{"69":95.48995717,"68":95.44609324,"67":95.5365626,"66":95.68028259,"65":95.86732992,"64":95.97798157,"63":96.07874552,"62":96.1758728,"61":96.11070251,"60":95.97163645,"59":95.98881022},"382":{"69":95.39598846,"68":95.54947408,"67":95.66752625,"66":95.79652913,"65":95.97105153,"64":96.1031545,"63":96.12795512,"62":96.13078308,"61":96.07928212,"60":95.93278249,"59":95.85951742},"383":{"69":95.24755351,"68":95.61108907,"67":95.82061005,"66":95.94770304,"65":96.39149729,"64":96.44357808,"63":96.36548869,"62":96.03669484,"61":95.98111216,"60":95.90209707,"59":95.8197759},"384":{"69":95.28951518,"68":95.64895376,"67":95.86978149,"66":95.9778595,"65":96.38129934,"64":96.40131632,"63":96.27190145,"62":95.89191437,"61":95.80121358,"60":95.72038269,"59":95.62214915},"385":{"69":95.39648183,"68":95.68600464,"67":95.82009125,"66":95.97604116,"65":96.0326004,"64":96.24373881,"63":95.82896678,"62":95.78509013,"61":95.65454356,"60":95.57142639,"59":95.49517568},"386":{"69":95.4391276,"68":95.60432688,"67":95.65179698,"66":95.75610606,"65":95.84377035,"64":95.79595693,"63":95.74820455,"62":95.60800934,"61":95.43557231,"60":95.2898763,"59":95.13865407},"387":{"69":95.52290853,"68":95.52096812,"67":95.58945465,"66":95.58002981,"65":95.57767741,"64":95.5463562,"63":95.45464834,"62":95.38054403,"61":95.16368866,"60":94.80255636,"59":94.1392924},"388":{"69":95.45360311,"68":95.43634796,"67":95.46976217,"66":95.28214264,"65":95.26015472,"64":95.00762177,"63":null,"62":95.54750315,"61":94.76472727,"60":95.54117839,"59":95.29338074},"389":{"69":95.22100321,"68":95.26028951,"67":95.22780863,"66":95.15766907,"65":94.98281097,"64":96.12052663,"63":95.91392263,"62":95.79514567,"61":95.60730743,"60":95.52641042,"59":null}}
{"379":{"69":null,"68":104.26004283,"67":104.27422587,"66":104.71524302,"65":105.07711538,"64":105.3049469,"63":105.43315379,"62":105.58296712,"61":105.59477234,"60":105.62835185,"59":105.63521322},"380":{"69":104.24872589,"68":104.20529683,"67":104.27147166,"66":104.66060384,"65":104.94124095,"64":105.13073476,"63":105.39308929,"62":105.65589396,"61":105.60009003,"60":105.59282176,"59":105.63689931},"381":{"69":104.68231455,"68":104.52719625,"67":104.57208761,"66":104.9016037,"65":105.18325043,"64":105.32562764,"63":105.45691172,"62":105.58450572,"61":105.6442159,"60":105.68914286,"59":105.73829142},"382":{"69":104.51274618,"68":104.62084452,"67":104.70028432,"66":104.89001465,"65":105.09442393,"64":105.3665212,"63":105.43612162,"62":105.49339294,"61":105.58650716,"60":105.75151825,"59":105.83447011},"383":{"69":104.36745453,"68":104.84699249,"67":105.08017985,"66":104.96725464,"65":105.16298421,"64":104.69278971,"63":104.96627045,"62":105.52370962,"61":105.47647349,"60":105.60466512,"59":105.58220418},"384":{"69":104.61238352,"68":105.16128286,"67":105.22434235,"66":104.93763224,"65":104.48727671,"64":104.73415629,"63":104.86899312,"62":105.30891164,"61":105.25524902,"60":105.40397135,"59":105.37552897},"385":{"69":104.9188029,"68":105.45729065,"67":105.47927602,"66":105.39281718,"65":105.18344116,"64":104.62691752,"63":104.61546326,"62":105.21126302,"61":105.27413686,"60":105.19931539,"59":105.2102534},"386":{"69":105.21754964,"68":105.4444987,"67":105.55696869,"66":105.67610931,"65":105.46055857,"64":105.32840983,"63":105.15311941,"62":105.01550293,"61":105.10227966,"60":104.9529953,"59":105.48542277},"387":{"69":105.54194387,"68":105.55379232,"67":105.80876923,"66":105.53162384,"65":105.48449198,"64":105.44847616,"63":105.21254222,"62":105.27232869,"61":105.2774531,"60":104.91109975,"59":104.73601023},"388":{"69":105.17012024,"68":105.17998759,"67":105.35989126,"66":105.38344065,"65":105.62269592,"64":105.77224731,"63":null,"62":108.85149129,"61":105.38987478,"60":109.50287374,"59":108.76417033},"389":{"69":105.17116801,"68":105.34819794,"67":105.49271139,"66":105.47119649,"65":105.66152445,"64":109.80835215,"63":109.55023702,"62":109.61615753,"61":109.22366587,"60":109.07183075,"59":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 125 F", "location1": "Charlotte, NC, United States", "location2": "Houston, TX, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Charlotte, NC, United States or Houston, TX, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 125 F throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
a59f768f-0559-41e5-9e16-672ec64b0248
As an environmental scientist analyzing future weather patterns for a municipal report, I'm curious: which city, New Orleans or Washington, DC, is projected to see a larger shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century and midway through the century under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) The Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.26229858,"75":65.27449799,"74":63.5483017,"73":64.37220001,"72":58.18379974,"71":58.18510056,"70":null},"423":{"76":68.78859711,"75":69.311203,"74":59.61809921,"73":60.67210007,"72":59.79359818,"71":57.37440109,"70":63.1385994},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.55039978,"73":55.59830093,"72":56.29040146,"71":59.18209839,"70":65.4260025},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":58.51380157,"73":57.54759979,"72":61.81499863,"71":67.29820251,"70":65.6371994},"426":{"76":79.26319885,"75":74.36640167,"74":64.25109863,"73":64.90309906,"72":69.05590057,"71":73.42070007,"70":73.96710205},"427":{"76":75.71469879,"75":74.91829681,"74":67.4464035,"73":70.96089935,"72":75.97319794,"71":77.87419891,"70":84.3635025},"428":{"76":80.08940125,"75":84.49900055,"74":75.04699707,"73":73.25440216,"72":76.3187027,"71":75.15529633,"70":76.14800262},"429":{"76":87.11599731,"75":87.91880035,"74":null,"73":70.36250305,"72":71.61530304,"71":69.98269653,"70":69.81099701}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":41.40890121,"181":42.13890076,"180":43.56840134,"179":43.36449814,"178":42.50650024,"177":42.80960083,"176":null},"494":{"182":41.59469986,"181":42.72109985,"180":43.00799942,"179":42.26100159,"178":41.67559814,"177":42.6719017,"176":43.52190018},"495":{"182":43.44179916,"181":43.63370132,"180":43.96900177,"179":45.87919998,"178":44.99369812,"177":44.98419952,"176":45.4048996},"496":{"182":45.56349945,"181":46.00139999,"180":45.91540146,"179":46.43489838,"178":45.79190063,"177":45.84429932,"176":44.0143013},"497":{"182":49.79729843,"181":46.21419907,"180":46.18450165,"179":46.79550171,"178":44.92050171,"177":43.77809906,"176":44.2242012},"498":{"182":56.917099,"181":48.5583992,"180":45.22230148,"179":45.68019867,"178":44.71279907,"177":44.59389877,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":52.22900009,"180":45.43730164,"179":45.74380112,"178":46.05540085,"177":45.60440063,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
abf12c82-5964-4188-bb71-24f147bdb5d7
As an environmental scientist analyzing future weather patterns for a municipal report, I'm curious: which city, New Orleans or Washington, DC, is projected to see a larger shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century and midway through the century under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1377/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) The Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.26229858,"75":65.27449799,"74":63.5483017,"73":64.37220001,"72":58.18379974,"71":58.18510056,"70":null},"423":{"76":68.78859711,"75":69.311203,"74":59.61809921,"73":60.67210007,"72":59.79359818,"71":57.37440109,"70":63.1385994},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.55039978,"73":55.59830093,"72":56.29040146,"71":59.18209839,"70":65.4260025},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":58.51380157,"73":57.54759979,"72":61.81499863,"71":67.29820251,"70":65.6371994},"426":{"76":79.26319885,"75":74.36640167,"74":64.25109863,"73":64.90309906,"72":69.05590057,"71":73.42070007,"70":73.96710205},"427":{"76":75.71469879,"75":74.91829681,"74":67.4464035,"73":70.96089935,"72":75.97319794,"71":77.87419891,"70":84.3635025},"428":{"76":80.08940125,"75":84.49900055,"74":75.04699707,"73":73.25440216,"72":76.3187027,"71":75.15529633,"70":76.14800262},"429":{"76":87.11599731,"75":87.91880035,"74":null,"73":70.36250305,"72":71.61530304,"71":69.98269653,"70":69.81099701}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":41.40890121,"181":42.13890076,"180":43.56840134,"179":43.36449814,"178":42.50650024,"177":42.80960083,"176":null},"494":{"182":41.59469986,"181":42.72109985,"180":43.00799942,"179":42.26100159,"178":41.67559814,"177":42.6719017,"176":43.52190018},"495":{"182":43.44179916,"181":43.63370132,"180":43.96900177,"179":45.87919998,"178":44.99369812,"177":44.98419952,"176":45.4048996},"496":{"182":45.56349945,"181":46.00139999,"180":45.91540146,"179":46.43489838,"178":45.79190063,"177":45.84429932,"176":44.0143013},"497":{"182":49.79729843,"181":46.21419907,"180":46.18450165,"179":46.79550171,"178":44.92050171,"177":43.77809906,"176":44.2242012},"498":{"182":56.917099,"181":48.5583992,"180":45.22230148,"179":45.68019867,"178":44.71279907,"177":44.59389877,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":52.22900009,"180":45.43730164,"179":45.74380112,"178":46.05540085,"177":45.60440063,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
e1a24f36-211a-4565-b6bf-be584c7c9e17
As an environmental scientist analyzing future weather patterns for a municipal report, I'm curious: which city, New Orleans or Washington, DC, is projected to see a larger shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century and midway through the century under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1377/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) The Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.26229858,"75":65.27449799,"74":63.5483017,"73":64.37220001,"72":58.18379974,"71":58.18510056,"70":null},"423":{"76":68.78859711,"75":69.311203,"74":59.61809921,"73":60.67210007,"72":59.79359818,"71":57.37440109,"70":63.1385994},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.55039978,"73":55.59830093,"72":56.29040146,"71":59.18209839,"70":65.4260025},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":58.51380157,"73":57.54759979,"72":61.81499863,"71":67.29820251,"70":65.6371994},"426":{"76":79.26319885,"75":74.36640167,"74":64.25109863,"73":64.90309906,"72":69.05590057,"71":73.42070007,"70":73.96710205},"427":{"76":75.71469879,"75":74.91829681,"74":67.4464035,"73":70.96089935,"72":75.97319794,"71":77.87419891,"70":84.3635025},"428":{"76":80.08940125,"75":84.49900055,"74":75.04699707,"73":73.25440216,"72":76.3187027,"71":75.15529633,"70":76.14800262},"429":{"76":87.11599731,"75":87.91880035,"74":null,"73":70.36250305,"72":71.61530304,"71":69.98269653,"70":69.81099701}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":41.40890121,"181":42.13890076,"180":43.56840134,"179":43.36449814,"178":42.50650024,"177":42.80960083,"176":null},"494":{"182":41.59469986,"181":42.72109985,"180":43.00799942,"179":42.26100159,"178":41.67559814,"177":42.6719017,"176":43.52190018},"495":{"182":43.44179916,"181":43.63370132,"180":43.96900177,"179":45.87919998,"178":44.99369812,"177":44.98419952,"176":45.4048996},"496":{"182":45.56349945,"181":46.00139999,"180":45.91540146,"179":46.43489838,"178":45.79190063,"177":45.84429932,"176":44.0143013},"497":{"182":49.79729843,"181":46.21419907,"180":46.18450165,"179":46.79550171,"178":44.92050171,"177":43.77809906,"176":44.2242012},"498":{"182":56.917099,"181":48.5583992,"180":45.22230148,"179":45.68019867,"178":44.71279907,"177":44.59389877,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":52.22900009,"180":45.43730164,"179":45.74380112,"178":46.05540085,"177":45.60440063,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
99b408c7-4c15-46bd-a600-7f88bf2ff739
As an environmental scientist analyzing future weather patterns for a municipal report, I'm curious: which city, New Orleans or Washington, DC, is projected to see a larger shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century and midway through the century under the RCP8.5 scenario?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1377/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) The Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.26229858,"75":65.27449799,"74":63.5483017,"73":64.37220001,"72":58.18379974,"71":58.18510056,"70":null},"423":{"76":68.78859711,"75":69.311203,"74":59.61809921,"73":60.67210007,"72":59.79359818,"71":57.37440109,"70":63.1385994},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.55039978,"73":55.59830093,"72":56.29040146,"71":59.18209839,"70":65.4260025},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":58.51380157,"73":57.54759979,"72":61.81499863,"71":67.29820251,"70":65.6371994},"426":{"76":79.26319885,"75":74.36640167,"74":64.25109863,"73":64.90309906,"72":69.05590057,"71":73.42070007,"70":73.96710205},"427":{"76":75.71469879,"75":74.91829681,"74":67.4464035,"73":70.96089935,"72":75.97319794,"71":77.87419891,"70":84.3635025},"428":{"76":80.08940125,"75":84.49900055,"74":75.04699707,"73":73.25440216,"72":76.3187027,"71":75.15529633,"70":76.14800262},"429":{"76":87.11599731,"75":87.91880035,"74":null,"73":70.36250305,"72":71.61530304,"71":69.98269653,"70":69.81099701}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":41.40890121,"181":42.13890076,"180":43.56840134,"179":43.36449814,"178":42.50650024,"177":42.80960083,"176":null},"494":{"182":41.59469986,"181":42.72109985,"180":43.00799942,"179":42.26100159,"178":41.67559814,"177":42.6719017,"176":43.52190018},"495":{"182":43.44179916,"181":43.63370132,"180":43.96900177,"179":45.87919998,"178":44.99369812,"177":44.98419952,"176":45.4048996},"496":{"182":45.56349945,"181":46.00139999,"180":45.91540146,"179":46.43489838,"178":45.79190063,"177":45.84429932,"176":44.0143013},"497":{"182":49.79729843,"181":46.21419907,"180":46.18450165,"179":46.79550171,"178":44.92050171,"177":43.77809906,"176":44.2242012},"498":{"182":56.917099,"181":48.5583992,"180":45.22230148,"179":45.68019867,"178":44.71279907,"177":44.59389877,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":52.22900009,"180":45.43730164,"179":45.74380112,"178":46.05540085,"177":45.60440063,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
cd5d6494-af03-4bb2-bddd-307c923fb3ab
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns in urban areas, I'm interested in understanding which location, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation during the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the mid-century period (RCP4.5).
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":null},"423":{"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875},"426":{"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076},"427":{"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965},"428":{"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266},"429":{"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":null,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":null},"494":{"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954},"495":{"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082},"496":{"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997},"497":{"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006},"498":{"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
a1a78daf-51b7-404f-9c94-b27717d2b9d4
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns in urban areas, I'm interested in understanding which location, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation during the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the mid-century period (RCP4.5).
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":null},"423":{"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875},"426":{"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076},"427":{"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965},"428":{"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266},"429":{"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":null,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":null},"494":{"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954},"495":{"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082},"496":{"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997},"497":{"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006},"498":{"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
90cbf47f-50b7-452e-a278-4df78ad3461d
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns in urban areas, I'm interested in understanding which location, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation during the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the mid-century period (RCP4.5).
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":null},"423":{"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875},"426":{"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076},"427":{"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965},"428":{"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266},"429":{"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":null,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":null},"494":{"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954},"495":{"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082},"496":{"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997},"497":{"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006},"498":{"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
d7841e1c-520d-4a7f-8a22-2122111a4c34
As a hydrologist analyzing precipitation patterns in urban areas, I'm interested in understanding which location, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has undergone a more significant shift in annual total precipitation during the end-century period (RCP8.5) compared to the mid-century period (RCP4.5).
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1382/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"422":{"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":null},"423":{"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375},"426":{"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734},"427":{"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912},"428":{"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319},"429":{"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":null,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337}}
{"422":{"76":64.06950378,"75":68.29190063,"74":69.00959778,"73":63.62139893,"72":57.62039948,"71":57.05559921,"70":null},"423":{"76":69.40350342,"75":74.38269806,"74":64.57289886,"73":62.79090118,"72":58.78639984,"71":56.82160187,"70":62.87990189},"424":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":63.85029984,"73":58.01250076,"72":55.99240112,"71":60.0617981,"70":67.72930145},"425":{"76":null,"75":null,"74":62.07749939,"73":59.21139908,"72":61.30709839,"71":69.36869812,"70":68.53559875},"426":{"76":81.6638031,"75":78.90260315,"74":68.7614975,"73":66.70079803,"72":68.77559662,"71":77.21640015,"70":76.38890076},"427":{"76":75.35489655,"75":76.39129639,"74":71.4394989,"73":73.21369934,"72":77.80670166,"71":80.83930206,"70":87.0535965},"428":{"76":80.26940155,"75":87.69180298,"74":80.18440247,"73":78.4940033,"72":81.32550049,"71":79.35929871,"70":79.07710266},"429":{"76":88.94419861,"75":94.03919983,"74":null,"73":73.40370178,"72":75.55020142,"71":73.21880341,"70":71.91280365}}
{"493":{"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":null},"494":{"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053},"495":{"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074},"496":{"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181},"497":{"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965},"498":{"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":null}}
{"493":{"182":38.31489944,"181":39.05780029,"180":39.63209915,"179":39.80699921,"178":39.08060074,"177":39.21060181,"176":null},"494":{"182":38.31029892,"181":39.01399994,"180":39.30899811,"179":38.32429886,"178":38.02730179,"177":38.5909996,"176":39.29249954},"495":{"182":39.61169815,"181":39.56840134,"180":39.79510117,"179":41.74649811,"178":40.82690048,"177":40.45550156,"176":40.43600082},"496":{"182":40.70970154,"181":41.16239929,"180":42.11180115,"179":43.02000046,"178":42.34740067,"177":41.80730057,"176":39.81949997},"497":{"182":44.58089828,"181":41.58430099,"180":42.6853981,"179":43.77629852,"178":41.93209839,"177":40.33470154,"176":40.7378006},"498":{"182":53.24140167,"181":44.51459885,"180":41.3227005,"179":41.53969955,"178":41.04949951,"177":41.17160034,"176":null},"499":{"182":null,"181":49.7696991,"180":42.54759979,"179":42.52149963,"178":42.41270065,"177":41.85570145,"176":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
af615cc7-4c25-4929-8d62-4c9249d6af31
As a wildfire management specialist assessing historical trends to improve fire preparedness strategies, I'm curious about which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index from the historical winter period to the mid-century winter period.
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":0.74277366,"152":0.23805761,"151":0.15294239,"150":0.26917284,"149":1.09486008,"148":1.43673662,"147":1.21372016,"146":0.87851852,"145":1.51313992,"144":2.46272428},"301":{"153":6.19878189,"152":5.13764609,"151":2.63703704,"150":2.16631687,"149":3.04169548,"148":4.48893828,"147":3.93273251,"146":3.5151646,"145":3.33855556,"144":2.48749383},"302":{"153":14.59880244,"152":16.32656379,"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079,"144":5.60481071},"303":{"153":12.72179835,"152":13.95704937,"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633,"144":8.1621605},"304":{"153":8.69697943,"152":9.38610698,"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387,"144":6.75050617},"305":{"153":7.94553909,"152":8.26490945,"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284,"144":6.6319712},"306":{"153":7.39690533,"152":7.31585597,"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354,"144":6.36681893},"307":{"153":6.90602468,"152":7.12504116,"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107,"144":6.02158436},"308":{"153":6.65170781,"152":7.03202469,"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411,"144":6.80648147},"309":{"153":6.57932098,"152":6.81685184,"151":7.76637038,"150":7.70740741,"149":7.67554733,"148":7.57467489,"147":7.37604526,"146":7.23520987,"145":7.4831358,"144":7.69293827}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":15.00014815,"119":13.84296297,"118":13.68950618,"117":13.74041564,"116":13.3228066,"115":14.41336626},"226":{"124":13.69472018,"123":12.56260494,"122":10.06852674,"121":8.86421398,"120":9.84801235,"119":10.44176542,"118":12.49264197,"117":14.33587655,"116":14.91920989,"115":15.21065431},"227":{"124":13.62586422,"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":16.85301235,"115":16.87755144},"228":{"124":15.80789298,"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":16.86258437,"115":17.97228393},"229":{"124":17.04438272,"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":15.58988065,"115":18.56308642},"230":{"124":12.85020577,"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678,"115":16.34881892},"231":{"124":7.51051853,"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852,"115":15.75949382},"232":{"124":5.73338684,"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695,"115":17.61787653},"233":{"124":12.91895061,"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288,"115":19.07162552},"234":{"124":15.94016051,"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":22.72218522,"118":23.38521399,"117":20.81798353,"116":19.41541562,"115":19.67698764},"235":{"124":15.13302058,"123":16.31099178,"122":17.34167078,"121":16.9689506,"120":17.49991771,"119":20.84355556,"118":22.23996295,"117":19.4802922,"116":18.04554324,"115":17.85291359}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
205e4106-50b3-4460-99c5-d7ee1a6d34db
As a wildfire management specialist assessing historical trends to improve fire preparedness strategies, I'm curious about which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index from the historical winter period to the mid-century winter period.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":0.74277366,"152":0.23805761,"151":0.15294239,"150":0.26917284,"149":1.09486008,"148":1.43673662,"147":1.21372016,"146":0.87851852,"145":1.51313992,"144":2.46272428},"301":{"153":6.19878189,"152":5.13764609,"151":2.63703704,"150":2.16631687,"149":3.04169548,"148":4.48893828,"147":3.93273251,"146":3.5151646,"145":3.33855556,"144":2.48749383},"302":{"153":14.59880244,"152":16.32656379,"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079,"144":5.60481071},"303":{"153":12.72179835,"152":13.95704937,"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633,"144":8.1621605},"304":{"153":8.69697943,"152":9.38610698,"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387,"144":6.75050617},"305":{"153":7.94553909,"152":8.26490945,"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284,"144":6.6319712},"306":{"153":7.39690533,"152":7.31585597,"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354,"144":6.36681893},"307":{"153":6.90602468,"152":7.12504116,"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107,"144":6.02158436},"308":{"153":6.65170781,"152":7.03202469,"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411,"144":6.80648147},"309":{"153":6.57932098,"152":6.81685184,"151":7.76637038,"150":7.70740741,"149":7.67554733,"148":7.57467489,"147":7.37604526,"146":7.23520987,"145":7.4831358,"144":7.69293827}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":15.00014815,"119":13.84296297,"118":13.68950618,"117":13.74041564,"116":13.3228066,"115":14.41336626},"226":{"124":13.69472018,"123":12.56260494,"122":10.06852674,"121":8.86421398,"120":9.84801235,"119":10.44176542,"118":12.49264197,"117":14.33587655,"116":14.91920989,"115":15.21065431},"227":{"124":13.62586422,"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":16.85301235,"115":16.87755144},"228":{"124":15.80789298,"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":16.86258437,"115":17.97228393},"229":{"124":17.04438272,"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":15.58988065,"115":18.56308642},"230":{"124":12.85020577,"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678,"115":16.34881892},"231":{"124":7.51051853,"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852,"115":15.75949382},"232":{"124":5.73338684,"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695,"115":17.61787653},"233":{"124":12.91895061,"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288,"115":19.07162552},"234":{"124":15.94016051,"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":22.72218522,"118":23.38521399,"117":20.81798353,"116":19.41541562,"115":19.67698764},"235":{"124":15.13302058,"123":16.31099178,"122":17.34167078,"121":16.9689506,"120":17.49991771,"119":20.84355556,"118":22.23996295,"117":19.4802922,"116":18.04554324,"115":17.85291359}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
e7134a69-f7f4-4f90-a3f7-38af9df90222
As a wildfire management specialist assessing historical trends to improve fire preparedness strategies, I'm curious about which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index from the historical winter period to the mid-century winter period.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":0.74277366,"152":0.23805761,"151":0.15294239,"150":0.26917284,"149":1.09486008,"148":1.43673662,"147":1.21372016,"146":0.87851852,"145":1.51313992,"144":2.46272428},"301":{"153":6.19878189,"152":5.13764609,"151":2.63703704,"150":2.16631687,"149":3.04169548,"148":4.48893828,"147":3.93273251,"146":3.5151646,"145":3.33855556,"144":2.48749383},"302":{"153":14.59880244,"152":16.32656379,"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079,"144":5.60481071},"303":{"153":12.72179835,"152":13.95704937,"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633,"144":8.1621605},"304":{"153":8.69697943,"152":9.38610698,"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387,"144":6.75050617},"305":{"153":7.94553909,"152":8.26490945,"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284,"144":6.6319712},"306":{"153":7.39690533,"152":7.31585597,"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354,"144":6.36681893},"307":{"153":6.90602468,"152":7.12504116,"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107,"144":6.02158436},"308":{"153":6.65170781,"152":7.03202469,"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411,"144":6.80648147},"309":{"153":6.57932098,"152":6.81685184,"151":7.76637038,"150":7.70740741,"149":7.67554733,"148":7.57467489,"147":7.37604526,"146":7.23520987,"145":7.4831358,"144":7.69293827}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":15.00014815,"119":13.84296297,"118":13.68950618,"117":13.74041564,"116":13.3228066,"115":14.41336626},"226":{"124":13.69472018,"123":12.56260494,"122":10.06852674,"121":8.86421398,"120":9.84801235,"119":10.44176542,"118":12.49264197,"117":14.33587655,"116":14.91920989,"115":15.21065431},"227":{"124":13.62586422,"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":16.85301235,"115":16.87755144},"228":{"124":15.80789298,"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":16.86258437,"115":17.97228393},"229":{"124":17.04438272,"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":15.58988065,"115":18.56308642},"230":{"124":12.85020577,"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678,"115":16.34881892},"231":{"124":7.51051853,"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852,"115":15.75949382},"232":{"124":5.73338684,"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695,"115":17.61787653},"233":{"124":12.91895061,"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288,"115":19.07162552},"234":{"124":15.94016051,"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":22.72218522,"118":23.38521399,"117":20.81798353,"116":19.41541562,"115":19.67698764},"235":{"124":15.13302058,"123":16.31099178,"122":17.34167078,"121":16.9689506,"120":17.49991771,"119":20.84355556,"118":22.23996295,"117":19.4802922,"116":18.04554324,"115":17.85291359}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
c695233c-a44c-43ab-bb27-90db3b3446de
As a wildfire management specialist assessing historical trends to improve fire preparedness strategies, I'm curious about which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index from the historical winter period to the mid-century winter period.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1331/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in winter in historical period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"300":{"153":0.74277366,"152":0.23805761,"151":0.15294239,"150":0.26917284,"149":1.09486008,"148":1.43673662,"147":1.21372016,"146":0.87851852,"145":1.51313992,"144":2.46272428},"301":{"153":6.19878189,"152":5.13764609,"151":2.63703704,"150":2.16631687,"149":3.04169548,"148":4.48893828,"147":3.93273251,"146":3.5151646,"145":3.33855556,"144":2.48749383},"302":{"153":14.59880244,"152":16.32656379,"151":11.74920577,"150":7.60482716,"149":8.42380659,"148":8.9835679,"147":7.08197943,"146":6.54614404,"145":6.85767079,"144":5.60481071},"303":{"153":12.72179835,"152":13.95704937,"151":12.75854321,"150":9.94796297,"149":11.08291769,"148":10.73301235,"147":8.08702058,"146":7.21123046,"145":8.02522633,"144":8.1621605},"304":{"153":8.69697943,"152":9.38610698,"151":9.66055554,"150":8.71909876,"149":8.4580823,"148":8.00743621,"147":7.68312347,"146":7.55511111,"145":7.31742387,"144":6.75050617},"305":{"153":7.94553909,"152":8.26490945,"151":8.49112756,"150":7.9259465,"149":7.76679012,"148":6.96782305,"147":6.80649383,"146":7.2680535,"145":7.09517284,"144":6.6319712},"306":{"153":7.39690533,"152":7.31585597,"151":8.04269547,"150":7.97132099,"149":7.67288478,"148":7.2975391,"147":6.75369548,"146":6.6413786,"145":6.53998354,"144":6.36681893},"307":{"153":6.90602468,"152":7.12504116,"151":8.10249794,"150":7.69686009,"149":7.32295886,"148":7.12569548,"147":6.62246914,"146":6.30976132,"145":6.15318107,"144":6.02158436},"308":{"153":6.65170781,"152":7.03202469,"151":7.90444856,"150":7.64428396,"149":7.43207408,"148":7.08623045,"147":6.89619342,"146":6.6842716,"145":6.73400411,"144":6.80648147},"309":{"153":6.57932098,"152":6.81685184,"151":7.76637038,"150":7.70740741,"149":7.67554733,"148":7.57467489,"147":7.37604526,"146":7.23520987,"145":7.4831358,"144":7.69293827}}
{"300":{"153":0.73388477,"152":0.26495062,"151":0.16771193,"150":0.27639918,"149":1.064107,"148":1.40790946,"147":1.17744856,"146":0.90275309,"145":1.46406173,"144":2.56577778},"301":{"153":6.27541152,"152":5.15816873,"151":2.71539095,"150":2.35530864,"149":3.20551851,"148":4.69993415,"147":4.02837037,"146":3.60083539,"145":3.2438107,"144":2.45975308},"302":{"153":15.28106174,"152":16.98067487,"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634,"144":5.92223458},"303":{"153":12.17372015,"152":13.35514816,"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321,"144":8.18342387},"304":{"153":7.91968725,"152":8.41045268,"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505,"144":6.45156378},"305":{"153":7.20004939,"152":7.36792594,"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304,"144":6.11553498},"306":{"153":6.86505763,"152":6.49375308,"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342,"144":6.03055968},"307":{"153":6.39559259,"152":6.18652675,"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239,"144":5.72393827},"308":{"153":6.13699588,"152":6.00001646,"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239,"144":6.24867077},"309":{"153":6.02425103,"152":5.8293745,"151":6.4480535,"150":6.51002469,"149":6.40579012,"148":6.29065433,"147":6.19721811,"146":6.15858024,"145":6.45670371,"144":6.83510699}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":15.00014815,"119":13.84296297,"118":13.68950618,"117":13.74041564,"116":13.3228066,"115":14.41336626},"226":{"124":13.69472018,"123":12.56260494,"122":10.06852674,"121":8.86421398,"120":9.84801235,"119":10.44176542,"118":12.49264197,"117":14.33587655,"116":14.91920989,"115":15.21065431},"227":{"124":13.62586422,"123":11.41131276,"122":7.56398765,"121":3.91878601,"120":3.99700412,"119":7.53763375,"118":11.25480246,"117":14.65879836,"116":16.85301235,"115":16.87755144},"228":{"124":15.80789298,"123":13.4309712,"122":10.09638682,"121":5.68857201,"120":3.76208642,"119":6.29461317,"118":11.09642388,"117":13.81434979,"116":16.86258437,"115":17.97228393},"229":{"124":17.04438272,"123":15.78931276,"122":16.16111111,"121":13.9521852,"120":10.71537449,"119":10.00844446,"118":11.64111935,"117":12.53991357,"116":15.58988065,"115":18.56308642},"230":{"124":12.85020577,"123":12.92035804,"122":12.89863785,"121":17.04832099,"120":17.32994652,"119":16.15663375,"118":15.55859257,"117":15.01733745,"116":15.58645678,"115":16.34881892},"231":{"124":7.51051853,"123":6.21012758,"122":8.09411524,"121":12.37630042,"120":16.08417284,"119":17.23351031,"118":16.9970782,"117":16.27013169,"116":16.3221852,"115":15.75949382},"232":{"124":5.73338684,"123":5.96131687,"122":8.88637448,"121":14.84661729,"120":19.65290536,"119":20.32774076,"118":19.16835802,"117":17.9860247,"116":18.29417695,"115":17.61787653},"233":{"124":12.91895061,"123":14.25125514,"122":16.6074609,"121":19.7984486,"120":23.09657614,"119":24.43312345,"118":22.99402058,"117":20.79512758,"116":20.0840288,"115":19.07162552},"234":{"124":15.94016051,"123":18.29379012,"122":19.91464197,"121":20.01327161,"120":20.16311521,"119":22.72218522,"118":23.38521399,"117":20.81798353,"116":19.41541562,"115":19.67698764},"235":{"124":15.13302058,"123":16.31099178,"122":17.34167078,"121":16.9689506,"120":17.49991771,"119":20.84355556,"118":22.23996295,"117":19.4802922,"116":18.04554324,"115":17.85291359}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":14.5962181,"119":13.87482302,"118":13.69257614,"117":14.04617696,"116":13.85017285,"115":14.54924691},"226":{"124":13.68327162,"123":12.74751441,"122":10.88620577,"121":9.90905351,"120":10.3767284,"119":10.48446913,"118":12.24955967,"117":13.9553457,"116":15.10527574,"115":15.51918517},"227":{"124":13.57388066,"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":16.31520985,"115":17.04337861},"228":{"124":15.45579011,"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":16.2894321,"115":17.4208107},"229":{"124":15.98295062,"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":16.30266666,"115":18.36709055},"230":{"124":12.06080659,"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416,"115":16.58946503},"231":{"124":7.60051852,"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891,"115":15.7327572},"232":{"124":6.27711111,"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373,"115":17.41684773},"233":{"124":12.92009465,"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791,"115":19.08715639},"234":{"124":15.52918109,"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":21.72960495,"118":22.34787656,"117":20.01644856,"116":18.81010287,"115":19.64920575},"235":{"124":14.59628807,"123":15.52639094,"122":16.67922632,"121":16.58699589,"120":17.13055143,"119":20.10877367,"118":21.28747736,"117":19.21178602,"116":18.1742963,"115":18.14905349}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "winter in historical period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout winter in historical period and winter in mid-century period?
06792e05-4efe-4982-ac1c-337d589dcb0a
As a climate scientist presenting at a conference about regional precipitation trends, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has seen a more significant shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century under both RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
tabular
null
48
(c)
['(a) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"192":{"226":155.50999451,"225":124.45200348,"224":95.87259674,"223":79.69819641,"222":75.26460266,"221":69.32050323,"220":null},"193":{"226":124.8010025,"225":93.97910309,"224":77.74469757,"223":69.58000183,"222":69.23519897,"221":67.9885025,"220":null},"194":{"226":90.13770294,"225":75.82330322,"224":67.12740326,"223":62.17490005,"222":61.96289825,"221":62.15589905,"220":63.33909988},"195":{"226":70.1760025,"225":69.61799622,"224":62.62099838,"223":57.68980026,"222":57.30250168,"221":57.27759933,"220":61.92860031},"196":{"226":null,"225":63.20140076,"224":68.71340179,"223":67.69400024,"222":54.12609863,"221":52.10129929,"220":56.2262001},"197":{"226":null,"225":54.60449982,"224":53.53250122,"223":53.13069916,"222":53.23279953,"221":50.59000015,"220":51.75370026}}
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.71959686,"73":65.16359711,"72":66.19660187,"71":63.20940018,"70":62.93439865,"69":63.97320175,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":65.57420349,"73":61.7057991,"72":63.68379974,"71":60.96210098,"70":56.92089844,"69":65.55999756,"68":81.44960022},"489":{"75":49.19139862,"74":50.3810997,"73":50.34059906,"72":50.4919014,"71":55.26309967,"70":59.71879959,"69":58.99530029,"68":67.83779907},"490":{"75":41.52709961,"74":43.75569916,"73":48.0583992,"72":48.89030075,"71":56.59400177,"70":72.10250092,"69":null,"68":61.32569885},"491":{"75":39.07659912,"74":38.58919907,"73":40.57759857,"72":45.79940033,"71":48.20399857,"70":52.27730179,"69":59.07450104,"68":57.4966011},"492":{"75":39.20669937,"74":40.21640015,"73":40.52840042,"72":41.57740021,"71":43.27299881,"70":44.44910049,"69":46.72359848,"68":48.35449982},"493":{"75":35.78070068,"74":37.51710129,"73":35.74980164,"72":36.28079987,"71":40.10189819,"70":40.50619888,"69":40.66730118,"68":43.14199829},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":35.48249817,"72":37.94599915,"71":37.15579987,"70":38.77759933,"69":37.22380066,"68":39.43870163}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
87649e88-d4ee-4edd-8f38-92e6485d1c8e
As a climate scientist presenting at a conference about regional precipitation trends, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has seen a more significant shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century under both RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1341/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"192":{"226":155.50999451,"225":124.45200348,"224":95.87259674,"223":79.69819641,"222":75.26460266,"221":69.32050323,"220":null},"193":{"226":124.8010025,"225":93.97910309,"224":77.74469757,"223":69.58000183,"222":69.23519897,"221":67.9885025,"220":null},"194":{"226":90.13770294,"225":75.82330322,"224":67.12740326,"223":62.17490005,"222":61.96289825,"221":62.15589905,"220":63.33909988},"195":{"226":70.1760025,"225":69.61799622,"224":62.62099838,"223":57.68980026,"222":57.30250168,"221":57.27759933,"220":61.92860031},"196":{"226":null,"225":63.20140076,"224":68.71340179,"223":67.69400024,"222":54.12609863,"221":52.10129929,"220":56.2262001},"197":{"226":null,"225":54.60449982,"224":53.53250122,"223":53.13069916,"222":53.23279953,"221":50.59000015,"220":51.75370026}}
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.71959686,"73":65.16359711,"72":66.19660187,"71":63.20940018,"70":62.93439865,"69":63.97320175,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":65.57420349,"73":61.7057991,"72":63.68379974,"71":60.96210098,"70":56.92089844,"69":65.55999756,"68":81.44960022},"489":{"75":49.19139862,"74":50.3810997,"73":50.34059906,"72":50.4919014,"71":55.26309967,"70":59.71879959,"69":58.99530029,"68":67.83779907},"490":{"75":41.52709961,"74":43.75569916,"73":48.0583992,"72":48.89030075,"71":56.59400177,"70":72.10250092,"69":null,"68":61.32569885},"491":{"75":39.07659912,"74":38.58919907,"73":40.57759857,"72":45.79940033,"71":48.20399857,"70":52.27730179,"69":59.07450104,"68":57.4966011},"492":{"75":39.20669937,"74":40.21640015,"73":40.52840042,"72":41.57740021,"71":43.27299881,"70":44.44910049,"69":46.72359848,"68":48.35449982},"493":{"75":35.78070068,"74":37.51710129,"73":35.74980164,"72":36.28079987,"71":40.10189819,"70":40.50619888,"69":40.66730118,"68":43.14199829},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":35.48249817,"72":37.94599915,"71":37.15579987,"70":38.77759933,"69":37.22380066,"68":39.43870163}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
c12ef0e3-7f0b-4ec3-8f6b-1192397c06b5
As a climate scientist presenting at a conference about regional precipitation trends, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has seen a more significant shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century under both RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1341/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"192":{"226":155.50999451,"225":124.45200348,"224":95.87259674,"223":79.69819641,"222":75.26460266,"221":69.32050323,"220":null},"193":{"226":124.8010025,"225":93.97910309,"224":77.74469757,"223":69.58000183,"222":69.23519897,"221":67.9885025,"220":null},"194":{"226":90.13770294,"225":75.82330322,"224":67.12740326,"223":62.17490005,"222":61.96289825,"221":62.15589905,"220":63.33909988},"195":{"226":70.1760025,"225":69.61799622,"224":62.62099838,"223":57.68980026,"222":57.30250168,"221":57.27759933,"220":61.92860031},"196":{"226":null,"225":63.20140076,"224":68.71340179,"223":67.69400024,"222":54.12609863,"221":52.10129929,"220":56.2262001},"197":{"226":null,"225":54.60449982,"224":53.53250122,"223":53.13069916,"222":53.23279953,"221":50.59000015,"220":51.75370026}}
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.71959686,"73":65.16359711,"72":66.19660187,"71":63.20940018,"70":62.93439865,"69":63.97320175,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":65.57420349,"73":61.7057991,"72":63.68379974,"71":60.96210098,"70":56.92089844,"69":65.55999756,"68":81.44960022},"489":{"75":49.19139862,"74":50.3810997,"73":50.34059906,"72":50.4919014,"71":55.26309967,"70":59.71879959,"69":58.99530029,"68":67.83779907},"490":{"75":41.52709961,"74":43.75569916,"73":48.0583992,"72":48.89030075,"71":56.59400177,"70":72.10250092,"69":null,"68":61.32569885},"491":{"75":39.07659912,"74":38.58919907,"73":40.57759857,"72":45.79940033,"71":48.20399857,"70":52.27730179,"69":59.07450104,"68":57.4966011},"492":{"75":39.20669937,"74":40.21640015,"73":40.52840042,"72":41.57740021,"71":43.27299881,"70":44.44910049,"69":46.72359848,"68":48.35449982},"493":{"75":35.78070068,"74":37.51710129,"73":35.74980164,"72":36.28079987,"71":40.10189819,"70":40.50619888,"69":40.66730118,"68":43.14199829},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":35.48249817,"72":37.94599915,"71":37.15579987,"70":38.77759933,"69":37.22380066,"68":39.43870163}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
18c1b155-eb0f-4c59-b578-63a3586a9ef7
As a climate scientist presenting at a conference about regional precipitation trends, I would like to know which city, Olympia, WA, or Tampa, FL, has seen a more significant shift in annual total precipitation by the end of the century under both RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1341/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(c)
['(a) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Olympia, WA, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) Olympia, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Olympia, WA, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Olympia, WA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"192":{"226":155.50999451,"225":124.45200348,"224":95.87259674,"223":79.69819641,"222":75.26460266,"221":69.32050323,"220":null},"193":{"226":124.8010025,"225":93.97910309,"224":77.74469757,"223":69.58000183,"222":69.23519897,"221":67.9885025,"220":null},"194":{"226":90.13770294,"225":75.82330322,"224":67.12740326,"223":62.17490005,"222":61.96289825,"221":62.15589905,"220":63.33909988},"195":{"226":70.1760025,"225":69.61799622,"224":62.62099838,"223":57.68980026,"222":57.30250168,"221":57.27759933,"220":61.92860031},"196":{"226":null,"225":63.20140076,"224":68.71340179,"223":67.69400024,"222":54.12609863,"221":52.10129929,"220":56.2262001},"197":{"226":null,"225":54.60449982,"224":53.53250122,"223":53.13069916,"222":53.23279953,"221":50.59000015,"220":51.75370026}}
{"192":{"226":119.79399872,"225":98.29160309,"224":76.73079681,"223":63.76079941,"222":60.85200119,"221":55.42419815,"220":null},"193":{"226":95.12969971,"225":72.15280151,"224":60.04859924,"223":53.37870026,"222":53.43180084,"221":54.47809982,"220":null},"194":{"226":67.67579651,"225":58.8769989,"224":51.7947998,"223":47.49269867,"222":46.7478981,"221":48.07099915,"220":50.95159912},"195":{"226":52.73989868,"225":54.65779877,"224":49.13660049,"223":44.5182991,"222":43.6908989,"221":43.21350098,"220":47.03720093},"196":{"226":null,"225":49.08480072,"224":55.90159988,"223":56.04980087,"222":42.06489944,"221":40.12879944,"220":41.07590103},"197":{"226":null,"225":41.88499832,"224":41.88790131,"223":41.80789948,"222":42.48720169,"221":40.95119858,"220":39.58549881}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.71959686,"73":65.16359711,"72":66.19660187,"71":63.20940018,"70":62.93439865,"69":63.97320175,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":65.57420349,"73":61.7057991,"72":63.68379974,"71":60.96210098,"70":56.92089844,"69":65.55999756,"68":81.44960022},"489":{"75":49.19139862,"74":50.3810997,"73":50.34059906,"72":50.4919014,"71":55.26309967,"70":59.71879959,"69":58.99530029,"68":67.83779907},"490":{"75":41.52709961,"74":43.75569916,"73":48.0583992,"72":48.89030075,"71":56.59400177,"70":72.10250092,"69":null,"68":61.32569885},"491":{"75":39.07659912,"74":38.58919907,"73":40.57759857,"72":45.79940033,"71":48.20399857,"70":52.27730179,"69":59.07450104,"68":57.4966011},"492":{"75":39.20669937,"74":40.21640015,"73":40.52840042,"72":41.57740021,"71":43.27299881,"70":44.44910049,"69":46.72359848,"68":48.35449982},"493":{"75":35.78070068,"74":37.51710129,"73":35.74980164,"72":36.28079987,"71":40.10189819,"70":40.50619888,"69":40.66730118,"68":43.14199829},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":35.48249817,"72":37.94599915,"71":37.15579987,"70":38.77759933,"69":37.22380066,"68":39.43870163}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":87.74330139,"73":75.58679962,"72":74.6568985,"71":70.11759949,"70":70.31410217,"69":70.86209869,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":84.16480255,"73":78.22100067,"72":79.00930023,"71":76.71029663,"70":71.01509857,"69":80.1115036,"68":88.67410278},"489":{"75":62.95560074,"74":63.53450012,"73":63.44169998,"72":64.2039032,"71":67.04219818,"70":67.37449646,"69":70.53350067,"68":78.4910965},"490":{"75":51.87179947,"74":54.53070068,"73":59.56100082,"72":61.75839996,"71":73.03749847,"70":86.01599884,"69":null,"68":67.15029907},"491":{"75":49.92229843,"74":49.02310181,"73":50.92679977,"72":57.21110153,"71":60.46310043,"70":65.2634964,"69":72.22720337,"68":71.32089996},"492":{"75":49.82429886,"74":50.57289886,"73":50.0766983,"72":51.91249847,"71":53.53250122,"70":55.19860077,"69":58.83369827,"68":61.90859985},"493":{"75":44.69120026,"74":46.94919968,"73":45.69039917,"72":45.36009979,"71":47.94049835,"70":48.76549911,"69":50.72359848,"68":53.91740036},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":44.06909943,"72":48.3205986,"71":44.56600189,"70":46.07920074,"69":44.6515007,"68":47.99620056}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "Olympia, WA, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Olympia, WA, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
03430eee-21a3-4cea-a9eb-037e4e195a5b
As an environmental scientist analyzing temperature trends in Florida, I need to know which city, Fort Myers or Tampa, experienced a greater variation in maximum annual temperatures during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP4.5 scenario.
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.25279999,"63":82.04599762,"62":81.51760101,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.40239716,"63":82.06620026,"62":79.95269775,"61":79.89779663,"60":79.81089783,"59":null},"497":{"64":82.6160965,"63":82.50309753,"62":82.37509918,"61":82.21820068,"60":81.88159943,"59":79.93479919},"498":{"64":82.79170227,"63":82.72389984,"62":82.69470215,"61":82.59760284,"60":82.24780273,"59":80.15640259},"499":{"64":82.85990143,"63":82.81240082,"62":82.93219757,"61":82.938797,"60":82.77429962,"59":82.29389954},"500":{"64":82.73670197,"63":82.91490173,"62":83.05750275,"61":83.02819824,"60":83.00930023,"59":82.8321991},"501":{"64":82.81349945,"63":82.95269775,"62":83.10269928,"61":83.10919952,"60":83.1269989,"59":83.09609985},"502":{"64":82.8986969,"63":83.0388031,"62":83.2233963,"61":83.22239685,"60":83.26480103,"59":83.20800018}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.66940308,"73":77.80599976,"72":77.93229675,"71":78.05470276,"70":78.15450287,"69":78.21829987,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":79.98059845,"73":80.27919769,"72":80.47239685,"71":80.62449646,"70":81.15149689,"69":80.15299988,"68":78.37200165},"489":{"75":80.16249847,"74":80.47049713,"73":80.72429657,"72":80.88510132,"71":80.41410065,"70":79.63700104,"69":81.28399658,"68":78.50530243},"490":{"75":80.39320374,"74":80.72779846,"73":81.07150269,"72":82.0789032,"71":81.92620087,"70":79.00309753,"69":null,"68":78.67169952},"491":{"75":80.68990326,"74":80.93379974,"73":81.2276001,"72":81.40529633,"71":81.4253006,"70":81.33519745,"69":81.40200043,"68":81.34809875},"492":{"75":81.01950073,"74":81.09719849,"73":81.24939728,"72":81.49479675,"71":81.58039856,"70":81.60289764,"69":81.61710358,"68":81.68990326},"493":{"75":81.21459961,"74":81.17520142,"73":81.3286972,"72":81.50229645,"71":81.58609772,"70":81.63289642,"69":81.62120056,"68":81.68979645},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.23249817,"72":81.51930237,"71":81.53700256,"70":81.60150146,"69":81.68900299,"68":81.82820129}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
7beb01bf-0a31-41a2-b276-91cdfbc90a71
As an environmental scientist analyzing temperature trends in Florida, I need to know which city, Fort Myers or Tampa, experienced a greater variation in maximum annual temperatures during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP4.5 scenario.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1254/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.25279999,"63":82.04599762,"62":81.51760101,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.40239716,"63":82.06620026,"62":79.95269775,"61":79.89779663,"60":79.81089783,"59":null},"497":{"64":82.6160965,"63":82.50309753,"62":82.37509918,"61":82.21820068,"60":81.88159943,"59":79.93479919},"498":{"64":82.79170227,"63":82.72389984,"62":82.69470215,"61":82.59760284,"60":82.24780273,"59":80.15640259},"499":{"64":82.85990143,"63":82.81240082,"62":82.93219757,"61":82.938797,"60":82.77429962,"59":82.29389954},"500":{"64":82.73670197,"63":82.91490173,"62":83.05750275,"61":83.02819824,"60":83.00930023,"59":82.8321991},"501":{"64":82.81349945,"63":82.95269775,"62":83.10269928,"61":83.10919952,"60":83.1269989,"59":83.09609985},"502":{"64":82.8986969,"63":83.0388031,"62":83.2233963,"61":83.22239685,"60":83.26480103,"59":83.20800018}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.66940308,"73":77.80599976,"72":77.93229675,"71":78.05470276,"70":78.15450287,"69":78.21829987,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":79.98059845,"73":80.27919769,"72":80.47239685,"71":80.62449646,"70":81.15149689,"69":80.15299988,"68":78.37200165},"489":{"75":80.16249847,"74":80.47049713,"73":80.72429657,"72":80.88510132,"71":80.41410065,"70":79.63700104,"69":81.28399658,"68":78.50530243},"490":{"75":80.39320374,"74":80.72779846,"73":81.07150269,"72":82.0789032,"71":81.92620087,"70":79.00309753,"69":null,"68":78.67169952},"491":{"75":80.68990326,"74":80.93379974,"73":81.2276001,"72":81.40529633,"71":81.4253006,"70":81.33519745,"69":81.40200043,"68":81.34809875},"492":{"75":81.01950073,"74":81.09719849,"73":81.24939728,"72":81.49479675,"71":81.58039856,"70":81.60289764,"69":81.61710358,"68":81.68990326},"493":{"75":81.21459961,"74":81.17520142,"73":81.3286972,"72":81.50229645,"71":81.58609772,"70":81.63289642,"69":81.62120056,"68":81.68979645},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.23249817,"72":81.51930237,"71":81.53700256,"70":81.60150146,"69":81.68900299,"68":81.82820129}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
6c3cfa95-726e-4917-8ed3-ca21707908f8
As an environmental scientist analyzing temperature trends in Florida, I need to know which city, Fort Myers or Tampa, experienced a greater variation in maximum annual temperatures during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP4.5 scenario.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1254/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.25279999,"63":82.04599762,"62":81.51760101,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.40239716,"63":82.06620026,"62":79.95269775,"61":79.89779663,"60":79.81089783,"59":null},"497":{"64":82.6160965,"63":82.50309753,"62":82.37509918,"61":82.21820068,"60":81.88159943,"59":79.93479919},"498":{"64":82.79170227,"63":82.72389984,"62":82.69470215,"61":82.59760284,"60":82.24780273,"59":80.15640259},"499":{"64":82.85990143,"63":82.81240082,"62":82.93219757,"61":82.938797,"60":82.77429962,"59":82.29389954},"500":{"64":82.73670197,"63":82.91490173,"62":83.05750275,"61":83.02819824,"60":83.00930023,"59":82.8321991},"501":{"64":82.81349945,"63":82.95269775,"62":83.10269928,"61":83.10919952,"60":83.1269989,"59":83.09609985},"502":{"64":82.8986969,"63":83.0388031,"62":83.2233963,"61":83.22239685,"60":83.26480103,"59":83.20800018}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.66940308,"73":77.80599976,"72":77.93229675,"71":78.05470276,"70":78.15450287,"69":78.21829987,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":79.98059845,"73":80.27919769,"72":80.47239685,"71":80.62449646,"70":81.15149689,"69":80.15299988,"68":78.37200165},"489":{"75":80.16249847,"74":80.47049713,"73":80.72429657,"72":80.88510132,"71":80.41410065,"70":79.63700104,"69":81.28399658,"68":78.50530243},"490":{"75":80.39320374,"74":80.72779846,"73":81.07150269,"72":82.0789032,"71":81.92620087,"70":79.00309753,"69":null,"68":78.67169952},"491":{"75":80.68990326,"74":80.93379974,"73":81.2276001,"72":81.40529633,"71":81.4253006,"70":81.33519745,"69":81.40200043,"68":81.34809875},"492":{"75":81.01950073,"74":81.09719849,"73":81.24939728,"72":81.49479675,"71":81.58039856,"70":81.60289764,"69":81.61710358,"68":81.68990326},"493":{"75":81.21459961,"74":81.17520142,"73":81.3286972,"72":81.50229645,"71":81.58609772,"70":81.63289642,"69":81.62120056,"68":81.68979645},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.23249817,"72":81.51930237,"71":81.53700256,"70":81.60150146,"69":81.68900299,"68":81.82820129}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
23cad2ae-01c8-454b-89a9-44089f726c40
As an environmental scientist analyzing temperature trends in Florida, I need to know which city, Fort Myers or Tampa, experienced a greater variation in maximum annual temperatures during the mid-century and end-century periods under the RCP4.5 scenario.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1254/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(c) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP4.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.25279999,"63":82.04599762,"62":81.51760101,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.40239716,"63":82.06620026,"62":79.95269775,"61":79.89779663,"60":79.81089783,"59":null},"497":{"64":82.6160965,"63":82.50309753,"62":82.37509918,"61":82.21820068,"60":81.88159943,"59":79.93479919},"498":{"64":82.79170227,"63":82.72389984,"62":82.69470215,"61":82.59760284,"60":82.24780273,"59":80.15640259},"499":{"64":82.85990143,"63":82.81240082,"62":82.93219757,"61":82.938797,"60":82.77429962,"59":82.29389954},"500":{"64":82.73670197,"63":82.91490173,"62":83.05750275,"61":83.02819824,"60":83.00930023,"59":82.8321991},"501":{"64":82.81349945,"63":82.95269775,"62":83.10269928,"61":83.10919952,"60":83.1269989,"59":83.09609985},"502":{"64":82.8986969,"63":83.0388031,"62":83.2233963,"61":83.22239685,"60":83.26480103,"59":83.20800018}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.66940308,"73":77.80599976,"72":77.93229675,"71":78.05470276,"70":78.15450287,"69":78.21829987,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":79.98059845,"73":80.27919769,"72":80.47239685,"71":80.62449646,"70":81.15149689,"69":80.15299988,"68":78.37200165},"489":{"75":80.16249847,"74":80.47049713,"73":80.72429657,"72":80.88510132,"71":80.41410065,"70":79.63700104,"69":81.28399658,"68":78.50530243},"490":{"75":80.39320374,"74":80.72779846,"73":81.07150269,"72":82.0789032,"71":81.92620087,"70":79.00309753,"69":null,"68":78.67169952},"491":{"75":80.68990326,"74":80.93379974,"73":81.2276001,"72":81.40529633,"71":81.4253006,"70":81.33519745,"69":81.40200043,"68":81.34809875},"492":{"75":81.01950073,"74":81.09719849,"73":81.24939728,"72":81.49479675,"71":81.58039856,"70":81.60289764,"69":81.61710358,"68":81.68990326},"493":{"75":81.21459961,"74":81.17520142,"73":81.3286972,"72":81.50229645,"71":81.58609772,"70":81.63289642,"69":81.62120056,"68":81.68979645},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.23249817,"72":81.51930237,"71":81.53700256,"70":81.60150146,"69":81.68900299,"68":81.82820129}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP4.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP4.5)?
5617e9a5-e613-4e10-a2ac-fd290993cf50
As a climate scientist presenting my findings at a regional conference, I would like to know which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188},"472":{"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887},"473":{"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988},"474":{"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076},"452":{"178":null,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863},"453":{"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882},"454":{"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816},"455":{"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":null},"456":{"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
c08f2bf2-8287-4f33-bae9-1116b50dd631
As a climate scientist presenting my findings at a regional conference, I would like to know which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188},"472":{"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887},"473":{"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988},"474":{"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076},"452":{"178":null,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863},"453":{"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882},"454":{"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816},"455":{"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":null},"456":{"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
c0ae2c26-d1bf-4754-9b5f-d837cb6fa1f8
As a climate scientist presenting my findings at a regional conference, I would like to know which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188},"472":{"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887},"473":{"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988},"474":{"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076},"452":{"178":null,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863},"453":{"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882},"454":{"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816},"455":{"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":null},"456":{"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
6fcc72d0-54bc-45b5-9034-0c80c4aaf5fd
As a climate scientist presenting my findings at a regional conference, I would like to know which city, Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH, has shown a more significant shift in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5 scenarios?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.', '(d) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"471":{"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054},"472":{"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963},"473":{"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002},"474":{"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067}}
{"471":{"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188},"472":{"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887},"473":{"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988},"474":{"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176},"452":{"178":null,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034},"453":{"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991},"454":{"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029},"455":{"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":null},"456":{"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":null}}
{"451":{"178":null,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076},"452":{"178":null,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863},"453":{"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882},"454":{"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816},"455":{"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":null},"456":{"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":null},"457":{"178":null,"177":null,"176":null,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
7b12e242-6ac8-4943-817b-8150474ddb75
As an environmental researcher analyzing heat trends for a report, I'm interested in which city, Atlanta, GA, or Savannah, GA, experienced a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index surpassing 105°F during the summer at both the mid-century and end-century periods.
trend
tabular
null
48
(d)
['(a) The Atlanta, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Savannah, GA, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States.', '(d) Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Atlanta, GA, United States.']
['Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"457":{"121":99.90242004,"120":100.828125,"119":100.41959635,"118":100.08107249,"117":99.93852743,"116":100.24418132,"115":101.25660706},"458":{"121":99.6512502,"120":99.89406586,"119":100.00577799,"118":100.57103221,"117":100.89954631,"116":101.24563599,"115":101.59099325},"459":{"121":99.42224121,"120":99.68692017,"119":99.79945374,"118":100.20587667,"117":101.24260457,"116":101.19402059,"115":101.1478831},"460":{"121":99.07933807,"120":99.50252533,"119":99.93342845,"118":100.36527507,"117":100.5246226,"116":100.94263458,"115":101.25667063},"461":{"121":99.01527913,"120":99.72080231,"119":99.88554891,"118":100.31162516,"117":101.06361898,"116":101.36058299,"115":101.54226939},"462":{"121":99.09925334,"120":99.73456573,"119":100.29472097,"118":101.08359528,"117":101.86824544,"116":102.01287333,"115":101.68755341},"463":{"121":99.56906637,"120":99.9985021,"119":100.81725057,"118":101.71986389,"117":102.38355001,"116":102.49519857,"115":102.38379161},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":102.0954361,"117":102.77646637,"116":103.21320343,"115":103.43357086}}
{"457":{"121":91.73181407,"120":92.51986949,"119":92.29990641,"118":92.01760101,"117":91.85661062,"116":92.12413534,"115":92.88408407},"458":{"121":91.6584727,"120":91.82889048,"119":92.06170146,"118":92.4605662,"117":92.64131673,"116":92.92547353,"115":93.19013468},"459":{"121":91.53886159,"120":91.95250702,"119":92.29305267,"118":92.5200882,"117":92.98632558,"116":92.86947886,"115":92.81973267},"460":{"121":91.33587138,"120":91.78578949,"119":92.50554403,"118":92.81025187,"117":92.82575734,"116":92.67072805,"115":92.93316905},"461":{"121":91.255277,"120":91.91927592,"119":92.47460175,"118":92.75092316,"117":92.8839035,"116":93.01645152,"115":93.15175374},"462":{"121":91.19456736,"120":91.80008952,"119":92.30530294,"118":92.87353007,"117":93.38350932,"116":93.47503153,"115":93.29695638},"463":{"121":91.50753021,"120":91.88424174,"119":92.56024933,"118":93.24180857,"117":93.76836141,"116":93.84611003,"115":93.73944092},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":93.47994995,"117":94.00340271,"116":94.39939372,"115":94.49393463}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":110.52474721,"112":110.80441538,"111":111.02591451,"110":111.41617076,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":111.12393697,"113":110.97758738,"112":111.1975886,"111":111.58555094,"110":111.90565999,"109":112.13837941,"108":112.6849467,"107":112.75291951},"487":{"114":111.77709961,"113":111.61250051,"112":111.72263336,"111":111.99946086,"110":112.38286845,"109":112.66323853,"108":113.37404887,"107":113.43789927},"488":{"114":112.03167979,"113":112.79406738,"112":112.91138967,"111":112.75357564,"110":112.95237223,"109":113.45188649,"108":113.73224131,"107":114.7176768},"489":{"114":112.81106822,"113":113.49932607,"112":113.6872762,"111":114.82542419,"110":114.80569204,"109":120.72298177,"108":116.05849457,"107":123.0769221},"490":{"114":119.70094299,"113":114.24997965,"112":116.05015055,"111":122.51213582,"110":123.01759847,"109":123.40630086,"108":123.46177165,"107":null},"491":{"114":123.23586019,"113":122.73166911,"112":123.88306173,"111":124.14703369,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":98.75552877,"112":99.00845846,"111":99.139534,"110":99.30267334,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":99.02246094,"113":98.9803594,"112":98.98006439,"111":99.22458394,"110":99.41500092,"109":99.70283254,"108":99.74521891,"107":99.73136393},"487":{"114":99.1795934,"113":99.26581828,"112":99.23094686,"111":99.37890879,"110":99.57146962,"109":99.73561351,"108":99.89630636,"107":99.8111852},"488":{"114":99.15543874,"113":99.55007172,"112":99.70179749,"111":99.53009796,"110":99.69676208,"109":99.68776449,"108":99.79467773,"107":99.94723256},"489":{"114":99.25371806,"113":99.61604818,"112":99.58234914,"111":99.89810689,"110":99.54058838,"109":101.35647329,"108":99.77870178,"107":102.40659332},"490":{"114":100.55256399,"113":99.34920502,"112":99.21088664,"111":101.98561859,"110":102.1836319,"109":102.48440297,"108":102.4967219,"107":null},"491":{"114":101.92319234,"113":101.71748098,"112":102.40319316,"111":102.69338735,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Atlanta, GA, United States", "location2": "Savannah, GA, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Atlanta, GA, United States or Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
77691d82-5bbe-465a-8d21-025030ffc8fb
As an environmental researcher analyzing heat trends for a report, I'm interested in which city, Atlanta, GA, or Savannah, GA, experienced a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index surpassing 105°F during the summer at both the mid-century and end-century periods.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1387/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Atlanta, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Savannah, GA, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States.', '(d) Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Atlanta, GA, United States.']
['Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"457":{"121":99.90242004,"120":100.828125,"119":100.41959635,"118":100.08107249,"117":99.93852743,"116":100.24418132,"115":101.25660706},"458":{"121":99.6512502,"120":99.89406586,"119":100.00577799,"118":100.57103221,"117":100.89954631,"116":101.24563599,"115":101.59099325},"459":{"121":99.42224121,"120":99.68692017,"119":99.79945374,"118":100.20587667,"117":101.24260457,"116":101.19402059,"115":101.1478831},"460":{"121":99.07933807,"120":99.50252533,"119":99.93342845,"118":100.36527507,"117":100.5246226,"116":100.94263458,"115":101.25667063},"461":{"121":99.01527913,"120":99.72080231,"119":99.88554891,"118":100.31162516,"117":101.06361898,"116":101.36058299,"115":101.54226939},"462":{"121":99.09925334,"120":99.73456573,"119":100.29472097,"118":101.08359528,"117":101.86824544,"116":102.01287333,"115":101.68755341},"463":{"121":99.56906637,"120":99.9985021,"119":100.81725057,"118":101.71986389,"117":102.38355001,"116":102.49519857,"115":102.38379161},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":102.0954361,"117":102.77646637,"116":103.21320343,"115":103.43357086}}
{"457":{"121":91.73181407,"120":92.51986949,"119":92.29990641,"118":92.01760101,"117":91.85661062,"116":92.12413534,"115":92.88408407},"458":{"121":91.6584727,"120":91.82889048,"119":92.06170146,"118":92.4605662,"117":92.64131673,"116":92.92547353,"115":93.19013468},"459":{"121":91.53886159,"120":91.95250702,"119":92.29305267,"118":92.5200882,"117":92.98632558,"116":92.86947886,"115":92.81973267},"460":{"121":91.33587138,"120":91.78578949,"119":92.50554403,"118":92.81025187,"117":92.82575734,"116":92.67072805,"115":92.93316905},"461":{"121":91.255277,"120":91.91927592,"119":92.47460175,"118":92.75092316,"117":92.8839035,"116":93.01645152,"115":93.15175374},"462":{"121":91.19456736,"120":91.80008952,"119":92.30530294,"118":92.87353007,"117":93.38350932,"116":93.47503153,"115":93.29695638},"463":{"121":91.50753021,"120":91.88424174,"119":92.56024933,"118":93.24180857,"117":93.76836141,"116":93.84611003,"115":93.73944092},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":93.47994995,"117":94.00340271,"116":94.39939372,"115":94.49393463}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":110.52474721,"112":110.80441538,"111":111.02591451,"110":111.41617076,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":111.12393697,"113":110.97758738,"112":111.1975886,"111":111.58555094,"110":111.90565999,"109":112.13837941,"108":112.6849467,"107":112.75291951},"487":{"114":111.77709961,"113":111.61250051,"112":111.72263336,"111":111.99946086,"110":112.38286845,"109":112.66323853,"108":113.37404887,"107":113.43789927},"488":{"114":112.03167979,"113":112.79406738,"112":112.91138967,"111":112.75357564,"110":112.95237223,"109":113.45188649,"108":113.73224131,"107":114.7176768},"489":{"114":112.81106822,"113":113.49932607,"112":113.6872762,"111":114.82542419,"110":114.80569204,"109":120.72298177,"108":116.05849457,"107":123.0769221},"490":{"114":119.70094299,"113":114.24997965,"112":116.05015055,"111":122.51213582,"110":123.01759847,"109":123.40630086,"108":123.46177165,"107":null},"491":{"114":123.23586019,"113":122.73166911,"112":123.88306173,"111":124.14703369,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":98.75552877,"112":99.00845846,"111":99.139534,"110":99.30267334,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":99.02246094,"113":98.9803594,"112":98.98006439,"111":99.22458394,"110":99.41500092,"109":99.70283254,"108":99.74521891,"107":99.73136393},"487":{"114":99.1795934,"113":99.26581828,"112":99.23094686,"111":99.37890879,"110":99.57146962,"109":99.73561351,"108":99.89630636,"107":99.8111852},"488":{"114":99.15543874,"113":99.55007172,"112":99.70179749,"111":99.53009796,"110":99.69676208,"109":99.68776449,"108":99.79467773,"107":99.94723256},"489":{"114":99.25371806,"113":99.61604818,"112":99.58234914,"111":99.89810689,"110":99.54058838,"109":101.35647329,"108":99.77870178,"107":102.40659332},"490":{"114":100.55256399,"113":99.34920502,"112":99.21088664,"111":101.98561859,"110":102.1836319,"109":102.48440297,"108":102.4967219,"107":null},"491":{"114":101.92319234,"113":101.71748098,"112":102.40319316,"111":102.69338735,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Atlanta, GA, United States", "location2": "Savannah, GA, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Atlanta, GA, United States or Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
553466c6-fe39-4745-9c82-7551713378f3
As an environmental researcher analyzing heat trends for a report, I'm interested in which city, Atlanta, GA, or Savannah, GA, experienced a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index surpassing 105°F during the summer at both the mid-century and end-century periods.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1387/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Atlanta, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Savannah, GA, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States.', '(d) Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Atlanta, GA, United States.']
['Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"457":{"121":99.90242004,"120":100.828125,"119":100.41959635,"118":100.08107249,"117":99.93852743,"116":100.24418132,"115":101.25660706},"458":{"121":99.6512502,"120":99.89406586,"119":100.00577799,"118":100.57103221,"117":100.89954631,"116":101.24563599,"115":101.59099325},"459":{"121":99.42224121,"120":99.68692017,"119":99.79945374,"118":100.20587667,"117":101.24260457,"116":101.19402059,"115":101.1478831},"460":{"121":99.07933807,"120":99.50252533,"119":99.93342845,"118":100.36527507,"117":100.5246226,"116":100.94263458,"115":101.25667063},"461":{"121":99.01527913,"120":99.72080231,"119":99.88554891,"118":100.31162516,"117":101.06361898,"116":101.36058299,"115":101.54226939},"462":{"121":99.09925334,"120":99.73456573,"119":100.29472097,"118":101.08359528,"117":101.86824544,"116":102.01287333,"115":101.68755341},"463":{"121":99.56906637,"120":99.9985021,"119":100.81725057,"118":101.71986389,"117":102.38355001,"116":102.49519857,"115":102.38379161},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":102.0954361,"117":102.77646637,"116":103.21320343,"115":103.43357086}}
{"457":{"121":91.73181407,"120":92.51986949,"119":92.29990641,"118":92.01760101,"117":91.85661062,"116":92.12413534,"115":92.88408407},"458":{"121":91.6584727,"120":91.82889048,"119":92.06170146,"118":92.4605662,"117":92.64131673,"116":92.92547353,"115":93.19013468},"459":{"121":91.53886159,"120":91.95250702,"119":92.29305267,"118":92.5200882,"117":92.98632558,"116":92.86947886,"115":92.81973267},"460":{"121":91.33587138,"120":91.78578949,"119":92.50554403,"118":92.81025187,"117":92.82575734,"116":92.67072805,"115":92.93316905},"461":{"121":91.255277,"120":91.91927592,"119":92.47460175,"118":92.75092316,"117":92.8839035,"116":93.01645152,"115":93.15175374},"462":{"121":91.19456736,"120":91.80008952,"119":92.30530294,"118":92.87353007,"117":93.38350932,"116":93.47503153,"115":93.29695638},"463":{"121":91.50753021,"120":91.88424174,"119":92.56024933,"118":93.24180857,"117":93.76836141,"116":93.84611003,"115":93.73944092},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":93.47994995,"117":94.00340271,"116":94.39939372,"115":94.49393463}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":110.52474721,"112":110.80441538,"111":111.02591451,"110":111.41617076,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":111.12393697,"113":110.97758738,"112":111.1975886,"111":111.58555094,"110":111.90565999,"109":112.13837941,"108":112.6849467,"107":112.75291951},"487":{"114":111.77709961,"113":111.61250051,"112":111.72263336,"111":111.99946086,"110":112.38286845,"109":112.66323853,"108":113.37404887,"107":113.43789927},"488":{"114":112.03167979,"113":112.79406738,"112":112.91138967,"111":112.75357564,"110":112.95237223,"109":113.45188649,"108":113.73224131,"107":114.7176768},"489":{"114":112.81106822,"113":113.49932607,"112":113.6872762,"111":114.82542419,"110":114.80569204,"109":120.72298177,"108":116.05849457,"107":123.0769221},"490":{"114":119.70094299,"113":114.24997965,"112":116.05015055,"111":122.51213582,"110":123.01759847,"109":123.40630086,"108":123.46177165,"107":null},"491":{"114":123.23586019,"113":122.73166911,"112":123.88306173,"111":124.14703369,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":98.75552877,"112":99.00845846,"111":99.139534,"110":99.30267334,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":99.02246094,"113":98.9803594,"112":98.98006439,"111":99.22458394,"110":99.41500092,"109":99.70283254,"108":99.74521891,"107":99.73136393},"487":{"114":99.1795934,"113":99.26581828,"112":99.23094686,"111":99.37890879,"110":99.57146962,"109":99.73561351,"108":99.89630636,"107":99.8111852},"488":{"114":99.15543874,"113":99.55007172,"112":99.70179749,"111":99.53009796,"110":99.69676208,"109":99.68776449,"108":99.79467773,"107":99.94723256},"489":{"114":99.25371806,"113":99.61604818,"112":99.58234914,"111":99.89810689,"110":99.54058838,"109":101.35647329,"108":99.77870178,"107":102.40659332},"490":{"114":100.55256399,"113":99.34920502,"112":99.21088664,"111":101.98561859,"110":102.1836319,"109":102.48440297,"108":102.4967219,"107":null},"491":{"114":101.92319234,"113":101.71748098,"112":102.40319316,"111":102.69338735,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Atlanta, GA, United States", "location2": "Savannah, GA, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Atlanta, GA, United States or Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
2d8b17d0-db84-4100-a109-d9ba2bc7e993
As an environmental researcher analyzing heat trends for a report, I'm interested in which city, Atlanta, GA, or Savannah, GA, experienced a more significant increase in the number of days with a daily heat index surpassing 105°F during the summer at both the mid-century and end-century periods.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1387/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(d)
['(a) The Atlanta, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Savannah, GA, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Atlanta, GA, United States and Savannah, GA, United States.', '(d) Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change than Atlanta, GA, United States.']
['Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Atlanta, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in end-century period', 'Savannah, GA, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"457":{"121":99.90242004,"120":100.828125,"119":100.41959635,"118":100.08107249,"117":99.93852743,"116":100.24418132,"115":101.25660706},"458":{"121":99.6512502,"120":99.89406586,"119":100.00577799,"118":100.57103221,"117":100.89954631,"116":101.24563599,"115":101.59099325},"459":{"121":99.42224121,"120":99.68692017,"119":99.79945374,"118":100.20587667,"117":101.24260457,"116":101.19402059,"115":101.1478831},"460":{"121":99.07933807,"120":99.50252533,"119":99.93342845,"118":100.36527507,"117":100.5246226,"116":100.94263458,"115":101.25667063},"461":{"121":99.01527913,"120":99.72080231,"119":99.88554891,"118":100.31162516,"117":101.06361898,"116":101.36058299,"115":101.54226939},"462":{"121":99.09925334,"120":99.73456573,"119":100.29472097,"118":101.08359528,"117":101.86824544,"116":102.01287333,"115":101.68755341},"463":{"121":99.56906637,"120":99.9985021,"119":100.81725057,"118":101.71986389,"117":102.38355001,"116":102.49519857,"115":102.38379161},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":102.0954361,"117":102.77646637,"116":103.21320343,"115":103.43357086}}
{"457":{"121":91.73181407,"120":92.51986949,"119":92.29990641,"118":92.01760101,"117":91.85661062,"116":92.12413534,"115":92.88408407},"458":{"121":91.6584727,"120":91.82889048,"119":92.06170146,"118":92.4605662,"117":92.64131673,"116":92.92547353,"115":93.19013468},"459":{"121":91.53886159,"120":91.95250702,"119":92.29305267,"118":92.5200882,"117":92.98632558,"116":92.86947886,"115":92.81973267},"460":{"121":91.33587138,"120":91.78578949,"119":92.50554403,"118":92.81025187,"117":92.82575734,"116":92.67072805,"115":92.93316905},"461":{"121":91.255277,"120":91.91927592,"119":92.47460175,"118":92.75092316,"117":92.8839035,"116":93.01645152,"115":93.15175374},"462":{"121":91.19456736,"120":91.80008952,"119":92.30530294,"118":92.87353007,"117":93.38350932,"116":93.47503153,"115":93.29695638},"463":{"121":91.50753021,"120":91.88424174,"119":92.56024933,"118":93.24180857,"117":93.76836141,"116":93.84611003,"115":93.73944092},"464":{"121":null,"120":null,"119":null,"118":93.47994995,"117":94.00340271,"116":94.39939372,"115":94.49393463}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":110.52474721,"112":110.80441538,"111":111.02591451,"110":111.41617076,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":111.12393697,"113":110.97758738,"112":111.1975886,"111":111.58555094,"110":111.90565999,"109":112.13837941,"108":112.6849467,"107":112.75291951},"487":{"114":111.77709961,"113":111.61250051,"112":111.72263336,"111":111.99946086,"110":112.38286845,"109":112.66323853,"108":113.37404887,"107":113.43789927},"488":{"114":112.03167979,"113":112.79406738,"112":112.91138967,"111":112.75357564,"110":112.95237223,"109":113.45188649,"108":113.73224131,"107":114.7176768},"489":{"114":112.81106822,"113":113.49932607,"112":113.6872762,"111":114.82542419,"110":114.80569204,"109":120.72298177,"108":116.05849457,"107":123.0769221},"490":{"114":119.70094299,"113":114.24997965,"112":116.05015055,"111":122.51213582,"110":123.01759847,"109":123.40630086,"108":123.46177165,"107":null},"491":{"114":123.23586019,"113":122.73166911,"112":123.88306173,"111":124.14703369,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
{"485":{"114":null,"113":98.75552877,"112":99.00845846,"111":99.139534,"110":99.30267334,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null},"486":{"114":99.02246094,"113":98.9803594,"112":98.98006439,"111":99.22458394,"110":99.41500092,"109":99.70283254,"108":99.74521891,"107":99.73136393},"487":{"114":99.1795934,"113":99.26581828,"112":99.23094686,"111":99.37890879,"110":99.57146962,"109":99.73561351,"108":99.89630636,"107":99.8111852},"488":{"114":99.15543874,"113":99.55007172,"112":99.70179749,"111":99.53009796,"110":99.69676208,"109":99.68776449,"108":99.79467773,"107":99.94723256},"489":{"114":99.25371806,"113":99.61604818,"112":99.58234914,"111":99.89810689,"110":99.54058838,"109":101.35647329,"108":99.77870178,"107":102.40659332},"490":{"114":100.55256399,"113":99.34920502,"112":99.21088664,"111":101.98561859,"110":102.1836319,"109":102.48440297,"108":102.4967219,"107":null},"491":{"114":101.92319234,"113":101.71748098,"112":102.40319316,"111":102.69338735,"110":null,"109":null,"108":null,"107":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "number of days with daily heat index above 105 F", "location1": "Atlanta, GA, United States", "location2": "Savannah, GA, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Atlanta, GA, United States or Savannah, GA, United States experienced a greater change in number of days with daily heat index above 105 F throughout summer in end-century period and summer in mid-century period?
c30cc2ab-1998-4c2a-a4c3-bc409e0c7de0
As a climate analyst presenting to a city council in Buffalo, NY, I'm interested in understanding which city experienced a more significant alteration in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5: Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":51.97919846,"211":49.56000137,"210":48.88489914,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":52.62239838,"204":51.38349915},"471":{"213":51.94369888,"212":49.72320175,"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188,"205":49.49100113,"204":48.86349869},"472":{"213":51.76100159,"212":49.26340103,"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887,"205":48.55250168,"204":47.68859863},"473":{"213":49.45970154,"212":48.90650177,"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988,"205":47.30009842,"204":46.78820038},"474":{"213":49.13750076,"212":48.61920166,"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952,"205":46.29729843,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":48.45479965,"211":47.63150024,"210":47.64400101,"209":46.89780045,"208":46.23809814,"207":45.87329865,"206":45.71049881,"205":45.29140091,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":47.30680084,"209":46.2154007,"208":45.45349884,"207":45.15380096,"206":45.08129883,"205":44.84790039,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":50.7602005,"177":50.59799957,"176":50.45759964,"175":50.50059891,"174":50.73479843,"173":51.00640106,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":50.85520172,"177":50.84870148,"176":50.82720184,"175":50.85250092,"174":50.92509842,"173":51.02289963,"172":51.19459915,"171":51.42670059,"170":51.61520004},"451":{"179":50.73590088,"178":50.82799911,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076,"170":51.70679855},"452":{"179":50.65439987,"178":50.80459976,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863,"170":51.83890152},"453":{"179":50.375,"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882,"170":51.96889877},"454":{"179":49.88010025,"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816,"170":52.04959869},"455":{"179":49.59820175,"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":51.99409866,"170":52.06299973},"456":{"179":49.6637001,"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":51.76589966,"170":null},"457":{"179":49.73310089,"178":49.84820175,"177":50.39630127,"176":50.42259979,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":51.61610031,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":50.43870163,"176":50.70899963,"175":50.71720123,"174":50.90579987,"173":51.24750137,"172":51.33860016,"171":51.50120163,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
8e485d7e-5c3e-43ab-a85d-a37af69836ec
As a climate analyst presenting to a city council in Buffalo, NY, I'm interested in understanding which city experienced a more significant alteration in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5: Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":51.97919846,"211":49.56000137,"210":48.88489914,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":52.62239838,"204":51.38349915},"471":{"213":51.94369888,"212":49.72320175,"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188,"205":49.49100113,"204":48.86349869},"472":{"213":51.76100159,"212":49.26340103,"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887,"205":48.55250168,"204":47.68859863},"473":{"213":49.45970154,"212":48.90650177,"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988,"205":47.30009842,"204":46.78820038},"474":{"213":49.13750076,"212":48.61920166,"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952,"205":46.29729843,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":48.45479965,"211":47.63150024,"210":47.64400101,"209":46.89780045,"208":46.23809814,"207":45.87329865,"206":45.71049881,"205":45.29140091,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":47.30680084,"209":46.2154007,"208":45.45349884,"207":45.15380096,"206":45.08129883,"205":44.84790039,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":50.7602005,"177":50.59799957,"176":50.45759964,"175":50.50059891,"174":50.73479843,"173":51.00640106,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":50.85520172,"177":50.84870148,"176":50.82720184,"175":50.85250092,"174":50.92509842,"173":51.02289963,"172":51.19459915,"171":51.42670059,"170":51.61520004},"451":{"179":50.73590088,"178":50.82799911,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076,"170":51.70679855},"452":{"179":50.65439987,"178":50.80459976,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863,"170":51.83890152},"453":{"179":50.375,"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882,"170":51.96889877},"454":{"179":49.88010025,"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816,"170":52.04959869},"455":{"179":49.59820175,"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":51.99409866,"170":52.06299973},"456":{"179":49.6637001,"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":51.76589966,"170":null},"457":{"179":49.73310089,"178":49.84820175,"177":50.39630127,"176":50.42259979,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":51.61610031,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":50.43870163,"176":50.70899963,"175":50.71720123,"174":50.90579987,"173":51.24750137,"172":51.33860016,"171":51.50120163,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
c67027f9-4889-4a46-90c1-45dc4960c322
As a climate analyst presenting to a city council in Buffalo, NY, I'm interested in understanding which city experienced a more significant alteration in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5: Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":51.97919846,"211":49.56000137,"210":48.88489914,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":52.62239838,"204":51.38349915},"471":{"213":51.94369888,"212":49.72320175,"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188,"205":49.49100113,"204":48.86349869},"472":{"213":51.76100159,"212":49.26340103,"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887,"205":48.55250168,"204":47.68859863},"473":{"213":49.45970154,"212":48.90650177,"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988,"205":47.30009842,"204":46.78820038},"474":{"213":49.13750076,"212":48.61920166,"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952,"205":46.29729843,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":48.45479965,"211":47.63150024,"210":47.64400101,"209":46.89780045,"208":46.23809814,"207":45.87329865,"206":45.71049881,"205":45.29140091,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":47.30680084,"209":46.2154007,"208":45.45349884,"207":45.15380096,"206":45.08129883,"205":44.84790039,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":50.7602005,"177":50.59799957,"176":50.45759964,"175":50.50059891,"174":50.73479843,"173":51.00640106,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":50.85520172,"177":50.84870148,"176":50.82720184,"175":50.85250092,"174":50.92509842,"173":51.02289963,"172":51.19459915,"171":51.42670059,"170":51.61520004},"451":{"179":50.73590088,"178":50.82799911,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076,"170":51.70679855},"452":{"179":50.65439987,"178":50.80459976,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863,"170":51.83890152},"453":{"179":50.375,"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882,"170":51.96889877},"454":{"179":49.88010025,"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816,"170":52.04959869},"455":{"179":49.59820175,"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":51.99409866,"170":52.06299973},"456":{"179":49.6637001,"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":51.76589966,"170":null},"457":{"179":49.73310089,"178":49.84820175,"177":50.39630127,"176":50.42259979,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":51.61610031,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":50.43870163,"176":50.70899963,"175":50.71720123,"174":50.90579987,"173":51.24750137,"172":51.33860016,"171":51.50120163,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
d751d901-fdb8-448a-ba55-50c722c100ae
As a climate analyst presenting to a city council in Buffalo, NY, I'm interested in understanding which city experienced a more significant alteration in minimum annual temperature by the end of the century under RCP4.5 and RCP8.5: Buffalo, NY, or Columbus, OH?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1393/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Buffalo, NY, United States experienced a greater change than Columbus, OH, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change than Buffalo, NY, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Buffalo, NY, United States and Columbus, OH, United States.']
['Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Buffalo, NY, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Columbus, OH, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"470":{"213":null,"212":46.11309814,"211":44.95890045,"210":44.34149933,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":46.91419983,"204":46.15200043},"471":{"213":46.08459854,"212":45.15399933,"211":44.44530106,"210":44.00590134,"209":46.9056015,"208":44.22290039,"207":46.19680023,"206":46.50180054,"205":45.05490112,"204":44.72829819},"472":{"213":45.95999908,"212":44.73220062,"211":44.28469849,"210":43.79949951,"209":47.14519882,"208":46.92399979,"207":43.97729874,"206":44.58539963,"205":44.46340179,"204":43.68289948},"473":{"213":44.87639999,"212":44.48680115,"211":44.14020157,"210":43.80950165,"209":43.68989944,"208":43.60029984,"207":43.67850113,"206":43.2052002,"205":43.26539993,"204":42.82130051},"474":{"213":44.68239975,"212":44.26800156,"211":43.77560043,"210":43.67309952,"209":43.60380173,"208":43.38629913,"207":42.72109985,"206":42.34600067,"205":42.29410172,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":44.19100189,"211":43.40620041,"210":43.55559921,"209":42.87549973,"208":42.18320084,"207":41.8567009,"206":41.73600006,"205":41.32089996,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":43.34059906,"209":42.25170135,"208":41.44400024,"207":41.17599869,"206":41.16479874,"205":40.9435997,"204":null}}
{"470":{"213":null,"212":51.97919846,"211":49.56000137,"210":48.88489914,"209":null,"208":null,"207":null,"206":null,"205":52.62239838,"204":51.38349915},"471":{"213":51.94369888,"212":49.72320175,"211":49.00780106,"210":48.49810028,"209":51.66360092,"208":48.9612999,"207":51.92129898,"206":52.13130188,"205":49.49100113,"204":48.86349869},"472":{"213":51.76100159,"212":49.26340103,"211":48.77460098,"210":48.26060104,"209":51.82820129,"208":51.63990021,"207":48.51440048,"206":48.88399887,"205":48.55250168,"204":47.68859863},"473":{"213":49.45970154,"212":48.90650177,"211":48.48479843,"210":48.19229889,"209":47.99580002,"208":47.91619873,"207":47.89929962,"206":47.3382988,"205":47.30009842,"204":46.78820038},"474":{"213":49.13750076,"212":48.61920166,"211":48.02659988,"210":47.9396019,"209":47.79769897,"208":47.47719955,"207":46.79529953,"206":46.35919952,"205":46.29729843,"204":null},"475":{"213":null,"212":48.45479965,"211":47.63150024,"210":47.64400101,"209":46.89780045,"208":46.23809814,"207":45.87329865,"206":45.71049881,"205":45.29140091,"204":null},"476":{"213":null,"212":null,"211":null,"210":47.30680084,"209":46.2154007,"208":45.45349884,"207":45.15380096,"206":45.08129883,"205":44.84790039,"204":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":47.43730164,"177":47.29650116,"176":47.17739868,"175":47.25350189,"174":47.54930115,"173":47.82920074,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":47.53720093,"177":47.57860184,"176":47.62210083,"175":47.68560028,"174":47.79159927,"173":47.85979843,"172":48.01660156,"171":48.23160172,"170":48.47060013},"451":{"179":47.39759827,"178":47.55189896,"177":47.6629982,"176":47.81330109,"175":48.01490021,"174":48.18700027,"173":48.17739868,"172":48.24359894,"171":48.40930176,"170":48.57970047},"452":{"179":47.35820007,"178":47.55680084,"177":47.71530151,"176":47.90029907,"175":48.0766983,"174":48.29259872,"173":48.47439957,"172":48.58119965,"171":48.67160034,"170":48.70930099},"453":{"179":47.11190033,"178":47.4219017,"177":47.69889832,"176":48.06919861,"175":51.83440018,"174":50.62739944,"173":48.70489883,"172":48.82569885,"171":48.89599991,"170":48.84889984},"454":{"179":46.67229843,"178":47.1169014,"177":47.4681015,"176":47.92229843,"175":51.68970108,"174":48.50640106,"173":48.81269836,"172":48.87039948,"171":48.93420029,"170":48.89920044},"455":{"179":46.44929886,"178":46.78770065,"177":46.99079895,"176":47.46020126,"175":47.94649887,"174":48.50479889,"173":48.71670151,"172":48.74259949,"171":48.76739883,"170":48.82789993},"456":{"179":46.53749847,"178":46.79240036,"177":46.98180008,"176":47.2845993,"175":47.78919983,"174":48.21250153,"173":48.37730026,"172":48.27360153,"171":48.56470108,"170":null},"457":{"179":46.58639908,"178":46.72290039,"177":47.35279846,"176":47.34519958,"175":47.51589966,"174":47.79959869,"173":48.01760101,"172":48.33169937,"171":48.44430161,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":47.38589859,"176":47.65259933,"175":47.59690094,"174":47.77610016,"173":48.17589951,"172":48.24509811,"171":48.37900162,"170":null}}
{"449":{"179":null,"178":50.7602005,"177":50.59799957,"176":50.45759964,"175":50.50059891,"174":50.73479843,"173":51.00640106,"172":null,"171":null,"170":null},"450":{"179":null,"178":50.85520172,"177":50.84870148,"176":50.82720184,"175":50.85250092,"174":50.92509842,"173":51.02289963,"172":51.19459915,"171":51.42670059,"170":51.61520004},"451":{"179":50.73590088,"178":50.82799911,"177":50.88669968,"176":50.97000122,"175":51.14410019,"174":51.28440094,"173":51.31740189,"172":51.4239006,"171":51.57640076,"170":51.70679855},"452":{"179":50.65439987,"178":50.80459976,"177":50.88940048,"176":51.03229904,"175":51.23699951,"174":51.43730164,"173":51.59880066,"172":51.72800064,"171":51.81499863,"170":51.83890152},"453":{"179":50.375,"178":50.63570023,"177":50.8730011,"176":51.18920135,"175":55.15219879,"174":54.05799866,"173":51.81219864,"172":51.95769882,"171":52.02019882,"170":51.96889877},"454":{"179":49.88010025,"178":50.28419876,"177":50.62829971,"176":51.06140137,"175":54.93379974,"174":51.63010025,"173":51.94720078,"172":52.03900146,"171":52.10889816,"170":52.04959869},"455":{"179":49.59820175,"178":49.90499878,"177":50.10820007,"176":50.58089828,"175":51.05020142,"174":51.59460068,"173":51.86270142,"172":51.94049835,"171":51.99409866,"170":52.06299973},"456":{"179":49.6637001,"178":49.88339996,"177":50.0780983,"176":50.37900162,"175":50.88079834,"174":51.32189941,"173":51.50569916,"172":51.47650146,"171":51.76589966,"170":null},"457":{"179":49.73310089,"178":49.84820175,"177":50.39630127,"176":50.42259979,"175":50.64929962,"174":50.91899872,"173":51.11149979,"172":51.45550156,"171":51.61610031,"170":null},"458":{"179":null,"178":null,"177":50.43870163,"176":50.70899963,"175":50.71720123,"174":50.90579987,"173":51.24750137,"172":51.33860016,"171":51.50120163,"170":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "minimum annual temperature", "location1": "Buffalo, NY, United States", "location2": "Columbus, OH, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "end-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Buffalo, NY, United States or Columbus, OH, United States experienced a greater change in minimum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and end-century period (RCP8.5)?
7ca78373-ff7f-4210-9ec6-1e449148990d
As a wildland firefighter assessing seasonal fire risks while planning our annual training, could you help me understand which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century compared to spring in the mid-century?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":6.48623991,"163":6.00203991,"162":5.71416998,"161":4.84141016,"160":6.47243023,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":8.63763046,"163":7.67045021,"162":7.43683004,"161":6.66334009,"160":7.21440983,"159":8.26854038,"158":9.8893404},"304":{"164":8.71100998,"163":8.05908012,"162":8.2108202,"161":8.15707016,"160":8.15165997,"159":9.04953003,"158":10.55780029},"305":{"164":9.01111984,"163":8.30204964,"162":8.38560963,"161":8.36291981,"160":8.61773968,"159":9.33358955,"158":10.66419983},"306":{"164":9.24201012,"163":8.54679966,"162":8.53862953,"161":8.63836002,"160":8.79951954,"159":9.26906967,"158":10.5316},"307":{"164":9.15466022,"163":8.59607983,"162":8.71763039,"161":8.90361023,"160":9.07487965,"159":9.54965973,"158":10.64430046},"308":{"164":9.25938988,"163":8.67555046,"162":8.86373997,"161":9.18472004,"160":9.55768013,"159":10.16209984,"158":10.86709976}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":3.9219799,"223":3.69525003,"222":3.68953991,"221":3.95604992,"220":null},"226":{"226":2.8066299,"225":3.66762996,"224":3.81434011,"223":3.63834,"222":3.56453991,"221":3.61070991,"220":null},"227":{"226":2.62904,"225":3.33469009,"224":3.65485001,"223":3.70419002,"222":3.57202005,"221":3.44437003,"220":3.33826995},"228":{"226":2.49541998,"225":3.06646991,"224":3.34188008,"223":3.76525998,"222":3.44984007,"221":3.25356007,"220":3.07634997},"229":{"226":2.47212005,"225":2.48932004,"224":2.62140989,"223":2.97487998,"222":2.88897991,"221":2.81757998,"220":2.79345989},"230":{"226":null,"225":1.62021005,"224":1.84990001,"223":2.49700999,"222":2.25704002,"221":2.4867599,"220":2.58422995},"231":{"226":null,"225":1.60636997,"224":1.79819,"223":2.32286,"222":2.00091004,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and spring in mid-century period?
a0fce8b7-9f47-42d4-bfd8-c7b60baf2378
As a wildland firefighter assessing seasonal fire risks while planning our annual training, could you help me understand which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century compared to spring in the mid-century?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1230/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":6.48623991,"163":6.00203991,"162":5.71416998,"161":4.84141016,"160":6.47243023,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":8.63763046,"163":7.67045021,"162":7.43683004,"161":6.66334009,"160":7.21440983,"159":8.26854038,"158":9.8893404},"304":{"164":8.71100998,"163":8.05908012,"162":8.2108202,"161":8.15707016,"160":8.15165997,"159":9.04953003,"158":10.55780029},"305":{"164":9.01111984,"163":8.30204964,"162":8.38560963,"161":8.36291981,"160":8.61773968,"159":9.33358955,"158":10.66419983},"306":{"164":9.24201012,"163":8.54679966,"162":8.53862953,"161":8.63836002,"160":8.79951954,"159":9.26906967,"158":10.5316},"307":{"164":9.15466022,"163":8.59607983,"162":8.71763039,"161":8.90361023,"160":9.07487965,"159":9.54965973,"158":10.64430046},"308":{"164":9.25938988,"163":8.67555046,"162":8.86373997,"161":9.18472004,"160":9.55768013,"159":10.16209984,"158":10.86709976}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":3.9219799,"223":3.69525003,"222":3.68953991,"221":3.95604992,"220":null},"226":{"226":2.8066299,"225":3.66762996,"224":3.81434011,"223":3.63834,"222":3.56453991,"221":3.61070991,"220":null},"227":{"226":2.62904,"225":3.33469009,"224":3.65485001,"223":3.70419002,"222":3.57202005,"221":3.44437003,"220":3.33826995},"228":{"226":2.49541998,"225":3.06646991,"224":3.34188008,"223":3.76525998,"222":3.44984007,"221":3.25356007,"220":3.07634997},"229":{"226":2.47212005,"225":2.48932004,"224":2.62140989,"223":2.97487998,"222":2.88897991,"221":2.81757998,"220":2.79345989},"230":{"226":null,"225":1.62021005,"224":1.84990001,"223":2.49700999,"222":2.25704002,"221":2.4867599,"220":2.58422995},"231":{"226":null,"225":1.60636997,"224":1.79819,"223":2.32286,"222":2.00091004,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and spring in mid-century period?
e51d9d87-4d60-42bd-a592-4a950546abad
As a wildland firefighter assessing seasonal fire risks while planning our annual training, could you help me understand which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century compared to spring in the mid-century?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1230/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":6.48623991,"163":6.00203991,"162":5.71416998,"161":4.84141016,"160":6.47243023,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":8.63763046,"163":7.67045021,"162":7.43683004,"161":6.66334009,"160":7.21440983,"159":8.26854038,"158":9.8893404},"304":{"164":8.71100998,"163":8.05908012,"162":8.2108202,"161":8.15707016,"160":8.15165997,"159":9.04953003,"158":10.55780029},"305":{"164":9.01111984,"163":8.30204964,"162":8.38560963,"161":8.36291981,"160":8.61773968,"159":9.33358955,"158":10.66419983},"306":{"164":9.24201012,"163":8.54679966,"162":8.53862953,"161":8.63836002,"160":8.79951954,"159":9.26906967,"158":10.5316},"307":{"164":9.15466022,"163":8.59607983,"162":8.71763039,"161":8.90361023,"160":9.07487965,"159":9.54965973,"158":10.64430046},"308":{"164":9.25938988,"163":8.67555046,"162":8.86373997,"161":9.18472004,"160":9.55768013,"159":10.16209984,"158":10.86709976}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":3.9219799,"223":3.69525003,"222":3.68953991,"221":3.95604992,"220":null},"226":{"226":2.8066299,"225":3.66762996,"224":3.81434011,"223":3.63834,"222":3.56453991,"221":3.61070991,"220":null},"227":{"226":2.62904,"225":3.33469009,"224":3.65485001,"223":3.70419002,"222":3.57202005,"221":3.44437003,"220":3.33826995},"228":{"226":2.49541998,"225":3.06646991,"224":3.34188008,"223":3.76525998,"222":3.44984007,"221":3.25356007,"220":3.07634997},"229":{"226":2.47212005,"225":2.48932004,"224":2.62140989,"223":2.97487998,"222":2.88897991,"221":2.81757998,"220":2.79345989},"230":{"226":null,"225":1.62021005,"224":1.84990001,"223":2.49700999,"222":2.25704002,"221":2.4867599,"220":2.58422995},"231":{"226":null,"225":1.60636997,"224":1.79819,"223":2.32286,"222":2.00091004,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and spring in mid-century period?
c9b5178d-55c9-4fbc-84f1-2e3860fd9ae6
As a wildland firefighter assessing seasonal fire risks while planning our annual training, could you help me understand which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn at the end of the century compared to spring in the mid-century?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1230/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"164":25.06690025,"163":23.92779922,"162":23.15060043,"161":20.14229965,"160":24.35499954,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":29.67239952,"163":27.43849945,"162":26.98380089,"161":24.47369957,"160":25.32290077,"159":24.81609917,"158":25.01849937},"304":{"164":29.18359947,"163":27.53569984,"162":27.54129982,"161":27.33460045,"160":26.68359947,"159":26.10090065,"158":26.02210045},"305":{"164":28.99220085,"163":27.5095005,"162":27.49799919,"161":27.00489998,"160":26.78289986,"159":26.4932003,"158":26.49080086},"306":{"164":28.93659973,"163":27.93300056,"162":27.61109924,"161":26.65579987,"160":26.56119919,"159":26.30089951,"158":26.59020042},"307":{"164":28.60289955,"163":27.72800064,"162":27.49670029,"161":27.04190063,"160":26.61109924,"159":26.54500008,"158":26.85540009},"308":{"164":28.2364006,"163":27.53919983,"162":27.55990028,"161":27.31579971,"160":27.16080093,"159":26.87280083,"158":26.5890007}}
{"302":{"164":6.48623991,"163":6.00203991,"162":5.71416998,"161":4.84141016,"160":6.47243023,"159":null,"158":null},"303":{"164":8.63763046,"163":7.67045021,"162":7.43683004,"161":6.66334009,"160":7.21440983,"159":8.26854038,"158":9.8893404},"304":{"164":8.71100998,"163":8.05908012,"162":8.2108202,"161":8.15707016,"160":8.15165997,"159":9.04953003,"158":10.55780029},"305":{"164":9.01111984,"163":8.30204964,"162":8.38560963,"161":8.36291981,"160":8.61773968,"159":9.33358955,"158":10.66419983},"306":{"164":9.24201012,"163":8.54679966,"162":8.53862953,"161":8.63836002,"160":8.79951954,"159":9.26906967,"158":10.5316},"307":{"164":9.15466022,"163":8.59607983,"162":8.71763039,"161":8.90361023,"160":9.07487965,"159":9.54965973,"158":10.64430046},"308":{"164":9.25938988,"163":8.67555046,"162":8.86373997,"161":9.18472004,"160":9.55768013,"159":10.16209984,"158":10.86709976}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":16.31920052,"223":16.44960022,"222":16.48069954,"221":16.85750008,"220":null},"226":{"226":13.41889954,"225":15.30840015,"224":15.9144001,"223":16.36440086,"222":16.45940018,"221":16.64410019,"220":null},"227":{"226":13.54889965,"225":15.09630013,"224":15.57870007,"223":16.03160095,"222":16.6012001,"221":16.76029968,"220":16.77420044},"228":{"226":13.76179981,"225":14.61870003,"224":14.88539982,"223":15.06229973,"222":16.4720993,"221":16.9034996,"220":16.88120079},"229":{"226":13.93280029,"225":13.79839993,"224":14.10420036,"223":15.52740002,"222":15.89719963,"221":16.33209991,"220":16.67169952},"230":{"226":null,"225":12.04730034,"224":12.49450016,"223":14.81359959,"222":14.26229954,"221":15.99520016,"220":16.70809937},"231":{"226":null,"225":11.92710018,"224":12.43050003,"223":14.58810043,"222":13.77210045,"221":null,"220":null}}
{"225":{"226":null,"225":null,"224":3.9219799,"223":3.69525003,"222":3.68953991,"221":3.95604992,"220":null},"226":{"226":2.8066299,"225":3.66762996,"224":3.81434011,"223":3.63834,"222":3.56453991,"221":3.61070991,"220":null},"227":{"226":2.62904,"225":3.33469009,"224":3.65485001,"223":3.70419002,"222":3.57202005,"221":3.44437003,"220":3.33826995},"228":{"226":2.49541998,"225":3.06646991,"224":3.34188008,"223":3.76525998,"222":3.44984007,"221":3.25356007,"220":3.07634997},"229":{"226":2.47212005,"225":2.48932004,"224":2.62140989,"223":2.97487998,"222":2.88897991,"221":2.81757998,"220":2.79345989},"230":{"226":null,"225":1.62021005,"224":1.84990001,"223":2.49700999,"222":2.25704002,"221":2.4867599,"220":2.58422995},"231":{"226":null,"225":1.60636997,"224":1.79819,"223":2.32286,"222":2.00091004,"221":null,"220":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and spring in mid-century period?
dea5157e-13bd-4994-bbce-fe83d640a769
As a wildfire risk analyst preparing a report for a government agency on fire hazards, I'm looking to determine which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has seen a more significant shift in fire weather index during autumn and spring in the mid-century timeframe.
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in mid-century period?
e2901355-8cd5-4168-b1de-f49e3029dc66
As a wildfire risk analyst preparing a report for a government agency on fire hazards, I'm looking to determine which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has seen a more significant shift in fire weather index during autumn and spring in the mid-century timeframe.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1318/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in mid-century period?
e6876258-2d9c-4133-b389-519cba29cc5d
As a wildfire risk analyst preparing a report for a government agency on fire hazards, I'm looking to determine which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has seen a more significant shift in fire weather index during autumn and spring in the mid-century timeframe.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1318/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in mid-century period?
222ed311-bb76-46ca-bab7-8cdb8953d1dc
As a wildfire risk analyst preparing a report for a government agency on fire hazards, I'm looking to determine which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has seen a more significant shift in fire weather index during autumn and spring in the mid-century timeframe.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1318/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(c) The Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in spring in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":20.4239006,"150":16.92130089,"149":17.10700035,"148":17.84900093,"147":15.51350021,"146":14.76780033,"145":16.20730019},"303":{"151":22.51259995,"150":20.36050034,"149":20.2996006,"148":20.49539948,"147":18.33919907,"146":17.20919991,"145":19.14819908},"304":{"151":21.63559914,"150":21.07670021,"149":20.96960068,"148":20.74169922,"147":20.67429924,"146":20.21150017,"145":19.76339912},"305":{"151":20.95170021,"150":20.6765995,"149":20.61260033,"148":20.08519936,"147":20.21820068,"146":20.90060043,"145":20.24500084},"306":{"151":20.79290009,"150":20.77479935,"149":20.83480072,"148":20.65509987,"147":20.69750023,"146":20.52389908,"145":20.25919914},"307":{"151":21.01250076,"150":20.85020065,"149":20.73609924,"148":20.6284008,"147":20.38269997,"146":19.97089958,"145":19.43779945},"308":{"151":21.14999962,"150":20.9946003,"149":21.03059959,"148":20.86619949,"147":20.77400017,"146":20.33349991,"145":20.12280083}}
{"302":{"151":9.94810963,"150":7.39869022,"149":7.49606991,"148":7.93196011,"147":7.23061991,"146":7.27496004,"145":8.30873966},"303":{"151":13.05879974,"150":11.01669979,"149":10.6171999,"148":10.60719967,"147":9.24785042,"146":8.67185974,"145":10.40139961},"304":{"151":12.70119953,"150":12.1626997,"149":12.0607996,"148":12.04209995,"147":11.75829983,"146":11.3458004,"145":11.51270008},"305":{"151":11.8348999,"150":11.67720032,"149":11.76119995,"148":11.6552,"147":11.61950016,"146":11.77560043,"145":11.35410023},"306":{"151":11.68360043,"150":11.61139965,"149":11.58920002,"148":11.32800007,"147":11.07310009,"146":10.90960026,"145":10.78250027},"307":{"151":11.50139999,"150":11.20460033,"149":11.00599957,"148":10.73110008,"147":10.39239979,"146":10.11480045,"145":9.8322897},"308":{"151":11.39179993,"150":11.05959988,"149":10.79279995,"148":10.49950027,"147":10.2361002,"146":10.02490044,"145":10.0309}}
{"227":{"123":34.90200043,"122":26.7276001,"121":18.60519981,"120":18.27659988,"119":25.55599976,"118":33.67240143,"117":38.80810165,"116":null},"228":{"123":36.49200058,"122":31.57329941,"121":22.87409973,"120":19.86669922,"119":24.29430008,"118":31.94420052,"117":35.62820053,"116":null},"229":{"123":41.0279007,"122":42.39360046,"121":39.53179932,"120":33.70740128,"119":33.23160172,"118":35.82429886,"117":36.81760025,"116":null},"230":{"123":37.67219925,"122":40.10469818,"121":42.85950089,"120":41.23500061,"119":39.96920013,"118":39.96120071,"117":39.98199844,"116":41.18379974},"231":{"123":21.68770027,"122":25.50799942,"121":34.55360031,"120":39.61589813,"119":40.79859924,"118":40.78319931,"117":40.61209869,"116":40.4197998},"232":{"123":23.27569962,"122":28.80419922,"121":37.3871994,"120":43.73329926,"119":44.87490082,"118":43.11209869,"117":41.94800186,"116":42.25590134},"233":{"123":38.02700043,"122":41.88059998,"121":46.167099,"120":49.29899979,"119":49.53990173,"118":46.73310089,"117":44.85609818,"116":44.94440079},"234":{"123":40.31539917,"122":43.4980011,"121":45.72259903,"120":46.55210114,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":29.13540077,"122":22.21940041,"121":13.42059994,"120":11.93939972,"119":17.71730042,"118":25.48740005,"117":30.49379921,"116":null},"228":{"123":31.53980064,"122":27.51250076,"121":18.15390015,"120":13.49790001,"119":17.22629929,"118":24.23430061,"117":27.3635006,"116":null},"229":{"123":34.32410049,"122":35.41490173,"121":32.66019821,"120":27.88269997,"119":27.80629921,"118":30.7840004,"117":31.2887001,"116":null},"230":{"123":29.93239975,"122":32.69350052,"121":37.31869888,"120":38.31290054,"119":38.49539948,"118":39.42810059,"117":38.61090088,"116":38.31399918},"231":{"123":16.9326992,"122":20.28650093,"121":29.54459953,"120":37.08950043,"119":40.19580078,"118":41.48619843,"117":40.90100098,"116":40.07440186},"232":{"123":18.45949936,"122":22.59519958,"121":31.65609932,"120":39.17179871,"119":42.35369873,"118":42.7181015,"117":41.68780136,"116":41.81330109},"233":{"123":32.21089935,"122":35.66500092,"121":39.68199921,"120":42.40280151,"119":44.04399872,"118":44.47290039,"117":44.02999878,"116":44.09960175},"234":{"123":37.17039871,"122":39.55479813,"121":40.78749847,"120":40.6147995,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in mid-century period?
1b92de72-7f13-4592-ae2c-f63543cb40bd
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical data at a conference on fire risk assessment, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the mid-century and spring in the end-century periods?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in end-century period?
c0172927-2acc-4c0b-8b6b-525a11919c86
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical data at a conference on fire risk assessment, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the mid-century and spring in the end-century periods?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1227/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in end-century period?
8559146c-4241-4195-ae9e-b3c5de430c63
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical data at a conference on fire risk assessment, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the mid-century and spring in the end-century periods?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1227/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in end-century period?
75021cef-bf83-4a5a-b913-632da3bee28f
As a wildfire management specialist evaluating historical data at a conference on fire risk assessment, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, experienced a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the mid-century and spring in the end-century periods?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1227/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) The Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in mid-century period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in mid-century period and spring in end-century period?
aa2812d9-bd4e-4fde-9963-db8d4e4453de
As a wildfire prevention officer reviewing historical data to improve safety measures, I'm interested in understanding which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a greater shift in fire weather index during the autumn months when comparing historical periods to mid-century assessments.
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "autumn in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and autumn in mid-century period?
2e91cb17-a6c1-4535-a4c8-e5e3ae21b971
As a wildfire prevention officer reviewing historical data to improve safety measures, I'm interested in understanding which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a greater shift in fire weather index during the autumn months when comparing historical periods to mid-century assessments.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1251/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "autumn in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and autumn in mid-century period?
7f520237-50f2-4b47-8762-29bc068c6e07
As a wildfire prevention officer reviewing historical data to improve safety measures, I'm interested in understanding which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a greater shift in fire weather index during the autumn months when comparing historical periods to mid-century assessments.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1251/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "autumn in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and autumn in mid-century period?
76453828-c3aa-4bf0-8f83-ccab3bd3c34c
As a wildfire prevention officer reviewing historical data to improve safety measures, I'm interested in understanding which city, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a greater shift in fire weather index during the autumn months when comparing historical periods to mid-century assessments.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1251/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(b) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in mid-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in mid-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":20.43610001,"164":18.14249992,"163":17.74620056,"162":17.82369995,"161":18.52029991,"160":20.82719994,"159":15.83189964,"158":15.68690014,"157":18.46850014,"156":11.09109974},"302":{"165":21.92849922,"164":20.75099945,"163":19.78520012,"162":18.73380089,"161":15.87069988,"160":19.67289925,"159":19.60370064,"158":20.41270065,"157":20.92650032,"156":13.77639961},"303":{"165":24.03860092,"164":24.48600006,"163":22.69799995,"162":21.92860031,"161":19.96339989,"160":20.68370056,"159":21.0177002,"158":22.29540062,"157":22.63349915,"156":19.8321991},"304":{"165":25.76460075,"164":24.0802002,"163":22.57500076,"162":22.55279922,"161":22.43790054,"160":21.90049934,"159":21.97450066,"158":22.81299973,"157":23.17550087,"156":22.38069916},"305":{"165":26.54120064,"164":23.9993,"163":22.50460052,"162":22.51689911,"161":22.50029945,"160":22.22590065,"159":22.34429932,"158":22.89819908,"157":22.98110008,"156":22.43250084},"306":{"165":25.31620026,"164":24.08860016,"163":22.84329987,"162":22.81279945,"161":22.64419937,"160":22.24189949,"159":22.16399956,"158":22.87969971,"157":23.0625,"156":22.46050072},"307":{"165":24.53910065,"164":23.83930016,"163":23.11249924,"162":22.95179939,"161":22.67099953,"160":22.34609985,"159":22.47100067,"158":22.74250031,"157":22.91690063,"156":22.62700081},"308":{"165":24.44569969,"164":23.69519997,"163":23.08180046,"162":22.98719978,"161":22.70120049,"160":22.6609993,"159":22.73069954,"158":22.86330032,"157":22.86149979,"156":22.3491993},"309":{"165":24.50930023,"164":23.76370049,"163":23.13809967,"162":22.98559952,"161":22.92519951,"160":22.72909927,"159":22.74160004,"158":22.87969971,"157":22.71220016,"156":null},"310":{"165":24.38680077,"164":23.47789955,"163":22.88619995,"162":22.87199974,"161":23.02230072,"160":22.79640007,"159":22.47520065,"158":22.70249939,"157":22.55380058,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.99650002,"225":17.41460037,"224":18.11940002,"223":18.0984993,"222":18.22610092,"221":19.12490082,"220":19.87660027,"219":null},"225":{"227":13.13829994,"226":14.34920025,"225":16.41640091,"224":17.7215004,"223":17.84729958,"222":17.90780067,"221":18.43090057,"220":19.21249962,"219":19.0034008},"226":{"227":13.76539993,"226":14.35709953,"225":16.70999908,"224":17.41360092,"223":17.77160072,"222":17.87719917,"221":18.12129974,"220":18.55699921,"219":18.60989952},"227":{"227":15.17020035,"226":14.5024004,"225":16.29660034,"224":16.92410088,"223":17.44009972,"222":17.91799927,"221":18.18009949,"220":18.4151001,"219":18.33300018},"228":{"227":13.03750038,"226":14.99549961,"225":15.76790047,"224":16.1310997,"223":16.43910027,"222":17.66839981,"221":18.07749939,"220":18.11779976,"219":17.97340012},"229":{"227":12.90709972,"226":14.96510029,"225":14.82750034,"224":15.36929989,"223":16.79089928,"222":16.98539925,"221":17.31030083,"220":17.64279938,"219":17.56879997},"230":{"227":12.93459988,"226":13.39220047,"225":12.7112999,"224":13.29510021,"223":15.8902998,"222":15.0156002,"221":16.71570015,"220":17.21940041,"219":16.87989998},"231":{"227":12.78349972,"226":12.93340015,"225":12.51760006,"224":13.0951004,"223":15.37030029,"222":14.25749969,"221":16.24819946,"220":16.80699921,"219":15.60579967},"232":{"227":12.0316,"226":12.40880013,"225":12.63679981,"224":12.58850002,"223":13.57069969,"222":12.86009979,"221":13.61789989,"220":14.78689957,"219":13.5678997}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "autumn in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and autumn in mid-century period?
1dcc847d-6861-4a9b-9796-35275d17e70c
As a hydrologist analyzing long-term precipitation trends for a forthcoming urban planning report, I need to know which city, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has experienced a more significant change in annual total precipitation from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
tabular
null
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in historical period', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in historical period']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.5367012,"77":53.99169922,"76":56.08390045,"75":58.82239914,"74":59.2193985,"73":55.49169922,"72":53.62599945,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":52.69950104,"77":55.38349915,"76":58.96490097,"75":63.18780136,"74":61.63570023,"73":56.88330078,"72":54.96179962,"71":55.37990189,"70":56.42139816,"69":58.02730179,"68":60.27719879},"422":{"79":null,"78":52.49069977,"77":56.93569946,"76":62.23329926,"75":65.35540009,"74":66.06210327,"73":62.62080002,"72":55.8390007,"71":55.02550125,"70":57.17490005,"69":58.96969986,"68":62.07509995},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.57550049,"77":60.76229858,"76":67.30319977,"75":69.45259857,"74":60.77930069,"73":61.17449951,"72":56.42079926,"71":54.36660004,"70":60.86059952,"69":62.81079865,"68":67.12129974},"424":{"79":null,"78":56.4817009,"77":63.91529846,"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.39659882,"73":56.00960159,"72":53.0298996,"71":58.45050049,"70":65.4437027,"69":69.18460083,"68":75.64009857},"425":{"79":53.77999878,"78":57.5931015,"77":64.14790344,"76":null,"75":null,"74":57.28720093,"73":57.40190125,"72":59.5367012,"71":66.86859894,"70":66.02189636,"69":72.52670288,"68":79.45469666},"426":{"79":53.80459976,"78":58.31380081,"77":63.83200073,"76":77.05439758,"75":71.66010284,"74":62.32360077,"73":62.58269882,"72":67.61710358,"71":72.67040253,"70":72.52310181,"69":76.70999908,"68":73.26989746},"427":{"79":54.33560181,"78":59.46559906,"77":62.27909851,"76":71.76039886,"75":71.30090332,"74":66.01010132,"73":70.05090332,"72":77.53299713,"71":78.71130371,"70":84.44609833,"69":76.47399902,"68":67.46749878},"428":{"79":55.50170135,"78":61.17179871,"77":66.98549652,"76":77.34850311,"75":83.7322998,"74":76.09889984,"73":76.44799805,"72":79.84290314,"71":76.89369965,"70":76.43209839,"69":71.89579773,"68":null},"429":{"79":57.50159836,"78":63.77410126,"77":72.69450378,"76":85.30899811,"75":89.82420349,"74":76.62969971,"73":70.70659637,"72":71.55329895,"71":68.59480286,"70":67.22480011,"69":67.51789856,"68":null},"430":{"79":60.38330078,"78":69.01899719,"77":85.52809906,"76":100.52500153,"75":86.62349701,"74":75.33390045,"73":72.76409912,"72":70.80069733,"71":69.57099915,"70":68.74960327,"69":68.00090027,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":77.62950134,"74":74.0503006,"73":71.57929993,"72":69.83799744,"71":68.83920288,"70":68.1576004,"69":67.5970993,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":40.95980072,"181":39.99679947,"180":38.22280121,"179":37.51639938,"178":36.9129982,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":38.1554985,"182":38.66479874,"181":38.1576004,"180":37.67900085,"179":37.02119827,"178":36.48920059,"177":36.47399902,"176":37.08810043,"175":37.77560043},"493":{"184":null,"183":36.71360016,"182":36.43579865,"181":36.89770126,"180":37.8730011,"179":37.58710098,"178":36.68030167,"177":36.93270111,"176":37.40750122,"175":37.23289871},"494":{"184":37.41320038,"183":36.93209839,"182":36.58480072,"181":36.91019821,"180":36.9978981,"179":36.3492012,"178":36.16329956,"177":36.75930023,"176":37.18190002,"175":36.7541008},"495":{"184":38.16820145,"183":37.57369995,"182":37.75600052,"181":37.34170151,"180":37.34059906,"179":38.88470078,"178":38.18190002,"177":38.31629944,"176":38.50249863,"175":38.51810074},"496":{"184":38.80599976,"183":39.69189835,"182":38.13339996,"181":38.68939972,"180":39.17399979,"179":39.92359924,"178":39.01750183,"177":39.01029968,"176":37.74459839,"175":38.00389862},"497":{"184":40.71549988,"183":41.80250168,"182":41.15980148,"181":39.12419891,"180":39.78889847,"179":40.41820145,"178":38.89839935,"177":37.88479996,"176":38.32949829,"175":38.89300156},"498":{"184":41.90140152,"183":42.20130157,"182":48.14410019,"181":40.45140076,"180":38.35129929,"179":38.99200058,"178":38.20360184,"177":38.60860062,"176":38.91669846,"175":40.00099945},"499":{"184":40.87730026,"183":49.80189896,"182":47.35079956,"181":45.26890182,"180":38.36500168,"179":39.2419014,"178":39.33480072,"177":39.24409866,"176":39.69609833,"175":39.83720016},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":45.30270004,"180":45.00960159,"179":45.2179985,"178":49.35599899,"177":40.43980026,"176":40.29270172,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
909c2b8f-0030-492a-a5b7-8150e0f188aa
As a hydrologist analyzing long-term precipitation trends for a forthcoming urban planning report, I need to know which city, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has experienced a more significant change in annual total precipitation from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1378/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in historical period', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in historical period']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.5367012,"77":53.99169922,"76":56.08390045,"75":58.82239914,"74":59.2193985,"73":55.49169922,"72":53.62599945,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":52.69950104,"77":55.38349915,"76":58.96490097,"75":63.18780136,"74":61.63570023,"73":56.88330078,"72":54.96179962,"71":55.37990189,"70":56.42139816,"69":58.02730179,"68":60.27719879},"422":{"79":null,"78":52.49069977,"77":56.93569946,"76":62.23329926,"75":65.35540009,"74":66.06210327,"73":62.62080002,"72":55.8390007,"71":55.02550125,"70":57.17490005,"69":58.96969986,"68":62.07509995},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.57550049,"77":60.76229858,"76":67.30319977,"75":69.45259857,"74":60.77930069,"73":61.17449951,"72":56.42079926,"71":54.36660004,"70":60.86059952,"69":62.81079865,"68":67.12129974},"424":{"79":null,"78":56.4817009,"77":63.91529846,"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.39659882,"73":56.00960159,"72":53.0298996,"71":58.45050049,"70":65.4437027,"69":69.18460083,"68":75.64009857},"425":{"79":53.77999878,"78":57.5931015,"77":64.14790344,"76":null,"75":null,"74":57.28720093,"73":57.40190125,"72":59.5367012,"71":66.86859894,"70":66.02189636,"69":72.52670288,"68":79.45469666},"426":{"79":53.80459976,"78":58.31380081,"77":63.83200073,"76":77.05439758,"75":71.66010284,"74":62.32360077,"73":62.58269882,"72":67.61710358,"71":72.67040253,"70":72.52310181,"69":76.70999908,"68":73.26989746},"427":{"79":54.33560181,"78":59.46559906,"77":62.27909851,"76":71.76039886,"75":71.30090332,"74":66.01010132,"73":70.05090332,"72":77.53299713,"71":78.71130371,"70":84.44609833,"69":76.47399902,"68":67.46749878},"428":{"79":55.50170135,"78":61.17179871,"77":66.98549652,"76":77.34850311,"75":83.7322998,"74":76.09889984,"73":76.44799805,"72":79.84290314,"71":76.89369965,"70":76.43209839,"69":71.89579773,"68":null},"429":{"79":57.50159836,"78":63.77410126,"77":72.69450378,"76":85.30899811,"75":89.82420349,"74":76.62969971,"73":70.70659637,"72":71.55329895,"71":68.59480286,"70":67.22480011,"69":67.51789856,"68":null},"430":{"79":60.38330078,"78":69.01899719,"77":85.52809906,"76":100.52500153,"75":86.62349701,"74":75.33390045,"73":72.76409912,"72":70.80069733,"71":69.57099915,"70":68.74960327,"69":68.00090027,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":77.62950134,"74":74.0503006,"73":71.57929993,"72":69.83799744,"71":68.83920288,"70":68.1576004,"69":67.5970993,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":40.95980072,"181":39.99679947,"180":38.22280121,"179":37.51639938,"178":36.9129982,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":38.1554985,"182":38.66479874,"181":38.1576004,"180":37.67900085,"179":37.02119827,"178":36.48920059,"177":36.47399902,"176":37.08810043,"175":37.77560043},"493":{"184":null,"183":36.71360016,"182":36.43579865,"181":36.89770126,"180":37.8730011,"179":37.58710098,"178":36.68030167,"177":36.93270111,"176":37.40750122,"175":37.23289871},"494":{"184":37.41320038,"183":36.93209839,"182":36.58480072,"181":36.91019821,"180":36.9978981,"179":36.3492012,"178":36.16329956,"177":36.75930023,"176":37.18190002,"175":36.7541008},"495":{"184":38.16820145,"183":37.57369995,"182":37.75600052,"181":37.34170151,"180":37.34059906,"179":38.88470078,"178":38.18190002,"177":38.31629944,"176":38.50249863,"175":38.51810074},"496":{"184":38.80599976,"183":39.69189835,"182":38.13339996,"181":38.68939972,"180":39.17399979,"179":39.92359924,"178":39.01750183,"177":39.01029968,"176":37.74459839,"175":38.00389862},"497":{"184":40.71549988,"183":41.80250168,"182":41.15980148,"181":39.12419891,"180":39.78889847,"179":40.41820145,"178":38.89839935,"177":37.88479996,"176":38.32949829,"175":38.89300156},"498":{"184":41.90140152,"183":42.20130157,"182":48.14410019,"181":40.45140076,"180":38.35129929,"179":38.99200058,"178":38.20360184,"177":38.60860062,"176":38.91669846,"175":40.00099945},"499":{"184":40.87730026,"183":49.80189896,"182":47.35079956,"181":45.26890182,"180":38.36500168,"179":39.2419014,"178":39.33480072,"177":39.24409866,"176":39.69609833,"175":39.83720016},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":45.30270004,"180":45.00960159,"179":45.2179985,"178":49.35599899,"177":40.43980026,"176":40.29270172,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
24fcab2f-6374-47aa-8b2b-e14b2094eddd
As a hydrologist analyzing long-term precipitation trends for a forthcoming urban planning report, I need to know which city, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has experienced a more significant change in annual total precipitation from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1378/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in historical period', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in historical period']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.5367012,"77":53.99169922,"76":56.08390045,"75":58.82239914,"74":59.2193985,"73":55.49169922,"72":53.62599945,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":52.69950104,"77":55.38349915,"76":58.96490097,"75":63.18780136,"74":61.63570023,"73":56.88330078,"72":54.96179962,"71":55.37990189,"70":56.42139816,"69":58.02730179,"68":60.27719879},"422":{"79":null,"78":52.49069977,"77":56.93569946,"76":62.23329926,"75":65.35540009,"74":66.06210327,"73":62.62080002,"72":55.8390007,"71":55.02550125,"70":57.17490005,"69":58.96969986,"68":62.07509995},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.57550049,"77":60.76229858,"76":67.30319977,"75":69.45259857,"74":60.77930069,"73":61.17449951,"72":56.42079926,"71":54.36660004,"70":60.86059952,"69":62.81079865,"68":67.12129974},"424":{"79":null,"78":56.4817009,"77":63.91529846,"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.39659882,"73":56.00960159,"72":53.0298996,"71":58.45050049,"70":65.4437027,"69":69.18460083,"68":75.64009857},"425":{"79":53.77999878,"78":57.5931015,"77":64.14790344,"76":null,"75":null,"74":57.28720093,"73":57.40190125,"72":59.5367012,"71":66.86859894,"70":66.02189636,"69":72.52670288,"68":79.45469666},"426":{"79":53.80459976,"78":58.31380081,"77":63.83200073,"76":77.05439758,"75":71.66010284,"74":62.32360077,"73":62.58269882,"72":67.61710358,"71":72.67040253,"70":72.52310181,"69":76.70999908,"68":73.26989746},"427":{"79":54.33560181,"78":59.46559906,"77":62.27909851,"76":71.76039886,"75":71.30090332,"74":66.01010132,"73":70.05090332,"72":77.53299713,"71":78.71130371,"70":84.44609833,"69":76.47399902,"68":67.46749878},"428":{"79":55.50170135,"78":61.17179871,"77":66.98549652,"76":77.34850311,"75":83.7322998,"74":76.09889984,"73":76.44799805,"72":79.84290314,"71":76.89369965,"70":76.43209839,"69":71.89579773,"68":null},"429":{"79":57.50159836,"78":63.77410126,"77":72.69450378,"76":85.30899811,"75":89.82420349,"74":76.62969971,"73":70.70659637,"72":71.55329895,"71":68.59480286,"70":67.22480011,"69":67.51789856,"68":null},"430":{"79":60.38330078,"78":69.01899719,"77":85.52809906,"76":100.52500153,"75":86.62349701,"74":75.33390045,"73":72.76409912,"72":70.80069733,"71":69.57099915,"70":68.74960327,"69":68.00090027,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":77.62950134,"74":74.0503006,"73":71.57929993,"72":69.83799744,"71":68.83920288,"70":68.1576004,"69":67.5970993,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":40.95980072,"181":39.99679947,"180":38.22280121,"179":37.51639938,"178":36.9129982,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":38.1554985,"182":38.66479874,"181":38.1576004,"180":37.67900085,"179":37.02119827,"178":36.48920059,"177":36.47399902,"176":37.08810043,"175":37.77560043},"493":{"184":null,"183":36.71360016,"182":36.43579865,"181":36.89770126,"180":37.8730011,"179":37.58710098,"178":36.68030167,"177":36.93270111,"176":37.40750122,"175":37.23289871},"494":{"184":37.41320038,"183":36.93209839,"182":36.58480072,"181":36.91019821,"180":36.9978981,"179":36.3492012,"178":36.16329956,"177":36.75930023,"176":37.18190002,"175":36.7541008},"495":{"184":38.16820145,"183":37.57369995,"182":37.75600052,"181":37.34170151,"180":37.34059906,"179":38.88470078,"178":38.18190002,"177":38.31629944,"176":38.50249863,"175":38.51810074},"496":{"184":38.80599976,"183":39.69189835,"182":38.13339996,"181":38.68939972,"180":39.17399979,"179":39.92359924,"178":39.01750183,"177":39.01029968,"176":37.74459839,"175":38.00389862},"497":{"184":40.71549988,"183":41.80250168,"182":41.15980148,"181":39.12419891,"180":39.78889847,"179":40.41820145,"178":38.89839935,"177":37.88479996,"176":38.32949829,"175":38.89300156},"498":{"184":41.90140152,"183":42.20130157,"182":48.14410019,"181":40.45140076,"180":38.35129929,"179":38.99200058,"178":38.20360184,"177":38.60860062,"176":38.91669846,"175":40.00099945},"499":{"184":40.87730026,"183":49.80189896,"182":47.35079956,"181":45.26890182,"180":38.36500168,"179":39.2419014,"178":39.33480072,"177":39.24409866,"176":39.69609833,"175":39.83720016},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":45.30270004,"180":45.00960159,"179":45.2179985,"178":49.35599899,"177":40.43980026,"176":40.29270172,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
b00836a3-531e-4fcb-988c-91e1ae4c77e9
As a hydrologist analyzing long-term precipitation trends for a forthcoming urban planning report, I need to know which city, New Orleans, LA, or Washington, DC, has experienced a more significant change in annual total precipitation from the historical period to the end-century period under RCP8.5.
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1378/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(b)
['(a) There was no significant difference in the changes between New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States.', '(b) Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change than New Orleans, LA, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, New Orleans, LA, United States and Washington, DC, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) The New Orleans, LA, United States experienced a greater change than Washington, DC, United States.']
['New Orleans, LA, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'New Orleans, LA, United States in historical period', 'Washington, DC, United States in end-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Washington, DC, United States in historical period']
{"420":{"79":null,"78":59.09410095,"77":60.9211998,"76":62.20389938,"75":65.95809937,"74":65.99629974,"73":63.22890091,"72":61.83420181,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":60.35919952,"77":62.59489822,"76":66.62190247,"75":70.41500092,"74":68.4937973,"73":65.74060059,"72":63.58100128,"71":63.34410095,"70":64.60420227,"69":64.90229797,"68":66.3065033},"422":{"79":null,"78":61.18870163,"77":64.47820282,"76":69.84780121,"75":70.73970032,"74":67.01529694,"73":70.4108963,"72":63.46170044,"71":63.5243988,"70":65.52149963,"69":65.08429718,"68":67.58350372},"423":{"79":null,"78":62.63090134,"77":67.729599,"76":74.76809692,"75":73.41750336,"74":62.24449921,"73":65.77449799,"72":65.96970367,"71":62.40069962,"70":68.90229797,"69":69.85289764,"68":73.02940369},"424":{"79":null,"78":64.74749756,"77":72.30619812,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.41949844,"73":59.5318985,"72":62.51940155,"71":64.59069824,"70":71.2098999,"69":74.61399841,"68":79.53130341},"425":{"79":61.41630173,"78":66.53579712,"77":73.3470993,"76":null,"75":null,"74":61.49069977,"73":61.4416008,"72":67.7335968,"71":71.86250305,"70":67.64040375,"69":75.61620331,"68":85.86019897},"426":{"79":61.50389862,"78":67.34519958,"77":72.64969635,"76":84.62090302,"75":76.32299805,"74":68.04720306,"73":71.12609863,"72":76.18840027,"71":80.52269745,"70":78.92289734,"69":75.501297,"68":74.37259674},"427":{"79":62.30160141,"78":67.76789856,"77":70.98010254,"76":81.47640228,"75":77.67299652,"74":70.74040222,"73":79.76170349,"72":83.22000122,"71":83.90209961,"70":90.38909912,"69":77.23300171,"68":70.32730103},"428":{"79":62.63579941,"78":68.59809875,"77":76.03160095,"76":86.9910965,"75":89.77760315,"74":78.31639862,"73":78.23049927,"72":81.33789825,"71":78.94799805,"70":79.51920319,"69":75.41840363,"68":null},"429":{"79":64.44909668,"78":72.2779007,"77":82.05149841,"76":94.05789948,"75":92.32430267,"74":80.28939819,"73":72.16359711,"72":74.26059723,"71":72.64620209,"70":71.72720337,"69":71.26069641,"68":null},"430":{"79":67.7779007,"78":78.70800018,"77":95.20349884,"76":104.65899658,"75":88.23690033,"74":79.89579773,"73":76.53690338,"72":74.69470215,"71":74.35849762,"70":73.67949677,"69":71.72080231,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":81.99230194,"74":79.73020172,"73":76.59380341,"72":75.74710083,"71":73.99019623,"70":73.18540192,"69":71.77880096,"68":null}}
{"420":{"79":null,"78":52.5367012,"77":53.99169922,"76":56.08390045,"75":58.82239914,"74":59.2193985,"73":55.49169922,"72":53.62599945,"71":null,"70":null,"69":null,"68":null},"421":{"79":null,"78":52.69950104,"77":55.38349915,"76":58.96490097,"75":63.18780136,"74":61.63570023,"73":56.88330078,"72":54.96179962,"71":55.37990189,"70":56.42139816,"69":58.02730179,"68":60.27719879},"422":{"79":null,"78":52.49069977,"77":56.93569946,"76":62.23329926,"75":65.35540009,"74":66.06210327,"73":62.62080002,"72":55.8390007,"71":55.02550125,"70":57.17490005,"69":58.96969986,"68":62.07509995},"423":{"79":null,"78":54.57550049,"77":60.76229858,"76":67.30319977,"75":69.45259857,"74":60.77930069,"73":61.17449951,"72":56.42079926,"71":54.36660004,"70":60.86059952,"69":62.81079865,"68":67.12129974},"424":{"79":null,"78":56.4817009,"77":63.91529846,"76":null,"75":null,"74":59.39659882,"73":56.00960159,"72":53.0298996,"71":58.45050049,"70":65.4437027,"69":69.18460083,"68":75.64009857},"425":{"79":53.77999878,"78":57.5931015,"77":64.14790344,"76":null,"75":null,"74":57.28720093,"73":57.40190125,"72":59.5367012,"71":66.86859894,"70":66.02189636,"69":72.52670288,"68":79.45469666},"426":{"79":53.80459976,"78":58.31380081,"77":63.83200073,"76":77.05439758,"75":71.66010284,"74":62.32360077,"73":62.58269882,"72":67.61710358,"71":72.67040253,"70":72.52310181,"69":76.70999908,"68":73.26989746},"427":{"79":54.33560181,"78":59.46559906,"77":62.27909851,"76":71.76039886,"75":71.30090332,"74":66.01010132,"73":70.05090332,"72":77.53299713,"71":78.71130371,"70":84.44609833,"69":76.47399902,"68":67.46749878},"428":{"79":55.50170135,"78":61.17179871,"77":66.98549652,"76":77.34850311,"75":83.7322998,"74":76.09889984,"73":76.44799805,"72":79.84290314,"71":76.89369965,"70":76.43209839,"69":71.89579773,"68":null},"429":{"79":57.50159836,"78":63.77410126,"77":72.69450378,"76":85.30899811,"75":89.82420349,"74":76.62969971,"73":70.70659637,"72":71.55329895,"71":68.59480286,"70":67.22480011,"69":67.51789856,"68":null},"430":{"79":60.38330078,"78":69.01899719,"77":85.52809906,"76":100.52500153,"75":86.62349701,"74":75.33390045,"73":72.76409912,"72":70.80069733,"71":69.57099915,"70":68.74960327,"69":68.00090027,"68":null},"431":{"79":null,"78":null,"77":null,"76":null,"75":77.62950134,"74":74.0503006,"73":71.57929993,"72":69.83799744,"71":68.83920288,"70":68.1576004,"69":67.5970993,"68":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":49.63729858,"181":48.96149826,"180":46.91650009,"179":46.36579895,"178":46.09560013,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":46.61299896,"182":47.1529007,"181":46.70619965,"180":46.91839981,"179":46.97000122,"178":46.17509842,"177":45.50149918,"176":45.7010994,"175":46.19869995},"493":{"184":null,"183":45.15879822,"182":44.78219986,"181":45.68920135,"180":47.74349976,"179":47.57820129,"178":46.26179886,"177":45.97639847,"176":46.41279984,"175":45.55059814},"494":{"184":44.41080093,"183":44.91749954,"182":44.80619812,"181":45.95280075,"180":46.33860016,"179":45.78609848,"178":45.10430145,"177":46.09249878,"176":46.56570053,"175":45.53620148},"495":{"184":45.60540009,"183":46.16569901,"182":46.51169968,"181":47.04899979,"180":47.47040176,"179":50.69120026,"178":49.81750107,"177":49.25830078,"176":48.64170074,"175":48.38529968},"496":{"184":48.07429886,"183":50.2397995,"182":48.74480057,"181":49.70970154,"180":50.9571991,"179":51.64960098,"178":50.69919968,"177":49.98770142,"176":47.39670181,"175":48.51380157},"497":{"184":52.87490082,"183":55.75400162,"182":54.66230011,"181":51.00889969,"180":51.21709824,"179":52.01319885,"178":49.30450058,"177":47.54359818,"176":48.51869965,"175":49.25590134},"498":{"184":55.95930099,"183":59.13380051,"182":62.69829941,"181":54.85250092,"180":50.41490173,"179":50.07659912,"178":48.30599976,"177":48.23500061,"176":48.64970016,"175":50.30220032},"499":{"184":56.96340179,"183":65.7858963,"182":62.06999969,"181":58.99679947,"180":51.28710175,"179":51.36719894,"178":51.23220062,"177":49.81549835,"176":49.30500031,"175":49.30599976},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":61.15169907,"180":59.67549896,"179":58.08769989,"178":60.62360001,"177":52.16930008,"176":51.93310165,"175":null}}
{"491":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":40.95980072,"181":39.99679947,"180":38.22280121,"179":37.51639938,"178":36.9129982,"177":null,"176":null,"175":null},"492":{"184":null,"183":38.1554985,"182":38.66479874,"181":38.1576004,"180":37.67900085,"179":37.02119827,"178":36.48920059,"177":36.47399902,"176":37.08810043,"175":37.77560043},"493":{"184":null,"183":36.71360016,"182":36.43579865,"181":36.89770126,"180":37.8730011,"179":37.58710098,"178":36.68030167,"177":36.93270111,"176":37.40750122,"175":37.23289871},"494":{"184":37.41320038,"183":36.93209839,"182":36.58480072,"181":36.91019821,"180":36.9978981,"179":36.3492012,"178":36.16329956,"177":36.75930023,"176":37.18190002,"175":36.7541008},"495":{"184":38.16820145,"183":37.57369995,"182":37.75600052,"181":37.34170151,"180":37.34059906,"179":38.88470078,"178":38.18190002,"177":38.31629944,"176":38.50249863,"175":38.51810074},"496":{"184":38.80599976,"183":39.69189835,"182":38.13339996,"181":38.68939972,"180":39.17399979,"179":39.92359924,"178":39.01750183,"177":39.01029968,"176":37.74459839,"175":38.00389862},"497":{"184":40.71549988,"183":41.80250168,"182":41.15980148,"181":39.12419891,"180":39.78889847,"179":40.41820145,"178":38.89839935,"177":37.88479996,"176":38.32949829,"175":38.89300156},"498":{"184":41.90140152,"183":42.20130157,"182":48.14410019,"181":40.45140076,"180":38.35129929,"179":38.99200058,"178":38.20360184,"177":38.60860062,"176":38.91669846,"175":40.00099945},"499":{"184":40.87730026,"183":49.80189896,"182":47.35079956,"181":45.26890182,"180":38.36500168,"179":39.2419014,"178":39.33480072,"177":39.24409866,"176":39.69609833,"175":39.83720016},"500":{"184":null,"183":null,"182":null,"181":45.30270004,"180":45.00960159,"179":45.2179985,"178":49.35599899,"177":40.43980026,"176":40.29270172,"175":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "annual total precipitation", "location1": "New Orleans, LA, United States", "location2": "Washington, DC, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP8.5)", "time_frame2": "historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of New Orleans, LA, United States or Washington, DC, United States experienced a greater change in annual total precipitation throughout end-century period (RCP8.5) and historical period?
b0ffdc1f-af8d-4922-833d-3fd69b989460
As an environmental scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on wildfire management, I would like to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has undergone a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring in the late century and winter in the mid-century period?
trend
tabular
null
48
(b)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":13.03849983,"150":10.04259968,"149":10.35789967,"148":11.2645998,"147":10.46150017,"146":10.49960041,"145":11.82530022},"303":{"151":17.04050064,"150":15.01060009,"149":14.57110023,"148":14.72019958,"147":13.16240025,"146":12.73579979,"145":14.59780025},"304":{"151":16.97039986,"150":16.43810081,"149":16.22710037,"148":15.93729973,"147":16.04649925,"146":15.84630013,"145":15.79199982},"305":{"151":15.94040012,"150":15.80070019,"149":15.81029987,"148":15.3991003,"147":15.70030022,"146":16.62630081,"145":15.89799976},"306":{"151":15.70730019,"150":15.55379963,"149":15.4921999,"148":15.23810005,"147":15.22070026,"146":15.4758997,"145":15.31809998},"307":{"151":15.62069988,"150":15.33539963,"149":15.05280018,"148":14.83360004,"147":14.51420021,"146":14.37269974,"145":13.96689987},"308":{"151":15.58040047,"150":15.3757,"149":15.06760025,"148":14.70370007,"147":14.4975996,"146":14.30920029,"145":14.02060032}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":33.67919922,"122":27.15999985,"121":18.02359962,"120":15.85680008,"119":21.7826004,"118":29.65049934,"117":35.02019882,"116":null},"228":{"123":35.70930099,"122":32.88050079,"121":23.68729973,"120":18.2154007,"119":22.02129936,"118":29.09670067,"117":32.76039886,"116":null},"229":{"123":39.69879913,"122":41.2317009,"121":38.81600189,"120":33.90269852,"119":33.26940155,"118":36.31880188,"117":37.2643013,"116":null},"230":{"123":35.40950012,"122":38.31470108,"121":42.80559921,"120":43.39730072,"119":43.49909973,"118":44.14640045,"117":43.52080154,"116":43.60079956},"231":{"123":22.0135994,"122":25.0177002,"121":34.45389938,"120":41.27479935,"119":43.99000168,"118":45.15650177,"117":45.00180054,"116":44.61380005},"232":{"123":23.43560028,"122":27.16819954,"121":35.63809967,"120":42.80799866,"119":45.73249817,"118":46.04449844,"117":45.66040039,"116":46.17060089},"233":{"123":36.67350006,"122":39.84420013,"121":43.77489853,"120":46.20019913,"119":47.64049911,"118":48.10680008,"117":47.97520065,"116":48.13299942},"234":{"123":40.99940109,"122":43.42160034,"121":45.03010178,"120":45.16460037,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and winter in mid-century period?
d0910906-3a1c-4c9e-97b9-60ad7d517a6b
As an environmental scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on wildfire management, I would like to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has undergone a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring in the late century and winter in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1327/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":13.03849983,"150":10.04259968,"149":10.35789967,"148":11.2645998,"147":10.46150017,"146":10.49960041,"145":11.82530022},"303":{"151":17.04050064,"150":15.01060009,"149":14.57110023,"148":14.72019958,"147":13.16240025,"146":12.73579979,"145":14.59780025},"304":{"151":16.97039986,"150":16.43810081,"149":16.22710037,"148":15.93729973,"147":16.04649925,"146":15.84630013,"145":15.79199982},"305":{"151":15.94040012,"150":15.80070019,"149":15.81029987,"148":15.3991003,"147":15.70030022,"146":16.62630081,"145":15.89799976},"306":{"151":15.70730019,"150":15.55379963,"149":15.4921999,"148":15.23810005,"147":15.22070026,"146":15.4758997,"145":15.31809998},"307":{"151":15.62069988,"150":15.33539963,"149":15.05280018,"148":14.83360004,"147":14.51420021,"146":14.37269974,"145":13.96689987},"308":{"151":15.58040047,"150":15.3757,"149":15.06760025,"148":14.70370007,"147":14.4975996,"146":14.30920029,"145":14.02060032}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":33.67919922,"122":27.15999985,"121":18.02359962,"120":15.85680008,"119":21.7826004,"118":29.65049934,"117":35.02019882,"116":null},"228":{"123":35.70930099,"122":32.88050079,"121":23.68729973,"120":18.2154007,"119":22.02129936,"118":29.09670067,"117":32.76039886,"116":null},"229":{"123":39.69879913,"122":41.2317009,"121":38.81600189,"120":33.90269852,"119":33.26940155,"118":36.31880188,"117":37.2643013,"116":null},"230":{"123":35.40950012,"122":38.31470108,"121":42.80559921,"120":43.39730072,"119":43.49909973,"118":44.14640045,"117":43.52080154,"116":43.60079956},"231":{"123":22.0135994,"122":25.0177002,"121":34.45389938,"120":41.27479935,"119":43.99000168,"118":45.15650177,"117":45.00180054,"116":44.61380005},"232":{"123":23.43560028,"122":27.16819954,"121":35.63809967,"120":42.80799866,"119":45.73249817,"118":46.04449844,"117":45.66040039,"116":46.17060089},"233":{"123":36.67350006,"122":39.84420013,"121":43.77489853,"120":46.20019913,"119":47.64049911,"118":48.10680008,"117":47.97520065,"116":48.13299942},"234":{"123":40.99940109,"122":43.42160034,"121":45.03010178,"120":45.16460037,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and winter in mid-century period?
9f0a7be1-47f3-46f4-999d-c444ccf89ca1
As an environmental scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on wildfire management, I would like to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has undergone a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring in the late century and winter in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1327/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":13.03849983,"150":10.04259968,"149":10.35789967,"148":11.2645998,"147":10.46150017,"146":10.49960041,"145":11.82530022},"303":{"151":17.04050064,"150":15.01060009,"149":14.57110023,"148":14.72019958,"147":13.16240025,"146":12.73579979,"145":14.59780025},"304":{"151":16.97039986,"150":16.43810081,"149":16.22710037,"148":15.93729973,"147":16.04649925,"146":15.84630013,"145":15.79199982},"305":{"151":15.94040012,"150":15.80070019,"149":15.81029987,"148":15.3991003,"147":15.70030022,"146":16.62630081,"145":15.89799976},"306":{"151":15.70730019,"150":15.55379963,"149":15.4921999,"148":15.23810005,"147":15.22070026,"146":15.4758997,"145":15.31809998},"307":{"151":15.62069988,"150":15.33539963,"149":15.05280018,"148":14.83360004,"147":14.51420021,"146":14.37269974,"145":13.96689987},"308":{"151":15.58040047,"150":15.3757,"149":15.06760025,"148":14.70370007,"147":14.4975996,"146":14.30920029,"145":14.02060032}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":33.67919922,"122":27.15999985,"121":18.02359962,"120":15.85680008,"119":21.7826004,"118":29.65049934,"117":35.02019882,"116":null},"228":{"123":35.70930099,"122":32.88050079,"121":23.68729973,"120":18.2154007,"119":22.02129936,"118":29.09670067,"117":32.76039886,"116":null},"229":{"123":39.69879913,"122":41.2317009,"121":38.81600189,"120":33.90269852,"119":33.26940155,"118":36.31880188,"117":37.2643013,"116":null},"230":{"123":35.40950012,"122":38.31470108,"121":42.80559921,"120":43.39730072,"119":43.49909973,"118":44.14640045,"117":43.52080154,"116":43.60079956},"231":{"123":22.0135994,"122":25.0177002,"121":34.45389938,"120":41.27479935,"119":43.99000168,"118":45.15650177,"117":45.00180054,"116":44.61380005},"232":{"123":23.43560028,"122":27.16819954,"121":35.63809967,"120":42.80799866,"119":45.73249817,"118":46.04449844,"117":45.66040039,"116":46.17060089},"233":{"123":36.67350006,"122":39.84420013,"121":43.77489853,"120":46.20019913,"119":47.64049911,"118":48.10680008,"117":47.97520065,"116":48.13299942},"234":{"123":40.99940109,"122":43.42160034,"121":45.03010178,"120":45.16460037,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and winter in mid-century period?
b4f6365f-1b3a-48ce-9692-8c81cba549c2
As an environmental scientist presenting findings at a regional conference on wildfire management, I would like to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has undergone a more significant shift in fire weather index during spring in the late century and winter in the mid-century period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1327/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius48.png
48
(b)
['(a) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(b) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(c) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(d) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in winter in mid-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in winter in mid-century period']
{"302":{"151":13.03849983,"150":10.04259968,"149":10.35789967,"148":11.2645998,"147":10.46150017,"146":10.49960041,"145":11.82530022},"303":{"151":17.04050064,"150":15.01060009,"149":14.57110023,"148":14.72019958,"147":13.16240025,"146":12.73579979,"145":14.59780025},"304":{"151":16.97039986,"150":16.43810081,"149":16.22710037,"148":15.93729973,"147":16.04649925,"146":15.84630013,"145":15.79199982},"305":{"151":15.94040012,"150":15.80070019,"149":15.81029987,"148":15.3991003,"147":15.70030022,"146":16.62630081,"145":15.89799976},"306":{"151":15.70730019,"150":15.55379963,"149":15.4921999,"148":15.23810005,"147":15.22070026,"146":15.4758997,"145":15.31809998},"307":{"151":15.62069988,"150":15.33539963,"149":15.05280018,"148":14.83360004,"147":14.51420021,"146":14.37269974,"145":13.96689987},"308":{"151":15.58040047,"150":15.3757,"149":15.06760025,"148":14.70370007,"147":14.4975996,"146":14.30920029,"145":14.02060032}}
{"302":{"151":12.11125924,"150":7.87454732,"149":8.66734981,"148":9.01827159,"147":7.06819342,"146":6.45296296,"145":6.77522634},"303":{"151":11.99924691,"150":9.42313168,"149":10.78140332,"148":10.36174072,"147":7.71009464,"146":6.67520988,"145":7.579321},"304":{"151":8.52262551,"150":7.7423004,"149":7.71751029,"148":7.28647736,"147":6.85745679,"146":6.67668724,"145":6.64539505},"305":{"151":7.43841564,"150":6.78350618,"149":6.54452264,"148":6.02499177,"147":5.97187654,"146":6.25399178,"145":6.31482304},"306":{"151":7.02217696,"150":6.79929631,"149":6.5361358,"148":6.15761317,"147":5.8109753,"146":5.78639094,"145":5.96019342},"307":{"151":6.88595062,"150":6.57956379,"149":6.28759259,"148":6.10521399,"147":5.742,"146":5.59986419,"145":5.60494239},"308":{"151":6.60128394,"150":6.44045678,"149":6.31805761,"148":5.98681069,"147":5.87765433,"146":5.8241605,"145":6.04294239}}
{"227":{"123":33.67919922,"122":27.15999985,"121":18.02359962,"120":15.85680008,"119":21.7826004,"118":29.65049934,"117":35.02019882,"116":null},"228":{"123":35.70930099,"122":32.88050079,"121":23.68729973,"120":18.2154007,"119":22.02129936,"118":29.09670067,"117":32.76039886,"116":null},"229":{"123":39.69879913,"122":41.2317009,"121":38.81600189,"120":33.90269852,"119":33.26940155,"118":36.31880188,"117":37.2643013,"116":null},"230":{"123":35.40950012,"122":38.31470108,"121":42.80559921,"120":43.39730072,"119":43.49909973,"118":44.14640045,"117":43.52080154,"116":43.60079956},"231":{"123":22.0135994,"122":25.0177002,"121":34.45389938,"120":41.27479935,"119":43.99000168,"118":45.15650177,"117":45.00180054,"116":44.61380005},"232":{"123":23.43560028,"122":27.16819954,"121":35.63809967,"120":42.80799866,"119":45.73249817,"118":46.04449844,"117":45.66040039,"116":46.17060089},"233":{"123":36.67350006,"122":39.84420013,"121":43.77489853,"120":46.20019913,"119":47.64049911,"118":48.10680008,"117":47.97520065,"116":48.13299942},"234":{"123":40.99940109,"122":43.42160034,"121":45.03010178,"120":45.16460037,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
{"227":{"123":11.12215226,"122":8.08298354,"121":5.26635803,"120":5.19610699,"119":8.12508232,"118":10.80110287,"117":13.82580248,"116":null},"228":{"123":12.81278599,"122":10.21444856,"121":6.8615144,"120":5.20076544,"119":7.67644857,"118":11.43953909,"117":13.5005391,"116":null},"229":{"123":14.66449795,"122":15.67772017,"121":14.59848972,"120":11.81286833,"119":11.55220987,"118":12.93178188,"117":13.66028808,"116":null},"230":{"123":12.15044443,"122":12.46691359,"121":16.913214,"120":17.56187655,"119":16.69303703,"118":16.59077365,"117":16.00634568,"116":16.34393416},"231":{"123":6.54616872,"122":8.44169548,"121":11.88152265,"120":15.40177366,"119":17.15862963,"118":17.28211524,"117":16.63705763,"116":16.46888891},"232":{"123":6.74964198,"122":9.57396709,"121":14.83454732,"120":18.60737447,"119":19.51695473,"118":18.39506585,"117":17.41450205,"116":17.80263373},"233":{"123":14.55756789,"122":16.86533744,"121":19.78706994,"120":22.39945681,"119":23.46029217,"118":21.63009464,"117":19.64752264,"116":19.12956791},"234":{"123":17.96107818,"122":19.71168313,"121":19.93498765,"120":19.90183128,"119":null,"118":null,"117":null,"116":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "spring in end-century period", "time_frame2": "winter in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout spring in end-century period and winter in mid-century period?
0cded71a-d9f8-40a8-a16c-b7d003e5c4a6
As a wildfire management specialist assessing long-term trends, I'm curious to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn in the end-century timeframe as compared to summer in the historical period?
trend
tabular
null
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in historical period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":6.39099979,"152":4.56463003,"151":4.92604017,"150":6.75716019,"149":8.68068027,"148":6.26566982,"147":3.69476008,"146":3.86450005,"145":6.46878004,"144":9.78201962},"301":{"153":9.60758972,"152":7.68634987,"151":6.73406982,"150":7.3415699,"149":8.49773026,"148":9.09951019,"147":6.50549984,"146":6.43112993,"145":7.62520981,"144":6.66908979},"302":{"153":14.73050022,"152":15.71039963,"151":15.54669952,"150":12.62440014,"149":12.03590012,"148":13.00030041,"147":11.9321003,"146":11.01159954,"145":12.06830025,"144":10.64140034},"303":{"153":19.15679932,"152":20.7336998,"151":20.96139908,"150":18.85239983,"149":17.78680038,"148":18.00219917,"147":16.04570007,"146":14.39210033,"145":16.1548996,"144":16.32749939},"304":{"153":21.70420074,"152":22.07620049,"151":21.85000038,"150":21.12739944,"149":21.04109955,"148":20.03919983,"147":19.37660027,"146":18.84560013,"145":17.92810059,"144":16.13739967},"305":{"153":21.61739922,"152":21.26819992,"151":20.82159996,"150":20.54129982,"149":20.76160049,"148":19.59390068,"147":18.90780067,"146":19.49139977,"145":18.39789963,"144":15.89560032},"306":{"153":21.51210022,"152":21.10370064,"151":20.60709953,"150":20.36260033,"149":19.95229912,"148":19.67790031,"147":19.19849968,"146":18.36289978,"145":17.78140068,"144":16.5984993},"307":{"153":21.51720047,"152":20.97470093,"151":20.90390015,"150":20.36199951,"149":19.56970024,"148":18.9265995,"147":18.02630043,"146":16.97769928,"145":16.31450081,"144":15.34959984},"308":{"153":21.79590034,"152":21.32859993,"151":21.37299919,"150":20.79190063,"149":19.71610069,"148":18.8512001,"147":18.18180084,"146":17.25110054,"145":16.55389977,"144":15.64430046},"309":{"153":22.30410004,"152":21.80069923,"151":21.7303009,"150":21.21269989,"149":20.32729912,"148":19.47949982,"147":18.81780052,"146":18.11100006,"145":17.65909958,"144":17.27009964}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":50.92839813,"119":48.90570068,"118":49.61629868,"117":51.68880081,"116":51.35499954,"115":51.99219894},"226":{"124":48.25460052,"123":44.88809967,"122":40.02709961,"121":38.37170029,"120":42.0469017,"119":45.30139923,"118":45.69229889,"117":47.71179962,"116":50.77140045,"115":53.01139832},"227":{"124":44.74470139,"123":42.42490005,"122":33.18050003,"121":23.90690041,"120":25.36800003,"119":34.61349869,"118":43.13840103,"117":45.78580093,"116":49.2057991,"115":51.9618988},"228":{"124":46.44720078,"123":46.145401,"122":43.20009995,"121":29.0060997,"120":25.45199966,"119":32.73310089,"118":41.1155014,"117":42.90399933,"116":46.92070007,"115":49.57820129},"229":{"124":47.98799896,"123":50.08300018,"122":53.02320099,"121":50.09909821,"120":42.06140137,"119":42.57410049,"118":47.17259979,"117":47.770401,"116":50.38880157,"115":51.18099976},"230":{"124":46.10079956,"123":47.40219879,"122":52.10169983,"121":55.30210114,"120":53.0326004,"119":51.15539932,"118":52.11489868,"117":52.47869873,"116":53.53559875,"115":52.42750168},"231":{"124":32.01449966,"123":28.9552002,"122":34.9992981,"121":48.33850098,"120":54.18360138,"119":53.57500076,"118":53.10559845,"117":52.96089935,"116":52.97819901,"115":51.84600067},"232":{"124":32.16870117,"123":31.47069931,"122":37.57780075,"121":48.56119919,"120":55.70449829,"119":56.7602005,"118":55.78639984,"117":55.58739853,"116":55.91809845,"115":55.38779831},"233":{"124":47.79980087,"123":49.55419922,"122":52.83769989,"121":56.69639969,"120":59.45230103,"119":61.44710159,"118":62.60219955,"117":64.08339691,"116":65.54299927,"115":65.69219971},"234":{"124":51.79290009,"123":52.57709885,"122":55.11209869,"121":58.34000015,"120":60.13570023,"119":62.33409882,"118":66.02100372,"117":69.05069733,"116":70.13929749,"115":70.88549805},"235":{"124":52.67689896,"123":52.32249832,"122":54.24200058,"121":57.24459839,"120":58.80310059,"119":61.26319885,"118":65.58110046,"117":68.69650269,"116":69.69270325,"115":69.51370239}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in historical period?
6687d901-6ecd-40e1-a99f-f392580a5df2
As a wildfire management specialist assessing long-term trends, I'm curious to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn in the end-century timeframe as compared to summer in the historical period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1309/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in historical period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":6.39099979,"152":4.56463003,"151":4.92604017,"150":6.75716019,"149":8.68068027,"148":6.26566982,"147":3.69476008,"146":3.86450005,"145":6.46878004,"144":9.78201962},"301":{"153":9.60758972,"152":7.68634987,"151":6.73406982,"150":7.3415699,"149":8.49773026,"148":9.09951019,"147":6.50549984,"146":6.43112993,"145":7.62520981,"144":6.66908979},"302":{"153":14.73050022,"152":15.71039963,"151":15.54669952,"150":12.62440014,"149":12.03590012,"148":13.00030041,"147":11.9321003,"146":11.01159954,"145":12.06830025,"144":10.64140034},"303":{"153":19.15679932,"152":20.7336998,"151":20.96139908,"150":18.85239983,"149":17.78680038,"148":18.00219917,"147":16.04570007,"146":14.39210033,"145":16.1548996,"144":16.32749939},"304":{"153":21.70420074,"152":22.07620049,"151":21.85000038,"150":21.12739944,"149":21.04109955,"148":20.03919983,"147":19.37660027,"146":18.84560013,"145":17.92810059,"144":16.13739967},"305":{"153":21.61739922,"152":21.26819992,"151":20.82159996,"150":20.54129982,"149":20.76160049,"148":19.59390068,"147":18.90780067,"146":19.49139977,"145":18.39789963,"144":15.89560032},"306":{"153":21.51210022,"152":21.10370064,"151":20.60709953,"150":20.36260033,"149":19.95229912,"148":19.67790031,"147":19.19849968,"146":18.36289978,"145":17.78140068,"144":16.5984993},"307":{"153":21.51720047,"152":20.97470093,"151":20.90390015,"150":20.36199951,"149":19.56970024,"148":18.9265995,"147":18.02630043,"146":16.97769928,"145":16.31450081,"144":15.34959984},"308":{"153":21.79590034,"152":21.32859993,"151":21.37299919,"150":20.79190063,"149":19.71610069,"148":18.8512001,"147":18.18180084,"146":17.25110054,"145":16.55389977,"144":15.64430046},"309":{"153":22.30410004,"152":21.80069923,"151":21.7303009,"150":21.21269989,"149":20.32729912,"148":19.47949982,"147":18.81780052,"146":18.11100006,"145":17.65909958,"144":17.27009964}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":50.92839813,"119":48.90570068,"118":49.61629868,"117":51.68880081,"116":51.35499954,"115":51.99219894},"226":{"124":48.25460052,"123":44.88809967,"122":40.02709961,"121":38.37170029,"120":42.0469017,"119":45.30139923,"118":45.69229889,"117":47.71179962,"116":50.77140045,"115":53.01139832},"227":{"124":44.74470139,"123":42.42490005,"122":33.18050003,"121":23.90690041,"120":25.36800003,"119":34.61349869,"118":43.13840103,"117":45.78580093,"116":49.2057991,"115":51.9618988},"228":{"124":46.44720078,"123":46.145401,"122":43.20009995,"121":29.0060997,"120":25.45199966,"119":32.73310089,"118":41.1155014,"117":42.90399933,"116":46.92070007,"115":49.57820129},"229":{"124":47.98799896,"123":50.08300018,"122":53.02320099,"121":50.09909821,"120":42.06140137,"119":42.57410049,"118":47.17259979,"117":47.770401,"116":50.38880157,"115":51.18099976},"230":{"124":46.10079956,"123":47.40219879,"122":52.10169983,"121":55.30210114,"120":53.0326004,"119":51.15539932,"118":52.11489868,"117":52.47869873,"116":53.53559875,"115":52.42750168},"231":{"124":32.01449966,"123":28.9552002,"122":34.9992981,"121":48.33850098,"120":54.18360138,"119":53.57500076,"118":53.10559845,"117":52.96089935,"116":52.97819901,"115":51.84600067},"232":{"124":32.16870117,"123":31.47069931,"122":37.57780075,"121":48.56119919,"120":55.70449829,"119":56.7602005,"118":55.78639984,"117":55.58739853,"116":55.91809845,"115":55.38779831},"233":{"124":47.79980087,"123":49.55419922,"122":52.83769989,"121":56.69639969,"120":59.45230103,"119":61.44710159,"118":62.60219955,"117":64.08339691,"116":65.54299927,"115":65.69219971},"234":{"124":51.79290009,"123":52.57709885,"122":55.11209869,"121":58.34000015,"120":60.13570023,"119":62.33409882,"118":66.02100372,"117":69.05069733,"116":70.13929749,"115":70.88549805},"235":{"124":52.67689896,"123":52.32249832,"122":54.24200058,"121":57.24459839,"120":58.80310059,"119":61.26319885,"118":65.58110046,"117":68.69650269,"116":69.69270325,"115":69.51370239}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in historical period?
afcf9857-5470-4e60-abae-d862f2281a56
As a wildfire management specialist assessing long-term trends, I'm curious to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn in the end-century timeframe as compared to summer in the historical period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1309/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in historical period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":6.39099979,"152":4.56463003,"151":4.92604017,"150":6.75716019,"149":8.68068027,"148":6.26566982,"147":3.69476008,"146":3.86450005,"145":6.46878004,"144":9.78201962},"301":{"153":9.60758972,"152":7.68634987,"151":6.73406982,"150":7.3415699,"149":8.49773026,"148":9.09951019,"147":6.50549984,"146":6.43112993,"145":7.62520981,"144":6.66908979},"302":{"153":14.73050022,"152":15.71039963,"151":15.54669952,"150":12.62440014,"149":12.03590012,"148":13.00030041,"147":11.9321003,"146":11.01159954,"145":12.06830025,"144":10.64140034},"303":{"153":19.15679932,"152":20.7336998,"151":20.96139908,"150":18.85239983,"149":17.78680038,"148":18.00219917,"147":16.04570007,"146":14.39210033,"145":16.1548996,"144":16.32749939},"304":{"153":21.70420074,"152":22.07620049,"151":21.85000038,"150":21.12739944,"149":21.04109955,"148":20.03919983,"147":19.37660027,"146":18.84560013,"145":17.92810059,"144":16.13739967},"305":{"153":21.61739922,"152":21.26819992,"151":20.82159996,"150":20.54129982,"149":20.76160049,"148":19.59390068,"147":18.90780067,"146":19.49139977,"145":18.39789963,"144":15.89560032},"306":{"153":21.51210022,"152":21.10370064,"151":20.60709953,"150":20.36260033,"149":19.95229912,"148":19.67790031,"147":19.19849968,"146":18.36289978,"145":17.78140068,"144":16.5984993},"307":{"153":21.51720047,"152":20.97470093,"151":20.90390015,"150":20.36199951,"149":19.56970024,"148":18.9265995,"147":18.02630043,"146":16.97769928,"145":16.31450081,"144":15.34959984},"308":{"153":21.79590034,"152":21.32859993,"151":21.37299919,"150":20.79190063,"149":19.71610069,"148":18.8512001,"147":18.18180084,"146":17.25110054,"145":16.55389977,"144":15.64430046},"309":{"153":22.30410004,"152":21.80069923,"151":21.7303009,"150":21.21269989,"149":20.32729912,"148":19.47949982,"147":18.81780052,"146":18.11100006,"145":17.65909958,"144":17.27009964}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":50.92839813,"119":48.90570068,"118":49.61629868,"117":51.68880081,"116":51.35499954,"115":51.99219894},"226":{"124":48.25460052,"123":44.88809967,"122":40.02709961,"121":38.37170029,"120":42.0469017,"119":45.30139923,"118":45.69229889,"117":47.71179962,"116":50.77140045,"115":53.01139832},"227":{"124":44.74470139,"123":42.42490005,"122":33.18050003,"121":23.90690041,"120":25.36800003,"119":34.61349869,"118":43.13840103,"117":45.78580093,"116":49.2057991,"115":51.9618988},"228":{"124":46.44720078,"123":46.145401,"122":43.20009995,"121":29.0060997,"120":25.45199966,"119":32.73310089,"118":41.1155014,"117":42.90399933,"116":46.92070007,"115":49.57820129},"229":{"124":47.98799896,"123":50.08300018,"122":53.02320099,"121":50.09909821,"120":42.06140137,"119":42.57410049,"118":47.17259979,"117":47.770401,"116":50.38880157,"115":51.18099976},"230":{"124":46.10079956,"123":47.40219879,"122":52.10169983,"121":55.30210114,"120":53.0326004,"119":51.15539932,"118":52.11489868,"117":52.47869873,"116":53.53559875,"115":52.42750168},"231":{"124":32.01449966,"123":28.9552002,"122":34.9992981,"121":48.33850098,"120":54.18360138,"119":53.57500076,"118":53.10559845,"117":52.96089935,"116":52.97819901,"115":51.84600067},"232":{"124":32.16870117,"123":31.47069931,"122":37.57780075,"121":48.56119919,"120":55.70449829,"119":56.7602005,"118":55.78639984,"117":55.58739853,"116":55.91809845,"115":55.38779831},"233":{"124":47.79980087,"123":49.55419922,"122":52.83769989,"121":56.69639969,"120":59.45230103,"119":61.44710159,"118":62.60219955,"117":64.08339691,"116":65.54299927,"115":65.69219971},"234":{"124":51.79290009,"123":52.57709885,"122":55.11209869,"121":58.34000015,"120":60.13570023,"119":62.33409882,"118":66.02100372,"117":69.05069733,"116":70.13929749,"115":70.88549805},"235":{"124":52.67689896,"123":52.32249832,"122":54.24200058,"121":57.24459839,"120":58.80310059,"119":61.26319885,"118":65.58110046,"117":68.69650269,"116":69.69270325,"115":69.51370239}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in historical period?
24483ab3-98cc-4d3e-ba26-f320384f1a45
As a wildfire management specialist assessing long-term trends, I'm curious to know which city, Denver, CO, or Las Vegas, NV, has shown a greater variation in fire weather index during autumn in the end-century timeframe as compared to summer in the historical period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1309/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(c)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Denver, CO, United States and Las Vegas, NV, United States.', '(c) Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change than Denver, CO, United States.', '(d) The Denver, CO, United States experienced a greater change than Las Vegas, NV, United States.']
['Denver, CO, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Denver, CO, United States in summer in historical period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in autumn in end-century period', 'Las Vegas, NV, United States in summer in historical period']
{"300":{"153":11.20899963,"152":7.6873498,"151":7.50427008,"150":10.0532999,"149":13.97259998,"148":11.54409981,"147":7.85391998,"146":7.71452999,"145":11.94120026,"144":15.84249973},"301":{"153":21.42410088,"152":18.12509918,"151":15.02449989,"150":15.58129978,"149":17.3477993,"148":18.06739998,"147":14.02470016,"146":13.76490021,"145":15.5394001,"144":13.89840031},"302":{"153":28.45140076,"152":28.86590004,"151":26.35029984,"150":22.46240044,"149":22.58499908,"148":22.72540092,"147":19.86730003,"146":19.30669975,"145":21.32279968,"144":20.09259987},"303":{"153":27.62170029,"152":28.31550026,"151":27.99279976,"150":25.73460007,"149":25.74090004,"148":25.54920006,"147":22.74410057,"146":21.72730064,"145":24.1942997,"144":25.16819954},"304":{"153":26.03359985,"152":26.45940018,"151":26.67270088,"150":26.22730064,"149":26.06979942,"148":25.07130051,"147":24.63339996,"146":24.84679985,"145":24.80430031,"144":24.13759995},"305":{"153":25.93499947,"152":25.75499916,"151":25.67009926,"150":25.27729988,"149":25.09230042,"148":24.06110001,"147":24.12549973,"146":25.63100052,"145":25.03520012,"144":23.85070038},"306":{"153":25.76849937,"152":25.30760002,"151":25.06620026,"150":24.97130013,"149":24.87520027,"148":24.73760033,"147":24.89909935,"146":24.96579933,"145":24.83889961,"144":24.40620041},"307":{"153":25.39909935,"152":25.01810074,"151":25.16189957,"150":24.97069931,"149":24.73530006,"148":24.64380074,"147":24.53289986,"146":24.32329941,"145":24.01589966,"144":24.21439934},"308":{"153":25.10000038,"152":24.91880035,"151":25.36599922,"150":25.13929939,"149":25.14259911,"148":24.90819931,"147":24.92140007,"146":24.81809998,"145":25.18670082,"144":25.04120064},"309":{"153":24.98940086,"152":24.97750092,"151":25.45700073,"150":25.65439987,"149":25.95089912,"148":25.82699966,"147":25.73279953,"146":25.76029968,"145":26.55459976,"144":26.53879929}}
{"300":{"153":6.39099979,"152":4.56463003,"151":4.92604017,"150":6.75716019,"149":8.68068027,"148":6.26566982,"147":3.69476008,"146":3.86450005,"145":6.46878004,"144":9.78201962},"301":{"153":9.60758972,"152":7.68634987,"151":6.73406982,"150":7.3415699,"149":8.49773026,"148":9.09951019,"147":6.50549984,"146":6.43112993,"145":7.62520981,"144":6.66908979},"302":{"153":14.73050022,"152":15.71039963,"151":15.54669952,"150":12.62440014,"149":12.03590012,"148":13.00030041,"147":11.9321003,"146":11.01159954,"145":12.06830025,"144":10.64140034},"303":{"153":19.15679932,"152":20.7336998,"151":20.96139908,"150":18.85239983,"149":17.78680038,"148":18.00219917,"147":16.04570007,"146":14.39210033,"145":16.1548996,"144":16.32749939},"304":{"153":21.70420074,"152":22.07620049,"151":21.85000038,"150":21.12739944,"149":21.04109955,"148":20.03919983,"147":19.37660027,"146":18.84560013,"145":17.92810059,"144":16.13739967},"305":{"153":21.61739922,"152":21.26819992,"151":20.82159996,"150":20.54129982,"149":20.76160049,"148":19.59390068,"147":18.90780067,"146":19.49139977,"145":18.39789963,"144":15.89560032},"306":{"153":21.51210022,"152":21.10370064,"151":20.60709953,"150":20.36260033,"149":19.95229912,"148":19.67790031,"147":19.19849968,"146":18.36289978,"145":17.78140068,"144":16.5984993},"307":{"153":21.51720047,"152":20.97470093,"151":20.90390015,"150":20.36199951,"149":19.56970024,"148":18.9265995,"147":18.02630043,"146":16.97769928,"145":16.31450081,"144":15.34959984},"308":{"153":21.79590034,"152":21.32859993,"151":21.37299919,"150":20.79190063,"149":19.71610069,"148":18.8512001,"147":18.18180084,"146":17.25110054,"145":16.55389977,"144":15.64430046},"309":{"153":22.30410004,"152":21.80069923,"151":21.7303009,"150":21.21269989,"149":20.32729912,"148":19.47949982,"147":18.81780052,"146":18.11100006,"145":17.65909958,"144":17.27009964}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":43.35029984,"119":40.7378006,"118":39.6772995,"117":41.05059814,"116":41.07210159,"115":42.70999908},"226":{"124":41.24629974,"123":39.16469955,"122":34.53469849,"121":31.89410019,"120":33.63610077,"119":36.17990112,"118":37.81990051,"117":40.35820007,"116":43.7682991,"115":45.27399826},"227":{"124":39.19800186,"123":34.90679932,"122":28.41189957,"121":21.01210022,"120":20.01659966,"119":26.16679955,"118":34.43610001,"117":39.49380112,"116":44.00699997,"115":45.62820053},"228":{"124":41.41249847,"123":36.85820007,"122":32.49919891,"121":25.16160011,"120":22.28429985,"119":26.38159943,"118":34.10800171,"117":37.41939926,"116":42.73740005,"115":44.48749924},"229":{"124":42.57649994,"123":41.49459839,"122":43.34220123,"121":40.8995018,"120":35.14459991,"119":34.9557991,"118":38.03639984,"117":39.37969971,"116":43.19950104,"115":45.44630051},"230":{"124":37.73419952,"123":37.80049896,"122":40.77719879,"121":44.21509933,"120":42.7961998,"119":41.00579834,"118":41.21659851,"117":41.96609879,"116":43.35630035,"115":43.92689896},"231":{"124":26.99609947,"123":23.70079994,"122":26.3166008,"121":35.44950104,"120":40.28179932,"119":41.30270004,"118":41.62060165,"117":41.45750046,"116":41.70140076,"115":41.5265007},"232":{"124":24.35090065,"123":24.68759918,"122":30.05940056,"121":38.66469955,"120":44.55920029,"119":45.35309982,"118":43.70899963,"117":43.14429855,"116":43.48839951,"115":42.95890045},"233":{"124":36.17340088,"123":39.66279984,"122":43.21300125,"121":47.18199921,"120":50.21300125,"119":50.35400009,"118":47.99430084,"117":46.15230179,"116":46.58800125,"115":47.4715004},"234":{"124":38.78900146,"123":41.79109955,"122":44.48270035,"121":46.37739944,"120":47.41450119,"119":48.26959991,"118":48.53929901,"117":48.13729858,"116":48.52220154,"115":50.16109848},"235":{"124":39.06269836,"123":38.65309906,"122":39.98920059,"121":41.6841011,"120":43.68270111,"119":45.98180008,"118":47.33720016,"117":47.63199997,"116":48.48020172,"115":48.91899872}}
{"225":{"124":null,"123":null,"122":null,"121":null,"120":50.92839813,"119":48.90570068,"118":49.61629868,"117":51.68880081,"116":51.35499954,"115":51.99219894},"226":{"124":48.25460052,"123":44.88809967,"122":40.02709961,"121":38.37170029,"120":42.0469017,"119":45.30139923,"118":45.69229889,"117":47.71179962,"116":50.77140045,"115":53.01139832},"227":{"124":44.74470139,"123":42.42490005,"122":33.18050003,"121":23.90690041,"120":25.36800003,"119":34.61349869,"118":43.13840103,"117":45.78580093,"116":49.2057991,"115":51.9618988},"228":{"124":46.44720078,"123":46.145401,"122":43.20009995,"121":29.0060997,"120":25.45199966,"119":32.73310089,"118":41.1155014,"117":42.90399933,"116":46.92070007,"115":49.57820129},"229":{"124":47.98799896,"123":50.08300018,"122":53.02320099,"121":50.09909821,"120":42.06140137,"119":42.57410049,"118":47.17259979,"117":47.770401,"116":50.38880157,"115":51.18099976},"230":{"124":46.10079956,"123":47.40219879,"122":52.10169983,"121":55.30210114,"120":53.0326004,"119":51.15539932,"118":52.11489868,"117":52.47869873,"116":53.53559875,"115":52.42750168},"231":{"124":32.01449966,"123":28.9552002,"122":34.9992981,"121":48.33850098,"120":54.18360138,"119":53.57500076,"118":53.10559845,"117":52.96089935,"116":52.97819901,"115":51.84600067},"232":{"124":32.16870117,"123":31.47069931,"122":37.57780075,"121":48.56119919,"120":55.70449829,"119":56.7602005,"118":55.78639984,"117":55.58739853,"116":55.91809845,"115":55.38779831},"233":{"124":47.79980087,"123":49.55419922,"122":52.83769989,"121":56.69639969,"120":59.45230103,"119":61.44710159,"118":62.60219955,"117":64.08339691,"116":65.54299927,"115":65.69219971},"234":{"124":51.79290009,"123":52.57709885,"122":55.11209869,"121":58.34000015,"120":60.13570023,"119":62.33409882,"118":66.02100372,"117":69.05069733,"116":70.13929749,"115":70.88549805},"235":{"124":52.67689896,"123":52.32249832,"122":54.24200058,"121":57.24459839,"120":58.80310059,"119":61.26319885,"118":65.58110046,"117":68.69650269,"116":69.69270325,"115":69.51370239}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Denver, CO, United States", "location2": "Las Vegas, NV, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in end-century period", "time_frame2": "summer in historical period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Denver, CO, United States or Las Vegas, NV, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in end-century period and summer in historical period?
81000e0f-5f55-4363-984c-082f1615ee15
As a meteorologist analyzing historical weather patterns for a report on urban heat effects, I'm interested in knowing which city, Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN, has seen a more significant increase in maximum seasonal heat index values during the summer months from historical data compared to mid-century readings?
trend
tabular
null
72
(a)
['(a) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"429":{"84":92.14192454,"83":92.05987803,"82":92.06394958,"81":92.32434082,"80":92.67441559,"79":93.01020559},"430":{"84":92.39171855,"83":92.29085795,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"84":92.42006938,"83":92.34653219,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"84":92.48581696,"83":92.50338999,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"84":92.79271698,"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"84":92.87924703,"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"84":92.48769379,"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"84":92.21564738,"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"84":92.17764537,"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913},"438":{"84":92.19515991,"83":92.16807556,"82":92.2482605,"81":92.40957642,"80":93.69782003,"79":94.16790009}}
{"429":{"84":100.42250824,"83":100.37963104,"82":100.45109558,"81":100.92184703,"80":101.5293808,"79":102.1977183},"430":{"84":100.7524058,"83":100.66541036,"82":100.64149984,"81":101.10594177,"80":101.66028849,"79":102.23142497},"431":{"84":100.81513977,"83":100.83908844,"82":100.94776154,"81":101.37170156,"80":101.78816477,"79":102.1593221},"432":{"84":101.01771545,"83":101.09857686,"82":101.32772064,"81":101.60890961,"80":101.95115662,"79":102.31183879},"433":{"84":101.50879669,"83":101.66415405,"82":101.74482981,"81":101.83610535,"80":102.19342295,"79":102.7506307},"434":{"84":101.64686076,"83":101.96948242,"82":102.02252452,"81":102.03278351,"80":102.3775355,"79":106.08330536},"435":{"84":101.17797089,"83":101.81832886,"82":102.34303029,"81":102.28585307,"80":102.70741781,"79":103.12684377},"436":{"84":100.84534709,"83":101.54206848,"82":102.30781809,"81":102.73699951,"80":103.11621348,"79":106.53950246},"437":{"84":100.86519623,"83":101.29006958,"82":101.94161733,"81":102.71864319,"80":103.1269633,"79":106.82963562},"438":{"84":100.87158457,"83":101.02611542,"82":101.38749186,"81":102.13349406,"80":106.07598623,"79":106.67299906}}
{"429":{"171":81.94441477,"170":81.82267507,"169":81.87039693,"168":81.87644196,"167":81.915212,"166":82.17000834,"165":82.63931274,"164":83.00992584,"163":83.31676737,"162":null},"430":{"171":81.51963806,"170":81.52394104,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":82.79416911,"163":83.18263753,"162":83.63732656},"431":{"171":81.27445984,"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464,"163":83.37394714,"162":83.65568797},"432":{"171":81.30040741,"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847,"163":83.48255157,"162":83.4817098},"433":{"171":81.56648254,"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966,"163":83.20517222,"162":83.28211975},"434":{"171":81.65947978,"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213,"163":82.89800517,"162":83.09157562},"435":{"171":81.50264231,"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619,"163":83.16178385,"162":null},"436":{"171":81.18163554,"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796,"163":83.46927134,"162":null},"437":{"171":80.74187469,"170":80.68540955,"169":80.8221995,"168":81.2023112,"167":81.59555308,"166":81.96758016,"165":82.33428701,"164":82.74884796,"163":83.23331451,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":80.81280263,"167":81.16618093,"166":81.50134532,"165":81.82526143,"164":82.20085398,"163":82.67316945,"162":null}}
{"429":{"171":87.31295522,"170":87.20752716,"169":87.24928284,"168":87.21202596,"167":87.31300863,"166":87.6888682,"165":88.26953634,"164":88.77185822,"163":89.04013824,"162":null},"430":{"171":86.80780284,"170":86.81738027,"169":86.77797445,"168":86.72226969,"167":86.94758097,"166":87.43943024,"165":88.08621724,"164":88.56729126,"163":89.03269958,"162":89.40670268},"431":{"171":86.51890055,"170":86.56462351,"169":86.62617493,"168":86.76410929,"167":87.14155833,"166":87.68671672,"165":88.26065572,"164":88.75571442,"163":89.14042918,"162":89.49257406},"432":{"171":86.54847717,"170":86.60865784,"169":86.80991618,"168":87.25551097,"167":87.83054606,"166":88.29964193,"165":88.78022512,"164":89.00658162,"163":89.27619171,"162":89.28326925},"433":{"171":86.87089284,"170":87.02443186,"169":87.32195282,"168":88.20524597,"167":88.63594564,"166":88.94934845,"165":88.78857931,"164":88.91176605,"163":88.88594055,"162":89.04221853},"434":{"171":86.91846975,"170":87.17388407,"169":87.48436737,"168":88.20765177,"167":88.38693492,"166":88.21294657,"165":88.45011902,"164":88.56740824,"163":88.52152252,"162":88.8375473},"435":{"171":86.72666931,"170":86.88824209,"169":87.0997289,"168":87.3543752,"167":87.71672058,"166":88.15355174,"165":88.58790334,"164":88.84000142,"163":88.84495036,"162":null},"436":{"171":86.35605113,"170":86.40647634,"169":86.51208242,"168":86.85261027,"167":87.37110647,"166":87.94256846,"165":88.47804769,"164":88.9029007,"163":89.32699076,"162":null},"437":{"171":85.85506694,"170":85.81829325,"169":85.94577789,"168":86.37988536,"167":86.89028168,"166":87.40656789,"165":87.9219869,"164":88.42491659,"163":89.0151062,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":85.94525909,"167":86.42741394,"166":86.86425273,"165":87.28136953,"164":87.73954519,"163":88.37074788,"162":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
9323249a-65b0-49c4-857f-f0286c4f0c5e
As a meteorologist analyzing historical weather patterns for a report on urban heat effects, I'm interested in knowing which city, Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN, has seen a more significant increase in maximum seasonal heat index values during the summer months from historical data compared to mid-century readings?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1347/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"429":{"84":92.14192454,"83":92.05987803,"82":92.06394958,"81":92.32434082,"80":92.67441559,"79":93.01020559},"430":{"84":92.39171855,"83":92.29085795,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"84":92.42006938,"83":92.34653219,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"84":92.48581696,"83":92.50338999,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"84":92.79271698,"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"84":92.87924703,"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"84":92.48769379,"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"84":92.21564738,"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"84":92.17764537,"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913},"438":{"84":92.19515991,"83":92.16807556,"82":92.2482605,"81":92.40957642,"80":93.69782003,"79":94.16790009}}
{"429":{"84":100.42250824,"83":100.37963104,"82":100.45109558,"81":100.92184703,"80":101.5293808,"79":102.1977183},"430":{"84":100.7524058,"83":100.66541036,"82":100.64149984,"81":101.10594177,"80":101.66028849,"79":102.23142497},"431":{"84":100.81513977,"83":100.83908844,"82":100.94776154,"81":101.37170156,"80":101.78816477,"79":102.1593221},"432":{"84":101.01771545,"83":101.09857686,"82":101.32772064,"81":101.60890961,"80":101.95115662,"79":102.31183879},"433":{"84":101.50879669,"83":101.66415405,"82":101.74482981,"81":101.83610535,"80":102.19342295,"79":102.7506307},"434":{"84":101.64686076,"83":101.96948242,"82":102.02252452,"81":102.03278351,"80":102.3775355,"79":106.08330536},"435":{"84":101.17797089,"83":101.81832886,"82":102.34303029,"81":102.28585307,"80":102.70741781,"79":103.12684377},"436":{"84":100.84534709,"83":101.54206848,"82":102.30781809,"81":102.73699951,"80":103.11621348,"79":106.53950246},"437":{"84":100.86519623,"83":101.29006958,"82":101.94161733,"81":102.71864319,"80":103.1269633,"79":106.82963562},"438":{"84":100.87158457,"83":101.02611542,"82":101.38749186,"81":102.13349406,"80":106.07598623,"79":106.67299906}}
{"429":{"171":81.94441477,"170":81.82267507,"169":81.87039693,"168":81.87644196,"167":81.915212,"166":82.17000834,"165":82.63931274,"164":83.00992584,"163":83.31676737,"162":null},"430":{"171":81.51963806,"170":81.52394104,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":82.79416911,"163":83.18263753,"162":83.63732656},"431":{"171":81.27445984,"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464,"163":83.37394714,"162":83.65568797},"432":{"171":81.30040741,"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847,"163":83.48255157,"162":83.4817098},"433":{"171":81.56648254,"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966,"163":83.20517222,"162":83.28211975},"434":{"171":81.65947978,"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213,"163":82.89800517,"162":83.09157562},"435":{"171":81.50264231,"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619,"163":83.16178385,"162":null},"436":{"171":81.18163554,"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796,"163":83.46927134,"162":null},"437":{"171":80.74187469,"170":80.68540955,"169":80.8221995,"168":81.2023112,"167":81.59555308,"166":81.96758016,"165":82.33428701,"164":82.74884796,"163":83.23331451,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":80.81280263,"167":81.16618093,"166":81.50134532,"165":81.82526143,"164":82.20085398,"163":82.67316945,"162":null}}
{"429":{"171":87.31295522,"170":87.20752716,"169":87.24928284,"168":87.21202596,"167":87.31300863,"166":87.6888682,"165":88.26953634,"164":88.77185822,"163":89.04013824,"162":null},"430":{"171":86.80780284,"170":86.81738027,"169":86.77797445,"168":86.72226969,"167":86.94758097,"166":87.43943024,"165":88.08621724,"164":88.56729126,"163":89.03269958,"162":89.40670268},"431":{"171":86.51890055,"170":86.56462351,"169":86.62617493,"168":86.76410929,"167":87.14155833,"166":87.68671672,"165":88.26065572,"164":88.75571442,"163":89.14042918,"162":89.49257406},"432":{"171":86.54847717,"170":86.60865784,"169":86.80991618,"168":87.25551097,"167":87.83054606,"166":88.29964193,"165":88.78022512,"164":89.00658162,"163":89.27619171,"162":89.28326925},"433":{"171":86.87089284,"170":87.02443186,"169":87.32195282,"168":88.20524597,"167":88.63594564,"166":88.94934845,"165":88.78857931,"164":88.91176605,"163":88.88594055,"162":89.04221853},"434":{"171":86.91846975,"170":87.17388407,"169":87.48436737,"168":88.20765177,"167":88.38693492,"166":88.21294657,"165":88.45011902,"164":88.56740824,"163":88.52152252,"162":88.8375473},"435":{"171":86.72666931,"170":86.88824209,"169":87.0997289,"168":87.3543752,"167":87.71672058,"166":88.15355174,"165":88.58790334,"164":88.84000142,"163":88.84495036,"162":null},"436":{"171":86.35605113,"170":86.40647634,"169":86.51208242,"168":86.85261027,"167":87.37110647,"166":87.94256846,"165":88.47804769,"164":88.9029007,"163":89.32699076,"162":null},"437":{"171":85.85506694,"170":85.81829325,"169":85.94577789,"168":86.37988536,"167":86.89028168,"166":87.40656789,"165":87.9219869,"164":88.42491659,"163":89.0151062,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":85.94525909,"167":86.42741394,"166":86.86425273,"165":87.28136953,"164":87.73954519,"163":88.37074788,"162":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
f2cf6a52-0421-428c-8f54-7183f5c95870
As a meteorologist analyzing historical weather patterns for a report on urban heat effects, I'm interested in knowing which city, Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN, has seen a more significant increase in maximum seasonal heat index values during the summer months from historical data compared to mid-century readings?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1347/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"429":{"84":92.14192454,"83":92.05987803,"82":92.06394958,"81":92.32434082,"80":92.67441559,"79":93.01020559},"430":{"84":92.39171855,"83":92.29085795,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"84":92.42006938,"83":92.34653219,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"84":92.48581696,"83":92.50338999,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"84":92.79271698,"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"84":92.87924703,"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"84":92.48769379,"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"84":92.21564738,"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"84":92.17764537,"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913},"438":{"84":92.19515991,"83":92.16807556,"82":92.2482605,"81":92.40957642,"80":93.69782003,"79":94.16790009}}
{"429":{"84":100.42250824,"83":100.37963104,"82":100.45109558,"81":100.92184703,"80":101.5293808,"79":102.1977183},"430":{"84":100.7524058,"83":100.66541036,"82":100.64149984,"81":101.10594177,"80":101.66028849,"79":102.23142497},"431":{"84":100.81513977,"83":100.83908844,"82":100.94776154,"81":101.37170156,"80":101.78816477,"79":102.1593221},"432":{"84":101.01771545,"83":101.09857686,"82":101.32772064,"81":101.60890961,"80":101.95115662,"79":102.31183879},"433":{"84":101.50879669,"83":101.66415405,"82":101.74482981,"81":101.83610535,"80":102.19342295,"79":102.7506307},"434":{"84":101.64686076,"83":101.96948242,"82":102.02252452,"81":102.03278351,"80":102.3775355,"79":106.08330536},"435":{"84":101.17797089,"83":101.81832886,"82":102.34303029,"81":102.28585307,"80":102.70741781,"79":103.12684377},"436":{"84":100.84534709,"83":101.54206848,"82":102.30781809,"81":102.73699951,"80":103.11621348,"79":106.53950246},"437":{"84":100.86519623,"83":101.29006958,"82":101.94161733,"81":102.71864319,"80":103.1269633,"79":106.82963562},"438":{"84":100.87158457,"83":101.02611542,"82":101.38749186,"81":102.13349406,"80":106.07598623,"79":106.67299906}}
{"429":{"171":81.94441477,"170":81.82267507,"169":81.87039693,"168":81.87644196,"167":81.915212,"166":82.17000834,"165":82.63931274,"164":83.00992584,"163":83.31676737,"162":null},"430":{"171":81.51963806,"170":81.52394104,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":82.79416911,"163":83.18263753,"162":83.63732656},"431":{"171":81.27445984,"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464,"163":83.37394714,"162":83.65568797},"432":{"171":81.30040741,"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847,"163":83.48255157,"162":83.4817098},"433":{"171":81.56648254,"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966,"163":83.20517222,"162":83.28211975},"434":{"171":81.65947978,"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213,"163":82.89800517,"162":83.09157562},"435":{"171":81.50264231,"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619,"163":83.16178385,"162":null},"436":{"171":81.18163554,"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796,"163":83.46927134,"162":null},"437":{"171":80.74187469,"170":80.68540955,"169":80.8221995,"168":81.2023112,"167":81.59555308,"166":81.96758016,"165":82.33428701,"164":82.74884796,"163":83.23331451,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":80.81280263,"167":81.16618093,"166":81.50134532,"165":81.82526143,"164":82.20085398,"163":82.67316945,"162":null}}
{"429":{"171":87.31295522,"170":87.20752716,"169":87.24928284,"168":87.21202596,"167":87.31300863,"166":87.6888682,"165":88.26953634,"164":88.77185822,"163":89.04013824,"162":null},"430":{"171":86.80780284,"170":86.81738027,"169":86.77797445,"168":86.72226969,"167":86.94758097,"166":87.43943024,"165":88.08621724,"164":88.56729126,"163":89.03269958,"162":89.40670268},"431":{"171":86.51890055,"170":86.56462351,"169":86.62617493,"168":86.76410929,"167":87.14155833,"166":87.68671672,"165":88.26065572,"164":88.75571442,"163":89.14042918,"162":89.49257406},"432":{"171":86.54847717,"170":86.60865784,"169":86.80991618,"168":87.25551097,"167":87.83054606,"166":88.29964193,"165":88.78022512,"164":89.00658162,"163":89.27619171,"162":89.28326925},"433":{"171":86.87089284,"170":87.02443186,"169":87.32195282,"168":88.20524597,"167":88.63594564,"166":88.94934845,"165":88.78857931,"164":88.91176605,"163":88.88594055,"162":89.04221853},"434":{"171":86.91846975,"170":87.17388407,"169":87.48436737,"168":88.20765177,"167":88.38693492,"166":88.21294657,"165":88.45011902,"164":88.56740824,"163":88.52152252,"162":88.8375473},"435":{"171":86.72666931,"170":86.88824209,"169":87.0997289,"168":87.3543752,"167":87.71672058,"166":88.15355174,"165":88.58790334,"164":88.84000142,"163":88.84495036,"162":null},"436":{"171":86.35605113,"170":86.40647634,"169":86.51208242,"168":86.85261027,"167":87.37110647,"166":87.94256846,"165":88.47804769,"164":88.9029007,"163":89.32699076,"162":null},"437":{"171":85.85506694,"170":85.81829325,"169":85.94577789,"168":86.37988536,"167":86.89028168,"166":87.40656789,"165":87.9219869,"164":88.42491659,"163":89.0151062,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":85.94525909,"167":86.42741394,"166":86.86425273,"165":87.28136953,"164":87.73954519,"163":88.37074788,"162":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
cfe2559a-8055-4341-ba8c-9d14f564a3a5
As a meteorologist analyzing historical weather patterns for a report on urban heat effects, I'm interested in knowing which city, Biloxi, MS, or Indianapolis, IN, has seen a more significant increase in maximum seasonal heat index values during the summer months from historical data compared to mid-century readings?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1347/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(a)
['(a) Biloxi, MS, United States experienced a greater change than Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(b) There was no significant difference in the changes between Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States.', '(c) The Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change than Biloxi, MS, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Biloxi, MS, United States and Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in historical period', 'Biloxi, MS, United States in summer in mid-century period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in historical period', 'Indianapolis, IN, United States in summer in mid-century period']
{"429":{"84":92.14192454,"83":92.05987803,"82":92.06394958,"81":92.32434082,"80":92.67441559,"79":93.01020559},"430":{"84":92.39171855,"83":92.29085795,"82":92.17914327,"81":92.4080658,"80":92.70253754,"79":92.95211538},"431":{"84":92.42006938,"83":92.34653219,"82":92.35336558,"81":92.56386566,"80":92.71323649,"79":92.81539408},"432":{"84":92.48581696,"83":92.50338999,"82":92.58362579,"81":92.6627655,"80":92.7898229,"79":92.86212921},"433":{"84":92.79271698,"83":92.81942495,"82":92.7826004,"81":92.75668844,"80":92.82648214,"79":92.86304474},"434":{"84":92.87924703,"83":92.99310048,"82":92.91366069,"81":92.76831818,"80":92.71583049,"79":93.82606506},"435":{"84":92.48769379,"83":92.81986491,"82":93.02088928,"81":92.87573242,"80":92.76906586,"79":92.59712728},"436":{"84":92.21564738,"83":92.54802958,"82":92.90224965,"81":92.96840668,"80":92.86545308,"79":94.06881714},"437":{"84":92.17764537,"83":92.35964966,"82":92.67107391,"81":92.86092122,"80":92.81175486,"79":94.26866913},"438":{"84":92.19515991,"83":92.16807556,"82":92.2482605,"81":92.40957642,"80":93.69782003,"79":94.16790009}}
{"429":{"84":100.42250824,"83":100.37963104,"82":100.45109558,"81":100.92184703,"80":101.5293808,"79":102.1977183},"430":{"84":100.7524058,"83":100.66541036,"82":100.64149984,"81":101.10594177,"80":101.66028849,"79":102.23142497},"431":{"84":100.81513977,"83":100.83908844,"82":100.94776154,"81":101.37170156,"80":101.78816477,"79":102.1593221},"432":{"84":101.01771545,"83":101.09857686,"82":101.32772064,"81":101.60890961,"80":101.95115662,"79":102.31183879},"433":{"84":101.50879669,"83":101.66415405,"82":101.74482981,"81":101.83610535,"80":102.19342295,"79":102.7506307},"434":{"84":101.64686076,"83":101.96948242,"82":102.02252452,"81":102.03278351,"80":102.3775355,"79":106.08330536},"435":{"84":101.17797089,"83":101.81832886,"82":102.34303029,"81":102.28585307,"80":102.70741781,"79":103.12684377},"436":{"84":100.84534709,"83":101.54206848,"82":102.30781809,"81":102.73699951,"80":103.11621348,"79":106.53950246},"437":{"84":100.86519623,"83":101.29006958,"82":101.94161733,"81":102.71864319,"80":103.1269633,"79":106.82963562},"438":{"84":100.87158457,"83":101.02611542,"82":101.38749186,"81":102.13349406,"80":106.07598623,"79":106.67299906}}
{"429":{"171":81.94441477,"170":81.82267507,"169":81.87039693,"168":81.87644196,"167":81.915212,"166":82.17000834,"165":82.63931274,"164":83.00992584,"163":83.31676737,"162":null},"430":{"171":81.51963806,"170":81.52394104,"169":81.52676392,"168":81.51202138,"167":81.62566884,"166":81.98667399,"165":82.44991557,"164":82.79416911,"163":83.18263753,"162":83.63732656},"431":{"171":81.27445984,"170":81.31806437,"169":81.40977224,"168":81.54559326,"167":81.79284922,"166":82.20256805,"165":82.62993368,"164":82.95531464,"163":83.37394714,"162":83.65568797},"432":{"171":81.30040741,"170":81.39892324,"169":81.58682251,"168":81.98931376,"167":82.4214325,"166":82.76166789,"165":83.12776438,"164":83.30621847,"163":83.48255157,"162":83.4817098},"433":{"171":81.56648254,"170":81.7817866,"169":82.04022217,"168":83.20054881,"167":83.59793854,"166":83.82169596,"165":83.16471354,"164":83.20000966,"163":83.20517222,"162":83.28211975},"434":{"171":81.65947978,"170":81.92999522,"169":82.18778737,"168":82.86469014,"167":83.35163116,"166":82.71429189,"165":82.84775798,"164":82.85316213,"163":82.89800517,"162":83.09157562},"435":{"171":81.50264231,"170":81.66261037,"169":81.83562978,"168":82.05867513,"167":82.31612905,"166":82.62644196,"165":82.94167837,"164":83.07303619,"163":83.16178385,"162":null},"436":{"171":81.18163554,"170":81.22033691,"169":81.33473714,"168":81.61830902,"167":82.01428986,"166":82.42758687,"165":82.79388936,"164":83.13121796,"163":83.46927134,"162":null},"437":{"171":80.74187469,"170":80.68540955,"169":80.8221995,"168":81.2023112,"167":81.59555308,"166":81.96758016,"165":82.33428701,"164":82.74884796,"163":83.23331451,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":80.81280263,"167":81.16618093,"166":81.50134532,"165":81.82526143,"164":82.20085398,"163":82.67316945,"162":null}}
{"429":{"171":87.31295522,"170":87.20752716,"169":87.24928284,"168":87.21202596,"167":87.31300863,"166":87.6888682,"165":88.26953634,"164":88.77185822,"163":89.04013824,"162":null},"430":{"171":86.80780284,"170":86.81738027,"169":86.77797445,"168":86.72226969,"167":86.94758097,"166":87.43943024,"165":88.08621724,"164":88.56729126,"163":89.03269958,"162":89.40670268},"431":{"171":86.51890055,"170":86.56462351,"169":86.62617493,"168":86.76410929,"167":87.14155833,"166":87.68671672,"165":88.26065572,"164":88.75571442,"163":89.14042918,"162":89.49257406},"432":{"171":86.54847717,"170":86.60865784,"169":86.80991618,"168":87.25551097,"167":87.83054606,"166":88.29964193,"165":88.78022512,"164":89.00658162,"163":89.27619171,"162":89.28326925},"433":{"171":86.87089284,"170":87.02443186,"169":87.32195282,"168":88.20524597,"167":88.63594564,"166":88.94934845,"165":88.78857931,"164":88.91176605,"163":88.88594055,"162":89.04221853},"434":{"171":86.91846975,"170":87.17388407,"169":87.48436737,"168":88.20765177,"167":88.38693492,"166":88.21294657,"165":88.45011902,"164":88.56740824,"163":88.52152252,"162":88.8375473},"435":{"171":86.72666931,"170":86.88824209,"169":87.0997289,"168":87.3543752,"167":87.71672058,"166":88.15355174,"165":88.58790334,"164":88.84000142,"163":88.84495036,"162":null},"436":{"171":86.35605113,"170":86.40647634,"169":86.51208242,"168":86.85261027,"167":87.37110647,"166":87.94256846,"165":88.47804769,"164":88.9029007,"163":89.32699076,"162":null},"437":{"171":85.85506694,"170":85.81829325,"169":85.94577789,"168":86.37988536,"167":86.89028168,"166":87.40656789,"165":87.9219869,"164":88.42491659,"163":89.0151062,"162":null},"438":{"171":null,"170":null,"169":null,"168":85.94525909,"167":86.42741394,"166":86.86425273,"165":87.28136953,"164":87.73954519,"163":88.37074788,"162":null}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum seasonal heat index", "location1": "Biloxi, MS, United States", "location2": "Indianapolis, IN, United States", "time_frame1": "summer in historical period", "time_frame2": "summer in mid-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Biloxi, MS, United States or Indianapolis, IN, United States experienced a greater change in maximum seasonal heat index throughout summer in historical period and summer in mid-century period?
c0fdee9a-5931-455f-bfa3-a5823b30ab40
As a wildland firefighter reviewing historical data for upcoming operations, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the historical period compared to spring in the end-century period?
trend
tabular
null
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in end-century period?
c3291e96-cae8-4ff5-a2c9-834115d7a5f6
As a wildland firefighter reviewing historical data for upcoming operations, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the historical period compared to spring in the end-century period?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1248/heatmap_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in end-century period?
a0a192b4-89f5-4aa3-817b-114c5d4839cc
As a wildland firefighter reviewing historical data for upcoming operations, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the historical period compared to spring in the end-century period?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1248/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in end-century period?
56ac5fe4-b615-46a9-90ea-fd31353c1d03
As a wildland firefighter reviewing historical data for upcoming operations, I'm curious to know which location, Cheyenne, WY, or Spokane, WA, has shown a more significant variation in fire weather index during autumn in the historical period compared to spring in the end-century period?
trend
heatmap_overlaid_on_map
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1248/heatmap_overlay_merged_radius72.png
72
(d)
['(a) Throughout this time period, Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States experienced similar changes.', '(b) The Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change than Cheyenne, WY, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Cheyenne, WY, United States and Spokane, WA, United States.', '(d) Cheyenne, WY, United States experienced a greater change than Spokane, WA, United States.']
['Cheyenne, WY, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Cheyenne, WY, United States in spring in end-century period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in autumn in historical period', 'Spokane, WA, United States in spring in end-century period']
{"301":{"165":21.92060089,"164":19.71159935,"163":19.17210007,"162":18.70639992,"161":19.4489994,"160":20.88839912,"159":15.93970013,"158":16.13059998,"157":18.92040062,"156":11.05049992},"302":{"165":23.47509956,"164":22.1644001,"163":20.5904007,"162":19.34480095,"161":16.40530014,"160":20.3560009,"159":20.71269989,"158":21.92379951,"157":22.16790009,"156":14.31910038},"303":{"165":26.32449913,"164":27.10350037,"163":24.84989929,"162":23.65880013,"161":21.04249954,"160":21.85099983,"159":22.64520073,"158":24.45240021,"157":24.68370056,"156":21.29319954},"304":{"165":28.71570015,"164":27.30979919,"163":25.66250038,"162":25.42589951,"161":24.79929924,"160":24.05039978,"159":24.36759949,"158":25.63479996,"157":25.78160095,"156":24.72669983},"305":{"165":30.13850021,"164":27.46879959,"163":25.92740059,"162":25.7003994,"161":25.45149994,"160":25.30120087,"159":25.58440018,"158":26.28339958,"157":26.04999924,"156":25.31419945},"306":{"165":29.11249924,"164":27.78800011,"163":26.33790016,"162":25.98810005,"161":25.8159008,"160":25.59930038,"159":25.82080078,"158":26.2791996,"157":26.28899956,"156":25.79540062},"307":{"165":28.63439941,"164":27.90229988,"163":26.59000015,"162":26.41110039,"161":26.21430016,"160":26.12639999,"159":26.17329979,"158":26.33309937,"157":26.32710075,"156":26.16900063},"308":{"165":28.64839935,"164":27.67420006,"163":26.71050072,"162":26.65139961,"161":26.8512001,"160":26.86610031,"159":26.84519958,"158":26.54210091,"157":26.67569923,"156":26.39349937},"309":{"165":28.75749969,"164":27.72220039,"163":26.94409943,"162":27.37129974,"161":27.53440094,"160":27.50289917,"159":27.3526001,"158":27.09980011,"157":26.81480026,"156":null},"310":{"165":28.32159996,"164":27.36899948,"163":26.96899986,"162":27.56430054,"161":27.72310066,"160":27.3682003,"159":26.90870094,"158":27.05060005,"157":26.82220078,"156":null}}
{"301":{"165":8.91703987,"164":7.75333023,"163":7.61195993,"162":7.88745022,"161":8.47821045,"160":9.41711044,"159":6.73873997,"158":7.12450981,"157":8.7255497,"156":4.36410999},"302":{"165":9.38689995,"164":8.78742027,"163":8.22167969,"162":7.75033998,"161":6.60043001,"160":8.82715988,"159":9.55066967,"158":11.18000031,"157":11.72710037,"156":6.87423992},"303":{"165":11.10330009,"164":11.65950012,"163":10.41250038,"162":10.09669971,"161":8.94474983,"160":9.71829987,"159":11.16499996,"158":13.45160007,"157":14.30860043,"156":12.59210014},"304":{"165":12.61569977,"164":11.77729988,"163":10.92169952,"162":11.1218996,"161":11.10859966,"160":11.05819988,"159":12.29139996,"158":14.24629974,"157":15.26830006,"156":15.07689953},"305":{"165":13.6633997,"164":12.07180023,"163":11.27350044,"162":11.4041996,"161":11.44540024,"160":11.72099972,"159":12.7730999,"158":14.24120045,"157":14.83749962,"156":15.19830036},"306":{"165":13.01650047,"164":12.37899971,"163":11.75220013,"162":11.68770027,"161":11.65380001,"160":11.69970036,"159":12.36880016,"158":13.75139999,"157":14.63780022,"156":15.1864996},"307":{"165":12.55679989,"164":12.33889961,"163":11.7968998,"162":11.77929974,"161":11.90839958,"160":12.03100014,"159":12.45499992,"158":13.50529957,"157":14.54740047,"156":15.14869976},"308":{"165":12.58950043,"164":12.17689991,"163":11.67949963,"162":11.81700039,"161":12.02219963,"160":12.32429981,"159":12.8107996,"158":13.58930016,"157":14.38020039,"156":15.03390026},"309":{"165":12.90359974,"164":12.18589973,"163":11.73779964,"162":11.96240044,"161":12.16600037,"160":12.42889977,"159":13.01900005,"158":13.6626997,"157":14.44279957,"156":null},"310":{"165":12.68999958,"164":11.98410034,"163":11.62349987,"162":12.15950012,"161":12.43900013,"160":12.45610046,"159":12.70559978,"158":13.36730003,"157":14.05319977,"156":null}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":14.87940025,"225":16.97730064,"224":17.65180016,"223":17.37989998,"222":17.48870087,"221":18.23600006,"220":18.75460052,"219":null},"225":{"227":12.85700035,"226":14.12699986,"225":16.13279915,"224":17.32729912,"223":17.15089989,"222":17.0904007,"221":17.5760994,"220":18.16040039,"219":18.08349991},"226":{"227":13.47420025,"226":14.15130043,"225":16.24819946,"224":16.92499924,"223":17.14699936,"222":17.09539986,"221":17.2826004,"220":17.74139977,"219":17.79759979},"227":{"227":14.9769001,"226":14.30739975,"225":15.93290043,"224":16.48469925,"223":16.84000015,"222":17.2098999,"221":17.35169983,"220":17.5,"219":17.52510071},"228":{"227":13.09350014,"226":14.69919968,"225":15.62870026,"224":16.06399918,"223":15.88729954,"222":17.10269928,"221":17.44799995,"220":17.30240059,"219":17.22030067},"229":{"227":12.83570004,"226":14.9066,"225":15.03670025,"224":15.38679981,"223":16.34720039,"222":16.52820015,"221":16.86940002,"220":17.02020073,"219":16.99270058},"230":{"227":12.98009968,"226":13.30799961,"225":12.5873003,"224":13.18019962,"223":15.46660042,"222":14.76749992,"221":16.35449982,"220":16.87229919,"219":16.57500076},"231":{"227":12.71940041,"226":12.54349995,"225":11.96000004,"224":12.77530003,"223":15.04440022,"222":14.05370045,"221":16.05209923,"220":16.53310013,"219":15.41170025},"232":{"227":11.98449993,"226":12.30189991,"225":12.38819981,"224":12.71000004,"223":13.77980042,"222":12.94919968,"221":13.74839973,"220":14.71440029,"219":13.31649971}}
{"224":{"227":null,"226":3.94394994,"225":4.91334009,"224":4.87457991,"223":4.5564599,"222":4.61276007,"221":5.40790987,"220":5.70098019,"219":null},"225":{"227":2.73847008,"226":3.43235993,"225":4.63226986,"224":4.72117996,"223":4.41913986,"222":4.35273981,"221":4.58748007,"220":5.12935019,"219":4.62327003},"226":{"227":3.05313993,"226":3.58034992,"225":4.49363995,"224":4.61534977,"223":4.40521002,"222":4.29125023,"221":4.22261,"220":4.2149601,"219":4.10757017},"227":{"227":3.26323009,"226":3.42411995,"225":4.13196993,"224":4.44375992,"223":4.43329,"222":4.27815008,"221":4.04991007,"220":3.85812998,"219":3.72268009},"228":{"227":2.60028005,"226":3.19693995,"225":3.73822999,"224":4.0016799,"223":4.41759014,"222":3.98157001,"221":3.80420995,"220":3.5885601,"219":3.42315006},"229":{"227":2.6795001,"226":3.09879994,"225":3.01920009,"224":3.11461997,"223":3.48818994,"222":3.32672,"221":3.28309011,"220":3.24514008,"219":3.1363399},"230":{"227":2.82591009,"226":2.63365006,"225":2.1221199,"224":2.32672,"223":2.95629001,"222":2.70214009,"221":2.89445996,"220":3.01062012,"219":2.74996996},"231":{"227":2.66662002,"226":2.49742007,"225":2.09369993,"224":2.2887001,"223":2.75484991,"222":2.45991993,"221":2.72585011,"220":2.86985993,"219":2.43803},"232":{"227":2.37875009,"226":2.42289996,"225":2.33482003,"224":2.22159004,"223":2.19845009,"222":2.09755993,"221":2.28215003,"220":2.31648993,"219":2.20509005}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "fire weather index", "location1": "Cheyenne, WY, United States", "location2": "Spokane, WA, United States", "time_frame1": "autumn in historical period", "time_frame2": "spring in end-century period"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Cheyenne, WY, United States or Spokane, WA, United States experienced a greater change in fire weather index throughout autumn in historical period and spring in end-century period?
793386ae-a951-4c48-a0c5-5999fe46e9f6
As a city planner in Florida analyzing the long-term temperature trends for urban development, could you help me understand which location, Fort Myers or Tampa, is projected to see a larger increase in maximum annual temperature by the end of the century under the RCP4.5 scenario compared to the mid-century period with RCP8.5?
trend
tabular
null
48
(a)
['(a) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227},"489":{"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071},"490":{"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785},"491":{"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153},"492":{"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949},"493":{"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
c4487caa-78b9-4ee9-ba0c-09257f505041
As a city planner in Florida analyzing the long-term temperature trends for urban development, could you help me understand which location, Fort Myers or Tampa, is projected to see a larger increase in maximum annual temperature by the end of the century under the RCP4.5 scenario compared to the mid-century period with RCP8.5?
trend
heatmap
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1256/heatmap_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227},"489":{"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071},"490":{"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785},"491":{"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153},"492":{"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949},"493":{"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?
7ac16eb8-9877-461d-813d-b30401bbd074
As a city planner in Florida analyzing the long-term temperature trends for urban development, could you help me understand which location, Fort Myers or Tampa, is projected to see a larger increase in maximum annual temperature by the end of the century under the RCP4.5 scenario compared to the mid-century period with RCP8.5?
trend
heatmap_annotated
data/benchmark/image_data/question_1256/heatmap_with_text_merged_radius48.png
48
(a)
['(a) Fort Myers, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Tampa, FL, United States.', '(b) The Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change than Fort Myers, FL, United States.', '(c) There was no significant difference in the changes between Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States.', '(d) Throughout this time period, Fort Myers, FL, United States and Tampa, FL, United States experienced similar changes.']
['Fort Myers, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Fort Myers, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in end-century period (RCP4.5)', 'Tampa, FL, United States in mid-century period (RCP8.5)']
{"495":{"64":84.22360229,"63":83.87169647,"62":83.06580353,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":84.37030029,"63":83.82420349,"62":80.86450195,"61":80.79679871,"60":80.66349792,"59":null},"497":{"64":84.56569672,"63":84.35890198,"62":84.14569855,"61":83.85959625,"60":83.37729645,"59":80.8082962},"498":{"64":84.85910034,"63":84.74729919,"62":84.65699768,"61":84.48010254,"60":83.83249664,"59":81.0931015},"499":{"64":84.98729706,"63":85.02670288,"62":85.12670135,"61":84.96900177,"60":84.60030365,"59":83.87580109},"500":{"64":84.97669983,"63":85.22180176,"62":85.31600189,"61":85.16880035,"60":85.00389862,"59":84.6529007},"501":{"64":85.08480072,"63":85.25309753,"62":85.35600281,"61":85.33370209,"60":85.22470093,"59":85.12030029},"502":{"64":85.14160156,"63":85.29709625,"62":85.41649628,"61":85.47519684,"60":85.50920105,"59":85.35890198}}
{"495":{"64":82.80740356,"63":82.56790161,"62":81.88580322,"61":null,"60":null,"59":null},"496":{"64":82.97270203,"63":82.63259888,"62":80.32360077,"61":80.26260376,"60":80.17639923,"59":null},"497":{"64":83.16999817,"63":83.05680084,"62":82.88929749,"61":82.65480042,"60":82.32189941,"59":80.3035965},"498":{"64":83.39730072,"63":83.31970215,"62":83.29750061,"61":83.15390015,"60":82.71199799,"59":80.57009888},"499":{"64":83.50450134,"63":83.5562973,"62":83.68340302,"61":83.59290314,"60":83.36370087,"59":82.85070038},"500":{"64":83.54299927,"63":83.81639862,"62":83.93779755,"61":83.78690338,"60":83.70529938,"59":83.54889679},"501":{"64":83.74420166,"63":83.96019745,"62":84.06330109,"61":83.97190094,"60":83.95570374,"59":83.88729858},"502":{"64":83.80709839,"63":84.02159882,"62":84.14009857,"61":84.13549805,"60":84.16369629,"59":84.10430145}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":78.27919769,"73":78.45700073,"72":78.58119965,"71":78.70379639,"70":78.82369995,"69":78.90380096,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":81.38050079,"73":81.63829803,"72":81.7507019,"71":81.87049866,"70":82.29419708,"69":80.85209656,"68":79.03620148},"489":{"75":81.91200256,"74":82.21360016,"73":82.4464035,"72":82.48269653,"71":81.40029907,"70":81.17990112,"69":82.50050354,"68":79.22689819},"490":{"75":82.26190186,"74":82.709198,"73":82.88829803,"72":83.72609711,"71":83.42669678,"70":79.84790039,"69":null,"68":79.36489868},"491":{"75":82.69270325,"74":82.87930298,"73":83.22940063,"72":83.29299927,"71":83.20539856,"70":82.94090271,"69":82.88659668,"68":82.86759949},"492":{"75":82.98480225,"74":83.15480042,"73":83.30780029,"72":83.49440002,"71":83.51760101,"70":83.50650024,"69":83.498703,"68":83.58679962},"493":{"75":83.30999756,"74":83.2664032,"73":83.37290192,"72":83.54419708,"71":83.68090057,"70":83.6780014,"69":83.69409943,"68":83.77870178},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":84.22219849,"72":83.62180328,"71":83.65679932,"70":83.72540283,"69":83.81340027,"68":83.87670135}}
{"487":{"75":null,"74":77.97170258,"73":78.103302,"72":78.21230316,"71":78.31569672,"70":78.41200256,"69":78.46279907,"68":null},"488":{"75":null,"74":80.44000244,"73":80.68509674,"72":80.83989716,"71":81.00569916,"70":81.54290009,"69":80.52480316,"68":78.60420227},"489":{"75":80.62020111,"74":80.93499756,"73":81.15080261,"72":81.33589935,"71":80.85079956,"70":80.00340271,"69":81.7460022,"68":78.77510071},"490":{"75":80.78399658,"74":81.17440033,"73":81.50900269,"72":82.53890228,"71":82.49410248,"70":79.32790375,"69":null,"68":78.99279785},"491":{"75":81.04730225,"74":81.3003006,"73":81.68969727,"72":81.85299683,"71":81.96880341,"70":81.89399719,"69":81.92630005,"68":81.90000153},"492":{"75":81.34380341,"74":81.54540253,"73":81.76329803,"72":81.99880219,"71":82.14129639,"70":82.17209625,"69":82.16960144,"68":82.24259949},"493":{"75":81.57389832,"74":81.66609955,"73":81.81729889,"72":82.00540161,"71":82.1835022,"70":82.18779755,"69":82.20570374,"68":82.28849792},"494":{"75":null,"74":null,"73":82.72599792,"72":82.10739899,"71":82.17630005,"70":82.21859741,"69":82.27639771,"68":82.37449646}}
null
null
null
null
{"climate_variable1": "maximum annual temperature", "location1": "Fort Myers, FL, United States", "location2": "Tampa, FL, United States", "time_frame1": "end-century period (RCP4.5)", "time_frame2": "mid-century period (RCP8.5)"}
Which of {location1} or {location2} experienced a greater change in {climate_variable1} throughout {time_frame1} and {time_frame2}?
Which of Fort Myers, FL, United States or Tampa, FL, United States experienced a greater change in maximum annual temperature throughout end-century period (RCP4.5) and mid-century period (RCP8.5)?